Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY VOLUME 22
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY
SAN Diso
VOL...
57 downloads
1889 Views
13MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY VOLUME 22
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY
SAN Diso
VOLUME 22 Edited by
J. H. S. BLAXTER Dunstaflnage Marine Research Laboratory, Oban, Scotland
Thelate
SIR FREDERICK S. RUSSELL
Reading, England and
SIR MAURICE YONGE Edinburgh, Scotland
Academic Press ( A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jouanouich) London Orlando San Diego New York
Toronto Montreal Sydney Tokyo
1985
COPYRIGHT 0 1985, BY ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24-28 Oval Road
LONDON NW1 7DX
United States Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. Orlando, Florida 32887
LIBRARYO F CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER: 63-14040 ISBN: 0-12-026122-7 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 8.5 M 87 88
9 8 7 . 5 5 4 3 2 1
CONTENTS ..
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME22
..
* .
..
..
xi
Assessing the Effects of “Stress” on Reef Corals B. E. BROWNA N D L. I. Introduction
..
..
..
s. HOWARD ..
..
11. Natural Fluctuations and Man-made Influences
..
..
1
..
..
3 3 5
A. Assessing changes on coral reefs . . .. .. .. B. lnterpreting temporal changes on coral reefs . . .. C. Effects and apparent lack of effects of pollution on coral .. .. .. .. .. reefs . . .. .. D. Predicting recovery of reefs .. .. .. ..
9 17
111. Experimental Studies on Effects of Pollutants on Corals . . .. .. .. .. .. A. Growth rate . . .. .. .. .. .. .. B. Metabolism . . .. C. Loss of zooxanthellae .. .. .. .. .. D. Behavioural responses .. .. .. .. .. E. Reproductive biology .. .. .. .. .. F. Histopathology . . .. .. .. .. .. G. Biochemical and cytochemical indexes . . .. ..
20 20 27 29 35 46 48 50
IV. Discussion and Future Research Needs .. References .. .. . .
..
.. ..
.. ..
51 55
..
..
,.
66
.. ..
.. ..
..
66 66
..
Nutrition of Sea Anemones M. VAN-PRAGT I. Introduction
..
..
..
..
11. Chemoreception and Feeding Behaviour A. Feeding behaviour . . .. .. V
..
vi
CONTENTS
B. Nature of activators. . .. .. C. The conducting systems . . .. D. The control of feeding behaviour . .
.. .. ..
..
.. .. ..
67 69 69
111. Absorption of Dissolved Organic Matter .. .. .. A. Localization of uptake .. .. .. .. .. B. Uptake systems for glucose and amino acids . . .. C. Ecological importance of dissolved compounds for the nutrition of sea anemones . . .. .. .. ..
70 70 71
.. ..
71
IV. Gathering and Digestion of Particulate Organic Matter . . A. Suspension-feeding structures . . .. . . .. B. Endodermal currents and the role of the trilobed portion .. .. .. .. .. of mesenteric filaments C. Phagocytic cells, cytological and enzymological aspects of intracellular digestion . . .. .. .. . . .. .. D. Importance of particulate organic matter
72 72
V. Predation and Digestion of Prey .. .. ,. A. Role of tentacles, acontia, and cnidae . . .. B. Extracellular digestion of prey, cytological and enzymological aspects .. . . .. .. .. .. C. Excretion .. .. .. . .
..
81 81
.. ..
82 89
.. .. .. .. VI. Symbiosis . . .. .. .. A. Localization of algal symbionts . . .. .. .. B. Regulation of the concentration of algae in the tissues . C . Translocation of metabolites .. .. .. ..
89 89 90 91
VII. Sea Anemones as Prey and Remarks on the Diet .. .. .. Anemones. . .. .. A. Predators of sea anemones. . .. .. B. Diet of sea anemones .. .. .. .. .. References .. .. . .
of Sea
.. ..
.. ..
..
74 76 79
.. .. .. ..
92 92 93 94
.. ..
I02 102
Effects of Environmental Stress on Marine Bivalve Molluscs H. B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
I. Introduction
..
A. Definition of stress
.. ..
..
..
.. ..
.. ..
.. ..
vii
CONTENTS
B. Occurrence of natural and man-made stresses . . C. Threshold levels of pollutant stress .. .. D. Development of experimental techniques ..
.. .. ..
I04 I04 105
11. Behavioural Responses to Stress .. .. .. .. A. Valve closure as a protective mechanism .. .. B. Relationship between heart rate, valve movement, and .. .. .. .. .. .. pumping activity C. Behavioural response to some pollutant stressors .. D. Relevance of valve closure in epifaunal and infaunal species .. .. .. .. .. .. .. E. Effect of subthreshold levels on behaviour .. .. F. Effect of temperature on heart rate .. .. . .
I08
111. Detection of Stress .. .. .. .. .. A. The significance of registering changes in the environment . . .. .. .. .. .. B. Sites of reception . . .. .. .. .. C. Detection and response to environmental changes
.. ..
..
..
..
..
.. ..
..
..
.. ..
121 I28 130 I32
..
I32 134 136
.. ..
V. The Role of the Shell . . .. .. .. .. .. A. Physical protection and isolation from environmental stress . . .. .. .. .. .. . . . . B. Shell closure and calcium reabsorption . . .. .. C. Effect of prolonged stress on shell strength .. ..
VII. Conclusions References
111 117
..
IV. Respiratory Physiology during Stress. . .. .. .. .. A. Valve closure and cessation of aerobic processes B. Relationship between heart rate, valve movements, POZ, and pC02 .. .. .. .. .. .. C. Anaerobic respiration during valve closure .. .. D. Valve activity and pH changes . . .. .. ~.
VI. Action of Heavy Metal Stressors .. .. .. A. Accumulation of heavy metals . . .. .. B. Effects of heavy metals on tissues .. .. C. Effects of heavy metals on released gametes and embryonic and juvenile stages .. .. .. D. Effects of heavy metals on cellular organelles . .
108
146 146 146 I48 151
I55 155 156 161
.. .. ..
162 162 163
..
168 175
..
.. ..
182 f83
...
CONTENTS
Vlll
Growth in Barnacles D. J. CRISPA N D E. BOURGET I. Evolution of Barnacles and Their Shells 11. Mechanisms of Growth . . .. .. A . Growth of individual shell plates . .
.i.
..
..
200
.. .. ..
.. ..
.. ,
.
..
203 203 204
..
207
.. .. .. ..
208 208 209 211
B . Primordial valves . . .. .. .. C. Orientation of barnacles at settlement and during .. .. .. .. .. growth. . ..
..
.. .. .. ..
.. .. ..
IV. Factors Influencing Growth Rate .. A. Temperature . . .. .. .. .. .. .. B. Light .. .. C. Current, tidal level, and nutrition.. D. Surface contour .. .. .. E. Orientation to current .. .. F. Population density . . .. .. G . Competing organisms .. .. H. Parasites . . .. .. .. I. Reproduction. . .. .. ..
..
..
..
.. .. ..
.. .. .. .. .. ..
.. .. .. .. ..
..
.,
V . Age and Growth-the
111. Modification of Shape
..
..
A. Effects of crowding . . .. .. €3. Influence of substratum on shape . . C. Influence of salinity on shape ..
..
..
..
..
..
..
211 215 216 216 217 217 217 219 219 219
Growth Curve..
..
..
..
220
..
..
..
..
221
..
222
..
..
227
..
..
.. ..
.. .. ..
.. ..
234 234 236 237 237
VI. Growth Rates of Various Species
.. .. ..
..
VII. Histology and Fine Structure of the Integument: Growth and Ecdysis .. .. . . .. . . . . VIII. Shell Structure in Relation to Function
..
..
.. .. .. .. ..
IX. Cyclical Factors in Growth A. Tidal influences .. B. Daily influences .. C. Other lunar influences D. Annual influences . .
..
.. .. ..
..
.. .. .. ..
..
..
..
r
ix
CONTENTS
E. Other cyclic influences .. .. .. .. F. Frequency, scale, and precision of measurement .. .. . . .. .. .. References Taxonomic Index Subject Index
..
..
..
..
238 238 239
..
..
..
..
..
..
245
..
..
..
..
..
..
249
Cumulative Index of Titles
,
.
..
..
..
..
255
Cumulative Index of Authors
..
..
..
..
..
259
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 22 H . B. A K B E R A LDepartments I, of Zoology und Botany, University of Manchester, Manchester MI3 9PL, England. E . BOURGET,Dkpartement de Biologie, UniversitP Laval, QuPbec GI K 7P4, Canada. B. E . BROWN,Department of Zoology, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne NEI 7RU, England.
D . J . CRISP,Natural Environment Research Council, Unit of Marine Invertebrate Biology, Marine Science Laboratories, Menai Bridge, Gwynedd LL59 5EH, United Kingdom. L. S . HOWARD, Department of Zoology, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne NEI 7RU, England.
E. R . TRUEMAN, Department of Zoology, University of Manchester, Manchester MI3 9PL, England.
M . VAN-PRAET,Laborutoire de Biologie des Inverte'bre's Marins et Malacologie, MusPum National d'Histoire Naturelle, 75005 Paris, France.
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Assessing the Effects of “Stress” on Reef Corals B. E. Brown and L. S. Howard Department of Zoology, University of Newcastle upon Tyne Newcastle upon Tyne, England
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Natural Fluctuations and Man-made Influences . . . . . . . . A. Assessing changes on coral reefs . . . . . . . . . . B. Interpreting temporal changes on coral reefs . . . . . . C. Effects and apparent lack of effects of pollution on coral reefs . . D. Predicting recovery of reefs . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Experimental Studies on Effects of Pollutants on Corals . . . . A. Growth rate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Metabolism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Loss of zooxanthellae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Behavioural responses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Reproductive biology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Histopathology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Biochemical and cytochemical indexes . . . . . . . . IV. Discussion and Future Research Needs . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1.
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
1 3 3 5
9 17 20 20 27 29 35 46
. .
48 50
. . .
51 55
Introduction
Some years ago Johannes (1975) published the first major literature review on the effects of marine pollutants on coral reefs. At that time he 1 ADVANCES I N MARlNh BIOLOGY. VOL 22
Copyright
(0 19x7. by Academic Press I n i (London) Ltd All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISBN 0-12-026122-7
2
B . E. BROWN A N D L. S. HOWARD
highlighted the paucity of knowledge in many areas of the subjects. Although research efforts in the field have increased, particularly with respect to potential effects of pollution by oil (Loya and Rinkevich, 1980) and drilling muds (Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984) there are still enormous gaps in our knowledge and serious contradictions in the existing literature. Much of this lack of information may be attributed to our limited understanding of the physiology of corals, although recent papers have contributed valuable data on growth (Highsmith, 1979), reproduction (Highsmith, 1982; Kojis and Quinn, 1981, 1982; van Moorsel, 1983), behavior patterns (Lasker, 1979), carbon turnover (Crossland ef ul., 1980b), calcification (Barnes and Crossland, 1978, 1982; Gladfelter 1982a), mucus production (Crossland et al., 1980a), and associated bacterial populations on living corals (Ducklow and Mitchell, 1979). The aims of the present article are to consider long-term ecological studies in the light of known effects of disturbances on coral reefs and to ask whether the effects of disturbances can be distinguished from longterm fluctuations on the reef and also where other difficulties lie in assessment of pollution in the field. In addition, in an attempt to improve understanding of the overall susceptibility of reef corals to marine pollution, an assessment is made of the responses of corals to stress and methods by which these responses have been monitored to date. The definition of “stress” has been much discussed in the literature (Grime, 1979; Pickering, 1981; Stebbing, 1981; Rosen, 1982), particularly with reference to problems involved in identifying and quantifying such a condition. Working with plants, Grime (1979) defined stress as the external constraints limiting dry matter production by all or part of the vegetation, while Rosen (l982), considering corals, described stressful conditions as those resulting in restricted growth and reproduction. Such specific definitions as these have not always been applied in many of the publications referred to in this article. For our purposes Rosen’s broader view of stress as a gradient between ideal conditions and the ultimate limits of survival will be adopted. As noted by Stebbing (1981), the term stress may be used as a cause or as an effect. In agreement with Stebbing and most other authors, we choose to view stress as an external force or stimulus. The article is divided into three sections, the first section dealing with observations in the field, the second with laboratory assessment of pollutant effects, and the third section incorporating a general discussion of the validity of generalizations made to date on the overall vulnerability of coral reefs to man-made disturbance.
EFFECTS O F STRESS O N REEF CORALS
3
II. Natural Fluctuations and Man-made Influences A. Assessing Changes on Coral Reefs
Assessing change necessarily implies that reefs are monitored regularly by standard, repeatable methods. It is only in recent years, however, that quantitative methods have become routinely employed on permanent transects over time intervals. The first review of field methods applied on coral reefs was published by Stoddart in 1972. Subsequently other workers (Loya, 1972, 1978; Done, 1977; Bouchon, 1983; Dodge er al., 1982) have successfully tested various quantitative and semiquantitative methods on the reef. Strictly quantitative techniques vary from plotless (Loya, 1978) to quadrat methods (Bak and Engel, 1979), and more recently workers have compared both approaches at the same sites in an attempt to gauge their relative efficiencies (Dodge et al., 1982; Bouchon, 1983). Although there appear to be no major differences in the results obtained by either methods, there are variations in the quantity and type of information generated and the time required for use; the line transect or “intersected length” method generally makes the most efficient use of the time spent underwater. Measurements made on coral reefs using these techniques include coral cover, diversity, evenness (Loya, 1972, 1976a; Brown and Holley, 1982; Dodge et a f . , 1982; Bouchon, 1983), colony number and colony size (Loya, 1972; Fishelson, 1977), and more recently spatial complexity (Rogers er a f . , 1982, 1983) and spatial arrangement of both living and dead substratum components (Bak and Luckhurst, 1980). Although monitoring of coral cover and diversity may yield fundamental information about coral assemblages, few studies incorporate measurements of the cover and diversity of other components of the coral community, such as soft corals, zoanthids, algae, sponges, and ascidians. Recently, the importance of monitoring these groups has been highlighted by the publications of Benayahu and Loya (1977), Bak er af. (1981), and Tursch and Tursch (1982). Invasion and/or overgrowth of scleractinian corals by many species of soft corals (Nishihira, 1981; Tursch and Tursch, 1982) and ascidians (Bak er al., 1981; Sammarco er al., 1983; Sya’rani, 1983) has frequently been observed in both the Indo-Pacific and the Caribbean provinces. In studies where dominant components of the coral community have been considered (Rogers er a f . , 1982), the effect of disturbance on coral reef diversity may be complex. Diversity of scleractinian corals as a result of hurricane damage in St. Croix was shown to decrease in shallow reef
4
B . E. BROWN A N D L. S . HOWARD
zones, whereas diversity of the community as a whole actually increased because of colonization of new substrata by a wide variety of reef organisms, e.g., algae, sponges, tunicates, bryozoa, and hydroids. Clearly quantitative measurements on coral reefs affected by disturbance should include some account of all major components of the reef community. Such measurements are also improved by an appreciation of the structural complexity of the coral reef environment. Rogers et al. (1982) used a modified transect method, with a linked chain following the contours of the reef, to obtain an index of reef topography or structural complexity. Done (1981) has applied the use of stereophotography to permanent transects on the Great Barrier Reef. A stereo pair of photographs provides a great resolution of detail, a means of determining the three-dimensional coordinates of colonies and substratum, and a means of determining true dimensions and shapes of benthic organisms at any depth in the photograph. With automated stereoanalysis it should be possible to accurately map three-dimensional growth patterns of living corals and/or surface area of other substratum components. So complex are the interactions on coral reefs (Bak et al., 1982; Porter et al., 1982) that standard measurements of areal coverage, diversity, and abundance may not always be sensitive to changes in interactions which would be detected in a threedimensional approach to community analysis. Such an analysis should also consider the nonliving components of the substratum. Bak and Luckhurst (1980) have highlighted the importance of monitoring not only living cover but also nonliving substrata such as rock and sediments. Their study showed that alteration of spatial arrangement through dislodgement and collapse of substrata and changes in sediment flow were of paramount importance in describing the community, particularly in shallow-water (10- and 20-m) quadrats. As the authors note, a continuous change in the cover of nonliving components must have serious implications for the settlement and survival of juvenile benthos. One further factor should be considered when assessing changes on coral reefs, and that is the measurement of colony size. This parameter has been used by various workers (Loya, 1972, 1967a; Fishelson, 1977) involved in monitoring the effects of disturbance on coral reefs. It has recently been recognized (Hughes and Jackson, 1980) that partial colony mortality, colony fission, and colony fusion may affect any simple relationship between the size and age of reef corals. Following known corals in photographs for successive years demonstrated that, in foliose Caribbean corals, size and age are seldom related. Measurements such as those of Fishelson (1977) on age groups of faviids from polluted and nonpolluted sites, estimated from size dimensions, may require reinterpretation in the
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
5
light of these more recent studies. Loya (1976a), however, recognizes the regenerative ability of corals when interpreting the effects of low tides at Eilat, and stresses that in the few cases where corals did not fully regenerate the separate parts were considered as one individual.colony. His results suggested that whereas before the low tide coral colonies on the control reef fell into relatively large size categories, in 1973 after the catastrophic low tide, colonies fell into small size categories. Corals with marked regenerative ability included Cyphastrea microphthalma (Lamarck), Pauona decussata (Dana), Millepora dichotoma (Forskal), and Porites lutea (Milne-Edwards and Haime). Generally the recovery of the control reef was mainly due to recolonization by coral planulae rather than regeneration of survivors. Nevertheless, regeneration of corals after partial mortality is an important process on all reefs, and it may be very difficult to decide if a small coral has recently settled or whether it is actually part of a much larger colony which has suffered partial colony mortality or colony fission. Such difficulties may be compounded in polluted areas, particularly those suffering from a high sediment load (personal observation) (Fig. 1). Clearly this aspect requires further study on reefs affected by sedimentation where the growth form of massive species such as P. lutea and Goniastrea retiformis (Lamarck) appears nodular and where partial colony mortality is high. Many long-term monitoring programmes incorporating techniques described earlier have now been initiated on coral reefs in both the Caribbean and the Indo-Pacific, and much interesting information should gradually become available over the next decade-to quote Lewis (1976), considering long-term ecological surveillance on temperate rocky shores, “to record ‘change’ is no problem. There is much and it would be a remarkable investigation that showed none. The major need is to ensure that the change recorded is real and relevant.”
B. Interpreting Temporal Changes on Coral Reex7 Table I demonstrates major long-term changes observed as a result of mainly natural disturbances, while Table I1 records instances of manmade damage on coral reefs. It is clear from these tables that recent regular monitoring of fixed stations and transects in CuraGao (Bak and Luckhurst, 1980) and Eilat (Loya, 1976a) have produced interesting data on coral distributions and their spatial distributions with time. In addition, surveys before and after damaging natural events such as hurricanes (Stoddart, 1974; Shinn, 1976; Rogers et al., 1982), low temperatures (Shinn, 1976), and low tides (Loya, 1972) provide some insights into reef recovery and development.
TABLEI. LONG-TERM SURVEILLANCE OF NATURAL DISTURBANCES ON REEFS Time span
Environmental history
British Honduras
1964- 1966
Heron Island, Australia Key Largo, Florida
1963-1970
Humcane damage (1961) Hurricane damage (1966) Hurricane damage (1960)
Key Largo, Florida
1965-1967
St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
1978-1979
Site
Gulf of Eilat
1950-1965
1970
Repeated hurricane damage (1965) Humcane damage ( 1979)
Catastrophic low tide
Major changes observed
Reference
Branching corals more susceptible than massive species
Stoddart (1974)
No marked change in coral abundance
Connell (1973)
Although colonies broken and much destruction within 1 year, difficult to recognize damage; by 1965 damage completely healed Damage not noticeable by 1967
Shinn (1976)
Effect of humcanes complex-may result in reduction in coral diversity but increase in community diversity due to provision of more light for slower growing corals and new substrate for algae and other invertebrates Change in the community structure with rare species affected
Rogers er a / . (1982)
Shinn (1976)
Loya (1972, 1976a)
Qatar, Persian Gulf
1965-1967
Low temperatures
Dry Tortugas, Florida St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands
1881-1976
Thermal shock (1976-1977) Bacterial infection
Carysfort Reef, Key Largo, Florida
MarchNo obvious natural November disturbances 1975 1973-1978 No obvious natural disturbances
CuraGao
John Brewer Reef, Australia Discovery Bay, Jamaica
1976-1979
1976-1980 1976-1980
No obvious natural disturbances Humcane Allen (1979)
Regeneration of Acroporu sp. after chill; 2 years later colonies 2-20 cm high Little change in area occupied by hermatypic corals; major changes were in coral species distributions Death of Acropora palmara as result of “white band disease” caused decrease in structural complexity of reef surface, decrease in living coral tissue and a reduction in CaC03 deposition on reef Estimates of net recruitment and mortality of reef corals suggested decline over 14-month study period Cover of living and nonliving components relatively constant throughout study; major differences lay in spatial arrangement of substrate components Net increase in colony abundance with a peak in recruitment in 1979 A trend of reduction in number of rarer coral species on the reef was reversed by Humcane Allen with storm-induced mortality being greatest in the most abundant species (Acroporu spp.)
Shinn (1976) Davis (1982) Gladfelter (1982b)
Dustan (1977)
Bak and Luckhurst (1980) Done (1981) Porter et a / . (1981)
1 FIG.
0.1 m
i
I . Portion of transect on intertidal reef affected by sedimentation where new recruits and colonies affected by partial mortality
and subsequent regeneration are difficult to distinguish (Brown, unpublished).
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
9
Studies of strictly long-term changes on coral reefs, however, are limited to those of Dahl and Lamberts (1978) and Davis (1982), who reassessed transects established 56 and 85 years before these recent surveys, respectively. In Dahl and Lamberts’ study in American Samoa, where results of dredging and cannery effluents were suspected of exerting influences on Arua Reef between 1917 and 1973, the total number of coral heads decreased by 28% during this 56-year period. Although the same genera were dominant in 1917 and 1973, the relative proportions of each differed in 1973 from that recorded in 1917. These authors conclude that the status of the reef in 1973 may reflect gradual recovery, or alternatively, a reef subject to intermittent “stress/sfresses.” Although little change (6%) in the overall area occupied by corals was noted in Dry Tortugas between 1881 and 1976 (Davis, 1982) and in Curaqao between 1973 and 1978 (Bak and Luckhurst, 1980), a major difference in the distribution and spatial arrangement of major coral species was observed in both studies during these time intervals. In the Dry Tortugas (Davis, 1982) in 1976 a lush Acropora ceruicornis (Lamarck) reef occupied what had been an octocoral-dominated region in 1881, while a considerable area of Acropora palmata (Lamarck) on the reef crest in 1881 was reduced to 600 m in 1976. During the relatively short time span of 5 years at Curaqao (Bak and Luckhurst, 1980) the combined effects of settlement, growth, dislodgement, and death of corals, coupled with variations in sedimentation, resulted in considerable temporal instability of both living and nonliving components. Generally shallow reefs show less short-term stability and lower predictability than deep reefs (Loya, 1976a; Bak and Luckhurst, 1980), the latter study demonstrating considerable change in spatial arrangement of substratum components and less stability at depths of 10-20 m when compared with deeper sites at 30-40 m. During the 5-year period of their study, Bak and Luckhurst comment on the constancy of coral cover in the reef habitats studied as compared with the shallow reef at Heron Island, Australia, where the area covered by living coral varied by a factor of 2-3 over 7 years of study (Connell, 1973). Similar variability was recorded by Glynn (1976) in Panama, where coral cover was observed to decrease by a factor of 2.5 in 15 months. C. Effects and Apparent Lack of Effects of Pollution on Coral Reefs Table I1 documents selected examples of recent studies on the effects of man-made disturbances on coral reefs. While studies on the effects of chronic oil and mineral pollution (Fishelson, 1973; Loya, 1975, 1976a), thermal pollution (Jokiel and Coles, 1974), sewage (Walker and Ormond,
TABLE11. EFFECTS,OR LACKOF EFFECTS,OBSERVED IN Pollutant
Site
Time scale
“Suspected” man-made influences (possibly dredging and cannery effluent)
Arua Reef, Samoa
191 7- 1973
Sedimentation from change in agricultural practice
Low Isles, Australia
1928-1978
Dredging and increased sedimenta. tion
Castle Harbour Bermuda
1974
Dredging
Piscadera Bay, CuraGao
1972
Dredging Kaolin clay spill
Diego Garcia Hawaii
Offshore oil drilling
N.W. Palawan Island, Philippines
1980
1981
THE
FIELDFROM “SUSPECTED”POLLUTION Species
Reference
Acroporu continued to be important throughout; Psummucoru reduced 213. Pocilloporu increased 5 x , Poritc7.s trndrcwsii reduced (three genera missing in 1973-Merrtlinrr. Goniopor~r , Cyplirist r-eu) Reef flat with few surviving corals but holothurians very abundant
Dahl and Lamberts (1978)
Diploria strigoscr more susceptible to sedimentation than Diplorio lubyrintirifortnis; most susceptible would appear to be Stepliancoeniu tnichilini Porites ustreoides (plating form) died as a result of inability to reject sediment; calcification rates of Modrueis mirubilis and Agoriciu oguricites decreased by 33% over 4-week period at least Coral diversity unaffected by dredging Corals survived discharge, although some Pocilloporrr meondrinu were temporarily bleached: coral cover in area dominated by P . meundrinu and Porites lobatu Massive species (e.g., P . Irrteu) appear to have survived in preference to branching species (Pocil/oporo, A croporu) which showed est imated 70-9096 reduction in nonstained area around wellheads
C. M. Yonge, personal communication Dodge and Vaisnys ( 1977)
Bak (1978)
Sheppard (1980) Dollar and Grigg (1981)
Hudson ct 01. (1982)
Experimental shading
San Cristobal Reef, S.W. Puerto Rico
Chronic oil pollution (and mineral dust)
Gulf of Eilat
1966-1972
Chronic oil pollution
Gulf of Eilat (Nature Reserve)
1966- I972
Thermal pollution
Kahe Point, Oahu, Hawaii
1971- 1972
Sewage pollution
Gulf of Aqaba
1979
A . ceruicornis most susceptible to partial shading; A . uguricires, Montustreu unnuluris, D. labyrinthiformis, Siderustreu sidereo, and Colpophylliu nutuns show bleaching and variable recovery; no visible response in Eitsmiliu fustigiutu, Montustreo cuuernosa,
or Mussu ungulosa Seriutoporu AcroPorU These genera were all reduced Stylophora Milleporu dichotomu: unchanged Nature reserve colonized after low tide by: P . luteu (16 colonies); M . dichotomu (8 CO~Onies); C . microphrhulmu (7 colonies); Fuvia favites ( 5 colonies); Acanthastreu echinata (2 colonies); Stylophoru pistillatu and C . microphtholmu suffered Order of resistance to high T" from field observations: strongly resistant-~epra.~rreu purpurea, Porites compressu, P . lobatu, Montiporu pufula, and Montiporu uerrucosu; least resistant-P. meandrinu Only surviving coral species was S . pistillutu at polluted site, while control site displayed Fuvia spp., Fuvites spp., Seriutoporu hystrix, Pocilloporu dunue, and S . pistillutu
I
Rogers (1979)
Fishelson (1973)
Loya ( 1976a)
Jokiel and Coles ( 1974)
Walker and Ormond (1982)
(continued)
TABLE11. (CONTINUED) Pollutant
Site
Time scale
Rotenone derivative (fish-collecting chemical)
E. Sambo Reef,
Recreational activities
Biscayne National Park, Florida
1977-1980
Heavy metal pollution and sedimentat ion
Intertidal reef Rats, Phuket, Thailand
1979
1973-1974
Florida
Species Octocorals apparently less susceptible than scleractinians; for the rotenone derivative, A . ceruicornis was more resistant than A. pulrnura, S.siderecc, D.strigo~ci.or Dichocoeniu stokesii; for quinaldine (generally less toxic to all scleractinia) A. qyiricites proved to be the most susceptible to the chemical Scleractinian damage greatest in branching species A . ceruicornis, A . pcclnzutrc, and P. porifes: Millepora highly susceptible; generally soft corals suffered more than scleractinians No apparent effect upon coral diversity and coral cover at site affected by heavy metal pollution, although increased incidence of partial mortality of faviids suspected at this site
Reference Jaap and Wheaton (1975)
Tilmant and Schmahl (1983)
Brown and Holley 1982; Brown (unpublished)
EFFECTS OF STRESS O N REEF CORALS
13
1982), fish-collecting chemicals (Jaap and Wheaton, 1975), dredging (Dodge and Vaisnys, 1977; Bak, 1978), and recreational activities (Tilmant and Schmahl, 1983) clearly show the impact of these disturbances on corals in the field, there are also a number of studies which demonstrate apparent lack of serious damage as a result of man-made interference. Such studies include the limited effects of a major spill of 2200 tons of kaolin clay on a reef in the Hawaiian Islands (Dollar and Grigg, 1981), of elevated metal levels from tin smelting and tin dredging activities on intertidal reef flats at Phuket, Thailand (Brown and Holley, 1982), of dredging activities in Diego Garcia Lagoon (Sheppard, 1980), and of drilling muds in the Palawan Islands, Philippines (Hudson et al., 1982). It may be argued that application of more detailed and longer term survey techniques may yet reveal subtle changes in the community structure at these sites. Nevertheless, no major deterioration in reef structure was evident in any of these examples. The possible reasons for this apparent lack of effect have been documented by the authors concerned. In the case of the kaolin spill, factors contributing to the lack of extensive damage were cited as the nontoxic nature of the kaolin, the small particle size of the clay, the presence of a wetting agent, and the rapid dispersal of the kaolin plume. In addition, rapid removal of sediments by coral cleansing aided the recovery process in the majority of coral colonies which were lobate and branching and hence less likely than platelike varieties to suffer heavy mortality (Dollar and Grigg, 1981). Apparent lack of effect of tin smelting and tin dredging processes at Phuket were ascribed to the possible reduced “biological availability” of toxic metals to corals, the general tolerance of intertidal reef species to stresses, and the possible acquisition of specific metal tolerance mechanisms by the corals themselves (Brown and Holley, 1982). At Diego Garcia dredging during the last decade was probably short term and limited in extent, any resulting damage being overcome by rapid recovery (Sheppard, 1980). Limited damage to branching corals only (an area 115 X 85 m2) was recorded in the vicinity of wellheads around Palawan Island, but the authors (Hudson et al., 1982) conclude that drilling mud probably constitutes a minor threat to coral growth under the conditions described in the study. In terms of overall tolerance of reef corals to disturbance in the field, the literature contains several references inferring the likely ability of intertidal and shallow-water corals to withstand physical stresses (Edmondson, 1928; Loya, 1972; Kojis and Quinn, 1981). Some authors also suggest that reef flat corals differ from deeper water species not only in
14
B. E. BROWN A N D L. S . HOWARD
increased physical tolerances, such as exposure to elevated temperatures (Jones and Randall, 1973), but also in reproductive strategies which they have evolved to reduce planktonic life to a minimum and to retain larvae on the reef (Stimson, 1978). Not surprisingly, then, it would appear that corals from shallow-water environments are more likely to be tolerant of environmental extremes, a finding reflected by Hudson (1981) on transplanting Montastrea annularis (Ellis and Solander) from a deep-water to a shallow-water location in the Florida Keys. The transfer resulted in severely reduced growth rates and mortality in one case. In contrast, transplantation of inshore M. annularis to offshore sites produced only slightly reduced growth rates compared with resident colonies. Should such increased environmental tolerances exist in shallow water corals, then there may be parallels with estuarine species in temperate ecosystems which have been described as “preadapted” to pollution stresses (Jones, 1975; Reeve et al., 1976). Indeed, Jokiel and Coles (1974) describe the Caribbean reef coral Siderastrea siderea (Ellis and Solander) as a “hardy estuarine coral” capable of establishing itself within a zone of maximum thermal effect around a thermal power plant in Florida during the winter and spring months of 1971. Although there may be some overall pattern in increased tolerances to stress shown by corals from different reef habitats and even varying geographical locations (Coles and Jokiel, 1977, having demonstrated lethal temperatures for Enewetak corals to be 2-5°C higher than for Hawaiian corals), Table I1 highlights the variability in response of different corals to the same stress at any one individual site. Considering, for example, temperature effects, Mayor (1914, 1918) was the first worker to note the ability of coral species to resist high temperatures in laboratory tests was inversely related to their metabolic rate. Since this date, Jokiel and Coles (1974) have camed out field observations in Hawaii, and their results confirm that this generalization also holds in the field-the most temperature-resistant coral being the large polyped species Leptasirea purpurea (Dana) with a low metabolic rate, and the most sensitive, Pocillopora meandrina (Dana) with a high metabolic rate. Recent observations by Neudecker (1981) in Guam showed Pocillopora damicornis (Linnaeus) to be more sensitive to thermal stress than Porites andrewsii (Vaughan), the most sensitive species being Acropora formosa (Dana). In the latter study, differences in temperature tolerance were considerable, colonies of P . andrewsii surviving up to 77 days in elevated (4-6°C above ambient) temperatures, whereas A . formosa generally died within 2 days. Whereas Pocillopora is cited in many studies as being relatively sensi-
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
I5
tive to stress in the form of increased temperatures, some authors (Dahl and Lamberts, 1978) describe P . dumicornis in American Samoa as “most tolerant of adverse conditions, being found near shore where there is silt and fluctuating water temperatures.” Since Mayor’s (1924) original transect at this site in 1917, P . dumicornis had increased fivefold, while P . andrewsii, once dominant in the midzone at Arua transect, was considerably reduced. Factors suspected of affecting the reef included dredging activities and discharge of cannery waste. Increased sedimentation resulting from drilling processes at Palawan Island, Philippines (Hudson et al., 1982), caused branching corals (including Pocillopora sp.) considerable mortality when compared with head corals such as P . futeu; Dollar and Grigg (1981) also describe short-term effects of a kaolin spill affecting P . meandrinu but cite no short-term damage in P . lobata as a result of sedimentation. Clearly, then, tolerance of Pocilloporu to either increased temperature or sedimentation, as described in Dahl and Lamberts’ study (1978), would appear to be at variance with observations of the above authors. It is, of course, acknowledged that there are probably few cases where a single factor is responsible for damaging effects observed in the field. Increased sedimentation, for example, will present at least three problems to exposed corals. These are decreased light values, increased energy-consuming processes such as sediment cleansing, and possibly reduction in planktonic food (Bak, 1978). One feature which does appear to be consistent throughout most studies involving sedimentation and/or shading is the particular susceptibility of branching corals to these stresses when compared with massive species. Considering shading alone, such observations would be in line with Porter’s (1976) conclusions that branching corals with small polyps may depend more upon light than upon planktonic capture and so are less able to withstand reduced light intensities than massive corals (Rogers, 1979), though evidence for such resource partitioning is now questioned (Rosen, 1982). With respect to sedimentation, branching corals are very effective in passive rejection of sediment because of their colony morphology (Hubbard and Pocock, 1972; Bak and Elgershuizen, 1976), and as Rogers (1979) showed, the branching Caribbean coral A . ceruicornis was unaffected by daily exposure to sediments. Plating colonies of Porites ustreoides (Lamark), however, which are reported as inefficient sediment rejectors (Bak, 1978), were unable to reject sediments resulting from dredging activities at Curasao and either wholly or partially died. Damage due to sedimentation summarized in Table I1 may therefore be variously interpreted. Where branching corals are observed to have suf-
16
B. E. BROWN A N D L . S . HOWARD
fered (Dollar and Grigg, 1981; Hudson et al., 1982) it may be speculated that light levels were sufficiently reduced to induce damage. Where plating varieties, e.g., P . astreoides, suffered more than branching species, e.g., Madracis mirabilis (Duchassaing and Michelotti) (Bak, 1978), it is likely that lack of sediment rejection capabilities proved to be more lethal than reduction in light intensity and subsequent zooxanthellae loss. As Jokiel and Coles (1977) point out, zooxanthellae loss may be temporary and reversible, bleached corals recovering within 2 months of return to normal conditions. In considering the response of a branching coral such as Pocillopora to temperature increase or sedimentation, it becomes apparent that generalizations must be applied with care when attempting to predict the response of an individual species to a pollutant or indeed the effect of a pollutant on a reef community. One further example will serve to demonstrate the need for more critical data on responses of corals to pollution. Stylophora pistillata (Esper) has been described as an opportunistic or “weedy” species, a typical colonizer of unpredictable environments (Loya, 1976a,b) and polluted habitats (Walker and Ormond, 1982). The latter study demonstrated that S. pistillata was the only surviving coral species on a reef flat in Aqaba affected by sewage and phosphate pollution. Fishelson (1973) also showed that Stylophora was apparently relatively resistant to oil pollution and phosphate dust at Eilat, the coral representing 47% of all branching species in 1966 and 73.7% of the sample in 1968. The combined effects of a low tide and chronic oil pollution, however, severely reduced recolonization by S. pistillata at the nature reserve at Eilat, the coral previously having been dominant at this site (Loya, 1975). In subsequent surveys, P . lutea proved to show more successful recolonization than Stylophora, with a relatively large number of small-sized colonies being recorded. P . lutea, however, could hardly be described as an opportunistic species; according to Highsmith (1982), the life history characteristics of P . lutea include a high growth rate, large adult size, a long life expectancy, but no apparent release of larvae. So, in contrast to Endean’s speculation that opportunistic species should be well represented among early colonizers of polluted habitats (Endean, 1973), in this instance-the only detailed study of its kind to date-such a hypothesis does not appear to hold. The reproductive biology of the adult and the settling behaviour of the larvae of Stylophora are detrimentally affected by exposure to oil (Rinkevich and Loya, 1977, 1979a), but no similar information is available for P . lutea, so it is impossible at this stage to say where the observed tolerance in the latter species lies.
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
17
D. Predicting Recouevy of Reefs Short-term phenomena on reefs are highlighted in Davis’ study (1982) on Dry Tortugas, with the destruction of 90% of an extensive A. ceruicornis stand in 1976-1977 as a result of lowered seawater temperatures in January, 1977. A . cervicornis, however, is known to show rapid recovery rates after partial destruction (Shinn, 1976). A growth rate of 10 cm/year, combined with a geometrical progression of branch formation, has been attributed to the short-term recovery (5 years) of A. ceruicornis reefs after storm damage in the Florida Keys (Shinn, 1976). Speedy partial recovery of Acropora sp. in Qatar, Persian Gulf, 2 years after death due to lowered seawater temperatures has also been reported by Shinn (1976). Highsmith (1982) concludes that S ~ recovery W occurs when disturbance is so severe that hardly any fragments of reef-building corals survive and when survival depends upon sexual reproduction, rapid recovery ensuing when asexual reproduction and regeneration are possible. Such conclusions are supported by the long-term recovery (10-20 years) of A. cervicornis in Belize after suffering high mortality as a result of Hurricane Hattie (Stoddart, 1974) and the relatively short-term recovery of A. cervicornis in studies of limited reef damage in Florida cited earlier (Shinn, 1976). In other instances, however, high rates of recruitment have been attributed to rapid recovery of reefs (Loya, 1975, 1976a), but care must be taken in noting the time scale of such “rapid” recovery. Initial recolonization of reef flats at Eilat between 1969-1973 was shown to be 23X greater on a control reef when compared to a reef affected by chronic oil pollution (Loya, 1976a), although by 1973 there was still a significantly lower coral cover on the control reef compared with the initial survey in 1969. It is interesting to note that the dominant corals on reef flats at Eilat, e.g., Stylophora and Cyphastrea, are species cited as showing life histories in which sexual reproduction is predominant over asexual reproduction, and therefore possibly a slower recovery when compared with corals reproducing primarily by asexual methods (Highsmith, 1982). Corals with high rates of recruitment have been observed to be among the most common species on submerged lava flows in Hawaii, where 20-50 years were required for recovery (Grigg and Maragos, 1974), and at Heron Island, Australia (Connell, 1973). Such a correlation was absent in CuraGao and Bonaire (Bak and Engel, 1979), where common species such as S . siderea, M . annularis, and Montastrea cauernosa (Linnaeus) had very few recruits. The authors suggest that such a finding may indicate a higher level of environmental disturbance on the examined shallow reefs in the Pacific when compared with those studied in the Caribbean.
18
B . E. BROWN A N D L . S . HOWARD
The importance of considering recruitment rates as only part of the overall life history strategy of a coral when attempting to explain distribution and abundance patterns has been shown in recent studies (Bak and Engel, 1979; Bak and Luckhurst, 1980). Two of the most common corals on the reef slopes of Curaqao are Agaricia agaricites (Linnaeus) and M . annularis. Agaricia displays a high recruitment rate, a low rate of survival, and a high mortality, whereas Montastrea combines a low recruitment rate, moderately good survival, and low mortality (Bak and Engel, 1979). Clearly, then, life history strategies of individual corals are all important in determining the rate of recovery of a reef after disturbance. Interpretation of data is further complicated by species exhibiting different life history features in different geographical locations. Highsmith (1982) describes P . darnicornis in Hawaii as a fugitive species, competitively subordinate, with a low growth rate, small adult size, and noted for production of planulae larvae. However, in Panama it is the major reef builder, competitively dominant, with a high growth rate and described as rarely showing recruitment of planulae. Contrasting characteristics are similarly shown in geographically isolated Porites haddoni (= P . lutea), which is reported as planulating from January to June at Low Isles, Australia, by Marshall and Stephenson (1933); no planulation, however, has been observed in P . futea at Enewetak (J. S. Stimson, personal communication, in Highsmith, 1982). As mentioned earlier, the depth of the reef may be important in assessing damage and also in predicting recovery. Hurricane damage has been reported to depths of 20 m (Highsmith et al., 1980; Luckhurst in Bak and Luckhurst, 1980), although damage is generally considered to be greatest in shallow waters (see Endean, 1971, 1973, for reviews). Shallow-water habitats, however, may not always show the greatest effects of hurricanes, as recent studies demonstrate. Rogers et al. (1982) describe the number of broken branches of A . palmata per metre as decreasing with depth (0.6-6.1 m) as a result of hurricane damage at St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands, but whereas shallow branches broke only at their distal ends, exposing relatively little surface area for healing, deeper branches broke at their bases and consequently exposed much greater surface areas for healing and recolonization. Generally the larger branches took longer to heal, the healing process being more effective in fractured small branches which predominated in shallow water. Theoretical aspects of recovery of coral reef communities devastated by catastrophic events have previously been reviewed by Endean (1973). At that time Endean speculated that in cases of extreme disturbance, opportunistic species with a high fecundity might be expected to be well
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
19
represented among the early colonizers; that substrata for colonization might be successfully invaded by benthic organisms other than corals such as algae and alcyonarians; that mortality of juvenile corals might be high; and that coral growth could be retarded, so increasing the time taken for the newly established coral to grow to maturity. Considering that Endean published his review 10 years ago, it is interesting to reflect how his speculations have been borne out by recent work. Earlier discussions in this article would suggest that while opportunistic species with a high fecundity might be found in polluted environments (Loya, 1976a; Walker and Ormond, 1982), they are not necessarily well represented among early colonizers in certain polluted conditions (see Section II,C of this article). Colonization of substrata by algae rather than corals has been observed in areas receiving sewage discharge such as Kaneohe Bay (Smith, 1977) and Aqaba (Walker and Ormond, 1982). Although algal growth was greatly stimulated in polluted areas at Aqaba, the authors maintained this factor was not the direct cause of coral death. They suggested that enhanced algal growth, stimulated by increased nutrient concentrations, may have acted as a sediment trap, thus exposing corals to a considerable sediment load. Other workers (Benayahu and Loya, 1977), looking at reef flats affected by periodic low tides at Eilat, have shown that resulting mass mortality of benthic communities opens up new spaces for settlement. Such unpredictable disturbances are believed to prevent potential dominant competitors from monopolizing the available space, the observed coexistence of stony corals, soft corals, and algae being due to different environmental tolerances and competitive abilities of each group. More recently, useful papers on space monopolization by some of the less well-known groups such as the soft corals have appeared in the literature (Samrnarco et af., 1983; Tursch and Tursch, 1982). Studies on the mortality ofjuvenile corals are still limited. The work of Connell(l973) and Bak and Engel (1979) suggests that on reefs unaffected by human disturbance, approximately 36 and 32% of the juvenile corals died or disappeared during the 1I-month and 6-month study periods, respectively. Bak and Engel cited causes of mortality as sedimentation and competition from coralline algae on shallow reefs and possibly random grazing and/or direct predation by parrot fishes on the reef slope. Another third of the juvenile population in this study were described as limited in growth by factors such as spatial competition, which was similar at all depths. Mortality of juvenile corals in polluted environments is unknown, apart from related work by Rinkevich and Loya (1977) on the effects of crude oil on planulae and juveniles of S. pistillata. Effects observed in the laboratory included a decrease in the viability and successful settlement
20
B . E. BROWN A N D L . S . HOWARD
of the planulae, which was manifest in the field by a limited recolonization by this coral at the polluted Nature Reserve at Eilat. It is clear that we are still lacking much fundamental information on aspects of recovery and recolonization of reefs (Pearson, 1981). From the limited knowledge we have gained during the last 10 years, it would seem that both generalizations and predictions are dangerous and that until more evidence is forthcoming we should consider each case individually. Recent work by Grigg (1983) suggests that disturbance is a primary mechanism governing diversity, community structure, and succession of coral reefs in Hawaii. Furthermore, Grigg depicts the effects of disturbance occurring at different stages of successional processes on coral reefs and concludes that in Hawaii, reef community structure is primarily a function of the interaction between disturbance and recovery time.
111.
Experimental Studies on Effects of Pollutants on Corals
The tolerance of scleractinian corals to factors such as increased temperature and sedimentation was first studied over 50 years ago by Mayor (1914, 1918), Edmondson (1928), and Marshall and Orr (1931). These early workers established the broad tolerances of a variety of coral species to physical disturbances which might be encountered in the field. Experiments were largely performed in the laboratory, where mortality was used as a measure of tolerance, though Mayor and others (Vaughan, 1915) saw the value of actually transplanting corals to a variety of environments and measuring growth rate and survival in siru as a reflection of environmental quality. Despite the short-term nature of laboratory experiments and their shortcomings, a variety of responses have been monitored, both in the laboratory and experimentally in the field, by exposure of corals to a wide selection of chemical and physical parameters (Tables 111-VIII). These responses are discussed below.
A. Growth Rate Growth rate of corals has been cited as one of the best quantitative measures of testing stress due to a disturbance since this parameter integrates a variety of physiological processes (Birkeland et al., 1976; Neudecker, 1983). It is also widely accepted, however, that coral growth rates may be inherently variable (Buddemeier and Kinzie, 1976; Barnes and Crossland, 1982) for a single species within reef zones (Gladfelter et al., 1978) and
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
21
even within individual colonies (Rogers, 1979; Brown et al., 1983). Gladfelter et al. (1978) have described some species as “conservative” in their growth whereas others are not. They cite M . annularis as showing relatively little response in growth rate to varying environmental conditions, while A . ceruicarnis shows marked variations under similar circumstances. Methods employed to measure growth rates of corals have been reviewed by Buddemeier and Kinzie (1976) and Gladfelter et al. (1978). Table I11 illustrates that the majority of studies, in which growth rate has been used as a parameter to measure the effect of disturbance, have involved either x-radiography (Dodge and Vaisnys, 1977; Hudson, 1981, 1983; Hudson and Robbin, 1980; Hudson et al., 1982), reference marking by alizarin red S stain or a fixed base line (Shinn, 1976; Rogers, 1979; Dodge, 1982; Bak and Criens, 1983; Neudecker, 1983), measurement of an increase in skeletal weight (Jokiel and Coles, 1977; Bak, 1978), or 4SCa deposition rate in the skeleton (Neff and Anderson, 1981). The use of x-radiography, in the above context, has been applied solely to massive corals such as P . lutea (Indo-Pacific) and M . annularis, Diploria strigosa (Dana), and Diploria labyrinthiformis (Linnaeus) (Caribbean). Significant suppression of coral growth as a result of disturbance has been observed using this method during short-term exposure of M . annularis to “extremely high” concentrations of drilling mud (Hudson and Robbin, 1980). Inhibition of coral growth was also obtained on transferring M . annularis from an offshore location to a more stressful inshore site (Hudson, 1983) and in D . strigosa and D . labyrinthiformis as a result of dredging in Bermuda (Dodge and Vaisnys, 1977). No suppression of growth was observed in M . annularis and P . lutea as a result of bombing activities at Vieques, Puerto Rico (Dodge, 1983) and drilling processes off N.W. Palawan, Philippines (Hudson et al., 1982), respectively. Results of the latter study, however, showed a 70-90% reduction in area coverage of branching coral species around the wellhead. Death of these low-profile corals was believed to be due to smothering by a prolonged and localized buildup of cuttings, surviving corals being primarily massive head corals in an elevated position above the bottom. Such differences between apparent tolerances of branching and massive species of coral emphasize the need for sensitive methods of assay. In long-term growth studies of M . annularis from the East Flower Gardens, Texas (Hudson et al., 1982), where exploratory drilling sites have been set up in recent years, and also at sites within the Key Largo coral reef marine sanctuary, Florida (Hudson, 1981), a decline in growth rates has been observed. However, in both studies the authors cannot directly attribute apparent growth suppression to any single environmen-
TABLE111. THEUSE OF GROWTHRATE TO ASSESSTHE EFFECTSOF DISTURBANCE ON CORALS IN A N D EXPERIMENTALLY I N THE FIELD Criterion: growth rate
As determined by x-ray analysis
Nature of study and location Analysis after field collection, N.W. Palawan, Philippines Analysis after application of drilling mud by divers to transplanted specimens, Florida Keys, USA, and after field collection, Texas Analysis after transplanting specimens, Florida Keys, USA Analysis after field collection, Castle Harbour, Bermuda Analysis after field collection, Vieques, Puerto Rico Analysis after field collection, Florida Keys, USA
Species
Disturbance
P. lutea
Drilling activities
M . annularis
Drilling muds
M . annularis
THE
LABORATORY
Results
Reference
Little apparent suppression of growth due to drilling Possible decrease in growth shown (though other factors may be responsible)
Hudson et a / . (1982)
Change of habitat from offshore to inshore site Dredging activities
Reduced growth rate and deposition of dense skeleton Decline in growth prior to death
Hudson (1983)
M . annularis
Military bombing activities
Apparent lack of effect
Dodge (1983)
M . annularis
Increased dredge and refill operations (?)
Decline in coral growth (1953-1968) at some midshore and inshore reef sites
Hudson (1981)
D . strigosa and D . labyrinrhifiormis
Hudson and Robbin (1980)
Dodge and Vaisnys (1977)
As determined
by alizarin S stain
Analysis after transplanting corals to site of thermal enrichment, Guam
P . andrewsii, P .
Experimental quadrats in the field, CuraCao
M . mirabilis, A . palmata, A . ceruicornis M . annularis
Laboratory experiment
damicornis, A . formosa
As determined by skeletal growth from a baseline
Analysis after shading and application of sediments to corals in experimental channels and on the reef, San Cristobal, Puerto Rico
A. ceruicornis
As determined by weight of skeletal growth deposited
Laboratory experiment using corals from a Hawaiian reef
P . damicornis, Montipora uerrucosa, Fungia scutaria
Thermal pollution 4-6°C above ambient
Fragmentation
1, 10, 100 ppm drilling mud doses for 6 weeks Experimental shading and sedimentation (receiving up to 800 mglcm2 and 200 mgicm2 once a day, once a week, and once a month during 40day period) Temperature increase
Coral growth impeded by higher temperature; suggests slower growing species more tolerant of high temperature than faster growing species M . mirabilis grew significantly more slowly after fragmentation Skeletal extension declined significantly in 100 pprn treatment
Neudecker (1983)
Shading significantly affected growth rate but no observed effect on growth rate as a result of exposure to sedimentation
Rogers (1979)
Exposure of corals to temperatures of 30°C reduced calcification
Jokiel and Coles (1977)
Bak and Criens (1981) Dodge (1983)
(continued)
TABLE111. (CONTINUED) Criterion: growth rate
As determined by "Ca incorporation
Nature of study and location
Species
Observations in the field, CuraGao
Selection of Caribbean corals
Dredging
Laboratory experiment
M . annularis
Drilling mud 1, 10, 100 ppm doses for 6 weeks
Laboratory experiment
Millepora sp., Madracis decactis, M . annularis, Oculina diffusu, Favia fragitrn
Water-soluble fractions of fuel oil and Louisiana crude oil
Disturbance
Results Exposure to increased turbidity and sedimentation caused a decrease in calcification rates of M . rnirabilis and A . agaricites Calcification rates decreased at 100 ppm dose after 4 weeks' exposure Variable results with no indications of a significant effect of hydrocarbons on 4SCaincorporation
Reference Bak (1978)
Szmant-Froelich et al. (1981)
Neff and Anderson (1983)
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON REEF CORALS
25
tal disturbance, although reduced growth rates in the Florida Keys coincide with a period of dredge and fill operations. Dodge and Lang (in Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984) suggest that the decline in coral growth at the Flower Gardens may be due to water temperature fluctuations and increasing river discharge in the area. Another feature revealed by x-radiography is the presence of highdensity skeletal deposits or “stress” bands which have been observed in sections of M . annularis during periods of rapid chilling and mixing of shallow inshore waters (Hudson et a f . , 1976; Hudson, 1977, 1981) (Fig. 2). In addition, Highsmith (1979) has noted that, in M . annulavis from Belize, the high-density bands appear to be deposited for only short periods of
2.2 cm FIG.2. “Stress bands” revealed in sections of M . annularis exposed to periods of chilling and mixing of shallow inshore waters. B and C indicate the boring activities of sponges (Hudson, 1977).
26
B . E . BROWN A N D L. S. HOWARD
time while the low-density band is produced for a greater part of the year when compared with M . cavernosa and P . astreoides from the same locality. Highsmith attributes this difference to the contrasting distribution pattern of the corals ( M . cauernosa and P . astreoides being relatively restricted with respect to the broader tolerances of M. annularis), which may be reflected in the density banding pattern. It would seem, then, that massive corals living under similar environmental conditions are likely to reflect environmental variables to different degrees and that, while M . annularis is widely used in sclerochronological techniques because of the clarity of its banding pattern and wide distribution, other massive corals may be more sensitive indicators of changing environmental conditions. One alternative suggested by Hudson (1981) is S . sidereu which, although environmentally tolerant, does have a very close banding pattern enabling test cores to record longer time periods when compared with M . annularis. Whether S . siderea reflects lesser or greater sensitivity to environmental change than M . annularis remains to be seen. Reduction in growth rate of branching corals as a result of thermal discharge (Neudecker, 1983) and fragmentation (Bak and Criens, 1983) has been observed using alizarin staining. Neudecker concluded that slower growing coral species were more tolerant of high temperatures than faster growing species, the fastest growing coral in his study being A . formosa, extending at a rate of 4.9 k 0.3 mm, while the slower growing coral P . andrewsii grew at a rate of 4.2 2 0.2 mm over the same 63-day period. No significance values were attributed to this comparison, and since there were no measurements of the weight of calcium carbonate deposited or the density of the skeleton laid down, care must be taken in interpreting the data as suggesting slower growing corals are more tolerant of thermal enrichment than faster growing species. Measurements of skeletal growth (as weight of CaC03 deposited) in Hawaiian corals exposed to increased temperatures (4-5°C) did not indicate similar results (Jokiel and Coles, 1977). The order of increasing thermal tolerance was P . damicornis < Montipora verrucosa (Lamarck) and Fungia scutaria (Lamarck), while M . verrucosa calcified most rapidly and F . scutaria least rapidly of the three corals tested. Rogers (1979), in her estimation of the effects of sedimentation on growth rate in A . cervicornis (determined by measuring skeletal growth from a base line), stresses the importance of making adequate measurements of branch extension on a large number of branches from different colonies of the same species before reliable data can be obtained. Results of this study indicated that even daily sediment doses of 200 mg/cm2for 45 days did not affect growth rates of treated corals when compared with controls.
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
27
In contrast, Bak (1978) demonstrated an acute decrease in growth rate (measured as a 33% decrease in calcification) of M. mirabilis and A . agaricites as a result of increased sedimentation from dredging activites in CuraGao. Depressed calcification rates were noted for more than 1 month after reduction in light levels and suggest that the decrease in growth is not just the result of reduced light but also of metabolic shock that exceeded the period of environmental disturbance. The effects of water-soluble fractions of a fuel oil and Louisiana crude oil on the rate of calcium deposition (measured as 45Caincorporation into the skeleton) in Millepora sp., Madracis decactis (Lyman), M . annuluris, Oculina diffusa (Lamarck), and Favia fragum (Esper) were quite variable, with sample variability being greater in hydrocarbon-exposed animals than in controls (Neff and Anderson, 1981). Such variability was attributed to the individual variation between colonies or parts of colonies in their sensitivity to oil, an explanation also favoured by Birkeland et ul. (1976) using coral growth as a parameter in assessing the effects of bunker oils on corals. Despite the variability encountered in growth rate data, it would appear that this parameter has considerable value in many field observations, particularly since both branching and massive species can be transplanted into different reef sites. B. Metabolism
A criticism of the use of metabolism as an indicator of stress in short-term experiments carried out in temperate waters has been the environmentally unrealistic levels of pollutants required to produce any effect (R. C. Newell, personal communication). In the limited number of experiments carried out with tropical scleractinians (Table IV) efforts have been made in many cases to carry out experimental manipulations in the field (Rogers, 1979; Dallmeyer et al., 1982), and in all examples cited some impairment of an aspect of metabolism has been noted as a result of experimental disturbance (Rogers, 1979; Dallmeyer et al., 1982; Szmant-Froelich et al., 1983). It is difficult to say, however, how experimental conditions in each case correspond to those observed in the field. Exposure of M . annularis to gradually increasing suspended peat levels of 175, 350, and 525 mg/litre may reduce photosynthesis during the day and oxygen levels during the night (Dallmeyer et al., 1982), but no indication is given in this article of the levels of peat in natural waters at Negril, even in the brown plume reported in the field (Dallmeyer et al., 1982). A need for improved information on levels of pollutants in the field and experimental designs that more accurately approach water quality conditions in situ has been
TABLE1v. THE USE
OF
METABOLISM TO
Criterion Metabolism Primary productivity and respiration Respiration, gross photosynthesis. NO1 UPtake, NH, uptake Respiration and net photosynthetic production Photosynthesis and respiration
Nature of study and location
EFFECTSO F DISTURBANCE O N CORALS EXPERIMENTALLY I N THE FIELD
ASSESS T H E
AND
Species
Disturbance
IN THE
LABORATORY
Results
Reference
Experimental channels in the field, San Cristobal
Caribbean corals
Experimental shading
Primary productivity and respiration decreased as a result of shading
Rogers (1979)
Laboratory experiment in Row-through seawater system
M . unnuluris
Exposure to 1. 10, and 100 ppm drilling mud for 6 weeks
Respiration and photosynthesis, NO3 and NH4 uptake all decreased as a result of exposure to 100 ppm drilling mud
Szmant-Froelich crl. (1983)
I n situ measurement of
M . unnuluris
Exposure to suspended peat
Reduced net oxygen production as a result of exposure to suspended peat
Dallmeyer et 01. (1982)
P . darnicornis, M . uerrucosa, P . compressa, Fungin scutariu
Thermal increase
Coral metabolism closely adapted to ambient T o conditions; results suggest lethal temperatures for Enewetak specimens to be 2-5°C higher than for Hawaiian corals
Cotes and Jokiel (1977)
oxygen metabolism, Negril, Jamaica
Laboratory experiment, Hawaii and Enewetak
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON REEF CORALS
29
highlighted by Hudson et al. (1982) and Dodge and Szmant-Froelich (1984), respectively. In all examples cited, a key factor leading to reduced production as a result of shading (Rogers, 1979), exposure to drilling mud (SzmantFroelich et al., 1983), and exposure to suspended peat (Dallmeyer et al., 1982) was expulsion of zooxanthellae-a response which will be discussed in detail in Section II1,C. Short-term (1- to 2-h intervals) exposure of M. annularis to suspended peat concentrations of a maximum of 525 mg/litre resulted in a 50% fall in production and respiration rates when pre- and postexposure rates were compared over a 24-h period. Longer term exposure of M. annuluris to 100 mg/litre drilling mud in a flowthrough system for 4 weeks resulted in a 25% fall in respiration rate and a decline in gross photosynthesis of 75% when compared with controls after 5 weeks (Szmant-Froelich et al., 1983). Shading alone of a selection of Caribbean corals (including M. annularis) produced a fall in production of approximately 50% after cover of 4 weeks (Rogers, 1979). Recent work by Barnes (1983) may have some application to the study of stressed environments. Using a buoy equipped with pH and oxygen electrodes and a sensitive thermistor, he obtained measurements of changes in oxygen concentration, pH, and temperature of water across the reef flat, from which he deduced values for reef productivity and calcification. Barnes cites Kinsey (1979), who suggested that reef flats operate within narrow metabolic limits, any departures from these limits possibly reflecting perturbation. Once the respiratory and metabolic characteristics of reef communities are better understood, such a method as that described above may have a place in pollution studies. The technique has one distinct advantage over other “metabolism” studies in that it could be carried out in the field and potentially could give a direct measurement of the “health” of similar reef areas.
C. Loss oJ’ Zooxunthellur The loss of zooxanthellae from coral tissue has been described by several authors (Franzicket, 1970; Jokiel and Coles, 1974; Jaap and Wheaton, 1975; Neff and Anderson, 1981) as a useful indicator of stress. Discolouration of corals as a consequence of zooxanthellae release may result from natural factors such as elevated temperatures and low tides (Vaughan, 1916; Yonge and Nicholls, 1931; Jaap, 1979), decreased temperatures (Wells, personal communication, in Jaap, 1979), salinity changes due to storms (Goreau, 1964), and also laboratory-induced elevated temperatures, darkness, and starvation (Yonge and Nicholls, 1931). In addition, as illustrated in Table V, loss of zooxanthellae may result from man-made
TABLEv. Criterion Expulsion of zooxanthellae
LOSS OF
ZOOXANTHELLAE AS
Nature of study and location
A
RESULTOF MAN-MADE A N D NATURAL DISTURBANCES
Species
Disturbance
Results
Reference Coles (1975); Jokiel and Coles (1974); Jokiel and Coles (1977) Jaap and Wheaton (1975)
Field and laboratory observations. Hawaii
Hawaiian reef corals
Elevated temperatures of 2-4°C
Loss of zooxanthellar pig-
Application of pollutant by divers in the field at Western and Eastern Sambo. Florida
Caribbean reef corals
Exposure to quinaldine and rotenone derivatives
Field observations at CuraGao
Caribbean reef corals
Dredging activities
Field observations at Middle Sambo, Florida
Caribbean reef corals
Combined high temperatures and low midday tides
Experimental chambers in the field, San Cristobal, Puerto Rico
Caribbean reef corals
Shading for 4 weeks
A . ceruicmwis. A . pulmcttu. S . sidereu. D . strigosu. and Dichocoeniu stokesii showed bleaching as a result of application of chemicals P. astrvoidrs lost zooxanBak (1978) thellae and subsequently died Millrporcr complunutu Jaap ( 1979) displayed greatest discolouration; A. pulmutu, M . unnuloris, and Polvtlioo sp. were mildly discoloured A . c<jruic,ornis.A . t ~ g ~ r i c ' i - Rogers (1979) les, Millepora ulcicornis, M . unnuluris. D . lubyrinthiformis, S .
ment
A . ceruicornis
Sedimentation
Experimental chambers in the field. Carysfort Reef, Florida
Seven Caribbean reef species
Drilling mud
Field observations, Ha. waii
Hawaiian reef corals
Kaolin spill
Transplant of corals to varying depths, Discovery Bay. Jamaica Experimental studies in situ. Negril, Jamaica
M . einnirltrri~
Transplanting of coral to 10 and 30 m depth Addition of suspended peat to environmental chambers. during night and day Elevated temperatures 4-6°C above ambient
Transplant studies at sites of thermal enrichment, Guam
M . cinnirloris
sidereit. and C . n c i i o n s all show some zooxanthellae expulsion; large polyped species least affected Both controls and test colonies showed small areas of bleached tissue A . ceruicornis exposed to “mud 3” lost all zooxanthellae after 41 h: all tissue disintegrated within 52 h Expulsion of zooxanthellae in P. mcwndrino and Poc~illlporcievdomi Corals transplanted from 30 to 15 m showed loss of zooxanthellae Loss of zooxanthellae by corals exposed to peat
A . fornio.sii and P. dciniicornis showed loss of
zooxant hellae
Thompson (1980)
1’1
it/.
Dollar and Grigg (1981) Dustan ( 1979)
Dallmeyer et ril. (1982)
Neudecker (1983)
32
B. E. BROWN A N D L. S. HOWARD
disturbances such as thermal discharge (Coles, 1975; Jokiel and Coles, 1974, 1977; Neudecker, 1983), dredging (Bak, 1978), exposure to drilling mud (Thompson et al., 1980), kaolin (Dollar and Grigg, 1981), peat (Dallmeyer et al., 1982), quinaldine (Jaap and Wheaton, 1975), oil (Peters et al., 1981), shading (Rogers, 1979), and transplantations from deep- to shallow-water reefs (Lang, 1973; Dustan, 1979) and from offshore to inshore sites (Shinn, 1976). The loss of zooxanthellae in different coral species subject to similar stresses under the same environmental conditions is extremely variable; the response within an individual coral may even differ over the colony (Rogers, 1979; Neff and Anderson, 1981). Triggering mechanisms for zooxanthellae expulsion have been cited as reduced supplies of nutrients available to the algae from the stressed coral host (Yonge and Nicholls, 1931; Muscatine, 1971), decrease in space available to the algae caused by atrophied host tissues (Muscatine, 1971), and secretion of substances by the coral host which produce a hostile environment around the algae (Jaap, 1979). Such mechanisms do not seem a wholly adequate explanation of the phenomenon for at least two reasons. First, the response may take place very rapidly, loss of zooxanthellae being reported within hours by Jokiel and Coles (1974), Thompson et al. (1980), Dallmeyer et al. (1982), and Neudecker (1981), and within 5 min by Jaap and Wheaton (1975). Second, although space may decrease in atrophied host tissues (Muscatine, 1971), Peters et al. (1981) have shown that under such conditions many zooxanthellae actually degenerate in situ. Clearly this aspect requires further clarification; it may well be that the speed and intensity of polyp retraction following disturbance is sufficient to expel zooxanthellae via the coelenteron, differing responses observed in corals simply reflecting the intensity of the reaction. In two studies where other aspects of coral behaviour were noted, in addition to tissue colouration, bleaching generally followed a period of polyp retraction which continued for longer than 5 min posttreatment (Jaap and Wheaton, 1975) or for the whole 96-h period of the experiment (Thompson et al., 1980). The route taken during expulsion is via the absorptive zone of the mesenteries, just below the filaments (Fig. 3), although the actual stimulus that causes the algae to be conveyed is unknown. Some authors have described connections between zooxanthellae loss, polyp size, and other stressful environmental parameters (Rogers, 1979), but results obtained in other studies do not appear to show any consistent patterns (Goreau, 1964). In Goreau’s study (1964) of the effect of salinity changes, following Hurricane Flora, on 16 Caribbean coral species, M . annularis was observed to be the species most susceptible to zooxanthellae loss. In this study no correlation between tendency to lose zooxanthel-
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
33
FIG. 3. Transverse section through a portion of mesenterial filament of Goniu.s~rmsp. after exposure to elevated temperatures, showing zooxanthella in process of ejection. Abbreviations: az, absorptive zone; z, zooxanthella; ze, zooxanthella being ejected; m, mesogloea; gm, glandular margin (after Yonge and Nicholls, 1931).
lae and polyp size was observed. Other studies indicate rather variable results, with Millepora complanata (Lamarck) displaying a greater tendency to discolour over A . palmata and M . annularis as a result of ternperature stress at low tide; the latter two species, with small and mediumsized polyps, respectively, both showing medium discolouration (Jaap, 1979). P. astreoides displayed a marked loss of zooxanthellae as a result of dredging (Bak, 1978) when compared to other small polyped corals such as A . agaricites, and in other small polyped varieties A . formosa lost greater numbers of zooxanthellae than P. damicornis when exposed to a 5 4 ° C temperature increase (Neudecker, 1983). The two studies where a correlation between polyp size and zooxanthellae loss has been described are those of Jokiel and Coles (1974) and Rogers (1979). Jokiel and Coles (1974) noted that the larger polyped coral L . purpurea was more tolerant of thermal increases than the smaller polyped species P . rrteandrina and P. lobata, which lost their zooxanthellae more rapidly on response to temperature increases 4-5°C above ambient. Rogers (1979) described a fairly close connection between increased susceptibility to shading, as demonstrated by bleaching, with decreased polyp size, e.g., A. cervicornis, with small polyps being the first species to bleach, followed by M. annularis, D. labyrinthiformis, and D . strigosa,
34
B. E . B R O W N A N D L. S. H O W A R D
with medium-sized polyps and large polyped species such as Eusrnalia fastigiata (Pallas), Mussa angulosa (Pallas), and M . cauernosa appearing relatively unaffected by shading. The author acknowledges, however, that the latter species were growing at the edge of experimental channels where light may not have been totally excluded. The apparent lack of a relationship between polyp size and the tendency for zooxanthellae loss in some studies, and yet the existence of an apparent relationship between the two parameters in others, probably reflects the likely complexity of the response. Apart from the obvious variability in responses from different corals at a given depth, the same species collected from a variety of depths may also exhibit widely differing responses. M . annularis from different depths contains zooxanthellae which are photoadapted to specific habitats (Dustan, 1979). In transplant experiments, zooxanthellae adapted to high light intensities function poorly in deeper water habitats, while zooxanthellae adapted to low light intensities are actually damaged by high light intensities in shallow waters. At deep water sites, corals transplanted from shallower depths show some reduction in algal content; in contrast, corals transplanted from deep water to shallow water display considerable bleaching and high mortality (Dustan, 1982). Hence, the tendency to lose zooxanthellae in response to changing light intensities is very much dependent upon the original position of the coral within the reef environment. Considering, then, the limited literature to date, it would seem that loss of zooxanthellae in response to a particular stress does give some indication of the relative tolerance of a coral species to parameters such as temperature increase, salinity change, etc. There are problems, however, in interpreting such responses since they may be reversible (Jokiel and Coles, 1974, 1977; Jaap, 1979); they may be very localized, the undersurface of an affected coral displaying little apparent loss of zooxanthellae (Jokiel and Coles, 1977); or they may reflect not only one stress but a combination of two or more, such as combined temperature and strong light intensity (Jokiel and Coles, 1977). In addition, loss of zooxanthellae may occur unperceived by the observer but calculated through some other measurable parameter such as reduced calcification (Bak, 1978) or production (Dallmeyer et al., 1982). Quantification of the response is possible by extraction of photosynthetic pigment from coral tissues, and this has been successfully carried out by a number of workers (Jokiel and Coles, 1974; Dallmeyer et al., 1982) in response to thermal stress and addition of peat, respectively. The value of the response of loss of zooxanthellae by coral tissues as an indicator of stress could be considerably improved (1) by quantification of the magnitude of algal loss using pigment extraction techniques, (2) by better understanding of the mechanism
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON REEF CORALS
35
of expulsion of the algae, and (3) by relating this response to other physiological parameters. D. 1.
Behaviourul Responsvs
Feeding and mesenterial filament extrusion
Mesenterial filament extrusion by scleractinian corals has been widely reported by early workers (Duerden, 1902; Carpenter, 1910; Vaughan, 1912; Matthai, 1918; Yonge, 1930) in connection with feeding activities. These early studies revealed the ability of many scleractinians to engage in extracoelenteric digestion of food material by means of filaments extruded either through the mouth or through temporary openings on the colony surface (Fig. 4). Lewis and Price (1975) failed to observe corals feeding routinely by this method and commented that in many cases where extracoelenteric digestion was described in the literature this was connected with the presence of large particles of food on the oral disc. Nevertheless, numerous other workers have noted mesenterial filament extrusion as a result of exposure of scleractinians to feeding inducers such as the amino acids glutathione and proline (Brown and Phillips, unpublished; Mariscal and Lenhoff, 1968; Goreau et al., 1971), where tactile stimuli were not involved.
FIG.4. The extrusion of mesenterial filaments through the mouth and body wall of a coral polyp. Abbreviations: t , tentacle; m, mesentery; f, filament; c, calyx; s, skeleton (after Goreau et at., 1979).
36
B . E. BROWN A N D L . S . HOWARD
The extrusion of mesenterial filaments in interspecific aggression responses by corals has been reported both in the Caribbean (Lang, 1970, 1971; Bak et al., 1982) and in the Indo-Pacific (C. R. C. Sheppard, personal communication). Sheppard (1979) implies that the response is triggered as a result of chemoreception properties of the aggressor, a suggestion first put forward by Muscatine (1973) when considering the nutrition of corals. Filament extrusion has also been cited in recent years as a response of corals to adverse conditions (Table VI). Goreau et al. (1971) report severe starvation resulting in extrusion of mesenterial filaments by M . angulosa; Lewis (1971) describes the same response in Madracis asperula (Milne, Edwards, and Haime) when exposed to crude oil and oil dispersant; Bak and Elgershuizen (1976) recorded filament extrusion in M. decactis as the result of the presence of oil droplets in the gastrovascular cavity, while M . annularis was observed to extrude mesenterial filaments in response to exposure to drilling muds (Thompson et a/., 1980). Similar behaviour has also been recently reported by S. Wyers (personal communication) in D . strigosa exposed to fuel oil. All these observations apply to laboratory experiments, although J. H. Thompson (personal communication, in Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, (1984) observed mesenterial filament extrusion on four heads of M . annularis in the field after application of 5 ml drilling mud slurry to each. The same behaviour was observed on four heads of M . annularis treated with a similar amount of carbonate sand. The majority of examples of filament extrusion cited above have been the result of exposure of animals to oil. Both Loya and Rinkevich (1980) and Ormond and Caldwell (1982), reviewing the literature concerning anthozoan feeding behaviour and oil exposure, highlight the work of Blumer et al. (1971), which discussed the possible interference of crude oil products with chemoreception in marine invertebrates. The mechanism suggested involved the mimicking of natural stimuli by the oil product, which in turn elicited feeding behaviour. Tentacle responses and/or mouth-opening reactions also associated with feeding (Table VI) have been observed in anthozoans in response to crude oil pollution (Reimer, 1975a,b; Loya and Rinkevich, 1980; Ormond and Caldwell, 1982). Experiments with the temperate anthozoan Actinia equina (Linnaeus) suggest that crude oil or some component of crude oil does act as a feeding inducer, whereas the pure hydrocarbons tested did not. It was also shown that crude oil presented on filter paper to the anemones either interfered with or diluted the action of natural feeding inducers present in fish muscle extract (Ormond and Caldwell, 1982). Clearly the mechanism(s) involved in the appearance of mesenterial filaments and other feeding responses such as mouth opening as a result of exposure to pollutants are unclear. The use of filament extrusion as an
TABLEVI. THE USE OF MESENTERIAL FILAMENT EXTRUSION TO ASSESSTHE EFFECTSOF DISTURBANCE O N CORALSIN EXPERIMENTALLY I N THE FIELD Criterion Mesenterial filament extrusion
Nature of study and location
THE
Species
Disturbance
Results
Laboratory experiment, Barbados, West Indies
Porites porites, Madracis asperula, F. fragum, A . agaricites
Exposure to crude oil and oil spill dispersant
Laboratory experiment at Caribbean Marine Biological Institute, CuraGao
Nineteen Caribbean coral species
Exposure to crude oil and sediments
Experimental chambers sited on a sand flat at Carysfort Reef, Key Largo. Florida
Seven Caribbean coral species
Exposure to drilling mud
Field experiment, Key Largo, Florida
M . annularis
Exposure to drill mud slurry or carbonate sand
Flow-through laboratory experiment, Bermuda
D . strigosa
Exposure to crude oil
M . asperula exhibited greatest effects on addition of 50 ppm oil, involving an increase of extrusion of mesenterial filaments; all species were more affected by the dispersant than by the crude oil Extrusion of mesenterial filaments in response to introduction of oil drops into the gastrovascular cavity Some polyps of M . annularis extruded mesenterial filaments; other corals tested did not show this response Although sediments were cleared within 2 h, all corals showed mesenterial filament extrusion later Extrusion of mesenterial filaments
LABORATORY AND
Reference Lewis (1971)
Bak and Elgershuizen ( 1976)
Thompson et a / . (1980)
Thompson, in Dodge and Szmant-Froelich (1984) S. Wyers, personal communication
38
B . E . BROWN A N D L . S . HOWARD
indicator of stress, often cited by workers (Lewis, 1971; Bak and Elgershuizen, 1976; Thompson, et al., 1980), would appear to be complicated by the variability in response of individual corals (S. Wyers, personal communication), the often temporary nature of the response (Thompson et al., 1980), its regular appearance in certain coral species and not in others (Goreau et al., 1971), and a lack of understanding of natural stimuli which might elicit such behaviour. Other behavioural responses normally associated with feeding and also sediment shedding, such as coenosarc distension, have been observed on exposure of certain coral species to pollutants (Thompson et al., 1980; Dallmeyer et al., 1982). Bak and Elgershuizen (1979) describe the sequence of events which follows a sediment rain on an expanded coral surface as initial contraction of the polyps followed by a marked expansion of tissues including the coenosarc. Such behaviour was also observed in M . annularis at night after exposure to drilling mud, although other corals, e.g., Porites diuaricata (Lesueur), Porites frrrcata (Lamarck), P . astreoides, A . cervicornis, A . agaricites, and Dichocoeniu stokesii (Edwards and Haime), under similar conditions did not display coenosarc expansion (Thompson et al., 1980). Addition of peat to M . annularis (Dallmeyer et al., 1982) also resulted in conspicuous coenosarc distension at night. A reverse phenomenon, i.e., polyp retraction, has been used in some studies to assess the toxicity of pollutants (Jaap and Wheaton, 1975; Thompson et al., 1980). Contraction of polyps as a reaction to stress in the form of electrical stimulation was described by Horridge (1957), and to extreme water currents by Hubbard (1974), while Bak and Elgershuizen (1979) observed contraction as a reaction to contact with nonfood particles. Polyp retraction was a common reaction of all 12 Caribbean corals exposed to fish-collecting chemicals (Jaap and Wheaton, 1975), while in experiments with drilling muds five species ( M . annularis, A . agaricites, A . cervicornis, P . furcata, and P . astreoides) demonstrated significant polyp retraction to 100 ppm and higher concentrations of drilling mud. D . stokesii, however, showed no reaction to drilling muds at any of the tested concentrations, while P . diuaricata displayed significant retraction at 316 ppm. Exposure of corals to water-soluble fractions of fuel oil resulted in polyps of M . decactis and M . annularis remaining partially or totally retracted while polyps of control corals were fully expanded during all or most of the exposure period (Neff and Anderson, 1981). These authors describe retraction of polyps as a sign of the effects of severe stress in corals. While acknowledging that individual polyps can alternate between an expanded and a retracted state (Sweeney, 1976; Sebens and de Riemer,
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
39
1977), with some species remaining expanded for long periods of time while others engage in die1 cycles of expansion, Dodge and SzmantFroelich (in press) believe coral polyp retraction may be useful as a bioassay technique for pollutants. Lasker (1979, 1981), however, has shown that in at least one example ( M . cauernosa) expansion cycles may vary within a species. On the Caribbean coast of Panama, colonies of M . cauernosa can be divided into two morphs based on their activity cycles and polyp morphology (Lehman and Porter, 1973; Lasker, 1976, 1977, 1979), with polyps of the diurnal morph of M . cauernosa expanded both day and night, while those of the nocturnal morph expand only at night. Furthermore, in diurnal morph colonies which exhibited zooxanthellae loss and bleaching, only the “normal” part of the colony expanded during the day and night, while the “bleached” area expanded solely at night. The loss of daytime expansion appeared to be linked to the absence of zooxanthellae. Since zooxanthellae loss has been cited as a response of many scleractinians to exposure by pollutants (see Section lll,C), careful consideration should be given to behavioural responses involving polyp expansion and retraction which may be influenced by the presence or absence of these symbionts. 2. Mucus production Mucus production by corals has been described during the course of feeding (Lewis and Price, 1975; Lewis, 1977), sediment rejection (Yonge, 1930; Bak, 1978), and shading (Rogers, 1979) and also as a result of exposure to pollutants such as crude oil (Mitchell and Chet, 1975; Neff and Anderson, 1981), copper sulphate (Mitchell and Chet, 1973, fishcollecting chemicals (Jaap and Wheaton, 1973, drilling muds (Thompson et al., 1980), peat (Dallmeyer et al., 1982), and increased temperatures (Neudecker, 1983) (see Table V11). In histological studies an increase in the number and size of mucous secretory cells was observed as a result of exposure of Manicina areolata (Linnaeus) to chronic oil pollution (Peters, et al., 1981). Although excess mucus production as a result of man-made stress has often been cited in the literature, Bak and Elgershuizen (1976) showed that the response of 19 hermatypic Caribbean corals to oiled sediments was not an obvious increase in mucus secretion compared with secretion resulting from exposure to clean sediments. Mucus production may, in some cases, actually delay cleaning of the coral surface, particularly when very small particles (e.g., carborundum powder) become trapped in the mucus. In Bak and Elgershuizen’s study such a process caused death in P . astreoides and A . agaricites.
TABLEVII. THEUSE OF Mucus PRODUCTION TO ASSESSTHE EFFECTSOF DISTURBANCE ON CORALSIN EXPERIMENTALLY IN THE FIELD Criterion
Nature of study and location
Species
Disturbance
Results ~
Mucus production
Fish-collecting chemicals applied in the field
Caribbean reef corals
Exposure to quinaldine and a rotenone derivative
Laboratory experiment
Platygyra spp.
Laboratory experiment at Caribbean Marine Biological Institute, CuraCao
Nineteen Caribbean coral species
Exposure to crude oil, copper sulphate, potassium phosphate or dextrase Exposure to crude oil and sediments
Field experiment, San Cnstobal Reef, S.W. Puerto Rico
Ten Caribbean coral species
Shading
Experimental chambers sited on a sand flat at Carysfort Reef, Key Largo, Florida
Seven Caribbean coral species
Exposure to drilling mud
LABORATORY AND
THE
Reference ~
All corals secreted increased amounts of mucus, although no long-term damage was evident All corals stimulated to produce large quantities of mucus
Jaap and Wheaton (1975)
Certain species (e.g., A . palmata, A. cervicornis, P . porites, and P . astreoides) proved to be copious mucus secreters Some areas on collines of M. annularis secreting mucus after 8 weeks’ shading All corals exhibited an increased mucus production, mucus being produced either as a sheath or as strands
Bak and Elgerhuizen ( 1976)
Mitchell and Chet (1975)
Rogers (1979)
Thompson et al. ( 1980)
Exposure to surface oil slick of south Louisiana crude oil Exposure to elevated temperatures (4-6°C above ambient)
Flow-through experiment on corals from Carysfort Reef, Florida
M . annularis, A . cervicornis, A . palmata
Experimental transplantation in the field, Guam
P . andrewsii, P . damicornis, A . for mosa
Laboratory experiment
Manicina areolata
Exposure to 0.15 ppm oil hydrocarbons for 3 months
Laboratory experiment, Jamaica
M . annularis
Exposure to particulate peat
Mucus production particularly stimulated in M . annuluris
Neff and Anderson (1981)
A . formosa appeared
Neudecker (1983)
most sensitive to elevated temperatures and produced large quantities of mucus after a few hours of exposure; mucus production was also noted during alizarin staining in P . andrewsii, although these colonies were not used in subsequent experiments Histological studies revealed an increase in the number of mucussecreting cells in tissues of exposed corals Clumps of mucus produced on the surface of the coral trapped peat, but were subsequently removed. After 15 h the coral showed a normal appearance
Peters er al. (1981)
Dallmeyer et al. (1982)
42
B. E. BROWN AND L. S . HOWARD
Under normal circumstances mucus production may result in up to 40% net carbon fixation being lost from a coral such as Acropora acuminata (Verrill) (Crossland, Barnes and Borowitzka, 1980), so mucus production in corals under stress may constitute a considerable energy loss, as noted by other authors (Loya and Rinkevich, 1980). Workers also suggest that mucus may bind or absorb pollutants such as aromatic hydrocarbons (Neff and Anderson, 1981) or heavy metals (Howard and Brown, 1984) and so confer some protection to the underlying coral tissues either by physically protecting them or by acting as an avenue for hydrocarbon release from contaminated corals (Neff and Anderson, 1981). However, it is also well known that mucus strands and nets may be ingested by corals (Lewis and Price, 1975); should oil particles be trapped in the mucus, then these may also be ingested during the feeding process (Bak and Elgershuizen, 1976). An increase in mucus production by a coral under stress may also result in significant increases in the bacterial population of the mucus (Ducklow and Mitchell, 1979), and these effects will be discussed later in this article (see Section 111,F).The existing literature on effects of drilling muds and increased temperature exposure on selected corals suggests that Acropora spp. readily produce mucus when compared with other coral species exposed to the same stress. In experiments with drilling muds (Thompson et al., 1980), A . cervicornis produced mucus strands after 30 min exposure, whereas mucus production in other species (P. divaricata, P. furcata, P. astreoides, and M . annularis) was not observed until at least 24 h after mud application. (It should be noted that these responses were not shown by all colonies of the test species.) Exposure of A . formosa, P . andrewsii, and P . damicornis to 5-6°C temperature increase at the Cabros Power Plant, Guam, resulted in considerable mucus production in A. formosa after a few hours; all test colonies in one experiment were dead within 48 h of exposure, whereas P . damicornis died within 30 days and P. andrewsii survived the entire test period of 77 days. No note of excessive mucus production in Pocillopora or Porites was reported (Neudecker, 1983). If mucus production were to be used as a measure of stress, then some attempts would have to be made to assess the amount of mucus produced during exposure to a pollutant. Using techniques adopted by Crossland et al. (1980a), it would be possible to quantify the amount of mucus produced and also the rate of production in a stressed coral. Quantification of mucus production rates is limited to A . acuminata, where the rate of mucus output does not appear to vary diurnally. Extension of quantitative methods of mucus production to corals under stress would necessarily demand some base line information of the type already obtained for A . acuminata.
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON R E E F CORALS
3.
43
Sediment shedding
Sediment-shedding behaviour has been observed in a variety of corals by numerous authors (Hubbard and Pocock, 1972; Hubbard, 1974; Schumacher, 1979; Lasker, 1980; Fisk, 1983). Hubbard and Pocock described a ranking in the ability of Caribbean coral species to reject sediments which was related to the diameter of coral colonies and their abundance on the colony surface, but subsequent work by Bak and Elgershuizen (1976) failed to demonstrate such a relationship in Caribbean corals. Other workers, however, have used sediment-shedding behaviour to assess the effects of drilling mud (Thompson, no date, in Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984; Thompson and Bright, 1980), oiled sediments (Bak and Elgershuizen, 1976), and heavy metals (Brown and Holley, unpublished) on reef corals (Table VIII). Results of experiments with drilling muds showed that while clearing rates varied from species to species, all three species tested ( D . strigosa, M. annufaris, and M . cauernosa) could clear barite, bentonite, and CaC03 but no species was able to remove the used drilling mud. The authors suggested that dissolved, toxic components of the mud were responsible for this dramatic difference in response. Similar results were obtained with M . annularis and P . astreoides exposed to drilling muds and carbonate sands. Montastrea failed to move the drilling mud and died within 15 h, while treated P. astreoides died within 10 days. Those specimens covered by carbonate sand recovered completely. In the 19 hermatypic coral species tested by Bak and Elgershuizen (1976), the efficiency of removal of oil sediment particles was the same and performed by an identical rejection mechanism as when they were covered with clean particles of the same size or quality. These authors highlighted the complexity of mechanisms involved in sediment rejection by corals, a feature noted recently by Fisk (1983) working with sediment shedding in fungiids. Bak and Elgershuizen state that the relationship between rejection efficiency and density of sediment particles and their size may involve a very rapid rejection, a rejection over time, or no rejection at all; e.g., M . cauernosa removes large oil-sand particles (3-mm diameter) by movements of the tentacles and polyp expansion, whereas smaller oil-sand particles (1-mm diameter) fall between the polyps and are rejected by ciliary activity; much smaller particles (0. I-mm diameter) are transported very rapidly by the cilia. Bak and Elgershuizen also noted that in some species rejection patterns varied considerably depending on the degree of expansion of the living tissue, a finding supported by Brown and Holley (unpublished) working with Fungia fungites (Linnaeus) exposed to metal-laden sediments.
TABLEVIII. THE USEOF SEDIMENT SHEDDING TO ASSESS THE EFFECTS OF DISTURBANCE ON CORALS I N THE LABORATORY AND EXPERIMENTALLY IN THE FIELD
Laboratory study
D . strigosa, M . annularis, M . cauernosa
Exposure to crude oil and sediments
Patterns of oil sediment rejection are identical to patterns of rejection of clean sediments; rates of sediment shedding are dependent on size and density of particles Cleaning rates varied from species to species; all corals could remove barite, bentonite, and calcium carbonate; no species was able to remove all the drilling mud
Laboratory experiment at Caribbean Marine Biological Institute
Exposure to drilling mud, barite, bentonite, and calcium carbonate
Sediment shed1 ding \
Nineteen Caribbean coral species
Results
Criterion
Laboratory experiment at Caribbean Marine Biological Institute
Disturbance
Laboratory study
Nature of study and location
Nineteen Caribbean coral species Species
Sediment shedding 1
Species
D . strigosa, M . annularis, M . cauernosa
\
Nature of study and location
Exposure to drilling mud, barite, bentonite, and calcium carbonate
Patterns of rejection to of clean rates of ding are size and particles Cleaning from all barite, calcium species remove mud
Criterion
Reference Bak and Elgershuizen (1976)
Thompson and Bright (1980)
Exposure to crude oil and sediments Disturbance
TABLEVIII. THE USEOF SEDIMENT SHEDDING TO ASSESS THE EFFECTS OF DISTURBANCE ON EXPERIMENTALLY IN THE FIELD
Laboratory study
Field experiment San Cristobal, Puerto Rico
M . annularis
M . annularis, D. srrigosa, Diploria cliuosa, A. palmata, A . cervicornis
Exposure to 10-ml aliquots of different (A and B) drilling muds and natural finegrained muds Exposure to calcareous sediments in different frequencies and doses
Corals were able to clear natural sediments and one type of drilling mud (A); only one specimen was able to clear the more concentrated drilling mud (B) A. palmata was the least tolerant of all species tested; although A . cervicornis and D . srrigosa were not significantly affected, single applications of 800 mglcm* to M . annularis and 200 mgl cm2 to A . palmata colonies caused death of underlying coral tissue
Thompson, in Dodge and SzmantFroelic h (1984)
Rogers (1984)
46
B. E. BROWN A N D L . S. HOWARD
Overall then, sediment-shedding efficiencies in corals exposed to stress may have some value as a bioassay, particularly when the environmental influence under consideration involves a combination of increased sedimentation and a pollutant. However, it must be borne in mind that patterns and efficiency of sediment rejection are often specific to particular coral species, that feeding status may affect ciliary rates (Holley, unpublished), and that observations in the laboratory must be extrapolated to the field with care since rates of sediment rejection in the natural environment may be accelerated by water movements (Bak and Elgershuizen, 1976; Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984).
E. Reproductive Biology Information on sexual (Rinkevich and Loya, 1979b,c; Kojis and Quinn, 1981, 1982; van Moorsel, 1983) and asexual (see Highsmith, 1982, for review) reproduction in corals has increased considerably in recent years. Several authors (Loya and Rinkevich, 1980; Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984) reviewing the effects of pollutants on corals, recognize the value of considering reproductive biology and larval recruitment as top priorities in any toxicity assessment. Not surprisingly in view of our recently acquired knowledge of reproductive strategies in corals, studies on the effects of pollutants on reproductive biology are limited, being restrkted to those of Rinkevich and Loya (1977, 1979a). Observations in thk field and laboratory suggested that populations of S . pistillata at a chronically oil-polluted reef at Eilat showed a smaller number of breeding colonies, a decrease in the average number of ovaria per polyp, a smaller number of planulae produced per coral head, and a lower settlement rate of planulae on artificial objects when compared with control colonies. The authors attributed the significant decrease in the number of ovaria in the oldest colonies from the oilpolluted site to the expulsion of premature and mature planulae, an observation recorded also by Cohen (1973) in the alcyonarian Hetoroxemia fuscescens (Hemprich and Ehrenberg) and Ormond and Caldwell (1982) in the anemone A . equina exposed to oil pollutants. In further laboratory experiments, Rinkevich and Loya (I979a) cut large and mature colonies of S . pistillata into two halves, exposing one half to pollutant and the other to a control solution. Such a procedure was devised to reduce expected variatjbn between colonies, and after 2 months a significant decrease in t& number of female gonads per polyp were recorded in 75% of the polluted halves as compared with control halves of the colonies in clean sea water. Similar detrimental effects of oil have been demonstrated by Peters et
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
47
al. (1981) in the Caribbean coral M . areolata and by Ormond and Caldwell (1982) in the temperate anemone A . equina. In these studies the anthozoans showed either degenerating ova and abnormal gonad development (Peters et al., 1981) or reduced size of ova (Ormond and Caldwell, 1982). The settlement of planulae on artificial substrata in chronic exposures to pollutants in the laboratory would appear to be an attractive bioassay, but care must be taken in selection of planulae for use in such experiments. Rinkevich and Loya (1979a) do not state how planulae were collected for settlement experiments, but experience has shown that planulae released by P . dumicornis in the laboratory display variable development, which may subsequently be reflected in their settlement behaviour during experiments (Brown and Holley, unpublished). In much earlier studies, Marshall and Stephenson (1933) speculated that coral collection in the field produced sufficient disturbance to trigger release of planulae in certain corals. Premature ejection of juveniles as a result of field collection of A . equina has also been described by Ormond and Caldwell (1982). It may be, then, that planulae which are to be used in settlement experiments in the laboratory should be collected in situ by methods adopted by Rinkevich and Loya (1977) when investigating the number of planulae expelled by individual colonies on the reef. In these experiments plankton nets (mesh size 125-pn diameter) were secured to cover individual coral colonies in the late afternoon, the nets being removed 2 h after sunset when the planulae were collected. Although the assessment of oil (Loya and Rinkevich, 1980) and heavy metal (Brown and Holley, unpublished) pollution using criteria based on sexual aspects of reproductive biology of corals may have yielded interesting results, the importance of asexual reproduction in reef coral life histories should not be neglected. Highsmith (1982) has already demonstrated that asexual reproduction by fragmentation is an important mode of reproduction in major reef-building corals. Separation of single colonies into independent units may also occur as a result of fission on partial mortality. Based on field data, Brown and Holley (1982, and unpublished) believe that the incidence of partial mortality in massive species may be increased on intertidal reefs affected by heavy metals and sedimentation in Thailand. Such observations could not be demonstrated easily in the laboratory, but nevertheless they do highlight the need to consider all life history characteristics when assessing the effects of pollutants, especially when many corals reproduce predominately by asexu$l methods (Highsmith, 1982). Coral fragments exposed to stress in thedorm of coral disease proved to be more vulnerable than undisturbed colonies in studies on survival after fragmentation in Curaqao (Bak and Criens, 1983). An unusual regeneration phenomenon, described as “polyp bail-out, ”
48
B. E. BROWN A N D L . S. HOWARD
has recently been demonstrated in Seriatopora hystrix (Dana) (Sammarco, 1982). This response, in which polyps detach from the skeleton and subsequently settle and calcify, has been described as an escape response to environmental stress. Polyp bail-out was induced in the laboratory by maintaining coral colonies in nonaerated, noncirculating sea water. However, the response was also noted in the field where no obvious adverse environmental conditions were apparent. Clearly, this mode of “reproduction” warrants further investigation in both the field and the laboratory. F. Histopathology
In a recent review on the pathology of reef corals (Antonius, 1983a) the author summarizes the four known coral diseases as bacterial infections, algal infections, white band disease, and shutdown reaction. According to Antonius, bacterial infections are often the result of corals protecting themselves against outside stresses by mucus secretion. Mitchell and Chett (1975) provide evidence of the involvement of predatory bacteria, Desulfouibrio, and Beggiatoa in the destruction of living tissue of Platygyra exposed to chemical pollutants. Excessive mucus production resulting from natural and man-made influences (e.g., increased sedimentation, toxic chemicals) may also enhance the numbers of the blue-green alga Oscillatoria submembranacea (Ardissone and Strafforella) thought to be responsible for black band disease. This disease may prove to be more damaging to some corals than to others, and Antonius (1983b) cites a tentative list of susceptibility for Caribbean corals, with D. strigosa and M . annularis as most prone to the disease and A . palmata, A . ceruicornis, and Acropora prolifera (Lamarck) as most resistant to black band infections. No pathogen is yet known to be responsible for white band disease (Antonius, 1983b), although work by E. C. Peters (personal communication, in Gladfelter, 1982b) suggests that bacteria may be responsible. The disease is currently widespread in the northeast Caribbean, Panama, and South Florida, and although Antonius cites A , pafmata as the most affected coral in certain parts of the Caribbean, Bak and Criens (1983) report that A . ceruicornis was more affected by the disease than A . palmata in Curasao. Shutdown reaction has been obydrved as the result of exposure of corals to continuous sedimentation or excessive temperature plus a slight additional stress (e.g., a scratch on the coral surface) which would normally not cause any effect in a healthy coral. The speed of this response, which involves tissue regression, may be spectacular (10 c d h ) , and it now appears that shutdown reactions are highly contagious (Antonius,
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
49
1983a). Antonius suggests that this response may be a purely physiological reaction, although the mechanism is unknown. Despite the apparent lack of understanding of causative agents involved in coral diseases, tumours which incorporate filamentous algae in Caribbean gorgonids have been cited as potential indicators of environmental stress (Morse rt a f . , 1977, 1981). According to these authors, tumour-like growths have previously been observed in scleractinia from the Pacific (Squires, 1965; Soule, 1965; Cheney, 1975). Although the etiology of these growths is unclear in most cases, Kaufman (1980) has described gall-like nodules in Acropora in response to predation by damselfish. The incidence of algal tumours in populations of the Caribbean gorgonid Gorgoniu uentulina (Linnaeus) is highly localized at Bonaire, and Morse et al. (1981) infer that the tumours may be produced in response to high levels of chronic or intermittent hydrocarbon pollution from nearby petroleum tanker lanes and loading depots. Similar tumours, however, have been described in the gorgonian coral Pseudoplexaura spp. in the Florida Keys (Goldman and Makemson, 1983), where the authors make no environmental implications in detailing the widespread occurrence of the condition. Tumours have been previously reported in the gonad tissues of clams collected from an oil-polluted area (Barry and Yevich, 1975), but there is no direct evidence that such pollutants result in malignant tumours. Similar histopathological studies in corals are restricted to observations made by Peters et al. (1981) on the effects of No. 2 fuel oil on M. arraluta after 3 months’ chronic exposure to 0. I ppm and 0.5 ppm concentrations. Cellular degeneration and atrophy of coral tissues were noted in both high and low concentrations of oil, a finding corroborated by S. Wyers (personal communication) working on the effects of oil on the Caribbean coral D . strigosa. Peters et a f . (1981) describe histopathological examinations as providing an early indication of tissue damage which might only be realized at a much later date in benthic ecological studies (i.e., mortality of adults and species recruitment). Despite this statement, it would seem that the general histology of coral tissues is poorly known, and the possible effects of laboratory entrainment and starvation (no mention of feeding of corals is given in the above experiment) on coral tissues remain to be documented. Effects observed by Peters et ul. may not have been the result of only one stress, b u t d m b i n a t i o n of pollutant and starvation. In addition, histopathological techniques generally involve the use of a limited number of specimens (three per assay). Considering the variability highlighted by other workers in measurement of physiological parameters between and even within different coral colonies, the potential pitfalls in histopathological examination of coral tissues are clear.
50
B. E. B R O W N A N D L. S. H O W A R D
G . Biochemical and Cytochemical Indexes Interest in biochemical indexes of effects of stress in reef corals has been shown by those workers studying the effects of drilling muds on Caribbean species (Szmant-Froelich et al., 1983; Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984). Szmant-Froelich and Pilson (1980) had earlier shown that the ratio of lipid to protein reflected the nutritional status of an ahermatypic coral, Astrangia danae (Agassiz). Similar analyses were applied to M . annularis, and although there was no significant difference in nitrogen content (a measure of protein content) between control corals and corals exposed to 100 ppm drilling mud, changes were evident in the lipid content and composition of exposed corals (Dodge and Szmant-Froelich, 1984). These authors also describe several unpublished studies in which biochemical indexes have been used in assessing effects of drilling muds. These include a study by Powell on A . ceruicornis in which exposure to 100 and 500 ppm drilling mud for 24 h produced dramatic increases in the protein content and in the total ninhydrin-positive substances (mostly free amino acids) of coral tissues, and work by Prassad in which he found that treatment of M . decactis with drilling mud at 10 and 100 ppm concentrations actually inhibited protein synthesis. Clearly such measurements need to be interpreted in the light of further data on coral material. Nevertheless, the use of biochemical indexes represents an interesting development in the assessment of effects of stress in reef corals. Such indexes have been used with some success by temperate workers (Jeffries, 1972; Bayne et al., 1976; Moore, 1976; Moore and Stebbing, 1976). Measurements of the taurine/glycine ratio appear to offer some promise as an empirical indicator of stress, at least when the stressor is temperature. Another index of stress used by these workers has been the cytochemical demonstration of latency of lysosomal hydrolases in mussels exposed to temperature stress (Moore, 1976), in hydroids exposed to increased concentrations of Cu, Cd, and Hg (Moore and Stebbing, 1976), and in homogenates of the sterile septa of the anemone Cerianthus lloydii (Gosse) (Tiffon, 1971). The exposure of Mytilus edulis (Linnaeus) to temperatures of 25-28°C over a period of 4 days induced a significant decrease in the latency of lysosomal glucosaminidase. In experiments with (Hincks), cytochemical threshold the hydroid CampanulaQexuosa concentrations were comparable to known environmental levels and were about one order of magnitude lower than those obtained by measuring inhibitory effects in colony growth rates (Moore and Stebbing, 1976). As such, then, these techniques appear to offer a very sensitive way of assessing effects of stress in invertebrate tissues.
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
IV.
51
Discussion and Future Research Needs
Statements such as those of Johannes (1972) and Rogers et af. (1982) that coral reefs are adapted to natural catastrophes but susceptible to unnatural stresses, and that of Loya (1976a) who concluded that human-perturbed reefs may not return to their former configurations, while naturally denuded areas of reef may recover, given time, are obviously very broad generalizations. In the light of recent data, these conclusions are not necessarily supported, for lack of recovery as a result of natural damage has been noted in several cases (see Endean, 1973, for review), and both chronic and acute man-made pollution have been shown to have limited impact in a significant number of examples (see Section 11,C of this article). Furthermore, stresses (e.g., salinity and temperature) in the tropics have been cited as greater than those in temperate waters (Moore, 1972). Moore concluded that tolerances shown by tropical animals would tend to decrease under stress, and that as a result the effect of any additional stress would be exaggerated. This, in turn, led Johannes (1975) to consider that tropical marine communities would appear to be less tolerant to pollution than their temperate counterparts, which has further contributed to the view that c o r d reefs are fragile communities, highly sensitive to a wide range of man-induced pollutants (a view discussed by Dollar and Grigg, 1981). Perhaps we should question the basic premise in the above statement. Considering temperature stress, then, tropical and temperate organisms have similar metabolic rates (measured as O2 consumption) when determined at their respective habitat temperatures (Vernberg, 1962; Vernberg and Vernberg, 1972), although tropical animals may have a limited ability to alter their metabolic response to different temperatures (Vernberg, 1981) when compared with homeostatic mechanisms shown by temperate organisms. Certainly data on one metabolic parameterprimary production-show no clear pattern when compared between tropical and temperate systems, higher values being obtained in tropical benthic communities but lower values in tropical phytoplankton (Johannes, 1975). It is our view, in accor ance with that of Dollar and Grigg (1981), that be as fragile as previous generalizations would reef ecosystems may lead us to believe. We believe that greater attention should be paid in the tropics to interpretation of individual examples of natural and man-made disturbances. Given the variability in responses of corals both in the field and in the laboratory to stress, as highlighted in this article, how should we approach each problem? Here a generalized approach to the assessment of natural and man-made disturbances may have some value in
,;d
52
B . E . BROWN A N D L . S . HOWARD
providing comparative data on tolerances both within and between different coral species and also between different provinces. Conclusions from the foregoing article may be summarized as follows: 1 . Of primary importance is the assessment of the disturbance (manmade or natural) in the field. A lesson learned from temperate studies is that relatively little can be gained from isolated laboratory experiments executed without any field context. Obviously, methods employed to characterize man-made pollution in the field will depend on the form of pollution. It is important that the pollutant should be both physically and chemically characterized in the environment (i.e., waters, sediments, biota, etc.) as completely as possible. Such analyses would ideally be carried out over time, particularly in a region which displayed a marked seasonal regime, i.e., reversing monsoon, where heavy rains and increased sediment loads may alter the biological availability of the pollutant at different times of the year. 2. Measurement of the response of the reef community in the field should involve estimates of abundance and diversity of all dominant members of the benthic community, as described in earlier sections of this article. Estimates of diversity, however, should be interpreted with care, since they may result in misleading conclusions (Hedgepeth, 1973; Johannes, 1975). High diversities may be variously interpreted (Rogers et al., 1982; Brown and Holley, 1982). The latter study showed a high diversity of scleractinians at a polluted site which could be directly attributable to a high diversity of faviids when compared with a control reef. Branching corals, however, were restricted in both number of species and abundance at the polluted location, a feature masked by the high diversity value obtained overall. Estimates of colony size of scleractinians, recruitment, mortality of juveniles, and spatial distribution of living and dead cover in permanent quadrats over time enable man-made disturbances to be evaluated with respect to natural fluctuations at both polluted and unpolluted sites (Bak and Engel, 1979; Bak and Luckhurst, 1980; Bak and Criens, 1983). Such observations constitute a vitally important part of any monitoring program. 3. Experimentahfanipulationsin the field offer considerable scope in assessing the effects of both man-made (Hudson, 1981; Neudecker, 1983) and natural (Bak and Criens, 1983) disturbances. Where appropriate, sediment-shifting capabilities of scleractinians measured in the field (Rogers, 1979, 1984) provide comparative data on a variety of species in different habitats. In addition, contaminated sediments may be used to assess the
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
53
relative tolerances of species from polluted and unpolluted sites under natural conditions. Growth rate measurements also offer a useful and sensitive technique for assessing stress in the field, especially when both branching and massive species are analyzed at selected sites. Unfortunately, very few studies to date have incorporated measurements of both types of coral, so we have no comparative data on tolerances of these species to stress. Techniques such as x-radiography and alizarin staining lend themselves well to transplantation of corals to different habitats, which again enables intra- and interspecific differences between sites to be established. Assessment of the reproductive potential of corals transplanted to different environments may also highlight the effects of stress at polluted sites. Measurement of the number of planulae produced per colony and the fecundity of individual species will ultimately reflect the structure of the whole community. Such techniques (Rinkevich and Loya, 1977) have already clearly demonstrated that pollutants such as oil, previously thought to be relatively harmless to adult corals (for review see Johannes, 1975), are in fact capable of exerting a significant effect on reproductive processes. Asexual reproduction, recognized as an important process on coral reefs (Highsmith, 1982; Tunnicliffe, 1983), may also be assessed in unpolluted and polluted sites by experimental manipulation (Bak and Criens, 1983). Using alizarin red S staining, skeletal extension, weight of calcium carbonate deposited and calcification rates, and growth of fragments may be compared with intact colony measurements in different habitats. 4. Experimental biossays in the laboratory should be closely related to field measurements and if possible be used to extend or confirm observations made in the field. There is little convincing evidence in the literature reviewed so w o f a sensitive laboratory bioassay to any pollutant tested; neither is there any indication of how many of the parameters measured relate to the ultimate survival of the coral. Work in progress in Bermuda (S. Wyers, personal communication) attempts to combine a series of laboratory assays on the effects of oil on scleractinians with a closely monitored recovery period in the field. Overall, however, results of laboratory exposure of corals to pollutants tend to be very variable, particularly with respect to behavioural responses, and it may well be argued that a new approach is urgently required here. Such an approach has already been adopted with temperate marine organisms in the use of a “scope for growth” model which measures the response of individuals to environmental stress and pollution (Bayne and Widdows, 1978). These authors argue that it is unlikely that analyses of physiological parameters such as behaviour, growth, and reproduction will provide information on
54
B . E. BROWN A N D L. S. HOWARD
specific environmental stresses since changes in the biochemical targets of particular pollutants will be integrated into more generalized physiological changes as part of a response syndrome. The equation for the scope for growth is as follows:
P
=
A
-
(R
+ U)
where P = production or scope for growth A = product of consumption and efficiency of absorption of energy from food R = respiratory heat loss U = energy lost as excreta Using the mussel M. edulis from natural environments, the authors were able to show a reduced scope for growth in animals from polluted habitats. Such an equation may not be entirely applicable to corals, for it appears that less than 1% of assimilated input appears as growth (P. Spencer Davies, personal communication). In addition, it would be extremely difficult to measure the energy intake from carnivorous sources in many corals. However, energy budgets have been constructed for several species, including Pocillopora eydouxi (Milne, Edwards, and Haime) (P. Spencer Davies, personal communication). A study of the overall energy budget of the coral, together with measurements of growth rate, may therefore be more appropriate. Combining this approach in in situ studies with biochemical and cytochemical assays of coral tissues from field and laboratory exposures would permit a reasonable interpretation of the condition of corals in the environment. The disadvantageLo3 these methods are clear-all require sophisticated equipment and techniques which are not always readily available at remote tropical laboratories. Although it is possible that any meaningful laboratory measurement of effects of stress in reef corals will involve a much more subtle approach than has been applied to date, the value of critical methods of evaluation of pollution in the field, such as those described here, should not be underestimated. On the basis of these field methods alone, considerable advances in our understanding of the tolerances of reef corals to effects of stress-both man-made and naturalcould be made during the next decade. Acknowledgments We would like to acknowledge authors who allowed us to see copies of papers in press and also the staff of the library at the Marine Biological Association, Plymouth, especially David Moulder, for their cooperation.
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
55
We should also like to acknowledge the helpful comments of Sir Maurice Yonge, Dr. Peter Spencer Davies, Dr. Tony Stebbing, and Mr. Martin Le Tissier on the manuscript draft, and the useful discussion with Dr. B. Widdows and Dr. Moore of the Institute of Marine Environmental Research, Plymouth.
References Antonius, A. (1983a). Coral reef pathology: A review. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila 1981 2, 3-6. Antonius, A. (1983b). The “band” diseases in coral reefs. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila 1981 2, 7-14. Bak, R. P. M. (1978). Lethal and sublethal effects of dredging on reef corals. Marine Pollution Bulletin 9, 14-16. Bak, R. P. M., and Criens, S. R. (1983). Survival after fragmentation of colonies of Madracis mirabilis, Acropora palmata, and A . cervicornis (Scleractinia) and the subsequent impact of a coral disease. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 2, 221-227. Bak, R. P. M., and Elgershuizen, J. H. B. W. (1976). Patterns of oil-sediment rejection in corals. Marine Biology 37, 105-1 13. Bak, R. P. M., and Engel, M. S. (1979). Distribution, abundance, and survival ofjuvenile hermatypic corals (Scleractinia) and the importance of life history strategies in the parent coral community. Marine Biology 54, 341-352. Bak, R. P. M., and Luckhurst, B. E. (1980). Constancy and change in coral reef habitats along depth gradients at CuraGao. Oceologia (Berlin) 47, 145-155. Bak, R. P. M., Sybesma, J., and van Duyl, F. C. (1981). The ecology of the tropical compound ascidian Tridemnum solidum. 11. Abundance, Growth and Survival. Marine Ecology Progress Series 6 , 43-52. Bak, R. P. M., Termaat, R. M., and Dekker, R. (1982). Complexity of coral interactions: i n f l d c e of time, location of interaction, and epifauna. Marine Biology 69, 215-222. Barnes, D. J. (1983). Profiling coral reef productivity and calcification using pH and oxygen electrodes. Journal of Experimental Marine Ecology 66, 149-161. Barnes, D. J., and Crossland, C. J. (1978). Diurnal productivity and apparent I4C calcification in the staghorn coral Acropora acuminata. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 59A, 133-138. Barnes, D. J., and Crossland, C. J. (1982). Variability in the calcification rate of Acropora acuminata measured with radioisotopes. Coral Reefs 1, 53-57. Barry, M., and Yevich, P. P. (1975). The ecological, chemical and histopathological evaluation of an oilspill site. 111. Histopathological studies. Marine Pollution Bulletin 6 , 171-173. Bayne, B. L., and Widdows, J. (1978). The physiological ecology of two populations of Mytilus edulis L.Oceologia (Berlin) 37, 137-162. Bayne, B. L., Livingstone, D. R., Moore, M. N., and Widdows, J. (1976). A cytochemical and a biochemical index of stress in Mytilus edulis L. Marine Pollution Bulletin 7, 221224. Benayahu, Y., and Loya, Y. (1977). Space partitioning by stony corals and benthic algae on the coral reefs of the northern Gulf of Eilat (Red Sea). Helgolander wissenschafiliche Meeresuntersuchungen 30, 362-282. Birkeland, C., Reimer, A. A., and Young, J. R. (1976). Survey of marine communities in Panama and experiments with oil. Environmental Protection Agency Ecological Research Series.
56
B. E. B R O W N A N D L . S. H O W A R D
Blumer, M., Sanders, H. L., Grassle, F. J., and Hampson, G. R. (1971). A small oil spill. Environment 13, 3-12. Bouchon, C. (1983). Comparison of two quantitative sampling methods used in coral reef studies: The line transect and the quadrat methods. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 2, p. 375. Brown, B. E., and Holley, M. C. (1982). Metal levels associated with tin dredging and smelting and their effect upon intertidal reef flats at KO Phuket, Thailand. Coral Reefs 1, 131-137. Brown, B. E., Hewit, R., and Le Tissier, M. D. (1983). The nature and construction of skeletal species in Pocillopora damicornis (Linnaeus). Coral Reefs 2, 81-89. Buddemeier, R. W., and Kinzie, R. A. (1976). Coral Growth. Oceanography and Marine Biology An Annual Review 14, 183-225. Carpenter, F. W. (1910). Feeding reactions of the rose Coral (Isophyllia).Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 46, 149-162. Cheney, D. P. (1975). Hard tissue tumors in scleractinian corals. I n “Immunologic Phylogeny” (W. H. Hildemann and A. A. Benedict, eds.), pp. 77-87. Plenum, New York. Cohen, Y. (1973). Effects of crude oil on the Red Sea alcyonanan Heteroxenia fuscescens. M. Sc. thesis, Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Coles, S. L. (1975). A comparison of effects of temperature versus temperature fluctuations on reef corals at Kahe Point, Oahu. Pac$c Science 29, 15-18. Coles, S. L., and Jokiel, P. L. (1977). Effects of temperature on photosynthesis and respiration in hermatypic corals. Marine Biology 43, 209-216. Connell, J. H. (1973). Population ecology of reef building corals. In “Biology and Geology of Coral Reefs” (0. A. Jones and R. Endean, eds.), pp. 205-245. Academic Press, New York. Cross$qd: C.,J., Barnes, D. J., and Borowitzka, M. A. (1980a). Diurnal lipid and mucus production in the staghorn coral Acropora acuminata. Marine Biology 60, 81-90. Crossland, C. J., Barnes, D. J., Cox, T., and Devereux, M. (1980b). Compartmentation and turnover of organic carbon in the staghorn coral Acropora formosa. Marine Biology 59, 181- 187. Dahl, A. L., and Lamberts, A. E. (1978). Environmental impact on a Samoan coral reef A resurvey of Mayor’s 1917 transect. Paci$c Science 31, 309-318. Dallmeyer, D. G., Porter, J. W., and Smith, G. J. (1982). Effects of particulate peat on the behaviour and physiology of the Jamaican reef-building coral Montastrea unnularis. Marine Biology 68, 229-233. Davis, G. E. (1982). A century of natural change in coral distribution at the Dry Tortugas: A comparison of reef maps from 1881 and 1976. Bulletin of Marine Science 32, 608623. Dodge, R. E. (1982). Effects of drilling mud on the reef building coral Montastrea annulark. Marine Biology 71, 141-147. Dodge, R. E. (1983). Growth characteristics of reef-building corals within and external to a naval ordnance test range: Vieques, Puerto Rico. Proceedings of the 4th Internalional Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 2, 241-248. Dodge, R. E., and Szmant-Froelich, A. (1984). Effects of drilling fluids on reef corals: A review. In “Wastes in the Ocean” (I. W. Duedall, D. R. Kester, P. K. Park, and B. H. Ketchum, eds.), Vol. 4. Wiley (Interscience), New York. Dodge, R. E., and Vaisnys, J. R. (1977). Coral populations and growth patterns: Responses to sedimentation and turbidity associated with dredging. Journal of Marine Research 35, 7 15-730. Dodge, R. E., Logan, A , , and Antonius, A. (1982). Quantitative reef assessment studies in
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
57
Bermuda: A comparison of methods and preliminary results. Bulletin of Marine Science 32, 745-760.
Dollar, S. J., and Grigg, R. W. (1981). Impact of a kaolin clay spill on a coral reef in Hawaii. Marine Biology 65, 269-276. Done, T. J. (1977). A comparison of units of cover in ecological classifications of coral communities. Proceedings of the 3rd International Corcil R e e f Sytnposiirm. Mirimi 1, 10-14. Done, T. J . (1981). Four years of change on a coral transect preliminary findings using stereophotography. Abstracts of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 p. 19. Ducklow, H. W., and Mitchell, R. (1979). Composition of mucus released by coral reef coelenterates. Limnology and Oceanography 24, 706-7 14. Duerden, J . E. (1902). West Indian Madreporarian polyps. Memoirs of the National Academy of Sciences, Washington, D . C . , 8, 399-597. Dustan, P. (1977). Vitality of reef coral populations off Key Largo, Florida: Recruitment and mortality. Environmental Geology (New York) 2, 51-58. Dustan, P. (1979). Distribution of zooxanthellae and photosynthetic chloroplast pigments of the reef-building coral Montastrea annularis (Ellis and Solander), in relation to depth on a West I dian coral reef. Bulletin of Marine Science 29, 79-95. Dust&. (1982). Depth-dependent photoadaptation by zooxanthellae of the reef coral Montastrea annularis. Marine Biology 68, 253-264. Edmondson, C. H. (1928). The ecology of an Hawaiian coral reef. Bulletin of the Bernice P . Bishop Museum 45, 1-64. Endean, R. (1971). The recovery of coral reefs devastated by catastrophic events, with particular reference to current Acanthaster plancii plagues in the tropical Indo-West Pacific region. Journal of the Marine Biological Association of India 13, 1. Endean, R. (1973). Destruction and recovery of coral reef communities. In “Biology and Geology of Coral Reefs” (0. A. Jones and R. Endean, eds.), pp. 215-254. Academic Press, New York. Fishelson, L. (1973). Ecology of coral reefs in the Gulf of Aqaba (Red Sea) influenced by pollution. Oceologia (Berlin) 12, 55-67. Fishelson, L. (1977). Stability and instability of marine ecosystems, illustrated by examples from the Red Sea. Helgolander wissenschaftliche Meeresuntersuchungen 30, 18-29. Fisk, D. A. (1983). Sediment shedding and particulate feeding of two free-living scleractinian corals at Wistari Reef, Great Barrier Reef. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 2, 21-26. Franzicket, L. (1970). The atrophy of hermatypic reef corals maintained in darkness and their subsequent regeneration in light. Internationale Revue der gesamten Hydrobiologie und Hydrographie 55, 1-12. Gladfelter, E. H. (1982a). Skeletal development in Acropora cervicornis. I . Patterns of calcium carbonate accretion in the axial corallite. Coral Reefs 1, 45-51. Gladfelter, W. B. (1982b). White band disease in Acropora palrnata: Implications for the structure and growth of shallow reefs. Bulletin of Marine Science 32, 639-643. Gladfelter, E. H., Monahan, R. K . , and Gladfelter, W. B. (1978). Growth rates of five reefbuilding corals in the northeastern Caribbean. Bulletin of Marine Science 28, 728-734. Glynn, P. W. (1976). Some physical and biological determinants of coral community structure in the eastern Pacific. Ecological Monographs 46, 43 1-456. Goldman, W. M., and Makemson, J. C. (1983). Description of a tumorous condition in a gorgonian coral associated with a filamentous green alga. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 2, 685-697.
58
B. E. B R O W N A N D L. S. H O W A R D
Goreau, T. F. (1964). Mass expulsion of zooxanthellae from Jamaican reef communities after Hurricane Flora. Science 145, 383-386. Goreau, T. F., Goreau, N. I., and Yonge, C. M. (1971). Reef corals: Autotrophs or heterotrophs? Biological Bulletin 141, 247-260. Goreau, T. F., Goreau, N. I., and Goreau, T. J. (1979). Corals and coral reefs. Scientific American 241, 124-136. Grigg, R. W. (1983). Community structure, succession, and development of coral reefs in Hawaii. Marine Ecology Progress Series 11, 1-14. Grigg, R. W., and Maragos, J. E. (1974). Recolonization of hermatypic corals on submerged lava flows in Hawaii. Ecology 55, 387-395. Grime, J. P. (1979). “Plant Strategies and Vegetation Processes.” Wiley, New York. Hedgepeth, J. W. (1973). The impact of impact studies. Helgolander wissenschafliche Meeresuntersuchungen 24, 436-445. Highsmith, R. C. (1979). Coral growth rates and environmental control of density banding. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 37, 105-125. Highsmith, R.C. (1982). Reproduction by fragmentation in corals. Marine Ecology Progress Series 7, 207-226. Highsmith, R. C., Riggs, A. C., and D’Antonio, C. M. (1980). Survival of hurricane-generated coral fragments and a disturbance model of reef calcification/growthrates. Oceologia (Berlin) 46, 322-329. Horridge, G. A. (1957). The coordination of the protective retraction of coral polyps. Philisophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B 240, 495-528. Howard, L. S., and Brown, B. E. (1984). Heavy metals and reef corals-a review. Oceunography and Marine Biology, An Annual Review 22, 195-2 10. Hubbard, J. A. E. B. (1974). Scleractinian coral behavior in calibrated current experiment: An index to their distribution patterns. Proceedings of the 2nd International Coral Reef Symposium, Brisbane 2, 107-126. Hubbard, J. A. E. B., and Pocock, Y. P. (1972). Sediment rejection by recent scleractinian corals: A key to palaeoenvironmental reconstruction. Geologische Rundschau 61, 598626. Hudson, J. H. (1977). Long-term bioerosion rates on a Florida reef A new method. Proceedings of the 3rd International Coral Reef Symposium, Miami 2, 491-497. Hudson, J. H. (1981). Growth rates in Montastrea anularis: A record of environmental change in the Key Largo Coral Reef Marine Sanctuary, Florida. Bulletin of Marine Science 31, 444-459. Hudson, J. H. (1983). Response of Montastrea annularis to environmental change in the Florida Keys. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila 2, 233-240. Hudson, J. H., and Robbin, D. M. (1980). Effects of drilling mud on the growth rate of the reef building coral Montastrea annularis. In Proceedings of the Symposium on Research on Environmental Fate and Effects of Drilling Fluids and Cuttings, Lake Buena Vista, Florida 2, 1101-1122. Hudson, J. H., Shinn, E. A., Halley, R. B., and Lidz, B. (1976). Sclerochronology-a tool for interpreting past environments. Geology 4, 361-364. Hudson, J. H., Shinn, E. A., and Robbin, D. M. (1982). Effects of offshore drilling on Philippine reef corals. Bulletin of Marine Science 32, 890-908. Hughes, T. P., and Jackson, J. B. C. (1980). Do corals lie about their age? Some demographic consequences of partial mortality, fission, and fusion. Science 209, 713-715. Jaap, W. C. (1979). Observations on zooxanthellae expulsion at Middle Sambo Reef, Florida Keys, Bulletin of Marine Science 29, 414-422.
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON REEF CORALS
59
Jaap, W. C., and Wheaton, J. (1975). Observations on Florida Reef corals treated with fish collecting chemicals. Florida Marine Research Publications 10, 1-17. Jeffries, H. P. (1972). A stress syndrome in the hard clam, Mercenaria mercenaria. Journal of Invertebrate Pathology 20, 242-287. Johannes, R. E. (1972). Coral reefs and pollution. In “Marine Pollution and Sea Life” (M. Ruivo, ed.), pp. 364-371. Fishing News, London. Johannes, R. E. (1975). Pollution and degradation of coral reef communities. In “Tropical Marine Pollution” (E. J. Ferguson Wood and R. E. Johannes, eds.), pp. 13-51. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Jokiel, P. L., and Coles, S. L. (1974). Effects of heated effluent on hermatypic corals at Kahe Point, Oahu. PaciJc Science 28, 1-18. Jokiel, P. L., and Coles, S. L. (1977). Effects of temperature on the mortality and growth of Hawaiian reef corals. Marine Biology 43, 201-208. Jones, M. B. (1975). Synergistic effects of salinity, temperature and heavy metals on mortality and osmoregulation in marine and estuarine isopods (Crustacea). Marine Biology 30, 13-20. Jones, R. S., and Randall, R. H. (1973). A study of biological impact caused by natural and man-induced changes on a tropical reef. University of Guam Marine Laboratory Technical Report No. 7. Kaufman, L. S. (1980). “Damselfish Disturbance on Caribbean Coral Reefs.” Ph.D. thesis, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Md. Kinsey, D. W. (1979). “Carbon Turnover and Accumulation by Coral Reefs.“ Ph.D. thesis, University of Hawaii. Kojis, B. L., and Quinn, N. J. (1981). Aspects of sexual reproduction and larval development in the shallow-water hermatypic coral Goniastrea australiensis (Edwards and Haime 1857). Bulletin of Marine Science 31, 558-573. Kojis, B. L., and Quinn, N. J. (1982). Reproductive ecology of two faviid corals (Coelenterata: Scleractinia) Marine Ecology Progress Series 8, 251-255. Lang, J. C. (1970). “Inter-specific Aggression within the Scleractinian Reef Corals.” Ph.D. thesis, Yale University. Lang, J. C. (1971). Interspecific aggression by scleractinian corals. 1 . The rediscovery of Scolymia cubensis (Milne, Edwards, and Haime) Bulletin of Marine Science 21, 952959. Lang, J. C. (1973). Interspecific aggression by scleractinian corals. 11. Why the race is not only to the swift. Bulletin of Marine Science 23, 260-279. Lasker, H. R. (1976). Intraspecific variability of zoo-plankton feeding in the hermatypic coral Montastrea cavernosa. In “Coelenterate Ecology and Behavior” (G. 0. Mackie, ed.), pp. 101-109. Plenum, New York. Lasker, H. R. (1977). Patterns of zooxanthellae distribution and polyp expansion in the reef coral Montastrea cavernosa. Proceedings of the 3rd International Coral Reef Symposium, Miami 1, 607-613. Lasker, H. R. (1979). Light-dependent activity patterns among reef corals: Montastrea cavernosa. Biological Bulletin 156, 196-21 1 . Lasker, H. R. (1980). Sediment rejection by reef corals: The roles of behaviour and morphology in Montastrea cuuernosa (Linnaeus). Journal of Experimentul Marine Biology and Ecology 47,7747’. Lasker, H. R. (1981). Phenotypic variation in the coral Montastrea cavernosa and its effects on colony energetics. Biological Bulletin 160, 292-302. Lehman, J. T., and Porter, J. W. (1973). Chemical activation of feeding in the Caribbean reef building coral Montastrea cavernosa. Biological Bulletin 145, 140-149.
60
B . E. B R O W N A N D L. S. H O W A R D
Lewis, J. B. (1971). Effect of crude oil and an oil-dispersant on reef corals. Marine Pollution Bulletin 2, 59-62. Lewis, J. B. (1976). Long-term ecological surveillance: Practical realities in the rocky littoral. Oceanography and Marine Biology, An Annual Review 14, 371-390. Lewis, J. B. (1977). Suspension feeding in Atlantic reef corals and the importance of suspended particulate matter as a food source. Proceedings of the 3rd International Coral Reef Symposium, Miami 1, 406-408. Lewis, J. B . , and Price, W. S. (1975). Feeding mechanisms and feeding strategies of Atlantic reef c&Journd of ZociloRy-ProceedinRs of the Zoologic.trl Societv of’ London 176, 527-544. Loya, Y. (1972). Community structure and species diversity of a hermatypic coral at Eilat, Red Sea. Marine Biology 13, 100-123. Loya, Y . (1975). Possible effects of water pollution on the community structure of Red Sea corals. Marine Biology 29, 177-185. Loya, Y. (1976a). Recolonization of Red Sea corals affected by natural catastrophes and man-made perturbations. Ecology 57, 278-289. Loya, Y. (1976b). The Red Sea coral Stylophora pistillata is an r strategist. Nature (London) 259, 478-480. Loya, Y. (1978). Plotless and transect methods. In “Coral Reefs: Research methods” (D. R. Stoddart and R. E. Johannes, eds.), pp. 197-217. UNESCO, Paris. Loya, Y . , and Rinkevich, B. (1980). Effects of oil pollution on coral reef communities. Marine Ecology Progress Series 3, 167-180. Mariscal, R. N., and Lenhoff, H. M. (1968). The chemical control of feeding behaviour in Cyphastrea ocellina and some other Hawaiian corals. Journal of Experimental Biology 49, 689-699. Marshall, S . M., and Om,A. P. (1931). Sedimentation on Low Isles Reef and its relation to coral growth. Great Barrier Reef Expedition 1928-1929. Scientijic Reports of the British Museum (Natural History) I, 94- 133. Marshall, S. M., and Stephenson, T. A. (1933). The breeding of reef animals, Part 1. The Corals. Scientific Reports o f the Great Barrier Reef Expedition 3, 219-245. Matthai, G. (1918). On reactions to stimuli in corals. Proceedings o f t h e Cambridge Philosophical Society 19, 164-166. Mayor, A. G. (1914). The effects of temperatures upon tropical marine animals. Carnegie Institute of Washington Publications 183. Mayor, A. G. (1918). Toxic effects due to high temperature. Carnegie Institute of Washington Publications 252, 175-178. Mayor, A. G . (1924). Structure and ecology of Samoan reefs. Carnegie Institute of Washington Publications 340, 1-25. Mitchell, R., and Chet, I. (1975). Bacterial attack of corals in polluted seawater. Microbial Ecology 2, 227-233. Moore, H. B. (1972). Aspects of stress in the tropical marine environment. Advances in Marine Biology 10, 217-269. Moore, M. N. (1976). Cytochemical demonstration of latency of lysosomal hydrolases in digestive cells of the common mussel, Mytilus edulis, and changes induced by thermal stress. Cell and Tissue Research 175, 279-287. Moore, M. N., and Stebbing, A. R. D. (1976). The quantitative cytochemical effects of three metal ions o n a lysomal hydrolase of a hydroid. Journal of the Marine Bioiogica/ Association of the United Kingdom 56, 995-1005. Morse, D. E., Morse, A. N. C., and Duncan, H. (1977). Algal “tumors” in the Caribbean sea-fan, Gorgonia ventalina. Proceedings of the 3rd International Coral Reef Symposium, Miami 1, 623-629.
E F F E C T S OF S T R E S S O N R € E F C O R A L S
61
Morse, D. E., Morse, A., Duncan, H., and Trench, R. K. (1981). Algal tumors in the Caribbean octocorallian Gorgonia uentalinu. 11. Biochemical characterization of the algae and first epidemiological observations. Bulletin of Marine Science 31, 399-409. Muscatine, L. (197 1). Endosymbiosis of algae and coelenterates. In “Experimental Coelenterate Biology” (H. M. Lenhoff, L. Muscatine, and L. V. Davis, eds.), pp. 255-268. Univ. of Hawaii Press, Honolulu. Muscatine, L. (1973). Nutrition of corals. In “Biology and Geology of Coral Reefs” (0.A. Jones and R. Endean, eds.), pp. 77-115. Academic Press, New York. Neff, J. M., and Anderson, J. W. (1981). “Response of Marine Animals to Petroleum and Specific Petroleum Hydrocarbons,” pp. 177-121. Applied Science Publ., London. Neudecker, S. (1983). Growth and survival of scleractinian corals exposed to thermal effluents at Guam. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 1, 173-180. Nishihira, M. (1981). Interactions of alcyonaria with hermatypic corals on an Okinawa reef flat. Abstracts of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 pp. 46-47. Ormond, R. F. G., and Caldwell, S. (1982). The effect of oil pollution on the reproduction and feeding behaviour of the sea anemone Actiniti ecpintr. Murine Pollrrtion Bulletin 13, 118-122. Pearson, R. G. (1981). Recovery and recolonization of coral reefs. Marine Ecology Progress Series 4, 105-122. Peters, E . C., Meyers, P. A., Yevich, P. P., and Blake, N. J. (1981). Bioaccumulation and histopathological effects of oil on a stony coral. Marine Polliition Bulletin 12, 333-339. Pickering, A. D. (1981). In “Stress in Fish” (A. D. Pickering, ed.), pp. 1-2. Academic Press, New York. Porter, J. W. (1976). Autotrophy, heterotrophy, and resource partitioning in Caribbean reefbuilding corals. American Naturalist 110, 731-742. Porter, J. W . . Woodley, J. D., Smith. G . J., Niegel, J. E., Battey, J. F., and Dallmeyer, D. G . (1981). Population trends among Jamaican reef corals. Nuture (London) 2Y4, 249250. Porter, J. W., Battey, J. F., and Smith, G . J. (1982). Perturbation and change in coral reef communities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 79, 1678-1681. Reeve, M. R., Grice, G . T., Gibson, V. R., Walker, M. A . , Darcy, K., and Ikeda, T. (1976). A controlled environmental experiment (CEPEX) and its usefulness in the study of larger marine zooplankton under toxic stress. Society f o r Experimental Biology Seminar Series 2, 145-164. Reimer, A. A. (1975a). Effects of crude oil on corals. Marine Pollution Bullefin 6 , 39-43. Reimer, A. A. (1975b). Effects of crude oil on the feeding behaviour of the zoanthid Ptrlythou uuriahilis. Enuironrnenrul Physiology und Bioc~Iirini.st~~ 5 , 258-266. Rinkevich, B., and Loya, Y. (1977). Harmful effects of chronic oil pollution on a Red Sea coral population. Proceedings of the 3rd International Coral Reef Symposium, Miami 2, 585-591. Rinkevich, B., and Loya, Y. (1979a). Laboratory experiments on the effects of crude oil on the Red Sea coral Stylophora pistillata. Marine Pollution Bulletin 10, 328-330. Rinkevich, B., and Loya, Y . (1979b). The reproduction of the Red Sea coral Stylophora pistillata. 1. Gonads and planulae. Marine Ecology Progress Series 1, 133-144. Rinkevich, B., and Loya, Y. (1979~).The reproduction of the Red Sea coral Stylophora pistillata. 11. Synchronization in breeding and seasonality of planulae shedding. Marine Ecology Progress Series 1, 145-152. Rogers, C. S. (1979). The effect of shading on coral reef structure and function. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 41, 269-288.
62
B. E. BROWN A N D L. S. HOWARD
Rogers, C. S. (1984). Sublethal and lethal effects of sediments applied to common Caribbean reef corals in the field. Marine Pollution Bulletin, in press. Rogers, C. S., Suchanek, R. H., and Pecora, F. (1982). Effects of hurricanes David and Frederick (1979) on shallow Acropora palmata reef communities: St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands. Bulletin of Marine Science 32, 532-548. Rogers, C. S., Gilnack and Fitz, H. C. (1983). Monitoring of coral reefs with linear transects: A study of stor damage. Juurnul of Experimentul Marine Biology and Ecology 66, 285-300. Rosen, B. R. (1982). The tropical high diversity enigma-the corals eye view. In “The Evolving Biosphere” (P. L. Forey, ed.), pp. 103-129. Cambridge University Press, London and New York. Sammarco, P. W. (1982). Polyp bail-out-an escape response to environmental stress and a new means of reproduction in corals. Marine Ecology Progress Series 10, 57-65. Sammarco, P. W . , Coll, J. C., La Barre, S., and Willis, B. (1983). Competitive strategies of soft corals (Coelenterata: Octocorallia): Allelopathic effects on selected scleractinian corals. Coral Reefs 1, 173-178. Schuhmacher, H. (1979). Experiments on adaptations to sedimentation and substrate in fungiid corals (Scleractinia, Fungiidae) Internationale Revue der gesamten Hydrobiologie und Hydrographie 64, 207-243. Sebens, K. P., and De Riemer, K. (1977). Die1 cycles of expansion and contraction in coral reef anthozoans. Marine Biology 43, 247-256. Sheppard, C. R. C. (1979). Interspecific aggression between reef corals with reference to their distribution. Marine Ecology Progress Series 1, 237-247. Sheppard, C. R. C. (1980). Coral fauna of Diego Garcia lagoon following harbor construction. Marine Pollution Bulletin 11, 227-230. Shinn, E. (1976). Coral reef recovery in Florida and the Persian Gulf. Environmental Geology (New York) 1, 241-254. Smith, S. S. (1977). Kaneohe Bay: A preliminary report on the responses of a coral reef/ estuary ecosystem to relaxation of sewage stress. Proceedings of the 3rd International Coral Reef Symposium, Miami 2, 578-583. Soule, J. D. (1965) Abnormal corallites. Science 150, 78. Squires, D. F. (1965). Neoplasia in a coral? Science 148, 503-505. Stebbing, A. R. D. (1981). Stress, health, and homeostasis. Marine Pollution Bulletin 12, 326-329. Stimson, J. S . (1978). Mode and timing of reproduction in some common hermatypic corals of Hawaii and Enewetak. Marine Biology 48, 173-184. Stoddart, D. R. (1972). Field methods in the study of coral reefs. Piweedings of the First International Symposium on Corals and Coral Reefs organized by the Marine Biological Association of India, Mandapam Camp, 12-16 Jan. 1969 pp. 71-80. Stoddart, D. R. (1974). Posthurricane changes on the British Honduras reefs: Resurvey of 1972. Proceedings of the 2nd International Coral Reef Symposium, Brisbane 2,473-483. Sweeney, B. M. (1976). Circadian rhythms in corals, particularly fungiidae. Biological Bulletin 151, 236-246. Sya’rani, L. (1983). “Ecology of Shallow Water Coral Communities, Java Sea, Indonesia.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Newcastle upon Tyne. Szmant-Froelich, A., and Pilson, M. E. Q . (1980). The effects of feeding frequency and symbiosis with zooxanthellae on the biochemical composition of Asrrangia danae (Milne, Edwards, and Haime, 1849). Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 48, 85-97. Szmant-Froelich, A., Johnson, V., Hoehn, T., Battey, J., Smith, J., Fleischmann, E.,
T
EFFECTS O F STRESS O N REEF CORALS
63
Porter, J., and Dallmeyer, D. (1983). The physiological effects of oil drilling muds on the Caribbean coral Montastrea annularis. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 I , 163-168. Thompson, J. H., and Bright, T. J. (1980). Effects of an offshore drilling fluid on selected corals. Proceedings of the Symposium: Research on Environmental Fate and Effects of Drilling Fluids and Cuttings, Lake Buena Vista, Florida 2, 1044-1078. Thompson, J. H., Shinn, E. A., and Bright, T. J. (1980). Effects of drilling mud on seven species of reef-building corals as measured in the field and laboratory. Elsevier Oceanography Series 2lA, 433-453. Tiffon, Y.(I97 I). Detection cytochemique d’hydrolases lysosomiales dans les cloisons septales sterlies de Cerianthus lloydi (Coelentere Anthozoaire). Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances, Acadamie des Sciences, Paris 273, 1953-1956. Tilmant, J. T., and Schmahl, G. P. (1983). A comparative analysis of coral damage on recreationally used reefs within Biscayne National Park, Florida, U.S.A. Proceedings of the 4th International Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981 I , 187-192. Tunnicliffe, V. (1983). Caribbean staghorn coral populations: Pre-Hurricane Allen conditions in Discovery Bay, Jamaica. Bulletin of Marine Science 33, 132-151. Tursch, B., and Tursch, A. (1982). The soft coral community on a sheltered reef quadrat at Laing Island (Papua, New Guinea). Marine Biology 68, 321-332. Van Moorsel, G. W. N. M. (1983). Different reproductive strategies in two closely related stony corals (Agaricia, Scleractinia). Proceedings of the 4th Internationul Coral Reef Symposium, Manila, 1981, 2, p. 193. Vaughan, T. W. (1912). Studies of the geology and of the Madreporaria of the Bahamas and of Southern Florida. Carnegie Institution of Washington Yearbook 11, 153-162. Vaughan, T. W. (1915). Growth rate of the Floridian and Bahaman Shoal-water corals. Carnegie Institution of Washington Yearbook 14, 221-23 I . Vaughan, T. W. (1916). The results of investigations of the ecology of Floridian and Bahaman Shoal-water corals. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2, 95-100. Vernberg, F. J. (1962). Latitudinal effects on physiological properties of animal populations. Annual Review of Physiology 24, 517-546. Vernberg, F. J. (1981). Comparative studies of tropical and temperate zone coastal systems. Bulletin of Marine Science 31, 801-808. Vernberg, W. B., and Vernberg, F. J. (1972). “Environmental Physiology of Marine Animals.” Springer-Verlag, Berlin and New York. Walker, D. I., and Ormond, R. F. G. (1982). Coral death from sewage and phosphate pollution at Aqaba, Red Sea. Marine Pollution Bulletin 13, 21-25. Yonge, C. M. (1930). Studies on the physiology of corals. 1 . Feeding mechanisms and food. Scientzjic Reports of the Great Barrier Reef Expedition 1928-1929 1, 13-57. Yonge, C. M., and Nicholls, A. C. (1931). Studies on the physiology of corals. IV. The structure, distribution, and physiology of the zooxanthellae. ScientiJic Reports of the Great Barrier Reef Expedition 1928-1929 1, 135-176.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Nutrition of Sea Anemones
.
M Van-Praet Laboratoire de Biologie des Inverte'bre's Marins et Malacologie Muse'um National d'Histoire Naturelle. Paris. France
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Chemoreception and Feeding Behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Feeding behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
B . Nature of activators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . The conducting systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . The control of feeding behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Absorption of Dissolved Organic Matter . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Localization of uptake . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Uptake systems for glucose and amino acids . . . . . . . . C . Ecological importance of dissolved compounds for the nutrition of sea anemones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Gathering and Digestion of Particulate Organic Matter . . . . . . . A . Suspension-feeding structures . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Endodermal currents and the role of the trilobed portion of mesenteric filaments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Phagocytic cells, cytological and enzymological aspects of intracellular digestion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Importance of particulate organic matter . . . . . . . . . . V . Predation and Digestion of Prey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Role of tentacles, acontia, and cnidae . . . . . . . . . . B . Extracellular digestion of prey, cytological and enzymological aspects . C . Excretion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Symbiosis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Localization of algal symbionts . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Regulation of the concentration of algae in the tissues . . . . . . C. Translocation of metabolites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Sea Anemones as Prey and Remarks on the Diet of Sea .4nemones . . . . A . Predators of sea anemones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Diet of sea anemones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .
66 66 66 67 69 69 70 70 71 71 72 12 74
76 79 81 81 82 89 89 89 90 91 92 92 93 94
65 ADVANCES IN MARINE BIOL.OGY, VOL . 22
Copyright 0 1985. by Academic Press Inc . (London) Ltd . All rights of reproduction in any form reserved . ISBN 0- 12-026122-7
66
M. VAN-PRAET
1.
Introduction
In the nineteenth century, the progress of histological techniques permitted zoologists such as the Hertwig brothers (1879), Metschnikoff (1880), Brandt (1881), and Faurot (1895) to extend knowledge of the biology of sea anemones. But paradoxically, the discovery of phagocytosis by Metschnikoff (1880, 1882) reduced the importance of other studies on digestion. Accurate information about digestion of prey was not established until the studies of Krijgsman and Talbot (1953) and Nicol (1959). More generally, the absence of cytological studies on sea anemones during the first 60 years of the twentieth century led biologists to interpret their observations by reference to those of the nineteenth century or to those known in the most studied cnidarian, Hydra. Knowledge about nutrition of sea anemones is, therefore, restricted to one particular aspect, namely, the chemoreception of prey and its related behaviour (Lenhoff et al., 1976), and the symbiosis with zooxanthellae (Taylor, 1973; Muscatine, 1974). Our present knowledge of digestion and absorption of particulate organic matter and dissolved organic compounds has recently benefited from the progress of electron microscopy, enzymology, and the use of labelled radioactive compounds. These advances and new trends will be discussed in order to determine the importance of prey, particulate organic matter, dissolved compounds, and symbionts in the diet of sea anemones.
II. Chemoreception and Feeding Behaviour A.
Feeding Behaviour
Pollock (1883) was the first to describe how, in sea anemones, the presence of nearby food evoked the induction of a particular behaviour. All common species studied by Pollock open their discs and wave their tentacles after the introduction of pieces of animal prey. Parker (1905) observed, during this behaviour in Metridium senile (L.), that ciliary currents reversed in the throat and on the lips. In the normal beat, the actual stroke and the propagation waves are directed outward. Shortly after the introduction of pieces of crab, both reverse (Holley and Shelton, 1984). Yonge (1968, 1973) observed identical structure and behaviour in corals. Recent studies on the nature of activators and the transmission of stimuli permit the differentiation of two distinct phases: the prefeeding response, which correspond to Pollock’s observations, and the feeding response,
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
67
which ensures the ingestion of prey. The prefeeding response, with the expansion of the oral disc, the movements of its tentacles, and the extension and swaying of the column, increases the chance of catching nearby food. The feeding response, after contact of prey or particulate animal matter with the tentacles or the oral disc, includes the discharge of nematocysts and ingestive movements. These movements include ciliary currents, movements of the tentacles, the oral disc and the throat, to varying extents depending on the species. These two responses are mediated by two distinct systems: an ectoderma1 conducting system (SS1) for the prefeeding response and an endoderma1 slow conducting system (SS2) for the feeding response (McFarlane, 1970, 1975). Both these conducting systems seem to be interconnected with the nerve nets of the deep part of the tissue layers, but may be nonnervous. McFarlane and Jackson (1976) suggest that SSI corresponds to a cell-to-cell conduction in the supporting layer of the ectoderm, including the secretory mucous cells, and that the SS2 is a low-resistance pathway between endodermal cells linked to ectodermal chemosensory cells. The induction of these two distinct responses requires different activators at least in certain species of sea anemones (Lindstedt, 1971b; Williams, 1972; Nagai and Nagai, 1973). The induction of the feeding response is normally elicited by a combination of chemical and mechanical stimuli (Pantin and Pantin, 1943), but starvation may lower the threshold of the response such that nematocyst discharges and ingestive movements are elicited by mechanical stimulations alone. Conversely, feeding with Artemia has been correlated with the inhibition of nematocyst discharges (Sandberg et al., 1971) and of ingestive movements of the oral disc (Logan, 1979).
B. Nature of Activators Carbohydrates and lipids do not induce feeding behaviour, and Pantin and Pantin (1943) demonstrated that the active substances of natural food are closely associated with proteins. They found that dissolved polypeptides and amino acids induce prefeeding behaviour. In Hydrozoa the only known activator molecules of the prefeeding and feeding responses are a tripeptide [reduced glutathione (GSH)] and an amino acid (proline). In sea anemones, GSH, a few amino acids, and vitamins induce or facilitate this behaviour (Table I). Lindstedt et al. (1968) demonstrated that lo-’ mol/l of valine induces the extension of the oral disc in Boloceroides and allows the ingestion by
68
M . VAN-PRAET
TABLEI. CHEMICAL ACTIVATORS OF FEEDING BEHAVIOUR I N SEAANEMONES Anemonia sulcata (Pennant) Actinia equina (L.) Boloceroides sp. Haliplanella luciae (Verrill) Anthopleura elegantissima (Brandt) Diadumene luciae (Haliplanella luciae)
Anthopleura midorii (Parulekar)
Culliacfispolypus (Forskll)
A few amino acids and glutathione (Pantin and Pantin, 1943) Glutamate (Steiner, 1957) Valine (Lindstedt et al., 1968) Leucine (Lindstedt, 1971a) Asparagine (prefeeding response), GSH (feeding response) (Lindstedt, 1971b) Proline, glutamic acid (prefeeding response); GSH, six amino acids, and vitamin B (feeding response) (Williams, 1972) Alanine, histidine, glycine (prefeeding response); proline (?), cysteine, and GSH (feeding response) (Nagai and Nagai, 1973) GSH, proline, and nine amino acids slightly (Reimer, 1973)
these sea anemones of inorganic particles which are usually refused. Lindstedt (1971b) demonstrated that in Anthopleura elegantissima (Brandt), asparagine induces prefeeding behaviour and that GSH controls feeding behaviour. In 81% of his experiments, Lindstedt obtained both phases of behaviour by placing a paper soaked with asparagine on the tentacles of sea anemones in aquaria containing mol/l of GSH. The comparative study of chemical activators in cnidarians and the results of experiments with structural analogues of GSH led Lenhoff et al. (1976) to propose a process of evolution of chemoreceptors in Cnidaria. According to these authors, primitive receptors could respond to many amino acids and to GSH as it is known in Chrysaora. They could then have evolved to become specific receptors of one amino acid and GSH, and then into two distinct receptors, one to GSH and another to proline. The chemosensitive sites could evolve from those associated with the induction of pinocytosis. This last hypothesis of Lenhoff et al. (1976) is based on the observations of Slautterback (1969), who found that certain amino acids stimulate the formation of microvilli and apical vesicles of pinocytosis in the digestive cells of Hydra. However, these cells can be considered as effectors, like the muscular cells of the tentacles and the oral discs, and not as the chemoreceptive cells themselves. There is a lack of cytological description of these chemoreceptors and the conducting systems of stimuli; electrophysiological studies permit us to locate them, but not precisely.
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
69
C . The Conducting Systems
The chemoreceptors of the prefeeding behaviour are located in the ectoderm (McFarlane, 1970). By placing chemical microdoses of activators (with tubular electrodes of l-mm tip diameter) Lawn (1976) demonstrated that these prefeeding chemoreceptors are dispersed throughout the column ectoderm but are particularly abundant at its base. According to this author, the ectoderm of the pedal disc, the oral disc, the tentacles, and the throat is devoid of these chemoreceptors, even if these tissues conduct SSl pulses, but they may contain mechanoreceptors. On the other hand, the chemoreceptors for feeding behaviour are situated in the ectoderm of the tentacles and the oral disc. Both these slow conduction systems act by inhibition of different muscles. The SS1 causes the opening of the oral disc by relaxation of its radial muscles. The SS2 causes inhibition of inherent contractions of circular and parietal muscles of the column endoderm. Its continuous stimulation evokes mouth opening and pharynx protrusion (McFarlane, 1975; Shelton and McFarlane, 1976). McFarlane and Shelton (1975) have suggested that the nematocyst discharge threshold may also be influenced by the SS 1. McFarlane and Jackson (1976) consider the possibility of four interacting systems in sea anemones; two are nerve-net, but SSl and SS2 could be nonnervous and may involve cell-to-cell conduction. The septate junctions which link all epithelial cells in all sea anemones studied (Van-Praet, 1982b) or gap junctions are known for their properties of high permeability and could be implicated in the process of slow conduction of pulses (Green, 1984).
D. The Control of Feeding Behaviour The detection of nearby prey by sea anemones is due to the emission by this prey of small dissolved molecules: amino acids, tripeptides (GSH), and probably vitamins (Table I). Their ectodermal chemoreception induces a stereotyped behaviour mediated by slow ectodermal conducting systems: opening of the oral disc and movements of the tentacles and the column, which increase the food capture range of the tentacles. The contact of solid food with the tentacles induces nematocyst discharges. Ingestion is controlled by chemical and mechanical stimuli originating from immobilized prey. These phenomena, due to the chemoreception of food, also induce behaviour propitious for the gathering of particles (opening of the oral disc, reversal of ciliary currents of the throat) and the absorption of the dissolved organic matter is particularly effective in the ectoderm of the tentacles.
70
M. VAN-PRAET
111.
Absorption of Dissolved Organic Matter A. Localization of Uptake
The absorption by sea anemones of amino acids dissolved in sea water is principally carried out at the level of the ectoderm of the tentacles and the column (Chia, 1972; Schlichter, 1975; Fig. 1). The opening of the oral disc and the enlargement of the ectodermal body surface by the exposure of the numerous tentacles are anatomical and behavioural factors which increase the capacity for absorption. The endoderm is capable of effectively absorbing glucose (Chia, 1972) and, contrary to Schlichter’s opinion, amino acids, but this occurs in particular zones, the mesenteric fila-
FIG.1. Autoradiography of a section of Actinia equina which was incubated 2 h in I4Clabelled amino acids. Most developed grains are over the ectoderm (EC), which is responsible for absorption of molecules dissolved in the sea water. Abbreviations: E, filaments; EN, endoderm; C, coelenteron; EC, ectoderm. FIG. 2. Autoradiography of a section of a dissected mesenterial filament which was incubated 2 h in 14C-labelledamino acids such as in Fig. 1. Developed grains are concentrated over the filaments (ELThe absorption of dissolved molecules by the filaments may be important during extracellular digestion of prey. Abbreviations: P, zone of phagocytosis; E, filaments.
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
71
ments (Van-Praet, 1978, 1980; Fig. 2). This endodermal absorption may be particularly important during extracellular digestion of prey in intimate contact with the convoluted portions of the mesenteric filaments. On the other hand, the digestive cells of the mesenteric filaments, which ensure phagocytosis, absorb very few of the dissolved molecules. B.
Uptake Systems for Glucose and Amino Acids
The absorption of dissolved organic molecules is energy-dependent, and reciprocal inhibitions between different amino acids exist. Schlichter (1978a) used this phenomenon of competitive inhibition to determine the number and the specificity of the uptake systems for amino acids in Anemonia sulcata (Pennant). With this method, Schlichter identified the existence of at least three systems. The first is highly specific for acidic amino acids. It is not inhibited by either basic or neutral amino acids. The second ensures the absorption of basic amino acids, but it is less specific than the first and it is influenced by neutral amino acids. The third system, for neutral amino acids, is defined by Schlichter as a single broad specific system or several systems with overlapping specificity. Bennet and Stroud [ 1981) have histochemically located the enzyme glutamyl transpeptidase in the ectodenn of the column and the tentacles. They state that this enzyme may be involved in the uptake of amino acids and small peptides from sea water. It is still not possible, however, to relate the occurrence of this enzyme to the three systems described by Schlichter (1978a,b) or to known sodium-coupled transport systems. C. Ecological Importance of Dissolved Compounds for the Nutrition of Sea Anemones
The uptake systems appear effective and permit sea anemones to absorb and accumulate in their tissues molecules dissolved in the sea. From experiments with [3H]glucose, Schlichter (1975) concluded that the energy profit provided may supply 50% of that needed for basal metabolism in the seashore actinian A . sulcata, and a maximal incorporation after 6 h of incubation. The use of tritiated molecules to study quantitative metabolism introduces artifacts due to the spontaneous exchange of the tritium with the hydrogen of sea water during incubation and the process of absorption. Metabolic studies require amino acids labelled with carbon14. The results of these experiments indicate a slightly longer period than the 6 h mentioned by Schlichter as maximal incorporation of amino acids such as proline and leucine in macromolecules is observed in 9-10 h (Gosline, 1971; Van-Praet, 1982b).
72
M . VAN-PRAET
The dissolved molecules and their absorption must be considered from another point of view. Murdock (1971) showed that extracellular digestion of prey produced amino acids, and Chia (1972) demonstrated the capacity of the embryos of Actinia equina (L.) to absorb dissolved molecules. This capacity permits the embryos of incubator species to benefit from the amino acids and carbohydrates produced in the coelenteron by the parent during extracellular digestion of prey. This fact is important if one considers the large number of species which incubate their embryos in the coelenteron. Numerous common European species such as A . equina, Cereus pedunculatus (Pennant), Sagartia troglodytes (Price), and Bunodactis uerrucosa (Pennant) are incubator species. Sea anemones seem to be well adapted for the absorption of dissolved organic matter. The importance of their surface epidermis is increased by their numerous tentacles and the presence of microvilli on the apical face of most cells. These anatomical adaptations are complemented by the possession of effective carrier uptake systems. Schlichter (1978a) demonstrated the nonsaturation of these systems with higher concentration than normal. He considered that sea anemones may quickly absorb a high level of dissolved compounds if these conditions briefly appear seasonally. For Schlichter the energy gain resulting from the absorption of dissolved compounds is particularly important for animals with low metabolic rates, such as sea anemones, and even though their energy content becomes negligible, the absorption of a few molecules such as vitamins could be vital.
IV. Gathering and Digestion of Particulate Organic Matter A.
Suspension-Feeding Structures
All sea anemone species are able to collect macromolecules and particles with the ciliary current of the pharynx. Many species have developed complementary adaptations, such as ectodermal ciliary currents on their tentacles, oral discs, and columns, as well as appropriate positioning in water currents. Parker (1905) demonstrated the influence of nearby food on the direction of the ciliary currents in the pharynx of M. senile. Carlgren (1905) studied the extension of the cilia on the epidermis and the currents that they induce in some species. He correlated these observations with the diet of the species studied. In the genera Protanthea and Gonactinia the
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
73
entire ectoderm, from the column to the tentacles and the oral disc, is ciliated. The currents extend along the column to the oral disc and to the top of the tentacles. In the presence of food the tentacles bend toward the throat, where particles are also carried along by the centripetal currents of the oral disc (Fig. 3A). This ciliary disposition may be restricted to strictly microphagous sea anemones specialized in the gathering of particulate organic matter in sandy or muddy environments. In the genera Halcampa, Metridium, and Sagartia, cilia are less developed on the column and do not induce currents on its surface. On the epidermis of the tentacles, the currents are similar to those described previously, but those on the oral disc are centrifugal (Fig. 3B). On the throat the direction of current depends on the microanatomical zone and on the physiological state of the individual. In the siphonoglyphs, the currents are permanently directed toward the coelenteron. On the other zones of the throat they are directed outward, but they are reversed in the presence of food, or if the individual is starved. This d i a r y disposition may be correlated with microphagous feeding, such as in S . troglodytes, in which the coelenteron contains diatoms, green algae, copepods, poly-
A
1;
FIG. 3. (A) Currents on the epidermis of microphagous sea anemones (Proranrhea, Gonactinia) (after Carlgren, 1905); (B) currents in the genera Halcampa, Metridium, and Sagartia. On the syphonoglyphs (S), the currents are permanently directed toward the coelenteron (C). On the other zones of the throat (T), they are directed outward, but they are reversed in the presence of food (after Carlgren, 1905).
74
M . VAN-PRAET
chaetes, and detritus (Riemann-Ziirneck, 1969). In the genera Tealia, Bolocera, and Actinostola, the column, the tentacles and the oral disc seem devoid of oriented ciliary currents. As in both preceding groups, the currents are permanently directed toward the coelenteron in the siphonoglyphs, but are reversed in the other parts of the throat. This disposition with restricted ectodermal currents may be characterisitic of macrophagous species. The gathering of particles is also favoured by adaptations like the development of the oral disc in the large deep-sea actinians, such as Actinoscyphia (Aldred et al., 1979) and Phelliactis (personal observations in the Bay of Biscay from the submersible “Cyana”). Phelliactis robusta (Carlgren), living at the surface of muddy sediments, appear as large orientable particle traps, with their two hypertrophied contractible lobes of the oral disc. In the closely related order of Ceriantharia, Tiffon and Daireaux (1974) described a ferritin endocytosis by the ectoderm of the labial tentacles in Cerianthus lloydi (Gosse). In sea anemones, absorption of dissolved molecules by the ectoderm is effective, but endocytosis of particles seems negligible. The collected particles are ingested in the coelenteron, where phagocytosis occurs.
B. Endodermal Currents and the Role of the Trilobed Portion of Mesenteric Filaments The endocytosis of macromolecules and particles of a few micrometres is restricted to certain tissues of the coelenteron, characterized by phagocytic cells. These tissues correspond to the zone of phagocytosis defined by Metschnikoff (1880) in his study on the absorption of carmine powder, which contributed to the establishment of the concept of phagocytosis. However, zones other than in the mesenterial filaments absorb particles, namely the endoderm of the tentacles and of the column between the insertions of the mesenteries and the upper trilobed part of the filaments (Fig. 16, section V,B). The cnidoglandular tracts of filaments and their ciliated tracts ensure coelenteric currents which have mainly been studied by RiemannZiirneck (1969) in S. troglodytes. She observed that after contact with feeding suspensions the cilia of the cnidoglandular tracts of the trilobed filaments, which ensure outward currents, come to a standstill. She presumed that this phenomenon favoured the phagocytosis of particles by the mesenterial filaments. In fact, experiments with 14C-labelledCyanophyceae revealed a high endocytosis by the intermediate tract of the
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
75
upper trilobed part of the filaments superior to those in the mesenterial filaments (Van-Praet, 1980, 1982b). These intermediate tracts lie transverse to the currents induced by the ciliated tracts. They are situated between them and the cnidoglandular tracts and are deep depressions mainly composed of phagocytic cells (Figs. 4 and 5). The trilobed portion of the filaments may have two main functions. First, it traps the particles which are too small (a few micrometres or less) to be caught and immobilized in the mesenterial filaments. Second, it contributes to the ejection of the indigestible elements (faecal pellets coated with mucus) and the pseudofaecal pellets of zooxanthellae (in the
FIG.4. (A) Edge of a mesentery; (B) diagrammatic section in the upper “trilobed” part of a mesentery. The cnidoglandular tract (CGT) is mainly composed of mucous cells (MI, nematocysts, and a few zymogen cells (Z). Abbreviations and symbols: CT, ciliated tract; IT, intermediate tracts, mainly composed of phagocytic cells; RT, reticular tracts, with vacuolar cells and cells with concretions (b);-, currents gathering the particles toward the intermediate tracts.
76
M. VAN-PRAET
FIG. 5. Section of Actinia equina stained with paradimethyl aminobenzaldehyde (pDMAB). The zymogen cells stained with pDMAB are located at the level of the filament sectioned in its lower portion (E), but are absent at the level of the filament sectioned in its upper portion ( C G , cnidoglandular tract). Zones of phagocytosis of mesenteries (P) and of the intermediate tracts (I) appear in black in this sea anemone placed in china ink 24 h before fixation. Other abbreviations: C, ciliated tract; R , reticular tract.
symbiotic species; section VI) carried to the throat by the outward ciliary currents of the cnidoglandular tracts.
C. Phagocytic Cells, Cytological and Enzymological Aspects of Intracellular Digestion The digestion of macromolecules and particles (of 10 pm or less) is carried out in the phagocytic cells without prior extracellular digestion. These phagocytic cells (Figs. 6-9), also called digestive cells, possess one cilium and several apical microvilli. They have many pinocytic vesicles with an inner layer similar to those of the coated vesicles described by Slautterback (1967) in the digestive cells of Hydra. Digestion occurs in vacuoles of a few micrometres diameter. Using absorption experiments with lit-
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
77
FIG.6 . Electron micrograph of phagocytic cells in rnesenterial filaments of Edwardsia callimorpha. Abbreviations: C, cilium; G, Golgi apparatus; MV, microvilli.
mus powder, Chapeaux (1893) revealed the acid pH of the small vesicles. According to recent finds, acid phosphatase activities have been located by cytochemistry in these phagosomes surrounded by primary lysosomes and an active Golgi apparatus (Van-Praet, 1976). These cytoenzymological observations in sea anemones are similar to those in other Anthozoa, such as Zoantharia (Trench, 1974) and Ceriantharia (Tiffon and Hugon, 1977), where acid phosphatases were also revealed. These observations confirm that their localization in mucous cells by Yamao and Makino (1954) is a mistaken interpretation due to the very positive reaction of the phagocytic cells in the mesenterial filaments. The absence of enzymological investigation on purified lysosomal fractions does not permit us to correlate the hydrolase activities revealed in the ground mesenterial filaments of sea anemones (Van-Praet, 1982a) and Ceriantharia (Tiffon, 1972). However, it is likely that a large proportion of the enzymes, such as acid phosphatases, glucuronidases, and amylases, originates from the numerous phagocytic cells. These phagocytic cells also ensure the storage
78
M. VAN-PRAET
FIG. 7. Electron micrograph of a phagocytic cell of the deep sea anemone Phelliactis rubusta. Abbreviations and symbols: C, cilium; G, Golgi apparatus; MV, microvilli; + , coated vesicles.
for many weeks of indigestible endocytosed particles (Mouchet, 1930) in large postphagosomes of a few micrometres, and the accumulation of glycogenolipidic reserves at their base. These reserves are composed of wax droplets surrounded by glycogen. Their metabolism into triglycerides (Hill-Manning and Blanquet, 1979) seems to induce enzymatic synthesis of esterase-lipases detectable in the reticulum around the droplets (VanPraet, 1982b) during starvation. Other cellular types are capable of endocytosis. It is mainly the function of vacuolar cells and of cells with concretions which absorb macromolecules (Van-Praet, 1978). These cells are located in the reticular tract of the trilobed filaments (Fig. 4) and the inner layer of the throat. These cells may be two stages of the same cell type evolving from the vacuolar state to the “concretion” stage (Van-Praet, 1982b; Figs. 10, 11). In experiments with ferritin, the process of absorption by coated vesicles is similar to that in phagocytic cells. The endocytosed macromolecules are accumulated in postphagosomes of a few micrometres, but never appear in the
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
79
FIG.8. Electron micrograph of phagocytic cells ofActiniu equinu which was incubated 1 h with femtin. Dark apical vesicles of pinocytosis (P) meet in phagosomes of a few micrometres. Abbreviations: G , Golgi apparatus; MV, microvilli; SJ, septate junctions; P, pinocytosis.
large vacuoles. Their function is unclear, but they may contribute to the excretory processes (see section V,C). D. Importance of Particulate Organic Matter The early observations on the ciliary currents, as well as recent findings of microphytoplankton and bacteria in phagocytic cells by electron microscopy (Van-Praet, 1980, 1982b; Fig. 9) and the studies on phagocytosis, allow us to consider that particulate organic matter (microzooplankton, phytoplankton, detritus, etc.) constitutes a source of food for sea anemones. It is possible to postulate that it may be the main source of food for the entirely ectodermal ciliated species studied by Carlgren (Section IV,A) and the deep-sea trap species. We have investigated its importance in a seashore anemone considered as macrophagous, A . equina. Experiments with Cyanobacteria permit us to estimate their ability to collect,
80
M . VAN-PRAET
FIG.9. Aspect of the inclusions of phagocytic cells of Actinia equina fixed on the sea shore. Bacteria (B) and fragments of prey (muscle, M) are observable in phagosomes. They are digested in a few hours.
ingest, and endocytose these particles (Van-Praet, 1980). Many studies on amylase and laminarinase of crustaceans show that the levels of these enzymes are characteristic of the trophic situation of the population, and especially of the richness of carbohydrates and/or microalgae in their diet. These enzymes are also known in sea anemones (Krijgsman and Talbot, 1953; Sova et al., 1970). We have thus looked for the existence of seasonal variations in the amylase levels and the amylase/chymotrypsin ratio (NC)and their eventual contribution to the diet of A . equina. The results show the increase of amylase levels in June as well as the A/C ratio (VanPraet, 1982a). The values seem to diminish in summer and reach their lowest level in winter (Fig. 12). These variations parallel those of microalgae in the sea and confirm our hypothesis of the role of the microalgae as well as bacteria and plant fragments (terrigenous, macroalgae) in the diet of A . equina. This species, as well as numerous others, should no longer be considered as a strictly carnivorous sea anemone, but future studies may determine the real importance of particulate organic matter, and of its origin from plants, in their diet.
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
81
FIG.10. Thin section in a reticular tract of a filament of Acrinia equina. Concretions (*) are observable around the vacuole (V) of a vacuolar cell. Vacuolar cells and cells with concretions may be two stages of the same cell type. Abbreviations: P, vesicles of pinocytosis; MV, microvilli; V, vacuole.
V.
Predation and Digestion of Prey
A. Role of Tentacles, Acontia, and Cnidae Chemoreception of nearby food induces prefeeding behaviour, which increases the rate of capture (section 11). Prey immobilized by the Cnidae of the tentacles are carried to the throat by movements of tentacles and often by contractions of the oral disc. Ciliary currents, protrusion, and peristaltic movements of the throat contribute to the ingestion of prey in the coelenteron. The cnidae which ensure the capture of prey are mainly spirocysts and a few nematocysts. The function of the numerous spirocysts of sea anemone tentacles seems essentially to be an adhesive one. Food stimuli are effective in causing a massive discharge of spirocysts (Mariscal, 1974), which hold prey while the nematocysts inject their toxins. The acontia and the particular tentacles rich in nematocysts, “catch-
82
M. VAN-PRAET
FIG.1 1 . Cell with concretions in a reticular tract of a filament ofActiniu equina. Abbreviations: MV, microvilli; m, mitochondria.
tentacles,” and acrorhagi have a defensive function; they are not predatory. On the other hand, in the coelenteron the prey is immobilized, killed, and enclosed by mesenterial filaments whose cnidoglandular tracts contain nematocysts but no spirocysts. The penetrating filaments of these nematocysts (principally basitrichs, holotrichs, and microbasic mastigophores) inject toxin which is composed of several active compounds. Two major polypeptide compounds, one cytolytic and the other acting on the sodium channel of cell membranes, are known. Prey in contact with the cnidoglandular tracts are subject to the action of the secretory cells, which ensure their extracellular digestion.
B. Extracellular Digestion of Prey, Cytological and Enzymological Aspects
Fredericq (1878) and Krukenberg (1880) revealed protease activity in extracts of tissues of sea anemones, but they could not detect activity in the coelenteric fluid. Metschnikoff (1880) formulated the concept of phagocytosis and described this function in sea anemones. He considered that
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
100
83
.... ...
.. ..
...
.,.
80
..
.. ..
70 60. 5040.
30. 20. 10. I
J ' F ' M ' A ' M h n e ' J ' A ' S ' O '
FIG. 12. Seasonal variations of the amylasekhymotrypsin ratio (AK) in extracts of Acrinia equina from the Brest Channel. This ratio is considered characteristic of the richness of microalgae and plant detritus in their diet (Van-Praet, 1982a,b). Symbols: - - - , mean value; . . . . , standard deviation.
digestion is exclusively intracellular in lower invertebrates. In spite of the observations of secretory cells in filaments by Hollard (1851) and Hertwig and Hertwig (1879), and the experiments of Chapeaux (1893), who revealed a fragmentation of prey in the coelenteron, Metschnikoff (1880, 1882) and then Mesnil(l901) maintained the hypothesis of a solely intracellular digestion. This mistaken hypothesis was corroborated by the impossibility of revealing any enzymological activities in the coelenteric fluid until the study of Krijgsman and Talbot (1953). These authors detected protease, lipase, and amylolytic activities in the tissues of Pseudactinia flagellifera (Hertwig) and were the first to describe slight protease and very weak amylolytic activities in the coelenteric fluid during digestion. They suggested the hypothesis that these weak enzymatic activities ensure digestion because they are not diluted in the fluid, but are stored in the mucous film covering the prey during digestion. Nicol(l959) considered that this nondilution of enzymes results from the disposition of mesenterial filaments around the food, which is enveloped in a saclike mass of tissues which adhere closely to the surface of prey. Thus this author confirmed the hypothesis of extracellular predigestion in contact with mesenteries, which was first formulated by Krukenberg as early as 1880! Jeuniaux (1962) revealed chitinolytic activities (chitinase and chitobiase) in the endodermal extracts of Adamsia palliata (Bohadsch), A . sulcata, Anthopleura ballii (Cocks), and Edwardsia dlimorpha (Gosse).
84
M. VAN-PRAET
He confirmed that digestion of chitin occurs in the coelenteron in close contact with filaments. Elyakova (1972) also described strong chitinase activity in extracts of M . senile. Gibson and Dixon (1969) purified three serine proteases from extracts of M . senile. One of them possesses a chymotrypsin-like zymogen activation mechanism, a specificity for substrates and reactions with inhibitors which strongly suggests that this enzyme is closely related to the mammalian chymotrypsin. At least two proteases, trypsin-like and chymotrypsin-like, are found in zymogen form in extracts of mesenterial filaments of all seashore and deep-sea species of tribes Athenaria and Thenaria which we have studied (Van-Praet, 1981, 1982a,b), A . equina, E. callimorpha, P . robusta, Paracalliactis stephensoni (Carlgren), and a sea anemone from hydrothermal vents (unpublished). The study of Michaelis constants at different temperatures demonstrates that enzyme-substrate affinity decreases rapidly in measurements carried out well outside physiological temperatures. The hypothesis of a regulation correlated with the existence of different isoenzymes has thus been formulated (Van-Praet, 1982a). Quantitative measurements of protease activity and histochemical studies allow us to differentiate two parts in the filaments and to define the zymogen secretory cells. The histochemical reaction with paradimethyl aminobenzaldehyde (pDMAB) specific to tryptophan is considered indicative of the zymogen cells (Gabe, 1968). In the upper trilobed part, the cnidoglandular tract of the filaments has a few pDMAB-positive secretory cells and the extracts possess weak proteolytic activity. On the other hand, in the lower convoluted part of the filaments, at the level of mesenterial filaments the cnidoglandular tracts show the highest pDMAB-positive cell concentration and the extracts present considerable trypsin and chymotrypsin activities (Van-Praet, 1978; 1982a,b; Fig. 5 ) . The secretion of pDMAB-positive cells also appears as basic proteins included in granules of 1 pm. In electron microscopy these granules, surrounded by a membrane, appear electron dense and homogeneous (Figs. 13, 14). The ,Golgi apparatus is not prominent in these cells, which contain an extensive rough endoplasmic reticulum (Van-Praet, 1978). These ultrastructural characteristics are similar to those of zymogen cells described by Rose and Burnett (1968) in the gastrodermis of Hydra. They resemble exocrine mammalian pancreatic cells. Vader and Lonning (1975) indicate that granules are variable in diameter, up to 3-4 pm, and that endoplasmic reticulum is more or less extensive in the type 111 cells (= zymogen cells) of Bolocera tuediae (Johnston). These observations were possible because the sea anemones were starved for a long period. In the same conditions we regularly observed an accumulation of granules, which invaded the entire cytoplasm, and a correlated decrease of the reticulum.
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
85
FIG. 13. Secretory cells in a cnidoglandular tract of a filament: zymogen cells (Z) and nematocysts (N). Abbreviation: er, endoplasmic reticulum.
On the other hand in fed individuals, or in individuals fixed immediately on the sea shore or after trawling, it is possible to observe a majority of zymogen cells with an abundant reticulum, and at the bottom of the cnidoglandular tract, near the mesoglea, some young zymogen cells with an active Golgi apparatus (Van-Praet, 1982b; Fig. 15). The results of protease measurements and of cytological observations definitely confirm that the lower part of filaments, at the level of mesenterial filaments, constitutes the main zone of extracellular digestion of prey from some 10 pm to a few cm in the bigger macrophagous species. The presence of a few pDMAB-positive secretory cells in the ectoderm of tentacles and the detection of trypsin and chymotrypsin activity in the extracts of dissected tentacles do not allow us to consider as likely an “external” digestion of large prey. The products of these cells may, with mucous secretions of other cells, contribute to bacterial protection and ectodermal cleaning (Van-Praet, 1982a). In the cnidoglandular tracts, secretory cells other than zymogen cells can be identified by histochemistry as well as electron microscopy. In their study on the mesenteries of B . tuediue, Vader and Loning (1975)
86
M . VAN-PRAET
FIG.14. Secretory cells in a cnidoglandulartract of a filament of Actiniu equinar spumous mucous cell (M) and zymogen cells (Z). Zymogen cells contain an extensive rough endoplasmic reticulum (er).
described two types of mucous cells, a spumous type and a granular mucous type which exist in all the sea anemones studied (Van-Praet, 1978, 1981, 1982b). The spumous type possesses an acid poiysaccharide secretion practically devoid of protein (Van-Praet, 1978). Its acidity is probably due to carboxylic groups detected by histochemistry (Van-Praet, 1978, 1982b)and to phosphonic compounds detected by biochemistry (Bunde et al., 1978; Dearlove et al., 1979). In electron microscopy the secretion is a dense filamentous material packed into granules of a few micrometres (Fig. 14). The bigger granules show aggregation and fusion of their membrane. The granular mucous type has smaller granules of 0.4-0.8 rum. The granules contain a fine granular compound which seems acid from histochemical tests (Van-Praet, 1982b). Bouillon (1966) presumed that granular mucous cells (= “cellules phkruleuses hypostomiales”), in the Hydrozoa contribute to extracellular digestion. Krijgsman and Talbot (1953) described very weak amylolytic activity in the coelenteric fluid, but the possibility of weak contamination by frag-
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
87
coelenteron
A
FIG.I S . (A) Edge of a mesentery; (B) section of the convoluted portion of a mesenterial filament. The cnidoglandular tract of the filament (enteroid) is mainly zymogen cells (Z), nematocysts, and a few mucous cells (M). Abbreviations: aa+ , zone of absorption of small molecules such as amino acids; P, phagocytic cells; p+ , zone of endocytosis of particles, preferentially in the dip between the enteroid and the zone of phagocytosis.
ments of the mesenteries cannot be excluded. The highest amylase levels have been detected in the extracts of mesenterial filaments, but levels are slightly different from those from other dissected tissues (Van-Praet, 1982a). In our hypothesis this enzyme acts essentially during digestion of plant detritus and microalgae and may be in the phagocytic cells of the mesenterial filaments and numerous other zones of the endoderm (Section IV,D). The fragmentation of prey ends within a few hours and produces macromolecules and particles which are caught by the phagocytic cells of the mesenterial filaments enclosing the food (Fig. 16). Murdock (1971) indicated that this extracellular digestion produces amino acids. The absorption of small molecules, such as amino acids, is mainly carried out by the cells of the filaments in contact with prey (Figs. 2, 15, and 16). 'The cnidoglandular tracts appear as effective as the ectoderm in absorbing small molecules (Van-Praet, 1978, 1982b). An emulsification of lipids has been demonstrated (Chapeaux, 1893;
88
M . VAN-PRAET
FIG.16. Diagrammatic representation of the zone of absorption and digestion in Actinia equina (after Van-Praet, 1980). Abbreviations and symbols: . , zones of absorption of small molecules [ectoderm (EC) and filaments (E)]; H , zones of absorption of macromolecules (intermediate and reticular tracts and zone of phagocytosis of mesenteries); 0 , zones of absorption of particles of a few micrometres [zone of phagocytosis of mesenteries (d), intermediate tracts ( S ) ] ;CT, ciliated tracts; M, mesentery; EN, endoderm; PREY, zone of extracellular digestion of prey in contact with mesenterial filaments; t , zone of storage of lipids.
Krijgsman and Talbot, 1953), but digestion in the coelenteron of high esters has never been proved. The absorption of lipids seems to occur by pinocytosis (Van-Praet, 1982b). Digestion of the products of prey fragmentation (lipids, macromolecules, fragments of a few micrometres) ends in vacuoles of a few micrometres in the phagocytic cells, as described in section IV,C, for the particles. Numerous coated vesicles may be seen in individuals fed with Arternia or fragments of mussel. They seem to meet and to form vesicles of 1 pm or less. One or two days later, large heterogeneous phagosomes of a diameter of a few micrometres and associated acid phosphatase activities persist. After a few days of starvation, the number of these phagosomes
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
89
of more than 1 p m decreases, but a few heterogeneous postphagosomes, sometimes with crystalline inclusions, are observable. C. Excretion This function, in cnidarians, is not well known. Some indigestible compounds seem to be stored, many in the phagocytic cells. The processes of catabolism remain unknown. Mouchet (1929) described the disappearance of the concretions of reticular tracts by the use of solvents such as ammonia and piperazine hydrate. This author concluded that xanthine was present. Raman spectrophotometry microanalysis of sections embedded in epon, after Carnoy fixation, showed a proteinaceous complex at the level of concretions, but did not permit identification of any major compound (Van-Praet, 1982b). The nature of these crystalline concretions (Van-Praet, 1977; Fig. 11) and the function of these cells (able to pinocytose, Van-Praet, 1982b) cannot be definitely established, but they appear to be the terminal state of the vacuolar cells (Van-Praet, 1982b). A molecule, homarine, has been isolated in extracts of many marine invertebrates. It is particularly abundant in sea anemones (Mathias ef al., 1960) and could intervene in excretion and osmoregulation (Beers, 1967; Gaill, 1981). Lewis and Smith (1971) and Cates and McLaughlin (1976) described excretion of ammonia by sea anemones. According to these authors, the symbiotic zooxanthellae remove a large part of ammonia and carbon dioxide excreted by the host sea anemone.
VI.
Symbiosis
Symbiosis has given rise to many studies and reviews (Taylor, 1973; Muscatine, 1974), and we consider here only recent results related to nutrition of sea anemones.
A. Localization of Algal Symbionts Brandt (1881) created the genus name Zooxanthella. In marine cnidarians, he was the first to determine that these organisms were microalgae and not parasites. Recent studies of their motile phase and the observations by electron microscopy indicate the similarity of structure of all the Dinophyceae of sea anemones, but the authors are still discussing the validity of the term “Zooxanthelfa.” Freudenthal (1962) proposed the term Symbiodinium, Taylor (1973, 1974) the term Gymnodinium, but
90
M. VAN-PRAET
Loeblich and Sherley (1979) reintroduced Zooxanthella. The presence of other microalgae was described by Muscatine (1971) in Anthopleura xanthogrammica (Brandt) and A . elegantissima (Brandt). These Chlorophyceae (= zoochlorellae) have been mainly investigated by O’Brien (1978, 1980). Zooxanthellae, like zoochlorellae, are always located in endodermal cells. They are abundant in the endoderm of tentacles, the oral disc, and the intermediate tracts of the filaments. During gametogenesis they accumulate in the mesenteries around the gametes. In a few genera they are located in specialized organs, such as pseudotentacles in Lebrunia, column vesicles in Bunodeopsis, or ruff on the upper part of the column in Phyllactis. Their accumulation in the tentacles facilitates the exposure of these algae to light. Sea anemones with specialized organs present a specialized behaviour. During daylight, organs with zooxanthellae are expanded, but the tentacles are contracted. On the other hand, the tentacles are expanded at night when prey is available (Gladfelter, 1975; Steele and Goreau, 1977; Sebens and Reimer, 1977). Phototaxis of symbiotic species may be related to local variations of the oxygen level in the tissues and to the metabolism of zooxanthellae. The cycle of expansion in the light and contraction in the dark, however, persists in Anthopleura which have lost their symbionts, so other factors may exist (Pearse, 1974). B. Regulation of the Concentration of Algae in the Tissues The efficiency of symbiosis seems a function of the type of symbionts (zooxanthellae or zoochlorellae) and of their number. Unlike zooxanthellae, zoochlorellae translocate only a small part of the products of their photosynthesis (O’Brien, 1980). Two processes maintain the quantity and balance of algae in the tissues: first, the growth rate by binary fission of the algae; and second, the expulsion rate of these symbionts by the host. Expulsion of algae may be continuous or sequential. It increases during starvation or after environmental stress (increase of temperature, darkness, variation of salinity). Steele (1976) considered that the density of symbionts in host tissues is directly related to the intensity of light and that the rate of expulsion is controlled by the presence or absence of altered metabolites. These metabolites are produced by zooxanthellae when they degenerate or when their number increases. The degeneration of algae is itself dependent on the environmental stress mentioned. In this scheme, Steele explains the egestion of zooxanthellae during starvation by the relative increase of algae, which accompanies shrinkage of host tissues, so leading to rapid passing of the critical level of metabolites within these tissues. The presence of altered metabolites initiates the
91
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
extrusion of zooxanthellae by the sea anemone, and this continues until the situation has reverted to normal; then it stops. This scheme seems realistic for many species. In Phyllactis jlosculifera (Lesueur), Steele and Goreau (1977) have described a more complete regulation, and a real “farming” of zooxanthellae by their host. As in all sea anemones, living zooxanthellae are never digested, but Phyllactis can secrete a proteinaceous substance which has a destructive effect on symbionts. Regulation of the secretion of this protein permits this actinian to use zooxanthellae as a source of food according to its needs. In general, the nutritional significance of symbiosis is not considered to be the direct utilization of symbionts by the sea anemone but as the translocation of metabolites produced during photosynthesis.
C . Translocation of Metabolites Any sea anemone species may be considered as autotrophic. The experiments of Muscatine and Hand (1958), Trench (1971), and Lewis and Smith (1971) have demonstrated the translocation of products of photosynthesis from zooxanthellae to their hosts. These studies demonstrated that zooxanthellae incorporate C 0 2 and release as much as 50% of this carbon, mainly as glycerol and a small amount as glucose and alanine. Trench (197 1) found that 75% of these translocated compounds were incorporated by the host into its lipids and 25% into its proteins. These authors described how the homogenated host tissues stimulate the release of soluble molecules from free zooxanthellae. They deduced a regulation of the phenomenonon of translocation by the host, and Muscatine (1974) considered zooxanthellae as ‘‘efficient primary producers. Recent studies indicate some further factors which must be assessed. The temperature of the environment has a great influence on carbon fixation by zooxanthellae and on carbon budget partitioning in symbiosis. In Aiptasia pallida, carbon fixation appears very low at less than lTC, and translocated molecules seem to be incorporated less in lipid and protein molecules of the sea anemone (Clark and Jensen, 1982). In sea anemones such as Aiptasia, which possess zooxanthellae and/or zoochlorellae, 0’Brien (1980) demonstrated that with zoochlorellae translocation is very low, less than 3% from the fixed carbon. The nutritional benefit appears generally in experiments under conditions of starvation (Taylor, 1969). In symbiotic A . sulcata fed daily with Euphausia, the wet weight increases at the same rate in light or in darkness (Janssen and Moller, 1981). It seems obvious that this symbiosis may be considered as a nutritional benefit during the seasonal periods when food decreases. The quantitative evaluation of this advantage under normal feeding conditions will become ”
92
M . VAN-PRAET
possible when the reversed translocation has been studied more thoroughly. The utilization by zooxanthellae of catabolic compounds of the sea anemone host has been demonstrated by Lewis and Smith (1971) and Cates and McLaughlin (1976). However, the reversed translocation seems to concern more compounds than carbon dioxide, ammonia, and nitrites. By feeding Aiptasia with 35S-labelledfood, Cook (1971) demonstrated the reversed translocation of compounds in a few hours and that 15-30% of the radioactivity was retained in zooxanthellae for at least 3-5 days.
VII.
Sea Anemones as Prey and Remarks on the Diet of Sea Anemones A. Predators of Sea Anemones
Many species of sea anemones live in commensalism with crustaceans (amphipods, decapods) or fish (Amphiprion). In a few cases, this association with amphipods may, in fact, be considered as parasitism. A few Caprellidae and Gammaridae find protection between the tentacles of sea anemones and catch their food in the sea, but a few Stenothoidae collect a part of the food caught by their actinian host. In the genera Onisismus, Aristias, and Allogausia, the amphipods live in the coelenteron of their host and collect a part of the ingested food. Onisismus normani (Sars) is associated with B. tuediae, Actinostola callosa (Verrill), and Hormathia spp.; 20 amphipods can live in the coelenteron of one Bolocera. The young of 3 mm infest their host, live in it for 18 months, and leave only at the oviger state (Vader, 1970). Amphipods that feed on the tissues of their host may exist in the genus Acidostoma (Lyssianassidae). In spite of their nematocysts, sea anemones constitute a source of food for many animals. The gastropods Aeolidae which stock nematocysts of their prey are their best known predators. Each species of aeolid seems to show an alimentary preference; thus Aeolidia papillosa (L.) feeds frequently on A . elegantissima, less on Anthopleura artemisia (Pickering), and never on Corynactis (Waters, 1973). Harris (1971) considered that fluctuations in the numbers of A . papillosa influence the distribution patterns of M. senile. Other gastropods, such as Trochidae and above all Epitoniidae, frequently feed on sea anemones. Pycnogonids, asterids, fish, and worms such as Hermodice are known to feed on sea anemones (Ottaway, 1977). Hermodice may affect the local
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
93
distribution of Stoichactis (Lizama and Blanquet, 1975). Predation by fish is effective; Webb (1973) found that Anthopleura spp. constitute 5% of the gut content of the flounder Rhombosolea, but in all the reports of predation by fish it seems that sea anemones may have been ingested accidentally along with commensal crustaceans and molluscs.
B. Diet of Sea Anemones In these sedentary coelenterates, prey is composed of small motile animals (zooplanktonic larvae, isopods, amphipods, polychaetes). On the sea shore some bigger sessile prey species dislodged by wave action, or occasionally by foraging predators, complete the diet of sea anemones. In the anemone species commensal with crustaceans, such as A . palliata and Calliactis parasitica (Couch), or with fish (Amphiprion), such as the Stoichactis and Stilodactys, pieces of prey caught by the commensal species are collected by the anemones. Generally the prey size is small considering the diameter of the sea anemone, and many species may be considered as microphagous (Section IV). In the nine common species of Caribbean reef sea anemones, seven are planktivores, and the two species Condylactis gigantea (Weinland) and Stoichactis helianthus (Ellis), which can eat macroscopic prey such as gastropods and echinoids, are probably dependent on heavy wave action on the reef to supply prey (Sebens, 1976). For common seashore species such as A . elegantissima and M . senile, the prey size ratio to the diameter of sea anemones is 0.08-0.09. In A . xanthogrammica, the value of this ratio attains 0.4, but this high value is due to the ingestion of mussels and barnacles dislodged by wave action and by asteroid foraging (Dayton, 1973; Sebens, 1981). The two most common species on the European coast, A . sulcata and A . equina, are able to immobilize large prey, but the observation of coelenteric contents demonstrates the scarcity of large crustaceans and molluscs (Moller, 1978; Van-Praet, 1982b). The most common prey are small crustaceans (amphipods, isopods), POlychaetes, and gastropods. Fairly often, fragments of appendages of Carcinus maenas (L.), insects, and detritus of macroalgae can be observed. As mentioned earlier, dissolved molecules and particulate organic matter are absorbed and used by sea anemones. The diet of these sessile cnidarians is less rigid than that of mobile animals. The classification into mainly microphagous, but with a few macrophagous species, does really reveal the extent of opportunism in the diet. Future studies may better determine the respective part constituted by prey, particulate organic matter, and dissolved molecules in their diet and its seasonal variation.
94
M. VAN-PRAET
Acknowledgments The author wishes to thank Professor C. Levi (Laboratoire de Biologie des Inverttbrts Marins et Malacologie, Musturn, Paris), Dr. J. F. Samain (Centre Octanologique de Bretagne, Brest), and Dr. C. Milet (Laboratoire de Physiologie, Museum, Paris) for their valuable suggestions and for providing laboratory facilities.
References Aldred, R. G . , Riemann-Ziirneck, K., Thiel, H., and Rice, A. L. (1979). Ecological observations on the deep-sea anemone Actinoscyphia aurelia. Oceanologica Acta 2, 389-395. Beers, J. R. (1967). The species distribution of some naturally occurring quarternary ammonium compounds. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 21, 11-21. Bennett, L. W.,and Stroud, E. (1981). Occurrence and possible functions of y-glutamyl transpeptidase in external epithelia of Meiridium senile (Cnidaria, Anthozoa). Transactions of the American Microscopical Society 100, 316-321. Bouillon, J. (1966). Les cellules glandulaires des Hydroides et des Hydromeduses. Leur structure et la nature de leurs stcrktions. Cahiers de Biologie Marine 7 , 157-205. Brandt, K. (1881). Ueber das Zusammenleben von Thieren und Algen. Sitzungsberichte der Gesellschaft Naturforschender Freunde zu Berlin 9, 140-146. Bunde, T. A., Dearlove, G . E., and Bischop, S. H. (1978). Aminoethylphosphonic acidcontaining glycoproteins: the acid mucopolysaccharide like components in mucus from Metridium senile. Journal of Experimental Zoology 206, 215-222. Carlgren, 0. (1905). Uber die Bedeutung der Flimmerbewegung fur den Nahrungstransport bei den Actiniarien und Madreporarien. Biologische Zentralblutter 25, 308-322. Cates, N., and McLaughlin, J. J. A. (1976). Differences of ammonia metabolism in symbiotic and aposymbiotic Condylactus and Cassiopea spp. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 21, 1-5. Chapeaux, M. (1893). Recherches sur la digestion des CoelentCrts. Archives de Zoologie ExpCrimentale et Ge‘ne‘rale 3, 139-160. Chia, F. S. (1972). Note on the assimilation of glucose and glycine from seawater by the embryos of a sea anemone, Actinia equina. Canadian Journal of Zoology 50, 1333-1334. Clark, K. B., and Jensen, K. R. (1982). Effects of temperature on carbon fixation and carbon budget partitioning in the zooxanthellal symbiosis of Aiptasia pallida (Verrill). Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 64, 2 15-230. Cook, C. B. (1971). Transfer of [3sS]labeled material from food ingested by Aiptasia sp. to its endosymbiotic zooxanthellae. In “Experimental Coelenterate Biology” (H. M. Lenhoff, L. Muscatine, and L. V. Davis, eds.), pp. 218-225. Univ. of Hawaii Press, Honolulu. Dayton, P. K. (1973). Two cases of resource partitioning in an intertidal community making the right prediction for the wrong reason. American Naturalist 107, 662-670. Dearlove, G.E., Viles, J. M., and Bischop, S. H. (1979). Aminoethylphosphonic acid (AEP) containing glycoproteins in Metridium senile: [I4C]AEPincorporation and electron probe microanalyses. Journal of Experimental Zoology 210, 169-179. El yakova, L. A. (1972). Distribution of cellulases and chitinases in marine invertebrates. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 43B, 67-70. Faurot, L. (1895). Etude sur l’anatomie, l’histologie, et le developpement des Actinies. Th&e de Doctorat d’Etat, No. 843, University of Paris.
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
95
Fredericq, L. (1878). Sur la digestion des albuminoides chez quelques invertebres. Archives de Zoologie Expirimentale et GPnirale 7 , 391-400. Freudenthal, H. D. (1962). Symbiodinium gen. nov. and Symbiodinium microadriaticum sp. nov., a zooxanthella: taxonomy, life cycle and morphology. Journal of Protozoology 9, 45-52.
Gabe, M. (1968). “Techniques Histologiques.” Masson, Paris. Gaill, F. (1981). Contribution i I’Ctude morphologique et fonctionnelle du rein et de la glande pylorique des Tuniciers benthiques. These de Doctorat d’Etat, MusCum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris VI. Gibson, D., and Dixon, G. H. (1969). Chymotrypsin-like proteases from the sea anemone Metridium senile. Nature (London) 222, 753-756. Gladfelter, W. B. (1975). Sea anemone with zooxanthellae: Simultaneous contraction and expansion in response to changing light intensity. Science 189, 570-571. Gosline, J. M. (1971). Kinetics of incorporation of [‘4C]prolineinto mesogleal protocollagen and collagen of the sea anemone Aiptasia. I n “Experimental Coelenterate Biology” (H. M. Lenhoff, L . Muscatine, and L. V. Davis, eds.), pp. 146-156. Univ. of Hawaii Press, Honolulu. Green, C. R. (1984). Intercellularjunctions. I n “Biology of the Integument I. Invertebrates” (J. Bereiter-Hahn, A. G. Matoitsky, and K. S. Richards, eds.), pp. 5-16. Springer Verlag, Berlin. Hams, L. (1971). Ecological observations on a New England nudibranch-anemone association. Echo 4, 22. Hertwig, O., und Hertwig, R. (1879). Die Actinien, anatomisch und histologisch mit besonderer Berucksichtigung des Nervenmuskelsystems untersucht. Zeitschr$t fur Naturwissenschafren 13, 457-640. Hill-Maning, D. N., and Blanquet, R. S. (1979). Seasonal changes in the lipids of the sea anemone Metridium senile (L.). Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 36, 249-258.
Hollard, H. (1851). Monographie anatomique du genre Actinia de L i m e considtrk comme type du groupe gCnCral des polypes zoanthaires. Annales des Sciences Naturelles 15,275291.
Holley, M. C., and Shelton, G. A. B. (1984). Reversal of direction of mucus-flow on the ciliated pharynx of the sea anemone. Journal of Experimental Biology 108, 151-161. Janssen, H. H., and Moller, H. (1981). Effects of various feeding conditions on Ammonia sulcata. Zoologischer Anzeiger 206, 161-170. Jeuniaux, C. (1962). Digestion de la chitine chez les Actiniaires. Calziers de Biologie Marine 3,391-400.
Krijgsman, B. J., and Talbot, F. H. (1953). Experiments in digestion in sea anemone. Archives Internationales de Physiologie 61, 277-291. Krukenberg, C. (1880). Ueber den Verdauungsmodus der Actinien. Vergleichend-Physiologische Studien 1, 33-56. Lawn, I. D. (1976). Chemoreception and conduction systems in sea anemones. I n “Coelenterate Biology and Behavior” (G. 0. Mackie, ed.), pp. 581-590. Plenum, New York. Lenhoff, H. M., Heagy, W., and Danner, J. (1976). A view of the evolution of chemoreceptors based on research with Cnidarians. In “Coelenterate Biology and Ecology” (G. 0. Mackie, ed.), pp. 571-580. Plenum, New York. Lewis, D. H., and Smith, D. C. (1971). The autotrotophic nutrition of marine coelenterates with special reference to hermatypic corals. I. Movement of photosynthetic products between the symbionts. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 178, 111-119.
96
M . VAN-PRAET
Lindsted, K. J. (1971a). Chemical control of feeding behaviour. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 39A, 553-581. Lindstedt, K.J. (1971b). Biphasic feeding response in a sea anemone: Control by asparagine and glutathione. Science 173, 333-334. Lindstedt, K. J., Muscatine, L., and Lenhoff, H. M. (1968). Valine activation of feeding in the sea anemone Boloceroides. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 26, 567-572. Lizama, J., and Blanquet, R. S. (1975). Predation on sea anemones by the amphinomid polychete, Hermodice carunculata. Bulletin of Marine Science 25, 442-443. Loeblich, A. R., and Sherley, J. L. (1979). Observations on the theca of the motile phase of free living and symbiotic isolates of Zooxanthella microadriatica (Frendenthal). Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 59, 195-205. Logan, C. A. (1979). Behavioral inhibition induced by ingestion in sea anemones (Anthopleura elegantissima). Animal Learning and Behavior 7 , 413-416. McFarlane, I. D. (1970). Control of preparatory feeding behaviour in the sea anemone Tealia felina. Journal of Experimental Biology 53, 21 1-220. McFarlane, I. D. (1975). Control of mouth opening and pharynx protrusion during feeding in the sea anemone Calliactis parasitica. Journal of Experimental Biology 63, 615-626. McFarlane, I. D., and Jackson, A. J. (1976). Interactions between conducting systems in the sea anemone Calliactis purasitica. In “Coelenterate Ecology and Behavior” (G. 0. Mackie, ed.), pp. 581-590. Plenum, New York. McFarlane, I. D., and Shelton, G. A. B. (1975). The nature of the adhesion of tentacles to shells during shell-climbing in the sea anemone Calliactis parasitica. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 19, 177-186. Mariscal, R. N. (1974). Nematocysts. In “Coelenterate Biology, Reviews and New Perspectives” (L. Muscatine and H. M. Lenhoff, eds.), pp. 129-178. Academic Press, New York. Mathias, A. P., Ross, D. M., and Shachter, M. (1960). The distribution of S-hydroxytryptamine, tetramethylammonium, homarine, and other substances in sea anemones. Journal of Physiology (London) 151, 296-3 1 1 . Mesnil, F. (1901). Recherches sur la digestion intracellulaire et les diastases chez les actinies. Annales de l’lnstitut Pasteur (Paris) 15, 352-397. Metschnikoff, E.(1880). Uber die intracellulare Verdauung bei Coelenteraten. Zoologischer Anzeiger 3, 261-263. Metschnikoff, E. (1882). Zur Lehre iiber die intracellulare Verdauung niederer Thiere. Zoologischer Anzeiger 5, 310-316. Moller, H.(1978). Nahrungsokologische Untersuchungen an Anemonia sulcata. Zoologischer Anzeiger 200, 369-373. Mouchet, S. (1929). Presence de xanthine chez les actinies. Bulletin de la SociPtP Zoologique de France 54, 345-350. Mouchet, S. (1930). L’excrktion chez les actinies. Notes de la Station OcPanographique de SalammbB 15, 1-14. Murdock, G. R. (1971). The formation and assimilation of alcohol-soluble proteins during intracellular digestion by Hydra littoralis and Aiptasia sp. I n “Experimental Coelenterate Biology” (H. M. Lenhoff, L. Muscatine, and L. V. Davis, eds.), pp. 137-145. Univ. of Hawaii Press, Honolulu. Muscatine, L. (1971). Experiments on green algae coexistent with zooxanthellae in sea anemones. PaciJc Science 25, 13-21. Muscatine, L . (1974). Endosymbiosis of Cnidarians and Algae. I n “Coelenterate Biology, Reviews and New Perspectives” (L. Muscatine and H. M. Lenhoff, eds.), pp. 359-395. Academic Press, New York. Muscatine, L., and Hand, C. (1958). Direct evidence for the transfer of materials from
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
97
symbiotic algae to the tissues of a Coelenterate. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 44, 1259-1263. Nagai, Y., and Nagai, S . (1973). Feeding factors for the sea anemone Anthopleura midorii. Marine Biology 18, 55-60. Nicol, J. A. (1959). Digestion in sea anemone. Journal ofthe Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 38, 469-476. O’Brien, T. L. (1978). Aspects of the symbiotic association between intracellular zoochlorellae (Chlorophyceae) and the coelenterate Anthopleura xanthogrammica. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Texas. O’Brien, T. L. (1980). The symbiotic association between intracellular zoochlorellae (Chlorophyceae) and the coelenterate Anthopleura xanthogrammica. Journal of Experimental zoology 211, 343-355. Ottaway, J. R. (1977). Predators of sea anemones. Tuatara 22, 213-221. Pantin, C. F. A., and Pantin, A. M. P. (1943). The stimulus to feeding in Anemonia sulcata. Journal of Experimental Biology 20, 6-14. Parker, G . H. (1905). The reversal of ciliary movement in Metazoans. American Journal of Physiology 13, 1-16. Pearse, V. B. (1974). Modification of sea anemone behavior by symbiotic zooxanthellae. Phototaxis. Biological Bulletin. Marine Biological Laboratory, Woods Hole 147,630-640. Pollock, W. L. (1883). On indications of the sense of smell in Actiniae. Journal of the Linnean Society 16,474-476. Reimer, A. A. (1973). Feeding behaviour in the sea anemone Calliactis polypus (Forskbl, 1975). Comparative Biochemistrj and Physiology 44A, 1289-1301. Riemann-Ziirneck, K. (1969). Sagartia troglodytes (Anthozoa). Biologie und Morphologie einer schlickbewohnenden Aktinie. Veroffentlichungen des fnstitut fur Meeresforschung in Brernerhauen 12, 169-230. Rose, P., and Burnett, A . (1968). An electron microscopic and histochemical study of secretory cells in Hydra uiridis. Wilhelm Roux’Archiv 161, 281-297. Sandberg, D. M., Kanciruk, P., and Mariscal, R. N. (1971). Inhibition of nematocyst discharge correlated with feeding in a sea anemone Calliactis tricolor (Lesueur). Nature (London) 232, 263-264. Schlichter, D. (1975). The importance of dissolved organic compounds in sea water for the nutrition of Anemonia sulcata Pennant. In “Proceedings of 9th European Marine Biology Symposium” (H. Barnes, ed.), pp. 395-405. Aberdeen Univ. Press, Aberdeen. Schlichter, D. (1978a). On the ability of Anemonia sulcata (Coelenterata, Anthozoa) to absorb charged and neutral aminoacids simultaneously. Marine Biology 45, 97-104. Schlichter, D. (1978b). The extraction of specific proteins for the simultaneous ectodermal absorption of charged and neutral aminoacids by Anemonia sulcata. In “Physiology and Behaviour of Marine Organisms” (D. S. McLusky and A. J . Berry, eds.), pp. 155-163. Pergamon, Oxford. Sebens, K. P. (1976). The ecology of Caribbean sea anemones in Panama: Utilization of space on a coral reef. In “Coelenterate Ecology and Behavior” ( G . 0. Mackie, ed.), pp. 67-77. Plenum, New York. Sebens, K. P. (1981). The allometry of feeding energetics, and body size in three anemones species. Biological Bulletin Marine Biological Laboratory, Woods Hole 161, 152-171. Sebens, K. P., and Reimer, K. (1977). Die1 cycles of expansion and contraction in coral reef anthozoans. Marine Biology 43, 247-256. Shelton, G . A. B., and McFarlane, I. D. (1976). Slow conduction in solitary and colonial Anthozoa. In “Coelenterate Ecology and Behavior” ( G . 0. Mackie, ed.), pp. 599-607. Plenum, New York.
98
M. VAN-PRAET
Slautterback, D. B. (1967). Coated vesicles in absorptive cells of Hydra. Journal of Cell Science 2, 563-572. Slautterback, D. B . (1969). Control of microvillus formation and coated vesicle stimulation in Hydra absorptive cells. Journal of Cell Biology 43, (Abstracts of the 9th Annual Meeting of the American Society for Cell Biology, p. 135). Sova, V. V.. Elvaknva, L. A.. and Vaskovsky, V. E. (1970). The distribution of laminarinases in marine invertebrates. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 32, 459-464. Steele, R. D. (1976). Light intensity as a factor in the regulation of the density of symbiotic zooxanthellae in Aiptasia tagetes (Coelenterata, Anthozoa). Journal of Zoology (London) 179, 387-405. Steele, R. D., and Goreau, N. 1. (1977). The breakdown of symbiotic zooxanthella in the sea anemone Phylliactis jlosculifera. Journal of Zoology (London) 181, 421-437. Steiner, G . (1957). Uber die chemische Nahrungswahl von Aclinia equina. Naturwissenschafen 44, 70-7 1 . Taylor, D. L. (1969). The nutritional relationship of Anemonia sulcata (Pennant) and its dinoflagellate symbiont. Journal of Cell Science 4, 75 1-762. Taylor, D. L. (1973). The cellular interactions of algal-invertebrate symbiosis. Advances in Marine Biology 11, 1-56. Taylor, D. L. (1974). Symbiotic marine algae: Taxonomy and biological fitness. In “Symbiosis in the Sea” (W. B. Vernberg, ed.), pp. 245-262. Univ. of South Carolina Press, Columbia. Tiffon, Y. (1972). Latency and sedimentability of acid hydrolases in sterile homogenates of Cerianthus Iloydi, Gosse. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 45B, 73 1-740. Tiffon, Y., and Daireaux, M. (1974). Phagocytose et pinocytose par I’ectoderme et l’endoderme de Cerianthus Iloydi, Gosse. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 16, 155-165. Tiffon, Y.,and Hugon, J. S. (1977). Localisation ultrastructurale de la phosphatase acide et de la phosphatase alcaline dans les cloisons septales steriles de 1’AnthozoairePachycerianthus jmbriatus. Histochimie 54, 289-297. Trench, R. K. (1971). The physiology and biochemistry of zooxanthellae symbiotic with marine coelenterates. I. The assimilation of photosynthetic products of zooxanthellae by two marine coelenterates. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B 177,225235. Trench, R. K. (1974). Nutritional potentials in Zoanthus socialus (Ellis). Helgolunder wissenschafliche Meeresunrersuchungen uon der biologischen Anstalf auf Helgoland 26, 174-216. Vader, W . (1970). Amphipods associated with the sea anemone Bolocera tuediae, in western Norway. Sarsia 43, 87-98. Vader, W., and Lonning, S. (1975). The ultrastructure of the mesenterial filaments of the sea anemone, Bolocera tuediae. Sarsia 58, 79-88. Van-Praet, M. (1976). Les activites phosphatasiques acides chez Actinia equina L. et Cereus pedunculatus P. Bulletin de la SociPtP Zoologique de France 101, 367-376. Van-Praet, M. (1977). Les cellules a concretions d’Acfinin equina L. Comptes-Rendus Hebdomadaires des Se‘ances de I’Acade‘mie des Sciences, ( D )285, 45-48. Van-Praet, M. (1978). Etude Histochimique et ultrastructurale des zones digestives d’Actinia equina L. (Cnidaria, Actiniaria). Cahiers de Biologie Marine 19, 415-431. Van-Praet, M. (1980). Absorption des substances dissoutes dans le milieu, des particules et des produits de la digestion extracellulaire chez Actinia equina L. Reproduction, Nutrition, DPveloppement, 20B, 1393-1399.
NUTRITION OF SEA ANEMONES
99
Van-Praet, M. (1981). Comparaison des taux d’activitk amylasique, trypsique et chymotrypsique, ainsi que des types cellulaires intervenant dans la digestion chez les actinies littorales et abyssales. Oceanis 7, 687-703. Van-Praet, M. (1982a). Amylase, trypsin, and chymotrypsin-like proteases from Actinia equina L.; their role in the nutrition of the sea anemone. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 72A, 523-528. Van-Praet, M. (1982b). Absorption et digestion chez Actinia equina L., nutrition des Actiniaires. These d e Doctorat d’Etat, Mustum National d’Histoire naturelle et UniversitC Pans VI, 218 p. Waters, V. L. (1973). Food preference of the Nudibranch Aeolidia papillosa and the effect of the defence of the prey on predation. Veliger 15, 174-192. Webb, B. F. (1973). Fish populations of the Avon-Heathcote estuary. 3. Gut contents. Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 7, 223-224. Williams, R. B. (1972). Chemical control of feeding behaviour in the sea anemone Diadumene luciae (Venill). Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 41A,361-371. Yamao, Y.,and Makino, N. (1954). Histochemistry and biochemistry of sea anemones. Histochemical distribution of the acid and alkaline glycerophosphatases. Journal of the College of Arts and Sciences of Chiba University I, 181-183. Yonge, C. M. (1968). Living corals. Proceedings of the Royal Sociefy of London Series B 169, 329-344. Yonge, C. M. (1973). The nature of reef-building (hermatypic) corals. Bulletin of Marine Science 23, 1-15.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Effects of Environmental Stress on Marine Bivalve Molluscs HeBeAkberali Departments of Zoology and Botany, University of Manchester, England
and
E. R. Trueman Department of Zoology, University of Manchester, England
I. Introduction
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
A. Definition of stress .. . . . . . . . . .. . . B. Occurrence of natural and man-made stresses .. .. .. C. Threshold levels of pollutant stress . . .. .. .. .. D. Development of experimental techniques . . . . .. . . 11. Behavioural Responses to Stress . . .. .. .. .. .. A. Valve closure as a protective mechanism . . .. .. .. B. Relationship between heart rate, valve movement, and pumping ., .. .. .. .. .. .. .. activity . . C. Behavioural response to some pollutant stressors .. .. D. Relevance of valve closure in epifaunal and infaunal species . . E. Effect of subthreshold levels on behaviour .. .. .. F. Effect of temperature on heart rate . . .. .. .. .. 111. Detection of Stress . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . A. The significance of registering changes in the environment .. B. Sites of reception .. .. .. . . . . . . .. C. Detection and response to environmental changes .. ..
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
.. .. ..
.. ..
102 102 104 104 105
108 108 Ill 1 I7 121 128 130 132 132 134 136
101 ADVANCES IN MARINE BIOLOGY, VOL. 22
Copyright Q 1985. by Academic Press Inc. (London1 Ltd. All righlr o f reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0- 12-026122-7
102
H . B . AKBERALI AND E. R . TRUEMAN
.. Respiratory Physiology during Stress . . . . . . . . . . .. A. Valve closure and cessation of aerobic processes. . . . . . B. Relationship between heart rate, valve movements, PO>. and pC02 . . C. Anaerobic respiration during valve closure.. . . . . .. .. .. D. Valve activity and pH changes . . . . . . . . . . V. The Role of the Shell . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. A. Physical protection and isolation from environmental stress . . .. B. Shell closure and calcium reabsorption . . . . . . . . .. C. Effect of prolonged stress on shell strength . . . . . . VI. Action of Heavy Metal Stressors . . . . . . . . . . .. .. A. Accumulation of heavy metals . . . . . . . . .. .. .. B. Effects of heavy metals on tissues . . . . . . . . . . C . Effects of heavy metals on released gametes and embryonic and juvenile stages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Effects of heavy metals on cellular organelles . . . . . . . . VII. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV.
146 146 146 148 151 155 155 156 161 162 162 163 168 175 182 183
I. Introduction A. Definition of Stress Concern about changes in the environment and their effect on animals has recently evoked extensive research on Bivalvia based on behavioural, physiological, and biochemical responses at organismal, tissue, or cellular levels. Bayne (1975) offered the following working definition of stress as applied to marine bivalve molluscs: “Stress is a measurable alteration of a physiological (behavioural, biochemical, or cytological) steady-state which is induced by an environmental change, and which renders the individuals (or the population) more vulnerable to further environmental change.” Most adult bivalves are relatively immobile, and any change in the environment of transient, recurrent, or permanent occurrence has to be accommodated by the animal. In the aquatic environment, many low levels of natural or man-made changes are within their normal adaptive range and are tolerated without serious consequences. More extreme changes may be temporarily resisted but can ultimately result in the death of organisms. Between these limits of tolerance and resistance to environmental stressors, a region of sublethal response occurs whereby the capability for survival may be reduced as a consequence of the stressor. The species used in this article are listed in Table I with their authorities.
EFFECTS OF STRESS O N MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
TABLEI. THE LIST OF SPECIES WITH THEIRAUTHORITIES USED I N THISARTICLE Species
Authority
Anadara s e n i h Anodonta anatina Anodonta cygnea Arctica islandica Cardium (Cerastoderma) edule Cardium (Cerastoderma) gluucum Chlamys opercularis Choromytilus meridionalis Crassostrea commercialis Crassostrea gigas Crassostrea margaritacea Crassostrea uirginica Donax denticulatus Donax juliane = Donax trunculus Donax serra Donax trunculus Helix uspersa Isognomon alatus Ligumia subrostrata Lima scabra Loligo pealii Lolliquneula breuis Macoma batthica Mercenaria (Venus) mercenaria Modiolus demissus Modiolus modiolus Mya arenaria Mytilus californianus Mytilus edulis Mytilus edulis planulatus Mytilus galloprovincialis Mytilus uiridis Neotrigonia margaritacea Ostrea edulis Pecten irradians Pecten maximus Perna perna Pimpehales promelas Pleurobema coccineum Scrobicularia plana Spisula solidissima Tellina fabula Unio tumidus Venerupis decussuta Venus striatula
Linnaeus Linnaeus Linnaeus Linnaeus Linnaeus Poiret Linnaeus Krauss Iredale and Roughley Thunberg Lamarck Grnelin Linnt Linnaeus Roding Linnaeus Linnaeus Gmelin Say Born Lesueur Blainville Linnaeus Linnaeus Dillwyn Linnaeus Linnaeus Conrad Linnaeus Lamarck Lamarck LinnC Lamarck Linnaeus Lamarck Linnaeus Linnaeus Rafinesque Conrad da Costa Dillwyn Gmelin Philipsson Linnaeus da Costa
103
104
H . B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
B.
Occurrence of Nuturul and Man-made Stresses
Bivalve molluscs are found in aquatic habitats ranging from oceanic waters to fresh water. The open marine environment is relatively stable with respect to its physicochemical composition, but in coastal and estuarine habitats significant fluctuations may occur in salinity, temperature, oxygen levels, and turbidity. Bivalves may also be subjected to further stresses arising from man’s activities, such as off-shore drilling, dredging, or the release of pollutants.
C. Threshold Levels of Pollutant Stress Bivalve molluscs may be either suspension or deposit feeders, and these feeding strategies pose different problems with respect to threshold levels of environmental stress. Suspension-feeding bivalves, e.g., Mytilus edulis, Cerastoderma edule, or Anodonta cygnea, filter suspended particles from the water current entering the mantle cavity, whereas deposit-feeding bivalves, e.g., Scrobiculuria plana, feed on the sediment surface with long extensible siphons but are also capable of suspension feeding (Hughes, 1969; Earll, 1975b). The principal source of pollutant stress in suspension feeders is from pollutants in solution and associated with suspended particles, whereas in deposit-feeding animals the most important source will be the sediment. In Scrobicularia, which is both a deposit and suspension feeder, the uptake of pollutants will be related to both modes of feeding. Different feeding strategies may determine the stressors likely to affect different bivalves; for example, several heavy metals, such as zinc, manganese, cadmium, or selenium, are largely taken up with particulate matter either in suspension or from the sediment, whereas the more acutely toxic metals, such as mercury, copper, and silver, are absorbed most rapidly from solution (Bryan, 1976, 1979). Evidence of significant differential absorption of metals from solution by various tissues has been reported; for example, copper is absorbed from solution about three times more rapidly by the gills and mantle/siphons than by the digestive gland and other tissues (Bryan and Uysal, 1978). The uptake of heavy metals bound to suspended food or inorganic particulate matter is less harmful than direct availability from solution since bound heavy metals have first to be isolated by digestive processes. They may thus be dealt with by metal scavenging systems, such as metallothionein proteins, which have been shown to exist in bivalve molluscs (see Section VI,A). It is also possible that the low toxicity threshold level for mercury and copper is partly related to their direct uptake from the solution. Metals such as zinc and cadmium have a higher toxicity threshold level (Bryan, 1976, 1979)
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BlVALVE MOLLUSCS
105
because they are less readily taken up in the free form from the solution. The sensitivity of bivalve molluscs to zinc in, for example, Mya arenaria (Eider, 1977), Mytilus viridis (D’Silva and Kureishy, 1978), Mytilus edulis planulatus and Neotrigonia margaritacea (Ahsanullah, 1976), and S. plana (Akberali et al., 1981), in terms of both the threshold for any behavioral response and acute toxicity is one order of magnitude lower than the corresponding values for copper in S . plana (Akberali and Black, 1980), M. edulis (Davenport and Manley, 1978), and other bivalve molluscs (D’Silva and Kureishy, 1978; Manley and Davenport, 1979). Differences in the threshold levels of response to salinity decline have also been reported in terms of siphonal closure and shell valve adduction, which occur at about 25 and 20%0,respectively, in M . edulis (Davenport, 1979) and S. plana (Akberali and Davenport, 1981).
D. Development of Experimental Techniques The development of electronic and other analytical techniques has led to significant advances in our knowledge of bivalve behaviour. These techniques allow continuous monitoring of heart activity and valve movements both in the laboratory and under field conditions (Hoggarth and Trueman, 1967; Trueman, 1967; Vero and Salanki, 1969; Trueman et al., 1973; Coleman, 1974; Earl1 and Evans, 1974; Brand, 1976) and have stimulated interest in the physiological and biochemical adaptations associated with behavioural changes. Electronic techniques are a considerable advance over previous studies, which involved cutting holes in the shell to observe the heart or the use of a cumbersome system of threads and levers to record valve movements (Koch, 1917; Brown, 1954; Barnes, 1955; Schleiper, 1955; Segal, 1956; Pickens, 1965). To minimize disturbance to the animals, attempts have been made to observe heart activity without cutting the shell, e.g., in A . cygnea (Koch, 1917) and in M. edulis (Schleiper, 1957), observation of heart activity being made through the almost transparent shell of young individuals. Hers (1943) etched away the outer shell layers of older Anodonta with acid and viewed the heart through the thin, transparent, inner nacreous sheet. Although these modifications of the “shell hole” technique might reduce interference with the animal, the use of direct observation is time consuming and impractical in the field. Monitoring of heart activity using the impedance technique developed by Trueman (1967) requires the positioning of electrodes through the shell on either side of the heart. Once the electrodes are properly positioned, the animal need not be disturbed further and recordings can be made remotely, hence facilitating laboratory and field studies. Recordings of
106
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
hydrostatic pressure in the pericardium and electrocardiographs have confirmed that the heart rate is satisfactorily recorded by the impedance technique (Helm and Trueman, 1967; Brand, 1976). The impedance technique has been used, both in the laboratory and in the field, to record heart and valve activity of bivalve molluscs and other marine invertebrates in relation to a variety of environmental changes such as tidal exposure (Trueman, 1967; Helm and Trueman, 1967; Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Coleman, 1972, 1974; Earll, 1975a), feeding (Thompson and Bayne, 1972; Widdows, 1973), temperature fluctuations (Segal, 1962; Trueman and Lowe, 1971; Lowe, 1974; Coleman, 1973, 1974; Parker, 1978; De Fur and Mangum, 1979; Dietz and Tomkins, 1980; Stone, 1980; Davenport and Carrion-Cotrina, 1981), environmental oxygen levels (Bayne, 1971; Lowe and Trueman, 1972; Badman, 1974; Brand and Roberts, 1973), salinity (Davenport, 1976, 1979; Akberali, 1978; Akberali and Davenport, 1981), pollution studies (Davenport, 1977; Manley and Davenport, 1979; Akberali and Black, 1980; Akberali et al., 1981, 1982b; Manley, 1983), and mantle cavity ventilation (Walne, 1972; Akberali and Trueman, 1979; Davenport, 1979). The relative size of the animals has also been shown to affect heart rate; in general, the heart beat in small specimens is faster than that of larger individuals in similar conditions (Pickens, 1965; Earll, 1975a). Monitoring of the water-pumping activity of bivalves has also been improved with the development of thermistor flow meters (Heusner and Enright, 1966; Brand and Taylor, 1974; Earll, 1975a,b; Brand, 1976; Foster-Smith, 1976; Akberali, 1978; Parker, 1978; Stone, 1980), although these have yet to be adapted for field recordings. This technique was, however, a great improvement on previous attempts at measuring the water flow through the mantle cavity involving the direct determination of water volumes by the insertion of tubes into the mantle cavity (Galtsoff, 1926, 1928) or the attachment of “rubber aprons” (Loosanoff and Engle, 1947) which considerably disturbed the animal being monitored. An alternative approach is the use of indirect particle filtration techniques which have posed a number of problems in the interpretation of the results, for these depend on several assumptions, any of which may not be met during the course of an experiment (Coughlan, 1969). In Pecten irradians after initial clearance on the gills, phytoplankton such as Nitzschia and Chlarnydornonas may be returned to the suspension (Chipman and Hopkins, 1954). Further doubt on the accuracy of plankton filtration studies has been cast by Hildreth (1980), who observed that considerable amounts of particulate material were produced from the faeces of M . edulis, which may be added to the suspension, resulting in an underestimate of filtration rate on the order of 35%. Furthermore, the flow rate of water across the
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
I07
gills can vary enormously, depending upon experimental procedure (Jergensen, 1966). A laser diffraction technique has recently been employed to measure the shell growth of Mytilus when subjected to fluctuating salinity regimes (Gruffydd et al., 1984) or the presence of copper or zinc in the sea water (Manley et al., 1984). This technique appears to be particularly suitable for future laboratory studies of the effect of stressors on shell growth. The use of electronic techniques has given further insight as to what constitutes “activity” in bivalve molluscs. The isolated observation of valve movements or indirect filtration methods led to a widely held interpretation of bivalve behaviour as a “steady state” of continuous feeding and activity (Loosanoff, 1939; Jgrgensen, 1966; Purchon, 1968). Recently, with the development of electronic techniques, this view has been questioned, for many examples exist in the literature which indicate differing levels of pumping, feeding, valve movements, and heart rate when bivalves are in the “active” state (Earll, 1975a,b). The results of recent studies (Purchon, 1971; Morton, 1973) make a “steady state,” or continuously active, concept difficult to apply, especially in an environmental context, for example, littoral bivalves are subject to tidal rhythms. Irregular discontinuity in pumping rate has also been observed in the sublittoral bivalves Zsognomon alutus (Trueman and Lowe, 1971) and Arctica islandicu (Brand and Taylor, 1974). Morton (1973) has put forward the view that in the long term feeding is discontinuous, exhibiting a distinct progression of events often closely synchronized with environmental rhythms. The concept of activity put forward by Loosanoff (1939), Jergensen (1966), and Purchon (1968) conceals the possibility of different levels of activity in “active” animals. The description of “active,” “routine,” and “standard” levels of metabolism in M . edulis, as defined by Bayne et al. (1973), would all fall into the category of animals described as “active” using Loosanoff s criteria (Earll, 1975a). Many other examples exist of bivalves which show differing levels of pumping, feeding, valve movements, heart rate, and shell deposition when they are in an “active” state (Earll,\,l975a; Coleman, 1974; Morton, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1973; SalAnki, 1966,a,b; Stone, 1980). In M . edulis, Bayne et ul. (1973) have suggested that, in the laboratory, once a period of behavioural adaptation has elapsed the main activities are those concerned with the maintenance of pumping for both feeding and respiratory purposes. Earll (1975a,b) defines “activity” as the maintenance of the pumping current for feeding, respiration, and excretion and “inactivity” as the cessation of pumping. However, most bivalves can show short-term discontinuous pumping patterns while still active (Earll, 1975a,b; Brand, 1976; Akberali, 1978; Parker, 1978; Stone, 1980), and accordingly Earll has defined inactivity as
I
108
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R . TRUEMAN
a period of prolonged cessation of pumping (exceeding an arbitrary period of 1 h) to differentiate between a short cessation of pumping during activity . The effects of environmental variables on bivalve molluscs have been studied at the organismal, tissue, and cellular level. In the past, the main approach adopted has been the “steady state” or “direct transfer” experiments where either a particular response or a multitide of responses of the animal is monitored in relation to experimental variation of a single environmental variable, e.g., salinity, temperature, or pollutant, while maintaining other factors as constant as possible. Although such studies provide a less complicated basis for understanding interactions with a particular environmental variable, doubts have been recently expressed as to whether animals in their natural habitat will ever encounter changes in a single environmental variable. For example, salinity variation in the natural habitat may be expected to alter other related factors such as temperature or oxygen solubility. Further doubts have been raised as to whether changes in the media reach a steady state in the natural habitat, especially with respect to intertidal bivalves (Davenport, 1982). This has led to the design of multivariate dynamic experiments in an attempt to simulate naturally variable conditions. Regimes such as salinity-temperature, salinity-pollutant, temperature-pollutant, and temperature-oxygen have been attempted. It is not intended to review the numerous papers on this subject here, but the following should be consulted: Stickle and Ahokas (1975), Davenport et al. (1975), Shumway (1977), Widdows (1978), Cawthorne (1979), and Manley (1980), together with a review written by Davenport (1982) on the subject of environmental simulation experiments on marine and estuarine animals.
II. Behavioural Responses to Stress A. Valve Closure as a Protective Mechanism Bivalve molluscs can isolate their tissues from the external environment by closing their valves, and some have been shown to minimize desiccation by valve adduction during periods of emersion at low tides. In M . edulis (Helm and Trueman, 1967; Coleman and Trueman, 1971), Cardium glaucum, and C. edule (Trueman, 1967; Boyden, 1972a) bradycardia occurs in response to littoral exposure when the valves become closed; activity is depressed, resulting in the animal respiring at lowered levels. In I . alatus (Trueman and Lowe, 1971) and Modiolus demissus (Lent, 1969), controlled valve opening exposes a film of water between the mantle
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
109
margins when exposed to air. This may serve both for oxygen exchange and as a source of moisture for evaporative cooling (Lent, 1968). When the level of water in an experimental tank was lowered beneath S . plana, bradycardia occurred and the valves closed (Earll, 1975b). Similarly, when Scrobicularia were transferred from normal sea water to a lowered salinity, the valves tended to remain closed; the’greater the drop in salinity, the greater the tendency to remain closed (Freeman and Rigler, 1956; Akberali, 1978). The activity of both intertidal and subtidal species of Modiolus, as measured by valve movements, was also reduced when the animals were exposed to either a high or a low salinity. The valve movements appeared to return to normal after a period of time the duration of which was dependent on the magnitude of the salinity change (Pierce, 1971). Valve closure in response to the presence of heavy metal pollutants has also been reported in a number of bivalve molluscs (Davenport, 1977; Manley and Davenport, 1979; Akberali and Black, 1980; Akberali et al., 1981). It has also been shown that low temperatures induce “hibernation” in oysters (Galtsoff, 1928). At low temperatures Mercenaria (Venus)mercenaria may remain completely closed for a period of several days; one clam was closed for a period of 18 days (Loosanoff, 1939). Valve closure response in M . edulis has been shown to operate at about -1.5”C when subjected to simulated subarctic conditions, which ensures that the tissues of mussels are exposed to little or no osmotic stress (Davenport and Carrion-Cotrina, 198 1). Furthermore, Loosanoff (1942) has also reported that M . edulis remained open more than 75% of the total time at temperatures as low as -1.O”C. The freshwater clam Pleurobema coccineum showed a continuous level of activity under well-aerated conditions, whereas in the absence of oxygen a remarkable activity shift occurred, consisting of prolonged shell closure interrupted by periods of intense valve activity (Badman, 1974). Bivalves respond to the presence of predators either by taking avoiding action or by closing the shell as a protective measure. The swimming of scallops by the rapid flapping of the valves in response to starfish is well known (Brand and Roberts, 1973), and the leaping movements of two species of the Asaphidae by flexure of the foot have been observed by Ansell (1967). Simple experiments (A. Jenkins and A. R. Brand, personal communication) during investigations of the feeding behaviour of the starfish Astropecten, using Venus striatula and Tellina fabula, indicate that the former may survive ingestion by the starfish for periods of longer than 1 week with its valves closed, but that Tellina appears to be unable to close its valves for more than brief periods and is fairly rapidly consumed after ingestion. Astropecten is only able to consume T . fabula when placed in aquaria without sand, for a shallow layer of sand allows this
110
H . B. AKBERALI A N D E. R . TRUEMAN
species to escape. This suggests two alternative strategies by which bivalves may respond to predator stress, either by rapid locomotion and escape or by the closure of thickened valves with the ability to remain quiescent utilizing anaerobic respiration (Section IV,C). Further experiments with a range of sessile and active infaunal bivalves are required to elucidate this (Trueman, 1983b). Valve closure of bivalves prevents drastic changes in osmotic concentration of their body fluids when exposed to short-term fluctuations in salinities (Shumway, 1977). With long-term exposure to salinity change, acclimatization of the internal body fluids does occur (Akberali, 1980a), suggesting that the valve closure mechanism allows the animal a period of grace and thus prevents osmotic shock. In M. edulis, Davenport (1979) showed that the valve closure response to short-term gradual decline in salinity is partially dependent upon rate of change of salinity. This led him to the discovery that the isolation of the mantle cavity fluid is not simply produced by valve closure, but comprises a three-part sequence. The first part of this sequence is the closure of the exhalant siphon, which effectively ceases the irrigation of the mantle cavity. Further decline in external salinity results in the closure of the inhalant siphon, which is then followed by valve closure. A similar sequence has also been reported in S . plana (Akberali and Davenport, 1981). Although “shell closing” in bivalve molluscs may help the organism to withstand transient adverse changes in the environment, it cannot contribute to its long-term survival in situations where a change in the environment may be of a permanent or recurrent nature. This is because during any period of valve closure the animal incurs penalties related to feeding, reproduction, or exchanges of gases and metabolites. The term “valve closure” does not necessarily imply that there is no contact between the tissues and the media. In the strictest sense, valve closure means the complete sealing of the ventral margins of the shell. Studies have shown that during valve closure some exchange or contact with the environment is often maintained. In M. edulis, for example, during exposure at low tides, there is a reduction in valve gape and apposition of the mantle margins but usually a small gape remains (Coleman and Trueman, 1971). Low salinity stress produces a similar feature in Donax denticulatus (Trueman, 1983a), and Perna perna has been observed to respond to copper ions by incomplete valve closure where the periostracal margins of the two mantle lobes are brought into contact so as to seal the shell from the exterior (Hodgson, unpublished). Furthermore, bivalves such as Mytilus californianus, Cardium edule, M . edulis, and S . plana, with the valves forcibly clamped together show a greater drop in the oxygen tension or increase in calcium concentration of the
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
111
mantle cavity than unclamped clams (Moon and Pritchard, 1970; Boyden, 1972a; Coleman, 1972; Akberali et al., 1977; Akberali and Trueman, 1979). When a bivalve is exposed to salinity or pollutant stress, the maintenance of some slight tissue contact with the media which may be intermittent is advantageous, for it allows the organism to monitor the situation and become active once the prevailing conditions become favorable (see Section 11,B). The animal must rely on the registering of chemical changes by a slight tissue contact with the media. This is in contrast to bivalves when exposed at low tide, for these may register vibrations due to water movement or temperature changes at reimmersion. B. Relationship between Heart Rate, Valve Movement, and Pumping Activity The heart rate of bivalves is a useful physiological rate function since it may easily be monitored together with valve movements and pumping activity (Trueman et al., 1973). Amplitude of heart beat is not, however, easy to monitor and interpret successfully using impedance techniques. A relationship between heart rate and valve movements was demonstrated many years ago by Koch (1917), who showed in Anodonta that the heart rate is reduced during periods of valve closure. More recently this phenomenon has been reported in a number of other bivalve molluscs (Bayne, 1971; Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Coleman, 1974; Earll, 1975a,b; Brand, 1976; Akberali, 1978; Dietz and Tomkins, 1980; Akberali et al., 1981). In bivalve molluscs high levels of heart rate are associated with periods of activity as indicated by valve gape, high rates of respiration, and filtering/pumping activity, whereas periods of inactivity are associated with a low heart rate (Fig. 1). Such marked changes in heart rate accompany different activity levels in bivalves, such as those which occur when pumping ceases and the valves close. Studies of some species, e.g., M . edulis, Anodonta anatina, M . arenaria, and Ostrea edulis, have demonstrated that when kept in constant conditions, bivalves show a particular activity level with relatively little change in the heart rate. The heart rate of these bivalves during activity is largely independent of gross changes in pumping activity. Depending on the species, heart rate might be expected to vary by 2, 3, or 4 beatslmin over a period of hours (Coleman, 1974; Earll, 197%). By far the most marked changes of heart rate occur when animals become inactive, for in these situations pumping ceases and in some species the valves are often completely closed (Fig. 1). This inactive period is associated with a marked slowing of the heart or bradycardia. Bradycardia is a term usually applied to describe major changes of heart rate in bivalves, such as be-
1 I2
H . B . AKBERALI AND E. R. TRUEMAN
L
c L
m
a
I
15 r
-I
lot
2
/---
A
-
\ Hours
FIG. 1. Analysis of events during experiments on the effect of exposure on the heart rate and valve gape of M. edulis (A), and the effect of exposure on the heart rate of Modiolus modiolus (B). The rate is measured as beatshinute, and gape in degrees. The period of exposure is indicated by the horizontal line above each (from Coleman and Trueman, 1971).
tween different activity levels, rather than to small fluctuations in rate during a particular activity level in the sense used by Boyden (1972a). Following periods of inactivity, pumping recommences and the heart rate increases markedly, often to a level greatly exceeding the heart rate of continual activity. This is commonly referred to as an “overshoot” effect. Within an hour of the onset of activity, the heart rate usually falls to a rate which is similar to that shown throughout the rest of the period of activity (Trueman, 1967; Helm and Trueman, 1967; Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Brand and Roberts, 1973; Coleman, 1974; Earll, 1975b; Brand, 1976; Taylor, 1976a,b; Akberali, 1978; Parker, 1978). Pumping, associated as it is in bivalves with both feeding and respiration, has been considered of primary importance in studies of activity. While recognizing the importance of pumping, it is often more convenient to obtain an indication of pumping activity by monitoring valve movements. Since pumping activity usually occurs when the valves are gaping, it is possible to obtain some indication of pumping activity from valve movements, but in some species these may be at a superficial level and lead to wrong conclusions. For example, in M . edulis, although the valves may be gaping and at the same time be exhibiting a high heart rate, the mussel need not necessarily be actively pumping (Bayne et al., 1973).
113
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
Davenport (1979, 1982) showed the closure of the exhalant siphon, thus preventing pumping, was the crucial event which largely isolated the mantle cavity of the mussel from falling external salinities; shell valve closure occurred at rather lower salinities to produce virtually complete isolation. Akberali and Davenport (1981) have shown that closure of the exhalant siphon is even more important to Scrobicularia, in which absolute valve closure is impossible, and in which valve adduction is delayed until low external salinities occur. This is reasonable for an infaunal estuarine species since the interstitial salinities of estuarine muds tend to be high and relatively stable (Kinne, 1971). Scrobicularia would hardly be exposed to the rigours of the salinity fluctuations in the estuarine water column except in respect of water flowing through the mantle cavity. In some other species of bivalves, variations of heart rate during activity in response to large changes in pumping level seem either disproportionately small, e.g., 0. edulis (Walne, 1972), or nonexistent as in M. edulis (Thompson and Bayne, 1972). A “regular” heart rate is maintained in M. arenaria during activity while its pumping is essentially a discontinuous process, being interrupted for varying periods by closure of the exhalant siphonal aperture (Earll, 1975a) (Fig. 2). In Scrobicularia plana, pumping during activity is also a discontinuous process but the heart rate is sensitive to changes in pumping level (Earll, 1975a,b; Akberali, 1978). During activity, S . plana shows a high heart rate and trace amplitude so
1 min I
I
I
I
I
I
h
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
1
1
I
FIG,2. M . arenaria: simultaneous records of pumping activity (exhalant current speed H, high and 0, zero pumping level), impedance heart trace and midventral valve movement (dc impedance). Abbreviations: imp, impedance; 0, open; C, closed. Discontinuous pumping is not related to the heart record. A burst of water from the exhalant siphon (V)coincides with the elimination of faeces (from Earll, 1975a).
FIG.3. S. plana: simultaneous records of pumping level, heart activity, and shell movement during short-term variation of heart activity; open (0)and closed (C) (from Earll, 1975a).
I15
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
long as pumping is maintained (Fig. 3). When pumping is interrupted during activity, however, a gradual fall occurs in the heart rate and the amplitude of the heart trace falls rapidly to a low level (Fig. 3). Earll (1975a,b) has broadly defined the short-term variation in the heart pattern of Scrobicularia plana as a repeating cycle of heart activity beginning with a transition to a high rate. This is then followed by a slowing down in a variable manner until a period of lowered heart rate is reached, which precedes the transition to the high heart rate once again (Fig. 4). In Scrobicularia, the heart rate and heart amplitude coincide significantly with changes in pumping level, suggesting that heart function is more sensitive to the cessation of pumping. This close relationship of heart rate and
I
10
5
I
Time fh)
0
20
c
5
I
30
60
T i me (min)
FIG. 4. Heart activity patterns of M. arenaria (A) and S. plana (B) when constantly submerged at 10°C: heart rate in Mya during behavioural inactivity shown by the continuous line (-); in Scrobicularia during activity, a cycle of heart rate variation as shown by the broken line (----) between transition, T, from low to high rates (from Earll, 1975b).
I16
H . B. AKBERALI AND E. R. TRUEMAN
pumping during activity, described by Earll (1975b), and confirmed by Akberali (1978), is uncommon in other bivalves which have been studied (Coleman, 1974; Earll, 1975b). Another example occurs in Donax serra, buried normally in sand, where valve adductions may be observed when the exhalant current stops flowing and the heart beat immediately ceases (Trueman, unpublished). Replacement of stressful change in environment, e.g., polluted, salinity, aerial exposure, with clean sea water is associated with a rapid resumption of activity (Fig. 5). An initial series of valve adductions, which may be associated both with testing behaviour and hyperventilation of the mantle cavity, is usually evident within 5-10 min, which is then followed by the progressive opening of the valves and extension of siphons. Accompanying this is a marked increase in heart rate, often beyond normal activity rates (Figs. 7, 10). This “overshoot” response is more marked in clams subjected to severe environmental changes and is comparable to the “overshoot” response observed in a number of studies with bivalve molluscs (see Section 11,B). The greater the change in the environment from normal conditions, the longer are the inactivity periods resulting in the cessation of pumping activity, isolation of the clam from the media, and pronounced bradycardia. The longer the inactive period the greater the “overshoot” response to compensate for the physiological needs in terms of respiration, feeding, and excretion.
MINUTES
FIG.5. Examples of recordings of heart beat and valve movements of S. p l u m at 10°C in control (A) and animal exposed to 10 ppm added zinc (B) for 6 h when test solutions were replaced by fresh sea water; c (J) and e (4) indicate removal of test solutions and d (1) subsequent replacement with fresh sea water (op, open; cl, closed). (From Akberali et al., 1981).
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
117
C. Behavioural Response to Some Pollutant Stressors
Since the heart rate in S . plana is so closely related to pumping, the heart rate may be utilized as a means of monitoring interactions with environmental stress (Akberali and Black, 1980). Whenever a high heart rate is recorded from this clam, pumping is indicated, thus implying interaction with the particular environment, and conversely. An example of this is found in the response of Scrubicularia to sea water with added copper to final concentrations of 0.01-0.5 ppm. The immediate response is valve closure, but the timing and duration of this varies with the copper concentration (Fig. 6) and is associated with an
B
A a
L 20
40
60
-
C
0
20
40
60
D
o%rG--%Minutes
-
0 Minutes
FIG.6. Heart rate (a) and valve movements (b) of individual Scrobiculuriu during the first hour when subjected to various copper concentrations. A, 0.5; B, 0.1; C, 0.05; and D, 0.01 ppm copper concentrations in sea water (S, 31%0). Arrows indicate addition of copper solution. Heart rate (HR) sampled by counting heart beats per minute for each minute. Valves open (o),closed (c) (from Akberali and Black, 1980).
118
H. B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
immediate drop in the heart rate indicating a cessation in pumping activity (Akberali and Black, 1980). In 0.01 and 0.05 ppm, heart rate subsequently increased, while in contrast, the heart rate in 0.1 and 0.5 ppm kept falling during the first hour of recordings. Over the 6-h exposure period to 0.5 ppm, the heart rate was maintained at about 6-8 beatdmin and the valves remained closed (Fig. 7). After 2-3 h in lower concentrations, there was an increase in heart rate and intense valve activity was observed, indicating interaction with the polluted sea water (Figs. 7 and 8). Akberali er ul. (1981) have also used heart rate and valve movements to examine the behavioural response of S. p l u m to various zinc concentrations. At concentrations of 0.1-0.5 ppm, the clams did not behave differently from the controls. At higher concentrations, however, the siphons were withdrawn and valves remained closed, with a marked lowering of A
O
B
i o 1 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
C
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
8
D
L-rrIl 1
2
3
4
Hours
5
6
1
8
o L 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1
Hours
FIG.7. Heart rate (HR) of Scrobicularia subjected to various copper concentrations over a 6-h exposure period. A, 0.5; B, 0.1; C, 0.05; and D, 0.01 ppm copper concentrations in sea water (S, 31%0). Addition of copper solution indicated by J, replacement with normal sea water by t. HR of each Scrobiculariu over the 6-h exposure period sampled by averaging 5min periods. Horizontal bars (-) refer to increased activity in heart rate and valve movements during the 6-h exposure period. Each point is a mean of four animals recorded in each concentration. Vertical bars (I) represent the range of individual variation (from Akberali and Black, 1980).
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
I19
A
B
C
D U
I
5 min
FIG. 8. Examples of recordings of heart activity (HA) and valve movements (VM) of Scrobicularia 2-3 h after subjection to various copper concentrations and corresponding to the state of increased activity referred to in Fig. 7 by horizontal bars (-). A, 0.5; B , 0.1; C, 0.05; and D, 0.01 ppm. Copper concentrations in sea water (S, 31%0). Valves open (o), closed (c) (from Akberali and Black, 1980).
heart rate (Fig. 9). Concentrations of 1-5 ppm zinc resulted in a partial resumption of activities in some clams, while animals exposed to 10 ppm zinc maintained valve closure over the experimental period, accompanied by pronounced bradycardia (Fig. 10). At lower zinc concentrations, the frequency and duration of interaction with the environment became greater over a 6-h period, as reflected by increase in heart rate. Similar behavioural responses have been reported in S. plana exposed to abrupt salinity changes or the first hydrolytic product (1-naphthol) of the insecticide Sevin (Akberali, 1978; Akberali et al., 1982b). Lethal toxicity tests based on a fixed exposure period, e.g., 24-h LCso,
H. B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
I 20
0.5pprn Zn
-
open, Closedl
--lppm Zn
I
~
:
:
i
:
i
0
:
:
:
l
i
.
:
:
;
:
10
;
:
:
:
:
:
;
MINUTES
:
;
:
;
;
: i
:
:
:
:
:
,
,
;
:
30
FIG.9. Examples of recordings of heart beat and valve movements of S. plana at 10°C on addition of various concentrations of zinc as described in the original paper. AJ, addition of stock zinc solution; BJ, attainment of final zinc concentrations. Valves open (op), closed (cl) (from Akberali et al., 1981).
48-h LCso,or 96-h LC50,may lead to erroneous interpretation of results in terms of toxicity threshold. In some bivalves, e.g., S . plana, it has been shown that the clam can withstand valve closure for periods of 5-7 days (Akberali et al., 1977; Akberali, 1978) while effectively isolating its tissues from the stress environment. In such animals, care should be taken in interpreting toxicity results based on fixed exposure periods. In these bivalves, median lethal time exposures would be more meaningful than fixed exposure periods. For example, when M. edulis (Davenport, 1977) and S. plana (Akberali and Black, 1980) were subjected to short-term (6h) 0.5 ppm copper concentration they suffered no mortality (Table 11) since they closed their valves immediately. Similar observations have
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
121
4’
a l ~ , ~ H o u r s 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 FIG.10. Effects of various levels of added zinc to normal sea water on the heart rate of S. plana at 10°C. Arrow (4)at 0 h indicates application of test concentration of zinc, while f at 6 h indicates replacement with fresh sea water. Each point is a mean of 4-8 animals. Vertical 0.5 ppm zinc ( N = 4); A-A, 1 ppm zinc ( N = bars represent the standard error. W-H, 7); A--A, 5 ppm zinc ( N = 5 ) ; 0-0, 10 ppm zinc ( N = 8). 50 ml normal sea water (1) applied to controls (0-0, N = 5). Treatment for controls after 6 h as in test solutions (from Akberali et al., 1981). I~~~~~~~~~
been made in Scrobicularia subjected to short-term (6-h) 5-10 ppm zinc (Akberali er al., 1981) or 1-naphthol (Akberali et al., 1982b). A longer exposure period, however, resulted in an increase in mortality, with a median lethal time of 2-7 days (Table 11). Akberali and Black (1980) and Akberali et al. (198 1) have suggested that there is a limit to the duration of anaerobic respiration, since the clam must eventually eliminate its accumulated wastes. When this occurs, the tissues then come into contact with the media, poisoning takes place, and death results.
D. Relevance of Valve Closure in Epifaunal and Infaunal Species Not all bivalve molluscs are capable of complete valve closure; e.g., infaunal species such as S. plana and M . arenaria show a reduction in heart rate indicative of a period of reduced activity which can frequently be related to the closure and the partial or complete retraction of the siphons into the burrow (Coleman, 1974; Earll, 1975a,b; Akberali, 1978; Akberali and Davenport, 1981). In littorally adapted epifaunal M . edulis, water is retained in the mantle cavity during exposure at low tide by the apposition of the mantle margins coupled with reduction of valve gape, but usually an opening remains (Coleman and Trueman, 1971). The retention of mantle cavity water reduces the danger of desiccation from aerial exposure or from osmotic shock during a decline in external salinity.
TABLE11. ADULTBIVALVE MORTALITYIN RELATIONTO THE PERIOD OF EXPOSURE TO POLLUTANT Species
Pollutant stressor
Concentration
STRESS'
Duration of exposure
Observed response
5 mg/l 39 Fg/l 35 P d l
48 h 96 h 168 h
LCJO LCSO LCSO
Eisler (1977)
Reference
M . arenaria
Copper
M . arenaria
Zinc
52 mg/l 5.2 mg/l 1.6 mgA
48 h 96 h 168 h
LCso LCSO LCSO
Eisler (1977)
M . edulis
Copper
300 pg/l
Continuous exposure for 7 days
LCSO
Scott and Major (1972); Martin e f al. (1975)
M . edulis
Copper
500 c~gfl
6h Continuous exposure Continuous exposure
No mortality MLT 4-5 days MLT 2 days
250 pg/l 500 pg/l
Davenport (1977)
M. edulis
Zinc
S. plana
Copper
S. plana
Zinc
> 5 mgfl
0.1-20 mg/l 10 mgA
20 mg/l
S.plana
1-Naphthol
1-10 mg/l
5 mgA 10 mg/l
Martin et al. (1975)
Continuous exposure for 7 days
6h Continuous exposure
No mortality MLT 5-7 days
Akberali and Black (1980)
6h Continuous exposure Continuous exposure
No mortality MLT 6 days MLT 5 days
Akberali et al. (1981)
6h Continuous exposure Continuous exposure
No mortality MLT 15 days MLT 9 days
Akberali et al. (1982b)
Abbreviations: MLT, median lethal time for 50% mortality; LCs0, lethal concentration for 50% mortality.
124
H . B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
In the M . edulis, a 50% fall in heart rate occurs within 20 min of being exposed at low tides (Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Coleman, 1972, 1973). The behaviour of M . edulis is similar to M. californianus (Moon and Pritchard, 1970; Bayne et al., 1976b) in that the valves are gradually closed at the onset of aerial exposure to retain water in the mantle cavity. Oxygen from the air, however, diffuses into the mantle cavity, leading to a higher oxygen tension in the mantle cavity than if the valves had been tightly closed (Moon and Pritchard, 1970). M . edulis respires during exposure at a level which approaches the lowest levels animals show when immersed (Widdows et al., 1979). Oxygen uptake, however, is erratic, and it appears to depend on an occasional opening of the valve (Coleman, 1973; Bayne and Livingstone, 1977). In the epifaunal M . demissus (Kuenzler, 1961; Lent, 1968), some water is expelled from the mantle cavity at the onset of exposure and the valve gape is reduced to about half that found when the animals are pumping actively. This enables air to enter the mantle cavity, so allowing aerobic respiration (Table 111). In M. edulis and Mytilus galloprovincialis, an aerial rate of between 4 and 17% of the rate of oxygen consumption in water occurs, and in C . edule and M . demissus between 28 and 78% has been reported (Widdows et al., 1979), the species differences being related to the degree of shell gape during exposure (Table 111). In C . edule, as in M . demissus (Kuenzler, 1961; Lent, 1968), some water is also expelled from the mantle cavity at the onset of exposure (Boyden, 1972a,b), and the heart rate of Cardium initially rises on exposure and then falls, but is maintained at a relatively high level throughout exposure (Trueman, 1967; Boyden, 1972a,b). I . alatus, a tropical epifaunal species, maintains a small valve gape during exposure, and it has been suggested that this species also respires aerobically (Trueman and Lowe, 1971). Another behavioural pattern is adopted by infaunal species such as C . glaucum, S. plana, and M . arenaria (Boyden, 1972a; Earll, 1975a,b). In these species, for example, little or no valve movement occurs during exposure, a pattern in contrast with M . demissus, C . edule, and M . edulis, which show a reduced but regular sequence of valve activity and the ability to utilize atmospheric oxygen during exposure at low tides (Table 111). For example, C . glaucum (Boyden, 1972a) seals its valves tightly, whereas M . arenaria (Dicks, 1972) and S. plana (Earll, 1975b) close the siphonal apertures and withdraw the siphons into the burrow. Neither S. plana, C. glaucum, nor M . arenaria has been reported to utilize atmospheric oxygen during exposure at low tide, and oxygen comsumption in these species is very low during exposure and difficult to demonstrate (Collip, 1920, 1921; van Dam, 1935; Boyden, 1972a; Dicks, 1972). Furthermore, in these infaunal species a complete cessation of heart rate and
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
125
valve movement occurs during exposure, and it is possible that they are entirely dependent upon anaerobic respiration during exposure at low tides (Table 111). Sublittoral species and those which live at low intertidal levels show erratic behaviour during experimentally simulated tidal exposure. This in part accounts for the greater variability of the heart and valve movement records found in these species during aerial exposure at low tides, e.g., M . modiolus (Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Coleman, 1972) and Pecten maximus (Brand and Roberts, 1973). Modiolus and Pecren appear unable to regulate either valve movements or the retention of water in the mantle cavity during aerial exposure. The behavioural differences and the subsequent biochemical and physiological adaptations between littoral epifaunal and infaunal bivalves pose a few interesting questions. Although the respiratory system of bivalves is characteristic of aquatic life, several epifaunal bivalve species, such as M . edulis, M . demissus, M . californianus, M . galloprovincialis, and also C. edule, are capable of utilizing atmospheric oxygen and may, during aerial exposure, obtain part of their energy requirement by aerobic respiration (Moon and Pritchard, 1970; Boyden, 1972a,b; Coleman, 1973; Bayne el al., 1976a,b; Bayne and Livingstone, 1977; Widdows et al., 1979). In infaunal species such as C. glaucum, S. plana, and M . arenaria, the opportunity for aerial respiration is reduced by the restricted atmospheric contact and the potentially anoxic conditions prevailing in the interstitial mud (Brafield, 1964). In these species there will thus be a far greater need for anaerobic respiration to sustain basal metabolism, either during exposure at low tides which results in the cessation of pumping activity or when exposed to other environmental stress conditions, such as saiinity or pollutants. These may induce valve closure and anaerobiosis in all bivalves, except those such as M . modiolus which appears unable to maintain valve closure. Moreover, among species shown to utilize atmospheric oxygen during exposure at low tides, differences in biochemical and physiological adaptations do exist in response to exposure at low tides. For example, M . edulis responds to aerial exposure by maintaining a tighter control over its valve gape than C . edule and M . demissus (Kuenzler, 1961; Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Boyden, 1972a,b; Coleman, 1973; Widdows et al., 19791, and this is reflected in the increase in aerial rate of oxygen uptake in Cardium and Modiolus compared with Mytilus (Table 111). This is also associated with greater need for utilizing anaerobic pathways in M . edulis, with subsequent greater accumulation of end products in the tissues than in C. edule (Widdows et al., 1979). The accessibility of the tissues of Cardium and Myrilus to atmospheric I4CO2, and hence to atmospheric oxygen during air exposure, has been investi-
TAESLE 111. COMPARISON OF BEHAVIORAL RESPONSES A N D ABILITYTO UTILIZE ATMOSPHERIC OXYGEN DURING EXPOSURE AT Low TIDEIN SOMEBIVALVE MOLLUSCS~ Species
Zone
Habitat
Valve activity
Oxygen utilization
Aquatic rate
Anaerobiosis demonstrated
Reference
M . edulis
Littoral
Epifaunal
Closure with a small gape
+
4-6%
+
Coleman and Trueman (1971); Coleman (1974); Bayne and Livingstone (1977); Widdows et al. (1979)
M . californianus
Littoral
Epifaunal
Closure with a small gape
+
74%
+
Moon and Pritchard (1970); Bayne et al. (1976b)
M . galloprovincialis
Littoral
Epifaunal
Closure with a small gape
+
11-17%
+
Widdows et al. (1979)
M. demissus
Littoral
Epifaunal
Closure with a controlled wide gape
+
56-65%
+
Kuenzler (1961); Lent (1968, 1969); Widdows et al. (1979)
I. alatus
Littoral
Epifaunal
Closure with a controlled wide gape
M . modiolus
Sublittoral
Epifaunal
Unable to maintain valve closure
C . edule
Littoral
Surface infaunal
Wide shell gape
C. glaucum
Littoral
Surface infaunal
Closure
M . arenaria
Littoral
Deep infaunal
S. plana
Littoral
Deep infaunal
Symbols:
+, shown to occur; -,
t
+?
Trueman and Lowe (1971)
Coleman and Trueman (1971); Coleman (1976)
+
+
Boyden (1972a,b); Widdows et al. (1979)
+
Boyden (1972a,b)
Closure
+?
Collip (1920, 1921); Dam (1935); Dicks (1972); Earll (1975a)
Closure
+?
Earll (1975a,b); Akberali er al. (1977)
-
shown not to occur; +?, not shown, but likely.
28-78%
128
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
gated by Ahmad and Chaplin (1977). They showed that C. edule is more efficient than M . edulis at incorporating 14C02into its tissues, which is in part a reflection on the wider shell gape of Cardium during exposure to low tides. Furthermore, in M . edulis a greater proportion of the total radioactivity was recovered from anaerobic end products such as succinate than in C . edule (Ahmad and Chaplin, 1977). These authors concluded that Mytilus uses anaerobiosis to a greater extent than Cardium. At present, it is not known whether such differences exist between epifaunal and infaunal species in their capacity for anaerobic respiration.
E. EfJPct of Subthreshold Levels on Behaviour Marine bivalve molluscs are frequently exposed to a range of sublethal levels of environmental stresses such as salinity, temperature, oxygen, and pollutants. The adverse effects of environmental stress on aquatic organisms including bivalve molluscs have been generally identified with their acute and lethal impact. Mortality is an end point that can be readily recognized and quantified; hence the standard assay for acute toxicity testing of pollutants in aquatic organisms measures the particular stress condition or concentration that causes 50% mortality over a standard period of time (LCso). It is evident that death is a very crude index of stress in the environment, and that sublethal effects can be induced at much lower levels than the LC5,,. While not directly resulting in death, sublethal effects can affect survival through effects on behaviour, growth, physiology, and reproduction (Bayne et al., 1978, 1979, 1981; Viarengo et al., 1980b; Lowe et al., 1982; Calabrese et al., 1984). The ultimate test of significance of a sublethal effect of environmental stress is whether it has an impact on the propagation of a species and on its population (Waldichuk, 1979; Bayne et al., 1979, 1981). However, as Perkins (1979) has pointed out, the demonstration of a sublethal effect is often of limited use because the ecological significance of a change in the measured parameter is usually not established. The lower the level at which the effect is demonstrated, the more difficult it is to translate it into a meaningful ecological observation. Behavioural modification is one of the most sensitive indicators of environmental stress and may directly affect survival (Eisler, 1979). Available literature on bivalve behavioural response to stress is limited, but studies (Perkin, 1979; Eisler, 1979; Olla et al., 1983) carried out in the recent past indicate that sublethal effects on bivalve behaviour may give some insight into the observed physiological, biochemical, and reproductive responses.
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
129
A behavioural avoidance mechanism to adverse environmental conditions has been shown to occur commonly in bivalves, and existing evidence indicates that below the sublethal threshold level the animal is capable of interacting with the environment. For example, it has been shown that siphonal and valve closure in M . edulis and S . plana is triggered at salinities of 25 and 20%0,respectively (Davenport, 1979; Akberali and Davenport, 1981). This implies that a drop from the normal salinity (32%0)to the respective salinities in these two species can be described as sublethal. Similarly, Akberali and Black (1980) and Akberali et al. (1981) have shown that S . plana interacts with 0.01-0.05 ppm copper and 0.10.5 ppm zinc in sea water. It is only when the organisms are subjected to a more extreme salinity or pollutant level that the behavioural avoidance mechanism is mediated. The present evidence indicates that during sublethal exposure, bivalve molluscs interact with stressors which may have long-term effects on metabolic processes. For example, sublethal stresses have been demonstrated to affect the behavioural and metabolic processes of bivalves in various ways. Both depth and rate of burrowing ofjuvenile hard clam M . mercenaria was affected by oil-contaminated sediments (Olla et al., 1983). These authors suggest that such effects indicated avoidance behaviour rather than oil-induced debilitation and may increase the vulnerability of this species to predation. McGreer (1979) studied the burrowing behaviour of the estuarine clam Macoma balthica in response to sublethal levels of mercury and cadmium. A correlation was found between higher concentration levels and decreased burrowing speed which was attributed to a behavioural avoidance mechanism. Similar effects on burrowing behaviour in the clam Protothaca (Phelps et d . , 1983) and in Venerupis decussata (Stephenson and Taylor, 1975) have been reported for copper in the sediment, the burrowing time being increased logarithmically with greater sediment copper concentrations. It has also been reported that sublethal levels of heavy metals decrease filtration rates in bivalve molluscs (Watling, 1981). In M . edulis, a 50% reduction in filtration rate was found at concentrations of only 0.04 ppm mercury, 0.15 ppm copper, and 1.6 ppm zinc (Abel, 1976). The rate of oxygen consumption of excised gill tissue of Crassostrea virginica showed a significant increase when continuously exposed to sublethal levels of 50 and 100 ppb copper (Engel and Fowler, 1979). The most obvious difference occurred after 14 days' exposure to 100 ppb copper, by which time the tissue concentration of copper had reached 0.8 pg/mg (dry wt). Robinson et al. (1984) have shown that in the surf clam Spisula solidissima, turbidity levels >100 mg/l of attapulgite clay resulted in a significant increase of pseudofaecal production and a
130
H . B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
decrease in the amount of algal food actually ingested. They have concluded that anthropogenic turbidity-producing discharges at low levels can possibly cause adverse effects on the energetics of surf clam populations. It has also been reported that continuous exposure to sublethal levels of copper and zinc suppresses gametogenesis in adult M . edulis, with copper being more toxic (Maung-Myint and Tyler, 1982).
F. Effect of Temperature on Heart Rate
It is apparent in many investigations (Pickens, 1965; Trueman and Lowe, 1971; Lowe and Trueman, 1972; Coleman, 1972, 1974; Davenport and Carrion-Cotrina, 1981) that heart rate is markedly affected by temperature. Increase in temperature leads to a rise in heart rate and a decrease in temperature results in a fall in heart rate in an intact M . edulis (Fig. 11). There is an almost linear relationship with a heart rate of 30 beats/min at 10°C decreasing to 3 beats/min at - 13°C (Davenport and Carrion-Cotrina, 1981). In the bivalve S. solidissima, an increase in temperature is associated with an increase in heart rate and vice versa (De Fur and Mangum, 1979). Similarly, in the freshwater Ligumia subrostrata the heart rate has been shown to be an exponential function of temperature (Dietz and Tomkins, 1980). In the bivalves M . arenaria and Crassostrea gigas, rapid temperature change also brings about an immediate response
I
0
n J '20
*10
0
-5
Temperature VC)
FIG. 11. M. edulis: effect of temperature on heart rate. Norwegian mussels (O), Welsh mussels (0) (from Davenport and Carrion-Cotrina, 1981).
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
131
in heart rate (Lowe, 1974). In both these species, heart rate is dependent on the temperature of the bathing fluid, but during sudden changes of temperature there is significant relationship between heart rate and mantle cavity temperature, and it has been suggested by Lowe (1974) that thermoreceptors, possibly in the mantle tissue, play an important role with respect to the immediate response to temperature change. A number of examples of perfect, partial, and nonexistent acclimation of seasonal variation in heart rate have been described in the mussels M. californianus and M . edulis by Pickens (1965). He suggested that these results might be accounted for by considering the effects of condition, in particular the reproductive state and food availability on a seasonal basis. Widdows (1973), in a closely controlled experiment, confirmed many of the results obtained by Pickens (1965). Using M. edulis he studied the effects of acclimation on heart rate, oxygen consumption, and pumping rates, and the effect of starvation. M. edulis acclimated at a set temperature was transferred to higher or lower temperatures and showed examples of both partial and complete acclimation in terms of oxygen consumption and pumping rate. Bayne et al. (1973) have also reported that the acclimation of these functions varies consistently on a seasonal basis. Heart rate, however, shows no acclimation in the long term and remains dependent upon ambient water temperature. Heart rate has been used as a measure of temperature acclimation in a number of poikilothermic animals such as M. edulis and M . californianus (Pickens, 1965; Widdows, 1973). Perfect acclimation of heart rate to temperature alone was not evident in either of these species and consequently seasonal changes in heart rate were attributed to other factors. Widdows (1973) found that starvation of M. edufis produced a 35% reduction in heart rate over 9 days, emphasizing the point that in the field, heart rate may depend not only on the ambient water temperature but also on the nutritive and reproductive state of animals. In addition, temperature has been shown to affect burrowing behaviour in the tropical surf clam D . denticulatus (Trueman, 1971, 1983a; Ansell and Trueman, 1973) and in D . serru (McLachlan and Young, 1982). Environmental variables, especially temperature, do affect patterns of activity on a seasonal basis, and some species, such as M . mercenaria, show a reduction in the duration of active periods (Loosanoff, 1939) and shell deposition (Panella and McClintock, 1968; Jones et al., 1983) with seasonal fall in temperature. A similar reduction in activity was found in A. cygnea (Salanki et al., 1974; Parker, 1978), although short-term fluctuations in temperature, which were equivalent to natural daily variation, appeared to have a minimal effect on periodic activity.
132
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
111. A.
Detection of Stress
The Signijicance of Registering Changes in the Environment
Many bivalve molluscs, when exposed to lethal levels of environmental stress, rely on behavioural mechanisms which enable them to avoid contact with such conditions (see Section 11, Behavioral Responses to Stress). Mobile species have the ability to move away from regions of potentially harmful stress conditions, whereas sedentary species possess behavioural mechanisms such as burrowing into the substratum, retracting into existing burrows, or closing of valves. In employing such mechanisms for osmotic control in response to salinity fluctuations and in avoiding harmful effects of pollutants, bivalve molluscs must therefore be capable of detecting changes in the environment and implementing the appropriate response. The immediate detection of environmental changes is essential for the success of any protective response. This applies at both the commencement and the termination of stress so as to allow feeding to be resumed immediately on the removal of the stress. Detection of changes in the environment by bivalves is particularly important with respect to distinguishing between sublethal and lethal levels and eliciting appropriate behavioural responses to lethal levels. Occurrence of environmental stress is often intermittent, being affected by the duration of tidal cycles, currents, and variable freshwater runoff. These factors are particularly relevant in intertidal and estuarine conditions. Reference should be made to the detailed review by Davenport (1982) on environmental simulation experiments. Bivalve molluscs such as S . plana, M . edulis, C. edule, and 0. edulis have been shown to accumulate heavy metals in their tissues far in excess of the environmental levels (Phillips, 1977; Bryan, 1979; Bryan and Gibbs, 1983; Viarengo et al., 1981; Calabrese et al., 1984). Tissue concentrations in S . plana at Restrongnet Creek (Cornwall) show a wide variation in metal ion concentration. The highest concentrations of 7270, 101, and 25 pg/g (dry wt) for zinc, copper, and manganese, respectively, occurred in the digestive gland, whereas highest iron concentration of 2051 pg/g (dry wt) was found in the mantle and siphons (Bryan and Gibbs, 1983). Such differences in tissue concentration in relation to various heavy metals and also between different localities have been reported in numerous studies involving bivalve molluscs. Akberali and Black (1980) and Akberali et al. (1981) have shown that S . plana avoids levels of 100-500 pgfl (0.1-0.5 ppm) and > 5000 pg/l (> 5 ppm) of copper and zinc concentration, respectively, by prolonged valve
EFFECTS O F STRESS ON MARINE BlVALVE MOLLUSCS
133
closure and thus protects the tissues from the presence of these heavy metals. However, at concentrations below these levels the clams continue to interact with the pollutant after an initial valve closure response. This response to lower concentrations in S. plana, which is probably similar to other bivalves, implies that bivalves may discriminate between toxic and nontoxic effects of heavy metals. It is important to emphasize that the high tissue levels of heavy metals, for example copper and zinc, in Scrobicularia could only have accumulated from heavy metals associated with particulate food or in solution in the ambient medium at subthreshold levels. The temporary incidence of lethal levels could be avoided by valve closure and would not lead to accumulation in the tissues. It has been rightly pointed out, in Scrobicularia for example, that bivalves would avoid the worst of conditions by deposit feeding when sediment metal contamination is low and suspension feeding when dissolved metal level is low (Bryan and Gibbs, 1983). It has also been shown that osmoconforming bivalves such as M . edulis and S. plana minimize osmotic stress when exposed to low external salinities of short-term duration by isolating their tissues and body fluids from the water to a considerable extent (Shumway, 1977; Davenport, 1979; Akberali and Davenport, 1981). In M . edulis this is achieved by siphon and shell valve closure at a salinity of about 25%0, while S . plana closes and retracts the siphons at about 20%0 (Fig. 12). This implies that the behavioural avoidance mechanism was triggered at a lower external salinity level, the difference being 7 and 12%0in M . edulis and S. plana, respectively, indicating that a fluctuation in the media of this magnitude
Minutes
FIG.12. Shell valve recordings from anterior (a) and posterior (b) part of normal Scrobicularia subjected to a decline and rise in salinity of the external medium (graph below). Op, open, C1, closed (from Akberali and Davenport, 1981).
I34
H . 0. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
can be tolerated without serious consequences. In both M. edulis and S . plana, closure of the exhalant siphon, which prevents pumping, was the crucial event in largely isolating the mantle cavity from falling external salinities, while shell valve closure occurred at rather lower salinities, so producing almost complete isolation (Davenport, 1979; Akberali and Davenport, 1981). Even when apparently isolated, bivalves can detect favorable changes, since they respond within a short period of time, resulting in valve opening and commencement of pumping (Figs. 5 and 12). The foregoing account suggests that bivalves may distinguish between lethal and sublethal levels of pollutant or salinity stress. During periods of valve closure the animal incurs penalties, and unnecessary valve closure at sublethal levels of pollutant or salinity would be of little survival value. B. Sites of Reception In the class Bivalvia, envelopment of the body by paired valves has resulted in the reduction of the head and the role of sensory perception has been taken over by the mantle margin and siphons, which are the main sites of contact with the external environment (Dakin, 1910; Bullock and Horridge, 1965). The structure of the mantle of a number of bivalves has been described and the sensory structures developed on the middle mantle fold discussed (Yonge, 1949, 1957; Kawaguti and Ikemoto, 1962; Gilmour, 1963; Beedham and Owen, 1965; Barber et al., 1967; Land, 1968; Petit et al., 1978). Tactile sensitivity in the mantle, which is probably a feature of all bivalve mantles, has been demonstrated in M. arenaria (Pumphrey, 1938), S . solidissima (Wilson and Nystrom, 1968), Lima scubra (Stephens, 1978a), Chlamys opercularis (Stephens and Boyle, 1978), and S . plana (Hodgson, 1982; Black, 1983). In the mantle of bivalves P . maximus (Thomas and Gruyffyd, 1971) and L . scabru (Stephens, 1978a) chemical sensitivity has also been reported. The application of extract from a predatory starfish onto the mantle in two species of Asaphidae (Ansell, 1967) triggered a violent escape response and caused leaping movements. The formation of siphons in bivalve molluscs involves partial or complete fusion of one or all of the mantle folds (Yonge, 1948). In some bivalves, such as C. edule, siphonal tentacles bearing eyes have been observed (Barber and Wright, 1969). Furthermore, tactile and chemical sensitivity in response to stimuli has been reported in bivalve siphons, e.g., touching the siphons of Ensis (Trueman, 1966a), Spisula (Mellon, 1965; Prior, 1972), and Scrobiculuriu (Hodgson, 1982; Black, 1983). The isolated and in situ siphon in S . plana responds to salinity decline and
EFFECTS OF STRESS O N MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
135
presence of pollutants (Akberali, 1981; Akberali et al., 1981, 1982a,b; Akberali and Davenport, 1982). Photosensitivity of the siphon has also been reported, exposure to high light intensities causing withdrawal (Light, 1930; Kennedy, 1960). In M. edulis it has been shown that salinity detection is carried out peripherally by salt-sensitive receptors on the tentaculate portion of the inhalant siphon (Davenport, 1981). In S. plana the sensory structures are more deeply situated, and it is thought that salinity or zinc detection is mediated by the central nervous system rather than by any peripheral neural network within the siphon (Akberali et al., 1981; Akberali and Davenport, 1981,1982). In none of these studies, however, have the sense organs been located or described structurally, and the areas of sensitivity are based on experimental studies related to observations, ablation, or isolation of likely sensory sites, and the recording of behavioural response to a particular environmental stress. In a number of bivalves, different types of ciliary tufts occur on the mantle and siphons (Moir, 1977; Owen and McCrae, 1979; Frenkiel and Moueza, 1980; Hodgson et al., 1982; Black, 1983); they show many characteristics of sensory receptors as described by Laverack (1968). It is difficult to assign functions for the receptors from their morphological features alone, but it is possible to assign some function by comparison with receptors whose functions have been identified, or by correlating receptor density in an area showing sensitivity to a particular stimulus (Zylstra, 1972). It has been shown in S. plana that the siphons have a higher density of ciliary tufts than the mantle, and this may explain a greater response of the inhalant siphon to chemical stimulation than the mantle (Black, 1983). It is likely that, in the mantle and siphons of bivalves, at least some of the different types of ciliary tufts are sensory and are the mechano- and chemoreceptors. The possibility of the cruciform muscle complex in S . plana functioning as a chemoreceptor has been suggested by Odiete (1978), who recorded a burst of electrical activity from this structure when the clam was exposed to “foul water.” There is some evidence that the cruciform muscle complex in Scrobiculuria is involved in the siphonal withdrawal response to changing salinity (Akberali and Davenport, 1982) and zinc ions (Akberali el al., 1981). Ablation of the cruciform muscle complex in Scrobicularia when exposed to changing salinity or zinc ions resulted in the siphonal withdrawal response being delayed or weakened (Figs. 17, 21, and 22). The withdrawal response was not, however, totally abolished, suggesting that receptors in other areas, such as mantle and siphons, were still functioning. In other Tellinacean bivalves, such as Donax trunculus (Moueza
136
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R . TRUEMAN
and Frenkiel, 1974; Frenkiel, 1980), it has been reported that the cruciform muscle complex functions not as a chemoreceptor but as a vibration receptor (Pichon et al., 1980). Studies using electrophysiological techniques have shown tactile and chemical sensitivity in the mantle edge of the bivalves L . scabra and Aequipecten (Stephens, 1978a,b). Afferent impulse activity in nerves innervating peripheral sensory regions of S. plana in response to tactile and chemical stimulation has also been demonstrated (Hodgson, 1982; Black, 1983). The visceral ganglion in Scrobicularia is involved in controlling adductor muscle rhythms (Odiete, 1976a,b; Black, 1983) and also in the withdrawal of the in situ siphon in response to decline in salinity (Fig. 17). Activity generated in the posterior adductor muscle nerve in response to tactile or chemical stimulation of peripheral regions may lead to valve adduction in the intact clam. Furthermore, Black (1983) has shown that, in Scrobicularia, the mantle and siphons possess chemoreceptors that respond to the presence of zinc. In mantle nerves, the electrical response to zinc or to tactile stimulation was less than that of the siphons, and she suggested that this may be either related to the mantle nerves being of smaller diameter than the siphonal nerves, to the number of chemoreceptors present in each site, or to their firing threshold. Black (1983) also made the important observation that the threshold for response in the lower mantle nerve was 2-3 ppm zinc, whereas for the inhalant siphon nerve it was less than 1 ppm. This finding is in close agreement with previously reported studies on the behavioural and inhalant siphon responses of S . plana to zinc, where 1 ppm zinc was the lowest concentration tested to cause a temporary reduction in heart rate, siphon contraction, and valve closure (Akberali et al., 1981). The thresholds for the exhalant siphon and mantle were higher than the inhalant siphon, which may reflect the lesser importance of these sites for chemoreception in the natural habitat (Black, 1983). Valve closure provides a useful behavioural avoidance mechanism during exposure to adverse environments (see Section II,A), but the site of perception has been less thoroughly investigated. In a few bivalve molluscs, including S . pluna, ciliated tufts on the mantle and siphons resemble sensory receptors and are probably involved as mechano- or chemoreceptors. Their stimulation may then elicit siphonal withdrawal and valve closure as a general stress avoidance response.
C. Detection and Response to Environmental Changes There have been few studies on mechanical and chemical detection in bivalve molluscs. From the literature, it is apparent that among marine
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
137
invertebrates there is no common mechanism for registering environmental changes. Studies on certain mobile species such as gastropod molluscs (Blandford and Little, 1983), crustaceans (Gross, 1957; Lagerspetz and Mattila, 1961; McLusky, 1970; Thomas e? al., 198l), and annelids (Janson, 1962) indicate that, when subjected to a choice of different salinities, these organisms are capable of detecting and discriminating salinity levels. In sedentary species such as bivalve molluscs, the underlying basis of salinity detection has been investigated by exposing animals to artificial sea waters of differing ionic and osmotic composition and observing the effect on behaviour (Davenport, 1979, 1981 ; Akberali and Davenport, 1981, 1982). In both mobile and sedentary species, salinity detection depends on the concentration of particular ions (Barnes, 1939, 1940; Davenport, 1981; Akberali and Davenport, 1982; Black, 1983), the osmotic pressure of the medium (Davenport, 1972; Bettison and Davenport, 1976; Blandford and Little, 1983), or to the combination of both (Barnes and Barnes, 1958). S. plana is an osmoconforming bivalve in which valve closure is mediated by detection of change in osmotic pressure, and not by measurement of any ionic constituent (Freeman and Rigler, 1956). Akberali and Davenport (1982) showed that siphon withdrawal is triggered by a change in groups of ions such as sodium, magnesium, calcium, and chloride (Fig. 13) rather than by changes in the gross osmotic pressure (Figs. 14 and 15)
-
i
MINUTES
FIG.13. The effects of exposure to NaC1, MgCI2, and CaClz followed by a salinity regime (graph below) on (a) an in siru Scrobicutnria siphon preparation in which the downward deflection of the trace represents isotonic siphon contraction [note the effect of a mechanical stimulus (s) applied by pinching with forceps] and on (b) intact mussels in which the horizontal bar represents activity: open sections, gaping; closed (black) portions, closed valves. The “ionic test medium” regime description represents an alteration from 0% (when animals were supplied solely with sea water of salinity 32%0)to 100% (when animals were supplied with pure “ionic test medium”) (from Akberali and Davenport, 1982).
138
H . B . AKBERALI AND E. R . TRUEMAN
-
-a
b
6
lb
1’5
2b
25 3b MINUTES
35
do
45
50 i
FIG.14. The effects of exposure to two test media, the first containing NaCI, MgC12,and CaCI2, the second containing NaCl alone: response of (a) an in situ Scrobiculan‘a siphon preparation and (b) of intact mussels: details as in Fig. 13, except that the “NaCI only” regime description represents an alteration from 0% (when animals were supplied solely with “ionic test medium” regime) to 100% (when animals were supplied with pure “NaCl only”) (from Akberali and Davenport, 1982).
or in the concentration of a single ion (Fig. 14). Similarly, in M . edulis, both siphon withdrawal and valve closure (Akberali and Davenport, 1982) and the opening reaction (Davenport, 1981) are mediated by a group of ions such as sodium, magnesium, and chloride rather than by changes in the osmotic pressure or in the concentration of a single ion (Figs. 13-15). Siphon withdrawal and valve closure in S . plana and valve closure in M . edulis are different with respect to the presence of one ion. In order to prevent siphon withdrawal and valve closure in Scrobiculariu, the presence of sodium, magnesium, calcium, and chloride is necessary, whereas in M . edulis valve closure can be prevented by the presence of only sodium, magnesium, and chloride (Figs. 14 and 15). The reasons underlying these differences in calcium ion specificity are not clear. They may be due to differences in the type of habitat occupied or to a variety of ionic and osmotic mechanisms of salinity detection of animals within the same class (Bettison and Davenport 1976). There is as yet no sign of coherent evolutionary or physiological pattern. This calcium dependency requirement for the closing response in S . plana with respect to salinity changes, and its absence from M . edulis, may reflect an additional physiological requirement in the former species. Both species use behavioural mechanisms to avoid salinity variations (Davenport, 1979; Akberali and Davenport, 1981). S. plana, however, has two long, mobile, and highly extensible siphons, whereas in the epifaunal M . edulis the siphons are of negligible length. In Scrobiculariu siphonal contractions are dependent on the presence of calcium ions in the external
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
139
4 7 0 m M NaCl a
h
NaCI.CaCI9
CholineCI.CaCl2. MgC12
h
b
010
d
MINUTES
FIG. 15. The effects of various test media on in situ Scrobicukuriu siphon preparations (a) and intact mussels (b); details as in Fig. 13. The graph at the bottom indicates percentage concentration (CONC.) change for ail media (from Akberali and Davenport, 1982).
medium (see Section VI,B), and this may reflect the requirement of calcium ions for detection of falling external salinities. The opening response of S. p l u m to rising salinities has been shown to be dependent on sodium, magnesium, and chloride ions, but the presence of calcium is not required (Black, 1983). In M. edulis, both the closing response to falling salinities and the opening response to rising salinities rely on the presence of the identical ions (Davenport, 1981; Akberali and Davenport, 1982). In M. edulis the salinity-sensitive receptors lie on the tentaculate portion of the inhalant siphon (Davenport, 1981). Therefore, when the mussels are open
140
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
and pumping, the water entering the mantle cavity will be continuously monitored near the margins of the valves so that any behavioural reaction to adverse media will result in negligible exchange between the mantle fluid and the external medium. It has been reported that the opening response to rising salinities is mediated by changes in electrochemical gradients due to the diffusion of salts to the tentaculate portion of the inhalant siphon and not to any other portion of the mantle edge or to any more deeply located structures (Davenport, 1981). Such a diffusion of salts to the salinity-sensitive region can easily be achieved in an epifaunal species even when the valves are closed, since valve closure does not always provide complete isolation. The existence of fine passageways between the mantle margins may allow salt diffusion. An epifaunal bivalve mollusc can thus continuously monitor the environment. In the infaunal S. plana when open and pumping, as in M . edulis, the water entering the clam will be registered by the salinity-sensitive region and accordingly trigger the behavioral avoidance mechanism when conditions become unfavourable. Once siphons are retracted and valves closed, an infaunal species cannot rely on salt diffusion gradients from interstitial water. These would not give a realistic assessment of conditions in the water column, since interstitial salinities of estuarine muds tend to be high and relatively stable (Kinne, 1971). In the natural habitat during exposure at low tide Scrobicularia does not withdraw its siphons into the shell, nor are the valves completely closed; the siphons are just withdrawn to the entrance of the burrow and the clam stops pumping (Earll, 1975a,b). It is possible that this behaviour allows periodic sampling by opening the siphonal apertures and drawing in small amounts of the external medium. In doing so the clam is at risk by the introduction of the stressor into the mantle cavity, and whether such a strategy is actually adopted by infaunal bivalves is not yet clear. Another alternative would be to locate sensory structures at the siphonal tips and along the entire length of the siphon so that loss of the tips by predation (Edwards and Steele, 1968) would not deprive the organism of its sensory structures. The isolated inhalant siphon of S . plana (Fig. 16) does not respond to dilute sea water, indicating that salinity detection either does not occur in the siphon or is mediated by the central nervous system (Fig. 17) rather than by any peripheral neural network. The dependency of the closing and opening response of M . edulis to sodium, magnesium, and chloride ions (Davenport, 1981; Akberali and Davenport, 1982) is hardly surprising since these ions make up the bulk of the salt content of sea water. It is possible that adequate concentrations of sodium and magnesium for ATPase activity, probably involved in the neural control of the gaping response, are also important. In S. plana;
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
141
ISOLATED SIPHON
OJ
0
I
Ib
do
5; $0 215 MINUTES FIG.16. Effects of salinity decline (graph below) on an isolated and an in situ pieparation of Scrobiculuria: the downward deflection of the traces represents isotonic siphon contraction; mechanical stimulus (s) applied by pinching with forceps (from Akberali and Davenport, 1982). 5
calcium is an added requirement for the closing response (Akberali and Davenport, 1982), but it is not required for the opening response (Black, 1983). The reason for this difference may be related to the dependence of the siphonal contraction on this ion (Akberali et ul., 1982a). Future work is required on other infaunal and epifaunal bivalve molluscs to elucidate this interesting phenomenon and to indicate whether calcium ions are an added physiological requirement in infaunal species for the contraction of the long extensible siphons. It must be understood throughout that the metal ions referred to in the text are those forms of inorganic metallic salts tested in sea water without taking into account the form of metal ions in solution. Behavioural avoidance mechanism in response to the presence of copper and zinc have been reported in both S. p l u m (Akberali and Black, 1980; Akberali ef a/., 1981) and M . edulis (Manley and Davenport, 1979; Davenport, 1977). These studies have also shown how quickly the animal responds to the removal of the pollutant, by the valves opening and pumping commencing (Fig. 5). The first visible response to changes in salinity or presence of pollutant in S. plana and M . edulis is the closure of the siphonal aperture, followed
I42
H . B. AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN VISCERAL GANGLFIO ~-
~~~
~
.
'a CRUCIFORM MUSCLE
FOOT
?(I) El6 3
2
]
-
v
0 0
5
I
I
I
1
@
10
15
20
25
30
MINUTES
FIG.17. The effects of ablation of the visceral ganglion, cruciform muscle complex, foot (including pedal ganglion), or gills upon the response of in situ Scrobiculuviu siphon preparations to a fall in salinity; for other details see Fig. 16 (from Akberali and Davenport, 1982).
by siphonal withdrawal and valve closure. This led Akberali (1981) to examine the direct effects of copper on the isolated inhalant siphon of S. plana to investigate the possibility that the behavioural response observed in the intact clam may be due to the detection of copper by the siphons. The isolated siphon reacts to the presence of copper with a series of spontaneous contractions (Fig. 18). The copper concentrations were close to those found to trigger the behavioural avoidance response in the intact clam. Similarly, Akberali et ul. (1981) showed that the intact clam avoids lethal zinc concentrations by behavioural avoidance mechanisms and that zinc has no effect on the isolated siphon (Fig. 19). In an in situ siphon
143
EFFECTS OF STRESS O N MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Time ( m i d
FIG.18. S. plana: Effects of addition of copper on an isolated inhalant siphon preparation. Upward deflection of the trace indicates isotonic siphonal contraction. The following experimental protocol was carried out in sequence: appropriate volume of stock copper solution (10 ppm copper nitrate) in normal sea water was added to give 0.25 ppm at (a) and 0.5 ppm at (b); removal of sea water containing 0.5 ppm copper (c), followed by washes (w) and replacement with normal sea water (d). Copper was added again to give a final concentration of 0.25 ppm (a’) and 0.5 ppm (b’) (from Akberali, 1981).
preparation where the clam is intact except for removal of one shell valve, the siphon reacts in a manner similar to that in the intact clam (Fig. 20). This led to the suggestion that zinc is registered by sensory structures on the mantle and ablation of the sensory cruciform muscle complex partially abolishes the in situ siphonal withdrawal response (Akberali et al., 1981) (Fig. 21). The possibility that the cruciform muscle complex in Scrobicularia has a chemoreceptive function has been suggested by Graham (1934), Yonge (1949), Moueza and Frenkiel (1974), and Odiete (1978); it appears to have a multiple function, facilitating siphonal movement vibration reception and acting as a chemoreceptor. However, as shown by Akberali et al. (1981) and Akberali and Davenport (1981, 1982), it is evident that ablation of the cruciform muscle complex affects the behavioural avoidance mechanisms to some extent but does not completely abolish the response to salinity decline (Figs. 17 and 22) or to the presence of zinc (Fig. 21). This suggests the possibility that the cruciform muscle complex together with other parts of the mantle lobes or siphons or ganglia may be involved.
t-httrmii i i i i i : : , , : <
0
10
20
t i i i i i j t
30
i i i i i i i : i i : i : ,
40
, i : i
i
50
i i i : : i : : i i bl’t-ti,
60
4-
70
f t 1
I
80
Minutes
FIG.19. Effects of various zinc and copper concentrations on an isolated inhalant siphon preparation of S. plann. Upward deflection of the trace indicates isotonic contraction of the inhalant siphon. The following experimental protocol was carried out in sequence: application of zinc at the final concentrations indicated (4)and removal of sea water containing 10 ppm zinc (C), followed by washes (w) and replacement with normal sea water (D). Prior to copper applications (J), the siphonal response was tested by a mechanical stimulus (s) (from Akberali et a / . , 1981).
1
+ +
I44
H. B. AKBERALI AND E. R. TRUEMAN
0
10
20
30 Minutes
50
40
FIG.20. Effects of various zinc concentrations on an in situ inhalant siphon preparation of
S.plana. Upward deflection of the trace indicates isotonic contraction of the siphon. The following experimental protocol was camed out in sequence: application of zinc at the final concentrations indicated (J) and removal of sea water containing 10 ppm zinc (C), followed by washes (w) and replacement with normal sea water (D), then mechanical stimulus (s) (from Akberali et al., 1981).
S. plana and M. edulis clearly avoid lethal levels of copper and zinc solutions by employing behavioural avoidance mechanisms, and are capable of discriminating sublethal levels. This response in Scrobicularia has also been demonstrated recently using other metal ions (Black, 1983). Black showed that silver and mercury cause siphon withdrawal and complete valve closure, whereas partial valve closure was observed in the presence of nickel and cobalt. The behaviour was least affected when Scrobiculuria were exposed to manganese, cadmium, or chromium (tri- or hexavalent forms). Observed differences in the behavioural responses of
* 0
20
10 Minutes
30
Frc. 21. Effects of various zinc concentrations on in situ inhalant siphon preparations of
S.plana. Arrows (1) mark the application of zinc stock solution to give the indicated concentrations. X, cutting of the cruciform muscle complex before addition of 10 ppm zinc; (A and B) Two examples of the recordings observed; s, mechanical stimulation (from Akberali et a / . , 1981).
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
145
I
CI
OJ I
0
20
I
I
40
I
I
I
I
60 80 Minutes
I
I
100
I
I
I
120
FIG.22. Shell valve recordings from anterior (a) and posterior (b) part of a specimen of S. plunu, with its cruciform muscle complex destroyed by making a median longitudinal incision through the muscle and then subjected to a decline and rise in salinity of the external medium (graph below). Op, Open; C1, closed (from Akberali and Davenport, 1981).
Scrobicularia can also be related to the toxicity of each metal ion over longer exposure periods. Black (1983) found that those metals which evoked closure responses were also acutely toxic to S . plana during prolonged exposures (median lethal time, ca. 1-7 days), whereas metal ions that did not cause complete valve closure had low toxic effects over a similar period of time. The isolated siphonal preparation of S. pfana was also used to test the effects of copper, zinc, cadmium, nickel, manganese, chromium (tri- or hexavalent), silver, and mercury (Black, 1983). Only copper was effective in causing spontaneous contractions of the isolated siphon, which is dependent on the presence of calcium ions in the external medium (Akberali et al., 1982a). The possible mode of action of copper is discussed later (Section V1,D). At present, it is not clear why copper, of all the metal ions studied so far, has this ability to induce contractions in the isolated inhalant siphon. Recent studies, using isolated myogenic heart of the land snail Helix aspersa, have shown that low copper concentrations induced continuous tonic contraction, whereas zinc does not have this effect (Akberali, unpublished). It is not known whether the direct effect of copper on the isolated siphon forms the basis of siphon withdrawal in the avoidance response of the intact animal or whether it acts in the same manner as other metal ions, through sensory reception sites. The evi-
146
H . B. AKBERALI AND E. R . TRUEMAN
dence so far indicates that the bivalve Scrobicularia is able to detect the presence of metal ions and discriminate potentially lethal levels.
IV. A.
Respiratory Physiology during Stress Valve Closure and Cessation of Aerobic Processes
Periods of valve closure are commonly associated with behavioural inactivity and cessation of pumping activity. The most obvious effects of this are limitation of time available for feeding and consequent reduced growth potential, cessation of aerobic respiration, and accumulation of excretory products. Despite these penalties, the behavioural avoidance strategy of bivalve molluscs is of great survival value. There is, however, a limit to the time an animal can remain isolated from the environment, depending on its overall physiological and biochemical condition and the adaptive mechanisms to sustain the basal metabolic processes. Such mechanisms will include the utilization of anaerobic respiration to sustain basal metabolism, availability of stored food reserves, and the ability to tolerate and accommodate levels of excretory products.
B. Relationship between Heart Rate, Valve Movements, P O ? ,and PC02 Numerous studies (Trueman, 1967; Coleman, 1974; Earll, 1975b; Brand, 1976; Akberali er al., 1981) have shown that the effect of valve closure on heart rate in bivalve molluscs is bradycardia, which may be associated with the depletion of oxygen tension in the mantle cavity. Oxygen depletion in the mantle cavity of M. californianus is rapid when the valves are clamped shut, falling from 115 mmHg to 20 mmHg O2 in 20 min or less (Moon and Pritchard, 1970). Similar rapid depletion of the oxygen in the mantle cavity of A . islandica (Brand and Taylor, 1974),S . plana (Akberali and Trueman, 1979), M. edulis (Davenport, 1979), and A. cygnea (Parker, 1978) has been reported. It is possible, as Bayne (1971) suggests, that the rapid fall of oxygen tension in the mantle cavity could account for the rapid bradycardia shown by M. edulis. Earll (1975a,b) considered why S . plana, of all the bivalve species investigated, alone shows a marked temporal variation in heart rate which is dependent upon pumping (Fig. 3). A number of factors may be responsible. The heart rate is reduced when the clam is subjected to reduced oxygen tensions. A high weight-specific oxygen consumption (Hughes, 1970) compared with a small mantle cavity volume would ensure an even
EFFECTS OF STRESS O N MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
147
faster depletion of mantle cavity oxygen tension than occurs in species such as A. islandica (Brand and Taylor, 1974) or the large M. arenaria which requires an average of 30 min for the heart rate to fall after the cessation of pumping (Earll, 1975a). Akberali and Trueman (1979) have examined the pattern of short-term variation in heart rate in S. plana in relation to p 0 2 and p C 0 2 changes in the mantle cavity. Samples of water were withdrawn from the mantle cavity at known heart rates (Fig. 23) and indicated that a high heart rate (16-18 beatshin, indicative of pumping) was correlated with a p 0 2value of between 140 and 160 mmHg. Decrease in heart rate to 10-13 beatshin was associated with a p 0 2 level of 80-1 10 mmHg. During activity, the p C 0 , rarely exceeded 2 mmHg, but on cessation of pumping never fell below this value. The factors causing suppression of heartbeat during inactivity are not clear. For example, Ptcsi and Salanki (1974), Brand (1976), and Parker
K
I
I" E E
O ' '
2
'
4 ' 6 .
e
' l o ' l z ' i 4
Individual Animal No.
FIG.23. Mantle cavity p O z ,pCOz, and heart rate (HR) of individual S. p l u m during active periods (0)and ventilatory pauses (0)when constantly immersed in sea water. Each point for the 14 animals during active periods is the mean of 6 determinations and each point for the 5 animals during ventilatory pauses is the mean of 4 determinations. Bars indicate SE; points for the same animal are joined by broken lines (from Akberali and Trueman, 1979).
148
H . B . AKBERALI A N D E. R. TRUEMAN
(1978) showed that bradycardia in A . cygnea and A . anatina is not merely an affect of shell closure. Schleiper (1957) suggested that bradycardia in M . edulis may be effected by a build-up of carbon dioxide, whereas Bayne (1971) postulated that depletion of oxygen within the mantle cavity of M . edulis was responsible. The factors and mechanisms of suppression of the heart during valve closure are thus largely uncertain, and further investigations are needed.
C. Anaerobic Respiration during Valve Closure It is well known that bivalves are able to withstand periods of shell closure and resultant lack of oxygen (Dugal, 1939; Trueman, 1967; Helm and Trueman, 1967; Crenshaw and Neff, 1969; Moon and Pritchard, 1970; Coleman and Trueman, 1971; Crenshaw, 1972; Akberali and Trueman, 1979; Davenport, 1979,1982; Widdows et al., 1979). The changeover from aerobic to anaerobic respiration in bivalves normally occurs when the oxygen tension of the mantle cavity falls to low levels, after the bivalve has closed its valves in response to environmental stress. Early work on this subject, reviewed by von Brand (1946), recorded a variety of species able to survive long periods in the absence of oxygen. Most of the earlier work reported for anaerobic metabolism in bivalves is based on the observation that, on return to aerobic conditions, there is a rapid rise in the rate of oxygen consumption to levels above normal (Schlieper, 1957; Moon and Pritchard, 1970; Coleman, 1973, 1974). Other authors have reported a similar “overshoot” in heart rate (Trueman, 1967; Helm and Trueman, 1967; Coleman, 1974; Earll, 1975b; Brand, 1976; Akberali, 1978; Parker, 1978; Stone, 1980). Shell closure in A . islandica is followed by an exponential decrease in the oxygen tension of the mantle cavity water and is accompanied by an initial increase in heart rate, which is then followed at lower oxygen tensions by bradycardia (Taylor, 1976a,b). On return to aerobic conditions, both the heart rate and oxygen consumption are increased to a high level but then decline gradually to normal levels. When the freshwater bivalve P . coccineum is kept out of water for 5 days, the gill tissue exhibits a well-developed oxygen debt (Badman and Chin, 1973). Crassostrea (Ishida, 1935) and M . arenaria (Collip, 1921; van Dam, 1935) exhibit a higher rate of oxygen consumption after anaerobiosis than normal. These observations have frequently been interpreted as representing an increase in circulatory and respiratory demands, associated with the repayment of an “oxygen debt” incurred during the period of anaerobiosis. In recent years, research carried out by a number of workers has led to a greater appreciation of the biochemical pathways operating in bivalve
EFFECTS OF STRESS ON MARINE BIVALVE MOLLUSCS
I49
molluscs during anaerobiosis, and has shown that these pathways differ in some ways from the classical ones described in vertebrates (Stokes and Awapara, 1968; Hochachka and Mustafa, 1972; De Zwaan and Zandee, 1972). It is now evident that many invertebrates are true facultative anaerobes, capable of surviving indefinitely in the absence of oxygen and capable of active oxidative metabolism in its presence. In these organisms, as in primeval ones that possibly arose under reducing conditions in the absence of molecular oxygen (Wald, 1964), organic substrates, instead of oxygen, are the acceptors of electrons and protons. In intertidal bivalve molluscs, Hammen (1969)