Analog Circuit Design
Michiel Steyaert • Arthur van Roermund Andrea Baschirotto Editors
Analog Circuit Design Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC
123
Editors Michiel Steyaert K.U. Leuven Department of Elektrotechniek ESAT-MICAS Kardinaal Mercierlaan 94 B-3001 Heverlee Belgium
[email protected]
Arthur van Roermund Electrical Engineering Technical University Eindhoven Mixed-signal Microelectronics Group Eindhoven Netherlands
[email protected]
Andrea Baschirotto Department of Physics University of Milan-Bicocca Milan Italy
[email protected]
ISBN 978-94-007-1925-5 e-ISBN 978-94-007-1926-2 DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 Springer Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York Library of Congress Control Number: 2011937971 © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2012 No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface
This book is part of the Analog Circuit Design series and contains contributions of the speakers of the 20th workshop on Advances in Analog Circuit Design (AACD), which was organized by KULeuven ESAT-MICAS. The workshop was held in Leuven, Belgium, from April 5 to April 7, 2011. I also would like to give my gratitude for the help to organize the workshop to Danielle Vermetten, Chris Mertens, Ben Geeraerts, Valentijn De Smedt and Hans Meyvaert. This book comprises three Parts, covering advanced analog and mixed-signal circuit design fields that are considered as very important by the circuit design community: • Low-Voltage Low-Power Data converters • Short Range Wireless Front-Ends • Power Management and DC-DC Each Part is set up with six papers from experts in the field. The aim of the AACD workshop is to bring together a group of expert designers to discuss new developments and future options. Each workshop is then followed by the publication of a book by Springer in their successful series of Analog Circuit Design. This book is number 20 in this series. The books can be seen as a reference for all people involved in analog and mixed-signal design. The full list of the previous books and topics in the series is given next. We sincerely hope that this 20th book continuous the tradition and provides a valuable contribution to our Analog Design Community. Michiel Steyaert
v
vi
Preface
The topics covered before in this series: 2010
Graz (Austria)
2009
Lund (Sweden)
2008
Pavia (Italy)
2007
Oostende (Belgium)
2006
Maastricht (The Netherlands)
2005
Limerick (Ireland)
2004
Montreux (Swiss)
2003
Graz (Austria)
2002
Spa (Belgium)
2001
Noordwijk (The Netherlands)
2000
Munich (Germany)
1999
Nice (France)
1998
Copenhagen (Denmark)
1997
Como (Italy)
Robust Design Sigma Delta Converters RFID Smart Data Converters Filters on Chip Multimode Transmitters High-speed Clock and Data Recovery High-performance Amplifiers Power Management Sensors, Actuators and Power Drivers for the Automotive and Industrial Environment Integrated PAs from Wireline to RF Very High Frequency Front Ends High-speed AD Converters Automotive Electronics: EMC Issues Ultra Low Power Wireless RF Circuits: Wide Band, Front-Ends, DACs Design Methodology and Verification of RF and Mixed-Signal Systems Low Power and Low Voltage Sensor and Actuator Interface Electronics Integrated High-Voltage Electronics and Power Management Low-Power and High-Resolution ADCs Fractional-N Synthesizers Design for Robustness Line and Bus drivers Structured Mixed-Mode Design Multi-Bit Sigma-Delta Converters Short-Range RF Circuits Scalable Analog Circuits High-Speed D/A Converters RF Power Amplifiers High-Speed A/D Converters Mixed-Signal Design PLLs and Synthesizers XDSL and other Communication Systems RF-MOST Models and Behavioural Modelling Integrated Filters and Oscillators 1-Volt Electronics Mixed-Mode Systems LNAs and RF Power Amps for Telecom RF A/D Converters Sensor and Actuator Interfaces Low-Noise Oscillators, PLLs and Synthesizers (continued)
Preface
vii
(continued) 1996 Lausanne (Swiss)
1995
Villach (Austria)
1994
Eindhoven (Netherlands)
1993
Leuven (Belgium)
1992
Scheveningen (The Netherlands)
RF CMOS Circuit Design Bandpass Sigma Delta and Other Data Converters Translineair Circuits Low-Noise/Power/Voltage Mixed-Mode with CAD tools Voltage, Current and Time References Low-Power Low-Voltage Integrated Filters Smart Power Mixed-Mode A/D Design Sensor Interfaces Communication Circuits OpAmps ADC Analog CAD
The book contains the contribution of 18 tutorials of the 20th workshop on Advances in Analog Circuit Design. Each part discusses a specific to-date topic on new and valuable design ideas in the area of analog circuit design. Each part is presented by six experts in that field and state of the art information is shared and overviewed. This book is number 20 in this successful series of Analog Circuit Design, providing valuable information and excellent overviews of • Low-Voltage Low-Power Data Converters – Chaired by Prof. Anderea Baschirotto, University of Milan-Bicocca • Short Range Wireless Front-Ends – Chaired by Prof. Arthur van Roermund, Eindhoven University of Technology • Power management and DC-DC – Chaired by Prof. M. Steyaert, Katholieke University Leuven Analog Circuit Design is an essential reference source for analog circuit designers and researchers wishing to keep abreast with the latest development in the field. The tutorial coverage also makes it suitable for use in an advanced design.
Contents
Part I
Low-Voltage Low-Power Data Converters
1
Power Minimization in ADC Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Willy Sansen
3
2
Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Boris Murmann
19
3
Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan Craninckx
4
Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta for Nanometer CMOS Technologies . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Di Giandomenico, L. Hernandez, E. Prefasi, S. Paton, A. Wiesbauer, R. Gaggl, and J. Hauptmann
39
59
5
Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs . . . . . . . Marian Verhelst, Erkan Alpman, and Hasnain Lakdawala
6
A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 K. Bult, C.-H. Lin, F. van der Goes, J. Westra, J. Mulder, Y. Lin, E. Arslan, E. Ayranci, and X. Liu
Part II 7
89
Short-Range Wireless Front-Ends
Short Range Radio Communication – Novel Applications and Their Physical Layer Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 139 William G. Scanlon
ix
x
Contents
8
Ultra Low-Power Wireless Body-Area Sensor Networks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 G. Dolmans, F. Bouwens, A. Breeschoten, B. Busze, P. Harpe, L. Huang, X. Huang, M. Konijnenburg, V. Pop, M. Vidojkovic, Y. Zhang, C. Zhou, and H. de Groot
9
Low Power RF Power Harvesting Enabling More Active Tag Functionality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163 Tim Piessens, Yves Geerts, Wim Vanacken, Eldert Geukens, Bram De Muer, Tim Butler, and Bob Hamlin
10 Low Power RF Frontend for Wireless Sensor Networks .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175 Frank Henkel, Thomas Leineweber, Mohamed Gamal El-Din, and Ralf Wilke 11 Ultra High Data Rate CMOS Front Ends . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199 Reza Mahmoudi and Arthur van Roermund 12 Extremely Wideband CMOS Circuits For Future THz Applications Lorenzo Tripodi, Marion K. Matters-Kammerer, Dave van Goor, Xin Hu, and Anders Rydberg Part III
237
Power Management and DC-DC
13 State-of-the-Art of Integrated Switching Power Converters.. . . . . . . . . . 259 Gerard Villar Piqu´e and Henk Jan Bergveld 14 Data Conversion Pulse-Width Modulators for SwitchMode Power Converter Digital Control .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283 Eduard Alarc´on, Vahid Yousefzadeh, Aleksandar Prodi´c, and Dragan Maksimovi´c 15 Advanced Power Management for Low Power Medical Applications 305 Kristof Quaegebeur and Jan Crols 16 Feedforward Control of Switching Regulators .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 321 Richard Redl 17 Device Optimization to Assess Losses and Ringing Issues in Integrated Synchronous Buck Converters .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 339 J. Roig and F. Bauwens 18 Control of Fully Integrated DC-DC Converters in CMOS . . . . . . . . . . . . 357 Tom Van Breussegem, Mike Wens, and Michiel Steyaert
Part I
Low-Voltage Low-Power Data Converters
The first part of the book deals with the design and implementation of “low-voltage low-power data-converters”. The topics have been addressed to the different dataconverter topologies, to the different implementation issues (from topology and system level down to circuit level). Moreover the presented solutions have been always analyzed in consideration of the effects of the CMOS technology scaling that reduces device analog performance but offers efficient digital signal processing for analog performance improvement. In the first paper, Willy Sansen gives an overview of the different ADC topologies, emphasizing the aspects relative the power consumption minimization. This contribution presents a good scenario of the different ADC topologies, like flash (using interpolation & folding), pipeline, SAR and Sigma-Delta, which have been introduced and compared with the data from the implementations most recently reported in literature. The second paper from Boris Murmann reviews recent developments and low-power design techniques for high-speed pipelined ADC. The fundamental operation principles are introduced, and, then, widely used low-power techniques are summarized. Finally some ideas that have been proposed in recent research publications are outlined. In the third paper Jan Craninckx discusses the advancements in SAR ADCs design, in particular for wireless transceivers application. An overview is given of recent techniques that reduce the switching power in the capacitive DAC, and as such improve the power ADC efficiency up to levels that are out of reach of the typically used pipeline architecture. Moreover, this paper discusses the chargesharing SAR ADC architecture, which proposes a new signal processing method in the charge domain that removes the often-neglected though requirements for the reference buffer. Antonio Digiandomenico et al. propose in the fourth paper low-power largebandwidth implementations of Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta ADCs, where cascaded architectures and time-encoding signal processing have been successfully applied. Two different implementations, PWM-based and VCO-based, are finally described.
2
I Low-Voltage Low-Power Data Converters
In the fifth paper, Mariam Verhelst et al. discuss digitally-assisted performance enhancement strategies to overcome ADC component mismatch limitation, otherwise addressed by increased component sizes and increased power consumption. Trade-off analysis between mismatch compensation in the analog domain (digitally assisted trimming, possibly in combination with up-scaling) vs. the digital domain (digital post-distortion) is considered. The increasing use of digitally enhanced ADC architectures proves to be the main driver for the observed improvement in area and power with CMOS technology scaling. Finally the sixth paper from Klaas Bult et al. analyzes the aspects relative to power reduction in very high-frequency DAC. The case study of 12b 2.9 Gs/s DAC is proposed as a benchmark. Several design technique limiting the DAC performances are introduced and eventual solutions are developed. Andrea Baschirotto
Chapter 1
Power Minimization in ADC Design Willy Sansen
Abstract An overview is given of the different ADCs, in which power consumption has been minimized. First flash ADCs are examined, in which interpolation and folding is used to reduce the number of comparators. Then pipeline and SAR ADCs are shortly reviewed. Oversampling ADCs are discussed in more detail. The noise shaping is carried out with Switched-capacitor, and with opamp/GmC filters. The text concludes with TDC based ADCs.
1 Introduction Excellent texts exist which give a good introduction on ADCs. Examples are the books by Van de Plassche [1], Razavi [2], Maloberti [3] and Johns and Martin [4]. A summary is given in the slide-based book of Sansen [5]. They all provide details on both system and transistor level. All of them compare ADC performance in terms of a FOM in pJoule per conversion step, which is limited by the effective number of bits resolution (ENOB), the bandwidth and the power consumption. The best overview of the state-of-the art is given on the website of Murmann [6]. It is clear that the minimization of the power consumption is the biggest concern of the designer. This is why this texts tries to highlight a number of design techniques which allow exactly that. Examples are drawn from all major categories of ADCs such as flash ADCs in which interpolation and folding is used to limit the number of comparators. Pipeline and successive-approximation ADCs follow shortly. Considerable attention is then paid to oversampling ADCs in which both switched-capacitor and continuous-time filters are used for noise shaping. Finally the capabilities are discussed of ADCs based on Time-to-Digital converters as they are most promising for nanometer CMOS technologies. W. Sansen () KULeuven, Groenstraat 124, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium e-mail:
[email protected] M. Steyaert et al. (eds.), Analog Circuit Design: Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 1, © Springer ScienceCBusiness Media B.V. 2012
3
4
W. Sansen
2 Flash/Interpolation and Folding Only three examples are given. The first one by Verbruggen [7] avoids preamplifiers for lower power consumption. The combination of 1-bit folding and a 4-bit flash ADC, using 15 comparators (see Fig. 1.1), leads to an impressive FOM of 50 fJ/conv.step. The bandwidth is 878 MHz. and is realized in 90 nm CMOS. The ENOB is only 4.7 bit as can be expected for high-speed flash converters. Another example is the 6-bit flash ADC which was realized in 45 nm CMOS [8]. Averaging and folding is realized with 65 dynamic comparators, which are all simple differential pairs. The realization (C045 in Fig. 1.2) is about a factor 8 worse than the simulation because of this averaging and folding circuitry, without calibration. The third flash ADC has been selected because of the low supply voltage [9]. Optimum performance is reached at 0.4 V but it operates down to 0.2 V. At 0.4 V the FOM is about 0.1 pJ/conv.step. It is realized in 0.18 m CMOS. This low supply
Fig. 1.1 A 5-bit folding flash ADC with 50 fJ/conv.step
Fig. 1.2 Five-bit folding flash ADC in 45 nm CMOS
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
5
Fig. 1.3 Highly-digital flash ADC at minimum 0.2 V supply voltage
voltage is only possible when dynamic CMOS inverters are used as amplifiers and all transistors operate in weak inversion. This is discussed in more detail in the next Chapter (Fig. 1.3).
3 Pipeline ADCs All pipeline ADCs need precision amplification to provide the amplified residue to the next stage. This is easily achieved by switching matched capacitors. The amplifiers however take most of the current. A comparison of the types of amplifiers (for 100 MHz GBW and 2 pF CL) shows that the CMOS inverter is by far the best choice, despite its higher noise and its zero PSRR [5]. Its current consumption ITIOT is lowest and its swing is excellent. Moreover it acts as a simple class-AB stage, which allows power savings beyond to what is given in Fig. 1.4. More and more class-AB amplifiers are used in analog blocks, as they only use power when solicited. Multistage amplifiers provide even higher GBW.CL over ITOT ratios [5] but may not be the best choice if other specifications are taken into account. In nanometer CMOS technologies however, weak-inversion operation becomes evident as shown in Fig. 1.5. It gives the inversion coefficient (which is the ratio of the current to the si-wi crossover current) for a two-stage amplifier with 3 GHz GBW (with GBW D fT/16 [5]). The weak inversion asymptote is given as well. It is clear that important power savings can be achieved in nanometer CMOS, because of its high fT values. Other techniques to save power are opamp sharing, capacitor sharing, removing the S/H input stage, etc. They are summarized in [10].
6
W. Sansen
Fig. 1.4 Comparison of types of amplifiers Fig. 1.5 Nanometer CMOS technologies push weak inversion operation
A good example of an inverter based amplifier for a low-power pipeline ADC is shown in Fig. 1.6 [11]. The inverter schematic is clearly distinguished. Switches are used to set the biasing such that the actual current is much lower than in a conventional CMOS inverter. Cross-coupling is used to enhance the gain. A FOM of 72 fJ/conv. was reached in 90 nm CMOS.
4 SAR ADCs Successive-approximation ADCs are ideally suited for low power consumption as they only consist of a comparator, switches and an array of capacitors (see Fig. 1.7) [12]. It is obvious that a dynamic comparator must be used and that the unit capacitance must be minimized. The one in [12] uses 12 fF but in [15] only 0.5 fF is used (see Fig. 1.8). The resulting SNRD can never be high because of lack of
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
7 To negative half circuit CNP
Stage1 φ1 : Resel φ2 : Sample φ3 : Compare φ4 : Amplify
Stage2
VBP CBP
VCM
Boot-strapped φ4
φ1 P0
φ2
φ4
φ1,3
φ4
CF
VIN
CF φ4
Cs A
φ2
φ4
CBN
VDAC φ3,4
N0 φ1
φ1
VCM
CS
φ4
φ1 VBN
VCM φ2e
φ4e
CNN
To negative half circuit
CNN
To negative half circuit
To negative half circuit
N0
Fig. 1.6 Pipeline ADC with inverters as class-AB amplifiers
Vcomp
Vref
Vref
Reference Switch
Vcomp
Vref 128C
64C
2C
C
+
–
C Comparator
Capacitor Array
CLK
Vin
Successive Approximation Register and Switching Network
D7
D6 D5
Fig. 1.7 Low-power SAR ADC
D4
D3
D2 D1
Vref GND D0
8
W. Sansen Clock input
Analog input
S&H Switched cap. network
Asynchronous logic
!
1.32 um
Digital output
DAC
0.70 um
0.5 fF Unit capacitance
INP INN
OUTP OUTN Ch
C7
C6 C5
C4
C3 C2
C1
C0
Sample CLK D7 D6
D5 D4 D3
D2
D1
D0
Fig. 1.8 Eight-bit 10 MS/s SAR in 90 nm CMOS [15]
good matching. As a result such low-power ADCs are only used for very low-power applications (portable electronics) and medium SNDR (8 : : : 10 bit). On the other hand their FOMs are impressive. It was 2.6 pJ for the one of [12], but 10 fJ/conv. for [13], 4.4 fJ/conv. for [14] and 12 fJ/conv. for [15].
5 Switched-Capacitor † ADCs Oversampling techniques give rise to higher resolutions than what is possible with matching. Three parameters determine the maximum SNDR, the first one of which is the oversampling ratio. The other ones are the multi-(or single-) bit quantizer and the order of the noise shaping filter [16]. At low supply voltages the switches become a problem. It is then easier to switch the amplifiers rather than the switches, as shown in Fig. 1.9 [17]. If class AB amplifiers are used, then excellent FOMs can be obtained. The amplifier used in [17] is s single VGS C VDSsat amplifier which allows supply voltage down to 0.7 V. It is shown in Fig. 1.10. Indeed transistor M2 acts as a source follower. It imposes vin2 on the source of transistor M1, which thus acts a single-transistor differential amplifier. It has a class-AB output as well which gives rise to low quiescent current consumption. The output current can thus be much larger than biasing current IB. Full feedforward is used now in all Sigma-delta modulators to avoid large signals at the input of the first integrator [18]. An example of a 4th order 1MS/s singlebit converter is shown in Fig. 1.11 [19]. It provides 1 MS/s and its FOM is 0.35 pJ/conv.step. Another low-power realization uses full feedforward as well and cascaded CMOS inverters as amplifiers. The minimum supply voltage is 0.7 V and its FOM is 0.1 pJ/conv.step [20]. Its schematic is shown in Fig. 1.12. The bandwidth is only 20 kHz but its power consumption is correspondingly small.
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
9
Fig. 1.9 Switched-opamp sigma-delta converter section Fig. 1.10 Class-AB differential V-I converter
x
c1
+ +
c2 + c3 –+
I(z) a1
I(z) a2
I(z) a3
I(z) a4
y
+ c4 DAC
Fig. 1.11 Full-feedforward 4th order single-bit †D ADC
10
W. Sansen
0.5 1
–1 / 2
Z
1 + + –
Z 0.2
–1 / 2 –1
1–Z
0.4
Z
–1 / 2
–1 / 2 –1
0.1
1–Z
Z
–1
1–Z
2
–1 / 2
Z
+
DAC
Fig. 1.12 Twenty kilo Hertz †D modulator on 0.7 V
Fig. 1.13 Four-bit †D modulator architecture
Fig. 1.14 0.1–20 MHz SC †D modulator
For higher speed and higher resolution, multibit quantizers are required, which puts severe constraints on linearity of the multibit DAC in the feedback loop. Many techniques have been developed such as DEM, DWA, etc. An example is shown in Fig. 1.13 for a 1.2 MHz input more than 16 bit resolution signal [21]. Better performance has been reached recently [22] with a programmable modulator shown in Fig. 1.14. Its FOM is only 0.62 pJ/conv.
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
11
Fig. 1.15 Ultra-low power amplifier based on a CMOS inverter
Fig. 1.16 SC modulator (left) and CT modulator (right)
The one with the lowest supply voltage (0.25 V) derives an internal supply voltage of 0.5 V. It reaches 10 kHz with 0.4 pJ/conv. CMOS inverters are used in weak inversion to reach such low power consumption of 7.4 W [23] (Fig. 1.15). For higher frequencies, SC filters cannot be used any more as they suffer from insufficient settling times and charge distribution effects. Continuous-time filters must then be used.
6 Continuous-Time † ADCs In such converters, the sampling is no more done at the input but in the quantizer (see Fig. 1.16). As a result no anti-aliasing filter is required. Moreover the speed of the amplifiers can be lower, saving a factor of 2 : : : 3 in power consumption. On the other hand, jitter occurs between the clocks of the quantizer and the DAC. Also differences between the time constants in the filters must be tuned out. Finally any delay around the feedback loop may cause stability problems [24, 25]. Two important discussions seem to continue. The first one has to do with the kind of filter to be used, an opamp based filter or a GmC filter. The other issue is related to feedforward versus feedback.
12
W. Sansen
Fig. 1.17 Comparison of filters [5]
– b4fs s + fs Vin
– a1fs s +
– a2fs s + DAC1
– a3fs s + DAC2
Digital Output DAC3
a4
1 bit FF fs = 640 MHz
Fig. 1.18 Architecture of 3-rd order single-bit † modulator
The following realizations will illustrate these points. It is clear from a first-order comparison (in Fig. 1.17) that opamp based filters excel in linearity at low frequencies. GmC filters on the other hand can reach higher frequencies but suffer from distortion. Both are used, sometimes even in the same † modulator ! An example of such CT † modulator using linearized GmC blocks is shown in Fig. 1.18 [26]. It only reaches 10 bit up to 10 MHz (0.22 pJ/conv.step). Local feedback is always used to sharpen the filter response. The CT Sigma Delta modulator with the lowest supply voltage, of only 0.5 V, is shown in Fig. 1.19 [27]. Its BW is 25 kHz and its FOM 1.5 pJ/conv.step. To reach such low voltage is only possible if either the bulk is used as an input or the bulks are slightly forward biased to reduce the threshold voltages.
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
13
Fig. 1.19 Third-order single-bit † modulator on 0.5 V
Fig. 1.20 Third-order four-bit † modulator up to 20 MHz
Amplifiers biased in weak inversion can be sued provided the bandwidth is small as in [28], which reaches 24 kHz with 0.11 pJ/conv. For higher frequencies, CMOS inverters are used as in [29] with 0.4 pJ/conv. The lowest FOM hitherto has been reached in [30] with 0.12 pJ/conv. It is shown in Fig. 1.20. Three-stage class-AB amplifiers are used! Similar frequencies are obtained in [31, 32], the latter one of which uses an opmap in the input stage, followed by two GmC blocks. Also the DACs use SC techniques to save power. Its FOM is 0.23 pJ/conv.step. The last example reaches 125 MHz and is realized in 45 nm CMOS [33]. Now two operational amplifiers are used followed by a single GmC block as shown in Fig. 1.21. Its FOM is only 0.65 pJ/conv.step.
14
W. Sansen
Fig. 1.21 A 125 MHz CT † modulator in 45 nm CMOS
7 TDC Based ADCs Nanometer CMOS technologies require lower supply voltages, although 0.9 V seems to become the new standard. As a result, maybe it is better to convert the input signal directly into a frequency, rather than to convert the input signal amplitude into a quantized equivalent, which suffers from offset and noise. Such ADCs uses a Pulse-width modulator (PWM) or an oscillator (VCO or ring oscillator). Its most important problem is the linearity of the conversion of the voltage into a frequency [34–36]. An early version of such VCO based ADC is shown in Fig. 1.22 [34]. The supply voltage of the ring oscillator is driven by the input signal, after buffering. Logic is required to output the output bits. As a result of the architecture, first-order noise shaping is realized, leading to excellent results. A bandwidth of 100 kHz was reached with 10 bit resolution, giving rise to a FOM of 3 pJ/conv.step. The same authors realized a version [34, ICECS 2009], with 50 MHz and 9.5 bit in 65 nm CMOS, yielding 20 fF/conv.step, which is impressive indeed. A similar VCO-based ADC was realized for low frequencies (20 kHz) operating at 0.2 V supply voltage [36], which gave 82 fF/conv.step. As linearity of such VCO’s is a problem, a linearization technique is used in Fig. 1.23 [37]. Two oscillators are connected in a differential configuration. The FOM is 25 fJ/conv.step for a 40 nm CMOS technology! The maximum frequency is 10 MHz.
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
15
Fig. 1.22 VCO based ADC [34]
Fig. 1.23 Linearized VCO based ADC [37]
A higher frequency of 30 MHz is obtained in [38] with a FOM of 143 fJ/conv. A bandwidth of 20 MHz is obtained in [39] with 0.33 pJ/conv. Its configuration is shown in Fig. 1.24. A TEQ (Time Encoding Quantizer) replaces the flash quantizer in Fig. 1.25 [40]. A clock of 2.56 GHz is used for high resolution. Another example of a VCO-based CT † modulator is shown in Fig. 1.25 [41]. Current starved pseudo-differential CMOS inverters are used in the current controlled ring oscillators (ICRO). Non-linear correction improves the linearity. It reaches 18 MHz and its FOM is 0.25 pJ/conv.step. The final one [42] reaches 20 MHz and its FOM is 0.32 pJ/conv.step, in 65 nm CMOS (Fig. 1.26).
16
W. Sansen (N-1)th Order Loop Filter a1
an-2
in(t) –
+
K1(s)
K2(s)
Kn-1(s)
1 s
1 s
1 s
VCO Quantizer Kn(s) –
+
Quantizer
1 s
τD
CLK NRZ DAC
NRZ DAC
Loop Delay
RZ DAC
out[n]
First Order Difference
REG
1–z–1
REG CLKB
CLK
CLK
Fig. 1.24 CT † with VCO quantizer [39]
Fig. 1.25 CT † with TEQ [40]
8 Conclusions An overview is given of the state-of-the art of ADCs. Most attention is paid to oversampling converters with SC or continuous-time filters. Finally TDC based ADCs are discussed as they show great promise for nanometer CMOS technologies. They can all be mapped on the P/fs (in pJoule) versus SNDR (in dB) curve [6], showing which ADC to use for which performance.
1 Power Minimization in ADC Design
n(t)
15-element ICRO
30
15-element ICRO
30
17
30 Ring Sampler
Phase Decoder
5
30 Ring Sampler
Phase Decoder
5
5
Nonlinearity Correction
5
Non14 linearity + – Correction 15
–1
1–z
VII –1
1–z
4-level DAC
14
16
Dither LFSR fs / 8
+ 4-level DAC 15-element ICRO
30
15-element ICRO
30
VII
30 Ring Sampler
Phase Decoder
5
30 Ring Sampler
Phase Decoder
5
–1
5
1–z
–1
1–z
5
Nonlinearity Correction Nonlinearity Correction
14
+ –
14
fz Calibration Unit
Fig. 1.26 Variable-rate CT † with ICRO’s [41]
References 1. R. Van de Plassche, Integrated Analog-to-Digital and Digital-to-Analog Converters (Kluwer Academic Press, Boston, 1994) 2. B. Razavi, Principles of Data Conversion System Design (IEEE Press, New York, 1995) 3. F. Maloberti, Data Converters (Springer, Dordrecht, 2007) 4. D. Johns, K. Martin, Analog Integrated Circuit Design (Wiley, New York, 1997) 5. W. Sansen, Analog Design Essentials (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006) 6. B. Murmann, http://www.stanford.edu/murmann/adcsurvey.html 7. B. Verbruggen,JSSC 44(3), 874–882 (2009) 8. P. Veldhorst,ESSCIRC, Athens, 2009, pp. 464–467 9. D.C. Daly, JSSC 44(11), 3030–3038 (2009) 10. J.W. Nam, ESSCIRC, Athens, 2009, pp. 468–471 11. J. Kim, B. Murmann, ESSCIRC, Sevilla, 2010, pp. 378–380 12. M. Scott, JSSC 38(7), 1123–1129 (2003) 13. G. Van der Plas, JSSC 43(12), 2631–2640 (2008) 14. M. Van Elzakker, ISSCC, San Francisco, 2008, pp. 244–245 15. P. Harpe, ESSCIRC, Sevilla, 2010, pp. 214–217 16. R. Schreier, G. Temes, Understanding Delta-Sigma Data Converters (Wiley, Chichester, 2004) 17. V. Peluso, JSSC 32, 1887–1896 (1998) 18. J. Silva, Electron Lett 37(12), 737–738 (2001) 19. L.B. Yao et al., Low-Power Low-Voltage † Modulators in Nanometer CMOS (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006) 20. M. Chae, ISSCC, San Francisco, 2008, p. 27.2 21. Y. Geerts et al., JSSC 35(12), 1829–1840 (2000) 22. T. Christen, ESSCIRC, Sevilla, 2010, pp. 414–417 23. F. Michel, ISSCC, San Francisco, 2011, pp. 476–477 24. J.A. Cherry, W.M. Snelgrove, CT SD Modulators for High-Speed ADCs (Kluwer Academic Press, Norwell, 2000) 25. S. Paton, JSSC 39(7), 1056–1063 (2004) 26. R. Schoofs, CAS 54(1), 209–217 (2007)
18 27. K.P. Pun, JSSC, 42(3), 496–507 (2007) 28. S. Pavan, JSSC, 45(7), 1365–1379 (2010) 29. R.H.M. van Veldhoven, ISSCC, San Francisco, 2008, pp. 492–493 30. G. Mitteregger, JSSC 41(12), 2641–2649 (2006) 31. L.J. Breems, JSSC 42(12), 2696–2705 (2007) 32. P. Crombez, JSSC 45(6), 1159–1171 (2010) 33. M. Bolatkale, ISSCC, San Francisco, 2011, pp. 470–471 34. T. Watanabe, JSSC 38(1), 120–125 (2003); ICECS, Hammamet, 2009, pp. 271–274 35. D. Hovin, JSSC 32(1), 13–22 (1997) 36. U. Wismar, ESSCIRC, Montreux, 2006, pp. 187–190 37. Op’t Eynde, ISSCC, San Francisco, 2010, pp. 450–451 38. J. Daniels, VLSI Circuits, Honolulu, 2010, pp. 155–156 39. M. Park, M.H. Perrott, JSSC 44(12), 3344–3358 (2009) 40. E. Prefasi, ESSCIRC, Sevilla, 2010, pp. 430–433 41. G. Taylor, I. Galton, JSSC 45(12), 2634–2646 (2010) 42. V. Dhanasekaran, JSSC 46(3), 639–650 (2011)
W. Sansen
Chapter 2
Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion Boris Murmann
Abstract This paper reviews recent developments and low-power design techniques for high-speed pipelined A/D converters. The discussion spans a review of the fundamental operation principles, a summary of widely used low-power techniques, and an examination of ideas that have been proposed in recent research publications. As we will show, the best research-level designs reach a power efficiency that lies within an order of magnitude of practically achievable limits in today’s architectures. This corresponds to a 2–3 order of magnitude improvement relative to the first pipelined ADCs designed in the late 1980s and early 1990s.
1 Introduction Pipelined ADCs have been investigated since the late 1980s [1–3] to enable highspeed conversion at moderate-to-high resolutions of approximately 8–14 bits. In the early days of its commercial adoption, the pipelined architecture was used to digitize video signals at approximately 20 MS/s and 10 bits of resolution [4]. At that time, with CMOS feature sizes of several microns, this level of performance was difficult to achieve with competing architectures. Even though more than two decades have passed, the situation hasn’t changed much. Despite the fact that competing architectures (such as successive approximation and oversampling ADCs) have substantially widened their performance space, pipelined converters still enjoy great popularity in high-speed applications. This can be seen from Fig. 2.1, which plots experimental ADC data presented at the IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conference (ISSCC) and the VLSI Circuit Symposium from 1997 until 2011 [5]. For the range of 50–80 dB signalto-noise-and-distortion ratio (SNDR), the pipelined architecture clearly dominates B. Murmann () Stanford University, 420 Via Palou Mall, Stanford, CA 94305-4070, USA e-mail:
[email protected] M. Steyaert et al. (eds.), Analog Circuit Design: Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 2, © Springer ScienceCBusiness Media B.V. 2012
19
20
B. Murmann
Flash Folding Two-Step Pipeline (Interleaved) Pipeline (1 Channel) SAR ΔΣ Other 100 fsrm s Jitter
1010
BW [Hz]
109
108
107
106 20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
SNDR [dB]
Fig. 2.1 Experimental data for ADC bandwidth (BW) versus SNDR. Pipelined ADCs dominate the 50–80 dB SNDR range for BW > 10 MHz
the architectural landscape for conversion bandwidths above 10 MHz. Within this range, popular applications include wireless base stations [6], wireless LAN [7, 8], Ethernet transceivers [9], and medical ultrasound imagers [10]. Regardless of the underlying architecture, a general application-driven necessity in the design of modern data converters is the aggressive reduction of power dissipation. According to the analysis described in [11], A/D conversion energy has halved every 2 years over the past decade (on average, across all architectures and performance regimes). While some of these improvements are undoubtedly due to technology scaling, refinements in ADC architectures and circuit design have carried a significant weight in this trajectory. Thus, the purpose of this paper is to review the progression of relevant design techniques for the specific case of highspeed pipelined A/D converters. As a basis for this discussion, Sect. 2 will review pipelined conversion at the conceptual block diagram level. In Sect. 3, common-practice and widely productized techniques applicable to low-power design are reviewed. These include for instance stage scaling, comparator redundancy, and amplifier sharing. In Sect. 4, we will then present ideas that have been evaluated mostly at the level of university research. The topics covered include OpAmp-less stage implementations as well as various digital enhancement techniques. In light of this discussion, Sect. 5 compares the state-of-the art with practical limits on power dissipation and Sect. 6 ends this chapter with a summary.
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
21
2 Review of Pipelined A/D Conversion Figure 2.2 shows a conceptual block diagram of the pipelined A/D converter topology. Several converter stages are cascaded and process the analog input sequentially, similar to flip-flops propagating a bit stream in a digital shift register. Each stage samples and holds its analog input (through S/H circuits implicitly contained in the local A/D block and the summing node) and performs a coarse A/D conversion. The error of this conversion result, often called residue, is computed with the help of a local D/A converter, amplified and fed to the next stage in order to extract additional bits. The last stage contains only a quantizer, since there is no further need to compute a residue. The sub-ADC results are aligned in time (using shift registers) and combined to yield the final digital output word. The principal advantage of this ADC architecture is that due to stage pipelining, its throughput rate is set by the time needed to perform a single sub-A/D and D/A conversion. Similar to workers on a manufacturing line, the stages operate concurrently, i.e. while stage i acquires a new input, stage i C 1 operates on the previous output of stage i. The propagation time through the cascade of pipeline stages merely results in conversion latency, which is tolerable in many applications. In order to understand the operating principle of a pipelined converter in more detail, it is useful to look at a simple two-stage pipeline example as shown in Fig. 2.3. In this diagram, the sub-DAC is ideal and the sub-ADCs are modeled as unity gain elements that introduce an additive quantization error. For an ideal
Align & Combine Bits Dout Vin SHA
Stage 1
Vin1
Stage n-1
Σ
G1 –
ADC
DAC D1
Fig. 2.2 Block diagram of a pipelined ADC
Vres1
Stage n
22
B. Murmann Stage 1
Stage 2
Vin
Σ
G11 G –
Vres1 = –G1εq
Σ εq2
Σ εq1 D2
D1 Dout
Σ
1 / Gd1
Fig. 2.3 Two-stage pipeline ADC example
B-bit quantizer, the quantization error (©q ) is bounded by ˙ ½, where is the quantizer’s step size. From this model, it is straightforward to show that ©q2 G1 C Dout D Vin C ©q1 1 Gd1 Gd1
(2.1)
and thus, for Gd1 D G1 Dout D Vin C
©q2 Gd1
(2.2)
From this result, we see that the “digital gain” term that combines the two subconversion results should ideally be set to the reciprocal of the gain used in the analog signal path.1 Under this condition, and assuming that the sub-DAC is ideal and none of the quantizers are driven into overload, it follows that the quantization error of the overall pipeline in this example is equal to the quantization error of the last stage, divided by gain of stage 1. It is straightforward to show that this result extends to an n-stage pipeline, in which case the last stage’s quantization error is divided by the aggregate gain in the analog path. We can therefore summarize the following key results: • In an ideal n-stage pipeline ADC (ideal DACs, quantizers are not overloading and ideal matching of analog and digital gain terms), the quantization error of stages 1 through n 1 does not appear in the output. • The aggregate bit-resolution of a pipeline is given by the resolution of the last quantizer plus the dual logarithm of the aggregate amplifier gain. I.e., for each factor of two in gain, the last stage’s quantization error is cut in half, corresponding one bit improvement in resolution.
1
The reader may notice a similarity to cascade delta-sigma converters: perfect cancellation of the first stage quantization noise requires perfect coefficient matching between the analog and digital domains; any mismatch will “leak” a portion of the coarse quantization error into the output.
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
23
3 Basic Low-Power Design Techniques Given the structural features of a pipelined converter and its underlying circuits, there exist a number of basic opportunities for translating relaxed precision requirements into power savings. We will review the most widely used concepts in this section using a prototypical circuit realization described next. Figure 2.4 shows a conceptual single-ended representation of a conventional pipeline stage. This circuit consists of a flash-type sub-ADC, a capacitive charge redistribution network, and an operational transconductance amplifier (OTA). The switched capacitor network, in combination with the OTA is often called MDAC (multiplying D/A converter). Like most switched capacitor circuits, the stage operates in two main clock phases. During the sampling phase (¥1 ), the stage input signal is acquired. In the redistribution phase (¥2 ), a residual charge packet, controlled by the local conversion result D, is redistributed onto the feedback capacitor CF to produce the amplified stage residue, Vres . In this scheme, the precise matching of capacitors in modern technologies and electronic feedback are leveraged to achieve an accurate realization of the required sub-DAC, subtraction and gain functions.
3.1 Comparator Redundancy The most widely used technique employed to save power in the stage’s flash subADC is comparator redundancy. As we have seen from the analysis of Sect. 2, the errors from the flash ADCs of stage 1 through n 1 do not appear in the converter’s output. Consequently, we should be able to get by with rather imprecise sub-ADCs that utilize near-minimum size transistors and run at very low levels of power. This turns out to be true in practice, provided that proper care is taken to prevent quantizer over-ranging. φ1
CF
. ..
. ..
Vin
Cs[1:m]
... Flash ADC
Switches
D
±Vref
Fig. 2.4 Generic pipeline stage implementation
Vres OTA φ1′
φ2
φ2
24
B. Murmann
Fig. 2.5 Overranging due to sub-ADC decision level error
Overranging due to misplaced decision level
Full-scale range
Vres1 4
Vin
As we see from the example in Fig. 2.3, the residue of the first stage is simply a gained-up version of the local quantization error. For the pipeline to work properly, we must ensure that the output does not saturate the following quantizer, i.e. the output must not exceed the next quantizer’s full-scale range (VFS ). Assuming that the local sub-ADC is free of errors in its decision levels, this condition is ensured as long as G1 2B since the quantization error of a B-bit ADC is bounded by VFS /2B and thus G1 VFS /2B VFS () G1 2B . The limit case of G1 D 2B with B D 2 is illustrated in Fig. 2.5. From this example, it is clear that any error in the sub-ADC decision levels will lead to over-ranging. Thus, it is impractical to design a stage for this limit case; it would require very high precision (and thus high power) in the sub-ADC comparators. There are three ways to ensure that over-ranging is avoided despite large errors in the sub-ADC’s decision levels. The first (and probably most obvious) is to design for a reduced gain less than 2B . This idea, sometimes called “radix <2,” is utilized e.g. in [12], which uses B D 1 and G D 1.93. In order to tolerate relatively large errors and to maintain a radix of 2 (which simplifies the digital logic that combines the bits), another option is to chose G D 2B1 , which was done e.g. in the design of [13]. A particularly elegant and popular variant for a stage that has G D 2 is to employ a sub-ADC with only two decision levels (instead of three), i.e. B D log2 (2 C 1) D 1.589 bits. Such a stage is typically called “1.5-bit” in literature [4]. A third option is to allow the stage to extend the full-scale range of the quantizer that takes the over-ranging residue voltage [14]. With proper redundancy in place, large comparator offsets can be tolerated, often allowing the designer to employ basic dynamic latch comparators without preamplification (unless charge kick-back is a concern). Typically, the power required for such comparators in modern technologies is on the order of 100 W/GHz (100 fJ per comparison) or less [15, 16]. Thus, the overall comparator power in a pipelined ADC tends to be small compared to the power dissipated in the MDAC circuit.
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
Vin
Stage 1
Stage 2
C1 / 2
C1 Vin
25
Stage 3
C2 / 2
C2 Gm
C3 / 2
C3 Gm
Gm
Fig. 2.6 Pipelined ADC model for noise considerations
3.2 Stage Scaling, Per-Stage Resolution and Noise Budgeting Unlike comparator nonidealities, errors in the MDAC circuitry refer directly to the input of the pipeline and there is no inherent architectural suppression mechanism. The most critical implication of this is that the electronic noise of the MDAC circuits must be minimized commensurate with the target resolution of the ADC. Since many stages contribute to the overall input referred noise, a key question is how the input referred noise budget should be distributed across the pipeline to minimize power dissipation. This question was investigated in detail by Cline [17] and later refined by Chiu [18]. In order to understand the first order result, consider the simplified ADC model in Fig. 2.6, using a stage gain of two as an example. Without worrying about the absolute value of the total input referred noise (which would require a more detailed analysis), we begin by expressing the rough proportionalities of the input referred noise, given by
Ntot
1 1 1 1 1 1 / kT C C C C1 C2 22 C3 22 22
(2.3)
In words, the noise power of the second stage is divided by 4 when referred to the input, and the third stage noise is divided by 16. If we choose all capacitors the same size, then the first stage will clearly dominate the noise. This is wasteful, since the second and third stage amplifiers are driving large capacitors that are essentially irrelevant to the circuit’s noise performance. Consider now the option of scaling the capacitors such that C2 D C1 /4 and C3 D C1 /16. In this case, each stage will contribute equally to the overall input referred noise. Unfortunately, this choice is also wasteful, since the first stage has a very small noise budget, requiring a very large input sampling capacitance. Further analysis shows that the optimum capacitance scale factor lies approximately midway between the two extremes considered above, i.e. the capacitance should be scaled by the aggregate gain (not gain squared) that precedes each stage. For instance, in the above example, C2 D C1 /2 and C3 D C1 /4 are near optimum
26
B. Murmann
Fig. 2.7 Pipelined ADC power as a function of stage scaling (from [18]) and for various per-stage resolutions
choices for a practical design. The exact optimum can deviate from these values depending on the speed of the converter and the per-stage resolution. Fortunately, however, the optimum is well-behaved and shallow, as can be seen from Fig. 2.7. For this illustration, the taper factor x is defined such that the capacitor scaling factor is equal to Gx , where G is the stage gain. Thus, x D 1 corresponds to a capacitor scaling by exactly the stage gain. Clearly, deviating by some fraction from x D 1 does not result in a significant change in power dissipation, as long as one does not approach x D 0 or x D 2, which correspond to the extreme (and undesired) scaling scenarios discussed above. In addition to properly distributing the electronic noise budget across stages, the designer must decide upon a split of the overall input noise budget into electronic noise and quantization noise. For an ideal ADC with quantization step , the input referred quantization noise is 2 /12. In general, it is wasteful to make the input referred electronic noise much smaller than the quantization noise; this is because in this case extra amplifier power is invested in diminishing gains in signal-to-noise ratio. For this reason, many designs make the input referred thermal noise at least comparable to the quantization noise. For embedded converters, one can argue that designing toward the other extreme of dominant electronic noise can be beneficial [19]. In an embedded converter, the cost of generating additional bits to reduce quantization noise (and thus allow for a larger electronic noise budget) is relatively low, since there is no I/O power associated with these bits. A quantitative evaluation of the proper sampling capacitor size versus number of bits and overall SNR is plotted in Fig. 9 of reference [20]. A final and equally important architectural parameter that must be considered in the power optimization of a pipelined converter is the per-stage resolution. Qualitatively speaking, the main result here is that the low-to-moderate speed pipelines can benefit from larger state resolutions of up to 4–5 bits (especially
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
27
in the first stage). This is because large per-stage resolutions minimize the OTA count at the expense of extra loading from the flash sub-ADCs. At moderate speeds, this extra loading is not detrimental and can be easily handled. For example, the designs of [21, 22] use only 3 and 5 stages to implement 10- and 14-bit converters, respectively. Recently, very low-power two-stage multi-bit designs were presented in [23, 24]. These ADCs use successive approximation to realize efficient subADCs, and rely on a single residue amplifier. Unfortunately multi-bit designs lose their advantage when the goal is to extract the maximum possible speed from a pipelined converter in a given technology. At the highest possible speeds, the designer will typically opt for a single-bit of effective stage resolution; see e.g. the 500-MS/s design of [25].
3.3 Mitigation of Capacitor Mismatch Since any errors in the first stage’s MDAC refer directly to the input of the converter, the matching precision of the employed capacitors must be commensurate with the overall target resolution of the design. In some cases, this leads to an outcome where the capacitor size is set by matching constraints rather than electronic noise requirements (see e.g. [7]). Thus, one can argue that any technique that addresses capacitor mismatch can translate into power savings. One popular architectural option is to increase the resolution of the pipeline’s first stage. One can show that for each extra bit resolved in the first stage, the converter DNL improves by 1 bit, while the INL improves by 0.5 bits. This was leveraged in the design of [26], which uses a 4-bit (3-bit effective) first stage to achieve no missing codes at 14-bits of resolution without any form of calibration and capacitor sizes set by electronic noise. Due to the limited benefit of increased stage resolution on INL, however, the integral nonlinearity in this design is still several LSBs at the 14-bit level.2 If better INL is desired, a variety of correction techniques are available in the analog or digital domain. In analog domain, it is for instance possible to employ passive error averaging to effectively cancel capacitor mismatch [18]. In the digital domain, there exist a wide range of schemes that are essentially based on adjusting the “digital gain terms” in the logic that combines the stage outputs (e.g. Gd1 in Fig. 2.2). The coefficients are typically measured iteratively, using the existing hardware within the pipeline. For instance, mismatch in stage i can be measured using the backend converter comprising of stages i C 1 : : : n. Self calibration techniques of this kind are described for instance in [12, 27–29]. As far as capacitor mismatch is concerned, it is important to note that the resulting errors do not drift. Consequently, it is sufficient to measure them once, e.g. during production test (or power up), and store the coefficients in fuses (or SRAM).
2
This is tolerable, e.g. in imaging applications.
28
B. Murmann
3.4 Amplifier Sharing and SHA-Less Frontends Beyond proper budgeting and distribution of electronic noise, trying to reduce the number of OTAs used in the pipeline is the designer’s next best architectural option for additional power savings. In this spirit, the concept of amplifier sharing has been evaluated. The main idea is to leverage the fact that the OTA in Fig. 2.4 is only used during charge redistribution; it is idle (reset) in the phase where the stage acquires its input. During that time, the OTA can potentially be used in the following stage, which performs charge redistribution in this time slot. This idea is used for example in the designs of [21, 30–32]. The key issues that limit the efficacy of inter-stage OTA sharing are: (1) the performance requirements (gain, bandwidth, load capacitance, etc.) are not equal in the two stages that share the same OTA; this leads to overdesign, (2) sharing the OTA requires additional switches that add load capacitance at critical nodes and thus lead to increase the power dissipation of the shared amplifier. The first of these issues can be overcome if the sharing occurs between two identical pipelines that run in parallel, as for instance in the I/Q channels of a radio receiver. An implementation that describes such an approach is found in [33]. In addition to the switch parasitics, a remaining problem in this approach is the channel-to-channel cross-talk that is introduced from switching a non-reset OTA between the two ideally independent signal paths. A more popular option for reducing the number of high-power OTAs in the pipeline is to eliminate the dedicated sample-and-hold amplifier (“SHA” in Fig. 2.1) from the pipeline. This option is attractive since this stage tends to dissipate up to one third of the total power in a high-performance design. One of the first highperformance designs that uses a SHA-less front-end was described by Mehr in 2001 [13]. Today, SHA-less operation is widely used across a wide range of performance specs, even in designs that sample at IF frequencies [34]. The primary issue that must be overcome in a SHA-less design is the clock timing and bandwidth mismatch between signals acquired by the sub-DAC and the main MDAC path. For relatively low-speed designs with a high degree of comparator redundancy in the first stage (e.g. 1.5-bit architecture), the designer can typically rely on the component matching of modern technologies (see e.g. [35]). For designs with wideband inputs, it is conceivable to measure and calibrate the mismatch [36]. Alternatively, it is possible to merge the sampling operation for the two paths into a single circuit [37].
3.5 Flip-Around Charge Redistribution Beyond reducing the number of amplifiers in the pipeline, the next step is to improve the efficiency of the circuit at the transistor level. A widely used idea is to employ “flip-around” charge redistribution [38]. A complete 1.5-bit pipeline stage that uses this technique is shown in Fig. 2.8. The input is sampled on Cs and Cf (nominally
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
29
Fig. 2.8 1.5-bit pipeline stage implementation using flip-around charge redistribution [39]
same size), and Cf is flipped around the amplifier as a feedback capacitor during redistribution. This scheme achieves a closed loop gain of 2 with a feedback factor of 1/2 (neglecting OTA input capacitance). If the generic circuit of Fig. 2.4 is used instead, the feedback factor would be only Cf /(Cf C 2Cs ) D 1/3. Since both the speed and noise performance of the circuit benefit from larger feedback factors, substantial power savings are enabled by flip-around charge redistribution.
3.6 Time Interleaving Time-interleaved architectures [40] exploit time parallelism and trade hardware complexity for an increased aggregate sampling rate. Once a single-channel pipeline has been optimized using the above-discussed techniques, time-interleaving can be employed to increase the achievable sampling rate in a given technology. In addition, interleaving has benefits for power efficiency, since the individual channels can be designed for lower speeds and thus achieve improved power efficiency. Time interleaved pipelined ADCs are currently popular in the 10GBASE-T Ethernet application, which demands sampling rates on the order of 1 GHz and 11 bits of resolution. While it may be possible to achieve this sampling rate by interleaving two channels, it is typically more efficient to work with four or more channels [9, 41]. A numerical justification of this argument is found in [20].
4 Exploratory Low-Power Design Techniques The techniques described in the previous section are widely used and have been in mass production for many years. In this section, we will consider exploratory ideas that have not yet found widespread industry adoption, and are mostly used in
30
B. Murmann
experimental converters. Since approximately 50–70% of all power in a pipelined ADC is dissipated in the residue amplifiers, research has focused mainly on this particular building block within the converter.
4.1 Residue Amplification with Low Loop Gain A first and most basic opportunity for power reduction lies in simplifying the OTA circuit shown in Fig. 2.4. Instead of using multiple gain stages to achieve high loop gain (to ensure precise amplification), it has been proposed to work with simplified single-stage amplifiers [42, 43], and to use calibration to overcome the resulting errors. Since the open-loop gain of an OTA varies with temperature, the calibration must run continuously and track changes in the converter’s operating conditions. Unfortunately, this creates overhead in and complexity that takes away from the benefits of the (sometimes minor) OTA simplification. In the realization of [6], a 10mW auxiliary ADC is used to monitor the gain of the first residue amplifier, helping to cut its power in half. This overhead is justifiable in this high-performance ADC that dissipates a total power of 850 mW. In general, when applying this particular or a similar technique, the benefits must be carefully evaluated against the cost of the added calibration. An alternative to handling the low amplifier gain through calibration is to apply some form of double sampling to boost the effective gain of the amplifier. The correlated level shifting technique (CLS) proposed recently [44] shows promise in this direction, as it also increases the available swing, which is highly desired in low-voltage technologies. In the context of designs that use simplified amplifiers, it should also be mentioned that there exist options in the optimization of the process technology. For instance, the design of [45] uses customized “high performance analog transistors” with increased intrinsic gain to achieve sufficient gain for 10-bit precision with a single-stage OTA.
4.2 Class-AB and Comparator-Based Residue Amplification Even in simplified, single-stage OTA realizations, the charge transfer from the power supply to the capacitive load is inherently inefficient, since the amplifier draws a constant current, while it delivers on average only a small fraction of this current to the load. In [46], it was found that the efficiency of a class-A OTA in a switched capacitor circuit is inversely proportional to the number of settling time constants. For the typical case of settling for approximately ten or more time constants, the overall efficiency, i.e. charge drawn from the supply versus charge delivered to the load, is only a few percent. One step toward improving the amplifier efficiency is to employ class-AB amplification [35, 47]. So far, class-AB amplification hasn’t been very popular for
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
31
Fig. 2.9 Comparator-based switched capacitor circuit + –
Vout CL
several reasons. First, a typical class-AB OTA still requires a class-A input stage, which upper bounds the possible savings, especially considering the relatively small load capacitances seen in pipelined ADCs. Furthermore, class-AB operation tends to reduce the achievable bandwidth when compared to a class-A design in the same technology. In [35], a single-stage inverter-based class-AB design was used to achieve good power efficiency at a sampling rate of 30 MS/s. A recent concept that has gained momentum is to replace the OpAmp by a comparator [48, 49], yielding a so-called comparator-based switched capacitor circuit (see Fig. 2.9). In this scheme, the comparator shuts off the capacitor charging current when the final signal value is reached. Thus, no charge is wasted and the efficiency of this topology can approach that of a class-B amplifier.
4.3 OpAmp-Less Residue Amplification A more aggressive approach to reduce the power spent on residue amplification is to eliminate the OTA (or comparator) in the stage entirely, and work with a more simplistic configuration that does not rely on OpAmp-like circuitry. Figure 2.10 shows examples of such circuits. The open-loop circuit of Fig. 2.10a [50] is similar to that of Fig. 2.4, except for the charge redistribution phase. The charge packet on the capacitive array is not re-distributed onto a feedback capacitor, but remains in place to produce a small voltage at node Vx . This residue is amplified by a resistively loaded transconductance stage to produce the desired full-swing residue voltage Vres . Since the high gain requirement in the transconductor is now dropped, a basic differential pair-type stage can be used to replace the complex amplifier in Fig. 2.4. Other variants of this open-loop residue amplification approach have been published; see e.g. [51, 52], and the current mode topology of [53]. The circuit in Fig. 2.10b [54] samples the input on two capacitors connected in parallel. Next, it stacks the capacitors in series to achieve a voltage gain of two. The 1 buffer can be a low-power source follower circuit. In scheme (c) a “bucket brigade” pass transistor is used to move a sampled charge packet (q) from a large sampling capacitor (CS ) to a smaller load capacitor (CL ), thereby achieving voltage gain without drawing a significant amount of energy from the supply [55]. The circuit in Fig. 2.10d uses the gate capacitance of a transistor to acquire a charge
32
B. Murmann
a
...
...
Vin
b
Cs[1:m] Vx
...
Switches
ADC
±Vref
D
c
Vres
Gm
d
+ – Vout
V
q
VDD
Vin
(large)
(small)
CL
q1
q2
q VBIAS
C
q1 + q2
– V + t q=0
Vout CL
(floating)
e
Fig. 2.10 Examples of OpAmp-less residue amplification schemes
sample (q1 , q2 ). The transistor is then switched into a source-follower configuration, moving all signal charge (q1 C q2 ) to the small capacitance from gate to drain, which also results in voltage amplification [56]. Much like the comparator based circuit of Fig. 2.9, all of the charge drawn from the supply is used to drive the load, thereby enabling high power efficiency. In this same spirit, the dynamic amplifier used in [57] [Fig. 2.10e] turns off once the amplification is complete and thereby achieves very low power dissipation. In this circuit, all nodes are first reset and the load capacitors are charged with a rate that depends on the input (inC, in). The current is shut off via transistors P1 once the stage’s comparator has made a decision. A general concern with most minimalistic design approaches is that they tend to sacrifice robustness, e.g., in terms of power supply rejection, common mode rejection and temperature stability. It remains to be seen if these issues can be handled efficiently in practice. Improving supply rejection, for instance, could be achieved using voltage regulators. This is custom practice in other areas of mixedsignal design, as for example clock generation circuits [58]. Especially when the power of the ADC’s critical core circuitry is lowered significantly, implementing supply regulation should be justifiable.
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
33
Analog Nonlinearity
Vin
Σ
Backend A/D
g –
A/D
Σ
D/A Coefficient Estimation
MOD Dout
Σ
g–1
Digital Inverse
Fig. 2.11 Digital residue amplifier linearization
A second issue with minimalistic designs is the achievable resolution and linearity. OpAmp circuits with large loop gain help linearize transfer functions; this feature is often removed when migrating to simplified circuits. For instance, the amplifier scheme of Fig. 2.10d is linear only to approximately 9-bit resolution. In cases where simplicity sacrifices linearity, it is attractive to consider digital linearization techniques (see Fig. 2.11). In [50], it was demonstrated that a basic open-loop differential pair can be digitally linearized (to 12-bit precision) using only a few 1,000 logic gates. Subsequently, this idea has been refined e.g. in the works of [59–62]. One key issue in most digital linearization schemes is that the correction parameters must track changes in operating conditions relatively quickly; preferably with time constants no larger than 1–10 ms. Unfortunately, most of the basic statistics-based algorithms for coefficient adaptation require much longer time constants at high target resolutions [60, 63]. Additional research is needed to extend the recently proposed “split-ADC” [64, 65] and feedforward noise cancellation techniques [66] for use in nonlinear calibration schemes.
4.4 Dynamic Error Correction Most of the digital correction methods developed in recent years have targeted the compensation of static circuit errors. However, it is conceivable that in the future the correction of dynamic errors will become attractive as well. One opportunity
34
B. Murmann 10–6
[4]
10–8 P / fs [Joules]
[34]
10–10
[24] [49] [56]
100 fJ / conv.-step [57]
10–12
10–14 20
10 fJ / conv.-step
[23]
30
40
50 60 SNDR [dB]
70
80
90
Fig. 2.12 Solid-line: predicted power limits for pipelined ADCs using class-A residue amplification (eq. (27) of [65] for 90 nm technology). The dashed lines represent the figure of merit P/(fs 2ENOB ), for 10 and 100 fJ/conv-step
is the digital correction of errors due to finite slew rate, incomplete settling or incomplete reset of amplifiers [59, 67–69]. With such corrections in place, the speed of the amplifier can be reduced and potentially translated into significant power savings.
5 Limits on Pipelined ADC Power Dissipation Even with the most innovative power saving techniques applied, there exists a practical minimum level of power that must be invested. Such a bound was developed specifically for pipelined ADCs [70] and assuming noise-limited classA residue amplification. The corresponding equation is plotted in Fig. 2.12 along with experimental pipeline ADC data points [5]. As we can see from this plot, the dynamic pipeline by Verbruggen [57] and the comparator based design by Chu and Lee [49] define the state-of the art in power efficiency and lie closest to the predicted limit line. Relative to Lewis’ pipeline from 1992, data point [49] achieves about 2.5 orders of magnitude improvement in power efficiency.
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
35
6 Summary The power efficiency of pipelined A/D converters has seen tremendous improvements over the past two decades. While a good portion of the progress can be attributed to process scaling, the design techniques reviewed in this paper have played an equally import role; especially as far as adjusting the architecture for optimization in fine line technology is concerned. Relative to Lewis’ pipeline from 1992, today’s research prototypes boast 2–3 orders of magnitude improvement in power efficiency. However, whether the most aggressive innovation will find their way into products is yet to be determined. Many of the ultra-low power architectures proposed recently tend to sacrifice robustness, either in terms of supply rejection or tolerance to process, voltage and temperature variations. Some of these issues can be addressed using calibration techniques, supply regulation and innovative transistorlevel design. With the continuing application-driven need for high-speed and power efficient pipeline ADCs, it is to be expected that many interesting and transformative answers to these challenges will emerge over the next decade.
References 1. S. Masuda et al., A CMOS pipeline algorithmic A/D converter, in Proceedings of the IEEE Custom Integrated Circuits Conference, Rochester, Sept 1984, pp. 559–562 2. S.H. Lewis, P.R. Gray, A pipelined 5-Msample/s 9-bit analog-to-digital converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 22(6), 954–961 (1987) 3. S. Sutarja, P.R. Gray, A pipelined 13-bit 250-ks/s 5-V analog-to-digital converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 23(6), 1316–1323 (1988) 4. S.H. Lewis et al., A 10-b 20-Msample/s analog-to-digital converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 27(3), 351–358 (1992) 5. B. Murmann, ADC performance survey 1997–2011, [Online]. Available: http://www.stanford. edu/murmann/adcsurvey.html 6. A.M.A. Ali et al., A 16-bit 250-MS/s IF sampling pipelined ADC with background calibration. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 45(12), 2602–2612 (2010) 7. J. Arias et al., Low-power pipeline ADC for wireless LANs. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 39(8), 1338–1340 (2004) 8. S. Mehta et al., An 802.11 g WLAN SoC, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, Feb, 2005, pp. 94–95 9. C.-C. Hsu et al., An 11b 800 MS/s time-interleaved ADC with digital background calibration, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2007, pp. 464–615 10. Texas Instruments, AFE5805 Datasheet. [Online]. Available: http://focus.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/ afe5805.pdf 11. B. Murmann, A/D converter trends: Power dissipation, scaling and digitally assisted architectures, in Proceedings of the IEEE Custom Integrated Circuits Conference, San Jose, Sept 2008, pp. 105–112 12. A.N. Karanicolas et al., A 15-b 1-Msample/s digitally self-calibrated pipeline ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 28(12), 1207–1215 (1993) 13. I. Mehr, L. Singer, A 55-mW, 10-bit, 40-Msample/s Nyquist-rate CMOS ADC. IEEE J. SolidState Circuits 35(3), 318–325 (2000)
36
B. Murmann
14. I.E. Opris et al., A single-ended 12-bit 20 Msample/s self-calibrating pipeline A/D converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 33(12), 1898–1903 (1998) 15. D. Schinkel et al., A double-tail latch-type voltage sense amplifier with 18 ps setup C hold time,” in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2007, pp. 314–605 16. T. Sundstrom, A. Alvandpour, A kick-back reduced comparator for a 4-6-Bit 3-GS/s flash ADC in a 90 nm CMOS process, in Proceedings of the MIXDES, Ciechocinek, Poland, 2007, pp. 195–198 17. D.W. Cline, P.R. Gray, A power optimized 13-b 5 Msamples/s pipelined analog-to-digital converter in 1.2 m CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 31(3), 294–303 (1996) 18. Y. Chiu et al., A 14-b 12-MS/s CMOS pipeline ADC with over 100-dB SFDR. IEEE J. SolidState Circuits 39(12), 2139–2151 (2004) 19. K. Bult, Embedded analog-to-digital converters, in Proceedings of the ESSCIRC, Athens, 2009, pp. 52–64 20. S. Kawahito, Low-power design of pipeline A/D converters, in Proceedings of the IEEE Custom Integrated Circuits Conference, San Jose, CA, USA, 2006, pp. 505–512 21. Y.-C. Huang, T,-C. Lee, A 10b 100MS/s 4.5 mW pipelined ADC with a time sharing technique, in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2010, pp. 300–301 22. P. Bogner et al., A 14b 100 MS/s digitally self-calibrated pipelined ADC in 0.13um CMOS, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Dec 2006, pp. 832–841 23. M. Furuta et al., A 0.06 mm2 8.9b ENOB 40MS/s pipelined SAR ADC in 65 nm CMOS, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2010, pp. 382–383 24. C.C. Lee, M.P. Flynn, A 12b 50MS/s 3.5 mW SAR assisted 2-stage pipeline ADC, in Symposium of VLSI Circuits Digest, Honolulu, HI, USA, June 2010, pp. 239–240 25. A. Verma, B. Razavi, A 10-bit 500-MS/s 55-mW CMOS ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(11), 3039–3050 (2009) 26. W. Yang et al., A 3-V 340-mW 14-b 75-Msample/s CMOS ADC with 85-dB SFDR at Nyquist input. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 36(12), 1931–1936 (2001) 27. E.G. Soenen, R.L. Geiger, An architecture and an algorithm for fully digital correction of monolithic pipelined ADCs. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. II 42(3), 143–153 (1995) 28. L. Singer et al., A 12 b 65 MSample/s CMOS ADC with 82 dB SFDR at 120 MHz, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2000, pp. 38–39 29. S.-Y. Chuang, T.L. Sculley, A digitally self-calibrating 14-bit 10-MHz CMOS pipelined A/D converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 37(6), 674–683 (2002) 30. Min Byung-Moo et al., A 69-mW 10-bit 80-MSample/s pipelined CMOS ADC. IEEE J. SolidState Circuits 38(12), 2031–2039 (2003) 31. K. Gulati, Lee Hae-Seung, A low-power reconfigurable analog-to-digital converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 36(12), 1900–1911 (2001) 32. P.C. Yu, Hae-Seung Lee, A 2.5 V 12 b 5 MSample/s pipelined CMOS ADC, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 1996, pp. 314–315 33. D. Kurose et al., 55-mW 200-MSPS 10-bit pipeline ADCs for wireless receivers. IEEE J. SolidState Circuits 41(7), 1589–1595 (2006) 34. S. Devarajan et al., A 16-bit, 125 MS/s, 385 mW, 78.7 dB SNR CMOS pipeline ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(12), 3305–3313 (2009) 35. J.K.-R. Kim, B. Murmann, A 12-bit, 30-MS/s, 2.95-mW pipelined ADC using single-stage class-AB amplifiers and deterministic background calibration, in Proceedings of the ESSCIRC, Sevilla, Sept 2010, pp. 378–381 36. P. Huang et al., SHA-less pipelined ADC converting 10th Nyquist band with in-situ clock-skew calibration, in Custom Integrated Circuits Conference (CICC), 2010 IEEE, San Jose, CA, USA, 2010, pp. 1–4 37. Byung-Geun Lee et al., A 14-b 100-MS/s pipelined ADC with a merged SHA and first MDAC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 43(12), 2613–2619 (2008) 38. Bang-Sup Song et al., A 12-bit 1-Msample/s capacitor error-averaging pipelined A/D converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 23(6), 1324–1333 (1988)
2 Low-Power Pipelined A/D Conversion
37
39. A.M. Abo, P.R. Gray, A 1.5 V, 10-bit, 14 MS/s CMOS pipeline analog-to-digital converter, in Symposium of VLSI Circuits Digest, Honolulu, HI, USA, 1998, pp. 166–169 40. W.C. Black, D.A. Hodges, Time interleaved converter arrays. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 15(6), 1022–1029 (1980) 41. S.K. Gupta et al., A 1-GS/s 11-bit ADC with 55-dB SNDR, 250-mW power realized by a high bandwidth scalable time-interleaved architecture. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 41(12), 2650– 2657 (2006) 42. J. Ming, S.H. Lewis, An 8b 80MSample/s pipelined ADC with background calibration, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2000, pp. 42–43 43. X. Wang et al., A 12-bit 20-Msample/s pipelined analog-to-digital converter with nested digital background calibration. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 39(11), 1799–1808 (2004) 44. B.R. Gregoire, Moon Un-Ku, An over-60 dB true rail-to-rail performance using correlated level shifting and an Opamp with only 30 dB loop gain. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 43(12), 2620–2630 (2008) 45. M. Boulemnakher et al., A 1.2 V 4.5 mW 10b 100MS/s pipeline ADC in a 65 nm CMOS, in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, 2008, pp. 250–611 46. B. Murmann, Limits on ADC Power Dissipation, in Analog Circuit Design, ed. by M. Steyaert et al. (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006), pp. 351–368 47. H.-C. Choi et al., A 12b 50MS/s 10.2 mA 0.18 m CMOS Nyquist ADC with a fully differential class-AB switched OP-AMP, in Symposium of VLSI Circuits Digest, Honolulu, HI, USA, June 2008, pp. 220–221 48. J.K. Fiorenza et al., Comparator-based switched-capacitor circuits for scaled CMOS technologies. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 41(12), 2658–2668 (2006) 49. J. Chu et al., A zero-crossing based 12b 100MS/s pipelined ADC with decision boundary gap estimation calibration, in Symposium of VLSI Circuits Digest, Honolulu, HI, USA, June 2010, pp. 237–238 50. B. Murmann, B.E. Boser, A 12-bit 75-MS/s pipelined ADC using open-loop residue amplification. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 38(12), 2040–2050 (2003) 51. Ding-Lan Shen and Tai-Cheng Lee, A 6-Bit 800-MS/s pipelined A/D converter with open-loop amplifiers, in Symposium on VLSI Circuits Digest, June 2006, pp. 134–135 52. A. Nazemi et al., A 10.3GS/s 6bit (5.1 ENOB at Nyquist) time-interleaved/pipelined ADC using open-loop amplifiers and digital calibration in 90 nm CMOS, in Symposium on VLSI Circuits Digest, 2008, pp. 18–19 53. K. Poulton et al., A 20 GS/s 8 b ADC with a 1 MB memory in 0.18 m CMOS, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, Feb 2003, pp. 318–496. 54. I. Ahmed et al., A low-power capacitive charge pump based pipelined ADC. IEEE J. SolidState Circuits 45(5), 1016–1027 (2010) 55. M. Anthony et al., A process-scalable low-power charge-domain 13-bit pipeline ADC, in Symposium on VLSI Circuits Dig., Honolulu, HI, USA, 2008, pp. 222–223 56. J. Hu et al., A 9.4-bit, 50-MS/s, 1.44-mW pipelined ADC using dynamic source follower residue amplification. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(4), 1057–1066 (2009) 57. B. Verbruggen et al., A 2.6 mW 6 bit 2.2 GS/s fully dynamic pipeline ADC in 40 nm digital CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 45(10), 2080–2090 (2010) 58. T. Toifl et al., A 1.25–5 GHz clock generator with high-bandwidth supply-rejection using a regulated-replica regulator in 45-nm CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(11), 2901–2910 (2009) 59. C.R. Grace et al., A 12-bit 80-MSample/s pipelined ADC with bootstrapped digital calibration. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 40(5), 1038–1046 (2005) 60. A. Panigada, I. Galton, A 130 mW 100 MS/s pipelined ADC with 69 dB SNDR enabled by digital harmonic distortion correction. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(12), 3314–3328 (2009) 61. B.D. Sahoo, B. Razavi, A 12-bit 200-MHz CMOS ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(9), 2366–2380 (2009) 62. M. Daito et al., A 14-bit 20-MS/s pipelined ADC with digital distortion calibration. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 41(11), 2417–2423 (2006)
38
B. Murmann
63. B. Murmann, B.E. Boser, Digital domain measurement and cancellation of residue amplifier nonlinearity in pipelined ADCs. IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas. 56(6), 2504–2514 (2007) 64. J. Li, U.-K. Moon, Background calibration techniques for multistage pipelined ADCs with digital redundancy. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. II 50(9), 531–538 (2003) 65. J. McNeill et al., ‘Split ADC’ architecture for deterministic digital background calibration of a 16-bit 1-MS/s ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 40(12), 2437–2445 (2005) 66. K.-W. Hsueh et al., A 1 V 11b 200MS/s Pipelined ADC with digital background calibration in 65 nm CMOS, in ISSCC Digest Technical Papers, San Francisco, CA, USA, 2008, pp. 546–634 67. J.P. Keane et al., Digital background calibration for memory effects in pipelined analog-todigital converters. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I 53(3), 511–525 (2006) 68. E. Iroaga, B. Murmann, A 12-Bit 75-MS/s pipelined ADC using incomplete settling. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 42(4), 748–756 (2007) 69. S. Kawahito et al., A 15b power-efficient pipeline A/D converter using non-slewing closedloop amplifiers, in Proceedings of the IEEE Custom Integrated Circuits Conference, San Jose, CA, USA, 2008, pp. 117–120 70. T. Sundstrom et al., Power dissipation bounds for high-speed Nyquist analog-to-digital converters. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I 56(3), 509–518 (2009)
Chapter 3
Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications Jan Craninckx
Abstract This chapter discusses the advancements made in SAR ADCs for wireless applications, which require accuracies in the range of 8–10 bit and a few 10’s of MHz sampling speed. An overview is given of recent techniques that reduce the switching power in the capacitive DAC, and as such improve the power efficiency of the ADC up to levels that are out of reach of the typically used pipeline architecture. The second part of this paper discusses the charge-sharing SAR ADC architecture, which proposes a new signal processing method in the charge domain that removes the often-neglected though requirements for the reference buffer. An implementation in 40 nm CMOS achieves 9.3ENOB and 60MS/s at a figure of merit of 34 fJ.
1 Introduction When it comes down to achieving low power consumption in A-to-D conversion, the successive approximation (SAR) principle appears to be a very attractive candidate. For an N-bit ADC, only N operations are needed to determine the output word, a process that can be done with little overhead. The use of the SAR architecture has been widely adopted since the original introduction of the charge-redistribution ADC in 1975 [1]. In this technique, illustrated in Fig. 3.1, the input voltage is first sampled on an array of binary scaled capacitors. Then, by sequentially switching the bottom plates of the capacitor to the reference voltage or to ground, this input voltage can be compared with different levels and in a binary-search the exact input level is determined. During this process, charge is indeed ‘redistributed’ between the two sides of a voltage
J. Craninckx () Imec, Kapeldreef 75, 3000 Leuven, Belgium e-mail:
[email protected] M. Steyaert et al. (eds.), Analog Circuit Design: Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 3, © Springer ScienceCBusiness Media B.V. 2012
39
40
J. Craninckx QX = –2CVIN VX = 0
VX
+
VC
–
C
C 2
C 8
C 4
C 16
VIN
C 16
VREF
Fig. 3.1 Conceptual 5-bit charge-redistribution SAR ADC [1]
divider constructed between the capacitors. A full conversion cycle thus consists out of 1 C N events (1 input sampling and N comparisons). This conceptual ADC schematic is deceivingly simple: there is only one active element (a comparator) and it further contains just some passive capacitors and a set of switches. An easy conclusion would be that a really low power consumption can be obtained. Still, some techniques have been proposed recently to make this basic structure even more efficient, focusing mostly on reducing the switching energy in the feedback DAC. They will be discussed in the state of the art overview in Sect. 2. An aspect that is often neglected however are the requirements posed on the reference buffers, and Sect. 3 will cover the design of an energy-efficient chargesharing SAR architecture. Finally, some conclusions are presented.
2 State-of-the-Art SAR Techniques 2.1 Split-Capacitor Array When analyzing the energy required to switch the capacitors in the typical binary weighted array, it becomes apparent that during a conversion the charge in the capacitors is not used efficiently [2, 3]. During the first bit decision after sampling, the MSB capacitor is connected to VREF with the remaining capacitors connected to ground. Depending on the output of the first comparison, the SAR will do one of two transitions. For a negative value of VX , an “up” transition must be performed for the MSB/2 capacitor, i.e. it must be switched from ground up to VREF , drawing an energy of EUP D 1=8 CV2REF from the supply. However, for a positive value of VX , more actions must be performed, i.e. besides the switching of the MSB/2 capacitor also the MSB capacitor must be switched from
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
41
Ssample
VX
Cb-1=2b-2C0
+ Sb–1
Sb––1
C0
C1=C0
+
S1
–
S1
+
S0
–
S0
Ssample
Ssample
Ssample
Cb,b-1=2b-2C0
Cb, 1=C0
Cb,0=C0
VREF VIN
+ Sb,b–1
–
Sb,b–1 Ssample
+ Sb,1
Sb,–1 Ssample
+ Sb,0
– Sb,0
Ssample
Fig. 3.2 Split capacitor array for a b-bit SAR, with the main subarray on top and the MSB subarray below [3]
VREF to ground. In fact they ‘trade places’. Doing these two actions independently would require a much larger energy of EDOWN D 5=8 CV2REF . It takes five times more energy to lower than to raise it; this occurs because all of the charge initially on the MSB capacitor is discharged to ground, and all the charge that ends up on the MSB/2 capacitor must be delivered from the reference voltage supply. From this analysis, it is apparent that energy savings in a SAR ADC are possible if a more efficient switching scheme were devised. The most optimal scheme from [2] splits the MSB capacitor in a number of units as shown in Fig. 3.2, and switches down only the required number of them during the sequence of the SAR algorithm. This technique is expected to have a 37% lower switching energy than the conventional one [3].
2.2 Step-Wise Charging Another method to reduce the energy needed to charge a capacitor from 0 to V is to perform that operation not in one but in several sequential steps [4]. Switching in a
42
J. Craninckx
b
a VN
N
V2
2
V
N
RN, CN
2
R2, C2
CT CT V1
R1, C1
1
1 0
CL R0, C0
0
CL
Fig. 3.3 (a) Step-wise charging of a capacitive load; (b) using large ‘tank’ capacitors for the intermediate voltages [4]
2
single step takes an energy of E1step D CV 2 . But because of the quadratic relation to the voltage, switching in N steps would require N units of energy that are each N2 times smaller than that: EN step D N
C
V 2 N
2
D
C V2 2N
(3.1)
This configuration is shown in Fig. 3.3, where it is also shown that there is no need for a separate circuit to generate the intermediate voltages. Since during a full up/down switching cycle, no supply except for the top one provides any net charge to the circuits, all intermediate voltages can be sustained by using large tank capacitors. This configuration is even self-stabilizing. This step-wise charging method thus offers the possibility of almost adiabatic switching, without the need for inductors, but of course at the expense of longer switching times, and neglecting the power needed to drive the switches themselves. This technique has been used in a low-speed but ultra-low power 10-bit SAR ADC [5], in combination with the split-capacitor array, to even further reduce the switching energy in the DAC portion of the converter. That design also uses a delayline based controller and a low-power comparator to achieve a power consumption of only 1.9 W at 1 MS/s.
2.3 Monotonic Capacitor Switching Another DAC switching method that allows even further savings was presented in [6, 7].The architecture depicted in Fig. 3.4 looks very similar to the original structure, but in fact operates rather differently because the switching only happens in one direction, e.g. downward.
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
43
Fig. 3.4 (a) Monotonic capacitor switching architecture; (b) typical waveforms [7]
The input is sampled on the top plates, while at the same time the bottom plates of the capacitors are reset to VREF . Next, the comparator directly performs the first comparison without switching any capacitor. According to the comparator output, the largest capacitor C1 on the higher voltage potential side is switched to ground and the other one (on the lower side) remains unchanged. The ADC repeats the procedure until the LSB is decided. For each bit cycle, there is only one capacitor switch, which reduces both charge transfer in the capacitive DAC network and the transitions of the control circuit and switch buffer, resulting in smaller power dissipation. This results in an 81% reduction of the total switching energy vs the conventional case [7]. On top to that, since the switching only goes in the downward direction and fast-settling NMOS transistors can be used for this, the ADC has a potentially high maximum conversion rate. A disadvantage of this technique is that, because of the fact that the common mode voltage at the input of the comparator lowers during the successive SAR cycles as shown in Fig. 3.4b, the signal-dependent comparator offset can cause a degradation in ADC linearity.
2.4 Discussion It is interesting to note that a lot of recent SAR improvements have focused on this reduction of capacitor switching energy. While in fact, it is often not the most power consuming block in the ADC. The implementation in [5] uses only 20% of the total power budget for this. The most efficient monotonic technique of [7] would have theoretically needed only about 7.5% of the total power, but just because of the digital buffers driving the switches this was increased to 16%. Designs targeting 8-bit resolutions have relaxed matching requirements and can use extremity small capacitor sizes to lower the switching energy [8, 9]. These numbers show that capacitor switching energy is not dominant and a shift in focus is needed for further efficiency improvements.
44
J. Craninckx
An aspect that in reality leads to a larger power consumption in other blocks is the fact that that the total SAR conversion takes 1 C N events, so certainly in highspeed designs only a limited amount of time can be attributed to each action. First, a powerful input voltage buffer is needed in order to make sure that during the (short) input sampling phase the voltage on the (large) capacitor array can settle accurately to the actual value. For the same reason also an accurate and high-speed reference buffer is needed to make sure that a stable reference voltage can be maintained during the charge-redistribution process. Second, the clock generation must be taken into account. Since the SAR algorithm runs at a speed higher than the actual conversion rate, a high-frequency clock is needed. This aspect was also already discussed in [5, 7], where asynchronous controllers are used. Thirdly, the comparator power must also be taken into account. This part is not easily quantified, as it heavily depends on the available or tolerable signal swing. Also the ADC speed requirements play an important role, as the comparator noise/power trade-off becomes more and more disadvantageous when very short evaluation times are needed. Of course, depending on the actual number of bits or conversion rate needed in a specific application, all these effects become more or less important. But they are not always taken into consideration when power consumption numbers are reported, so care must be taken. In the remainder of this paper, a novel charge-sharing SAR architecture will be presented that focuses on these aspect for the realization of lowpower ADCs.
3 Charge-Sharing Successive Approximation ADC Architecture The SAR ADC topology proposed does not need any high-speed buffers. Instead of operating in the voltage-domain, the useful signal is represented by charge. Its operation is explained in the following steps [10, 11].
3.1 Input Sampling An accurate charge proportional to the input signal must be created, and the most obvious way is of course to sample the input voltage on a capacitor. However, to avoid the problems of high-speed settling, a full conversion period must be available for this. If we manage to avoid that the input must be sampled on the binary capacitor array, but instead can be sampled on a separate capacitor, a time-interleaved Sample & Hold (S/H) can be used.
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
45
Ψ1 Φ2
CTH1
CLK
Φ1 TG1
Ψ1
BM1 CTL1 VQP
INP
rst
Φ2 Ψ2
0 0 1
1 1 1
0
1
0
1
CTL2 TG1
Φ1
1
0 1 0
Ψ2
rst BM1
1
Φ1 Φ2
CTH2
VQP INP VCM
Fig. 3.5 Single ended schematic of the time-interleaved S/H and relevant waveforms
The time-interleaved sampling circuit, shown in Fig. 3.5, processes a largeswing single-ended input signal with common mode level VCM typically around half of the supply voltage. The circuit is based on bootstrapped NMOS switches at the input (BM1) [12], offering a low, signal-independent on-resistance, and passgates at the output (TG1). When phase ˆ2 is active, the input signal is tracked on capacitors CTL1 C CTH1 while the charge previously sampled on CTL2 C CTH2 is already available for conversion. So after sampling, the capacitors CT hold a charge proportional to the input: Qin D CT Vin
(3.2)
An extension to the basic operation is the fact that, after the MSB will have been determined and the maximum differential voltage on the nodes VQP;N becomes smaller, the common mode voltage VCM can be lowered without the risk clipping the signal to ground. To create this CM shift, the connection of the capacitors CTH is switched from VDD to ground by the signal ‰ 1;2 . With this lower common mode, the on-resistance of NMOS switches that will be connected to the sampling nodes will significantly decrease, an effect that will show its benefit once the core of the SAR operation is explained.
3.2 Successive Approximation Operation After sampling, the analog-to-digital conversion can start. The most significant bit is determined first by using the comparator to check if the differential voltage on CT
46
J. Craninckx VQP c0n
CTP
c0p
c0p
CTN VQN
Precharge CMSB
Precharge
c0n
S/H Compare c0p c0n VQN
VQP
Fig. 3.6 Comparison and charge sharing action for MSB detection
is positive or negative. Depending on that decision, a signal proportional to half of the input range must be subtracted or added to the input signal. In order to avoid tough specs on the voltage settling time with opamps, we will not add a certain voltage to the signal, but instead add a charge. This operation can be done by passive charge sharing and happens very fast without taking any power. As shown in Fig. 3.6, this charge is taken from a capacitor of a certain size that has been pre-charged previously to a fixed reference voltage. If the comparator input voltage is positive (VQP > VQN ), the switches controlled by c0p are closed, after which the charges on the three capacitors (CTP , CTN and CMSB ) equalizes. The voltage VQN will rise and VQP will fall. Likewise, if the comparator input voltage is negative (VQP < VQN ) as in the figure, the switches controlled by c0n are closed, after which voltage VQN will fall and VQP will rise. The total charge on the capacitor set is now given by Q0 D CS Vin C S0 C0 Vref
(3.3)
where S0 represents the output of the comparator (C1 for positive,1 for negative signal). The time needed for this charge-sharing process is of course proportional
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
47
to the time constant given by the product of the switches on-resistance and the capacitor size. Since nmos switches are used for this, the on-resistance is improved by lowering the common-mode voltage as described earlier, and hence the ADC speed increases. It is crucial to note here that the reference voltage itself is not loaded by this action. During the pre-charge phase, that reference voltage was sampled on the capacitor CMSB , and it is that reference charge that is now used to provide the feedback DAC action required in the SAR ADC. The reference is thus independent on the input voltage, and the constraints posed on the reference buffer are almost negligible. Even if an error would have been made during the reference sampling, because of its independency on the input that would only result in a gain error of the ADC, which is not important. The following bit is determined in the same way, but now a precharged capacitor of size CMSB1 D CMSB /2 will be used, since in the binary search for the correct digital output code the range is now reduced by a factor 2. The sign of the voltage on the capacitor set formed by CT and CMSB represents the sign of the current signal Q0 , so the comparator can be used again to determine it. Depending on the comparator output, the switches c1p or c1n are closed, and the following charge sharing action between CTP , CTN , CMSB and the newly connected CMSB1 will cause the voltages VQP and VQN to rise or fall. Intuitively one can see that the SAR algorithm at each step uses these pre-charged capacitors to add or subtract a binary scaled-down charge to the initial charge (that represented the sampled input voltage) until the results converges to zero. If too much charge was added during a certain step, the next comparison returns the opposite sign, and in the next step the charge will be subtracted. The actual value of the voltage on the nodes (VQp,VQn) is not needed, just the sign is used to determine if the next binary scaled down capacitor (and hence, charge) must be connected positively of negatively.
3.3 First Block Diagram The block diagram of this initial charge-sharing SAR ADC architecture is shown in Fig. 3.7. As already explained, it consists of • a passive time-interleaved Sample&Hold with capacitors and switches • a binary scaled array of unit capacitors that are pre-charged to the reference voltage (e.g. the power supply) and afterwards connected positively or negatively to the sampling capacitor, depending on the outcome of the comparator • a comparator that returns the sign of the differential voltage on the sampling capacitors (VQP VQN ) • a control block that implements the SAR algorithm, i.e. – generate the control signals for the S&H switches – generate the signal precharge
48
J. Craninckx VQP
INP
4
2
1
N–1
M=2
CU
INN cn
cp
VQN cp[0..N–2] cn [0..N–2]
Sample & Hold
Precharge Comp
CLK Control block @FS
Result
B[0..N–1]
Fig. 3.7 Block diagram of initial charge-sharing SAR architecture
– go through a loop that for every bit of the ADC • activate the comparator • interprete the result and close one of the switches cp or cn – output the digital code that represents the digitized value of the input voltage.
3.4 Asynchronous Operation The synchronous operation of the control block described above would need a highfrequency clock, which has to be generated externally and hence also results in a power consumption penalty. Moreover, the maximum speed possible with the circuit is not exploited, as this way of working requires the control block to e.g. wait until the falling edge of the clock to close one of the switches cp or cn, although the comparator result S is already available earlier. All blocks (comparator speed, settling time for charge sharing) must be designed fast enough to certainly finish within the available clock period.
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
INp
INn
OUTp
Comp
49
OUTn
OUTp OUTn
Valid
Fig. 3.8 Comparator for asynchronous operation
An asynchronous operation must be implemented that removes the need for an extra high-frequency clock, and allows analog-to-digital conversion at the highest possible speed. The timing of this asynchronous controller is fairly simple, as a straightforward sequential list of actions must be taken during the binary search algorithm. It is further aided by the use of a comparator that also provides a ‘valid’ signal, as shown in Fig. 3.8. The comparator is based on [13]. The ‘valid’ signal goes high after the two crosscoupled inverters leave their metastable operating point, meaning one of the two sides has gone high. This means the comparison results is ready. This comparator circuit also has the nice feature that it is a fully dynamic implementation that does not consume any power when inactive, and thus enables for the whole ADC the feature that its power consumption scales linearly with the sampling frequency.
3.5 Binary Scaled Capacitor Array The linearity (INL/DNL) performance of a SAR ADC is determined by the INL/DNL performance of the feedback DAC, and thus by the matching of the capacitors in the binary scaled reference array. From [14] it can be derived that e.g. for 99.7% yield, the units of a 9bit DAC need a standard deviation less than 0.7%, which is the key number in determining the size of the reference capacitor array. With some margin, the total size is set at 2 pF, such that CMSB D 1 pF, CMSB1 D 0.5 pF, etc.
50
J. Craninckx VREF
Share1
16C
8C
4C
2C
C
C
Share2
C
Share3
C
C
Charge Ground Charge Ground Share1 Share2 Share3
Fig. 3.9 Example of the capacitor array for a 9-bit ADC with a 3 upscaled unit capacitor
The resulting LSB capacitor size now equals about 8 fF, which is obviously too small to be used. The parasitics from the connections will be too large w.r.t. the actual capacitance, and since the units can be positively or negatively connected to the sampling capacitor, any difference or mismatch in these parasitics deteriorates the INL/DNL behavior. An alternative for the most significant bits is certainly to use a bigger unit, e.g. eight times bigger. The capacitor controlled by c0p;n can now consist of 16 units of 60 fF, which is a value that can be practically used. The following one has 8 units, and so on until the one controlled by c4p;n which has 1 unit. For the next charge sharing, a 30 fF unit could be used, but this will not match correctly with a ‘half’ unit of 60 fF. Instead, since we only care about the amount of charge that we will connect to the sampling capacitors CT , a 60 fF capacitor can also be charged to half of the reference voltage. This is done by taking 2 units, keep one of them empty and charge the other one to VREF . If then a switch between them is closed, the charge redistributes evenly and on each one a charge of 60 fFVREF /2 remains. This one can be used for the charge sharing by switches c5p;n . Also the next bits can be done similarly. If we close a switch between the other unit with half of the charge and an empty one, on each of them we have one quarter of charge for the next bit, and so on. With this structure a practical size unit capacitor can be used, and an example of this capacitor array is depicted in Fig. 3.9. The effect of parasitics in the capacitor array must of course be evaluated carefully. In first order, the parasitics to the substrate of the unit capacitors do not pose a problem. They behave just as useful capacitors, i.e. they have a certain charge on them which will be connected to the positive or negative sampling capacitor and this way help to perform the DAC operation of the SAR ADC. Some constraints do apply however. First of all, the parasitics on both sides of the capacitor must be balanced. If not, connecting the units positively or negatively to the sampling capacitor will have a
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
51
different result. Therefore, the use of symmetric MoM capacitors that use lateral capacitance between a large number of closely space metal fingers is necessary. Capacitor structures that use vertical capacitance have obviously different parasitics on the top and the bottom plate. Mismatch of the parasitics will also result in missing the INL spec of the ADC, but since often no process data is available to estimate these mismatches, the only solution is to keep the parasitics small. An important part of the parasitics is caused by the switching transistors as well. Their drain-bulk and source-bulk junction constitute a non-linear capacitance. Their gate capacitance varies from very large to very small when the transistor switches from on to off. At first sight, this could be a performance-degrading effect, but to a first degree this nonlinearity is not important. The signal is represented by charge, and the fact that this charge is present on a nonlinear capacitance is of no importance. Besides matching, also sampling noise is an item that determines the minimum input capacitance of the ADC, and hence also the size of the reference array as these two are proportional. Each time a sampling switch closes, a noise power (given by the integrated noise voltage kT/C) remains on the capacitor. However, with capacitor sizes in the picoFarad range as dictated by matching requirements, kT/C noise is often negligible.
3.6 Comparator Noise Although also not obvious from the basic architecture of Fig. 3.8, care must be taken when designing the comparator. During the SAR algorithm, sometimes the input signal to the comparator is very small, and when this value becomes comparable to the inherent noise of the comparator, an error can be made. An elaborate analysis of the noise sources in a comparator falls out of the scope of this text, more details on this can be found in [15]. Comparator noise was the reason why the first prototype of the charge-sharing SAR that was implemented [10] had a measured performance that was worse than originally estimated. Reducing comparator noise by increasing its power consumption quickly has a detrimental effect on the overall energy efficiency, since for a 6 dB (2) noise reduction, a quadratic increase (4) in power is needed. To resolve this issue, a noise robust design approach to fully dynamic SAR ADCs was developed by leveraging redundancy in the search algorithm [11]. The strategy behind the proposed correction technique is the fact that during the SAR operation, at most two out of N comparisons are critical, i.e. the one when the signal is right below the threshold and the one when it is right above. All other comparisons will be done on a relatively large input signal, and hence can use a low-power but noisy comparator. A low-noise (higher-power) comparator is only needed for the critical decisions, but of course it is unknown when they will appear. However, one of them will certainly be the last one: an error in this decision can be avoided by using the comparator in its low-noise/high-power state. The other one can be any of the
52
J. Craninckx
a
High Noise Comp b0
b1
b2
Low Noise Comp b3
b4
b+ Vout = 11011 = 27
V QP
OK! Vout = 11011(0)
YES
NO
b4 == b+
Truth table
VQN
b
1
1
0
1
1
b0
b1
b2
b3
b4
VQP
Nth 0 1 1 0
0 b+
OR!
ERR
(N+1)th 1 0 1 0
Correction No No +1 –1
Vout = 11100–1 = 27 Vout = 11100(0) –1
b4 == b+
YES
NO 0 or 1
0 1 +1
VQN 1
1
1
0
0
0
Fig. 3.10 Correction algorithm for comparator noise (5b example) in case no error is made (a) and in case of error (b)
previous (N1) comparisons, and avoiding it by always employing a low-noise comparator is not power efficient. As shown in Fig. 3.10 for a 5b example, the SAR algorithm in the proposed redundant search algorithm uses the comparator in its high-noise state during the first (N1) iterations, thus allowing errors in these cycles. However, if H , the input comparator RMS noise in that mode, is less than one half of the LSB value, only one error can be made. The ADC then switches into its low-noise mode (with comparator input noise L H /2) to avoid errors for the Nth comparison, and an extra (N C 1)th iteration is added to correct for the error possibly made in the first phase. As shown in Fig. 3.10a, if the last two comparisons give different results, no error was made and no action has to be taken. On the other hand, in case the last two bits are equal, then a digital addition or subtraction needs to be performed on the final N-bit result. Being pipelined to the SAR conversion, the simple digital adder needed to correct does not work at the internal SAR frequency (N times the sampling frequency), thus limiting its power consumption. Importantly, the correction is effective not only for thermal noise, but also for other error sources, including static non-linearities, as far as they are not bigger than one LSB.
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
53
3.7 Comparator Offset In contract with classical charge-redistribution SARs, in the charge-sharing SAR offset of the comparator does have an effect on the INL/DNL performance. The reason for this is that the signal is represented by charge and the offset in the comparator is always a certain voltage. During the successive approximation process, the capacitance size is changing and hence the relationship between charge and voltage is not fixed. To make the comparator offset small enough not to have an effect, the same offset calibration technique as in [13] was again used, as already indicated by the varicaps shown in Fig. 3.8. At startup or at regular time intervals, the two inputs of the ADC must be shorted and the correct digital value must be searched that results in equal probability of a positive/negative comparator decision.
4 Implementation The ADC prototype that was designed to show the performance of the proposed techniques was implemented in a 90 nm 1 V 1P9M digital CMOS process [11]. The die photo is shown in Fig. 3.11. Only regular transistors and MoM-caps are used in the whole design, making it ideally suited for implementation in digital CMOS. Figure 3.12a shows the static INL/DNL performance when the correction is active. The peaks in DNL and INL are due to incomplete settling during the common mode switching, a small design mistake that could easily be corrected. The actual
Fig. 3.11 Nine-bit 40MS/s charge-sharing SAR ADC photograph
54
J. Craninckx
a
b 9
ENOB
1.5 1 0.5 0 –0.5 –1 –1.5 0
255
8.5 8
7.5
510
0
0.5
–20
[dBFS]
1
0 –0.5
1
21
ENOB = 8.23 Bit SNDR = 51.31 dB THD = 52.76 d B fln = 18.8821MHz N = 16384
–40 2nd
–60
–1
11
Freq [MHz]
7th
5th
3rd
–80 0
255
510
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Freq [MHz]
Fig. 3.12 (a) Measured INL/DNL plot; (b) ENOB vs. frequency and near-Nyquist FFT at 40MS/s
error caused by this effect is even worse (uncorrected INL/DNL is worse than C/1LSB), but as already stated the correction algorithm does not only detect errors cause by noise, but also this static nonlinearity. The peak resulting DNL and INL are 0.7/0.45 and 0.56/0.65 respectively. As shown in Fig. 3.12b, when the input signal is sampled at 40Ms/s, the measured ENOB is 8.56 (53.3 dB SNDR) at low frequencies, mainly limited by static distortion, and lowers to 8.23 at Nyquist. The effective resolution bandwidth extends up to 32 MHz. At 40Ms/s the ADC consumes 820 A from a 1 V supply voltage of which 290 A are drawn by the asynchronous controller, and 530 A are shared between the S/H, the pre-charging phase of the capacitor array, and the flexible comparator. Because of the dynamic architecture, power scales linearly with the sampling frequency. The resulting FoM is only 54 fJ per conversion step. Since this SAR ADC only contains digital gates, capacitors, switches and one comparator, it lends itself easily to further scaling in more advanced technology nodes. With decreasing CMOS features, the performance is expected to improve, since controller will become more power efficient and on top of that the capacitor sizes could be chosen smaller because of the improved matching characteristics. A new implementation of the charge-sharing SAR ADC in 40 nm CMOS as part of a full SDR transceiver [16] targets a resolution of 10 bit. This extra bit would normally require a 4 increase in the capacitors for matching, but because of the more advanced process node the total reference array size could be kept at 2 pF. Most of the building blocks (boosted input switch, capacitor array with 3 upscaled unit, controller, : : : ) have been simply ported into the new technology, the only serious effort needed for the new design was on the only analog block of the
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
55
Fig. 3.13 Low-noise comparator schematic
Fig. 3.14 Ten-bit 60MS/s SAR ADC in 40 nm CMOS
converter, i.e. the comparator. As the comparator noise becomes the limiting factor in the achievable ADC resolution, the new design uses a dynamic preamp and an improved latch timing of the second stage that uses internal signals instead of the external clock [17] (Fig. 3.13). A die photo of a separate test chip to evaluate the ADC performance is shown in Fig. 3.14 and the measurements are reported in Fig. 3.15. The maximal sampling speed is 60 MS/s, with a power consumption of 1.2 mW. At lower speeds, the power decreases proportionally. The maximum DNL and INL are 1.4 and 0.8 LSB, respectively. An SNDR of 54 dB (9.3 ENOB) is obtained, which results in a figure-of-merit of 34 fJ per conversion step.
56
J. Craninckx
a
b
c
Fig. 3.15 Measured ADC performance. (a) INL/DNL; (b) near-Nyquist FFT; (c) SNDR vs input frequency
5 Conclusions As has been shown by many publications in the last years, SAR ADCs have replaced the typical pipeline design in the application range of 8–10 bit accuracy and sampling speeds up to several 10’s of MHz. The simplicity of the SAR architecture
3 Low-Power Successive Approximation ADCS for Wireless Applications
57
makes it very well suited for implementation in nanoscale CMOS, and several improvements in capacitor switching strategy, asynchronous controller implementation and low-power comparator design has improved the power efficiency by an order of magnitude. Furthermore, the charge-sharing architecture is proposed which makes the load of the reference buffer signal-independent, thereby removing all constraints posed on the reference buffer by a high-speed ADC. With continuous scaling of CMOS technology nodes, and probably with some more architectural improvements, ADCs with a figure of merit of a few femtoJoules per conversion step will be just around the corner! Acknowledgment The work presented here is the result of the research on ADCs performed in imec’s wireless research group in the past years, and the author would like to acknowledge the contributions of all team members, an especially Vito Giannini, Geert van der Plas, Bob Verbruggen, and Takaya Yamamoto.
References 1. J. McCreary, P. Gray, All-MOS charge redistribution analog-to-digital conversion techniques – Part I. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 10(6), 371–379 (1975) 2. B. Ginsburg, A. Chandrakasan, An energy-efficient charge recycling approach for a SAR converter with capacitive DAC, in Proceedings of IEEE International Symposium Circuits and Systems, 2005, pp. 184–187 3. B. Ginsburg, A. Chandrakasan, 500-MS/s 5-bit ADC in 65-nm CMOS with split capacitor array DAC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 42(4), 739–747 (2007) 4. L.J. Svensson, J.G. Koller, Driving a capacitive load without dissipating fCV2, in IEEE Symposium on Low Power Electronics, 1994, pp. 100–101 5. M. van Elzakker, E. van Tuijl, P. Geraedts, D. Schinkel, E.A.M. Klumperink, B. Nauta, A 10-bit charge-redistribution ADC consuming 1.9 W at 1 MS/s. IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 45(5), 1007–1015 (2010) 6. C.-C. Liu, S.-J. Chang, G.-Y. Huang, Y.-Z. Lin, A 0.92 mW 10-bit 50-MS/s SAR ADC in 0.13 m CMOS process, in IEEE Symposium on VLSI Circuits Digest, June 2009, pp. 236–237 7. C.-C. Liu, S.-J. Chang, G.-Y. Huang, Y.-Z. Lin, A 10-bit 50-MS/s SAR ADC With a monotonic capacitor switching procedure. IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 45(4), 731–740 (2010) 8. P. Harpe, C. Zhou, X. Wang, G. Dolmans, H. de Groot, A 30fJ/conversion-step 8b 0-to-10MS/s asynchronous SAR ADC in 90 nm CMOS, in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, Feb 2010, pp. 388–389 9. P. Harpe, C. Zhou, X. Wang, G. Dolmans, H. de Groot, A 12fJ/conversion-step 8bit 10MS/s asynchronous SAR ADC for low energy radios, in Proceedings of European Solid-State Circuits Conference, Sept 2010, pp. 214–217 10. J. Craninckx, G. Van der Plas, A 65fJ/conversion-step 0-to-50Ms/s 0-to-0.7 mW 9b Charge sharing SAR ADC in 90 nm digital CMOS, in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, Feb 2007, pp. 246–247 11. V. Giannini, P. Nuzzo, V. Chironi, A. Baschirotto, G. Van der Plas, J. Craninckx, A 820 W 9b 40MS/s noise tolerant dynamic SAR ADC in 90 nm digital CMOS, in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, Feb 2008, pp. 238–239 12. M. Abo, P. Gray, A 1.5-V, 10-bit, 14.3-MS/s CMOS pipeline analog-to-digital converter. IEEE J. Solid State Circuits 34(5), 599–606 (1999)
58
J. Craninckx
13. G. Van der Plas, S. Decoutere, S. Donnay, A 0.16 pF/conversion-step 2.5 mW 1.25GS/s 4b ADC in a 90 nm digital CMOS process, in ISSCC Digest of Technical Papers, Feb 2006, pp. 566–567 14. A. Van den Bosch, Static and Dynamic Performance Limitations for High Speed D/A Converters (Springer, New York, 2004). ISBN 9781402077616 15. P. Nuzzo et al., Noise analysis of regenerative comparators for reconfigurable ADC Architectures. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I: Fundam. Theory Appl. 55(6), 1441–1454 (2008) 16. M. Ingels et al., A 5 mm2 40nm LP CMOS transceiver for a software-defined radio platform. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 45(12), 2794–2806 (2010) 17. M. Miyahara, et al., A low-noise self-calibrating dynamic comparator for high-speed ADCs, in Proceedings of IEEE Asian Solid-State Circuits Conference, Nov 2008, pp. 269–272
Chapter 4
Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta for Nanometer CMOS Technologies A. Di Giandomenico, L. Hernandez, E. Prefasi, S. Paton, A. Wiesbauer, R. Gaggl, and J. Hauptmann
Abstract This paper describes first the properties of Continuous-Time SigmaDelta ADCs which make this type of converters attractive for low-power and high-bandwidth applications. Cascaded architectures are analyzed as a possible way to further improve the analog bandwidth. The limits towards nanometer technology integration are then described, showing how the time-encoding theory can be successfully applied to overcome them. Two different implementations are introduced (PWM-based and VCO-based), and some case-studies are given to support the theories. Conclusions are drawn, with emphasis on possible future development steps.
1 Introduction Sigma-Delta ADCs are a valid and attractive solution to build converters with either a very high resolution (above 20-bits [8]) or a very high analog bandwidth (above 100 MHz [14]) while consuming a lower power if compared to other A/D types, such as SAR (for high resolution) or pipeline (for high bandwidth). Discrete-Time (DT) types are preferred when a high resolution in a narrow-band is required, due to the very good matching achievable between integrators gain and system
A. Di Giandomenico () • R. Gaggl • J. Hauptmann Lantiq, Villach, Austria L. Hernandez • E. Prefasi • S. Paton UCIIIM, Madrid, Spain A. Wiesbauer Infineon Technologies, Villach, Austria M. Steyaert et al. (eds.), Analog Circuit Design: Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 4, © Springer ScienceCBusiness Media B.V. 2012
59
60
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
a
b fs =
Amp[H(s)]
1
poles
Ts
u(t)
y(n)
zeros
H(s) DAC
UGF ADC Phase[H(s)] –180º PM
Fig. 4.1 (a) A classical CTSD converter and (b) Amplitude and phase of the open-loop transfer function
coefficients. On the other hand, Continuous-Time (CT) implementation presents someadvantages, when the target resolution is not very high (below 14-bits): • Built-in anti-alias filter: since the sampler is moved just before the internal ADC (see Fig. 4.1), the loop filter H(s) can be designed such that the signal transfer function (STF) has a low-pass characteristic. This can be realized efficiently by using multi-feedback architectures, although an interesting structure was proposed which uses explicit-filtering to provide high immunity to interferers [6]. This property can be used in the system where the CTSD is embedded, to simplify the receive chain, saving area and power. • High-impedance input stage: the input network of a CTSD is usually a simple resistor connected to the virtual-ground of the first integrator (Opamp-RC filter implementation) or a simple differential-pair of a transconductor (Gm-C filter implementation); this simplifies the design of the preceding filter, since it doesn’t need to drive a big switching load (like the one presented from other types of converters such as DT-SD, SAR or pipeline). Moreover, the input network can be made programmable quite easily (for instance with a programmable resistor), realizing in this way also a built-in PGA functionality [6]. The system design of the loop filter is done by placing first the poles to optimize the bandwidth and then by finding the zeros to recover stability. For a given loopfilter, the architecture of the CTSD can be chosen to target high analog bandwidth (BW) and low power consumption, by tuning some system parameters such as OverSampling-Ratio (OSR), loop-filter order or number of levels of the internal quantizer [3]. The physical limit towards BW increase is the maximum sampling frequency achievable in a given technology, while the limit towards power reduction is the current consumption of the active elements used. This paper aims to present two architectural strategies to push the CTSD beyond their limits: • Cascaded (MASH) architectures: increasing the OSR allows increasing the analog BW. When the clock frequency can’t be made higher, then the only option
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
61
to further increase the analog BW is reducing the OSR. Since high-order loops become unstable for low OSR, the architecture must be split into a cascade of low-order single-loop SD, still maintaining the overall high-order noise-shaping. • Time-Encoded quantizers: exchanging amplitude-quantization with timequantization allows replacing the power-hungry quantizer with structures simpler which consume less current and occupy less area. This exchange can be done at a price of a higher time resolution (which often means also a higher sampling rate), making these architectures particularly attractive for nanometer technologies. This paper is organized as follows: Chap. 2 gives an overview of the most important challenges for designing efficient CTSD converters; Chap. 3 describes how to extend the analog BW by using MASH topologies; Chap. 4 shows how the time-encoding theory can be effectively applied to the design for low-power and low-voltage applications; in Chap. 5 the conclusions are presented.
2 Challenges and Limitations of Classical CTSD One of the most important challenges for designing an efficient CTSD is to keep the modulator stable even with all the impairments imposed by the non idealities of the analog and digital building blocks. Another limitation of this type of converters – which must be considered in the noise budget since the beginning of the system design phase – is the high sensitivity to clock-jitter. This chapter describes all these challenges and shows the most common ways to reduce their undesired effects.
2.1 Modulator Stability and Excess Loop Delay As described in Fig. 4.1, the phase margin of the open-loop transfer function mainly depends on the location of the compensation zeros with respect to the in-band poles. If the OSR of the modulator is high enough, then the compensation is easy and a high phase margin can be achieved. On the other hand when the OSR becomes too low (typically below 16), then the order of the modulator must be increased to still achieve the target SNR: this leads to a loop filter design very aggressive, with reduced phase-margin and high sensitivity to coefficient deviation. Hence, when trying to increase the BW by reducing the OSR, all non-idealities leading to a phase-loss in the loop must be considered, and primarily two among all: the parasitic effects in the integrators and the digital latency in the feedback path.
2.1.1 Parasitic Effects in a Real Integrator The most severe non-idealities in a real integrator are the finite GBW of the OpAmp and the parasitic capacitance at the virtual-ground node, as shown in Fig. 4.2.
62
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
a
b
CINT RINT
RZ
CINT
RINT –
CPAR
–
+
CPAR
GBW
+
–
+ GBW + –
OpAmp Transfer Func Ideal Integrator Transfer Func
Real Integrator Transfer Func With compensation
FREAL FINT
Real Integrator Transfer Func
GBW
FLP
Fig. 4.2 A real integrator without (a) and with (b) zero-compensation
Given a first-order approximation of the OpAmp (considering the finite DC gain Av1), then the real transfer function of an ideal integrator with ¨int D 1/Rint Cint angular frequency, can be written as: Hint;real .s/ D GE Hint;ideal .s/ Hlp .s/ D GE
Tclk 1 s s Rint Cint 1 C 2F LP
(4.1)
The real transfer function is therefore affected by a gain-error GE and by a phaseloss equivalent to having a high-frequency pole FLP : GE D
1 1C
!int 2GBW
FLP D
! Cint int C GBW Cint C CPAR 2
(4.2)
From (4.2), one can see that both effects are proportional to the GBW of the OpAmp (which changes under different PVT conditions); the gain error mainly depends on how far is the GBW with respect to the integration frequency, while the parasitic pole mainly depends on how big is the parasitic capacitance with respect to the integrating capacitance. The gain error can only be compensated by re-tuning the integration frequency, though particular care must be taken to ensure that the GBW doesn’t change too much with the operative conditions. On the other hand, the phase-loss due to the parasitic pole can be compensated by adding one resistor in the feedback network to realize a pole-zero cancelation [46], such that:
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta... 1
63
2
u(t) H(s) DAC 4
3 DEM ?
FADC u(t) –
ADC-out
H(s)
A
τ = ELD, [0..1] e
–sττ
DAC Ideal delay-free subsystem
PMLOSS
Φ –180° PM
Fig. 4.3 (a) Excess loop delay and its effect in a CTSD converter
1 1 2 GBW D 1C RZ RINT C RZ !int
(4.3)
The compensating resistor Rz is usually very small (in the range of some hundreds of Ohms) and hence can’t be tuned. As a result, from (4.3), one can see that the cancelation works well only if the gain-bandwidth product of the OpAmp doesn’t vary too much with the operative conditions.
2.1.2 Analog and Digital Latencies in the Feedback Path In an ideal CT sigma-delta converter the digital data in the feedback loop is instantaneously generated in the quantizer when the clock edge arrives, is then instantaneously propagated via the feedback network down to the main DAC and is finally instantaneously converted into an analog signal at the summing node of the loop-filter. In real life, however, all these processes require some finite time to happen as in practice (see Fig. 4.3): 1. The comparators need some time to decide, depending on the input level 2. The digital buffers needed to drive the long feedback lines introduce a digital latency 3. If a DEM block is necessary to linearize the main DAC, then its latency must also taken into account (this is often the dominant delay source) 4. The response time of the main DAC is always finite
64
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
b
a +
Hsd(s)
+
–
Hsd(s)
–
+
+
–
fbe
D/A
c
D/A
d
Loop Filter H(s) x(t)
Loop Filter H(s)
Analog Adder
+
+
y(t)
x (t) A/D
+
–
y(t)
+ –
fbe
cint / s
A/D
Last Integrator
fbe¢ u(n)
v(n)
D/A
D/A
Inner D / A converter
Digital Differentiator
u(n)
Inner D / A converter
Fig. 4.4 (a, b) Excess loop delay compensation at system level and (c, d) some implementations
The latency introduced by the DEM block can be avoided by using different techniques to linearize the main DAC, such as background self-calibration [47]. To understand the effects of all these delays in the loop, one can build a simple model, using a single delay element in the feedback path to take into account the four non-idealities listed above. The phase loss introduced by this delay element is then proportional to the relative delay Td (compared to the clock period) and to the analog bandwidth (compared to the clock frequency): P MLOSS
1 / 2OSR
2 Td Tclk
(4.4)
Expression (4.4) tells that the effect is higher for low-oversampling converters, while it can be negligible if the OSR is high enough. Since in Low-OSR converter the loop filter is usually designed to be quite aggressive, any additional phase-loss can’t be tolerated and compensation techniques become unavoidable. One of the most used ELD-compensation consists in adding a high-frequency zero in the openloop transfer function, by a dedicated feedback loop just before the quantizer (see Fig. 4.4b) [1, 5]. One way to realize this loop is to build an additional D/A converter and an analog adder (see Fig. 4.4c); however, this solution is not really efficient, since it requires extra-hardware which costs area and power (the analog-adder should have also very high bandwidth, in order to maintain the high-frequency zero). An alternative and more efficient solution [9, 14] is to make use of the last integrator of the loop-filter (see Fig. 4.4d): in this case, the digital signal must
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
65
Fig. 4.5 A sensitive (a) and a less sensitive (b) Noise transfer function
be differentiated before the inner D/A converter, in order to compensate for the following integration. If the architecture of the modulator is multi-feedback, then the inner D/A converter can be also re-used by taking a digital adder to combine the normal digital signal to the ELD-compensation signal coming from the digital differentiator.
2.1.3 Effects of Clock Jitter The biggest drawback of CT sigma-delta modulation is the high sensitivity to clock jitter [1]. This is basically due to the fact that if the width of the pulse sent back in the loop by the main DAC varies randomly at each sampling process, it generates an error which is at least integrated once in the loop filter. If the spectral density of the clock jitter (assumed to be a random process uncorrelated with the input signal) surpasses the quantization noise density, it can limit the overall SNR. The only way to reduce the effects of clock jitter is to reduce the average-step-size (ASZ) of the modulator, and this can be achieved either by increasing the levels of the quantizer (using multi-bit D/A converters) or by reducing the oversampling ratio. However, in [4] a jitter-model was presented, which could be used to link the jitter-sensitivity to the spectral shape of the noise-transfer-function (NTF), hence finding a design criterion to minimize the variance 2dy of the ASZ: 2 Š dy
2 Q
2
Z
2
ˇ ˇ ˇ 1 e j! NTF.e j! /ˇ2 d!
(4.5)
0
Where 2Q is the variance of the jitter noise introduced at the quantizer, assumed white. From (4.5), one can see that the effect of the NTF are shaped by the weighting function Hw(¨)(1 ej¨ ), which gives more emphasis to the higher frequencies of the NTF (see Fig. 4.5).
66
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
3 MASH Topologies One way to look at a cascaded CTSD architecture is to describe the system like a 2-step sigma-delta, where (see Fig. 4.6): • The first stage produces a quantization error ©Q • The quantization error is sensed and sent to the second stage • The second stage amplifies the error to fit into the full-scale range and quantizes it again • A digital filter takes the two digital signals from the single-stages and combines them to cancel out the quantization error of the first stage This concept can be of course extended to N-step converters, with more than two stages. The biggest advantage of this architecture is that the order of the overall modulator is given by the sum of the order of the single stages, allowing for higher stability and lower achievable OSR. On the other side, the digital coefficients must have a perfect matching with the analog coefficients in order to guarantee a perfect cancellation of the quantization noise of the first stage, avoiding noise leakage which could degrade the overall SNR. The biggest challenge in CT MASH topologies is that the quantization error is usually not available in the circuit as it is in Discrete-Time SD-ADCs, because most of the designs use a continuous-time quantizer which does not provide the sampled information before quantization [11, 12]. In such architectures, the estimated quantization error transferred from one SD-stage to the next has a peakpeak value much higher than the actual sampled quantization error. The inter-stage gain must thus be reduced to avoid overloading of the succeeding stages, reducing the efficiency of the cascaded principle by the same factor.
Q1 x(t)
1 st Stage Sigma-Delta
Q
Digital Cancelation Filters NCF1 = STF2
y1(n)
+
Q2
– G
2 nd Stage Sigma-Delta
y2(n)
1/G
NCF2 = NTF1
Y = STF1·X-1 / G· NTF1·NTF2·Q2
Fig. 4.6 A cascaded CTSD
y(n)
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
67
Fig. 4.7 Block diagram of the 2–2 MASH converter
3.1 A Design Example In this chapter we present a MASH converter using a novel and simple inter-stage network, which does not overload the succeeding stages, thereby increasing the maximum stable amplitude and the dynamic range at the same time. The proposed architecture is shown in Fig. 4.7. The quantizers have been replaced with linear models. Each stage is implemented as a second order multiple feedback CTSD, so that the implicit anti-alias filter has a second order slope in each stage and a fourth order slope at the output of the cascaded CTSD. The quantization error is estimated by a simple linear combination of the two state variables of the first stage, removing the need of an extra DAC as is usually done [11, 12]. The values of the two coefficients K1 and K2 are chosen imposing that (1) the input of the second stage is a band-limited signal, (2) the transfer function from the first quantization noise to the output of the second stage is all-pass in-band, and that (3) the transfer function from the input signal to the input of the second stage is high-pass in-band. The removal of the extra DAC in the inter-stage network gives the advantage of power and area saving. The integrators are realized with OpAmp-RC cells, where the capacitors are tuned to compensate for process deviation. The feedback DAC connected to the first integrator of the first MASH-stage is self-calibrated. No mismatch-shaping logic is therefore needed in the digital feedback loop. This reduces the Excess-Loop-Delay of the modulator, which is fixed in this converter to ½ of the clock period. The Loop-Filter of the second stage is designed to be equal to the one used in the first stage.
68
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
Analog Bandwidth
40 MHz
30 MHz
Clock-Frequency
800 MHz
600 MHz
Dynamic-Range
63 dB
70 dB
Peak-SNR
60 dB
68 dB
Peak-SNDR
60 dB
68 dB
SFDR Total Power
79 dB
85 dB
110 mW, 1.5 V
100 mW, 1.5 V 1.2 mm
Area
2
0.13 μm CMOS
Technology
FFT @ VIN = –2dBFS / 2.8320 MHz 0 SNDR vs AIN
SNR = 58.8 dB SNDR = 58.8 dB DR = 60.6 dB
–20
70
SNDR [dB]]
50 40 30 SNDR (40MHz)
20
SFDR = 79 dB
–40 –60 –80
10 0
SNDR (30MHz)
–10 –20 –80
PSD [dB]
60
–60
–40 AIN [dBFS]
–20
0
HD2 = 92.2 dBc HD3 = 78.9 dBc HD4 = 90.4 dBc HD5 = 83.3 dBc
–100 –120
0
5
10
15
20 25 freq [MHz]
30
35
40
Fig. 4.8 Layout of the MASH prototype and measurement results
This prototype CTSD modulator has been fabricated in a digital 0.13 m CMOS process. The two digital cancellation filters are designed as FIR types (2-TAPs and 5-TAPs respectively) and emulated in a software platform off-line. The loop-filter coefficients and the sampling frequency are programmable to work in two modes. In the 40-MHz analog bandwidth (ABW) mode, the modulator is clocked at 800MHz; it achieves a DR of 63-dB and a peak-SNDR of 60-dB consuming 110-mW from a single 1.5 V supply. In the 30-MHz ABW-mode, the modulator is clocked at 600-MHz and achieves a peak-SNDR of 68-dB. Figure 4.8 shows a measured output spectrum and the SNR as a function of the input signal. An FFT-plot of the output is also included for the 40-MHz mode, and the in-band zoom reveals a 79-dB SFDR for a -2dBFS sine (FS D 1.5 Vpp-diff).
4 New CTSD Architectures Towards Nanometer Technologies Integrating CTSD converters in nanometer technologies would allow for achieving higher bandwidths without power consumption penalty; however, the integration of these converters is limited by the growing difficulty of implementing circuits with high amplitude accuracy. Many problems concur to make this difficult: the implementation of the embedded multi-bit A/D and D/A converters. The main problem is the limited dynamic range of the comparators in a low voltage technology, which degrades the linearity of the quantizer.
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
69
As CMOS technology scales towards smaller feature sizes, it is getting more difficult to design circuits with high amplitude accuracy. This is due to several problems: the threshold voltages of the transistor keep almost constant, while the supply voltages decrease; the intrinsic gain of the transistor reduces, requiring more and more cascading topologies to achieve same linearity; current sources and current mirrors have lower output impedance and a higher leakage current, requesting trimming and calibration procedures. On the other hand, nanometer technologies offer digital operations at a speed faster and faster and at an area-cost smaller and smaller. It becomes then advantageous trying to port some power-hungry operations in the CTSD modulator from the analog-domain to the digital-domain, and the most interesting area for improvements seems to be the embedded Flash A/D in the CTSD loop: here the main problem is the limited dynamic range of the comparators in a low voltage technology, which degrades the linearity of the quantizer. The “tracking-quantizer” [7] has been one of the first attempts to reduce the analog complexity of this block at a cost of more sophisticated digital circuits. However it suffers from a limited slew-rate, which can become a problem if high immunity to out-of-band interferers must be guaranteed (especially in feed-forward CTSD structures with no anti-alias built-in function). To leverage the hardware possibilities opened up by the increased maximum clock frequency of the digital circuits, one more efficient solution has been explored in the recent past: turning the amplitude-quantization into time-quantization thereby focusing on time-based analog signal processing instead of voltage- (current-) based analog signal processing, as explained in Fig. 4.9. The background of this idea is that the analog signal v(t) coming from the feedback-path is being processed by a Continuous-Time integrator (the first CTSD stage); hence, the most important information which v(t) brings in the loop is the area of the DAC pulse, which is proportional to the quantized amplitude of the DAC-output. The same information (i.e. the same area of the DAC pulse) can indeed be propagated if the amplitude of the DAC-output keeps constant, while the pulse duration becomes quantized in time. To make this idea possible, two building blocks can be defined to realize a Single-Bit Time-Encoded ADC equivalent to the standard multi-bit FLASH ADC: a Time-Encoder and a high-speed sampler. The Time-Encoder converts the amplitude of the input signal into a sequence of continuous-time pulses having the same amplitude but different duration and/or period. Such a block has the following characteristics: • It oscillates at rest (i.e. when the input signal u(t) is null) at a free-running frequency Fo, providing a well defined pulse width and period. • The duration of the pulse (referred to the instantaneous oscillation period) is modulated by the amplitude of the input signal u(t), providing a phase and/or frequency variation of the generated signal p(t). • The free-running oscillation Fo is in the same order of the sampling frequency Fs of the equivalent multi-bit FLASH ADC.
70
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
a
b u(t)
y(n)
p(t)
u(t)
p(t)
x(n)
Fs
TDC Single-Bit TE-ADC
FLASH ADC u(t)
p(t)
y(n)
u(t)
Time Encoder
Fc x(n)
p(t)
Time Decoder
Sampler
v(t)
v(t) D/A
D/A N-bit @ Fs
1-bit @ Fc
Ts = 1 / Fs
To = 1 / Fo ROSR = To / Tc
v(t)
v(t) ~ y(n)
COSR = Ts / To
v(t)
Tc = 1 / Fc
Fig. 4.9 (a) Classical multi-bit quantizer within a CTSD loop and (b) an alternative equivalent Single-Bit Time-Encoding-ADC
The high speed sampler must run at a frequency Fc much higher than the free-running oscillation Fo of the Time-Encoder; the Ratio-Over-Sampling-Ratio (ROSR D Fc/Fo) is a measure of the ability of the sampler to digitize the timedomain information contained in the time-encoded analog signal (it’s equivalent to the number of digital levels that a quantizer is able to resolve in a FLASH ADC). In some implementations there is not a physical high speed sampler, as it is embedded in a Time-to-Digital-Converter (TDC) block, where multiple phases of the lowfrequency Fs clock are derived and distributed to a bank of latches, which sample the time-encoded continuous-time signal on different time edges. Although this idea looks simple, many system aspects must be considered, such as the relative position of the free-running oscillation frequency of the TimeEncoder with respect to the system clock Fs of the equivalent CTSD (defined by the ratio COSR D Fo/Fs) and such as the stability of the main CTSD loop. Also the Time-Encoder type plays a significant role, and in some cases additional analog or digital filtering is required in the feedback loop, as better explained in the next section. In general, the implementation of the architecture proposed in Fig. 4.9b looks quite attractive for many reasons: • The multi-bit FLASH ADC can be replaced by a simpler single-bit structure, with a big area and power saving potential: the simpler structure can be either a single comparator or a VCO, as it will be explained in the next section.
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
71
• The multi-bit DAC is replaced by a single-bit DAC, which is an inherently linearblock: no DEM block is needed any more in the feedback path, reducing in this way the ELD and making the loop-filter design much easier. In opposite to these positive aspects, the biggest drawbacks of Single-Bit TimeEncoding CT sigma-delta are mainly some toughest requirements on the clock generation and distribution to the modulator. This architecture suffers indeed of: • An increased sensitivity to clock-jitter, which can be considered to be half-way between a standard multi-bit CTSD and a standard single-bit one. • A high sensitivity to deterministic mismatch between time-edges (for those implementations using multi-phase TDC) which can be turned into signal distortion. Indeed, the architecture proposed in Fig. 4.9b is completely different from a standard single-bit CTSD running at clock frequency Fc (i.e. the same structure shown, where only the Time-Encoder is removed). In the latter case, the loop filter would be designed for an OSR much higher, and the average-step-size [4] during normal operation would be also much higher. For this reason the sensitivity to clock-jitter of the single-bit Time-Encoded CTSD is much lower than the standard single-bit CTSD. However, since the height of the pulse at the output of the feedback DAC is always higher than the height of the equivalent multi-bit CTSD in Fig. 4.9a, this latter architecture will still result in a lower sensitivity to clock-jitter. The exact influence of clock-jitter to modulator noise strictly depends on the way the highspeed clock Fc is generated: • In some implementations, this high-frequency clock is directly derived from the main clock source (PLL): in this case the jitter requirement is directly One way to overcome this limitation and to reduce the sensitivity to clock-jitter of TE-based CTSD is to convert the single-bit stream back into a multi-bit stream by using an additional Time Decoder in the feedback loop, between the ADC and the DAC, as shown in Fig. 4.10. This alternative architecture has now only half of the benefits of the Single-Bit one, since the DAC is again multi-bit and for highresolution converters DEM logic is again necessary. However, the implementation of the Time-Decoder which follows the sampler depends on the particular type of the Time-Encoder. Although in some cases it is not possible to achieve the low-latency required by the SD loop to maintain the ELD below the stability-limit, in some other cases it can be realized by means of compact Time-to-Digital-Converters (TDC), which are able to reconstruct the multibit stream at the original sampling rate Fs. As these TDC blocks are built with purely digital cells, their area and power penalty will become more and more negligible with the scaling of the technology. The implementation of the Time-Decoder which follows the sampler clearly depends on the particular type of the Time-Encoder; in some cases it is not possible to achieve the low-latency required by the SD loop to maintain the ELD below the stability-limit, making this multi-bit approach practically unfeasible. In some other
72
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
u(t)
p(t)
y(n)
Fs
Fc
x(n)
Tc = 1 / Fc
Ts = 1 / Fs
Multi-Bit TE-ADC u(t)
Time Encoder
p(t)
y(n)
Time Decoder
x(n)
Sampler
TDC v(t) D/A N-bit @ Fs
Fig. 4.10 A Multi-Bit Time-Encoding-ADC within a CTSD loop
cases, the sampler and the decoder can be realized by means of Time-to-DigitalConverters (TDC), which are able to reconstruct the multi-bit stream at a lower rate (usually the original sampling frequency Fs of the equivalent CTSD).
4.1 Basics of Time-Encoding ADC: Theory and Examples For a structured analysis of the Time-Encoded CTSD systems described in Figs. 4.9b and 4.10, it helps the classifications based on the specific Time-Encoder which makes the Amplitude-to-Time mapping [22]: 1. PWM-based TE-ADC: a Pulse-Width-Modulator (PWM) is used as TimeEncoder, and the way the modulation is produced leads to the two following sub-categories: (a) Synchronous PWM [24]: the pulse-width modulated waveform is generated by comparing the input signal with a periodical waveform (usually a saw-tooth or a triangular-shape) synchronous with the master clock. (b) Asynchronous PWM [18, 19, 26, 30]: the pulse-width modulated waveform is generated with a self-oscillating loop fulfilling the Barkhaussen phase criterion. The main difference between the two subcategories here above defined, is that the self-oscillation frequency is fixed and constant in the synchronous
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
73
systems, while it depends on the input signal (amplitude and frequency) in the asynchronous ones. 2. VCO-based TE-ADC [21, 28]: in such systems a Voltage-Controlled-Oscillator is used as Time-Encoder to generate the oscillation at rest; the VCO output can then be perturbed (in frequency and/or phase) by the input signal to the TE-ADC, thereby mapping the amplitude-to-time information.
4.2 PWM-Based CTSD ADCs There are two types of Time-Encoded ADCs [22] (synchronous and asynchronous) based on Pulse Width Modulators (PWM) and their most common implementations are shown in Fig. 4.4. In the former category a fixed frequency square pulse stream is produced, where the width of each pulse is proportional to the amplitude of the sampled continuous time input signal. A saw-tooth signal generator and a comparator are used, and it has been shown that different type of triangular waveforms can lead to different results [20]. When closed in the Sigma-Delta loop, the non-linearity of the ramp generator is attenuated by the loop-gain, so its implementation is normally easy and very efficient. In an Asynchronous PWM Time-Encoded ADC, the oscillation is induced by a positive feedback fulfilling the Barkhaussen phase criterion. The input signal is then added to the feedback signal, perturbing the phase and frequency of the oscillation itself. Figure 4.11b shows the block diagram of a typical implementation, composed of a comparator, a loop filter H(s) and a delay element. Since the loop-filter (usually one integrator) is not sufficient to reach the required 180ı phase, to induce a stable oscillation, the phase of the loop is increased by a delay-block in the feedback path or by introducing hysteresis in the comparator. The oscillation frequency (so called limit-cycle) at rest and the dynamics of the system are nontrivial and need to be established in approximately [19]. One of the biggest challenge of these systems is to control (via tuning or tracking) the limit-cycle frequency over PVT variations (process, voltage, temperature) and also over the whole variety of input signals (amplitudes and frequencies). It can be proven [19] that both of the PWM time-encoding architectures do realize ideal signal coders that do not introduce any error, given that the input signal is band limited and the self-oscillation frequency is sufficiently high. In both cases, to implement a practical decoder with digital logic running with a synchronous clock, the PWM signal must be sampled first. The decoder performs the Time-toDigital-Conversion, i.e. measures the pulse width within a discrete set of values, thereby introducing a time-quantization noise. For this reason, the resolution of a TE-ADC built with this principle is directly proportional to the sampling frequency Fc, which determines the number of discrete-time values resolvable by the TDC (or, in turn, by the achievable time-resolution of the TDC when implemented with multiple-phases of the low-speed Fs clock). When used in combination with a CTSD, then it is convenient placing the TDC decoder within the SD loop, such
74
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
a
Fs TDC Fc
u(t)
+
From Loop Filter
y(n)
–
T&H
Time Decoder
Sampler
Ramp Gen
To Main DAC
Time-Encoder
b
PWM sampled signal
TDC Fc
u(t) From Loop Filter
y(n)
+
–
H(s)
Time Decoder
Sampler Td Delay
Time-Encoder
To Main DAC
PWM sampled signal
Fig. 4.11 (a) Synchronous PWM, (b) Asynchronous PWM
that the time-quantization error gets shaped by the NTF of the Sigma Delta itself, allowing for easier implementation. Is worthwhile to mention that for asynchronous modulators, a perfect recovery algorithm also exists, although it is quite complicated [17] and would require a very sophisticated digital reconstruction filter.
4.2.1 Synchronous PWM CTSD – Case Studies One recent example of a Single-Bit Synchronous PWM Sigma-Delta ADC is given in [24, 26, 29] and the block diagram of such a system is given in Fig. 4.12. The CTSD modulator implements a third order feed-forward architecture, with an active-RC inv-chebyshev filter. An additional feedback loop realizes the ELD compensation by placing a high-frequency zero in the NTF [1]. The triangular waveform used in the PWM generator is realized by integrating the master clock square-wave with a simple active integrator (switched-current sources driving a capacitive load [24]). Double sampled PWM [16] is used to eliminate the harmonics of the input signal (minimize the distortion) as compared with single sampled PWM. The high-speed sampler working at 12.5 GHz does not exist as a unique block in the circuit, being this embedded in a compact time-to-digital converter. The TDC decoder is realized by using 50 different latches, each one triggered by a different phase of the master clock (Fs D 250 MHz), achieving an equivalent sampling of the
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
Fs = 250 MHz
75
Fc = 12.5 GHz Single-Bit TE-ADC
Fs = 250 MHz
PWM-mod +
H(s) –
+
+ –
Time Decoder
–
Loop Filter
y(n) [50 lev @ 250MS / s]
Sampler TDC fbe pq(t) D/A 1
D/A 1
Fig. 4.12 The Synchronous PWM CTSD presented in [24]
PWM signal of 12.5 GHz. The re-sampled single-bit feedback signal is then sent back in the CTSD loop, using different DAC types for the two loops: • a differential-pair as the “main-DAC” for high PSRR requirement • a CMOS digital driver (connected to the supplies) as the “fbe-DAC” for power reduction The sensitivity to the jitter of the master-clock Fs of this converter is very low [24], since the TDC architecture generates a DAC pulse with one rise-edge and one fall-edge in each clock period Ts. The resulting waveform can be therefore considered a Return-to-Zero code with very low pulse-width jitter ı£2 and very high delay clock jitter ıtd 2 , resulting therefore quite robust [33]. The pulse-width jitter depends mainly on the size of the delay line used for the multi-phase clock generation: this implies that jitter sensitivity can be exchanged with area and power of the TDC. Increasing the size of the unity elements composing the delay line helps also to reduce the distortion due to static mismatch between them. The time-quantization noise generated in the TDC is similar to the amplitudequantization of the equivalent quantizer, but for the same sampling frequency Fs and for the same number of levels, the noise floor of the time-quantizer results higher (8 dB in this example); this is due to the aliasing of the high-frequency tones of the PWM continuous-time signal (harmonics of the free-running frequency and intermodulation products with the input signal) which are folded in band.
76
A. Di Giandomenico et al. FFT Spectrum of pq(t)
FFT Spectrum of y(n)
0 NTF peak Magnitude (dBFs)
Magnitude (dBFs)
0 NTF peak
–20 –40 –60 –80
–20 –40 –60 –80
–100
–100 10
6
107
107
106
109
108
108
Frequency (Hz)
Frequency (Hz) Fs = 250 MHz Fc / 2 = 6.25 GHz
Fs / 2 = 125 MHz
SNR, SNDR (dB)
Limited DR
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 –10
SNR SNDR
–80
–60
–40
Amplitude (dBFs)
–20
0
Analog Bandwidth
20 MHz
Clock-Frequency Fc
12.5 GHz (equivalent)
Clock-Frequency Fs
250 MHz
Dynamic Range
68 dB
Peak-SNR
62 dB
Peak-SNDR
60 dB
Total Power
10.5 mW @ 1.2 V
Technology
CMOS 65 nm
Fig. 4.13 Some measurement results of the Synchronous PWM CTSD presented in [24]
Figure 4.13 shows some measurement results, where the FFT of the signal before decoding and after decoding are shown. The FFT plot of the PWM signal pq(t) clearly shows a high out-of-band (OOB) energy due to the oscillation tone and its multiples. The NTF-peak contributes to the OOB power which is sent back into the loop-filter and reveals a design closed to the instability margin, despite the help of the compensation fbe-DAC. The OOB high-energy constrains the first Op-Amp of the loop filter to have a high gain-bandwidth product and limits also the dynamic range of the modulator, as it can be seen in the SNR versus input amplitude plot.
4.2.2 Single-Bit Asynchronous PWM CTSD – Case Studies When the asynchronous Time-Encoding ADC shown in Fig. 4.11b is embedded into a CT Sigma-Delta converter, the resulting structure is shown in Fig. 4.14a. The architecture can be further improved, by moving the sampler inside the PWM loop (see Fig. 4.14b) and then by moving the PWM-filter H(s) in the feedback path (see Fig. 4.14c), realizing in this way a Single-Bit Time-Encoding-Quantizer (TEQ, [25]). Due to the nature of the limit-cycle generated by the asynchronous modulation (it is not constant, but depends on amplitude and frequency of the input signal), the exact time-decoder filter would require a very high hardware complexity [17,
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
a
77
Fc v(t)
x(t) +
–
w(t) +
Hsd(s)
–
p(m)
Time Decoder
H(s)
y(n)
Sampler Td PWM sampled signal
Delay
Time-Encoder u(t) D/A
b
Fc w(t)
v(t)
x(t) +
+
Hsd(s)
–
–
p(m)
Time Decoder
H(s)
y(n)
Sampler u(t) Td
D/A
Delay
Time-Encoder
c
Fc v(t)
x(t) +
Hsd(s)
– u(t)
Loop-2
w(t) +
p(m)
u(m) H(z)
– Loop-1 H(s)
Sampler p(t) D/A
Time-Encoding-Quantizer
Td Delay
Equalizer
y(m) S(z)
y(n) ROSR
Oscillation Removal (Sync) Time-Decoder
Fig. 4.14 The Asynchronous PWM CTSD architecture
19]. Instead, a simple time-decoder can be built as a cascade of an equalization filter H(z) – the digital equivalent of the PWM filter H(s) – and an oscillationremoval filter S(z) – a sync-filter is sufficient for the purpose – which decimates also the digital stream down to the equivalent sampling frequency Fs. Since this modified system present two loops, the dynamics of the signals involved depend on the design of the two filters H(s) and Hsd(s): by proper placement of poles and zeros, it can be guaranteed that at low-frequencies the outer loop (Loop-2 in Fig. 4.14c) dominates, while at high-frequencies the inner PWM-loop (Loop-1 in Fig. 4.14c) becomes dominant. By doing so, one can virtually split the feedback signal path in a way that most of the OOB energy circulates mainly in the inner loop (providing the oscillation at the limit-cycle) and that most of the in-band power circulates in the outer loop (giving to the SD the optimal signal to be cancelled on the input adder). As a result, this modified architecture presents multiple advantages: • Since the PWM filter H(s) has usually a high-frequency low-pass characteristic (can be also a high-frequency integrator), it attenuates the high OOB energy of the signal p(t), it helps to increase the dynamic range of the CTSD modulator, as more dynamic is then available in the loop filter Hsd(s) for the input signal x(t). • As the inner loop (Loop-1 in Fig. 4.14c) provides already a first order shaping to the time-quantization error of the sampler in the TEQ, the intrinsic SNR of the TEQ stand-alone is increased (also thanks to the high OSR). • If the clock Fc is affected by jitter, then the jitter-error-signal at the output of the D/A (which is a stream of very narrow pulses produced every time p(t) changes
78
A. Di Giandomenico et al. Ca1
Ra
Vi x(t) + –
Rx2 Ci2
Ci1
Rx1
R1 + – –+
+
R2
+
+– – +
–
R1
Ca2
–
R2 Rx1 C i1
u(t)
Rx2
Tunable Lowpass
Latch
v(t)
Delay clk
Rx3 C i3
Ca2
Ci2
Vdac1 –
+
Ra
CLK = 2.56 GHz
Vco
v(t)
+– – +
R3
Comp Vci clk
Rx3 Ci3
R3
Passive Adder
DAC 1
Data-Out
Ca1
Outer-Loop
DAC 2
FFT plot of feedback signals in Loop-2 Fc
+
v(t)
–
Hsd(s)
+
Loop-2
BEFORE H2(s)
–20 AFTER H2(s)
–
–40 Loop-1
u(t)
0
p(m)
w(t)
Sampler p(t)
H1(s)
dBFs
x(t)
D/A
Td Delay
–60 –80 –100 –120
p2(t) H2(s)
D/A
–140 10
6
10
7
10
8
10
9
Freq (Hz.)
Fig. 4.15 The Asynchronous PWM CTSD presented in [30]
polarity and which has a high OOB frequency content) is also attenuated by the low-pass filter H(s) before it’s subtracted from the input signal x(t); this clearly reduces the jitter sensitivity of the modulator. As the derivation of the limit-cycle frequency is not easy, the design methodology of such converters is more complex and has been in details explained in [19, 25]. In short, three important parameters must be determined, to make the PWM-based oversampled converter shown in Fig. 4.15c equivalent to the standard CTSD shown in Fig. 4.8a: 1. PWM loop gain: although the oscillation can be easily guaranteed at rest, the dynamics of the loop may be perturbed when an input signal v(t) is applied to the TEQ. The filtered signal u(t) can be considered to be a triangular signal, if the filter H(s) is an integrator or a low-pass filter with very low cut-off frequency as compared to the limit-cycle frequency. When the slope of the input signal v(t) becomes comparable with the slope of the ramp-signal u(t), then the oscillation could be lost, leading the modulator into overload condition. To avoid that this occurs, a sufficiently high gain kg must be chosen in the feedback DAC of the inner loop. The minimum value of the gain kg depends mainly onto the ratio between the oscillation tone ¨O and the maximum input frequency and amplitude, ¨B and A [19] (the maximum amplitude A can be seen also as the full-scale input voltage of the Time-Encoded-Quantizer shownin Fig. 4.14c):
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta... Table 4.1 System parameters of the PWM CTSD presented in [30]
79
Parameter
Value
Analog BW CTSD OSR/Fs Kg COSR/Fosc ROSR/Fc TEQ resolution
20 MHz 16/640 MHz 6.7 0.5/320 MHz 8/2.56 GHz 4.7 bits
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ j !S ˇ ˇH j !S ˇ kg A j1 C H.j !B /j jH.j !O /j D A ˇˇ1 C H ˇ ˇ 2 OSR COSR ˇ (4.6) 2. Relation between ¨S and ¨O : due to the sampling error, the time when the digitized signal p(m) changes polarity will be always delayed as compared to its analog representation w(t). This introduces a time-varying delay which, in average, will be always smaller that TO (the oscillation period itself). Since this delay may cause the sigma-delta loop to become unstable, it must be kept always below the maximum tolerable excess loop delay EMAX (expressed as a portion of the sampling period Ts). As a rule of thumb, one can assume that the oscillation period must be always smaller than twice the maximum tolerable ELD [19], yielding to: COSR D
!O TS 1 > D !S 2 .EMAX / TS 2 EMAX
(4.7)
3. Relation between the quantizer resolution and the sampler frequency Fc: the time-quantization error introduced by the uniform sampler can be reduced by increasing the sampling frequency Fc. The minimum value of the Ratio-Oversampling-Ratio (ROSR) required to obtain an error lower than the quantization error of an equivalent classical amplitude quantizer with N LEV levels can be estimated to be [19]: ROSRmin D
!C 2NLEV > 2P !O kg
(4.8)
Where P is the amplitude of the PWM signal before quantization (usually it’s 1). Once these three parameters are computed, the Single-Bit Time-EncodedQuantizer (TEQ) is ready for integration into a CT Sigma-Delta converter. Many designs have been proposed to implement system in Fig. 4.14c [25, 27] and the most efficient one, presented in [30], is described in Fig. 4.15. The most important system parameters are listed in Table 4.1.
80
A. Di Giandomenico et al. FFT Spectrum of p(m) for a small signal
FFT Spectrum of p(m) for a big signal
0
0
NTF not peaking
Limit Cycle moving
–20 PSD [dBFS]
PSD [dBFS]
–20 –40 –60 –80 –100
–40 –60 –80 –100
–120 105
106
108 107 Frequency [Hz]
109
–120 105
106
107
8
10
109
Frequency [Hz]
Fosc ~ 320 MHz Fc / 2 = 1.28 GHz Extended DR
70 SNR SNDR
SNR/SNDR [dB]
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 –70
–60
–50 –40 –30 –20 Relative input leve [dBFS]
–10
0
Analog Bandwidth
20 MHz
Clock-Frequency Fc
2.56 GHz
Clock-Frequency Fs Dynamic Range
640 MHz (equivalent) 63 dB
Peak-SNR
63 dB
Peak-SNDR Total Power Technology
61 dB 7.0 mW @ 1.0 V CMOS 65 nm
Fig. 4.16 Some measurement results of the Asynchronous PWM CTSD presented in [30]
The loop filter realizes a multiple feed-forward architecture where the last integrator is used also as capacitive adder of all state-variables. The two feedback loops are split for a different optimization of the D/A converters: • DAC1 in the inner loop: uses as reference voltages the supply rails, with more noise and more gain • DAC2 in the outer loop: uses low-noise reference buffers The analog filters in the feedback path are realized with a passive implementation, boosting the efficiency of the overall modulator. A programmable high frequency pole is used in the filter H1(s) of the inner loop to tune the limit-cycle frequency over process deviation. A low-frequency pole is used in the filter H2(s) of the outer loop to dump the OOB energy in the loop filter, enhancing in this way the Dynamic Range of the modulator. Figure 4.16 shows some measurement results, where the FFT of the singlebit output is compared for different values of the input amplitude. It can be seen that the peak of the limit-cycle (and its harmonics) is very dominant for lowamplitudes, while it becomes more flattened (and moves to lower frequency) for higher values. The NTF does not peak significantly, revealing a robust design with enough stability-margin, despite there’s no use of any ELD compensation technique.
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
a
81
Fc v(t)
x(t) +
–
Hsd(s)
w(t) +
u(m)
y(m)
H(z)
p(t)
H(s) Loop-2 Time -Encoding
1-bit D/A
S(z)
Equalizer
Sampler
Loop-1
u(t)
p(m)
–
Oscillation Removal (Sync)
Td Delay
- Quantizer
y(n) ROSR
Time-Decoder
M-bit D/A
b p ( t)
α
1-bit D/A
Time-Encoding-Quantizer p(m)
Fc Loop-1
w (t) +
–
a1/s
+
–
a1/s
+
–
–d
a1/s
z
Fs
Loop-2 M-bit D/A
Time Decoder
y(n)
Edge detect
u(m)
–1
z
1–z
–1
Digital Integrator
Fig. 4.17 A multi-bit Asynchronous PWM CTSD architecture proposed in [17]
The OOB high-energy is attenuated by the filter H2(s) (see Fig. 4.15); hence the design of the first Op-Amp of the loop filter is more relaxed and the dynamic range of the modulator is extended, as it can be seen in the SNR versus input amplitude plot.
4.2.3 Towards Multi-Bit Asynchronous PWM CTSD If the clock speed is already at the edge of the technology, getting more resolution from the Asynchronous PWM CTSD converters can be achieved by increasing the number of levels of the time-encoding quantizer [19] as shown in Fig. 4.17a. This can be accomplished by moving the Equalization filter H(z) inside the outer loop (Loop-2) which will act as the previous analog filter H(s) for the outer loop. The two loops are now independent one from each other, being the inner one still realized with Single-Bit D/A converter. The design procedure of such a converter is the same as the one described in the next section. If the parameter ROSR has been chosen to be the minimum, according to (4.8), then the number of levels for the multi-bit DAC in Loop-2 will be the same as the levels of the quantizer of the equivalent standard CTSD system: NDAC2 D log2
kg ROSR 2
(4.9)
82
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
One interesting design example is also presented in [19] (see Fig. 4.17b), presenting the following characteristics: • The equalizer H(z) is realized with an integrator, which can be implemented as an up/down counter running with the high-frequency clock Fc (the same as the comparator) • The sampling and interpolation operations can be implemented with a row of two M-bit registers running at the low-speed clock Fs • One DEM module might be needed before the multi-bit DAC, in case its static non-linearity does not meet the distortion requirement • The last integrator of the loop-filter can be reused also within the inner loop, to realize the pulse-width modulation If the implementation of the digital integrator is unfeasible due the tough latency requirement (to meet the maximum ELD target), then a hybrid solution has been also proposed, by combining the digital filter in the feedback with the D/A converter, employing a single-bit FIR-DAC [23].
4.3 VCO-Based CTSD ADCs Time encoders using a VCO can also be used to directly implement an ADC. Its principle relies in a very simple fact. If we periodically sample the number of complete cycles of an oscillator that fit within a given sampling time, we will have an estimate of the frequency of the oscillator. Due to the fact that the phase state of the oscillator may not be an integer number of periods within the sampling period, the phase error is accumulated for the next estimation, which results in a first order noise shaping of the quantization error. To implement a data converter we only need to control the oscillator frequency by a voltage such that input voltage maps directly into a digital code. Strictly speaking, such data converter is not a sigma delta modulator, because there is no feedback loop. Instead, is may be seen as a quantizer whose quantization noise exhibits noise shaping. An in depth mathematical analysis of VCO based ADCs can be found for example in [34]. Figure 4.18a shows the basic building block of a VCO based ADC, where the input is directly connected with the VCO frequency control input. The VCO signal clocks a digital counter that is dumped and reset periodically at a sampling frequency fs . This scheme can be refined by using several of the intermediate phases of a VCO implemented with a ring oscillator. The system of Fig. 4.18a produces first-order shaped quantization noise only, and as a consequence, it requires oversampling to achieve a sufficient SNR. As there is no feedback loop, all distortion components introduced in the VCO are coupled to the output. For this reason, the system of Fig. 4.18 can only be used for limited resolutions, although it permits achieving a remarkable FoM and low area. For instance, [35] shows an exemplary circuit implemented with digital inverters which exhibits very low area and FoM, but whose linearity is strongly limited by the VCO.
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
a
fs
VCO Input signal
reset COUNTER
Clk LATCH
Digital out
fs
b
Digital out VCO
Input signal
83
reset
Clk
COUNTER
LATCH
Look-up Table
Fig. 4.18 A VCO based oversampling converter
Calibration has been proposed as an option to improve the linearity. In this case, the ADC core resorts to the building block of Fig. 4.18b and first order is maintained. However, the output data is linearized by use of a look up table after the counter. The look up table contents is calculated at power up by a calibration system which may require dedicated calibration hardware. In [37] this approach is employed to achieve a low FoM and very small size converter. Although this approach can be very adequate for low resolution ADCs (below 11-bits), increasing the resolution above that value by means of calibration seems not so efficient. Moreover, concerns have been raised about the possibility of maintaining the calibration with power supply and temperature variations. Apart from these two alternatives, some others have been developed [38], based in similar principles. VCO based oversampled converters have been there for more than 15 years [39], however, this topic cannot be considered already closed and more architectures based on oscillators will likely be seen in the future.
4.3.1 Sigma-Delta Employing VCO-Based ADCs VCO based ADC converters have been the subject of many research works for its promising advantages, namely simplicity and low power. However, the hardware cost of the proposed solutions to their inherent drawbacks has placed them as an option similar to the PWM based converters. Using the VCO as the quantizer of a higher order conventional continuous time sigma delta modulator is an approach which combines several advantages: • The order can be increased arbitrarily; it’s just a matter of increasing the complexity of the analog filter. Moreover, one needs one integrator less than the modulator order, because the VCO already provides first order noise shaping
84
A. Di Giandomenico et al. Φ0
fs
Analog input Hsd
ring oscillator
register
1–z–1
Digital multibit output
ΦN 5b DAC Analog feedback
Fig. 4.19 A VCO as time quantizer of a CT-SDM [33]
• If the VCO is implemented with a particular ring oscillator topology, the feedback DAC may incorporate a Data Weighted Averaging (DWA) effect without the need of a dedicated DWA hardware. Finally, VCO nonlinearity is spectrally shaped by the analog loop filter. In [36], a polyphase VCO is implemented using a ring oscillator as shown in Fig. 4.19. Each output phase, (ˆ0 : : : ˆN) is sampled in a register by a flip-flop and thus, time quantized with a single bit. This way, a multilevel code is generated. After a digital differentiator, this code is both used as digital output and to drive a conventional unit element current-DAC. The rotating effect of the ring oscillator eases the equiprobable use of the DAC elements, resulting in a built-in DWA kind of nonlinearity compensation. In spite of all these advantages, one still needs high performance analog integrators and a multi-bit D/A converter which end up in a real improvement over a standard continuous time sigma delta but with similar limitations, especially the linearity of the first integrator, which dominates the overall performance.
5 Conclusions As many other research topics with an industrial application, Sigma Delta converters have been a fashion item that many semiconductor companies wanted to display in its portfolio. Recently its effectiveness has been questioned in favor of classical Nyquist architectures such as SAR and pipeline converters. As a difference to Nyquist ADC architectures, they have been surrounded by a myth of complicated mathematics and connections with chaos theory and other exotic disciplines. While this is true, their design resorts to a deep analog circuit design knowledge (same a Nyquist converters) combined with a clear understanding of classical linear systems and filter theory (same as the anti-aliasing filters that precede a Nyquist converter). In spite of these arguments, Sigma Delta converters are typically the solution in the industry “after” pipelines and SAR fail to deliver the power or performance that differences a product from its competitors.
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
85
The historical steps taken in sigma delta converter evolution go from the ideal model of a sigma delta, embodied as a switched capacitor circuit to continuous time sigma deltas and lately to time encoding designs. This evolution has been forced by starvation of analog performance as feature sizes decreased. The way to exploit the extra digital MHz allowed by shrinking technologies could not come from higher bandwidth opamps or better matched current sources. Hence, researchers have been forced to dig a bit more in unconventional engineering knowledge. Time encoding techniques will represent in the near future one of the main escapes to this low performance of analog electronics associated with nanometer CMOS. The attempts to implement time encoding converters with direct sampling in 65 nm and 45 nm have shown to date that the paradigm of excellence of digital versus analog circuitry is still not enough accomplished. High order continuous time Sigma delta converters implemented with time encoded quantizers [30], VCOs [36] are bridging the gap momentarily, but still require high performance operational amplifiers. It can be envisioned that a definitive solution must benefit from the advantages of time encoding in the whole analog signal processing chain, and not only at the quantizer. This way, time encoding could be applied to filtering, amplification and other building blocks made mostly of digital logic but realizing analog operations. Opamps and integrators implemented with charge pumps and logic inverters [40] are one of the early examples of the changes that will arrive. Other uses of time encoding to implement analog to digital conversion are a mix of traditional frequency synthesis techniques with VCO oversampled converters [41, 42]. A classical time encoding converter was the dual slope ADC. In [43, 44], it is shown how to implement a multi-bit oversampled converter using the dual slope principle by means of time encoding. Continuous time digital signal processing [45] shows that the real barrier is not the speed and performance of CMOS technology but the way engineers see real world signals and signal processing, linked to the classical theory of sampled data systems with a fixed sampling rate.
References CTSD Theory 1. J.A. Cherry, W.M. Snelgrove, Continuous-Time Delta-Sigma Modulators for High Speed A/D Conversion (Kluwer Academic, Boston, 2000) 2. L. Breems, J.H. Huijsing, Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta Modulation for A/D Conversion in Radio Receivers (Kluwer Academic, Boston, 2001) 3. R. Schreier, G. Temes, Understanding Delta-Sigma Converters (IEEE Press, Hoboken, 2005) 4. L. Hernandez, A. Wiesbauer, S. Paton, A. Di Giandomenico, Modelling and optimization of low-pass continuous-time sigma-delta modulators for clock-jitter noise reduction, in Proceedings of 2004 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), Vancouver, May 2004, pp. 1072–1075
86
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
CTSD Examples 5. S. Paton, A. Di Giandomenico, L. Hernandez, A. Wiesbauer, T. Poetscher, M. Clara, A 70 mW 300 MHz CMOS continuous-time DS ADC with 15 MHz bandwidth and 11 bits of resolution. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 39(7), 1056–1063 (2004) 6. K. Philips, P.A.C.M. Nuijten, R.L.J. Roovers, A.H.M. van Roermund, F. Munoz Chavero, M. Tejero Pallares, A. Torralba, A continuous-time SD ADC with increased immunity to interferers. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 39(12), 2170–2178 (2004) 7. L. Doerrer, F. Kuttner, P. Greco, P. Torta, T. Hartig, A 3-mW 74-dB SNR 2-MHz continuoustime delta-sigma ADC with a tracking ADC quantizer in 0.13 m CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 40(12), 2416–2627 (2005) 8. V. Quiquempoix, P. Deval, A. Barreto, G. Bellini, J. M´arkus, J. Silva, G.C. Temes, A low-power 22-bit incremental ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 41(7), 1562–1571 (2006) 9. G. Mitteregger, C. Ebner, S. Mechnig, T. Blon, C. Holuigue, E. Romani, A 20-mW 640-MHz CMOS continuous-time SD ADC With 20-MHz signal bandwidth, 80-dB dynamic range and 12-bit ENOB. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 41(12), 2641–2649 (2006) 10. S. Ouzonov, R. van Veldhoven, C. Bastianseen, K. Vongehr, R. van Wegberg, G. Geelen, L. Breems, A. van Roermund, A 1.2 V 121-mode CT SD modulator for wireless receivers in 90 nm CMOS, in Proceedings of ISSCC (2007), San Francisco, 2007, pp. 242–243 11. L. Breems, R. Rutten, R.H.M. van Veldhoven, G. van der Weide, A 56 mW CT quadrature cascaded SD modulator with 77-dB DR in a near zero-IF 20-MHz band. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 42(12), 2696–2705 (2007) 12. J. Sauerbrey, J. San Pablo Garcia, G. Panov, T. Piorek, X. Shen, M. Schimper, R. Koch, M. Keller, Y. Manoli, M. Ortmanns, A configurable cascaded continuous-time DS modulator with up to 15 MHz bandwidth, in Proceedings of the Custom Integrated Circuits Conference (CICC), IEEE, San Jose, May 2010, pp. 426–429 13.Y. Ke, P. Gao, J. Craninckx, G. Van der Plas, G. Gielen, A 2.8-to-8.5 mW GSM/Bluetooth/UMTS/DVB-H/WLAN fully reconfigurable CT DS with 200 KHz to 20 MHz BW for 4 G radios in 90 nm digital CMOS, in Proceedings of the Symposium on VLSI Circuits Conference, IEEE, 2010, pp. 153–154 14. M. Bolatkale, L.J. Breems, R. Rutten, K.A.A. Makinwa, A 4 GHz CD SD ADC with 70 dB DR and -74 dBS THD in 125 MHz BW, in Proceedings of ISSCC, San Francisco, Feb 2011, pp. 470–471 PWM-Based and VCO-Based Theory 15. E. Roza, Analog-to-digital conversion via duty-cycle modulation. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. II 44(11), 907–914 (1997) 16. D.G. Holmes, T.A. Lipo, Pulse Width Modulation for Power Converters: Principles and Practice (IEEE Press, Piscataway, 2003) 17. A.A. Lazar, L.T. Toth, Time encoding and perfect recovery of bandlimited signals, in International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, 2003. Proceedings (ICASSP ’03), 2003 IEEE, vol. 6, Hong Kong, 6–10 Apr 2003, pp. VI709–712 18. F. Colodro, A. Torralba, M. Laguna, Continuous-time sigma-delta modulator with an embedded pulsewidth modulation. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I 55(3), 775–785 (2008) 19. L. Hernandez, E. Prefasi, Analog-to-digital conversion using noise shaping and time encoding. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I 55(7), 2026–2037 (2008) 20. F. Colodro, A. Torralba, New continuous-time multibit sigma-delta modulators with low sensitivity to clock jitter. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I 56(1), 74–83 (2009) 21. M.H. Perrot, VCO-based wideband continuous-time sigma-delta analog-to-digital converters, in Proceedings of the 19th Workshop on Advances in Analog Circuit Design, Graz, Apr 2010, pp. 177–203 22. L. Hernandez, A. Wiesbauer, Exploiting time resolution in nanometer CMOS data converters, in Proceedings of 2010 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), Paris, May 2010
4 Oversampling Converters Beyond Continuous-Time Sigma-Delta...
87
23. F. Colodro, A. Torralba, Pulse-width modulation in sigma-delta modulators, in Proceedings of 2010 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), Paris, May 2010, pp. 1081–1084 PWM-Based and VCO-Based Examples 24. V. Dhanasekaran, Basedband analog circuits in deep-submicron CMOS technologies targeted for mobile multimedia, PhD dissertation, Texas A&M University, College Station, Aug 2008 25. L. Hernandez, E. Prefasi, E. Pun, S. Paton, A 1.2 MHz 10-bit continuous-time sigma-delta ADC using a time encoding quantizer. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. II 56(1), 16–20 (2009) 26. V. Dhanasekaran, M. Gambhir, M.M. Elsayed, E. S´anchez-Sinencio, J. Silva-Martinez, C. Mishra, L. Chen, E. Pankratz1, A 20 MHz BW 68 dB DR CT † ADC based on a multibit time-domain quantizer and feedback element, in Proceedings of the Solid State Circuits Conference (ISSCC), San Francisco, IEEE, 2009, pp. 174–176 27. E. Prefasi, L. Hernandez, S. Paton, A. Wiesbauer, R. Gaggl, E. Pun, A 0.1 mm², wide bandwidth continuous-time SD ADC based on a time encoding quantizer in 0.13 m CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(10), 2745–2754 (2009) 28. M. Park, M.H. Perrot, A 78 dB SNDR 87 mW 20 MHz bandwidth continuous-time DS ADC with VCO-based integrator and quantizer implemented in 0.13 m CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(12), 3344–3358 (2009) 29. J. Silva-Marinez, C.Y. Lu, M. Onabajo, F. Silva-Rivas, V. Dhanasekaran, M. Gambhir, Wideband continuous-time multi-bit delta-sigma ADCs, in Proceedings of the 19th Workshop on Advances in Analog Circuit Design, Graz, Apr 2010, pp. 205–225 30. E. Prefasi, S. Paton, L. Hernandez, R. Gaggl, A. Wiesbauer, J. Hauptmann, A 0.08 mm², 7 mW time-encoding oversampling converter with 10 bits and 20 MHz BW in 65 nm CMOS, in Proceedings of ESSCIRC 2010, Sevilla, 2010 Others (Asynchronous, etc.) 31. S. Ouzonov, E. Roza, H. Hegt, G. van der Weide, A. van Roermund, An 8 MHz, 72 dB SFDR asynchronous sigma-delta modulator with 1.5 mW power dissipation, in Proceedings of the Symposium on VLSI Circuits Conference, Honolulu, IEEE, 2004, pp. 88–91 32. S. Ouzonov, E. Roza, H. Hegt, G. van der Weide, A. van Roermund, Design of highperformance asynchronous sigma delta modulators with a binary quantizer with hysteresis, in Proceedings of the Custom Integrated Circuits Conference (CICC), San Jose, IEEE, 2004, pp. 181–184 33. O. Oliaei, H. Aboushady, Jitter effects in continuous-time SD modulators with delayed returnto-zero feedback, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Electronics, Circuits and Systems, The Hague, IEEE, 1998, pp. 351–354 34. J. Kim, T.-K. Jang, Y.-G. Yoon, S.H. Cho, Analysis and design of voltage-controlled oscillator based analog-to-digital converter. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I Regul. Pap. 57(1, January), 18–30 (2010) 35. U. Wismar, D. Wisland, P. Andreani, A 0.2 V 0.44 uW 20 kHz analog to digital sigma delta modulator with 57 fJ/conversion FoM, in Proceedings of the 32nd European Solid-State Circuits Conference, 2006, ESSCIRC 2006, Montreux, 19–21 Sept 2006, pp. 187–190 36. M.Z. Straayer, M.H. Perrott, A 12-Bit, 10-MHz bandwidth, continuous-time sigma-delta ADC With a 5-Bit, 950-MS/s VCO-based quantizer. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 43(4, April), 805–814 (2008) 37. J. Daniels, W. Dehaene, M. Steyaert, A. Wiesbauer, A 0.02 mm2 65 nm CMOS 30 MHz BW all-digital differential VCO-based ADC with 64 dB SNDR, in 2010 IEEE Symposium on VLSI circuits (VLSIC), Honolulu, 16–18 June 2010, pp. 155–156 38. G. Taylor, I. Galton, A mostly-digital variable-rate continuous-time delta-sigma modulator ADC. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 45(12), 2634–2646 (2010) 39. M. Hovin, A. Olsen, T.S. Lande, C. Toumazou, Delta-sigma converters using frequencymodulated intermediate values, in 1995 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems, ISCAS ’95, vol. 1, Seattle, 30 Apr–3 May 1995, pp. 175–178
88
A. Di Giandomenico et al.
40. L. Brooks, H.-S. Lee, A zero-crossing-based 8b 200MS/s pipelined ADC, in IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conference, 2007, ISSCC 2007, San Francisco, 11–15 Feb 2007, pp. 460–615 41. L. Hernandez, E. Prefasi, Continuous time † modulator based on digital delay loop and time quantisation. Electron. Lett. 46(25), 1655–1656 (2010) 42. B. Young, P.K. Hanumolu, Phase-locked loop based -† ADC. Electron. Lett. 46(6), 403–404 (2010) 43. E. Prefasi, E. Pun, L. Hernandez, S. Paton, Second-order multi-bit † ADC using a pulsewidth modulated DAC and an integrating quantizer, in 16th IEEE International Conference on Electronics, Circuits, and Systems, 2009. ICECS 2009, Hammamet, 13–16 Dec 2009, pp. 37–40 44. L. Hernandez, E. Pun, E. Prefasi, S. Paton, Continuous time sigma-delta modulator based on binary weighted charge balance. Electron. Lett. 45(9), 458–460 (2009) 45. M. Kurchuk, Y. Tsividis, Signal-dependent variable-resolution clockless A/D conversion with application to continuous-time digital signal processing. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. I Regul. Pap. 57(5), 982–991 (2010) 46. A.M. Soliman, M. Ismail, Phase correction in two-integrator loop-filters using a single compensating resistor. Electron Lett 14(12), 375–376 (1978) 47. S. Paton, T. P¨otscher, A. Di Giandomenico, K. Kolhaupt, L. Hernandez, A. Wiesbauer, M. Clara, R. Frutos, Linearity enhancement techniques in low OSR, high clock rate multi-bit continuous-time sigma-delta modulators, in Proceedings of the Custom Integrated Circuits Conference (CICC), San Jose, IEEE, 2004
Chapter 5
Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs Marian Verhelst, Erkan Alpman, and Hasnain Lakdawala
Abstract Observed ADC area and power scaling do not seem to follow the trends predicted using pure technology scaling arguments. A cubic improvement in area and power with gate length is observed in literature, which has been enabled by migration towards more and more capacitor-based ADC architectures, and the introduction of digitally-assisted performance enhancement strategies to overcome component mismatch. This paper assesses these trends, and discusses the most relevant enhancement strategies for mismatch-limited ADCs. Trade-off analysis between mismatch compensation in the analog domain (digitally assisted trimming, possibly in combination with up-scaling) vs. the digital domain (digital postdistortion) is required. The increasing use of digitally enhanced ADC architectures proves to be the main driver for the observed improvement in area and power with scaling.
1 Introduction The need for increased mobility and portability of computing devices and ever increasing data rate requirements puts more and more stress on the ADC’s performance. At the same time cost and battery life issues demand continuous scaling of the ADC area and power consumption and require designs in smaller and smaller (CMOS) technologies. Furthermore increased dynamic range required for modern communication standards also pushes the required dynamic range of the ADCs with scaling. This causes significant noise and matching issues in several key ADC building blocks, as traditional scaling studies predict a power and area flattening or even increase.Nevertheless, a survey of published data indicates that
M. Verhelst () • E. Alpman • H. Lakdawala Intel Labs – Radio Integration Research, 2111 NW 25th Ave, Hillsboro, OR, USA e-mail:
[email protected] M. Steyaert et al. (eds.), Analog Circuit Design: Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 5, © Springer ScienceCBusiness Media B.V. 2012
89
90
M. Verhelst et al.
ADC performance does improve significantly over technology. This contradiction is explained by new architecture and design innovations in ADC design that exploit the inherent improvements provided by CMOS technology scaling. These improvements include: 1. Metal finger capacitor (MFC) density as well as MFC matching per pF improved significantly over the last technology generations. 2. The speed of digital gates increases, while their power and area reduce. Analysis of performance enhancement techniques that exploit these advantages of scaling is necessary to understand the improved performance of ADC implementations and to extrapolate these learnings towards future scaled ADC designs. This paper starts by deriving the expected ADC area and power consumption trends from pure technology scaling in Sect. 2. Section 3 makes the comparison with observed trends from survey data on state-of-the-art ADCs of the last decade. Next, Sect. 4 focuses on several digital enhancement techniques to explain the inconsistency between the theoretical and observed trends. Section 5 finally derives the strategies to incorporate these calibrations in a cost-aware way into ADC design and illustrates this with a design example.
2 Theoretical Performance Trends in Scaled ADCs 2.1 ADC Performance Limiters Noise and distortion impose fundamental limits on ADC performance. Their impact on ADC area and power consumption has been covered extensively in literature [1–4]. This section summarizes these dependencies, which will be used in Sect. 2.2 to evaluate the impact of scaling. The conversion accuracy of ADCs is typically expressed in ENOB (effective number of bits), or SNDR (signal-to-noise-and-distortion power ratio): SNDR.dB/ 1:76 ; 6:02
(5.1)
S Nnoise C Nmismatch C Nnonlin
(5.2)
ENOB D SNDR D Where:
S: signal power at the ADC input, or Vsig; rms 2 . Nnoise : input referred noise power. Noise appearing in the ADC output signal is caused by a combination of quantization noise, thermal noise, flicker noise and input sampling jitter. Quantization noise, caused by the finite resolution quantization intervals, sets the limit for the maximum achievable SNDR. Practical ADC designs
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
91
are also limited by thermal noise, which can be characterized by the total integrated noise: Nnoise D
kB :T ; C
(5.3)
With kB the Boltzmann constant, temperature T and effective input referred noise capacitance C. Nmismatch : distortion due to mismatch. As shown in [2, 5] matching rather than thermal noise dictates the performance of low resolution ADCs. Mismatch of critical circuit elements has different effects depending on the ADC architecture. In Flash converters the random mismatch among the comparators’ (or pre-amplifiers’) offset degrades performance, while in a SAR ADCs, the comparator offset is un-important, but the sensitivity to capacitor (and hence radix) mismatch is large. Pipelined ADCs need carefully matched opamps and capacitors to maintain good ENOB, while finally time-interleaved ADCs heavily suffer from mismatch among gain, offset, skew or bandwidth of the time interleaved channels. This mismatch causes non-linear distortion, affecting dynamic and static ADC metrics, like SNDR, INL and DNL. The latter have to be reduced to a fraction of the LSB to avoid ADC performance degradation. One way to reduce circuit mismatch, is by increasing circuit area. This linear relationship is demonstrated in Eqs. 5.4 and 5.5 for amplifier differential offset voltage matching (Vgs ) [5–7], as well as capacitor matching (C ): # " A2ˇ 2 1 2 AVT C .Vgs / D Vgs VT W:L 4 2
2
C C
D
A2C N Cunit
(5.4)
(5.5)
with AVT t , Aˇ and AC technology constants, W.L the transistor area and N the unit capacitor multiplier. However, due to the deterministic nature of mismatch (unlike thermal noise), opportunities for smarter correction exist. They are the primary focus of this paper and will be covered extensively in Sect. 4. Nnon lin : device non-linearity. The linearity of an ADC is further degraded by device non-linearity. A well know example of this is the input sampling stage, which
92
M. Verhelst et al.
a
b
VDD
VDD
vbias2
i2
vo1 vid1 / 2
iod1
W1, L1
–vid1 / 2
W1, L1
vo2 Cpassive1 vi2
W2, L2 (M2)
Cpassive2
IB1
Fig. 5.1 Representative circuit model of ADC input stage (a) and output stage (b)
is affected due to charge injection and a varying input resistance [8]. The input resistance Ron heavily depends on the sampled input voltage Vin : Ron D dV in =dI D
2 WL
1 Cox .Vin VT /
(5.6)
To limit the non-linear distortion, the difference in Ron over the signal swing (Ron) has to be kept small. Assuming a transmission gate: max Ron D
2k 2 Vdd VT Ronmax D D Vdd Ronmin k=2 1 . 2 VT /=2
(5.7)
This parameter however significantly degrades with process scaling, as the ratio k D Vdd=V th decreases rapidly with technology (trending < 2.5 for some low leakage <45 nm CMOS). Luckily, gain boosting and bootstrapping resolve most of this signal dependency, but at the cost of input bandwidth, area and power [9]. Again, due to the deterministic nature of the impairment, post-distortion techniques have proven to provide additional improvement [8]. Amplifying stages can also be a source of non-linear distortion. Although even order harmonics are typically cancelled out by employing differential circuits, odd order distortion does affect the ADC performance. For the differential pair of Fig. 5.1a, and assuming ideal square law devices, it can be shown that [10]: iod Dx IB
r 1
x2 ; 4
with x D
vid .Vgs1 VT /
(5.8)
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
93
and hence by approximation: gm IB D 8:.Vgs1 VT /2 : Š8 gm3 2:Kn :W1 =L1
(5.9)
with gm being the transconductance, gm3 D ı 3 iod =ıVgs3 (third harmonic of the transconductance) and Kn D 2n Cox .
2.2 Fixed Performance ADC Scaling The noise and distortion formulae of previous section allow assessing the impact of scaling on ADC performance. More specifically this section derives trends in ADC area and power consumption with iso-performance technology scaling. Broader studies of scaling effects in analog and mixed signal circuits can be found in [6, 7, 11–14]. The circuits shown in Fig. 5.1 will be used as a representative circuit for an ADC input stage (Fig. 5.1a), respectively output stage (Fig. 5.1b), driving a passive capacitor Cpassive . These circuits are relevant for a multitude of recent ADCs based on open loop amplifiers and passive capacitors, like pipelined, sigma-delta or SAR ADCs. While noise and matching constraints mainly impact the input stage, device linearity has to be addressed for both input- and output stage. Throughout this study, following assumptions are made: • The square law MOSFET model is used, with the understanding that short channel effects limit the accuracy of this model in scaled technologies. However this assumption allows a first order calculation to reveal trends. • L scales with technology. Design rules of deep submicron technologies do not allow long channel devices without severe area and leakage penalties. The scaling factor of L per technology generation will be denoted sL (0.7). • Voltage scaling is pursued less aggressively in latest technology generations. Leakage concerns cause the threshold voltage to be almost flat. As a result VDD scales at a slower pace to keep sufficient voltage overdrive. Therefore, a voltage scaling factor sV , different from sL , is used. Recently this factor has been trending p towards sL or even less when different supply voltages are used for analog and digital blocks. • Gate tox , and as a result Cox has not been keeping up with feature scaling due to gate leakage concerns. Survey data [15] shows Cox scaling of 1=sL (towards 1=sL for high-k gate). Interconnect tox scales with 1=sL . • Absolute matching coefficients AVT and AC (Eqs. 5.4 and 5.5) improve with every new technology generation. Lately this improvement rate has been trending p around sL [15, 16]. Aˇ , which does not see similar improvements, has not been taken into account in this study, resulting in a slightly optimistic (smaller area, power) outcome.
94
M. Verhelst et al.
• A passive metal finger capacitor (MFC) capacitor is assumed. MFC capacitor density scales with technology as 1=sL [16]. • The input stage operates in Class A, or IB1 =iod1 D constant. This implies that .Vgs VT / cannot scale faster than the input signal swing, or sV . • Iso-bandwidth (conversion rate) scaling is pursued in all scenarios (unless other iso-performance requirements force the bandwidth to be larger). This poses the following constraints for the representative circuits: Input stage: (linear settling): gm1 D constant Cload1
(5.10)
Output stage: (slew rate limited): Cload2 :.vo /max D constant i2
(5.11)
Table 5.1 shows the effect on the most important circuit parameters when scaling device length (sL ) and supply voltage (sV ) under different scenarios.
2.2.1 Iso-(device-)linearity Scaling In a first scenario, an iso-linearity scaling of the input stage is pursued, assuming a constant load capacitor Cpassive1 . Only the intrinsic non-linearity of the transistor device is considered. Non-linearity due to mismatch will be covered later (isomatching). As can be derived from Eq. 5.9, this linearity is maintained as long as the overdrive voltage Vov D .Vgs1 VT / scales proportional to vid . This is realized by scaling both voltages with sV , resulting in a device width scaling: W
I L Cox .Vgs VT /2
p sI sL : sL : sV 2
(5.12)
Iso-(device-)linearity scaling of the output driver stage (Fig. 5.1b) requires both .Vgs VT / of M2, as well as the voltage drop over the output stage bias transistor to scale with sV . Assuming constant bandwidth, bias current can be decreased according to Eq. 5.11. As a result, iso-linearity enforces similar scaling to the output driver stages as derived for the input stage (Eq. 5.12). As can be seen from Table 5.1, iso-(device-)linearity scaling (without other noise or matching requirements) results in an almost perfect scaling with technology, p where both area and power scale down with a factor sL to sL 2 (using sV sL ). From this observation, linearity does not seem to be affected by scaling if the input swing range is allowed to be reduced with the input supply, predicting ever
sL sV sV 1 sV sL 3=2 sV 1 sV 2 sL sL 5=2 sV 1 sL2 sL p Green formulaeassuming sV sL
L Vdd (vo ), (vi )max Cpassive I W Power Area (active) Area (passives)
sL sV sV sV 2 sV 1 sL 3=2 sV 3 1 sL 5=2 sV 3 sL sL sV 2 1
sL sV sV sL sL 3=2 .passive load/ sV 2 .offset/ sL 3=2 sV sL1 sL sV 2 1 sL 2
sL sV sV sV 2 .noise/ sL 3=2 .linearity/ sV 2 .matching/ sL 3=2 sV sL1 sL sV 2 1 sL sV 2 1
Table 5.1 Effect on design parameters, area and power consumption of the input stage reference circuit of Fig. 5.1a under iso-performance scaling Parameter Iso-linearity Iso-noise Iso-matching Iso-SNDR
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs 95
96
M. Verhelst et al.
decreasing area and power numbers for scaled technologies. However, system, noise and matching requirements will make it harder and harder to scale the input swing with sV , which will be reflected in an area and power penalty as seen in the following scenarios. 2.2.2 Iso-thermal Noise Scaling To keep the signal-to-thermal-noise-ratio constant in a scaled technology, assuming the input swing scales proportional to the supply, circuit noise has to be suppressed with sV 2 . As a result, the passive capacitive load Cpassive has to be scaled up with the same factor. To account for the larger gm requirement due to this load under iso-bandwidth constraints and only allowing limited overdrive voltage scaling to maintain Class-A operation, this requires approximately flat device width scaling. Table 5.1 shows the impact on area and power consumption. It has to be noted that flicker noise, important for low frequency ADC designs has been neglected here. Flicker noise limited designs can use architectural solutions like correlated double sampling or need to keep input device sizes large to limit the flicker noise. 2.2.3 Iso-matching Scaling In an iso-matching scenario the amount with which active and passive circuits can scale is limited, and directly tied to the improvement over technology of AVT and AC (Eqs. 5.4 and 5.5). Additionally, the scaled supply voltage and input swing increases the threshold voltage matching requirement for the active devices with sV . The decrease in required gm (smaller load) does however not allow significant power savings due to the Class A operating requirement. The design is no longer iso-bandwidth, but is forced to increase bandwidth with ‘sL 3 ’ at a larger power cost. As shown in Table 5.1, area is flat for active devices, passive area decreases due to improved capacitor density and matching. Note that a purely passive load is assumed. An active load (with matching requirements, like in current steering DACs, or CT † ADCs) scales slower, 3=2 resulting in a 1=sL times higher power consumption. 2.2.4 Iso-SNDR A good ADC implementation will always use all excess margin in terms of every performance limiter: device non-linearity, noise and matching. As result, when such a design has to scale down, performance across all three has to be improved simultaneously. The last column in Table 5.1 shows the result on the circuit’s area and power consumption for such an iso-SNDR scaling (iso-linearity C iso-noise C iso-matching). The size of the passives will typically be determined by
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
97
noise, and of the actives in many designs (e.g. flash) by threshold voltage matching, while the current is set based on the linearity constraint of Eqs. 5.9, taking the p increased W due to matching into account. Assuming sV sL , this scenario results in iso-bandwidth scaling as well.
2.3 Conclusion An interesting observation from Table 5.1 is the difference in scaling between active and passive devices. While active devices seem to suffer less from scaling in a noise-limited scenario, passive devices scale better under matching constraints. This relates to the ongoing shift of ADC designs towards oversampling implementations (relying more on active devices) for noise limited designs, while more passive capacitor based designs (like SAR ADCs) gain popularity for low SNDR requirements (matching limited [17]). However, as can be concluded from Table 5.1, no significant overall area or power improvements can be expected from pure technology scaling alone under fixed performance constraints. The ADC area and power seems solely dependent on and tied to its SNDR requirement. Due to the p slowed down voltage scaling sV 6 sL both are more or less flat, or slightly increasing over generations. If sV would have maintained his old trend sL , power would have scaled better at the cost of additional area. The increasingly common trend of using of dual supplies for the ADC, with the analog supply being higher and scaling slower than the digital supply helps in terms of area scaling. Next section will compare these trends with survey data from recent ADC implementations.
3 ADC Area and Power Survey Based on the survey data from [18] an assessment can be made about the actual trend of area and power consumption of iso-SNDR ADC implementations over the past decade. The power consumption scaling per calendar year is studied extensively in [17]. The study reveals a significant scaling divergence between high SNDR ADCs (>75 dB SNDR), limited by thermal noise (technology), and lower SNDR ADCs, which are mismatch limited. The remainder of this paper will focus on trends for mismatch limited ADCs, as they contain the majority of recent ADC designs. This section will investigate the trend in area scaling, as well as quantify the area and power scaling over technology generations. Figure 5.2 shows an analysis of all ADC implementations presented at the IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Conference (ISSCC) and the VLSI Circuit Symposium during the last decade [18]. In this plot, the area efficiency (area divided by the Nyquist sampling rate fnyquist ) is plotted in function of the achieved SNDR.
98
M. Verhelst et al.
ISSCC, VLSI data 10–4
2000-2001 2010
area / fnyquist [mm2 / Hz]
fit all fit 2000-2001
10–6
fit 2010
10–8
10–10
10–12 20
40
60 SNDR [dB]
80
100
Fig. 5.2 ADC performance data (ISSCC 2000–2010, VLSI Circuit Symposium 2000–2010). Area efficiency plotted in function of SNDR
The oldest (2000–2001) and most recent (2010) implementations are highlighted. A first observation is the large spread of the data around their best linear fit, which can be explained by different performance metrics targeted by the various ADC designs, not all reflected in this drawing: area, power, bandwidth, or a combination of them. However, due to the abundance of data, interesting conclusions can still be drawn from averaged data through linear regression models. Figure 5.2 shows linear fits constructed based on all mismatch limited ADCs (SNDR < 75 dB) of different publication years. Based on these lines, a clear improvement of area efficiency from 2000 to 2010 can be identified. This trend is also observed in three generations of similar sigma-delta ADCs at Intel in scaled technologies (Fig. 5.3) [19]. This observation is contradictory to the theoretical area scaling effect derived in previous section. One partial explanation is a shift toward passive capacitor-based ADC designs, which rely on passive, rather than active device matching. As shown in Table 5.1, these devices still scale quite well over technology. Figure 5.4 confirms this trend: The fraction of SAR ADC implementations significantly increased over the past years. Also, sigma-delta (SD) and pipeline ADCs, relying heavily on passive capacitors as well, remain popular.
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
MASH 2-2 90 nm CMOS 1X
99
MASH 2-0 45 nm CMOS ~ 0.2X
MASH 2-2-0 32 nm CMOS ~ 0.1X
Fig. 5.3 Three generations of similar delta-sigma ADC implementations, demonstrating the ongoing area improvement over technology generations
1
other SAR SD(SC+CT) flash pipeline
fraction of ISSCC +VLSI paper
0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 year
Fig. 5.4 Fraction of ADC architectures published in ISSCC and VLSI in different calendar years
However, as derived in Table 5.1, this design shift can only (partially) explain an improvement in area efficiency. Improvements in power efficiency (power consumption divided by the Nyquist sampling rate fnyquist ) are not expected from the scaling study of Sect. 2. Figure 5.5 however shows that the power efficiency of ADC designs demonstrates a similar decrease over the last decade. This scatter plot visualizes the power versus area FOM (figure-of-merit): power FOM D
P ; fnyquist :2ENOB
area FOM D
A fnyquist :2ENOB
(5.13)
100
M. Verhelst et al. 10–10 ISSCC, VLSI data
power FOM
10–11
2000-2001 2010
10–12
10–13
10–14
10–15 10–14
10–12
10–10 area FOM
10–8
10–6
Fig. 5.5 Power figure-of-merit vs. area figure-of-merit (FOM)
The scattered data can again be attributed to different design optimization metrics pursued. A clear power-area trade-off locus can be observed, which steadily improves over the years for both area and power. A similar trend can be observed when computing the expected area and power consumption of a iso-SNDR ADC in different technology generations: Based on a linear fit of both area and power in function of SNDR over the ISSCC/VLSI survey data for every different CMOS technology generation between 600 and 65 nm (not enough data points available for 45 nm), the area and power consumption of a typical comms ADC, targeting 60 dB SNDR, is predicted. Figure 5.6 plots the result: a perfect scaling with sL 2 for both metrics : : : To understand why this perfect scaling with technology is possible, despite the contradictory theoretical derivation of Table 5.1, let’s look at two interesting data points in Fig. 5.5: the most power efficient and most area efficient design up to date, indicated with the ‘stars’: The most power efficient ADC design, described in [20] is a 4.4fJ/conversion step charge redistribution (SAR) ADC, heavily relying on metal-plate capacitor matching. The most area efficient ADC design, described in [21] is a 0.01 mm2 flash ADC using minimum-size input devices in 65 nm. To compensate for resulting non-linearities and offsets in the comparator and track-and-hold, the ADC employs digital compensation techniques, both calibrated during startup.
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
101
fitted area / fs, resp. power / fs for 60 dB ADC
100
10–1
10–2 mean area scaling mean power scaling scaling with L sL2 10–3
65
90
130
180
250 technology
350
500
650
Fig. 5.6 Predicted power consumption and area for 60 dB SNDR ADC over technology generation (normalized to the 650 nm data point (1 m2 /Hz, 9.5nW/Hz))
These two examples beautifully illustrate the two most important strategies followed in many of the ISSCC/VLSI survey designs to overcome mismatch limitations and maintain aggressive area and power scaling over technology: 1. Rely on metal-plate capacitor matching instead of device matching whenever possible (see also Fig. 5.4). 2. Add digital enhancements to the ADC to boost performance. Although a majority of the recent ISSCC/VLSI ADC implementations heavily relied on digital enhancements, only few of them demonstrated these in actual silicon. As a result, their true power and area cost is often not taken into account in the reported performance metrics. The remainder of this paper will focus on various digital enhancement strategies for ADCs, as well as quantify their benefits and penalties. This information helps the ADC designer to make smart design choices to optimize overall area and power of analog plus digital.
4 ADC Performance Through Digital Enhancements Designers have been using digital enhancements for many decades to boost the ADC performance at a reduced power/area cost compared to traditional up-scaling
102
M. Verhelst et al.
Fig. 5.7 (b–f) Enhancement techniques to improve matching performance over the minimum size, thermal noise-limited, baseline design (a)
[22, 23]. Analog power/area is saved, at the expense of more digital gates. Finding the best trade-off between the two is not straightforward and requires thorough understanding of the impact of these enhancements. This section will revise different digital enhancement techniques and their influence on both analog and digital performance metrics. This data can be used to understand the sL 2 scaling trends seen for ADC area and power consumption, and to investigate whether this trends is expected to continue in the future. A well-known and thoroughly studied digital enhancement technique for overcoming SNDR limitations for thermal noise limited ADCs is oversampling [24]. This section will therefore solely focus on enhancements for mismatch limited ADCs.
4.1 Non-digital Enhancements Figure 5.7 gives a classification of various strategies to improve matching performance of circuit components, and by extension of ADCs.
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
103
The baseline, reference design which has to be improved is drawn in Fig. 5.7a. It consists of a set of N mismatched circuit components, which can be either active or passive devices, depending on the ADC under study. Example in a Flash ADC, these could be N pre-amplifiers which require careful voltage offset matching; While in a SAR ADC these could be N capacitors. In this reference design of Fig. 5.7a these N components have the minimal size required to meet the signal-to-thermal-noiseratio constraint (target SNDR). We denote this size as ‘1’. As shown in Table 5.2, such an ADC would consume a reference (D‘1’) analog area Aanalog and power Panalog , and does not need any digital area Adigital , power Pdigital or calibration time Tcal . Its performance is limited by mismatch, having a component variation of .a/ and the resulting SNDR is again normalized to ‘1’. A first way to improve matching between the fundamental circuit components of the reference design of Fig. 5.7a in a fixed silicon technology is by up-sizing the individual circuit components. Up-scaling every device area with a factor U, as shown in Fig. 5.7b improves the component matching and reduces their variance p with U (Eqs. 5.4 and 5.5). As a result, the ‘voltage accuracy’ improves by U , or an SNDR (power ratio) improvement of a factor ‘U’ is achieved at the cost of a ‘U’ times analog area and power increase (See Table 5.2). From the discussions earlier in this paper, it is clear that this is not the way mismatch and non-linearity are overcome in modern ADCs. The oldest calibration techniques to improve ADC matching and linearity are based on analog feedback (e.g. Opamps). Drawback of these analog feedback loops are however the requirement for the circuit to remain active during the whole circuit operation, as well as the very stringent gain-bandwidth (GBW) and linearity requirements for the feedback opamps and reproducibility and yield concerns. Designing under these requirements becomes problematic in scaled technologies and has a detrimental impact on system power consumption and area. This trend, together with the ever decreasing cost of digital gates over technology [2], pushes designers towards digital performance enhancements to improve performance will a smaller area/power penalty. Three techniques will be described: digitally assisted analog selection (including analog redundancy), digitally assisted analog trimming and digital post-distortion.
4.2 Analog Redundancy and Digitally Assisted Analog Selection A straightforward approach to avoid designing accurate analog components is to create analog redundancy, and average the outcome of the redundant, inaccurate (min-size) elements in the digital domain (shown in Fig. 5.7c) to enhance performance. This is e.g. used in Flash convertors to reduce sensitivity to offset voltage, by having several comparators evaluate the same input voltage and use their output in a voting mechanism [25]. By statistically averaging, the designer can get away with small devices.
Component trimming Digital postdistortion
1 C Z/2.ftrim (Š1 C 3. a ) 1 (e.g. 1.2)
Minimal (at startup) Significant (e.g. LUT)
1 1 C 6:a 1 (e.g. 1.2)
log2(Z) 0 (if ran in background)
Minimal Significant (e.g. LUT)
"" ,depends on impairment, f(an. redund., LUT size)
6. a /ftrim (DZ)
sL 2 ; sL 2 (Eq. (5.16)) sL 3=2 ; sL 2 (digital scaling)
Table p 5.2 Costs and SNDR improvement of enhancement techniques. Last column shows the effect of technology scaling on every enhanced ADC (assuming sV sL ) SNDR (defined Technology Aanalog Adigital Panalog Pdigital Tcal by Eq. (5.2)) effect on (P ; A) Min size design 1 / 1 / 0 1 sL 1 ; 1 (Table 5.1) Upscaled U / U / 0 U sL 1 ; 1 (Table 5.1) design Analog X Small, log2(X) X Small, 0 X sL 1 ; 1 (Table 5.1) redundancy log2(X) erfcinv.erfc.3/1=Y / sL 1 ; 1 Component Y Minimal >1 Minimal Y 3 (Table 5.1) selection (at startup)
104 M. Verhelst et al.
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
105
Fig. 5.8 Area and SNR impact of different performance enhancement techniques, normalized to the thermal noise-sized design (1,0). Assumptions for baseline design: 7% mismatch, ftrim;min D 1/10, trimming overhead D 1/10
As shown in Table 5.2, increasing the number of redundant devices bypa factor of X, will only reduce equivalent device mismatch standard deviation by X , hence improving SNDR by X. A small area and power penalty in the digital domain is paid, to implement the averaging. As a result, analog redundancy shows a similar, or even slightly worse performance cost compared to classical up-scaling. Similarly, Fig. 5.8, which plots the SNDR improvement in function of area increase, shows an identical SNDR-area relationship for device up-scaling and analog redundancy, which both linearly reduce the component variation with increasing area (see distribution histograms in Fig. 5.8). Pure analog redundancy is hence not a good strategy to enhance ADC performance. It can however be extended with digitally assisted analog component selection, which is much more interesting [26]. This technique (Fig. 5.7d) aims at digitally selecting the best devices out of the pool of redundant analog components. It has been applied to Flash converters to reduce input offset voltages, where for an N- bit converter, all 2N comparator (Cpreamplifier) stages are replaced by Y identical copies of the same component. During a training phase, the best matching comparator (smallest offset) is selected out of every pool of Y comparators [26, 27]. This “selection step” reduces the variation of the remaining components much more effectively than adding redundancy. It can be derived that the 3:.d / spread
106
M. Verhelst et al.
(determining SNDR) after component selection in scheme (d) is reduced from the spread 3:.a/ of the reference design of scheme (a) as: 3:.d / D erfcinv .erfc.3/1=Y /:.a/
(5.14)
with erfc and erfcinv the (inverse) error function. The resulting “peaking” distribution is depicted in Fig. 5.8. Power savings are more significant, than area savings, since power is saved due to smartly shutting down the non-selected components. However, depending on how the non-selected components are gated, they might still load the input stage, resulting in some additional power consumption compared to the baseline design. The overhead of the off-line calibration required to implement this approach can have significant impact on the system and should not be neglected. Contrary to previous solutions (Fig. 5.7), calibration time (Tcal) will have to be foreseen in the manufacturing environment or when powering up the device to run the selection procedure. Depending on the configuration stability, this could however be a onetime tune-and-store process.
4.3 Digitally Assisted Analog Trimming While analog component selection allows reducing ADC power consumption for a fixed SNDR drastically, it does not come with a significant area breakthrough. Even more importantly though, as shown in the last column of Table 5.2: it does not allow to break with the traditional scaling laws presented in Table 5.1 and hence does not explain the observed scaling of Fig. 5.6. The enhanced designs (b)–(d) don’t scale any better than the reference case (a)! More interesting it is however to trim, instead of selecting components [28–30]. In component trimming (Fig. 5.7e), component variation is reduced by postmanufacturing inserting or removing small fractions of the component. A wellknown example is trimming capacitor values by connecting or disconnecting small capacitor to the main capacitor [30]. Similar trimming can be done to match current sources, gm, etc. [28, 29]. As shown in Fig. 5.8, this kind of trimming reduces the spread of the component drastically, since it cuts the tails of the component variation distribution. Both the amount of trimming steps Z, as well as the size of every trim step required depends on the original variation of the baseline device (.a/ 2 ) and the target SNDR. All trim steps together should cover the 6:.a/ spread of the original component. Or, defining ftrim as the fraction of the trim step size to the original component size: .Z C 1/:ftrim D 6:.a/
(5.15)
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
107
Fundamental unit of digital trimming Vout Ctrim Corig Cp
select Rp
Fig. 5.9 Fundamental unit of digital trimming
The resulting SNDR will then show an improvement with approximately a factor Z (6:.a/ =ftrim ) over the baseline design. This of course comes at a small area cost due to the component selection switches and interconnect overhead. The power cost is often negligible, since the extra load of the switches can be incorporated in the design. Certainly the most important observation is that digitally controlled trimming decouples device sizing from the target SNDR, since it is tuned post-manufacturing to the required SNDR. As a result the area and power cost is nearly independent of SNDR, as seen in Fig. 5.8 by the steep increase in SNDR at almost no area cost. This would lead to the conclusion that minimum sized components (thermal noise limited) can in theory be used as trimmable devices. This however does not hold in practice due to two reasons: 1. The size of a trim component cannot be made arbitrarily small. Technology limits the trim step ftrim . As a result, the maximally achievable SNDR improvement for a design depends on the original mismatch 6:.a/ and the best achievable trim ratio ftrim . 2. The component selection area and power overhead is not negligible for close to minimum size devices. To assess this, let’s look into a representative circuit, which can be used as a “fundamental unit of digital trimming”: a digitally controlled switch, plus a passive element (Rtrim or Ctrim ) (Fig. 5.9). The overhead of using this passive element as a trim component are the parasitics of the switch, which load the component under trim, consume area and power and diminish the effect of the trim impact. In order to keep the overhead marginal and ensure a predictable impact of the trim, the value of the passive trim component should be significantly (e.g. 5X) larger than the parasitic of the switch.
108
M. Verhelst et al.
As a result, these switch parasitics (Cp or Rp ) determine the maximal achievable SNDR improvement and hence the sizing and power consumption of the original component under trim. Since switch parasitics, and hence ftrim;min Cp ; Rp , heavily depend on technology, this directly links the design cost to achieve a certain SNDR to the silicon technology used. Parasitics are moreover characterized by following scaling rules [31]: Cp;switch W:L sL 2
(5.16)
Rp;switch L=W 1
(5.17)
Interconnect parasitics follow different scaling rules [31]: Cp;interc
W:L sL ! .local interconnect/ tox
1 ! .constant length interconnect/
(5.18)
Rp;interc L=.W:H / 1=sL 1=2 ! .local interconnect/ 1=sL 3=2 ! .constant length interconnect/
(5.19)
The relationship between ftrim;min and Cp together with Eq. 5.16 justifies a scaling of the ADC design cost (area and power) with sL 2 over technology: The intrinsic accuracy with which components can be trimmed in a certain technology improves by sL 2 , which does explain the observed trends of Sect. 3. This conclusion holds for C-based trimming, and as long as interconnect parasitics do not dominate. Since interconnect parasitics start to become more and more relevant relative to device parasitics, a slowdown of this area and power scaling trend is to be expected. It is also clear that R-based trimming is not favorable in advanced silicon technologies. Once the trimming accuracy limit of a certain technology is reached, the only way to increase SNDR further in the analog domain is to increase original device sizes. This up-scaling results in a relative decrease of ftrim . It however again has a linear effect on area and power consumption. An alternative to stick with minimal size devices is to increase SNDR in the digital domain by using digital post-distortion when technology prevents further trimming.
4.4 Digital Post-processing Due to the decreasing cost of digital gates over technology generations, digital postdistortion (Fig. 5.7f) to boost ADC performance becomes less and less costly [2]. A multitude of digital post-distortion techniques for ADCs have been developed and published over the past decade and are all very diverse in nature. The two most common, but very distinct, classes of digital post-processing are “look-up-table
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
109
Table 5.3 Analog overhead required for digital impairment correction Impairment type Offset Gain error Radix mismatch (e.g. in SAR) Linearity correction
Required analog overhead ADC dynamic range C max offset ADC dynamic range * max gain error Use nominal radix <2, to ensure max radix 2. Typically radix Š 1.7 Ensure worst case DNL still within spec (smaller nominal DNL)
(LUT)”-based [32] and filter-based [8]. The former corrects analog impairments by using the bare ADC output as the index to a table look-up containing the corrected sample data. This approach is very straightforward and easy to implement, but only suitable for low SNDR (small number of bits) ADCs. It is also not well suited for on-line calibration. Filter based correction eliminates impairments by sending the bare ADC output data through a digital filter. The filter coefficients are adapted (on-line or offline) based on the detected actual ADC impairments. The type of filter required (linear vs. non-linear, order, length, etc.) is heavily dependent on the nature of the impairment(s) under correction. E.g. offset and gain mismatches between channels in a time interleaved ADC can simply be corrected with a linear, single-tap ‘filter’, while skew or non-linearity correction of the same ADC needs complex higher order implementations [8, 33]. These types of adaptive filters are especially attractive in medium to high SNDR ADCs, where LUT approaches become infeasible and where the cost of extra digital gates is relatively low compared to the analog power. Moreover, these filters lend themselves perfectly to on-line training and background adaptation, hence eliminating the need for (and cost of) startup calibration time Tcal , but only if initial settling transients are acceptable before achieving full performance. While very distinct in nature, digital post-distortion techniques have several key characteristics in common: They are all able of achieving very large SNDR improvements, and allow close-to-minimum size ADC front-end designs. Like in the case of digitally assisted trimming, this partly decouples component sizing, area and power requirements from the target SNDR, explaining the observed improvement over technology. However, unlike in the case of digitally assisted trimming, this comes at a significant (digital) area and power penalty. Additionally, a penalty in the analog domain has to be paid as well: Almost all forms of digital post-distortion require analog overhead to allow correction in the digital domain. This overhead is necessary to ensure that no unrecoverable information gets lost when digitizing the data. Table 5.3 lists the required overhead for common digitally corrected ADC impairments. The amount of analog overhead area and power consumption due to this depends on the (3- value of the) expected impairment, but can typically be estimated to be between 10% and 20%. It finally has to be noted that sometimes digital power and area are non-existent if leveraged from other DSP blocks already present in the system [34].
110
M. Verhelst et al.
5 Cost-Aware Calibration Design 5.1 Cost-Aware Enhancement Selection Previous section gave an overview of strategies for digital ADC enhancement. The effect of every strategy on the area, power consumption, the calibration time, as well as the SNDR was discussed. As shown, the various strategies improve component matching, which in its turn allows to scale down analog component sizes, and hence area and power consumption. However, often a penalty on either the digital area, power or the calibration time has to be paid. As a result, the selection of the optimal strategy for a particular ADC design is not straightforward. It requires a careful analysis of the expected analog savings due to the enhancement compared to its cost. Depending on the relative importance ˛ i of area vs. power vs. calibration time in the overall cost factor K of the particular design a different solution will be preferred. K D ˛1 :.Aanalog C Adigital / C ˛2 :.Panalog C Pdigital / C ˛3 :Tcal
(5.20)
Often a combination of different strategies offers the best trade-off. This “strategy selection/combination” problem can be treated as an optimization problem. Starting from a minimum sized design, without any enhancements, the overall cost factor K has to be minimized under an SNDR constraint by successively applying several enhancement strategies (Fig. 5.10). At every point in this optimization process, the enhancement strategy x with the highest SNDR vs. cost sensitivity SSNDR; K; x should be applied first until the target SNDR is achieved: SSNDR;K;x D
SNDR=x ; applying enhancement strategy x K=x
Fig. 5.10 Optimizing K under SNDR constraint by successively applying performance enhancement with largest sensitivity
(5.21)
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
111
This sensitivity is a measure of the expected cost investment to achieve SNDR improvement with this strategy. As can be seen from Fig. 5.8 and Table 5.2, up-scaling and analog redundancy have and equal SNDR-cost sensitivity of ‘1’. Analog selection demonstrates a larger sensitivity, which is however still far off from the sensitivity of digitally assisted trimming, being 2/ftrim considering area cost and even larger when taking power cost into account. However, the benefit of this large SNDR sensitivity to trimming is only limited, since technology restricts achievable ftrim . When more SNDR improvement is needed, additional up-scaling can however be combined with trimming, resulting in a joint SNDR-cost sensitivity of: SupscaleCtrim
p p 6:.a/ = U =ftrim :U p 6:.a/ = U =ftrim .for large U / (5.22) D .U 1/ C 3.a/ = U
with .a/ and ftrim , resp. the component standard deviation and trim-ratio of the minimum size baseline design. This sensitivity decreases when U gets larger. The SNDR-cost sensitivity of digital post-distortion cannot be put into formulae that easily, as it heavily depends on the type (LUT vs. filter) and complexity of the implemented enhancement. Moreover, the sensitivity will in general be larger for complex, high resolution ADCs, since the area and cost adder will be relatively smaller compared to the overall ADC area and power consumption [2]. This sensitivity should be compared to the (decreasing) SupscaleCtrim , to determine at what point in the design it no longer makes sense to add additional trimming (in combination with up-scaling) and post-distortion should be deployed instead due to its larger sensitivity.
5.2 Practical Example: TI SAR ADC Calibrations In this section, the cost K of a time interleaved (TI) successive approximation (SAR) ADC will be optimized by applying different enhancement strategies. The performance of the 7-bit, 2.5 GHz 45 nm TI SAR ADC [35] (architecture in Fig. 5.11), is severely impacted by mismatch of the following parameters: • Capacitor values within every ADC: The linearity of a SAR ADC depends on the ADC’s capacitor ratios, which have to be equal to 2. • Offset and gain mismatch: Different (comparator) offset voltages and gains for the different TI channels also cause spurious tones. • Sampling skew mismatch between the different TI channels. 5.2.1 Capacitor Value Mismatch As depicted in Fig. 5.11, the SAR ADC under study does not rely on a binary weighted DAC, but uses a C-2C DAC instead [36]. This has the advantage that the
112
M. Verhelst et al.
Fig. 5.11 Architecture of the TI SAR ADC (* D parasitic capacitor)
DAC size only increases linearly with the resolution and small, fixed capacitor sizes can be used. However, a C-2C DAC suffers heavily from the parasitic capacitances at the intermediated nodes, which distort the capacitor ratios and can serve as a resolution limit [36]. The proposed SAR however incorporates these parasitic capacitors into the design: The ‘Cu /2’ capacitors in this design (Fig. 5.11) represent the total parasitic capacitances at the intermediate nodes but are also included as an integral part of the DAC [35]. Their nominal (parasitic) value is around 40 fF, which sets the limit of the minimum size design of this ADC, which is hence not thermal noise limited. The values of these parasitic capacitors will be severely mismatched and have to be corrected by calibration. When assessing the SNDR-cost sensitivity of both capacitor trimming and digital post-distortion, capacitor trimming is to be preferred here due to the achievable ftrim being: ftrim D
Ctrim D 0:125; 40f F
with Ctrim D 5:Cp;switch D 5fF in 45 nm CMOS design
(5.23)
As shown in Fig. 5.11, a slightly (2.2X) smaller effective ftrim can even be achieved by placing several trim capacitors in series. The trimming structure is able to compensate the range of 6. mismatch with a Z D 6, assuming a mismatch of D 5% on the nominally 40 fF parasitic capacitors. The resulting measured performance improvement can be seen in Fig. 5.12.
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
113
Fig. 5.12 INL improvement after capacitor trimming of individual SAR ADC
Fig. 5.13 Automated offset calibration loop in TI SAR ADCs [35]
The remaining capacitors ‘Cu ’ and ‘2Cu ’ are formed by metal finger capacitors (MFC). In the technology (45 nm LPCMOS ) used, their matching is more than sufficient to achieve 7-bit resolution without the need for additional calibration.
5.2.2 Offset and Gain Mismatch Once mismatch within the individual ADCs is calibrated, the mismatch across ADCs has to be addressed. In this design, an un-calibrated offset mismatch up to ˙85 mV is expected, while un-calibrated gain mismatch is typically limited to less than 5%. Both offset, as well as gain mismatches can easily be detected in the digital domain. Also the circuitry to correct for them does not require a lot of digital gates. However, due to the large offset mismatch (3- spread typically equals ˙85 mV D 34% of comparator input range) the analog cost adder of the required extra analog redundancy to allow digital post-distortion is very large. As a result, the SNDR-cost sensitivity of digital post-distortion will be poor for offset mismatch correction, while it is good for gain mismatch correction. As a result, the ADC gain is calibrated in the digital domain using a multiplier, while an automated offset calibration loop is implemented in the analog domain (Fig. 5.13).
114
M. Verhelst et al. 0
0 SNDR = 31.4 dB SFDR = 42.8 dB
–20
–40 PSD [dB]
PSD [dB]
–40 –60 –80
–60 –80
–100
–100
–120
–120
–140
SNDR = 36.0 dB SFDR = 49.1 dB
–20
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
–140
14
0
2
4
8
Input frequency [Hz]
x 10
6
8
10
Input frequency [Hz]
12
14 x 10
8
Fig. 5.14 Performance of full ADC before (left) and after (right) TI channel mismatch correction
5.2.3 Sampling Skew Mismatch Sampling skew mismatch affects the maximum ADC performance by [37]: SNRmax D 20 log
1 skew fsignal =fsample
.M 1/ 2 4 dB 10 log M
(5.24)
with skew the sampling error standard deviation and M the number of time interleaved ADC channels. The original sampling skew mismatch in our design is estimated have a skew 1:5% of the sampling period. This sampling skew mismatch between different ADCs is much harder to detect than gain or offset mismatch, and has attracted a lot of attention from the research community. The most common estimation approach is a digitally implemented LMS optimization loop [33]. While implemented in the digital domain, the correction can both be executed digitally (digital post-distortion) or in the analog domain by using digitally assisted trimming. The required compensation step resolution is found from Eq. 5.24 to be about 0.2% of the total ADC sampling period, or 1 psec. Digital post-distortion involves the implementation of a time-varying fractional delay filter, often realized with a (poly-phase) Farrow filter [38]. The instantiation of this, typically at least 30-tap [33], digital filter comes with a large area and power penalty, as it is always on and runs at the full rate. The digitally assisted trimming counterpart consists of a digitally tuned delay line. This can be realized by cascaded inverters, loaded by a programmable capacitor bank (16 2.5 fF capacitors). Both the area (45 um2 /channel) and power cost (50uW/channel) of this are negligible on the total ADC design. The realized performance enhancement of the full TI SAR ADC under the described channel mismatch correction (offset, gain, timing) can be derived from Fig. 5.14.
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
115
6 Conclusions Theoretical analysis of ADC scaling over technology predicts a flat to increasing trend on the ADC’s area and power consumption. A study over survey data of all published state-of-the-art ADC designs over the last decade however shows a cubic area and power improvement with technology gate length. The same survey data seems to indicate that this improvement is realized by heavily relying on capacitorbased ADC architectures, as well as by exploiting digitally assisted performance enhancement techniques. Several digitally assisted techniques to improve performance of mismatchlimited ADCs are evaluated. Digitally assisted trimming, as well as digital postdistortion do not only show the largest SNDR-cost sensitivity, but also demonstrate the same cubic improvement relationship with the technology gate length, which explains the observed ADC scaling. A practical design example is used to describe the ADC enhancement selection for different mismatch parameters. More work is required on system level techniques for fast, but low complexity background mismatch estimation techniques, to limit the calibration time penalty of both digitally assisted trimming and post-distortion.
References 1.P. Scholtens, D. Smola, M. Vertregt, Systematic power reduction and performance analysis of mismatch limited ADC designs, in Proceedings of ISPED, Bordeaux, Aug 2005, pp. 78–83 2.B. Murmann, Limits on ADC power dissipation, in Analog Circuit Design, ed. by A.H.M. van Roermund, H. Casier, M. Steyaert (Springer, Dordrecht, 2006), pp. 351–367 3. Y. Chiu, B. Nikolic, P.R. Gray, Scaling of analog-to-digital converters into ultra-deepsubmicron CMOS, in Proceedings of IEEE CICC, San Jose, 2005, pp. 375–382 4.K. Uyttenhove, M. Steyaert, Speed–power–accuracy tradeoff in high-speed CMOS ADCs. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. (CAS-II) 49(4), 280–287 (2002) 5. P. Kinget, M. Steyaert, Impact of transistor mismatch on the speed-accuracy-power trade-off of analog CMOS circuits, in Proceedings of IEEE CICC, Rochester, 1988, pp. 333–336 6. M. Pelgrom, A. Duinmaijer, A. Welbers, Matching properties of MOS transistors. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 24(5), 1433–1440 (1989) 7. P. Kinget, Device mismatch and tradeoffs in the design of analog circuits. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 40(6), 1212–1224 (2005) 8. P. Nikaeen, B. Murmann, Digital compensation of dynamic acquisition errors at the front-end of high-performance A/D converters. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Signal Process. 3(3), 499–508 (2009) 9. A. Abo, P. Gray, A 1.5-V, 10-bit, 14.3-MS/s CMOS pipeline analog-to-digital converter. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 34(4), 599–606 (1999) 10.K. Laker, W. Sansen, Design of Analog Integrated Circuits and Systems (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1994) 11. P. Woerlee, M. Knitel, R. van Langevelde, D. Klaassen, L. Tiemeijer, A. Scholten, A. Zegersvan Duijnhoven, RF-CMOS performance trends. IEEE Trans. Electron. Devices 48(8), 1776– 1782 (2001) 12. C. Diaz, D. Tang, J. Sun, CMOS technology for MS/RF SoC. IEEE Trans. Electron. Devices 50(3), 557–566 (2003)
116
M. Verhelst et al.
13. Q. Huang, F. Piazza, P. Orsatti, T. Ohguro, The impact of scaling down to deep submicron on CMOS RF circuits. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 33(7), 1023–1036 (1998) 14. M. Vertregt, P. Scholtens, Scalable high-speed analog circuit design, in Analog Circuit Design, ed. by M. Steyaert, J.H. Huijsing, A.H.M. van Roermund (Kluwer, Boston, 2003), pp. 3–21 15. C.-H. Jan et al., RF CMOS technology scaling in high-k/metal gate era for RF SoC (Systemon-chip) applications, in Proceedings of IEEE IEDM, 2010, San Francisco, 2010, pp. 27.2.1 16. International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors, 2009 edition: www.16.net/Links/ 200916/Home2009.htm 17. B. Murmann, A/D converter trends: power dissipation, scaling and digitally assisted architectures, in Proceedings of IEEE CICC, 2008, San Jose, 2008, pp. 105–112 18. B. Murmann, ADC performance survey 1997–2010, [Online]. Available: www.stanford.edu/ murmann/adcsurvey.html 19. P. Malla, H. Lakdawala, K. Kornegay, K. Soumyanath, A 28 mW spectrum-sensing reconfigurable 20 MHz 72 dB-SNR 70 dB-SNDR DT † ADC for 802.11n/WiMAX receivers, in Proceedings of IEEE ISSCC, 2008, San Francisco, 2008, pp. 496–497 20. M. van Elzakker, E. van Tuijl, P. Geraedts, D. Schinkel, E. Klumperink, B. Nauta, A 1.9 W 4.4fJ/Conversion-step 10b 1MS/s charge-redistribution ADC, in IEEE ISSCC, 2008, San Francisco, 2008, pp. 244–245 21. H. Chung, A. Rylyakov, Z. Toprak Deniz, J. Bulzacchelli, G.-Y. Wei, D. Friedman, A 7.5-GS/s 3.8-ENOB 52-mW flash ADC with clock duty cycle control in 65 nm CMOS, in Proceedings of Symposium on VLSI Circuits, 2009, Kyoto, 2009, pp. 268–269 22. B. Murmann, Digitally assisted analog circuits. IEEE Micro 26(2), 38–47 (2006) 23. B. Murmann, C. Vogel, H. Koeppl, Digitally enhanced analog circuits: system aspects, in Proceedings of ISCAS, 2008, Seattle, 2008, pp. 560–563 24. R. van de Plassche, A sigma-delta modulator as an A/D converter. IEEE TCAS 25(7), 510–514 (1978) 25. S. Weaver, B. Hershberg, D. Knierim, U. Moon, A 6b stochastic flash analog-to-digital converter without calibration or reference ladder, in IEEE ASSCC, 2008, Fukuoka, 2008, pp. 373–376 26. L. Pileggi, G. Keskin, X. Li, K. Mai, J. Proesel, Mismatch analysis and statistical design at 65 nm and below, in IEEE CICC 2008, San Jose, 2008, pp. 9–12 27. M. Flynn, C. Donovan, L. Sattler, Digital calibration incorporating redundancy of flash ADCs. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. CAS-II 50(5), 205–213 (2003) 28. B. Verbruggen, J. Craninckx, M. Kuijk, P. Wambacq, G.V. der Plas, A 2.2 mW 1.75 GS/s 5 bit folding flash ADC in 90 nm digital CMOS. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(3), 874–882 (2009) 29. D.C. Daly, A.P. Chandrakasan, A 6-bit, 0.2 V to 0.9 V highly digital flash ADC With comparator redundancy. IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 44(11), 3030–3038 (2009) 30. G.V. der Plas, S. Decoutere, S. Donnay, A 0.16pJ/conversion-Step 2.5 mW 1.25GS/s 4b ADC in a 90 nm digital CMOS process, in IEEE ISSCC, 2006, San Francisco, 2008, p. 2310 31. J. Rabaey, A. Chandrakasan, B. Nikolic (eds.), Digital Integrated Circuits, 2nd edn. (Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, 2003) 32. C. Grace, P. Hurst, S. Lewis, A 12b 80MS/s pipelined ADC with bootstrapped digital calibration, in IEEE ISSCC, 2004, San Francisco, 2004, p. 460 33. C. Vogel, S. Saleem, S. Mendel, Adaptive blind compensation of gain and timing mismatches in M-channel time-interleaved ADCs, in Proceedings of IEEE ICECS, Malta, Sept 2008, pp. 49–52 34. Y. Oh, B. Murmann, System embedded ADC calibration for OFDM receivers. IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. CAS-I 53(8), 1693–1703 (2006) 35. E. Alpman, H. Lakdawala, R. Carley, K. Soumyanath, A 1.1 V 50 mW 2.5GS/s 7b timeinterleaved C-2C SAR ADC in 45 nm LP digital CMOS, in IEEE ISSCC, 2009, San Francisco, 2009, pp. 76–77 36. S. Iyer et al., A 0.5 mm2 integrated capacitive vibration sensor with sub-10 zF/rt-Hz noise floor, in IEEE CICC, 2005, San Jose, 2005, pp. 93–96
5 Considerations for Cost-Efficient Calibration of Scaled ADCs
117
37. Y.-C. Jenq, Digital spectra of nonuniformly sampled signals: a robust sampling time offset estimation algorithm for ultra high-speed waveform interleaving. IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas. 39(1), 71–75 (1990) 38. C. Farrow, A continuously variable digital delay element. Proc. IEEE ISCAS 3, 2641–2645 (1988)
Chapter 6
A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS K. Bult, C.-H. Lin, F. van der Goes, J. Westra, J. Mulder, Y. Lin, E. Arslan, E. Ayranci, and X. Liu
Abstract A 12b 2.9GS/s current-steering DAC implemented in 65 nm CMOS is presented, with an IM3 < 60dBc beyond 1 GHz while driving a 50 load with an output swing of 2.5Vppd and dissipating a power of 188 mW. The SFDR measured at 2.9 GS/s is better than 60 dB beyond 340 MHz while the SFDR measured at 1.6 GS/s is better than 60 dB beyond 440 MHz. The increase in performance at highfrequencies, compared to previously published results, is mainly obtained by adding local cascodes on top of the current-switches with “always-ON” biasing.
1 Introduction In large Systems-on-Chips (SoC), Data Converters are critical for connecting signals to the real world, often limiting the accuracy and speed of the overall system. The clear trend towards digital signal processing of traditional analog functions, reducing the Analog Front-End (AFE) and Analog Back-End (ABE) to a bare minimum, by connecting the Data Converter directly to the terminals, requires very high bandwidth and sampling speeds. As an example, 10GBASE-T Ethernet requires a Transmit DAC sampling at 1.6 GS/s with at least 70 dB IM3 up to a frequency of 400 MHz, while supporting an amplitude of 2.5 Vppd driven in to a 50 load. In recent years many papers have been published on high-speed DAC design [1–9]. Most of these designs concentrate on obtaining good low-frequency
K. Bult () • F. van der Goes • J. Westra • J. Mulder • Y. Lin • E. Arslan • E. Ayranci • X. Liu Broadcom Netherlands BV, Bunnik, The Netherlands e-mail:
[email protected] C.-H. Lin Broadcom Corporation, Irvine, CA, USA
M. Steyaert et al. (eds.), Analog Circuit Design: Low Voltage Low Power; Short Range Wireless Front-Ends; Power Management and DC-DC, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-1926-2 6, © IEEE. Reprinted, with permission, from K. Bult, C.-H. Lin, F. van der Goes, J. Westra, J. Mulder, Y. Lin, E. Arslan, E. Ayranci, and X. Liu, A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS, Journal of Solid State Circuit, December 2009
119
120
K. Bult et al.
IM3 [dB]
–70
–60
–50
Fsig [MHz] 100
200
400
800
1600
Fig. 6.1 IM3 requirements for this design
performance and use techniques like calibration [1] or Dynamic Element Matching [10]. However, these techniques do not help the performance at higher frequencies since at those frequencies matching problems are not the limiting factor anymore. The goal of this paper is to design a DAC which achieves a minimum of 70 dB IM3 at low frequencies, maintains that performance up to a minimum of 400 MHz and achieves at least 60 dB IM3 at 800 MHz, as is shown in Fig. 6.1. Currently, no published designs meet these requirements. Section 2 introduces the chosen architecture. Sections 3 and 4 deal with various distortion mechanisms that are dominant at low- and high-frequencies respectively. In Sect. 5 the DAC-Cell for the thermometer-coded Coarse-DAC is shown and the implemented techniques are discussed in detail. The test-chip and set-up are discussed in Sect. 6 and the results of measurements along with a comparisons with the theory (as discussed in Sect. 5) as well as with previously published data are shown in Sect. 7. Finally, Sect. 8 summarizes the conclusions.
2 Architecture For fast-sampling applications the Current-Steering architecture is the architecture of choice [1–9]. Because of the obvious advantages of thermometer-coded DACs with respect to DNL, glitch-energy, monotonicity and linearity on the one hand and on the other hand the advantages of binary-coded DACs with respect to compactness and simplicity, a segmented design was chosen (Fig. 6.2). Using the approach outlined in [2] the optimal segmentation ratio was determined and a 6b thermometercoded DAC was combined with a 6b binary-coded DAC. A transformer connects the DAC to the load. For proper termination reasons, on each side of the transformer the impedance equals 100 and the total effective impedance to the DAC equals 50 .
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS
100 Ω
121
100 Ω
cable-imp. Therm. DAC
2.5 V
Binary DAC
6 MSBs
6 LSBs
row decoding + latches
latches
Fig. 6.2 Top-level architecture
row
decode
column
column decoding + latches
Fig. 6.3 Thermometer-coded Coarse DAC
The Thermometer-coded MSB section (Coarse-DAC) determines the overall performance with respect to linearity and most of the design effort was focused on that block. The architecture is shown in Fig. 6.3. Although the final layout was not done in a matrix-style layout but rather in a single-line layout, the cells are driven by row and column decoders as this turns out to be area efficient. Latches are placed at the input of the DAC, after the column and row-decoding and inside the cells.
3 Low Frequency Performance This section deals with error-mechanisms that are frequency-independent and as such will dominate the accuracy at low frequencies.
122
K. Bult et al.
Vss Isupply IR
Fig. 6.4 IR-drop in the supply-line causes DNL
3.1 Matching Transistor-mismatch in the current source of the DAC-cell is a source of nonlinearity, especially in the coarse-DAC. Care has to be taken to obtain good matching by using sufficient gate-area [11], short distances between the transistors and equal environments through the use of dummy-transistors. Many papers have been written about various techniques to improve matching between current sources, like calibration techniques [1] or Dynamic Element Matching (DEM) [10]. Although there are ample examples of papers that show that for low-frequencies this does indeed improve the linearity of the DAC, for high-frequencies these techniques in general do not help and often even degrade the performance. This is mostly because both techniques complicate the design significantly, including the layout, whereas high-frequency performance mostly benefits from simplicity and low parasitic capacitances. As a result no matching improvement techniques were used other than proper layout and proper transistor-sizing.
3.2 IR-Drops on the Supply Routing of the supply-lines to the DAC current sources is a critical step. As the supply-lines carry current, any resistance will cause voltage drops (“IR”, see Fig. 6.4) on the supply line, which in turn can cause the individual gate-source voltages to be unequal [12]. As a result the value of the currents will become smaller (or bigger) along the supply-line (Fig. 6.4), causing not only a DNL problem, but, without any randomization, could also cause significant INL problems. Solutions can be found in using wide power supply lines and binary trees for the supply-grid.
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS
RL
123
RL Vout
2Zo (N+n)
(N+n) Io 2
(N–n) Io 2
2Zo (N–n)
Fig. 6.5 The effect of finite current source output impedance on DAC linearity
3.3 Finite Output Impedance Finite output impedance of DAC current sources leads to distortion, as has been pointed out by several authors [4, 8, 9]. Figure 6.5 shows a thermometer-coded DAC with ideal current sources, but with finite current source output impedance Ro . In this graph, N equals the total number of current sources, Io is the value of one current source and n equals the digital input code (N n N). Depending on the digital input code, more or less current sources are connected to the left and the right output nodes. Along with that also more or less output impedances are connected in parallel with the load impedance RL . This means that the total effective load impedance becomes signal-dependent. Since the output voltage is a simple multiplication of the current and the output impedance, a signal-dependent load impedance leads to distortion. A straightforward calculation of the transfer-function from the digital input word (n) to the output voltage Vout in Fig. 6.5 leads to the following expression: h i Vout D RL NIo .n=N/ C .n=N/3 ŒRL N=2Ro 2
(6.1)
For full swing conditions (n D N) the expression for third order distortion becomes: HD3 D ŒRL N=4Ro 2
(6.2)
As Eq. 6.2 shows, low third-order distortion (due to this mechanism only) requires a high output impedance from each current source: Ro NRL . This can be fairly easily achieved at low frequencies by cascoding and if necessary double or active cascoding. For high frequencies this is not a sufficient solution as will be shown in Sect. 4.
124
K. Bult et al.
4 High Frequency Performance High frequency performance is quite a different problem from its low frequency counterpart and special measures have to be taken.
4.1 Switch Gate Driving It is well-known that it is important to keep the voltage across the current sources as stable as possible during the output current transition from one side to the other [2, 8]. Special gate-driving circuits have been developed for that purpose [8]. However, it is also important that the transition itself is as short as possible. The main reasons for that are to reduce the effects of switch driver mismatch, clock jitter, decoding feed through and, to some extent, device noise. CML-drivers are often used to obtain maximum possible clock speed (because of the reduced swing), but the steepest transitions are obtained using regular CMOS logic. In this design the latch of Fig. 6.6 is used for two reasons, it creates the steepest transition [2] and has the shortest clock-to-Q delay known to the authors [8]. Inherently, this circuit has a low crossing of the Q and QB signals. If followed by inverters for Q and QB, the signals become high-crossing and can be used to drive the switch gates directly. It was found that the rapid transitions exhibited by this circuit have more benefits than any reduced swing circuit known to the authors.
4.2 Decoding Feedthrough Since decoding signals contain information about the input signal, any feedthrough from the decoding to the DAC output can lead to distortion. In [8] Data-Dependent Clock Loading is discussed and a solution is presented. Another error mechanism is non-symmetrical decoding. In the design presented here, decoding is done as if the current source cells were distributed in a matrix-style layout, using column and
clk D QB
Q
Fig. 6.6 Fast latch
DB
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS col
125
row clk QB
col+1
row Q
col
col+1
Fig. 6.7 Latch with symmetrical decoding
row signals [2]. A cell can get activated either because the next column signal is active or the current column and the current row are active. The circuit in Fig. 6.7 has been used to make sure that in all cases the cell gets activated with the same signal strength [3]. At high speed the transition of digital signals can still have a finite settling effect at the end of the clock-period and a difference can emerge between the values of those signals that had to transition and those that already transitioned in a previous clock-period. Adding an extra latch reduces this effect considerably.
4.3 Switch Driver Mismatch Mismatch in switch driver transistors can lead to small differences in the speed of the transition and therefore also the exact switching moment. Deviations in switching moments are more important at higher signal speeds and therefore a degradation proportional to frequency is to be expected. For good high-frequency performance, care should be taken to obtain good matching of the driver transistors. However, since any spread in switching moment is proportional to the switching time, the absolute transition of the driving signal should be as fast as possible. Both good matching as well as a fast transition requires the driver transistors to be fairly large. The latch or logic preceding the driver is less sensitive and can be scaled down in size, leading to a tapered design in logic, latches and driver. Also the supply-line needs to be low-Ohmic and routed in such a way that the actual driving strength for all drivers is matching well.
126
K. Bult et al.
4.4 Output Current Tree Equal delays are not only relevant in the clock-tree but just as much in the signal path. For that reason it is crucial to design the paths from the cells to the outputnodes as well-matched as possible. A binary output-current tree is used in an effort to keep all possible delays in the signal path the same.
4.5 Output Impedance at Higher Frequencies As discussed in section III.C, finite current source output impedance causes distortion in current-steering DACs. Equation 6.2 shows the expression for third harmonic distortion (HD3) at low frequencies. In the analysis it was assumed that the output impedance was purely real and equal to Ro . At higher frequencies this assumption is no longer valid. A better assumption would be that the output impedance can be modeled by the parallel connection of a resistor and a capacitor: Zo D Ro == .1=j!Co / :
(6.3)
An expression for HD3 valid for all frequencies is found by substituting Ro in (6.2) by jZo j: HD3 D ŒRL N=4 jZo j2
(6.4)
As the impedance Zo shows a first-order roll-off with frequency, it can be expected that for higher frequencies (! > 1/Ro Co ) HD3 degrades quadratically with frequency and this will become the dominant distortion mechanism. The effective output capacitance Co being switched back and forth between the positive and negative output, will be referred to as the “switching capacitor” in the remainder of this paper and should be kept small. A numerical example may make the above more clear. A 12b DAC is built from a 6b Fine-DAC and a 6b Coarse-DAC and the Coarse-DAC is thermometer coded. The number of current sources in the Coarse-DAC is 64 (DN). Using Eq. 6.4 with a load resistance of 50 (DRL ) and HD3 67.5 dB (D IM3 70 dB) yields jZo j 39k, which seems reasonable and could be achieved through cascoding. However, if this level of HD3 also is required at an output frequency of 600 MHz, the maximum capacitance in this impedance can be no more than 6.8fF. This is very difficult to achieve indeed.
5 The DAC-Cell After discussing various error mechanisms in Sects. 3 and 4, this section deals with the solution proposed here. The DAC-Cell designed to combat these issues is shown in Fig. 6.8.
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS
2.50 V
127
2.5 V supply
DAC-CELL M5
1.75V
M6
3 Decoding + Latches
4
M4
M3
M13 1.0 V supply
1.0 V supply
BIASING
2 M12
M9
M8
M2
M11
0.75 V
M7
M1
M10
0.41 V
Fig. 6.8 DAC-Cell
5.1 Low Frequency Issues To obtain good matching between the Coarse-DAC currents, it is of key importance that transistor M1 is well matched to its counterparts in the other DAC-cells. For this reason M1 is sized large enough to support the required matching [11] and is placed in a large array of transistors with ample dummies placed at each end of the array. Triple cascoding (M2, M3/M4 and M5/M6) is used to prevent finite outputimpedance of the current sources dominating the low frequency distortion.
5.2 High-Frequency Output Impedance The goal of this paper is to obtain good harmonic performance even at high frequencies. As pointed out in Sect. 4.5, it is crucial to keep the effective “switching” capacitance Co as small as possible. Therefore M2 is sized as small as possible to reduce the parasitic capacitance at the sources of switches M3 and M4, which themselves are also sized minimally. Since the switches operate with a large Vgs ,
128
K. Bult et al.
their sizes are close to the minimum allowed in the technology. The device sizes in the DAC-cell are therefore large at the bottom (for good accuracy), getting smaller in the middle (just large enough to support the current) and close to the minimum at the switches. As discussed in Sect. 5.1, M5 and M6 are added in each cell to reduce the effect of finite output-impedance at low frequencies. Unfortunately, at higher frequencies this techniques does not work that well. M5 and M6 do reduce the effect of parasitic capacitances from M1 to M4, but also add their own parasitic capacitances, primarily their own Cgs ’s [9]. When M3 and M4 are switching, so are the Cgs ’s of M5 and M6 and they become the dominant limitation of the switching output impedance of the current source.
5.3 The “Switching Impedance” It is important at this point, to realize that the part of the output impedance that is hurting the distortion performance is only that part which is actually switching. Any impedances (like parasitic capacitances) which are not switching, but are rather fixed at each side of the output, are not contributing to distortion. This observation leads to one of the key contributions of this paper. In the remainder of this paper the term “switching impedance” is used for that part of the output impedance that is actually switching, equivalent to Zo in Eqs. 6.3 and 6.4. At higher frequencies Zo is dominated by the “switching capacitance” Co .
5.4 The Proposed Solution Adding small current sources (M7–M9 and M10–M12) to the sources of cascodes M5–M6 prevents the cascodes from being fully switched off. That means that even if the current from the current source M1/M2 is not routed through a particular cascode, that cascode remains active. In turn this means that the parasitic capacitances associated with nodes 3 and 4 can still be observed from the DACcell output, irrespective of the status of the switches M3–M4. Therefore these capacitors will not contribute to distortion degradation. Now, the first switching capacitors that can be observed are the Cgs ’s of M3 and M4, but their effect on finite output impedance is reduced by the intrinsic gain (gm .rout ) of the cascode transistors M5–M6. The use of the cascode transistors M5–M6 together with the small current sources M7–M9 and M10–M12 achieves a reduction of the switching output-impedance, and therefore also the distortion, by an order of magnitude. To make the solution proposed here more clear, the effect discussed above is illustrated in Fig. 6.9, where both the circuits of the “on”-impedance Zo (on) as well as the “off”-impedance Zo (off) are shown. The “switching-impedance” Zo can be obtained mathematically through:
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS
Zo(off)
Zo(on)
M5
129
Zo
M6
M3
M5
M3
1 / Zo = 1 / Zo(on) – 1 / Zo(off)
Fig. 6.9 Subtracting the “off ”-impedance Zo (off ) from the “on”-impedance Zo (on). The resulting “switching-impedance” Zo is shown on the right
1=Zo D 1=Zo .on/ 1=Zo .off/ ;
(6.5)
as is shown in Fig. 6.9. By “subtracting” the two circuits, as a result of which all the capacitances associated with M5/M6 are cancelled, the first capacitor seen from the output becomes the Cgs of M3/M4. However, this capacitance is reduced by the intrinsic gain of both M3/M4 as well as M5/M6, improving the performance by a factor (gm .rout 2 ). In order to keep the power dissipation as low as possible, the additional current sources should be kept as small as possible. Their purpose is to keep M5–M6 “on” in order to keep the parasitic capacitances associated with node 3 and 4 observable at all times. However, if the additional current source values are too small, the switching of the DAC-cell will vary the Cgs ’s of M5–M6 too much and a finite effect on distortion will be the result. Simulations have shown that a relative small value of 1–2% of the main current source is sufficient to keep the Cgs ’s of M5–M6 fairly constant.
6 Test-Chip The 12b DAC was built from a 6b Thermometer-coded Coarse-DAC and a 6b Binary-coded Fine-DAC (as shown in Fig. 6.2). The Coarse-DAC uses 63 DACCells as depicted in Fig. 6.8. As mentioned before, although the layout of the coarse-DAC was implemented with all the current sources in a straight line (as opposed to a matrix style layout), the decoding was implemented using column and row decoding using the circuit of Fig. 6.7, as this results in a very effective decoding structure.
130
K. Bult et al.
A transformer was used (as depicted in Figs. 6.2 and 6.8) to connect to the loadimpedance. As the total effective load-impedance is 50 and a 2.5 Vppd swing is required by the application, the total available current for driving the load is 50 mA. As a result of that large signal-swing the center-tap of the transformer is biased at 2.5 V, which necessitates the use of thick-oxide devices for M5 and M6. Two Direct Digital Frequency Synthesizers (DDFS) were integrated along with the DAC to enable two-tone testing. This avoids the problem of having to bring highfrequency digital signals onto the chip for test purposes. In the real application that is of course also not necessary because the digital signals to drive the DAC come from a dedicated Digital Signal Processor (DSP).
7 Measurements The design was implemented in 65 nm CMOS technology and measures 0.31 mm2 . The layout is shown in Fig. 6.10. The power-dissipation was 188 mW, combined from a 1.0 and 2.5 V supply. The measured INL and DNL were 0.5lsb and 0.3lsb respectively on a 12b level. All dynamic measurements were performed using the two on-board DDFS’s. Although the circuit was designed for a 1.6 GS/s application, it ran with good performance up to 2.9 GS/s. Many of the measurements were performed at 2.9 GS/s, others at the speed of the application, 1.6 GS/s.
7.1 IM3 Measurements Figure 6.11 shows a spectrum of the output signal of a two-tone test centered at 1 GHz and sampling at 2.9 GS/s. As can been seen the IM3 is better than 62 dB.
Biasing
Tail Current Sources Switches + Cascodes Decoding + Registers
Fig. 6.10 DAC layout
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS
131
Fig. 6.11 Two-Tone measurement centered around 1 GHz while sampling at 2.9 GS/s 100
[6] @ 0.4 GS / s
90
IM3 [dB]
Theory 80 This work @ 2.9 GS / s
70 60 [4] @ 1.0 GS / s 50
[5] @ 1.4 GS / s 400
800 Frequency [MHz]
1200
Fig. 6.12 Measured IM3 versus signal-frequency. Note the differences in output swing and sampling-frequency
Many of those measurements were taken and Fig. 6.12 shows the measured IM3 results versus signal frequency, sampling at 2.9 GS/s. The figure shows a 70 dB IM3 bandwidth of 550 MHz and a 60 dB IM3 bandwidth of more than 1 GHz.
132
K. Bult et al. 100 M Zo(off)
Zo [Ohm]
1M
Zo
Zo(on)
10 K
100
100 K
1M
10 M 100 M Frequency [MHz]
1G
10 G
Fig. 6.13 Simulated output impedances Zo (ON) and Zo (OFF) versus frequency. The switching impedance Zo is calculated using (6.5)
7.2 Comparison with Theory In order to show the validity of the simple high-frequency distortion model discussed in Sect. 4.5, the output-impedance of the DAC-cell, as shown in Fig. 6.8, was simulated, both for the output that is ON as well as for the output that is OFF. The results are shown in Fig. 6.13 as Zo (ON) and Zo (OFF). An effective switchingimpedance Zo was extracted using Eq. 6.5. By taking the imaginary part of Zo we can make an estimate of the “switching-capacitance”. Both the imaginary part of Zo as well as the switching-capacitance is shown in Fig. 6.14. For frequencies up to about 200 MHz the estimated switching capacitance is about 5fF, after which the capacitance increases and peaks around 1.5 GHz at 9.5fF. At a frequency of 600 MHz the value is about 6.5fF, very close to what was needed for our goal of 70 dB IM3 at that frequency. Using the data from Fig. 6.14 in Eq. 6.5, with RL D 50 and N D 64, an estimate was made of the IM3 for higher frequencies. This is shown in Fig. 6.12 as the curve labeled “Theory”. As can be seen, for higher frequencies (>400 MHz) a very close match is obtained with the measured data, showing the validity of the theory. The IM3 at lower frequencies is clearly dominated by other effects, most likely a combination of matching errors, IR-drops and transformer-effects. The peaking observed around 400 MHz can be explained by a cancellation effect. The lowfrequency distortion mechanism (mismatch, IR-drops, transformer) cancels with the high-frequency mechanism (finite output impedance).
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS 10G
10
Co
1 / jωCo
8
1M
6
10K
4
100K
1M
10M 100M
1G
10G
Co [fF]
Zo [Ohm]
100M
100
133
2
Frequency [MHz]
Fig. 6.14 Simulated imaginary part of the switching output impedance and the associated output capacitance Co versus frequency
7.3 SFDR Measurements SFDR was measured at 1.6 GS/s and 2.9 GS/s. A spectrum of the output signal measured at 1.6 GS/s and producing an output tone of 125 MHz is shown in Fig. 6.15. Many of those measurements were performed and Fig. 6.16 shows the results. It shows a 70 dB SFDR bandwidth of 225 MHz and a 60 dB SFDR bandwidth of 550 MHz. The SFDR-results clearly show a lower bandwidth than the IM3 results. This is to be expected and can be explained as follows. In the first place, IM3 measurements only look at close-in third-order components, while SFDR measurements look at all the tones. Secondly, and more importantly, all measurements have been performed through a transformer (see Figs. 6.2 and 6.8), which has a bandwidth of about 300 MHz. This means that if the signal frequency is higher it gets attenuated. However, if spurious tones are generated and folded back to lower frequencies (below the transformer bandwidth), they do not get attenuated. This mechanism degrades the measured SFDR performance results significantly. The same mechanism has no effect on IM3 measurements, since the signal tones and the close-in tones are approximately at the same frequency and get the same attenuation.
7.4 Comparison with Literature Table 6.1 shows a comparison with published data [4–7]. Although all designs are driving a 50 load, the available current varies significantly, from 15 [7] to 50 mA (this work). This results in equally significantly different signal swings.
134
K. Bult et al.
Fig. 6.15 SFDR measurement producing a tone at 125-MHz while sampling at 1.6 G-S/s
90 [6] @ 0.4 GS / s
80 SFDR [dB]
[5] @ 1.4 GS / s
70
[4] @ 1.0 GS / s
This work @1.6 GS / s
60 [7] @0.5 GS / s
50
This work @ 2.9 GS / s
200
400 Frequency [MHz]
600
800
Fig. 6.16 Measured SFDR versus signal-frequency. Note the differences in output swing and sampling-frequency
6 A 12b 2.9 GS/s DAC with IM3 < 60 dBc Beyond 1 GHz in 65 nm CMOS
135
Table 6.1 Comparison with published data Reference
Tech [nm]
Fclk [GHz]
Iload [mA]
Swing [Vppd ]
Power [mW]
NPE [%]
This work [4] [5] [6] [7]
65 350 180 250 180
2.9 1.0 1.4 0.4 0.5
50 16 30 20 15
2.5 0.8 1.5 1.0 0.75
188 110