Progress in Colloid and Polymer Science · Volume 131 · 2006
Progress in Colloid and Polymer Science Recently Published and Forthcoming Volumes
Characterization of Polymer Surfaces and Thin Films Volume Editors: Grundke, K., Stamm, M., Adler, H.-J. Vol. 132, 2006
Trends in Colloid and Interface Science XVII Volume Editors: Cabuil, V., Levitz, P., Treiner, C. Vol. 126, 2004
Analytical Ultracentrifugation VIII Volume Editors: Wandrey, C., Cölfen, H. Vol. 131, 2006
From Colloids to Nanotechnology Volume Editors: Zrinyi, M., Hórvölgyi, Z. D. Vol. 125, 2004
Scattering Methods and the Properties of Polymer Materials Volume Editors: Stribeck, N., Smarsly, B. Vol. 130, 2005
Aqueous Polymer Dispersions Volume Editor: Tauer, K. Vol. 124, 2004
Mesophases, Polymers, and Particles Volume Editors: Lagaly, G., Richtering, W. Vol. 129, 2004 Surface and Colloid Science Volume Editor: Galembeck, F. Vol. 128, 2004 Analytical Ultracentrifugation VII Volume Editors: Lechner, M. D., Börger, L. Vol. 127, 2004
Trends in Colloid and Interface Science XVI Volume Editors: Miguel, M., Burrows, H. D. Vol. 123, 2004 Aqueous Polymer – Cosolute Systems Volume Editor: Anghel, D. F. Vol. 122, 2002 Molecular Organisation on Interfaces Volume Editor: Lagaly, G. Vol. 121, 2002 Lipid and Polymer-Lipid Systems Volume Editor: Nylander, T. Vol. 120, 2002
Progress in Colloid and Polymer Science Editors: F. Kremer, Leipzig and W. Richtering, Aachen
Volume 131 · 2006
Analytical Ultracentrifugation VIII Volume Editors: Christine Wandrey Helmut Cölfen
123
IV
The series Progress in Colloid and Polymer Science is also available electronically (ISSN 1437-8027) – Access to tables of contents and abstracts is free for everybody. – Scientists affiliated with departments/institutes subscribing to Progress in Colloid and Polymer Science as a whole also have full access to all papers in PDF form. Point your librarian to the Springerlink access registration form at http://www.springerlink.com
ISSN 0340-255X ISBN-10 3-540-29615-8 ISBN-13 978-3-540-29615-7 DOI 10.1007/b96539 Springer Berlin, Heidelberg, New York
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law.
Springer is a part of Springer Science + Business Media
The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
Typesetting and production: LE-TEX Jelonek, Schmidt & Vöckler GbR, Leipzig
http://www.springer.com © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Printed in Germany Cover design: eStudio Calamar S. L., F. Steinen-Broo, Pau/Girona, Spain
Printed on acid-free paper
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: V © Springer-Verlag 2006
PREFACE
The Symposia on Analytical Ultracentrifugation have had the tradition to take place biannually at universities or other institutions in Germany. This tradition was, for the first time, interrupted organizing the 14th International Symposium on Analytical Ultracentrifugation on March 1–2, 2005, at the École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne in Switzerland under the auspice of the Faculté des Sciences de Base and the Institut des Sciences et Ingénierie Chimiques. On the other hand, this development characterizes the continuous extension of the symposium, which was initiated in 1978 as a national event in Germany, then increasingly opened for international participation, and now even placed in a neighboring country. The internationality is reflected by about 65 participants from leading groups in 10 countries, the majority of them coming traditionally from Germany, UK, and USA but also, for the first time, from China. Furthermore, collaborators of international companies such as Roche, Serono, BASF, and Bayer attended the symposium. The major goal of the symposium was to continue promoting the best use of analytical ultracentrifugation by establishing and renewing fruitful exchange of ideas and contacts between biologists, chemists, physicists, not yet experienced users and professional developers of the technique, young and senior scientists from academia and industry. A two days workshop with 35 participants preceded the symposium. 27 lectures were presented and discussed by globally leading scientists but also by junior staff, which is expected to ensure the future of analytical ultracentrifugation. Posters completed the presentations. The program of the symposium was organized in seven sessions revealing the wide potential of this fascinating and powerful technique such as • Instrumentation • Data analysis and modeling • Biological systems • Particles, colloids, synthetic macromolecules, interacting systems and included comparison with results obtained from other methods. 21 contributions were selected for publication in this special volume of Progress in Colloid and Polymer Science covering all topics of the symposium with the hope to provide a helpful collection of recent developments but also to show the still extendable potential of the technique. The EPFL, the Kontaktgruppe für Forschungsfragen (Novartis, Serono, Syngenta, Roche), the Swiss National Science Foundation, Beckman Coulter International, the Polymer Group of Switzerland, H.G. Müller-Bayer Industry Service, BASF AG, and the Canton de Vaud, Suisse, generously sponsored the 14th International Symposium on Analytical Ultracentrifugation. Thanks go to all the unnamed reviewers of the contributions, to Cristina Spillmann, Laurent Bourdillon, and Ronald Zbinden but, particularly, to Ingrid Margot for her assistance preparing the symposium and this volume. November 2005,
Christine Wandrey (EPFL, Switzerland) Helmut Cölfen (MPI-KGF, Germany)
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: VI–VII © Springer-Verlag 2006
CONTENTS
Instrumentation
Laue TM, Austin JB, Rau DA:
A Light Intensity Measurement System for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
Bhattacharyya SK, Maciejewska P, Börger L, Stadler M, Gülsün AM, Cicek HB, Cölfen H:
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
9
Lavrenko VP, Lavrenko PN:
Automatic Analysis of Lebedev Interference Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23
Data Analysis and Modeling
Behlke J, Ristau O:
A New Possibility to Recognize the Concentration Dependence of Sedimentation Coefficients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
29
Genetic Algorithm Optimization for Obtaining Accurate Molecular Weight Distributions from Sedimentation Velocity Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
32
Zipper P, Durchschlag H, Krebs A:
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin. . . . . . . . . .
40
Durchschlag H, Zipper P, Krebs A:
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
54
Brookes E, Demeler B:
Biological Systems
Salvay AG, Ebel C:
Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Detergent in Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73
Chebotareva NA, Meremyanin AV, Makeeva VF, Kurganov BI:
Self-Association of Phosphorylase Kinase under Molecular Crowding Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
82
Mutowo P, Scott DJ:
Oligomerisation of TBP1 from Haloferax volcanii . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
92
Clay O, Carels N, Douady CJ, Bernardi G:
Density Gradient Ultracentrifugation and Whole Genome Sequences: Fine-tuning the Correspondence . . . . . . . . . .
96
Stouffer AL, DeGrado WF, Lear JD:
Analytical Ultracentrifugation Studies of the Influenza M2 Homotetramerization Equilibrium in Detergent Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
107
Khan A, Hughes RK, Belfield EJ, Casey R, Rowe AJ, Harding SE:
Oligomerization of Hydroperoxide Lyase, a Novel P450 Enzyme in Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115 Particles, Colloids, Synthetic Macromolecules and Interacting Systems
Müller HG:
Determination of Particle Size Distributions of Swollen (Hydrated) Particles by Analytical Ultracentrifugation . . . . . . . . . . 120
VII
Cölfen H, Völkel A:
Application of the Density Variation Method on Calciumcarbonate Nanoparticles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
125
Cölfen H, Lucas G:
Particle Sedimentation in pH-Gradients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 128
Pavlov GM, Panarin EF, Korneeva EV, Gavrilova II, Tarasova NN:
Molecular Properties and Electrostatic Interactions of Linear Poly(allylamine hydrochloride) Chains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 133
Bourdillon L, Hunkeler D, Wandrey C:
The Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Polydisperse Polyelectrolytes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 140
Bourdillon L, Freitag R, Wandrey C:
Association and Temperature-induced Phase Transition Studied by Analytical Ultracentrifugation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 149
Lavrenko PN, Belyaeva EV, Volokhova DM, Okatova OV:
Aggregation of Dibutyl Phthalate Molecules in Decalin Solutions Evidenced by Hydrodynamic and Optical Measurements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157
Ras¸a M, Tziatzios C, Lohmeijer BGG:
Analytical Ultracentrifugation Studies on Terpyridine-end-functionalized Poly(ethylene oxide) and Polystyrene Systems Complexed via Ru(II) ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
164
Author/Title Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172
Keyword Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 173
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 1–8 DOI 10.1007/2882_001 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 4 February 2006
INSTRUMENTATION
Thomas M. Laue Joseph B. Austin David A. Rau
A Light Intensity Measurement System for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge
Thomas M. Laue (u) · Joseph B. Austin · David A. Rau The Center to Advance Molecular Interaction Science, University of New Hampshire, Rudman Hall-379, Durham, New Hampshire 03824-3544, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract Light intensity measurements are required by absorbance, fluorescence, turbidity and low-angle light scattering detectors in order to determine the concentration distributions encountered in analytical ultracentrifugation. By using four fast analog-to-digital converters operating in parallel, a data acquisition system has been developed for the analytical ultracentrifuge that can acquire light intensity readings from three detectors (e.g. photomultipliers, avalanche photodiodes, etc.) simultaneously. For each detector, up to forty thousand intensity readings are acquired during each rotor revolution, for up to ten revolutions. Software synchronizes data acquisition with the
Introduction Measurement of the radial concentration distribution in a sample as a function of time is central to analytical ultracentrifugation. Amongst the optical systems used to measure concentration distributions, absorbance, fluorescence and light scattering detectors require measurements of the light intensity either passing through or emanating from a sample. Data acquisition from the ultracentrifuge poses two particular problems. First, signal acquisition must be synchronized with the spinning rotor and, second, some means must be provided to isolate the signals from each sample. The standard Beckman Coulter XLI analytical ultracentrifuge solves the first problem by using a pair of small magnets on the rotor and a Hall effect sensor mounted on the chamber bottom to produce two closely
spinning rotor. The use of continuous light sources allows simultaneous acquisition of dozens of intensity readings from all of the samples. Data acquisition is fast, allowing rapid radial scanning of samples. This data acquisition scheme is used in the Aviv Biomedical AU-FDS fluorescence detection retrofit system for the Beckman XLI analytical ultracentrifuge. It also will be used for the updated XLI absorbance system, as well as the next generation of analytical ultracentrifuge. Keywords Absorbance detector · Analytical ultracentrifugation · Detector systems · Fluorescence detector · Instrumentation software
spaced pulses, one positive going and the other negative going (Fig. 1), with each turn of the rotor. A single TTL pulse is generated at the zero-crossing point between the positive and negative Hall effect pulses, and the leading edge of this TTL pulse is used to synchronize the XLI data acquisition systems. The second problem is solved by using a pulsed light source that is triggered when a sample is aligned with the detector. Timing of the trigger signal is accomplished in hardware using counters and a fast clock as described previously [1]. In this scheme, the rotor timing signal must be jitterfree to better than one part in 4000, or else data quality suffers from poor timing of the light pulses [2]. Propagation delays in the electronics that generate the rotor timing pulse, in the clocks that produce the strobe pulse, and in the light sources themselves, require that the synchronizing systems provide rotor speed-dependent timing
2
Fig. 1 Rotor timing pulse. Data are shown as the A/D values (0–4095, corresponding to ±1.0 volts) as a function of the array index (solid line), for a span of ∼ 20◦ of rotation. The dotted line shows the AverageSignal (∼ 2047), with two steps above the AverageSignal. The first, wider step shows the value of the PulseDiscriminator (= AverageSignal + 200). For clarity, this step covers the range of data between the positive and negative peaks in the rotor timing signal. The second, higher step shows the value used for the PeakDiscriminator (= AverageSignal + 300). The spike in the data shows the position calculated for the midpoint between the two peaks. Data were simulated for a signal to noise ratio of 40 dB
adjustments [1, 2]. Additional complications arise from the frequency dependence of the signals and propagation delays, for which the synchronizing system must compensate [1]. Given this complexity, the hardware based strobe light system of the XLI is remarkably reliable. Despite its reliability, the current system limits the XLI absorbance data acquisition systems to one light pulse per rotor revolution. Furthermore, the maximum repetition rate for the XLI’s high intensity Xenon light source is 100 Hz, so that 10 ms must elapse between light bursts. At rotor speeds above 6000 rpm, the 10 ms hiatus limits the rate at which data may be acquired, and at 60 000 rpm the light is pulsed only once for every 10 rotor revolutions. While similar lamps are available with slightly higher repetition rates (300 Hz), it is not feasible to construct lamps of this intensity that will operate at suitably higher repetition rates (> 1000 Hz). Even if such lamps were available, data acquisition is slowed by the fact that only one sample is illuminated per light pulse. If the XLI’s absorbance system is being operated in the usual doublebeam mode, then a second light pulse is required to illuminate the reference channel. At 60 000 rpm, a minimum of 20 rotor revolutions is required to gather the data for one absorbance reading for each sample. If the user chooses to average multiple intensity readings in order to improve data precision, the time required per reading increases proportionally.
T.M. Laue et al.
As currently configured, the XLI performs a complete radial scan of one sample before resetting and starting to scan a second sample. At a radial spacing of 50 microns, and using one sample and one reference intensity per radial position, a radial scan of 1.3 cm length may be completed in 20–25 seconds, with the interval between scans being about 30 seconds when the time needed to reset between scans is included. For an experiment with seven samples, each sample will be scanned approximately every 3 1/2 to 4 minutes. This is a minimum time interval per scan. If the user chooses to acquire data at multiple wavelengths, or increases the number of intensity readings by either decreasing the radial spacing or increasing the number of intensity readings per radial position, the time interval between scans of a sample increases. The compromise between data quantity and data quality fundamentally limits the usefulness of the absorbance system for sedimentation velocity analysis. One means to speed up data acquisition is to use a continuous light source, and to separate the signals from the different samples by synchronizing the detector with the spinning rotor. In this sort of scheme, those portions of the detector signal corresponding to the moments when a particular sample is in the light beam are separated, e.g. by a de-multiplexing circuit. The analog absorbance system of the Beckman Model E used this scheme to acquire data from one sample at a time. More recently, the turbidity and schlieren systems have used an analogous scheme to acquire intensity data from all of the samples with each rotor revolution [3, 4]. The system presented here uses four parallel highspeed analog-to-digital (A/D) converters to acquire data simultaneously from four separate detectors. The signal from the XLI Hall effect detector is one of the signals, and light intensity data from the absorbance, fluorescence or turbidity optical systems are the other signals that may be digitized. The software both synchronizes data acquisition with the spinning rotor and isolates the signals from each sample. With this system, it is possible to average the data for all of the detectors over several rotor revolutions for each of the samples simultaneously. Furthermore, the software can be configured to acquire data from new rotor and cell designs easily.
Description Signals: There are four signal sources that require highspeed data acquisition: the rotor timing pulse and three light intensity detector voltages. A less expensive interface handles the lower speed analog and digital signals used to monitor device status (e.g. the presence of various optical systems, the fluorescence laser power and temperature, etc.) or control devices (e.g. fluorescence laser on/off, PMT voltages). In addition to the two interface cards, two RS-232 serial I/O ports are required. The first serial port
A Light Intensity Measurement System for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge
provides communication with the XLI and is used both to control its operation and to monitor its status. The second serial port controls the stepping motors used in the optical systems. Up to six stepping motors may be present: two for the fluorescence hardware (radial position and objective lens focus), two for the absorbance system (radial position and wavelength selector) and two for the refractive detectors (camera position and schlieren bar angle). Hardware and software are included to determine which optical systems are present so that the stepping motor functions are configured properly. The software controlling the instrument uses a low level hardware abstraction layer. That is, the software is written so that function calls from common programming languages (e.g. C++, Visual Basic) remain unchanged even if the underlying hardware changes. Hardware: Voltages from the four high speed sources are digitized using four 12-bit, 20 MHz A/D converters (PCI-DAS4020/12, Measurement Computing, Inc., Middleboro, MA, USA). This device also provides two 12-bit digital-to-analog (D/A) outputs and 24 digital inputoutput (DIO) lines. An internal first-in-first-out buffer memory accommodates computer latencies (e.g. hardware memory refresh, software interrupt handling) thus allowing sustained data acquisition at the full data rate. The ±1 volt input range was used for all four A/D channels. The digitized data streams are stored as interleaved values in the computer memory as: I1,1 , I2,1 , I3,1 , I4,1 , I1,2 , I2,2 . . . I1,n , I2,n , I3,n , I4,n , where the first index refers to which A/D produced the signal and the second index indicates which reading this is in the sequence. When fresh data are desired, the software triggers data acquisition from all four high-speed A/Ds. Once triggered, a sufficient number of data points (TotalCount) are gathered to cover several turns of the rotor, RevolutionsToAverage. The operating software adjusts the A/D clock frequency (ADClockRate) and acquisition period (TotalPeriod) so that each detector will acquire at least 10 000 values per rotor revolution (CountsPerRevolution). After each data acquisition period, fresh values ADClockRate, TotalPeriod and TotalCount are calculated so that rotor acceleration/deceleration may be accommodated. Following data acquisition, four separate data arrays are created from the interleaved data, one for each A/D channel. A separate device (PCI-DAS6025, Measurement Computing, Inc., Middleborough, MA, USA) is used as the low-speed interface and contains 16 channels of 12-bit A/D input (at 200 KHz), two 12-bit D/A outputs, 8 DIO lines and two 16-bit counters. All signals to and from the computer are connected to a custom-designed “system box” that contains the amplifiers, power supplies, digital signal buffers, a programmable clock and custom analog signal conditioning circuits to accommodate five optical systems (absorbance, fluorescence, turbidity, interference and schlieren). Signal conditioning includes programmable gain amplifiers that provide 1, 2, 4 or 8-fold gain for each of the light detec-
3
tor signals, as well as a precision voltage source used to offset the signals so that zero light intensity corresponds to −1 volt and saturating light corresponds to +1 volt. All of the components in the signal pathways have a frequency response > 30 MHz. A single wiring harness connects the system box to a 100-pin connector on the XLI. A custom-designed “distribution box” within the XLI contains power supplies, the laser controller for the fluorescence optics, circuits to buffer the rotor timing pulse and vacuum signals, circuits to detect which optical systems are present, and connectors to direct the various signals to the different optical subsystems. Throughout, careful circuit layout is needed to minimize stray noise, crosstalk and ground loops. The rotor timing pulse: All data acquisition must be synchronized to an accurate rotor timing pulse. Previous data acquisition systems use the rotor timing pulse to trigger data acquisition hardware, with subsequent transfer of the data to the computer [1–3]. The system described here acquires data asynchronously, with post-acquisition processing used to extract the light intensity signals. One of the four high speed A/Ds monitors the rotor timing signal from the Hall effect sensor (Fig. 1). The signal is amplified to provide ±0.95 volts when a magnet passes over the sensor, and otherwise is nominally 0 volts. One magnet produces a positive going pulse and the other a negative going pulse, with each pulse occupying ∼ 18 degrees of the rotor revolution, and the two pulses being separated by ∼ 20 degrees. Because data acquisition is triggered asynchronously, rotor timing pulses may fall anywhere in the data acquisition time period. Furthermore, until ADClockRate, TotalPeriod and TotalCount are set correctly, an unknown number of rotor timing pulses may be present in the data. Thus, two situations arise: one where these parameters have not yet been determined and, more commonly, one where good estimates of these parameters exist. When the software is first started, the rotor speed is unknown (i.e. the XLI may or may not be operating when the software is started), and default values for ADClockRate, TotalPeriod, TotalCount and RevolutionsToAverage are used. The default values for these parameters are set to acquire 20 000 data points (e.g. TotalCount = 20 000) for a TotalPeriod covering seven rotor revolutions (RevolutionsToAverage +2) at 1000 rpm. These defaults allow the system to detect rotor spinning at low rpm (e.g. during initial rotor acceleration), while still gathering data at sufficient resolution to determine an approximate rotor speed should the rotor already be spinning at 60 000 rpm. Two other default values are set: the number of clock pulses per rotor revolution (CountsPerRevolution, as TotalCount divided by the number of revolutions) and the number of clock pulses (MagnetPulseWidth) corresponding to the width (approximately 18 degrees) of one of the two peaks from the Hall effect sensor.
4
The software uses two values to discriminate a rotor timing pulse from background noise. The first (PulseDiscriminator) is the minimum signal amplitude required to consider the signal at any point (Signal[i]) in the data array to be part of a rotor timing pulse. The second (PeakDiscriminator) is the minimum amplitude of Signal[i] required to consider it the peak value. Comparisons are made as the absolute value of the difference between the Signal[i] and the average signal (AverageSignal, default = 2048, corresponding to 0 volts) calculated for a portion of the data that does not contain a rotor timing pulse (calculated as described below). The default values of PulseDiscriminator and PeakDiscriminator are 200 and 300, respectively. These values are stored in a database and may be changed if necessary. The rotor timing peak finding algorithm begins by determining whether or not there is rotor timing pulse at the start of the Signal array (i.e. data acquisition was triggered when a rotor timing pulse was occurring). Data are tested for Signal[i], for i = 0 to i = twice the MagnetPulseWidth to determine if the magnitude any data point exceeds the AverageSignal. If so, the starting index for peak finding (StartIndex) is set to one-half the CountsPerRevolution to avoid dealing with partial rotor timing pulses. Because StartIndex is guaranteed to be in a region of Signal[i] devoid of a rotor timing pulse, AverageSignal is calculated as the mean value of Signal[i] from i = StartIndex to i = StartIndex plus twice the MagnetPulseWidth. Beginning with StartIndex, Signal[i] is scanned to find the first data point having a magnitude exceeding PulseDiscriminator. At this point, StartIndex is set to i, and the portion of the Signal array from StartIndex to four times the MagnetPulseWidth (EndIndex) is searched to find the indices of the maximum and minimum values. To avoid false maxima or minima due to noise, data generated using the “reverse smoothing” algorithm of Roark [5] are searched. The values of Signal[i] corresponding to the indices for the maximum and minimum are tested to see that they exceed PeakDiscriminator, and the two indices are tested to make sure that they are not equal to either StartIndex or EndIndex (indicating that a partial rotor timing pulse is being tested). If the indices pass this test, then the index corresponding to the midpoint between them (calculated as the rounded integer of the minimum and maximum indices cast to be double precision numbers) is considered to be the position of a rotor timing pulse, and this index is added to an array (RotorPulseIndices). Once a pulse has been found, the StartIndex is set equal to the EndIndex and the peak-finding process is repeated so long as the EndIndex is less than TotalCount. Once the rotor timing pulses have been determined, the CountsPerRevolution is calculated as the rounded integer of the average difference between entries in the RotorPulseIndices array. From CountsPerRevolution, the rotor speed (as rpm) is determined as 60∗ CountsPerRevolution/ ADClockRate. The rotor speed calculated in this man-
T.M. Laue et al.
ner is accurate to better than ±5 rpm, with a precision of ±2 rpm. Synchronizing data acquisition to the spinning rotor: The magnets used to produce the rotor timing signal are incorporated in the “over-speed disk” that is glued to the base of each rotor. The over-speed disk is positioned so that the two magnets are approximately midway between the first and last rotor hole (e.g. between rotor holes 1 and 4 for a 4-hole rotor). The magnet position is not exact, and changes every time the over-speed disc is replaced. Consequently, the rotor timing pulse provides only an approximate position, and separate means must be provided to determine the exact relationship between the rotor timing pulse and a reference position on the rotor as it passes a detector (below). Once this angle, MagnetAngle, is established at a particular rotor speed, all other angles needed to acquire data from a particular channel are fixed. The fixed angles include: the offset angle, called the CellAngle, from the center of the first rotor hole to the center of each of the other rotor holes; the offset angle from the center of a rotor hole to the center of each channel in a centerpiece, called the ChannelAngle; and the angles separating the optical detectors, called the DetectorAngle. Values of the CellAngle are constant for a given rotor type, and are just 360∗CN/CT , where CN is the cell number (starting at zero) and CT is the total number of cell holes. ChannelAngle values are constant for any given type of cell, and the angular positions of the XLI optical tracks, measured clockwise from the fluorescence detector, determine the DetectorAngle values. A database is used to store the ChannelAngle values for each type of cell. Similarly, each type of detector has a DetectorAngle value stored in the database. It is possible to accommodate new cell designs or add new detectors without changing the software by defining and storing these fixed angles. Light intensity data typically are acquired over a small angle (e.g. 0.2 degrees, called the DataOffsetAngle) on either side of the channel center. The starting angle for data acquisition, StartingAngle, is simply the sum all of the fixed angles, plus the MagnetAngle less the DataOffsetAngle. Determining MagnetAngle: In order to produce highquality data, it is essential that the angle over which intensity data is gathered is held constant to within a few thousandths of a degree. Because of propagation delays in the electronics, signals arrive at the computer some time after they are produced. During the delay, the rotor continues to turn, so that the fixed geometric angles described above appear to vary with rotor speed [2]. The variation in angle is complex, particularly at rotor speeds <∼ 6000 rpm, due to the frequency dependence of the components in the various signal processing circuits. Accordingly, the MagnetAngle is determined empirically. Experience suggests that the MagnetAngle should be checked whenever the ro-
A Light Intensity Measurement System for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge
tor speed changes by 5000 rpm. The operating software monitors the rotor speed and, once the rotor speed is stable, determines the magnet angle for each optical system. For the fluorescence system [6, and in preparation], a special calibration cell has been developed (www.camis. unh.edu) that incorporates a two-degree long by 1 mm high by 1 mm deep groove. The groove is centered at a radial position of 5.85 cm with a ChannelOffset of zero degrees. This groove is filled with a dye so that a bright fluorescent signal is produced whenever the sample is in the excitation beam. The MagnetAngle is determined as the apparent angle needed to move the “image” of the groove so that it coincides exactly with the angle predicted from the fixed angles (above). A similar scheme is used for the absorbance system, except that the image used is that of the pair of intensity pulses that occur whenever the inner calibration holes (at 5.75 cm) of the counterweight pass over the absorbance detector. Intensity measurements: Intensity data are acquired for each channel starting from its StartingAngle and covering an angle equal to twice the DataOffsetAngle. To accomplish this, the StartingAngle and DataOffsetAngle must be converted to the corresponding number of A/D clock pulses (i.e. range of indices in the data arrays). The StartingAngle is converted to an index offset, Offset, which corresponds to the fraction of counts in one revolution: Offset = CountsPerRevolution∗ (StartingAngle/360). The starting indices for the data arrays are simply the value of Offset added to each of the values saved in the RotorPulseIndices array. Similarly, the range of indices, IndexRange, over which intensity data will be gathered is: IndexRange = CountsPerRevolution∗ (2∗DataOffsetAngle /360). Typically, the IndexRange is between 10 and 100, meaning that that many intensity readings will be obtained for each A/D channel for each rotor revolution. The software is configured to acquire data from three to ten (default five) rotor revolutions. Thus, each average intensity reading comprises 30 to 1000 individual intensity readings. The upper limit of averaging over ten rotor revolutions maintains relatively rapid radial scanning while providing good reduction of the stochastic noise. There is no reason, however, that the upper limit could not be set much higher (the software limit is 180 scans, and it could be set higher). Our experience is that only a small reduction in stochastic noise can be expected with increased averaging. However, future versions of the software will allow for more averaging. From the moment the A/Ds complete their data acquisition until the average intensities are stored for all of the samples requires < 20 milliseconds on a 1 GHz computer. The computations are done while the radial positions of the optical systems are changed, which requires 50 milliseconds or more, depending upon the distance moved. Thus, the calculations are not the rate limiting step in data acquisition.
5
Intensity scans: For mechanical reasons, both the fluorescence and absorbance data acquisition systems scan from the bottom to the top of the cell. The radial increment for the scans is adjustable from 2–50 microns (default = 20 microns). After each step, the fast A/Ds are triggered and intensity data are acquired for the period determined by the RevolutionsToAverage. Using the scheme described above, raw intensity data are available for all of the detectors and all of the cells. However, not all of the data are useful, and some tests must be applied to determine which data to include in the output file for a sample. The operating software uses five layers of logic to determine whether to include the intensity data from an optical system in the output file for a particular sample. These logic layers may be posed as questions: 1) is the optical system in use, 2) are data being acquired for this sample using the particular optical system, 3) is the radial position in the correct range (e.g. for multi-channel equilibrium cells) for the sample, 4) is the wavelength setting one that is being used for the sample, and 5) are the gain settings for the detector the correct ones for this wavelength? If all of these conditions are true, then the average intensity, along with the standard deviation, is determined and saved in a temporary array. When the scan is completed, the data files are written to disc, and the data displayed in the chart for that sample. All disc and charting operations are done during the period required to reset the detector positions to their starting positions (∼ 5 seconds).
Methods Data simulation: The operating software for the data acquisition system includes a signal simulator which allows the gains, voltage offsets, amplifier slew rates and noise level to be set for each A/D channel. The rotor timing pulse signal is simulated as a single sine wave whose angular extent and amplitude may be set. If the detector is situated at a radial position that is between the top and bottom of a channel, intensity data are simulated initially as a square wave pulse centered at the ChannelAngle for that channel. The amplitude of the pulse is adjusted according to the optical properties (scattering factor, extinction coefficient or quantum yield) and concentration of the solution components in the channel, as well as the gain setting for the A/D channel. For the A/D channels, gain settings are ∗ simulated as: PGA · e((10 V/4095)−10) , where PGA is the gain setting of the programmable gain amplifier (1, 2, 4 or 8) for the A/D channel, V is the D/A setting (0–4095) corresponding to the PMT high-voltage setting. The rise and fall times of the square pulse are adjusted for the slew rate for the A/D channel, and white-noise with user-adjustable amplitude (in bits) is added to the signal. In simulation mode, then, the signal to noise ratio may be controlled by the user.
6
T.M. Laue et al.
Jitter determination: The effect of noise on synchronizing data acquisition was assessed using the root-meansquare (rms) variation in the difference between the indices determined for each rotor timing pulse (Fig. 1). Any variation in these positions from the correct value directly affects the portion of the signals used to acquire intensity data. Rotor timing pulses were simulated with a fixed noise level, and the average distance (in number of data points) calculated between rotor timing pulses for ten rotor pulses. The jitter was calculated as the variance (in number of data points) for a set of ten average distances, and is reported as parts per thousand of the ratio of the variance to the average distance.
Results and Discussion Synchronizing data acquisition: Figure 1 shows the signal for a single rotor timing pulse, along with the discriminator values and the array index determined to be the “rotor timing pulse.” The index for all of the intensity data during the rotor revolution will be an integer offset from this index. The number of indices, Ni, between this rotor timing pulse, Rtp[i], and the next pulse, Rtp[i+1] corresponds to one turn of the rotor (i.e. Ni = Rtp[i+1] − Rtp[i]). Hence, the angular position to the center of any sample (ChannelAngle) may be converted to an index, ChannelIndex, as: ChannelIndex = Rtp[i] + Ni∗ ChannelAngle/360 .
Fig. 2 Simulated raw intensity data acquired from ten revolutions of the rotor. Data were superimposed using the conversion from intensity array index to angle, as described in the text. For data shown here, the rotor timing signal had a signal to noise ratio of 40 dB, and the intensity data shown here have ±40 bits of noise. The dashed vertical line shows the angle calculated to be the center of the cell. The solid vertical line shows the angle calculated to be the center of the sample channel, and the two dotted vertical lines enclose the range of angles that will be used to calculate the average intensity
It was found that double precision math, followed by rounding to the nearest integer, was required to minimize jitter. Likewise, any index i between Rtp[i] and Rtp[i + 1], may be converted to an angle using: Angle = i − Rtp[i]/CountsPerRevolution · 360. Intensity data acquired over ten revolutions of the rotor, then superimposed by converting their indices to angles, are shown in Fig. 2. The variation in the position of the signal pulses is a consequence of the rotor timing signal having a signal to noise ratio of 40 dB. At 40 dB, the uncertainty in the rotor timing pulse position is 0.1 part per thousand (Fig. 3), corresponding to an angular uncertainty of ±37 millidegrees. Radial scans: Because data may be acquired for all samples simultaneously at each radial position, significantly more data may be acquired for each sample over the course of an experiment. The time required to acquire a complete scan of the samples depends on several factors: the number of revolutions over which data are to be averaged, the rotor speed, the time needed to move the optics to the next radial position, the number of radial data positions sampled, and the time needed to reset the radial scan mechanism to the starting position. At rotor speeds above 40 000 rpm, the system requires approximately 60 seconds to acquire data at 600 radial positions (e.g. at 20 micron intervals over a 1.2 cm radial distance),
Fig. 3 Jitter as function of the signal to noise ratio of the rotor timing pulse. The jitter is presented in parts per thousand, determined as the root mean square variation in the number of data points between rotor timing pulses (Fig. 1) divided by the average number of data points between rotor timing pulses. Previous work [1] determined that a jitter less than 0.25 parts per thousand provides sufficient precision to acquire data. For the present system, jitter is acceptable so long as the signal to noise ratio is greater than 20 dB
A Light Intensity Measurement System for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge
averaging the intensities from 5 rotor revolutions at each radial position (resulting in 50 or so intensity readings per sample), then resetting the optical position to start the next scan. Using the current XLA absorbance system, approximately 720 seconds is required to gather data from three samples at the same radial spacing and averaging 5 flashes of the lamp (i.e. resulting in 5 intensities per sample). Thus, the new system provides significant speed and signal processing advantages over the current XLA absorbance optics. The shorter scan times and the use of a continuous light source in the new data acquisition system results in significantly improved data acquisition from samples containing rapidly sedimenting material. If samples provide dramatically different signals (e.g. there is > 100-fold concentration difference in fluorescent dye), it will be necessary to use different gain settings in order to optimize the signal to noise. Due to the time needed for the photomultiplier tube to settle down after changing its gain, it is not practical to change the gain at each radial position. Consequently, a separate scan must be acquired for each gain setting needed. This means that the time interval between scans of any given sample will in-
7
crease in direct proportion to the number of gain settings used in a protocol. Fluorescence intensity scans of green fluorescent protein are shown in Fig. 4a. The total signal from this sample is about 300 (on a scale from 0 to 4095) and the rms noise is about 5, yielding a signal to noise of 35 dB. For comparison, this is approximately the same signal to noise ratio that would be obtained for absorbance data with an optical density of 0.5 ± 0.01. The apparent molecular weight distribution for this sample is presented in Fig. 4b. The peak at a molecular weight of 29 570 (using an assumed partial specific volume of 0.73 ml/g) is in reasonable agreement with the protein’s sequence molecular weight of 30 800.
Conclusion The light intensity data acquisition system described here offers four advantages over current methods: 1) greater signal averaging, thus reducing stochastic noise; 2) intensity data may be acquired from all samples simultaneously,
Fig. 4 Fluorescence intensity data from a sedimentation velocity (50 000 rpm, 20.0 ◦ C) experiment. The sample is 40 nM green fluorescent protein (M = 30 800) in 100 mM KCl, 20 mM Tris, pH 7.5. a Scans were acquired at approximately 50 second intervals, with scans taken ∼ 30 minutes apart shown in this panel. For each scan, intensity data were acquired at 20 micron radial intervals over the range from 5.9–7.3 cm. At each radial position, data from 5 rotations were acquired, yielding 264 individual intensity readings for each sample. The average and standard deviation of these readings is saved in the output file and presented here. All data were acquired using 73% of the maximum photomultiplier tube voltage and an 8× gain setting for the programmable gain amplifier. The photomultiplier tube gain is highly nonlinear, so that a 90% voltage setting is about 2 orders of magnitude more sensitive than the 73% setting. Hence, these data were acquired at a moderate, not high, gain setting. b Molecular weight distribution calculated by Sedfit [7] for the data in panel A. The peak in the distribution falls within 4% of sequence molecular weight
8
T.M. Laue et al.
increasing the number of scans that may be acquired per experiment; 3) intensity data may be acquired from multiple detectors (e.g. fluorescence and absorbance) simultaneously, thus increasing the amount of information that may be obtained from a sample; and 4) where data are to be acquired (e.g. over which radii and at what angles) may be defined by the user, thus making it possible to use new centerpieces and rotors without changing the data acquisition software. This system is available commercially in the Aviv Biomedical AU-FDS (Lakeview, NJ) fluorescence detector retrofit for the XLI analytical ultracentrifuge. It will be used for the upcoming rapid-scan absorbance system
XLI retrofit, and it is anticipated that it will be used on the next generation of analytical ultracentrifuge. The full characterization of the AU-FDS optical system (e.g. sensitivity, radial resolution, scan times, etc.) will be presented in a separate publication. Acknowledgement The authors wish to thank the following individuals for their patient help and encouragement in making this system a reality: Rachel Kroe, Jack Correia, Edward Eisenstein, Jeff Hansen, Bo Demeler, Jack Aviv and Ash Tripathy. This research was supported in part by NIH grant R01GM6283601, NSF grant DBI-9876582, the Biomolecular Interactions Technology Center, the Center to Advance Molecular Interaction Technology and the Aviv Family Foundation.
References 1. Laue TM, Yphantis DA, Rhodes DG (1984) Anal Biochem 143:103–112 2. Laue TM, Domanik DM, Yphantis DA (1983) Anal Biochem 131:220–231
3. Scholtan W, Lange H (1972) Polymere 250:782–796 4. Mächtle W (1999) Biophys J 76:1080–1091 5. Roark DE (2004) Biophys Chem 2004 108:121–126
6. MacGregor IK, Anderson AL, Laue TM (2004) Biophys Chem 108:165–185 7. Dam J, Schuck P (2004) Methods Enzymol 384:185–212
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 9–22 DOI 10.1007/2882_002 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 10 February 2006
Saroj Kumar Bhattacharyya Patrycja Maciejewska Lars Börger Manfred Stadler Akif Mehmet Gülsün Hasan Basri Cicek Helmut Cölfen
Saroj Kumar Bhattacharyya · Patrycja Maciejewska · Helmut Cölfen (u) Department of Colloid Chemistry, MPI Research Campus Golm, Max Planck Institute of Colloids and Interfaces, Am Mühlenberg 2, 14424 Potsdam, Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Lars Börger · Manfred Stadler Polymer Research Laboratory, BASF AG, G201, 67056 Ludwigshafen, Germany Akif Mehmet Gülsün · Hasan Basri Cicek Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Bilkent University, 06800 Bilkent Ankara, Turkey
INSTRUMENTATION
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
Abstract The advantages of simultaneously detecting multiple wavelengths in ultracentrifugation experiments are obvious, especially for interacting systems. In addition, the detection of the wavelength dependence of turbidity opens up the possibility to obtain independent information on the particle size in addition to the usual sedimentation coefficient distribution for colloidal systems. We therefore made an effort to develop a fast UV/Vis detector, which is able to simultaneously detect the range from 200–800 nm. This is possible by the use of a modern CCD chip based generation of UV-Vis spectrometers, which translates the dispersed white light onto a CCD chip, where each pixel corresponds to a particular wavelength. In addition to the simultaneous detection of a large number of wavelengths in the range 200–800 nm, also with non integer values, these spectrometers are very fast. Current typical spectrum scan times with the necessary scan quality in the ultracentrifuge are in the range of 100 ms but this time can be significantly shortened down to 3 ms for higher light intensities and even down to 10 µs for a new generation of CCD chip based spectrometers. The introduction of a fiber based UV-Vis optics into a preparative XL-80K ultracentrifuge with the associated hardware developments
will be described as a first generation prototype. In this study, we use a wavelength dependent optical lens system instead of the necessary but more complex wavelength independent mirror optical system for a first check on possibilities and limitations of the optical system. First examples for biopolymers and latexes will be presented and compared to those obtained in the commercial XL-A ultracentrifuge. Already the fast detection enables completely new possibilities like the determination of a particle size distribution in a few minutes. Multiwavelength detection at constant position in dependence of time will be demonstrated, which is an important mode for the use of speed profiles for very polydisperse samples. Also, the use of radial multiwavelength scans will be demonstrated producing a three dimensional data space for monitoring the sedimentation via radial scans with multiwavelength detection. However, despite the advantages, the current problems with the detector will also be discussed including the main problem that much intensity is lost in the important UV range as a result of fiber coupling and bending. Keywords Analytical Ultracentrifugation · CCD based UV-Vis Spectrometer · Detector Development · Fiber Optics
10
Introduction The development of optical detection systems for ultracentrifuges is as old as Analytical Ultracentrifugation itself and dates back to the development of Analytical Ultracentrifugation [1]. The classical detection systems are UVVis absorption optics, Rayleigh Interference optics and Schlieren optics as discussed in detail in the classical book of Lloyd [2]. Furthermore, fluorescence optics was developed for the platform of the Beckman Model E [3] and more recently for the platform of the Beckman XL-I ultracentrifuge [4, 5]. In addition, turbidity optics was developed for the characterization of particle size distributions of colloidal particles [6–9]. Despite some progress on the detector or illumination part of the optical systems concerning the transformation of photographic detection to CCD chip detection for Schlieren and Interference optics or the use of laser light sources [10–18] (for further references see also the references for multiplexer systems) and photomultiplier detection for the UV-Vis [19] and fluorescence optics [3, 4], the classical optical systems remained essentially unchanged for decades. Exceptions are the Flossdorf optics [20], which significantly increased the detected intensity for UV-Vis optical systems and the ultrasensitive Schlieren optics [21]. However, the demands of Analytical Ultracentrifugation have greatly improved with the advent of cheap and powerful computer resources. The most obvious change is the speed of data acquisition and the amount of experimental data becoming available from computer based detectors, which has found its commercial expression in the launch of the Beckman XL-I ultracentrifuge in the 90s of last century [19]. This has in turn catalyzed many methodic advances, which enable analyses with an accuracy not being even imaginable a decade ago [22–26]. However, it must clearly be stated that the development on the data evaluation side is by magnitudes more significant than the hardware development – especially that of optical detection systems for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge (AUC). This is understandable as hardware development is by factors slower than software development due to the delivery and workshop manufacturing waiting times. Nevertheless, there is an urgent need for improved multi detector development for the AUC [27], not only concerning detection speed but also detection capabilities. Examples for the benefit of multi detector use are manifold. They include determination of extinction coefficients [28], even in complicated mixtures [29] but also the possibility of global analysis by evaluation of multiple experiments [30–32] as well as increased experimental information from a single experiment with multiple species and different chromophores by multiwavelength analysis. The detection of multiple wavelengths from UV-Vis absorption optics proved especially useful for the analysis of biopolymers from sedimentation equilibrium [33] or sedimentation velocity [34], although in the
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
reported cases, the analysis was restricted to the three possible scanning wavelengths of the XL-I AUC under addition of information from the interference optical system. Thus, the potential benefit of multiwavelength analyses of hundreds of wavelengths is obvious not only for interaction analyses of complicated interacting polymer mixtures but also for colloidal systems as the wavelength dependence of the turbidity of colloidal samples contains information about their particle size according to the MIE scattering theory [35–38]. With the advent of global analysis approaches involving AUC data, multiwavelength analysis will become an especially important technique for all light absorbing samples of colloidal or polymeric nature. Parallel to the above developments in AUC methodology, there was also a significant development in the UVVis spectrometer technology. Modern UV-Vis spectrometers can use simple CCD line arrays for the simultaneous detection of a large number of wavelengths, which is essentially only limited by the CCD array pixel number as well as the quality of the applied diffraction grating for the dispersion of the incoming white light. These spectrometers do not only allow for the simultaneous detection of the entire UV-Vis wavelength range, but are furthermore very fast and cheap. Commonly available spectrometers like the USB2000 by Ocean Optics allow for scanning times of down to 3 ms for an entire UV-Vis spectrum [39]. More recent instruments like the Ocean Optics HR4000 [40] or the series of CCD and ICCD based spectrometers available from LOT-Oriel [41] are magnitudes faster and can scan UV-Vis spectra as fast as 10 µs. The cooled spectrometers give a quite broad linear dynamic range with the advantage of working with low dark current due to cooling [41]. However, although these fast and powerful UV-Vis detectors are available, they were not yet applied as detectors for AUC’s. One of the reasons is that these detectors are based on fiber optics and also operate with incoming white light. White light with wavelength dependent refractive indices makes the precise use of a refractive optics impossible – at least in the UV range, where the conventional achromat lenses cannot be applied or vice versa in the visible range if an expensive UV achromat lens system is applied. This is only one obstacle, with no parallel in previous AUC optics, which always operates with monochromatic light – or in case of the XL-A AUC with a torroidally curved diffraction grating producing monochromatic light. This means that in AUC history, the challenge of a multiwavelength optics has not been undertaken despite the potential benefits. This was the starting point for the cooperation between the Max-Planck Institute of Colloids and Interfaces and the polymer physics department of BASF R&D. This study presents the first results from this cooperation aiming to improve the AUC capabilities by the development of new detection systems. We have on purpose started with the use of conventional wavelength dependent refractive index based lens optics as:
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
1. Ocean Optics as spectrometer supplier also offers optimized lens systems. They are available as plug & play components for a fiber based optical system so that potentially, a fiber optical plug and play system could be applied using the commercial spectrometer software as a first data acquisition software. With this system, first experiences can be made for the further detector development. 2. The mirror optics that use small focal length spherical and parabolic mirrors are not standard optical components, and are not yet available for this application. 3. Fiber optics are only very rarely applied in AUC detectors. Therefore, potentials and limitations of this optical transport medium for AUC detectors shall be explored. 4. The detector hardware needs to be developed. A lens based system is relatively compact but also the most distorting optical system for white light. Nevertheless, first developments can be made with this compact setup. The adaptation to the mirror based system can be done on the basis of these experiences if necessary. As a consequence, the present study can only be seen as the first step towards a fast fiber based UV-Vis multiwavelength detector. Here we will only use classical lens optics as a case study well knowing about the problem of chromatic abberation. It is clear that this design cannot be the final prototype but there is already much to be learned not only about the actually detected light intensity but potential problems that may come in way for using other components as fibers or fiber coupled spectrometers. We have therefore also included developments, which are independent of the fiber optical system or multiwavelength detector so that we report about a fiber based high power Xenon lamp as well as on an advanced multiplexer hard/software based on earlier hardware developments [42] currently available as a LABVIEW software. Although just being a snapshot of an ongoing development process, the present study will be able to show the possibilities but also the first limitations of a fast fiber based UV-Vis detector for the AUC.
11
(b) Fibers: 600 µm UV/Vis fibers in four channel vacuum feed through, OZ optics, Canada for illumination optics. 600 µm UV/Vis patchcord from Oceanoptics, Duiven, The Netherlands. (c) Focuser: Receptacle style focuser from OZ optics, Canada with biconvex lens ( f = 15 mm) and SMA 905 connector (d) Linear actuator: Linear actuator model T-LA28-SV (shorter version) with necessary power supply from Zaber, Canada for precise movement of the detector arm. (e) Lenses and Prism: Biconvex lenses f = 20.6 mm for custom built collimation optics and f = 20 mm for collecting transmitted UV/Vis light and a right angled prism from Linos, Göttingen, Germany. (f) Slit: 25 µm slit from slit-lens assembly of commercial Beckman XL-I, Analytical Ultracentrifuge. (g) Light source: Xe-Flash lamp with mirror (model L-4633-01) with the relevant power supply from Hamamatsu Photonics GmbH, Herrsching, Germany. (h) Optical Bench: From Owis GmbH, Göttingen, Germany with possibility for x, y, z adjustment and angular adjustment for coupling the light from the flash lamp to fiber. (i) Optical stage: From OWIS GmbH, Staufen, Germany with possibility to fine-adjust in x and y direction for the precise adjustment of the detection optics part of the detector arm. (j) Electrical feedthrough: 18 pin electrical feedthrough for electrical connection of the linear actuator from Lemo Electronic GmbH, Munich, Germany. Samples for measurement: The proteins were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich, Germany, the latexes were prepared in house. For data generation with the designed detector the following samples were used: (1) BSA (∼ 1.0 g/L) in 0.1 MNaCl, pH = 7.5. (2) Cytochrome C (∼ 1.0 g/L) in 20 mM MOPS pH 7.2 containing 2 microM K3 Fe(CN)6 and 5 mg/mL dodecyl maltoside. (3) Polystyrene Latex with different particle sizes (150 nm, 190 nm, 240 nm, 430 nm, 450 nm & 660 nm) were mixed and prepared by dilution with water so that satisfactory intensity of the UV/Vis transmitted light can be detected. (4) For the experiment corresponding to Fig. 12, Polystyrene latex particles of sizes 190 nm, 305 nm and 605 nm were mixed in a ratio of 1 : 2 : 2 by wt. and diluted with water to suitable dilution for the AUC UV/Vis absorption optics.
Experimental For the detector development, we used the following commercial products: (a) Spectrometer: USB 2000 Fiber Optics Spectrometer (UV/Vis), Ocean Optics BV, Duiven, The Netherlands with SMA 905 fiber optics connection, 25 µm entrance slit, grating: 600 lines/mm, L2 detector collection lens with UV optimized coating and OFLV-350-1000 2-nd order filter installed and operable with the Ocean optics OOIBASE 32 software. For the UV optimized spectrometer, we have applied a 1200 line holographic grating in combination with a 50 µm slit as the entrance aperture (Fig. 5, component 3) and all other UV optimized compounds as described above.
Results and Discussion Hardware Developments Illumination System. The whole optical system was designed as a modular system, which permits the use of as many commercially available components as possible and simultaneously enables easy exchange of individual components. For illumination, a Hamamatsu L4633-01 flash lamp was used with a built in reflector which focuses the white light directly into an optical fiber. For further details, see [43]. This design enables a fourfold greater relative light intensity relative to the conventional Hamamatsu
12
Fig. 1 Set-up of the illumination system for the fiber optics. (1) Lamp, (2) Holder with x, y, z positioning unit, (3) Fiber, (4) Power supply
L-2435 flash lamp, which is installed in the XL-I. However, the main intensity gain is obtained from the fact, that much of the light is coupled into an optical fiber, whereas in the design of the Beckman XL-A AUC, a pinhole in front of the flash lamp is applied as optical aperture, so that much of the light does not enter the optical detection system. A direct intensity comparison between the fiber coupled Xenon flash lamp and the XL-A design in the wavelength range 400–800 nm revealed a factor of 35–70 higher intensity at the end of the fiber set-up depending on the applied wavelength. However, the flash repetition speed of the flash lamp is relatively slow (only 100 Hz), which corresponds to a maximum flash repetition of 10 ms. Although this is the same speed as the lamp of the XL-A, it is not satisfactory in view of the fast spectrometer detection capabilities. If it is considered that a single flash is only about 4 µs long, but the flash repetition takes 10 ms, it is clear that the flash lamp is the time limiting component in the present set-up at rotor speed > 6000 rpm. The set-up of the illumination system for the fiber optics is simple. An optical bench (OWIS GmbH, Staufen, Germany) with an x, y, z positioning element is used to mount the lamp and the fiber as shown in Fig. 1. This set-up enables the optimum coupling of the light from the lamp into a fiber, which can be adjusted by observing the beam intensity exiting the fiber on a sheet of paper. Coupling is then further optimized using the intensity reading from the spectrometer. Vacuum Feedthroughs/Heatsink Modification. One of the most significant changes of the AUC hardware necessary for the fiber based UV-Vis optical system is the need to feed light and electricity into and out of the vacuum chamber. In the present set-up, this is solved by drilling 6 holes into the heatsink of the XL ultracentrifuge, which was done in the mechanical workshop of the BASF (see
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
Fig. 2 XL-heatsink with vacuum feedthroughs and mounted fibers. (1) Focuser (2) Vacuum feedthrough for electrical cables (3) Window for further optical system (4) vacuum feedthroughs for fibers (5) Vacuum feedthrough for electrical cables
Fig. 2). This has the significant disadvantage that the Beckman warranty is lost so that future designs will be based upon XL-I heatsinks. However, modified heatsinks of the shown type are operated already for several years in the AUC laboratory at BASF AG, Ludwigshafen, Germany without any problem so that they are considered by the authors to be safe. In addition, the present design in principle allows for the mounting of three detector arms of the type presented in this work so that up to three detectors can be run simultaneously. As vacuum feedthroughs, either a four fiber 600 µm vacuum feedthrough from Oz Optics, Ottawa, Canada was applied as shown in Fig. 2 or one fiber vacuum feedthroughs with SMA 905 connectors (Ocean optics B.V., Duiven, The Netherlands). Both feedthroughs have their specific advantages and disadvantages. Whereas the one fiber feedthrough with SMA 905 connector is a very easy and modular system, it looses light (∼ 5%) as it creates an additional two fiber couplings. The four fiber feedthrough does not have this disadvantage. It also uses only one feedthrough for four fibers and should be the system of choice. However, if a fiber breaks, the whole feedthrough has to be taken out and be sent for repair, which can be a significant disadvantage at least in the prototype design process, where many modifications of the optical system are carried out. The feedthroughs for electrical cables are less problematic. Here, we use LEMO Electronic, Munich, Germany electric feedthroughs for 18 cables, where one feedthrough is sufficient for the whole UV-Vis fiber optics. Optical Fibers. The choice of optical fibers is difficult and always a compromise. On one hand, they should enable the transmittance of as much light as possible, while on the other hand, the precision of the optical system is determined by the fiber diameter, as this is the smallest spot size, the light can be focused to. Another requirement is
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
13
that the fibers should have a high transmittance over the entire UV-Vis range (200–800 nm). We have decided to allow for the maximum light intensity, meaning that we use 600 µm or even 1000 µm fibers (Oz optics or Ocean optics). Another issue, which should not be neglected is the capability of the fibers to bend without too much light intensity loss, especially in the UV range, as the fibers have to be bent in the vacuum chamber in the present prototype. As connector system for the fibers, we have applied SMA 905 connectors, which appear to be the most universal for our purpose, but other connectors are also possible. The Detector Arm. The detector arm is the central element of the UV-Vis optical system, as it contains all essential optical components of the optical system itself. The detector arm is schematically shown in Fig. 3. The fiber coming from the lamp is coupled to a collimation system (2 in Fig. 3). This collimation system focuses the light onto the center of the cell. However, it has to be mentioned that the focusing is only achieved for the visible part of the white light and that unavoidable errors are made as long as lenses are used due to chromatic aberration. This can partially be compensated for by using achromatic lenses but they are only available for the visible or UV range respectively and not over the entire range between 200–800 nm, which is envisaged in our application. Therefore, we did not use achromats for this prototype. Instead, we have focused the light onto the center of the cell (spot size ca. 2 mm) for the reason that we were not able to make
Fig. 3 The detector arm. (1) 600 micron patch fiber UV/Vis (Ocean optics), (2) The collimating lens system (self built), f = 20.6 mm biconvex, (3) 90◦ Quartz prism, (4) Slit-lens assembly (from the XL-A) only one lens f = 20 mm biconvex, (5) Focuser, one biconvex lens (15 mm), (6) 600 µm patch fiber (Ocean optics). The light path is also shown schematically
Fig. 4 left. Photograph of the arm, (1) Detector arm, (2) Stepping motor (0.1 µm resolution at up to 4 mm/s), (3) Detection unit with x-y positioning screws. Right: Mounted arm in the rotor chamber
the light parallel, which is the desired situation and in addition needed as much light for detection as possible to investigate the principal capabilities of this first generation prototype. Earlier efforts were made for producing collimated light by using plano convex lenses in the collimation optics part. However, the desired collimated light could not be achieved by using commercially available lenses. The light, which has passed the centrifuge cell is then collected by a modified slit-lens assembly from a Beckman XL-A (4 in Fig. 3) with a 25 µm slit forming the aperture for the radial resolution. The camera lenses of the original system were replaced by a single biconvex lens (f = 20 mm). After the light has passed the slit, it is collected by a commercial focuser system (Ocean optics, with a f = 15 mm biconvex lens) and coupled back into a fiber to the spectrometer. The whole slit-lens assembly can be adjusted by an x-y table to collect the maximum light. The entire illumination and detection parts of the detector arm (Fig. 3) are connected so that they move as a unit along the ultracentrifuge cell. This is achieved by a Zaber (Zaber, Richmond, Canada) step motor (Model T-LA28-SV), which is very fast and precise (Fig. 4). It enables a scanning speed of up to 4 mm/s with an accuracy of 100 nm. In principle, the motor can scan a whole cell in only 3 s. The motor axis itself pushes a plate attached to a spring to ensure mechanical contact between the step motor and the moveable part of the detector arm. The whole detector arm is shown in Fig. 4 in the unmounted state and mounted in the ultracentrifuge. The UV-Vis Spectrometer. The most important part of the UV-Vis optics, besides the detector arm, is the detector itself. In the present study, we have applied a USB2000 spectrometer (Ocean Optics, Duiven, The Netherlands). There are many available spectrometer options (see http://
14
oceanoptics.com/), the most important being the choice of the diffraction grating and the spectrometer aperture (see Fig. 5). We have applied the 1200 line holographic grating for the UV optimized spectrometer & 600 lines blazed grating at 400 nm for the UV/Vis in combination with a 25 µm slit (for UV/Vis) and a 50 µm (for UV) entrance slit as the entrance aperture (Fig. 5, component 3). The main feature of the USB2000 UV-Vis spectrometer is the use of a CCD line array detector (a 2048-element linear silicon CCD array), which allows for the simultaneous detection of the entire spectral range within an integration time as short as 3 ms. Practical integration times used in this study are in the 50–100 ms range so that the spectrometer is rate limiting rather than the lamp. The USBS2000 spectrometer has several vital components. They are shown in Fig. 5 and explained in the following. First, the fiber with the light coming from the sample cell is connected to the SMA905 connector (1) of the spectrometer. After passing a filter (2), the light passes the 25 or 50 µm slit (3) as the entrance aperture. It is then collimated by a collimating mirror (4), which reflects the light from the entrance aperture as a collimated beam towards the diffraction grating (5), which disperses the white light. The refracted light is subsequently reflected by a focusing mirror (6), which reflects and focuses the light onto the detector array. The light collection efficiency is further increased by a cylindrical lens in front of the CCD array (7). Before the light finally reaches the CCD detector (9), it passes through a longpass filter (8) for the elimination of second and third order effects. All spectrometer lenses were coated with a special coating for increased UV transmittance. The spectrometer data can then be directly read out by the commercial spectrometer software. However, this is only of very limited use for the application in an AUC. We therefore used the LABVIEW drivers supplied by Ocean Optics and programmed our own application software (see 2. Software developments).
Fig. 5 The USB2000 UV-Vis spectrometer. Figure courtesy of Ocean Optics and reproduced with kind permission from Ocean optics BV, Duiven, The Netherlands. For description of the components see text
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
Multiplexer and Data Acquisition System. To control the firing of the lamp, a multiplexer system is needed. For this, a trigger signal per rotor revolution has to be generated. This is achieved in our case by polishing an inner sector shaped part of the rotor next to the overspeed disk. This polished part is detected by a reflection light gate similar to an earlier system developed for the model E AUC [42, 44] resulting in a TTL rectangular trigger pulse per rotor revolution. This TTL trigger signal then serves for the precise determination of the rotor speed and the exact time between two rotor revolutions. This time interval is divided into 1000 steps corresponding to an angular resolution of 0.36◦ on the spinning AUC rotor and the time delay of a cell passing the optical detection part to the trigger signal from the rotor has to be calculated by a so-called multiplexer. These units were described before as analog and partially already as digital devices to enable the use of multiplace rotors without wedge windows; [14–17, 45–55]. Multiplexer technology is also common standard in the XL-I AUC although for this centrifuge platform, it is difficult to get precise information on the position where to grab a TTL output signal from the multiplexer. As such signals have to be grabbed directly from the XL-I boards, it is recommended that the user supplies their own separate system for the generation of a TTL trigger pulse similar to the one used in this study. As we aim at a complete software control of the centrifuge system, we applied a National Instruments PCI6602 timer card, which can be programmed under the LABVIEW environment using the supplied virtual instrument drivers. The programming of the multiplexer is described under Software developments. Principal Operation Modes The new fiber based UV-Vis detection system was developed for two principal operation modes. One is the familiar radial mode, where the radial concentration variation in the sample cell is observed at various times, as already realized in all previous AUC’s (Radial mode). This mode, however is not suitable for very polydisperse systems, and only very recently, it became possible to combine the radial profiles obtained at various speeds for a sedimentation velocity experiment [56, 57]. For very polydisperse samples, the use of speed profiles is essential to resolve the complete sample over the entire colloidal range [7, 58]. This is achieved by observing the sample at a fixed position over time so that via use of a speed profile, all samples pass the detector at some stage and are detected (Time mode). This mode is not only interesting for colloids but also for polymers, for example for the detection of aggregates etc. In addition, it has to be stated that the time mode is a very universal mode, where several different samples can be combined in one run, simultaneously enhancing the effectivity of the AUC measurements.
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
For each of the detection modes, a calibration scan has to be performed to find the correct sector position as well as for the calibration of the radius. The cell position calibration is done fully automatically, as is the radial calibration. An option is implemented to store the calibration file and use it if the same rotor and cells are used again, which is especially useful for fast sedimenting samples. Alternatively, an option can be selected to perform the radial calibration after the last scan of the experiment, which allows for instantaneous sample observation but with the disadvantage that the detector positions are not precisely known until the calibration step at the end of the experiment. Both modes are restricted in speed by the flash repetition speed of the flash lamp. Time Mode. In this mode, the detector is set fixed at a defined and known position in the cell. Usually, this is the center of the cell, but if a short experimental duration is desired, a position near the top of the cell can be selected, where care must be taken that the detection position is far enough from the meniscus to avoid optical and physical distortions of the sedimenting boundary. If the highest fractionation of the sample is desired, a position near the cell bottom can be used. As the detector is very fast, it is possible to use more than one detection positions, as the motor of the detection system can move 4 mm/s and the acquisition of a spectrum is in the ms range. With this, the movement of the sample can be followed between two or more precisely known positions, which greatly enhances the accuracy of measurements in the time mode, as already discussed for the dual beam mode [59]. Up to now, in the existing turbidity optics [8, 9], the sample is detected at a single position and the cells have to be completely filled in order to know the starting point of sedimentation, with the related inaccuracies in case of small remaining air bubbles etc. In the time mode, the scan time interval is set as well as the radial position for detection and the length of the entire experiment. This mode is not only useful for very polydisperse samples but also for very fast detection, as a sedimentation velocity experiment can be performed in just a few minutes by speeding up the centrifuge to 60 000 rpm with maximum acceleration provided that the samples sediment sufficiently fast. This suppresses diffusion to the maximum possible extent. Also, the time mode runs can be very useful screening experiments to find out proper centrifugation conditions for radial scans of an unknown sample. In addition it can be used as supplementary data to radial scan data in a global analysis approach [32], as the time mode can detect minor amounts of large aggregates, which maybe lost from detection during rotor acceleration. Radial Mode. The radial mode is familiar to every centrifuge user. The described multiwavelength detector essentially works as the XL-A AUC with the difference of
15
a higher speed and a whole acquired UV-Vis spectrum for each radial point. However, if the user is just interested in 1–3 wavelengths for radial scans, for example to be compatible with existing XL-A evaluation programs, they can be selected in analogy to the XL-A with the difference, that for the CCD based detector, it makes no difference in detection speed how many wavelengths are detected. For all other applications, the wavelength range is selected in order to save only useful data and to reduce data storage space required. Radial scan intervals down to 100 nm can provide a factor 100 in the amount of radial points as compared to the XL-A, which could be a very useful feature for sedimentation equilibrium analysis. Likewise the fast scanning times allow many more radial scan to be acquired per experiment than the XL-A, even with the additional multiwavelength information. However, making the radial steps too small can over-sample the data because two neighbor radial points could be not independent from each other anymore depending on the radial optical resolution of the system. Software Development The software for centrifuge control, multiplexer and data acquisition was written using the LABVIEW 7.1 (National Instruments) programming environment. The software has the capability of ultracentrifuge and step motor control via a serial port, spectrometer and flash lamp triggering via the timer card, as well as data acquisition from the spectrometer. It is convenient to classify software options into three categories such as General Options, Cell Options and Calibration Settings. 1) General Options. Before starting an experiment, some important parameters of the experiment are adjusted. Rotor Adjustment: 4 hole or 8 hole rotor XL Settings Adjustment: Speed, temperature and time setting of ultracentrifuge Scan Mode Time Mode Scan Radial Mode Scan Scan Options Adjustment Acquire intensity data instead of absorbance: Default is absorbance data Filter scan intensities below a certain level: Only in radial mode scan Stop XL after last scan Make radial calibration after experiment Method Scan Options Adjustment Delayed Start: Time delay before the first scan Time between Scans: In Radial Mode only Number of Scans: In Radial Mode only Experiment Directory
16
2) Cell Options. For both time mode and radial mode scan, after enabling desired cells, their experimental parameters should be adjusted, which differ in the two modes Common Options Wavelength Selection: Up to 4 wavelengths Saving Full Spectra Wavelength Range Time Mode Options Radius: Position in the cell Acquisition/Averaging time for one data point (number of lamp flashes) Radial Mode Options Rmin and Rmax: Minimum and maximum radial distance Radial Step: Radial step size between two detector readings Replicates: Number of data points collected at each wavelength Set All Settings Identical to Cell 1: Sets the parameters of cell 1 for each cell 3) Calibration Settings. Cell Calibration: used to set the angular cell positions with respect to the triggering pulse. Position: angle from the trigger pulse to the cell Length: size of the cell in angle units Shifting:provides to access two different positions in the cell e.g. reference and sample sector to allow for the correction of the sample for the reference solvent Angle Calibration: the positions of the cells can be determined with this property Radial Calibration: inner and outer radii for the cells are determined Step Motor Settings: Adjustment of Port, Minimum and Maximum positions of motor Calibrate Outer Position: Maximum outer position of the step motor determined with a sensor on arm Graph Settings: Determination of Scale Settings When the scan starts, the user can observe the experiment online for each cell. Some important information is also shown such as XL Status and Cell Information. It is also possible to change some experimental parameters during the scan such as XL speed, temperature and the intensity limit below which filtering is done. This is an important improvement with respect to the commercial XL-I, which only allows for parameter changes after stopping an ongoing scan. All the options above can be saved in different files for different categories so that the user only needs to adjust necessary parts for any other experiment. The user interface of the control system was adapted to the style of the existing XL-I centrifuge control user interface to maintain an easy operation by the majority of users,
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
already being familiar with the XL-I instrument control and data acquisition software. Basic System Performance The basic check if the optical system correctly images the ultracentrifuge cell and also provides sufficient radial resolution can be performed by scanning a slit. We used a 200 µm slit, which was placed as coating on a cell window (see Fig. 6 lower image). This window was used in an AUC cell with a 2 mm centerpiece with the slit facing the centerpiece and oriented perpendicular to the radial direction. Scanning this cell in the intensity mode yields a radial scan, which should show a 200 µm wide rectangular peak. Ideally, the transition from zero to maximum intensity should be very sharp. However, as the aperture slit for the optics is only 25 µm, a better optical resolution cannot be expected. In Fig. 6, the result of this experiment is shown for the XL-A (right) and our fiber detector (Fig. 6 left). For the experiment, we chose a radial step size of 3 µm, the step size for the XL-A was set to the finest possible value of 10 µm. It can be seen that the transition zone for 0–100% intensity is about 50 µm for the fiber optics detector. Due to the limited number of data points, the transition is more shallow for the XL-A optical system. This demonstrates that our basic optical system performance is at least as good as that of the XL-A, although we use a lens optics, which shows the chromatic aberration problem for white light.
Fig. 6 Resolution observed by placing a 200 micrometer slit at the centre of the cell. The figure in the top left shows observation for the fiber optics based detector. The figure at upper right shows the observation for the commercial XL-A. Bottom: A light microscopy image of the slit. Scale bar = 500 µm
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
17
Results and Discussion Time Mode. The first sample, which we used to test our optical system was bovine serum albumin (BSA) – a standard protein sample which shows an absorbance peak at 280 nm in the UV-Vis spectrum. We set the slit position to 6.1 cm close to the meniscus in order to enable a fast measurement in the time mode. Absorbance was determined by recording the intensity of the sample and applying the intensity recorded for the reference solvent in a separate calibration experiment. The experimental raw data are shown in Fig. 7. The tremendous amount of data becomes directly obvious. Also, it can be seen that the present lower wavelength limit of the fiber detector is 240 nm, which just shows the onset of the 230 nm BSA peak. This is a bad situation for investigations of proteins, where usually the 230 nm peak is the most intense one but tolerable for most other samples. If only one wavelength is picked out of the multiwavelength scans, the time dependent sedimentation can be visualized in a similar way to the traditional AUC scans and the data quality can be controlled (Fig. 8). The expected sigmoidal curve is shown and the data quality is comparable to that of the XL-A. Repetition of the experiment in time mode with the fiber optics and in the radial mode in the XL-A yielded comparable results in terms of the sedimentation coefficients for the identical sample run on both instruments as shown in Fig. 9. The noise level in both scans is about the same although for the fiber optics, there are many more data points, which is advantageous for the subsequent evaluation. Another obvious difference is the broadness of the experimental curve. The apparent sedimentation coefficient distribution, which is not corrected for diffusion broadening is considerably sharper from the fiber optics than from
Fig. 7 Sedimentation velocity experiment for BSA, temperature: 25 ◦ C, Rotor Speed: 50 000 rpm, Slit position: 6.1 cm, lowest detectable wavelength 240 nm. Spectra recording condition: 98 ms integration time and 10 averages
Fig. 8 Absorbance vs time plot for BSA 1 g/L at 280 nm. (Experimental conditions; Rotor speed: 5000 rpm, Slit position: 6.1 cm. Data recorded with 98 ms integration time and 10 averages). The data were not yet corrected for reference solvent
Fig. 9 Comparison of XL-A and Fiber optics. Slit position 6.1 cm, Meniscus 5.81 cm, Fiber optics: 1 s time interval and time mode scan, XL-A: Continuous radial scan 0.05 cm, 2averages. For fiber optics: 14 100 points and for XL-A: 250 points. The data were recorded at wavelength 280 nm. Equation used to convert ‘r’ values to ‘s’: s = (1/ω2 t) ln(r/rm ); variables have their usual meaning
the XL-A. This effect is attributed to the fact that the detector was placed very close to the meniscus so that diffusion broadening of the boundary could not yet set in. Whereas the sedimentation coefficient distributions get sharper with time in the radial mode, as diffusion goes with the square root of time but sedimentation is directly proportional; this is not observed in the time mode as long as the detector is placed at a position, where diffusion broadening could not yet set in to a significant extent. On the other hand, the fractionation capability of the AUC is not fully exploited with that setting. A slightly tilted lower plateau is observed for the data from the fiber optics. The reason for this is not yet clear, but it has to be stressed that we do not yet use a reference solvent correction nor a correction for variations in the flash lamp intensity. In addition, this tilting of the lower plateau is not regularly observed. Another comparison between the time mode of the fiber optics detector and the radial mode in the XL-A was made for a mixture of three latex standards (150 nm, 190 nm & 240 nm). The results are shown in Fig. 10.
18
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
Fig. 10 Sedimentation velocity of a latex mixture (Polystyrene latex mixture with particle sizes 150 nm, 190 nm and 240 nm). Left: Fiber optics, time mode scan (slit position 6.1 cm, Recording conditions, wavelength: 450 nm, Integration time: 100 ms, 10 averages). Right: XL-A, radial mode scan, continuous (0.005 cm and 2 averages)
It can be seen that the 3 components are resolved in both ultracentrifuges. Also, the detected concentration of the individual species is comparable for both ultracentrifuges. The data quality of the fiber optics detector is, however, much higher than that of the XL-A. The reason maybe the fact that the flash lamp intensity is lower in the visible range, which degrades the data quality. For the fiber optics, the UV-intensity is significantly decreased due to fiber bending (see discussion below) so that the data quality is better in the visible range for the present prototype. However, for the fiber optics, a significant tilting of the upper plateau is observed at the early times. Such tilting is always observed in case of turbid samples and could have to do with the significantly enhanced stray light for these samples. In the slit-lens assembly of the XL-A, an aperture is installed, which limits stray light from the sample to +/− 4◦ . This aperture is not yet realized for the present fiber optics prototype. Indicative for stray light is also the fact that just the upper plateau is tilted but not the lower plateau, where all turbid latices have already sedimented. The turbidity of colloidal dispersions is often a problem for their analysis by AUC. This is caused by the fact that the scattering of particles is size dependent according to the MIE theory where a small amount of large particles scatters more light than a large amount of small particles. This in turn affects the apparent light absorption and turbidity and makes the absorption optics sensitive to size dependence analysis. Therefore, a so called coupling technique was developed for the determination of particle size distributions with a turbidity detector, where the same sample is investigated at a high concentration to detect the small particles and at a low concentration for the detection of the larger particles [60]. This obstacle is omitted with the new multiwavelength detector, as the short wavelengths are especially sensitive, so that small particles could be detected at short wavelengths and the larger ones at the more insensitive large wavelengths in
a single experiment. This effect is demonstrated in Fig. 11 for a binary latex mixture, which is displayed for three different wavelengths. The drastic effect of the wavelength dependence of the detected signals is clearly visible. When for example the wavelengths 430 & 660 nm are combined, the two different latexes are detected with a comparable sensitivity. Another feature of the new detector is its speed. It is no problem to perform a whole sedimentation velocity experiment during the acceleration of the AUC to 60 000 rpm with maximum speed provided that the samples sediment fast enough. This is shown in Fig. 12 where the experimental raw data and the differential distribution being proportional to the particle size and sedimentation coefficient distribution are displayed. In only 3 minutes, the whole sedimentation coefficient distribution is determined. The huge advantage of such experiments beside the speed is the fact that diffusion broadening is suppressed to the maximum possible extent so
Fig. 11 Latex mixture (150 & 240 nm) observed at three different wavelengths (430, 450 & 660 nm). Experimental conditions: Rotor speed: 10 000 rpm, Temperature: 25 ◦ C, Slit position: 6.1 cm. Data collection conditions: 100 ms averaging time, 10 averages
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
19
Fig. 12 Fast sedimentation velocity Experiment with a Polystyrene Latex Mixture of sizes 190 nm, 305 nm and 605 nm in 1 : 2 : 2 mixing ratio by wt.; data collected at 350 nm; Left: Experimental raw data. Right: Derivative curve was generated performing differentiation after 5 point FFT smoothing. Slit position: 6.1 cm
Fig. 13 Upper left: Raw data for a total radial Scan (Sample: 175 nm Polystyrene Latex, 10 000 rpm, 25 ◦ C). Upper right: radial scan at a fixed wavelength. Lower left: Radial scan at a fixed wavelength (Zoomed view), lower right: Radial scan after cutting off noisy regions. Note that the radius is expressed in radius points corresponding to the steps of the detector movement and no real radial calibration was performed yet
20
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
that a diffusion correction can become obsolete for many samples. However, the evaluation of such experiments has to be improved. With this, we can adapt the experiences with the turbidity detector where similar problems were faced. Radial Mode. The data amount of the radial mode is much higher than that of the time mode, as a whole spectrum can be saved for every radial point. A 1 cm solution column can in principle be scanned with 100 nm resolution, which corresponds to 105 data points per scan. For radial scans with the detector prototype, we first used the spectrometer software supplied with the spectrometer and visualized the data with a data viewer written by B. Demeler, UTHCSA, San Antonio. In the following we demonstrate how the useable data in a single scan can be extracted for the example of a 175 nm latex sample (Fig. 13). First of all, all experimental data are read in for a particular scan. If the whole cell is scanned as in this example, the first view along the cell from top to bottom just shows noise from the cell part before the sector starts (Fig. 13 upper left). Therefore, the plot has to be transformed from the wavelength display to a radial display at a selected wavelength (Fig. 13 upper right), which is a familiar data display for every AUC user. In the zoomed view (Fig. 13 lower left) the meniscus can be seen. Also top and bottom of the cell are clearly visible and define the data regions, which have to be cut off. This step is eliminated in the new data acquisition software, where the radius is calibrated before the experiment, so that only the useful data range is scanned. Also, noisy wavelength regions can be clipped until the final scan is obtained as shown in Fig. 13 lower right. If this scan is turned appropriately, the three dimensional nature of a scan becomes obvious (Fig. 14). Not only the sigmoidal radial sedimentation velocity profile is shown, but also the wavelength dependence of
Fig. 14 Radial Scan for a 175 nm polystyrene latex sample (10 000 rpm, 25 ◦ C)
Fig. 15 Radial scan for a 1.0 g/L solution of Cytochrome C (Speed 50 000 rpm)
turbidity, which can even be used to evaluate the colloid particle size independently. It is clear that such scan contains much more information than the conventional two dimensional radial scan. Especially fitting algorithms should greatly profit from the additional wavelength dimension. Another example for a single radial scan is presented in Fig. 15 for Cytochrome C. Even although the typical 230 & 280 protein absorption peaks could not be detected without significant noise in this example, Fig. 15 already shows the information increase of a single multiwavelength scan as compared to a radial scan at a single wavelength as performed in the commercial XL-I. The use of the introduced multiwavelength detection can easily be imagined for interacting systems with different chromophores. Problems. One of the big current limitations of the detector is the low light intensity in the UV region, which is the most important part of the spectrum – at least for
Fig. 16 UV-Vis spectrum detected without fiber bending on an optical bench and with fiber bending in the AUC
Development of a Fast Fiber Based UV-Vis Multiwavelength Detector for an Ultracentrifuge
many biopolymers. This is mainly caused by the necessity to bend the fibers upon installation of the detector arm in the ultracentrifuge (see also Fig. 4). Fiber bending reduces the light especially in the UV region < 250 nm. When the detector arm is mounted on an optical bench without fiber bending, there is still an intensity of more than 200 counts registered down to 225 nm, which would enable the investigation of proteins. Fiber bending, however, causes intensity loss of a factor of three around 250 nm and about a factor of two for the rest of the spectral range (Fig. 15). Therefore, the construction of the arm has to be modified to avoid fiber bending.
Conclusion and Outlook In this work, we could show a first prototype of a fiber based multiwavelength detector for the XL preparative ultracentrifuge. First measurements demonstrate that the detector is very fast with present typical scan times of only 100 ms/spectrum and delivers a data quality comparable to that of the XL-A. Due to the speed of the detector, two experimental modes are possible – the well known radial scanning mode as well as the time mode, where the detector is set at a fixed position and the sedimentation is observed with time. These modes extend the possibility of AUC with absorption optics detection to very polydisperse samples. Sedimentation velocity experiments as fast as two minutes become possible now, where just the centrifuge is accelerated to 60 000 rpm and immediately slowed down again. The detector design was made in a modular way so that all components can be easily exchanged. Therefore, advantage of new developments for example in lamp or spectrometer performance can be fully taken. For example, Ocean optics has very recently released the HR4000 spectrometer, which can scan as fast as 10 µs. This already allows the use of a continuous lamp
21
with a pulsed spectrometer so that a very high light intensity could be realized in future designs on that basis. As commercially available compounds are applied, the price for the detector is also moderate. One drawback of the present detector is the high light intensity loss upon fiber bending and the use of lens optics with the associated chromatic aberration problem. Although the latter appeared to be of minor importance, we will develop a mirror optical system for this detector in the future, which enables defined and equal light beams at all wavelengths. In addition, mirrors can help to eliminate the necessity for fiber bending. Nevertheless, the present detector prototype is a cheap and modular add on, which transforms a preparative ultracentrifuge into an analytical machine. The now available multiwavelength data add a further dimension to ultracentrifuge analyses allowing for future use of global multiwavelength fits, evaluation of the particle size via the wavelength dependence of turbidity, a turbidity detection with multiple sensitivity, rapid sedimentation velocity experiments and many more. Nevertheless, the software basis for these applications still needs to be developed. Acknowledgement We thank the BASF AG, Ludwigshafen and the Max-Planck-Society for financial support of this work. We also thank Dr. Walter Mächtle, BASF, for useful discussions and Dr. Borries Demeler, UTHCSA, San Antonio for writing a data visualization program to display the multiwavelength data. The mechanical workshop of the BASF is acknowledged for the modification of the XL heatsink and for building the basic detector arm. Andreas Kretzschmar, mechanical workshop MPI-KGF, is acknowledged for multiple modifications of the detector arm. Henryk Pitas, electrical workshop MPI-KGF, is thanked for help with electrical problems. Dr. K. Tauer (MPI-KGF) is acknowledged for the latex samples and Dr. Neil Robinson (UTHCSA) for the cytochrome samples. Finally, we thank Antje Völkel for helpful assistance and Prof. Dr. Dr. h.c. Markus Antonietti for the overall support of this project.
References 1. Svedberg T, Pedersen KO(1940) The Ultracentrifuge. Clarendon Press, Oxford 2. Lloyd PH (1974) Optical methods in Ultracentrifugation, Electrophoresis, and Diffusion: with a guide to the interpretation of records. Clarendon Press, Oxford 3. Schmidt B, Riesner D (1992) A Fluorescence Detection System for the Analytical Ultracentrifuge and its Application to Proteins, Nucleic Acids, Viroids and Viruses. In: Harding SE et al. (ed) Analytical Ultracentrifugation in Biochemistry and Polymer Science. Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 176
4. MacGregor IK, Laue TM (1999) Biophys J 76:357 5. MacGregor IK, Anderson AL, Laue TM (2004) Biophys Chem 108:165 6. Cantow HJ (1964) Makromol Chem 70:130 7. Scholtan W, Lange H (1972) Kolloid Z Z Polym 250:782 8. Müller HG (1989) Colloid Polym Sci 267:1113 9. Mächtle W (1992) Analysis of Polymer Dispersions with an Eight-Cell-AUC-Multiplexer: High Resolution Particle Size Distribution and Density Gradient Techniques. In: Harding SE et al. (ed) Analytical
10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
Ultracentrifugation in Biochemistry and Polymer Science. Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 147 Klodwig U, Mächtle W (1989) Colloid Polym Sci 267:1117 Clewelow AC, Errington N, Rowe AJ (1997) Eur Biophys J 25:311 Holtus G, Borchard W (1989) Colloid and Polymer Science 267:1133 Cölfen H, Borchard W (1994) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 94:90 Kisters D, Borchard W (1999) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 113:10 Laue TM (1992) On-Line data aquisition and analysis from the Rayleigh interferometer. In: Harding SE et al. (ed) Analytical
22
16.
17. 18. 19.
20. 21.
22. 23. 24. 25.
26.
27.
S.K. Bhattacharyya et al.
Ultracentrifugation in Biochemistry and Polymer Science. Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 63 Börger L, Lechner MD, Stadler M (2004) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 127:19 Mächtle W (1999) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 113:1 Flossdorf J, Schillig H, Schindler KP (1978) Makromol Chem 179:1617 Giebeler R (1992) The Optima XL-A: A New Analytical Ultracentrifuge with a Novel Precision Absorption Optical System. In: Harding SE et al. (ed) Analytical Ultracentrifugation in Biochemistry and Polymer Science. Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 16 Flossdorf J (1980) Makromol Chem 181:715 Cölfen H, Borchard W (1994) Ultrasensitive Schlieren Optical System. In: Bonner RF et al. (ed) Progress in Biomedical Optics, Vol 2136. SPIE Bellingham, Washington, p 307 Schuck P (2000) Biophys J 78:1606 Stafford WF (1992) Anal Biochem 203:295 Johnson ML, Correia JJ, Yphantis DA, Halvorson (1981) Biophys J 36:575 McRorie DK, Voelker PJ (1993) Self-Associating Systems in the Analytical Ultracentrifuge. Beckman Instruments California (http://www.beckman.com/Literature/ BioResearch/362784.pdf) Demeler B, van Holde KE (2004) Anal Biochem 335:279 and Ultrascan Website: http://www.ultrascan.uthscsa.edu/ Mächtle W (1991) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 86:111
28. Voelker P (1995) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 99:162 29. Cölfen H, Pauck T, Antonietti M (1997) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 107:136 30. Schuck P (2003) Anal Biochem 320:104 31. Cölfen H, Völkel A (2003) Eur Biophys J 32:432 32. Global analysis is also possible with the SEDPHAT software by Peter Schuck. See the following Website for further details: http://www.analyticalultracentrifugation.com/sedphat/sedphat.htm 33. Vistica J, Dam J, Balbo A, Yikilmaz E, Mariuzza RA, Rouault TA, Schuck P (2004) Anal Biochem 326:234 34. Balbo A, Minor KH, Velikovsky CA, Mariuzza RA, Peterson CB, Schuck P (2005) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102 1:81 35. Gledhill RJ (1962) J Phys Chem 66:458 36. Bateman JB, Weneck EJ, Eshler DC (1959) J Colloid Sci 14:308 37. Heller W, Bhatnagar HL, Nakagaki M (1962) J Chem Phys 36:1163 38. Hosono M, Sugii S, Kusudo O, Tsuji W (1973) Bull Inst Chem Res, Kyoto Univ 51:104 39. http://oceanoptics.com/technical/ engineering/USB2000%20OEM% 20Data%20Sheet.pdf 40. http://oceanoptics.com/technical/ engineering/OEM%20Data% 20Sheet%20–%20HR4000.pdf 41. www.lot-oriel.com/ccd 42. Cölfen H (1994) Bestimmung thermodynamischer und elastischer Eigenschaften von Gelen mit Hilfe von Sedimentations-gleichgewichten
43.
44. 45.
46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54.
55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60.
in einer Analytischen Ultrazentrifuge am Beispiel des Systems Gelatine/Wasser. Verlag Köster, Berlin Visit the following website: http://usa.hamamatsu.com/en/ products/electron-tube-division/lightsources/xenon-flash-lamps.php Cölfen H, Borchard W (1994) Anal Biochem 219:321 Laue TM (1981) PhD Dissertation, Univ Of Connecticut, Storrs, CT, USA Rockholt DL, Royce CR, Richards (1976) Biophys Chem 5:55 Laue TM, Domanic RA, Yphantis DA (1983) Anal Biochem 131:220 Yphantis DA, Laue TM, Anderson IA (1983) Anal Biochem 143:95 Mächtle W, Klodwig U (1979) Makromol Chem 180:2507 Mächtle W, Klodwig U (1976) Makromol Chem 177:1607 Sedlack U, Lechner MD (1995) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 99:136 Ortlepp B, Panke D (1991) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 86:57 Schindler KP (1980) Avail NTIS. Report (Order No. PB81-167140):157 Flossdorf J, Schillig H, Schindler KP (1980) J Phys E: Scientific Instruments 13:647 Kuhnert R, Boedel E, Stegemann H, Wastl G (1973) CZ-Chem Tech 2:441 Müller HG (2004) Progr Colloid Polym Sci 127:9 Stafford WE, Braswell EH (2004) Biophys Chem 108:273 Müller HG (1989) Colloid Polym Sci 267:1113 Mächtle W (1999) Biophys J 76:1080 Mächtle W (1988) Angew Makromol Chem 162:35
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 23–28 DOI 10.1007/2882_016 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 22 February 2006
INSTRUMENTATION
Victor P. Lavrenko Peter N. Lavrenko
Automatic Analysis of Lebedev Interference Patterns
Victor P. Lavrenko (u) · Peter N. Lavrenko Institute of Macromolecular Compounds, Russian Academy of Sciences, 199004 St. Petersburg, Russia e-mail:
[email protected]
Abstract We developed a system for acquisition and analysis of interference patterns from an analytical ultracentrifuge or a polarising diffusiometer. The system is the first of its kind to be based on highly sensitive Lebedev optical system. We also present a novel algorithm for automatic extraction of interference curves from photographs. The algorithm is fast, robust in the face of
Victor P. Lavrenko (u) Present address: Department of Computer Science, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA 01003, USA
Introduction Optical interferometers play an important part in analysis of ultracentrifugation and diffusion processes. In recent years there has been increased interest in developing methods for automated acquisition of data from these interferometers, as well as in algorithms for their analysis by a digital computer. Computerized processing is valuable because it enables rapid scrutinizing of very large amounts of experimental results – something that is not possible with manual investigation. Several promising approaches [1–5] have been proposed and developed by Laue, Stafford, Mächtle, Cölfen, Harding, and others for the widely used Schlieren and Rayleigh optical systems. For example, the authors use a modified Walsh analysis [6] of light intensities across the interference envelope to obtain fringe phases and the magnitudes of associated transformations. However, previously proposed approaches are closely tied to the particular interferometer for which they were developed, and cannot be readily used with the Lebedev interferometer. In this paper we describe a system for automatic acquisition and analysis of data from the Lebedev polarising interferometer [7]. The Lebedev interferometer represents one of the most sensitive optical systems. It is sim-
optical noise and may have potential applications in other domains.
Keywords Digital recording · Optical noise · Polarising interference patterns
ple, convenient to use and enjoys a near-optimal balance of resolving power to noise. The Lebedev interferometer differs from the Rayleigh system and from similar approaches [9, 10] in that the interfering beams of light are not isolated from each other. Instead, both systems of rays pass simultaneously through the whole field, allowing the use of very small separations between the rays. The principle is schematically represented below for one arbitrary beam of polarised light.
Scheme 1
V.P. Lavrenko · P.N. Lavrenko
24
The interferometer is made up of two similarly oriented plane-parallel plates of Iceland spar of equal thickness. The plates are cut at a 45 degree angle to the proper crystal optical axis to provide the spar twinning, a. A half-wave plate λ/2 is placed between them to rotate the light polarisation direction for 90 degree. The ordinate value of the interference fringe, y, is proportional to the difference in the refractive indices in a cell, y ∼ (n 1 − n 2 ). A reader interested in a more detailed description of the system, or in comparing its properties with other interferometers will find a plethora of relevant material in [11]. For years the Lebedev optical scheme has been successfully applied to the analysis of sedimentation and diffusion of numerous polymers [8]. However, all these studies involved manual data acquisition and analysis of optical images. Manual analysis of interference patterns is an extremely tedious process. A photograph of an interference pattern in Fig. 1 serves to illustrate this.
based on the Lebedev polarising interferometer [8, 11]. The interferometer operates with the spar twinning of 0.10 cm and the Babbine compensator fringe interval, b, of 0.167 cm. Interference photographs were captured using a digital camera. We obtained satisfactory results using a very simple cameras, such as the Logitech QuickCam 2 web-cam and the Olympus C-310 digital camera. We used an additional short-focus lens to project the interference pattern from the compensator through the optics of the digital camera and onto its sensor. The camera sensor was aligned in such a way that rows of pixels were parallel to the radial direction of the ultracentrifugation. The camera was controlled by a personal computer through a USB cable, and could be programmed to capture interference images at set time intervals. Each image was then passed to the analytical algorithm, which automatically digitizes the interference curves and computes a set of standard summary statistics. In the following section we will provide a detailed description of that algorithm. Our algorithm may appear somewhat unusual to a reader familiar with pattern analysis, therefore, we will start discussing the challenges that motivated our choice and precluded simpler solutions.
Motivation
Fig. 1 The fragment of a striped pattern of Lebedev interference optics as recorded for a concentration boundary formed between decalin (left) and decalin solution of dioctyl phthalate at solute concentration c = 0.99 wt%. The recording time is 15 min
The photograph shows a set of five bell-shaped curves. Analysis of such a pattern involves the following three steps: 1. selecting the curve which exhibits the lowest level of noise, 2. digitising the curve, i.e. converting it to a set of {x, y} values, 3. computing a number of standard statistics for the curve, such as the location and height of the peak, the centre of mass, variance around the centre, etc. The second step of this process is particularly tedious when performed by hand. Therefore, this paper will focus in this step. We will first describe the experimental setup, which has been constructed for the automatic acquisition of interference photographs. Then we present a novel algorithm for digitizing the photographs obtained thereof.
Experimental Setup We used the MOM 3180 analytical ultracentrifuge manufactured by the Hungarian Optical Works [12]. The centrifuge was equipped with the Tsvetkov optical device
Figure 1 shows a pattern of the Lebedev interference optics, reflecting a concentration boundary between two liquids. Human eyes looking at the image will easily recognize a series of bell-shaped curves stretching from left to right. The curves are of nearly identical shape and can be thought of as the same curve repeated several times at different vertical positions. Our goal is, through several steps illustrated in Figs. 2–5, to construct a numerical representation of the curve – a set of points {x, y} similar to the one presented in Fig. 6. We must note that the exact scale of {x, y} values is somewhat arbitrary, our primary interest concerns the general shape of the curve and how it evolves over time. Extracting numerical values {x, y} from a photograph of the curve is a simple task for a human, but represents a formidable challenge for a digital computer as was already mentioned by Laue and others [2–4]. The apparent simplicity stems from the fact that humans are endowed with an incredibly powerful visual cortex, which quickly extracts salient patterns, filters out noise and fills in the missing portions of an image – all performed in a blink of an eye without a human realizing it. By comparison, the computer’s capabilities are extremely primitive. To illustrate shortly this claim, we would like to point out that any computer working with the photograph in Fig. 1 must explicitly deal with the following difficulties that humans will hardly notice: 1. There is no sharp boundary to distinguish the curve and the background – the computer will see shades of grey
Automatic Analysis of Lebedev Interference Patterns
2. 3. 4. 5.
where a human makes a judgement call as to what is black and what is white. The curves themselves are thick, and it is not trivial to identify their centre. Parts are missing for some of the curves, for example, the topmost curve is missing its base line, whereas the bottom curve is missing its peak. Optical noise produces small dark and light spots in random locations. Lighting intensity varies significantly over the photograph, for example the “white” background between the curves in the upper-right portion of the image is actually darker than the “black” curves in the lower-left portion.
Overall, a digital computer is presented with an input that is quite different from the human perception of the photograph. A computer sees a surface formed by light intensities, similar to the one shown in Fig. 2.
Fig. 2 The surface of the lighting intensity for the fragment presented in Fig. 1 as obtained with using the vidicon tube (for visual convenience, the image was arbitrarily turned left for an optimal angle). The x-scale ranges from 0 to 120 pixel columns, and y(×0.1)-scale ranges from 0 to 80 pixels
Darker portions of an image (e.g. curves) correspond to troughs, whereas lighter portions (space between curves) are represented by elevated regions. Recognizing a curve in this environment is quite challenging, particularly in the right portion of the figure where the distinction between curves and the background (troughs and peaks) is almost completely washed out. Below we will propose an automatic procedure that attempts to deal with the difficulties outlined above and ultimately converts a photograph (Fig. 1) into a corresponding numerical representation (Fig. 6).
25
Algorithm Intuitively, if we wanted to extract a numerical representation of a photographed curve we would need to: (1) find any initial point {x 0 , y0} that lies on the curve, and (2) “trace” the curve by finding adjacent points {x i , yi } until we hit the image boundary. Unfortunately, this simple procedure will run into substantial difficulties because of the noise inherent in the photographs. It is our experience that the procedure frequently gets stuck if there is a light spot on a curve, and will sometimes “jump” to a neighbouring curve if there is a dark region between the two curves. Simple smoothing and filtering techniques did not alleviate the problem. Therefore, we focused on a completely different solution. Instead of directly extracting the points {x i , yi } of the target curve, we will seek the points { dx i , dyi } that roughly correspond to partial derivatives at the ith point along the target curve. Note that dx i will be constant if the points are spaced out at equal intervals. Once we have obtained the derivatives, we can easily reconstruct the target curve by performing numerical integration over { dx i , dyi }. Now we turn our attention to extracting the partial derivatives { dx i , dyi } from the original photograph. Suppose that {x, y} is a point that lies on one of the curves in Fig. 1. A key observation behind our approach is that the partial derivative { dx, dy} at the point {x, y} defines a vector tangential to the target curve, and therefore tangential to the perceived boundary separating the dark regions of the photograph (the curves) from the lighter areas (the background). In other words, in order to find the partial derivatives { dx i , dyi } of the target curve, we need to find vectors that are tangential to the illumination boundaries in the photograph. The photograph is represented as an m × n illumination matrix V where Vj,i represents light intensity at the ith pixel of the jth line in the digitized photograph. Intensities are given in arbitrary units. As aforementioned, this matrix can be represented as an intensity surface (Fig. 2), where elevation is proportional to light intensity at that point. Accordingly, boundaries between light and dark regions will correspond to steep slopes in the intensity surface, and vectors {dx,dy} are precisely the vectors that are tangential to these slopes. This observation leads to a procedure for obtaining the tangent vectors: 1. For each coordinate ( j, i) in the digitized photograph we compute the numerical gradient: G xj,i = Vj,i+1 − Vj,i y
G j,i = Vj+1,i − Vj,i . Together, the matrices G x and G y define a vector field. A fragment thereof is shown in Fig. 3. Each gradient vector {G x ,G y } j,i is rooted at the point ( j, i) and points in the direction of the steepest rise in the light intensity surface, i.e. perpendicular to the boundaries between light and dark.
V.P. Lavrenko · P.N. Lavrenko
26
3. In the next step, we average the tangent vectors by column: dx i = dyi =
Fig. 3 Fragment of the vector field of the light intensity gradient (with horizontal x-axis in column units and vertical y-axis in pixel units, ≈ 20 µm/column and ≈ 9 µm/pixel, respectively) as obtained with using the program applied to the surface shown in Fig. 2. Vectors are directed to higher illumination, and their random disordering is resulted from the optical noises
m 1 x Tj,i m
1 m
j=1 m
y
Tj,i .
j=1
The averaging is motivated by the fact that the photograph contains several identical curves shifted vertically. Since the curves are identical, all non-zero partial derivatives {dx,dy} in the same column should ideally be the same. Averaging serves as a noisereduction step: whatever irregularities are present in any individual curve are unlikely to repeat within the same column and will hopefully wash out. The resulting set of partial derivatives {dx,dy} is shown in Fig. 5.
Fig. 5 Fragment of the vector field with the envelope ∂ f/∂x(x) function obtained by summation of the tangential vectors given in Fig. 4. The axes definitions are the same as in Fig. 3 Fig. 4 Fragment of the field of the vectors tangential to those given in Fig. 3. The axe definitions are the same as in Fig. 3
4. Finally, we recover the target curve from the partial derivatives by performing discrete integration: 2. Since we are interested in the vectors tangential to the boundaries, we rotate each gradient vector {G x , G y } j,i by 90 degrees. The result is a tangent vector field {T x , T y }, displayed in Fig. 4, where each vector points along the boundary between light and dark. Note that we can rotate each vector either clockwise or counterclockwise: in either case we get a vector tangential to illumination slope. We choose the direction of rotation so as to ensure that the resulting vector has a positive x. x-component Tj,i
xi =
i
dx j
j=1
yi =
i
dy j .
j=1
The result is shown in Fig. 6. Computing the summary statistics from the target curve is a trivial task.
Automatic Analysis of Lebedev Interference Patterns
Fig. 6 The desired f(x) distribution function with the required parameters as calculated by integration of the function given in Fig. 5. The axe definitions are the same as in Fig. 3
Discussion The algorithm proposed in the previous section is suited to extract a digitized curve from an interference photograph such as shown in Fig. 1. The algorithm is believed to be advantageous, specifically due to the following features: 1. The algorithm is extremely fast. It can process thousands of interference photographs per hour on a Pentium-4 personal computer. The speed results from the fact that all intermediate steps can be expressed as simple matrix operations. 2. The algorithm requires no interaction with the user and can be incorporated into a completely autonomous system for on-line acquisition and analysis of centrifugation and diffusion experiments. 3. The algorithm is robust to optical noise: we have demonstrated its ability to extract a curve from a photograph with non-uniform lighting, optical blemishes, washed-out boundaries and missing curve portions. 4. The algorithm takes advantage of all curves in the image. A typical curve extraction algorithm would rely on a single dark line in Fig. 1. Our algorithm leverages redundancy between curves; it effectively collates portions of broken curves (top-most and bottom-most curves in Fig. 1). The resolving power of an optical system can be evaluated by the ratio d/b, where d is an optical width of the interference fringe as the distance between the equal-density lines with an intensity equal to half of the maximum darkness of the fringe [11]. We have evaluated the average d/b value of 0.35 for the curve shown in Fig. 1 and a precision of ∆ y ≈ 0.2 fringes for the fringe displacement. The precision value for the final curve in Fig. 6 is approxi-
27
mately five times higher. Hence, the procedure developed in this paper leads to increased accuracy when localizing the fringe position. This effect is similar to the one attained for Rayleigh optics by Stafford [4] who has reached an accuracy of about 0.01 fringe in the blank corrected measurements. In addition to increased accuracy, the specific summation procedure proposed in our algorithm has the effect of smoothing out the fringe contour. The problem addressed in this paper bears a lot of similarity to the problem solved by Yphantis et al. [3]. However, the algorithm we propose is fundamentally different from the Fourier approach used by Yphantis et al. The authors in [3] perform a single-frequency Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) on each column of the target interference photograph to determine the “phase” of the underlying intensity profile. Fringe displacement is computed as a cumulative sum of phase differences between adjacent columns. The algorithm proposed in this paper exhibits two important differences from the Fourier method [3]: (1) Single-frequency DFT requires the operator to select the target frequency. Yphantis et. al. [3] estimate this frequency as the number of pixels separating two fringes in an image. This step has to be done manually and the authors recommend that optimal target frequency be re-estimated for each new experiment. Contrarily, our algorithm makes no assumptions about the harmonic nature of the pixel column. Not relying on a harmonic representation gives our algorithm two important advantages. First, the algorithm requires no manual intervention or re-calibration from run to run. Second, the algorithm can be applied to images that cannot be processed with DFT, e.g. images with nonuniform spacing between the curves, or optically-distorted images where the middle of the image is magnified and contains fewer curves than the edges (lens effect). (2) The DFT method is limited to tracking curves with gradient no greater than 0.5 fringe per column of pixels. The limitation stems from the fact that Fourier analysis is performed on each column of pixels independently of its neighbours. In contrast to that, our algorithm uses both adjacent rows and adjacent columns to compute the tangent vector at each point in the image. This tangent vector can have any orientation, so technically there is no limit on the gradient of the curve to be tracked.
Conclusions We have presented a novel idea for digitising noisy interference images to extract intrinsic sedimentation and diffusion data from Lebedev interference optical systems by using gradient averages of intensity recording. The novel method of gradient vector summation was applied to eliminate some optical defects of the interference patterns and to provide a smoothing analysis. We are presently investigating applications of the algorithm to band images recorded with other interference schemes.
V.P. Lavrenko · P.N. Lavrenko
28
References 1. Rowe AJ, Wynne Jones S, Thomas DG, Harding SE (1992) In: Harding SE, Rowe AJ, Horton JC (eds) Analytical ultracentrifugation in biochemistry and polymer science. The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 49 2. Laue TM (1992) In: Harding SE, Rowe AJ, Horton JC (eds) Analytical ultracentrifugation in biochemistry and polymer science. The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 63 3. Yphantis DA, Lary JW, Stafford WF, Liu S, Olsen PH, Hayes DB, Moody TP, Ridgeway TM, Lyons DA, Laue TM (1994) On line Data Acquisition for the Rayleigh Interference Optical System of the Analytical Ultracentrifuge. In: Modern Analytical Ultracentrifugation: Acquisition and
4.
5.
6.
7.
Interpretation of Data for Biological Synthetic Polymer System. Birkhauser-Boston, Boston, p 209 Stafford WF (1994) Boundary Analysis in Sedimentation Velocity Experiments. Methods in Enzymology. In: Johnson ML, Brand L (eds) Numerical Computer Methods, 240, Part B. Academic Press, Orlando, p 478–501 Börger L, Lechner MD, Stadler M (2004) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 127:19–25 Beauchamp KG (1975) Walsh functions and their applications. Academic Press, Inc. London Lebedev AA (1930) Polarization interferometer and its applications. Rev d’ Opt 9:385–417
8. Tsvetkov VN (1989) Rigid-Chain Polymers. Plenum, New York 9. Brillouin M (1903) Compt Rend 137:786 10. Frenkel SY, Lavrenko PN (1983) Measurement of refractive index gradients. In: Ioffe BV (ed) Refractometric Methods in Chemistry. Khimiya, Leningrad, p 276–305 (in Russian) 11. Lavrenko P, Lavrenko V, Tsvetkov V (1999) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 113:14–22 12. Görnitz E, Linow K-J (1992) In: Harding SE, Rowe AJ, Horton JC (eds) Analytical ultracentrifugation in biochemistry and polymer science. The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, p 26
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 29–32 DOI 10.1007/2882_003 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 4 February 2006
Joachim Behlke Otto Ristau
Joachim Behlke (u) · Otto Ristau Max Dellbrück Center for Molecular Medicine, Robert-Rössle-Str. 10, 13125 Berlin, Germany e-mail:
[email protected]
D A T A A N A L Y SI S A N D MO D E L I N G
A New Possibility to Recognize the Concentration Dependence of Sedimentation Coefficients
Abstract The binding constants of self-associating proteins can be determined from sedimentation velocity runs using the numerical solution of the Lamm equation. This procedure requires good starting values of sedimentation and diffusion coefficients or their possible concentration dependencies. We found, based on fits of synthetic data files, a connection between the concentration dependence of sedimentation coefficients (ks ) and the estimated
Introduction Analytical ultracentrifugation is a powerful tool to study self-association of proteins. This technique is especially important to study enzymes that regulate their biological function though changes of their quaternary structure e.g. in [1, 2]. The classical approaches to study selfassociation events are using the sedimentation equilibrium or the concentration dependent analysis of weight average sedimentation coefficients, the so-called isotherm method [3]. An additional method to obtain association constants is based on the shape analysis of sedimentation velocity profiles [4–7], which can be performed rapidly from a single sedimentation velocity run. A disadvantage of this technique compared to a conventional sedimentation equilibrium approach is the fit of multiple parameters (sedimentation and diffusion coefficients) while suitable start values should be available. Moreover, one has to consider that the latter parameters can depend on the concentration. The concentration dependence of sedimentation coefficients which is described in the equation sc = s0 /(1 + ks c) has been shown by different laboratories [8–11]. The influence of not correctly consid-
radius position at the cell base (rb ). Deviation of the estimated rb value from the expected one is indicating the occurrence of ks that can be estimated by the program LammNum as a prerequisite for the calculation of reliable binding constants. Keywords Sedimentation velocity · Lamm equation · Binding constants · Concentration dependence of sedimentation coefficients
ered ks values to other parameters e.g. the estimated apparent position of bottom radius (rb ) has not been investigated yet. In this short communication we describe the influence of ks on rb and the possibility to predict a concentration dependence of s from the estimated rb values.
Methodical Approach When analyzing sedimentation velocity profiles of single species with or without association it is important to examine the curves whether a distinct concentration dependence of s has to be considered. In order to find a reliable criterion between ks and other hydrodynamic parameters we have simulated concentration gradients with different ks values using the finite element method based on the approach developed by Schuck [5]. Taking the law of mass action into account cw T
= cM +
i=n i=2
ciM K iw
(1)
30
J. Behlke · O. Ristau
with cw T the total weight concentration, cM the monomer concentration or K iw the weight related equilibium constant and using the relations for spherical shaped complexes. si = i 2/3 sM Di = i
−1/3
(2) DM
for the constituent sedimentation or diffusion coefficients follows i=n 2/3 w i−1 1+ i K i cM i=2 (3) s(cw ) = sM i=n w i−1 1+ K i cM
Results The fit procedure of synthetic data files for a monomerdimer equilibrium with a monomer molecular mass of 32.1 kDa and a ks value of 0.01 L/g yields a small discrepancy with respect to the dimer association constant when the concentration dependence of s is ignored (Fig. 1). This becomes more apparent for substances with lower or higher affinity to form self-associates. However, when the ks value is elevated up to 0.025 L/g and is not considered in the fit procedure the obtained difference from the ex-
i=2
1+ D(cw ) = DM
i=n
i−1 i 2/3 K iw cM
i=2 i=n
1+
i=2
(4) i−1 iK iw cM
The concentration dependence of sedimentation coefficient s(cw ) (Eq. 3) is approximately described by the dependence of the monomer sedimentation coefficient on the total weight concentration according to (Eq. 5). 1+ s(cw ) = sM /(1 + kS cw T)
i=n
i−1 i 2/3 K iw cM
i=2 i=n
1+
i=2
.
(5)
i−1 K iw cM
Data Acquisition
Fig. 1 Estimated dimer association constants for an assumed protein (M = 32.1 kDa, loading cw = 1 g/L). The fit procedure of synthetic data files (sedimentation velocity profiles generated with ks = 0.01 L/g) with the program LammNum (7) but without consideration of ks . The molecular weight was kept constant during the fit. The dotted line represents identity of observed with expected binding constants
We have generated a series of data files with the parameters s = 3 S, D = 8.44 F, ( f/ f 0 = 1.2) and dimer association constants of 100, 13.5, 4.5, 1.5, 0.5, 0.15 (L/g) and zero (no association). The ks values (Eq. 5) vary from 0.01, 0.025, 0.05, 0.075 until 0.1 L/g. The loading concentration is cw = 1 g/L and the molecular mass M = 32.1 kDa. Curve Fitting Synthetic data files were fitted using the program LammNum [7] that also allows estimating the radius position at meniscus and cell bottom. Each data set was fitted from the meniscus up to the crossing point of the concentration profiles. This radius position was used as starting bottom radius for fit. The steep bottom region, which is very likely described inaccurate by Eq. 5, was ignored. In all fits the molecular mass of 32.1 kDa was kept constant.
Fig. 2 Estimated dimer association constants for the same protein as in Fig. 1 and with the same fit conditions, but the data files were generated with ks = 0.025 L/g, which again was ignored in the fit procedure. As in Fig. 1 the dotted line shows agreement of observed and expected binding constants
A New Possibility to Recognize the Concentration Dependence of Sedimentation Coefficients
31
Table 1 Estimated hydrodynamic parameters for a self-associating protein (monomer-dimer) with a molecular mass of 32.1 kDa (kept constant during the fit). The dependence of sedimentation constant on ks (Eq. 5) was not considered during the fit. The loading concentration was cw = 1 g/L
sideration of ks . This is also true for non-interacting single species.
ks (L/g)
Our results are showing a relationship between ks the parameter which describes the strength of concentration dependence of sedimentation coefficients and the estimated apparent bottom radius position rb for sedimentation velocity experiments. To identify a distinct ks value is an important and necessary step in the fit procedure when estimating binding constants from sedimentation velocity runs. Neglecting of ks can lead to considerable divergence in the estimated parameters, e.g. binding constants etc. Our program LammNum allows the estimation of rb and therefore has the possibility to indicate a distinct concentration dependence of s. This can be used to obtain more reliable binding constants. When in praxis the estimated apparent bottom radius is distinct lower than the radius found in the 3000 rpm run the simultaneous estimation of ks may be necessary. In our analysis we have considered a broad range of ks data between 0.01 and 0.1 L/g and we have to discuss which of the values are realistic. As known from the literature one can expect nearly 0.01 L/g [10, 11] for globular proteins. More extended molecules possesses a clearly higher value [8] due to the increased surface. This seems to be valid also for globular proteins with a tail of unordered structure in the N- or C-terminal sequence of polypeptides, which usually can not be recognized in the X-ray crystal structure [12]. Furthermore, one has to expect a ks > 0.01 L/g for contributions of net charge when the chosen solvent conditions are far from the isoelectric point of a protein and not sufficient neutral salts are present. For all these cases the above mentioned procedure is helpful to estimate reliable parameters from sedimentation velocity runs using the program LammNum [7].
0.01
0.025
0.05
0.075 0.1
Bottom 7.20 radius (cm)
7.1967
7.193
7.188
7.183 7.182
Meniscus 6.2 radius (cm)
6.2
6.2
6.2
6.2
Sediment const. (S)
3.0
2.956
2.89
2.795
2.719 2.655
Diffusion const. (F)∗
8.44
8.317
8.14
7.864
7.650 7.470
Binding constant (L/g)
100
147
301
2673
4620
Frictional ratio
1.2
1.218
1.244
1.288
1.324 1.356
∗
0.00
6.2
1.1 × 109
F = 10−7 cm2 s−1
pected dimer association constant can vary up to multiple orders of a magnitude (Fig. 2). As we could demonstrate furthermore not only is the association constant different from the actual ones but also other hydrodynamic parameters vary when the real ks value in (Eq. 5) is ignored, (see Table 1). It is also striking that a substance unspecific parameter, e.g. the position of bottom radius is estimated incorrectly. This observation led to the conclusion that the estimated bottom radius could be an indicator for a distinct concentration dependence of sedimentation coefficients. As shown in Table 1 the estimated rb value is found to be to low when analyzing a self-associating protein without con-
Discussion
References 1. Behlke J, Heidrich K, Naumann M, Müller E-C, Otto A, Reuter R, Kriegel T (1998) Biochemistry 37:11989 2. Golbik R, Naumann M, Otto A, Müller E-C, Behlke J, Reuter RR, Hübner G, Kriegel TM (2001) Biochemistry 40:1083 3. Frigon RP, Timasheff SN (1975) Biochemistry 14:4559
4. Claverie J-M, Dreux H, Cohen R (1975) Biopolymers 14:1685 5. Schuck P (1998) Biophys J 75:1503 6. Schuck P (2003) Analytical Biochem 320:104 7. Behlke J, Ristau O (2005) LAMMNUM: A Program to Study Self-Associating Macromulecules in Sedimentation Velocity Experiments.
In: Scott DJ, Harding SE (eds) Modern Analytical Ultracentrifugation: Techniques and Methods. Royal Society of Chemistry UK p 122–132 8. Rowe AJ (1992) The Concentration Dependence of Sedimentation. In: Harding SE, Rowe AJ, Horton JC (eds) Analytical Ultracentrifugation in Biochemistry and Polymer Science p 394–406
32
9. Adams ET Jr (1992) Sedimentation Coefficients of Self-Associating Species. In: Harding SE, Rowe AJ, Horton JC (eds) Analytical Ultracentrifugation in Biochemistry and Polymer Science p 407–427 10. Teller DC (1973) Characterization of Proteins by Sedimentation Equilibrium
J. Behlke · O. Ristau
in the Analytical Ultracentrifuge. In: Hirs CHW, Timasheff SN (eds) Methods in Enzymology, Vol XXVII. Academic Press, New York, p 346 11. Kumosinski TF, Pessen H (1985) Structural Interpretation of Hydrodynamic Measurements of Proteins in Solution through
Correlations with X-Ray Data. In: Hirs CHW, Timasheff SN (eds) Methods in Enzymology, Vol 117. Academic Press, New York, p 154 12. Pikuleva IA, Tesh K, Waterman MR, Kim Y (2000) Arch Biochem Biophys 373:44
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 33–40 DOI 10.1007/2882_004 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 15 February 2006
Emre Brookes Borries Demeler
Emre Brookes (u) The University of Texas at San Antonio, Dept. of Computer Science, San Antonio, USA e-mail:
[email protected] Borries Demeler The University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, Dept. of Biochemistry, San Antonio, USA
D A T A A N A L Y SI S A N D MO D E L I N G
Genetic Algorithm Optimization for Obtaining Accurate Molecular Weight Distributions from Sedimentation Velocity Experiments
Abstract Sedimentation experiments can provide a large amount of information about the composition of a sample, and the properties of each component contained in the sample. To extract the details of the composition and the component properties, experimental data can be described by a mathematical model, which can then be fitted to the data. If the model is nonlinear in the parameters, the parameter adjustments are typically performed by a nonlinear least squares optimization algorithm. For models with many parameters, the error surface of this optimization often becomes very complex, the parameter solution tends to become
Introduction A commonly used approach for determining observable parameters from experimental sedimentation data involves building a mathematical model describing the transport of macromolecular species in the ultracentrifugation cell. In such a model, every feature of the system under study which results in an observable signal such as a change in absorbance is described by an adjustable parameter in the model. The parameters are adjusted by a fitting method that seeks to minimize the difference between the model and the experimental data in a least squares sense: Min
n
[yi − Yi (P)]2
(1)
i
Here, yi represents each experimental data point i, and Yi (P) represents the corresponding data point simulated
trapped in a local minimum and the method may fail to converge. We introduce here a stochastic optimization approach for sedimentation velocity experiments utilizing genetic algorithms which is immune to such convergence traps and allows high-resolution fitting of nonlinear multi-component sedimentation models to yield distributions for sedimentation and diffusion coefficients, molecular weights, and partial concentrations. Keywords Analytical ultracentrifugation · Genetic algorithms · Sedimentation velocity analysis
by the model as described by parameter vector P. Models that are linear with respect to their parameters can be fitted by a generalized linear least squares approach in a single iteration, while models that are nonlinear with respect to their parameters have to be fitted in an approach that iteratively adjusts all parameters to an optimal value. The optimal parameter combination Pˆ represents those parameters that minimize Eq. 1. For highly nonlinear problems, models with many parameters, and parameters that exhibit a high degree of correlation, the error surface described by Eq. 1 can be very complex and contain many local minima which tend to trap the optimization process. For such cases, conventional gradient descent methods such as Gauss-Newton, Levenberg-Marquardt, and quasi-Newton commonly will fail to converge to the global minimum, and will provide less than optimal solutions for the fit. Other problems associated with direct fitting of experimental data relate to the selection of the correct model
34
function. Here, user input is required which introduces an unavoidable bias into the approach. To circumvent such caveats, other methods not relying on nonlinear least squares fitting have been explored. Not unexpectedly, each method exhibits both advantages and shortcomings. We will briefly review three popular methods for the analysis of sedimentation velocity experiments. Graphical transformations of sedimentation velocity data were introduced by van Holde and Weischet [1] and later refined [2]. This approach yields model-independent, diffusion-corrected sedimentation coefficient distributions. However, diffusion coefficients and molecular weights, or frictional parameters can not be reliably obtained by this method. In another model-independent approach, Stafford [3] introduced time-differencing of sedimentation velocity profiles to transform sedimentation velocity data to g(s) profiles. The main advantage of this approach is its capability to eliminate time-invariant noise contributions. Here too, molecular weights and diffusion coefficients are unavailable and sedimentation distributions are not deconvoluted from diffusion without further nonlinear least squares fitting. The C(s) method [4] avoids a multi-dimensional nonlinear least squares fit by linearizing the problem over the sedimentation coefficient domain using a constant frictional ratio f/ f 0 to provide corresponding diffusion coefficients. In the latter approach, a linear combination of finite element solutions to the Lamm equation [5] are fitted to the experimental data. The NNLS algorithm [6] is used to fit the linear coefficients of each term. The method finds all non-negative contributions, the remaining terms are set to zero. In an iterative approach, the frictional coefficient (which makes this problem nonlinear) can be fitted as well, reducing the problem to a wellconditioned one-dimensional search. Because a frictional coefficient is available, diffusion coefficients can also be obtained from the fit and can be used to determine molecular weights. This approach works well for those systems where all components have very nearly the same frictional properties, and can be equally well described by a single frictional ratio. Such cases may be present when all components in the system are globular proteins. However, when components of appreciably different frictional ratios are present, such as mixtures of globular proteins with different length aggregates, fibrils, extended DNA molecules, random coil conformations, or mixtures of any of the above, and complexes with intermediate frictional properties, a single frictional ratio will yield suboptimal results and is insufficient to describe the entire system accurately. When parameters from such a system are determined with the C(s) method, the determined molecular weights will be unreliable if only a single frictional coefficient is used to represent all components. Therefore, for such systems it is important to allow the frictional ratio or the diffusion coefficients to be adjusted independently for all components. Table 1 summarizes the results obtained from the analysis of a non-interacting mixture (Fig. 1) of a linear
E. Brookes · B. Demeler
Table 1 Comparison between sedimentation velocity methods. Data analysis parameters from the finite element and C(s) fitting method, and the van Holde–Weischet method. Molecular weights (Mw ) in parentheses indicate theoretical molecular weight Model
s20,W D20,W f/ f0 Mw (kD) Species (×10−13 ) (×10−7 )
Finite Element Fit, RMSD: 4.60 × 10−3
5.43 1.71
C(s) Fit, RMSD: 5.19 6.26 × 10−3 2.45 van Holde– Weischet
5.35 1.87
2.28 10.2
3.1 1.29
3.67
2.29∗
5.45
1.75∗
N/A N/A
N/A N/A
128.8 (130.7) 14.6 (14.4) 76.65 (130.7) 39.67 (14.4) N/A N/A
DNA Lysozyme DNA Lysozyme DNA Lysozyme
∗
Frictional ratios are corrected for the partial specific volume of DNA and lysozyme, respectively
208 basepair DNA molecule and a small globular protein (lysozyme), with three different approaches: 1. a nonlinear least squares fitting approach of finite element solutions to the Lamm equations (overlays are shown in Fig. 1), 2. the C(s) method, and 3. by the van Holde–Weischet method (results from all three methods are combined in Fig. 2). Results from the nonlinear least squares fitting with finite element solutions of the Lamm equation allow parameters from both components in the system to be adjusted independently, and are in excellent agreement with the known molecular weights of the two components. As expected, two very different frictional ratios are observed. While the van Holde–Weischet method results in sedimentation coefficients closely matching the nonlinear least squares fitting
Fig. 1 Sedimentation velocity data of a 208 bp linear DNA fragment and lysozyme fitted to a finite element solution of a twocomponent non-interacting model. Such a mixture is representative of a system that exhibits two very different frictional ratios in a single experiment. Experimental datapoints are represented by open circles, the finite element solution is shown as continuous lines. Parameters for this fit are shown in Table 1
Genetic Algorithm Optimization
Fig. 2 Sedimentation velocity analysis of the two-component system shown in Fig. 1 by the C(s) method (regularization with F-ratio of 95%, solid line, no regularization: line with upside-down triangles, RMSD = 0.0063), the van Holde–Weischet analysis (line with filled circles) and the direct boundary fit with the finite element method (stars, RMSD = 0.0046). Due to the difference in frictional ratio, the C(s) method fails to provide reliable sedimentation coefficient distributions, while the van Holde–Weischet method approximates more closely the sedimentation coefficients observed in the finite element direct boundary fitting method
results, molecular weight information or shape information is not available. When the C(s) method is used in conjunction with an adjustable frictional ratios, the ratio obtained can by design only represent the best average between the two species, and is therefore too high for lysozyme, and too low for DNA. When analyzed with no regularization, the C(s) method will introduce artifactual peaks around the lysozyme peak, and when regularization with an F-ratio of 0.95 is used, the peak is strongly broadened and the peak appears off-center. Furthermore, the C(s) analysis results in an RMSD 36% higher than the RMSD from the finite element fit. When the frictional ratio is combined with the sedimentation coefficient distribution, this value results in incorrect molecular weights for both species. Even after correction with the appropriate partial specific volumes the molecular weight of lysozyme is predicted too high, while the molecular weight of the DNA molecule is predicted too low. Therefore, we conclude that for systems involving components with different frictional ratios the C(s) method is not the appropriate approach. In addition, using a constant frictional term for the description of all species in the cell further complicates the interpretation of the results when molecules with different densities are examined (for example, mixtures of nucleic acids and nucleic acid binding proteins). From the results shown in Table 1 it may appear that the nonlinear least squares fitting approach with finite element solutions of the Lamm equation will provide the best information possible. In the example shown here, a bimodal
35
fit clearly results in a satisfactory solution, but this result will not be observed in the general case. The same approach will almost always fail for cases where more than 2 or 3 components are fitted and all relevant parameters are adjusted simultaneously (data not shown). The reason for this failure can be traced to the nonlinear least squares fitting approaches which are very sensitive to initial parameter guesses and the presence of local minima in the error surface of the fitting function. The problem becomes especially apparent when many nonlinear parameters are present, or the parameters are highly correlated. Such circumstances result in very complex error surfaces and often prevent convergence at the global minimum. Our goal is therefore to provide a method that combines a modelindependent approach with the generality of directly and independently fitting each parameter’s sedimentation and diffusion coefficient with an optimization method robust enough to reliably identify global minima in the error surface described by a multi-dimensional parameter space.
Proposed Method Here we propose an alternative approach to the global parameter optimization by nonlinear least squares fitting by introducing stochastic methods for parameter estimation. Stochastic methods do not rely on gradient descent in the error surface to find the best-fit solution, but instead introduce a random parameterization of the search space which allows the methods to probe for solutions by randomly placing parameter values within a constrained domain. Although these methods are computationally more expensive, they allow the solution to escape or ignore local minima and provide a higher likelihood of finding the global minimum. Several approaches employing stochastic parameter estimation have been explored, among them are genetic algorithms (GA) [7–9], Monte Carlo methods and simulated annealing methods [10, 11]. For our study, we chose to explore Monte Carlo methods and GAs. A Monte Carlo approach is based on randomly selecting parameters from the search space, simulating a model function based on these parameters, and evaluating the fitness function. However, there is no particular bias towards any solution, so if the search space is very large, the computational effort can be prohibitive because the entire space needs to be evaluated. When GAs are employed, a bias is introduced to the generic Monte Carlo approach by implementing a selection process analogous to natural selection in evolution. An initial random population of individuals is simulated, and each individual’s fitness is evaluated and the population is allowed to evolve. Parameter vectors are treated as genes which can exchange or modify parameters (bases) by crossover with other parameter vectors or by mutation, insertion or deletion operators. Multiple populations (demes) can evolve independently, or experience a controlled migration rate, which allows for exchange of
36
E. Brookes · B. Demeler
parameter information among multiple demes. Evolution of the best fit parameter combination within a population is controlled by a multi-generational selection process, which favors survival of individuals with a better fit. The survival pressure, migration rate, crossover frequency, mutation, insertion and deletion probability can be independently controlled by random number operators, and each probability rate needs to be optimized for best efficiency. The fitness function is given by the l 2 -norm of Eq. 1: n 1 (2) [yi − Yi (P)]2 . n i
Description of the Algorithm The algorithm proceeds as follows: To limit the search to a reasonable domain, the search space is initialized with a model-independent approach. We found that the van Holde–Weischet analysis [1, 2] best serves this requirement by providing a lower and upper limit of the sedimentation space, and by providing an approximate number of species in the system. Using the number of estimated components and the sedimentation coefficient range, the search space is partitioned accordingly, and a set of random individuals are initialized with sedimentation coefficients randomly selected between the limits projected by the van Holde–Weischet method. In order to form a complete parameter set for a given species j, a diffusion coefficient is needed as well. We chose to initialize diffusion coefficients based on a reasonable range of frictional coefficient ratios κ j as a parameter to the sedimentation coefficient s for each species in the system. Equation 3 shows the formula used to calculate the diffusion coefficient for species j: 9s j κ j ν¯ η −1/2 −1 D j (s, κ j ) = RT(Nκ j 6πη) (3) 2(1 − ν¯ ρ) and 1.0 ≤ κ j ≤ κmax , where R is the gas constant, T the temperature in Kelvin, N is Avogadro’s number, η is the viscosity of the solvent, ρ is the density of solvent, and rˆ is the partial specific volume of the molecule. Here, κ j is assigned a random value in a reasonable range for the system under study. For globular proteins, we suggest values between 1.0 and 3.0, for linear DNA fragments κmax values as high as 15 are appropriate. The size of this initial set can vary between 50–500 individuals in each deme, and several demes can evolve simultaneously, depending on computational resources. Each pair of sedimentation and diffusion coefficients is used to calculate a finite element solution for the experimental conditions [12] with a unity concentration factor. The NNLS algorithm [6] is used to solve Eq. 4, where C is the vector of coefficients c j for each species j, and L is the matrix of Lamm equations used to model
each individual component. The values of c j correspond to the relative concentration of each species in the linear combination that forms an individual in the deme. CL(s j , κ j ) ≈ B .
(4)
A fitness value is then computed for each individual in the population using the l 2 -norm shown in Eq. 2. At this point, the first generation is completed and the GA is used to calculate the next generation. For each individual, progeny is generated by applying the GA operators on the parameter sets defining the individuals. Selection takes place by preferentially discarding individuals which display a poor fit, and maintaining the best individuals in the population. It is important to avoid dominance of one particular individual by always maintaining a range of fitness in the population, which will assure diversity in the parameter pool. The next generation is created by applying the GA operators to the selected individuals. Each operator is controlled by a probabilistic rate constant. Here, the deletion operator may delete a species from an individual, or a new species is added to an individual. Individuals containing fewer species are assigned a higher selection rate than individuals with more species and the same fitness value in order to reflect the lower computational cost of reproduction. Mutation operators may change the value of any one species’ sedimentation or diffusion coefficient, and the crossover operator allows two parental individuals to randomly exchange information encoding one or more species. The fitness of the individuals in the new generation is again evaluated, and the process is repeated until convergence is approached. Once the solution reaches an optimum, a nonlinear least squares optimization routine can be applied to quickly find the estimated global minimum in the vicinity of the GA solution. Once the solution is in the vicinity of the global minimum, any gradient descent will perform much more quickly in locating the global minimum, since the error surface is generally well conditioned in this much reduced parameter space. To alleviate the computational demand for solving this stochastic problem, we have implemented the GA on a parallel architecture using SUSE Linux 64 on a 44-node opteron cluster at the Department of Biochemistry at the University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio [13].
Results and Discussion A typical problem that may be faced in a laboratory is the analysis of a DNA binding protein complex, with some free DNA and free protein present in the mixture. If the association kinetics are sufficiently slow, such a system can be simulated with a noninteracting model and will present a situation where all components will have different frictional ratios: A large frictional ratio for the free DNA, a globular frictional ratio for the free protein, and an intermediate frictional ratio for the complex. To ver-
Genetic Algorithm Optimization
37
ify the capability of the proposed method, we simulated such a system and added noise of comparable quality to that observed in the XL-A analytical ultracentrifuge to the solution. The parameters for this 3-species system are listed in Table 2. Data analysis results from the van Holde–Weischet method, the C(s) method, and the GA optimization are presented in Fig. 3. As can be seen from this Figure, the results from the GA are nearly identical with the parameters used in the original simulation. We further compared the results from different speed simulations (20, 40 and 60 krpm, data not shown) and from globally fitting all three speeds simultaneously. Table 3 lists the results from these experiments and indicates the errors between the simulated parameters and the parameters determined with the GA optimization. The results suggest that the highest speed provides the most reliable information for the partial concentration and sedimentation parameters, as long as enough signal for the fastest component can be collected. Adding slower speeds to a global multi-speed fit further improved the optimized paTable 2 Parameters used for the simulation of the 3- and 8-species velocity experiments. For the 8-species system, parameters were chosen to determine if components with the same molecular weight, but different shapes (species 6 and 8) and species with closely spaced sedimentation and diffusion coefficients (species 3 and 4) can be resolved. Also, the components were broadly spaced in s and molecular weight, to determine the limits of the method in its ability to resolve multiple species, even if they are closely spaced Model
Partial s concentration
3 species, 1 0.3 3 species, 2 0.2 3 species, 3 0.8 8 species, 1 0.1 8 species, 2 0.2 8 species, 3 0.3 8 species, 4 0.4 8 species, 5 0.3 8 species, 6 0.2 8 species, 7 0.1 8 species, 8 0.15
4.238 ×10−13 5.943 ×10−13 9.023 ×10−13 2.481 ×10−13 3.707 ×10−13 4.587 ×10−13 5.063 ×10−13 1.053 ×10−12 7.827 ×10−13 1.294 ×10−12 1.760 ×10−12
D
7.343 ×10−7 1.622 ×10−7 1.872 ×10−7 1.080 ×10−6 6.423 ×10−7 4.416 ×10−7 3.147 ×10−7 9.651 ×10−8 1.514 ×10−7 1.502 ×10−7 3.405 ×10−7
Molecular f/ f 0 Weight (kD) 50
1.203
198
3.765
298
2.754
20
1.112
50
1.375
90
1.644
140
1.994
945
3.435
450
2.809
750
2.389
450
1.249
Fig. 3 Sedimentation coefficient distributions reported by various data analysis methods when applied to the simulated 3-species system shown in Table 2 (60 krpm). Shown are the target values from the simulation (stars), the van Holde–Weischet analysis (dotted line), the C(s) analysis without regularization applied (solid line) and the results from the genetic algorithm (vertical bars). Residual bitmaps for the C(s) fit and the genetic algorithm fit are shown in insert on top left. The characteristic diagonal indicating systematic deviations that can be seen in the C(s) analysis bitmap is absent in the genetic algorithm fit, indicating that a more appropriate fit is obtained with the genetic algorithm that allows for a variation in the frictional ratio
rameters. To further test the capabilities of this method, we attempted to identify the components of an 8-species system, where the components cover a large range of molecular weights. Simultaneously, we wanted to challenge the resolving power of this method by simulating a system where two components may share the same molecular weight, but have markedly different frictional ratios. Such a condition may be presented by a system undergoing a conformational isomerization, an example may be a folded protein with a fraction of the protein in an unfolded or improperly folded state. A system displaying both heterogeneity in sedimentation and in frictional properties may be presented by aggregating proteins forming fibrils and other extended structures. The simulation parameters for the 8-component system are listed in Table 2, the results for the fit and errors are shown in Table 4, and a comparison of the partial concentrations and calculated molecular weights with those from the target distribution is shown in Fig. 4. Here, the results suggest that the method can resolve well 8 components with disparate frictional ratios extending over a large sedimentation coefficient range. While sedimentation coefficients and partial concentrations are reproduced most reliably, the resolution of diffusion coefficients can be impaired when species with similar sedimentation coefficients but diverging diffusion coefficients are present. In all cases we compared evolutions spanning 100 generations and 500 individuals
38
E. Brookes · B. Demeler
Table 3 Parameters obtained from the average of 25 runs of 100 generations of the GA optimization for the simulated 3-species system shown in Table 2. The same system was simulated with a speed of 20 krpm (GA fit RMSD: 5.74 × 10−3 ), 40 krpm (GA fit RMSD: 5.79 × 10−3 ), and 60 krpm (GA fit RMSD: 5.84 × 10−3 ). We show here the results from the 60 krpm experiment and the results from the global fit of multiple speeds (20, 40 and 60 krpm, GA fit RMSD: 4.05 × 10−3 ). As can be seen from these results, not only is the overall percent error for parameter determinations smaller for a global multi-speed analysis, but the RMSD of the fit is smaller as well, indicating a better fit. The highest increase in accuracy results from the improvements in the estimation of the diffusion coefficients. We speculate that the longer run times in the low speed runs improve the signal for the diffusion and hence provide additional information to the global fit allowing a higher accuracy for diffusion determinations. Each run took approximately 7 minutes using 1 CPU Parameter
60 krpm
% Error
20/40/ 60 krpm
% Error
Concentration 1: Concentration 2: Concentration 3: Sed. Coeff. 1:
0.2946 0.2047 0.8009 4.228 ×10−13 5.915 ×10−13 9.021 ×10−13 7.239 ×10−7 1.899 ×10−7 1.890 ×10−7
− 1.80% + 2.35% − 0.11% − 0.24% ×10−13 − 0.47% ×10−13 − 0.02% ×10−13 − 1.42% ×10−7 + 17.01% ×10−7 + 0.96% ×10−7
0.2989 0.1998 0.8010 4.236
− 0.37% − 0.10% + 0.13% − 0.05%
5.934
− 0.15%
9.016
− 0.08%
7.358
+ 0.20%
1.6250
+ 0.19%
1.875
0.16%
Sed. Coeff. 2: Sed. Coeff. 3: Diff. Coeff. 1: Diff. Coeff. 2: Diff. Coeff. 3:
and 410 demes. At this point a well isolated solution had emerged in all cases, and further iterations did not improve the fit. It should be noted that the RMSD values from all individuals in each iteration provide a statistical sampling of the parameter space which can be used in place of Monte Carlo analysis results. An example of such a parameter distribution is shown in Fig. 5 for the sedimentation coefficient distributions of the 8-component system. We further observed a trend in the speed of convergence. For the case of the 3 component system, we noticed that convergence was most rapidly obtained in the 20 krpm and the global 20/40/60 krpm fits, followed by the 40 krpm fit, and then trailed by the 60 krpm fit. While all fits resulted in a convergence with essentially the same RMSD, the relative performance at different speeds suggests that different experimental speeds result in varying signal strengths that can be distinguished by the GA. The performance of a GA is measured by the rate of convergence to a target solution. Tuning the parameters controlling the GA has a major impact on performance. Let N be the popu-
Table 4 Parameters obtained from the GA optimization for the 8-species system shown in Table 2 simulated with 60 krpm. At 60 krpm the errors for the sedimentation coefficient are much smaller than for the diffusion coefficient, indicating a stronger signal from sedimentation than diffusion. The resolution of the method is limited for diffusion coefficients when the species sediment very close together, even when the diffusion coefficients are far apart (species 8, see discussion). This multi-deme run took approximately 10 hours using 44 CPUs Species
Concentration
s
D
1
0.100379 (− 0.38%) 0.198768 (- 0.62%) 0.306232 (+ 2.08%) 0.394280 (− 1.43%) 0.198518 ( − 0.74%) 0.301060 (+ 0.35%) 0.099526 (− 0.47%) 0.151501 (+ 1.00%)
2.49 × 10−13 (+ 0.36%) 3.69 × 10−13 (− 0.46%) 4.61 × 10−13 (+ 0.50%) 5.06 × 10−13 (− 0.06%) 7.80 × 10−13 (− 0.34%) 1.05 × 10−13 (+/− 0.0%) 1.29 × 10−13 (− 0.46%) 1.75 × 10−13 (− 0.62%)
1.062 × 10−6 (− 1.67%) 6.190 × 10−7 (− 3.63%) 4.190 × 10−7 (− 5.12%) 3.290 × 10−7 (+ 4.54%) 1.370 × 10−7 (− 9.51%) 1.000 × 10−7 (+ 3.62%) 1.600 × 10−7 (+ 6.52%) 5.340 × 10−7 (+ 56.83%)
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
lation size times the number of generations. N is the total number of individuals tested throughout the run and is approximately proportional to the total running time. We evaluated the effect of several factors impacting the performance of the GA. First, we compared the performance of a small population and a large number of generations to the performance of a large population with a small number of generations. At the extremes, a population size of one with N generations would be useless, and a population size of N with one generation would be equivalent to random guessing. Neither case is optimal as can be seen from the results presented in Table 5. Next, we considered crossover and mutation rates together. In crossover, parts from two good individuals are taken and combined to create a new individual for the next generation. Mutation is applied by taking one individual and adding randomness to one or more parameters in this individual to create a new individual for the next generation. Naively, one may want high rates for both crossover and mutation operators, but our total population size is restricted, so high rates of mutation would hide any crossover benefit. Preliminary results indicate that crossover likely provides a benefit in finding solutions to sedimentation velocity experiments. From this data it is clear that the GA method affords remarkable resolution in partial concentration, sedimentation and diffusion coefficient determination for sedimentation velocity experiments. Therefore, the method
Genetic Algorithm Optimization
39
Fig. 4 Molecular Weight distribution obtained from the genetic algorithm when fitting the simulated 8-component system listed in Table 2. The simulated target values are represented by stars, the values derived from the genetic algorithm optimization are shown as vertical lines. The vertical position of the stars and the height of the lines correspond to the partial concentration of each species. As can be seen from this graph, the genetic algorithm faithfully reproduces the number of components and the partial concentration of each component in the system, and in all but one cases closely matches the molecular weight of the target. The two targets at 450 000 dalton represent two species with the same molecular weight, but different frictional ratios and sedimentation coefficients. In this case, only one of the species could be resolved correctly Table 5 Performance observed for a fixed N (N = population size × generations). Targeted is the 3-species velocity experiment. For each population size and generations pair, 25 separate GA runs were performed with different random seeds. The lowest RMSD individual is chosen from each run giving 25 individuals from which the average and best RMSD are reported. The first case of a single generation can be considered a pure Monte Carlo method since no GA operators are applied. An intermediate population and generation size results in the most consistent performance improvement Population size Generations
Average RMSD Best RMSD
1000 100 50 20 10 5 2
0.01173 0.00946 0.00932 0.00919 0.00919 0.00947 0.04487
1 10 20 50 100 200 500
0.00965 0.00902 0.00906 0.00903 0.00901 0.00901 0.01776
excells at resolving molecular weights, even for systems with a relatively large number of components. In addition, GAs gain an increase in accuracy by globally fitting experiments conducted at multiple speeds. Insertion and
Fig. 5 Monte Carlo parameter distributions derived from the 8-component genetic algorithm fit for the sedimentation coefficient distribution. Here the sedimentation coefficient distribution from the best-fit 5000 individuals are shown. The best definition is for well separated components in the center of the distribution which have the largest amplitude and the narrowest parameter spread. The best fit parameter combination is represented by the tips of each peak, and corresponds to an RMSD of 5.84 × 10−3 . The parameters at the bottom of the distribution are derived from those individuals with an RMSD similar to the RMSD of the worst individual in the top 5000 individuals. The area under each peak is exactly 5000 individuals, since all top 5000 individuals showed 8 species
deletion operators effectively and automatically control the selection of the appropriate model, removing the user bias associated with the selection of a fitting model, providing a model-independent and general approach for fitting sedimentation velocity experiments. Overall, the reproduced accuracy and resolution is unmatched by any other method available to us.
Future Outlook We are currently investigating if GAs can also be applied to determine self-association properties and equilibrium constants, and if GAs can automatically determine the appropriate model for an interacting system. Future work in this area will focus on further reducing the search space and optimizing the GA itself. While the potential of this method for resolving individual species in a sedimentation velocity experiment are obvious from the presented data, GA calculations are computationally intensive and are best performed through parallel computation. Optimization of the method itself remains a requirement before this analysis method can be adopted on a routine basis. Although a poorly optimized algorithm will eventually arrive at the global optimum, convergence rates may vary drastically. Considering the computational expense of Lamm equation evaluations, a well-tuned GA is an important requirement. Our preliminary findings indicate that factors such as population size, the number of demes and generations, the
40
E. Brookes · B. Demeler
rates for mutation, crossover, deletion, insertion, migration, and the method chosen for initialization all effect the convergence rate. Thus, we can consider these factors as parameters in a second optimization problem. Since the GA is a stochastic process, each parameter vector must be tested on multiple target systems. It is quite possible that performance tuning will suggest different search conditions for different systems, and that these parameters are dependent on the number of species, s and D distributions, and partial concentrations. Each parameter needs to be evaluated with many trials using different random seeds. We are continuing to explore this parameter space. We further propose that this method could easily be extended to also include related experiments in a global analysis such as a combined analysis of sedimentation velocity and
equilibrium experiments, and dynamic light scattering experiments. Here, the experiment can be described with a nonlinear least squares fitting model containing the same parameters used in the sedimentation velocity experiment (D and the ratio of s/D, which is proportional to molecular weight). In summary, we conclude that the GA approach excells in avoiding local minima convergence traps. From our analysis we conclude that the only limitation of the method is the signal contained in the data. As soon as changes in concentration needed for the determination of a parameter are masked by experimental noise, the limit of resolution has been reached. Highly correlated parameters such as multiple diffusion coefficients for molecules sedimenting with similar sedimentation coefficients have also proven to be difficult to resolve.
References 1. van Holde KE, Weischet WO (1978) Biopolymers 17:1387–1403 2. Demeler B, van Holde KE (2004) Anal Biochem 335(2):279–288 3. Stafford WF (2000) Methods Enzymol 323:302–25 4. Schuck P (2000) Biophys J 78(3):1606–19 5. Lamm O (1929) Ark Mat Astron Fys 21B:1–4 6. Lawson CL, Hanson RJ (1974) Solving Least Squares Problems. Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey
7. Holland JH (1975) Adaption in Natural and Artificial Systems. University of Michigan Press 8. Goldberg DE (1989) Genetic Algorithms in Search, Optimization, and Machine Learning. Addison-Wesley 9. Koza JR (1992) Genetic Programming: On the Programming of Computers by Means of Natural Selection. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA 10. Kirkpatrick S, Gelatt Jr CD, Vecchi MP (1983) Science 220:671–680
11. Cerny V (1985) J Opt Theory Appl 45/1:41–51 12. Cao W, Demeler B (2005) Modelling analytical ultracentrifugation experiments with an adaptive space-time finite element solution of the Lamm equation. Biophys J 89(3):1589–1602 13. Demeler B (2005) UltraScan version 7.1 – A Software Package for Analytical Ultracentrifugation Experiments. The University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio, Department of Biochemistry, San Antonio TX, 78229 USA http://www.ultrascan.uthscsa.edu
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 41–54 DOI 10.1007/2882_005 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 10 February 2006
Peter Zipper Helmut Durchschlag Angelika Krebs
Peter Zipper Physical Chemistry, Institute of Chemistry, University of Graz, Heinrichstrasse 28, 8010 Graz, Austria Helmut Durchschlag (u) Institute of Biophysics and Physical Biochemistry, University of Regensburg, Universitätsstrasse 31, 93040 Regensburg, Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Angelika Krebs Structural and Computational Biology Programme, European Molecular Biology Laboratory, Meyerhofstrasse 1, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany
D A T A A N A L Y SI S A N D MO D E L I N G
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin
Abstract For modeling the lowresolution shape of the dodecameric subunit of Lumbricus terrestris hemoglobin, experimental smallangle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data and ab initio modeling approaches using a genetic algorithm or simulated annealing have been applied. In addition to the use of strict ab initio approaches, procedures which additionally include available structural information concerning symmetry and shape in the form of constraints or templates have been employed to improve the results. Templates for the subunit were preferably derived from SAXS-based models for the native hexagonal bilayer (HBL) complex that were biased by electron microscopic reconstructions. The obtained subunit models were carefully examined by variation of different selection and averaging methods and other checks such as surface renderings of the models. The findings were quantified by prediction of scattering profiles, I(h) and p(r), and structural
Introduction The hexagonal bilayer (HBL) appearance of the annelid hemoglobins represents an extraordinary type of quaternary structure observed among hemoglobins [1, 2]. Their extracellular occurrence is predicated on the large molecular size that prevents loss through membranes. The most extensively studied HBL hemoglobin is that of the common earthworm Lumbricus terrestris (L.t. Hb). This
and hydrodynamic parameters (V , RG , dmax , s, D). The best matching models for the subunit were also scrutinized by comparing them to a model derived from currently available crystallographic data. The following results could be obtained: (i) The obtained parameter predictions for the dodecameric subunit are satisfactory, if compared to the SAXS data (consensus model, profiles and molecular parameters) or the results from hydrodynamic studies. (ii) The comparison between solution and crystal data of the dodecameric subunit, however, unequivocally proves a different behavior of the subunit in solution and the crystalline state. Keywords Advanced modeling techniques · Dodecameric subunit · Extracellular hemoglobin · Hydrodynamics · Small-angle X-ray scattering
giant, multisubunit molecule has a sedimentation coefficient of about 60 S and its molecular mass is likely to be 3.5 MDa. Although, in the past, a broad range of masses has been reported for L.t. Hb, recent considerations [3] provide evidence for the validity of the given mass for the HBL assembly consisting of 144 globins and 36 nonglobin linker chains. The assembled chains form a molecule with D6 symmetry [4, 5], and the validity of the previous “bracelet” model [6, 7] has been
42
proven meanwhile. 12 subassemblies of globin chains are arranged in two hexagonal layers, and, as a consequence of this assemblage, a central cavity is formed in the particle center. The linker subunits are required for HBL formation [8, 9]. Relevant information concerning the three-dimensional (3D) structure of L.t. Hb and other annelid hemoglobins mainly emerged from electron microscopy (EM) including 3D reconstructions [1, 10–15], small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) [16–20], and X-ray crystallography [21]. The dissociation behavior of L.t. Hb was investigated at extremes of pH and in the presence of several dissociating agents (e.g., [6, 7, 22–24]). A variety of dissociation and re-association experiments resulted in the observation of a 9–10 S species which was considered to represent one-twelfth protomer, an approx. 200 kDa linker-free subassembly [25, 26]. Again, EM [15, 27], SAXS [28] and crystallographic studies [29, 30] concentrated on the 3D structure of the dodecameric subunit, in particular to identify it as the putative major dissociation product. Because of its special architecture, L.t. Hb has already been subject of several modeling attempts. Previous SAXS studies aimed at the elucidation of beaded consensus models for the native HBL L.t. Hb [19] and its dodecameric subunit [28], using conventional (trial-anderror) modeling approaches. More recent studies tried to apply a variety of different modeling approaches, in order to combine and compare the results from quite different solution and nonsolution techniques. Such approaches are indispensable links between different methods, eventually enabling the critical comparison and the transfer of molecule parameters from one method to another. As a first approximation, wholebody approaches have been applied to the HBL complex of L.t. Hb [31–33] and the dodecameric subunit [32, 34, 35] as well. These simple approaches already proved the compatibility and reliability of the basic parameters applied (e.g., radius of gyration, volume, axial ratio, sedimentation coefficient, in addition to external parameters such as molar mass and partial specific volume), however, revealed slight overestimations of predicted s values [31, 32, 34]. The HBL complex has also been subject of detailed multibody approaches [20, 31, 32, 36–39], employing primarily the information from solution techniques (SAXS, hydrodynamics) and EM. In particular, several SAXS-based ab initio methods were applied, to test their capability to predict the low-resolution particle shape and structural and hydrodynamic parameters of this complex protein, utilizing either strict ab initio conditions or the advantage of additionally adopting realistic constraints or templates. Amongst the advanced modeling programs available, approaches using a genetic algorithm (GA; program DALAI_GA [40, 41]) or simulated annealing (SA; program DAMMIN [42, 43]) turned out to be especially helpful for the reconstruction of 3D solution structures [32, 38]. A crucial problem encountered with all approaches which model protein shapes in solution is the
P. Zipper et al.
problem of particle uniqueness [32, 38, 44]. For the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb only one concise modeling attempt has been performed that compared the effectiveness of a few DAMMIN results [32]. No detailed modeling attempt of the subunit or inclusion of crystallographic data has been tried up to now. The present study tries to model the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb on the basis of experimental SAXS data for the subunit [28] in a detailed way, considering numerous aspects that are of importance for ab initio modeling studies. First, the most relevant approaches (GA, SA) were applied, varying input parameters, possible constraints and EM-biased templates as well as averaging procedures over a wide range. The obtained models were controlled by surface renderings and a quantitative comparison of predicted and observed molecular parameters. These parameters comprise aspects usually considered in SAXS and analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) as well. Second, since just now the crystallographic data for the subunit [30] became available, the comparison of models derived from the 0.26 nm resolution crystal structure and those from solution scattering turned out to be a further challenging task, to validate or invalidate the models under consideration. In this context, again, various input variables and models can be tested and the influence of hydration contributions can be taken into account. The significance of the project is focused on a variety of useful modeling aspects rather than on biological data. Low-resolution shapes and molecule parameters are predicted by ab initio modeling approaches and the results obtained under various input conditions will be tested and compared to other techniques including crystallography. It is clear a priori that the anticipation of data by ab initio modeling can only provide rough shape estimates, unless accessory information is included. In particular, the results will show that the combined use of solution scattering and hydrodynamic data, in connection with 3D crystallographic information, allows various interesting aspects to be addressed.
Methods All modeling approaches described and used in the following are based on scattering curves derived from SAXS experiments or calculated from crystallographic data. The models obtained by GA or SA were used to anticipate structural and hydrodynamic parameters, after a variety of preceding steps such as selection of appropriate models, superimposing of models, and averaging procedures for the generation of proper consensus models. In some SA calculations, appropriate templates, ultimately based on 3D EM reconstructions of the native HBL complex, were used. Finally, the results obtained from the obtained consensus models were compared to available reference data.
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin
Sources of Data Scattering profiles and structural and hydrodynamic parameters of L.t. Hb and its dodecameric subunit were taken from previous papers [19, 20, 28]: SAXS data originate from measurements performed at protein concentrations, c, ranging from 5 to 53 mg/ml; the experimental scattering curves had been extrapolated to c = 0 and evaluated by the program ITP [45]; sedimentation coefficients descend from runs performed at varying c (0.04–12 mg/ml). EM-biased templates were derived from [39]. The atomic coordinates of the dodecamer were obtained from the Protein Data Bank (PDB) [46]. For calculations, primarily the following data were used: atomic coordinates, scattering intensity, I(h) [where h = (4π/λ) sin θ, θ = half the scattering angle, and λ the wavelength of the incident X-rays], pair-distance distribution function (PDDF), p(r) [where r = distance between pairs of scatterers and p(r) ≡ 0 for r values greater than the maximum particle diameter], molar mass, M, radius of gyration, RG , hydrated volume, V , maximum particle diameter, dmax , translational diffusion coefficient, D, and sedimentation coefficient, s. Modeling by Ab Initio Approaches Particularly substantial low-resolution models can be obtained by a GA or SA. (i) The program DALAI_GA [40, 41] uses an iterative fitting of scattering curves by a GA. The GA gradually explores a discrete search space and evolves convergent bead models fitting the target experimental profile upon Debye calculation of the beaded models. Modeling refinement is achieved by reducing the bead size together with the search space in successive cycles. (ii) The program DAMMIN [42, 43] is based on SA. It starts with a search space filled with densely packed dummy atoms and assigns the atoms either to the protein or the solvent. By SA an appropriate particle configuration is finally obtained that matches the experimental SAXS curve satisfactorily. For the calculation of scattering intensities of the models, the DAMMIN approach uses spherical harmonics. As primary input for the experimental data, a GNOM file [47] is required. The program may be used in the strict ab initio sense or allowing the input of additional structural information (e.g., use of symmetry constraints, expected anisometry, or a template to replace the default spherical search space). For further details the reader is referred to previous papers [20, 32, 36, 38, 39]. Selection and Averaging of Models For the alignment and superposition of best-matching 3D models as well as the subsequent averaging process, special auxiliary procedures are required.
43
In context with the application of ab initio approaches for the shape determination based on solution scattering data, usually the program package DAMAVER [44] is applied. The package comprises several subprograms and is based on the precedent program SUPCOMB [48]. In an automated analysis, initially all models are pairwise aligned and a respective dissimilarity measure is acquired for each pair. Finally all obtained model pairs are compared: a reference model is selected owing to the smallest average dissimilarity and outliers are discarded. All models remaining in the analysis are then superimposed onto the reference model and the resultant assembly is mapped onto a densely packed grid of equally sized spheres but varying occupancy factors. These factors are then exploited for the ensuing filtering of the averaged model, by neglecting grid points characterized by low occupancy. By contrast, our program DAMMIX [32] creates averaged models where either different densities of equally sized spheres or different sphere volumes (radii) are used as a probability measure; RG and in the second case also V of the models are identical to the mean values of the models used for averaging. Sorting out spheres of low probability can serve as appropriate filtering rule, concomitantly standardizing the sum of sphere volumes to the value of V , if required. While in the DAMAVER procedure the individual models become re-oriented (after shifting and rotation procedures) until an optimal overlapping of the models is achieved, the DAMMIX procedure only uses a rotation around the z axis. This implies that the DAMAVER approach is ideal for averaging pure ab initio models without any additional information, while DAMMIX is rather qualified for the generation of averaged template-biased models. Modeling of Hydration Since both SAXS curves and hydrodynamic data inherently contain already hydration contributions, no further precautions have to be adopted for applying SAXS-based modeling approaches. In principle, the program GASBOR [49, 50], a SA program similar to DAMMIN, can model water molecules and, thus, simulate hydration. Since, however, only dummy waters are used, no biophysically relevant model of a hydrated protein is obtained by this approach (cf. separate paper in this issue). A more realistic allocation of bound water is achieved, if atomic coordinates in conjunction with accurate surface calculation programs such as SIMS [51] and special hydration algorithms are applied. Our hydration programs HYDMODEL or HYDCRYST [52–56] assign specific hydration numbers, for example those obtained by Kuntz [57], to definite amino acid residues on the protein surface, so that hydrated models of biochemical relevance are achieved.
44
P. Zipper et al.
Parameter Predictions
Computational Requirements
For predicting scattering and hydrodynamic parameters of the models, in general the bead radii were upscaled by appropriate factors to account for the packing density of the beads. For averaged models, additionally, a rescaling of the coordinates of the beads turned out to be useful. Calculation of I(h) and p(r) profiles and molecular parameters from the coordinates of spheres were performed by programs based on algorithms described elsewhere [45, 58]. The I(h) curves of averaged models were calculated by means of Debye’s formula, applying the upscaled bead radii and rescaled coordinates; for calculating the I(h) curves of individual DAMMIN models, however, the size of the bead radii had to be reduced by the same empirical factor as in previous studies [39] to optimize the fit to the experimental I(h) and to the model scattering curves as provided directly by DAMMIN. The necessity for this different treatment is a consequence of the fact that the DAMMIN program uses spherical harmonics instead of Debye’s formula for the internal calculation of scattering curves; the resulting slight discrepancies in the tail ends of the I(h) functions calculated by the different algorithms can usually be reduced by downscaling the bead radii when applying Debye’s formula. The p(r) functions of all models were calculated as outlined by Glatter [58] from the coordinates and the upscaled radii of the beads, if applicable taking into account additionally the rescaling of bead coordinates. Hydrodynamic parameters (s, D) were obtained by applying version 13 of the program HYDRO [59, 60]. However, the dimensions of several arrays had to be increased and the input routine of the program was adapted, to allow handling of models consisting of a multitude of spheres and to ease the input steps. Our expression for the interaction tensor of overlapping spheres of unequal size [61–63] is already implemented in the used version of the program [64].
For our model calculations, personal computers with processors Intel Pentium IV (3.2 GHz and 2 GB RAM) or AMD 3000+ (2.2 GHz and 1 GB RAM) were used; for surface renderings a SGI workstation was applied. The CPU time required for the ab initio calculations depended on the program and input variables used: typical CPU times for DALAI_GA and DAMMIN varied between 2 h and 1 d. HYDRO runs with about 6800 beads took about 2 1/2 h; the calculation times for models with smaller sphere numbers were essentially lower.
Results and Discussion SAXS Experiments: Information in Reciprocal and Real Space Figure 1a illustrates the experimental scattering intensities I(h) of the native HBL complex of L.t. Hb and of its dodecameric subunit [17, 19, 28]. These scattering curves, which have been normalized to a value of I(0) = 1, represent the starting points for all subsequent creations of
Visualization of Models All obtained 3D models can be visualized by the program RASMOL [65] or any other 3D molecular graphics program. Further structural features of the models obtained can be obtained by surface representations of the models, preferably applying programs from the CCP4 package [66]. For this purpose, electron density maps were generated from the sphere coordinates and threshold levels were chosen as to furnish all models with the same volume [20]; the electron densities obtained were displayed by the program VOLVIS [67].
Fig. 1 Experimental SAXS profiles of L.t. Hb: scattering intensity, I(h), and distance distribution function, p(r), of the native HBL complex (dashed lines) and its dodecameric subunit (solid lines). For convenience, the scattering intensities are normalized to I(0) = 1, whereas the areas under the p(r) functions are proportional to the molecular mass of the particles under consideration
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin
SAXS models for the subunit and the HBL complex. Obviously, the decay of I(h) at small angles is much more pronounced for the HBL complex than for the subunit. Considering the inverse relation between particle size (real space) and the decay of scattering intensity (reciprocal space) [45], the two curves clearly reflect the different size of the two objects of interest. Moreover, the distinct submaxima in the I(h) curve of the complex suggest that this particle is rather globular and symmetric, whereas the dodecameric subunit appears to be much less isometric than the whole complex. The information in the reciprocal space, the scattering intensity I(h), can be converted to the real space by applying a Fourier transformation [45]. This procedure yields a pair-distance distribution function, p(r), which allows a much more realistic (physical) visualization of particle dimensions in terms of a distance distribution profile and a particle diameter. Figure 1b clearly reveals that all distances found for the subunit of L.t. Hb are located at small r values while those for the complex exhibit a broad distribution and, consequently, dmax of the entire HBL complex (about 30 nm) exceeds that of the subunit (about 10 nm) by far. Owing to the proper scaling of the curves, the enormous difference between the masses of the complex and the subunit is convincingly illustrated.
45
SAXS-based Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit
Fig. 2 Various SAXS models of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb presented in different views. A The trial-and-error consensus model consists of beads of equal density but different volumes (bead radii rb ≤ 0.661 nm) reflecting different probabilities of bead positions. The different probabilities are additionally expressed by different shades of gray (low probability: light gray; high probability: dark gray). The image on the right-hand side of the first row depicts a central slab of the side view. B and C The selected DALAI_GA models are the result of two different runs and correspond to bead radii of 0.95, 0.75, and 0.55 nm
The first SAXS models for the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb had been generated by trial-and-error procedures, starting from 1/12 of a previously established trial-anderror SAXS model for the entire HBL complex [17, 28]: a total of about 300 different bead models with bead radius rb = 0.661 nm were generated; eventually, 22 of them were selected for further analysis, because of their good matching the scattering behavior of the dodecameric subunit. The selected models were superimposed and averaged to yield a consensus model for the subunit. While in the original consensus model [28] the different probabilities of positions of the beads were taken into account by different weightings (i.e. different densities) of the equalsized beads, in the consensus model shown in Fig. 2A the different probabilities are represented by different volumes of beads of equal density. This way of expressing the probabilities was chosen with regard to the subsequent application of the program HYDRO [59, 60], used for the prediction of hydrodynamic parameters. HYDRO cannot make use of different densities of beads, whereas it can handle beads of different size. For better visualization, in the graphic presentation of the consensus model (Fig. 2A) the different probabilities of positions are additionally reflected by different shades of gray: the lighter the color of a bead, the lower is its probability. Mean values for the calculated structural parameters RG , V , dmax , and the hydrodynamic parameters D and s of the selected trialand-error models are presented in Table 1, together with
the values of the corresponding parameters as obtained from the averaged structure represented by the consensus model in Fig. 2A. A comparison of I(h) and p(r) profiles of the consensus model with the experimentally obtained functions is shown in Fig. 3. The good agreement between experimental and model functions (in the case of I(h) only for h ≤ 2 nm−1 ) reveals the consensus model as well as the underlying trial-and-error models to be nearly equivalent in scattering with the native particles. An interesting feature of these models is the kinked appearance that can be observed particularly in side views and corresponding central slabs (Fig. 2A). This is clearly related to the domed overall shape of the models. It should be noted that models lacking such a domed shape gave much poorer fits to the experimental scattering functions [28]. To study the efficiency of advanced modeling approaches [32, 38], we first applied the GA as implemented in the program DALAI_GA [40, 41]. In this context several runs were performed. Here we present the results obtained from two runs applying a background-corrected experimental I(h) curve as input, together with an oblate ellipsoid as initial search space and rb = 1.15 nm as initial bead radius. In each of these runs, the bead size was stepwise reduced down to rb = 0.55 nm; the upper limit of the analyzed h range of the experimental scattering curve, h max , was changed simultaneously according to the relation h max ≤ π/(2rb ). The models corresponding
46
Fig. 3 Comparison of the experimental scattering profiles, I(h) and p(r), of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb with the scattering profiles calculated from various SAXS models. The black lines signify the experimental profiles and the filled black circles the profiles of the consensus model. The colored open circles mark the averaged functions of DAMMIN models derived from modified experimental scattering curves, and the colored lines represent the scattering curves calculated for averaged DAMMIN models: blue: P1U; green: P3U:O; dark green: P3U:P; red: P3O; brown: P1T; the averaging process was performed by DAMAVER (solid lines) or by DAMMIX (dashed lines). The codes P1U, P3U:O, P3U:P, and P3U correspond to the nomenclature as used in the DAMMIN approach [42] and symbolize the absence/presence of different symmetry constraints and shape bias, while the code P1T points to a template-biased model (see text)
to rb varying between 0.95 and 0.55 nm are presented in the lower part of Fig. 2B and C. These models also exhibit a kinked shape, quite similar to the trial-and-error models. In this context it has to be mentioned that models generated by applying the DALAI_GA approach can be considered to be strictly ab initio, because, apart from the guess of the initial search space, no other a priori information is used by the program. The structural and hydrodynamic parameters of the selected DALAI_GA models are listed in Table 1. The I(h) curves calculated from these models were found to be virtually identical with the experimental curves, in the range below the respective h max . A similar, however somewhat less perfect coincidence was also proven by a comparison of calculated and experimental p(r) functions. For these reasons, the I(h) and p(r) functions of the DALAI_GA models are not shown in Fig. 3.
P. Zipper et al.
A plethora of further ab initio models for the dodecameric subunit were created by applying the SA approach implemented in the program DAMMIN [42, 43]. Owing to the extended input facilities of this program, models were generated without any symmetry constraint and shape bias (coded as P1U), with C3 symmetry as constraint but without any a priori shape bias (coded as P3U:O and P3U:P, respectively, depending on the oblate or prolate shape of the resulting model), and with C3 symmetry as constraint and preference of oblate shape as bias (coded as P3O). The majority of the ab initio DAMMIN models were obtained making use of the option for the automatic subtraction of a constant background from the experimental scattering curve. In Table 1, these models are tabulated separately from models that were derived without background subtraction. In addition to the mean values and standard deviations of the structural and hydrodynamic parameters of the various sets of ab initio models, Table 1 also presents the values that were obtained from the corresponding averaged structures generated by applying the program package DAMAVER [44] which performs a superposition and filtered averaging of a selection of models. To superimpose the models, each model, except the one which is chosen as reference model by the program, is rotated appropriately to achieve an optimal overlap. While a rescaling of the nominal bead radii rb by a factor of 1.105 (to account for the packing density of the beads) was applied with all ab initio DAMMIN models, an additional rescaling of the bead coordinates was performed in the case of the averaged models, to match the mean RG of the set of models used for averaging. A close inspection of the tabulated values for RG , V , dmax , D, and s reveals a high extent of agreement between the values obtained for different types of models (P1U, P3U:O, P3U:P, P3O), irrespective of whether individual/averaged models are considered or the data are based on the original/modified experimental scattering curve. The largest deviations are encountered between the volumes, V , of the models derived from the original experimental scattering curve and those from the modified curve. Here the application of the background correction of the scattering curve obviously favors V values that are more similar to the experimentally observed V . Smaller deviations can also be observed between the mean values for D and s of the individual P3U:P models and the values for the corresponding averaged structures. Surface representations of the averaged ab initio DAMMIN models, based on the modified experimental scattering curve, are displayed in Fig. 4. All models are shown in four views corresponding to successive 90◦ rotations around the vertical axis. The averaged I(h) and p(r) curves of the ab initio DAMMIN models derived from the modified experimental scattering curve and the I(h) and p(r) profiles of the corresponding averaged structures are presented in Fig. 3. The constant background that had been automat-
Ab initio DAMMIN models derived from the original experimental scattering curve g,f Selected models without symmetry constraint and shape bias (code P1U) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P1U models h Selected prolate models with symmetry C3 and no a priori shape bias (code P3U:P) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P3U:P models h Selected models with symmetry C3 and shape bias oblate (code P3O) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P3O models h Ab initio DAMMIN models derived from the modified experimental scattering curve e,f Selected models without symmetry constraint and shape bias (code P1U) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P1U models h Selected oblate models with symmetry C3 and no a priori shape bias (code P3U:O) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P3U:O models h Selected prolate models with symmetry C3 and no a priori shape bias (code P3U:P) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P3U:P models h 23
13
12
19
16
6
1,548±171 0.3–0.325 1,369 0.325 1,351±245 0.30–0.35 1,325 0.325 1,326±249 0.30–0.35 1,299 0.325
1,177±109 0.325 1,177 0.325 1,075±202 0.30–0.35 1,083 0.325 1,111±203 0.30–0.35 1,102 0.325
53–275 0.95–0.55
6
Consensus model: unfiltered average (obtained by DAMMIX) of the selected models Ab initio DALAI_GA models Selected models e,f d
206±2 0.661 265 0.661
33
Nb ,rb (nm)
Experimental Trial-and-error models Selected models
Nm
252±5 252
3.766
257
3.766 3.766±0.002
257±4
266
3.765 3.766±0.002
265±4
214
3.764
3.765±0.001
214±4
210
3.763 3.764±0.002
210±4
229
3.763 3.763±0.003
228±2
257±4
249
249±2
255±10
V (nm3 )
3.763±0.001
3.79±0.01
3.739
3.740±0.005
3.74±0.01
RG (nm)
11.8
11.5±0.1
11.8
11.6±0.1
11.5
11.6±0.1
11.9
11.5±0.2
11.4
11.5±0.2
11.9
11.7±0.1
10.5±0.3 12.1±0.2
10.2±0.2 11.4±0.2 10.7 c 11.1
10.6±0.0
c
c
dmax b (nm)
Table 1 Comparison of experimental and model parameters of the dodecameric subunit from Lumbricus terrestris hemoglobina
4.84
4.75±0.05
4.77
4.76±0.02
4.82
4.80±0.03
4.82
4.78±0.04
4.97
4.77±0.07
4.85
4.84±0.04
10.09
9.90±0.10
9.93
9.92±0.05
10.05
10.00±0.06
10.03
9.96±0.09
10.34
9.93±0.15
10.10
10.09±0.09
9.82±0.13
10.04
4.82
4.71±0.06
10.09±0.02
4.84±0.01
9.18–9.44
D (10−7 cm2 /s) s (10−13 s)
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin 47
5,125 0.18–0.57
1,755 0.24–0.57
179±1 0.60 483 0.60 168–309 0.60 900 0.35
48
11
1,357±243 0.30–0.35 1,066 0.35
Nb ,rb (nm)
36
Nm
3.740
3.740 4.152
255 m 333 255 m
m
m
250
267
3.798
4.074
267
267
3.798 3.798
267±2
259
3.766
3.798±0.008
258±5
V (nm3 )
3.766±0.002
RG (nm)
11.5 m
11.6 m 12.8
12.5
12.1
11.8±0.2
12.8
12.4±0.3
11.8
11.6±0.1
dmax b (nm)
4.75 m
4.79 m 4.28
4.42
4.77
4.52±0.03
4.09
4.77±0.02
4.78
4.77±0.03
9.89
m
9.98 m 8.91
9.22
9.93
9.43±0.06
8.52
9.94±0.05
9.95
9.94±0.06
D (10−7 cm2 /s) s (10−13 s)
Experimental SAXS and hydrodynamic data for the oxygenated dodecamer are taken from [28]. The SAXS data (radius of gyration, RG , hydrated volume, V , and maximum diameter, dmax ) refer to the dodecamer (obtained from urea dissociation) at infinite dilution (c = 0) and represent mean values and standard deviations of the results derived from the I(h) and p(r) functions obtained from two independent measurements yielding a molar mass of M = 190 ± 19 kg/mol. The hydrodynamic data refer to dodecamers obtained from urea and SiW dissociation, respectively, and represent sw,20 values derived from sedimentation velocity experiments at c = 0.04, 4.0, and 12.4 mg/ml. The corresponding model parameters were calculated for bead models consisting of Nb beads of radius rb . The data represent the mean values and standard deviations of Nm selected models or refer to averaged structures obtained by superimposing Nm models b If not stated otherwise, for models the value corresponding to the maximum vertex-to-vertex distance of the beads is given c Value corresponding to the maximum center-to-center distance of the beads d For the calculation of parameters, the probabilities of bead positions, resulting from superimposing the selected models, were taken into account by different bead volumes; the nominal bead radius rb given in column 3 only applies to positions of probability = 1 e For generating these models, the experimental I(h) function was modified by subtraction of a constant background f The nominal bead radii rb given in column 3 were upscaled by a factor of 1.105 to account for the packing density of the beads g For generating these models, the experimental I(h) function was not modified by subtraction of a constant background h For the calculation of parameters, the coordinates of the beads were rescaled to match the mean RG of the models used for averaging i The templates were derived from 8 EM-biased DAMMIN models of the HBL complex of L.t. Hb [39]. Each template contains 1/12 of the HBL model, starting at angular position 22.5 or 30◦ j The nominal bead radius rb given in column 3 was upscaled by a factor of 1.183 to account for the packing density of the beads in these models k These averaged structures are composed of equal-sized beads; only beads occurring in at least f min models were selected. The mean values and standard deviations of parameters were obtained by varying f min from 12 to 24, thereby applying separate optimized scaling factors for the coordinates and radii of the beads to match the mean RG and V of the 48 models used for averaging l The crystal data for the dodecamer were obtained from the Protein Data Bank (file 1X9F.PDB). For surface calculations by SIMS [51], the following input parameters were used: dot density ddot = 100 nm−2 , rprobe = 0.14 nm, water volume Vw = 0.0245 nm3 , a smoothing probe sphere, rsm = 0.04 nm, and a centerto-center distance criterion for the spacing between water and AA spheres. Hydration calculations by HYDMODEL [52–54] used the hydration numbers given by Kuntz [57] for preferentially bound water molecules, in combination with a hydration factor of f K = 1 m Parameter calculated after rescaling the coordinates and radii of the beads by two slightly different factors to match the experimental values for RG and V
a
Reduced crystal structure, hydrated (AA residues + heme groups + 3,370 H2 O obtained by SIMS and HYDMODEL)
Models derived from the crystal structure l Reduced crystal structure, anhydrous (AA residues + heme groups)
Selected models with symmetry C3 and shape bias oblate (code P3O) Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P3O models h DAMMIN models biased by templates g Selected models without symmetry constraint (code P1T) i,j Unfiltered average (obtained by DAMMIX) of the selected P1T models d,j,h Filtered averages (obtained by DAMMIX) of the selected P1T models k Filtered average (obtained by DAMAVER) of the selected P1T models j,h
Table 1 (continued)
48 P. Zipper et al.
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin
Fig. 4 Surface representations of averaged DAMMIN models of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb. The models are shown in four different views corresponding to successive 90◦ rotations around the vertical axis. The dark-gray images comprise ab initio models (P1U, P3U:O, P3U:P, P3O) and represent filtered averages produced by DAMAVER. The light-gray images illustrate models biased by templates; they correspond to filtered averages created by DAMAVER or to unfiltered averages produced by DAMMIX. The encoding items for the models are the same as given in the legend to Fig. 3. The DAMAVER package determined an optimum rotation for each of the P1T models by comparison with the model that was adopted as reference, disregarding any information about the angular position of the template applied, and without any restrictions about the rotation axes. In the approach based on DAMMIX, the rotation of each model was strictly depending on the angular position (22.5 or 30◦ ) of the underlying template and amounted to ±3.75◦ around the z direction
ically subtracted from the experimental scattering curve by DAMMIN was, of course, re-added to the scattering curves of the ab initio DAMMIN models presented in Fig. 3. A second line of DAMMIN models for the dodecameric subunit was created by using more detailed a priori shape information, imported in the form of templates ultimately based on 3D EM reconstructions of the native HBL complex of L.t. Hb [19]. Figure 5 outlines the various steps of this approach. The first two steps, the derivation of templates for the entire HBL complex from 3D reconstructions obtained from cryo-EM and the use
49
Fig. 5 Creation of models for the HBL complex of L.t. Hb models based on templates. A Template for the native HBL complex as derived from 3D EM reconstructions. B and C Sectors containing 1/12 of the EM-biased DAMMIN model of the complex can be used as templates for the DAMMIN analysis of the scattering curve of the dodecameric subunit. The patterns drawn in red and blue represent two alternative sectors. The angular positions of the two sectors are 22.5◦ (red) or 30◦ (blue), respectively. D and E Selected DAMMIN models of the dodecameric subunit and the underlying templates. The superpositions of the templates (light colors) with the resulting DAMMIN models (dark colors) of the dodecameric subunit are shown in two different views and as central slabs
of these templates for generating EM-biased DAMMIN models of the complex have already been described in detail elsewhere [39]. Eight selected DAMMIN models from the previous study, consisting of beads with rb = 0.6 nm on hexagonal lattice points, were now used to prepare appropriate templates for the dodecameric subunit. For this purpose, from each of these previously established models two slightly different sectors were taken and used as templates, each of them representing exactly 1/12 of the original DAMMIN model. One sector (drawn in Fig. 5 in red) was taken starting at angular position 22.5◦ , whereas the start position of the other sector (drawn in blue) was at 30◦ . In this way a total of 16 different templates were established, and each template was applied in at least three separate runs of the DAMMIN program. Finally, 48 different template-biased DAMMIN models for the dodecameric subunit resulted from applying this approach to the original experimental scattering curve. These models (coded as P1T) were generated without any symmetry constraint1 . Each of the P1T models represents a subset of the beads contained in the underlying template, 1
The simultaneous use of a template and a special symmetry constraint requires that the template fulfils the selected symmetry conditions strictly [39]. If, on the other hand, a symmetrical template but no symmetry constraint is applied, the resulting model will certainly not reflect the symmetry of the template perfectly.
50
without any additional beads not already occurring in the template.2 Surface representations of averaged structures derived from the P1T models are shown in the lower part of Fig. 4. The first row of these images corresponds to a filtered average as obtained by application of the DAMAVER package, the second row to an unfiltered average computed by our program DAMMIX. The appearance of the structures obtained by the two averaging approaches is obviously diverging. This is mainly caused by the differences in the procedures used for superimposing the individual models. In the resulting unfiltered averages the different probabilities of the beads were again expressed by different bead volumes, to enable the calculation of structural and hydrodynamic parameters. Alternatively, also special filtered averages were generated by applying the DAMMIX approach. For these averages, only beads occurring in at least f min P1T models were selected; the different probabilities of these selected beads were neglected and not taken into account in the calculation of parameters. To study the influence of filtering more thoroughly, the value of f min was varied systematically between 12 and 24. Figure 6 presents visualizations of the three limiting DAMMIX averages corresponding to f min = 1, 12, and 24, respectively. The mean values of the structural and hydrodynamic parameters of the individual P1T models and the parameters calculated from the various averaged structures based on these models are again compiled in Table 1. An inspec2
In principle templates for the dodecameric subunit can also be derived directly from EM-based templates for the whole HBL complex; this alternative approach was only used in a few pilot tests performed, however, with HBL templates consisting of beads with rb = 0.8 nm, which disables a direct comparison with the results presented in this study.
Fig. 6 DAMMIX averages of P1T models for the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb, studied at varying filtering conditions. A unfiltered average, f min = 1 (different probabilities are expressed by different shades of gray and by different bead radii); B filtered average, fmin = 12; C filtered average, fmin = 24
P. Zipper et al.
tion of the data discloses a good agreement of the mean values for D and s of these models with the results obtained for the various ab initio DAMMIN models based on the modified experimental scattering curve; the mean value for V only agrees with the corresponding data for the P1U models, whereas the mean values for RG and dmax are distinctly higher than the results obtained for the ab initio models. Among the various averaged structures derived from the P1T models, only the filtered average obtained by application of the DAMAVER package yields the closest agreement with the mean values for D and s of the underlying models, whereas the unfiltered average generated by DAMMIX exhibits the largest deviations from the mean values; smaller deviations are observed, however, in the case of the set of filtered DAMMIX averages. It should be mentioned, that preliminary tests with a few template-biased models derived from the modified experimental scattering curve yielded results (data not shown) similar to those reported in Table 1, however, the volumes of these models were found to be systematically higher by a few percent. Scattering curves I(h) and p(r) functions of the P1T models are included in Fig. 3. For convenience, as I(h) values of the individual models, the data provided by DAMMIN were adopted in this case. The averaged I(h) and p(r) functions excellently agree with the experimental functions. On the other hand, the I(h) and p(r) functions calculated from the various averaged structures deviate considerably; the most pronounced deviations from the experimental functions are observed with the unfiltered averaged structure generated by DAMMIX. Models of the Dodecameric Subunit Based on the Crystal Structure The recently published crystal structure of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb [30] and the atomic coordinates deposited in the Protein Data Bank (PDB ID: 1X9F) provided the basis for a critical check of the physical relevance of the various models derived from SAXS. For this purpose, several models of the anhydrous and the hydrated protein were constructed from the original crystal structure. These models are visualized in Fig. 7 in three orthogonal views, to allow a better recognition of the shape and structural details such as the location of heme groups and waters. The CPK model of the anhydrous protein (A) was obtained by omission of the 264 water molecules observed in the crystal structure. Since the number of atoms exceeded the limit imposed by the program HYDRO [59, 60], the CPK model of the anhydrous protein was converted to a model (B) in which each amino acid (AA) residue is represented by a single bead placed at the center of gravity of the residue; the size of each bead corresponds to the molecular volume of the respective residue. In a similar way also each heme group is represented by a single bead; for convenience these beads
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin
Fig. 7 Models of the crystal structure of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb, shown in top, side, and bottom views. A Original crystal structure (atoms shown in CPK colors), anhydrous model. B Reduced crystal structure (AA residues in gray, heme groups in black), anhydrous model. C Central slabs of the anhydrous reduced crystal structure shown in B. D Reduced crystal structure, hydrated model (obtained by means of the programs SIMS and HYDMODEL; water molecules are displayed in green)
are drawn in black color. Central slabs of the reduced model of the anhydrous docecameric subunit (C) unveil further details of its structure (e.g. the different appearances in the top and bottom views). The model for the hydrated protein (D) was obtained in a multi-step procedure: first the coordinates of about 100,000 potential water positions were obtained by applying the program SIMS [51] to the anhydrous crystal structure; a subsequent analysis of these potential positions by means of our program HYDMODEL [52–54], applied to the reduced anhydrous model (B) and using Kuntz hydration numbers [57], eventually resulted in the selection of 3,370 positions as coordinates of hydration waters (green beads). In Fig. 8 the I(h) and p(r) curves calculated for the anhydrous and hydrated models based on the crystal structure of the dodecameric subunit are compared to the experimental curves and the functions obtained for the SAXS consensus model of the subunit. This comparison evidently reveals a distinct discrepancy in the particle dimensions, suggesting the crystal structure to correspond to larger dmax and RG values than obtained from SAXS. The parameters tabulated in Table 1 reflect this discrepancy in a quantitative manner. In an attempt to improve the fit to the experimental I(h) and p(r) functions, the reduced hydrated model was downscaled appropriately to match the experimental values for RG and V . As follows from Fig. 8, in this way the divergent behavior of the I(h) and
51
Fig. 8 Comparison of the experimental scattering profiles, I(h) and p(r), of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb (open black circles) and the SAXS consensus model (solid black circles) with the scattering profiles of models derived from crystallographic data of the subunit (lines). The dot-dashed lines mirror an anhydrous model describing the crystal structure built from AA residues and the solid lines render the corresponding hydrated model; the dashed lines indicate a rescaled hydrated model
p(r) functions could be reduced considerably, however, significant deviations from the experimental functions still persist. Figure 9 presents superpositions of the reduced anhydrous model (grey beads) derived from the crystal structure with a gamut of averaged SAXS models (red beads) based on trial and error or the DAMMIN approach. For generating the superpositions, the SAXS models were aligned appropriately by means of the programs DAMSEL and DAMSUP from the DAMAVER suite. The first impression gained from the figure is that the shape of nearly all SAXS models considered is in fair accord with the crystal structure of the dodecameric subunit. However, a closer inspection, especially of the central slabs related to the top and side views of the particles, unveils characteristic differences. On the whole, the SAXS models exhibit a less domed shape than the model based on the crystal structure, mainly owing to a less pronounced cavity on the bottom side of the models. This cavity is least expressed in the models P3U:O and P3O and in the trialand-error model, and appears to be most pronounced in the models P1U and P1T. The model P3U:P represents an exception per se because of its divergent structure, which is, however, quite obscured by the superposition
52
P. Zipper et al.
Conclusions
Fig. 9 Comparison of the reduced crystal structure of the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb with various models derived from SAXS. All images represent superpositions of the reduced anhydrous model (gray beads) excerpted from the crystallographic information with averaged SAXS models (red beads) based on trialand-error or DAMMIN approaches. The averaged trial-and-error models in the first row are compared to the averaged DAMMIN models beneath which have been encoded as listed in the legend to Fig. 3
with the crystal structure model. That none of the SAXS models matches the crystal structure more perfectly is not unexpected in view of the mentioned discrepancies observed with the I(h) and p(r) functions and the particle dimensions. Superpositions of the downscaled reduced anhydrous model with the SAXS models (not shown here) differ from the superpositions shown in Fig. 9 to some extent because of differences in the alignment and orientation of the SAXS models; the general appearance of these superpositions is, however, quite similar to that observed in Fig. 9.
Exploiting the information of experimental SAXS curves, ab initio modeling programs allow the low-resolution shape of proteins to be predicted with a high degree of probability. The present study shows that this is also valid for the dodecameric subunit of L.t. Hb, a subassembly of a complex of high structural hierarchy (HBL complex). Both types of approaches applied, GA (program DALAI_GA) and SA (program DAMMIN), turned out to be effective in estimating the 3D solution shape of the subunit and predicting structural and hydrodynamic molecular parameters. In agreement with the results of previous modeling trials on several proteins [32, 38], the use of strict ab initio conditions is clearly inferior to approaches which implement additional structural information. In particular, the performance of DAMMIN calculations with symmetry constraints and shape bias as well as computations using EM-biased templates yielded less ambiguous models. However, appropriate selection criteria for the models chosen and averaging procedures have to be applied, to avoid less relevant models. To judge the reliability of the obtained models, these were compared to the previously established SAXS trial-and-error model [17, 28] and to the 3D subunit structure derived from crystallographic data [30]. In the latter case, however, appropriate hydration contributions have to be taken into account, to make the molecular parameters comparable to the data observed in solution scattering or hydrodynamic studies. As an essential outcome, the comparison between solution and crystal data reveals a different behavior of the dodecameric subunit in solution and the crystalline state, respectively. This may be taken unequivocally from the differences in the models presented in Fig. 9, irrespective of the constraints for the DAMMIN modeling procedure. In particular, the cavity in the particle center found by crystallography could not be simulated sufficiently by any of the SAXS-based DAMMIN models. Evidently, the crystallographic models are more domed than the SAXS-based models. It is therefore not surprising that the rather speculative attempts to reduce the differences in the p(r) functions of the models by a homogeneous downscaling of the models derived from the crystal structure, applying the same scaling factor to the x, y and z coordinates, were unable to shift the maximum of the p(r) function sufficiently to lower r values, i.e. to the position found by SAXS experiments and also observed with the SAXS-based models. Alternative attempts with inhomogeneous downscaling, applying in pilot tests a lower scaling factor to the z coordinates as compared to the factor acting on the x and y coordinates, improved the results only slightly. From the obvious failure of mere downscaling approaches in reducing the observed discrepancies one must conclude that additional modifications of the crystallographic models will be required to succeed. At the moment we can only speculate about the nature of these neces-
Modeling of the Dodecameric Subunit of Lumbricus Hemoglobin
sary modifications (presumably rotation and realignment of parts of the crystallographic models) which must decrease the size and the cavity of the models, thereby shifting the maximum of the p(r) function from about 5.7 to 4.6 nm (Fig. 8). To achieve this goal, further systematic investigations, outside the scope of this paper, have to be performed. In this context, however, also questions concerning the ultimate reliability of experimental data and calculation modes should be addressed. Of course, the investigation of biological material is always, unavoidably, afflicted with the problem of absolute sample purity and stability. In the case of the L.t. Hb subunit, no disturbances have been reported [28]. Both SAXS and hydrodynamic data have been obtained after extrapolating the data to c = 0 and using high-tech equipment and modern evaluation procedures. Similarly, the applied modeling approaches used the highest standard of available computer programs. Therefore any explanations of the differences in the p(r) functions by the assumption of errors in the processing of experimental and/or model data can be ruled out definitely. In the past, numerous attempts have been made to compare the results from solution techniques and crystallography, although this intention must a priori remain tentatively, because of the investigation in different aggregation states (solution or crystal). In the course of such investigations, essentially agreement between the structure in solution and the crystal has been established [68–70]. A close inspection of the results in molecular terms, however, revealed minor, sometimes only marginal differences, e.g. in the values for RG , obtained either experimentally by SAXS or calculated from the atomic coordinates, for volume and surface area, or in the tail-end regions of SAXS
53
curves. Remaining discrepancies were ascribed to different flexibility of certain protein parts (e.g. termini and surface loops), different particle anisometry, different extent of preferential hydration and salt binding, in addition to varying protein-protein interactions and unavoidable aggregation/irradiation effects (influenceable, however, by variation of c). In addition, the results, may be influenced by a different extent of surface roughness (rugosity) of the models, a problem which usually crops up if SAXS and diffraction data are to be compared quantitatively [33, 70]. Because of the complex effects, a clear-cut answer concerning the differences between solution and crystal data for the subunit of L.t. Hb cannot be given at present. Since reasonable SAXS-based models for the whole HBL complex have already been established [19], modeling an entire HBL complex from the dodecameric subunit model, would also be a further challenging modeling task. Putting side by side the resulting models and the models obtained for the native HBL complex revealed a basic agreement in the overall structure [32], the quantitative comparison of data, however, disclosed a major discrepancy, owing to the fact that HBL complexes built alone from models of the dodecameric subunit lack the scaffold of linker chains which form the central part of the native HBL complex. Acknowledgement The authors are much obliged to several scientists and institutions for use of their computer programs: to D.I. Svergun for DAMMIN, the DAMAVER suite, GNOM and SUPCOMB, to P. Chacón for DALAI_GA, to Y.N. Vorobjev for SIMS, to J. García de la Torre for HYDRO, to R.A Sayle for RASMOL, to the SERC Daresbury Laboratory for the CCP4 suite, and to the Research Foundation of the State University of New York for VOLVIS, respectively. A.K. thanks the Austrian Academy of Sciences for support (APART fellowship).
References 1. Lamy JN, Green BN, Toulmond A, Wall JS, Weber RE, Vinogradov SN (1996) Chem Rev 96:3113–3124 2. Weber RE, Vinogradov SN (2001) Physiol Rev 81:569–628 3. Daniel E, Lustig A, David MM, Tsfadia Y (2003) Biochim Biophys Acta 1649:1–15 4. Royer WE Jr, Hendrickson WA (1988) J Biol Chem 263:13762–13765 5. Boekema EJ, van Heel M (1989) Biochim Biophys Acta 957:370–379 6. Vinogradov SN, Lugo SD, Mainwaring MG, Kapp OH, Crewe AV (1986) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 83:8034–8038 7. Vinogradov SN, Sharma PK, Qabar AN, Wall JS, Westrick JA, Simmons JH, Gill SJ (1991) J Biol Chem 266:13091–13096
8. Zhu H, Ownby DW, Riggs CK, Nolasco NJ, Stoops JK, Riggs AF (1996) J Biol Chem 271:30007–30021 9. Kuchumov AR, Taveau J-C, Lamy JN, Wall JS, Weber RE, Vinogradov SN (1999) J Mol Biol 289:1361–1374 10. Schatz M, Orlova EV, Dube P, Jäger J, van Heel M (1995) J Struct Biol 114:28–40 11. de Haas F, Boisset N, Taveau J-C, Lambert O, Vinogradov SN, Lamy JN (1996) Biophys J 70:1973–1984 12. de Haas F, Taveau J-C, Boisset N, Lambert O, Vinogradov SN, Lamy JN (1996) J Mol Biol 255:140–153 13. de Haas F, Kuchumov A, Taveau J-C, Boisset N, Vinogradov SN, Lamy JN (1997) Biochemistry 36:7330–7338 14. Taveau J-C, Boisset N, Vinogradov SN, Lamy JN (1999) J Mol Biol 289:1343–1359
15. Mouche F, Boisset N, Penczek PA (2001) J Struct Biol 133:176–192 16. Pilz I, Schwarz E, Vinogradov SN (1980) Int J Biol Macromol 2:279–283 17. Krebs A (1996) Thesis, University of Graz, Austria 18. Krebs A, Zipper P, Vinogradov SN (1996) Biochim Biophys Acta 1297:115–118 19. Krebs A, Lamy J, Vinogradov SN, Zipper P (1998) Biopolymers 45:289–298 20. Krebs A, Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2004) Biophys J 87:1173–1185 21. Royer WE Jr, Strand K, van Heel M, Hendrickson WA (2000) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:7107–7111 22. David MM, Daniel E (1974) J Mol Biol 87:89–101
54
23. Kapp OH, Polidori G, Mainwaring MG, Crewe AV, Vinogradov SN (1984) J Biol Chem 259:628–639 24. Mainwaring MG, Lugo SD, Fingal RA, Kapp OH, Vinogradov SN (1986) J Biol Chem 261:10899–10908 25. Martin PD, Kuchumov AR, Green BN, Oliver RWA, Braswell EH, Wall JS, Vinogradov SN (1996) J Mol Biol 255:154–169 26. Green BN, Bordoli RS, Hanin LG, Lallier FH, Toulmond A, Vinogradov SN (1999) J Biol Chem 274:28206–28212 27. Sharma PK, Kuchumov AR, Chottard G, Martin PD, Wall JS, Vinogradov SN (1996) J Biol Chem 271:8754–8762 28. Krebs A, Kuchumov AR, Sharma PK, Braswell EH, Zipper P, Weber RE, Chottard G, Vinogradov SN (1996) J Biol Chem 271:18695–18704 29. Martin PD, Eisele KL, Doyle MA, Kuchumov AR, Walz DA, Arutyunyan EG, Vinogradov SN, Edwards BFP (1996) J Mol Biol 255:170–175 30. Strand K, Knapp JE, Bhyravbhatla B, Royer WE Jr (2004) J Mol Biol 344:119–134 31. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2000) J Appl Crystallogr 33:788–792 32. Zipper P, Durchschlag H, Krebs A (2005) In: Scott DJ, Harding SE, Rowe AJ (eds) Analytical ultracentrifugation: techniques and methods, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge UK, in press 33. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2002) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 119:121–130 34. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (1997) J Appl Crystallogr 30:1112–1124 35. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (1999) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 113:87–105
P. Zipper et al.
36. Zipper P, Krebs A, Durchschlag H (2002) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 119:141–148 37. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2002) Physica A 314:613–622 38. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:509–514 39. Zipper P, Krebs A, Durchschlag H (2004) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 127:126–135 40. Chacón P, Morán F, Díaz JF, Pantos E, Andreu JM (1998) Biophys J 74:2760–2775 41. Chacón P, Díaz JF, Morán F, Andreu JM (2000) J Mol Biol 299:1289–1302 42. Svergun DI (1999) Biophys J 76:2879–2886 43. Svergun DI (2000) J Appl Crystallogr 33:530–534 44. Volkov VV, Svergun DI (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:860–864 45. Glatter O, Kratky O (eds) (1982) Small angle X-ray scattering. Academic, London 46. Berman HM, Westbrook J, Feng Z, Gilliland G, Bhat TN, Weissig H, Shindyalov IN, Bourne PE (2000) Nucleic Acids Res 28:235–242 47. Svergun DI (1992) J Appl Crystallogr 25:495–503 48. Kozin MB, Svergun DI (2001) J Appl Crystallogr 34:33–41 49. Svergun DI, Petoukhov MV, Koch MHJ (2001) Biophys J 80:2946–2953 50. Petoukhov MV, Svergun DI (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:540–544 51. Vorobjev YN, Hermans J (1997) Biophys J 73:722–732 52. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2001) Biophys Chem 93:141–157 53. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2002) J Phys Condens Matter 14:2439– 2452
54. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2002) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 119:131–140 55. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2003) Eur Biophys J 32:487–502 56. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2004) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 127:98–112 57. Kuntz ID (1971) J Am Chem Soc 93:514–516 58. Glatter O (1980) Acta Phys Austriaca 52:243–256 59. García de la Torre J, Navarro S, López Martínez MC, Díaz FG, López Cascales JJ (1994) Biophys J 67:530–531 60. García de la Torre J, Huertas ML, Carrasco B (2000) Biophys J 78:719–730 61. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (1997) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 107:58–71 62. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (1998) Biochem Soc Trans 26:726–731 63. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (1999) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 113:106–113 64. Carrasco B, García de la Torre J, Zipper P (1999) Eur Biophys J 28:510–515 65. Sayle RA, Milner-White EJ (1995) Trends Biochem Sci 20:374–376 66. Collaborative Computational Project, Number 4 (1994) Acta Cryst D50:760–763 67. Avila R, He T, Hong L, Kaufman A, Pfister H, Silva C, Sobierajski L, Wang S (1994) In: Bergeron R, Kaufman A (eds) Proceedings IEEE Visualization ’94, IEEE Computer Society, Washington DC, p 31–38 68. Kratky O, Pilz I (1978) Q Rev Biophys 11:39–70 69. Durchschlag H, Zipper P, Wilfing R, Purr G (1991) J Appl Crystallogr 24:822–831 70. Durchschlag H, Zipper P, Purr G, Jaenicke R (1996) Colloid Polym Sci 274:117–137
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 55–73 DOI 10.1007/2882_017 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 17 February 2006
Helmut Durchschlag Peter Zipper Angelika Krebs
Helmut Durchschlag (u) Institute of Biophysics and Physical Biochemistry, University of Regensburg, Universitätsstrasse 31, 93040 Regensburg, Germany e-mail:
[email protected] Peter Zipper Physical Chemistry, Institute of Chemistry, University of Graz, Heinrichstrasse 28, 8010 Graz, Austria Angelika Krebs Structural and Computational Biology Programme, European Molecular Biology Laboratory, Meyerhofstrasse 1, 69117 Heidelberg, Germany
D A T A A N A L Y SI S A N D MO D E L I N G
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
Abstract The joint use of smallangle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and hydrodynamic data permits biologically useful reconstructions of protein structures to be determined. Lowresolution shapes of proteins can be obtained by SAXS-based modeling approaches, among them the ab initio approaches being the most recent and challenging ones. The programs DAMMIN and GASBOR have been applied to C. callunae starch phosphorylase in a case study, to test in a systematic manner the principles governing the evaluation strategies of the approaches applied. Therefore, emphasis was laid on the elaboration of modeling aspects rather than on biological details. Optimum results concerning the predictions of particle shapes and molecule properties have been obtained by utilizing tight constraints for modeling, such as symmetry and anisometry information. The use of pure ab initio conditions yields rather moderate shape and parameter predictions. Application of erroneous constraints generally leads to unrealistic particle shapes, although the parameter predictions may be satisfactory. The usage of the program DAMMIN turned out to be superior to application of the program GASBOR, whether the
latter approach was used in the reciprocal- or real-space version. For hydrodynamic modeling, a modified version of the program HYDRO was adopted. By recourse to known crystallographic 3D structures for phosphorylases from other sources, SAXS profiles of anhydrous proteins can be modeled. Procedures for the addition of individual water molecules to anhydrous protein envelopes based on the atomic coordinates yield biologically relevant models for hydrated phosphorylases. This requires the usage of advanced surface calculation programs such as SIMS and of appropriate hydration algorithms such as those implemented in our programs HYDCRYST and HYDMODEL. The resulting SAXS profiles and structural and hydrodynamic parameters of the hydrated proteins can be compared with the data obtained by solution scattering.
Keywords Advanced modeling techniques · Hydration · Smallangle X-ray scattering · X-ray crystallography · Hydrodynamics
56
Introduction Glycogen phosphorylase (GP) catalyzes the first step in the intracellular degradation of glycogen, to give the product glucose-1-phosphate. The activity of the enzyme is regulated by the interconversion between two alternative structural states (T and R, designating tense and relaxed structures of the enzyme), an event that is modulated by allosteric interactions and reversible phosphorylation. The nonphosphorylated form (phosphorylase b) is activated by adenosine monophosphate (AMP), whereas the phosphorylated form (phosphorylase a) is independent of AMP. The properties of GP and the structural mechanism of its control have been reviewed previously [1–6]. In the absence of effectors, GP is a dimer composed of approx. 90–100 kDa subunits. Comprehensive results are available for various data of the enzyme from various sources, including solution scattering and hydrodynamic data. In particular, the enzyme from rabbit muscle attracted interest over many years. Among the techniques applied to this enzyme, analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC) (e.g. [7–17]) and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) [14, 18] played a major role. More recent investigations concentrated on bacterial phosphorylases from various sources (reviewed in [6]), including the enzyme from Escherichia coli and Corynebacterium callunae. The E. coli enzyme (MalP) shows a clear preference for maltodextrins, whereas the enzyme from C. callunae (StP) seems to prefer starch as a substrate. MalP as well as StP have been subjected to SAXS investigations, however, only the latter one resulted in an unambiguous model for the solution structure and yielded well-defined results for the SAXS parameters [19]. Overall, the shape model for StP differs slightly from that of rabbit GP, both in size and axial dimensions [19]. Hydrodynamic data for StP are not available to date, contrary to the GPs from many other sources. The crystal structure of several GPs has been determined to a high resolution. Crystallographic investigations are primarily concerned with the rabbit enzyme [2, 3, 20], MalP from E. coli [21–23], and the enzyme from yeast [24, 25]. Crystallization attempts to solve the 3D structure of StP have not yet been successful. The X-ray diffraction analyses of T to R transitions of GPs have provided explanations for the molecular mechanism of regulation, attributing the allosteric mechanism to an intimate connection between tertiary and quaternary structure [3, 20]. The 3D models obtained by crystallography resemble the consensus model for StP as obtained by SAXS that established a slightly elongated, flat ellipsoid with 2-fold symmetry in solution [19]. Quite recently, StP was used for probing the efficacy of different ab initio modeling procedures based on SAXS data [26]. A comparison of approaches based on simulated annealing (SA) [27], a genetic algorithm [28, 29] or Monte-Carlo simulation [30] proved the extraordinary
H. Durchschlag et al.
practicability of the available programs applying SA. In particular, the possibility to use either strict ab initio conditions or adopt constraints or templates turned out to be a major advantage of the available SA-based programs. The present paper uses StP for detailed modeling attempts, comprising either simple ab initio conditions or the usage of realistic and unrealistic assumptions concerning the constraints. This emerged as an especially challenging task, since frequently the information concerning size, shape and particle symmetry is unknown or even may be wrong. Insofar it was of interest whether the modeling calculations can derive acceptable results concerning particle shape and parameter predictions also under complicated premises. This intention was tested in a systematic manner, applying different available SA approaches, namely the programs DAMMIN [27] and GASBOR [31, 32], under varying input and calculation options and applying different procedures for averaging the obtained model structures. Use of surface representation techniques can be used for additionally controlling the obtained particle shapes. However, the ultimate decision concerning the usability of applied programs and constraints is the comparison of predicted and observed structural and hydrodynamic properties that usually are obtained by SAXS and AUC studies. This also implies a critical examination of experimental and calculated scattering profiles, both in reciprocal and real space. The critical comparison of the SAXS models obtained for the solution shape (StP), on the one hand, and those derived from crystal structures (rabbit phosphorylase and MalP), on the other, arouses additional interest. In this context, however, we should remember the existing slight differences in the molecular features of the enzymes from different sources. The influence of hydration contributions, i.e. of water molecules bound preferentially to the protein surface, has to be considered as well.
Methods X-ray data can be used advantageously as the general basis for efficient modeling approaches to describe the structure of biopolymers in solution or the solid, preferably crystalline state, respectively. This requires knowledge of either low-resolution SAXS data (one-dimensional scattering curves) to obtain eventually the size and shape of molecules in solution, or information from high-resolution diffraction analyses (atomic coordinates) to derive precise 3D images of crystal structures. Usually, in SAXS investigations, models consisting of a certain number of spheres (“bead models”) are constructed, to illustrate the spatial distribution of the masses of the biopolymers under consideration. The fine structure of molecules can be modeled by integrating a great number of beads in the modeling calculations, for example by characterizing atoms or amino acid (AA) residues of proteins by many beads of constant or variable size.
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
In the context of scattering and hydrodynamic modeling, a variety of multibody approaches and applications cross our mind, among them the ab initio approaches [27– 32] being the most challenging attempts. The SA approaches DAMMIN [27] and GASBOR [31, 32], which will be used in the following, permit the calculation of such bead models which, in turn, after various intermediate steps, allow the prediction of structural and hydrodynamic parameters of hydrated molecules that can be compared to existing experimental data.
57
diameter, dmax , translational diffusion coefficient, D, and sedimentation coefficient, s. In connection with scattering and hydrodynamic modeling approaches, two essential points should be mentioned explicitly. (i) Both SAXS and hydrodynamic techniques usually yield data which already inherently contain hydration contributions [35]. (ii) The interpretation of SAXS data and their evaluation in terms of molecular parameters can be performed either in the reciprocal or the real space, applying either I(h) or p(r); the two functions are connected via Fourier transformation ([36, 37]; cf. also separate paper in this issue).
Sources of Data SAXS data (scattering profiles and parameters as well as the characteristics of the best-fit trial-and-error model) of C. callunae StP were taken from a previous paper [19]. For the establishment of hydrodynamic reference data, consensus values were derived from a critical comparison of s and D values found in the literature for phosphorylases from various sources [7–17]. Needless to say, the enzymes from different sources possess slightly different properties, with respect to number and composition of AA residues as well as mass and shape of the particles. For example, the enzymes from rabbit, E. coli and C. callunae possess 842, 796 and 796 AA residues per subunit, respectively, as follows from AA sequence data stored in the SWISS-PROT data bank [33] (entries P00489 for rabbit GP, P00490 for E. coli MalP, Q8KQ56 for C. callunae StP). The atomic coordinates and molar masses of rabbit and E. coli phosphorylase were obtained from the Protein Data Bank (PDB) [34]: accession codes 3GPB for rabbit GP and 1AHP for E. coli MalP. The molar masses derived from the PDB files, however, are slightly smaller than those retrieved from the AA sequence data stored in the SWISSPROT data bank [33], since a few AA residues are not resolved in the crystal structure analysis (3GPB: only 833 of a total of 842 AA residues per subunit have been detected) or are slightly different from the composition given in the SWISS-PROT data bank. For the calculations of parameters of models, hetero atoms and also the crystallographically found water molecules were neglected. The latter aspect is obviously justified, since previous considerations [35] revealed that the number and position of these waters generally do not match the situation valid for solution studies. For the calculations with StP we used the mass as derived from SAXS [19]. For the calculations to be performed, essentially the following information was applied: atomic coordinates, scattering intensity, I(h) (where h = (4π/λ) sin θ, θ = half the scattering angle, and λ the wavelength of the incident X-rays), pair-distance distribution function (PDDF), p(r) (where r = distance between pairs of scatterers and p(r) ≡ 0 for r values greater than dmax ), molar mass, M, partial specific volume, v, radius of gyration, RG , hydrated volume, V , amount of hydration, δ1 , maximum particle
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling Approaches As outlined previously [26, 38], the SA approaches in the form of the programs DAMMIN [27] and GASBOR [31, 32] are particularly useful for the ab initio modeling of particle shapes because of their suitability to use the programs in the strict ab initio sense or by inclusion of various constraints concerning symmetry and shape specifications. The program DAMMIN [27, 39] starts with a predefined search space (usually a sphere of a diameter slightly exceeding dmax ) filled with densely packed dummy atoms and allocates the atoms either to the protein or the solvent. SA is used as a global minimization algorithm that finally achieves a particle configuration matching the experimental SAXS data (scattering profiles and molecule parameters) as far as possible. The program uses the entire scattering curve for fitting, and spheres of equal size for modeling. Compactness and connectivity restrictions are imposed on the search, thus minimizing the number of ambiguous models. To calculate scattering curves of the models, the DAMMIN approach uses spherical harmonics instead of Debye’s formula which is conventionally adopted in bead modeling studies. SAXS experiments usually abstain from the usage of contrast variation techniques. Then the DAMMIN program can act as a strict ab initio method, unless particle symmetry (point group) or shape (unknown/oblate/prolate) or any kind of template (e.g., obtained from electron microscopic or atomic data) is implemented as additional structural information (expert mode). In this case, the program can advantageously be used as a constrained modeling approach. As primary input for the experimental data, a GNOM file [40] is required. Usually, a constant is subtracted from the experimental scattering intensities to consider the influence of the internal particle structure [37]. The DAMMIN program, however, allows consideration of such a background correction (BC) or suppression of any correction (NBC). The program GASBOR [31, 32] represents another SA approach, similar to DAMMIN. However, contrary to DAMMIN, the GASBOR procedure uses a chain-like
58
ensemble of dummy residues to simulate the protein backbone, and dummy water molecules to consider hydration associated with the protein. Scattering intensities of the obtained sphere models are calculated by means of Debye’s formula. Currently, two versions of GASBOR are available, using either the reciprocal-space [31] or the realspace [32] information. For both GASBOR versions the input of experimental data is possible by a GNOM file, and the accounting for a constant background of experimental scattering curves (BC) is enabled, at least in the reciprocalspace version. The real-space version that fits p(r) instead of I(h) allows a substantially faster generation of models than the reciprocal-space version. The real-space version, therefore, could be a valuable tool for screening a large number of models, provided that the accuracy achieved is the same as that obtained in the reciprocal-space program. All modeling approaches, including the SA procedures DAMMIN and GASBOR, call for the performance of multiple runs for each condition chosen. Comparing the resulting models additionally requires visualizing, aligning, superimposing, averaging and filtering the models obtained. In defiance of all possible precautions, however, all shape reconstructions lack an ultimate perfection; all models obtained share the problem of deficient uniqueness [26, 38, 41]. Subsequent Processing of Models For the processing of the models provided by DAMMIN [27] and GASBOR [31, 32], the program package DAMAVER [41] is highly qualified. The program set consists of the programs DAMSEL, DAMSUP, DAMAVER and DAMFILT, and uses SUPCOMB [42]. The shared access to this program suite allows aligning and comparing all the models under construction, averaging the aligned models, filtering the averaged models, and, finally, building the most probable model. The whole process is automated. In the first step, the selected models are pairwise aligned and a measure of dissimilarity is obtained for each pair of models. When all pairs of independent models have been tested in this way, the dissimilarities of all models are compared, outliers are discarded, and from the remaining models the one with the lowest average dissimilarity is chosen as reference model. The other ultimately selected models are then superimposed onto the reference model. The assembly of aligned models is averaged by mapping their dummy atoms onto a densely packed grid of beads. The occupancy factors of the obtained grid points can be used for filtering the averaged model at a given cut-off volume by neglecting points of too low occupancy. Averaging procedures have also been described for other types of ab initio approaches [29, 30, 43]. In context with the generation of averaged models from the SA procedures under consideration, averaging was also
H. Durchschlag et al.
executed by in-house, purpose-written software. In the present study, the program DAMHEXMIX [26] was used which maps the models to be averaged onto a grid of hexagonal cells; the edge length of the cells is an adjustable parameter. DAMHEXMIX is similar to the program DAMMIX [26] which has been designed for direct averaging of models. With both programs, the different probabilities of the beads in the averaged models can be expressed by different bead volumes (radii) or by different densities of equally sized beads. In both cases, the values for RG of the averaged models correspond to the mean value of the models used for averaging, whereas a similar statement concerning the V values is restricted to averaged models of the first kind (models with variable bead radii). Preferably with models of the second kind (models with variable bead densities), if desired, a filtering process and a standardization of the overall volume can be launched by sorting out spheres of low likelihood. Since DAMHEXMIX, similarly to DAMMIX but unlike the DAMAVER suite, does not provide tools for performing an appropriate alignment of the models prior to averaging (the only operation implemented in DAMHEXMIX is a rotation around the z axis), the models were properly aligned by means of DAMSEL and DAMSUP from the DAMAVER package before DAMHEXMIX was applied. Previous trials have shown that averaging is a helpful and legitimate tool for accentuating the peculiarities of structural models [26, 44]. Similarly, the combined use of different averaging procedures, for example with respect to filtering aspects, may be applied for discriminating between different ab initio and constrained models. Modeling of Hydration In principle, all ab initio approaches that are based on SAXS data consider the contributions of hydration, since the target experimental profiles already involve both the protein and the water molecules bound to it. While the SA program DAMMIN [27] mimics the shape of the hydrated proteins by a number of dummy spheres of appropriate size which already include the contributions of hydration, the program GASBOR [31, 32] simulates their solution structure by anhydrous protein dummies to which water dummies are added, thereby simulating some kind of “water shell”. As has been shown previously [35], and will be proven in the following, the resultant models are unacceptable with respect to their biological relevance: the water molecules are placed on the protein surface neither in the form of a shell nor at biologically realistic surface sites. Because of the obvious deficiencies in biological relevance of water molecules in the ab initio models, we kept an eye out for more efficient hydration algorithms that are able to allocate definite amounts of water to definite AA residues of the protein surface [45]. This re-
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
quires knowledge of the exact protein surface topography, on the one hand, and of appropriate amounts of water bound to specific sites on the protein surface, on the other. To comply with these requirements, the atomic coordinates, the AA sequence and specific hydration numbers for the AA residues must be known, in addition to the availability of advanced surface calculation and hydration programs. The accessible surface area of proteins can be calculated analytically by modern surface calculation programs such as MSROLL [46] or SIMS [47], which use one or two probe spheres, respectively, for analyzing the surface area by means of a rolling-ball mechanism. Essentially, both programs create an accurate, smooth molecular dot surface. Because of the high homogeneity of the dot distributions obtained, usage of the SIMS program is a good choice for the following hydration calculations. The inhouse programs HYDCRYST (for models based on atomic coordinates) or HYDMODEL (for reduced models using AA coordinates; in these models each AA residue is expressed by a single sphere of appropriate volume) employ special hydration algorithms for assigning specific hydration numbers to definite amino acid residues on the protein surface [35, 48, 49]. For these purposes, the following general procedure is applied. From the atomic coordinates of the crystal structure, only the atoms representing the protein moiety are selected. Application of any of the surface calculation programs to this anhydrous (“dry”) protein model results in a great number of surface points, Ndot , and respective normal vectors. From this collection of points and vectors, a pool of potential positions of water molecules bound to the protein surface is derived. By means of special hydration algorithms, implemented in HYDCRYST or HYDMODEL, preferential sites for bound water molecules can be selected. The number of water molecules, Nw , assigned to each AA residue can be adopted from the values given by Kuntz [50], but have to be triggered slightly to achieve realistic levels of hydration. The hydration algorithms have been checked for various molecules and conditions [35, 45, 48, 49, 51– 54]. Such investigations also revealed the elucidation of several fine tuning parameters required for optimum results, among them the choice of the water volume, Vw , and the scaling factor acting on the Kuntz hydration numbers, f K , being the most relevant ones. The results concerning the hydration obtained by application of HYDCRYST and HYDMODEL may differ slightly owing to the different representation of the AA residues, either by a number of small beads or by single larger spheres. To avoid such discrepancies, in cases where the number of protein atoms and assigned water molecules exceeds the maximum number of beads that are allowed in subsequent calculations, the water molecules assigned by HYDCRYST may be combined also with the reduced anhydrous protein model (in AA coordinates); this alternative approach was used, for instance, in the prediction of hydrodynamic parameters
59
of rabbit GP and MalP by means of the program HYDRO (see below). Visualization of Models The obtained models were visualized by the program RASMOL [55]. Surface representations of the models utilized programs from the CCP4 package [56]; electron density maps were created and threshold levels were chosen as described [44]. The electron densities obtained were displayed by the program VOLVIS [57]. Prediction of Molecule Parameters The calculation of SAXS profiles, I(h) and p(r), from the coordinates of the spheres and the computation of structural parameters were performed by means of Debye’s formula and the algorithms described previously [37, 58]. Hydrodynamic parameters (s, D) were obtained by applying version 13 of García de la Torre’s program HYDRO [59, 60]; our ad hoc expression for the interaction tensor of overlapping spheres of unequal size [61] is implemented in this version of the program [62]. The version used by us was additionally adapted to handle models of up to about 10 000 beads. Further details concerning the prediction of structural and hydrodynamic parameters can be found in previous papers (e.g. [26, 44]). Computational Requirements For the model calculations, personal computers with processors Intel Pentium IV (3.2 GHz and 2 GB RAM) or AMD 3000+ (2.2 GHz and 1 GB RAM) were used; for surface renderings a SGI workstation was applied. The CPU times required depended substantially on the programs and input variables used: typical CPU times for DAMMIN runs varied between 10 and 14 h; GASBOR runs in the reciprocal-space version amounted up to 2 d, while runs in the real-space version were finished after approx. 1/10 of the time needed for the reciprocal-space version; HYDRO runs with about 8100 beads required about 4 h.
Results and Discussion The experimental SAXS curves of C. callunae StP [19] were used as data basis for the solution modeling approaches on phosphorylases. The previous SAXS investigations have established a simple model for the solution structure of the protein dimer and provided several molecular properties such as M, RG , V and dmax . The trial-and-error model obtained as well as the models derived from the crystallographic analyses of rabbit GP and E. coli MalP can be used as reference structures for a comparison with the ab initio reconstructions to be performed.
60
H. Durchschlag et al.
SAXS-based Modeling of C. callunae StP by DAMMIN The DAMMIN approach [27] was used in a systematic manner, varying the input variables over a wide range. In particular, handling of scattering background (BC or NBC procedures), symmetry constraints (point groups P1– P6, corresponding to no symmetry or space groups C2 to C6 , respectively), shape biases (unknown/oblate/prolate and subgroups unknown/along/across) and averaging procedures (DAMAVER, DAMHEXMIX) have been tested in their capability to predict reasonable particle models and/or structural and hydrodynamic parameters. The models obtained were processed (aligned, compared, superimposed, averaged and filtered) as outlined in the Methods section, to generate ultimately various models for hydrated StP. Figure 1 comprises a variety of realistic models that were obtained by applying the program DAMMIN as a pure ab initio approach (code P1U) or after imposing plausible constraints (code P2, in consideration of the dimeric structure of the particle). Both the ab initio and the constrained modeling procedures yield particle shapes in accord with the previously mentioned reference structures. Among the P2 models, assumption of oblate or unknown particle shapes is superior to the choice of a prolate bias. Irrespective of the known information on symmetry and particle shape, we additionally scrutinized the possibility to use erroneous symmetry and shape constraints, at least in a few examples. Figure 2 summarizes a collection of several unrealistic models obtained after using codes P3–P6. Most of these structures exhibit a rather curious
Fig. 1 Top and side views of acceptable reconstructions of the StP structure, obtained by DAMMIN modeling without any constraint (P1U) or with C2 symmetry as constraint and plausible assumptions of additional shape biases [P2: unknown (U), oblate (O) or prolate (P) shape; in the two latter cases the direction of the C2 axis could be defined as unknown (U), along (L) or across (C)], adapted from [26]. All models were derived from the background-corrected (BC) experimental scattering curve
Fig. 2 Top and side views of unacceptable reconstructions of the StP structure, obtained by DAMMIN modeling with unreasonable symmetry constraints (C3 , C4 , C5 or C6 ) and assumptions of additional shape biases (P3–P6: unknown, oblate or prolate shape). All models were derived from the background-corrected (BC) experimental scattering curve
Fig. 3 Surface representations of averaged DAMMIN models of StP in two orthogonal views. The selected models were derived from experimental SAXS curves by applying or neglecting a background correction (BC, NBC) and were constructed on the basis of C2 symmetry and different shape biases; averaging (usually over six individual models) was performed by DAMHEXMIX or the DAMAVER suite
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
appearance; only a few of them resemble the correct structure, oblate biases hit the proper shape most nearly. For the performance of further calculation steps, averaged DAMMIN models were created by different averaging approaches (DAMHEXMIX and DAMAVER). The resultant averaged models (cf. [26]) provide the basis for the ensuing surface renderings and hydrodynamic predictions by HYDRO. The surface rendering procedure applied to the most realistic models (P2U and P2O) reveals a crude overall shape (Fig. 3), strictly speaking, a smoothed oblate spheroid, essentially devoid of any structural peculiarities. Notable differences between the models derived from BC- or NBCtreated scattering curves cannot be observed. The critical comparison of experimental I(h) and p(r) SAXS profiles with those calculated for various realistic DAMMIN models (P2U and P2O) shows excellent agreement between experimental and calculated
61
profiles up to high angles (Fig. 4). This obviously shows the highly professional efficiency of the DAMMIN approach for fitting target SAXS profiles (BC: panels a and b). Discrepancies in the functions, however, can be observed when the experimental curves are compared with the functions of averaged models (dashed and dotdashed lines). This is in accord with previous considerations [26, 41, 44, 63] that averaging procedures may enhance the most persistent features of the bead models and shape reconstructions. However, the scattering profiles of the averaged models do not necessarily result in good fits to the experimental SAXS profiles. At first glance, neglect of a background subtraction (NBC: panels c and d) does not seem to affect the quality of the accordance of observed and predicted curves. The comparison of the experimental I(h) curve with the curves for the averaged models, however, discloses an enhanced incongruity, obviously caused by disregarding the con-
Fig. 4 Comparison of experimental and model SAXS profiles of StP: a,c scattering intensities I(h); b,d distance-distribution functions p(r). The selected models were derived from experimental SAXS curves by using a preceding background-correction step (BC models; panels a and b) or disregarding such a correction (NBC models; panels c and d). The experimental functions (solid black lines) comply widely with the functions calculated for various BC and NBC models. The filled black circles denote the trial-and-error model obtained earlier [19] and the open circles the averaged functions for various DAMMIN models based on C2 symmetry and absence/presence of shape constraints (P2U: blue circles; P2OL: green circles; P2OC: red circles). Usually the functions of six individual DAMMIN models of each type were averaged; the resulting standard deviations are very small. The colored lines represent the SAXS profiles of the averaged structures of these models, obtained by DAMHEXMIX (averaged models of unequal beads: dashed lines) or the DAMAVER suite (averaged models of equal-sized beads: dot-dashed lines). For the lines the same colors are used as applied to the circles; the green lines in b and d are nearly identical to the red lines
62
H. Durchschlag et al.
Table 1 Comparison of experimental and model parameters of StP from C. callunae. Models were obtained by the program DAMMIN, applying ab initio (P1U) or constrained (P2–P6) modeling conditions; models were derived from the experimental scattering curves by using a background correction (BC) or disregarding such a correction (NBC). Averaging of models was performed by employing the DAMAVER suite or our program DAMHEXMIX. For comparison, the model data of the previous trial-and-error model [19] have been added Nm
Experimental c Trial-and-error model DAMMIN models 3 (BC, unconstrained): P1U DAMMIN models (BC, symmetry constraint C2 ) e No shape bias: P2U 6 No shape bias, averaged (DAMAVER) No shape bias, 4 averaged (DAMHEXMIX) Shape bias oblate 1 (unknown): P2OU Shape bias oblate 6 (along): P2OL Shape bias oblate (along), averaged (DAMAVER) Shape bias oblate 4 (along), averaged (DAMHEXMIX) Shape bias oblate 6 (across): P2OC Shape bias oblate (across), averaged (DAMAVER) Shape bias oblate 4 (across), averaged (DAMHEXMIX) Shape bias prolate 1 (unknown): P2PU Shape bias prolate 1 (along): P2PL Shape bias prolate 1 (across): P2PC
Nb
rb a (nm)
RG (nm)
V (nm3 )
dmax b (nm)
4612
0.248
3.89 ± 0.02 3.87
290 ± 14 293
11.8 ± 0.0 4.3 ± 0.2 11.9 d ,12.4 4.67
8.7 ± 0.3 8.83
D (10−7 cm2 /s)
s (10−13 s)
1860 ± 20 0.3
3.897 ± 0.001 284 ± 3
12.5 ± 0.1 4.66 ± 0.05
8.81 ± 0.09
1823 ± 6 1149
3.897 ± 0.001 278 ± 1 278 3.897 f
12.7 ± 0.1 4.61 ± 0.03 12.8 f 4.68 f
8.73 ± 0.05 8.85 f
2655–8081 0.6–0.3 g
3.890 ± 0.002 279 ± 0
1860
0.3
3.898
13.0 ± 0.0 4.43 ± 0.12 4.58 h 13.0 4.59
8.37 ± 0.22 8.66 h 8.68
1838 ± 9
0.3
3.897 ± 0.001 281 ± 1
12.8 ± 0.1 4.59 ± 0.01
8.69 ± 0.01
1840
0.3
3.897 f
12.8 f
8.81 f
0.3 0.35
284
281
4.66 f
2342–6461 0.6–0.3 g
3.892 ± 0.002 281 ± 0
12.5 ± 0.0 4.52 ± 0.07 4.60 h
8.56 ± 0.13 8.70 h
1845 ± 11 0.3
3.897 ± 0.001 282 ± 2
12.6 ± 0.1 4.61 ± 0.01
8.73 ± 0.05
1846
3.897 f
12.6 f
8.84 f
0.3
282
4.67 f
2360–8068 0.6–0.3 g
3.892 ± 0.002 282 ± 0
13.0 ± 0.0 4.52 ± 0.08 4.62 h
8.56 ± 0.14 8.74 h
1842
0.3
3.895
281
12.7
4.63
8.75
1820
0.3
3.898
278
12.8
4.60
8.71
1835
0.3
3.897
280
12.8
4.63
8.77
tribution of the scattering background in the high-angle regime. Apart from the visual inspection of models and the comparison of SAXS profiles, the assessment of structural and hydrodynamic parameters of all the models is the crucial point. Table 1 demonstrates that the calculated parameters (RG , V , dmax , D, s) of all models, especially those of type P1 and P2 (Fig. 1), are in reasonable agreement with the experimental data set (indeed, the values for dmax and D slightly overestimate the experimental values), irrespective of the mode of approach (ab initio or based
on constraints). The conformity of the values also holds for different averaging procedures and, except the values for V , for different handlings of the background correction. Amazingly, the models of biochemically unrealistic appearance (codes P3–P6; Fig. 2), which are based on intentionally erroneous constraints, yield a fair agreement as well; in the case of P4–P6 models, the discrepancies in some parameters (especially in V ), however, are more pronounced, presumably caused by differences in the packing density of the spheres in models of different symmetry.
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
63
Table 1 (continued) Nm
Nb
rb a (nm)
DAMMIN models (BC, symmetry constraint C3 ) e No shape bias: P3U 1 1780 0.3 Shape bias oblate: P3O 1 1794 0.3 Shape bias prolate: P3P 1 1775 0.3 DAMMIN models (BC, symmetry constraint C4 ) e No shape bias: P4U 1 1732 0.3 Shape bias oblate: P4O 1 1612 0.3 Shape bias prolate: P4P 1 1704 0.3 DAMMIN models (BC, symmetry constraint C5 ) e No shape bias: P5U 1 1432 0.3 Shape bias oblate: P5O 1 1442 0.3 Shape bias prolate: P5P 1 1453 0.3 e DAMMIN models (BC, symmetry constraint C6 ) No shape bias: P6U 1 1572 0.3 Shape bias oblate: P6O 1 1516 0.3 Shape bias prolate: P6P 1 1581 0.3 DAMMIN models (NBC, symmetry constraint C2 ) e No shape bias: 6 1579 ± 6 0.3 P2U No shape bias, 1243 0.325 averaged (DAMAVER) No shape bias, 4 2479–7590 0.6–0.3 g averaged (DAMHEXMIX) Shape bias oblate 7 1570 ± 13 0.3 (along): P2OL Shape bias oblate 1571 0.3 (along), averaged (DAMAVER) Shape bias oblate 4 2278–7749 0.6–0.3 g (along), averaged (DAMHEXMIX) Shape bias oblate 6 1571 ± 13 0.3 (across): P2OC Shape bias oblate 1237 0.325 (across), averaged (DAMAVER) Shape bias oblate 4 2332–7073 0.6–0.3 g (across), averaged (DAMHEXMIX) a
RG (nm)
V (nm3 )
dmax b (nm)
D (10−7 cm2 /s)
s (10−13 s)
3.898 3.897 3.896
272 274 271
12.5 12.7 12.5
4.50 4.55 4.56
8.51 8.61 8.62
3.899 3.900 3.897
265 246 260
12.4 13.0 12.4
4.62 4.17 4.62
8.74 7.89 8.74
3.890 3.888 3.897
219 220 222
12.6 12.6 12.4
4.24 4.24 4.26
8.01 8.03 8.06
3.896 3.891 3.898
240 232 241
12.3 12.7 12.5
4.54 4.22 4.41
8.59 7.99 8.34
3.897 ± 0.002
241 ± 1
12.7 ± 0.2 4.67 ± 0.05
241
13.0
3.894 ± 0.002
241 ± 0
3.896 ± 0.001
240 ± 2
13.0 ± 0.0 4.44 ± 0.08 4.55 h 12.8 ± 0.1 4.65 ± 0.01
240
12.9
3.889 ± 0.002
240 ± 0
3.896 ± 0.002
240 ± 2
12.6 ± 0.0 4.57 ± 0.08 4.67 h 12.8 ± 0.2 4.65 ± 0.02
240
12.9
240 ± 0
13.0 ± 0.1 4.52 ± 0.07 4.62 h
3.897
3.896
3.896
f
f
f
3.891 ± 0.002
f
f
f
4.74
4.71
4.67
f
f
f
8.84 ± 0.09 8.97
f
8.40 ± 0.15 8.61 h 8.80 ± 0.02 8.91
f
8.65 ± 0.15 8.84 h 8.79 ± 0.04 8.84
f
8.55 ± 0.14 8.73 h
For the calculation of parameters, in general the nominal bead radii rb were upscaled by a factor of 1.105 to account for the packing density of the beads b If not stated otherwise, for bead models the value corresponding to the maximum vertex-to-vertex distance of the beads is given c Experimental values were adopted from the literature: SAXS data were taken from [19]; the molar mass of StP as estimated from SAXS is M = 170 kg/mol, based on ν = 0.729 cm3 /g [14]; for hydrodynamic reference data, consensus values derived from phosphorylases of different sources were used d Value corresponding to the maximum center-to-center distance of the beads e BC signifies that a background subtraction was performed and NBC denotes no background subtraction f Parameter calculated after rescaling the coordinates of the beads to match the mean R of the models used for averaging G g The edge length of the hexagonal lattice cells (voxel size) is given instead of r b h Value referring to the model with voxel size 0.3 nm
64
H. Durchschlag et al.
SAXS-based Modeling of C. callunae StP by GASBOR Because of its conceptual formulation, viz. separate modeling steps for protein and water moieties, the GASBOR approach [31, 32] seems to be more target-oriented for the modeling of hydrated protein structures. Therefore, we performed a detailed study for testing this approach in its reciprocal-space and real-space versions, in order to derive the optimum input and evaluation conditions. Accordingly, all P1–P2 models were computed by means of the reciprocal-space version (BC) and compared systematically. Again, symmetry constraints, shape biases and averaging procedures were varied. Furthermore, to obtain rapid estimates of models, also the real-space version was tried out. Figure 5 presents a gallery of selected models, illustrating the results for various model types of the reciprocaland real-space GASBOR runs. The overall shapes are similar to those obtained by the DAMMIN approach (Fig. 1). In the first instance, oblate spheroids are obtained. Except for a few examples (e.g. model P2PL, not shown), the shapes of the less time-consuming real-space runs are similar to the reciprocal-space runs. The most striking result, however, is the highly unrealistic distribution of the water dummies on the protein surface. As may be learnt from the accumulations of red water beads in Fig. 5, the dummies are placed quite unreasonably on the protein envelope, frequently accumulated in crevices or around poles of the particle. From the biological point of view and physical considerations as well, such an appearance is unacceptable. A homogeneous distribution of water molecules would rather realize the perception of a water shell, although this assumption is still missing the true placement of preferentially bound waters [35]. In the GASBOR program, the small water molecules are rather used as filling material for modulating the models than for elaborating biologically realistic hydrated models. To confine the multitude of models obtained, grand averages of reciprocal-space and real-space models of all constrained combinations used were created, applying the DAMAVER suite to already DAMAVERaged GASBOR models (Fig. 6). As a result, the overall impression of an oblate spheroid still remains. Comparing the experimental SAXS profiles, I(h) and p(r), with the functions derived from the various reciprocal-space GASBOR models (Fig. 7) reveals agreement of I(h) up to h about 1 nm−1 . In the h range between 1 and 4 nm−1 the agreement is half-decent only for the models representing the averages of the scattering curves of the ab initio models, calculated by GASBOR (black diamonds) or by means of Debye’s formula (blue diamonds). The scattering curves corresponding to averaged structures (red and green diamonds; colored lines) deviate considerably. The most obvious discrepancy in the p(r) profiles is observed for functions derived from the grand averages of
Fig. 5 Selected models of StP as obtained by applying the reciprocal-space or real-space GASBOR approaches to the experimental I(h) and p(r) functions, respectively. The symmetry constraints and shape biases used in the GASBOR analyses are given below the images. Beads representing the protein are displayed in gray, and beads symbolizing dummy water atoms in red. Each model is shown in three different views corresponding to 90◦ rotations around the horizontal or vertical axis. The models presented in the figure were selected by DAMSEL as reference models for the purpose of averaging over usually five models of the same type by means of the DAMAVER suite
the ab initio models (black and blue solid lines). In principle, a similar situation holds for the real-space GASBOR models (Fig. 8), the mentioned discrepancies between experimental curves and the profiles of the models, however, are much more expressed. Again, the key point for examining the validity of model calculations is the quantitative comparison of experimental and calculated molecule parameters. Table 2
Fig. 6 Grand averages of GASBOR models of StP, obtained by applying the DAMAVER suite once more to the already DAMAVERaged GASBOR models corresponding to the various combinations of constraints and biases. A: grand average of all reciprocal-space GASBOR models; B: grand average of the real-space GASBOR models except the models coded P2PL. The averaged structures consist only of protein beads; the beads representing dummy water atoms in the original GASBOR models were discarded in the DAMAVER process
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
65
Fig. 7 Comparison of I(h) (a) and p(r) (b) curves derived from reciprocal-space GASBOR models of StP with the experimentally obtained scattering functions (open black circles). The blue, red and green diamonds with error bars represent averages of Debye scattering curves (a) or p(r) functions (b) calculated from the protein coordinates of 50 ab initio models, after rescaling the bead radii to match the experimental V (blue diamonds), or of 10 averaged models (generated by means of the DAMAVER suite), after rescaling the bead radii and coordinates to match the experimental V and RG values (red diamonds) or the experimental V and the mean RG of the 50 ab initio models (green diamonds). The black diamonds (a) represent the average of the scattering curves calculated by GASBOR for the 50 ab initio models. Scattering functions calculated from the coordinates of the grand average of the 50 ab initio models (obtained by DAMAVERaging over 10 averaged models) are shown as solid lines. The black lines, representing the functions calculated from the original grand average, are nearly completely overlaid by the functions calculated after rescaling the bead radii to match the experimental V (blue lines). For the red lines, bead radii and coordinates were rescaled to match the experimental V and RG values; rescaling bead radii and coordinates to match the experimental V and the mean RG of the 50 ab initio models gave the green lines
Fig. 8 Comparison of I(h) (a) and p(r) (b) curves derived from real-space GASBOR models of StP with the experimentally obtained scattering functions (open black circles). The blue, red and green diamonds with error bars represent averages of Debye scattering curves (a) or p(r) functions (b) calculated from the protein coordinates of 45 ab initio models, after rescaling the bead radii to match the experimental V (blue diamonds), or of 9 averaged models (generated by means of the DAMAVER suite), after rescaling the bead radii and coordinates to match the experimental V and RG values (red diamonds) or the experimental V and the mean RG of the 45 ab initio models (green diamonds). The black diamonds represent the averages of the I(h) and p(r) functions provided by GASBOR for the 45 ab initio models. Scattering functions calculated from the coordinates of the grand average of the 45 ab initio models (obtained by DAMAVERaging over 9 averaged models) are shown as solid lines. The black lines, representing the functions calculated from the original grand average, are nearly completely overlaid by the functions calculated after rescaling the bead radii to match the experimental V (blue lines). For the red lines, bead radii and coordinates were rescaled to match the experimental V and RG values; rescaling bead radii and coordinates to match the experimental V and the mean RG of the 45 ab initio models gave the green lines
reveals the problems encountered with the GASBOR approach convincingly. The anticipation of most of the parameters under analysis (dmax , D, s) gave overestimates: the predicted values hit the experimental reference values to a lesser extent than the DAMMIN approach, regardless of the model constraints applied. The problem observed with the GASBOR data is presumably caused by the concept of a beaded chain and artificial water dummies for
consideration of protein hydration. The chain structure of the molecule and the neglect of the water dummies in the subsequent calculations require rigorous scaling procedures which also might contribute to enhanced discrepancies. The usage of both water and protein dummies in the case of the GASBOR approach is clearly opposed to the DAMMIN practice, where only one type of dummies is used to simulate the hydrated protein.
66
H. Durchschlag et al.
Table 2 Comparison of experimental and model parameters of StP from C. callunae. Models were obtained by the program GASBOR, applying ab initio (P1U) or constrained (P1O, P1P, P2) modelling conditions; models were derived from reciprocal-space or real-space versions of the program; for the reciprocal-space approach a background correction (BC) of the experimental scattering curves was used. Averaging of models was performed by employing the DAMAVER suite Nm
Nb
rb a (nm)
Experimental c Reciprocal-space GASBOR models, no symmetry constraint No shape bias: P1U 5 1605 ± 0 0.19 d No shape bias, 1406 0.325 f averaged Shape bias oblate: P1O 5 1605 ± 0 0.19 d Shape bias oblate, 1405 0.325 f averaged Shape bias prolate: P1P 5 1605 ± 0 0.19 d Shape bias prolate, 1406 0.325 f averaged Reciprocal-space GASBOR models, symmetry constraint C2 No shape bias: P2U 5 1604 ± 0 0.19 d No shape bias, 1406 0.325 f averaged Shape bias oblate 5 1604 ± 0 0.19 d (unknown): P2OU Shape bias oblate 1404 0.325 f (unknown): averaged Shape bias oblate 5 1604 ± 0 0.19d (along): P2OL Shape bias oblate 1785 0.3 f (along), averaged Shape bias oblate 5 1604 ± 0 0.19 d (across): P2OC Shape bias oblate 1785 0.3 f (across), averaged Shape bias prolate 5 1604 0.19 d (unknown): P2PU Shape bias prolate 1786 0.3 f (unknown), averaged Shape bias prolate 5 1604 ± 0 0.19 d (along): P2PL Shape bias prolate 1785 0.3 f (along), averaged Shape bias prolate 5 1604 ± 0 0.19 d (across): P2PC Shape bias prolate 1785 0.3 f (across), averaged Reciprocal-space GASBOR models, grand averages 0.19 d Averages of the mean values 10 g 1604 ± 0 for all types of models Grand average 10 g 2957 0.25 h of all averaged models
RG (nm)
dmax b (nm)
D (10−7 cm2 /s)
s (10−13 s)
3.89 ± 0.02
11.8 ± 0.0
4.3 ± 0.2
8.7 ± 0.3
3.836 ± 0.008 3.836 e
12.8 ± 0.2 12.8 e
4.86 ± 0.02 4.74 e
9.19 ± 0.03 8.96 e
3.829 ± 0.005 3.829 e
12.7 ± 0.1 12.9 e
4.80 ± 0.03 4.68 e
9.08 ± 0.05 8.86 e
3.833 ± 0.008 3.833 e
12.7 ± 0.2 12.8 e
4.86 ± 0.02 4.74 e
9.19 ± 0.04 8.96 e
3.834 ± 0.005 3.834 e
12.6 ± 0.3 13.0 e
4.85 ± 0.03 4.70 e
9.17 ± 0.05 8.90 e
3.828 ± 0.005
12.6 ± 0.1
4.82 ± 0.03
9.12 ± 0.05
3.828 e
13.0 e
4.68 e
8.86 e
3.835 ± 0.006
12.9 ± 0.3
4.83 ± 0.02
9.14 ± 0.04
3.835 e
13.0 e
4.71 e
8.91 e
3.827 ± 0.009
12.6 ± 0.2
4.82 ± 0.02
9.12 ± 0.05
4.69 e
8.87 e
4.87 ± 0.03
9.21 ± 0.06
4.74 e
8.96 e
4.88 ± 0.02
9.23 ± 0.04
4.75 e
8.99 e
4.86 ± 0.03
9.20 ± 0.06
4.73 e
8.96 e
4.85 ± 0.03
9.17 ± 0.05
4.77 e
9.03 e
3.827
e
3.834 ± 0.007 3.834
e
3.828 ± 0.005 3.828
e
3.834 ± 0.004 3.834
e
3.832 ± 0.003 3.832
e
12.7
e
12.7 ± 0.4 12.9
e
12.4 ± 0.1 12.9
e
12.8 ± 0.2 12.9
e
12.7 ± 0.1 12.6
e
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
67
Table 2 (continued) Nm
Nb
Real-space GASBOR models, no symmetry constraint No shape bias: P1U 5 1605 ± 0 No shape bias, averaged 1406 Shape bias oblate: P1O 5 1605 ± 0 Shape bias oblate, averaged 1405 Shape bias prolate: P1P 5 1605 ± 0 Shape bias prolate, averaged 1406 Real-space GASBOR models, symmetry constraint C2 No shape bias: P2U 5 1604 ± 0 No shape bias, averaged 1786 Shape bias oblate 5 1604 ± 0 (unknown): P2OU Shape bias oblate 1405 (unknown): averaged Shape bias oblate 5 1604 ± 0 (along): P2OL Shape bias oblate 2319 (along), averaged Shape bias oblate 5 1604 ± 0 (across): P2OC Shape bias oblate 1787 (across), averaged Shape bias prolate 5 1604 ± 0 (unknown): P2PU Shape bias prolate 1786 (unknown), averaged Shape bias prolate 5 1604 (along): P2PL Shape bias prolate 754 (along), averaged Shape bias prolate 5 1604 ± 0 (across): P2PC Shape bias prolate 1786 (across), averaged Real-space GASBOR models, grand averages 1604 ± 1 Averages of the mean values 9g for all types of models except type P2PL Grand average of all averaged 9 g 2850 models except type P2PL
rb a (nm)
RG (nm)
dmax b (nm)
D (10−7 cm2 /s)
s (10−13 s)
0.19 d 0.325 f 0.19 d 0.325 f 0.19 d 0.325 f
3.821 ± 0.007 3.821 e 3.825 ± 0.004 3.825 e 3.829 ± 0.007 3.829 e
12.8 ± 0.2 12.8 e 12.7 ± 0.3 12.9 e 12.9 ± 0.2 13.1 e
4.87 ± 0.01 4.76 e 4.83 ± 0.01 4.73 e 4.85 ± 0.02 4.71 e
9.21 ± 0.02 9.00 e 9.14 ± 0.03 8.95 e 9.18 ± 0.04 8.91 e
0.19 d 0.3 f 0.19 d
3.830 ± 0.008 3.830 e 3.820 ± 0.012
12.9 ± 0.2 13.2 e 12.5 ± 0.2
4.87 ± 0.03 4.72 e 4.83 ± 0.02
9.20 ± 0.05 8.94 e 9.14 ± 0.04
0.325 f
3.820
0.19 d
3.809 ± 0.012
0.275 f
3.809
0.19 d
3.817 ± 0.008
0.3 f
3.817
0.19 d
3.822 ± 0.006
0.3 f
3.822
0.19 d
3.830 ± 0.013
0.4 f
3.830
0.19 d
3.828 ± 0.012
0.3 f
3.828
0.19 d
3.822 ± 0.007
0.25 i
3.822
e
e
e
e
e
e
e
12.8
e
12.4 ± 0.1 12.6
e
12.8 ± 0.3 13.2
e
12.5 ± 0.3 12.8
e
12.8 ± 0.2 12.0
e
12.9 ± 0.2 13.2
e
12.7 ± 0.2
13.0
e
4.71
e
4.87 ± 0.03 4.78
e
4.80 ± 0.04 4.72
e
4.86 ± 0.01 4.72
e
4.58 ± 0.03 4.52
e
4.88 ± 0.02 4.76
e
4.85 ± 0.03
4.78
e
8.91
e
9.22 ± 0.06 9.05
e
9.08 ± 0.07 8.92
e
9.20 ± 0.02 8.94
e
8.67 ± 0.06 8.55
e
9.22 ± 0.05 9.00
e
9.18 ± 0.05
9.05
e
With all models, the bead radii rb were upscaled by appropriate factors to match the experimental volume of V = 290 nm3 For bead models the value corresponding to the maximum vertex-to-vertex distance of the beads is given c Experimental values were adopted from the literature: SAXS data were taken from [19]; the molar mass of StP as estimated from SAXS is M = 170 kg/mol, based on ν = 0.729 cm3 /g [14]; for hydrodynamic reference data, consensus values derived from phosphorylases of different sources were used d For the calculation of parameters the nominal bead radii r were upscaled by a factor of about 1.846 to match the experimental V b e Parameter calculated after rescaling the coordinates of the beads to match the mean R of the models used for averaging G f For the calculation of parameters the nominal bead radii r were upscaled by a factor of about 1.128 to match the experimental V b g Number of different types of models included h For the calculation of parameters the nominal bead radii r were upscaled by a factor of about 1.144 to match the experimental V b i For the calculation of parameters the nominal bead radii r were upscaled by a factor of about 1.158 to match the experimental V b a
b
68
Models of Rabbit GP and E. coli MalP Based on the Crystal Structures The availability of the high-resolution crystal structures of rabbit GP [2, 3, 20] and E. coli MalP [21–23] and of the respective atomic coordinates offers the possibility to use this type of information for designing anhydrous 3D protein structures, and, together with surface calcu-
Fig. 9 Space-filling models for anhydrous GP from rabbit muscle (A) and for anhydrous (B,C) and hydrated (D,E) MalP from E. coli in three different views corresponding to successive 90◦ rotations around two perpendicular axes. In A and B, the basic protein atoms derived from the crystal structures (Protein Data Bank files: 3GPB.pdb1 (A) and 1AHP.pdb1 (B)), however, without ligands and crystallographically found waters, are shown in the usual CPK colors (C in light gray, O in red, N in light blue, S in yellow); in C each AA residue is represented by a single bead placed at the mass center of gravity of the AA residue and having a volume identical to the sum of volumes of the constituent atoms. The hydrated models were obtained by usage of the surface calculation program SIMS (rprobe = 0.145 nm, ddot = 300 nm−2 ) followed by application of the hydration algorithm implemented in our programs HYDCRYST (D: Nw = 3556, calculated using Vw = 0.0244 nm3 , Kuntz hydration values, fK = 2.5) and HYDMODEL (E: Nw = 3521, calculated using Vw = 0.0244 nm3 , Kuntz hydration values, f K = 2.0). The hydration waters are displayed in green
H. Durchschlag et al.
lation and advanced hydration programs, for constructing hydrated protein models as well (Fig. 9). The anhydrous models of the enzymes from both sources (panels A and B) reveal oblate particles with twofold symmetry and are, in general terms, of similar appearance. Panels B and C show space-filling models of MalP, with beads representing either the atoms or the AA residues. Application of the surface calculation program SIMS [47] together with the hydration algorithm HYDCRYST [35, 49] unravels the finding of a water sheath (panel D), with many water molecules covering the protein envelope. Owing to some hydrophobic patches on the protein surface, however, the protein is not completely engulfed by the water molecules. A similar coverage of the protein surface by water molecules is achieved when AA-residue-based models are used instead of models derived from the atomic coordinates (panel E). Modeling water molecules to AAresidues-based protein models requires use of the hydration program HYDMODEL [48, 49]. Attaching water molecules to the anhydrous 3D structures of rabbit GP and E. coli MalP by means of our special hydration approaches yields similarly hydrated models. It is quite obvious that their appearance rather reflects biochemical relevance than the previously mentioned GASBOR models.
Fig. 10 Comparison of I(h) (a) and p(r) (b) curves derived from hydrated models of rabbit muscle GP (solid lines) and E. coli MalP (dashed lines) with the experimentally obtained functions for StP from C. callunae (open circles). The calculated SAXS profiles are based on the hydrated models (as shown in panels D and E of Fig. 9, for instance, for MalP). The electron densities of the beads were taken into account appropriately
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
69
In Fig. 10 the I(h) and p(r) curves deduced from the hydrated models of rabbit GP and E. coli MalP based on their crystal structures are compared with the corresponding experimental profiles of C. callunae StP. Despite some slight disagreements between observed and predicted profiles, the overall impression is that of reasonable conformity. In Tables 3 and 4 the calculated structural and hydrodynamic parameters of rabbit GP and E. coli MalP are listed in dependence on the most important input variables, rw , Vw and f K . In spite of a substantial influence of f K on the number of bound water molecules (Nw varying between approx. 2500 and 4500), the predicted values for RG , D and s differ only insignificantly. The anticipated values for s yield slight overestimates if compared to the consensus values of phosphorylases from various sources, in particular when the crystal data for rabbit GP have been applied for such a comparison. The discrepancies observed in scattering and hydrodynamic data for the three enzymes under consideration have to be considered in the light of the a priori given differ-
ences. There are subtle distinctions in the enzyme sources (C. callunae StP, rabbit GP, E. coli MalP) and in the molecular size and shape of the particles as well as in the mode of their investigation (solution scattering of C. callunae StP, crystallographic studies of rabbit GP and E. coli MalP). Consequently, the two bacterial enzymes of similar size (C. callunae StP, E. coli MalP) exhibit a more pronounced agreement in the SAXS profiles and molecule parameters. Superpositions of anhydrous models of MalP from E. coli, deduced from the crystallographic data, with the most important models of C. callunae StP, figured out on the basis of SAXS in conjunction with modeling studies, again cast a positive light on the relevance of the obtained solution models (Fig. 11). The trial-and-error model (panel A), the DAMMIN models (panels B and C) and the GASBOR models (panels D and E) exhibit a rough overall conformity of all the models. A critical peer assessment, however, discloses slight differences with respect to some mass clusters at certain protein positions, both on the surface and the molecule interior. This may be recognized from the fig-
Table 3 Comparison of calculated parameters for hydrated rabbit GP models as obtained by the hydration program HYDCRYST on the basis of the crystal structure (3GPB), together with several input parameters (rw , Vw , f K ). Potential positions of hydration waters were derived by the preceding surface calculation program SIMS applied to the crystal structure of the anhydrous apo-enzyme, using ddot = 300 nm−2 and rprobe = 0.14, 0.145, and 0.15 nm, respectively; the number of potential water positions varied between 208 000 and 219 000 fK
Crystal structure, anhydrous b 0 0 Reduced anhydrous model b Hydrated models (HYDCRYST) e rw = 0.14 nm, 1.0 Vw = 0.0220 nm3 1.5–4.0 rw = 0.145 nm, Vw = 0.0244 nm3
rw = 0.15 nm, Vw = 0.0270 nm3
a
Nw
0 0 2939 3972 ± 301
1.0
2792
1.5–4.0
3710 ± 258
1.0
2609
1.5–4.0
3440 ± 245
Nb a
RG (nm)
13 558 1666
3.859 3.835
16 497 4605 f 17 530 ± 301 5638 ± 301 f 16 350 4458 f 17 268 ± 258 5376 ± 258 f 16 167 4275 f 16 998 ± 245 5106 ± 245 f
3.950 c 3.922 d 4.000 ± 0.014 c 3.969 ± 0.014 d 3.930 c 3.934 d 3.967 ± 0.010 c 3.980 ± 0.013 d 3.900 c 3.941 d 3.922 ± 0.007 c 3.988 ± 0.014 d
c d
V (nm3 )
D (10−7 cm2 /s)
s (10−13 s)
234.1 234.0
4.67
9.78
4.53
9.69
4.51 ± 0.00
9.66 ± 0.01
4.51
9.65
4.49 ± 0.00
9.61 ± 0.01
4.50
9.62
4.47 ± 0.01
9.56 ± 0.01
298.6 298.6 321 ± 7 321 ± 7 302.2 302.2 325 ± 6 325 ± 6 304.5 304.5 327 ± 7 327 ± 7
Total number of beads (protein + water) The maximum diameter, dmax , of the anhydrous model (vertex-to-vertex distance) amounts to 12.96 or 13.07 nm, as revealed from the atomic or AA coordinates, respectively c Value calculated by HYDCRYST, using coordinates, radii and electron densities of the beads d Value calculated by HYDRO, using coordinates and radii of the beads e For the calculations, M = 192.234 kg/mol (obtained from the PDB file) and ν = 0.729 cm3 /g [14] were used. For comparison, the values for maximum hydration based on the values by Kuntz [50], and for the hydration of accessible AA residues obtained from HYDCRYST, are given: Nw = 4258 (δ1 = 0.399 g g−1 ) and, depending on rw , Nw,acc = 3951–4045 (δ1 = 0.370–0.379 g g−1 ) f The N water beads located by HYDCRYST are attached to the reduced anhydrous model w b
70
H. Durchschlag et al.
Table 4 Comparison of calculated parameters for hydrated E. coli MalP models as obtained by the hydration programs HYDCRYST and HYDMODEL on the basis of the crystal structure (1AHP), together with several input parameters (rw , Vw , f K ). Potential positions of hydration waters were derived by the preceding surface calculation program SIMS applied to the crystal structure of the anhydrous apoenzyme, using ddot = 300 nm−2 and rprobe = 0.14, 0.145, and 0.15 nm, respectively; the number of potential water positions varied between 184 000 and 191 000 fK
Crystal structure, anhydrous b 0 Reduced anhydrous model b 0 Hydrated models (HYDCRYST) e rw = 0.14 nm, 1.0 Vw = 0.0220 nm3 1.5–4.0 rw = 0.145 nm, Vw = 0.0244 nm3
rw = 0.15 nm, Vw = 0.0270 nm3
Nw
0 0 2670 3724 ± 319
1.0
2569
1.5–4.0
3481 ± 261
1.0
2434
1.5–4.0
3241 ± 228
Hydrated models (HYDMODEL) e rw = 0.145 nm, 1.0 Vw = 0.0244 nm3 1.5–4.0
Nb a
RG (nm)
12 732 1592
3.830 3.843
15 402 4262 f 16 456 ± 319 5316 ± 319f 15 301 4161 f 16 213 ± 261 5073 ± 261f 15 166 4026 f 15 973 ± 228 4833 ± 228f
3.929 c 3.927 d 3.989 ± 0.018c 3.982 ± 0.016d 3.906 c 3.937 d 3.951 ± 0.013c 3.991 ± 0.016d 3.875 c 3.946 d 3.901 ± 0.008c 4.001 ± 0.015d
2611
4203
3669 ± 309
5261 ± 309
c d
V (nm3 )
D (10−7 cm2 /s)
s (10−13 s)
219.9 219.9
4.73
9.52
4.54
9.13
4.51 ± 0.00
9.07 ± 0.01
4.52
9.10
4.49 ± 0.01
9.03 ± 0.01
4.50
9.06
4.47 ± 0.01
8.99 ± 0.01
4.57
9.19
4.51 ± 0.02
9.07 ± 0.05
278.5 278.5 302 ± 7 302 ± 7 282.6 282.6 305 ± 6 305 ± 6 285.6 285.6 307 ± 6 307 ± 6
3.906 g 283.6 3.943 d 3.956 ± 0.015g 309 ± 8 4.003 ± 0.018d
a
Total number of beads (protein + water) The maximum diameter, dmax , of the anhydrous model (vertex-to-vertex distance) amounts to 13.37 nm, as revealed from the atomic or AA coordinates, respectively c Value calculated by HYDCRYST, using coordinates, radii and electron densities of the beads d Value calculated by HYDRO, using coordinates and radii of the beads e For the calculations, M = 180.782 kg/mol (obtained from the PDB file) and ν = 0.729 cm3 /g [14] were used. For comparison, the values for maximum hydration based on the values by Kuntz [50], and for the hydration of accessible AA residues obtained from HYDCRYST, are given: Nw = 3916 (δ1 = 0.390 g g1 ) and, depending on rw , Nw,acc = 3540–3628 (δ1 = 0.353–0.362 g g1 ) f The N water beads located by HYDCRYST are attached to the reduced anhydrous model w g Value calculated by HYDMODEL, using coordinates, radii and electron densities of the beads b
ure by comparing the model derived from crystallography (gray beads) with the SAXS-based models (red beads). The occurrence of more distant bead spacings in the models derived from crystal data is in agreement with the finding of elevated dmax values (Table 4), in comparison with the maximum distances of the solution models found by DAMMIN or GASBOR (Tables 1 and 2). More experiments, outside the scope of this study, would be required to elucidate the causes of the remaining discrepancies.
Conclusions The application of advanced modeling techniques presents the rational basis for relating the results obtained from so-
lution scattering and hydrodynamic techniques, on the one hand, and from solution techniques and crystallography, on the other. This holds both for the comparison of model structures and molecular parameters. Of course, the combined use of different techniques of structural analysis is much more efficient than the application of a single method. SAXS-based ab initio modeling of protein structures is the latest, but a highly promising development in this field [39, 64–67]; this especially holds when it is coupled to hydrodynamic analyses [26, 38]. For obvious reasons, the expedient application of these modern techniques requires a systematic investigation of the scientific settings and fine adjustments of the input variables under a variety of conditions, together with probing different procedures for averaging the obtained models. Moreover, biomolecules
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
Fig. 11 Comparison of the crystal structure of MalP from E. coli with various models of C. callunae StP derived from SAXS. All images are shown in two different views corresponding to a 90◦ rotation around the horizontal axis and as central slabs. They represent superpositions of the anhydrous model (gray beads), excerpted from the crystallographic information, with SAXS models (red beads) based on trial-and-error [19] (A) or SA approaches (B: average of DAMMIN models P2U (BC); C: average of DAMMIN models P2OL (BC); D: average of reciprocal-space GASBOR models P2PU (BC); E: average of real-space GASBOR models P2U; all averages were obtained by the DAMAVER suite)
of quite different size, shape and substructure have to be analyzed critically. In the present study, this was performed for the enzyme phosphorylase and the most prominent programs in this area, DAMMIN [27] and GASBOR [31, 32] in the SAXS field, and HYDRO [59, 60] in hydrodynamics. The results of the solution data may also be compared to those derived from crystallography, if appropriate contributions of hydration are taken into account [35, 48, 49]. The following conclusions can be drawn: (i) Biologically reasonable low-resolution shapes of proteins can be obtained by the SAXS-based ab initio approaches DAMMIN and GASBOR. With both programs quite correct low-resolution shapes of hydrated particles are obtained. Since both SA programs exploit dummy beads, the localization of the individual dummies (either protein or water beads), however, are of no biological significance.
71
(ii) The most efficient shape predictions can be obtained when constrained modeling is applied, provided that the applied constraints are reasonable. This modus operandi is clearly superior to the performance of a strictly ab initio approach. Use of erroneous constraints may lead to unrealistic shape predictions. (iii) Application of DAMMIN and GASBOR in combination with HYDRO, together with the known potential of SAXS and AUC knowledge, allows various molecule properties to be anticipated correctly. Most astonishingly, the prediction of structural and hydrodynamic parameters may also be quite correct, if wrong modeling constraints are applied. Of course, the correct choice of conditions is superior to the usage of ill-conditioned constraints. (iv) The agreement of experimental data and calculated parameters is no ultimate proof of the correctness of a model under consideration. This unequivocally follows from the possible coincidence of data in the case of wrong models, which however fit the target SAXS profiles very well. This problem is also well known in SAXS analyses: usually only models which are equivalent in scattering are obtained [37]; in context with the application of ab initio modeling, this phenomenon is called the problem of uniqueness [41]. (v) Both for the shape reconstructions and the subsequent parameter predictions, the program DAMMIN is superior to the program GASBOR. Application of the reciprocal-space version of GASBOR exceeds the real-space version with respect to the accuracy of the data obtained. (vi) The comparison of the low-resolution SAXS-based shapes and parameters of the proteins with highresolution 3D structures and parameters derived therefrom also corroborates the practicability of the applied scattering and hydrodynamic modeling approaches. Hydrated models of biological significance, however, can only be obtained by employing advanced surface calculation programs (such as SIMS [47]) in connection with appropriate hydration algorithms (such as HYDCRYST or HYDMODEL [35, 48, 49]). Acknowledgement The authors are much obliged to several scientists and institutions for use of their computer programs: to D.I. Svergun for DAMMIN, GASBOR, the DAMAVER suite, GNOM and SUPCOMB, to Y.N. Vorobjev for SIMS, to J. García de la Torre for HYDRO, to R.A Sayle for RASMOL, to the SERC Daresbury Laboratory for the CCP4 suite, and to the Research Foundation of the State University of New York for VOLVIS, respectively. A.K. thanks the Austrian Academy of Sciences for support (APART fellowship).
72
H. Durchschlag et al.
References 1. Palm D, Klein HW, Schinzel R, Buehner M, Helmreich EJM (1990) Biochemistry 29:1099–1107 2. Acharya KR, Stuart DI, Varvill KM, Johnson LN (1991) Glycogen phosphorylase b: description of the protein structure. World Scientific, Singapore 3. Barford D, Hu S-H, Johnson LN (1991) J Mol Biol 218:233–260 4. Johnson LN (1992) FASEB J 6:2274–2282 5. Browner MF, Fletterick RJ (1992) Trends Biochem Sci 17:66–71 6. Schinzel R, Nidetzky B (1999) FEMS Microbiol Lett 171:73–79 7. Yunis AA, Fischer EH, Krebs EG (1960) J Biol Chem 235:3163–3168 8. Yunis AA, Fischer EH, Krebs EG (1962) J Biol Chem 237:2809–2815 9. Wang JH, Graves DJ (1963) J Biol Chem 238:2386–2389 10. Seery VL, Fischer EH, Teller DC (1967) Biochemistry 6:3315–3327 11. DeVincenzi DL, Hedrick JL (1967) Biochemistry 6:3489–3497 12. Sevilla CL, Fischer EH (1969) Biochemistry 8:2161–2171 13. Childress CC, Sacktor B (1970) J Biol Chem 245:2927–2936 14. Puchwein G, Kratky O, Gölker CF, Helmreich E (1970) Biochemistry 9:4691–4698 15. Cohen P, Duewer T, Fischer EH (1971) Biochemistry 10:2683–2694 16. Buc MH, Ullmann A, Goldberg M, Buc H (1971) Biochimie 53:283–289 17. Chebotareva NA, Harding SE, Winzor DJ (2001) Eur J Biochem 268:506–513 18. Wang Z-X, Tsuruta H, Honda Y, Tachi-iri Y, Wakabayashi K, Amemiya Y, Kihara H (1989) Biophys Chem 33:153–160 19. Weinhäusel A, Griessler R, Krebs A, Zipper P, Haltrich D, Kulbe KD, Nidetzky B (1997) Biochem J 326:773–783 20. Johnson LN, Barford D (1990) J Biol Chem 265:2409–2412 21. O’Reilly M, Watson KA, Schinzel R, Palm D, Johnson LN (1997) Nature Struct Biol 4:405–412
22. Watson KA, Schinzel R, Palm D, Johnson LN (1997) EMBO J 16:1–14 23. Watson KA, McCleverty C, Geremia S, Cottaz S, Driguez H, Johnson LN (1999) EMBO J 18:4619–4632 24. Rath VL, Fletterick RJ (1994) Nature Struct Biol 1:681–690 25. Lin K, Rath VL, Dai SC, Fletterick RJ, Hwang PK (1996) Science 273:1539–1541 26. Zipper P, Durchschlag H, Krebs A (2005) In: Scott DJ, Harding SE, Rowe AJ (eds) Analytical ultracentrifugation: techniques and methods, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge UK, in press 27. Svergun DI (1999) Biophys J 76:2879–2886 28. Chacón P, Morán F, Díaz JF, Pantos E, Andreu JM (1998) Biophys J 74:2760–2775 29. Chacón P, Díaz JF, Morán F, Andreu JM (2000) J Mol Biol 299:1289–1302 30. Walter D, Cohen FE, Doniach S (2000) J Appl Crystallogr 33:350–363 31. Svergun DI, Petoukhov MV, Koch MHJ (2001) Biophys J 80:2946–2953 32. Petoukhov MV, Svergun DI (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:540–544 33. Boeckmann B, Bairoch A, Apweiler R, Blatter M-C, Estreicher A, Gasteiger E, Martin MJ, Michoud K, O’Donovan C, Phan I, Pilbout S, Schneider M (2003) Nucleic Acids Res 31:365–370 34. Berman HM, Westbrook J, Feng Z, Gilliland G, Bhat TN, Weissig H, Shindyalov IN, Bourne PE (2000) Nucleic Acids Res 28:235–242 35. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2003) Eur Biophys J 32:487–502 36. Durchschlag H (1975) Biophys Struct Mechanism 1:169–188 37. Glatter O, Kratky O (eds) (1982) Small angle X-ray scattering. Academic, London 38. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:509–514 39. Svergun DI (2000) J Appl Crystallogr 33:530–534 40. Svergun DI (1992) J Appl Crystallogr 25:495–503
41. Volkov VV, Svergun DI (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:860–864 42. Kozin MB, Svergun DI (2001) J Appl Crystallogr 34:33–41 43. Heller WT, Abusamhadneh E, Finley N, Rosevear PR, Trewhella J (2002) Biochemistry 41:15654–15663 44. Krebs A, Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2004) Biophys J 87:1173–1185 45. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2005) In: Scott DJ, Harding SE, Rowe AJ (eds) Analytical ultracentrifugation: techniques and methods, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge UK, in press 46. Connolly ML (1993) J Mol Graph 11:139–141 47. Vorobjev YN, Hermans J (1997) Biophys J 73:722–732 48. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2001) Biophys Chem 93:141–157 49. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2002) J Phys Condens Matter 14:2439–2452 50. Kuntz ID (1971) J Am Chem Soc 93:514–516 51. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2002) Physica A 304:283–293 52. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2002) Physica A 314:613–622 53. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2002) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 119:131–140 54. Durchschlag H, Zipper P (2004) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 127:98–112 55. Sayle RA, Milner-White EJ (1995) Trends Biochem Sci 20:374–376 56. Collaborative Computational Project, Number 4 (1994) Acta Cryst D50:760–763 57. Avila R, He T, Hong L, Kaufman A, Pfister H, Silva C, Sobierajski L, Wang S (1994) In: Bergeron R, Kaufman A (eds) Proceedings IEEE Visualization ’94, IEEE Computer Society, Washington DC, p 31–38 58. Glatter O (1980) Acta Phys Austriaca 52:243–256 59. García de la Torre J, Navarro S, López Martínez MC, Díaz FG, López Cascales JJ (1994) Biophys J 67:530–531 60. García de la Torre J, Huertas ML, Carrasco B (2000) Biophys J 78:719–730
Ab initio and Constrained Modeling of Phosphorylase
61. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (1997) Prog Colloid Polym Sci 107:58–71 62. Carrasco B, García de la Torre J, Zipper P (1999) Eur Biophys J 28:510–515
63. Zipper P, Durchschlag H (2005) Physica Scripta T118:228–232 64. Svergun DI, Koch MHJ (2002) Curr Opin Struct Biol 12:654–660
73
65. Svergun DI, Koch MHJ (2003) Rep Prog Phys 66:1735–1782 66. Koch MHJ, Vachette P, Svergun DI (2003) Q Rev Biophys 36:147–227 67. Takahashi Y, Nishikawa Y, Fujisawa T (2003) J Appl Crystallogr 36:549-552
Progr Colloid Polym Sci (2006) 131: 74–82 DOI 10.1007/2882_006 © Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Published online: 22 February 2006
Andrés G. Salvay Christine Ebel
Andrés G. Salvay Instituto de Física de Líquidos y Sistemas Biológicos, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, c.c. 565, B1900BTE La Plata, Argentina Andrés G. Salvay · Christine Ebel (u) Laboratoire de Biophysique Moléculaire, Institut de Biologie Structurale, UMR 5075 CEA-CNRS-UJF, 41 rue Jules Horowitz, F-38027 Grenoble Cedex 01, France e-mail:
[email protected]
BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS
Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Detergent in Solution
Abstract We have characterized the hydrodynamic behaviour in H2 O and D2 O of two detergents, dodecyl-β-Dmaltoside (DDM) and octaethylene glycol monododecyl ether (C12 E8 ), by analysing sedimentation velocity profiles obtained with interference optics in terms of continuous particle distribution and non-interacting species. The analysis in H2 0 provides values for the sedimentation and diffusion coefficients that give aggregation numbers of 130 and 115 for DDM and C12 E8 , respectively, close to that given in the literature. The analysis of the number of interference fringes as a function of detergent concentration gave values
Introduction The characterization of the association states of membrane proteins in solution is rather difficult and often the subject of controversy. For example, the native state of rhodopsin [1–4] and of ethidium multidrug resistance protein (EmrE) [5–9] were recently the object of debates; proteins have associated with them detergent and lipids in unknown but sometimes large amounts: see for reviews: [10, 11]. As recent examples, about 4 gram per gram in the case of EmrE [6, 9]; 0.5 gram per gram in the case of renal Na+ -, K+ -APTase [12]. Also, protein-detergent complexes coexist with detergent micelles of similar sizes. The effect on protein self-association of changing the solvent composition is poorly understood [13–18], and these studies participate to the more general purpose of understanding membrane protein folding and oligomerization [19–21].
for the critical micelle concentration and refractive index increments that are also in good agreement with published values. The values of the partial specific volumes of DDM and C12 E8 , obtained by sedimentation in H2 O and D2 O – where C12 E8 floats – are identical to those obtained from density measurements. These results indicate that sedimentation velocity has good potential for proper characterisation of detergent-solubilized proteins. Keywords Analytical ultracentrifugation · Detergents · Membrane · Proteins
Analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC), including sedimentation velocity (SV) is an essential technique for studying the association and interactions of macromolecular assemblies, because it is firmly based on rigorous hydrodynamic and thermodynamic theory and benefits from recent progress in data analysis [22–24]. In the last years, SV has become a reliable technique for determination of mass and hydrodynamic radius for solutions containing one or two types of non-interacting macromolecules [25– 28]. For interacting systems, recent data treatments allows SV to provide reliable values for the association constants and kinetics of association/dissociation [28–31], and, in the case of weak interactions, second virial coefficientsrelated to weak inter-particle potentials and characterizing potentially good crystallization conditions [32]. Analysis of SV experiments in terms of size distribution is extremely powerful for evaluation of sample polydispersity and concentration dependency phenom-
Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Detergent in Solution
ena [33–35]. Using solvents of different densities gives the density properties of the particle (related to composition) [36, 37]; the potential of SV was recently described in detail in H2 O/D2 O solvents: for a heterogeneous polyelectrolyte polymer, the effective charge was determined [38]. Using different optics such as absorbance and interference in SV allows in theory the characterization of multi-component systems if the partners have different spectral properties, which was recently investigated [39]. For the study of membrane proteins, these new approaches are of major interest. Some years ago, different detergents, which either absorb UV light or were monitored using a trace of fluorescent dye, were studied mainly by equilibrium sedimentation [40]. But the analysis was not appropriate for further studies of the detergent associated with membrane proteins. The analysis of SV in terms of size distribution, using both absorbance and interference optics, has the potential to evaluate the amount of amphiphile bound to the proteins. This is because the absorbance of detergent and proteins is different: for example, most detergents do not absorb light at 280 nm. On the other hand, the interference optics depends on the concentration of all partners of the complex. Also, the concentration of “free” detergent can be estimated by the amount of detergent micelles: in a number of experimental studies, this parameter – while essential for thermodynamic analysis – in general is far from being known, because of the protocols used for protein purification and the difficulty of proper dialysis with detergents. SV, through measurements in solvents of different densities, by using H2 O and D2 O, can be used to evaluate the density of the particles which can give insight to their compositions. The preliminary step is to check if the detergent itself can be properly described. Difficulties can arise from the equilibrium between monomer and micelle, and from their low buoyancy. Also, a slightly different behaviour in D2 O – a different aggregation number, for example – can-
75
not be a priori excluded. Finally, most of the detergents do not absorb UV light and have to be detected using interference optics, which provides a signal superimposed with systematic noise. We will demonstrate here that the concentration in the ultracentrifuge and the partial specific volume of two detergents can be determined with accuracy by SV with interference optics. The detergents investigated here – dodecyl-β-D-maltoside (DDM) and octaethylene glycol monododecyl ether (C12 E8 ) – have been chosen because they are commonly used for the solubilization and stabilization of membrane proteins and assemblies. Their chemical structures are given in Scheme 1. Also, their buoyant properties differ: DDM will sediment in dilute aqueous solutions, while C12 E8 has a density close to water, and is therefore almost invisible to the centrifugal field.
Theoretical Background For each homogeneous ideal solute the sedimentation, i.e. the evolution of the weight concentration, c, with time, t, and radial position, r, is given by the Lamm equation: (∂c/∂t) = −1/r∂/∂r[r(csω2r − D∂c/∂r)] ,
(1)
ω being the angular velocity of the rotor. The sedimentation coefficient, s, and the diffusion coefficient, D, are related to other properties of the macromolecule: buoyant molar mass, Mb , and hydrodynamic radius, RH , and to the solvent viscosity, η◦ : D = kT/6πη◦ RH , s = Mb /NA 6πη◦ RH ,
(2) (3)
k being Bolzman’s constant, T the temperature, NA Avogradro’s number. Mb is related to the molar mass, M, and partial specific volume, v¯ , of the particle and to the solvent density, ρ ◦ : Mb = M(1 − ρ ◦ v¯ ) .
(4)
In the case of a detergent micelle, M is related to the aggregation number Nagg through the molar mass of the monomer Mmonomer : Nagg = M/Mmonomer .
(5)
Experiments performed in D2 O solvents can provide v¯ determination, if the macromolecule assembly (Nagg in the case of detergent) and shape (RH ) is unaffected by isotopic substitution. The Svedberg relation in the D2 O solvent, with the corresponding index D, is: sD = MbD /NA 6πη◦D RH ,
(6)
If RH does not change,RMb , the ratio of the buoyancy molar masses in D2 O and H2 O solvents, reduces to: Scheme 1 Chemical Structure of DDM and C12 E8
RMb = MbD /MbH = s D η◦D /sη◦ .
(7)
76
A.G. Salvay · C. Ebel
Because of the substitution of labile H for D, the mass of the particle increases to MD in the D2 O solvent, while isotopic substitution does not change its volume. As a consequence, the partial specific volume in D2 O can be expressed as a function of v¯ : v¯ D = v¯ M/MD , then, from ◦ v) = M((M /M)− Eq. 4: MbD = MD (1 − (M/MD )ρD ¯ D ◦ ◦ ρD v¯ ), and RMb = ((MD /M) − ρD v¯ )/(1 − ρ ◦v¯ ), provides a relation allowing to extraction of v¯ from RMb : ◦ v¯ = (MD /M − RMb )/(ρD − RMb ρ ◦ ) .
(8)
Thus, RMb decreases slowly from 1 (¯v close to 0) to zero ◦ ) and more and more rapidly as v approaches (¯v = 1/ρD ¯ ◦ < v < 1/ρ ◦ , R ◦ 1/ρ (RMb infinitely negative). For 1/ρD ¯ Mb is negative and the macromolecule floats in D2 O and sediments in H2 O. The closer to 1 is the value of v¯ , the more accurate its estimate from RMb . In addition, uncertainties on MD /M entail small errors on v¯ for v¯ close to 1. We have shown previously that, when RMb is close to 1 (low values of v¯ ), the values of v¯ derived from it strongly depend on the MD /M ratio. Conversely, uncertainties on MD /M entail smaller errors on v¯ when RMb values move farther away from 1. For example, the values of v¯ calculated from RMb values of 0.9, 0.75 and 0.3 with MD /M values of 1.000 or 1.016 – corresponding to 0 and 100% exchange of the exchangeable H for bovine serum albumin and 0 and 84% exchange of the exchangeable H for white egg lysozyme – differ by 0.07, 0.04 and 0.02 ml g−1 , respectively. It is therefore most important to use good estimates of MD /M when measuring low partial specific volumes [38].
Materials and Methods All experiments were performed at 20 ◦ C. Preparation of the Solutions DDM (Anatrace) was dried as a power over P2 O5 during three days. Solutions were prepared by its weighted dissolution in H2 O and D2 O. C12 E8 (Anatrace), obtained as a solution at 100 mg per ml of H2 O, was diluted in H2 O and mixtures of H2 O and D2 O. The weights of detergent and water were measured with a Mettler AE240 balance with a precision of 10−5 g. Density Measurements Solution and solvent densities, ρ and ρ ◦ (g ml−1 ), were measured with a DMA5000 density meter (Anton Paar, Graz, Austria) with a precision of 2 × 10−6 g ml−1 . The partial specific volume v¯ (ml g−1 ) was obtained from the dependency of ρ–ρ ◦ with the detergent concentration c (g ml−1 ), calculated from the weights of detergent and water in the solution and ρ: ∂ρ/∂c = (1 − v¯ ρ ◦ ) .
(9)
Analytical Ultracentrifugation Sedimentation velocity experiments were performed on a Beckman Coulter XL-I analytical ultracentrifuge at a rotor speed of 42 000 rpm (the maximum rotor speed recommended for the standard central pieces that we used). Typically the sample and solvent (400 µl each) were loaded into a double sector cell of optical path 1.2 cm equipped with sapphire windows. The experiments were performed over more than 16 hours and sedimentation profiles of the detergents solutions acquired using interference optics every 2 minutes. SV data were analysed with the c(s) analysis of the program Sedfit (version 8.9) available at www.analyticalultra centrifugation.com [35]. The c(s) method deconvolutes the effects of diffusion broadening, which results in highresolution sedimentation coefficient distributions. This is done by assuming a relationship between the sedimentation and diffusion coefficients, through reasonable values of v¯ , of the frictional ratio f/ f ◦ , of ρ ◦ and of the solvent viscosity η◦ . f/ f ◦ links the value of RH to the minimum theoretical value, R◦H , corresponding to a non-hydrated ◦ . A value of 1.25 corresponds to sphere: RH = f/ f ◦ RH a globular usually hydrated particle. The analysis is based on finite element solutions of the Lamm equation (Eq. 1) and algebraically accounts for the systematic noise of the experimental data. Further details are given in the web site. Typically, we considered 60 experimental profiles corresponding to a total of 16 hours of sedimentation. During analysis, the Lamm equation was simulated for 200 particles in the range [0.01S, 4S] for DDM and C12 E8 , and [−1S, −0.01S] for C12 E8 in D2 O/H2 O mixtures. We supplied, for the detergents, the v¯ values determined by us via densimetry. We also supplied f/ f ◦ = 1.25 and the experimental values of ρ ◦ and η◦ , the latter being measured using a AMVn viscosity meter (Anton Paar, Graz, Austria): ρ ◦ = 0.998282 g ml−1 and η◦ = 1.00 cP for H2 O; ρ ◦ = 1.105166 g ml−1 and η◦ = 1.239 cP for D2 O. For mixtures of 98, 75, 50, and 0% D2 O, the densities are 1.101301, 1.076002, 1.051299, and 0.998282 g ml−1 and the viscosities are 1.232, 1.178, 1.120, and 1.00 cP, respectively. All the c(s) distributions were calculated with a regularization procedure (confidence level of 0.7). The non-interacting species model analysis of Sedfit was also used, which evaluates, for each species, independent values of the sedimentation and diffusion coefficients, without assumptions about the shape of the molecules or assemblies. For the sedimentation of DDM solutions, six samples at different concentrations were globally analysed with a two non-interacting species model (monomer and micelles), using the program Sedphat (http://www.analytical ultracentrifugation.com/sedphat/sedphat.htm). This analysis evaluates globally for each species the values of the sedimentation and diffusion coefficients, while providing
Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Detergent in Solution
for each sample the absorbance or fringe shift characterizing the species.
The refractive index increments ∂n/∂c (ml g−1 ) were calculated from the number of fringes J of interference of the sedimenting species measured in the analytical ultracentrifuge at different detergent concentrations c (g ml−1 ), according to ∂n/∂c = (∂J/∂c)(λ/Kl) ,
Table 1 Characterization of DDM and C12 E8 by sedimentation velocity Parameter
Determination of the Refractive Index Increments from Analytical Ultracentrifugation
(10)
with λ the wavelength of the laser (675 × 10−7 cm), K = 1 the magnifying coefficient, and l the optical path of the cell (in cm).
Results and Discussion Characterization of DDM and C12 E8 in H2 O Partial Specific Volumes from Density Measurements. Figure 1 shows the results of the density measurements. The solution density increases linearly with the detergent concentration. The v¯ values are determined from the slopes of the plot. Knowledge of the absolute concentration of the detergent is thus required. For DDM, it was estimated from the weight of the dried detergent powder. For C12 E8 , we used the nominal value given for the commercial solution. Values for v¯ of 0.82 ± 0.01 and 0.97 ± 0.02 ml g−1 were obtained for DDM and C12 E8 respectively, considering 5% incertitude on the concentrations. The values of v¯ are close to those reported for these detergents in the literature [11] (see Table 1).
Fig. 1 Determination of v¯ . The density increment ρ–ρ◦ , with ρ and ρ◦ the solution and solvent densities, is plotted as a function of the detergent concentration. The lines connecting the experimental points are the linear regressions of the data
77
Mmonomer (Da) v¯ (ml g−1 ) v¯ (ml g−1 ) v¯ (ml g−1 ) s0 (S) ks (ml g−1 ) D0 (F) M (kDa) Nagg Nagg ˚ RH (A) CMC (mg ml−1 ) CMC (mg ml−1 ) ∂n/∂c (ml g−1 ) ∂n/∂c (ml g−1 )
Method (our work) or reference
density SV in H2 0 and D2 0 [11] SV, c(s) SV, c(s) SV, IS SV, from s0 and D0 SV, from M [11] SV, from D0 SV, c(s) [11] SV, c(s) [41]
DDM
C12 E8
511 538 0.82 ± 0.01 0.95 ± 0.02 0.815 ± 0.015 0.95 ± 0.01 0.81–0.837 3.12 ± 0.02 0.0 ± 0.1 6.34 ± 0.01 67 ± 2
0.973 0.73 ± 0.01 11.6 ± 1.0 5.61 ± 0.05 62 ± 4
130 ± 4 110–140 34 ± 1 0.11 ± 0.02 0.092 0.143 ± 0.001 –
115 ± 8 90–120 38 ± 2 0.12 ± 0.04 0.048 0.121 ± 0.02 0.134
Index 0 is given for values extrapolated to infinite dilution. SV: sedimentation velocity. c(s): size distribution analysis. IS: independent species analysis.
Sedimentation Velocity of DDM and C12 E8 in H2 O: General Behavior. The sedimentation of DDM and C12 E8 in H2 O for 8 hours at 42 000 rpm can be compared in Fig. 2, panels 1A and 2A. However, for most of the sample and particularly for C12 E8 , the analysis was made considering a total of 16 hours typically. DDM sediments as a nice boundary while C12 E8 sediments very slowly and without depletion at the meniscus position. This is expected, since the density of C12 E8 is close to that of the solvent. Size Distribution Analysis of DDM and C12 E8 in H2 O. The c(s) analysis was used first to describe the detergent solution in term of particle distributions. For DDM at 1.8 mg ml−1 , one major peak is obtained at 3.1S, which may reasonably be attributed to the detergent micelle (Fig. 2, Panels 1A-1C). The barely distinguishable signal below 0.1S in Fig. 2, Panel 1C may be monomer DDM. For DDM at 0.3, 0.6, 0.8, 1.8, 3.6, and 4.7 mg ml−1 , the same behavior is found, with one major peak corresponding to with the well-defined micelle (Fig. 2, Panel 1D). For C12 E8 at 1.8 mg ml−1 only one contribution at 0.7S is observed and is attributed to the detergent micelle (Fig. 2, Panels 2A–2C). The sedimentation of the monomer must be so slow that not distinguished from a slight baseline drift (considered by the program as time independent noise). For C12 E8 at 0.2, 1.8, 4.8, 9.5, and 14.4 mg ml−1 , the same behavior with one peak corresponding to the micelle is found (Fig. 2, Panel 2D).
78
A.G. Salvay · C. Ebel
Fig. 3 Concentration dependence of the sedimentation of DDM and C12 E8 . The inverse of the sedimentation coefficient s is plotted as a function of the detergent concentration. This dependence is analyzed by the equation s−1 = s0−1 + (ks /s0 )c, where s0 is the sedimentation coefficient extrapolated to zero concentration, c is the concentration (g ml−1 ), and ks is the concentration dependence coefficient (ml g−1 ). The lines connecting the experimental points are the linear regressions of the data
the concentrations in the range of investigation (up to 4.7 mg ml−1 ). All peaks in the c(s) distributions (Fig. 2, Panel 1D) are around 3.1S and the linear fit of s −1 (c) = s0−1 + ks s0−1 c (Fig. 3) gave s0 = 3.12 ± 0.02S and ks = 0.0 ± 0.1 ml g−1 . The explanation for the difference in the behavior of the two detergents is not clear.
Fig. 2 Sedimentation velocity in H2 O of 1: DDM, and 2: C12 E8 . Panels: A: selection of experimental data (dots) and fit to the data (continuous line) corrected for all systematic noises, for the detergents at 1.8 mg/ml. The last profiles correspond to 8 hours of sedimentation at 42 000 rpm; B superposition of the difference between the experimental and fitted curves; C corresponding c(s) distributions; D superimposition of the c(s) distributions for concentrations in the range 0.2–5 mg ml−1 for DDM and 0.2–15 mg ml−1 for C12 E8 . The sedimentation coefficient of C12 E8 decreases with increasing concentration (this effect is not observed for DDM)
Concentration Dependence of s. For C12 E8 the value of the sedimentation coefficient decreases from 0.72 S at the lower concentration of 0.2 mg ml−1 to 0.62S at the larger one of 14.4 mg ml−1 (Fig. 2, Panel 1D). This can be understood considering weak repulsive interparticle interactions related to excluded volume effects. Fitting s −1 (c) = s0−1 + ks s0−1 c (shown in Fig. 3) provided a limiting value of s at infinite dilution, s0 , of 0.73 ± 0.01S and a ks of 11.6 ± 1.0 ml g−1 . For DDM the value of the sedimentation coefficient is essentially not altered by
Analysis in Terms of Independent Species. Because the sample is homogeneous, the sedimentation velocity profiles were analyzed in terms of one (for C12 E8 ) – micelles – or two (for DDM) – monomers and micelles – non-interacting particles, providing independent estimations, for the micelle, of the sedimentation and apparent diffusion coefficients s and Dapp for the micelle. Due to the large effects of non-ideality mentioned above, through concentration dependencies of s (and in a minor way of D), on the shape boundary, Dapp is unrelated to the value of D at the considered concentration [32]. The extrapolation to infinite dilution of Dapp – which for C12 E8 was found to decrease when c increases, as shown in Fig. 4 – provides for the micelle values for the diffusion coefficient at infinite dilution (D0 ) reported on Table 1. The Molecular Characteristics of DDM and C12 E8 Micelles. The hydrodynamic radius RH , the molecular weight M and related aggregation number of the micelle Nagg , were derived from s0 and D0 (Eqs. 2 and 3) and are given in Table 1. The values for Nagg are close to those reported in the literature [11].
Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Detergent in Solution
79
for ∂n/∂c of 0.143 ml g−1 for DDM and 0.121 ml g−1 for C12 E8 are close to the value of 0.134 ml g−1 reported for C12 E8 and generally used for DDM [41]. This indicates that the estimation of the fringe number – and thus concentration – is precise and accurate, even at low detergent concentration. Global Analysis of DDM at Various Concentrations. Because of the nice superimposition of the c(s) distribution for DDM in the range 0.2–5 mg ml−1 , we used the data from these six sets of SV and analyzed them globally with a model for two non-interacting species, using the program Sedphat. The analysis – Fig. 6 and Table 2 – provides for the detergent monomer a sedimentation coefficient of 0.112S (the molar mass of the monomer was fixed) and, for the micelle, s = 3.15S, M = 67 kDa (Nagg = 130 ˚ These values are virmolecules of DDM) and RH = 34 A. Fig. 4 Concentration dependence of the apparent diffusion coeffitually identical to those shown in Table 1, which are decient Dapp of DDM and C12 E8 termined from s0 and D0 . The analysis provides for each SV experiment, the numbers of interference fringes corMicelle Concentration. The number of interference fringes responding to the monomer and the micelle species. If the obtained from the area under the peaks of the c(s) distribution is related to the micelle concentration. It increases linearly with the detergent concentration (Fig. 5). The slope of the linear regression gives the value of the refractive index increment ∂n/∂c (Eq. 10) and the critical micelle concentration (CMC) can be estimated from the intercept with the concentration axis. The values, reported in Table 1, compare well with those from the literature. Values for CMC of 0.11 mg ml−1 for DDM and of 0.12 mg ml−1 for C12 E8 are obtained, compared with values of 0.09 and 0.05 mg ml−1 , respectively, reported in [11]. Our estimates
Fig. 5 Concentration of the micelles in the ultracentrifuge. The concentrations are measured in terms of a number of fringes of interference. The lines connecting the experimental points are the linear regressions of the data. The insert shows the intersection of the lines with the concentration axis that determine the CMC of detergents
Fig. 6 Sedimentation of 1 0.3, 2 0.6, 3 0.8, 4 1.8, 5 3.6, and 6 4.7 mg DDM per ml of H2 O. The panels show: A the experimental interference data (dots) and fits to the data (continuous line) corrected for all systematic noises. The last profile corresponds to 8 hours of sedimentation at 42 000 rpm; B the difference between the experimental and fitted curves. The global analysis was undertaken with the program Sedphat using a two non-interacting species model (monomer and micelles). This analysis evaluates globally for each species the values of the sedimentation and diffusion coefficients, while providing for each sample the fringe shift J characterizing the species
80
A.G. Salvay · C. Ebel
Table 2 Global analysis of DDM in H2 O s1 (S)
M1 (kDa) Nagg
˚ s2 (S) RH1 (A)
˚ M2∗ (Da) RH2 (A)
3.15
67
34
511
130
0.112
7
Six sets of sedimentation profiles of DDM between 0.3 and 4.7 mg ml−1 in H2 0 were analyzed globally using the program Sedphat (available at analyticalultracentrifugation.com) in terms of two independent species. Species 1 represents the detergent micelle and species 2 the monomer. The molar mass of the monomer was fixed (underlined value)
former was imprecise, between 0 and 0.4 fringes, the latter gave precise values that were, again, virtually the same as those determined by the c(s) distribution for the micelle. This global analysis in term of non-interacting species is not appropriate for C12 E8 , for which non-ideal behaviour is observed. Sedimentation Velocity in H2 O and D2 O Partial Specific Volume of DDM from SV in D2 O and H2 O. For DDM at 1.6 mg ml−1 in D2 O, one peak is obtained in the c(s) analysis around 1.5S, which is attributed to the detergent micelle (Fig. 7, Panels 1A–1C). For DDM at 0.3, 0.8, 1.6, and 5.0 mg ml−1 , the same behaviour is found (Fig. 7, Panel 1D). The global analysis using Sedphat with a single non-interacting species model was also performed for this series of DDM samples. The analysis – not shown – provided for the micelles a value of sD = 1.55 S. From the ratio RMb of 0.61 calculated with Eq. 7, i.e. the ratio of the buoyant mass in D2 O and H2 O assuming the structure remains unchanged in the two solvents, and assuming 7H exchanged with D for each DDM in D2 O, we obtain (Eq. 8) v¯ = 0.815 ± 0.015 ml g−1 , i.e. virtually the same value as that obtained by density. Partial Specific Volume of C12 E8 from SV in H2 O/ D2 O Mixtures. Figure 7, Panels 2A–2C, show the flotation of 2 mg ml−1 of C12 E8 in 98% D2 O. One peak is obtained in the c(s) analysis around −0.5S, which as attributed to the flotation of the detergent micelle. Because of the small value of the sedimentation coefficient, the preciseness of the measurement is questionable. For this reason, the sedimentation of C12 E8 at 2 mg ml−1 was studied in 98, 75, 50, and 0% D2 O (Fig. 7, Panel 2D): the c(s) analysis shows one unique peak for each solvent condition, at −0.5, −0.22, 0.02, and 0.72S correspondingly. The plot of the product of the sedimentation coefficient with the solvent viscosity of C12 E8 in the different solvent mixtures is plotted as function of the solvent density ρ (Fig. 8). The linear relationship demonstrates the high precision of the estimation of the sedimentation coefficients, despite their
Fig. 7 Sedimentation velocity in D2 O of 1: DDM, and 2: C12 E8 . Panels A: selection of experimental data (dots) and fits to the data (continuous line) corrected for all systematic noises, for the detergents at 1.6 mg ml−1 (DDM) and 2 mg ml−1 (C12 E8 ). The last profiles correspond to 8 hours of sedimentation at 42 000 rpm; B superposition of the difference between the experimental and fitted curves; C corresponding c(s) distribution; D superimposition of the c(s) distributions for concentrations in the range 0.2–5 mg ml−1 (DDM), and for concentration 2 mg ml−1 (C12 E8 in 98, 75, 50, and 0% D2 O – left to right respectively in the Panel 2D-)
rather low values. The density of the detergent ρdet can be estimated as the density of the solvent −1.05651 g ml−1 – corresponding to a nul contrast: the density of the particle is the same of the solvent and is invisible to the centrifugal field (the complications related to H/D exchange are reasonably neglected because this density is close to 1, see the theoretical background). Assuming ρdet = 1/¯v, we obtain v¯ = 0.95 ml g−1 , a value identical to the value determined by density measurements and reported in Table 1. The same value is obtained from the RMb ratio of −0.88 (Eq. 7), considering 1 H/D exchange in D2 O.
Analytical Ultracentrifuge for the Characterization of Detergent in Solution
Fig. 8 Sedimentation of C12 E8 in mixtures of D2 O and H2 O. The product of the solvent viscosity η with the sedimentation coefficient s for 2 mg ml−1 of C12 E8 in different solvent mixtures is plotted as function of the solvent density ρ. The line connecting the experimental points is the linear regression of the data. The intersection of the line with the abscissa determines the reciprocal of v¯ for C12 E8
Concl