i
Biodiesel science and technology
ii
Related titles: Bioalcohol production: biochemical conversion of lignocellulosic biomass (ISBN 978-1-84569-510-1) Bioethanol is one of the main biofuels used as a petroleum substitute in transportation. Second generation bioalcohol production technology, based on highly efficient biochemical conversion, offers advantages over existing, energy-intensive bioethanol production processes. This book covers the process engineering, technology, modelling and integration of the entire production chain, from feedstock pretreatment on to hydrolysis, fermentation, and purification. Primarily reviewing bioethanol production, coverage extends to the production of longer-chain bioalcohols which will be elemental to the future of the industry. Handbook of biofuels production: processes and technologies (ISBN 978-1-84569-679-5) This book provides a comprehensive and systematic reference on the range of biomass conversion processes and technology. The initial section of the book covers the biofuels production chain and analysis of the environmental, social and economic issues surrounding biofuels production. Sections then follow on the entire range of chemical, biochemical and thermochemical biofuels production routes, with chapters reviewing in detail the development of individual processes, from principles and feedstocks, to batch and continuous processes and technology, and also modelling and optimisation. Handbook of waste management and co-product recovery in food processing, Volume 2 (ISBN 978-1-84569-391-6) Food processors are under pressure, from both consumers and legislation, to reduce the amount of waste they produce and to consume water and energy more efficiently. Handbook of waste management and co-product recovery in food processing provides essential information about the major issues and technologies involved in waste co-product valorisation, methods to reduce raw material waste and water and energy consumption, waste reduction in particular industry sectors and endwaste management. Chapters in Volume 2 focus on the transformation of food co-products using microorganisms and enzymes, advanced methods to optimise food manufacturing, such as closed-loop factories, non-food uses of food waste co-product and commercialisation issues. Details of these and other Woodhead Publishing books can be obtained by: visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 893694; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 891358 ext. 130; address: Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Granta Park, Great Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, UK) If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail: francis.
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
iii
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy: Number 7
Biodiesel science and technology From soil to oil Jan C. J. Bart, Natale Palmeri and Stefano Cavallaro
CRC Press Boca Raton Boston New York Washington, DC
Woodhead
publishing limited
Oxford Cambridge New Delhi
iv Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, Abington Hall, Granta Park, Great Abington, Cambridge CB21 6AH, UK www.woodheadpublishing.com Woodhead Publishing India Private Limited, G-2, Vardaan House, 7/28 Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi – 110002, India www.woodheadpublishingindia.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC, 6000 Broken Sound Parkway, NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487, USA First published 2010, Woodhead Publishing Limited and CRC Press LLC © 2010, Woodhead Publishing Limited The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-591-0 (book) Woodhead Publishing ISBN 978-1-84569-776-1 (e-book) CRC Press ISBN 978-1-4398-2730-7 CRC Press order number: N10147 The publishers’ policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elemental chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publishers ensure that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India Printed by TJ International Limited, Padstow, Cornwall, UK
v
Contents
About the authors
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy
Preface
1
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7
Introduction Energy policy Transformation of biomass Global biodiesel development Value chain of biodiesel Bibliography References
1 2 20 26 38 40 44
2
Development of non-food agricultural industries for biofuel applications
50
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6
Introduction Biofuels Biomass potentials and limitations Advanced agroenergy crops Bibliography References
50 51 52 56 59 60
3
Oleochemical sources: basic science, processing and applications of oils
62
Introduction Biochemistry of lipid metabolism Modification of vegetable oil quality Industrial use of vegetable oils Unusual fatty acids
62 64 76 80 85
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5
xi xiii xv 1
vi
Contents
3.6 3.7 3.8
Oil processing techniques Bibliography References
90 100 103
4
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
114
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5
Introduction Fuel properties of oils and fats Low-viscosity formulations Bibliography References
114 116 121 125 125
5
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
130
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11 5.12
Introduction Global oilseed and oil production Resources for biodiesel production Main biodiesel crops Minor edible oil crops Fish oils Algae mass culture systems Oleaginous microorganisms Non-edible oilseeds Low-quality feedstocks Bibliography References
130 135 137 143 159 163 168 187 188 197 206 208
6
Emerging new energy crops for biodiesel production
226
6.1 6.2 6.3
Introduction Crop selection criteria for biodiesel application Structure and quality parameters for evaluating alternative feedstocks Agronomic potential of underexploited oil crops by region Bibliography References
226 227 231 244 273 274
Transesterification processes for biodiesel production from oils and fats
285
Introduction Process variables Transesterification kinetics In-situ transesterification Non-catalytic fatty acid alkyl ester production References
285 287 295 308 310 314
6.4 6.5 6.6 7 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6
Contents
vii
8
Biodiesel catalysis
322
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6
Introduction Homogeneous alkaline catalysis in biodiesel synthesis Liquid-phase acid catalysis Heterogeneous catalysis in biodiesel synthesis Bibliography References
322 327 340 348 371 371
9
Processes for biodiesel production from unrefined oils and fats
386
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 9.9
Introduction Fatty acid esterification Transesterification of acidic feedstocks Jatrodiesel Algal biodiesel Vegetable oil soapstocks for biodiesel application Tall biodiesel Bibliography References
386 389 394 412 414 420 423 425 425
10
Biocatalytic production of biodiesel
434
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5
Introduction Enzymatic (trans)esterification Bioplastic-to-biodiesel Bibliography References
434 435 454 454 455
11
Industrial process technology for biodiesel production
462
11.1 11.2 11.3
Introduction Biodiesel plant design and engineering Selected proprietary transesterification processing technologies Selected biodiesel producers Biodiesel blending techniques Bibliography References
462 467
11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7 12 12.1
487 497 505 508 509
Analytical methods and standards for quality assurance in biodiesel production
514
Introduction
514
viii
Contents
12.2 12.3 12.4 12.5 12.6 12.7
Quality control of biodiesel feedstocks Biodiesel standardisation Biodiesel quality management Biodiesel analytical methodology Bibliography References
515 516 526 540 562 563
13
Valorisation of the glycerol by-product from biodiesel production
571
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 13.8
Introduction Industrial glycerol production Glycerol purification Industrial uses and markets Innovative use of glycerol Renewable diesel synthesis without glycerol co-production Bibliography References
571 572 575 579 584 611 615 615
14
Sustainability and use of biodiesel
625
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7 14.8
Introduction Energy balance Life cycle assessment of biodiesel Performance characteristics for biodiesel Biodiesel cost structure Biodiesel use and markets Bibliography References
625 627 630 637 658 677 701 703
15
Evolution of biodiesel and alternative diesel fuels
713
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4 15.5 15.6 15.7 15.8
Introduction Second-generation biofuels Biodiesel: the next generations Hydroprocessing technology Perspectives of biomass-to-liquid fuels Renewable energy and biomass Bibliography References
713 719 724 742 756 772 775 776
16
Epilogue: outlook for biodiesel science and technology 783
16.1 16.2
Introduction State of the biodiesel industry
783 784
Contents
16.3
Challenges for the global biodiesel industry
Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Appendix Index
I Acronyms/abbreviations of techniques II (Bio)chemical nomenclature III Physical and mathematical symbols IV General abbreviations V Main websites
ix
789 799 801 810 814 820 822
x
xi
About the authors
Jan C. J. Bart (PhD Structural Chemistry, University of Amsterdam) is a senior scientist with a wide interest in materials characterisation, heterogeneous catalysis and product development who spent an industrial carrier in chemical R&D with Monsanto, Montedison and DSM Research in various countries. Dr Bart has held several teaching assignments in universities in the Netherlands and Italy, researched extensively in both industrial and academic areas, and authored over 250 scientific papers and chapters in books; he is also author of three recent monographs on polymer additive analytics. Dr Bart has acted as a Ramsay Memorial Fellow at the Universities of Leeds (Colour Chemistry) and Oxford (Material Science), a visiting scientist at the Institut de Recherches sur la Catalyse (CNRS, Villeurbanne), and a Meyerhoff Visiting Professor at the Weizmann Institute of Science (Rehovoth), and held an Invited Professorship at the University of Science and Technology of China (Hefei). He is currently a Full Professor of Industrial Chemistry at the University of Messina (Italy). Natale Palmeri (PhD Industrial Chemistry, University of Messina) has interest in heterogeneous catalysis and energy carriers. He acted as a guest junior researcher at the Nicola Giordano CNR-TAE Institute of Advanced Technologies for Energy (Messina) and at the Boreskov Institute of Catalysis (BIC) of Novosibirsk (with Prof. Vladimir Sobyanin). Dr Palmeri has authored several research papers and presently serves as a technologist at ISAB Srl’s Priolo refinery (Sicily). Stefano Cavallaro graduated with an honours degree in Chemistry from the University of Messina, where he now acts as an Associate Professor of Industrial Chemistry in the Department of Industrial Chemistry and Materials Engineering. His interests are applied industrial chemistry, in particular heterogeneous catalysis and transformation and storage of energy. Dr Cavallaro has a standing cooperation with the National Research Council Institute of Advanced Technologies for Energy (CNR-TAE) in Messina and is author of over 110 research papers.
xii
xiii
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy
1 Generating power at high efficiency: Combined cycle technology for sustainable energy production Eric Jeffs 2 Advanced separation techniques for nuclear fuel reprocessing and radioactive waste treatment Edited by Kenneth L. Nash and Gregg J. Lumetta 3 Bioalcohol production: Biochemical conversion of lignocellulosic biomass Edited by K.W. Waldron 4 Understanding and mitigating ageing in nuclear power plants: Materials and operational aspects of plant life management (PLiM) Edited by Philip G. Tipping 5 Advanced power plant materials, design and technology Edited by Dermot Roddy 6 Stand-alone and hybrid wind energy systems: Technology, energy storage and applications Edited by J.K. Kaldellis 7 Biodiesel science and technology: From soil to oil Jan C.J. Bart, Natale Palmeri and Stefano Cavallaro 8 Developments and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology Volume 1: Carbon dioxide (CO2) capture, transport and industrial applications Edited by M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer 9 Geologic repository systems for safe disposal of spent nuclear fuels and radioactive materials Edited by Joonhong Ahn and Mick Apted 10 Wind energy systems: Optimising design and construction for safe and reliable operation Edited by John Dalsgaard Sørensen and Jens Nørkær Sørensen
xiv
Woodhead Publishing Series in Energy
11 Solid oxide fuel cell technology: Principles, performance and operations Kevin Huang and John Bannister Goodenough 12 Handbook of advanced radioactive waste conditioning technologies Edited by Michael I. Ojovan 13 Nuclear reactor safety systems Edited by Dan Gabriel Cacuci 14 Materials for energy efficiency and thermal comfort in buildings Edited by Matthew R. Hall 15 Handbook of biofuels production: Processes and technology Edited by Rafael Luque, Juan Campelo and James Clark 16 Developments and innovation in carbon dioxide (CO2) capture and storage technology Volume 2: Carbon dioxide (CO2) storage and utilisation Edited by M. Mercedes Maroto-Valer 17 Oxy-fuel combustion for fossil-fuel power plants: Developments and applications for advanced CO2 capture Edited by Ligang Zheng
xv
Preface
Energy, climate change and biofuels have recently become among the hot ‘buzzwords’ and with good reason. Meeting future energy requirements with continued use of limited fossil fuels is now widely recognised as unsustainable because of depleting supplies and environmental degradation. Ideally, energy demands should be reduced. However, the world’s appetite for energy is expected to rise by another 60% in the next 25 years. Prognoses of worldwide petroleum reserves are uncertain but generally predict maximum production in or before the period 2010–20 with a decline to the 1960 level by the year 2050. The world can no longer afford to rely solely on fossil oil and oil-derived products. Finding a cure for mankind’s oil (and carbon) addiction is urgently needed. This requires energy efficiency awareness and changes in consumer behaviour. The best way to maintain energy reliability is through diversity in sources of energy, suppliers and supply routes. Sound public policy calls for measures to gradually out-compete imported crude oil. The world should prepare for a post-fossil oil future. The challenges of ensuring energy security and reducing carbon emissions are closely linked. Global warming is accelerating. The threat of anthropogenic climate change knows no national boundaries and means that rapid action is required to reduce the CO2 output (concentration of 280 ppm before the industrial revolution vs 385 ppm in 2008). Alongside the promotion of sustainability, it is time for alternative low-carbon emission energy sources. However, there is no single low-carbon solution to cover all our energy needs. Investment in technologies that improve energy efficiency for electricity, heating and transportation is vital. A portfolio of different technologies is needed. Society needs to reshape the global energy system in the coming decades. Chemical sciences are crucial in increasing the efficiency of fossil fuels, addressing climate change and developing sustainable and renewable energy sources and a low-carbon economy. Despite best efforts, liquid hydrocarbons, coal and gas will still dominate transport, heat and power for some considerable time to come. It will take decades before we see a real shift away from oil as the predominant
xvi
Preface
fuel source. The pace of changeover from oil will be driven by oil price, unpredictable geopolitical factors and investment in technological innovation and development with protection of the environment. Alternative fuels, energy conservation and management, energy efficiency and environmental protection are becoming all important. With concerns over rising petroleum prices, security of supply, climate change and needs for agricultural product diversity, the race is on to produce fuels from renewable sources. Quite likely, however, fossil fuel prices need to rise even further before more substantial and effective political support is given to exploration of real alternative fuel sources. Possible alternative transportation fuels are many: biogas, bioethanol, biomethanol, biobutanol, cellulosic ethanol, dimethylether, biodiesel, straight vegetable oils (SVO), hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO), synthetic natural gas (SNG), FT-diesel and hydrogen. Some alternatives to petrol and other fossil fuels are already being used in a variety of forms of transport. Biodiesel derived from oil crops as a liquid energy carrier for transport is a potential renewable and carbon neutral alternative to petroleum fuels. In the medium to long term, switching to other forms of biomass as the raw material for biofuels (and materials) production is probably unavoidable, as fossil oil is a finite resource and food too precious for mankind. The urgency of responsible energy management and its timeframe are well illustrated by a manifold of ambitious (supra)national and industrial targets up to the year 2050. However, current biofuel policies have already caused unforeseen social and environmental problems (rising food prices, deforestation and soil degradation) and therefore require rethinking in terms of criteria for sustainability. Sustainable energy systems are achievable, but the problems are many and need urgent tackling. At present, supply and demand of oils and fats are not in healthy balance. Although mankind is very inefficient in exploiting the photosynthetic process, the energy landscape continues to move rapidly. The need to harness sustainable energy and reduce global warming has led to a search for alternative fuel sources. In contrast with solar energy, biofuels are unique in their impact on agriculture, food, transportation, energy and chemistry and may therefore serve different interests. EC president José Manuel Barroso has stated: ‘Biofuels figure prominently in the common energy policy of the European Union’. Although biofuels are not the most efficient way to harvest solar energy, being liquids they provide a most convenient method of distribution. As we run out of fossil fuels, the ‘green revolution’ may be just as radical as the previous industrial and digital revolutions. The bio-economic revolution aims at responsible industrial development in bioenergy (biofuels) and bioproducts. Biofuels mean a shift away from finite resources to almost infinite possibilities. Traditionally, the agricultural industry has provided
Preface
xvii
food, feed and fabrics. Now we need to add fuel. Use of plant matter as a feedstock for both energy and chemical products includes the development of fermentation-derived alcoholic biofuels, mainly bioethanol (from sugarcane in Brazil to wine in Europe) and more recently biobutanol (from corn grain, wheat, sugar beets, sugarcane and sorghum). Bioalcohols and biodiesel, made from sustainable agricultural crops, also produce valuable by-products in the process. Although first-generation biofuels are in direct competition with food (sugar, maize, vegetable oils), future energy chemistry developments can be expected for the use of woody biomass wastes and residues that are rich in cellulose (rather than in starch). Cellulosic biofuels may be based on lignocellulosic resources such as switchgrass, straw, corn stalks and other agricultural waste. Use of sustainable energy systems is as diversified as the geographical context, as illustrated for some leading countries. Germany already has produced over 2.9 Mt of biodiesel in 2007. The United States has installed 178 biodiesel plants with a total capacity of 10 Mt/yr (as of September 2008) but suffers from underdeveloped domestic use, in stark contrast to Europe. Sweden is a globally acknowledged world leader in biomass combustion (supplying 20% of its national energy needs). Iceland has successfully switched from a coal-based economy to one that uses renewable energy sources (hydroelectric and geothermal) for all heating and nearly all electricity; only transportation still depends on fossil fuels. With the favourable agricultural conditions and flexible processing infrastructure, the majority of Brazil’s road transport is powered economically with a fuel mix made up of 85% (cane-derived) bioethanol. Nevertheless, advanced biofuels based on adequate technological developments and edible energy crops cannot be expected to supply more than some 10–15% of global demand in an environmentally responsible manner without affecting food production. Biodiesel demand creates a fundamental new demand for agricultural commodities that was non-existent several years ago. Better prospects for farming biodiesel without undesirable side effects are based on the use of the non-edible oil of Jatropha, now being cultivated in large plantations around the globe, and on the development of biodiesel from algae, without competing for land area. These feedstock sources will not make a significant impact before 2015. Biodiesel is increasingly being used commercially with a view to decrease dependence on fossil fuel, reduce greenhouse gas emissions from the transport sector and support agriculture. Biodiesel stands as the only renewable energy source that is nowadays considered as a (partial) substitute for fossil diesel. Biodiesel has similar combustion properties as diesel and is considered a clean fuel. The growth rate of the rapidly changing and maturing biodiesel industry is without comparison in the chemical industry. The total installed capacity (mid 2008) has exceeded
xviii
Preface
some 30 Mt in a matter of only few years. Commercial processes for manufacturing biodiesel from a great variety of feedstocks (including urban wastes) almost invariably employ different catalysts. An analysis of state-of-the-art biodiesel technology is timely. Messina
1
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
Abstract: Renewable fuels are bound to gradually replace fossil fuels. Development of biorefineries will mark the historic transition into a sustainable society in which biological feedstocks, processes and products constitute the main pillars of the economy. Energy policy facilitating the introduction of biofuels, including biodiesel, avails itself of taxation, subsidies and mandates, which are not always unquestioned. Transformation of vegetable oils to liquid fuels is achieved industrially by catalytic transesterification. Biodiesel manufacturing, as yet based mainly on rapeseed oil (Europe), soybean oil (US, Argentina, Brazil) and palm oil (SouthEast Asia), requires further feedstock development. Important actors in the biodiesel value chain are vegetable oil milling facilities and the crude oil industry. Key words: Renewable fuels, energy policy, transformation of biomass, global biodiesel development, biodiesel value chain.
1.1
Introduction
Our industrial civilisation greatly depends upon abundant, low-cost energy, which could be produced without political intervention and suppression. Despite recent new oil discoveries in areas such as the Gulf of Mexico, the Tupi and Guará fields off South-East Brazil, Sudan, the Caspian Sea, Sakhalin, and in the Arctic, fossil resources are limited and nowadays no longer constitute cheap and reliable raw materials. Moreover, many convenient industrial products and processes based on these resources seriously damage the environment. The Petrochemical Age has resulted in massive pollution of air, water and soil as well as in emissions of anthropogenic greenhouse gases (GHGs) thought to be at least partly responsible for the recent climate change [1]. Warming of the climate system is unequivocal and there is a high probability that it has taken place during the last five decades or so as a result of human actions. In order to tackle climate change it is deemed necessary to stabilise the atmospheric level of CO2 at about 450 ppm by the end of the century. This means an emission level of 2 t CO2/yr per person, corresponding to the present Indian average (the current European level is at 11–12 t). Meeting the target requires a variety of actions, including government regulation, energy efficiency in industry (in particular in chemical, cement and steel manufacturing) and elsewhere, production of biofuels in a zerocarbon cycle, development of GM crops, nuclear power and photovoltaics, 1
2
Biodiesel science and technology
and capturing and storage of CO2. It is uncertain, however, that global warming can be limited by implementing low-carbon energy technologies. This would anyhow require considerable R&D efforts (not foreseen by the Kyoto Protocol). There is also no unanimous short-term solution for reversing climate change. Moreover, the harmful climatic effects (‘human-caused global warming’) due to increased hydrocarbon use and CO2 emissions have also been questioned [2, 3]. About 40% of the heat trapped by GHGs is due to gases other than CO2, primarily methane [4]. In any case, water, oxygen and CO2 enable life. In a higher CO2 environment crop growth rates may be expected to increase to the benefit of agriculture. The search for alternatives to fossil fuels dates back to the petrol crisis of the early 1970s, but just more recently the looming dangers of a global climate change are driving renewed interest in biofuels. The world is awakening to the renewable fuels movement and the public clamours for alternatives to foreign petroleum. The last 25 years have witnessed a gradual but growing shift towards greater use of plant matter as a feedstock for both energy and chemical products. The combination of steeply increasing oil prices (in particular in the past few years), environmental awareness, relatively low cost of plant material (until recently), and the development of biorefineries prepare mankind for a historic transition into a sustainable society in which biological feedstocks, processes and products become the main pillars of the economy. This calls for further developing the necessary science and technology that enable this transition, while at the same time investing in infrastructure and defining economic and policy issues. The various biomass-based resources used so far for fuel generation have mostly been (expensive) food crops, but biomass also consists of (cheap) agricultural and forest residues (e.g. crop residues, rice husk, cotton stalk, pine sawdust, sugarcane, bagasse, etc.), urban and industrial residues. Renewable and sustainable resources, which can be used as an extender or a complete substitute of diesel fuel may play a significant role in agriculture, industrial and transport sectors in the energy crisis situation. Agricultural and transport sectors are highly diesel dependent. Various alternative fuel options for diesel are mainly biogas, producer gas, ethanol, methanol and vegetable oils. Development of new energy sources replacing fossil sources is the greatest challenge of the 21st century. Renewable resources are more evenly distributed than fossil resources and energy flows from renewable resources are more than three orders of magnitude higher than current global energy use.
1.2
Energy policy
The world economy depends on only two significant energy carriers, namely hydrocarbons (natural gas, gasoline and diesel fuel or heating oil) and electrical current. Whereas the primary energy supply differs greatly from
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
3
nation to nation, hydrocarbons are our main means of storing energy. At present, the consumption of primary energy is globally highly dependent on fossil fuels, as shown in Table 1.1. US energy figures for 2006 are as follows: hydrocarbons, 84.9%; nuclear, 8.2%; hydropower, 2.9%; wood, 2.1%; biofuels, 0.8%; waste, 0.4%; geothermal, 0.3%; wind and solar, 0.3% (43% being used for electricity production). With France being the nuclear energy champion, Germany is a solar power leader (total PV capacity of 3063 MWp in 2006); by the end of 2007, the installed photovoltaic capacity in the EU amounted to 4700 MWp (globally: 9200 MWp). USA and Spain are actively developing large-scale concentrating solar power (CSP) plants. Large-scale hydropower provides virtually all of Norway’s electricity. Wind power accounts for at most 5% of primary energy generation in Europe, but up to 21% in Denmark. Important onshore wind farms are located also in USA, Portugal and Egypt; focus is nowadays on large offshore power stations (e.g. in Sweden, UK, Belgium and the Netherlands). In global energy supply fossil fuels amount to over 80%. Petroleum provides a significant fraction (~ 35%) of the world’s energy [5]. Currently, global production and world consumption are approximately 85 Mbd of conventional oil and 11 Mbd of natural gas (totalling 5600 Mt/yr); the predicted output of oil would stall at about 100 Mbd. Even the world’s largest oil fields (Ghawar, 80 billion barrels; offshore Safaniya, 25 billion barrels, and Cantavell, 20 billion barrels) are at the limits of their capacity and oil extraction is slowing down. Actually, it is even not so much the quantity of total reserves (which are still immense), which causes an impending oil shortage in the short term [6], but the flow and quality of the oil recovered. There exists insufficient refining capacity for heavy oils with higher molecular mass hydrocarbon composition and higher sulphur content. The era of cheap oil for our oiloholic society has definitely finished. According to some (Energy Watch Group), maximum petroleum production already occurred in 2006. More optimistic views foresee an irreversible decline in oil production by 2015–20 in the 20 oil-producing countries (rather concentrated areas of the globe). On the other hand, global demand for energy (and food) is predicted to double by 2050 [7, 8]. The International Table 1.1 Fuel shares of world total primary energy supply (%) Energy source
Developed countries
Developing countries
Biomass Natural gas Solid fuels Crude oila Hydropower Nuclear
3 24 26 35 6 6
35 7 28 23 6 1
a
Gasoline, diesel, aviaton fuel, marine bunker, middle distillates.
4
Biodiesel science and technology
Energy Agency (IEA) estimates an increase in energy consumption of 55% between 2005 and 2030 at an annual increase of 1.8%. Safe global fossil reserves, estimated as 1.3 trillion barrels (2000), will be exhausted in less than 40 years. While it is difficult to predict when the world is going to run out of petroleum, the reduction in the rate at which it can be extracted has set in before alternatives such as biofuels are cost effective. The IEA thus warns of a forthcoming energy crisis: the gap in supply and demand for oil worldwide is expected to occur by 2015, when there will be a shortage of at least 12.5 Mbd (or about 15% of global needs). Energy changes take time. Natural gas (NG) accounts today for over 20% of world primary energy production and represents the fastest growing primary energy source. Proven gas reserves are located mainly in the Middle East (43%) and Russia (33%). A peak in conventional gas production may occur between 2020 and 2050. Exploration of methane hydrates is still in its infancy [9]. Among the fossil energy carriers, coal has the longest projected range (155 years worldwide). Supply security means for many countries (such as Poland) that coal remains the cheapest and most readily available form of energy. Fossil fuels will still dominate the scene for some time to come (> 80% in 2030). Continuity of supply of fossil fuels, particularly crude oil, is increasingly being governed by geopolitical, economic and ecological factors. Political developments have an impact on fuel prices, while environmental concerns require a reduction in greenhouse gases and toxic emissions. There is an impelling need for energy diversification and containment of the negative environmental impact of indiscriminate use of mineral fuels. We clearly require an alternative fuel or strategy soon if we are to keep transportation going and the global economy running. Hydrogen is an environmentally friendly energy carrier rather than a primary fuel source. Moreover, the hydrogen era is still far over the horizon. With the hydrogen fuel economy dream fading, time is running short. Biofuels now account for over 1.5% of global transport fuels (around 34 Mtoe in 2007). In the future, an increasingly larger share of global consumption of liquid energy carriers must be filled with renewable resources (vegetable oils, wood, straw, waste). Investments in a low-carbon energy infrastucture are needed. Although transport is globally not the main consumer of energy (accounting for about 30% of total EU energy needs), it is almost fully (98%) dependent on oil-derived products and accounts for 67% of final oil demand in the EU. Transportation represents a key GHG and CO2 generating sector (especially in urban centres), responsible for 20% of total GHG and 26% of all CO2 emissions in the EU. Transport accounts for about 90% of the increase in CO2 emissions in the period 1990–2010 and is the main reason for not meeting the Kyoto objectives. Renewable resources such as biomass can be used for the production of chemicals and the supply of energy. Renewables accounted for 8% of
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
5
the EU27’s energy consumption in 2006. Use of renewable resources can contribute towards the conservation of finite energy resources. Despite an expected increase of about 1.8% per year, in the short term the contribution of renewables to the global primary energy supply will remain at only approximately 14% [10]. Biomass and biofuels constitute a big share of the renewable energy sources (RES). Production of first-generation biofuels (Fig. 1.1) requires the use of 0.2 to 1.3 L fossil fuel per litre of biofuel [11]. Apart from biomass and hydropower, the impact of other potentially important renewable sources such as geothermal, solar (PV, CSP), wind, tidal/ wave/ocean is still negligible as primary energy sources (0.416%, 0.038%, 0.050% and 0.0005%, respectively). Hydroelectric energy (highly important to countries such as Norway and Iceland) may be expected to grow, in particular in currently less developed areas. The contribution of geothermal energy is expected to be limited (e.g. Iceland). The impact of solar energy could increase significantly with organic solar collectors which reduce the effective cost of photovoltaic cells by an order of magnitude [12]. The United Kingdom plans to hit its 2020 target of producing 15% of its energy from renewable resources by a 1000% increase over current renewable energy levels principally by vastly boosting wind power production. The country also utilises impressive coal (accessible via underground gasification), wave and tidal power resources. Oceanlinx Ltd (Sydney) is developing wave farms in Rhode Island waters.
Biomass (sugar)
Hydrolysis
Fermentation
Ethanol recovery
Bioethanol
Residue
Biomass (oleaginous)
Oil extraction
Transesterification
Ester recovery
Methanol or Ethanol
Glycerol
1.1 First-generation biofuels.
Biodiesel FAME or FAEE
6
Biodiesel science and technology
The success of biofuels is highly contingent on national governmental measures to encourage their use through positive contributions of agriculture, energy efficiency, environmental and energy security legislation and regulations, legal obligations and/or beneficial measures (mandates, production plant incentives, federal tax credits and forgiving sales tax), as well as petroleum prices. The EU25 are heavily dependent upon energy imports. The share of imports in their total energy consumption (47.1% in 2005) could easily reach 67.5% by 2030, which threatens the security of the EU oil supply. Figure 1.2 shows the road fuel demand in the EU, which is steadily shifting from gasoline to diesel. European refineries are characterised by a gasoline surplus and a diesel deficit. The European refinery system will not be able to meet the projected demand for diesel. Demand for diesel in the US is expected to increase by about 12% over the next 15 years while demand for petroleum-based gasoline is expected to decline by 7% over the same period. Before 2004 diesel was always less expensive than gasoline in the US. In the past year, diesel prices in the US have greatly increased relative to gasoline (with increases of US$1.81 and US$1.12, respectively) as a result of high global demand and insufficient diesel refining capacity.
200
Gasoline Diesel
Mt/yr
150
100
50
0 1995
2000
Year
2005
1.2 Gasoline and diesel demand in the EU.
2010
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
7
Under the Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) most industrialised countries have committed themselves to limit or reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases (CO2, CH4, N2O, HFCs, PFCs, SF6) by 5.2% in relation to the base year 1990 or 1995. The contribution of H2O to global warming was not considered. Reductions in GHG emissions in the framework of the Kyoto Protocol (1997) are to be achieved by a combination of energy efficiency, reforestation, use of renewable energy sources, carbon capture and storage (CCS), and application of automatic meter reading (AMR technology). The Kyoto Protocol (141 signatories, US excluded) also provides for industrialised countries to implement project activities that reduce emissions in developing countries, in return for certified emission reductions (CERs). Biodiesel projects are actually not actively participating under the Kyoto Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) [13]. The EU is committed to cut its GHG emissions within 2008–12 by 8% from their 1990 level. Ambitious self-imposed climate change objectives were defined by most EU member states. The UK domestic carbon emission reduction target is 20% below 1990 levels by 2010 (and 80% by 2050). However, the likelihood of such domestic targets being met in 2010 is highly doubtful. In fact, both the Kyoto protocol and (inter)national targets on climate change are very ambitious, high cost and environmentally limited. Figure 1.3 illustrates the impact of CO2 in the case of use of fossil and renewable resources. Protocols are being developed to enable biodiesel producers to qualify for carbon credits.
1.2.1 Biodiesel strategy In 2001 the European Commission agreed on a strategy for sustainable development, including the use of biofuels. The EU aims at increasing the share of renewable energy from 5.4% in 1997 to 12% in 2010. EU Directive 2001/77/EC aims at increasing renewable electrical energy (biopower) in
Fuels, power and products
Biorefineries
Biomass/ Bio-organics
CO2
1–10 yrs Net CO2 reduction
Fossil resources (petroleum, natural gas)
> 106 yrs
Net CO2 gain
Biomass/ Bio-organics
1.3 Short- and long-term CO2 cycles.
Fuels, power and products
Production and refining
8
Biodiesel science and technology
the EU25 from 14% in 1997 to 21% in 2010. In May 2003, the EU outlined the Biofuels Directive (EU Directive 2003/30/EC) on the Promotion and Use of Biofuels and Other Renewable Fuels for Transport. Biodiesel should substantially reduce petroleum used and GHG generated compared with their petroleum-derived alternatives. The Biofuels Directive requires member states to increase the use of biofuels to a minimum of 2% of total liquid fuel consumption by 2005 (or 5.7 Mt) and to 5.75% by 2010 (or 16.5 Mt). If the target of 5.75% market share of biofuels in 2010 is met (current expectations: 4.2%), the EU27 will be short in feedstock to support the necessary biodiesel production (9.8 Mt/yr) (see Table 1.2). The EU requires 5.1 Mt/yr extra biodiesel capacity between 2006 and 2010. The agricultural surface needed for energy crops would then amount to 15–18 Mha (out of a total of 103.6 Mha EU cropland) or about 15–16% of the total agricultural area. Satisfying these objectives is an enormous challenge for each member state, especially if one considers that some 10% of total cultivated land dedicated to energy crops is generally considered to be the limit. Government policies are expressed through taxation, subsidies and mandates. Government subsidies substantially affect the commercial viability of biodiesel. Oilseed growers may benefit from subsidies. Subsidies to blenders may lead to increased demand for feedstocks. Tax credits for capital investments may benefit farmers. There is uncertainty about which producers or processors are able to take advantage of the particular programmes. In November 2003, the Energy Tax Directive 2003/96/EC was adopted concerning taxation of energy products, including detaxation of pure biodiesel (and blends containing up to 5% biodiesel) and biofuels to boost their production. Tax exemption (initially for six years) is limited to the biomass portion of the biofuel. This council directive is vital to achieve the targets in the Biofuels Directive. Without tax relief (operated by various EU member states) biofuels are at present not competitive with conventional fuels. Tax waivers have been responsible for the rapid growth of biodiesel Table 1.2 EU biofuel targetsa
Year
Target shareb
Biodiesel (Mt)c
Gasoline (Mt)d
Total (Mt)
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
2.00 2.75 3.50 4.25 5.00 5.75
3.4 4.7 5.9 7.2 8.5 9.8
2.3 3.2 4.1 5.0 5.9 6.7
5.7 7.9 10.0 12.2 14.4 16.5
a
Directive 2003/30/EC (8 May 2003). Percentage of total demand. c Based on EU consumption (170 Mt, 2005). d Based on EU consumption (117 Mt, 2005). b
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
9
in Europe. Also in November 2003, the EU agreed on a Biodiesel Standard (EN 14214 CEN) for fatty acid methyl esters (FAME). Another development was adoption of a revised standard for petroleum diesel (EN 590) which specifies that blends up to 5% FAME are considered as conventional diesel in all respects. This modification simplifies marketing of biodiesel/diesel blends. A number of government programmes encourage oilseed production for biodiesel. These programmes alter the private profitability of oilseed production in direct and indirect ways. The main effect is to lower the costs for oilseed growers and biodiesel processors, while at the same time raising the costs borne by taxpayers. Oilseed growers can benefit directly from subsidies or tax credits related to their production or investments. They also can benefit indirectly by incentives paid to oilseed crushers or biofuel processors, because these incentives can alter the prices paid to producers in ways that effectively share the government subsidies among growers, processors and consumers. On 8 February 2006, the European Commission (EC) adopted an ambitious European Union (EU) Strategy for Biofuels to boost production from agricultural raw materials. The main objectives are as follows: ∑ ∑
to promote biofuels in both the EU and emerging countries; to prepare for large-scale use of biofuels by improving their cost competitiveness and increasing research into second-generation fuels; and ∑ to support developing countries where biofuels production could stimulate economic growth. Unfortunately, the document assumed (erroneously) that biofuel production would have very little impact on feedstock prices and land use. Secondgeneration biofuel feedstocks are expected to play an increasing role only after 2010. It was estimated that 27% of EU biofuel demand could be met domestically, but would also require increases in feedstock production and land use (up to 13% of available area). Rising demands for biofuels were considered to require accelerated imports of oilseeds (+ 19.9%) in the EU in the period 2006–12. A European strategy for the security of energy supply sets the objective of 25% substitution of conventional fuels by alternative fuels in the road transport sector by the year 2030. The EU claims it can meet the targets for bioenergy and biofuels for 2010, 2020 and 2030 with no damage to biodiversity, soil or water resources [14]. Some EU measures aiming at promotion of increased use of renewable resources comprise the policy of use of set-aside land for non-food crop purposes, and industrial oilseed subsidies. In fact, large tracts of land formerly used to cultivate annual crops had become barren. The Mid-Term Review Reform of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), which defines set-aside
10
Biodiesel science and technology
arrangements under which non-food crops for biodiesel production can be grown, has led to support for such energy crops in the form of a carbon credit of 745/ha. Table 2.2 lists subsidised hectarage for energy crops in Europe. In the US, farmers are being paid billions of dollars not to farm up to 36 million acres. National biofuels legislation and targets vary widely among the EU27 member states. Biofuels policies of the EU are (at least partly) aimed at GHG reduction (35% or more). There is some consensus about the GHG calculation methodology [15]. Some EU member states intend to provide incentives for biofuels with higher GHG reduction. Even though fossil fuels will still be available for several decades, producing supplementary fuels from biomass addresses various important societal concerns without requiring substantial modification of existing vehicles or of the fuel distribution infrastructure. Challenges to a nation’s energy security and diversity encompass: ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
increasing the efficiency of all energy-intensive sectors through conservation and improved technologies; promoting diversity of energy supply; decreasing the dependence on foreign energy imports; improving national energy security; decreasing the environmental impact of energy-related activities (climate, GHG emissions, local pollution); and rural development (support for agriculture).
As the IEA claims, biofuel market developments are mainly influenced by agricultural policies, rather than security of energy supply issues [16]. In fact, supply security should not be overemphasised since the percentage of a country’s fuel supply that can be replaced with biofuels is small (some 10%), in particular taking into account the anticipated yearly growth of the global transport sector by 2.1%, with expected large national differences (cf. car density/1000 pp: USA, 500; Germany, 710; UK, 523; France, 633; India, 14; P.R. China, 13). An important biofuels policy goal is a sustainable production and use of bioenergy crops as part of a renewable energy mix in order to combat climate change. Drivers for increased use of biofuels are country specific, with emphasis on securing the economy and diversifying energy sources (e.g. in the US, UK, P.R. China, India, Taiwan, Indonesia), reducing reliance on imported energy products (EU, US, Thailand, Argentina, Brazil), readjustment of agricultural structure, regional development and improving farmers’ income (Brazil, Mexico, Philippines, P.R. China), added value to national economy (Singapore, Philippines, Malaysia, Argentina) or health and environmental protection/sustainability (EU, UK, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia). Colombia intends substituting all imports of diesel for domestic biodiesel by 2020.
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
11
EU policy toward utilising renewable energy aims at: (i) combating climate change; (ii) reducing local environmental stress; (iii) creating jobs (regional development); and (iv) securing energy supply. Changing national energy systems requires much time and brings huge costs. Consumer acceptance of the drive to substitute or blend some of the mineral-based fuel with biomass fuel in gasoline and diesel is receiving increasing support. Climate change is low on the list of global priorities (Copenhagen Consensus). Several states have enacted legislation mandating the use of biodieselbased products, such as South Korea, B0.5 (current) to B3 (2012); Taiwan, B1 (current) to B2 (2010); Thailand, B2 (Apr. 2008); Philippines, B2 (2009); EU, B7 (2011); Norway, B5 (2009); Romania, B2 (2008); Canada (federal), B2 (2012); Brazil, B3 and B4 (2009) to B5 (2010); Argentina, B5 (2010); Colombia, B5 (2008) to B10 (2010) and B20 (2012); Peru, B2 (2009) to B5 (2011); where B# denotes the percentage of biodiesel in a biodiesel/diesel blend. Mandates set by many governments will probably not be achieved. Biodiesel blends are now also mandated in some US states (LA, MA, MN, NM, OR, PA and WA). The Minnesota Biodiesel Mandate (2002) requires that all diesel fuel for transportation use in Minnesota, among the top five soybean-producing states in the US, contains at least 2% biodiesel in 2005 (up to B5 by 2009 and B20 by 2015) [17]. Globally, public authorities promote the use of blends of biofuel and conventional fuel through directives and by setting ambitious goals (Table 1.3). EU targets comprise a 10% voluntary biodiesel inclusion by 2010, and 10% obligatory by 2020. The European Biodiesel Board (EBB) favours a biodiesel share of 15% in the medium to long term. A binding EU-wide target (RED), signed up in 2007, is to source 20% of the total EU energy needs from renewables by 2020 [18]. Long-term goals in UK energy policy are securing clean energy at affordable prices and tackling climate change by reducing CO2 emissions [19]. The UK’s Climate Change Bill (a world first) has set legally binding targets for cutting GHG emissions by 80% (based on 1990 levels) by 2050. Achieving this target requires de-carbonising electricity generation, by a combination of renewables, nuclear, and carbon capture and storage. In the UK the current options for biofuels are bioethanol from the fermentation of sugars in sugarbeet or cereal crops and biodiesel from oilseed rape and (imported) soybean. The UK Renewable Transport Fuels Obligation (RTFO) stipulates that from April 2008 biofuels must make up at least 2.5% of the sales of transport fuel suppliers, increasing to 5% by 2010 and 10% by 2015. To satisfy RTFO without significant biofuels imports, which would be counterproductive, requires technological advances (second-generation technologies), including conversion of agricultural and forestry lignocellulosic waste materials to bioethanol and thermal conversion processes (conversion of biomass into syngas). The UK government has also set a target that, by 2020, 20% of energy should be from renewable sources [20].
12
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 1.3 Some long-term (national) goals in energy policy Challenger Target(s) World
Reduction in GHG emissions by 5.2% on 1990 levels throughout the 2008–12 perioda; halving CO2 emissions by 2050
EU25
10% market share for biomass-derived transport fuels by 2020b
Obligatory non-food set-aside rate of 10% for period 2000–06c
Reduction of energy consumption of 20% by 2020
Source 12% of total domestic energy consumption from renewables by 2010 (20% by 2020, 33% by 2030)
Reduction by 20% of imported gas/petrol by 2030
25% of transport fuel from biofuels by 2030
Reduction of GHG emissions below 1990 level (20% by 2020, 50% by 2050)
UK
Renewable transport fuels accounting for 5% in 2010 and 10% in 2015d
Renewable energy sources (including biofuels) accounting for 20% by 2020
Reduction in CO2 emissions by 26–32% (2020) to 80% (by 2050) against 1990 baselinee
Germany Biodiesel target of 10% by 2015
Reduction of GHG emissions by 40% by 2020 against 1990 levels
Portugal
Generation of 30% of power by new technologies by 2020
Iceland
Propulsion of fishing fleet and all vehicles with hydrogen produced with geothermal and hydropower by 2050
USA
Tripling use of bio-based products and bioenergy over 2001–10 period
Increasing use of bioethanol fuel up to 5% of gasoline consumption by 2010
Reduction by 30% of imported petroleum by the year 2010f
Minimum renewable diesel of 0.5 Bgy (2009) to 1 Bgy (as from 2012)g
Cost-competitive plant-derived ethanol by 2012
25% increase in energy efficiency by 2012h
Renewable fuels (largely bioethanol) industry volume of 7.5 Bgy by 2012h
Soy biodiesel share of 4% in 2016
Replacement of 15% of current gasoline consumption by 2017i
Minimum of 36 Bgy of alternative fuels by 2022g; 60 Bgy by 2030
Replacement of more than 75% of oil imports from Middle East by 2025
Biomass supplies 5% of nation’s power by 2030 (5.0 quad)j
Replacement of 12–18–25% of industrial organic chemicals with biomass-derived chemicals by 2010–20–30j
Biomass share of 20% (9.5 quad) for transportation fuels by 2030j
Subsidised agricultural commodities for bioenergy productionk
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
13
Table 1.3 Continued Challenger Target(s) Australia
1 Mgy biofuel target by 2012
Reduction of GHG emissions by 25% below 2000 level by 2020 and by 60% by 2050
P.R. China Share of 10% renewable energy by 2010, 15% by 2020 India
Share of 10% renewable energy by 2012
a
Kyoto Protocol (1997). EU Fuel Quality Directive (17 Dec. 2008). c MacSharry Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) Reforms (1992, 2000). d Renewable Transport Fuels Obligation (RTFO). e Climate Change Bill (26 Nov. 2008). f US Energy Policy Act (EPAct, 1992). g Energy Independence and Security Act 2007. h US Energy Policy Act 2005. i State of the Union 2007. j Biomass R&D Technical Advisory Committee (BTAC). k US Department of Agriculture’s Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) program. b
Germany’s Renewable Energy Act is a support programme offering attractive feed-in tariffs to renewable energy suppliers. The production capacity of biodiesel requires at least doubling in order to meet the country’s biodiesel target of 10% by 2015. B10 is being rejected by German car companies who believe the higher blends lead to a dilution of the engine oil due to the different boiling point of biodiesel. Accelerated biofuel targets in France are as follows: 2% in 2007, 5.75% in 2008, 7% in 2010 (or 2.65 Mt biodiesel; requiring imports in view of limited acreage), and 10% in 2015. The United States relied on imported oil to meet 58.4% of its crude oil needs in 2004 (47% in 1990) at a cost of US$200 billion. The total consumption of petroleum in the US corresponds to about 7.5 billion barrels of oil equivalent each year (43 ¥ 1015 BTU), and almost 70% of this petroleum is consumed by the transportation sector. Low-carbon fuel standards (LCFS) are being developed at the state, federal and international levels. Less than 5% of America’s energy is renewable. In the US, biofuels are being driven by a variety of regulations, including the US Department of Agriculture’s Federal Biobased Products Preferred Procurement Program (FB4P). The primary objective of the US Energy Policy Act (EPAct, 1992), administered by the Department of Energy (DOE), is to reduce US reliance on foreign oil by the promotion of alternative fuels. While EPAct 1992 sets a replacement of 10% of petroleum-based transportation fuels with domestically produced alternative fuels by 2000 and 30% by 2010 (goals far-off), US Energy Policy Act 2003 requires the use of 3.15 Bgy of biofuel by 2005. The Renewable Fuels Standard (RFS) under EPAct 2005 mandates that a minimum of 4 Bgy of renewable fuel (largely bioethanol) must be used in the US in 2006,
14
Biodiesel science and technology
increasing to 7.5 Bgy in 2012 out of total gasoline use of 130 Bgy (2007: 143 Bgy). There is no compelling evidence that RFS (2005) has been a factor in the impact that high commodity prices have had on the economy. EPAct 2005 also demanded a 25% increase in energy efficiency by 2012. The Biofuels Initiative has called for an enhanced RFS of 35 Bgy by 2017. The US Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA) of 2007 includes a second stage of the renewable fuels standard (RFS2) that requires the domestic use of at least 500 Mgy of biomass-based diesel in the US in 2009 increasing to 1 Bgy as from 2012, and expands the minimum amount of biofuels that will be used in the US to 36 Bgy by 2022. The required total volume of renewables to be blended into the US fuel supply is 9 Bgy (2008) up to 11.1 Bgy (2009). Many questions remain as to how these volume mandates will materialise. Industry needs to expand beyond corn, which means using cellulosic biomass. RFS2 has also established three new renewable fuels categories: advanced biofuels, biomass-based diesel and cellulosic biofuels. In RFS2 terminology ‘biomass-based diesel’ is a specific title under ‘advanced biofuels’ and includes biodiesel, biomass-to-liquid diesel and renewable diesel, provided that oils and fats are not co-processed with petroleum diesel (see also Chapter 15). Up to now, and including 2009, the only commercially available biomass-based diesel available in the US in significant quantities is biodiesel. Expectations are that 500 Mgy of biodiesel for 2009 can easily be reached even if the current high volume of exports to Europe is cut back. The EPA has delayed RFS2 ruling until mid-2009. The current target set by the National Biodiesel Board (NBB) is 5% of the country’s on-road diesel fuel market by 2015, corresponding to about 9 Mt/yr of biodiesel. Analysts’ forecasts estimate a production of 15 Bgy bioethanol and 2 Bgy biodiesel in the US by 2015 (cf. 2007 figures of 6.9 Bgy and 0.45 Bgy, respectively) [21]. Bioethanol should be competitive by 2012. A US DOE goal is also to reduce the production cost of lignocellulosic ethanol from the present US$2.25/gal to US$0.82/gal by 2012 and to reduce feedstock logistics costs (harvesting, storage, preprocessing and transportation) to US$0.35/gal. The agency aims at making the fuel cost competitive to petroleum at a modelled cost of US$1.33/gal (2007 US$), thus dramatically increasing ethanol’s feedstock capacity. The DOE has also set the long-term goals of producing at least 10% of basic chemical building blocks from biomass by the year 2020 and to increase this share to 50% by 2050 [22]. The US Air Force aims at covering 50% of its fuel needs from domestic alternatives by 2016. Policy proposals for a viable US biodiesel industry comprise a tax credit as well as feedstock cost support through the Commodity Credit Corporation (CCC) Bioenergy Program; CCC is a US government entity created to stabilise farm income (Farm Bill 2002) and provides support for biodiesel and ethanol producers. The tax credit system being operated in the US is
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
15
primarily geared to support US farmers. Despite enormous tax subsidies over the past 30 years, green sources still provide only a very small fraction of US energy. The US Food, Conservation and Energy Act of 2008 promotes advanced biofuels (cellulosic ethanol, biobutanol and biobased hydrocarbons) made from non-food crops and offers incentives to move away from corn ethanol production. The act institutes a production tax credit of up to US$1.01 per gallon of second-generation biofuels. The law encourages farmers to grow biomass crops in areas around biomass facilities, such as biorefineries, to reduce the environmental impacts of transporting fuel feedstocks. Subsidies for corn ethanol were trimmed from US$0.51 to US$0.45/gal. The US biodiesel-blender tax incentive (enacted in 2004) is presently in the form of a US$0.01 per FAME-% per gallon; this provision was to expire in 2008. For B99 biodiesel the agri-subsidy is equivalent to US$0.99/gal. This blenders’ credit makes biodiesel blends very cost competitive with conventional diesel. The US biodiesel tax credit, aimed at the producer, has not stimulated growth in consumer demand. Among the provisions of the recent Energy and Tax Extenders Act of 2008 (H.R. 6049) US House has extended the biodiesel tax credits through 31 Dec. 2009, qualifying all biodiesel produced in the US for a tax credit of US$1/gal, regardless of feedstock. A significant change to the biodiesel tax incentive is therefore the complete credit eligibility of producers using non-virgin feedstocks such as yellow grease. Previously, waste-grease biodiesel only qualified for a 50 cent per gallon tax credit. The law also shuts down the abusive ‘splash-anddash’ loophole that previously allowed foreign-produced fuel to enter the US, claim the biodiesel tax incentive, only to be shipped to a third country for end use. Fuel produced outside the US now no longer qualifies for the biodiesel tax incentive. The act also eliminates the requirement that renewable diesel be produced using a thermal depolymerisation process, and reduces the credit for biomass co-processed with a petroleum feedstock to 50 cents. The EPA established the RIN (Renewable Identification Number) system to track renewable fuel batches from the producer through various downstream entities. According to an ACS Public Policy Statement (9 Dec. 2007) the US should significantly raise its public and private sector investments in technologies to mitigate climate change through economically viable energy conservation, biomass fuel substitution for fossil fuels, carbon sequestrations and nonfossil fuel based energy sources. The Obama administration is expected to dramatically reduce the country’s carbon emissions. National biofuel programmes are operative in several other countries (e.g. Brazil, France, Sweden). The Netherlands is the only European country without a biofuels programme. Even developing countries nowadays have energy policies which include the use of locally available biofuels. For example,
16
Biodiesel science and technology
the regulatory framework for biodiesel production in Brazil is coordinated by Probiodiesel (Programa Brasileiro de Desenvolvimento Tecnológico de Biodiesel). Costa Rica intends to displace 25% of oil imports with renewable sources by 2010. According to the Philippine Energy Plan 2002–11, bioenergy is expected to supply roughly 25% of the nation’s energy needs (domestic and industrial heat generation, liquid biofuels for transport) by 2011 [23]. Asian energy policy is summarised in Table 1.4. It is important to notice that biodiesel has met all due regulatory and technical requirements, including health effect testing and creation of standards (ASTM, EN, national). Without these essential provisions in place it would not have been possible to commercialise the fuel. In this context, it is only to be remembered that circumventing the regulatory process was one of the reasons that has led to the fallout regarding methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE).
1.2.2 Gain and pain Without initial governmental subsidies industrial production of biodiesel is not profitable because of heavy start-up costs. However, biodiesel has become more attractive recently because of its environmental benefits. The cost of biodiesel, however, is the main obstacle to its commercialisation. In Table 1.4 Asian energy policy (after ref. [24])
Drivers
Regulatory
Mandates
P.R. China
Renewable Energy Legislation 2006
No
RE share 15% (2020)
India
Diversify energy sources
No
11.2 Mha jatropha (2012)
Japan
Kyoto Protocol, energy efficiency
No
6% CO2 reduction (2010)
South Korea Environmental
B0.5
B3 (2012)
Taiwan
Diversify energy sources
B1
B2 (2010); import
Thailand
Reduce imported energy products
No
B2 (2008)
Philippines
Increase farmers’ income
B2
B3 (2010)
Targets
Singapore National economy No
3 Mt/yr (2015); develop into major renewable diesel producer/exporter
Indonesia
9.2 Mt/yr (2025)
Diversify energy sources
No
Malaysia Environmental No
Develop into major biodiesel producer/ exporter
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
17
the present, production and utilisation of biodiesel are generally facilitated through the agricultural policy of subsidising the cultivation of non-food crops and by tax exemptions. In the long term, however, policy decisions should just ensure a free market for biodiesel, without farm subsidies, regulations and other interventions. Several recent changes in governmental priorities should not go unnoticed. The European Union is moving towards sustainable energy and not renewable energy. Under the Bush Administration, the US has upgraded the 7.5 Bgy renewable fuels standard in 2012 to 36 Bgy by 2022 (mandatory requirement), whereas more recently, under the Obama Administration, the biofuels policy has changed focus from energy security to critical environmental issues. China changed from using food feedstocks to not using any food. Brazil started biodiesel production in 2005. In Europe, tax credits are in the form of reductions in the excise tax paid at fuel pumps, benefiting consumers rather than producers. This arrangement builds demand for biodiesel. In contrast, the US producer tax credit assists mainly in building up unnecessary production capacity. The introduction of graduated taxation of biodiesel in Germany has slumped biodiesel sales at public filling stations by a third in comparison to 2007. It would appear that a viable industry may only be so because of tax credit policy. Tax credits may have the best intentions, though the effects appear to be anything but. An energy policy is only as good as its execution. Realistic legislative targets have to be mandatory and governments need to ensure that they are met. Only Germany met the 2% 2005 target set by EU Directive 2003/30/ EC. Moreover, usage mandates do not guarantee sustainability or remedy for the feedstock crisis. Recently, the EU biofuels policy has been challenged (in particular the 10% target for the market share of transport fuels from biomass by 2020) as it had not foreseen causing social and environmental problems. Consequently, there might be a regulations rethink. It would also appear that other political intervention elsewhere has not altogether been based on entirely sound considerations. Replacing all the transport fuel consumed in the US with biodiesel will require 0.53 billion m3 of biodiesel annually at the current rate of consumption. As shown in Section 1.4.2, oil crops, waste cooking oil and animal fat cannot realistically satisfy this demand. Even the minimum renewable requirement in the US diesel pool from 0.5 Bgy in 2009 to 1 Bgy as from 2012 (according to EISA 2007) ignores the fact that acquisition of additional feedstocks beyond a biodiesel production level at 0.2–0.3 Bgy is very difficult and upsets regional markets [25]. A 0.5 Bgy US biodiesel industry, which would satisfy only 1.5% of US on-highway petrodiesel or < 1% of total fuel oil and kerosene use, would require all of the surplus vegetable oil (0.13 Bgy), half of the used oil (0.17 Bgy), and all of the oil that could be produced on 13.8 Mha of idle cropland (~ 0.3 Bgy), or the equivalent by displacing current crops. This is clearly unrealistic. The political requirement may then
18
Biodiesel science and technology
only be met by imports, which is not precisely in the best interest of a sound energy balance (see Section 14.2). Oil crops cannot significantly contribute to replacing petroleum-derived liquid fuels in the foreseeable future, unless microalgae are used to produce biodiesel. Between 1 and 3% of the total US cropping area would be sufficient for producing algal biomass that satisfies 50% of the transport fuel needs (see Section 5.7.2). An OECD recommendation [26] urges countries to end mandates for biofuel production and replace them with technologically neutral policies, such as carbon taxes that stimulate energy efficiency and a broad range of approaches to reduce GHG emissions (certification requirement). Indiscriminately increasing the amount of biofuels may not automatically lead to the best reductions in emissions. Recently, concerns have been expressed on large biofuel mandates on account of previously ignored increased greenhouse gases through emissions from land-use change [27]. Many governments are now revising biofuels policies. Ireland has lowered the 2010 biofuels target from 5.75% to 3%, citing price and emissions concerns. Also the UK’s Renewable Fuels Agency has recently recommended that the EU slows its advancement of biofuels and re-evaluates its policies, in particular taking into account the detrimental effect caused by an increase in food prices. Not surprisingly, food and consumer goods group Unilever backs recommendations to scrap mandatory biofuel targets and subsidies. Key non-technical issues that need to be addressed are creation of public awareness, biomass availability, ethical issues (use of food material for non-food; not relevant for waste oils), evaluation of environmental impacts through life cycle analysis (LCA), regulations, harmonisation of standards, taxation, etc. Biodiesel and bioethanol have already reached commercial markets, especially as blends with petrofuels. Biofuels may develop into a more locally available resource than fossil fuels, although economy of scale makes stringent requirements [28]. There is a need for long-term supply and consistency of the raw material(s) involved. The most remarkable feature of the biodiesel production market is its rapid growth (until 2007), probably unequalled in the chemicals sector. This has been driven largely by increasingly detailed political directives to achieve biodiesel substitution in petrodiesel fuel blends. More recently, however, the biodiesel industry has been victim of its own success as steep increases in feedstock prices have forced many operations (temporarily or permanently) out of the market. In March 2008 at least 20 US operations (totalling 220 MMgy capacity) were idle; in March 2009 the corresponding figures had increased to 32 operations with a total capacity of 507 MMgy. At least 15 past US biodiesel facilities (with a total capacity of exceeding 200 MMgy) are now defunct. At present, the biodiesel market is confronted with high uncertainty and volatility. Growth prospects are negatively influenced by the ongoing fuel vs. food debate, the public’s disillusion regarding biofuels, rising raw material
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
19
prices, constantly changing regulatory environments, a slowing economy and the financial crisis restricting financing future projects. According to USDA high energy prices, increasing global demand, drought and other factors – not biofuels – are the primary drivers to higher food costs. Severe floods in the US Midwest in mid-june 2008, damaging crops, have caused a sharp rise in corn prices to a record high of more than US$7 per bushel. In the present market conditions (high vegetable oil prices) the 2010 biodiesel targets appear elusive. The end of the period of rapid growth in the biodiesel industry is creating both uncertainty and opportunities.
1.2.3 Biofuel research and development Bioproduct R&D is currently a hot topic worldwide [29], albeit with strong economic and political conditioning. Biofuel R&D has been driven by recent regulations to reduce dependence on mineral oil (US FB4P and EU Directive 2003/30/EC). The biofuels industry faces a more than 60 year R&D delay with respect to the petrochemical industry with its advanced standards of performance. However, synergies between the bioprocessing and petroleum industry might be realised. Since the end of 2003 mineral oil companies have been allowed to mix up to 5% of biodiesel with their conventional diesel. The present ratio is 2.7% (or 3.75% in Germany, 2005). Several major oil and chemical companies (e.g. BP [30], DuPont [31], Fina [32], IFP [33–38], Mizusawa [39], Petrobras [40], Petronas [41, 42], Petronic [43], Royal Dutch Shell [28, 44], Neste Oy [45–47], and others such as Chevron, ConocoPhillips, ExxonMobil, Grace Davison, Gulf Oil, HPLC, IOC, Mitsubishi, Petropar, Petroplus, PetroSun, PTT, Statoil, TotalFinaElf, UOP) are committed to alternative fuels (see Section 15.5). Whereas Total claims to be the world market leader for rape biodiesel, Grace Davison focuses on catalysts and adsorbents for purification to enhance biodiesel and bioethanol quality and is developing chromatography-based analytical and QC tools for the quality of the renewable fuels. DuPont advances biobutanol and cellulosic ethanol (corn-stover-derived). Chevron is committed to conversion of cellulosic biomass (forestry and agricultural waste) – rather than corn – into ethanol and renewable diesel and to bio-oil reforming (conversion into hydrogen). Statoil has a keen interest in marine biomass. Not surprisingly, the chemical and petrochemical industry is well aware of the concept of mineral oil as a limited resource and has taken action. After a variety of energy efficiency measures resulting in a 22% energy reduction in the past decade, Dow Chemical plans to reduce its global energy consumption by another 25% over the period 2005–15. DuPont intends to produce 25% of its products from renewable sources by the year 2010. The Dutch chemical industry aims at halving its dependence on fossil raw materials within the next 25 years (Nederlandse Regiegroep Chemie). Shell
20
Biodiesel science and technology
Oil intends providing 30% of the world’s chemical and energy needs by use of biomass by 2050.
1.3
Transformation of biomass
The term biomass means any (biodegradable) organic matter, available on a renewable or recurring basis (excluding old-growth timber), including dedicated energy crops and trees, agricultural food residues, aquatic plants, wood and wood residues, animal wastes and other (industrial and municipal) waste materials that can be used in place of fossil-fuel sources to develop value-added products such as power, heat, industrial chemicals and consumer goods [48]. Biomass, which has a complex composition, may be harvested for food, feed, energy or as a chemical feedstock (Fig. 1.4). Biomass reflects the synthesis performance of nature and has a different C:H:O:N ratio from (equally complex) petroleum. Biomass denotes a great variety of biomass types, arbitrarily divided into wet (>50%) and dry (<50%) biomass, roughly corresponding to agricultural and forestry crops. Elimination of water by evaporation greatly determines the processing costs and total energy balance. Biomass-based energy use differs greatly in various parts of the world. Zimbabwe covers 75% of its energy use with biomass (producing 40 ML bioethanol), followed by Finland, Sweden and Austria with 20, 19 and 11%, respectively. In Western countries, where land and labour are relatively expensive, the energy-crop harvest will not be as rapidly profitable Conversion Pyrolysis Gasification
Output
Combustion
Electricity
Agro products
Fermentation
Process steam
Waste products
Bio-gasification
Heat, cooling
Forestry products
Transesterification
Biofuel
Marine products
Hydrotreatment
Bioplastics
GTL
Proteins
Input
Steam/water cyclus Gas turbine
1.4 Benefits of an integrated system for conversion of combustible renewables.
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
21
as elsewhere in the world. In any case, improved combustion, or preferably advanced gasification techniques should accompany the wider use of biomass. Processing of biomass is CO2 neutral [49]. The primary conversion processes of biomass are summarised in Table 1.5. Heating biomass (mainly wood) in the absence of oxygen at temperatures of 723–1073 K (thermolysis) up to 1773 K (pyrolysis) yields char and charcoal (at lower temperatures), an acid fuel oil, and a gas mixture, containing H 2, CO, acetylene (mainly at higher temperatures). Gasification differs from thermal conversion processes in that air and steam are used to give a product richer in oxygen (CO, CO2, H2, CH4). The product can be used for the generation of electricity or syngas. Interesting perspectives are offered by ‘biomass-to-liquid’ or BTL technology, which permits the transformation of biomass (cellulosics, wood, organic waste, etc.) into biofuels by hightemperature gasification followed by Fischer-Tropsch (see Section 15.5). Fuel production from the lignocellulosic component of biomass will be very important. Hydrothermolysis (Royal Dutch Shell) produces a low-oxygen content oil-like material (bio-crude). Anaerobic digestion evolves methane. Fermentation of glucose-based crops such as sugarcane (Saccharinum officinarum) and corn starch using Saccharomyces yeasts leads to ethanol. Most biomass technologies have not yet become competitive. A great variety of products are considered ‘biofuels’ (i.e. a liquid or gaseous fuel for transport produced from biomass), including bioethanol, biodiesel, pure vegetable oils, and others (see Section 2.2). Ethanol is by far the largest volume chemical made by bioprocessing. Biofuels often present an important advantage as compared to other alternative fuels such as LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) as no specific distribution system is needed. Direct use of unmodified vegetable oils and fats of renewable feedstocks, consisting of long-chain (mainly C12–C22) fatty acid triglycerides, as biofuel in existing engines has some disadvantages even in tropical climates (see Chapter 4). The greatest drawback of using pure vegetable oils as fuels is high viscosity, although this can be reduced by techniques such as dilution, micro-emulsification, pyrolysis and transesterification. Table 1.5 Biomass conversion processes Process
Major products
Combustion Thermolysis (723–1073 K) Pyrolysis (1773 K) Gasification (923–1473 K) Hydrothermolysis (523–873 K) Fermentation Anaerobic digestion Aerobic digestion Extraction
Heat, CO2, H2O Char, oil, gases Gases (C2H2), char CO, H2, CO2, CH4 Oil, char, gases (CO2) Ethanol, CO2 CH4, H2O CO2, H2O, heat Vegetable oil
22
Biodiesel science and technology
1.3.1 Transesterification to biodiesel Biodiesel (chemical name: fatty acid methyl esters (Fame), C14–C24 methyl esters; CAS No: 67784-80-9) is defined as a fuel comprised of monoalkyl esters of long-chain fatty acids derived from renewable lipid feedstocks, such as vegetable oils or animal fats, for use in compression-ignition (diesel) engines [50]. Biodiesel is not a single chemical entity. In 2003, US Congress proposed that, for tax purposes: ‘The term “biodiesel” means the monoalkyl esters of long-chain fatty acids derived from plant or animal matter which meet (a) the registration requirements for fuels and fuel additives established by the Environmental Protection Agency under section 211 of the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 7545), and (b) the requirements of the American Society of Testing and Materials D 6751’. On this basis, biodiesel is not crude vegetable oils, oil/diesel or alcohol/diesel binary mixtures, microemulsions, biomass pyrolysates, vegetable oil pyrolysates (bio-oil), or alcohol/diesel/co-solvent ternary mixtures. A later EPAct05 biodiesel definition includes two types of biodiesel: traditional fatty acid methyl esters (bio-esters) and non-ester renewable diesel (NERD or bio-alkanes). In this text ‘biodiesel’ is used exclusively in the more restricted bio-ester sense. Biodiesel, which is a clear, amber-yellow liquid, is used pure (B100) or preferably as blends (B5, B20) with petrodiesel. Biodiesel is usually compared to petrodiesel No. 2 (DF2), which is characterised by a 453–613 K boiling range. Petrodiesel is a fraction boiling in the mid-range of cracking products, also termed ‘middle distillates’. As the viscosity of the biodiesel fuel (BDF) is approximately twice that of petrodiesel it has better lubricating properties. Biodiesel is commonly added to the petrodiesel sold at pumps today to increase the lubricity of pure ultra-low sulfur diesel (ULSD). Industrially, biodiesel (consisting of mixtures of medium- to long-chain fatty acid alkyl esters, mainly methyl esters: FAMEs) is produced by relatively complex (catalytic) alcoholysis (transesterification) of vegetable oils and animal fats. This process is more typical of the chemical industry than of the petrochemical industry. Simple fatty acid alkyl esters produced from renewable feedstocks such as oils and fats are being investigated in numerous settings as replacements for petroleum-derived materials, particularly diesel fuel. Requirements for economic exploitation are cheap raw materials and low process costs (low T, p, t, quantitative conversion); see Chapters 7–12. The transesterification yield is high: 1 t vegetable oil yields about 1 t biodiesel and 110 kg glycerol, but requires 110 kg methanol, catalysts and neutral reactants (see Fig. 5.2). However, the yield is less impressive if one considers the whole life cycle. Generation of 1 t biodiesel typically requires cultivation of about 1 ha, which yields 9 t product; of these 6.5 t are currently not valorised (stalks, roots, leaves) and only 2.5 t are oilseeds. Oil is extracted from the oilseeds by trituration, pressing and/or solvent
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
23
extraction. For each ton of oil 1.5 t of solid residue is obtained which can be used as animal feed (see also Fig. 3.7 and Fig. 5.2). One of the first uses of transesterified vegetable oil was powering heavy-duty vehicles in South Africa before World War II.
1.3.2 Alternative diesel fuels Other processes can also be used to produce high-quality diesel fuel from vegetable oil or animal fat. Less appropriately, pyrolysis and hydrogenation products, diesel-vegetable oil blends, microemulsions of alcohols and water in vegetable oils and fermentation butanol are sometimes also referred to as biodiesel; in fact, they are just alternative (renewable) diesel fuels. For use as diesel fuels vegetable oils and animal fats with high viscosity and low volatility must be modified in order to gain sufficient engine compatibility. Viscosity values of vegetable oils typically vary between 27.2 and 53.6 mm2/s, whereas those of vegetable oil methyl esters are between 3.59 and 4.63 mm2/s. Apart from transesterification with low alcohols (MeOH, EtOH) various other processes exist to improve the fuel combustion characteristics of biomass (in particular vegetable oils and fats) by reduction of viscosity: ∑ blending (dilution) of vegetable oil with other fuels (diesel, alcohols); ∑ microemulsification with short-chain alcohols (MeOH, EtOH); ∑ thermal treatment (pyrolysis, gasification) producing alkanes, alkenes, carboxylic acids and aromatic compounds; ∑ catalytic cracking to (cyclo)alkanes; ∑ hydrotreating; and ∑ ozonation. Among these primary technologies only dilution, microemulsification and heating do not chemically alter the raw material. Co-solvent blending of vegetable oils with other fuels like alcohol may bring the viscosity to within specification. Microemulsions cannot generally be recommended for long-term use in diesel engines (see Section 4.3). The development of stable bio-crude oil (BCO)/diesel oil emulsions is under way [51, 52]. Pyrolysis is a thermochemical conversion process in conditions of significantly less oxygen than required for complete combustion, which offers a way to convert (solid) biomass into an easily stored and transported liquid or bio-oil for use in producing chemicals and fuels [53]. Torrefaction is a mild form of low-oxygen pyrolysis (573 K) producing biomass without moisture and volatiles. In pyrolysis, the feedstock is subjected to moderate-to-high temperatures in the absence of oxygen and degrades to a liquid (preferred product), gaseous and solid phase. The product distribution depends on biomass composition and pyrolysis conditions (T, ΔT, t). Table 1.6 shows
24
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 1.6 Pyrolysis modes Method
Residence time (tr)
Temperature Heating rate Product(s) (K)
Torrefaction Carbonation Conventional Slow Fast Flash liquid Flash gas Hydropyrolysisb Ultrafast Vacuum pyrolysis
< 90 min Days 5–30 min > 1 s 0.5–5 s < 1 s < 1 s < 10 s < 0.5 s 2–30 s
473–573 673 873 773 923 773 > 973 <773 1273 673
a
Low Very low Low Low Medium High High High Very high Medium
Biomassa Charcoal Oil, gas, char C (30%) Bio-oil Bio-oil (80%) Gas Bio-oil Chemicals, gas Bio-oil
Without moisture and volatiles. Pyrolysis with water.
b
various pyrolysis conditions and main products. Pyrolysis modes are flash or ultrafast (up to 1000 K/s with rapid condensation of vapour products), fast (300 K/min) and slow (30 K/min), all usually up to 773–873 K. Processes can be adjusted to favour charcoal, pyrolytic oil, gas or methanol production with a fuel-to-feed efficiency up to 95%. Slow heating rates tend to favour production of volatile gases, organic acids and aldehydes, mixed phenols and char. High heating rates tend to minimise char formation and liquid production and maximise gas production. Pyrolysis can be used for the production of bio-oil by various processes (e.g. flash pyrolysis) [53–56]. The yield of pyrolytic liquid, also known as bio-oil, depends on pyrolysis conditions, including relatively short residence times tr (0.5–2 sec.), moderate temperatures (673–873 K), and rapid quenching at the end of the process. The multi-component liquid is highly oxygenated, and contains up to 15–20% water. The elemental composition of bio-oil resembles that of biomass (cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin) rather than that of petroleum oils. Fast pyrolysis technologies for energy application have recently entered the stage of commercialisation (25 kt/yr; DynaMotive, West Lorne, Canada). Bio-crude oil (BCO) use for power and heat production represents a main goal in the biomass sector. BCOs have already been used in modified diesel engines (see Section 4.2). Their use in internal combustion engines offers several advantages in terms of logistics (compared to bio-energy from solid biomass) as well as in terms of power-to-heat ratio and efficiency. Direct use of pyrolysis oils requires significant adaptations of technology to fuel characteristics. Other problems with bio-oil include high corrosivity. The biomass pyrolysis-to-energy chain is not yet fully developed. The pyrolysis technology that is closest to commercialisation is the pyrolysis of high lignin-containing lignocelluloses. Ensyn (Canada)’s Rapid Thermal Processing (RTP) can use sawmill residuals and construction and demolition
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
25
wood waste as well as fast-growing wood species such as willow and poplar, liquefying 75% of the original in a fast pyrolysis process to ‘bio-oil’. Pyrolysis and cracking of oils and fats produce compounds that are smaller than triglyceride molecules and are, therefore, more suitable as a fuel. In petroleum refining hydrocracking is widely used for converting various fractions to lighter and more valuable products, especially distillates such as jet fuels, diesel oils and heating oils. Ester-containing vegetable oils have been converted into hydrocarbons by pyrolysis at 573–973 K in the presence of a catalyst [57]. Pyrolysis or thermal catalytic cracking has been applied to various oilseed feedstocks, including soybean [58, 59], rapeseed [60, 61], tropical vegetable oils (babassu, piqui, palm, copra) [62, 63], tung oilseeds [64], soybean oil cake [65] and sunflower oil cake [66]. Pyrolysis and hydrocracking of SBO, hydrogenolysis of palm oil (PMO) and rapeseed oil (RSO), and hydrocracking of SBO and babassu oil were reviewed by Dunn [67]. Cracking of canola oil (used as a model compound for waste vegetable oils) to fuels and chemicals at 673–773 K using a variety of catalysts yields mainly C1–C5 hydrocarbon gases, liquid aromatics and aliphatics, and coke [68]. Da Rocha Filho et al. [69] studied catalytic hydrocracking of vegetable oils obtained from Passiflora edulis (maracuja), Astrocaryum vulgare (tucuma), Mauritia flexuosa (buriti), Orbignya martiana (babassu) and soybean. In catalytic cracking of triglycerides (TGs) using a variety of catalysts, including SiO2/Al2O3 [63], NiMo/g-Al2O3 [69], Ni/SiO2 [70], Al2O3 [71], MgO [71], zeolites [72-74], a gasoline-like fuel is more likely to be formed than a diesel-like fuel. Bio-oil was obtained in tubular reactor fixed-bed hydropyrolysis experiments from extracted Euphorbia rigida at a hydrogen pressure of 15 MPa at 823 K [75]. The main shortcoming of such biofuels lies in the economics of the process with the use of expensive vegetable oils as new raw materials. Pyrolysis of vegetable oilseeds avoids the complicated and expensive extraction step [60]. Some drawbacks of pyrolysis are: ∑ use of tremendous amounts of heat; ∑ production of a wide range of compounds due to low selectivity; ∑ removal of oxygen from substrate molecules (thus eliminating one of the benefits of oxygenated fuels); and ∑ creation of solid residues of ash and carbon, thus requiring additional separation steps. Vegetable oils and animal fats can be hydrogenated catalytically under formation of a product that can be used as a commercial fuel (see Section 15.4). Finnish Patent No. FI 100,248 to Aalto et al. (to Neste Oy) [76] describes a two-step process for producing middle distillate from vegetable oil by hydrogenating fatty acids of vegetable oil or triglycerides, to give n-paraffins, and then branched-chain paraffins by isomerising the n-paraffins.
26
Biodiesel science and technology
Neste Oy has recently commercialised a renewable diesel process based on hydrotreated vegetable oils (HVOs) and animal fats [45, 77] (see also Section 15.4.1). US Patent Appl. No. 2006/0207166 A1 to Herskowitz et al. [78] describes a one-step hydrodeoxygenating/hydroisomerising process for producing a low-sulphur diesel fuel composition (mixture of C14 to C18 (iso)paraffins) from vegetable and/or animal oil using a dual-functional Pt/ SAPO-11 catalyst at 643–683 K at 2–4 MPa. Hydrocracking was inhibited. Composition and fuel characteristics of the produced diesel may be adjusted by varying the vegetable and/or animal starting product, process conditions and catalyst used. Paraffinic diesel fuel compositions provide superior fuel properties, especially for low-temperature performance (e.g. density, viscosity, cetane number, lower heating value, cloud point and CFPP), to FAME biodiesel. US Patent No. 6,364,917 B1 to Matsumura and Murakami [79] discloses a method of converting virgin plant oils and/or waste vegetable oils into (diesel) fuel, by heating the oil, mixing the oil with water and/or ozone and agitating the mixture of oil and water dissipating the ozone. Ozonation (aeration with ozone-oxygen mixed gas) at close to normal temperature (313–353 K) involves no other chemicals aside from ozone (i.e. electrical power) and readily allows transformation of waste oils and requires low plant construction costs. The end product has lower average molecular weight than petrodiesel as a result of formation of ozonides (1,2,4-trioxolane rings) and bond rupture in the fatty acids composing the vegetable oil (i.e. aldehyde formation) [80]. Obviously, the chemistry of the resulting fuel differs totally from that of hydrotreating, pyrolysis or transesterification technology. As ozonation hardly produces any post-refining waste matter it thus shows remarkable efficacy as a recycling system.
1.4
Global biodiesel development
The usage of biodegradable fuels from renewable agricultural oils and fats represents only a small fraction of the market for industrial products in developed countries. Global production of biofuels has developed from about 15 Mt in 2000 (biodiesel 0.7 Mt; bioethanol 14.4 Mt) to 40.7 Mt in 2005 (biodiesel 3.7 Mt, bioethanol 37.0 Mt) (Table 1.7), compared with 1.2 Bt of gasoline. Main biofuel producers were US (14.0 Mt) and Brazil (14.1 Mt). US bioethanol production figures have recently increased steeply from about 8.9 Mt in 2001/02 and 16.6 Mt in 2006 to 23 Mt (or 0.45 Mbd) in 2007, putting the farm system into a high state of alarm by using 27% of the entire corn crop production [81]. Nevertheless, even this record level still replaced only about 5% of the US total gasoline consumption. IEA estimates foresee a 2008 world biofuel production of 1.35 Mbd (70 Mt/yr), which is expected to rise to 1.95 Mbd (100 Mt/yr) by 2013.
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
27
Table 1.7 Biofuels production (2005) Country
Production (ML)
US Brazil P.R. China India EU Others Total
16 130 15 990 3800 1700 3100 5480 46 200
Brazil (191.8 M population) has one of the most advanced biofuels programmes in the world with over 30 000 filling stations offering pure hydrous ethanol as well as gasoline with a mandatory blend of E20 to E25. Brazilian bioethanol takes up half the country’s sugarcane crop. Brazil has been world leader in E95 (azeotropic bioethanol) and E25 for the last 25 years. ‘Flex-fuel’ vehicles (FFVs; Brazil, USA, Sweden) allow use of E85. In Brazil 60% of all new cars run on a fuel mix made up of 85% bioethanol. Brazil has recently started biodiesel production. EU25 is the main biodiesel producer but also generates small amounts of bioethanol (491 kt in 2004), mainly in Spain, France, Germany and Sweden from wheat (50%), barley (20%) and sugar beet (30%), with a forecast of 640 kt for 2008. Ethanol is generally used in gasoline as ethyl tertiary butyl ether (ETBE). Biofuels of minor production were neat vegetable oils (Austria, Germany) and biogas (Sweden). Diesel fuel is largely utilised in road, rail and sea transport, agriculture, and commercial, domestic and industrial sectors for the generation of power and mechanical energy. Today’s biodiesel industry is about 20 years old. In 2005, biodiesel contributed only about 1.8% of the EU diesel fuel consumption and just over 0.2% of that in the US. Although its potential has initially been held back by legislation, fiscal and duty structure, blending technology, learning curve and interested parties, today the industry is growing fast with an expected production of 11.1 Mt in 2008 [82]. This figure may be compared with a world production of about 130–135 Mt of vegetable oils (2007). In particular, the first-generation biodiesel markets in Europe and the US have reached impressive biodiesel capacity levels but are constrained by feedstock availability. Global biodiesel production in 2007 was mainly derived from RSO (4.6 Mt), SBO (2.1 Mt) and PMO and other vegetable oils and animal fats (<2.0 Mt), with the EU being the main biodiesel manufacturer (66%). Only five years ago, Europe was the dominant player in the biodiesel industry, accounting for more than 83% of the global installed capacity and 93% of world biodiesel production and consumption. By 2007 the European share had declined to about 46%, with North America and Asia accounting for 23% and 19% of world biodiesel capacity, respectively [83].
28
Biodiesel science and technology
Diesel fuel consumption and market share are expected to rise significantly in North America, as well as Eastern Europe and in developing Asia. International regulations promote biodiesel growth [84]. Biofuels have been successfully implemented only in those countries that have recognised the benefits and have undertaken appropriate policy actions to support biofuels. The extent to which biodiesel has entered the marketplace varies significantly by country. Biodiesel is usually blended with petroleum diesel to make biodiesel blends; B100 is pure FAME, while B20, B5 and B2 are fairly common blend levels. Low-level blending is the easiest and cheapest way for marketing biodiesel. The distribution of B5 requires negligible investments in distribution systems and no different pumps or labels. Most oil companies are therefore prepared to support low-level blends more than B100, which requires higher investments. Pure biodiesel (B100) requires entirely separate logistics and a dedicated car fleet. Some 400 000 cars in Germany, Austria and Sweden use B100. Biodiesel is sold in unblended form directly to freight forwarding companies, and to mineral oil dealers. The European diesel quality standard EN 590 does not allow using FAME blends exceeding 5% with diesel. The 5% biofuel blending cap only applies for consumer vehicles. Others, such as fleets, can come to individual agreements with their vehicle manufacturers. For example, in 2007 UK retailer Tesco was running its delivery fleet on B50 and UK’s McDonald on B100; Scania trucks allow for B100. Similary, Safeway (USA) uses B20 in its fleet of more than 1000 trucks. Also Eastman Chemical Co. is fueling its locomotive fleet, heavy-duty vehicles and equipment at Kingsport, TN, with B20. Low-level B5 blending is not sufficient to meet the 2010 targets for biofuels. This dilemma can be overcome by: alteration of the fuel standards for diesel to allow blending of B10, or promotion of the diffusion of high-level blends (requiring flexi-fuel vehicles). The escalation in crude oil prices since 2005 up to and beyond US$100/ barrel (Fig. 1.5) – doubling from US$69 in June 2007 to US$147 in June 2008 – and way up from the 1991 level of US$20 determines in principle a favourable marketing opportunity for biodiesel and other alternative energy sources. Commercial biodiesel is usually obtained by transesterification of crude or more expensive high-quality VO raw materials or blends of different types of VOs, in relation to (limited) market availability in order to achieve the final desired properties of the fuel (oxidation stability, iodine number). Apart from production costs, development of the biodiesel industry depends on several non-technological factors, including feedstock prices and market availability, crude oil prices, and taxation of energy products. The extremely high global energy prices have driven up feedstock costs for many products. For example, European RSO prices have increased from US$480/t (exchange rate 7/US$: 1.10) in 2003 to US$670/t (exchange rate 7/US$: 1.20) by the end of 2004, and even higher more recently (see Fig. 14.9). Consequently,
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
29
95 90 85 80
US$/barrel
75 70 65 60 55 50 45 40 2005
2006
Year
2007
2008
1.5 Crude oil price per barrel.
the market cost of biodiesel remains higher than that of petroleum-based diesel despite the fact that between April 2007 and April 2008 the price of No. 2 diesel in the US increased by 35% (with an increase of 52% from Apr. 2005–08). Refined vegetable oils, especially RSO in Europe and SBO in the US are the most common feedstocks for biodiesel production. These raw materials are traditionally more expensive than palm oil (see Figs 5.1, 14.9 and Table 5.9). Favourable taxation in Europe has allowed biodiesel to achieve approximate cost parity with conventional diesel. Based on 7.7 lb of soybean oil (at US$0.22/lb; 2003 level) required for 1 gal, up to 91% of the product cost of biodiesel is accounted for by the feedstock. With processing costs ranging from US$0.15 to US$0.50 per pound, operating cost and capital cost represent about 3–4% and production cost some 5–6% [85]. As biodiesel made from refined SBO makes difficult competition with petroleum-derived diesel fuel, this calls for use of lower value lipids. For palm oil sourced biodiesel to be competitive with petrodiesel the price of crude palm oil should not exceed US$1.82/gal, assuming absence of tax on biodiesel. This price level has recently been exceeded. Transesterification of palm oil adds about US$0.53/gal to the price of the oil. Use of low-cost feedstocks, such as non-edible oils or waste frying oils,
30
Biodiesel science and technology
help make biodiesel competitive in price with petroleum diesel [86]; some industrial plants exploit recycled cooking oil as a feedstock (see Tables 1.8, 11.7 and 14.21). Prices (2003) per pound are lower for inedible tallow (US$0.14), mustard oil (US$0.10), yellow grease (US$0.09) and brown or trap grease (US$0.05). While fuel quality is not greatly affected, there are concerns that pour point could be increased by using such lower quality feedstocks. Moreover, a higher free fatty acid content makes processing more expensive. In case of use of waste materials, logistics of collection and availability are limiting factors, as always in recycling. Biodiesel production using the transesterification process is also being limited in several countries because of an excess supply of the by-product glycerol.
1.4.1 Rape biodiesel Biodiesel fuel was first commercially produced in a pilot plant in Silberberg (Austria) in 1985 [87]. Already in 1997 biodiesel development had been identified in 28 countries with a worldwide capacity of some 1.2 Mt/yr [88]. Meanwhile world biodiesel production is rapidly expanding from 2.7 Mt in 2003 (60% EU share) to 7.1 Mt in 2006 (69% EU share). Different countries adopt different solutions. Table 1.8 shows the status of biodiesel production in several countries. At the moment, 35–40% of Europeans drive diesel cars. Diesels reached a 53.3% share of new car registrations in Europe in 2007. On the other hand, only about 3% of US passenger vehicles now run on diesel although the US light-duty diesel market share is expected to increase to 6.9% by 2012 and 14.4% by 2017 [89]. Total diesel consumption in the EU (2005) amounted to 170 Mt, and continues to expand (see Fig. 1.2). There is a predicted shortage of EU mineral diesel refining capacity. The EU could be 20% short of its mineral diesel needs by 2015. The continuing trend of increasing diesel car ownership and increasing need for imported diesel while gasoline demand is decreasing (Fig. 1.2) ensure that biodiesel is an important contributor towards Europe’s energy security strategy. Biodiesel is being produced on an industrial scale in the EU primarily as rapeseed methyl ester (RME). Whereas in 2003 only nine member states produced biodiesel (with 89% being produced in Germany, France and Italy), in 2007 almost all member states are producers (see Table 14.31). The EU27 (as the world’s leading producer) reported a production of over 4.9 Mt/yr of biodiesel in 2006 in comparison with 3.2 Mt in 2005 (+54%), after a 65% record growth in 2005 over 2004 (Fig. 1.6). While production was beyond expectation (see Table 1.2), the biodiesel target (EU Directive 2003/30/EC) was not respected by all member states. In the past, total EU nameplate biodiesel capacity has not been used to its full extent (2.4 Mt vs. 1.8 Mt production in 2004). Although the EU biodiesel industry is in a good
Table 1.8 Status of biodiesel production in selected countries Country Reference year
Number of production plants
Nameplate Feedstock Domestic crops production (cropland) capacity (kt/yr)
a
70 400 1500–1800 1400 1400 570 – f
n.g. n.g. n.g.
n.g. n.g. n.g.
31
Assuming 1 t/ha for rapeseed. Production quota. c Under construction. d Expansion. e Including 1 310 kt/yr unconfirmed capacity. f 1.3 billion dry t/yr of biomass; vast surplus of capacity resources. g Total cropland area: 455 M acres. h Total cropland area: 150 Mha. b
RSO (70 kha) RSO (n.g.) RSO (1.2 Mha) RSO (1.4 Mha) RSO, import RSO (570 kha) – SBO (73.0 M acres) CRO (68.8 M acres) CSO (13.8 M acres)g CO (15.5 M acres) SBO (15 Mha), (SNO) SBO (23 Mha) CRO (14 Mha) CSO (0.2 Mha) PNO (0.1 Mha)h SBO (n.g.) Import PMO (3.75 Mha)
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
Austria 2007 11 326 RSO, UCO, (SNO) Czech Republic 2007 17 203 RSO, UCO, (SNO, SBO) France 2007 8 1450 RSO, SNO, SBO Germany 2006 39 3603 RSO, PMO, SBO, UCO Italy 2006 11 857b RSO, SBO, SNO UK 2007 n.g. 657 UCO, TLW, RSO, SBO Netherlands 2008 8 571 RSO, SBO, PMO, SNO US Sept. 2008 165 (+12c+1d) 8840e (+1 160c) SBO, UCO, (RSO, CSO, TLW) Canada 2009 9 216 CO, TLW, UCO Argentina 2010 33 3697 SBO Brazil 2008 51 2058 SBO, CSO Australia 2008 n.g. 500 RSO, SNO, SBO, TLW, UCO P.R. China 2007 n.g. 200 RSO, PMO, CSO, UCO Malaysia 2008 12 1500 PMO
Maximum domestic oil potential (kt/yr)a
32
Biodiesel science and technology 6000
5000
Germany France Italy
4500
Total
5500
EU27
Others EU
EU27
4000
kt/yr
3500
EU25
3000 2500 EU15
2000 EU15
1500
EU15
1000 500
EU15 EU15
0 1998
2000
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
1.6 Biodiesel production in EU and member states (Source: European Biodiesel Board).
position to be able to fulfil the 2010 EU biofuel target in terms of capacity, expectations as to production are stagnating or may even decline as from 2007. Table 1.9 shows the growth in German biodiesel production capacity over the period 2000–07, which has recently increased considerably and accounts for about a third of the European capacity in 2008 (see Table 14.31). Today there are some 40 small to industrial-scale plants in Germany alone, using RSO as 90% of total feedstock. Since fuels in Germany are taxed according to carbon emissions, with biodiesel enjoying a healthy tax break, production has long been competitive with diesel fuel. In the recent past, almost 2000 filling stations throughout Germany offered biodiesel at their pumps. On the basis of fossil diesel road consumption (25.5 Mt in 2001; annual increase of 2%) and considering that 700 kha rapeseed cultivation yields 1 Mt biodiesel, Germany requires at least 450 kha of rapeseed oil cultivation for biodiesel production alone in 2005 and 1.3 Mha in 2010 in order to meet the EU targets (of 2% in 2005 and 5.75% in 2010). However, due to new legislation (the biofuels quota act and energy tax act), leading to loss of the tax credit, and the recent steep increase in vegetable oil prices, biodiesel growth in Germany has slowed down. With massive B99 exports
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
33
Table 1.9 Biodiesel production capacity in Germany Yeara Number of producers
Plant capacity range (kt/yr)
Total capacity (kt/yr)
Production (kt/yr)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
2–100 2–120 2–120 2–120 2–120 2–180 2–425 n.d.
340 506 849 1105 1237 1973 3603 4361
265 450 550 700 1064 1669 2662 2890
6 11 17 25 27 30 39 n.d.
Source: Union zur Förderung von Oel- und Proteinpflanzen e.V. (UFOP). End of year.
a
from the US to the EU, about 75% of Germany’s biodiesel production capacity now lies virtually idle. In the UK sales of biodiesel amounts to 20 kt/yr (2005) compared to total diesel sales of approximately 22.4 Mt/yr. Biodiesel thus makes up less than 0.1% of total UK diesel sales and less than 0.04% of total combined petrol and diesel sales. Taking into account exported wheat and set-aside farm land, the UK could produce a maximum of 5% of its current (2007) transport fuel requirement. France has adopted more ambitious objectives than the European Commission for biofuel incorporation into conventional fuels. Expected French biodiesel production is 1.45 Mt by 2008, out of a projected French consumption of 35 Mt of diesel and 10 Mt of gasoline in 2008 [90]. One third of Italian territory (10 Mha, or almost the total agricultural area) would be needed for rapeseed cultivation to attain production equivalent to 10% of total domestic petroleum product consumption.
1.4.2 Soy biodiesel Only 6% of US energy (2006) comes from renewable sources (including hydropower and wood) with no more than 1% from wind, solar and biofuels. US consumption figures for 2007 are 143 Bgy of gasoline and 63 Bgy of diesel and distillate fuel. The high consumption of petroleum transportation fuels in the US (522 gal per capita in 2001), far in excess to that of other most developed countries (Germany 211 gal, Japan 196 gal), suggests an impelling need for more energy efficiency and massive conversion from gasoline-powered cars and light-duty trucks to cleaner-burning diesel vehicles. However, there is only limited support from the car industry for consumer diesels in the US. This might change following the 2008 financial crisis and the election of the Obama administration.
34
Biodiesel science and technology
Much of the early support for biodiesel in the US came from the American Soybean Association, which implemented a soybean checkoff programme in 1991 and funded biodiesel research. Biodiesel has been registered with the EPA as a fuel and a fuel additive under Section 211(b) of the Clean Air Act. Biodiesel is available only at around 1650 retail filling stations across the US (as at Oct. 2009). The Soyatech Biofuels Index monitors development of biofuels production capacity [91]. One of the driving forces behind the development of the biodiesel industry was a glut of virgin oils such as soybean and rapeseed (canola) oils on the market only five years ago. The main reason that biodiesel has not gained wider acceptance in the US in the past is the consistently much higher retail price of biodiesel relative to petrodiesel (see Fig. 1.7). In fact, the price of soybean oil, before esterification, was even higher than that of the final competing product, petrodiesel. In 2006, the on-highway petrodiesel price ranged between US$2.50 and US$3.00/gal, reaching US$4.00/gal in June 2008 (but averaging US$2.19/gal in Feb. 2009). This price includes taxes (20%), cost of crude oil (52%), refining expenses (19%), distribution and 3.0 Biodiesel (medium) Base diesel 2.5
1.5
1.0
0.5
3
2 l-0
pr -0 A
1 Ju
-0 ct
01
O
n-
0
Ja
9
pr -0
l-9
A
-9
8 Ju
ct
98
O
7
Ja
n-
6 l-9
pr -9 A
-9
5 Ju
ct O
n-
95
0.0 Ja
US$
2.0
1.7 Comparison of price per gallon (no tax) of diesel fuel vs. canola biodiesel (after ref. [92]).
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
35
marketing (9%). Excluding taxes and distribution the average 2006 price for petrodiesel was therefore US$1.85/gal (crude oil 73%, refining 27%). Biodiesel blends are relatively competitive with a premium of 6.2 and 24.9 cents/lb for B5 and B20, respectively. High oil prices were once expected to trigger a major increase in soy biodiesel in the US. In the past, the corresponding demand for soybean oil could easily be accommodated in view of an existing soybean surplus situation and idle production capacity. The resulting expected economic impacts of biodiesel were estimated as an increase of US$0.10 to US$0.18 to the price of soybeans at a demand for 70 Mgal of soy biodiesel [93]. However, in practice the world market prices of vegetable oils are even more strongly influenced by the increasing need for foodstuff oils of developing countries (P.R. China, India). In recent years the price of virgin oils has been pushed up from about US$0.20/lb to US$0.60/lb and beyond (see Table 14.20). While the US still enjoys low fuel prices relative to Europe, US diesel sales have begun an upward trend. The US consumer diesels are expected to be on the verge of an increase in market share. As shown in Table 1.10, vegetable oil crops cannot realistically satisfy US (or indeed global) demand for fuel consumption. The combined vegetable oil, animal fat and grease production in the US of 21 Mt/yr (2006) could at most provide 6.0 Bgy of biodiesel. Consequently, biodiesel based on these resources can only ever replace a small fraction of the petroleum-based diesel fuel in the US. Although markets in key bioproduct areas (mainly bioethanol) are expected to expand considerably, biomass now accounts for no more than 3% of US energy needs [94]. Corn-derived bioethanol contributes about 3.6% to the total transportation fuels mix (2007). Bioethanol from corn is not a real solution to the US transportation fuel problem (see Section 1.4). Lately, the US government is actively encouraging production of biodiesel Table 1.10 Comparison of some sources of biodiesel (after ref. [95]) Crop
Oil yield (L/ha)
Land area needed (Mha)a
Percent of existing US cropping areaa
Corn Soybean Canola Jatropha Coconut Oil palm Microalgaeb Microalgaec
172 446 1190 1892 2689 5950 136 900 58 700
1540 594 223 140 99 45 2 4.5
846 326 122 77 54 24 1.1 2.5
a
For meeting 50% of all transport fuel needs of the US. 70 wt% oil in biomass. c 30 wt% oil in biomass. b
36
Biodiesel science and technology
as an alternative to petroleum-based fuels by subsidies which stimulate production but not domestic consumption (see Section 1.2.1). US biodiesel production is rapidly gaining momentum (Fig. 1.8) and has grown from a mere 0.5 Mgy (1999), directed to niche markets, to 7 Mgy (2000) and to over 25 Mgy (2004). The 2004 production did not exceed 0.1% of total diesel consumption for transportation purposes (39.9 Bgy in 2003). US production in the period 1999–2004 was indeed a very small fraction of European production [96]. Meanwhile, biodiesel sales volumes developed from 250 Mgy in 2006 (with a 230% increase from 2005) to 450 Mgy (1.5 Mt) in 2007 [97], and beyond. The biodiesel-blender tax incentive (recently extended up to 31 Dec. 2009) has been instrumental in the rapid growth of the US biodiesel industry and has been responsible for exports to Europe (1 Mt in 2007). The Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 calls for more biodiesel usage, from 0.5 Bgy (2009) to 1 Bgy (2012). Biodiesel plants increased from 88 to 178 units from 2006 to Sept. 2008 (31 idle, 12 under construction, 1 under expansion; 21 unconfirmed). At least 113 US plants (with total nameplate capacity of 1853 MMgy) are continuing to produce biodiesel (24 Sept. 2008), but at below 40% production capacity [98]. Additional manufacturing plants
700
600
Mgal
500
400
300
200
100
0 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Year
1.8 US biodiesel production.
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
37
are being built to accommodate further growth, now at a slower rate than expected in the past [99]. In the near future a combined production capacity of 3.0 Bgy is expected (see Table 14.36). While it was expected in 2002 that US production might be upgraded to at least 350 Mgy by as late as 2011, with incentives comparable to those provided for ethanol, US biodiesel sales could then actually easily reach 1 Bgy, all greatly depending on oil prices. This production volume would upset glycerol markets. US producers use mostly soy oil and recycled cooking oils. US options for additional feedstock supply are several: SBO (reducing exports), oil-rich oilseeds (e.g. canola), palm (imports), mustard, camelina, algae and jatropha (under development). Canola would be the lower cost feedstock of biodiesel production compared to soybean and sunflower. However, because of the value of its co-products (e.g. meal), soybean results in a lower production cost for biodiesel than canola. Consequently, soybean oil continues to dominate the US market as feedstock to biodiesel. In 2007, 12% of US soybean production (4% of global soybean production) was used by the US biodiesel industry to produce fuel, exceeding total US soy oil exports. In a tight market this is sufficient to raise prices. The US is currently characterised by high soybean prices and idle plants virtually next to fields of soybean that biodiesel producers cannot afford. Soy prices are likely to drop in 2009. Total consumption of soy oil for food use has decreased nearly 1 billion pounds over the last three years in the US. Argentina is another important soy biodiesel producer and exporter (see Section 14.6.4).
1.4.3 Tropical oil crop biodiesels Today only a few percent of global transportation fuels are derived from biomass and are produced either by fermentation of food-derived carbohydrates (e.g. sugar or cornstarch) to ethanol or by processing of plant oils to produce biodiesel. Except for Brazil, where favourable agricultural conditions and a flexible processing infrastructure allow the majority of the country’s road transport to be powered economically with cane-derived ethanol, without mandates or subsidies biomass derived fuels are not economically competitive with fossil fuels even at crude oil prices of US$150/barrel and at correspondingly high vegetable oil prices. Brazil needs some 534 M barrels/yr, or 85 Mt/yr. The Brazilian diesel oil consumption (2003) amounts to about 40 Mt. Estimated domestic biodiesel need in Brazil will be about 800 kt in 2008 (mandatory B2 blend) up to 2.5 Mt in 2013 (at B5 mandate). This requires 8–25 100 kt/yr plants. Installed capacity is increasing rapidly from 50 kt (2005) and 600 kt (2006) to 2 Mt (2007). Brazilian biodiesel production has just started, using mainly soybean oil, but many other options are being considered and implemented (SNO, CSO, PMO, jatropha, castor). Brazil’s initial involvement in biodiesel
38
Biodiesel science and technology
production (by ethanolysis of SBO) is clearly too restrictive. The regulation of biodiesel production in Brazil does not limit the use of vegetable oils [100]. Babassu palm (17 Mha) could produce at least 20 Mt oil/yr. The country could easily become a major renewable fuel supplier, both for bioethanol and biodiesel. Palm diesel has been established as a diesel substitute since 1996. Malaysia is the second largest producer of palm oil and operates a 500 kt/yr biodiesel plant (2003). Malaysia intends to utilise crude palm oil and RBD palm oil (olein) at 5–10% blend level directly, or as palm diesel, as industrial and transport fuels, also in order to achieve price stabilisation of the palm oil market during periods of high stock levels. Malaysian palm oil methyl ester was already used in 1987 as biodiesel in buses. With a limitation in the CFPP of 284 K, this type of biodiesel faces a major obstacle in colder climatic conditions, where it may be used in multi-feedstock mode. The use of coconut biodiesel is being tested by the Philippine Coconut Authority. In Thailand various mixes of CNO and PMO blended with diesel oil have been introduced without meeting the official standards for commercial use. P.R. China is one of the biggest diesel oil consumers worldwide (60–70 Mt) with a forecast growth of 6.4% from 1999 to 2020, thus increasing its share for world energy use for transportation to 9.1%. The country is highly import dependent and committed to non-food biodiesel feedstocks. Bioethanol development is much faster than that of biodiesel. Japan has interest in importation of coco-biodiesel. A recent overview of the Asian biodiesel industry can be found in Wahid [24]. See also Section 14.6.4.
1.5
Value chain of biodiesel
Actors in the biodiesel industry include the vegetable oil industry, biodiesel technology providers and producers, trade associations, oil companies, automobile manufacturers and regulatory agencies. The general public does not play any role in either supporting or blocking biodiesel (except perhaps in plebiscitian Switzerland). Along the biodiesel value chain, the main actors are the vegetable oil milling facilities and crude oil industry (i.e. the blending and distribution steps). Few companies have an integrated position along the whole biodiesel supply chain. Examples of vertical integration of vegetable oil and biodiesel producers are Diester Industrie (France; RSO/ RME), AGD and Vicentin (Argentina; SBO/SBME), Archer Daniels Midland Co. (USA; canola/RME), Oelmühle Leer Connemann (Germany; RSO/RME) and Argent Energy (Scotland; TLW, UCO/TME, UFOME). Cargill’s 37.5 MMgy biodiesel plant (Iowa Falls, IA) combines soybean crushing, biodiesel and USP grade glycerol production in a single site. Market development of a new product affects the whole value chain, which is divided into production, supply and consumption. The value chain of
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
39
biodiesel production (Fig. 1.9) begins with large-scale plantation and growing of oil-bearing energy crops (e.g. EU’s set-aside land policy, India’s wasteland cultivation, P.R. China’s Planting Plan, and many physic nut plantations). This is followed by collection of oil-bearing seeds and extracting vegetable oil from the seeds/kernels in expeller units. Thereafter, the vegetable oil is put through a catalytic transesterification process for producing biodiesel. Biodiesel does not typically go straight from the processor to the fuel tank. It has to be distributed, blended in diesel for commercial use, and then redistributed to retailers before it is sold to consumers. Unlike ethanol, very little biodiesel is blended by refiners. Biodiesel is blended just before retail, either by a petroleum marketer or the biodiesel producers themselves. The supply step, including the blending and distribution process is usually the oligopoly of petrol companies. The value chain is easily interrupted, e.g. by an insufficient local infrastructure for blending. Biodiesel can use the transport, storage and retail systems of petrodiesel. In order to effectively ensure that biodiesel products meet all the specifications throughout the entire supply chain (from producer to blender, distributor, engine manufacturer, fleet manager, end-user and regulator) handheld field analysers have been developed (see Section 12.4.3). Critical issues as to a sustainable energy future in which biodiesel plays a role are the net energy balance, sustainable bioenergy crops, scale of production, consumer access and economics (cost-effective production). Increased vegetable oil production for biodiesel is not just a matter of (idle) cropland, but requires construction of crushing and esterification plants, distribution and storage facilities. In addition to the oil produced, also considerable amounts of biomass will be generated. Biodiesel may be directed to the transport sector or heating oil market. Collection
Processing
Distribution
Sourcing
Pre-processing
Storage
Securing
Merging
Storing
Production and monitoring
1.9 Biodiesel production cycle model.
Blending
Delivery
40
Biodiesel science and technology
B100 use is restricted and focused on eco-sensitive environments, such as waterways. Splash-blended 99.99% biodiesel is produced for tax credit allocation and export purposes. Blends of 20% to 2% are for fleet fueling and retail sale. B20 blends serve certain niches such as government and city fleets, whereas blends of less than 2% are used as fuel additives to prolong engine life. When introducing biofuels, fuel distributors need to take into account such issues as storage stability and water tolerance. Managing the transfers and tracking the blending are important to growing a viable biodiesel industry. The US trademarked Rinstar Renewable Fuel System (RFS) Registry provides companies throughout the industry, representing all facets of the supply chain (from producers and importers to marketers, refiners and blenders), with a cost-effective means to manage and validate their renewable fuel transfers while satisfying environmental obligations. This system has been in operation since 1 Sept. 2007 [101]. Biodiesel production is essentially transesterification catalysis. The present text describes the state-of-the-art of advanced processing technologies from both virgin oils and waste oils and fats to produce biodiesel on the basis of scientific and patent literature up to mid 2009 and gives some directions for the future. Methods to reduce the high cost of biodiesel focus on minimising the raw material cost and process (including catalyst) costs. In this respect the role of catalysis is an important one both technologically and economically.
1.6
Bibliography
K. Waldron (ed.), Bioalcohol Production: Biochemical Conversion of Lignocellulosic Biomass, Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Cambridge (2009). W. Thurmond, Biodiesel 2020: A Global Market Survey, Emerging Markets Online, Houston, TX (2008). A. Demirbaş, Biodiesel: A Realistic Fuel Alternative for Diesel Engines, Springer-Verlag, London (2008). National Biodiesel Board, Biodiesel. A Sustainable Choice, Jefferson City, MO (2008). Global Biofuels Center, Global Ethanol and Biodiesel Outlook, 2008–2015, Hart Energy Publishing, Houston, TX (2008). D.M. Mousdale, Biofuels. Biotechnology, Chemistry and Sustainable Development, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (2008). V. Smil, The Metrics of Energy, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (2008). A. Züttel, A. Borgschulte and L. Schlapbach, Hydrogen as a Future Energy Carrier, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (2008). D.A.J. Rand and R.M. Dell, Hydrogen Energy: Challenges and Prospects, RSC Publishing, Cambridge (2008).
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
41
T. Volk, CO2 Rising: The World’s Greatest Environmental Challenge, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (2008). Coordinating Group for Chemical Energy Research, Future Energy Supplies – The Contribution of Chemistry, GDCh, Frankfurt (2007);
[email protected]. European Commission, Adapting to Climate Change in Europe: Options for EU Action, Brussels (2007) COM 354. S. Lee, J.G. Speight and S.K. Loyalka (eds), Handbook of Alternative Fuel Technologies, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (2007). Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Summary for Policymakers, IPCC, Geneva (2007); www.ipcc.ch. European Renewable Energy Council and Greenpeace, Energy Revolution: A Sustainable World Outlook, Greenpeace International, Amsterdam (2007). D. Howell and C. Nakhle, Out of the Energy Labyrinth, I.B. Taurus, London (2007). E. Wilson and D. Gerard (eds), Carbon Capture and Sequestration: Integrating Technology, Monitoring and Regulation, Blackwell Publishing, Oxford (2007). European Commission, An Energy Policy for Europe, Brussels (2007); http:// eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/site/en/com/2007/com2007_0001en01. pdf. Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, World Oil Outlook 2007, OPEC, Vienna (2007). Commission of the European Communities, Biofuels Progress Report: Report on the Progress Made in the Use of Biofuels and Other Renewable Fuels in the Member States of the European Union, Brussels (2006), COM 845 final. European Commission, Green Paper on a European Strategy for Sustainable, Competitive and Secure Energy, Brussels (2006); http://eur-lex.europa. eu/LexUriServ/site/en/com/2006/com2006_0105en01.pdf. European Commission, Renewable Energies Roadmap, Brussels (2006); http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/site/en/com/2006/com2006_0848en01. pdf. European Commission, Action Plan for Energy Efficiency, Brussels (2006); http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/site/en/com/2006/com2006_0545en01. pdf. A. Gore and Melcher Media, An Inconvenient Truth: The Planetary Emergency of Global Warming and What We Can Do about It, Rodale Press, Emmaus, PA (2006). Copenhagen Consensus Group, A United Nations Perspective (30 Oct. 2006); http://www.copenhagen.consensus.com/Admin/Public/DWSDownload.as px?File=Files%2fFiler%2fCC+UNP%2fCC06_Outcome.pdf. European Commission, Directorate – General for Research, Directorate
42
Biodiesel science and technology
Energy, World Energy Technology Outlook – 2050, EUR 22038, Brussels (2006). Department of Trade and Industry, The Energy Challenge. Energy Review Report 2006, DTI, London (2006). Energy Information Administration, International Energy Outlook (DOE/ EIA-0484), U.S. Dept. of Energy, Washington, DC (2006). International Energy Agency (IEA), World Energy Outlook 2006, International Energy Agency Publications, Paris (2006). International Energy Agency (IEA), Energy Technology Perspectives 2006: Scenarios and Strategies to 2050, OECD/IEA, Paris (2006). International Energy Agency – Bioenergy Implementing Agreement (IEA/ BA). Task 39: Liquid Biofuels from Biomass (2004–2006), IEA, Paris (2006). Biofuels Research Advisory Council, Biofuels in the European Union: A Vision for 2030 and Beyond, EU Report, Brussels (2006). Associazione Italiana di Ingegneria Chimica (AIDIC), Aspetti Tecnicoeconomici della Produzione di Biocarburanti, AIDIC, Milan (2006). J. Tickell, Biodiesel America, Yorkshire Press, Ashland, OH (2006). G.A. Olah, A. Goeppert and G.K. Surya Prakash, Beyond Oil and Gas: The Methanol Economy, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (2006). S. Minteer (ed.), Alcoholic Fuels, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (2006). G. Knothe, J. Van Gerpen and J. Krahl (eds), The Biodiesel Handbook, AOCS Press, Champaign, IL (2005). G. Knothe (ed.), Focus on Biodiesel (CD-ROM), AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2005). B. Kamm, P.R. Gruber and M. Kamm (eds), Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products: Status Quo and Future Directions, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (2005). R.S. White, Energy for the Public: The Case for Increased Nuclear Fission Energy, BookSurge Publishing, Santa Barbara, CA (2005). G. Phal, Biodiesel: Growing a New Energy Economy, Chelsea Green, White River Junction, VT (2005); 2nd edn (2008). R.D. Perlack, L.L. Wright, A.F. Turhollow, R.L. Graham, B.J. Stokes and D.C. Erbach, Biomass as Feedstock for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry: The Technical Feasibility of a Billion-Ton Annual Supply, DOE/ USDA, Washington, DC (2005). Commission of the European Communities, Biomass Action Plan, Brussels (2005), COM 628. D. Bockey and W. Von Schenck, Status Report – Biodiesel Production and Marketing in Germany 2005, UFOP, Berlin (2005). D. Bockey (ed.), Biodiesel Flowerpower, UFOP, Berlin (2004). M. Mittelbach and C. Remschmidt, Biodiesel – The Comprehensive Handbook, Boersedruck Ges., Vienna (2004).
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
43
D. Ryan, Biodiesel – A Primer, ATTRA Publication, National Center for Appropriate Technology, Butte, MT (2004). B. Elvers, Handbook of Fuels. Energy Sources for Transportation, WileyVCH, Weinheim (2004). B.T. Aranow (ed.), Winning the Oil Endgame: Innovation for Profits, Jobs and Security, Rocky Mountain Institute, Snowmass, CO (2004). International Energy Agency, Biofuels for Transport, IEA, Paris (2004). Union of Concerned Scientists, The Diesel Dilemma – Diesel’s Role in the Race for Clean Cars, UCS, Cambridge, MA (2004). G. Boyle (ed.), Renewable Energy, Oxford University Press, New York, NY (2004). Wissenschaftlicher Beirat der Bundesregierung, Globale Umweltveränderungen, Welt im Wandel: Energiewende zur Nachhaltichkeit, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (2003). S. Friedrich, A World-wide Review of the Commercial Production of Biodiesel, Institut für Technologie und nachhaltiges Produktmanagement, Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien, Schriftenreihe Umweltschutz und Ressourcenökonomie, Band 41, Vienna (2003). R.C. Brown, Biorenewable Resources, Iowa State University Press, Ames, IA (2003). E.J.S. Parente, Biodiesel: Uma Aventura Tecnológica num Pais Engraçado Ceará, Fortaleza (2003). World Energy Council, Survey of Energy Sources, WEC, New York, NY (2002). Biomass R&D Technical Advisory Committee, Roadmap for Biomass Technologies in the United States, Washington, DC (2002). Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), Climate Change 2001 – Mitigation, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2001). National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Biodiesel – Clean, Green Diesel Fuel, Golden, CO (2001); DOE/GO-102001-1449; www.afdc.doc.gov/ pdfs/Bio_CleanGreen.pdf. B. Lomborg, The Skeptical Environmentalist, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2001). United Nations Development Program, World Energy Assessment: Energy and the Challenge of Sustainability, UNDP, New York, NY (2000). S. Howell and A. Weber, US Biodiesel Overview, National Biodiesel Board (ed.), Jefferson City, MO (2000). C. Song, C.S. Hsu and I. Moshida (eds), Chemistry of Diesel Fuels, Taylor & Francis, London (2000). J. Tickell, From the Fryer to the Fuel Tank: The Complete Guide to Using Vegetable Oil as an Alternative Fuel, Tickell Energy, Hollywood, CA (2000).
44
Biodiesel science and technology
T. Anema and M. Szuic-Krzyzanowski, World of Energy, De Verbeelding Publishers, Amsterdam (2000). D.L. Klass, Biomass for Renewable Energy, Fuels and Chemicals, Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1998). P.T. Anastas and J.C. Warner, Green Chemistry. Theory and Practice, Oxford University Press, New York, NY (1998). C.B. Prakash, A Critical Review of Biodiesel as a Transportation Fuel in Canada. A Technical Report, Global Change Strategies International, Inc., Ottawa (1998). N. Nakicenovic, A. Grübler and A. McDonald (eds), Global Energy Perspectives, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1998). UNFCCC, The Kyoto Protocol, United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, New York, NY (1997). C.E. Wyman, Handbook on Bioethanol: Production and Utilization, Taylor & Francis, New York, NY (1996). W.C. Holmberg and J.E. Peeples, Biodiesel: A Technology, Performance and Regulatory Overview, National SoyDiesel Board, Jefferson City, MO (1994). I.M. Campbell, Biomass, Catalysts and Liquid Fuels, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, London (1983). M. Grosser, Diesel: The Man and the Machine, Book Press, Brattleboro, VT (1978). W.R. Nitske and C.M. Wilson, Rudolf Diesel, Pioneer of the Age of Power, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, OK (1965). R. Diesel, Die Entstehung des Dieselmotors, Julius Springer Verlag, Berlin (1913).
1.7
References
[1] Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Fourth Assessment Report (AR4), UN, New York, NY (2007); adopted at IPCC Plenary XXVII, Valencia (12–17 Nov. 2007). [2] A.B. Robinson, N.E. Robinson and W. Soon, Environmental effects of increased atmospheric carbon dioxide, J. Am. Phys. Surg. 12 (2007) 79–90. [3] B. Lomborg, The Skeptical Environmentalist, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2001). [4] K.P. Shine and W.T. Sturges, CO2 is not the only gas, Science 315 (2007) 1804–5. [5] G. Alexander and G. Boyle, Introducing renewable energy, in Renewable Energy (G. Boyle, ed.), Oxford University Press, New York, NY (2004). [6] K.S. Deffeyes, Hubbert’s Peak: The Impending World Oil Shortage, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ (2001). [7] N.V. Fedoroff and J.E. Cohen, Plants and population: Is there time?, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 (1999) 5903–7.
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
45
[8] Energy Information Administration, International Energy Outlook (DOE/EIA0484), US Dept. of Energy, Washington, DC (2006). [9] C. Griggs, Gas hydrates. A curse to the world’s oil and gas industries or the energy source of the future?, Petro Ind. News 5(5) (2004) 45–6. [10] Renewables in Global Energy Supply, OECD/IEA, Paris (2006). [11] M. Katan, R. Rabbinge and W. Van Swaaij, Toekomst voor biodiesel is illusie, Financieel Dagblad (2006). [12] M.J. Currie, J.K. Mapel, T.D. Heidel, S. Goffri and M.A. Baldo, High-efficiency organic solar concentrators for photovoltaics, Science 321 (2008) 226–8. [13] C. Plöchl, Biodiesel projects under the Kyoto Clean Development Mechanism, Proc. Intl. Congress on Biodiesel, Vienna (5–7 Nov. 2007). [14] European Environment Agency, How Much Biomass Can Europe Use Without Harming the Environment?, EEA Briefing 02 (2005); http://www.eea.eu.int/ [15] G. Bergsma, GHG calculation of biofuels in the international debate: bottlenecks and perspectives, Proc. Intl. Congress on Biodiesel, Vienna (5–7 Nov. 2007). [16] International Energy Agency, Biofuels for Transport – An International Perspective, IEA, Paris (2004). [17] Minnesota State Legislature, The Minnesota Biodiesel Mandate, Minnesota Session Laws, Chapter 239 SF-1495 (15 March 2002). [18] Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Promotion and Use of Energy from Renewable Sources (RED), Brussels, COM (2008) 30 final. [19] The Energy Challenge (report to DTI), http://www.dti.govuk/energy/review/page 31995.html (July 2006). [20] UK Dept. for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, Meeting the Energy Challenge. A White Paper on Energy, BERR, London (2007). [21] P. Hammond, Simmons & Co. International, Houston, TX (2007). [22] US Dept. of Energy (DOE), Plant/Crop-based Renewable Resources 2020 – A Vision to Enhance US Economic Security through Renewable Plant/Crop-based Resource Use, DOE/GO – 10098 – 3385, Washington, DC (Jan. 1998). [23] Philippine Department of Energy, Philippine Energy Plan 2002–2011, Manila (2002). [24] M.B. Wahid, Asian perspective: Overview of the biodiesel industry in Asia, Proc. Intl. Congress on Biodiesel, Vienna (5–7 Nov. 2007). [25] C.L. Peterson, Potential production of biodiesel, in The Biodiesel Handbook (G. Knothe, J. Van Gerpen and J. Krahl, eds.), AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2005), pp. 231–8. [26] www.oecd.org/dataoecd/40/25/39266869.pdf. [27] T. Searchinger, R. Heimlich, R.A. Houghton, F. Dong, A. Elobeid, J. Fabiosa, S. Tokgoz, D. Hayes and T.-H. Yu, Use of U.S. croplands for biofuels increases greenhouse gases through emissions from land-use change, Science 319 (2008) 1238–40. [28] H.W. Lüke, BTL-Kraftstoffe: Eine vielversprechende Option für die Zukunft, Erdoel, Erdgas, Kohle 121 (2005) 3–14. [29] F. Ma and M.A. Hanna, Biodiesel production: a review, Bioresour. Technol. 70 (1999) 1–15. [30] C. Macve and C. Rowntree, Driving towards a cleaner future, Chem. Rev. 14 (2005) 10–13. [31] A.J. Kinney and T.E. Clemente, Modifying soybean oil for enhanced performance in biodiesel blends, Fuel Proc. Technol. 86 (2005) 1137–47.
46
Biodiesel science and technology
[32] C.R. Bayense, H. Hinnekens and J. Martens (to Engelhard/Fina Research), Esterification process, Eur. Pat. EP 0,623,581 A2 (4 May 1994). [33] R.G. Stern, G. Hillion, J.-J. Rouxel and S. Leporq (to IFP), Process for the production of esters from vegetable oils or animal oils and alcohols, US Pat. 5,908,946 (1 June 1999). [34] B. Delfort, G. Hillion and I. Durand (to IFP), Procédé de fabrication de biocarburants. Transformation de triglycerides en deux familles de biocarburants: monoesters d’acides gras et acetales solubles du glycerol, Fr. Pat. Appl. 2,866,654 (26 Aug. 2005). [35] G. Hillion, B. Delfort and I. Durand (to IFP), Procédé de fabrication de biocarburants. Transformation de triglycerides en deux familles de biocarburants: monoesters d’acides gras et ethers solubles du glycerol, Fr. Pat. Appl. 2,866,653 (26 Aug. 2005). [36] C. Baudouin, Biodiesel second-generation technology, Paper presented at WRA 2005 – 6th European Fuels Conference, Paris (14–16 March 2005). [37] Institut Français du Petrole (IFP), Procédé de fabrication d’esters à partir d’huiles végétales ou animales et d’alcools, Fr. Pat. 2,752,242 (13 Feb. 1998). [38] B. Delfort, I. Durand, A. Jaecker, T. Lacome, X. Montagne and F. Paille (to IFP), Compositions de carburants diesel contenant des acetals de glycerol, Fr. Pat. 2,833,607 (20 June 2003). [39] S. Kojima and E.Y. Park, Conversion of residual vegetable oil on waste activated bleaching earth to biodiesel fuel, Nendo Kagaku 44 (2005) 138–42. [40] C.N. Khalil and L.C.F. Leite (to Petrobras), Process for producing biodiesel, PCT Int. Publ. No. WO 2005/030911 (7 Apr. 2005). [41] Y.M. Choo, A.N. Ma and Y. Basiron, Production and evaluation of palm oil methyl esters as diesel substitute, Elaeis Special Issue (1995) 5–25. [42] S.H. Ong, Y.M. Choo, K.Y. Cheah and N. Abu Bakar (to Palm Oil Research and Development Board/Petronas), Production of alkyl esters from oils and fats, Austral. Pat. AU-B-43519/89 (18 Oct., 1989). [43] N. Foidl, G. Foidl, M.Sanchez, M. Mittelbach and S. Hackel, Jatropha curcas L. as a source for the production of biofuel in Nicaragua, Bioresour. Technol. 58 (1996) 77–82. [44] A. Mutsaars and H. Gosselink (Shell Global Solutions); confronta A. Duyndam, C2W103 (17 March 2007), pp. 16–17 (in Dutch). [45] L. Rantanen, R. Linnaila, P. Aakko and T. Harju, NExBTL – Biodiesel fuel of the second generation, SAE Tech. Paper 2005-01-3771 (2005). [46] D. Rothe, J. Lorenz, R. Lämmermann, E. Jacobi, L. Rantanen and R. Linnaila, New BTL diesel reduces effectively emissions of a modern heavy-duty engine, Kolloquium ‘Fuels’ der Technischen Akademie Esslingen (TAE), January 2005. [47] M. Koskinen, M. Sourander and M. Nurminen, Apply a comprehensive approach to biofuels, Hydrocarb. Proc. 85 (2006) 81–6. [48] B. Kamm and M. Kamm, Principles of biorefineries, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 64 (2004) 137–45. [49] D.L. Klass, Biomass for Renewable Energy, Fuels, and Chemicals, Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1998). [50] European Committee for Standardisation. Automotive Fuels. Fatty Acid Methyl Esters (FAME) for Diesel Engines. Requirements and Test Methods. European Standard EN 14214 (2003).
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
47
[51] D. Chiaramonti, M. Bonini, E. Fratini, G. Tondi, K. Gartner, A.V. Bridgwater, H.P. Grimm, I. Soldaini, A. Webster and P. Baglioni, Development of emulsions from biomass pyrolysis liquid and diesel and their use in engines – Part 1: Emulsion production, Biomass Bioen. 25 (2003) 85–99. [52] D. Chiaramonti, M. Bonini, E. Fratini, G. Tondi, K. Gartner, A.V. Bridgwater, H.P. Grimm, I. Soldaini, A. Webster and P. Baglioni, Development of emulsions from biomass pyrolysis liquid and diesel and their use engines – Part 2: Tests in diesel engines, Biomass Bioen. 25 (2003) 101–11. [53] A.V. Bridgwater, Principles and practice of biomass fast pyrolysis processes for liquids, J. Anal. Appl. Pyrol. 51 (1999) 3–22. [54] A.V. Bridgwater, D. Meier and D. Radlein, An overview of fast pyrolysis of biomass, Org. Geochem. 30 (1999) 1479–93. [55] A.V. Bridgwater and G.V.C. Peacocke, Fast pyrolysis processes for biomass, Renew. Sust. En. Revs. 4 (2000) 1–73. [56] D. Meier and O. Faix, State of the art of applied fast pyrolysis of lignocellulosic materials – a review, Bioresour. Technol. 68 (1999) 71–7. [57] Indian Space Research Organisation, Production of hydrocarbons by thermolysis of vegetable oils, UK Pat. 1,524,781 (24 Jan. 1977). [58] R.A. Niehaus, C.E. Goering, L.D. Savage and S.C. Sorenson, Cracked soybean oil as a fuel for a diesel engine, Trans. ASAE 29 (1986) 683–9. [59] A.W. Schwab, G.J. Dykstra, E. Selke, S.C. Sorenson and E.H. Pryde, Diesel fuel from thermal decomposition of soybean oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 65 (1988) 1781–6. [60] M. Predel and W. Kaminsky, Pyrolysis of rape-seed in a fluidised-bed reactor, Bioresour. Technol. 66 (1998) 113–17. [61] F. Billaud, V. Dominguez, P. Broutin and C. Busson, Production of hydrocarbons by pyrolysis of methyl esters from rapeseed oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 72 (1995) 1149–54. [62] J.W. Alencar, P.B. Alves and A.A. Craveiro, Pyrolysis of tropical vegetable oils, J. Agric. Food Chem. 31 (1983) 1268–70. [63] D. Pioch, P. Lozano, M.C. Rasoanantoandro, J. Graille, P. Geneste and A. Guida, Biofuels from catalytic cracking of tropical vegetable oils, Oléagineux 48 (1993) 289–92. [64] C.-C. Chang and S.-W. Wan, China’s motor fuels from tung oil, J. Ind. Engng. Chem. 39 (1947) 1543–8. [65] S. Şensöz and I. Kaynar, Bio-oil production from soybean (Glycine max L.): fuel properties of bio-oil, Ind. Crops Prod. 23 (2006) 99–105. [66] S. Yorgun, S. Şensöz and Ö.M. Koçkar, Flash pyrolysis of sunflower oil cake for production of liquid fuels, J. Anal. Appl. Pyrol. 60 (2001) 1–12. [67] R.O. Dunn, Other alternative diesel fuels from vegetable oils, in The Biodiesel Handbook (G. Knothe, J. Van Gerpen and J. Krahl, eds), AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2005), pp. 241–63. [68] S.P.R. Katikaneni, J.D. Adjaye, R.O. Idem and N.N. Bakhshi, Performance studies of various cracking catalysts in the conversion of canola oil to fuels and chemicals in a fluidized-bed reactor, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75 (1198) 381–91. [69] G.N. da Rocha Filho, D. Brodzki and G. Djéga-Mariadassou, Formation of alkanes, alkylcycloalkanes and alkylbenzenes during the catalytic hydrocracking of vegetable oils, Fuel 72 (1993) 543–9.
48
Biodiesel science and technology
[70] J. Gusmão, D. Brodzki, G. Djéga-Mariadassou and R. Frety, Utilization of vegetable oils as an alternative source for diesel-type fuel: hydrocracking on reduced Ni/ SO2 and sulphided Ni-Mo/g-Al2O3, Catal. Today 5 (1989) 533–44. [71] J.R.S. Dos Anjos, W. De Araujo Gonzalez, Y.L. Lam and R. Frety, Catalytic decomposition of vegetable oil, Appl. Catal. 5 (1983) 299–308. [72] F.A.A. Twaiq, A.R. Mohamad and S. Bhatia, Performance of composite catalysts in palm oil cracking for the production of liquid fuels and chemicals, Fuel Proc. Technol. 85 (2004) 1283–300. [73] F.A.A. Twaiq, N.A.M. Zabidi, A.R. Mohamad and S. Bhatia, Catalytic conversion of palm oil over mesoporous aluminosilicate MCM-41 for the production of liquid hydrocarbon fuels, Fuel Proc. Technol. 84 (2003) 105–20. [74] F.A.A. Twaiq, A.R. Mohamad and S. Bhatia, Liquid hydrocarbon fuels from palm oil by catalytic cracking over aluminosilicate mesoporous catalysts with various Si/Al ratios, Micropor. Mesopor. Mat. 64 (2003) 95–107. [75] H.F. Gerçel, A.E. Pütün and E. Pütün, Hydropyrolysis of extracted Euphorbia rigida in a well-swept fixed-bed tubular reactor, En. Sourc. 24A (2002) 423–30. [76] P. Aalto and O. Piirainen (to Neste Oy), Keskilisleen valmistus, Finnish Pat. FI 100,248 (6 Aug. 1997). [77] S. Mikkonen, Second-generation renewable diesel offers advantages, Hydrocarb. Proc. (Feb. 2008) 63–8. [78] M. Herskowitz, M. Landau, I. Reizner and M. Kaliya (to Ben Gurion University of the Negev Research and Development Authority), Production of diesel fuel from vegetable and animal oils, US Pat. Appl. 2006/0207166 A1 (21 Sept. 2006). [79] M. Matsumura and S. Murakami, Method and equipment of refining plant oil and waste vegetable oil into diesel engine fuel, US Pat. No. 6,364,917 B1 (2 Apr. 2002). [80] N.U. Soriano, V.P. Migo and M. Matsumura, Ozonation of sunflower oil: spectroscopic monitoring of the degree of unsaturation, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 80 (2003) 997–1001. [81] M.R. Simmons, Can motor fuels be redesigned?, Hydrocarbon Proc. (Feb. 2008) 41–4. [82] W. Thurmond, Biodiesel 2020: A Global Market Survey, 2nd edn, Emerging Markets Online, Houston, TX (2008). [83] S. Blagoev, S. Bizzari, R. Gubler, C. Funada and Z. Yi, Biodiesel Report 2008, SRI Consulting, Stanford, CA (Sept. 2008). [84] Y. Basiron, Biofuel: an alternative fuel in the Malaysian scenario, Palm Oil Dev. 42 (June 2005) 1–2. [85] J. Duffield, H. Shapouri, M. Graboski, R. McCormick and R. Wilson, Biodiesel Development: New Markets for Conventional and Genetically Modified Agricultural Products, Economic Research Service Rept. No. 770, USDA, Washington, DC (1998). [86] Y. Zhang, M.A. Dubé, D.D. McLean and M. Kates, Biodiesel production from waste cooking oil: 2. Economic assessment and sensitivity analysis, Bioresour. Technol. 90 (2003) 229–40. [87] Austrian Biofuels Institute (ABI), World-wide trends in reduction and marketing of biodiesel. Presentation at ALTENER-Seminar New Markets for Biodiesel in Modern Common Rail Diesel Engines, University of Technology, Graz (22 May, 2000).
Biodiesel as a renewable energy source
49
[88] W. Körbitz, Review on Commercial Production of Biodiesel Worldwide 1997, Austrian Biofuels Institute, Vienna (1998). [89] A. Bedwell, Global diesel trends, Presentation at Renewable Diesel Conference, Houston, TX (15–16 Nov. 2007). [90] M.-C. Hénard, GAIN Report-FR6005, USDA Foreign Agricultural Service, Paris (2006). [91] Soyatech Biofuels Index, www.soyatech.com /store.htm. [92] C. Strong, C. Erickson and D. Shukla, Evaluation of Biodiesel Fuel: Literature Review, Report to Montana Department of Transportation, Helena, MT (Jan. 2004). [93] Biodiesel Economic Impacts, Minnesota Soybean Board webpage, http://www. mnsoybean.org/showpages.cfm?pageid=566. [94] Canadian Agri-Food Research Council, An Assessment of the Opportunities and Challenges of a Bio-Based Economy for Agriculture and Food Research in Canada, Ottawa, ON (2003). [95] Y. Chisti, Biodiesel from microalgae, Biotechnol. Adv. 25 (2007) 294–306. [96] European Biodiesel Board, Biodiesel Production Statistics, Brussels (2003); http:// www.ebb.eu.org/stats.php. [97] B. Prebo and A. Thurlo Pearson, Update on US biodiesel production, Hydrocarb. Proc. (Feb. 2008) 95–8. [98] C.A. Johnson, Biodiesel production trends survey 2008, Biodiesel Mag. 5(5) (2008) 38–42. [99] M. Bowman, D. Hilligoss, S. Rasmussen and R. Thomas, Biodiesel: A renewable and biodegradable fuel, Hydrocarb. Proc. 85(2) (2006) 103–6. [100] Brazilian National Agency for Petroleum, Natural Gas and Biofuels (ANP), Act No. 255 (15 Sept. 2003). [101] C. McMartin, The hidden costs of the renewable fuel standard, Biodiesel Mag. 5(2) (2008) 160–4.
2
Development of non-food agricultural industries for biofuel applications
Abstract: Quite recently, agriculture not only acts as a traditional source for food, feed and fibre, but is generating feedstock for vegetable oil-based renewable fuels. In particular, edible oils are increasingly finding industrial applications for energy purposes beyond their traditional oleochemical use. Higher pressure on globally limited vegetable oil commodities poses commercial and ethical threats which require an urgent solution. As biomass has a limited edible oil potential, development of a non-food agricultural industry for fuel applications has clear advantages. Biotechnology is vital in addressing the growing global demands for crops for food, fodder, fibre and fuel. Key words: Food security, energy needs, non-food crops, renewable energy sources, advanced agroenergy crops.
2.1
Introduction
Out of the 170–200 billion tons of annually produced biomass (any organic matter available on a renewable basis, including dedicated energy crops and trees, agricultural food and feed crop residues, aquatic plants, wood and wood residues, animal wastes, and other waste materials), 75% are carbohydrates (cellulose, starch, saccharose), 20% lignin, and only 5% other natural components such as oils and fats, proteins and other substances. Of the 3.5% biomass production currently used for human needs (or 6 Bty), 62% is used for human food, 33% for energy use, paper and construction needs, and 5% (or 300 Mt) for other technical (non-food) raw materials (clothing, detergents, chemicals) [1]. Agriculture has developed mainly as a source of food, feed and fibre. The economic added-value of plants (in approximate decreasing order) is related to flowers, flavours and fragrances, fine chemicals, feed, fodder and fuels (7F). Out of approximately 125 Mt of oils and fats produced worldwide in 2003, 81% was used in human foodstuffs (over 120 edible oils) and 5% in animal feed. For (oleo)chemical (or non-food) applications 17.4 Mt (14%) were available. Plant oils are widely used for food products such as shortenings, salad and cooking oils, and margarines. Industrial use of vegetable oils is specified in more detail in Section 3.4. Nowadays, some 7% of synthetic chemicals are produced from non-fossil biological sources or by means of biotechnology. Edible vegetable oils may 50
Development of non-food agricultural industries
51
also find useful applications for energy purposes. Table 2.1 shows the main market segments for oils and fats (pharmaceutical, chemical, food and fuel), with an indication of the allowable price levels for the raw materials. There is clearly competition between various applications. Some crops release high-value oils for use in the pharmaceutical and cosmetics industries (e.g. castor oil, jojoba wax oil, argan oil, almond oil, and others). Vegetable oils are a large renewable resource, now harvested at about 125 Mt/yr (2007/08). In recent years, particularly in the EU and US, there has been growing interest in the use of crops as biorenewable industrial feedstocks, for applications such as fuels, lubricants and bio-plastics. The agricultural industry would not be able to expand and create wealth on the current scale if not for biofuel demand; the industry is changing in providing material for first- and second-generation biofuels. Use of vegetable oils for biodiesel has put pressure on the nutritional use of the commodity and has triggered questions about the ethics of pulling edible oils from the food and feed supply chain to produce fuel. Food and energy are the number one drivers in the world. The challenge can be alleviated by exploration of new (non-food) crops and unexploited crops capable of producing oils and fats for the industry [2]; see also Chapter 6. Using waste plant material instead of food crops could circumvent political pressure and public controversy over using crops for fuel. The fact is, however, that even farmers do not make a choice between energy and food; they simply go for the highest profit. Citizens need both food and energy, while politicians avoid unpopular decisions concerning nuclear energy, coal, gentech and eventually just favour windmills as long as they are out of sight.
2.2
Biofuels
Production of liquid transportation fuels and industrial chemicals from biomass relies most heavily on utilisation of polysaccharide, lignocellulosic and triacylglyceride feedstocks. The following products are regarded as biofuels (an umbrella term covering all fuels derived from organic matter): Table 2.1 Market segments for oils and fats Market segment
Market characteristics
Relative potential
Product need (t/yr)
Commercial valuea
Pharmaceutical Chemicalb Food Energy
Very limited Moderate Great Infinite
< 105 2 x 107 108 > 108
> 2000 700–2000 450–700 < 450
a
Price level US$ (2003)/ton. Including cosmetics.
b
52
Biodiesel science and technology
bioethanol, biodiesel, biogas, biomethanol, biodimethylether, bio-methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE), bio-ethyl tertiary butyl ether (ETBE), synthetic biofuels, biohydrogen and pure vegetable oil. The main types of biofuel are bioethanol, as a direct substitute for petrol (although most petrol engines cannot operate on bioethanol without modification) and biodiesel, as a fuel produced by catalytic processing of vegetable oils (and directly applicable in diesel engines without modification). Ethanol may be obtained from corn, which is a crop requiring much water and fertilisers. Alternatives are sugar beets, sugarcane, agricultural waste or fast-growing grasses. Cellulose ethanol has reached production in demonstration plants. Ethanol as a biofuel has several drawbacks: it acts as a poison to microorganisms, is water soluble and requires energy-intensive distillation. Ethanol cannot be pumped, and needs local production with transportation by tanks. Biodiesel fuel has been in commercial use in many countries for up to 20 years. Given the total vegetable oil/animal fat market of about 157 Mt in comparison with world use of crude mineral oil of 4.2 Bty (2006/07) it is apparent that the contribution of vegetable oils to replace mineral oils will ever only be minimal. It is expected, however, that the fundamental aspects of the biofuels industry will change dramatically by 2020.
2.3
Biomass potentials and limitations
Hundreds of crops have been domesticated and cultivated by humankind during the history of agriculture, utilised for food, forage, fibre and medicine. However, only a small number provide the bulk of raw material necessary for human survival. The limited diversity has increased the vulnerability of crops to adverse climatic conditions and fluctuating markets. Not every location on earth is suitable for energy-crop production. Water supply is indispensable for plant growth (a volume of thousands of litres of water is necessary for 1 kg of biomass) and agricultural productivity is limited by the availability of water. Judicious use of water is paramount. Non-food crops, though not edible, nevertheless compete with food crops for land and water supplies. Less than 1% of cultivated land is currently used for the production of transportation fuels. Non-food crops are an ambitious goal. Development of a ‘non-food’ agricultural industry, where non-food refers to all biological materials and processes used in the production of industrial chemicals, polymers and fibres, servicing diverse industrial outlets, is a recent phenomenon. From an agricultural point of view benefits of non-food uses of crops include reduction of food surpluses, creation of new market outlets for agricultural products, development of a new range of value-added products, environmental benefits and sustained employment for farmers and related industries. Moreover, if a non-food agricultural industry can be developed without the need for large
Development of non-food agricultural industries
53
processing units, such production facilities close to the source of the raw materials and end-users strengthen the economy of rural areas. Major technical bottlenecks limiting production and utilisation of industrial crops and products arise from the fact that the quality, quantity and price of agricultural raw materials are insufficient to supply industries with appropriate feedstocks for their processes [3]. More specifically: ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
the batch-to-batch variable composition of biological raw materials is inconvenient for continuous industrial processing; continual supply of raw materials (except waste oils and fats) is difficult as agricultural production is essentially a seasonal activity (not applicable to the tropics); plant size is limited by biomass collection; the specific knowledge base of biological raw materials is limited as for decades industrial R&D has been focused on processing of fossil resources; traditional process technologies for biological materials do not fulfil current ecological requirements; and intensive use of fertilisers might even result in a net loss of energy.
While more than 1000 oil plants have been identified worldwide, existing global lipid production is not enough to meet future demands. Biodiesel production could lead to a shortage of oil. The EU’s ultimate goal of 5.75% market share for biomass-derived transport fuels by 2010 has a profound impact on agriculture, as it would need at least 9% of the EU agricultural area. To achieve the goal of having all petrol diluted by 10% ethanol would require turning 70% of all EU agricultural land into the production of corn. If one-third of the total Italian surface were dedicated to cultivation of rapeseed, this would yield a quantity of biodiesel sufficient to satisfy 40% of the total consumption of diesel for transportation in the country. Similarly, to replace 5% of the fuel consumed annually in the UK with bioethanol requires turning over around 6300 km2 of arable land for this purpose, or 10% of the total arable area of the UK, which would conflict with food production. Harvested cropland in the US is about 147.1 Mha. In the unrealistic scenario that the entire US cropland were planted with rapeseed, a maximum of 40 Bgy of biodiesel could be produced, which is equivalent to 121% of the annual consumption of petrodiesel for on-highway transportation. Soybean cultivation would yield 23 Bgy or 70% of annual consumption. Energy security and food security are no longer distinct problems and are subject to increasing political intervention (such as EU and US oilseed tax subsidies and regulations, bilateral fuel-for-food contracting, Chinese investments in foreign farming land and foodstuff export restrictions by some Asian countries) and financial speculation (hedge funds, futures). Energy needs may become so pressing that so much agricultural land is diverted to
54
Biodiesel science and technology
fuel crops that this results in a shortage in actual food production. Already in the last three years sugar and alcohol are fighting for sugarcane acres in the (sub)tropics; corn and soy are competing for food and fuel applications in the US. A strategy based on the use of agricultural areas for food production and development of robust (non-edible) energy crops (with high draught resistance, high photosynthesis capacity and possibilities for fixation of nitrogen and CO2) for marginal areas limits competition between food and energy/fuels/chemistry. Out of the total global usable land area, consisting of 1650 Mha farmland, 4700 Mha grassland and 5750 Mha forest, by 2000 already some 1550 Mha were considered as being degraded due to erosion, desertification and salination. The degradation process proceeds at 6–10 Mha/yr and is particularly pronounced in the last 30 years. The reform of the EU Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) includes set-aside regulations which allow for growing of new and traditional crops for non-food industrial end-uses (energy, pulp and paper, composites and chemicals) with full hectare premium (EC Directive 1870/95). For example, the EC is attempting to reinstate castor beans as a strategic oil crop to be grown in set-aside lands. In the same context non-wood fibrous plants such as flax, hemp, cotton, miscanthus, kenaf, esparto and cardoon are potential crops for the paper industry in different EU countries. However, although the regulation should have been most attractive for new non-food crops, in practice about 90% of the crops sown were rapeseed and sunflower seed with the main outlet being the biofuels sector. One hectare of agricultural land can annually yield around 1200 L of rape biodiesel (see Fig. 5.2). With the great variations in set-aside rate (in % of total acreage) in the EU (15% in 1992, 5% in 1997, 10% afterwards) calculated maximum domestic oil potentials have varied considerably over time. Table 2.2 lists subsidised hectarage for energy crops in Europe (out of 2.5 Mha). The United States is the largest single consumer of fossil fuels in the world with a consumption exceeding 140 Bgy of gasoline and 60 Bgy of diesel fuel. The amount of biomass grown annually in the US is sufficient to provide approximately 70% of the transportation sector, assuming that this biomass can be converted to clean-burning fuels having high energy densities, such as currently provided by petroleum. It is estimated that the combined forest and agriculture land resources of the US are capable of producing a sustainable supply of biomass (1.3 billion dry tons/yr) without major changes in agricultural practices. This amount of biomass corresponds to approximately 3.5 billion barrels of oil equivalent each year, sufficient to displace about 30% of the country’s present petroleum consumption and still continue to meet food, feed and export demands [4]. Biomass feedstock consumption (190 million dry tons in 2003) surpassed hydropower as the largest domestic source of renewable energy and currently provides over 3% of the total energy consumption in the US. Corn-to-ethanol
Development of non-food agricultural industries
55
Table 2.2 Subsidised areas (kha) for energy crops in Europe Country
2004
2005
Germany France UK Sweden Spain Denmark Finland Austria Italy Others Total
109.1 130.0 33.0 14.5 6.7 4.5 3.5 3.5 – 1.1 305.9
237.7 135.8 88.6 31.1 27.3 17.5 10.3 8.1 0.3 4.7 561.4
Source: EC–DG Agri.
distilleries are springing up all over the US and bioethanol production is forecast to double between 2005 and 2007, by which time bioethanol will be consuming 20% of the total US corn harvest. With the dawning realisation that oil-dependent economies may not be sustainable, the major crop source for producing biofuels, i.e. corn, has recently shown a spectacular rise in price. Biodiesel production in the USA, mainly from soybeans, increased from 12.5 Mgal in 2001 to 700 Mgal in 2008 (Fig. 1.8), partly as a result of an Environment Protection Agency (EPA) mandate to reduce sulphur in diesel fuel. Assuming that all soybeans not needed for food (at constant requirements), feed or export could be used for biodiesel, the maximum available amount of 297 Mbu (million bushels) could result in 415 Mgal of pure biodiesel [4]. The soybean equivalent of oil required for a 4% share of biodiesel in 2016 is projected to increase from 51 Mbu (1.39 Mt) in 2002 to 318 Mbu (8.65 Mt) by 2016. While soybeans are expected to remain the predominant feedstock, an increasing share of biodiesel production will come from other oils, including recycled soybean oil (SBO). Total vegetable oil consumption in the US is about 12 Mt/yr; the country produces some 5.2 Mt of animal derived fats and generates approximately 1.25 Mt/yr of waste recyclable restaurant grease. The US could produce some 3.75 Bgy of vegetable oil (rapeseed oil (RSO) or sunflower oil (SNO)) on its fallow croplands (37 million out of 455 million acres in 2002), but this potential could even double by using high-efficiency farming. Taking into account a share of used frying oil, the US could easily boost biodiesel to over 10% of its annual diesel fuel usage without interference with food production. Algae farming is another area of high potential (see Section 5.7). Chevron Technology Ventures is among proponents of using non-food plants to create transportation fuels.
56
Biodiesel science and technology
Between 1961 and 2001 world production of oil palm fruit grew from 14 Mt/yr to 128 Mt/yr; soybean production increased from 27 Mt/yr to 178 Mt/ yr over the same period. The global area used for soybean crop growth has increased from 24 Mha to 77 Mha, while the yield has doubled from 1.13 to 2.32 t/ha. The amount of global land used for production of oil palm has grown from 4 Mha to 11 Mha, while the worldwide yield of the crop has nearly quadrupled from 3.77 to 12.17 t/ha. In Malaysia, yields have grown even higher, increasing from 11.5 to 17.8 t/ha. High-yield seedlings might increase the crude palm oil (CPO) yield even further (up to 27–30 t/ha). Generally, it is considered that non-edible oils should be exploited as far as possible so that edible oils can be made available for human consumption. This is especially important in developing countries such as India where food supply poses a challenge. Agricultural productivity usually increases by about 1%/yr, but a three- to six-fold increase is needed.
2.4
Advanced agroenergy crops
Biomass production needs improvement as well as development of technologies to derive the maximum amount of usable energy from biomass at an acceptable price. Advances in plant sciences and genetics are required to develop agroenergy crops having increased yield and utility. Although many annual crops have been subjected to continuous domestication, this is much less the case for perennial species. Breeding technologies have traditionally aimed mainly at an improvement in the yield performance of useful plants. Breeding allows propagation of superior plant varieties which are vital to ensure the sustainability of food and energy supplies. The advent of agricultural biotechnology, including genetic engineering, has extended the range of tools by which this can be achieved. Gene technology is a universal approach for inducing new genetic variation. Although the oil processing industry is considered a mature one, biotechnology has implications for modifying nature’s traditional oil-bearing materials to produce herbicide-resistant plants, or ones with customised fatty acid content, as well as vastly speeding development of desirable commercial plant varieties. Biotechnologies are vital in addressing the growing demand for crops for food, feed, fibre and fuel, their primary production and processing. If the production of industrially important fatty acids in high-yielding oil crops can be developed successfully through genetic engineering approaches, there is a huge market volume available. Given the apparent worldwide limitation on land suitable for oilseed production, genetic enhancement of oilseed productivity may be the best means to achieve the quantity and quality of edible oils needed to accommodate both food markets and the potential demand for oleochemicals and biofuels. Recent steep increases in food prices will undoubtedly trigger further discussions about increasing agricultural
Development of non-food agricultural industries
57
production by plant biotechnology. Biotech crops bring considerable benefits to agriculture. Breeding and biotechnology are the primary methods used to increase crop yields. Yield gains are considerable and range from 10 bu/ac (1925) to 40 bu/ac (2005) for soybean and from 1500 kg/ha (1930) to 9500 kg/ ha (2005) for corn. As an illustrative example, soybean crop production in Argentina has steadily increased in the past, with a significant rise during the last decade, mainly because of the increase in land devoted to soy (53% of the farmland in 2007). Soy production has almost tripled in the last 15 years, increasing sharply after the introduction of genetically modified soy in the 1996–97 season (Fig. 2.1). At present, 100% of the country’s soy production (used for food/feed and for biodiesel export) is genetically modified. Few issues have proved as globally divisive as the ability to modify crops genetically. There are certain barriers to the realisation and use of gene technology because of poor acceptance by some end-users. However, there exists overwhelming scientific evidence and positive commercial experience of biotech crops around the world with no fewer than 125 Mha of land in 2008 in 22 countries (mainly US 62.5 Mha, Argentina 21 Mha, Brazil 15.8 Mha, Canada 7.6 Mha, India 7.6 Mha and China 3.8 Mha) producing genetically modified (GM) crops, in particular soy (58.6 Mha), corn (25.2 Mha), cotton 40
35
Soybean production (Mt)
30
25
20
15
10
5 1990
1992
1994
1996
1998 Year
2000
2002
2.1 Soybean production (Mt) in Argentina (after ref. [5]).
2004
2006
58
Biodiesel science and technology
(13.4 Mha) and rapeseed (4.8 Mha) (2006 data) [6]. While the US has a substantial list of authorised oil-bearing GM crops (soybean, rape, cottonseed, maize) which are being widely grown and mainly modified in view of the need for sturdier crops (resistance to pests, floods, drought) hardly any GM food crops are being grown in the EU (with France, Germany, Austria, Italy, Greece and Luxembourg expressing doubts about the value of GM crops). Spain is the only EU country with a significant hectarage of commercial biotech crops (Bt maize); also Romania is growing GM soybean. The EU is cautious with its regulatory regime (2001/18/EC, 2003/1829/ EC, 2003/1830/EC and 2003/1946/EC). Progress on crop growing and GM approvals in the EU is slow. Recently, the European Commission has been approving the release of some GM products, as in case of oilseed rapes Bayer MSSRF3 and Monsanto GT73. EU has recently also admitted the genetically modified maize Mon810 and T25, but is still blocking introduction of two other GM maize seedlings (Pioneer Hi-Bred 1507 and Syngenta Bt11). Moreover, gentech crops which are not (yet) legally permitted in the EU cannot be imported. Consequently, imported soybean oil suffers from GM limitations. The conditions for imports of rapeseed into Europe are that GM varieties must be approved. Because Canada grows genetically modified canola it cannot export to the EU. Curiously, Dubai imports and crushes Canadian canola and exports it to Europe for biodiesel manufacture. Generally, trading companies are not willing to bear the risk of guaranteeing absence of traces of genetically modified organisms (GMO) approved in some third countries but not yet in the EU. By 2007, there is a good chance that two varieties of GM rapeseed will be authorised for import from Canada, which would relieve the feedstock problem. The present strict EU zero-tolerance policy as to GMO is disproportionate, damages European competitiveness and will eventually lead to a complete halt of vital food/feed supplies from North and South America. Europe admits Argentinean GM soy biodiesel. The composition of soybean oil can be modified to improve the usefulness across the food and fuel chain. DuPont has developed a GM soybean plant that gives an oil containing 80% oleic acid. Major US seed companies (DuPont, Monsanto, Pioneer) are in the process of commercialising new soybean varieties that will increase oilseed yields by 9–12% on current acreage (‘virtual acres’ is a term for generating additional feedstock from the same acre). A yield increase of 10% corresponds to an additional 250 Mbu of soybeans, or almost 400 Mgal of biodiesel. These technologies are set to have an impact in 2010. The same benefit can be achieved by increasing soybean oil content. Current industry genetic programmes suggest 10% oil increases are achievable within the next few years, while further research is under way to increase the oil yield of soybean by more than 20% [7]. In this respect, the long-term future of the biodiesel industry looks positive. Recent developments in gene segment transfer and modification techniques
Development of non-food agricultural industries
59
suggest an alternative route for development of diesel fuel from plant sources. Major technology goals of genetic manipulation of energy crops for biodiesel are increased productivity and economic return while providing environmental sustainability (decreased greenhouse gas emissions), reduced agricultural inputs (nutrient requirements and pesticide reduction), tolerance of biotic and abiotic stresses, and control of chemical composition (oil concentration and profiles, introduction of new fatty acids) [8]. The great challenge is doubling biomass yields of energy crops with desirable physical and chemical traits. Development of novel energy crops may proceed in various directions, e.g. along ways to produce triacylglycerols in abundant non-seed tissues, or by improving the fuel characteristics of biodiesel by altering the fatty acid composition. Benefits sought by the biodiesel industry are improved oxidative stability and improved cold-flow properties. These properties are interconnected. Although applications of modern bio- and gene technology are quite likely to provide vegetable raw materials of improved quality and yield, industrial demand requires that these new materials of vegetable origin are made available in sufficient quantities at competitive prices. Plant triacylglycerols as feedstocks for the production of biofuels have recently been reviewed [9]. It has been argued that transgenics are imperative for biofuel crops [10].
2.5
Bibliography
J. Gressel, Genetic Glass Ceilings: Transgenics for Crop Biodiversity, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD (2008). B. Kamm, P.R. Gruber and M. Kamm (eds), Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (2006), 2 vols. Nexant, Inc. ChemSystems, Liquid Biofuels: Substituting for Petroleum (multiclient study), White Plains, NY (2006). J. Outlaw, K. Collins and J. Duffield (eds), Agriculture as a Producer and Consumer of Energy, CABI, Wallingford (2005). G. Boyle (ed.), Renewable Energy, Oxford University Press, New York, NY (2004). J.A. Duke, Handbook of Energy Crops, Purdue University Center for New Crops and Plant Products, West Lafayette, IN (2003); http://www.hort. purdue.edu/newcrop. V. Shiva, Protect or Plunder? Understanding Intellectual Property Rights, Zed Books, London and New York, NY (2001). Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), The Application of Biotechnology to Industrial Sustainability – A Primer, OECD Publishing, Paris (2001). H. Zoebelein (ed.), Dictionary of Renewable Resources, 2nd edn, WileyVCH, Weinheim (2001).
60
Biodiesel science and technology
National Agricultural Biotechnology Council, The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century: Agriculture Expanding into Health, Energy, Chemicals, and Materials, NABC Report 12, Ithaca, NY (2000). G.T.S. Mugnozza, E. Porceddu and M.A. Pagnotta (eds), Genetics and Breeding for Crop Quality and Resistance, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht (1999). R.P. Overend and E. Chornet (ed.), Biomass: A Growth Opportunity in Green Energy and Value-Added Products, Pergamon Press, Oxford (1999). D.L. Klass, Biomass for Renewable Energy, Fuels, and Chemicals, Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1998). K. Miyamoto, Renewable Biological Systems for Alternative Sustainable Energy Production (FAO Agricultural Services Bulletin – 128), FAO, Rome (1997). H. Eierdanz (ed.), Perspektiven nachwachsender Rohstoffe in der Chemie, VCH, Weinheim (1996). D.J. Murphy (ed.), Designer Oil Crops, VCH, Weinheim (1994). B.S. Kamel and Y. Kakudo (eds), Technological Advances in Improved and Alternative Sources of Lipids, Chapman & Hall, London (1994). S.L. Mackenzie and D.C. Taylor (eds), Seed Oils for the Future, AOCS Press, Champaign, IL (1992). B.A. Stout, The Handbook of Energy for World Agriculture, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1990). O. Kitani and C.W. Hall, Biomass Handbook, Gordon & Breach, New York, NY (1989). G. Leach, Energy and Food Production, International Institute for Environment and Development, London (1975).
2.6
References
[1] H. Zoebelein (ed.), Dictionary of Renewable Resources, 2nd edn, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim (2001). [2] S.C. Gray, Oils and fats: An industrialist’s view, in New Crops for Temperate Regions (K.R.M. Anthony, J. Meadly and G. Röbbelen, eds), Chapman & Hall, London (1993), pp. 179–86. [3] B. Kerckow, C. Mangan and L. Breslin, Industrial crops and products and European Union research policy, Ind. Crops Prod. 6 (1997) 325–31. [4] R.D. Perlack, L.L. Wright, A. Turhollow, R.L. Graham, B.J. Stokes and D.C. Erbach, Biomass as Feedstock for a Bioenergy and Bioproducts Industry: The Technical Feasibility of a Billion-Ton Annual Supply, US Dept. of Energy, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, DOE/90-102005-2135 (2005), pp. 1–78. [5] P. Lamers, K. McCormick and J.A. Hilbert, The emerging liquid biofuel market in Argentina: implications for domestic demand and international trade, En. Policy 36 (2008) 1479–90. [6] International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications, ISAAA, Manila/Nairobi/Ithaca (2006).
Development of non-food agricultural industries
61
[7] www.danforthcenter.org. [8] B.J. Calabotta and K. Burger, Application of molecular and genetic technologies to improve feedstock supplies for biodiesel production, Proc. Intl. Congress on Biodiesel, Vienna (5–7 Nov. 2007). [9] T. Durrett, C. Benning and J. Ohlrogge, Plant triacylglycerols as feedstocks for the production of biofuels, Plant J. 54 (2008) 593–607. [10] J. Gressel, Transgenics are imperative for biofuel crops, Plant Sci. 174 (2008) 246–63.
3
Oleochemical sources: basic science, processing and applications of oils
Abstract: Natural lipid biosynthesis is regulated by enzymatic activity and leads to a broad variety of oils in seeds and fruits in which a restricted subset of fatty acid compositions predominates and accounts for the traditional use of oils and fats in food and oleochemical applications. Both genetic and environmental factors affect triacylglycerol (TAG) biochemistry. Manipulation of fatty acid and TAG synthesis for the purpose of usability for both nutritional and industrial applications by means of natural breeding methods and genetic engineering techniques rely on detailed knowledge of biochemical pathways. The features of various oil recovery and refining techniques are outlined and the applications of unusual fatty acids are described. Key words: Biosynthesis and biodegradative pathways, plant breeding, genetic engineering, vegetable oil processing techniques, unusual fatty acids.
3.1
Introduction
The primary components of oils and fats are esters of fatty acids (FAs) and glycerol that can be obtained from several natural sources (vegetable, animal and marine). The world production of plant oils amounted to 127 Mt in 2006 [1]. The annual production of animal fats (tallow, lard and butter) is approximately 22 Mt, while fish oils contribute about 1 Mt/yr. If a lipid is a solid at 298 K, it is classified as a fat; otherwise, it is an oil. Most triglycerides found in animals are fats, while those in plants tend to be oils. Irrespective of origin, these materials have identical chemical structures and very similar chemical compositions. In typical vegetable oils ‘only’ some 25–50 FAs are present at meaningful levels. In more complex animal fats or oils the number of FAs is easily as high as 100. The basic structure of a triacylglyceride is a three-carbon hydroxycarbon (dehydrated glycerol) with three short to (very) long-chain (C8 to C30) fatty acids attached. The use of the oil or fat is determined by the composition of fatty acids, and this is highly dependent on its natural origin. Animal sources are characterised by high concentrations of saturated fatty acids, whilst marine sources (fish oils) are rich in very long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (VLCPUFAs). The fatty acid composition of oils from vegetable sources varies depending on plant origin and sort. Plant oils consist almost entirely of triacylglycerol (TAG) esters containing three fatty acids with 62
Oleochemical sources
63
chain lengths of C8-C24, with C16 and C18 being the most common. None of the VLCPUFAs are normally produced by higher plants. A striking feature of naturally occurring fatty acids is that they almost entirely contain an even number of carbon atoms. Since one molecule of glycerol is combined with three molecules of fatty acid, either simple triglycerides (where all acyl groups are alike) or mixed triglycerides (consisting of two or three different acyl constituents) are possible. It is unusual to find any simple triglyceride in a vegetable oil unless a considerable excess of one fatty acid is prevalent. In the case of tung oil, which contains 75–85% eleostearic acid, the triglycerides of this acid can be separated. Table 3.1 indicates the nomenclature of the most common fatty acids. Shorthand fatty acid designations are based on the length of the acyl chain and the number and positions of double bonds. A frequently used fatty acid nomenclature is L:Dn – x, where L = chain length, D = number of double bonds and n – x = position of the ultimate double bond from the terminal methyl group. For example, soybean oil contains about 20.7% C18:1n – 9c (cisoleic acid) and 1.22% C18:1n – 9t (trans-oleic or elaidic acid) [2]. Similarly, Table 3.1 Fatty acid nomenclature Structurea Fatty acid
Systematic name
Formula
C6:0 C8:0 C10:0 C12:0 C14:0 C16:0 C18:0 C20:0 C22:0 C24:0 C26:0 C16:1 C18:1 C18:1 C18:1 C18:1-OH C18:1>O C18:2 C18:3 C18:3 C20:1 C20:1-OH C20:4 C22:1
Hexanoic Octanoic Decanoic Dodecanoic Tetradecanoic Hexadecanoic Octadecanoic Eicosanoic Docosanoic Tetracosanoic Hexacosanoic 9-Hexadecenoic cis-9-Octadecenoic trans-9-Octadecenoic cis-6-Octadecenoic 12-Hydroxy-cis-9-octadecenoic 9,10-Epoxy-octadec-cis-12-enoic cis, cis-9,12-Octadecadienoic cis, cis, cis-9,12,15-Octadecatrienoic cis, trans, trans-9,11,13-Octadecatrienoic cis-9-Eicosenoic 14-Hydroxy-cis-11-eicosenoic 5,8,11,14-Eicosatetraenoic cis-13-Docosenoic
C6H12O2 C8H16O2 C10H20O2 C12H24O2 C14H28O2 C16H32O2 C18H36O2 C20H40O2 C22H44O2 C24H48O2 C26H52O2 C16H30O2 C18H34O2 C18H34O2 C18H34O2 C18H34O3 C18H32O3 C18H32O2 C18H30O2 C18H30O2 C20H38O2 C20H38O3 C20H32O2 C22H42O2
a
Caproic Caprylic Capric Lauric Myristic Palmitic Stearic Arachidic Behenic Lignoceric Cerotic Palmitoleic Oleic Elaidic Petroselenic Ricinoleic Coronaric Linoleic a-Linolenic Eleostearic Gadoleic Lesquerolic Arachidonic Erucic
xx:y indicates xx carbons in the fatty acid chain with y double bonds. Chemical names include isomeric variations.
64
Biodiesel science and technology
lard contains about 38% oleic acid and 2.35% elaidic acid. Alternatively, the position of the first carbon of a double bond counting from the carboxyl group is designated by delta (D), or the position of a double bond relative to the terminal methyl group is designated by omega (w). The double bonds in naturally occurring fatty acids are almost all in cis(Z)-configuration and, therefore, a designation is only used in case of a trans(E)-isomer. There are three main classes of triglycerides: saturated fats, unsaturated cis-fats and trans-fats. Most natural vegetable oils consist of cis-fats and are polyunsaturated. The cis nature prevents solidification of the fat; trans-fats solidify more readily and may increase blood cholesterol levels. Nutritionists distinguish various fatty acid diets (Table 3.2) and currently insist on reduced trans-isomer content of hardstocks despite lack of scientific justification for a causal relation between high cholesterol levels and heart disease [3].
3.2
Biochemistry of lipid metabolism
In many plants, lipids (insoluble in water) represent up to 80% of dry weight of storage tissues. Lipids are an essential constituent of all plant cells, are extremely diverse in structure and constitute the products of several distinct biosynthetic pathways. The most abundant types of lipids in most cells are those that derive from the fatty acid and glycerolipid biosynthetic pathways [4–8]. The fatty acid biosynthesis pathway is a primary metabolic pathway, because it is found in every cell of the plant and is essential to growth. In annual oil crops five main fatty acids, namely saturated palmitic (C16:0) and stearic (C18:0) acids, monounsaturated oleic acid (C18:1) and polyunsaturated linoleic (C18:2) and linolenic (C18:3) acids (and in some species also C16:1-transD3), make up over 90% of the acyl chains of structural (glycero)lipids of almost all plant membranes. However, many variations on the theme are possible. The ratio of the amounts of the two most common (adjacent) saturated fatty acids (C16:0 and C18:0) present in almost every vegetable oil remains fairly constant for the same oil and differs for other oils. Accordingly, the palmitate to stearate methyl ester (P/S) ratio can constitute an identifying feature of an oil. Literature values for average Table 3.2 Fatty acid diets Diet
Exemplary nutritional component
Structurea
w-3 w-6 w-9 w-6/w-9 Saturated
Fish oil Sunflower oil Olive oil Argan oil Coconut oil
20:5, 22:5, 22:6 18:2 18:1 18:1, 18:2 £ 14:0
a
xx:y indicates xx carbons in the fatty acid chain with y double bonds.
Oleochemical sources
65
P/S ratio are typically about 1.5 for linseed oil, 2.5 for walnut oil, and 5.0 for poppyseed oil. Several hundred different fatty acid structures have been found to occur in oil seeds and oil fruits, indicating a broad biosynthetic flexibility with regard to both fatty acid and TAG synthesis [9]. Each plant has a typical fatty acid pattern that is determined by its enzyme configuration. Control mechanisms of fatty acid and TAG synthesis are complex and not yet completely understood. Plants differ fundamentally from other eukaryotes in the molecular organisation of the enzymes of fatty acid synthesis. Although fatty acids are major constituents of every membrane in a cell and are also found outside cells in the cuticular lipids, the individual enzymes of the fatty acid synthesis pathway in plants are dissociable soluble components located in the stroma of plastids. In this respect, lipid biosynthesis in plants is fundamentally different from that in animals, fungi and some bacteria, where all of these reactions are catalysed by a multifunctional peptide complex located mainly in the cytosol. The plastid localisation of fatty acid synthesis means that unlike animals and fungi, plants must have mechanisms to export fatty acids from the plastid to other sites in the cell.
3.2.1 De novo fatty acid biosynthesis The first stage of lipid metabolism, the fatty acid synthesis, is illustrated here in particular for the case of oil fruits such as olive, palm and avocado [10, 11]. It is possible to explain the oil composition of these species as a function of the biochemical parameters of the enzymes present in the fruit mesocarp tissues. Unlike seeds, the TAGs that constitute the fruit oil in these species are produced from both the photosynthates imported from the leaves as well as the CO2 fixed in the fruit itself. The biosynthesis of oil in the mesocarp of oil fruits has been well studied. In particular, avocado has been a very important oil fruit for understanding of lipid metabolism in higher plants. Fatty acid synthesis is a process that occurs in plant plastids and needs the concerted action of two enzymes, acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACCase) and fatty acid synthase (FAS). In plants, animals, yeast and E. coli, ACCase is a regulatory enzyme that controls, at least in part, the rate of fatty acid synthesis (light/dark regulation). Two forms of ACCase occur in plants, termed prokaryotic and eukaryotic. Which type of ACCase structure is present depends on its subcellular localisation and the type of plant. The all-important precursor for de novo fatty acid biosynthesis is acetylCoA. A major unresolved question in plant metabolism is how acetyl-CoA in chloroplasts is generated. Plastid ACCase catalyses condensation of a molecule of bicarbonate with acetyl-CoA to produce malonyl-CoA (Fig. 3.1), which
66
Biodiesel science and technology
is the key intermediate and central carbon donor in fatty acid biosynthesis. However, before entering the fatty acid synthesis pathway, the malonyl group is transferred from CoA to a protein cofactor, acyl carrier protein (ACP), by malonyl-CoA: ACP transacylase. ACP is a small (9 kDa) acidic protein that contains a phosphopantethein prosthetic group to which the growing acyl chain is attached as a thioester. All the subsequent reactions of the fatty acid synthesis pathway involve ACP until a 16- or 18-carbon product is ready for transfer to glycerolipids or export from the plastid. Overall, to produce C16 or C18 fatty acids from acetyl-CoA and malonyl-CoA, at least 30 enzymatic reactions are required. Plant fatty acid synthesis is based on discrete enzyme components: various b-ketoacyl-ACP synthases (KAS), b-ketoacyl-ACP reductase, 3-hydroxyacylACP dehydrase and enoyl-ACP reductase. The condensing b-ketoacyl-ACP synthases differ in their substrate specificities: KAS I appears to be specific for elongating substrates ranging from C4 : 0- to C16: 0-ACP, and KAS II for elongating C16 : 0-ACP; KAS III is the enzyme of the FAS complex responsible for the first chain-lengthening step and catalyses the condensation of acetyl-CoA and malonyl-ACP; KAS IV directs its condensing activity towards medium-chain acyl-ACP substrates [12]. The cycle of elongation starts with condensation of malonyl-ACP with acetyl-CoA by the action of KAS III to produce acetoacetyl-ACP, which is subsequently reduced by b-ketoacyl-ACP reductase, dehydrated by 3-hydroxyacyl-ACP dehydrase and finally reduced by enoyl-ACP reductase (Fig. 3.1). The resulting four-carbon butyryl-ACP derivative can undergo further elongation. These condensations are catalysed by KAS I, which uses acyl-ACPs as substrates rather than acetyl-CoA, as for KAS III. The combined action of four reactions thus leads to lengthening of the precursor fatty acid by two carbons at a time while it is still attached to ACP as a thioester. The condensing enzyme KAS I is believed responsible for producing chain lengths from 6 to 16 carbons; the final product of these condensation cycles is palmitoyl-ACP (Fig. 3.1) [13]. This compound can be chain elongated to stearoyl-ACP involving participation of condensing enzyme KAS II. The latter step determines the C16/C18 ratio of the resulting mix of fatty acids. This ratio is also directly related to the degree of unsaturation of the final oil product, because palmitate is the most usual saturated fatty acid in vegetable oils whereas C18 acids are almost entirely unsaturated. The process of fatty acid synthesis de novo finishes, i.e. elongation of fatty acids in the plastids is terminated with the release of the acyl moieties from the ACP derivatives by the action of plastid thioesterases (TE) or their transfer into complex lipids by acyltransferases (see Fig. 3.2). In most cases, a specific acyl-ACP thioesterase hydrolyses the acyl-ACP and releases the free fatty acid. Thioesterases are indicated as important chain length determining enzymes and responsible, in combination with condensing enzymes, for the
O
O
HCO3–
O
O
ACP
Acetyl-CoA carboxylase
O
O
–
S-CoA
O
Acetyl-CoA
KAS III –
S-CoA
O
Acetyl-CoA
Malonyl-CoA : ACP transacylase
O
S-ACP
Malonyl-CoA
S-ACP
Malonyl-ACP
3-Ketobutyryl-ACP
+ H+ (1)
O
O
O
O + H+
Malonyl-ACP KAS I
S-ACP
S-ACP
3-Ketoacyl-ACP
OH
O
–H2O (2)
(3)
S-ACP
Butyryl-ACP
Butenoyl-ACP
S-ACP 3-Hydroxybutyryl-ACP
O Malonyl-ACP
S-ACP Palmitoyl-ACP
KAS II
O
O
O S-ACP
(1) (2) (3)
S-ACP
Oleochemical sources
KAS I Malonyl-ACP x5
Stearoyl-ACP
67
3.1 Biosynthesis of fatty acids (in oil fruits) by fatty acid synthase. Key: ACP, acyl carrier protein; KAS (I, II, III), b-ketoacyl-ACP synthases; (1) b-ketoacyl-ACP reductase; (2) 3-hydroxyacyl-ACP dehydrase; (3) enoyl-ACP reductase (after ref. [11]).
Cytoplasm
Biodiesel science and technology
3.2 Simplified scheme of fatty acid biosynthesis malonyl-CoA malonyl-CoA in plants. Fatty acids are first synthesised de FatA 22 : 1-CoA 18 : 1 18 : 1-CoA 20 : 1-CoA ACP novo as ACP thioesters 24 : 1-CoA KCS KCS in the plastid. Upon Glycerol-318 : 1-ACP hydrolysis (FatA, FatB), D9-DES phosphate G3PAT the resulting ‘free’ fatty ACS 18 : 0-ACP acids are able to cross Acyl–CoA LPA the plastidial membrane pool KAS II P R 16 : 0-ACP FatB into the cytoplasmic compartment, where R-CoA Free they are esterified LPAAT FatB 18 : 1-PC 14 : 0-ACP with CoA, catalysed D12-DES by acyl-CoA synthase 18 : 2-PC (ACS). Acyl-CoAs can PA 12 : 0-ACP FatB fatty be further processed by D15-DES R R P phospholipid-dependent FatB 18 : 3-PC desaturation and KAS I 10 : 0-ACP PAP other modifications, acids or elongated with 8 : 0-ACP FatB KAS IV b-ketoacyl-CoA DAG CPT synthase (KCS). Final R R 6 : 0-ACP TAG formation can be attained either by R-CoA stepwise acylation DAGAT R R PC 4 : 0-ACP along the glycerol-3KAS III PDAT Oil body phosphate (G3P) route or by several acyl-CoAR R R independent pathways, Acetyl-CoA Malonyl-ACP TAG involving CPT and PDAT De novo fatty acid biosynthesis Triacylglycerol biosynthesis (after ref. [14]).
68
Plastid
Oleochemical sources
69
chain length distribution of the products of fatty acid synthesis in plants, and especially in the oils of seed storage tissues [15, 16]. Most species, including oil fruits, dispose of thioesterases with high substrate specificity for C18-acyl-ACPs [17]. Acyl-ACP thioesterases are classified into the FatA type preferring oleoyl-ACP as substrate and the FatB enzymes that usually hydrolyse saturated acyl-ACP. High content of palmitate in palm oil is explained by low KAS II activity and an important C16 acyl-ACP thioesterase activity that releases C16 moieties in the mesocarp of oil palm fruit [11]. Alternatively, one of two highly selective acyltransferases (AT) in the plastid transfers the fatty acid from ACP to glycerol-3-phosphate (G3P) or to monoacylglycerol-3-phosphate (LPA) to initiate the synthesis of plastidial membrane lipids followed by further desaturations. The first of these acyltransferases is a soluble enzyme that prefers oleyl-ACP as a substrate. The second acyltransferase resides on the inner chloroplast envelope membrane and preferentially selects palmitoyl-ACP. Whether the fatty acid is released from ACP by a thioesterase or an acyltransferase determines whether it leaves the plastid. If a thioesterase acts on acyl-ACP, then the free fatty acid is able to leave the plastid for export to the acyl-CoA and acyl-lipid pools, presumably by simple diffusion across the envelope membrane. The products of the fatty acid biosynthesis pathway in oil fruits are thus mainly saturated C16 and C18 acyl chains. However, in most plant tissues, over 75% of the fatty acids are unsaturated species, like oleate or linoleate. Most plants dispose of the necessary mechanisms to introduce double bonds into specific positions of the acyl chains synthesised by the FAS reactions. The first double bond is introduced by the very active plastid-localised soluble enzyme D9-stearoyl-ACP-desaturase (D9-DES), which leads to oleate rather than stearate accumulation in most plant species [18]. This fatty acid desaturase is unique in the plant kingdom in that all other known desaturases are integral membrane proteins. In some plants, 16 : 0-ACP is further modified by a soluble enzyme (representing a diverged form of the soluble desaturase that is typically involved in conversion of 18:0-ACP to 18 : 1D9-ACP) that introduces a double bond at the D4 or D6 position. In plants, oleate is a central metabolite by virtue of its position in lipid biosynthesis [19]. It is the end product of the ‘ACP-track’ set of fatty acid biosynthetic reactions in the plastid using acyl carrier protein (ACP) as the acyl carrier, and at the same time the starting point for another set of modifying reactions localised elsewhere [20]. The enzymes stearoyl-ACP desaturase and acyl-ACP hydrolase guarantee termination of fatty acid synthesis at the 18:1(9) level in the chloroplast (leaf) or in the proplastid (seed) [21]. Much is known also about the biosynthesis of oleic acid in animal systems. Apart from the three standard fatty acids, palmitic (16 : 0), stearic (18 : 0) and oleic (D9-18 : 1), required for the biosynthesis of all cellular membrane
70
Biodiesel science and technology
lipids, plastids can produce a variety of other fatty acids varying in chain length (8 : 0 to 14 : 0) and location of a single double bond (D9-14 : 1, D616 : 1, D9-16 : 1, D6-18 : 1). These fatty acids, once exported to the cytosol, enter the acyl-CoA and acyl-lipid pools. Enzyme activities responsible for controlling the flux of fatty acids between phospholipid and acyl-CoA pools require further elucidation. Esterification with CoA is catalysed by acyl-CoA synthase (ACS) located in the extraplastidial membranes. Modifications of oleate, such as elongation to VLCFAs or reduction, take place outside the plastid, primarily on membrane systems in the cytosol. Elongation of oleic acid (18 : 1) to erucic acid (22 : 1) is a major malonylCoA-dependent pathway in some oilseeds, such as Brassica napus, which presumably depends on the cytosolic ACCase enzyme. When used for storage lipid synthesis, a large proportion of all fatty acids exported from plastids is incorporated into microsomal phospholipids (particularly phosphatidylcholine, PC) for various modifications (desaturation, hydroxylation, epoxidation, acetylation, conjugation, elongation, reduction) to produce polyunsaturated and unusual fatty acids (C18*); see also Fig. 3.6. Even fatty acids not subject to any modification may pass through PC for subsequent channeling into reserve lipids which mostly are triacylglycerols (TAGs). Although desaturation of oleate to produce polyunsaturated fatty acids can take place either in the plastid or in the endoplasmic reticulum via prokaryotic or eukaryotic pathways, respectively [16, 22], for many plants (including olive, palm and avocado) such desaturation involves transportation of oleate out of the plastid to the cytosol [23]. Oleic acid (18 : 1) incorporated into phosphatidylcholine (PC) in the ER is available for conversion to linoleic (18 : 2 D9, 12) and then a-linolenic (18 : 3 D9, 12, 15) acid by the sequential action of substrate-specific desaturases. Oleoyl desaturase is the enzyme responsible for conversion of oleic to linoleic acid, and linoleoyl desaturase is involved in the conversion of linoleic to a-linolenic acid. As biosynthesis of C18 : 2 and C18 : 3 acids utilises C18 : 1 acid as primary substrate, the concentration of the latter decreases as they are produced (see Fig. 3.3 for pecan oil). For biosynthesis of PUFAs in eukaryotic algae, see ref. [24].
3.2.2 Triacylglycerol biosynthesis Fatty acids in cells are almost never found as ‘free’ fatty acids. Instead, their carboxylic group is esterified or otherwise modified. A proportion of the fatty acid products formed is retained as structural components of cellular membranes (e.g. phospholipids of the ER and galactolipids of plastids) and the rest is transferred to TAG by a variety of potential routes. In membrane glycerolipids, fatty acids are attached to both the sn-1 and sn-2 positions of the glycerol backbone and a polar headgroup is attached to the sn-3 position. If
Oleochemical sources
71
3.2 [C18 : 2] = 76.475–0.805 · [C18 : 1]
34
[C18 : 3] = 5.929–0.057 · [C18 : 1]
3.0 2.8
30 28
2.6
26
2.4
24
2.2
22
2.0
20
Linolenic acid (% wt/wt, oil basis)
Linoleic acid (% wt/wt, oil basis)
32
1.8
18 1.6 54
56
58 60 62 64 66 68 70 72 Oleic acid (% wt/wt, oil basis)
74
76
3.3 Linear regression of oleic concentration on the concentration of linoleic and linolenic acids in pecan oil (after ref. [25]).
all three positions on glycerol are esterified with fatty acids, a TAG structure results that is not suitable for membranes but instead constitutes the major form of lipid storage in seeds. All the major steps in the biosynthetic pathway of TAG are now known. The 16:0 and 18:1 acyl chains produced in the plastid are to form the hydrophobic portion of glycerolipid molecules. Glycerolipid synthesis comprises acylation reactions that transfer fatty acids to glycerol-3-phosphate (G3P). Higher plants possess two distinct pathways for the synthesis of glycerolipids. The prokaryotic pathway occurs in the plastids, uses acyl-ACPs as substrates, and esterifies predominantly palmitate (16 : 0) at position 2 of glycerol. The eukaryotic pathway of assembling acyl chains to the glycerol backbone is extra-plastidial (primarily at the endoplasmic reticulum), uses acyl-CoAs as substrates, and positions 18-carbon fatty acids at position 2 of glycerol-3phosphate. The details of the synthetic routes that probably operate in higher plants have been reviewed [4]. In almost all plants, the chemical form in which oil is stored is as triacylglycerols, which are formed by an extension of the membranelipid biosynthetic pathway common to all plant tissues. In some species TAG biosynthesis has been proposed to take place by the comparatively straightforward Kennedy pathway, which essentially involves re-entry into the acyl-CoA pool and attachment to all three positions of TAG by consecutive
72
Biodiesel science and technology
reactions catalysed by various acyltransferases (G3PAT, LPAAT, PAP, DAGAT), which attach CoA-activated fatty acids to the glycerol backbone [26] (see Fig. 3.2). Fatty acids are sequentially transferred from CoA to positions 1 and 2 of glycerol-3-phosphate, resulting in the formation of phosphatidic acid (PA). Dephosphorylation of PA releases diacylglycerol (DAG). In the final step of TAG synthesis, a third fatty acid is transferred to the vacant position 3 of DAG. This step is catalysed by diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DAGAT), the only enzyme of the G3P pathway unique to storage lipid synthesis [27]. The specificity of the acyltransferases of the Kennedy pathway represents an important aspect of lipid metabolism because they broadly determine the fatty acid composition of the accumulating species. Assembly of free fatty acids into the glycerol backbone does not always proceed according to the Kennedy pathway as in many oilseeds most fatty acids produced in the plastid are not immediately available for TAG biosynthesis. Formation of TAG from DAG may occur in the absence of acyl-CoA without DAGAT activity. The acyl-CoA-independent pathway to TAG involves phosphatidylcholine (PC) with either direct transfer from phospholipids to diacylglycerol (DAG) by an enzyme called phospholipid:1,2-diacylglycerol acyltransferase (PDAT) or removal of the phospholipid headgroup to form DAG, which can subsequently be utilised by DAGAT or PDAT to form TAG [4]. Storage of TAGs synthesised in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in mature oil seeds involves formation of small spherical (about 1 mm diameter), and densely packed cytosolic oil bodies, surrounded by monolayer phospholipid membranes. Accumulation of oil then means an increase in the number of such lipid bodies. Unlike seeds, in oil fruits like olive most of the oil accumulates in larger and oleosin-free droplets formed in the fleshy pericarp [28]. It is estimated that plants contain thousands of fatty acid structures, many of which arise by the action of membrane-bound desaturases and desaturase-like enzymes. How plants exert control on which fatty acids are stored in triacylglycerol is unknown. This question is particularly relevant for storage of ‘unusual’ fatty acids. More than 300 different fatty acids are known to occur in seed TAG [29, 30]. The acyl groups of seed TAGs can vary in chain length (from 8 to 24). In addition, the position and number of double bonds may vary and unusual functional groups such as hydroxy, oxirane or acetylene may be added to the acyl group (see Section 3.5). The reason for this great diversity in plant storage oils is unknown. The observed divergence in seed oil acyl chains among different species is very high, in contrast to the narrow fatty acid composition of membrane lipids, which exclude unusual fatty acids. The details of ‘unusual’, e.g. hydroxyl or conjugated, fatty acid formation remain elusive, because these enzymes await structural characterisation. However, soluble plant acyl-ACP desaturases have been studied in far greater detail but typically only catalyse desaturation (dehydrogenation) reactions.
Oleochemical sources
73
A recent study has contributed detailed mechanistic insights into factors that govern the highly selective production of unusual fatty acids [31]. A mutant of the castor acyl-ACP desaturase converts (E)-9-18 : 1-ACP into two major products: (Z)-10-18 : 1-9-OH and the conjugated linoleic acid isomer (E)-9(Z)-11-18:2 (Fig. 3.4). In recent years, knowledge of the biochemical relationships of plant metabolism – in particular of the biosynthesis of the storage fats in commercial use – has increased considerably [27, 28, 32–34]. Voelker and Kinney [27] have reviewed variations in the biosynthesis of seed-storage lipids. Seed oils normally contain predominantly C18 unsaturated fatty acids; saturated fatty acids represent only a minor fraction [9]. The saturated acyl groups are normally found only in the sn-1 and sn-3 positions of triacylglycerols [35]. In fact, highly saturated oils from different plants fall into two classes with respect to the fatty acyl distribution in the TAG structure. On the one hand, in cocoa butter (containing 60 mol% SFA) the saturated fatty acids (predominantly 16 : 0 and 18 : 0) reside almost exclusively in the sn-1 and sn-3 positions of the (saturated-unsaturated-saturated) TAGs. Similarly, in highly saturated canola oil (BTE canola) with 48% C12 : 0 (total SFA: 60%) 12 : 0 is also located almost exclusively at sn-1 and sn-3 positions of triacylglycerols; with only 4% sn-2 laurate almost no trilaurin accumulates [36]. On the other hand, oils of medium-chain (C8-C14) producing species (including many palms, Lauraceae, Myristiacaceae, and Cuphea spp.) contain almost exclusively saturated fatty acids. For example, coconut (Cocos nucifera) oil contains 92% SFA, predominantly laurate, and most of its TAGs are trisaturated. Laurate is found enriched at sn-2, which indicates that a laurate-CoA-preferring LPA (lysophosphatidic acid) acyltransferase is active during endosperm maturation [37]. Positional isomerism is obviously of no concern to biodiesel production. 11
ra
se
9
de
sa
tu
OH
9
desaturase
de
t sa
ur
10
e
C~
as
~C
9
11 10
3.4 Enzymatic conversion of stearoyl-ACP by mutant desaturase into an allylic alcohol and linoleic acid isomer (after ref. [31]).
74
Biodiesel science and technology
3.2.3 Biodegradative pathways Biodegradative pathways are strongly involved in vegetable oil quality. Lipolytic activities in the oil palm fruit mesocarp are important for the acidity of the final oil product. Oil palm fruit lipases are particularly important because they are responsible for the increase in oil acidity in certain conditions. While polyunsaturated fatty acids are not usually in a free state in plants, but mainly esterified to glycerol in the form of membrane or storage lipids, their prior release by the action of lipolytic acylhydrolases is necessary [11]. Hydrolysis of lipids by lipase is induced by fruit bruising and/or poor storage. Once the polyunsaturated fatty acids have been released, they can be oxidised by the action of lipoxygenase (LOX) [38]. The fact that olive LOX oxidises free unsaturated fatty acids at a much higher rate than esterified ones confirms that action of an acylhydrolase releasing C18:2 or C18:3 acids for the glycerolipid fraction is necessary prior to their oxygenation. Among the catabolic pathways related to lipids, the so-called lipoxygenase pathway is also particularly important in view of sensory quality (relevant for oil fruits, e.g. olive). Virgin oil aroma consists of a complex mixture of more than 100 compounds, mainly volatile saturated and unsaturated aldehydes, alcohols and esters [39]. These compounds are produced from polyunsaturated fatty acids through a cascade of reactions (lipoxygenase pathway). The LOX pathway involves oxidative degradation of polyunsaturated linoleic and a-linolenic acids, which are split into volatile C6 or C9 carbonyl fragments, which can further be modified by isomerisation, reduction and esterification (Fig. 3.5). In the case of olive oil, the lipoxygenase pathway is principally triggered during crushing of olive fruits and malaxation of the resulting pulp that takes place in the extraction process. The aroma of a given oil is a function of the activity levels and characteristics of the enzymes involved in that cascade of reactions. There exists a relationship between the activity level and the characteristics of the LOX pathway enzymes in olive pulp with the quality of the sensory components of the resulting olive oil [11]. The same phenomenon does not occur in other oil fruits (palm fruit, avocado). The extraction process of oil palm includes sterilisation (by heating) to inactivate enzymes such as endogenous lipases, which also cause inactivation of LOX pathway enzymes [40]. Aroma is not a quality parameter of palm oil.
3.2.4 Environmental factors As indicated in Table 3.3, lipid biosynthesis is also affected by environmental factors (light, temperature, water stress, soil and atmospheric constituents) and biotic factors such as physical damage and pest attack, which play an important quantitative and qualitative role in terms of oil yield and fatty acid profile. Ecological factors (and consequently some geographical areas) are
Oleochemical sources Polyunsaturated glycerolipids
Lipolytic acylhydrolase
75
Free polyunsaturated fatty acids
O2 LOX
Oxoacids Aldehydes + (non-volatile) (volatile)
HPL
Hydroxyperoxides
EI, ADH, AAT
Modified volatiles
3.5 Biosynthesis of volatiles from polyunsaturated fatty acids by the lipoxygenase pathway. Abbreviations: AAT, alcohol acyltransferase; ADH, alcohol dehydrogenase; EI, enal isomerase; HPL, hydroperoxide lyase; LOX, lipoxygenase. Table 3.3 Some factors affecting lipid biosynthesis ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Genetic variations Enzyme activity (synthetases, desaturases, acyl-tranferases, thioesterases, etc.) Ecological and environmental factors (climate conditions: light temperature; geographical area: soil and atmospheric constituents) Water management (water regime and water stress) Souring date Seasonal variations Seed development stage (maturity, post-maturity) Bioetic factors (physical damage, pest attack)
more favourable than others for the production of a given botanical species as an industrial oilseed crop. Oil content varies by region due to climatic and other environmental factors. For example, spring canola in Oregon has significantly lower oil content (32%) than that of North Dakota and Canada (43%). Also the fatty acid profile of sunflower oil is greatly affected by climatic conditions (N. Dakota: C18 : 1, 15%; C18 : 2, 75%; Texas: C18 : 1, 50%; C18 : 2, 35%). High irradiation may improve the oil content of a crop. Differences of oil content among olives located in different parts of the tree have been noticed [41]. Seasonal variations in vegetable oil yield and quality are observed. Temperature affects lipid metabolism. The effects of air temperature variations
76
Biodiesel science and technology
on oil content and fatty acid composition of plants are well documented [9, 42–47], as shown for RSO, SNO, SFO, LSO, CAS and others, and generally show an increased synthesis of total cellular lipids and unsaturated fatty acids at lower temperature. The activity of diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DAGAT) is limited within the TAG production process in olives at T > 303 K [11], which agrees with the reported instability of this enzyme in Brassica napus at T > 313 K [48]. Temperature also has an effect on the catabolic pathways related to lipid metabolism. For example, lipolytic activity increases following exposure to chilling temperatures in oil palm and leads to increased free fatty acid levels [49]. HPL is rather unstable above 293 K. As most of the palm oil is synthesised in the last two weeks of fruit development, a correct judgement of ripeness is essential to ensure good yield. Over-ripeness leads to biodeterioration and poor quality oil and lower mill efficiency. During seed development, the fatty acid composition changes considerably with maturity or with air temperature, as observed for Lesquerella fendleri in relation to harvest date [50]. Triglyceride and fatty acid compositions in the mesocarp of avocado (Persea americana) during fruit development were reported [51]. In the period between harvesting and full maturation (post-harvest period), the oil content increases and change occurs in the oil composition [52]. Water management is another important factor in seed production. Water stress during peak flowering and seed development reduces yields. Changes in seed yield and fatty acid composition of oils of high oleic sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) hybrids in relation to the sowing date and water regime were reported [53]. Water stress influences the C18 : 1/C18 : 2 ratio. The attack of pests causes an appreciable loss of yield in most oil fruits and causes a loss of quality of the final product due to the increase of acidity and appearance of off-flavours. The involvement of the LOX pathway in plant wound response mechanisms is well known [38]. In addition, the production of volatile aldehydes through the LOX pathway is also related to plant defence mechanisms.
3.3
Modification of vegetable oil quality
As the production of plant oils needs to be expanded, plant biology has to play a critical part in the large-scale development of biodiesel by addressing some of its major limitations. Durrett et al. [54] have outlined some speculative strategies for the design of new crops to produce biodiesel, including considerations on increasing plant oil production, and on oil (instead of carbohydrate) production in vegetative tissues, such as leaves or stems rather than seeds. Altering the fatty acid profile can improve fuel properties of biodiesel such as cold-temperature flow characteristics, oxidative stability and NOx emissions (see Sections 14.4.1–3).
Oleochemical sources
77
Each plant has a typical fatty acid pattern that is regulated by its enzyme configuration. An increase of the content of an existing or a new fatty acid in order to facilitate industrial processing of the raw material is one of the most important objectives of genetic engineering in oil crops. Current knowledge of the biosynthesis of TAGs is the basis for the future improvement of yield, quality or composition of oil produced from seeds and fruit. It follows from Section 3.2 that manipulation of both fatty acid and TAG synthesis may lead to developing seeds or fruits which produce the desired fatty acid in high rates and effectively incorporate it into each position of the triglyceride [55–57]. Already, an increased knowledge of how plants synthesise fatty acids has enabled successful engineering of the composition of plant oils, thereby providing a biodiesel with better fuel properties [58]. Many complex biochemical pathways have been manipulated genetically to produce fatty acid compositions having increased oleate level, decreased linoleate, linolenate, stearate, and/or palmitate levels, and a decreased overall level of saturates [59, 60]. A modification of typical fatty acid patterns may be derived by increasing or reducing enzyme activities (Fig. 3.2). Acyltransferases, especially 1-acylglycerol-3-phosphate (G3PAT), are important in determining oil quality and usability for industrial application [35]. Evidence has been provided that expression of acyltranferase genes in transgenic rapeseed plants can improve not only quality but also oil yield. The generation of transgenic soybean lines with high oleic acid content [61] is an example in which plant biotechnology has already contributed to the improvement of biodiesel. The diversity of fatty acids represents a major opportunity for the rational design of new seed oils in domesticated oil crops both for food and nonfood use. Natural breeding methods have been used for many years to try and increase the desired components in conventional industrial crops, and in recent times this method has been supplemented by direct mutagenesis and other genetic engineering techniques. In addition to improved crop yielding ability, the oil concentration and composition of the storage lipids may be enhanced through advanced genomics and biotechnology [62, 63]. Even drastic variations in the fatty acid pattern of seeds are tolerated by plants and seedlings. Systematic screening programmes for oil-producing crops from diverse plant species have been undertaken [64–67]. Classical plant breeding, combined with experimental mutagenesis (‘mutation breeding’) and modern in vitro cell- and tissue culture methods, has frequently proved to be successful in commercially exploited oil plants, such as soybean, rapeseed, sunflower, peanut or linseed, which now exhibit a considerable variation in their fatty acid pattern (see Tables 5.11–5.14). By using these techniques to produce variant strains of rapeseed, the erucic acid (C22 : 1) component in the fatty acids can be varied from 0% to over 50%, whilst the lauric acid (C12 : 0)
78
Biodiesel science and technology
component can be varied from 0% to some 37%. With sunflower seeds the oleic acid (C18:1) content has been increased to over 92%, providing a highly valuable source of this material. Transferring a novel oil quality into a high yielding, agronomically adapted plant species by conventional methods is possible, though fraught with difficulty. Classic breeding programmes are lengthy processes, requiring at least 10–15 years. Gene technology is well suited to accelerate breeding progress. This grants the ability to implant a specific and desired quality property from distantly related plant species. Sustainable agriculture could benefit from gene mapping. Besides guiding selection of genes with high yield, the gene map could also be used to select genes that are necessary for trees to thrive in a changing climate. In addition to mutation breeding efforts on traditional crops, work is being carried out to domesticate alternative oil-rich plants that may yield new potentially useful fatty acids. The availability of modern biotechnological approaches has sped up the development of new oil types [68]. Using GM techniques to alter the activity of a plant enzyme can convert unsaturated oils in the seeds of a plant from a temperate zone to the more saturated type generally found in tropical plants like oil-producing palm. A special GM coconut variety with much less lauric acid is under development in the Philippines. Monsanto’s Vistive III soybeans are designed to have a similar oil profile to olive oil and are low in linolenic acid. Studies are also being conducted to genetically modify soybeans to produce oil resembling tung oil in composition. Careful breeding and genetic improvement of plants can help in meeting growing demand worldwide, especially in the energy sector. All possible needs cannot be met using a single plant. Hence, a careful selection of species with maximum potential for desirable oil producing qualities needs to be made which can be genetically improved for desired compounds using modern techniques. Genomic manipulation of saturated and unsaturated fatty acid composition has utility in enhanced ignition and flow properties of biofuels [58, 61]. Similarly, improved digestibility and metabolisable energy values for meal co-products sustain the economy of biodiesel. Implementation of the products of genetically enhanced oilseeds on an economic scale is necessary to secure the level of agricultural capacity desired in the future. Plant tissue culture has been used to produce elite varieties of oil palm and coconut. A recently developed new clonal oil palm increases oil yield by 20%. Increases in oil concentration from 40% to 60% of kernel weight of peanut have been achieved, thus resulting in a 50% increase in oil production per hectare. Pioneer intends introducing high-oil corn by 2013. Advanced plant breeding may result in other high-oil varieties (e.g. coriander, 23%). Also plant breeding efforts to domesticate wild plants, such as species of the genera Cuphea, Calendula, Euphorbia, Vernonia, Lesquerella, Crambe or
Oleochemical sources
79
Limnanthes, have been reported in order to develop useful plants that may be more productive (see Section 6.4.6). Breeding programmes have focused on improving agronomic traits necessary for Cuphea domestication and commercial production [69, 70]. Knapp [71] has reported mutagenic work to extend the range of phenotypes in several Cuphea species. This resulted in the production of the mutant C. viscosissima VS-320 with an oil that has increased medium-chain triglyceride (SCT) content, as follows: C6 : 0, 4.19%; C8 : 0, 40.24%; C10 : 0, 36.90%; C12 :0, 4.81%; C14 : 0, 6.84%; C16 : 0, 3.33%; C18:0, 0.15%; C18 : 1, 1.37%; C18 : 2, 2.05%; C18 : 3, 0.13%. Oil of the mutant plant C. viscosissima VS-320 contains the highest reported levels of the SCTs tricaprin (C10 : 0) and tricaprylin (C8 : 0) in plant oils. In addition, this oil produces the triglyceride tricaproin (C6 : 0), which is normally not present in other plant-derived oils. The unique triglyceride composition makes this oil a natural, inexpensive source of SCTs for industrial application. The physical properties of C. viscosissima VS-320 oil were studied by Geller et al. [72]. Viscosity is an important factor in predicting the performance of potential alternative diesel fuel sources. Fuel performance of the oil produced by this Cuphea mutant shows a marked improvement compared to that of traditional vegetable oils, approaching that of methyl esters. The viscosity of the mutant Cuphea oil falls between that of diesel fuel and rapeseed oil. It may be possible to tailor Cuphae crops to produce selected fatty acids on demand under a variety of growing conditions [73]. Synthase genes can be used to alter fatty acid composition in such crop plants. Further genetic development of the plant genus Cuphea as a source of diesel fuel is warranted. Other developments are non-toxic GM cottonseed (containing 0.19 mg gossypol/kg seed) [74]. However, bringing such new products to market nowadays requires 8–10 years and US$100 Million investment. Transgenic oils were recently reviewed [75]. No transgenic oil fruits (olive, palm, avocado) are under exploitation at present on a large scale. Introduction of transgenic oil palm varieties with new traits such as lower content of palmitic acid or a low level of endogenous lipase is of interest. Consumer resistance may delay such developments. Ongoing efforts to obtain unconventional modified seed oils containing ‘pure’ triglycerides (e.g. trilaurin) in commercial crops all aim at obtaining important tailor-made feedstocks for the chemical industry. The increase in variability demands fast, cost-effective, and easy-to-handle methods to discriminate between different oil types. Near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy (NIRS) finds application as a non-destructive method in prescreening of seed quality traits (seed oil, crude protein and water content, fatty acid composition) in plant breeding projects [76–80]. The potential of quantitative and qualitative analysis based on NIRS spectra to discriminate between oils from different vegetable sources (canola, soybean, peanut, cottonseed) [81, 82] or from the same vegetable source (sunflower types with
80
Biodiesel science and technology
high palmitic, stearic or oleic acid contents; see Table 5.13) [83] has been demonstrated. NIRS was also applied to determine the seed oil content and FA composition in sunflower through the analysis of intact seeds, husked seeds, meal and oil [79]. Similarly, the FA profile of whole soybeans was determined [84]. NIR calibration equations were developed for the major fatty acids (16 : 0, 18 : 0, 18 : 1, 18 : 2, 18 : 3, 20 : 1, 22 : 1) in intact-seed Ethiopian mustard (B. carinata L.) [85]. NIRS has also been used for non-destructive determination of linoleic and erucic acid contents in intact seed kernels and in a single seed of rape (B. napus L.) [86]. The fatty acid composition in canola, flax and solin (low-linolenic flax) for oleic, linoleic and linolenic acids, saturated fatty acids and iodine value were successfully determined by the same spectroscopic technique [87]. NIRS has also been used for palmitic, stearic, oleic and linoleic acid profiling of sesame seeds for breeding selection [88]. Similarly, the free fatty acid content in palm oil may rapidly be assessed by NIRS [89]. Breeding programmes of V. galamensis were sustained by NIRS analysis of seed weight, FA composition, oil and protein contents of intact seeds [90]. Also the non-destructive single-seed oil content determination of meadowfoam by near-infrared transmission spectroscopy (NITS) has been reported [91]. Meanwhile, patent protection of plants has led to considerable concern as to biodiversity conservation, violation of the basic principles of agriculture, undesired seed and food monopolies, biopiracy practices, and the future of farmers [92]. Sustainable farming is fundamentally not in favour of GMO crops. The mission of Sustainable Biodiesel Alliance, formed in December 2006 in the US, is to create a vision for the sustainable production of biodiesel and the means to certify sustainable biodiesel producers (see also Chapter 14). A basic principle of the Alliance is that GMO feedstocks should not be used unless proven safe.
3.4
Industrial use of vegetable oils
Oils and waxes are commonly found in many plant species. Oils are abundant in seeds, while waxes are normally abundant on the surface of leaves or stems. Oil yielding crop plants are very important for the economic growth of the agricultural sector. Oil volumes and values change widely. In the past, the world’s fat and oil outputs have been more than enough to satisfy the needs of human and animal nutrition (86% food/feed). Consequently, the oleochemical industry was assured of a reliable supply of raw materials (14% of oils and fats) for chemicals manufacture [93]. Fatty acids are used to make soaps, lubricants and greases, and chemical intermediates such as esters, ethoxylates and amides. These three important classes of intermediates are used in the manufacture of surfactants, emulsifiers, detergents, alkyd resins, polyamides, additives (plasticisers, stabilisers), high-performance
Oleochemical sources
81
coatings, paints and varnishes, dispersants, corrosion inhibitors, adhesives, paper, cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, water repellents and fuels. Surfactants are the most important oleochemical outlet for fatty acids. In Europe alone, 200 kt of vegetable oil methyl ester are produced annually as raw materials especially for surfactants. In the last eight years, food consumption has exceeded production, leading to historically low reserves. Higher demand for human nutrition from developing countries (China, India) and the development of biodiesel have determined a change in global use of vegetable oils in 2007, namely 84% foodstuffs, 10% oleochemical and 6% biodiesel (of which 4.6 Mt RSO, 2.1 Mt SBO and < 2.0 Mt PMO and other vegetable oils). Although there is a large genetic variation for the different quality traits of vegetable oil plants both in the seed and leaf, and while natural lipid biosynthesis leads to a broad variety of oils in seeds and fruits, a restricted subset of fatty acid compositions predominates. This has largely determined the value and use of oils and fats in food and oleochemical applications [34, 93]; see Table 3.4. On the other hand, biodiesel application sets different requirements to the oily feedstocks, both in terms of composition and of extraction/refining techniques. While for some chemical applications of triacylglycerides the intact TAG structure (fatty acid positional distribution; see Section 3.2.2) is crucial, for biodiesel application only the fatty acid profile (resulting from hydrolysis of TAGs) matters. Use of plant triacylglycerols as feedstocks for the production of biofuels has recently been reviewed [54]. Table 3.4 Fatty acid specificity and applications Fatty acid composition Industrial crop source Applicability Medium-chain fatty acids (C6 – C14)a
Coconut, palm kernel, Industrial (plasticisers, detergents, cuphea, babassu lubricants), medicinal, nutritional
Lauric acid (C12) Coconut, palm kernel, Detergents, soaps, defoaming (cuphea, babassu) agents, cosmetics, lubricants, food emulsifiers Epoxy fatty acids (C18) Euphorbia, Acacia arabicab
Plasticisers, additives, drying solvents, crosslinkers
Polyunsaturated fatty Linseed, tung acids (C18:3)
Drying oils (coatings, organic binders), varnishes
Hydroxy fatty acids Castor, Lesquerella (C18-OH, C20-OH)
Cosmetics, lubricity enhancers, heavy-duty detergents, inks, coatings
Long-chain fatty acids (C20 – C22)
Cosmetics, specialty lubricants, polymers
a
Meadowfoam, high-erucic rapeseed
Caproic, caprylic, capric, lauric, myristic. Other sources of EFAs include epoxidised soybean oil, linseed oil (from oilseed flax) and processed petrochemicals. b
82
Biodiesel science and technology
Dyer et al. [34] have recently given an overview of several areas (food/feed, fuel/energy, industrial feedstocks, lubricants, inks, nutraceuticals) where plant oils can have a significant impact on the emerging bioeconomy. Many oilseeds find wide application for their nutritional and pharmaceutical values; various polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) show high nutritional properties and are essential to human health. Trans fatty acids are gradually being banned for cooking purposes [94]. Cosmetics oils, such as kukui nut (Aleurites moluccana), borage (Borago officinalis), blackcurrant (Ribes nigrum) and evening primrose (Œnothera biennis) oils are all highly polyunsaturated (50–80%) and therefore less suitable directly as biodiesel feedstocks, despite claims to that extent [95]. Many of the vegetable oils produced in agricultural systems are necessary for a variety of other oleochemical industrial uses, and more recently also for biodiesel. Various early methods of transformation of vegetable oils to yield fuels of varying nature have included tung oil [96], fish oils [97, 98], linseed oil [99], castor oil [100], palm oil [101], cottonseed oil [102] and olive oil [103]. Fatty acid composition determines the quality of oils and fats. Nature has generated an enormous variety of fatty acids, differing in chain length, number and position of double bonds and functional groups. While saturated fatty acids are less desired for nutritional applications, in the industrial sector (cosmetics, softeners, lubricants, and others) such fatty acids are valuable raw materials. For industrial non-food applications such as oleochemicals, high amounts of a single fatty acid content in vegetable oils is of considerable value because processing costs for homogeneous or nearly homogeneous starting material would be reduced. Coconut, palm kernel and Cuphea oils are natural sources of medium-chain fatty acids (C8-C14). Certain natural medium-chain fatty acid producers accumulate just one triglyceride. For example, Actinodaphne hookeri (tali; Lauraceae) seeds contain 95% trilaurin; nutmeg oil contains more than 80% tri-14:0. Some of the Brassicaceae, e.g. Crambe abyssinica, Brassica napus L. and a specially bred high-erucic rapeseed (HEAR) are rich sources (40–60%) of erucic acid (C22 : 1Δ13). Almost 40 kha of land is used to grow rapeseed for erucic acid production in Europe. The high level of erucic acid makes HEAR unsuitable for human consumption. Breeders have bred out erucic acid and lowered levels of glucosinolates (canola). The oleic/linoleic acid group comprises crops such as sunflower (> 85% C18 : 1 + C18 : 2), sesame (> 85%), corn (> 80%), safflower (> 90%), rice bran (>75%), sorghum (> 85%), high-oleic soybean (> 85%) and rapeseed oils (> 80%). Safflower is the highest commercial source of linoleic acid. Cottonseed typically contains about 15 wt% oleic acid; increased seed oleic acid content in transgenic cotton plants ranges from 21 to 30 wt% [104]. The increase in oleic acid content is at the expense of linoleic acid. Drying oils (Table 3.5) have the property of forming a solid, elastic substance when exposed to air in thin layers. The drying power is proportional to the
Oleochemical sources
83
Table 3.5 Classification of oils on the basis of the degree of saturation Saturated: non-drying oils (IV 100–80 g I2/hg) Palm, peanut, olive, rape, castor, almond, jamba Moderately unsaturated: semi-drying oils (IV 120–100 g I2/hg) Cottonseed, sunflower, sesame, croton, corn, curcas, kapok Highly unsaturated: drying oils (IV 200–120 g I2/hg) Linseed, tung, soybean, hempseed, walnut, candlenut, poppy, safflower, perilla
amount of unsaturated fatty acids present. Although the drying process for all drying oils is essentially the same, there are important differences in the oxidation rate. The IV of these oils ranges from about 200 to 120 g I2/hg, which is beyond the range of interest for biodiesel application (unless blending). Vegetable semi-drying oils (IV 120–100 g I2/hg) are characterised by forming a skin when exposed to air at somewhat elevated temperatures. Non-drying oils (Table 3.5), with IV ranges from 100–80 g I2/hg, thicken at elevated temperature but do not dry to a skin. The linolenic acid group has semi-drying properties and is widely used industrially in paints and varnishes. As all tend to oxidise readily, they are regarded as low-quality oils. Lallemantia iberica contains 68.0% of linolenic acid (C18:3), representing one of the highest contents of this unsaturated fatty acid in plant species known. Conventional cold-pressed flaxseed (linseed) oil is an excellent source of linolenic acid, containing approximately 50 wt% C18:3 [105–107]. Also the high linolenic acid contents in C. sativa (false flax, up to 39%) [108] is of interest. Also canola (7% C18 : 3), Lupinus albus (white lupin, 8.7%), perilla (59.6%), hempseed (22.4%) and wheat germ (6.2%) have significant quantities of linolenic acid, in addition to oleic and linoleic acid. Soybean oil from current commercial cultivars typically contains roughly 8% linolenic acid but breeding programmes have allowed the development of germplasm with lower than normal levels of C18 : 3, namely 3.3% [109, 110]. Little is known of the genetic mechanisms that govern C18 : 3 in wild soybean. The linolenic level is most vulnerable to environmental effects in soybean seed oil [111]. It has also been possible to select extremely low-linolenic acid mutants in linseed [107, 112]; see Tables 5.11 and 5.14. Various families are rich sources for g-linolenic acid (GLA: Z,Z,Z-6,9,12-octadecatrienoic acid, 18:3n-6): Onagracea, Saxiferagacea and Boraginacea. Three species gave birth to industrial developments: onagre (Œ. biennis), blackcurrant pip (R. nigrum) and borage (B. officinalis) with g-linolenic acid contents of 8–11%, 14–19% and 18–26%, respectively [113]. The Mediterranean borage crop contains 30–33% of an oil that is the most concentrated source of GLA. In oils containing conjugated fatty acids, such as tung oil (containing 80% of cis, trans, trans-9,11,13-octadecatrienoic acid or C18 : 3c, where ‘c’ stands for conjugation) and oiticica oil (containing 78% of licanic acid or 4-keto-9,11,13-octadecatrienoic acid), the position of double bonds favours
84
Biodiesel science and technology
oxidation and polymerisation. Tung oil is contained in the kernel of fruits (nuts) of the tung tree (Aleuritis fordii, A. cordata, A. verrucosa or A. montana). Major producers include China, Paraguay, Argentina and Brazil; estimated world production averages 50 kt/yr. Kekuna and candlenut or lumbang (A. moluccana) oils, which have similar compositions to Chinese tung oil (A. fordii), are from A. trisperma and A. triloba, respectively. The expensive non-edible tung oil contains about 90% PUFA, mainly as a-eleostearic acid with smaller amounts of oleic, linoleic and palmitic fatty acids [114]. Consequently, tung oil classifies as a conjugated polyunsaturated drying oil whereas linseed oil is of the non-conjugated type. Tung oil’s physical and chemical properties make it useful as a protective coating, solvent, and/or drying agent in various paints, varnishes, lacquers and resins. Its superior drying properties, faster than those of the linolenic acid group, allow it to be sold at a price premium (US$25–50/gal) compared to other vegetable drying oils such as linseed oil. Synthetic diesel from tung oil was once produced in China [96]. Castor oil (world production volume about 600 kt/yr, mainly originating from India and China), which is an inedible, inexpensive, non-volatile oil with good shelf-life, is rich in ricinoleic, or 12-hydroxy-9-cis-octadecenoic acid (85–95%), which is the only hydroxyl acid oil of commercial value. Enzymatic hydrolysis of castor oil with lipolase yields ricinoleic acid [115]. Castor oil (CAS) has too high a viscosity for use in diesel engines (see Table 4.1). CAS is classified as a non-drying oil with very low PUFA value (4.8%). Dehydration of castor oil leads to formation of the conjugated 9,11-octadecadienoic acid; dehydrated castor oil (DCAS) is a semi-drying or drying oil, which can replace tung oil. Castor oil cultivation for biodiesel production is being considered by various countries (see Section 5.9). Unlike vegetable oils and animal fats, oil from the specialty crop jojoba (Simmondsia chinensis) is not just a triglyceride but rather a mixture of long-chain fatty acid esters and fatty alcohols, and is more properly referred to as a wax (average molecular weight of C38-C42 wax esters of 606–610 Da). Many factors affect wax ester, fatty acid and fatty alcohol molecular weight [116]. The liquid wax esters extracted are used commercially in the lubricant and cosmetics industries. Jojoba seed production is quite limited (5 kt/yr) [117]. Krill oil, which contains phospholipids, omega-3 (>30% EPA and DHA), omega-6 (<2.0% C18 : 2) and omega-9 fatty acids (>10% C18 : 1) as well as astaxanthin, finds use in the nutraceutical and pharmaceutical industries. Krills (or euphausiids) are at the bottom of the animal food chain and are mainly used for aquaculture and aquarium feeds, but are also sold for human consumption, mainly in Japan. With the current regulatory catch quota of about 6 Mt/yr and a lipid content of only 3 wt%, the potential oil yield is 180 kt if all krill were dried and the oil extracted.
Oleochemical sources
3.5
85
Unusual fatty acids
Triglycerides are commonly classified as short-chain (SCT, C2-C5), mediumchain (MCT, C6-C14) and long-chain (LCT, > C16). Both SCT and MCT are mostly saturated and are found in dairy products as well as in some plant oils. Long-chain triglycerides may have points of unsaturation and are found in animal, food and fish products as well as in plant oils. Most liquid plant oils (soybean, canola, safflower, sunflower, etc.) are composed of predominantly 18-carbon fatty acids. Longer chain fatty acids, such as those found in camelina, mustard and meadowfoam, give these oils unique hydrating and stability properties. In plant oils generally only even-numbered chain lengths occur (see Section 3.2.1), whereas animal fats also contain unevenly-numbered fatty acids. Odd chain length long-chain fatty acids are frequently found in marine oils. Fish oils contain unusual odd-numbered triglycerides (0.1–0.5% of 17 : 0, 17 : 1, 19 : 0, 19 : 1, 21 : 0, 21 : 5) and/or branched-chain triacylglycerols (0.1–0.8% of C15, C17, C18, C19). These minor fatty acids are relatively insignificant in determining the characteristics of each fish oil. The structures of fatty acids esterified in triacylglycerols are remarkably diverse in the plant kingdom [30]. As shown in Section 3.2, lipid content can be affected by genotype within the same species and also by environment. As shown in Figs 3.2 and 3.6 for plants, oleic acid may be transferred into the PC fraction of the ER for conversion to linoleic acid by a membrane-bound oleate D12-desaturase. Many plants contain a divergent form of D12-DES capable of producing a variety of unusual fatty acids, such as hydroxy, epoxy, acetylenic or conjugated fatty acids. The transfer of unusual fatty acids from PC to TAG is significantly more complex than for the common fatty acids; details of the relevant enzyme activities are still largely unknown. The commercial production of seed oils containing unusual fatty acids is frequently hampered by the poor agronomic traits of the plants (e.g. small seeds, limited geographical growing areas), which significantly increase production costs [118]. The mix and concentration of the triacylglycerides present in many oils also raise other economic issues, since the desired component is often only present in relatively small amounts. Exotic fatty acids of commercial interest in oilseeds to be used for chemical or nutritional purposes were recently listed by Drexler et al. [28] and Dyer et al. [34]. For example, very few plants synthesise the triglycerides, tricaprylin (C8:0) and tricaprin (C10 : 0). MCTs may be derived from specific fractions of unhydrogenated, partially hydrogenated or fully hydrogenated dairy butterfat, coconut oil, palm kernel oil and the like. Plant sources of tricaproin are limited only to trace components in some tropical plants and are incapable of supplying sufficient volumes for industrial application. The diversity of structure and inherent functionality of vegetable oils make them prime candidates for use in polymers and resins. Chemistry
86
Biodiesel science and technology 18 : 1-CoA
18 : 1-PC
OH-18 : 1-PC
D12-DES
18 : 2-PC
Epoxy-18 : 1-PC Acetylenic-18 : 1-PC Conjugated-18 : 3-PC
D15-DES
18 : 3-PC
Triacylglycerols (oil)
3.6 Production of unusual fatty acids and oils in plants.
being considered to modify and functionalise vegetable oils includes transesterification, epoxidation, hydroformylation and metathesis. Unusual fatty acids are of particular interest for various industrial applications. Consequently, considerable efforts have been undertaken to alter the genome of traditional oilseed crops in such a way that they accumulate new economically valuable oils [119]. A genetically altered plant strain (Cuphea viscosissima VS-320) produces an oil with elevated levels (> 80%) of MCTs, in particular C10 : 0 and C8 : 0, and some C6 : 0 [72]. Such an oil may be appropriate for use as a natural substitute for diesel fuel without chemical conversion of component triglycerides to methyl esters (see Section 3.3). Modern DNA transfer technologies might afford the transfer of genes that control the synthesis of low molecular weight triglycerides from species such as Cuphea into other better established oilseed crops. Oil composition could then be genetically modified for the optimal desired biodiesel properties. The manipulation of oil synthesis in canola plants to produce specific, desired,
Oleochemical sources
87
chemically altered triglycerides has already been implemented on a large scale. For example, canola oil synthesis was altered to produce high levels of the medium-chain triglyceride C12 : 0 resulting in reduced levels of the long-chain triglycerides C16 : 0 and C18 : 0 [36]. Seed oils containing fatty acids with unusual structures are highly important in the chemical industry as raw materials for the production of a variety of oleochemicals (see Tables 3.4 and 3.5). The chemical structure of fatty acids in plant lipids is usually bound to a chain of 18 carbon atoms with double bonds occurring at D9, 12 and/or 15 positions. However, some plant species are able to produce unusual fatty acids with special characteristics, such as variations in chain length (mainly C12 and C14), conjugated double bonds or functional groups within the fatty acid molecule. An abundance of unusual fatty acids with various functionalities in the fatty acid chain can be found in plants from nature, like acetylenic, allenic, conjugated, epoxide, keto, hydroxy, furanoid, fluoro, cyclopropene and cyclopentenyl fatty acids [120]. In fact, over 300 different unusual fatty acids have been identified in seed oils from various plants [29, 30, 121–123]. Some of these unusual fatty acids can occur in very high amounts (up to 95%) in the seed oil of certain species. Of these plants only relatively few, e.g. castor bean, are used for significant commercial production. However, many other unusual fatty acids have considerable potential as renewable industrial feedstocks. Biochemical pathways involved in the synthesis of unusual monounsaturated fatty acids, such as petroselinic acid (C18 : 1), are complex [124]. The synthesis of these fatty acids likely involves enzyme complexes. Oxygenated fatty acids are mainly mono- and dihydroxy fatty acids, keto and epoxy fatty acids. Hydroxyl functionality is rare in plant oils. Castor (Ricinus communis) oil contains 88–90% of the main monohydroxy fatty acid, ricinoleic acid (C18 : 1-OH), and trace quantities of dihydroxystearic acid (~0.7%), which has two hydroxyl groups. Hydroxy fatty acids (HFAs) find application in the manufacture of polymers, paints, flavour and fragrance components. Ricinoleic acid is a much sought-after hydroxy fatty acid and is also found in Crotalaria striata (15.8%), Ochrocarpus africanus (20.0%) and Alternanthera triandra (22.1%). The uniquely high level of the ricinoleic acid in castor oil imparts increased lubricity to the oil esters as compared to normal vegetable oil esters with similar carbon chain length [125]. Similarly, the developing crop plant Lesquerella also produces HFAs. Lesquerella fendleri and L. gordonii are members of the genus Lesquerella of the Brassicaceae (mustard) family. The oils of L. fendleri and L. gordonii are attractive due to their high HFA content (see Table 6.7). The major hydroxy fatty acid (53%) is 14-hydroxy-cis-11-eicosenoic acid (lesquerolic acid), a homologue to ricinoleic acid. Lesquerella also contains densipolic acid (C18 : 2-OH), auricolic acid (C20 : 2-OH) and traces of ricinoleic acid (C18 : 1-OH). The hydroxyl group facilitates plasticisation and adhesion of
88
Biodiesel science and technology
the oil esters. The fatty acid profile imparts Lesquerella oil methyl esters with exceptional value as diesel fuel additives [126]. The seed oils from Dimorphoteca pluvialis (Cape marigold) contain the HFA dimorphecolic acid (C18 : 2-OH) [127]. The kernel oil Licania rigida (Oiticica) has obtained commercial status as it contains high amounts of the ketonic polyene-acid 4-ketoeleostearic (or licanic) acid, C18:3=O (drying agent) [128, 129]. Similarly, Mappia foetida contains 16.0% of 3-keto-octadec-cis-15-enoic acid [130]. Natural sources of epoxy oil (vernolic acid, C18:1>O) are Vernonia galamensis (> 74%), V. anthelmintica (67%) and Euphorbia lagascae (60%). The seeds from Acacia arabica (Leguminosae) varieties – Telia babul, Vediana and Cupressiformis – contain about 9% of the related epoxy derivative coronaric acid (9,10-epoxy-octadec-cis-12-enoic acid; C18 : 1>O), as well as the cyclopropene fatty acids malvalic acid (about 2.5%) and sterculic acid (about 2.1%) [131]. Similarly, Ficus benghalensis (banyan tree) oil contains normal fatty acids, along with an epoxy fatty acid (vernolic acid) and two cyclopropenoid fatty acids (malvalic and sterculic acid). Currently, no oilseed crop has been commercialised as a source of natural epoxidised oils. However, V. galamensis has potential for domestication as a new industrial oilseed source of natural epoxy fatty acids. Epoxidised oils, manufactured by chemical epoxidation of fats and vegetable oils such as soybean, are useful in reformulation of oil-based (alkyl-resin) paints, as plasticisers, and in cosmetic and pharmaceutical applications. The naturally occurring epoxidised oil of Vernonia and the chemically epoxidised soybean oil (ESO) and linseed oil are similar, but there is an important difference. Epoxidised soybean and linseed oil are highly viscous and are non-pourable below 273 K. Vernonia oil, however, has low viscosity and can be stored below 273 K. Whereas methyl vernoleate (containing an epoxy group) is very stable towards oxidation, methyl crepenynate (containing a triple bond) oxidises extremely rapidly [132]. Small amounts of furanoid fatty acids (C20 and C22) are contained in soybean oil [133]. Cyclopropenoid fatty acids occur most commonly in the seed oils of the order Malvales (Sterculiaceae, Malvaceae, Bombaceae and Tiliaceae). As shown in Table 3.6, the cyclopropenoid fatty acids malvalic acid (C18 : 1) and sterculic acid (C19 : 1) frequently occur together, as in the cases of F. benghalensis, A. arabica, C. striata, Triumfetta pilosa (Roth seed), Cassia marginata and O. africanus. Small amounts of cyclopropene fatty acids (malvalic and sterculic acids) are also present in crude cottonseed oil, and exert harmful biological effects when fed to animals [134]. The seed oils of many species of plants of the Flacourtiaceae family contain fatty acids with a terminal cyclopentenyl group. The cyclopentenyl fatty acids hydnocarpic acid (C16 : 1), chaulmoogric acid (C18 : 1) and gorlic acid (C18 : 2) constitute up to 90% of the total fatty acids of the seed oils of Hydnocarpus, a medicinal oil [135]. Momordica balsamina L. (balsam
Table 3.6 Composition of a selection of seed oils containing unusual fatty acids
Oil SN content
a
200
CN C12:0 C14:0 C16:0 C18:0 C18:1 C18:1a C18:1>Ob C18:1>Oc C18:1–OH C18:1=Od C18:2 C18:3 C19:1e References
78 54 1.5
1.3
35.2
4.2
20.3
3.7
8.2
–
–
–
15.4
8.7
1.6
[136]
201 116 48 – 203 92 51 –
1.3 3.6
12.7 32.1
6.0 4.1
20.7 8.0
2.5 2.1
– –
9.0 –
– 15.8
– –
45.7 – 15.0 15.0
2.1 4.3
[131] [137]
200 85 55 – 200 102 50 –
– –
24.2 16.7
8.9 10.8
17.1 20.1
– 2.4
22.0 –
– –
– –
– –
27.8 43.4
– –
– 6.6
[138] [139]
201 110 47 –
–
17.3
4.5
14.2
3.5
8.5
–
–
–
49.4
–
2.6
[140]
200
1.3
28.2
27.4
–
6.0
12.0
–
20.0
–
–
–
4.0
[141]
203 102 54 –
3.9
16.9
5.9
26.0
–
–
–
22.1
–
25.2
–
–
[142]
201 196
99 38 – 35 66 –
– –
12.3 56.0
4.2 3.6
16.2 5.3
– 0.5
– –
– –
– –
16.0 –
11.6 39.7 5.6 –
188
61 62 –
–
27.0
3.7
5.6
6.7
–
–
–
–
35 65 1.1
6.3
–
Malvalic acid. Vernolic acid. c Coronaric acid. d 3-Keto-octadec-cis-15-enoic acid. e Sterculic acid. b
– 22.9
[130] [143, 144]
45.0
[143]
Oleochemical sources
Ficus 20 benghalensis Acacia arabica 7–9 Crotalaria 5 striata Rivea ornata 10 Triumfetta 12 pilosa Cassia 5 marginata Ochrocarpus 30 africanus Alternanthera 8 triandra Mappia foetida 35 Bombax – munguba Sterculia – foetida
IV
89
90
Biodiesel science and technology
apple) seed oil contains geometrical isomers of conjugated octadecatrienoic acids, namely punicic acid (50%) and a-eleostearic acid (13%) [145]. In the industrial field, there is competition between oleochemicals and petrochemicals (fuels). Being combustible, vegetable oils have great potential to be used as liquid fuel and some will combust in diesel engines. Requirements to the fatty acid profile of a vegetable oil, which makes it a good starting material for biodiesel production (at least from a chemical point of view), are complex but many different compositions qualify. The compositions of the seed oils with unusual fatty acids shown in Table 3.6 are mainly of interest for oleochemical production. For biodiesel applications the oil contents of most seeds are too low. Taking into account the linolenic acid content (< 12% for biodiesel applications), F. benghalensis and O. africanus deserve some further attention in this respect.
3.6
Oil processing techniques
The widely differing characteristics of fatty materials from diverse sources have given rise to various oil recovery processes, such as rendering (see Section 5.10.1), pressing and solvent extraction. The term ‘rendering’ is generally applied to treatment designed to remove all or most of the fatty animal tissue or other materials with a high ratio of fat to solid matter. Natural vegetable oils and animal fats are pressed or extracted to obtain crude oil or fat, and crude oils may be refined (see Section 3.6.5). The method used to extract vegetable oil depends on the type of raw material available. Raw materials may be grouped according to the part of the plant that contains oil or fat (seed, bean, nut or fruit). The main difference in raw materials is the moisture content. Raw materials with low moisture content include seeds and beans and some nuts, which are dried on harvest. Palm fruit, olive fruits and some coconuts are processed wet. Most oil (75%) comes from seeds. The use of fruits as an oil source (e.g. palm, olive, avocado) presents several advantages compared with seeds. Oil from fruits is easily extractable and can often be obtained by a few simple mechanical steps, which contrasts with seeds that often have to be submitted to several transformation steps before extraction of the oil with organic solvents. Moreover, oil fruits typically have an overall higher yield of oil per unit of growth area than oil seeds. The production of vegetable oils from oleaginous seeds employs technology which has been developed over many decades of commercial use. Seed crushing needs to consider the oil recovery rate and oil losses. Most commercial processing of common oilseeds is by mechanical expression (cold or hot), solvent extraction or mixed mechanical/solvent extraction [146]. The general principles of processing methods and preservation include:
Oleochemical sources
91
sterilisation by application of heat; elimination of as much water as possible from the oil to prevent microbial growth during storage; and proper packaging and storage of the extracted oil to slow down chemical deterioration (oxidation, rancidity). The objectives of sterilisation (‘cooking’) are loosening of fruit on the bunch, softening of fruit, conditioning of nuts, coagulation of proteins, and destruction of enzymes in the raw material and contaminating microorganisms that produce free fatty acids on processing. Vegetable oil processing from oilseeds or oil fruits may comprise various stages, including cleaning, dehulling, pre-treatment (cooking at 353–363 K; conditioning at 7–10% relative humidity; enzymatic hydrolysis; drying; flaking), cracking/grinding, extraction (mechanically, chemically or in combination), purification and refining. Obviously, any pre-treatment step of oleaginous seeds adds to the overall cost. There are, however, essentially three major steps in extraction of oil from seed: heating, crushing and further processing. First, the seeds may be heated or left cold before pressing through a mechanical crusher, i.e. hot pressed or cold pressed. Heat treatment applied to oilseeds prior to pressing is not generally necessary. Second, the seeds pass through some type of press which presses oil into a container and directs seed meal into another. Third, and optionally, a mechanical or chemical process may be used to increase oil yield. In a mechanical process, the remaining meal is prepared for recrushing by passing it through an extruder which heats the meal to the point that seed cell walls break, facilitating further oil removal. The preferred extraction depends on the nature of the oilseed/fruit, oil content and production capacity (Table 3.7). Only seeds, nuts and fruits that contain considerable amounts of edible oil are used for small-scale oil extraction. Edible oil content may also be too small for economic processing
Table 3.7 Extraction procedures of vegetable oils Process
Applicability
Raw materials
Mechanical High oil content (> 35%) Small/medium capacitya (< 200 t/d)
Babassu Castor bean Peanut
Solvent Low oil content (< 25%) High capacitya (> 300 t/d)
Soybean Rice bran Cottonseed
Mixed Medium/high oil content (> 25%) Medium/high capacitya (> 200 t/d)
Coconut Castor bean Peanut Babassu Sunflower
a
Raw material.
92
Biodiesel science and technology
on a small scale (e.g. maize). Palm fruit containing about 56% edible oil (or 25% on a fresh fruit bunch (FFB) basis) with no known toxins is suitable for small-scale processing. Oils containing toxins or having unpleasant flavours require careful processing and are generally not suitable for small-scale processing (e.g. castor oil). The oil content of vegetable oil seeds varies considerably, from very low (soybean ca. 20%) to high (euphorbs, ca. 50%) (see Table 3.8). Consequently, 1000 kg of canola seed yields about 420 kg of biodiesel from the oil fraction, as opposed to only 200 kg from 1000 kg of soybeans. With biodiesel application in mind, we notice the exceedingly low seed oil content (7–9%) of Acacia arabica, and therefore other use (in particular medicinal) is recommended here. The preferred extraction method also depends on the desired results. The choice of extraction method may have implications for uses and prices for both oil and meal. If one wishes to preserve the cake, then the oil press is Table 3.8 Oil content (wt%) of oil fruits and oil seeds Acacia arabica B. carinata Babassua Camelina Canola Cardoon Castor bean Coconut (copra) Coriander Corna Cottonseed Crambe Crotona Euphorbia Hazelnut Hempseed Jatropha c. Joyoba oil-wax Kapok seed Kenaf Lesquerella Linseed Lupin a
7–9 39–50 42–63 30–43 38–43 25 46–55 50–65 9–19 7–8 15–25 35b–46c 50–60 48–52 49–63 25–35 46–58a 25–40b 50–60 20 21–26 25 35–45 12–22
Mahua Meadowfoam Moringa oleifera Mustard Olive Oiticicaa Palm (E. guineensis) Palm (E. oleifera) Peanut Pennycress Perilla Pongamia pinnata Poppyseed Rapeseed Rice bran Rubber seeda Safflower Sesame Soybean Sunflower Tung Vernonia Wheat germ
50 20–26 25–41 25–50d 20 60 40–65e, f 29–50e 35–54 36 38–48 24–33 40–50 36–50 16–32g 40–50 28–45 37–63 15–23 22–55 35 30–42 8–12
Kernels. Whole seed. c Dehulled seed. d Yellow mustard (27%), brown mustard (36%), some oriental mustards (50%). e Mesocarp. f 21–25% on FFB basis. g Depending on variety of rice and degree of milling. b
Oleochemical sources
93
used. The hexane crusher process extracts more than 90% of the oil from the seed, leaving very little in the meal. The cold-press extraction method, an ‘organic’ expeller process, leaves 8–13% of oil in the meal. The meal’s higher oil content, and in some cases its omega-3 fatty acid content, and the ‘organic’ process might generate a price premium, or the higher oil content might lead to a discount, because the oil is not good for ruminants. Vegetable oils should ideally be kept in dark containers in cool and dry locations, minimising contact with air and moisture. In colder climates, used vegetable oil can be stored indefinitely; in warm climates, microorganisms can grow rapidly in used vegetable oils. Quality control in the oil mill concentrates on optimising oil yield and minimising deterioration of the oil by hydrolysis and oxidation. Vegetable oil processing techniques were recently reviewed [147–149].
3.6.1 Mechanical pressing Several costly pre-treatments of the oleaginous seeds, such as drying, dehulling, flaking and cooking, may precede mechanical pressing, usually continuous single-screw (expeller) processing. A cold-press expeller process is often preferred and used by most small-scale crushers. First, an extruder can be many times more costly than a regular expeller, making it less feasible for smaller operations. Second, using a hot-press mechanism increases input costs (i.e. energy) to a degree not currently justified. Third, using hexane increases production costs and complicates the feasibility of small-scale, on-farm production. Recovery efficiencies of 80% are typical for smallscale, cold-press expeller crushing techniques. The expeller is less efficient on seeds with lower oil content. Other drawbacks of mechanical extraction are higher operating costs, the need for more material storage and handling, more maintenance and more operators. Olive, flaxseed and avocado are examples of cold pressing, which yields the better (edible) oil; palm kernel and babassu are hot pressed. The maximum temperature of ‘cold pressing’ is 300 K. Depending on the pressing procedures, temperatures of 333 K may be reached in olive oil extraction. Oilseeds yield their oil more readily to mechanical expression after cooking (e.g. in the case of cottonseed). Oil extraction of palm fruit bunches is a complex process, that may be carried out by large mills in plantations (up to 60 t fruit/h) or by small mills in rural villages (1 t oil in 8 h shift). In either case, oil extraction from fruit follows the same basic steps (Table 3.9). Palm oil production from fruit involves sterilisation, mechanical removal of fruit from the bunch, and mechanical breakdown of the fruit structure followed by expression of the oil in a screw press. Oil yield represents 25% of the fresh fruit bunch (FFB). Solvent extraction is rarely used.
94
Biodiesel science and technology Table 3.9 Post-harvest handling of palm fruit Step
Action
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Steam sterilisation of bunches Stripping fruit from bunches Crushing, digestion and heating of fruit Oil extraction from macerated fruit (hydraulic pressing) Palm oil clarificationa Separating fibre from endocarp Drying, grading, and cracking of endocarp Separating endocarp from kernel Kernel drying and packing
a
Product is termed crude palm oil.
A screw press makes it possible to have a continuous feeding of seeds. High-oil content seeds, such as copra, are difficult to express by a single pressing. The use of twin-screw extruders for oil extraction provides an alternative to traditional procedures which has received but little attention for rapeseeds [150] and oleic sunflower seeds [151]. Direct expression of oleic sunflower in a twin-screw extruder yields high-quality oil (acidity < 2 mg KOH/g).
3.6.2 Solvent extraction The screw press process is no longer the most common type of oil extraction. Vegetable oil producers are now more likely to use a closed-loop solvent extraction system that involves less mechanical force and produces vegetable oil at lower cost. Ordinary (high-pressure) mechanical expression results in considerably more oil (up to 10–15%) remaining in the seed cake compared to solvent extraction. The protein-rich seed cake for feed is important in determining profitability of oilseed cultivation. Solvent extraction constitutes the most efficient method for the recovery of oil from any oil-bearing material and is most advantageous for processing of low-oil seeds. Trichloroethene, ether, n-hexane and lower alkanes have been used. Chemicals present inherent dangers (health, explosions). Hexane is relatively inexpensive. Hexane solvent extraction can be used in isolation or along with the oil press/expeller method. Chemical extraction yields depend on the operating conditions, typically as follows: seed/solvent ratio, 1:18 w/w%; reaction temperature, 323 K; contact time, 2 h (rapeseed) or 1 h (sunflower). Contact mode depends on granulometry, with immersion for finely ground oilseeds and countercurrent percolation for larger particle sizes. Chemical extraction can be continuous (> 250–500 t/d) or batch. In optimal conditions commercial solvent extraction reduces the oil content of the dry solid residue to < 0.1%.
Oleochemical sources
95
Soybeans (which account for 32% of edible oils), cottonseed, and rice bran are all solvent (hexane) extracted. Also palm kernel is usually solvent extracted (5% on FFB basis). Substitution of solvent extraction for pressing methods increases the yield of oil from soybeans by 12.1%, from cottonseed by 11.5% and from flaxseed by only 5.3%. Solvent extraction of lipids from soybeans with acidic hexane (containing 5 vol% acetic acid) yielded roughly 6–10% more neutral oil than did hexane extractions [152]. High-quality oil and improved meal of canola are obtained by two-phase solvent extraction using 10% (w/w) NH3 in 95/5% (vol./vol.) CH3OH/H2O as a polar phase and hexane as a non-polar phase [153]. Castor oil, olive oil and wheat germ oil residuals from mechanical pressing are also solvent extracted. The most common solvents used for oil and fat extraction are light paraffinic petroleum fractions (C5-C8). However, EPA classifies hexane as a hazardous air pollutant and its release is regulated. The crushing facility must take steps to contain emissions and to ensure worker safety. Local legislation and authorities usually require permission for installation and operation of a solvent extraction plant. Because of the 1990 Clean Air Act and potential health risks, an alternative solvent or solvent system may eventually replace n-hexane as the extraction agent of vegetable oils. Kuk and Hron [154] reported a system of isohexane and either 5 to 25% ethanol or isopropyl alcohol to extract cottonseed oil. Less odorous cottonseed meals were obtained by extraction with mixtures of acetone and n-hexane [155]. Conventional wisdom holds that combining oil crushing and biodiesel production is too expensive for all but the largest producers. This puts biodiesel producers at the mercy of a volatile market. While solvent-based systems generally suffer from higher capital costs (about twice that of mechanical systems), recently solvent-based oil extraction systems have been designed which are cost competitive with mechanical oilseed crushers and give biodiesel producers more control over their feedstock costs [156]. A solvent extraction system can provide economical operation for biodiesel plants as small as 15 Mgy to 20 Mgy (50 to 67 kt). The solvent extraction developed by SRS Engineering Corp. (Murrieta, CA) cleans, cracks and cooks oilseeds with steam before flaking and drying [156]. Oil is extracted from the flaked seed with hexane. For biodiesel production the crude vegetable oil obtained needs degumming by adding phosphoric or citric acid, bleaching, filtration and deacidification. Both the obtained FFA- and water-free oil and FFA distillates can be used to produce biodiesel. No costly reworking of the biodiesel product is required. On the other hand, solvent extraction systems requiring caustic washing remove FFA from the oil and thereby lose 2–4% in overall yield.
96
Biodiesel science and technology
3.6.3 Mixed mechanical/solvent extraction Hexane solvent extraction can be used in isolation or along with the oil press/expeller method. After the oil has been extracted using an expeller, the remaining pulp can be further processed with (cyclo)hexane to extract the remaining oil content. The oil dissolves in the (cyclo-)hexane, and the pulp is filtered out from the solution. Oil and solvent are separated by distillation. The hexane process increases oil removal efficiency in a strictly cold-pressed process. Current procedures for the industrial extraction of sunflower seeds involve a two-step process of mechanical pressing followed by extraction with hexane. Prior to extraction of oil, sunflower seeds are frequently dehulled in order to improve the oil and meal quality and increase the capacity and efficiency of the extraction plant (see Fig. 3.7). Economical utilisation of the hull material is industrially important. Hulls are mainly used for heat production, as animal feed and fertiliser. Seventy-five percent of the oil of sunflower seeds can be extracted by crushing with rollers, and the fatty cake then contains about 15% of oil. The oil level of the cake can be reduced to less than 2% by solvent extraction. Also corn germ is pressed and then often solvent (hexane) extracted (See Section 5.5). Similarly, conventional commercial processing of babassu and rapeseed involves mechanical pressing and solvent extraction to separate oil and meal. Today’s oil market situation favours pre-pressing (PP) and solvent extraction (SE) over full-pressing (FP). Two-step full-pressing is applicable to most soft seeds; 65 to 75% of the oil is separated under moderate pre-pressing conditions. Light coloured oils are obtained with low non-hydratable and total phosphatide content. There are promising approaches to improve the oil yields of full-pressing operations to reduce the cost gap of FP to PP/SE.
Oilseed (100) Dehulling
Hulls (30–40)
Kernels (60–70) Pre-press solvent extraction
Meal (30–35)
Oil (30–35)
3.7 Materials balance (wt%) for sunflower seed (after ref. [157]).
Oleochemical sources
97
3.6.4 New processing techniques There is a need for the development of new processing techniques to facilitate vegetable oil extraction and refining while sustaining the nutritional components naturally present in edible oils and reducing the adverse impact of oil processing on the environment. It is well known that, during milling of oleaginous seeds, a high percentage of the antioxidants is lost in the mill’s wastewaters [158]. Supercritical CO2 (scCO2) extraction and fractionation techniques are alternative methods to obtain oil of high quality and purity [159]. Supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) is attracting a great deal of interest because the technique can reduce considerably sample extraction time, and oil recovery (almost 100%) is better than that of most classical extraction techniques for solid and semisolid samples [160]. However, the method needs special equipment for containment and pressure in supercritical CO 2 (scCO2) extraction. SFE is generally carried out in a mechanically stirring or rocking batch reactor at the solvent’s critical temperature and pressure (304.3 K and 7.29 Mha for CO2). For an overview on the solubility behaviour of lipid components in scCO2, see ref. [161]. Soybean oil has been deacidified using supercritical CO2 and membrane technology [162]. The American Oil Chemists’ Society has approved an official method to determine oil in oilseeds through supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) [163]. Quantitative supercritical-fluid-based extraction employing scCO2 is becoming increasingly popular, as reported for pecan oil [164], soy and corn soapstocks [165], walnut [166], flaxseed [167], dry macroalgae [168] and jojoba oils [169]. Similarly, SFE of oil from palm-pressed mesocarp fibre (E. guineensis) has been reported [170]. The technique can be used to determine the oil content in copra and its meal in less than 10 min. Rice bran was extracted by means of scCO2 and liquid propane and compared with accelerated solvent extraction (ASE) with hexane [171]. Neither process resulted in a positive rate of return on investment. Supercritical extraction is used industrially in the decaffeination of coffee beans [172], extraction of fragrances and essences from plant material [173], of fats in food [174], of fatty acids and hydrocarbons from algae [168], and of additives in polymers [160]. SFE technology has been used increasingly for the processing of nutraceuticals, including bioactive lipids, on a commercial level as it provides a solvent-free product. Supercritical technologies for oil processing have been reviewed [161]. Recently, some new approaches have been proposed for the extraction of oil from plant materials, such as three-phase partitioning (TPP) of SBO [175], enzyme-assisted three-phase partitioning (EATPP) of jatropha [176], and aqueous enzymatic oil extraction (AEOE) of rice bran [177] and peanut (using Protizyme™) [178]. Some oilseeds, such as soybean, are inefficiently
98
Biodiesel science and technology
extracted by mechanical expression alone. In these cases preconditioning of the oilseeds by enzymatic hydrolysis is an option. Enzymatic hydrolysis results in higher oil yields, higher extraction rates and improved product characteristics. Enzymatic extraction of oil from the Chilean hazelnut (G. avellana) was compared with extraction in aqueous medium [179]. Extraction speeds may be enhanced by sonication [176]. At a laboratory level extraction techniques are even more numerous and range from conventional extraction technologies (reflux, Soxhlet, etc.) to ultrasonically assisted extraction and high-pressure solvent extraction methods (SFE, ASE, subcritical water extraction and microwave-assisted extraction). For characterising features of these techniques, see ref. [160]. Soxhlet extraction is notoriously slow. Soxhlet extraction for at least 2 h or ASE for 20 min are more reliable methods for the determination of FFA in cottonseed than the AOCS Official Method Aa 6-38 [180]. Matthäus and Brühl [181] have reported a comparison of different methods (SFE, ASE, MAE, Soxtherm and solid fluid vortex extraction) for the determination of the oil content in various oilseeds (rapeseed, sunflower and soybean). FA profiles of catfish liver oils were analysed using a microwave-assisted method [182].
3.6.5 Crude oil refining Physical and chemical properties of vegetable oils vary with the method of extraction. For example, cold-pressed castor oil has low acid value (3 mg/g), low iodine number (82–88 g I2/hg) and a slightly higher saponification value (179–185 mg KOH/g) than solvent-extracted oil (3 mg/g, 80–88 g I 2/hg, 177–182 mg KOH/g, respectively), and is lighter in colour [183]. Cooking and drying conditions for oilseeds preparatory to screw pressing influence the screw press performance. Cold-pressed whole flaxseeds are an excellent source of linolenic acid. Wan and Dowd [184] have compared the influence of various extraction techniques (hydraulic pressing, room temperature and Soxhlet solvent extraction) on the free fatty acid (FFA) concentration of cottonseed oil. Seed abuse prior to processing deteriorates the product. Low acidity oils can be obtained by shortening the time between collection of the mature crop and processing (at room temperature) in N2 atmosphere, as shown for olive oil [185]. Storing olives for protracted periods accounts for a rather high FFA content in the oil. Good palm plantation oil consistently runs lower than 5% in FFA, whereas native-produced oil may contain up to 50% FFA. Crude vegetable oils (VOs) and fats may contain other materials, notably fatty acids (typically 1–5%), water, saccharides, antioxidants, proteins, aminoacids, hydrocarbons, flavours, colorants, enzymes, alcohols, particulates, metal salts, and N-, S- and P-containing compounds. The sulphur content of
Crude oil
Liquid-liquid extraction
Centrifugation
Oil
Diluted soda
Aqueous
Centrifugation
Aqueous
Polar organics Degumming
Water/soap Caustic treatment
Clays/impurities
Wax crystals
Oil T279–281K Wax crystals
Dewaxing
Filtration Crystallisation
Oil
Oil + special clays
Bleaching
Refined oil
3.8 Main crude oil refining steps consisting of degumming, caustic treatment, bleaching and dewaxing.
Oleochemical sources
Filtration Oil 291 K
Oil
99
100
Biodiesel science and technology
VOs is mainly due to glucosinolates and their breakdown products, while the phosphorous content is related to the presence of phospho- and glycolipids. It is preferable to remove most of such materials by a suitable method such as filtration, distillation, etc. prior to the transesterification reaction, when the other materials may interfere in the production process or affect the final product quality. Crude palm oil has a strong negative odour and oxidised coconut oil smells soapy. After isolation, crude oils are therefore given physical and chemical pretreatments for several reasons. The main aim of refining crude oils (Fig. 3.8) is to remove impurities and other undesirable constituents (gums or slimes) to give an oil impurity content of about 0.1%. Refining includes: oil degumming consisting in a liquid–liquid extraction process with aqueous phosphoric acid followed by centrifuging to selectively remove all of the leftover solid and colloidal plant matter and polar organics (e.g. phospholipids, lecithin); caustic treatment of the degummed oil to remove FFAs as soaps, followed by centrifuging; removing coloured matter by bleaching (with Fuller’s earth or activated charcoal); deodorising by steam treatment at high T and low p; and dewaxing or winterising by cooling the anhydrous oil to 279–281 K and removing unwanted waxes (esters of long-chain alcohols and fatty acids) that precipitate out. Dewaxed vegetable oil feedstocks improve pour and cloud points of the final biodiesel product. The application of degumming is essential with oil feedstocks. Oils with higher gum contents tend to exhibit more storage problems. On the other hand, refining usually also decreases oxidation stability as a result of loss of antioxidants (tocopherols). Liquid–liquid extraction is used to deacidify high-acidity oils. The method is based on the different solubilities of fatty acids and triglycerides in organic solvents such as methanol [186]. The free fatty acid content of seed oils can also be reduced by supercritical fractionation techniques. For example, supercritical fluid fractionation is a viable process to remove FFAs efficiently from both hexane- and scCO2-extracted wheat germ oil while retaining bioactive components in the final product [187]. Distillation methods include vacuum, steam, molecular and extraction distillation. Semirefined and refined (RBD) vegetable oils are the predominant feedstocks for the production of biodiesel. Partially refined products are obtained when one or more of the usual refining stages are omitted. Bleaching and deodorisation are often omitted in commercial partially refined fats and oils. However, neutralisation, bleaching and deodorisation of oils before biodiesel production contribute to the oxidative stability of the end product.
3.7
Bibliography
D.E. Vance and J.E. Vance (eds), Biochemistry of Lipids, Lipoproteins, and Membranes, 5th edn, Elsevier, Amsterdam (2008).
Oleochemical sources
101
F. Shahidi (ed.), Maximising the Value of Marine By-Products, Woodhead Publishing Ltd, Cambridge (2007). H. Breivik (ed.), Long-Chain Omega-3 Speciality Oils, The Oily Press, Bridgwater (2007). M.K. Gupta, Practical Guide to Vegetable Oil Processing, AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2007). F. Shahidi, Nutraceutical and Specialty Lipids and their Co-Products, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (2006). K. Larsson, P. Quinn, K. Sato and F. Tiberg, Lipids: Structure, Physical Properties and Functionality, vol. 19, The Oily Press Lipid Library, Bridgwater (2006). F. Shahidi (ed.), Bailey’s Industrial Oils and Fat Products, 6th edn, 6 vols, Wiley-Interscience, Hoboken, NJ (2005). S. Erhan (ed.), Industrial Uses of Vegetable Oils, AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2005). R.M. Goodman (ed.), Encyclopedia of Plant and Crop Science, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY (2004). D.L. Luthria (ed.), Oil Extraction and Analysis: Critical Issues and Comparative Studies, AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2004). W.W. Christie, Lipid Analysis, Vol. 15, The Oily Press Lipid Library, Bridgwater (2003). J.A. Duke, Handbook of Energy Crops, Purdue University Center for New Crops and Plant Products, West Lafayette, IN (2003); http://www.hort. purdue.edu./newcrop T.M. Kuo and H.W. Gardner (eds), Lipid Technology, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY (2002). F.D. Gunstone and R.J. Hamilton (eds), Oleochemical Manufacture and Applications, Sheffield Academic Press and CRC, Sheffield/Boca Raton, FL (2001). H. Zoebelein (ed.), Dictionary of Renewable Resources, 2nd edn, WileyVCH, Weinheim (2001). R.D. O’Brien, W. Farr and P.J. Wan (eds), Introduction to Fats and Oils Technology, 2nd edn, AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2000). W. Hamm and R.J. Hamilton, Edible Oil Processing, Sheffield Academic Press and CRC, Sheffield/Boca Raton, FL (1999). R.D. O’Brien, Fats and Oils: Formulating and Processing for Applications, Technomic Publ. Co., Lancaster, PA (1998). D.L. Klass, Biomass for Renewable Energy, Fuels and Chemicals, Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1998). J.L. Harwood (ed.), Plant Lipid Biosynthesis: Fundamentals and Agricultural Applications, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1998). J.L. Castner, S.L. Timme and J.A. Duke, A Field Guide to Medicinal and Useful Plants of the Upper Amazon, Feline Press, Gainsville, FL (1998).
102
Biodiesel science and technology
T. Clifford, Fundamentals of Supercritical Fluids, Oxford University Press, Oxford (1998). E.N. Frankel, Lipid Oxidation, The Oily Press, Dundee (1998). D.A. Fell, Understanding the Control of Metabolism, Portland Press, London (1997). J.P. Williams, M.U. Khan and N.W. Lem (eds), Physiology, Biochemistry and Molecular Biology of Plant Lipids, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht (1997). M.S. Verrall (ed.), Supercritical Fluid Extraction and Chromatography, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester (1996). M.A. McHugh and V.J. Krukonis, Supercritical Fluid Extraction – Principles and Practice, Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston, MA (1996). L.T. Taylor, Supercritical Fluid Extraction, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester (1996). J.C. Kader and O. Mazliak (eds), Plant Lipid Metabolism, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht (1995). D.S. Kimber and D.I. McGregor (eds), Brassica Oilseeds: Production and Utilization, CABI Publishing, Wallingford (1995). D.R. Erickson (ed.), Practical Handbook of Soybean Processing and Utilization, AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (1995). F.D. Gunstone, J.L. Harwood and F.B. Padley, The Lipid Handbook, 2nd edn, Chapman & Hall, London (1994). K.A. Larsson, Lipids: Molecular Organization, Physical Functions and Technical Applications, The Oily Press, Dundee (1994). H. Kigel and G. Galili (eds.), Seed Development and Germination, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY (1994). T.S. Moore Jr. (ed.), Lipid Metabolism in Plants, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (1993). F.C. Naughton (ed.), The Chemistry of Castor Oil and Its Derivatives and Their Applications, ICOA Technical Bulletin No. 2, ICOA, Westfield, NJ (1992). F.D. Gunstone and B.G. Herslöf, A Lipid Glossary, The Oily Press, Dundee (1992). A. Cherif, D.B. Miled-Daoud, B. Marzouk, A. Smaoui and M. Zarrouk (eds), Metabolism, Structure and Utilisation of Plant Lipids, Centre Pedagogique, Tunis (1992). T.J. Bruno and J.F. Ely (eds), Supercritical Fluid Technology: Reviews in Modern Theory and Applications, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (1991). P.J. Quinn and J.L. Harwood (eds), Plant Lipid Biochemistry, Structure and Utilization, Portland Press, London (1990). S. Facciola, Cornucopia – A Source Book of Edible Plants, Kampong Publications, Vista, CA (1990). B.A. Stout, The Handbook of Energy for World Agriculture, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1990).
Oleochemical sources
103
G.M. de Rougemont, A Field Guide to the Crops of Britain and Europe, Collins, London (1989). G. Röbbelen, R.K. Downey and A. Ashri (eds), Oil Crops of the World, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY (1989). P.A. Biacs, K. Gruiz and T. Kremmer (eds), Biological Role of Plant Lipids, Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest and Plenum Publishing, New York, NY (1989). C. Ratledge and S.G. Wilkinson (eds), Microbial Lipids, Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1989). G. Hoffman, The Chemistry and Technology of Edible Oils and Fats and Their High Fat Products, Academic Press, London (1989). C.W.S. Hartely, The Oil Palm, Longman Publishers, London (1988). R. Mansfeld, Verzeichnis landwirtschaftlicher und gärtnerischer Kulturpflanzen, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1986). E.S. Pattison (ed.), Fatty Acids and Their Industrial Application, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY (1986). J.M.L. Penninger, M. Radosz, M.A. McHugh and V.J. Krukonis (eds), Supercritical Fluid Technology, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1985). G. Kunkel, Plants for Human Consumption, Koeltz Scientific Book, Koenigstein (1984). P.A. Siegenthaler and W. Eichenberger (eds), Structure, Functions and Metabolism of Plant Lipids, Elsevier, Amsterdam (1984). P. Mazliak, P. Benveniste, C. Costes and R. Douce (eds), Biogenesis and Function of Plant Lipids, Elsevier/North-Holland, Amsterdam (1980). D.R. Erickson, E.H. Pryde, O.L. Brekke, T.L. Mounts and R.A. Falb, Handbook of Soy Oil Processing and Utilization, American Soybean Association and American Oil Chemistry Society, St. Louis, MO, and Champaign, IL (1980). J.D. Weete, Lipid Biochemistry of Fungi and Other Organisms, Plenum Press, New York, NY (1980). G. Usher, A Dictionary of Plants Used by Man, Constable & Co., London (1974). T.P. Hilditch and P.N. Williams, The Chemical Constitution of Natural Fats, Chapman & Hall, London (1964). J.C. Th. Uphof, Dictionary of Economic Plants, Hafner Publishing Co., New York, NY (1959).
3.8
References
[1] FAOSTAT, ProdStat: Crops, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome (2007). [2] R.C. da Silva and L.A. Gioielli, Physical properties of structured lipids from lard and soybean oil, Rev. Bras. Ciênc. Farm. 42 (2006) 223–35 (in Portuguese). [3] U. Ravnskov, The Cholesterol Myth Exposing the Fallacy that Saturated Fat and Cholesterol Cause Heart Disease, New Trends Publishing, Inc., Washington, DC (2000).
104
Biodiesel science and technology
[4] J.B. Ohlrogge and J. Browse, Lipid biosynthesis, Plant Cell 7 (1995) 957–70. [5] J.B. Ohlrogge, J.G. Jaworski and D. Post-Beitenmiller, De novo fatty acid biosynthesis, in Lipid Metabolism in Plants (T.S. Moore Jr., ed.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (1993), pp. 3–32. [6] A.J. Kinney, Genetic modification of the storage lipids of plants, Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 5 (1994) 144–51. [7] M. Miquel and J. Browse, Lipid biosynthesis in developing seeds, in Seed Development and Germination (J. Kigel and G. Galili, eds), Marcel Dekker, New York, NY (1994), pp. 169–93. [8] R. Töpfer, N. Martini and J. Schell, Modification of plant lipid synthesis, Science 268 (1995) 681–6. [9] T.P. Hilditch and P.N. Williams, The Chemical Constitution of Natural Fats, Chapman & Hall, London (1964). [10] R. Sambanthamurthi, K.-C. Oo and A.S.H. Ong, Lipid metabolism in oil palm (Elaeis guineensis and Elaeis oleifera) protoplasts, Plant Sci. 51 (1987) 97–103. [11] J.J. Salas, J. Sánchez, U.S. Ramli, A.M. Manaf, M. Williams and J.L. Harwood, Biochemistry of lipid metabolism in olive and other oil fruits, Progr. Lipid Res. 39 (2000) 151–80. [12] K. Dehesh, P. Edwards, J. Fillatti, M. Slabaugh and J. Byrne, KAS IV: A 3-ketoacylACP synthase from Cuphea sp. is a medium chain specific condensing enzyme, Plant J. 15 (1998) 383–90. [13] S. Stymne and A.K. Stobart, Triacylglycerol biosynthesis, Biochem. Plants 9 (1987) 175–214. [14] C. Stoll, W. Lühs, M. K. Zarhloul and W. Friedt, Genetic modification of saturated fatty acids in oilseed rape (Brassica napus), Eur. J. Lipid Sci. Technol. 107 (2005) 244–8. [15] K. Dehesh, P. Edwards, T. Hayes, A.M. Cranmer and J. Fillatti, Two novel thioesterases are key determinants of the bimodal distribution of acyl chain length of Cuphea palustris seed oil, Plant Physiol. 110 (1996) 203–10. [16] T. Voelker, Plant acyl-ACP thioesterases: chain-length determining enzymes in plant fatty acid biosynthesis, Genet. Engng. 18 (1996) 111–33. [17] J.L. Harwood, Recent advances in the biosynthesis of plant fatty acids, Biochem. Biophys. Acta 1301 (1996) 7–56. [18] F.D. Gunstone, J.L. Harwood and F.B. Padley, The Lipid Handbook, 2nd edn, Chapman & Hall, London (1994). [19] P.K. Stumpf, D.N. Kuhn, D.J. Murphy, M.R. Pollard, T.A. McKeon and J.J. MacCarthy, Oleic acid, the central substrate, Developm. Plant Biol. 6 (1980) 3–10. [20] W.E. Shine, M. Mancha and P.K. Stumpf, Fat metabolism in higher plants. Function of acyl thioesterases in the metabolism of acyl-coenzymes A and acyl-acyl carrier proteins, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 172 (1976) 110–16. [21] T.A. McKeon and P.K. Stumpf, Purification and characterization of stearoyl-ACP desaturase and the acyl-ACP thioesterase from maturing seeds of safflower, J. Biol. Chem. 257(20) (1982) 12141–7. [22] E. Heinz and P.G. Roughan, Similarities and differences in lipid metabolism of chloroplasts isolated from 18:3 and 16:3 plants, Plant Physiol. 72 (1983) 273–9. [23] I.K. Vijay and P.K. Stumpf, Fat metabolism in higher plants. XLVI. Nature of the substrate and product of oleyl coenzyme A desaturase from Carthamus tinctorius, J. Biol. Chem. 246 (1971) 2910–17.
Oleochemical sources
105
[24] J.L. Harwood and I.A. Gushina, The versatility of algae and their lipid metabolism, Biochem. 91 (2009) 679–84. [25] J.F. Toro-Vazquez, M.A. Charó-Alonso and F. Pérez-Briceño, Fatty acid composition and its relationship with physicochemical properties of pecan (Carya illinoensis) oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 76 (1999) 957–65. [26] E.P. Kennedy, Biosynthesis of complex lipids, Fed. Proc. Am. Soc. Exp. Biol. 20 (1961) 934–40. [27] T. Voelker and A.J. Kinney, Variations in the biosynthesis of seed-storage lipids, Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 52 (2001) 335–61. [28] H. Drexler, P. Spiekermann, A. Meyer, F. Domergue, T. Zank, P. Sperling, A. Abbadi and E. Heinz, Metabolic engineering of fatty acids for breeding of new oilseed crops: strategies, problems and first results, J. Plant Physiol. 160 (2003) 779–802. [29] J.L. Harwood, Plant acyl lipids: structure, distribution and analysis, in Biochemistry of Plants (P.K. Stumpf, ed.), Vol. 4, Academic Press, New York, NY (1980), pp. 2–58. [30] F.J. van de Loo, B.G. Fox and C. Somerville, Unusual fatty acids, in Lipid Metabolism in Plants (T.S. Moore Jr., ed.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL (1993), pp. 91–126. [31] E.J. Whittle, A.E. Tremblay, P.H. Buist and J. Shanklin, Revealing the catalytic potential of an acyl-ACP desaturase: tandem selective oxidation of saturated fatty acids, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 105 (2008) 14738–43. [32] K.M. Schmid and J.B. Ohlrogge, Lipid metabolism in plants, in Biochemistry of Lipids, Lipoproteins and Membranes, 5th edn (D.E. Vance and J.E. Vance, eds), Elsevier, Amsterdam (2008), Ch. 4. [33] C. Hou and J.-F. Shaw (eds), Biocatalysis and Biotechnology for Functional Foods and Industrial Products, AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2007). [34] J.M. Dyer, S. Stymne, A.G. Green and A.S. Carlsson, High-value oils from plants, Plant J. 54 (2008) 640–55. [35] M. Frentzen, Acyltransferases from basic science to modified seed oils, Fett/Lipid 100 (1998) 161–6. [36] T.A. Voelker, T.R. Hayes, A.M. Cranmer, J.C. Turner and H.M. Davies, Genetic engineering of a quantitative trait: metabolic and genetic parameters influencing the accumulation of laurate in rapeseed, Plant J. 9(2) (1996) 229–41. [37] F.B. Padley, F.D. Gunstone and J.L. Harwood, Occurrence and characteristics of oils and fats, in The Lipid Handbook (F.D. Gunstone, J.L. Harwood and F.B. Padley, eds), Chapman & Hall, London (1994), pp. 49–170. [38] J.N. Siedow, Plant lipoxygenase: structure and function, Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 42 (1991), pp. 145–88. [39] M.T. Morales, R. Aparicio and J.J. Rios, Dynamic headspace gas chromatographic method for determining volatiles in virgin olive oil, J. Chromatogr. 668 (1994) 455–62. [40] K.G. Berger, Production of palm oil from fruit, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 206–10. [41] J.M. Ortega-Nieto, La Poda del Olivo, Ministerio de Agricultura, Madrid (1962). [42] R.R. Leathers and A.H. Scragg, The effect of different temperatures on the growth, lipid content and fatty acid composition of Theobroma cacao cell suspension cultures, Plant Sci. 62 (1989) 217–27.
106
Biodiesel science and technology
[43] D.T. Canvin, The effect of temperature on the oil content and fatty acid composition of the oils from several oil seed crops, Can. J. Bot. 43(1) (1965) 63–9. [44] C. Hitchcock and B.W. Nichols, Plant Lipid Biochemistry, Academic Press, London (1971), pp. 152–4. [45] S.G. Silver, C.P. Rochester, D.G. Bishop and H.C. Harris, Unsaturated fatty acid synthesis during the development of isolated sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) seeds, J. Exp. Bot. 35(159) (1984) 1507–14. [46] H.C. Harris, J.R. McWilliam and W.K. Mason, Influence of temperature on oil content and composition of sunflower seed, Austr. J. Agric. Res. 29(6) (1978) 1203–12. [47] G.J. Seiler, Analysis of the relationships of environmental factors with seed oil and fatty acid concentrations of wild annual sunflower, Field Crops Res. 15 (1986) 57–72. [48] R.J. Weselake, D.C. Taylor, M.K. Pomeroy, S.L. Lawson and E.W. Underhill, Properties of diacylglycerol acyltransferase from microspore-derived embryos of Brassica napus, Phytochem. 30 (1991) 3533–8. [49] R. Sambanthamurthi, C.C. Let, O.K. Cheang, Y.K. Huat and P. Rajan, Chillinginduced lipid hydrolysis in the oil palm (Elaeis guineensis) mesocarp, J. Exp. Bot. 42 (1991) 1199–205. [50] K. Brahim, D.K. Stumpf, D.T. Ray and D.A. Dierig, Lesquerella fendleri seed oil content and composition: harvest date and plant population effects, Ind. Crops Prod. 5 (1996) 245–52. [51] E.M. Gaydou, Y. Lozano and J. Ratovohery, Triglyceride and fatty acid compositions in the mesocarp of Persea americana during fruit development, Phytochem. 26 (1987) 1595–7. [52] F. Ozdemir and A. Topuz, Changes in dry matter, oil content and fatty acids composition of avocado during harvesting time and post-harvesting ripening period, Food Chem. 86 (2004) 79–83. [53] Z. Flagella, T. Rotunno, E. Tarantino, R. Di Caterina and A. De Caro, Changes in seed yield and oil fatty acid composition of high oleic sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) hybrids in relation to the sowing date and the water regime, Eur. J. Agron. 17 (2002) 221–30. [54] T. Durrett, C. Benning and J. Ohlrogge, Plant triacylglycerols as feedstocks for the production of biofuels, Plant J. 54 (2008) 593–607. [55] J.B. Ohlrogge, Design of new plant products: engineering of fatty acid metabolism, Plant Physiol. 104 (1994) 821–6. [56] D.J. Murphy, Engineering oil production in rapeseed and other oil crops, Trends Biotechnol. 14 (1996) 206–13. [57] A.J. Kinney, Genetic engineering of oilseeds for desired traits, in Genetic Engineering (J.K. Setlow, ed.), Vol. 19, Plenum Press, New York, NY (1997), pp. 149–64. [58] M.E. Tat, P.S. Wang, J.H. Van Gerpen and T.E. Clemente, Exhaust emissions from an engine fueled with biodiesel from high-oleic soybeans, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 84 (2007) 865–9. [59] J.J. Fillatti, N.A. Bringe and K. Dehesh, Nucleic acid constructs and methods for producing altered seed oil compositions, US Pat. Appl. 2004/0107460 A1 (3 June 2004). [60] W.D. Hitz (E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co.), Nucleotide sequences of canola and soybean palmitoyl-ACP thioesterase genes and their use in the regulation of
Oleochemical sources
107
fatty acid content of the oils of soybean and canola plants, US Pat. 5,955,650 (21 Sept. 1999). [61] T. Buhr, S. Sato, F. Ebrahim, A.Q. Xing, Y. Zhou, M. Mathiesen, B. Schweiger, A. Kinney, P. Staswick and T. Clemente, Ribozyme termination of RNA transcripts down-regulate seed fatty acid genes in transgenic soybean, Plant J. 30 (2002) 155–63. [62] F.D. Gunstone, Oil seed crops with modified fatty acid composition, J. Oleo Sci. 50 (2001) 269–79. [63] R.F. Wilson, Genetic enhancement of vegetable oil feedstock supply and quality for biofuel applications, Proc. Intl. Congress on Biodiesel, Vienna (5–7 Nov. 2007). [64] L.H. Princen, Potential wealth in new crops: research and development, in Crop Resources (D.S. Seigler, ed.), Academic Press, New York, NY (1977), pp. 1–15. [65] M.M. Azam, A. Waris and N.M. Nahar, Prospects and potential of fatty acid methyl esters of some non-traditional seed oils for use as biodiesel in India, Biomass Bioen. 29 (2005) 293–302. [66] G.D.P.S. Augustus and G.J. Seiler, Promising oil producing seed species of Western Ghats (Tamil Nadu, India), Ind. Crops Prod. 13 (2001) 93–100. [67] Alternative Crops Research Program, Western Illinois University (http://www. wiu.edu/Alt/Crops/). [68] D.J. Murphy, The use of conventional and molecular genetics to produce new diversity in seed oil composition for the use of plant breeders – Progress, problems and future prospects, Euphytica 85 (1995) 433–40. [69] S.J. Knapp and J.M. Crane, Registration of high oil Cuphea germplasm VL186, Crop Sci. 40 (2000) 301. [70] S.J. Knapp and J.M. Crane, Registration of reduced seed shattering Cuphea germplasm PSR23, Crop Sci. 40 (2000) 299–300. [71] S.J. Knapp, Modifying the seed storage lipids of Cuphea: a source of mediumchain triglycerides, in Seed Oils for the Future (S.L. MacKenzie and D.C. Taylor, eds), AOCS Press, Champaign, IL (1992), pp. 142–54. [72] D.P. Geller, J.W. Goodrum and S.J. Knapp, Fuel properties of oil from genetically altered Cuphea viscosissima, Ind. Crops Prod. 9 (1999) 85–91. [73] S.A. Graham, Cuphea: a new plant source of medium-chain fatty acids, Crit. Revs. Food Sci. Nutr. 28 (1989) 139–73. [74] K.S. Rathore, G. Sunilkumar, L.M. Campbell, R.D. Stipanovic and L.S. Puckhaber, Enhancing the value of cottonseed as a source of feed and food by RNAi-mediated, selective and substantial reduction in seed-gossypol, Abstr. 236th ACS Natl. Mtg., Philadelphia, PA (17–21 Aug. 2008). [75] T.A. McKeon, Transgenic oils, in Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn (F. Shahidi, ed.), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ (2005), Vol. 3, pp. 154–74. [76] J.A. Robertson and F.E. Barton, Oil and water analysis of sunflower seed by nearinfrared reflectance spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 61(3) (1984) 543–7. [77] A. Fassio and D. Cozzolino, Non-destructive prediction of chemical composition in sunflower seeds by near infrared spectroscopy, Ind. Crops Prod. 20 (2004) 321–9. [78] T. Sato, Y. Takahata, T. Noda, T. Yanagisawa, T. Morishita and S. Sakai, Nondestructive determination of fatty acid composition of husked sunflower (Helianthus
108
Biodiesel science and technology
annua L.) seeds by near-infrared spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 72(10) (1992) 1177–83. [79] B. Pérez-Vich, L. Velasco and J.M. Fernández-Martínez, Determination of seed oil content and fatty acid composition in sunflower through the analysis of intact seeds, husked seeds, meal and oil by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75(5) (1998) 547–55. [80] L. Velasco, B. Pérez-Vich and J.M. Fernández-Martínez, Nondestructive screening for oleic and linoleic acid in single sunflower achenes by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, Crop Sci. 39 (1999) 219–22. [81] K.M. Bewig, A.D. Clarke, C. Roberts and N. Unklesbay, Discriminant analysis of vegetable oils by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 71(2) (1994) 195–200. [82] T. Sato, Application of principle-component analysis of near-infrared spectroscopic data of vegetable oils for their classification, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 71 (1994) 293–8. [83] L. Velasco, B. Pérez-Vich and J.M. Fernández-Martínez, A rapid and simple approach to identify different sunflower oil types by means of near-infrared spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75(12) (1998) 1883–8. [84] I.V. Kovalenko, G.R. Rippke and C.R. Hurburgh, Measurement of soybean fatty acids by near-infrared spectroscopy: linear and nonlinear calibration methods, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 83(5) (2006) 421–7. [85] L.Velasco, J.M. Fernández-Martínez and A. De Haro, Determination of the fatty acid composition of the oil in intact-seed mustard by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 74(12) (1997) 1595–602. [86] T. Sato, I. Uezono, T. Morishita and T. Tetsuka, Nondestructive estimation of fatty acid composition in seeds of Brassica napus L. by near-infrared spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75(12) (1998) 1877–81. [87] B.J. Siemens and J.K. Daun, Determination of the fatty acid composition of canola, flax, and solin by near-infrared spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 82(3) (2005) 153–7. [88] T. Sato, A.A. Maw and M. Katsuta, NIR reflectance spectroscopic analysis of the FA composition in sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) seeds, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 80(12) (2003) 1157–61. [89] Y.B. Che Man and M.H. Moh, Determination of free fatty acids in palm oil by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75(5) (1998) 557–62. [90] T. Baye and H.C. Becker, Analyzing seed weight, fatty acid composition, oil, and protein contents in Vernonia galamensis germplasm by near-infrared reflectance spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 81(7) (2004) 641–5. [91] B.E. Patrick and G.D. Jolliff, Nondestructive single-seed oil determination of meadowfoam by near-infrared transmission spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 74(3) (1997) 273–6. [92] V. Shiva, Protect or Plunder? Understanding Intellectual Property Rights, Zed Books, London and New York, NY (2002). [93] F. Shahidi (ed.), Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, 6 vols, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ (2005). [94] A.J. Dijkstra, Revisiting the formation of trans isomers during partial hydrogenation of triacylglycerol oils, Eur. J. Lipid Sci. Technol. 108 (2006) 249–64. [95] T. Wimmer (to Vogel & Noot Industrieanlagenbau GmbH), Process for the
Oleochemical sources
109
production of fatty acid esters of lower alcohols, US Pat. 5,399,731 (21 Mar. 1995). [96] C.-C. Chang and S.-W. Wan, China’s motor fuels from tung oil, I&EC 39 (1947) 1543–8. [97] K. Kobayashi, Formation of petroleum from fish oil. Origin of Japanese petroleum, J. Chem. Ind. (Japan) 24 (1921) 1–26. [98] K. Kobayashi and E. Yamaguchi, Artificial petroleum from fish oils, J. Chem. Ind. (Japan) 24 (1921) 1399–420. [99] A. Mailhe, Preparation of a petroleum from a vegetable oil, Compt. Rend. 173 (1921) 358–9. [100] B. Melis, Experiments on the transformation of vegetable oils and animal fats to light fuels, Atti Congr. Naz. Chim. Ind. (1924), pp. 238–40. [101] J.C. Morrell, G. Egloff and W.F. Faragher, Cracking of palm oil, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Ind. 51 (1932) 133–4T. [102] G. Egloff and J.C. Morrell, The cracking of cottonseed oil, I&EC 24 (1932) 1426–7. [103] V. Gomez Aranda, A Spanish contribution to the artificial production of hydrocarbons, Ion 2 (1942) 197–205. [104] K.D. Chapman, S. Austin-Brown, S.A. Sparace, A.J. Kinney, K.G. Ripp, I.L. Pirtle and R.M. Pirtle, Transgenic cotton plants with increased seed oleic acid content, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 78(9) (2001) 941–7. [105] R. Steiss, A. Schuster and W. Friedt, Development of linseed for industrial purposes via pedigree-selection and haploid-technique, Ind. Crops Prod. 7 (1998) 303–9. [106] A. Overeem, G.J.H. Buisman, J.T.P. Derksen, F.P. Cuperus, L. Molhoek, W. Grisnich and C. Goemans, Seed oils rich in linolenic acid as renewable feedstock for environment-friendly crosslinkers in powder coatings, Ind. Crops Prod. 10 (1999) 157–65. [107] C. Stenberg, M. Svensson and M. Johansson, A study of the drying of linseed oils with different fatty acid patterns using RTIR-spectroscopy and chemiluminescence (CL), Ind. Crops Prod. 21 (2005) 263–72. [108] A. Büchsenschütz-Nothdurft, A. Schuster and W. Friedt, Breeding for modified fatty acid composition via experimental mutagenesis in Camelina sativa (L.) Crtz, Ind. Crops Prod. 7 (1998) 291–5. [109] J.W. Burton, R.F. Wilson, C.A. Brim and R.W. Rinne, Registration of soybean germoplasm lines with modified fatty acid composition of seed oil, Crop Sci. 29 (1989) 1583. [110] R.C. Leffel, Registration of BARC-12, a low linolenic acid soybean germplasm line, Crop Sci. 34 (1994) 1426–7. [111] G. Hou, G.R. Ablett, K.P. Pauls and I. Rajcan, Environmental effects on fatty acid levels in soybean seed oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 83(9) (2006) 759–63. [112] J.C.P. Dribnenki, A.G. Green and G.N. Atlin, Linola 989 low linolenic acid flax, Can. J. Plant Sci. 76 (1996) 329–32. [113] M. Schmitt-Rozières, G. Vanot, V. Deyris and L.-C. Comeau, Borago officinalis oil: fatty acid fractionation by immobilized Candida rugosa lipase, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 76(5) (1999) 557–62. [114] A. Thomas, Fats and fatty oils, in Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, 7th edn (M. Bohnet et al., eds), Wiley-Verlag, Weinheim (2004), Vol. A10, pp. 173–243. [115] M.S. Puthli, V.K. Rathod and A.B. Pandit, Enzymatic hydrolysis of castor oil: process intensification studies, Biochem. Engng. J. 31 (2006) 31–41.
110
Biodiesel science and technology
[116] P. Cappillino, R. Kleiman and C. Botti, Composition of Chilean jojoba seeds, Ind. Crops Prod. 17 (2003) 177–82. [117] L. Canoira, R. Alcántara, M.J. García-Martínez and J. Carrasco, Biodiesel from jojoba oil-wax: transesterification with methanol and properties as a fuel, Biomass Bioen. 30 (2006) 76–81. [118] F.P. Cuperus, G. Boswinkel and J.T.P. Derksen, The processing of new oilseed crops: an economic evaluation, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 73 (1996) 1635–40. [119] J.A. Napier, The production of unusual fatty acids in transgenic plants, Ann. Rev. Plant Biol. 58 (2007) 295–319. [120] V. Spitzer, Screening analysis of unknown seed oils, Fett/Lipid 101 (1999) 2–19. [121] C.R. Smith Jr., Occurrence of unusual fatty acids in plants, Progr. Chem. Fats Other Lipids 11 (1971) 137, 139–77. [122] R.C. Badami and K.B. Patil, Structure and occurrence of unusual fatty acids in minor seed oils, Prog. Lipid Res. 19 (1980) 119–53. [123] J. Jaworski and E.B. Cahoon, Industrial oils from transgenic plants, Curr. Opin. Plant Biol. 6 (2003) 178–84. [124] M.C. Suh, D.J. Schultz and J.B. Ohlrogge, What limits production of unusual monoenoic fatty acids in transgenic plants?, Planta 215 (2002) 584–95. [125] D.C. Drown, K. Harper and E. Frame, Screening vegetable oil alcohol esters as fuel lubricity enhancers, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 78 (2001) 579–84. [126] J.W. Goodrum and D.P. Geller, Influence of fatty acid methyl esters from hydroxylated vegetable oils on diesel fuel lubricity. Bioresour. Technol. 96 (2005) 851–5. [127] C. Borch-Jensen, B. Jensen, K. Mathiasen and J. Mollerup, Analysis of seed oil from Ricinus communis and Dimorphoteca pluvialis by gas and supercritical fluid chromatography, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 74(3) (1997) 277–84. [128] W.B. Brown and E.H. Farmer, Unsaturated acids of natural oils: highly unsaturated acids from oiticica oil Licania rigida, Biochem. J. 29(3) (1935) 631–9. [129] A.L. Markman, L.N. Andrianova, B.K. Kruptsov, I.U. Yusupova, L.M. Yakushina and M. E. Konchalovskaya, Triacylglycerols of oiticica oil, Khim. Prirodn. Soed. (3) (1980) 316–19; J. Nat. Compds. 16 (1980) 229–32. [130] K.M. Hosamani and R.S. Pattanashettar, Mappia foetida seed oil: A rich source of oil and moderate source of novel 3-keto-octadec-cis-15–enoic acid and its possible industrial utilization, Ind. Crops Prod. 22 (2005) 135–9. [131] K.M. Hosamani, A.S. Patil and R.S. Pattanashettar, Acacia arabica varieties – Telia babul, Vediana and Cupressiformis seed oils: a moderate source of coronaric and cyclopropene fatty acids, Ind. Crops Prod. 15 (2002) 131–7. [132] J. Samuelsson and M. Johansson, A study of fatty acid methyl esters with epoxy or alkyne functionalities, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 78 (2001) 1191–6. [133] H. Guth and W. Grosch, Detection of furanoid fatty acids in soya-bean oil – cause for light-induced off-flavour, Fett Wissensch. Technol. 93(7) (1991) 249–55. [134] P.K. Raju and R. Reiser, Inhibition of fatty acyl desaturase by cyclopropene fatty acids, J. Biol. Chem. 242(3) (1967) 379–84. [135] P. Blaise, M. Farines and J Souliér, Identification of cyclopentenyl fatty acids by 1H and 13C nuclear magnetic resonance, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 74(6) (1997) 727–30. [136] K.M. Hosamani and R.S. Pattanashettar, Occurrence of unusual fatty acids in Ficus benghalensis seed oil, Ind. Crops Prod. 18 (2003) 139–43.
Oleochemical sources
111
[137] K.M. Hosamani and H.S. Ramesh, Unusual fatty acids from Crotolaria striata Syn. Crotolaria mucronata seed oil, Ind. Crops Prod. 14 (2001) 223–7. [138] K.M. Hosamani and R.M. Sattigeri, Industrial utilization of Rivea ornata seed oil: a moderate source of vernolic acid, Ind. Crops Prod. 12 (2000) 93–6. [139] K.M. Hosamani and H.S. Ramesh, Industrial utilization of Triumfetta pilosa, Roth seed oil: a moderate source of oil and cyclopropenoid fatty acids, Ind. Crops Prod. 17 (2003) 53–6. [140] K.M. Hosamani and R.M. Sattigeri, Analysis of Cassia marginata and Cassia corymbosa seed oils: an approach for the industrial utilization, Ind. Crops Prod. 17 (2002) 57–60. [141] K.M. Hosamani and S.S. Ganjihal, Unique occurrence of unusual fatty acids in Ochrocarpus africanus seed oil, Ind. Crops Prod. 18 (2003) 111–16. [142] K.M. Hosamani, S.S. Ganjihal and D.V. Chavadi, Alternanthera triandra seed oil: a moderate source of ricinoleic acid and its possible industrial utilisation, Ind. Crops Prod. 19 (2004) 133–6. [143] E. Fehling, S. Schönwiese, E. Klein, K. D. Mukherjee and N. Weber, Preparation of malvalic and sterculic acid methyl esters from Bombax munguba and Sterculia foetida seed oils, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75 (1998) 1757–60. [144] R. Schuch, F. Ahmad and K.D. Mukherjee, Composition of triacylglycerols containing cyclopropene fatty acids in seed lipids of Munguba (Bombax munguba Mart.), J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 63 (1986) 778. [145] E.M. Gaydou, J. Miralles and V. Rasoazanakolona, Analysis of conjugated octadecatrienoic acids in Momordica balsamina seed oil by GLC and carbon-13 NMR spectroscopy, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 64(6) (1987) 997–1000. [146] F. Norris, Extraction of fats and oils, in Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, Vol. 2 (D. Swern, ed.), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, NY (1982), pp. 175–251. [147] F. Shahidi (ed.), Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, Vol. 5, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ (2005). [148] T.G. Kemper, Oil extraction, in Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, Vol. 5 (F. Shahidi, ed.), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ (2005), pp. 57–98. [149] M.A. Williams, Recovery of oils and fats from oilseeds and fatty materials, in Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, Vol. 5 (F. Shahidi, ed.), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ (2005), pp. 99–189. [150] R. Guyomard, Study of the Use of a Twin-Screw Extruder in Pressing-Extrusion of Oleagineous Seeds, Ph.D. Thesis, Université Technologique de Compiègne (1994). [151] C. Dufaure, J. Leyris, L. Rigal and Z. Mouloungui, A twin-screw extruder for oil extraction. Part 1. Direct expression of oleic sunflower seeds, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 76(9) (1999) 1073–9. [152] T.P. Hensarling and T.J. Jacks, Solvent extraction of lipids from soybeans with acidic hexane, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 783. [153] M. Thobani and L.L. Diosady, Two-phase solvent extraction of canola, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 74(3) (1997) 207–14. [154] M.S. Kuk and R.J. Hron, Cottonseed extraction with a new solvent system: isohexane and alcohol mixture, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75(8) (1998) 927–30. [155] M.S. Kuk, R. Tetlow and M.K. Dowd, Cottonseed extraction with mixture of acetone and acetone and hexane, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 82(8) (2005) 609–12.
112
Biodiesel science and technology
[156] J.W. Kram, Do-it-yourself oil extraction, Biodiesel Mag. 5(2) (2008) 112–17. [157] K.J. Harrington and C. D’Arcy-Evans, Transesterification in situ of sunflower seed oil, I&EC Prod. Res. Dev. 24 (1985) 314–18. [158] M. Roche, C. Dufour, N. Mora and O. Dangles, Antioxidant activity of olive phenols: mechanistic investigation and characterization of oxidation products by mass spectrometry, Org. Biomol. Chem. 3(3) (2005) 423–30. [159] S.S.H. Rizvi, A.L. Benado, J.A. Zollweg and J.A. Daniëls, Supercritical fluid extraction: fundamental principles and modeling methods, Food Technol. 40 (1986) 55–65. [160] J.C.J. Bart, Additives in Polymers. Industrial Analysis and Applications, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester (2005), pp. 51–169. [161] F. Temelli and O. Gueclue-Uestuendag, Supercritical technologies for further processing of edible oils, in Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, Vol. 5 (F. Shahidi, ed.), John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, NJ (2005), pp. 397–432. [162] W.E. Artz, T. Kinyanjui and M. Cheryan, Deacidification of soybean oil using supercritical fluid and membrane technology, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 82 (2005) 803–8. [163] D. Firestone (ed.), Official Methods and Recommended Practices of the American Oil Chemists’ Society, 4th edn, AOCS, Champaign (1990), Method Am 3–96. [164] N.O. Maness, D. Chrz, T. Pierce and G.H. Brusewitz, Quantitative extraction of pecan oil from small samples with supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 72(6) (1995) 665–9. [165] J.W. King, S.L. Taylor, J.M. Snyder and R.L. Holliday, Total fatty acid analysis of vegetable oil soap stocks by supercritical fluid extraction/reaction, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75(10) (1998) 1291–5. [166] R. Oliveira, M.F. Rodrigues and M.G. Bernardo-Gil, Characterization and supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of walnut oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 79(3) (2002) 225–30. [167] B. Bozan and F. Temelli, Supercritical CO2 extraction of flaxseed, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 79(3) (2002) 231–5. [168] M. Aresta, A. Dibenedetto, M. Carone, T. Colonna and C. Fragale, Production of biodiesel from macroalgae by supercritical CO2 extraction and thermochemical liquefaction, Environm. Chem. Lett. 3 (2005) 136–9. [169] U. Salgin, A. Çalimli and B.Z. Uysal, Supercritical fluid extraction of jojoba oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 81(3) (2004) 293–6. [170] H.L.N. Lau, Y.M. Choo, A.N. Ma and C.H. Chuah, Quality of residual oil from palm-pressed mesocarp fiber (Elaeis guineensis) using supercritical CO2 with and without ethanol, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 83(10) (2006) 893–8. [171] D. Sparks, R. Hernandez, M. Zappi, D. Blackwell and T. Fleming, Extraction of rice bran oil using supercritical carbon dioxide and propane, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 83(10) (2006) 885–91. [172] P. Hubert and O. Vitzthum (to Hag A.-G.), Separation of caffeine from supercritical solutions, Germ. Offenl. DE 2,637,197 A1 (23 Feb. 1978). [173] P. Hubert and O. Vitzthum, Liquid extraction of hops, spices and tobacco with supercritical gases, Angew. Chem. Intl. Ed. 17 (1978) 710–15. [174] J.M. Levy, V. Danielson, R. Ravey and L. Dolata, Routine determination of fats in foods using supercritical fluid extraction, LC.GC 12(12) (1994) 920–3. [175] A. Sharma, S.K. Khare and M.N. Gupta, Three phase partitioning for extraction of oil from soybean, Bioresour. Technol. 85 (2002) 327–9.
Oleochemical sources
113
[176] S. Shah, A. Sharma and M.N. Gupta, Extraction of oil from Jatropha curcas L. seed kernels by enzyme assisted three phase partitioning, Ind. Crops Prod. 20 (2004) 275–9. [177] A. Sharma, S.K. Khare and M.N. Gupta, Enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction of rice bran oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 78(9) (2001) 949–51. [178] A. Sharma, S.K. Khare and M.N. Gupta, Enzyme-assisted aqueous extraction of peanut oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 79(3) (2002) 215–18. [179] R.I. Santamaría, C. Soto, M.E. Zúñiga, R. Chamy and A. López-Manguía, Enzymatic extraction of oil from Gevuina avellana, the Chilean hazelnut, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 80(1) (2003) 33–6. [180] P.J. Wan, D.R. Pakarinen and P.J. Wakelyn, Concerns for the determination of free fatty acid in cottonseed, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 75 (1998) 1321–4. [181] B. Matthäus and L. Brühl, Comparison of different methods for the determination of the oil content in oilseeds, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 78 (2001) 95–102. [182] S. Sathivel, W. Prinyawiwatkul, J.M. King, C.C. Grimm and S. Lloyd, Microwaveassisted catfish liver oil extraction and FA analysis, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 80 (2003) 15–20. [183] D.S. Ogunniyi, Castor oil: a vital industrial raw material, Bioresour. Technol. 97 (2006) 1086–91. [184] P.J. Wan and M.K. Dowd, Comparative study of the extraction and measurement of cottonseed free fatty acids, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 77(1) (2000) 23–7. [185] Valderrama Aceite de Oliva Virgen Extra, http://www.valderrama.es/. [186] H. Gürbüz, S. Sirkecioğlu, N. Yavasoğlu, G. Ahunbay and S. Türkay, Design of deacidification process of high acidity biodiesel feedstocks with liquid-liquid methanol extraction, Proc. Intl. Congr. on Biodiesel, Vienna (5–7 Nov. 2007). [187] M. Eisenmenger, N.T. Dunford, F. Eller, S. Taylor and J. Martinez, Pilot-scale supercritical carbon dioxide extraction and fractionation of wheat germ oil, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 83(10) (2006) 863–8.
4
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
Abstract: Although direct use of high-viscosity straight vegetable oils in standard modern diesel engines has been reported, the practice of using such non-regulated fuels is generally not recommended as short- and long-term problems do result. Engine compatibility for vegetable oils and animal fats may be enhanced chemically (by derivatisation, pyrolysis/gasification, ozonation) or physically (by dilution, blending, microemulsification). Fuel properties of oils and fats are outlined. Key words: Fuel properties, straight vegetable oils, low-viscosity formulations, co-solvent blending, microemulsions.
4.1
Introduction
The term biodiesel (now in use to denote monoalkyl esters of long-chain fatty acids derived from renewable feedstocks) was originally coined to describe unmodified vegetable oils that could substitute for diesel fuel (DF). Industrial use of biofuels started in the 1880s. Rudolf Diesel designed a prototype of the diesel engine, received a German patent (28 Feb. 1892), and demonstrated a workable engine in 1897 [1]. The first public demonstration by the French Otto Company of a small diesel engine operated on straight peanut (Arachis hypogaea) oil was seen at the World Fair in Paris of 1900 [2]. At that time the inventor, Diesel, held the view that the future of his engine (in contrast to those operating on steam) would be connected to fuel use derived from biomass, in particular plant oils (such as peanut and castor oil) and animal fats. Diesel’s compression-ignition engine used large injectors to prevent clogging by viscous, heavy fuels, such as unrefined vegetable oil. Because of the size of the engines, large warships were among the first users of Diesel’s technology. In the 1920s, technological changes made possible much smaller diesel engines, which required lower viscosity fuels. At the same time, the advent of relatively cheap medium-weight diesel fuels from fossil origin produced by the upcoming petroleum industry temporarily put a halt to the commercial viability of biofuels. Since about 1930 the diesel engine has been fine-tuned to run on the diesel fraction of crude oil, which consists mainly of saturated hydrocarbons. As a result, modern diesel engines do not run satisfactorily on a pure vegetable oil feedstock because of problems of high viscosity, deposit formation in the injection system and poor cold-start 114
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
115
problems. Pure rape oil can only be used in indirect injection (IDI) compression engines and very few diesel engines are now of this type. As petroleum has historically been in short supply, vegetable oils and their derivatives have been proposed as alternative diesel fuels during such emergency situations. The concept of using biomass-based fuels, specifically straight vegetable oils (SVOs) as diesel fuel alternatives, is particularly interesting and has been pursued on various occasions. Since 1930, the use of SVOs or their blends and derivatives, such as hydrocarbons obtained by thermal-catalytic cracking, and fatty acid esters (nowadays known as biodiesel) has been proposed. Edible refined soybean oil was used to power Japanese vessels in the Battle of Okinawa (1945). Coconut oil had also been used. During World War II various Indian vegetable fuel oils were also considered for diesel engines [3]. Pyrolysis of different triglycerides was also used for liquid fuel supply in different countries. For example, hydrocarbons were produced in China by a tung oil pyrolysis batch system and used as liquid fuels [4]; in another approach, vegetable oils were transesterified [5–7] and fatty acids were esterified [7]. Neat vegetable oils, such as babassu, coconut, castor seed and cottonseed were used in internal combustion engines in Brazil during the 1940s [8] or hydrocarbons produced by thermal-catalytic cracking [9]. Export of CSO, which was the main Brazilian vegetable oil at that time, was forbidden in order to force a drop in price and, thus, make possible its use as fuel in trains. Cottonseed oil was regarded as a strategic material as a substitute for imported diesel fuel [10]. Later, grapeseed oil was tested as a petroleum substitute. Quite recently, the Boungainville Revolutionary Army again used straight CNO. Since Diesel’s first experiments various other neat vegetable oils (mainly RSO, PMO, CNO) have been tested and used as diesel fuel alternatives [11–15]. All these fuels are non-toxic, renewable sources of energy, which do not contribute to the net global CO2 build-up. Direct use of renewable feedstocks, such as SVOs, in diesels may seem attractive (see Table 4.2), but there are risks. In fact, early tests already showed that using unmodified vegetable oils in diesel engines caused serious problems [16]. Vegetable oil sold for culinary purposes requires no stringent viscosity specification. Vehicles can be adapted to run on this sort of oil in unused or in waste form, though in the latter case filtration is necessary. Adaptations to make a modern diesel vehicle run reliably on SVO are fairly major. Vehicular use of SVO purchased for kitchen use is illegal in many countries, including the UK. Spent cooking oil from fast food outlets has been used to power vehicles with compression ignition engines. Some potential for serious usage of plant-derived waste cooking oils can be envisaged as the product is carbon neutral. R&D into the use of spent cooking oil as an automotive fuel is taking place in several countries (e.g. Greece and Spain).
116
4.2
Biodiesel science and technology
Fuel properties of oils and fats
Fuel-related properties of vegetable oils are listed in Table 4.1 [17]. The high kinematic viscosity (30–40 cSt at 311 K) is due to the high molecular mass (MW 600–900 Da), which greatly exceeds that of petrodiesel fuels. High viscosity is the main reason why neat vegetable oils have been largely abandoned as an alternative diesel oil. Viscosity increases with chain length (number of carbon atoms) and with increasing degree of saturation. Flash points are very high (above 473 K) and the volumetric heating values (39–40 MJ/kg) are low compared to diesel fuels (about 45 MJ/kg). Cetane numbers are also low whereas cloud and pour points are higher than those of diesel fuels. Vegetable oils can be used in diesel engines in a variety of forms. These comprise pure vegetable oil, blends with fossil diesel, methyl ester (FAME), FAME/petrodiesel blends and hydrotreated vegetable oil. Unfortunately, unmodified commercial vegetable oils are too viscous (10 to 20 times higher than No. 2 diesel fuels, up to 110 times for castor oil) to be compatible with modern direct-injection (DI) diesel fuel systems and engines. The injection, atomisation and combustion characteristics of vegetable oils as diesel fuels are significantly different from those of hydrocarbon-based diesel fuels. SVO-based fuel must be filtered to five microns and preheated to at least Table 4.1 Chemical and physical properties of vegetable oils and diesel Oil
Kinematic Cetane viscosity number at 310.8 K (mm2/s)
Babassu 30.3 Castora 297.0 Corn 34.9 Cottonseed 33.5 Crambe 53.6 Linseed 27.2 Palm 39.6 Peanut 39.6 Rapeseed 37.0 Safflower 31.3 H.O. Safflower 41.2 Sesame 35.5 Soybean 32.6 Sunflower 33.9 Tallowb 51.2 Diesel (No. 2 DF)a 2.7 a
38.0 – 37.6 41.8 44.6 34.6 42.0 41.8 37.6 41.3 49.1 40.2 37.9 37.1 – 47.0
Ref. [18]. Ref. [19]. Source: Ref. [17] unless otherwise stated. b
Heating value (MJ/kg)
Cloud point (K)
Pour Flash point (K) point (K)
– 39.5 39.5 39.5 40.5 39.3 – 39.8 39.7 39.5 39.5 39.3 39.6 39.6 40.0 45.3
293.0 – 271.9 274.7 283.0 274.7 304.0 285.8 269.1 291.3 261.8 269.1 269.1 280.2 – 258.0
– 241.3 233.0 258.0 261.8 258.0 – 266.3 241.3 266.3 252.4 263.6 260.8 258.0 – 240.0
423 533 550 507 547 514 540 544 519 533 566 536 527 547 474 325
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
117
333 K before use in diesel engines. The engine technology required for this purpose is cost-effective only for large diesel aggregates used in ships or heavy lorries. For use in automobiles and smaller trucks, at present chemically altered vegetable oils are more economical. Ideally, seed oil that is minimally processed could be considered directly as a replacement for diesel without chemical modification, thereby significantly improving the economic status of this alternative fuel source. Many publications have discussed the performance of vegetable oils as fuels or fuel sources. Use of vegetable oils and their derivatives as fuels in compression ignition engines has been reviewed [20]. In general, it is not practical to substitute 100% vegetable oil (B100) for diesel fuel (DF), but blends of up to 20% VO and 80% DF are feasible to maintain total power without any alterations to the engine. Diesel engines for the agricultural and transport sector have been powered with fuel extenders based on sunflower oil (SNO) [21–24], soybean oil (SBO) [22, 25–27], canola oil (CO) [28], rapeseed oil (RSO) [11, 28], semirefined rapeseed oil (SRO) [29], cottonseed oil (CSO) [21, 26], palm oil (PMO) [30, 31], peanut oil (PNO) [26], Chinese tallow seed oil [32] and other vegetable oils [33, 34], including frying oil. Altin et al. [35] used preheated unprocessed SNO, CSO, CRO, SBO, RSO and opium poppy oil and concluded that, compared to mineral diesel fuel, little power loss occurred with the seed oils, but particulate emissions from vegetable oils were higher, and NO2 emissions were lower. Bernardo et al. [36] evaluated the stability of cold pressed and filtered Camelina sativa (cameline) seed oil as a fuel at typical diesel engine fuel operating temperatures. Cameline oil has been used as a bio-fuel in admixture with diesel oil without esterification [37]. Nut-sedge (Cyperus esculentus L.) tuber oil has a great potential as a biofuel. The oil is characterised by a very high phosphorus content (73 ppm) – far exceeding EN 14214 limits – and a very low peroxide value (6 meq/kg). Nut-sedge oil has lower cloud point and pour point temperatures than other vegetable oils. The calculated cetane number of nut-sedge oil (41.2) compares favourably with SBO (37.9), RSO (37.6) and SNO (37.1). A diesel engine using pure yellow nut-sedge tuber oil as fuel was operated near its rated power [38]. A mixture of nut-sedge oil and diesel fuel performed better than pure oil. Straight castor oil provides an economical source of a lubricity enhancing diesel fuel additive [39]. Various fractions obtained by refining crude oil obtained from Mesua ferrea L. seeds have been proposed as fuels for gasoline (fraction of the oil b. 310–473 K), for diesel engines (b. 473–573 K) and for steam and electric power generation (b. 573–618 K) [40]. Pongamia oil is being used in Karnataka (South India) to run generators for irrigation [41]. After residual decantation and filtration, pure Jatropha oil makes a suitable diesel substitute for various stationary engines (such as irrigation pumps, mills and generators) that are commonly used in African settings. The engines
118
Biodiesel science and technology
require only minor modifications. Jatropha oil also functions as a replacement for kerosene (for oil lamps and cooking stoves). Introduction of a sustainable and renewable Jatropha Energy System (JES) as a flexible, decentralised and localised energy option empowers rural African communities (Fig. 4.1) [42]. These efforts show that all the vegetable oils tested can be used as fuel with some reservations. The most detrimental properties of these oils are their high viscosity, low volatility, poor atomisation and autoxidation. Direct use of vegetable oils in diesel engines as an alternative renewable fuel competing with petroleum diesel has several advantages (Table 4.2). Full combustion of a fuel requires there to be sufficient stoichiometric oxygen. The combustion efficiency of vegetable oils is higher than that of diesel fuel because of the structural oxygen content. The main disadvantages of Jatropha village system
Nursery
Fertiliser
Services
Soap
Plantations
Seedcake
Seeds
Biocycle
Expeller
Raw oil
Services
Residuals
Filter
Extra oil
Electricity
Oil
Milling
Generator
Engine
Mill
Power area
Dispensary
Other services
4.1 Flow diagram of the Jatropha Energy System (after ref. [42]).
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
119
Table 4.2 Main characteristics of straight vegetable oil as diesel fuel (after ref. [34]) Advantages: ∑ Liquid nature-portability ∑ Renewability ∑ High heat content ∑ Low sulphur content ∑ Low aromatic content ∑ Biodegradability Disadvantages: ∑ Higher viscosity (order of magnitude higher than petrofuel) ∑ Lower volatility ∑ Reactivity of unsaturated hydrocarbon chains ∑ Limited availability ∑ High cost (compared to petroleum-based diesel fuel) ∑ Non-regulated status
raw vegetable oils for diesel engines are higher viscosity, lower volatility, and reactivity of unsaturated hydrocarbon chains. Straight vegetable oils are non-tested and non-regulated fuels. Although diesel engines fueled with safflower oil were run for more than 700 h in Idaho, prolonged use of straight vegetable oils with their higher viscosity, lower cetane and volatility results in several short- and long-term problems with standard modern DI engines, including cold start, plugging of filters, knocking, poor fuel atomisation, excessive wear and lubricating oil thickening and gelling [43]. The build-up of carbon deposits is attributable to the large molecular size and resulting high viscosity of the medium- and long-chain triglycerides that constitute most commercial vegetable oils. Incomplete combustion, as evidenced by nozzle coking, engine deposits, ring sticking and contamination of crankcase lubricant may eventually result in significant decreases in engine performance, horse power and fuel economy, and may cause mechanical damage and increased exhaust emissions [44]. Use of unmodified oils or fats will also cause excessive fuel dilution of the engine oil (thus requiring frequent engine oil changes), which will eventually lead to a build-up of sludge in the engine oil and catastrophic engine failure [45]. Non-modified diesel engines can run for only up to a few hundred hours on plant oil without damage [46]. Using SVO as a fuel voids manufacturers’ warranties. Table 4.3 summarises the performance characteristics of vegetable oils as diesel fuels. The use of vegetable oil in diesel engines requires significant engine modification, including changing of piping and injector construction materials, otherwise engine running times are decreased, maintenance costs are increased due to higher wear, and the danger of engine failure is increased. Unlike biodiesel, in which the vegetable oil is adapted to the engine, the
120
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 4.3 Performance of vegetable oils as diesel fuels Fuel characteristics Consequence(s) Cetane number
Low cetane number implies long ignition delay Fuels with high autoignition temperatures are more likely to cause diesel knock
Distillation range
Presence of high-boiling components affects the degree of formation of solid combustion deposits Important to engine start- and warm-up
Combustion
Inefficient mixing of oil with air leads to incomplete combustion
Flash point
High flash point contributes to lower volatility characteristics
Viscosity
High viscosity interferes with injection process Poor fuel atomisation High viscosity/low volatility causes poor cold engine start-up and ignition delay
Cloud point, pour Fuel performance compromised under cold-temperature point, cold-filter conditions plugging point Carbon residue
Lower volatilisation characteristics lead to more deposit formation, carbonisation of injector strips, ring sticking and lubricating oil dilution and degradation
Oxidative stability Oxidative and thermal polymerisation cause deposition on injectors Long-term operation
Development of gumming, injector coking and ring sticking Serious engine deterioration
engine must be adapted to the fuel if pure vegetable oil is to be used. The use of native vegetable oils is only possible to a certain extent in conventional diesel engines. Only special engines or engines rebuilt for use with vegetable oil can use native vegetable oils in the long term without causing problems. Initially (until the 1940s) diesel engines were designed and developed to be dual-fuel engines, suitable for operation with vegetable oils. Diesel engines suitably modified according to the conditions of use and oil involved show a good performance when fueled with vegetable oils of different compositions and grades. In fact, cold pressed and filtered neat seed oils (in particular RSO) or even animal fats may be used in special or modified existing diesel engines [29, 47–50]. Their application as fuel substitutes for rugged indirect injection (IDI) diesel engines has been known since the first use of tractors [51], or for special engines like the Duotherm diesel engine designed by the German Elsbett Company [47]. The Elsbett engine is the only engine especially developed for successful use of vegetable oil. Engine conversion is recommended if using SVO. This conversion often includes installing a second fuel tank in order to be able to start and shut down on bio- or
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
121
petrodiesel. Vegetable oil engines cannot usually comply with the increasingly strict exhaust gas regulations and have restricted winter capability. Diesel engines have also been modified to run on pure pyrolysis oil (BCOs) [52, 53]. The direct use of BCOs requires significant adaptations of technology to fuel characteristics and poses considerable challenges due to low pH, low cetane index, high ash content, viscosity, and operating temperature limitations compared with light fuel oil. BCO/diesel emulsions are expected to significantly reduce the need for these adaptations.
4.3
Low-viscosity formulations
Fats contain more saturated fatty acids and cannot be used as fuel in a diesel engine in their original form. Viscosity is an important factor in predicting the performance of potential alternative diesel fuel sources. Standard fuel specification ASTM D 975 for petrodiesel may be used to evaluate the suitability of fuel compositions for compression-ignition engines. The kinematic viscosity limits (at 313 K) of petrodiesel fuel, namely 1.9–4.1 mm2/s for DF2 (ASTM D 975) and 2.0–4.5 mm2/s for the European petrodiesel standard (EN 590), are lower than those of biodiesel. Direct use of vegetable oils and/or oil blends is generally considered to be unsatisfactory and impractical for both direct injection and indirect type diesel engines because of their relatively high kinematic viscosities and low volatilities. Various methods have been considered to gain sufficient engine compatibility for vegetable oil and animal fat-derived high-quality diesel fuels, including derivatisation (transesterification, hydrotreating, ozonation), pyrolysis/gasification, dilution, blending and microemulsification. It was not until vegetable oils were derivatised that low-viscosity biofuel became available. The process of transesterification (see Section 1.3.1 and Chapter 7) removes glycerol from the triglycerides and replaces it with an alcohol. The process decreases the viscosity but maintains the cetane number and heating value. By transesterification the viscosity of vegetable oils is reduced from about 10–15 times that of No. 2 diesel fuel to about twice that of No. 2 diesel for methyl esters, which is low enough to be used as diesel fuel. Other physical properties of FAME, such as cloud point and pour point, are considerably higher than No. 2 diesel fuel, which limits their use as an alternative to diesel fuel. However, up to 30 vol% of methyl esters in diesel fuel does not significantly change the cold-flow properties of the fuel [54]. Among the aforementioned primary technologies that may bring the viscosity to within specification for existing engines, only dilution, blending, microemulsification and heating do not chemically alter the feedstock. Blending of vegetable oils with other fuels may bring the viscosity to within a specification range. For blending purposes, intersolubility of the
122
Biodiesel science and technology
components is very important but pertinent data are rarely available [55, 56]. Dilution of oils with solvents and microemulsification of vegetable oils with immiscible liquids lowers the viscosity and mitigates some engine performance problems such as injector coking and carbon deposits. Dilution of vegetable oils can be accomplished with such materials as diesel fuels, a solvent or ethanol. By blending diesel fuel with plant oil up to 25%, the resulting viscosity is low enough to avoid special adaptations to the engine [57]. However, the problems of carbonisation and resulting engine troubles cannot be completely avoided. Mixing rape oil with diesel overcomes some of the problems connected to the viscosity and gumming properties of the vegetable oil in its use in direct injection engines. Although sunflower oil is completely miscible with diesel oil, the low CN value (30) creates cold-start problems. Blends of SNO or HOSFO with diesel fuels could not be recommended for long-term use. There have been reports on the use of unmodified oils in diesel engines (e.g. a CNO fuel blend [58]), although in one case the oils were just heated at 353 K to reduce the viscosity [35]. Also 40–50% of Jatropha oil can be substituted for diesel without the need for engine modification [59]. Results for various DF2 mixtures with CNO, J. curcas, PNO, RSO, SFO grades and SNO were recently reviewed by Dunn [60]. Vegetable oil/petrodiesel blends are generally not suitable for long-term fueling of direct injection diesel engines. Direct use of crude palm oil (CPO) is feasible in the Elsbett engine. A problem is clogging of the filter by impurities and hence the need to warm the fuel before combustion. However, the use of processed liquid palm oil (PLPO) directly or in blends, can overcome this problem, even in normal diesel engines. Palm oil in diesel changes the fuel’s physicochemical properties, including viscosity, cloud point, cetane number, heat value and boiling point. Blending of palm oil products (PLPO, RBDPO) with conventional diesel was evaluated at MPOB, Kuala Lumpur, as possible diesel substitutes for industrial and vehicle fuels. Several palm oil products can be used directly, without chemical modification, in conventional diesel engines as biofuel for industrial and transport purposes, notably CPO/MFO (1:1) (pour point 267 K), as well as refined, bleached and deodorised (RBD) palm oil and palm olein, RBDPO (as B5; pour point 282 K) and RBDPOo (as B10; pour point 288 K) as diesel extenders at tropical temperatures [61]. Palm oil or palm oil blended with diesel (50:50) or fuel oil have been successfully tested and used as fuel for power stations and diesel passenger cars. There is currently no biodiesel standard for vegetable oil/diesel blends. Both the European EN 14214 and US ASTM D 6751 standards on biodiesel are intended for methyl esters and, consequently, are not suitable for evaluation of PLPO/PD (petroleum diesel) blends. The Malaysian Standard for Diesel Fuel (MS 123:1993) has been applied as a close reference standard [62]. B2 and B5 of the PLPO/PD blends meet all the requirements of MS 123:1993.
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
123
Various mixes of unesterified vegetable oil (CNO and PMO) blended with diesel oil or kerosene were introduced in recent years in Thailand under the name of ‘biodiesel’, even though most of them did not comply with the official standards for commercial use. Formulating hydrid diesel fuels by mixing with low molecular weight alcohols is another approach for reducing viscosity of vegetable oils. For that purpose the limited solubility of polar alcohols (except for scMeOH) in non-polar vegetable oils needs to be increased by addition of amphiphilic compounds. The formulation of hybrid diesel fuels by solubilisation (or equilibrium dispersion of an insoluble substance in a solvent under formation of a thermodynamically stable isotropic solution) of vegetable oil/shortchain alcohol mixtures through addition of amphiphilics is referred to as microemulsification [63]. Microemulsions (with droplet diameters ranging from 10 to 100 nm) can be made of vegetable oils with an ester and dispersant (co-solvent), or of vegetable oils, an alcohol and a surfactant, with or without diesel fuels, e.g. SBO, 95 wt% EtOH (E95) stabilised by n-BuOH [64] and 1.5 wt% H2O in triolein/2-octanol/MeOH [65]. Achievement of stable microemulsions at low temperature is difficult [66]. Dunn and Bagby [67] have described the low-temperature phase behaviour of solubilised SBO/ methanol mixtures. A microemulsion fuel of methanol with vegetable oils can perform nearly as well as diesel fuels. Blends can be formulated with cold-flow properties superior with respect to cloud point and comparable with respect to kinematic viscosity of methyl soyate (biodiesel). Similarly, various microemulsions of vegetable oils (e.g. SBO, SNO) with solvents such as lower alcohols (C1–C8) have been studied [68–72] as well as microemulsions of oil, diesel, water and a surfactant [73] to achieve better viscosities and spray patterns. Technology licensed to NGB (Baltimore, MD) enables production of a biofuel (diesel, heating oil) by emulsification of vegetable oils or animal fats, water and proprietary additives, with properties different from both biodiesel and SVO [74]. Scragg et al. [75] have proposed an emulsion of REE biodiesel/water/surfactant/microalgae (Chlorella vulgaris) (80:10:0.5:10) as a diesel fuel for industrial use despite the increased viscosity of the oil. However, not all engine performance problems could be solved using this fuel. The triglycerides present still lead to carbonisation. Hybrid diesel fuels may also be formulated by employing a co-solvent. Such formulations typically consist of vegetable oil/short-chain alcohol mixtures solubilised by a co-solvent. The co-solvent, consisting of a surfactant plus an amphiphilic compound, is added to solubilise otherwise nearly immiscible oil–alcohol mixtures into a single-layer (isotropic) solution. Co-solvent blending is a simple and flexible technology that reduces viscosity [64, 69]. Formulating vegetable oil/co-solvent blends requires no catalyst, consumes very little energy, and adapts readily to continuous processing. A problem
124
Biodiesel science and technology
is meeting the ASTM D 975 specification for minimum cetane number of 40. SBO/n-BuOH/E95 has a cetane number of only 25.1 [76]. Also the solubility of biodiesel fuel components in various fossil diesel fuel-alcohol-rapeseed oil alkyl ester systems was studied [56]. Whereas solubility of the pair RME-methanol is limited, solubility of fossil DF in RME and of RME in DF is not limited. Consequently, usage of DF-methanolRME mixtures for diesel fuels is not viable because of low solubility. Hybrid fuel formulations such as microemulsions or co-solvent blends are generally less expensive to prepare than biodiesel because of simple technology, merely consisting in mixing the components at room temperature. Several such formulations containing TGs in the absence of petrodiesel have been patented. Hybrid fuels formulated with TGs are susceptible to oxidative degradation. Hybrid diesel fuels formulated with short- or mediumchain alcohols also require special handling and storage considerations. The development of such alternative fuels from TGs is no longer actively being pursued. Most studies recommend against long-term use of vegetable oilbased hybrid diesel fuels [60]. If plant species were available that produce oil with high levels of shortand medium-chain triglycerides, transesterification before use as a diesel fuel substitute might be avoided. This would both lower the processing cost of the fuel and eliminate the production of the undesired glycerol by-product. Fuel properties (including heat capacity, viscosity, vapour pressure, surface tension and density) of tributyrin (C4:0), tricaproin (C6:0), tricaprylin (C8:0) and tricaprin (C10:0) indicate that these triglycerides are potential components in future diesel fuels derived from plant oils [77]. Because there are very few natural sources of these triglycerides, altering oil synthesis in plants may provide a method for increasing the SCT/MCT content. One problem with the direct use of such low molecular weight triacylglycerols is their poor cold-temperature flow properties. Cuphea oil tends to solidify. An interesting development is the genetic manipulation of Cuphea species (see Section 3.3). The viscosity of the mutant Cuphea oil falls between that of diesel fuel (DF2) and rapeseed oil. Fuel performance of the oil shows a marked improvement compared to that of unmodified commercial vegetable oils, approaching that of methyl esters [78]. Further work along these lines might result in development of a vegetable oil suitable as a neat biodiesel. Table 4.4 shows some of the considerable obstacles to straight vegetable oil biofuel technology. Future developments in engine construction may open new horizons for the use of native vegetable oils. However, because the market for users of SVO as a fuel is small (and limited anyway), there is no substantial economic incentive for engine manufacturers to pursue straight vegetable oils as a fuel. Use of SVO as a biofuel also requires setting of a standard for fuel quality and a quality assurance system in relation to product liability.
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
125
Table 4.4 Future development of vegetable oil biofuel technology Advantages: ∑ No need for chemical transformation (transesterification, hydrotreatment, cracking) ∑ Renewable fuel source ∑ Green product ∑ No undesired by-products (glycerol) Requirements: ∑ Genetic manipulation of plant species ∑ Development of vegetable oil engines (viscosity, combustion properties, etc.) ∑ Development of standard for fuel quality ∑ Need for a quality assurance (product liability) ∑ Environmental friendliness (need for meeting increasingly strict exhaust gas emissions)
4.4
Bibliography
M.J.T. Reaney, P.B. Hertz and W.W. McCalley, Industrial and nonedible products from oils and fats, in Bailey’s Industrial Oil and Fat Products, 6th edn, Vol. 6 (F. Shahidi, ed.), Wiley-Interscience, Hoboken, NJ (2005), pp. 223–52. Union of Concerned Scientists, The Diesel Dilemma – Diesel’s Role in the Race for Clean Cars, Cambridge, MA (2004). C.R. Ferguson and A.T. Kirkpatrick, Internal Combustion Engines: Applied Thermosciences, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, NY (2001). C. Song, C.S. Hsu and I. Mochida, Chemistry of Diesel Fuels, Taylor & Francis, New York, NY (2000). W.R. Nitske and C.M. Wilson, Rudolf Diesel, Pioneer of the Age of Power, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, OK (1965).
4.5
References
[1] R. Diesel, Arbeitsverfahren und Ausführungsart für Verbrenn ungskraftmaschinen, Imp. germ. Pat. 67, 207 (28 Feb. 1892); see also Deutsches Museum, www.deutschesmuseum.de/ausstell/meister/e_diesel.htm. [2] W.R. Nitske and C.M. Wilson, Rudolf Diesel, Pioneer of the Age of Power, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman, OK (1965). [3] D.H. Chowhury, S.N. Mukerji, J.S. Aggarwal and L.C. Verman, Indian vegetable fuel oils for diesel engines, Gas Oil Power 37 (1942) 80–5. [4] C.C. Chang and S.W. Wan, China’s motor fuels from tung oil, I&EC Res. 39 (1947) 1543–8. [5] G. Chavanne, Procédé de transformation d’huiles végétales en vue de leur utilisation comme carburants, Belg. Pat. 422,877 (1937); C.A. 32:43132 (1938). [6] G. Chavanne, Sur un mode d’utilization possible d’huile de palme à la fabrication d’un carburant lourd, Bull. Agric. Congo Belge 10 (1942) 52–8; C.A. 38:21839 (1944).
126
Biodiesel science and technology
[7] G.I. Keim (to Colgate-Palmolive-Peet Co.), Treating fats and fatty oils, US Pat. 2,383,601 (28 Aug. 1945); C.A. 40:4617 (1946). [8] G.S.C. Barros, A.P Silva, L.A. Ponchio, L.R.A. Alves, M. Osaki and M. Cenamo, Custo de produção de biodiesel no Brasil, Rev. Polit. Agríc. 15(3) (2006) 36–50. [9] R.B. Otto, Gasolina derivada dos oleos vegetais, Bol. Div. Inst. Óleos 3 (1945) 91–9; C.A. 41:6690 f (1947). [10] Anon., Brazil uses vegetable oil for diesel fuel, Chem. Metall. Engng. 50 (1943) 225. [11] C.L. Peterson, D.L. Auld and R.A. Korus, Winter rape oil fuel for diesel engines: recovery and utilization, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 1579–87. [12] H. Masjuki, Rapid test to measure performance, emissions and wear of a diesel engine with palm oil diesel, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 70 (1993) 1021–5. [13] T.W. Ryan III, L.G. Dodge and T.J. Callahan, The effects of vegetable oil properties on injection and combustion in two different diesel engines, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 61 (1984) 1610–19. [14] H.T.C. Machacon, Y. Matsumoto, C. Ohkawara, S. Shiga, T. Karasawa and H. Nakamura, The effect of coconut oil and diesel fuel blends on diesel engine performance and exhaust emissions, J. SAE Rev. 22 (2001) 349–55. [15] A.W. Baker and R.L. Sweigert, Comparison of various vegetable oils as fuels for compression-ignition engines, Proceedings 19th Oil & Gas Power Mtg. of the ASME, Cleveland, OH (21–24 May 1947), pp. 40–8; Gas Oil Power, Ann. Tech. Rev. (1947), pp. 338–9. [16] J. Walton, Gas and Oil Power, Whitehall Press, London (1938). [17] A. Srivastava and R. Prasad, Triglycerides-based diesel fuels, Renew. Sustain. En. Revs. 4 (2000) 111–33. [18] C.E. Goering, A.W. Schwab, M.J. Daugherty, E.H. Pryde and A.J. Healkin, Fuel properties of eleven vegetable oils, Trans. ASAE 25 (1982) 1472–7. [19] Y. Ali, M.A. Hanna and S.L. Cuppett, Fuel properties of tallow and soybean oil esters, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 72 (1995) 1557–64. [20] E.G. Shay, Diesel fuel from vegetable oils: status and opportunities, Biomass Bioen. 4 (1993) 227–42. [21] C.R. Engler and L.A. Johnson, Effects of processing and chemical characteristics of plant oils on performance of an indirect-injection diesel engine, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 1592–6. [22] M.L. Schlick, M.A. Hanna and J.L. Schinstock, Soybean and sunflower oil performances in a diesel engine, Trans. ASAE 31 (1988) 1345–9. [23] M. Ziejewski, H. Goettler and G.L. Pratt, Comparative analysis of the long-term performance of a diesel engine on vegetable oil based alternative fuels, SAE Tech. Paper Ser. 860301 (1986). [24] M. Ziejewski and K.R. Kaufman, Laboratory endurance test of a sunflower oil blend in a diesel engine, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 1567–73. [25] R.W. Pryor, M.A. Hanna, J.L. Schinstock and L.L. Bashford, Soybean oil fuel in a small diesel engine, Trans. ASAE 26 (1983) 333–7. [26] M.A. Mazed, J.D. Summer and D.G. Batchelder, Peanut, soybean, and cottonseed oil as diesel fuels, Trans. ASAE 28 (1985) 1375–7. [27] C. Adams, J.F. Peters, R.J. Rand, B.J. Schroer and M.C. Ziemke, Investigation of soybean oil as a diesel fuel extender: endurance tests II, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 1574–9. [28] R.C. Strayer, J.A. Blake and W.K. Craig, Canola and high erucic rapeseed oil
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
127
as substitutes for diesel fuel: preliminary tests, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 1587–92. [29] K. McDonnell, S. Ward, J.J. Leahy and P. McNulty, Properties of rapeseed oil for use as a diesel fuel extender, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 76 (1999) 539–43. [30] Y.M. Choo, A.N. Ma and Y. Basiron, Introduction and evaluation of palm oil methyl esters as diesel substitute, Elaeis Spec. Issue (1995), pp. 15–25. [31] A.J. Akor, W.J. Chanallor and N. Raubach, The potential of palm oil as motor fuel, Trans. ASAE 26 (1983) 23–8. [32] W.D. Samson, C.G. Vedrine and W.D. Robbins, Chinese tallow seed oil as a diesel fuel extender, Trans. ASAE 28 (1985) 1406–9. [33] C.L. Peterson, G.L. Wagner and D.L. Auld, Vegetable oil substitutes for diesel fuel, Trans. ASAE 26 (1983) 322–32. [34] E.H. Pryde, Vegetable oils as diesel fuels: overview, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 60 (1983) 1557–8. [35] R. Altin, S. Çetinkaya and H.S. Yücesu, The potential of using vegetable oil fuels as fuel for diesel engines, En. Conv. Managm. 42 (2001) 529–38. [36] A. Bernardo, R. Howard-Hildige, A. O’Connell, R. Nichol, J. Ryan, B. Rice, E. Roche and J.J. Leahy, Camelina oil as a fuel for diesel transport engines, Ind. Crops Prod. 17 (2003) 191–7. [37] J. Zubr, Oil-seed crop: Camelina sativa, Ind. Crops Prod. 6 (1997) 113–19. [38] L. Nan, Z.C. Liang, R.X. Wan and J.X. Ma, Use of yellow nut-sedge oil as a substitute for diesel fuel, ASAE Paper No. MCR 84-108, St. Joseph, MI (1984). [39] D.P. Geller and J.W. Goodrum, Effects of specific fatty acid methyl esters on diesel fuel lubricity, Fuel 83 (2004) 2351–6. [40] D. Konwer and K. Baruah, Refining of the crude oil obtained from Mesua ferrea L. seeds, Chem. Ind. (London) (1984) 413–14. [41] U. Shrinivasa, A viable substitute for diesel in rural India, Curr. Sci. 80 (2001) 1483–4. [42] G. Venturini Del Greco and L. Rademakers, The Jatropha energy system: an integrated approach to decentralized and sustainable energy production at the village level; http://www.isf.lilik.it/files/jatropha/jes.pdf. [43] R.A. Korus, T.L. Mousetis and L. Lloyd, Polymerization of vegetable oils, in Proceedings Intl. Conf. Plant and Vegetable Oils as Fuels, ASAE Special Publ. SP 4-82 (1982), pp. 218–23. [44] H.J. Harwood, Oleochemicals as a fuel: mechanical and economic feasibility, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 61 (1984) 315–24. [45] S. Howell, Working Position Paper by NBB in Non-Allowance of Unmodified Vegetable Oils or Animal Fats for Use in Diesel Engines, NBB, Jefferson City, MO (Feb. 2005). [46] G. Vellguth, Field test of DI-diesel tractor with methylester of rape oil as alternative fuel, in Proceedings Intl. Conf. Bioenergy (H. Egneus and A. Ellegard, eds), Elsevier, London (1984), Vol. IV: Bioenergy Utilisation, pp. 215–22. [47] K. Elsbett, L. Elsbett, G. Elsbett and M. Behrens, The duothermic combustion for direct injection diesel engines, SAE Tech. Paper Ser. 860310 (1986). [48] R. Howard-Hildige, S. Condon, J.J. Leahy and K.P. McDonnell, Emissions from two compression engined vehicles running on mineral and rapeseed oil based fuels, in Air Pollution III (H. Power, N. Moussiopoulos and C.A. Brebbia, eds), Computational Mechanics Publications, Southampton (1995), Vol. 2, pp. 381–5. [49] O.M.I. Nwafor and G. Rice, Performance of rapeseed oil blends in a diesel engine,
128
Biodiesel science and technology
Appl. En. 54 (1996) 345–54. [50] O.M.I. Nwafar, G. Rice and A.I. Ogbonna, Effect of advanced injection timing on the performance of rapeseed oil in diesel engines, Renew. En. 21 (2000) 433–44. [51] C. Meyer, R. Stern and J. C. Guibet, Esters from vegetable oils as substitutes for diesel fuels, in Proceedings VIII Intl. Symp. Alcohol Fuels, Tokyo (13–16 Nov. 1988), pp. 137–42. [52] S. Gros, Pyrolysis oil as diesel fuel, in Power Production from Biomass II, VTT Symposium 164, Espoo (1996), pp. 225–38. [53] Y. Iwamoto, K. Noma, O. Nakayama, T. Yamauchi and H. Ando, Development of gasoline direct injection engine, SAE Paper No. 970541 (1997). [54] R.O. Dunn and M.O. Bagby, Low-temperature properties of triglyceride-based diesel fuels: transesterified methyl esters and petroleum middle distillate/ester blends, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 72 (1995) 895–904. [55] H. Zhou, H. Lu and B. Liang, Solubility of multicomponent systems in the biodiesel production by transesterification of Jatropha curcas L. oil with methanol, J. Chem. Engng. Data 51 (2006) 1130–5. [56] V. Makareviciene, E. Sendzikiene and P. Janulis, Solubility of multicomponent biodiesel fuel systems, Bioresour. Technol. 96 (2005) 611–16. [57] K.J. Leifert, Zukunftsperspektiven der Erzeugung und Verwendung von Pflanzenöl als Motortreibstoff in der EU, Verlag Lang, Frankfurt/M (1996). [58] H.T.C. Machacon, S. Shiga, T. Karasawa and H. Nakamura, Performance and emission characteristics of a diesel engine fueled with coconut oil-diesel fuel blend, Biomass Bioen. 20 (2001) 63–9. [59] K. Pramanik, Properties and use of Jatropha curcas oil and diesel fuel blends in compression ignition engine, Renew. En. 28 (2003) 239–48. [60] R.O. Dunn, Other alternative diesel fuels from vegetable oils, in The Biodiesel Handbook (G. Knothe, J. Van Gerpen and J. Krahl, eds), AOCS Press, Urbana, IL (2005), pp. 241–63. [61] A.A. Azhar, F.S. Mohd and M.A. Awang, Performance of palm oil-based biodiesel fuels in a single cylinder direct injection engine, Palm Oil Dev. 42 (June 2005) 15–27. [62] S.F. Cheng, Y.M. Choo, C.L. Yung, A.N. Ma and Y. Basiron, Palm biodiesel: gearing towards Malaysian biodiesel standards, Palm Oil Dev. 42 (June 2005) 28–34. [63] A.W. Schwab, M.O. Bagby and B. Freedman, Preparation and properties of diesel fuels from vegetable oils, Fuel 66 (1987) 1372–8. [64] A.W. Schwab, H.C. Nielson, D.D. Brooks and E.H. Pryde, Triglyceride/aqueous ethanol/1-butanol microemulsions, J. Disp. Sci. Technol. 4 (1983) 1–17. [65] A.W. Schwab and E.H. Pryde, Triglyceride-methanol microemulsions, J. Disp. Sci. Technol. 6 (1985) 563–74. [66] M. Mittelbach, Herstellung von Fettsäuremethylestern und deren Verwendung als Dieselkraftstoff, Österr. Chem. Ztschr. 90 (1989) 147–50. [67] R.O. Dunn and M.O. Bagby, Low-temperature phase behavior of vegetable oil/ co-solvent blends as alternative diesel fuel, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 77 (2000) 1315–23. [68] C.E. Goering, R.N. Campion, A.W. Schwab and E.H. Pryde, Evaluation of soybean oil-aqueous ethanol microemulsions for diesel engines, in Proceedings Intl. Conf. Plant and Vegetable Oils as Fuels, ASAE Special Publ. SP 4–82 (1982), pp. 279–86. [69] C.E. Goering and B. Fry, Engine durability screening test of a diesel oil/soy oil/ alcohol microemulsion fuel, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 61 (1984) 1627–32. [70] Z. Ji, Method for producing microemulsified fuel, Faming Zhuanli Shenqing Gongkai
Vegetable oil formulations for utilisation as biofuels
129
Shuomingshu (2005), C.A. 144:131591 (2005). [71] M. Ziejewski, K.R. Kaufman, A.W. Schwab and E.H. Pryde, Diesel engine evaluation of a nonionic sunflower oil-aqueous ethanol microemulsion, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 61 (1984) 1620–6. [72] Z. Ji, Method for producing microemulsified fuel, Chin. Pat. 1,632,067 (29 June 2005). [73] T.N. de Castro Dantas, A.C. da Silva and A.A.D. Neto, New microemulsion systems using diesel and vegetable oils, Fuel 80 (2001) 75–81. [74] F. Petnucci and A. Festuccia, Biofuel composition and method of producing a biofuel, PCT Int. Publ. No. WO 2007/127059 A2 (8 Nov. 2007). [75] A.H. Scragg, J. Morrison and S.W. Shales, The use of a fuel containing Chlorella vulgaris in a diesel engine, Enzyme Microb. Technol. 33 (2003) 884–9. [76] C.E. Goering, A.W. Schwab, R.M. Campion and E.H. Pryde, Soyoil-ethanol microemulsions as diesel fuel, Trans. ASAE 26 (1983) 1602–4, 1607. [77] J.W. Goodrum and M.A. Eiteman, Physical properties of low molecular weight triglycerides for the development of biodiesel fuel models, Bioresour. Technol. 56 (1996) 55–60. [78] D.P. Geller, J.W. Goodrum and S.J. Knapp, Fuel properties of oil from genetically altered Cuphea viscosissima, Ind. Crops Prod. 9 (1999) 85–91.
5
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
Abstract: Globally dominating feedstocks for biodiesel production nowadays are mainly rapeseed, soybean, sunflower and palm oils; animal fats (tallow) and recycled frying oils are minor contributors. This chapter describes the main characteristics of the major and minor first-generation foodstocks for biodiesel production and the short- to medium-term prospects of secondgeneration, non-edible feedstocks (in particular Jatropha and algae) and various highly acidic, low-quality oils for the same purpose. Biodiesel outlooks are differing geographically as a result of the prevailing agronomic and climatic conditions. Important developments can be observed in various parts of the world. Key words: Biodiesel resources; main energy crops; first-generation foodstocks; non-edible oilseeds; second-generation feedstocks.
5.1
Introduction
Potential renewable raw materials for biodiesel production are edible and non-edible vegetable oils, animal fats and oils, recycled or waste oils, by-products of the edible oil and dairy industries, and other saturated and unsaturated fatty acids varying in carbon chain length and degree of unsaturation. Selection criteria of vegetable oils are: availability, cost, oil quality (composition) and product shelf-life. Unlike fossil reserves, different regions of the world have their own vegetable oil resources that could be exploited for biodiesel production. Oil crops dominating the early (1998) feedstock sources for biodiesel were rapeseed oil (RSO, 84%), sunflower seed oil (SNO, 13%), soybean oil (SBO, 1%), palm oil (PMO, 1%) and other oils (including Jatropha oil, beef tallow and recycled frying oils, 1%) [1, 2]. With increasing biodiesel production in the US, South America and Asia, the shares of SBO and PMO have increased rapidly. Table 5.1 shows the fatty acid profiles and other relevant chemical data in relation to biodiesel manufacture from common vegetable oil and animal fat raw materials. For fatty acid compositions of other (non)edible oils and fats, recycled and waste oils can be used as raw materials in biodiesel production (see also refs. [3, 4]). Quality indicators of raw materials comprise acid value, anisidine value, oil content, free fatty acid (FFA) content, moisture content, saponification value, unsaponifiable matter, P content, and the composition of fatty acids according to standard methods [5]. Unlike FFA content, which is a measure of free fatty acids present in a fat or oil, acid 130
Table 5.1 (a) Fatty acid profiles of common vegetable oils and animal fats (b) Other chemical properties of common vegetable oils and animal fats (a)
B. campestris B. carinataa Canola Cardoon Castorb Coconutc Coriander Corn (maize) Cottonseed Crambe Jatropha Karanja Kenaf Linseed Mahuad Olive African palm Palm kernele Palm oleine Palm stearin Peanut Poppy seed Pumpkin seed Rapeseed (LE)f
0.0
0.0
0.0
1.9–2.8
0.6–2.9 1.0–3.5
12.3–16.3 12.0–15.8 7.2–9.9
0.6–2.4 3.5–6.0 0.6–2.1 45.0–52.5 0.5–0.8
0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 14.0–21.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 41.5–53.2 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 16.0–21.0 0.1 0.5–2.0
2.4–3.1 4.0–5.6 11.0–14.0 0.9–1.4 6.0–11.3 3.8–5.4 10.0–12.0
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.1–1.5
1.0–2.0 2.4 3.0–3.6 0.9–1.0 1.5–4.2 0.4 1.6–4.5
9.7–17.0 60.0–75.0 25.0–30.0 2.6–3.7 4.0–8.7 74.9–76.3l 20.0–32.5
16.8–25.0 12.0–23.4 54.0–60.0 4.1–4.9 0.8–2.6 16.6–18.6 52.0–62.0
10.0–16.6 3.2–9.1 < 1.0 0.3–0.4 0.0 0.2 0.5–1.7
0.7 0.5–1.3 0.5 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.2–1.0
5.0–8.2 < 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.2–0.6
0.0 0.0 0.8 2.1 0.0 0.1 0.1–0.5
33.0–46.5 < 2.0 < 1.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.1–0.3
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.1–0.5
<2.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0.1–0.2 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.1–0.5
0.7–1.4 0.0 0.1–1.4 0.0 0.5 < 0.1 0.0 0.4–1.2 0.6–2.4
17.0–31.0 1.8–2.2 12.8–17.7 3.7–7.9 20.1 4.0–7.0 16.0–28.2 6.9–15.6 32.3–47.9
0.4–2.0 0.0 0.0–1.3 0.0 1.6 0.1 0.0 0.5–1.1 0.2–1.4
0.9–4.0 0.7–0.9 3.7–9.8 2.4–8.9 3.2 2.0–5.0 20.0–25.1 1.4–4.4 3.7–6.3
13.3–22.9 15.9–18.8 37.8–45.8 44.5–71.3 29.2 18.0–24.0 37.0–51.0 62.8–84.4 37.0–52.4
47.8–58.2 8.7–9.3 29.0–45.0 10.8–18.3 45.9 14.0–19.0 8.9–14.3 3.0–20.2 6.4–12.5
0.1–2.1 4.8–8.7 0.0–0.3 0.0 0.7 50.0–58.0 0.0 0.5–4.0 0.2–0.6
0.2–1.3 1.0–2.0 0.1–0.3 0.0 0.5 0.1 0.0–3.3 0.1–0.6 0.1–1.0
0.1–0.5 0.0–4.7 0.0 0.0 0.2 0.3–0.4 0.3–0.4 0.2–0.4 0.1–0.4
0.1–0.6 0.8–2.0 0.2 0.0 0.3 0.2 0.1–0.2 0.1–0.2 < 0.2
0.1–0.3 56.2–62.5 0.0 0.0 0.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0.1 0.7–1.1 0.0 1.1–3.5 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.4 0.0
0.0 1.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0.2
1.3–8.0
8.7–21.0
0.5–3.5
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.2
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.1–0.6 0.1–0.5
0.0–0.6 0.4 1.0 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0
5.1–13.0 42.4–55.0 12.0–19.0 3.0–11.4 0.0 0.0
0.1–0.5 0.1–0.5
0.5–1.5 1.0–2.0
38.0–44.3 0.2–0.6 3.5–5.0 48.0–74.1 0.2 3.9–6.0
37.9–46.0 9.0–13.5 15.5–36.0 3.0–10.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 < 0.1 0.1
8.0–12.6 1.4 6.0–12.0 0.2 11.8–12.0 0.0
1.0–4.5 1.0–2.3 6.6–6.9
41.0–56.0 26.0–31.9 0.9 15.6–22.0 60.0–76.0 0.1–0.6 33.7 46.5 0.2–1.9
0.8–4.2 0.6–2.6 1.5–5.4 0.0 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.5 0.0 0.1 0.0
0.5–2.5 0.0 0.0
1.0 0.0 0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0–0.5
3.0–5.7
0.8–1.5
55.0–64.4 20.0–26.0 8.2–12.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
1.0–2.0 0.5
0.5–2.0
131
Fatty acid profilek, % by weight ——————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————— £ 10 12:0 14:0 16:0 16:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:0 20:1 22:0 22:1 24:0 24:1
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
Oil and fat source
Fatty acid profilek, % by weight ————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————— £ 10 12:0 14:0 16:0 16:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:0 20:1 22:0 22:1 24:0 24:1
Rice bran 0.0 0.0 0.3–1.0 12.0–22.1 0.2–0.4 0.8–3.0 38.9–50.0 29.4–35.2 0.4–1.1 0.5–1.2 Safflower 0.0 0.0 0.0–0.1 5.2–9.0 0.0 1.0–3.0 10.0–16.2 76.3–82.0 0.1–0.4 0.0 Safflower 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.8 0.0 2.0 77.4–79.0 13.0–13.8 0.5 0.6 (HO)g Sesame 0.0 0.0 0.0 7.8–13.0 0.1 3.7–7.0 36.8–53.0 35.0–53.0 0.3 0.4–0.6 Soybean 0.0 0.1 0.1–0.4 7.0–12.7 0.1–1.0 1.4–5.9 11.5–27.2 51.5–63.1 2.9–12.1 0.3–4.0 Soybean 0.0 0.0 0.0 5.4 0.0 4.1 81.3 3.8 5.3 0.0 (HO) Soybean 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.3–11.1 0.0 3.5–5.0 43.7–55.0 24.0–35.5 < 3.1 0.6 (MO) Soybean 0.0 0.0 0.0 17.2 0.0 4.4 15.7 55.6 7.1 0.0 soapstock Sunflower 0.0 0.1 0.1–0.2 2.0–9.0 0.3 1.6–6.5 14.0–39.4 48.3–74.0 0.2–0.7 0.1–1.2 Sunflower 0.0 0.0 0.4–0.8 4.0–5.5 0.1 2.1–5.0 43.1–71.8 18.7–45.3 0.1–0.7 0.2–2.9 (MO)h Sunflower 0.0 0.0 0.1 2.6–5.9 0.1 2.8–6.2 75.0–90.7 2.1–17.0 0.1–0.3 0.2–0.5 (HO)i Tung 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.0–3.0 0.0 1.0–3.0 4.0–9.0 8.0–10.0 78.0 0.0 –89.0m Jojoba 0.0 0.0 0.0 1.1–1.9 0.1–0.3 < 0.1 10.1–12.2 0.2 0.1 0.1–0.4 oil–waxj Beef tallow 0.0 0.1–0.7 2.0–8.0 23.0–38.0 0.0–4.7 14.0–29.0 34.9–50.0 1.0–5.0 0.5 0.1 Brown 0.0 0.0 1.7 22.8 3.1 12.5 42.4 12.1 0.8 0.0 grease Lard 0.0 0.1 1.4–2.3 17.3–30.0 1.9–3.0 12.0–20.0 42.5–50.0 7.0–13.0 0.4–1.0 0.3 Poultry fat 0.0 0.0 0.0–0.5 22.2–23.0 8.4 5.1–5.4 42.3 17.0–19.3 1.0 0.0 White 0.0 0.0 0.0 23.3 3.5 11.0 47.1 11.0 1.0 0.0 grease Yellow 0.0 0.0 2.4 23.2 3.8 13.0 44.3 7.0 0.7 0.0 grease
0.0 0.0 0.0
< 1.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.4 0.0 0.0
<1.0 0.0 0.0
0.2 0.1 0.0 0.1–0.4 0.1–0.8 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.0
0.1 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0
0.9
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.4 0.3–1.5 0.3 0.2–0.3 0.6–6.8 0.0
0.5 0.3–0.4
0.0 0.0
0.1–0.5 0.5–2.0 0.3
0.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
63.5– 0.5 12.7–18.9 0.0 73.9 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0.9– 1.9 0.0 0.0
1.5 0.0 1.0–2.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0 0.0 0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Biodiesel science and technology
Oil and fat source
132
Table 5.1 Continued
a
Ethiopian mustard. Contains 87–88% of ricinoleic acid. Contains < 4% FFAs. d Contains about 19% FFAs. e Fractionated product from palm oil. f Zero–zero. g High–oleic safflower. h Mid–oleic sunflower, NuSun. i High–oleic sunflower. j Contains about 59% of fatty acid esters and 41% of fatty alcohols. k Acids: Caproic, caprylic, capric (< 10); Lauric(12:0); Myristic (14:0); Palmitic (16:0); Palmitoleic (16:1); Stearic (18:0); Oleic (18:1); Linoleic (18:2); Linolenic (18:3); Arachidic (20:0); Gadoleic (20:1); Behenic (22:0); Erucic (22:1); Lignoceric (24:0); Methyl 15 – tetracosenoate (24:1). l Petroselinic acid (68.8%) + oleic acid (7.5%). m Linolenic acid (C18:3) 1–3 wt%; a-eleostearic acid (C18–3c) 77–86 wt%. b c
Feedstocks for biodiesel production 133
134
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.1 Continued (b) Phosl Peroxm Iodine ppm value number
SFAn %
MUFAn PUFAn % %
B. campestris 1052 0.8–0.98 92–130 B. carinataa Canola 883 0.15 18 100–127 Cardoon 879 118–125 921 < 2.0 82–88 Castorb 638 0.30 6–17 Coconutc Coriander Corn (maize) 871 0.11 7 18.4 109–140 Cottonseed 858 0.07 8 64.8 90–117 Crambe 0.36 12 26.5 85–93 Jatropha 0.1–0.35 < 10 92–110 Karanja Kenaf Linseed 873 170–211 55–70 Mahuad Olive 868 0.5–0.8 53.0 78–94 African palm 847 6.9 51–58 0.28 12–19.7 Palm kernele 50–52 Palm oleine Palm stearin < 48 Peanut 0.20 9 82.7 73–107 Poppy seed < 0.2 < 5.0 140–158 Pumpkin seed < 0.1 < 0.1 1–3 30.2 96–121 Rapeseed (LE)f Rice bran Safflower 126–150 80–100 Safflower (HO)g Sesame 82–120 Soybean 0.1 < 1 44.5 121–143 Soybean (HO) 90.0 Soybean (MO) 107.0 Soybean soapstock Sunflower 883 0.15–0.6 15 2.9–10.7 118–141 882 94–122 Sunflower (MO)h 78–90 Sunflower (HO)i Tung 160–175 0.32 0.4 81–89 Jojoba oil–waxj Beef tallow 15.4 35–48 Brown grease Lard 55–71 Poultry fat 3.7 75–85 White grease Yellow grease 8.0 2 90
8.0 5.0 7.0 16.0 2.7 92.0 5.5 15.0 29.0 6.5 22.0 15.8 24.5 10.0 44.5 14.0 47.0 84.5 45.0 68.0 19.0 11.0 19.4 5.5 20.0 8.0 7.0 15.0 16.0 9.5 17.5 21.6
70.0 20.0 69.0 26.0 92.5o 6.0 76.5 26.0 19.0 78.5 41.0 66.6 30.5 20.0 44.5 71.0 44.0 15.0 43.0 26.0 51.0 18.0 33.8 62.0 44.5 13.0 78.0 43.0 21.0 81.5 43.5 15.7
22.0 75.0 24.0 58.0 4.8 2.0 18.0 59.0 52.0 15.0 37.0 16.7 45.0 70.0 11.0 15.0 9.0 0.5 12.0 6.0 30.0 71.0 46.8 32.5 35.5 79.0 15.0 42.0 63.0 9.0 39.0 62.7
11.5 14.0 10.0 4.0 2.3 55.0 39.0 40.0 28.2 36.5 40.0
27.0 53.5 81.0 6.0 97.5 42.5 48.0 49.5 52.3 51.0 51.0
61.5 32.5 9.0 90.0 0.2 2.5 13.0 10.5 19.5 12.5 9.0
Oil and fat source
a–j
Mean MW (g/mol)
Acidk value
Cf. Table 5.1(a). Acid values are mg KOH necessary to neutralise FFA in 1 g of oil sample. l Phosphatide (gum) content varies in direct proportion to phosphorus value. m Peroxide values are meq. peroxide per 1000 g of oil sample, which oxidise KI under test conditions. n Average values. o Including ricinoleic acid (12-hydroxyoleic acid). k
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
135
value is a measure of total acidity of the lipid, involving contributions from all the constituent fatty acids that make up the glyceride molecule. The fatty acids are the most important constituents of the raw material and the acid profile largely determines the properties and uses of the oil. The fatty acid composition gives the degree of (un)saturation of the product. In palm and coconut oil and beef tallow the saturated fatty acid component accounts for some 50% or more of the total fatty acids.
5.2
Global oilseed and oil production
Worldwide, 1 billion tons of diesel fuel are consumed annually. The total feedstocks available for biodiesel production do not exceed some 12% of diesel fuel use [6], unless oil yields and oilseed production are increased. Worldwide oil crop production amounted to 662 Mt in 2005 (Table 5.2), with a European production of 31 Mt (Table 5.3) or 8.5 Mt of vegetable oil (corresponding to 7% of world production). Recent estimates (1 Aug. 2007) of the total global production of three major oilseed plants (soybean, rapeseed, sunflower; sum) amount to (235.0, 47.2, 29.8; 312.0 MMT), (221.0, 50.8, 29.4; 301.2 MMT) and (231.0, 52.1, 29.6; 312.7 MMT) for 2006/07, 2007/08 and 2008/09, respectively [7]. In 2008/09 worldwide consumption of the major oilseeds is expected to be just under the expected production. Soybeans, wheat and corn compete for acres: the US has recently witnessed extensive switching of plantings from soybeans to corn for ethanol production (sec Section 14.6.3). Oil fruits (such as palm, olive, argan and avocado) represent an alternative source of oil to oilseeds and, moreover, they have the advantages of a higher oil yield per hectare and lower oil extraction costs. Tables 5.4–5.6 show some global production and consumption figures of vegetable oils and fats with growth forecast until 2020. Estimated total production in 2020 is 194 Mt, 68% being on account of PMO, SBO, RSO and SNO. In the past five years (2002–07) the world vegetable oil production rose by 31 Mt, mainly on account of palm (+11 Mt), canola and sunflower (+7 Mt each) and soya (+ 6 Mt). With growth by about 5.2 Mt/yr since 1997 the global edible oil production is now estimated as 112.0 Mt for the major four oils (SBO, PMO, SNO, RSO) and 127.1 Mt (including also CSO, PNO, PKO, CNO) by 2007/08 [7]. World production of the main vegetable oils and animal fats (17 commodities) amounted to 153 Mt (2006/07). Production of palm oil is increasing most rapidly, from a modest 7.9% share in 1980 to 19.0% by 2000, with highest growth figures until 2020, thus classifying it as the main oil crop. Rapeseed oil is now available in greater quantities than sunflower oil. About 75% of edible vegetable oils is extracted from the endosperm of oilseeds, like soybean and oilseed rape, whereas the remaining 25% is produced from the pericarp of oil fruits, such as oil palm, olive and avocado. The global production of oilseeds is expanding with advances in
136
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.2 Worldwide crop production in 2005. Crops are listed in order of production volumes Oilcrop
World production (kton)
Top 3 producers (% of total)
Soybean Oil palm fruit Coconut Rape/mustard Cottonseed Groundnut Oil palm Sunflower Olive Palm kernel Sesame Linseed Oilseeds variousa Castor Tallow tree Safflower Sheanut Melon Tung nut Kapok fruit Poppy seed Hempseed Jojoba
209 532 173 261 55 037 46 572 41 132 36 492 32 814 30 674 14 512 8771 3321 2711 1892 1394 870 773 693 587 516 393 60 32 0.4
USA, Brazil, Argentina (81.8%) Malaysia, Indonesia, Nigeria (85.8%) Indonesia, Philippines, India (73.2%) China, Canada, Germany (53.1%) China, USA, India (63.6%) China, India, Nigeria (66.0%)
Total
662 039
Russia, Ukraine, Argentina (46.7%) Italy, Spain, Greece (69.1%) China, India, Myanmar (58.9%) Canada, China, USA (72.4%) India, China, Brazil (94.3%) China India (n.g.), USA, Mexico Nigera, Cameroon, Sudan (76.5%) China, Paraguay, Argentina (99.0%) Czech Republic, Turkey, France (82.3%) China, France, Chile (96.6%)
a
Includes: Beech nut, Fagus sylvatica; Candle nut, Aleurites moluccana; Crabwood, Carapa guineensis; Croton seed, Croton tiglium; Mowrah buttertree, Bassia latifolia; Nigerseed, Guizotia abyssinica; Oiticica, Licania rigida; Perilla seed, Perilla frutescens; Physic nut, Jatropha curcas; Sal fat, Shorea robusta; Karanja, Pongamia glabra; Black palm nut, Astrocaryum spp. Source: FAOSTAT data (2006).
technology and expansion in acreage. However, if RSO and SBO producing countries could achieve production levels similar to those using most advanced farming practices, some 23 Mt of additional vegetable oil could be generated without taking new acres into production. World demand for vegetable oils has been expanding at about 6 Mt/yr (4 Mt/yr for edible oils and 2 Mt/yr for biofuel), albeit most recently at a lower pace. About 80% of the whole range of oils and fats is now being used as human food, 6% for animal feed and 14% provides the basis of the oleochemical industry (in the widest sense: soaps, detergents, toiletries, cosmetics, surfactants, emulsifiers, perfumes, solvents and biofuels). At present the world’s largest sources of vegetable oils are palm oil (31.0%), soybean oil (29.2%), rapeseed oil/canola (14.6%) and sunflower oil (8.5%). There is not enough of such oils to supply the world’s total oil needs. Consequently, there is a limited availability of surplus oil and fat resources.
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
137
Table 5.3 Oil crops under cultivation in Europe 2005 Oil crop
EU25 (kton)
% World production
Rape/mustard Olive Sunflower Soybean Cottonseed Oilseeds variousa Linseed Poppy seed Melon Hempseed Groundnuts Sesame Safflower
15 019 10 354 3898 921 765 212 179 41 5 5 4 2 0.7
32.7% 71.4% 12.7% 0.4% 1.9% 11.2% 6.6% 68.0% 0.9% 15.1% 0.1% 0.1% 0.1%
Total
31 407
a
See Table 5.2. Source: FAOSTAT data (2006).
Table 5.4 Global production of vegetable oils (2006/07) Source Bio–oil Mt
Source Bio–oil
Mt
Palm Soybean Rapeseed Sunflower Peanut
Cottonseed Palm kernel Coconut Olive Total
4.70 4.48 3.26 2.85 120.53
37.37 35.19 17.64 10.18 4.86
Source: USDA.
5.3
Resources for biodiesel production
There are more than 350 oil-bearing plants identified (with thousands of sub-species) that could be used to grow a new crop of fuel every year. The productivity of perennials is higher, they avoid erosion and can also be cultivated in mountain areas. Some species can be harvested more than once a year. Many oleaginous plant species produce more oil in tropical climates and conditions. The fuel potentialities of many vegetable oils (including castor, grapeseed, maize, camelina, pumpkinseed, beechnut, rapeseed, lupin, pea, poppyseed, peanut, hemp, linseed, chestnut, sunflower seed, palm, olive, soybean, cottonseed, shea butter) were considered as early as 1939 [8]. A shift from annual energy crops, which need to be replanted and harvested every year, to perennial crops (e.g. palm, Jatropha) is observed. Raw materials for modern biodiesel production were outlined recently [9]. Table 5.7 shows a selection of suitable biodiesel feedstocks, at present mainly RSO, SNO, SBO and PMO. New sources are HOSNO, rapeseed varieties
138
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.5 Vegetable oil production, consumption and imports for top consuming markets (2003/04) Country Total oil productiona (kton)
Total oil Total oil consumption imports (kton) (kton)
Brazil 12 118 (SBO, CSO) 6886 244 P.R. China 11 959 (RSO, SBO, SFO, CSO, PNO) 18 964 7141 EU25 11 268 (RSO, SFO, OO) 15 474 5622 India 6835 (CNO, PNO, CSO, SBO, 11 258 4515 RSO, SFO) Indonesia 13 791 (PMO, CNO, PKO) 4861 82 Malaysia 15 118 (PMO, PKO) 3286 1101 Pakistan 643 (CSO) 1939 1347 Russian 1729 (SFO) 2254 654 Federation USA 8768 (SBO) 10 029 1910 World 101 696 100 337 37 268
(PMO, SBO) (PMO, SFO) (PMO, SBO)
(PMO, SBO) (PMO, SBO) (RSO, PMO) (PMO, SBO, SFO, RSO)
a
Production is oil processed from domestic and/or imported oilseeds. Animal fats are not included. Source: Official Statistics, USDA.
(HO, LL) and linola (LL). RSO(00) and HOSNO are currently considered to be the best candidates to substitute for conventional petrol-based lubricating oils. Promising non-food sources are Jatropha, algae, castor beans, camelina, karanja, acrocomia palm, babassu, buriti and dendê. The hope is that nonfood oils will be available in the future in sufficiently large, cost-effective volumes. Generally, factors such as geography, climate and economics determine which vegetable oil has the highest potential use in biodiesel fuel. Raw materials considered for biodiesel production are country/region specific, e.g. EU: RSO, SNO; US: SBO, CSO; Canada: CO; Nicaragua: Jatropha curcas, PMO; Japan: recycled VOs; India, P.R. China: Jatropha curcas; South-East Asia: PMO, RBO; Philippines: CNO. In fact, the specification of oil quality used for biodiesel varies between the US (soydiesel) and Europe (rapediesel) (see also Chapter 12). Whereas the US still concentrates on ‘soydiesel’ (from 90% of biodiesel virgin oil feedstock in 2001 to 45% soy, 39% multi-feedstock, 3% animal fats/soy, 3% animal fats, 4% canola and 6% other in 2007), US biodiesel production could be further diversified to include rapeseed, yellow mustard, corn, sunflower, peanut, coconut, Jatropha, cooking oil and yellow grease. The contribution of used frying oil to the total necessary biodiesel production is small (even in the US) and limited by the use of virgin oil for cooking. Waste vegetable oils (WVOs) discarded by Japanese restaurants, food manufacturing industries and general households amount to 400 kt/yr and constitute a valuable resource. Moreover,
Table 5.6 World oils and fats production (Mt) Year
1980
1990
2000
2010(f)
2020(f)
Palm Soybean Rapeseed Sunflower World
4.59 (7.9%) 13.42 (23.1%) 3.48 (6.0%) 4.98 (8.6%) 58.04
11.03 (13.7%) 16.14 (20.0%) 8.18 (10.1%) 7.80 (9.6%) 80.77
21.73 (19.0%) 25.48 (22.3%) 14.24 (12.4%) 9.63 (8.4%) 114.51
35.10 (22.9%) 37.50 (24.5%) 20.70 (13.5%) 10.98 (7.1%) 153.30
49.42 (25.4%) 41.39 (21.3%) 25.15 (12.9%) 17.49 (9.0%) 194.43
Source: Malaysian Palm Oil Board (2001). f = forecast.
% Growth 2000–20 4.1 2.4 2.8 3.0 2.7
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
Production
139
140
Biodiesel science and technology Table 5.7 Selection of suitable biodiesel feedstocks Vegetable oil crop Top ten oilseeds
Other oil crops New varieties
Soybean Cottonseed Groundnut Sunflower Rapeseed Sesame Oil palm Coconut Linseed Castor
Camelina HOa Sunflower Hemp HOa Rapeseed Olive LLb Rapeseed Jatropha HEAc Rapeseed Corn
Animal fats and used oils Tallow Lard Poultry fats Rendered fats Used frying oil
a
high oleic. low linolenic. c high erucic acid. b
Table 5.8 Global biodiesel market prospects (2010) Germany Europe USA
3.30 Mt 13.90 14.90
Sources: Eurostat/AUS Consultants/DOE/ETA.
environmental pollution due to WVOs such as oil used in cooking tempura is a social problem in Japan. The major bulk of biodiesel is currently made from rapeseed oil in Europe. Only a small fraction of the world’s oilseed resources (Table 5.2) would be expected to be available for industrial uses such as biodiesel. An estimated 10% of PMO could be allocated for the biofuel project without destabilising the international palm oil market. The present potential diesel engine fuel requirements far outstrip the ability of current vegetable oil production. This calls for cultivation of non-food crops for energy on set-aside land (EU agricultural policy). EU biodiesel production figures are shown in Fig. 1.6 and Table 14.31. Production in 2006 (4.9 Mt) increased by 54% as compared to 2005 (3.2 Mt), which followed a record growth of 65% over 2004. Installed EU27 production capacity (as of July 2007) exceeds 10.3 Mt, compared with 6.2 Mt in July 2006. European biodiesel production in 2006 required an acreage of 3.5 Mha (average yield/ha 1.4 t biodiesel). For biodiesel market prospects worldwide, see Table 5.8 and refs. [10, 11]. The availability and cost of all VOs are extremely critical for the industry. In fact, resources for biodiesel production strongly depend on pollination. While some commodity crops are wind-pollinated (e.g. corn and soybeans), most other biodiesel feedstocks (including oil palm, rapeseed/canola, sunflower
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
141
and cotton) are dependent on pollinators, mainly insects such as wild native bees or honeybees. In this context, it is not without concern that pollinators are currently endangered, for example, through colony collapse disorder (CCD) [12]. Foodstuff oils, such as soybean, sunflower and lauric oils, are traditionally quite expensive. Figure 5.1 shows price fluctuations of various vegetable oil commodities. Annual supplies of nine major vegetable oils (PMO, SBO, RSO, SNO, CSO, PNO, OO, CNO and PKO) have increased each year at a rate of 5–6 Mt (1998–2007) to 6.7 Mt more recently (2002–07). This rise has been used increasingly for non-food purposes, in particular during this period. However, as food demands increase by about 4 Mt/yr, whereas oleochemical use and use in animal feed grows at about 0.5 Mt/yr, severe price rises have resulted. Indonesia, Malaysia and other PMO producing countries (such as Nigeria) are categorised as high-yield low-cost producers, making PMO the world’s most cost-effective vegetable oil. Oil palm is also the highest oil-yielding crop among all VOs (see Table 6.1). As shown in Table 5.9, Indonesia is the world’s lowest cost producer of PMO with a production cost of US$165/t in 2003, with Argentina and Brazil the soybean oil champions (US$228/t). 800 Crude palm oil Soybean oil Sunflower oil Rapeseed oil
700
US$/t
600
500
400
300
200 1980
1985
1990 Year
1995
2000
5.1 Annual average prices of selected vegetable oils (North-west European market, 1980–2000) (Sources: Malaysian Palm Oil Board (2002); www.mpob.gov.my and Oil World (2002); www.oilworld.biz).
142
RSO
SBO
SNO
PMO
CNO
Australia Canadaa Poland Germany P.R. China UK France India
Argentina Brazil Paraguay USA P.R. China India Italy
Argentina Ukraine Russia France USA Spain
Indonesia Papua NG Malaysia Colombia Nigeria
Indonesia Philippines
a
Canola oil.
222.60 249.30 322.40 400.60 407.70 409.80 415.80 500.10
227.60 228.30 398.50 459.90 493.30 681.20 687.40
285.00 292.20 389.00 440.40 511.60 674.50
165.20 215.80 239.40 292.80 n.g.
328.10 430.20
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.9 Main world producers of vegetable oils and cost/t (US$, 2003) (after ref. 13)
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
143
Crops grown in tropical areas are cheaper than those grown in temperate areas. In general, Europe’s rapeseed industry is less competitive than all PMO producers and the aforementioned low-cost high-yield SBO suppliers. Nevertheless, with the incentives provided by their governments, it is still cheaper for Europe to produce its own RSO than to import it. For global and regional production figures of the main vegetable oils, see ref. [13]. Oleaginous crops used for industry are cheaper than those for human consumption (typical 2003 prices for rapeseed: non-food 7210–235/t; food 7225–257/t), some of which are in short supply, such as sesame (Sesamum indicum, Pedaliaceae) seed and safflower oils, and consequently highly priced. Production costs for biodiesel fuels may be reduced by using a variety of non-edible oils, such as cardoon or artichoke (Cynara cardunculus L.) oil [14], castor (Ricinus communis) oil [15], crambe (Crambe abyssinica) oil [16], physic nut (Jatropha curcas) oil [17, 18] and other vegetable oils of Indian origin [19, 20] (see Section 5.9). An upper-limit global biodiesel production potential of 45 Mt from 119 countries was estimated in October, 2007, of which 41.5 Mt could be produced profitably at today’s import prices [21]. The world’s top five palm and soybean oil producers (Malaysia, Indonesia, Argentina, USA and Brazil) are expected to account for 65% of global biodiesel production. Optimistic views foresee an upper-limit total potential biodiesel volume of 530 Mt through agricultural yield increases. This 12-fold increase is spread over many crops, but is mainly attributed to the tropical oilseeds palm and coconut, whose current yields are much below their well-managed yields. Even after a conservative increase in annual oil demand for food purposes of 165 Mt by 2015, some 365 Mt of biodiesel could then be produced [21]. However, agricultural intensification associated with boosting yields favours the practice of clear-cutting and can introduce additional problems including pressure on fresh water supplies from irrigation, nitrogen fertiliser run-off, and soil degradation. Plants transpire about 200 kg of water per kg of dry plant matter produced. Table 11.1 lists the critical success factors to ensure an industrially stable biodiesel feedstock.
5.4
Main biodiesel crops
5.4.1 Brassica oilseeds The Brassica oleracea family includes rapeseed, broccoli, Chinese cabbage, cauliflower, mustard, radish, kale, isis, camelina and turnip. Brassica oilseeds are one of the few edible oil crops that can be cultivated in the temperate zones of the world, at higher elevations and as winter crops. Both summer and winter species of brassicas are available, allowing cultivation in climatically different regions.
144
Biodiesel science and technology
Rapeseed (Brassica napus L. ssp. oleifera) oil with its high content of monounsaturated oleic acid (ca. 60%) and low levels of saturated (ca. 5.5%) and polyunsaturated acids (32.5%) is considered as being the ideal raw material for biodiesel (rapeseed methyl ether, RME) because of its combustion characteristics, oxidative stability and temperature. Rapeseed is the third most important source of vegetable oil in the world (Tables 5.4 and 5.10). Europe (EU25) is world’s key producer of rapeseed with a total rape planted area in 2007 of nearly 4.2 Mha, highly supported through the Common Agricultural Policy. Of the 11.42 Mt rapeseed grown in EU15 (1999–2000) 2.69 Mt came from set-aside land. Although the EU is a large producer of rapeseed (canola) oil, production (8.1 MMT forecast in 2008–09, up from 7.6 MMT in 2007–08 and 6.5 MMT in 2006–07) is not enough to cater for the growing demand (including biodiesel capacity growth). In 2004–05 already approximately one-third of the EU rapeseed crop was used by the non-food sector. Estimates of the amounts of oils and fats required to meet the EU goals (5.75% of biofuels by 2010) indicate that 85% of EU rapeseed crop would then be required for biodiesel production, necessitating imports. While alternative oils may be used, they give rise to some physical problems, such as poor flow (as in case of palm oil). A restriction of the potential quantities results from the requirement of crop rotation of the rapeseed plant. It can only be cultivated economically and for ecological reasons every third or fourth year. In contrast with grain or maize, rapeseed is not self-sustaining and monocultures are therefore impossible. Moreover, it should be remembered that it took some 50 years to triple the rapeseed oil crop yield. In 2006, rapeseed was grown on about 1.5 Mha of land in Germany, or 11% of the total agricultural land area; this is considered the maximum ecologically achievable cultivation potential. Approximately 7 Mha was used to grow crops for food. As Brassica species are strong emitters of ozone layer depleting alkane halides, oilseed rape cultivation can be questioned on environmental grounds [22]. The price of canola oil (Europe, pmt) has been rising steadily from a low Table 5.10 Geographic spread of rapeseed production (1999/2000) (after ref. [23]) Country
Crop (Mt)
Oil (Mt)
EU15 P.R. China Canada India Eastern Europe Australia Rest of the world World total
11.42 10.00 8.80 4.90 2.74 2.46 1.78 42.10
3.90 4.60 1.26 1.78 0.67 1.00 1.21 14.42
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
145
of US$359 in 1999–2000 to US$770 (2005–06 on average) and US$1577 more recently (June 2008). Several forms of plants included in the genus Brassica and Crambe are cultivated for the oil. Brassica oilseeds include such crops as B. napus L. (the most common rapeseed cultivated in continental Europe) and B. rapa L. or Rubsen oil (two primary species of rapeseed), B. carinata or Crambe abyssinica (Ethiopian mustard or colewart), and B. campestris (from rutabaga, or Swedish turnip) [24]. In fact, rutabagas are not oilseed plants (which produce oil in seeds) despite being in the same species as rapeseed and canola. Genetically modified rutabaga (preventing starch production, promoting oil biosynthesis) is being considered as a potential oil source [25]. Brassica juncea L. (mustard) is the common name for multiple species in the Brassica genus. Yellow mustard, referred to as white mustard (Sinapis alba L.) in Europe, is a spring-seeded crop that grows best in cool areas (< 302 K). As it is a different genus, it will not cross-pollinate with Brassicas. Yellow mustard seed is relatively small, about 100 000 seeds/lb. It does not have as high oil content as the other commonly known Indian mustard, referred to interchangeably in commerce as brown or oriental mustard. The oil is high in long-chain fatty acids, so biodiesel made from mustard would have properties different from biodiesel from most other oilseeds. High glucosinolate content renders yellow mustard unsuitable as food oil and animal feed. High-erucic rapeseed oils (HERO; erucic acid content > 45% detrimental to food quality) constitute the classic source of erucic acid and are important vegetable oils for oleochemical and lubricating purposes (e.g. slip oil in plastic bags) [26, 27]. Winter hardy rapeseed (B. napus L. and B. rapa L.) were characterised for oil, erucic acid and glucosinolate contents for use in breeding programmes to develop commercial production of rapeseed [28]. The erucic acid content was higher in rapa (32.6%) than the napus accessions (26.1%) with a small difference in the mean oil content in the seeds. Although rapeseed (colza oil or coleseed) used to contain high levels of erucic acid and glucosinolates, nowadays most rapeseed cultivars – developed by classical breeding methods – belong to the so-called ‘zero’ (0) and ‘double zero’ (00) varieties with reduced levels of both erucic acid (<2%) and glucosinolates (<30 mmol/g), also referred to as edible rapeseed or Canola (CANadian Oil Low Acid), in accordance with FDA standards. Canola (Brassica napus L.) is not a botanical term, but one used to describe compositional qualities. From an agronomic standpoint, canola offers the advantage of being both a spring and a winter crop. Canola rotates nicely with wheat. Whereas industrial rapeseed traditionally refers to any HERO variety, the low-erucic (LE) acid high-oleic varieties (with some 60% C18:1) are of interest to the food industry in view of their high nutritional qualities and a low level of saturated fat. In the US and Canada, canola and rapeseed
146
Biodiesel science and technology
are distinct crops, carefully kept apart with adequate buffer distances. Strict segregation of Brassica varieties is necessary in view of observed crosspollination between industrial rapeseed (now mainly localised in Eastern European countries) and canola. Since the break-up of the Eastern bloc, industrial rapeseed has yielded to canola because industrial rapeseed cannot be sold in EU countries for edible purposes. Erucic acid containing rapeseed varieties are now considered specialty crops in Europe and Canada. China, Russia and India, however, still use high-erucic acid rapeseed oil for human consumption. Since commodity low-erucic rapeseed is now widely available with supplies beyond that needed for food purposes, and the availability of HERO has greatly been diminished, low-erucic RSO (canola) is now the source of oil for some non-food applications and the primary component of biodiesel in Europe. Roughly 60% of rapeseed oil production finds non-food applications. With its low SFA and high MUFA contents biodiesel obtained from 00-rapeseed shows both good stability and winter operability. However, contrasting results have been reported concerning engine performance and carbon deposits of rapeseed diesel in comparison to fossil diesel [29]. Canola is a type of rapeseed that was first developed in the 1970s [30] Canadian plant breeders developed canola explicitly for the nutritional advantages compared to industrial rapeseed. Canola varieties of napus and juncea have similar compositional characteristics but different crop or agronomic qualities. Canola grows on most soil types but requires good drainage. Canola may be grown no more than two in every five years on the same plot of land. Canola is cultivated on some 15.5 M acres of Canadian farmland compared to 1 M acres in the US. Canadian farmers are expected to grow more than 14 MMT of canola by 2015 (as compared to 10 MMT in 2007) [31]. The yield increase is due to adoption of hybrids, better agronomic management and improved genetics. Canola yield could improve by as much as 35% by 2015 from the present level of about 30 bushels per acre. Higher-yielding canola varieties are increasing grower profits. Almost all the Canadian canola crop is used for human consumption, with less than 5% going to biodiesel. Despite a large canola oil output in Canada, the use of canola biodiesel as a total fuel replacement is not practical. To satisfy current highway transport diesel fuel requirements, it would require 11 times the acreage of all the canola grown in Canada to replace the diesel fuel used (5 Bgy). North Dakota and Minnesota are the main US canola producers. Canola’s share of the US biodiesel market was boosted in 2007 when ADM’s 85 MMgy biodiesel plant came on stream alongside its canola crushing facility at Velva, ND. ADM’s Velva facility crushed 1.3 MMt (1.4 Mt) of canola in 2006, which was twice the amount grown in the US in 2006. Imports from Canada were needed. Development of a high-fat content (25–40%), low cost (US$0.10/lb), non-food grade mustard seed is under way. The key development that makes
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
147
industrial mustard so promising is that the defatted meal (after the oil is removed) can be used as an organic pesticide without further processing. The inedible mustard can be grown in rotation with dry-land wheat production without irrigation. Blue Sun Biodiesel (Fort Collins, CO) has started development of an industrial mustard seed industry to support the biodiesel industry. The Ethiopian mustard (B. carinata) oilseed crop, which originated in Ethiopia, allows use of set-aside lands in (high heat and drought) environmental conditions (Spain, Italy, North Africa) unfavourable for the cultivation of B. napus. B. carinata provides greater grain yields than B. napus in conditions of low rainfall during the grain filling period and high temperature. Canola-quality B. carinata is a potential oilseed crop for the Canadian prairies. Recently, B. carinata cultivation has been promoted also in Sicily (55 ha in 2006–07; to be extended to about 3.5 kha). Limitations of B. carinata for biodiesel production are its high content of erucic acid and linolenic acid (exceeding the EN 14214 limit) with the risk of a correspondingly high iodine value (130 g I2/100 g) [32], and high allyl glucosinolate concentrations; however, a more recent pilot plant study reported 109.4 g I2/100 g [33]. B. carinata also has a high sulphur content (0.5% on a dry basis) as compared to most forms of biomass. This can create a problem of SO2 gas emissions above the normal levels found in the combustion of biomass. Tables 5.11 and 5.12 show some commercially available and extreme fatty acid variants in breeding material from important oilseeds. Rapeseed is highly accessible to biotechnological methods. The manipulation of oil synthesis in rapeseed to produce specific, desired, chemically altered triglycerides has already been implemented on a large scale [51]. The breeding of high oleic acid (>80%) or linolenic acid deficient (<3%) rapeseed forms has been achieved by induced mutation [44, 52] and genetically by inhibition of the inherent 12- or 15-desaturase genes [45] (Table 5.12). RS80 is an 80% oleic acid containing GM rapeseed oil obtained from B. campestris or B. napus (available from AC Humko, Memphis, TN). InVigor“ Health canola (Bayer CropScience/Cargill) is a high oleic acid hybrid for the food market. New rapeseed varieties (e.g. LZ 7632) are reaching high levels of up to 87% C18:1. Inhibition of the desaturation step in B. rapa yields high stearic acid seed oil [43]. Other special fatty acid variants (with high concentrations of C8-C14 chain lengths), which are of special interest for oleochemistry and which could be obtained previously only from tropical vegetable oils (CNO, PKO), were developed by gene technology [42]. Canola oil synthesis was altered by genetic engineering to produce high levels of C12 : 0 and reduced levels of C16 : 0 and C18 : 0 [51]. High lauric acid rapeseed (40–60% C12 : 0) is rich in sn-1,3-dilauroyl triglycerides and is commercially planted [37, 51]. Auld et al. [44] developed rapeseed lines with reduced levels of polyunsaturated fatty acids, e.g. linoleic acid. It should be mentioned that
148 SNa IVb CN 12:0 14:0 16:0 18:0 18:1 18:2 18:3 20:1 22:1 Othersc Reference(s)
Type
Variant
Origin
Rapeseed
high erucic acid 0 or 00 (canola) low linolenic acid high lauric acid (HLCO)
conventional 180 102 54 natural mutation 199 121 46 mutagenesis 199 115 48 gene 231 71 54 technology
Sunflower conventional high oleic acid (HO) mutagenesis
201 140 42 199 93 53
– – – 37
– – – 4
3 4 4 3
1 2 2 1
11 60 61 33
12 21 28 12
9 10 3 7
8 1 1 –
52 1 – –
4 1 1 3
[34] [34] [35] [36, 37]
– –
– –
7 3
5 4
19 83
68 10
– –
– –
– –
1 –
[34] [34]
Soybean
conventional
202 141 42
–
–
11
4
23
54
8
–
–
–
[34]
Linseed
conventional low linolenic mutagenesis acid (Linola)
202 201 28 201 154 39
– –
– –
6 6
4 3
18 15
14 73
58 3
– –
– –
– –
[34] [38]
Peanut
conventional 199 high oleic acid (HO) natural mutation 197
– –
– –
12 6
4 2
47 81
31 3
– –
– –
– –
6 8
[39] [39, 40]
a
mg KOH/g. g I2/hg. c wt%. b
99 51 78 56
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.11 Some commercially available fatty acid variants of important oilseeds (after ref. [41])
Table 5.12 Extreme fatty acid variants in breeding materials from important oilseeds (after ref. [41]) Variant
Method
14:0
16:0
18:0
18:1
18:2
18:3
20:1
22:1
Others
Source
Rapeseed
high myristic acid high stearin high oleic acid (HO) high oleic acid (HO) low linolen
gene technology gene technology mutagenesis gene technology gene technology
17.7 – – – –
23.1 4.0 4.2 4.3 3.8
2.4 29.0 2.2 1.4 1.5
33.7 15.0 80.2 84.1 68.5
14.8 19.0 4.5 5.2 22.1
3.8 22.0 5.2 2.9 1.2
– 1.0 1.8 0.9 1.1
– – – – –
4.5 10.0a 1.9 1.2 1.8
[42] [43] [44] [45] [45]
Sunflower high palmitin high stearin high oleic/low saturated fatty acids
mutagenesis mutagenesis mutagenesis
– – –
25.2 5.1 3.2
3.5 26.0 2.4
11.4 13.8 92.1
55.1 55.1 2.3
– – –
– – –
– – –
4.8b – –
[46] [46] [47]
Soybean
low linolenic acid low palmitic acid high palmitic acid high stearic acid high oleic acid (HO)
mutagenesis mutagenesis mutagenesis mutagenesis gene technology
– – – – –
10.5 3.7 17.3 8.4 6.6
4.6 3.7 2.9 28.1 3.6
23.2 24.1 16.8 19.8 84.9
59.6 58.9 54.5 35.5 0.6
2.0 8.9 8.3 6.6 1.9
– – – – –
– – – – –
– 0.7 0.2 1.6 2.4
[47] [48] [41] [41] [49]
Linseed
high palmitin
mutagenesis
–
27.8
1.8
17.5
6.0
42.0
–
–
4.8c
[50]
a
Includes 6 wt% C20:0, 2 wt% C22:0, 1 wt% C24:0. Includes 3.7 wt% C16:1. c C16:1. b
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
Type
149
150
Biodiesel science and technology
there are also new high-erucic varieties and varieties with modified fatty acid composition [53, 54]. GM high-erucic acid B. napus cultivars may even contain > 80 mol% erucic acid [55]. Similarly, recombinant genotypes with increased MUFA (C22 : 1 + C20 : 1 + C18 : 1) of up to 89% and decreased PUFA (<8%) and SFA content (<3.5%) have been described [56]. Rapeseed breeders have also succeeded in improving yield levels of up to 2.9 t/oil in North Germany using ‘precision farming’. Figure 5.2 illustrates rapeseed cultivation and processing.
5.4.2 Sunflower oilseeds Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.) yields are lower than rapeseed yields (see Table 6.1), but SNO represents a choice for biodiesel production in countries with warm and dry climatic conditions and rich soil. Although seed oil of standard cultivated sunflower is considered to be of good quality for edible purposes, it has more limited use for fuel production in view of its high linoleic acid content, and high iodine value of the resulting sunflower oil methyl esters (SNMEs), exceeding the European biodiesel standard (EN 14214) value of 120 g I2/100 g. In this respect, mid- and high-oleic varieties with higher oxidative stability are of more interest [57]. Mid-range oleic NuSun has been developed for frying applications and is in direct competition with low-linolenic canola oil [58]. HO types were developed by mutagenesis (see Table 5.11) [59, 60], as well as varieties with increased proportions of saturated
1 ha rapeseed
3 Mt rapeseed
Crush
1.77 Mt rape meal
1.23 Mt crude oil
0.1 Mt methanol
Transesterification
1.22 Mt rapeseed methyl ester
5.2 Rapeseed cultivation and processing.
0.12 Mt glycerol
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
151
fatty acids (C16:0, C18:0) (see Tables 5.12 and 5.13) [46]. Sunyl 80 “ is a high genetically-modified sunflower oil (80% oleic acid), available from AC Humko, Memphis, TN. Industrial use of HO sunflower oils is favoured by a low SFA content [47]. In recent years, the development of cultivars with high oil content and high oleic acid concentration is an important breeding objective for this crop [61]. These are no transgenic sunflower varieties. Sunflower is the only major oil crop native to western North America. While the US is involved in the production of the nutritionally attractive NuSun, Argentina produces regular and high-oleic sunflower oils; Europe has focused on high-oleic sunflower. For a recent review, see ref. [62].
5.4.3 Soybean oilseeds World soybean production has increased from 125 Mt in 1995 to over 200 Mt in 2005 with an average annual increase of 4.6%. During the period 2002–2007 soya provided about 50% of the growth in world oilseed crush (about 31 Mt). The US soybean (Glycine max) production capacity (with a record of 86.8 Mt on 74 M acres in 2006) accounts for 40% of the world soybean output and for over 50% of the total available bio-based oil for industrial applications [63]. The soybean market has historically been driven by demand for meal, which is not a very storable product, as opposed to oil (making up 35–40% of soybean value). With the advent of biodiesel, this is now moving towards an oil-driven market with prices at top levels. The high value of soybean oil as a food product makes production of a cost-effective fuel very challenging. Soybean oil is a complex mixture of triglycerides with a high proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs, 63.0%), a characteristic that renders SBO very susceptible to peroxidation with molecular oxygen. Similar to Table 5.13 Sunflower oil mutants according to their fatty acid composition (wt%), indicated by average, minimum, and maximum values (after ref. [64]) Class
C16:0
C16:1
C18:0
C18:1
C18:2
High C16:0
32.0 29.3–35.8
6.9 6.0–8.5
2.0 1.7–2.2
9.7 9.1–10.4
47.4 40.6–50.1
High C16:1/high C18:1 30.6 27.1–35.2
8.0 6.8–8.6
1.9 1.7–2.2
55.6 51.7–59.4
3.6 3.0–4.4
High C18:0
6.9 0.0 6.4–7.7
24.8 22.6–28.5
16.7 13.7–19.7
51.3 47.3–55.2
High C18:1
4.6 0.0 3.9–7.6
3.9 2.9–5.3
88.2 83.9–90.5
2.9 1.9–4.1
Standard
6.3 0.0 4.9–9.6
9.4 3.9–15.1
40.0 20.3–54.9
44.1 34.1–64.4
152
Biodiesel science and technology
sunflower oil, soybean oil is also excluded by EN 14214 in view of high iodine values of 121–143 g I2/100 g. There are several thousand sub-species of soybean. Prior soybean oils often lacked important food quality properties (oxidative stability, saturated fat content, flavour) or biodiesel properties (NOx emissions, cold flow). As a result of intensive quality breeding, the fatty acid pattern of soybean is now remarkably variable [65]. Soybean oil typically contains about 16–20 wt% SFA (13–16% C16:0 and 3.4% C18:0). Low-saturate oils contain between 3.6 and 8 wt% saturated fatty acids. A zero-saturate oil composition contains less than 3.6 wt% SFAs. Methods for producing such altered seed oil compositions have been outlined [66] and enable production of SBO containing 69–73 wt% C18 : 1, 21–24 wt% C18 : 2, 0.5–3 wt% C18 : 3 and 2–3 wt% SFA. Low-linolenic varieties (1.5–2.3% C18 : 3, IV 120 g I2/100g) – mainly for food applications – have improved oxidative stability [67]. The development of soybean cultivars with oil enriched in oleic acid, such as mid-oleic (43.7% C18:1, IV 107 g I2/100g) and high-oleic (81.3% C18 : 1, IV 90 g I2/100g), is an important breeding objective for the crop. These oils exhibit a higher degree of oxidative stability than oils low in oleic acid [68]. High-oleic (HO) soybeans have been produced by genetic engineering [49]. A transgenic soybean seed with an oil composition comprising high levels of oleic and linoleic acid, and low levels of linolenic acid and saturated fatty acids has been claimed [66]. Other varieties have modified proportions of individual saturated fatty acid (Table 5.12) [47, 48]. Plant breeding efforts are currently focused on developing low-palmitic, low-linolenic soybean [69]. Almost all of Argentina’s soy production is based on GM material. Although soybean oils have been modified by various breeding methods to create benefits for specific markets, a soybean oil that is broadly beneficial to major users in the food and industrial markets is not readily available. An optimised SBO composition for both food and fuel use is retained to contain about 24 wt% PUFA [70]. A target soybean oil composition (C16 : 0, 2.1%; C18 : 0, 1.0%; C18 : 1, 71.3%; C18 : 2, 21.4%; C18 : 3, 2.2%; other, 2.0 wt%) is characterised by CP, PP and CFPP values of 255, 252 and 252 K, respectively, which is comparable to or better than the corresponding values for petroleum diesel. The agronomic challenge is then to create soybean oil near the target composition without sacrificing soybean yield. Soybean oil prices (US, pmt) have varied considerably, from a low of US$507 in 2004–05, to US$684 (June 2007), US$1376 (June 2008) and to US$1120 in Aug. 2008 [71]. Global soy oil production is expected to increase to 38.4 MMT in 2008–09, compared with 37.9 MMT in 2007–08 [72]. The overall consumption of SBO is expected to increase to 37.9 MMT in 2008–09, compared with 37.2 MMT in 2007–08. It is anticipated that soybean oil prices will reach a record high in 2008–09, attributable to tight global inventories, growing demand and escalating production costs.
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
153
5.4.4 Palm oil products The palm family (palmae or Arecaceae) comprises over 4000 species. Analysis of oil palm genetic diversity has been reported [73]. The oil palm Elaeis guineensis, which grows in rainy climates, is the highest oil-yielding crop (see Table 6.1) and the major supplier of both edible oil and renewable industrial feedstocks since 2003. Palm oil production in some 42 countries worldwide has doubled since 1990 with an increase in cultivated area from about 4 Mha to 9.1 Mha in 2006 (exceeding 35 Mt of oil), mainly at the expense of tropical rainforests. Plantations incur high initial costs, with a first harvest after 5 years. The trees are most productive at 7–12 years of age. The practical production life of an oil palm tree in a plantation is about 25 years. Oil palm is regarded as the most cost-effective vegetable oil crop with typical yields of about 5.0 t/ha/yr. However, the average oil yield in Malaysian plantations is 19 t/ha/yr, and top producers even achieve 25 t/ ha/yr. Biotechnological efforts are directed towards production of palm oil with even higher oil yields, high IV and high monounsaturated fatty acid contents for edible purposes and industrial uses [74]. High yielding seedlings are expected to allow an increase in CPO yield to 27–30 t/ha. The crop that produces over 40 MMT of oil annually worldwide (43.2 MMT forecast 2008–09; 41.4 MMT in 2007–08) is hand harvested. Palm oil, a viscous semi-solid even at tropical ambients and a solid fat in temperate climates, is used mainly as edible oil; its non-food use (cosmetics, toiletries, biodiesel) is relatively small at about 20% [75]. Palm oil has to compete with 16 other oils and fats (total about 135 Mt/yr) for its market share. Fluctuations in the demand for palm oil are due largely to competition from soybean oil. Palm oil needs biodiesel demand [76]. The genus Elaeis contains two very closely related palms of high economic value: E. guineensis (African oil palm) and E. oleifera (American oil palm) with different proportions of the major fatty acids. While palmitic acid (C16:0) is the predominant fatty acid in E. guineensis, oleic acid (C18:1) predominates in E. oleifera. The considerably greater proportion of unsaturated fatty acids determines a higher iodine value and higher fluid fraction at room temperature (lower melting point) in the mesocarp oil of E. oleifera (80%) than in E. guineensis (50%). Hybrid plants might produce an even more desirable oil. Palms from Madagascar have high iodine value and unsaturated oil (C18:2) content [77]. In Africa, the natural habitat of oil palms is the forest fringe near rivers, where moisture is plentiful. Oil palms differ from most other oil crops in that both the fruit pulp and seed are used. Two totally different kinds of oil are produced from the oil palm: orange red palm oil (PMO) and colourless palm kernel oil (PKO). Palm oil (m.p. 298 to 323 K) is extracted from the outer reddish-yellow fleshy mesocarp of the fruit. Palm kernel oil is extracted from the white
154
Biodiesel science and technology
kernel (which is inside a hard shell) of endosperm. Similar to coconut oil, with high content of saturated acids, mainly lauric acid (C12 : 0), it is solid at room temperature. Both oils are quite different in their fatty acid profile and exhibit very poor compatibility with each other. The ratio of palm oil to palm kernel oil is about 5–10 : 1. Fractionation is used in the oils and fats industry to physically separate oils into high-melting ‘stearin’ fractions and lower-melting ‘olein’ fractions. Palm oil is most widely fractionated (see Fig. 5.3). The main triglycerides in palm oil can be grouped into: trisaturated triglycerides – typically PPP (palmitate-palmitate-palmitate); monounsaturated triglycerides – typically POP (palmitate-oleate-palmitate); and polyunsaturated triglycerides – typically POO (palmitate-oleate-oleate). These three groups also correspond roughly to the three main fractions produced from palm oil-stearin (PS), mid-fraction, and olein (POo). A common fractionation process is the separation of palm mid-fraction from palm olein. Palm olein (POo) is the liquid fraction derived from the fractionation of palm oil, and palm stearin (PS) the high-melting (hard) fraction. Palm stearin and palm kernel olein are both products of the palm oil industry that presently have limited use. Free fatty acids are released naturally in crude palm oil (CPO) and can be increased by the action of enzymes in the palm fruit and by microbial lipases. During storage, FFAs are produced by the reaction of oil with water. Standard specifications for the FFA content (as palmitic acid) are 5% maximum in CPO and 0.1% maximum in refined-bleached-deodorised (RBD) oils, respectively. Routine procedures to determine the FFA content in vegetable oils are AOCS Official Methods Aa 6-38 and Ca 5a-40, as well as FTIR analysis [78]. Crude oil or fat
Pre-treatment/refining Option 1
Option 2
Dry fractionation
Transesterification
Stearin
Olein
Food/feed
Transesterification
Dry fractionation
Olein FAME
Stearin FAME Oleochemical
Biodiesel
5.3 Fractionation of palm oil or crude animal fat.
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
155
Palm diesel consists of methyl esters of crude palm oil or crude palm stearin prepared from transesterification with methanol. Use of fatty acid alkyl esters, in particular ethyl esters of palm oil, as diesel fuel was first reported in 1937 by Chavanne [79]. Palm oil ethyl esters were already used as a biodiesel in the Belgian Congo before World War II [80]. High FFA contents in crude palm oil feedstock (up to 30%) necessitate deacidification or acid-catalysed pre-esterification. In the patented MPOB/ Petronas process, esterification of FFAs present in crude palm oil, crude palm stearin and crude palm kernel oil into methyl esters is carried out with a solid-acid catalyst; transesterification of neutral glycerides then proceeds in the presence of a base catalyst [81]. Biodiesel produced from palm oil has high cetane levels, which makes it prized as a fuel additive. The high content of saturated fatty acids in CPO (47.0%) confines operation on palm oil methyl esters (POMEs) (pour point 288 K) as a car fuel to tropical climates. Low pour point (258 K) fractionated palm diesel (without additives) has recently been developed, which is suitable to temperate climates [82]. Both types of palm diesel (normal and low pour point palm diesel) meet all the specifications in EN 14214 and ASTM D 6751. Figure 5.4 shows an integrated process for the production of palm diesel and palm phytonutrients. The co-production of high-value phytonutrients will make palm diesel more viable. A number of issues arise in the context of oil palm cultivation [83]. Oil palm plantations should be established exclusively on degraded land (tropical fallow). Malaysian palm oil, excluding land-use effects, can achieve a 60% net CO2 reduction when used as a feedstock for biodiesel. CO2 reductions for biodiesel oil palm from marginal degraded land are more conspicuous than Crude palm oil (CPO)
CPO methyl esters (palm diesel)
Distilled methyl esters (palm diesel)
Feedstocks for value-added oleochemicals
Phytonutrients concentrate
Carotenes, vitamin E, sterols, squalene, co-enzyme Q, phospholipids (lecithin)
5.4 Integrated process for production of palm diesel and palm phytonutrients.
156
Biodiesel science and technology
from natural forest. On the other hand, biodiesel oil palm from plantations through cutting of tropical forest may well lead to a negative CO2 balance. Biodiesel from palm oil (as well as ethanol from sugarcane) must be discussed in the context of indiscriminate tropical rainforest clearance [84]. Accelerating demand for palm oil is contributing to the 1.5% annual rate of deforestation in South-East Asia [85]. A Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) was set up in 2004 to define, identify and promote ‘sustainable’ palm oil production. However, as long as the certification system of this branch organisation is not effective, the use of palm oil must still be regarded as unsustainable [86]. Palm oil prices (Malaysia, pmt) have developed from a low of US$235 (2000–01) to US$416 (2005–06 on average), US$1291 (March 2008) and US$879 (Aug. 2008).
5.4.5 Oilseed flax There are both fibre and oilseed varieties of flax (Linum usitatissimum L.). Oilseed flax can grow in a variety of climates but in cool climates has a higher oil content. With sufficient moisture, winter flax can yield 2000 to 3000 lb/acre of seed. Oilseed flax has both high- and low-linolenic varieties, called linseed and linola or solin, respectively. Solin varieties have been developed in Canada. Linseed oils with high C18:3 contents are preferred for non-food, technical purposes, although not for biodiesel application (unless as blends). The main non-food uses of linseed (flax) are in the production of dyes, coatings and linoleum. Drying oils such as linseed (Linum usitatissimum L.) oil, Canadian linseed oil and the oil of Iberian dragonhead (Lallemantia iberica L.) typically contain 54.1, 60.2 and 68% of linolenic acid (C18 : 3), respectively, and show high theoretical iodine values of 211, 226 and 236 g I2/hg and low cetane numbers [87]. The high reactivity of the polyene structure of linseed fatty acids results in high sensitivity toward autoxidation. Both linoleate and linolenate structures oxidise rapidly since they contain double allylic hydrogen atoms that are easily abstracted in the autoxidative process. Oils containing linolenic acid are widely used in oil-modified resins and varnishes in works of art. In oil painting, linseed oil remains the most popular oil for binding pigment, thinning paint, and varnishing finished paintings. Walnut oil and poppyseed oil are also favoured by painters. Poppyseed oil dries more slowly (5–7 days) than linseed oil (3–5 days). Flax oils are high in omega-3 fatty acids and have significant value in the food oil market. Modern crop development has resulted in linseed varieties with higher yields, controlled oil content and increased content of unsaturated fatty acids. Classical mutagenesis has been used to breed linseed varieties with less than 5% C18 : 3 (linola quality) [38, 88, 89] or with increased palmitic
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
157
Table 5.14 Fatty acid content (wt%) of linseed oils (after ref. 90) Oil
C16:0 C16:1 C18:0 C18:1 C18:2 C18:3 C20:0 C20:1 SNa
IVb
CN
Edible linseed 6.0 oilc
0.1
3.3
13.0
74.2
2.7
0.1
0.4
200.4 154.2 38.8
Conventional linseed oil
0.1
3.5
13.4
16.8
60.4
0.1
0.4
201.1 166.4 36.0
5.1
a
mg KOH/g. g I2/hg. c PurolinTM. b
acid content in the oil [50] (see Tables 5.11 and 5.12). In the edible linseed crop (linola varieties; solin) the linolenic acid content has been reduced substantially from 50% to 2% through traditional breeding procedures. Genetic manipulation of the activity of desaturase enzymes blocks the conversion of double-unsaturated linoleic acid (C18 : 2) into triple-unsaturated linolenic acid (C18 : 3) in the developing seed. This creates low-linolenic mutants with very high levels of linoleic acid (65–76%). This reduction in unpalatable linolenic acid greatly increases the oxidative stability of the oil. In fatty acid composition, edible linola oil (SFA 10%, MUFA 17%, PUFA 73%) is similar to premium polyunsaturated oils such as SFO, SNO and CRO [91]. Although the risk of formation of rancidity products is removed, the iodine value is reduced and such oils are unsuitable in paints and coatings but qualify instead for biodiesel blending application. Drying of linseed oils with different fatty acid profiles with either high content of linoleic or linolenic acid (Table 5.14) has been studied. The oil high in C18 : 3 oxidises rapidly. Development of linseed with higher C18 : 3 contents for industrial purposes via pedigree-selection has been reported [92]. Flax oil and high a-linolenic oils (perilla, camelina and chia) were recently reviewed [93]. Use of linseed methyl esters with high di-, tri- and polyenoic fatty acid contents in biodiesel requires blending with RME [3].
5.4.6 Safflower oilseeds Safflower or False saffron (Carthamus tinctorius L., Asteraceae family) is an annual drought-resistant niche crop, which grows in the temperate zone where wheat and barley do well. India is the largest producer of safflower, which is grown exclusively for its food oil, which is high in essential unsaturated fatty acids. Around half of US acreage is in California. The cost of growing safflower runs just a little higher per hectare than barley. Traditional plant breeding and plant biotechnology play an important role in developing safflower, sunflower, soybean, rapeseed, linseed and peanut varieties with increased seed oil yields and fatty acid profiles that more closely
158
Biodiesel science and technology
meet the requirements for food and non-food use, including drought-tolerant varieties that have low fertiliser and pesticide requirements [94]. Genetic engineering, which enables development of crops producing seed oils with tailored fatty acid compositions [64, 66], may uncover new horizons in biodiesel production. Most alterations in the oil quality of cultivated plants have concentrated on rapeseed (B. napus). High-oleic (HO) canola, safflower, and sunflower oils, as well as low-linolenic (LoLn) canola and soybean oils, have been developed. HO safflower with 77.4% C18:1 (SFA 7.0%, MUFA 78.0%, PUFA 15.0%) is characterised by a low iodine value (80–100 g I2/ hg) and high CN number (52.2). For further details, see ref. [95]. Turkish safflower seed oil conversion to methyl esters as a biodiesel has been described [96]. Safflower oil does not meet European EN 14214 biodiesel specifications due to high IV (126–150 g I2/hg) and low CN (30).
5.4.7 Coconut oil crops Different species of coconut (Cocos nucifera) live in adverse conditions. Coconut oil is a primary source of basic oleochemicals (soaps, lubricants, plasticisers, surfactants, detergents) [97]. Coconut oil is the main crop in the Philippines (1.25–1.75 Mt/yr), which intends developing coconut biodiesel (a pilot plant was already operational in 1995); see also Sections 14.3 and 14.3.1. Coconut and palm oil production in South-East Asia is frequently hit by weather-related problems, such as typhoons. Biodiesel from the two lauric oils, originating from coconut and palm fruit kernel (E. guineensis), which both contain high contents of C12:0 (approximately 50%) and saturated short-chain fatty acids (~85–90%), are characterised by an excellent cetane number but poor cold-temperature properties (relevant only to temperate climates) [98]. Coconut oil generates more glycerol (13.5%) than most other oils and fats (from 9 to 12%). The coconut biodiesel life cycle system is shown in Fig. 14.4.
5.4.8 Peanut cultivars Peanut (Arachis hypogaea) cultivars are characterised by a slightly lower oil yield per acre than rapeseed but much higher than soybean (see Table 6.1). Yields increase considerably (up to 3.3 t/ha) by irrigation. Peanuts are native to South America. Peanut oil has excellent stability, is extremely durable and less prone to oxidation than other vegetable oils in frying applications; the oil price is high. It is well known that the small diesel engine shown at the Paris exposition in 1900 by the French Otto Company ran on arachide (or peanut) oil [99]. Peanut oil has a low cetane number (41.8). High-oleic peanut cultivars, developed using conventional breeding procedures, contain up to 81% oleic acid (Table 5.11) [40] (see also ref. [100]). Such HO mutants
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
159
provide an oil with high oxidative stability and improved CN (58.3) [39, 101, 102]. In the US there are currently 24 peanut varieties being scrutinised for biodiesel application, including Georgianic. Promising varieties also include DP-1 and Georgia-048, a new high-oleic, Spanish-type peanut (ars.usda. gov). Production of these peanuts would be limited to the southern regions of the US where growing conditions are more suitable. Production and characterisation of biodiesel from groundnut oil have been reported [103]. Development of pure biodiesel from groundnut oil and its blends up to 10% is actively being pursued in Karnataka State, India [104].
5.5
Minor edible oil crops
Various alternative edible oils have suitable fatty acid compositions for use in biodiesel applications but are not expected to find large-scale application due to their high price and/or limited availability. Olive and corn oils are used as quality oils in human nutrition [105, 106]. Olive tree (Olea europaea L.) cultivation started in Syria in the prehistoric age. Olive oil production in Mediterranean basin countries now accounts for 97% of world production (2.81 Mt/yr). Use of olive oil for fuel use was critically considered many years ago [107]. Spent olive oil constitutes a biodiesel raw material resource for local and niche applications [108–110]. Olive residue (pomace) oil is obtained by treating pomace (the substance remaining from previous pressings) with solvents. Pomace oils are classified as crude olive-pomace oil, refined olive-pomace oil and olive-pomace oil. The latter is not recommended for human consumption. Argan oil from the oil fruit of Argania spinosa L. (Sapotaceae), an endemic tree located mainly in South-West Morocco, is well known for its cosmetic, pharmaceutical and nutritional virtues. The unique fatty acid composition (in %) of cold-pressed argan oil – available in quite limited quantities – is: C14 : 0, 0.4%; C16 : 0, 13.5%; C18 : 0, 5.4%; C18 : 1, 44.8%; C18 : 2, 35.7%; C18 : 3, 0.1%; C20 : 2-3, 0.6%; (SFA 20%, MUFA 45%, PUFA 35%, IV 109, CN 49.0, SN 200.9) [111]. Tigernut or yellow nut-sedge (Cyperus esculentus L.) is a fast growing root crop, commonly found wild and cultivated in Northern Nigeria, which yields oil (also called chufa oil) with high oleic acid content (68.8%) and low acidity (0.4 mg KOH/g). Its fatty acid composition (C14 : 0, 0.1%; C16 : 0, 13.2%; C16 : 1, 0.3%; C18 : 0, 4.3%; C18 : 1, 68.8%; C18 : 2, 11.7%; C18 : 3, 0.2%; C20 : 0, 0.6%; C20 : 1, 0.2%; C22 : 0, 0.1%; C24 : 0, 0.2%) is very similar to that of olive oil. C. esculentus oil was first used by Egyptians some 4000 years ago in preference to olive oil. Tigernut is more valuable for its chemical and nutritional properties than as a fuel. The biofuel characteristics of tigernut oil have been reported [112, 113]. Cottonseed oil (CSO) is a vegetable oil extracted from the seeds of the
160
Biodiesel science and technology
cotton plant (Gossypium herbaceum) after the cotton lint has been removed. It must be refined to remove the naturally occurring toxin gossypol (a polyphenol). Cottonseed oil is one of the few oils considered acceptable for reducing saturated fat intake. CSO is among the most unsaturated oils (PUFA, 52%); others include safflower (PUFA, 79%), corn (PUFA, 59%) and sunflower seed oils (PUFA, 61.5%). Cottonseed oil has many food applications (salad oil, cooking oil, shortenings or margarine, baking and frying fats) [114]. Only a small amount (18%) is used for other industrial purposes. Cottonseed oil was considered as a fuel for diesel engines as long ago as the early 1950s [115]. Cotton (oil) is also one of the main four (soy, corn, rapeseed/canola and cotton) genetically modified crops grown around the world. Oil contents and yields are low. Rice is a staple food for around half the world’s population, next to wheat. Worldwide, more than 415 Mt of rice was consumed in 2006–07. Over 90% of world rice production is concentrated in Asia. China will require 600 Mt by 2020. Rice bran oil (RBO) is an important derivative of rice [116]. Rice bran is a brown layer present between rice and the outer husk of the paddy. Rice bran oil ranks first among the non-conventional, inexpensive, lowgrade vegetable oils and is widely available. Depending on the variety of rice and degree of milling, the bran contains 16–32 wt% oil. Dark-coloured crude rice bran oil (CRBO) is difficult to refine because of its high content of free fatty acids (up to 60%), unsaponifiable matter and colour. RBO is not considered as an edible oil all over South-East Asia. Using RBO as a biodiesel with a transesterification process followed by removal of esters gives an unsaponifiable liquid fraction which contains highly concentrated and highly value-added nutraceutical and bio-active components (g-oryzanol, tocopherols, tocotrieniols, phytosterols and squalene). Utilisation of these compounds reduces the cost of rice bran biodiesel. Consequently, replacement of expensive edible oils with RBO as a raw material for biodiesel has economically attractive prospects. Although corn oil was considered as a fuel for biodiesel engines already in 1952 [117], historically it has not been a viable biodiesel feedstock due to its relatively high cost and high value as edible oil. Corn (maize) is a native grain crop of the Americas and is the third most important grain in the world after wheat and rice. Since only 7–8% of the grain is oil, corn oil is a bonus by-product. Processed corn oil is used extensively in the US as a fast food frying oil. Corn oil’s desirable properties include its mild nutty flavour, high levels of unsaturated fatty acids (MUFA, 26%; PUFA, 59%), low levels of saturated fatty acids (15%), very low levels of linolenic acid (0.5–1.7%), high levels of unsaponifiables (including phytosterols and tocopherols), and stability during frying. The food industry relies heavily on (hydrogenated) corn oils [106]. Processes for increasing throughput of corn for oil extraction are currently of great interest [118]. Corn oil production
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
161
may be increased by more efficient solvent extraction. In current dry grind processes, corn oil essentially passes through the process and remains in the resulting distillers dry grains with solubles (DDGS). Approximately 12 Mt/yr of DDGS are being produced in the US. Ethanol producers are investigating fractionating technology to remove corn germ (the portion of the corn kernel that contains oil) prior to the ethanol process. Some ethanol plants remove the remaining vegetable oil from dried distillers grains, a co-product of the ethanol process. Recovery of additional co-products, including corn oil, from the dry-grind process for ethanol takes advantage of membrane technology [119]. For instance, in PCT Int. Publ. No. WO 2008/039859 A2 Janes et al. (to VeraSun Energy Corp.) [120] describe a solvent extraction process from distillers dried grains with solubles to provide distillers meal (with high nutrient content for use as biodiesel supplement) and crude oil (for consumer use and biodiesel production), (see Fig. 5.5). Primafuel, Inc. (Signal Hall, CA) has recently launched its SMAART Oil corn extraction system. The profitability of both ethanol and biodiesel plants may be enhanced by extraction of industrial-grade crude corn oil from the ethanol process for use as an alternative feedstock for biodiesel plants [121, 122]. Ethanol producers may thus offer the biodiesel industry its nearest term opportunity for feedstock diversification. A 50 to 100 MMgy bioethanol plant can profitably be combined with a 1 to 3 MMgy modular biodiesel plant on extracted corn oil. The expected US production of bioethanol from corn of 15 Bgy in 2015 could generate almost 400 Mgy (non-edible) corn oil if only 0.5 lb of oil were extracted from each bushel
DDGS
Extractor
Desolventiser/ dryer
De-oiled DDGS
Evaporator Solvent Extraction system
Crude corn oil
Oil pre-treatment
Biodiesel production
Biodiesel
Biodiesel system Glycerin
5.5 Biodiesel production from distillers dried grains with solubles (DDGS).
162
Biodiesel science and technology
of corn. In addition to the various extraction technologies, the quantity of corn oil could also be increased in the long term by producing more highoil corn varieties. While industrial-grade crude corn oil is not available on the spot market, it is offered at a price discount because of its composition. Compared with other vegetable and rendered oils, it is high in FFA content (12–17 wt%), as well as in waxes and other chemicals that make it unsuitable for human consumption. Consequently, for biodiesel application pre-treatment (acid esterification) is required. Corn oil does not give the cold-flow problems associated with the use of animal fat. Also combined corn ethanol-biodiesel production has been proposed [123]. Sesamum indicum L. (sesame) is a herbaceous oilseed crop of the Pedaliaceae family. The economically important crop is widely cultivated in many parts of the world (5 million acres), mainly in (sub)tropical areas (main producers: India, China, Myanmar) and has been adapted to semiarid regions. Sesame is currently being developed as a major oilseed crop in Turkey (South-eastern Anatolia Project). Global sesame production amounts to 3.3 Mt/yr. Sesame is widely used in food, and for nutraceutical and pharmaceutical purposes because of its high contents in oil (37–63%), protein (18–25%) and antioxidants (sesamin and sesaminol lignans) [124]. Fatty acid composition consists of C16 : 0 (11%), C18 : 0 (7%), C18 : 1 (43%) and C18 : 2 (35%). Sesame oil shows high oxidation stability. Although sesame oil methyl esters can successfully be used as biodiesel [125], sesame oil is in short supply and, consequently, highly priced. Moringa oleifera (Moringa, Murungai or drumstick tree) of the Moringaceae family and Moringa genus is an exceptionally nutritious vegetable tree growing rapidly in semi-arid (sub)tropical areas (India, Africa, Central and South America, Mexico, Malaysia, Philippines and Australia), which tolerates poor soil, drought, saline land and brackish water [126]. There are 48 varieties of Moringa, which is considered as one of the world’s most useful trees, as almost every part can be used for food. The crop yields 3 t seeds/ha. The seeds are relatively easy to crush using non-solvent based crushing techniques. Moringa seeds contain 38–40% oleic acid-rich oil. Its oil composition (C14 : 0, 0.1%; C16 : 0, 6.0%; C16 : 1, 1.5%; C18 : 0, 4.0–6.0%; C18 : 1, 71.2–74.0%; C18 : 2, 0.7%; C18 : 3, 0.2%; C20 : 0, 2.5–3.6%; C20 : 1, 2.2–2.5%; C22 : 0, 5.8–6.2%; C22 : 1, 0.1%; C26 : 0, 1.1%; SFA 22%, MUFA 77%, PUFA 1%; SN, 186 mg KOH/g; IV, 65.6 g I2/100 g) indicates an acceptable substitute for olive oil, although with a significantly higher FFA (as oleic acid) content (1.4%) [126, 127]. Moringa oil is considered to be a more sustainable biodiesel feedstock than jatropha oil by those who argue that sustainability is better served by feedstocks that can yield both food and fuel [128]. However, little research has been conducted on the tree’s potential as an oilseed crop. Moringa is more hardy compared with Jatropha
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
163
and its calorific value exceeds that of Jatropha. This little-known vegetable oil has the potential to be a next-generation agro-fuel feedstock, improving the food/fuel security. However, harvesting of difficult agro-fuel crops like Jatropha, castor bean and moringa needs to be addressed. Moringa could be grown initially as a feedstock for biodiesel production but has prospects as a food source. Moringa biodiesel has better oxidative stability than biodiesel from most other feedstocks, although the cloud point is similar to tallow and thus rather high. The tea plant (Camellia sinensis), cultivated mainly for its leaves, is a perennial, evergreen shrub, and produces large seeds which contain approximately 30% oil. The seeds of the other genera of Camellia, C. sasanqua or japonica, which are planted for their oils as well, have oil contents up to 60%. Tea seed oil is a by-product of the tea industry. Camellia or tea seed oil is a high-quality edible oil with a unique flavour and taste, and good storage stability. Being a high-oleic (59.0–61.3%), medium-linoleic (20.0–22.0%), and low-linolenic acid (0.25–0.35%) oil, and having a high antioxidant content, tea seed oil is a suitable feedstock for biodiesel production with low acid value (0.6–0.9 mg KOH/g), adequate IV (89.9 g I2/hg) and OSI (> 8.6 h) [129]. Solvent extraction of spent coffee grounds (15% oil; mainly C16 : 0, 51.4%; C18 : 0, 8.3%; C18 : 2, 40.3%; FFA 4–6%) yields a low-cost biodiesel feedstock with high antioxidant and sulphur levels [130]. 1.1 Mt/yr of good quality biodiesel (CP, 284 K) could eventually be produced from the waste coffee grounds around the world. Many other potential oils, e.g. from dikanut or oil bean seeds, walnut, poppyseed, cocoa butter (waste chocolate), etc., are unlikely to ever become serious feedstocks for biodiesels. Poppyseed (Papaver somniferum) oil is the edible oil obtained from the small, dark seeds of the opium poppy flower. The oil is similar in nature to soybean and hempseed oils and is highly valued (US$99/gal) for nutritional, medical and cosmetic applications. The oil composition of pumpkin seed (Cucurbitia maxima) is similar to that of cardoon. For the prospects of chokecherries, see Section 6.4.6.
5.6
Fish oils
Aquatic biomass comprises microorganisms (planktonic), macroalgae and fish. Annual world fish supplies amount to about 92 Mt/yr from capture fisheries (illegal fisheries not included and ocean stocks in decline) and 52.7 Mt/yr from marine and freshwater aquaculture production (mainly finfish and shellfish); 2008 data. Fish oils may be extracted from finfish such as anchovy, catfish, cod, dogfish, eel, hake, halibut, herring, mackerel, menhaden, pollock, sardine, shark, squid, trout and tuna. Such fish oils, farmed fish (salmon, tambaqui) oils, and marine mammal (dolphin, porpoise, whale) oils comprise
164
Biodiesel science and technology
some of the cheapest of oils [131, 132]. A disadvantage of aquatic biomass as compared to plant sources is frequently poor sensorial properties. Table 5.15 lists the main fish oils available in commercial quantities. Total world fish oil production is relatively small with approximately 1.1 Mt in 2002 (main producers: Chile, Peru, USA); some 100 kt/yr menhaden oil is being produced (at US$200 to US$650/t). The quantity of oil as a proportion of the body weight of the fish is significantly lower than those proportions found in oilseeds. Fish typically may contain 2–10% oil. Fish production is extremely seasonal. Fish oil is a by-product of the fish meal industry. In value terms, however, fish oil assumes much greater importance, in particular in its refined but unhydrogenated form. Crude fish oil prices in the US (2003) amounted to US$495/t. Worldwide uses for fish oil (2002) are as follows: aquafeed 56%, edible 30%, industrial 12%, and pharmaceutical 2%. Hydrogenation removes the highly unsaturated (n-3) fatty acids (EPA and DHA). Fish oil is a very complex mixture that contains high-boiling fatty acids, triglycerides, phospholipids, glycerol ethers, wax esters and fatty alcohols. Table 5.16 shows some total fish oil fatty acid compositions. For typical contents of principal fish oil fatty acids, see also ref. [133]. The compositions of fish oils vary not only with the type of fish, but also with factors including the season of the year (seawater temperature), the geographic location of the catch and the diet of the fish. These factors are interdependent. In spite of these variations, fish oils share important similarities in fatty acid composition which distinguish them from both vegetable oils and animal fats, namely, a wider range of chain lengths (C12-C26), higher degrees of unsaturation (D = 4–6) and low levels of odd-numbered and branched chain fatty acids [133], (see also Table 5.17). Fish oils may contain up to 40 components [134], as Table 5.15 Fish oils available in commercial quantities (after ref. [133]) Type
Main source(s)
Anchovy
Off South and South-West Africa, Chile, Peru and Mexico (Pacific Coast)
Capelin
Barents Sea, North Atlantic
Herring
North Atlantic, North Sea, Norwegian Sea, Pacific Ocean
Horse mackerel
South Africa, Pacific Coast of South America
Mackerel
North Atlantic, Pacific, North Sea
Menhaden
USA East Coast, Gulf of Mexico
Norway pout
North Sea, North Atlantic, Barents Sea
Sand eel
North Sea
Sardine/pilchard Off South Africa, Chile, Peru, Japan, Atlantic Coasts of Canada and USA Sprat
North Sea
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
165
compared to about 10 different fatty acids in the triacylglycerol structure of RSO and SBO. The significant contents of C14:0 (7–9%), C16:1 (5–12%) and C20:1 (usually 5–17%) differentiate fish oils from most vegetable oils and fats and from animal fats. Equally significant quantities of eicosapentaenoic acid C20:5 (EPA) and decosahexaenoic acid C22:6 (DHA) are unique to fish oils. The C22:1 fatty acid (n-11 isomer) is cetoleic acid (up to 20%), which differs from erucic acid (n-9 isomer). Fish oils are often characterised by very long-chain fatty acids (VLCFA). For instance, farmed tambaqui (Colossoma macropomum) fish oil contains C25/C26; in salmon oil PUFA (D ≥ 4) amounts to 28.5–41.7%, in sardine oil 22.0% has D ≥ 4. In the fish oil group, n-3 fatty acids (C20:5, C22:5, C22:6) are quite common. The high amounts of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (up to 30%) in some fish oils (see Tables 5.16 and 5.17) cause high iodine values (>120 g I2/hg), low CN (30–40) and poor oxidation stability. The iodine values of menhaden fish oil (typically 160–180 g I2/hg) were directly calculated from fatty acid profiles by using reacting ratios between I2 and either the fatty acids bound to a triglyceride or the free fatty acids [135]. Satisfactory agreement with the traditional titration method was found. Table 5.16 allows two groups of oil types to be distinguished on the basis of their fatty acid profile: Group A oils, mainly from fish caught in seas in the southern hemisphere or southern part of the northern hemisphere, and Group B oils from fish of the northern part of the northern hemisphere [133]. In view of higher iodine value and polyunsaturate content, Group A fish oils are more susceptible to oxidation than Group B oils. Fish oils contain high levels of EPA (C20:5), DHA (C22:6) and omega-3 Table 5.16 Total fish oil fatty acid compositions (after ref. [133]) Type of fish
Degree of unsaturationa
SFA
MUFA
PUFAb
HUFAc
IVd
A:
33 29 30 33
24 28 32 29
17 20 15 18
8 9 10 9
150–200 141–212 158–193 178–200
19 26 19 20 24 18
57 54 47 42 47 47
8 6 7 8 7 10
6 6 9 13 8 9
94–164 95–160 125–147 140 136–167 144–173
Menhaden Sardine/pilchard Horse mackerel Anchovy
B: Capelin Herring Sprat Norway pout Mackerel Sand eel a
Calculated for total C14+C16+C18+C20+C22; wt%. Pentaunsaturated fatty acids. c Hexaunsaturated fatty acids. d g I2/hg. b
166
Biodiesel science and technology
fatty acids such as a-linolenic acid (C18:3) that are thought to have beneficial health effects. Omega-3 PUFAs may be extracted from zooplankton or krill [136], fish and other marine animals, or may be synthesised using microalgae (see Section 5.7). Euphasia superba oil is derived from Antarctic krill. EPA may also be sourced from both fish oil and microalgae [137]. The fatty acids found in crude catfish visceral oil are C14 : 0, 16 : 0-1, 18 : 0-3, 20 : 0-4 and 22 : 6, the predominant FAs being C18 : 1, 16 : 0, 18 : 2 and 18 : 0, with a total unsaturated FA in purified catfish oil of 67.7% [143]. The major fatty acids of visceral oil extracted from farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) are C16 : 0, 16 : 1n7, 18 : 1n9, 20 : 5n3 (EPA), 14 : 0 and 22 : 6n3 (DHA); SFA, MUFA and PUFA values are 31.7, 36.0 and 32.2%, respectively [144]. The FA profile of salmon visceral oil is similar to that of salmon filet and characterised by high EPA (1.64 g I2/100 g) and DHA (1.47 g I2/100 g) contents. Some marine oils find application for dietary purposes associated with cardiovascular/thrombotic diseases. Fish liver oils, such as cod liver oil (CLO) and hake (Merluccius hubbsi) liver oil, constitute a special class of oils, being used for medicinal purposes (source of vitamins A and D). CLO contains 7.5–9.0% C20:5 (EPA) and 10.0–12.0% C22:6 (DHA) (see Table 5.17). Cod Table 5.17 Fatty acid compositions (wt%) of some fish oils Fish oil
Composition
Cod liver
14:0(6.5), 16:0(16.0), 16:1(9.5), 18:1(26.5), 18:4(2.0), [138] 20:1(11.5), 20:5(10.0), 22:1(6.5), 22:5(1.0), 22:6(7.5) SFA 23.5, MUFA 55.0, PUFA 21.5; SN 193 mg KOH/g, IV 135 g I2/hg, CN 44.1
Menhadena
14:0(9.7), 15:0(1.4), 16:0(20.5), 16:1(12.6), 16:2(1.6), [139] 16:3(2.2), 16:4(1.7), 18:0(3.3), 18:1(11.1), 18:2(1.8), 18:3(1.6), 18:4(2.9), 20:0(0.4), 20:1(1.0), 20:4(2.1), 20:5(13.7), 22:1(0.8), 22:5(2.6), 22:6(9.2) SFA 35.1, MUFA 23.6, PUFA 39.1; SN 206 mg KOH/g, IV 176 g I2/hg, CN 33.2
Salmon
14:0(5.5–7.9), 16:0(15.3–22.3), 16:1(6.3–9.0), 17:0(0.3–1.0), 18:0(3.1–3.9), 18:1(10.4–17.8), 18:2(1.1–3.8), 18:3(0.6–1.1), 18:4(1.7–2.4), 20:0(0.2), 20:1(1.1–5.5), 20:2(0.2–0.4), 20:5(9.3–17.1), 22:1(0.4–5.9), 22:5(2.1–4.0), 22:6(11.3–20.1), 24:1(0.9) SFA 26.0, MUFA 38.0, PUFA 36.0; SN 191 mg KOH/g, IV 181 g I2/hg, CN 34.2
Sardine
14:0(8.1), 16:0(21.4), 16:1(8.9), 18:0(4.0), 18:1(18.5), [142] 18:2(16.0), 18:3(0.6), 20:2–4(1.0), 20:5(13.3), 22:4(0.9), 22:5(1.2), 22:6(5.9) SFA 33.5, MUFA 27.4, PUFA 39.1; SN 204 mg KOH/g, IV 148 g I2/hg, CN 39.6
a
Herring family.
Reference(s)
[140, 141]
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
167
liver oil is very expensive (and consequently often adulterated with rapeseed oil). Intracellularly synthesised eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) is less expensive when obtained from Phaeodactylum tricornutum than from cod liver [145]. FTIR may be used for rapid analysis of FFAs in fish oil biodiesel feedstock covering the range of 0–6.5% FFA [146]. AOCS Method Ce 1i-07 analyses fatty acids in marine and other oils containing long-chain PUFAs by GC; see also ref. [134]. The primary potential source of biodiesel feedstock from the fisheries and seafood (aquaculture) processing sector is fish oil. Fish oil is currently being used or evaluated as feedstock for biodiesel blends in Norway, Alaska (US) and Nova Scotia (Canada). To be cost-effective, biodiesel has to be produced locally, or it will be just as expensive as imported diesel. Biodiesel production can utilise marine oils or crude unprocessed fish oil which is removed from waste materials (fish processing discards). Statoil Biodiesel produces yearly 4.5 ML biodiesel based on Norwegian fish oil from the waste of salmon farms (salmon methyl ester), which is probably used to blend 5 vol% rape biodiesel. Herring oil biodiesel is solid. The European Enerfish project (project leader: VTT, Finland) aims at demonstrating the commercial feasibility of transforming fish waste into biodiesel; pilot plants (120 t/d) are planned near pangasius (P. hypophthalmus) fish farms in Vietnam. In North America two significant projects successfully utilise fish oil as feedstock to biodiesel. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd./Wilson Fuels (Bedford, NS) produces 5 ML/yr biodiesel from the less desirable saturated waste fish oil residues. Unisea Fisheries (Dutch Harbor, AK) produced fish oil biodiesel for several years. In the framework of the Alaska Fish Oil Biodiesel Project, the Alaskan commercial fishery industry currently produces 8 Mgy of fish oil (market value US$0.75 to US$1.50/gal in 2003), but with the capacity to produce up to 21 Mgy using oil of the fish that are harvested (excess oils now being dumped) [147, 148]. The potential of fish processing discards as feedstock for biodiesel production via enzymatic transesterification was also evaluated [149] (see Tables 10.1 and 10.2). Rendering is the most common process to extract usable oils from fish wastes. Fish oil has valuable properties for animal feed, aquaculture, pharmaceutical and cosmetics, and is usually worth more than biodiesel. The economic potential of using fish oil as a feedstock for biodiesel production is enhanced in more remote areas that have a locally produced supply of crude fish oil. In British Columbia, fish oils are derived from the rendering and recovery of waste by-products resulting from value-added seafood processing. The tasks of collecting the raw wastes and of extracting usable oils from them are capitalintensive and complex operations. Consequently, in British Columbia it is unlikely that a potential biodiesel manufacturer would find it strategically or economically viable to invest in a purpose-built rendering/recovering facility for producing an in-house source of fish oil feedstock from raw waste.
168
Biodiesel science and technology
One of the factors to consider is the shelf-life of the fish oil supply. Because of the high level of long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, fish oils are readily oxidised [150]. Consequently, commercial additives are needed to improve the oxidative stability of fish oil biodiesel to meet standard quality specifications.
5.7
Algae mass culture systems
Photosynthetic organisms growing in aquatic environments include macroalgae (‘seaweed’), microalgae (microscopic organisms) and emergents (plants growing partially submerged in bogs and marshes). Macro- and microalgae are aquaculture products which can be found in both marine and freshwater environments. Microalgae growth covering 700 000 km2 (twice the size of Germany) has been observed in the Arctic Ocean [151].
5.7.1 Microalgae Microalgae comprise a vast group of photosynthetic, heterotrophic organisms which have an extraordinary potential for cultivation as energy crops. Photosynthetic algae are dominant producers in aquatic environments, account for a substantial proportion of global O2 production and CO2 fixation, are a component of feed for aquaculture and produce numerous valuable compounds such as fats, oils, sugars, pigments and other functional bio-active compounds. Microalgae represent an immense range of genetic diversity and can exist as unicells, colonies or extended filaments. They grow under the widest possible variety of conditions (from freshwater to extreme salinity, from moist earth to desert sands). Microalgae are microscopic aquatic plants that carry out the same process and mechanism of photosynthesis as higher plants in converting sunlight, water and carbon dioxide into biomass, lipids and oxygen. However, algae production does not require fresh water or arable land used for cultivation of food crops. Most microalgae are obligate photoautotrophs and their growth is strictly dependent on the generation of photosynthetically derived energy. The use of algae is of great interest for their higher photosynthetic activity compared with terrestrial plants. Certain algae (e.g. Chlamydomonas reinhardtii) are effective in the production of hydrogen and oxygen through the process of biophotolysis, while others produce starch (e.g. green algae), lipids (e.g. diatom algae) or long-chain hydrocarbons (e.g. Botryococcus braunii), suitable for direct use as highenergy liquid fuels. It should be remembered that the petroleum of today is derived from prehistoric biomass, including algae. For example, the deposits of oil pumped from the North Sea consist partly of decomposed haptophyte algae (Coccolithophorids). The challenge is now to grow and transform algae into biocrude within days rather than millenia.
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
169
Algae are commonly categorised in nine divisions: the largest groups are diatoms (Bacillariophyceae), green algae (Chlorophyceae), blue-green algae (Cyanophyceae) and golden-brown algae (Chrysophyceae). Microalgae are unicellular and are the most primitive form of plants. While the mechanism of photosynthesis in microalgae is similar to that of higher plants, they are generally more efficient converters of solar energy because of their simple cellular structure. Algae can be 10% efficient at converting sunlight into fuel, as compared to the 1–2% efficiency for ethanol from maize. Moreover, because the cells grow in aqueous suspension, they have more efficient access to water, CO2 and other nutrients. Consequently, microalgae are capable of producing at least 30 times the amount of oil per unit area of land compared to terrestrial oilseed crops (see Table 6.1). Algae can be a promising feedstock as the fatty acid yield on a unit area basis is 15–20 times higher than for palm and over 200 times higher than soybean. Microalgae are sunlight-driven cell factories that convert CO2 to potential biofuels, foods, feeds and high-value bioactives. The approximate molecular formula of microalgal biomass is CO0.48H1.83N0.11P0.01. Microalgal biomass contains approximately 50% carbon by dry weight, which is typically all derived from carbon dioxide. Producing 100 t of algal biomass requires roughly 183 t of carbon dioxide. Algal biomass contains carbohydrates, proteins and natural oils. Cultivated microalgae are a minor source of food for humans and animals, and yield a wide range of chemical compounds, such as phycocolloids, used in industry, food technology and pharmaceuticals. Similar to fish oils and animal viscera, many cultured microalgae are potential sources of high-value nutraceuticals and pharmaceuticals such as polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) and other bioactive compounds with a product value of US$100–1000/gal, including health food. The majority of the commercial algal cultivation plants (3–500 t/yr) are located in Asia [152]. Total worldwide production is a few thousand tons of algal biomass per year. Most of the commercially produced algal biomass is marketed as health food or dietary food supplement (overproduction scenario). There are also algae cultivation ponds across the US (in Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Florida, Oregon, California and Arizona). The world’s largest algae farm (108 acres), operated by the Earthrise Nutritionals facility (CA), produces cyanobacterial biomass for food. Certain algae contain 30% omega fatty acids. Commercially-grown algae like Spirulina are high in protein and starch but low in fat. A few high-fat species of algae like Haematococcus are promising, but the fats (at prices of around US$1200/lb) are too expensive for fuel purposes. Algae can potentially provide different types of renewable biofuels, namely: photobiologically produced biohydrogen [153, 154]; methane from thermal gasification or anaerobic digestion [155]; bioethanol by subsequent fermentation [156]; bio-oil by pyrolysis [157]; and biodiesel by heterotrophic fermentation
170
Biodiesel science and technology
[158] or from microalgal oil by transesterification [156, 159–166]. Microalgae are very efficient in converting a waste (zero-energy) form of carbon (CO2) into a high-density liquid form of energy (natural oil). Biodiesel production applies exclusively to the natural oil fraction. Microalgae are among those species which produce more of the right kind of natural oils for biodiesel applications. Microalgae are an alternative source of lipids, which can be readily converted to biodiesel, but without competing for arable land. Only step-change solutions, such as efficient production from algae, will allow biodiesel production meeting much more than ~10% of the diesel market. Starting with algae production eliminates the trading and handling cost for the crude oil. Algal biomass may also be used for production of steam or electricity by direct combustion. The concept of algal biomass as a fuel extender in power plants is being pursued especially in Japan. Oil obtained from the marine microalga Dunaliella tertiolecta has a calorific value of 36 kJ/g (compared with 45 kJ/g for fossil fuel and 28 kJ/g for coal) [167]. Oil extraction from algae may be achieved by expeller/pressing (yielding 70–75% of oils out of dried algae), hexane solvent method (yielding 95% of total oil present in combination with cold press), or supercritical fluid extraction (100% oil recoverage). The algal oil quality and yield depend on the algae species and vary widely depending on ecological habitat. Within the US Biofuels Program the DOE-funded Aquatic Species Program Biodiesel from Algae (or ASP; operated between 1978 and 1996 in reaction to the 1973 oil crisis) has aimed at demonstrating the feasibility of producing biodiesel from high lipid content algae grown in open ponds, utilising fossil CO2 (flue gas) from coal-fired power plants [163]. Some 3000 highly oleaginous strains of algae were screened and isolated in an attempt to find high-oil producing algae that grow under severe conditions of T, pH and salinity. Many of the algal species can grow in brackish, non-potable water or in the open sea, i.e. water containing high salt levels. Some 300 species of high oil producing algae (originating mainly from native shallow, inland saline habitats in southwestern US), mostly green algae (especially in freshwater) and diatoms (in marine and fresh water), were selected and their capabilities were determined. Not all algal species that looked promising in laboratory tests were robust enough under field conditions. The best choice of microalgae is still an open question. No one single species seems to meet all the needs of the algal biodiesel technology. The strains most favoured by NREL were Bacillariophyceae and Chlorophyceae. Diatom algae need silicon in the water to grow; green algae require nitrogen. Whereas certain algae strains are very tolerant to temperature fluctuations, diatoms have a fairly narrow temperature range. The NREL programme was terminated in 1996, largely because at that time crude oil prices were far too low for algae to compete. Today’s higher oil prices
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
171
make competition easier. Moreover, biotech advances and new genomic and proteomic techniques have enhanced our understanding of the mechanisms involved in algae oil production. While some types of algae can produce as much as 60 wt% of oil, in the necessary conditions of starvation for nutrients they lose their ability to grow and reproduce. By overcoming this problem oil production could be dramatically increased and drive down prices. The primary ingredients of algal life are sunlight, CO2 and water. Although it is common understanding that algae use CO2 for their photosynthesis process, it has recently appeared that some algae (e.g. the marine cyanobacterium Synechococcus WH 8102) use oxygen [168]. Unlike other crops, microalgae grow extremely rapidly and many are exceedingly rich in oil. Algae produce by cellular division. Algae grow in a wide variety of climates and conditions (including wastewater treatment facilities). Areas targeted for the highest production per hectare of algae are desert climates, which are largely unused and unsuitable for traditional crop cultivation. One of the great strengths of algae is the ability to grow robustly in brackish water. Table 5.18 summarises Table 5.18 Main characteristics of microscopic algae biomass for biodiesel production Advantages: ∑ Great variety in natural and GM algae strains ∑ Sustainable and carbon neutral technology (CO2 sequestor) ∑ Turns pollution into energy ∑ Very high energy potential ∑ Home-grown source of energy ∑ Contributes to energy security ∑ Avoids use of scarce fossil fuels ∑ Rapid reproduction ∑ Day-after-day harvesting ∑ High per-acre yield ∑ High oil contents ∑ No competition with food crops ∑ No competition for agricultural land use (wastelands, deserts) ∑ No competition for scarce sweet water ∑ Robust growth in brackish and marine waters ∑ No sulphur, non-toxic, highly biodegradable biofuel Disadvantages: ∑ No affordable processing method ∑ Danger of culture crashing (microbe contamination) ∑ Limited commercial availability ∑ High PUFA (D ≥ 4) contents Challenges: ∑ Scaling up of algae production methods ∑ Availability of concentrated CO2 ∑ Large–scale harvesting and dewatering ∑ Improved extraction methods
172
Biodiesel science and technology Table 5.19 Oil content of some microalgae (adapted from ref. [169]) Microalga
Oil content (% dry wt)
Botryococcus braunii Chlorella sp. Crypthecodinium cohnii Cylindrotheca sp. Dunaliella primolecta Dunaliella tertiolecta Isochrysis sp. Monallanthus salina Nannochloris sp. Nannochloropsis sp. Neochloris oleoabundans Nitzschia sp. Phaeodactylum tricornutum Schizochytrium sp. Tetraselmis suecica
25–75 28–32 20 16–37 23 37 25–33 > 20 20–35 31–68 35–54 45–47 20–30 50–77 15–23
the main characteristics of microalgae as a biodiesel feedstock. Unlike other sources, such as soybean or rapeseed, algae can be harvested day after day. Advantages of microalgae are higher photosynthetic efficiency, higher biomass production and faster growth compared to other energy crops. Algae reproduce more rapidly and consume more CO2 than any other form of plant life. Microalgae commonly double their biomass within 24 h. Biotechnology has allowed development of modified algae strains with bio-yields three times higher than naturally. Lipid productivity of many microalgae greatly exceeds that of the best producing oil crops (see Table 1.10). Oil content in microalgae can exceed 80% by weight of dry biomass [155]. Oil levels of 20–50% are quite common (Table 5.19). Diatom algae typically contain approximately 50 wt% oil. Microalgae with high oil productivities are desired for producing biodiesel. Depending on the species, microalgae produce many different kinds of lipids (though simpler than fish oils), hydrocarbons and complex oils. Renaud et al. [170] described the fatty acid composition of 18 species of microalgae from tropical Australian marine and freshwater environments, which mostly contained lipid contents between 15 and 20 wt% of dry matter. Good quality oil (low P and neglible S content) was obtained by direct extraction from such microalgae. Table 5.20 shows that the highest PUFA percentages were found in cryptophytes (in the range of 65.8–75.2% of total fatty acids) and prasionophytes (52.2–61.6%). An overview of genomic and biomolecular techniques for enhancing lipid yield in tropical microalgae is available [171]. Marine algae cultivation in coastal waters (e.g. in Bretagne, Hawaii, Singapore) minimises the impact on agricultural land and freshwater supplies
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
173
Table 5.20 Fatty acid compositiona of some tropical Australian microalgae (after ref. [170]) Species
SFA (%)
MUFA (%)
PUFA (%)
PUFA (D ≥ 4) %
Bacillariophyceae (diatoms) Cryptophyceae Prasinophyceae Prymnesiophyceae Rhodophyceae
25.8–33.0 14.4–22.6 21.7–24.7 25.9–30.3 33.9
23.2–41.4 6.0–11.0 12.7–16.5 11.3–20.5 18.7
26.1–47.2 65.8–75.2 52.2–61.6 48.4–56.4 43.6
13.5–29.9 35.9–49.5 27.6–38.4 28.9–43.9 10.7
a
Percent of total fatty acids (w/w).
Table 5.21 Some algae species under consideration as a mass oil producing crop Botryococcus braunii Dunaliella tertiolecta Euglena gracilis Isochrysis galbana Nannochloris sp. Nannochloropsis salina Neochloris oleoabundansa
Phaeodactylum tricornutumb Pleurochrysis carteraec Prymnesium parvumd Scenedesmus dimorphusa Spirulina sp. Tetraselmis chui e Tetraselmis suecica
a
Green alga (Chlorophyceae). Diatom. c Prymnesiophyceae. d Toxic. e Marine unicellular. b
and avoids the conversion of rainforest into vegetable oil plantations. Examples of salt-tolerant microscopic algae (plankton) are the diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum (Bacillariophyceae), Botryococcus braunii and Dunaliella tertiolecta. Japan operates a national research project for mass cultivation of oil producing Botryococcus [172]. Locally isolated strains of tropical marine microalgae were screened in Singapore for cellular lipid content for the development of an indigenous biodiesel feedstock [170]. Table 5.21 lists various algae species which are being considered for oil production. Not all algal oils are equally suitable for making biodiesel, but suitable oils commonly occur. In view of the composition of many microalgal oils, most of them are unlikely to comply with the European biodiesel standards. A drawback of the algal oils in Table 5.20 is their invariably high PUFA (D ≥ 4) percentage. These oils might require partial catalytic hydrogenation to reduce the extent of unsaturation (see Section 15.3.2). Plant biotechnology is a field that is only recently coming into its own. Within this field, algae research is still largely unexplored. An important research topic is improving oil production in algal organisms and manufacturing the metabolism of algae. Although overall rates of oil production are lower
174
Biodiesel science and technology
during periods of nutrient deficiency, no simple means appears to exist for increasing lipid production without a penalty in overall productivity due to a slowing down of cell growth. Possibly, a net increase in total oil productivity may be achieved by carefully controlling the timing of nutrient depletion and cell harvesting. High CO2 sequestration yields are required [173]. Finding key enzymes in the lipid synthesis pathway whose level of activity in the cell influences the rate at which oil forms is critical to understanding the mechanisms for controlling oil production. The enzyme acetyl CoA carboxylase (ACCase), isolated from a diatom, which catalyses a key metabolic step in the synthesis of oils in algae, is considered to be such an enzyme. Biochemistry and physiology of oil production in algae mass culture systems require further development on a fundamental level in order to improve the performance of existing organisms. Production of algal oils requires an ability to inexpensively produce large quantities of oil-rich microalgal biomass. Producing microalgal biomass is generally considered more expensive than growing crops. The challenges are several (Table 5.18) and lie in the growth, harvesting and oil extraction rather than in the chemistry of converting algal oil products to fuels. Many fundamental technological questions still need to be solved: where to grow algae; which strains to select; how to boost productivity while keeping a sensitive culture robust and stable; and how to design the most cost-effective culture ponds. Large-scale harvesting and dewatering are major issues. Centrifugal algae harvesting is an option [174]. The cost of harvesting can amount to some 30% of the total algal production cost. Extraction methods (‘milking the algae’) have also yet to be perfected. Origin Oil Inc. (Los Angeles, CA) has developed a one-step algae harvesting/oil extraction process. It may reasonably be expected that the various challenges may be overcome given the sheer diversity of algae species. With more than 35 000 species of algae described scientifically and as many as 100 000 presumed, finding the most suitable strain is not an easy task. There will not be just one magic strain. Different species are likely to be needed for every location to ensure that a consistent amount of oil is produced all year round, despite fluctuations in temperature and sunlight. The most suitable strains are most likely to be found close to proposed algae cultivation sites. In all likelihood, there is a species that can be optimised for a given algae production system.
5.7.2 Microalgae technology The useful energy capture of growing crops represents less than 1% of sunlight absorbed. However, growing algae to make biofuel presents potentially a different proposition. The much promoted energy re-evolution from fossil power to algae/solar power passes through engineering of high-volume microalgae production systems.
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
175
Growth media are generally inexpensive and must provide the inorganic elements that constitute the algal cell (mainly N, P and sometimes Si). Photosynthetic growth requires (sun)light, CO2, water and inorganic salts. Carbon dioxide must be fed continuously during daylight hours. Temperature must remain generally within 293 to 303 K. Seawater supplemented with commercial nitrate and phosphate fertilisers and other micronutrients is commonly used for growing marine microalgae. Mixotrophic growth reduces the need for light and reduces the use of CO2, which is expensive in large-scale culture. Heterotrophic growth of microalgae could eliminate the requirements for light, and thus may offer the possibility of greatly increasing the algal cell concentration and productivity on a large scale. However, only a few industrial heterotrophic processes are known, possibly due to a limited number of available heterotrophic algal species. Algae technology is unique in its ability to produce a useful, highvolume product from waste CO2, e.g. as generated in power plants. There are significant barriers to the large-scale production of algae. These include maintaining mass culture stability, developing low-cost algae harvesting methods and optimising strains for energy yields. For technically feasible and practical cultivation of microalgae, algae farms commonly produce in various types of outdoor open ‘raceway’ ponds, enclosed open-ponds or photobioreactors (including plastic algal bags). Fermenters are preferred for heterotrophically growing algae (Table 5.22). For an overview of microalgae production systems, see ref. [175]. Fundamental operational issues of raceway production ponds, in which algae, water and nutrients circulate around a racetrack with paddlewheels providing the flow (Fig. 5.6), are the effects of fluid flow patterns, light intensity, dissolved oxygen levels, temperature, pH and algae harvesting methods. The open ponds are shallow to keep the algae exposed to sunlight. Open ponds require relatively low investment but are sensitive to rainfall and drought, temperature fluctuations, high evaporative losses and pollution (e.g. takeover by low oil strains); introduction of CO2 is somewhat problematic. The use of simple open ponds was favoured by the US Aquatic Species Program. The view was held that the factors that most influence cost are biological, and not engineering related, if low cost ponds are used. There is no one ideal algae culture system. Table 5.22 Microalgal biomass production modes Technology a
Open ponds , photobioreactors Fermentation tanks a
b
Including enclosed open-ponds. Including tubes and algal bags.
b
Growth mechanism
Energy supply
Photoautotrophic Heterotrophic
hn, CO2, nutrients Sugars
176
Biodiesel science and technology
Water nutrients
Motorised paddle
Algae
Waste CO2
5.6 Open raceway pond for algae production (after ref. [163]). Table 5.23 Main characteristics of open-pond cultivation of photosynthetic microalgae Advantages: ∑ Exploitation of natural sunlight ∑ Relatively low investment Disadvantages: ∑ Pollution ∑ Seasonal and diurnal variations in conditions (T, hn) ∑ High evaporative losses ∑ Difficult prediction of growth rates and culture densities ∑ Self-shading ∑ Low cell densities ∑ Inefficient harvesting ∑ Relatively low biomass productivity ∑ Applicable to few genera (e.g. some diatoms)
Culture conditions determining growth rate, biochemical and fatty acid composition comprise aeration rate and irradiance, culture temperature, cell and nutrient concentrations. For example, the effect of light intensity on the growth of two marine microalgae, the eustigmatophyte Nannochloropsis oculata and the chrysophyte Isochrysis sp. has been reported [176]. Commercialscale cultivation of photosynthetic microalgae in large, open outdoor ponds has a number of disadvantages, as listed in Table 5.23. Phototropic algae production is preferably located in areas with higher inolation. One of the challenges with algae systems is when the algae density is high, as light then only penetrates a few centimetres into the culture. Self-shading severely limits biomass production, and low cell densities prevent efficient harvesting. Large-scale cultivation of microalgae in open ponds is restricted to a small subset of genera that includes Spirulina and Dunaliella.
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
177
Algae may be grown rapidly in ponds using fertilisers with subsequent transportation to nitrate-poor ponds to increase the oil production. Under mixotrophic conditions some microalgae are known to grow rapidly and to have a higher growth rate than under photoautotrophic conditions [177]. Suitable zones for algae production based on climate, land, water and fossil CO2 availability were identified in the southwestern USA, but are extendable to other geographical areas. Within ASP the concept of longterm, reliable large-scale production of algae in 1000 m2 outdoor open-pond systems in several US states (e.g. California, Hawaii and New Mexico) has been proven. Using native species of algae and careful control of pH and other physical conditions for introducing CO2 into the ponds allows very efficient (> 90%) utilisation of injected CO2 in large open ponds. Target levels of 50 g of algae/m2/day can be achieved under optimum conditions. Recently, most development work is focusing on photobioreactors (PBRs). Closed-loop or bioreactor systems grow algae in a controlled environment using a wide variety of production processes like plastic bags, tubes, or fermentation reactors. A tubular photobioreactor consists of an array of straight transparent tubes that are usually made of plastic or glass. Horizontal, parallel straight tubes are sometimes arranged like a fence. Also helical coil tubular photobioreactors have been described. Closed photoreactor systems, either flat panels (with higher, but more energy-intensive production) or tubular (l = 100–200 m, characterised by a relatively lower production), require a much smaller surface than open cultivation systems, and process control and optimisation of algal growth are improved. Closed-loop systems provide the advantage of additional control over seasonal temperature changes, evaporation losses and contamination by undesired algae strains. An advantage of such closed systems is that they protect the cultivation of a monoculture of algae. The University of Wageningen Research Centre (WUR) is developing algae for biofuel production using a variety of flat panel reactors. In a transparent tank or algal bag system algae are essentially exposed to light only in a few centimetres near the tank wall or surface where they react with CO2 and nutrients and photosynthesis occurs. Algae growth is limited in areas in which light cannot penetrate. However, the dark area allows more complex protein building to occur within the algae. Narrow diameter tubular reactors allow light to penetrate to the centre of the tube. The algae are constantly recirculated from the tube to a tank (for protein building). In tubular reactors, CO2 is supplied at entry. As photosynthesis generates oxygen, high concentrations of dissolved oxygen build up along the tubes. In combination with intense sunlight this may result in photooxidative damage to algal cells and consequently retarded algal growth. Degassing zones are needed as oxygen cannot be removed within a photobioreactor tube. Photobioreactors also suffer from internal wall growth of some algae. In order to reduce the problems of algae fouling and to avoid frequent tube
178
Biodiesel science and technology
cleaning, the flow rate through the tubing needs to be sufficient to induce turbulent flow. Nannochloropsis and Chlorella are species grown in tubular reactors to extremely good densities. Table 5.24 shows the benefits of a tubular reactor. Typically, the culture density of algae produced is 10–20 times greater than bag culture. Tubular reactors can be mounted vertically, horizontally, indoors or outdoors. Cultures are easily kept hygienically. Biomass recovery from photobioreactor-cultured broth costs only a fraction of the recovery cost for broth produced in raceways. Photobioreactors provide a controlled environment that can be tailored to the specific demands of highly productive microalgae to obtain a consistently high oil yield. Investment costs are higher than for open ponds. An energy balance model PBR-based algae system is needed. Dutch AlgaeLink NV is marketing industrial-scale closed algae photobioreactors as from the third quarter of 2007. The tubular systems (l = 36 m, F = 0.64 m), connected by a pumping system, are autocleaning with extensive monitoring and scalable for producing from 1 to 100 dry-weight tons of biomass per day. Demonstration plant produced algal oil costs only US 7 cents/L. Solix Biofuels (Colorado State University) has developed the Solix AGS photobioreactor production system; Varicon Aqua Solutions, Ltd. (Malvern, UK) and Scottish Bioenergy Cooperative Ventures (St. Cyrus, UK) are other technology providers. Culturing Solutions, Inc. (Pinellas Park, FL) operates a commercially available continuous algae production technology (BioFence) based on photoreactors. Large-scale commercial production of microalgae makes use of both raceway ponds (open culture systems) [163, 178] and tubular photobioreactors [179]. The largest raceway-based biomass production facility occupies a pond area of 440 000 m2 (108 acres) [155]. Raceways are perceived to be less expensive than photobioreactors, because they require a lower capital cost to build and operate. However, they have a considerably lower biomass productivity compared with photobioreactors. At a biomass production of 10 kt/yr, the production cost of one kg of microalgal biomass is about US$0.47 and US$0.60 for photobioreactors and raceways, respectively. At 30% oil content, the cost of biomass for providing a litre of microalgal oil would be US$1.40 and US$1.81 for photobioreactors and raceways, respectively. Oil Table 5.24 Key benefits of a tubular algae bioreactor ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Maximum light efficiency Space saving Reduced labour and handling problems Dramatically reduced fouling Reduced incidence of culture crashing Closed, controlled and automated systems Simple control of environmental parameters
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
179
recovered from biomass produced in photobioreactors is estimated to cost US$2.80/L [169], compared with US$0.52/L for CPO (2006). Reduction of the production cost of algal oil from about US$2.80/L to US$0.48/L is a strategic objective. The level of cost reduction is substantial, but attainable. Recently (April 2008) the price of crude algae oil was quoted as US$3.85/ gal. For algal biodiesel production costs, see Section 9.5. Locating algae processing plants strategically adds to their efficiency. Microalgae can be used directly in carbon capture. Microalgae have the highest carbon fixing rates of any plant. Algae can be produced in large volumes in nutrient-rich waste streams such as at the settling ponds of standard effluent management systems (EMS). Already in 1976 a combined wastewater treatment facility/fuel production system based on microalgae growing in open ponds was evaluated at the University of California Berkeley’s Richmond Field Station. Since then, the DOE has shifted emphasis to dedicated algae farming using vast areas with continuously operated open ponds of raceway design into which some source of waste CO2 (e.g. from fossil fuel-fired power plants) could be efficiently bubbled and captured by algae (Fig. 5.7). Locating algae facilities next to flue gas producing power plants or to other manufacturing plants (e.g. breweries, natural gas purification units) could sequester CO2 emissions to help grow algae in their photosynthesis. Most carbon capture research focuses on removing CO2 gas from power plant waste streams, which contain around 10%. Power plant CO2 capture is inevitably cheaper than air capture. Biomass produced by algae can be used for fuel, creating a carbon neutral scheme. The concept of a coal-fired power plant adjacent to an algae farm provides excellent synergy to recycle CO2 from coal combustion into a usable liquid fuel. Integrated processing technologies involving photobioreactors may tie algae production with nutrient sources from wastewater treatment (from human, animal and agricultural streams) and power plant emissions (Fig. 5.8). Eni refinery (Gela, Sicily) has recently started up an experimental plant (both open ponds and photobioreactors) for biofixation of fossil CO2 in air and wastewater effluents by microalgae for biodiesel production. Dow Chemical/Algenol Biofuels intend using CO2 emissions at Dow Freeport, TX, to produce bioethanol in algae-filled bioreactors. Closed bioreactor designs for algae production have been investigated in Japan, the US, France, Germany and The Netherlands. A suitable profile for freshwater algae cultivation is to put the cheap plastic tube bioreactors over sunny non-productive land adjacent to ample carbon sources such as smokestacks, farm runoff and sewage close to where the fuel is needed. GreenFuel’s Emissions-to-Biofuels™ (E2B™) technology uses algae to recycle CO2 coming out of the smokestack of the Arizona Public Service Company (APS) Redhawk (Arlington, AZ) 1040 MW power plant [180]. CO2 emissions are trapped and transferred to special containers (proprietary
180
Biodiesel science and technology
CO2 recovery system
Algal/oil recovery system
Fuel production
5.7 Algae farm consisting of a waste CO2 source and open raceway algae ponds (after ref. [163]).
Wastewater treatment plant
Nutrients
Power plant
Photobioreactor
Algal biomass
Biohydrogen
Methane Algal biodiesel Bioethanol
Bio-oil
5.8 Integrated algal biomass processing technology within a biorefinery context.
photosynthesis algal bioreactor system) holding algae. After harvesting the algae, its starches are turned into ethanol, its lipids into high-quality biodiesel, and its proteins into high-grade feed and nutritional supplements for livestock, or else are returned to the algae farm as nutrients (Fig. 5.9).
Feedstocks for biodiesel production CO2
181
Nutrients
Algae
Harvesting
Starch
Lipids
Proteins
Bioethanol
Biodiesel
Feed
5.9 Integrated algae farm.
E2BTM technology allows power plants to significantly reduce CO2 and NOx emissions (by 45% and 90%, respectively) to generate carbon credits, and produce clean, renewable biofuels. In a similar approach, Valcent Products, Inc. (El Paso, TX) has recently developed a commercial-scale bioreactor for algae-to-biofuels, consisting of a series of closely spaced vertical photobioreactors constructed of thin film membranes allowing high levels of light penetration (up to 1–1.5 inch) [181]. This so-called Vertigro biofuel oil/CO2 sequestration technology is ideal for location adjacent to heavy producers of CO2, such as coal-fired power plants, refineries or manufacturing facilities (cement factories, steel mills, etc.), can be deployed on non-arable land and requires very little water (only the amount bound to algae) due to its closed circuit process which eliminates cross-contamination by other algae species. The dynamic, high surface area system produces much higher algae growth rates than conventional static systems. The continuously operated test bed facility yields 4000 barrels of oil per acre, per year, at a cost of US$20 per barrel. In other words, 1000 acres have the potential of producing 4 million barrels per year, with significant CO2 green credits and other commercial products. In this way, about onetenth of New Mexico would suffice for the total energy needs of the US. Lipids produced, e.g. for jet fuel or diesel fuel, can be tailored on the basis of the algae species. Algae ponds the size of Maryland, US (3.4 Mha) would be able to supply the global aviation fuel needs (some 85 Bgy) [182]. In 2006 LiveFuels/Sandia National Laboratory formed a US national alliance dedicated to transforming algae into biocrude by the year 2010. Hurdles to be overcome for commercialisation include breeding various strains of algae and driving down the cost of harvesting and extraction of fats and oils. Theoretically, algae can yield 1000 to 20 000 gallons of oil per acre. ConocoPhillips (in cooperation with C2B2 – Colorado Center for
182
Biodiesel science and technology
Biorefining and Biofuels) is actively involved in strain collection, cultivation and extraction technologies of algae. In order to improve production economics, biotech company Solazyme, Inc. (San Francisco, CA) is modifying algae to grow in the dark in fermentation tanks, sustained by sugar, rather than photosynthetically in the open. See also Section 9.5. PetroSun Biofuels’ (PetroSun Inc., Rio Hondo, TX) pilot algae farm in Opelika, AL, has reached algal oil production between 5000 and 8000 gal/acre/yr. After extraction, the residual algae biomass can be made into ethanol or other products. In early 2008 PetroSun Biofuels, Inc. started the first commercial scale open-pond algae farm operations (157 separate ponds on 1100 acres) in the US for the production of oil for biodiesel feedstock near South Padre Island (TX). The open-pond system uses salt water and native marine algae species. The potential biodiesel production will be 4.4 Mgy. With the expected production of 32.6 t/ha/yr of diesel and 116 t/ha/yr of other biomass this corresponds to a photosynthesis efficiency of 4.7%, which is better than crop-based fuel production by a factor of 10–20. Algae farms and oil extraction plants are also planned in Alabama, Louisiana, California, Sonora (Mexico), Brazil and Australia. A pilot-scale algae-oil production facility (10 ha raceway) is being built on Torrens Island (South Australia) by Algal Fuels Consortium’s Microalgal Research Alliance. The novel, efficient and low-cost hybrid-algae production system (HAPS) to continuously extract oil and cellulose sugars from oil-bearing microalgae, developed by Biotech Research, Inc. (Ensenada, Mexico), allows conversion into biodiesel and cellulosic ethanol. The method also eliminates the need to mechanically dry and press-extract the algae oil. Green Star Products, Inc. (Chula Vista, CA) has operated a 40 kL HAPS demo plant in Butte, MT, through 2007–08. The unit, which is basically a covered pond system that combines the controlled environment of a photoreactor with the lower costs of an open-pond system, was robust enough to grow a strain of algae (ZX-13) at an outdoor temperature of 255 K. A commercial-sized harvesting from a pilot-scale algae pond (12 000 gal of water) was reported by the Center of Excellence for Hazardous Materials Management in Carlsbad, NM. Expectations are here that algal oil can be produced for approximately US$80/barrel. This is far below estimates of the US Defense Department of the current production cost of algae oil (in excess of US$20/gal). Appropriate climate, land, water and CO2 resource availability could easily supply several quads (quadrillion BTUs, or 1015 BTUs of energy) of algal biodiesel, which is substantially more than existing oilseed crops can provide. (A quad is a unit of energy often used to describe the amounts of energy that a given technology might be able to displace.) Some 200 000 ha (less than 0.1% of climatically suitable crop land areas in the US) could
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
183
produce one quad of fuel (approximately equivalent to 28 billion litres of oil). Microalgae appear to be the only source of biodiesel that has the potential of completely displacing fossil diesel. In one 1000 m2 pond yearly some 7600 L of algal oil can be produced, as compared to 190 L of oil from high-yield canola plants on an equivalent land area. Thus, while traditional crops have yields of around 50–150 gallons of biodiesel/acre/year, algae can yield 5000–20 000 gal/acre/year. According to Briggs [183], widescale biodiesel production from algae in 40 000 saltwater algae farms with a water surface of 250 acres each would ensure America’s diesel fuel independence. Between 2 and 6% of the total US cropping area (455 million acres) would be sufficient for producing algal biomass that satisfies all of the transport fuel needs. There is enough fossil CO2 available in the southwestern US states where climate conditions are suitable to support 2 to 7 quads of fuel production annually. The need for concentrated CO2 limits geographical location of algae ponds to locations next to power plants. Open ponds systems have been or are being developed also in Israel, Malaysia and Mozambique. The algae-biodiesel development company Aquaflow Bionomic Corp. Ltd, Marlborough (New Zealand), has produced B5 from wild microalgae harvested from local open-air sewage ponds and intends to produce 1 ML of ‘green-crude’ on a commercial scale in a 100acre facility as from 2007. Even in countries without abundant sunshine for the photosynthesis of algae, (unwanted) algal growth in ponds, pools and lakes is quite common. Therefore, manufacturing fuel from algae could also help such countries (e.g. in Western Europe) to meet their diesel fuel needs and carbon emission targets. UK’s Carbon Trust has recently launched an algal biofuels alternative. Braun [184] has described biodiesel derived from algal biomass grown under light and temperature conditions that prevail in The Netherlands. Microalgae cultivation allows wastewater treatment, abatement of fossil CO2, production of biodiesel from algal oil, and production of fertilisers. Algae technology offers the opportunity to utilise land and water resources that are unsuited for other use. Land is hardly a limitation. Microalgae systems also use far less water than traditional oilseed crops. Algal production is a closed loop process which allows water to be filtered and reused. Resource limitations are therefore not an argument against algal biodiesel technology. Algae production offers medium- to long-term prospects for the biodiesel industry. It is not the conversion of algae to biofuels that is difficult. The real challenge is producing adequate feedstock. Algae are unlikely to be a viable feedstock option for biodiesel, biocrude and bioethanol for at least 5 to 10 years. Commercial production of significant quantities of algae oil for energy is expected by the year 2015. Prospects of phototropic culture of algae for biodiesel are long term [185].
184
Biodiesel science and technology
Successful application of algae for biodiesel production requires: suitable fresh or salt water supplies, excess CO2 (preferably pond locations next to power plants), efficient and cost-effective oil extraction and high investment costs. Microalgae can be used to capture and reutilise concentrated fossil CO2 emitted by refineries. Before storage lipids of microalgae can be transformed, they must be extracted. Several processes for algal oil extraction have been developed, such as physical or chemical extraction, and thermochemical liquefaction (at high T, p) [186]. Algal oil extraction methods have achieved oil yields of 30–40%. Fermentation technology Growing conventional, photosynthetic algae in the open requires dealing with the variability of the environment, light limitations and contamination with microbes. Fermenters provide controlled, sterile growth conditions. Heterotrophic growth of algae in conventional microbial fermenters in the absence of light can improve the efficiency, maximise productivity, and reduce the cost of microalgal biomass production. In this case, glucose or other forms of organic carbon, rather than light, supply energy. However, as most microalgae are obligate photoautotrophs and unable to grow on fixed carbon compounds [187], the use of fermentation technology is limited. Table 5.25 lists the main characteristics of fermentation technology applied to microalgal biomass. Chlorella protothecoides is a green autotrophic alga that can be grown photoautotrophically or heterotrophically under different conditions. Heterotrophic growth of C. protothecoides results in the accumulation of high lipid contents (55%) in cells, which is several times that in autotrophic cells (14%) [158, 188, 189]. Large amounts of microalgal oil are efficiently extracted from these heterotrophic cells by using n-hexane. To increase the biomass and reduce the cost of microalgal oil production, corn powder hydrolysate instead of glucose can be used as an organic carbon source in the heterotrophic culture medium in fermenters. Table 5.25 Use of fermentation technology in microalgal biomass production Advantages: ∑ Use of conventional microbial fermenters ∑ High productivity, improved efficiency ∑ Reduced production cost ∑ Controlled, sterile growth conditions ∑ Eliminates contamination by microbes ∑ Absence of light Disadvantages: ∑ Applicability limited to few natural or GM algal strains
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
185
Microalgal metabolism may also be genetically engineered for high rates of heterotrophic growth. This extends the applicability of fermentation technology. Focus on scale and production economics are the main drivers to modify algae to grow in the dark in fermentation tanks, sustained by sugar, rather than photosynthetically in the open. Recently, Martek Bioscience Corp. (Columbia, MD) first introduced a fundamental metabolic change in singlecelled algae so that it no longer requires light to grow [190]. The diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum was genetically engineered to thrive exclusively on exogenous glucose in the absence of light through the introduction of a gene encoding a glucose transporter. This demonstrates that a fundamental change in the metabolism of an organism can be accomplished through the introduction of a single gene. This breakthrough is expected to allow for large-scale, high-density, cost-effective cultivation of algae using fermentation technology. Commercial exploitation of metabolically engineered microalgae requires high rates of exogenous glucose-dependent growth and the achievement of high cell densities. Fermentation-based systems can reduce production costs of microalgae by an order of magnitude relative to that incurred by photosynthesisbased production. The ability to grow microalgae heterotrophically increases the feasibility for developing a large range of new algal products.
5.7.3 Macroalgae Seaweeds are classified into three groups: brown, red and green. Seaweed is primarily grown in the Eastern hemisphere to produce fertiliser and food/ feed but holds potential also for other biomass applications. Farmed seaweed production amounts to 8 Mt/yr. In US Patent No. 7,135,308 B1 Bush and Hall [156] describe cellular decay of starch-accumulating, filament-forming or colony-forming macroalgae (Spirogyra, Cladophora or Oedogonium spp.) in an anaerobic environment followed by fermentation in the presence of a yeast (forming bioethanol) and recovering of the lipids/oils in the residual biomass for conversion into biodiesel. On the whole, the use of macroalgae for the production of biodiesel has found limited interest, which is related to their low oil content [191, 192]. Aresta et al. [191] used scCO2 extraction and thermochemical liquefaction to process a green macroalga from the Mediterranean (Chaetomorpha linum; Cladophorales, Chlorophyta). Thermochemical liquefaction (TL) of algae uses moderate T (523–668 K) and p (3 MPa) and can be applied on wet material. Algal oil composition varies with extraction methodology and TL temperature (see Table 5.26). Within the thermochemical technologies for biofuel production from algae, liquefaction requires lower energy input than pyrolysis [191]. Because of the low permeability and resistance of the cell membrane of the algae, the efficacy of scCO2 extraction depends on
186
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.26 Fatty acid composition of Chaetomorpha linum macroalgal oil (after ref. [191]) Procedurea
Composition (wt%)
14:0 16:0 16:1 18:0 18:1 18:2 20:0 20:4 20:6 24:0 Other FAsb
scCO2 extraction 9.8 TL @ 523 K 7.4 a
32.0 3.3 1.5 14.2 21.4 0.3 1.6 21.5 3.2 2.4 14.9 14.4 0.7 1.2
2.6 0.6 18.3 1.6 0.7 15.6
TL, thermochemical liquefaction. Other FAs identified: 15 : 0, 17 : 0, 14 : 1, 16 : 2, 16 : 3, 18 : 3, 18 : 4, 20 : 2, 22 : 5.
b
the pre-treatment (liquid N2 crashing of cells). This methodology does not allow direct use of fresh-wet biomass, but a soft preliminary dry treatment (using solar energy) is required. scCO2 extracts only 4.5 wt% oil from C. linum as opposed to 8 wt% by TL at 668 K. However, in the latter operating conditions decomposition of fatty acids may occur. Both processes also extract phytols. The lipid content (% dry weight) of four species of macroalgae, Ulva lactuca L. (Chlorophyta), Enteromorpha compressa L. Greville (Chlorophyta), Padina pavonica L. Thivy (Phaeophyta) and Laurencia obtusa (Hudson) Lamouroux (Rhodophyta), was reported in the range of 6.6% in E. compressa to 2.4% in L. obtusa [193]. Polyunsaturated fatty acids represented 50.1 to 68.1% of the total fatty acids, with SFAs accounting for 15.0–23.7% of total fatty acids and MFAs 9.0–18.7%. The biochemical composition of marine benthic algae, particularly members of Rhodophyta and Phaeophyta, has received limited attention. Oil from two other species of macroalgae (Gracilariopsis longissima (Rhodophyceae) and Chaetomorpha linum (Ulvophyceae)) were also evaluated for their biofuel potential [192]. Lipid concentrations were 1.87% in G. longissima and 2.40% (fresh mass) in C. linum. Large-scale seaweed cultivation has potential for bioenergy applications. With a 2% recoverable oil content on a dry-weight basis, 1000 L (264 gal) of oil/ha/yr can be obtained from seaweed [194]. From the point of view of natural resource exploitation and energy requirements, macroalgae oil extraction for biodiesel production is nowadays not profitable on the basis of the actual oil yield. Oil yields for biodiesel applications can eventually be increased by selecting and developing seaweed strains or by genetic manipulation methods. Once the oil is extracted, the seaweed biomass may then further be used for alcohol production. Ethanol yield is expected at about 40% of the biomass yield on a dry weight basis, i.e. 20 000 L of ethanol/ha/yr. After ethanol production, a considerable amount of residue is left, which can be burned to generate electricity. Seaweed farming could also be developed using domestic wastewater as a nutritional resource (Fig. 5.10).
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
187
Biodiesel Domestic wastewater
Seaweed
Ethanol Electricity
5.10 Potential benefits of seaweed farming.
Spontaneous macroalgae are best considered as a residual biomass for energy uses other than biodiesel (bio-oil, biomethanol, methane for power generation). Europe is planning several algae power plants. The potential of biomass production at sea is still to be explored. Seaweed farming could develop on the Pacific coasts of North and South America, and in the Caribbean. Seaweeds grow well also at low temperatures. One of the most important issues with algae utilisation for energy purposes is their high water content (up to 80–90%).
5.8
Oleaginous microorganisms
Microorganisms are the single-celled entities at the bottom of the food chain. Microorganisms, especially oleaginous moulds, have the capacity to convert a number of raw materials into value-added products, such as oils and fats [195–197]. The oils thus produced are known as single-cell oils (SCO) and are a potential starting material for the production of biodiesel. The best producers with the highest oil contents (up to 70%) are various species of yeasts and fungi with several key algae that are also able to produce high levels of nutritionally important PUFA. Oleaginous microorganisms can accumulate lipids, rapidly, independently of seasons or climates, and grow well on nutritional agro-industrial residues. Although microorganisms have long been known as producers of edible oils, opportunities for their biotechnological exploitation may prove economical only for specialised high-value products (nutraceuticals) [198]. Oils from moulds contain medium-chain fatty acids (C8-C12) to long-chain fatty acids (C22-C24) [199]. Bacteria and fungi, as well as algae (see Section 5.7), often produce polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) of both the n-6 and n-3 series. Many microbial PUFA oils are characterised by the absence of other PUFAs. Polyunsaturated fatty acids, in particular oleic and linolenic acid, are usually present in abundance in fungal lipids. For the purpose of biodiesel production in Europe the C18:3 content is restricted (see Table 12.6). Carbohydrate-based microbial oils consist of similar fatty acids as plant oils, but no such cost-effective oils are yet available. The fatty acid profiles of fungal lipids obtained from oleaginous moulds on a Czapek-Dox (sucrosebased) medium indicate that single-cell oils harvested from Aspergillus sydowii, Fusarium oxysporum and F. equisetti are rich in oleic acid (46.0–62.9%), with similarity to groundnut and palm oil [200]. The composition of oil from A.
188
Biodiesel science and technology
nidulans is largely saturated fatty acids. The fatty acid profile of the fungus F. oxysporum grown on glucose medium has been found to resemble edible palm oil [201]. The same organisms, when grown on sucrose as a carbon source, showed interconversion between C16:0 and C18:0 acids. Fungal oils prepared from Mortierella alpina are very rich in arachidonic (C20:4n-6) acids (29.2–46.3%) [196, 202]. Biodiesel has been produced in a combined microbial/chemical process in which Cryptococcus curvatus in a sterile whey fraction produces an intracellular fatty acid-rich triglyceride single-cell oil [203]. After disruption of the cells, the oil is removed from the culture broth and cell fragments and is directly subjected to known chemical treatment to produce FAME. Oleaginous yeasts studied for biodiesel preparation include Trichosporon fermentans on waste molasses [204], Lipomyces starkeyi on sewage sludge [205], amongst others. A combination of bacteria, yeast and fungi oil for biodiesel production can be obtained from municipal wastewater plant microorganisms and seafood industry waste [206]. The process is based on the conversion of sugar from waste into fats that can be extracted. Potentially, instead of microalgae, oil producing heterotrophic microorganisms [198, 207] grown on a natural organic carbon source such as sugar, can be used to make biodiesel. However, heterotrophic production is not as efficient as using photosynthetic microalgae. This is because the renewable organic carbon sources required for growing heterotrophic microorganisms are produced ultimately by photosynthesis, usually in crop plants. The commercial outlook for the production of microbial lipids for edible and non-edible industrial purposes is still remote. In particular, the commercial reality of conversion of microbial lipids (yeast or fungal SCOs, algal oils) into biodiesel cannot at this point make a strong case [208].
5.9
Non-edible oilseeds
Alternative feedstocks for biodiesel and renewable diesel fuels are non-food crops and food crop residues. Non-food feedstocks are playing a vital role in the biodiesel market, both for economic and environmental reasons. Oils that contain toxic substances in their seeds and therefore do not conflict with food resources may eventually be good candidates for future worldwide production and supply of plant oils for the biodiesel industry. These include curcas oil (physic nut oil) from Jatropha curcas, and oils from the sandbox tree (Hura crepitans) and sea mango tree (Cerbera manghas). For these and other oils (e.g. Shorea robusta, Mallotus philippines, Hevea brasiliensis, Salvadora oleiodes, Mesua ferrea L., and Garcinia indica) an economical and sustainable system with an appropriate production method must be developed, from the collection of oils/fats as virgin or waste, and their supply
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
189
to the market as the final products. Non-edible rubber (Hevea brasiliensis) seed oil (AV, 1 mg KOH/g; SN, 185.8 mg KOH/g; IV 142.6 g I2/100 g), of limited industrial use, has been transesterified by base-catalysis (NaOH) in 84% yield [209]. Moisture content of the oil is moderately high (3.7%) and may cause serious degradation of the fatty materials by hydrolysis, thus imposing the need for drying. Production of biodiesel using unrefined, highFFA rubber seed oil (C16 : 0, 10.2%; C18 : 0, 8.7%; C18 : 1, 24.6%; C18 : 2, 39.6%; C18 : 3, 16.3%; SFA, 19%; MUFA, 25%; PUFA, 56%; AV 34 mg KOH/g) requires a two-step transesterification process [210]. At present, the market is mainly investing in new, non-edible raw materials such as algae, Jatropha, camelina, mustard, seashore mallow and brown grease. One must remain realistic about the amount of time required to fully benefit from these investments. Moreover, large-scale cultivation of non-food oil crops is not even a panacea for biofuels, as large amounts of toxic meal are co-produced, for example using castor beans, jatropha, pongamia, undi, etc. [22]. Crambe (Crambe abyssinica) is a member of the Brassicaceae family. The herbaceous annual is also known as Ethiopian kale, Abyssinian mustard, Abyssinian kale, colewart and katran. Crambe, a drought-tolerant, low-input, industrial oilseed, has been grown and processed on a commercial scale in North Dakota (US) since 1990 [211]. Production area is limited (30 000 to 60 000 acres). Crambe has a higher concentration of erucic acid (> 55% C22:1) than most other species (see Table 5.1) and low FFA contents (< 0.5%). Crambe has been developed mainly as a source of erucic acid but shows promise of becoming a new industrial oil crop [212]. Crambe oil and HERO can be considered as the most important vegetable oils for lubricating purposes. Their high unsaturated fatty acid contents negatively influence the oxidative stability. The many advantages of cardoon or artichoke (Cynara cardunculus L.), namely low cost of production, capability of growing in harsh climatic conditions, and no competition with the food market or chemical industry, make it an ideal raw material for biodiesel production. Cultivation of cardoon as a non-food crop for energy (and as a suitable source of cellulose fibres) using abandoned croplands has been proposed [213]. Cardoon belongs to the Asteraceae family (Compositae), which also includes sunflower and safflower, and yields oil characterised by a fatty acid composition similar to (conventional) SNO (see Table 5.1). Cardoon oil contains about 1% FFA (as oleic acid). Biodiesel obtained from cynara oil has fairly suitable characteristics but for CN (48.6) and IV (118–125 g I2/hg), slightly beyond EN 14214 limits [14]. Cloud and pour points indicate potential difficult cold starts. In-situ transesterification of C. cardunculus seeds to obtain biodiesel has been evaluated [214]. Spanish research outfit Technatom is heading the BIOCARD programme to improve the exploitation of this energy
190
Biodiesel science and technology
crop. Though cardoon is considered suitable for Mediterranean areas with problems of water sufficiency, early research programmes have not proved very successful so far. Castor beans (Ricinus communis) grow on marginal lands, require little rainfall (15–18 in./yr), and can withstand long periods of drought. Castor bean (Mamona) cultivation is low maintenance, but machine harvesting needs to be developed. The poisonous plant provides beans with a high oil content; the cake contains toxins. The enzymatic production of biodiesel from castor oil has been reported [15]. Castor bean oil is an option for fuel production because it does not compete with food crops for arable land space. Castor oil is considered as a most important feedstock for perennial crops for biodiesel in arid North-East Brazil. Jamaica has also selected castor beans as a biodiesel feedstock. Castor beans yield approximately 47–49% of oil. With an oilseed productivity of 700–1200 kg/ha, some 500 L biodiesel/ha can be generated. As pointed out elsewhere (Sections 3.4, 3.5 and 6.4.6), castor oil is valuable both as an oleochemical multipurpose resource (soaps, perfumes, paints, plastics industry) and for lubricity enhancing applications. Biodiesel obtained from castor oil has a lower cost compared to that obtained from other oils, as transesterification occurs at room temperature because of its unusual solubility in alcohols. It appears, however, that castor oil may not prove to be a good raw material for the production of biodiesel [215, 216]. Even if high yields of biodiesel are obtained, the viscosity of castor biodiesel (13.75 mm2/s, as compared to 3.2 mm2/s for mineral diesel) would cause a problem for most practical diesel engines. The fringe oilseed crop Camelina sativa L. (Brassicaceae), commonly known as gold-of-pleasure, false flax, or linseed dodder, is considered as a promising potential oil crop for non-food industrial applications [217, 218]. The under-exploited canola relative is a short-season crop (85 to 100 days) that is well suited for marginally productive soils and has low harvesting costs and a lower break-even cost than soybeans, wheat or canola. Camelina varieties have been developed which require little water or fertiliser. Camelina seeds are small (220 000 to 450 000 seeds/lb), and oil content is 29–41%, but 38–40% in some varieties. Its yields are impressive with 1200 to 1500 lbs/acre, up to 2400 lbs, compared with 1000 lbs for canola. The crop is of interest for its very low requirements for tillage and weed control. Camelina has been grown for millennia in parts of Europe, but is a relatively new crop to the US. Camelina is an annual or winter annual crop, fit for cool regions where canola production is difficult (e.g. northern US states). As camelina does not yet have GRAS status from federal US agencies, all of the oil is eventually going towards biodiesel production. The oil and meal by-product of camelina can be used in cosmetics, for protein enrichment in animal feeds, as a fuel additive, a barrier to prevent weed emergence, and for the biofuel and by-product industries. Limited research has been done
Feedstocks for biodiesel production
191
to determine its full agronomic potential. NACTA is promoting camelina development. Sustainable Oils, Inc. (Bozeman, MT) is currently evaluating the agronomic characteristics, grain yield and oil quality attributes of more than 120 breeding populations on 40 trials across North America. Many different views exist in regard to Camelina’s oil composition: C18:1, 14–20%; C18:2, 15–25%; C18:3, 35–45%; C20:1, 15–20%; C22:1, 1–3%. C. sativa oil is considered a high-quality oil, low in saturated fatty acids and with exceptionally high levels (up to 45%) of omega-3 fatty acids, which is uncommon in vegetable sources. Camelina’s high percentage of PUFAs (> 50%) makes it more susceptible to oxidation (despite a substantial amount of natural antioxidants), thereby making it undesirable for biodiesel production. C. sativa is fast drying. So far, there is no commercial use for the oil. The viability of Camelina as a feedstock for biodiesel application remains to be seen [218]. Although camelina oil has been considered for biodiesel production [16, 217, 219, 220] its potential high value (due to the important nutritional components a-linolenic acid and g-tocopherol) may preclude its future use as a biofuel feedstock. The price of camelina biodiesel is currently about US$6/gal; the challenge is to make camelina biodiesel affordable. Further research is necessary to develop it into a strong potential biodiesel feedstock. It has been reported that camelina biodiesel meets the ASTM standards with good cold-flow properties (PP, 248 K; CP, 258 K; CFPP, 270 K), oxidative stability and low phosphorous [221]. Early 2009, Japan Airlines has carried out a demo flight fueled in part by camelina. In Europe, where camelina oil has been used in biodiesel for several years, extensive tests determined that fuel properties are within specifications with the exception of cold filter plug point (CFPP). The CFPP additive CP7134 has been approved in Ireland, making the camelina CFPP acceptable at winter temperatures. However, for commercial use of biodiesel it seems necessary to reduce the content of highly unsaturated fatty acids in C. sativa. The high C18:3 content (35–45%) – though not as high as in flax oil – is incompatible with EN 14214 specifications. Büchsenschütz-Nothdurft et al. [222] have described breeding for modified fatty acid composition via mutagenesis in Camelina sativa (L.) Crtz. Aloe vera (Asphodelaceae family) is used as a cosmetic and medicinal remedy. Aloe vera seed oil (AVSO) may be used for biodiesel production [223]. The oil content of AVSO is about 20–22 wt%; SFA amounts to 12%. The high unsaturated fatty acid content (87%) imparts the properties of low melting point and low viscosity. AVSO properties are quite similar to those of conventional SNO. Also tobacco and rubber seed oils have been considered as an alternative diesel fuel [209, 224]. The Indian and Chinese challenge is food or fuel. India accounts for about 10% of global oilseed production, in particular SBO, CNO, CSO, PNO, RSO
192
Biodiesel science and technology
Table 5.27 Chemical composition of some Indian vegetable oils (after ref. [225]) Vegetable
Fatty acid composition, wt.%
oil
14:0
16:0
18:0
20:0
24:0
18:1
18:2
Sal Mahua Neem Karanja Rice bran
– – 0.2–0.3 – 0.4–0.6
4.5–8.6 16.0–28.2 13.6–16.2 3.7–7.9 11.7–16.5
34.2–44.8 20.0–25.1 14.4–24.1 2.4–8.9 1.7–2.5
6.3–12.2 0.0–3.3 0.8–3.4 – 0.4–0.6
– – – 1.1–3.5 0.4–0.9
34.2–44.8 41.0–51.0 49.1–61.9 44.5–71.3 39.2–43.7
2.7 8.9–13.7 2.3–15.8 10.8–18.3 26.4–35.1
Table 5.28 Non-edible Indian oil sources (after ref. [225]) Oil
Botanical name
Potential (kt)
Utilised (kt)
Utilisation (%)
Rice bran Sal Neem Karanja
Oryza sativa Shorea robusta Azadirachta indica Pongamia pinnata
474 720 400 135
101 23 20 8
21