Bram Stoker A Literary Life
Lisa Hopkins
Literary Lives Founding Editor: Richard Dutton, Professor of English, Lancas...
104 downloads
2141 Views
527KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Bram Stoker A Literary Life
Lisa Hopkins
Literary Lives Founding Editor: Richard Dutton, Professor of English, Lancaster University This series offers stimulating accounts of the literary careers of the most admired and influential English-language authors. Volumes follow the outline of the writers’ working lives, not in the spirit of traditional biography, but aiming to trace the professional, publishing and social contexts which shaped their writing. Published titles include: Clinton Machann MATTHEW ARNOLD
Kerry McSweeney GEORGE ELIOT
Jan Fergus JANE AUSTEN
Tony Sharpe T. S. ELIOT
John Beer WILLIAM BLAKE
Harold Pagliaro HENRY FIELDING
Tom Winnifrith and Edward Chitham CHARLOTTE AND EMILY BRONTË
Andrew Hook F. SCOTT FITZGERALD
Sarah Wood ROBERT BROWNING
Mary Lago E. M. FORSTER
Janice Farrar Thaddeus FRANCES BURNEY
Shirley Foster ELIZABETH GASKELL
Caroline Franklin BYRON
Neil Sinyard GRAHAM GREENE
Sarah Gamble ANGELA CARTER
James Gibson THOMAS HARDY
Nancy A. Walker KATE CHOPIN
Cristina Malcolmson GEORGE HERBERT
Roger Sales JOHN CLARE
Gerald Robert GERARD MANLEY HOPKINS
Cedric Watts JOSEPH CONRAD
Neil Roberts TED HUGHES
Grahame Smith CHARLES DICKENS
Kenneth Graham HENRY JAMES
George Parfitt JOHN DONNE
W. David Kaye BEN JONSON
Paul Hammond JOHN DRYDEN
Philip Mallett RUDYARD KIPLING
John Worthen D. H. LAWRENCE
Gary Waller EDMUND SPENSER
William Gray ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON
Tony Sharpe WALLACE STEVENS
Angela Smith KATHERINE MANSFIELD
Lisa Hopkins BRAM STOKER
Lisa Hopkins CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE
Joseph McMinn JONATHAN SWIFT
Cedric C. Brown JOHN MILTON
William Christie SAMUEL TAYLOR COLERIDGE
Peter Davison GEORGE ORWELL
Leonée Ormond ALFRED TENNYSON
Linda Wagner-Martin SYLVIA PLATH
Peter Shilingsburg WILLIAM MAKEPEACE THACKERAY
Felicity Rosslyn ALEXANDER POPE
David Wykes EVELYN WAUGH
Ira B. Nadel EZRA POUND
Caroline Franklin MARY WOLLSTONECRAFT
Richard Dutton WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE
John Mepham VIRGINIA WOOLF
John Williams MARY SHELLEY
John Williams WILLIAM WORDSWORTH
Michael O’Neill PERCY BYSSHE SHELLEY
Alasdair D. F. Macrae W. B. YEATS
Literary Lives Series Standing Order ISBN 0–333–71486–5 hardcover Series Standing Order ISBN 0–333–80334–5 paperback (outside North America only) You can receive future titles in this series as they are published by placing a standing order. Please contact your bookseller or, in case of difficulty, write to us at the address below with your name and address, the title of the series and the ISBN quoted above. Customer Services Department, Macmillan Distribution Ltd, Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS, England
Bram Stoker A Literary Life Lisa Hopkins
© Lisa Hopkins 2007 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted her right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2007 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN 13: 978–1–4039–4647–8 hardback ISBN 10: 1–4039–4647–7 hardback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Hopkins, Lisa, 1962– Bram Stoker : a literary life / Lisa Hopkins. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1–4039–4647–7 (cloth) 1. Stoker, Bram, 1847–1912. 2. Novelists, English–19th century– Biography. 3. Theatrical managers–Great Britain–Biography. 4. Dracula, Count (Fictitious character) 5. Horror tales–Authorship. I Title. PR6037.T617Z675 2007 823′.8–dc22 [B] 10 16
9 15
8 14
7 13
6 12
5 11
2006049825 4 10
3 09
2 08
1 07
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham and Eastbourne
In memory of Mike Davis
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Acknowledgements
viii
Abbreviations
ix
Editions Cited
x
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 1 Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 2 At the Theatre 3 London with its Teeming Millions 4 On Holiday 5 The Cave Conclusion
1 23 47 69 91 121 149
Notes
151
Works Cited
165
Index
171
vii
Acknowledgements I would like to thank Scott McCracken, for his very helpful comments on the first draft of the last chapter; Michael Worboys, for help with the history of syphilis; Mary and Derek Grover; my father, for supplying Mozart books and taking me to Lourdes; the anonymous reader for Palgrave; Karin Brown, for kindly photocopying for me the phrenological report on Henry Irving; the interlibrary loan staff at the Mary Badland Library, Sheffield Hallam University, who have as always gone well beyond the call of duty; and my colleagues at Sheffield Hallam for being, also as always, models of collegiality. Andy Smith and Bill Hughes have been helpful in all things Stokerian for a long time now, and Chris and Sam make everything possible. This book is for Mike, who should have been here to read it. An earlier version of a small part of Chapter 1 appeared as ‘Vampires and Snakes: Monstrosity and Motherhood in Bram Stoker’, Irish Studies Review 19 (summer 1997), 5–8.
viii
Abbreviations D DG FI Jewel LA Man MB MT Mystery PP PR Shasta Shroud Snowbound SP WM WW
Dracula Dracula’s Guest Famous Impostors The Jewel of Seven Stars Lady Athlyne The Man Miss Betty Midnight Tales The Mystery of the Sea The Primrose Path Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving The Shoulder of Shasta The Lady of the Shroud Snowbound: The Record of a Theatrical Touring Party The Snake’s Pass The Watter’s Mou’ The Lair of the White Worm
ix
Editions Cited Dracula [1897], ed. A. N. Wilson (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1983) Dracula’s Guest [1914] (Dingle, Co. Kerry: 1990) Famous Impostors (London: Sidgwick & Jackson, 1910) Lady Athlyne (London: William Heinemann, 1908) The Lady of the Shroud [1909] (Stroud: Alan Sutton, 1994) The Lair of the White Worm [1911] (London: Brandon, 1991) The Man (London: William Heinemann, 1905) Midnight Tales, ed. Peter Haining (London: Peter Owen, 1990) Miss Betty [1898] (London: New English Library, 1974) The Mystery of The Sea [1902] (Stroud: Sutton, 1997) Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving (London: William Heinemann, 1906), 2 vols The Primrose Path [1875], introduced by Richard Dalby (Westcliffon-Sea: Desert Island Books, 1999) The Shoulder of Shasta [1895], ed. Alan Johnson (Westcliff-on-Sea: Desert Island Books, 2000) The Snake’s Pass [1890] (London: Brandon, 1990) Snowbound: The Record of a Theatrical Touring Party [1908], ed. Bruce Wightman (Westcliff-on-Sea: Desert Island Books, 2000) The Watter’s Mou’ [1895] (Doylestown, PA: Wildside Press, n.d.)
x
Introduction: Stoker’s Book
Bram Stoker wrote 18 books.1 I am well aware that the primary if not the only interest of most readers of this book will be in Dracula, and I have therefore included some discussion of Dracula in four of the five chapters (the exception is the last, since the kind of readings which I offer there of lesser-known texts are already readily available elsewhere for Dracula). However, Dracula alone cannot give a full sense of either the range of Stoker’s interests or of the pressures and contexts that conditioned the creation of his most famous novel. Even the weakest and most disregarded of Stoker’s other fictions – The Shoulder of Shasta, Miss Betty, The Primrose Path – are interesting in this respect, and the more significant works – particularly The Jewel of Seven Stars and The Lady of the Shroud, but also The Mystery of the Sea – are well worth attending to in their own right as well as for what they can tell us about Dracula and its creator. I have, therefore, ranged widely over Stoker’s fiction and also his non-fiction, since his Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving and Famous Impostors in particular reveal much not only about Stoker’s life but also about the concerns which dominate his fiction. I began by observing that Stoker is popularly remembered only for one book when he also wrote 17 others. In one sense, however, Stoker did not write 17 other books: although it is true that his factual works are distinctively different, when it comes to his fiction, there is a sense in which he wrote Dracula many times over and called it a variety of different things. There are certainly numerous overlaps and recurrences between Dracula and his other novels. In Dracula, for instance, Mina writes while in Whitby that ‘I keep 1
2 Bram Stoker
the key of our door always fastened to my wrist at night’ (D: 95). This directly foreshadows The Jewel of Seven Stars, which David Glover calls ‘a kind of sequel to Dracula’,2 where Mr Trelawny too sleeps with a key fastened to his wrist. Also in Dracula, Seward thinks that Lucy’s ‘whole bed would have been drenched to a scarlet with the blood which the girl must have lost to leave such a pallor as she had before the transfusion’ (D: 123–4); Mr Trelawny’s bed too is so drenched. Later, Seward remarks on opening Lucy’s coffin, ‘It seemed to be as much an affront to the dead as it would have been to have stripped off her clothing in her sleep whilst living’ (D: 197); in The Jewel of Seven Stars Margaret Trelawny has precisely similar qualms about the unveiling of Queen Tera. Other works also share similarities. As Jeffrey Richards remarks, ‘Both Athlyne [in Lady Athlyne] on seeing Joy and Arthur Severn [in The Snake’s Pass] on seeing Norah exclaim “Here by God’s rood is the one maid for me”, echoing Sir Geraint in Tennyson’s Idylls of the King’, and Joy echoes the language used of Dracula when she ‘had seen Him pass into the garden opposite to the hotel and go secretively behind some lilac bushes opposite the doorway’ (LA: 141), while both The Man and The Snake’s Pass contain reference to the church at Hythe.3 David Glover compares The Snake’s Pass with Dracula,4 while Cannon Schmitt argues that ‘Orientalism, the West’s construction of a reified and stereotyped East, is arguably the dominant discourse in Dracula’ and claims that ‘Written at the zenith of European imperial expansion, between the Berlin Conference of 1884 and the outbreak of the Boer War in 1899, Dracula takes shape at that moment when widespread armed conflict among European nations over territorial possessions, although temporarily suspended, must have appeared inevitable’.5 This makes Dracula sound like nothing so much as The Lady of the Shroud, and indeed that novel has in many ways as good a claim to be called a sequel to Dracula as The Jewel of Seven Stars has. Stoker’s great-nephew Daniel Farson, meanwhile, even though he declares of the other books that ‘Candidly, most of them might have been written by another author’,6 compares The Lair of the White Worm to Dracula, pointing out that ‘The two heroines are Lilla and Mimi, as against Lucy and Mina. Lilla is the virtuous victim; Mimi becomes Adam’s wife’ and that ‘Like Count Dracula, the Worm moves with the vital protection of darkness’.7
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 3
There certainly are similarities between The Lair of the White Worm and Stoker’s other texts. Adam thinks he has a second-sight vision (WW: 38), as Aunt Janet does in The Lady of the Shroud or as Miss Betty has an intuition so strong it is like second sight (MB: 91–2); the effect of the absence of birds in Lair is like that of the plague in Under the Sunset. Like Dracula, The Lair of the White Worm is interested in doubling – Richard Salton’s remark to Adam that ‘It is not every day that an heir to the old house comes back’ (WW: 10) proves the ironic preface to his announcement of the imminent return of precisely such another heir, Edgar Caswall. Caswall moves and opens the chest in his sleep (WW: 70), making this part of the novel a version of the same kind of locked-room-mystery logic that structures The Jewel of Seven Stars. Equally, Caswall’s remark to Mimi on the turret roof of Castra Regis, ‘When the Master of Evil took Christ up on a high place and showed Him all the kingdoms of the earth, he was doing what he thought no other could do. He was wrong – he forgot Me’ (WW: 148), recalls Miss Gimp’s acid observation about Dick in The Shoulder of Shasta: ‘Wants to show her all the kingdoms of the earth from a high place! We know what to make of him!’ (Shasta: 45). The Shoulder of Shasta also has parallels with other Stoker texts. Like Lucy, Esse has been suffering from disturbed nights. Esse’s colour comes and goes as Lucy’s will (Shasta: 109), and after carrying Dick home she arrives dressed in white and covered with blood, evoking in her mother’s mind ‘all sorts of unknown possibilities of horror’ (WW: 77). The evocation of Dracula is complete when Dick says of Esse, ‘ye may take the full of her purty little body of blood out of my veins for her, if that will do her any good!’ (Shasta: 105). Finally, an eerie collapse of Dracula and Stoker’s short story ‘The Secret of the Growing Gold’ is effected when the Indian regards Mrs Elstree’s hair as likely to cover some actual gold and ‘in the agonizing suspense she could hear – or thought she could – the blood running through the veins of her neck’ (Shasta: 50). If Stoker effectively wrote only one work of fiction, what does it mean? Here we touch directly on the whole question of what a literary life is. This book is not in any sense a biography of Stoker, of which there are already several available, but an attempt to locate his fiction in its biographical and cultural contexts. This is made
4 Bram Stoker
both easier and harder by the fact that Stoker’s own life, like that of so many of his characters, was dual. On the one hand, his rôle as Acting Manager of Sir Henry Irving’s Lyceum made him one of the most publicly recognisable figures of Victorian London; no evening at the Lyceum was complete without Stoker, in evening dress, greeting the guests at the top of the stairs. On the other, he was intensely private. As Stoker himself wrote to Walt Whitman, whom he greatly admired, ‘I am equal in temper and cool in disposition and have a large amount of self control and am naturally secretive to the world.’8 By the same token, on the one hand it was a life of conspicuous achievement – one might indeed say over-achievement, since he held down a demanding job as factotum to Irving as well as writing one of the most famous and successful books ever published. Again, though, this is counterbalanced by the fact that Stoker’s life has some odd elements, beginning with the mysterious childhood illness that apparently kept him paralysed until the age of 7, moving through the extraordinary letter he wrote to Walt Whitman in 1872, when he was 24, which declared that ‘I am six feet two inches high and twelve stone weight naked and used to be forty-one or forty-two inches round the chest’,9 and culminating in his alleged death from syphilis. The letter to Whitman might seem like clear proof of homoeroticism, and, as discussed in Chapter 1, it has been argued that Dracula’s sharing of crucial dates with the Wilde trial makes it most easily readable as a text of concealment of such a dangerous proclivity. However, it is equally true that Stoker’s fiction characteristically seems to be deeply invested in the erotic power of women. These contradictions make Stoker a difficult subject to write about, and this has led to a wide range of critical manoeuvres by those who have tackled him and his works. Because of this wide range of approaches, Stoker’s biographer Barbara Belford accuses critics of assuming that ‘There has to be some unsavory explanation of why, out of an oeuvre of eighteen books, only Dracula succeeds as literature – in fact, is a masterpiece.’10 I have no particular desire either to muck-rake or to assume a one-to-one correspondence between an author’s books and his life of the kind offered by Belford herself when she declares that ‘Stoker and his mother, Charlotte, inform the brave and loyal Mina; while the frivolous and fragile Lucy, yearning to marry all her suitors, echoes Stoker’s socially
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 5
ambitious fiancée, Florence Balcombe’,11 and I find Paul Murray theoretically naïve when he writes that Stoker was rediscovered primarily on the campuses of America by academics who found in his writings a rich source for interpretations driven by Freudianism, Marxism and feminism. While great credit is due to those who first insisted that there was more than mere sensationalism in his writings, some of their conclusions, at least, were based on insufficient biographical research.12 As Michael Valdez Moses well observes, ‘it is finally impossible on the basis of scant biographical evidence to know what the circumspect and secretive author intended his greatest literary creation to signify’, 13 and I note too the force of Jennifer L. Fleissner’s identification of ‘the dangers of applying the repressive hypothesis too hastily to Dracula – of assuming that the novel is “really” pointing to a repressed sexuality at every turn, rather than mobilizing discourses of the sexual in order to explain potentially even more outré technological phenonema’.14 Nevertheless, it is hardly possible to ignore the abundant evidence of exactly the kind of internal conflict which is, one might well feel, most likely to energise fiction. Moreover, as David Glover points out, ‘Stoker himself constantly invites a biographical reading by playfully scattering topical references and allusions throughout his work’. 15 For instance, many of his mother’s ancestors were sheriffs of Galway, 16 and he refers to a heroic sheriff of Galway in The Man; and Jeffrey Richards points out that ‘Stoker regularly uses familiar locales for his tales. Betty Pole lives, like Stoker, in Cheyne Walk.’ 17 I have, therefore, sought to relate Stoker’s works to the most crucial and formative aspects of his life, namely his childhood and upbringing in Dublin, his long involvement with the theatre, his position as an Irishman in London, his fondness for travel, and, I suggest, his probable involvement in freemasonry. It is in the light of these factors that I have attempted to postulate meanings for ‘Stoker’s book’. One might add to this that at least a gesture towards the language and concerns of psychoanalysis is a reading strategy which insistently forces itself on any attentive reader of Stoker. Daniel Farson writes that ‘Frankly, I would hardly recognise a Freudian meaning if
6 Bram Stoker
I saw one, except in the case of Dracula and Bram Stoker, where it seems too obvious to ignore.’18 Stoker’s book insistently recurs to the motif of the return of something from a distant past, a pattern repeated in The Snake’s Pass, The Mystery of the Sea, The Jewel of Seven Stars, Dracula, and The Lair of the White Worm. In these novels, what returns can, uncannily, be either monster or treasure, as if they were interchangeable, something which irresistibly evokes the concept of the return of the repressed. The central question for many critics and biographers is whether Stoker knew what he was doing. The range of opinion on this point is striking. At one extreme, Stoker’s great-nephew Daniel Farson is completely dismissive of the possibility that Stoker might have been aware of the implications of his own texts: I doubt if Bram realised the homosexual implications of Whitman’s concept of idyllic boy-love; I doubt if he recognised the lesbianism in Carmilla, the novel that was to influence him so deeply; and I am sure he was unaware of the sexuality inherent in Dracula.19 At the other, Joseph Valente assumes total control and design on Stoker’s part: To my mind, the cleverness of Stoker’s narrative method consists in striking an unstably ironic attitude toward his characters’ moral and political assumptions, sentiments, and dispositions, even while maintaining a certain patina of the righteous and the heroic about them.20 Between these two polarised positions, other critics position themselves at varying points along the scale. Barbara Belford, for instance, argues that some critics claim he did not realize the import of what he was writing: it was all an unconscious dream. But they are in error. Stoker was an intelligent and thoughtful man, and his position at the Lyceum Theatre placed him at the social nexus of Victorian society. He was many things, but naïve was not one of them; he was fully aware of the subtexts in his horror tale.21
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 7
For Belford, the difference between one great work and 17 indifferent or poor ones is easy to explain: it lies in the fact that ‘Stoker was a hasty writer’ except for Dracula, for which ‘Dates on the Dracula Notes at the Rosenbach Museum & Library in Philadelphia certify a six-year devotion to plotting and writing this vampire tale … This was the only novel he took within himself.’ 22 Belford is undoubtedly right that Stoker was generally hasty – David Glover points out that ‘the original draft of Seven Golden Buttons, the short historical novel that eventually appeared under the title Miss Betty in 1898, was completed in slightly less than three weeks’, 23 and the manuscript of the play version of Dracula cleary testifies to extreme hurry in its preparation, since ‘in some scenes such as the encounter with the Un-Dead Lucy, large gaps have been left in the text’. 24 Still, carelessness born of speed, however great, is not in itself sufficient to account for the gaping gulf in power and suggestiveness between Dracula and Stoker’s other books. It is true that part of Stoker’s suggestiveness is undoubtedly fortuitous. For instance, much critical ink has been spilled over the question of why Jonathan Harker thinks that one of the three female vampires whom he meets in Castle Dracula seems oddly familiar to him. Barbara Belford, however, has made it quite clear that in the original form of the novel it was obvious that the reason Harker recognises one of the women is that she is Countess Dolingen of Gratz, whom he has encountered earlier on his journey, in the deleted first chapter of the novel which was later separately published by Florence Stoker as the short story ‘Dracula’s Guest’.25 That prosaic explanation is, however, far less effective than the sense of the uncanny generated by the failure to catch the continuity slip; as David Glover observes, ‘The presence of what Ken Gelder has shrewdly noted as the “undercoded moment[s]” in Stoker’s writings make them susceptible to a variety of sexual readings – queer, heteronormative, and bisexual alike – which cannot easily be reduced to plain matters of biography,’26 and there is a precisely similar effect in Snowbound, in which Mr Sparbrook says of Mr Macrae, ‘He simply idolised his little daughter, a bright, pretty child with golden hair and big grey eyes that I seemed, when I saw them, to have known all my life’ (Snowbound: 85). Regardless of the authorial intention here, the effect is magnificent.
8 Bram Stoker
Some of the interpretations which have assumed that Stoker did not know what he was doing have been weird and wonderful indeed. Daniel Farson’s description of Joseph Bierman’s is a gem in its own right: Anyone who wishes to play the Dracula game can bend the most surprising pieces of evidence to fit the puzzle. A number of distinguished American professors have done so with relish. One of the most astounding interpretations comes from Dr Joseph S. Bierman, of Baltimore, who argues that Bram’s subconscious wanted to eat my grandfather Tom.27 Although Farson’s contention that Stoker got on well with his brothers in later life neatly misses the point, one can forgive him on account of the delicious image of a subconscious eating someone’s grandfather. However, one should in justice note that Stoker himself invited readings which overrode his own agency: Farson reports him as writing to an American correspondent in 1906 that ‘you know a lot more about Dracula than I do’.28 A more subtle view sees Stoker’s novels as tapping in not only to the workings of their author’s mind but also to an entire cultural moment. Thus Jeffrey Richards writes that ‘Stoker is a fascinating case of a popular novelist who while working out his own concerns and preoccupations also plugged into the main currents of anxiety political, theoretical and ideological,’29 and David Glover prefaces his important critical study of Stoker by explaining that ‘I read Stoker’s fiction as public and primarily conscious fantasies, narratives that are formally structured and designed for popular consumption.’ Nevertheless, Glover still thinks that Paradoxically, for all their obsession with scientific knowledge and factual accuracy, Stoker’s narratives are best understood as fantasy, as their frequent evocation of states of reverie, unconsciousness, dream, and daydream ought perhaps to suggest.30 My own approach also seeks to register both the private roots and the public resonances of Stoker’s work. After the Lyceum company performed privately for her at Windor, Queen Victoria telegraphed that ‘Mr Bram Stoker may write whatever he likes about the event.’31
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 9
Although I am well aware that this had a limited, local application, there is nevertheless something magnificent in the idea of Queen Victoria thus licensing Stoker, for in a sense Stoker did indeed write whatever he pleased about the late Victorian period as a whole. Certainly Stoker himself felt that any writer was in some sense a public figure; he complained in his article ‘The Censorship of Fiction’, published in The Nineteenth Century in 1908, that for the modern writer ‘his duty to the public – to the State – appears to be nil.’32 I think, then, that Stoker’s book means more than just Stoker’s own concerns. In the first place, the interest of Stoker’s book does not, whatever Stoker himself may have thought about the matter, lie in its hero figure. It is certainly true that Stoker seems to have invested considerable emotional energy in the creation of his heroes and in encouraging his readers to receive them favourably. As Jeffrey Richards notes, ‘His heroes are frequently projections of himself, big, burly, athletic manly men who act according to chivalric ideas’, and ‘These heroes frequently save someone from drowning, Stoker’s regular measure of manhood. Stoker had earned headline praise from the newspapers for trying to save a would-be suicide in the Thames and had been awarded the Bronze Medal of the Royal Humane Society’, after his ultimately unsuccessful rescue attempt on 14 September 1882; thus in Miss Betty Rafe Otwell rescues Betty from the river (MB: 33), while in Lady Athlyne the captain of the Cryptic was ‘a valiant man who on state occasions wore on his right breast in accordance with the etiquette of the occasion the large gold medal of the Royal Humane Society’ (LA: 8). Stoker and his heroes share other traits too: ‘The experience of going blind and recovering partial sight, described in The Man, is something Stoker himself had undergone following Irving’s death in 1905.’33 However, despite their burly physiques and much-articulated code of chivalry, Stoker’s heroes are only rarely effective. Typically, they are late, unconscious or unsuspecting of the true nature of the danger whenever there is actually a woman to be saved. Even the manly Lord Athlyne, supremely effective when confronted by a Boer army, gets himself arrested by a Dumfriesshire policeman when it is a matter of protecting his fiancée’s reputation by driving her home to her father on time. The one exception is Rupert Sent Leger in The Lady of the Shroud, but here I think Stoker is writing under rather
10 Bram Stoker
different pressures from those which usually mobilise him, for he is, as Jeffrey Richards points out, clearly writing a riposte to Elinor Glyn’s bestselling novel Three Weeks.34 Glyn’s novel, which deserves immortality if only for the line ‘she must have been one of those exceptional women we read of in the sixth form’,35 tells the story of a fascinating Balkan queen who seduces an innocent young Englishman in a Swiss hotel. Stoker clearly both draws on it and counters it in The Lady of the Shroud. Like Rupert Sent Leger, Paul Verdayne ‘could not go and call like an ordinary visitor because he did not know her name!’ (Glyn, Three Weeks: 53), though he felt ‘the conviction that she must be some Queen or Princess of a country south in Europe – half barbaric, half advanced’ (151); like Miss McKelpie, the nameless queen correctly foretells that a son of theirs will sit on the throne (204–5); like the Voivodin Teuta, she does not want to be disturbed by ‘English conventionalities’ (61); and like Lady Arabella March she is repeatedly described as snakelike, most notably when reclining on the tiger-skin that made the book notorious: ‘Perfectly straight out her body was, the twisted purple drapery outlining her perfect shape, and flowing in graceful lines beyond – like a serpent’s tail’ (88). Like Stoker’s work in general, too, Glyn’s deploys Shakespearean allusion: in Venice the queen exclaims ‘Look, Paul! … Can you not see Desdemona peeping from the balcony of her house there!’ (Three Weeks:186), and later ‘the sweetness of the serpent of old Nile fell upon her’ (188), although she herself thinks that Shakespeare knew little of lovers (211). The nameless queen’s brother, Grand Duke Peter, even supplies the name of Stoker’s Voivode Peter Vissarion. Elinor Glyn shares Stoker’s wry scepticism about Englishmen – the queen teases Paul, ‘You dear, insular, arrogant Englishman!’ (Three Weeks: 64) – and even his obsession with mothering: the queen declares ‘You are beautiful, you know, Paul … So tall and straight like you English, with curly hair of gold. Your mother must have loved you as a baby’ (45), and she ‘drew Paul down to her until his head rested on her breast, and her arms held him like a mother with a child’ (130). However, Glyn’s gender politics are remarkably different from Stoker’s. Although Glyn is caustic about unduly masculine women, saying of Paul’s misguided first love for the parson’s daughter that ‘Paul was six foot two, and Isabella quite six foot, and broad in proportion. They were dressed almost alike, and at a little
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 11
distance, but for the lady’s scanty petticoat, it would have been difficult to distinguish her sex’ (Three Weeks: 10), Stoker could never have approved of her implicit endorsement of the truth of the queen’s observation that ‘in all ages it is unfortunately not the simple good women who have ruled the hearts of men’ (212). Nor could he have countenanced the amoral wit of the account of how ‘the scurrilous rag even gave a résumé of this ruler’s dissolute life, and a broad hint that the child could in no case be his; but, as they pithily remarked, this added to the little prince’s welcome in Ministerial circles, where the lady was greatly beloved and revered’ (Glyn, Three Weeks: 275). Stoker would not, either, have agreed with even the mild form of feminism underlying Glyn’s summation that ‘And so, as ever, the woman paid the price’ (302). It is under pressure of contesting these dangerous and heretical views that Stoker creates his own very different Balkan fantasy, in which women are almost comically abject and only too glad to sacrifice themselves for the good of men. In his other novels, though, one might well be tempted to note how often Stoker creates male projections of himself and then renders them helpless, outwitted or unmanned by disobedient or manipulative women. If Stoker’s heroes are not of much interest, however, the heroines indubitably are. It is the representation of women which energises Stoker’s fiction, and the story which he most loves to tell is of the woman who is put in her coffin. Tera in The Jewel of Seven Stars spends the entire narrative dead; Teuta in The Lady of the Shroud voluntarily inhabits a coffin for a third of the book, and wears a shroud for much of the rest; Lucy in Dracula is staked and forced back into the coffin from which she has struggled to escape; Marjory in The Mystery of the Sea is brought to the brink of death before being rescued by her husband; Stephen in The Man, in a moment of obvious psychoanalytic resonance, is traumatised by stumbling unexpectedly on the coffin of her mother. Most bizarrely, Lady Arabella in The Lair of the White Worm, seeing Oolanga carrying a box, asks him for no apparent reason, ‘Is that a coffin you have with you? If so, you are wasting your time. It would not hold me’ (WW: 94). As Alison Case tellingly expresses it, in Stoker’s novels ‘The only genuine Angel in the House is a wife who has joined the angels.’36 Stoker is also fascinated more generally by riddling the distinction between death and life. In the childhood stories which his mother
12 Bram Stoker
told him of the cholera epidemic, it was impossible to distinguish death from life; in his own short story ‘The Man From Shorrox’, a commercial traveller is duped into spending the night with a corpse, whom he believes to be a living man. Related to this is the fact that Stoker’s book is interested in resurrections of a different sort, that of the re-emergence of races or racial qualities from former times. This is a concern which recurs in many guises in Stoker’s fiction. As I explore in Chapter 3, Stoker was always aware of his own position as an Irishman in London, but he was also equally fascinated by what it meant to be a member of a number of other nationalities, from American to Spanish (as in The Mystery of the Sea) to his own imagined Men of the Blue Mountains. Sometimes Stoker’s representations of ethnic identities can be seen as configured by what we would now understand as racism, often fed by the phrenological and physiognomic prejudices of the time, but sometimes they are animated by a less judgemental and more simply ethnographic impulse (I shall be looking in Chapter 4 at the influence of travel on Stoker’s writing). At all events, it is impossible to think of virtually any Stoker character without remembering their nationality and/or ethnic identity. David Glover points out that ‘Stoker often gives his heroes some kind of Viking genealogy.’37 In The Shoulder of Shasta, for instance, ‘Dick looked a perfect giant as he stood in the doorway following out his guest, for all the manhood of him seemed to swell within him, and to glorify him till the blood and dirt on him seemed as if Viking adjuncts to his mighty personality’ (Shasta: 106). In Dracula, Arthur Holmwood is compared to Thor, and as Joseph Valente observes, ‘At the time of the novel, the figure of Thor was a popular, incipiently racist icon of Nordic-Aryan purity.’38 As Jeffrey Richards remarks, ‘Stoker subscribes to the racial ideas dominant in his period, in particular the superiority of the Nordic races to all others.’39 Particularly notable in this respect is the symbolism of Teuta’s name;40 in this context, the fact that Teuta had for some time lain as if dead before her triumphal re-emergence might well look like a revival of Teutonic values. One reason for Stoker’s interest in the Nordic might well have been the contemporary plight of Norway, which was, for most of his writing life, in much the same position in relation to Sweden as
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 13
Ireland was to England. The ongoing war amongst Stoker’s closest theatrical associates about whether or not to stage Ibsen is likely to have raised his consciousness of Norway, and the celebrated explorer Fridtjof Nansen, whose exploits received much coverage in the London press and who visited London in 1903, wrote a series of columns in the Times denouncing the Union of Sweden and Norway.41 Given the concern with launching a new kingdom in The Lady of the Shroud, Stoker might well have noted too that the Norwegian Parliament lobbied heavily for monarchism in the wake of the vote for independence in the hope that this would make it more acceptable to the Great Powers, and the Danish prince Carl was selected as the new king partly because he was married to Edward VII’s daughter Maud. (In the absence of a Norwegian diplomatic corps, it was Nansen who was sent to invite Carl to take the throne.) Given The Lady of the Shroud’s concern with armaments, Stoker might also have been interested in the fact that from 1902 onwards Kristian Birkeland was experimenting with revolutionary weaponry, on which The Daily Mail reported.42 Conversely, those who are of spectacularly non-Viking descent in Stoker’s book are open to constant attack. John Allen Stevenson’s remark of Dracula that ‘it may be fruitful to reconsider Stoker’s compelling and frequently retold story in terms of interracial sexual competition rather than as intrafamilial strife’43 can profitably be applied to all Stoker’s work. In The Lair of The White Worm, Adam’s man, asked to look around the ship, is ‘Naturally … struck with the aboriginal savage’ (WW: 43), while Caswall cheerfully declares that ‘the law doesn’t concern itself much about dead niggers. A few more or less do not matter. To my mind it’s rather a relief!’ (WW: 88). In Lady Athlyne, Lt Breckenridge says casually that ‘I’m from Kentucky myself; and I was there for a while – that time of the nigger disturbance you know’ (LA: 108), and Colonel Ogilvie observes, I find I have been wrong to quarrel so readily and without waiting to understand. If a nigger did it I think I’d understand, for I don’t look for much from him. But I do expect much from myself; and therefore I’ll go back a bit and go a bit farther. Hear me promise, so help me God, I’ll never quarrel again!’ (LA: 309)
14 Bram Stoker
In The Shoulder of Shasta: The Indians sat on one side of the fire and ate their meat half cooked – part of a little deer which Dick had shot, on purpose for the meal, just before sunset. Le Maistre and Dick sat together at the opposite side of the fire, and took their dinner with the larger deliberation of the Caucasian. (Shasta: 31) Esse ‘could not help thinking that the Indian want of humour was alone sufficient to put the race in a low place in the scale of human types’ (Shasta: 40), while Dick’s ‘proximity kept the Indians in order; for with the dominance of a Causcasian he made himself to some degree regulator of his neighbour’s affairs’ (Shasta: 49), and Mrs Elstree ‘had once seen, in a chest full of scalps, in the collection of a friend who was an amateur of Indian trophies, a scalp of a woman’s golden hair, and she herself, in common with all who had seen it, felt more pity for the late owner of those yellow tresses, than for all the original proprietors of the dark ones put together’ (Shasta: 50). Finally, one of the reasons Esse is attracted to Dick is that ‘Dick was the only male in the place, for of course Indians and servants did not count’ (Shasta: 54). Stoker’s views in this respect were abundantly supported by the scientific racism which had spread rapidly in the wake of Darwin, and above all by the pseudo-science of phrenology. (The Stoker collection at the Shakespeare Centre Library includes a phrenological report of Irving’s brain.) The Jewel of Seven Stars is a particularly good example of Stoker’s interest in this subject. Throughout the book, we are made insistently aware of the extent to which identity may be thought to be located in the actual physical configurations of the body. Malcolm Ross is a devoted student of physiognomy, whose evaluations of human characters are totally reliant on the kinds of supposedly quantifiable and measurable external signs so beloved of believers in criminal types and atavistic degenerates.44 At first sight of Doctor Winchester, he concludes that the latter has ‘aquiline features, keen grey eyes, and a forehead that stood out square and broad as that of a thinker’ (Jewel: 12), while Nurse Kennedy had a snub nose – there was no possible doubt about it; but like such noses in general it showed a nature generous, untiring, and
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 15
full of good nature. Her broad white forehead, which even the freckles had spared, was full of forceful thought and reason. (Jewel: 24) Of Mr Trelawny, Ross decides that ‘[t]hose beetling brows screened some massive purpose; that high, broad forehead held some finished train of reasoning, which the broad chin and massive jaw would help to carry into effect’ (Jewel: 40).45 Most suggestive of all is Ross’s analysis of Corbeck’s appearance: The Far East, the Tropic Seasons, and the Desert – each can have its colour mark. But all three are quite different; and an eye which has once known, can thenceforth easily distinguish them. The dusky pallor of one; the fierce red-brown of the other; and of the third, the dark, ingrained burning, as though it had become a permanent colour. Mr Corbeck had a big head, massive and full; with shaggy, dark red-brown hair, but bald on the temples. His forehead was a fine one, high and broad; with, to use the terms of physiognomy, the frontal sinus boldly marked. The squareness of it showed ‘ratiocination’; and the fullness under the eyes ‘language’. He had the short, broad nose that marks energy; the square chin – marked despite a thick, unkempt beard – and massive jaw that showed great resolution. (Jewel: 68) Here, Mr Corbeck’s history and character can both be read on his face. Stoker’s book is also about breaking and evading the law, particularly in the form of subverting the Victorian information-gathering project. Gary Day notes that ‘It was through the alliance of law and medicine that state intervention in civil society was most evident. Dracula bears witness to this in as much as two major discourses in the novel are those of law and medicine, represented by Harker and Seward respectively.’ He argues that The predominantly diary form … says something about the nature of the professions themselves. As already mentioned, professional expertise is based on selection through merit. However, it is precisely the specialized nature of the professions which inhibits an understanding of society as a whole.46
16 Bram Stoker
Throughout Stoker’s work, the drive towards greater civic control is in tension with a sense of the need for the liberty of individuals to act, something which I shall be exploring in greater detail in Chapter 3. Most notably, Stoker’s book is invested in undoing what it itself has done, and reasserting gender norms. David Glover writes interestingly on Stoker’s admiration for Otto Weininger, whose first appearance in Britain, in 1906, came courtesy of Stoker’s own publisher, William Heinemann,47 and who is mentioned approvingly in Lady Athlyne, a novel in which we read that ‘Instinctively the woman recognised the tone and obeyed, as women have obeyed the commands of the men they loved, and were proud to do so, from Eden garden down the ages’ (LA: 303). In a sense, though, Weininger only confirmed what Stoker already subscribed to. In Snowbound, the connected collection of short stories centred on a theatrical troupe, we find an interesting exchange: ‘Did none of the men confess anything?’ asked the Singing Chambermaid. There was in the tone of her voice that underlying note of militant defiance which is always evident when the subject of woman in the abstract is mentioned in mixed company. The Second Low Comedian smiled as he replied: ‘Certainly, my dear! I thought you understood that I was speaking of the young ladies of both sexes. You remember that the first, in fact the one to set them off, was an alleged Man.’ (Snowbound: 73) The fear of possible gender blurring registered here is one which Stoker’s book works diligently to redress by jaunty statements such as that in Miss Betty of Betty and her grandfather: ‘unconsciously her womanhood admitted the dominance of the man’ (MB: 19). Stoker has no time for what he derisively identifies in The Man as Stephen’s ‘theory of sexual equality’ (Man: 221), which leads to nothing but trouble and misery for her. It is, however, repeatedly clear that Stoker is worried about gender rôles not only in relation to women but also, and even more urgently, in relation to men. Jeffrey Richards remarks on the prevalence of stories about crossdressing and gender uncertainty in Famous Impostors, and suggests of the discussion of the Chevalier d’Eon that ‘Stoker’s tone suggests
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 17
that he is anxious to stress that a certain feminine sensitivity in the male nature does not compromise basic masculinity,’48 just as in Miss Betty the rider with the money is disguised as a woman (MB: 127), but is nevertheless a daredevil. There are also passages in Famous Impostors where the behaviour of one sex leaches worryingly into that of the other: Stoker writes of the followers of one of the various fake Dauphins, for instance, that He got round him a gang of persons of evil life, as shown by their various records. One was a false priest, another a prisoner for embezzlement, another an ex-bailiff who was also a forger, another a deserter; with the usual criminal concomitant of women, dishonoured clergy and such like. (FI: 41) Stoker’s proposed solution to the contaminating influence of women was the promotion of strong male–male bonds, which typically work to exclude or marginalise women. In The Man, Harold asks Mr Stonehouse to keep his secret even from his wife (Man: 172), in an echo of how when Hall Caine lent Stoker money in his later years, he wrote to him that ‘I shall not even tell my wife, and you need not tell your wife.’49 It is worth noting that this bond of shared secrecy between men which excludes women was also what lay at the heart of freemasonry, which, I shall be suggesting in Chapter 5, was a force in Stoker’s life: Mrs Caudle’s Curtain Lectures, which first appeared in Punch, objected to her husband’s freemasonry on the grounds that it entailed keeping secrets from his wife.50 I should make it plain that I do not regard Stoker’s drive to enforce gender codes as born of simple misogyny. Rather I see it as a form of self-policing, and as the result of writing under considerable pressure on this front. On several grounds, Stoker found his own masculinity embattled. In the first place, he started his working life as a clerk, and as Jennifer Fleissner notes, ‘a popular phrase such as “Born a man, died a clerk” … suggested a job inherently at odds with masculinity.’51 Moreover, his escape from this ‘unmanly’ occupation came courtesy of the fit of hysteria with which he greeted Irving’s recital of ‘The Ballad of Eugene Aram’, and William Hughes points to the pervasive association of hysteria with femininity.52 Most notably, the theatre was notorious as a place of sexual nonconformity, and there
18 Bram Stoker
were many insinuations of sexual impropriety against theatre people.53 Irving’s Hamlet was called unmanly and his Othello effeminate; Ellen Terry’s daughter Edith Craig, who probably played Mina Harker in the Lyceum’s read-through of Dracula,54 was a lesbian, and even though she did not move in with her long-term partner Christopher St John (Christabel Marshall) until 1899, her sexual orientation may well have been apparent much earlier, since she had already previously shared a house with a woman.55 Certainly Irving’s circle seem to have accepted Christopher St John’s preferred selfdesignation, though they must have been well aware of his true name and gender: Brereton’s life of Irving, for instance, lists in its bibliography ‘Henry Irving. By Christopher St. John’.56 Edith Craig further subverted gender roles by appearing as Donalbain in Irving’s Macbeth, and Stoker himself could be seen as metaphorically emasculated in his role at the Lyceum, where he was not only subservient to Irving but where Ellen Terry called him ‘Mama’.57 At the same time, he would have been all the more sharply aware of the growing push to police sexual behaviour and criminalise homosexuality because of his personal friendship with Henry Labouchere, author of the amendment under which Oscar Wilde was convicted.58 The hysteria which so often surrounds Stoker’s writing about gender could well be seen as the product of a radical insecurity on this front. In Stoker’s work, moreover, gender bears on wider issues than itself. David Glover writes of how, in The Man and Lady Athlyne, ‘science takes the form of sexology or sexual psychology and in Stoker’s hands it underwrites a normative heterosexuality that holds the key to national regeneration’, and he identifies ‘the strategic marriages between different national subjects that are a common form of closure in Stoker’s novels’.59 This returns us to the central question of any literary life, the relationship of the author’s works to his or her life. There is one central aspect of Stoker the person to which the reading process entirely blinds us: he was Irish. When we silently read his works in our own voices inside our heads, we forget what his contemporaries remembered every time he opened his mouth, since he never troubled to modify his Irish brogue. As Joseph Valente points out: Moonshine, a magazine of ‘wit, humour, and satire’, which was given to libelous caricatures of the Celtic race, lampooned Stoker
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 19
as a man of laughably boundless ambitions … the Tatler mocked Stoker’s attempt to fit into English club society by pointing to his clumsy Irish inflected wit, his ‘horrible dooble ongtong’.60 In all Stoker’s fiction, Ireland plays a part, and the relationships which Stoker fantasises between his idealised men and women can indeed be seen as uneasily mirroring the harmony which this ‘philosophical’ but sentimental Home Ruler hoped to see between his adopted country and the country of his birth. Marriage thus becomes, in Stoker’s book, a metaphor with a very wide range. Above all, though, Stoker’s book is concerned not only with its own content, but with the process of presenting it in writing. Writing and its mechanics are at the very heart of Stoker’s interests. As Gary Day observes, ‘That Dracula is a novel ultimately preoccupied with form is clear from the fact that it destroys its own content’ and comments on the novel’s ‘identification of writing with a machine’.61 Alison Case argues that In Dracula, knowledge is power, and not only power over Dracula himself. The opening note, with its tantalizing promise that ‘how these papers have been placed in sequence will be made manifest in the reading of them’ (xxi), asks that we read with a consciousness, not only of the emerging story, but of the process by which it has been recognized and organized as such.62 Similarly, Jennifer Fleissner poses the provocative question ‘Is Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1897) as much about secretarial work as it is about sex?’,63 while Rebecca A. Pope argues that ‘One glance at the novel’s extravagant narrative structure … suggests that it is as concerned with textuality as with sexuality.’64 Stoker’s representation of texts is certainly eroticised: when Lord Athlyne is a prisoner at Pretoria, we are told that ‘At this time they were occasionally getting letters. These had of course gone through the hands of the censor and their virginity thus destroyed’ (LA: 47). Similarly in The Jewel of Seven Stars, the all-important writing on the jewel itself, the hekau, has been produced by means unknown. There is also a constant interplay between Stoker’s own texts and those of Milton,65 the Bible, and above all Shakespeare, something which I will explore more
20 Bram Stoker
closely in Chapter 2. Stoker’s concerns thus extended to the form as well as the content of his book. This book has five chapters. The first, ‘Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction’, considers the impact on Stoker’s work of his early life in Dublin, including the mysterious childhood illness which kept him bedridden until the age of 7 and therefore led him to be much in the company of his mother Charlotte. It proposes that the peculiarly literary and narrativised nature of the relationship between Stoker and his mother was an important influence on his later fiction, particularly with regard to its typically conflicted depictions of motherhood. Other traces of Stoker’s Dublin years are also readily detectable in his works: the Stokers lived close to St Michan’s Church, where the unusually dry air had caused the spontaneous mummification of the bodies in the crypt, a sight which has often been seen as the genesis of the undead bodies in Dracula; and it was also in Dublin that Stoker met both his wife, Florence Balcombe, and the Wilde family. Both Oscar and his father, the Egyptologist Sir William Wilde, seem to have influenced Stoker’s works: Egyptology provides the story of Stoker’s 1903 novel The Jewel of Seven Stars, and many of the dates so carefully cited in Dracula correspond directly with those of the Wilde trial, allowing the novel to be read as a covert examination of the plight of the homosexual in society. The second chapter, ‘At the Theatre’, centres on the connection with Henry Irving which was to prove so central to Stoker’s life. When Stoker realised that there were no regular theatre reviews appearing in the Dublin press, he offered his own services for free, and was thereafter associated with the theatre for the rest of his life. This chapter traces the history of that connection and explore its meanings for Stoker’s work, paying particular attention to the construction of his plots and to the extent and functions of his allusions to plays and dramatic characters. It also goes on to look briefly at the chequered history of dramatisation of Dracula after the failure of Stoker’s repeated attempts to interest Irving in it, and to glance at the history of this and his other novels on screen. The third chapter, ‘London with its Teeming Millions’, considers the effect of England and Englishness on Stoker’s work. ‘London with its teeming millions’ is what Count Dracula hopes he will be able to prey on when he leaves his Transylvanian crypt. When Stoker left Dublin in 1878, never to live there again, he entered a world which offered
Introduction: Stoker’s Book 21
him many more opportunities, but in which he was also permanently marked as an outsider by the persistence of his Irish accent – something which has been suggested as a genesis for the heavily accented speech which persistently marks both Count Dracula and Van Helsing as different from those around them. This chapter outlines the main events of Stoker’s life in London, not least the publication of Dracula by Constable in 1897 (although the initial critical reception was somewhat muted, giving little indication of the success the book would eventually achieve), and explores both what London means in Stoker’s fiction and also what Ireland came to mean in these years of exile. It considers particularly the extent to which his novels can be seen as dealing with questions of Irishness and, above all, of Irish Home Rule, and the ways in which both the possibilities and the restrictions of London life are figured in his work. The fourth chapter, ‘On Holiday’, looks at Stoker’s travels. Almost as important to Stoker’s fiction as London are the places to which he (and even to some extent his friends) travelled during the years that he lived there. From 1883, the Lyceum company, and Stoker with it, toured America almost annually, and this is reflected in novels like The Shoulder of Shasta and Lady Athlyne, as well as in the important rôle played by the Texan Quincy Morris in Dracula. In 1890 Stoker visited Whitby, a trip which he famously revisits in Dracula in ways which, I argue, do not only contribute a picturesque setting to the novel but also inform its examinations of domesticity versus foreign threats and of evolutionary theory. Finally, 1893 saw the first of his subsequently regular trips to Cruden Bay in Aberdeenshire, which became the setting for The Watter’s Mou’ and The Mystery of the Sea, and here too the connotations of the location condition the meanings of the fictions. The fifth and final chapter is called simply ‘The Cave’. Many of Stoker’s novels feature a cave, crypt or other dark subterranean place, ranging from Dracula’s tomb to the cave of The Mystery of the Sea and the cellar of The Jewel of Seven Stars, and it is not hard (indeed hard not) to read these in psychoanalytic terms. Stoker himself was so secretive that several key questions about his life remain unanswered, but all too often his novels seem to tell the stories that he himself will not. This chapter explores the darker side of Stoker’s fiction, especially its obsessions with sex, gender, disease, and various forms of secret knowledge, and argues that, in his fiction, Stoker was in fact writing his own literary life.
This page intentionally left blank
1 Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction
Bram Stoker was born in Dublin on 8 November 1847. By his own account, his early childhood was one of entire invalidism: ‘till I was about seven years old I never knew what it was to stand upright’ (PR I: 31). This produced a particularly intense exposure to the company of his mother, Charlotte, and the horrific stories she told of her childhood in Sligo at the time of the cholera epidemic, some of which were highly dramatic: Stoker’s great-nephew Daniel Farson claims that his grandmother, Charlotte’s daughter-in-law, told him that towards the end of the cholera epidemic, ‘on one of the last, desperate days, Charlotte saw a hand reaching through the skylight. Seizing an axe, she cut it off with one tremendous blow’.1 The fact that the relationship between Stoker and his mother centred so much on stories was an important influence on his later fiction, particularly with regard to its typically conflicted depictions of motherhood. Charlotte appears to have been a powerful figure; Farson recalls that ‘My grandmother Enid married [Bram’s brother] Tom when she was little more than a girl, in 1891. She was not a fanciful woman and she told me that the family were in awe of Charlotte if not actually afraid of her’.2 Indeed Carol A. Senf suggests that ‘When [Charlotte] died, her son lost one of the most powerful influences in his life. The result may be that women characters in his later novels are less powerful’.3 Certainly Barbara Belford remarks that ‘Stoker’s women characters frequently have names beginning with M (Maggie, Mina, Mimi, Marjory, Margaret), a tribute, perhaps, to “Mother” and sisters, Matilda and Margaret, his early caretakers’.4 23
24 Bram Stoker
Two features of Stoker’s early life in Dublin appear to have been particularly influential on his later writing. It was there that he met, at an unknown date, his wife Florence Balcombe, whom he married on 4 December 1878 when she was 19 and he 31, and the Wilde family, whom he knew from childhood and whom Florence too knew, since her first romantic involvement was with Oscar Wilde. Both Oscar and his father, the Egyptologist Sir William Wilde, seem to have influenced Stoker’s works. The Snake’s Pass, in which Arthur can contemplate the possibility of Norah having to rescind a promise formerly given to marry Dick Sutherland and Dick is expected to react favourably, looks very like a wish-fulfilment revisiting of the love-triangle of Stoker, Wilde and Florence (SP: 129) (the short story ‘Greater Love’, published by Florence after Stoker’s death, also centres on two friends in love with the same girl),5 while Egyptology provides the story of Stoker’s 1903 novel The Jewel of Seven Stars. The DNB article on Stoker claims unequivocally that The Jewel of Seven Stars was ‘inspired by the Egyptian adventures of Oscar Wilde’s father’, although Sir William was not the only influence on Stoker’s ideas about Egypt. Stoker noted that once when he was visiting Tennyson, ‘In the garden [he] pointed out to us some blue flowering pea which had been reared from seed found in the hand of a mummy’ (PR I: 215), and Peter Haining notes that ‘in 1902 … Stoker discussed with [his friend Hall] Caine his plot about the Egyptian mummy, and from the novelist he received a considerable amount of esoteric and occult knowledge which he included in the story. Caine also helped him with the stark and gruesome ending’ (MT: 152), while in The Jewel of Seven Stars, Stoker himself gives the various parts of the being as listed by ‘Doctor Budge’ (Jewel 150), that is Wallis Budge, author of Egyptian Magic (1901). Moreover, mummies were an increasingly fashionable topic for fiction in the wake of British military occupation of Egypt in 1882, with several notable examples of the genre preceding and clearly influencing Stoker.6 Most intriguingly, mummies could be seen as bringing together two of Stoker’s most deep-rooted concerns, female power and the position of Ireland, since, as Sandra M. Gilbert points out: The figure of the New Woman, with its evocation of such unruly females as the Egyptian Cleopatra and the pseudo-Egyptologist Madame Blavatsky, vividly suggested an ultimate triumph of
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 25
otherness. Feminist thinkers had long understood this point, quite consciously identifying their work for women’s rights with such related challenges to patriarchal authority as spiritualism, abolitionism, and the Home Rule movement in Ireland.7 Still, early exposure to Egyptology can only have fed the fascination with the borderline of death already begun by his mother’s stories about how in the confusion of the cholera epidemic people had been buried alive. Moreover, Stoker’s most recent biographer, Paul Murray, plausibly suggests that the ‘Docther Wilde’ reference in The Snake’s Pass (SP: 129) is to Sir William, and further suggests that Stoker’s ‘notion of the Irish regenerating the United States may well have come from Stoker’s friends, Sir William and Lady Wilde’.8 There is also the fact that, as Talia Schaffer has shown,9 many of the dates so carefully cited in Dracula correspond directly with those of the trial of Oscar Wilde. The other major element of Stoker’s work which seems to be traceable back to his childhood, which I have already touched on above, is his insistent troubling of the borderline between life and death. This is no doubt partly attributable to the bizarre phenomenon of the spontaneous mummification that had occurred to the bodies in the crypt of St Michan’s Church, near to where the Stokers lived, and in which Charlotte Stoker was buried when she died in 1902. Early exposure to this resulted in a riddling throughout Stoker’s work of the distinction between life and death. In his short story ‘The Secret of the Growing Gold’, for instance, when Margaret Delandre appears to her brother it is initially unclear if she is alive or dead (DG: 63), and the same is true of Teuta in The Lady of the Shroud, and of Tera/Margaret in The Jewel of Seven Stars, while several characters in Dracula so bestride the boundary that they can be classified only as Un-Dead. This surely contributed to Stoker’s deeply conflicted and ambivalent attitude towards ‘mummification’ of a different sort – actual motherhood.10 I make the bad pun because there is a close connection in Stoker’s mind between the two concepts: as Andrew Smith points out, in The Jewel of Seven Stars ‘The novel … works towards the idea of the pursuit of the absent mother (here presented as an Egyptian Mummy) that forms one of the underlying tensions of the Female Gothic’,11 a trope that is especially effective because, as David Glover observes, ‘one of the most
26 Bram Stoker
provocative of contemporary archaeological findings was that ancient Egypt was a matrilineal society’.12 The Jewel of Seven Stars is typical of Stoker’s works in that attitudes to the mother are wildly unstable in it. On the one hand, there is a careful observation of the conventional pieties fed by the ideal of the Angel in the House: the late Mrs Trelawny is never spoken of in any terms but those of the most profound respect and affection, and Margaret is sure that the scar on her wrist testifies to her mother’s suitably wifely anxiety about her father (Jewel: 141). To the reader, however, it is only too obvious that the scar could all too easily have another meaning, and be the sign of a deeply disturbing bond between Margaret and the mummy, Tera, which calls into radical question not only her particular relationship with her own mother but the whole nature of mothers/mummies in general. Although all the characters shy away from facing up to this possibility directly, it haunts them in the shape of a half-terrified fascination with ‘the mummy pit’, which Corbeck and Trelawny repeatedly enter. What they find there is hideously emblematic: in the tomb, which is decorated with ‘disjointed limbs and features, such as arms and legs, fingers, eyes, noses, ears, and lips’ (Jewel: 97), lies a mummy with a missing hand, which neatly encapsulates the whole gamut of fears about the fragmentation and self-splitting produced by either too close identification with or too radical separation from the mother. It is a sign of this tension between fear of severance and fear of absorption that Stoker’s depictions of both mothering and being mothered are equally fraught. In The Shoulder of Shasta, for instance, Dick tells Esse that ‘Mother couldn’t abide mountings, and kept dad down in the bottoms’ (Shasta: 39), but after she died ‘Me an’ Dad scooped a hole for the old lady ’way down by One Tree Creek’ (Shasta: 40), and were then free to live as they liked. During the crucial scene in which Esse rescues Dick from the bear, it is slyly insinuated that the two humans offer an eerie parallel to the bear and his mate: Esse throws her handkerchief in the male bear’s face just as she used to hold it to her own, while he rips her dress and nearly undresses her in this highly sexualised scene (Shasta: 70–1), and the doctor says of Dick that ‘we must not judge of his health and recovery by the standard of the towns, but rather by the animals, who simply lie quiet and lick their wounds’ (Shasta 80). It is, therefore, suggestive that it is the mother bear which is the more
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 27
threatening both to Dick and to Esse – ‘Each instant the monster seemed to be coming closer, closer, till its great paw was stretched to tear her heart out’ (Shasta: 68) – and that this is a prelude to the first hint of distance between Esse and her own mother: we are told that Esse ‘knew her own secret now, and it took all her time and effort to so bear herself as to deceive her mother’ (Shasta: 82), with the wildly suggestive use of the verb ‘bear’ confirming the link. Similarly in the very early novella The Primrose Path, the first chapter is entitled ‘A Happy Home’, and yet on the very first page of this there is a remark which is by no means unequivocally suggestive of happiness, when Katey gives Jerry the baby to kiss: ‘Children are quite as jealous as dogs and cats in their own way, and instinctively the urchin sprawling on the hearth-rug came over and pulled at his mother’s dress, saying plaintively “Me too, mammy – me too”’ (PP: 16). Here both the mother and the child are placed under strain, the child by feeling that he is being excluded and the mother by being badgered, and it is notable that though it is the father who, by kissing the baby, is seeming to exclude the older child, it is at the mother that the child’s anger and desire are directed. Although the principal emotional investment may be in mothers, however, fathers are not forgotten, for all Stoker’s depictions of parenthood are conflicted, something which one might well be tempted to see as doubly grounded in his own experience, since Florence Stoker does not seem to have been a very affectionate mother to their only child Noel: it seems suggestive, for instance, that Noel spoke French before he spoke English because that was the language of his governess,13 and Daniel Farson claims of Noel that ‘When he was a boy he spent much of his time with my grandmother, who told me that Florence was not particularly fond of him.’14 Certainly a less than warm relationship seems to be implied by George duMaurier’s Punch cartoon of the Stoker family, ‘A Filial Reproof’, in which Noel, told by Florence that he should be seen and not heard, replies ‘But you don’t look at me, Mamma.’15 Coolnesses between parents and children are omnipresent in Stoker’s fiction. It is a sorrow to Margaret Trelawny in The Jewel of Seven Stars that she knows so little of her father’s life; in Dracula, the truth about Lucy’s illness must be kept from her mother at all costs. In the short story ‘The Dualitists’, which Paul Murray sees as reflecting ‘the influence on Stoker of the work of the contemporary criminologists,
28 Bram Stoker
Cesare Lombroso...and Guglielmo Ferrero, who propagated the notion of the inherent criminality of women and children’,16 we are offered a detailed description of the trials undergone by the parents of twins: The twins were the idols of their parents, and at the same time their pleasure and their pain. Did Zerubabbel cough, Ephraim would start from his balmy slumbers with an agonized cry of consternation, for visions of innumerable twins black in the face from croup haunted his nightly pillow. Did Zachariah rail at ethereal expansion, Sophonisba with pallid hue and dishevelled locks would fly to the cradle of her offspring. Did pins torture or strings afflict, or flannel or flies tickle, or light dazzle, or darkness affright, or hunger or thirst assail the synchronous productions, the household of Bubb would be roused from quiet slumbers or the current of its manifold workings changed. (MT: 47) Nor are the babies the only troublesome offspring in the tale, for their eventual killers are also children, Harry Merford and Thomas Santon, whose names clearly glance ironically at the idealising view of childhood peddled in Thomas Day’s Sanford and Merton (1783–89). Each of the two boys is given a knife by his parents, a gesture which Joseph Valente interprets as initiation into compulsory heterosexuality: One Christmas, they give each boy a knife, distinguished by his initials, a master signifier of his individual subjectivity. Now since the parents likely feared some manner of homoeroticism in the lads’ intimacy (a never distant possibility in Stoker’s works), the gift of such an obvious phallic symbol, monogrammed, seems intended to impart to each boy a positive sense of his masculine gender identity.17 I think this reading is a little strained, but there is no doubt that, whether or not they are the products of it, the knives are certainly the causes of tension between parents and children: after Harry and Tommy are thwarted in their first attempts to destroy the pianos and family portraits (MT: 49) with these knives, ‘articles of crockery began to be missed … Mrs Merford and Mrs Santon mourned their losses, but Harry and Tommy gloated day after day over their spoils’
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 29
(MT: 52). Finally the two boys kill the babies in the ‘hacking’ game they have developed: The pasty face of Zerubbabel had fallen fair on that of Zachariah, for Tommy and Harry were by this time artists of too great experience to miss so simple a mark. The putty-like noses collapsed, the putty-like cheeks became for a moment flattened, and when in an instant more they parted, the faces of both were dabbled in gore. Immediately the firmament was rent with a series of such yells as might have awakened the dead. (MT: 56) Moreover, not only do they take a callous pleasure in their actions – the two boys ‘continued their awful pastime with a zest tenfold as they knew that the agonised eyes of parents wept at the cause of their joy’ (MT: 57) – but they also cause the deaths of both the twins’ parents, killed trying to catch the decapitated bodies of the twins, ‘who were thus posthumously guilty of the crime of parricide’ (MT: 57). In the ultimate – and typically Stokerian – insult, because Harry and Tommy testify that they have committed suicide, the parents are buried with ‘stakes driven through their middles’ (MT: 58). In ‘The Dualitists’, it is hard to say which is the greater, the animus against parents or the animus against children. Elsewhere in Stoker’s fiction parenthood is similarly consistently disastrous. In ‘The Secret of the Growing Gold’ it is the pregnancy of Geoffrey Brent’s wife which precipitates the disaster, and when she refers to ‘us three’ (MT: 69), of whom one is clearly an intruder, and Geoffrey protests that there are only two, she could mean the baby as much as the ghost of Margaret. Stoker’s women are often weak or flawed – in the short story ‘The Gipsy Prophecy’ Gerald wisely counsels Joshua not to tell his wife about the prophecy on the grounds that women are superstitious (DG: 75) – but his mothers are most notably so, not least because, as Carol A. Senf notes, ‘he tends to connect sensuality in women with cruelty to children’,18 and despite Victorian doctors’ protestations that good women felt no sexual desire, the fear at the heart of Stoker’s novels is that motherhood is inevitably a sign of sensuality. This half-fascinated, half-terrified obsession with the mother is perhaps most memorably illustrated in Dracula. The teleology of
30 Bram Stoker
Dracula is an interesting one: rather than progressing, like so many other Victorian novels, towards a closing marriage, which, in Gail Cunningham’s formulation, is normally ‘the mainstay of Victorian fiction’, 19 it ends instead on an image of motherhood. The final paragraph of the novel, spoken by Van Helsing and relayed by Jonathan Harker, is ostensibly offered as a celebration of domesticity, continuity, and affective ties: We want no proofs; we ask none to believe us! This boy will some day know what a brave and gallant woman his mother is. Already he knows her sweetness and loving care; later on he will understand how some men so loved her, that they did dare much for her sake. (D: 449) Alongside the discourse of affect, with its reinforcement by the physical location of the boy on Van Helsing’s knee while these words are spoken, another language is surprisingly dominant: Van Helsing focuses not only on what the boy’s future experiences will be, but, above all, on the epistemological structures which will produce them.20 These are, apparently, unproblematic; indeed the text has already instantiated a model of knowledge as essentially a benevolent communion of souls, untainted by the mechanics of actual communication, when, earlier in the closing ‘Note’, Jonathan Harker posits a replacement of the terrifying psychic link between Dracula and Mina by one between Mina and himself: ‘His mother holds, I know, the secret belief that some of our brave friend’s spirit has passed into him’ (D: 449). What Mina secretly ‘holds’ is wordlessly ‘known’ to her husband. Van Helsing’s summing-up is structured by verbs of perception. After the dismissal of the initial notion of ‘proof’ there come instead ‘believe’, ‘know’, ‘knows’ and ‘understand’. ‘Belief’ is in fact negated by its association with the impossibility of ‘proofs’, and ‘understanding’ and part of the ‘knowing’ are displaced to the future; but one thing is figured as already ‘known’ to the young Quincey Harker, and that is his mother’s ‘sweetness and loving care’. The basis for his apprehension of these must, presumably, be sensory and experiential, and the fact that his future knowledge of her bravery and gallantry will be available to him despite the absence of
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 31
any proofs such as could induce belief in others suggests that there will be a similarly felt and intuitive quality to his future knowledge. This idea is reinforced by the fact that the basis for this future knowledge will in fact be grounded in love: ‘later on he will understand how some men so loved her, that they did dare much for her sake’. In fact, love underpins all the paragraph’s epistemological assumptions, since it is through the operation of Mina’s maternal affection that the boy already ‘knows her sweetness and loving care’. However, there is surely a difference in the kind of love which will inform his later awareness: ‘later on he will understand how some men so loved her, that they did dare much for her sake’. Before he can imaginatively apprehend the nature of the love entertained by other men for his mother he will have to have negotiated a very different awareness of both himself and her, and of the affective structures which govern mature human relationships. ‘Later on’ signals not only the passage of time, but the developing awareness of sexuality, loss, and of the social structures which dictate that men must ‘dare’ for the sublimated love of the woman they can never possess – a process of understanding which will have its roots in the development of the Oedipus complex which forestalls the boy’s own possession of his mother. Motherhood, then, is encoded at the close of the novel not as any idyllic image of Madonna and child – indeed the child sits not on its mother’s knee, but on Van Helsing’s, and Mina herself is silent throughout the closing ‘Note’ – but as a merely temporary refuge from precisely the kinds of sexual knowledge that initially unleashed the horrors of vampirism amongst the Crew of Light. In fact, despite its structural status as narrative telos, this closing representation of motherhood is fissured by the same kinds of ambiguity that have made many of the novel’s images of maternity only slightly less obviously monstrous than the figure of the Count himself. The figuration of motherhood as implictly monstrous begins both early in the text and early in the processes of the novel’s gestation. The historical Vlad Dracul was alleged to be guilty of appalling cruelty to mothers and their children, and Peter Haining and Peter Tremayne point to the possibility that Stoker may have been influenced by the story of Henry Holm, who, as a medical student,
32 Bram Stoker
obtained access to the tomb of his mother and cut off her head.21 Moreover, J. Sheridan Le Fanu’s Carmilla, an undoubted source for Dracula, centres on a girl apparently abandoned by her mother, and her victim, like Coleridge’s Christabel, is warned by the voice of her own dead mother.22 In the novel itself, Jonathan Harker, once in Transylvania, notes that ‘the women looked pretty, except when you got near them, but they were all very clumsy about the waist’ (D: 3). He thus registers a horror of the thickened waist – prime symbol of motherhood – found throughout Stoker’s work: in The Lady of the Shroud, the Voivode Vissarion, being rescued from mortal danger, still takes time to notice that the woman who is about to save him ‘was figured something like my Teuta, but broader, less shapely’ (Shroud: 175); it is in fact his daughter Teuta, with ropes coiled round her waist. The woman who supplies Harker with a rosary to ward off Dracula tells him that it is for his mother’s sake (D: 5); later Dracula himself hideously mimics motherhood when he puts Harker to bed and folds up his clothes (D: 40),23 and the ship which brings him to England is named after the earth-mother Demeter (a name which, surely significantly, Stoker had changed from the Dmitry which he found in his source).24 Most suggestively, the mother of the child whom Dracula kills is destroyed by a pack of wolves who flood in ‘like a pent-up dam when liberated’ (D: 45), just as she herself, the ‘dam’ of the child (a term used most often in ‘the devil and his dam’) has in a sense fallen victim to the extravagance of her own behaviour in trying to storm the castle door.25 The pattern persists in the central part of the novel. The inadequacy of Mrs Westenra, for instance, has often been commented on. Alan P. Johnson argues that it is her selfishness and instinct for selfpreservation which both drive Lucy into rebellion and strip her of her defences against Dracula.26 Suggestively, he also posits a link between Lucy’s unarticulated feelings for her mother and another of the novel’s representations of monstrous motherhood, the story of the suicide George Cannon, whose grave lies immediately beneath Lucy’s favourite seat in Whitby churchyard: The epitaph says that the slab and the seat were ‘erected by his sorrowing mother to her dearly beloved son’ and that ‘he died, in the hope of a glorious resurrection’. Swales states that ‘the sorrowin’ mother was a hell-cat that hated him … an’ he hated her
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 33
so that he committed suicide in order that she mightn’t get an insurance she put on his life.’ Although George Canon was outspoken in his filial rebellion, the antagonism between him and his hypocritical mother parallels closely the implicit antagonism between Lucy and Mrs. Westenra. Lucy’s response to Swales is revealing: ‘Oh, why did you tell us of this? It is my favourite seat, and now I cannot leave it …’27 And although Johnson does not develop the suggestion, he also attaches to his discussion of Mrs Westenra a brief consideration of the history of the wolf by which she is frightened to her death, a normally passive creature who may nevertheless, his keeper fears, ‘devour an untended baby in the park’28 – surely a potent image of such an annihilating rage against children from an unexpected source as characterises the novel’s other representations of monstrous motherhood. There is, too, the zoo-keeper’s instructive comment that ‘you can’t trust wolves no more nor women’ (D: 167), coupled with his explicit linking of a failure to nurture with unbridled female sexuality: If he can’t get food he’s bound to look for it, and mayhap he may chance to light on a butcher’s shop in time. If he doesn’t, and some nursemaid goes a-walkin ’orf with a soldier, leavin’ of the hinfant in the perambulator – well then I shouldn’t be surprised if the census is one babby the less. That’s all. (D: 169–70) There is no mention at all here of the child’s mother; her maternal role has been relegated to a careless nursemaid, more intent on securing her own sexuality and fertitlity than on attending to the product of another woman’s, and the grief that would be produced in her by the loss of her child is deflected by the brutal figuring of the dead infant as merely a statistic in the population count. Instead of the nurturing mother, we are left with the devouring mouth of the wolf (so reminiscent of the monstrous metamorphosis of Red Riding Hood’s grandmother) and the wandering sexuality of the nursemaid, deterministically drawn to the stereotype of aggression embodied by the soldier. Elsewhere in the novel, even the performance of nurturing cannot save the maternal woman from demonisation. As Christopher Craft
34 Bram Stoker
points out, the milk with which a mother feeds her child is radically confused in the image patterns of the text: ‘What are the relations between blood and semen, milk and blood?.’29 When Mina sucks from Dracula’s breast images of motherhood and images of monstrosity startlingly coalesce.30 This is even more the case when a somnambulistic Lucy actualises the fantasies of preying on small children which are expressed by that archetype of the devouring mother, Lady Macbeth; the parallel between the two is accentuated by her earlier tearing of a paper while asleep (D: 152), and again at the end when the three weird sisters appear to Van Helsing and Mina and lead to the death of the horses (D: 336–7), something which in Macbeth had functioned as a sign of the evil to come. Such mergings of nurturings and preyings recall one of the nineteenth century’s most startling images of monstrous motherhood, which occurs in the seemingly innocuous pages of Mrs Beeton’s The Book of Household Management (1861). Her adjuration to women not to go to sleep breastfeeding encodes some very interesting assumptions: the mother wakes in a state of clammy exhaustion, with giddiness, dimness of sight, nausea, loss of appetite, and a dull waking pain through the back and between the shoulders. In fact, she wakes languid and unrefreshed from her sleep, with febrile symptoms and hectic flushes, caused by her baby vampire, who, while dragging from her her health and strength, has excited in itself a set of symptoms directly opposite, but fraught with the most injurious consequences – ‘functional derangement’.31 For Mrs Beeton, a sucking infant is ‘a baby vampire’, and similar language is used in an American news report which Stoker may well have seen, subtitled ‘The Old Belief Was that Ghostly Monsters Suckled the Blood of Their Living Relatives’.32 Sally Shuttleworth, quoting the Beeton passage, goes on to focus on the deep tension felt in Victorian ideologies of femininity between the duties of the wife and those of the mother: ‘whenever a mother thus doats upon her children, she is guilty of an act of unfaithfulness to her husband’.33 On similar lines, Jill L. Matus quotes another self-styled nursing authority of the nineteenth century, Mary Anne Baines: If a married woman hired herself out to nurse another’s child, Mary Anne Baines asserted, her own must suffer. More import-
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 35
antly, her ‘husband’s comforts are not attended to, and thus temptations offer to wean a man from home and to contract irregular habits’ [(Matus’s) italics]. The husband, it would seem, is also in the position of the nursing child, weaned only at the responsible wife/mother’s peril.34 Once again, milk supply is imaged as conflicting with the demands of wifehood, although on this occasion difficulties arise only if the wife suckles children other than her own. Even when she does not do that, however, she can keep her husband only by infantilising him and by becoming, in effect, his mother. As with the wandering nursemaid, then, female sexuality cannot coexist with the ability to nurture. Commenting on the presentation of the vampiric Lucy, Christopher Craft points out: the child Lucy clutches ‘strenuously to her breast’ is not being fed but is being fed upon. Furthermore, by requiring that the child be discarded that the husband may be embraced, Stoker provides a little emblem of this novel’s anxious protestation that appetite in a woman (‘My arms are hungry for you’) is a diabolic (‘callous as a devil’) inversion of natural order, and of the novel’s fantastic but futile hope that maternity and sexuality be divorced.35 Lucy, like the woman who suckles a vampire in an act of infidelity to her husband, collapses codes and taboos about eating, menstruation, sexuality, nurturance and lesbianism36 into one hideous emblem of monstrous motherhood, in which it is always already the woman who is intrinsically perceived as demonic. Critical response to Dracula has generally identified two possible motivations for the deep-seated ambivalence in the portrayal of the novel’s women: Stoker’s attitudes to his own wife and mother, and his uneasiness at the the figure of the ‘New Woman’, about whom Mina jokes during the course of the novel, and who was widely seen as encroaching on the territory of masculinity. Ironically, it may have been the case that Stoker’s wife Florence did indeed divorce sexuality and maternity: Daniel Farson reported that ‘Stoker’s granddaughter believes that Florence refused to have sexual relations with Bram after the birth of their child’,37 though Ann Stoker later disassociated herself from this. The wider cultural context, however, should not be neglected. The text’s explicit reference to New
36 Bram Stoker
Women is a sufficient indicator of their importance in the genesis of Stoker’s conception of his female characters, and of the ambivalence associated with them – as Matthew Brennan comments, even Mina herself, ‘[d]espite her jokes about the New Woman … resembles one in several ways’.38 However, her difference from the New Woman is equally strongly signalled: ‘the New Woman was often a professional woman who chose financial independence and personal fulfilment as alternatives to marriage and motherhood’.39 Even when a New Woman espouses motherhood, she does so in terms which cannot help but ring alarm bells. This is certainly the case for Herminia Barton in Grant Allen’s The Woman Who Did, a novel which seems to have been an influence on Stoker – a friend of Grant Allen’s – since the scene in Stoker’s The Man in which Stephen invites Leonard up on to a hilltop to propose to him closely echoes Herminia’s hilltop soliciting of her reluctant lover. Herminia’s opinion is that Every woman should naturally wish to live her whole life, to fulfil her whole functions; and that she could do only by becoming a mother, accepting the orbit for which nature designed her. In the end, no doubt, complete independence would be secured for each woman by the civilized state, or, in other words, by the whole body of men who do the hard work of the world, and who would collectively guarantee every necessary and luxury to every woman of the community equally. In that way alone could perfect liberty of choice and action be secured for women; and she held it just that women should be so provided for, because the mothers of the community fulfil in the state as important and necessary a function as the men themselves do. It would be well, too, that the mothers should be free to perform that function without preoccupation of any sort. Herminia’s utopian vision of the future seems to allow of no space for women to nurture men; she would, therefore, doubtless incur the censure of Mary Anne Baines and Mrs Beeton, as well of moralists in other areas. And in the end, however much Allen may insist on her ‘stainless soul’, her own daughter thinks her choices mad.40 In contrast to many of the New Woman tracts, however, Stoker’s novels work habitually to reinsert his female characters into a
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 37
maternal role. As such, they seem to function in precise antithesis to the New Woman writers; but, as Nicholas Daly argues of a group of novels including Stoker’s early work The Snake’s Pass, ‘[i]t would be an over-simplification to think that the conservatism of these fictions works through a simple reversal of the gender roles presented in the New Woman novels.’41 The opposition in Stoker’s work between the New Woman and the maternal woman is figured not only by difference but by reaction, a reaction which leaves even the apparent sanctity of motherhood radically fissured by an ambivalence which may, in its turn, be further inflected by a psychological as well as a political response shaped by the dynamics of Stoker’s personal relationships with mother-figures. In Dracula, indeed, it may well be that the overt element of engagement with the particularities of the New Woman controversy actually serves to mask a more general malaise which would be more sharply visible in isolation. In fact, the emotional logic of Stoker’s other works suggests that this is indeed the case. Considerable light may be thrown on Dracula by a consideration of representations of monstrous motherhood elsewhere in Stoker’s writing, in texts shaped by imperatives other than what Senf has termed ‘Stoker’s response to the New Woman’. The imaging of motherhood as monstrous recurs throughout his work, from the very early novel The Snake’s Pass to his last novel, The Lair of the White Worm, where, in Alexandra Warwick’s formulation, the usual association between the vagina and birth is inverted because ‘[t]he worm/woman’s hole is where death lives, and not just ordinary death, but dreadful death from disease and corruption.’42 Incrimination of mother-figures surfaces even in the sophisticated comedy Lady Athlyne. In this novel, an exuberant cross between the inns and tight plotting of Tom Jones and the mistaken identities of The Importance of Being Earnest which also, in its frantic car journeys round the Scottish borders, prefigures John Buchan, there seems at first hardly to be space for a monstrous mother, or indeed for a mother at all: the mother of the heroine, ‘something of a valetudinarian’ (LA: 21), is packed off to Ischia for much of the book, and comprehensively eclipsed by her sister Judy, a maiden aunt of considerable gumption. Towards the end, though, Stoker’s characteristic obsessions abruptly find vent. The first hint of them may perhaps be seen when Colonel Ogilvie, the heroine’s irate father, threatens her
38 Bram Stoker
lover Athlyne that ‘for the disrespect in her description as a woman, you will have to answer me’ (LA: 281). When it unexpectedly transpires that having spent the night in the same hotel means that Joy and Athlyne are actually married, we revisit the familiar Stoker motif of the sexless wedding night: the Sheriff takes their having been in adjacent rooms as ‘proof of consummation’ (LA: 298), despite the fact that neither knew that the other was there. Finally, the joyful couple are joined, most unexpectedly, by Athlyne’s old wet-nurse, who, learning that they propose to regularise the situation by a second ceremony, asks improbably which of the two wives she supposes Athlyne to be thus taking ‘will be the mother?’ (LA: 319) and goes on, in the same atrocious brogue as Andy Sullivan of The Snake’s Pass, to make of Joy a strange demand: ‘Me lady, mayn’t I have the nursin’ av yer childher, the way I had their father before them? Though be the same token, it’s not the same nursin’ I can give thim, with me bein’ ould an’ rhun dry’ (LA: 319). No occasion, it seems, is quite complete without a monstrous mother figure present at it. Sometimes, of course, there are good, revered mothers in Stoker – but they are dead. Something of the same urbanity of tone as characterises almost the whole of Lady Athlyne is also found in Miss Betty. The opening of the novel, with the traumatic breaking of a china jar irresistibly recalling The Rape of the Lock, seems to augur social comedy, though we might note that this particular jar had been much cherished by the child’s dead mother (MB: 9); moreover, Betty’s inheritance, albeit channelled through her great-grandfather, is imaged largely as maternal, with the great-grandfather’s memories of ‘my mother, who, when a child like you, stood with her mother on the heights of Portland Bill and saw the great Armada’ (MB: 21) and the three generations of women who link the child to the greatgrandfather. All these women are dead, however, and Betty feels bitterly the want of a mother (MB: 78). The same is true of Stephen Norman in The Man, a book whose agenda is to assert that gender is innate: Stephen Norman may have been brought up effectively as a boy, but she can never truly become one, not least because ‘[i]n the nature of every woman, old or young, there is something of motherhood; and with Stephen this found expression with regard to her father’ (Man: 24). Both her mother and that of Harold An Wolf, her childhood friend and eventual lover, die young, and are revered and
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 39
regretted; indeed Stephen faints with grief at the sight of her mother’s coffin (Man: 64–5). Living mothers, though, fare less well. Harold cites motherhood as a reason why women cannot be just: ‘Do you think that Sheriff of Galway, who in default of a hangman hanged his son with his own hands, would have done so if he had been a woman?’ (Man: 7), and Stephen as a baby is nursed by Mrs Jarrold, whose ‘own baby had died as the result of an accident a few days after its birth’ (Man: 18) – not a very encouraging testimony to the quality of its care, especially given the addition that ‘[s]he had no other child alive’. The portrayal of motherhood is hardly more cheering when we are adjured to ‘[s]ee how little babies in the street obey the bigger babies in charge of them, as distinguished from the reluctant yielding to the stronger pressure of maternal power’ (Man: 51), while a subsidiary character dies from what Stephen’s aunt, who very effectively replaces her mother (Man: 106), terms ‘[t]he sin … of woman’s wrong-doing … as woman … of motherhood, without marriage!’ (Man 86). Even Mrs Stonehouse, apparently admirable as a mother, cannot comfort her daughter as the presence of Harold does, and little Pearl, in a passage which would now be unwritable, opts to sleep in his bed rather than her mother’s (Man: 296–7), while the book’s metaphors further undo its explicit project when Stephen is interpellated as future mother only by suffering imaged as motherhood: ‘[t]he motherhood of pain is a factor in the making of a strong life’ (Man: 142). Motherhood may be the natural, desirable state towards which Stephen must move, but its darker side is, once again, well in evidence. The idea is also very pronouced in the short stories which make up the volume Dracula’s Guest. In ‘The Burial of the Rats’, a tale centred on the repeated stripping to the bone of fresh corpses left accessible to rats, the gruesome events are specifically located near the Enceinte (DG: 101), which is the French term not only for a protective fortification but also for ‘pregnant’. In ‘A Dream of Red Hands’, motherhood, being in this case the product of seduction, is a hideous and fatal misfortune which can be only obliquely described: ‘I learned that her shame had come and that she had died in it’ (DG: 132). Most telling of all is the story entitled ‘The Squaw’, a sustained portrayal of monstrous motherhood. The narrative opens on a singularly disenchanted picture of newly married life: ‘My wife and
40 Bram Stoker
I being in the second week of our honeymoon, naturally wanted someone else to join our party’ (DG: 43). They soon find the desired addition in the shape of a brash American named Elias P. Hutcheson, hailing from the suggestively named Bleeding Gulch, who very soon after they meet him accidentally brains a kitten while in their company. The kitten is not one of a large litter, but the only offspring of its mother, who is virtually demented with grief. However, it is not the grief of the cat which becomes the focus of narrative attention, but her lust for revenge, as rather than pitying her or dwelling on the pathos of the situation, we are immediately invited to perceive her as alarming and dangerous: I shall never forget the sight, for she looked the perfect incarnation of hate. Her green eyes blazed with lurid fire, and the white, sharp teeth seemed to almost shine through the blood which dabbled her mouth and whiskers. She gnashed her teeth, and her claws stood out stark and at full length on every paw. Then she made a wild rush up the wall as if to reach us, but when the momentum ended fell back, and further added to her horrible appearance for she fell on the kitten, and rose with her black fur smeared with its brains and blood. Amelia turned quite faint, and I had to lift her back from the wall. (DG: 45) The blood on the cat’s mouth and whiskers is in fact the kitten’s, whose wounds she has been licking, but within the language of the passage it creates an impression not of motherly care but of monstrosity, with its marked association with the blood-sucking mouth of the vampire. Like the mother in The Snake’s Pass, the cat is both driven wild by grief and also physically marked as other, her fur smeared with the brains and blood of her dead kitten just as the human mother’s throat bears the mark of the snake. There is no attempt at all to create empathy with her; we share the narrative point of view of the young couple and their new acquaintaince, looking down on her from above, and the use of the technical term ‘momentum’ marks the difference between our superior, scientifically grounded apprehension of the situation and the cat’s uninformed attempt to scale a sheer wall (mimicking the fruitless gallantry of the human mother who
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 41
climbed the hill where the King of the Snakes lived, and implanting a disturbing suggestion of an equation between motherhood and animality). It was in fact precisely such a superior awareness of the laws of gravity, and a resulting sense of superiority grounded in both literal and emotional distance, that led to the original accident, since Hutcheson’s motive in throwing the stone which brained the kitten was to mystify the animals and demonstrate his greater understanding of spatial laws: ‘I will drop it near the kitten, and they will both wonder where it came from’ (DG: 45). What the passage does not foreground, but what does later become apparent to the reader, is that there is another mother present. That Amelia’s faintness is not to be ascribed solely to the inherent horror of the incident she has just witnessed first begins to become clear when the party immediately afterwards move on to the Torture Tower: Amelia grew quite pale with the horror of the things, but fortunately did not faint, for being a little overcome she sat down on a torture chair, but jumped up again with a shriek, all tendency to faint gone. We both pretended that it was the injury done to her dress by the dust of the chair, and the rusty spikes which had upset her, and Mr Hutcheson acquiesced in accepting the explanation with a kind-hearted laugh. (DG: 50) The reader, however, cannot emulate Mr Hutcheson, since it has been so clearly signalled to us that the explanation which he ‘acquiesced in accepting’ is merely a ‘pretended’ one. Given the situation of the young couple, the obvious explanation will surely be that Amelia’s faintness is caused by her being in the first stages of pregnancy. This may initially seem unlikely, since it is only the second week of the honeymoon, but there are two potential explanations for this: either the honeymoon has not taken place immediately after the wedding – which is perfectly possible – or conception occurred at once, in which case Amelia might just have had time to observe that her period had not arrived as usual, and might also have become aware of some of the physical changes which can mark even the very first stages of pregnancy.
42 Bram Stoker
That this is in fact the true situation is signalled still more plainly in a third episode of fainting, when the party is shown the instrument of torture known as the Iron Virgin: The sight was too much for poor Amelia, and this time she fainted dead off, and I had to carry her down the stairs, and place her on a bench outside till she recovered. That she felt it to the quick was afterwards shown by the fact that my eldest son bears to this day a rude birthmark on his breast, which has, by family consent, been accepted as representing the Nurnberg Virgin. (DG: 51) Amelia’s experiences prove to be disfiguringly written on the body, and in this Stoker precisely echoes the numerous medical manuals of the day which warn that any stress or upset, or any negative emotions, experienced by the mother during pregnancy will leave their physical mark on the baby43 (one wonders what the effect of Mina Harker’s experiences before and during gestation will be on the constitution of her child). At this current stage of Amelia’s pregnancy, however, it is precisely not written on her own body; it can be, and is, concealed – though the phrase ‘acquiesced in accepting’ suggests that Hutcheson may not be actually deceived. Instead, he subscribes to the socially required fiction that the condition of a pregnant woman is too delicate a matter to be openly spoken of – a convention that makes an awkwardness of incipient motherhood by its attempt to render the all-too-visibly pregnant body invisible in speech. Though Amelia’s own pregnancy is delicately dealt with, other representations of motherhood within the text are overtly monstrous. Hutcheson compares the vengeful cat with another vindictive mother of his acquaintance: Wall, I guess that air the savagest beast I ever see – ’cept once when an Apache squaw had an edge on a half-breed what they nicknamed ‘Splinters’ ’cos of the way he fixed up her papoose which he stole on a raid just to show that he appreciated the way they had given his mother the fire torture. She got that kinder look so set on her face that it jest seemed to grow there. She followed Splinters more’n three year till at last the braves got him
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 43
and handed him over to her. They did say that no man, white or Injun, had ever been so long a-dying under the tortures of the Apaches. (DG: 46) This anecdote of matching pairs of mutilated and murderous mothers and children prefaces the climax of the narrative, the party’s encounter with the instrument of torture known as the Iron Virgin, which, despite its title of Virgin, is actually figured as an incarnation of a monstrously destructive maternal womb: the central object in the whole of this chamber of horrors was the engine known as the Iron Virgin, which stood near the centre of the room. It was a rudely-shaped figure of a woman, something of the bell order, or, to make a closer comparison, of the figure of Mrs Noah in the children’s Ark, but without the slimness of waist and perfect rondeur of hip which marks the aesthetic type of the Noah family. (DG: 50) The Virgin is explicitly sexual here, associated with Mrs Noah and clearly showing in her shape either the potential or the actuality of childbearing; she also mimics very closely Victorian ideas of female beauty, which were precisely centred on the female ‘reproductive organs’.44 When the Virgin is further investigated, the emphasis on a ‘womb’ becomes even more pronounced: It was only, however, when we came to look at the inside of the door that the diabolical intention was manifest to the full. Here were several long spikes, square and massive, broad at the base and sharp at the points, placed in such a position that when the door should close the upper ones would pierce the eyes of the victim, and the lower ones his heart and vitals. (DG: 51) To enter the virgin is to lose one’s eyes – the traditional punishment for sexual sin, as in the cases of Oedipus and of Gloucester in King Lear, of whom it is said that ‘The dark and vicious place where thee he got/ Cost him his eyes’.45 It is suggestive, too, that this is the
44 Bram Stoker
sight that directly precipitates Amelia’s third episode of faintness and the consequent revelation of her own pregnancy: the story’s most overt comment on literal human motherhood lies immediately adjacent to its most terrifying metaphorical manifestation of the womb. Elias Hutcheson’s reaction to the Iron Virgin is very different from Amelia’s. Utterly fascinated, he wants to recreate the experience of its original victims as fully as possible by being himself bound and inserted into the hideous belly of the engine. Still not satisfied, he exhorts the custodian to impart even greater verisimilitude: ‘Now, Judge, you jest begin to let this door down, slow, on to me. I want to feel the same pleasure as the other jays had when those spikes began to move toward their eyes!’ (DG: 53). It is while this is being done that the cat finds him, and leaps at the face of the custodian, tearing one eye across and forcing the custodian to drop the lid onto the unfortunate Hutcheson. The narrator, faced with an unconscious wife, a dead friend and a half-blinded custodian, acts decisively. In a ghastly parody of a Caesarian section, he removes the mangled body of Hutcheson from the Virgin and lets it fall on the floor, where the cat immediately pounces on it, ‘purring loudly as she licked the blood which trickled through the gashed socket of his eyes’ (DG: 55); and, says the narrator in the brief paragraph which concludes the story, ‘I think no one will call me cruel because I seized one of the old executioner’s swords and shore her in two as she sat’ (DG: 55). The turn of phrase deliberately invites a reader response, but that response may well not be the one which the narrrator anticipates, for his action is not the natural, inevitable reaction to the situation which he seems to think. To shear the cat in two suggests a bisection which, if imagined literally, could involve cutting through her womb – a second parodic Caesarian on which the narrator’s concern for his unconscious, pregnant wife might well seem to function as a powerful, silent commentary. The horror of the scene has been such that the young husband ‘feared for her very reason if she should wake from her faint to such a scene’ (DG: 55) – the final association of motherhood with madness in a text which, through the unstated logic of its symbolic patternings, has insistently represented motherhood as mania and as destruction, and has penalised its manifestations with the deaths of children and the most brutal of deliveries.
Early Life in Stoker’s Fiction 45
Mother figures in Stoker, then, are closely and consistently associated with monstrosity. Jeffrey Spear argues that in Dracula, ‘the fantasy of reunion with the pre-Oedipal mother is also the threat of a horrific reabsorption by that which gave suck’,46 and Phyllis Roth similarly suggests that vampirism elicits from the men a blurring between ‘memory of nursing at the mother’s breast with a primal scene fantasy which produces the fear that the sexually desirable woman will annihilate if she is not first destroyed’.47 This seems, in fact, to be the basic logic persistently underlying Stoker’s writing, which on one level insists on a separation of the sexual and the maternal while, at another, radically confounding them, and seeing maternity as in fact impossible to confine within its appointed bounds but dangerously, monstrously, manifesting itself elsewhere. This is a patterning which seems, ultimately, only partly explicable in terms of a response to the unease generated by the New Woman; underpinning it, surely, is a far more wide-reaching and deeperseated psychological unease with woman as mother which may well be attributable to Stoker’s own feelings of ambivalence about the devouring mother and the maternal wife, and a marker of the process by which Abraham Stoker the Dublin boy grew into Bram Stoker the author of Dracula.
This page intentionally left blank
2 At the Theatre
Stoker’s Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving began with a simple statement of the event which was to prove the most momentous of his life: ‘The first time I ever saw Henry Irving was at the Theatre Royal, Dublin, on the evening of Wednesday, August 28, 1867’ (PR I: 1). Stoker was then aged 20. After that first encounter, when Stoker realised that there were no regular theatre reviews appearing in the Dublin press, he offered his own services for free, and was thereafter associated with the theatre for the rest of his life. Nine years after first seeing Irving on stage, he was finally introduced to the great man, and the two bonded for life over an odd episode in which Stoker was apparently reduced to hysterics by Irving’s recital of ‘The Ballad of Eugene Aram’, a long narrative poem which focuses on the guilty conscience of a murderer: as Stoker himself put it, ‘In those moments of our mutual emotion he too had found a friend and knew it. Soul had looked into soul!’ (PR I: 33). Jeffrey Richards suggests that ‘It is perhaps significant that Stoker’s father died aged 77 in 1876, the year he had his momentous encounter with Irving’,1 and that Stoker was thus perhaps subconsciously seeking a replacement father-figure. Whether this was so or not, he had found in Irving a man who from now on would be at the emotional centre of his life. Eventually, Irving invited Stoker to join him in London, rescuing him from the clerk’s position at Dublin Castle to which he had hitherto been confined,2 and as Stoker remembered years later, ‘In my diary that night, November 22, 1877, I wrote: “London in view!”’ (PR I: 54). The history of that connection is central to the meanings of Stoker’s work, affecting every level of his texts from the 47
48 Bram Stoker
construction of his plots to the extent and functions of his allusions to plays and dramatic characters. In his collection of Stoker’s short stories, Midnight Tales, Peter Haining unequivocally traces the origin of all the tales in the volume and many others of Stoker’s works to the post-theatre dinners regularly hosted by Irving at the Lyceum (MT: 6). Haining suggests, for instance, that Dracula may have been influenced by the Greek actor Jacques Damala, husband of Sarah Bernhardt, of whom Stoker wrote in his diary, ‘He looked like a dead man’ (MT: 7), and Haining also ascribes the origin of the Gombeen man story to one of Stoker’s many talks with Gladstone about Ireland in the Beefsteak Room (MT: 71). Stoker himself openly advertises the Irvingesque origins of his short story ‘The Squaw’ when he writes in the opening paragraph, ‘Nurnberg at the time was not so much exploited as it has been since then. Irving had not been playing Faust, and the very name of the old town was hardly known to the great bulk of the travelling public’ (DG: 43). Haining claims that ‘in the course of an atmosphere-gathering trip to the Brocken Mountains, where the final scenes of Goethe’s Faust, one of Irving’s favourite pieces, were set, Stoker and Irving visited Nuremberg and saw the Iron Maiden’ (MT: 85); in fact Paul Murray points out that, although Barbara Belford unequivocally asserts it,3 there is no evidence that Stoker went to Nuremberg, though other members of the Lyceum Company did. 4 However, the Crown Prince of Germany, the future Emperor Frederick, certainly discussed Nuremberg with Stoker at the Lyceum (PR I: 179). Murray does though think that ‘The Atlantic storm in The Man … had its genesis in a hurricane which struck when Stoker was crossing the Atlantic on the SS Marquette in 1899 with the Lyceum Company’,5 while Haining traces ‘The Red Stockade’ to Stoker’s and Irving’s entertainment of the officers and crew of the US cruiser Chicago in 1894, particularly Admiral Erben, who had coined the phrase ‘Blood is thicker than water’ (MT: 120). Stoker’s most vivid portrait of theatrical life as he knew it comes in the collection of short stories Snowbound: The Record of a Theatrical Touring Party. Structured on the principle of The Canterbury Tales, this offers a picture gallery of briskly sketched characters, headed by Mr Benville Nonplusser, the Irvingesque manager. The collection deliberately teases the reader about the extent to which it is based on
At the Theatre 49
actual experience. The preface to the volume reads (in its entirety) ‘The Truth – or rather Accuracy – of these Stories may be accepted or not as the Reader pleases. They are given as Fiction’, and the Wardrobe Mistress says Mr Sparbrook’s story is a lie because he was never in Australia (Snowbound 89), and that the story of the star trap is also not true (Snowbound: 145). However, Bruce Wightman argues that the events are certainly based on the experiences of the Lyceum Company: In Volume II of Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving Stoker records that in January 1904, while Irving was touring the USA and Canada, the company’s train became ‘snowbound’ in the Adirondack Mountains in upstate New York. The experience evidently played on Stoker’s mind, though in his fictional account he switches the setting from the United States to Scotland. (Snowbound: 9) Indeed the Guard’s remark that ‘the Stoker has gone out to prospect’ (Snowbound: 14) looks almost like an advertisement of personal involvement. The stories certainly, and conspicuously, testify to a precise and detailed knowledge of the theatrical scene. The Manager, organising the making of a fire on the snowbound train, orders: Now, Hempitch, you get out the thunder and lay it here on the floor on the lee side of the car opposite this window; you will see, Guard, that the iron sheet will protect the floor. You, Ruggles, get a good lump of modelling clay from Pygmalion and make a rim all round to keep in the ashes. Then, Hempitch, have halfa-dozen iron braces and lay them on billets or a couple of stage boxes. On this platform put down one of the fireplaces – any one will do. Then, Ruggles, you will put a Louis XI chimney over it, with a fire backing behind, and make an asbestos fire-cloth into a chimney leading out of the window; you can seal it up with clay. (Snowbound: 16–17) There is also a cleverly sustained tension developed not only through the match between teller and tale, as in the Chaucerian
50 Bram Stoker
model, but also in that between teller’s personality, as revealed by the tale, and teller’s rôle in the company, since most of the characters are identified primarily or exclusively by titles such as the Singing Chambermaid or the Second Low Comedian. There is a degree of narrative control here not often found in Stoker, and indeed this is for the most part one of the most measured and tonally assured of all his works, apart from the utter vitriol animating the portrait of the Tragedian, Mr Wellesley Dovercourt. There is, however, one note persistently sounded which aligns Snowbound directly with Stoker’s more disturbing writing. Early in the sequence of tale-telling, the Sewing Woman threatens to recount a story about ‘a dead byby’ (Snowbound 37). She is never allowed to do this, but nevertheless the fantasised deaths of babies haunt the narrative, as they do elsewhere in Stoker: a baby is eaten in Dracula, and in Miss Betty we are told that ‘Lucy … lay beside her baby and her husband too in the deep sea beyond the Dogger Bank where the Queen of Sheba went down with all hands’ (MB: 26). In Snowbound, the Tragedian declares that Dead babies are always cheerful. I love them on the walls of the Academy. The Christy Minstrels’ deepest bass as he trills his carol, Cradle’s Empty, Baby’s Gone, fills me with delight. On such a night as this, surrounded as we are by the profound manifestations of Nature’s feller forces, the theme is not uncongenial. Methinks the very snow-wreaths with which the driving tempest smites the windows of our prison-house are the beatings of dead baby fingers as they clamour to lay ice-cold touches on our hearts. (Snowbound: 38–9) Along similar lines, the Second Heavies declares: When a man has a large family – I regret to say that at that time my first wife was nursing her seventh – he acquires a certain indifference to infantile querulousness. As a matter of fact, he does not feel sympathy with the child at all, his pity being reserved for other people. All babies are malignant; the natural wickedness of man, as elaborated at the primeval curse, seems to find an unadulterated effect in their expressions of feeling.
At the Theatre 51
I confess that the sight of a child crying, and especially crying angrily – unless, of course, it disturbs me in anything I may be doing – affords me a pleasure which is at once philosophical, humorous, contemplative, reminiscent and speculative. (Snowbound: 92) And the other people on the train with a crying baby object to its presence in distinctly threatening terms: ‘Say, mister! What kind of a howling-piece is it you have got there? Have none of you boys got a gun?’ There came from the bunks a regular chorus of acquiescence: ‘The durned thing had ought to be killed!’ (Snowbound: 93) Danger is only averted when, in a scene reminiscent of Harold’s rapport with Pearl in The Man, a young man dressed only in his under-flannels succeeds in pacifying the baby, which goes to sleep on him (Snowbound: 94–5). Nevertheless, the disturbing note has been sounded, and the intrusion of one of Stoker’s darker obsessions is, I think, a telling indication of the extent to which his emotions and indeed the deepest fibre of his being were touched in his work at the theatre. Though surrounded by actors throughout his time at the Lyceum, Stoker himself was not acting. Initially, the story of the Lyceum was a story of success. Irving’s popularity was assured from the moment he gave his first performance as Mathias in The Bells on 25 November 1871, ‘catapulting him to stardom’.6 Irving’s knighthood was announced on 25 May 1895 and the actual ceremony was performed on 18 July of the same year, making him the first actor ever to be knighted. Stoker’s association with the Lyceum gave him an entrée to the very highest levels of society. The people he knew ranged from crowned heads and American presidents to writers, including Hall Caine, dedicatee of Dracula, who Stoker thought looked like Shakespeare7 and for whom he worked as a literary agent after Irving’s death, as well as pruning his autobiography for him (Snowbound: 7); Mark Twain; Conan Doyle, whom Stoker met in 1891 when he brought the manuscript of his play Waterloo to the theatre and who subsequently became a regular guest at the Beefsteak Room; and Tennyson, whom he follows in
52 Bram Stoker
deploying Arthurian mythology in The Shoulder of Shasta when Reginald is the only one who can pull Dick’s knife out of the floor (Shasta: 125). The literary scene in which Stoker’s novels appeared, moreover, was one conditioned by Irving and his performances at the Lyceum. A particularly interesting example of this is afforded by another book which nearly threatened to eclipse Stoker’s own most successful work. As its most recent modern editor notes, Richard Marsh’s book The Beetle was published in September 1897, just two months after Bram Stoker’s Dracula, and was, initially at least, even more of a popular success with the reading public than Stoker’s now canonical work. There is an apocryphal tale that Stoker and Marsh had a wager to see who could produce the most successful supernatural novel.8 There are in fact no known links between Marsh and Stoker, though Julian Wolfreys notes that ‘Marsh’s writing, from the earliest examples onwards, demonstrates the occasional depiction of somewhat sadistic sexuality or, as in the schoolboy stories, the expression of homoerotic affection’ (Beetle: 10), which might well seem reminiscent of Stoker’s own sexual attitudes. There are, however, a number of points of similarity between this text and Dracula, and they help to illustrate the way in which deployment of theatrical allusion was a crucial tool in both novels’ repertoire for the making of meanings. Julian Wolfreys opines that What is truly unsettling, I would suggest, for the late Victorian reader of The Beetle, is that a ‘science,’ already seen in a highly ambivalent light by the end of the century, is appropriated by a non-European monstrous other for clearly criminal and sexual purposes, all of which are aimed at undermining any self-reflective certainties about the stability of identity, whether one is speaking of class-position, masculinity, femininity, national identity, or secure belief in one’s own position as a subject of empire. That mesmerism is employed to achieve this in the hands of the ‘degenerate’ gothic foreigner, proves all the more efficacious as a narrative device in unleashing the irrational and unconscious fears at the
At the Theatre 53
heart of Englishness. As in Dracula, mesmerism provides the opportunity for the unscrupulous predatory alien to control and devastate not merely through physical attack and corporeal destruction, but also through the psychic erasure of the boundaries which one imposes on oneself as the necessary limits of self-definition. From this it can be suggested that mesmerism is readable as an act analogous with sexual penetration, an analogy borne out in both Dracula and The Beetle. (Beetle: introduction, 12–13) (Mesmerism, as we shall see, will also be a concern in Stoker’s last novel, The Lair of the White Worm.) There are certainly strong similarities between Dracula and Richard Holt’s narrative in The Beetle, which declares, among other things: That the man in the bed was the one whom, to my cost, I had suffered myself to stumble on the night before there could, of course, not be the faintest doubt. And yet, directly I saw him, I recognized that some astonishing alteration had taken place in his appearance. To begin with, he seemed younger, – the decrepitude of age had given place to something very like the fire of youth. His features had undergone some subtle change. His nose, for instance, was not by any means so grotesque; its beak-like quality was less conspicuous. The most part of his wrinkles had disappeared, as if by magic. And, though his skin was as yellow as saffron, his contours had rounded, – he had even come into possession of a modest allowance of chin. But the most astounding novelty was that about the face there was something which was essentially feminine; so feminine, indeed, that I wondered if I could by any possibility have blundered, and mistaken a woman for a man; some ghoulish example of her sex, who had so yielded to her depraved instincts as to have become nothing but a ghastly reminiscence of womanhood. (Beetle: 61) This uncertainty about gender is a crucial concern in Stoker’s work in general, and the sinister man who rejuvenates himself obviously recalls Dracula in particular.
54 Bram Stoker
Equally reminiscent of Dracula are Atherton’s remark about his Arab visitor, ‘He must have made pretty good travelling, because, before I had a foot in the hall, I heard the front door slam’ (Beetle: 106), and the episode in which Atherton kidnaps what he takes to be Lessingham’s cat to demonstrate his killing machine (Beetle: 136), just as Renfield wishes for a cat to experiment on in order to test his theory of life. Moreover, Marjorie in The Beetle, like Lucy in Dracula, receives three proposals, from Lessingham, Atherton and Woodville, while Sydney, cornering the alien in his rented house, is oblivious to the fact that Marjorie, left alone, is in danger (Beetle: 228–9), just as Mina falls victim to Dracula while the Crew of Light are searching Carfax. Lessingham echoes Jonathan Harker’s reaction to the three women in Castle Dracula when he says of ‘the Woman of the Songs’: ‘Leaning over, she wooed my mouth with kisses. I cannot describe to you the sense of horror and of loathing with which the contact of her lips oppressed me’ (Beetle: 241). Holt is discarded like Renfield, and two good men and one tainted one, who correspond closely to the Crew of Light, pursue Marjorie and the Arab by train and telegraph. Gender proves as unstable in this text as in Dracula when Champnell says of Lessingham, ‘This Leader of Men, whose predominate characteristic in the House of Commons was immobility, was rapidly approximating to the condition of a hysterical woman’ (Beetle: 292), and the Inspector finds on Holt’s body ‘two abrasions on the skin, – one on either side of the man’s neck’ (Beetle: 303). Moreover, both texts seem to have syphilis as a subtext, since we are told of the dying Holt that ‘Even his nose was wasted, so that nothing but a ridge of cartilage remained’ (Beetle: 303) and Champnell opines, ‘I doubt … if this man has been murdered. It looks to me like a case of starvation, or exhaustion, – or possibly a combination of both’ (Beetle: 303). Syphilis notoriously destroys the nose, and as has been so much remarked on in connection with Stoker’s own death certificate, ‘exhaustion’ was a common euphemism for the effects of syphilis. It is also possible that the name Marjorie prompted that of the heroine of Stoker’s later The Mystery of the Sea, especially since both women make a miraculous recovery from near or apparent death. It is, therefore, suggestive that both texts choose to play out their parallel concerns in highly theatricalised language steeped in allusions to Shakespeare in particular. There are a number of references
At the Theatre 55
in The Beetle to Shakespearean texts. Macbeth, for instance, is remembered when Holt says ‘If I could I would not have stood upon the order of my going, but gone at once, anywhere, anyhow’ (Beetle: 74; Macbeth III.iv.118), or when Marjorie says of her father, ‘He has not actually forbidden me to speak to Paul, – his courage is not quite at the sticking point’ (Beetle 193; Macbeth I.vii.61). A Midsummer Night’s Dream is echoed when Atherton says, ‘Now, cabman, don’t go driving further on, – you’ll have to put a girdle round the earth if you do’ (Beetle: 258; Dream II.i.175–6), and The Merchant of Venice when Marjorie says, ‘The mere suspicion of a harmless, and, I am told, necessary cockroach, being within several feet has always made me seriously uneasy’ (Beetle: 205; Merchant IV.i.55). There are shades of Antony and Cleopatra when Marjorie is kidnapped by the Arab, has her clothes removed, and is dressed as a boy. Her friends even think that she has been wrapped in the carpet, as Enobarbus says that Cleopatra had been (Antony IV.vi.68–70). Jonson’s praise of Shakespeare is recalled when Holt says, ‘I gazed at the frightened figure in front of me, and realized that it was that of the great Paul Lessingham, the god of my political idolatry’ (Beetle: 76), and there is an attempt at a direct quotation from Twelfth Night when Sydney Atherton says of Marjorie, ‘all that time – well, I was nearly persuaded that the whole of the time I had loved her. If I had not mentioned it, it was because I had suffered my affection, “like the worm, to lie hidden in the bud,” – or whatever it is the fellow says’ (Beetle: 97). King Lear is recalled when Lessingham says to Atherton of Holt after Atherton has seen him jumping out of the window, ‘Poor fellow! more sinned against than sinning!’ (Beetle: 101; Lear III.ii.59–60), and Othello when Champnell says of Lessingham, ‘He shook Sydney as if he had been a rat, – then flung him from him headlong onto the floor. It reminded me of nothing so much as Othello’s treatment of Iago’ (Beetle: 253). Above all, there is a particular quantity of references to Hamlet. Atherton says that ‘The cat which I choose to believe is Paul Lessingham’s has received its quietus’ (Beetle: 137; Hamlet III.i.75), and notes that after Woodville has accidentally gassed himself: ‘I was conscious of exclaiming, – remember the saying about the engineer being hoist by his own petard’ (Beetle: 138; Hamlet III.iv.209). When the Arab offers to make Marjorie love him, Atherton asks, ‘pray how is this consummation which is so devoutly
56 Bram Stoker
to be wished to be brought about?’ (Beetle: 143; Hamlet III.i.63–4). Lindon goes behind a screen to eavesdrop on Atherton and Marjorie (Beetle: 161) shortly before Marjorie herself remarks, Claudius-like, that ‘I knelt down, and I prayed, but the words couldn’t come’ (Beetle: 166, Hamlet III.iii.97–8), an episode which is rounded off in a manner multiply reminiscent of Hamlet when Atherton warns Lindon of Marjorie that ‘You don’t want people to say you have driven her into a lunatic asylum’ (Beetle: 171). Finally, Champnell calls the apparent destruction of the beetles’ lair ‘a consummation devoutly to be desired’ (Beetle: 321; Hamlet III.i.63–4 again). The parallels between Dracula and The Beetle should alert us to the extent to which Stoker’s novels need to be read against a general background of the theatre. Jeffrey Richards declares that Dracula ‘is steeped in the atmosphere and imagery of the Lyceum’,9 while Barbara Belford maintains that ‘Dracula is all about Irving as the vampire and Terry as the unattainable good woman’.10 It is certainly true that Dracula abounds in theatrical memories and language – Stephanie Moss, for instance, relates Dracula’s lack of reflection to the theatrical trick known as ‘Pepper’s ghost’11 – and at one point the novel even reflects directly on Stoker’s Lyceum experiences: ‘Our correspondent naïvely says that even Ellen Terry could not be so winningly attractive as some of these grubby-faced little children pretend – and even imagine themselves – to be’ (D: 177). Also, and more particularly, the parallels between Dracula and The Beetle draw our attention to the ways in which theatrical allusion is associated with danger, and likely to accrue to villains in particular, or to those whom the text is overtly or covertly incriminating. The specific influence of Irving in this process should not be underestimated; Barbara Belford’s DNB article on Stoker declares that ‘Stoker also wanted to create a dark, sinister role to swell the actor’s repertory of villains, from Mathias to Macbeth to Mephistopheles. Dracula was a homage to Irving’, while John Pick and Robert Protherough claim that Dracula was based specifically on Irving as Macbeth,12 the part which his dresser claimed was his best on the grounds that he sweated twice as much in that as in Hamlet.13 Stoker’s novels in general are indeed particularly interested in rôles which Irving performed, Hamlet and Macbeth in particular (The Watter’s Mou’, for instance, speaks of a church built by Malcolm, Macbeth’s successor [WM: 47–8]), and the mesmeric power of Edgar
At the Theatre 57
Caswall in The Lair of the White Worm, for instance, might well recall Irving’s experiments in this area. Dracula openly announces its own status as a novel influenced by Hamlet. Quite apart from the obvious reference to ‘“My tablets! quick, tablets!/” Tis meet that I put it down’ (D: 36), John Allen Stevenson observes of Mina’s scar that ‘the caste mark is also a kind of venereal scar, not only because it results from the count’s seduction of Mina but also because the echo of Hamlet’s accusation against Gertrude is far too strong to be accidental’,14 while Philip Holden argues that ‘The continual direct quotation of and reference to Shakespearean tragedy in the early part of the novel ally Harker’s own conflicted masculine subjectivity with that of Hamlet and Macbeth, characters through whose example, Henry Irving suggested, “higher moral education” might be achieved.’15 Hamlet is first echoed when ‘All at once we heard the crow of a cock coming up with preternatural shrillness through the clear morning air’ (D: 25) and Dracula leaves immediately, the Hamletian overtones of which are made clear when Jonathan writes, ‘Mem., this diary seems horribly like the beginning of the “Arabian Nights,” for everything has to break off at cockcrow – or like the ghost of Hamlet’s father’ (D: 30). Like Elsinore, where Horatio fears that the Ghost may tempt Hamlet to fall from a cliff, Dracula’s ‘castle is on the very edge of a terrible precipice. A stone falling from the window would fall a thousand feet without touching anything!’ (D: 26); like Hamlet, Jonathan exhorts himself, ‘Let me not think of it. Action!’ (D: 46). Van Helsing comically misremembers the language of Laertes’ resolution of revenge when he declares ‘this case of our dear miss is one that may be – mind, I say may be – of such interest to us and others that all the rest may not make him kick the beam, as your peoples say’ (D: 119), which distorts Laertes’ vow to Ophelia: ‘By heaven, thy madness shall be paid with weight/ Till our scale turn the beam.’16 Lucy writes that she is ‘hoping for sleep, and lying like Ophelia in the play, with “virgin crants and maiden strewments”’ (D: 132); and Seward, like Hamlet, ‘determined … to “be cruel only to be kind”’ (D: 270). It is sometimes even suggested that Van Helsing’s name should be traced back to Helsingor, the Danish version of Elsinore. Macbeth is also recalled: indeed it is a play which Barbara Belford sees as central to the genesis of Dracula, arguing that ‘Many similarities exist between Macbeth and Dracula’ and that 1888
58 Bram Stoker
was the year of the first Ripper murders and of the Lyceum Macbeth: ‘At this time Stoker conceptualized a story that would intermingle Shakespeare’s dark psychology with contemporary evils’. (Michael Valdez Moses points to Stoker’s comment, in the preface to the Icelandic edition of Dracula, that ‘the 1888 Whitechapel murders of Jack the Ripper “originated from the same source” as the murders in Dracula’.)17 One notable pattern is that those who quote Hamlet in Stoker are likely to prove more reliable or more accurate than those who quote Othello, and this may well derive from Irving’s very different attitude towards the two plays. Virtually every aspect of the conception of Othello changed during the course of the nineteenth century, largely as a result of the scientific racism to which Darwinian theory gave rise. In the earlier half of the century, William Charles Macready, touring the United States in the rôle, had been appalled by the conditions in which he saw black slaves being kept and had felt that it was an outrage against humanity: he wrote in his journal, ‘I should neither wonder nor blame if I saw these black and dusky men strike their knives into the brutal bosoms of those who assert the right of might over them.’18 This is language strongly suggestive of identification – he empathizes with the position of the slaves as opposed to that of those who have power over them, whose possible murder he contemplates with complete equanimity. The same repudiation of any possibility of identification with white Americans is found again when he notes, ‘I am sick of American audiences; they are not fit to have the language in which Shakespeare wrote.’ 19 A very different attitude characterizes later imaginations of Othello, however. Irving’s was compared to a sepoy, an Other rather than a Self, like that of Fechter (to whose Hamlet Ellen Terry played Ophelia, 20 and who offered Irving himself an engagement) 21 before him, and the Italian-language performances of Tommaso Salvini, one of the century’s most notable Othellos, equally estranged the Moor from the English-speaking cast around him. It might also be worth noting that Stoker claimed not to have expected the Lyceum’s proposed staging of a play on the life of Mohammed to prove controversial (as it did) in a Christian country, suggesting little interest in or understanding of Islam, and though he would of course know that Othello seems to be represented as a convert from Islam
At the Theatre 59
rather than an adherent to it, he would also know that Iago at least believes the change to be only skin-deep. It is therefore unsurprising that in The Jewel of Seven Stars, for instance, it is the astute Dr Winchester who refers to ‘more things in heaven and earth’ (Jewel: 60), echoing Hamlet’s words to Horatio, while in Snowbound, the unpretentious Prompter twice echoes Hamlet, first when he says of the heat: ‘It was just a miracle how moustaches stuck on; and as for the flush of youth and beauty on the girls’ cheeks! – well, “there is a Providence that shapes our ends, rough hew them how we will”’ (Snowbound: 62–3) and then when he laments that I suppose I must confine myself to some personal experience, and that connected with the theatre. It is a pity I am so limited; as if I were free to speak of the adventures of my youth by flood and field, ‘I could a tale unfold’ that would ‘freeze your young blood and make each particular hair to stand on end like quills upon the fretful porcupine’. (Snowbound: 61) Hamlet can also be used as a benchmark for shoddiness of aspiration or achievement, as when we are told in Snowbound that ‘he had, with the best and purest intention, he assured us, dared the blue ribbon of histrionic achievement in essaying the part of Hamlet in the Ladbroke Hall’ (Snowbound: 77). It might perhaps be pertinent here to note that it was when Irving was playing Hamlet that fire broke out in the theatre and only Stoker’s prompt action prevented panic and a possibly fatal stampede for the doors, and that when he first came to work at the Lyceum he found that Irving had already taken such financial gambles that ‘[e]verything depended on the success of Hamlet’.22 By contrast, the callow Juvenile Lead who makes such a foolish confession on the train which faces possible derailment at Bayou Pierre, in contrast, quotes Othello when he speaks of how ‘That evil quality, which, like jealousy, “mocks the meat it feeds on,” had grown with the enlarging successes which seemed to whirl upon him like giant snowflakes from the Empyrean’ (Snowbound: 76). And in Lady Athlyne the remark that Athlyne watching Joy and her father ‘knew they would be starting out after tea time which meant, he
60 Bram Stoker
knew, something after five o’clock; and not for a world of chrysolite would he miss being there’ (LA: 148), which echoes Othello, proves the ironic prelude to a spectacular failure to be in the right place at the right time. Othello himself seems to be regarded as untrustworthy by Stoker. In The Lair of the White Worm, Adam says of the loathsome Edgar Caswall that ‘He seems to think he had only to throw his handkerchief to any woman, and be her master’ (WW: 31), an image which seems to recall Othello’s gift of a handkerchief to Desdemona, while in The Shoulder of Shasta, watching the growth of the clearly undesirable intimacy between Dick and Esse, After a while Mrs Elstree came to understand something of the feelings of Brabantio, as he afterwards reflected on the method of Desdemona’s wooing by Othello – with the exception that she assured herself that in no way had Dick the smallest intention of making love. (Shasta: 81) This clearly suggests that Mrs Elstree at least, and presumably Stoker as well, does not take Othello’s apparent disingenuousness at face value. Stoker’s fiction, then, is rooted in Irving’s Shakespearean repertoire. It was probably also the case that Stoker hoped that Irving would act Dracula, but he never did; Barbara Belford suggests that the part may have been too small for him, since ‘Dracula is present on only sixty-two pages out of a total of 390 in the first edition’.23 However, I think the direct influence of Irving on Stoker’s fiction is overestimated. In the first place, here is what seems clearly to be a testimony to the influence of Irving on Stoker’s work: in Stoker’s novel The Primrose Path, a ‘tall mesmeric Irving-like actor “who was performing the part of ‘Mephistopheles’”’ (Path: introduction, 9) in a production which was ‘a version of Faust, and the dresses were the same as those used in Gounod’s opera’ (Path: 51) interferes in the destiny of a young Irish immigrant and ultimately leads him astray. The novel clearly attests to an intimate knowledge of the theatre: we are told that ‘The outside of a small theatre is at the best of times unpromising’ (Path: 50); that ‘Theatrical life, save on occasions, begins late’ (Path: 55); and that ‘It is the misery of all those whose
At the Theatre 61
work is connected with the arts that there is a spice of uncertainty in everything’ (Path: 56). Moreover, the authentic note of the author of Dracula is surely sounded when we hear that ‘Jerry kept dreaming of slots, and flies, and wings, and flats, and vampire traps, and grooves, and PS (prompt side), and OP (opposite prompt side)’ (Path: 57). In particular there are some significant Shakespearean references to plays that were central to Irving’s repertoire: ‘Jerry awoke with an evil conscience, that which makes “cowards of us all”’ (Path: 64), and when Jerry confronts Katey in her bed, believing that she has been unfaithful, ‘The big veins stood out on his forehead and his eyes rolled’ (Path: 103); he then kills first her and then himself. However, The Primrose Path was first published in 1875 as a serialisation in The Shamrock, and thus predates Stoker’s first actual meeting with Irving, even if not his first sight of him, by almost two years. The awareness of theatre that permeates this novel thus cannot be ascribed solely to Irving. Moreover, Irving was not the only reason that Stoker referred to Shakespeare, and nor was he by any means the only writer of his time to do so. Shakespeare was a crucial cultural reference point for Victorian and Edwardian England. Allusion to Shakespeare shored up cultural capital and also offered a quick and ready means for writers to make a number of points with maximum economy. In the first place, allusion to Shakespeare offered a shortcut to asserting the importance of traditional gender norms. Again, this is an established pattern in late Victorian and early Edwardian culture: Edward Drinker Cope, who spoke of leaving the prince out of Hamlet, was violently opposed, on allegedly scientific grounds, to the New Woman movement. In The Lady of the Shroud, the Lady, like the ghost of Hamlet’s father, flees at the crowing of the cock (Shroud: 73). Although she is eventually revealed as non-vampiric, she is nevertheless, in traditional Stoker fashion, still to some extent incriminated and belittled, first by association with Dracula – we are told of her ancestors that ‘this was the race of that first Voivode Vissarion, of whom, in legend, it was prophesied that he – once known as “The Sword of Freedom,” a giant among men – would some day, when the nation had need of him, come forth from his water-tomb in the lost Lake of Reo’ (Shroud: 145), and the aeroplane on which she rides is imported from Whitby (Shroud: 211) – and second by a brief but ominous reference to Othello, when she asks Rupert to take
62 Bram Stoker
her to the Silent Tower and he replies ‘Not for a world of chrysolite!’ (Shroud: 169). Second, allusion to Shakespeare inevitably brought with it a sense of metatheatre, of rôle play, and of the doublings which were both a requirement of the conditions of Shakespearean theatre and a powerful psychological tool. This was particularly useful for Dracula, since it is a text which is interested above all in uncanny doublings and mirrorings, something which was indeed firmly in line with Irving’s theory of the double consciousness of an actor. As Michael Valdez Moses points out, In his notes for Dracula, Stoker projected a scene (never written) in which a painter attempts to render a lifelike portrait of the vampire but discovers that, ‘however hard the artist tries, the subject always ends up looking like someone else’.24 John Allen Stevenson suggests that ‘The vampire, “the other,” “the monster” – everything that Dracula represents, and represents so powerfully – depends on our refusal to see the ways in which he is also a mirror. After all, it is Harker who can see nothing in the glass’,25 and certainly when Jonathan asks, ‘Where his body has gone why may not another body go?’ (D: 46), he postulates a dangerous equivalence between the two people between whom the novel is officially trying to put most distance. The uncanny similarity between Harker and Dracula is repeatedly suggested, and indeed Joseph Valente calls Dracula ‘[s]omeone whose occupational temper and expertise are unexpectedly cognate with Harker’s own, but of superior merit, perhaps even forming something of an ego-ideal for the younger man’. He cites in particular Harker’s remark that Dracula ‘would have made a wonderful solicitor’, and notes that Harker first sees Dracula in London on his way back from the funeral of Mr Hawkins, his surrogate father. Valente also poses the question ‘How does Harker know how vampires multiply? … How does he even know that they multiply?’ and points to ‘a detailed pattern of affinities and correspondences that align the vampire with the various vampire fighters in London, much as he is twinned with Jonathan Harker in Transylvania’. As he well observes, ‘Renfield in effect informs Mina that he is on her side – he wishes only her safety – and that, in a structural sense, he is on the other
At the Theatre 63
side.’26 But then the women themselves are also ambiguous: as Alan P. Johnson notes, ‘In the case of each woman, Dracula symbolizes her inner rebelliousness, and its crisis coincides with her commerce with Dracula.’27 Equally sinister is Seward musing on allowing Renfield to continue his experiments: ‘If only there were a sufficient cause! I must not think too much of this, or I may be tempted; a good cause might turn the scale with me, for may not I too be of an exceptional brain, congenitally?’ (D: 71). The suggestion of a doubling here is bolstered when Seward gets out of the window Renfield had escaped through (D: 101). More systematically, there is a sustained pattern of doubling between humans and animals. Not only can Dracula effortlessly cross the border between the two, but the wolf-keeper says, ‘there’s a deal of the same nature in us as in them there animiles’ (D: 136). His wife confirms this – ‘’E’s got mindin’ the animiles so long that blest if he ain’t like a old wolf ’isself!’ (D: 137) – and it is also demonstrated by the behaviour of Renfield, who is found ‘lying on his belly on the floor licking up, like a dog, the blood which had fallen from my wounded wrist’ (D: 141). Equally, Franco Moretti declares that Quincy Morris is a highly suspect character: Morris is a vampire … Lucy dies – and then turns into a vampire – immediately after receiving a blood transfusion from Morris … Morris, shortly afterwards, tells the story of his mare, sucked dry of blood in the Pampas.28 Perhaps most alarming is the suggestion of a bond between two ostensible opposites, Dracula and Van Helsing, when Van Helsing appears to be able to read his enemy’s mind: ‘he have gone back to Transylvania. I know it so well, as if a great hand of fire wrote it on the wall’ (D: 315). Joseph Valente also points out that ‘the one figure in the novel whose eyebrows are said to fit Lombroso’s category, “bushy,” is Van Helsing’,29 and it might be worth noting that Van Helsing’s pronunciations and grammatical slips are very close to those of the villainous Jew Mendoza in The Watter’s Mou’: ‘For you, mein frient Keith, this check, which one week you cash, and for you, my tear Miss Alice, these so bright necklace, which you will wear, ant which will sell if you so choose’ (WM: 27). As Valente comments,
64 Bram Stoker
‘the character bearing perhaps the most varied metonymic and metaphorical links with the Count is Van Helsing’.30 As part of the novel’s interest in uncanny doubling, there are also, alongside its references to Hamlet, allusions to other plays by Shakespeare, and these do not always work in the same direction as those in Hamlet. Jonathan in Castle Dracula exhorts himself, Great God! merciful God! Let me be calm, for out of that way lies madness indeed. I begin to get new lights on certain things which have puzzled me. Up to now I never quite knew what Shakespeare meant when he made Hamlet say: – ‘My tablets! quick, tablets! ’Tis meet that I put it down’ (D: 36) This ends with one of the novel’s most overt allusions to Hamlet, but it also encodes within itself a quiet but potent recollection of a different play, King Lear, echoing Lear’s ‘O! that way madness lies; let me shun that’.31 The same passage is also echoed when Jonathan writes, ‘Whilst I live on here there is but one thing to hope for: that I may not go mad, if, indeed, I be not mad already’ (D: 36), and a third time when Seward exclaims ‘Stop; that way madness lies!’ (D: 225). Renfield quotes poor Tom in Lear when he says of spiders, ‘“Rats and mice and such small deer” as Shakespeare has it’ (D: 271; III.iv.135) and Seward recalls Goneril when he says of Renfield that ‘These infinitesimal distinctions between man and man are too paltry for an Omnipotent being’ (D: 100). Othello is also evoked: Lucy on being proposed to by Quincey Morris declares, ‘I sympathize with poor Desdemona when she had such a dangerous stream poured in her ear, even by a black man’ (D: 57), and Seward says Van Helsing has ‘a temper of the ice brook’ (D: 112; Othello V.iii.253). Nor is the fourth of the great tragedies forgotten, for Lucy tearing the paper while still asleep is an obvious image of Lady Macbeth (D: 152). Barbara Belford also argues that one of the tragicomic last plays is evoked in Dracula, since she suggests that ‘Bedroom visitations recall Cymbeline’.32 Even when an undoubted comedy, Twelfth Night, is briefly remembered, it is only for one of its darkest parts, as Seward observes that Renfield ‘smiled on me in quite a superior sort of way – such a smile as would have become
At the Theatre 65
the face of Malvolio’ (D: 268) (and a performance of Twelfth Night was the occasion of a rare Lyceum failure and audience unrest).33 Obviously this rapid reference-check of Shakespearean tragedy serves to keep the overall tone of the novel suitably dark and ominous. However, it also does other cultural work as well. To associate Lucy with Lady Macbeth serves as a further incrimination of an already compromised character, linking her with the three sisters in Castle Dracula as Lady Macbeth can be linked with the witches and confirming how much the men need to band together to dispose forever of the threat she poses. But this is an allusion that can cut two ways, for Lady Macbeth’s exhortations to her husband to commit murder are clearly based on the premise that he does not fulfil her idea of a man. This is also what is implied by Goneril’s ‘Oh! the difference of man and man’ (IV.ii.26), which is what can be heard lying behind Seward’s ‘These infinitesimal distinctions between man and man’; she is complaining that the man whom society has assigned to her does not offer the same level of excitement as the one who is seeking her illicitly, a suggestion which Dracula too can all too readily be seen as making and one which does no favours to the Crew of Light. Finally, both Morris and Van Helsing are metaphorically blackened by the references to Othello, since Morris is compared to the hero of that play while Van Helsing quotes him. In the debate about gender rôles which was so fed by Darwinian theory, reference to Shakespeare was generally felt to function as a guarantor of the safe separation of women from men, but Shakespeare when actually quoted does not so readily lend himself to neat schematisation. In Dracula, as so often in Stoker, the quotations from Hamlet may allow for an ennobling vision of man and his capacities, but the quotations from other plays reveal something much less safe and comfortable about Victorian society and what it holds dear. Not long after the publication of Dracula, the Lyceum began to fall on hard times. Irving fell and strained his knee on 19 December 1896, after the unpromising opening night of Richard III. In his review of this, George Bernard Shaw suggested that Irving was drunk, which whether true or not damaged his reputation. At around the same time, a production of a play about Peter the Great mounted by Irving’s son Laurence was a financial disaster for the theatre, and Irving himself developed pneumonia and pleurisy in
66 Bram Stoker
1898. A disastrous fire on 18 February 1898 damaged almost the entirety of the theatre’s expensive, irreplaceable, and insufficiently insured stock, and from then on the story of the Lyceum is a sad tale of steady and irrevocable decline. The end finally came with Irving’s death on 13 October 1905, after performing in Bradford, and Stoker’s connection with the theatre was finally ended. If Stoker had finished with the theatre, though, the theatre – and much more so its indirect successor the cinema – had by no means finished with Stoker. His own adaptation of Dracula, probably intended simply to protect his copyright (he later had Miss Betty acted at the Lyceum for the same reason), was first performed on 18 May 1897. A centenary read-through took place at the Spaniards Inn, Hampstead, on 18 May 1997, at which it was noted that, even when read at great speed, it still took six hours to perform. As its editor notes, ‘There is every reason to believe that the original reading was much the same, except that it is likely that the original reading had the futher handicap of having only the one manuscript to read from’, and she concludes that ‘Irving himself is reported to have looked in and to have described what he saw as “Dreadful!”. In all probability he was right’.34 Quite apart from the question of length, adapting Dracula for the stage also brought to the fore issues of censorship: Later efforts to adapt the play for the stage certainly brought out the censor’s blue pencil. The Lord Chamberlain would have nothing to do with phrases such as ‘reeking lips’ which were initially included in Hamilton Deane’s dramatic adaptation of the novel in 1924.35 Nevertheless, adaptations were allowed and did well:36 in his memoirs, the actor Geoffrey Kendal recalls acting in Hamilton Deane’s Dracula well into the 1930s.37 It has prospered even more on the silver screen, not least because, as Jonathan Bignell notes, ‘contemporary film and TV Draculas recast the story in order to address the fears of our own time’.38 The Internet Movie Database lists 13 exact hits for Dracula and 132 other titles related or derived from Dracula in a variety of languages, culminating in Francis Ford Coppola’s Dracula, whose distinctively modern sensibility has led Kenneth Jurkiewicz to call it ‘a New Age parable of free will, eternal
At the Theatre 67
love, and second chances gratefully taken’. Jurkiewicz proposes that its message is ‘[t]here’s hope for everybody, … even for an embittered centuries-old Byronic Übermensch with a bad attitude and an even worse drinking problem’.39 The film not only bestowed notoriety on Gary Oldman, who played Dracula, but also inspired a short story which was printed in a centenary collection of Dracula spin-offs. The author, Kim Newman, says that the premise of this ‘is what it would have been like if Francis Ford Coppola had made Dracula as one of his good films’, and it is modelled on the ‘process of the making of Apocalypse Now’.40 Instead of Keanu Reeves, this fictional version would have starred Martin Sheen (who nearly dies of a heart attack during filming, although Coppola won’t stop the camera rolling for it, and is resuscitated by the vampire heroine Kate Reed), and Marlon Brando, who does endless method-inspired renditions of the same mumbled line, ‘I am Dracula’; it would have been filmed on location in Romania during the days of Ceacescu, would have gone massively over both budget and schedule, and would have bled all those associated with it dry (sometimes literally). It is hard to imagine what could follow this masterpiece of postmodern parody. There have also been films of the short story ‘Burial of the Rats’ and The Lair of the White Worm, and, most notably, The Jewel of Seven Stars. These include Blood From the Mummy’s Tomb (1971, directed by Seth Holt) and The Awakening (1980, directed by Mike Newell), not to mention Jeffrey Obrow’s 1997 Bram Stoker’s Legend of the Mummy and, subsequently, David DeCoteau’s Ancient Evil: Scream of the Mummy (2000). There are also clear parallels between The Jewel of Seven Stars and Stephen Sommers’s The Mummy (1999) and, to a lesser extent, The Mummy Returns (2001).41 Performance, which was so central an element of Stoker’s daily life, has thus proved central, too, to his literary afterlife.
This page intentionally left blank
3 London with its Teeming Millions
Stoker is almost as ambivalent about England as he is about mothers. ‘London with its teeming millions’ is what Count Dracula hopes he will be able to prey on when he leaves his Transylvanian crypt. When Stoker left Dublin for London in 1878, he entered a world which offered him many more opportunities.Certainly Stoker’s work, and particularly his early work, registers a distinct sense of frustration with Ireland as a small and indeed cramping arena, as when we read in The Snake’s Pass of how the priest tells Phelim Joyce that he should be thankful because he has ‘such a boy as Eugene, winnin’ name and credit, and perhaps fame to come, even in England itself’ (SP: 41), or that At Dublin Mr. Caicy met me, as agreed; and together we went to various courts, chambers, offices, and banks – completing the purchase with all the endless official formalities and eccentricities habitual to a country whose administration has traditionally adopted and adapted every possible development of all belonging to red-tape. (SP: 191) Similarly in Famous Impostors we read in relation to the Perkin Warbeck episode that ‘It cannot be denied that the Irish people were in this matter as unstable as they were swift in their judgments’ (FI: 14), while Andrew Smith points to the importance in Stoker’s fiction of his ‘view that Ireland would benefit, economically, by becoming part of Britain although crucially it would not have to 69
70 Bram Stoker
surrender its own cultural history’;1 as Mrs O’Brien says of the earl of Athlyne in Lady Athlyne, ‘An Irishman!God be thanked he is.But me Lady, av it’ll plaze ye betther he’s an Englishman too, an’ a Welshman an’ a Scotchman as well!’ (LA: 13). The Snake’s Pass also shows an acute awareness of the kind of language all too often used by the English about the Irish, when Moynahan says ‘He’s a nagur, anyhow – Black Murdock the Gombeen – bloody end to him!’ (TSP: 196). Taken together with the earlier discussion about how Norah is dark but not a ‘nigger’ (STP: 101), this illustrates only too clearly Stoker’s awareness of how dangerously volatile and floating the concept of negritude could be, and how easily it could be affixed to the Irish.2 Although ‘Stoker’s cousin John Dillon proclaimed that the Irish deserved Home Rule “because we are white men”’, in 1895 Lord Salisbury, then Prime Minister, openly compared the Irish to Hottentots in their incapacity for self-rule,3 and the phrase ‘the Niggers of Europe’ was all too often applied to them. Under such pressure as this, a form of self-deprecating humour might well seem to the only possible gambit. Arthur Conan Doyle, a friend of Stoker’s who was also of Irish origin, resorted to selfparody in his short story ‘The Fiend of the Cooperage’ in which two Irishmen, Severall and Walker, are the only white men on a distant island: ‘What do we do?’ said the Doctor, when I had begun asking questions in my turn.‘Our business keeps us pretty busy, and in our leisure time we talk politics.’ ‘Yes, by the special mercy of Providence Severall is a rank Radical, and I am a good stiff Unionist, and we talk Home Rule for two solid hours every evening.’4 Stoker, too, sometimes registers a clear sense of the Irish as comic, as when he records how Lady Wilde greeted a woman whom Stoker had introduced to her as ‘half English and half Irish’ with ‘Your English half is as welcome as your Irish bottom’.5 However, he also had a persistent sense of national identity, and the two impulses did not always sit easily together. After all, as David Glover notes, ‘to be a “believer” in physiognomy who was also Irish, let alone a “believer” in Irish Home Rule – no matter how “philosophical” – was to find oneself torn by a contradictory set of allegiances’.6 In
London with its Teeming Millions 71
Stoker’s novels, however, the Irish feature primarily for comic effect, like Andy O’Sullivan in The Snake’s Pass or as when Mrs O’Brien declares in Lady Athlyne, ‘An’ him in Bowness – for that’s where he tells me he’s shtoppin’ – an’ his wife in Ambleside – on their weddin’ night!Begob!Ireland’s changin’ fast, fur that usen’t to be the way. I’m thinkin’ that the Shinn-Fayn’ll have to wake up a bit if that’s the way things is going to go’ (LA: 326). Stoker himself, however, never forgot Ireland. Joseph Valente points out that ‘the stage-minded Stoker regularly took up the works of Dion Boucicault, Anglo-Ireland’s most successful playwright, as sources for his Irish fiction’,7 and Dracula in particular has often been related to Ireland. Although some scholars have tried to trace a descent for the vampiric count from the real-life Transylvanian warlord Vlad Dracul,8 David Glover argues rather that ‘Paradoxically it is Dracula, at first glance among the least Irish of all Stoker’s texts, that goes furthest in establishing his pedigree as a distinctively Irish writer. For Dracula properly belongs within the Anglo-Irish Gothic tradition’,9 and Joseph Valente well observes that ‘A founding insight of the Irish Dracula school of criticism has been that Harker’s observations in Transylvania refer in whole or in part to the features of life in Ireland in the nineteenth century.’10 Cannon Schmitt, who compares the hyphen in Anglo-Irish to the hyphen in Un-Dead, argues that ‘The savage bestiality of [Dracula’]s vampiric attacks combined with the aristocratic hauteur of his manner suggests the peculiarly Irish double threat of Fenianism and Catholic feudalism.’ He points out that ‘Dracula is feeding Mina, feeding her from his breast’ and compares this with the fears voiced about Irish wet-nurses.11 Joseph Valente argues that ‘the literal meaning of the name Transylvania, “beyond the forest,” irresistibly suggests “beyond the Pale”’; he also points to ‘the name of Dracula’s self-identified tribal group, the Szekelys, which means “at the frontier or beyond”’, and notes that ‘[w]hen Dracula finally comes into direct confrontation with Jonathan Harker, Van Helsing, and the rest … he derides them as “pale faces” (D: 267), an odd ethnic slur considering the Count’s own “extraordinary pallor”’. For Valente, what is crucial is that ‘this dramatic encounter with Little England occurs in a London townhouse whose purchase was arranged in Sackville Street, eponymous with the main thoroughfare of Dublin, the very heart of the Pale … Moreover, Dracula’s phrase picks up on the prior usage of his agent /
72 Bram Stoker
victim, R. N. Renfield, who complains, “I don’t care for the pale people” (D: 245)’.12 Noting that ‘the sole indisputably Irish classification of Dracula in Stoker’s own working notes consists of a single word, Fenian’ and that Mina’s ‘full Christian name, Wilhelmina, is the Dutch feminine form of William and, as such, alludes to the most famous Dutch William of them all, William of Orange’, Valente suggests that the figure of Dracula recalls Percy Bysshe Shelley’s comment, long before the famine, that ‘the Aristocracy of Ireland sucks the veins of inhabitants’ or Fanny Parnell’s reprobation of the same class as ‘coroneted ghouls.’And surely Dracula is intended to bring to mind Michael Davitt’s castigation of the Irish landowners as ‘cormorant vampires’ – after all, Dracula’s initial assault on Lucy Westenra leaves her with ‘an appetite like a cormorant’ (101).13 Equally, Michael Valdez Moses, noting that ‘In May 1887, Charles Stewart Parnell coolly attended a performance at the Lyceum Theatre in London’, suggests that ‘Parnell serves as a model (and a particularly malleable and politically suggestive one) for Stoker’s aristocratic vampire’. In particular, Valdez Moses argues that ‘Though Renfield is nowhere referred to as Irish, his condition as an imprisoned subject under direct British supervision, one who in the absence of his English warder, John Seward, must be monitored by an Irish doctor named Patrick Hennessey, provides fertile ground for an allegorical reading.’14 Similarly, and suggestively in view of Stoker’s central concern with writing, Gary Day argues that ‘All writing in the novel is subordinated to the style of the professional middle class, which aims at the clear communication of facts. This is incompatible with a foreigner’s use of English and this is why neither Dracula nor Van Helsing are allowed to write their own record of events.’15 A particularly interesting insight into Stoker’s conflicted attitudes to Irishness can be found in his various references to the so-called Shakespearean authorship controversy. As might be expected of someone who was ultimately to write a book called Famous Impostors, Stoker was interested in the idea that the plays of Shakespeare might have been written by someone else, an idea often played with in his
London with its Teeming Millions 73
circle, as when W. S. Gilbert naughtily enquired ‘Do you know how they are going to settle the Shakespeare-Bacon dispute?They are going to dig up Shakespeare and dig up Bacon and let Tree recite Hamlet to them. And the one who turns over in his grave will be the author.’16 Stoker recounts how It was quite a treat to hear Irving and Robert Browning talking. Their conversation, no matter how it began, usually swerved round to Shakespeare; as they were both excellent scholars of the subject the talk was on a high plane. It was not of double-endings or rhyming lines, or of any of the points or objects of that intellectual dissection which forms the work of a certain order of scholars who seem always to want to prove to themselves that Shakespeare was Shakespeare and no one else – and that he was the same man at the end of his life that he had been at the beginning. These two men took large views. (PR II: 89) Also in the Personal Reminiscences, he tells how Tennyson, referring to the theory that Sir Francis Bacon wrote the plays, ridiculed the idea. ‘From the Shakespeare side he was indignant of a doubt. From the Bacon side he was scornful’ (PR I: 235). Stoker then proceeds to tell a story about how an Irishman in a bar, asked to adjudicate on the authorship of the plays, decides, ‘thim plays was not wrote be Shakespeare! But they was wrote be a man iv the saame naame!’ This presumably notional Irishman displays none of the finesse of Irving, Tennyson or Browning in his approach to the subject: he merely comes out with a palpable absurdity. Although Ellen Terry’s father was of Irish descent, Stoker was the only Irishman at the Lyceum, and these anecdotes clearly register that his situation as an Irishman in England was not an easy one, not least because, as the DNB article on Irving notes, he was perforce at war with one of the other prominent Irishmen in London: From January 1895 until 1898 George Bernard Shaw was theatre critic for the Saturday Review, and during that time he pursued an implacable course of harassment against Irving, ostensibly because he did nothing for contemporary playwrights and ignored the new direction which the theatre had taken from the example of Ibsen.
74 Bram Stoker
Stoker’s open reference to Ibsen in The Lady of the Shroud – ‘Think of that, Hedda!’ (Shroud 244) – might perhaps be seen as something of a peace offering in this respect, especially since Ellen Terry was by now acting in Ibsen. Given the sense of Ireland and Irishness as constricting, the move to England in December 1878 was understood as a liberation and advancement, and the Stokers’ life in London was comfortable: on the 1881 census Bram Stoker, who gives his occupation as ‘Theatrical Manager M.A.’ and his age as 33, is living at the desirable address of 27 Cheyne Walk with Florence, 21, born Falmouth, son Irving N. Stoker, 15 months, Stoker’s brother George, who gives his occupation as physician and surgeon, Elizabeth Jarrald, aged 30, nurse, Harriett Daw from Notting Hill, aged 21, cook, and Emma Barton from Woodford, Essex, aged 15, housemaid; on the 1901 census, when the family are living at 18 St Leonards Terrace, Chelsea, Stoker is ‘Barrister at Law’, and Irving Noel Thornley Stoker is Accountant Apprentice. The other members of the household are Maria Mitchell from Dorking, 63, housekeeper, and Louisa Driver from London, 27, parlourmaid, so although they no longer needed a nurse now that Noel had grown up, they are still maintaining enough servants to spare Florence from any domestic work. At the same time as registering the way in which the census records these servants, however, it is also worth noting that both Stoker’s personal affairs and his literary works show many signs of resistance to this kind of formalised knowledge-gathering and to what David Glover has termed ‘the various “régimes of truth” upon which [Stoker] draws’,17 and that this was an aspect of life as a public figure in London which he might well have found irksome. Paul Murray notes, for instance, that ‘It is difficult to square Stoker’s tortuous progress towards finalising a four-year BA course in almost six years with his claim that he had graduated with “Honours in Pure Mathematics”’,18 and the information supplied on the 1881 census both exceeds the bounds of what was formally required and at the same time misleads: Stoker himself has given not only his occupation but also his qualification – ‘M.A.’ – which was something the census was not designed to elicit. Stoker was exceptionally proud of his MA: when he left Dublin Castle, ‘His colleagues presented him with a handsome silver wine-ewer, inscribed “To Bram Stoker MA from the Members of his office”’,19 and as Paul Murray notes, The
London with its Teeming Millions 75
Daily News in 1894 mocked Stoker for his insistence on possessing an MA,20 while Barbara Belford observes that ‘On passenger lists his name was followed by “M.A.,” a form he also used on business cards’ and that ‘For the twenty-five years Florence outlived her husband, she referred to him in publications only as a barrister – never as the author of Dracula or the acting manager for the late Sir Henry Irving’.21 Nevertheless, Joseph Valente claims that ‘Even Stoker’s university degree, the only one among the Lyceum company, failed to earn him the respectability he craved, mainly because it was conferred by an Irish institution.’22 Other information on Stoker’s census entry is equally unhelpful or not to the point. His son, always known as Noel, appears accurately but unhelpfully as ‘Irving N. Stoker’;23 on the 1901 census Stoker’s stated profession of ‘Barrister at Law’ is entirely unrealistic and bears no relation to reality – although Stoker was called to the Bar in 1890, he never practised – while Florence Stoker, who was listed as 21 on the 1881 census and should therefore now be 41, has stayed at an elegant 39. (She had also given Thornley Stoker’s address rather than her parents’ on the marriage certificate.)24 Stoker was well aware of the imperatives to collect and categorise infomation: his mother Charlotte was ‘an active member of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland’, and his own first book ‘The Duties of Clerks of Petty Sessions has been seen as part of what Thomas Richards calls the “imperial archive” – “a fantasy of knowledge collected and united in the service of state and Empire” which, in Stoker’s novel, is responsible for the defeat of Dracula’, in which particular attention is paid to the importance of systematically tracking dog ownership by observance of the licensing system.25 He also made great use of statistics in his talk on ‘A Glimpse of America’.26 Nevertheless the dominant impression in his fiction is one of resistance to such projects, and to the inquisitive bureaucratic gaze. Although Colonel Ogilvie in Lady Athlyne declares that ‘Those people who go under an alias are to my mind the worst of criminals’ (LA: 37), Stoker’s novels are full of people who change their names, Lord Athlyne himself being a case in point. Moreover, although Athlyne initially regrets his adoption of an alias, it proves the providential mechanism for bringing him and Joy together, and Stoker takes a visible delight in minute description of the process by which
76 Bram Stoker
Athlyne evades official scrutiny of his disguises. When Athlyne goes to America as Mr Hardy, he was altogether in a disappointed and a discontented frame of mind. The acute cause of this was the filling up of the immigration paper which is so exhaustive as to details as to become inquisitorial. The answering of each question seemed to him like telling a lie – as indeed it was. As, however, he had nothing to declare and was without obvious objection he had no trouble. (LA: 58–9) Indeed Betty in Miss Betty expressly wishes that she could say to Rafe, ‘You have given me your name – a woman who has none worth having in our English law’ (MB: 42), which explicitly legitimises name-changing for women at least. Dracula has a number of such concealments, which sit in ironic tension with Stoker’s official position. David Glover comments, Though Dracula is clearly a quasi-legal narrative of the kind pioneered and popularised by Wilkie Collins, it also needs to be read against the background of Stoker’s exhaustive compilation of The Duties of Clerks of Petty Sessions in Ireland (1879), written with the aim of enhancing bureaucratic effectiveness throughout ‘the whole British Empire’ while the author was still employed as a civil servant in Dublin. There … Stoker itemised the formal requirements in preparing evidence for use in court proceedings in words which echo those of the novel’s prologue … Empirically, … Dracula pretends to the status of ‘simple fact,’ assembling an impressive variety of sources, predominantly journal or diary entries, but also including newspaper articles, letters, fragments from a ship’s log book, and an alienist’s case notes. Yet the opening chapters of the novel present us with the law’s fallibilities.27 All the main events of the Victorian life-narrative – birth, marriage and death – are represented in Stoker’s novel, but in each case they are represented and transacted in such a way as to mystify the vigilance of Victorian civic authority and evade and indeed destabilize the proliferating categories devised to describe and circumscribe
London with its Teeming Millions 77
identity. Although Jonathan Harker comments on the clerk who observes that ‘“The affairs of their clients are absolutely safe in the hands of Mitchell, Sons & Candy”’ that ‘This was manifestly a prig of the first water’ (D: 266), the Crew of Light are anxious to keep such knowledge to themselves, and systematically evade the information-gathering processes of others: ‘We think that we shall not have much trouble with officials or the seamen. Thank God! this is the country where bribery can do anything, and we are well supplied with money’ (D: 334), while Seward has no qualms about the fact that ‘I gave Renfield a strong opiate tonight, enough to make even him sleep, and took away his pocket-book to look at it’ (D: 70) and Van Helsing serenely declares that ‘All chambers are alike to the doctor’ (D: 281). Van Helsing is indeed so confident in his right to be omniscient that he even usurps spiritual authority, for amidst its plethora of professional men in the shape of solicitors, medical and psychiatric practitioners, there has perhaps been insufficient attention paid to who doesn’t appear in Dracula: there is no priest, in any shape, denomination or form. Gary Day suggests that it was not only that ‘The language of religion, organized around the opposition of good and evil, was being replaced by a language of expediency; the priest was giving way to the professional’, but that ‘Religion … exists in some tension with the professional ideology of Dracula. A religious view of the world, for example, entails notions of individual responsibility which are less pronounced in professional society’.28 Van Helsing alone exercises some priestly functions, but his authority to do so remains unclear. At no time does Mina turn to a representative of established religion for consolation, despite the spiritual distress which one must presume to be caused by the mark left by the Eucharist on her brow and her growing fear of eternal damnation. We hear much of the ruins of ecclesiastical buildings like Whitby Abbey and the chapel of Carfax, but nothing of any living incumbent, and the fact that Jonathan’s and Mina’s wedding takes place abroad further obviates the need for any mention of an English clergyman. Indeed the silence on the subject is so profound (who officiates at Lucy’s funeral service?) that one might well refer to the Church of England as the dog that doesn’t bark in Dracula. (Its absence seems similarly marked in The Jewel of Seven Stars, where one might well feel surprised that it never occurs to anybody to call
78 Bram Stoker
for spiritual guidance in dealing with the obviously supernatural trance of the Egyptologist.) All the paraphernalia of Victorian policing and observation are paraded in Dracula. Ordnance Survey maps are mentioned on the first page, and Jonathan’s comments on the ancestry of those amongst whom he finds himself follow almost immediately. He finds in Castle Dracula ‘such books of reference as the London Directory, the “Red” and “Blue” books, Whitaker’s Almanack, the Army and Navy Lists, and – it somehow gladdened my heart to see it – the Law List’ (D: 19) (Michael Kline suggests that ‘the “red” and “blue” books … are probably references to Burke’s Landed Gentry and Burke’s Peerage’).29 Harker also notes that ‘I found the Count lying on the sofa, reading, of all things in the world, an English Bradshaw’s Guide’ (D: 22). However, in marked contrast to the pinpoint accuracy with which the times of trains are observed, the times of crucial events in the lives of the characters are obfuscated. Jonathan and Mina are married abroad, in a ceremony which would prove difficult to trace afterwards; Seward and Van Helsing conspire to keep the truth about Mrs Westenra’s and Renfield’s demises off their death certificates (D: 150 and 290), the date of Lucy’s true death is also different from any which could have been officially recorded, and Mrs Westenra leaves the most irregular of wills (D: 166–7). Mr Swales comments on the falsity of what is written on the tombstones at Whitby (D: 66–7), particularly that of the suicide: ‘He blew nigh the top of his head off with an old musket … That’s the way he fell off the rocks’ (D: 67); Van Helsing laughs at the similar falsity of Lucy’s funeral service (D: 175); and Harker when reporting Seward’s views on Renfield’s death declares, ‘the question of an inquest had to be considered, and it would never do to put forward the truth … As it was, he thought that on the attendant’s evidence he could give a certificate of death by misadventure in falling from bed’ (D: 288–9). The records of these events thus become as misleading as those on the gravestones which Mr Swales so viciously critiques (D: 65), or as the ostensibly ‘[a]ccurate note … of the state of things’ (D: 79) on board the Demeter which so signally fails to register the truth of what has happened. Dracula wishes to disperse knowledge of his legal affairs amongst several solicitors so that none may see the full picture and travels by a ship too small to be listed in The Times (D: 316), and the Captain of the Demeter
London with its Teeming Millions 79
writes what he knows on a paper in a bottle rather than in the official log (D: 81). Mina even goes so far as to destroy the originals of Seward’s diary because, like so many records, they ‘contained more than you intended me to know’ (D: 222). Even Jonathan’s and Mina’s decision to live with Mr Hawkins can be seen as running counter to the Victorian information-gathering project, since none of all the many modes of classifying relationships offered by the census could stretch to accommodate this: ‘Lodger’ or ‘Boarder’, the closest available approximations, would hardly have done for Jonathan, and since the relationship recorded for any person was solely that to the householder, Mina’s position would have been even harder to define. Most subversive in its implications and connotations is Jonathan and Mina’s decision to name their son after the names of all their friends (in what order is not said). Middle and other multiple names, previously the preserve of the gentry (like the middle names ‘Fingal O’Flahertie Wills’ of which Stoker’s friend Oscar Wilde was so proud), were indeed spreading to other sections of the population, but they were used primarily to advertise a family connection or, occasionally, an important friendship: Stoker himself called his only son Irving Noel Thornley Stoker, announcing his friendship with Henry Irving and his relationship with his most successful brother, the prominent surgeon Thornley Stoker (later Sir Thornley) – a choice which would have seemed particularly pointed since Stoker’s other brother George was actually recorded as living with him on the 1881 census, but had given no name to the then 15-month-old Noel. The other principal reason for the growth in popularity of middle names during the period was, implicitly, to guard against the possibility of inbreeding, with its associated threat to the future of the species. In the anxious post-Darwinian atmosphere of concern over breeding groups, particularly in small communities, there seem to have been specific, if only vaguely understood, motivations for the recording of the maternal surnames of preceding generations which patriarchal nomenclature had buried (as there may also have been in the spiralling codes for classification of physical and mental disabilities which appeared on the census as the nineteenth century progressed). And Stoker – who lists the degeneration theorist Professor Ray Lankester as among the frequenters of Henry Irving’s Lyceum (PR I: 322), and who has Van Helsing ask Seward, ‘Do you
80 Bram Stoker
know the altogether of comparative anatomy?’ (D: 192) – was well aware of the genesis and impact of Darwinian thought: he declares that Irving had recreated the appearance of a character in Two Roses ‘just as Cuvier or Owen could from a single bone reconstruct giant reptiles of the Palaeozoic age’ (PR I: 10), while in ‘A Lesson in Pets’, one of the stories in Snowbound, Mr Benville Nonplusser notes that ‘The carriages became by a sort of natural selection divided into two camps’ (Snowbound: 26) and the Acting Manager ‘had become by a sort of natural selection, manifested by tacit consent of the Company, Master of the Ceremonies’ (Snowbound: 29). Finally, in The Shoulder of Shasta we are told of Esse and the Indians that ‘she went with them through somewhat of those phases with which one comes to regard a monkey before its place in the scale of creation is put in true perspective’ (Shasta 52), and in Lady Athlyne, à propos of the idea that very masculine men and very feminine women are attracted to each other, that ‘This is the true principle of selection which is one of the most important of Nature’s laws; one which holds in the lower as well as in the higher orders of life, zoological and botanical as well as human’ (LA: 82). It is not, however, interrelationships or family history which the complicated nomenclature of Jonathan and Mina’s son records, but an eccentric, arguably homoerotic, and wholly uncategorisable set of alliances which have entirely failed to result in any more tangible or certificatable product. It is in fact left to the villain, Dracula himself, publicly to display all the links in an ancestry which has kept names transparent and unchanged, and he does so fully and freely in his long account of his antecedents (D: 28–9). The only one of the ‘Crew of Light’ who even approaches such certainty of descent is Quincey Morris, who in Stoker’s earliest drafts was originally intended to be named Brutus P. Morris, thus gesturing to the traditional account of continuous, demonstrable British descent from the Trojans emblematized in the mythical figure of Brutus, great-grandson of Aeneas and supposed colonizer of Britain, which, in this account, took its name from him. (In this context, it is also suggestive that Stoker originally intended the Sortes Virgilianae to play a part in the story.30) By contrast, Godalming’s original name of Holmwood disappears on his accession to the title just as a woman’s did on her marriage, and Mina’s nickname never quite succeeds in deflecting attention from the fact that its full version is
London with its Teeming Millions 81
so strongly suggestive of Teutonic rather than indigenous origins. In short, though Harker the lawyer, with his notarial functions, and Seward the classifier of lunatics may both be central planks of the Victorian project of categorisation of identity, the novel itself vigorously resists it. Like the tombstone which lyingly pretends to stand above the body of Edward Spencelagh (D: 65) and the mass of typewriting which has resulted in the destruction of all original documentation – or, indeed, like its creator’s constant use of ‘Bram’, even on the census, rather than the ‘Abraham’ which was his baptismal name – Dracula constantly makes a nonsense of the recording processes of officialdom, and seems even to glory in it when Mr Bilder declares with relish that if the wolf does not come back ‘and some nursemaid goes a-walkin’ orf with a soldier, leavin’ of the hinfant in the perambulator – well then I shouldn’t be surprised if the census is one babby the less’ (D: 140). For Dracula, indeed, even evolutionary change seems less threatening than the means which officialdom has devised to record it. Similar scepticism about official repositories of knowledge is found in other Stoker novels. As Carol A. Senf observes, in The Lair of the White Worm, ‘as in Dracula, the surviving characters do not follow normal scientific protocol’,31 and Sir Nathaniel, in splendidly deadpan fashion given the circumstances, observes of Lady Arabella ‘we know, by our own experience of her movments, that for some reason she shuns publicity’ (WW: 121). Moreover, the typical Stoker motif of a secret or irregular marriage recurs here, when we are told that even though ‘when it began to be noticed that he walked beside Mimi Watford and seemed to desire her society, all their friends endeavoured to give the promising affair a helping hand’ (WW: 30), nevertheless when it comes to the point The advice and assistance of Sir Nathaniel was a great help to Adam in carrying out his idea of marrying Mimi Watford without publicity. He went with him to London, and, with his influence, the young man obtained the license of the Archbishop of Canterbury for a private marriage. (WW: 115) In The Lady of the Shroud Roger Melton states in his will his desire ‘to keep my secret trusts secret’ (Shroud: 21) and writes to Rupert that
82 Bram Stoker
‘When you ran away to sea, I used in secret every part of the mechanism of commerce to find out what had become of you’ (Shroud: 37), while in Snowbound a young actress reaps bitter consequences from an insufficiently regular union: ‘in her youth she had run away with a man whom she thought she loved; they were married at a registry, but after a while she found out that he was married already … Then her baby was born dead, and she found herself alone’ (Shroud: 83). In Famous Impostors, we hear of ‘Princess Olive’s’ forging of marriage and birth certificates (FI: 54–5). In The Snake’s Pass, Dick Sutherland says to Arthur Severn: ‘You can imagine how devoid of knowledge we are, when I tell you that even the last edition of the “Encyclopedia Britannica” does not contain the heading “bog”’ (SP: 55). And another doubt of the efficacy of the census is found in Arthur’s remark that ‘It would seem that so many inhabitants had been allured by fairies, and consequently had mysteriously disappeared, that this method of minimisation of the census must have formed a distinct drain on the local population’ (SP: 107). Stoker – who would undoubtedly have been well aware of the complex and wholly irregular history of Ellen Terry’s marriages – also shows himself markedly interested in many of his novels in having his characters sidestep the law altogether by having their marriages solemnised in Scotland, as Stoker’s friend Hall Caine had done when he married his mistress, by whom he already had a child, in Edinburgh. The most sustained exploration of this is in Lady Athlyne, where Athlyne and Joy pass Gretna Green without thinking of going there (LA: 190), but find themselves in any case married by the distinctive laws of Scotland, although Athlyne then further muddies the issue by decreeing that ‘In addition to this we can have a “regular” marriage to follow these two irregular ones. I shall go to London and get a special license from the Archbishop of Canterbury, who is a connection of my own’ (LA: 310). Despite this apparent scepticism about some of the city’s protocols and institutions, Stoker’s life in London was generally successful, not least after the publication of Dracula by Constable in 1897.32 ‘Louis Frederick Austin, Stoker’s colleague and sometime rival at the Lyceum, claimed that Stoker had spent £700 getting Sunset published’, but Stoker’s agreement with Constable for the publication of Dracula stipulated that at least 3000 copies were to be produced in that year alone, though no royalties were to be payable
London with its Teeming Millions 83
on the first 1000.33 (Barbara Belford notes that ‘The initial printing was three thousand copies; no records survive on the total number sold or whether there were reprints. The next printing was a Constable paperback in 1901’, and that the book was more shoddily presented than previous Stoker works had been: ‘Dracula arrived at booksellers on May 26, 1897, bound in yellow, the color of the French novel that Oscar Wilde draws attention to in The Picture of Dorian Gray’.)34 It was generally favourably received, however, perhaps because, as Barbara Belford suggests, by now ‘part of London’s cultural establishment, Stoker never had a book panned; something positive was always said’.35 Although the Athenaeum had acerbically remarked of The Shoulder of Shasta that ‘Mr. Stoker can probably do much better than this; so perhaps the less said about “The Shoulder of Shasta” the better for everyone concerned’,36 even that ‘received at least a baker’s dozen of notices and reviews. Nearly all of them had high praise for its description of natural scenery.’37 Dracula itself was received with quiet appreciation. A number of other writers wrote to congratulate Stoker, including Mary Elizabeth Braddon and Anthony Hope Hawkins, author of The Prisoner of Zenda.38 The Daily Mail, reviewing Dracula on 1 June, noted that ‘We started reading it early in the evening’ and ‘By ten o’clock the story had so fastened itself upon our attention that we could not pause even to light our pipe.’39 By 1901 the first translation, into Icelandic, had appeared, and a few years later The Sketch, reviewing Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving, wrote that Dracula would be ‘reprinted in the cheap series of 2000 A.D’,40 a prediction which has proved entirely correct. The principal note of reservation related to the novel’s sexual content. David Glover observes that ‘The Keighley News, in an otherwise fairly favorable notice, primly stated that “the nature of Count Dracula’s adventure may not be hinted at in this domestic column”.’41Some critics also thought the novel derivative: The Athenaeum opined on 26 June that ‘Mr. Stoker is a purveyor of so many strange wares that “Dracula” reads like a determined effort to go, as it were, “one better” than others in the same field’, and The Spectator on 31 July wrote that Mr. Bram Stoker gives the impression – we may be doing him an injustice – of having deliberately laid himself out in Dracula
84 Bram Stoker
to eclipse all previous efforts in the domain of the horrible, – to ‘go one better’ than Wilkie Collins (whose method of narration he has closely followed), Sheridan Le Fanu, and all the other professors of the flesh-creeping school. The Bookman in August was also moved to think of Wilkie Collins, but sounded a more definitely favourable note in this respect – ‘Since Wilkie Collins left us we have had no tale of mystery so liberal in manner and so closely woven.’42 Stoker’s later books also tended to attract generally respectful attention in the wake of Dracula, and indeed Punch placed The Man ‘among the best halfdozen novels of the year’,43 while it is tempting to see a reflection of Lady Athlyne in the bestowal of the Christian name Athlyne on a child born in America in the year of its publication.44 Even despite this generally favourable treatment by the British establishment,however, there are many signs in his fiction that Stoker had something less than an unequivocal admiration of the English. In the excised original beginning to Dracula, later separately published as the short story ‘Dracula’s Guest’, this note is struck from the outset. The stupidly overconfident narrator foolishly dismisses his guide with the lordly ‘Go home, Johann – Walpurgis Nacht doesn’t concern Englishmen’, before noting that ‘His English was quite gone now. In his anxiety he had forgotten that his only means of making me understand was to talk my language, so he jabbered away in his native German. It began to be a little tedious’ (DG: 12); under the circumstances, it is hard not to detect a note of sarcasm when we learn that Dracula’s letter instigating the search warns ‘He is English and therefore adventurous’ (DG: 21). In the final version of the novel we find Sister Agatha’s sly remark ‘Seeing from his violent demeanour that he was English’ (D: 99), and an interesting indictment of one of London’s prime repositories of imperial knowledge: In plot terms, it would have been sufficient to have a wolf escape, but Stoker gives us the lengthy Pall Mall Gazette interview with a keeper (165–71) in his cottage ‘in the enclosure behind the elephant-house’. Why so much detail?Jonathan Schneer points out that the Zoo was a conscious emblem of Britain’s imperial victories, with animals from every corner of the globe. By the end of
London with its Teeming Millions 85
the century, ‘visiting the zoo has become a common form of popular recreation. More than half a million people attended annually.’ Thus to locate Dracula in the zoo is not only to identify his animalistic and dangerous drives, but also to point up his threat by placing him in relation to a popular imperial signifier.45 It is certainly true that Stoker had an even more jaundiced view of other nationalities and ethnic groups – it is notable, for instance, that no tears are shed when, in the short story ‘Crooken Sands’, the man who dies in the quicksands turns out to have been a Jew masquerading as a Scot, as his partner also is (DG: 159), and the Jewish Solomon Mendoza is the villain of The Watter’s Mou’. Nevertheless, as we see perhaps most clearly in The Lady of the Shroud, the English are by no means immune from criticism either. A particularly provocative instance of this comes towards the end of The Lady of the Shroud, in a scene which features a monarch identified only as the Western King. The identity of this personage is heavily riddled: he himself is presumably from a Western country, though he is also the monarch of many races of the East, and his wife is ‘the fair Northern Queen’ (matters are not made any easier by the fact that Irish Rupert and Serbian Teuta are here identified as the ‘Southern Queen’ and ‘the giant King of the South’ [Shroud: 255], probably because ‘southern’ is Elinor Glyn’s term for her Balkan queen). One thing, though, is clear: the Western King is not Edward VII, who is mentioned by name several times elsewhere in the novel, because we are explicitly told that Rupert is ‘the former subject of another King’ (Shroud: 255) – that is, a king other than the Western King. We must, then, conclude that the Western King is a veiled representation of Kaiser Wilhelm, and this may make it rather alarming when we read that he and his wife are ‘the King and Queen of the greatest nation of the earth’ (Shroud: 255). (It is presumably also Kaiser Wilhelm who is referred to in The Shoulder of Shasta, where Reginald has a knife which ‘was given me by an emperor, who was good enough to say I had done him some service when a wild boar charged him in a Thuringian forest’ [Shasta: 126].)Coupled with the apparently irresistible rise of the Land of the Blue Mountains and the Balkan Federation which it heads, this provides yet another warning sign that, as is also predicted in George Chesney’s The Battle of Dorking and Saki’s When William Came,
86 Bram Stoker
English supremacy in world affairs is imperilled. Even nations are subject to degeneration, as Rupert reminds us when he speculates that ‘Germany wished to link the North Sea to the Mediterranean by her own territory, and thus stand as a flawless barrier across Europe from north to south. When Nature should have terminated the headship of the Empire-Kingdom, she, as natural heir, would creep southward through the German-speaking provinces’ (Shroud: 240). A notable and underrated Stoker theme, related both to the question of Englishness and Irishness and also to the issue of proper keeping of records, is the redistribution of land. The idea of rearranging the land/setting the world to rights again is found in a number of Stoker texts, starting with The Snake’s Pass when Arthur Severn buys back the land that the Gombeen Man had extracted from Phelim Joyce. It is found too in The Man, where Harold, under the alias of John Robinson, changes the landscape: ‘when the second year of his exile was coming to a close, and Robinson City was teeming with life and commerce, when banks and police and soldiers made life and property comparatively safe …’. (Man: 352). It culminates, perhaps most bizarrely, in Sir Nathaniel’s surprising concern about the ownership of the land in The Lair of the White Worm, when, although certain that Lady Arabella must be destroyed, Sir Nathaniel nevertheless advocates delay: There were all sorts of legal cruxes to be thought out, not only regarding the taking of life, even of a monstrosity in human form, but also of property. Lady Arabella, be she woman or snake or devil, owned the ground she moved in, according to British law. (WW: 111) Consequently, Adam Salton buys the land first, and only then kills its monstrous occupant. Although it is sometimes, as here, a question of purchase, often the desired change in the structure of land or its ownership is to be effected through the means of technology. David Glover argues that ‘Like many advanced Liberals, Stoker looked to scientific growth as the key to modernization,’46 and certainly Stoker had a great interest in technology, partly for its own sake and partly, too, for the effect
London with its Teeming Millions 87
it could create in fiction: in The Snake’s Pass, Arthur after hearing of the effects of the bog, says ‘for real cold-blooded horror, commend me to your men of science’ (SP: 59). Throughout his books, Stoker delights in showing that he could use the language of science, as in his reference to ‘the Thomassin “infernal machine,” which was suspected of having been the means by which many ships had been sent to the bottom. These machines were exploded by clockwork set for a certain time, and were made in such fashion as would not excite suspicion’ (he also records how he and Irving were once in a boat when they realised there were underwater torpedoes all around them) (PR II: 49 and 268), an episode remembered in The Lady of the Shroud in the operation of the crab (Shroud: 184–5). As Carol A. Senf notes, à propos of the public preference for Dracula, ‘Stoker wrote seventeen other books; and many of them reveal his interest in areas that seem antithetical to the Gothic and its mysteries. Included among those are areas are an interest in science and technology’. In particular, she observes that ‘Stoker’s Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving reveals his fascination with the technological aspect of theatrical special effects’.47 He was also interested in cars, as is vividly illustrated in Lady Athlyne, though it might have caused some tension that one of W. S. Gilbert’s attractions for Florence Stoker, who was his frequent companion, was that he could take her out in his car. The most sustained signs of Stoker’s interest in technology, however, cluster on this theme of land change. The result of the redistribution or rearrangement of land is frequently a quasi-biblical garden. In The Shoulder of Shasta, As the train, after leaving Sacramento, wound its way by the brawling river, its windows brushed by the branches of hazel and mountain-ash, the whole wilderness seemed like the natural pleasaunce of an old-world garden. The road took its serpentine course up and above its own track, over and over again. (Shasta: 24) This motif is perhaps most notably found in The Lady of the Shroud: whatever the garden may have been, and no matter how it was guarded, it is a most lovely place. There are whole sections of garden here of various styles – Greek, Italian, French, German,
88 Bram Stoker
Dutch, British, Spanish, African, Moorish – all the older nationalities. I am going to have a new one laid out for you – a Japanese garden … If it should ever turn out that the climate does not suit, we shall put a great high glass roof over it, and make a suitable climate. (Shroud: 55) The idea is present too in The Snake’s Pass, where Dick Sutherland promises Arthur that we can make the place a paradise. The springs are evidently high up on the hill, so that we can not only get water for irrigating and ornamental purposes, but we can get power also!Why, you can have electric light, and everything else you like, at the smallest cost. And if it be, as I suspect, that there is a streak of limestone in the hill, the place might be a positive mine of wealth as well!We have not lime within fifty miles, and if once we can quarry the stone here we can do anything. We can build a harbour on the south side, which would be the loveliest place to keep a yacht in that ever was known – quite big enough for anything in these parts – as safe as Portsmouth, and of fathomless depth. (SP: 178) It is notable that in this mass redistribution of wealth and territory many things which most Victorians would take to be static are in fact imagined as fluid, not least class, as when Phelim Joyce says to Arthur Severn of Norah that ‘Of course, we’re not of your class, an’ if ye wish for her it is only right an’ fair that she should be brought up to the level of the people that she’s goin’ into’ (SP: 159). It it part of this potentially radical undertone that this theme of land redistribution is frequently related, implicitly or explicitly, to Ireland. Most notably, Dracula, as has often been observed, is not only a colonisation novel but also specifically an Irish novel. The DNB article on Stoker claims that ‘More Irish than Transylvanian, Count Dracula embodies the Celtic phenomenon known as ‘shape shifting’, the ability to become anything – a wolf, bat, rat, or swirling mist’, and there is certainly considerable evidence for this
London with its Teeming Millions 89
idea. In particular, there are notably strong links between Dracula and the Gombeen Man of The Snake’s Pass. Sutherland refers to Murdock as ‘that human-shaped wolf’ (SP: 87), and Joyce says to Murdock ‘I put my mark upon ye once – I see it now comin’ up white through the red of yer passion!’ (SP: 113), foreshadowing the white complexion and red blood associated with Dracula. Arthur remarks that when he saw Norah ‘To this day I cannot make out whether I took a bee-line for that isolated table of rock, and from where I was, slid or crawled down the face of the rock, or whether I made a detour to the same end’ (SP: 125) to the girl he recognises but cannot name. This closely foreshadows both Dracula’s descent from his castle by crawling down the face of the rock and the troubling sense of familiarity which the three female vampires spark in Jonathan Harker. Stoker himself favoured Irish Home Rule, and it is notable that Joyce when accepting the treasure says, ‘Take it I will, an’ gladly; but not for meself. The money was sent for Ireland’s good – to help them that wanted help, an’ plase God!’ (SP: 240), while the cave in which the crown is found contains Ogham writing (Stoker first met the explorer Richard Burton, whose adventures suggested the name of the Land of the Blue Mountains in The Lady of the Shroud, in 1878 when he visited Ireland to lecture on Ogham).48 The crown itself is described as being very similar to those now to be found in the Museum of Ireland (which have been on display to the public since 1890, the year in which The Snake’s Pass was first published): In her hand she held an ancient crown of strange form. It was composed of three pieces of flat gold joined all along one edge, like angle iron, and twisted delicately. The gold was wider and the curves bolder in the centre, from which they were fined away to the ends and then curved into a sort of hook. In the centre was set a great stone, that shone with the yellow light of a topaz, but with a fire all its own! (SP: 241–2) Indeed Stoker sent a copy of The Snake’s Pass to Michael Davitt, who founded the Land League to support tenants’ rights against those of landlords.49 However, even though his elder brother Sir Thornley Stoker later knew James Joyce’s friend Oliver St John Gogarty, it is of
90 Bram Stoker
course a joke that Stoker could not have intended that his ideal Irishwoman should be called Norah Joyce. Stoker, then, positions himself ambivalently as an Irishman writing in England. Doubly an outsider, he capitalises on his liminality to interrogate both countries and expose strengths and weaknesses in each. In his professional career, Stoker was confined to discussing questions of governance and reform with Gladstone on his visits to the Lyceum. In his fiction, untrammelled by the demands of either reality or realism, he proposed bolder solutions to what he seems to have seen as the two principal problems of the two sides of the coin of citizenship and rule. In the first place, he clearly proposes a model in which successful results are achieved only by individual citizens clawing back some of the autonomy and freedom of comment which the state is shown as trying to wrest from them. Second, throughout his fiction he imagines a radical redistribution of ownership, with an Irishman being king of a Balkan country in The Lady of the Shroud, an Australian acceding to the ownership of a large estate in the Peak District in The Lair of the White Worm, an Englishman presiding over the literal realignment of territory in Ireland in The Snake’s Pass, a Transylvanian buying an estate in England in Dracula, an American and a Spaniard contesting seigneurial rights over a Scottish castle in The Mystery of the Sea, and an Egyptian queen apparently planning to install herself in England in The Jewel of Seven Stars. In such a world, anything can happen: all Europe, it seems, is on the move, and there is no predicting where the representatives of various nationalities will finally end up. England and Ireland must compete with the rest, and Stoker, with his acute awareness of the power of America, is well aware that neither is guaranteed to succeed (indeed Gary Day suggests that ‘The death of Quincey Morris … may … be seen as a symbolic way of coping with the economic threat posed by America’).50 By thus triangulating the relationship of England and Ireland with America, however, Stoker has at least imagined the possibility of the forging of a bond of common interest between them; and at the close of The Lady of the Shroud at least, the Englishman, for the first time, is proud of his Irish cousin.
4 On Holiday
Almost as important to Stoker’s fiction as London are the places to which he travelled during the years that he lived there. For Stoker, travel represented freedom, adventure, and a loosening of the constricting standards of Victorian morality: as Rupert Sent Leger remarks in The Lady of the Shroud, ‘To travel in strange places amongst strange peoples with strange views of their own is to have odd experiences and peculiar adventures now and again; a man without human passions is not of the type necessary for an adventurous life, such as I myself have had’ (Shroud: 72). Rupert’s view gives an important clue to one of the recurrent themes of Stoker’s depictions of non-London locations: they offer sites both of sexual opportunity and of sexual discrimination, in the form of allowing the demonisation and incrimination of women. At home, Stoker might be the dutiful husband of Florence, but outside it, his imagination brings him into dangerous proximity with wayward, wicked women whom he is free to demonise and punish however he likes. In new locations, new truths can be revealed; and indeed specific locations in Stoker often function effectively as tropes, offering, as it were, dis-locations of the familiar and expected and revealing strange new levels of meaning and association for them. Consequently, after offering an overview of Stoker’s use of locations, this chapter will move to detailed examination of two texts in particular, The Mystery of the Sea and Dracula, in both of which Stoker delineates a detailed, intricate, and ultimately incriminating connection between women and the associations generated by specific places. 91
92 Bram Stoker
Probably we do not know the full extent of Stoker’s travels, because we do not have complete records of his journeys. For instance, he noted in Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving that after their first meeting, he did not see Irving for another five years because ‘my work did not allow my going to London except at times when he was not playing there’ (PR I: 12), but there is no other indication of any such visit, though Stoker’s travels between England and Ireland leave their mark in the comment in The Primrose Path that ‘The south coast of England is full of charming scenery, which one sees much of in passing from port to port’ (Path: 48), with Plymouth and Portsmouth particularly commended. In 1876 Stoker went to Cava di Terreni, near Naples, for his father’s funeral, something which may well be reflected in the descriptions of Ischia and the Amalfi coast in Lady Athlyne (LA: 28–9) (which also contains a description that shows knowledge of the Lake District [LA: 189]). He also visited Vienna, Amsterdam and Paris – which Florence loved – frequently:1 amongst other visits, he stayed there with his friend the actress Geneviève Ward in 1875, and it too is important in his fiction, even, I shall suggest, when its presence is not openly advertised: for instance, the three vampiric women in Dracula may well owe something to the ‘three unmarried women’ with ‘chalky complexions, those eyes blackened with kohl and the scarlet stains of their painted lips, like bloody wounds gaping in the flesh of those dead faces’ who bring men to ruin in the short story ‘Magic Lantern’ by Jean Lorrain, associate of Oscar Wilde.2 Although we can probably feel confident that Stoker never went to Transylvania, since his accounts of it are so clearly based on his reading, and perhaps not to Nuremberg, I would not be surprised if evidence were one day to emerge that he had been at least in the vicinity of Montenegro, since he certainly seems remarkably well informed about it, transparently alluding to the battle of Kosovo – ‘For more than a thousand years – ever since its settlement after the disaster of Rossoro’ (Shroud: 33) – and referring to ‘a Vladika somewhat similar in power and function to the Prince-Bishops of Montenegro’ (Shroud: 33), as well as speaking of a time ‘when it would seem that Montenegro was to be deprived for all time of the hope of regaining the Bocche di Cattaro’ (Shroud: 239–40). Of particular importance in a wide range of Stoker’s fiction is the fact that from 1883 the Lyceum company, and Stoker with it,
On Holiday 93
toured America almost annually, although there was no tour between spring 1888 and autumn 1893. This is reflected in novels like The Shoulder of Shasta and Lady Athlyne, as well as in the important rôle played by the Texan Quincy Morris in Dracula and the Americans Marjory Drake in The Mystery of the Sea and Elias P. Hutcheson in ‘The Squaw’. Andrew Smith argues that America is a crucial presence in Stoker’s fiction: ‘Stoker’s account of racial Otherness is not solely predicated on a perception of the racial inferiority of apparently primitive cultures, rather it is directed towards a vision of the most modern and powerful of societies: America.’ He points out that ‘“The Squaw” was first published in the Christmas issue of The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News in 1893 and it suggests that Stoker already had ambivalent ideas about America before writing Dracula’ and argues that ‘It is America’s involvement in a colonial war that links Marjory with the figure of the vampire. This is also evidenced in some telling similarities between Count Dracula’s speech concerning his genealogy and Marjory’s account of her forefathers.’3 Other locations also loom large in Stoker’s fiction. In 1890 Stoker visited Whitby, a trip which he famously revisits in Dracula in ways which do not only contribute a picturesque setting to the novel but also inform its examinations of domesticity versus foreign threats and of evolutionary theory, since it was already famous for the fossils which proved so important a support to Darwinian theory. In 1892 Stoker holidayed at Boscastle in Cornwall (PR I: 221), which surfaces in The Jewel of Seven Stars, and his sister-in-law told her grandson that Stoker’s glowing reports were the principal cause of its subsequent popularity.4 1893 saw the first of his subsequently regular trips to Cruden Bay in Aberdeenshire, which he had first spotted five years previously on a Lyceum trip north to research Macbeth.5 This became the setting for The Watter’s Mou’ and The Mystery of the Sea, and possibly also an impetus for Dracula: the DNB article on Stoker claims that ‘During a holiday in Whitby, Stoker drafted the scene in which the count arrives in the fishing village on a ghost ship, and during other holidays at Cruden Bay in Aberdeenshire he walked daily to the ruined Slains Castle, considered the inspiration for Dracula’s castle.’ David Glover argues that such a Scottish setting would be intimately linked with the novel’s overall Irishness, since ‘in a number of his stories the Scottish countryside or Scottish people appear to stand in
94 Bram Stoker
for their counterparts across the Irish Sea’;6 as Mrs O’Brien says in Lady Athlyne, ‘Begob! av it’s Ireland y’objict to ye can take him as Scotch’ (LA: 13). Stoker was also influenced by places he had not visited personally, but of which he had heard accounts from friends or Lyceum connections. The Transylvanian setting of the opening scenes of Dracula is the most famous instance of this, but the references to Australia in Snowbound and The Lair of the White Worm may well have been prompted by the fact that Irving’s friend J. L. Toole played in Melbourne in 1891 and Sarah Bernhardt acted there in June of the same year, while it was presumably Stoker’s long friendship with the Manx-born novelist Hall Caine, dedicatee of Dracula (under his childhood nickname of ‘Hommy-Beg’), which led to the choice of the Isle of Man as a place of safe refuge for Mimi in The Lair of the White Worm. When a location is used in Stoker’s fiction, it is invariably important. The scenes set at Whitby form only a small part of the narrative of Dracula, but they seem to be deeply rooted in the imaginative genesis of the novel; indeed as Paul Murray notes, ‘The anonymous author of a profile of Stoker in the Literary World in 1905 divided his fiction into two categories, the supernatural and the marine’,7 and the Whitby scenes of Dracula allow the two to be combined. (Barbara Belford attributes the obsession with the marine to a childhood spent looking out of the window while an invalid at Clontarf, and the interest in danger at sea will also have been fed by the fact that on 13 April 1887 Florence and Noel were shipwrecked and fetched ashore at Fécamp, which thereafter became an annual site of pilgrimage for the family.8) In a pamphlet entitled Whitby and the Dracula Connection, the author declares that his maternal great-grandmother, Fanny Harker, was Stoker’s landlady at 7 Royal Crescent Avenue, now 7 Crescent Avenue,9 and if he is right (although the Lyceum scenepainter Joseph Harker said Stoker had told him he was the source of the name10) then the recollection of Whitby clearly pervades the book as a whole rather than being simply confined to the section explicitly set there, and certainly Barbara Belford points out that Stoker did a lot of reading for Dracula while at Whitby.11 Nor was the influence of Whitby confined to Dracula. It has recently been established that a mummy originally but erroneously identified as that of a princess was brought to Hull from Whitby,
On Holiday 95
where the Egyptologist Joann Fletcher contends that it must have been seen by Stoker in 1890. It belonged to Sir George Elliot MP, a friend of Disraeli, who had gone to Egypt as advisor to the Khedive before settling in Royal Crescent. Fletcher argues: Think of the seaside location, the fact that Elliot’s mummy is described as an Egyptian princess in correspondence of the time and then [The Jewel of Seven Stars] is published in 1903, with its original scary ending where the princess goes bonkers and kills everybody. And all of a sudden, in 1903, a mummy is suddenly donated to the Whitby museum and right round the country, people seem anxious to donate mummified body parts to their own local museums.12 Whitby, then, is of an importance to Stoker which well justifies its current status as Gothic capital of England, with its Dracula Experience and regular Goth weekends. Cruden Bay in Aberdeenshire was even more influential on Stoker’s fiction, most notably in The Mystery of the Sea (1902), and here the setting does not simply function as a backdrop: in a move which I shall be suggesting also occurs in Dracula, location here becomes dislocation as the Scottish setting becomes a miniature melting-pot in which a variety of tensions between different races and nationalities can be ultimately resolved by displacing nationalised conflicts onto gendered ones. The Mystery of the Sea is a novel no more amenable to generic classification than the rest of Stoker’s fiction. Part love story, part political tract, part treasure quest and part tale of the supernatural, its closest antecedents are Rider Haggard (at one point Marjory actually refers to Hunter as ‘King Solomon’ [Mystery: 45], and the trust that has been handed down from father to son in the De Escoban family is obviously reminiscent of that which has passed down the Vincey family in She) and Stoker’s own Dracula. The novel is set against the background of the contemporary hostilities between Spain and America, yet although it frequently refers to these and other events, principally, as I shall discuss, the A. T. Stewart ransom case, the novel puts distance between itself and its historical moment. It does this by confining its action entirely to Scotland, where its American heroine Marjory Drake (a descendant of Sir Francis Drake, to whom Stoker himself was compared in appearance by Irving’s son
96 Bram Stoker
Laurence)13 meets the second-sighted hero, Archibald Hunter, prompts him to decipher a sixteenth-century manuscript, and assists him in uncovering a vast treasure which has lain undetected in Scotland since the time of the Armada but which now, providentially, can be used to fuel the war against Spain, of which Marjory Drake has become a virtual icon. At the same time, however, the invocation of the language of war, in which masculine valour is paramount and women become damsels to be rescued, allows the novel to unleash the full force of its covert animus against its heroine: as ironically befits a descendant of Sir Francis Drake, whose actions oscillated between piracy and legitimate seamanship depending on the perspective of the observer, it is Marjory who can thus be demoted from legitimate combatant to pirate. As Andrew Smith observes, ‘the putative heroine of the novel, Marjory Anita Drake, is resourceful and powerful, but this is contained within a discourse of chivalry which re-writes her as victim.’14 The novel’s treatment of Marjory can only be understood in terms of its complex and multiple cultural contexts, for which the ostensibly Highland setting becomes a multi-faceted symbol as the tiny community turns host to a steady influx of people from a wide variety of backgrounds trailing with them a complex set of heritages, just as on Lammas Eve it becomes the gateway to the past as well as the present. In the first place, the Spanish-Cuban-American war of 1895–98 forms the crucial historical backdrop for the novel. Because of it, Marjory, an American, hates Spaniards: ‘Look at the way they are treating Cuba! Look at the Maine!’ (Mystery: 49). The battleship Maine was blown up in Havana in 1898. There is in fact no evidence that the Spanish were responsible and the captain of the sunken ship recorded that the crew of the Alfonso XII, which was in the vicinity, afforded instant assistance and rescued many of those on board; nevertheless, the event gave rise to the popular cry ‘Remember the Maine! To hell with Spain!’. In one of the few critical responses to The Mystery of the Sea, Andrew Smith has analysed the significance of this historical moment for Stoker’s novel. He points first to the ways in which perception of the war was racialised: America disguised its imperial expansionist interests by turning the war into a moral crusade against the Spanish. In order to do this a
On Holiday 97
complex process of othering was required which, to pamper [sic] to populist American sentiments, imaged the largely black Cuban insurgents as white; conversely the ‘swarthy’ complexion of the Spanish was seen as indicative of their barbarism.15 Second, he discusses how this in turn can be made to map onto Stoker’s more immediate concerns: ‘the novel can also be read as Stoker’s response to Catholic and Protestant relations. As in The Snake’s Pass and The Lady of the Shroud, The Mystery of the Sea constructs a settlement between Catholic and Protestant which is the product of appeasement and compromise’.16 Certainly these two issues are important in The Mystery of the Sea. Race becomes a crucial issue towards the end of the novel, when the potential ‘swarthiness’ of Don Bernardino is in fact comprehensively displaced onto the far more threatening figure of the ‘buck nigger’ to whom it is threatened that Marjory might be given, allowing for the eventual recuperation of Don Bernardino and the defusion of any sense of remaining hostility between America and Spain. It certainly seems at least possible, too, that we should read this idea of reconciliation as to be extended to the ideological and political tensions between Protestantism and Catholicism which had proved so divisive in Ireland, though that is something much less strongly signalled in this text than in the earlier The Snake’s Pass. The war also, however, raises another issue, which is the question of whether combat, and the strategies used in it, are legitimate or not. This is something which Marjory’s reference to the Maine brings directly to the fore, since the allegation from the American side was that the destruction of the Maine had been achieved by illegitimate means. Marjory ventures onto more dangerous ground, however, when she alleges that the Spaniards are also deviating from the rules of war by interning women in concentration camps (Mystery: 160) – for if the point is that these women are not legitimate combatants, then, by the same token, neither is she. Ironically, then, what began as a cause of war between different nations melts away: the enemy Spaniard is accepted, while the woman is manoeuvred into the position of opponent. The novel’s repeated allusions to a second real-life event with which there are close parallels also work in the same direction. This
98 Bram Stoker
is the A. T. Stewart ransom case. This is referred to in the chief of the detectives’ description of the gang that has abducted Marjory: I take it that ‘Feathers’ is none other than Featherstone who was with Whisky Tommy – which was Tom Mason – in the A. T. Stewart ransom case. If those two are in it, most likely the one they called the ‘Dago’ is a half-bred Spaniard that comes from somewheres over here. That Max that she named, if he’s the same man, is a Dutchman; he’s about the worst of the bunch. Then for this game there’s likely to be two Chicago bums from the Levee, way-down politicians and heelers. It’s possible that there are two more; a man from Frisco that they call Sailor Ben – what they call a cosmopolite for he doesn’t come from nowhere in particular; and a buck nigger from Noo Orleans. A real bad ’un he is; of all the … But I hope he isn’t in the gang. If he is, we haven’t no time to lose. (Mystery: 225) Appropriately for someone figuring in a story by an Irish writer which is set in Scotland, A. T. Stewart was a Scottish-Irish immigrant from Belfast who had arrived in America in 1818. The case which was to make him a household name, certainly in America, is best summed up by Howard Baetzhold in his account of Mark Twain’s parody of it: The news story that sparked Mark Twain’s investigative fiasco broke on November 8, 1878, when headlines announced the theft during the night before of the body of multi-millionaire dry-goods merchant, Alexander T. Stewart, from a family crypt in St. Mark’s churchyard. Lurid column headings gasped to their readers that ‘GHOULS IN NEW YORK CITY’ had perpetrated this ‘UNPRECEDENTED AND GHASTLY CRIME,’ the New York Times, for instance, devoting six of its seven front-page columns to details of the robbery and speculations about motives and methods.17 Mark Twain made no bones about the fact that he was directly inspired by the case when writing his short story ‘The Stolen White Elephant’: Writing on January 21, 1879, from Munich he announced to William Dean Howells that he had given up work on his Simon
On Holiday 99
Wheeler detective story because he had decided that the novel was not his forte. ‘But,’ he continued, ‘when the detectives were nosing around after Stewart’s loud remains, I threw a chapter in my present book in which I have very extravagantly burlesqued the detective business – if it is possible to burlesque that business extravagantly.’ That ‘chapter,’ ultimately omitted from A Tramp Abroad, was ‘The Stolen White Elephant,’ later published as a title piece of a collection in 1882.18 In Stoker’s novel, the chief’s description of the suspects comes suggestively close to Twain’s: in Twain’s story all newspaper accounts of the theft of the elephant ‘concluded with Blunt’s own assurances that the principals in the crime were the “noted villains,” Brick Duffy and Red McFadden, whom he could apprehend any moment he chose’.19 However, the only two people to be arrested were released without charge and the actual fate of the body remains a mystery: Clue after clue, lead after lead petered out. It soon was apparent that Burke and Vreeland had had nothing to do with the crime. A Dr. Hatch, once named as ‘chief conspirator’ and thought to be a notorious Chicago ‘resurrectionist,’ proved equally innocent. Another prime suspect, Kelly the Hackman, alias ‘Bull’ Kelly, was also eliminated, though not until after two New York detectives detailed to find him had been with him one evening in a Patterson, N.J., bar but failed to recognize him.20 The affair, however, did not fade from the public imagination: further tips in 1881 and 1882 led to additional investigations … again with no results. The case then rested again until April, 1887, when a pre-publication review of George W. Walling’s Recollections of a New York Chief of Police once more revived it by summarizing Walling’s supposed first-hand account of robbery, investigation, $20,000 ransom, return, and reinterment … But the reviewer also emphasized the ‘imagination’ in Walling’s account and the fact that ‘those in possession of the facts’ now refused to say whether or not the remains had ever been returned.21
100 Bram Stoker
The story, then, was an ongoing mystery when Stoker referred to it. The Stewart ransom case is a particularly ominous precedent for Stoker to invoke because not only did it originally concern a corpse, but also the white elephant – the stolen object in the Twain satire – is already dead when found; moreover, the failure to solve the crime does not bode well for the events of a novel whose title explicitly describes it as a mystery. The details of the Stewart case also contain