Caring Capitalism: A New Middle Class Base for the Welfare State

Caring Capitalism A New Middle-Class Base for the Welfare State Ronald M. Glassman Copyright material from www.palgra...

Author: Ronald R. Glassman

14 downloads 362 Views 3MB Size Report

This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!

Report copyright / DMCA form

DOWNLOAD PDF

Caring Capitalism A New Middle-Class Base for the Welfare State

Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

Caring Capitalism

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Also by Ronald M. Glassman BUREAUCRACY AGAINST DEMOCRACY AND SOCIALISM (co-editor) CHARISMA, HISTORY, AND SOCIAL STRUCTURE (co-editor)

CONFLICT AND CONTROL: The Challenge to Legitimacy of Modern Governments (co-editor) A DEMOCRACY AGENDA FOR THE YEAR 2000 (co-author) DEMOCRACY AND DESPOTISM IN PRIMITIVE SOCIETY DEMOCRACY AND EQUALITY FOR DEMOCRACY: The Noble Character and Tragic Flaws of the Middle Classes (co-author) MAX WEBER’S POLITICAL SOCIOLOGY: A Pessimistic Vision of a Rationaled World (co-editor) THE MIDDLE CLASS AND DEMOCRACY IN SOCIO-HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE

* THE NEW MIDDLE CLASS AND DEMOCRACY IN GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE THE POLITICAL HISTORY OF LATIN AMERICA A WEBER–MARX DIALOGUE (co-editor)

* From the same publishers

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

CHINA IN TRANSITION: Communism, Capitalism, Democracy

Caring Capitalism

Ronald M. Glassman Professor of Sociology William Paterson University New Jersey

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A New Middle-Class Base for the Welfare State

First published in Great Britain 2000 by

MACMILLAN PRESS LTD

Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and London Companies and representatives throughout the world A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.

First published in the United States of America 2000 by ST. MARTIN’S PRESS, LLC, Scholarly and Reference Division, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 ISBN 0–312–23467–8 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Glassman, Ronald M. Caring Capitalism : a new middle class base for the welfare state / Ronald M. Glassman. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0–312–23467–8 1. Capitalism—Moral and ethical aspects. 2. Free enterprise—Moral and ethical aspects. 3. Welfare economics. 4. Middle class. I. Title. HB501 .G543 2000 330.12'2—dc21

00–027829

© Ronald M. Glassman 2000 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. 10 09

9 08

8 07

7 06

6 05

5 04

4 03

3 02

2 01

1 00

Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ISBN 0–333–77384–5

!"#$%&#' '() *+%",-./ +%0,1%2,345

()

*+","-.%' /0% *+"1.2$)(% 3)+42,% 4#1 $0% 56%2)7)2 *4$$%+# "7 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& <#-%#1%+%1 ?; M$

8

8

/0% 9)-0:/%20#","-; <2"#"=; "7 >?.#14#2%' @""1& (& 5%+()2%&

8D

/0% 56%2)7)2 *4$$%+# "7 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& B)#C%1 $" $0% G%H 3)11,% !,4&&

8L

/0% E"+C)#- !,4&& F)()1%1' G%H 3)11,% !,4&& 3"?),)$; (& N#1%+2,4&& F%2,)#%

IO

/0% 56%2)7)2 *4$$%+# "7 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& <#-.,7)#- $0% @,"?4, N#1%+2,4&&

O8

O

/0% 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& "7 $0% G%H N66%+ !,4&&

PI

P

/0% E%,74+% 5$4$% 7"+ $0% G%H K)20

QO

Q

/0% E%,74+% 5$4$%'
LJ

J

/0% K)&)#- !"&$ "7 5%+()2%& )# 9)-0:/%20 5"2)%$)%& 4#1 K%(%#.%:@%#%+4$)#- 3%204#)&=&

8DT

E0; /+4#&7%+ *4;=%#$& 4+% G%2%&&4+; )# 9)-0:/%20 M#1.&$+)4, !46)$4,)&$ 5"2)%$)%&

8OD

8T

/0% U+%% 34+C%$ 4#1 3"+4,)$;

8JA

88

K%,)-)".& 4#1 5%2.,4+ !.+?& "# $0% 5%,7)&0#%&& 4#1 >="+4,)$; "7 $0% 34+C%$

A8O

A D I

L

<6),"-.%' E0; !4+%V

AII

671#3

AIQ

8-9#:

API

(

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"#$%#$&

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

()

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

*+%742%' E0; W!4+)#-X !46)$4,)&=V

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`Y /0% 6+"1: .2$& 2+%4$%1 04(% ?%2"=% ="+% $%20#","-)24,' #"$ "#,; $0% %,%2$+"#)2 6+"1.2$&S &.20 4& 2"=6.$%+& "+ 2%,,.,4+ 60"#%&S ?.$ %(%# 6+%()".&,; =.#14#% 6+"1.2$&S &.20 4& &6%2)4,)\%1S 0)-0:6%+7"+=4#2% &#%4C%+& "+ 7,4=%:+%$4+14#$ ?4?; 2,"$0)#-Y /0)& #%H %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= )& -71 W6"&$:)#1.&$+)4,Xa )$ )& &$),, )#1.&$+)4, 4$ )$& 2"+%Y E04$ $0% H"+,1 H4#$& )& $0% 0)-0:$%20 W$";&X $04$ $0)& +%=4+C4?,% #%H )#1.&$+)4, &;&$%= 1)&-"+-%& H)$0 2"+#.2"6)4 4?.#14#2%Y /04$ )&S $0% H"+,1 H4#$& 24+& H)$0 %,%2$+"#)2 7.%, )#b%2$)"#S $.+?" 204+-%+&S 4#$):,"2C ?+4C%&S 4)+ ?4-&S 4)+ 2"#1)$)"#)#-S &)R:&6%4C%+ &$%+%" &;&$%=&S 4#1 ="+%a 2","+ /c& H)$0 W&.++".#1 &".#1XS c!K&S 24=2"+1%+&S H4,C=4#&S &$%+%"&S 0"=% 2"=6.$%+&S 1%&)-#%+ 2,"$0)#- =41% 7+"= 0)-0:$%20 7)?%+&S 4#1 &" "#Y !"#&.=%+& H4#$ 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$& 7)+&$S $0%# $0%; 1%=4#1 W&%+()2%&XS &.20 4& 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2%S 20),1 24+%S %,1%+ 24+%S %1.24: $)"#S 6%#&)"#&S 0".&)#-S %$2Y 8

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

*+","-.%' $0% *+"1.2$)(% 3)+42,% 4#1 $0% 56%2)7)2 *4$$%+# "7 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& <#-%#1%+%1 ?; M$

!"#$+4&$ d464# H)$0 !0)#4Y /0% d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e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e.)$% +%=4+C4?,%Y [%$S $0% (%+; &.22%&& "7 &2)%#2% 4#1 $%20#","-; 04& ,%7$ ="1%+# =%# 4#1 H"=%# ="+% .#2%+$4)# $04# %(%+ 4?".$ ".+ 6,42% )# $0% .#)(%+&% 4#1 $0% =%4#)#"7 ".+ ,)7% 4#1 ".+ 1%4$0YD

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

@%#%& 4+% ?%)#- =466%1 4#1 &6,)2%1Y >#)=4,& 4+% ?%)#- 2,"#%1 ^ H),, 0.=4#& ?% 2,"#%1V !4# $0%+% ?% 4#"$0%+ W=%XS 4#"$0%+ W;".XV E".,1 $04$ 6%+&"# +%4,,; ?% =% "+ ;".S "+ 1)77%+%#$S "+ Y Y Y H04$ 1"%& $0)& =%4#V WM $0)#CS $0%+%7"+% M 4=XI ^ ?.$ 4= MS "+ 4= M &"=%"#% %,&%V /0% &.22%&& "7 $0% +4$)"#4,:&2)%#$)7)2 $%20#","-)24, +%(",.$)"# 04& ,%7$ .& H)$0 ="+% e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b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a H0),% &"=% "7 $0% %77%2$& 4+% #%-4$)(% ^ &.20 4& $0% ?+%4C:.6 "7 $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),; 4#1 $0% -+"H)#- 1+)7$ )#$" 1+.- 4#1 4,2"0", 4?.&%Y /0% )=642$ "7 $0% -,"?4, 0)-0:$%20#","-; 246)$4,)&$ )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=; 04& ?%%# 6+": 7".#1S 4#1 $0%+%7"+%S H% &0".,1 ,)C% $" %R6,"+% )$& )=642$ 7.+$0%+Y

!"# "+4"5*#)" +3'(2*%+./ ).$+*./+2* #)&3&-7 #34#3'#%2 . 3#8 )&32*#//.*+&3 &1 )/.22#2 /0% #%H 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=; 04& 2+%4$%1 #%H 2,4&&%& 4#1 "?,)$%+4$%1 ",1 "#%&Y U)+&$S $0% 246)$4,)&$& $0%=&%,(%& 04(% ?%%# $+4#&7"+=%1 7+"= ",1: 74&0)"#%1 %#$+%6+%#%.+& $" %)$0%+ 2"+6"+4$% =4#4-%+& "+ -,"?4, 7)#4#: 2)%+&Y /0)& 204#-% ?%-4# $" $4C% 6,42% 4$ $0% ?%-)##)#- "7 $0% $H%#$)%$0 2%#$.+;S 4#1 H4& 1"2.=%#$%1 ?; c%?,%#L 4#1 ?; ]%+,% 4#1 3%4#&Y8T 9"H%(%+S $0% #%H 0)-0:$%20 W6+"1.2%+ .#)$&XS 4#1 $0% 2"=6.$%+)\%1S -,"?4,)\%1 7)#4#2)4, =4+C%$& 04(% 422%,%+4$%1 $0% &%64+4$% -+"H$0 "7 $0%&% $H" &$+4$4Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"727.<#= !"79<&1,># ?,"%&2# %-9 @7&,%2 !"7A2#43 D

/0.&S $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& )& 1)()1%1 )#$" $H" &$+4$4 ^ &"=%$)=%& )# 2",,.&)"#S &"=%$)=%& )# 2"=6%$)$)"#S 7"+ 2"#$+", "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2": #"=)2 &;&$%= )$&%,7Y E% &04,, 1%&2+)?% $0% #%H &$+4$4 )# ="+% 1%$4),S ?.$ $0% e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e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`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b"+)$; 4#1 )$& +%6,42%=%#$ H)$0 $0% #%H =)11,%:2,4&& =4b"+)$;Y M# $0% 1%(%,"6)#- #4$)"#&S &.20 4& 5)#-46"+%S /04),4#1S M#1"#%&)4S Z"+%4S ]+4\),S 3%R)2"S $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& )& %R64#1)#- 4& 64+$ "7 $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

I +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

+%,"24$)"# "7 0)-0:$%20 742$"+)%& 7+"= $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&S d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`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b"?& )# $0)& #%H &;&$%= 1%=4#1 4 0)-0 ,%(%, "7 %1.24$)"#S 4#1 &" 7%H b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a )# >&)4 $0% .#1%+2,4&& )& %R64#1)#- 7+"= +.+4,: $":.+?4# =)-+4$)"#a )# B4$)# >=%+)24 $0% .#1%+2,4&& )& %R6,"1)#- H)$0)# $0% 2)$)%& 7+"= +.+4,:$":.+?4# =)-+4$)"#a )# $0% N5> )==)-+4$)"# 7+"= B4$)# >=%+)24S $0% !4+)??%4# 4#1 %,&%H0%+%S 411%1 $" $0% 2"+% "7 .#: 4?&"+?%1 ?,42C >=%+)24#&S 04& 2+%4$%1 4# .#1%+2,4&& "7 (4&$ 6+"6"+$)"#&Y /0.&S $0% .#1%+2,4&& ^ 4& 4 2,4&& ^ )& 4# )#$%+#4$)"#4, 6+"?,%=S 742%1 ?; 4,, "7 $0% #4$)"#& "7 $0% -,"?4, 0)-0:$%20 H"+,1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"727.<#= !"79<&1,># ?,"%&2# %-9 @7&,%2 !"7A2#43 O

P +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E0),% $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& 04& ?%%# 1%2,)#)#- )# #.=?%+&S 4#1 )#7,.%#2%S 4#1 $0% .#1%+2,4&& 04& ?%2"=% 6+"?,%=4$)2S $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& )& %R64#1)#- H"+,1:H)1%S 4#1 +46)1,; ?%2"=)#- $0% =4b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b"+)$; 2,4&&S H),, $0%; -%#%+4$% #%H )1%","-)%&S 6+"-+4=&S 4#1 6",)2)%& )# &"2)%$;V f+S 4& &%-=%#$& "7 $0% 2"+6"+4$%S 41=)#)&$+4$)(% 4#1 &%+()2% &;&$%=&S H),, $0%; ?% .#4?,% $" 4+$)2.,4$% 4 2"0%+%#$ &%$ "7 6",)$)24, 6"&)$)"#&V

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# 3#8 -+''/#5)/.22 -.9&%+*7

4& $0% #%H #"+=4$)(% 64$$%+# ,)#C%1 $" $0% .+?4# 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;Y 3"&$ ="1%+# 2)$)\%#& 4+% 7)#1)#- $0%=&%,(%& %#&2"#2%1 )# )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),; .#)$&Y E)$0)# $0)& $+%#1:&%$$)#- #.2,%4+ 74=),; 2"#1)$)"#S $0% 0.&?4#1S $0% H)7%S 4#1 $0% 20),1+%# ?%2"=% $0% =4)# 7"2.& "7 74=),; ,)7%Y E04$ "7 -+4#164+%#$&V @+4#164+%#$&S H0" H%+% $0% 1"=)#4#$ =%=: ?%+& "7 $0% 2,4# 4#1 $0% -,.% $04$ 0%,1 $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),; $"-%$0%+S 04(% %)$0%+ ?%%# ,%7$ ?%0)#1 "+ ="(%1 40%41Y /04$ )&S %)$0%+ $0% -+4#1: 64+%#$& 04(% +%=4)#%1 )# $0%)+ +.+4, (),,4-%&S "+ )# $0% )##%+ 2)$)%& $" H0)20 $0%; =4; 04(% =)-+4$%1S "+S $0%; 04(% &.22%%1%1 )# $0% ="1%+# %2"#"=; 4#1 #"H 04(% +%$)+%1 $" &%#)"+ 2)$)\%# 4+%4&Y M# %420 24&%S $0%; 04(% ?%%# &%64+4$%1 7+"= $0% 74=),;Y E)$0 $0% &%64+4$)"# "7 $0% -+4#164+%#$& 7+"= $0% 74=),; .#)$S =.,: $)6,% 74=),; 6+"?,%=& 04(% %=%+-%1Y > &$+.2$.+4, #%%1 7"+ )#&$)$.$)"#4,: )\%1 20),1 24+%S ".$&)1% $0% #.2,%4+ 74=),;S ?%2"=%& 4?&",.$%,; #%2%&&4+;S H0),% %,1%+:24+% )#&$)$.$)"#& 04(% 4,&" ?%2"=% %&&%#$)4,Y >#"$0%+ $+%#1 )# $0% #%H 0)-0:$%20 W-,"?4, (),,4-%X )& $0% ,)?%+4$)"# "7 H"=%# 7+"= $0% 74=),; 4#1 )#$" $0% H"+C H"+,1Y /0)& ,)?%+4$)"#S $0".-0 H"#1%+7., 7"+ H"=%#S 04& ?%%# 1%(4&$4$)#- 7"+ 74=),; 7.#2$)"#: )#-Y E"=%#S 47$%+ 4,,S H%+% $0% 2"+% "7 $0% 74=),;Y E"=%# ?%4+ 20),1+%#S H"=%# ?+%4&$:7%%1 20),1+%#S H"=%# 24+% 7"+ 20),1+%#Y E0%# H"=%# ,%4(% $0% 74=),;S H0" #.+$.+%& $0% 20),1+%#V /"14;X& #.2,%4+ 74=),; )& =41% .6 "7 $H" H"+C)#- 64+%#$& ^ $H" 0.&?4#1&S 4& )$ H%+%S 4#1 #" H)7%g /0% 0".&%H)7% +",% )& -"#%Y <)$0%+ $0% H"=4# &$),, 24++)%& ".$ $0)& 7.#2$)"# )# 0%+ &64+% $)=% ^ 4#1 ?%2"=%& %R04.&$%1 _4#1 +%&%#$7.,` 7+"= $0)& W+",% "(%+,"41XS "+ $0% =4# 0%,6& 4#1 $0%; ?"$0 &04+% $0% 0".&%0",1 +",% ^ ?"$0 $0%# ?%2"=)#- %R04.&$%1 _4#1 +%&%#$7.,` 7+"= $0% W+",% "(%+,"41XY E"+&%S H)$0 #" -+4#164+%#$& )# $0% #.2,%4+ 74=),; 4#1 $0% H"=4# H"+C)#-S H0" $4C%& "(%+ $0% ="$0%+)#- +",%V ^ 64)1 #4##)%&S 14;:24+% #.+&%+)%&S ?4?;:&)$$%+&S #.+&%+; &20"",&S 6+%:&20"", 6+"-+4=&S 47$%+: &20"", 6+"-+4=&S %$2Y /0.&S ".$&)1% )#&$)$.$)"#& $4C% "(%+ =.20 "7 $0% 20),1:+%4+)#-Y >,"#- H)$0 $0% &%64+4$)"# "7 $0% ="$0%+ 4#1 $0% -+4#164+%#$& 7+"= $0% ="1%+# 74=),;S $%%#4-%+& 04(% ?%2"=% &%64+4$%1 "77 7+"= $0% #.2,%4+ 74=),;Y G"$ $04$ $0% $%%#& 42$.4,,; ,%4(% $0% 74=),; 60;&)24,,;S ?.$ +4$0%+ $0%; ,%4(% =%#$4,,; 4#1 ="+4,,;Y /%%#& )# $0% -,"?4, (),,4-% 04(% $0%)+ "H# 2.,$.+%' $0%)+ "H# =.&)2S $0%)+ "H# 2,"$0)#-S $0%)+ ,)$%+4$.+%S $0%)+ ="()%&S $0%)+ $%,%()&)"# &0"H&S $0%)+ 1+.-&S 4#1 $0%)+ "H# &%R.4, ="+%&Y /0)& $%%# 2.,$.+% )&S )# 64+$S 4 6+"1.2$ "7 $0% H"+,1 =4&& =%1)4 +%(",.$)"#Y /0% )#2+%4&)#- 6&;20","-)24, 4#1 2.,$.+4,

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"727.<#= !"79<&1,># ?,"%&2# %-9 @7&,%2 !"7A2#43 Q

1)&$4#2% "7 $0% $%%#& 7+"= $0%)+ 64+%#$& ,%4(%& $%%#4-%+& H)$0 4# 4#"=)2 (")1 )# $%+=& "7 #"+=&S (4,.%&S 4=?)$)"#& 4#1 74=),; +",% ="1%,&Y >#1 7.+$0%+S $0% %#$)+% 6+"2%&& "7 74=),; 1%2,)#% 4#1 74=),; 1;&7.#2: $)"# 04& ?%%# =41% 74+ H"+&% ?; $0% +)&)#- 1)("+2%:+4$%Y F)("+2% 04& ?%2"=% 4 -+"H)#- 6+"?,%= )# ="&$ 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#&Y U+"= K.&&)4 $" $0% N5>S 7+"= /4)H4# $" !4#414S 7+"= @%+=4#; $" ]+4\),S ?.$ #"$ )# d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d.14: )&=S !0+)&$)4#)$;S M&,4=S 9)#1.)&=S ].110)&=S 4#1 "$0%+& ^ 4,, 04(% ?%%# 2,4&0)#- H)$0 $0% #%H &"2)4, +%4,)$; "7 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$;Y /0% +%4&"#& 7"+ $0% 1%2,)#% "7 +%,)-)"# 4+% $H":7",1Y /0% -,"?4, %2"#"=; 24++)%& H)$0 )$ $H" 1"=)#4#$ 6+"2%&&%& 1%%6,; )=?%11%1 )# )$& %&&%#2%' &2)%#2% 4#1 $0% =4&& =%1)4 "7 2"==.#)24$)"#&Y f.+ 2"#2%6$)"# "7 @"1 4#1 9%4(%# 4#1 9%,, ^ H0%+% 4+% $0%;V ^ 04(% ?%%# ="1)7)%1 ?; G%H$"#S <)#&$%)#S8P 4#1 ]"0+S8Q 9%)&%#?%+-8J 4#1 94HC)#-S8L 4#1 4,, $0% "$0%+&S H0" 04(% 6+"()1%1 .& H)$0 4 ()%H "7 $0% =4$%+)4, .#)(%+&%S H0)20 04& 4,,"H%1 .& $" .#1%+&$4#1 W#4$.+%X 4#1 .&% )$& %#%+-;Y /0% &2)%#$)&$& 04(% 2+%4$%1 4 #%H ()%H "7 $0% .#)(%+&%S $0% #4$.+4, H"+,1S 4#1 0.=4# ?%)#-&Y /0%; 04(% #"$S 0"H%(%+S 4#&H%+%1 $0% e.%&: $)"#& H0)20 -%#%+4$%1 +%,)-)"# )# $0% 7)+&$ 6,42%' H0" 2+%4$%1 $0% .#): (%+&%V >#1 H0; 1(,3 .#)(%+&%S $0)& H4;V E0; 4+% H% ?"+# 4#1 H0; 1" H% 1)%V >#1 H0; 4+% H% 4H4+% "7 ".+ ,)7% 4#1 1%4$0V >#1 0"H &04,, H% ,)(% ".+ ,)(%& )# &"2)%$;V M# F.+C0%)=X& $%+=&S 2"#7.&)"# )# ".+ ?%,)%7 &;&$%= ,%41& $" %-74,#'AT ,"&& "7 =%4#)#-S ,"&& "7 #"+=&S 4#1 ="+4, =4,4)&%Y >,"#- H)$0 +4$)"#4,S %=6)+)24, &2)%#2%S $0% =4&& =%1)4 04(% .#H)$: $)#-,; .#1%+=)#%1 H"+,1 +%,)-)".& ?%,)%7&Y /0% H"+,1 H)1% H%? "7 2"=: =.#)24$)"#& =%1)4 )& "#,; )# )$& )#74#2;Y [%$S 4,+%41;S 6%"6,% 4,, "(%+ $0% H"+,1 24# $4,C $" %420 "$0%+ ?; 2"=6.$%+S ?; $%,%60"#%S 4#1 &""# ?;

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

J +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

2"=6.$%+:$%,%()&)"#:$%,%60"#% &;&$%=&Y M$ )& $+.,; %R0),4+4$)#- $" ?% 4?,% $" -" $" 9"#- Z"#-S 5)#-46"+% "+ ].146%&$S 4#1 ?% 4?,% $" 2"==.#)2: 4$%S 2)$)\%# $" 2)$)\%#S )# 4 &04+%1 H"+,1 2.,$.+%Y /0% 1)77)2.,$;S 0"H%(%+S ,)%& )# $0% 2"#$%#$ "7 $0% =4&& =%1)4 4#1 )$& 2,4&0 H)$0 ,"24, )#1)-%#".& (4,.%& 4,, "(%+ $0% H"+,1S )#2,.1)#- W&=4,, $"H#X N5>Y /0% 2"#$%#$ "7 $0% =4&& =%1)4 )& 6+"?,%=4$)24, )# $H" H4;&' "#% 6+"?,%= )& $0% %=604&)& "# &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% )# $0% ="()%&S /cS +"2C =.&)2S 4#1 ()1%"24&&%$$%&Y /0% "$0%+ 6+"?,%= )& $0% >=%+)24# ^ WE%&$: %+#X ^ 2.,$.+4, #"+=& 4#1 (4,.%& H0)20 1"=)#4$% $0% =%1)4 ?%24.&% "7 $0% >=%+)24# #%4+:="#"6",; "7 6+"1.2$)"# "7 =%1)4 6+"-+4==)#-Y E0; 4+% &%RS ()",%#2% 4#1 $0% &%R^()",%#2% ,)#C &" %()1%#$ )# =4&& =%1)4 6+"-+4==)#-V ]%24.&% $0%; H"+C 4& 4 1%()2% $" -+4? ".+ 4$$%#: $)"#Y [". 1"#X$ #%%1 4 -+%4$ 6,"$ H0%# &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% 04(% +)(%$%1 $0% 4$$%#$)"# "7 $0% 4.1)%#2%Y /0% &"2)4, 6+"?,%= 0%+% )& "?()".&' $0% 2"#$%#$ "7 $0% =4&& =%1)4 "7$%# 2,4&0%& H)$0 $0% 2.,$.+4, #"+=& 4#1 (4,.%& "7 $0% 6%"6,% ()%H)#4#1 0%4+)#- $0% %#$%+$4)#=%#$Y G%-4$)(% +%42$)"#& $" $0% =4&& =%1)4 ^ %&6%2)4,,; ?; 64+%#$& H)$0 20),1+%# ^ 04(% 2+%4$%1 4# )#$%+#4$)"#4,S ;%$ ,"24,)\%1S 4$$%=6$ $" 0",1 "# $" $0% "+)-)#4, 2.,$.+4, (4,.%& $04$ &%%= .#1%+ 4$$42C ?; $0% =4&& =%1)4Y E0%$0%+ )$ )& 5)#-46"+% "+ f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"727.<#= !"79<&1,># ?,"%&2# %-9 @7&,%2 !"7A2#43 L

E)$0 $0% 6+)=4+; )#&$)$.$)"#& "7 74=),;S =4++)4-% 4#1 20.+20 )# 2+)&)& 4="#- $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S 4 &%$ "7 &%2"#14+; &.66"+$ )#&$)$.$)"#& ?%2"=%& 4?&",.$%,; %&&%#$)4,S )7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& )& $" &.+()(% )# 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$;Y /0% &04+%1 #%%1& %=4#4$% 7+"= $0%&% 6+"?,%=&S H0)20 H% H),, 1%&2+)?% )# ="+% 1%$4),' 74=),; ?+%4C.6 4#1 1;&7.#2$)"#S $0% 0)-0 +4$% "7 1)("+2%S -%#1%+ 2,4&0%& )# $0% 0"=% 4#1 $0% H"+C6,42%S )#41%e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`Y 9"H%(%+S $4C)#$0% 6,42% "7 $0% ",1 H"+C)#- 2,4&& ^ $0% ,"H:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, H"+C)#- 2,4&& "7 $0% #)#%$%%#$0 2%#$.+; ^ )& $0% #%H .#1%+2,4&&Y /0)& .#1%+2,4&& ^ H0)20 )& =41% .6 "7 $H" &$+4$4' $0% H"+C)#- 6""+ 4#1 $0% .#%=6,";4?,% 6""+ ^ 04& 4 1)77%+%#$ &%$ "7 &04+%1 #%%1& $04# $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S $0".-0 $0%+% )& &"=% "(%+,46Y /0% &04+%1 #%%1& "7 $0)& #%H .#1%+2,4&& 4,&" %#-%#1%+ $0% #%2%&&)$; 7"+ 2%+$4)# &"2)4, 6+"-+4=&Y 9"H%(%+S &)#2% $0% .#1%+2,4&& )& 6",)$)24,,;S %2"#"=)24,,; 4#1 &"2)4,,; ,%&& 6"H%+7., $04# $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S $0% #%%1& "7 $0)& 2,4&& 4+% ,%&& 24+%7.,,; 4$$%#1%1 $"Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8T +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E% &04,, 4+-.% $04$ $0% H4; )# H0)20 $0% #%%1& "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& 4+% $4C%# 24+% "7 =4; 1+4=4$)24,,; 477%2$ $0% &$4?),)$; "7 $0% %#$)+% &"2)%$; )# e.%&$)"#Y /0% 2"#$+4&$ ?%$H%%# 5)#-46"+% 4#1 ]+4\), )# $0)& +%-4+1 )& ),,.&$+4$)(%S )# $04$ 5)#-46"+% )& 6+".1 "7 )$& 0.=4#% 4$$%=6$& 4$ &.6: 6"+$)#- 4#1 +%04?),)$4$)#- )$& .#1%+2,4&& _$0".-0 5)#-46"+% )& -71 4 1%="2+4$)2 #4$)"#`S H0),% ]+4\), )& +.$0,%&& )# )$& &.66+%&&)"# "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& _$0".-0 ]+4\), )& 4# %=%+-)#- 1%="2+4$)2 #4$)"#`Y /0% .#1%+2,4&& 6+"?,%= )& =.20 H"+&% )# ]+4\),S ?.$ #"#%$0%,%&& $0% 1)77%+: %#2% )# 2.,$.+4, 4$$)$.1% 4#1 &"2)4, +%&6"#&% )& 1+4=4$)2Y 5)#2% $0% .#1%+2,4&& )& 6",)$)24,,; H%4C 4#1 1)&"+-4#)\%1S )# ="&$ 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#& )$ H),, ?% $0% 6",)$)24, 1%2)&)"# "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& ^ H0" 0",1 4# %,%2$"+4, =4b"+)$; ^ 4& $" H0%$0%+ $0% .#1%+2,4&& H),, ?% )#2,.1%1 )# )$& H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=& "+ #"$Y

!"# 8#/1.%# 2*.*# &3 . 3#8 -+''/#5)/.22 ;.2# /0".-0 )$ )& $+.% $04$ 4+".#1 $0% H"+,1S $0% WH%,74+% &$4$%X 4& H% 6+%(: )".&,; C#%H )$ )& ?%)#- 2.$ ?42C 7)#4#2)4,,;S 4#1 $0".-0 )$ )& $+.% $04$ $0% 2"&$ "7 $0% ",1 H%,74+% &$4$% )& ?%2"=)#- $"" 0)-0S ;%$ )$ )& #"$ $+.% $04$ $0% H%,74+% &$4$% )& ?%)#- 1)&=4#$,%1Y M# 742$S $0% H%,74+% &$4$% )& ?%)#- #:1#-9#9B $0".-0 64+$)4, 64;=%#$ 7"+ $0)& #%H H%,74+% &$4$% )& ?%)#&0)7$%1 $" $0% )#1)()1.4, .&%+&S &" $04$ 7.,, -"(%+#=%#$ 64;=%#$ $0+".-0 2",,%2$)(% $4R%& =4; #" ,"#-%+ ?% $0% ="1%, 7"+ H%,74+%:&$4$% 7.#1)#-S %(%# )# &"2)4,:1%="2+4$)2 #4$)"#& ,)C% G"+H4;Y M# $0% N5>S $0% &4=% H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& 4+% %=%+-)#- 4& )# G"+: H4;S U+4#2%S 4#1 5)#-46"+%Y 9"H%(%+S $0%&% 6+"-+4=& 4+% W6+)(4$)\%1X )# $0% N5>Y *+)(4$)\%1S "+ #"$S $H" $+%#1& 4+% %=%+-)#-' 7)+&$ $0% H%,74+%: &$4$% 6+"-+4=& 4+% ?%)#- %R$%#1%1 $" ="+% 4#1 ="+% >=%+)24#&S 4#1 &%2"#1S $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )& ?%-)##)#- $" 64; )# $0+".-0 $4R +%?4$%& 4#1 "$0%+ &.?&)1)%&Y E% &04,, &0"H $04$ &)=),4+ 6+"-+4=&S H)$0 1)77%+%#$ 7.#1)#- 4,$%+: #4$)(%&S 4+% %=%+-)#- H"+,1:H)1%Y /0.&S $0% WH%,74+% &$4$%X H),, ,""C &)=),4+S ?.$ )$& 7.#1)#- 6+"2%&&%& =4; ?% 1)77%+%#$S +4#-)#- 7+"= $"$4, &"2)4,:1%="2+4$)2 &$4$% 64;=%#$S $" 6+)(4$% 64;=%#$ H)$0 )#2+%4&)#-"(%+#=%#$ &.66"+$S 4& )# $0% N5>Y f#% ,4&$ 742$"+ #%%1& $" ?% =%#$)"#%1S ?%7"+% %#$%+)#- )#$" ".+ &6%2)7)2 4#4,;&)&' 4 H%,74+% &$4$% 7"+ $0% +)20 04& 4,+%41; %=%+-%1 )# $0% N5> 4#1 "$0%+ 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$)%&Y /04$ )&S H0%+% H%4,$0; )#1)()1.4,&S "+S H0%+% &6%2)7)2 ,4+-%:&24,% 2"+6"+4$)"#&S "+ H0%+% $0% H0",% 7)#4#2)4, 4#1 )#1.&: $+)4, &;&$%= )& $0+%4$%#%1 H)$0 2",,46&%S $0% -"(%+#=%#$ H),, &$%6 )# 4#1 W?4), ".$X $0% )#1)()1.4,S $0% 2"+6"+4$)"#S 4#1 $0% H0",% &;&$%=Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"727.<#= !"79<&1,># ?,"%&2# %-9 @7&,%2 !"7A2#43 88

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8A +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

8

>/.22+)./ #)&3&-+)2 .3' 2).%)# %#2&(%)#2 524+2)$; 04& 4,H4;& ?%%# 64+$ "7 $0% 1%7)#)$)"# "7 %2"#"=)2&Y N&.4,,; $0% +%7%+%#2% )& $" &24+2% +%&".+2%& 4#1 $0% .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 %2": #"=)2 H%,,:?%)#-Y 9%#2%S $0% #%-4$)(% 1)&$)#2$)"# "7 %2"#"=)2& 4& $0% W1)&=4, &2)%#2%XY /0.&S H% =.&$ %=604&)\% 4$ $0% ".$&%$ $04$ W#4$.+4, +%&".+2%&X 4+% &$),, &24+2%Y f),S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S H),, #"$ ,4&$ 7"+%(%+S 4#1 =.20 "7 ="1%+# 6+"1.2$)"# )& 1%6%#1%#$ "# 6%$+"20%=)24,&Y [%&S 2"4, 24# +%6,42% "),S ?.$ $0% 2"&$ $" $0% %4+$0X& &.+742% 4#1 4$="&60%+% H".,1 ?% $%++)?,%Y >#1S ;%&S #.2,%4+ 7.&)"# =4; &"=% 14; ?% $4=%1 $" ".+ .&%&S ?.$ $0)& )& 4 ,"#- H4; "77S 4#1 4-4)#S $0%+% 4+% 0.-% %#()+"#=%#$4, 14#-%+&Y >,, $0% +%&".+2%& "7 $0% %4+$0 4#1 )$& 7+4-),% 4$="&60%+% 4+% 7)#)$%S 4#1 $0%+%7"+% &24+2)$; +%=4)#& 4 =4b"+ 6+"?,%= H)$0)# %2"#"=)2 7"+=.,4: $)"#& )# 4#; ,"#-:$%+= 6+"b%2$)"#Y f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% 9)-0:/%20#","-; <2"#"=; "7 >?.#14#2%' @""1& (& 5%+()2%&

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h _H0),% &$),, 4,,"H)#- .& $" )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\% ,4$% =4++)4-%`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e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e.4$)"#&Y M7 &24+2)$; &$),, .#1%+-)+1& %2"#"=)2 $0%"+; 4$ )$& 2"+%S )+"#)24,,;S 4?.#14#2% 04& ?%2"=% 6+"?,%=4$)2 )# $%+=& "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1&g !"# .;(3'.3)# &1 -.3(1.)*(%#' 4&&'20 &,#%5$%&'()*+&3 .2 . -&'#%3 #)&3&-+) $%&;/#/0".-0 ".+ )#$%,,%2$.4, 2+%4$)()$; 04& "(%+2"=% 34,$0.&X %e.4$)"# )# $%+=& "7 7""1 &.66,;S )$ =.&$ ?% 6")#$%1 ".$ $04$ $0% 6+"?,%= "7 &24+2)$; ^ "+ WH0" -%$& H04$ 4#1 0"H =.20X "7 4 ,)=)$%1 &.66,;S 4& )$ )& &$4$%1 )# )#$+"1.2$"+; %2"#"=)2& $%R$?""C&D ^ )& &$),, 4$ $0% 2"+% "7 $0% %2"#"=)2

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8I +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

8O

6+"?,%=Y U"+S )$ )& #"$ "#,; $0% 7""1 &.66,;S "+ #4$.+4, +%&".+2%&S H0)20 24# ?%2"=% &24+2%Y 34#.742$.+%1 -""1& ^ 7"+=%+,; 2+47$ -""1& ^ 24# 4,&" %R)&$ )# &0"+$ &.66,;S ,%4()#- &"=% 6%"6,% H)$0 4 ,%&&%+ e.4,)$; "7 ,)7% $04# "$0%+&Y /0%; 1"#X$ &$4+(% 4#;="+%S )# ="&$ 24&%&S ?.$ $0%)+ 2,"$0)#-S 0".&)#-S 4#1 $0% -""1& $0%; .&% )# $0%)+ %(%+;14; ,)7% =4; ?% "7 4 e.4,)$; &" 6""+ $04$ $0% ,)7% "7 &.20 6%"6,% =4; ?% H+%$20%1Y E% &%% $0)& ?"$0 )# /0)+1 E"+,1 #4$)"#& 4#1 )# $0% &,.=& "7 1%(%,"6%1 #4$)"#&Y 9"H%(%+S )# $%+=& "7 $0% 6+"1.2$)"# "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1&S ="1%+# 0)-0:$%20#","-; )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&= )& "(%+2"=)#- &24+2)$; )# 4 +%(": ,.$)"#4+; H4;Y /04$ )&S )#&$%41 "7 &24+2)$;S $0%+% )& =4&&)(% "(%+6+"1.2: $)"# "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1&Y /0% /0)+1 E"+,1 #4$)"#&S 4#1 6"(%+$; 4+%4& "7 $0% F%(%,"6%1 E"+,1S 4+% $0% %R2%6$)"#&S 4-4)#S H0)20 6+"(% $0% +.,%Y /0%; 4+% %R2%6$)"#& ?%24.&% $0%; 4+% #"$ ;%$ 64+$ "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;S $0".-0 $0%; 4+% +46)1,; ?%)#- 4?&"+?%1 )#$" )$Y >#1S $0% W+.,%X )& $04$ $0)& #%H %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= 6+"1.2%& &.20 4# )#2+%1)?,% (",.=% "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1&S $04$ "(%+6+"1.2$)"#S +4$0%+ $04# &24+2)$;S 04& ?%2"=% $0% 2%#$+4, W&;&$%=&X 6+"?,%= )# $0% 2"#$%=6"+4+; &)$.4$)"#Y f(%+6+"1.2$)"#S 4& c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b"+)$; "7 6%"6,%S $0.& =4C)#- ,)7% 60;&)24,,; %4&)%+ 4#1 ="+% &%2.+%S )7S )# $+.$0S ,%4()#- .& 6&;20","-)24,,; 4#1 ="+4,,; )#&%2.+% 4#1 .#2%+$4)#Y E0),% 34+R 4#1 c%?,%# ?%="4#%1 "(%+6+"1.2$)"#S "(%+:2"#&.=6: $)"#S 4#1 $0% 2"#&6)2.".& 1)&6,4; "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1&S W4?.#14#2%X $0%"+)&$&S &.20 4& /0%"?4,1Q ^ H+)$)#- 1.+)#- $0% 8LPT& 4#1 8LQT& ^ 0"6%1 $04$ H% 2".,1 2+%4$% 4# %2"#"=)2 .$"6)4 H)$0 $0)& #%H:7".#1 6+"1.2$)(% 24642)$;Y /0%)+ 6")#$ "7 ()%H )& $04$ "(%+6+"1.2$)"# )& 4 ?,%&&)#- $04$ H),, %(%#$.4,,; ,%41 $" 4 (%+; 0)-0 &$4#14+1 "7 ,)()#- 7"+

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

C,.(DE#&( FA<-9%-&#= G7793 >3 @#">,

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e.%&$)"#Y >#1S H0%$0%+ )$ .#1%+=)#%& ".+ 0.=4#)&$)2 2"#2%+# 7"+ "$0%+& )& 4 1)77%+%#$ e.%&$)"# 4-4)#Y >#1S 7.+$0%+ ;%$S WH0" -%$& H04$ 4#1 0"H =.20X "7 $0)& 0)-0 &$4#14+1 "7 ,)()#- ^ $04$ )&S $0% 6+"?,%= "7 ,.R.+; ,)()#- (& ="1%&$ ,)()#- H)$0)# $0% H"+,1 "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1& ^ )& &$),, 4 2+)$)24, )&&.%S )7 #"$ 4 +%(",.$)"#4+; )&&.%Y >,, "7 $0%&% e.%&$)"#& H),, 04(% $" ?% +%%R4=)#%1 )# $0% 6"&$:&"2)4,)&$S 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$S H"+,1 $04$ )& %=%+-)#- -,"?4,,;Y ].$S ?%7"+% 1)&2.&&: )#- $0% "(%+6+"1.2$)"# "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1& 4#1 )$& .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.: $)"#S 4#1 ?%7"+% 1)&2.&&)#- H0%$0%+ $0% 4?.#14#2%S "+ $0% 1)&$+)?.$)"#S 4+% $+.,; 6+"?,%=4$)24,S ,%$ .& 7"2.& "# 4 1)77%+%#$ C)#1 "7 W&24+2)$;X H0)20 2"#$)#.%& $" %R)&$ 4#1 2"#$)#.%& $" =4C% %2"#"=)2& $0% W1)&=4, &2)%#2%XY E% 4+% +%7%++)#- $" $0% &24+2)$; "7 3#">,Y !"# 2).%)+*7 &1 2#%,+)#2 +3 "+4"5*#)" +3'(2*%+./ ).$+*./+2* 2&)+#*+#2 /0%+% 4+% &"=%S &.20 4& F4#)%, ]%,,SJ H0" ?%,)%(% $04$ $0% #%H %2"#"=; )& 4 W&%+()2% %2"#"=;XY /0%; 204+42$%+)\% )$ 4& &.20 ?%24.&% $0%; "?&%+(% $04$ $0% =4b"+)$; "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"# 4+% ?%2"=)#- %=6,";%1S #"$ )# ?,.%:2",,4+ 742$"+; 6+"1.2$)"#S ?.$ )# H0)$%:2",,4+ "77)2% 6"&)$)"#&Y ]%,, 4#1 "$0%+& 2"#2%)(% "7 $0%&% H0)$%:2",,4+ 6"&)$)"#& 4& W&%+()2% H"+CXY 9"H%(%+S $0%; 4+% &$+%$20)#- $0% 2"#2%6$)"# "7 W&%+()2%X ?%;"#1 +%2"-: #)$)"#Y U"+ $0% =%# 4#1 H"=%# H0" H"+C 7"+ $0% 2"+6"+4$% 4#1 7)#4#2)4, H"+,1 4+% #"$ 6+"1.2)#- &%+()2%& ^ ="&$ "7 $0%= 4+% H"+C)#H)$0)# $0% W$%20#"&$+.2$.+%XL H0)20 6+"1.2%& %)$0%+ =4#.742$.+%1 -""1&S "+ $0% 7)#4#2)4, &.66"+$ 7"+ $0% =4#.742$.+)#- )#1.&$+)%&Y >-4)#S $0% =4b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8P +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

8Q

2"==.#)24$)"#& #%$H"+C&S 4#1 &" "#Y /0%&% $0)#-& 4+% H"#1%+7.,S ?.$ $0%; 4+% #"$ W&%+()2%&XY G%)$0%+ 4+% $0% 6+"1.2$& 6+"1.2%1 ?; )#&.+4#2% 2"=64#)%&S &$"2C 4#1 ?"#1 2"=64#)%&S "+ ?4#C&S W&%+()2%&XY /0%&% 7)#4#: 2)4, W6+"1.2$&X 4+% 4# )#$%-+4, 64+$ "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$ &;&$%=S b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e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 =4#.742$.+%1 -""1& 7"+ 4,, ?.$ $0% 6""+Y >& $0% ="1%+# )#1)()1.4, 1+)(%& $" H"+C )# 0)& "+ 0%+ /";"$4S H)$0 )$& &$%+%" 1)&C 6,4;%+ e.)%$)#- $0% $+477)2 #")&%S 0% "+ &0% =4; ?% 74+ ="+% H"++)%1 4?".$ $0% 14;:24+% 2%#$%+ $0%; ,%7$ $0%)+ 20),1 )# "+ $0% #.+&)#0"=% $0%; ,%7$ $0%)+ ="$0%+ )#S $04# $0% 3%+2%1%& ]%#\ OTT -,)1)#- ?; H)$0 )$& 0)-0%+ ".$6.$ %#-)#% 4#1 &)R:&6%4C%+ &$%+%" 1)&C:6,4;%+ e.)%$)#$0% $+477)2 #")&% ="+% %77%2$)(%,;Y E0),% 2"#&.=%+ -""1& 7,""1 $0% =4+C%$S 2"=% 1"H# )# 6+)2%S 4#1 -" .6 )# e.4,)$;S &%+()2%& 04(% +%=4)#%1 &24+2% 4#1 7+)-0$7.,,; %R6%#&)(%Y /0)& 1)&2+%64#2; 2"#$)#.%& $" 6%+&)&$ ?%24.&% &%+()2%& 4+% #"$ 1)+%2$,; 2"##%2$%1 $" $0% =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= )# )$& 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$ 7"+=Y /0)& )& ?%24.&%' _8` &%+()2%& =4; #"$ ?% 6+"7)$4?,% ^ )# 742$S $0%; 4+% "7$%# .#6+"7)$4?,%S "+ 4$ ?%&$S =)#)=4,,; 6+"7)$4?,%Y M# 742$S &%+()2%& =4;

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

C,.(DE#&( FA<-9%-&#= G7793 >3 @#">,

?% &" .#6+"7)$4?,% $04$ $0%; +%e.)+% -"(%+#=%#$ &.?&)1)%&S "+ 2"==.#: )$; &.?&)1)%&S "+ )#1.&$+)4, &.?&)1)%&S "+ 204+)$4?,% &.?&)1)%&S $" 6+%&%+(% $0%)+ %R)&$%#2%a _A`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f# $0% 2"#$+4+;S $0% =)11,% 4#1 .66%+ &$+4$4 #%%1 $0%&% &%+()2%& 4& H%,,Y M# 742$S $0% +%=4+C4?,% &)$.4$)"# $04$ 04& %=%+-%1 H)$0 $0% 0)-0:$%20 -,"?4, 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= )& $04$ $0% =)11,% 4#1 .66%+ 2,4&&%& 24##"$ 7.#2$)"# H)$0".$ 4# )#2+%4&)#- #.=?%+ "7 &%+()2%& $04$ H%+%S )# $+41)$)"#4, &"2)%$)%&S 6+"()1%1 ?; 74=),; 4#1 20.+20 "+-4#)\4$)"#& ^ "+ H%+% .##%2%&&4+; "+ .#C#"H# )# $0% &)=6,%+ &"2)%$)%& "7 $0% 64&$Y E0; H".,1 4# %R$%#1%1 74=),;S ?%7"+% $0% %+4 "7 H"=%#X& ,)?%+4$)"# 4#1 &4,4+)%1 %=6,";=%#$S #%%1 20),1:24+% &%+()2%&V E0; H".,1 4 6%4&: 4#$ #%%1 4 2",,%-% %1.24$)"#V ].$S #"H 2".,1 4 6+)%&$ "+ 4 &04=4# 6+"()1% 4 0%4+$ $+4#&6,4#$ 7"+ 4 1;)#- 64$)%#$V >#1S 1"%& #"$ 4 +)20 =4# 1%&)+% &.20 4 0%4+$ "6%+4$)"#S 4& H%,, 4& 4 6""+ =4#V >#1S 1"%& #"$ 4 =)11,%:2,4&& H"=4# +%e.)+% 4 2",,%-% 1%-+%% )# $"14;X& 0)-0:$%20 b"? =4+C%$V B%$ .& ,""C 24+%7.,,; 4$ $0% W&%+()2% #%%1&X "7 $0% -%#%+4, 6"6.,4$)"#S 4#1 4,&" $0% (4+)4$)"#& )# $0% #%%1& 4#1 &%+()2%& +%e.)+%1 ?; $0% (4+)".& &$+4$4 "7 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$;Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8J +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0% 56%2)7)2 *4$$%+# "7 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& B)#C%1 $" $0% G%H 3)11,% !,4&&

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A

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`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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i0%+ 64+%#$&S $04$ 20),1 =)-0$ )1%#$)7; e.)$% &$+"#-,; H)$0 4 -+4#164+%#$ 4#1S "+S ,""C 7"+ ,"(% 7+"= 4 -+4#164+%#$Y /0)&S $""S )& 2"=="# 2+"&&:2.,$.+4,,;S 74=),)%& "7$%# +%=4+C)#- $04$ &.20 4#1 &.20 4 20),1 W$4C%& 47$%+X 4 64+$)2.,4+ -+4#164+%#$ _#"$ "#,; ?%24.&% $0% 20),1 =4; ,""C ,)C% $04$ -+4#164+%#$S ?.$ ?%24.&% $0% 20),1 42$& ,)C% $04$ -+4#164+%#$`Y E0%# -+4#164+%#$& 4+% 4?&%#$ 7+"= $0% 74=),;S $0% 20),1+%# 04(% #" 4,$%+#4$)(% 7)-.+%& $" 4$$420 $"S 4#1 =4; ="+% %4&),; &.22.=? $" 6&;: 20","-)24, 1)77)2.,$)%& &.++".#1)#- $0%)+ +%,4$)"#&0)6 H)$0 "#% "+ ?"$0 "7 $0%)+ 64+%#$&Y /0)& 6+"2%&& )& 64+4,,%,%1S 4,&" H)$0 $0% 4?&%#2% "7 .#2,%& 4#1 4.#$& 7+"= $0% 74=),;S H0%# $0% )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),; +%6,42%& $0% &$%= 74=),;Y U"+ $0% ?+"$0%+& 4#1 &)&$%+& "7 $0% 64+%#$& 4,&" =4; ?%2"=% ,"()#- 7)-.+%& 4#1 )1%#$)7)24$)"# 7)-.+%& 7"+ $0% 20),1+%# )# $0% &$%= 74=),; &$+.2$.+%Y E)$0 $0% )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),;S $0)& ?%2"=%& )=6"&&: )?,%Y >#1S H)$0 $0% W"#,; 20),1X 74=),;S "+ $0% $H":20),1 74=),;S $0% 6"&&)?),)$)%& )# $0)& #%H )#&$)$.$)"#4, &$+.2$.+% ?%2"=% e.)$% ,)=)$%1Y WU4("+)$%X 4.#$& "+ .#2,%& "#2% =%4#$ 4 -+%4$ 1%4, $" 4 20),1 )# $%+=& "7 ,"()#- &.66"+$ 4#1 6&;20"4#4,;$)2 )1%#$)7)24$)"#Y U)#4,,;S -+4#164+%#$& "7$%# 6+"()1%1 %2"#"=)2 &.66"+$ 7"+ $0% &$%= 74=),;Y /0".-0 )$ )& &$),, $+.% $04$ =4#; -+4#164+%#$& 2"#$)#.% $" 6+": ()1% &.20 &.66"+$ 7"+ $0%)+ 20),1+%# 4#1 $0%)+ -+4#120),1+%#S )$ )& 4,&" %e.4,,; $+.% $04$ )# $"14;X& 0)-0:$%20 H"+,1S $0% -+4#164+%#$& H),, ?%2"=% 4# %2"#"=)2 4#1S "+S 4 =%1)24, ,)4?),)$;Y /04$ )&S H)$0 ="1%+# &4#)$4$)"#S #.$+)$)"#S 4#1 =%1)2)#% C%%6)#- $0% -+4#164+%#$& 4,)(% 7"+

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 A8

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f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b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`S $0%; +%=4)# )# $0% H"+C H"+,1Y /0.&S $0% ="1%+# #.2,%4+ 74=),; )& #"$ 4 #.2,%4+ 74=),; )# $0% &4=% &%#&% $04$ 8LOT& >=%+)24# &"2)","-)&$& $0".-0$ "7 )$Y >-4)#S ,%$ .& %=604&)\% $04$ $"14;X& #.2,%4+ 74=),; )& =41% .6 "7 $H" H"+C)#- 64+: %#$& ^ $H" 0.&?4#1&S 4& )$ H%+%S 4#1 #" H)7%g /0% 0".&%H)7% +",% )& -"#%Y <)$0%+ $0% H"=4# &$),, 1"%& )$ )# 0%+ &64+% $)=% ^ 4#1 ?%2"=%& %R04.&$%1 _4#1 +%&%#$7.,` 7+"= $0)& W+",% "(%+,"41XS "+ $0% =4# 0%,6& 4#1 $0%; ?"$0

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

&04+% $0% 0".&%0",1 +",% ^ ?"$0 $0%# ?%2"=)#- %R04.&$%1 _4#1 +%&%#$: 7.,`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j" *4.," ^ "#% &0".,1 #"$ ?% &.+6+)&%1 $" 1)&2"(%+ $04$ $0%+% 04& ?%%# 4# %=%+-%#2% "7 20),1 $0%+46;S 74=),; $0%+46;S 1)("+2% 2".#&%,)#-S 4#1 "$0%+ &.20 ".$&)1% &.66"+$ 4-%#2)%& $" H0)20 $0% ="1%+# #.2,%4+ 2".6,% =.&$ $.+# 7"+ 0%,6S H0%# 74=),; 1;&7.#2$)"# $0+%4$%#& "#% "+ 4,, "7 $0% =%=?%+& "7 4# )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),; .#)$Y B%$ .& =4C% $0)#-& H"+&% ;%$Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 AD

AI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b.&$ 6,4)# +)1)2.,".&Y G"H $%%#& 04(% 4,H4;& 041 41b.&$: =%#$ 6+"?,%=&Y M$ )& 04+1 $" =4C% $0% $+4#&)$)"# 7+"= 20),10""1 $" 41.,$0""1 ^ b.&$ +%41 34+-4+%$ 3%41S +74,-. 7$ F.# ,- @%47%Y8 9"H%(%+S $0% $%%# 2.,$.+% ^ H0)20 04& &6+%41 $" $0% %#$)+% -,"?4, (),,4-% ?; H4; "7 $0% =4&& =%1)4 _4#1 #"H $0% M#$%+#%$`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b.4#4S 2"24)#%S 4#1 #%H W1%&)-#%+X 1+.-& &.20 4& W<2&$4&;X 4#1 (4+)".& 04,,.2)#"-%#&S 04(% ?%2"=% 2"=="#,; .&%1 4#1S .#7"+$.#4$%,;S 4,&" 4?.&%1Y F+)#C)#- $" %R2%&& )& 4,&" 4 -,"?4, $%%# 64$$%+#Y >,"#- H)$0 1+.-& 4#1 4,2"0",S $0% $%%#& 4,&" %R6%+)%#2% $0%)+ %=%+: -)#- &%R.4,)$; )# 4 ="+4,,; 2"#7.&)#- 4#"=)2 2"#1)$)"# _)# =4#; &"2)%: $)%&`Y /0% +%4&"# 7"+ $0% 2"#7.&)"# )# ="&$ ="1%+# &"2)%$)%& )& $04$ $0% 4-% "7 =4++)4-% 04& ?%%# 6"&$6"#%1 .#$), 2",,%-%S .#)(%+&)$;S "+ 4$ ,%4&$ -;=#4&).= 4#1 $+41% &20"",S 04(% ?%%# 2"=6,%$%1Y /0% 4(%+4-% 4-% "7 =4++)4-% 04& 2,)=?%1 7+"= 6.?%+$; 4="#- 2,4#&S $" 8Q )# $0% &$%= 74=),; &)$.4$)"#S 4#1 #"H $" AO "+ ",1%+ )# $0% )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),;Y ].$ 0"H 24# $%%#4-%+& 2"#$4)# $0%)+ &%R.4, 1%&)+%& .#$),

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# 2#$.%.*+34 &1 *##3.4#%2 1%&- *"# 3()/#.% 1.-+/7

$0% 4-% "7 AOV /0%; 24##"$S )# ="&$ 24&%&Y >#1S 0"H 24# $%%#4-%+&S %R6"&%1 $" $0% (%+; &%R; =4&& =%1)4 2.,$.+%S 2"#$4)# $0%)+ &%R.4, 1%&)+%& 4$ 4,,V /0%; 24##"$S )# ="&$ 24&%&Y /0% $%%#& 7)#1 $0%=&%,(%& )# 4 (%+; &%R; $%%#4-% H"+,1 2.,$.+%S H0%+%)# $0%; C#"H $0%; H),, #"$ =4++; .#$), 47$%+ $0%; -+41.4$% 7+"= %R$%#&)(% &20"",)#- _)# $0%)+ $H%#: $)%&`Y E)$0 ,)$$,% -.)14#2% 7+"= $0%)+ 64+%#$&S H0" 4+% ?"$0 H"+C)#- 4#1 .&.4,,; %=?4++4&&%1 $" $4,C H)$0 $0%)+ $%%# 4?".$ &%R _)# ="&$ ="1%+# 2.,$.+%&`S 4#1 H)$0 2"=6,%$% +%b%2$)"# 7+"= ="&$ "7 $0% H"+,1X& 20.+20%& ^ H0)20 %#()&)"# &%R.4, 42$)()$; "#,; H)$0)# $0% =4+)$4, +",%: &%$S 4#1 H0)20 04(% #"$ 42C#"H,%1-%1 $0% 1+4=4$)2 6"&$6"#%=%#$ "7 $0% =4+)$4, 4-% _7+"= 8Q $" AO`S $0% $%%#4-%+& 4+% ,%7$ ="&$,; 41+)7$Y M$ )& #" H"#1%+ $04$ =4#; $%%#& 42$:".$ &%R.4,,;S 2"=?)#)#- 1+)#C)#- 4#1 1+.-& H)$0 &%R.4, 42$)()$;S "+ %#b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i0%+ 0"+="#%&S 4#R)%$)%&S 74=),; )#$%+42$)"#&S %$2Y E04$ H% H)&0 $" %=604&)\% 0%+% )& $0% -+"H)#- #%%1 7"+ )#&$)$.$)"#4, &.66"+$& 7"+ $%%#4-%+& 7<13,9# $0% #.2,%4+ 74=),; &$+.2$.+%Y /%%#4-%+& 4+% ,%7$ 4,"#% 1.+)#- $0% 47$%+:&20"", 0".+& )# ="+% 4#1 ="+% 74=),)%&S 4& ="+% H"=%# %#$%+ $0% H"+C 7"+2% 4#1 4& ="+% -+4#164+%#$& 1)&466%4+ 7+"= $0% 74=),; 2"=6,%RY WB4$20C%; C)1&XS H0" ,%$ $0%=&%,(%& )#$" $0%)+ 0"=%&S 4#1 %R)&$ H)$0".$ &.6%+()&)"#S 2".,1 ?%2"=% $0% #"+=Y f#,; $0% $%,%()&)"# 4#1 $0%)+ 7+)%#1& %R)&$ $" C%%6 $0%= 2"=64#;Y M# &.20 4 &)$.4: $)"# $0% )#7,.%#2% "7 $0% $%,%()&)"# 6+"-+4==)#-S $0% H"+,1 $%%# 2.,$.+%S 4#1 $0% 6%%+ -+".6 ?%2"=% 0%)-0$%#%1 4#1 $0)& )& "22.++)#- 7+"= /"C;" $" 3"&2"HS 7+"= B"& >#-%,%& $" >=&$%+14=S 7+"= K)" $" >$0%#&Y 5"2)","-)24, &.+(%;& )# $0% N5> &0"H $04$ 20),1+%# H0" $.+# $" "$0%+ 6%%+& 4#1 $0% =%1)4S ="+% $04# $" $0%)+ 64+%#$&S %#-4-% )# ="+%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 AO

W1%,)#e.%#$X ?%04()"+' (4#14,)&=S 1+.- 4#1 4,2"0", 4?.&%S )#466+"6+)4$% "+ .#6+"$%2$%1 &%R.4,)$;S 4#1 &" "#Y [%$ $0)& )& ?%2"=)#- 4 H"+,1 $+%#1Y f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d464#S $0% +)&)#1)("+2% +4$% 04& 7.+$0%+ &6,)#$%+%1 $0% 4,+%41; H%4CS )&",4$%1S #.2,%4+ 74=),;Y E)$0 1)("+2% 04& 2"=% $0% &)#-,%:64+%#$ 74=),;Y >#1 $0% 7.+$0%+ 6+"?,%= "7 +%=4++)4-% 04& 2+%4$%1 ="+% 2"=6,%R 6+"?,%=& +%,4$)#- $" &$%6:64+%#$)#- 4#1 &$%6 &)?,)#-&Y /0% =4b"+)$; "7 &)#-,%:64+%#$ 74=),)%& 4+% H"=4#:2%#$%+%1 ^ $0% =%# 741% 4H4; 7+"= $0%)+ 74=),; +%&6"#&)?),)$)%&Y ].$S 24# 4 H"=4# H"+C 4#1 +4)&% 20),1+%# "# 0%+ "H#V /0% %2"#"=)2S &"2)4,S 4#1 6&;20","-)24, &$+%&& 4+% %#"+=".& )# &.20 24&%&Y /0% 2+%4$)"#S ?; 1)("+2%S "7 &" =4#; &)#-,%:64+%#$ 74=),)%& H"+,1:H)1%S 4#1 $0% 1)77%+%#$ ?.$ 2"+",,4+; 60%: #"=%#"# "7 6+%:=4+)$4, 6+%-#4#2; 4="#- $%%#4-% -)+,&S 04& ,%1 $" 4 =4b"+ $+%#1 $"H4+1 7%=4,%:2%#$%+%1 &)#-,%:64+%#$ 74=),)%&Y f?()".&,;S $0)& )& 4# )#41%e.4$% 74=),; .#)$S ?"$0 6&;20","-)24,,; 4#1 %2"#"=)24,,;Y 5)#-,% ="$0%+&S $0%+%7"+%S #%%1 &.66"+$ )# $%+=& "7 20),1: 24+% )#&$)$.$)"#&S b"?:$+4)#)#-S 4#1 0%4,$0 24+%Y ].$S $0%; 4,&" #%%1 %="$)"#4, &.66"+$ 7+"= 7+)%#1&0)6 -+".6&S 4#1 $0%+46; -+".6&Y <(%# $0% &20"",& ?%2"=% )#(",(%1 )# 6+"()1)#- ?+%4C74&$S ,.#20S 4#1 47$%+: &20"", 6+"-+4=& 7"+ 20),1+%# "7 &)#-,%:64+%#$ 74=),)%&Y M7 $0% 1)("+2% +4$% )& (%+; 0)-0S 4#1 )$ )& +)&)#- )# =4#; 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#&S $0% +%=4++)4-% +4$% )& 4,&" e.)$% 0)-0 ^ 4#1 $0)& )& 4 -""1 $0)#-g 9"H%(%+S H04$ )& $0% +",% "7 4 &$%674$0%+ "+ &$%6="$0%+V M& )$ $0% &4=% 4& $0% 64+%#$4, +",%V 50".,1 )$ ?% &04+%1 H)$0 $0% ?)","-)24, 64+%#$V M# H04$ 6+"6"+$)"#&V 4#1S H),, $0% )#2%&$ $4?"" 0",1 )# $0% &4=% &%#&%Y Y Y Y &)=),4+,; H)$0 &$%6:?+"$0%+& 4#1 :&)&$%+&V /0% )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),; H)$0 $0% 1.4, 24+%%+ 2".6,%Y Y Y Y /0% &)#-,% 64+%#$ 74=),;Y Y Y Y /0% +%2"#&$)$.$%1 &$%6:74=),;Y Y Y Y /+".?,% )# $0% -,"?4,

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 AQ

(),,4-% ^ $+".?,% H0)20 04&S 4#1 H),,S %#$4), $0% %&$4?,)&0=%#$ "7 6%+=4#%#$ ".$&)1% )#&$)$.$)"#& $" 6+"()1% $0% 7.#2$)"#& $04$ $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),; "#2% 6+"()1%1Y B%$ .& =4C% $0% &)$.4$)"# H"+&%Y

U+"= <(%D $" $0% !0)#%&% H"=%# H0"&% 7%%$ H%+% ?".#1S H"=%# 04(% ?%%# &.?"+1)#4$%1S 0.=),)4$%1S 4#1 &"=%$)=%& =.$),4$%1Y /0% 41(4#2% "7 =),)$4+; $%20#)e.%& 1%(%,"6%1 ?; =%# 4#1 $0% 1+4&$)2 )#2+%4&% )# H4+74+% )# $0% 4#2)%#$ H"+,1 H"+&%#%1 $0% &$4$.& "7 H"=%# )# $0% %=6)+% 4+%4& "7 $0% H"+,1Y U.+$0%+="+%S $0% %4+,; W7%+$),)$;X +%,)-)"#&S H0)20 7"2.&%1 "# 4-+)2.,: $.+4, +%#%H4, 4#1 0.=4# +%6+"1.2$)"# 4#1 H0)20 7%4$.+%1 4 64#$0%"# "7 -"1& 4#1 -"11%&&%& ^ H)$0 $0% %4+$0 -"11%&& 4#1 6+)%&$%&&%& e.)$% 2%#$+4,I ^ H%+% +%6,42%1 H)$0 ="#"$0%)&$)2 +%,)-)"#& 4& 2)(),)\4$)"#& 6+"-+%&&%1Y M$ 24# ?% 4+-.%1 $04$ $0% H"+,1 +%,)-)"#& ^ H)$0 $0%)+ &$+)2$ ="+4, 2"1%& ^ H%+% %$0)24,,; &.6%+)"+ $" $0% 7%+$),)$; +%,)-)"#&S H0)20 "7$%# )#2,.1%1 0.=4# &42+)7)2%& 4#1 "+-)4&$)2 &%R.4, +)$%&S ?.$ $0%; H%+% 4,&" =4,%: 1"=)#4#$ )# $0% %R$+%=%Y /0%; 7%4$.+%1 $0% W74$0%+ -"1X 4#1 H%+% 6.+(%;%1 ?; =4,% 6+)%&$0""1& %R2,.&)(%,;Y U+"= d.14)&= $" !0+)&$)4#)$; $" ].110)&= 4#1 .,$)=4$%,; H)$0 M&,4=S $0% &.?"+1)#4$)"# "7 H"=%# H4& 1%=4#1%1Y 9"H%(%+S M&)&S M&0$4+S >60: +"1)$%S 4#1 >$0%#4 04(% ?%%# +%?"+# H)$0 $0% H"=%#X& ,)?%+4$)"# ="(%: =%#$ "7 $0% ="1%+# H"+,1Y 9"H 04& $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=; 04&$%#%1 $0% ,)?%+4$)"# "7 H"=%#V 9)-0:$%20 H"+C )& WH0)$% 2",,4+X H"+CS "77)2% H"+CS =%#$4, H"+CS &%+: ()2% H"+CY 9)-0:$%20 H"+C 1"%& -71 +%e.)+% ?+.$% &$+%#-$0S #"+ 1"%& )$ "22.+ )# 4# %#()+"#=%#$ $04$ 2".,1 ?% 1%$+)=%#$4, $" 6+%-#4#$ H"=%#X& 0%4,$0Y M# &0"+$S 0)-0:$%20 H"+C )& &47%S 2,%4# 4#1 =%#$4,Y E"=%# H%+% 1+4H# )#$" $0)& #%H -,"?4, H0)$%:2",,4+ H"+C H"+,1 ^ 4$ 7)+&$S 7"+ $0% H+"#- +%4&"#' $0%; 2".,1 ?% .#1%+64)1Y /0%#S $0%; H%+% 1+4H# )# 7"+ $0% +)-0$ +%4&"#' $0%; 1)1 %e.4,,; -""1 H"+C 4& =%#Y E0%# 2",,%-% 4#1 .#)(%+&)$; %1.24$)"# ?%24=% "6%# $" H"=%#S H"=%# ?%-4# $" 1%=4#1 7.,, +%2"-#)$)"# )# $0% 24+%%+ H"+,1S 4#1 %e.4, &4,4+; 7"+ %e.4, H"+CY E"+,1:H)1%S 4$ %(%+; ,%(%, "7 H"+C ^ 7+"= 0)-0:$%20 %,%2$+"#)2 4&&%=: ?,; 742$"+)%& $" =4#4-%+)4, 4#1 6+"7%&&)"#4, "+-4#)\4$)"#& ^ H"=%# 04(% %#$%+%1 $0% H"+C H"+,1Y >#1S $0)& )& -""1S )&#X$ )$V E04$X& $0% 6+"?,%=V /0%+% 4+%S .#7"+$.#4$%,;S =4#; 6+"?,%=& )#(",(%1S 4#1 $0%&% 6+"?,%=& 2+"6 .6 )# %(%+; 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# 4/&;./ 4#3'#% 8.%

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`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b"?Y E0%# =%# 4#1 H"=%# H"+C $"-%$0%+S ,.#20 $"-%$0%+S ()&)$ ?4+& $"-%$0%+ ^ 4#1 $0)& )& 4 $+4#&:#4$)"#4, 60%#"=%#"#S $0".-0 )$ )& &,"H%+ $" 1%(%,"6 )# d464# 4#1 d"+14# $04# )# @%+=4#; 4#1 $0% N5> ^ H04$ &0".,1 $0% 1%2"+.= ?% ?%$H%%# $0% &%R%&V M& 7,)+$4$)"# 4,,"H4?,%V 9"H =.20' #"#%S &"=%V /0% 6+"?,%= "7 &%R.4, 04+4&&=%#$ 04& ?%2"=% 4 -,"?4, 6+"?,%= &%%C)#- -,"?4, 1%7)#)$)"#& 4#1 -,"?4, &",.$)"#&Y 50".,1 $0%+% ?% (4+)4?,% 1%7)#)$)"#& ^ &0".,1 M$4,)4# =%# ?% 4,,"H%1 ="+% ,%%H4; $04# ]+)$)&0 =%#S ?%24.&% "7 $0% 2.,$.+4, "+)%#$4$)"# $"H4+1& 7,)+$4$)"# )# M$4,;V 5%R.4, 04+4&&=%#$ ^ 1%7)#%1 4& $0% .&% "7 b"?:&.6%+)"+)$; $" 7"+2% &%R "# 4 H"=4# _"+ 4 =4#` ^ )& #"$ 422%6$4?,% )# 4#; 2.,$.+%S 4#1 24##"$ 04(% 4 (4+)4?,% 1%7)#)$)"# )# 4#; 2.,$.+%Y 9"H%(%+S $0% -+4; 4+%4& 1" 4?".#1 ?%$H%%# ?,4$4#$ &%R.4, 04+4&&=%#$ 4#1 7,)+$4$)"#Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% $%#&)"# ?%$H%%# $0% &%R%& 2"#$)#.%& $" %R)&$ )# $0% b"?: H"+,1Y /0)+1,;S H"+,1:H)1%S =%# 4+% $0+%4$%#%1 ?; H"=%#X& 41(4#2%=%#$Y M7 H"=%# 4+% -4)#)#- 6"H%+ 4#1 H%4,$0S $0%# =%# 7%%, $04$ $0%; =.&$ ?% ,"&)#- )$Y 34,% 2"+6"+4$% %R%2.$)(%& ?,"2C 7%=4,% %R%2.$)(%& 7+"= $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

$"6 =4#4-%=%#$ 6"&)$)"#& _$0% W-,4&& 2%),)#-X`Y 3%# 6.+6"&%,; 04+4&& 7%=4,% %=6,";%%&S 0"6)#- $" 6+%(%#$ $0%= 7+"= 7%%,)#- 2"=7"+$4?,% )# $0%)+ H"+CY U.+$0%+S =%# ^ -,"?4,,; ^ 04(% ?%2"=% "?&%&&%1 H)$0 H%)-0$:,)7$)#4#1 &$%+")1& _H0)20 4+% ,%-4, $" .&% )# <.+"6% 4#1 %4&; $" -%$ )# $0% N5>`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d.14)&=Y M# ?"$0 "7 $0%&%S H"=%# 4+% ?%2"=)#- 7.,,; 422%6$%1 4& %e.4,& $" =%#Y E"=%# 04(% ?%2"=% =)#)&$%+& 4#1 +4??)&Y E"=%# 04(% b")#%1 )# $0% &%+()2%& 4,"#- H)$0 =%#S %#-4-)#- )# +)$.4,&S 6+4;%+&S &%+="#&S %$2Y f# $0% "$0%+ %#1 "7 $0% &6%2$+.=S H% 7)#1 $0% !4$0",)2 !0.+20 4#1 M&,4=Y /0% *"6% _8LLL`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 AL

#"H 1%=4#1%1 "7 $0%=S 4#1 H)$0 $0% 2"#7,)2$)#- #"+=& "7 =4,% =420)&=" 4#1 &%#&)$)()$; 1%=4#1%1 "7 $0% #%H 0.&?4#1& 4#1 H)(%&Y U"+ )#&$4#2%S )# =%#X& ?4$0+""=& 4,"#- >=%+)24X& )#$%+&$4$% 0)-0H4;& 4#1 4$ &6"+$& 4+%#4&S $0%+% 4+% #"H ?4?;X& 204#-)#- $4?,%&g 9)-0:$%20 2"+6"+4$)"#& 04(% 041 $" 6+"()1% 20),1 24+% .#)$&S "77%+ 1)("+2% 2".#&%,)#-S %&$4?,)&0 &%R.4, 04+4&&=%#$ +.,%&S 4#1 %&$4?,)&0 ?"4+1& $" b.1-% &%R.4, 04+4&&=%#$ 24&%&Y >,, "7 $0%&% 6+"-+4=& 04(% %=%+-%1 7+"= $0% H"=%#X& ,)?%+4$)"# 6+"2%&&S H0)20 04& ?%2"=% 4 H"+,1 $+%#1Y >#1S )#&$)$.$)"#4, +%&6"#&%& $" $0%&% 6+"?,%=& 04(% 4,&" %=%+-%1Y /" &.= .6S $0%#' $0% W#%%1&X "7 ="1%+# H"=%# 4#1 =%# %=%+-)#7+"= $0% W-%#1%+ H4+X 04(% &64H#%1 4 &%$ "7 &%+()2%& 4$$%#1)#- $" $0)& &)$.4$)"# )# =4#; 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$)%&Y /0".-0 &"=% &"2)%$)%&S &.20 4& d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d.14)&=S !0+)&$)4#)$;S M&,4=S 9)#1.)&=S ].110)&= 4#1 "$0%+ (4+)4#$& ^ 4,, 04(% ?%%# 2,4&0)#- H)$0 $0% #%H &"2)4, +%4,)$; "7 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$;Y /0% &$4$.& "7 H"=%# )# $0%&% =4,%:1"=)#4$%1 +%,)-)"#& 04& ?%%# 4 204,,%#-% $" $0%)+ (4,.%&a $0% 4,$%+%1 74=),; 64$$%+#S H)$0 ?)+$0 2"#$+", 4#1 74=),; 6,4##)#-S 04& ?%%# 6+"?,%=4$)24, 7"+ $0%=a $0% &$4$.& "7 $0% %,1%+,; 4#1 $0% ;".#- ^ ?%)#- +%(%+&%1 )# +%(%+%#2%S $0% ;".$0:2.,$.+% +%6,42)#- $0% 2.,$.+% "7 $0% H)&1"= "7 $0% 4-%1 ^ 04& ?%%# 2"#7.&)#- 7"+ $0%=a &%R.4,)$; ^ ?%7"+%S 1.+)#-S 4#1 47$%+ =4++)4-% ^ 04& 204#-%1S H0),% =4,% 0"="&%R.4,)$; 4#1 ,%&?)4#)&= 4+% #"H "6%#,; 6+"2,4)=%1a 6+)(4$% H%4,$0 422.=.,4$)"#&S H)$0".$ 204+)$;S 4+% %#2".+4-%1S %(%# 7,4.#$%1Y >,, $0%&%S 4#1 &" =4#; ="+% 204#-%& 04(% 204,,%#-%1 $0% H"+,1X& =4b"+ +%,)-)"#&Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ H04$ $0% -,"?4, %2"#"=; 24++)%& H)$0)# )$ ^ 4,"#- H)$0 )$& 6+"1.2$)(% 24642)$; ^ $04$ 4,$%+& ".+ ?4&)2 ?%,)%7 &;&$%= ^ $04$ 4,$%+& ".+ 2"#2%6$)"#& "7 $0% .#)(%+&%S &"2)%$; 4#1 ".+&%,(%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 D8

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d464#S ]+)$4)#S U+4#2%S K.&&)4S H),, 2"==.#)24$% H)$0 %420 "$0%+ )# 6.+&.)$ "7 =.$.4, +%&%4+20 )#$%+%&$&Y /0%; H),, 2"==.#)24$% 1)+%2$,;S 4$ 2"#7%+%#2%& 4#1 $0+".-0 b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@)+#3)#A *"# -.22 -#'+.A .3' -&%./ -./.+2#

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d.14)&=S !0+)&$)4#)$;S M&,4=S 7)#1 $0%=&%,(%& %=?4$$,%1S H0),% 9)#1.)&= 4#1 ].110)&= 04(% 4,&" 7%,$ $0% &041"H "7 &2)%#2% 1)= $0%)+ ,)-0$Y /H" H"+,1 $+%#1& 04(% "22.++%1 H0)20 4+% 2"=6,%$%,; 2"#$+41)2$"+;S ?.$ ;%$ 7.,,; .#1%+&$4#14?,%' $0% H"+,1X& 6%"6,% ^ $0% 2)$)\%#& "7 $0% #%H -,"?4, (),,4-% ^ 04(% ?%2"=% ="+% +4$)"#4,:=)#1%1 4#1 ,%&& $0%","-)24,S H0),% 4$ $0% &4=% $)=% $0%; 04(% ?%2"=% ="+% =;&$)24, 4#1 +%$.+#%1 $" $0% )++4$)"#4, &.6%+&$)$)"#& "7 $0% 64&$YP f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 DD

/0% WH"+,1 H)1% H%?X "7 2"==.#)24$)"#& =%1)4 )& "#,; )# )$& )#74#2;Y [%$S 4,+%41;S 6%"6,% 4,, "(%+ $0% H"+,1 24# $4,C $" %420 "$0%+ ?; 2"=: 6.$%+S ?; $%,%60"#%S 4#1 &""# ?; 2"=6.$%+:$%,%()&)"#:$%,%60"#% &;&$%=&Y >,+%41;S 4 ="()% &$4+ H),, ?% +%2"-#)\%1 4#1 ="??%1 )# /"C;"S G)2%S ]%+,)#S "+ 5$ *%$%+&?.+-Y K"2C &$4+& 4+% )#$%+#4$)"#4,,; C#"H#S J%);%1&( )& "-,%1 ?; /c ()%H%+& 7+"= F.?+"(#)C $" U)b)Y /0% H"#1%+7., $0)#- 4?".$ $0% =4&& =%1)4 ^ ="()%&S $%,%()&)"#S c!K $46%&S Fc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cS +"2C =.&)2S 4#1 ()1%"24&&%$$%&Y /0% "$0%+ 6+"?,%= )& $0% >=%+)24# ^ WE%&$: %+#X ^ 2.,$.+4, #"+=& 4#1 (4,.%& H0)20 1"=)#4$% $0% =%1)4 ?%24.&% "7 $0% >=%+)24# #%4+:="#"6",; "7 6+"1.2$)"# "7 =%1)4 6+"-+4==)#-Y /0% 7)+&$ 6+"?,%= ^ $04$ "7 &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% ^ 4#1 ,%$ .& ,""C 4$ &%R 7)+&$ ^ %&6%2)4,,; $+".?,%& #4$)"#& $04$ 4+% ="+% 6.+)$4#)24, )# "+)%#$4$)"#Y M# $0%&% &"2)%$)%&S $0% %R6,)2)$ &%R.4,)$; 4#1 &%R ".$&)1% =4++)4-% ()",4$% $0%)+ 1%%6%&$ &%R.4, ="+%&Y G4$)"#& ,)C% M+4# 04(% $+)%1 $" ?4# $%,%()&)"# 4#1 ="()%& 2"=6,%$%,; _.#&.22%&&7.,,;g`Y >#1 )# $0% N5>S &=4,,:$"H# *+"$%&$4#$ 7.#14=%#$4,)&$& 04(% $+)%1 $" 7"+2% 9",,;H""1 $" &$"6 6+"1.: 2)#- &%R.4,,; "+)%#$%1 =4$%+)4,Y >#1S 74),)#- $04$S $0%; 04(% 4$$%=6$%1 $" 6+%(%#$ $0%)+ 20),1+%# 7+"= &%%)#- )$Y _M# $0% N5>S $0% )#(%#$)"# 4#1 41"6$)"# "7 $0% Wc 20)6XS H0)20 24# ?,"2C 2%+$4)# 24?,% /c 204##%,& %#$)+%,;S "+ 24# ?,"2C &6%2)7)2 6+"-+4==)#-S 04& ?%%# 6+"="$%1 ?; $0% 6.+)$4#)24, )#$%+%&$ -+".6&Y` <(%# ,%&& 6.+)$4#)24, #4$)"#&S &.20 4& U+4#2% 4#1 M$4,;S 7)#1 $0% ,)#C)#"7 &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% ^ H0)20 &%%=& $" $;6)7; 9",,;H""1 6+"1.2$)"#& ^

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# -.22 -#'+. .3' *"# 4/&;./ )(/*(%# 8.%

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f0)"S "66"#%#$& "7 $0% 2"#$%#$ "7 $0% =4&& =%1)4 04(% $+)%1 $" 1%7%#1 $0%)+ 2.,$.+% 7+"= $0% %+"&)"# %#-%#1%+%1 ?; $0% =4&& =%1)4Y /0% 742$ )&S $0".-0S $04$ 1(# &(,29"#- ^ +4)&%1 "# $0% =%1)4S ,"()#- $0% =%1)4S &$%%6%1 )# $0% =%1)4 _?%;"#1 $0%)+ 64+%#$X& 4?),)$)%& 4& H%,, 4& 1%&)+%&`S ,"41%1 H)$0 =%1)4:-%#%+4$%1 -4=%&S $";& 4#1 !F +"=&S 4#1 )1",)\)#- $0% =%1)4 &$4+& 4#1 2%,%?+)$)%& ^ 04(% ?%%# 37&,%2,K#9 $" $0% =4&& =%1)4 4#1 04(% 4?&"+?%1 &"=% "7 $0% #"+=& 4#1 (4,.%& )# $0% =%1)4S 4#1 ,9#-1,$,#9 H)$0 $0% &$4+& 4#1 $0%)+ ,)7%&$;,%Y /0% W2.,$.+% H4+X )&S )# 64+$S $0%#S 4 -%#%+4$)"# H4+ ?%$H%%# $%%#& 4#1 41.,$&S 64+%#$& 4#1 20),1+%#Y M$ 24# 4,&" ?% 4 H4+ 4-4)#&$ >=%+)24# )#7,.%#2%S 4& )# M&,4=)2 #4$)"#& 4#1 >&)4# #4$)"#&S &.20 4& 5)#-46"+%Y M$ 24# %(%# ?% 4 H4+ ?%$H%%# &=4,,:$"H#%+& 4#1 .+?4#)$%& 2",,)1)#- )# $0% =.&0+""=)#- &.?.+?& 4+".#1 $0% H"+,1Y >#1S 7)#4,,;S )$ )& 4 H4+ ?%$H%%# $0% 1%%6,; +%,)-)".& ^ "7 4,, +%,)-)"#& ^ 4#1 $0% W-"1,%&&X 4="+: 4,)$; "7 $0% 9",,;H""1 6+"1.2$)"#&Y M# $0)& 2"#$%R$S H% H)&0 $" %=604&)\% $04$S -,"?4,,;S $0% %+"&)"# "7 2.,$.+4, #"+=& 04& "22.++%1S 4#1 $04$ ^ 4,"#- H)$0 $0% &%4+20 7"+ #%H +%,)-)".& %$0)2& 4#1 &%2.,4+ %$0)2& ^ 4 C)#1 "7 &"2)":64$0)2 ="+4, =4,4)&% 04& %#-.,7%1 $0% -,"?4, (),,4-%S %&6%2)4,,; $0% ;".#-%+ -%#%+4$)"#Y /0% 6%"6,% "7 $0% -,"?4, (),,4-% H),, "7$%# 42$ =4+(%,".&,; ="+4,,;' $0%; H),, &%#1 7""1 $" <$0)"6)4 H0%# $0%+% )& 4 1+".-0$a $0%; H),, 0%,6 %4+$0e.4C% ()2$)=& )# >+=%#)4 "+ d464# "+ !0)#4 "+ !0),%a $0%; H),, &4(%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

20),1+%# 4#1 )=6+"(% $0%)+ 0%4,$0 4#1 %1.24$)"#a $0%; H),, &$"6 -%#": 2)1% )# [.-"&,4()4 4#1 K.4#14:].+.#1)Y 9"H%(%+S $0%; H),, 4,&" 20%4$ 4#1 &$%4, )7 $0%; 24# -%$ 4H4; H)$0 )$a -%$ W0)-0X H0%# $0%; 4+% 4#R)".&a $+%4$ 2+)=)#4,& ,%#)%#$,; )# $0% 2".+$&S %(%# H0%# $0%; 4+% =.+1%+%+& _W%=64$0)\)#-XS +4$0%+ $04# W="+4,)\)#-XS "# $0%)+ ="$)(%& 7"+ =.+1%+`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b.&$ 4& $0%; 2".,1 #"$ 0%,6 $0%)+ 20),1+%# H)$0".$ %R6%+$ =%1)24,:0%4,$0 )#$%+(%#: $)"#Y 9.&?4#1& 4#1 H)(%& =4; #"$ ?% 4?,% $" &4(% $0%)+ =4++)4-%&S "+ +%,4$% 6+"6%+,; $" $0%)+ 20),1+%# 47$%+ 4 1)("+2%S H)$0".$ %R6%+$ $0%+4: 6%.$)2 0%,6Y *4+%#$& =4; #"$ ?% 4?,% $" 6+%(%#$ "+ $+%4$ 4 $%%#4-% 20),1 "# 1+.-& "+ 4$$%=6$)#- &.)2)1%S 4-4)#S H)$0".$ &2)%#$)7)2 $0%+46%.$)2 6+"7%&&)"#4, &.66"+$Y /0% 1%2,)#% "7 $0% W6+)=4+; )#&$)$.$)"#&XS $04$ )&S 74=),; 4#1 +%,)-)"#S )# $0% 0)-0 $%20#","-; H"+,1S 04& -%#%+4$%1 $0% #%%1 7"+ 4 &%$ "7 W&%2"#14+; )#&$)$.$)"#&X $" 7),, $0% -46 H0%+% 74=),; +",%& 4#1 +%,)-)".& )#&$)$.$)"#& 4#1 #"+=& #" ,"#-%+ &.77)2% "+ #" ,"#-%+ %R)&$ )# $0% &4=% 7"+= 4& $0%; "#2% 1)1Y /0% 60%#"=%#"# "7 74=),; 1%2,)#%S 7+"= %R$%#1%1 2,4# $" 1.4,:24+%%+ 2".6,%& "+ %(%# &)#-,%:64+%#$ .#)$&S )& H"+,1:H)1%S 4& )& $0% 1%2,)#% "7 $+41)$)"#4, H"+,1:+%,)-)"#&S 2"#2%6$)"#& 4#1 +)$.4,&Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% &"2)4, 6+"?,%=& "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& H0)20 H% 04(% 1%&2+)?%1S H),, -%#%+4$% $0% #%%1 7"+ 4 &%$ "7 H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=& H"+,1:H)1%Y B%$ .& 2"#$)#.% ".+ 4#4,;&)& 4#1 1%&2+)6$)"# )# $0)& +%-4+1S 7"2.&)##"H "# &"=% ,%&& 0%4+$7%,$ 4,$%+4$)"#&S H0)20 4+% 2+)$)24, 4#1 $;6)24,S #"#%$0%,%&&Y

!"# #B*#32+&3 &1 #'().*+&3 +3 "+4"5*#)"3&/&47 2&)+#*7 M# 4 =.20 ,%&& 2"#$+"(%+&)4, (%)#S $0% %1.24$)"#4, #%%1& "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& 04(% %R64#1%1 1+4=4$)24,,; 4& $0% %2"#"=; 04& ="(%1

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 DO

)# 4 ="+% $%20#","-)24, 1)+%2$)"#Y /0% )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=; H4& 4,+%41; ,)#C%1 $" %#-)#%%+)#- 4#1 &2)%#$)7)2 )#(%#$)(%#%&&Y ].$S #"HS $0%+% 04& ?%%# 4 e.4#$.= ,%46 ^ )7 M =4; 6.# =; =%$460"+ ^ )# &2)%#$)7)2 4#1 $%20#","-)24, ()+$."&)$;Y M# 6+%64+4$)"# 7"+ $0% 24+%%+ H"+,1S $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& =.&$ ?% 7,.%#$ )# 2"=6.$%+:.&%Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% $%420)#- "7 2"=6.$%+ .&4-% =.&$ "22.+ %4+,; )# $0% &20"",)#- 6+"2%&&Y M# "+1%+ $" ?% W2"=6.$%+ ,)$%+4$%XS 4 -""1 1%4, "7 =4$0%=4$)2& 4#1 ,)$%+4+; &"60)&$)24$)"# )& 1%=4#1%1Y > &$+"#- 742),)$; 7"+ W#.=?%+:2+.#20)#-X 4#1 W60+4&%:$.+#: )#-X )& #%2%&&4+; 7"+ &.22%&& "# $0% b"? )# $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;Y 52)%#2%S =4$0S ,4#-.4-%S 4#1 ,)$%+42; H%+% 4,H4;& 64+$ "7 $0% %1.24: $)"#4, &;&$%=Y 9"H%(%+S )# $0% 64&$S $0% =4b"+)$; H"+C)#- 2,4&& "#,; #%%1%1 =)#)=4, &C),,& )# $0%&% 4+%4&Y G"HS $0% =4b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e.%&$)"#& "7 2"&$S 422%&& 4#1 2.++)2.,4 H),, ?%2"=% 0"$ 6",)$)24, )&&.%&Y *+%&&.+% 7"+ 6+%&20"", 6+"-+4=& %=4#4$%& 7+"= $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

1%=4#1& "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;S )# $0% &%#&% $04$ $0% ="1%+# H"+C%+ =.&$ ?% %1.24$)"#4,,; 6+%64+%1 7"+ $%20#)24,S 6+"7%&&)"#4,S 4#1 H0)$%:2",,4+ H"+CY E% &0".,1 4,&" =4C% )$ 2,%4+ $04$ $0% )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),; 4#1 1.4,: 24+%%+ 2".6,% %#-%#1%+ 4#"$0%+ ,)#% "7 6+%&&.+% 7"+ 6+%&20"", 6+"-+4=&Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% 20),1:24+% )#&$)$.$)"#& 4#1 $0% %1.24$)"#4, )#&$)$.$)"#& 2"#(%+-% 4$ $0)& 6")#$S -%#%+4$)#- H04$ )# $0% 7.$.+% 2".,1 ?% 4# %1.24: $)"#4, 4#1 20),1:24+% 2"=6,%R $04$ =)-0$ 04(% 4 =4b"+ )=642$ .6"# $0% 20),1X& &"2)4,)\4$)"# 4#1 )#$%,,%2$.4, 1%(%,"6=%#$Y <20"%& 7+"= *,4$"X& L#0 $"14;Y :%.'# 2)"&&/ *& "+4" 2)"&&/ #3%+)"-#3* $%&4%.-2 /0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=; #%%1& )#1)()1.4,& ?%$$%+ $+4)#%1 )# =4$0%=: 4$)2&S &2)%#2% 4#1 ,4#-.4-% &C),,& $04# 1)1 $0% )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=;Y /0%+%7"+%S 6+%&&.+% $" .6-+41% $0% &20"",& )# $0)& 4+%4 04& ?%%# =".#$: )#-Y M# d464# 4#1 K.&&)4S $0% &20"",& 04(% 4,+%41; .6-+41%1 $0% =4$0 4#1 &2)%#2% 2.++)2.,4 H)$0 -+%4$ &.22%&&Y /0% @%+=4# 4#1 "$0%+ <.+": 6%4# &20"",& 4,+%41; 041 &$+"#- =4$0 4#1 &2)%#2% 2"=6"#%#$&S ?.$ H%+% %,)$)&$S 2"#2%#$+4$)#- "# $0% -""1 &$.1%#$&Y >=%+)24# &20"",& 04(% #"$ 411%1 4# 41%e.4$% =4$0S &2)%#2%S 4#1 ,4#-.4-% 2"=6"#%#$ 4$ 4,,Y f.+ &.22%&&7., &$.1%#$& %)$0%+ 04(% 4# )##4$% 742),)$; 7"+ $0%&% &.?b%2$&S 4 &$+"#- 74=),; ?42C-+".#1 )# $0%=S "+ 4# 422)1%#$4, 4$$420=%#$ $" $0%= $0+".-0 4 64+$)2.,4+ $%420%+ "+ 2".+&% $04$ &$)=.,4$%1 $0%=Y U.+$0%+="+%S $0% 20),1+%# "7 !0)#%&%S Z"+%4#S d464#%&%S 4#1 K.&&)4#:d%H)&0 4#1 K.&&)4# )==)-+4#$& 1" 74+ ?%$$%+ $04# ".+ 0"=%-+"H# C)1& )# $0% =4$0 4#1 &2)%#2% &%e.%#2%&Y M# ]+)$4)#S 4& !Y*Y 5#"H88 04& H+)$$%#S $0%+% %R)&$& 4 &%64+4$)"# "7 $H" %1.24$)"#4, 2.,$.+%&' &2)%#2% 4#1 =4$0 ?%)#- &%64+4$%1 7+"= $0% 0.=4#: )$)%&S H)$0 $0% ,4$$%+ %=604&)\%1Y !4# $0%&% $H" %1.24$)"#4, 2.,$.+%& ?% 2"=?)#%1V E),, $0% %=604&)& &0)7$ $" &2)%#2% 4#1 =4$0S H0),% H%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 DQ

#%-,%2$ $0% 0.=4#)$)%&V E),, $%20#","-)24, )#(%#$)(%#%&& &.6%+&%1% W6.+% &2)%#2%XV /0% ]+)$)&0 04(% ?%%# 1%?4$)#- $0%&% 6+"?,%=& 7"+ $H" 1%241%& #"HY M# #4$)"#& H0%+% $0% =4$0S &2)%#2%S 4#1 ,4#-.4-% &%e.%#2%& 4+% (%+; &$+"#-S $0% 6+"?,%= )& )# ?+"41%#)#- $0% &.22%&& +4$% "7 $0% W4(%+4-%X &$.1%#$S ?%24.&% $0% W4(%+4-%X &$.1%#$ #"H #%%1& &.20 &C),,& $" &.22%%1 )# $0% ="+% $%20#)24, b"?:H"+,1 H0)20 04& %=%+-%1Y M# #4$)"#& H0%+% $0)& &%e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f#% 24# &%%S $0%#S $04$ $0% 2"#$%#$ "7 $0% %1.24$)"#4, .6-+41)#- 24# 4#1 H),, ?% 2"#$+"(%+&)4,Y 50".,1 H% %=604&)\% $%20#","-; 4$ $0% %R6%#&% "7 0)&$"+;S 60),"&"60; 4#1 ,)$%+4$.+%V !4# H% .6-+41% 4,, "7 $0%&% &.?b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` 4#1 $0%&% 24# -4)# "#% &.22%&&S $0% =4b"+)$; "7 $0% -""1 b"?& )# ="1%+# &"2)%$; 1%=4#1 4 2",,%-%:,%(%, %1.24$)"#Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

DJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

G"H $0)& %1.24$)"# %R$%#&)"# 2+%4$%& 4 1)77)2.,$ &%$ "7 6+"?,%=&' 24# ;". 6+%64+% %(%+; 20),1 $" &.22%%1 )# 2",,%-%V !4# ;". ="$)(4$% %(%+; 20),1 $" -" $" 2",,%-%V 50".,1 $0% 2",,%-%& ?%2"=% $%20#)24, 4#1 24+%%+ $+4)#)#- )#&$)$.$%&S "+ &0".,1 $0%; +%e.)+% $0% W2,4&&)24,X %1.24$)"# 7"+ H0)20 $0%; H%+% "+)-)#4,,; 7".#1%1V /0% 4#&H%+& $" $0%&% e.%&$)"#& 2".,1 %#-%#1%+ 4 (%+; 1)77%+%#$ e.4,)$; $" %420 &"2)%$; )# e.%&$)"#Y 5"=% &"2)%$)%& =4; ,%4# $"H4+1 #4++"H $%20#)24, 6+"7)2)%#2;S "$0%+& $"H4+1 ?+"41%+ W,)?%+4, 4+$&X -+".#1)#-S H0),% "$0%+& H),, +%e.)+% ?"$0 )# 1)77%+)#- 6+"6"+$)"#&Y E),, $0%+% ?% 4 -,"?4, $+%#1 4H4; 7+"= $0% ,)?%+4, 4+$& 4#1 $"H4+1 $%20#)24, 4#1 $%20:&2)%#2% ,%4+#)#- 4,"#%V /0)& 2".,1 "22.+S 4#1 )$ 2".,1 477%2$ ".+ 6",)$)24, 4#1 ="+4, "+1%+Y U"+ #4+: +"H,; $+4)#%1 $%20#"2+4$& 2".,1 ?%2"=% $0% W&.?b%2$&X "7 4 $%20#",": -)24,:4.$0"+)$4+)4# "+1%+S +4$0%+ $04# $0% W2)$)\%#&X "7 4 1%="2+42;Y <420 #4$)"# H),, 04(% $" 411+%&& $0%&% 6+"?,%=&Y 9"H%(%+S %(%+; #4$)"# 04& 041 $" %R$%#1 %1.24$)"# $" 4 H)1%+ 4#1 H)1%+ &%-=%#$ "7 )$& 6"6.,4$)"#Y M7 2",,%-%:,%(%, %1.24$)"# ?%2"=%& .#)(%+&4,S b.&$ 4& -+41% &20"", 4#1 0)-0 &20"", %1.24$)"# 04&S &0".,1 )$ ?% 7+%% ^ $04$ )&S 64)1 7"+ ?; $4R%&S ?.$ "77%+%1 %e.4,,; $" 4,, 2,4&&%& "7 &"2)%$;V M# =4#; #4$)"#&S &.20 4& $0"&% "7 <.+"6% 4#1 $0% 7"+=%+ 5"()%$ K%6.?,)2&S 2",,%-% )& 7+%%Y M# "$0%+ #4$)"#&S &.20 4& ]+)$4)# 4#1 $0% N5>S 2",,%-% $.)$)"# 2"&$& 4+% (%+; 0)-0Y >#1S "7 2".+&%S )# $0% N5>S 6+)(4$% %,)$% 2",,%-%& 204+-% =.20 0)-0%+ $.)$)"#& $04# $0% &$4$% .#)(%+&)$)%&Y M# $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&S 2",,%-% 2"&$& 4+% ?%-)##)#- $" ".$+.# $0% 4?),)$; "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&& $" 64; $0%=S H0),% )# <.+"6%S $0% #.=?%+ "7 &$.1%#$& e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 DL

0"H 0)-0 &0".,1 $0% &$4#14+1& ?%S 4#1S 24# H% 6+%64+% 4 ?+"41%+ 4#1 ?+"41%+ ?4&% "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"# 7"+ &.22%&& 4$ $0%&% 0)-0%+ ,%(%,& "7 %1.24$)"#V U)#4,,;S 4& 4 &"2)","-)24, 2"+",,4+;S )7 $0% =4b"+)$; "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"# 4$$%#1& 2",,%-% 4#1 -+41.4$% &20"",S 4#1 )7 $0%; 6"&$6"#% =4++)4-% .#$), 47$%+ -+41.4$)"#S H04$ 1" H% 1" H)$0 $0% %#"+=".&,; %R$%#1%1 W41",%&: 2%#$X &$4$.& "7 $0% &$.1%#$& H0" -+41.4$% ?%$H%%# AO 4#1 DT ;%4+& "7 4-%V E04$ 0466%#& $" 6+%:=4+)$4, &%R.4,)$;S 4 H"=4#X& W?)","-)24, 2,"2CX "7 20),1:?%4+)#- $)=%S ,"#-:$%+= 74=),; 1%6%#1%#2;S 4#1 %(%# 1%=": 2+4$)2 2)$)\%#&0)6S 1.+)#- $0)& &$4-% "7 %R$%#1%1 41",%&2%#$ &$4$.&V >-4)#S 4 &%$ "7 #%%1& =4; %#-%#1%+ 4 &%$ "7 &%+()2%& ^ )# $0)& 24&% &.++".#1)#- $0% 2",,%-% 4#1 .#)(%+&)$; )#&$)$.$)"#& ^ 411+%&&)#- ?"$0 %1.24$)"#4, 4#1 %="$)"#4, 6+"?,%=& &%$ )# ="$)"# ?; $0% #%H &"2)4, &$+.2$.+% "7 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$;Y

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e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a $0%+%7"+%S 1" ;". ,%$ $0%= 1)% "+ 1%-%#%+4$%S "+

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

IT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

1" ;". &%+()2% $0% 6""+ H)$0 $0% 7.,, 2"=6,%R "7 ="1%+# =%1)2)#%V M7 ;". 1" &%+()2% $0%=S H0" 64;& ^ $0% =)11,% 2,4&&S $0+".-0 $4R%&S $0% +)20 $0+".-0 60),4#$0+"6;S %=6,";%+& H0" %=6,"; 6""+ H"+C%+&V /0% =%1)24, 24+% "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 $0% 6""+ ?%2"=%& 6+"?,%=4$)24,S 4#1 %420 #4$)"# =.&$ =4C% 4# %2"#"=)2 4#1 ="+4, 20")2% 2"#2%+#)#- 0%4,$0 24+% &%+()2%& 4#1 0%4,$0 24+% 64;=%#$&Y /0% e.%&$)"# ?%2"=%&' 0"H 1" H% 64; 7"+ $0%&% &%+()2%&V F" H% 64; $0+".-0 $4R%&S $0+".-0 6+"-+%&&)(% $4R%& _0)-0 $4R%& "# $0% +)20`S $0+".-0 6+): (4$% )#&.+4#2% 6,4#& ^ )7 6+)(4$%S H04$ 6%+2%#$4-% &0".,1 ?% 64)1 ?; $0% %=6,";%% 4#1 %=6,";%+S 4#1 &0".,1 &.20 )#&.+4#2% ?% $+4#&7%+4?,% 7+"= "#% %=6,";%+ $" 4#"$0%+V 50".,1 6+)(4$% )#&.+4#2% "+ 6.?,)2 6,4#& "77%+ 7.,, 2"(%+4-% "+ 1%=4#1 64+$)4, 64;=%#$V 50".,1 1"2$"+& ?% "# &4,4+; "+ )# 6+)(4$% ?.&)#%&& 7"+ $0%=&%,(%&V 50".,1 2"&=%$)2 &.+-%+; ?% 2"(%+%1 ^ )& )$ W#%2%&&4+;XV >#1S H04$ "7 6&;20","-)24, 6+"?,%=&V E% 04(% 4,+%41; &.--%&$%1 $04$ ="1%+# &"2)%$; H),, H%4C%# =4++)4-% 4#1 74=),; ?"#1&Y /0%+%7"+%S &0".,1 %R$%+#4, 6&;20","-)24, &.66"+$ ?; $0%+46)&$& 4#1 -+".6 $0%+46)&$& ?% 2"(%+%1 ?; 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2%V 3%#$4, 0%4,$0 6+"?,%=& 4+% 4,+%41; 2"(%+%1S "+ 64+: $)4,,; 2"(%+%1S ?; ?"$0 6.?,)2 4#1 6+)(4$% 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6,4#&S &" ,%$ .& ,""C 7.+$0%+ 4$ $0)&Y ].$ ,%$ .& 4&&%+$ &$+"#-,; $04$ H0%$0%+ $0% #4$)"# )# e.%&$)"# 41"6$& $0% >=%+)24#:&$;,% 6+)(4$)\%1 =%1)2)#% 4#1 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 64$$%+#S "+ $0% @%+=4# &$;,% -"(%+#=%#$:+.# =%1)24, 4#1 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6+": -+4=&S 0%4,$0 &%+()2%& H),, 2"#$)#.% $" ?% )# -+%4$ 1%=4#1S 4#1 H),, ?% 4 &24+2% 4#1 %R6%#&)(% +%&".+2%Y !"# #B*#32+&3 &1 -#3*./ "#./*" 3##'2 .3' 2#%,+)#2 M# ".+ 1)&2.&&)"# "7 74=),; ?+%4C1"H# 4#1 -%#1%+ $%#&)"#&S H% &.-: -%&$%1 $04$ $0% )&",4$%1 #.2,%4+ 74=),;S $0% &)#-,%:64+%#$ 74=),;S 4#1 $0% &$%6:64+%#$ 74=),; 04(% %#-%#1%+%1 .#)e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 I8

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c 4#1 $0% M#$%+#%$V M7 $0% 64$$%+# H% 04(% 1%&2+)?%1 2"#$)#.%& ^ 4#1 #"?"1; )& $7" &.20 4 64$$%+# 4& &.20 ^ $0%# $0% $+%#1 $"H4+1 $0% %R$%#&)"# "7 =%#$4, 0%4,$0 &%+()2%& H),, 2"#$)#.%Y >#1S )7 $0% E%&$%+# <.+"6%4#& ^ %&6%2)4,,; $0% @%+=4#& ^ 4+% #%-4$)(% $" =%#$4, 0%4,$0 &%+()2%&S $0% <4&$%+# <.+"6%4#& 4+% 4&C)#- >=%+)24# 4#1 ]+)$)&0 6+"7%&&)"#4,& $" 0%,6 &%$ .6 &.20 &%+: ()2%&Y >#1S )7 $0% d464#%&% 4+% +%&)&$4#$ $" &.20 &%+()2%&S $0% !0)#%&% )# 9"#- Z"#-S /4)H4#S 504#-04)S 4#1 ]%)b)#- 4+% ?%2"=)#- )#2+%4&)#-,; 42$)(% )# %&$4?,)&0)#- &.20 =%#$4, 0%4,$0 &%+()2%&Y M7 =%#$4, 0%4,$0 &%+()2%& 4+% %&$4?,)&0%1S $0% &4=% e.%&$)"#& 4+)&% 4& H)$0 0%4,$0 &%+()2%& )# -%#%+4,Y 50".,1 &.20 &%+()2%& ?% 7.,,; 2"(%+%1 "+ 64+$)4,,; 2"(%+%1S 6.?,)2 "+ 6+)(4$%S %$2Y 5"=% 6+"()#2%& "7 !4#414 7.,,; 2"(%+ =%#$4, 0%4,$0 &%+()2%&S &"=% 1" #"$Y 5"=% >=%+)24# 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6+"-+4=& 04(% %R2%,,%#$ 2"(%+4-%S &"=% 1" #"$Y >#1S 7)#4,,;S $0% 2"&$ "7 =%#$4, 0%4,$0 &%+()2%& )& 0)-0S 4#1 )$ )#2+%4&%& 4& )$ )&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

IA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 H,-I#9 17 1(# ?,992# +2%33 ID

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

%R$%#1%1 $" -+".6 4#1 )#1)()1.4, &%$$)#-&S 4#1 4& $+4#e.),)\)#-S 4#$): 4#R)%$;S 4#$):1%6+%&&)(% 1+.-& ?%2"=% ?%$$%+ 1%(%,"6%1 4#1 ="+% H)1%,; .$),)\%1Y /0.& )# @%+=4#; H0%+% $0%+% )& ,%&& 6&;20"$0%+46; $04# )# U+4#2%S ="+% 1+.-& 4+% 1)&6%#&%1 ?; 1"2$"+& ^ 4#1 $0% 1+.-& &$),, 04(% $" ?% 64)1 7"+Y

9"H%(%+S $0% $H)# 6+"?,%=& "7 +%1.2%1 .6H4+1 ="?),)$; _2"=64+%1 $" $0% +%&$ "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&` 4#1 ,%&&%+ b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`Y >& H% &04,, &0"HS $0%+% )& &"=% "(%+,46 ?%$H%%# $0% #%%1& "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& 4#1 $0"&% "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S ?.$ $0%+% 4+% 4,&" &6%2)7)2 1)77%+%#2%& )# $0%&% 64$$%+#& 4& H%,,Y >#1S )=6"+$4#$,;S &)#2% $0% .#1%+: 2,4&& )& 6",)$)24,,;S %2"#"=)24,,;S 4#1 &"2)4,,; ,%&& 6"H%+7., $04# $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S $0% #%%1& "7 $0)& 2,4&& =4; ?% ,%&& 24+%7.,,; 4$$%#1%1 $"Y >-4)#S H% &04,, 4+-.% $04$ $0% H4; )# H0)20 $0% #%%1& "7 $0% .#1%+: 2,4&& 4+% $4C%# 24+% "7 =4; 1+4=4$)24,,; 477%2$ $0% &$4?),)$; "7 $0% %#$)+% &"2)%$; )# e.%&$)"#Y /0% 2"#$+4&$ ?%$H%%# 5)#-46"+% 4#1 ]+4\), )# $0)& +%-4+1 )& ),,.&$+4$)(%' )# 5)#-46"+%S $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )& 6+".1 "7 )$& 6+": 42$)(% 4$$%=6$& 4$ &.66"+$)#-S $+4)#)#- 4#1 )#$%-+4$)#- )$& .#1%+2,4&& )#$" )$& %R64#1)#- %2"#"=; _$0".-0 $0% 5)#-46"+% -"(%+#=%#$ )& #"$ 4 1%="2+42; 4#1 )& "7$%# +%6+%&&)(%`a $0% ]+4\),)4# -"(%+#=%#$S "# $0% "$0%+ 04#1S 04& ?%%# ()",%#$ )# )$& &.66+%&&)"# "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& 4#1 ,4R )# 4$$%=6$& 4$ )#$%-+4$)#- $0%= )#$" $0% ?.+-%"#)#- %2"#"=; _$0".-0 ]+4\), )& ="+% 1%="2+4$)2 $04# 5)#-46"+%S 6",)$)24,,;`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b"+)$;S 4#1 $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& ^ H0" 0",1 %#"+=".& )#7,.%#2% H)$0)# $0% ,%-4,:1%="2+4$)2 &;&$%=& %=%+-)#- H"+,1:H)1% ^ H0%$0%+ "+ #"$ $0% .#1%+2,4&& H),, ?% )#2,.1%1 )# $0% H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& "+ #"$Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

II +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0% E"+C)#- !,4&& F)()1%1' G%H 3)11,%:!,4&& 3"?),)$; (& N#1%+2,4&& F%2,)#%

!"# '#)/+3# &1 *"# +3'(2*%+./ 8&%6+34 )/.22 +3 "+4"5*#)" 2&)+#*+#2 /0% $;6)24, H"+C)#-:2,4&& 74=),; H),, %R6%+)%#2% $0% &4=% &%$ "7 6+"?,%=& 4#1 %R0)?)$ $0% &4=% &%$ "7 #%%1& 4& $0% #%H =)11,%:2,4&& 74=),;Y /0)& )& ?%24.&%' $0% WH)7%X H),, H"+C ^ 0%+ &4,4+; H),, ?% #%2%&&4+; 7"+ 74=),; &.+()(4, )# $0% 0)-0:$%20S 0)-0:6+)2%1 %2"#"=;a -+4#1: ="$0%+& =4;S "+ =4; #"$S ?% 4(4),4?,% 7"+ 20),1 24+%a $%%#& H),, 42$ ".$ 1.+)#- $0%)+ 0)-0:&20"", ;%4+& ^ 4#1 H"+C)#-:2,4&& $%%#& 4+% "7$%# ="+% ()",%#$ $04# =)11,%:2,4&& $%%#&S 4#1 $0% -)+,& ="+% ,)C%,; $" -%$ 6+%-#4#$a &%#)"+ 74=),; =%=?%+& H),, ,)(% ,"#-%+ 4#1 +%e.)+% ="+% =%1)24, 4#1 #.+&)#-:0"=% 24+%a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e.)+% ?,.%:2",,4+ ,4?"+S 4#1 2%+$4)# 6+"2%&&%& )# $0% 0)-0:$%20 6+"1.2$)"# &;&$%= &$),, +%e.)+% ,4?"+ ^ ,)C% 4&&%=?,)#- 4#1 642C)#- %,%2$+"#)2 %e.)6=%#$Y /0%+%7"+%S )# $0%)+ $;6)24,,; 246)$4,)&$ e.%&$ 7"+ 20%46 ,4?"+S $0% 0)-0:$%20 7)+=& IO

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

D

04(% ="(%1 $0)& 6"+$)"# "7 $0%)+ 6+"1.2$)"# "6%+4$)"#& $" $0% /0)+1 E"+,1Y /0% %77%2$ "7 b")#$:(%#$.+% 246)$4,)&= "# $0% /0)+1 E"+,1 )& 2"=6,%RY /0% 6"&)$)(% &)1% )& $0% 2+%4$)"# "7 b"?& ^ 4,?%)$ ,"H:64;)#- b"?& ^ H0)20 )# 4 6""+ #4$)"# 4+% 4 -""1 $0)#-S 4#1S $0% ?%-)##)#-& "7 4 2"#&.=%+ %2"#"=; H)$0 4# )#1)-%#".& #%H =)11,% 2,4&& %=%+-)#- $" 6+"1.2%S 1)&$+)?.$%S 4#1 2"#&.=% $0% 0)-0:$%20 6+"1.2$&Y f# $0% #%-4$)(% &)1%S $0% %R6,")$4$)"# "7 $0% H"+C%+& 24# ?% F)2C%#&: )4#S 4#1 H"+&%Y /0"&% ,.+%1 $" .+?4# 2%#$%+& 7"+ H"+CS ?.$ #"$ 7)#1)#- )$S "7$%# %#1 .6 ,)()#- $0% ,)7% "7 4 ,.=6%# 6+",%$4+)4$ )# $0% 0)1%".& &e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b"? H"+,1Y /0)& )& -%#.)#% .6H4+1 ="?),)$;S %&6%2)4,,; )# $%+=& "7 &$4$.&S 4#1 &0".,1 ?% ()%H%1 )# $0% 6"&)$)(% ,)-0$ $0)& 2"##"$%&YD 9"H%(%+S $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& 4+% .&.4,,; #"$ 4& -""1 &$.1%#$& 4& $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&Y /0%)+ ?42C-+".#1 )& ,%&& )#$%,,%2$.4,S 4#1 $0%)+ 74=),)%& $%#1 $" $0)#C )# +)-)1 ="+4, 4#1 +%,)-)".& 24$%-"+)%&S "+ 2,)20%h1 4#4,"-)%&Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#2,4&& $%#1 #"$ $" 1" H%,, )# 0)-0 &20"", _4#1 -;=#4&).=` 4#1 $" 1" ,%&& H%,, )# 2",,%-% ^ )7 $0%; 1" -4)# %#$+4#2% $" 2",,%-%Y G"+ 1" $0%; -4)# %#$+4#2% $" $0% ="+% 6+%&$)-)".& 2",,%-%&S ?.$ +4$0%+ $%#1 $" %#$%+ $H": ;%4+ "+ 7".+:;%4+ &$4$% 2",,%-%& )# $0% N5>S W+%1?+)2C .#)(%+&)$)%&X )# ]+)$4)#S 4#1 $%20#)24, &20"",& )# <.+"6%Y f# $0% 6"&)$)(% &)1% 4-4)#S $0% &$4$% 2",,%-%& )# $0% N5>S $0% +%1?+)2C .#)(%+&)$)%& )# ]+)$4)#S 4#1 $0% -;=#4&)4 4#1 $%20#)24, &20"",& )# <.+: "6%S 4+% (%+; -""1 %1.24$)"#4, )#&$)$.$)"#&Y >#1S $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& 1" H%,, %#".-0 $0%+%)# $" e.4,)7; 7"+S 4#1 -4)# %=6,";: =%#$ )#S H0)$%:2",,4+S &%+()2%S =)11,% =4#4-%=%#$S 4#1 6+"7%&&)"#4, 24+%%+ $+42C&Y <(%# $0".-0 $0%; 1" #"$ 1" 4& H%,, 4& $0% =)11,%:2,4&& 20),1+%#S $0%; 1" H%,, %#".-0 $" ?%2"=% &$4?,; 4?&"+?%1 )#$" $0% ,"H%+: =)11,%:2,4&& 6"+$)"# "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&Y 5" H04$ 4+% $0% 6+"?,%=&V /0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& %R6%+)%#2% $%++)?,% 6+%&&.+%S 1.+)#$0%)+ $%%# ;%4+&S )# $%+=& "7 &20"", &.22%&&Y /0)& $+%=%#1".& &20"",

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

IP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

6+%&&.+% ^ ;".+ H0",% ,)7% ?%2"=%& 1%6%#1%#$ .6"# ;".+ 4?),)$; $" -4)# %#$+4#2% $" 4 2",,%-% "+ $%20#).= ^ 2".6,%1 H)$0 $0% )#4?),)$; $" 2"=: 6%$% 4241%=)24,,; H)$0 $0% =)11,%:2,4&& &$.1%#$&S 24.&%& 4#-%+S ()": ,%#2%S 1%()4#2% 4#1 H)$01+4H4, 7+"= $0% 2.,$.+%YI E% &0".,1 #"$ )-#"+% $0% 0)-0 +4$% "7 $%%# &.)2)1% H0)20 04& %=%+-%1 )# $0% N5> 4#1 04& %R)&$%1 )# d464# 7"+ 4 ,"#- $)=%Y >#1 0"H 24# "#% )-#"+% $0% 1+.- 4?.&% H0)20 204+42$%+)\%& 0)-0 &20"", 2.,$.+% H"+,1 H)1%V >,2"0", 4?.&% %e.4,,; 204+42$%+)\%& $"14;X& $%%#&Y >#1S 4="#- $0% H"+C)#-:2,4&& &$.1%#$& %&6%2)4,,;S 4#-+; 4#1 1%()4#$ -+".6& 4#1 ,)7%: &$;,%& 4?".#1' &C)#0%41&S #%":G4\)&S -"$0&S 6.#C& ^ H04$%(%+ $0%; 4+% 24,,%1 $0)& H%%CS $0%; %R)&$S 4#1 $0%; %R)&$ ="+% %R$+%=%,; 4="#$0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&&Y /0)& 6+"?,%= %R)&$& )# $0% N5>S ]+)$4)#S @%+=4#;S U+4#2% ^ %(%# )# d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e.%&$ 7"+ .6H4+1 ="?),)$;Y 56%2)4, =4$0S &2)%#2%S 4#1 2"=6.$%+ 6+%6 6+"-+4=& 4+% %&6%2)4,,; #%%1%1 ?; $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&&Y /0%; $%#1 $" ?% H%4C )# $0%&% &.?b%2$ 4+%4&S 4#1 ;%$ $0%&% 4+% $0% (%+; 4+%4& H0)20 $0% b"?:H"+,1 )& #"H %=604&)\)#-Y M# @%+=4#;S U+4#2%S 524#1)#4()4S ]+)$4)#S d464# ^ 4#1 K.&&)4 1.+)#$0% 2"==.#)&$ %+4 ^ =4$0S &2)%#2%S 4#1 2"=6.$%+ 6+"-+4=& H%+% )=6+"(%1 1+4=4$)24,,;S 4#1 =41% 4(4),4?,% $" H"+C)#-:2,4&& 20),1+%# $0+".-0 $0% &20"",&S $%20#)24, &20"",&S 4#1 "#:$0%:b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e.)$% )=6"+$4#$Y U"+ $0% H"+C)#-:2,4&& 64+%#$& 4+% "7$%# .#4?,% $" 0%,6 $0%)+ 20),1+%# H)$0 $0%)+ 0"=%H"+C 4#1 &20"",H"+CS ?%24.&% $0%; 1"#X$ 04(% 4 -""1 %1.: 24$)"#4, ?42C-+".#1 $0%=&%,(%&YO [%$ 41.,$ %1.24$)"# 6+"-+4=& 04(%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '7"I,-. +2%33 M,>,9#9 IQ

?%%# (%+; &.22%&&7., H)$0 H"+C)#-:2,4&& 41.,$& ^ %&6%2)4,,; H)$0 H"+C: )#-:2,4&& H"=%#Y >,"#- H)$0 0)-0:&20"", %e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b"? ?%24.&% "7 4.$"=4$)"#S 4#1 24##"$ .6-+41% 0)& "+ 0%+ &C),,& 1.% $" ,42C "7 %1.24$)"#4, ?42C-+".#1Y > 0"++)7)2 #%-4$)(% %77%2$ "7 4.$"=4$)"# 04& ?%%# $0% +)&)#- .#%=: 6,";=%#$ +4$% 4="#- 6+%()".&,; .#)"#)\%1 H"+C%+& H0" 041 &$%41; b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d464# $0% 2"+6"+4$)"#& 4#1 $0% -"(%+#=%#$ 4+% 1%4,)#- H)$0 $0)& 6+"?,%= (%+; H%,,Y
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

IJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

?%%# 4 7+)-0$%#)#- +%$.+# "7 #%":G4\) 04$% -+".6& ^ $0)& $)=% 7"2.&%1 "# $0% /.+C& 4#1 $0% -;6&)%&S 4#1 "$0%+ -.%&$:H"+C%+&S &)#2% $0%+% 4+% 7%H d%H& $" 04$% 4#; ="+%Y /0.&S 2+)=%S ()",%#2%S 4#1 1%()4#2% 04(% %=%+-%1 )# @%+=4#;S H0%+% H"+C%+& 04(% ,"&$ $0%)+ b"?& 4#1 #"$ ?%%# +%:%=6,";%1Y /0)& &4=% 60%#"=%#"# )& 0466%#)#- )# U+4#2% 4#1 04& ?%%# 64+$ "7 $0% ]+)$)&0 ,4#1&246% 7"+ 4# %=?4++4&&)#-,; ,"#- $)=%Y E04$ "7 $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&V G%%1,%&& $" &4;S )# $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ %2": #"=;S $0% 2"+6"+4$)"#& 4#1 -"(%+#=%#$ 1" ,)$$,% 7"+ $0"&% H"+C%+& 4.$"=4$%1 ".$ "7 4 b"?Y E% $4,C 4?".$ b"?:+%$+4)#)#- 6+"-+4=&S 1%?4$% 4 #4$)"#4, b"?:6,42%=%#$ 6+"2%&& _$0% b"?:?4#C 6+"6"&4,`S ?.$ ?4&)24,,; 4?4#1"# $0% .#%=6,";%1 H"+C%+&Y f7 2".+&%S $0%; -%$ .#%=6,";=%#$ )#&.+4#2% 7"+ 4H0),%S ?.$ $0%; -%$ ,)$$,% 47$%+ $04$YJ E04$ 0466%#& $" >=%+)24# H"+C%+& H0" 24##"$ 7)#1 H"+CV /0% +%2"+1 )& 7+)-0$%#)#-' 7+"= 4="#- .#%=6,";%1 H"+C%+& _H0" 041 "#2% 0%,1 1%2%#$:64;)#- .#)"# b"?&` 4 +)&)#- +4$% "7 =.+1%+ 4#1 74=),; ()",%#2% )& %=%+-)#-Y <(%+;14; )# $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%& "#% +%41& "7 4 ,4)1:"77 H"+C%+ +%$.+#)#- $" 0)& 6,4#$ 4#1 &0""$)#- $0% &.6%+()&"+ H0" 7)+%1 0)= 4#1 4#;"#% %,&% 0466%#)#- $" ?% )# 0)& H4;S $0%# $.+#)#- $0% -.# "# 0)=&%,7Y 5"=%$)=%& $0% &0""$)#-& 4+% ="+% +4#1"=S "22.++)#- 4$ 4 =4,, "+ 4 32F"#4,1X&Y f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`S $0% 1%2,)#)#- H"+C)#- 2,4&& #%%1& &6%2)4, 6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0%)+ 20),1+%# 4#1 $0%)+ .#%=6,";%1 74$0%+&Y U"+ $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&&S 6+%&20"", 6+"-+4=& 4+% 4 =.&$S &" $04$ $0%&% 20),1+%# 24# 24$20 .6 $" $0%)+ =)11,%:2,4&& 2"=6%$)$"+& )# $0% &20"", &;&$%=Y >#1S )# -+41% &20"",S $0% H"+C)#-:2,4&& 20),1+%# #%%1 W2.,$.+4, %#+)20=%#$X 6+"-+4=& $" 0%,6 $0%= H)$0 $0%)+ ,42C "7 &C),,& )# =4$0%=4$)2& 4#1 ,)$%+4$.+%S 4#1 $" 42e.4)#$ $0%= H)$0 $0% H"+,1 "7 $0% 4+$& 4#1 &2)%#2%& H0)20 $0%)+ 64+%#$& H%+% .#4H4+% "7Y 520"", &.66"+$ 6+"-+4=& 7+"= 6+%:&20"", $" 2",,%-% H".,1 0%,6 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& &$.1%#$& $" &.22%&&7.,,; =4C% $0% $+4#&)$)"# $" $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '7"I,-. +2%33 M,>,9#9 IL

f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` &0""$)#-& )# $0% F%#(%+ &.?.+?4# 0)-0 &20"", H%+% $0% $)6 "7 $0% )2%?%+-Y E04$ "7 $0% .#%=6,";%1 H"+C%+& H0" 04(% ,"&$ $0%)+ b"?& $" 4.$"=4: $)"# 4#1 2"=6.$%+)\4$)"#V >-4)#S $0% @%+=4# 4#1 d464#%&% 466+"420%& 6+%&%#$ $0% ="1%, 7"+ $0% H"+,1Y @%+=4#; 04& $0% ?%&$ +%:$+4)#)#6+"-+4=&S H0),% d464# 1"%& $0% ="&$ $" C%%6 H"+C%+& H"+C)#- .#$), $0%; +%$)+%Y G"HS H"+C%+& 1" 04(% 4 204#2%S )# $0% N5>S $" -" $" $%20: #)24, &20"",& "+ $H":;%4+ 2",,%-%&Y /0% 6+"?,%= )& $04$ ",1%+ H"+C%+& 4#1 ,%&&:%1.24$%1 H"+C%+& $%#1 #"$ $" 4$$%#1 $0%&% &20"",&Y /0%+%7"+%S )# $0% N5>S %)$0%+ 6+)(4$% "+ 6.?,)2 %=6,";=%#$ 4-%#2)%& =4; 04(% $" ?% &.?&)1)\%1 $" 0%,6 2"##%2$ &.20 H"+C%+& ^ %&6%2)4,,; =4,% H"+C%+& "(%+ DT ;%4+& "7 4-% ^ $" $0% &C),,& .6-+41)#- 6+"2%&& 4#1 $" $0% b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

OT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0% 56%2)7)2 *4$$%+# "7 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& <#-.,7)#- $0% @,"?4, N#1%+2,4&&

D3*%&'()*+&3 >& $0% 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=; %R64#1& )#$" $0% 1%(%,: "6)#- #4$)"#&S 4 #%H 2,4&& &$+.2$.+% )& -%#%+4$%1 H)$0)# $0%= ^ 4#1 H)$0)# $0% ="+% 41(4#2%1 #4$)"#&Y M# $0% 1%(%,"6)#- #4$)"#&S %&6%2)4,,; $0"&% H0%+%)# $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=; )& +46)1,; %=%+-)#-S &.20 4& )# >&)4 4#1 B4$)# >=%+)24S 6%4&4#$ (),,4-%+& ,%4(% $0% ,4#1 4#1 =)-+4$% $" $0% 2)$)%& 4#1 $0% 742$"+; 4+%4&Y /0%; ?%2"=% $0% #%H H"+C)#- 2,4&& ^ H0%# $0%; 24# -%$ b"?&Y >& )# $0% %4+,; 14;& "7 $0% )#1.&$+)4, +%(",.$)"#S ?"$0 =%# 4#1 H"=%# -4)# H"+C: )#-:2,4&& b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`S b.&$ 4& )$ H4& )# #)#%$%%#$0:2%#$.+; <.+"6% _4& 4# %R$%#&)"# "7 20),1 ,4?"+ "# $0% 6%4&4#$ 74+=&`Y >,"#- H)$0 $0"&% 6%4&4#$& H0" -4)# b"?& H)$0)# $0% ="1%+# 742$"+; &%2$"+ 4+%S .#7"+$.#4$%,;S =),,)"#& "7 6%4&4#$& H0" 74), $" -4)# -""1 H"+C)#-:2,4&& b"?&Y >-4)#S $0)& 6+"2%&& 1)1 "22.+ )# <.+"6%S 4#1 $0% .#%=6,";%1 6+",%$4+)4$ 422.=.,4$%1 )# $0% 2)$; &,.=& 4#1 ,)(%1 4 O8

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

I

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d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b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

OA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

G"+$0 4#1 5".$0 >=%+)24Y /0%&% )==)-+4#$& &%%C $0% &4=% $0)#- )# $0%)+ 2".#$+; "7 1%&$)#4$)"# $04$ $0%; &".-0$ )# $0%)+ "H# 2".#$+;' H"+C)#-:2,4&& b"?&Y >#1S 4& )# $0%)+ "H# 2".#$+)%&S "#,; &"=% "7 $0%= 1" -4)# &.20 b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b.&$ 4& $0%; 04(% )# $0%)+ 2".#$+)%& "7 "+)-)#' 4 H"+C)#2,4&&S H)$0 4 6"$%#$)4, 7"+ .6H4+1 ="?),)$;S 4#1 4# .#1%+2,4&&S H)$0 4 6"$%#$)4, 7"+ 1"H#H4+1 ="?),)$; )#$" 2+)=%S ()2% 4#1 ()",%#2%Y f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`Y G"S $0%; 24##"$ C%%6 .6 H)$0 $0%)+ 6"6.,4$)"# 1%#&)$;S ?.$ ;%&S 4& H)$0 d464# 47$%+ $0% 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+S $0%; 4+% 4?&"+?)#- 74+ ="+%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# O-9#"&2%33 OD

H"+C%+& $04# 4#;"#% $0".-0$ 6"&&)?,% $H%#$; ;%4+& 4-"Y ]+4\),S >+-%#: $)#4S !0),% 4#1 3%R)2" 4,&" 04(% +46)1,; %R64#1)#- %2"#"=)%&S 4#1 $0%;S $""S 4+% 4?&"+?)#- ="+% H"+C%+& $04# 6+"b%2$%1Y M# $%+=& "7 $0% =)11,%:2,4&& 2"=6"#%#$ "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;S $0%+% )& 4 0"6%7., 4#1 H"#1%+7., $+%#1 H0",,; 4?&%#$ 7+"= $0% <.+"6%4# 6+"2%&& "7 %2"#"=)2 1%(%,"6=%#$ )# )$& %4+,; 604&%&Y /0% ,4+-% =)11,% 2,4&& %=%+-)#- )# 9"#- Z"#-S /4)H4#S 5)#-46"+%S Z"+%4 4#1 #"H !0)#4S M#1)4S ]+4\), _%&6%2)4,,; )# 54j" *4","`S >+-%#$)#4S !0),%S 4#1 %,&%H0%+%S )& 0%4+$%#)#- )#1%%1Y N#$), $0% 2",,46&% )# 8LLJS ?"$0 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& 4#1 $0% =)11,%:2,4&& &%2$"+& "7 $0% /04) 4#1 M#1"#%&)4# %2"#"=)%& H%+% 4,&" e.)$% )=6+%&&)(%Y B%$ .& 4,&" 411 $04$ 4,"#- H)$0 $0% -+"H$0 "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& )# $0% 1%(%,"6)#- %2"#"=)%&S $0% -+"H$0 "7 $0% &=4,, ?.&)#%&& 2,4&& 04& 4,&" ?%%# 4&$"#)&0)#-S %&6%2)4,,; )# >&)4Y d.&$ 4& $0% d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

OI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# O-9#"&2%33 OO

!"# 2".%#' 3##'2 &1 *"# (3'#%)/.22

/0% ?+%4C1"H# "7 $0% 74=),; 4="#- $0% .#1%+2,4&& 4+)&%& 7+"= 1)77%+%#$ 1;#4=)2& $04# $04$ "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&Y M$ )& #"$ $0% ,)?%+4: $)"# "7 H"=%# )#$" $0% H"+C H"+,1S "+ $0% 1.4, 24+%%+ 2".6,% $04$ -%#: %+4$%& $0% 1%2,)#% "7 $0% 74=),;S ?.$ +4$0%+ .#%=6,";=%#$ 4#1 6"(%+$;Y /0% 64$$%+# ?%-)#& &)=),4+,;S )# $04$ $0% -+4#164+%#$& 4+% &%64+4$%1 7+"= $0% 74=),; ?%24.&% $0%; 04(% ?%%# ,%7$ ?%0)#1 )# $0%)+ (),,4-%&Y /0% 64$$%+# $0%# 1)(%+-%&Y [".#- =%# %#2".#$%+ -+4(% 1)77)2.,$)%& )# 7)#1)#- b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e.%&$)"#S $0% 6+"?,%= "7 $0% &)#-,%S .#H%1 ="$0%+ ,%7$ $" +4)&% 0%+ 20),1+%# 4,"#% =4; ?%2"=% 4,="&$ #"+=4$)(% )# $0% .#1%+2,4&&Y M# ]+4\),S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S 4#1 4="#- ?,42CS 6""+ >=%+)24#&S $0)& =4; ?% $0% #.=?%+ "#% &"2)4, 6+"?,%=S H0%+%4& )# 3%R)2" 4#1 $0% <.+"6%4# 2)$)%&S )$ )& ,%&& 7+%e.%#$Y ].$S ,%$ .& =4C% $0% &)$.4$)"# H"+&%Y > ;".#- H"=4#S 4?4#1"#%1 H)$0 4# )#74#$S =4; &$),, ?% 4?,% $" +4,,; 0%+&%,7 4#1 +4)&% $0% 20),1 _"+ 20),1+%#` H%,,Y >#1S &0% =4; $0%# -4)# =%# )# 0%+ ,)7%S H0"S 4$ ,%4&$ $%=6"+4+),;S 42$ 4& 74$0%+)#- 7)-.+%& $" 0%+ 20),1+%#Y 9"H%(%+S &"=% 20),1+%# H),, ?% #%-,%2$%1 "+ +%b%2$%1 ?; $0%)+ ="$0%+S H0),% "$0%+& =4; ?% ?%4$%# "+ ?+.$4,)\%1Y 5"=% 20),1+%# H),, %(%# ?% 4?4#1"#%1 $" $0% &$+%%$& 4$ 4 ;".#- 4-%Y U+"= G%H4+C $" K)" $" 34#),4S ?+.$4,)\%1 4#1 #%-,%2$%1 W&$+%%$ C)1&X 04(% ?%2"=% 2"=="#6,42%S 4#1 $0%; "7$%# ?%2"=% 4#$):&"2)4,S &"2)"64$0)2 4#1 4 &"2)4, 6+"?,%= $" $0%=&%,(%& 4#1 $0% &"2)%$; 4+".#1 $0%=Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# ;%#.6'&83 &1 *"# 1.-+/7

/" =4C% $0)#-& H"+&% 4-4)#S $0% ?";7+)%#1& "7 $0% ="$0%+& "7$%# ?%4$ .6 4#1 $"+=%#$ $0% H"=4#X& 20),1+%# _?; "$0%+ =%#`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e.)+% 4 2",,%-% %1.24: $)"#S ="&$ =%=?%+& "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& H),, #"$ e.4,)7; 7"+ $0"&% b"?&Y <(%# $"14;X& 742$"+; 6"&)$)"#& "7$%# 1%=4#1 2"=6.$%+ ,)$%+42; 4#1 4 C#"H,%1-% "7 =4$0 4#1 ,4#-.4-% "7 4$ ,%4&$ 4 7.#2$)"#4, ,%(%,Y /0"&% =)-+4#$& 4#1 )==)-+4#$& H0" -4)# &.20 %1.24$)"#4, &C),,& 04(% 4 =.20 ?%$$%+ 204#2% "7 42e.)+)#- H"+C)#-:2,4&& "+ ,"H%+:=)11,%:2,4&& 24+%%+&Y /0"&% H0" ,42C 4,, %1.24$)"#4, &C),,& =4; ?% 1""=%1 $" 4 ,)7% "7 =)#)=.=:H4-% b"?&S "+ #" b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f+S H)$0)# &"2)%$)%&S &.20 4& $04$ "7 M#1)4S $0% ,"H%&$ 24&$%& =4; ?% $4.-0$ $04$ $0%; 04(% #" 204#2% 7"+ &.22%&& 4#1 $04$ %1.24$)"# )& "#,; 7"+ $0% .66%+ 24&$%&Y U.+$0%+S )# &"=% 2.,$.+%& "#,; ?";& 4+% 6.&0%1 $"H4+1& %1.24$)"#S H0),% )# "$0%+& %1.24$)"# )& 2"#&)1%+%1 %77%=)#4$% 4#1 4 ?"; )& 6.&0%1 $"H4+1& =420" 42$)()$)%& 4#1 4H4; 7+"= &20"", &$.1)%& ^ 5".$0%+# M$4,)4# )==)-+4#$& $" >=%+)24 %R0)?)$%1 $0)& ,4$$%+ 64$$%+#S H0),% <4&$: %+# <.+"6%4# d%H& %R0)?)$%1 $0% 7"+=%+Y U)#4,,;S $0% ="&$ +%2%#$ ?)","-)24, &$.1)%& 04(% &0"H# $04$ $0% %4+,; ;%4+& "7 20),10""1 4+% 2+.2)4, 7"+ %1.24$)"#4, &.22%&&Y /0% ="+% $0% 20),1 ,%4+#& )# $0%&% %4+,; ;%4+& ^ )# $%+=& "7 ("24?.,4+;S ,"-)2S =4$0S

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

OP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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e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b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`Y >$ $0% "$0%+ %R$+%=% )& ]+4\),S H0)20 ?.),1& 4& ,)$$,% 6"(%+$; 0".&)#- 4& )$ 24#Y G"HS 9"#- Z"#- )& +)20S 4#1 9"#- Z"#- H4#$%1 $" &%$ )$&%,7 4& 4# 4,$%+#4$)(% %R4=6,% $" $0% 2"==.#)&$ !0)#%&% ^ H0" 041 ?.),$ 4 2"#: &)1%+4?,% 4=".#$ "7 6"(%+$; 0".&)#- )# 2%+$4)# 2)$)%& ^ )#2,.1)#- #%4+?;

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# O-9#"&2%33 OQ

!4#$"# [email protected]#-1"#-`Y G"#%$0%,%&&S 9"#- Z"#- )& %R%=6,4+; )# $%+=& "7 0".&)#- 7"+ $0% .#1%+2,4&&Y ].$S 7.+$0%+S )# 9"#- Z"#-S $0% .#1%+2,4&& +46)1,; -4)#& b"?&S ?%2"=)#- =%=?%+& "7 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&&S 4#1 %(%# $0% =)11,% 2,4&&S )# "#% -%#%+4$)"#S H0),%S )# 4+%4& H)$0 ,%&&%+ %2"#"=)2 -+"H$0 4#1 H)$0 ,%&& H%,,:&"2)4,)\%1 6""+S &.20 %2"#"=)2 ="?),)$; =4; ?% =.20 &,"H%+Y /0% 0".&)#- 6+"?,%=& 7"+ $0% .#1%+2,4&&S $0%#S 4+% 4 =4b"+ 6+"?,%= 7"+ 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#&Y U"+ 0".&)#- =.&$ ?% 2"=?)#%1 H)$0 b"? $+4)#)#-S %1.24$)"#S 4#1 b"? 6,42%=%#$S "+ )$ H),, #"$ ?% &.22%&&7.,Y 9".&)#6+"b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b"?:$+4)#)#- 4#1 %1.24$)"# =.&$ ?% 6+"()1%1 4#1 -)(%# 7)+&$ 6+)"+)$; )# W$0% H%,74+% &$4$% 7"+ $0% 6""+XS ?.$S &$),,S $0% &$%41; ?.),1)#- "7 41%e.4$% 0".&)#- 7"+ $0% H"+C)#- &%-=%#$ "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& &0".,1 C%%6 642% H)$0 $0% %2"#"=)2 %R64#&)"# "7 $0% #4$)"# )# e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e.4$%,;Y E% &04,, 1)&2.&& $0)& 7.+$0%+S ?.$ 7)+&$ ,%$ .& 1%,(% ="+% 1%%6,; )#$" $0% 2+)=% 4#1 1%()4#2% 6+"?,%=& "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&&Y !"# *#3'#3)7 *&8.%' )%+-#A ,+&/#3)#A ,+)# .3' '%(42 E% 04(% 4,+%41; &.--%&$%1 $04$ =4#; "7 $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& 4+% #%-,%2$%1 ?; $0%)+ ="$0%+& 4#1 ?+.$4,)\%1 ?; $0% =%# H0" 04#4+".#1 $0%)+ ="$0%+&Y !"=?)#% $0)& 4#-%+ H)$0 $0% ,42C "7 %1.24$)"#4, &C),,& 4#1 b"? "66"+$.#)$)%&S 4#1 ;". 2".,1 7)#1 4 ()",%#$ "+ 1%()4#$ ;".$0S +%41; $" W42$ ".$X 4#1 &$+)C% ".$ 4$ $0% &.++".#1)#- &"2)%$;Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

OJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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`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` "+ ?%24.&% "7 $0% ,42C "7 $0% 1+.-& _%&6%2)4,,; "6).= 1%+)(4$)(%&`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f?()".&,;S &.20 4 1;&7.#2$)"#4, .#1%+2,4&& H),, ?%2"=% 4 ?.+1%# 4#1 %=?4++4&&=%#$ $" 4#; &"2)%$; 4$$%=6$)#- $" ="1%+#)\%Y /0%+%7"+%S 6+": -+4=& 411+%&&)#- $0% W&04+%1 #%%1&X "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& =4; %=%+-%Y 5.20 6+"-+4=& H".,1 )#2,.1% #"$ "#,; 6+"2%&&%& 7"+ $0% 4?&"+6$)"# "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& )#$" $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;S 4#1 6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0% +%04?),)$4: $)"# "7 $0% 1%()4#$ .#1%+2,4&&S ?.$ 4,&" 6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0% +%6+%&&)"# "7 $0% 2+)=)#4, %,%=%#$& )# $0% .#1%+2,4&& _4#1 $0%)+ 6"$%#$)4, +%04?),)$4: $)"#`Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# O-9#"&2%33 OL

/0.&S $0% .#1%+2,4&& )& )# #%%1 "7 74=),; &.66"+$ 6+"-+4=&S 6+%&20"", 4#1 -+41%:&20"", %1.24$)"#4, 6+"-+4=&S b"?:$+4)#)#- 4#1 b"?:6,42%=%#$ 6+"-+4=&S 4,"#- H)$0 6+)&"# 4#1 6",)2% 6+"-+4=&S H0)20 =4; #%%1 $" ?% +%6+%&&)(%S 4& H%,, 4& +%04?),)$4$)(%Y M# =4#; 4+%4& "7 $0% H"+,1S 0".&)#6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0% 6""+ =4; 4,&" 04(% $" ?% 64+$ "7 $0% 6.?,)2 6",)2; 2"##%2$%1 H)$0 $0% .#1%+2,4&& &)#2% $0% ?4++)"& 4+% &" .#0%4,$0; 4#1 .#,)(4?,%Y E% &04,, 1)&2.&& $0%&% 6+"-+4=& ?%,"HY ].$ 7)+&$S ,%$ .& =4C% $0)#-& H"+&%Y E>&32$+)(&(2 )&32(-$*+&3FG .3' E+3,+'+&(2 )&-$.%+2&3FH -.7 -.6# )%+-# -&%# ,+&/#3* .3' -&%# &%4.3+<#' !46)$4,)&=S H0%$0%+ 0)-0:$%20 "+ $0% %4+,)%+ )#1.&$+)4, 7"+=S %#-%#1%+& -+%4$ H%4,$0 1)77%+%#$)4,&Y /0% +)20 1" -%$ +)20%+ 4#1 ="+% #.=%+".&S $0% 6""+ "7$%# 1" +%=4)# +%-+%$$4?,; 6""+Y f7 2".+&%S $0% ="1%+# 246): $4,)&$ %2"#"=;S 4& H% 04(% %=604&)\%1S 04& &64H#%1 4 =4&&)(% =4b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e.)2C,; )& $+%=%#1".&Y /0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

PT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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kATTT 4#1 kAT TTTS )$ )& #" H"#1%+ $04$ $0% $0%7$ "7 H4$20%& 4#1 "$0%+ b%H%,+; )& "+-4#)\%1 )#$%+: #4$)"#4,,; ^ 4& H%,, 4& &6"#$4#%".& ,"24,,;Y /0% =4&& 6+"1.2$)"# "7 W2,"#%&X 4#1 WC#"2C:"77&X 0%,6& +%1.2% $0% )#()1)".& 2"=64+)&"#S &)#2% 6""+%+ 6%"6,% H4,C 4+".#1 H)$0 04#1?4-& $04$ ,""C ,)C% @.22)& 4#1 H4$20%& $04$ 466%4+ $" ?% K",%R%&Y ].$ $0% 6""+ C#"H $0% 1)77%+%#2%S 4#1 +4$%& "7 $0%7$ 4+% (%+; 0)-0 ^ ?"$0 4-4)#&$ $0% )#1)-%#".& +)20 4#1 $".+)&$&Y F+.- ="#%;S )# 1+.- 24+%%+&S )& "#% e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# O-9#"&2%33 P8

G"HS &"=% +%-)"#& 4#1 #4$)"#& 04(% ?%%# 4?,% $" %R64#1 $0%)+ %2"#"=: )%& 4#1 422"=="14$% $0%)+ 6"6.,4$)"#& &" &.22%&&7.,,; $04$ $0% 2+)=% +4$%& 4+% #"$ 0)-0Y 5)#-46"+% 4#1 Z"+%4S @%+=4#; 4#1 U+4#2% 04(% 1"#% 74)+,; H%,, )# $0)& +%-4+1Y ]+4\), 4#1 M#1"#%&)4S "# $0% "$0%+ 04#1S 04(% 1"#% 6""+,;S 4#1 2+)=% +4$%& 4#1 1%()4#2% +4$%& 04(% ?%%# +)&)#- "77 $0% 204+$&Y >#1S )# 4,, 74)+#%&& $" $0% N5>S )$& =)11,% 2,4&& 1"%& #"$ %R0)?)$ 4 0)-0 +4$% "7 2+)=%Y /0% N5 .#1%+2,4&& 1"%& %R0)?)$ 4 0)-0 +4$% "7 2+)=% 4#1 ()2% 4#1 ()",%#2%S 0"H%(%+Y E0%+% $0% =)11,% 2,4&& %R64#1&S $0% +4$%& "7 2+)=% 4#1 ()",%#2% .&.4,,; 1%2,)#%Y ].$ ,4+-% #.=?%+& "7 6""+ 6%"6,% H),, 2"#$)#.% $" 422.=.,4$% )# $0% H"+,1X& 2)$)%&S 4#1 #"$ 4,, "7 $0%= H),, ?% 4?&"+?%1 )#$" $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=)%&Y M# &"=% &"2)%$)%&S $0% +)20 4+% H),,)#- $" &04+% $0%)+ H%4,$0 4#1 0%,6 $" 4?&"+? $0% 6""+ $0+".-0 &6%2)7)2 6+"-+4=& 411+%&&)#- $0% W#%%1&X "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& ^ 6+"-+4=& ,)#C%1 $" b"?:$+4)#)#- 4#1 %1.24$)"# 4#1 0".&)#4#1 74=),; &.66"+$Y d464#S 5)#-46"+%S 9"#- Z"#-S @%+=4#;S /0% G%$0: %+,4#1&S 5H%1%#S 5H)$\%+,4#1 4#1 "$0%+& 7)$ 0%+%S H0),% )# "$0%+ &"2): %$)%&S $0% +)20 04(% ?%%# .#H),,)#- $" &04+% $0%)+ H%4,$0 H)$0 $0% .#1%+2,4&& ^ 3%R)2"S ]+4\),S 4#1 $0% N5> %R0)?)$ $0)& 64$$%+#Y M# 2"#2,.&)"#' $0% #%H -,"?4, .#1%+2,4&& %R0)?)$& 4 &6%2)7)2 &%$ "7 &"2)4, 6+"?,%=& 4#1 &04+%& 4 &%$ "7 #%%1&Y M# $0% 24&% "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& $0% &04+%1 #%%1& +%(",(% 4+".#1 $0% ,42C "7 %1.24$)"# 4#1 b"? &C),,&S 4#1 $0% ?+%4C.6 "7 $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),; 24+)#- &;&$%= _%R)&$%#$ )# $0% +.+4, (),,4-%& 7+"= H0)20 $0%; =)-+4$%1`Y *+"-+4=& $" )=6+"(% $0% %1.24: $)"#4, 4#1 b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b"+)$; #"$ ;%$ 6",)$)24,,; 42$)(%`Y /0%+%7"+%S )$ )& .6 $" $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& $" ,%-)&,4$% 7"+ $0% #%H 6""+Y E0%$0%+ "+ #"$ $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& H),, 41("24$% 7"+ $0% 6""+S )-#"+% $0% #%%1& "7 $0% 6""+S "+ +%b%2$ 4#1 +%6+%&& $0% 6""+S 1%6%#1& "# $0% 2.,$.+4, $+41)$)"#S 6",)$)24, )1%","-;S 4#1 64+$)2.,4+ %2"#"=)2 2"#1)$)"#&S )# $0% #4$)"# )# e.%&$)"#Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

PA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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d464# 4#1 5)#-46"+%S8I "+ %(%# "7 64$%+#4,)&$)2 +%&6"#&)?),)$;S 4& )# 524#1)#4()4 4#1 @%+=4#;S8O 4#1 6%+046& )# !0)#4 _)$ )& $"" &""# $" $%,, $0%+%`S $0%; $%#1 $" 2"#$+)?.$% $" $0% %77"+$ "7 4?&"+?)#- $0% 6""+ )#$" $0% %2"#"=;Y E0%+% $0% +)20 04(% 4 ="+% 6.+%,; 246)$4,)&$ %$0)2S 4& )# $0% N5> 4#1 ]+)$4)#S $0%; =4; #"$ 64+$)2)64$% 42$)(%,; )# 4#; 6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0% 6""+ ^ 74,,)#- ?42C "# $0% %$0)2 "7 )#1)()1.4, +%&6"#&)?),)$; 4#1 &%,7:0%,6 "+ 2%,33#KD$%,"#S $" b.&$)7; $0%)+ ?%04()"+Y f+S H"+&%S )# B4$)# >=%+)24 $0% +)20 &$),, 74,, ?42C "# $0%)+ W2"#e.)&$41"+X 2.,$.+%S 6+%7%++)#- $" 1"=)#4$% $0% 6""+ 4#1 .&% $0%= 7"+ &%+(4#$& 4#1 20%46 ,4?"+S 4#1 $0%# +%&"+$)#- $" 1)+%2$ =),)$4+; ()",%#2% $" C%%6 $0%= )# ,)#%Y B4$)# >=%+)24 )& 204#-)#-S 0"H%(%+S 4& $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=; %R64#1& 4#1 -%#%+4$%& 4 #%H =)1: 1,% 2,4&&Y W<&$4$% ,"+1&X &$),, %R)&$S ?.$ ="1%+# ?.&)#%&&=%# 4#1 H0)$%: 2",,4+ H"+C%+& 4+% 2+%4$)#- #%H 6",)2)%& 4#1 6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0% .#1%+2,4&& ^ 4#1 7"+ $0% =)11,% 2,4&& )$&%,7Y E% &04,, 04(% ="+% $" &4; 4?".$ %420 "7 $0%&% $;6%& "7 +%&6"#&%& $" $0% .#1%+2,4&& )# ,4$%+ 2046$%+&Y ].$ +%=%=?%+ $""S $04$ )7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& )& #%-,%2$%1 4#1 +%6+%&&%1S 4#1 )7 $0%+% )& #" +46)1 %2"#"=)2 %R64#&)"#S $0% .#1%+2,4&& =4; +)"$S ,""$S b")# +41)24, 6",)$)24, ="(%=%#$& ^ &.20 4& $0% W9.C&X )# $0% *0),: )66)#%& 4#1 $0% W50)#)#- *4$0X )# *%+. ^ 4#1 +)&% .6 )# +%(",.$)"#4+; 7.+"+Y /0".-0 $0)& ,4$$%+ )& .#,)C%,;S -)(%# $0% +%=4+C4?,% %R64#&)"# "7 $0% H"+,1X& %2"#"=;S )$ )& 2%+$4)#,; &$),, 4 6"&&)?),)$; H0%+% $0% 2"#1): $)"#& "7 $0% .#1%+2,4&& 1%$%+)"+4$% _4& +%2%#$,; )# M#1"#%&)4`Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# O-9#"&2%33 PD

O

D3*%&'()*+&3 /0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& "7 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$ 7)#4#2)%+& 4#1 2"+6"+4$% =4#4-%+& )& %R6%+)%#2)#- $0% &4=% &"2)4, 6+"?,%=& 4& $0% #%H =)11,%: 2,4&&Y 9"H%(%+S ?%24.&% "7 $0%)+ %R$+%=% H%4,$0S $0%; 1" #"$ #%%1 H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& $" 4$$%#1 $" $0%&% 6+"?,%=&Y U4=),;S =4+)$4, 4#1 -%#1%+ 2"#7,)2$& 4?".#1 )# $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& b.&$ 4& $0%; 1" )# $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S 4& 1"%& $%%#4-% 42$)#-:".$ 4#1 1+.- 4?.&%Y 9"H%(%+S $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& 64;& 1)+%2$,; 7"+ $0% 20),1 24+%S %,1%+ 24+%S 0%4,$0 24+%S 6&;20"$0%+46;S 1+.- 4#1 4,2"0", $+%4$=%#$ 4#1 %1.24$)"#4, %#+)20=%#$ $04$ $0%)+ 74=),)%& #%%1Y ]%24.&% $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& &.77%+& 7+"= $0% &4=% &"2)4, =4,41)%& 4& $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S 4#1S ?%24.&% $0% -,"?4, 2.,$.+% )& #"H 7.,,; "6%# 4?".$ 4,, "7 $0%&% 6+"?,%=&S $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& )& =.20 ="+% &;=64$0: %$)2 $" $0% 6+"-+4==4$)2 &",.$)"#& $" $0%&% 6+"?,%=& $04# $0% ",1%+ 246)$4,)&$ .66%+ 2,4&& ^ H0)20 %)$0%+ 0)1 "+ 1%#)%1 4#; 74=),;S -%#1%+S 1+)#C)#-S "+ 1%()4#2% 6+"?,%=& $0%; =4; 04(% 041Y U"+ )#&$4#2%S $0% 1)("+2%:+4$% )& 0)-0 4="#- $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& )# <.+"6%S 4#1 #"H %(%# )# >&)4S 4#1 74=),; 1;&7.#2$)"# 4?".#1&Y M# 8LLJS 7"+ )#&$4#2%S 4 F4#)&0 ="()% H"# $0% &6%2)4, b.+; 4H4+1 4$ $0% !4##%& U),= 7%&$)(4, ^ $0% ="()% H4& 4?".$ 4 H%4,$0; )#1.&$+)4,)&$ $.+#%1 PT ;%4+& ",1S H0" )& 2"#7+"#$%1 4$ 0)& ?)+$014; 2%,%?+4$)"# _+#2#A"%1,7- )& $0% $)$,% "7 $0% ="()%` ?; 0)& &"#S H0" 4##".#2%& $" 4,, $0% -.%&$& $04$ 0)& 74$0%+ 041 &%R.4,,; 4?.&%1 0)= 4#1 0)& &)&$%+& H0%# $0%; H%+% 20),1+%#a $0% "#% &)&$%+ 041 +%2%#$,; 2"==)$$%1 &.)2)1%Y 5.20 4 ="()% H".,1 #"$ 04(% ?%%# =41% DT ;%4+& 4-"S ?.$ #"HS 4,, $0% &"2)4, ),,& "7 &"2)%$; 4+% ".$ )# $0% "6%# 7"+ 4#4,;&)& ^ 7"+ ?%$$%+ "+ 7"+ H"+&%S 7"+ +)20%+ "+ 7"+ 6""+%+Y PI

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% 5"2)4, *+"?,%=& "7 $0% G%H N66%+ !,4&&

<(%# $0".-0 $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& )& =.20 ="+% &;=64$0%$)2 4?".$S 4#1 .6:7+"#$ H)$0S $0% &"2)4, 6+"?,%=& ^ 4#1 #"$ 4$ 4,, 4(%+&% $" 6+"-+4==4$)2 &",.$)"#& $" $0%&% 6+"?,%=& ^ $0%; 7%%, #" &%#&% "7 .+-%#2; "+ 7%+("+ +%-4+1)#- &.20 6+"?,%=&S ?%24.&% $0%; 24# 64; 7"+ $0% &%+()2%& +%e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f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

=.-+/7 $%&;/#-2 &1 *"# 3#8 %+)" /0% 74=),; 6+"?,%=& "7 $0% #%H +)20 %=%+-% 7+"= &"=%H04$ 1)77%+%#$ 1;#4=)2& $04# $0"&% "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&S ?.$ =4#; "7 $0% +%&.,$& 4+% &)=),4+Y U"+ )#&$4#2%S $0% ="$0%+ )& "7$%# 4?&%#$ 7+"= $0% 74=),;S )# $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# 6#; O00#" +2%33 PO

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f7$%# $0% #4##)%& 4+% 7"+%)-# H"=%#S "+ )#1)-%#".& H"+C)#-:2,4&& H"=%#S "+S )# $0% N5>S &".$0%+#S ,"H%+:2,4&&S ?,42C H"=%#Y E0"%(%+ $0%; 4+%S $0% +)20 20),1+%# H),, &"=%$)=%& 7"+= 4 &$+"#- "%1)64, ?"#1 H)$0 $0%=Y f7$%#S H%4,$0; 20),1+%# ^ 422"+1)#- $" $0% $0%+46)&$& H0" H"+C H)$0 $0%= ^ H),, %R0)?)$ 4 W&6,)$ "%1)64,XS 04+?"+)#- 7%%,)#-& "7 ,"(% 4#1 04$% 7"+ $0% #4##; 4& H%,, 4& $0% ="$0%+ 4#1 74$0%+Y 5"=%$)=%& $0% 7%%,)#-& 7"+ $0% #4##; 4+% ="+% )#$%#&% $04# $0"&% 7"+ $0% 42$.4, ="$0%+ ^ )7 $0% ="$0%+ )& $"" 1)&$4#$S $"" 1)77)1%#$S $"" .#)#(",(%1 H)$0 0%+ 20),1+%# "# 4 14;:$":14; ?4&)&Y > -""1 %R4=6,% "7 $0)& ,4$$%+ )& $0% 24&% "7 d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` /0% 4?&%#2% "7 $0% ="$0%+S 4#1 $0% 6+%&%#2% "7 $0% #4##; )& 64+4,: ,%,%1 ?; $0% 4?&%#2% "7 $0% 74$0%+ 4#1 $0% 6+%&%#2% "7 =4,% &%+(4#$&Y /04$ )&S $0% 74$0%+S )# $0% #%H +)20 &$+4$4S )7 0% )& $0% "#% H0" 04& 2+%4$%1

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

PP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b.&$ 4& )# $0% =)11,% 2,4&&Y 94()#- ="+% ="#%;S &.20 $%%#& =4; ?%-)# $" 4?.&% %R6%#&)(% 1+.-&S &.20 4& 2"24)#%S <2&$4&;S ?4+?)$.+4$%& 4#1 %(%# 0%+")# ^ $" &4; #"$0)#- 4?".$ %4&; 422%&& $" %R6%#&)(% 04+1 ,)e."+&Y /0.&S 1+.- +%04?),)$4$)"# 4#1 4,2"0", +%04?),)$4$)"# 4+% 4,="&$ #"+=4$: )(% 4="#- $0% #%H +)20S 4#1 $0% &4=% &$;,% "7 $0%+46)&$& 4#1 2,)#)2& 4+% &".-0$ ".$ ^ %R2%6$ $04$ $0% +)20 24#S 4#1 1"S 64; ="+%Y U.+$0%+S b.&$ 4& $0% $%%#& "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& =4; 42$ ".$ $0%)+ $+".?,%&S "+ $0%)+ ="+4, 2"#7.&)"#&S $0+".-0 &%R.4,)$;S &" $""S =4; $0% $%%#& "7 $0% +)20Y /0% $%%#4-%+& "7 $0% #%H +)20 &"=%$)=%& 6.+6"&%,; 14$% W)#466+"6+)4$%X 64+$#%+&Y /04$ )&S $0%; 14$% ,"H%+:2,4&& 64+$#%+& "+

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# 6#; O00#" +2%33 PQ

+42)4,,; 1)77%+%#$ 64+$#%+& "+ %$0#)24,,; &$)-=4$)\%1 64+$#%+&Y /0)& =4; ?% 4 +%?%,,)"# 4-4)#&$ $0%)+ 64+%#$&S "+ )$ =4; ?% 4# "%1)64, )1%#$)7)24: $)"# H)$0 $0% #4##; ^ )# %)$0%+ 24&%S 6+%:=4+)$4, 6+%-#4#2; 2"#7+"#$& $0% 64+%#$& _4#1 $0% $%%#` H)$0 4 +%4, 6+"?,%=Y K)20 74=),)%& 742% $0% &4=% &%R.4,S &"2)4,S 4#1 ="+4, 6+"?,%= )# $0)& +%-4+1 4& =)11,%:2,4&& 74=),)%&S %R2%6$ 4-4)#S $0%; 24# 64; 7"+ 4# 4?"+: $)"# 4$ $0% ?%&$ 0"&6)$4,S )7 $0)& )& $0%)+ 20")2%S "+ 4++4#-% 7"+ 41"6$)"# $0+".-0 $0% ?%&$ 41"6$)"# 4-%#2;S "+ 4++4#-% 7"+ 4 #4##; $" 24+% 7"+ $0% ".$:"7:H%1,"2C 20),1Y >-4)#S "#,; $0% 7.#1)#- )& 1)77%+%#$Y *+"=)&2.)$; 4#1 1+.- 4#1 4,2"0", 4?.&% 4="#- .66%+:2,4&& $%%#4-%+& 4+% &)=),4+ )# 64$$%+#S )7 #"$ )# %R42$ 24.&4,)$;S $" $0"&% )# $0% =)11,% 2,4&&Y

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b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

PJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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f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a $0%; H4#$ $0% ?%&$ 1"2$"+& 4#1 $0% ?%&$ 0"&6)$4,&S 4#1 $0% 2.$$)#-:%1-% =420)#%&S =%1)2)#%& 4#1 $%20#)e.%&Y /0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& H),, 74("+ $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$ "7 0)-0:$%20 =%1)2)#% )# $0%)+ 2".#$+; ^ H0%$0%+ )$ ?% @%+=4#; "+ 5)#-46"+%Y >#1S H0%+% )$ )& #"$ .6 $" 64+S $0% +)20 H),, $+4(%, $" 4 ="+% .6:$":14$% #4$)"#Y /0)& 4?),)$; $" $+4(%, =%4#& $04$ $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& =4; 6.$ ,%&& 6+%&&.+%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# 6#; O00#" +2%33 PL

"# $0%)+ #4$)"# $" 1%(%,"6 %R2%,,%#$ ="1%+# =%1)2)#% $04# H),, $0% =)11,% 2,4&&Y 9"H%(%+S )# ="&$ 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#& ^ 1%(%,"6%1 "+ 1%(%,: "6)#- ^ 0)-0:$%20 =%1)2)#% %=%+-%& H)$0 &$+"#- ,%-)$)=4$)"# 7+"= 4,, 2,4&&%&Y E)$0 $0% 2"&$ "7 ="1%+# =%1)2)#% &C;+"2C%$)#- ^ 4#1 ;%$ 4=4\)#-,; %77%2$)(% ^ %(%# $0% #%H +)20 04(% &".-0$ 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6+"-+4=&Y M# #4$)"#& H0%+% 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 04& ?%%# =41% 6.?,)2 4#1 W7+%%X $" 4,, ^ $04$ )&S 64)1 7"+ $0+".-0 $4R%& ^ $0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& 04& 422%6$%1 $0)& &;&$%=S ?.$ 4+% H),,)#- $" 64; ="+% )7 $0%; 4+% #"$ &4$)&7)%1 H)$0 $0% #4$)"#4, &;&$%=Y 5"=%$)=%& $0)& =%4#& 64;)#- 6+)(4$% 1"2$"+& &6%2)4, 7%%&Y 5"=%$)=%& )$ =%4#& 64;)#- ?"#.&%& $" 0"&6)$4,& "+ 1"2$"+& $" -4)# =%1)24, &%+()2%& 74&$%+ _="()#- .6S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S "# 1"#"+ ,)&$& 7"+ "+-4# $+4#&6,4#$&`a "$0%+ $)=%& )$ =%4#& ,%4()#- ;".+ 2".#$+; 4#1 -")#- $" 4#"$0%+ H0)20 %R2%,& )# &"=% =%1)24, $%20#)e.%Y 3"+4, e.%&$)"#& ^ &.20 4&S W&0".,1 4 H%4,$0; )#1)()1.4, ?% 4,,"H%1 $" ="(% .6 "# 4# "+-4# 1"#"+ ,)&$S "+ -4)# ?%$$%+ 0"&6)$4, 24+% ?%24.&% "7 4 ="#%$4+; 1"#4$)"#VX ^ ?%2"=% 6",)$)24, 4#1 =%1)24, e.%&$)"#& 4#1 2"#7,)2$&Y 5$),,S %(%# H)$0 $0%&% ="+4, e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

QT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

M# <.+"6% $0% e.%&$)"# )& 1)77%+%#$' $0% #%H +)20 4+% 4&C)#- 0"H $0%; 24# )=6+"(% =%1)24, &%+()2%&S H0),% C%%6)#- $0% 2"&$& 2"#$4)#%1Y 5)#2% .#)(%+&4, 6.?,)2 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 4,+%41; %R)&$&S $0% 6+"?,%= )& )# 0",1: )#- $0% 2"&$& 1"H# H)$0".$ ,"&)#- 2.$$)#-:%1-% $%20#","-;Y /0)& )& (%+; 04+1 $" 420)%(%Y /0% #%H +)20 1" 74("+ 0",1)#- 2"&$& 1"H# ^ %(%# 204+-)#- )#1)()1.4,& 7"+ 2%+$4)# &%+()2%& ^ .#0%4+1 "7 .#$), $0% 8LJT& )# <.+"6%Y >#1 0%+%S $0% =)11,% 4#1 .66%+ &$+4$4 1)(%+-%Y U"+ $0% .66%+ &$+4$4 24# 477"+1 $" 64; ="+%S H0),% $0% =)11,% &$+4$4 24##"$Y >,, "(%+ $0% H"+,1S $0% +)20 4#1 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& 4+% 4$$%=6$)#- $" 2+%4$% 0)-0:$%20 =%1)24, &%+()2%&S 4#1 7)-.+% ".$ 0"H $" 64; 7"+ $0%=Y /0% .66%+ 2,4&& H),, b")# $0% =)11,% 2,4&& )# $0)& e.%&$S ?.$ =4; 1)(%+-% "# $0% e.%&$)"# "7 64;=%#$&Y E0%+% $0%+% )& 4 &$+"#- &"2)4,)&$ ="(%=%#$S "+ 4 $+41)$)"# "7 24+)#- 4="#- $0% %,)$%S $0% 2,4&&%& H),, ?% ,%&& 74+ 464+$Y E0%+% $0%+% )& 4 6.+% 246)$4,)&$ $+41)$)"# "+ 4# 4+)&$"2+4$)2 $+41)$)"# 4="#- $0% %,)$%S 4#1 H0%+% $0% =)11,% 4#1 6""+%+ 2,4&&%& 4+% ,%&& H%,,:"+-4#)\%1S $0%; =4; ?% 74+ 464+$ "# $0)&S 4& )# $0% N5> 4#1 )# B4$)# >=%+)24Y

I'().*+&3./ $%&;/#-2 &1 *"# 3#8 %+)" /0% #%H +)20S ,)C% $0% ",1 +)20S &%#1 $0%)+ 20),1+%# $" $0% ?%&$ &20"",& $0%; 24# 64; 7"+Y M# $0% N5>S ]+)$4)# 4#1 U+4#2%S $0)& =%4#& %,)$% 6+)(4$% &20"",&S ?"4+1)#- &20"",&S W6+%6X &20"",& 4#1 %,)$% .#)(%+&)$)%&Y M# $0% +%&$ "7 E%&$%+# <.+"6% 4#1 d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e.% $" =4C% &.+% $04$ $0% 20),1 &6"C% H)$0 4# %1.24$%1 %,)$)&$ 422%#$S 4#1 $04$ $0% 20),1 H4& ?%$$%+:%1.24$%1 $0%# 0)& "+ 0%+ W)#7%+)"+&XY /0)& )& #" ,"#-%+ $0% 24&%S 7"+ $0% #%H +)20 4+% #"$ 4# 4+)&$"2+42;S ?.$ +4$0%+ =%=?%+& "7 $0% 7)#4#2)4, "+ )#1.&$+)4, &$+4$4Y /0% #%H +)20 1" #"$ &%% $0%=&%,(%& 4& 4# 4+)&$"2+42;S %&6%2)4,,; &)#2% $0% -+%4$ &2)%#$)&$&S %#-)#%%+&S 4#1 &20",4+& "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$)%& $%#1 $" %=%+-% 7+"= $0% =)11,%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# 6#; O00#" +2%33 Q8

&$+4$4Y /0.&S )#$%,,%2$.4, &.6%+)"+)$; ^ H0)20 H4& 2,4)=%1 ?; $0% <.+"6%4# 4+)&$"2+42; 6+)"+ $" $0% $H%#$)%$0 2%#$.+; ^ 24# #" ,"#-%+ ?% 2,4)=%1Y /0% 2,"&%+ $0% ="1%+# .66%+ 2,4&&%& 4+% ,)#C%1 H)$0 6.+%,; ?.&)#%&& 42$)()$)%&S $0% ,%&& 4+)&$"2+4$)2 $0%)+ &$4$.& ?%2"=%&Y 5$),,S $0% #%H +)20 1" H4#$ $0%)+ 20),1+%# H%,,:%1.24$%1Y 9%#2%S $0% 6+%:&20"", 6+"-+4=& 4+% &$),, )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1S 4#1 $0%; &$),, &%%C $" 6+"()1% 4# %1-% $" $0% 20),1+%#Y >7$%+ 6+%:&20"", 4#1 #.+&%+; &20"",S $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% #%H +)20 -" $" %,)$% 6+)(4$% &20"",& 4#1 ?"4+1)#- &20"",&S "+S $0% ?%&$ 6.?,)2 &20"",&Y 5"S H04$ )& $0% 6+"?,%=V /0% 6+"?,%= )& $H":7",1' "#%S =4#; "7 $0% ]+)$)&0S >=%+)24# 4#1 U+%#20 %,)$% &20"",& 4+% &$),, &$+.2$.+%1 )# $0% ",1 4+)&$"2+4$)2 &$;,%S %=604&)\)#- ,)$%+4$.+%S ,4#-.4-%& 4#1 &$;,%S 4?"(% &2)%#2%S =4$0%=4$)2& 4#1 &.?&$4#2%Y >#1S $H"S =4#; "7 $0% 20),1+%# "7 $0% +)20 ,42C $0% ="$)(4$)"# 4#1 1+)(% "7 $0%)+ =)11,%:2,4&& 2"#$%=6"+4+)%&S ?%24.&% $0%; 4,+%41; 04(% %(%+;$0)#- $0%; =)-0$ 1%&)+% 4#1 $0%; ?%,)%(% $0%; 24# 2"#$)#.% $" -%$ %(%+;$0)#- H)$0".$ 04()#- $" %4+# )$Y M# $0% 7)+&$ )#&$4#2%S H0%+% $0% &20"",& %=604&)\% $0% ",1 W4+)&$"2+4$)2X $+41)$)"#S $0% &"# "+ 14.-0$%+ "7 $0% ?.&)#%&& $;2""# =4; 1%(%,"6 4 ,"(% 7"+ =.&)2 "+ 6"%$+; "+ 4+$ ^ 4#1 $0)& )& H"#1%+7., ^ ?.$ $0% &"# "+ 14.-0$%+ =4; 04(% 1%(%,"6%1 ,)$$,% &C),, 4$ %2"#"=)2& "+ &2)%#2%S 4#1 %(%# 4 1)&14)# 7"+ ?.&)#%&& 42$)()$)%&Y E% 4+% #"$ &.--%&$)#- $04$ $0% ,"(% 7"+ $0% 4+$& "+ 60),"&"60; )& &"=%0"H 4 ?41 $0)#- ^ e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d464# 4#1 $0% N5>Y 50% H4& 7"#1 "7 6.$$)#- .6 $0% d%H& 4#1 <4&$ M#1)4#& 4& %R4=6,%& "7 ="$)(4$%1 -+".6& H0" H%+% H),,)#- $" W1)+$; $0%)+ 04#1&X )# ?.&)#%&&Y /04$20%+ H4& %&6%2)4,,; 2+)$)24, "7 $0% fR7"+1 4#1 !4=: ?+)1-% -+41.4$%& H0" +%7.&%1 $" W+%:)#1.&$+)4,)\%X <#-,4#1Y /04$20%+S =)11,%:2,4&& 0%+&%,7S 4 /"+; 6",)$)24,,;S C#%H $04$ $0% ]+)$)&0 <=6)+%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

QA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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d"0# *4., @%$$;X& &"#S @"+1"# @%$$;S H0" -+41.4$%1 7+"= 6+%6 &20"", 4#1 4# M(; B%4-.% 2",,%-% H)$0 4 =4b"+ )# 2,4&&)24, =.&)2S 2"=%& $" =)#1S ?%24.&% @%$$;S d+ 1)1 #"$ 4$$%=6$ $" ?%2"=% 4 2,4&&)24, 2"=6"&%+a )#&$%41S 0% 4$$%=6$%1 $" ?%2"=% !
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@7&,%2 !"7A2#43 7$ 1(# 6#; O00#" +2%33 QD

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d4C4+$4Y [%$S $0%+% 4+% #4$)"#&S &.20 4& $0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%&S @%+=4#; 4#1 d464#S H0%+% $0% .66%+ &$+4$4 %#-4-% )# ,%&& W6,4;?";X 42$)()$; 4#1 $4C% ="+% 2"#$+)?.$"+; 4#1 6+"7%&: &)"#4, H"+C +",%&YP

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

QI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

P

!"# #)&3&-+) $%&;/#-2 &1 *"# 3#8 %+)" /0% #%H .66%+ 2,4&& 24# 7)#4#2% $0%)+ &"2)4, &%+()2%& 6+)(4$%,;S ?.$ $0%; 24##"$ 7)#4#2% $0%)+ %2"#"=)2 #%%1& 6+)(4$%,;g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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% E%,74+% 5$4$% 7"+ $0% G%H K)20

%2"#"=)2&Y M$ )& )# $0)& 2"#$%R$ $04$ ?.&)#%&&=%# 04(% 4,$%+%1 $0%)+ 6%+2%6$)"# "7 -"(%+#=%#$Y M+"#)24,,;S #"HS 4& H% ="(% )#$" $0% #%H =),,%##).=S 0)-0:$%20 7)#4#2)%+& 4#1 0)-0:$%20 2"+6"+4$% 6+"1.2%+& 4+% 4&C)#- $0% -"(%+#=%#$& "7 $0%)+ +%&6%2$)(% #4$)"#& $" &$%6 )# 4#1 "+20%&: $+4$% 4 W?4),".$X 6+"-+4= H0%#%(%+ $0%; =4C% 4 2","&&4, =)&$4C%S "+ H0%#%(%+ $0%; &.77%+ 7+"= .#6+%1)2$4?,% =4+C%$ 2;2,%&S 1"H# 2;2,%&S "+ .#%R6%2$%1 2",,46&%& )# "#% "+ 4#"$0%+ 6"+$)"# "7 $0% -,"?4, ?.&)#%&& &;&$%=Y E% 04(% ?%%# H)$#%&&)#-S 7+"= $0% 8LQT& $0+".-0 $" $0% 6+%&%#$S $0% %=%+-%#2% "7 4 #%HS H"+,1H)1% 6+"2%&& "7 -"(%+#=%#$:1)+%2$%1 ?4),".$& 7"+ )#1.&$+)4, 2"+6"+4$)"#&S 7)#4#2% 0".&%&S ?4#C&S %#$)+% )#1.&$+)%&S %#$)+% #4$)"#&S %#$)+% +%-)"#& 4#1S +%=4+C4?,;S %(%# +)20 )#1)()1.4,& )#(",(%1 )# &"=% =4b"+ 7)#4#2)4, 1)&4&$%+Y E% &04,, -)(% %R4=6,%& "7 4,, "7 $0%&% ?4),".$ 6+"-+4=& ?%,"HY /0)& 6+"2%&& )& e.)$% 74&2)#4$)#-S 4#1 04& 04&$%#%1 $0% $+.,; -,"?4, )#$%+$H)#)#- "7 4,, $0% H"+,1X& %2"#"=)%&Y /0%&% ?+),,)4#$ 6+"-+4=& 4+% .#1%+ $0% 1)+%2$)"# "7 4 2",,%2$)(% ,%41%+&0)6 "7 $0% ="&$ 41(4#2%1 %2"#"=)%& )# $0% H"+,1Y !.++%#$,; 24,,%1 $0% @QS 4#1 2.++%#$,; 41=)#: )&$%+%1 ?; $0% E"+,1 ]4#C 4#1 $0% M#$%+#4$)"#4, 3"#%$4+; U.#1S $0% 6+"-+4=& 4+% ,%1 ?; $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&S H0)20 )& $0% ,4+-%&$ 2"#$+)?.$"+ $" $0%&% )#$%+#4$)"#4, %2"#"=)2 )#&$)$.$)"#&S ?.$ $0% <.+"6%4#&S $0% ]+)$: )&0S 4#1 $0% d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b"+: )$)%& 4+% %=%+-)#-S H0),% "?&%+()#- $0%&% 0)-0,; 6.?,)2)\%1 ?4),".$&Y U4#$4&$)2 4& )$ =4; &%%=S $0% WH%,74+%X 6+"-+4= 7"+ $0% +)20 +%&%=?,%& $0% %4+,; H%,74+% 6+"-+4= 7"+ $0% 6""+S )# $04$ )$ %#$4),& 4 1)+%2$ ="#%$: 4+; &.?&)1; ^ $0% ?4),".$& "7 $0% +)20 )#(",()#- -)()#- ="#%; $" $0% ?4#C&S $0% &$"2C 4#1 ?"#1 0".&%&S $0% 2"+6"+4$)"#& "+ H0",% #4$)"#&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

QP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

>#1 $0% 0"6% )& $0% &4=% ^ 0"6% $04$ .&%1 $" 422"=64#; -)()#- ="#%; $" $0% 6""+ ^ $04$ )&S $04$ $0% ="#%; H".,1 ?% .&%1 H%,,S &%#&)?,;S )#$%,,)-%#$,;S 6+.1%#$,;S &" $04$ $0% %2"#"=)2 2"#1)$)"# "7 $0% +%2%)(%+ H".,1 ?% )=6+"(%1Y d.&$ 4& $0)& 0"6% "7$%# H%#$ 4&$+4; H)$0 $0% 6""+S &" $""S )$ "7$%# -"%& 4&$+4; H)$0 $0% +)20Y >+)&$"$,% &4)1 $04$ -)()#- ="#%; $" $0% 6""+ ^ )# $0% 7"+= "7 1)+%2$ ="#%$4+; &.?&)1; ^ H4& ,)C% W6".+)#- H4$%+ )#$" 4 ,%4C; b4+XY8 /0% ="+% ;". -)(%S $0% ="+% ;". H4&$%S 4#1 $0% ="+% ;". 04(% $" -)(% 4-4)#Y >+)&$"$,% &.--%&$%1 )#&$%41 $04$ $0% 6""+ ?% $+4)#%1 )# 4 $+41%S %1.24$%1 4#1 %#2".+4-%1 $" ?%2"=% )#(",(%1 6",)$)24,,;S &" $04$ $0%; H".,1 ?% 4?,% $" )=6+"(% $0%=&%,(%&YA M# $%+=& "7 $0% W,%4C; b4+X 7"+ $0% +)20S 1)+%2$ &.?&)1)%& )# M#1"#%&)4S ]+4\), 4#1 )# 64+$ )# K.&&)4S 3%R)2" 4#1 34,4;&)4S H%#$ &$+4)-0$ )#$" ,.R.+; -""1&S 5H)&& ]4#C 422".#$&S 4#1 &$"2C &6%2.,4$)"# ^ 4#1 $0%# ="+% 041 $" ?% -)(%#Y E0%+%4&S +%2%#$,; )# 3%R)2"S ]+4\),S K.&&)4 4#1 /04),4#1S =.20 "7 $0% ?4),".$ ="#%; H%#$ )#$" )#1.&$+)4, 4#1 7)#4#2)4, 1%(%,"6=%#$S &" $04$ %(%#$.4,,; &"=% "7 $0% ?4),".$ 2".,1 ?% +%64)1Y /0% 6")#$ )&S $04$S b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e.)$% =41 ^ "+ 6%+046& 4 Z%;#%&)4#YD [%$S $0)& ?4),".$ 64$$%+# 04& ?%2"=% )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1 4& 64+$ "7 $0% 64$$%+# "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,: )&$ %2"#"=;Y >,+%41; $0% M3U 4#1 $0% E"+,1 ]4#C 4+% 04,,"H%1 )#&$)$.: $)"#&S 422%6$%1 -,"?4,,;Y /0% "#,; "?b%2$)"#& $" $0%&% )#&$)$.$)"#& 04(% 2"=% 7+"= 2"#&%+(4$)(% >=%+)24# 6",)$)2)4#& 4#1 &"=% d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( QQ

.#1%+&$""1 ^ ,""C 4$ $0% 1)&4-+%%=%#$& 4="#- $0% 4241%=)2 %2"#": =)&$& $04$ %R)&$%1 $0%# 4#1 #"HY /0%&% 1)&4-+%%=%#$& 04(% %#-%#1%+%1 (4+)".& &20"",& "7 $0".-0$S +4#-)#- 7+"= 2,4&&)24, $" #%":2,4&&)24, $" Z%;#%&)4# $" #%":Z%;#%&)4#S 4#1 $" =4#; "$0%+ &20"",& "7 $0".-0$S 7+"= W="#%$4+)&$&XS &.20 4& 3),$"# U+)%1=4#X& !0)24-" 520"",SI $" W7)&24,)&$&XS &.20 4& $0% 6"&$:Z%;#%&)4# !4=?+)1-% &20"",O $" $0% 2"+6"+4$% W6,4##%+&X )# @4,?+4)$0X& $+41)$)"#SP $" ".$+)-0$ &$4$)&$& &.20 4& $0% d464#%&% %2"#"=)2 ?.+%4.2+4$&YQ !%#$+4, $" $0% ",1 4#1 #%H 1)&4-+%%=%#$& 04& ?%%# $0% +",% "7 $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )# %2"#"=)2 42$)()$)%&Y 9"H%(%+S $0".-0 $0)& 1%?4$% )& $0%"+%$)24,,; (%+; )=6"+$4#$S $0% 42$.4, 6+42$)2% "7 ="1%+# -"(%+#: =%#$& 04& &.6%+&%1%1 $0% $0%"+%$)24, 1%?4$%Y U"+S 4& H% 4+% 4$$%=6$)#$" &0"HS ="&$ ="1%+# -"(%+#=%#$& 04(% ?%2"=% e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`SJ ?.$S "7 2".+&%S $0%; H%+% H+"#-S 4#1 $0%)+ &;&$%= 74),%1S &$.,$)7)%1 ?; ?.+%4.2+4$)2 +%1 $46%Y /0% %77)2)%#2; 4#1 2+%4$)()$; "7 =4+C%$ 1;#4=)2& H4& #%2%&&4+; 7"+ $0% 6+"6%+ 7.#2$)"#)#- "7 ="1%+# )#1.&$+)4,)&=Y 9"H%(%+S =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2& 4#1 )$& 7)#4#2)4, )#&$)$.$)"#& 6+%:%R)&$%1 $0% )#1.&$+)4, +%(",.$)"#S 4#1S )# 64+$S -%#%+4$%1 $0% )#1.&$+)4, +%(",.: $)"#SL 4#1 $0%# =%+-%1 H)$0 )#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$)"# ^ %#-%#1%+)#- $0% 246)$4,)&$:)#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$)(% 6+"2%&& H0)20 $0%# %(",(%1 $"H4+1& )$& 0)-0:$%20 604&%Y8T /"14;S =4+C%$ 1;#4=)2& 4#1 0)-0:$%20 742$"+; 6+"1.2$)"# )#$%+,"2C ^ ?.$ &$),,S 4& c%?,%#88 4&&%+$%1S &%%= $" 2"#$4)# $H" (%+; 1)77%+%#$ %2": #"=)2 6+"2%&&%&' $0% $,-%-&,%2 3#.4#-1 2+%4$%& 246)$4, H%4,$0 4#1 6+%&&.+%& $"H4+1 %77)2)%#$ ?.&)#%&& =4#4-%=%#$ _4#1S 4& =%#$)"#%1S )$ 6+%:%R)&$%1 $0% )#1.&$+)4, +%(",.$)"#S %=%+-)#- 1.+)#- $0% $+41%:246)$4,: )&$ %+4 )# $0% =4+C%$ 2)$)%& "7 K%#4)&&4#2% M$4,;S 94#&%4$)2 @%+=4#; 4#1 <#,)-0$%#=%#$ ]+)$4)# 4#1 U+4#2%`S8A H0),% $0% 0"79<&#" &%-=%#$8D 2+%4$%& $0% )#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$&S 4#1 $0% 742$"+; &;&$%= 7"+ $0% 2+%4$)"# "7 $0"&% 6+"1.2$&S 4#1 %#2".+4-%& $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$S )##"(4$)"#S 4#1 466,)24$)"# "7 &2)%#$)7)2 $%20#","-; $" $0% 6+"1.2$)(% 6+"2%&&Y8I ]"$0 %#1& "7 $0% &;&$%= 04(% #"H ?%2"=% 0)-0:$%20S .$),)\)#2"=6.$%+& 4#1 41(4#2%1 2"==.#)24$)"#& $%20#","-; 7"+ 246)$4,

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

QJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

="(%=%#$S 6+"1.2$)"# 4#1 1)&$+)?.$)"#Y >#1 ?"$0 $0% 7)#4#2)4, 4#1 $0% 6+"1.2%+ &%-=%#$& "7 $0% &;&$%= 4+% #"H -,"?4,Y @)(%# $0% )#2+%4&)#- #.=?%+ 4#1 2"&$ "7 ?4),".$&S "#% =)-0$ H"#1%+ )7 H% H),, ?%-)# $" 0%4+ H"+,1:H)1% 64+,)4=%#$4+; 1%?4$%& "(%+ H0%$0%+ H% &0".,1 04(% WH%,74+%X "+ WH"+C74+%X 7"+ $0% +)20Y /04$ )&S &0".,1 $0% ?4),".$& 2"#$)#.%S "+ &0".,1 $0%; ?% ="+% 24+%7.,,; ="#)$"+%1S &" $04$ $0% ="#%; 7,"H& $" +%4, %2"#"=)2 4#1 7)#4#2)4, 1%(%,"6=%#$S +4$0%+ $04# )#$" >+)&$"$,%X& W,%4C; b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d464#Y E4+ 6+"1.2$)"# 7.,,; +%()$4,: )\%1 $0"&% %2"#"=)%&S H0),% $"14;S )$ )& $0% 6%42%$)=% %2"#"=)%& H0)20 #%%1 &.&$4)#)#-Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( QL

M# $%+=& "7 )#1)()1.4, 2"+6"+4$)"#& )# $0% N5> H0)20 H".,1 04(% 74),%1 H)$0".$ -"(%+#=%#$ 0%,6S !0+;&,%+ 4#1 B"2C0%%1 &$4#1 ".$Y M# $0% 24&% "7 !0+;&,%+S =4+C%$ 2"=6%$)$)"# 7+"= d464# 4#1 @%+=4#;S 4#1 $0% 74),.+% "7 =4#4-%=%#$ $" ="(% $"H4+1 4 2"=642$ ,)#% "7 24+&S &)=6,; H".,1 04(% 6.$ !0+;&,%+ ".$ "7 ?.&)#%&&Y /0% !=%+: )24# 3"$"+X& d%%6S -%#%+4$%1 4 $+%#1 )# ,.R.+; b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d464#%&% -"(%+#=%#$ ?4),%1 ".$ F4$&.# ^ )$ )& #"H G)&&4# ^ H0),% )# 8LLJS $0% Z"+%4# -"(%+#=%#$ 4++4#-%1 7"+ 4 ?4),".$ "7 ZM> >.$"="$)(%S H0)20 04& #"H ?%%# 4?&"+?%1 ?; 9;.#14) 3"$"+&Y M7 $0% 4#&H%+ )& $04$ -"(%+#=%#$& &0".,1 ?4),".$ $0%&% C%; 2"+6"+4$% 6+"1.2%+ .#)$&S $0%# H04$ &0".,1 H% 24,, $0)& #%H 7"+= "7 246)$4,)&=' W7+%% =4+C%$ 6,.&X ^ 7+%% =4+C%$ 6,.& 2"+6"+4$% H%,74+%V >,="&$ %(%+; =4b"+ #4$)"# 04& 041 $" 0%,6 "#% "+ ="+% "7 )$& 2"+% 6+"1.2%+ .#)$& )# $0% ,4&$ $H%#$; ;%4+&Y @%+=4#; 4#1 /0% G%$0%+,4#1& 041 $" )=6"&% &$+)2$ $4+)77 4#1 )=6"+$ ,)=)$4$)"# e."$4& "# d464#%&% %,%2$+"#)2 6+"1.2$& )# "+1%+ $" &4(% ]+4.# 4#1 *0),,)6&Y M$4,; 041 $"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

JT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( J8

8-9<31")D;,9# A%,27<13 M# $0% <.+"6%4# !"=="# 34+C%$S 1.+)#- $0% 8LPT& 4#1 8LQT&S 4 2+)&)& "22.++%1 )# $0% %#$)+% %,%2$+"#)2& )#1.&$+;Y /0% d464#%&% H%+% =4C)#$%,%()&)"# &%$&S +41)"&S &$%+%"& 4#1 c!K& 20%46%+ 4#1 ?%$$%+ $04# $0% <.+"6%4# 2"=64#)%&Y 50".,1 $0% @%+=4#&S F.$20S U+%#20 4#1 M$4,)4#& 4,,"H $0% H0",% %,%2$+"#)2& )#1.&$+; $" -" .#1%+S 4#1 422%6$ d464#%&% 1"=)#4$)"# "7 $0% =4+C%$V /0% !"=="# 34+C%$ #4$)"#& 1%2)1%1 $04$ )$ H".,1 ?% 4-4)#&$ $0%)+ #4$)"#4, 4#1 =),)$4+; )#$%+%&$& $" 4,,"H $0% d464#%&% $" 7.,,; 2"#$+", &.20 4 2+.2)4, 4#1 %R64#1)#- =4+C%$Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% & 4#"$0%+ %R4=6,% "7 )#1.&$+;:H)1% ?4),".$&S )# $0% N5>S $0% =)2+": 20)6 )#1.&$+; ^ H0)20 $0% N5 041 6+".1,; 6)"#%%+%1 ^ H4& )# 14#-%+ "7 -")#- .#1%+ ^ 4-4)#S ?%24.&% "7 d464#%&% 2"=6%$)$)"#YAT /0% d464#%&% H%+% ?%-)##)#- $" 1" $" $0% =)2+":20)6 )#1.&$+; H04$ $0%; 041 1"#% $" $0% /c 4#1 c!K )#1.&$+; )# $0% N5>' .#1%+&%,, $0%= 4#1 6.$ $0%= ".$ "7 ?.&)#%&&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

&.?&)1)\% >,74 K"=%" 4#1 &%$ $4+)77& 4#1 e."$4& "# d464#%&% 6+"1.2$& )# "+1%+ $" &4(% f,)(%$$)X& %=%+-)#- 2"=6.$%+ )#1.&$+;Y U+4#2% 041 $" ?4),: ".$ K%#4.,$ 3"$"+& #.=%+".& $)=%&Y >#1 ]+)$4)#S 74),)#- $" ?4),".$ d4-.4+ 4#1 K",,&:K";2%S 4,,"H%1 $0%&% 2"=64#)%& $" ?% $4C%# "(%+ ?; 7"+%)-# 2"=6%$)$"+& ^ U"+1 4#1 ]3E +%&6%2$)(%,;Y 50".,1 ]+)$4)# 04(% W&4(%1X d4-.4+ 4#1 K",,&:K";2%V

E0%$0%+ $0% d464#%&% H%+% %#-4-)#- )# W.#74)+X ?.&)#%&& 6+42$)2%& ^ W1.=6)#-X =)2+":20)6& )#$" $0% >=%+)24# =4+C%$ ?%,"H $0% =4+C%$ 6+)2% )# "+1%+ $" 1%&$+"; $0% 2"=6%$)$)"# ^ "+ H0%$0%+ $0% d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d464#%&% 2"=: 64#)%&S ?.$ $" ,%41 $0% -,"?4, )#1.&$+; )#$" 4 #%H 4-% "7 +%=4+C4?,% )##"(4$)"#& )# 0)-0:$%20 6+"1.2$& 4#1 #%$H"+C&Y /0% d464#%&% -"(%+#=%#$ ^ H0)20 )& ,)#C%1 $" )$& ?4#C& 1)+%2$,; _.#,)C% ]+)$)&0 4#1 >=%+)24# ?4#C&S H0)20 4+% 6+)(4$%,; "H#%1` ^ "#.#1 .#$), $0% /04)S 34,4;&)4# 4#1 M#1"#%&)4# %2"#"=)2 2",,46&%S $0% d464#%&% &;&$%= 041 ?%%# &.22%&&7.,Y G"HS $0% H0",% ?4#C)#- )#1.&$+; "7 d464#S 4,"#- H)$0 $0% H0",% 2"#-,"=%+4$% &;&$%=S 04& 041 $" ?% ?4),%1 ".$ ?; $0% -"(%+#=%#$Y /0% +%&.,$ "7 $0)& .#6+%2%1%#$%1,; ,4+-% 4#1 2"=6+%0%#&)(% ?4),".$ )& #"$ ;%$ 2,%4+ _8LLL`S $0".-0 )$ ,""C& 4& $0".-0 $0% 6+"-+4= H),, ?% &.22%&&7., )# $0% ,"#- +.#Y E% 04(% 7"2.&%1 "# $0% &.22%&&7., )#1.&$+;:H)1% ?4),".$&S ?.$ $0%+% 04(% ?%%# 74),.+%& 4& H%,,Y /0% U+%#20 4.$" )#1.&$+; 04& #%(%+ +%4,,; ?%%# &.22%&&7.,S %(%# 47$%+ =4#; -"(%+#=%#$ ?4),".$&Y /0% Z"+%4# W&(7#A723X _K%,A%13<`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

JA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

W1%+)(4$)(%&X )& #"$ 2,%4+,; 1%7)#%1 ,%-4,,; )# $%+=& "7 W)#&)1%+ )#7"+=4: $)"#XS =4+-)# ?"++"H)#-S &6%2.,4$)"#:1+)(%# &$"2C 4#1 ?"#1 $+%#1&S 4#1 ?%24.&% $0% ?4),".$ 6+"2%&& =4; )#(",(% )#$%+2"##%2$%1 -,"?4, 7)#4#2)4, $+4#&42$)"#& "7 4 (%+; 2"=6,)24$%1 #4$.+%YAI E0%#%(%+ %.60%=)&=& "+ .#2,%4+ $%+=& 4+% .&%1 $" 1%&2+)?% 60%#"=: %#4S ?%H4+%Y /%+=& ,)C% 1%+)(4$)(%&S ,%(%+4-%1 4+?)$+4-%S b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e.)2C,; H"+C%1 ".$ 4 ?4),".$ 642C4-% 1%&)-#%1 $" ?+)#- $0% &$"2C =4+C%$ ?42C .6Y /0% ?4),".$ 642C4-%S 1%&2+)?%1 )# 4+$)2,%&S ?""C&S 4#1 ,%2$.+%&S ?; B%&$%+ /0.+"H "7 3M/SAO 2"#&)&$%1 "7 ?),,)"#& "7 1",,4+& -)(%# $" ?4#C& H0)20 041 ,%#$ $0% ?),,)"#& $" $0% &$"2C =4+C%$ 7)+=& 4#1 $0%)+ 6+)(4$% 4#1 )#&$)$.$)"#4, )#(%&$"+& _6%#&)"# 7.#1&S =.$.4, 7.#1&S )#&.+4#2% 2"=64#)%&`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( JD

JI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

H%+% +%:&$+.2$.+%1 H0%+% $0%)+ ,"&&%& 041 ?%%# 0.-%S &" $04$S 4& H)$0 $0% ?4#C&S #%H #4=%& "+ 0;60%#4$%1 #4=%& #"H 1"=)#4$% $0% &$"2C =4+C%$ 7)+=&YAQ

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b%2$& 4#1 $"" 7%H )#1.&$+)4, 6+"b%2$&Y E)$0 $0% 6+%2)6)$".& 1%2,)#% "7 $0% 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4# %2"#"=)%&S $0% d464#%&% 4#1 $0% 9"#- Z"#- !0)#%&% 742%1 4 &.11%# 2+)&)&Y U"+ $0%; 041 )#(%&$%1 0%4(),; )# $0%&% %2"#"=)%&S 4#1 #"H $0%; H%+% ,"&)#- $0%)+ )#(%&$=%#$&Y >#1 )# $0% 24&% "7 $0% d464#%&%S $0%; H%+% ,"&)#- 4 ,4+-% #%H =4+C%$ 7"+ $0%)+ -""1&S 4,"#- H)$0 $0%)+ )#(%&$=%#$&Y d464#%&% 4#1 9"#- Z"#- ?4#C& 2",,46&%1S $0%)+ &$"2C =4+C%$& 2+4&0%1S $0%)+ 2.++%#2)%& ^ %&6%2)4,,; $04$ "7 9"#- Z"#- ^ 6,.==%$%1 )# (4,.%Y E)$0 $0% 1%2,)#% "7 $0% d464#%&% 4#1 9"#- Z"#- 2.++%#2)%& 4#1 &$"2C&S >=%+)24#S ]+)$)&0 4#1 <.+"6%4# )#(%&$"+& 4#1 &6%2.,4$"+& ?%-4# $" ,"&% $0%)+ )#(%&$=%#$& 4#1 $0%)+ ?%$&YAJ >& H)$0 $0% 3%R)24# 24&%S $0% >&)4# 24&% 24,,%1 7"+ 4 ?4),".$Y M# $0)& 24&%S ]+)$)&0 4#1 <.+"6%4# )#(%&$"+& H%+% 4& 0%4(),; )#(",(%1 4& >=%+)24# )#(%&$"+&S 4#1S "7 2".+&%S &" $"" H%+% $0% d464#%&% 4#1 !0)#%&% )#(%&$"+&Y /0)& ?4),".$ ^ ?%24.&% "7 $0% &24,% 4#1 7.,, -,"?4, %#$4#-,%=%#$ ^ %#-%#1%+%1 4 &%+)%& "7 %2"#"=)2 &$%6&S &" 1)77%+%#$ 7+"= $04$ H0)20 )&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# $,-%-&,%2 A%,27<13 .7 .27A%2

1%&2+)?%1 )# $0% %2"#"=)2 $%R$?""C& $04$ $0%; =.&$ ?% &%%# 4& +%(",.: $)"#4+;Y [%$S $0%&% &$%6& 04(% ?%%# )#$%+6+%$%1 4& 4?%++4$)"#&S 4#1 $0% $0%"+; 04& #"$ ?%%# 4=%#1%1Y _Z.0#SAL 2"=% ".$ "7 ;".+ -+4(%S 4#1 0",1 4 &%=)#4+ H)$0 $0% #%":2,4&&)24, =4+C%$ $0%"+)&$& "# W64+41)-= &0)7$&XS 6,%4&%g`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`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e.)%$ "# $0% U%1X& ?4),".$ 6+"-+4= )# $0% N5>Y /04$ )&S $0% 9"#- Z"#- -"(%+#=%#$ 42$.4,,; ?".-0$ .6 AT^DT 6%+ 2%#$ "7 4,, $0% 9"#- Z"#- &$"2C& "# $0%)+ "H# &$"2C %R204#-% ^ 4#1 -.4+4#$%%1 $04$ $0% =4+C%$ H".,1 #"$ 1+"6 )# (4,.%Y /0%; W&4(%1X $0%)+ &$"2C =4+C%$ 7+"= 2",,46&%Y >#1 $0%; 4+$)7)2)4,,; &$4?),)\%1 $0% 9"#- Z"#- 2.++%#2;S +%7.&)#- $" 4,,"H )$ $" 7,"4$ $" 4 ,"H%+%1 (4,.%Y U.+$0%+S $0%; ?4),%1 ".$ $0% 9"#- Z"#- ?4#C& 4#1 &.66"+$%1 $0% ,4+-% 6+)(4$% )#(%&$"+& H0" 041 ,"&$ ?)- ="#%; )# 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4YD8 /0% +%&.,$ )# 9"#- Z"#- H4& &)=),4+ $" $0% +%&.,$ )# $0% N5> 4#1 <.+"6%' $0% -"(%+#=%#$ 041 &$%66%1 )# 4#1 42$)(%,; &4(%1 $0% 7)#4#2)4,

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( JO

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d464#%&% H%+% 04+1%&$ 0)$ ?; $0% >&)4# 2",,46&%Y /0%; 041 $0% ,4+-%&$ $"$4, )#(%&$=%#$ )# /04),4#1S M#1"#%&)4S 34,4;&)4 4#1 %(%# c)%$#4= ^ 4,, "7 H0)20 041 2",,46&)#- %2"#"=)%&Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% d464#: %&% 041 $" 42$ "# $0%)+ "H#S 4& H%,, 4& )# 2"#2%+$ H)$0 $0% M3UY 9"H%(%+S $0% d464#%&% %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= )& 1)77%+%#$Y M$ #%(%+ 041 ?%%# 2%,33#KD$%,"#S )# $0%"+; "+ )# 6+42$)2%Y /0% d464#%&% 04(% 4,H4;& 041 4 W-.)1%1 =4+C%$XSDA )# H0)20 $0% -"(%+#=%#$ ?.+%4.2+42;S $0% ?4#C& 4#1 $0% )#1.&$+)4, 2"#-,"=%+4$%& _K%,A%13<` 4,, H"+C%1 $"-%$0%+S 4$ 4,, $)=%&Y /0% d464#%&% %2"#"=; 041 ?%%# ,%-%#14+; )# )$& &$%41; -+"H$0 7+"= $0% 8LOT& $" $0% 8LLT&Y >#1S $0% d464#%&% 041 6+)1%7.,,; ?%-.# $" 20)1% $0% >=%+)24# 4#1 ]+)$)&0 %2"#"=)&$& 4#1 ?.&)#%&&=%# H0" $4,C%1 2%,33#KD$%,"# 4#1 7+%% =4+C%$Y /0% d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d464#%&% 6+"1.2$& ".$ "7 $0%)+ =4+C%$& .#$), $0%; 24.-0$ .6Y ].$ )# 8LLQ^LJ $0% d464#%&% -"(%+#=%#$ ?.+%4.2+4$& 4#1 )#1.&$+)4, ,%41%+& 041 %#2".#$%+%1 $0%)+ 7)+&$ 74),.+%Y M# 4 W&04=% 2.,$.+%XS ,)C% d464#X&S )$ )& 04+1 $" 42$S "#2% ;". 04(% ?%%# &04=%1Y /0% d464#%&% ,%41%+& H%+% &$.##%1 4#1 7+"\%# 7"+ 4 H0),%Y U)#4,,;S 0"H%(%+S $0%; ?%-4# $" 42$Y G" ?,4=% H4& 24&$Y /0%; +%7.&%1 $" %,)=)#4$% .#&.22%&&7., ?4#C&Y 9"H%(%+S $0%; 04(% ?4),%1 ".$ $0% )=6"+$4#$ ?4#C& 4#1 604&%1 1"H# $0% 1%4,)#-& "7 $0% ,%&& %77)2)%#$ ?4#C&Y /0% d464#%&% %2"#"=)2 ,%41%+& 041 $" &0"+% .6 $0% +%4,:%&$4$% =4+C%$S ?%24.&% )# d464# =4#; "7 $0% &$"2C& 041 ?%%# ?42C%1 ?; +%4,:%&$4$% 0",1)#-& _+%4,:%&$4$% (4,.%& 4+% 4&$+"#"=)24,,; 0)-0 )# 2+"H1%1 d464#`Y /0% &$"2C =4+C%$ 04& 2"=%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

JP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

&,"H,; ?42C .6Y /0%#S $0% ;%# H4& &$4?),)\%1 4+$)7)2)4,,; ?; $%=6"+4+; -"(%+#=%#$ 42$)"#&Y ].$ H04$ "7 $0% 2"#-,"=%+4$%& H0)20 4+% 0%4(),; )#(%&$%1 )# 74),)#%2"#"=)2 1%(%,"6=%#$ 4$$%=6$& )# 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4V /0% d464#%&% 4+% 0"6)#- $04$ $0% M3U ?4),".$ "7 $0%&% %2"#"=)%& H),, ?% &.77)2)%#$ $" +%()(% $0%= &.77)2)%#$,; &" $04$ $0% d464#%&% b")#$ (%#$.+%& 4#1 $0% =4+C%$ 7"+ d464#%&% -""1& H),, +)&% 4-4)#Y /0% d464#%&% %2"#"=; )& &,"H,; =4C)#- 4 2"=%?42CY /0% &)$.4$)"# )# Z"+%4 )& &)=),4+ $" $04$ )# d464#S ?.$ $0% 2.+% H),, $4C% =.20 ,"#-%+ $04# $04$ "7 d464# ^ Z"+%4X& =%#$"+Y <(%+;$0)#- &4)1 4?".$ d464# ^ )# $%+=& "7 $0% W-.)1%1 =4+C%$X &;&$%= 4#1 $0% W>&)4# U,.X 2",,46&% ^ 0",1& 7"+ Z"+%4Y 9"H%(%+S ?%24.&% $0% Z"+%4# %2"#"=; )& #"$ ;%$ 7.,,; %&$4?,)&0%1S $0% 2+4&0 H4& =.20 H"+&% )# )$& $"$4, %77%2$Y /0% Z"+%4# K%,A%13< _&(7#A723` 04(% &24,%1 ?42C &.?&$4#$)4,,;S $0% H0",% %2"#"=; 2"#$+42$)#-Y >#1 )$ H),, ?% ;%4+& ?%7"+% Z"+%4 ?%-)#& 4 &.&: $4)#%1 -+"H$0 6%+)"1 4-4)#Y /0%+% 04& ?%%# N5 4#1 d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`S $0% N5 -"(%+#=%#$ 4#1 E4,, 5$+%%$ ,%41%+& 4+% =%%$)#- $" 2+%4$% 4 ?4),".$ 6+"-+4= 7"+ ]+4\),S H0"&% 2.++%#2; 04& ?%2"=% 1%(4,.%1 4#1 H0"&% ,"4#& 4+% $"" 0.-% $" +%64; Y Y Y >=%+)24#S <.+"6%4#S 4#1 d464#%&% )#(%&$=%#$& )# ]+4\), 4+% &" ,4+-%S $04$ Y Y Y 8-1#"-%1,7-%2 A%,27<13B 1(# '7"29 J%-I %-9 1(# 8-1#"-%1,7-%2 ?7-#1%") P<-9 /0% (%+; W-,"?4,#%&&X "7 $0% -,"?4, %2"#"=; )& ?%&$ ),,.&$+4$%1 ?; $0% %R)&$%#2% 4#1 42$)()$; "7 $0% E"+,1 ]4#C 4#1 $0% M#$%+#4$)"#4, 3"#%$: 4+; U.#1Y 3"#%; )& -4$0%+%1 $0+".-0 $0%&% -,"?4, )#&$)$.$)"#& 7+"= $0% @Q 4#1 "$0%+& ^ $0% @Q ?%)#-' $0% N5>S !4#414S @+%4$ ]+)$4)#S @%+=4#; 4#1 $0%
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( JQ

)# $0% %#$)+% &;&$%=S )7 $0% &)$.4$)"# )& &%+)".& %#".-0Y >& 1%&2+)?%1S $0%+% 04(% 4,+%41; ?%%# 4 &%+)%& "7 ?4),".$&S 4#1 $0%+% .#1".?$%1,; H),, ?% ="+% ^ $0% K.&&)4# &)$.4$)"# )& 4,+%41; +)6% 7"+ 4#"$0%+ +".#1 "7 42$)"# _8LLL`Y M# &"=% #4$)"#&S $0% ?4),".$ 6+"-+4= )& H%,, 2+47$%1S H%,, )=6,%: =%#$%1S 4#1 +46)1,; &.22%&&7.,Y M# "$0%+ #4$)"#&S $0% 6+"-+4= 04& 041 ,)$$,% %77%2$S ="+% 246)$4, ?%)#- =)&&6%#$S H4&$%1S "+ &$",%#Y G" "#% ;%$ C#"H& H0)20 H4; $0% K.&&)4# 24&% H),, -"Y d.&$ $" ),,.&$+4$% $04$ #4$)"#& 24#S 4#1 1"S 204#-%S $" $0% &.+6+)&% 4#1 1%,)-0$ "7 =4#;S $0% 3%R)24#& ^ H0" 041 ?%%# )#74=".& 7"+ =)&=4#4-)#7.#1&S &$%4,)#- 7.#1& 4#1 422.=.,4$)#- 6%+&"#4, 7"+$.#%& )# 7"+%)-# ?4#C& ^ &.22%&&7.,,; )#(%&$%1 $0% ?4),".$ 7.#1&S 4#1 H)$0 $0% $.$%,4-% "7 >=%+)24# 2"+6"+4$% 1%(%,"6%+&S 2+%4$%1 &"=% &",)1 W6+"1.2%+ .#)$&X H0)20 04(% ?%2"=% 6+"7)$4?,% %#".-0S &" $04$ $0% N5 ,"4#& 2".,1 ?% 64)1 ?42CY f# $0% "$0%+ &)1% $0%+% )& K.&&)4S H0%+%)# <.+"6%4# 4#1 >=%+)24# )#(%&$"+& ?%,)%(%1 $0%; H".,1 04(% 4 &47%+ &%$ "7 )#(%&$=%#$ "66"+$.#: )$)%& $04# )# 3%R)2"Y K.&&)4 04& $0% $%20#","-)24, %R6%+$)&% 4#1 $0% +)20 #4$.+4, +%&".+2%& $" 2+%4$% 4# %R64#&)(% )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=;Y 9"H: %(%+S $0% )#(%&$"+& 1)1 #"$ 2".#$ "# $0% K.&&)4# ?.&)#%&&=%# 42$)#- ,)C% 2"==.#)&$ 2"==)&&4+& _H0)20 =4#; "7 $0%= 041 ?%%#`S "+ "# $0% "+-4#)\%1 2+)=)#4, %,%=%#$ H0)20 041 -+"H# .6 )# K.&&)4 H0%# $0% ?,42C =4+C%$ H4& $0% "#,; &".+2% "7 &24+2% 2"#&.=%+ -""1&Y 34#; W?.&)#%&&=%#X &$",% $0% )#(%&$=%#$& ".$+)-0$S "+ .&%1 =47)4: &$;,% ()",%#2% $" 2"#$+", ?4#C& 4#1 )#1.&$+)%&Y f$0%+& ;%$S )# 7)#1)#$0%)+ )#1.&$+)%& .#6+"7)$4?,% ?%24.&% "7 ".$14$%1 %e.)6=%#$ 4#1 "(%+:&$477%1 H"+C7"+2%&S &)=6,; 1)&=4#$,%1 $0% 742$"+)%& 4#1 &",1 "77 %(%+;$0)#- $0%; 2".,1S )#&$%41 "7 )#(%&$)#- $0% ,"4#& )#$" 6,4#$ ="1%+#: )\4$)"#YDI M# &0"+$S $0% K.&&)4# 2",,46&% H4& #"$ 7.,,; 4(%+$%1 ?; $0% M3U ?4),".$S 4#1 #"H $0% @Q 4+% H"#1%+)#- H0%$0%+ 4#; 7.+$0%+ ?4),".$& =4C% &%#&%Y 5$),,S $0% K.&&)4# %2"#"=; &0"H& $0% 6"$%#$)4, 7"+ -%#.)#% &.22%&&7., 0)-0:$%20 6+"1.2$)"#S 4#1 $0%+%7"+%S $0% ,"4# 6+"-+4=& H),, 6+"?4?,; ?% +%&.=%1Y /" &.= .6 "#2% 4-4)#' WH%,74+% &$4$% +%(%#.%S )# $0% 7"+= "7 M3U: "+20%&$+4$%1 ?4),".$& "7 $+".?,%1 %2"#"=)%&S 04(% ?%2"=% 64+$ "7 $0% H"+,1 %2"#"=;Y 5" =.20 &"S $04$S 4& 6+%()".&,; =%#$)"#%1S H% =4; #%%1 4 #%H #4=% 7"+ $0% %2"#"=)2 &;&$%=Y /0% -,"?4, 7+%% =4+C%$ %2"#"=;S 0"H%(%+S 97#3 "6%+4$% "# =4+C%$ 6+)#2)6,%& ^ =4+C%$ 1;#4=)2& 4+% %&&%#$)4, $" )$& 7.#2$)"#)#-Y 9"H%(%+S )$ 04& ?%%# 2,%4+ &)#2% 8LALS 4#1 )$ )& ?%2"=)#- %(%+ ="+% 2,%4+S $04$ -"(%+#=%#$& =.&$ 42$ )# 4 6+":42$)(% 4#1 &.66"+$)(% =4##%+ ^ #"$ $" +%-.,4$% 4#1 )#0)?)$

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

JJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( JL

$0% =4+C%$S ?.$ $" W&0"+% )$ .6X H)$0 4 W&47%$;:#%$X "7 "#-")#- ,"4# 6+"-+4=&Y

/0% ?4),".$ "7 $0% 0%1-% 7.#1 WB"#-:/%+= !46)$4,X H4& "+20%&$+4$%1 ?; $0% >=%+)24# U%1%+4, K%&%+(% ]"4+1S H0)20 "+-4#)\%1 6+)(4$% 246)$4, 7"+ $0% +%&2.%Y /0% +%&2.% "6%+4$)"# H4& &)=),4+ $" $04$ 7"+ ?4#C& 4#1 7)#4#2% 0".&%&Y ].$S 0%1-% 7.#1& 4+% 1)77%+%#$Y 9%+% )& $0% C%; 1)77%+%#2%' 0%1-%:7.#1 =4#4-%+& W?%$XS $0%; 1"#X$ )#(%&$YDO 9%1-%: 7.#1& ?%$ "# 7,.2$.4$)"#& )# 2"=="1)$; 6+)2%&S 2.++%#2)%&S )#$%+%&$ +4$%&S &$"2C 6+)2%&S ?"#1 6+)2%&S "+S "# W1%+)(4$)(%&X ^ H0)20 H% &04,, &0"+$,; %R%=6,)7;YDP 9%1-% 7.#1& 4+% +)20 =%#X& ?%$$)#- 2,.?&Y /0%; .&% &"60)&$)24$%1 2"=6.$%+ $%20#","-; 4#1 G"?%, 6+)\%:H)##)#- %e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f7 2".+&%S $0% "6%+4$"+& "7 ,"#-:$%+= 246)$4, H4#$%1 $0%)+ H%4,$0; W6,4;%+&X $" C%%6 $0%)+ 246)$4, W)# 6,4;X 7"+ 4# %R$%#1%1 6%+)"1 "7 $)=% ^ 0%#2% $0% #4=%YDJ @0#&<2%1,7- ,3 *A#11,-./ -71 ,->#31,-. 9%1-% 7.#1& 4+% ?%$$)#- 2,.?&S #"$ )#(%&$=%#$ 7.#1&Y /0%; 4+% #"$ )# ?.&)#%&& $" +%&%4+20 2"+6"+4$)"#& 4#1 )#(%&$ )# $0% "#%& $0%; $0)#C H),, -+"H 4#1 6+"&6%+Y E)$0 $0% 0%,6 "7 $0% 2"=6.$%+ 4#1 $0% G"?%, 6+)\%:H)##)#- %e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

+79%= 1(# (#9.#D$<-9 A%,27<13

&.+% $0)#-Y >#1 $0%; 1)1S .#$), $0% >&)4# 4#1 K.&&)4# 2+)&%& 2+%4$%1 &.20 4 7+%% 74,, )# $0% =4+C%$S $04$ $0% %e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mfn#% $0)#- $04$ &.+6+)&%1 6%"6,% H4& $0% 1%-+%% $" H0)20 $0% 7.#1 041 1%,(%1 )#$" W%e.)$; +)&C 4+?)$+4-%X ^ $0)& )& 4# 4+%4 )# H0)20 W)#&)1%+ )#7"+=4$)"#X )& 2+)$)24, 7"+ &.22%&&Y M#1%%1S )# $0% ,"#- $%+= )$ )& &4)1 $" 04(% $+4#&7"+=%1 )$&%,7 )#$" "#% "7 $0% ,4+-%&$ 6,4;%+& )# &$"2C 4+?)$+4-% "# E4,, 5$+%%$S )#(%&$)#- 4& =.20 4& "#% ?),,)"# 1",,4+& )# $4C%"(%+ &$"2C&S 4& H%,, 4& 1%+)(4$)(%& $)%1 $" $0"&% )#(%&$=%#$&YIA WN&.4,,;S B"#- /%+= )#(%&$%1 )# ?"#1 4+?)$+4-%S &%%C)#- $%=6"+4+; 6+)2% 4#"=4,)%& )# $0% H)1% .#)(%+&% "7 -"(%+#=%#$ 4#1 2"+6"+4$% ?"#1&S ="+$-4-% ?42C%1 &%2.+)$)%& _4 H0",% #%H 7)#4#2)4, 6+"2%&& %&$4?: ,)&0%1 1.+)#- $0% 8LQT& 4#1 8LJT&`SID 4#1 "$0%+ 2+%1)$ )#&$+.=%#$&YX >,"#- H)$0 0.-% )#$%+#4$)"#4, ?%$&S )#2,.1)#- F4#)&0 ?"#1& 4#1 "$0%+ <.+"6%4# -"(%+#=%#$ ?"#1&S WB"#- /%+= !46)$4, 4,&" "722#9 1(# 9,&# )# $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&Y 9%+% 2"==%+2)4, ="+$-4-% ?42C%1 &%2.+)$)%& ?%24=% 64+$ "7 $0%)+ 4+?)$+4-% 6,4#YXII E0; 1)1 $0)& 0%1-% 7.#1 74),V m/0%n 6+)2% 4,)-#=%#$& $04$ B"#- /%+= !46)$4, .&%& $" 6+"-+4= )$& 2"=6.$%+& 04(% %(%+;H0%+% 74,,%# ".$ "7 H042CY 56+%41& "# ?"#1& =%4#$ $" 2"#(%+-% %#1%1 .6 ?; 1)(%+-)#-S &"=%$)=%& ?; 0.-% =4+: -)#& Y Y Y $0% $.+="), )# >&)4S K.&&)4S 4#1 "$0%+ %=%+-)#- =4+C%$& _B4$)# >=%+)24S %&6%2)4,,; ]+4\),` $.+#%1 &.20 ?%$& &".+ Y Y Y B"#- /%+= 041 &"=% H)##)#- 6"&)$)"#& Y Y Y ?.$ )$& ?41 ?%$& "(%+H0%,=%1 )$& -""1 "#%&S 4#1 $0% 0%4(; ,%(%+4-% _)#1%?$%1#%&&` 6+"(%1 1%41,;YIO 5"S $0% ?%$& H%#$ H+"#-S 4#1 $0% -4=?,%+& ,"&$ ^ $0% ?%&$ 4#1 ?+)-0$%&$ =4$0%=4$)24, =)#1& 041 #"$ ?%%# 4?,% $" 2+%4$% 4 2"=6,%$%,; +)--%1 -4=%Y *%+046&S )# $)=%S $0%; H),,Y U"+S $0%; 04(% ?%%# +%&2.%1S 4#1 $0%; 4+% )# ?.&)#%&& $" $+; 4-4)#Y W3+Y 3%+)H%$0%+ )& &$),, )# 2"#$+", "7 B"#/%+= !46)$4,Y /0% +%&2.% %77"+$S ?; 4 2"#&"+$).= "7 ?)- ?4#C& _4#1

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

LT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

7)#4#2)4, 0".&%&S "+20%&$+4$%1 ?; >,4# @+%%#&64# 4#1 $0% U%1%+4, K%&%+(% ]"4+1` )& #"H (4,.%1 4$ DYP ?),,)"# 1",,4+&YXIP /0% e.%&$)"# ?%2"=%&S &0".,1 $0%+% 04(% ?%%# 4 ?4),".$ "7 $0)& 0%1-% 7.#1S "+ 4#; 0%1-% 7.#1V E".,1 $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )#$%+2%1% $" 0%,6 "+-4#)\% 4 ?4),".$ 7"+ 4 ?)-:$)=% -4=?,%+ H0" ,"&$V f+S )& &6%2.,4$)"# 4 7.,,; ,%-)$)=4$% 64+$ "7 $0% &$"2C =4+C%$S &" %&&%#$)4, $04$ )$& 6+42$)$)"#%+& &0".,1 ?% &0"+%1 .6S b.&$ 4&S 7+"= $)=% $" $)=%S ?4#C& 4+% &0"+%1 .6V >& $0% '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 6.$ )$ _AO 5%6$%=?%+ 8LLJS 64-% JS e."$)#K"# !0%+#"HS 4# 4.$0"+ "# E4,, 5$+%%$ 7)+=&`S H04$ )& &$+)C)#- $0)& $)=% "# $0)& ?4),".$ )& $04$ $0% 2"==%+2)4, 4#1 )#(%&$=%#$ ?4#C& ^ 6+"11%1 ?; $0% U%1%+4, K%&%+(% ^ 4+% %R$%#1)#- 4 3%$#1) -#1 $" 4 0%1-% 7.#1 ^ 4# <-"#.<2%1#9 7)+=S &.66"&%1,; +)20 %#".-0 4#1 &"60)&$)24$%1 %#".-0 #"$ $" +%e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f$0%+& &4)1 $04$ $0% U%1X& 42$)"# 2".,1 ?42C7)+%S 2+%4$)#- H04$ ?4#C%+& 24,, W="+4, 04\4+1X ^ )# H0)20 )#(%&$"+& $4C% %(%# -+%4$%+ +)&C&S C#"H)#- $04$S )# $0% %#1S +%-.,4$"+& H),, 6+%(%#$ 2",,46&%YXIJ /0% '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 -"%& "# $" &4;S W/0%+% )& 4,&" 0;6"2+)&; )# $0% >=%+)24# 6"&)$)"#S 7"+ 4$ $0% (%+; &4=% $)=% H% H%+% ?4),)#- ".$ ".+ ?4#C& 4#1 %(%# #.=%+".& 0%1-% 7.#1&S H% H%+% 6.&0)#- d464# 4#1 "$0%+ >&)4# 2".#$+)%& $" 4,,"H ="+% 7)#4#2)4, )#&$)$.$)"#& $" 74),YXIL /0% '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 7.+$0%+ &$4$%&S WM# $0% NY5YS $0% B"#- /%+= !46)$4, 7)4&2" )& 4,+%41; &64+C)#- 24,,& 7"+ -+%4$%+ +%-.,4$)"# ^ "+ 4$ ,%4&$ =.20 ?%$$%+ &2+.$)#; ^ "7 $0% &%2+%$)(%S 2"=6,%R 0%1-% 7.#1 )#1.&$+;YXOT B%$ .& ,""C ="+% 2,"&%,;Y U+"= )$& 0%41e.4+$%+& )# @+%%#H)20S !"##%2$)2.$S B"#- /%+= !46)$4, %4+#%1 A,22,7-3 "7 1",,4+& 7"+ )$& 64+$#%+& 4#1 $0%)+ 2,)%#$&Y /0% 1+)()#- 7"+2% ?%0)#1 B"#- /%+= !46)$4, H4& 4 04#17., "7 ?+),,)4#$ =%#Y /H" "7 $0%= ^ 3;+"# 520",%& 4#1 K"?%+$ 3%+$"# ^ H"# 67A#2 0",K#3 7"+ %2"#"=)2&YO8 >#"$0%+S F4()1 3.,,)#& d+Y )& 4 $7"4#" S,&#

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( L8

+(%,"4%- 7$ 1(# P#9#"%2 L#3#">#Y /0%)+ ,%41%+' d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d4=%& !4;#%S ]%4+ 5$%4+#& !"=64#;X& 20)%7 %R%2.$)(%S 4#1 F"#4,1 34++"#S *4)#% E%?%+ @+".6 M#2YX& 204)+=4# 4#1 20)%7 %R%2.$)(%S H%+% 4="#- $0% %R%2.$)(%& H0" )#(%&$%1 6%+&"#4, &$4C%& )# B"#/%+= !46)$4,Y /0% ,"H 2"&$ ,"4#& H%+% "#% )=6"+$4#$ 04+?)#-%+ "7 %(%#$.4, $+".?,% ^ B"#- /%+= 1)1 -%$ $%+=& $04$ H%+% ?%$$%+ $04# #"+=4, Y Y Y E4,, 5$+%%$ 041 &$4+1.&$ )# )$& %;%&OI _$0%; ?%,)%(%1 $0% G"?%, ,4.+%: 4$%&X %e.4$)"#& H%+% &" 6%+7%2$ $04$ $0%; 2".,1 #"$ ,"&% $0%)+ W?%$&X`Y 5.20 4$$+42$)(% 7)#4#2)#- $%+=& %#4?,%1 B"#- /%+= !46)$4, $" 4=4&& 4 -4+-4#$.4# 6"+$7",)" "7 4&&%$&Y M# ,4$% >.-.&$S 8LLJS B"#/%+= !46)$4, H4& &.66"+$)#- 4 ?4,4#2% &0%%$ "7 VTWX A,22,7- "7 4&&%$&S 4?".$ OI $)=%& )$& 246)$4, ?4&% "7 kAYD ?),,)"# Y Y Y 4#1 $04$ H4& ="1%&$ 2"=64+%1 $" $0% ,%(%+4-% _+%41' 1%?$` $0% 7)+= %=6,";%1 ?%7"+% )$ ?%-4# $" +.# )#$" $+".?,%Y <4+,)%+ $0)& ;%4+ m8LLJnS B"#- /%+= !46)$4, H4& &.66"+$)#- 6"&)$)"#&S )#2,.1)#- "77:?4,4#2%:&0%%$ &H46&S $04$ H%+% 4,="&$ TYY 1,4#3 )$& 246)$4, ?4&% Y Y Y <(%# #"H _47$%+ $0% 2",,46&% 4#1 $0% ?4),".$`S )$ 04& 246)$4, "7 +".-0,; kPTT =),,)"# &.66"+$)#4&&%$& "7 kJT ?),,)"#YOO M# "$0%+ H"+1&S .#&%2.+%1 ,"4#& H%+% -)(%# B"#- /%+= !46)$4,S ?%24.&% $0% E4,, 5$+%%$ 7)#4#2)4, 0".&%& ?%,)%(%1 $0%; 2".,1#X$ ,"&%S ?%24.&% $0% =4$0%=4$)24, %e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

LA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

5%2+%2; H4& 4#"$0%+ 64+$ "7 $0% 7"+=.,4 7"+ 1)&4&$%+Y 9%1-% 7.#1& ?; $0%)+ #4$.+% 1"#X$ H4#$ 2,)%#$& ^ "+ 4#;"#% %,&% ^ $" ,%4+# H04$ $0%; 4+% 1")#-S 4$ ,%4&$ #"$ .#$), $0%)+ A#13 4+% )# 6,42% Y Y Y B"#- /%+= !46)$4, H".,1#X$ 1)&2,"&% $0% #4$.+% "7 $0% $+41%& %(%# 47$%+ )$ =41% ="#%; H)$0 $0%= Y Y Y #" "#% ".$&)1% B"#- /%+= !46)$4, C#%H $0% 7.,, %R$%#$ "7 $0% 7)+=X& .27A%2 07"1$72,7 7$ A#13Y G" "#% C#%H $0% H0",% &)$.4$)"# ?%24.&% "7 $0)& ,42C "7 W$+4#&64+%#2;YXOJ m/0% ?4#C%+&X %.60%=)&= 7"+ &%2+%2;Yn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a ;".X+% $4,C)#- 4?".$ 4 &)$.4$)"# H0%+% 1(#) (%9 1(#," 479#23 ;"7-.SX &4;& 9%#+; 9.S 6+"7%&&"+ "7 ,4H 4$ $0% N#)(%+&)$; "7 /%R4& 4#1 4# %R6%+$ )# +)&C =4#4-%=%#$Y WE0%# $0%&% +"2C%$ &2)%#$)&$& 1%&)-# ="1%,&S $0%; 1"#X$ $4C% )#$" 422".#$ $0% ,"H 6+"?4?),)$;S ?.$ 0)-0 &$+%&& %(%#$&YXPT /0% >&)4# 2+)&)& H4& $0% #4), )# $0% 2"77)# 7"+ $0% 6+"?4?),)$; %e.4$)"#& #"$ &%$ 7"+ $0% W0)-0 &$+%&& %(%#$&X 9%#+; 9. +%7%++%1 $"a $0%; 74),%1 $" 2"++%2$,; 6+%1)2$ $0% 7,.2$.4$)"#& "22.++)#- 1.+)#- $0)& H"+,1 2+)&)&S 4#1 &.11%#,;S ?),,)"#& "7 1",,4+& H%+% ,"&$S )#&$%41 "7 =41%Y @4=?,)#- )& &$),, -4=?,)#-S ?%24.&% $0% G"?%, ,4.+%4$%&X %e.4$)"#& H%+% "?()".&,; 7,4H%1Y f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( LD

LI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0% U%1%+4, K%&%+(%S 0%41%1 ?; >,4# @+%%#&64#S "+20%&$+4$%1 4 =4b"+ 4#1 2"=6,%R ?4),".$ 7"+ B"#- /%+= !46)$4, )# "+1%+ $" 6+%(%#$ 4 -%#%+4, 2",,46&% "7 &$"2C =4+C%$ 7)+=&Y >-4)#S 4& $0% '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 6.$ )$S WE4,, 5$+%%$X& =4&&)(% ?4),".$ "7 4 &$+)2C%# 0%1-% 7.#1 +%6+%&%#$& "#% "7 $0% ?)--%&$ %77"+$& )# >=%+)24# 9)&$"+; ?; 7)#4#2)4, 6"H%+ ?+"C%+& $" 3%># &%0,1%2,34 $"74 ,13#2$YXPA U)#4#2)4, +%&2.% =)&&)"#& 4+% 4& ",1 4& ="#%;Y <(%# &"S NY5Y 0)&$"+)4#& 4#1 %2"#"=)&$& 4+% =4+(%,)#- 4$ $0% &)\% "7 $0% )#$+)24$% +%&2.% 642C4-% 4++4#-%1 7"+ B"#- /%+= !46)$4, Y Y Y /0)& =4; H%,, ?% $0% ,4+-%&$ ?4),".$ "7 4# >=%+)24# 7)#4#2)4, )#&$)$.$)"# ?; "$0%+ 7)#4#2)4, )#&$)$.$)"#& &)#2% $0% IYO ?),,)"# 7%1%+4, +%&2.% )# 8LJI "7 !"#$)#%#$4, M,,)#")& ?4#CYPD K"# !0%+#"HS 4.$0"+ "7 E(# C7<3# 7$ ?7".%-SPI &4;&S $0% B"#- /%+= !46)$4, "6%+4$)"# )& 6%+046& ="&$ +%=)#)&2%#$ "7 $0% ?),,)"# 1",,4+ d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

4#; &)#-,% 7)+= 1%=4#1%1 $" 2.$ 4#1 +.#S $0%# $0% (4,.% "7 %(%+;: "#%X& 2",,4$%+4, H".,1 ?%-)# $" 1%$%+)"+4$% Y Y Y ].$ H0%# $0% U%1& %#$%+%1 $0% 6)2$.+%S 4#; &.20 #"$)"#& H%+% &%$ 4&)1% )# $0% )#$%+%&$ "7 6+%(%#$)#- 4 +.&0 $" .#H)#1YP8

H04$X& &$+)C)#- $0)& $)=%S )& $04$ $0% 2"==%+2)4, 4#1 )#(%&$=%#$ ?4#C&S 6+"11%1 ?; $0% U%1&S 4+% %R$%#1)#- 4 3%$#1) -#1 $" 4 0%1-% 7.#1 ^ 4# <-"#.<2%1#9 7)+= &.66"&%1,; +)20 %#".-0 4#1 &"60)&$)24$%1 %#".-0 #"$ +%e.)+% -"(%+#=%#$ +%-.,4$)"#Y M# $0)& H4;S $0% =4&&)(% ?4),".$ )#1)+%2$,; %R$%#1& $0% W$"" ?)- $" 74),X 1"2$+)#% $" )#&$)$.$)"#& $04$ 4+% #%)$0%+ 204+$%+%1 ?4#C& #"+ +%-.,4$%1 ?+"C%+:1%4,%+& ^ 4 (%+; 1)&$.+?)#- 6+%2%1%#$YPQ f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dY*Y 3"+-4#S @",1=4# 5420&S 3%++),, B;#20S 3"+-4# 5$4#,%;:F%4# E)$$%+S 5","="# 5=)$0 ]4+#%; ^ 4,, $0% C%; >=%+)24# 7)#4#2)4, 0".&%& ^ 6,.&S ]4+2,4;& "7 <#-,4#1S F%.$&20% ]4#C "7 @%+=4#;S N]5 "7 5H)$\%+,4#1S !+%1)$ 5.)&&% U)+&$ ]"&$"#S 4#1 5"2)%h$%h @%h#%h+4,%S !+%h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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( LO

H0)20 $0% =4+C%$ 24# 7.#2$)"# %77%2$)(%,;Y f#% 2".,1 24,, $0)& #%H H"+,1 7)#4#2)4, 6+42$)2%S W-"(%+#=%#$:4&&)&$%1 7+%% =4+C%$ 246)$4,)&=XS "+S W7+%% =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2& H)$0 2+)&)& &.66"+$XY 5"=% e.%&$)"#& +%=4)# $" ?% 4#&H%+%1 )# $%+=& "7 $0% 0%1-% 7.#1& 4#1 $0%)+ ?4),".$' &0".,1 $0% G"?%, !"==)$$%% 04(% -)(%# 4 6+)\% $" %2"#"=)&$& H0" 2+%4$%1 4 ?%$$)#- &20%=%V 50".,1 $0%; 04(% -)(%# 4 G"?%, 6+)\% $" $0% =4$0%=4$)2)4#& H0" W?+"C% $0% 0".&%X )# B4& c%-4&S 4#1 H0" H%+% &.?&%e.%#$,; ?4##%1 7+"= ?%$$)#- $0%+%V 50".,1 $0% G"?%, 6+)\% ?% +%("C%1S #"H $04$ )$ )& 2,%4+ $04$ $0% ],42C^520",%&^ 3%+$"# %e.4$)"#& 1" #"$ 0",1 1.+)#- 2+)&)& 2"#1)$)"#&V _>#;"#% 24# =4C% ="#%; )# 4 ?.,, =4+C%$Y` >#1S H04$ )& $0% +%,4$)"#&0)6 ?%$H%%# &6%2.,4$)"# 4#1 246)$4, -+"H$0V M& )$ %&&%#$)4,a )& )$ 4# )#(%&$=%#$ &$+4$%-; $04$ %#-%#1%+& 246)$4, 7,"H 4#1 %#2".+4-%& )#1.&$+)4, -+"H$0V F"%& )$ %#2".+4-% ?.&)#%&& 2+%4$)()$; 4#1 2"+6"+4$% %77)2)%#2; ?; 1%(%,"6)#- 4 0.-% 6"", "7 246)$4, 7"+ W(%#$.+% 246)$4,)&$X )#(%&$=%#$ 4#1 2"+6"+4$% $4C%"(%+&V /0%&% 4#1 "$0%+ e.%&$)"#& 4+% )#$%+%&$)#- )# $0%=&%,(%&S 4#1 &0".,1 ?% 4#&H%+%1 #"#:b.1-=%#$4,,; 4& 64+$ "7 4&&%&&=%#$ $0%"+; )# %2"#"=)2&Y U+"= $0% 6")#$ "7 ()%H "7 $0)& ?""CS 0"H%(%+S $0% 4#&H%+& $" $0%&% e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d464#%&% 04(% 4,H4;& 422%6$%1 $0)& .#,)C%,; 2"=?)#4$)"# 4& +%6+%&%#$: )#- $0% %&1<%2 1%&2+)6$)"# "7 ="1%+# 246)$4,)&=YPL 9"H%(%+S $0% ]+)$)&0 4#1 $0% >=%+)24#& H),, 04(% -+%4$ 1)77)2.,$; 422%6$)#- $0% #"$)"# "7 4 -"(%+#=%#$:4&&)&$%1 =4+C%$Y >#1S )# 4 1)77%+%#$ (%)#S ?.$ 2%#$+4, $" $0% $0%&)& "7 $0)& (",.=%S )7 ?4),".$& 7"+ $0% +)20 ?%2"=% )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1S "+ 4$ ,%4&$ 7+%e.%#$,; .$),)\%1S $0%# W?4),".$&X 7"+ $0% =)11,% 4#1 ,"H%+ 2,4&&%& ?%2"=% ,"-)2: 4,,; 2"#&)&$%#$S H)$0)# $0% #%H %2"#"=)2 &;&$%=S 4& H%,,Y >#1S )7 ?4),".$ W)#(%&$=%#$&X )# )#1.&$+; 4#1 7)#4#2% 24# ?% b.&$)7)%1 )# $%+=& "7 $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

LP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

2+%4$)"# "7 $0% ,"#-:$%+= &$4?),)$; "7 $0% %#$)+% %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= _#4$)"#4, 4#1 -,"?4,`S $0%# W)#(%&$=%#$&X )# %1.24$)"# 4#1 0%4,$0 24+% 7"+ )#&$4#2%S 2".,1 ?% %e.4,,; H%,, b.&$)7)%1 "# %2"#"=)2 -+".#1& ^ )# $0% &%#&% $04$ 4 ?%$$%+ %1.24$%1S 0%4,$0)%+ H"+C 7"+2% 04& $" )=6+"(% $0% ,"#-:$%+= &$4?),)$; 4#1 -+"H$0 "7 $0% %2"#"=;S 4,"#- H)$0 246)$4, 7"+=4$)"#Y <(%# )7 "#% H".,1 "66"&% ?4),".$& 7"+ $0% =)11,% 4#1 ,"H%+ 2,4&&%&S "#% 2".,1 #"$ 1%#; $0% +%4,)$; "+ $0% &24,% ^ "7 $0% -,"?4, 4#1 #4$)"#4, ?4),".$& 7"+ $0% +)20Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# $7" 1(# 6#; L,&( LQ

Q

D*./70 *"# 3#8 $%&*&*7$#J M$4,; =4; ?% 6+"$"$;6)24, "7 $0% #%H &$;,% "7 H%,74+% &$4$% $04$ 2".,1 ?%2"=% $0% H"+,1 ="1%,Y M$4,; ?%-4# H)$0 4 H"+C)#-:2,4&& H%,74+% &$4$% -%#%+4$%1 ?; &"2)4,)&$S 2"==.#)&$ 4#1 74&2)&$ 6+"-+4=&S ?.$ +%$4)#%1 )$& 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=;Y >& H)$0 ="&$ "7 $0% <.+"6%4# H%,74+% &$4$%&S $0% M$4,)4# H%,74+% &$4$% )#2,.1%1 +%$)+%=%#$ 6%#&)"#&S &"=% .#%=6,";=%#$ )#&.+4#2% _,%&& $04# )# "$0%+ <.+"6%4# #4$)"#&`S .#)(%+&4, 0%4,$0 )#&.+: 4#2% 4#1 7+%% %1.24$)"# 7+"= -+41% &20"", $" .#)(%+&)$;Y /"14;S M$4,; )& +%&6"#1)#- $" $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 )$& #%%1& ^ 4& H%,, 4& $0% $;6)24, #%H 1%="-+460)2 $+%#1&Y /04$ )&S 4,"#- H)$0 6%#: &)"#&S 0%4,$0 24+% 4#1 %1.24$)"#S M$4,; #"H "77%+& 7+%% 20),1 24+% 7"+ 4,, 20),1+%# ?%$H%%# $0% 4-%& "7 D 4#1 P ^ H04$ )# >=%+)24 H".,1 ?% 24,,%1 W#.+&%+; &20"",XY /0%&% #.+&%+; &20"",& 4+% 7+%%S 4#1 )# 41%e.4$% &.66,; $0+".-0".$ =.20 "7 M$4,; _%R2,.1)#- $0% &".$0`Y 9"H%(%+S #"H $04$ H"=%# 4+% )#2+%4&)#-,; %#$%+)#- $0% H"+C 7"+2%S M$4,; )& 6+"()1)#- 14;:24+% 7"+ ?4?)%&Y /0%&% #%H 742),)$)%& 4+% )# $+%=%#: 1".& 1%=4#1 ?; $0% %=%+-)#- 1.4,:24+%%+ 2".6,%&S ?.$ 4& ;%$S 4+% )# &0"+$ &.66,;Y /0%+% 4+% H4)$)#- ,)&$& 7"+ %420 742),)$;Y /0%&% ?4?;:24+% 742),)$)%& 4+% ?%)#- %R64#1%1S 4#1S 4$ 6+%&%#$S 4+% 7+%% _4& )# U+4#2%S H0)20 6)"#%%+%1 $0% ?4?;:24+% 2%#$%+&`Y G%H )1%4& 4?".$ $0% ?%&$ $;6% "7 ?4?; 24+% 4+% ?%)#- 1%?4$%1 4#1 %R6%+)=%#$%1 H)$0Y 50".,1 ?4?; 24+% ?% )# "#%X& #%)-0?"+0""1S #%4+ "#%X& b"?S ,4+-% "+ &=4,,V >,, $0%&% 6+"?,%=& 4+% ?%)#- 1)&2.&&%1 4& $0% ?4?;:24+% 2%#$%+& 4+% ?%)#- )#&$)$.$%1 4#1 %R64#1%1Y 50".,1 64+%#$& ?% -)(%# 7,%R:$)=%S =4$%+#)$; ,%4(% H)$0 64;V 50".,1 74$0%+& ?% %#2".+4-%1 $" &$4; 0"=%V >,, $0)& =.&$ ?% H"+C%1 ".$S 6,.& $0% 6+"?,%= "7 7.#1)#-Y !4# $0%; +%=4)# 7+%%V LJ

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% E%,74+% 5$4$%'
LL

5)#2% $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),; &$),, %R)&$& &$+"#-,; )# M$4,;S -+4#1="$0%+& &$),, 1" 4 -+%4$ 1%4, "7 20),1 24+% 7"+ H"+C)#- ="$0%+&Y /0)& )& &$),, $;6)24, H"+,1H)1%S $0".-0 1%2,)#)#-Y M# 742$S b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b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k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` &4)1 $0% 6+)(4

%$10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13

2":64;=%#$& H%+% &4()#- $0% 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% &;&$%=Y >#1S &)#2% 64;: )#& H%+% e.)$% ="1%&$S $0% ?%$$%+ =%1)24, 24+% H4& H"+$0 )$Y >,&"S )# M&+4%, 4#1 M$4,;S 0%4,$0 24+% 7"+ $0% 6""+ )& 2"=6,%$%,; 7+%%S 4#1 6+)(4$% 64;:)#& 4+% 6+"-+%&&)(% 422"+1)#- $" "#%X& )#2"=%Y U)#4,,; )$ =4; ?%2"=% $0% $+%#1S )# $0% 7.$.+%S $" 1%=4#1 64;:)#& 7"+ 20),1 24+%Y >$ $0% ="=%#$S 20),1 24+% )# M$4,; )& 7+%%Y 9"H%(%+S .#)(%+&)$)%& H%+% 7+%% 7)(% ;%4+& 4-"S 4& H4& 0%4,$0 24+%Y /0% M$4,)4#&S 4& H)$0 $0% "$0%+ <.+"6%4#&S 4,+%41; 04(% 0)-0 )#2"=% $4R%& ^ .6 $" OT 6%+ 2%#$ ^ 4,"#- H)$0 $4+-%$%1 $4R%& 7"+ %1.24$)"# 4#1 0%4,$0 24+%S 4#1 #"HS $4R%& 7"+ <.+"6%4# N#)"# )#$%-+4$)"# _=4C)#- $0% #%H 2.++%#2; H"+CS %$2Y` M$4,; )& 6+"$"$;6)24,S $0%#S ?%24.&%' _8` $0% M$4,)4# %2"#"=; )& "#,; ="1%+4$%,; %R64#&)(%a _A` $0% ,"H ?)+$0:+4$% 4#1 ,"#- ,%#-$0 "7 ,)7% $0+%4$%# $0% +%(%#.% 422.=.,4$)"# "7 $0% H%,74+% &$4$%S 7"+2)#- 64;:)# 6+"-+4=& "7 "#% &"+$ "+ 4#"$0%+a _D` $0% 2"&$ "7 H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=& %-9 1(# -<4A#" 7$ 3<&( 0"7."%43 4+% ?"$0 )#2+%4&)#-a 4#1 7)#4,,; _I` $0% 2"==)$=%#$ $" $0% H%,74+% &$4$% )& +%=4)#)#- &$+"#- ^ %(%# -4)#)#- )# ,%-)$)=4$)"# ^ 4& $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 )$& #%%1& ?%2"=% 2%#$+4,a ?.$ +%(%#.% 7"+ 7)#4#2)#- $0)& %R64#1)#- H%,74+% &$4$% )& #"H ?%)#- 1+4H# 7+"= 4 2"=?)#4$)"# "7 6.?,)2 $4R%& 4#1 6+)(4$% 2":64;=%#$&Y /0)& H0",% 6+"2%&& )# M$4,; )& $;6)24, 4#1 $0% M$4,)4# 64$$%+# =4; ?%2"=% $0% -,"?4, 64$$%+#Y ].$S $0%+% H),, ?% (4+)4$)"#& ^ #"$ &" =.20 )# $0% H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=&S H0)20 4+% ?%2"=)#- e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d464#S H% 7)#1 4 64$$%+# "7 H%,74+%:&$4$% %R64#&)"#S H)$0 4 2"=?)#4: $)"# "7 6.?,)2 4#1 6+)(4$% 7.#1)#-Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ 4 &%+)%& "7 %R4=6,%& 7+"= 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%& 4+".#1 $0% H"+,1Y

D2%.#/0 1%&- 6+;;(*< 2&)+./+2- *& "+4"5*#)" ).$+*./+2-K M&+4%, )& 04+1,; 6+"$"$;6)24,Y /0% &$4$% H4& ?%-.# ?; 4 -+".6 "7 .$"6)4# &"2)4,)&$&S H0" 2+%4$%1 $0% C)??.$\ 2"==.#%&S 64+$,; ".$ "7 )1%","-; 4#1 64+$,; ".$ "7 #%2%&&)$;Y /0% <4&$%+# <.+"6%4# d%H& &)=6,; 1)1 #"$ C#"H

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8TT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

0"H $" 74+= "+ &",1)%+ ^ )# *4,%&$)#%S $0%; 041 $" 1" ?"$0Y > 2"==.#4, %77"+$ H4&S $0%+%7"+%S #%2%&&4+;S ?.$ $0% &$+"#- &"2)4,)&$ )1%","-; H4& 4,&" 2.,$.+4,,; )#-+4)#%1 7+"= $0% 14;& "7 $0% ,4$%:#)#%$%%#$0:2%#$.+; d%H)&0 )#$%,,%2$.4, +%()(4,S 4#1 $0% &"2)4,)&$ W?.#1X "+-4#)\4$)"#&Y E0%# M&+4%, ?%24=% 4 #4$)"#S $0% ,4?"+ 64+$; ?%24=% 1"=)#4#$S 4#1 %&$4?,)&0%1 4 7.,,:&24,% H%,74+% &$4$%S ?%7"+% $0% 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=; H4& H%,, 1%(%,"6%1Y !"#$+)?.$)"#& 7+"= >=%+)24#:d%H)&0 60),4#$0+"6)2 "+-4#)\4$)"#& 7.#1%1 &.20 6+"-+4=& .#$), $0% M&+4%,)& 2".,1 7.#1 $0%= "# $0%)+ "H#Y >#1S 7.+$0%+S $0% H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& )# M&+4%, )#2,.1%1 =4b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d%H)&0 6&;20"4#4,;$)2:)#$+"&6%2$)(% $+4: 1)$)"# 4o ,4 U+%.1 H4& 4,&" 0%,67., )# $0)& +%-4+1YD 5)#2% $0% M&+4%,) H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=& 4+% #"$ 4$ 4,, $;6)24,S H0; .&% M&+4%, 4& 4# %R4=6,%V ]%24.&% $"14;S 4& H% 466+"420 $0% #%H =),,%#: #).=S M&+4%,S ,)C% M$4,;S 04& %R64#1%1 )$& H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& )# 4 #%H =)11,%:2,4&& 1)+%2$)"#S 4#1S &"2)4,)&$ $+41)$)"# #"$H)$0&$4#1)#-S 04& %=?4+C%1 "# 4 6+"-+4= "7 %R64#1%1 64;:)#& 7+"= 6+)(4$% )#1)()1.4,& )# "+1%+ $" C%%6 $0%&% 6+"-+4=& +.##)#- &.22%&&7.,,;Y >& H)$0 M$4,;S 6+)(4$% 6%#&)"# 6,4#& #"H 2"=="#,; &.66,%=%#$ -"(: %+#=%#$ 6%#&)"# 6,4#& ^ $0% M&+4%,) 6%#&)"# 6+"-+4= )& ?%-)##)#- $" ,""C &)=),4+ $" $0% >=%+)24#Y 9%4,$0 24+% )& 2"=6,%$%,; 7+%% 7"+ $0% 6""+%+ M&+4%,) 2)$)\%#& _)#2,.1)#- $0% 6""+%+ >+4?&`S ?.$ $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& 4+% #"H 6+"()1)#- 2":64;=%#$& 4#1 &.66,%=%#$4+; 64;=%#$& )# "+1%+ $" -4)# $0% 1"2$"+ "7 $0%)+ 20")2%S 4#1 $" "?$4)# $0% W2.$$)#-: %1-%X 0)-0:$%20#","-; =%1)24, $+%4$=%#$& H0)20 M&+4%,) =%1)2)#% 04& $0% 24642)$; $" 1%,)(%+S ?.$ H0)20 $0% &$4$% 24##"$ 7.,,; 7.#1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8T8

5)=),4+,; H)$0 20),1 24+% 6+"-+4=&' ?4?; 24+% 4#1 #.+&%+; &20"",& 4+% 4(4),4?,% $" H"+C)#- ="$0%+&S 4#1 "7 %R2%,,%#$ e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

@+34.$&%#0 1%&- >&31()+.3+2- *& '#-&)%.*+)52&)+./+2- *& "+4"5*#)" ).$+*./+2-L 5)#-46"+% H".,1 04+1,; &%%= $;6)24, "7 4#;$0)#-S -)(%# )$& &=4,, &)\% 4#1 .#.&.4, -%":6",)$)24, 0)&$"+;Y 9"H%(%+S 4& "#% "7 $0% W7".+ $)-%+&XS 5)#-46"+% +%6+%&%#$& $0% +46)1,; 41(4#2)#- #4$)"#& "7 <4&$ >&)4S 4#1 4& 4 !0)#%&% %#2,4(%S =4; -)(% .& 2,.%& 4& $" !0)#4X& 6"$%#$)4, 1%(%,"6=%#$Y M#1%6%#1%#$ 7+"= <#-,)&0 2","#)4, &$4$.&S 4#1 &%64+4$%1 7+"= 34,4;&)4S H)$0 4 =4b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8TA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

+%$.+#S $0% 2"=="# 6%"6,% 64; 1%7%+%#2% $" $0% -"(%+#=%#$ ^ 4& ,"#4& )$ 7.,7),,& $0%)+ #%%1& _4$ ,%4&$ $" 4 =)#)=.= %R$%#$`Y G"$)2% $04$ )# $0% !"#7.2)4# $+41)$)"#S 74=),;:&$;,% 4.$0"+)$; ?%&$ %R%=6,)7)%& -"(%+#=%#$^&.?b%2$ +%,4$)"#&0)6&Y /0%+% )& #" $+41)$)"# "7 1%="2+42;S %e.4,)$;S ,4H "+ )#1)()1.4,)&=Y /0% &.?b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e.)$% &=4,, ?; >=%+)24# &$4#14+1&Y /0% -"(%+#=%#$ ?.),$ -+41% &20"",&S 0)-0 &20"",& 4#1 .#)(%+&)$)%&Y !0)#%&% ,4#-.4-% &20"",& H%+% ?.),$ 4,"#- H)$0 <#-,)&0 ,4#-.4-% &20"",&S 4#1 $0% &20"",& 4+% "7 4# %R2%,,%#$ e.4,)$;Y d"?:$+4)#)#- 6+"-+4=& H%+% 2+%4$%1 7"+ 6""+ )==)-+4#$& ^ !0)#%&%S M#1)4#& 4#1 34,4;& ^ &" $04$ $0%&% 6%4&4#$& 2".,1 -4)# $0% &C),,& $" 7)$ )#$" $0% ="1%+# %2"#"=)2 H"+,1Y B"4#& 7"+ &=4,, ?.&)#%&&%& H%+% =41% +%41),; 4(4),4?,% ^ $0)&S ?%24.&% 5)#-46"+% 041 0.-% $+41% +%(%#.%&S 4#1 ?%24.&% $0% !0)#%&% 4+% ,%-%#14+; )# 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4 7"+ $0%)+ ?.&)#%&& &C),,&Y 94()#- &.22%%1%1 4$ 0".&)#-S &20"",& 4#1 b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b4),)#- "66"&)$)"# ,%41%+&S +.)#)#- $0% %1.24$)"# 4#1 24+%%+ 64$0& "7 ".$&6"C%# "66"&)$)"#)&$&S 4#1 )# -%#%+4, $4C)#- 4 W0",)%+ $04# $0".XS WM C#"H H04$X& ?%&$ 7"+ 5)#-46"+%XS

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8TD

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b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8TI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0%+%7"+%S 4& $0% 5)#-46"+% -"(%+#=%#$ %R64#1& )$& H%,74+% &$4$% $" 422"=="14$% $0% #%%1& "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& ^ H0),% &$),, 422"=="1: 4$)#- $0% #%%1& "7 )#2"=)#- )==)-+4#$& 7+"= !0)#4S M#1)4 4#1 34,4;: &)4 ^ #%H &".+2%& "7 +%(%#.% $" 7.#1 $0)& %R64#&)"# 04(% ?%%# &".-0$Y M# $0)& +%-4+1S 64;:)#& 4+% )#2+%4&)#-,; ?%)#- 4&C%1 7"+ 7+"= )#1)(): 1.4,& 4#1 74=),)%&S 4#1 $0% e.%&$)"# "7 $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$& 7+"= $0% +%=4+C4?,; +)20 4#1 #%H:+)20 "7 5)#-46"+%S 4+% ?%)#- 4&C%1 7"+ $0+".-0 6+"-+%&&)(% $4R4$)"# 6",)2)%&Y /0% 1),%==4 "7 $0% +)&)#- 2"&$& "7 H%,74+% &$4$% &%+()2%& )& &" -+%4$ $04$ B%% %#2".+4-%1 1%?4$%& 4?".$ H0%$0%+ H"=%# &0".,1 ,%4(% $0% 74=),; ^ ?.$ $0%# ?42C%1 1"H# H0%# H"=%#X& -+".6& 6+"$%&$%1a 0% e.%&$)"#%1 H0%$0%+ &" =.20 =%1)24, &2)%#2% H4& #%2%&&4+;S %#2".+4-)#- $0% .&% "7 !0)#%&% 0%+?4, 4#1 42.6.#2$.+% =%1)2)#%S ?.$ $0%# ?42C%1 4H4;a 0% 4&C%1 7"+ ="+% &"2)4,)&$:&$;,% 0)-0 $4R4$)"# "7 $0% +)20S ?.$ $0%# H4& "(%+H0%,=%1 ?; $0% &.22%&& "7 $0% 7)#4#2)4, 4#1 -,"?4, 246)$4,)&$ &%2$"+& "7 $0% %2"#"=;S 4#1 4-4)# ?42C%1 "77Y88 ]%24.&% "7 4,, $0%&% +%2%#$ _8LLT&` 1%?4$%& 4#1 7,)6:7,"6& 7+"= B%% Z.4# [%HX& 64+$; _B%% )& #"H &.66"&%1,; +%$)+%1S ?.$ 0% &$),, 0",1& -+%4$ 4.$0"+)$; )# $0% 64+$;`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f?()".&,;S $0%&% &%+()2%& H),, ?%2"=% )#2+%4&)#-,; %R6%#&)(% $" =4)#$4)#Y ].$ =4)#$4)#%1 $0%; =.&$ ?%S "+ $0%+% )& 4 +)&C "7 -%#%+4, 1%-%#%+4$)"# "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"#S %="$)"#4,,; 4#1 60;&)24,,;Y 3"1%+# &"2)%$)%& H),, #"$ ,%4(% $0% %,1%+,; $" 1)%a $0%; H),, ?.),1 4&&)&$%1 ,)()#- 4#1 #.+&)#- 0"=% 742),)$)%&Y 3"1%+# &"2)%$)%& H),, #"$ ,%4(% ?4?)%& 4#1 20),1+%# .#4$$%#1%1a $0%; H),, ?.),1 14;:24+% 2%#$%+& 4#1 #.+&%+; &20"",&Y f.+ 0"&6)$4,&S 4#1 ".+ &20"",& H),, ?% 2.$$)#-:%1-%S 4#1 ".+ 6"6.,4$)"#& H),, #"$ ?% 0".&%1 )# 0"(%,&Y /0%+%7"+%S H% H),, 4$$%=6$ $" 7)#1 H4;& $" 7.#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%&S H0%$0%+ $0%; ?% 6.?,)2 "+ 6+)(4$%Y

M#/1.%#52*.*# #B$.32+&30 N&%8.7A >.3.'.A O&34 P&34 5"=% #4$)"#& 4+% %R64#1)#- $0%)+ H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=&S $0".-0 )# "$0%+& ?.1-%$ 6+"?,%=& 04(% -%#%+4$%1 4 #%%1 $" 2.$ ?42CY B%$ .& ,""C

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8TO

8TP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

4$ $0+%% #4$)"#& &%64+4$%,;S 7"+ $0% +%4&"#& ?%0)#1 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% %R64#&)"#& 4+% 1)77%+%#$ )# %420 #4$)"#Y

>& )& H%,, C#"H#S $0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%& 6)"#%%+%1 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% $0+".-0 $0%)+ 5"2)4, F%="2+4$)2 64+$)%&X &.22%&&S 47$%+ $0% @+%4$ F%6+%&&)"# "7 8LALY M$ H4& ])&=4+2CS )# @%+=4#;S H0" ?%-4# $0% $+%#1 )# "+1%+ $" 2""6$ $0% &"2)4,)&$ ="(%=%#$Y >,"#- H)$0 1)+%2$ +%6+%&&)"# "7 $0% &"2)4,)&$& 4#1 2"==.#)&$&S ])&=4+2C 2+%4$%1 4 -%#%+".& H%,74+% &$4$%Y /0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%& %R64#1%1 $0%)+ H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& H)$0".$ $0% #%%1 7"+ +%6+%&&)"#S ?%24.&% $0% 1%6+%&&)"# 041 $%=6"+4+),; +%&",(%1 $0% 2"#7,)2$ ?%$H%%# ?.&)#%&& 4#1 ,4?"+Y f#2% $0% 524#1)#: 4()4# %2"#"=)%& +%?".#1%1 4#1 ?%24=% 6+"&6%+".&S $0% H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& 041 ?%2"=% 422%6$%1 4#1 )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1Y N#,)C% $0% N5>S H0%+% $0% K""&%(%,$ G%H F%4, E%,74+% 5$4$% H4& 64+$)4,,; 1)&=4#$,%1 47$%+ $0% 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+S $0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%& -+41.4,,; %R64#1%1 $0%)+ H%,74+% &$4$%Y f#% +%4&"# ?)- ?.&): #%&& 1)1 #"$ "66"&% $0)& %R64#&)"# ()-"+".&,; )& $04$ )$ 041 ?%%# 2"%+2%1 $" &.66"+$ $0% G4\) H4+ =420)#%S 4#1 041 246)$.,4$%1Y @.),$g @.),$ 7"+ 2",,.&)"# )# 5H%1%#S -.),$ 7"+ $0% p.)&,)#- #%":G4\) -"(%+#: =%#$ )# G"+H4;Y @.),$ %#-%#1%+%1 422%6$4#2% "7 $0% 5"2)4, F%="2+4$)2 ,%41%+&0)6 H)$0 )$& H%,74+% &$4$% 7+"= 2+41,%:$":-+4(% )1%","-;Y >#1S "7 2".+&%S $0% 5"2)4, F%="2+4$&S 7"+ $0%)+ 64+$S 1)1 #"$ )#$%+7%+% )# $0% 246)$4,)&$ 1%(%,"6=%#$ "7 $0% %2"#"=;Y > 7.,, 7+%% =4+C%$ %2": #"=; 204+42$%+)\%1 $0% 524#1)#4()4# %2"#"=)%& %(%# $0".-0 4 -+4#1 H%,74+% &$4$% H4& 4$$420%1 $" )$Y U.+$0%+S $0% 524#1)#4()4# #4$)"#& 04(% &=4,,S 0"="-%#%".& 6"6.,4: $)"#&Y /0%+% 4+% WB466&X ^ U)##& ^ )# $0% #"+$0 "7 G"+H4;S 5H%1%# 4#1 U)#,4#1S ?.$ $0%; ,)(% &%64+4$%,; 7+"=S 4#1 )# 04+="#; H)$0S $0% 524#: 1)#4()4#&Y /0% &=4,, 0"="-%#%".& 6"6.,4$)"#S 4#1 $0% ,42C "7 =),)$4+; 1"=)#4$)"# 7+"= ".$&)1%S 04(% 4,,"H%1 $0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%& $" +%$4)# 4# 4,="&$ $+)?4, 204+42$%+Y /0)& $+)?4,)&= %#-%#1%+& 4 2"==.#4, &6)+)$S H0%+%)# $0% 7.,, H%,74+% &$4$% &%%=& ="+4, 4#1 -""1 ^ %(%# $0".-0 )$ &)$& "# 4# %2"#"=)2 ?4&% $04$ )& $;6)24,,; 2"+6"+4$%S 0)-0: $%20 246)$4,)&$Y G"+H%-)4# $+)?4,)&= 24# ?% %R%=6,)7)%1 ?; $0% G"+H%-)4# H"+1 R%-1#2%;S8D H0)20 =%4#& #"?"1; &0".,1 &$4+$ $0)#C)#- $04$ 0% "+ &0% )& ?%$$%+ $04# 4#;"#% %,&%Y /0)& )& $;6)24, $+)?4,:2"==.#4, $0)#C)#-S ?.$ )$ 04& ?%%# +%$4)#%1 )# 524#1)#4()4 ^ H0%+% $0% Wc)C)#-X $+)?%& %R)&$%1 .#$), #%4+:="1%+# $)=%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

N&%8.7JK

>,, $0)& 04& ?%%# C#"H# &)#2% $0% 8LPT& H0%# $0% W524#1)#4()4# 3"1%,X ?%24=% "#% "7 $0% 2"=6%$)#- ="1%& "7 ="1%+# %2"#"=)2 "+-4#)\4$)"#Y /0% e.%&$)"# )&S )# $0)& %+4 "7 )#2+%4&)#- )#$%+#4$)"#4, %2"#"=)2 246)$4,)&=S 4#1 $0% +)&)#- 2"&$& "7 &%+()2%&S 0"H 24# G"+H4; ?% %R64#1)#- )$& H%,74+% &$4$%V >#1 5H%1%# 4& H%,,V /0% G"+H%-)4#& 1)&2"(%+%1 4 0.-% 1%6"&)$ "7 "), )# $0% "2%4# "77 $0% 2"4&$Y >,"#- H)$0 G"+H4;X& 4,+%41; +%=4+C4?,% #4$.+4, +%&".+2%&S )#2,.1)#- ,.=?%+S $0% "),:?""= 04& 7.%,%1 _64+1"# $0% 6.#`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kP ?),,)"# ="+% $04# $0% -"(%+#=%#$X& kP8 ?),,)"# )# %R6%#1)$.+%&Y /0.&S G"+H4;S H0)20 4,"#- H)$0 5H%1%# 4#1 F%#=4+CS 4,+%41; 041 $0% H"+,1X& ="&$ 2"=6,%$% H%,74+% &$4$%S 04& #"H %R64#1%1 )$Y E04$ )& $0% #4$.+% "7 $0% %R64#&)"#S 4#1 H04$ 1)1 G"+H4; 4,+%41; 04(% )# $0% H4; "7 H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=&V /0% G"+H%-)4#& 4,+%41; 04(% %R2%,,%#$ +%$)+%=%#$ 6%#&)"#& 4$ PO ^ 4#1 #"H $0%; 4+% 1)&2.&&)#- +%$)+%=%#$ 4$ PAa .#%=6,";=%#$ ?%#%7)$& 4#1 &)2C ,%4(%a 2"=6,%$%,; 7+%% 0%4,$0 24+% ^ $0% 1"2$"+& 4+% "# &4,4+;S ?.$ $0% 524#1)#4()4# 0%4,$0:24+% &;&$%= )& %R2%,,%#$S 4& )& @%+=4#;X&S H0),% ]+)$4)#X& &;&$%= )& #"$ 0%,1 .6 4& 4 ="1%, $" %=.,4$% _H% &04,, 1)&2.&& ]+)$4)#`a G"+H4; 04& $0% 20),1 4,,"H4#2% &;&$%=S .&%1 )# #4$)"#& H0%+% $0% ?)+$0+4$% 04& ?%2"=% $"" ,"HY /04$ )&S %(%+; 74=),; )# G"+H4; _4#1 4,, 524#1)#4()4` +%2%)(%1 _466+"R)=4$%,;` k8PAT 4##.4,,; 7"+ %(%+; 20),1 .#1%+ 8QS 4#1 $0% &$)6%#1 )#2+%4&%& 7"+ %420 411)$)"#4, 20),1Y N#1%+6"6.,4$%1 !4#414 04& $0)& 6+"-+4=S ?.$S "7 2".+&%S "(%+6"6.: ,4$%1 #4$)"#& &.20 4& 3%R)2" H".,1 #"$ H4#$ &.20 4 6+"-+4=Y E04$ 4+% &"=% "7 $0% %R64#&)"#&V G"+H%-)4#& #"H +%2%)(% IA H%%C& "7 7.,,; 64)1 =4$%+#)$; ,%4(%S 4#1 =%# 24# 20""&% $" &$4; 4$ 0"=% H)$0 $0%)+ 20),1 4#1 +%2%)(% $0)& W=4$%+#)$;X ,%4(% 4& H%,,Y E)$0 H"=%# H"+C: )#- ="+% 4#1 ="+%S 20),1 24+% &%+()2%& 04(% ?%%# %R$%#1%1S &" $04$ ?4?; 24+%S 14;24+%S -+".6 "+ W#4##;X 24+% 4+% 4,, 7.,,; 7+%%Y <1.24$)"#4, &%+()2%& 04(% 4,&" ?%%# %R$%#1%1' 6+%:&20"", ^ #"H _8LLL` 7+"= A ;%4+& ",1 .#$), C)#1%+-4+$%# ^ &20"",)#- )& 4(4),4?,% 4#1 )& 7+%%Y U.+$0%+="+%S 4 #%H 6+"-+4= 24,,%1 WB)7%,"#- B%4+#)#-X 04& ?%%# )=6,%=%#$%1Y /0)& 6+"-+4= H".,1 6+"()1% 7"+ 4 "#% ;%4+ 7.,,; 64)1

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8TQ

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e.)(4,%#$ $" $H" ;%4+& "7 >=%+)24# 2",,%-%S 4#1 $0% .#): (%+&)$; )& %e.)(4,%#$ $" -+41.4$% &20"",Y /0% H%,74+% &$4$% )# G"+H4; 04& ?%%# %R64#1%1 7.+$0%+ H)$0 74=),; 6+"-+4=& 4#1 0%4,$0 6+"-+4=&Y U,%R $)=%S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S 04& ?%%# )#&$): $.$%1 &" $04$ 0.&?4#1& 4#1 H)(%& 24# b.--,% 20),1:+%4+)#- 4#1 b"?& ^ "+ &" $04$ $H" H"=%# 24# &04+% "#% b"?S H0),% $4C)#- $.+#& H)$0 20),1 24+% _7%H%+ =%# 1" $0)&S $0".-0 )$ )& #"$ -%#1%+:?4&%1`Y >,&"S 74=),; ,%4(%S $" 24+% 7"+ &)2C 20),1+%# "+ 64+%#$&S )& ,)?%+4,,; -+4#$%1 )# G"+H4;Y E04$ 4?".$ 4 &)#-,% ="$0%+ H)$0 20),1+%#V M# G"+H4;S ;". H),, -%$ 64)1 ,%4(% 7+"= ;".+ b"? $" +%4+ $0%= ^ )$ )& $0%# %R6%2$%1 $04$ ;". H),, +%$.+# $" ;".+ b"?Y /0)& )& #"$ ,)C% $0% WH%,74+%X 6+"-+4= 7"+ 6""+ H"=%# )# $0% N5>Y 5)#2% $0%+% 4+% #" 6""+ H"=%# )# G"+H4;S $0% %R6%2$4$)"# $04$ 4 H"=4# H),, +%$.+# $" 0%+ b"? )& 7.,7),,%1Y 9%+% )& 4 $;6)24, 24&% +%6"+$%1 )# $0% 6#; Q7"I E,4#3S L F%2%=?%+ 8LLQ' WE0%# 5)1&%, Z+%;?%+-X& 0.&?4#1 1)("+2%1 0%+S &0% +%2%)(%1 H%,74+% 64;=%#$& 7"+ 20),124+% 7"+ %)-0$ ;%4+& 7+"= $0% -"(%+#=%#$Y 50% 4,&" +%2%)(%1 7+%% 14;24+%S &.?&)1)\%1 0".&)#-S 7+%% (424$)"#&S 7+%% =%1)24, 4#1 1%#$4, 24+%Y /0%#S H0%# &0% 1%2)1%1 $" +%$.+# $" &20"", $" -4)# 4 1%-+%% )# %6)1%=)","-; 4$ $0% N#)(%+&)$; "7 f&,"S $0% -"(%+#=%#$ 64;%1 7"+ )$Y G"HS &0% )& "77 H%,74+% 4#1 04& 4 ?%$$%+ 64;)#- b"? $04# ?%7"+% 0%+ 1)("+2%S 4#1S 0%+ 20),1+%# Z4+",)#% 4#1 Z4+&$%# 4+% 1")#(%+; H%,, ^ &0% ?%4=%1 4& &0% &4)1 $0)&YX8O /" &0"H b.&$ 0"H 74+ $0% H%,74+% &$4$% 04& %R64#1%1 )# G"+H4;S )7 ;". &.77%+ 7+"= 4 1)&%4&%S ,)C% +0%.=4$)&=S H0)20 )& =41% H"+&% ?; G"+H4;X& 04+&0 H)#$%+ 2,)=4$%S $0% -"(%+#=%#$ H),, &%#1 ;". $" $0% !4#4+; M&,4#1& 7"+ 4 7.,, ="#$0 "7 $0%+46; ^ &.# $0%+46; ^ 4,, %R6%#&%& 64)1 ?; $0% -"(%+#=%#$Y >-4)#S $0% .#)e.% &)$.4$)"# "7 G"+H4;S 4#1 $0% "$0%+ 524#1): #4()4# 2".#$+)%&S 1"%& #"$ 4,,"H $0%= $" ?%2"=% %4&; ="1%,& "7

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8TJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

%=.,4$)"#Y /0% &=4,, 0"="-%#%".& 6"6.,4$)"#S $0% (4&$ ,4#1%1 $%++)$"+; _%R2%6$ 7"+ F%#=4+C`S $0% .6&24,% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=;S $0% 7.,,; %1.24$%1 6"6.,4$)"#S $0% )#-+4)#%1 2.,$.+4, 4#1 +%,)-)".& H"+C %$0)2S 4#1 $0% ,42C "7 6"(%+$; _4#1 +)20%&`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b"+: )$; "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&Y /0.&S $0% 2"#&.=%+ ,)7%:&$;,% )& 7+.-4, 2"=64+%1 $" $0"&% "7 $0% N5> 4#1 @%+=4#;Y ].$ $0% H%,74+% &$4$% -%#%+4$%& %#"+=".& &%2.+)$;Y 5"=% G"+H%-)4#&S 4#1 >=%+)24# 2+)$)2&S &4; $04$ $0% %#$+%6+%#%.+)4, 4#1 2+%4$)(% &6)+)$ )& &466%1 )# G"+H4; ?%24.&% H%4,$0 422.=.,4$)"# )& ,)=)$%1 $0+".-0 0)-0 $4R4$)"#S H0),% ,)7%:&%2.+)$; )& -.4+4#$%%1Y /0)& 2".,1 ?% $+.%S %R2%6$ $04$ 524#1)#4()4# )#1.&$+)%& 04(% ?%%# 4$ $0% 2.$$)#- %1-% ^ c",("S 544?S <+)2&&"#S G"C)4S MC%4S G"+H4; 50)66)#- 4#1 "$0%+ 2"+6"+4$)"#& 4+% 1")#- e.)$% H%,, )# H"+,1 2"=6%$): $)"#S 4#1 524#1)#4()4# &2)%#$)7)2S 4+$)&$)2S 4#1 4$0,%$)2 420)%(%: =%#$& 04(% 4,&" ?%%# +%=4+C4?,%S -)(%# $0% &=4,, 6"6.,4$)"#& "7 $0%&% 2".#$+)%&Y >,$0".-0S ?; @%+=4# 4#1 >=%+)24# &$4#14+1&S 2"#&.=%+)&= )& =%4: -%+ )# G"+H4; 4#1 $0% +%&$ "7 524#1)#4()4S 4#1 -""1& 4#1 $4R%& &%%= )#"+1)#4$%,; 0)-0S )# G"+H4; %(%# ?.&)#%&& 6%"6,% ^ )#2,.1)#- $0"&% H0" %R6"+$ 6.,6S 646%+S ,.=?%+S 20%=)24,&S 7%+$),)\%+&S 4,.=)#.=S 4#1 $+4#&6"+$ =420)#%+; _)#2,.1)#- &0)6&` $" $0% -,"?4,)\)#- H"+,1 "7 1"-: %4$:1"- 246)$4,)&= ^ b")# )# $0%)+ #4$)"#X& 410%+%#2% $" &"2)4, 1%="2: +42;Y M# G"+H4;S H0%+% )#1)()1.4, $4R +4$%& 24# 2,)=? 4?"(% OT 6%+ 2%#$S 2)$)\%#& ?%#%7)$ 7+"= 4 &%+)%& "7 7+%% %#$)$,%=%#$&S 4#1 )#7,4$)"# )& ?%,"H A 6%+ 2%#$a $0% .#%=6,";=%#$ +4$% )& $0% ,"H%&$ )# <.+"6%Y /0% 0"=%: &6.# H%,74+% 24C% ^ 4& $0% 6#; Q7"I E,4#3 6.$ )$ ^ )& &.+%,; $0% &H%%$%&$ )# $0% H"+,1Y8P

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8TL

88T +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

!4#414X& H%,74+% &$4$% )& "#,; 64+$)4,,; $0% +%&.,$ "7 &"2)4,:1%="2+4$)2 )1%","-;Y 3"+% )=6"+$4#$,;S !4#414 )& .#1%+6"6.,4$%1S (%+; 2",1 )# $0% H)#$%+ _)# &"=% 6+"()#2%&`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`Y U.+$0%+S !4#41)4# &20"",)#- )& 7+%%S .6 $0+".-0 0)-0 &20"",S 4#1 )=6"+$4#$,;S $0% .#)(%+&)$)%& 4+% )#%R6%#&)(% ?; G"+$0 >=%+)24# &$4#: 14+1&Y *+%:&20"", %1.24$)"#4, 6+"-+4=& 4+% ?%)#- +46)1,; %R$%#1%1 )# !4#414S 4#1 )#2,.1% ?),)#-.4, )#&$+.2$)"# )# U+%#20 )# &"=% "7 $0% 6+"()#2%&Y /0% 6+%:&20"", 6+"-+4=& 04(% +%2%)(%1 0)-0 =4+C& 7+"= %1.24$"+&S 4#1 H),, ?% %R$%#1%1 7.+$0%+ _$" $0% 4-% "7 D` )# 7.$.+% ;%4+&Y >1.,$ %1.24$)"#S )#2,.1)#- U+%#20:,4#-.4-% )==%+&)"#S )& 4,&" %R64#1)#-S 4#1 )& 4,&" (%+; )#%R6%#&)(%Y !0),1:24+% 6+"-+4=& 4+% %R2%,,%#$S ?.$ ,4+-%,; 6+)(4$)\%1S 4#1 24# ?% 2"&$,;Y 9"H%(%+S $0% 20),1 4,,"$=%#$S H0%+% $0% &$4$% 64;& %420 74=),; 7"+ %420 20),1S 64+$,; 1%7+4;& $0% 2"&$ "7 &.20 24+%Y /0)& 20),1 4,,"$=%#$ 04& ?%%# )#2+%4&%1 4& $0% 2"&$ "7 ,)()#- 04& )#2+%4&%1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>.3.'.JQ

/" &.= .6' !4#414X& H%,74+% &$4$% 04& ?%%# &.22%&&7., 4#1 )& %R64#1: )#-Y >#1 !4#414 04& 1+4H# #%H )==)-+4#$& ?; $0% 0.#1+%1& "7 $0".: &4#1&Y 3"#$+%4, 4#1 /"+"#$" 4+% =4b"+ =.,$):%$0#)2 2)$)%&S H0),% ]+)$)&0 !",.=?)4 ^ H)$0 )$& =),1%+ *42)7)2 2,)=4$% ^ )& %=%+-)#- +46)1,; 4& "#% "7 $0% ="&$ 6"6.,4+ "7 !4#414X& 6+"()#2%&Y B4&$,;S !4#414X& %2"#"=;S $0".-0 #"$ %R64#1)#- 4& +46)1,; 4& $0% N5>X& ^ $0% !4#41)4# 1",,4+ )& H"+$0 "#,; QO 2%#$& _8LLL` ^ )& 7.,,; 0)-0: $%20 4#1 (%+; &.22%&&7.,,; %R64#1)#- )# $0% #%H -,"?4, %#()+"#=%#$Y /0% G>U/> 4-+%%=%#$8L 04& ?%%# e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b%2$& 7"+ $0% 6""+ 4#1 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&S 4,"#- H)$0 ="1%, &.?.+?4# 2"==.#)$)%&S %R0)?)$)#- 0)-0:&6%%1 $+4)# &%+()2% )#$" $0% 2)$;S ?%4.$)7., +%2+%4$)"#4, 4+%4& H)$0 &H)==)#- 6"",& 4#1 $%##)& 2".+$&S 4#1 ,"(%,; 464+$=%#$ ?.),1)#-&Y 9"H%(%+S ?%24.&% "7 $0% 0)-0 1%#&)$; "7 !0)#%&% 6"6.,4$)"# 4#1 $0% ,42C "7 ,4#1S $0% 464+$=%#$& 4+% W+4??)$ 0.$20%&X ^ &=4,,S =.20 $"" &=4,, ^ %(%# ?; <.+"6%4# &$4#14+1&S =.20 ,%&& >=%+)24#Y 9"#- Z"#-S $0".-0 6.+%,; 246)$4,)&$S 1%(%,"6%1 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 888

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b"?& ^ "77 $0% ?"4$& ^ H%+% 6+"()1%1 7"+ 4,, 7)&0%+=%# 4#1 $0%)+ H)(%&Y /0% 6+"-+4= 04& ?%%# 4 $+%=%#1".& &.22%&&S 4#1 7"+=%1 $0% ?4&)& 7"+ $0% 6+"-+4=& %&$4?,)&0%1 $" 4?&"+? $0% =4)#,4#1 !0)#%&%Y M# 742$S #"HS $0% 9"#- Z"#-%+& C%%6 4 7%H ?"4$ 74=),)%& 4+".#1S b.&$ $" &0"H $0% $".+)&$& ^ 4#1 $0%&% 74=),)%& =4C% 4 -""1 ,)()#- 7%++;)#- $0% $".+)&$& 4+".#1 $0%)+ ",1 04+?"+ 4+%4Y U",,"H)#- $0)& 6+"-+4= $0+".-0S 0".&)#- 6+"b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`S $0% 6%#&)"# 6+"-+4=& 4+% e.)$% ,.2+4$)(%Y <4+,; 20),10""1 4#1 41.,$ %1.24$)"# 4+% 4(4),4?,% )# 9"#- Z"#- 4$ +%4&"#4?,; ,"H 2"&$&S 4#1 =4#; 9"#- Z"#-%+& $4C% 41(4#$4-% "7 $0%&% 6+"-+4=& ^ H0)20 )#2,.1% <#-,)&0 ,4#-.4-% &$.1;S #"H $04$ $0% ]+)$)&0 04(% ,%7$ ^ ?%24.&%S 4& $0%; &4; )# 9"#- Z"#-S W<#-,)&0 )& $0% ,4#-.4-% "7 ?.&)#%&&YX _>#1 )$ )& 4,&" $+.% $04$ !4#$"#%&% )& #"$ .#1%+&$""1 ?; $0% 34#14+)#:&6%4C)#- ]%)b)#- "77)2)4,&Y` >& ="+% H"=%# %#$%+ $0% H"+C 7"+2% ^ 4#1 b.&$ H4$20 $0% 2+"H1& 6".+ ".$ "7 $0% &.?H4;& "# $0%)+ H4; $" H"+C )# 9"#- Z"#- 4#1 ;". H),, &%%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

88A +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

$04$ 4$ ,%4&$ 4 $0)+1 "7 $04$ 2+"H1 )& H"=%# "# $0%)+ H4; $" H0)$%:2",,4+ b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b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

M#/1.%#52*.*# )(*;.)620 :#%-.37A S%+*.+3A *"# 1&%-#% @&,+#*5 ;/&)6 3.*+&32 .3' >"+3. !%+$4)# #4$)"#& H0)20 041 7.,,; 1%(%,"6%1 H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=& 04(% 041 $" 2.$ ?42C "# &"=% "7 $0%= 7"+ %2"#"=)2 +%4&"#&Y /0% %2"#"=)2 2"#1)$)"#& $04$ 04(% -%#%+4$%1 $0% 2.$?42C& 04(% ?%%# 1)7: 7%+%#$ )# %420 #4$)"# )# e.%&$)"#S 4#1S $0%+%7"+%S =.&$ ?% 1%&2+)?%1 24&% ?; 24&%Y >,&"S )# $0% )#&$4#2% "7 @%+=4#;S #" )1%","-)24, &0)7$ 04& "22.++%1S H0%+%4& )# $0% "$0%+ #4$)"#& )1%","-)24, 4,$%+4$)"#& 4+% (%+; =.20 )#(",(%1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 88D

88I +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/H" 742$"+& 04(% -%#%+4$%1 4# %2"#"=)2 2+)&)& )# @%+=4#;' $0% +%: )#1.&$+)4,)\4$)"# "7 <4&$ @%+=4#;S 4#1 $0% 4?&"+6$)"# "7 $0% <4&$ @%+: =4# H"+C)#- 2,4&&S $"-%$0%+ H)$0 4 0.-% )#7,.R "7 H"+C%+& 7+"= <4&$%+# <.+"6%S /.+C%;S $0% 7"+=%+ [.-"&,4()4S G"+$0 >7+)24S >7+)24S 4#1 ="+%Y /0% +%.#)7)24$)"# "7 @%+=4#; H4& 4 ="=%#$".& %(%#$ 7"+ ?"$0 @%+=4#; 4#1 $0% H"+,1 ^ )$ 6+"1.2%1 %,4$)"# 4#1 $+%6)14$)"#Y /0% !",1 E4+ H4& 7)#4,,; "(%+S ?.$ 4 +%.#)7)%1 @%+=4#; =41% $0% "$0%+ <.+"6%4#& #%+(".&Y f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b"?& )# $0% $+4#&)$)"# $" $0% 0)-0: $%20 )#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$)(% .#)$&Y >,"#- H)$0 $0% &.11%#,; 0)-0 .#%=: 6,";=%#$ +4$% 7+"= <4&$ @%+=4#;S 24=% 4# %#"+=".& )#7,.R "7 H"+C%+& 7+"= *",4#1S 5,"(4C)4S K.&&)4S [.-"&,4()4 4#1 "$0%+ <4&$%+# <.+"6%4# 2".#$+)%& H0"&% %2"#"=)%& H%+% 4,&" )# $0% =)1&$ "7 4 &)=),4+ +%:)#1.&: $+)4,)\4$)"# 6+"2%&&S 47$%+ $0% 74,, "7 2"==.#)&=Y /0% @%+=4#& 4,+%41; 041 %#".-0 W-.%&$ H"+C%+&XAI 7+"= /.+C%;S @+%%2%S [.-"&,4()4 4#1 %,&%H0%+%Y /0%; 1)1 #"$S 4#1 2".,1 #"$S 4?&"+? &" =4#; #%H )==)-+4#$& 4$ "#2%Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% .#%=6,";=%#$ ,%(%, 04& &.11%#,; &"4+%1S H0),% %2"#"=)2 %R6%#1)$.+%& )# <4&$ @%+=4#; 4,&" ?.+-%"#%1 ?%;"#1 %R6%2$4$)"#&Y @)(%# $0% %2"#"=)2 2+)&%&S 2"&$:2.$$)#- )# "$0%+ &%2$"+& "7 $0% %2"#"=; 04& ?%%# &".-0$Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ H04$ 04& ?%%# 2.$S 4#1 H04$ 04& #"$Y @%+=4#; 04& "#% "7 $0% ?%&$ b"?:$+4)#)#- 4#1 b"?:.6-+41)#- 6+"-+4=& )# $0% H"+,1Y U"+ AT ;%4+& $0%&% @%+=4# 6+"-+4=& 04(% ?%%# 6+"()1%1 7+%% ?; ?"$0 -"(%+#=%#$ 4-%#2)%& 4#1 6+)(4$% 2"+6"+4$)"#&YAO 5)#2% $0% @%+=4# %2"#"=; #%%1%1 0)-0,; &C),,%1 H"+C%+&S 7"+ $0% 64&$ AT ;%4+& $0%&% 6+"-+4=& 04(% =",1%1 $0% W-.%&$ H"+C%+X )==)-+4#$& )#$" 4

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

:#%-.37KT

=4+(%,".&,; 7.#2$)"#)#- H"+C7"+2%Y G"HS 0"H%(%+S H)$0 $0% #%H 7,""1 "7 )==)-+4$)"#S $0%&% b"?:$+4)#)#- 6+"-+4=& 24##"$ 422"=="14$% 4,, $0% H"+C%+& H0" H)&0 $" %#$%+ $0% H"+C7"+2%Y M$ )& #"$ $04$ $0% $+4)#)#- 6+"-+4=& 04(% ?%%# 2.$ ?42CS 7"+ $0%; 04(% #"$S #"+ 04& $0%+% ?%%# 4 2.$:?42C )# $0% b"?:.6-+41)#- 6+"-+4=& _H)$0 2"=6.$%+ )#&$+.2$)"#`a )$ )& +4$0%+ $04$ $0".&4#1& "7 -.%&$ H"+C%+& 04(% ?%%# &%#$ 0"=% "+ 1)&2".+4-%1S H0),% =4#; H0" 04(% +%=4)#%1 04(% ?%2"=% .#%=6,";%1Y @%+=4#; )& %R6%+)%#2)#- =4b"+ 6+"?,%=& "(%+ $0)& %2"#"=)2 1),%==4Y *+%b.1)2% 4-4)#&$ -.%&$ H"+C%+& )& %&24,4$)#-S 4#1 )# <4&$ @%+: =4#; %&6%2)4,,;S H0%+% @%+=4# H"+C%+& 4+% ?%)#- ,4)1 "77S &C)#0%41 4#1 #%":G4\) -+".6& 04(% %R64#1%1 $0%)+ =%=?%+&0)6 4#1 )#7,.%#2%YAP c)",%#$ 2+)=%& 4#1 04$% 2+)=%& 04(% )#2+%4&%1 ^ %&6%2)4,,; )# $0% <4&$ @%+=4# 2)$)%&Y f,1 6+%b.1)2%&S &.20 4& $0% 04$+%1 "7 $0% -;6&)%& _#"H 24,,%1 $0% K"=4`S 04(% +%:%=%+-%1S H0),% #%H 6+%b.1)2%&S &.20 4& $04$ 4-4)#&$ $0% /.+C&S 04(% )#2+%4&%1Y @%+=4#; 04& #"$ 42$.4,,; 2.$ ?42C "# )$& b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`S 04& 2+%4$%1 4 2+)&)& 7"+ $0% 7.$.+%Y >& )# $0% N5>S +%=%1)%& 7"+ $0)& 2+)&)& 4+% ?%)#- &".-0$ )# @%+=4#;S H)$0 #" 2,%4+:2.$ 4#&H%+ 04()#- ;%$ %=%+-%1Y >& H)$0 $0% N5>S ?"$0 6+"b%2$%1 ?.1-%$ &.+6,.&%& 4#1 0)-0:;)%,1 6+)(4$% &$"2C:=4+C%$ &",.$)"#& 4+% ?%)#- 1)&2.&&%1Y 5$),,S 4-4)# 4& )# $0% N5>S $0% #4$)"#4, 6%#&)"# 6,4# 04& #"$ ?%%# 2.$ ?42CS

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 88O

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` $0% @%+=4#& 04(% &6"#&"+%1 W0%4,$0; ,)()#- 6+"-+4=&XS )#(",(%1 H)$0 %R%+: 2)&%S 1)%$S 4#1 0%+?& ^ H)$0 0%+?4, +%=%1)%& )#2+%4&)#-,; &".-0$ 7"+ 6&;20","-)24, 4#1 60;&)24, +%,)%7 _$0%; 4+% 20%46%+ $04# 1+.-& "+ ,"#-: $%+= 6&;20"$0%+46;S $0".-0 "7$%#S "7 2".+&%S ,%&& %77%2$)(%`Y 5"S $0% 6%#&)"# 4#1 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6+"-+4=& 04(% #"$ +%4,,; ?%%# 2.$ ?42C )# @%+=4#;Y >#1S $0%+% 4+% H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=& H0)20 4+% ?%)#- #%H,; )#$+"1.2%1 "+ %R64#1%1Y U"+ )#&$4#2%S 4& ="+% H"=%# ="(% )#$" $0% H"+C7"+2% ^ 4#1 $0)& )& 0466%#)#- e.)$% +46)1,; ^ 20),1:24+% 6+"-+4=& 4+% ?%)#- )#)$)4$%1Y U",,"H)#- G"+H4;S )# @%+=4#; 4#1 )# U+4#2%S 4 =4b"+ -"(%+#=%#$: &6"#&"+%1S 4#1i"+ &.?&)1)\%1S 20),1:24+% 6+"-+4= )& %=%+-)#-Y f#% 24# 20""&% &$4$%:+.# #.+&%+)%& 4#1 #.+&%+; &20"",&S "+ 6+)(4$%,; +.# #.+&%+)%&Y f#% 24# 20""&% ,)2%#2%1 20),1:24+% H"+C%+& H0" 24+% 7"+ -+".6& "7 20),1+%#S "+ 6+)(4$%,; 64)1 #4##)%&Y M# 4,, 24&%&S -"(%+#=%#$ %2"#"=)2 &.66"+$ "+ &.?&)1; )& )#(",(%1Y 9"H%(%+S H0%+%4& )# G"+H4; 4#1 $0% "$0%+ 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%& 20),1 24+% )& 2"=6,%$%,; 7+%% 7"+ %(%+;"#%S )# @%+=4#; 4#1 U+4#2%S $0".-0 $0% 24+% )& $%20#)24,,; 7+%%S ,"#- H4)$)#- ,)&$& &$),, "22.+S 7"+ #"$ %#".-0 20),1:24+% 742),)$)%& 04(% ;%$ ?%%# ?.),$ ^ #"+ )& H"=%#X& ,)?%+4: $)"# )#$" $0% H"+C 7"+2% 4& 2"=6,%$% 4& )# $0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%&Y 5$),,S $0% 6,4#S 4$ $0% ="=%#$S )& $" %R64#1 20),1:24+% 742),)$)%& $" 4,, 1.4,:24+%%+ 2".6,%& 4& $0% #%H =),,%##).= "6%#&Y G" 411)$)"#4, $4R%& 04(%S 4& ;%$S ?%%# 6+"6"&%1 $" 2"(%+ &.20 6+"-+4=&S ?.$ +%=%=?%+ $04$ 4,, "7 $0% <.+"6%4# 2".#$+)%& 04(% 6,42%1 4 W(4,.%:411%1 $4RX "# ,4+-%:

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

88P +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

)$%= 2"#&.=%+ 6.+204&%&S H)$0 $0)& $4R %&24,4$)#- 4& $0% 6+)2% "7 $0% )$%= %&24,4$%& _$0.& $4R)#- $0% +)20 ="+% $04# $0% =)11,% 4#1 H"+C)#2,4&&%&`Y 5"S )# %&&%#2%S $0% W(4,.%:411%1 $4RX 04& 4,+%41; ?%%# $4+-%$%1 $" 2"(%+ =.20 "7 $0% #%H H%,74+%:&$4$% %R64#&)"#Y E% &04,, 1)&2.&& c>/ )# $0% #%R$ 2046$%+Y >,"#- H)$0 7+%% 20),1 24+%S 7,%R $)=% 4#1 %R$%#1%1 =4$%+#)$; ,%4(%& H)$0 64; ^ 7+"= $0+%%:e.4+$%+& $" 7.,, 64; 7"+ 4 ;%4+ ^ 04(% ?%-.# $" ?%2"=% 7.,,; )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1 )# @%+=4#; _4& H%,, 4& /0% G%$0%+,4#1& 4#1 5H)$\%+,4#1`Y U,%R:$)=% b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` $4C%& 41(4#$4-% "7 $0%&% 6+"-+4=&S 4#1 $0%; 4+% #"$ ;%$ .#)(%+&4,Y 9"H%(%+S $0% $+%#1 )& 1%7)#)$%,; $"H4+1& G"+H4;X& 7.,,; .#)(%+&4, 6+%:&20"", 6+"-+4=Y >& 7"+ .#)(%+&)$; %1.24$)"#S $0)& )& ?%)#- %R64#1%1Y G%H .#)(%+&)$)%& 04(% ?%%# ?.),$Y /0% -""1 64+$ 4?".$ $0% @%+=4# %R64#&)"# )& $04$ 4,, $0% .#)(%+&)$)%& ^ %(%# $0% #%H%&$ ^ 0",1 %e.4, &$4#1)#- )# @%+=4#; )# $%+=& "7 4241%=)2 %R2%,,%#2%S &" $04$ 4 &$.1%#$ =)-0$ 6+%7%+ $" -" $" 9%)1%,?%+- "+ 3.#)20S ?%24.&% "7 $0% ,"24$)"# 4#1 $0% $+41)$)"#S ?.$ )7 $04$ &$.1%#$ -+41.4$%1S &4;S 7+"= 4 #%HS ,%&& H%,,:,"24$%1 .#)(%+&)$;S &.20 4& ])%,%7%,1SAL $04$ &$.1%#$ H".,1 &$),, -4)# 7.,, 6+%&$)-% 4#1 %e.4, &$4#1)#- 4241%=)24,,;Y /0% ?41 64+$ 4?".$ $0% @%+=4# .#)(%+&)$; %R64#&)"# )& $04$ =4&& ,%2$.+%& ^ 4,H4;& 4 @%+=4# .#)(%+&)$; $+41)$)"# ^ 04(% ?%2"=% ="+% 2"=="#6,42%S H)$0 $.$"+)4, &%&&)"#& "7 &=4,,%+ -+".6& "7 &$.1%#$& #"$ 0%,1 "7$%# %#".-0Y >,&"S $0% 2"=6%$)$)(% $%&$)#- &;&$%= "7 @%+=4#; _4#1 4,, <.+"6%S 4& H%,, 4& d464# 4#1 #"H 5)#-46"+%` )& (%+; 04+&0S 6,42)#- %#"+=".& &$+%&& "# $0% &$.1%#$& )# $0% ;%4+& b.&$ 6+)"+ $" $0% $%&$)#-Y /0)& 6+"?,%= #"H 4,&" $;6)7)%& >=%+)24# &$.1%#$& &$.1;)#- 7"+ $0%)+ 5>/ %#$+4#2% %R4=&S ?.$ )&S #"#%$0%,%&&S 6+"?,%=4$)24,S 4#1 24# -%#%+4$% 6%+&"#4,

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 88Q

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e.)$% ?",1Y /0% 7.$.+% "7 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% )# @%+=4#;S )# 64+$)2.,4+S 1%6%#1& "# 0"H H%,, $0%; +%)#1.&$+)4,)\% *+.&&)4S 4#1S )# 0"H $0%; )#$%-+4$% _"+ %R6%,` $0% =),,)"#& "7 -.%&$ H"+C%+&DT H0" 04(% 7,""1%1 @%+=4#; &)#2% $0% 74,, "7 2"==.#)&= 4#1 $0% %#1 "7 2","#)4,)&=Y S%+*.+3TJ f#% 0%4+& 4 -+%4$ 1%4, 4?".$ 34+-4+%$ /04$20%+X& 4$$%=6$ $" 1)&=4#$,% $0% H%,74+% &$4$%Y >#1 1.+)#- 0%+ W+%)-#X 4& *+)=% 3)#)&$%+ $0%+% 2%+$4)#,; H%+% =4b"+ 2.$?42C& 4#1 4 -%#%+4, 4$="&60%+% "7 4.&$%+)$;Y ].$ H4& 2.$$)#- $0% H%,74+% &$4$% +%4,,; /04$20%+X& 4-%#14V f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`S &.20 $04$ 4--+%&&)(% %#$+%6+%#%.+)4,)&= H4& &%%# 4& 1)&-.&$)#- 4#1 1%-+41)#-S H0),% $0% ="+% -%#$,%=4#,; 6+"2%&&%& "7 H4$20)#- "(%+ &$"2C )#(%&$=%#$& 4#1 0.#$)#- )# $0% 2".#$+;&)1% H%+% 6+%7%++%1Y /0% +%&.,$ H4& $04$ ]+)$)&0 )#1.&$+)4, 2"+6"+4$)"#& H%+% 74),)#- 4#1 $0%)+ 6+"1.2$& H%+% .#+%,)4?,% 4#1 14$%1Y /0% d4-.4+ ="$"+ 24+ )& $0% 6%+7%2$ %R4=6,% 0%+%Y E0),% 3%+2%1%& H%#$ 0)-0:$%20 4#1 6+"1.2%1 $0% ?%&$: &%,,)#- 24+ )# $0% H"+,1S d4-.4+ H4& #"$%1 7"+ )$& ,%4$0%+S )$& H""1S 4#1 )$& 2"=6,%$% .#+%,)4?),)$;Y d4-.4+ &4,%& H%+% 1%2,)#)#- H0),% F4)=,%+:]%#\ H4& ?%2"=)#- $0% 1"=)#4#$ 4.$" =4#.742$.+%+ )# $0% H"+,1Y M# $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

88J +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

%#1S d4-.4+ 041 $" ?% &",1 "77 $" U"+1S 4#1 U"+1 041 $" )=6,%=%#$ "(%+ ATT 204#-%& )# $0% d4-.4+ 1%&)-# )# "+1%+ $" =4C% $0% 24+ 7.#2$)"#4,S H0),% 2"=6,%$%,; +%4++4#-)#- $0% d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d%H)&0S M#1)4#S *4C)&$4#) 4#1 3)11,% <4&$%+# )==)-+4#$& H0" &0"H%1 &"=% %#$+%6+%#%.+)4, 7,4)+Y 50% %#2".+4-%1 #%H )#1.&$+)4,)\4: $)"#S 4#1 1%#4$)"#4,)\%1 ="&$ "7 $0% )#1.&$+)%&Y 9)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&= H4& H04$ &0% H4#$%1 $" %#2".+4-% )# ]+)$4)#Y >#1S ;%&S &0% 041 $" 2+.&0 $0% .#)"#& $" 1" )$S 4#1 &0% 041 $" &04=% $0% ?.&)#%&& 4#1 ?4#C)#- "H#%+& $" 1" )$Y <(%# #"HS =4#; "7 $0% =4b"+ ]+)$)&0 )#1.&$+)%& 04(% ?%2"=% 7"+%)-#: "H#%1 "+ b")#$,; "H#%1 ?; >=%+)24# 7)+=&Y <.+"6%4# 4#1 d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 88L

]"$0 $0% 4#$)e.% -%#$+;:&$;,% "7 ,)7% 4#1 $0% 4#$)e.4$%1 .#)"#& 04(% ?%%# ,%7$ ?%0)#1Y /0% /04$20%+ +%(",.$)"# 1)1 +%4,,; %#-%#1%+ $0% 0)-0: $%20 246)$4,)&$ ="1%+#)\4$)"# "7 ]+)$4)#Y G"HS .#7"+$.#4$%,;S 1.+)#- $0)& $+4#&)$)"#S /04$20%+ ;%3 $"" $)-0$:7)&$%1S $"" H)$00",1)#-S $"" .#24+)#-Y /0% #%-4$)(% +%&.,$ "7 /04$20%+X& &%,7:+)-0$%".& 6+"-+4= H4& 4 =4b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`S $0% ]+)$)&0 =)11,% 2,4&& )& -")#- $" .#)(%+&)$)%& ^ +%1?+)2C .#)(%+&)$)%& ^ )# -+%4$%+ #.=?%+&S 4#1 $0".-0 $0%&% .#)(%+&)$)%& 1" #"$ 04(% $0% %,)$% &$4$.& "7 !4=?+)1-% 4#1 fR7"+1S $0%; 4+% e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e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8AT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

&,"H,; ="()#- $"H4+1Y U"+ W&"2)4,)\%1 =%1)2)#%X H4& #"$ 4 &.22%&&S ?.$ $0% )1%4 "7 7+%% =%1)2)#% 7"+ 4,, 04& #"$ ?%%# 4?4#1"#%1Y M# $%+=& "7 %1.24$)"#S <#-,4#1 04& ?%%# 4 ,%41%+ )# 2%+$4)# +%-4+1& ^ 4#1 %&6%2)4,,; )# $%+=& "7 422"=="14$)#- $0% %1.24$)"#4, #%%1& "7 $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&Y /04$ )&S $0% ]+)$)&0 &;&$%= 04& 2+%4$%1 %R2%,,%#$ #.+&%+; &20"",& 4#1 6+%:&20"",&Y >#1 $0%&% &20"",& 04(% $+)%1 #%HS ,%&& 4.$0"+: )$4+)4#S $%420)#- $%20#)e.%&Y *%+046& 5.==%+0),,DL H%#$ $"" 74+ )# 6%+: =)&&)(%#%&&S ?.$ 041 #"$ $0% ",1 &20"",& ?%%# $"" 4.$0"+)$4+)4#V 34#; &.22%&&7.,S %R6%+)=%#$4, &20"",& #"H %R)&$ )# <#-,4#1S H0),% $0% &$4#: 14+1 &20"",& 4+% 4="#- $0% 7)#%&$ )# $0% H"+,1S #"$ "#,; )# $%420)#$%20#)e.%&S ?.$ 4,&" )# 2"#$%#$Y !0),1+%# H)$0 4 ]+)$)&0 %1.24$)"# 1" 74+ ?%$$%+ )# >=%+)24# 0)-0 &20"",&S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S $04# $0"&% %1.24$%1 )# >=%+)24# -+41% &20"",&Y >#1 ]+)$)&0 %1.24$)"# &%%=& $" )#&$),, 4 -%#%+4, ,"(% 7"+ ,4H 4#1 1%="2+42;S H0)20 04& #"$ "#,; ?%%# 4 -)7$ 7"+ @+%4$ ]+)$4)#S ?.$ 4 -)7$ 7"+ $0% H"+,1 ^ %&6%2)4,,; )# $0% 7"+=%+ 2","#)%&Y /0% +%1?+)2C .#)(%+&)$)%&S 2+%4$%1 ;%4+& 4-"S 041 ?%%# %R64#1%1 $" 4?&"+? $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 %1.24$% $0%= 7"+ $0% 0)-0:$%20 H"+,1Y >#1 $0%; 2"#$)#.% $" ?% %R2%,,%#$ ?; H"+,1 &$4#14+1&Y /0% 6+"?,%= +%=4)#&S 0"H%(%+S $04$ 4,$0".-0 f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`Y /0% ]+)$)&0 <=6)+% =4; 04(% ?%%# WH"# "# $0% 6,4;)#- 7)%,1& "7 <$"#XS ?.$ )$ H4& 4,&" ,"&$ $0%+%Y U.+$0%+S $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& )# ]+)$4)# 2"#$)#.%& $" ?% #%-,%2$%1Y <1.24: $)"#4, 6+"-+4=& 04(% #"$ &.22%%1%1 H)$0 $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&& ^ #4$)(% "+ )==)-+4#$Y <#-,4#1 #%%1& @%+=4#;X& b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8A8

>& )# 4,, $0% 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#&S $0% %#$+4#2% "7 H"=%# )#$" $0% H"+C: 7"+2% 04& 2+%4$%1 $0% #%%1 7"+ 20),1:24+% 742),)$)%&Y 9%+%S ]+)$4)# )& ="(: )#- 4,"#- e.)$% H%,,Y ].$ H0%$0%+ $0% &;&$%= "7 20),1 24+% H),, ?% 6+)(4$%S &.?&)1)\%1S "+ -"(%+#=%#$:+.# )& #"$ ;%$ 7.,,; 2,%4+Y E04$ )& 2,%4+S $0".-0S )& $04$S 4& H)$0 $0% ]+)$)&0 &20"",&S $0% #.+&%+)%&S &" 74+S 04(% ?%%# H%,, +.# 4#1 e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b"?&Y 9"H%(%+S ]+)$)&0 &20"",& 4+% 4="#- $0% ?%&$ )# $0% H"+,1S 4#1 ]+)$)&0 20),1:24+% )#&$)$.$)"#& 4+% %R2%,,%#$S $0".-0 2,4&&: ?4&%1Y /0% &%#)"+ 2)$)\%# 742),)$)%& 4+% %R64#1)#-S 4#1 "7 +%,4$)(%,; -""1 e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e.4$%1 742$"+; &;&$%=S 4#1 $H"S $0% %#$+%#20%1 2"=:

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8AA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

=.#)&$ ?.+%4.2+42; $04$ 041 &%+(%1 $" ?,"2CS +4$0%+ $04# 41=)#)&$%+S &" =4#; "7 $0% 6+"-+4=& $04$ 041 ?%%# 4$$%=6$%1YID U)+&$S 4 W6+)(4$)\4$)"#X "7 $0% -"(%+#=%#$:+.# %#$%+6+)&%& 041 $" ?% 422"=6,)&0%1 ^ 4#1S .#7"+$.#4$%,;S =4#; &.20 %#$%+6+)&%& H%+% 2,4)=%1 ?; 7"+=%+ ?.+%4.2+4$& H0" &$),, 041 6"H%+Y 5"=%$)=%& $0%&% ?.+%4.2+4$& &",1 "77 $0% H0",% "+ 64+$ "7 742$"+)%&S 74),)#- $" ="1%+#)\% 4$ 4,,Y 5"=%: $)=%& $0%; %#-4-%1 )# b")#$ (%#$.+%& H)$0 H%&$%+# 2"+6"+4$)"#& $04$ 0%,6%1 ="1%+#)\% $0% 742$"+)%&Y M# 4#; 24&%S $0)& 6+"2%&& "7 6+)(4$)\4$)"# 04& ?%%# 1)77)2.,$ ^ "#,; )# $0% !\%20 K%6.?,)2 4#1 9.#-4+; 04& $0% 6+"2%&& -"#% H%,, _4#1 $" 4 ,%&& %R$%#$ )# *",4#1`Y M# K.&&)4 4#1 NC+4)#% $0%+% 04& ?%%# &" =.20 2"++.6$)"# 4#1 ()",%#$ 2+)=% )# $0)& $+4#&)$)"#S $04$ )$ )& .#2,%4+ H04$ H),, ?% $0% 7)#4, +%&.,$Y >#1S &%2"#1S H)$0 $0% &.11%# +%="(4, "7 $0% !"==.#)&$ *4+$; ?.+%4.2+42;S #" &$4$% 41=)#)&$+4$)"# 6+"2%&& H4& ,%7$ )# 6,42% $" %4&% $0% $+4#&)$)"# $" 4 =4+C%$ %2"#"=;Y <&6%2)4,,; )# K.&&)4S ?.$ 4,&" )# $0% "$0%+ #4$)"#&S $0% 6,4# H4& $" -" W2",1 $.+C%;X 1)+%2$,; $" $0% =4+C%$ %2"#"=;YII ].$ $0)& 4&&.=%& $04$ $0%+% 4+%S "+ H),, ?%S %#$+%6+%#%.+)4, ?.&)#%&&=%# 4#1 )#1.&$+)4,)&$& H0" H),, =4-)24,,; 466%4+ 4#1 +.# $0% ?.&)#%&& %2"#"=; %77)2)%#$,; 4#1 6+"7)$4?,;Y M$ 4,&" 4&&.=%& $04$ $0%+% )&S )# 6,42%S W-"(%+#=%#$ ?; ,4HXS &" $04$ 2"#$+42$& H),, ?% 0"#"+%1S 64$%#$& +4$)"#4,,; +%H4+1%1S 4#1 ?.&)#%&& %#$%+6+)&%& H),, "6%+4$% )# 4 +4$)"#4, 2"#$%R$ "7 ,4H 4#1 0"#"+%1 4-+%%=%#$&Y 9"H%(%+S ".$&)1% $0% !\%20 K%6.?,)2 4#1 9.#-4+;S H0%+% %#$+%6+%#%.+)4, ?.&)#%&&=%# 041 %R)&$%1 ?%7"+% $0% 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+S 4#1 H0%+% -"(%+#=%#$ ?; ,4H H4& 64+$)4,,; )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1S $0%+% H%+% #" ?.&)#%&&=%# 4#1 $0%+% H4& #" ,4HY K.&&)4 )& $0% %R$+%=% 24&% H0%+%)# 7"+=%+ -"(%+#=%#$ ?.+%4.2+4$&S 4#1 -4#-&$%+ ?,42C =4+C%$%%+& 04(% 4$$%=6$%1 $" ?%2"=% ?.&)#%&&=%#Y ].$ ,42C)#- 4 ,4H7., 6",)$)24, &;&$%=S 4#1 .&%1 $" 4 +%6+%&&)(% 1)2$4$"+: &0)6S $0%&% &":24,,%1 ?.&)#%&&=%# .&% %R$"+$)"#S ?+)?%+; 4#1 =.+1%+ $" 422"=6,)&0 $0%)+ ?.&)#%&& -"4,&Y >$ $0)& ="=%#$ )# 0)&$"+; _ATTT`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8AD

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f7 2".+&%S 1.+)#- $0% $+4#&)$)"#S $0%+% =4; #"$ ?% %#".-0 246)$4, $" 1" ?"$0Y ].$ $0% <4&$%+# ?,"2 %,%2$"+4$%S )$ &%%=&S H".,1 +4$0%+ &,"H 1"H# %2"#"=)2 1%(%,"6=%#$ $04# -)(% .6 $0%)+ H%,74+% &$4$% ?%#%7)$&YIP B%% Z.4# [%H "7 5)#-46"+% ^ e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8AI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

$0% 24+% "7 $0% %,1%+,; 04& ?%%# 6,42%1 "# $0%)+ 74=),)%& ^ 4#1 $0)& )& 4 $%++)?,% ?.+1%# 4$ 4 $)=% "7 0)-0 .#%=6,";=%#$ 4#1 )#7,4$)"#Y 9".&)#- )& #"$ ?%)#- ?.),$ ^ )$ )& #"$ 4 0)-0:6+)"+)$; )$%= )# $0% 4$$%=6$%1 %2"#"=)2 $+4#&)$)"#Y /0%+%7"+%S 74=),)%& 4+% 2+"H1%1 )#$" &=4,, 464+$=%#$&S 4#1 7%H +%64)+& 04(% ?%%# =41% "# $0% %R)&$)#0".&)#- .#)$&Y /0% 20),1:24+% 742),)$)%& 4+% &$),, "6%+4$)"#4, 4#1 &$),, .$),)\%1Y 9"H%(%+S &.66,)%& 4+% &0"+$S ?.),1)#-& 4+% +4+%,; +%64)+%1S 4#1 #%H 20),1:24+% H"+C%+& 4+% #"$ ?%)#- 0)+%1Y /0% &20"",&S +%=4+C4?,;S 4+% &$),, 4241%=)24,,; %R2%,,%#$S 7+"= -+41% &20"", $" .#)(%+&)$;Y 9"H%(%+S #" #%H ?.),1)#-& 4+% -")#- .6S #" #%H $%420%+& 4+% ?%)#- 0)+%1S +%64)+& 4+% #"$ ?%)#- =41%S 4#1S "7 2".+&%S $0%+% )& #" ,"#-%+ $0% -.4+4#$%% "7 4 b"? 7"+ -;=#4&).= "+ .#)(%+&)$; -+41.4$%&Y /0% 0%4,$0:24+% &;&$%= )& &$),, 7+%%S ?.$ )# K.&&)4 4#1 )$& &4$%,,)$%& )$ )& 1%2,)#)#- )# e.4,)$;S 7+)-0$%#)#-,;Y 9"&6)$4,& 4+% 1%$%+)"+4$)#-S %e.)6: =%#$ )& #"$ ?%)#- +%64)+%1S ,)-0$)#- )& 6""+S 4#1 %(%# &4#)$4$)"# )& H"+&%#)#-Y M# *",4#1S 9.#-4+;S 4#1 $0% !\%20 K%6.?,)2S $0% 0%4,$0 24+% &;&$%=& 4+% #"$ 74,,)#- 464+$S ?%24.&% $0% %2"#"=)%& 4+% 6+"()1)#%#".-0 +%(%#.% $" &.&$4)# $0%)+ .6C%%6Y ].$ )# K.&&)4 $0% &)$.4$)"# )& H"+&%#)#-Y /0.&S )# "(%+4,, 6%+&6%2$)(%S H04$ H% 7)#1 )# $0% 7"+=%+ 5"()%$:?,"2 #4$)"#& )& 4 =4b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e.4+% 1%="#&$+4: $)"#&YIL >#1S 7.+$0%+S 04()#- +%6+%&&%1 $0% 1%="2+42; ="(%=%#$S $0% 64+$; ,%41%+& $0%# &4H $0% 5"()%$ N#)"# 74,, 464+$ 6",)$)24,,; 4#1 ?%2"=% -4#-&$%+:()",%#$ %2"#"=)24,,;Y /0)& 7+)-0$%#%1 $0%= 4#1 ?",&$%+%1 $0%)+ &%,7:+)-0$%".& 4#$):1%="2+4$)2 ?%,)%7&Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% !0)#%&% !"==.#:

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8AO

)&$ *4+$; ,%41%+&0)6 1%2)1%1 $" =4C% $0% $+4#&)$)"# $" 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&: $+)4, 246)$4,)&=S 4#1 $" "6%# .6 7+%% =4+C%$ %#$+%6+%#%.+)4,)&=S H0),% +%$4)#)#- 6",)$)24, 6"H%+ )# $0%)+ "H# 04#1&Y U+%%:=4+C%$ %2"#"=)2 -+"H$0 04& ?%%# &6%2$42.,4+ ^ !0)#%&% %2": #"=)2 -+"H$0 ,%(%,& %R2%%1%1 $0% H"+,1X& %R6%2$4$)"#&Y M# 742$S 0"H: %(%+S $0% 1)&=4#$,)#- "7 $0% )#%77)2)%#$ &$4$% )#1.&$+)%& 04& ?%%# b.&$ 4& 64)#7., 4#1 1)77)2.,$ 4& )# K.&&)4Y ].$ !0)#%&% ?.&)#%&&=%# 1)1 %R)&$ $" 0%,6 !0)#4 )# $0% $+4#&)$)"#Y /0%&% !0)#%&% ?.&)#%&&=%#S "7 2".+&%S 1)1 #"$ %R)&$ )# !0)#4S ?.$ +4$0%+ )# 9"#- Z"#-S 5)#-46"+%S 4#1 /4)H4#g ].$ )$ &0".,1 ?% %R6,4)#%1S $04$ .#,)C% K.&&)4S !0)#4 041 4 1;#4=)2 %#$+%: 6+%#%.+)4, 2,4&& )# 6+%:2"==.#)&$ 14;& 4#1S $0".-0 $0%; H%+% +%6+%&&%1S $0% $+41)$)"# H4& )#-+4)#%1 %#".-0S &.20 $04$ #"HS 4 #%H 2,4&& "7 ="1%+# %#$+%6+%#%.+& )& +46)1,; %=%+-)#- )# 504#-04)S !4#$"# 4#1 ]%)b)#-YOT B%1 ?; 9"#- Z"#- ?.&)#%&& ,%41%+&S !0)#4 )& &$4+$,)#- $0% H"+,1 H)$0 )$& &.22%&&7., 7+%%:%#$%+6+)&% %2"#"=;Y f7 2".+&%S $0%+% )& &$),, #" ,4H7., -"(%+#=%#$S &" $04$ 2"#$+42$& 4#1 64$%#$& 4+% 6+"?,%=4$)24,S 4#1 .#,4H7., 42$)()$)%& 1" 4?".#1 _%&6%2)4,,; )# $%+=& "7 6)+4$)#- 64$%#$%1 6+"1.2$&S &.20 4& ()1%" $46%&S ?""C& 4#1 2"=6.$%+ &"7$H4+%`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d464#%&% 7"+ $0% W+46% "7 G4#b)#-X 4#1 "$0%+ 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+ 4$+"2)$)%&S $0%; 04(% 422%6$%1 2%+$4)# "7 $0%&% b")#$ (%#$.+%&S 4#1 $0%&% 04(% ?%%# e.)$% &.22%&&7.,Y U.+$0%+S 4& )# /4)H4#S >=%+)24# 2"+6"+4$)"#& 04(% ?%%# (%+; )#$%+: %&$%1 )# ?"$0 b")#$ (%#$.+%& )# )#1.&$+;S 4#1S )# 1%(%,"6)#- $0% !0)#%&% =4+C%$ 7"+ >=%+)24# -""1&Y /0% !0)#%&% #%%1 H04$ H% 04(%' 7""1 4#1 0)-0:$%20 6+"1.2$&Y E)$0 4 ?),,)"# 6%"6,%S !0)#4 )& $0% .,$)=4$% =4+C%$

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8AP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

7"+ >=%+)24X& "(%+6+"1.2$)"# "7 -+4)#&S ?%4#&S =%4$S 4#1 14)+; 6+"1.2$&Y 32F"#4,1X& 4#1 Z%#$.2C; U+)%1 !0)2C%#S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S 04(% &.22%%1%1 )# 9"#- Z"#- 4#1 /4)H4#S 4#1 2".,1 +%46 4 ?"#4#\4 )# !0)#4Y 5"S $""S >=%+)24X& &"7$H4+% 4#1 2"=6.$%+ 04+1H4+% 2"=64#)%& 4+% 20"=6)#- 4$ $0% ?)$ $" -4)# $0% (4&$ !0)#4 =4+C%$Y E)$0 !0)#4X& 4#$)e.4$%1 !"==.#)&$ *4+$; C%%6)#- 4 &%=?,4#2% "7 6",)$)24, "+1%+S 4#1 H)$0 !0)#%&% ?.&)#%&&=%# &0"H)#- 9"#- Z"#-: &$;,% ?.&)#%&& %R2%,,%#2% 4#1 ,%-4,)$;S >=%+)24# 2"+6"+4$)"#& 4#1 d464#: %&% 2"=64#)%& 04(% ?%%# (%+; H),,)#- $" -" )#$" !0)#4 4#1 -+"HY E)$0 $0)& !0)#%&% %2"#"=)2 &.22%&&S H04$ 4?".$ !0)#4X& H%,74+% &$4$% ^ )$& &":24,,%1 W)+"# +)2% ?"H,VXOA 34" 041 ?%%# 6+".1 "7 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% $04$ $0% !0)#%&% !"==.#)&$ *4+$; 041 2+%4$%1Y 9"H%(%+S )$ =.&$ ?% &4)1 $04$ 34" %R42$%1 4# %R$"+: $)"#4$% 6+)2% 7"+ $0% 7+%% &%+()2%&' $04$ )&S 2"+(%h%:,4?"+ 6+"b%2$& ^ $0% 04,,=4+C "7 4#2)%#$ !0)#4 4#1 )$& C)#-,;:?.+%4.2+4$)2 =4#14+)# &$4$%Y /0% 6%4&4#$& 4#1 H"+C%+& H%+% )#0.=4#,; "(%+H"+C%1 )# $0% -.)&% "7 0%+")2 #4$)"#:?.),1)#-S %&6%2)4,,; 1.+)#- $0% W@+%4$ B%46 U"+H4+1X %+4YOD M# +%$.+#S $0% !"==.#)&$ *4+$; 1)1 "77%+ 4 -.4+4#$%%1 b"? ^ 74+ $"" =.20 "7 4 -.4+4#$%%1 b"? ^ &"=% &20"",)#-S &"=% =%1)2)#%S &"=% 0".&)#-S &"=% 20),1 24+%S 4 6%#&)"#S 4#1 "$0%+ H%,74+%:&$4$% ?%#%7)$&Y /0% H%,74+% &$4$% C%6$ 6%"6,% 2,"$0%1S 0".&%1S 7%1S %1.24$%1 4#1 H"+C: )#- ^ 4#1 )$ 1)1 ,)?%+4$% H"=%# )#$" $0% b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d"?& 4+% #" ,"#-%+ -.4+4#$%%1S ?.$ 24+%%+& )# $0% #%H 0)-0:$%20 %2": #"=; 4+% %=%+-)#-Y >$ $0% =)11,%:2,4&& %#1S &.20 24+%%+& 4+% e.)$% 6+"=)&)#-S H0),% 4$ $0% H"+C)#-:2,4&& %#1S $0%; =4; ?% =.20 H"+&% $04# .#1%+ 2"==.#)&= ^ ,"#- 0".+&S ,"H H4-%& 4#1 20),1 %R6,")$4$)"# 204+42$%+)\)#- &"=% "7 $0% #%H 742$"+)%&YOI

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8AQ

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e.4$%1 2"=: =.#)&$ H%,74+%:&$4$% 6+"-+4=&Y >& "7 #"HS 0"H%(%+S $0)& )& 6.+% &6%2.: ,4$)"#Y

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8AJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

$0% 64+,)4=%#$4+; 1%="2+42)%& H),, &.+()(% )# K.&&)4 4#1 &"=% "7 $0% &4$%,,)$% +%6.?,)2&Y <2"#"=)2 6+%1)2$)"#& "# !0)#4 4+% 0"6%7.,S ?.$ ?%24.&% "7 $0% "(%+: 6"6.,4$)"#S 7"+2%1 ,4?"+S 20),1 ,4?"+S 4#1 ),,%-4, %2"#"=)2 42$)()$)%&S H0)20 H),, 2"#$)#.% $" %R)&$ 4,"#-&)1% %R2%,,%#$ ?.&)#%&& -+"H$0S )$ )& 1)77)2.,$ $" =4C% 6+%1)2$)"#& #"HY 94()#- &.+(%;%1 (4+)".& #4$)"#& 4+".#1 $0% -,"?%S ,%$ .& #"H ,""C 4$ $0% =4b"+ 6+"?,%= 742)#- 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#& )# $%+=& "7 H%,74+%:&$4$% &%+()2%&' +)&)#- 2"&$& ^ 1.% $" 1%="-+460)2S $%20#","-)24, 4#1 %R64#: &)"#4+; +%4,)$)%&Y M7 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% )& $" ?% +%$4)#%1S 4#1 %R64#1%1 "# 4 #%H =)11,%:2,4&& ?4&%S 0"H 1" H% 64; 7"+ )$V

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'#2$%"# @1%1# Z:0%-3,7-3B +<1A%&I3B +7D!%)4#-13 8AL

/0% K)&)#- !"&$ "7 5%+()2%& )# 9)-0:/%20 5"2)%$)%& 4#1 K%(%#.%: @%#%+4$)#- 3%204#)&=&

!"# %+2+34 )&2*2 &1 *"# 8#/1.%# 2*.*#0 +-$%&,#' *#)"3&/&47 .3' '#-&4%.$"+) *%.32+*+&3 E0%$0%+ "#% )& )1%","-)24,,; )# 74("+ "7 $0% H%,74+% &$4$% "+ "66"&%1 $" )$S $0% 6+"?,%= "7 +)&)#- 2"&$& 04& ?%2"=% 4 +%4,)$;Y /0% 1+4=4$)2 +)&% )# $0% 2"&$ "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%& 04& %=4#4$%1 7+"= $0+%% ?4&)2 &".+2%&' $0% %&24,4$)#- 2"&$ "7 $%20#","-)24, %e.)6=%#$ 4#1 $0% $%4=& $04$ .&% $0)& %e.)6=%#$ )# $0% =%1)24, 4#1 0%4,$0:&%+()2%& 7)%,1&a $0% 1%="-+460)2 $+4#&)$)"# $" 4 ,"H ?)+$0:+4$% 4#1 ,"#-:,)(%1 &%#)"+ 2)$)\%#&a 4#1 $0% )#2+%4&)#- &4,4+)%& "7 6+"7%&&)"#4,,; $+4)#%1 &%+()2% H"+C%+&Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ %420 "7 $0%&%Y !"# (2# &1 -&'#%3 *#)"3&/&47 +3 -#'+)./ .3' "#./*"5%#/.*#' 2#%,+)#2 9%4,$0 24+% 2"&$& 04(% &C;+"2C%$%1 74&$%+ $04# 4,, "$0%+ &%+()2% 2"&$&Y f#% "7 $0% +%4&"#& 7"+ $0)& )& $0% )#2+%4&)#- .&% "7 $%20#","-)24,,; &"60)&$)24$%1 =420)#%&' ,4&%+ &.+-%+; )& #"H 2"=="#6,42%S C)1#%;:1)4: ,;&)& =420)#%& 4+% +".$)#%,; .&%1 $" &4(% 64$)%#$& H)$0 74),)#- C)1#%; 7.#2$)"#&S +41)":42$)(% )"1)#% =420)#%& 4+% .&%1 $" 2"++%2$ $0;+")1 1;&7.#2$)"#S 4#1 C)1#%;:$+4#&6,4#$ "6%+4$)"#& 4+% #"H 1"#% 4,="&$ +".$)#%,; ^ M 2".,1 -" "#Y 9)-0 $%20#","-; )& ?%)#- 466,)%1 H)$0 )#2+%4&)#- &.22%&& $" =%1)2)#% *%"6,%X& ,)(%& 4+% ?%)#- &4(%1S 6%"6,%X& 0%4,$0 )& ?%)#- +%&$"+%1 ^ H% 24#X$ -" ?42C 4#1 H% H),, -" 7"+H4+1 H)$0 $0)& 6+"2%&&Y 9"H%(%+S $0% $%20#": ,"-; )& 2"&$,;Y <(%+; =420)#%S %(%+; $%20#)e.%S 2"&$& $0".&4#1& "7 1",: ,4+&Y >#1 $+4)#%1 $%4=& "7 $%20#)2)4#& 4#1 &.66"+$ &$477 4+% #%%1%1 $" H"+C H)$0 $0% 1"2$"+& 4#1 #.+&%& "# %(%+; #%H 0%4,$0 6+"2%&&Y /0%&% 8DT

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

J

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e.%&$)"# )& #"$S &0".,1 H% %R64#1 ".+ $%20#",": -)24, ()+$."&)$;V ^ ?.$ +4$0%+S 0"H &0".,1 H% 64; 7"+ $0)& %R64#&)"#V !"# '#-&4%.$"+) *%.32+*+&3 /0% 1%="-+460)2 $+4#&)$)"# 04& ?%2"=% 4 -,"?4, 60%#"=%#"#Y8 M$ )#(",(%& =4++)4-% ^ 4+".#1 $0% 4-% "7 AO^DT _.&.4,,; 47$%+ 2",,%-% "+ %R$%#1%1 0)-0 &20"", "+ $%20#)24, &20"",`S $0% #.+$.+)#- "7 "#,; "#% "+ $H" 20),1+%#S 4#1 4 ,"#- ,)7%:%R6%2$4#2;S %R$%#1)#- ?%;"#1 JT ;%4+&Y /0)& 1%="-+460)2 $+4#&)$)"# )& (%+; -""1 )# $%+=& "7 6"6.,4$)"# 2"#$+",Y >& )& H%,, C#"H#S $0% 6"6.,4$)"# %R6,"&)"#A )& $0+%4$%#)##"$ "#,; )#1)()1.4, #4$)"#&S &.20 4& M#1)4S !0)#4S 4#1 3%R)2"S ?.$ 4,&" $0% %#$)+% 6,4#%$Y *"6.,4$)"# 2"#$+", )& 4?&",.$%,; #%2%&&4+; )7 H%S 4& 4 &6%2)%&S 4+% $" &.+()(%Y /0%+%7"+%S )$ )& #" H"#1%+ $04$ 2"#$+42%6$)(% 1%()2%& 04(% ?%%# 1%(%,"6%1 4#1 1%6,";%1S 4#1 4+% ?%)#- %R$%#1%1 )# $0% +4#-% "7 #4$)"#& .&)#- $0%=S 4#1 )# $0% C)#1& 4#1 #.=?%+& 4(4),: 4?,%YD /0% #%H W="+#)#-:47$%+X 6),,& 2".,1 ?%2"=% $0% .,$)=4$% 74),:&47% 1%()2% 7"+ ,)=)$)#- .#H4#$%1 6+%-#4#2)%&Y /0% .&% "7 2"#$+42%6$)(%& ?; ="1%+# 2".6,%& )# "+1%+ $" 6,4# $0% #.=?%+ 4#1 $)=)#- "7 $0%)+ 20),: 1+%# )& ?%2"=)#- 4 H"+,1:H)1% 60%#"=%#"#Y >#1 $0% "66"&)$)"# $" &.20 74=),; 6,4##)#- 4#1 6"6.,4$)"# 2"#$+", )& 1%2,)#)#- ^ $0".-0 $0% !4$0",)2 !0.+20S f+$0"1"R d.14)&=S 4#1 "$0%+ +%,)-)".& "+-4#)\4$)"#& 2"#$)#.% $" 1)&466+"(% &.20 6+"2%&&%&Y /0% 6")#$ 0%+% )& $04$ $0% #.=?%+ "7 ;".#- 6%"6,% )& ?%)#- +%1.2%1 H"+,1H)1%S 4#1S $0)& )& "22.++)#- 4$ $0% &4=% $)=% $04$ ",1%+ 6%"6,% 4+% ?%)#- &4(%1 ?; ="1%+# 0)-0:$%20 =%1)2)#%Y /0)& )& 4 6+"?,%= )# $%+=& "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%& ?%24.&% $0% +%(%#.% -4)#%1 7+"= ;".#- 41.,$& )& 1%2,)#)#-S H0),% $0% &%+()2%& "77%+%1 $0% &%#)"+ 2)$)\%#& 4+% )#2+%4&)#)# #.=?%+ 4#1 1.+4$)"#Y G4$)"#& &.20 4& d464# 4#1 5)#-46"+%S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S H0%+% ",1 6%"6,% H%+% 24+%1 7"+ ?; $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),;S #"H 742% 4 &%+)".& 2+)&)& )# $0)& +%-4+1YI >#1 $0% <.+"6%4# #4$)"#& 4#1 $0% N5> 742% 4 7.#1)#- 2+)&)& 7"+ 6%#&)"#& 4#1 0%4,$0 24+% ?%24.&% "7 $0)& 1%="-+460)2 &0)7$YO /0%+%7"+%S 2"&$:7"+=.,4& )# $0% 6+%&%#$ 4#1 $0% 7.$.+% =.&$ $4C% )#$" 422".#$ $0)&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8D8

8DA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

-+"H)#- 1%="-+460)2 )=?4,4#2%S H0)20 )& &4()#- $0% H"+,1 7+"= "(%+: 6"6.,4$)"#S ?.$ 2".,1 4,&" ?4#C+.6$ )$Y

/0% $0)+1 742$"+ $04$ 04& ?%%# 1+)()#- 2"&$& .6 )& 6+"7%&&)"#4,)\4$)"#Y B""C 4$ 0%4,$0 24+% 4,"#%' 1"2$"+& 04(% ?%2"=% &6%2)4,)&$&S 4#1 &6%2)4,: )&$& 1%=4#1 0)-0%+ 7%%&a #.+&%& 4+% $+4)#%1 4& 64+$ "7 $0% $%4=& $04$ 1%,)(%+ 0)-0:$%20 &.+-)24, $%20#)e.%&S $0%+%7"+%S $0%; -%$ 64)1 ="+%a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e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` 4# %R64#1)#- %2"#"=;S -%#%+4$)#- -+%4$%+ +%(%#.%a _A` +%,4$)(%,; 4.&$%+% =),)$4+; &6%#1)#-S ,%4()#- ="+% +%(%#.% 7"+

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# $%&1#22+&3./+<.*+&3 &1 2#%,+)# ).%##%2

2)(),)4# &%+()2%&' _D` 0)-0%+ $4R%& ^ )#2,.1)#- )#2"=% $4R%&S $4+-%$%1 $4R%& _%4+=4+C%1 7"+ &6%2)7)2 &"2)4, &%+()2%&` 4#1 2"#&.=6$)"# $4R%& _&.20 4& $0% <.+"6%4# c4,.% >11%1 /4R`a _I` W$+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$&X 7+"= $0% +)20S &6%2)7)24,,; $4+-%$%1 7"+ &"2)4, &%+()2%&a 4#1 _O` 2":64;=%#$& 7+"= 6+)(4$% )#1)()1.4,& ".$ "7 &4,4+;Y f7 2".+&%S %420 #4$)"#X& %2"#"=)2 2"#1)$)"#S =),)$4+; #%2%&&)$)%&S 4#1 )1%","-)24, 6+"2,)()$)%& H),, ?% 1)77%+%#$Y ].$S #"#%$0%,%&&S &"=% 2"=?): #4$)"# "7 $0% 4?"(%:=%#$)"#%1 %2"#"=)2 =%204#)&=& H),, ?% .$),)\%1 )# "+1%+ $" 64; 7"+ $0% )#2+%4&)#-,; 1%=4#1%1 4#1 )#2+%4&)#-,; %R64#&: )(% &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y U3 #B$.3'+34 #)&3&-7 f#% H".,1 $0)#C $04$ %2"#"=)%& 24##"$ %R64#1 2"#$)#.".&,;Y /0%+% H),, ?% ,)=)$& $" %R64#&)"#S )# $%+=& "7 +%&".+2%& 4#1 )#1.&$+)4, -+"H$0YP 9"H%(%+S ?%24.&% "7 $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$ "7 #%H $%20#","-)%&S #%H )#1.&: $+)%& 4#1 -,"?4, 2"+6"+4$% =%+-%+&S %R64#&)"# &%%=& $" ?% 4 ,"#-:$%+= 60%#"=%#"# $04$ =4; #"$ &%% )$& ,)=)$ +%420%1 7"+ e.)$% &"=% $)=%Y f7 2".+&%S 4 ,)=)$ H),, 6+"?4?,; ?% +%420%1 ^ ?.$ H0%#V >$ $0% ="=%#$S H% 2".,1 6+%1)2$ -+"H$0 )# !0)#4 4#1 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4S ?.$S 6%+046&S d464#X& -+"H$0 H),, ?% &,"H%1Y >#1 @%+=4#; 4#1 $0% <.+"6%4# N#)"# 4+% %R6%+)%#2)#- &$4-#4$)"# #"HS 4#1 04(% b.&$ _8LLL`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`S 41=)$$%1 $04$ $0% &%+()2%& H".,1 ?% 6+"()1%1S 4#1 7.+$0%+S $04$ 0% &$+"#-,; &.6: 6"+$%1 $0% %#$+4#2% "7 H"=%# )#$" $0% H"+C7"+2% _$0".-0 0% 0"6%1 $0%; H".,1 04(% 20),1+%# ^ &)#2% 0% ?%,)%(%& $04$ %1.24$%1 H"=%# 6+"1.2% ?%$$%+:%1.24$%1 20),1+%#S H0"&% W=%+)$X )& #%%1%1 )# 5)#-46"+%X& H"+C 7"+2%`Y >& 4#"$0%+ %R4=6,%S ?"$0 $0% F%="2+4$& 4#1 $0% K%6.?,)24#& )# $0% N5> H%+% &.+6+)&%1 $04$ 4 ?.1-%$ &.+6,.& %=%+-%1 )# $0% 8LLT& H0)20

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8DD

)#2,.1%1 %#".-0 +%(%#.% $" 7)#4#2% =4#; "7 $0% &"2)4, &%+()2%& 0%+%: $"7"+% "66"&%1 "# %2"#"=)2 4#1 )1%","-)24, -+".#1&Y > +%(%+&% %R4=6,% H".,1 ?% $04$ "7 d464#S H0%+% $0% &,"H1"H# "7 $0% %2"#"=; )# $0% 8LLT& ^ 04(% $0%; +%420%1 $0%)+ ,)=)$ "7 %R6"+$& "+ H4& )$ b.&$ $0% W>&)4# U,.XVL ^ 04& %#-%#1%+%1 4 2+)&)& )# &%+()2%&Y <,1%+ 24+% )& ?%)#- &0)7$%1 ?42C $" $0% 74=),;a b"? +%:$+4)#)#- )& ?%)#- +%6,42%1 ?; 7)+)#-&a 0".&)#- )& #"$ ?%)#- ?.),$S 4#1 &" "#Y E),, $0% d464#%&% %2"#"=; +%()(%V M$ 2".,1 )7 !0)#4 W"6%#&X H)1%+S 4#1 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4 _/04),4#1S %&6%2)4,,;` +%2"(%+& 7+"= )$& %2"#"=)2 2",,46&%Y U(2*#%# -+/+*.%7 2$#3'+34 <(%+; #4$)"# =.&$ 6+"$%2$ )$&%,7' 1%(%,"6)#- 4#1 )=6+"()#- $0% =),)$4+; 2464?),)$)%& "7 4 #4$)"# 4+% )=6"+$4#$Y f#% 24##"$ ?% #4)(% 4?".$ 0.=4#&S 4& 0.=4#&' "#% "7 ".+ -%#%$)2 e.4,)$)%& &%%=& $" ?% 04$)#- $0% W"$0%+X 0.=4# -+".6 4#1 H4++)#- H)$0 $0%=Y8T E4+&S #%4+: H4+&S 4#1 $0+%4$& "7 H4+S 0466%# %(%+; ;%4+Y K%2%#$,;S $0% 5%+?& 4#1 >,?4#)4#& 7".-0$ "(%+ Z"&"("Y /0% 5%+?&S H)$0 $0% -+%4$%+ =),)$4+; 24642)$; 04(% 4$$%=6$%1 $" 1+)(% $0% >,?4#)4#& ".$S H0),% G>/fS H)$0 ="+% =),)$4+; 24642)$; $04# $0% 5%+?&S 04& 7"+2%1 $0%= )#$" 4 2"=6+"=: )&% 6%42%Y /0.&S =),)$4+; 24642)$; )& #%2%&&4+; 7"+ #4$)"#4, &.+()(4,Y /0% e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8DI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0% 24&%& "7 d464# 4#1 @%+=4#;S ?%$H%%# 8LIO 4#1 8LQOS ),,.&$+4$% $0)& 60%#"=%#"# 7.+$0%+Y ]"$0 #4$)"#& H%+% 6+%(%#$%1 7+"= 1%(%,"6: )#- $0%)+ =),)$4+; 24642)$)%& 4& 64+$ "7 $0% &.++%#1%+ 4-+%%=%#$& 47$%+ $0% 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+Y /0)& $.+#%1 ".$ $" ?% 4# %2"#"=)2 -)7$S ?"$0 )# $%+=& "7 )#(%&$=%#$ )#$" 2)(),)4# 2"#&.=%+ 6+"1.2$)"#S 4#1 )# $%+=& "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y ]"$0 @%+=4#; 4#1 d464# %R64#1%1 4#1 $%20#","-)\%1 $0%)+ 2)(),)4# 6+"1.2$)"#S H0),% 6+"()1)#- 4# %R2%,,%#$ 4++4; "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y M# 742$S @%+=4#;S 4,"#- H)$0 G"+H4; 4#1 5H%1%#S 6+"1.2%1 $0% ="&$ 2"=6,%$% 4#1 H%,,:+.# H%,74+% &$4$% &%+()2% &;&$%= )# $0% H"+,1Y8D d464#X& &"2)4, &%+()2% &;&$%= 04& "#,; ?%%# ,)=)$%1 ?; 2.,$.+4, 742$"+& ^ &.20 4& 74=),; 24+% 7"+ $0% %,1%+,;S 4#1 74=),; &4()#-& 7"+ +%$)+%=%#$Y f$0%+H)&%S d464# 6+"()1%& 4 7.,, +4#-% "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%&S )#2,.1)#- b"?:$+4)#)#- 4#1 +%$+4)#: )#- 7"+ H"+C%+& H0" H".,1 "$0%+H)&% ?% ,4)1 "77 ?%24.&% "7 1%(%,"6=%#$& )# 4.$"=4$%1 6+"1.2$)"# _)# H0)20 $0% d464#%&% ,%41 $0% H"+,1`Y /0%+%7"+%S =),)$4+; 6+%64+%1#%&&S )7 2"=?)#%1 H)$0 4.&$%+)$; )# 6+": 1.2$)"# 4#1 1%6,";=%#$S 24# 4,,"H 7"+ %#".-0 2)(),)4# +%(%#.% $" 7.#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y K.&&)4 )& $0% 24&% H0%+%)# 4# %R2%&& "7 =),)$4+; &6%#1)#- 1.+)#- $0% !",1 E4+ 6+%(%#$%1 #"$ "#,; $0% 7.#1)#- "7 41%e.4$% &"2)4, &%+()2%&S ?.$ )#0)?)$%1 $0% -+"H$0 "7 $0% 2)(),)4# 2"#&.=%+ %2"#"=;Y8I /0% K.&&)4# 4.&$%+)$; )# 2"#&.=%+ 6+"1.2$)"# 4#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%& %(%#$.4,,; %#-%#1%+%1 &.20 4#-%+ 4#1 7+.&$+4$)"# )# $0% #%H -%#%+4$)"#S $04$ 2"==.#)&= 7%,, 7+"= H)$0)# ^ &"=%$0)#- $04$ $0% H"+,1X& %=)#%#$ 6",)$)24, &2)%#$)&$& &4)1 2".,1 #"$ 0466%#Y8O f7 2".+&%S 4#1 M 1" #"$ =%4# $" =)#)=)\% $0)& )# 4#; H4;S 1%="2+42; 4#1 7+%%1"= "7 %R6+%&: &)"# %e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e.4,)7)%1 ?; $0% &"2)4, 742$ "7 $0% 1%&)+% 7"+ %$0#)2 )#1%6%#1%#2% H0)20 04& ?%2"=% 4 H"+,1 60%#"=%#"#Y ].$S )# $0)& +%-4+1S "#2% W4 6%"6,%X ?%2"=% 7.,,; ="1%+# ^ W6"&$="1%+#XS )7 ;". )#&)&$ ^ $0%; &%%= ,%&& )#$%+%&$%1 )# $0%)+ %$0#)2 6.+)$; 4#1 ="+% )#$%+%&$%1 )# ?%2"=)#477,.%#$ 2)$)\%#& "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 -,"?4, (),,4-%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8DO

8DP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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e.%&$)"# +%4,,; )&S 4+% 2)$)\%#& "(%+:$4R%1V >#1S $0% 4#&H%+ )& ;%&S )7 $0%; 04(% #" 246)$4, ,%7$ $" ?.; $0% 6+"1.2$& 2"+6"+4$)"#& H)&0 $" &%,, $0%= )# "+1%+ $" C%%6 $0% %2"#"=; %R64#1)#- _C%%6)#- )#7,4$)"# 4& 4 2"#&$4#$S 4#1 .&)#- W+%4,X 1",,4+&S "7 2".+&%`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b%2$ )# )$& "+)-)#Y 9"H%(%+S %(%# 4#$):&"2)4,)&$S 6.+% 246)$4,)&$ #4$)"#& &.20 4& $0% N5> 41"6$%1 $0% -+41.4$%1 )#2"=% $4R 1.+)#- $0% @+%4$ F%6+%&&)"#Y >$ $0% ="=%#$S H% 1" #"$ H)&0 $" 1)&2.&& H0%$0%+ $0% -+41.4$%1 )#2"=% $4R

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

O+4"#% *.B#20 +3)&-# *.B#2A *.%4#*#' *.B#2 .3' )&32(-$*+&3 *.B#2

"+ 4 1)77%+%#$ &"+$ "7 )#2"=% $4RS &.20 4&S &4;S 4 W7,4$X $4RS8L H".,1 ?% $0% +)-0$ )1%4Y 9%+% H% H)&0 $" 2"=64+% $0% ,%(%, "7 )#2"=% $4R4$)"# )# @%+=4#; 4#1 U+4#2%S 2"=64+%1 H)$0 $04$ )# $0% N5>Y M# @%+=4#; 4#1 U+4#2% $0% )#2"=% $4R )& 0)-0%+ $04# )# $0% N5> 7"+ $0"&% )# $0% H"+C)#-:2,4&& 4#1 =)11,%:2,4&& ?+42C%$&Y >#1 )#2"=% $4R )& =.20 0)-0%+ "# $0"&% )# $0% H%4,$0; ?+42C%$&Y /0)& 0)-0 +4$% "7 )#2"=% $4R4$)"# 04& 6+"()1%1 $0% @%+=4# 4#1 U+%#20 -"(%+#: =%#$& H)$0 =.20 "7 $0% +%(%#.% $0%; #%%1 7"+ $0%)+ H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=&Y N#$), +%2%#$,;S @%+=4#; 4#1 U+4#2% H%+% 4?,% $" 6+"()1% 7"+ $0%)+ 2)$)\%#& 4 H%,74+% &$4$% #%4+,; 4& 2"=6,%$% 4& $04$ "7 G"+H4; 4#1 5H%1%#Y /04$ )&S $0%; 6+"()1%1 %R2%,,%#$ 6%#&)"#& 4#1 7)(% H%%C&X 64)1 (424$)"#&S 7+%% 0%4,$0 24+%S 7+%% &20"",)#- ^ 7+"= #.+&%+; $" .#)(%+&)$; ^ 4#1 #"H 7+%% 20),1:24+% 742),)$)%& _$0".-0 $0%&% ,4$$%+ 4+%S 4& ;%$S &24+2%`YAT /0% 0)-0 )#2"=% $4R%&S 0"H%(%+S 1" +%1.2% $0% 4(%+4-% )#1)()1.4,X& 4?),)$; $" ?.; 2"#&.=%+ -""1&Y M# 2"=64+)&"# H)$0 $0% N5>S 24+& 4+% &=4,,%+S 464+$=%#$& 4#1 0".&%& 4+% &=4,,%+S H"=%# 04(% 7%H%+ ".$7)$& 4#1 &0"%&a %,%2$+"#)2 %e.)6=%#$S &.20 4& $%,%()&)"#& 4#1 c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g !+%1)$:

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8DQ

24+1 1%?$ )# $0% N5> )& &" 0)-0 $04$ >=%+)24#& 4+% $4C)#- ".$ &%2"#1 ="+$-4-%& 4#1 0"=% %e.)$; ,"4#& )# "+1%+ $" 64; 2"#&.=%+:6.+204&% 1%?$Y >#1S "#2% )$ )& 64)1S $0%; +.# .6 $0% 2+%1)$ 24+1 1%?$ 4-4)#YA8 M$ &%%=& $04$ $0% 6+%&&.+% $" ?.; )# >=%+)24 ^ 7+"= /c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e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e.%& )#

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8DJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

"+1%+ $" &4(% 4#1 ,%#-$0%# ,)(%&Y /0% &4=% ,4&%+&S 1)4,;&)&S +41)":42$)(% )"1)#%S 0%4+$ $+4#&6,4#$&S %$2YS 4+% ?%)#- .&%1 )# @%+=4#; 4& )# $0% N5>Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% 2"&$& "7 =%1)24, 24+% 04(% -"#% .6Y >#1 @%+=4#& 4+% ,)()#- ,"#-%+ 4#1 +%e.)+)#- ="+% "6%+4$)"#& 4#1 ="+% =%1)2)#%&S b.&$ 4& )# $0% N5>Y 5)#2% $0% @%+=4# 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6+"-+4= )& -"(%+#=%#$:+.# 4#1 $4R:7.#1%1S ="+% +%(%#.% H4& #%%1%1 )# "+1%+ $" &4(% $0% 6+"-+4= 7+"= ?4#C+.6$2;Y /0% &",.$)"# 20"&%# ?; $0% @%+=4#& ^ 4#1 $0)& H4& 4 b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`Y /0% @%+=4# $4+-%$%1 O 6%+ 2%#$ $4R 04& +4)&%1 4 (%+; ,4+-% 6"", "7 +%(%#.%S H0)20 $0% -"(%+#=%#$ 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% ?.+%4. 04& 24+%7.,,; 04+(%&$%1Y /0% AT:;%4+ 6+%1)2$)"# =4; "+ =4; #"$ ?% "(%+,; "6$)=)&$)2S ?.$ %2"#"=)&$& 4#1 0%4,$0 %R6%+$& )# @%+=4#; 4-+%% $04$ $0% 7+%% 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% &;&$%= H),, ?% &47% 7"+ 4$ ,%4&$ $0% #%R$ 8T ;%4+&Y f7 2".+&%S =.20 1%6%#1& "# 0"H e.)2C,; <4&$ @%+=4#; 24# ?% ="1%+#)\%1S 0"H =4#; )==)-+4#$ H"+C%+& 24# ?% 4?&"+?%1S 4#1 0"H %77%2$)(% $0% 4$$%=6$%1 %2"#"=)2 %R64#&)"# 6",)2)%& H),, ?%Y G"#%$0%,%&&S $0% $4+-%$%1 $4R )1%4S &6%2)7)24,,; W%4+=4+C%1X 7"+ 4 -)(%# &"2)4, &%+()2%S )& 6"6.,4+S #"$ "#,; )# @%+=4#;S ?.$ )# U+4#2%S /0% G%$0%+,4#1&S F%#=4+CS G"+H4; 4#1 5H%1%#S 4#1 4,&" #"H )# 564)#Y M# M$4,;S $0% 6+"?,%= "7 ,"24,)\%1S $+41)$)"#4, 7.1-)#- 4#1 74C)#- "# $4R 64;=%#$& =4C%& $0)& 6"&&)?),)$; #"$ e.)$% 4& %77%2$)(% ^ ?.$ $0)& )& 4 &6%2)7)2 M$4,)4# 6+"?,%=S +%,4$)#- $" )#2"=% $4R%& 4#1 4,, "$0%+ $4R%&Y >#1S $0%+%7"+%S $0% M$4,)4#& 04(% "6$%1 7"+ 2":64;=%#$&S "+ 6+)(4$% 64;: =%#$&a H% H),, 1)&2.&& $0)& "6$)"# &0"+$,;Y /0% $4+-%$%1 $4R 04& ?%%# .&%1 7"+ $0% 7.#1)#- "7 7+%% %1.24$)"# )# <.+"6%S 4& H%,, 4& 7+%% 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2%Y f$0%+ $4+-%$%1 $4R%& 04(% ?%%# 466,)%1 $" 20),1:24+% 6+"-+4=&S &.20 4& $04$ )# U+4#2%S H0%+% $0% 7+%% 20),1:24+% 6+"-+4= )& "#% "7 $0% ?%&$S %(%# $0".-0 )$ )& 1%6%#1%#$ .6"# )#2+%4&%1 $4R4$)"#Y G"HS $0% $4+-%$%1 $4R ^ 4& H)$0 $0% )#2"=% $4R ^ 1%6%#1& "#' _8` $0% +%,4$)(% %77)2)%#2; "7 -"(%+#=%#$ ?.+%4.&a 4#1 _A` $0% ,42C "7 -+47$

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8DL

_$0%7$`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f=?.1&=4# ^ "+ W6%"6,%X& 41("24$% 4-4)#&$ $0% ?.+%4.2+4$)2 &$4$%XYAP 94()#- H4+#%1 4-4)#&$ $0% 6+"?,%= "7 -"(%+#=%#$ ?.+%4.2+42;S ,%$ .& +%)$%+4$%S 0"H%(%+S $04$ $0% $4+-%$%1 $4R )& 4# %R2%,,%#$ )1%4S 7.#2$)"#)#e.)$% H%,, )# <.+"6%S 7"+ 6+"()1)#- $0% %R64#&)"# "7 &24+2%S %R6%#&)(%S &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y E(# &7-3<4#" 1%:= 1(# Z<"70#%- S%2<# F99#9 E%: [SFE\ %-9 1(# F4#",&%3%2#3 1%: /0% <.+"6%4# N#)"# 04& 411%1 4 $4R "# 2"#&.=%+ -""1&S c>/YAQ /0)& $4R )& ,)C% $0% &4,%& $4R )# $0% N5>S 4#1 4& H)$0 ="&$ &4,%& $4R%&S )$ )& 24,2.,4$%1 4& 4 6%+2%#$4-% "7 $0% 6.+204&% 6+)2%Y 5"S c>/ )& ,"H "# ,"H: $)2C%$ )$%=&S ?.$ 24# ?% e.)$% 0)-0 "# 4 24+ "+ ;420$Y ]%24.&% c>/ )#2+%4&%& H)$0 $0% ,.R.+; "7 $0% )$%= 6.+204&%1S )$ )&S )# $0)& &%#&%S W-+41.4$%1X ,)C% )#2"=% $4RY /0% (4,.% 411%1 $4RS ,)C% $0% >=%+)24# &4,%& $4RS -%#%+4$%& +%(%#.% 7"+ $0% -"(%+#=%#$Y 9"H%(%+S )# <.+"6%S c>/ )& .$),)\%1 $" &.66"+$ H%,74+% &%+()2%& _4& $0% &4,%& $4R )& .$),)\%1 ?; &"=% >=%+)24# &$4$%& $" &.?&)1)\% &$4$% &"2)4, &%+()2%&`Y G"H c>/ )& 4 0)-0 $4RS 4#1S "7 2".+&%S )$ )#2+%4&%& $0% 6+)2% "7 $0% 6+"1.2$ 6.+204&%1 &.?&$4#$)4,,;Y /0%+%7"+%S )$ &%+(%& %)$0%+ $" +%1.2% 2"#&.=%+ &6%#1)#-S "+S $" 7"+2% $0% =)11,%:2,4&& 2"#&.=%+ $" ?.; 4 ,%&& %R6%#&)(% ="1%, "7 $0% 2"#&.=%+ 6+"1.2$ )# e.%&$)"#Y /0.&S ="&$ >=%+)24#& 4+% &.+6+)&%1 ?; 0"H &=4,, $0% 4(%+4-% <.+"6%4# 24+& 4+%S 4#1 0"H ="1%&$ $0%)+ 464+$=%#$& 4+%S 4& H%,,Y /0% 6+)2% "7 -4&",)#% C%%6&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8IT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

24+& &=4,,%+S ?.$ )$ )& $0% 6.+204&% 6+)2%S 6,.& c>/S $04$ +%4,,; 7"+2%& $0% =)11,% 2,4&& $" &0; 4H4; 7+"= ,.R.+; 2"#&.=%+ -""1&Y f# $0% 6"&)$)(% &)1%S c>/ 04& 0%,6%1 $0% <.+"6%4# N#)"# 2".#$+)%& $" 2"#$)#.% $" 6+"()1% 4#1 %R64#1 H%,74+%:&$4$% &%+()2%& 4$ $0% G"+H4;: &$;,% ,%(%,Y 3"&$ <.+"6%4#& %#b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kOTTT $" kDT TTT )# &$4$% 4#1 6+)(4$% .#)(%+&)$)%&YAJ 5" $0% >=%+)24# 74=),; =4; 04(% ,4+-%+S ="+% ,.R.+)".&S 4#1 ="+% #.=%+".& 24+&S ?.$ $0%# =4; 04(% $" -" )#$" 1%?$ $" 64; $0% %&24,4$)#- 2",,%-% $.)$)"# 2"&$&S H0)20 )# <.+"6% 4+% 2"(%+%1 ?; c>/S $4+-%$%1 $4R%& 7"+ %1.24$)"#S 4#1 0)-0%+ )#2"=% $4R%&Y 5" $0% <.+"6%4#& 2"=6,4)# 4?".$ 0)-0%+ 2"#&.=%+ 2"&$&S 4#1 >=%+)24#& ?%="4# $0% 2"&$& "7 %1.24$)"# 4#1 20),1 24+%Y /H" ,4&$ 6")#$& "# $0% c>/' 7)+&$S $0% c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c>/ )& &%$ 4& 64+$ "7 $0% 742$"+; 6+)2%S 6+)"+ $" &4,%&S 4#1 24##"$ ?% 4(")1%1 ?; $0% &%,,%+ "+ 6.+204&%+Y G"HS ,%$ .& ,""C 4$ H04$ H4& "#2% $0% ="&$ 2"#$+"(%+&)4, %2"#"=)2 2"#7,)2$ )# <.+"6%S 4#1 )# %2"#"=)2 $0%"+; )# -%#%+4,' $0% 2"#2%6$ H0)20 )& #"H $%+=%1 W$+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$&XSAL ?.$ H0)20 =%4#& $4C)#7+"= $0% +)20 4#1 -)()#- $" $0% =)11,% 2,4&&S $0% H"+C)#- 2,4&&S 4#1 $0% 6""+Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8I8

50".,1 W6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$;X ?% &42+"&4#2$a &0".,1 $0% +)20 C%%6 %(%+;: $0)#- $0%; 04(% %4+#%1VDT f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`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e.)$% 0)-0S +4#-)#- H%,, 4?"(% OT 6%+ 2%#$ "7 )#2"=% 4$ $0% =),,)"#4)+% 4#1 ?),,)"#4)+% ,%(%,YIA >#1S )=6"+$: 4#$,;S $0%+% 4+% 7%H $4R ,""60",%& "+ $4R &0%,$%+& ^ $0% +)20 +%4,,; 1" 64; $0%)+ $4R%& )# @%+=4#; 4#1 4,, "7 $0% G"+$0 E%&$ <.+"6%4# #4$)"#& _)#2,.1)#- U+4#2%`Y /0%&% 7.#1& 4+% "7$%# .&%1 7"+ $0% W2"=="# -""1X )# $%+=& "7 &%+()2%&Y @%+=4#;S /0% G%$0%+,4#1&S 4#1 $0% 524#1)#4()4# 2".#$+)%& 4+% C#"H# 7"+ $0%)+ %R2%,,%#$ &%+()2%&Y U+"= &20"",& $" 0".&)#- $" 20),1:24+% 742),: )$)%& $" =%1)24, 24+%S $0%&% #4$)"#& 6+"()1% %R2%,,%#$ &%+()2%&S 4#1 =.20 "7 $0% 7.#1)#- 7"+ $0%&% &%+()2%& 2"=%& 7+"= )#2"=%:$4R +%(%#.%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8IA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

G"HS $0% e.%&$)"# "7 ,42C "7 ="$)(4$)"# $" -%$ +)20S "+ +)20%+S "+ $" )##"(4$% %#$+%6+%#%.+)4,,;S 04& ?%%#S 4#1 )& ?%)#-S +4)&%1 4#1 1%?4$%1 )# $0% @%+=4#)2 2".#$+)%&Y U"+ $0%+% 4+% 7%H%+ &=4,, ?.&)#%&& &$4+$.6&S 6%+2%#$4-%:H)&%S 2"=64+%1 $" $0% N5>S 4#1 $0%+% 4+% 7%H%+ &=4,,:?.&)#%&&:$":?)-:?.&)#%&& &.22%&& &$"+)%&Y /0%+% )& 4 1%7)#)$% $+41%:"77 0%+%S ?%$H%%# &%2.+)$; 4#1 ?.&)#%&& ="$)(4$)"#Y f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e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d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c",(" 4#1 "$0%+&S 04(% 0%,1 "+ %R64#1%1 $0%)+ =4+C%$ &04+% 4-4)#&$ $0%)+ >=%+)24# 2"=6%$)$"+&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8ID

/0% @%+=4#)2 2"+6"+4$)"#& 4+% 1")#- (%+; H%,, -,"?4,,;Y f7 2".+&%S .#$), $0% >&)4# 2+)&)& "7 $0% ,4$% 8LLT&S $0% d464#%&% 2"+6"+4$)"#& H%+% +%-.: ,4+,; ".$2"=6%$)#- $0%)+ >=%+)24# 2".#$%+64+$&Y M7 U"+1S 7"+ )#&$4#2% 04& b.&$ ?".-0$ $0% c",(" 24+ 1)()&)"#S F4)=,%+:]%#\ 04& b.&$ ?".-0$ !0+;&,%+Y >#1S .#$), U"+1 6.$ ".$ $0% U"+1 /4.+.&S $0% /";"$4 !4=+; 4#1 9"#14 >22"+1 H%+% $0% ?%&$:&%,,)#- 24+& )# >=%+)24Y 5"S 4-4)#S $0% e.%&$)"# "7 H0%$0%+ 0)-0 2"+6"+4$% $4R4$)"# +%1.2%& 2"+6"+4$% -+"H$0 4#1 0.+$& $0% "(%+4,, #4$)"#4, %2"#"=; )& 4 +%4, %2"#"=)2 6+"?,%= &$),, .#1%+ 1%?4$%Y /0% <.+"6%4#&S )# -%#%+4,S 4#1 $0% d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c>/ H),, 4,&" $4RS 7"+ )#&$4#2%S $0"&% ?.;)#- 0)-0:1%7)#)$)"# $%,%()&)"#& 4#1 "$0%+ 0)-0 6+)2%1 %,%2$+"#)2 -""1&S "+ 0)-0:&$;,%1 1%&)-#%+ 2,"$0)#-Y 5" c>/ &%+(%& 4& ?"$0 4 &4,%& $4R "# %(%+;"#%S 4#1 4 ,.R.+; $4R "# $0% +)20Y 5" 74+S $0% <.+"6%4# +)20 04(% #"$ 2"=6,4)#%1 4?".$ $0)&S #"+ 04(% $0% 2"+6"+4$% %R%2.$)(%&Y @%+=4#S G"+H%-)4# 4#1 F.$20 2"+6"+4$% %R%2.$)(%& &%%= $" 422%6$ $0% 0)-0 $4R4$)"# 4& 4 ?.),$: )# 2"&$ 6+"?,%=S H0)20 7"+2%& $0%= $"H4+1& %77)2)%#$ 6+"1.2$)"# 4#1 $%20#","-)24, )##"(4$)"#S H0),% 6+"()1)#- $0%= H)$0 4 ="+% 2"#$%#$%1 4#1 2""6%+4$)(% H"+C 7"+2%Y E)$0 $0% +%2%#$ &,"H1"H# )# %2"#"=)2 -+"H$0 )# <.+"6% 4#1 d464#S 4#1 H)$0 $0% &04+6 2.$ )# )#$%+%&$ +4$%&S H% 24# ?% &.+% $04$ $4R:2.$& 7"+ 2"+6"+4$)"#& H),, ?% &"=%$0)#- $04$ H),, 0466%#Y 9"H%(%+S )#2+%4&%1 -"(%+#=%#$ )#(%&$=%#$& 4#1 ,"H:)#$%+%&$ ?4#C ,"4#& 04(% ?%%# .$),)\%1 $" &$)=.,4$% $0% %2"#"=; )# @%+=4#; _4#1 d464#`S &" $04$ 2"+6"+4$% $4R%& =4; #"$ ?% 2.$ 4#; 7.+$0%+Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8II +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8IO

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e.4$%S ;%$ $0%; 1" %R)&$ 4#1 $0%; 1" $+4#&7%+ H%4,$0 ^ 0.-% 4=".#$& "7 H%4,$0 ^ 7+"= $0% +)20 $" $0% -%#%+4, 6"6.,4$)"#Y /0% -+41.4$%1 )#2"=% $4R 1"%& %R)&$Y M$ )& -+%4$,; ="1)7)%1 )# %77%2$: )(%#%&& 7+"= )$& <.+"6%4# _4#1 &"2)4,)&$` "+)-)#S )# $04$ $0% +)20 )# $0% N5> 04(% ?%%# 6"H%+7., %#".-0 4#1 )#7,.%#$)4, %#".-0 $" 6.&0 $0% !"#-+%&& $" 2+%4$% =.,$)6,% $4R ,""60",%& 4#1 $4R &0%,$%+&YII 5" =4#; ,""60",%& 4#1 &0%,$%+& %R)&$S $04$ $0% $4R4?,% )#2"=% "7 $0% +)20 )& +%1.2%1 74+ ?%;"#1 $04$ "7 $0% )#$%#$)"# "7 $0% -+41.4$%1 )#2"=% $4RY N#,)C% )# $0% <.+"6%4# #4$)"#& _4#1 d464#`S $0% >=%+)24# +)20 1" #"$ 64; $0%)+ 74)+ &04+% "7 $4R%& ^ ?4&)#- 74)+#%&& "# $0% $4R 2"1% ?+42C%$& $0%=&%,(%&Y /0% 6"&)$)(% 64+$ "7 $0% >=%+)24# $4R 2"1% )& $04$ )$ 6.&0%& $0% +)20 $" )#(%&$ $0%)+ ="#%; )# ?.&)#%&&S +%4, %&$4$% 4#1 ?"#1&S &)#2% $0%&% 4+% -)(%# &0%,$%+%1 &$4$.&Y /0)& 1"%& %#-%#1%+ )#(%&$=%#$ )# $0% %2"#"=;S 4#1 $0.& )& -""1 7"+ %2"#"=)2 -+"H$0Y /0% @%+=4#& 4#1 d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a )$ =4; ?% 422.+4$% ^ >=%+)24 )&S 47$%+ 4,,S 60%#"=%#4,,; &.22%&&7., %2"#"=)2: 4,,;S %&6%2)4,,; 7"+ $0% =)11,% 4#1 .66%+ =)11,% 2,4&&%&S 4#1 &.22%&&7., )==)-+4#$&S H0" $%#1 $" %&6".&% $0% W>=%+)24# F+%4=X %$0"&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# O@F %-9 1"%-3$#" 0%)4#-13

].$S $" $0% 6")#$' )# $%+=& "7 W$+4#&7%+ 7.#1)#-X 7"+ &"2)4, &%+()2%&S $0% )#2"=% $4R "# $0% +)20 )& )#41%e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e.4$% )# >=%+)24S 6+)(4$% 204+)$)%& 04(% %=%+-%1 $0+".-0 H0)20 $0% +)20 =4; 1"#4$% ,4+-% &.=& "7 ="#%; $" $0% &"2)%$; 4$ ,4+-%Y *+)(4$% 204+)$)%&IL 7)$ $0% >=%+)24# 2.,$.+4, %$0"& (%+; H%,,S 7"+ $0% )#1)()1.4, 4,"#% 1%$%+=)#%& H04$ 0% "+ &0% 1"%& H)$0 $0%)+ 6+)(4$% 64;=%#$ 4#1 H%4,$0Y 34#; =),,)"#4)+%& 4+% e.)$% 204+)$4?,% ^ 4#1 4-4)#S $0% $4R ,4H& %#2".+4-% 204+)$;S &)#2% 204+)$4?,% 2"#$+)?.$)"#& 4+% $4R:1%1.2$)?,%Y /0% 6+"?,%= )& $H"7",1' $0% 6+)(4$% 2"#$+)?.$)"#& "7$%# &.66"+$ )#&$)$.$)"#& H0)20 $0% +)20 7+%e.%#$S &.20 4& 6+)(4$% 0"&6)$4,&S 6+%6 &20"",&S 4#1 %,)$% 2",,%-%&a 4#1 $0% 2"#$+)?.$)"#& 4+% )#41%e.4$% $" &.66"+$ 4 <-,>#"D 3%2 &%$ "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y >& $" $0% 7)+&$ 6+"?,%=S $0% +)20 =4C% &.+% $04$ $0%; &.?&)1)\% e.)$% ,4()&0,; 4,, $0% &%+()2%& $0%; .&%Y d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8IP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

f#%S $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& 64; )#S 7+"= $0%)+ "H# )#2"=%S 7"+ &%+()2%& &.20 4& 20),1 24+%S 6+%:&20"",S 6+)(4$% 2",,%-%&S =%1)24, 24+%S 4#1 6%#&)"# 7.#1& _?%;"#1 &"2)4, &%2.+)$;S H0)20 )& )#41%e.4$% 4#1 ".$14$%1`Y /0% =)11,% 2,4&& 64;& )# 4 H0"66)#- 6%+2%#$4-% "7 $0%)+ )#2"=% $" &.&$4)# 4 ="1%+4$%,; 41%e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b.#2$ 6+"7%&&"+& H0" 4+% .#1%+64)1S )#%R6%+)%#2%1 4#1 "7$%# .#&.6%+()&%1Y /0)& )& #"$ $" &4; $04$ 4,, &%+()2%& 7"+ $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& 4+% )#41%e.4$%Y 3%1)24, 24+%S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S )& %R2%,,%#$ ^ $0".-0 =%1)24, )#&.+4#2% )& )#41%e.4$%Y 5.?.+?4# &20"",& 4#1 &$4$% .#)(%+&)$)%& 4+% -""1S )7 $0%; 4+% #"$ %R2%,,%#$S 4#1 &.?.+?4# #.+&%+; &20"",& 4+% 24+)#-S )7 $0%; 4+% $"" %R6%#&)(%Y 94()#- 1%&2+)?%1 $0% )#41%e.42; "7 $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$& )# $0% N5> 4#1 $0% +%&.,$)#- .#%(%##%&& )# &"2)4, &%+()2%&S ,%$ .& #"H ,""C 4$ &"=% 7.+$0%+ =%$0"1& "7 $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$& $04$ %R)&$S )# (%),%1 7"+=S )# $0% N5>Y +7"07"%1# 1%:#3 !"+6"+4$% $4R%& )# >=%+)24 4+% ,"H%+ $04# )# <.+"6% "+ d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b.&$ 6,4)# 1.=? ,.2CY B%$ =% %R6,4)#Y M# $%+=& "7 2,4&& 6"&)$)"#S $0% .66%+ =)11,% 2,4&& %=6,";%1 )# $0% 2"+6"+4$)"#& $%#1 $" -%$ ?%$$%+ 0%4,$0 4#1 6%#&)"# ?%#%7)$&S 4#1 =.20 ?%$$%+ &$"2C:"H#%+&0)6 6"&&)?),)$)%&Y M# $%+=& "7 6%#&)"# ?%#%7)$&S ,4+-%+ &4,4+)%& 4#1 ?"#.&%& 6+"1.2% ,4+-% )#1)+%2$ 6%+2%#$4-%& "7 2"+6"+4

%$10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8IQ

2"#$+)?.$)"#& $" $0% 6%#&)"# 6,4#& ^ "+ 4,,"H 7"+ ,4+-%+ )#1)()1.4, 2"#: $+)?.$)"#& )#$" 6+)(4$% 6%#&)"# 6,4#& _&.20 4& IT8Z&`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e.4$% ?%#%7)$& 642C4-%S "+ 041 $" 2.$ ?42C "# ?%#%7)$& 1.% $" W1"H#:&)\)#-X "+ =%+-%+S $0+".-0 #" 74.,$ "7 0)& "+ 0%+ "H# 1"%& #"$ -4)# 6+"6%+ ?%#%7)$&Y 5)#2% )# $0)& %+4 "7 W=%+-%+:=4#)4X 4#; 2"+6"+4: $)"# =4; ?% 4?&"+?%1 4#1 1"H#:&)\%1S #" )#1)()1.4, C#"H& H0)20 2"+6"+4$)"# H),, +%$4)# )$& ?%#%7)$& 642C4-% 4#1 H0)20 H),, ?% 7"+2%1 $" +%1.2% )$Y 5" $0% .#%(%# 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 2"+6"+4$% ?%#%7)$& %#-%#1%+& 4# .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 &%+()2%&Y /0)& .#%e.4, 2"#1)$)"# )& =41% H"+&% ?; "#%X& 2,4&& 6"&)$)"# ^ $0% .66%+ =)11,% 2,4&& ?%)#- 4?,% $" &.66,%=%#$ )$& &%+()2% 642C4-%S H0),% $0% =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 ,"H%+ =)11,% 2,4&& +%=4)#& .#4?,% $" 1" &"Y >#1S 4& =%#$)"#%1S $0% )#%e.4,)$; )# $0% 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 &%+()2%& )& 4,&" H"+&%#%1 ?; $0% -""1 "+ ?41 ,.2C "7 $0% 2"+6"+4$)"# "#% )& %=6,";%1 ?;Y U.+$0%+S $0"&% )#1)()1.4,& #"$ %=6,";%1 ?; 4 ,4+-% 2"+6"+4$)"#S ?.$ +4$0%+ ?; 4 &=4,, ?.&)#%&&S =4; 04(% #" ?%#%7)$& 642C4-% 4$ 4,,a =%1)24, 2"&$&S 6%#&)"#&S 20),1 24+%S &20"",)#- ^ 4,, =4; 04(% $" ?% 24++)%1 4& %R6%#1)$.+%& 7+"= 6%+&"#4, &4,4+)%1 )#2"=%Y /0)& ,4$$%+ 24# $4C% 4 ,4+-% 20.#C ".$ "7 ;%4+,; %4+#)#-&S 4#1 +%=4)#& "#% "7 $0% 4?&.+1)$)%& "7 >=%+)24X& 6+)(4$% &%+()2% )#&.+4#2% &;&$%=Y 5"S $0% >=%+)24# 2"+6"+4$)"#& 1" 6+"()1% $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$&S ?.$ $0% &;&$%= )& )#41%e.4$% 4#1 .#74)+S 4#1 ?%2"=)#- ="+% 6+"?,%=4$)24, )# $0)& %+4 "7 =%+-%+& 4#1 1"H#:&)\)#-Y E(# &%0,1%2 .%,-3 1%: /0% 246)$4, -4)#& $4R )& 4#"$0%+ $+4#&7%+ =%204#)&= )# $0% N5>Y >#1S $0".-0 $0% ?.&)#%&& 2"==.#)$; 4#1 $0% 2"#&%+(4$)(% K%6.?,)24#& C%%6 6.&0)#- $" ,"H%+ $0% 246)$4, -4)#& $4RSO8 )$ &$),, 6+"()1%& 4 -""1 1%4, "7 $4R +%(%#.%Y M# 742$S $0% =%+-%+& 4#1 42e.)&)$)"#& $+%#1 04& -%#%+4$%1 4 (%+; ,4+-% 4=".#$ "7 $4R +%(%#.% $" $0% >=%+)24# -"(%+#=%#$ )# +%2%#$ ;%4+&Y ].$ )$ )& &)-#)7)24#$ $04$ ="+% 246)$4, -4)#& $4R +%(%#.% H".,1 04(% ?%%#

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8IJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

-%#%+4$%1 7"+ .&% 4& $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$&S )7 $0% !"#-+%&& 041 #"$ 2.$ $0)& $4RY >#1S )+"#)24,,;S $0% 2"+6"+4$% 2"==.#)$; 1)1 #"$ 6.&0 7"+ 4 ,"H: %+)#- "7 $0% 246)$4, -4)#& $4Ra )$ H4& $0% 2"#&%+(4$)(% &".$0%+#%+& H0" 6.&0%1 $0)& 6+"-+4= ^ $0% (%+; &4=% -+".6 $04$ "66"&%& $0% .&% "7 -"(%+#=%#$ 7.#1& 7"+ $0% %R64#&)"# "7 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y !"#&%+(4$)(%& 4&)1%S 0"H%(%+S $0% #%H %R64#1%1 =)11,% 2,4&& $+%#1 $"H4+1 &$"2C 42e.)&)$)"#&S 4#1 $0% 0.-% )#&$)$.$)"#4, )#(%&$=%#$ 6+": -+4= )# &$"2C&S 04& -%#%+4$%1 4#"$0%+ ,4+-% 6"", "7 6"$%#$)4, $+4#&7%+ H%4,$0S ?%24.&% &$"2C $+4#&42$)"#& 4+% $4R%1Y 5)#2% &.20 $+4#&42$)"#& #"H "22.+ )# =),,)"#& "7 &04+%& 4 14;S 4#1 &)#2% W6+"7)$:$4C)#-X "22.+& "# 4 2%+$4)# 6%+2%#$4-% "7 $0% &$"2C $+4#&42$)"#&S 246)$4, -4)#& $4R H%4,$0 )& )#2+%4&%1Y f7 2".+&%S &)#2% $0)& $4R +%(%#.% )& #"$ $4+-%$%1 $"H4+1 &"2)4, &%+()2%& &6%2)7)24,,;S )$ 24# ?% .&%1 ?; $0% -"(%+#=%#$ 7"+ "$0%+ 6.+6"&%&S &.20 4& =),)$4+; &6%#1)#-S "+ )#2"=%:$4R 2.$&Y M# &.20 24&%&S "7 2".+&%S $0% &%+()2% &%2$"+ H),, ?% #%-,%2$%1 ^ $0".-0 2"#&.=%+ &6%#1)#- =4; )#2+%4&%S 4#1 =),)$4+;:+%,4$%1 )#1.&$+; 4#1 b"?& =4; %R64#1Y U)#4,,;S 246)$4, -4)#& $4R%& "# +%4,:%&$4$% $+4#&42$)"#& 04(% 4,&" 6+": 1.2%1 ,4+-% $4R +%(%#.%&Y K%4,:%&$4$% (4,.%& 04(% ?%%# %&24,4$)#- ?%;"#1 $0% +4$% "7 -%#%+4, )#7,4$)"#S 4#1 &" $0% ?.;)#- 4#1 &%,,)#- "7 +%4, %&$4$% 04& ?%%# e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e.4$% 6",)2)#- ^ $".-0 0"&$),%S ?.$ ;%$ )#41%e.4$% ^ 6",)2)#-Y G"HS $0)& &;&$%= 1"%& &%$ .6 4 ="$)(4$)"#4, 4#1 =%+)$"2+4$)2 &$4#14+1 $04$ 1"%& %#2".+4-% 4#1 +%H4+1 $0% &$+)()#- 7"+ .6H4+1 ="?),)$;Y /0)& )& $0% >=%+)24# F+%4= %$0"& ^ 4#1 )$ 04& =41% >=%+)24 -+%4$Y 9"H%(%+S 4 &%+()2% &;&$%= "7 W-""1S ?%$$%+S 4#1 ?%&$XS 2".,1 420)%(% $0% &4=%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8IL

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i"+ W+%$+%4$)&=XOI )#$" 4,2"0",)&= 4#1 1+.- 4?.&%Y >#1 7.+$0%+S $0% ="1%+4$%,; &.22%&&7., &%$ "7 &%+()2%& )# $0% =)11,%: 2,4&& 4+%4& )#0)?)$& =)11,%:2,4&& &.22%&& 4& H%,,Y 34#; =)11,%:2,4&& 20),1+%# 1" #"$ 1" H%,, )# $0%)+ =)11,%:2,4&& &20"",&S ?%24.&% $0%&% &20"",& 04(% 041 $" 2.$ ?42C 1+4&$)24,,; _&)#2% $0% 8LJT&` "# W-)7$%1X 6+"-+4=& _H0%+%)# 4241%=)2 %R2%,,%#2% H4& )#&$),,%1 4#1 +%H4+1%1`S "# 4+$ 4#1 =.&)2 6+"-+4=& 4#1 ^ H"+&$ "7 4,, )# $0)& )#2+%4&)#-,; 0)-0:$%20 H"+,1 ^ &6%2)4, &2)%#2%S =4$0 4#1 2"=6.$%+ $%20#","-; 6+"-+4=& 04(% %)$0%+ ?%%# 2.$ ?42CS "+ &" 6""+,; 41=)#)&$%+%1 $04$ >=%+)24X& =)11,%:2,4&& 0)-0:&20"", &$.1%#$& +4$% 4$ $0% ?"$$"= "7 $0% ,)&$ )# $0)& 24$%-"+; "7 4241%=)2&S 2"=64+%1 $" $0% "$0%+ )#1.&$+)4, 2".#$+)%&Y M# 742$S $0% &2)%#2% 4#1 =4$0 6+"-+4=& 04(% ?%%# &" )#41%e.4$%,; 6+"()1%1S $04$ H% 04(% 1%6%#1%1 .6"# ".+ #%H )==)-+4#$&X 20),1+%# ^ "7 !0)#%&%S Z"+%4#S M#1)4#S @+%%C 4#1 K.&&)4# "+)-)# ^ $" 7),, $0% -46Y /0.&S +%,;)#- "# 6+"6%+$; $4R%& 7"+ &"2)4, &%+()2%& %#-%#1%+& 6+"7".#1 )#%e.4,)$)%& )# $0%&% &%+()2%&S 4#1 74),& ?"$0 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& 4#1 $0% 6""+Y >#1 H0),% 1%&)+% 7"+ .6H4+1 ="?),)$; $" $0% ?%$$%+ 2"==.#)$)%& )& )#&$),,%1S $0% +"41 $" $04$ .6H4+1 ="?),)$; =4; ?% 64+$)4,,; ?,"2C%1 ?; $0% 2"=6,%$% )#41%e.42; "7 &%+()2%& )# 6"(%+$; #%)-0?"+0""1& 4#1 $0% +%2%#$ 1%2,)#% )# &%+()2%& )# $0% =)11,%:2,4&& 2"==.#)$)%&Y >&C $0% 4(%+4-% >=%+)24# 0)-0:&20"", &$.1%#$ H0%$0%+ $0%)+ &20"", 4#1 2"=: =.#)$; 04(% 41%e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8OT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E(# L,3,-. +731 7$ @#">, 8O8

54,%& $4R%& )# $0% N5> 24# ?% 4# )=6"+$4#$ &".+2% "7 $+4#&7%+ 7.#1)#-Y 5)#2% >=%+)24 )& $0% 2"#&.=%+:"+)%#$%1 &"2)%$;S $0% (",.=% "7 &4,%& )# $0% N5> )& %#"+=".&Y /0.&S $0% &4,%& $4RS 4& 4 6%+2%#$4-% "7 $0% &4,% 6+)2% "7 4 2"=="1)$;S 24# ?% 4 0.-% &".+2% "7 +%(%#.% 4#1 4 ,.R.+; $4R "# $0% +)20 4& H%,,Y 54,%& $4R%& 4+% .&%1 $" +4)&% +%(%#.% 7"+ &$4$% 4#1 ,"24, 2"==.#)$)%&S 4#1 &.20 7.#1& 4+% .&%1 7"+ 2)()2 4#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y >#1S )# &" 74+ 4& H%4,$0; >=%+)24#& ?.; ?)-S %R6%#&)(% 24+&S ;420$&S b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c>/ 411& 4 ?)- b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e.4$%S 2)$)\%#& ?%2"=% 2;#)24, 4?".$ $0% .&% 4#1 7.#2$)"# "7 $4R4$)"# ^ W>+% $0% 6",)$)2)4#& &$%4,)#- )$ ^ ;". C#"H 0"H $0%; 4+% ^ 4+% $0%; H4&$)#- )$ "# $0% 6""+ ^ $0% 6""+ 4+% ,4\; 4#;H4; 4#1 1"#X$ 1%&%+(% ".+ H%,74+% 1",,4+&YX /0)& C)#1 "7 2;#)2)&=S ?+".-0$ 4?".$ ?%24.&% "7 $0% ,42C "7 4 1)+%2$ "?&%+(4?,% ,)#C ?%$H%%# $4R4$)"# 4#1 2)()2 4#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%&S )& #"$ -""1 7"+ 1%="2+42;Y U"+ 2;#)2)&= 4?".$ 6",)$)2)4#& 6+"1.2%& 4 H)$0: 1+4H4, "7 2)$)\%#X& )#$%+%&$S 4#1 7%%,)#-& "7 4,)%#4$)"# 7+"= $0% 6",)$)24, 6+"2%&&Y /0% +%2%#$ &%R &24#14,& 4="#- 6",)$)2)4#&S 4#1 $0% =4&& =%1: )4X& 7+%#\)%1 2"(%+4-% "7 $0%=S 04& H"+&%#%1 $0)& 2;#)24,S 4,)%#4$%1 4$$)$.1%Y ].$ $0)& )& 7"+ 4#"$0%+ $+%4$)&%Y U"+ #"HS +%=%=?%+ $04$ $0% ("$)#- +4$% )& 1%2,)#)#-S 4#1 $04$ ;".#- >=%+)24#& b.&$ 1"#X$ ("$%Y >#1 $04$ #" "?&%+(4?,% ,)#C %R)&$& ?%$H%%# $4R +%(%#.%& 4#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

@%2#3 1%:#3

8OA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0%+% 4+% =4#; =%204#)&=& 7"+ +4)&)#- +%(%#.% $" 7.#1 &"2)4, &%+()2%&Y E0%# $0%&% =%204#)&=& 4+% 7.,,; .$),)\%1S &"2)4, &%+()2%& 24# ?% 6+": ()1%1 4& 7+%% &%+()2%& ^ 4&&.=)#- $04$ $0% 0)-0:$%20 %2"#"=; )# e.%&: $)"# )& &$+"#- 4#1 %R64#&)(%Y /0)& ,4&$ )& e.)$% 4# 4&&.=6$)"#S "7 2".+&%S ?.$ 1"%& #"H &%%= e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` ^ -"(%+#=%#$ &.?&)1)%& 7"+ &.20 6+"-+4=&S )#2,.1)#- &20"", (".: 20%+&S 4+% 4?&",.$%,; #%2%&&4+; )# $0% N5>Y _!4# 4 =)11,%:2,4&& 74=),; 64; 4 kDT TTT 2",,%-% $.)$)"# 642C4-%S "+ 64; 7"+ "6%#:0%4+$ &.+-%+;V` /0%+%7"+%S -"(%+#=%#$ &.?&)1)%& 7"+ %,1%+ 24+%S 20),1 24+%S %1.24$)"# 4#1 0%4,$0 24+% 4+% %R64#1)#- )# $0% N5> 4$ 4?".$ $0% &4=% +4$% 4& 6+)(4$% 2":64;=%#$& 4+% %R64#1)#- )# M$4,;S M&+4%, 4#1 5)#-46"+%Y /0%+% H),, ?% -7 $<22 &7->#".#-&#Y U.#1)#- &20%=%& H),, 2"#$)#.% $" 1)77%+Y ].$ $0% $;6% "7 &"2)4, &%+()2% 6+"-+4=&S 4#1 $0% %R64#&)"# "7 &.20 &%+()2% 6+"-+4=&S H),, 2"#$)#.% 4& 4 H"+,1 $+%#1 )# $0% 0)-0:$%20 -,"?4, (),,4-%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>&3)/(2+&32A $/(2 . 8&%' &3 )&5$.7-#3* $.75+32

E0; /+4#&7%+ *4;=%#$& 4+% G%2%&&4+; )# 9)-0:/%20 M#1.&$+)4, !46)$4,)&$ 5"2)%$)%&

>.$+*./+2* 8#./*" +3#V(./+*7 .2 #3'#-+) *& *"# 272*#/0% 7+%%:=4+C%$ %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= )& 1;#4=)2S %R64#&)(%S 2+%4$)(% 4#1 -,"?4, )# )$& +%420Y M$ )& +%=4+C4?,% )# )$& 6+"1.2$)(% 24642)$;S 4#1 ,)#C%1 $" ,4HS )#1)()1.4, 7+%%1"= 4#1 1%="2+42;Y E0" )# $0% 2"#$%=6"+4+; H"+,1 H".,1 20""&% 4#"$0%+ %2"#"=)2 &;&$%=V ].$ $0% "#% 6+"?,%= $04$ 24##"$ ?% &",(%1 7+"= H)$0)# =4+C%$ 1;#4=)2& )& $0% 6+"?,%= "7 $0% .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0Y 5=)$08 4#1 ]%#$04=SA %#()&)"#)#- 4 =4+C%$ &;&$%= =41% .6 "7 7+%% 4#1 )#1%6%#1%#$ ?.&)#%&& 2"=6%$)$"+&S 6+"b%2$%1 4 #%4+:7.$.+% )# H0)20 $0)& 2"=6%$)$)(% =4+C%$ &;&$%= H".,1 2+%4$% 4 +%,4$)(%,; 74)+ 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0Y U",,"H)#- B"2C%SD $0%; ?%,)%(%1 $04$ $0"&% )#1)()1.4,& H0" 6.$ ="+% %77"+$ )#$" $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$ "7 $0%)+ 6+"6%+$; &0".,1 -%$ ="+% $04# $0"&% )#1)()1.4,& H0" #%-,%2$%1 $0%)+&Y ].$ B"2C% H4& 2"#$+4&$)#- $0"&% 7%.14, ,"+1& 4#1 6%4&4#$& H0" 1)1 ,)$$,% ?.$ -%#%+4$% &.?&)&$%#2%S H)$0 $0"&% #%H ,4#1%1 =%+204#$& _$0% -%#$+;` H0" H%+% 2+%4$)#- ="#%; H%4,$0 $0+".-0 $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$ "7 &0%%6 74+=)#-S H"",%# -""1&S 24&0 2+"6&S 4#1 "$0%+ 2+47$ -""1& H0)20 -%#%+4$%1 -+%4$%+ H%4,$0 4#1 &$)=.,4$%1 246)$4, 1%(%,"6=%#$YI B"2C%S 0"H%(%+S H4& +%7%++)#- $" ,4#1%1 6+"6%+$;S H0),% 5=)$0 4#1 ]%#$04= H%+% %=604&)\)#- ?.&)#%&&%& 4#1 742$"+)%&Y 5=)$0X& 1%&2+)6$)"# "7 $0% +4$)"#4,)$; "7 4&&%=?,;:,)#% 6+"1.2$)"# )# 0)& 74=".& 1%&2+)6$)"# "7 $0% 6)# 742$"+;O &0"H& .& e.)$% 2,%4+,; $04$ 0% H4& $0%"+)\)#- 4?".$ 4 2"=6%$)$)(% =4+C%$ %2"#"=; $04$ H4& "+)%#$%1 $"H4+1& #%H 6+"1.2$)(% 6+"2%&&%&S 4& H%,, 4& +4$)"#4, %2"#"=)2 42$)"# 1)+%2$%1 $"H4+1& $0% =4R)=)\4$)"# "7 ?.&)#%&& 6+"7)$&Y ].&)#%&& 6+"7)$&S +4$)"#4,)\%1 6+"1.2$)"# 6+"2%&&%&S #%H $%20#","-; 466,)%1 $" $0% 6+"1.2$)"# 6+"2%&& ^ $0)& )& )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&=S 4#1 $0)& 8OD

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L

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` %#&.+% 4 +%=4+C4?,% 6+"1.2$)(% 4?.#14#2% 7"+ $0% &"2)%$; 4$ ,4+-% $0+".-0 )##": (4$)(% %#$+%6+%#%.+&0)6a _A` =4)#$4)# 4 1;#4=)2 .&% "7 =420)#%+;S ,4?"+S 4#1 $+41%a 4#1 _D` 6+"()1% ^ $0+".-0 =4+C%$ 2"=6%$)$)"# ^ 7"+ 4 +%,4$)(%,; %e.)$4?,% 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 -""1& 4#1 H%4,$0Y /0% 7)+&$ $H" 742$"+& H%+% 7.,7),,%1 H)$0 H"+,1:4&$".#1)#- &.22%&&S %#2".+4-)#- $0% 41"6$)"# "7 $0% #%H %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= ?; %(%+; #4$)"# H)$#%&&)#- )$& =)+42.,".& 420)%(%=%#$Y ].$S =4+C%$ 2"=6%$)$)"#S "7 )$&%,7S ,%1 $" 4# )#%e.)$4?,% 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 -""1& 4#1 H%4,$0Y ]%#$04= H4& 2"#()#2%1 $04$ $0% 2"=6%$)$)(% =4+C%$ H".,1 H"+C ".$ 74)+,; )# $0% ,"#- +.#S )7 -)(%# 7+%% +%)-#YL 9"H%(%+S $0% +%,4$)(% %e.)$; 1)1 #"$ %=%+-% )# $0% &0"+$ +.#S 4#1 dY5Y 3),,8T H4& 4,+%41; &6%2.,4$)#- 4?".$ $0% ="1)7)24$)"# "7 $0% &;&$%=Y 5)#2% 5=)$0 4#1 ]%#$04= 04(% ?%%# ()#1)24$%1 )# $0% ,"#- +.# ^ 4#1 )$ H4& 4 (%+; ,"#- +.# "7 ATT ;%4+& "+ ="+% ^ H04$ )& $0% 6+"?,%=V U)+&$S $0%+% H4& $0% &0"+$ +.# ^ 4 -+"$%&e.%S F)2C%#&)4#88 H"+,1 "7 34+R)4#8A $+4-%1; 7"+ $0% =4b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f,)(%+ /H)&$ 2"#$)#.% $"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8OI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

"(%+H0%,= ="1%+# +%41%+& H)$0 7%%,)#-& "7 !0+)&$)4# 204+)$; "(%++)1)#^ 7"+ "#% %="$)"#4, ="=%#$ ^ ".+ ="$)(4$)"# "7 &%,7:)#$%+%&$%1 -+%%1Y ].$ )$ )& $0% ="1%+# H"+,1 H0)20 2"#2%+#& .& 0%+%Y M# 742$S )$ )& $0% ="&$ ="1%+# 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$ &;&$%= H0)20 H% 4+% 2"#2%+#%1 H)$0 #"HY f7 2".+&%S 0)-0:$%20 -,"?4, 246)$4,)&= )& #"$ $0% 246)$4,)&= "7 $0% +)20 4#1 6""+ $04$ F)2C%#& 4#1 9.-" &4HY G"+ )& )$ $0% 246)$4,)&= "7 +)20 742$"+;:"H#%+& 4#1 6""+ H"+C%+& $04$ 34+R 4#1 <#-%,& &4HY _<#-%,&S "7 2".+&%S )#0%+)$%1 &.20 4 742$"+; )# $0% 0%4+$ "7 <#-,4#1X& )#1.&$+)4, ?%,$Y` f.+ "H# 2"#$%=6"+4+; 0)-0:$%20 =4+C%$ &;&$%= 04& -%#%+4$%1 4 =4b"+)$; =)11,% 2,4&&S8O 4#1 &64H#%1 4 (4&$ 4#1 -+"H)#- H0)$%:2",,4+ H"+,1 "7 -%#1%+:%e.4, H"+C 4#1 =%+)$"2+4$)2S $%20#"2+4$)2 +%2+.)$=%#$Y M# $%+=& "7 %2"#"=)2 -+"H$0S =)11,%:2,4&& %-4,)$4+)4#)&=S %$0#)2S +42)4, 4#1 -%#1%+ %e.4,)$;S $0% &;&$%= 04& ?%2"=% +%=4+C4?,; &.22%&&7.,Y ].$ $0%+% +%=4)#& $0% "#% 0",1"(%+ 7+"= $0% 34+R)4# 2+)$)e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`Y E0; 1"%& $0)& W&;&$%=&X $%#1%#2; 6%+&)&$ )# 7+%%:=4+C%$ 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%&V /0% ,"#- +.# )& ,"#- %#".-0S )&#X$ )$V

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e.%&$)"# &;&$%=: 4$)24,,;S 4#1 &)#2% 0% ,)(%1 $" &%% $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$ "7 $0% -)4#$ )#1.&$+)4, 2"+6"+4$)"#& ^ H0)20 5=)$0 #%(%+ ,)(%1 $" &%% ^ 0)& 4#4,;&)& H4& 2,"&%+ $" $0% ="1%+# =4+C%$ 2"#1)$)"# $04# 5=)$0X&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8OO

34+R $0%"+)\%1 $04$ $0%+% H4& 4# )#0%+%#$ $%#1%#2; $"H4+1& =%+-%+ 4#1 -+"H$0 4#1 $0% 2+%4$)"# "7 -)4#$ )#1.&$+)4, 7)+=&S ?%24.&% _8` 0.-% 4=".#$& "7 246)$4, 041 $" ?% +4)&%1 )# "+1%+ $" 1%(%,"6 4#1 466,; $0% $%20#","-; #%2%&&4+; $" )=6+"(% 6+"1.2$)(% %77)2)%#2; 4#1 &.22%%1 )# $0% =4+C%$a 4#1 _A` $0% 1%(%,"6=%#$ 4#1 466,)24$)"# "7 $%20#","-; $" $0% )#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$)(% &;&$%= +%e.)+%1 &.20 4 ,4+-% )#(%&$=%#$ "7 246)$4, $04$ 4 ,"#-:$%+=S &$4?,% =4+C%$ 6+"b%2$)"# H4& #%2%&&4+; 7"+ &.22%&&7., 6+"7)$:$4C)#-Y /0% 7)+&$ 6+"2%&& ^ $0% #%%1 7"+ (%+; ,4+-% 4=".#$& "7 246)$4, %R6%#1: )$.+%& "# $0% 2"#&$4#$ )#(%#$)"#S 466,)24$)"#S 4#1 .6-+41)#- "7 $%20: #","-; ^ %#-%#1%+& $0% #%%1 7"+ =%+-%+& 4#1 -)-4#$)&= )# $0% ="1%+# )#1.&$+)4, 7)+=Y 3%+-%+& 4#1 0.-% &)\% -)(% $0% ?4#C& 4#1 $0% H%4,$0; )#(%&$"+& 2"#7)1%#2%S &" $04$ ,4+-%:&24,% ,"4#& 4#1 )#(%&$=%#$& H),, ?% ="+% "+ ,%&& -.4+4#$%%1Y f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e.%&S H0)20 24##"$ ?% 1"#% 04604\4+1,;Y B"#-: $%+= )#(%&$=%#$& )# 6+"1.2$)"# =.&$ -.4+4#$%% ,"#-:$%+= 6+"7)$&S "+ H0; $4C% $0% +)&CV /0% +)&C )& "$0%+H)&% $"" -+%4$ ^ $"" =.20 246)$4, )& )#(",(%1 $" 4,,"H $0% (4-4+)%& "7 $0% =4+C%$ $" 1)2$4$% $0% 7)#4, +%&.,$Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% -)4#$ 2"+6"+4$)"# $4C%& $0% =4+C%$ )# 04#1 ^ $+)%& $" 2"#$+", $0% =4+C%$ ?; 6,4##)#- 6+)2%&S H4-%& 4#1 &4,4+)%& $" =4$20 $0% ,"#-:$%+= )#(%&$=%#$ 64$$%+#Y >& c%?,%#A8 %=604&)\%1S $0%; 6,4# 1%=4#1 $0+".-0 =4&&)(% 41(%+$)&)#-Y ]; 6,4##)#- $0%&% 2"&$&S 6+"7)$& 24# ?% -.4+4#$%%1Y >#1S )# $.+#S $0% -.4+4#$%%1 6+"7)$& ?%2"=% 4# )#2%#$)(% $"H4+1& 7.+$0%+ ,"#-:$%+= $%20#","-)24, )#(%&$=%#$&Y >22"+1: )#- $" @4,?+4)$0S W$0% 6,4##)#- &;&$%=XAA =4C%& .6 4 0)-0 6%+2%#$4-% "7 =4+C%$ $+4#&42$)"#&Y f7 2".+&%S &=4,, ?.&)#%&& )& &$),, )#(",(%1 )# $0% 2"=6%$)$)(% =4+C%$S 4#1 7"+%)-# 2"=6%$)$)"# 7"+2%& =4+C%$ 2"=6%$)$)"# %(%# "# $0% -)4#$ 7)+=& H0)20 4+% %#-4-%1 )# $0% 4$$%=6$%1 ="#"6",)&$)2 6,4##)#- "7 $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8OP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

=4+C%$Y >#1S $""S 4#$):$+.&$ ,4H& 6+%(%#$ ="#"6",; )# =4#; #4$)"#&S &" $04$ 72,.7072) )& $0% 42$.4, 7"+= "7 %2"#"=)2 .#)$&Y ].$S 422"+1)#- $" @4,?+4)$0S $0% ",)-"6",)%& 24+%7.,,; 7",,"H %420 "$0%+ )# $0% 6+)2% 6,4#: #)#- 4#1 H4-% 6,4##)#- 6+"2%&& ^ #"$ )# 2",,.&)"#S 7"+ $0)& H".,1 ?% ),,%-4, ^ ?.$ )# ?4+%,; (%),%1 2""6%+4$)"#Y U"+1S @%#%+4, 3"$"+&S 4#1 !0+;&,%+S 4& H%,, 4& /";"$4 4#1 9"#14S "+ F4)=,%+:]%#\ >.1)S 4#1 c",C&H4-%#S H),, 7",,"H %420 "$0%+ )# 6+)2% 4#1 H4-% 24,2.,4$)"#&S &" $04$ $0%+% )& ,)$$,% +%4, 2"=6%$)$)"# )# $0%&% 24,2.,4$)"#&Y /0% ="#"6",; 4#1 =4+C%$:6,4##)#- $+%#1& 4+% 2"#$)#.)#- 4& 4 -,"?4, 60%#"=%#"#Y /0% +%2%#$ =%+-%+& "7 U"+1 4#1 d4-.4+S U"+1 4#1 c",("S F4)=,%+:]%#\ 4#1 !0+;&,%+S @3:/";"$4 b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c%?,%#)4#AD )# )$& $0%"+%$)24, 7".#14$)"#Y 9%+% @4,?+4)$0S 7",,"H)#- c%?,%#S )& $0%"+)\)#- $04$ )#1.&$+)4, 6+"1.2$)"# ^ )# )$& $%20: #","-)24, 2"=6"#%#$ ^ #%2%&&)$4$%& ,"#-:$%+= 6,4##)#-S %(%# $0".-0 =4+C%$ 2"=6%$)$)"# )& 4,&" #%2%&&4+;S )# "+1%+ $" =4)#$4)# %77)2)%#2; )# 6+"1.2$)"#Y /0)& ,4$$%+ &%$ "7 %2"#"=)2 2"=6,%R)$)%& 04& ?%%# 1%&2+)?%1 )# c%?,%#X& E(# Z-.,-##"3 %-9 1(# !",&# @)31#4SAI 4#1S 4& =%#$)"#%1S )# @4,?+4)$0X& 6#; 8-9<31",%2 @1%1#YAO M# $0)& $+%4$)&%S 0"H%(%+S H% H)&0 $" 2"#2%#$+4$% "# $0% 6+"?,%= "7 $0% 2"#2%#$+4$)"# "7 H%4,$0 H0)20 %=%+-%& 7+"= $0% 6+%&&.+% $" 2+%4$% -)4#$S ",)-"6",)&$)2S 0)-0,; $%20#": ,"-)\%1S -,"?4,)\%1 2"+6"+4$% %#$%+6+)&%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8OQ

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e.)$% &6%2$42.,4+ ^ 4#1S 6%+046&S H"++)&"=%Y ]))#(%&$"+& )# $0% N5>S &.20 4& @%"+-% 5"+"&S /%1 /.+#%+ 4#1 ]),, @4$%&S ,)C% $0% K"2C%7%,,%+& 4#1 !4+#%-)%& ?%7"+% $0%=S 04(% %R64#1%1 $0%)+ 7"+$.#%& &" =.20 $04$ $0%; 4+% 42$.4,,; %=?4++4&&%1 _4& H4& !4+#%-)%` ?; $0% -+"H$0 "7 $0%)+ H%4,$0Y 5.20 ?),,)"#4)+%& 4+% %=%+-)#- -,"?4,,;S H)$0 $0% -,"?4,)\4$)"# "7 $0% 7)#4#2)4, =4+C%$&Y G"HS H0%$0%+ $0% ?),,)"#4)+% )& 204+)$4?,% "+ #"$S )& #"$ 4$ )&&.% 0%+% ^ $0".-0S "7 2".+&%S $0)& )& 2+)$)24, 7"+ $0% &"2)%$; )#(",(%1Y E04$ )& 4$ )&&.% 0%+% )& $0% %2"#"=)2 742$ $04$ 6+)(4$% 7"+$.#%& ?%2"=% -+%4$%+

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8OJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

$0+".-0 1)(%+&)7)%1 6"+$7",)" )#(%&$=%#$&S 4#1 $04$ $0)& 7.+$0%+ 2"#2%#: $+4$%& H%4,$0 )# $0% 04#1& "7 $0% (%+; +)20 7%H )# 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%&Y /0)& )& 4 +%4, 6+"?,%=S )7 7.#1)#- 7"+ .#)(%+&4, &"2)4, &%+()2%& )& $0% -"4, "7 4 #4$)"#Y /0.&S F"#4,1 /+.=6 =4; 6+%7%+ $" %4$ H)$0 -",1%# .$%#&),& )7 0% &" 6,%4&%&S +4$0%+ $04# -)()#- $" 4 0"&6)$4, 7.#1Y >#1 4 !0)#%&% =),,)"#4)+% =4; 6+%7%+ $" &6+)#C,% -",1 1.&$ "# 0)& 7""1S +4$0%+ $04# 2"#$+)?.$)#- $" $0% %,1%+ 24+% 6+"-+4=Y f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e.%&$)"# ?%2"=%&' 0"H 1"%& 4 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$;S 64+$)2)64$)#- )# 4 -,"?4, 7)#4#2)4, =4+C%$ &;&$%=S %R$+42$ +%(%#.% 7+"= $04$ &;&$%= 7"+ $0% 2)()2 -""1V 50".,1 ="1%+# 2)$)\%#& ?%- ?),,)"#4)+%& 7"+ $0%)+ 64+C&S $0%)+ &20"",&S $0%)+ 0"&6)$4,&S $0%)+ #.+&%+)%&Y Y Y YV B%$ .& ,""C 7.+$0%+ 4$ $0)& W&;&$%=& 6+"?,%=X "7 246)$4,)&= 4#1 )$& &",.$)"#&Y

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e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 -""1&S 04& #"$S 0"H%(%+S 6+"1.2%1 4# %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= "+ 4# %2"#"=)2 $0%"+; &.6%+)"+ )# )$& 6+"1.2$)(% "+ 1)&$+)?.$)(% 24642)$;Y /0.&S )# $%+=& "7 2,4&&)24, %2"#"=)2& 4#1 )$& 34+R)4# 2+)$)e.%S H% 04(% $H" &"2)4, 742$"+& $04$ H% #"H 24##"$ 4(")1 1%4,)#- H)$0Y U)+&$S

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8OL

$0% &"2)4,)&$ )#1.&$+)4, ="1%,S 4& )$ 04& %=%+-%1 )# 6+42$)2%S 04& 74),%1 ?"$0 %2"#"=)24,,; 4#1 6",)$)24,,;Y M$ 6+"()1%& 7"+ #" 1%="2+42; )# $0% 0%+% 4#1 #"HS 4#1 %(%# )$& ?,.%6+)#$ 7"+ $0% .$"6)4# 7.$.+% 2"#$4)#& #" +%4, 1%="2+4$)2 $0%"+;Y >#1 $0% %e.4,)$; )$ 420)%(%& )& ,"&$ )# $0% =4\% "7 ?.+%4.2+4$)2 0)%+4+20)%&SAQ 1%&6"$)2 6",)$)24, 6"H%+ 422.: =.,4$)"#&S 6%+%##)4, &0"+$4-%& "7 -""1&S ?,42C =4+C%$ 4#1 2+)=)#4, =420)#4$)"#&Y 5%2"#1S $0% 246)$4,)&$ )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=)2 ="1%,S H0),% &.22%&&7.,,; .#1%+-)+1)#- 4 6",)$)24, &;&$%= ?4&%1 "# ,4H 4#1 1%="2+42;SAJ +%=4)#& 6,4-.%1 H)$0 4# .#422%6$4?,; .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0S 4 2"#: $)#.)#- 0)-0 +4$% "7 .#%=6,";=%#$S 4#1 )#&$4?),)$; )# )$& W?.&)#%&& 2;2,%XY M# &0"+$S )#%e.4,)$; 4#1 )#&$4?),)$; &$),, 6,4-.% 4 246)$4,)&$ )#1.&: $+)4, &;&$%=S &.22%&&7., )# )$& 6+"1.2$)(% 24642)$;S )##"(4$)(% )# )$& $%20: #","-)\%1 1%(%,"6=%#$S 4#1 &.66"+$)(%,; %#=%&0%1 H)$0 4 &;&$%= "7 -"(%+#=%#$ ?4&%1 "# ,4HS )#1)()1.4, 7+%%1"=S 4#1 1%="2+42;Y >,, "7 $0)& )& H+)$$%# $" %&$4?,)&0 $04$ 2,4&&)24, %2"#"=)2 $0%"+; 24##"$ ?% .$),)\%1 )# .#="1)7)%1 7"+= $" -+".#1 4 $0%"+; "7 1%="2+4$)2 &$4?),)$; "+ %2"#"=)2 %e.)$;Y 5)#2% &"2)4,)&$ $0%"+; 04& %(%#$.4$%1 )# #%)$0%+S 4 ="1)7)%1 7"+= "7 2,4&&)24, $0%"+;S H0)20 =)#)=)\%& )$& $%#1%#2)%& $"H4+1 )#&$4?),)$; 4#1 )#%e.4,)$;S H0),% +%$4)#)#- )$& 7".#14: $)"#4, &.66"+$ 7"+ ,%-4, 1%="2+42;S &0".,1 ?% ,""C%1 $"Y <#$%+ Z%;#%&Y

!"# P#73#2+.3 -&'+1+).*+&3 &1 )/.22+)./ #)&3&-+) *"#&%7 F.+)#- $0% @+%4$ F%6+%&&)"#S $0% -%#%+4, 6"6.,4$)"# )# )#1.&$+)4, #4$)"#& ?%-4# $" ,"&% 74)$0 )# 246)$4,)&=Y 5"2)4,)&= ?%24=% e.)$% 6"6.,4+S H0),% +%(",.$)"#4+; 2"==.#)&= H)1%#%1 )$& 466%4, 1+4=4$)24,,;Y Z%;#%&S 0"H%(%+S ?%,)%(%1 $04$ 246)$4,)&= H4& &.6%+)"+ $" &"2)4,)&=S ?.$ +%e.)+%1 -"(%+#=%#$ )#$%+(%#$)"# $" 6+%(%#$ $0% W?""= 4#1 ?.&$X ?.&): #%&& 2;2,%S 4#1 -"(%+#=%#$ )#(%&$=%#$ $" &$)=.,4$% 4#1 %R64#1 $0% %2"#"=;Y ]%7"+% +%b%2$)#- Z%;#%&X )1%4&S ,""C 24+%7.,,; 4$ $0% %2"#"=)2 0)&$"+; "7 $0% N5> 1.+)#- $0% 8LJT& 4#1 8LLT&Y /0+%% $)=%& $0% >=%+)24# -"(%+#=%#$ ^ ,%1 ?; $0% U%1%+4, K%&%+(% ]"4+1 )# 2""6%+4$)"# H)$0 E4,, 5$+%%$ 7)#4#2)%+& 4#1 E4&0)#-$"# 24?)#%$ =)#)&$%+& ^ )#$%+: (%#%1 $" &0"+% .6 $0% =4+C%$ 4#1 &4(% $0% %2"#"=; 7+"= 4#"$0%+ 1%6+%&&)"#Y >& H% H+)$%S $0% d464#%&% -"(%+#=%#$S $0% Z"+%4# -"(%+#=%#$S 4#1 $0% /04) -"(%+#=%#$ 4+% 1%&6%+4$%,; 4$$%=6$)#- $" +%()(% 4#1 +%)#()-": +4$% $0%)+ %2"#"=)%&Y /0% 9"#- Z"#- -"(%+#=%#$ 04& 4,+%41;

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8PT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

&.22%%1%1 )# +%:&$4?),)\)#- $0%)+ %2"#"=; H)$0 $0% 1%&6%+4$% =%4&.+% "7 ?.;)#- .6 =4#; &$"2C& $%=6"+4+),;Y /0% d464#%&% 4+% =4C)#- &,"H 6+"-+%&& ^ 7",,"H)#- Z%;#%&)4# )1%4& ^ ?; 7)#4#2)#- 6.?,)2 H"+C&S )#(%&$: )#- )# $4+-%$%1 )#1.&$+)%&S 4#1 &0"+)#- .6 $0%)+ &4--)#- &$"2C =4+C%$Y /0% @%+=4# -"(%+#=%#$ 04& &$%66%1 )#$" )$& %2"#"=; _56+)#- 8LLL` $" 42$)(%,; &$)=.,4$% %2"#"=)2 -+"H$0 $0+".-0 4 &04+6 ,"H%+)#- "7 $0% )#$%+%&$ +4$%& 4#1 $0% %#2".+4-%=%#$ "7 ?4#C ,"4#& 7"+ )#1.&$+)4, %R64#: &)"# ^ ?"$0 =4)#&$4;& "7 $0% Z%;#%&)4# 6+"-+4=YAL 5"S Z%;#%&X )1%4& 4?".$ -"(%+#=%#$ )#$%+(%#$)"# $" 6+%(%#$ ?""= 4#1 ?.&$S 4#1 0)& )1%4& 4?".$ -"(%+#=%#$ )#$%+(%#$)"# $" &$)=.,4$% $0% %2"#"=;S 4+% 422%6$%1 4$ $0% ,%(%, "7 42$.4, 246)$4,)&$ 0"7! )# 2"#: $%=6"+4+; &"2)%$; ^ $0".-0 4& $0%"+;S $0%; 4+% #"$ 422%6$%1 ?; 2,4&&)24, 4#1 #%":2,4&&)24, %2"#"=)&$& 4$ $0% .#)(%+&)$)%&S 4#1 $0%; 4+% %&6%2)4,,; +%b%2$%1 4$ >=%+)24# .#)(%+&)$)%&Y 5"S H0;S )# $0)& &%2$)"#S H0%+% H% 4+% ,""C)#- $" -+".#1 $0% 2"#2%6$ "7 $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$& $0%"+%$)24,,;S 4+% H% ,""C)#- $" $0% H"+C "7 Z%;#%&V 9%+% )& $0% +%4&"# )# Z%;#%&X "H# H"+1&' W/0% ".$&$4#1)#- 74.,$& "7 $0% %2"#"=)2 &"2)%$; )# H0)20 H% ,)(% 4+% )$& 74),.+%& $" 6+"()1% 7"+ 7.,, %=6,";=%#$ 4#1 )$& 4+?)$+4+; 4#1 )#%e.)$4?,% 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0 4#1 )#2"=%&YXDT M# $%+=& "7 H%4,$0 1)&64+)$)%&S Z%;#%& H4& #"$ 4 WB%(%,,%+XD8 "+ 4 &"2)4,)&$Y 9% H4& #"$ 1%=4#1)#- 2"=6,%$% %e.4,)$;S #"+ H4& 0% &.--%&$)#- 4 +41)24, +%"+-4#)\4$)"# "7 &"2)%$; $" 422"=6,)&0 &.20 4 -"4,Y Z%;#%& 422%6$%1 $0% ?4&)2 1)&$+)?.$)"# 6+"2%&& "7 246)$4,)&=S ?.$ H)&0%1 $" ="1)7; )$ &" $04$ )$& +%&.,$& H%+% ,%&& %R$+%=%Y WU"+ =; 64+$S M ?%,)%(% $04$ $0%+% )& &"2)4, 4#1 6&;20","-)24, b.&$)7)24$)"# 7"+ &)-#)7)24#$ )#%e.4,)$)%& "7 )#2"=% 4#1 H%4,$0S ?.$ #"$ 7"+ &.20 ,4+-% 1)&64+)$)%& 4& %R)&$ $"14;YXDA E0" 2".,1 1)&4-+%% H)$0 Z%;#%& H0%#S 4& H% +%420 $0% ;%4+ ATTTS ?4&%?4,, 4#1 &"22%+ 6,4;%+& )# $0% N5> 4#1 <.+"6% =4; =4C% k8T =),,)"# 4 ;%4+S H0),% &20"", $%420%+& )# $0% N5> 4#1 <.+"6% =4C% kDT $0".&4#1 4 ;%4+V f+ H0%# $0% !
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8P8

M$ )& 4?&",.$%,; 2+)$)24, $" .#1%+&$4#1 $04$ -"(%+#=%#$& )# 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%& 04(% ?%%# 1")#- H04$ Z%;#%& H4#$%1 $0%= $" 1" ^ $04$ )&S )#(%&$ )# )#1.&$+; ^ ?.$ )# &"=% #4$)"#&S &.20 4& $0% N5> 1.+)#$0% 8LQT& 4#1 8LJT&S $0% ?.,C "7 $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )#(%&$=%#$ H4& 4,2D ,1%") )#(%&$=%#$Y K%4-4#S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S $"$%1 .6 4 =),)$4+; )#(%&$=%#$ 6+"-+4= 4=".#$)#- $" kD $+),,)"# )# %)-0$ ;%4+&g 9"H%(%+S W=),)$4+; Z%;#%&)4#)&=XS 422"+1)#- $" Z%;#%& 0)=&%,7S )& WH4&$%7.,X 4#1 6+"1.2%& ,%&& "7 4 W=.,$)6,)%+ %77%2$XDI $04# #"#:=),)$4+; 6.?,)2 H"+C& "+ 2)(),)4# 2"+6"+4$% )#(%&$=%#$&Y Z%;#%& H4& 6+"7".#1,; 4H4+% $04$ 1%="2+4$)2 -"(%+#=%#$& )# 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%& 04(% ?%%# +%$)2%#$ $" )#(%&$ )#$" W&"2)4,,; .&%7., 6+"b%2$&XS ?.$ "6%# $" ,4+-%:&24,% =),)$4+; )#(%&$=%#$& ^ H0)20 4,&" &$)=.,4$% $0% %2"#"=; 4#1 2+%4$% b"?&Y M# 4#; 24&%S W$0% 64+$)4, &"2)4,)\4$)"# "7 )#(%&$=%#$X )& 4$ $0% 2"+% "7 $0% Z%;#%&)4# 6+"-+4=Y >#1 $0)& Z%;#%&)4# 6+"-+4= )#2,.1%& 4 6"H%+: 7., =%204#)&= 7"+ $+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$&Y U"+S 4,"#- H)$0 )#1.&$+)4, )#(%&$: =%#$& _=),)$4+; "+ 2)(),)4#` 4#1 7)#4#2)4, &$4?),)\4$)"# "7 $0% &$"2C =4+C%$S Z%;#%& 41("24$%1 ,4+-%:&24,% 6.?,)2 H"+C& 4& 2%#$+4, $" 0)& %2"#"=)2 &$)=.,.& 642C4-%Y 5.20 6.?,)2 H"+C& 2".,1 )#2,.1% $0% ?.),1)#- "7 +"41&S ?+)1-%&S 14=&S &20"",&S 64+C&S 0".&)#-S 2.,$.+4, 2%#$%+&S 4#1 ="+%YDOSDP ]; 1)+%2$)#,4+-% &24,% )#(%&$=%#$& )#$" W6.?,)2 H"+C&XS $0% -"(%+#=%#$ H".,1 ?% $+4#&7%++)#- +%(%#.%& $"H4+1 $0% .&% "7 4,, $0% 2)$)\%#&Y >#1S b.&$ 4& =),)$4+; 6+"$%2$)"# 6+"$%2$& 4,, 2)$)\%#& ^ +)20S 6""+S 4#1 =)11,)#- 4,)C% ^ &"S $""S 1" 6.?,)2 H"+C& 6+"b%2$& %#04#2% $0% 2)()2 H%,,:?%)#- "7 4,, 2)$)\%#& 4,)C%Y Z%;#%&X &;&$%=S $0".-0 $%20#)24,S =4$0%=4$)24,S 4#1 2"=6,%R )# $%+=& "7 %2"#"=)2 $0%"+;S )& 2,%4+ 6",)$)24,,; 4#1 &"2)4,,;' )$ )& 1)+%2$%1 $"H4+1& $0% 7.,, +%$%#$)"# "7 6",)$)24, 1%="2+42;S H)$0 4# )#2+%4&%1 1%-+%% "7 %e.4,)$;Y /0% 2"#1)$)"# "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& )& %#04#2%1 $0+".-0 6.?,)2 %R6%#1)$.+%&S H0),% $0% +)20 4+% )#1.2%1 $" 2"#$+)?.$% &"=% 6"+$)"# "7 $0%)+ H%4,$0 $" $0% 2)()2 -""1Y /0% 6""+ 4+% 4?&"+?%1 )#$" $0% ,4?"+ 7"+2% ?; $0% %R64#&)"# "7 ?"$0 $0% 6+)(4$% 4#1 $0% 6.?,)2 &%2$"+&Y >#1 4,, "7 $0)&S )# $0% Z%;#%&)4# ="1)7)24$)"# "7 2,4&&)24, %2"#"=)2 $0%"+;S )& 24+%7.,,; 24,2.,4$%1 &" 4& $" 6+"1.2% 4 ="+% %77)2)%#$S ="+% %R64#&)(%S 4#1 ="+% &$4?,% )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=;YDQ

P#73#2 &3 *.B.*+&3 &1 *"# %+)" Z%;#%& ?%-)#& H)$0 4 H4+#)#- "# $4R4$)"# "7 $0% +)20 ^ )$ =.&$ #"$ ?% $"" -+%4$' W/0%+% 4+% (4,.4?,% 0.=4# 42$)()$)%& H0)20 +%e.)+% $0% ="$)(%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8PA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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a +4$0%+S $04$ $0%; H),, #"$ .&% $0% 6"H%+ "7 W$0% &$4$%X $" 1" &" ^ 4 &%%=)#-,; )#2"#&%e.%#$)4, 1)77%+%#$)4$)"# $04$ )& 42$.4,,; e.)$% 2+.2)4,Y U"+ $0% 1)77%+%#2% ?%$H%%# ",)-4+20)2 "(%+:)#7,.%#2% "7 ,%-4, 1%="2+42; 4#1 1)+%2$ 1%&6"$)2 1)2$4$"+)4, 1"=)#4$)"# )& 4,, $0% 1)77%+%#2% )# $0% H"+,1Y Z%;#%& -"%& "# $" =4C% 4 7"+2%7., 4+-.=%#$S "# ?"$0 6",)$)24, 4#1 %2"#"=)2 -+".#1&S $04$ $0% &%64+4$)"# "7 %2"#"=)2 7+"= 6",)$)24, 6"H%+ 4#1 )$& 2"#2"=)$4#$ 6"&)$)(% %77%2$ "# $0% 6",)$; )# $%+=& "7 1)(%+$)#- $0% 0.=4# WH),, $" 6"H%+X )#$" 7)#4#2)4, 4#1 %#$+%6+%#%.+)4, 42$)()$; 24# ?% &.22%&&7.,,; =4)#$4)#%1 H)$0".$ &.20 2","&&4, 1)77%+%#: $)4,& "7 H%4,$0 4& %=%+-% )# .#?+)1,%1 246)$4,)&$:)#1.&$+)4, &"2)%$)%&Y 9% &$4$%& .#%e.)("24,,; $04$' M$ )& #"$ #%2%&&4+; 7"+ $0% &$)=.,4$)"# "7 $0%&% 42$)()$)%& 4#1 $0% &4$)&742$)"# "7 $0%&% 6+"2,)()$)%& $04$ $0% -4=% &0".,1 ?% 6,4;%1 7"+ &.20 0)-0 &$4C%& 4& 4$ 6+%&%#$Y 3.20 ,"H%+ &$4C%& H),, &%+(% $0% 6.+6"&% %e.4,,; H%,,S 4& &""# 4& $0% 6,4;%+& 4+% 422.&$"=%1 $"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8PD

8PI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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f7 2".+&%S $0% +)20 H),, $+; $" 6+%(%#$ $0%)+ "H# $4R4$)"#S ?.$ $0%; H),, #"$ 642C .6 $0%)+ =4+?,%& 4#1 -" 0"=% $" 6,"$ 4# ",)-4+20)2 $4C%"(%+Y >& Z%;#%& ?%,)%(%1S $0% -4)#& 7+"= 1)(%+$)#- &.20 7.#1& 7+"= $0% +)20 $" $0% +%&$ "7 &"2)%$; H".,1 ?% -+%4$ %#".-0 $" %#2".+4-% 4#; &"2)%$; $" $4C% $0% +)&CY 5%2"#1S $0% W&C),,7., %(4&)"#&X "7 $0% +)20 2".,1 ?% 6+%(%#$%1 $0+".-0 $0% %&$4?,)&0=%#$ "7 4 4,-,4<4 1%:a H)$0 #" 4,,"H4?,% ,""60",%&Y E0%$0%+ $0% =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 $0% 6""+ 04(% $0% 6"H%+ $" 64&& &.20 4 ,4H "(%+ $0% "?b%2$)"#& "7 $0% +)20 ?%2"=%& 4 e.%&$)"# $04$ %420 246: )$4,)&$ 2".#$+; =.&$ 742% &%64+4$%,;Y 9"H%(%+S &.20 4 =)#)=.= $4RS &%$ 4$ 4 0)-0 %#".-0 6%+2%#$4-%S ?%2"=%& 4 ,"#-:$%+= &",.$)"# $" $0% $4R: %(4&)"#& "7 $0% +)20Y /0% +)20 H),, 4,H4;& $+; $" %(41% $0%)+ $4R%&a $0%+%: 7"+%S $0% =)11,% 2,4&& 4#1 $0% 6""+S $0+".-0 $0% =%204#)&=& "7 $0% ,%-4,:1%="2+4$)2 )#&$)$.$)"#&S =.&$ 4,H4;& 2".#$%+(4), $0% +)20 )# &.20 4$$%=6$& 4$ %(4&)"#Y Z%;#%&X 4+-.=%#$ 0%+% )& "#% "7 $0% 7".#14$)"#& 7"+ ="1%+#: 14; %2"#"=)2 $0%"+;S %(%# $0".-0 )$ )& 2"#&)1%+%1 ".$+4-%".& ?; $0"&% 410%+)#- $" 2,4&&)24, %2"#"=)2&Y Z%;#%& )& )#&)&$)#- $04$ $0% $4R4$)"# "7 $0% +)20 =4C%& 4(4),4?,% 246)$4, $04$ =.&$ ?% )#(%&$%1 ?; $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )#$" 6.?,)2 6+"b%2$& ^ ?% $0%; =),)$4+;S 2)()2S "+ )#1.&$+)4, ^ 4#1 $04$ &.20 )#(%&$=%#$ &$)=.,4$%& $0% -+"H$0 "7 $0% %2"#"=;Y /0.&S 7+"= $0% Z%;#%&)4# &;&$%=S 4 =)#)=.= $4R &%$ "# $0% +)20 H0)20 4,,"H%1 #" ,""60",%&S H".,1 =4C% 4(4),4?,% 0.-% 4=".#$& "7 246)$4, $04$ 2".,1 $0%# ?% )#(%&$%1 )#$" &"2)4,,; .&%7., 6.?,)2 6+"b%2$&Y 5.20 6+"b%2$& &0".,1 )#2,.1% )#1.&$+)4, 1%(%,"6=%#$ 4#1 $%20#","-)24, +%&%4+20S 4& H%,, 4& 24+%%+ 6+"-+4=& 7"+ $0% 6""+S 0".&)#-S &"2)4, H%,74+% 6+"-+4=& 4#1 &" 7"+$0Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

$0%=Y /0% $4&C "7 $+4#&=.$)#- 0.=4# #4$.+% =.&$ #"$ ?% 2"#7.&%1 H)$0 $0% $4&C "7 =4#4-)#- )$YIT

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8PO

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` W6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; 4#1 7+%% =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2 42$)"#X 4+% 422%6$%1 ?; 0)= 4& W4R)"=4$)2X 4#1 _A` $0% <#,)-0$: %#=%#$ 2"#2%6$)"#& "7 6",)$)24, 7+%%1"= 4#1 1%="2+4$)2 6",)$)24, 42$)"# 4+% 0%,1 4& W7)+&$ 6+)#2)6,%&S .#2"=6+"=)&4?,%XY [%$S $0".-0 K4H,& %#&0+)#%& $0% 6+)(4$%,; "H#%1 7+%% =4+C%$ %2"#"=; 4#1 ,%-4,: +%6+%&%#$4$)(% 1%="2+42;S 0% ?%,)%(%& $04$ $0% W&$4$% "7 #4$.+%X 4#1 W&"2)4, 2"#$+42$X $0%"+; "7 $0% <#,)-0$%#=%#$ 4+% 7,4H%1 "# $0% 6+"?,%= "7 %2"#"=)2 %e.4,)$;Y B%$ .& =4C% )$ 4?&",.$%,; 2,%4+S 0"H%(%+S $04$ 7"+ K4H,&S <#,)-0$%#: =%#$ 6",)$)24, $0%"+; )& 4+20)$%2$"#)2Y /0% H"+C& "7 9"??%&S B"2C%S 3"#$%&e.)%.S d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d%H)&0 4#1 >=%+)24# $0)#C%+& +%42$)#- $" $0% $.=.,$.".& %(%#$& "7 $0% b.&$:%+.6$)#- )#1.&: $+)4, $+4#&7"+=4$)"# "7 #4$)"#4, %2"#"=)%&Y /0% H"+C& "7 5=)$0S K)24+1"S 34,$0.&S 54;S 3),, 4#1 "$0%+& H%+% &%=)#4,Y 9"H%(%+S H0%# H% 2"=% $" $0% 6+"?,%= "7 %e.4,)$; ^ 4 6+"?,%= )#%()$4?,; 4+)&)#- ".$ "7 $0% 7+4=%H"+C "7 ,4H 4#1 1%="2+42; )$&%,7S 4#1 %#-%#1%+%1 ?; $0% =4+C%$:)#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= $04$ 04& 64+4,,%,%1 6",)$)24, 1%="2+42; ^ H% 7)#1 4# %=6$; &642%S "+ H"+&%S 4

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

W.8/20 *"# 1%## -.%6#* .3' 2&)+./ 9(2*+)# X *"# 2*.*# &1 3.*(%# %#,+2+*#'

b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e.4,)7)24$)"# H4& 4,,"H4?,% )# B"2C%X& "$0%+H)&% 1%="2+4$)2 &;&$%=Y M# 742$S 7+"= B"2C%X& $+%4$)&%S ,%-4,:",)-4+20;S +4$0%+ $04# ,%-4,:1%="2+42;S %=%+-%&YI8 /0% 64+41"R 4+)&%& )# $04$S "# $0% "#% 04#1S $0% 2)$)\%# )& 6+"()1%1 H)$0 $0% ="&$ H"#1%+7., &%$ "7 ,%-4, 6+"$%2$)"#& 7+"= $0% 6"H%+ "7 $0% &$4$% %(%+ 6+"6".#1%1S H0),% "# $0% "$0%+ 04#1S $0% =4b"+)$; "7 &.20 2)$): \%#&S ,42C)#- 6+"6%+$; e.4,)7)24$)"#&S 2".,1 #%)$0%+ ("$% #"+ 0",1 "77)2% ()4 $0% ,%-4,:64+,)4=%#$4+; &$+.2$.+%Y 9%+% )& K4H,&X 6+%&%#$4$)"# "7 0)& ,"-)24, +%:-+".#1)#- "7 $0% $0%"+; "7 ,4H 4#1 +)-0$&Y 9% 24,,& )$ Wb.&$)2% 4& 74)+#%&&XS 4#1 0% $4C%& .& ?42C $" W$0% &$4$% "7 #4$.+%X )# "+1%+ $" ?%-)# $0% W&"2)4, 2"#$+42$X "(%+ 4-4)#Y /0% &$4$% "7 #4$.+% )&S "7 2".+&%S #"$ $0".-0$ "7 4& 4# 42$.4, 0)&$"+)24, &$4$% "7 4774)+&S =.20 ,%&& 4& 4 6+)=)$)(% 2"#1)$)"# "7 2.,$.+%Y M$ )& .#1%+&$""1 4& 4 6.+%,; 0;6"$0%$)24, &)$.4$)"# 204+42$%+)\%1 &" 4& $" ,%41 $" 4 2%+$4)# 2"#2%6$)"# "7 b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b.&$)2% 4+% $0% +%&.,$ "7 4 74)+ 4-+%%=%#$ "+ ?4+-4)#YIA K4H,&X ,"-)2 +%=)#1& "#% "7 $0% ,"-)2 )# $0% 7",C $4,% )# H0)20 $H" )#1)()1.4,& =.&$ 1)()1% 4 6)%Y M# "+1%+ $" %#&.+% 74)+#%&& )# $0% +%&.,$S $0%; 1%2)1% $04$ "#% "7 $0%= H),, 1)()1% )$S ?.$ $0% "$0%+ H),, 20""&% H0)20 04,7 $" $4C%Y M# K4H,&X &20%=%S &)#2% $0% 64+$)2)64#$& H".,1 ?% 42$)#?%0)#1 4 W(%), "7 )-#"+4#2%XS #"$ C#"H)#- $0%)+ 6"&)$)"#& )# $0% &"2)%$; $04$ H),, %=%+-%S $0%; H".,1 04(% $" &%$ .6 4 74)+ &;&$%= ?"$0 6",)$)24,,; 4#1 %2"#"=)24,,; $" 4(")1 $0% +)&C "7 1)&41(4#$4-)#- $0%=&%,(%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8PP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8PQ

K4H,& 1%(%,"6& $H" ?4&)2 6+)#2)6,%& "7 b.&$)2%S H0)20 %=%+-% 7+"= $0% &"2)4, 2"#$+42$ %#$%+%1 )#$" ?%0)#1 $0% W(%), "7 )-#"+4#2%X )# $0% 0;6"$0%$)24, &$4$% "7 #4$.+%Y U)+&$' %420 6%+&"# )& $" 04(% 4# %e.4, +)-0$ $" $0% ="&$ %R$%#&)(% ?4&)2 ,)?%+$; 2"=64$)?,% H)$0 4 &)=),4+ ,)?%+$; 7"+ "$0%+&Y 5%2"#1' &"2)4, 4#1 %2"#"=)2 )#%e.4,)$)%& 4+% $" ?% 4++4#-%1 &" $04$ $0%; 4+% ?"$0 4` +%4&"#4?,; %R6%2$%1 $" ?% $" %(%+;"#%X& 41(4#$4-%S 4#1 ?` 4$$420%1 $" 6"&)$)"#& 4#1 "77)2%& "6%# $" 4,,YII /0% 7)+&$ 6+)#2)6,%S $04$ "7 6",)$)24, 7+%%1"=S )& %4&; $" %&$4?,)&0 $0+".-0 K4H,&X ,"-)2S 4#1 )$ )& 2"#&)&$%#$ H)$0 $0% <#,)-0$%#=%#$ $+41): $)"# _4& $04$ $+41)$)"# 24=% $" )$& \%#)$0 H)$0 $0% 2"#$+)?.$)"#& "7 $0% ]+)$)&0 E0)-& 4#1 $0% >=%+)24# 4#1 U+%#20 )#$%,,%2$.4,&`Y /0% ?4&)2 ,)?%+$)%& "7 2)$)\%#& 4+%S +".-0,; &6%4C)#-S 6",)$)24, ,)?%+$; _$0% +)-0$ $" ("$% 4#1 $" ?% %,)-)?,% 7"+ 6.?,)2 "77)2%` $"-%$0%+ H)$0 7+%%1"= "7 &6%%20 4#1 4&&%=?,;a ,)?%+$; "7 2"#&2)%#2% 4#1 7+%%1"= "7 $0".-0$a 7+%%1"= "7 $0% 6%+&"# 4,"#- H)$0 $0% +)-0$ $" 0",1 _6%+&"#4,` 6+"6%+$;a 4#1 7+%%1"= 7+"= 4+?)$+4+; 4++%&$ 4#1 &%)\.+% 4& 1%7)#%1 ?; $0% 2"#2%6$ "7 $0% ,4HY /0%&% ,)?%+$)%& 4+% 4,, +%e.)+%1 $" ?% %e.4, ?; $0% 7)+&$ 6+)#2)6,%S &)#2% 2)$)\%#& "7 4 b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e.4,)$; )# %2"#"=)2 H%4,$0 _4#1 &"2)4, &$4$.&`Y B"2C% H4& 2"#$%#$ $" 4,,"H 7"+ $0)&S ?.$ K4H,& 24##"$ ?% &" 2"#$%#$Y U"+S ?%0)#1 $0% W(%), "7 )-#"+4#2%X )# K4H,&X &$4$% "7 #4$.+%S )#1): ()1.4,& H".,1 #%(%+ 4-+%% $" 4 &"2)4, 2"#$+42$ )# H0)20 &"=% 2".,1 ?%2"=% %2"#"=)24,,; 1)&41(4#$4-%1 )# $0% &"2)%$; $04$ H".,1 %=%+-%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

U"+ %R4=6,%S )7 4 =4# C#%H $04$ 0% H4& H%4,$0;S 0% =)-0$ 7)#1 )$ +4$)"#4, $" 41(4#2% $0% 6+)#2)6,% $04$ (4+)".& $4R%& 7"+ H%,74+% =%4: &.+%& ?% 2".#$%1 .#b.&$a )7 0% C#%H $04$ 0% H4& 6""+S 0% H".,1 ="&$ ,)C%,; 6+"6"&% $0% 2"#$+4+; 6+)#2)6,%YID

8PJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0% &%2"#1 6+)#2)6,% 466,)%&S )# $0% 7)+&$ 466+"R)=4$)"#S $" $0% 1)&: $+)?.$)"# "7 )#2"=% 4#1 H%4,$0 4#1 $" $0% 1%&)-# "7 "+-4#)\4$)"#& $04$ =4C% .&% "7 1)77%+%#2%& )# 4.$0"+)$; 4#1 +%&6"#&)?),)$;S "+ 204)#& "7 2"==4#1Y E0),% 1(# 9,31",A<1,7- 7$ ;#%21( %-9 ,-&74# -##9 -71 A# #_<%2S )$ =.&$ ?% 17 #>#")7-#/3 %9>%-1%.#S 4#1 4$ $0% &4=% $)=%S 073,D 1,7-3 "7 4.$0"+)$; 4#1 7$$, "7 2"==4#1 =.&$ ?% %&!,A2# 17 %22Y f#% 466,)%& $0% &%2"#1 6+)#2)6,% ?; 0",1)#- 6"&)$)"#& "6%#S 4#1 $0%# &.?b%2$ $" $0)& 2"#&$+4)#$S %""%-.#3 37&,%2 %-9 #&7-74,& ,-#_<%2,1,#3 37 1(%1 #>#")7-# A#-#$,13YIP 5"2)4,)&$ $0%"+)&$& H),, ?% )#7.+)4$%1 ?; K4H,&X ,"-)2 "# $0)&S 4& H),, ,)?%+4, $0%"+)&$& _>=%+)24# 2"#&%+(4$)(%& 4#1 #%"2"#&%+(4$)(%&`Y /0% &"2)4,)&$& H),, 1%=4#1 $" C#"H H0; )$ 1"%& #"$ ,"-)24,,; 7",,"H $04$ )# W$0% )#)$)4, &)$.4$)"#X $0% 20")2% 7"+ 2"=6,%$% %e.4,)$; )& #"$ 4++)(%1 4$ ^ 7"+ #" "#% C#"H& $0%)+ 6"&)$)"#S b.&$ 4& )# $0% 24&% "7 6",)$)24, +)-0$&S 4#1 $0%+%7"+%S #" "#% H".,1 H4#$ $" %#1 .6 4="#- $0% 1)&41(4#$4-%1 2,4&&%&Y B)?%+4,& _>=%+)24# 2"#&%+(4$)(%& 4#1 #%"2"#&%+(4$)(%&`S 7"+ $0%)+ 64+$S H),, H"#1%+ 0"H %e.4,)$; "7 "66"+$.#)$; 24# ?% 7.,,; -.4+: 4#$%%1S 4#1 0"H &"2)4, 4#1 %2"#"=)2 )#%e.4,)$)%& 24# ?% W2"#&$+4)#%1X &" $04$ $0%; H"+C $" W%(%+;"#%X& ?%#%7)$XS H)$0".$ =4&&)(% )#$%+(%#$)"# ?; $0% &$4$%Y K4H,& 4#&H%+& ?"$0 "7 $0%&% 2+)$)2)&=&Y E)$0".$ 1%=4#1)#- 4#;$0)#,)C% 2"%+2%1 %e.4,)\4$)"#S K4H,& 4+-.%& 4-4)#&$ 4 &;&$%= "7 .#?+)1,%1 )#1)()1.4, H%4,$0 422.=.,4$)"# 4#1 )#0%+)$4#2%Y E0%$0%+ $0% 422.=.: ,4$)"# )& "# $0% ?4&)& "7 =%+)$ "+ )#0%+)$4#2%S K4H,& )#&)&$& $04$ $0% "#,; b.&$)7)24$)"# 7"+ &.20 422.=.,4$)"# )& $04$ )$ ?%#%7)$ $0% -""1 "7 4,, _4#1 $0% ,%4&$ 7"+$.#4$%`Y U"+S )7 )$ 1)1 #"$S $0%# )$ 2".,1 #"$ 04(% ?%%# 4-+%%1 .6"# ?%0)#1 $0% W(%), "7 )-#"+4#2%XY M# $0)& 0% )& ,"-)24,,; 2"++%2$Y M# $0% W)#)$)4, &)$.4$)"#X #" +4$)"#4, 0.=4# H".,1 4-+%% $" &.20 4 1)77%+%#$)4, 422.=.,4$)"# .#,%&& )$ H%+% $" $0%)+ "H# %(%#$.4, ?%#%7)$Y /0.&S 4,$0".-0 4,,"H)#- 7"+ 1)77%+%#$)4,& )# H%4,$0 ?4&%1 "# =%+)$ 4#1 )#0%+)$4#2% _$0.& =4C)#- 0)& &;&$%= 2"#&)&$%#$ H)$0 ,)?%+4,)&=`S K4H,& 4,&" )#2,.1%& 4 2"#2%6$)"# "7 +%2)6+"2)$; )# H%4,$0 <3# ^ $0.& =)$)-4$)#$0% H"+&$ %R2%&&%& "7 ,)?%+4,)&= _7"+ &.20 %R2%&&%& 04(% %=%+-%1 )# 42$.4, 0)&$"+)24, 2)+2.=&$4#2%&`Y Y Y Y $0% 9,$$#"#-&# 0",-&,02# %R6+%&&%& 4 2"#2%6$)"# "7 "#&,0"7&,1)Y M$ )& 4 6+)#2)6,% "7 =.$.4, ?%#%7)$ Y Y Y $0% &"2)4, "+1%+ 24# ?% b.&$)7)%1 $"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0%+%7"+% K4H,&S )# "+1%+ $" C%%6 0)& &;&$%= ,"-)24,,; 2"#&)&$%#$S 041 $" %&$4?,)&0 0)& 3#&7-9 0",-&,02# "7 b.&$)2%Y

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8PL

G" )1%","-; "7 ,%(%,)#- )& =41% 2%#$+4,S 4#1 2%+$4)#,; #" )#&$)$.$)"#: 4,)\4$)"# "7 &$4$% "H#%+&0)6 "7 $0% 6+"1.2$)(% &;&$%= "+ 2"%+2)(% +%1)&: $+)?.$)"# )& 1%=4#1%1Y 9"H%(%+S H)$0)# 4 &;&$%= "7 )#1)()1.4, %2"#"=)2 4&&%+$)"#S &%,7:42$.4,)\4$)"#S 4#1 %&24,4$%1 +%H4+1&S $0% W1)7: 7%+%#2% 6+)#2)6,%X %#-%#1%+& 4 &%#&% "7 W7+4$%+#)$;XS ?%24.&% 1)77%+%#$)4,& "7 H%4,$0 4#1 6"H%+ 24# "#,; ?% b.&$)7)%1 )7 $0%; 2"#$+)?.$% $" $0% -""1 "7 4,, 4#1 $0% ,%4&$ 41(4#$4-%1Y > 7.+$0%+ =%+)$ "7 $0% 1)77%+%#2% 6+)#2)6,% )& $04$ )$ 6+"()1%& 4# )#$%+6+%$4$)"# "7 $0% 6+)#2)6,% "7 7+4$%+#)$;Y Y Y Y /0% 1)77%+%#2% 6+)#2): 6,% Y Y Y 1"%& &%%= $" 2"++%&6"#1 $" 4 #4$.+4, =%4#)#- "7 7+4$%+#)$;' #4=%,;S $" $0% )1%4 "7 #"$ H4#$)#- $" 04(% -+%4$%+ 41(4#$4-%& .#,%&& $0)& )& $" $0% ?%#%7)$ "7 "$0%+& H0" 4+% ,%&& H%,, "77YIJ

!"# -.%6#* #)&3&-7 .3' +*2 -&'+1+).*+&3 K4H,& -"%& "# $" 4&&%+$ $04$ $0%+% )& 74)+ _4& "66"&%1 $" 7"+=4,` %e.4,)$; "7 "66"+$.#)$;Y /0)& =%4#& $04$ )# 411)$)"# $" =4)#$4)#)#- $0% .&.4, C)#1& "7 "(%+0%41 246)$4,S 1(# .7>#"-4#-1 1",#3 17 #-3<"# #_<%2 &(%- 7$ #9<&%1,7- %-9 &<21<"# $7" 0#"37-3 3,4,2%"2) #-97;#9 %-9 471,>%1#9B #,1(#" A) 3%1# 3&(7723 7" A) #31%A2,3(,-. % 0,1,#3 4#1 )# 1(# $"## &(7,&# 7$ 7&&<0%1,7-Y U.+$0%+S K4H,& H".,1 %&$4?,)&0 4 #%H ?+4#20 "7 -"(%+#=%#$ $" 0%,6 2+%4$% &"2)4, %e.4,)$;Y /0% &"2)4, =)#)=.= )& $0% +%&6"#&)?),)$; "7 $0% 1"%-3$#" A"%-&(Y Y Y Y > 2"=6%$)$)(% 6+)2% &;&$%= -)(%& #" 2"#&)1%+4$)"# $" #%%1&S 4#1 $0%+%: 7"+% )$ 24##"$ ?% $0% &",% 1%()2% "7 1)&$+)?.$)"#Y Y Y Y !"=6%$)$)(% =4+: C%$& 6+"6%+,; +%-.,4$%1 &%2.+% 7+%% 20")2% "7 "22.64$)"#& 4#1 ,%41 $" 4# %77)2)%#$ .&% "7 +%&".+2%& 4#1 4,,"24$)"# "7 2"=="1)$)%& $" 0".&%: 0",1& Y Y Y H0%+%4& $0% 1"%-3$#" A"%-&( -.4+4#$%%& 4 2%+$4)# ,%(%, "7 H%,,: ?%)#- 4#1 (7-7"3 1(# &2%,43 7$ -##9Y Y Y YIL /0% .#%e.4, )#0%+)$4#2% "7 H%4,$0 )& #"$ ="+% )#0%+%#$,; .#b.&$ $04# $0% .#%e.4, )#0%+)$4#2% "7 )#$%,,)-%#2% Y Y Y $0% %&&%#$)4, $0)#-

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

%(%+;"#%S 4#1 )# 64+$)2.,4+ $" $0"&% H0" 4+% ,%4&$ 74("+%1S 4#1 )# $0)& &%#&% )$ )& %-4,)$4+)4#YIQ

)& $04$ 4& 74+ 4& 6"&&)?,% )#%e.4,)$)%& 7".#1%1 "# %)$0%+ &0".,1 &4$)&7; $0% 1)77%+%#2% 6+)#2)6,%Y m/04$ )&n )#0%+)$4#2% )& 6%+=)&&)?,% 6+"()1%1 $04$ $0% +%&.,$)#- )#%e.4,)$)%& 4+% $" $0% 41(4#$4-% "7 $0% ,%4&$ 7"+: $.#4$% 4#1 2"=64$)?,% H)$0 ,)?%+$; 4#1 74)+ %e.4,)$; "7 "66"+$.#)$;Y >& %4+,)%+ 1%7)#%1S 74)+ %e.4,)$; "7 "66"+$.#)$; =%4#& 4 2%+$4)# &%$ "7 )#&$)$.$)"#& $04$ 4&&.+%& &)=),4+ 204#2%& "7 %1.24$)"# 4#1 2.,$.+% 7"+ 6%+&"#& &)=),4+,; ="$)(4$%1 4#1 C%%6& 6"&)$)"#& 4#1 "77)2%& "6%# $" 4,, "# $0% ?4&)& "7 e.4,)$)%& 4#1 %77"+$& +%4&"#4?,; +%,4$%1 $" $0% +%,%(4#$ 1.$)%& 4#1 $4&C&Y 81 ,3 1(#3# ,-31,1<1,7-3 1(%1 %"# 0<1 ,- ^#70%"9) ;(#- ,-#_<%2,1,#3 7$ ;#%21( "#%&( % &#"1%,- 2,4,1` %-9 072,1,&%2 2,A#"1) 2,I#;,3# 1#-93 17 273# ,13 >%2<#B %-9 "#0"#3#-1%1,># .7>#"-4#-1 17 A#&74# 3<&( ,- %00#%"%-&# 7-2)YOT /0% 7,4H "7 <#,)-0$%#=%#$ $0%"+; "# $0% )&&.% "7 6+"6%+$;S H%4,$0 4#1 2,4&& %#-%#1%+%1 $0% &"2)4,)&$ +%42$)"# 4-4)#&$ W?".+-%")& 1%="2+42;XY /0% &"2)4,)&$ &",.$)"#S 0"H%(%+ ^ $04$ "7 2,4&&,%&&#%&& ^ )& 4& =.20 4# ),,.&)"# 4& $0% 246)$4,)&$ &",.$)"# ^ $04$ "7 $0% W)#()&)?,% 04#1 "7 $0% =4+C%$X %#&.+)#- 4# %e.)$4?,%S )7 .#%e.4,S 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0Y E% =.&$ +%6,42% ?"$0 $0%&% .$"6)4# ()&)"#& H)$0 $0% +%4,)&$)2 6"&&)?),)$; 1%+)(%1 7+"= $0%"+)&$& &.20 4& K4H,&Y K4H,&S %#$0+4,,%1 ?; <#,)-0$%#=%#$ 6+)#2)6,%& "7 7+%%1"=S ,4HS 4#1 =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2&S "77%+& .& 4 &;&$%= H0"&% &$+%#-$0& +%=4)# .#2"=: 6+"=)&%1 H0),% )$& H%4C#%&&%& 4+% "(%+2"=%Y 9% 6+%&%#$& .& H)$0 4 &;&$%= "7 2"++%2$)(% 6+"2%&&%& 1%&)-#%1 $" %#&.+% 4 74)+ &;&$%= "7 W%e.4,: )$; "7 "66"+$.#)$;X 4#1 4 b.&$ &;&$%= "7 W%#1 +%&.,$&XY 9)& $0%"+; "7 #9<&%1,7- )& -%4+%1 $"H4+1 2"++%2$)#- $0% .#74)+#%&& "7 "66"+$.#)$; $04$ .&.4,,; 6+%(4),& )# ,%-4,:1%="2+4$)2 &"2)%$)%&S H0),% 0)& $0%"+; "7 1"%-3$#"3 )& -%4+%1 $" 2"++%2$)#- $0% %R$+%=% )#%e.4,)$; "7 )#2"=%& $04$ 204+42$%+)\%1 =4+C%$:%2"#"=; &"2)%$)%&Y /0% ,%-4,:1%="2+4$)2 6",)$)24, &;&$%= %=%+-%#$ 7+"= $0% H"+C& "7 9"??%&S B"2C%S 3"#$%&e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b.&$)7)%1 )7 $0%; 2"#$+)?.$% $" $0% -""1 "7 4,, 4#1 $0% ,%4&$ 41(4#$4-%1YO8

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8QT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8Q8

>#2)%#$ @+%%2% H4& $0% ?)+$06,42% "7 1%="2+42; 4& H% C#"H )$Y >&&%=: ?,)%& "7 2)$)\%#& -4$0%+%1 _)# &"=% @+%%C 2)$;:&$4$%&` $" 1%?4$% 4#1 1%2)1% .6"# 6.?,)2 6",)2;Y f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e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f#2% +%C)#1,%1S $0%&% )1%4& 4#1 6+"-+4=& &0"#% ,)C% 4 ?%42"#S "?,)$%+4$)#- $0% ,"#- #)-0$ "7 $0% F4+C >-%&Y >#1 )7 1%="2+42; H4& %&$4?,)&0%1 "# 4 #%H 4#1 +4$)"#4, ?4&%S ?%;"#1 $04$ "7 $0% $+)?4, 24&%S &" $"" H4& %e.4,)$;Y M# 6+%:6",)& $+)?%&S 2""6%+4$)"# H4& #%2%&&4+; 7"+ &.+()(4,Y /0% 2""+1: )#4$%1 %77"+$& "7 =%# )# 0.#$)#- H%+% 4?&",.$%,; %&&%#$)4,S H0),% $0% 2"=?)#%1 %77"+$& "7 H"=%# H%+% 2+)$)24, 7"+ -4$0%+)#- _4#1i"+ -4+1%#: )#-`Y /0% &04+)#- "7 =%4$ 4#1 (%-%$4?,% 7""1 ?%$H%%# $0% =%# 4#1 $0% H"=%# $0%# %#&.+%1 $0% &.+()(4, "7 $0% )#1)()1.4,& H)$0)# $0% -+".6YOD *+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; %R)&$%1 )# $0% 7"+= "7 2+47$%1 H%46"#&S 2,"$0)#-S &0%,$%+S "+#4=%#$&S +%,)-)".& 4+$)2,%&S 4#1 &" "#Y 9"H%(%+S 4,$0".-0

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

U%+2*&*/#0 '#-&)%.)7A #V(./+*7A .3' *"# -+''/# )/.22

6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; %R)&$%1S )$ H4& 2"==.#4, )# .&%Y /04$ )&S 4# 4++"H 6+"1.2%1 ?; $0% ?%&$ 2+47$&=4# H".,1 ?% &04+%1 H)$0 $0% ?%&$ 0.#$%+ ^ 4 20")2% &04+% "7 $0% C),, +%$.+#)#- $" $0% 2+47$&=4#Y f+ 4 64)+ "7 ="224&)#& H".,1 ?% -)(%# $" 4#"$0%+ )# #%%1S H)$0 0"#"+ 422+.)#- $" $0% =4C%+ 4#1 -)(%+Y *+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; H)$0 2"==.#4, .&% H4& $0% #"+= 7"+ ="&$ $+)?4, &"2)%$)%&Y U4=),)%& 2".,1 ,%4(% 4 $+)?4, -+".6 7"+ 4#"$0%+ %#24=6=%#$ H)$0 ="&$ "7 $0%)+ 6"&&%&&)"#& )# 04#1a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e.4, 4++4#-%=%#$ "7 6"H%+S &$4$.&S 4#1 ,)()#&$4#14+1&Y M# $0% 1)()#% C)#-,; %=6)+%&S $0)& 1),%==4 H4& +%&",(%1 ?; H4; "7 4# )1%","-)24, &,%)-0$ "7 04#1' /0+".-0 $0% +%,)-)".& =420)#4$)"#& "7 $0% 64-4# 6+)%&$0""1S $0% 4+)&$"2+42; 4#1 $0% C)#- H%+% 1%2,4+%1 1)()#%Y f#2% $0% +";4, 4.+4 041 ?%%# 24&$ "(%+ $0% 4+)&$"2+42;S $0% &0"H%+)#- "7 &.+6,.& -""1& .6"# $0%= ?%24=% ,"-)24,YOO /0% -"1,; -4)#%1 $0% &.+: 6,.& 4#1 H%+% 41"+#%1 H)$0 $0% ,.R.+)%&Y 5" 41"+#%1S $0%; 466%4+%1 -"1:,)C%S 4#1 &" $0% 2)+2,% "7 %R2,.&)"# H4& 2"=6,%$%Y ]%,"H $0% 1%)7)%1 4+)&$"2+42;S 4 2"==.#4, %$0)2& ^ ="1)7)%1S ;%$ &)=),4+ $" $+)?4, %$0)2& ^ 2"#$)#.%1 $" 6+%(4),Y <#$%+ $0% $+41% =%+204#$& >$ $0% ?%0%&$ "7 $0% -"1,;:4+)&$"2+42;S 4 #%H 2,4&& "7 $+41)#- =%+: 204#$& H%+% %#2".+4-%1 )# $0%)+ $4&CY /0% =%+204#$& )#(%#$%1S 4& $0%)+ W$"",& "7 $0% $+41%XS ="#%; 4#1 2"#$+42$ ,4HYOP >+=%1 H)$0 $0%)+ #%H $"",&S 4#1 7"+2%1 ?; #%2%&&)$; $" ,%4+# $0% 4+$& "7 24,2.,4$)"#S H+)$)#-S 4#1 7"+%)-# ,4#-.4-%S $0% =%+204#$& ?%24=% 4 +4$)"#4,S )#$%,,%2$.4, 4#1 H%4,$0; &$+4$.= "7 4#2)%#$ 2)(),)\%1 &"2)%$;Y 9"H%(%+S H)$0)# $0% 2"#$%R$ "7 $0% 1)()#% C)#-,; %=6)+%&S $0% =%+: 204#$&X H%4,$0 4#1 &$4$.& 2".,1 #%(%+ ?%2"=% ,%-)$)=4$%1Y /0%; H%+% #"$ -"1&S $0%+%7"+% $0%)+ 422.=.,4$)"# "7 H%4,$0 4#1 ,.R.+; H4& .#42: 2%6$4?,% ^ ?"$0 $" $0% 4+)&$"2+42; 4#1 $0% 6+"74#% 2,4&&%&Y /0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8QA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

=%+204#$& H%+% 04$%1 ?; $0% ,"H%+ 2,4&&%& 4#1 1%=%4#%1 H0%#%(%+ 6"&&)?,% ?; $0% 4+)&$"2+42;Y /0.&S 4,$0".-0 $0%)+ 422.=.,4$)"# "7 6+)(4$% H%4,$0 2"#$)#.%1 _?%24.&% $0%)+ 2+47$ H4& %&&%#$)4, $" $0% 7.#2$)"#)#- "7 $0% %=6)+%&`S 4# %$0)2 "7 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; 4#1 6+)(4$% H%4,$0 422.=.,4$)"# H4& #%(%+ 422%6$%1 4& 4 -%#%+4, 6+)#2)6,% "7 %2"#"=)2 1)&$+)?.$)"# "+ 4 ="+4, )1%4,YOQ /0% ="#%; %2"#"=; 4#1 2"#$+42$ ,4H H%+% ,)=)$%1 $" $+41% $+4#&42$)"#&S H0),% $0% 2"==.#4, &$"+%0".&%&S $0% )#$%+#4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 -""1&S 4#1 $0% 2"+(%h% ,4?"+ 6+"b%2$& 2"#$)#.%1 $" ?% 2"#$+",,%1 ?; $0% 64-4# 6+)%&$0""1 4#1 C)#-,; "77)2)4,&Y /0% 4+)&$"2+42;S "7 2".+&%S 2"#: $)#.%1 $" 422+.% )$& -"1,; &04+%Y M# $0% @+%%C 2)$;:&$4$%&S 7".#1%1 4& =),)$4+; 4&&"2)4$)"#& 4#1 #"$ 4& 1)()#% C)#-,; %=6)+% 2%#$%+&SOJ 4#1 4,&" )# $0% *0"%#)2)4# $+41)#- 2)$)%&S =%+204#$ 42$)()$; %#-%#1%+%1 4 74+ ="+% 6+"7".#1 %77%2$Y *+)(4$% H%4,$0 422.=.,4$)"# 4#1 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; ?%24=% 2"=="#6,42%Y ].$ $0% .#%e.4, 422.=.,4$)"# "7 H%4,$0 4="#- 2)$)\%#+; $04$ H4& %e.4, )# 6",)$)24, 6"H%+ 4#1 &$4$.& H".,1 2+%4$% 4# %$0)24, 1),%==4 $04$ H".,1 04(% $" ?% +%&",(%1Y U"+ $0% 422.=.,4$)"# "7 -+%4$ 6+)(4$% H%4,$0 H".,1 -%#%+4$% 04$+%1 4#1 b%4,".&; .#=)$)-4$%1 ?; 4#; 1)()#% 4.+4Y E)$0)# 4 +4$)"#4,,; "+)%#$%1 =),)$4+; &"2)%$; )# H0)20 $0% )#1)()1.4, 2)$)\%# H4& %1.24$%1 $" 6",)$)24, %e.4,)$; 4#1 $+4)#%1 )# =),)$4+; 6+"H%&&S b%4,".&; )# $0% %2"#"=)2 &60%+% H4& ?".#1 $" &6),, "(%+ )#$" ()",%#2% )# $0% 6",)$)24, &60%+%Y >#1 &" )$ 1)1Y >& $0% ,4#1%1 =),)$4+; %,)$% _H0)20 H4& #%(%+ W1)()#%X )# @+%%2%` H4& +%6,42%1 ?; 4 #%H =%+204#$ %,)$%S 4 2;2,% "7 +%(",.$)"# 4#1 2".#$%+: +%(",.$)"# H4& &%$ "77 $04$ $0+%4$%#%1 $" 1%&$+"; @+%%C &"2)%$;YOL E)$0)# $0% 1.4, 2"#$%R$ "7 %=%+-)#- 2"#&$)$.$)"#4, 1%="2+42; 4#1 -+"H)#- 2,4&& ()",%#2%S @+%%C $0)#C%+&S ="+% 4& 6+42$)24, 6",)2;=4C%+& $04# 4& )("+;:$"H%+ 60),"&"60%+&S 4$$%=6$%1 $" %&$4?,)&0 &20%=4& $04$ H".,1 ?4,4#2% $0% 2,4)=& "7 1%="2+4$)2 2)$)\%#+; 6"&&%&&%1 "7 ,%-4, %e.4,)$; H)$0 $0% 64+4,,%, ?.$ 2"#7,)2$)#- 2,4)=& "7 4 7+%%:$+41)#- )#&$)$.: $)"# -%#%+4$)#- %#"+=".& 1)77%+%#$)4,& )# $0% 422.=.,4$)"# "7 6%+&"#4, H%4,$0 _4#1 $0% 6+"6%+$;S 6"H%+S 4#1 &$4$.& $04$ $0)& H%4,$0 2".,1 ?.;`Y >=)1 $0% $.+="), -%#%+4$%1 ?; $0% +)&% "7 6",)$)24, 1%="2+42; 4#1 $0% 2"#2"=)$4#$ +)&% "7 %2"#"=)2 )#%e.4,)$;S $0)#C%+& &.20 4& *,4$"S >+)&: $"$,%S *04,%.&S /0.2;1)1%& ^ 4#1 ,4$%+ *",;?).& 4#1 *,.$4+20 ^ H+"$%S "77%+)#- $0%)+ 4#4,;&%& 4#1 &",.$)"#& $" $0)& 6+"?,%= %#(%,"6)#- @+%%C &"2)%$;Y K%42$)#- $" $0% $.+?.,%#2% "7 ?"$0 6",)$)24, 1%="2+42; 4#1 %R2%&&)(% %2"#"=)2 )#%e.4,)$;S *,4$" 6.$ 7"+$0 4 &20%=4 1%=4#1)#- 4 +%$.+# $" $0% =),)$4+;:4&2%$)2 4#1 +%-)=%#$%1 &"2)%$; "7 $0% @+%%C 64&$Y 5.20 4

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8QD

&"2)%$;S )# 64+$S &$),, %R)&$%1 )# 564+$4Y ].$S .#,)C% $0% 564+$4# ="1%,S *,4$" %R4,$%1 $0% ()+$.% "7 )#$%,,%2$.4, 1%(%,"6=%#$ 4?"(% $04$ "7 $0% =),)$4+;Y 9% +%b%2$%1 564+$4X& W$)="2+42;XS "+ &;&$%= "7 -"(%+#=%#$ ?4&%1 "# =),)$4+; 0"#"+ 4,"#%S 4#1 H".,1 04(% +%6,42%1 )$ H)$0 $+.% 4+)&$": 2+42;S "+ -"(%+#=%#$ ?; $0% W?%&$X _%",317,` ^ $0% W?%&$X =%4#)#-S )# *,4$"X& $%+=&S $0% )#$%,,%2$.4,,; ="&$ &.6%+)"+Y /0%&% %",317, H".,1 +.,% 7"+ $0% +%&$ "7 $0% 6%"6,%S 4& $0% W-.4+1)4#&XS $0% -"(%+#=%#$ )# *,4$"X& )1%4, +%6.?,)2 $0.& $4C)#- $0% 7"+= "7 4# ",)-4+20; "7 $0% )#$%,,%2$.4,,; &.6%+)"+ 7%HYPT *,4$" +%b%2$%1 1%="2+42;S "+ +.,% ?; 4,, $0% 6%"6,% _9#473`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`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b%2$ *,4$"X& ="1%, 7"+ $0% ="1%+# H"+,1YPA f$0%+ $0%"+)&$&S &.20 4& *04,%.&S 4$$%=6$%1 $" 2+%4$% &20%=4& )# H0)20 4 &;&$%= "7 %e.4, 6+"6%+$; H".,1 .#1%+-)+1 4 6+"2%&& "7 6",)$)24,

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8QI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

1%="2+42;Y ].$ )# *04,%.&X 6+"-+4=S 2"#&$4#$ &$4$% )#$%+(%#$)"# H".,1 04(% ?%2"=% #%2%&&4+; $" %#&.+% $0% 2"#$)#.4$)"# "7 %e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e.4,)$; 4#1 422.=.,4$)"# "7 6+)(4$% H%4,$0Y /0% ?4&%& "7 $0% $0%"+; H%+%' 6+"6"+$)"#4$% %e.4,)$;S 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; H)$0 6.?,)2 .&% 4#1 4 =4b"+)$; =)11,% 2,4&&Y M# $0% 7",,"H)#- &%2$)"# H% H),, 4$$%=6$ $" &0"H $04$ $0% $0%"+; "7 $0% =4b"+)$; =)11,% 2,4&& )& $0% 4+20)$%2$"#)2 $0%"+; .6"# H0)20 4,, "$0%+ $0%"+)%& "7 %e.4,)$; =.&$ ?% ?.),$YPD > 24(%4$' >+)&$"$,%S 4& H)$0 ="&$ "7 $0% @+%%C $0)#C%+&S 422%6$%1 =),)$4+),; 1%+)(%1 &,4(%+; 4& 4 742$ "7 &"2)4, %R)&$%#2%a 0% 1)1 #"$ &.66"+$ 7+%%)#- $0% &,4(%& "+ =4C)#- $0%= 2)$)\%#&Y f# H"=%#X& 64+$)2)64$)"# )# 6",)$)2&S >+)&$"$,% H4& 4,&" +%-+%&&)(%S 2"#&)1%+)#- H"=%# 4& )#7%+)"+ $" =%#S H0%+%4& *,4$" H4& 6+"-+%&&)(% 4#1 H".,1 04(% )#2,.1%1 )#$%,,%2: $.4,,; &.6%+)"+ H"=%# )# 0)& -.4+1)4# 2,4&&Y f# ,%-4, 6+"$%2$)"# "7 $0% 6%"6,% 4-4)#&$ $0% &$4$%S 0"H%(%+S >+)&$"$,%X& 6"&)$)"# )& 4?"(% +%6+"420' W9% H0" 2"==4#1& $04$ ,4H &0".,1 +.,% =4; $0.& ?% +%-4+1%1 4& 2"==4#1)#- $04$ @"1 4#1 K%4&"# 4,"#% &0".,1 +.,%a 0% H0" 2"=: =4#1& $04$ 4 =4# &0".,1 +.,% 411& $0% 204+42$%+ "7 $0% ?%4&$YXPI Y#-&)%.)7 .3' #V(./+*7 +3 U%+2*&*#/+.3 ;./.3)# >+)&$"$,% ?%-)#& H)$0 4 &"2)","-)24, 7"+=.,4$)"# $04$ 2".,1 04(% 2"=% 7+"= 4 ="1%+# $%R$?""CY N#,)C% $0% <#,)-0$%#=%#$ $0)#C%+& "7 4 ,4$%+ 4-%S 0% 1"%& #"$ ?%-)# H)$0 )#1)()1.4,& )# 4 W0;6"$0%$)24, &$4$% "7 #4$.+%XS ?.$ +4$0%+ H)$0 $0% +%4,)$; "7 &"2)%$;' 0.=4# ?%)#-& )# 4# 4&&"2)4$)"# H)$0".$ H0)20 $0%; 2".,1 #"$ &.+()(%Y /0% 6",)& %R)&$& ?; #4$.+% 4#1 )$ )& 6+)"+ $" $0% )#1)()1.4, Y Y Y #"$ ?%)#&%,7:&.77)2)%#$ H0%# $0%; 4+% )&",4$%1S 4,, )#1)()1.4,& 4+% &" =4#; 64+$& 4,, %e.4,,; 1%6%#1)#- "# $0% H0",% _H0)20 4,"#% 24# ?+)#-

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8QO

8QP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

>+)&$"$,% $0%# %&$4?,)&0%& $0% %$0)24, .#)e.%#%&& "7 0.=4#& 4& "66"&%1 $" "$0%+ -+".6 4#)=4,&Y M$ )& $0% 6%2.,)4+)$; "7 =4#S )# 2"=64+)&"# H)$0 $0% +%&$ "7 $0% 4#)=4, H"+,1S $04$ 0% 4,"#% 6"&&%&&%& 4 6%+2%6$)"# "7 -""1 4#1 %(),S "7 $0% b.&$ 4#1 $0% .#b.&$S 4#1 "7 "$0%+ &)=),4+ e.4,)$)%&a 4#1 )$ )& 4&&"2)4$)"# )# _4 2"=="# 6%+2%6$)"# "7` $0%&% $0)#-& H0)20 =4C% 4 74=),; 4#1 4 6",)&Y 34#S H0%# 6%+7%2$%1S )& $0% ?%&$ "7 4#)=4,&a ?.$ )7 0% ?% )&",4$%1 7+"= ,4H 4#1 b.&$)2% 0% )& $0% H"+&$ "7 4,,YPP >+)&$"$,% 6,.#-%& 1)+%2$,; )#$" $0% 1%?4$% $04$ H4& +4-)#- )# 0)& 14;' W/0% #%R$ &.?b%2$ 7"+ 2"#&)1%+4$)"# )& 6+"6%+$;Y E04$ )& $0% 6+"6%+ &;&$%= "7 6+"6%+$; 7"+ 2)$)\%#& H0" 4+% $" ,)(% .#1%+ 4# )1%4, 2"#&$)$.: $)"#V M& )$ 4 &;&$%= "7 2"==.#)&=S "+ "#% "7 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$;VX >+)&$"$,% $0%# &$4$%& .#%e.)("24,,;' W!"==.#)&= 24##"$ +%=%1; %(),& H0)20 &6+)#- 7+"= $0% 1%7%2$& "7 0.=4# #4$.+%' )$ )& 4,&" ?4&%1 "# 4 74,&% 2"#2%6$)"# "7 .#)$;S 4#1 #%-,%2$& $0% $+.% .#)$; H0)20 2"=%& 7+"= %1.24$)"#a 7)#4,,;S )$ )& 2"#$+41)2$%1 ?; %R6%+)%#2% Y Y Y 4#1 $0% &;&$%= "7 -"(%+#=%#$ H0)20 0% m*,4$"n 2"##%2$& H)$0 0)& &20%=% )& $"" 4?&",.$% 4#1 )& ,)C%,; $" 24.&% 1)&2"#$%#$YXPQ >+)&$"$,% $0%# 2+)$)2)\%& *,4$"X& )1%4 "7 2"==.#)&= 7.+$0%+S 4#1 $0% 2+)$e.% +%41& 4& )7 )$ H%+% H+)$$%# ;%&$%+14;' B%-)&,4$)"# &.20 4& *,4$" 6+"6"&%& =4; 466%4+ $" H%4+ 4# 4$$+42$)(% 742% 4#1 $" 4+-.% ?%#%(",%#2%Y /0% ?%4+%+ +%()%H& )$ -,41,;S $0)#C)#$04$ %(%+;?"1; H),, 7%%, $"H4+1& %(%+;?"1; %,&% &"=% =4+(%,".& &%#&% "7 7+4$%+#)$; ^ 4,, $0% ="+% 4& $0% %(),& #"H %R)&$)#- .#1%+ "+1)#4+; 7"+=& "7 -"(%+#=%#$ _,4H&.)$& 4?".$ 2"#$+42$&S 2"#()2$)"#& 7"+ 6%+b.+; 4#1 "?&%e.)".& 7,4$$%+)%& "7 $0% +)20` 4+% 1%(".+%1 4& 1.% $" $0% 4?&%#2% "7 2"==.#)&=Y /0%; 4,, 4+)&% 7+"= $0% H)2C%1#%&& "7 0.=4# #4$.+%YPJ >+)&$"$,% )& H4+#)#- $0% .$"6)4# $0)#C%+ $04$ $0% %&$4?,)&0=%#$ "7 2"==.#)&= H),, #"$ &.11%#,; +%="(% 4,, "7 $0% ),,& "7 &"2)%$;Y 9"H%(%+S 0% -"%& =.20 7.+$0%+ )# 0)& 2+)$)e.% "7 2"==.#4, 6+"6%+$;S 7"+ 0% 4&&%+$& $04$ #"$ "#,; H),, $0% ),,& "7 =4#C)#1 #"$ &.11%#,; 1)&466%4+S

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

4?".$ &%,7:&.77)2)%#2;`Y /0% =4# H0" )& )&",4$%1 ^ H0" )& .#4?,% $" &04+% )# $0% ?%#%7)$& "7 6",)$)24, 4&&"2)4$)"#S "+ 04& #" #%%1 $" &04+% ?%24.&% 0% )& 4,+%41; &%,7:&.77)2)%#$ ^ )& #" 64+$ "7 $0% 6",)&S 4#1 =.&$ $0%+%7"+% ?% %)$0%+ 4 ?%4&$ "+ 4 -"1YPO

?.$ 2%+$4)# 6"&)$)(% +%&.,$& "7 6+)(4$% "H#%+&0)6 H".,1 4,&" ?% ,"&$' W>#"$0%+ 2"#&)1%+4$)"# =.&$ 4,&" ?% 6+%&&%1Y d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` )& 4 7%%,)#- )=6,4#$%1 ?; #4$.+%S 4#1 #"$ 4 =%+% +4#1"= )=6.,&%XYQT >+)&$"$,% $0%# -"%& "# $" ".$,)#% 0)& 6,4# 7"+ $0% ?%&$ 7"+= "7 6+"6%+$; 0",1)#- 4#1 6+"6%+$; .&% _)# 2"#$+41)&$)#2$)"# $" *,4$" 4#1 *04,%.& 4#1 "$0%+& H0" 041 ?%%# &.--%&$)#- 2"==.#)&$)2 6,4#&`Y U 272*#- &1 $%+,.*# $%&$#%*7 8+*" $(;/+) (2# >+)&$"$,% 6+"6"&%1 4 &;&$%= "7 6+"6%+$; )# H0)20 W"H#%+&0)6 )& 6+)(4$% 4#1 .&% )& 2"=="#XYQ8 9% 4+-.%& ?+),,)4#$,; 7"+ 4 &;&$%= "7 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$;S H0)20 $0+".-0 6+"6%+ 2#.%2 %-9 37&,%2 0"#33<"# )& 6.$ $" 6.?,)2 .&%Y 9)& 4+-.=%#$ 6+"2%%1& )# $0)& =4##%+S 4#1 6+"()1%& .& H)$0 4 +%=4+C4?,; 2"#$%=6"+4+; &%$ "7 -.)1%,)#%& 4#1 ?4&)2 6+)#2)6,%&' /0% 6+%&%#$ &;&$%= _"7 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$;` H".,1 ?% 74+ 6+%7%+4?,%S )7 )$ H%+% 41"+#%1 ?; 2.&$"=& _)# $0% &"2)4, &60%+%` 4#1 ?; %#42$=%#$& "7 6+"6%+ ,4H& _)# $0% 6",)$)24,`Y M$ H".,1 6"&&%&& $0% 41(4#$4-%& "7 ?"$0 &;&$%=&S 4#1 H".,1 &74A,-# 1(# 4#",13 7$ % 3)31#4 7$ &744<-,1) 7$ 0"70#"1) ;,1( 1(73# 7$ 1(# 3)31#4 7$ 0",>%1# 0"70#"1)Y _M$ H".,1 ?% $0% )1%4,`a $7" 0"70#"1) 7<.(1 17 A# .#-#"%22) %-9 ,- 1(# 4%,- 0",>%1#B A<1 &7447- ,- 7-# "#30#&1 [,a#a ,- <3#\a a a a 81 ,3 &2#%" a a a 1(%1 1(# A#11#" 3)31#4 ,3 1(%1 <-9#" ;(,&( 0"70#"1) ,3 0",>%1#2) 7;-#9 A<1 ,3 0<1 17 &7447- <3#a 4#1 1(# $<-&1,7- 0"70#" 17 1(# 2#.,32%17" ,3 17 4%I# 4#- 37 9,3073#9 1(%1 1(#) ;,22 1"#%1 0"70#"1) ,- 1(,3 ;%)YQA M# $0)& 4++4#-%=%#$S >+)&$"$,% )& 4?,% $" .$),)\% $0% &$+%#-$0 "7 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; _)Y%Y $04$ )$ H),, ?% 1%(%,"6%1 $" )$& .$="&$ 4& )7 )$ H%+% 64+$ "7 "#%&%,7` ?.$ $" ="1)7; )$& H%4C#%&& _)Y%Y $04$ $0% 6+)(4$% "H#%+& H".,1 .&% $0%)+ 6+"6%+$; 7"+ $0%)+ "H# &%,7)&0 %#1&`Y G" 2"%+2)"# "+ 2"#7)&24$)"# )& 4,,"H4?,% )# >+)&$"$,%X& &20%=4 "7 W6.?,)2 .&%XS ?.$ +4$0%+ $0% 6"H%+ "7 $0% ,%-)&,4$"+& _4& 4$$420%1 $" 4

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8QQ

8QJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

=)11,%:2,4&& =4b"+)$;` 4#1 4 6+"6%+ &;&$%= "7 %1.24$)"# 4#1 &"2)4,)\4: $)"# H".,1 6+%&&.+% $0% +)20 4#1 =)11,)#- 6+"6%+$;:"H#%+& $"H4+1 2"#$+)?.$)#- $" $0% 2"=="# -""1Y

>+)&$"$,% ?%,)%(%1 $04$ %R$+%=%& "7 H%4,$0 1%&$4?),)\% &"2)%$; 4#1 ,%41 $" 6",)$)24, 2"#7,)2$ 4#1 ()",%#$ 2+)=%Y 9"H%(%+S 0% 1)1 #"$ ?%,)%(% $04$ $0% 2"==.#)&$ 6+"-+4=& 7"+ %,)=)#4$)#- $0%&% H%4,$0 1)77%+%#$)4,& H%+% ()4?,% "+ 1%&)+4?,%Y 9% &".-0$S $0%+%7"+%S $" 2+%4$% 4 6+42$)24, 6+"-+4= 7"+ $0% 2"#$4)#=%#$ "7 $0% 2"#7,)2$ %#-%#1%+%1 ?; %R$+%=% H%4,$0 1)77%+%#$)4,&Y /0% 6+"-+4= 2%#$%+& "#' _8` $0% %R64#&)"# "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&a _A` $0% 4?&"+6$)"# "7 $0% 6""+ _&" $04$ $0%; ?%2"=% 64+$ "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&& )# 6",)$)24, 4& H%,, 4& )# %2"#"=)2 42$)()$;`a 4#1 _D` $0% ,%-4,S &"2)4,S 4#1 %1.24$)"#4, 6%+&.4&)"# "7 $0% +)20 $" &04+% $0%)+ H%4,$0 H)$0 $0% 6""+ 4#1 $0% =)11,% 2,4&&Y M# 4,, &$4$%& $0%+% =4; ?% 1)&$)#-.)&0%1 $0+%% 64+$&S "+ 2,4&&%&S "7 $0% 2)$)\%# ?"1;' $0% (%+; +)20S $0% (%+; 6""+ 4#1 $0% =)11,% 2,4&& H0)20 7"+=& $0% =%4#Y ?#- ;(7 %"# ,- 1(,3 [4,992#\ &7-9,1,7- %"# 1(# 4731 "#%9) 17 2,31#- 17 "#%37-Y /0"&% H0" ?%,"#- $" %)$0%+ %R$+%=% ^ $0% "(%+:04#1&"=%S $0% "(%+:&$+"#-S $0% "(%+:#"?,%S $0% "(%+:H%4,$0;a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` %-9 1(# 4,992# &2%33B 47"# 1(%- %-) 71(#"B (%3 1(,3 37"1 7$ &74073,1,7-YQD M$ )& $0%+%7"+% "7 $0% -+%4$%&$ ?,%&&)#-& 7"+ 4 &$4$% $04$ )$& =%=?%+& &0".,1 6"&&%&& 4 479#"%1# %-9 %9#_<%1# 0"70#"1)Y E0%+% &"=% 04(% -+%4$ 6"&&%&&)"#&S 4#1 "$0%+& 04(% #"$0)#- 4$ 4,,S $0% +%&.,$ )& %)$0%+ 4# %R$+%=% 1%="2+42; "+ 4# .#=)R%1 ",)-4+20;a "+ )$ =4; %(%# ?% ^ 1)+%2$,;S 4#1 4& 4 +%42$)"# 4-4)#&$ ?"$0 $0%&% %R$+%=%& ^ 4 $;+4##;Y /;+4##; )& 4 7"+= "7 -"(%+#=%#$ H0)20 =4; -+"H ".$ "7 $0% 0%41)%&$ $;6% "7 1%="2+42;S "+ ".$ "7 ",)-4+20;a ?.$ )& =.20 ,%&& ,)C%,; $" -+"H ".$ "7 2"#&$)$.$)"#& "7 $0% =)11,% "+1%+YQI

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

U%+2*&*/#F2 *"#&%7 &1 *"# -.9&%+*7 -+''/# )/.220 2*.;/# '#-&)%.)7 8+*" $%.)*+)./ #V(./+*7

U"+ >+)&$"$,%S 4 &"2)%$; 1"=)#4$%1 ?; $0% +)20 "+ $0% 6""+ H".,1 ?%2"=% .#1%="2+4$)2S $%#1)#- $"H4+1 ",)-4+20;S 1%="2+42;:"7:$0%: 6""+S "+ $;+4##;Y > ,4+-% =)11,% 2,4&&S 0"H%(%+S &%+(%& $" &$4?),)\% $0% 1%="2+42;S 2+%4$)#- 4# 4+%#4 "7 %2"#"=)2 2"=6+"=)&% ?%$H%%# $0% +)20 4#1 $0% 6""+S 4#1 4# 4&&%=?,; "7 6",)$)24, 2"=6+"=)&% )# H0)20 +%4&"# 4#1 ,4H &.6%+&%1% $0% 64&&)"#& _$04$ 4+% )#7,4=%1 ?; 1)77%+%#2%& )# H%4,$0 4#1 &$4$.&`Y >+)&$"$,% &$4$%& )$ $0)& H4;' /0% +%4&"# H0; 1%="2+42)%& 4+% -%#%+4,,; ="+% &%2.+% 4#1 ="+% 6%+=4#%#$ $04# ",)-4+20)%& )& $0% 204+42$%+ "7 $0%)+ =)11,% 2,4&&S H0)20 )& ="+% #.=%+".& 4#1 )& %227;#9 % 2%".#" 3(%"# ,- 1(# .7>#"-4#-1B 1(%- ,1 ,3 ,- 72,.%"&(,#3a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a 4#1 $0% 6%"6,% )# $0% 42$ "7 $4C)#- 4&C 7"+ $0% &4=% 4-4)#Y /" 0%,6 $0% 6""+ )# $0)& H4; )& $" 7),, 4 ,%4C; b4+ Y Y Y ;%$ )$ )& $0% 1.$; "7 4 -%#.)#% 1%="2+4$ $" &%% $" )$ $04$ $0% =4&&%& 4+% #"$ %R2%&&)(%,; 6""+YQQ !7>#"1) ,3 1(# &%<3# 7$ 1(# 9#$#&13 7$ 9#47&"%&)Y /0)& )& $0% +%4&"# H0; =%4&.+%& &0".,1 ?% $4C%# $" %#&.+% 4 6%+=4#%#$ ,%(%, "7 6+"&6%+)$;Y /0)& )& )# $0% )#$%+%&$ "7 4,, 2,4&&%&S )#2,.1)#- $0% 6+"&6%+".& $0%=: &%,(%&a 4#1 $0%+%7"+%S $0% 6+"6%+ 6",)2; )& $" 422.=.,4$% 4#; &.+6,.& +%(%#.% )# 4 7.#1S 4#1 $0%# $" 1)&$+)?.$% $0)& 7.#1 )# ?,"2C -+4#$& $" $0% 6""+Y /0% )1%4, =%$0"1 "7 1)&$+)?.$)"#S )7 4 &.77)2)%#$ 7.#1 24# ?%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8QL

8JT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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` H".,1 ?% 74+ 6+%7%+4?,%S )7 )$ H%+% 41"+#%1 ?; 2.&$"=& _)# $0% &"2)4, &60%+%` 4#1 ?; %#42$=%#$ "7 6+"6%+ ,4H& _)# $0% 6",)$)24,`Y M$ H".,1 6"&&%&& $0% 41(4#$4-% "7 ?"$0 &;&$%=&S 4#1 H".,1 &74A,-# 1(# 4#",13 7$ % 3)31#4 7$ &744<-,1) 7$ 0"70#"1) ;,1( 1(73# 7$ 1(# 3)31#4 7$ 0",>%1# 0"70#"1)Y _M$ H".,1 ?% $0% )1%4,`a 7"+ 0"70#"1) 7<.(1 17 A# .#-#"%22) %-9 ,- 1(# 4%,- 0",>%1#B A<1 &7447- ,- 7-# "#30#&1 [,a#a ,- <3#\Y Y Y Y 81 ,3 &2#%" Y Y Y 1(%1 1(# A#11#" 3)31#4 ,3 1(%1 <-9#" ;(,&( 0"70#"1) ,3 0",>%1#2) 7;-#9 A<1 ,3 0<1 17 &7447- <3#a 4#1 1(# $<-&1,7- 0"70#" 17 1(# 2#.,32%17" ,3 17 4%I# 4#- 37 9,3073#9 1(%1 1(#) ;,22 1"#%1 0"70#"1) ,- 1(,3 ;%)YJT C&/+)+#2 1&% *"# #B$.32+&3 &1 *"# -+''/# )/.22 >+)&$"$,% )& 2,%4+ H0%# 0% &.--%&$& $04$ 6",)2)%& &0".,1 ?% %&$4?,)&0%1 $04$ %#&.+%' _8` $0% #.=?%+& "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&& )#2+%4&% _$0)& )#2,.1%&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

422.=.,4$%1S )& $" =4C% &.20 -+4#$& &.77)2)%#$ 7"+ $0% 6.+204&% "7 4 6,"$ "7 ,4#1' 74),)#- $04$ $0%; &0".,1 ?% ,4+-% %#".-0 17 31%"1 4#- ,&744#"&# 7" %.",&<21<"#YQJ

'() E"%-3$#" !%)4#-13 %"# 6#!%") 8J8

M$ )& 2,%4+ 7+"= ".+ 4+-.=%#$S 7)+&$S $04$ $0% ?%&$ 7"+= "7 6",)$)24, &"2)%$; )& "#% H0%+% 6"H%+ )& (%&$%1 )# $0% =)11,% 2,4&&S 4#1 &%2"#1,;S $04$ -""1 -"(%+#=%#$ )& 4$$4)#4?,% )# $0"&% &$4$%& H0%+% $0%+% )& 4 ,4+-% =)11,% 2,4&&Y Y Y Y M$ )& $0%+%7"+% "7 $0% -+%4$%&$ "7 ?,%&&)#-& 7"+ 4 &$4$% $04$ )$& =%=?%+& &0".,1 6"&&%&& 4 ="1%+4$% 4#1 41%e.4$% 6+"6%+$;YJ8 /0.&S 6",)2)%& 7"+ $0% %R64#&)"#S 6+"&6%+)$; 4#1 6",)$)24, %=6"H%+: =%#$ "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&& H".,1S 7"+ >+)&$"$,%S ?%2"=% $0% 4+20)$%2$"#)2 6",)2)%& 7"+ $0% 2+%4$)"# "7 4 &$4?,%S ,4H7., 1%="2+42; H)$0 $0% -+%4$%&$ 6+42$)24, 4=".#$ "7 %e.4,)$;Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

$0% .6-+41)#- "7 $0% 6""+ $" =)11,% 2,4&& %2"#"=)2S 6",)$)24, 4#1 %1.24$)"#4, &$4#14+1&`a _A` $0% H%4,$0 4#1 6+"6%+$; "7 $0% =)11,% 2,4&& ?% 41%e.4$% 4#1 &%2.+%a 4#1 _D` $04$ $0% =)11,% 2,4&& 6,4; 4 =4b"+)$; +",% )# $0% ,%-)&,4$.+% 4#1 ,4H 2".+$&Y

8T

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

!"# $&2+*+,# .2$#)*2 &1 1%##5-.%6#* ).$+*./+2- &3 *"# -&%./ 1+;#% &1 2&)+#*7 U+%% =4+C%$ 246)$4,)&= 04& ?%%# ,)#C%1 H)$0' _8` ,4H ^ $04$ )&S +4$)"#4, ,%-4, 4.$0"+)$;8 4#1 +4$)"#4, &2)%#$)7)2 _,4H7.,` $0%"+)%& "7 $0% .#)(%+&%a _A` 1%="2+42; ^ "+ -"(%+#=%#$ ?; 4,, $0% 6%"6,% H)$0 "6%#S +4$)"#4, 1%?4$% "7 6.?,)2 6",)2)%&a _D` %2"#"=)2 "66"+$.#)$; 4#1 $0% 6"&&)?),)$; "7 .6H4+1 ="?),)$; H)$0 #" 24&$% "+ 2,4&& ,)=)$4$)"#&a 4#1 _I` )#1)()1.: 4,)&=S H0)20 )# )$& ="&$ 6+"7".#1 7"+= %#-%#1%+& $0% 6"&&)?),)$; "7 W&%,7: 42$.4,)\4$)"#XA 7"+ %(%+;"#%Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ $0%&% 6"&)$)(% 4&6%2$& "7 7+%% =4+C%$ 246)$4,)&=Y =%&- )&3*%.)* /.8 *& )&32*+*(*+&3./ /.8 .3' %.*+&3./5/#4./ .(*"&%+*7 !46)$4,)&=S 4& 4# %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= ^ H0%$0%+ $+41%:246)$4,)&=S )#1.&: $+)4, 246)$4,)&= "+ 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&= ^ 24++)%& H)$0)# )$& 8JA

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/0% U+%% 34+C%$ 4#1 3"+4,)$;

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f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8JD

f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a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b"+)$; +.,%Y f+4$"+)24, 204+)&=4 H".,1S "7 2".+&%S 6,4; 4# )=6"+$4#$ +",%Y ].$ $0% )=6"+$4#$ 6")#$ )& $04$ $0% 6+"2%&& "7 1%2)&)"#:=4C)#- H".,1 ?% 2"=6,%$%,; .#2"#&$+4)#%1 ?; 4#;$0)#-S &4(% $0% e.%&$)"# 4$ 04#1 4#1 $0% =4b"+)$; "6)#)"# "7 $0% ="=%#$Y 9"H%(%+S .#1%+ W-"(%+#=%#$ ?; ,4HXS 2"#&$)$.$)"#4,,; 6+%%R)&$)#,4H& &.--%&$ -.)1%,)#%& 4#1 )=6"&% 2"#&$+4)#$& .6"# $0% 1%2)&)"#:=4C: )#- 6+"2%&& "7 $0% ="=%#$Y F%2)&)"#:=4C)#- 4#1 1%?4$% 4+% #"$ ,%7$ $"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8JI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b%2$ $" ()",%#$ 4#1 2"#$+41)2$"+; &0)7$& )# 6",)2; ,)#C%1 $" )++4$)"#4, 6+"2%&&%& &.20 4& 2+"H1 ?%04()"+S 204+)&=4$)2 "+4$"+;S 1%=4-"-)2 =4#)6.,4$)"#S 4#1 2+)&)& 1%2)&)"#:=4C)#-Y /0% &$4?),)$; "7 $0% 6.+% 1%="2+42; "7 ?4#1& 4#1 $+)?%& H4& %#&.+%1 ?; $0% )#$)=42; "7 $0% &=4,, -+".6 4#1 $0% %R$%#1%1 74=),;S 4#1 +%)#7"+2%1 ?; $0% &,"H 6+"2%&& "7 204#-% 4#1 $0% +%,)-)".&,; ,%-)$)=4$%1S )&",4$%1S 1%%6,; )#-+4)#%1 #"+=4$)(% _2.&$"=4+;`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8JO

B4H Y Y Y $+4)#& $0% 0",1%+& "7 "77)2% %R6+%&&,; )# )$& "H# &6)+)$S 4#1 $0%# &%$& $0%= $" 1%2)1% 4#1 &%$$,% $0"&% +%&)1.4+; )&&.%& H0)20 )$ 24##"$ +%-.,4$%S W4& b.&$,; 4& )# $0%= ,)%&YX M$ 4,&" 4,,"H& $0%= $" )#$+"1.2% 4#; )=6+"(%=%#$& H0)20 =4; &%%= $" $0%=S 4& $0% +%&.,$ "7 %R6%+): %#2%S $" ?% ?%$$%+ $04# $0% %R)&$)#- ,4H&Y 9% H0" 2"==4#1& $04$ ,4H &0".,1 +.,% =4; $0.& ?% +%-4+1%1 4& 2"==4#1)#- $04$ @"1 4#1 +%4&"# 4,"#% &0".,1 +.,%a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b.1-%1 ?; 4 &=4,,S +4#1"=,; 20"&%# W4&&%=?,;X "7 2)$)\%#&Y /0% ,4H 2".+$& H%+% &=4,, 1%="2+4$)2 1%?4$)#- 2".#2),& &%$ .6 $" 1%$%+=)#% -.),$S )##"2%#2%S 4#1 6"&&)?,% 6.#)&0=%#$ 7"+ 6%+&"#4, 24&%& "7 +.,% ?+%4C)#-Y /0% ,4H 2".+$& "7 $0% $+41)#- 2)$)%& "7 @+%%2% H%+% $0% 7)+&$ )# 0)&$"+; $" ?% &%64+4$%1 7+"= 2,4# 4#1 +%,)-)"# _4#1 7+"= $0% C)#-,;:?.+%4.2+4$)2 &$4$%`Y G%)$0%+ 2,4# %,1%+&S #"+ 6+)%&$0""1&S #"+ C)#-S #"+ C)#-,;:?.+%4.: 2+4$)2 "77)2)4,& 6+%&)1%1 4$ $0% 2".+$&Y d.+)%& "7 2)$)\%#&S 20"&%# ?; ,"$S &%+(%1 $%=6"+4+),; 4#1 64&&%1 b.1-%=%#$ )# 24&%& ?+".-0$ ?%7"+% $0%=Y8L 5)#2% #%)$0%+ 2,4# %,1%+& #"+ 6+)%&$& #"+ C)#-,;:?.+%4.2+4$& 4+-.%1 $0% 24&%&S &%2.,4+ &6%2)4,)&$&S $+4)#%1 )# $0% #.4#2%& "7 $0% #%H &%2.,4+ 2)()2 ,4H 4#1 &C),,%1 4$ "+4$"+)24, 6%+&.4&)"#S ?%24=% $0% 64)1 41("24$%& "7 $0% 2"#$%&$)#- 64+$)%&Y B4H;%+& H%+% #"$ 4& ;%$ %&$4?,)&0%1 4& 7.,,:$)=% 6+"7%&&)"#4,&Y K4$0%+S $0%; H%+% 1+4H# 7+"= 4="#- $0% H%4,$0)%+ 2)$)\%#& H0" 041 $0% ,%)&.+% $)=% 4#1 $0% ="#%; $" &$.1; $0% ,4HS 6+42$)2% "+4$"+; 4#1 466%4+ 4$ $0% 2".+$&Y /0% ,4H 2".+$& "7 @+%%2%S 4#1 ,4$%+S K"=%S 4#1 $0% &%2.,4+ ,4H;%+& H%+% .#)e.% )#&$)$.$)"#& 4#1 +",%& #"$ 6+%%R)&$)#- )# 6+)=)$)(% "+ $+41): $)"#4, 4.$0"+)$; &;&$%=&Y /+41)$)"#4, 2,4#:0%41& 4#1 6+)%&$& ()&)$)#@+%%2% _"+ ,4$%+S "?&%+()#- $0% @+%%C& "+ K"=4#& 47$%+ 2"#e.%&$& ?; $0%=` H%+% &0"2C%1 4#1 4664,,%1 ?; $0% &%2.,4+ ,4H 2".+$& H0%+%)# "+4$"+)24, W7,)=:7,4=X H4& %#2".+4-%1 4#1 W+.1%X 0%4$%1 1%?4$%& H%+% 1%=4#1%1Y /0% 2".+$& "7 $0% %,1%+&S 6+)%&$& 4#1 C)#-& H%+% &",%=# 6,42%& 2"=64+%1 $" $0% @+%%C 4#1 K"=4# 2".+$& "7 ,4HYAT

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8JP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

G"HS )$ &0".,1 ?% =%#$)"#%1 $04$ ?4#1 4#1 $+)?4, 6%"6,%& 4+-.%1 ()",%#$,; H0%# b.1-)#- 24&%& "7 ?+"C%# #"+=&YA8 9"H%(%+S 4+-.)#%="$)"#4,,; )& e.)$% 1)77%+%#$ 7+"= 4+-.)#- 2,%(%+,; 4#1 =4C)#- 1%: ?4$%+&X 6")#$&Y /0% &%2.,4+ 1%?4$)#- &$;,% 4#1 $0% )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\4$)"# "7 64)1 41("24$%& H4& 4 74+ 2+; 7+"= $0% 6%+&"#4,)\%1 74=),)4, 1%?4$%& "7 ?4#1& 4#1 $+)?%&Y !".+$& "7 &%2.,4+ ,4H H)$0 2)$)\%# b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`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e.4, $" $04$ "7 =%# 4#1 &0".,1 $0%+%7"+% ?% )#2,.1%1 4="#- $0% W60),"&"60%+:-.4+1)4#&X "7 &$4$%&VAD G4$.+4, ,4H 60),"&"60; 24++)%& H)$0 )$ $0% )1%4 "7 )#4,)%#4?,% +)-0$&S $0".-0 H)$0)# 4 &"2)%$; H)$0 4 &,4(% %2"#"=; 4#1 =4,% H4++)"+ 2;#"&.+% $0)& )1%4 2".,1 #"$ -4)# 7.,, 422%6$4#2%Y f7 2".+&%S 1.+)#$0% U+%#20 4#1 52"$$)&0 <#,)-0$%#=%#$S $0% )1%4 "7 )#4,)%#4?,% +)-0$& H".,1 -4)# -+".#1Y >#1 )# $0% >=%+)24# F%2,4+4$)"# "7 M#1%6%#1%#2% 4#1 !"#&$)$.$)"# )$ H".,1 ?%2"=% 2%#$+4,Y <(%# $0".-0 #4$.+4, ,4H 60),"&"60; #%(%+ -4)#%1 7.,, ,%-)$)=4$)"# )# @+%%2%S )$& 422%6$4#2% 4& 4 2"#2%6$)"# "7 #4$.+% 1)1 -4)# ,%-)$)=42;Y /0)& 2"#2%6$)"# "7 #4$.+% )& 1+4=4$)24,,; 1)77%+%#$ 7+"= $04$ %=%+-)#-

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8JQ

7+"= &"2)%$)%& H0%+%)# $+41)$)"#4, 4.$0"+)$; H4& 422%6$%1Y M# $0% H"+,1: ()%H "7 $+41)$)"#4, 4.$0"+)$;S #4$.+% )& 6"+$+4;%1 4& 4 &;&$%= "7 0)%+: 4+20)24, 6"H%+& .#%e.4,,; 4++4#-%1Y G4$.+% &.--%&$& 1"=)#4$)"#S #"$ 7+%%1"= ^ )# &.20 4 H"+,1:()%HS 0.=4# b.&$)2% )& 7".#1 "#,; 47$%+ 1%4$0YAI U.+$0%+S $0% %e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b%2$%1 $" ,"-)24, $0%"+)\)#- )# $%+=& "7 +4$)"#4, 24.&%&Y U"+ $0% 7)+&$ $)=%S #"#:=;&$)24,S #"#:=4-)24, 24.&4,)$; H4& &;&$%=4$)24,,; )=6.$%1 $" #4$.+4, %(%#$&Y /0%&% W+4$)"#4, 24.&%&X H%+% &.?b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`Y *,4$" ?%,)%(%1 $04$ $+4)#)#- )# =4$0%=4$)2& H4& %&&%#$)4, $" 0)-0%+ 6+"2%&&%& "7 $0)#C)#-S H0),% *;$04-"+4& ?%,)%(%1 $04$ $0% C%;

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8JJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b.-4$)"# $" $0% 1)()#% C)#-,; &$4$% 4#1 7"&$%+%1 W74,&% )1%","-)%&XAL "7 +";4, ?,""1 4#1 1)()#% %=?"1)=%#$ )# $0% 6%+&"# "7 $0% C)#- 4#1 0)-0 6+)%&$%&&YDT

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8JL

f#2% $0% 6+)%&$& &04+%1 $0%)+ C#"H,%1-% H)$0 $0% )#e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b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b.-4$)"#Y /0.&S $0% +4$)"#4,:=)#1%1S ="1%&$,; %1.24$%1 W2)$)\%#X %=%+-%1 )# $0% $+41)#2)$)%&S +%6,42)#- $0% &.6%+&$)$)".&S ),,)$%+4$% W&.?b%2$X "7 $0% -+%4$ %=6)+%&Y M# $0)&S $0% "+)-)#& "7 2)$;:&$4$% 1%="2+42; 4+% $" ?% 7".#1Y /0.2;1)1%&S $0+".-0 $0% H"+1& "7 *%+)2,%&S 6.$& )$ ?%&$' f.+ 2"#&$)$.$)"# )& 24,,%1 4 1%="2+42; ?%24.&% 6"H%+ )& )# $0% 04#1S #"$ "7 4 =)#"+)$;S ?.$ "7 $0% H0",% 6%"6,%Y E0%# )$ )& 4 e.%&$)"# "7 &%$$,)#- 6+)(4$% 1)&6.$%&S %(%+;"#% )& %e.4, ?%7"+% $0% ,4Ha H0%# )$ )& 4 e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b"+)$; ("$% "7 $0% 2)$)\%#&Y /0% (%+; 2"#2%6$ "7 $0% W&"2)4, 2"#$+42$XDO ?)#1)#- =%# $"-%$0%+ )# 4 6",)$)24, 4&&"2)4$)"#S 4& 1%(%,"6%1 ?; $0% <#,)-0$%#=%#$ 6",)$)24, $0%: "+)&$&S 04& )$& +""$& )# 7+%%:=4+C%$ 2"#$+42$ ,4HY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8LT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

/0.&S $" &.= .6S H0%+%(%+ =4+C%$ 2)$)%& %=%+-%1S 7+%% "7 $0% 1)()#% C)#-,;:?.+%4.2+4$)2 &$4$%S 1%="2+42; %=%+-%1 4& H%,,Y >#1 &" $0+".-0 $)=% 4#1 &642% 7+"= >$0%#& $" U,"+%#2% 4#1 7+"= >=&$%+14= $" ]%+-%#S 7+"= 94=?.+- $" G"(-"+"1S =4+C%$ 2)$)%& -%#%+4$%1 1%="2+4$)2 $%#: 1%#2)%&YDP M .&% $0% H"+1 W$%#1%#2)%&XS ?%24.&% ",)-4+20)%& "7 $0% +)20 H%+% b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e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8L8

8LA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

=)11,% 2,4&&S 4#1 $0% 6""+ 4+% -+%4$,; &.6%+)"+ )# #.=?%+S $+".?,% %#&.%&S 4#1 $0%; 4+% &6%%1),; +.)#%1YI8

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b4+S 7"+ $0% 6""+S )# $4C)#- )$S H),, &)=6,; 04(% $" 4&C 7"+ ="+%Y ].$S )7 =%# "7 H%4,$0 H)$0 -""1 &%#&% 4#1 )#$%#$)"#&S H),, -)(% $0% 6""+ &"=% ="1)2.= "7 6+"6%+$; 4#1 $%420 $0%= $0% &C),,& "7 4 $+41%S $0%# $0%; H),, ?% 0%,6: )#- $0% 6""+ )# 4 ="+% 2"#&$+.2$)(% =4##%+YID E% $4C% 7"+ -+4#$%1 $0% )1%4 "7 .6H4+1 ="?),)$;Y [%$ $0)& )1%4 H4& 6+"=.,-4$%1 "#,; H)$0 $0% 7+%%:=4+C%$ 2.,$.+% "7 $0% 1%="2+4$)\)#2)$)%&Y M# $0% -+%4$ %=6)+%&S .6H4+1 ="?),)$; H4& #"$ %#2".+4-%1 7"+ %(%+;?"1;Y [%&S )# <-;6$S ]4?;,"#S 4#1 !0)#4S 4 04#17., "7 ?+)-0$ ?";& 7+"= 4="#- $0% 6%4&4#$& 4#1 4+$)&4#& H".,1 ?% 20"&%# $0+".-0 =%+: )$"2+4$)2 %R4=)#4$)"#& $" ?%2"=% &2+)?%& 4#1 &$4$% "77)2)4,&Y >#1 ;%&S $0)& W=4#14+)#X &;&$%= 1)1 6+"()1% &"=% .6H4+1 ="?),)$;YII ].$ $0)& H4& "#,; 7"+ 4 7+42$)"# "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"#S H0),% $0% -+%4$ =4b"+)$; ,4#-.)&0%1 )# $0%)+ &.?b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

=%##5-.%6#* ).$+*./+2- .3' &$$&%*(3+*70 ($8.%' -&;+/+*7 #32"%+3#'

9"H%(%+S !"#7.2)4# ?%#%(",%#2% "77%+%1 #" 0"6%S #" 64$0 "7 ?%$$%+: =%#$ 7"+ $0% W2"=="# 6%"6,%XS H0" H%+% 4&&.=%1 $" ,42C =%+)$S %R2%6$ )# 04+1 H"+CY /0%+%7"+%S $0% %$0)2 "7 .6H4+1 ="?),)$; =.&$ ?% &%%# 4& 4 -)4#$ &$%6 )# 0.=4# 0)&$"+;S H0%+%)# $0% H"+$0 ^ $0% =%+)$ ^ "7 %(%+; )#1)()1.4, )& $4C%# 7"+ -+4#$%1Y /0)& %$0)2 "7 .6H4+1 ="?),)$; )& #"$ #4)(% ^ $04$ )&S )$ 1"%& #"$ )=6,; $04$ 4,, =%# 4#1 H"=%# 4+% %e.4,Y M$ &)=6,; 4&&%+$& $04$ %(%+;"#% ".-0$ $" 04(% $0% 204#2% $" 1%(%,"6 $0%)+ &C),,&S $0%)+ 24+%%+&S 4#1 $0%)+ ,)7%:&$;,%S $" $0% 7.,,%&$Y M7S 4& *%+)2,%& &4)1S $0% &04=% )& #"$ )# ?%)#- 6""+S ?.$ )# #"$ 1")#4#;$0)#- $" %&246% 7+"= 6"(%+$;S $0%# 0% )& 4&&%+$)#- e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d%H&S ?; 4&&%+$)#- $04$ 0.=4#& H%+% =41% )# @"1X& )=4-%S 041 4,+%41; $4C%# 4 -)4#$ &$%6 $"H4+1& $0% +%2"-#)$)"# "7 $0% H"+$0 "7 %(%+; )#1)()1.4,Y >& )$ )& H+)$$%# )# @%#%&)&' W>#1 @"1 =41% $0%=S =4,%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8LD

4#1 7%=4,%S 0% =41% $0%= )# 0)& )=4-%S =4,% 4#1 7%=4,%S 4#1 0% &4)1S )$ )& -""1S ?% 7+.)$7., 4#1 =.,$)6,;YXIJ /0% 2"#2%6$ "7 )#1)()1.4, H"+$0S $0".-0 1%(%,"6%1 )# d.14)&= 4#1 ?+".-0$ $" 7+.)$)"# H)$0 $0% 7+%%:=4+C%$ %2"#"=;S H4& -)(%# 4 1+4=4$)2 #%H %#04#2%=%#$ 4& 4 +%&.,$ "7 $0% *+"$%&$4#$ K%7"+=4$)"#Y U"+ )$ H4& *+"$%&$4#$)&= $04$ H".,1 7.,,; %#&0+)#% 4#1 ,%-)$)=4$% )#1)()1.4,)&=Y B.$0%+ )#&)&$%1 $04$ %(%+; )#1)()1.4, ^ =4,% 4#1 7%=4,% ^ 041 $0% +)-0$S #4;S $0% "?,)-4$)"#S $" )#$%+6+%$ &2+)6$.+% "# $0%)+ "H#YIL G" 6"6%S #" 6+)%&$ 2".,1 )#$%+6+%$ &2+)6$.+% 7"+ "#%Y f#% 041 $" )#$%+6+%$ &2+)6$.+% "#%&%,7Y f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d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b%2$Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8LI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

F%="2+42;S "+ &%,7:+.,% ?; 4,, $0% 6%"6,%S 1%=4#1& )#1)()1.4, 2)$)\%#&0b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b.&$ 4& 0.=4#& ?%)#- =41% W)# @"1X& )=4-%X H4& #%HY M$ H4& #%HS b.&$ 4& 0.=4#& ?%)#- 4?,% $" +4)&% $0%=&%,(%& ".$ "7 6"(%+$; H4& #%HS "+ $04$ )#1)()1.4,& 2".,1 )#$%+6+%$ $0% 0",; &2+)6$.+%& H4& #%HY 5" #"HS $0% ="1%+# )#1)()1.4, 04& $0% 6"&&)?),)$; 7"+ 6",)$)24, 7+%%: 1"=S +%,)-)".& 7+%%1"=S %2"#"=)2 &.22%&&S 4#1S 6&;20","-)24, &%,7: 42$.4,)\4$)"#Y >#1S $0)& )& H"#1%+7.,g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e.%&$ 7"+ 6&;20","-)24, &%,7:42$.4,)\4$)"#S 24# 1%-%#%+4

%$10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8LO

8LP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b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a 246)$4, )& 7"+ ?.&)#%&& )#(%&$=%#$a 4#; "$0%+ .&% "7 ="#%; )& H4&$%7.,a $0%+% )& #" &"2)4, .&% "7 ="#%;a ="#%; )& 6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$;a ="#%; )& 7"+ ?.&)#%&& %R64#&)"# 4#1 7"+ 6+)(4$% 74=),; #%%1&a %420 )#1)()1.4, )& +%&6"#&)?,% 7"+ 0)& "+ 0%+ 6+)(4$% #%%1&a ?; 2"=6%$)#- )# $0% =4+C%$S "#% -4)#& $0% 246)$4, 4#1 $0% )#2"=% $" 24+% 7"+ "#%&%,7Y /0% =4+C%$S )# &0"+$S ,%41& )#1)()1.4,& $"H4+1& 4# 4$$)$.1% "7 &%,7: +%,)4#2%Y /0)& &%,7:+%,)4#2% )& H"#1%+7.,S 4& ,"#- 4& $0% )#1)()1.4, &.2: 2%%1& H)$0)# $0% &;&$%=Y 9"H%(%+S )7 4# )#1)()1.4, 1"%& ,%&& H%,,S ;%$ )& H"+C)#- 4# %&&%#$)4, b"? H)$0)# $0% &;&$%=S $0% =4+C%$ =%#$4,)$; 6.&0%&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

)#$" 4 &%,7:2%#$%+%1 ,)7% &$;,%S H0%+%)# 24+)#- 7"+ "$0%+& )& 1%:(4,.%1Y 5)#2% 0)-0:$%20 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&= )& +%:%#7"+2)#- %R2%&&)(% )#1)()1.: 4,)&= -,"?4,,;S ,%$ .& ,""C 4$ $0% #%-4$)(% 4&6%2$& "7 $0)& #%H 7+%%:=4+C%$ &;&$%= "# $0% 2.,$.+% "7 $0% %=%+-)#- -,"?4, (),,4-%Y E% &04,, ?%-)# H)$0 $0% #%-4$)(% 4&6%2$& "7 W%R$+%=% )#1)()1.4,)&=XY

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e.4, "66"+$.#)$;S 4#1 $0+".-0 #" 74.,$ "7 $0%)+ "H#S $0%; =4; %#1 .6 .#%=6,";%1S "+ 64+$)4,,; %=6,";%1S "+ %=6,";%1 4$ 4 (%+; ,"H:64;: )#- b"?Y /0%+% H),, ?% ,"&%+& )# $0% 2"=6%$)$)(% =4+C%$Y >#1 H04$ H),, $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ 1" 7"+ $0"&% H0" 1" ,%&& H%,, "+ $0"&% H0" 1" #"$ &.22%%1V G"$0)#-Y /0% =4+C%$ &;&$%= 04& H)$0)# )$& "H# +.,%& #" =%204#)&= 7"+ 1%4,)#H)$0S "+ 24+)#- 7"+S $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$%Y /0% 246)$4,)&$ &;&$%= )& #"$ 4 24+)#- &;&$%=Y M$ )& 4 2"=6%$)$)(% &;&$%= -%#%+4$)#- H)##%+& 4#1 ,"&%+&S 4#1 "$0%+& H0" 1" =)11,)#- H%,,Y ].$ $0% 7+%%:=4+C%$ 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=)2 &;&$%= 1)1 #"$ %R)&$ 4,"#% )# )$& 2.,$.+4, =),)%.Y K%,)-)".&:%$0)24, #"+=& %R)&$%1 )# <.+"6% 4#1 $0% N5> $04$ 2".,1 04(% $%=6%+%1 $0% 04+&0 +%4,)$; "7 2"=6%$)$)(% 246)$4,: )&=Y 9"H%(%+S 0%+% H% =.&$ ,""C 4$ $0% ="#.=%#$4, %77%2$ "7 *+"$%&$: 4#$)&= ^ %&6%2)4,,; !4,()#)&$ 6.+)$4#)24, *+"$%&$4#$)&= ^ "# $0% %$0)2& $04$ %=%+-%1 H)$0 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&=Y U"+S H)$0 $0% W6.+)$4# %$0)2XS H% H),, ,%4(% *%+)2,%4# +4$)"#4,)$; 4#1 %#$%+ 4 +%4,= "7 &6)+)$.4, ="+4,)$; $04$ H),, +%)#7"+2% $0% )#1)()1.4,)&= "7 $0% =4+C%$ &;&$%=S ?.$ 1+)(% )$ )# 4 #"#:24+)#- 1)+%2$)"#Y K4$0%+ $04# 4=%,)"+4$)#- $0% 2",1#%&& "7 =4+C%$ 2"=6%$)$)"# H)$0 !0+)&$)4# 204+)$; 4#1 4 !0+)&$:,)C% C)#1#%&&S !4,()#)&$ 6.+)$4#)&= H".,1 2.+&% $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$% 7"+ 2"#&"+$)#- H)$0 $0% 1%(), 4#1 ,)()#- 4 ,)7% "7 ,)2%#$)".&#%&& 4#1 &,"$0Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ $0)& ="+% 2,"&%,;Y /0)& 4#4,;&)& )& 1%+)(%1 7+"= E%?%+X& $0%"+; "# $0% ,)#C ?%$H%%# W$0% 6.+)$4# %$0)2X 4#1 W$0% &6)+)$ "7 246)$4,)&=XYPA >./,+3+2* $(%+*.3 C%&*#2*.3*+2- .3' *"# 2*+4-.*+<.*+&3 &1 *"# $&&% E% 04(% 1)&2.&&%1 $0% 6"&)$)(% )#7,.%#2% "7 *+"$%&$4#$)&= "# $0% 1%(%,: "6=%#$ "7 )#1)()1.4,)&=Y /0%+% )& #" 1".?$ $04$ *+"$%&$4#$)&= +%)#7"+: 2%& )#1)()1.4,)&=S ,%#1)#- )$ 4 &42+%1 204+42$%+' %420 )#1)()1.4, 04& 4

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8LQ

6%+&"#4, 2"(%#4#$ H)$0 !0+)&$a %420 )#1)()1.4, 04& $0% 4.$0"+)$; H)$0)# 0)=: "+ 0%+&%,7 $" )#$%+6+%$ &2+)6$.+%a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f#,; "#% $0)#-' )#(%&$ )$ $" =4C% ="+% ="#%;Y U"+S ?; )#(%&$)#- )$S 0% =4C%& $0% ="#%; WH"+CX $" 2+%4$% ="+% ="#%;Y /0)&S 4& E%?%+ 6.$ )$S )& W$0% &6)+)$ "7 246)$4,)&=XY f#% )#(%&$& ="#%; $" =4C% ="+% ="#%;Y 3"#%; ?%2"=%& 4# %#1 )#

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

8LJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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q"+"4&$+)4#)&= ^ -"1 4#1 $0% 1%(), ^ $0% -"1 "7 -""1 4#1 $0% -"1 "7 %(),Y G"HS !4,()# 041 +%()(%1 >.-.&$)#%X& #"$)"# "7 6+%1%&$)#4$)"#S 4#1 4,"#- H)$0 )$ $0% 1.4,)&$)2 2"#2%6$)"# "7 -"1 4#1 $0% 1%(),Y ].$ !4,()#X& 6+%1%&$)#4$)"# $0%","-; H4& $"" 2"#7.&)#- 7"+ $0% +4$)"#4,:=)#1%1 ?.+: -0%+&Y E0" H".,1 -" $" 0%4(%#S H0" $" 0%,,V 9"H H".,1 ;". C#"HS 0"H H".,1 H04$ ;". 1)1 "# %4+$0 1%$%+=)#% ;".+ 74$%V f.+ %4+$0,; 42$)"#& 4<31 ?% ,)#C%1 H)$0 ".+ 47$%+:,)7% +%H4+1 "+ 6.#)&0=%#$Y f+ %,&%S H0; ?% -""1V /0% 6.+)$4# 2"#(%+$& 041 7".#1 $0% ,"-)24, 7,4H )# !4,()#X& $0%","-;S 4#1 $0%+%7"+%S $0%; 1%=4#1%1 4 W&)-#XS 4#1 $0%; 1%=4#1%1 $04$ %4+$0,; 42$)"#& ?% ,)#C%1 H)$0 0%4(%#,; +%H4+1& _"+ $0% 7)+%& "7 0%,,`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d%&.&X C)#1,; @"&6%, 42$)"#& 4+% #%-4$%1 "+ +%)#$%+6+%$%1Y d.14)2S M&4)40:+%)#7"+2%1S 1%=4#1& 7"+ 24+% "7 $0% 6""+S $0% H)1"H%1S $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) 8LL

)#7)+=S $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$%S 4+% +%b%2$%1S 4& 4+% $0% M&,4=)2 +%()(4,& "7 $0% d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b%2$)"# "7 $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$% 4#1 ,%&& &.22%&&7.,Y /0".-0 F)2C%#&X 52+""-%QT )& 04.#$%1 ?; ()&)"#& "7 !0+)&$)4# 204+)$;S )$ )& $0% 52+""-%:,)C% 42$)"#& "7 $0% !4,()#)&$& $04$ $;6)7)%1 $0% 246)$4,)&$ )#1.&$+)4, &;&$%= 4& )$ %=%+-%1 )#$" $0% $H%#$)%$0 2%#$.+;Y E0; )& WH%,74+%X &" +%(),%1 )# $0% N5>S 4#1 $0% W1",%X &" 1%#)-+4$%1 )# <#-,4#1V E0; 1"%& WH"+C74+%X +%&"#4$% &" H%,, H)$0 >=%+)24#&V E0; 1" ]+)$4)#& 4#1 >=%+)24#& %e.4$% WH%,74+%X H)$0 ,4\)#%&&S ,)2%#$)".&#%&&S .#H),,)#-#%&& $" H"+CV E0; 1" H% 04$% $0% 6""+V E0; 1)1 $0% ]+)$)&0 4+)&$"2+42; ?%-)# $" 2"#2%)(% "7 $0% ,"H%+ 2,4&&%& 4& ?%&$)4, 4#1 ?%;"#1 &4()#-V /0%&% 4$$)$.1%& 4+% ,)#C%1 $" $0% 6.+)$4# %$0)2Y /0%+%7"+%S $0% 2"=6%$)$)(% )#1)()1.4,)&= "7 $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ ?%24=% 4# )#1)()1.4,)&= H0)20 2%,%?+4$%1 $0% -"1,)#%&& "7 $0% &.22%&&7., +)20S 4#1 ,%-)$)=4$%1 $0% .#%e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ATT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) AT8

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c%?,%#QI H4& $0% 7)+&$ $" 1%&2+)?% 0"H 41(%+$)&)#- %#2".+4-%& .& $" ?.;Y /0)& )& -""1 7"+ $0% %2"#"=;S "7 2".+&%Y ].$S H0%# 41(%+$)&)#- ?%24=% 1+4=4$)24,,; 6%+(4&)(% )# 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%&S )$ ?%-4# $" "(%++)1% $0% 6.+)$4# ,)=)$4: $)"# "# ,.R.+; ,)()#- 4#1 6,%4&.+%:&%%C)#-Y >,+%41;S 7+"= $0% 8JLT& $" $0% 8LAT&S $0% 7)+&$ W-),1%1 4-%X "7 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ &6,%#1"+ %=%+-%1Y >-4)#S c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b4\\ =.&)2 4#1 H),1 14#2)#- %R6+%&&%1 H"=%#X& &%R.4, ,)?%+4$)"# ^ &;=?",)\%1 ?; $0% &0"+$%#%1 &C)+$& ^ 1+)#C)#- 64+$)%&S 4#1 4 -%#%+4, 1%2,)#% )# 6.+)$4#)24, #"+=& 4#1 (4,.%&Y E%?%+X& 6+%1)2: $)"# H4& 2"=)#- $+.%S 4#1 c%?,%#X& &4$)+)24, 1%&2+)6$)"#& =4C% $04$ %()1%#$Y 9"H%(%+S $0% -+%4$ 1%6+%&&)"# 4#1 $0% $H" H"+,1 H4+& )#$%+(%#%1 $" 04,$ $0% 6+"2%&& "7 )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,%& 4#1 $0% 1%2,)#% "7 6.+)$4#)&=Y E0%#S 0"H%(%+S $0% )#1.&$+)4, H"+,1 +%2"(%+%1 7+"= $0%&% $%++)?,% 0)&$"+)24, &0"2C&S $0% 6+"1.2$)(% 24642)$; "7 $0% )#1.&$+)4, =4+C%$ &;&$%=S 4#1 $0% )#(%#$)"# "7 $0% =4&& =%1)4 "7 2"==.#)24: $)"#&S H".,1 )#$%#&)7; $0% $+%#1 1+4=4$)24,,;Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>&-$#*+*+,# +3'+,+'(./+2- +3 .3 .4# &1 -&%./ -./.+2# .3' !"#$%&

/0% =4&& =%1)4 ^ H0)20 c%?,%# #%(%+ ,)(%1 $" &%% ^ %R64#1%1 $0% 41(%+$)&)#- ?,)$\ 4 $0".&4#17",1Y >#1S $0% =4&& =%1)4 ^ %&6%2)4,,; ="()%& 4#1 $%,%()&)"# ^ =4-#)7)%1 $0% ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% "7 $0% +)20 4#1 74=".&Y /0% %77%2$ "7 $0% )#$%#&)(% =4&&:=%1)4 41(%+$)&)#- 24=64)-#S 4#1 $0% 2"#&$4#$ ()%H)#- "7 4 14\\,)#- ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% H4& $" 6.&0 4&)1% $0% H0",% %$0)2 "7 W1%#)4, "7 $0% 6,%4&.+%& "7 $0% 7,%&0XS 4#1 $" +%6,42% )$ H)$0 4# %$0)2 "7 W$0% 7%$)&0 "7 2"=="1)$)%&XQP _?%;"#1 4#;$0)#- $04$ 34+R %(%+ %#()&)"#%1`S 4,"#- H)$0 4# %$0)2 "7 W)7 )$ 7%%,& -""1S 1" )$X _$0% ="$$" "7 $0% 8LPT& &%R 4#1 1+.- 2".#$%+:2.,$.+%`YQQ !"# /+1#52*7/# &1 *"# %+)" .3' 1.-&(2 1&% #,#%7&3# /0% ",1 *+"$%&$4#$ %$0)2S ?4&%1 "# 04+1 H"+C 4#1 &%,7:1%#)4,S 04& ?%2"=% "?&",%$%Y 9"H 24# 4#;"#% ,)(% 4 &64+$4# ,)7%:&$;,% H0%# %R6"&%1 4 $0".&4#1 $)=%& 4 14; $" $0)#-& $04$ $0% =%1)4 &.--%&$& H),, =4C% ;". 0466;V >#1S $0% =4&& =%1)4 1"%& #"$ b.&$ %#2".+4-% .& $" ?.; 2"=: ="1)$)%& $0+".-0 +%6%$)$)"# "7 41& ^ $0".-0 )$ 1"%& +%6%4$ $0%= "(%+ 4#1 "(%+ 4-4)#S &" $04$ %(%+;"#% C#"H& $0% 6+"1.2$S $0% b)#-,%S $0% ,"-"Y /0% =%1)4 4,&" ,)#C& $0% &%,,)#- "7 6+"1.2$& $" ".+ .#2"#&2)".& 1%&)+%& 7"+ &%RS 4--+%&&)"#S &%,7:%&$%%=S ?%4.$; 4#1 4&&%+$)(%#%&&S 4#1 Y Y Y ="+%Y /0% =4&& =%1)4 1)&2"(%+%1 $04$ W0)11%# 6%+&.41%+&XQJ ,)#C%1 $" ".+ 1%%6%&$ 1+)(%& 24# 0%,6 &%,, 6+"1.2$&Y /0.&S 24+& 4+% ,)#C%1 $" =4&2.,)#% &%R.4, &;=?",&S -)(%# 4--+%&&)(% #4=%&S 4#1 41(%+$)&%1 H)$0 ?%4.$)7., H"=%# "# $0% 0""1Y f+S ?%%+ )& 41(%+$)&%1 ?; =.&2.,4+ =%#S &%+(%1 ?; &%R; H"=%#Y 5%R 4#1 4--+%&&)"# &%,,S &" "+1)#4+; 6+"1.2$& 4+% ,)#C%1 $" &%R.4, 4#1 4--+%&&)(% )=4-%&Y f+S $0%; 4+% ,)#C%1 $" "$0%+ 2"#1)$)"#)#&$)=.,) $04$ -%#%+4$% ="+% $04# b.&$ $0% 1%&)+% $" ?.; $0% 6+"1.2$S ?.$ $0% 1%&)+% $" 7.,7),, 4 ?4&)2 #%%1S "+ 4$$4)# 4 74#$4&;Y E0%$0%+ "#% .&%& 4 U+%.1)4# "+ 5C)##%+)4# ="1%,S "#% 4++)(%& 4$ $0% &4=% 2"#2,.&)"#' ="1%+# )#1)()1.4,& 4+% &$)=.,4$%1 $" ?.; $0% 6+"1.2$& "7 $0% )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=;S 4#1 $0% ?.;)#- 466%4+& $" ?% 7.,: 7),,)#- 4 9##02) $#21 *-##9/a ].$S "7 2".+&%S "#2% ?".-0$S $0% 6+"1.2$ 1"%& #"$ 7.,7),, $04$ #%%1S 4#1 &" $0% )#1)()1.4, 04& $" ?.; 4-4)# 4#1 4-4)#Y /0)& )& $0% W7%$)&0 "7 2"=="1)$)%&XQL ^ 34+RX& #)-0$=4+% ()&)"# "7 2"#&.=%+ &"2)%$)%& H0%+%)# $0)#-& $4C% $0% 6,42% "7 +%,4$)"#&0)6&S 4#1 $0% )#1)()1.4, ?%,)%(%& $04$ ?; ?.;)#- $0)#-& 0% "+ &0% H),, ?%2"=% 0466;Y 34+R H4& 2"++%2$ )# $04$ $0% $0)#-& ^ $0% 2"=="1)$)%& ^ 1" #"$ =4C% "#% 0466;S %R2%6$ 7"+ 4 7,%%$)#- ="=%#$Y /0%#S ;". H4#$ 4#"$0%+ $0)#- ^ 4 #%H%+ $0)#-S 4 ?%$$%+ $0)#-S 4 1)77%+%#$ $0)#-Y /0% 6+"?,%= H)$0 34+RX& 2+)$)e.% )& $04$ $0% "?(%+&% &)$.4$)"# ^ 4 H"+,1 H)$0".$ 2"=="1)$)%& ^ )& 1+4?S ?"+)#-S .#&$)=.,4$)#-S .#="1: %+#Y /0% 6%"6,% )# 2"==.#)&$ 2".#$+)%&S H0%+%)# 2"=="1)$)%& H%+%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ATA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

#"$ 6+"1.2%1 "+ H%+% )# &0"+$ &.66,;S H%+% ?"+%1 4#1 =)&%+4?,% 4#1 7%,$ 4& )7 $0%; H%+% #"$ 64+$)2)64$)#- )# $0% H"+,1 "7 ="1%+#)$;Y ].$S 0%+% H% 4+% )# $0% 0)-0:$%20S )#1.&$+)4, 246)$4,)&$ H"+,1S 4#1 6%+046& ^ 6%+046& ^ H% 04(% -"#% $"" 74+ H)$0 41(%+$)&)#- 4#1 "(%+: 6+"1.2$)"#S 4#1 $0% ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,%Y 34;?% H% 04(% =41% 2"=="1: )$)%& &" 7%$)&0)\%1 $04$ H% 04(% #%-,%2$%1 $0% +%4, #%%1& $04$ H% +%4,,; 04(%S 4#1 $04$ 24# "#,; ?% 7.,7),,%1 $0+".-0 0.=4# +%,4$)"#&0)6& 4#1 4 0.=4#)&$)2 2"#2%6$)"# "7 ,)7%Y Y Y Y /0)& )& 7"+ $0%","-)4#& 4#1 ="+4, 60),": &"60%+& $" 1%?4$%S 4#1 H% H),, +%$.+# $" )$ &0"+$,;Y 9%+% H% H)&0 $" 7"2.& "# $0% 1%2,)#% "7 6.+)$4# &%,7:1%#)4, 4#1 $0% %=%+-%#2% "7 $0% %$0)2 "7 6%+&"#4, 6,%4&.+% 4#1 ,.R.+; ?.;)#-Y M# $"14;X& 0)-0:$%20 H"+,1S ,.R.+; -""1& 4+% 1%&)+%1 ?; %(%+;"#%Y c%+; %R6%#&)(% H4$20%& 4+% &",1 H"+,1:H)1%S %(%# $0".-0 4 k8TT:H4$20 H),, ?% %R2%,,%#$ 4#1 H),, ,4&$ 7"+ $%# ;%4+& "+ ="+%Y U4=),)%& H),, ?.; 4 B%R.&S H0%+% 4 /";"$4 H".,1 1"Y /0% K4#-% K"(%+ b%%6 2"&$)#- kAT TTT ="+% $04# 4 U"+1 "+ !0+;&,%+ b%%6S H),, ?% 6.+204&%1Y F%&)-#%+ 2,"$0)#- ^ H)$0 $0% ,4?%,& 4#1 ,"-"& "6%#,; 1)&6,4;%1 ^ &%,, ?; $0% $0".&4#1&Y @)4#$ &2+%%# /c& 4#1 =.,$):7.#2$)"# c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b%2$)#- 0)-0:$%20 &"2)%$;Y E% 4+% 4H4+% "7 $0% 1+4?#%&& "7 $0% 74),%1 34+R)&$ &"2)%$)%&Y E% 4+% 4H4+% $04$ %(%# .$"6)4# &"2)4,)&$&S ,)C% $0% Z)??.$\#)2C& )# M&+4%,S #"H H4#$ ^ #%%1 ^ 24+&S $%,%()&)"#&S 1%&)-#%+ 2,"$0%&S %$2Y /0%; ,)C% $0%&% $0)#-&S 4& H% 4,, 1"Y /0%+%7"+%S H)$0".$ &.--%&$)#- 4 +%$.+# $" $0% 64&$ "+ 4 +%b%2$)"# "7 $0% 7.$.+%S ,%$ .& 4#4,;\% &"=% "7 $0% 6+"?,%=& %=%+-)#-Y U"+ H% 4+% 1)&: 2.&&)#- $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ 4#1 )$& +%,4$)"#&0)6 $" ="+4,)$;Y /0%+%7"+%S )7 ="+4, 6+"?,%=& 04(% %=%+-%1S ,%$ .& 742% $0%= &e.4+%,;S 4#1 ^ )7 6"&&: )?,% ^ "?b%2$)(%,;Y U)+&$S $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& 04(% ?%-.# $" )#1%?$ $0%=&%,(%&S -,"?4,,;S )# "+1%+ $" 4$$4)# 4 ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,%Y /0)& &)$.4$)"# )& H"+&% )# $0% N5>S ?.$ 4#;"#% H0" 04& %(%+ &%%# $0% d464#%&% &0"66)#- )# G%H ["+CS *4+)&S 9"#- Z"#- "+ E4)C)C)S C#"H& $04$ $0% d464#%&% 4+% 1")#- $0% &4=%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) ATD

34#; @%+=4#& 04(% %R6%#&)(% 24+&S 4& 1" $0% @+%%C&S M$4,)4#& 4#1 "$0%+ <.+"6%4#&Y /0% !0)#%&% 4+% ?.;)#- %(%+;$0)#- $0%; 24# -%$ $0%)+ 04#1& "#Y 5"S $0% 7)+&$ 6+"?,%= )& $04$ "7 2+%1)$:1%?$ H0)20 )& (%+; -""1 7"+ $0% =4+C%$ %2"#"=;S ?.$ 4#R)%$;:6+"1.2)#- 7"+ $0% #%H =)11,% 2,4&&Y 5%2"#1,;S $0)#-& ^ 2"=="1)$)%& ^ =4C% ;". (%+; .#0466; H0%# ;". 1"#X$ 04(% $0%=Y ].$S H0%# ;". 1" -%$ $0%=S ;". $)+% "7 $0%= (%+; e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e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e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ATI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b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d.14)&= 04(% 4,, ?%%# .#1%+=)#%1 ?; $0% =4+C%$S H)$0 )$& 2"#&$4#$,; 204#-)#- 741& 4#1 )$& 1)\\;)#- 4++4; "7 #%H )1%4&S #%H $%20#","-)%&S 4#1 #%H 6+"1.2$&Y M# M&+4%,S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S $0% =4b"+)$; "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"# 4+% ="+% )#$%+%&$%1 )# $0% 2"=6.$%+ 4#1 2"=6.$%+ &"7$H4+% $04# )# C"&0%+ ,4H&Y > +%4, 6",)$)24, 2"#7,)2$ )& %=%+-)#?%$H%%# $0% -%#%+4, 6"6.,4$)"# 4#1 $0% "+$0"1"R d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c%?,%# ,4=6""#%1S ?.$ H0)20 )& #"$ 2"=)24, 4#;="+%S #"H $04$ #>#")7-# )& 4$$%=6$)#- $" -4)# W$0% ,)7% &$;,% "7 $0% +)20 4#1 74=".&XY K"?%+$ ZY 3%+$"#S )# 0)& 646%+ W5"2)4, 5$+.2$.+% 4#1 >#"=)%XSJQ H4& $0% 7)+&$ $" $0%"+)\% "# $0% %77%2$ "7 $0% >=%+)24# F+%4= ^ ".+ W+4-& $"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) ATO

+)20%&X 2.,$.+% H0)20 04& =41% .& 4 =4-#%$ 7"+ $0% H"+,1X& )=6"(%+: )&0%1S W0.11,%1X =4&&%& ^ "# $0% 2+)=% +4$%Y U"+S 422"+1)#- $" 3%+$"#S )$ H4& $0% $+%=%#1".& 6+%&&.+% 7"+ .6H4+1 ="?),)$; )# >=%+)24 $04$ ?"$0 6+"1.2%1 )==)-+4#$ &.22%&& &$"+)%& 4#1 -%#%+4$%1 4 64$0","-)24,,; 0)-0 +4$% "7 2+)=%Y M# 3%+$"#X& ()%HS $0% 6+%&&.+% $" &.22%%1 )# $0% N5> )& &" -+%4$ $04$ )$ "(%++)1%& ?"$0 $0% d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b"?S 4#1 ="(%=%#$ $" 4 ?%$$%+ 2"==.#)$;S "+S $0+".-0 %1.24$)"# 4#1 %#$+4#2% )#$" $0% H0)$%:2",,4+S =)11,%:2,4&& H"+,1S 4#1 )7 ;". &.22%%1S %)$0%+ )# ?,.%:2",,4+ "+ H0)$%:2",,4+ H"+CS ;". H),, #"$ $.+# $" 2+)=%Y 9"H%(%+S )7 ;".+ ,%-)$)=4$% +".$% $" .6H4+1 ="?),)$; )& ?,"2C%1S ?%24.&% ;". 24##"$ -4)# 4 H%,,:64;)#- ?,.%:2",,4+ b"?S 4#1 ;". ,42C $0% &C),,& $" &.22%%1 )# $0% H0)$%:2",,4+ H"+,1S ;". H"#X$ b.&$ -)(% .6 ^ ,)C% 4# 4#2)%#$ 6%4&4#$S 4#1 422%6$ ;".+ ,"$ )# ,)7% 4& H+%$20%1Y >22"+1: )#- $" 3%+$"#S ;". H),, W)##"(4$%XSJJ "+ 4$$%=6$ $" 7)#1 4# ),,%-)$)=4$% 24+%%+ +".$%Y /0)& ),,%-)$)=4$% +".$% 2".,1 ?% 4 6+"7%&&)"#4, 2+)=)#4, 24+%%+' 24+ $0%7$S ?.+-,4+;S &$"+%:0",1:.6&S &$+%%$ =.--)#-&Y f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f+S "7 2".+&%S $0% &.22%&&7., 2+)=)#4, 24+%%+ =4; ?% )#$%++.6$%1 ?; 4 ,"#- 6+)&"# &%#$%#2%Y >22"+1)#- $" 3%+$"#S ?%24.&% $0% 6+%&&.+% 7"+ .6H4+1 ="?),)$; "(%+: +)1%& +%,)-)".& ="+4,)$; 4#1 +%&6%2$ 7"+ $0% ,4H )# =4+C%$ &"2)%$)%& ^

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ATP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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`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d464#%&% 6+%7%+ 1%&)-#%+ #4=%& "# 4,, $0%)+ 6.+204&%&Y /0% 4(%+4-% @%+=4# #" ,"#-%+ 1+)(%& 4 c",C&H4-%#Y /0% ]+4\),)4# .66%+ 4#1 =)11,% 2,4&&%& 14\\,% $0% $".+)&$& H)$0 $0%)+ ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,%Y /0% W&64+$4#X ,)7%:&$;,% &%%=& "#,; $" ?% &.+()()#- )# 524#1)#: 4()4 4#1 /0% G%$0%+,4#1&S ;%$ %(%# $0%+%S ,.R.+; -""1& 4+% %4&),; "?&%+: (4?,% 4#1 "6%#,; 1)&6,4;%1 ?; &"=% &%-=%#$& "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"#Y E04$ )& =; 6")#$V E)$0 $0% ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% "6%#,; 1)&6,4;%1 )# ="&$ 0)-0:$%20 #4$)"#&S 6+%&&.+% $" 4$$4)# &.20 4 ,)7%:&$;,% )& $+%=%#1".&Y >#1 )7 %1.24$)"#S b"?:$+4)#)#-S 4#1 b"? 4(4),4?),)$; 4+% +%41),; 4(4),4?,%S $0%# ,%-)$)=4$% b"? 4#1 24+%%+ $+42C& H),, ?% $4C%#Y /0% 6+"?,%= "22.+& H0%+% $0% ,%-)$)=4$% 64$0& $" .6H4+1 ="?),)$; 4+% %)$0%+ 4(4),4?,% )# $"" &0"+$ 4 &.66,;S "+ H0%+% $0%+% 4+% )=6%1): =%#$& $" $0%&% 64$0&Y /0.&S )7S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S 4 #4$)"# 04& 4# %2"#"=; #"$ %R64#&)(% %#".-0 $" 4?&"+? $0% )#1)-%#".& 4#1 )==)-+4#$ 6""+S $0%# $0%&% &%-=%#$& "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"# =4; $.+# $" 2+)=%Y f+S )7 $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) ATQ

)#1)-%#".& "+ )==)-+4#$ 6"6.,4$)"# ,42C& %1.24$)"#4, 4#1 b"? &C),,&S $0%# $0)& &%-=%#$ "7 $0% 6"6.,4$)"# =4; #"$ ?% 4?,% $" $4C% 41(4#$4-% "7 $0% $+42C& $04$ 4+% "6%#Y G4$)"#& H0)20 6"&&%&& %R64#&)(% %2"#"=)%& 4#1 b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b"?& 4+% 4(4),4?,%S $0% 2+)=% +4$% 04& ?%%# =.20 ,"H%+ $04# )# $0% N5>S B4$)# >=%+)24 4#1 >&)4Y ].$S %(%# )# <.+"6%S 4& $0% #.=?%+ "7 )==)-+4#$& 04& )#2+%4&%1S 4#1 4& $0% .#%=6,";=%#$ +4$% 04& +)&%#S $0% +4$% "7 ()",%#2%S 2+)=% 4#1 1%()4#2% 04& -"#% .6Y /0% 7,4.#$)#- "7 $0% ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% ^ 4 +%,4$)(%,; #%H 60%#"=%#"# )# $0)& W&%2"#1 -),1%1 4-%XS 04& 1%7)#)$%,; 2+%4$%1 4 &"2)%$; H0%+%)# 4%-) 0#702# H4#$ 4 -+%4$ 1%4,S 4#1 $0%; H4#$ )$ -7;a M$ )& 1)77)2.,$ )#1%%1 $" =4)#$4)# 4 ,4H7., 4#1 %$0)24, &"2)%$; .#1%+ &.20 2"#1)$)"#&Y /0% 2,.% $" $0% 1%2,)#% )# ="+4, )#$%-+)$; %#-%#1%+%1 ?; $0% #%H ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% H4& ?%&$ %R%=6,)7)%1 ?; $0% E4,, 5$+%%$ W)#&)1%+ $+41)#-X &24#14,& "7 $0% ,4$% 8LJT& )# $0% N5>Y 5%%)#- &.20 (4&$ 4=".#$& "7 H%4,$0 ?%)#- =41% ^ 4#1 H4$20)#- 4& $0)& H%4,$0 H4& $0+"H# )#$" 94=6$"#X& ]%420 9".&%&S &.?.+?4# %&$4$% 0".&%&S ,.R.+; 24+& 4#1 &6"+$& 24+&S k8T TTT H4$20%&S $0% ?.;)#- "7 ?%4.$)7., W24,, -)+,&SX kDTTT &.)$&S k8TT $)%&S 4#1 "2%4#:,)#%+ ;420$& ^ =4#; "# E4,, 5$+%%$ 4$$%=6$%1 $" -4)# $0% H%4,$0 4#1 $0% ,.R.+; -""1&Y M#&)1%+ $+41)#- H4& %#-4-%1 )# ?; &"=% "7 $0% %R%2.$)(%& 4#1 .#1%+,)#-& ^ 4#1 $0%; 46%1 $0% ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% 4& e.)2C,; 4& $0%; 2".,1Y E0%# %R6"&%1 ?; $0% U]M )#(%&$)-4$)"#S ="&$ 2,4)=%1 $0%; H%+% b.&$ 1")#- H04$ %(%+;"#% %,&% H4& 1")#-Y G"+ H4& $0%+% 4 =4b"+ ="+4, ".$: +4-% 4="#- $0% -%#%+4, 6"6.,4$)"#Y K4$0%+ ^ 4#1 $0)& 04& ?%2"=% 4 -""1 $+%#1 )# $%+=& "7 =)11,%:2,4&& 6+"&6%+)$; ^ $0% =)11,% 2,4&&%&

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ATJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

?%-4# $" )#(%&$ 2#.,1,4%1#2) )# $0% &$"2C =4+C%$ )# $0% 0"6%& "7 -4)#)#$0% H%4,$0 4#1 ,.R.+; $04$ $0% )#&)1%+ $+41%+& 041 -4)#%1 ),,%-)$)=4$%,;Y 5$"2C =4+C%$ )#(%&$=%#$ )& 4 -""1 $0)#-S &" H04$ )& )$ $04$ H% 4+% 2+)$)2)\)#-V G"$0)#-Y E04$ H% 4+% "?&%+()#- )& $04$ $0% ,.R.+; ,)7%:&$;,% )& &" 14\\,)#- $04$ %(%+;"#% H4#$& $" 4$$4)# )$Y /0% =)11,% 2,4&&%& H),, 4$$%=6$ $" 4$$4)# )$ $0+".-0 %1.24$)"#S "(%+H"+C )# $0%)+ 24+%%+&SL8 4#1 "(%+:)#1%?$%1#%&&LA _)# $%+=& "7 2+%1)$ 24+1&S ,"4#&S 4#1 &%2"#1 ="+$: -4-%&`S H0),% $0% 6""+ 4#1 $0% )==)-+4#$& H),, 4$$%=6$ $" 4$$4)# )$S %)$0%+ $0+".-0 04+1 H"+C )# ,"H%+:64;)#- b"?&S "+ $0+".-0 2+)=% 4#1 ()",%#2%Y !"# .-&%./+*7 &1 *"# 1%## -.%6#*0 +1 +* 2#//2A 2#// +* /0% =4+C%$ %2"#"=; 04& 4,H4;& %R)&$%1 )# 4 2"#$%R$ "7 +%,)-)".& ="+: 4,)$;Y 9"H%(%+S $0% =4+C%$S )# )$&%,7S 2"#$4)#& 4 6+%&&.+% 7"+ 4="+4,)$;Y /0% 4="+4,)$; %=%+-%& 7+"= $0% 1;#4=)2& "7 &%,,)#- 7"+ 4 6+"7)$Y 5%,,)#7"+ 4 6+"7)$ )& $0% =4b"+ ="$)(4$)"#4, 742$"+ H)$0)# $0% =4+C%$ &;&$%=Y /0)& )& H04$ W#4$.+4, %2"#"=)2 ?%04()"+X )& 4,, 4?".$' 6+"1.2)#- %77): 2)%#$,; 4#1 &%,,)#- 7"+ 4 6+"7)$Y /0%+%7"+%S )7 &"=%$0)#- 24# ?% 6+"1.2%1 %77)2)%#$,; 4#1 &",1 7"+ 4 6+"7)$S )$ 7",,"H& $04$ "#% 1"%& &"Y /0% 4="+4,)$; 2"=%& )#$" $0% %e.4$)"# ?%24.&%S )7 &"=%$0)#- &%,,&S +4$)"#4,:=)#1%1 %#$+%6+%#%.+& H),, H4#$ $" &%,, )$S #" =4$$%+ H04$ $0% 6+"1.2$ =4; ?%S "+ H04$ )$& %77%2$ =4; ?% "# $0% 6%"6,% "+ $0% %#()+"#=%#$Y /0.&S ="1%+# 2"+6"+4$)"#& H),, &%,, #464,= 4#1 6%#)2),,)# ^ $0%; ?"$0 &%,,S &" &%,, $0%=Y 3"1%+# 2"+6"+4$)"#& H),, &%,, 2)-4+%$$%& 4#1 2,"$0)#-S ,)e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) ATL

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b%4#& 4#1 C04C)&Y @46 4--+%&&)(%,; =4+C%$%1 )$& 6+"1.2$& H)$0 $%%#4-%+&S 4#1 7".#1 7)?+% 411)$)(%& $04$ =41% $0% b%4#& 4#1 C04C)& ="+% &.66,%S ,%&& H+)#C,%:6+"#%S 4#1 %4&)%+ $" H%4+Y /04$ $0% 2,"$0)#- 2"=64#; 1)1 #"$ 0.+$ 4#;"#% 4#1 $04$ $0% 2)-4+%$$% 2"=64#)%& 1)1 )&S "7 2".+&%S "7 =4b"+ %$0)24, &)-#)7)24#2%Y ].$S ,""C 2,"&%,;' $0% $H" ?.&)#%&& $%4=& 1)1 $0% &4=% $0)#- )# $%+=& "7 6+"1.2: $)"#S =4+C%$)#-S 4#1 41(%+$)&)#-Y f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A8T +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) A88

2"==.#)24$)"#LD ^ $0+".-0 H0)20 H% 4+% 4,, 2"##%2$%1S 4#1 ;%$S 1)&: 2"##%2$%1Y

3"()%&S $%,%()&)"#S +"2C =.&)2S c!K ()1%"& ^ $0%&% 4+% #"H =4b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b.&$ 0"H 74+ $0%; 24# -" H)$0 &%R.4, 4#1 4--+%&&)(% )=4-%&Y /0.&S $0%; 04(% )#2+%4&%1 $0% 4=".#$ "7 #.1)$; 4#1 $0% %R6,)2)$#%&& "7 &%R.4, 42$&Y >#1 $0%; 04(% &%64+4$%1 $0% &%R.4, 42$& 7+"= 4#; +"=4#: $)2 4#1 +%,4$)"#4, 2"#$%R$ ^ =4C)#- $0%&% =%1)4 &%R.4, 42$& )#$" 6.+% 74#$4&; ^ H04$ <+)C4 d"#- 24,,%1 $0% W\)6,%&& 7.2CXLO )# H0)20 &%R b.&$ 0466%#& =4-)24,,; ?%$H%%# $H" 6%"6,% H)$0 #" 7.=?,)#- ^ 4#1 #" +%,4$)"#&0)6 ^ $" %#2.=?%+ )$Y /0%# 9",,;H""1 W6.&0%1 $0% %#(%,"6%X 7.+$0%+Y /0%; &0"H%1 &%R H)$0 #" +%,4$)"#&0)6S 4#1 $0%# C)#C; &%RS $0%# 6"+#"-+460)2 &%RS $0%# ^ 4#1 $0)& )& $0% H"+&$ 64+$ ^ &%R =)R%1 H)$0 ()",%#2% ^ &%R 4#1 =.+1%+Y f(%+ 4#1 "(%+ 4-4)#S &%R 4#1 =.+1%+ 4+% 2"=?)#%1Y 3"()%& ,)C% J%3,& 8-31,-&1 4#1 4 H0",% -%#+% "7 W0"++"+X ="()%& 2"=?)#% &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% ^ .&.4,,; H)$0 ()",%#2% 4-4)#&$ H"=%#Y >-4)#S $0% =%1)4 )#1.&$+; 04& 1"#% $0% &4=% $0)#- H)$0 ()",%#2% 4& H)$0 &%RS ?.$ H)$0 $#;#" "#31",&1,7-3Y /0% =%1)4 =4C%+& W6.&0%1 $0% %#(%,"6%YX U)+&$ $0%; &0"H%1 =.+1%+Y /0%# $0%; &0"H%1 ="+% 4#1 %R6,)2)$ C),,)#-Y /0%# $0%; &0"H%1 0)1%".&,; %R6,)2)$ C),,)#-S H)$0

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

!"# -.22 -#'+. .3' .-&%./+*70 2#B .3' ,+&/#3)# 2#//A 2& 2#// *"#-

0%41& ?,"H# 464+$S ?,""1 &6+".$)#- 7+"= ?"1; 64+$&S 4#1 ?"1; 64+$& 2.$ "77Y c)",%#2% ?%24=% 6"+#"-+460)2 ^ $04$ )&S %R6,)2)$ 4#1 -+4$.)$".& ^ #"$ 4$ 4,, #%2%&&4+; $" $0% 6,"$ "+ +%,%(4#$ $" $0% ,)(%& "7 $0% 204+42$%+&Y <(%# %R2%,,%#$ 7),=&S &.20 4& @%>,-. !",>%1# L)%-S &0"H %R6,)2)$ W6"+#": -+460)2X ()",%#2%S #%(%+ &0"H# )# $0% 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+ ="()%& =41% )# $0% 8LIT& 4#1 8LOT&Y U),=& &.20 4& $0% d4=%& ]"#1 ="()%& 2"#$4)#%1 74#$4&; \)6,%&& &%R 4#1 #4&$;S &41)&$)2S 6"+#"-+460)2 ()",%#2% ^ 4#1S "7 2".+&%S $0%; ?%24=% +%=4+C4?,; 6"6.,4+Y 3"()%&S $%,%()&)"#S +"2C ()1%"& ^ $0%; 4,, 2"#$4)# ()",%#2%S &%R.4,)$; 4#1 $0% 2"=?)#4$)"# "7 &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% $04$ 04& 2+%4$%1 4 -,"?4, 2.,$.+% "7 &%#&%,%&& ()",%#2% 4#1 &%R H)$0".$ ,"(%Y E% 1" #"$ =%4# $04$ $0% 2.,$.+% )$&%,7 )& 6+"b%2$)#- $0)& C)#1 "7 ="+4,)$;Y E04$ H% 4+% &.--%&$)#- )& $04$ $0% =4&& =%1)4 4+% 6+"b%2$)#_64+1"# $0% 6.#` $0)& C)#1 "7 ="+4,)$; ^ -,"?4,,; ^ 4#1 )$& %77%2$ "# $0% 0.=4# 6&;20% =4; ?% 6+"7".#1Y E% 4+% #"$ &.+% H04$ $04$ )=642$ )& ;%$Y 9"H%(%+S H% 1" C#"H $04$ )# $"14;X& 0)-0:$%20 H"+,1 $0%+% )& 4 -+%4$ 1%4, "7 H04$ $0% &"2)","-)&$& 24,, W0"+)\"#$4, &"2)4,)\4$)"#XYLP c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c!K ()1%"&S 2"=6.$%+ !F&S ()1%" -4=%&S 4#1 $0% M#$%+#%$Y >,, "7 $0%&% =%1)4 60%#"=%#4S 2"=?)#%1 H)$0 6%%+ -+".6 2"#7"+=)$; 6+%&&.+%S 24# 2+%4$% 4 W0"+)\"#$4, &"2)4,)\4$)"#X 6+"2%&& $04$ )& 6"H%+7.,S )#1%,)?,%S 4#1 e.)$% ".$&)1% $0% +%4,= "7 $0% 64+%#$4, &"2)4,: )\4$)"# 6+"2%&&YLQ /0% $%%#& )# !","+41"S 7"+ )#&$4#2%S H0" &0"$ &" =4#; "7 $0%)+ 2,4&&: =4$%&S H%+% 1+%&&%1 )# ?,42C $+%#20 2"4$&S 0",1)#- $H" -.#&S &0""$)#6%"6,% +4#1"=,;S &4;)#- &41)&$)2 4#1 W7.##;X $0)#-& $" $0%)+ ()2$)=& ?%7"+% C),,)#- $0%=S 7",,"H)#- 4 W-"$0)2 ,)7%&$;,%X ^ )# &0"+$S 4,="&$ %(%+;$0)#- $0%; 1)1 2".,1 04(% 2"=% ".$ "7 4# >+#",1 520H4+\%#%--%+ ="()%S "+ 4 5;,(%&$%+ 5$4,,"#% ="()%S "+ 7+"= 4# 3/c ()1%"S "+ 4 $%%#: H%&$%+# ="()%Y G"$0)#- $04$ $0%&% $%%#& 1)1S &4)1S "+ H"+% 24=% 7+"= $0%)+ 64+%#$&Y /0%; H%+% #"$ +",%:="1%,)#- $0%)+ 64+%#$&S $0%; H%+% +",%: ="1%,)#- $0% =4&& =%1)4 4#1 )$& $%%#:)=4-%&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A8A +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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f$0%+H)&%S H% +%(%+$ $" 4#)=4, ?%04()"+S 4#1 H% 0.=4#&S .#7"+$.#4$%,;S 24# ?%2"=% $0% H"+&$ ?%4&$& "7 4,,Y /0% =4&& =%1)4 =4; ?% )#41(%+$%#$,; <-"#0"#33,-. .&Y 34+2.&%LL H"#: 1%+%1 0"H =.20 +%6+%&&)"# H4& #%2%&&4+; )# &"2)%$;Y F)1 ="1%+# &"2)%$; 04(% #:!,># 4=".#$& "7 +%6+%&&)"#V 9% $0".-0$ &"S 4#1 ?%,)%(%1 $04$ H% 2".,1 7.#2$)"# H%,, H)$0 ,%&& +%6+%&&)"# $04# U+%.1 $0".-0$ #%2%&&4+;Y ].$ #"HS $0% =4&& =%1)4 =4; 04(% 0%,6%1 .#: +%6+%&& .& $"" 2"=6,%$%,;Y /%%#& &%%= $" ?% %R6+%&&)#- &%R.4,)$; 4#1 ()",%#2% (%+; 1)+%2$,;S H)$0 ,)$$,% &.6%+%-" +%&$+4)#$ "+ -.),$S 4#1 H)$0 =.20 ,%&& %-":+4$)"#4, 6+"?,%=:&",()#- ?%04()"+Y 34+2.&% =)-0$ 04(% +%2"#&)1%+%1 $0% ,)?%+4$)"# "7 W%+"&X )7 0% 041 ,)(%1 $" &%% 2"#$%=6"+4+; 2.,$.+% ^ "+ 0% H".,1 &)=6,; 04(% ?,4=%1 %+"&:-"#%:6"+#"-+460)2 "# $0% =4+C%$S &)#2% 4$ $0% 2"+%S 0% H4& ="+% 4 34+R)&$ $04# 4 U+%.1)4#Y8TT f#% 1"%& #"$ 04(% $" ?% 4 34+R)&$ "+ 4 +%,)-)".& 7.#14=%#$4,)&$ $" &%% $04$ $0% &%,,)#- "7 &%R 4#1 ()",%#2% 4+% )=642$)#- "# $0% ;".#- -%#%+4: $)"#Y <(%# $0% #%H& =%1)4 7"2.& "# &%R 4#1 ()",%#2%Y !,)#$"#X& 6+%&)1: %#2; )& ?%&$ C#"H# $0+".-0 $0% 3"#)24 B%H)#&C; 4774)+Y >#1 $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E(# P"## ?%"I#1 %-9 ?7"%2,1) A8D

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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A8I +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

K%,)-)".& 4#1 5%2.,4+ !.+?& "# $0% 5%,7)&0#%&& 4#1 >="+4,)$; "7 $0% 34+C%$

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a $0% <.+"6%4#& &$)-=4$)\%1 $0% d%H& )# $0% =%1)%(4, H"+,1a $0% 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4#& (),): 7)%1 $0% !0)#%&% 7"+ $0%)+ &.22%&&7., =%+204#$ 42$)()$)%& )# $0% ="1%+# H"+,1Y Z('.+2- .3' *"# #*"+) &1 2&)+./ 9(2*+)# /0% H+)$)#-& "7 M&4)408 ?%&$ %R%=6,)7; $0% d%H)&0 $+41)$)"# "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2%S 4#1 H% &04,, 6+%&%#$ $0%&% )1%4& )# 4 ="=%#$Y ].$S %(%# ?%7"+% M&4)40S )# $0% &$"+; "7 d"&%60S H% 4,+%41; 7)#1 $0% d.14)2 2"#2%+# 7"+ $0% &04+)#- "7 H%4,$0 H)$0 $0% 6%"6,%Y U"+ #"$ "#,; )& d"&%60 %R$",,%1 7"+ 0)& 4?),)$; $" )#$%+6+%$ 1+%4=& 4#1 7"+ 0)& 0"#%&$ 4#1 %77)2)%#$ 41=)#)&$+4: $)(% 4?),)$)%&S ?.$ 0% ?%2"=%& 6"H%+7., 4#1 H%,, C#"H# )# $0)& H4;Y 9% )#$%+6+%$& $0% 1+%4=& "7 $0% 604+"40 4& 6+%1)2$)#- 4 7.$.+% &24+2)$; ^ A8O

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

88

&%(%# ?41 ;%4+&Y >#1 0% &.--%&$& $04$ &$"+%0".&%& "7 -""1& ?% 2"#&%+(%1 1.+)#- $0% &%(%# -""1 ;%4+&S &" $04$ 1.+)#- $0% 6%+)"1 "7 7.$.+% &24+2)$;S $0% 6%"6,% H),, #"$ &$4+(%Y d"&%60 ?%2"=%& $0% 0%41 "77)2)4, "7 <-;6$S ?%24.&% "7 0)& 2"#2%+# 7"+ $0% 6%"6,% 4#1 0)& &.22%&&7., 6,4##)#- 7"+ $0%)+ 7.$.+% 6+"()&)"#YA G"HS $0% <-;6$)4#& 041 2+%4$%1 $0% &$"+%0".&% &;&$%= ,"#- ?%7"+% $0% $+)?4, d%H& 4++)(%1 $0%+%YD 5"S H0; 4$$+)?.$% $0)& =4+(%,".& &;&$%= $" d"&%60V E%+% $0% d%H)&0 +4??)#)24, &2+)?%& $+;)#- $" +%H+)$% 0)&$"+;V G"S 4& 4,H4;&S $0%; H%+% 4$$%=6$)#- $" $%420 4 ="+4, ,%&&"#S H0),% $+4#&2+)?: )#- $0%)+ .#)e.% 0)&$"+;Y /0% ,%&&"# )# $0)& 24&% )& 2,%4+' !4+%7.,,; 6+"()1)#- 7"+ $0% 7.$.+% H%,,:?%)#- "7 $0% 6%"6,% )& )=6"+$4#$S )#$%,,): -%#$ 4#1 ()+$.".&Y /0)& $+41)$)"# "7 &"2)4, 2"#2%+# 7"+ $0% 6%"6,%X& H%,,:?%)#- H4&S )# )$& "+)-)#&S 4 $+)?4, 2"==.#4, 60%#"=%#"#YI 9"H%(%+S )# 4 ,4$%+ %+4 ^ 47$%+ 5","="# 4#1 $0+".-0 $" 9%+"1 ^ H0%# $0% d%H& ?%24=% )#$%-+4$%1 )#$" $0% 3)11,% <4&$%+# $+41% 4#1 =4+C%$ %2"#"=;S 4 6"H%+7., %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% %=%+-%1 4& 64+$ "7 $0% d.14)2 %$0)24, &;&$%=Y F.+)#- $0% %+4 "7 M&4)40S $0% ]4?;,"#)4#& 4#1 >&&;+)4#& 1"=)#4$%1 $0% 3)11,% <4&$ =),)$4+),;S 4#1 $0% *0"%#)2)4#& 041 "6%#%1 .6 $0% (4&$ 3%1)$%++4#%4# =4+C%$& 4#1 ,)#C%1 $0% 0.-% <-;6$)4# 4#1 ]4?;,"#)4# 6+"1.2$)(% 24642)$; H)$0 $0% +4H =4$%+)4,& =4+C%$& "7 $0% 3%1)$%++4#: %4# 0)#$%+,4#1Y @+%4$ H%4,$0 H4& ?%)#- 4=4&&%1 )# $0% %R64#1)#- 2)$)%& "7 $0% 4+%4S 4#1 H%4,$0 )#%e.4,)$; ?%24=% %R$+%=% H)$0)# d%H)&0 &"2)%$; 7"+ $0% 7)+&$ $)=%Y /0% d%H)&0 $+)?4, %$0)2 "7 2"==.#4, &04+)#- H4& #" ,"#-%+ +%,%(4#$ $" $0% 6+"&6%+)#- =4+C%$ &"2)%$; $04$ 041 %=%+-%1Y ].$ $0% 2"=: =.#4, %$0)2 &$),, +4# 1%%6S %&6%2)4,,; )# $0% 2".#$+;&)1%S 4#1 64+$): 2.,4+,; H)$0)# 4 +%,)-)".& $+41)$)"# H0)20 =41% 2%#$+4, )$& 6%"6,%X& W%R"1.&X 7+"= <-;6$)4# &,4(%+;S "(%+:H"+CS 4#1 *04+"4#)2 &%,7: 4--+4#1)\%=%#$Y O d.14)&=S 47$%+ $0% <-;6$)4# %R6%+)%#2%S %=604&)\%1 4 7"+-)()#- 4$$): $.1% $"H4+1 %2"#"=)2 04+1&0)6&Y /0% 54??4$0 H4& 1%2,4+%1 4& 4 0",; 14; "7 +%&$ H0)20 2".,1 #"$ ?% ()",4$%1Y >#1S "# 4 +%-.,4+ ?4&)&S Wb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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

A8P +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

E)$0 $0% +)&% "7 $0% +%=4+C4?,; 6+"&6%+".& $+41% 4#1 =4+C%$ %2": #"=;L "7 $0% 3%1)$%++4#%4# H"+,1S $0% %#$)+% 2"+% "7 $0% d%H)&0 %$0)2 "7 24+)#-S &04+)#-S 4#1 7"+-)()#- 1%?$S 24=% )#$" b%"64+1;Y G"HS $0)& %R64#&)"# "7 $+41% 4#1 6+"1.2$)"# H4& 4 =4+(%,".& %(%#$S 4#1 +%2"-#)\%1 4& &.20 ?; ="&$ "7 $0% 6%"6,%& "7 $0% 3)11,% <4&$Y ].$S 0"H $" =4)#$4)# $0% d%H)&0 2"==.#4, %$0)2 .#1%+ $0%&% #%H 2"#1): $)"#&V /0% +)20 H%+% -%$$)#- +)20%+ 4#1 ,)()#- 4 &6%2$42.,4+ ,.R.+; ,)7%: &$;,%Y /0% 6""+ H%+% 7%%,)#- #%-,%2$%1S 4#1 )# $0%)+ #%-,%2$S 4#-+;S +%&%#$7., 4#1 ()",%#$Y /0% ="#4+20; H4& #%(%+ 422%6$%1 %R2%6$ 7"+ =),)$4+; =4$$%+& _%(%# Z)#- F4()1 H4& 2+)$)2)\%1 7"+ ?%)#- $"" ()",%#$ ^ 0% H4& #"$ 4,,"H%1 $" ?.),1 $0% $%=6,% 4$ d%+.&4,%= 7"+ $0)& +%4&"#Y8T 9%+"1S $0% ,4&$ 7.,, d%H)&0 C)#-S H4& (),)7)%1 7"+ 0)& ()",%#2%`Y88 > C)#1 "7 $+)?4, 1%="2+42;S H)$0 2,4# %,1%+& &$),, )# 2"#$+",S %(",(%1 )#$" H04$ d"&%60.& H".,1 24,, 4 W$0%"2+42;SX8A )# H0)20 6+)%&$& H".,1 &)$ 4& Wb.1-%&X 4#1 6+%&)1% "(%+ $0% &;&$%= "7 +%,)-)".& ,4H 4#1 b.&$)2% )# $0% ,4#1 "7 M&+4%,Y /0% 6+)%&$0""1S ,4$%+ 24,,%1 5411.2%%& 4#1 *04+)&%%&S 4+% H%,, C#"H# 7+"= ?"$0 f,1 4#1 G%H /%&$4=%#$ &".+2%&Y8D <#$%+ M&4)40Y8I E)$0 M&4)40S H% 7)#1 4 +%:477)+=4$)"# "7 $0% %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% 4#1 2"==.#4, &04+)#-Y >22"+1)#- $" M&4)40S "#% 2".,1 #"$ ?% 2"#&)1%+%1 4 6)".& d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a )# ;".+ 0".&%& 4+% $0% &6"),& $4C%# 7+"= $0% 6""+Y M& )$ #"$0)#- $" ;". $04$ ;". 2+.&0 =; 6%"6,% 4#1 -+)#1 $0% 742%& "7 $0% 6""+V M ,"4$0% ;".+ #%H =""#& 4#1 ;".+ 7%&$)(4,&a $0%; 04(% ?%2"=% 4 ?.+1%# $" =%S 4#1 M 24# $",%+4$% $0%= #" ,"#-%+Y E0%# ;". 0",1 ".$ ;".+ 04#1& )# 6+4;%+S M &04,, $.+# 4H4; =; %;%&Y /0".-0 ;". "77%+ 2".#$,%&& 6+4;%+&S M &04,, #"$ ,)&$%#a 4#1 $0%+% )& ?,""1 "# ;".+ 04#1&Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 A8Q

A8J +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

f#% 24# &%% $04$ H)$0 M&4)40 4# %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% 1%=4#1)#2"==.#4, &04+)#- %=%+-%& .#%e.)("24,,;Y f#% 24# &%% 4,&" $04$ $0%+% )& 4 7%4+ "7 ="#%; 4#1 ,.R.+; -""1& 4#1 =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%&Y 3"#%;: ,%#1%+& 4#1 .&.+; 4+% +%(),%1S 4#1 $0% 1)&6,4; "7 ,.R.+; -""1& )# 4 1)&14)#7., =4##%+ )& +%b%2$%1 7"+2%7.,,;Y ># 4&2%$)2 +%b%2$)"# "7 $0% H"+,1 "7 ,.R.+; -""1& )& %R$",,%1 ?; M&4)40S 4#1 ?%2"=%& 4 $+%#1 H)$0)# d.14)&=S 4#1 4# "?&%&&)"# H)$0 $0% q%4,"$& "7 $0% K"=4# %+4Y8P /0+".-0 $0% F%41 5%4 52+",,&8Q H% &%% $0% H"+1& 4#1 $0".-0$& "7 M&4)40 +%)$%+4$%1 4#1 +%)#7"+2%1Y >#1S "7 2".+&%S !0+)&: $)4#)$; H".,1 %=%+-% 7+"= 4="#- $0% q%4,"$&S 4#1 d%&.& H".,1 %R6%, $0% ="#%;204#-%+& 7+"= $0% $%=6,%S8J 4#1 -)(% 4H4; 4,, "7 0)& H"+,1,; 6"&&%&&)"#&S $0.& =)++"+)#- $0% 42$& "7 M&4)40Y E% &04,, 1)&2.&& !0+)&$)4# 4$$)$.1%& $"H4+1& H%4,$0 4#1 $0% =4+C%$ &0"+$,;Y ]%7"+% 4#4,;\)#- $0% !0+)&$)4# %$0)2S 0"H%(%+S ,%$ .& #"$% $0% 1%&$+.2: $)"# "7 $0% d%H)&0 &$4$%Y U"+S 4& 1%&2+)?%1 ?; d"&%60.&S8L $0% d%H)&0 $%=6,% H".,1 ?% 1%&$+";%1 ?; $0% K"=4#&S 4#1S $0% d%H)&0 q%4,"$:,%1 +%(",$ e.%,,%1 H)$0 0"++)7)2 ?,""1&0%1 4#1 -+%4$ ,"&& "7 ,)7%Y >#1 $0% 2"#$)#.)#- +%(",$& "7 $0% d%H&AT %(%#$.4,,; 1+"(% $0% K"=4#& $" %R6%, $0%= %#$)+%,; 7+"= $0% ,4#1 "7 M&+4%, 4#1 1)&6%+&% $0%= )#$" $0% 3%1): $%++4#%4# +)= "7 $0% K"=4# H"+,1Y /0% 1)4&6"+4 6%+)"1 "7 $0% d%H&S H0)20 ?%-4# )# $0% 7)+&$ 2%#$.+; 4#1 04& ,4&$%1 .#$), $0% ="1%+# &$4$% "7 M&+4%, H4& %&$4?,)&0%1S H4& 4 6%+)"1 )# H0)20 $0% %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% $""C "# 4 #%H =%4#)#-Y U"+ $0% d%H& H%+% #"H ,)()#- 4& 4 -.%&$ 6%"6,% ^ 4# 4,)%# 6%"6,% ^ H)$0)# $0% (4+)".& #4$)"#& "7 $0% K"=4# H"+,1Y E)$0)# $0)& #%H 2"#$%R$S d%H)&0 60),4#: $0+"6)2 "+-4#)\4$)"#& %(%#$.4,,; %=%+-%1 H0)20 $%#1%1 $" $0% #%%1& "7 #%%1; d%H&Y /0% %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% 4#1 2"==.#4, &04+)#- 2"#$)#.%1 $" 04(% -+%4$ =%4#)#-Y >#1S 4& H)$0 M&4)40S $0% +)20 H%+% %#2".+4-%1 $" &04+% $0%)+ H%4,$0 H)$0 $0% ,%&& H%,,:"77Y ].$S ?%24.&% "7 $0% 6+%: 24+)".& #4$.+% "7 d%H)&0 %R)&$%#2% ^ 4#1 4 2"#&$4#$ 7%4+ 7"+ $0%)+ &.+()(4, )$&%,7 ^ $0% 6.#)&0)#- 4$$)$.1% "7 M&4)40 H4& &"7$%#%1 $" 4# 4$$)$.1% "7 %#2".+4-%=%#$S +%H4+1 4#1 +%2"-#)$)"# 7"+ $0"&% H0" -4(% $" $0% #%%1;Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

E4&0 4#1 ?% 2,%4#a 6.$ 4H4; ;".+ %(), 1%%1& 74+ 7+"= =; &)-0$a 2%4&% $" 1" %(),S ,%4+# $" 1" -""1S 0<"3<# ^<31,&#B .<,9# 1(# 700"#33#9` <0(729 1(# ",.(13 7$ 1(# $%1(#"2#33B %-9 02#%9 1(# ;,97;/3 &%<3#a E"% ?%$)1% $0"&% H0" H4#$ .#b.&$ ,4H& 4#1 1+47$ "66+%&&)(% %1)2$&S 1%6+)()#- $0% 6""+ "7 b.&$)2%S +"??)#- $0% H%4C%&$ "7 =; 6%"6,% "7 $0%)+ +)-0$&S 6,.#1%+)#- $0% H)1"H 4#1 1%&6"),)#- $0% 74$0%+,%&&g8O

d%H)&0 2"==.#4, &%+()2%& 4#1 204+)$4?,% "+-4#)\4$)"#& 4+% &$),, ,%-%#14+;Y >#1 $0"&% H0" -)(% H),,)#-,; 4+% &$),, +%2"-#)\%1 4& 0%+"%& "7 $0% 2"==.#)$;Y /0% %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% )& %()1%#$S #"$ "#,; )# $0% 2"#$)#.)#- &.+()(4, "7 d%H)&0 2"==.#4, "+-4#)\4$)"#& H)$0)# $0% 1)4: &6"+4 2"==.#)$)%&S ?.$ 4,&" )# $0% 0)-0,; 1%(%,"6%1 H%,74+%:&$4$% &%+: ()2%& "7 ="1%+# M&+4%,Y /0% M&+4%,) %2"#"=; )& #"H 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$S ?.$S "7 2".+&%S )$ ?%-4# 4& C)??.$\ 4-+4+)4# &"2)4,)&$Y B%$ .& ,""C 4$ $0)& ="+% 2,"&%,;S 7"+ 4 64+41"R 04& %R)&$%1 )# d%H)&0 2.,$.+% &)#2% $0% 1)4&6"+4 ?%-4#Y /0% 64+41"R %=%+-%1 ?%24.&% $0% d%H&S 4& 4 6%"6,%S H%+% #"$ 4,,"H%1 $" "H# ,4#1 "+ ?%4+ 4+=& )# ="&$ "7 $0% ,4#1& $0%; H%+% 1)&6%+&%1 )#$"Y /0%;S $0%+%7"+% ?%24=% 2)$; 1H%,,%+& ^ =%+204#$&S 4+$)&4#&S 4#1 &0"6C%%6%+& ^ )# $0% ,4#1& $0%; )#04?)$%1Y > ?.&)#%&& 2.,$.+% %=%+-%1 4="#- $0% d%H&S 4#1 4,"#- H)$0 &6%2)4, $+41% &C),,& ^ &.20 4& 1"2$"+)#- 4#1 $4),"+)#- 4#1 b%H%,+;:=4C)#- ^ ?.&)#%&& 42$)()$; )$&%,7 ?%24=% 4 &6%2)4,)\4$)"# 7"+ d%H&Y 3"#%;:04#1: ,)#-S ="#%;:,%#1)#-S ?4#C)#-S ?""CC%%6)#-S 4#1 $+41%S ?%24=% $;6)24, &C),,& ,%41)#- $" ?.&)#%&& "22.64$)"#& 7"+ =4#; d%H&Y M# 564)#S 466+"R): =4$%,; ?%$H%%# LTT 4#1 8OTT >FS $0% d%H& ?%24=% $0% =4b"+ ?4#C%+&S 4#1S b.&$ ?%7"+% $0%)+ %R6.,&)"# 7+"= 564)# )# ,ILA ,%#$ ="#%; $" !",.=?.& 7"+ 0)& (";4-% "7 1)&2"(%+;YA8 >#1S 4-4)#S )# >=&$%+14=S $0% d%H& 6,4;%1 $0% &4=% +",%Y >#1S )$ =4; ?% &)-#)7)24#$ $04$ >,%R4#1%+ 94=),$"# ^ H0"&% ="$0%+ &%#$ 0)= $" 4 d%H)&0 &20"", "# $0% !4+)??%4# M&,4#1 &0% 041 ="(%1 $" ^ &%$ .6 $0% 7)+&$ 2%#$+4, =%+204#$ ?4#C )# $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&S 4=)1&$ 4# 4$="&60%+% "7 &$+"#- #%-4$)"# 7+"= ?"$0 $0% +)20 -%#$+; 4#1 $0% 6""+ ;%"=4# 74+=%+&YAA 5)=),4+,; )# @%+=4#;S $0% d%H& ?%24=% )#(",(%1 )# $0% $+41%:246)$4,)&$ %R64#&)"# "7 $0% 94#&4 ;%4+& 4#1 $0%+%47$%+Y <(%# H)$0)# $0% /.+C)&0 <=6)+%S H)$0 $0%)+ +%$.+# 7+"= 564)#S d%H& H%+% 6+"=)#%#$ )# $0% $+41%: 246)$4,)&$ 2.,$.+% "7 $0% /.+C)&0 <=6)+% 4#1 *%+&)4Y 5" H04$ )& $0% 64+41"RV /0% d%H& +%$4)#%1 $0%)+ 2"==.#4, %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2%S H0),% %#-4-)#- )# ?.&)#%&& 42$)()$)%& 4,="&$ %R2,.&)(%,;Y G"HS $0)& H".,1 #"$ ?%2"=% 64+41"R)24, .#$), $0% &"2)4,)&$ ="(%=%#$ %=%+-%1 )# <.+"6%Y 9"H%(%+S "#2% &"2)4,)&= %=%+-%1S H)$0 )$& 2"=6,%$% +%b%2$)"# "7 =4+C%$ 246)$4,)&$ 42$)()$)%&S $0%# $0% 64+41"R H".,1 ?%2"=% 4664+%#$Y U"+S =4#; )#$%,,%2$.4, d%H&S &%#&)#- $0% 2"#&"#4#2% "7 &"2)4: ,)&= H)$0 M&4)40X& %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2%S ?%24=% %#4="+%1 "7 &"2)4,)&= ^ )# 742$S ?%24=% $0% ,%41%+& "7 $0% &"2)4,)&$ ="(%=%#$YAD G"HS +%=%=?%+S $""S $04$ $0% &"2)4,)&$& ?%,)%(%1 )# $0% ?+"$0%+0""1 "7 =4#C)#1Y >#1 $04$ $0% &"2)4,)&$& H%+%S $0%+%7"+%S )#$%+#4$)"#4,)&$& H0" 422%6$%1 $0% d%H&Y E04$ "$0%+ ="(%=%#$ 422%6$%1 $0% d%H&V /0% #4$)"#4,)&$ ="(%=%#$&V /0% 6+"$":74&2)&$ ="(%=%#$&V /0% K"=4#

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 A8L

!4$0",)2 !0.+20 H)$0 )$& M#e.)&)$)"#V /0% B.$0%+4# *+"$%&$4#$ !0.+20%& H)$0 B.$0%+X& 4#$)&%=)$)2 H+)$)#-& 7+%&0 "# $0%)+ 1""+&V f#,; $0% &"2)4,)&$& 422%6$%1 $0% d%H&Y >#1S &)#2% &"2)4,)&= H4& 4 .$"6)4# ="(%=%#$ ^ ,)$%+4,,; &6%,,%1 ".$ )# 3"+%X& O170,%AI ^ )$ &%%=%1 2"#&"#4#$ H)$0 M&4)40X& =;&$)24, .$"6)4#)&=Y /0% 64+41"R H4& 0%)-0$: %#%1S "7 2".+&%S ?%24.&% $0% d%H& H%+% ,%41%+& "7 $0% &"2)4,)&$ ="(%=%#$ 4$ $0% &4=% $)=% $04$ $0% =4b"+)$; "7 $0%= H%+% %=6,";%1 )# 246)$4,)&$ 42$)()$)%&Y 5"S d%H)&0 ?4#C%+& %R)&$%1 &)1% ?; &)1% H)$0 d%H)&0 &"2)4,)&$ )1%","-)&$&Y >#1S "7 2".+&%S 34+R ,%1 $0% 2"==.#)&$ ="(%=%#$ $"H4+1& 4 $"$4, +%b%2$)"# "7 $0% %#$)+% =4+C%$ &;&$%= 4#1 )$& +%6,42%=%#$ H)$0 &$4$% &"2)4,)&=S 4#1S )# $0% H"+,1 "7 $0% .$"6)4# 7.$.+%S &$4$%,%&&S 2,4&&: ,%&&S 2"==.#)&$ &04+)#-AO ^ $0% @4+1%# "7 <1%# Y Y Y W&6%2)%& ?%)#-XY Y Y YAP U+"= 466+"R)=4$%,; 8JIT $" 8LPTS $0% $%#&)"# ?%$H%%# &"2)4,)&$ d%H& 4#1 $0% d%H)&0 ?.&)#%&& 2"==.#)$; H4& 6+"7".#1Y >#1S "7 2".+&%S H0),% 2,4)=)#- $" +%b%2$ d.14)&=S 4,"#- H)$0 4,, +%,)-)"#&S $0% 2"==.#)&$& 42$.4,,; =41% W34+R)&=X )#$" 4 #%H W2)(),X +%,)-)"#Y E)$0 34+R)&=X& 74),.+% 4#1 H"+,1H)1% 2",,46&%S d%H)&0 ?.&)#%&& 42$)(: )$)%& 4#1 d%H)&0 2"==.#4, %$0)2& 04(% +%$.+#%1 $" $0%)+ %4+,)%+ 1)4&6"+4 7"+=Y E0; 1" M =%#$)"# $0)&V ]%24.&% d.14)&=S 4& )$ 04& %=%+-%1 )# $0% ="1%+# H"+,1S 04& +%$4)#%1 )$& %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% 4#1 2"==.#4, 24+)#-S H0),% 4$ $0% &4=% $)=% #"H ,%-)$)=4$)#- 7+%%:=4+C%$ 246)$4,)&= 4#1 4,, "7 )$& 42$)()$)%&Y d%H)&0 2"==.#4, "+-4#)\4$)"#& &$),, +%2"-#)\% 4#1 +%H4+1 4#; H%4,$0; d%H)&0 ?.&)#%&&=4# "+ 7)#4#2)%+ H0" -)(%& -%#%+".&,; $" $0% 2"==.#)$; "7 $0% #%%1;Y >#1S )7 $0% #%%1; 4+% #"#: d%H&S $0% ="#%; )& &$),, 1"#4$%1 $" $0%= -%#%+".&,;Y /0%+%7"+%S H)$0 2"==.#)&= 1%41 4#1 &"2)4,)&= $+4#&7"+=%1 )#$" 524#1)#4()4#:&$;,% &"2)4, 1%="2+42;S d.14)&= 04& 4-4)# ?%2"=% 4# %$0)24, 20%2C "# 7+%%:=4+C%$ %R2%&&%&Y ].$S "7 2".+&%S d.14)&= )& &$),, ,)#C%1 4,="&$ %R2,.&)(%,; $" $0% d%H&S 4& 4# %$0#)2 -+".6Y /0%+%7"+%S $0".-0 $0% d.14)2 %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% 4#1 &04+)#- ^ #"H "# 4 0)-0: $%20 246)$4,)&$ ?4&% ^ 6+%&%#$& 4 &.22%&&7., ="+4, 20%2C "# $0% =4+C%$X& %R2%&&%&S )$& +%420 )& ,)=)$%1 $" 4 &=4,, &%-=%#$ "7 0.=4#C)#1Y /0%+%7"+%S ,%$ .& ,""C 4$ )$& 7)+&$ "77&0""$S !0+)&$)4#)$;S H0)20 ?%24=% $0% H"+,1 +%,)-)"# $04$ &H%6$ H%&$%+# 2)(),)\4$)"#Y >& H% &04,, &%%S !0+)&$)4#)$; #%(%+ 1%(%,"6%1 4& 2,%4+ 4# %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% 4& d.14: )&=S 7)+&$ ?%24.&% =%1)%(4, !4$0",)2)&= 2"=6,%$%,; +%b%2$%1 $0% =4+C%$ ^ =4C)#- $0% (%+; 04#1,)#- "7 ="#%; 4 &)# ^ 4#1 &%2"#1 ?%24.&% *+"$%&$4#$)&= ?%24=% 24.-0$ .6 )# $0% 2"=6,%$% ,%-)$)=4$)"# "7 =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%&S 6+4)&)#- 4#1 +%)#7"+2)#- )$& %R2%&&%&S +4$0%+ $04# 2+%4$)#- 4 ="+4, 20%2C "# $0%=Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AAT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AA8

!0+)&$)4#)$; 4+"&% 7+"= 4="#- $0% d%H)&0 \%4,"$& "7 $0% 7)+&$ 2%#$.+; ^ 4$ $0% $)=% "7 $0%)+ ),,:74$%1 +%(",.$)"# 4-4)#&$ K"=4# 1"=)#4$)"#YAQ /0% q%4,"$& #"$ "#,; +%()(%1 $0% )1%4& "7 M&4)40S ?.$ $0%; %#2".+4-%1 4,, d%H& $" ,%4(% $0% 2)$)%& %#$)+%,; 4#1 $4C% .6 4# 4&2%$)2 ,)7% )# $0% 1%&%+$ 4#1 $0% =".#$4)#&Y >,, H"+,1,; -""1& ^ 4#1 $0% =4+C%$:+%,4$%1 42$)()$)%& $04$ -%#%+4$%1 $0%= ^ H%+% +%b%2$%1Y /0% &)=6,% 64&$"+4, ,)7% H4& 41"6$%1S 4#1 6.$ 7"+$0 7"+ 4,, 6)".& 6%"6,% $" %=.,4$%Y f.$ "7 $0)& =),)%.S $0% 0)&$"+)24, d%&.& %=%+-%1 ^ )# 4 &%#&%S 4& $0% ,4&$ "7 $0% 6+"60%$&Y E% C#"H #"$0)#- "7 $0% 0)&$"+)24, d%&.&SAJ ?.$ $0% d%&.& "7 $0% @"&6%,& )& ="1%,%1 "# M&4)40Y M&4)40X& H+)$)#-& 4+% 2)$%1 4-4)# 4#1 4-4)# 4& $0% &".+2% 7"+ $0% 6+%1)2$)"# "7 $0% 2"=)#- "7 d%&.&:$0%:3%&&)40Y M# M&4)40:,)C% 74&0)"#S d%&.& -)(%& 4H4; 0)& 2,"4C 4#1 0)& H"+,1,; 6"&&%&&)"#&S 0%4,& $0% &)2C 4#1 $%420%& 2"=64&&)"# 7"+ $0% .#7"+$.#4$%Y >-4)#S 4& M&4)40 =)-0$ 04(%S d%&.& %R6%,& $0% W="#%;204#-%+&X 7+"= $0% $%=6,%S 4#1 6.+)7)%& )$ "7 $0% -+%%1; 6+"7)$:&%%C%+&YAL d%&.& H%#$ )#$" $0% $%=6,% 4#1 1+"(% ".$ 4,, H0" H%+% ?.;)#- 4#1 &%,,)#- )# $0% $%=6,% 6+%2)#2$&a 0% .6&%$ $0% $4?,%& "7 $0% ="#%;: 204#-%+& 4#1 $0% &%4$& "7 $0% 1%4,%+& )# 6)-%"#&S 4#1 &4)1 $" $0%=S W&2+)6$.+% &4;&S =; 0".&% &04,, ?% 24,,%1 4 0".&% "7 6+4;%+a ?.$ ;". 4+% =4C)#- )$ 4 ?4#1)$X& 24(%YXDT G"H $0)& )=4-% ^ "7 d%&.& 1+)()#- ".$ 4,, $0"&% H0" H%+% ?.;)#- 4#1 &%,,)#- 4#1 204#-)#- ="#%; ^ ?%2"=%& 4 6"H%+7., 4#$):=4+C%$ )=4-% ,4$%+ "# )# !0+)&$)4# 0)&$"+;S 4& )$ %(",(%1 )# =%1)%(4, <.+"6%Y E% &04,, 2"=% ?42C $" $0)& )=4-%Y ].$S )# $0% %4+,; ;%4+& "7 !0+)&$)4# 1%(%,"6=%#$S $0% 7"2.& "7 $0% #%H +%,)-)"# H4& "# d%&.&S $0% &"# "7 F4()1S $0% &4()"+S $0% 3%&&)40S $0% 20"&%# "#% ^ $0)& )& $0% d%&.& $0% q%4,"$& H".,1 04(% C#"H#Y /0%#S 47$%+ $0% 1%4$0 "7 d%&.&S *%$%+D8 041 4 ()&)"#S 4#1 *4.,DA H+"$% $0% 7)+&$ H"+C& 1%&2+)?)#- 4 1)77%+%#$ d%&.&Y d%&.& H4& $0% &"# "7 @"1S ?"+# "7 4 ()+-)#S 1)%1 7"+ $0% &)#& "7 =4#C)#1S 4#1 $0%# H4& +%&.++%2$%1 4#1 b")#%1 @"1: $0%:74$0%+Y /0)& H4& 1)77%+%#$ 7+"= $0% ?%,)%7& "7 $0% q%4,"$& 4#1 041 4 $+%=%#1".& 466%4, $" $0% @+%%C& 4#1 5;+)4#& 7"+ $H" +%4&"#&' 7)+&$S $0)& #%H d%&.& H4& 2"#&)&$%#$ H)$0 $0% @+%%C F)"#;&.& 4#1 H)$0 $0% 5;+)4# >1"#)&Y >#1 &%2"#1S ?%24.&% 4 #%H 7"+= "7 0"6% H4& 0%,1 ".$ $" 4,, $0"&% H0" 2"#(%+$%1 ^ $04$ )&S )7 $0%; 422%6$%1 d%&.& 4& $0% 3%&&)40 ^ +(",3173 )# @+%%CS H0)20 H4& $0% 2,-.<% $"%-&% "7 $0% =)11,% %4&$ 4$ $04$ $)=% ^ $0%+% H4& 0"6% 7"+ $0%)+ "H# +%?)+$0 4#1 &4,(4$)"#Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

>.*"&/+)+2- .3' *"# %#9#)*+&3 &1 -.%6#* .)*+,+*+#2

/0.&S 7+"= $0% M&4)40:,)C% 3%&&)40 "7 $0% q%4,"$&S d%&.& ?%24=% $0% &"# "7 @"1S 1;)#- 7"+ ".+ &)#& 4#1 $0%# ?%2"=)#- +%&.++%2$%1 4#1 +%?"+#Y /0% F)"#;&.&:,)C%DD d%&.& H4& &)=),4+ $" >1"#)&SDI $0% 1;)#@"1 "7 $0% 5;+)4# 7%+$),)$; 2.,$&S 4#1 H4& 6+"?4?,; 1%+)(%1 7+"= $0% =.20 ",1%+ f&)+)& 4#1 M&)& $0%","-; "7 $0% 3)11,% Z)#-1"= <-;6$)4#&SDO H0)20 =41% 2%#$+4, $0% 1;)#- @"1 4#1 0)& +%?)+$0S 4#1 4,&" -4(% 0)= ^ f&)+)& ^ $0% +",% "7 4+?)$%+ "7 b.&$)2% 4$ $0% %#$+4#2% $" $0% &".,X& b".+#%; $" $0% 47$%+:,)7%YDP M&)& 4#1 0%+ )#74#$ &"# 9"+.&DQ ?%24=% $0% ="1%,& 7"+ $0% 0,#1%b &$4$.%& "7 34+; 4#1 d%&.&S 7".#1 $0+".-0".$ K"=% )# $0% %4+,; ;%4+& "7 !0+)&$)4#)$;Y /0% @+%%C&S %&6%2)4,,;S ,)C%1 *4.,X& d%&.&S 7"+ 0% H4& F)"#;&.&:,)C%S 4#1 $0% F)"#;&)4# 2.,$ H4& $0% =4b"+ 2.,$ "7 $0% @+%%C& 4$ $04$ $)=%YDJ >#1 *4.,S 04()#- -+"H# .6 H)$0 $0% @+%%C& )# /4+&.&S 4#1 ?%)#- 7,.%#$ )# $0%)+ ,4#-.4-% 4#1 2.&$"=&S $4.-0$ $0% @+%%C& $04$ $0%; 1)1 #"$ 04(% $" 2)+2.=2)&% $0%=&%,(%& $" 2"#(%+$ $" $0% #%H +%,)-)"# ^ 7"+ $0% @+%%C& ?%,)%(%1 $04$ 2)+2.=2)&)"# H4& 6%#)&:=.$),4$)"#YDL >#1 *4., $4.-0$ $0%= $04$ $0%; 1)1 #"$ 04(% $" 7",,"H d%H)&0 7""1:$4?""&Y E)$0 $0% 204#-%& )# $0%","-; 4#1 +)$.4,S !0+)&$)4#)$; H4& ?"+# 4& 4 &%64+4$% +%,)-)"# 7+"= d.14)&=S 4,$0".-0 d%&.&S 4& !0+)&$:$0%:3%&&)40S H4& +%$4)#%1Y 9%#2% $0% #4=% "7 $0% #%H +%,)-)"# ?%&$"H%1 .6"# )$ )# >#$)"20Y B%$ .& +%$.+#S 0"H%(%+S $" !0+)&$)4#)$; 4#1 )$& +%,4$)"# $" =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2&Y M$ H4& #"$ )# @+%%2% "+ 5;+)4S ?.$ )# K"=4#)\%1 <.+"6% $04$ !0+)&$)4#: )$;X& 4#$):=4+C%$ )1%","-; 1%(%,"6%1Y /0% @+%%C f+$0"1"R !0.+20 #%(%+ ?4##%1 =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%&S 7"+ $0%&% H%+% $0% =4b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AAA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b%2$)"# "7 W$0)&:H"+,1,;X 42$)()$)%& ?%2"=% $04$ 4,, 42$)()$)%&S &4(% $0"&% "7 $0% 2%,)?4$% "+1%+&S H%+% ,""C%1 1"H# .6"# 4& 6+"74#%Y /0.&S )$ 24=% 4?".$ 7+"= $0% F4+C >-%& )#$" $0% 3)11,% >-%& $04$ =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%& H%+% ,""C%1 .6"# 4& &)#7.,S 4#1 $04$ $0% (%+; 04#1,)#- "7 ="#%; H4& %#".-0 $" 1%7),% $0% &".,Y N#7"+$.#4$%,; 7"+ $0% d%H&S 04()#- ?%2"=% 4 #4$)"# "7 &=4,, ?.&)#%&&: =%# 4#1 ="#%; ,%#1%+& )# 564)#S M$4,;S 4#1 5".$0%+# @%+=4#;S $0% +",% "7 ="#%;:04#1,)#- ^ )#2,.1)#- $4R:2",,%2$)#- ^ 4#1 $+41)#-S H4& ,%7$ )# $0%)+ 04#1&Y /0% d%H& ?%24=% (),)7)%1 7"+ ?%)#- $0% W="#%;:204#-%+&XS 4#1 $0% )=4-% "7 !0+)&$ %R6%,,)#- W4,, $0"&% H0" H%+% ?.;)#- 4#1 &%,,: )#-X 4#1 "(%+$.+#)#- $0% $4?,%& 4#1 &$4,,& "7 $0% W="#%;:204#-%+&X $""C "# #%H =%4#)#-Y 504C%&6%4+%X& ?#"&(%-1 7$ S#-,&#IP 1%&2+)?%& $0% .#7"+: $.#4$% &)$.4$)"# "7 $0% d%H&Y M# $%+=& "7 !4$0",)2)&=S $0%#S 4& $0% K%#4)&&4#2% %=%+-%1 4#1 2)$)%& 4#1 $+41% ?%24=% 2%#$+4, 4-4)#S $0% K"=4# 20.+20 "66"&%1 &.20 42$)(: )$)%&Y M# M$4,; )$&%,7S $0% H%4,$0; =%+204#$& -4)#%1 2"#$+", "7 $0% 64642; ^ 54("#4+",4 H4& ?.+#%1 4$ $0% &$4C%S #"$ B"+%#\" 1) 3%1)2)IQ ^ 4#1 )-#"+%1 $0% 20.+20X& 4#$):=4+C%$ +%&$+)2$)"#&Y /0% M$4,)4# =%+204#$& ?%24=% &" H%4,$0; $0%; 24,,%1 $0%=&%,(%& W6+)#2%&X 4#1 W1.C%&XS $0".-0 $0%; 0%,1 #" 7%.14, $)$,%&Y ].$ $0% !4$0",)2 )1%","-;S ?%24.&% )$ H4& &" 2"=6,%$%,; 4#$):=4+C%$S #%(%+ &%+(%1 4& 4 20%2C "# =4+C%$ 4="+4,)$; "+ &%,7)&0#%&&Y /0% +)20 M$4,)4# =%+204#$& H%+% C#"H# 7"+ $0%)+ 64$+"#4-% "7 $0% 4+$& 4#1 $0%)+ =4-#)7)2%#$ 64,42%&S ?.$ $0%; H%+% #"$ C#"H# 7"+ $0%)+ C)#1#%&&S -%#%+"&)$;S "+ 0.=4#)&$)2 24+)#- 7"+ $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$%YIJ M# 742$S $0% )#2+%1)?,% H%4,$0 4#1 ,.R.+)".& ,)7%:&$;,% "7 $0% M$4,)4# =%+204#$&S 2"=?)#%1 H)$0 $0% >.-.&$)#)4# 1%#.#2)4$)"# "7 &.20 42$)(: )$)%& 0%,6%1 %#-%#1%+ $0% *+"$%&$4#$ K%7"+=4$)"#Y /0% K%7"+=4$)"#S ;".

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AAD

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f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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AAI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

9"H%(%+S .#,)C% )# d.14)&=S H0%+% $0% 204+)$4?,% "+-4#)\4$)"#& 4+% 6+)(4$%,;:+.# 2"==.#4, -+".6&S )# !4$0",)2)&=S $0% 204+)$)%& 4+% !4$0",)2 204+)$)%& ^ $04$ )&S +.# ?; $0% 20.+20 )$&%,7S 41=)#)&$%+%1 4#1 &%+()2%1 ?; 6+)%&$&S #.#& 4#1 ="#C& 4& $0% 1)+%2$ 4-%#$& "7 204+)$4?,% &%+()2%&Y f7 2".+&%S ,4; !4$0",)2& 04(% ?%2"=% )#(",(%1 )# $0% 1%,)(%+; "7 204+)$4?,% &%+()2%&S ?.$ $0% !0.+20 )& )# 7.,, 2"#$+", )# $%+=& "7 ="#%; 4#1 6",)2)%&Y /0".-0 20.+20:1"=)#4$%1S #"#%$0%,%&& !4$0",)2 204+)$; "+-4#)\4$)"#& 04(% ?%%# &.22%&&7., )# 6+"()1)#- &%+()2%& 7"+ $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$%Y 9"H%(%+S #" 1%%6 %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2% %=%+-%& 7+"= !4$0",)2 $0%","-;Y f#% &)=6,; -)(%& $" $0% !0.+20S 4#1 $0% !0.+20 1%2)1%& H04$ )& b.&$ 4#1 H04$ )& #"$Y /0%+%7"+%S $0".-0 $0% 6"6%& "7 $0% 6"&$: 5%2"#1 E"+,1 E4+ 6%+)"1 04(% 2"#&)&$%#$,; 6+%420%1 !0+)&$)4# 204+)$;S !4$0",)2 $0%","-; 1"%& #"$ 6+%&%#$ 4 $+.% 20%2C "# ="1%+# =4+C%$ %R2%&&%&S ?.$ 466%4+&S +4$0%+S 4& 4 e.4)#$ =%1)%(4, W4,=&X +%e.%&$S .#+%,4$%1 $" $0% &"2)4, 2"#1)$)"#& "7 $0% 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$ -,"?4, (),,4-%Y /0% $%+= W4,=&:-)()#-X ?+)#-& .& $" $0% &42+%1 "77&0""$ "7 d.14)&=S M&,4= ^ $0% #%H +%,)-)"# $04$ &$.##%1 $0% H"+,1S &6+%41)#- ="+% +46)1,; $04# 4#; "$0%+ +%,)-)"#S 4#1 %R$%#1)#- 7+"= 564)# $" M#1"#%&)4 ?%$H%%# 466+"R)=4$%,; >F QTT 4#1 LTTY D2/.- .3' *"# -.%6#*0 $%&2$#% .3' 4+,# ./-2 *& *"# 3##'7 M&,4= 4+"&% 1.+)#- $0% &%(%#$0 2%#$.+; >FS )# 4 d%H)&0S !0+)&$)4# 4#1 34#)20%4# 2"#$%R$Y /0% H"+,1 "7 $0% 3)11,% <4&$ H4& 1"=)#4$%1 ?; $0% ];\4#$)#% @+%%C&Y @+%%C ,4#-.4-%S @+%%C 60),"&"60;SIL @+%%C &2)%#2%S 4#1 @+%%C f+$0"1"R !0+)&$)4#)$; H%+% 0%,1 )# 0)-0 %&$%%=Y *%+&)4# 34#)20%4# _q"+"4&$+)4#` 1.4,)&= ^ 7"2.&)#- "# @"1 4#1 54$4#S 0%4(%# 4#1 0%,,S 4#1 $0% d.1-%=%#$ F4; ^ H4& 4,&" &$),, (%+; =.20 4 64+$ "7 $0% 3)11,% <4&$%+# 2.,$.+4, =)RY 3"04==%1 0)=&%,7S 4# "+604#S +4)&%1 ?; 0)& .#2,% H0" H4& 4 24+: 4(4# =%+204#$S -+%H .6 2,"&% $" $0% d%H)&0 2"==.#)$; )# 3%224 ^ H0)20 H4& $0% &42+%1 2%#$%+ 7"+ >+4? 64-4# 6",;$0%)&=S H)$0 $0% Z4?4S $0% ,4+-% ?,42C &$"#%S 4$ )$& 2%#$%+Y U+"= $0% d%H&S 3"04==%1 ,%4+#%1 "7 ="#"$0%)&= 4#1 $0% ,4H& "7 3"&%&Y /0%&% 2"#2%6$& 0% )#2"+6"+4$%1 )#$" 0)& #%H +%,)-)".& ()&)"#Y U+"= $0% !0+)&$)4#&S 0% ,%4+#%1 "7 +%1%=6$)"# $0+".-0 2"#(%+&)"#Y >#1S $0".-0 0% +%b%2$%1 $0% $+)#)$; 4#1 $0% ?%,)%7 $04$ d%&.& H4& $0% &"# "7 @"1 ^ 7"+ 4# )#2"+6"+%4, ="#"$0%)&$)2 -"1 2".,1 04(% #" &"# ^ 0% 422%6$%1 d%&.& 4& $0% &%2"#1 W>6"&$,%XS $0% 7)+&$ ?%)#- 3"&%&S 4#1S "7 2".+&%S $0% $0)+1 4#1 ,4&$S ?%)#- 3"04==%1 0)=&%,7Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AAO

3"04==%1 422%6$%1 $0% f,1 /%&$4=%#$ 4& 4 &42+%1 4#1 ,%4+#%1 $%R$S 4#1 0% 422%6$%1 $0% @"&6%,& 4& &42+%1 4#1 ="+4,,; .6,)7$)#-Y ].$S 0% 4,&"S 47$%+ 4 1+%4=:()&)"#S &6"C% $0% Z"+4#S 4& $0% .,$)=4$% &42+%1 &".+2%S H)$0 @"1S W$0% "#%S $0% "#,;S $0% "=#)&2)%#$S $0% 4,, =)-0$;S $0% =%+2)7.,XSOT &6%4C)#- $0+".-0 0)=S $0% ,4&$ >6"&$,%Y U+"= *%+&)4# q"+"4&$+)4#:34#)20%4# )1%4&S 4#1 $0+".-0 $0% ,%#& "7 0)& 2"#$%=6"+4+; d.14)&= 4#1 !0+)&$)4#)$;S 3"04==%1 =41% 2%#$+4, W&.?=)&&)"# $" @"1 4#1 ?%,)%7 )# $0% b.1-%=%#$ 14;XYO8 @"1 )& 4,,: =%+2)7., $" $0"&% H0" &.?=)$ $" 0)= 4#1 ?%2"=% $+.% ?%,)%(%+& ^ $0%; H),, -" $" 0%4(%#S H0),% $0"&% H0" +%7.&% $" ?%,)%(% 4#1 +%=4)# 64-4# )1", H"+&0)6%+& H),, ?.+# )# 0%,,Y M#$%+%&$)#-,;S 4#1 $" 0)& 2+%1)$S 3"04==%1 ^ $0".-0 1%&)+)#- $0%)+ 2"#(%+&)"# ^ $4.-0$ $04$ d%H& 4#1 !0+)&$)4#& 2".,1 -" $" 0%4(%# )7 $0%; 42$%1 %$0)24,,; %(%# )7 $0%; 1)1 #"$ 2"#(%+$Y 9"H%(%+S &"2)4, 4#1 6",): $)24, +%&$+)2$)"#& H%+% 6,42%1 "# $0%=S )# "+1%+ $" 6+%&&.+% $0%= $" 2"#(%+$Y 5$),,S M&,4= +%=4)#%1 74+ ="+% $",%+4#$ $04# !0+)&$)4#)$; $" "$0%+ H"+,1 +%,)-)".& ?%,)%7&Y /0% Z"+4# )& 4 W+%2)$4$)"#X "7 3"04==%1X& +%2",,%2$)"#& "7 $0% f,1 /%&$4=%#$ $4,%& 4#1 @"&6%, &$"+)%&Y /0%&% 4+% +%6%4$%1 "(%+ 4#1 "(%+ 4-4)# )# $0% Z"+4# )# 4??+%()4$%1 (%+&)"#&Y ].$S $0+".-0 $0%=S 3"04==%1 $4.-0$ 0)& 1"2$+)#% "7 ="#"$0%)&=S $0% b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b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d.14)2 2"#1%=#4$)"#

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AAP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AAQ

M# $0% #4=% "7 @"1S $0% 2"=64&&)"#4$%S $0% =%+2)7.,S $0%&% 4+% $0% (%+&%& "7 $0% E)&% ]""CS 4 -.)1% 4#1 4 ?,%&&)#- $" $0% +)-0$%".&S H0" 4$$%#1 $" $0%)+ 6+4;%+&S "#-9#" 1(# %243 2#>)B 4#1 7)+=,; ?%,)%(% )# $0% ,)7% $" 2"=%Y /0%&% 4+% +)-0$,; -.)1%1 ?; $0%)+ B"+1S 4#1 H),, &.+%,; 6+"&6%+Y Y Y Y F" #"$ $+%4$ =%# H)$0 &2"+#S #"+ H4,C 6+".1,; "# $0% %4+$0' @"1 1"%& #"$ ,"(% $0% 4++"-4#$ 4#1 $0% (4)#-,"+)".&Y K4$0%+S ,%$ ;".+ -4)$ ?% ="1%&$ 4#1 ;".+ (")2% ,"Ha $0% 04+&0%&$ "7 (")2%& )& $0% ?+4--)#4&&Y Y YY F" $0%; #"$ &%% $04$ @"1 -)(%& 4?.#14#$,; $" H0"= 9% H),, 4#1 &64+)#-,; $" H0"= 9% 6,%4&%&V 5.+%,; $0%+% 4+% &)-#& )# $0)& 7"+ $+.% ?%,)%(%+&Y /0%+%7"+%S -)(% $0%)+ 1.% $" $0% #%4+ "7 C)#S $" $0% 1%&$)$.$%S 4#1 $" $0% $+4(%,%+ )# #%%1Y /04$ )& ?%&$ 7"+ $0"&% $04$ &$+)(% $" 6,%4&% @"1a &.20 =%# H),, &.+%,; 6+"&6%+Y Y Y Y /04$ H0)20 ;". &%%C $" )#2+%4&% ?; .&.+; H),, #"$ ?% ?,%&&%1 ?; @"1a ?.$ $0% 4,=& ;". -)(% 7"+ 9)& &4C% &04,, ?% +%64)1 $" ;". =4#; $)=%& "(%+Y Y Y Y >$$%#1 $" ;".+ 6+4;%+&S +%#1%+ $0% 4,=& ,%(;S 4#1 "?%; $0% >6"&$,%S &" $04$ ;". =4; ?% &0"H# =%+2;Y Y Y Y M$ &04,, ?% #" "77%#&% 7"+ $0% ?,)#1S $0% ,4=%S 4#1 $0% &)2C $" %4$ 4$ ;".+ $4?,%Y G"+ &04,, )$ ?% 4# "77%#&% 7"+ ;". $" %4$ )# $0% 0".&%& "7 ;".+ 20),1+%#Y Y Y YOA f#% 24# &%% $04$S $0".-0 $+41% 4#1 =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%& 4+% #"$ +%b%2$%1S .&.+; )& &%%# 4& ),,%-)$)=4$%S 4& )# !0+)&$)4#)$;Y ].$ 4,=&:-)()#- ^ 1(# .,>,-. 7$ &(%",1) ^ )& ?.),$ )# $0+".-0 4 ,4H7., ,%(;Y M# M&,4=S "#% )& %#2".+4-%1 $" 6+"&6%+ $0+".-0 $+41% 4#1 =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%&S 4#1 $0%# "#% )& ,4H7.,,; %#b")#%1 $" -)(% $" $0% 6""+ $0+".-0 $0% 4#2)%#$ 4#1 )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1 4,=& ,%(;S "+ $4R 7"+ $0% 6""+Y > W$+4#&7%+ =%204#)&=X )&S $0.&S ?.),$ )#$" M&,4=Y 3"1%+# M&,4= 04& ?%2"=% 0"&$),% $" ="1%+# 246)$4,)&= ^ ?.$ "#,; ?%24.&% )$ )& &%%# 4& WH%&$%+#XS <.+"6%4# 4#1 W)=6%+)4,)&$X )# )#$%#$Y /0%+% )& #" M&,4=)2 ?4# "# =4+C%$ 42$)()$)%& "+ ?4#C)#- ^ $0".-0 $0% 24.$)"# "# .&.+; &$),, &$4#1& )# $0% Z"+4#Y /0%+% )&S 0"H%(%+S 4 +%b%2$)"# "7 $0% )#1)()1.4, 4=4&&)#- "7 H%4,$0 H)$0".$ 4 2"==.#4, &04+)#- H)$0 $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

"7 $0% &%,7)&0 +)20S )$ )& =41% 2,%4+ )# $0% Z"+4# $04$ $0% -""1 =4#S H0" 0466%#& $" ?% +)20S =.&$ -)(% $" $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$% )7 0% %R6%2$& $" -" $" 0%4(%#Y ]; )=6,)24$)"#S )7 0% )& &%,7)&0 4#1 1)&+%-4+1& $0% 6,%4& "7 $0% 6""+S 0% H),, &%% $0% 7)+%& "7 0%,,Y

M&,4=S $0.&S 1"%& =4#14$% 204+)$4?,% C)#1#%&&Y /0% )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\4: $)"# "7 4,=&:-)()#- )& +%6%4$%1 "(%+ 4#1 "(%+ 4-4)# )# $0% Z"+4#Y >#1S $0".-0 $0)& %$0)2 "7 4,=&:-)()#- ,42C& $0% ,"7$)#%&& "7 M&4)40X& %$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b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d.14)&=S )# )$& 4#2)%#$ 604&%S H4& 4#$):="#4+20)24, 4#1 $0%"2+4$)2 )# )$& )1%","-;Y M# $0% 1)4&6"+4 6%+)"1S d.14)&= ?%24=% 46",)$)24,S 4#1S )# )$& ="1%+# 7"+= )& 1)()1%1' $0% =4b"+)$; "7 d%H&S %)$0%+ &%2.,4+ "+ +%7"+=)&$S &$+"#-,; &.66"+$ 1%="2+42; 4#1 ,4H 4& 4 6+"$%2$)"# 4-4)#&$ $0% 6"&&)?),)$; "7 7.$.+% 6%+&%2.$)"#S H0),% $0% .,$+4:"+$0"1"R d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AAJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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e.%&$ 7"+ H)&1"=X ^ W$0% H4;XPT ^ 0% H4& 0%,1 )# ,"H%+ %&$%%= $04# $0% 6%4&4#$S H0" 4$ ,%4&$ H"+C%1 04+1 7"+ 74=),; 4#1 &$4$%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AAL

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e.4,)$; "#% 24# 04(%Y >#1 "#% 24##"$ 1%(%,"6 "#%X& "H# ?%#%(",%#2% H)$0".$ )#2,.1)#- $0% 7.,7),,=%#$ "7 "$0%+& )# $0)& %#1%4("+Y C<4%-,1)B $7" +7-$<&,%-3B 4#%-3 &7D(<4%-,1)a ]%#%(",%#2% )#2,.1%& ?"$0 &%,7: )=6+"(%=%#$ 4#1 =.$.4, )=6+"(%=%#$ ^ )$ 24##"$ ?% 420)%(%1 H)$0".$ 2"#2%+# 7"+ 74=),;S 7+)%#1& 4#1 &"2)%$;Y 5"=%$)=%& !"#7.2).& %(%# 1%7)#%& ?%#%(",%#2% 4& W,"(% 7"+ ;".+ 7%,,"H =%#XYPD !"#7.2).& 4,&" 41("24$%1 4 -"(%+#=%#$ )# H0)20 $0% &"(%+%)-# )& ?%#%(",%#$S $4C)#- 24+% $" 7.,7),, $0% #%%1& "7 $0% 2"=="# 6%"6,%Y f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b.&$)2% H),, ?% 6+"6%+,; &%+(%1 4#1 =%# H),, ?% 2"=64&&)"#:

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ADT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AD8

4$%Y ]%#%(",%#2% )& %&&%#$)4, 7"+ 2+%4$)#- 4 &"2)%$; 2"=6"&%1 "7 ()+: $.".& 6%"6,% H)$0".$ ="+4, 204"&YPQ

]%)#- ="+4, 04& #"$0)#- $" 1" H)$0 &%,7:)#$%+%&$ Y Y Y =4$%+)4, $0)#-& 4+% ,)C%,; $" 1)&$"+$ 4 =4#X& ="+4, b.1-%=%#$ 4#1 1%7,%2$ 0)= 7+"= 0)& ="+4, 6.+6"&%Y U"+S ?%7"+% 4 =4# -%$& H04$ 0% H4#$&S 0% H"++)%& ,%&$ 0% &0".,1 #"$ -%$ )$Y >7$%+ 0% 04& -"$ )$S 0% H"++)%& ,%&$ 0% &0".,1 ,"&% )$S 4#1 H0%# $04$ 0466%#& 0% H),, #"$ &$"6 4$ 4#;$0)#-YPJ /0)& )& 4 &$+"#- H4+#)#- $04$ 2"#2%+# H)$0 $0% 422.=.,4$)"# "7 -""1& =4; #"$ ?+)#- "#% 0466)#%&&S ?.$ +4$0%+ 6.$ "#% )#$" 4 &$4$% "7 4#R)%$; 4#1 &%,7:2%#$%+%1#%&&Y G"HS %(%# $0".-0 !"#7.2).&X H4+#)#- "# 42e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f?%1)%#2% 4#1 +%&6%2$ 7"+ %,1%+& ^ X7),)4, 6)%$;X ^ )& 1%%6,; )#-+4)#%1 )# !"#7.2)4# 2.,$.+%&Y 9"H%(%+S )# 9"#- Z"#- 4#1 Z"+%4 e.)2C,;S 4#1 )# 5)#-46"+% 4#1 d464# &,"H,;S 4 1%="2+4$)2 W2)(), &"2)%$;X 2.,$.+% )& %=%+-)#-Y >#1S )# !0)#4S $0% 1%="2+42; ="(%=%#$ 2%+$4)#,; 04& $4C%# 0",1 4="#- &$.1: %#$&S )#$%,,%2$.4,&S 4#1 .+?4# H"+C%+&YQT 5"S H% &04,, &%% H0%$0%+ !"#7.2)4#)&= +%=4)#& 4# )=6%1)=%#$ $" 1%="2+42;Y ].$ H04$ "7 7+%%:=4+C%$ 42$)()$)%& 4#1 $0% 2"=6%$)$)(%S )#1)()1.4,)&$)2S ,.R.+;:-""1& "+)%#$%1 2.,$.+% $0% =4+C%$ %#-%#1%+&V !"#7.2)4#)&= H4&S 4& =%#$)"#%1S 0"&$),% $" 6+)(4$% H%4,$0 422.=.,4: $)"#&S 4#1 H04$ )$ ()%H%1 4& $0% &%,7)&0S 7+.)$,%&& e.%&$ 7"+ =4$%+)4, $0)#-&Y 9"H%(%+S )+"#)24,,;S $0% !0)#%&% ?.&)#%&& 2,4&& 1%(%,"6%1 (%+; &.22%&&7.,,; 7<13,9# !0)#4S )# $0% *42)7)2 K)= "7 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4Y >#1S #"H )# $0% 2"#$%=6"+4+; H"+,1S $0)& !0)#%&% ?.&)#%&& 2,4&& 7+"=

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

M# $%+=& "7 6%+&"#4, ="+4, 1%(%,"6=%#$ 4#1 $0% 422.=.,4$)"# "7 =4$%+)4, $0)#-& 4#1 ,.R.+; H%4,$0S $0)& )& H04$ !"#7.2).& $4.-0$'

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`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e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

@#)(/.% )"#)62 &3 *"# #B)#22#2 &1 *"# -.%6#* >,"#- H)$0 +%,)-)".& 20%2C&S $0%+% 04(% ?%%# &%2.,4+ )1%","-)%& $04$ 04(% 24++)%1 H)$0)# $0%= %$0)24, +%&$+4)#$& "# &%,7)&0 )#1)()1.4,: )&= 4#1S $0% W)7 )$ &%,,&S &%,, )$X 4="+4,)$; %#1%=)2 $" $0% 7+%%:=4+C%$ &;&$%=Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ADA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

5"2)4,)&=S "7 2".+&%S )# 4,, )$& 7"+=&S 4+"&% 4& 4 +%42$)"# $" $0% %R2%&&%& "7 $0% =4+C%$Y ].$ &"S $""S 04& 2"#&$)$.$)"#4, ,4H ^ &64H#%1 ?; $0% =4+C%$ ^ &%+(%1 $" 2.+? $0% &%,7)&0#%&& 4#1 4="+4,)$;S ?; =4C)#- 2%#$+4, $0% )1%4 "7 W0.=4# +)-0$&X 4#1 ?; %&$4?,)&0)#- 2%+$4)# %$0)24, &$4#14+1& 4& )#0%+%#$ )# ,%-4, 4.$0"+)$; )$&%,7Y U)#4,,;S &%2.,4+ _4#1 +%,)-)".&`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p.4C%+&S $0% >=)&0SQA $0% 3%##"#)$%&a &"=% H%+% &%2.,4+S &.20 4& $04$ "7 K"?%+$ fH%#&QD "+ $0% ="1%+# M&+4%,) C)??.$\)=YQI ].$ 4,, %R0)?)$%1 4 +%$.+# $" $0% &)=6,% 4-+4+)4# 64&$S 4#1 4,, H%+% $+.,; 2"==.#4,Y /0% 6+"?,%= H)$0 $0%&% .$"6)4# &"2)4,)&$ 2"==.#)$)%& H4& $04$ $0% 7.$.+% ,4; H)$0 $0% =4+C%$ %2"#"=)%& "7 $0% 2)$)%&Y >#1S H0%# ?.&)#%&&: =%# )# <#-,4#1S 9",,4#1S 4#1 $0% N5> 4146$%1 =420)#% $%20#","-; $" $0% 246)$4,)&$ =4+C%$ &;&$%=S 4 =)-0$; )#1.&$+)4, +%(",.$)"# "22.++%1 $04$ ,%7$ .$"6)4# &"2)4,)&= ?%0)#1 4& 4 e.4)#$ +%=)#1%+ "7 4# )1%4,)\%1 64&$Y <(%# ?%7"+% $0% 246)$4,)&$:)#1.&$+)4, %R64#&)"#S 1.+)#- $0% U+%#20 +%(",.$)"#S &"=% )#$%,,%2$.4,& ^ 4$$420%1 $" $0% ?.+%4.2+4$)2 &$4$% "7 $0% 2",,46&)#- ="#4+20; ^ 6+"b%2$%1 $0% )1%4 "7 4 7.$.+% &"2)4,)&$ %2"#: "=; 41=)#)&$%+%1 ?; $0% 31%1# 7"+ $0% -""1 "7 4,,YQO /"2e.%(),,%QP +4),%1 4-4)#&$ $0)& )1%4S H4+#)#- "7 $0% 4.$0"+)$4+)4# $%#1%#2)%& )# 4,, ?.+%4.: 2+42)%& ^ %&6%2)4,,; -"(%+#=%#$ ?.+%4.2+42)%& _4,$0".-0 $0% ?.+%4.: 2+42; "7 $0% !4$0",)2 !0.+20 H4& 4,&" 2+)$)2)\%1 )# $0)& H4;`Y 9"H%(%+S $0% U+%#20 &"2)4,)&$& 6%+&)&$%1S 4#1 -%#%+4$%1 4 ?,.%6+)#$ 7"+ H04$ $0%; ?%,)%(%1 H".,1 ?% 4 &$4$%:+.#S ;%$ ="1%+#)\)#-S %2"#"=; $04$ H".,1 6+"()1% %2"#"=)2 H%,,:?%)#- 7"+ %(%+;"#% ^ %e.4,,; ^ H)$0 #" 4+)&$": 2+4$)2 &$4$.& 4#1 H%4,$0 1)&$)#2$)"#&Y /0% 246)$4,)&$:)#1.&$+)4, +%(",.$)"# )# <#-,4#1 &%%=%1 $" =4C% $0)& U+%#20 &$4$%:&"2)4,)&$ ()&)"# 0%33#NY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 ADD

<#$%+ 34+RY Z4+, 34+R 4146$%1 $0% U+%#20 &$4$%:&"2)4,)&$ ="1%, $" $0% %=%+-)#)#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=; 0% &4H ?%7"+% 0)= 1.+)#- 0)& ;%4+& )# <#-,4#1Y 34+R $0%"+)\%1 $04$ $0% ="&$ 41(4#2%1 &2)%#$)7)2 4#1 $%20#","-)24, )#1.&$+)4,: )&= 2".,1 ?% ,)#C%1 #"$ "#,; $" $0% &%,7)&0 ?.&)#%&& 2,4&&S ?.$ H)$0 4# 4,,: &04+)#- 2"==.#)&$ &$4$%YQQ M# 742$S 34+R 6+%1)2$%1 $04$S 47$%+ $0% 246)$4,)&$:)#1.&$+)4, W&$4-% "7 0)&$"+;X $0%+% H".,1 ?% 4 #%H 6+"-+%&&)(% &$4-% "7 0)&$"+;' $0% &"2)4: ,)&$:)#1.&$+)4, &$4-%Y M# $0)& &$4-% "7 0)&$"+;S $0% )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=; H".,1 ?% $4C%# 4H4; 7+"= $0% +)20 246)$4,)&$&S 4#1 41=)#)&$%+%1 ?; 4 2"=?)#4$)"# "7 H"+C%+&X 2"==)$$%%&S 4$ $0% 742$"+; ,%(%,S 4#1 2"==.#: )&$ 64+$; "77)2)4,& 4$ $0% #4$)"#4, ,%(%,YQJ f7 2".+&%S 34+R $0%# 1+)7$%1 )#$" .$"6)4# $0)#C)#- 0)=&%,7Y U"+S 4& )& &" H%,, C#"H#S 0% %#()&)"#%1 $0% 7)#4, &$4-% "7 0)&$"+; ^ W$0% %#1 "7 0)&$"+;XQL ^ )# H0)20 W$0% &$4$% H".,1 H)$0%+ 4H4;XS 4#1 )# H0)20 $0%+% H".,1 ?% #" 2,4&& 1)&$)#2$)"#&S 4#1 %(%+;"#% H".,1 &04+% %e.4,,;S W422"+1)#- $" $0%)+ #%%1XS )# $0% 4?.#14#2% -%#%+4$%1S 4#1 )# H0)20 %420 )#1)()1.4, H".,1 2"#$+)?.$% W422"+1)#- $" $0%)+ 4?),)$;XS $" &"2)%$; H)$0 0)& "+ 0%+ .#)e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b.&$ 4 7+"#$ 7"+ ?".+-%")& ",)-4+20;Y K%b%2$)#- 4#1 1%#)-+4$)#- $0% 6",)$)24, &;&$%= 2+47$%1 1.+)#$0% <#,)-0$%#=%#$S 4#1 1)&=)&&)#- $0% 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=; 4& .#: #%2%&&4+; $" )#1.&$+)4,)&=S $0% 2"==.#)&$& %#1%1 .6 2+%4$)#- 4# 4.$0"+)$4+)4# &$4$% H)$0 4 ?.+%4.2+4$)2 %2"#"=;Y /"2e.%(),,% 6+"(%1 $" ?% 2"++%2$S $0% U+%#20 &$4$)&$:&"2)4,)&$& H+"#-Y /0% &$4$%:+.# )#1.&$+)4, %2"#"=)%& 04(% 6+"(%# $" ?% )#%77)2)%#$ 4#1 .#6+"1.2$)(%S H0),%S "7 2".+&%S $0% 2"==.#)&$ 64+$; -"(%+#=%#$& 04(% 6+"(%# $" ?% =.+1%+".&,; 1)2$4$"+)4,S $0".-0 )+"#)24,,; _4#1 =%+2)7.,,;`S $%=6"+4+;Y E0; 1)&2.&& &"2)4,)&= 4#1 2"==.#)&= H0%# $0%; 04(% 74),%1V ]%24.&% 4,"#- $0% H4;S 4 -+".6 "7 M#47&"%1,& @7&,%2,313 &6,)$ "77 7+"= $0% +%(",.$)"#4+; ="(%=%#$S 4#1 ?%-4# 4 +%7"+=)&$ 6+"-+4= H0)20 )& #"$ "#,; &$),, +%,%(4#$ .#1%+ ="1%+# 0)-0:$%20 2"#1)$)"#&S ?.$ H0)20

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ADI +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

)& &$),, 7.#2$)"#)#- 4& 4# 4,$%+#4$)(% ="1%, $" $0% ="+% 6.+%,; 7+%%: =4+C%$ ="1%, "7 $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&YJ8 /" $0% 2+%1)$ "7 $0% 2"==.#)&$&S 1.+)#- $0% 8JIT& $" $0% 8JQT&S $0%; 2+%4$%1 4 +%7"+= 6+"-+4= $04$ H4& 1%(%,"6%1 $" +%1.2% $0% %R2%&&)(% H%4,$0 )#%e.4,)$)%& "7 246)$4,)&=Y K%4,)\)#- $04$ $0% +%(",.$)"# =)-0$ #"$ ?% #%4+ 4$ 04#1S 4 H0",% &%+)%& "7 $+4#&7%+ =%204#)&=&S &"2)4, &%+()2%&S 4#1 &47%$;:#%$ =%4&.+%& 7"+ H"+C%+& H%+% 1%(%,"6%1Y E0%# $0% F%="2+4$)2 5"2)4,)&$& 1%2)1%1 $" &%$ 4&)1% +%(",.$)"#4+; 1+%4=&S 4#1 H"+C H)$0)# 246)$4,)&$ &"2)%$)%& $" ?"$0 7"&$%+ 1%="2+42; 4#1 &"2)4,: )&=S $0%; 41"6$%1 $0% +%7"+=)&$ 6,4$7"+= 4& $0%)+ "H#Y f(%+ $0% ;%4+&S )# 524#1)#4()4S @%+=4#;S /0% G%$0%+,4#1&S U+4#2%S M$4,;S 4#1 #"H 564)#S &"2)4,)&$ 64+$)%& 04(% 2"=% $" 6"H%+ %,%2$"+4,,;S 4#1 04(% )#$+"1.2%1 &"2)4,)&$ 6+"-+4=& H0)20 4$$%=6$S -71 17 ,-1#"$#"# ;,1( 1(# $"## 4%"I#1 )# )$& 6+"1.2$)(% &$+.2$.+%S ?.$ $" "#9,31",A<1# )$& H%4,$0 ="+% %e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 ADO

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e.)$% H%,, )# <.+"6%Y ].$ H),, )$ 741% 4& 2"#&.=%+)&= 4#1 $0% =4&& =%1)4 %#-.,7 $0% ;".#-%+ -%#%+4$)"# )# <.+"6%S 4#1 -,"?4,,;V M7 )$ 741%&S $0% .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0 H),, H"+&%#S &%+()2%& H),, ?% 2.$ ?42C 4#1 #%-,%2$%1S 4#1 &%,7)&0 )#1)()1.4,)&= =4; &)=6,; ?%2"=% $0% H"+,1 %$0)2Y f+S $0% 0)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&$ %2"#"=; =4; %#-%#1%+ &.20 4# )#2+%1: )?,% W4?.#14#2%XJO $04$ F%="2+4$)2 5"2)4,)&= =)-0$ ?%2"=% 64&&%hS ,)C% 4-+4+)4# &"2)4,)&=Y M# $0% 2"#$%=6"+4+; H"+,1S 0"H%(%+S H0%+% &%+()2%& 4+% &$),, &24+2% 4#1 H%4,$0 )#%e.4,)$)%& &$),, )==%#&%S F%="2+4$)2 5"2)4,: )&$ =%204#)&=& 4+% &$),, 4# %77%2$)(% =%$0"1 "7 2.+?)#- $0% =4+C%$X& %R2%&&%&Y W.*+&3./ )&32*+*(*+&3./ /.8 .2 . )"#)6 &3 *"# .-&%./+*7 &1 *"# -.%6#* K4$)"#4, ,4HS 4& 1%&2+)?%1S H4& -%#%+4$%1 ?; =4+C%$ %2"#"=)2 42$)()$)%& )# )$& "+)-)#&YJP !"#$+42$ ,4H -+%H )#$" 2)()2 ,4HS H0)20 ^ )# 7+%%:=4+C%$ &"2)%$)%& "#,; ^ ?%24=% $0% ?4&)& 7"+ 1%="2+4$)2 2"#&$)$.$)"#4, ,4HY !"#&$)$.$)"#4, ,4H %#-%#1%+%1 &"2)%$)%& )# H0)20 2#.%2 %<1(7",1)JQ ".$: H%)-0%1 C)#-,; 1%2+%%&S ?.+%4.2+4$)2 +.,%& 4#1 +%-.,4$)"#&S +%,)-)".& %$0)24, 2"1%&S 4#1 2.&$"=4+; #"+=&Y E0; 1" M =%#$)"# $0)&V ]%24.&% H% 04(% 1%&2+)?%1 0"H $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ 24# ?%2"=% 4="+4,' WM7 )$ &%,,&S &%,, )$YX /0)& =4+C%$ 4="+4,)$; 04& 4,H4;& ?%%# 20%2C%1 ?; +%,)-)".& %$0)24, 2"1%&Y 9"H%(%+S H)$0 H"+,1 +%,)-)"#& 1%2,)#)#- )# $0%)+ 0",1 "# 6%"6,%S )# $0% 742% "7 $0% -,"?4, =4+C%$ 4#1 )$& =4&& =%1)4S $0% ,4H )$&%,7 =4; ?%2"=% $0% ,4&$ ?4&$)"# "7 ="+4,)$;Y /04$ )&S $0".-0 1%="2+4$)2 2"#&$)$.$)"#4, 2"1%& "7 ,4H 4+% ?4&%1 "# +%,)-)".& 4#1 2.&$"=4+; ="+4,)$;S W$0% ,4HX )& 1)77%+%#$ 7+"= $0%&% 2"1%&Y M$ )& 1)77%+%#$ ?%24.&% )$ )& +4$)"#4, 4#1 4=%#14?,% 4#1 1%?4$: 4?,%YJJ ]%24.&% $0% ,4H 24# 204#-% 4& H"+,1 2"#1)$)"#& 204#-%S 4#1 ?%24.&% $0% =4)# ?"1; "7 $0% 2"#&$)$.$)"#4, ,4H +%=4)#& &$4?,%S $0%

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ADP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 ADQ

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b"? 4$ 74)+ H4-%&S $0% +)-0$ $" 1%2%#$ 0".&)#-S $0% +)-0$ $" 4# %1.24$)"#S 4#1 $0% +)-0$ $" -""1 0%4,$0S 4+% 4,&" &42+"&4#2$Y /0)& %R$%#&)"# "7 $0% ,)&$ "7 )#4,)%#4?,% +)-0$& $" $0% %2"#"=)2 4#1 &"2)4, &60%+% )& +%b%2$%1 ?; >=%+)24# 2"#&%+(4$)(%&SL8 ?.$ e.)$% 6"6.,4+ )# ="&$ "7 $0% 1%(%,"6)#- H"+,1S 4#1 )# <.+"6%Y >=%+)24# 2"#&%+(4$)(%& ?%,)%(% $04$ $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ )& b.&$ $04$' 7+%%YLA >#1 $04$ $0% =4+C%$S )7 ,%7$ .#7%$$%+%1 ?; -"(%+#=%#$ )#$%+(%#$)"#S H),, 6+"()1% -""1 b"?&S -""1 &20"",&S -""1 0%4,$0 24+%S -""1 0".&)#-S %$2Y >#1 $0% =4+C%$ 1"%& 1%,)(%+S H0%# -)(%# 7+%% +%)-#Y ].$ 4& H% 04(% $+)%1 $" 6")#$ ".$S #"$ 4,, &%+()2%& 4+% 6+"7)$4?,%S 4#1 b"?& 4#1 H%4,$0 4+% .#%e.4,,; 1)&: $+)?.$%1 H)$0)# $0% =4+C%$ &;&$%=Y U.+$0%+="+%S $0% W&)#C "+ &H)=X 4$$)$.1% "7 7.,,:7,%1-%1 7+%%:=4+C%$ 2"#&%+(4$)&= ^ $0".-0 %#-%#1%+)#- 4# )#1%6%#1%#$S &%,7:="$)(4$)#4$$)$.1% )# )#1)()1.4,& H0)20 )& %R2%,,%#$ ^ 2"#$4)#& 4# ".$="1%1 6.+: )$4#:*+"$%&$4#$ ?)4& 4-4)#&$ $0% ,%&& 7"+$.#4$%Y U"+S )7 $0%+% 4+% )#1)()1.4,& H0" 1" ,%&& H%,, ^ %(%# )7 ?%24.&% "7 2)+2.=&$4#2%& ?%;"#1 $0%)+ 6%+&"#4, 2"#$+", ^ $0%; 4+% +%b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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

ADJ +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

^ H)$0)# $0% 2"#$%R$ "7 $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ ^ )& -4)#)#- 2.++%#2; H"+,1:H)1%Y M$ )& 7.,,; 422%6$%1 )# $0% 5"2)4,:F%="2+4$)2 #4$)"#& "7 #"+$0%+# <.+"6%S 4#1 )# U+4#2%S M$4,; 4#1 564)# 4& H%,,Y M$ =4; ?%2"=% 422%6$%1 )# %4&$%+# <.+"6%^6"&$:2"==.#)&$ "+ #"$Y >#1S )$ )& 2%+$4)#,; 422%6$%1 ?; ="&$ 1%(%,"6)#- #4$)"#& ^ .#1%+ H0"&% 6+%&&.+% $0% NG !04+$%+ "7 9.=4# K)-0$& H4& 2"=6"&%1Y E0; )& $0)& ?+"41%#)#- "7 $0% 2"#2%6$)"# "7 W0.=4# +)-0$&X )=6"+$: 4#$V ]%24.&% )$ 6,42%& $0% 2"#2%6$ "7 6+"()1)#- %R2%,,%#$ &"2)4, &%+()2%& ^ &20"",&S 0".&)#-S 0"&6)$4,&S %,1%+ 24+%S 20),1 24+%S 6%#&)"#&S %$2Y ^ H)$0)# $0% 2"#$%R$ "7 "%1,7-%2 2%;Y *%"6,%X& #%%1& 24# ?% 4&&%&&%1 +4$)"#4,,;S 4#1 6+"()1%1 7"+ H)$0 $0% ?%&$ $%20#","-; 4(4),4?,%Y *%"6,%X& #%%1& 24# ?% ()%H%1 4#1 1)&2.&&%1 H)$0)# 4 1%?4$4?,%S 4#1 4=%#14?,% &;&$%=S H0)20 )& "6%# $" $0% 204#: -)#- 2)+2.=&$4#2%& "7 0.=4# &"2)%$)%&Y K4$0%+ $04# ()%H)#- 0.=4# #%%1& $0+".-0 $0% &42+%1 ,%#& "7 4 +)-)1 ="+4, &;&$%= $04$ =)-0$ 04(% %(",(%1 "# 4 6+%:="1%+# &"2)4, ?4&%S $0%&% #%%1& 2".,1 ?% ()%H%1 $0+".-0 $0% 04,,"H%1 ,%#& "7 4# %$0)24, &;&$%= +%)#7"+2%1 ?; $0% 4.$0"+: )$; "7 2"#&$)$.$)"#4, ,4H ^ 4 ,4HS H0)20 $0".-0 +%(%+%1S )& 4?,% $" ?% 204#-%1 H)$0 204#-)#- 2)+2.=&$4#2%&Y /0% $%+= W%#$)$,%=%#$&XLD )& "7$%# .&%1 $" %R6+%&& $0% ,%-4, %R$%#&)"# "7 0.=4# +)-0$& )#$" $0% &"2)4, 7)%,1Y M 1" #"$ 24+% 7"+ $0)& $%+=)#","-;S 7"+ )$ &.--%&$& &"=% &"+$ "7 4++"-4#$ 1%=4#1 7"+ &"2)4, &%+()2%&S "+ H"+&%S &"=% &"+$ "7 ?%--4+X& 1+%4= ^ W@)(% =% %(%+;$0)#-S 7"+ M 1%&%+(% )$S %(%# $0".-0 M 1"#X$ H"+CS M 1"#X$ &4(%S 4#1 M 1"#X$ 24+% 4?".$ 2"==.#)$; #"+=&YX 9.=4#& 4+% #"$ W%#$)$,%1X $" 4#;$0)#- ^ H% =.&$ %4+# ".+ ,)(%,)0""1S 4#1 %4+# $0% +%&6%2$ "7 ".+ 7%,,"H 0.=4#& $0+".-0 04+1 H"+CS -""1 ="+4, 2"#1.2$ 4#1 2"=64&&)"#4$% 42$&Y 5"S H0; =4C% %2"#"=)2 4#1 &"2)4, +)-0$& W)#4,)%#4?,%VX ]%24.&%S W,)7%S ,)?%+$;S 4#1 $0% 6.+&.)$ "7 0466)#%&&XLI 4+% ?%&$ 6+"$%2$%1 H0%# $0% ?4&)2 %2"#"=)2 4#1 &"2)4, #%%1& "7 0.=4#& 4+% -.4+4#$%%1 4& 24+%7.,,; 4& ".+ 6",)$)24, 7+%%1"=Y E% 0",1 $04$ $0)& )& 4 #%H W&%,7:%()1%#$X $+.$0YLO /0.&S .&)#- $0% ,4H ^ +4$)"#4,S 1%?4$4?,%S 4=%#14?,%S ;%$ 04,,"H%1 ^ $" %R$%#1 0.=4# W)#4,)%#4?,% +)-0$&X )#$" $0% %2"#"=)2 4#1 &"2)4, &60%+% 2".,1 ?%2"=% 4 ="1%+# H4; $" 20%2C $0% %R2%&&%& "7 $0% 7+%% =4+C%$ )# $%+=& "7 )$& .#%e.4, 1)&$+)?.$)"# "7 H%4,$0S )$& &%,7)&0 )#1): ()1.4,)&=S 4#1 )$& =4+C%$:4="+4,)$;Y O(-.3+2-0 2#)(/.% .3' %#/+4+&(2 >,$0".-0 $0% H"+,1 )& 4 ()",%#$ 6,42%S 4#1 $0% )=4-%& "7 $0)& ()",%#2%S 4& ()%H%1 $0+".-0 $0% =4&& =%1)4S 04(% ?%2"=% 4,="&$ "(%+: H0%,=)#-S $0%+% )& 4 &$+"#- 0.=4#)&$)2 2.++%#$ $04$ 4,&" 2"#&)&$%#$,;

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 ADL

%R0)?)$& )$&%,7Y E0%# -,"?4, 1)&4&$%+& &$+)C%S $0% 6%"6,% "7 $0% H"+,1 .#)$% $" "+-4#)\% +%,)%7 %77"+$& 7"+ $0% &$+)2C%# 6%"6,%Y /0% 6%"6,% "7 $0% H"+,1 04(% -,41,; 0%,6%1 6,4-.% ()2$)=& )# >7+)24S %4+$0: e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`S &" $04$ $0%; 2".,1 =4C% $0% 2,4)= "7 ?%)#- W-""1XS H)$0".$ 04()#- $" 20""&% 4 64+$)2.,4+ *+"$%&$4#$ &%2$ "+ !4$0",)2)&=Y /0"=4& 3"+% 4#1 $0% <#,)-0$%#=%#$ $0%"+)&$& H%+% H+"#- )# ".+ ()%HY *%"6,% 24# ?% W-""1X ^ $04$ )&S %$0)24,S 24+)#-S 4#1 2"=64&&)"#4$% ^ H)$0".$ ?%,)%()#- )# @"1 "+ $0% d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AIT +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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`S $0% <$0)24, !.,$.+% 5"2)%$;S 54(% $0% !0),1+%#S $0% E"+,1 9%4,$0 f+-4#)\4$)"#S $0% E"+,1 *"6.,4$)"# f+-4#)\4$)"#S 4#1 "7 2".+&%S $0% N#)$%1 G4$)"#& NG<5!f -+".6S 4#1 =4#; "$0%+& H"+,1:H)1%Y G"HS )$ )& 4,&" $+.% $04$ +%,)-)".& 0.=4#)&$)2 -+".6& 04(% ?%%# 42$)(% 4#1 &$+"#- )# $0%)+ 2"==)$=%#$ $" 4,,%()4$% $0% 64)# 4#1 &.77%+)#- "7 $0% H"+,1X& ,%&& 7"+$.#4$% 6%"6,%Y @+".6& ,)C% $0% >=%+)24# U+)%#1& 5"2)%$; 4#1 "$0%+ p.4C%+ "+-4#)\4$)"#&S $0% E"+,1 !".#2), "7 !0.+20%&S $0% &"2)4, &%+()2% 4#1 204+)$4?,% "+-4#)\4$)"#& "7 d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AI8

?)","-)&$&S ,)C% <1=.#1 fY E),&"#S8TA &%%= $" 04(% 4 04+1%+ $)=% .#1%+: &$4#1)#- 4,$+.)&= $04# $0%; 1" 4--+%&&)"#Y [%$S 4,$+.)&= )& #"$ 04+1 $" .#1%+&$4#1' &%",-. %-9 (#20,-. ,40"7># (<4%- 3<">,>%2a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f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e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AIA +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

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e.)("24,,; 2%,%?+4$%1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

L#2,.,7<3 %-9 @#&<2%" +<"A3 AID

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e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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

<6),"-.%' E0; !4+%V

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f7 2".+&%S )++4$)"#4, 4#1 %="$)"#4, 466%4,& 4?".#1S ?.$ .#,)C% )# C)#-&0)6& "+ 1)2$4$"+&0)6&S H0%+%)# )++4$)"#4, %,%=%#$& 6+%1"=)#4$%S )# ,4H7., 1%="2+42)%& $0% +4$)"#4, %,%=%#$& 6+%1"=)#4$%Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

Z0,27.<#= '() +%"#5 AIO

]"$0 ,4H 4#1 1%="2+42; 6.&0 0.=4#& $"H4+1& 4 +4$)"#4, 6+"?,%=: &",()#- "+)%#$4$)"# $" $0% H"+,1Y /0%+%7"+%S ,4H 4#1 1%="2+42; =.&$ ?% 24+%7.,,; =4)#$4)#%1Y >#1 $0% &"2)4,)\4$)"# "7 $0% ;".#- $" ,4H7., 6+": 2%1.+%& "7 6+"?,%=:&",()#- 4#1 1%="2+4$)2 6+"2%&&%& "7 -"(%+#=%#$ =.&$ 4,&" ?% 24+%7.,,; =4)#$4)#%1Y /0% 7+%% =4+C%$ +%)#7"+2%& $0%&% 6+"2%&&%&S ?.$ )$ 4,&" 24++)%& $0% 2".#$%+:6+"2%&&%& "7 4="+4,)$; 4#1 =4&& =%1)4 ()",%#2%Y 5"S )$ ?%2"=%& 4 e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d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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AIP +%",-. +%0,1%2,34

G"$%&

8 5$%60%# 94HC)#-S E(# J,. J%-. E(#7") %-9 1(# c",.,- 7$ 1(# O-,>#"3#S G%H ["+C 4#1 fR7"+1S 8LLPY A >7$%+ &$.1;)#- 9%)&%#?%+-X& W/0%"+; "7 N#2%+$4)#$;XS <)#&$%)# &4)1S WM 1"#X$ ?%,)%(% @"1 $0+"H& 1)2% H)$0 =%#Xa >+)&$"$,%S )# 0)& =%$460;&)2&S 4+-.%1 7"+ 4 W7)+&$ 24.&%X "7 $0% .#)(%+&%a /0"=4& >e.)#4&S 7",,"H)#- >+)&$"$,%S 4$$%=6$%1 $" 6+"(% $0% %R)&$%#2% "7 @"1 .&)#- ,"-)2Y D Z)%+C%-44+1S )# Z,1(#"B c"S G%H ["+CS <(%+;=4#S 8LOD 4#1 54+$+%S )# J#,-. %-9 671(,-.-#33S G%H ["+CS Z#"67S 8LILS &$4$%1 %&&%#$)4,,; $04$S W@"1 )& 1%41Y E% 4+% 4,"#% )# $0% .#)(%+&%YX I K%#%h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c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#S G%H ["+CS c)C)#- *+%&&S 8LOAY 8T >1",60 ]%+,% 4#1 @4+1#%+ 3%4#&S E(# ?79#"- +7"07"%1,7- %-9 !",>%1# !"70#"1)S !0)24-"S N#)(%+&)$; "7 !0)24-" *+%&&S 8LDJY 88 3")+4 d"0#&"#S E%I#7>#"S G%H ["+CS >+?"+ 9".&%S 8LJPa d"0# ]+""C&S E(# E%I#7>#" G%4#S G%H ["+CS #= J,22 G%1#3S G%H ["+CS E),%;S 8LLAY 8D d"&%60 ]Y /4=#%;S E(# @1"<..2# 7>#" @,-.%07"#/3 @7<2S G%H ["+CS E4,$%+ F% @+.;$%+S 8LLPY 8I <=),% F.+C0%)=S E(# L<2#3 7$ @7&,727.,&%2 ?#1(79S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LOIY 8O !Y E+)-0$ 3),,&S '(,1# +722%"S G%H ["+C 4#1 fR7"+1S 8LODY 8P <)#&$%)#X& $0%"+; "7 +%,4$)()$; 4,$%+%1 ".+ 6%+2%6$)"# "7 $0% .#)(%+&%Y 8Q G)%,& ]"0+X& $0%"+; "7 e.4#$.= =%204#)2& 7.+$0%+ 4,$%+%1 ".+ 6%+2%6$)"#& 4#1 +4)&%1 &2)%#$)7)2 $0)#C)#- $" #%H 0%)-0$&Y 8J 9%)&%#?%+-X& .#2%+$4)#$; 6+)#2)6,% 24&$ 1".?$ "# $0% %=6)+)24, 6%+2%6$)"# "7 $0% .#)(%+&%S 4#1 ,%7$ %(%+;"#% )# 2"#7.&)"#S )#2,.1)#- <)#&$%)#Y 8L 94HC)#-X& W])- ]4#-X $0%"+; +%6,42%1 W!+%4$)"#X 4& +%2".#$%1 )# $0% ])?,%Y AT <=),% F.+C0%)=S @<,&,9#S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LOAa &%% 4,&" F.+C0%)=S E(# L<2#3S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LOAY

AIQ

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

C%&/&4(#

AIJ 671#3

8 /0"=4& 34,$0.&S '7"I3S %1)$%1 Y E+)-,%;S B"#1"#S *)2C%+)#- l !04$$"S 8LJPY A 34R E%?%+S E(# !"71#31%-1 Z1(,& %-9 1(# @0,",1 7$ +%0,1%2,34S ]%(%+,; 9),,&S !4,YS K"R?.+; *.?,)&0%+&S 8LLOY D *4., >Y 54=.%,&"#S Z&7-74,&3 _$0% &$4#14+1 $%R$`S 8A$0 <1)$)"#S G%H ["+CS 32@+4H:9),,S 8LJOY I /0"+&$%)#S c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ 1(# H#,3<"# +2%33S G%H ["+CS c)C)#-S 8LPDY 5%% 4,&"S c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#S G%H ["+CS 3%#$"+ ]""C&S 8LOJY O c4#2% *42C4+1S E(# C,99#- !#"3<%9#"3S G%H ["+CS F".?,%14; >#20"+S 8LOQY P Z4+, 34+RS +%0,1%2S G%H ["+CS M#$%+#4$)"#4, *.?,)&0%+&S 8LDIY Q K"?%+$ /0%"?4,1S E(# +(%22#-.# 7$ FA<-9%-&#S ]"&$"#S ]%42"#S 8LPDY J F4#)%, ]%,,S E(# +74,-. 7$ !731D8-9<31",%2 @7&,#1)S G%H ["+CS ]4&)2 ]""C&S 8LPLY L d"0# Z%##%$0 @4,?+4)$0S E(# 6#; 8-9<31",%2 @1%1#S ]"&$"#S 9".-0$"# 3)77,)#S 8LQAY 8T K"# !0%+#"HS E(# C7<3# 7$ ?7".%-S G%H ["+CS >$,4#$)2 3"#$0,; *+%&&S 8LLPY

K !"# @$#)+1+) C.**#%3 &1 @&)+./ C%&;/#-2 [+36#' *& *"# N#8 ?+''/# >/.22 8 34+-4+%$ 3%41S +74,-. 7$ F.# ,- @%47%S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+ *.?,)&0%+&S 8LPJY A <=),% F.+C0%)=S @<,&,9#S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPDY D /0% fR7"+1 5$.1; ])?,%S @%#%&)& _/0% @4+1%# "7 <1%#`S fR7"+1S <#-,4#1S fR7"+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LJPa <(% )& 6.#)&0%1 7"+ %4$)#- "7 $0% $+%% "7 C#"H,%1-% $0+".-0 64)# )# 20),1?)+$0 4#1 &.?"+1)#4$)"# $" 0%+ 0.&?4#1Y I W/0% @"11%&&XS "+ $0% 7%+$),)$; -"11%&&' M&)&S M##4#4S M&0$4+S >60+"1)$% ^ $0% 2.,$ "7 7%+$),)$; =41% 2%#$+4, $0)& -"11%&& H0" 6,4;& 4 6+"=)#%#$ +",% )# $0% +%,)-)"#& "7 <-;6$S 3%&"6"$4=)4 4#1 $0% 3)11,% <4&$ )# -%#%+4,Y O 34R E%?%+S E(# @7&,727.) 7$ L#2,.,7-S )# Z&7-74) %-9 @7&,#1)S /+4#&Y @.#$%+ K"$0 l Z,4.& E)$$)20S G%H ["+CS ]%1=)#&$%+ *+%&&S 8LQJY P M?)1Y Q <=),% F.+C0%)=S E(# Z2#4#-1%") P7"43 7$ L#2,.,7<3 H,$#S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPIY J M?)1Y L /0% U+4#C7"+$ 520"", H+"$% %R$%#&)(%,; "# $0% =4&& =%1)4 4#1 $0% W6"6.,4+ 2.,$.+% )#1.&$+;XY 5%% 9%+?%+$ 34+2.&%S c-# M,4#-3,7-%2 ?%-S ]"&$"#S ]%4: 2"#S 8LP8Y 5%% 4,&"S Z"73 %-9 +,>,2,K%1,7-S ]"&$"#S ]%42"#S 8LOJY 5%% 4,&" %&&4;& ?; 9"+C0%)=%+ 4#1 >1"+#" )# E(# P"%-I$7"1 @&(772S G%H ]+.#&H)2CS K.$-%+& N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LJAY 8T *,4$"S E(# L#0
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

J !"# O+4"5!#)"3&/&47 I)&3&-7 &1 U;(3'.3)#0 :&&'2 ,2 @#%,+)#2

671#3 AIL

8 Z%()# *0),,)6&S F""7.%-1 +%0,1%2S G%H ["+CS K4#1"= 9".&%S 8LLOY A B%&$%+ /0.+"HS C#%9 17 C#%9S <#-,%H""1S GdS *+%#$)2% 94,,S 8LLTa &%% 4,&" K"?%+$ K%)20S E(# E"%-3-%1,7-%2 '7"29 Z&7-74)S ]"&$"#S ]%42"#S 8LLTY D !Y E+)-0$ 3),,&S '(,1# +722%"S G%H ["+C 4#1 fR7"+1S 8LOPY I M# $0% N5> $0% &20"", &0""$)#-& 1.+)#- $0% 8LLT& +%7,%2$ $0)& 7+.&$+4$)"# 4#1 4#-%+S H0),% )# d464#S $0% 0)-0 &.)2)1% +4$% +%7,%2$& $0% &4=% &;#1+"=% _$.+#%1 )#H4+1 "# $0% &%,7`Y M# @%+=4#;S $0% H"+C)#-:2,4&& ?";& b")# #%": G4\) 04$% -+".6&S 4#1 42$ ".$ ()",%#2% )# $0)& H4;Y O M# G"+H4;S 4 6+"-+4= "7 W,)7%$)=%X %1.24$)"# )& #"H .#1%+H4;S 4#1 04& ?%%# (%+; 6"6.,4+Y P /0% ]+)$)&0 ="()%S E(# P<22 ?7-1) &0"H%1 $0)& 60%#"=%#"#S 4#1 $0% 1%&: 6%+4$)"# H0)20 )$ 1+"(% $0% H"+C%+& $"Y Q d4=%& U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-S G%H ["+CS *4#$0%"#S 8LLIY J /0% +%2%#$ ="()% 4?".$ U,)#$ 3)20)-4# 4#1 $0% 2,"&)#- "7 $0% @3 4.$" 6,4#$ $0%+% &0"H& $0% 6,)-0$ "7 $0% .#%=6,";%1 H"+C%+& H%,,Y /0% ="()% H4& 24,,%1 @#%"&(,-. $7" C%";779 ^ 0% ?%)#- $0% !
L !"# @$#)+1+) C.**#%3 &1 @&)+./ C%&;/#-2 I34(/1+34 *"# :/&;./ \3'#%)/.22 8 !04+,%& F)2C%#&S c2,>#" E;,31S G%H ["+CS !",,)%+ ]""C&S 8JOIY 5%% 4,&" F +(",314%3 +%"72S B"#1"#S FY!Y 9%4$0S 8LIQY A c)2$"+ 9.-"S H#3 ?,3#N"%A2#3S G%H ["+CS 3"1%+# B)?+4+;S 8LOJY D 3"1%+# 4#$0+"6","-)&$& &6%4C "7 4 W2.,$.+% "7 6"(%+$;XS H0)20 )#2,.1%& ?+"C%# 74=),)%&S 1+.- .&%S ()",%#2%S &20"", 74),.+% 4#1 ()2%Y I /0% $0%"+; "7 W1)77%+%#$)4, 4&&"2)4$)"#X )& "#% "7 $0% 8LIT& 4#1 8LOT& $0%"+)%& "7 1%,)#e.%#2; 4#1 2+)=%Y >&&"2)4$)#- H)$0 2+)=)#4,& )# "#%X& 6"(%+$; #%)-0: ?"+0""1S "#% ?%2"=%& W&"2)4,)\%1X )#$" 2+)=)#4, #"+=&Y O B%&$%+ /0.+"HS C#%9 17 C#%9S <#-,%H""1 !,)77&S GdS *+%#$)2% 94,,S 8LLTY 5%% 4,&"S d4=%& U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-S G%H ["+CS *4#$0%"#S 8LLIY P K)204+1 !,"H4+1 4#1 B,";1 f0,)#S M#2,-_<#-&) %-9 c007"1<-,1)S G%H ["+CS K4#1"= 9".&%S 8LPTY Q K"?%+$ ZY 3%+$"#S @7&,%2 E(#7") %-9 @7&,%2 @1"<&1<"#S W5"2)4, 5$+.2$.+% 4#1 >#"=)%XS G%H ["+CS !",.=?)4 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LIJY J /0"+&$%)# c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ 1(# H#,3<"# +2%33S G%H ["+CS c)C)#- *+%&&S 8LOPY L M?)1Y 8T Z4+, 34+R l U+)%1+)20 <#-%,&S E(# +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317S G%H ["+CS M#$%+#4: $)"#4, *.?,)&0%+&S 8LDIY 5%%S G"<-9",33#S G%H ["+CS M#$%+#4$)"#4, *.?,)&0%+&S 8LPAY 88 M?)1Y 8A U+)%1+)20 94;%CS E(# +7-31,1<1,7- 7$ H,A#"1)S !0)24-"S !0)24-" N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LQJY 8D !,"H4+1 4#1 f0,)#S M#2,-_<#-&) %-9 c007"1<-,1)S "6Y 2)$Y 8I !"#7.2).&S E(# F-%2#&13S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)#S 8LLIY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

T !"# M&%6+34 >/.22 Y+,+'#'0 N#8 ?+''/#5>/.22 ?&;+/+*7 ,2 \3'#%)/.22 Y#)/+3#

AOT 671#3 8O @.##4+ 3;+14,S E(# +(%22#-.# 7$ F$$2<#-&#S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+ l K"HS 8LOLY 5%% 4,&"S 3;+14,S J#)7-9 1(# '#2$%"# @1%1#S G%H 94(%#S [4,% N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LPTY

!"# @&)+./ C%&;/#-2 &1 *"# N#8 \$$#% >/.22

8 E(# ?#1"7072,1%-S 4 8LQT& ="()%Y A /+.1% @",1?%+-S E(# P#4,-,K%1,7- 7$ !7>#"1)S E%&$6"+$S !$S @+%%#H""1 *+%&&S 8LJPY D /0% )#&.+4#2% 2"=64#)%&X ,"??; &.22%&&7.,,; ?,"2C%1 9),,4+; !,)#$"#X& 6,4# $" =4C% 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2% 6"+$4?,%S $" )#2+%4&% )$& 2"(%+4-%& 4#1 $" =4C% )$ .#)(%+&4, ^ $0% 2"=64#)%& 1)1 #"$ H4#$ $" )#2.+ $0%&% 2"&$&Y I 9%+?%+$ 34+2.&%S c-# M,4#-3,7-%2 ?%-a 94##4 >+%#1$S E(# C<4%- +7-9,1,7-S !0)24-"S N#)(%+&)$; "7 !0)24-" *+%&&S 8LOJY O *,4$"S E(# L#0
^

!"# M#/1.%# @*.*# 1&% *"# N#8 W+)"

8 >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3S <+#%&$ ]4+C%+ $+4#&YS G%H ["+CS fR7"+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LOJY A M?)1Y D d"0# 34;#4+1 Z%;#%&S G#-#"%2 E(#7") 7$ Z4027)4#-1B 8-1#"#31 %-9 ?7-#)S G%H ["+CS 94+2".+$ ]+42% d"(4#"()20S 8LPOY I 3),$"# U+)%1=4#S +%0,1%2,34 %-9 P"##974S !0)24-"S N#)(%+&)$; "7 !0)24-" *+%&&S 8LJAY O d"4# K"?)#&"#S '(%1 F"# 1(# d<#31,7-35S G%H ["+CS 504+6%S 8LJTY P d"0# Z%##%$0 @4,?+4)$0S E(# 6#; 8-9<31",%2 @1%1#S ]"&$"#S 9".-0$"# 3)77,)#Y Q U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-S "6Y 2)$Y J 34+R 4#1 <#-%,&S E(# +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317S "6Y 2)$Y L c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#S &%% 4,&"S KY9Y /4H#%;S L#2,.,7- %-9 1(# L,3# 7$ +%0,1%2,34S G%H ["+CS 3%#$"+ ]""C&S 8LOIY 8T c%?,%#S E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#a &%% 4,&" d"&%60 520.=6%$%+S +%0,1%2,34B @7&,%2,34B M#47&"%&)S G%H ["+CS K4#1"= 9".&%S 8LOAY 5%% 4,&" >Y>Y ]%+,% 4#1 @4+1#%+ 3%4#&S E(# ?79#"- +7"07"%1,7- %-9 !",>%1# !"70#"1)S G%H ["+CS 94+: 2".+$ ]+42% d"(4#"()20S 8LPJY 88 c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#S "6Y 2)$Y 8A K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S E(# ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,- @7&,7(,317",&%2 !#"D 30#&1,>#S B%)1%#S /0% G%$0%+,4#1&S +)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3S <+#%&$ ]4+C%+ $+4#&Y _2+)$)e.% "7 *04,%.&X $0%"+; "7 6.+% 2"==.#)&=`Y 8P >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3 _$0%"+; "7 W6+"6"+$)"#4, %e.4,)$;X 4#1 W6+)(4$% 6+"6%+$; H)$0 6.?,)2 .&%XY 8Q M?)1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

]

8J /)= 3""+%S H,%"/3 !7I#"S G%H ["+CS K4#1"= 9".&%S 8LLJa d"0# ]+""C&S E(# E%I#7>#" G%4#S G%H ["+CS #"S G%H ["+CS >+?"+ 9".&%S 8LJPa !"##)% ]+.2CS !"#D 9%17"3 J%22S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+ /"+20S 8LLJY AT U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-S "6Y 2)$Ya K"?%+$ E41%S G7>#"-,-. 1(# ?%"I#1S *+)#: 2%$"#S N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LLTa !04,=%+& d"0#&"#S ?8E8S 5$4#7"+1S 5$4#7"+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LJAY A8 /0.+"HS C#%9 17 C#%9S "6Y 2)$Y AA M?)1Ya &%% 4,&" #"$% ATY AD U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-S "6Y 2)$Y AI '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2S 5%6$Y AOS 8LLJS *>Ja /0% G%H ["+C /)=%&S E%1Y 5%6$Y DT$0S $0% ?.&)#%&& &%2$)"#Y 5%% 4,&"S 3""+%S H,%"/3 !7I#"S "6Y 2)$YS 4#1 ]+""C&S E(# E%I#7>#" G%4#S "6Y 2)$Y AO /0.+"HS C#%9 17 C#%9S "6Y 2)$Y AP '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 _&%% #"$% AI`Y AQ ]+""C&S E(# E%I#7>#" G%4#S "6Y 2)$Y AJ '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2S >.-^5%6$Y 8LLJS 4+$)2,%& "# $0% W>&)4# U,.XY AL /0"=4& Z.0#S E(# @1"<&1<"# 7$ @&,#-1,$,& L#>72<1,7-3S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+ /"+20S 8LPOY DT '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 _&%% #"$% AJ`Y D8 '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2S 5%6$Y ATS 8LLJ _"# $0% 9"#- Z"#- ?4),".$`Y DA U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-a &%% 4,&"S E41%S G7>#"-,-. 1(# ?%"I#1S "6Y 2)$Y 4#1 d"0#&"#S ?8E8S "6Y 2)$Y DD M?)1Y DI /0.+"HS C#%9 17 C#%9S "6Y 2)$Y DO E(# 6#; Q7"I E,4#3S E%1Y 5%6$Y DT$0S ?.&)#%&& &%2$)"#Y DP K"?%+$ K%)20S E(# E"%-3-%1,7-%2 Z&7-74)S ]"&$"#S ]%42"#S 8LLTS d"0# E)2C: ,%)#S Z2#&1"7-,& 6,.(14%"#S G%H ["+CS c)C)#-S 8LJ8Y DQ K%)20S E"%-3-%1,7-%2 Z&7-74)S "6Y 2)$Y DJ '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 _4?"(%S #"$% AI`Y DL M?)1Y IT M?)1Y I8 6#; Q7"I E,4#3 _&%% #"$% DO`Y IA M?)1Y ID 3""+%S H,%"/3 !7I#"Y II 6#; Q7"I E,4#3 _&%% #"$% DO`Y IO M?)1Y IP M?)1Y IQ '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 _4?"(%S #"$% AI`Y IJ M?)1Y IL M?)1Y OT M?)1Y O8 d"0# E)2C,%)#S Z2#&1"7-,& 6,.(14%"#S "6Y 2)$Y OA 3""+%S H,%"/3 !7I#"S "6Y 2)$Y OD '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 _4?"(%S #"$% AI`Y OI M?)1Y OO M?)1Y OP M(4# ]"%&C;S ?#".#" ?%-,%S 94+2".+$ ]+42% d"(4#"()20S 8LJOa $0)& ?""C H4& 6.,,%1 "77 $0% =4+C%$ 47$%+ $0% &24#14,Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 AO8

OQ OJ OL PT P8 PA PD PI PO PP PQ PJ PL

]+""C&S E(# E%I#7>#" G%4#S "6Y 2)$Ya d"0#&"#S E%I#7>#"S "6Y 2)$Y '%22 @1"##1 R7<"-%2 _4?"(%S #"$% AI`Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y M?)1Y d"&%60 520.=6%$%+S +%0,1%2,34B @7&,%2,34B M#47&"%&)Y

Q

!"# M#/1.%# @*.*#0 IB$.32+&32A >(*;.)62A .3' >&5C.7-#3*2

8 ]%(%+,; >,,%# 4#1 34+; K.&&"S %1&S L#>,3,7-,-. 81%2)= 6%1,7-%2 89#-1,1) %-9 G27A%2 +<21<"#S 3)##%46",)&S N#)(%+&)$; "7 3)##%&"$4 *+%&&S 8LLQY A U+4 504+C4#&C;S '(%1 4%I#3 83"%#2 E,&IS !0)24-"S G%,&"# 94,,S 8LJOY D E0%# U+%.1 7)+&$ H+"$% 4#1 ,%2$.+%1S 0% H4& "#,; H%,2"=%1 ?; $0% d%H)&0 "+-4#)\4$)"#& "7 c)%##4Y 5%% *%$%+ @4;S F J,7."%0() 7$ P"#<9S G%H ["+CS f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f+(),, >14=&S 54# U+4#2)&2"S d"&&%;:]4&&S 8LLDY 8J M?)1Y 8L /0% G"+$0 >=%+)24# U+%% /+41% >-+%%=%#$ H%#$ )#$" %77%2$ .#1%+ $0% !,)#: $"# 41=)#)&$+4$)"# )# $0% 8LLT&Y AT d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

%$10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AOA 671#3

AI AO AP AQ AJ AL DT D8

DA DD DI DO DP DQ DJ DL IT

I8 IA ID II

IO IP

IQ IJ

6+"-+4=&S ,%1 ?; $0% 5*F ^ $0% @%+=4# 5"2)4, F%="2+4$)2 *4+$; ^ 4#1 $0% @+%%# *4+$;Y @%+=4#; 24,,& )$& )==)-+4#$& W-.%&$ H"+C%+&X ?%24.&% )$ H4#$& $0%= $" ,%4(% 4#1 -" 0"=% 47$%+ $0%; 04(% H"+C%1 7"+ 4 #.=?%+ "7 ;%4+&Y @%+=4#; 04& $0% ?%&$ b"?:$+4)#)#- 6+"-+4=& )# $0% H"+,1Y 5C)#0%41& 4#1 #%":G4\) -+".6& 04(% -+"H# 4#1 ?%24=% e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e1( +#-1<")S GY[YS 94+6%+ /"+20S 8LQPY K"# !0%+#"HS E(# C7<3# 7$ ?7".%-S "6Y 2)$Y 34R E%?%+S E(# !"71#31%-1 Z1(,& %-9 1(# @0,",1 7$ +%0,1%2,34S "6Y 2)$Y /0% W?+4)# 1+4)#X ^ ]+)$)&0 .#)(%+&)$; -+41.4$%& %=)-+4$)#- $" !4#414S >.&: $+4,)4S 4#1 $0% N#)$%1 5$4$%&Y ]+)$)&0 ="()%&' E(# P<22 ?7-1)a ?) J#%<1,$<2 H%<-9"#11#Y <#-,4#1X& 0%4,$0 24+% 6+"-+4= )& C#"H# 7"+ )$& )#%77)2)%#2; 4#1 .#:="1%+# &$;,%Y >,%R4#1%+ 5Y G%),,S @<44#"(,22 @&(772= % 6#; S,#; 7$ +(,29(779S G%H ["+CS 5$ 34+$)#& *+%&&S 8LLDY W/0% 1",%X )& 4 2",,"e.)4, $%+= 7"+ .#%=6,";=%#$ ?%#%7)$Y 5%% F)2C%#&S c2,>#" E;,31S 7"+ 4 ()%H "7 WH"+C0".&%&X 7"+ $0% 6""+ )# $0% #)#%$%%#$0 2%#$.+;Y ]+)$)&0 %1.24$)"# 04& 0%,6%1 %&$4?,)&0 1%="2+42; 4#1 ,%-4, 4.$0"+)$; )# 4,, )$& 2","#)%&Y !#"#31"7,I% H4& $0% 4$$%=6$ $" +%&$+.2$.+% $0% K.&&)4# %2"#"=; "# ="1%+# ,)#%&a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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 AOD

IL /0% /)4#4#=%# 5e.4+% .6+)&)#- &0"H%1 $04$ $0% 1%="2+42; ="(%=%#$ )& -4)#)#- ="=%#$.= )# !0)#4S ?.$ $04$ $0% W",1 =%#X "7 $0% !"==.#)&$ *4+$; 4+% #"$ ;%$ +%41; 7"+ )$Y OT /0% !0)#%&% ?.&)#%&& &.22%&& )# 5".$0 <4&$ >&)4 04& ?%%# &6%2$42.,4+Y O8 504#-04) )& 74&$ ?%2"=)#- 4#"$0%+ 9"#- Z"#- ^ 4#1 $0% !0)#%&% 6+%=)%+% )& 7+"= 504#-04)Y OA !0)#%&% 2"==.#)&= 6+"()1%1 $0% W)+"# +)2% ?"H,X H%,74+% &$4$%Y OD @,4&&=4#S +(,-% ,- E"%-3,1,7-= +744<-,34B +%0,1%2,34B M#47&"%&) _&%% 2046: $%+ "# W/0% @+%4$ B%46 U"+H4+1X`S G%H ["+CS *+4%-%+Y OI !0),1 ,4?"+ )# !0)#4 4#1 M#1)4 )& #"H 4 NG:+%2"-#)\%1 6+"?,%=a 6+)&"# W&,4(%:,4?"+X )& 4,&" 6+"?,%=4$)2 )# !0)#4Y

G !"# W+2+34 >&2* &1 @#%,+)#2 +3 O+4"5!#)" @&)+#*+#2 .3' W#,#3(#5:#3#%.*+34 ?#)".3+2-2 8 A D I O P Q J L 8T 88 8A

8D 8I 8O 8P 8Q 8J 8L

AT

F%##)& E+"#-S !70<2%1,7- %-9 @7&,#1)S G%H ["+CS ]4&)2 ]""C&S 8LOJY M?)1Y *,4##%1 64+%#$0""1 )& #"H "6%+4$)#- H"+,1H)1%Y /4=#%;S E(# @1"<..2# 7>#" @,-.%07"#/3 @7<2a U4,,"H&S H77I,-. %1 1(# @<-S "6Y 2)$Y /0% !,)#$"# >1=)#)&$+4$)"# 4#1 !"#-+%&& 4+% $+;)#- $" 2"=% .6 H)$0 6,4#& $" W&4(%X &"2)4, &%2.+)$;Y >,4# E",7%S F4#",&%/3 840%33= 1(# L,3# %-9 P%22 7$ G"7;1(S G%H ["+CS *4#$0%"#S 8LJ8Y >#1+%H !"+#%,,S C%"9 M",>#= J,22 G%1#3 %-9 ?,&"737$1S G%H ["+CS E),%;S 8LJAY /4=#%;S @,-.%07"#S "6Y 2)$Y M& $0% d464#%&% %2"#"=; )# 6%+=4#%#$ &,"H1"H#S "+S )& )$ b.&$ $0% W>&)4# U,.X 2+)&)&V <1=.#1 f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`Y M?)1Y 34+R l <#-%,&S E(# +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317 _$0% W6+"-+%&&)(% )#2"=% $4RX`Y W/0% 7,4$ $4RX ^ ,%$ .& &4;S AT 6%+ 2%#$ "# %(%+;"#% ^ 04& ?%%# 204=6)"#%1 ?; 5$%(% U"+?%&Y 5)#2% $0%+% H".,1 ?% #" ,""60",%& 7"+ $0% +)20S $0% )1%4 )& #"$ 4 ?41 "#%Y 5$%(% U"+?%& "H#& P7"A#3 ?%.%K,-#S 4#1 04& ?%%# 4 8LLT& K%6.?,)24# 24#1)14$% 7"+ 6+%&)1%#$Y /0% U+%#20 W#.+&%+)%&X 4+% &" 6"6.,4+ $04$ $0%+% )& 4 ,"#- H4)$)#- ,)&$ 7"+ $0)& &%+()2%Y /0% +%&$ "7 $0%
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

AOI 671#3

A8 d.,)%$ ]Y 520"+S E(# c>#"30#-1 F4#",&%-S 8LLJS E(# c>#";7"I#9 F4#",&%-S 8LLOS ?"$0 G%H ["+CS ]4&)2 ]""C&S AA @%+=4#& #"H 04(% 411%1 4 O 6%+ 2%#$ $4R 7"+ 0%4,$0 )#&.+4#2%Y AD K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S E),,)4= 5H4$"& d+S *4., BY K"&%#S J<"#%<&"%&) %.%,-31 M#47&"%&) %-9 @7&,%2,34S E%&$6"+$S !$S @+%%#H""1 *+%&&S 8LJLY AI U+4#\ Z47C4S E(# +%312#S G%H ["+CS <(%+;=4# B)?+4+;S 8LO8Y AO 94#& @%+$0 4#1 !Y E+)-0$ 3),,&S P"74 ?%: '#A#"S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPAY AP F"#4,1 K"H4$S E(# c4A<934%-S B4#04=S 31S N#)(%+&)$; *+%&& "7 >=%+)24S 8LJOY AQ /0% c4,.% >11%1 /4RS c>/S )& )#&$)$.$)"#4,)\%1 )# $0% <.+"6%4# N#)"#Y AJ >$ >=%+)24# M(; B%4-.% 2",,%-%& )# 8LLLS $0% $.)$)"# 642C4-% 04& &"4+%1 $" kD8 TTT 6%+ ;%4+Y AL /0.+"HS C#%9 17 C#%9S "6Y 2)$Y DT d"0# B"2C%S c- +,>,2 G7>#"-4#-1S G%H ["+CS 3"1%+# B)?+4+;S 8LOJY D8 >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3a &%% 4,&"S @,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 Z_<%2,1)S G%H ["+CS *+4%-%+S 8LJAY DA M?)1Y DD *,4$"S E(# L#0+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3Y DO /0"=4& 3"+%S O170,%S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)#S 8LLPY DP B"2C%S c- +,>,2 G7>#"-4#-1Y DQ d"0# 5$.4+$ 3),,S c- L#0"#3#-1%1,># G7>#"-4#-1S G%H ["+CS 3"1%+# B)?+4+;S 8LP8Y DJ >14= 5=)$0S E(# '#%21( 7$ 6%1,7-3S G%H ["+CS K4#1"= 9".&%S 8LODY DL Z4+, 34+RS E(# G#"4%- 89#727.)S ]"&$"#S ]%42"#S 8LQDY IT 5%% $0% 5"2)4, F%="2+4$)2 *4+$; 6,4$7"+=& )# $0% <.+"6%4# #4$)"#&Y I8 N5> K%6.?,)24#& 6+%7%+ 6+)(4$% 204+)$)%& ^ *+%&)1%#$ @%"+-% ].&0 24,,%1 &.20 )#1)()1.4, 1"#4$)"#& W4 $0".&4#1 6")#$& "7 ,)-0$X ^ ?.$ 0% H4& #"$ +%:%,%2$%1S 4#1 $0)& 60+4&% H4& .#6"6.,4+Y IA M# $0% +$0.+ dY c)1)20S W/0% 9)-0%+ F)4,%2$)2 "7 *0),4#$0+"6;SX )# @7&,%2 L#3#%"&(S c",Y 8AS 66Y 8J^8P8S 8LQTY OT *0),,)6&S E(# !72,1,&3 7$ L,&( %-9 !77"S "6Y 2)$Y O8 U+"= *+%&)1%#$ ].&0 $" =4b"+)$; ,%41%+ G%H$ @)#-+)20S $0% K%6.?,)24# ?4$$,% 2+; H4&S WB"H%+ $0% 246)$4, -4)#& $4RgX OA K"?%+$ ZY 3%+$"#S W5"2)4, 5$+.2$.+% 4#1 >#"=)%XS )# @7&,%2 E(#7") %-9 @7&,%2 @1"<&1<"#S "6Y 2)$Ya &%% 4,&" !,"H4+1 l f0,)#S M#2,-_<#-&) %-9 c007"1<-,1)S "6Y 2)$Y OD M?)1Y OI /0% &20"", W(".20%+X 6+"-+4= &%%C& $" 6+)(4$)\% 4,, &20"",&a )$ H4& 7)+&$ &.--%&$%1 ?; 3),$"# U+)%1=4#S )# +%0,1%2,34 %-9 P"##974S "6Y 2)$Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 AOO

AOP 671#3

8 >14= 5=)$0S E(# '#%21( 7$ 6%1,7-3Y A d%+%=; ]%#$04= 4#1 dY5Y 3),,S O1,2,1%",%-,34 %-9 c1(#" Z33%)3S 94+="#1&: H"+$0S 3)11,%&%RS <#-,4#1S *%#-.)#S 8LJQY D d"0# B"2C%S c- +,>,2 G7>#"-4#-1Y I KY9Y /4H#%;S E(# F."%",%- !"7A2#4 7$ 1(# Te1( +#-1<")Y O 5=)$0S E(# '#%21( 7$ 6%1,7-3Y P W/0% +)&)#- $)1% H),, +4)&% 4,, &0)6&X ?%24=% $0% ="$$" "7 ]+)$)&0 4#1 >=%+)24# 7+%%:=4+C%$ %2"#"=)&$&Y Q 5=)$0S '#%21( 7$ 6%1,7-3Y J M?)1Y L ]%#$04=Y 8T dY5Y 3),,S c- L#0"#3#-1%1,># G7>#"-4#-1Y 88 !04+,%& F)2C%#& ^ 4,, "7 0)& H"+C& 7"2.& "# $0% =)&%+; "7 $0% H"+C%+& 4#1 $0% =)&%+,)#%&& "7 $0% 246)$4,)&$&Y 8A 34+R 4#1 <#-%,&S +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317Y 8D F)2C%#&S F +(",314%3 +%"72Y 8I 9.-"S H#3 ?,3#N"%A2#3Y 8O K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S E(# 6#; ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,- G27A%2 !#"30#&D 1,>#S B"#1"#S 342=),,4#S 8LLQY 8P *0),,)6&S !72,1,&3 7$ L,&( %-9 !77"Y 8Q 3),$"# U+)%1=4#S +%0,1%2,34 %-9 P"##974S "6Y 2)$Y 8J 34+RS +%0,1%2Y 8L 5%% $0% 2046$%+ )# $0)& ?""C "# H%,74+% &$4$% W?4),".$&X 7"+ $0% +)20Y AT dYZY @4,?+4)$0S 6#; 8-9<31",%2 @1%1#S "6Y 2)$Y A8 c%?,%#S E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#S "6Y 2)$Y AA @4,?+4)$0S 6#; 8-9<31",%2 @1%1#S "6Y 2)$Y AD /0"+&$%)# c%?,%#S E(# Z-.,-##"3 %-9 1(# !",&# @)31#4S "6Y 2)$Y AI M?)1Y AO @4,?+4)$0S 6#; 8-9<31",%2 @1%1#S "6Y 2)$Y AP 34+R l <#-%,&S +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317Y AQ K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4# l c4$+" 3.+(4+S ?%: '#A#"/3 !72,1,&%2 @7&,727.)S E%&$: 6"+$S !$S @+%%#H""1 *+%&&S 8LQJa &%% 4,&"S @,4&&=4#S 5H4$"& l K"&%#S J<"#%#S B%)1%#S /0% G%$0%+,4#1&S #1+%H 504+6%S E(# H#>#22#"3S G%H ["+CS !4=?+)1-% N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LLTY DA Z%;#%&S G#-#"%2 E(#7")S 6Y DQIY DD M?)1YS 6Y DQJY DI M?)1YS 2046$%+ "# W$0% =.,$)6,)%+ %77%2$XY DO M?)1YS 66Y 8AL^DTY DP M?)1YS 66Y 8AL^DTY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

H M"7 !%.321#% C.7-#3*2 .%# N#)#22.%7 +3 O+4"5!#)" D3'(2*%+./ >.$+*./+2* @&)+#*+#2

DQ DJ DL IT I8 IA ID II IO IP IQ IJ IL OT O8 OA

OD OI OO OP OQ OJ OL PT P8 PA PD

PI PO PP PQ PJ PL QT Q8 QA QD QI QO QP QQ QJ

Z%;#%& )#2,.1%1 2"=6,%R =4$0%=4$)24, 7"+=.,4& )# 0)& G#-#"%2 E(#7")Y M?)1YS 6Y DQIY M?)1YS 6Y DQIY M?)1YS 6Y DQIY d"0# K4H,&S F E(#7") 7$ R<31,&#S !4=?+)1-%S 34&&YS 94+(4+1 N#)(Y *+%&&S 8LP8Y d"0# B"2C%S c- +,>,2 G7>#"-4#-1Y ]4+"# 1% 3"#$%&e.)%.S @0,",1 7$ 1(# H%;3S ]%+C%,%;S !4,YS N#)(%+&)$; "7 !4,): 7"+#)4 *+%&&S 8LQAY K4H,&S E(#7")S 6Y 8AY M?)1YS 66Y 8J^8LY M?)1YS 6Y PTY M?)1YS 6Y P8Y M?)1YS 6Y P8Y M?)1YS 6Y 8TAY M?)1YS 6Y 8TPY M?)1YS 66Y AQO^PY K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 Z_<%2,1)S G%H ["+CS *+4%-%+S 8LJIa &%% 4,&" K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 M#3071,34 ,- !",4,1,># @7&,#1,#3S G%H ["+CS Z%##)2"$$ *+%&&S 8LQLY M?)1YS ?"$0 &".+2%&Y M?)1YS ?"$0 &".+2%&Y M?)1YS ?"$0 &".+2%&Y K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S E(# ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,- @7&,7DC,317",&%2 !#"D 30#&1,>#S B%)1%#S #` E(# 6#; ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,- G27A%2 !#"30#&1,>#Y >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3S <+#%&$ ]4+C%+ $+4#&YS G%H ["+CS fR7"+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LOJS 6Y 8IPY M?)1YS 6Y PY M?)1YS 66Y P^QY M?)1YS 6Y IJY M?)1YS 66Y OT^8Y M?)1YS 6Y O8Y M?)1YS 6Y OTY M?)1YS 6Y IJY M?)1YS 6Y IL^OTY M?)1YS 6Y 8J8Y M?)1YS 6Y 8JAY M?)1YS 6Y 8JAY M?)1YS 6Y APQY M?)1YS 6Y APJY M?)1YS 6Y APQY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 AOQ

AOJ 671#3 QL M?)1YS 6Y APLY JT M?)1YS 66Y IL^OTY J8 M?)1YS 6Y 8JAY

!"# =%## ?.%6#* .3' ?&%./+*7

8 34R E%?%+S Z&7-74) %-9 @7&,#1)S $+4#&Y K"$0 4#1 E)$$)20S G%H ["+CS ]%1: =)#&$%+ *+%&&S 8LQJa &%2$)"# "# WB%-4, >.$0"+)$;XY A >?+404= 34&,"HS *@#2$DF&1<%2,K%1,7-/B @#2$DZ31##4B %-9 M74,-%-&#S 3"#$%+%;S !4,YS !",% *.?,)&0%+&S 8LQDY D 5=)$0S '#%21( 7$ 6%1,7-3Y I K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4#S +(,-% ,- E"%-3,1,7-= +744<-,34B +%0,1%2,34B M#47&"%&)Y O N#7"+$.#4$%,;S $0% K.&&)4#& 4+% &$),, %#-4-)#- )# W347)4X:&$;,% ?.&)#%&& $+4#&: 42$)"#&Y P @,4&&=4#S E(# ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,- @7&,7DC,317",&%2 !#"30#&1,>#a 4#1S P7" M#47&"%&)= 1(# 67A2# +(%"%&1#" %-9 E"%.,& P2%;3 7$ 1(# ?,992# +2%33Y Q M?)1YS ?"$0 &".+2%&Y J E),&"#S @7&,727.) "6Y 2)$Ya 5)-=.#1 U+%.1S +,>,2,K%1,7- %-9 813 M,3&7-1#-13S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+ /"+20S 8LJAY L 34R E%?%+S E(# +,1)S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPIY 8T /0.2;1)1%&S E(# !#2707--#3,%- '%"Y 88 @,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 M#3071,34 ,- !",4,1,># @7&,#1,#3Y 8A >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3Y 8D M?)1Y 8I E%?%+S Z&7-74) %-9 @7&,#1)S "# W,%-4, 4.$0"+)$;XY 8O 9%#+; 5.=#%+ 34)#%S F-&,#-1 H%;S !0)24-"S N#)(%+&)$; "7 !0)24-" *+%&&S 8LLQY 8P >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3Y 8Q M?)1Y 8J *",;?).&S C,317",#3S ]C cM "# W="? +.,%XS !4=?+)1-%S 34&&YS 94+(4+1 N#)(Y *+%&&S 8LQIY 8L 5%% *,4$"X& 1)4,"-.%& "# $0% $+)4, "7 5"2+4$%& 7"+ 4# )1%4 "7 0"H $0% ,4H 2".+$& H"+C%1 )# 4#2)%#$ @+%%2%a &%% 4,&" 3YMY U)#,%;S M#47&"%&)= F-&,#-1 %-9 ?79#"-S GdS K.$-%+& N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LQDY AT @,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 M#3071,34 ,- !",4,1,># @7&,#1,#3Y A8 M?)1Y AA >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3 _"# &,4(%+; 4#1 H"=%#`a *,4$"S E(# L#0
10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

JR

DT K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4# 4#1 E),,)4= 5H4$"& d+S +(%",34%B C,317")B %-9 @7&,%2 @1"<&1<"#S E%&$6"+$S !$YS @+%%#H""1 *+%&&S 8LJAY D8 >#2)%#$ @+%%C ()&)$"+& $" <-;6$ )#2,.1%1 9%+"1"$.&S *;$04-"+4&S /04,%&S *,4$" 4#1 =4#; "$0%+&Y DA *,4$" 1%&2+)?%& 4#1 2+)$)2)\%& $0% $%420)#- "7 $0% 5"60)&$& $0+".-0".$ 0)& 1)4,"-.%&Y DD @,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 M#3071,34 ,- !",4,1,># @7&,#1,#3Y DI /0.2;1)1%&S E(# !#2707--#3,%- '%"S W*%+)2,%&X U.#%+4, f+4$)"#XY DO d%4# d42e.%& K".&&%4.S E(# @7&,%2 +7-1"%&1S *%#-.)# !,4&&)2&S 8LJDY DP E%?%+S E(# +,1)S G%H ["+CS U+%% *+%&&S 8LODY DQ >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3Y DJ E%?%+S E(# +,1)S "6Y 2)$Y DL >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3S WU+4-=%#$& "7 $0% 2"#&$)$.$)"# "7 !4+$04-%X ^ "$0%+ *0"%: #)2)4# 2)$; W2"#&$)$.$)"#&X 04(% ?%%# ,"&$S .#7"+$.#4$%,;Y IT 5%% 4#; &".+2% "# $0% 74),%1 @+4220) K%(",.$)"# )# K"=%a &%% >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3S "# ",)-4+20; 4#1 1%="2+42;a &%% /0.2;1)1%&S !#2707--#3,%- '%"Y I8 >+)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3S 6Y DOY 5%% 4,&" @,4&&=4#S E(# ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,@7&,7DC,317",&%2 !#"30#&1,>#S +)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3Y II 34R E%?%+S E(# L#2,.,7- 7$ +(,-%S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPIY IO !"#7.2).&S E(# F-%2#&13Y IP E%?%+S E(# !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&S K"R?.+; *+%&& %1)$)"#S H)$0 )#$+"1.2$)"# ?; K4#14,, !",,)#&Y IQ 3%+$"#S W5"2)4, 5$+.2$.+% 4#1 >#"=)%X )# @7&,%2 E(#7") %-9 @7&,%2 @1"<&1<"#S "6Y 2)$Y IJ c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S @%#%&)&S fR7"+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S G%H ["+CS 8LLAY IL 94#& dY 9),,%+?+4#1S E(# L#$7"4%1,7-S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+S 8LPJY OT M?)1Y O8 9%-%,S E(# !(,27370() 7$ C,317")Y OA Z4+, 34+RS W/0% @%+=4# *%4&4#$ K%(",$XS )# +722#&1#9 '7"I3S G%H ["+CS M#$%+: #4$)"#4, *.?,)&0%+&S 8LDIY OD E%?%+S !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&S "6Y 2)$Y OI /0"=4& d%77%+&"#S W/0% F%2,4+4$)"# "7 M#1%6%#1%#2%XY OO M+4 5Y @,4&&%+S S,3,7-3 7$ H,A#"1)S G%H ["+CS B)$$,% ]+"H#S 8LL8Y OP Z%()# *0),,)6&S E(# +7<3,-3 '%"3S G%H ["+CS K4#1"= 9".&%S 8LLLY OQ U+%.1S +,>,2,K%1,7- %-9 813 M,3&7-1#-13S G%H ["+C 4#1 B"#1"#S EYEY G"+$"#S 8LP8a E(# 8-1#"0"#1%1,7- 7$ M"#%43S )# E(# P"#<9 L#%9#"S %1Y *%$%+ @4;S G%H ["+C 4#1 B"#1"#S EYEY G"+$"#S 8LJLY OJ 5%% >1,%+S d.#-S 4#1 $0% #%":U+%.1)4# &20"",& "7 $0".-0$Y OL >?+404= 34&,"HS W@#2$D%&1<%2,K%1,7-/B @#2$DZ31##4B %-9 M74,-%-&#S "6Y 2)$Y PT E%?%+S !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&S "6Y 2)$Y P8 9%+?%+$ 34+2.&%S c-# M,4#-3,7-%2 ?%-S "6Y 2)$Y PA E%?%+S !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&S "6Y 2)$Y PD KY9Y /4H#%;S L#2,.,7- %-9 1(# L,3# 7$ +%0,1%2,34S "6Y 2)$Y PI E%?%+S !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&S "6Y 2)$Y PO M?)1Y PP 5$Y >.-.&$)#%S E(# +,1) 7$ G79S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)#S 8LLOa d"0# !4,()#S )# 94#&Y dY 9),,%+?+4#1S E(# !"71#31%-1 L#$7"4%1,7-S G%H ["+CS 94+6%+ /"+20 ]""C&S 8LPJY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 AOL

PQ PJ PL QT Q8 QA QD QI QO QP QQ QJ QL JT J8 JA JD JI JO JP JQ JJ JL LT L8 LA LD LI LO LP LQ LJ LL

8TT

M?)1S ?"$0 &".+2%&Y M?)1S ?"$0 &".+2%&Y E%?%+S !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&Y !04+,%& F)2C%#&S F +(",314%3 +%"72S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)#S 8LPTa &%% 4,&" Z4+, *",4#;)S E(# G"#%1 E"%-3$7"4%1,7-S ]"&$"#S ]%42"#S 8LQDY F.+C0%)=S @<,&,9#S "6Y 2)$Y _&%2$)"# "# >#"=)2 5.2)1%` E%?%+S !"71#31%-1 Z1(,&S "6Y 2)$Y c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ J<3,-#33 Z-1#"0",3#S "6Y 2)$Y M?)1Y c%?,%#S E(# E(#7") 7$ 1(# H#,3<"# +2%33S "6Y 2)$Y 34+R 4#1 <#-%,&S +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317S "6Y 2)$Y !04+,%& K%)20S E(# G"##-,-. 7$ F4#",&%S G%H ["+CS *"2C%$ ]""C&S 8LQ8Y c4#2% *42C4+1S E(# C,99#- !#"3<%9#"3S "6Y 2)$Y 34+RS ?%-,$#317S "6Y 2)$Y 520"+S E(# c>#";7"I#9 F4#",&%-S E(# c>#"30#-1 F4#",&%-S ?"$0 "6Y 2)$Y M?)1Y F.+C0%)=S E(# L<2#3S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LOAY M?)1Ya &%% 4,&" F.+C0%)=S @<,&,9#S "6Y 2)$Y M?)1Y ?"$0 L<2#3 4#1 @<,&,9#Y M?)1Y ?"$0 L<2#3 4#1 @<,&,9#Y M?)1Y ?"$0 L<2#3 4#1 @<,&,9#Y 3%+$"#S @7&,%2 E(#7") %-9 @7&,%2 @1"<&1<"#S "6Y 2)$Y 3%+$"#S @7&,%2 E(#7") %-9 @7&,%2 @1"<&1<"#S "6Y 2)$Y M?)1Y M?)1Y 520"+%S c>#";7"I#9 F4#",&%-Y 520"+%S c>#"30#-1 F4#",&%-Y 34+&04,, 342B.04#S O-9#"31%-9,-. ?#9,%S !0)24-"S N#)(%+&)$; "7 !0)24-" *+%&&S 8LQAY U+%.1S E(# 8-1#"0"#1%1,7- 7$ M"#%43S "6Y 2)$Y <+)C4 d"#-S P#%" 7$ P2),-.S G%H ["+CS 94+2".+$S ]+42%S d"(4#"()20S 8LJ8Y U"+ 4# 4#4,;&)& "7 W=%=%X &"2)4,)\4$)"# 4#1 W0"+)\"#$4, &"2)4,)\4$)"#XS &%% d.1)$0 K)20 94++)&S E(# 6<"1<"# F33<401,7-S G%H ["+CS U+%% *+%&&S 8LLJY M?)1Y U+%.1S +,>,2,K%1,7- %-9 813 M,3&7-1#-13Y 34+2.&%S Z"73 %-9 +,>,2,K%1,7-S "6Y 2)$Ya &%% 4,&"S >Y5Y @,4&&=4#S W>,)%#4$)"# 4#1 $0% *+)=4, U4$0%+ )# 34+2.&%X& <+"& 4#1 !)(),)\4$)"#XS )# O-,>#"3,1) 7$ !#--3)2D >%-,% O-9#"."%9<%1# !(,27370() R7<"-%2S c",Y DS #.=?%+ 8S 56+)#- 8LLLY M?)1Ya $0".-0 34+2.&% )& $"" 34+R)&$ 7"+ =; $4&$%S 0)& 2+)$)e.% "7 $0% W2.,$.+% )#1.&$+;X )& )#$%+%&$)#-Y

JJ W#/+4+&(2 .3' @#)(/.% >(%;2 &3 *"# @#/1+2"3#22 .3' U-&%./+*7 &1 *"# ?.%6#* 8 c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S M&4)40S fR7"+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S G%H ["+CS 8LLAS 66Y QTT^QJY A c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S d"&%60S 6Y IPY D dY9Y ]+%4&$%1S E(# M#>#2704#-1 7$ L#2,.,7- %-9 E(7<.(1 ,- F-&,#-1 Z.)01S G%H ["+CS 52+)?#%+&S 8L8AY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

APT 671#3

I O P Q J L 8T 88 8A 8D 8I 8O 8P 8Q 8J 8L AT A8

AA AD AI AO AP AQ AJ AL DT D8 DA DD DI DO DP DQ DJ DL

@,4&&=4#S M#47&"%&) %-9 M#3071,34 ,- !",4,1,># @7&,#1,#3S "6Y 2)$Y c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S +)&$"$,%S !72,1,&3 _"# &,4(%+;`Y c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2# _$0% ,4H& 7"+ $+%4$=%#$ "7 &,4(%&S )# B%()$)2.&`Y Z4+, *",4#;)S E"%9# %-9 ?%"I#1 ,- Z%"2) Z40,"#3S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPQY c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2# _Z)#-&`Y d"&%60.&S E(# L74%-fR#;,3( '%"S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)# !,4&&)2&S 8LJ8Y d"&%60.& 24,,& d%H)&0 -"(%+#=%#$ 4 W$0%"2+42;X )# L74%-fR#;,3( '%"S 4#1 )# F.%,-31 F0,7-S B"#1"#S 9%4$0S 8LP8Y d"&%60.&a 4#1 /0% @"&6%,&S )# $0% c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#Y M&4)40S c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#Y M&4)40S 66Y QTD^8DS c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#Y /0% q%4,"$ d%H& 4+% 1%&2+)?%1 ?; d"&%60.&S 4#1 4,&" 1%&2+)?% $0%=&%,(%& )# E(# M#%9 @#% @&"7223Y M?)1Y c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S /0% @"&6%,&Y d"&%60.&Y /0% ]4+ Z"20?40 K%(",$ H4& $0% ,4&$ &$+4H ^ $0% K"=4#& 1+"(% $0% d%H& ".$ "7 *4,%&$)#%Y !",.=?.& H4& 7.#1%1 ?; 564#)&0^d%H)&0 ?4#C%+&S #"$ ?; M&4?%,,4 ^ &%% !",.=?.&X ,%$$%+&S 4#1 0)& R7<"-%2S %1)$%1 ?; B4& !4&4&S H0" H4& 4,&" 4 2"#(%+$%1 d%HY 9"H4+1 3Y 54204+S F C,317") 7$ R#;3 ,- F4#",&%S G%H ["+CS >,7+%1 Z#"67S 8LLAS 6Y 8QY 34+RS B.R%=?.+-S /+"$&C;S Z4.$&C;S ]%+#&$%)#S 4#1 &" =4#; "$0%+ &"2)4,)&$& 4#1 2"==.#)&$ ,%41%+& H%+% d%H)&0Y /0"=4& 3"+%S O170,%S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)#S 8LLPY 34+RS +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317Y 34+RS G#"4%- 89#727.)Y d"&%60.&S L74%-fR#;,3( '%"Y d"&%60.&S L74%-fR#;,3( '%" ^ $0% 64+4-+460& "# d%&.& H%+% 7"+-%1 4#1 411%1 )#$" $0% $%R$Y c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S 6Y 8AL8' d%&.& %R6%,& $0% ="#%; 204#-%+&Y M?)1YS 6Y 8AL8Y c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S *%$%+X& 1+%4= "7 !0+)&$ +)&%#S )# $0% @"&6%,&Y c:$7"9 @1<9) J,A2#S *4.,X& ,%$$%+&Y 5%% $0% 6,4;S E(# J%&&(%#S ?; <.+)6)1%& 7"+ 4 1%&2+)6$)"# "7 $0% F)"#;&)4# 2.,$Y >1"#)&S $0% 1;)#- 4#1 +%&.++%2$%1 -"1S H4& 2%#$+4, $" $0% 7%+$),)$; 2.,$& "7 $0% 5;+)4# 4+%4Y f&)+)& 4#1 M&)& 4+% 1%&2+)?%1 )# *,.$4+20S E(# H,>#3S 3"1%+# B)?+4+;S 8LOAa 4#1 &%% d4=%& ]+%4&$%1S Z.)01,%- L#2,.,7-S "6Y 2)$Y f&)+)& H4& $0% ,"+1 "7 $0% H"+,1 "7 $0% 1%41Y 9% H4& $0% C%%6%+ "7 $0% &24,%& "7 b.&$)2% H0)20 1%$%+=)#%1 ;".+ &".,X& 74$%Y M&)& 4#1 $0% ?4?; 9"+.& ^ 1(# !,#1%b ^ 4+% 6)2$.+%1 4#1 &2.,6$%1 )# 3)11,% Z)#-1"= <-;6$S $0%# ?%24=% 6"6.,4+ )# K"=%S 2%#$.+)%& ,4$%+Y <.+)6)1%&S E(# J%&&(%#Y 5"=% &20",4+& ?%,)%(% $04$ "#% "7 $0% 24.&%& "7 $0% 34224?%4# K%(",$ 4-4)#&$ $0% 342%1"#)4#:@+%%C& H4& $0% 1%=4#1 $04$ 2)+2.=2)&)"# ?% &$"66%1 &"

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 AP8

IT I8 IA ID II IO IP IQ IJ IL OT O8 OA OD OI OO OP OQ OJ OL PT P8 PA PD PI PO PP PQ PJ PL QT Q8 QA QD QI QO

$04$ d%H)&0 ;".$0& 2".,1 2"=6%$% )# $0% f,;=6)2 -4=%&Y 5%% d"&%60.& "# $0% 34224?%%&Y 5$ >.-.&$)#%S E(# +,1) 7$ G79a 4#1 E(# +7-$#33,7-3S ?"$0 *%#-.)# 646%+?42C&S G%H ["+CS 8LLPY M?)1Y d.,)4 *%4+&"#S E(# +72,3#<4= 1(# F"#-%S G%H ["+CS 32@+4H 9),,S 8LQDY 5$ >.-.&$)#%S +7-$#33,7-3Y 5$ >.-.&$)#%S +,1) 7$ G79Y /42)$.&S E(# F--%23 7$ 840#",%2 L74#S G%H ["+CS 3"1%+# B)?+4+;S 8LPQY E),,)4= 504C%&6%4+%S E(# ?#"&(%-1 7$ S#-,&#Y G)22","o 3420)4(%,,)S E(# !",-&#S $+4#&Y F4()1 *+%&&S E""$%#S !4=?+)1-%S <#-,4#1S 942C%$$ *.?,)&0%+&S 8LLOY M?)1Y /0% >+4?& 24,,%1 >+)&$"$,%S W/0% *0),"&"60%+X 4#1 &2)%#2%S W@+%%C &2)%#2%XY /0% Z"+4#S $+4#&S GYdY F4+H""1S G%H ["+CS *%#-.)# !,4&&)2&S 8LLTY /0% 60+4&%S W&.?=)&&)"# $" @"1 4#1 $0% d.1-=%#$ F4;X 466%4+& "(%+ 4#1 "(%+ 4-4)# )# $0% Z"+4#Y /0% Z"+4#S 8LLT' 66Y AO8^JLY 5%;=".+ 34+$)# B)6&%$S !72,1,&%2 ?%-S ]4,$)="+%S d"0#& 9"6C)#& *+%&&S 8LLAY 34R E%?%+S E(# L#2,.,7- 7$ 8-9,%S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPJY /0+".-0 W$+4#&2%#1%#$4, =%1)$4$)"#X "#% )& &.66"&%1 $" 420)%(% =%+-%+ "7 "#%&%,7 4#1 &"., H)$0 -"1 4#1 $0% .#)(%+&%Y /4")&= +%=4)#%1 "$0%+:H"+,1,;S H0),% !"#7.2)4#)&= 6+"()1%1 $0% %$0)2& 7"+ %(%+;14; ,)7%Y !"#7.2).&S E(# F-%2#&13S $+4#&Y FY!Y B4.S GY[YS *%#-.)#S 8LQLY E%?%+S L#2,.,7- 7$ +(,-%S G%H ["+CS U+%% *+%&&S 8LO8Y M?)1Y !"#7.2).&S E(# F-%2#&13Y M?)1Y !"#7.2).&S E(# F-%2#&13S 8LQL' ]C rMMS 66Y 88A^DOY M?)1Y B"2C%S c- +,>,2 G7>#"-4#-1S WH0" H),, -.4+1 $0% -.4+1)4#&VX B"2C% 4&C& *,4$"X& -0"&$Y 3420)4(%,,)S E(# !",-&#Y !"#7.2).&S F-%2#&13S ]C rMMS 6Y AAY M?)1YS ]C rcMMS 6Y 8IPY M?)1YS ]C rcMMS 6Y 8IPY 54=.%, 9.#$)#-$"#S E(# E(,"9 '%>#S !4=?+)1-%S 34&&YS 94+(4+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LJJY @,4&&=4#S +(,-% ,- E"%-3,1,7-= +744<-,34B +%0,1%2,34B M#47&"%&)Y /4=#%;S E(# @1"<..2# 7>#" @,-.%07"#/3 @7<2Y Z4+, Z4.$&C;S +744<-,34 ,- +#-1"%2 Z<"70# ,- 1(# @,:1##-1( +#-1<")S !4=: ?+)1-%S 34&&YS 94+(4+1 N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LQPY !4+",% Z4,=%#$"#S L7A#"1 c;#-3 %-9 (,3 O170,%- +744<-,1,#3S *.+1.%S M#1): 4#4S *.+1.% N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LIPY *4.,4 K4;=4#S E(# ],AA<1K +744<-,1) %-9 6%1,7- J<,29,-.S *+)#2%$"#S GdS *+)#2%$"# N#)(%+&)$; *+%&&S 8LJ8Y 5%% >,%R)& 1% /"2e.%(),,%X& 2+)$)e.% "7 $0% U+%#20 &$4$)&$& )# E(# c29 L#.,4# %-9 1(# P"#-&( L#>72<1,7-S $+4#&Y 9%#+; K%%(%S B"#1"#S 3.++4;S 8JJJY

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

APA 671#3

QP QQ QJ QL JT J8 JA JD JI JO JP JQ JJ

JL LT L8 LA LD LI LO LP LQ LJ LL 8TT 8T8 8TA 8TD 8TI

M?)1Y 34+R l <#-%,&S +744<-,31 ?%-,$#317Y M?)1Y M?)1Ya &%% 4,&" U+4#2)& U.C4;4=4S E(# *Z-9 7$ C,317")/B E(# 6%1,7-%2 8-1#"#31B TUgUY 34+RS G#"4%- 89#727.)Y @,4&&=4#S E(# 6#; ?,992# +2%33 %-9 M#47&"%&) ,- G27A%2 !#"30#&1,>#Y @.##4+ 3;+14,S E(# '#2$%"# @1%1# L#&7-3,9#"#9S "6Y 2)$Y F"#4,1 K"H4$S E(# c4A<934%-Y M?)1Y /0%"?4,1S E(# +(%22#-.# 7$ FA<-9%-&#S "6Y 2)$Y @,4&&=4# 4#1 5H4$"&S P7" M#47&"%&)= 1(# 67A2# +(%"%&1#" %-9 E"%.,& P2%;3 7$ 1(# ?,992# +2%33S "6Y 2)$Y E%?%+S Z&7-74) %-9 @7&,#1)S "6Y 2)$Y K"#4,1 3Y @,4&&=4# 4#1 >+$0.+ dY c)1)20S +7-$2,&1 %-9 +7-1"72= E(# +(%22#-.# 17 H#.,1,4%&) ,- 1(# E;#-1,#1( +#-1<")S ]%(%+,; 9),,&S !4,YS 54-% *.?,)24$)"#&S 8LQIY @%+=4# W+%,4$)()&=X )# %$0)2& 04& ?%%# 4$$42C%1 &$+"#-,; &)#2% $0% G4\) %+4 ^ 4#1 +)-0$,; &"Y F.+C0%)=S W/0% &42+%1 4#1 6+"74#%X )# E(# L<2#3S "6Y 2)$Y 94;%CS E(# +7-31,1<1,7- 7$ H,A#"1)S "6Y 2)$Y U+)%1=4#S +%0,1%2,34 %-9 P"##974S "6Y 2)$Y /0% W%#$)$,%=%#$&X 1%?4$% &$)+& $0% 64&&)"# "7 >=%+)24# 2"#&%+(4$)(%&Y /0"=4& d%77%+&"#S E(# M#&2%"%1,7- 7$ 8-9#0#-9#-&#Y /0% N#)$%1 G4$)"#& M#&2%"%1,7- 7$ C<4%- L,.(13 ^ )$ )#2,.1%& %2"#"=)2 4#1 &"2)4, +)-0$&Y K"?%+$ ]",$S F ?%- P7" F22 @#%37-3S G%H ["+CS c)C)#-S 8LJTY 3"+%S O170,%Y 34R E%?%+S E(# @7&,727.) 7$ L#2,.,7-S @,%#2"%S M,,YS U+%% *+%&&S 8LPQY d%4# *4., 54+$+%S J#,-. %-9 671(,-.-#33S G%H ["+CS *+%#$)2% 94,,S 8LOPY K"," 34;S Z:,31#-&#S G%H ["+CS ]4&)2 ]""C&S 8LODY <1=.#1 fY E),&"#S @7&,7A,727.)S "6Y 2)$Y M?)1Y d.1)$0 K)20 94++)&S E(# 6<"1<"# F33<401,7-S G%H ["+CS U+%% *+%&&S 8LLJY M?)1Y

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

671#3 APD

>?.#14#2% $0%"+;S 8I^8P >,2"0", 4?.&%S DTS IPS PT^D >,$+.)&=S AAJS AI8^A >="+4,)$;S AT8S ATL^8I >#"=)%S LS DT^DOS ATI^P >+?)$+4-%S JL^LQ >+)&$"$,%S QLS 8OTS 8Q8^J8S 8LA^D >&)4# WU,.X _>&)4# 7)#4#2)4, 2+)&)& 8LLJ`S JA^O >.-.&$)#%S 5$S AAA^D ]4),".$& 7"+ $0% +)20S QP^LQ J%"",73 _&,.=&`S OIS OQ^L ]%,,S F4#)%,S 8P ]%#%(",%#2% _!"#7.2)4#`S 8TA^PS 8LA^DS AAJ^DA ]%#$04=S d%+%=;S 8OD^I ]%+,%S >Y>Y 4#1 @4+1)#%+ 3%4#&S D ]%+#4,S 34+$)#S 8JJ^L ])&=4+2CS 88P ]+4\),S 88S APS OI^OS QL ]+)$4)# _H%,74+% &$4$% 6+"-+4=&`S 88J^AA ].&)#%&& 2;2,% "7 ?""= 4#1 ?.&$S 8PT^A !4#414S 88T^88 !46)$4,)&=S 24+)#-S 8JS 8AJ^LS ADL^IT !46)$4,)&=S 0)-0:$%20S 8^8AS QO^JT !46)$4,)&=S .#24+)#-S 8LP^AT8 !4$0",)2 204+)$;S AAI^O !4$0",)2)&=S AA8^O !0%+#"HS K"#S LI !0),124+%S Q^LS LL^8TL !0)#4S 8AO^J !0+)&$)4#)$;S AA8^O !,"H4+1S K)204+1 4#1 f0,)#S OJ^PTS 8IL^OTS ATPS ATJ !"#7.2).&S 8TA^PS 8LA^DS AAJ^DA !":64;=%#$&S LJ^8TOS 8OA !"#&6)2.".& 2"#&.=6$)"#S 8OS PT^D !.,$.+% "7 6"(%+$;S O8^PD

F%="2+4$)2:5"2)4,)&=S 8TA^8T F%="-+460)2 $+4#&)$)"#S LJ^8TTS 8DT^A F)2C%#&S !04+,%&S OA^IS 8OI F+.- 4?.&%S AQS IPS OJ^PD F.4,:24+%%+ 2".6,%S J^8AS 8L^AO F.+C0%)=S <=),%S AS JS 8OTS ATI^L <1.24$)"#S 2",,%-% 4#1 .#)(%+&)$;S DJ^L <1.24$)"#S -+41% &20"",S DQ^J <1.24$)"#S 6+%:&20"",S DP^Q <,1%+ 24+%S 8QS PL^QT <$0)2 "7 &"2)4, b.&$)2%S A8O^AT `S JI^PS JL^LQ U%$)&0 "7 2"=="1)$)%&S 8OS ATA^I U,%R $)=%S 8TP^8TS 8AJ^L U".+ $)-%+& _5)#-46"+%S 9"#- Z"#-S Z"+%4S /4)H4#`S OIS 8TA^P U+4#2%S JJ^8TA U+4#C7"+$ 520"",S DOS DJ^IT U+%.1S 5)-=.#1S A8D U+)%1=4#S 3),$"#S QJS 8OO^Q @4,?+4)$0S d"0# Z%##%$0S QJS 8OO^L @%#1%+ 2"#7,)2$&S Q^ATS PJ^QT @%+=4#;S IQ^OTS OO^POS 88I^8JS 8IA^I @,"?4, (),,4-%S D^8TS 8L^DL @+4#164+%#$&S 8L^A8 @.%&$ H"+C%+& _@%+=4#;`S 88I^8J @.)1%1 =4+C%$ _ d464#`S JP 94HC)#-S 5$%60%#S JS D8^D API

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

M#1%R

8-9#: APO

M3US QL^LI M#1)()1.4,)&=S AT8^D M#&)1%+ $+41)#-S JL^LAS ATA^D M#&$)$.$)"#&S 6+)=4+;S 8L^IT M#&$)$.$)"#&S &%2"#14+;S J^88S ID^I M#$%+#4$)"#4, 3"#%$4+; U.#1S QL^LI M+"# +)2% ?"H, _!0)#4`S 8AO^P M&4)40S A8O^8Q M&,4=S AAO^J M&+4%,S 8TT^A M$4,;S LJ^8TT d464#S IJ^OTS J8^L d"? $+4)#)#- 6+"-+4=&S IQ^OTS P8^DS 88I^8P d"&%60.&S A8J d.14)&=S A8O^AT Z%;#%&S d"0# 34;#4+1S QL^J8S 8PT^O Z)??.$\S A8O^AT Z"0,S 9%,=.$S 88I^8J Z"+4#S AAD^O Z"+%4S JI^Q B4HS 8JA^JS ADP^L B4HS #4$.+4, ,4H 60),"&"60;S 8JJ^LT B%% Z.4# [%HS 8TA^P B%-4, 4.$0"+)$;S 8JA^JS ADP^L 34,$0.&S /0"=4&S 8D^8IS OD^I 34+2.&%S 9%+?%+$S A88^8I 34+RS Z4+,S 8I^8PS OO^PS 8DPS 8OO^PT 34&,"HS 8LD^P 34&& =%1)4S D8^OS A88^8I 3%#$4, 0%4,$0 24+%S I8^A 3%+$"#S K"?%+$ ZYS OJ^PTS ATI^J 3)11,% 2,4&&S 8L^II 3),,S d"0# 5$.4+$S 8OI

3),,&S !Y E+)-0$S L^8A 3"04==%1S AAO^J 3"+4, =4,4)&%S DD^QS ATT^88 3"+%S /0"=4&S ADL^ID 3"+-4#S dY*YS LI G%H =)11,% 2,4&&S 8L^II G"+H4;S 8TP^8T G.2,%4+ 74=),;S A^AT *,4$"S DQS Q8^AS 8Q8^J8S 8JQ^J *"(%+$;S 2.,$.+% "7S OO^PD *"(%+$;S $0% .#1%+2,4&&S OO^PD *+"1.2%+ .#)$&S 8I^8O *+"$%&$4#$ %$0)2S 8LQ^ATA *.+)$4#)&=S 8LQ^ATA K4H,&S d"0#S 8PO^Q8 K%1?+)2C .#)(%+&)$)%& _]+)$4)#`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

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

9%4,$0 24+%S 8P^8QS IT^IS PL^QTS 88I^A8S 8DT^IA 9%1-% 7.#1S JL^LQ 9)-0:$%20 246)$4,)&=S A^8TS QO^JT 9"#- Z"#-S OA^IS JI^P 9"+)\"#$4, &"2)4,)\4$)"#S A88^8DS ADL^ID 9.-"S c)2$"+S OA^IS 8OI^O 9.=4#)&=S +%,)-)".&S ADL^ID 9.=4#)&=S &%2.,4+S ADL^ID

APP 8-9#:

N#1%+2,4&&S O8^PD N#)$%1 G4$)"#& !04+$%+ "7 9.=4# K)-0$&S AIT^A N66%+ 2,4&&S PI^QI

c%?,%#S /0"+&$%)#S DS 8OS PT^8S QJS 8OQS ATL E%?%+S 34RS DT^8S 8LQ^AT8 E%,74+% &$4$% 7"+ $0% +)20S QO^LQ E"+C)#- 2,4&&S IO^OT E"+,1 ]4#CS QL^LI h%,A%13<S JA

c4,.%:411%1 $4R _c>/`S 8DP^OA

10.1057/9780333985427 - Caring Capitalism, Ronald M. Glassman

Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to University of St Andrews - PalgraveConnect - 2011-09-24

/"2e.%(),,%S >,%R)& 1%S ADD /+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$&S 8OD^J8 /+4#&7%+ 64;=%#$& _N5>`S 8IO^OA