Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 93 CHARACTERIZATION AND CHEMICAL MODIFICATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE
This Pag...
80 downloads
2359 Views
20MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 93 CHARACTERIZATION AND CHEMICAL MODIFICATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis Advisory Editors: B. Delmon and J.T. Yates Vol. 93
CHARACTERIZATION AND CHEMICAL MODIFICATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE E. E Vansant, R Van Der Voort and K. C. Vrancken
University of Antwerp (U.LA.), Laboratory of Inorganic Chemistry, Universiteitsplein 1, B-2610 Wilrijk, Belgium
1995 ELSEVIER
A m s t e r d a m m L a u s a n n e - - N e w York m O x f o r d - - S h a n n o n - - T o k y o
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0-444-81928-2 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A.- This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
Preface
Oxide surface materials are widely used in many applications, in particular where chemically modified oxide surfaces are involved. Indeed, in disciplines as separations, catalysis, bioengineering, electronics, ceramics, etc. modified oxide surfaces are very important. In all cases, the knowledge of their chemical and surface characteristics is of great importance for the understanding and eventual improvement of their performances. The purpose of this book is essentially to cover techniques and procedures characterizing and modifying the silica surface. We hope that this book will be useful for all those who, working at the graduate student or research worker level, are interested in the chemistry of silica and chemically modified oxide surfaces. The content of this book reviews the latest developments in the characterization and chemical modification of silica surfaces. No attempt has been made to survey exhaustively the literature of any topic. The material has been collected from recent publications and own research work in this field. Also, recent disclosures of research activities in the former USSR are documented in detail in the text. The book is divided into three major parts. The first part (Part I) reviews the characterization of the silica surface, discussing the preparation and properties of pure silica (Chapter 1), the physical characterization of the silica surface (Chapter 2), the chemistry of silica (Chapter 3), the quantification of the silanol number (Chapter 4), the distribution of the silanol types and their desorption energies (Chapter 5), the effect of surface morphology on the dehydroxilation behaviour (Chapter 6) and the related silicate materials (Chapter 7). Part II discusses the chemical modification of
vi the silica surface, coveting the procedures for a chemical modification of the silica surface and their applications (Chapter 8), the modification with silicon compounds (Chapter 9), the modification with boron compounds (Chapter 10) and the use of other modifiers (Chapter 11) including the ammoniation of modified silicas to introduce functional groups on the surface (Chapter 12). The third part (Part III) describes the chemical surface coating technique (Chapter 14) with respect to other surface coating methods (Chapter 13). Furthermore, the principles of the most frequently used surface analysis techniques are briefly described in the annexes A, B, C and D. We are grateful to the authors and publishers (The American Chemical Society, Plenum Press, The American Institute of Chemical Engineering, Elsevier Science Publishers, The Royal Society of Chemistry, Academic Press, VCH Verlaggeselschaft mbH, VSP International Science Publishers, Marcel Dekker Inc., John Wiley and Sons, Degussa AG, Gordon and Breach Science Publishers, Springer Verlag INC, and The National Research Council of Canada) who granted us permission to reproduce illustrations from their books, articles and journals. We wish to express our appreciation to Prof. J. Riga (University of Namur), Prof. P. Grobet (Catholic University of Leuven), Dr. B. Gilissen (Flemish Institute for Technological Research), Prof. P. Geladi (University of Umeh-Sweden) and Prof. J. Van Landuyt (University of Antwerp) for their research collaboration. Very special thanks to Mr. K. Possemiers for his help in the writing of Chapter 10 and Mrs. L.F. Quiroz and Mrs. I. De Ridder for typing and setting every letter and every figure of this work. Finally, we want to thank the NFWO (National Science Foundation of Belgium), the University of Antwerp (UIA), the Commission of the European Communities and the IUAP for their financial support.
E.F. Vansant
P. Van Der Voort K.C. Vrancken
vii Etienne F. Vansant is presently Professor in Inorganic Chemistry at the University of
Antwerp (UIA), Belgium. He has served as Visiting Professor, Research Associate and Invited Consultant in several universities and companies in the field of material science. Professor Vansant's research interests include the optimalization of gas separation and purification techniques for both industrial and ecological purposes, the conditioning and purification of waste waters and soils, and the development of new materials. Pascal Van Der Voort is presently senior research assistant at the Laboratory of
Inorganic Chemistry (University of Antwerp). He was granted the title of Doctor in Sciences for his pioneering work on Chemical Surface Coating. After that, Dr. Van Der Voort stayed strongly involved in the research on chemically modified oxide surfaces and their application as ceramics and catalysts. Karl C. Vrancken is presently a researcher at the Laboratory of Inorganic Chemistry
(University of Antwerp). In this position he substantiated the development of the Chemical Surface Coating method. In his young career as a Doctor in Sciences, he gained full expertise in organosilane chemistry. His current work is concerned with surface modifications and advanced materials preparation.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ix
Table of contents PART I CHAPTER 1
CHARACTERIZATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE SILICA: PREPARATION AND PROPERTIES
1. Introduction: natural and synthetic silica 2. Preparation of amorphous silica 2.1 Silica sols and gels 2.2 Pyrogenic silicas 2.3 Precipitated silicas 2.4 Comparative properties of silicas 3. The effect of particle packing on the surface area 4. The sol - gel process 4.1 Hydrolysis 4.2 Condensation 4.3 Gelation 4.4 Aging 4.5 Drying 4.6 Stabilization, consolidation 4.7 Advantages and applications 5. Applications of pure silicas and powders 5.1 Porosity 5.2 Active surface 5.3 Hardness 5.4 Particle size References CHAPTER 2
PHYSICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE
1. The isotherm 2. Determination of the specific surface area 3. Pore size characterization 3.1 Average pore diameter 3.2 Pore size distributions 3.2.1 Mesoporous silicas 3.2.2 Microporous silicas 3.2.3 Macroporous silicas 3.3 Modelling theories References
3 4 4 7 8 9 13 15 16 19 22 24 24 25 27 27 27 28 28 28 28
31 32 34 37 37 38 38 41 53 55 55
CHAPTER 3
THE SURFACE CHEMISTRY OF SILICA
1. Surface species 2. The hydroxylated surface 3. Dehydroxylation and rehydroxylation 3.1 Dehydration and dehydroxylation 3.2 Rehydration and rehydroxylation 4. Infrared study of the silica surface 5. Deuteration 5.1 Deuteration of hydroxylated silica 5.2 Deuteration of partially dehydroxylated silica References CHAPTER 4
QUANTIFICATION OF THE SILANOL NUMBER
1. Introduction 2. The silanol number- a physicochemical constant 3. Hexamethyldisilazane as a silanol titrator 4. Conclusion References CHAPTER 5
THE DISTRIBUTION OF THE SILANOL TYPES AND THEIR DESORPTION ENERGIES
1. The infrared models 2. The NMR models 3. T P D - models 4. Zhuravlev's model 5. Comparison and conclusion References CHAPTER 6
THE EFFECT OF SURFACE MORPHOLOGY ON THE DEHYDROXYLATION BEHAVIOUR
References CHAPTER 7 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
59 59 62 62 62 64 65 68 68 71 74 79 79 81 83 88 89
93 94 104 109 118 122 125
127 131
RELATED MATERIALS: SILICATES
Simple orthosilicates Other discrete, noncyclic silicate anions Cyclic silicate anions Infinite chain anions Infinite sheet anions Minerals 6.1 Clays 6.2 Zeolites References
133 133 133 134 134 135 135 136 137 145
xi PART II
CHAPTER 8
CHEMICAL MODIFICATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE CHEMICAL MODIFICATION OF SILICA: APPLICATIONS AND PROCEDURES
1. Applications of modified silica gel 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Analytical 1.2.1 High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) 1.2.2 Ion Exchange Chromatography 1.2.3 Size Exclusion Chromatography 1.2.4 Gas Chromatography 1.2.5 Preconcentration of trace metals 1.3 Chemical 1.3.1 Heterogeneous catalysis 1.3.2 Phase transfer catalysis 1.4 Biochemical 1.4.1 Immobilization of enzymes 1.4.2 Affinity Chromatography (AC) 1.5 Industrial 1.5.1 Composites 1.5.2 S-emission monitoring 1.5.3 Modification of thin SiO/layers 2. Modification procedures 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Sol- gel 2.3 Aqueous solvent 2.4 Organic solvent 2.5 Self- assembled monolayers 2.6 Hydride intermediate 2.7 Vapour- phase reactions References CHAPTER 9
MODIFICATION WITH SILICON COMPOUNDS: MECHANISTIC STUDIES
1. Modification with aminosilanes 1.1 Modification of silica gel with aminosilanes from aqueous solution 1.1.1 The APTS structure in aqueous solution 1.1.2 Modification from aqueous solvent 1.2 The influence of water in the reaction of silica with APTS 1.2.1 Reaction on hydrated silica gel 1.2.2 Water in the solvent- silica system 1.2.3 Air humidity in the curing stage 1.2.4 Conclusion
149 149 149 151 154 158 158 159 159 160 160 162 163 163 165 167 168 171 171 172 172 173 175 177 180 183 185 187
193 194 196 196 198 200 200 205 206 209
o~
Xll
1.3 Modelling of the interactions in the loading step 1.3.1 Adsorption kinetics and isotherms 1.3.2 Limitations by substrate structure 1.3.3 Conclusion 1.4 Characterization of the aminosilane modified silica 1.4.1 Chemical condensation of aminosilanes with the silica surface 1.4.2 Limitations by substrate structure 1.4.3 Conclusion 1.5 Interactions at the amine side 1.5.1 Stability and surface interaction 1.5.2 Coordination of the amine group 1.5.3 Conclusion 1.6 The role of silanols in the modification of silica with aminosilanes 1.6.1 The role of surface silanols 1.6.2 The role of silane silanols 1.6.3 Conclusion 2. Modification with chlorosilanes 2.1 Vapour- phase reactions with (methyl) chlorosilanes 2.1.1 A review 2.1.2 Effectiveness, surface coverage and stoichiometry 2.2 Liquid - phase reactions with alkylchlorosilanes (Cg - C~g) 3. Modification with other silicon compounds 3.1 Halogenosilanes (R4.,SiBr., R4_.SiI.) 3.2 Alkoxysilanes (R4_,Si(OR).) 3.3 Alkylsiloxanes References CHAPTER 10
MODIFICATION WITH BORON COMPOUNDS
1. Introduction 2. Modification with boronhalides 2.1 Reaction mechanism 2.2 Influencing factors 2.2.1 The effect of the pretreatment temperature 2.2.2 The effect of the reaction temperature 2.2.3 The effect of the degassing temperature 2.2.4 The effect of the transition state 2.2.4 The effect of the reaction time 2.3 Stability of the modified surface 3. Modification of the silica surface with diborane 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Reaction mechanism 3.2.1 Reaction with hydroxyls 3.2.2 Reaction with siloxanes 3.3 Hydroxyl specificity 3.4 Kinetic study of the boronation reaction
209 210 219 225 225 226 233 239 240 240 243 244 255 256 262 265 266 266 266 270 282 288 288 289 290 292 299 299 300 300 304 304 311 312 313 315 315 319 319 320 320 331 335 339
xiii
CHAPTER 11
3.5 Influence of the boronation reaction on porosity of the silica References
347 353
MODIFICATION WITH OTHER COMPOUNDS
357
1. Modification with T i - compounds 1.1 Reaction mechanisms 1.2 Analysis techniques 1.3 Applications 2. Modification with A1- compounds 2.1 Reaction mechanisms 2.2 Analysis techniques 2.3 Applications 2.3.1 Model systems for cracking catalysts 2.3.2 Ziegler - Natta catalysts 3. Modification with P - compounds 3.1 Reaction mechanisms 3.2 Analysis techniques 3.3 Applications 4. Modification with transition metal compounds References CHAPTER 12
AMMONIATION OF MODIFIED SILICA: INTRODUCTION OF FUNCTIONAL GROUPS
1. Introduction 2. Ammoniation of the unmodified silica 2.1 At room temperature 2.2 At moderate temperatures 2.3 At high temperatures 2.4 At very high temperatures 2.5 Summary 3. Ammoniation of halogenated silica 4. Ammoniation of chlorosilylated silica 4.1 Room temperature ammoniation 4.2 Ammoniation at higher temperatures 4.2.1 Silazane functions 4.2.2 Nitride functions 4.3 Diagnostic value of the Si - H vibration 4.3.1 Quantitative determination of the surface species, using PLS 4.3.2 Mechanistic study of the perturbation of the silane band 4.3.3 Conclusion 5. Ammoniation of silica, activated with boron compounds 5.1 The boron - nitrogen chemistry 5.2 Ammoniation of boronated silica 5.3 Ammoniation of silica, activated with BC13
357 357 361 363 364 364 368 368 368 369 370 370 374 375 375 378
383 383 384 384 386 388 389 389 390 393 393 396 399 401 404 405 413 417 418 418 422 425
xiv PART IH
CHEMICAL SURFACE COATING
CHAPTER 13
COATING TECHNIQUES
437
1. Chemical Vapour Deposition (CVD) 1.1 Conventional Chemical Vapour Deposition 1.2 Metal - organic CVD (MOCVD) 1.3 Plasma- Enhanced CVD (PECVD) 1.4 Laser CVD (LCVD) 1.5 Fluidized CVD (FBCVD) 1.6 Chemical Vapour Infiltration (CVI) 1.7 Materials and applications 2. Physical Vapour Deposition (PVD) 2.1 Thermal Physical Vapour Deposition (PVD) 2.2 Sputtering 2.3 Ion plating 3. Atomic Layer Epitaxy 4. Molecular Layering 5. Chemical Surface Coating References
437 438 440 441 442 443 445 445 449 450 451 452 453 455 458 458
CHAPTER 14
CHEMICAL SURFACE COATING
1. Principles of Chemical Surface Coating 2. Gas-phase modification 2.1 Creation of the precursor 2.1.1 Cycle 1 2.1.2 Cycles 2 - 4 2.1.3 Further optimization of the CSC precursor 2.2 Thermal conversion of the precursor 2.2.1 Quantitative determination of the surface species 2.2.2 Conversion of silanes, some reflections 2.2.3 Conclusion 3. Liquid phase CSC 3.1 The synthesis of silicon carbides 3.2 Silicon (oxy)carbide coatings by Chemical Surface Coating 3.3 Conclusion References
461 461 463 464 464 465 469 471 471 474 475 476 476 478 485 485
XV
APPENDICES
SURFACE ANALYSIS TECHNIQUES
APPENDIX A
FTIR-PAS Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy with Photoacoustic detection
1. Introduction 2. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy 2.1 Principles 2.2 The interferogram 2.3 Apodization and phase correction 3. Photoacoustic spectroscopy 3.1 Principles Bibliography APPENDIX B
XPS X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy
1. Principles 2. Instrumentation Bibliography APPENDIX C
489 491 491 492 495 496 496 499
501 501 503 504
29Si CP MAS NMR
Cross Polarization Magic Angle Nuclear Magnetic Resonance 1. Principles 2. Magic Angle Spinning 3. Cross Polarization Bibliography APPENDIX D
489
SURFACE SCIENCE TECHNIQUES
505 505 507 509 510 511
AUTHOR INDEX
529
SUBJECT INDEX
543
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
9iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!i!i!iiiiii#ili!iiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
..........................
iiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiii!iiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
~
i~!i~ii~i~iiii~iiiii~iiiiiiii~iiiiiii~ii~iii~i~~iiii!~iiii~liliii~!iii~!i!ii!iiii~ii~ii~ii!iiiili~i~i~i~ii~i~i~i~i~i~iiii!iiiii~~~iii~i~ i~iiii!i!iiiiii~iiiii!i~i!~i~ii~iiiiii~i~!iii~i~ii!i~iiiiii~ii~iiiiiiii~iii~li~iii~iiiiiiiiiii
~iii~iii~i~iiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiii!ii~iiiiiiiiiiiii~i~iiiiiii~i~ii~iiiiii~i~i~iiiiii~iii!iiii~iiiiiii~iiii~ii~
'.iiiiiii . . .i.ii.i.ii. .iiiiiiiiiiiii . . . . . .ii!iii!iiiiiiiiii!i . . . . . . . .iiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiii!iliiiiii!iiii~, . . . . .~. . . .~. U ~~,, ~ ~,~~,~,~,, ~,~,~i,~,~~,~,, ~,~,i~,~~,~,~,~,~,~,,,~,~, ,~, , , ,................... , ~,............. 9 ~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~ t~,~,~,~,l~oooo,,~,~t,oooo,l~,~~,~l,l,t,~,~,~i~~ ,~,~,t~,l ~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiil ~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~tI~1I~i~iii~Ii~...... I~oi~oo~o~io~II~ ~'~ '~""~"''"'iiiiiiliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii#iiiiiiiiiiiiiiill i ~ii~iiiiiiii~iii~i~iiii!iiiii~iiiiiiiiii~i~i~!iiiiiiiii~iG~iiii~iiiiiiii~i~i~iiiiii~iiii~i~iii~iiiiii~iiiiii~iiiiiiiiii~i!iiiiii~i~i~iiiiiiiiiiiiiii~i~i~iiiiiiiiiii~i~i~iiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiii~iii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iii
iiiiiiiiiiiili!ii!i!!iiiii!iii!i!i!iiiiiii!ii!i!i!i!iil!i!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iii!ii!ii i!ii!ii!i!ii iii!ii!i!i!iiiiiiii~iii!i!iiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiii!~iiiiiiiii!iiiiii•iiii•~•iiiii•i•i••••iiii••iiiii•iii•!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii i!iii•iii•i•i•i•i••iii•i•ii•iiii•i•iiiiii•iiii•iiiiiii ~i~i~!~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~!i~iii~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~,i~,,i~li~ii~ii~ii~iiiiiii~ii~ii~ii~iiiiii~ili~iii~ilii~ii~ii~i~ii~iii~iii~!i~iiii~ii~ii~ii~iii~iiiiiiiii!i~ii~!~~ii~l~i~i~i~176 iii
iiiii~iii!iii~iii!ii!ii~~i!iiii~iiiii~iiii!~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiii~iii!iiii~iii!iiii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PART 1: THE SILICA SURFACE
Chapter 1
Silica:
preparation and properties
1 Introduction: natural and synthetic silica The name silica comprises a large class of products with the general formula SiO2 or SiO2.xH20. Silica is a naturally occurring material in minerals, such as quartz and flint, and in plants such as bamboo, rice and barley. Most of the silica used in chemical applications however, has a synthetic origin. In its natural form it mostly occurs as a crystalline phase. Various phases may be formed, depending on temperature, pressure and degree of hydration. At atmospheric pressure the anhydrous crystalline silica may be classified in the following phases, according to the temperature:
1143 K quartz
,
'~
1743 K tridymite
"
cristobalite
At 1973 K cristobalite is transformed to amorphous vitreous silica glass. The crystalline form involves a high degree of ordering in a dense structure. The active surface, which may participate in any chemical or physical interaction, is limited to the external surface of the crystalline particles. The specific surface area therefore is similar to the geometric surface.
Amorphous silica occurs in various forms. According to the application, fibres, sheets, sols, gels and powders may be fabricated. A clear view upon the properties of all amorphous forms can be obtained from the process used for their preparation. A main feature of interest in this work is the porosity of the amorphous silica forms. Porosity introduces a large surface area inside the silica particles. As interphase processes require a large surface/mass ratio, amorphous silicas are far more interesting for chemical and physical applications than their crystalline counterparts.
2 Preparation of amorphous silica By changing the method and specific parameters of the silica preparation, surface area, pore volume, pore size and particle size are, to some extent, independently controllable. These are the four variables, governing the chemical and physical behaviour of silica. Each of them will be discussed in detail in the subsequent paragraphs. Initial interest is directed to the methods of preparation and the various types obtained. A survey of these methods and their main characteristics is presented in table 1.1.
2.1 Silica sols and gels The most documented method for the preparation of silica is the sol-gel route. In this process Si(OH)4 molecules condense to form a siloxane network. As a starting compound a soluble silicate (generally sodium silicate) has mainly been used. Over the last decade, however, the use of alkoxysilanes (Si(OR)4 , with R = CH3, C2H5 or C3H7) has gained importance rapidly. Hydrolysis of the alkoxy-group precedes condensation with a neighbouring silanol. Hydrolysis and condensation occur simultaneously, in the aqueous alkoxide solution. Silica sols thus are formed by the mixing of the silicate salt with an acid or the liquid alkoxide with water. By condensation, stable particles of colloidal size are formed. As condensation proceeds, small three-dimensional siloxane networks are gradually formed. The condensation reaction may be influenced by the addition of an electrolyte
or a change of the pH. A control of both factors will either favour the growing of the particles or the linkage of particles to form chains. This is accompanied by an increase in the viscosity of the medium. At the point where elastic stress is supported, the sol has condensed to a gel. Because of the gradual sol-to-gel transition, the gelation point is difficult to measure analytically. The as-formed gel is termed a hydrogel (or alcogel if an alcohol has been used as solvent). The hydrogel structure is controlled by temperature, the pH of the medium, the nature of the solvent, the nature of the added electrolyte and the type of the starting salt or alkoxyde. Aging or drying of the hydrogel results in a loss of the pore-filling liquid. The pores are narrowed by capillary forces exerted by this liquid. A xerogel is formed, with porosity and surface area depending on the aging and drying conditions such as: application of hydrothermal aging (aging at high temperature in aqueous medium), pH and concentration of the hydrogel particles. If an alcogel is dried under supercritical conditions, the pore narrowing by capillary attraction is excluded. The thus formed gel has a very large pore volume (up to 98 % of the total volume) and is therefore named an aerogel. Following Barby, ~ a somewhat broader definition for this type of gel is needed, the main feature being that the pores of an aerogel do not collapse upon immersion in water and redrying, as can be accurately measured by direct porosimetry. A more profound survey of the sol-gel process will be given below.
Table 1.1 Classification of silicas, according to Barby I I.
NATURAL SILICAS
Have a specific surface area, similar to their geometric surface.
II.
SYNTHETIC SILICAS (mostly amorphous)
Surface area, pore volume, pore size and particle size are to some extent independently controllable (commercially interesting).
1.
Colloidal silica Silica sols
Stable dispersions or sols of discrete particles of amorphous silica.
2.
Silica gels
Coherent, rigid, 3D network of contiguous particles of colloidal silica.
2.1. Hydrogels
Silica gel, in which the pores are filled with the corresponding liquid (water).
2.2. Xerogels
A gel from which the liquid medium has been removed, resulting in a compressed structure and a reduced porosity.
2.3. Aerogels
A special form of xerogel, from which the liquid has been removed in such a way as to prevent any collapse or change in the structure as liquid is removed (Iler). A gel with water-collapsible macropores as judged by direct porosimetry (Barby).
Pyrogenic silicas
Silicas made at high temperatures.
3.1. Aerosils
| flame hydrolysis products of SIC14; very pure materials.
3.2. Arc silicas
Made by the reduction of high purity sand.
3.3. Plasma silicas
Ultra fine silica powders, made by the direct volatilization of sand in a plasma jet.
Precipitates
Made by the precipitation of the silicic acid solution.
3.
4.
2.2 Pyrogenic silicas Besides the preparation in the liquid phase, silica may also be formed with high temperature processes, using a flame, arc or plasma. One of the most widely used sources of pure silicas is the burning of SiCI 4 with hydrogen and oxygen. In the flame the following reactions take place" 2 H2 SiC14 2 H2
+ O2
-
+2 H20
+ 02
+ SiC14
2 H20 -
SiO 2 -
+ 4 HC1 SiO 2
+4 HC1
In this way 'fumed' silicas are formed. This process was developed by Degussa and the thus formed silicas were marketed as Aerosil. | A flow-chart of the production process is displayed in figure 1.1. In the reaction process HCI is formed, which is evacuated from the system.
The
characteristics of the produced silica may be controlled by a variation of the reagent concentrations, the flame temperature and the time of presence in the combustion chamber. Thus, the specific surface area, particle size and particle size distribution may be varied. In this type of silica, primary particles are linked into linear chains and a nonporous structure is produced (figure 1.2).
Arc silicas are formed by the reduction of high-purity sand in a furnace. This type of silica shows a greater variation in particle size. Primary particles do not form chains but form dense, non-microporous secondary particles. The volatilization of sand in a plasma jet produces plasma silicas. These are ultra fine silica powders.
Hydrogen
HCl-adsorption
Oxygen (air) Si-tetra chloride
b
~
~ I
I
l
]
I f
i,I I
...........
pyrogenic silica gel a: vaporiser b: mixing chamber c: combustion chamber
d: cooling e: separation
f: purification g: silo
Figure 1.1 Flow - chart of production process. Taken from ref (2), with permission.
2.3 Precipitated silicas
The precipitated silicas include a wide range of silicas with a variety of structural characteristics. Most of the preparation methods are patented. In general the formation involves a coagulation and precipitation from silica solutions. Properties may therefore be supposed to be similar to those of the gels. For these silicas however, preparation conditions are such as to avoid gel growth and stimulate precipitation. As an overall definition, Barby proposed: dry silicas with no long or short distance characteristic structure.
1
.... ~~::, ~
~-'iiiiiii~iiiiii~ii!::~i !~............ .i~i!~!i~ill ........
!!!iiii~i!ii:,i~iii~i...... ~iii.!i~:ii."~. i~i:. . . . . . . .
Figure 1.2 TEM- picture of AEROSIL 380. Takenfrom ref (2), with permission.
2.4 Comparative properties of silicas The physical properties of the different silicas, prepared by the above mentioned methods, are compared in table 1.2. The variation in physical properties between various silicas is caused by the different way in which particles are aggregated and agglomerated. Agglomeration is the sharing of a plane or side between two particles, while aggregation indicates one-point linking of particles or agglomerates. The size of the primary particles, together with the density and degree of agglomeration and aggregation, determines the porosity and specific surface area of the silicas. The chain-like agglomeration of primary particles in fumed silicasresults in a non-porous structure. Aerosils are finely divided and have no interior surface. For arc silicas, primary particles agglomerate in spheres. Because of the dense packing of the particles, those spheres do not show any porosity. The specific surface is the external surface of the spheres. Xerogels and aerogels have a porous structure. The processes governing this structural build-up in the silica gels will be discussed below.
Table 1.2 Physical properties of various silicas2 Characteristics
Pyrogenic silicas fumed silica
Specific BET area Size primary particles Size aggregation /agglomeration Density Volume Mean pore diameter Pore diameter distribution Shape of interior surface Aggregation and agglomeration structure
* not applicable
m2/g nm /zm
50 to 600 5 to 50
g/cm 3 ml/100g nm
2.2 1000 to 2000 non porous till ca. 300 m2/g 0 chain-like agglomeration (open surface)
Silicas made by wet methods arc silica
precipitated silica
25 to 300 5 to 500 2 t o 15
30 to 800 5 to 100
2.2 500 to 1000 non porous
0 dense spherical aggregates/particles non-agglomerated
xerogels
aerogels
250 to 1000 3 to 20 1 to 20
250 to 400 3 to 20 1 to 15
1.9 to 2.1 200 to 2000 > 30
2.0 100 to 200 2 to 20
2.0 800 to 2000 > 25
very broad poor
narrow very much
narrow much
slightly aggregated nearly spherical particles
highly porous agglomerated particles
macroporous agglomerated particles
1 to 40
11
The TEM microstructure of three porous silica xerogels is shown in figure 1.3.
Figure 1.3 TEM picture of porous silica xerogels, (a) microporous," (b) mesoporous and (c) macroporous (see next page).
12
Figure 1.3. TEM-picture of porous silica xerogels (continued).
It is apparent that the average pore size is related to the size of the agglomerated particles. While in the microporous (a) sample the particles may not be discerned individually, the macroporous (c) samples clearly show agglomerated particles with a 20-30 nm diameter. Macropores are also visible on this picture. The mesoporous sample (b) has intermediate characteristics. The agglomerated clusters have a particle size in the 1-20/zm range. The specific surface area is mainly due to the interior surface of these clusters. This property is responsible for the fact that silica gels are mainly applied for adsorption while fumed silicas are used in rheological applications. In these the presence of highly dispersed small particles is important. The applications of silica will be discussed in detail furtheron.
13 3 The effect of particle packing on the surface area
Whereas the surface area of a crystalline silica is in fact the external surface area, the surface area and the pore size distribution of an amorphous silica are actually determined by the dimensions of the silica spheres (primary particles) that build up the network. For non-aggregated spherical particles, this relationship is very straightforward. In this silica type, the primary particles are not clustered and Sheinfain's 3 globular theory can be applied. The globular theory predicts an inverse relationship between surface area and the primary particle size by the following equation: S -
3
(1)
a.p
with S the specific surface area (m2/g), a the particle radius (nm) and p the density (2.2 * 106/m3). Upon clustering of the primary particles towards secondary structures (aggregation), obviously the surface area will drop. This is illustrated in figure 1.4, showing the area lost at the point of contact between two spheres. The approximate area lost per contact and per particle is 7rb2. A slightly more accurate value is given by equation 2" fraction of area lost per contact -
aR
2(R+a)2
(2)
Based upon the theoretical maximum surface area (Sm) and the measured surface area (SBEr, cfr. chapter 2), the average coordination number of the primary particles in the aggregate can be calculated as: 1 jv~
--
-
SBET Sm aR
total loss of surface area loss of surface area per coordination
(3)
2 (R + a)2 This number should be interpreted as the average number of primary particles that surround the particle under study.
14
SiO 2
R
R R
~l,~ I
;"
2b
r
I
Figure 1.4 Area lost to nitrogen adsorption at the point of contact between spherical particles. Taken from ref . (6), with permission.
15
4 The sol-gel process From the above mentioned silica preparation paths, the sol-gel route is the most studied and consequently most documented. Sol-gel processing is used not only for the preparation of silica gels, but also for the synthesis of ceramic products, ranging from thin films and coatings over porous membranes to composite bodies. 4 This broad success of the method is due to its ability to form pure and homogeneous products at very low temperatures. 5 Thus, the sol-gel technology is replacing the millennia old ceramic fabrication processes in which powders are shaped into objects and subsequently densified at temperatures close to their liquidus. This allowed a transformation of ceramics and glasses from 'stone age materials' to 'space age materials'. The sol-gel process is a wet chemical method, involving hydrolysis and condensation of metal alkoxides and inorganic salts. The synthesis of silica gel using sodium silicate as a starting product has been well documented by Iler, 6 Unger 7 and Barby ~ at the end of the 1970's. Though St6ber et al. 8 had reported the controlled synthesis of spherical silica powder from tetraethoxysilane (TEOS), using ammonia as a catalyst in 1968, the use of alkoxide precursors got minor attention in their works. The activity in the research on these precursors was definitively initiated by the work of Yoldas 9'1~ and Yamane et al., II who demonstrated the preparation of silica monoliths by careful drying of gels. During the 1980's until now the sol-gel process, using alkoxysilane precursors has been a major research topic, aiming at the thorough understanding of the various process steps and at a broadening of the field of applications. The huge amount of literature in this context has been excellently reviewed and synthesized by Brinker and Scherer, ~2Hench and West 13and Scherer. 5'26 We will restrict ourselves to giving a survey of the sol-gel synthesis of silica gel, emphasizing the control of pore structure, specific surface area and particle size in the course of the process.
16
4.1 Hydrolysis Sol-gel silica synthesis is based on the controlled condensation of Si(OH)4 entities. These may be formed by hydrolysis of soluble alkali metal silicates or of alkoxysilanes. The commonly used compounds are sodium silicates and tetraethoxysilane (TEOS). Both reactions are governed by specific parameters, which will be discussed briefly:
(1)
hydrolysis of sodium silicate:
Silicate solution species are controlled by the pH of the medium and silicon concentration. ~4 Figure 1.5 displays the aqueous silicate species as a function of pH for concentrations of 0.01 and 10.5 M of silicon. Monomolecular Si(OH)4 is the predominant solution species below pH 7. At higher pH, anionic and polynuclear species are formed. Sodium silicate solutions are neutralized using sulphuric acid to obtain the Si(OH)4. The sodium silicate solution characteristics are dependent on the SiO2:Na20 ratio. For production of precipitated silicas, sols and gels, a sodium silicate ratio 10:3 is usually employed rather than lower ratios, since less acid is required for neutralisation. Furthermore this ratio is available at low cost, since large quantities are produced.
(2)
hydrolysis of alkoxysilanes:
Alkoxysilanes have the general formula Si(OR)4. In most cases the organic R group is methyl or ethyl. Nomenclature and abbreviations are as follows" Si(OCn3) 4 tetramethoxysilane TMOS Si(OCH2CH3)4 tetraethoxysilane TEOS
Because water and alkoxysilanes are immiscible, a mutual solvent such as alcohol is usually used as a homogenizing agent. ~2 However, gels can be prepared from
17
t00
(a) OJm Si(~r) [~.,j
i
80/,
60
....
\
I ....
I .... I ....
Si408(OH ~-
/
rlt3HL, --
I ....
"4il
,/
si,O(OH- :
(b) t0 -Sin Si(T~)
80
\
t
~
2O 6
O0
~ ....
60
20 8
I0 pH
t2
6
8
t0 pH
12
Figure 1.5 Distribution of aqueous silicate species at 298 K in (a) O. 01 M Si(IV) and (b) 10 s M Si(IV). Ionic strength, I = 3 M.
siliconalkoxyde-water mixtures without added solvent, since alcohol produced as a byproduct of the hydrolysis reaction is sufficient to homogenize the initially phase separated system. In order to get a rapid and complete hydrolysis, an acid or a base catalyst may be used. In both cases the reaction occurs by a nucleophilic attack of the oxygen contained in water, to the silicon atom. Hydrolysis mechanisms were studied by Osterholz and Pohl, ~5using alkyltrialkoxysilanes instead of tetra-alkoxysilanes. Both types of compounds are following the mechanism below. The base catalyzed hydrolysis (figure 1.6) is a two-step process, with formation of a pentacoordinate intermediate. Acid catalyzed hydrolysis proceeds by an SN2-type mechanism. The leaving alkoxy group is rapidly protonated and a water molecule performs a nucleophilic attack at the central silicon atom.
18
kl _~SiOR + B: + H20
['-~+ H 6 _ / --] z/:: ~:--H--O--~~RA
\
\
Stepl
T.S.1 [B:H++ HO-Si-OR/.
k2
x 6 - R 8+ :/: ~HO-Si--6--H--:B~~.
" "
/A
Pentacoordinate Intermediate
\ Step2
"
T.S.2
SiOH + B: + ROH Figure 1.6a Proposed mechanism for the base catalyzed hydrolysis of silane esters. +
+ "SiOR
kl
+ H
"
H +
~--SiOR +
~--SiOR/+ H20 .
+ H! --~ ~ SiOH
H Step 1 +
~
H+
1 "" ..
. ~SiOH
+ HOR Step 2
k3 -x SiOH + H +
Step 3
Figure 1.6b Proposed mechanism for the hydronium catalyzed hydrolysis of silane esters.
19 4.2 Condensation
Silicic acid molecules condense to form siloxane bonds, with release of water (A). 6 --Si-OH
+
HO-Si-
~
-Si-O-Si-
+
1t20
(A)
Condensation may also proceed by the reaction of the alkoxysilane with a silanol group, releasing an alcohol (B). - Si-OH
+
RO-Si--
--,
-- S i - O - S i -
+
ROH
(B)
The condensation may be acid or base catalyzed. Osterholz and Poh115 concluded that acid catalyzed condensation proceeds through an SN2-Si type mechanism, while base catalyzed condensation is less well understood. They also found that the reaction goes to completion in protic solvents, while in aprotic solvents equilibrium is reached. Hydrolysis and condensation occur simultaneously. The relative rate of both processes determines the sol structure. As discussed by Ying et a l . , 16 in acidic conditions, hydrolysis is faster than condensation. The rate of condensation slows down with increasing number of siloxane linkages around a central silicon atom. This leads to weakly branched polymeric networks. In the basic conditions, on the contrary, condensation is accelerated relative to hydrolysis. The rate of condensation increases with increasing number of siloxane linkages. Thus, highly branched networks with ring structures are formed. This generates large, bulkier, more ramified polymers. According to Ro et al. 17 gels made from low water content sols contain residual organic groups, caused by incomplete hydrolysis, which contributes to the formation of micropores during the thermal treatment. Acid-catalyzed gels show slit-shaped micropores and have a fibrous or plate-like structure. Base-catalyzed gels have cylindrical pores and spherical particles. An understanding of these trends may be gained from the polymerization and growth mechanism of silica sols. Iler 6 stated that the Si(OH)4 condensation and polymerization is not analogous to the linear branching and cross-linking in organic polymers. Three stages are recognized in the silicic acid polymerization"
20
1) 2) 3)
polymerization of monomers to form small primary particles; growth of primary particles; linking of particles into branched chains, then networks, finally extending throughout the liquid medium, thickening it to a gel.
By controlling the pH and with the addition of electrolytes that induce flocculation, the relative importance of steps 2 and 3 may be varied. This control is displayed in figure 1.7.
Monomer Dimer Cyclic pH < 7 or pH 7-10 with salts present
Particle A
~.
~/ ~ ~
".
1 nm 5 nm
pH 7-10 with salts B absent
00 nm
three-dimensional ~ gel networEs..........
Figure 1.7
~(-~ ~
~'/~ /
,,~ors
Polymerizationbehaviour of silica. Takenfrom ref (6), with permission.
21 Condensation takes place in such a way as to maximize the number of Si-O-Si bonds and minimize the number of terminal hydroxyl groups by internal condensation. Thus rings are quickly formed to which monomers add, creating three-dimensional particles. ~2 By a variation of pH and salt addition the particle aggregation into secondary particles (A) or further particle growth (B) is controlled. Thus the particle size and pore structure of the silica is determined. Iler discerned three pH domains in the polymerization process. At pH below 2 the gel time, which indicates the rate of polymerization, is proportional to the proton concentration [H§ Brinker and Scherer ~2 proposed a mechanism involving an associative m SiOHR(OH2) + intermediate. At pH 2 the particles reach the isoelectric point. Above this pH value the condensation rate is proportional to [OH], following: fast - S i - O H + O H - - , - S i O + HzO (C) slow -Si-O
+
HO-Si~
-~
-Si-O-Si-
+
Off
fa)
Reaction (D) occurs preferentially between more highly condensed species and less highly condensed neutral species. I.e. monomers add to small polymerized particles (trimers, tetramers). Further growth involves continued monomer deposition and particle aggregation. Particle growth is limited to about 2 nm by the solubility of the silica in this pH range. Above pH 7, particles are charged by ionisation. Aggregation is therefore reduced. Growth occurs by monomer deposition and Ostwald ripening. This involves the dissolution of small particles and redeposition on larger ones. Aggregation can only take place after the addition of salts, which reduce the stabilizing double layer thickness. Following Murakata et al., TM the pore size distribution is controlled by the addition of several kinds of inorganic salts and surfactants in the sol-gel reaction mixture. Inorganic salts depress the formation of mesopores. The influence of surfactants is dependent on the charge of the head group. The fractional pore volume of large pores is increased in using long-chain diols in the starting solution. ~9
22 Solid silica spheres are prepared by the St6ber s method. This involves the condensation of TEOS in alcoholic solution of water and ammonia. The mechanism of this synthesis was elucidated by Van Blaaderen et al) ~ The particle growth is rate-limited by the production of hydrolysed monomer molecules. It involves a surface condensation of monomers and oligomers, while aggregation of particles is only occurring in the early stages of the condensation.
4.3 Gelation As the polymeric network extends throughout the total volume, the sol thickens to a gel. 6 The sol-to-gel conversion is a gradual process, which is easily observed qualitatively, but difficult to measure analytically. The gelation point tg~ is defined as the point where elastic stress is supported. ~3 Thetg~ is not an intrinsic property of a sol. It is influenced by the size of the container, the solution pH, the nature of the salt concentration, the anion and solvent, the type of initial alkoxy group and the amount of water. A lot of work has been directed to the modelling of the gelling process. The percolation model offers the most widely accepted theory. A review of the model is beyond the scope of this book. The reader is referred to the reviews of Zallen, 22 Staufer et al. 23 and Brinker and Scherer. 12 The gelation rate influences the pore structure. Fast gelation gives an open structure because the particles are quickly connected and cannot undergo further rearrangements.U
4. 4 Aging When the gel is kept in contact with the pore-filling liquid, its structure and properties keep changing as a function of time. This process is called aging. During the aging period, four processes affect the porous structure and surface area of the silica gel. These are polycondensation, syneresis, coarsening and phase transformation. 6'~2'~3
23 Polycondensation is the further reaction of silanols and alkoxy groups in the gel structure to form siloxane bonds by reactions 3 and 4. These reactions result in a densification and stiffening of the siloxane network. Syneresis is the shrinkage of the gel network, resulting in the expulsion of the pore liquid. This shrinkage is caused by the condensation of surface groups inside the pores, resulting in a pore narrowing. In aqueous gel systems the pore size is controlled by an equilibrium between electrostatic repulsion and Van Der Waals attractions. In this case, shrinkage is produced by addition of an electrolyte. The syneresis contraction rate is affected by the sol concentration, temperature and type of solvent. ~3 Besides the condensation, shrinkage may also be caused by capillary forces exerted by the pore-filling liquid on the walls. ~2 Coarsening or Ostwald ripening is the solution and redeposition of small particles. The cause of this process is the higher solubility of convex surfaces, compared to concave surfaces. Therefore, the small particles are dissolved and redeposition on larger particles occurs. Also necks between particles will grow (figure 1.8) and small pores may be filled in. This results in an increase in the average pore size and a decrease in the specific surface area. Summarizing, during aging the pore structure, surface area and stiffness of the gel network are changed and controlled by the following parameters: time, temperature, pH, added electrolyte and pore fluid. 25
Figure 1.8 A chain of small particles is converted to a fiber or rod by the laws of solubility of convex and concave surfaces.
24
4.5 Drying In the drying step the hydrogel or alcogel obtained by gelling and aging is converted to a xerogel. Drying of silica gels is a three stage process. 13 In stage 1 the decrease in gel volume is equal to the volume of the liquid lost by evaporation. Shrinkage of the gel structure occurs due to the large capillary forces exerted by the pore liquid. The greatest changes in volume, weight, density and structure occur in this stage. According to Deshpande et al. 25 a linear decrease in xerogel surface area is observed with increasing solvent tension. Pore volume and pore size distribution follow a similar trend. Stage 1 stops when shrinkage ceases because of the increased stiffness of the dried gel network. This is noted as the 'critical point'. Up to this point the pores remain full of liquid. 26 In stage 2 the pores are emptied. Though the capillary pressure is at its highest level, at the critical point the network may not be compressed further, and the pore liquid evaporates. Liquid is transported through films that cover partially empty pores and evaporates at the surface. The capillary forces reduce consequently. Stage 3 starts when the pores have substantially emptied and surface films can not longer be sustained. The liquid escapes by evaporation within pores and diffusion of vapour to the surface. During this stage there is no further change in structure. The high shrinkage of gels in this drying process has prevented the economical production of large objects and thick films by sol-gel processing. For thin films shrinkage results in thinning of the film rather than cracking. However, processes have been developed to reduce these problems. TM
4. 6 Stabilization, consolidation In order to convert xerogels to dense, stable, solid materials, a further thermal treatment is required. In this stabilization step the gel is dehydrated, dehydroxylated and sintered. Thus all surface hydroxyls are removed and the material is fully densified. Since this work discusses the characterization and modification of porous silica xerogel we will not further discuss the processes in this step. The reader is
25 referred to the work of Brinker and Scherer n and Hench and West ~3 for further details.
4. 7 Advantages and applications A general survey of the advantages of the sol-gel route over the traditional ceramic synthesis processes, concerning processing temperature, is presented in figure 1.9. The huge advantage of sol-gel processing is evident from its step-wise temperature profile, with gradually increasing temperatures. Traditional processes require much higher temperatures and major temperature variations in the course of the process. Further advantages and disadvantages of the sol-gel process were summarized by MacKenzie27 and are presented in tables 1.3 and 1.4.
Melt
1773 TL
Quench
T
Melt-formed Glass b
1
~
!
Time
Figure 1.9 Comparison of the processing of melt-derived glasses and gel-derived 'glass-like' solids.
26
Table 1.3 Some advantages of the sol-gel method over conventional melting for glass .
2. 3.
.
5. 6. 7.
Better homogeneity from raw materials. Better purity from raw materials. Lower temperature of preparation: a. Save energy; b. Minimize evaporation losses; c. Minimize air pollution; d. No reaction with containers, thus purity; e. Bypass phase separation; f. Bypass crystallization. New crystalline solids outside the range of normal glass formation. New crystalline phases from new noncrystalline solids. Better glass products from special glass properties. Special products such as films.
Table 1.4 Some disadvantages of the sol-gel method .
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
High cost of raw materials. Large shrinkage during process. Residual fine pores. Residual hydroxyl. Residual carbon. Health hazard of organic solutions. Long processing times.
Sol-gel derived materials may be used in the form of films, fibres, monoliths, powders, composites and porous media. The most successful applications are those that utilize the potential advantages of the sol-gel processing such as purity, homogeneity and controlled porosity, combined with the ability to form shaped objects at low temperatures, while avoiding inherent disadvantages such as cost of raw materials, long processing times and high shrinkage. ~2
27
5 Applications of pure silicas and powders Due to the variety in porous structure, particle size and surface area, pure silica gels and powders find a very wide range of applications. Variation in preparation methods and parameters allows the tailoring of the substrate properties for specific application needs. The main features in the silica applications are its porosity, active surface, hardness, particle size and the viscous and thixotropic properties. Although most applications are based on a combination of those, a classification according to the main properties of interest may be set up. For references, the reader is referred to the works of Iler 6 and Unger 7 and to the references cited in chapter 8. 5.1 Porosity
Pure silica is used as a stationary phase in various types of liquid chromatography. 2g In size exclusion chromatography 29the separation of polymer compounds is effectuated on basis of diffusion rate of variably-sized molecules through a microporous silica packing with uniform pore size. 5. 2 Active surface
The silica surface allows variable types of interactions in which the large specific surface area as well as the surface site chemistry play an important role. Both topics will be discussed in detail below. Concerning the applications, three types of interactions may be discerned" * adsorption" in liquid-liquid chromatography, silica packings are used, which acts as a sponge to hold the static liquid phase as an active adsorbent. The pure silica may also be used as a stationary phase in column liquid chromatography. The adsorption characteristics are also applied in the use of silica as a catalyst base. Active catalyst species are adsorbed onto high-area silica. The adsorption of dye molecules on silica powders in coatings, paintings and painting inks results in less intense and flatted color. * absorption: silica is used in various forms (from finely divided powders to small granules) as a desiccant. This is probably the largest of all applications. Water is
28 physically and chemically bound to the silica surface. Silica is added to any package product, which may be subjected to corrosion or deterioration by moisture. * ion-exchange: the ion-exchange capacity of the silica surface is used for the bounding of metal complexes and surface metal cations. This property is applicable in the chromatographic separation of cationic species. These have been reviewed by Bannasch and Stam3~and Markova and Vydra. 3~ The nature of the silica surface may be changed by modification with a variety of molecules, causing a still broader range of applications. A survey of these will be given in chapter 2. 5.3 Hardness
The hardness and abrasive properties of silica gels and powders are of interest in their use as reinforcing agents in composite materials. Wear resistance and tensile strength of rubbers and polymers are increased by the introduction of silica in the organic network. In order to preserve these improved qualities in wet conditions, however, the silica surface has to be modified to assure interfacial bonding. 32 5. 4 Particle Size
Due to their disperse character and small particle size, silicas are used as flow aids, i.e. they are used to improve the flow behaviour of other materials. The adsorption of the fine silica particles on other type powdered compounds reduces interparticle interactions. Particle adhesion, electrostatic adhesion, Van Der Waals forces and liquid bridge formation is reduced or avoided. 33 This allows free-flowing behaviour of strongly interacting or irregularly shaped powdered materials. 5.5 Viscosity andthixotropy
When suspended colloidal particles form a network through the liquid, viscosity is increased. For silica gels the thickening and thixotropic effects are used in a large number of applications. The silica is mixed with paints, coatings, inks, pharmaceutical and cosmetics with this purpose. 34
29 References D. Barby, Silicas, in 'Characterization of Powder Surfaces', G.D. Parfitt and G.S.W. Sing eds., Academic Press, London, UK, 1976, 353. 2. .
4. 0
0
.
G. Michael and H. Ferch, Schriftenreihe Pigmente, Degussa, 1991, 11. R. Yu. Sheinfain, N.S. Kruglikova, O.P. Stas and I.E. Neimark, Kolloid Zhur., 1963, 25, 732. J.D. MacKenzie, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., 1988, 100, 162. G.W. Scherer, in Drying '92, A.S. Mujumdar ed., Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1992, 92. R.K. Iler, The Chemistry of Silica, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1979. K.K. Unger, 'Porous Silica, its properties and use as a support in column liquid chromatography', Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1979.
8.
W. St6ber, A. Fink and E. Bohm, J. Coll. Interface Sci., 1968, 26, 62.
9.
B.E. Yoldas, J. Mater. Sci., 1975, 10, 1856.
10.
B.E. Yoldas, J. Mater. Sci., 1977, 12, 1203.
11.
M. Yamane, A. Shinji and T. Sakaino, J. Mater. Sci., 1978, 13, 865.
12.
C.J. Brinker and G.W. Scherer, 'Sol-gel Science', Academic Press, New York, 1989.
13.
L.L. Hench and J.K. West, Chem. Rev., 1990, 90, 33.
14.
C.F. Baes and R.E. Mesmen, in 'The Hydrolysis of Cations', John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1976, p 342.
15.
F.D. Osterholz and E.R. Pohl, in 'Silanes and other Coupling Agents', K.L. Mittaled VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 1992, 119.
16.
J.Y. Ying, J.B. Benzingen and A. Navrotsky, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 1993, 76(10), 2571.
17.
J.C. Ro and I.J. Chung, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 1991, 130, 8.
18.
T. Murakata, S. Sato, T. Ohgawara, T. Watanabe and T. Suzuki, J. Mater. Sci., 1992, 27, 1567.
19.
K. Kwabata, H. Yamashita and T. Maekawa, J. Ceram. Soc. Jpn. Int. Ed., 1993, 101,490.
30 20.
A. Van Blaaderen, J. Van Geest and A. Vrij, J. Gel. Interface Sci., 1992, 154, 481.
21.
A. Van Blaaderen and A.P.M. Kentgens, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., 1992, 149, 161.
22.
R. ZaUen, 'The Physics of Amorphous Solids', John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1983.
23.
D. Stauffer, A. Coniglio and M. Adam, Advances in Polymer Science, 1982, 44, 103.
24.
G. Dessacles, I. Biay, F. Kolenda, J.F. Quinson and J.P. Reymond, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 1992, 147&148, 141.
25.
R. Deshpande, D.V. Hua, D.M. Smith and C.J. Brinker, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 1992, 144, 32.
26.
G.W. Scherer, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 1992, 147, 363.
27.
J.D. MacKenzie, in 'Ultrastructure Processing of Glasses, Ceramics and Composites', L.L. Hench and D.R. Ulrich eds., John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1984, 15.
28.
R.M. Smith, Gas and Liquid Chromatography in Analytical Chemistry, J. Wiley & Sons, 1988.
29.
W.W. Yau, J.J. Kirkland and D.D. Bly, Modem size-exclusion liquid chromatography. Practice of gel permeation and gel filtration chromatography., J. Wiley, Chichester, 1979.
30.
W. Bannasch and H.H. Stamm, AEC Accession No. 15760, Rep. No. KFK-233, Avail AEC, 54 pp, 1964.
31.
V. Markova and F. Vydra, Chem. Listy, 1966, 60, 860.
32.
E.P. Pleuddemann, Silane Coupling Agents, Plenum Press, New York, 1991.
33.
H. Ferch, R. Oelm/iller and B. Grinschgl, Technical Bull. Pigments, Degussa, 1993, 31.
34.
H. Fratzsceh, Schriftenreihe Pigmente, Degussa, 1983, 23.
31
Chapter 2
Physical characterization of the silica surface
The three parameters specific surface area (m2/g), pore size distribution (f~(rp) and fA(rp)-distributions based on pore volume and pore area respectively) and particle size are sufficient to fully characterize the physical properties of the silica matrix. The exact knowledge of the specific surface area of a silica gel, treated at a given temperature, is essential to express the concentration of the reactive surface species in (#/nm2). This unit is in many cases superior to the more conventional (mmol/g), since it gives a microscopical image of the surface loading, and since it is directly related to effects such as sterical hindrance. The pore size distribution gives a deeper insight in the availability of the reactive surface silanols towards the reacting molecules. It also explains the sorption characteristics of the silica. In fact, pore size and surface area are established by an underlying parameter: the particle size of the (secondary) particles. Direct measurement of particle sizes yields information on surface area and porosity and vice versa.
32 1 The isotherm
In sorption, the amount of gas adsorbed, X,, on a given adsorbent is measured as a function of the equilibrium partial pressure, p, of the adsorbate at constant temperature. The equilibrium partial pressure is preferably related to Po, the saturation vapour pressure of the adsorbate. Measurements are made at temperatures at which the gas at atmospheric pressure is in the liquid state. For nitrogen, this is 77 K. The sorption isotherms can be grouped into five types, according to the classification of Brunauer, Emmet and Teller. ~a'3'4 However, we prefer a classification, based on the pore size of the adsorbent. 5 The IUPAC classification 6 of pores is given in table 2.1.
Table 2.1 IUPAC classification of pores Micropores Mesopores Macropores Megapores
Pore-diameter: Pore-diameter: Pore-diameter: Pore-diameter:
0- 2 2 - 50 50 - 7500 > 7500
nm nm nm nm
Figure 2.1 shows three nitrogen adsorption isotherms that were obtained on a purely microporous, a purely mesoporous and a purely macroporous silica sample. There are distinct differences in the shapes of these isotherms. Their different slopes can be interpreted by means of three mechanisms that may occur during the adsorption and desorption runs. On a purely microporous silica, a Langmuir 7,g type isotherm is observed. This is the type I isotherm, according to the BDDT classification. 2 Starting at relatively low pressure, a sharp increase in adsorption is observed, which is due to the gradual filling of the micropores with adsorbate. Adsorption proceeds until all pores are filled, which is indicated by a fiat region, reflecting a constant adsorption. The adsorption and desorption branches are identical, so no hysteresis is observed. On the purely mesoporous silica, a multilayer of adsorbate is formed, with increasing relative pressures. Depending on the mean pore diameter, but generally above P/P0 = 0.4, capillary condensation takes place, resulting in a further increase of X~. The
33
Xa (g/g)
1.2
_
9
0.80.60.40
0
0.2
0.4
P/P0
0.6
0.8
1
Figure 2.1 Nitrogen sorption isotherms at 77 K for a purely microporous (+), mesoporous (m) and macroporous (o) silica.
horizontal branch near the saturation pressure (P/P0 = 1) indicates that all mesopores are filled with liquid adsorbate. The desorption branch does not follow the adsorption branch, but gives a distinct hysteresis loop" the amount adsorbed is always greater along the desorption branch compared to the adsorption branch. This typical pattern for mesoporous solids is explained by capillary condensation of the adsorbate in the pores, causing an increase of adsorbate during the adsorption run, and a consequent retardation during the desorption. This is a type IV isotherm in the BDDT classification. On the purely macroporous substrate, multilayer formation takes place in the adsorption run, whereas capillary condensation only occurs at relative pressures near unity. The desorption follows the adsorption branch (type II isotherm in the BET classification).
34 Figure 2.2 shows the nitrogen isotherm for a mesoporous silicagel (Kieselgel 60, Merck) thermally treated at 973 K. In fact, in the remainder of this book, we will often refer to this specific silica, since it was used as the starting material in many of our studies. This isotherm is typically a mesoporous isotherm, according to the classification of Unger, or a type IV isotherm, according to the BET classification. The three main areas - formation of monolayer, multilayer, and capillary condensation- are indicated in the figure.
ml/g (at STP)
600
MULTILAYER
CAPILLARY CONDENSATION
500 400 300 200 100 0
0
0.2
0.4
1
1
0.6
0.8
1
P]Po Figure 2.2 Nitrogen sorption isotherm (77 K) on Kieselgel 60, treated at 973 K for 17 h.
2 Determination of the specific surface area
The most widespread method in determining the specific surface area of solid substrates is without doubt the Brunauer-Emmet-Teller (BET) method. 3 It is based on a kinetic model of the adsorption process by Langmuir, 7 in which the surface of the solid was regarded as an array of adsorption sites. A state of dynamic equilibrium
35 was postulated, in which the rate of molecules arriving from the gas phase and condensing onto the bare sites (00) is equal to the rate at which molecules evaporate from occupied sites (00. When extended to a two-layer adsorption, the Langmuir mechanism requires that the rate of condensation from the gas phase on molecules, already adsorbed in the first layer, equals the rate of evaporation from the second layer. For multilayer adsorption, the model implies that at any pressure, the fractions of the surface covered with 1,2,...,i molecules will be 0~, 02, ..., 0~ respectively, so that the thickness of the adsorbed layer will not be constant throughout. Since this model was far too complex to serve any practical purpose, Brunauer, Emmet and Teller made some simplifying assumptions (the main one being that in all layers the evaporation-condensation mechanisms are identical) to derive their famous BET equation, to be used in the multilayer-adsorption region of the adsorption isotherm:
P v,,(Po-P)
-
1 v,..c
+
(c-1)P Vm.C.Po
(1)
where v, is the number of moles adsorbed per gram adsorbent at gas pressure P, Vm is the monolayer capacity of the surface (the number of moles of gas per gram of adsorbent, required to form a monolayer), P0 is the saturation pressure and C is the BET constant, which is a function of the heat of adsorption. Mathematical treatment of the adsorption points in the P/Po region 0.05-0.35 with the BET equation, yields the two unknowns C and Vm. Using the monolayer capacity, the specific surface area (SB~v) can be easily calculated, according to
SBrr = vm.am.Na.lO-2O
(m2[g)
(2)
36 with NA the Avogadro number (6.02"1023 molecules/mol) and am the molecular crosssectional area of the gas molecule. This value is commonly assumed to be about 0.162 nm 2 for nitrogen on an oxide surface. 9'1~ In spite of some grounded criticisms 11'12'13'14'15'16(the BET model assumes energetically identical adsorption sites, neglects lateral interactions and assumes identical behaviour in all layers of the multilayer adsorption), and the proposal of alternative models, 17'1s'19'2~the BET equation has retained its utility. It is a relatively easy approach and the method is applicable to a great variety of adsorption isotherms. Figure 2.3 shows the surface area (SBEv) of Kieselgel 40, 60 and 100 as a function of the pretreatment temperature. These numbers (40, 60 and 100) refer to the mean pore diameter, as will be discussed further in the text. It can be seen from figure 2.3 that the surface area is constant up to temperatures of 873-973 K, after which the surface area collapses. The decrease in surface area is influenced by the pore size of the sample. 700 600
BET --
surface area (m2/g) "
500 400
+
300 200 100 0
273
373
473
573 673 773 Temperature (K)
873
973
1073
Figure 2.3 Specific surface area (SBer)of Kieselgel 40 (m), 60 (+) and 100 (*) as a function of the temperature.
37
In the temperature range 473-673 K, mainly vicinal hydroxyl groups condense at the surface, forming strained siloxane bridges. This process does not influence the pore structure parameters. Above 873 K, interparticle condensation of free hydroxyl groups occurs, which is combined with a rearrangement of silica globules to produce a more stable configuration. Obviously, this interparticle condensation is highly favoured by smaller pores, resulting in a faster collapse of the pore structure. At temperatures higher than 1473 K, non-porous products are obtained.
3 Pore size characterization
3.1 Average pore diameter
Assuming that the external surface of a porous substrate is negligible, and that the pores are cylindrically shaped, the average pore diameter of a substrate can be calculated by the Wheeler formula: 21
rp _ 2"103 lip
(3)
SBET
Pore diameter and pore radius are expressed in nm. Vp is the volume (ml/g) of liquid adsorbate, and can be calculated from the volume of adsorbed g_~ (V~) by means of the Gurvitsch rule 22 Vp = 1,54.10-3 . Va
(4)
The average pore radii of Kieselgel 40, 60 and 100, degassed for 17 h at room temperature were 2.14, 3.59 and 6.22 nm respectively.
38 3.2 Pore sizedistributions
3.2.1 Mesoporous silicas Most models to calculate the pore size distributions of mesoporous solids, are based on the Kelvin equation, based on Thomson's 23 (later Lord Kelvin) thermodynamical statement that 'the equilibrium vapour pressure (p), over a concave meniscus of liquid, must be less than the saturation vapour pressure (P0) at the same temperature'. This implies that a vapour will be able to condense to a liquid in the pore of a solid, even when the relative pressure is less than unity. This process is commonly called the capillary condensation. The mathematical formulation correlates the core radius of the liquid adsorbate (r0 to the relative pressure"
trip
_ -2~,V~cos(O)._l
Po
0
=
Vl
--
l'k
=
RT
(5)
rt
surface tension of liquid nitrogen at 77 K (8.85"10 .3 N/m) contact angle; assumed to be 0 molar volume of liquid nitrogen at 77 K (34.65"10 .3 l/mol) Kelvin radius (nm)
Thus, for liquid nitrogen at 77 K, this equation reduces to" ~
_=
0.415
log P---. Po
(6)
Unfortunately, the Kelvin radius (r0 does not equal the actual pore radius (rp), one would like to measure. This is due to the fact that multilayer adsorption occurs, prior to the capillary condensation, resulting in a pore narrowing. Therefore, if t is the thickness of the adsorbed layer, then rp equals
39
r p = r , +t
Numerous scientist have calculated t-values as a function of
(7)
p / p 0 .24'25'26'27
A
general
accepted formulation is the Halsey equation: 2g
(8)
X
m
=
n
-"
Halsey exponent (1/3 for N 2 at 77 K) monolayer thickness (0.354 nm for N 2 at 77 K) Halsey constant (-5.0 for N 2 at 77 K)
Based on the above general principles, quite a number of models have been developed to estimate pore size distributions. 29'3~ They are based on different pore models (cylindrical, ink bottle, packed sphere, ...). Even the so-called 'modelless' calculation methods do need a pore model in the end to convert the results into an actual pore size distribution. Very often, the exact pore shape is not known, or the pores are very irregular, which makes the choice of the model rather arbitrary. The model of Barett, Joyner and Halenda 34 (BJH model) is based on calculation methods for cylindrical pores. The method uses the desorption branch of the isotherm. The desorbed amount of gas is due either to the evaporation of the liquid core, or to the desorption of a multilayer. Both phenomena are related to the relative pressure, by means of the Kelvin and the Halsey equation. The exact computer algorithms 35 are not discussed here. The calculations are rather tedious, but straightforward. Figures 2.4 and 2.5 present the pore size distributions of the three silicas under study, based on the pore volume (fv(rp)) and on the pore area (fA(rp)) respectively. It is obvious from these figures that the pore size distributions of Kieselgel 40 and 60 are centered reasonably well around the average (Wheeler) pore diameter.
40
Pore volume (ml/g)
0.14
1
0.12
3
0.I0
0.08 0.06 0.040.02 0
0
5
10 15 Average pore diameter (rim)
20
Figure 2.4 Pore size distribution (RIH-method), based on pore volume of KG 60 (1), KG 40 (2) and KG 100 (3), degassed at 373 K.
140
Pore area (m2/g)
120 100 8O 604020 0
0
5
10 Average pore diameter (rim)
15
20
Figure 2.5 Pore size distribution (BJH-method), based on pore-area of KG 60 (1), KG 40 (2) and KG 100 (3), degassed at 373 K.
41
The pore size distribution of Kieselgel 100 is also centered around the Wheeler pore diameter, but the distribution is very broad, indicating that extreme caution is needed when interpreting average pore diameters. This latter value has only a statistical relevance, and is by no means a reflection of the actual pore size. Both the BET model and pore size distribution models have a rather low degree of accuracy. A divergence of at least 10% from the actual area is not exceptional. 36 A way of checking the validity of the different models consists in comparing the cumulative pore area, as calculated by the BJH model, with the BET surface. Some results are presented in table 2.2. Table 2.2 Comparison of BET-surface area with BJH cumulative pore area
Sample
KG KG KG
SBET (m2/g) 40 60 100
582 403 313
cum. pore area (m2/g) 564 466 433
% deviation
3 16 38
It is obvious that the deviation between the two models becomes larger with an increasing broadness of the pore size distribution. The results only agree very well for the fairly narrow pore size distribution of Kieselgel 40. However, for the broad KG100 distribution, the BJH model overestimates the surface area by almost 40%. Repeated measurement on independently prepared samples clearly demonstrated that this overestimation was an artifact of the model, and was not caused by (erroneous) sample preparation.
3.2.2 Microporous silicas Models to evaluate the microporous volume exist for several decades. They do not yield a micropore size distribution, but simply quantify the pore volume of all pores with a diameter < 2 nm.
42 Typical methods for testing microporosity consist in the comparison of a standard isotherm (mostly an isotherm of a non-(micro)porous sample of identical chemical composition), with the isotherm under study. t-plot A convenient method is provided by the t-plot of Lippens and De Boer. 37 It consists of plotting the volume of gas adsorbed vs t, the statistical thickness of the adsorbed film. t is a function of P/Po, as measured in the standard isotherm, according to the Halsey equation or one of its modifications. 3s'39'4~ In any normal case of multimolecular adsorption, the experimental points (t vs. P/P0) should fall on a straight line through the origin. If the adsorbent contains micropores, the uptake is enhanced in the low pressure region and the isotherm is correspondingly distorted. In the t-plot, extrapolation of the curve gives a positive intercept which is equivalent to the micropore volume by means of the Gurvitsch rule. When mesopores are present, capillary condensation will occur according to the Kelvin equation. A t-plot will therefore show an upward deviation, starting at the relative pressure at which the finest pores are just being filled. Figure 2.6 schematically illustrates the effects of micro- and mesoporosity on a t-plot.
~,-plot
The t-curve was originally developed to evaluate the thickness of the adsorbed layer on the walls of the pores of mesoporous solids. However, for the purpose of testing for conformity to the standard isotherm, a knowledge of the numerical thickness is irrelevant. Sing 42 has pointed out that it is sufficient to use as a normalizing factor, the amount adsorbed at some fixed relative pressure, in practice taken as (p/po)~= 0.4. The
43
ml/g 400 350 mesopores 300 250 200 150 100 ....... ~ I micro~pore volume
50 /,"
0
I
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
I
1.0
I
1.2
1.4
De Boer statistical thickness (rim) Figure 2.6 Effects of micro- and mesoporosity on a t-plot.
normalized adsorption n / n o . 4 - - Ors, obtained from the isotherm on a reference sample of the solid, is then plotted against P/Po, to obtain a standard c~ccurve, rather than a t-curve. The as-CUrve can then be used to construct an ctcplot from the isotherm of a test sample of the solid, just as the t-curve can be used to produce a t-plot. If a straight line through the origin results, one may infer that the isotherm under test is identical in shape with the standard. A particular advantage of the ors-method is that its applicability is not restricted to nitrogen. 42 It offers a simple but effective means of testing for the identity in shape of the isotherms of any suitable adsorptive on a given set of samples of the same substance. In view of the widespread use of nitrogen and argon in surface area and porosity studies, data for the construction of the standard cry-curves for these adsorbates on hydroxylated silica are given in tables 2.3 and 2.4.
44 Table 2.3 Standard data for the adsorption of argon at 77 K on nonporous hydroxylated silica 43 Relative pressure p/po
~, ( =n/no 4)
Relative pressure P/Po
(=n/no.a)
0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.10 0.11 0.12 0.13 0.14 0.15 0.16 0.17 0.18 0.19 0.20 0.22 0.24 0.25 0.26 0.28
0.243 0.324 0.373 0.413 0.450 0.483 0.514 0.541 0.563 0.583 0.602 0.620 0.638 0.657 0.674 0.689 0.705 0.719 0.733 0.748 0.773 0.801 0.813 0.826 0.851
0.30 0.32 0.34 0.36 0.38 0.40 0.42 0.44 0.46 0.48 0.50 0.52 0.54 0.56 0.58 0.60 0.62 0.64 0.66 0.68 0.70 0.72 0.74 0.76 0.78
0.876 0.900 0.923 0.948 0.973 1.000 1.022 1.048 1.064 1.098 1.123 1.148 1.172 1.198 1.225 1.250 1.275 1.300 1.327 1.354 1.387 1.418 1.451 1.486 1.527
45
Table 2.4 Standard data for the adsorption of nitrogen at 77 K on nonporous hydroxylated silica *~'~s Relative P/Po 0.001 0.005 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.20 0.22 0.24 0.26 0.28 0.30 0.32 0.34 0.36 0.38 0.40 0.42 0.44 0.46 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90
Adsorption per unit area mol m2 4.0 5.4 6.2 7.7 8.5 9.0 9.3 9.4 9.7 10.0 10.2 10.5 10.8 11.3 11.6 11.9 12.4 12.7 13.0 13.3 13.6 13.9 14.2 14.5 14.8 15.1 15.5 15.6 16.1 16.4 17.0 17.8 18.9 19.9 21.3 22.7 25.0 28.0 37.0
as (=n/no.4) 0.26 0.35 0.40 0.50 0.55 0.58 0.60 0.61 0.63 0.65 0.66 0.68 0.70 0.73 0.75 0.77 0.80 0.82 0.84 0.86 0.88 0.90 0.92 0.94 0.96 0.98 1.00 1.01 1.04 1.06 1.10 1.14 1.22 1.29 1.38 1.47 1.62 1.81 2.40
46
Other -more complicated- models to evaluate the microporous volume exist.
The
Dubinin-Radushkevich model 46'47'48,49 is based on thermodynamical considerations
concerning the process of micropore filling. Full discussion of this model is beyond the scope of this book. The reader is referred to the standard work of Gregg and Sing5~ on adsorption for a detailed treatment.
Micropore size distributions Many technologically important solids (including silica) have a micropore structure that is well below the lower limit of pore size at which the Kelvin equation (equation 5) is applicable. The basis for the Kelvin equation is a thermomechanical equilibrium across the hemispherical meniscus of a capillary condensate within a cylindrical pore. Below a pore size of 2 nm diameter, the liquid cannot be considered as a fluid with bulk properties because of the forces exerted by the wall. Theoretical calculations suggest that the properties of fluids in microporous structures are highly dependent on the size of the pore. Useful information about micropore structures can be derived from nitrogen or argon isotherm data in terms of the C-constant (BET), t or a:plots and the DubininRadushkevich models. Yet these models do not provide a straightforward relation between the logarithm of relative pressure and the pore size, as does the Kelvin equation. Everett and Pow151 (1976) have developed a pore size distribution model for the slit shaped pores of ultramicroporous carbons. This model has been further elaborated by Horvath and Kawazoe. 52 Because of the conceptual and mathematical simplicity of these models, they have been used recently to describe adsorption in zeolite and clay structures, 53'54'55'56 based on either a cylindrical pore model or a packed sphere model. These models provide an easy analysis of the microporous structure in terms of the argon adsorption isotherm.
47
The slit model Adsorption in ultramicroporous carbon was treated in terms of a slit-potential model by Everett and PowP ~ and was later extended by Horvath and Kawazoe. 52 They assumed a slab geometry with the slit walls comprised of two infinite graphitic planes. Adsorption occurs on the two parallel planes, as shown in figure 2.7.
A
dE
A :: d
dA
v
O
do
(~
A: Adsorbatc
E: Adsorbent
Figure 2. 7 Slit-shape pore model (Horvath and Kawazoe).
The potential energy of interaction, e, for one adsorbate molecule at a distance z from an atom in the surface layer can be expressed as
c (z) -- K c*
-
+
(9)
48
where E* is the potential energy minimum m
r = (--n--n)c-n) c'-') ?l-Dl
(10)
/71
and
1
o = (m__)(,-m) do
(11)
n
The parameters n and m are the order of the dispersion and repulsion terms in equation 9, respectively, and do is taken as the arithmetic mean of the diameters of the adsorbent atoms in the wall,
de,
and the adsorbate atoms,
dA, as
shown in figure 2.7.
With n = 10 and m = 4, K = 3.07 and tr = 0.858 do. If the distance between the nuclei of the two parallel layers is L, then the potential function of one adsorbate molecule between the two layers is"
()lO (,o),
c(z) -Ke*
(12)
In the case of the pore filled with adsorbate molecules one must account for adsorbateadsorbent, and adsorbate-adsorbate-adsorbent interactions. Walker 57 expressed the potential energy minimum, : , corresponding to these two respective interactions in terms of two dispersion constants, AE.A, and AA-A, as well as the number density of adsorbate and adsorbent atoms per unit area. This potential minimum takes the form: -
(13)
10
do4
49 where the dispersion constants can be expressed according to the Kirkwood-Miiller formalism as"
AF_A --
AA-A= with
M
c--
6Mc 2t~eaa
(14)
3Mc20~aXa
(15)
mass of an electron (kg) speed of light (m/s)
polarizability (cm3)
X=
magnetic susceptibility
(cm 3)
Using equation 11 to reexpress do in terms of a and by replacing E" in equation 12 by the expression in equation 13, one obtains:
r
-
+
NA a~_A + Ne ae_a 204
+( 0 )IO
(Z)4 (Z) 10 (~-Z)' ~'~-Z)] -
(16) .
If the free energy of adsorption is taken as equal to the net energy of interaction between the layers, then the energy balance yields"
50
f R r In
P
(17)
-~ N . ~ (L - do) - do
With substitution of equation 16 into equation 17 and integration this yields the Horvarth and Kavazoe result for slitlike geometry: RT
•(To) P
04
3 (L-do) 3
NA aA_~ + N~ a~_A
= Nay __
o 4 (L-2do) 1210
9(L-do) 9
__
124
3d3o
(18) +
1210 ]
9dgoJ
This has Kelvin-like simplicity in that it relates the relative pressure, P/Po, to the relevant pore size, L, in terms of the physical properties of the adsorbate-adsorbent couple.
Cylindrical model
To test the geometric sensitivity of the calculated pore size for a cylindrical model, a cylindrical potential was utilized along with the following assumptions: ~
2.
@
Q
The pore is a perfect cylinder of infinite length but finite radius, rp. The inside wall of the cylinder is a single layer of atoms, which is taken as a continuum of potential interaction. The interaction with the pore wall is taken to be due only to the dispersion forces. Adsorption occurs only on the inside wall of a cylinder in the micropore region. The interaction of adsorption is taken to be due only to that between the adsorbate and the adsorbent, with the latter considered to be the oxide ion of the zeolite.
51
Based on these assumptions, the potential energy for the cylindrical pore displayed in figure 2.8 is a function of r, the distance from the central axis. A general expression for a cylindrical potential was provided by Everett and Powl. 5~
5 r
r (r) = ~ ~
6 ttk, [-21~ (trp) -d ~ 1 7k--o ~
-
tr,)
~
--
[3k
(19)
where the constants Ctk and ~k are given by:
o.,
tg k
=
13o.5 =
r (-4.5) r(-4.5 - k) r(k+ 1)
(20)
r (-1.5) r (-1.5-k) r (k+l)
(21)
The potential energy minimum, e*, can be expressed in term of equation 13, using the dispersion constants from equations 14 and 15. Once again, if one assumes that the free energy of adsorption is given by the average of the intermolecular potential in the cylindrical pore, then one can take either a line average or an area average. In the latter, one can envision the molecules as having two degrees of freedom to move across the pore, while in the former they may have only one degree of freedom, along the diameter of the pore. This could correspond to the physically real case in which a portion of the pore is blocked by foreign atoms such as carbon.
For the line-average case, the potential for the cylindrical model becomes: rp-d o
f e(r) dr 0
ELl
=
r,-do
(22)
52
Ido
P
O
E: Adsorbent
O
A: Adsorbatr
Figure 2.8 Cylindrical pore model.
and the model equation that results is:
In(
RT
)-4
d4o
1 (1_ do)2~ (-~ 21 IXk ( d~ x E** [2k+1 k--o
r.
r.
(23) - [3k (d~ r.
For the case of the area-average cylindrical potential"
ELA =
f
e (r) 2~ rdr
o
(24)
r,-d,
f o
2~ rdr
53 and the model equation that results is" In(
RT
)-4
d~ (25)
x ~
,=o
~
1
rp )
"t
--
~ rp )
Pt ~ rp ) j
The Horvath-Kawazoe pore size model (or one of its modifications) has become recently available as a fully implemented software package.
3.2.3 Macroporous silicas Mercury porosimetry is generally regarded as the best method available for the routine determination of pore sizes in the macropore and upper mesopore range. The idea of using mercury intrusion to measure pore size appears to have been first suggested by Washburn, 58 who put forward the basic equation (the Washburn equation): rp = _ 2ycos0 Ap
with 3,
=
0
=
(26)
the radius of a cylindrical pore surface tension of Hg (484 mN/m = dyne/cm) contact angle between mercury and the wall, assumed to be 130 ~ or 140" depending on the source. 42
The principles of mercury porosimetry are further illustrated in figure 2.9. The technique of mercury porosimetry consists essentially of measuring the extent of mercury penetration into an evaluated solid as a function of the applied hydrostatic pressure. The full scope of the method first became apparent in 1945 when Ritter and Drake 59 developed a technique for making measurements at high pressures. The method has enjoyed increasing popularity with the passing of years, and automatic porosimeters are now in use for the routine examination of the pore structure of
54
catalysts, cements and other porous materials. The range of such porosimeters extends from r p --- 3.5 nm (corresponding to the usual maximum pressure - 2000 bar) to r p - 7 . 5 / ~ m , the size of pores penetrated at atmospheric pressure. One problem is that if the silica gel is not very strong, the structure collapses by the external pressure of mercury before pores are penetrated. It is for this reason that the nitrogen adsorption isotherm method is preferred for research purposes. Nevertheless, for strong bodies like industrial catalyst gels, the mercury penetration method is far more rapid not only in execution, but also in converting results to pore size distribution curves.
ii i ii!iiiiiiiii Sig:::i~ii~i~:t':~!i::::%
~,:5:% ,:: .. :::, ~;%~..:::::::::::::::::::::
~ rP
Figure 2.9 Mercury penetrating a cylindrical pore; taken from ref (1) with permission.
55
3.3 Modelling theories In the late 1980's and the early 1990's, two modelling theories have been successfully used in the modelling of irregular surfaces: fractal analysis and molecular dynamics theories. The physical idea of fractal analysis is that the general morphology of surface irregularities is independent of the magnification at which the surface is observed. Increasing the magnification reveals an increase in the number of irregularities that are morphologically similar to that observed on the larger scale. Although several researchers have used fractal analysis successfully on many different surfaces, 6~ Drake and coworkers 64 concluded that silica (gel) surfaces cannot be characterized by a fractal surface, but should be viewed as aggregates of elementary building blocks whose sizes are in the order of the mean pore radius. The formalism of nonlocal functional density theory provides an attractive way to describe the physical adsorption process at the fluid - solid interface. 65 In particular, the ability to model adsorption in a pore of slit - like or cylindrical geometry has led to useful methods for extracting pore size distribution information from experimental adsorption isotherms. At the moment the model has only been tested for microporous carbons and slit - shaped materials. 66'67 It is expected that the model will soon be implemented for silica surfaces. References
S.J. Gregg and K.S.W. Sing, Adsorption, Surface Area and Porosity, Academic Press, London, 1967. ,
,
,
,
0
S. Brunauer, L.S. Deming, W.S. Deming and E. Teller, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1940, 62, 1723. S. Brunauer, P.H. Emmet and E. Teller, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1938, 60, 309. S. Brunauer, The adsorption of gases and vapours, Oxford University Press, 1945. K.K. Unger, Porous Silica, its properties and use as support in column liquid chromatography, Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam, 1979, p.19. IUPAC Manual of Symbols and Terminology, Appendix 2, Pt. 1, Colloid and Surface Chemistry, Pure and Applied Chemistry, 1972, 31,578.
56
0
0
0
I. Langmuir, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1916, 38, 2221. I. l.angmuir, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1918, 40, 1361. A.L. McClellan and H.F. Harnsberger, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1967, 23, 577.
10.
I.M.K. Ismail, Carbon, 1990, 28, 423.
11.
T.L. Hill, J. Chem. Phys., 1946, 14, 263.
12.
W.A. Steele, The interaction of gases with solid surfaces, Pergamom Press, Oxford, 1974.
13.
G.D. Halsey, J. Chem. Phys. , 1948, 16, 931.
14.
M.A. Cook, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1948, 70, 2925.
15.
M.A. Barrer, N. Mackenzie and D. McLexxt, J. Chem. Soc., 1952, 1736.
16.
D.M. Young and A.D. Crowell, Physical adsorption of gases, Butterworths, London, 1962.
17.
P.J.M. Carrott, R.A. Roberts and K.S.W. Sing, Langmuir, 1988, 4, 740.
18.
F. Rodriguez-Reinoso, J.M. Martin-Martinez, C. Prado-Burguete and B. McEnaney, J. Phys. Chem., 1987, 91,515.
19.
S. Partyka, F. Rouquerol and J. Rouquerol, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1979, 68, 21.
20.
B. Rand, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1976, 56, 337.
21.
A. Wheeler, Adv. Cat., 1951, 3, 250.
22.
L. Gurvitsch, J. Phys. Chem. Soc. Russ., 1915, 47, 805.
23.
W.T. Thomson, Phil. Mag, 1971, 42, 448.
24.
B.C. Lippens, B.G. Linsen and J.H. De Boer, J. Catal., 1964, 3, 32.
25.
J.H. De Boer, B.G. Linsen and T.J. Osind, J. Catal., 1965, 4, 643.
26.
C. Pierce, J. Phys. Chem., 1968, 72, 3673.
27.
M.R. Bhambhani, P.A. Cutting, K.S.W. Sing and D.H. Turk, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1972, 38, 109.
28.
G. Halsey, J. Chem. Phys., 1948, 16, 931.
29.
A.G. Foster, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1932, 28, 645.
57
30.
C. Pierce, J. Phys. Chem., 1953, 57, 149.
31.
C.G. Shull, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1948, 7t), 1410.
32.
B.F. Roberts, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1967, 23, 266.
33.
S. Brunauer, R. Sh. Mikhail and E.E. Bodor, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1967, 24, 451.
34.
E.P. Barrett, L.G. Joyner and P.H. Halenda, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1951, 73, 373.
35.
Micromeritics, Instruction Manual, 1985.
36.
D.H. Everett, G.D. Parfitt, K.S.W. Sing and R. Wilson, J. Appl. Chem. Biotechnol., 1974, 24, 199.
37.
B.C. Lippens and J.H. De Boer, J. Catal., 1965, 4, 319.
38.
B.S. Girgis, J. Appl. Chem. Biotechnol., 1973, 23, 19.
39.
J.H. De Boer, B.G. Linsen, J.C.P. Broekhoff and Th.G. Osinga, J. Catal., 1968, 11, 46.
40.
M. Ternan, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1973, 45, 270.
41.
S. Brunauer, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1972, 39, 435.
42.
K.S.W. Sing, in 'Surface Area Determination', Proc. Int. Symp., 1969, eds. D.H. Everett and R.H. Ottewill, Butterworths, London, 1970.
43.
D.A. Payne, K.S.W. Sing and D.H. Turk, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1973, 43, 287.
44.
J.D. Carrutheus, P.A. Cutting, R.E. Day, M.R. Harris, S.A. Mitchell and K.S.W. Sing, Chem. and Ind., 1968, 1772
45.
M.R. Bhambhani, P.A. Cutting, K.S.W. Sing and D.H. Turk, Chem. and Ind., 1969, 918.
46.
M.M. Dubinin and E.D. Zaverina, Zhur. Fiz. Khim., 1949, 23, 1129.
47.
M.M. Dubinin, Quart. Rev. Chem. Soc., 1955, 9, 101.
48.
M.M. Dubinin and L.V. Radushkevich, Proc. Acad. Sci., USSR, 1947, 55, 331.
49.
M.M. Dubinin, Russ. J. Phys. Chem., 1965, 39, 697.
50.
S.J. Gregg and K.S.W. Sing, 'Adsorption, Surface Area and Porosity', Academic Press, London, 1982.
58 51.
D.H. Everett and J.C. Powl, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1976, 72, 619.
52.
G. Horvath and K. Kawazoe, J. Chem. Eng. Japan, 1983, 16, 470.
53.
M.E. Davis, C. Saldarriago, C. Montes, J. Garc6s and C. Crowder, Zeolites, 1988, $, 362.
54.
M.E. Davis, C. Montes, P.E. Hathaway, J.P. Arhancet, D.L. Hasha and J.E. Garc6s, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1980, 111, 3919.
55.
A.F. Venero and J.N. Chiou, M.R.S. Symp. Proc., 1988, 111,235.
56.
M.S.A. Baksh and R.T. Yang, Am. Inst. of Chem. Eng., 1991, 37, 923.
57.
P.L. Walker, Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, 2, Dekker, New York, 1966.
58.
E.W. Washburn, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., USA, 1921, 7, 115.
59.
H.L. Ritter and L.C. Drake, Ind. Eng. Chem. Analyt. Ed., 1945, 17, 782.
60.
D. Avnir, D. Pfeifer, Nouveau J. Chim., 1983, 7, 71. (in french)
61.
D. Avnir, D. Farin and P. Pfeifer, Nature, 1984, 308, 261.
62.
D. Farin and D. Avnir, J. Chromatogr., 1987, 406, 347.
63.
D. Avnir and P. Pfeifer, J.Chem. Phys., 1983, 79, 3588.
4.
J. M. Drake, L. M. Yacullo, P. Levitz and J. Klafter, J. Phys. Chem., 1994, 98, 380.
65.
J.P. Olivier, private communication.
66.
C. Lastoskie, K. E. Gubbins and N. Quirke, J. Phys. Chem., 1993, 97, 4786.
67.
P.B. Balbuena and K. E. Gubbins, Langmuir, 1993, 9, 1801.
59
Chapter 3
The surface chemistry of silica
1 Surface species The ultimate particles which make up the silicas can be regarded as polymers of silicic acid, consisting of interlinked
S i O 4 tetrahedra.
At the surface, the structure terminates
in either a siloxane group (=Si-O-Si = ) with the oxygen on the surface, or one of several forms of silanol groups (=-Si-OH). The silanols can be divided into isolated groups (or free silanols), where the surface silicon atom has three bonds into the bulk
structure and the fourth bond attached to a single OH group, and vicinal silanols (or
bridged silanols), where two single silanol groups, attached to different silicon atoms, are close enough to hydrogen bond. A third type of silanols, geminal silanols, consist of two hydroxyl groups, that are attached to one silicon atom. The geminal silanols are too close to hydrogen bond each other, l whereas the free hydroxyl groups are too far separated.
Isolated silanol
Vicinal silanols
H 0/
i
8i
/IX
H 0/
I
8i
/IX
H
\o / l
8i
/IX
Geminal silanols H\.
/ 0
\/ Si /\
O
H
60 There is some discussion in literature, concerning the existence of geminal hydroxyl groups. These groups were first proposed by Peri 2 in 1968. Van Cauwelaert 3 stated that the free hydroxyl stretching vibration (3745 cm ~) consists of 2 different species (isolated and geminal silanols). Two years later, Morrow and Cody 4 questioned the fitting techniques of Van Cauwelaert. Very recently, the same author 5'6 stated in the same journal that the 3745 cm -~ band indeed consists of two species, but it is more reasonably to assign the low wavenumber shoulder to a pair of vicinal isolated silanols, which are sufficiently far apart as not to significantly interact via strong hydrogen bonding'. On the other hand, Hoffmann 7 studied the same IR-vibration, using high resolution FTIR (0.1 cm l) and concluded that the low wavenumber shoulder should indeed be attributed to geminal silanols. The same confusion can be found in studies using NMR spectroscopy. Whereas 29SiNMR spectra show a distinct band at-92 ppm, attributed to Si-atoms, carrying a geminal hydroxyl group, s 1H-NMR seems not to be able to distinguish between isolated and geminal silanols. 9 Even in studies, modelling the silica surface on a theoretical basis, no consensus can be found concerning the existence of geminal hydroxyl groups. The early theoretical study of Peri and Hensley, 2 performing a Monte Carlo analysis on the idealized 111 and 100 faces of cristobalite concluded that 85 % to 95 % of all surface silanols are paired (geminal), whereas the earlier study of De Boer and Vleeskens 1~ modelled the 0001 face of/3-cristobalite to conclude that no geminal hydroxyls are present at all. Although in a less polarized way (it is now agreed that -if geminols exist- their relative contribution to the total silanol number is relatively small), this ambiguity exists until today. The group of Ogenko l~ states that geminal silanols do not exist and that the shift in the infrared 3745 cm -1 vibration and the occurrence of the -92 ppm 29Si-NMR peak can be explained by changes in the coordination of the surface Si atoms and electronical interactions between silanols. Smirnov 12 on the other hand used the theory of molecular dynamics to prove that the 3745 cm l band is a superposition of 2 species.
61 The isolated silanols absorb at 3747 cm-~,and the geminal silanols absorb at 3736 cm ~. These peak maxima are temperature dependent. Figure 3.1 shows the 29Si CP MAS NMR spectrum of silica gel (Kieselgel 60), thermally treated at 973 K for 17 h. The spectrum indeed shows a tiny shoulder at 92 ppm, attributable to silicon atoms, carrying geminal silanols. The -100 ppm band is attributed to silicon atoms carrying single hydroxyl groups, being either isolated or vicinal silanols. It can be concluded from this figure that the geminol concentration is less than 5 % of the total silanol concentration. Hair and Hertl ~3 concluded that the freely vibrating hydroxyl groups are mono-energetic. So, if geminols do exist on a dried silica surface, no particular preference is shown in the respective reactivity.
, , , !
. . . .
-6t~
,
. . . .
t
. . . .
-86
,
. . . .
!
. . . .
-lOD ppm
,. . . . . .
I _ . . . . ,
-126
. . . .
I
. . . .
,
-InB
Figure 3.1 29Si CP MAS NMR spectrum of Kieselgel 60, treated at 973 K for 17 h.
In almost all kinds of amorphous silicas, there are silanol groups, not only on the surface, but throughout the particle structure. Such silanols, which are inaccessible to water are said to be internal (intraglobular). However, there is no clear-cut distinction between internal and surface silanols. The accessibility to water is not by itself a completely defined criterion, since water diffusion depends on physical conditions as effective temperature and state of aggregation of the powder. ~4
62 Davydov et al. ~5 estimated the concentration of internal hydroxyls for a silica gel to be 0.5 mmol/g, after treatment at 473 K. According to the same authors, temperatures higher than 873 K are required to remove all intraglobular hydroxyls.
2 The hydroxylated surface The surface structure of amorphous silica is highly disordered, so one cannot expect a regular arrangement of hydroxyl groups. Hence the surface of amorphous silica gel may be covered by isolated as well as vicinal hydroxyl groups. Irrespective of whether a surface contains both types or only isolated hydroxyl groups (as in crystalline silica), complete surface coverage can be achieved: the surface is fully hydroxylated. On exposing it to water, it is further able to adsorb water physically by means of hydrogen bonding. In fully hydroxylated non-porous silica species, a multilayer of adsorbed water is build up by increasing the partial pressure. In fully hydroxylated porous silica species, additional capillary condensation takes place on the adsorbed multilayer: on increasing the partial pressure, the pore volume is gradually filled with liquid water (cfr. chapter 2). The uptake of physically adsorbed water is termed hydration.
3 Dehydroxylation and rehydroxylation
3.1 Dehydration and dehydroxylation The terms dehydration and dehydroxylation are often confused in literature, which is not surprising, since it is very difficult to separate the two processes. Dehydration is the loss of physisorbed water as a function of increasing temperature, whereas dehydroxylation stands for the condensation of hydroxylgroups to form siloxane bonds (reaction (A)).
63
=--Si- O \n~
O-H -=Si - o - - H \H
-=Si - O \n
-H20 _
/
/ =Si - 0
DEHYDRATION
iSi ___
\ -=Si
\H
O
(A)
'/
DEHYDROXYLATION
The temperature at which dehydration is completed cannot be determined unambiguously. The porosity, the size and the morphology of the pores largely influence the water desorption. It is now generally agreed that heating at 373 K for a prolonged period, removes all physisorbed water on a non-porous silica. 16'17 A nonmicroporous silica has what is sometimes called an 'open surface', TM leading to approximately the same desorption behaviour as a non-porous silica. However, when microporosity is present, heating up to 473 K is not necessarily adequate to remove all physisorbed water. ~9 Bermudez z~ showed by NMR techniques that drying at 373 K not only removes physisorbed water, but also a dehydroxylation of some silanol groups was observed. Figure 3.2 shows a thermogram of Kieselgel 60. The heating rate was 10 K/min in a 150 ml/min N2 flow. This thermogram clearly shows a sharp DTG (Differential Thermogravimetric Analysis) peak, attributed to the loss of physisorbed water from the pore system. Curve fitting of the DTG profile reveals that the desorption of physisorbed water is complete at 393 K and is followed by a broad region of weight loss, due to dehydroxylation processes. It will be shown in chapter 5 that in the temperature range 473-673 K mainly vicinal hydroxyls condense, whereas in the region above 673 K mainly isolated hydroxyls condense with increasing difficulty. Temperatures > 1473 K are required to remove all silanols. 2~
64
100 Weight (%) 99 98 97 96 95 94 93 92 91 90 273 373
. . . . . . . 473 573 673 773 873 973 1073 1173 Temperature (K)
Figure 3.2 TGA thermogram (Nz-flow, 150 ml/min, heating rate: 10 K/min) of Kieselgel 60. 3.2 Rehydration and rehydroxylation Already in the late 1950's, many authors 2'17'22'23 have pointed out that complete rehydroxylation of the surface can only be achieved for silica samples which were subjected to a thermal treatment below 673 K. After calcination at higher temperatures, only partial rehydroxylation takes place. However, Agzamkhodzhaev and Zhuravlev 2~ showed that the dehydroxylated surface of silicas, treated in the range from 673 K to 1373 K, can be completely rehydroxylated by treatment with water at room temperature. However, they found that the more completely the surface was dehydroxylated, the longer the time required for rehydroxylation. A surface dehydroxylated at 1173 K for 10 h required several years in water at ambient temperature to become fully rehydroxylated. When the same silica sample was hydrothermally treated in boiling water, 60 h sufficed to obtain full rehydroxylation. Caution is necessary however in using hydrothermal treatment, since some silicas tend to undergo drastic changes in structure and reduction in surface area under these conditions.
65
The rehydroxylation process of silica proceeds in two steps. In a first step, water molecules preadsorb on the hydrophilic silanol sites. In a second step, this preadsorbed water causes a bond breaking of a siloxane group, yielding two new silanols. At temperatures below 673 K, every siloxane surface group is surrounded by at least one silanol, allowing a neighbouring preadsorption of a water molecule. On top of that, the proximity of silanol groups weakens the actual Si-O bond strength of the siloxane bridge (d,~-p,~ interaction). So, during the rehydroxylation process, additionally introduced water molecules first become adsorbed on silanol groups and have a direct effect on the neighbouring weakened siloxane groups. This results in the splitting of the groups and the formation of new OH groups on the silica surface. Upon a preliminary activation of the silica above 673 K the concentration of the siloxane bridges increases sharply. The bridges form hydrophobic regions on the surface, while the silanol concentration drops as a function of temperature. These isolated silanols -at a large distance from one another- act as the centres of adsorption. Rehydroxylation takes place first in the vicinity of the silanol groups. The hydroxylated sections that are localized in the shape of small spots gradually expand, z4
4 Infrared study of the silica surface Infrared spectroscopy has been widely applied when studying the silica surface. ~ Figure 3.3 shows typical FTIR (Fourier Transform Infrared) spectra with photoacoustic detection (cfr. appendix A) of Kieselgel 60, treated for 17 h at (a) 373 K; (b) 673 K and (c) 973 K. The Y-scales of the three spectra are not comparable. The region 1950- 1766 cm ~ is attributed to an overtone structure vibration. Its integrated value is used as a reference band to normalize all other integrations, since this band is found unaffected by the different treatments. 25 '26 '27 The assignment of the broad absorption region between 3740 and 3400 cm ~ has caused some discussion in the literature.
66
Intensity (a.u.) (c)
(a)
/ I
/
I
4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 Wavenumber (cm- 1)
I
1500
Figure 3.3 FTIR spectra of Kieselgel 60. Table 3.1 summarizes the best accepted attributions. 7'28,29,3~
Table 3.1 Infrared band assignments (stretching O-H vibrations) Frequency cm-1
Species
3746 3742 3730-3720 3650 3520 3400-3500
free OH geminal OH hydrogen perturbed OH intraglobular OH oxygen perturbed OH molecular adsorbed H20
67
The vibrations at 3730 - 3720 cm ~ and 3520 cm -~ have been assigned recently 35 to the interaction of the oxygen of the hydroxyl group with the hydrogen of a neighbouring hydroxyl group. This vibration can thus be regarded as the O-H stretching vibration of the 'free' silanol in a couple of hydrogen bonded hydroxyl groups, whereas the vibration band at 3520 cm ~ is attributed to the 'bonding' hydroxyl group.
/H~ /H , ?
0
Si
iii Oxygen perturbed
Si
iii Hydrogen perturbed
The term bridged hydroxyl groups actually implies a broad distribution of hydroxyl groups, with various strengths of hydrogen bonding. Bridged hydroxyl groups with strong hydrogen bonding absorb at the low-wavenumber region of the adsorption band, whereas hydroxyls with weak hydrogen bonding absorb at the high-wavenumber region. Nowadays, many other infrared vibrations are being studied, using the fingerprint region of the mid-infrared, as well as the far and near infrared regions. We will restrict ourselves in this work to the assignments, presented in table 3.2.
Table 3.2 Other infrared vibrations of silica 5235 4505 4425 2000-1870 1625 1250-1020 970 870 800 600 148 127
cm -~ cm -~ cm ~ cm ~ cm -~ cm ~ cm ~ cm ~ cm ~ cm -~ cm ~ cm -~
O-H overtone (adsorbed water) 36 O-H overtone (isolated OH) 36 O-H overtone (isolated OH and ads. water) 36 skeleton (overtone) vibrations bending O-H (molecular water) asymmetrical Si-O-Si stretching Si-O-(H...H20) bending bending O-H (silanol) in-plane bending (geminol) ~2 in-plane bending (geminol) ~2 out-of-plane bending (geminol) 7 out-of-plane bending (vicinol) 7
68 Various authors 5'17'35'37'3s'39'4~
have tried to model the dehydroxylation of bridged
hydroxyls as a function of hydrogen bonding strength. However, the obtained results are often inconclusive, if not contradictory. The results can probably best be summarized by Hoffmann's 7 statement that 'the complexity of some spectral intervals in the mid infrared is still beyond the scope of a detailed and unambiguous structural interpretation'. 5
Deuteration
5.1 Deuteration of hydroxylated silica
Deuteration is the exchange of surface silanol hydrogen atoms for deuterium. This process has been used to study the surface and structural properties of silica and their variation upon modification. The isotopic exchange of H for D is highly favoured by the kinetic isotope effect, because the mass of the D atom is double that of the H atom. The exchange proceeds much more readily with heavy water vapour (D20) than if deuterium gas (D2) is used. ~ In the case of D2, no exchange is observed at 298 K, unless the surface is coated with platinum. Complete exchange can only be carded out in a few hours at 973 K. The adsorption of D20 was first studied by Pimentel et al. 44 and has been studied repeatedly since. Full references may be found in the work of Kiselev and Lygin. ~ Using the D20 in the vapour phase gives superior results compared to liquid phase exchange. The exchange reaction follows equation (B).
-- S i - O H + D 2 0 -~ --- S i - O D + H D O
fB)
69
Tertykh 45 proposed following mechanism:
-SiOH + DOD ~
..........D ~ D -Si - 0 .... .. 0 " /
"
~H
...........
D+
-si- 6
........................... '
6 D
.......H+ ......... / D .............. /
~-Si - O,
.......
D
0
=SiOD + HOD
...... H / This reaction is often reported to proceed easily at room temperature 6' 8,14,30,46 for fully hydroxylated silica, although other temperatures have also been used for deuteration. 47'4g However, some comments on the deuteration process used and the initial silica hydration degree have to be considered. The most cited silica deuteration study was performed by Davydov and coworkers.~5,24, 25,49 A known amount of D20 vapour was contacted with silica in a vacuum unit with circulation of vapours. 5~ The silica used for deuteration was pretreated at temperatures ranging from 298 to 473 K. Reaction was performed at room temperature with subsequent evacuation at 473 K. From a mass spectrometrical analysis of the produced vapours, a quantitative measure of the number of surface hydroxyl groups (aoH) was obtained, this quantity will be discussed in chapter 6. Deuteration of a fully hydroxylated silica gel does not result in a full exchange of all hydroxyl groups. Internal hydroxyls reside inside the silica structure and can not be reached by (heavy) water molecules. They are therefore not exchanged. The deuteration technique is therefore selective for silanol groups on the silica surface. Davydov ~5used FTIR spectra of the deuterated compounds to show that different types of silica have a different amount of internal silanol groups. Upon rising the exchange temperature to 473 K and contact time to 3 - 4 h, also internal groups could be exchanged, for some silica types. Based on 295i CP MAS NMR results, Chuang et
70 al. 51 quantised the relative percentage of these internal hydroxyls. Their results are given in table 3.3. Table 3.3 Relative percentage of internal silanols as measured from D20 exchange for two silica gels, SBer: BET surface area, r: average pore size distribution
high area silica gel low area silica gel
SBEr (m2/g)
particle size (/~m)
r (nm)
%int
666 422
75-150 75-150
2.6 3.0
3.0 9.3
As can be observed, the high surface area (HSA) sample contains less internal silanols. The surface area of the HSA silica is larger, while the particle size is the same of that of the low surface area (LSA) silica, because of a lower average pore diameter in the HSA silica. A larger number of small pores rather than large pores can be accommodated on a particle of a given diameter. The result is a particle with more of its internal volume penetrated by smaller and more numerous pores. This leaves less internal volume for trapped or unexchangeable protons. Chuang et al. used liquid D20 , at room temperature followed by evacuation. A total of 8 reaction-evacuation cycles was performed to obtain optimal exchange. From inspection of NMR spectra, they stated that the presence or absence of a geminalsilanol peak in the 29Si CP MAS NMR spectrum permits to assess the quality of the D20-exchange. As may be observed from figure 3.4, deuteration results in a sharp decrease in peak intensity, due to loss of CP-active protons. The resulting spectrum after deuteration (figure 3.4b) shows only two maxima, for silicons beating one and no hydroxyls, at -99 and -109 ppm, respectively. The absence of the peak due to silicon atoms beating geminal silanols at -89 ppm in the deuterated sample, indicates full surface deuteration.
71
b)
-
-I00
-120
PPM
Figure 3.4 29Si CP MAS NMR spectra of LSA silica gel before (a) and after (b and b ') H/D exchange in liquid D20, (b) plotted on the same intensity scale as (a), (b') at 26 times this intensity scale. Taken from ref (51) with permission.
5.2 Deuteration of partially dehydroxylated silica
In all above-cited studies, deuteration was performed on silicas, pretreated in the 298473 K temperature range. Deuteration of silicas after pretreatment at higher temperatures requires different conditions. White and Nair 52 used D20 vapour at 1 Torr partial pressure at a temperature of 373 K. They pretreated silica at high temperature (873 K) and found that for this substrate reaction with D20 resulted in breaking of strained siloxanes, producing surface OD groups. At reaction times below 100 min. This reaction is favoured to H/D exchange. Van Roosmalen and Mo142'45 worked at 700 K for the deuteration of 875 K pretreated silica. They did not succeed in a total exchange of the isolated silanols. A deuteration method for the whole silica pretreatment temperature range was developed by Vrancken et. al.. 53'54 Critical parameters of the above cited methods appeared to be the cyclic nature, which is labour-intensive and time-consuming, and the temperatures used during adsorption and evacuation. Using the intensity of silanol signal in FTIR-PAS as an evaluation criterion, the H/D exchange was optimized.
72 Silica gels were deuterated by pumping D20 at equilibrium vapour pressure over the sample. Time and temperature of both the adsorption and evacuation step were varied. The continuous flow of D20 vapour overcomes the need for repeating the procedure in several reaction cycles. The spectrum of silica gel, pretreated at 473 K under vacuum, before and after room temperature deuteration is shown in figure 3.5. Optimal exchange was observed if the adsorption was performed for 1 h at room temperature and the evacuation at the same temperature as pretreatment. Concerning the position of the OH and OD vibration bands in the FTIR spectrum, a shift for the free silanols from 3740 cm ~ to 2760 cm -1 is observed. Generally, the MO-H deformation mode of a triatomic molecule shift with a factor of about 1.36 towards lower wavenumber. 55 For more complex molecules, the H/D shift differs considerably, ranging from 1.40 to 1.28 in silanols. 56'57A thorough study of all FTIR spectral changes was reported by Morrow and McFarlan. 3~
Intensity(a.u.)
4ooo
3o0o
26~0
'
~600
Wavenumbers (can-l)
Figure 3.5 FTIR-PAS spectra of silica gel pretreated at 473 K under vacuum, (a) before and (b) after deuteration at room temperature with subsequent evacuation at 473 K
73
For all samples pretreated under vacuum at temperatures in the 298 - 573 K range, optimal H/D exchange was observed if D20 adsorption was performed for lh at room temperature, followed by evacuation at the same temperature as pretreatment. Deuteration may be considered as a rehydration of the surface, with heavy water, followed by H/D exchange. Product HDO and H20 molecules are thermally desorbed in the evacuation step. In this way, H/D exchange occurs without rehydroxylation, the deuterated silica has a deuterated surface silanol distribution identical to the initial pretreated silica. If the sample was pretreated at temperatures above 573 K, i.e. in the 673 - 1073 K range, other process parameters had to be chosen in order to obtain optimal H/D exchange. Better results are obtained with increasing temperature in the adsorption step. The choice of adsorption and evacuation temperatures was limited to 673 K, by the glass material of the experimental apparatus. Figure 3.6 shows the FTIR-PAS spectra of silica gel pretreated at 973 K, before deuteration (fig. 3.6a), after deuteration at room temperature (fig 3.6b) and at 673 K (fig 3.6c). Both samples were evacuated at room temperature after adsorption. It is evident from these spectra, that near full exchange is obtained if adsorption takes place at elevated temperature. Changing the temperature in the evacuation step did not result in better H/D exchange efficiencies. Similar results were obtained for other samples pretreated in the 573 - 1073 K temperature range. The different reaction parameters to be used for this series of substrates, compared to the low pretreatment temperature range, indicate a difference in deuteration process. For the high temperature pretreated samples, only isolated and geminal hydroxyls are present on the silica surface. These types of silanols have a low water physisorption ability. Therefore, instead of the formation of a hydration layer prior to H/D exchange, direct exchange from vapour phase has to occur. This is favoured at higher temperatures. Deuteration of silica gel therefore shows to be governed by the rehydration capacity of the substrate. At low pretreatment temperature the extent of H/D exchange is limited by internal silanols, which may not be reached by (heavy) water molecules. At high pretreatment temperature the exchange is restricted by the low physisorption ability of the isolated silanols.
74 Intensity (a.u.)
4000
'
31~0
'l
2000
i
Wavenumber (cm-1)
1003
Figure 3.6 FT1R spectra of silica gel pretreated at 973 K, (a) before deuteration, (b) after deuteration at room temperature, (c) after deuteration at 673 K and evacuation at room temperature
References
A.V. Kiselev and V.I. Lygin, Infrared spectra of surface compounds, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1975. ,
.
.
0
0
.
8.
J.B. Peri and A.L. Hensley, J. Phys. Chem., 1968, 70, 2926. F.H. Van Cauwelaert, P.A. Jacobs and J.B. Uytterhoeven, J. Phys. Chem., 1970, 76, 1434. B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1465. A.J. McFarlan and B.A. Morrow, J. Phys. Chem., 1991, 95, 5388. B.A. Morrow and A.J. McFarlan, J. Phys. Chem., 1992, 96, 1395. P. Hoffmann and E. Kn6zinger, Surface Science, 1987, 188, 181. D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1983, 105, 1487.
75
.
C. Bronnimann, R.C. Zeigler and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1988, 110, 2023.
10.
J.H. De Boer and J.M. Vleeskens, Proc. Koninkl. Ned. Akad. Wetenschap., 1958, Brl, 2.
11.
V.M. Ogenko, React. Kinet. Catal. Lett., 1993, 50, 103.
12.
K.S. Smimov, Vibrational Spectroscopy, 1993, 4, 255.
13.
M.L. Hair and W. Hertl, J. Phys. Chem., 1966, 70, 2372.
14.
A. Burneau, O. Barr~s, J.P. Gallas and J.C. Lavalley, Langmuir, 1990, 6, 1364.
15.
V. Davydov, A.V. Kiselev and L.T. Zhuravlev, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1964, 60, 2254.
16.
J.H. De Boer, M.E. Hermans and J. Vleeskens, Proc. Koninkl. Ned. Acad. Wetenschap., 1957, Br0, 45.
17.
G.J. Young, J. Colloid Sci., 1958, 13, 67.
18.
D. Barby, Silicas, in 'Characterization of powder surface', eds. G.D. Parfitt and K.S.W. Sing, Academic Press, London, 1976.
19.
W.K. Thompson, Proc. Brit. Ceramic Soc., 1965, 5, 143.
20.
V.M. Bermudez, J. Phys. Chem., 1970, 74, 4160.
21.
A.A. Agzamkhodzhaev, L.T. Zhuravlev, A.V. Kiselev and K.Y. Shengeliya, Kolloidn. Zh., 1974, 36, 1145.
22.
V.V. Strelko, in Adsorption and Adsorbents, No.2, Naukova Dumka, Kiev, 1974, p.65.
23.
M.M. Egorov, T.S. Egorova, V.F. Kiselev and K.G. Krasilnokov, Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR, 1957, 114, 579.
24.
L.T. Zhuravlev, Colloids and Surfaces A, 1993, 74, 71.
25.
D.A. Gardella, D.Z. Jiang and E.M. Eyring, Appl. Spectrosc., 1983, 37, 131.
26.
D.E. Leyden, R.S. Shreedhara, J.P. Blitz and J.B. Atwater, Microchem. Acta Wien, 1988, 2, 53.
27.
D. Gorski, E. Klemm, P. Fink and H. H6rhold, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 126, 445.
28.
S.P. Zhdanov, Langmuir, 1987, 3, 960.
76 29.
B.A. Morrow and A.J. McFarlan, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., 1990, 120, 61.
30.
B.A. Morrow, I.A. Cody and L.S.M. Lee, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 2761.
31.
G. Ghiotti, E. Garrone, C. Morterra and F. Boccuzzi, J. Phys. Chem., 1979, 83, 2863.
32.
F. Boccuzzi, S. Coluccia, G. Ghiotti, C. Morterra and A. Zecchina, J. Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 1298.
33.
B.A. Morrow, I.A. Cody and L.S.M. Lee, J. Phys. Chem., 1975, 79, 2405.
34.
A.T. Tsyganenko, Russ. J. Phys. Chem., 1982, 56, 1482.
35.
P. Fink, H. Hartmut and G. Rudakoff, Wiss. Ztschr. FSU, Naturwiss. R., 1987, 36, 581. (in German)
36.
J. Kratochvila, Z. Salajka, A. Kzada, Z. Kadlc, J. Soucek and M. Gheorgiu, J. NonCryst. Solids, 1990, 116, 93.
37.
R.S. McDonald, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1957, 79, 850.
38.
A.V. Kiselev and V.I. Lygin, Kolloidn. Zh., 1959, 21,581.
39.
J.J. Fripiat, M.C. Gastuche and R. Brichard, J. Phys. Chem., 1962, 66, 805.
40.
S. Kondo and M. Muroya, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jap., 1970, 43, 2657.
41.
M.L. Hair, Infrared spectroscopy in surface chemistry, Dekker, New York, 1967.
42.
A.J. Van Roosmalen and J.C. Mol, J. Phys. Chem., 1978, 82, 2748.
43.
H.P. Boehm, M. Schneider and F. Ahrendt, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem., 1963, 320, 43.
44.
G.C. Pimentel, C.W. Garland and G. Jura, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1953, 75, 803.
45.
V.A. Tertykh and L.A. Belyakova, 'Chemical reactions involving the surface of silica', Naukova Dumka Publ., Kiev, 1991, (in Russian).
46.
F.H. Hambleton, J.A. Hockey and J.A.G. Taylor, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1966, 62, 801.
47.
J. Mathias and G. Wannemacher, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 125, 61.
48.
K. Susa, I. Matsuyama and S. Satoh, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., 1992, 146, 81.
49.
V.Y. Davydov, A.V. Kiselev, H. Pfeifer and I. Junger, Russ. J. Phys. Chem., 1983, 157, 1527.
77
50.
R.G. Haldeman and P.H. Emmett, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1956, 78, 2917.
51.
I. Chuang, D.R. Kinney and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1993, 115, 8695.
52.
R.L. White and A. Nair, Appl. Spectr., 1990, 44, 69.
53.
K.C. Vrancken and L. De Coster, unpublished results.
54.
K.C. Vrancken, L. De Coster, P. Van Der Voort, P.J. Grobet and E.F. Vansant, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1995, 169, in print.
55.
S.D. Ross, in Inorganic Infrared and Raman Spectra, McGraw-Hill, London, 1972.
56.
R. Whitnall and L. Andrews, J. Phys. Chem., 1985, 89, 3261.
57.
Z.K. Ismail, R.H. Hauge, L. Fredin, J.W. Kauffman and J.L. Margrave, J. Chem. Phys., 1982, 77, 1617.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
79
Chapter 4
Quantification of the silanol number
1 Introduction Since Kiselev 1 discovered the surface hydroxyl groups on silica in 1936, many studies on the quantification of the silanol number (Cto. : number of hydroxyl groups per nm 2) and on the characterization of the different hydroxyl types have been published. These studies can be divided into theoretical calculations, physical methods and chemical methods. An often cited theoretical calculation is the one of De Boer, 2 who used the (111) plane of the octahedral face of/3-cristobalite to calculate an CtOHof 4.55 OH/nm 2. Peri and Hensley 3 found the same value, using the (100) crystal plane of cristobalite.
Chemical methods are generally based on the reaction of surface hydroxyl groups with a selectively reacting compound to form a covalently bonded surface species of well known composition. As reactive compounds, diborane, 4'5 boron trichloride, 6'7 diazomethane, s organosilanes, 3'6'9'1~ and organometallic compounds ~5have been employed. OtoHis then derived from the amount of the chemisorbed species as well as the amount of volatile reaction products. For the physical methods, infrared spectroscopy is the most commonly applied technique for monitoring and controlling the surface hydroxylation of silica. Mid infrared spectroscopy is limited for quantitative applications, since it is very difficult to distinguish between adsorbed water and actual surface hydroxyl groups.
80
Kratochvila ~6 and co-workers have tried to circumvent this problem, using the near infrared region. Their suggested peak assignments are summarized in table 4.1. The authors made no attempt to determine the silanol number, but concluded that 'the results obtained reveal a necessity to verify the hypotheses, using silica gel samples containing known amounts of different types of OH groups'. Table 4.1 Peak attribution of the O-H overtone vibrations in the near infrared region, according to Kratochvila
Peak position (cm1)
5235 4425 4505
attribution
adsorbed water free OH free + bridged water
absorption coefficient (1/mol.cm) 1.33 4- 0.04 0.35 +__0.02 0.89 ___0.03
Also TGA (Thermogravimetric Analysis) is often used to study dehydroxylation effects and to estimate Cto.. The crucial problem is the separation of dehydration and dehydroxylation phenomena. Kellum and Smith 17 proved in 1967 that TGA overestimates CtoHfor an amorphous silica gel typically with 2.5 OH/nm 2. This value was very close to the amount of adsorbed water on the silica. Good results can be obtained though, when curve fitting software is used to deconvolute the DTG (Differential Thermogravimetry) peaks of the dehydration and dehydroxylation ~g processes. During the last decade, a wide variety of new techniques has been applied. Sindorf et al. 9 have evaluated Cto. using 29Si CP MAS NMR (Cross Polarisation-Magic Angle Spinning-Nuclear Magnetic Resonance). Haukka and co-workers 19'2~ used the CRAMPS (Combined Rotation and Multiple Pulse Spectroscopy) technique, developed by Bronnimann 2~ for a direct measurement of the silanols by ~H MAS NMR. Lochmiiller22used a modification with trimethylchlorosilane, analyzed by luminescence spectroscopy to quantify CtoH. Following the earlier work of Van Cauwelaert 23 and Morrow, 24 Fink et al. 25 used infrared band deconvolution algorithms to calculate a relative distribution of the different hydroxyl types on the surface of silica gel.
81
The determination of the silanol number of a fully hydroxylated silica has been reviewed by many authors. 26'27'28'29In this section, we will focus upon a few studies that estimate the silanol number as a function of the dehydroxylation temperature. This is not possible using theoretical calculations, which can only provide a fair estimation of the silanol number of a fully hydroxylated silica.
2 The silanol n u m b e r - a physicochemical constant
The experiments of Z h u r a v l e v 3~ for determining the silanol number were based upon a deuterium exchange method with mass spectrometric analysis. The method of deuterium exchange has the advantage that only the surface hydroxyls enter into the reaction of isotopic exchange and that structural water or intraglobular hydroxyls do not. The surface concentration of hydroxyl groups (the silanol number, CtoH), expressed in OH groups per nm 2, is determined as "OH = ~on * NA * 10"21 s'l
(1)
where tSonis the concentration of hydroxyls groups (mmol/g), S is the specific surface area (m2/g) and NA is the Avogadro number. Based upon more than 100 samples, with a specific surface area varying from 5 to 1000 m2/g, Zhuravlev found that the silanol number for a fully hydroxylated silica amounts 4.6 _ 0 . 5 0 H / n m 2. This constant is claimed to be independent of the origin and structural characteristics (specific surface area, type of pores, pore size distribution, ...) of the sample. The deuterium exchange method was also used to determine the average value of the silanol number as a function of dehydroxylation temperature (473 - 1373 K in vacuo). The experimental results are shown in figure 4.1. The samples differed from one another in the method of their synthesis and in their structural characteristics" the specific surface area of the samples varied from 11 to 905 m2/g, and their porosity also varied within a wide range. Despite all these differences, the value of aOH at a given treatment temperature is similar for all the samples, and the decrease in the value of Cton under similar heating conditions also
82 follows approximately the same pattern. The average values of C~o. (and their corresponding degree of surface coverage, 0oH) are presented in table 4.2.
6
r
OI-I/nm2
5 4
3 2 1
I
473
673
I
_
873 1 0 7 3 1 2 7 3 1473 Temperature (K)
Figure 4.1 Silanol number as a function of the temperature of pretreatment in vacuo for different samples of Si02; taken from ref (31) with permission.
As can be seen from data in figure 4.1 and table 4.2, the values of aoH decrease considerably in the range from 473 to about 723 K; between 723 and 1373 K this decrease becomes notably smaller. Correspondingly the value of 0oH in the first steep section of the plot decreases from 1 to about 0.5 and in the second, more fiat section, it drops from 0.5 to very small values approaching zero.
The fast dehydroxylation in the low temperature region is caused by the condensation of bridged silanols, whereas the slow dehydroxylation in the high temperature region is caused by the condensation of free silanols. The dehydroxylation behaviour of free and bridged silanols is treated in chapter 5.
83 Table 4.2 Values of UoH and Oon following treatment in vacuo of amorphous silica at different temperatures, with the initial state corresponding to the maximum degree of surface hydroxylation
Temp. of vacuum treatment (K) 453 - 473 573 673 773 873 973 1073 1173 1273 1373
Silanol number C~oH,.v (OH groups/nm 2)
Degree of coverage with OH groups (0on)
4.60 3.55 2.35 1.80 1.50 1.15 0.70 0.40 0.25 <0.15
1.00 0.77 0.50 0.40 0.33 0.25 0.15 0.09 0.05 <0.03
3 H e x a m e t h y l d i s i l a z a n e as a silanol titrator 32
The quantification of the silanol number by reaction with hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) is a typical chemical modification technique. Hexamethyldisilazane is known as a methylating, deactivating reagent in chromatography. 29'33'34It reacts readily with hydrophilic silanols yielding very stable methylsilyl groupings according to the following reaction: 2 - Si-OH + (CH3)3-Si-NH-Si-(CH3)3 --, 2 - Si-O-Si(CH3) 3 + NH 3
(A)
To our knowledge, no significant side reactions have been reported. Reaction (A) has been used by various researchers, in order to determine the silanol number. Stark and co-workers 35 used radiochemical tracer methods to model the sorption of They confirmed a 1:1 stoichiometry of silanols reacted vs. trimethylsilyls formed. Zettlemoyer and Hsing 36 studied the interaction of HMDS with
HMDS on silica.
silica in the NIR region. They contested the statement of Hair 37 that HMDS reacts solely with free hydroxyl groups, and proved that intraglobular hydroxyls on aerosil
84 silicas are not attacked. Maciel and Sindorf 3s quantified ao. using 29Si CP MAS NMR. They found a silanol number of 4.8 + 0 . 4 0 H / n m 2 for 8 different HMDS treated silicas. B u z e k 39 determined the silanol concentration on aerosils with trimethylchlorosilane and HMDS, using gravimetric and mass spectroscopic methods. The results based on the adsorption (in gas phase) of trimethylchlorosilane agreed very well with the generally accepted data. In 1985, Nawrocki 4~ finally proved that the liberated N H 3 does not adsorb on the silica surface. In 1988, Gorski and c o - w o r k e r s 41 performed a silanol quantization by FTIR band integration of the free OH band, the reference band and the methyl band 0'rex = 2865 cm~). The obtained ao. values were rather low and quantitative data were only published for two temperatures. A recent review on the reaction of HMDS with the silica surface is provided by Haukka and co-workers. 2~ All these studies are based on spectroscopic techniques. Such determinations are offline, post-reaction analysis. Therefore, sample treatment in the time between reaction and measurement is very important, since it is a source of uncontrollable errors. Looking at the reaction mechanism of HMDS with silica, the possibility of an in situ determination of the silanol number arises. The on-line determination of the liberated N H 3 during the reaction directly yields the number of silanols reacted with HMDS. FTIR spectroscopy is only used to check whether all hydroxyls have reacted.
Advantages and limitations of chemical modification techniques It is obvious that in calculating the number of silanol groups on the surface, the internal or intraglobular hydroxyl groups must not be included. Unfortunately, this has not been done in many investigations. Especially the data in studies, based on thermogravimetric analysis or on infrared analysis are confused by the presence of intraglobular hydroxyl groups. Lygin and K i s e l e v 42 proved by deuteration experiments that intraglobular hydroxyls are even not accessible to D20. Therefore, the surface modification of silica with HMDS (or with other chemical modifiers) is a typical probe of surface hydroxyl groups.
85
Iler 26 wrote that 'it is necessary to measure the surface hydroxyl groups by a method that responds only to the SiOH groups on the surface'. HMDS modification performs this task excellently. However, extreme caution 43 is necessary when applying chemical modification techniques. In general, 3 requirements have to be fulfilled: (1) the stoichiometry of the reaction has to be known; (2) all (surface) hydroxyl groups should be accessible; (3) physisorbed products must be removed before analysis. Condition (1) is well fulfilled in the case of HMDS: no side reactions have been detected. This is without doubt the main advantage of HMDS compared to the often used methylchorosilanes, ~'5'6'7'8'11'44,45exhibiting poorly controllable side and secondary reactions (cfr. chapter 9). Concerning condition (2), one has to deal with sterical hindrance effects. L o w e n 46 found a maximal trimethylsilyl (TMS) coverage of 2.2 per nm 2, UngeP 7 reported 2.7 TMS groups per nm 2, Zettlemoyer 36 detected 2.45 TMS groups per nm 2 and Maciel and Sindorf 38 found a value of 2.7 TMS groups per nm 2. Maciel and Sindorf have included in their publication a number of theoretical surface models, explaining these maximal TMS loadings. Based on known values of typical bond angles and Van Der Waals radii, the maximal lateral extension of a TMS group on the surface is calculated to be roughly 0.37 nm, resulting in a projected (free rotation) surface area of 0.43 nm 2. Incorporation of corrections for void volume, for the Van Der Waals radius of a methyl group and for crowding effects, yields a theoretical maximal TMS loading of 2.8 groups per nm 2. Silanol concentrations above this value cannot be detected by direct N H 3 measurement. Condition (3) warns for a reaction of HMDS with other species than silanols on the surface of silica. The main source of error is in this case the glassware. Therefore, the HMDS reactions are performed in fully methylated glassware, and the HMDS is allowed to reflux for at least 30 minutes, before the silica is introduced.
86
Determination of the silanol number Figure 4.2 shows the spectra of Kieselgel 60," thermally treated at 873 K, before and after reaction with HMDS. The distinct free hydroxyl band (3745 cm ~) of the unreacted sample has completely disappeared after trimethylsilylation. The peaks centred around 2865 cm ~ are attributed to various C-H stretching vibrations. The main attributions are presented in table 4.3, based on the data published by Chiang. 4s
Table 4.3 Infrared band assignment of the C-H stretching region l)max,
assignment
(era-1) 2975 2928 2886 2870
l,as (CH3)
1,as (CH2) ~,s (CH3) l,s (CH3)
Critical inspection of the spectrum after HMDS modification shows a tiny band around 3650 cm -1. This band can be attributed to either residual intraglobular hydroxyl groups, either to a readsorption of water during the post-reaction sample treatment. The reacted sample had to be dried before FTIR analysis. Zettlemoyer and Hsing 36 wrote that water is still able to penetrate the 'umbrella layer' and adsorb on the underlying surface. Confirmation for the latter possibility is found in the article of Gorse and co-workers, 4~ where HMDS was reacted in the gas-phase. Not being forced to dry the reacted sample, they reported at no point residual hydroxyl bands. A second argument is to be found in the publication of Thompson, 49 who stated that intraglobular hydroxyl groups and trapped water are removed after a thermal treatment of 673 K. The samples shown in figure 4.2 have endured a thermal treatment at 873 K.
Kieselgel 60: a silica gel with an average pore radius 3.6 nm, obtained from Merck.
87
Intensity (a.u.)
4000
3500
3000
2:500 2600
Wavenumbers (cm-1)
1~500
Figure 4.2 FTIR spectra of Kieselgel 60, thermally treated at 873 K, before (a) and after (b) reaction with HMDS.
At pretreatment temperatures below 673 K, HMDS is no longer able to remove all surface hydroxyl groups, due the previously described sterical hindrance effects. In these cases, quantification of the silanol number is still possible, using the integrated values of the hydroxyl and C-H infrared bands, normalized to the reference band. Figure 4.3 shows the silanol number, as a function of treatment temperature, for Kieselgel 60, using the above described HMDS method. Zhuravlev's data are also included in the figure. In the temperature region below 573 K, the sterical upper limit is clearly demonstrated. Maximum TMS coverage is about 2.5 per nm 2. In the temperature region above 673 K, the data obtained by the HMDS method agree very well with Zhuravlev's data. The deviation is about 0.2 OH per nm 2, which is considerably smaller than the experimental errors (Zhuravlev postulated -for 139 silicas- a deviation of 0.5 OH per nm2).
88
Silanol number (#Into2) 5~
::::::: ::: :::: ::: ::: ======================= ::: :: ::.: :::::
::
. ...:.
::.: ::. :. :::
/..: ::::.
m
iiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii ~
473
l
l
1
573 673 773 873 973 1073 Pretreatment temperature (K)
HMD$ upper limit
--x-
Observed deviation (Zhuravlev)
-+-
Zhuravlev MDS
Figure 4.3 Determination of the silanol number on Kieselgel 60 using the HMDS method.
4 Conclusion The silanol number can be considered as a physicochemical constant, independent of the silica type. A fully hydroxylated silica contains 4.6 hydroxyls per nm 2. This number decreases fast to approximately 2.3 OH per nm 2 at treatment temperatures of 673 K in vacuo. At higher temperatures, the dehydroxylation is much slower. Temperatures higher than 1473 K are required to remove all silanols from the silica surface.
89 References
1. .
3. 0
A.V. Kiselev, Kolloidn. Zh., 1936, 2, 17. J.H. De Boer, M.E. Hermans and J. Vleeskens, Koninkl. Ned. Acad. Wetenschap., 1957, B.60, 45. J.B. Peri and A.L. Hensley, J. Phys. Chem., 1968, 72, 2936. J. Shapiro and H.G. Weiss, J. Phys. Chem., 1953, 57, 219.
5.
C1. Naccache, J.F. Rosetti and B. Imelik, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr., 1959, 404.
6.
C.G. Armistead and F.H. Hambleton, J. Phys. Chem., 1969, 73, 3947.
7.
H.P. Boehm, M. Schneider and F. Ahrendt, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem., 1963, 32t), 43.
8.
F.H. Hambleton and J.A. Hockey, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1966, 63, 1694.
9.
D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1983, 105, 1487.
10.
M.L. Hair and W. Hertl, J. Phys. Chem., 1966, 70, 2372.
11.
L.R. Snyder and J.W. Ward, J. Phys. Chem., 1966, 70, 3941.
12.
B. Evans and T.E. White, J. Catal., 1968, 11,336.
13.
C.G. Armistead and J.A. Hockey, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1967, 63, 2549.
14.
K. Yoshinaga, H. Yoshida, Y. Yamamoto and K. Takakura, J. Coll. Interface Sci., 1992, 153, 207.
15.
J.J. Fripiat and J. Uytterhoeven, J. Phys. Chem., 1962, 66, 800.
16.
J. Kratochvila, Z. Salajka, A. Kzada, Z. Kadlc, J. Soucek and M. Gheorgiu, J. of Non-Cryst. Sol., 1990, 116, 93.
17.
G.E. Kellum and R.C. Smith, Anal. Chem., 1967, 39, 341.
18.
I. Gillis-D'Hamers, PhD-thesis, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, 1993.
19.
S. Haukka, E. l_akomaa and A. Root, J. Phys. Chem., 1993, 97, 5085.
20.
S. Haukka and A. Root, J. Phys. Chem., 1994, 98, 1695.
21.
C.E. Bronnimann, R.G. Zeigler and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1988, 110, 2023.
90 22.
C.H. l_x~hmiiller and M.T. Kersey, Langmuir, 1988, 4, 572.
23.
F.H. Van Cauwelaert, P. Jacobs and J.B. Uytterhoeven, J. Phys. Chem., 1972, 72, 1434.
24.
B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1465.
25.
P. Fink, H. Hartmut and G. Rudakoff, Wiss. Ztschr. FSU, Naturwiss. R., 1987, 36, 581. (in German)
26.
R.K. Iler, The Chemistry of Silica; Solubility, Polymerization, Colloid and Surface Properties and Biochemistry, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1979.
27.
K.K. Unger, Porous Silica, its properties and use as support in column liquid chromatography, Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam, 1979.
28.
D. Barby, Silicas, in 'Characterization of powder surfaces', eds. G.D. Parfitt and K.S.W. Sing, Academic Press, London, 1976.
29.
A.V. Kiselev and V.I. Lygin, Infrared spectra of surface compounds, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1975.
30.
L.T. Zhuravlev, Langmuir, 1987, 3, 316.
31.
L.T. Zhuravlev, Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects, 1993, 74, 71.
32.
P. Van Der Voort, PhD thesis, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, 1993.
33.
M.L. Hair, Infrared Spectroscopy in Surface Chemistry, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1967.
34.
L.H. Little, Infrared spectra of adsorbed species, Academic Press, London, 1966.
35.
F.O. Stark, O.K. Johannson, G.E. Vogel, R.G. Chaffee and R.M. Lacefield, J. Phys. Chem., 1968, 72, 2750.
36.
A.C. Zettlemoyer and H.H. Hsing, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1977, 58, 263.
37.
M.L. Hair and W. Hertl, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1965.
38.
D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Phys. Chem., 1982, 86, 5208.
39.
F. Buzek and J. Rathousky, J, Colloid Interface Sci., 1980, 79, 47.
40.
J. Nawrocki, Chromatographia, 1985, 20, 308.
41.
D. GorsE, E. Klemm, P. Fink and H. H6rhold, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 126, 445.
91
42.
V.I. Lygin and A.V. Kiselev, Kolloidn. Zh., 1961, 23, 299.
43.
P. Van Der Voort, S. Vercauteren, K. Peeters and E.F. Vansant, J. Coll. Interface Sci., 1993, 157, 518.
44.
P. Hoffmann and E. Kn6zinger, Surface Science, 1987, 188, 181.
45.
G.J. Young, J. Colloid Sci., 1958, 13, 67.
46.
W.K. Lowen and E.C. Broge, J. Phys. Chem., 1966, 65, 16.
47.
K.K. Unger, N. Becker and P. Paumeliotis, J. Chromatogr., 1976, 125, 115.
48.
C. Chiang, H. Ishida and J.L. Koenig, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1980, 74, 396.
49.
W.K. Thompson, Proc. Brit. Ceram. Soc., 1965, 5, 143.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
93
Chapter 5
The distribution of the silanol types and their desorption energies
Once the silanol number as a function of temperature is known, further distinction between isolated, vicinal and geminal hydroxyls should be made. Since all silanol types exhibit different reactivities, an exact knowledge of the ratio isolated/vicinal silanols is crucial for a thorough study of a modification reaction. In the last decade, a number of publications has been devoted to this subject. These studies are either based on spectroscopic techniques (IR, NMR) or on desorption techniques (temperature programmed desorption of pyridine and water). In all of these models the distinction between free and bridged silanols, trapped water and intraglobular hydroxyls is the key problem. The models based on desorption techniques are also able to derive the kinetic parameters of the dehydroxylation and dehydration processes. Also, the desorption energy (E~) for the different condensation processes can be calculated. Therefore, also energetically a distinction can be made between adsorbed water, free hydroxyls and bridged hydroxyls.
94 1 The infrared models
The integration model The simplest possible way to estimate the concentration of the different silanol types on the silica surface consists of an integration of the corresponding infrared bands. Van Der Voort et al. 1'2 used the ratio of the integrated values of the silanol infrared bands in combination with the quantitative CtoHvalues, provided in chapter 4, to obtain a fast estimation of the number of free and bridged silanols on the silica surface. The relevant infrared bands, together with their abbreviations are presented in table 5.1.
Table 5.1 Integration intervals of the various infrared bands integration interval 3760-3720 3760-3400 (TOH-FOH) 1950-1766
peak maximum
assignment
name in text
3746 1870
free hydroxyls (isolated) total hydroxyls bridged hydroxyls (vicinal) overtone structure vibration
FOH band TOH band BOH band reference band
In infrared spectroscopy, isolated silanols are commonly referred to as free silanols and vicinal silanols as bridged. The geminal silanols are not separately detectable in infrared and are also classified as free silanols. All integrated values are normalized to a reference band, whose intensity is independent for the different treatments. 3'4'5 Basically, the calculations are performed using the ratio (A) : FOH band / TOH band, obtained by the numerical band integration. Multiplication of (A) with the total number of hydroxyl groups yields quantitative data on the amount of free and bridged hydroxyls on the silica surface.
95 The peak maximum of the free silanol band, presented in table 5.1, is the maximum at room temperature, since this band is known to shift as a function of temperature. 6'7'g Figure 5.1 shows the estimated distribution of free and bridged hydroxyl groups as a function of the pretreatment temperature for Kieselgel 60, as obtained by the numerical band integration of the respective FTIR spectra. In the low temperature region, the surface is almost completely covered with vicinal (bridged) silanols. This is consistent with the theoretical model of Peri and Hensley, 9 who performed Monte-Carlo simulations on the (100) plane of/3-cristobalite. They concluded that the surface of a hydroxylated silica is completely covered with bridged silanols. The hypothesis that a fully hydroxylated silica is only covered with bridged hydroxyls is probably not entirely correct, as will be evidenced later in this section.
O~nm2
0 373
473
573 673 773 873 Temperature (K)
973
1073
Figure 5.1 Distribution of free (m) and bridged (+) silanols on Kieselgel 60, as a function of the pretreatment temperature.
96 In the temperature range 373-873 K, the concentration of free silanols increases, whereas the number of bridged hydroxyls decreases. Both phenomena occur at the same time and can be explained by reaction (A).
~i--O\
~i § n 20
(A)
H Random condensation of bridged silanols yields siloxane bridges, but also causes a relative increase in the free silanol number. In the temperature range above 873 K, the surface is mainly covered with free silanols. Their concentration decreases as a function of increasing temperature, due to a condensation reaction forming siloxane bridges. Some of these condensation reactions occur as interparticle condensations, explaining the collapse of surface area and porosity above 873 K. It is obvious that the model of Van Der Voort can only provide a quick estimation of the actual distribution. The biggest problem in this integration technique are errors due to band overlap (figure 5.2). This causes an underestimation of the fraction of free hydroxyl groups in the low treatment region.
Also, the model makes no distinction between single (free) and geminal (free) silanols. This infrared integration model is further sophisticated by Fink and co-workers.
The deconvolution model The infrared deconvolution model of Fink s is based on curve fitting of the free hydroxyl band, in order to distinguish between single free silanols and geminal free silanols.
97
Intensity (a.u.)
Free hydroxyls
I
I
3800
3600
I
I
3400 3200 Wavenumbers (cm- 1)
3000
Figure 5.2 Integration intervals of the model of Van Der Voort. The deconvolution was based on following attributions: 5 cm -~
free, single OH
3749 cm -~
v~/2 =
3742 cm -~
v~a = 10 cm ~
free, geminal OH
3730 cm ~
v~/2 = 12 cm ~
weak interparticle interaction between free OH and a siloxane bridge
3717 cm ~
v~/2 =
9 cm -~
weak interparticle interaction between free OH and a hydroxyl proton
Typical results of such deconvolution are shown in figure 5.3. Figure 5.4 shows the result of these peak deconvolutions. Fink made no attempt to convert these semi-quantitative results to absolute numbers on the hydroxyl content.
If one assumes that the hydroxyl content on a silica,
pretreated at 1073 K is 0 . 7 0 H / n m 2 (cfr. chapter 4), that the adsorption coefficient of the free and geminal hydroxyls does not differ significantly, and if one neglects the 3730 cm -~ and 3718 cm ~ contributions to the total signal, absolute numbers can be derived (figure 5.5).
98
T
E
.
i
3710
3720 3730
3%0
3750 3760
"~ Ccm-~]
3770
Figure 5.3 Curve fitting results of the OH band of aerosil at (a) 673 K; (b) 873 K and (c) 1073 K; taken from ref (8) with permission.
The model of Fink contains two troubleshooting points. The disagreement on the existence and infrared peak attribution of the geminal silanols was already covered in the previous section. But also fitting techniques have been subjected to severe discussions. Morrow and Cody ~~questioned an early attempt of Van Cauwelaert '~ to deconvolute the free and geminal infrared vibration by curve fitting, stating that '... (they would like to) plea for caution in applying such (fitting) methods for the resolution of overlapping band envelopes. It is most important to indicate one's criteria for a 'satisfactory fit', since an infinite number of such fits can be obtained if the permissible discrepancy is large enough'. Especially the attribution of the 'weak interparticle interactions of free silanols' can be subjected to criticism, since no physical model is proposed to prove this statement.
99
8
Peakarea
I
673
,,x
773
873 973 1073 1173 Temperature (K)
Figure 5.4. Peak area of the different hydroxyl types. OH, [] 3750 cm -1, x 3718 cm ~.
9total OH, + geminal OH, * isolated
The band shift model
The band shift model of Gillis-D'Hamers 7 is based on the observation that the peak maximum of the free silanol vibration shifts as a function of treatment temperature (figures 5.6 and 5.7). Measurements were performed using the FTIR technique, in the high resolution (0.5 cm ~) mode. The outline of the shift approaches an S-shape. The slope of the curve is at its maximum in the temperature region 473 to 573-673 K. Moreover, above 673 K, the absorption maximum of the free hydroxyl groups shows only a small, almost linear increase in wavenumber. Gillis-D'Hamers explains this shift by the interaction of the free silanols with the surrounding hydrophilic centres (adsorbed water, bridged and free silanols). The free silanol peak shift is considered as a secondary effect: although the free silanols are in no direct interaction with the other silanols, still their presence causes slight changes in the electronic environment of the free O-H bond, resulting in a small peak shift.
100
2.5
Silanol number (OI-I/nm2)
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5 I
673
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
773 873 973 1073 1173 Temperature (K)
Figure 5.5 Absolute silanol concentration on aerosil as a function of temperature. free OH, + geminal OH, * free OH.
9total
Therefore, the wavenumber shift of the free hydroxyl vibration is -according to GillisD'Hamers- a direct reflection of the population of free and bridged silanols. In order to correlate the peak shift to absolute numbers on the free and bridged hydroxyl concentration, following assumptions were made: (1) (2) (3) (4)
The relative coverage of the bridged hydroxyls at 1073 K is zero. The relative coverage of the bridged hydroxyls at room temperature is one. The intermediate wavenumbers represent the relative coverage as a function of temperature. The relative coverage of the free hydroxyls as a function of temperature is equal to one minus the relative coverage of the bridged hydroxyl groups.
The results of these calculations are shown in figure 5.8.
101
Intensity (a~u.) 973 K 673 K 573 K 473 K 373 K !
3760 Wavemumbex (cm -1) 3700 Figure 5.6
FTIR spectra of silica gel at different pretreatment temperatures.
3750
Wavenumber (cm-1)
J
3745-
3740-
f 3735 273 373 Figure 5.7
473
573 673 773 Temperature(K)
873
973
1073
Wavenumber of the absorption maximum as a function of temperature.
When discussing this result, Gillis-D'Hamers acknowledges that 'it is not fully justified to associate the lowest wavenumber, i.e. at room temperature, with a surface
102
1.0
Coverage (a.u.)
0.8 0.6
0.4 0.2 0
373
Figure 5.8
473
Relative
573
coverage
673 773 Temperature (K)
of free
(.)
873
973
and bridged
107]
(+)
OH groups.
consisting of bridged hydroxyls only. In practice, the ratio of bridged hydroxyls over the free hydroxyls is obtained from infrared integration and exceeds 10:1.' This relative error of 10% at the low temperatures should be considered as a limitation of the model. The extrapolation of these relative coverage numbers to absolute hydroxyl concentrations is performed using the relative coverage of free and bridged hydroxyl groups (figure 5.8) and the total hydroxyl content. It should be remembered that the total hydroxyl content is not constant with the temperature. Therefore, the shape of the curve in absolute numbers (OH per nm 2) will differ from that of figure 5.8, see figure 5.9. The greatest fall in bridged hydroxyls concentration occurs between 473 and 573 K, the region showing the maximum wavenumber shift. Above 723 K the bridged hydroxyl concentration is almost reduced to zero. The most remarkable feature of this model is the different interpretation that GillisD'Hamers has given to the cause of the free hydroxyl shift.
103 In fact, many other authors 12'13'14'15'16'17have noticed a shift in the free hydroxyl peak maximum as a function of temperature. Hoffmann and Kn6zinger 17 have performed a detailed study of the free hydroxyl vibration, using high resolution (0.25 cm ~) FTIR, equipped with a heatable vacuum cell. They observed a (very small) peak shift as a function of temperature, but also a significant peak narrowing (table 5.2).
Table 5.2 FWHM, position and intensity variation of the stretching band of free surface OH groups as a function of the degassing temperature according to Hoffmann and KnOzinger
Degassing temperature (K) 298 573 723 873 1173 1373
Band position (cm~)
FWHM (cm-~)
3748.0 3748.2 3748.3 3748.3 3749.1 3749.3
7.2 5.7 5.5 4.5 3.9 3.9
Hoffmann and Kn6zinger therefore state that the free hydroxyl vibration in fact is a superimposition of the free hydroxyl vibration and the geminal vibration. The absence of geminal hydroxyls at high temperatures explains the peak narrowing of this 'sumpeak'. They further argument that 'obviously the band width is in any case at least twice as large as the distance between the two peaks. This explains that most researchers involved have not been able to detect any fine structure in the respective OH band'. Two very closely spaced frequencies have also been predicted for single and geminal OH groups by theoretical calculations. TM Additional experimental evidence is provided by the observation that the OH stretching frequencies of trimethylsilanol and dimethylsilanediol differ only by 2 cm-l. 19'2~ These two different interpretations of the free hydroxyl shift have caused an ambiguity in literature, yet to be solved.
104
Silanol number (OI-I/nm2)
_
iI
2
Temperature (K) Figure 5.9 Total content and absolute surface concentrations of the two different hydroxyl types, according to the band s h ~ model (m total OH; + free OH; * bridged OH).
2 The NMR Models 29 Si NMR
Whereas infrared spectroscopy classifies the surface hydroxyls according to their bond strength (free and bridged silanols), 29 Si NMR spectroscopy distinguishes single (either isolated or vicinal) from double (geminal) silanols. This technique can thus be regarded upon as complementary to infrared spectroscopy. In 29 Si NMR spectroscopy, silanols are not referred to as free, bridged and geminal silanols, but as 'Q' sites. Siloxane bridges are called 'Q4 sites', single silanols 'Q3 sites' and geminal silanols 'Q2 sites'. A survey of the peak assignments is given in table 5.3.
105 Figure 5.10 shows the structural resolution obtainable in a 29Si CP MAS NMR experiment in the most favourable cases. The low intensity peak a t - 8 9 ppm is assigned to geminal silanol sites, the peak at -100 ppm to single silanol sites and the peak at-109 ppm to siloxane bridges. Table 5.3 Surface silanol types with their 29Si CP MAS NMR and FTIR peak position and names
HO
\
OH
/
/ \ 0
OH-
OH
/1\ 0
0
0
0
/
0
OH
...Si----------~i 0
0
0
0
geminal
isolated
vicinal
Q2 -94 ppm
Q3 - 100 ppm
Q3 - 100 ppm
3743 cm-1 free
3743 cm-I free
3660 cm~ bridged
Deconvolution of these peaks would yield a distribution of Q2 and Q3 sites as a function of temperature. However, cross-polarisation spectroscopy is not automatically a quantitative technique, since the signal's intensity depends -amongst others- upon the proximity of protons and upon the contact time, used in the experiment. It is the merit of Maciel and Sindorf 2~'22 to have studied these effects in detail, and to have provided methods and algorithms to perform quantitative measurements with 29Si CP MAS NMR. The final outcome of this study is shown in figure 5.11.
106
I
.
.
.
.
I
-50
-100
.
.
.
.
I -150
'
PPM
Figure 5.10 CP/MAS 29SiNMR spectrum of Fisher S-157 silica saturated with liquid water; taken from ref (21) with permission. Fraction of geminols 0.30
0.26
0.22 -
0.18 -
0.14
0.10 273
I
373
I
473
I
573 673 773 Temperature (K)
I
873
I
973
1073
Figure 5.11 Plot offractional population of geminal sites measured for dehydrated samples vs. temperature.
107 As often observed in literature, these results are quite inconsistent with the FTIR models, which predict a very low concentration of geminal hydroxyls. As an example, the reader is referred to the Hoffmann model. 17 The results of Maciel and Sindorf show that, for dehydrated samples, the relative apparent population of the surface geminal sites decreases from the initial value of about 15% at room temperature to a value of about 12% at 673 K. Above this temperature, there is a sharp increase in the relative population of geminal sites, which reaches a maximum of approximately 24% at 923 K and then decreases again at higher dehydration temperatures. Due to the ambiguity in literature concerning the peak assignment of geminal hydroxyls in infrared spectroscopy, and due to the quantification problems encountered in infrared spectroscopy, caused by the almost complete overlap of the free and geminal hydroxyl band, the NMR results on geminal silanols should be preferred over the infrared results. It is tempting to combine infrared and NMR results to obtain a complete picture on the distribution of isolated, vicinal and geminal hydroxyls. This exercise will be made further in this chapter.
1H NMR
Proton NMR should -in principle- be an extremely useful tool in the characterization of surface hydroxyls. Obviously, the technique is complementary to silicon NMR, since it discerns free and bridged hydroxyls and not -as silicon NMR- single and geminal hydroxyls. However, proton NMR on solid samples is encumbered by the severe broadening effects of strong ~H-~H magnetic dipolar interactions. If these effects are not too large, because of the large ~H-~H internuclear distances and/or fast motional averaging, then sharp ~H NMR resonances can often be achieved by magicangle-spinning (MAS). For systems in which ~H-1H dipolar line broadening effects are large (> 20 kHz), another approach is required, using either extremely fast MAS or multiple-pulse line-narrowing techniques.
108 Although the CRAMPS technique (Combined Rotation and Multiple-Pulse Spectroscopy) was developed in the 1970's z3'u'~ it lasted up to 1988 before Bronnimann ~ was able to produce well resolved IH NMR spectra of the silica surface. Bronnimann's technique was further developed by Haukka and co-workers 27'28in 1993. The ~H MAS NMR spectra resemble infrared spectra: one broad peak is attributed to hydrogen bonded silanols and one sharper peak to the isolated silanols. As in infrared, it is very difficult to derive the exact line shapes on a theoretical basis. Therefore, Haukka derived the line shapes for simulating the spectra empirically from the best fit to the data. It can be seen from figure 5.12 that in the end two curves were used to simulate both the free and bridged hydroxyl contribution. The intensity of the 1H MAS NMR spectra was calibrated to a weight loss experiment in which the amount of water lost on heating under vacuum at 450 K for 12 h was determined.
.~ISOLAT'ED I.q OHInm 2
siMut~rtON
......
!. . . . . . . . . . . .
i0.00
8.00
! ..........
6.00
:. . . . . .
4.00
~ .........
2.00
'-. . . . . . . . .
0.00
! .........
-2.00
!.,L,~
-4.00
PPM
Figure 5.12 1H MAS NMR spectrum of untreated, dried silica EPIO; taken from ref. (2 7) with permission.
109 The quantitative results of the 1H MAS NMR experiments on air-heated silica are shown in table 5.4 and are visualized in figure 5.13. The values for the total number of hydroxyl groups are somewhat higher than the values obtained by Zhuravlev (cfr. chapter 4). Zhuravlev used the deuterio-exchange method, stating that this method is advantageous in that only surface groups enter into the reaction of isotopic exchange and that structural water inside the silica particles does not. NMR on the other hand is a bulk method, measuring all OH groups present. Table 5.4 Numbers of different OH groups/nm 2 of silica EPIO determined by IH MAS NMR
Heat treatment temperature (K)
Total no. of OH groups/nm 2
Isolated OH groups/nm 2
H - b o n d e dOH groups/nm 2
473 723 833 1023 1093
6.5 4.1 2.1 1.1 1.1
1.9 2.0 1.6 1.1 1.1
4.6 2.1 0.5
3 TPD-models
Pyridine desorption
TPD is the acronym for temperature programmed desorption, which is one of the most widely used techniques for analyzing the sorption properties of porous adsorbents. Pyridine is desorbed from the silica gel surface in a two-stage desorption process, figure 5.14. The two peaks appear at 333-363 K and 423-453 K, indicating that two different adsorption/desorption sites exist on the silica gel surface. Since pyridine is adsorbed on both types of hydroxyl groups, the two adsorption sites are the isolated and the vicinal hydroxyl groups.
110
Silanol number (OI-llm2) 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
0 4OO
I
I
I
I
I
500
600
700
800
900
I
1000
II00
Temperature (K)
Figure 5.13 Numbers of different OH groups/nm 2 of silica EPIO determined by 1H MAS NMR (Haukka model).
An energetic evaluation of the two adsorption sites is possible using the formula proposed by Cvetanovic and Amenomiya: 29 2 In T,. - In p =
Rr.
+C
Tm is the temperature at the maximum desorption rate of a certain adsorption site and is the heating rate (K/min) of the TPD experiment. Activation energies of the desorption are obtained by linear regression of (2 In Tm - In/3) v s . 1 / T m. The two different adsorption sites exhibit two different activation energies of desorption (figure 5.15). The activation energies of both sites demonstrate a small linear increase as a function of the pretreatment temperature of the silica gel, featuring a constant energy gap (ca. 30 kJ mol~). The levels of activation energy are located at ca. 60 and ca. 90 kJ mol -~. Since desorption of pyridine from a free hydroxyl group requires a higher activation energy than the desorption from bridged hydroxyls, 8 the high-energy sites are assigned to the free hydroxyl groups. The analysis, using the simple formula of Cvetanovic and Amenomiya, only yields average data on the desorption energy.
111
x 10-2 DTG (m~s) _
_
-5-
-I0 -15 -20 -25 -30 273
373
473 573 6~73 773 873 Temperature (K)
973 1073
Figure 5.14 Representative derivative thermograms (DTG) of pyridine desorption from silica gel surface. Pretreatment temperatures: 578 K (1); 668 K (2); 1073 K (3). In a real system, the desorption Gillis-D'Hamers has evaluated variable heating rate method, estimates Ed as a function of experimental data.
energy (E,t) is dependent on the coverage. Therefore, the surface heterogeneity by the constant coverage, developed by Richards and Rees. 3~ This method coverage by the least-squares minimization of the
The calculation of the activation energy is based on the approximation of the following integral equation, resulting from the combination of the Arrhenius equation and the formula for a kinetic desorption process: ~
-f00a00 -
,
f exp - Ea dT
with 0 = coverage, 13 = heating rate, T = temperature and A = a constant. Calculations are not straightforward but are discussed in detail in the references. 7'3~ The final results are presented in figure 5.16.
112
Ed (kJ/mol) 110 -t-
90 +
+ _......__..-------= __..4,,-----------+--+
+
+
70
50
30
I
373
473
I
573
I
I
673 773 Temperature (K)
I
873
I
973
1073
Figure 5.15 Activation energies of desorption at two different surface sites as a function of pretreatment temperature, resulting from the formula Cvetanovic and Amenomiya,'m site 1; + site 2.
The energy curves of silica gel pretreated at high temperatures (figure 5.16) exhibit a constant Ea as a function of coverage. This is consistent with the previous models" silica gel, treated at 1073 K, consists only of free hydroxyls. It is noticeable that the desorption energy for a silica treated at 1073 K ( - 9 0 kJ mol -~) is consistent with the Cvetanovic and Amenomiya model (figure 5.15), also predicting a desorption energy of about 90 kJ mol -~ for the desorption of pyridine from free silanols. The Ea(0) curves of the lower pretreatment temperatures show a significant drop in activation energy with increasing coverages. This is assigned to the pyridinedesorption from bridged silanols. The Cvetanovic and Amenomiya model already showed a distinct energy gap for the two processes. Coverages approaching one show gradually increasing E~ values (figure 5.16). At a high coverage of pyridine, interaction between the adsorbed pyridine molecules can influence the desorption from the hydroxylic sites, resulting in higher Ed values. Steric repulsions are possible between adjacent molecules. 3~
113
130
110 "..
";
90
-... " ~
..~
~" 7o
_
~
"...
50
,
/,:1
~
../
"". ".
~
.~
....9 ~." ... ....... .''~,/~
30
0
'
0.25
's
O. 0
coverage (arb. units)
'
0.75
t
I j
1.00
Figure 5.16 Activation energies of pyridine desorption as a function of coverage at different pretreatment temperatures. ( 0 ) 503; (<>) 638; (~) 823; (~I') 1073 K.
Based upon the inflection points of the E~(0) curves in figure 5.16, a relative coverage of free and bridged silanols can be calculated. 7 These results are shown in figure 5.17. Adapting these relative coverages to the total hydroxyl content as a function of temperature, yields the absolute numbers of figure 5.18. Although the calculations involved in this TPD model are very tedious and timeconsuming, the results can be considered as highly reliable, since they are based on the evaluation of desorption energies.
114 Relative density 1.0
+/~~.,~'~
-
0.8
I).4_
~
0.2-
~
473
I
I
573
I
67~ 773 "remperature (K)
I
873
I
973
1073
Figure 5.17 Relative coverages of the two adsorption sites: relative density of free (m) and bridged (+) OH groups as a function of pretreatment temperature of silica gel. (TPD of pyridine) Number of OI-I/nm2
5-
i 0/
473
I
573
i
673
i
I
773 873 Temperature (K)
973
1073
Figure 5.18 Absolute number (OH/nm 2) offree (+) and bridged OH (*) groups on the silica gel surface as a function of pretreatment temperature. (TPD of pyridine)
115
Water desorption The same procedures and calculations, described in the previous section on pyridine desorption, can be applied to the natural desorption of water from silica as a function of temperature. 32 The thermogram of silica (figure 5.19) shows two distincts areas. Water desorption in the region (298-423 K) is due to a dehydration process, desorption in the region (423-1173 K) is due to a dehydroxylation process. The desorption energies of both processes can be estimated by the Cvetanovic and Amenomiya formula. 29 The results are shown in figure 5.20. The activation energy obtained from the dehydration (303-423 K) is almost constant and independent of the average pore diameter. The latent vaporization heat of water is fairly comparable (~Hv = 40.9 kJ mol-1). 33 In approximation of the applied formula, the desorption of adsorbed water can be depicted as a vaporization of liquid water out of the silica gel pores. The condensation of two hydroxyl groups with water and a siloxane bridge as a result, will consequently demand higher average activation energies. The estimated activation energy of water desorption is also presented in figure 5.20. A linear dependence with pore diameter is observed. The intermolecular distance, directly dependent on the curvature of the pores, i.e. the average pore diameter, is linearly related to the activation energy for dehydroxylation. Extrapolation to smaller pores suggests activation energies of approximately 100 kJ mol 1 for dehydroxylation of hydroxyl groups in e.g. zeolite channels, if the hydroxyls are of a comparable type. Rees published corresponding activation energies for water desorption in dealuminated Y-zeolites.34 An evaluation of the functional dependence of the activation energy on coverage is performed with the constant coverage, variable heating method of Richards and Rees. 3~ The results are shown in figure 5.21. In this figure, the relative coverage 0 (x-axis) is replaced by the silanol number (Oton).
116
100 99
Weight (%) _
98 97 96 95 94 93 92 91 90 273
373 473 573 643 773 S'73 973 10:73 1173 Temperature (K)
Figure 5.19 Thermogram of a fully hydroxylated silica. 1 = TGA; 2= DTG.
160
Ed / kJ mol-1
120
80
40
02
:k._
lb
Pore diameter/ nm
14
Figure 5.20 Average activation energies for water desorption originating from dehydration (+) and dehydroxylation (a) respectively.
117 Gillis-D'Hamers has discerned three different linear sections in figure 5.21. The sharp decrease in Ed at the higher silanol numbers is assigned to a transition process between dehydration and dehydroxilation. The middle section of the Ed curve is assigned to the condensation of bridged hydroxyls and the high region to the condensation of free hydroxyls. Both rectilinear parts of a Ed(aOH) curve are related to a hydroxyl type. Hence, if a linear regression is performed individually on both linear sections of the Ed curve, the intercept of both linear functions reveals the transition of the dehydroxylation between the free and bridged hydroxyls. The resulting silanol number of the point of intersection exposes the relative presence of free and bridged hydroxyls groups on a fully hydroxylated silica gel surface. Multiplication with the silanol number yields absolute data on the silanol distribution (figure 5.22).
Ed/kJ mol-1
350 300
%
%
250 200 150
%
%
100 50 0
o
i
:3
OH/nm 2
Figure 5.21 Ea(OH)plot of fully hydroxylated silica.
'4
118 A remarkable feature of this model is the fact that this is the first model, discussed so far, that proposes a dehydroxylation behaviour of silica, dependent on the porosity of the sample. Whereas the total silanol number is a constant (the Zhuravlev constant), the relative distribution of free and bridged silanols is not. We will see in the next chapter that-in fact- the particle size is a determining factor in the dehydroxylation behaviour of silica.
Silanol number (OI-I/nm2) 6 5 4 3 2 1
0 373
I
I
473
573
I
I
673 773 Temperature (K)
873
973
Figure 5.22 Hydroxyl population with temperature of silica gel Kieselgel 60. OH; * bridged OH (Gillis-D'Hamers model).
1~3
c~OH; 9 + free
4 Zhuravlev's model In 1993, L.T. Zhuravlev 35 published a review article of work performed in the former USSR on the surface characterization of amorphous silica. This review article is a very important document in the study of the silanol distribution. Also, the energetical aspects of the dehydration and dehydroxylation processes are discussed in detail. The determination of the silanol number as a function of treatment temperature has already been discussed in chapter 4.
119
Silanol distribution The components of the silanol number (free and bridged hydroxyls) were determined by the deuterium exchange method and infrared spectroscopic measurements. 36 Zhuravlev noticed that the intensity of the adsorption band of the free hydroxyl groups increases in the temperature interval from 473 to 673 K, while above this temperature, the intensity decreases. The correlation between the silanol number at 673 K and the intensity of the infrared absorption band is based on the fact that for the samples calcined in vacuo at 673 K, there are practically only free hydroxyl groups. This means that the total concentration of silanol groups on the silica surface at 673 K corresponds to the concentration of free hydroxyl groups. The concentration of the free hydroxyl groups on the silica surface was calculated from the absorption coefficient of OH groups on the surface, treated at temperatures above 673 K. The concentration of bridged groups and the concentration of siloxane bridges throughout the range of temperatures was determined from the total concentration of OH groups and the concentration of free OH groups. The results are presented in figure 5.23. The total disappearance of bridged hydroxyls at 673 K, as predicted by this model, may seem a bit peculiar at first sight. Some of the discussed models propose 773 K or even 873 K as the upper limit for the presence of bridged silanols. It should therefore be stressed that the model, presented in figure 5.23 is based upon a treatment of silica in vacuo. Dependent on external factors such as air humidity and operating conditions, a similar treatment in ambient air may cause a shift in the dehydroxylation of 100 to even 200 K.
Desorption energies The way in which Zhuravlev determined the desorption energies for the dehydration and dehydroxylation process is very similar to the model of Gillis-D'Hamers.
120
a O H (# / rim9 _
3210 373
I
473
573
673 773 873 Temperature (K)
!
973 1073
Figure 5.23 Distribution of the silanol types as a function of temperature (in vacuo) according to Zhuravlev. 9total OH; + free OH," * bridged OH; o siloxanes.
The most important difference is that Zhuravlev's model was not based on the constant coverage method of Richards and Rees, but on the difference-differential method of Freemann and Carrol. 37'3g The results are shown in figure 5.24 (as a function of treatment temperature) and in figure 5.25 (as a function of surface coverage). The results are fairly comparable with the results of Gillis-D'Hamers. Zhuravlev discerns two linear sections. In the case of the high coverage (1 > 0o. > 0.5) the main process is the dehydroxylation of bridged silanols. The desorption energy is almost independent of the silanol concentration and is mainly determined by a set of perturbations due to hydrogen bonded OH groups. In other words, this subregion is characterized by the presence of lateral interactions (= hydrogen bonds) between the neighbouring OH groups. In the low coverage subregion (0 < 0.5), the main role is played by free hydroxyl groups and siloxane bridges. For this subregion, Ed is strongly dependent on the concentration of hydroxyl groups. When there are only free hydroxyl groups, surrounded by siloxane bridges, the latter groups can acquire a relatively large area following high temperature treatment of silica.
121
250
Ed ~ / mol)
200
150 1130
i Y
50
i73 673 Temperature (K)
273
S73
Figure 5.24 Activation energy of water desorption, Ea as a function of temperature.
Ed O0 / too1) 300
200
100 Free OH 012
0'.4 0'.6 0~8 Surface coverage
1.q
Figure 5.25 Activation energy of water desorption, Ea as a function of the surface concentration of OH groups.
Under these conditions the main mechanism describing the transfer of OH groups corresponds to condensation via disordered migration of protons on the surface (a process of the activated diffusion of OH groups). At the final stage, water is evolved, owing to the interaction of two OH groups that accidentally approach each other to a
122 distance of about 0.3 nm. The mechanism describing the migration of protons is not entirely clear. It probably involves the interaction of the protons with oxygen atoms which are adjacent to the siloxane bridges, resulting in the formation of new surface OH groups, which are displaced relative to their initial position. In other words, this mechanism can be represented as the transition from one local minimum of the potential energy into another by means of 'jumps' between the neighbouring siloxane bridges. Obviously, at a low concentration of OH groups such a diffusion of protons along the surface will limit the condensation process.
5 Comparison and conclusion The distribution of the free silanols as a function of pretreatment temperature according to the different models is shown in figure 5.26. The model of Maciel and Sindorf is not included, since it makes no distinction between free and bridged silanols. This model will be used later on to distinguish free (single) and free (geminal) hydroxyls. As a reference, we have taken Zhuravlev's values, with an error region of +__ 0 . 5 0 H / n m 2. This was the error Zhuravlev found for the total silanol distribution (cfr. chapter 4). It can be inferred from figure 5.26 that almost all models are situated in this error region. The model of Van Der Voort underestimates the free silanols in the low temperature region. As explained previously, this is due to a large infrared overlap of the free and bridged silanols (figure 5.2). Also the free hydroxyl band shift model of GillisD'Hamers shows anomalous results in the low temperature region, which is most probably caused by a strong interference of geminal hydroxyls in this temperature region. The reader is reminded that Gillis-D'Hamers has neglected the existence of geminal hydroxyls in his algorithms. These results are presented in figure 5.27, showing the absolute distribution of the three silanol types on the silica surface as a function of temperature. The absolute concentration of the free silanols increases in the low temperature region, due to dehydroxylation processes of bridged silanols (reaction 5.1). A distribution of isolated (free), vicinal (bridged) and geminal (free) hydroxyls can be obtained when Zhuravlev's model is corrected with the results of Maciel and Sindorf. Practically, this means that the free hydroxyl curve of Zhuravlev is decomposed in
123 single (free) and geminal (free) hydroxyls, taking into account the ratios of Maciel and Sindorf (figure 5.11).
Free silanol number (OI-l/nm2) 3.0 2.5
.............!:!:!~i~ii:i::::!ii:ii i:: : ::!!ii"::::iii!iii!!i!!!!iiiiiii:!iiiii!i!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~
2.0
.......................................................................................:~
1.5
1.0 ti ~~~.,j
0.5
473
573
673
I
I
773 873 Temperature (K)
973
1073
Figure 5.26 Free silanol distribution: survey of the different models. 9Van Der Voort (IR integration.); + Fink (IR deconvolution); * Zhuravlev; [] GillisD 'Hamers (pyridine); x Gillis D 'Hamers (FOH shift); (> Gillis D 'Hamers (H20 desorption); 1H NMR model.
At higher temperatures (> 673 K) the free silanols start to condense. This process is relatively slow, since a certain proton mobility is required. At low concentrations of hydroxyl groups, such an activated diffusion of protons along the surface strongly limits the condensation process. The absolute concentration of the geminal silanols decreases over the entire temperature region, but also very slowly. Since geminal hydroxyls may be considered as a special form of free hydroxyls, their condensation is limited by the same factors. The bridged silanols condense very quickly and disappear completely after a treatment in vacuo at 673 K. The suggested distribution of the silanol types as a function of temperature is numerically presented in table 5.5.
124
Silanol number (OI-I/nn/)
!
473
573
Figure 5.27 In vacuo. vicinal silanols.
673
773 873 Temperature (K)
973
1073
9total hydroxyls; + geminal silanols; * isolated silanols;
Table 5.5 Concentration of the different silanol types, as a function of treatment temperature in vacuo
Temperature (K)
Total OH (OH/nm 2)
Isolated OH (OH/nm 2)
Vicinal OH (OH/nm 2)
Geminal OH (OH/nm2)
473 573 673 773 873 973 1073
4.60 3.55 2.35 1.80 1.50 1.15 0.70
1.15 1.65 2.05 1.55 1.30 0.90 0.60
2.85 1.40 0 0 0 0 0
0.60 0.50 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.25 0.10
125
References
P. Van Der Voort, I. Gillis-D'Hamers and E.F. Vansant, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1990, 86, 3751, 0
P. Van Der Voort, I. Gillis-D'Hamers, K.C. Vranken and E.F. Vansant, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1992, 88, 723. D.A. Gardella, D.Z. Jiang, and E.M. Eyring, Appl. Spectrosc., 1983, 37, 131.
.
D.E. Leyden, R.S. Shreedhara, J.P. Blitz, and J.B. Atwater, Microchem. Acta Wien, 1988, II, 53.
.
.
0
.
.
0
D. Gorski, E. Klemm, P. Fink, and H. H6rhold, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 126, 445. I. Gillis-D'Hamers, P. Van Der Voort, P. De Hulsters and E.F. Vansant, A high resolution FTIR-PAS study of the free hydroxyl group on the silica gel surface, in Proc. Int. Workshop on FTIR, ed. E.F. Vansant, U.I.A., Wilrijk, 1990. I. Gillis-D'Hamers, K.C. Vrancken, E.F. Vansant and G. De Roy, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1992, 88, 2047. P. Fink, H. Hobert and G. Rudakoff, Wiss. Ztschr. F.S.U., 1987, R36, 581. (in German) J.B. Peri and A.L. Hensley, J. Phys. Chem., 1968, 72, 2936.
10.
B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1465.
11.
F.M. Van Cauwelaert, P. Jacobs and J.B. Uytterhoeven, J. Phys. Chem., 1970, 76, 1434.
12.
H.P. Boehm and H. Kn6zinger, Catalysis-Science and Technology, Vol 4 Eds. J.R. Andersen and M. Boudart (Springer, Berlin, 1984).
13.
B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 1998.
14.
B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1975, 79, 761.
15.
B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 1995.
16.
B.A. Morrow, I.A. Cody and L.S.M. Lee, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 2761.
17.
P. Hoffmann and E. Kn/Szinger, Surface Science, 1987, 188, 181.
126 18.
J. Sauer and K.P. Scr6der Z. Phys. (Leipzig), 1985, 266, 379.
19.
R. West and R.H. Baney, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1959, 81, 6145.
20.
G.I. Harris, J. Chem. Soc., 1963, 5978.
21.
D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Phys. Chem., 1983, 105, 1487.
22.
G.E. Maciel and D.W. Sindorf, J. Phys. Chem., 1983, 87, 5516.
23.
J.S. Waugh, L.M Huber and U. Haeberlen, Phys. Rev. Lett., 1968, 20, 180.
24.
B.C. Gerstein, C. Chou, R.G. Pembleton and R.C. Wilson, J. Phys. Chem., 1977, 81,565.
25.
B. Schnabel, U. Haubenreisser, G. Scheler and R. Muller in Proceedings 19~ Congress Ampere, H. Brunner, K.H. Hauser and D. Schweitzer ed., Heiselberg, 1976.
26.
C. Bronnimann, R.G. Zeigler and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Soc. 1988, 110, 2023.
27.
S. Haukka, E. Lakomaa and A. Root, J. Phys. Chem., 1993, 97, 5058.
28.
S. Haukka and A. Root, J. Phys. Chem., 1994, 98, 1695.
29.
R.V. Cvetanovic and Y. Amenomiya, Adv. Catal., 1967, 17, 103.
30.
R.E. Richards and L.V.C. Rees, Zeolites, 1986, 6, 17.
31.
F. Duprat and G. Gau, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 1990, 29, 1424.
32.
I. Gillis-D'Hamers, PhD-thesis, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, 1993.
33.
R.C. Weast, Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, CRC-press, 1984, p. D-47.
34.
E. Dima and L.V.C. Rees, Zeolites, 1987, 7, 219.
35.
L.T. Zhuravlev, Colloids and Surfaces A: physicochemical and engineering aspects, 1993, 74, 71.
36.
A.A. Agzamkhodzhaev, G.A. Galkin and L.T. Zhuravlev, in M.M. Dubidin and V.V. Serpinsky (Ms.), Main Problems of Physical Adsorption Theory, Nauka, Moscow, 1970. Proc. All-Union Conf., Moscow, 1968.
37.
E.S. Freemann and B. Carrol, J. Phys. Chem., 1958, 62, 394.
38.
D.A. Anderson and E.S. Freemann, J. Polym. Sci., 1961, 54, 253.
127
Chapter 6 The effect of surface morphology on the d e h y d r o x y l a t i o n behaviour
In the previous chapter, it was concluded that the silanol number (i.e. the total concentration of silanol groups on the silica surface, expressed in OH/nm 2) can be considered as a physicochemical constant, within certain margins of error (+ 0.5 OH/nm2). Examining the dehydroxylation behaviour of various silica structures in more detail, small differences in the dehydroxylation rate can be observed. Gillis-D'Hamers ~ has calculated the dehydroxylation energies (E~(OH)) of silica gels with varying porosity (cfr. chapter 5). The Ea(OH) curves as a function of the silanol number are presented in figure 6.1. In this figure, KG 40 and KG 60 are the acronyms for Kieselgel 40 and 60, which are silica gels obtained from Merck with an average Wheeler pore diameter of 2.1 nm and 3.6 nm respectively. The abcis of the figure can be converted to treatment temperature, using the data in table 5.5 (Chapter 5). For instance, the silanol region 4 - 5 0 H / n m z corresponds to a treatment temperature of 373 -573 K. It is obvious from figure 6.1 that there is no difference in desorption energies in the silanol region from 0 to 4 0 H / n m 2, confirming Zhuravlev's statement that the silanol number can be considered as a physicochemical constant.
128
Desorption energies (kJ/mol)
350
1001
~176
150-
0[ 0
I
I
1
I
I
2 3 4 Silanol number (OI-I]nm2)
I
5
Figure 6.1. Water desorption energies as a function of the silanol number for Kieselgel 40 (o) and Kieselgel 60 (0).
In the high silanol region, the KG 40 seems to dehydroxylate a little easier. This silanol region corresponds to a thermal treatment at 373 - 573 K, suggesting that in the very early stages of dehydroxylation, the surface morphology has a small impact on the rate of water desorption. However, quite contradictory conclusions have been drawn in literature concerning the dehydroxylation as a function of porosity. Snyder 2 stated that the relative ratio of free to bridged silanols is closely related to the pore diameter. He claimed that the surface of a wide pore is comparable to crystalline silica, and will therefore contain more free silanols. Dzis'ko et al. 3 found that smaller pores undergo slower dehydroxylation, whereas Bakyrdzhiev 4 reported that dehydroxylation occurs at lower temperature in smaller pores. In order to comprehend and explain these different statements, it is essential to consider the actual physical reason for bridged silanol condensation. The dehydroxylation of bridged silanols is mainly determined by the strength of the hydrogen bonding. The closer the vicinal hydroxyls, the stronger the hydrogen bonding, resulting in a greater stability towards dehydroxylation.
129 It is obvious that pore size (especially pore diameter) plays an important role in the spacing of the bridged silanols. Smaller pores exhibit a more negative radius of curvature, as shown in figure 6.2. This negative radius causes a decrease in the intersilanol distance, and thus a strengthening of the hydrogen bonding. This is reflected in a slower dehydroxylation behaviour.
i::~:, i::~::.
Figure 6.2.
H
H
H
H
H
:~il ....~::i
Stabilizing effect of small pore radii on the hydroxyl spacing.
However, the experimental data of figure 6.1 show exactly the opposite: the bridged silanols of Kieselgel 40 (smaller pores) condense more readily than the ones of Kieselgel 60. In view of this apparent contradiction, supported by the ambiguity in literature, one must conclude that the pore size cannot be the only parameter, influencing the relative distance between the vicinal silanols. Another factor must be involved, causing the destabilization of the bridged silanols in Kieselgel 40. Microscopically, a silica (gel) can be considered as a cluster of primary particles. The pores can be regarded as open spaces between these particles. The particle size itself has a destabilizing effect on the bridged silanols (figure 6.3). Smaller particles exhibit a more positive radius of curvature, resulting in an increase of the intersilanol distance. Precise data on the primary particle size of the silica gels could not be obtained from the manufacturer. Fortunately, particle size can be estimated, based on theoretical considerations.
130
H
H
H
H
H ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::.
Figure 6.3 Destabilizing effect of small particle sizes on the hydroxyl spacing.
It was pointed out in chapter 1 that Sheinfain's globular theory 5 allows an estimation of the average primary particle size if the specific surface area is known, a according to
S -
3 a.p
(1)
with S the specific surface area (m2/g), a the primary particle radius (nm) and p the density (2.2"106 g/m3). Putting the specific surface areas of 400 m2/g and 610 m2/g (cfr. chapter 2) for Kieselgel 60 and 40 in equation 1, one obtains primary particle diameters of 6.8 and 4.5 nm respectively. This means that Kieselgel 40 consists of considerably smaller primary particles, explaining the destabilization of the bridged silanols.
The loss in surface area upon aggregation, according to equation 2 (chapter 1) can be neglected if the particle radius R > > adsorbate radius a.
131 References
I. Gillis-D'Hamers, PhD-thesis, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, 1993. ~
~
~
~
L.R. Snyder, Principles of adsorption chromatography, Dekker, New York, 1967. V.A. Dzis'ko, A.A. Vishnevskaya and V.S. Chesalova, Zh. Fiz. Khim., 1950, 24, 1416. I. Bakyrdzhiev, Dokl. Acad. Nauk. SSSR, 1966, 168, 618. R.Yu. Sheinfain, N.S. Kruglikova, O.P. Stas and I.E. Neimark, Kolloid Zhur., 1963, 25, 732.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
133
Chapter 7 Related Materials : Silicates
Most of our understanding of silicate structures comes from studies of the many naturally occurring or synthetic silicates. As for silica, the basic unit of the structure is the SiO 4 tetrahedron. These tetrahedra occur singly or by sharing oxygen atoms, in small groups, in small cyclic groups, in infinite chains, in infinite sheets or in structures enclosing cavities or channels.
1 Simple orthosilicates A few silicates are known in which there are simple, discrete orthosilicate, SiO44In such components, the associated cations are coordinated by the oxygen atoms, and various structures are found depending on the coordination number of the cations. There are a number of compounds of the type M2SiO4, where M 2§ is Mg 2§ Fe 2§ Mn 2§ or some other cation with a preferred coordination number of 6, in which the SiO44- anions are arranged to provide an interaction with six oxygen atoms in an anions.
octahedron symmetry. 2 Other discrete, noncyclic silicate anions The simplest of the condensed silicate anions are formed by combining two or more SiO4 tetrahedra by sharing oxygen atoms. The pyrosilicate anion, in thortveitite
(Sc2Si207) and hemimorphite (Zna(OH)2Si207).
Si2076-, is present
134 3 Cyclic silicate anions
The structures of two such cyclic ions, 5i3096 and Si601812-, are shown schematically in figure 7.1. The general formula for any such ion is SinO3~n-. The ion 5i3096" forms the structure of benitoite (BaTiSi309).
0-o "
=Si
Figure 7.1 Examples of cyclic silicate anions. 4 Inf'mite chain anions
These are of two main types" the pyroxenes, which contain single-strand chains of composition (SiO32-)n (figure 7.2) and the amphiboles, which contain double-strand, cross-linked chains or bands of composition (Si4O116-)n.
Figure 7. 2 A linear chain silicate anion.
Examples of pyroxenes are enstatite (MgSiO3), diopside [CaMg(SiO3)2], and spodumene [LiAI(SiO3)2]. A typical amphibole is tremolite Ca2Mgs(Si40~)2(OH)2.
135 5 Infinite sheet anions
When SiO 4 tetrahedra are linked into infinite two-dimensional networks as shown in figure 7.3, the empirical formula for the anions is (SiOsZ-)n. Many silicates have sheet structures with sheets bound together by cations that lie between them.
Figure 7.3 Sheet silicate anion structure idealized. 6 Minerals
The next logical extension in the progression above from simple SiO4 4- ions to larger and more complex structures would be to three-dimensional structures in which each oxygen is shared between two tetrahedra. The empirical formula for such a substance is simply (SiO2)n. However, if some silicon atoms in such a three-dimensional framework structure are replaced by aluminium, the frame must be negatively charged and neutralized by cations. Aluminosilicates of these type are clays and many zeolites.
136 6.1 Clays
Clays are aluminosilicates with a two-dimensional or layered structure including the common sheet 2:1 alumino- and magnesium- silicates (montmorillonite, hectorite, micas, vermiculites) (figure 7.4) and 1:1 minerals (kaolinites, chlorites). These materials swell in water and polar solvents, up to the point where there remains no mutual interaction between the clay sheets. After dehydration below 393 K, the clay can be restored in its original state, however dehydration at higher temperatures causes irreversible collapse of the structure in the sense that the clay platelets are electrostatically bonded by dehydrated cations and exhibit no adsorption.
Mr~. xH20
Figure 7. 4 The cross-linked structure of a 2:1 layer lattice silicate. Oxygen atoms in the central two planes link the octahedral sheet with the tetrahedral sheets. Metal ions in the octahedral and tetrahedral positions are not shown.
Pillared clays Pillared clays or in general pillared interlayered compounds have a virtually constant distance between the layers and therefore interlayer space. It is probably the most interesting group of new stable micro- and meso-porous materials available for adsorption and separation applications (figure 7.5). The great diversity of layered compounds and pillar combinations so far used in PILC synthesis were recently reviewed by Vaughan. ~ Pillared interlayered compounds are prepared by swelling the layered compounds in water or by amine intercalation and the exchanging of the
137 interlayer cations or anions with a large polymeric inorganic cation or anion. After filtration, washing and drying, a calcination at about 773 K is required to cross-link the pillars with the layers (figure 7.6). The overall process is quite complicated and can be tuned according to the utilization of the material.
i~o~O day" sweOOing
dehydraltion
b~\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\NNNN\\NN\\\"x\X~
~ ~~~
o~
~ - ~ ~ _
~KK';KK';~KK~-;';K'~';KK';'~i
~\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'q
~N\\\\NN\\NN\\\N\\~ ~\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\~
,:.:.:.:.-.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:
~\~,,NN\\\\\\\\\\\\~
~NN\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\~
D iiiiiiii ii',iiiii /ii~,i',ii~Hiii,',i', ~ ~\\\\\\NN\\\\\\\\\~
PiO0~~l cll~y dimensien~J 9 s~s~biOi~ 9
9
Figure 7. 5 Swelling effects in normal clay and dimensional stability in pillared clays. 6. 2 Zeolites Since their discovery more than a century ago, many studies on zeolite minerals have been carried out. Moreover, in the late 1940's the preparation of synthetic zeolites was the start of a large range of zeolitic materials reflecting the complete range of framework substituted tectosilicate including phosphates. From their structural formula nx M n+[(At0~)~ (Si02)y ] wH20
138 I
12_-
I
micropore !_ m
"
m
1
mesopore
Figure 7. 6 Schematic representation of pores in pillared clays. adsorption and ion exchange properties were recognized as their specific characteristics. The possibility of zeolites to adsorb molecules of relative small size over molecules of larger size formed the basis for the introduction of the term molecular sieves. The first generation of zeolites (1940-1950) reflects the zeolites with low silica to alumina ratios (SIO2/A1203 -< 10), prepared from a crystallization of reactive aluminosilicate gels with alkali and alkaline earth metal hydroxides. Such zeolites are characterized by a high ion-exchange capacity, an extremely hydrophilic surface and many acid sites with a wide variety of acid strength. Such frameworks show different thermal and hydrothermal stability, depending on structural and compositional factors. Typical zeolites are zeolite A, X, Y, chabazite, erionite, mordenite (figures 7.7 and
7.8).
139
a
b
l <
d
(3
Figure 7. 7. Schematic representation showing framework structures of (a) zeolite A, (b) zeolites X and Y, (c) erionite and (d) chabazite. --
10--
9
--
8
--
(C4Fg)3N
(C4Hg)3N (C2Fs)2NC3F~
7
--
6
--
--
-
--
Neupentanc C04 SF6 l~butane
5
CF4 __CF2CI2 - -
Cyclopropane
-Xe _ ._.____._N2, --0~__
t
H2
z
x
2
"E
Zeohte
-~
<
<
pore size (A)
S02
Ar
NH3
--
Propane
CO,CH4 Kr
CI2 i.120
<
o(A)
Figure 7. 8. Chart showing the correlation between effective pore size of various zeolites and the Lennard-Jones kinetic diameter.
140 The second generation of zeolites were prepared by using all possible quaternary ammonium ions and resulted in many new materials with new structure and different chemical compositions. More in particular, aluminosilicates with SIO2/A1203 - 20 were synthesized, out of which ZSM-5 became the most prominent (1960-1970) (figure 7.9). ZSM-11
ZSM-5
LEllipticalstraight channels (5.1 x 5.6~.)
Near c i r c u l a r channels (5.4 x 5.6~.1
Figure 7.9 Schematic representation showing the framework of ZSM-5 and ZSM-11. The extensive size of organic amine as structure-directing templates or pore filling agents, coupled with a new gel chemistry resulted in the discovery of a third generation of zeolites containing A13§ and ps+ as lattice atoms (1982). These aluminophosphate materials are a family of molecular sieves as shown in figure 7.10. In order to improve the performance of zeolites as molecular sieves, several modification techniques were developed to vary in a controlled way the zeolitic pore system: pore size engineering. In practice, pore size engineering in zeolites can be the result of a (a) modification by cation exchange process; (b) modification by a preadsorption of polar molecules; (c) modification of the zeolitic framework.
(a) Modification by a cation exchange processz'3 Changing the cations in a zeolite may effectively enlarge the pore openings by diminishing the cation population and/or a resiting of cations which are normally located near these openings. In the zeolite A, divalent ion exchange opens the
141
since 1982" AIPO4-n
since 1984" SAPO-n
since 1985" MeAPO-n
(Me, Al, P)O2 Me-- Mg, Mn, Fe Co, Zn
L. since 1985"
E1APO-n (El, AI, P),O El- Li, Be ,,, As, Ga, Ge, Ti
(Si, Al, P)O2
since 1985" MeAPSO-n (Me, Al, P, Si)O 2
E1APSO-n El, A1, P, Si)O Z
Figure 7.10 The aluminophosphate-based molecular sieves. aperture to full diameter, whereas exchange with a larger univalent ion diminishes the aperture size. The pore size reduction does not occur gradually with increasing extent of exchange but rather suddenly. Also, an increase in the adsorption can be observed by a calcium exchange in NaA and again it does not occur in a linear fashion but rather abruptly. Similar effects are exhibited by the zeolites mordenite, chabazite, zeolite X and offretite.
(b) Modification by a preadsorption of polar molecules 4 Another method for altering the molecular sieving effect of a zeolite is the preadsorption of polar molecules. If small amounts of polar molecules, such as water or ammonia, are preadsorbed in a dehydrated zeolite, the adsorption of a second absorbate can be drastically reduced. It is assumed that the strong interactions between the zeolite cation and the dipole moment of the polar molecules produces a diffusion block by clustering the polar molecules around the exchangeable cations in the zeolite channels.
142
(c) Modification of the zeolitic framework Pore size engineering in zeolites can also be achieved by a modification of the zeolitic framework resulting from: (1) (2)
(3)
crystallographic changes by a thermal treatment; internal and external structural modification by implantation of additional atom groups; external surface modification of the zeolite crystal (coating process).
(1) Pore size modification by crystallographic changes 5 The molecular sieve behaviour of zeolites can be controlled by a hydrolytic process at elevated temperatures. Water vapour in contact with zeolite crystals at elevated temperatures results in a variation of the zeolitic adsorption characteristics. The amount of water vapour, the pretreatment temperature and the pretreatment time, can control the effect pore size of zeolites. It appears, that a steam treatment causes a cation migration and a cation hydrolysis of the exchangeable cations. However, the effect of steam on the adsorption behaviour of zeolites is influenced by the nature of the initial exchangeable cations.
(2) Internal and external modification of the zeolite structures 6 Silane and diborane show a high reactivity towards zeolitic hydroxyl groups. Treatment of H-zeolites with silane results in a permanent change of their structural properties. The reaction scheme can be divided into" primary reaction, involving accessible zeolitic OH-groups: -Si-OH
+
Sill 4 ~
-Si-O-SiH
3 +
H2
(A)
143
secondary reactions, in which chemisorbed groups may react further with other OHgroups in the zeolite" - Si-O-SiH 3 +
HO-Si-
~
- Si-O-SiH2-O-Si-
+
H2
(B)
hydrolysis reaction, in which the chemisorbed groups (-Sill3, -Sill2-) can be hydrolyzed with water to give-Si(OH)3, -Si(OH)2- groups" -Si-O-SiH3 = Si-O-SiH2-O-Si-
+
3H20--,
--Si-O-Si(OH)3 +
+
2H20 --, - Si-O-Si(OH)2-O-Si---
(C)
3H2 +
2H 2
(D)
Any combination of reactions (A), (B) and (C) or (D) will give a ratio evolved H2/consumed Sill4 - 4. For diborane, also reactive towards surface hydroxyl groups, and because of its electron deficient character reactive towards the oxygen bridges -Si-O-Si- in the zeolite structure, the primary and secondary reactions on H-zeolites can be summarized as: 2(-Si-OH)
+
B2H 6 -,
2(-Si-O-BH
-Si \ 2
- Si-O-BH2
/
-Si
0 ~BH
+
2H 2
(E)
-Si\ O + B2H 6
,..-
2
-Si /
=--Si\
2)
+
HO-Si-
--,
O-,BH 3 _Si ~
-- S i - O - B H - O - S i
=-
+
(F)
H2
(G)
-:Si\
3
+ HO-Si =
9
~,-
-:S~
O + =Si-O-BH2 + H 2
(H)
144
Because of the reactivity of the chemisorbed groups, an hydrolysis reaction can be carded out not only with water, but also with other molecules such as CH3OH" -Si-O-BHz m Si-O-BH-O-Si m -Si-O-BHz
+
+
2HzO--,, +
-Si-O-B(OH) z +
2Hz
HzO --, =- Si-O-B(OH)-O-Si m
2CH3OH--,
-Si-O-B(OCH3) z +
(I) +
I-Iz
(j)
(K)
2H z
Similar reactions can occur with the modifying agents X~Rmwhere x = Si, B, Ge and R = H, C1, etc. Modification of zeolites, based on chemisorption of silane or diborane and subsequent hydrolysis of the chemisorbed hydride groups can also be applied for encapsulating gas molecules in zeolites. For example, krypton and xenon can be encapsulated in mordenite combining the modification process with a physical adsorption of the noble gases at moderate pressures and temperatures (e.g. 100 kPa, 300 K). The encapsulates are homogeneous and stable towards acids, mechanical grinding and ~,irradiation. By controlling the pore size reduction however, the thermal stability can be controlled. Furthermore, the implantation of various boron-nitrogen compounds inside the zeolite framework can reduce, in a controlled way, the effective pore size of zeolites. When NH 3 is added to the boranated zeolite (before hydrolysis reaction), at room temperature, the formation of amine-boranes can be detected, which changes the molecular sieving properties of the zeolite. - Si.O.BH 2
= S i - ~ H + NH3 ---Si-O"
+
NH 3 ~
(L)
~_~Si-O-BHz~NH 3
~.. =Si-QBH -Si-(~
-NH3
r
145
A gradual increase of the reaction temperature accentuates the pore-blocking effect. Depending on the reaction temperature polymeric amino-boranes (H2N--,BH2), and borazines (B3N3H6) were observed in the zeolites.
(3) External surface modification of the zeolite crystals 7'g In order to control the pore-opening size without affecting the internal pore system of the zeolite, modifications were carried out using modifying agents with a molecular size larger than that of the zeolite pores so that they can not enter the pores and interact only with the external surface. It has been shown that Si(OCH3) 4 is deposited irreversibly on the H-zeolite. The alkoxide can be deposited by reaction with surface hydroxyl groups, thus coveting the external surface of the zeolite crystal after subsequent reactions. Calcination with oxygen removes the hydrocarbon residue and produces silica-coated zeolites. The deposition of SiO2 at the external surface of the zeolite reduces the size of the pore opening without changing the internal properties of the zeolite. Similar observations were found using methyl-chlorosilanes, as modifying agents, forming silica-polymers at the external surface of the zeolites. This modification method is very useful in the field of shape-selective catalytic reactions and sorption. Depending on the degree of the SiO 2 deposition at the zeolite crystals the adsorption behaviour can be influenced. The most obvious approach to obtain controlled mesoporosity is the extension of zeolite-like three-dimensional framework structures to larger pore-sizes. Zeolite-like compounds in the micro- and mesoporous range are the aluminophosphate VPI-5, cloverite and ULP (MCM-41). These new materials are characterized by pore diameters between 1.3 nm and 20 nm.
References
D.E.W. Vaughan, Am. Chem. Soc. Symp. Ser. 368, eds. W.H. Flank and T. Wyte, American Chemical Society, Washington, 1988, 308. D
D.W. Breck, W.G. Eversole, R.M. Milton, T.B. Reed and T.L. Thomas, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1966, 78, 5963.
146
0
4. 0
0
0
0
E.F. Vansant, G. Peeters and I. Michelena, J. Chem. Res., 1978, 90, 1165. R.M. Barrer and L.V.C. Rees, Trans. Far. Soc., 1945, 10, 852. D.W. Breck, Zeolite Molecular Sieves, J. Wiley & Sons, New York, 1973, 490. E.F. Vansant, Pore Size Engineering in Zeolites, J. Wiley & Sons, 1990.
M. Niva, S. Kato, T.Hattori and Y. Marakumi, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I, 1984, 80, 3135. E.F.Vansant, P. De Bi~vre, G. Peeters, A. Thijs and I. Verhaert, Eur. Appl. Res. Rep.-Nucl. Sci. Techn., 1982, 4, 893.
~!i!~i.#..i~.~~~~~~#~~H~~~#~ i.!.i!.~i...~~ll~, ~.i.~i~i!~!i.~..i.i~..i~..i~..i.i!.~.....9.......... i!iiii!iiiiii!ili!i!ili!ii#ii•iii!i!ii!i!i •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••~M~W~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~~i~!~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~!ii!i~!iii!~i#iiiiiili~ ~i~i~i~i!i~i~ii~i~i~i~i!ii~i~iiiii~ii!i~i~i~i~ii~ii!i~i~iii~i~ii~!~iii~iiiii~iii~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~ii~!~iii~ii~i~i~i~i~iii~!~i~i~i~iii~i~i~i~i!i!i~i~i~i~ii iiii~iii~i~i~iiiiiii~i~iii~iii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iii~iiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiii~~iiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiii~i~iiiiiii~i~iiiiiii~i~i~iiii iiiiili!il
..........
iiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iii!~ii~iiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiii ili~ ~iiilii!i!ili! !ililiiiiii!iii!iiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii i!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiilliiil. . . . . . . .iilil. i!iiiii . . iiiii!iiii !i !i!i i!iii!~~iii!ilili!iiiii!iiiii!i!il i i i!i •••••••!iiiii!i!iiiiiii!ili!iiii ••••••••••••••••!!i•••!•!!i•••!•i•!•!!!~| ••••••i••i•~.••.i••.i•~•.•i.•~•.•i•.~••. . . . ........
~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiii!iii!ii~iiiii!iiiiii~iiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiii!i!iiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~!!i~iii!!ii~i!!ii~iiiiii!ii!~i!iiii!iii!~~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!ii!iiiiiiiiii~iii!iii~iiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~~~iiii~~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~!iiiii!iiiii!iii~iiiii!!iiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
~i~i~i~i~i~i~~~~~i~~~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~i~~i~i~i~i~i~i~~~i~iiijoi~iIii~iiiiii~iii~ioIi~IiIIi~i~ii~iii,ii,i~iii~iiiJiIIii,i~i,i~i~iiiii
iiii•iiiiiiiiii•iiiiiiiiiiiiii••ii~iiiiiiiiiiiii iiiiiiiii!l•ii!iiiiii•ii•iilii!i!i!i•iiiiii!iiiiii•i!i!ili•i!i•i!i•i!iii!•ii!i•i•iii•ii•i•iiiiiiiiiiiiii•iiiiii•iii•i•i•ii•!•iii•ii••iiiii•ii•iiii•iiiiil i•iiili i•iiiii•iii•ii•iii•i•i•i•i!i•iii•i•ii
iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii••iiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiii•i!iii!i!iiii•ii!iiiiiiiiiiii••i!i!i!iiiiiii!iiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiii•iiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii•iiiiiiii•iiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiii•iiiiiiiiiiii!i
i~iiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~ii~i!ii~iii~i~iiiiiiiiii~i~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iii~iiiiiiiiiUiiiii!i~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~i~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~i~iiii~i~iii~ii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiii~iii iiiiii•iiiii•i•iiiiii•ii!i••!ii••iii!i•i!i•iii•ii•i•ii••iii!i!i•i•!iiiii•ii•i•i!•iiii!i•i••iiii•!iii•iiiiiiiiiiii!iiiii•iiiiii!i•i!i•iiiii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
149
PART 2: CHEMICAL MODIFICATION OF THE SILICA SURFACE
Chapter 8
Chemical modification of silica: applications and procedures
1 Applications of modified silica gel
1.1 Introduction Applications of pure silica powders are based on porosity, active surface, hardness, thixotropic and viscous characteristics. If the chemical structure of the silica surface is altered, these properties may be combined with specific chemical or physical interaction capacities. Thus interaction with bulk matrices as well as individual molecules may be ameliorated. The purpose of chemical modification is the combination of the mechanical or structural properties of the pure substrate with dedicated intermolecular interactions. Chemical surface modification may be defined as the chemical bonding of molecules or molecule fragments to a surface in order to change its chemical or physical prope~ies in a controlled way. The chemical modification of the surface of solids has led to increased possibilities in a number of fields on laboratory as well as on industrial scale. Applications of modified silicas may be classified according to the field in which they are of interest. In each field the interaction with a specific type of molecules is effectuated. In the analytical field organic compounds and metal ions are selectively adsorbed. The chemical field aims at the immobilization of metal complexes for use as catalyst
150 centres. Enzymes are immobilized in the biochemical field. In the industrial field interaction with polymers and ceramics is realized. In most of these applications, silica has the role of a support material. The popularity of silicon-based supports for multiple modification applications is well summarized by Mottola. ~ Chemical modification requires seemingly paradoxal support properties: (a) supports need to have a surface hydrophilic in nature but also to be insoluble in aqueous solutions and polar solvents; (b) supports are required, in many instances, to be porous but retain mechanical stability; and (c) they must be chemically stable but easily derivatized. Silica gel meets all of these requirements. In choosing the molecules to modify the surface with, organofunctional silanes seem to be the best suited. Organofunctional silanes have an advantage over comparable organic compounds in that the silanes have potential for bonding through several mechanisms. 2 Electrokinetic forces can be used to attract or repel at relatively great distances. At closer approach, Van Der Waals forces, hydrogen bonding and covalent bonding are possible through silanol groups. By combining all of these possibilities in a single molecule, the silanes are uniquely capable of competing with water for hydroxylated surfaces. The advantageous chemical interaction capacities have led to a broad interest in silanes. The industrial production of a wide variety of organofunctional silanes has followed along. Despite of the great offer, ample use is restricted to few molecules. Those most commonly used silanes are listed in Table I. The names given are common names, which do not always follow IUPAC nomenclature rules. The IUPAC name for APTS e.g. would be 3-triethoxysilylpropanamine. The organosilanes all have the general formula Rn-Si-X4.n. With R being an organic group and X a hydrolyzable ligand. X may be an acyloxy, amine, halogen or alkoxy. Chlorine, ethoxy and methoxy are the most common X groups. In Table I the silanes with X = C1 constitute the first class. The R group is a normal alkyl chain. In all the other classes the hydrolysable function is an alkoxy group. The R chain carries a functional group, as referred to in the class name. Hexamethyldisilazane and bis(triethoxysilyl)tetrasulfan do not follow this general structure in that the R- chain links two - S i X 3 groups.
151 Most silanes are known by their acronym. The formation of acronyms has not been standardized, however. We prefer to indicate the trichlorosilyl group as TCS, while the trialkoxysilyl group is noted simply as TS. In order to note the type of alkoxyfunction an additional letter is sometimes introduced (APTES for APTS), but this will not be used here. The organofunctional group is abbreviated using the first letter of the organic function, or two letters if confusion with another compound is possible (e.g. MPTS and McPTS). Exception is made for octadecyltrichlorosilane. This compound is of very common use in chromatography, and is generally referred to as OTS. Concerning the general applications of organofunctional silanes, the main application is as coupling agent. Hence, both the organic character of the functional group and the inorganic character of the silicon side of the molecule are used. Bonding of fillers to polymer matrices and increasing bond strength of surface coatings, paints and inks are well developed. As a surface modification layer on silica gel, chromatography is the main application. All fields of use of silane modified silica gel are indicated in Table 8.1. In the subsequent chapter we are trying to give insight in the current uses of modified silica gel. We are also mentioning related substrates such as glass beads, glass fibres and thin SiO2 layers. It is not our intention to present a total survey on all possible applications, but merely to report recent research developments in the still expanding field of modified silica.
1.2 Analytical In the analytical field, modification implements the use of silica gel as a selective adsorbent for gases, liquids and metals. Modified silica is widely used as a stationary phase in various types of chromatography and as a metal ion sorbent. The use of silica as a support is restricted to the pH 1-8 range, due to the instability of the silica structure in basic conditions. For the separation of basic solutions, polymeric support materials are used.
Formula
Acronym
Uses
trichlorosilane
C13SiH
TCS
res.
methyltrichlorosilane
C13SiCH3
MTCS
res.
dimethyldichlorosilane
C12Si(CH3)2
DMDCS
res.
trimethylchlorosilane
C1Si(CH3)3
TMCS
block.
propyltrichlorosilane
C13SiCH2CH2CH2
PTCS
chrom.
octyltrichlorosilane
C13Si(CH2)7CH3
CsTCS
chrom.
octadecyltrichlorosilane
C13Si(CH2)I7CH3
ClsTCS, OTS
chrom.
vinyltriethoxysilane
(CH3CH20)3Si-CH-CH 2
VTS
comp.
methacryloxypropyltriethoxysilane
(CH3CH20)3SiCH2CH2CH2-O-CO-C(CH3) = C H 2
MPTS
comp.
(CH3CH20)3SiC6H5
PHTS
chrom.
(CH30)3SiCH2CH2CH2-O-CH2CH-CH2 \O/
GPTS
chrom., enz., IC
Name
chlorosilanes
alkenylsilanes
arylsilanes phenyltriethoxysilane
epoxyfunctional silanes 3,-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane
N-functional silanes 3,-aminopropyltriethoxysilane
(CH3CH20)3SiCH2CH2CH2NH2
APTS
chrom., met., cat., enz.,comp., IC
.y-aminopropyldiethoxymethylsilane
(CH3CH20)2CH3SiCH2CH2CH2NH2
APDMS
res., chrom.
3,-aminopropylethoxydimethylsilane
(CHaCH20)(CH3)2SiCH2CH2CH2NH2
APMDS
res.
N-/3-aminoethylaminopropyltrimethoxysilane
(CH30)3SiCHECHECHENHCH2CH2NH2
AEAPTS
met., cat., enz., IC
cyanopropyltriethoxysilane
(CH3CH20)aSiCH2CHECH2CN
CyPTS
chrom., cat.
hexamethyldisilazane
(CH3)aSiNHSi(CH3)3
HMDS
chrom., block.
3,-mercaptopropyltriethoxysilane
(CHaCH20)3SiCH2CH2CH2SH
McPTS
comp., cat.
bis(triethoxysilylpropyl)tetrasulfan
[(CHaCH20)aSiCH2CH2CH2]2S4
S-functional silanes comp., cat.
Cl-functional silanes chloropropyltriethoxysilane
(CH3CH20)aSiCH2CH2CH2C1
CPTS
cat., comp.
Table 8.1 Chlorosilanes and alkoxysilanes commonly used in the modification of silica, with formula, acronym and common application with silica. (res." research, block. "blocking agent, chrom." chromatography, comp." composites, enz. "enzyme immobilization, IC: integrated circuits, cat.." catalyst, met: preconcentration of metals).
154 1.2.1 High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) Chemically modified silicas are widely employed as stationary phases in High Performance Liquid Chromatography. Whereas pure silica is extensively used as a polar column material, modification allowed the development of apolar stationary phases. Because most interactions are reversed, compared to the silica column (straight phase) technique, the separation using apolar columns was termed reversed phase chromatography. The nature of the stationary phase depends on the type of silica, the type of modifier and the bonding reaction used. Organosilanes (either functionalized or not) and polymers are used as modifying agent. The reaction procedure determines the density of the introduced ligands.
Table 8.2 Octadecysilyl-bonded silica stationary phase materials for HPLC 3
Material
Shapea Carbon loading
Capping
Typical efficiencyb
(%) /~ Bondapak C~s LiChrosorb RP 18 (7/~m) LiChrospher 100 CH-8 Hypersil ODS Nova-Pak C~8 (4/~m) Nucleosil ODS Partisil 10 ODS 1c Partisil ODS 2 Partisil ODS 3 Resolve Cl8 Spherisorb ODS 1 Spherisorb ODS 2 Ultrasphere ODS Vydax 201 HS Vydax 201 TP Zorbax C- 18
I I S S S S I I I S S S S S S S
10 17
Capped Uncapped
45 000 40 000
10 7 14 5 15 10.5 12 7 12
Capped Capped Capped Uncapped Uncapped Capped Uncapped Partially Capped
100 000 120 000 60 000 20 000 25 000 20 000 100 000 60 000 - 80 000 60 000- 80 000 65 000
13.5 8 15
Capped Uncapped
particle shape: S, spherical; I, irregular. based on 5 t~m packing material unless noted. 10/xm particle size.
65 000
155 Table 8.3 Other alkyl- and aryl- bonded silica stationary phases for HPLC3
Material
Carbon loading (%) (if reported)
Methyl- or trimethyl-bonded silica Hypersil SAS LiChrosorb RP-2 Spherisorb C1 Zorbax TMS Hexyl-bonded silica Spherisorb 5 C6 Octyl-bonded silica Hypersil MOS LiChrosorb RP-8 LiChrosorb Select B LiChrospher CH-8 Nucleosil 5 C8 Partisil C8 (CCS) Resolve C8 Spherisorb C8 Ultrasphere Octyl Zorbax C8 Aryl-bonded silica /~ Bondapak phenyl Nova-Pak phenyl Nucleosil 7 C6H5 Phenyl Hypersil Spherisorb phenyl Vydax 219 TP diphenyl Zorbax phenyl (dimethylaryl)
6 7
9 9 6 6
8 4 8 3 5
The most popular chemically bonded phases are those with n-alkylligands (mostly octadecyl, C18, or octyl, C8).a These phases are prepared by the modification of silica gel with the corresponding alkyltrichlorosilane (RSiC13) or the alkyldimethylchlorosilane (RSi(CH3)2CI). The apolar character of the stationary phase is reflected in its carbon content (expressed as %C). Monochlorotrialkylsilanes usually yield 7 - 10% carbon. Due to polymerization of the silane molecules, alkyltrichlorosilanes give a higher carbon content of 12 - 25 %.
156 Because of steric hindrance between the long alkyl chains, not all surface hydroxyl groups are reacted with the silane molecule. Those unreacted groups may be endcapped by reaction with trimethylchlorosilane, in order to prevent them from interfering in the chromatographic separation. Octadecylsilyl- and octylsilyl-bonded silica is most generally applied. However, also methyl, hexyl, doeicosanyl (C22) and phenyl coated stationary phases have been developed5,6 and are commercially available (tables 8.2 and 8.3). Apolar stationary phases suffer from hydrolytic instability at pH extremes. The use of mixed phases of long (Cg, C~g) and short (C~, C3) chain alkyls produces stationary phases with increased hydrolytic stability. 7,g Crowding of the long alkyl chains does not allow the alkylsilane molecules to deposit in close packing on a smooth or fiat surface. Silane molecules polymerize in vertical direction, loosing contact with the silica surface. The insertion of short chain alkyls allows horizontal polymerization of the silane molecules. Thus, alkyl chains are aligned in a parallel way. The stability of the silane layer is increased consequently (figure 8.1).
(a)
(b)
I
I
I
0
0
0
HO 0 I
I
I
I
\ 0 R\ / si--OH o
\
R I
0 [
Figure 8.1 Horizontal (a) and vertical (b) polymerization of silanes on a silica surface.
Functionalized silanes are applied to form stationary phases with different polarities. Those may be used in straight phase as well as reversed phase mode. Amino 9, cyano ~~ nitro and diol functional groups are introduced on the silica surface. Commercially available stationary phases are listed in table 8.4.
157 Table 8.4 Substituted alkyl-bonded stationary phases for HPLC~
Material
Carbon loading (%)
Aminopropyl- and aminodimethylpropyl-bonded silica
# Bondapak NH2 Hypersil APS Hypersil APS-2 LiChrosorb NH2 Nucleosil 5 NMea (weakly basic) Nucleosil 5 NH2 Spherisorb NH/ Zorbax NH2 Special amino-bonded silica
Carbohydrate Analysis (Waters) (amino-bonded silica) Cyanopropyl-bonded silicaa
# Bondapak CN Hypersil CPS Nova-Pak CN Nucleosil 5CN Spherisorb S5CN Resolve CN Ultrasphere Cyano Zorbax CN Mixed bonded phase
Partisil 10 PAC (amino-cyano) Diol-substituted silica~
LiChrosorb DIOL Nucleosil 7 OH Nitropropyl-bonded silica c
Nucleosil 5 NO2 (for unsaturated organics)
the group is -(CH2)3-CN the group is Si-(CH2)3-O-CH2-CH(OH)-CHzOH the group is (CH2)3-C6H4-NO2
3.5 4
158 Amino and cyano-bonded columns have mainly been used for separation of carbohydrates. Aminophases should not be used with aldehydes or ketones, because they react with the formation of a Schiff's base. The mobility of the alkylchain, 4'~ as well as the accessibility of the functional group control the separation efficiency. Gilpin ~2 found no difference in chromatographic performance in comparing a bidentate alkylsilane modified silica to its monodentate analogue. This indicates that chain mobility only has a minor influence on performance, for n-alkyl ligands. In order to combine the strength of an inorganic matrix with the selectivity and chemical inertness of organic resins, polymers immobilized on silica gel have been developed. The polymers may be coated on the silica surface, with or without the use of an interphasing alkylsilane. 13 Alternatively the silica pores may be filled with the polymer network. This type of compounds was reviewed by Petro and Berek. ~4
1.2.2 Ion Exchange Chromatography Ion exchange separations are strongly linked to the HPLC-technique, concerning the technology involved. Stationary phases are prepared by the implantation of an ionic group on the silica surface. Simple aminosilanes or the uncoated silica surface hydroxyls may be converted to ionic species by changing the pH of the eluent. Alternatively, ionizable groups, such as sulphonic acid or higher amines, may be coated onto the premodified substrate. ~5 This method has lost some popularity, due to its low efficiency and the development of ion chromatography. 3 However, it is still used for the separation of basic drugs.
1.2.3 Size Exclusion Chromatography SEC Another chromatographic method, which is related to HPLC, is Size Exclusion Chromatography. ~6 In this technique, separation is based on molecular size. The analytes do not interact with the column material, but are separated on basis of the amount of pores into which they may penetrate. SEC is used for the separation and characterization of synthetic and natural water-soluble polymers. Organic or silica-
159 based stationary phases are used. Modified silica is used to prevent the irreversible adsorption of polymers on the silica-based material. ~7 Modification may be performed in two steps. First the silica is modified with 7-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APTS). In the second step the free amine group is converted to an amide. Porsch TM reports the use of diol-bonded silica for SEC. This type of silica is obtained by simultaneous opening of the oxirane ring in the bonding reaction with 7-glycidoxypropyltrimethoxysilane (GPTMS).
1.2.4 Gas Chromatography GC For the preparation of capillary columns for gas chromatography, the fused silica column wall is deactivated using polysiloxanes, and modified with a suitable stationary phase. Hetem ~9 discussed the use of polymethylhydrosiloxanes (PMHS) for deactivation and subsequent coating with a polymerized C~8-type silane for stationary phase formation. Stationary phases used in packed GC are analogous to HPLC.
1.2.5 Preconcentration of trace metals Trace metals play an important role in natural aqueous systems. Analysis of these systems requires a separation and concentration of the metals, to overcome matrix effects. Modified silica is used for this purpose as well as various chelating polymers. Chelate-functional groups, bonded to inorganic supports have several advantages over comparable functional polymers. 2 Inorganic supports have a greater mechanical strength. This allows greater operating pressures and higher flow rates. The functional groups are located at the substrate surface, causing a local concentration of reagents. The rate of reaction is further increased, because the process is not diffusion limited. Furthermore the inorganic material is cheaper than its organic counterpart. The use of modified silica in this field was initiated by Leyden and Luttrell. 2~ They used amine-modified silica for the concentration of copper from lake water and high purity industrial water. Both diamine and monoamine modified silicas and their dithiocarbamate derivatives were used. Taylor and Howard 22 related the copper capacity of the aminated silicas to the primary amine content. Efficient complexation therefore requires linear rather than bridged chains, with a primary amine ending.
160 The interaction of amine-modified silica with Cu 2§ ion is the most documented. 23,~,25 However, the retention of other transition metals as well as precious metals with dedicated modification layers has also been reported. The separation of Pd and Pt from base metals, Ir(III) and Rh(III) was effectuated by using silica-bound thioether sulfur and primary amine groups. 26 A review on polymeric as well as modified silica supports for separation and preconcentration of trace metals is presented by Kantipuly. 27 This metal immobilization also allows other applications such as metalion chromatography 2g and heavy metal catalysis. 29
1.3 Chemical
The chemical uses of modified silica comprise various types of solid substrates for heterogeneous and phase transfer catalysis. Most applications use a multi-step modification, in which the deposition of a simple silane, often an aminosilane, is followed by modification with a molecule holding the needed reactive centre.
1.3.1 Heterogeneous catalysis Solid heterogeneous catalysts are prepared by the immobilization of complex ions on modified silica. These complexes are third generation catalysts. These systems combine the advantages of activity and selectivity of homogeneous catalysts, with the advantage of easy separation of heterogeneous catalysts. Inorganic supports show clear advantages over organic polymers for large-scale applications. Contrarily to the latter supports, silica has a mechanically rigid structure, which is unaffected by all but the most severe temperature and solvent conditions. Hoffmann 3~ describes the immobilization of a Ru'complex on variously premodified silica gel. The silica was first reacted with an aminopropylsilane and subsequently functionalized with aromatic groups. The trans-[Ru(NH3)4SO2(H20)] 2§ complex is immobilized on this modification layer. This type of material may be used as a catalyst for hydrogenation and isomerization. Kamada 3~ studied the deposition and catalytic activity of 12-tungstophosphate anion (PW~2) on aminoalkylated silica. PW~2 is an effective heteropoly acid catalyst. Due to the concentration and homogeneous
161
dispersion of the catalyst on the modified silica surface, the activity per gram of the modified catalyst is higher than that of the unmodified catalyst. Carlier 32'33 used various functional alkylsilane groups on silica as co-monomer, transfer
agent or initiator for grafting of a functional polymer. These functional polymers may be used to anchor a catalyst. The polymer polyphenylsilsesquioxane was grafted onto porous silica and sulfonated, to obtain catalysts of high stability with enhanced site accessibility and increased number of sites, as well as high acidity level. 34 This catalyst is used for esterification and phenol alkylation. Other catalysts have been reviewed by Pinnavaia, 35 and are summarized in table 8.5. Two general methods are available for immobilizing metal complex catalysts on metal oxide surfaces by the use of ligand silane coupling reagents of the type X3SiL where X is a hydrolyzable group and L is a liganding group. In method A, the ligand silane is used to react with surface hydroxyl groups to form a ligand-functional silica, and then a metal complex precursor is allowed to react with the functionalized surface. In method B, a metal-ligand silane complex is first formed in solution and then allowed to react with surface hydroxyls of the support. Method A: =--SiOl-I
+
Surface silanol -- SiOSi-L ligand silica
X3SiL
--,
ligand silane +
M
--SiOSi-L
+
tIX
ligand silica --,
complex precursor
- SiOSiLM
surface complex
Method B: X3SiL
+
ligand silane -- SiOH surface silane
M
--,
XaSiLM metal-silane complex
-,
~- S i O S i L M
metal precursor +
XaSiLM
metal-silane complex
+ I-~
162
Table 8.5 Representative silica-supported metal complex catalysts prepared by use of ligand silane coupling agentsa,35 Surface complex catalystb on silica
Method of preparation
Catalytic application
CpTiCI2(CsH4)TiCI2(CsH4)2RhCI[PPh2(CH2)2]3-
B B A,B
RhCI[(CO)PPh2(CH2)2]2-
B A B B A A,B A A A A A,B A A A
Hydrogenation Hydrogenation Hydrogenation and hydroformation Hydroformylation Carbonlylation Hydroformylation Hydrogenation Hydrosilylation Hydroformylation Hydrosilylation Isomerization Hydrosilylation Carbonylation Hydroformulation Hydroformylation Oligomerization Hydrogenation
Rh (acac)(CO)PPh2(CH2)2PhCI[PPh2C6H4(CH2)4]2RhCI3/PPh2(CH2)2RhCI3(COD)[PPh2(CH2)I4]RhCI3/NMe2(CH2)3PtCI2-4/SnC1/PPh2(CH2)2H2PtCI6/NMe2(CH2)3Pd(acac)2/PPh2(CH2)8Co(CO)2(CsH4)Co(acac)JPPh2(CH2)2NiC12[PPh2(CH2)2]-
IrCI[PPh2C6H4(CH2)4]-
abbreviations used in this table are as follows: acac: acetyl-acetonate; COD: 1,5-cyclo-octadiene; Cp: cyclopentadienyl in cases where undefined metal complexes were formed by method A, the metal precursor/ligand silica system is specified 1.3.2 Phase transfer catalysis The immobilization of phase transfer catalysts on solid substrates allows a clean reaction with no contamination of the products by the catalyst. Insoluble polystyrene matrices have been used as a solid support. The polymer matrix does not affect the velocity of the reaction, apart from steric hindrance with respect to the reagents. In the case of immobilization on modified silica the active centre is linked to the support by an alkyl chain of variable length. This length strictly determines the adsorption capacity of the polar support, which then controls the rate of reaction. A three-phase catalytic system is set up. Two distinct phases, containing reagents, come into close
163
contact on a third one and react. Aminosilane or bromosilane modified silica is used for further modification with bromoacylchlorides and tri-n-butylphosphines. Resulting in immobilized phosphonium salts on silica. These catalysts have been used in reduction, alkylation and substitution reactions. 36
1.4 Biochemical The immobilization of enzymes on solid supports is the oldest of new biotechnologies. As for most of the chemical applications, the uses in this field require a multi-step modification. As a first layer a simple silane, mostly APTS, is used. In order to minimize sterical hindrance in the ultimate application reaction, a spacer molecule is often introduced between the active surface group and the immobilizing species. This may either be introduced at once, using a long-chain functional silane, or in a second step, after silanization.
1.4.1 Immobilization of enzymes Enzymes in their native state are unstable to elevated temperatures, as well as to aqueous-organic environments and to pH variations. 37 They loose their activity under these conditions and denaturate. Many ways to solve these problems have been tried. Immobilization of the enzymes on solid supports has proven to be the most successful. Apart from their increased stability, isolated enzymes are easier to handle, more specific in their function and more predictable in their activity. 2 Various supports, both inorganic and organic, have been developed. Silica has the advantage of having a large specific surface area, a high thermal and mechanical stability and persistence in acid conditions. The porous structure may be either advantageous or disadvantageous, depending on the size of the enzyme and reagent. Organic support materials, such as cellulose or agarose have also been deposited on silica or glass beads, thus increasing their ease of handling. In order to get insight in the many supports and coupling methods which may be employed, Scouten 38 reported the criteria to be regarded in enzyme coupling. These range from choosing the level of activation (maximal :/: optimal), to harshness of coupling conditions and optimal duration.
164 Amine groups are preferred for the bonding of the enzymes. Therefore the glass or silica support is generally pretreated with an aminosilane, such as APTS. The following reactions are used to couple the silica-amine group (S-NH2) to the enzymeamine (E-NH2) or enzyme phenol group (E-CH2C6H3OH)2'39:
A: Michael coupling through glutaraldehyde" S-NH 2 + OHC(CH2)3CHO + NH2E
~
S-NH-CH(CH2)3-C=N-E + 2 1-120
B" Amide coupling:
o
o~.o
0
,
,//
0
S - NHCCH 2CH 2C \ O H
2
//
0
O +
S - N H C C H 2 CH 2 C \
E- NH 2
#
it
-
S - NHCCH 2 CH2 C \OH
OH
C" Azo coupling:
0
0 S-NH 2
s-
0 it
+ CI-CQNO
NaNO2
HCl-
E-CH~> OH
0
[H]
0
It
S-NHCQN O It
2 §
CI
165 The stability of covalent bonds formed in method A have been tested by washing off the immobilized enzyme with detergents. 4~ This study indicated that glutaraldehyde reacts quickly with the APTS surface with the formation of stable bonds. The enzymes adsorb to the activated surface, with the majority being adsorbed within the first minute. Stable covalent bonds are formed between the glutaraldehyde and the enzyme. Besides the stability of the bonding of the enzyme to the support, the activity of the immobilized enzyme is an important parameter. Kallury 4~'42'43 studied the influence of immobilization on phospholipid-bound silica. He found a considerable stabilizing influence of the phospholipid environment on the enzyme activity. The results with urease demonstrated that a very high thermal stability could be achieved by combining the rigidity generated through immobilization with the stabilizing effect of the phospholipid molecules. The current large body of immobilization procedures has been reviewed by Cabral and Kennedy. 44 Besides facilitating and optimizing the practical application of enzymes, the developing of the immobilized enzymes also allowed a better study of enzyme functioning. 45 Many other new applications in the field of biotechnological products and processes have emerged. Enzymes immobilized on various supports are used e.g. for the purification of molecules that bind to immoglobulines, lecithins or other binding proteins, for improved biocompatibility of materials, to provide selective biosensors and in solid-phase analytical assays. Of these, silica is used as a porous support in the fabrication of analytical detection s y s t e m s . 46 1.4.2 Affinity Chromatography (AC) Affinity Chromatography was initially defined as a method based on specific and reversible molecular interactions between biologically active substances. However, the method has extended to non-biological stationary phases, such as metal-chelate complexes. This technique is used for separation and purification of proteins and other biologic materials, such as viruses and cells. 47'48 A survey of various stationary phases and affinity interactions is given in figure 8.2.
166
Motrix ~nmobiUzedIAffine
componentIcomponen{
E
(a)
(b)
Motrix Adsorption (or binding)
Protein
0 II
J
U
componen{
of {he of'fine
0
nu.,
L1
,:.me H20~" 1~"O4-1.L 2+3 ~ LJ = -
?A
~ ~
I
O L~
3HzO
(c)
(d)
V IOn rO'e'n=
(e)
~Ads~176
~ t
+
-I- R'-S-S-R' Figure 8.2 Variants of affinity chromatography, (a) biospecific A C," (b) metal chelate chrom. ;(c) charge transfer adsorption chrom.; (d) hydrophobic interaction chrom, and (e) covalent chrom. (chemisorption). Abbreviations: E = enzyme, L = amino acid group, me = metal ion, R~ = electron - withdrawing substituent, R~ = electron donating substituent; taken from ref (47) with permission.
167 Specific inhibitors for proteins are immobilized on a (inorganic or organic) porous substrate. In varying the inhibitor, enzymes can be selectively adsorbed and enzyme mixtures separated. The adsorbed enzyme may be eluted by a solution of free ligand or by a change in pH and/or ionic strength. 49 Affinity chromatography combines the analytical and chemical capacities of chemically bonded stationary phases and immobilized enzymes. Technology and methodology of both techniques are joined in the development of affinity stationary phases. Since steric requirements are even more determining than in simple immobilized enzyme systems, spacer molecules have great importance in these modifications. Commonly used spacer arms are summarized in figure 8.3.
The ultimate combination of HPLC and AC is effectuated in High Performance Affinity Chromatography (HPAC). 47 The development of this hybrid technique was highly assisted by the use of modified silica. Traditional polysaccharide supports may not be used for HPAC, because they lack mechanical stability to withstand the high pressure drops, inherent to this method. Modified silica beads are well suited. These may be coated with active groups as in normal AC applications. Additionally, if the separation requires the use of an organic stationary phase, the silica beads are modified with a silane or polymer with subsequent deposition of polysaccharides such as dextrans, agarose or cellulose. 5~
1.5 Industrial
In the industrial field, modified silica assists the development of advanced materials. Modified silica powders are used as a filler in rubbers and in new-type gas sensors. Most industrial applications involve the use of strongly related materials such as glass fibres or thin SiO2 layers. We wish to restrict ourselves to a discussion of the application of powdered silica and a short indication of related compounds. The chemistry behind the modification of powders, fibres or thin layers is similar. Therefore fibres as well as thin oxide layers have repeatedly been used to model silica modification mechanisms.
168
0 - CH 2" CH2"OH
(CH2) 3" N H 2 - (CH2) n- NH 2 [- (CH2) n- COOH -
CH 2- CH
-
CH
n = 2-12 n=2-12
\o / [" (CH2) 3" N H - (CH2) 3- N H 2 OH O OH II II I [- CH 2- CH - CH 2" NH - C - CH_2," NH - CH 2- CH - C H2-NH 2
-cH-c2 6 ~-N-N
-c5 ~
-cH-cooI 2 N-N+CI"
Figure 8.3 Some spacers used in affinity chromatography; takenfrom ref (47) with permission.
1.5.1 Composites Silica powder, glass beads and fibres are commonly used for the reinforcement of plastics. The produced composite materials have an increased thermal and mechanical stability, compared to the pure polymeric material. In order to bind the inorganic filler to the organic matrix, silane molecules, with both an inorganic and organic side, are used. The silane may be mixed with the matrix and filler material in the composite preparation, or be coated onto the filler prior to mixing. The application
169 of silane coupling agents perseveres the enhanced properties of composite materials in wet conditions. Glass fibres are used in the fabrication of tough materials, while silica powders are added to elastomers. Commonly used materials for glass fiber reinforcement include polyester, epoxy and phenolic resins. These are used in building and construction industry. Glass fibres are mostly of the E-glass type. The E-glass composition is displayed in table 8.6. 5~ The mechanism governing the reinforcing ability of coupling agents has been repeatedly studied, and falls beyond the scope of this book. The reader is referred to the work of Plueddemann 2'52 and Fowkes. 53'54 Table 8.6 Relative percentages of various oxides in E-glass composition51
E-glass composition (%) SiO2 A1203 CaO MgO Na20 K20 B203
55.2 8.0 18.7 4.6 0.3 0.2 7.3
In elastomers, such as natural and synthetic rubbers, modified silica as well as active carbon is used as a reinforcing material. It imparts utmost tear, tensile and abrasive resistance. The advantages of silica over carbon are its colourlessness and its constant isolating properties, even at high temperatures. Disadvantages of pure silica as a filler, such as the low network density, have been overcome by the application of the modified substrate. The difunctional tertrasulfane (bis(3-trimethoxysilylpropyl)tetrasulfane) is commonly applied. In composite formation, the sulfur bridges are split and react with elastomer carbon-carbon double bonds (figure 8.4). Other silanes, containing amino, sulfur, halogen or phenyl groups are also applied with various rubber types, as summarized in table 8.7. 55
170
--Si-'-Si-Si-
o
\Si" -O/ \ (CH2)3.S .~ S I -o\ (CH2)3- S ~S
+
o/Si /
--Si-
i/
\ OC2H5 $81 A
=Si-Si=Si-Si-
- oO\Si/OC2H5/\ / ~ (CH2)3- Sa- "Sxl Sx3 -O\o/ /OC(CH2) ~H3- Sb'I 2 ~ Si\ 5 -Sx2 Sx4
Figure 8. 4 The use o f bis(3-trimethoxysilyl)tetrasulfane) modified silica in the vulcanization of elastomers (idealized a +b = 4, 1 90 90 8); taken from ref (55).
Table 8.7 Use of organosilanes in reinforced rubbers55 (NR: natural rubber, SBR: slyrene-butadiene rubber, EPDM: ethylene-propylene-diene rubber)
ORGANOSILANE
RUBBER TYPE
FILLER MATERIAL
(RO)3Si-(CH2)3-C1
halogenrubber NR, SBR
SiO2 SiO2, clay
(RO)3Si-(CH2)3-NH2
NR, SBR
SiO2, clay
(RO)3Si-(CH2)3-SH
NR, SBR
SiO2, clay
(RO)3Si-(CH2)3-S-C(NH2)2+C1-
halogenrubber NR, SBR
SiO2 SiO2, clay
(RO)aSi-(CH2)3-Sx-(CH2)a-Si-SCN
NR, SBR
SiO2
(RO)3Si-(CH2)3C5H5
EPDM
SiO2, clay
171 1.5.2 S-emission monitoring The modification of silica gel with diethanolamine (DEA) resulted in a stable alkaline filter, capable to collect H2S, COS, CS2, SO2, CO2 and H20 from contaminated air. 56 The presence of odorous mercaptanes and organic sulphides may be selectively determined, as these compounds do not react with the DEA and therefore are not collected on the filter. By means of this scrubber an automatic survey system has been developed allowing the detection and determination of the nature of odour nuisance, caused by industrial emissions of volatile organic sulphur compounds, up to the ppb-level. The system consists of two continuous, highly sensitive and fast responding sulphur analyzers. One of the detectors is equipped with an SOx scrubber and measures the total amount of non-SO2 sulphur compounds. The other detects the organic S-compounds, using the amine-silica filter. 1.5.3 Modification of thin SiO2 layers In various industrial applications, silica modification is used on thin layers of SiO2, rather than on the powdered form. Monomolecular or thin layers of silicon oxide are thermally grown on Si-wafers for the production of high-tech materials. The surface chemistry of these layers is comparable to the powdered form, with the absence of a porous structure. This type of material is commonly used in the production of semiconductor devices. 57 The silica layer is used as a starting layer for integrated circuit (IC) build-up. IC layer materials range from single crystals and doped polycrystalline silicon, silicon nitride, thermally-grown oxide to vapour deposited or sputtered metal or metal silicide layers. Structural adhesion of the various layers is obtained by the application of organosilanes, such as AEAPTS, APTS and GPTS. The thin layer technology is also used in the fabrication of chemical sensors. Cleche: 8 defines a chemical sensor as a physical device, called a transducer which delivers an electric signal, which is controlled by its sensitized part, called the detector. This detector must be selective i.e. must be prepared, or functionalized in order to respond only to the substance or group of substances to be detected. Since sensor technology goes beyond the scope of this work, we will limit ourselves here to this definition.
172 In research on the mechanisms gouverning the modification reactions, the thin silica layers allow the application of various surface analytical techniques, which are of no use for analysis inside porous systems. Reaction mechanisms are simplified by the elimination of porosity and may be studied by direct surface techniques such as ellipsometry, as well as microscopic techniques such as Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). 59
2 Modification procedures 2.1 Introduction
In the selection of a chemical modification procedure, two criteria have to be considered. (i) (ii)
the aimed coating morphology; the scale on which the modification has to be performed.
The coating morphology includes layer thickness (mono or multilayer), the modification density (molecules/nm2), the orientation of the surface molecules, and the type of interaction of the coating layer with the surface (relative amount physisorption/chemisorption). The second criterium is of equal importance. Laboratory-scale modifications require different procedures than industrial applications. Modifications for mechanistic studies may be more labour-intensive than large-scale fabrication of e.g. filler materials. In this perspective, various applications also require a variable control of the surface morphology. The production of stationary phases for HPLC needs careful control of the obtained surface structure, although they are produced on a relatively large scale. In industrial applications, the degree of precision which needs to be achieved, is of main interest. In this respect, the time/temperature profile of the procedure, the material movement inside the reaction vessel, and the means and form of introducing the reagent need to be considered. The cost of the surface modifying reagent also dictates the precision of the method and the monitoring which should be applied. 6~
173
The procedures used for the chemical modification of silica, will be discussed using these criteria. This survey is restricted to the preparation of chemically modified silicas, used as a base material in the above-cited applications. Procedures are ordered according to the possibility to control the ultimately formed layer.
2.2 Sol-gel The incorporation of organofunctional groups on the silica surface may be effectuated during the synthesis of the silica material. The addition of organofunctional alkoxysilanes to the TEOS solution in the sol-gel process, produces functionalized silica gels. This procedure does not allow a careful control of the obtained surface morphology. Since the relative amounts of silane and TEOS is the only variable parameter, neither layer thickness, nor modification density can be precisely tuned. This results in an irreproducible functionalization of the surface.
Base-catalyze~ RSi(OR' )3 1
H20
Acid-base RSi(OR' )3 I
1. H O 2. ~_i~catalyst
Hydrolysis
Hydrolysis
I
I Na4~
Na 4oH
Gelation Vacuum 353 - 373 K Dried gel
Gelation
Chlorosilane RSiC1
3
1. CHCI 2, H20 3
Hydrolysis and gelation I Vaemtm 353 - 373 K Dried gel
| Vaeanma 4 353 373 K -
Dried gel
Figure 8.5 Synthesis of organosilicon gels, takenfrom ref (61) with permission.
174 The organic functionality may also be incorporated by the sol-gel synthesis of the pure organosilane. The thus formed gels are referred to as organosilicon gels. These type of gels have been produced to serve as precursor gels in the preparation of silicon carbides. 6~ Three routes have been set up, as displayed in figure 8.5. Either alkoxy- or chlorosilanes are used as a starting material. Alkoxysilane gel synthesis may proceed via a base catalysed or an acid-base route. The effectiveness of each route is dictated by the functionality of the starting silane. The acid-base route is most generally preferred. 61'62 The obtained gels show very low porosity and surface area values (table 8.8). Therefore this procedure is only used for dedicated applications, such as the production of ceramics.
Table 8.8 Pore volume and surface area data for chlorosilane-derived gels 61
R-group
Pore vol. (cm3/g)
Surface area (m2/g)
Methyl Ethyl Vinyl Propyl Allyl Phenyl
0.45 0.26 0.21 0.09 0.22 0.05
2.20 0.33 0.27 0.24 0.08 0.15
Surface coating using sol-gel technology is mainly used for the preparation of oxide or organofunctional siloxane layers on solid materials. In this case, the material is dipped or spun in the TEOS sol. This procedure leads to the formation of multilayered coatings of irreproducible thickness. Since this type of coating may only be used for axially or radially symmetric materials, alternatives have been developed. Those include spraying, electrophoresis, thermophoresis and ultrasonic pulverization. 63 However, these are not of interest in powder modification.
175
2.3 Aqueous solvent The preparation of organofunctional silica gels on industrial scale is performed by liquid phase reaction. As a solvent, water, a water/ethanol or water/acetone mixture is used.
Chlorosilanes or alkoxysilanes are used for this type of modification.
In the aqueous solvent the silanes undergo hydrolysis and condensation, before deposition on the surface 64 (figure 8.6).
RSi(OMe) 3 3H20 -~,/[ k.~
Hydrogenbonding R I HO~Si
Hydrolysis
O
Condensation
H
~Si
I
H
~OH
O H
H
H
"O
O
"O "
I
I
I
2H 20
Substrate
2H20
R I
R I
R I
I
I
I
Bond formation R
HO - - S i - 0 -- Si - - 0 - - Si - - OH
OH
R I
O
H
!
OH + OH
O ~ S i ~ O I
I
RSi(OH)3 3MeOH
OH
R I
HO--
OH
R
I
R
I
Si--
0 -- S i -
O
t
0 --
O
OH
i
Si' m
I I
O I
H ~
Substrate
OH
H i
0 I Substrate
Figure 8. 6 Mechanism of silane deposition in aqueous solvent, taken from ref (64), with permission.
In contact with water, halogen or alkoxy groups are hydrolyzed.
The as-formed
silanol groups go into hydrogen-bonding interactions with neighbouring hydrolyzed silane molecules and with surface silanol groups. release of water.
Siloxane bonds are formed, with
The coating molecules are polymerized horizontally as well as
vertically. Thus, a three-dimensional polymeric silane network is formed on the silica surface.
The polymerization
reactions
are hard
to control
and a layer of
176 unreproducible thickness results. The control is ameliorated with the addition of a variable amount of a polar organic solvent, such as ethanol or acetone. Ethanol/water mixtures in a 70/30% ratio are commonly used. Covalent bond formation is not an immediate process. Silane coating layers consist of physisorbed as well as chemisorbed molecules. Physisorbed molecules go into condensation only slowly and chemical stabilization of the coating layer requires a post-reaction curing step. In this step the modified substrate is thermally treated at temperatures generally in the 353 - 473 K range. The rate of hydrolysis of silanes is influenced by the functionality of the organic group and the type of the leaving group. The stability of the silanols increases with increasing size of the organic group. Acyloxy- and aminofunctional silanes are far more susceptible to hydrolysis than other alkoxysilanes. They hydrolyse in minutes in water, whereas others are stable for several hours. The increased rate of hydrolysis of the former is due to the acid or basic character of the functional group. Hydrolysis of the other alkoxysilane molecules may be catalyzed by the addition of a base or an acid. In solution, acid addition accelerates hydrolysis but decelerates polymerization. In the reaction mixture, however, the acid evaporates from the surface after hydrolysis, thus allowing polymerization. The molecular weight of adsorbed species increases, with increasing concentration of HCI. 65 The amount of silane deposited from water on a mineral surface, increases rapidly with increasing concentration, up to certain transition concentrations. Above this concentration deposition increases more slowly. These type of transitions are attributed to the onset of micelle formation between the aqueous silanetriols, causing enhanced stability of the hydrolyzed molecules. 2 The detailed hydrolysis and condensation behaviour of silane molecules in solution has been studied repeatedly, those were brought together in the festschrift in honour of Prof. Plueddemann. 66 Morral167 reported the formation of APTS layers with a thickness on the order of
10nm, by modification from aqueous solution. Tutas 68 found that aminosilane layers reach maximal thickness within the first minute of reaction, while vinylsilane layers keep growing with time. Films, deposited on glass from 0.1 - 5 % aqueous solutions were 5 - 20 nm thick. The thick, polymerized layers are ideal for industrial applications, such as the coupling of filler materials. In the chemical or analytical
177 field, they are of very limited value. For catalyst development and chromatographic separations, well-defined, ordered layers are required. In order to combine the stability gained by cross-linking with the reproducibility and characteristics of a monolayer coating, modification procedures in organic solvents have been set up.
2.4 Organic solvent If modification with chlorosilanes or alkoxysilanes is performed in fully dry conditions (dry organic solvent, dehydrated surface), hydrolysis is prevented. Chemical bonding with the substrate should result from the direct condensation of the chloro- or alkoxygroups with the surface silanols. From experiments using methoxymethylsilanes, B l i t z 69 concluded that this direct condensation does not take place. Post-reaction curing only results in evaporation of the adsorbed molecules. Alkoxysilanes may only bond chemically to the silica surface if water is present at the interface. Thus adsorbed silane molecules are hydrolyzed before reaction with the surface. Hydrolysis, however also causes polymerization and therefore non-monolayer coverages are obtained. Another way to realize the direct condensation is using ammonia as a catalyst. 7~ Surface loadings of up to twelve times the uncatalyzed reactions have been found. In figures 8.7 and 8.8 two possible mechanisms of ammonia catalysis are proposed. 7~
OMe Me~, I ..,,, ~H MeOV Sir'~u " ~ ~ N 7--- H O J..L.. H ~ " " H ............
J ................................................................................................
Me
+ MeOH
MeO b'gSi~OMe :-
t
O I .....
Figure 8. 7 Amine catalysis of silylaytion reaction, mechanism #1.
+NH
3
178
80/-
H, ~H N- H H";" 8+
OMe MeO, ,[. , ~l-Me
MeO'~_.
A
H,,~ N- H /n .
>'.8 +
. .. Me H H Meu O \ 9 Me .,.~,,./ N.~H ~bl" H ")' 8 + MeO N O / +
B
MeO
Me-~ H
M e /~1 ----'MeO ~,-~H
o" D
--,~.m
C
H
OMe
Si I
H
MeO /
+ MeOH 3
\
o E
Figure 8.8 Amine catalysis of silylation reaction, mechanism #2. In the first mechanism (figure 8.7) the transition state involves the formation of a lowenergetic six-membered ring. The second mechanism (figure 8.8) proceeds by the formation of a pentacoordinate intermediate, after nucleophilic attack of the ammonia at the silicon atom. Aminosilanes contain the catalyzing amine function in the organic chain. The reaction of aminosilanes with silica gel in dry conditions is therefore self-catalyzed. They show direct condensation, even in completely dry conditions. Upon addition of the aminosilane to the silica substrate, the amine group may form hydrogen bonds or proton transfer complexes with the surface silanols. This results in a very fast adsorption, followed by direct condensation. This reaction mechanism of APTS with silica gel in dry conditions, is displayed in figure 8.9. After liquid phase reaction, the filtered substrate is cured, in order to consolidate the modification layer. concluded that the initial adsorption step for -y-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APTS) takes less than 18 s, which was the shortest measurable time. The ultimate orientation of the aminopropylchain (amine near the surface or pointing away from it) is determined by the presence of water in the reaction and curing phase. 72 Kallury 73 demonstrated that the addition of a base in the reaction also reduces the amount of
Morral167
179 ) J
SI
APTS
H
0
1
NIt
2
Silica
Physisorptioa t-O, ~,O Si
& O~ S~,~
or
+
NIt 3
d
I
d-
Condensation
O"
rt, ,,H
o I
....N .~" ...... I H
,,H ........Nr'r'l H Curing
0
0
Figure 8.9 Modification o f silica gel with APTS.
amine-surface interaction. Further details on the reaction mechanism of APTS will be given extensively in the subsequent chapter. In order to exclude any hydrolyzed molecules in the reaction mixture, silanes are commonly distilled under reduced pressure before use. The toluene solvent may also be distilled prior to use or be stored on molecular sieve (5A zeolite) to assure complete drying. For extreme precaution, the silanation reactions may be performed under dry nitrogen atmosphere. A CaCI2 guard tube may also be employed. The use of hazardous organic solvents makes this procedure non-suited for large-scale industrial application. On the other hand, the possibility to control the modification structure, makes it very well suited for lab-scale mechanistic studies. The density of the alkyl-loading is strongly determined by the size of the alkylgroup. If bulky alkylgroups are used, the number of siloxane linkages with the surface is reduced, leaving unreacted alkoxy groups. Those are easily hydrolyzed, producing
180 residual silanols in the bonded phase. Since these have deleterious effects on chromatographic performance of n-alkyl stationary phases, a new procedure was developed to increase silane loading density for this type of application.
2.5 Self-assembled monolayers Among the liquid phase adsorption procedures, Self-Assembled Monolayers (SAMs) take a special place. This type of monolayer originated as an extension of LangmuirBlodgett film technology. TM In this latter technique, highly ordered films of large polar molecules are deposited on fiat surfaces. Being obtained as insoluble ordered floating films on the surface of a liquid, Langmuir-Blodgett monolayer films are transferred on solid supports from the water-gas interface, by dipping or immersion of the substrate (figure 8.10).
i (a)
Co)
I
I
I
|
Figure 8.10 Langmuir-Blodgett film formation on a solid support by transfer of a film at liquid-gas interface (a) to solid-gas (b) interface.
181
In the formation of SAMs, the film-forming molecules order themselves by chemical interaction with neighbouring molecules and with the substrate surface. This technique has been applied for a large variety of modifier/substrate combinations. Various sulphur compounds, like alkanethiols and (di)sulfides have been deposited on metals such as silver, copper and gold; isocyanides on platinum and carboxylic acids on aluminum oxide and silver oxide. 75 Alkyltrichlorosilanes have been deposited on gold, mica, aluminum, tin oxide and silicon oxide. The latter combination is of interest here. The main feature of the technique is the deposition of the coating molecules from organic solvent, on a cleaned hydrated surface. As a solvent dicyclohexyl, ethanol, n-hexadecane and n-heptane are used. In a typical synthesis procedure, the silica is first cleaned to remove all trace organic compounds. This cleaning step appears to be crucial in the formation of smooth, complete monolayers, especially on metal surfaces. Cleaning is performed by boiling in nitric acid or hydrogenperoxide/sulphuric acid ('piranha') solution. The cleaning step is followed by a careful rinse with distilled water and drying in a stream of dry nitrogen. The silica may be rehydrated by exposure to air with controlled humidity, shortly before use. Whereas the modification of flat solid substrates involves an immersion/retraction procedure, this is not possible for powdered substrates such as silica gel. Therefore, these are stirred in the reagent solution, filtered or decanted and rinsed with the pure solvent. Detailed descriptions of the reaction conditions may be found in 7 74 76 77 literature. ' ' ' The SAM is formed by using only the monolayer of surface water on the silica gel. Since no excess water is present, the polymerization reaction is strictly under control. Additionally, the water is present at the place where the surface bond has to be formed. Thus-formed SAM's are densely packed, ordered films, attached to the surface with chemical bonds. Alkyl chains are aligned paralel in a densely packed fashion. The surface is fully covered, irrespective of the number of hydroxyl groups. Not all silane molecules are covalently linked to the surface. Le Grange et al. 76 evidenced that on a dehydrated surface that was exposed to moisture, 1 in 5 octadecylchlorosilane molecules is bonded to the surface. Due to this dense structure and full surface
182 coverage, this type of layer is clearly different from other wet modification methods. In figure 8.11 the structure of a self-assembled monolayer is compared to that of a conventional polymeric layer.
0 " Si" ~ Si~ ~ Si~ ~Si
b ~ 1 7 6 1 7~6 1 7 o6
~Si.
..S~o.
o
ZZ~7
HO " i"o" b x OH
HO (~ "0
"O'~li"oOH
Figure 8.11 Schematic drawings of self-assembled monolayer (upper) and conventional monolayer. Takenfrom ref(8), with permission.
Wirth and Fatunmbi s defined the bonding of trifunctional silanes as self-assembly, when the bonding density of functional groups is made to be close-packed, approximately 8/~mol/m 2 (2.2 nmZ/chain). Conventional polymeric phases are no more than 5 /~mol/m2. Because of their close packing, these phases are very well suited for chromatographic separations, since all interference of surface hydroxyls is excluded. In order to avoid over-crowding of the alkyl chains, but retain the advantages of molecular self-assembly, mixed phases of long and short chain alkyls have been prepared. As one of such possible combinations, C3 chains have been mixed with
C18.7
183
2. 6 Hydride intermediate Alkyl chains are generally deposited on the silica surface using the corresponding alkylsilane. The hydride intermediate route, developed by Sandoval and Pesek 7g'79 gives an alternative for this method. The one-step alkylsilane route, is replaced by a two-step silanization-alkylation procedure. The loss of process simplicity is compensated by the advantages of an increased alkyl density and enhanced coating stability. In modification reactions using alkylsilanes, the silane density is influenced by the size of the alkyl group. The preparation of chromatographic stationary phases involves long chain alkyls (C8 or C~8) but requires a high alkyl density with a minimal amount of residual silanols. To overcome this apparent contradiction, alternatives to the alkylsilane methods have been developed. In the hydride intermediate route, the sterical limitations of the silanation reaction are overcome by applying the smallest possible silane. Triethoxysilane (HSi(OCH2CH3)3, TES) is used in a first step, producing a hydride surface. In order to make a clear distinction with normal alkylsilane reactions, this step is referred to as silanization. The silanization reaction is performed in dioxane/water solvent at reflux temperature, with acid catalysis. 8~ The reaction of the TES is analogous to other trialkoxysilanes. HSi(OCH2CH3) 3 -k 3 H20 ~ HSi(OH) 3 -I- 3 CH3CHzOH
(A)
HSi(OH) 3 -t- HO-Si --- --, HSi(OH)2-O-Si ---
(B)
After reaction (B) bidentate and intermolecular linkages are formed. This way to produce a hydride surface was proven to be preferential to the older procedure, involving chlorination and reduction of the surface. 8~ The deposition of alkylchains on the hydride surface is performed using heterogeneous phase hydrosilation of terminal unsaturated hydrocarbons (reaction (C)). cat. - Si-H + CH 2= CH-R
~
- Si-CH2-CHz-R
(C)
184 The reaction is influenced by various parameters, such as solvent, reaction time, reaction temperature and applied catalyst. 79 The reaction proceeds well in toluene solvent. However, if possible it is best to use the neat liquid olefin, depending on the physical state of the olefin at the reaction temperature. If a solvent is used, higher concentrations of the olefin lead to higher surface loadings. Various types of heterogeneous as well as homogeneous catalysts may be used. However, it appears that no catalyst of general use will be found. Every olefin has its own catalyst of choice. In this reaction a direct surface Si-C bond is formed. This type of bond appears to be more stable than the normal ---Si-O-Si-C bond. The stability of a Cs stationary phase, prepared both by hydrosilation and organosilanization are compared in figure 8.12. Both curves represent fraction of the initial surface coverage as a function of hydrolysis time. It is clear that the hydrosilated phase has a much better performance over the displayed time interval.
Fraction of initial surface coverage 1.00 0.90 0.80 0.70 0.60 0.50 0.40 0.30 0
' 2'0'
4b ' 6'0'' Elapsed time (h)
80
'
100
Figure 8.12 Relative surface coverage of C-8 phase on Vydac TP as a function of hydrolysis time. A: C-8 prepared by hydrosilation, B: C-8 prepared by organosilanization. Takenfrom ref. (79), with permission.
185
2. 7 Vapour-phase reactions Modification of silica gel with volatile or gaseous compounds is performed in the vapour phase. Industrial-scale reactors and laboratory scale gas adsorption apparatus have been used. In the industrial field, fluidized bed and fluid mill reactors are of main importance. In fluidized bed reactors, g2 the particles undergo constant agitation due to a turbulent gas stream. Therefore, temperatures are uniform and easy to control. Reagents are introduced in the system as gases. Mass transport in the gas phase is much faster than in solution. Furthermore, gaseous phase separations require fewer procedural steps than solution phase procedures, and may also be more costeffective, due to independence from the use and disposal of non-aqueous solvents. All these advantages make the fluidized bed reactors preferential for controlled-process industrial modifications. Fluid mill reactors have comparable characteristics. In this type of reactor, the reagent/solvent mixture is introduced as a spray. The solvent is evaporated quickly upon introduction, leaving the reagent to interact with the substrate. 6~ For laboratory-scale modification, distinction has to be made between static and dynamic adsorption procedures. In a static procedure, the substrate is contacted with a known volume of gas at a well-defined pressure. The modifying gas may be stationary or circulating in a closed loop. Modification in a static gas adsorption apparatus allows the careful control of all reaction parameters. Temperature and pressure can be controlled and easily measured. Adsorption kinetics may be determined by following the pressure as a function of the reaction time. Figure 8.13 displays a volumetric adsorption apparatus, in which mercury is used, as a means to change the internal volume and for pressure measurement. In the dynamic gas modification procedure, the reacting gas is passed through the substrate and dissipated. Temperature and gas flow may be controlled, with the limitation of pressure build-up at the substrate site. Relatively large amounts of gas may be passed through the sample. The main difference between both procedures is the type of control of the reaction mechanism. For static reactions, the reaction velocity is controlled
186 thermodynamically. In the dynamic regime, on the other hand, the processes are under kinetic control.
F
[ A
C
Figure 8.13 Dynamic volumetric gas adsorption apparatus, (A) sample compartment, (B) calibrated volume bowls, (C) cryogenic trap, 09) manometer, (E) evacuation line, 07) circulation pump.
Small amounts of substrate (form 0.2 to several grams) may be modified. Therefore, this type of procedure is preferential in the fundamental research on modification mechanisms. For mechanistic study of reaction mechanisms various 'home-made' reactors have been build. Variable reagent dosing and spectroscopic detection systems have been
187 reported. 83'84'85 In these laboratory-scale procedures, either gaseous or volatile compounds may be used. Concerning volatiles, mainly volatile liquids, such as shortchain chloro- and alkoxysilanes have been reported. However some crystalline organic solids, which are of interest for silica modification, may also be deposited from the vapour phase. Solid amino acids, nucleic bases and carboxylic acids may be sublimed without decomposition at normal or reduced pressure and elevated temperature. The adsorption of carboxylic acids from the vapour phase, with formation of Si-O-CO-R bonds has been reported by Basyuk. 86 Studies on the modification with diborane, and various organosilanes have been reported and will be discussed in subsequent chapters. Hydrolysis and condensation behaviour are analogous to modification procedures in dry organic solvent. However, controlled gas phase procedures allow a better control of reaction conditions, leading to a more reproducible coating layer. While the possibility to form true monolayered coatings from solution has been doubted, 73'85gas phase modification is generally agreed to give monolayer modification.
References
H.A. Mottola, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, H.A. Mottola and J.R. Steinmetz eds., Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1992, 1. 0
Q
.
0
0
E.P. Plueddemann, Silane Coupling Agents, Plenum Press, New York, 1991. R.M. Smith, Gas and Liquid Chromatography in Analytical Chemistry, John Wiley & Sons, 1988. K.B. Sentell, D.M. Bliesner and S.T. Shearer, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 190. T.S. Den, H.G. Kicinski and A.A. Kattrup, in Chemically Modified Surfaces in Science and Industry, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach Science Publ., New York, 1988, 621. K. Albert, J. Schmid, B. Pfleiderer and E. Bayer, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, H.A. Mottola and J.R. Steinmetz eds., Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1992, 105.
188 7. 0
M.J. Wirth and H.O. Fatunmbi, Anal. Chem., 1993, 65, 822. M.J. Wirth and H.O. Fatunmbi, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 203.
9.
B. Porsch and J. Kratka, J. Chromatogr., 1991, 543, 1.
10.
R.S. Shreedhara Murthy and J.P. Berry, in Chemically Modified Oxide Surfaces, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach Science Publ., New York, 1990, 151.
11.
M.R. Schure, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 181.
12.
R.K. Gilpin and M.E. Gangoda, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1990, 28, 277.
13.
H. Engelhardt, H. Low, W. Beck and W. Gotzinger, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, H.A. Mottola and J.R. Steinmetz eds., Elsevier, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 1992, 225.
14.
M. Petro and D. Berek, Chromatographia, 1993, 37, 549.
15.
K.K. Unger, Porous Silica its properties and use as support in column liquid chromatography, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1979.
16.
W.W. Yau, J.J. Kirkland and D.D. Bly, Modem size-exclusion liquid chromatography. Practice of gel permeation and gel filtration chromatography., John Wiley, Chichester, 1979.
17.
H. Engelhardt and D. Mathes, J. Chromatogr., 1975, 108, 85.
18.
B. Porsch, J. Chromatogr. A, 1993, 653, 1.
19.
M.J.J. Hetem, J.W. De Haan, L.J.M. Van De Ven, J.A. Rijks and C.A. Cramers, in Chemically Modified Oxide Surfaces, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach Science Publ., New York, 1990, 387.
20.
D.E. Leyden and G.H. Luttrell, Anal. Chem., 1975, 47, 1612.
21.
D.E. Leyden, G.H. Luttrell and G.E. Sloan, N.J. DeAngelis, Anal. Chim. Acta, 1976, 84, 97.
22.
I. Taylor and A.G. Howard, Anal. Chim. Acta, 1993, 271, 77.
23.
R.J. Kvitek, J.F. Evans and P.W. Carr, Anal. Chim. Acta, 1982, 144, 93.
24.
G.V. Kudryavtsev, D.V. Miltchenko, V.V. Yagov and A.A. Lopatkin, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1990, 140, 114.
189
25.
A.M. Klonkowski and C.W. Schlaepfer, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., 1991, 129, 101.
26.
T. Seshadri and H.-J. Haupt, in Chemically Modified Surfaces in Science and Industry, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach Science Publ., New York, 1988, 531.
27.
C. Kantipuly and S. Katragadda, A. Chow, H.D. Gesser, Talanta, 1990, 37, 491.
28.
J.R. Jezorek and H. Freiser, Anal. Chem., 1979, 51,366.
29.
L.L. Murrel, in Advanced Materials in Catalysis, J.J. Burton and F.L. Garten eds., Academic Press, New York, 1977, 235.
30.
M.T. Hoffmann, S.M.C. Neiva, M.R. Martins and D.W. Franco, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, H.A. Mottola and J.R. Steinmetz eds., Elsevier, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, 1992, 257.
31.
M. Kamada, H. Nishijama and Y. Kera, Bull. Chem. Soc. Japan, 1993, 66, 3565.
32.
E. Carlier, A. Guyot, A. Revillon, M.-F. Llauro-Darricades and R. Petiaud, React. Polym., 1991/1992, 16, 41.
33.
E. Carlier, A. Guyot and A. Revillon, React. Polym., 1991/1992, 16, 115.
34.
E. Carlier, A. Revillon, A. Guyot and P. Baumgartner, React. Polym., 1993, 21, 15.
35.
T.J. Pinnavaia, J. G-S. Lee and M. Abedini, in Silylated Surfaces, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach, London, 1980, 333.
36.
P. Tundo and P. Vanturello, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 1979, 101, 6606.
37.
L. Gianfreda and M.R. Scarfi, Mol. Cell. Biol., 1991, 100, 97.
38.
W.H. Scouten, R. Rines, C. Elhardt, J. Putker, E. de Vries, P. Jones, E. Edsmalm and B. Lindner, in Chemically Modified Surfaces in Science and Industry, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach Science Publ., New York, 1988, 35.
39.
H.H. Weetall, in Immobilized Enzymes for Industrial Reactors, R.A. Messing ed., Academic Press, New York, 1975, 99.
40.
E. Vandenberg, H. Elwing, A. Askendal and I. Lundstr6m, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1991, 143, 327.
41.
K.M.R. Kallury, W.E. Lee and M. Thompson, Anal. Chem., 1992, 64, 1062.
42.
K.M.R. Kallury, W.E. Lee and M. Thompson, Anal. Chem., 1993, 65, 2459.
190 43.
K.M.R. Kallury and M. Thompson, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., the Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 58.
44.
J.M.S. Cabral and J.F. Kennedy, in Protein Immobilization: Fundamentals and Applications, R.F. Taylor ed., Marcel Dekker, New York, 1991, 73.
45.
A.M. Klibanov, Science, 1983, 219, 722.
46.
G. Gfibitz, E. Kfinssberg, P. Van Zoonen, H. Janssen, C. Gooijer, N.H. Velthorst and R.W. Frei, in Chemically Modified Surfaces in Science and Industry, D.E. Leyden and W.T. Collins eds., Gordon and Breach Science Publ., New York, 1988, 129.
47.
P. Mohr and K. Pommering, Affinity Chromatography: practical and theoretical aspects, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1985.
48.
W.H. Scouten, Affinity Chromatography, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1981.
49.
P. Creatrecasas and C.B. Anfinsen, Ann. Rev. Biochem., 1971, 40, 259.
50.
D. Mislovicova, I. Novak and M. Pasteka, J. Chromatogr., 1991, 543, 9.
51.
K.K. Chawla, Composite Materials, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1987.
52.
E.P. Plueddemann, in Silanes and other Coupling Agents, K.L. Mittal ed., VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 1992, p.3.
53.
F.M. Fowkes, J. Adhesion Sci. Technol., 1987, 1, 7.
54.
D.W. Dwight, F.M. Fowkes, D.A. Cole, M.J. Kulp, P.J. Sabat, L. Salvati Jr. and T.C. Huang, J. Adhesion Sci. Technol., 1990, 4, 619.
55.
U. Deschler, P. Kleinschmitt and P. Panster, Angew. Chemie, 1986, 98, 237.
56.
E. Vanderheyden, PhD thesis, University of Antwerp, Antwerp, 1989.
57.
J.H. Helbert and N. Saha, in Silanes and Other Coupling Agents, K.L. Mittal ed., VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 1992, p.439.
58.
P. Clechet and N. Jaffrezic-Renault, Adv. Mater., 1990, 2, 293.
59.
E.T. Vandenberg, L. Bertilsson, B. Liedberg, K. Uvdal, R. Erlandsson, H. Elwing and I. Lundstr6m, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1991, 147, 103.
60.
J. Griffiths, Ind. Min., 1987, 11, 23.
61.
D.A. White, S.M. Oleff, R.D. Boyer, P.A. Budinger and J.R. Fox, Adv. Ceram. Mater., 1987, 2, 45.
191 62.
H. Zhang and C.G. Pantano, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 1990, 73, 958.
63.
P. Marage, M. Langlet and J.C. Joubert, Thin Solid Films, 1994, 238, 218.
64.
B. Arkles, Chemtech, 1977, 7, 766.
65.
N. Nishijama, R. Shick and H. Ishida, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1991, 143, 146.
66.
K.L. Mittal ed., Silanes and Other Coupling Agents, VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 1992, 119-198.
67.
S.W. Morrall, PhD dissertation, Fort Collins, Colorado, 1984.
68.
D.J. Tutas, R. Stromberg and E. Passaglia, SPE Trans., 1964, 4, 256.
69.
J.P. Blitz, R.S.S. Murthy and D.E. Leyden, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 121, 63.
70.
J.P. Blitz, R.S.S. Murthy and D.E. Leyden, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1987, 109, 7141.
71.
J.P. Blitz, R.S.S. Murthy and D.E. Leyden, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 126, 387.
72.
K.C. Vrancken, P. Van Der Voort, K. Possemiers, P. Grobet and E.F. Vansant, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 46.
73.
K.M.R. Kallury, P.M. MacDonald and M. Thompson, Langmuir, 1994, 10, 492.
74.
R. Maoz and J. Sagiv, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1984, 100, 465.
75.
D.A. Offord and J.H. Griffin, Langmuir, 1993, 9, 3015.
76.
J.D. Le Grange, J.L. Markham and C.R. Kurkjian, I.angmuir, 1993, 9, 1746.
77.
S.R. Wasserman, G.M. Whitesides, I.M. Tidswell, B.M. Ocko, P.S. Pershan and J.D. Axe, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1989, 111, 5852.
78.
J.J. Pesek, J.E. Sandoval, C.-H. Chu and E. Jonsson, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, H.A. Mottola and J.R. Steinmetz eds., Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1992, 57.
79.
J.J. Pesek, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 1.
80.
C.-H. Chu, E. Jonsson, M. Auvinen, J.J. Pesek and J.E. Sandoval, Anal. Chem., 1993, 65, 808.
81.
J.E. Sandoval and J.J. Pesek, Anal. Chem., 1989, 61, 2067.
192 82.
K.G. Proctor and J.P. Blitz, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, H.A. Mottola and J.R. Steinmetz eds., Elsevier Science Publ., Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1992, 209.
83.
J.B. Danner and J.M. Vohs, Appl. Surf. Sci., 1992, 62, 255.
84.
D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Phys. Chem., 1982, 86, 5208.
85.
D.G. Kurth and T. Bein, J. Phys. Chem., 1992, 96, 6707.
86.
V.A. Basyuk, React. Kinet. Catal. Lett., 1993, 50, 83.
193
Chapter 9 Modification with silicon compounds: mechanistic studies
The organosilane modification of silica is of great importance in science and industry. Because of its widespread applications, there is a lot of interest in the underlying reaction mechanisms in the modification process. A fundamental understanding of these mechanisms can lead to an improvement of known applications and the development of new ones. Thus, fundamental knowledge supports industrial development. Mechanistic studies are performed on model systems with low complexity. Therefore organic solvent and vapour phase modification procedures are mostly used. Thus, the concentration of the reactants and the presence of water in the system may be easily controlled. From a careful description of the simple model systems, extrapolation towards large-scale industrial processes may be performed. In this part, we wish to focus on the study of two types of silanes. Aminoorganosilanes are special members of the alkoxysilanes group. They carry the catalyzing amine function, required for chemical bonding with the silica surface, inside the molecule. This makes them more reactive than other organosilanes and reduces the complexity of the liquid phase reaction system to be studied. Only three components, silica, silane and solvent, are present. Furthermore there is a large interest in the reaction mechanism of silica gel with APTS, since this aminosilane is the most widely used compound of the organosilane family. Chlorosilanes are discussed, considering both those with short-chain and long-chain organic groups. Short-chain chlorosilanes are important as model compounds in the general study of silica surface reactivity in vapour phase modification. Furthermore,
194 these compounds are very valid in the Chemical Surface Coating method, which will be discussed in part 3. The long-chain (Cs, C~s) organosilanes are very important in the fabrication of stationary phases. For these, special liquid phase modification procedures have been developed. The underlying mechanism deserves special attention. Finally, the modification with alkoxysilanes and alkylsiloxanes is briefly discussed.
1 Modification with aminosilanes Aminoorganofunctional alkoxysilanes (named as aminosilanes for clarity) carry one or more amine groups in the organic chain. This amine group is responsible for the specific chemical reaction behaviour and high reactivity of the aminosilane molecules. The electron rich amine centre can enter into hydrogen bonding interactions with hydrogen donating groups, such as hydroxyls or other amines. Because of its basic character (pI~ = 10.8 for a terminal primary amine), the amine is easily protonated. The three most widely used and studied aminosilanes are: ~ ~-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (APTS, (CH3CH20)3SiCH2CH2CH2NH2) ,
~,-aminopropyldiethoxymethylsilane (APDMS, (CH3CH20)2CH3SiCH2CH2CH2NH2) and N-~-aminoethyl-q~-aminopropyltrimethoxysilane, (AEAPTS ((CH30)3SiCH2CH2CH2NHCH2CH2NH2). Mixing of an aminosilane with silica gel results in a fast adsorption, by hydrogen bonding of the amine to a surface hydroxyl group. 2 After adsorption, the amine group can catalyze the condensation of the silicon side of the molecule with a surface silanol. Thus siloxane bonds with the surface may be formed in the absence of water. 3'4 For other silanes the siloxane bond formation requires an initial hydrolysis of the ethoxy groups or the addition of an amine in the reaction mixture. ~ This general reaction scheme has been presented in chapter 8. Here we will go into further detail on the types of interaction of the aminosilane with the silica surface and the characterization of the bonded silane species.
195 For the modification of silica with aminosilanes, the liquid phase procedure is usually applied. Only few studies have described the vapour phase APTS modification. 6'7 The modification proceeds in three steps. (i) A thermal pretreatment of the silica determines the degree of hydration and hydroxylation of the surface. (ii) In the loading step, the pretreated substrate is stirred with the silane in the appropriate solvent. (iii) Curing of the coating is accomplished in a thermal treatment. On industrial scale ethanol/water is used as a solvent, on lab-scale an organic solvent is used. The reasons for this discrepancy is the increased control on the reaction processes, possible in an organic solvent. This will be clarified by the discussion of the modification mechanism in aqueous solvent and the effect of water in the different modification steps. A correlation of data from literature is often hampered by the use of different reaction parameters or silica types. Therefore, a clear survey of the effect of parameters related to reaction conditions and substrate structure is given. Furthermore, a full description of the modification mechanism is only possible if the processes occurring in the loading step and the curing step are discussed separately. The study of each of these steps requires dedicated analytical procedures. For the study of the loading step, most analyses are performed on the silane/solvent mixture, while spectroscopic analyses are performed on the modified substrate after drying and curing. The amine side of the molecule requires special attention. The orientation of the aminosilane molecule on the silica surface is determined by the amine-surface interactions. This orientation is of great interest for any further application of the aminosilane modified silica substrate. In order to complete the full characterization of the aminosilane modification of silica, the specific role of silanols, both on the surface and on the silane molecule, will be regarded in detail. Silanol groups are the main reactive centers for chemical bonding, whatever the reaction conditions may be.
196
1.1 Modification of silica gel with aminosilanesfrom aqueous solution On industrial scale, water or water/ethanol mixtures are mostly used as a solvent for aminosilane modification of silica or glass fibres. Water has a profound effect on the silane structure in solution. Alkoxy groups are hydrolyzed to silanols. Those can combine to form a siloxane linkage between two silane molecules, with production of a new water molecule (reaction (A)). 2 -Si-OEt
+ 2 HzO--, 2 --Si-OH + 2 EtOH
- Si-OH + HO-Si-
~
- Si-O-Si-
+ H20
(A)
This reaction is generally applicable for organosilanes. However, APTS solutions are more stable towards polymerization than non-aminated silanes. This effect and the consequences of the APTS solute structure on the eventual modified layer structure will be discussed in this paragraph. 1.1.1 The APTS structure in aqueous solution Aqueous solutions of APTS have a clearly enhanced stability towards polymerization, compared to other, non-aminated, organosilanes. Based on his own work and on the FTIR study of Chiang et al., g Plueddemann 9 proposed the formation of an intramolecular seven membered ring in order to explain this special behaviour. This hypothesis was further supported by results of thermometric enthalpy titrations, performed by Kelly and Leyden. ~~ The ring conformation is given in figure 9.1. The bonding of a silanol hydrogen explains the stability against cross-linking. With a change of pH of the solution, acid-base equilibria govern the aminosilane conformation. This was studied by Chu et al., ~ using ~SN NMR on aqueous solutions of ~SN enriched APTS. NMR spectra at different pH are given in figure 9.2.
The nitrogen chemical shifts are -1.2, 2.8 and 6.8 ppm respectively. In 'neat' APTS, a resonance was found at-4.8 ppm. Both this peak and the -1.2 peak found in strong base (figure 9.2 a), are assigned to the free amine form. In acid (figure 9.2 c), the amine is in the protonated or 'open' amine cation form. The closed 7-membered ring,
197
..
"kc H
I-I
H
o
si /
n N
2.02 A
H H
O~
H/"2.45 ~
Figure 9.1 7-membered ring conformation of aminopropylsilanetriol, taken from ref (9) with permission. "~- NH 2
b C pH<
ioo
~o
~o
~o
~o
~o
~o
PPN
~o
~o
'1o
~
'-~o
'-2o
1
'-3o
Figure 9.2 15N NMR spectra of aqueous APTS solution; (a) strong base (pH > 13), (b) ambient (pH 10- 11), (c) acid (pH < 1), taken from ref (11) with permission. as proposed by Plueddemann, is expected to resonate between both of these forms. The position of the resonance is expected to reflect the state of hydrogen bonding. The closer the proton is to the amine, the more downfield the resonance. The resonance found at 2.8 ppm (figure 9.2 b) is assigned to an APTS having considerable cation character. Therefore both the closed hydrogen bonded form and an internal zwitterion structure may be supported. In the internal zwitterion a proton is transferred from a silane silanol to the amine group.
198 -O(OH)2Si-CH2CH2CH2NH3 +
Concluding, we may state that in aqueous solutions of APTS the amine is involved in acid-base interactions. The conformation of the molecule changes with changing pH of the medium. At natural pH (10.8) the hydrolyzed aminosilane forms a 6- or 7 - m e m b e r e d ring structure, stabilized by internal hydrogen bonding or protonation.
1.1.2 Modification from aqueous solvent For silica modification with APTS, the pH of the aqueous solution also has an effect on the eventual loading of the surface. ~2 The APTS surface loading on dehydrated silica, is given as a function of pH in figure 9.3. The loading was measured by integration of the CH2 vibration bands, after internal normalization.
40
xlO 17 Mole~afles/ nag silica
30-
20-
10,,
0
I
2
4
I
I
6
8
I
10
12
pH
Figure 9.3 APTS loading on dehydrated silica as a function of pH of the treating solution. taken from ref (12) with permission.
199 The surface loading appears to be highly dependent on the structure of the amine group. Maximal adsorption is found at a pH 10.6, which is the natural pH of the APTS solution. The closed APTS forms appear to show better adsorption to the silica surface than both, free and cation, open forms. The silica iso-electric point is about 2. The SiO- concentration increases with increasing pH. At low pH, the tendency of the -NH3+C1- to interact with the SiOH is low. At higher pH the concentration of surface SiO- increases, allowing a better interaction with the aminosilane. At high pH, some of the APTS silanol groups are in the form of SiO- and have the tendency to repel the negatively charged surface. Immobilization of the aminosilane molecule changes its interaction characteristics. Because the surface silanols are more acidic than silane silanols, the interaction with the surface silanols is thermodynamically favoured over intramolecular interaction. Kelly and Leyden ~~measured the enthalpy of adsorption of the aminosilane molecules. Their results indicate that interaction with the surface involves more proton transfer than in the closed form dissolved molecules. The ultimate structure of the aminosilane layer has been characterized using spectroscopic methods. Initial monolayer formation was indicated by Pantano and Wittberg, using X P S . 13 Upon modification with dilute aqueous solution of various silanes, the thickness of the silane layer was shown to be dependent on the length of the organic functional group. Insight in the coating structure was obtained from a solid-state NMR study on silica modified with deuterated APTS, by Kang and Blum. ~4 The aminosilane molecules are adsorbed and reacted directly on the silica surface, by siloxane bond formation, until a monolayer coverage is obtained. Then a polysilsesquioxane layer is formed on top of the monolayer. The absorbed amount increases with increasing initial concentration of the silane solution. The polymer layer is intermolecularly condensed and indirectly bonded to the surface. The following may be concluded. The reaction process for modification in aqueous solvent is affected by the pH of the solution. Maximal loading is obtained at natural pH. The modification layer is composed of a chemically bonded monolayer and an overlying physically adsorbed polymer network.
200
1.2
The influence of water in the reaction of silica with APTS
The modification in aqueous solvent causes uncontrollable hydrolysis and polymerization of the aminosilane molecules. Irreproducible coatings result. In order to control this parameter, modification procedures in dry organic solvents have been set up. The use of organic solvent allows a better control of reaction parameters and is therefore preferred in the study of the modification mechanism. Additionally, it allows the controlled adding of water in the reaction mixture. Thus, the exact role of water in the various modification steps may be assessed. The knowledge of the influence of water in the reaction mechanism forms the bridge from aqueous to organic phase modification. Many surface analysis techniques have been applied in studies on the reaction mechanism of APTS with silica gel. ~5 In order to study the chemical structure and interactions of the surface compound, FTIR has been recognized as a very powerful tooI.2,s,16,17, is
The infrared spectrum provides information on the presence and physical interactions of functional groups. Complementary information on the chemical environment and coordination of the Si and C atoms in the coating can be obtained from CP MAS N M R . 4'19'20'21'22'23'24 Thus a combination of both techniques allows a clear description of the physical and chemical interactions and coordination of silanes on silica. Both these techniques have been applied to study the influence of water in the three modification steps. 3 Every step will be discussed separately.
1.2.1 Reaction on hydrated silica gel Mesoporous silica gel was reacted with APTS (1%v/v APTS/solvent mixture), using various reaction and curing conditions. Sample-specific reaction conditions are indicated in table 9.1.
201 Table 9.1 Sample preparing conditions and integrated values of the siloxane band (1350-870 cm-1), ratioed to the reference band (1938-1766 cm-~)
sample
pretreatment
solvent
1 2 3 4
none 673 K air 673 K air 673 K air
C7H8 H20 1%H20/CTH 8 C7H8
curing conditions (20 h) 383 383 383 383
K air K air K air K air
SiOSi peak area 102.9 55.30 46.94 33.78
Hydrated silica gel was modified with APTS (sample 1) and studied by DRIFT (Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier Transform) and CP MAS NMR. The IR spectrum of the modified silica (figure 9.4) shows silane NH, CH and Si-O-Si bands along with silica lattice and surface vibrations. Assignments of IR bands of APTS modified silica are given in table 9.2. Table 9.2 IR vibration bands: frequencies and band assignments 3'16'19
Wavenumber (cm1)
Assignment
3740 3740-3500 3373 3310 2978 2936 2869 1940-1770 1597 1471 1448 1413 1393 1250-1020 800
free Si-OH vibration (stretching) bridged Si-OH vibration (stretching) NH vibration (stretching) NH vibration (stretching) CH3 vibration (stretching) CH2 vibration (stretching) CH2 vibration (stretching) Si-O-Si vibration NH2 bending CH2 bending CH3bending Si-CH2 bending CH3 bending vibration Si-O-Si asymmetric stretching vibration OH bending
202
Kubelka - Munk units
f
0.8 -
0.6-
0.4
0.2
4000
'
3(~0
'
2000
'
10~
500
Wavenumber/cm"1 Figure 9. 4. DRIFT spectrum of hydrated silica, reacted with APTS in toluene solution, dried in air.
The influence of water can be investigated in studying the CH3 and Si-O-Si band areas, because hydrolysis and subsequent polymerization will decrease the former and increase the latter. In practice the asymmetrical CH 3 stretching (p = 2978 cm -~ ) and the Si-O-Si stretching (1350 - 870 cm ~) bands are most suited. The position of the NH 2 vibrational modes indicates a perturbation of the NH 2 group. Hydrogen bonding shifts the maxima of the stretching vibration bands to below 3370 and 3310 cm ~, respectively. The absence of the CH3 band and the magnitude of Si-O-Si band together with the position of the NH vibration modes (3367, 3300 cm ~) indicate the formation of a polymerized aminopropylsiloxane coating with NH2 groups interacting with Si-OH groups by means of hydrogen bonding (figure 9.5, structure I). In analogy with this, Kallury et al. 4 reported that surface water promotes amine-surface interactions and orients the amino moieties towards the surface. These conclusions were based on XPS results. Further details of the amine-surface interaction in loading and curing step will be given in the subsequent chapters.
203
* category
(i)
surface water, water solvent
~////////////////////////////~ = silica
R' O\Si/,R' /\ S i \/ / O
O O
surface
R,. H
* category (ii) Modificationof dry silica gel a) air curing H/ H\ CH CH O
o
\ Si/
/
\
(CI'I2) 3 - N ~ H
o
CH3 CH 2%
O o"
It' \ Si
R' Si/
/R'
O
c. c.:o
H
\ St'"
R'
b) vacuumcuring
Si O /
H
/
"O-Si-
\O
IV
Figure 9.5 Bonding models of APTS on silica gel.
These observations are further confirmed by the 29Si and ~3C CP MAS NMR spectra of the modified compound (figure 9.6 a, b). Band assignments of the 29Si spectra of APTS modified silica have been fully elaborated by De Haan et al. 2~ Comparing the shielding effects of ethoxy and hydroxy substituents, they proposed that hydrolyzed and non-hydrolyzed monodentate species have a different peak position. Thus, the following assignment was effectuated: R O - S i/\ Si / \
6
o (a) -67ppm
R
\Si / \ o
OR'
(b) -59ppm
R
R
EtO - S iI - OEt
HO - _~;i - OH
6
(c) -52.gppm
6
(d) -49.2ppm
R'-H or Et
In the spectrum of the modified hydrated silica (figure 9.6 a), the peaks corresponding to tridentate (a) and bidentate (b) species are clearly present. Peaks in the -100 ppm region are due to surface silicon atoms, with peaks at -100 ppm and -109 ppm for Q3 and Q4 sites, respectively (cfr. table 5.3). The peak corresponding to the monodentate (c) form is negligibly small, while the hydrolyzed monodentate (d) form is absent.
204
I
!
.
50
1
40
.
!
! . . . . . .
i
30
20
. . . .
1 .
.
10
.
.
L
=
0
6
I I
(a)
--4'0
'-
6o-i
,o"i,i0
....
Figure 9.6 Hydrated silica, modified in toluene solvent, air cured. (a) 29Si CP MAS NMR spectrum; (b) I~C CP MAS NMR spectrum.
The 29Si spectrum (figure 9.6 a) indicates the coating to be hydrolyzed and crosslinked. In order to conceive the contributions of the various species to every band, the spectra are deconvoluted. After deconvolution of the recorded spectrum into a sum of Gaussian curves, the different contributing signals can be integrated separately. For quantitative assessment some contact time and cross-polarization criteria have to be met. Optimal conditions are obtained from a variable contact time experiment. Full details have been worked out by Pfleiderer 2s and Caravajal et al. 2~a2 In general, quantitative correlations should only be made for species within one spectrum and not
205 between various spectra. Thus, the relative population of the different surface structures present can be determined. From the integration data a 40/60 ratio of the APTS molecules in the bidentate/tridentate form can be calculated. The presence of the monodentate form can be neglected in comparison to the amount of the other two forms. Because three covalent bonds with the surface can be excluded on steric grounds, the tridentate form implies polymerization of the APTS molecules. The ~3C spectrum (fig. 9.6 b) indicates a total loss of ethoxy groups as no peaks are observed at 57.6 ppm (-OCH2-) and 15.9 ppm (-OCHz_C_.CH3). The three observed peaks have been assigned ~9to the propyl carbons ( ctCH=9.5 ppm,/3CH=26.3 ppm, qtCH =43.3 ppm). The ~3C shift value of the ctCH is an indication of the stability of the aminosilane coating on the silica surface. Caravaja122 has shown that an increase in the APTS coating stability shifts the aCH peak to higher shift value (APTS solution ctCH=7.9 ppm). The observed peak position of the ctCH (9.5 ppm) indicates the covalent attachment of the silane molecules to the silica surface. Surface water can cause hydrolysis and polymerisation of the APTS coating, leading to a coating with 60% of the molecules having a structure of type I (figure 9.5). The residual 40% occur as the type II structure in the hydrolyzed form.
1.2.2
Water in the solvent-silica system
Various experiments were performed on dehydrated silica gel, using different amounts of water in the reaction phase. Polymer formation is evaluated by integrating the SiO-Si stretching band. The results are summarized in table 9.1. By rationing the integrated value to the internal reference band (1938 - 1766 cml) 16 variations in the silica surface (Si-O-Si) contribution to the different samples are ruled out. Integrated values show a clear increase with increasing water content of the solvent. It is therefore obvious that the amount of water is the determining factor in the polymerization process. Additionally, the DRIFT spectrum of the sample reacted in toluene solvent (sample 4) shows residual ethoxy groups, whereas the aqueous samples (samples 2, 3) do not have the CH 3 band. Comparing the Si-O-Si peak area of the dehydrated, aqueous modified sample (2) to the hydrated sample reacted in toluene
206 (sample 1) shows an increase in the amount of polymerized silane molecules on the silica surface for the latter sample. Comparable results have been obtained by MorraU 2 and Caravajal et al. 22 A higher APTS loading was found on a hydrated silica reacted in toluene solvent, compared to modification in aqueous solvent. Therefore, it can be concluded that the polymerization takes place at the silica surface, i.e. after adsorption of the aminosilane molecules. The surface effect can be explained by the interaction of the silane NH2 group with the substrate surface. As shown above, in water solvent the hydrolyzed aminosilane molecules are stabilized by internal hydrogen bonding of the amino group to the silane hydroxyls. When the amino group is H-bonded to a surface hydroxyl group this stabilization disappears and the silane silanols can condense to form a siloxane linkage. When the reaction is performed with hydrated silica in a dry solvent (sample 1), the hydrolysis only takes place at the silica surface and can immediately be followed by the condensation reaction. In both cases, structures of type I are formed. Reaction in a dry solvent with dehydrated silica (sample 4) minimizes the hydrolysis and polymerization in the reaction stage. Bonding takes place by direct condensation of the silane silicon with a silica surface hydroxyl, with loss of ethanol.
1.2.3 Air humidity in the curing stage In order to study the influence of air humidity in the curing stage, a post reaction curing was performed in air at 383 K (sample 4) and in vacuum at 423 K (sample 5). In both samples dehydrated silica was reacted in a dry solvent, minimizing the influence of hydrolysis in the first two modification stages. DRIFT spectra of both samples (figure 9.7) show a higher ethoxy content for the vacuum cured sample. Increasing the curing temperature has been reported to cause a decrease in the ethoxy content. 22 Therefore, a higher degree of covalent bonding to the silica surface, i.e. a lower ethoxy content, is expected for this sample. The observed loss of ethoxy groups can be attributed to the influence of air humidity in the curing stage, inducing hydrolysis, possibly followed by oligomerization, even for samples reacted in dry conditions. The polymerization, however, is reduced, comparing to the reaction in the presence of water. The existence of silane silanols,
207
3050
2920
2 7 9J 0
waven u mber/cm - 1
Figure 9. 7 DRIFT spectra of APTS modified silica gel: (a) air cured," (b) vacuum cured. oligomers and residual ethoxy groups can be concluded (figure 9.5, structure II, III). Only when the reaction and the curing stage are performed without any water present (sample 5) a hydrolysis can be prevented, leading to a type IV surface structure. These results are again confirmed by CP MAS NMR measurements. Vacuum pretreated vacuum cured samples were prepared, with minimal water contact. The influence of air humidity in the curing stage was tested by precuring one sample in air for 2 h (sample 7). ~3C NMR spectra are presented in figure 9.8. Ethoxy peaks are visible at 57.6 ppm (-OCH2-) and at 15.8 ppm (-OCH2..C_.CH3). The ethoxy content of the air precured sample (figure 5A) is clearly reduced, compared to the non-precured sample (figure 9.8 b). The z9si spectra, however, show no clear difference in relative species population. Both samples have 60% of the surface species in the bidentate form, with 20% both in mono- and tridentate form. The bidentate species however covers molecules with R' =H as well as R' = C H 2 C H 3. A decrease in the ethoxycontent with constant population of the bidentate species indicates the conversion of the-OCH2CH 3 into a - O H group, without further condensation. This conversion should be attributed to the influence of the air
208
I
I
I
I
) I
--
|
. . . . . . .
70
,
1
.
.
60
.
.
.
.
I
1 . . . . . . . .
50
!
. . . . . . . .
40
i
30
. . . . .
|
20
._
i
. . . . . . . . .
10
i
,_
0
6 Figure 9,8 13CCP MAS NMR spectra of dry treated APTS-modified silica: (a) 2h, 383K air precured; (b) 423K vacuum cured.
humidity. The coating in sample 7 mainly has the type II structure. The stability of the OH group is caused by a H-bond with the NH2 group of a neighbouring silane molecule or by the isolated character of these groups at the surface. Air humidity therefore, appears to have a clear influence on the hydrolysis of surface bonded APTS molecules.
209 1.2.4 Conclusion The effect of surface water and air humidity on the hydrolysis of APTS molecules adsorbed on the silica surface may be characterized as follows. Short time exposures to humid air cause partial hydrolysis of the modified layer. Extensive hydrolysis is only caused by surface adsorbed water. Hydrolyzed aminosilane molecules at the surface condense to form an aminopropylpolysiloxane layer. Only when all three modification stages (pretreating, loading, curing) are performed in completely dry conditions, hydrolysis of ethoxy groups can be prevented. The structures formed under the various modification conditions are summarized in figure 9.5.
1.3 Modelling of the interactions in the loading step In the broad range of literature on the organosilane modification of silica gel, most studies are based on spectroscopic analysis of the modified substrate. This requires a drying or curing step before analysis. This curing and drying may cause desorption and/or condensation of adsorbed molecules, thus changing the modification structure. Therefore, no data on the adsorption mechanism or the processes occurring in the loading step can be obtained from this type of studies. Still these processes are of interest because they control the ultimate structure of the modified layer. In literature distinction between loading and curing processes is not always made clearly. In order to clarify this interchange of information, we will discuss the mechanisms of loading and curing step in separate paragraphs. The bifunctionality of the aminosilane molecules is responsible for their specific chemical behaviour. The interaction of the amine group, and its role in the adsorption mechanism was already indicated in the previous paragraph. The different types of interaction of the amino group and its role in the modification mechanism will be evaluated in a separate paragraph. Here we consider the general physical and chemical adsorption of the silane molecule. Discussions will mainly be concerned with the silicon side of the molecule. In the few studies reporting on loading processes, specific analysis procedures have been developed in order to evaluate the course of the aminosilane deposition. Those include various in situ FTIR techniques as well as solvent analysis by various
210
analytical or spectrometric methods. These allow the measuring of adsorption kinetics and the building of adsorption isotherms. The correlation of data from literature is often hampered by the different reaction conditions and types of silica used in various studies. In order to overcome this problem, the effect of the porosity of the substrate on the reaction mechanism is studied. Also here a difference has to be made between the effect in the loading and curing step.
1.3.1 Adsorption kinetics and isotherms
Adsorption kinetics For the measuring of adsorption kinetics two criteria have to be met. The amount of compound adsorbed has to be quantified, and analyses have to be performed with short time intervals. Both these criteria are difficult to meet for reactions in solution. Various researchers have set up analysis procedures for this type of measurement. Morrall 2 used a HPLC system with two columns. The first column was loaded with the controlled pore glass (CPG) to be modified. The second column was used for separation of the reaction effluents. This column was coupled to a refractive index detector, allowing for quantitative detection of the effluents. The reaction was initiated by injecting an APTS/toluene mixture and stopped by injection of pure toluene. With this so-called stop-flow mechanism reaction times down to 18 seconds could be used. From these analyses it became evident that upon mixing of the aminosilane with the silica, a very rapid physisorption occurs. The initial adsorption of the APTS (from toluene solution on dried CPG) occurred before the 18 second minimum time delay of the stop-flow apparatus. For non-aminated silanes the adsorption proved to be much slower. This study also revealed the pivotal role of surface water in the modification of siliceous surfaces with alkoxysilanes, as discussed in the previous chapter. Vandenberg et al. 15used liquid/solid ellipsometry to obtain kinetic data. The thickness of the APTS coating on oxidized silicon wafers was measured, as a function of immersion time in APTS/toluene solution. The deposition profile showed a fast initial
211 adsorption, followed by a slower process. This was interpreted as an indication that the APTS first adsorbs non-covalently to the surface. After 30 min. reaction time, the deposition rate increases again. This additional adsorption was not further discussed. An analogous reaction profile is found using freeze sampling analysis. 26 In this technique, small samples are taken from the silane/toluene/silica gel reaction mixture, which are immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen to stop the reaction. The reaction mixture is stirred in order to secure a homogeneous mixing of the silica powder through the entire reaction volume. The samples are allowed to melt and are immediately centrifuged to separate substrate and solvent. The supernatant is than analyzed by classical Kjeldahl nitrogen analysis. From this analysis, surface loading is obtained as a function of reaction time. The surface loading (1) is generally expressed as amount adsorbed (mmol) per unit of mass (g) (or area (m2)) of the pure silica. The amount adsorbed is usually obtained from analysis of the residual amount of silane in the solvent at equilibrium (Cf). Various techniques have been applied to measure this quantity. Thus, surface loading 1 is given by" l=
(C i - C~
ms
(1)
With Ci the initially added amount of silane and ms the initial mass of the substrate. The reaction profiles of APTS and AEAPTS are displayed in figure 9.9. The reaction proceeds identically for both silanes in the first few minutes after mixing. At a reaction time of 6 min. a clear divergence occurs. Both compounds reach an equilibrium adsorption within one minute of reaction. This reflects the quick adsorption of the amine group, forming hydrogen bonds with the surface silanols. The lack of further deposition indicates that an equilibrium is reached. Because the reaction is performed in a dry solvent, on a dehydrated substrate, no oligomerization of the silane molecules can occur. It may be concluded, accordingly, that the equilibrium situation reflects the formation of a monolayer coating on the silica surface.
212
Loading (mmo1~g)
1.3
1.2
D 0
rl
[]
D 9
I.I []
D 9
1.0 0.9
1
10 100 Reaction time (m~n,)
1000
Figure 9.9 Silane loading on dried mesoporous silica gel as a function of reaction time," ( i ) APTS, (F-l) AEAPTS.
For the AEAPTS, carrying two amine groups, a two step adsorption is found. This indicates that an amine of the organic chain remains free in the first step (t < 6 min.) and is able to adsorb an additional layer of silane molecules. Secondary amines are better acceptors for hydrogen bonds than primary ones. The secondary amine will therefore enter in the initial hydrogen bonding with the surface silanols much more readily than the primary amine at the end of the organic chain. It will be the primary amine function, that remains free and is able to adsorb silane molecules from solution. Thus a secondary aminosilane layer is build up on the silica surface. Upon adsorption of the secondary layer, again an equilibrium situation is reached. For the monofunctional APTS, the observed deposition profile is identical to that reported by Vandenberg et al., using liquid/solid ellipsometry. ~5 The rapid, first equilibrium is followed by an additional adsorption. The equilibrium situation is related to the localized adsorption of silane molecules on the surface hydroxyls. Thus forming a monolayered coating on the surface. The extent of the additional adsorption was found to be not very reproducible and not strictly correlated to the initial silane concentration. At any time it showed not to have the step-wise profile, as found for the bifunctional aminosilane. Therefore, this last adsorption appears to be of a nonspecific type. We will discuss this further below.
213
Adsorption isotherms Further information on the adsorption process may be obtained from adsorption isotherm data. The construction of these isotherms for liquid phase processes differs from the well-known gas phase adsorption isotherms. For the liquid phase adsorption, the surface loading is plotted as a function of the equilibrium concentration of adsorbate (Cf). Adsorption isotherms for APTS and AEAPTS from acetone/water solvent on high surface area fumed silica were reported by Blum et al. 27 The aminosilane molecules show Langmuir type adsorption to the silica surface. Analysis data were recorded after shaking the silica with the treating solution, centrifugation and FTIR analysis of the supernatant. The absorbance values were determined by measuring the absorbance at 2877 cm -~ (methylene C-H stretch) in the difference spectra, after subtracting solvent contributions. With this method, the precision of a single adsorption experiment appeared to be very good, while reproducibility of the entire isotherm was poor. This was attributed to the wide variety of reactions undergone by the silanes, in this type of solvent. FTIR was also used by Trens. 7 Equilibrium concentrations were determined on the supernatant after centrifugation, by measuring the transmittance signal at 950 or 1104 cm -~. Isotherm data were recorded for modification of a precipitated silica gel (SBET = 25 m2/g) with APTS in aqueous as well as organic solvent. For the modification in aqueous solvent, a Langmuir type isotherm with a sharp rise at the origin, indicating the high affinity of the APTS for the silica surface, and a clear plateau was obtained. An analogous isotherm type was found for adsorption from organic solvent. A clear difference was observed for dehydrated and non-dehydrated silica. The plateau value decreases from 0.175 mmol/g to 0.057 mmol/g upon dehydration of the substrate. In the same work, isotherms for gas-phase adsorption of APTS are reported also. APTS loadings are lower than for the liquid phase adsorption. Relating data from different silicas and glass fibres, a clear correlation between water adsorption capacity of the substrate and silane affinity was found. Isotherm data at high equilibrium concentration for modification from organic solvent, have also been obtained by the freeze sampling method. The adsorption isotherm of APTS on dehydrated mesoporous silica from toluene solution is given in figure 9.10.
214
Loading (mmol]g) 2.0 1.6 1.2 9
9
9
m
9
9
0.8 0.4
0
2
,~
(i 8 1'0 Ceq (mmol)
1'2
1'4
16
Figure 9.10 Adsorption isotherm of APTS on dehydrated (673K) mesoporous silica gel from toluene solution, by freeze sampling method. The data points are obtained from adsorption values at equilibrium in the first 50 min. of reaction. At longer reaction times an additional adsorption was found, as reported above. The isotherm has two regions. For equilibrium concentrations up to 6 mmol, a plateau is observed, with a corresponding loading value of 1.02 mmol/g. This indicates the equilibrium formation of a monolayer coating of APTS on the silica surface, in the initial phase of the reaction. At higher concentration, the loading increases with increasing equilibrium concentration. At this excess of APTS over surface active sites, the equilibrium formation of a monolayer can not be pertained and the loading is proportional to the concentration of the aminosilane. Further insight in the structure of the coating, formed in both concentration regions, can be gained using two relative quantities, input ratio I, and degree of conversion X~. Both are defined as follows.
I-
NOn
(2)
Xa -
I
(3)
215 where NoH is the amount of OH groups (mmol) on the dehydrated silica surface (i.e. 1.44 mmol/g) and NAvrs the amount of APTS initially added to the reaction mixture. Modelling of the bonding type of the APTS molecules can be based on the relation between the values of I vs. X, for various concentrations of the silane used. In the case where all APTS forms a monolayer with one molecule of APTS occupying one surface silanol group over the whole range of concentrations, all experimental data would be situated on curve A (figure 9.11). A hypothetical monolayer having all APTS molecules coveting two hydroxyls is presented by curve B. It should be noted that curves A and B pass through the origin, because no intermolecular APTS reaction is assumed.
Xa
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
0.0
6.2
0'.4
I
6.6
6.8
i.0
i.2
1.4
Figure 9.11 Degree of conversion as a function of input ratio: ( ~ t ) monolayer modelling curves representing one (a) and two (b) hydroxy groups occupied by one APTS molecule; (- - - ) linear regression through experimental values for low and high concentrations.
216
Plotting of the experimental data for the low equilibrium concentration range (C~q= 0 - 6 mmol, i.e. I = 1.2 - 0.24) reveals that the data are linearly related. The linear regression curve passing through the data (X, = aI + b) has a slope a = 0.69 _+ 0.01, with a correlation r = 0.998. The good correlation between the data indicates that in this concentration range a similar type of coating is formed in the initial phase of the loading step, at all equilibrium concentrations. The data for the high concentration range (C~= 8 - 16 mmol, i.e. I = 0.18 - 0.09 ), can also be fitted with a linear curve. This curve, however, does not pass through the origin (figure 9.11), in contrast with both the modelling curves and the experimental curve at low concentration. Linear regression results in equation (4) : X,, = 0.73.1 + 0.04
(4)
with a correlation r = 0.991. The slopes of both curves through the experimental values (a~= 0.69 _ 0.01; a2 = 0.73 + 0.07) are equal within the margins of the respective standard errors. This indicates that for the high concentration range the first deposited layer is a monolayer, identical to the one formed at low concentrations. The positive intercept with the X~-axis (b) shows that at NoH = 0 (I = 0) still a conversion of 0.04 is reached, reflecting an intermolecular reaction of the APTS. Due to this intermolecular interaction, 4% of the initially added amount of APTS, is deposited on the first monolayer, leading to an equilibrium within the first minute of reaction. From these data the coordination of the APTS molecules with the surface can be evaluated. The inverse of the slope value gives the number of surface silanols bonded per APTS molecule, at initial monolayer coverage. A value of 1 . 4 0 H / A P T S is found. In the APTS monolayer, every APTS molecule is linked to an average of 1.4 surface silanols. This number gives no further information on the type or stability of interaction. Both the amine and the silicon side of the molecule may be involved. Generally, 60% of the monolayer molecules have a double interaction, and 40% interact with only one site. Further details have to be gained from other data. The adsorption isotherm for AEAPTS modification of mesoporous silica gel is given in figure 9.12.
217 3.5 loading (mmol/g)
3.0
x
(b)
2.5 2.0
[]
(a)
1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0
0
015
]
1'.5 Ceq (mmol)
2
2'.5
3
Figure 9.12 Adsorption isotherms of AEAPTS on dehydrated (673K) mesoporous silica gel from toluene solution, by freeze sampling method, (a) first equilibrium, (b) second equilibrium.
Since the reaction kinetic investigation showed a two-step adsorption, isotherms for both steps can be produced. Secondary adsorption is observed for equilibrium concentrations higher than 0.17 mmol. Both steps show an adsorption isotherm, analogous to the APTS adsorption isotherm, showing initial Langmuir behaviour, followed by additional adsorption at high equilibrium concentration. The equilibrium level reached in the first step is nearly identical to that of the mono-aminofunctional APTS, having a loading of 1.1 mmol/g. However, additional deposition occurs at far lower equilibrium concentration. The surface loadings above monolayer level at long reaction times or high concentrations have also been pointed out by Vandenberg et al. ~5 Using Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), they found small aggregates of aminosilane on top of the coating layer. On these basis surface structures, as displayed in figure 9.13, were proposed.
218
//////////////////
I
////////////////// \\\\\ \\ \\\ \\ \\ \\\\ //////////////////
I
////////////////// \\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\ //////////////////
I
I
I
I
Figure 9.13 Schematic diagram of the structure of APTS on oxidized silicon wafers, after reaction in toluene under various conditions. (i) reaction time of minutes at RT, (ii) reaction time of hours at RT, (iii) reaction time of hours under reflux; taken from ref. a N with permission.
Some precaution has to be taken in extrapolating these data towards the porous silica gels discussed here. The reaction was performed on fiat thin SiO2 layers on silicon wafers. Therefore, no limitations by porosity are applicable. Secondly, the samples studied by AFM and SEM were dried before analysis. The effect of both these parameters will be evaluated further on. Summarizing, aminosilanes show a fast adsorption on the silica surface. An equilibrium monolayer coating is formed. Modification in aqueous solvent causes polymerization on top of the initial monolayer. For modification from organic solvent, the reactions can be better controlled. With the bifunctional AEAPTS, a secondary silane layer adsorbs on the free primary amine groups of the first monolayer. At high concentration and after long reaction times, for both aminosilane types, a further non-specific deposition occurs.
219 1.3.2 Limitations by substrate structure The effect of solvent type and aminosilane concentration has been evaluated. The third component in the reaction system is the silica substrate. The surface of the silica gel carries the active sites for adsorption. The concentration of these sites varies with varying silica type, its specific surface area and pretreatment temperature. Additionally, surface adsorbed water has a clear effect on the reaction mechanism. Isotherm data, reported in the previous paragraph, only accounted for fully hydrated or fully dehydrated silica. The effect of the available surface area and silanol number remains to be assessed. Information on these parameters allows the correlation of data from studies in which different silica types have been used. In this part the effect of these parameters in the loading step is discussed. Silica structural effects on the ultimate coating, after curing, are evaluated in the next paragraph. The effect of substrate structure in the loading step can be studied by measuring the total aminosilane loading on silicas with different topology. Analyses are performed on the solvent after the reaction, since any study of the modified substrate involves drying or curing. The quantitative analysis of the aminosilane in the toluene solvent may be performed using a spectrophotometrical method. 28 Thus an easy and quick alternative for the time-consuming and indirect Kjeldahl-N-analysis is applied. The determination of APTS by means of a colour reaction with salicylic aldehyde in protic solvent has been reported by Waddell and Leyden. 29 Upon reaction of an amine with salicylic aldehyde (reaction (B)) a yellow Schiff's base is formed. O II CH R-NH
2
+
CH 3 "-
R-NH=C
+ H20
03)
This reaction involves the formation of an imine, requiring proton catalysis and liberation of a molecule of water. Therefore, this procedure may not be applied directly in an aprotic solvent, such as toluene. With the addition of a small amount of diethylether, however, the reaction was found to reach equilibrium after one hour
220 of diethylether, however, the reaction was found to reach equilibrium after one hour and a linear correlation between the APTS concentration and the absorbance at ),=404 nm was found. After setting up a calibration curve (r = 0.996), unknown aminosilane concentrations in toluene solvent could be quantified. The total deposited amount of APTS was calculated from analysis of the residual amount of aminosilane in the solvent. Analysis was performed after two hours of reaction and consecutive filtration under ambient atmosphere. 150 td aliquots of the salicylic aldehyde and the diethylether were added to 10 ml samples of the filtrate. Absorbance was measured one hour after the ether addition. The calculated loading value yields the total surface loading, including chemical and physical deposition, in the loading step. Concerning substrate topology, three factors are of interest in the study of the aminosilane modification" surface hydration/hydroxylation, specific surface area and the mean pore size of the substrate. Comparative data on the effect of these parameters in the loading step have not been published, until recently. 2g Three mesoporous silica gels, with variable mean pore radius and specific surface area, have been studied. The substrates are named according to their approximated mean pore diameter. Measured values appeared to differ somewhat from the product names. 3~ The Kieselgels 40, 60 and 100 have a mean pore diameter of 4.2, 7.0 and 12.0 nm, respectively. Specific surface area increases with decreasing pore radius. Measured values, using the BET method, are given in table 9.3. Table 9.3 BET surface area of various silica gels used
silica type- pretreatment T
KG KG KG KG KG
60406010060-
473K 673K 673K 673 K 1073 K
SBET(before reaction, m2/g)
370 603 394 325 235
221 The influence of surface hydration and hydroxylation may be studied from the surface loading data, displayed in figure 9.14. Total surface loading was measured for the three silicas with variable pore size, at various pretreatment temperatures. 1 (retool/g) 1.9 1.7 1.5 []
1.3
123
1.1 06 200
'
4(10
'
6()0
'
8(10
'
IlXIO
pretreatment temperature (K) Figure 9.14 Total surface loading of APTS modified silica gel as a function of pretreatment temperature; *:Kieselgel 40, o: Kieselgel 60, ." Kieselgel 100.
Studying the total loading curve of the silica with intermediate pore size (KG60), three regions may be observed. At pretreatment temperatures below 473 K the total surface loading decreases with increasing temperature. A constant loading level (ltot -- 1.33 mmol/g) is obtained for pretreatment between 473 and 873 K. At 1073 K the total loading shows a reduced value. Samples with different pore size show a similar trend. At high pretreatment temperature (673 - 1073 K), the KG40 sample shows an identical loading as the KG60, while the KG100 has a reduced value. The influence of surface hydration is apparent in the 298 - 473 K region. Adsorbed aminosilane molecules are hydrolyzed and produce reactive sites for further condensation. Thus a vertically polymerised aminosilane layer is formed on the silica surface. Accordingly a higher loading value is found at low pretreatment temperature.
222 The total loading decreases with decreasing surface hydration, i.e. increasing pretreatment temperature. At 473 K the surface is totally dehydrated. As the pretreatment temperature is increased up to 873 K, the surface is gradually dehydroxylated. No change in total loading is obtained for either sample. Apparently, the number of hydroxyl groups has no effect on the total surface loading. The APTS deposition on the surface is non-hydroxyl specific. This agrees with the aspecific adsorption at long reaction times, as reported in the previous paragraph. The number of hydroxyls on the substrate surface plays no role in the total loading before drying or curing. As pretreatment temperature is raised to 1073 K, the total loading is reduced. After pretreatment at this temperature the silica shows a decreased specific surface area. In order to test whether this decrease can account for the reduction in total loading, surface coverage (C) was calculated, by rationing the loading (1) to the specific surface area (SB~x) of the sample. Multiplication by the Avogadro constant yields units of molecules/nm 2. C -
l
SBer
,NA
15)
Total surface coverage is plotted as a function of pretreatment temperature in figure 9.15. Within experimental error on surface area analyses, identical coverages are found for the KG60 and KG100 samples, over the entire pretreatment temperature range. At low temperature, the influence of polymerization is apparent again. Total coverage is constant in the 473 - 873 K range. In this temperature range loading as well as BET-surface area do not vary. A correlation between those two parameters is apparent. In this temperature region, the specific surface area appears to be of more importance than the silanol number. The total coverage at 1073 K, however, shows an increased value. The decrease in surface area can not account entirely for the reduced loading value. This indicates that specific surface area is not the only factor governing the APTS deposition at this high pretreatment temperature. A special type of control of the silane-to-surface reactivity
223
C (molec/nm2)
1
200
400
600
800
1000
pretreatment temperature (K)
Figure 9.15 Total surface coverage of APTS modified silica gel, with variable pretreatment temperature; *:Kieselgel 40, m: Kieselgel 60, A: Kieselgel 100.
may be inferred. It appears that this special type of interaction on dehydroxylated silica has a profound effect on the surface coverage, causing a higher coverage value than that found for the hydrated sample. Reasons for this typical behaviour of the dehydroxylated silica may be sought in a changed structure of the porous network or a higher reactivity of the surface. None of both hypotheses can be excluded on basis of these data. Concerning the coating structure, this effect may involve multilayer formation or a change in the molecular orientation at the surface.
1073 K pretreated silica has previously been reported to have an increased reactivity, compared to (partially) hydroxylated silica. This has been attributed to the formation of strained siloxane bridges upon dehydroxylation. 31 Strained siloxanes act as Lewis acid sites in reactions with compounds such as silanes 3~ and ammonia. 33'34 A possible explanation for the increased coverage may be that the amine group of the APTS may also enter into interaction with this type of surface species.
More
information on this effect will be obtained from the chemical loading values, after curing of the samples. This will be discussed in the following paragraph.
224
Coverages on the KG40 sample show a reduced value, compared to both other samples, at temperatures below 1073 K. This may be explained as a sterical hindrance of the modification process, due to the reduced average pore size. APTS molecules can not enter the porous structure of the KG40 as easily as they can in the larger pores of the KG60 and KG100 sample. Further evidence has to be obtained from the modified samples after curing, and will be discussed below. The above-cited behaviour of the dehydrated silica (pretreatment temp. = 473 - 873 K) is further exemplified by plotting the total coverage as a function of the silanol number (figure 9.16).
4.0
C (molec/nm2)
3.0.
A
2.0
m
-
1.0_
0.0
1
~2
3
4
5
Ix(OH) (#/nm2)
Figure 9.16 Total coverage of APTS modified dehydrated silica gel (pretreatment temperature = 473-873K) as a function of silanol number; m: Kieselge160, A "Kieselge1100.
The total coverage of APTS on dehydrated KG60 and KG100, clearly is independent of the silanol number. An average coverage of 2.05 APTS molecules per square nanometre is obtained. If we suppose that the silane molecules form one single layer on the surface, this implies that every APTS molecule covers an area of about 5.0 nm2, irrespective of the OH coverage of the surface. This value is reasonable, concerning the molecular dimensions of the APTS molecule. Chiang et al. s have previously used a hypothetical value of 4.0 nm2.
225
Correlating these data to the kinetic profile found previously, this would imply the following. In the initial phase of reaction, a monolayer coating is formed by instant adsorption of the amine groups to surface silanols. On a dehydrated surface, the silanes cover an average of 1.4 silanols per APTS molecule. After one hour of reaction the surface is further covered with silane molecules, to an extent, controlled by the specific surface area. This implies a surface filling, probably due to a rearrangement of the initially adsorbed molecules, which may reorient upon chemical bonding with the surface. In the ultimate layer each molecule covers an average area of 5.0 nm2. Although this descriptive model seems reasonable, it should be regarded as hypothetical, since it encompasses that deposition on top of the initial layer does not occur.
1.3.3 Conclusion Summarizing we may state that, as adsorption isotherms revealed the formation of an equilibrium in the initial stage of the reaction, total loading data after two hours of reaction and filtration reveal that specific surface area and mean pore size are the controlling parameters in the loading step. Surface water causes hydrolysis and polymerization. On a dehydrated surface, a surface coverage irrespective of the number of hydroxyls is formed. For silica dehydroxylated at elevated temperature (1073 K) a different behaviour is observed, suggesting the participation of strained siloxanes.
1.4 Characterization of the aminosilane modified silica For the stabilization of the silane layer on the silica surface, a post reaction curing step is required. After filtering and possibly washing, the reacted substrate is cured at temperatures in the 353-473 K range. The parameters used in different studies vary reasonably. The solvent used for washing, the curing temperature and surrounding atmosphere, predrying of the substrate before curing, all are used in a variable way. Together with the variability used in the loading parameters, this hinders a quantitative correlation of data from different studies. In order to allow a qualitative comparison, we are discussing the effect of various parameters on the modified structure.
226 In analogy to the discussion of the loading step processes, both the processes occurring in the curing step and the effect of substrate structure on these processes will be discussed. Whereas the study of the loading step processes involved analysis of the solvent, here the modified substrate is studied. For this, various spectroscopic techniques are applied. The discussion is focused on the silicon side of the aminosilane molecule. The interactions at the amine side will be discussed in the next paragraph. 1.4.1 Chemical condensation of aminosilanes with the silica surface
UV stability studies In the curing phase, the silane coating is stabilized by the formation of siloxane bonds between the silane and surface silicon atoms. Thus, physically adsorbed molecules are chemically bonded. The extent and rate of this process may be studied from the stability of the coating towards ethanol leaching under varying curing conditions. Detection of the aminosilane lost from the surface is performed by means of a spectrophotometric method, analogous to the one used in the measuring of the adsorption isotherms. Amines react with salicylic aldehyde with the formation of a yellow Schiff's base, having ~,max= 404 nm (reaction B). In toluene solvent, ether was needed to initiate the reaction. In a protic solvent, such as ethanol, the reaction proceeds readily. After calibration, the amine function thus allows the quantitative determination of the amount of an alkylamine or aminosilane liberated from a modified substrate upon ethanol leaching, by UV detection. Using this method, Waddell et al. 29 compared the stabilities of mono-, di- and trialkoxyaminosilanes, upon curing at 353 K in air. Reaction was performed on ovendried mesoporous silica gel in dry toluene. Their results indicated the progressive stabilization of the aminosilane layer upon heating. Under these circumstances, they found that 3 hours of curing were sufficient to reach optimal coating stability. The number of alkoxy groups in the silane molecule was shown to determine the overall stability of the layer, even before heating of the reacted substrate. After optimal stabilization, the trialkoxysilane (APTS) showed a comparable stability, to the
227
dialkoxysilane (APDMS). This indicated that the APTS does not form long polymers on the surface, since the APDMS can only form dimers. These results were further elaborated by measuring the silane loss over short leaching times for samples cured in air and under vacuum. 35 Dehydrated mesoporous silica gel was modified with APTS or APDMS in dry toluene (1% v/v silane/toluene). Curing was performed for variable times in air at 383 K or under vacuum at 423 K. For UV tests the modified silica was stirred in a salicylic aldehyde/ethanol solution. At indicated times a 5ml sample was taken, centrifuged and the supernatant was measured at 404 nm. The loss curves of APTS for variably cured samples are displayed in figure 9.17. The position and profile of the absorbance curves are indicative for the stability of the coating under study.
abs. A
0.8 0.6 !
0.4
[]
I._lr"n
.
0.2
I
0
50
I
I
I
100 150 200 reaction time (rain,)
I
250
300
Figure 9.17 Loss curves for short term ethanol leaching on APTS modified silica: (x) uncured," (+) 3h air cured," (*) 20h air cured," (m ) 20h vacuum cured.
The amount of product lost as well as the course of the loss, upon stirring of the modified substrate in ethanol, are indicative of the stability of the coating. All samples show a rapid initial loss, followed by a slower process.
228 The curve of the air dried, uncured sample (x) shows a clear sloping over this relatively short reaction period, indicating the occurrence of an easy removable and a more firmly bound component. However both are not stable towards short term ethanol leaching. For the sample which has been cured for 20 h under vacuum (o), thus securing the absence of air humidity, the coating is stabilized. An invariable amount of silane is detected over the entire leaching period, indicating only one type of physical interaction. The increased coating stability after 20 h of curing is due to chemisorption to the silica surface. Still a small amount of the coating molecules is easily removed. The absorbance value found, corresponds to a concentration of 0.02 mmol/g. From correlation with the loading values, cited earlier, this would correspond to about 2 % of the coating, which is not irreversibly bound to the surface. These molecules are physisorbed to the surface by hydrogen bonding of the amine group to a surface hydroxyl. For the sample cured in air for 20 h (*), an additional stabilization is obtained. This stabilization is attributed to oligomerization of the silane molecules on the silica surface. Oligomerization occurs under the influence of air humidity. From the difference in position of the curves for 3 h (+) and 20 h (*) cured sample, it can be concluded that there is a progressive oligomerization during the air curing period. The air cured APTS curves have a more clear sloping than those of the vacuum cured samples. The rapid release of loosely physisorbed molecules is followed by a more slow loss. Because the slow process is measurable within this short ethanol leaching time, it can not be attributed to the breaking of chemical bonds. The occurrence in humid conditions lead us to conclude that this slow loss is caused by hydrogen bonding interactions of the silane molecules via the silane silanols. These silanols are formed under the influence of air humidity. Hydrolysis of silane alkoxy groups by air humidity, therefore, causes a double stabilization. Silane silanols can form hydrogen bonds to the surface and can cause oligomerization of the silane coating. Figure 9.18 gives a clear view on the stabilization of the coating by condensation with the surface hydroxyls during curing under vacuum conditions. The amount of hydrogen bonded aminosilane, as calculated from the absorbance data, is plotted as a function of curing time in vacuum.
229
0.028 mmol/g
I
0.026 0.024 0.022
a []
0.020
[]
I
0
10
I
I
20 30 curing time (h)
I
40
50
Figure 9.18 Amount of physisorbed silane molecules per g of modified silica as a function of curing time in vacuum, (a) APTS; (b) APDMS.
In evaluating the data for the vacuum curing only, contributions from oligomerization and hydrogen bonding of silane silanols are ruled out. Additional information is obtained in comparing the data for APTS modified silica to those measured on silica modified with APDMS. The APDMS molecule has only two ethoxy groups and therefore can only form two chemical bonds to the silica surface. For APTS a maximal stability (minimal amount of physisorbed species) is obtained within 3 h of curing at 423 K under vacuum. In the APDMS case the physisorbed amount decreases with curing time increasing up to 20 h. Because of the presence of only 2 ethoxy groups in the APDMS molecule, compared to 3 for the APTS, stabilization by formation of a siloxane bond is at maximum only after prolonged curing. For vacuum curing times above 20 h, the same level as obtained for APTS is maintained. Both silanes have an identical stability towards short-term leaching. About 2 % of the coating layer remains physically adsorbed. Concluding, it may be stated that the amount of non-chemically bound silanes decreases upon curing of the samples, due to condensation with the surface. Extra stabilization is obtained by oligomerization of the silane molecules, for air cured samples. Also for these samples, silane hydroxyls, formed upon hydrolysis of ethoxy
230 groups, are in hydrogen bonding interaction with the silica surface. For vacuum curing, the time needed for full stabilization is related to the number of alkoxy groups in the silane molecules. After curing for 20 h both APTS and APDMS layers on silica have an identical stability.
29Si CP MAS NMR study of the chemically bonded species After characterization of the physisorption, we wish to get information on the ultimate chemical structure of the coating. Spectroscopic analysis of the modified substrate is used to complement the indirect analytical data, reported above. Further elucidation of the chemical bonding of the silanes to the surface is obtained from 295i CP MAS NMR. With this technique, the formation of siloxane bonds with the surface can be modelled.
29Si CP MAS NMR spectra of 20 h air and vacuum cured APTS modified silica and 20 h air cured APDMS modified silica were recorded. The 29Si NMR spectra (figure 9.19) give information on the coordination at the silicon atoms of the silane molecules and in the silica gel. Band assignments for the APTS modified silica haven been given earlier in this chapter. For the APDMS modified sample, the band at -19.7 ppm is assigned to the bidentate bonded form, the monodentate form is found at -12.4 ppm:
R CH3 ~
I
S l - - OH
-12.4 ppm
.\
/
~
-19.7 ppm
R
R
I
I
CH3 ~ Si--- O ~ S I ~ CH3
-19.7
ppm
From peak deconvolution, the relative percentages of the different bonding forms have been calculated. Results are given in table 9.4 In the vacuum cured sample (figure 9.19 a), the APTS is mainly in the bidentate form (-59 ppm). From curve fitting and integration a relative amount of 60% was calculated. Monodentate and tridentate forms show only minor contributions (20% each).
9
~marl
~
o~
c~
co
olli~
o~
~
232 The previously discussed hydrolysis and oligomerization are evident from the spectrum of the air cured sample (figure 9.19 b). The silane region shows clear contributions from the hydrolyzed monodentate (-46 ppm) and oligomerized (tridentate, -66 ppm) forms. The APDMS is found to be almost entirely (90%) in the bidentate form. Because of the bifunctionality of the APDMS this is the most plausible form. Any hydrolysis and condensation between silane molecules can at most lead to surface dimers. A minor contribution of the monodentate form (-12.4 ppm) is visible.
Table 9.4 ~gsi CP MAS NMR peak positions, with relative contributions of bonding form, for APTS and APDMS modified silica gel silane used + curing conditions APTS, air 20 h APTS, vacuum 20 h APDMS, air 20 h
chemical shift (ppm) / relative contribution of bonding form (%) -49 ppm 11 -12 ppm 10
-53 ppm 20 -20 ppm 90
-59 ppm 52 60
-67 ppm 37 20
Caravajal et al. 22 discussed the effect of curing temperature on the silane conformation. APTS modified silica was cured at variable temperature and 29Si CP MAS NMR spectra were subsequently recorded. Results for the modification of silica gel pretreated at 473 K are given in figure 9.20. Other reaction parameters were comparable to the study reported above. A clear shift of intensity is visible from the -49 ppm peak to the -58 ppm peak to the -66 ppm peak as the curing temperature is increased. This clearly shows that the number of siloxane bonds between the silane silicon atoms and the surface (or other silanes) increases as the curing temperature increases. Concluding, the processes occurring under various curing conditions have been modelled. In the curing phase, the aminosilane layer is stabilized by covalent bonding to the surface. Siloxane bonds are formed between silane and silica surface atoms. The velocity of the siloxane formation is dependent on the initial number of ethoxy
233 200 Series POST RE ACT l ON CUR 1 NO TEMPERATURE ! "Cl
200
-s8
150 110 65
......
-50
-I00
-150
Figure 9.20 29Si CP MAS NMR spectra of mesoporous silica gel, pretreated at 473 K and modified with APTS in toluene solvent, after curing under vacuum at indicated temperature; taken from ref (22) with permission.
groups in the silane molecule. Upon curing in air the physisorbed silane molecules hydrolyze and form short oligomers. This process enhances the stability of the layer. Curing under vacuum results in a majority of silane molecules bonded in a bidentate form. The average number of siloxane bonds per molecule increases with increasing curing temperature.
1.4.2 Limitations by substrate structure As the effect of curing parameters has been assessed, the role of the silica structure remains to be studied. In the previous chapter, we discussed the effect of substrate structure in the loading step. Data were obtained from solvent analysis after reaction. Those revealed information on the total loading of the surface. Concerning the curing phase, it has been shown that physically adsorbed molecules are progressively chemically bonded. No distinction has been made hereto between the total deposition, i.e. the amount of silane adsorbed from the solution, and the ultimate number of chemically bonded molecules. Comparing these figures should also yield information on the loss of physically adsorbed molecules by desorption during curing.
234
Chemisorption and physisorption The silane loading on the surface after curing may be analyzed using various techniques. Elemental analysis has been used repeatedly, zs The Leyden group introduced quantitative analysis from Diffuse Reflectance FTIR spectroscopy. ~6'17 Recently, Kallury calculated quantitative loading data from XPS spectral data. 4 Elemental analysis, however, gives the most direct results. This technique involves the catalytic combustion of the modified sample, with selective adsorption of the evolved gasses. The relative percentages of C, O and N may thus be obtained. From this percentage, the amount of APTS per gram of modified silica may be derived directly. Total loading data, however, have been given in mmol APTS per gram of initial pure silica. In order to allow comparison, this value should also be used here. To calculate the APTS loading per gram of pure silica, the molar mass of the deposited molecule is needed. Since APTS may be deposited in three configurations (mono-, bi- or tridentate form) this molar mass is not defined unequivocally. For a dehydrated silica it was shown previously that the relative mono/bi/tri ratio equals 0.2:0.6:0.2. The weighted average molar mass of the molecule fragment, MM = 131, is used. For the dehydroxylated substrate, this approach will cause a slight underestimation of the loading, since the relative contribution of the monodentate form increases with increasing pretreatment temperature. The elemental analysis gives the surface loading after curing of the modified sample. Therefore only chemically bonded species are measured. In analogy to the loading step study, the effect of substrate structure has been studied by modifying mesoporous silica gels with a variable mean pore diameter, zg Sample pretreatment and curing (20 h, 423 K) were performed under vacuum. Variation of the pretreatment temperature causes a change in specific surface area and silanol number. While the hydroxyl content did not influence the total deposition, it is expected to affect the chemical load of the surface. The effect of the hydroxyl content on the chemical load may be obtained, after plotting the load as a function of the input ratio (I). As defined earlier, I is the initial relative ratio of the number of surface hydroxyl groups (NoH) to the total amount of silane in the reaction mixture (NAvrs)(eq.2). Results are displayed in figure 9.21.
235
1 (retool/g) 1.3 1.1 0.~ 0.'~ 0.5 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Figure 9.21 Chemical loading of APTS modified mesoporous silica gel as a function of input ratio OH:APTS.
The chemical loading increases with increasing relative number of hydroxyls. The curve levels off at a maximum of 1.16 mmol/g, for I >__ 1. This shows that the chemical bonding of the silane molecules is controlled by the hydroxyl content, as long as the aminosilane is in excess of the number of hydroxyls. As the hydroxyl number is further increased, with constant concentration of the reagent solution, the chemical loading remains constant. Reaction will result in a higher coordination of the silane molecules. The numerical values of total and chemical loading are displayed in table 9.5. The total loading reflects the sum of physically and chemically bonded species. During curing at high temperature and reduced pressure, physically adsorbed species are desorbed from the surface, or form chemical bonds. By subtracting the chemical loading after curing from the total loading before curing, the amount of APTS lost by desorption may be calculated. This amount is given as a relative percentage of the total deposition in table 9.5.
236
Table 9.5 Pretreated silicas, with their specific surface area and the total, chemically bonded and (relative) physically bonded loading of APTS a~er modification silica type pretreatment T
silica silica silica silica silica
60 - 473 K 40 - 673 K 60 - 673 K 100- 673 K 60 -1073 K
SBEr
Itotn1
(before reaction) (m2/g)
(mmol/g)
370 603 394 325 235
1.27 1.27 1.31 1.06 1.11
Ich~ (mmol/g)
1.14 1.18 1.09 0.96 0.72
Iphy,/Itot~ (%)
10 7 17 9 35
From the tabulated data, it may be observed that the amount of desorbed molecules varies a little with pretreatment temperature. For the 473 - 673 K pretreated samples about 10% of the total loading is lost during curing. For the dehydroxylated silica (1073 K), a relative loss of 35 % is observed. Similarly to the processes reported in the loading step, the behaviour of the dehydroxylated surface clearly differs from the other samples. This will be discussed below. Concerning first the dehydrated substrates (473 - 673 K), we reported above that in the loading step, a state of equilibrium is reached during the first hour of reaction. This was attributed to the formation of a monolayered coating. At longer reaction times, an additional deposition was observed. For the dehydrated substrate with intermediate porosity, (silica gel 6 0 - 673 K) at equilibrium, a silane loading of 1.02 mmol/g was obtained. Since the chemical loading value (1.09 mmol/g) corresponds to this monolayer equilibrium value, the following conclusions may be drawn. Upon mixing of the silane with the silica, the APTS adsorbs very rapidly on the silica surface by hydrogen bonding or ionic interaction of the amine group with a surface hydroxyl. The adsorption is hydroxyl specific and a monolayer is formed. Adsorbed silane molecules may self-catalyze the direct condensation of the silane with the surface, with the formation of siloxane bonds. This causes some reorientation of the adsorbed layer. At long reaction time additional silane adsorbs on the surface, filling the 'holes' between the hydroxyl-adsorbed species. Thus, a total loading controlled by the specific surface area of the substrate is obtained. Non-specific adsorbed molecules desorb quickly upon drying or curing, while hydroxyl-adsorbed species are further chemically bonded by siloxane formation.
237 As the additional physisorption has built up additional layers on top of the first monolayer, as for modification at higher concentration, the additional layers will analogously be desorbed. This mechanism is pointed out by thickness measurements, performed on non-porous modified silica layers. ~5 Upon curing at 473 K on air the thickness of the APTS layer appears to be reduced from 1.8 to 0.7 nm, indicating that after curing only one layer of APTS is left. The modification of the dehydroxylated substrate (pretreatment temperature = 1073 K) appears to follow a different mechanism. As stated above, the total coverage of this sample has a very high value. However, upon curing, as much as 35 % of the total loading is desorbed, leaving a chemical loading of 0.72 mmol/g. The mechanism of enhanced loading causes mainly a physical interaction with the surface. If we consider the ratio of the initial hydroxyl number to the number of chemically bonded molecules, the average number of reacted silanols per silane molecule is obtained. For this sample, a value of 0.6 is obtained. This indicates that at least 40% of the silane molecules have not coordinated with a surface hydroxyl group. The coordination with strained siloxanes may be an explanation for this phenomenon. However, based on these data, no absolute proof can be given. The physical and chemical bonding would than proceed by reactions (C) and (D), respectively.
- - SI
- - SI \ . . - - N H 2 R S i ( O R ' ) 3 0
+
H2NRSI(OR')3
- - Si /
0
=
(c)
- - Si /
= SI ~ N H 2 R S i ( O R '
)
= SI-- NHRSi(OR') 3 (D)
0 SI /
---- 81-- OH
Pore size distribution
As the effect of surface hydration and hydroxylation has been characterized, the influence of the porous structure remains to be studied. Sterical hindrance of the modification process was suspected from the total coverage values. This is further evidenced by measuring the pore size distribution of the three silicas before and after modification, as displayed in figure 9.22.
238
lXl~volut~ dltltlllit~ 0,8.
0,6 f
0,4
0"2
~~nt"7 ,.
_,-a_
~ - ~ i
.
.
.
.
-
z
,
10
port:~lu~ d~l~x~m 0.04 0"0~ 0"~ 0"01
~o
1
lmm VOlUmOd i m l l l o n
0.03
d
1=,
~ii,'-~ D~ t
0"0~
\
0"01
0 ~ 1
\
./
~
. . . . . . .
;
1o
Figure 9.22 Pore size distribution of various dehydrated silica gels, (o) before and (11) after modification with APTS, (a) Kieselge140; (b) Kieselge160; (c) Kieselge1100.
239 Upon modification, the pore size distribution of the smaller pore Kieselge140 narrows. Both other distributions show a shift towards a lower radius. This indicates that for the large pore silicas (figure 9.22 b,c), all pores are modified comparably, causing a tendency towards reduction of the pore radius over the total pore range. An increase in mean pore radius from 7.2 to 12.0 nm does not have an effect on the modification process. This accords with the identical total coverage values found in the loading step. If coverage is calculated after curing, also an identical value, of 1.7 molecules/nm z, is found. For the small pore silica (figure 9.22 a), the pore size distribution curve lowers at the high radius side. The relative amount of pores with a radius r > 20nm decreases. Comparable results were reported by Kondo et al., 36 upon modification of an analogous silica gel (rp= 1.8nm, SBEr= 718 m2/g), under similar conditions. Specific surface areas and pore volume decreased as the degree of modification with APTS was increased. However, the mean pore radii did not decrease significantly. This involves a narrowing of the pore size distribution. These results indicate that the larger pores are coated, thus reducing their radius, while there is sterical hinderance for reaction in the smaller pores. An overall reduction in surface reactivity follows. Already in the loading step study, this effect was observed in the reduced coverage values, found for this silica type. Calculation of the chemical coverage value (CCh~m= 1.2 molecules/nm 2) yields analogous results. Concluding, the effect of the substrate structure on chemisorption is controlled by three parameters: the number of surface silanols, the presence of strained siloxanes and the average pore size. Chemical bonding in dry conditions is localized on the surface silanols. Only hydroxyl-specific adsorbed silane molecules are chemically bonded during curing. On dehydroxylated silica a anomalous high level of physisorption is found, probably due to interaction with strained siloxanes. In pores smaller than 4.0 nm, the reaction with APTS is sterically hindered.
1.4.3 Conclusion Summarizing, the curing process can be characterized as follows.
Upon thermal
treatment of the loaded substrate, silane molecules are chemically bonded by siloxane formation. These bonds are formed between neighbouring silanes or between the
240 silane and a surface silicon atom. The extent and velocity of this chemisorption are enhanced by the presence of air humidity, the applied curing temperature and the initial number of silane alkoxy groups. The molecules which have made up the initial monolayer in the loading step are chemically bonded. Additionally adsorbed molecules are desorbed upon curing. Dehydroxylated silica shows an increased reactivity, while on the other hand reaction is sterically hindered in small pores (r < 2.0 nm).
1.5 Interactions at the amine side
In the discussion of the loading and curing step, we have focused on the conformation of the silicon side of the aminosilane molecules. Siloxane bond formation and effect of hydrolysis of the alkoxy groups have been characterized clearly. The special reactivity of aminosilanes, compared to other organosilanes, however, is due to the presence of the amino group inside the molecule. The inter- and intramolecular interactions of this group cause special stability and reactivity according to the conditions used. Therefore we will now focus on this side of the bifunctional molecule. 1.5.1 Stability and surface interaction The electron rich amine function is a good acceptor for hydrogen bonds. On the other hand, the basic character of the amine causes proton transfer from acidic groups. Both types of interaction occur on the silica surface. Together with the siloxane bond formation, three types of hydroxyl-specific interaction of the aminosilane molecule with the silica surface may be described, for the modification in organic solvent. These are displayed in figure 9.23. The amine may enter into hydrogen bonding interaction with a surface hydroxyl (figure 9.23 a). The hydrogen bond formation is responsible for the fast adsorption of the silane molecules onto the silica surface, as discussed above. The basic amine function may abstract a proton from a silanol and form an ionic bond (figure 9.23 b). This type of interaction is much more stable than the first one. The hydrogen bonded molecules may self-catalyse the condensation of the silicon side of the silane molecule (figure 9.23 c). Thus, a covalent siloxane bond is formed.
241
4
> o _i I/ o
o
>
o 0--7
~.
\Si
O\~i /
/ NH2 /
NIt +
H~
3
-
O
O
(a)
(b)
Fo /
~HN
/
I-I"
~L
2
H/~ HN r"~ /
/"
2
0
(e) Figure 9.23 Surface - aminosilane interactions in the loading step, (a) hydrogen bonding, (b) proton transfer, (c) condensation to siloxane.
Apart from this hydroxyl-specific interaction, also non-hydroxyl specific adsorption was demonstrated to occur at high concentration and long reaction times. This includes physical interactions with the surface or other adsorbed molecules. Only the molecules, adsorbed specifically in the first monolayer were shown to remain chemisorbed on the surface after curing. Other molecules desorb upon curing. Therefore, after modification in dry solvent and before curing, the coating layer is composed of molecules in one of these four types of interaction with the surface: hydrogen bonding, ionic interaction, chemically bonded or physically adsorbed. The extent to which all these interaction types contribute to the total silane stability after the loading step was determined from an ethanol leaching test. 35'37 The different stability of the bonding types is reflected in the ease of leaching of aminosilane molecules from the surface, upon stirring in ethanol. The aminosilane lost from the surface is analyzed quantitatively by means of UV-detection, after a colour reaction.
242
The resulting value is ratioed to the total loading, as obtained from Kjeldahl analysis on the solvent, to obtain the relative percentage of coating lost. This percentage is plotted as a function of ethanol leaching time in figure 9.24. The test was performed on dry mesoporous silica gel, modified with APTS in dry toluene, filtered and dried for only 5 min., in order to minimize losses due to desorption. An identical experiment was done, using n-butylamine.
100
% lost (b)
80
I
II
I
60 40 20
Ca)
o
26oo
400o
reaction time (rain,)
6600
80oo
Figure 9.24 Ethanol leaching curves of uncured modified silica; (a) APTS, (b) n-butylamine.
Both samples show a rapid initial loss. For APTS this is followed by a slow process. The APTS appears to have a largely increased stability compared to the butylamine. A tenfold relative amount of butylamine is released from the silica, over the measured time interval. A relative amount of respectively 78 % and 9 % is lost after 6 days of stirring in ethanol. This percentage is attributed to both hydrogen bonded and physically adsorbed molecules. Because both of these interaction types are expected to be unstable towards the ethanol leaching. n-Butylamine can interact with the silica surface hydroxyls by hydrogen bonding as well as proton transfer. The hydrogen bonded species are easily removed by ethanol. 22 % of the coating is stable towards ethanol leaching and therefore is concluded to be bonded by ionic interactions. An identical chemical behaviour of the amine group of
243 butylamine and APTS may be assumed. Therefore ionic interactions will have an equal share (22%) in the surface bonded APTS molecules. Kelly and Leyden ~~ studied the interaction of APTS with silica gel by thermometric enthalpy titration. This technique provides information regarding kinetic and thermodynamic parameters, which govern the reactivity of immobilized functional groups. They found that 26 % of the APTS molecules were irreversibly bonded to the silica surface and attributed this stability to ionic interactions. Both values are equal within experimental error. The increased stability of APTS compared to butylamine is attributable to stable interactions involving the silicon side of the molecule. These should be interpreted as chemical bonding of the silane molecules to the silica surface. From both other percentages, it can be inferred that a relative number of 69 % of the total coating are chemically bonded to the silica surface, before the sample has been thermally cured. Care should be taken however, because this test concerns an air dried substrate. Although drying time was reduced to a minimum, reactive adsorbed species may rapidly condense or hydrolyze upon exposure to air humidity. Therefore the coating stability might be slightly overestimated. The drying step can however not be overcome. Therefore it can be concluded that, after modification in dry solvent and before curing, the aminosilane layer is composed as follows. 22% of the molecules are bonded by ionic interaction of the amine group. At least 9 % of the coating is bonded by hydrogen bridge formation or non-specific adsorption. Considerable condensation already occurs in the reaction phase.
1.5.2 Coordination of the amine group The test reported above does not yield any information on the state of the amine group in the chemically bonded molecules. Aminosilane molecules may be chemically bonded at the silicon side and interacting with a surface hydroxyl at the amine side. Data were only obtained on the stability of the molecule as a whole. In order to study the state of interaction of the amine groups of chemically bonded molecules, spectroscopic techniques should be applied.
244
XPS studies of free and surface-bonded amine groups Using X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) a distinction is made between free amine groups and amines in interaction with the surface. The N ls XPS signal of APTS modified silica shows two contributing bands, at binding energies of 400 and 402 eV (figure 9.25). Relative Intensity a] O*
9
ee
t e , .
80 ~
ee
!
9
BINDING ENERGY (eV)
Figure 9.25 XPS N ls signal of an APTS modified Si02 layer, at different detector angles. (a) 0 ~ (b) 80 ~ taken from ref (15), with permission.
Measurements at different exit angles give information on the relative contributions at different depths in the coating layer. 15 The spectrum obtained at 0 ~ (figure 9.25 a) yields data on the bulk of the coating layer, while the spectrum at 80 ~ (figure 9.25 b) gives the external surface composition. The low energy signal has a higher relative contribution in the external surface mode. It may therefore be assigned to free amines. The high energy band has been assigned to hydrogen bonded as well as protonated amine nitrogens. 4'~5'3g'39Both types of interaction appear to contribute to the signal. For the spectrum of aminopropylethoxydimethylsilane (APEDS) modified silica, the assignment is more straightforward, since three bands contribute to the N Is signal (figure 9.26). 4
245
Intensity (cps) lin
i
N
III
9
IIL~@
9~
.
.
...
! . -
.
,
Binding Energy (eV) lin
Figure 9.26 XPS N ls signal of APEDS modified silica gel; taken from ref (4) with permission. From deconvolution, bands at 399.5, 401.0 and 402.8 eV are obtained. Those are assigned to free, hydrogen bonded and protonated amine, respectively. In the same study4, the use of XPS allowed to study the effect of surface water and added base on the interaction of the amine with the surface. Surface water appeared to play an important role in the promotion of amine-to-surface interaction. The addition of triethylamine in the reaction mixture reduces the surface interaction. The base promotes cross-linking and/or surface siloxane bond formation, either of which leaves the amino group in the free form. Moses et al. 39 obtained similar results from XPS data of the modification of metal oxides with aminosilanes. From amidization of the immobilized aminosilanes the activity (i.e. free character) of the amino groups was tested. For the bifunctional AEAPTS, all of the primary amine groups are in the active form. Interaction with the surface is restricted to the secondary amine function in the middle of the organic chain.
1~C CP MAS NMR studies of the amine interaction ~3C CP MAS NMR has proved to be another powerful tool in the study of the amine interaction. The potential of this technique in modified silica research was pointed out
246 by Leyden et al. in the early 80's. 4~ Chiang et al. 19 reported the carbon positions of aqueous aminosilane solutions and their shifts upon polymerization and deposition on the silica surface. These are indicated in table 9.6. Table 9.6
13CNMR chemical shifts (ppm) of APTS and AEAPTS in different states, from refs. (19,23,35) *: not given, ():shoulder.
APTS
-OC_.H2CH3
CV
C/~
CH~.CH3
Cc~
* -
45.5 43.7
27.9 25.9
* -
8.1 10.8
initial
-
45.5
-
12.1
403 K, 24h
-
46.0
27.3 (23.2) 28.4
-
11.7
20.7 25.0 (20.7)
-
8.8 8.7
others
liquid phase~9 neat liquid 5% APTS/H20
bulk polymer:9
APTS modified silica gel -
from aqueous solution, dried 19 RT, vac 403 K, 24h, vac
42.5 43.0
- under reflux conditions, washed, dried 353 K, vac 23 CH3OH washed 44.2 27.4 H20 washed 43.2 25.4 HMDS, H20 wash 42.7 25.0 (29.1) HCI, CH3OH wash 59.7 43.0 21.8 (26-29) from organic solvent, dried 35 423 K, vac, 20h 57.8 43.5 26.6 383 K, air, 20h (57.4) 42.7 25.0
9.7 9.7 9.7
CHaO-: 49.4
16.5
9.5
__CH30-: 49.0
15.8 (15.5)
8.4 8.0
-
AEAPTS 19 neat liquid polymer on silica, from aq.solvent
C5 42.4 41.9
C4 53.2 52.7
C3 53.1 52.7
C2 23.8 24.2
C1 7.2 12.2
40.4
50.2
50.2
22.3
9.8
(_C_H3)3Si:-0.7
247 A strong line broadening from the liquid aminosilane, over the polymer to the immobilized compound, indicates the loss of motional freedom of the organic chain. The shift of about 2 ppm upon deposition on the silica was attributed to the presence of the glass. Since a polymerized aminosilane layer is considered, only the alkyl carbon atoms are observed in the spectrum. Furthermore, the band due to the B carbon atom showed a strong shoulder at higher field (20.7 ppm). This was attributed to interaction with the silica surface, while the low field peak (25 ppm) was assigned to a BC atom in a free, extended chain. Caravajal et al. 22 showed that the BC peak could be reversibly shifted between both positions (figure 9.27).
b
a
I
80
"
"
"
I
60
"
"
"
!
LIO
"
"
"
I
20
"
'
"
I
0
"
-'-'
I
-213
Figure 9.27 Uc CP MAS NMR spectra of APTS modified evacuated silica gel (pretreated 298 K, vacuum," curing T = 473 K), (a): after curing, (b): sample (a) saturated with water, (c) sample (b) after heating at 473 K and O.01 Torr; taken from ref. (22) with permission.
The initial APTS modified silica spectrum (figure 9.27 a) shows the three peaks of the alkyl carbon atoms. Upon hydration of the sample, all peaks narrow and the BC peak shifts to a lower position (figure 9.27 b). Heating the hydrated sample again to 474 K under vacuum restores the spectrum to that of the initial sample. From this experiment and other analogous results, 2~ the shift of the BC atom is correlated with
248 Br6nstedt protonation of the amine group. This protonation is promoted by the presence of water, as indicated in reaction (E).
-
Si-OH---H2NCH2CH2CH 2- + n H20 ~
-= Si-O(H20)H, +NCH2CH2CH 2- rE)
The removal of H20 from the system shifts the reversible equilibrium to the hydrogenbonded amine on the left, with a chemical shift of 25 - 27 ppm. The addition of 1-120 shifts the equilibrium to the hydrated Brfnstedt complex, having a chemical shift of 21 - 22 ppm. From the relative plC~ values of the surface silanols (5.0 - 9.5) and the water (14), it is clear that the proton will be abstracted from the surface rather than from the adsorbed water molecule. SudhSlter et al. 23 studied the BC shift position for silica modified with APTS under reflux conditions. The samples were washed using various solvents after modification and reacted with HMDS or HCI in order to affect the amine interaction. The resulting spectra are displayed in figure 9.28. Shift positions are indicated in table 9.6. All four spectra show the alkyl carbon peaks. In the methanol-washed sample, some methoxy groups have coordinated with the silica surface. The corresponding carbon signal is found at 49.4 ppm. The BC peak is at 27.4 ppm. After water washing the peak is found at 25.4 ppm. The water washing does not have the same effect as the full saturation with water, performed by Caravajal. The aminopropyl silica was reacted with HMDS in order to block all residual hydroxyls, thus hampering any amine-hydroxyl interaction. A clear trimethylsilyl carbon signal is observed at - 0.7 ppm. The BC peak shows a weak shoulder at 29.1 ppm. Upon reaction with HC1, the amine is protonated with the formation of-NH3+CI groups. Consequently, the BC peak shifts to 21.8 ppm. These observations should be linked to data obtained by Vrancken et al., 35 upon variation of the curing conditions. In figure 9.29, ~3C CP MAS NMR spectra for APTS modified silica, cured at 423 K on air and under vacuum are given. Corresponding peak positions are displayed in table 9.7.
249
b
|
200
1
l
1
1
I
I
150
100
50
0
200
1 50
I
100
I
50
ppm
j__
0 ppm
c
d
'
r * ,%...~ ~i *
'
f
l
1
l
J
J
l
I
;
;
I
200
150
100
50
0
200
150
"100
50
0
ppm
ppm
Figure 9.28 tsC CP MAS NMR spectra of silica gel modified with APTS (pretreated 423K, xylene reflux 48h, washed, cured 353K vacuum): (a): methanol washed, (b): water washed, (c): sample (b) reacted with HMDS, (d): sample (b) reacted with HCI; taken from ref (63) with permission.
The vacuum cured sample (figure 9.29 a) has major ethoxy peaks. Reaction and curing in dry conditions has prevented extensive hydrolysis and polymerization. Air curing (figure 9.29 b) causes a near complete loss of ethoxy groups, because of oligomerization, as indicated in the previous chapter on curing processes. The I~C peak is found at 26.6 ppm and 25.0 ppm for the vacuum and air cured sample, respectively. Before curing, a position of 24.7 ppm was found. From these data and the data from Sudhrlter, a clear correlation between the hydroxyl content of the sample (in the coating and on the surface) and the I~C position can be deduced. Air curing and water washing cause hydrolysis, as has been shown above. The as-formed silanols are good donors for hydrogen bond formation with the amine nitrogen. Furthermore, on the uncured air dried sample, amino groups are hydrogen
250
u
i
-i
'
l
4O
'
'i
'1
i
0
i
~
-i---~
i
i
l
4O
i ' "i"
i
u
0
9
9
Figure 9.29 1 3 C CP MAS NMR spectra of APTS modified silica gel (pretreatment 673K, vacuum; curing T = 423K), (a) vacuum cured, (b) air cured.
bonded to the surface. If hydrogen bonding is prevented, as in the HMDS modified sample, a peak at 29.1 ppm is formed. It may be concluded that the position of the BC in the 25 - 27 ppm region, is indicative for the extent of hydrogen bonding of the amino groups. A reduction of the number of hydrogen bonds, results in a shift to higher shift value (i.e. lower shielding). This shift is caused by the increased mobility of the alkyl chain. Protonation of the amino group causes a peak shift to the 20 - 21 ppm region. This protonation is favoured by the presence of water at the surface in the loading stage. Correlating these data to the conformation of the aminosilane through the modification procedure in dry conditions, the following conclusions may be drawn. In the initial phase of deposition, hydrogen bonding allows fast adsorption of the aminosilane molecules to the silica surface silanols (figure 9.30 a). For part of the hydrogen bonded molecules, proton transfer from the surface silanol occurs. This transfer is promoted by the presence of surface water, and is reversible. The hydrogen bonded aminosilane catalyses siloxane bond formation, through the loading or curing step (figure 9.30 b). After siloxane formation the amine is free, with the alkyl chain pointing upwards from the surface (figure 9.30 c). Thus, the aminosilane molecule
251 is turned over from its initial amine-down position to a final amine-up position. This is called the flip mechanism. 26'4~
Co\ ~|/~oJ Nit
o
-
Xo
~v-m~2 r'r"
$i 0
(a)
fo)
0
(c)
Figure 9.30 Flip mechanism for APTS reaction in dry conditions, (a) physisorption, (b) condensation, (c) main structure after curing. This mechanism is valid for modification of silica in fully dry conditions, including post reaction curing. If the modified substrate is dried under ambient atmosphere at room temperature, other factors interfere.
Reaction with C02 Upon air drying of aminosilane modified silica, samples often get a bright yellow colour. This was also observed upon drying of aqueous APTS solutions. Naviroj et al. ~2intended to use FTIR spectroscopy to study the aminosilane structure in aqueous solution at various pH. For spectroscopic analysis, hydrolyzed APTS was casted onto an AgBr plate, dried and analyzed. The spectrum showed varying features according to the drying atmosphere. The spectra did therefore not reflect the solute conformation, but the structure of the dried material. The normal amine IR absorption band for NH 2 deformation, at 1600 cm -l, was only observed upon drying under N2 atmosphere. Drying in room environment caused peaks at 1575, 1488 and 1332 cm -~. Those were attributed to the formation of an aminebicarbonate salt (-NH3+(HCO3)-). 42 This salt is formed by reaction of CO2 from
252
the surrounding air with the silane amine groups.
Culler et al. 43 showed that the
reaction with CO2 occurs while drying and not during hydrolysis. The amine conformation of the dried polymer was characterized for varying pH of the initial solution. A change from -NH3+CI to -NH3+(HCO3) and to -NH2 with increasing pH was concluded. The proposed structures, with their specific FTIR absorption bands are given in figure 9.31.
pH (iCI-I2)3- NI~ Cl" 2
HO - Si - OH I OH
amine des (cm-1)
SiOH (cm-1)
1610, 1505
902
1575, 1488
930
1601
934
H
10.8 air dried
HO - Si - O.....H i H OH H I
N
a,ed 2,~-
HO- Si-O ....H I
OH I
heated
12
-Si
I
H
(CH2) 3- NI~ - O - SiI
1591
( H2)3" O-Si-O I O-
1595
925
Figure 9.31 Proposed structures of partially cured APTS as a function of pH of the solution and drying conditions. Amine deformation and SiOH vibrational modes were used to derive the structures; taken from ref (12) with permission. The assignment of the 1575 and 1488 cm -~ IR bands to an amine bicarbonate salt has been questioned by Battjes et al. 44 NMR and FTIR were applied to show the formation of carbamates (-NH2COO) instead of bicarbonates in the reaction of various amines with CO2. The carbamate reacts with a second amine group with formation of an ammonium salt (equation F).
253 2 RNH 2 + CO2 ~ RNH2COO" +H3NR
if3
This reaction was supported by the observation that CO2 was liberated from the reaction product in a 2:1 amine:CO2 ratio. Those experiments were performed under excess CO2 in the absence of water. Since water is needed in the bicarbonate formation, this may strongly influence the occuring reaction. Both reactions (Ga) and (Gb) are therefore plausible. The equilibrium is governed by the presence of water.
1-120 R-NHzCOO ~ R-NHz + CO2 ~-NH3 +(I-ICO9(a) (b)
(G)
We may therefore state that, upon drying of the hydrolysed species, reaction with CO2 from the surrounding atmosphere yields ammonium bicarbonates or ammonium carbamates, according to the presence or absence of water. The reaction with CO2, as reported for the dried aminosilane polymer also occurs with immobilized aminosilane molecules. C u l l e r 43 reported that approximately half of the amine groups are reacting with CO2 when silica samples modified with APTS in aqueous solution, are dried in air. Comparison with AEAPTS and a triaminosilane showed that only primary amines react with CO2. The reaction product is evidenced by FTIR bands at 1630, 1575, 1488 and 1332 cm -1. Also after modification in dry conditions and drying at room temperature in humid air, the reaction with CO2 may be observed. Characteristic infrared bands appear upon modification at high concentrations of APTS. Figure 9.32 shows the infrared spectrum of dry silica, modified with a 10% APTS/toluene solution, after air drying for 30 minutes. At this high concentration an APTS multilayer is formed. For modification at lower concentrations, yielding a monolayer coverage, the salt formation could not be observed clearly. The salt formed upon drying, disappears upon curing of the sample. Culler stated that heating of the modified sample for 2 minutes at 373 K is sufficient to evolve the CO2. Therefore, the reaction of aminosilane coatings with CO2 has no effect on cured substrates.
254
~ity
(a.u.)
1'700
l~d)O
1500
1'400
Wave,numbers (era- 1)
Figure 9.32 FTIR spectrum of dry silica, modified with 10% APTS/toluene solution, air dried.
1.5.3 Conclusion The interaction of the aminosilane with the silica is governed by the amine group. In the loading step hydrogen bonding between the amine and the silica surface silanols initiates the reaction. The strong hydrogen bonding interaction yields proton transfer to the amine and catalyzes siloxane formation. Considerable condensation already occurs during the loading step. In the curing step the amine-silica interaction is determined by the presence of water. Proton transfer complexes are formed in the presence of water. In dry conditions the amine is in the free form. In polymerized APTS layers, the amine reacts with CO2 from the surrounding atmosphere, with formation of bicarbonate or carbamate salts, according to the presence or absence of water. This reaction occurs during drying and the product salts are thermally unstable.
255
1.6 The role of silanols in the modification of silica with aminosilanes We have shown how hydroxyl groups on the silica surface act as active sites in the modification reaction. The amount of hydroxyls is controlled by the thermal pretreatment of the substrate. APTS molecules are physisorbed to the surface by hydrogen bonding of the amine group to a surface hydroxyl (H). Chemisorption of APTS to the silica surface, in dry conditions, involves the formation of siloxane bonds with release of ethanol (I). Water causes the hydrolysis of the ethoxy groups of the APTS, with formation of silane silanols. These silanols are more reactive than the original alkoxy groups. Siloxane bonds with other silane molecules or with the silica surface are formed with release of water (J). -Si-OH +
H2NCH2CH2CH2Si(OCHzCH3) 3 ~ --Si-OH..NH2CH2CH2CH2Si(OCH2CH3)3(I-I)
- Si-OH + (CH3CHzO)3SiCH2CH2CH2NH 2 ~ - Si-O-Si(OCHz CH3)2(CH 2CH2CH2NHz) + CH3CH2OH (CH3CH20)3SiCHzCH2CH2NH 2 + 3HzO--~ (HO)3SiCH2CH2CH2NH 2 + 3 CH3CH2OH 2 (HO)3SiCH2CHzCHzNH 2 ~ (H2NCH2CH2CH2)(OH)2Si-O-Si(OH)2(CH2CHzCH2NH2)
Or) (J)
+ H20
The deposition of the silane in the loading step has been studied. The surface loading was correlated to the specific surface area of the silica rather than the hydroxyl content. Part of the deposition, therefore, is non-hydroxyl specific. The above reaction schemes, however, indicate the crucial role of the hydroxyls in the consolidation of the silane coating on the surface. Physisorption may involve the amine-side as well as the silicon-side of the silane molecule. Silanol groups (on the surface as well as on the silane) therefore are very important in the reaction sequence. In this paragraph we aim to clarify the role of both surface and silane silanols. A clear distinction between both types is possible with the complementary use of solid-state NMR and FTIR, and with conversion of the surface hydroxyls to deuteroxyls (K) prior to modification with the silane. 2 ---Si-OH + DzO ~ 2 - S i - O D + HzO
(K)
The deuteration process was described above (cfr. chapter 3). By deuteration of the surface silanols before modification, a distinction can be made between unreacted
256 surface groups (~-Si-OD) and surface groups created in the course of the modification sequence ( - Si-OH).45 1.6.1 The role of surface silanols In order to study the role of surface silanols, three silicas with a variable silanol number (C~o.) were modified. Data on the silanol content are listed in table 9.7. Table 9.7 Hydroxyl distribution and specific surface area of variably pretreated silica gel (OHI = isolated + geminal; OHbr-- vicinal, bridged) pretreatment temperature (K)
C~o. (#/nm2)
OHf/nm2
OHb/nm2
SB~r (m2/g)
473 673 973
4.60 2.35 1.15
1.75 2.35 1.15
2.85 0 0
370 394 422
In figure 9.33 the 29Si CP MAS NMR spectra of the APTS modified silica samples with variable pretreatment temperature are displayed. The spectrum contains two broad bands, which may be decomposed into three or four peaks. The surface Si atoms are found in the (-85, -125 ppm) region, while the (-45, -80 ppm) signals are due to silane Si atoms. Band assignments of the silane Si region have been made previously as indicated in table 9.8. The absolute shift value decreases from tri- over bi to monodentate silane molecules. Hydrolysis of the silane molecules is not visible for the bidentate type, but gives a downfield shift for the monodentate molecules. Because the formation of three siloxane bonds with the surface is excluded for sterical reasons, the tridentate form corresponds to oligomerized silane molecules. A general trend of decreasing number of tridentate linked molecules and increasing number of monodentate molecules with increasing pretreatment temperature can be seen. This trend will be discussed below.
257
9 .,
....
I ....
-4,0
, ....
I ....
-6B
, . . . .
I ....
-SB PPH
, ....
I ....
-1BB
, ....
I ....
-12B
,
Figure 9.33 zgSi CP MAS NMR spectra of APTS modified silica gel with variable silica pretreatment temperature: (a) 473 K, (b) 673 K, (c) 973 K.
258 Table 9.8 29Si CP MAS NMR peak positions (ppm) and assignments (R = CH2CH2CH~H2; R'=H or CH2CHO
hydrolyzed monodentate R
I
monodentate R
R
\s,
I
J,
-43ppm
bidentate
-53ppm
o i
/ OR'
o i
-59ppm
tridentate (oligomer) R
\
si
/
O ~
o/,,o
-67ppm
Primary interest goes to the surface hydroxyls found after modification. Unreacted Q3and Q4 sites are detected. Concurrent with the silanol number before reaction, also the number of surface silanols after reaction decreases with increasing pretreatment temperature. From the general reaction scheme, these bands may be attributed either to surface silanols in hydrogen bonding interaction with amine groups, or to unreacted surface groups. Inspection of the FTIR-PAS spectra of these samples (figure 9.34) indicates the presence of bridged hydroxyls (3660 cm ~) for the 473 K (figure 9.34 a) and 673 K (figure 9.34 b) sample and a small amount of free silanols (3731 cm 1) for the 973 K sample (figure 9.34 c). The OHbrband may be caused by unreacted as well as amineinteracting hydroxyls. Based on these spectra no exclusion of one of both types is possible. The OHf band, present in the 973 K sample, is very weak and has its maximum at 3731 cm -l. Morrow and McFarlan 46 assigned a 3733 c m 1 band on silica to vicinal single silanols in weak interaction with neighbouring silanols. At this point it is not clear whether this peak should be assigned to non-reacted surface silanols of the Morrow type or to silane silanols. From the NMR data (figure 9.33 c) however, the 973 K sample is the only one to have hydrolyzed monodentate silane molecules at the surface. If these silane silanols do not form hydrogen bonds with other silanols or with amine groups, they are expected to give a IR band in this 3731 cm l region.
259
Intcmity (a.u.)
4OOO
I
350O
I
30OO
I
Wavenumbers(un-1)
Figure 9.34 FTIR PAS spectra of APTS modified silica gel with variable silica pretreatment temperature: (a) 473 K, (b) 673 K, (c) 973 K. In order to be able to distinguish non-reacted surface silanols from silanols formed in the reaction, the silica surface was deuterated before modification. After thermal pretreatment, a maximal amount of surface hydroxyls is exchanged to deuteroxyls. If the silane is applied to this deuterated substrate, deuteroxyls found after reaction are non-reacted surface groups. Detected hydroxyls must have been formed in the course of the modification procedure. The deuteration was performed with D20 vapour, as discussed above. Deuterated silicas were modified with APTS. 29Si CP MAS NMR spectra of the deuterated modified substrates are analogous to the spectra of the non-predeuterated
260 samples (Figure 9.33). The spectrum of the 973 K predeuterated sample before and after modification with APTS is shown in figure 9.35 d and 9.35 b, respectively.
(o) (b)
(c)
'
~40
'
--'60
'
~80
(p~)
'
-I'00
'
-I'20
'
Figure 9. 35 mSi CP MAS NMR spectra of silica gel after pretreatment at 973 K, deuteration and modification with APTS, measured with variable contact time, (a): 8 ms, (b): 5 ms, (c): 2.5 ms, (d): same sample before APTS modification at same scale, with 5 ms contact time.
Identical relative contributions in the silane band region are observed. This indicates that there is no difference in the chemical reaction behaviour of the silane and the surface with or without predeuteration. On the other hand, the surface Si region of the spectrum, has the same pattern as well. Although nearly no surface silanols were present before modification (figure 9.35 d), these groups are detected after the reaction (figure 9.35 b). It appears that some surface hydroxyls are created and remain unreacted during the modification procedure.
261
The occurrence of the formed hydroxyls may be studied by CP MAS NMR. When the contact time for the NMR-measurement is increased, protons on atoms near Si atoms are better able to transfer their polarization to the nearby Si centre. This induces an increased signal for the Si atoms with nearby protons. Thus, insight in the distribution of proton-beating groups may be gained. The effect of varying contact time on the deuterated modified sample is displayed in figure 9.35 a-c. Contact time is changed from 2.5 ms over 5 ms to 8 ms. This change has no effect on the intensity of the silane band. The silane silicons do not experience any increased polarisation transfer. The Q3 and Q4 bands on the other hand, both have increased intensity with increasing contact time. Q4 sites bear no hydrogen atom and therefore may only show an NMR band due to polarisation transfer from nearby H atoms. Consequently, the increase in Q4 intensity with increasing contact time is logical. For the Q3 band however, this effect indicates that Q3 sites have near proton beating (i.e. hydroxyl carrying) neighbours. A Q3 site is not standing lonely in a field of Q4's. The hydroxyls present after modification, appear in patches on the surface. In the coating layer some small bare hydroxyl regions occur. An impression of the quantity of these surface hydroxyls can be obtained from their FTIR spectra. In figure 9.36 a the FTIR-PAS spectrum for the 973 K deuterated modified silica is displayed. In the deuteroxyl region (2800 - 2500 cm -~) no absorption band is observed. All deuteroxyl groups have reacted. The silanol region reveals that only a minor amount of hydroxyl groups is present. The FTIR-PAS signal gives a quantitative indication of the amount of IR-active groups. The CP MAS NMR signal, on the other hand, is proportional to the amount of cross polarization, i.e. to the ability of the surface groups to interact with neighbouring hydrogen atoms. Therefore the signal is non-quantitative. Combination of both techniques therefore shows that only few hydroxyls are present on the surface, but those appear as patches in the coating layer. These hydroxyls may have been formed by traces of water entering the reaction solution or contacting the surface during the filtration. In the loading step, silane molecules are deposited on the silica surface in a non-hydroxyl specific way. Physical interaction is established by hydrogen bonding of the amine group. Only part of the silane molecules form chemical bonds. Therefore, during filtration on air, some
262
mtemity (a.u.)
I
4000
I
3500
3000
I
I
2500
I
2000
1500
Wavenumbers (era-l)
Figure 9.36 FTIR spectra of silica gel, aj2er pretreatment at 973 K, deuteration and modification with APTS, using (a) FTIR PAS under He, (b) DRIFT under ambient atmosphere.
desorption may take place, leaving deuteroxyls exposed to air humidity. Thus, a fast exchange of D for H will occur.
1.6.2 The role of silane silanols Let us now focus on the FTIR free silanol band. From figure 9.36 a it can be seen that this band is small and the peak maximum is unclear, due to the noise level. Therefore, the sample was measured again using the DRIFT-technique. This involved an exposure to air before measuring. The OH-region of this DRIFT spectrum is shown in figure 9.36 b. Here a clear peak splitting, unaffected by the spectral noise, is observed, causing two maxima, at 3743 cm ~ and 3731 cm ~. This band could only be observed in the high pretreatment temperature sample. For samples pretreated at
263
473K or 673 K (figure 9.34 a,b, resp.) no OHf band is present in the spectrum, either with or without predeuteration. The maximum at 3743 cm l corresponds to the position of the free surface silanol peak in the original silica spectrum. This peak may therefore be assigned to unreacted surface hydroxyls, as discussed above. From the 29Si NMR spectrum (figure 9.33 c) it is observed that this 973 K sample is the only sample carrying hydrolyzed monodentate silane molecules. From band deconvolution and integration, a relative amount of 5 % of the total silane may be calculated for this bonding type. Because of the lower silanol density of the original substrate, silane molecules have less anchoring groups at the surface. Therefore, the silane molecules are lower coordinated with the surface. More molecules are in monodentate coordination at higher pretreatment temperatures. Additionally, the intermolecular distance of bonded silane molecules is larger, causing a lower probability of intermolecular reactions. The stability of silane silanols increases consecutively. Therefore, it is tempting to assign the 3731 cm l band to silane hydroxyls. Further grounds for this silane silanol assignment may be found, when the reaction is performed with a low concentration silane solution, which also causes a lower surface silane density. Figure 9.37 shows the OHf region for 673 K silica samples, reacted with 0.1% (a,b) APTS/toluene solution, after variable curing times in air. The solution is too low concentrated to form a complete silane layer on the silica surface. After 30 min. of air curing, unreacted free surface silanols (3743 cm l ) are left on the surface. When the sample is cured for several months, a second band at 3731 cm -~ is formed. This may be attributed to the hydrolysis of surface bonded molecules by air humidity, causing silane silanol formation. The surface silanol peak decreases because of a condensation of silane molecules with the surface. There is no correlation between the intensities of both peaks. Therefore the 3731 cm ~ peak may not be assigned to surface silanol groups. The above cited surface hydroxyls of the Morrow type are not the cause of this band. From both experiments, it may be concluded that silane silanols are stable, when the silica surface has a low density of silane molecules. This low density may arise from a low initial surface hydroxyl density, as in the 973K sample, or from a low loading of silane molecules, as in the latter two samples.
264
Intensity ~a.u.)
(c)
~,/
Wavenumbers (cm-1)
Figure 9.37 DRIFT spectra of 673 K pretreated silica, modified with APTS, (a): at low concentration (0.1%) after 30 min of air curing, (b): sample (a) after air curing for several months, (c): using aqueous solvents.
The 3731 cm~ peak is also observed in the spectrum of silica modified with APTS in aqueous conditions (figure 9.37 c). Under these circumstances a multi-layer polymerized coating is formed, after hydrolysis of the silane molecules. However, some uncondensed hydrolyzed silane silanols remain at the edge of the coating layer.
265 1.6.3 Conclusion The overall role of silanols in the modification of silica with silanes can be summarized as follows. Silica surface silanols are the active sites for physisorption (H-bonding), proton transfer and condensation of silane molecules. Loading step deposition of silane, however, is governed by the available surface area. Upon drying of the reacted substrate, desorption of silane molecules takes place, leaving small bare patches of surface silanols. Silane silanols are formed by the hydrolysis of silane ethoxy groups. They may show hydrogen bonding interaction with the surface hydroxyls. Silane silanols condense to form siloxane bonds to the surface or to neighbouring silane molecules. They remain unreacted if the silane has a low surface density and at the edge of a polymer layer.
266 2 Modification with chlorosilanes
Strange enough, an unified approach to the reactions of chlorosilanes with the silica surface is lacking in international literature. This is probably due to the different reaction procedures that have been used and the different applications of the modified silica surfaces. The high vapour pressure of the (methyl)chlorosilanes allows a vapour-phase reaction. Moreover, these reactions are usually performed on amorphous silica with a high surface area, which is very suitable for a detailed study of the surface species by means of FTIR, XPS and NMR. The higher order alkylchlorosilanes (C8 and C~8) have historically been treated in the same way as organosilanes. The reaction inevitably occurs in the liquid phase and is usually followed by a curing step. The extremely low surface of the silicon wafers and the deposited SiO2 layers, used for self-assembled-monolayers does not allow a spectroscopic quantification of the surface species. A completely different type of analysis techniques is used here mainly to determine the quality (roughness and uniformity), the adherence (parallel or at random) and the hydrofobicity of the coated layer. Often used techniques are AFM (Atomic Force Microscopy), ellipsometry and chromatography. In the next paragraphs, we have tried to present a unified approach to the chlorosilylation of silica.
2.1 Vapour-phase reactions with (methyl)chlorosilanes 2.1.1 A review The reactions between (methyl)chlorosilanes and the surface of silica have been investigated by many researchers, primarily because of the utility of these reagents as coupling agents in polymer chemistry and as surface deactivating agents in chromatography.
267
Few studies are devoted to the reaction of silica with trichlorosilane (TCS).
The
earliest report, dealing specifically with the TCS modification of silica, is the one of Chuiko et al. 47 A silica, pretreated at 673 K, was reacted with TCS vapour at room temperature.
The authors observed a complete disappearance of the free hydroxyl
groups, due to reaction (L).
C1 -- Si
-
OH
+
~
Si "/
/
\
H
/ C1 -Si-O-Si-H
~
+HC1
(L)
\ cl
They claimed that under these conditions, a bimolecular reaction with two silanols is not possible, due to sterical reasons.
The distance between 2 C1 groups in
trichlorosilane is 0.33 nm (cfr. figure 9.38); whereas the mean distance between 2 OH groups on a silica surface, annealed at 673 K, is considerably larger.
\ I
0.76 nm
I
Figure 9.38 Surface filling of the silanols of a silica, treated at 673 K.
Chuiko mentioned no actual numbers, but his statement calls for a closer examination. Based on an OtoH of 5 OH per nm 2 for a completely hydroxylated surface, the surface area of a silanol group can be estimated to be 0.2 nm 2, so the radius, roll, equals 0.25 nm. At 673 K, the silica surface contains 2.2 OH/nm2; this means that 1 silanol group is present per 0.45 nm 2. Figure 9.38 shows that the distance between the middle-points of 2 silanols is then 0.76 nm and the distance between the outer-sphere
268
of the free rotating silanols is 0.26 nm. As the distance between 2 CI groups in trichlorosilane is 0.33 nm, a bimolecular reaction of TCS with silica gel, treated at temperatures higher than 673 K, is indeed unlikely. Low 4s refined Chuiko's findings in 1981. He confirmed his statement that bimolecular reactions are not likely to occur at high pretreatment temperatures, but he suggested a secondary, (consecutive) reaction (M): /Cl
-Si
- O - Si - H
-Si
H
- O
\ca
Si
/ - Si - OH
J
+ HCl
(M)
Cl
- Si - O"
He also suggested a side reaction (N) with so-called strained siloxane bridges.
- Si
Cl
\ o /
+
\
si"
Cl
/
H
- Si -- Cl
Cl
/Cl -si- o- si- n \ Cl
si "/
\
0'0
In the mean time, many articles were published on the reaction of methylchlorosilanes with silica. Especially the publications of Hair and co-workers 49'5~ have gained widespread attention. Using infrared band integration of the hydroxyl region, and putting the normalized data into the integrated form of the rate equation, they found that all polyfunctional methylchlorosilanes followed a reaction order of 1.6 at a reaction temperature of 573 K. This means that 60% of the silane reacts bifunctionally. The bimolecular reaction of trichlorosilane with silica is presented as reaction (O): Si - OH
CI
+ - Si - OH
H
Si
CI
/\
- Si - 0
~ Cl
H
/
- Si - O"
Si
\
+ 2 HCI Cl
(0)
269 In addition to this reaction, they noticed a positive intercept in the fitting of the experimental data by the rate equation, and ascribed this effect to an initial fast reaction (P). Cl
\
-Si-On
+
/
Cl
Si /\ CI'
OH ~
H
-Si-C1
+
Cl ~Si
Cl ~
/
(P)
~H
In his kinetic plots, Hair only considered a monomolecular reaction (L), and a bimolecular reaction (O). He never mentioned the secondary reaction (M) or the side reaction (N). Although his general conclusions on the stoichiometry of the reaction may be correct, it is not excluded that other reactions than the two he mentioned are involved. Parallel with the observations of Hair, Evans and White 54 concluded that 'uptakes of the dimethyldichloro- and methyltrichlorosilanes are consistent with a mechanism which results in approximately 31% and 39 % of the available surface hydroxyl groups reacting on a 2:1 basis with the dimethyl and monomethylsilane respectively'. Their conclusion were based on a silica gel, thermally pretreated at 723 K. They stated that certain geometric requirements must be fulfilled if a silane is to react on a 1"2 basis with surface hydroxyl groups, and ideally, the pair of hydroxyls involved should be separated by a distance of about 0.3 nm. Since this is considerably less than the separation expected after outgassing the silica at 723 K, the reaction mechanism would involve 'an initial reaction of the silane on a 1" 1 basis, followed by the possibility of a secondary reaction process, involving the elimination of a secondary molecule of HCI'. In other words, they suggested a secondary reaction, that Low would resuggest, more than 10 years later, for the trichlorosilane adsorption. Summarizing, the study of the chlorosilylation of the silica surface, has given rise to 5 possible reaction mechanisms, that are believed to occur simultaneously or consecutively. In order to quantify all 5 mechanisms, the researcher needs at least 5 independently measurable and quantifiable parameters.
270 However, there are often less independently measurable parameters than unknowns. In these cases, only semi-quantitative data can be obtained. One possible way to optimize such a chemical modification, is to express the experimental data in terms of effectiveness, surface coverage and stoichiometry. 2.1.2 Effectiveness, surface coverage and stoichiometry55 In the case of a chemical modification of silica, the ratio of the number of hydroxyl groups undergoing reaction (noH~r)) to the total number of initial hydroxyl groups (non,t)) reflects the effectiveness factor ~. If the specific surface area (SB~r) of the silica sample does not change during the reaction, the effectiveness factor can also be expressed as a ratio of the number of silanols per nm 2 (aon). TI
=
non~,J[mmol[g] non~o[mmol/g]
_
~] ~ on~o[#/nm2]
~ out, ) [ # / n m
(6)
However, using ~ as the only parameter in the optimization can often be misleading, since the maximum degree of conversion is not only determined by the number of reacting hydroxyl groups, but also by the mean cross-sectional area (Am) of the reacted group (sterical hindrance effects). The maximum number of bonded groups on the surface can be estimated as
am,~- 1 [#/nm2] Am
(7)
The surface coverage (0) is defined as the ratio of the actual bonded species on the surface to the maximum number of bonded species that is sterically possible.
0 -
",Xl,
0~max
_ A,,,.a,~
(8)
271
The two quantities 0 and r/are each other's complement. If 0 < 1, obviously r/can never reach unity. If 0 = 1, the quantity r/, however, is not necessarily 1, but can attain a smaller value depending on the Am value of the bonded groups. Effectiveness and surface coverage are only indices for the amount of silanols that have reacted. Depending on the functionality of the modifier, various reaction mechanisms can take place. A third parameter has to be introduced, yielding information on the different kinds of surface species. stoichiometry of the reaction, can be defined as:
f=
nou~,~
=
aou~,)
A factor f, reflecting the
(9)
For a monomolecular reaction, f is 1. Using a bifunctional modifier of the type R2SiX2, f varies in the range 1-2, depending on the ratio of vicinal to free silanols. For a completely bimolecular reaction, where 2 silanol molecules react with one molecule of modifier, f=2. Trimolecular reactions are excluded for steric reasons. In the specific case of trichlorosilane, the monomolecular reaction with silica occurs according to (L). The resulting surface groups will be called primary species furtheron. Secondary species can be formed either by a true bimolecular reaction (O) or by a secondary (consecutive) reaction (M). Incorporating the correction factor for void volume, the amx would amount about 2.2/nm 2. For spherical molecules, a fast approximation of the mean cross-sectional area is given by the formula of Emmett and Brunauer: 56 Am= 1.092(__~_M/~43.1014
~N.p)
(10)
where M is the molecular weight (135.34 g/mol for the chlorosilyl group), N is Avogadro's number and p is the density (1.34 g/ml). Application of this formula yields a mean cross-sectional area of 0.33 nm 2, and thus a C~m~xof 2.7 species per nm 2. This value is a better estimation of the experimental maximum of 2.8 per nm 2, as we have determined.
272 Assuming that the reaction of trichlorosilane with silica gel only causes primary and secondary species, the general formulae for effectiveness, surface coverage and stoichiometry can be rewritten in function of OH(o and CI on the surface. Since in the main reaction, 1 silanol yields 2 CI groups and for a secondary species, 2 silanols yield 1 CI groups, one can write: Cl 01t(0
2PS+SS PS +2SS
2-SS 1 +SS
(II)
where SS stands for the percentage of secondary species and PS for the percentage of primary species. The primary species can be substituted in equation (11), following the initial assumption that SS + PS = 1. Rewriting equation (11) as a function of SS, one obtains" Cl SS =
un(~ I+
(12)
C!
one,)
Formula (9) for the stoichiometry factor can then be actualized for the TCS chemisorption as:
f
[(1-S~.0tt~o] +
ss. Ott~o
(13)
2
When optimizing the reaction of trichlorosilane with silica gel, the first important factor to consider is the effectiveness. The pretreatment temperature of the silica, the reaction temperature and reaction time must be controlled to yield an effectiveness of
273
1. Remaining hydroxyl groups on the surface of silica gel are highly undesirable, since they would cause uncontrollable side-effects in the following reaction steps. Of all conditions, yielding an r/of 1, those must be chosen which produce the highest amount of reactive chlorine groups. This means that the surface coverage must be as high as possible, and that the stoichiometry must approach unity.
1.5
0.5-
I
73
573
I
I
I
I
673 773 873 973 Pretreatment temperature (K)
T
1023
Figure 9.39 Effectiveness, surface coverage and stoichiometry factor for the reaction of silica gel with TCS. Reactions occurred at 623 K for 1 h (mf. + ~,. 90). Figure 9.38 shows the three parameters as a function of the pretreatment temperature of the silica. All reactions occurred at 623 K for 1 h. The surface coverage curve is decreasing as a function of pretreatment temperature. A maximal surface coverage is only possible at pretreatment temperatures below 673 K. However, as can be inferred from the figure, this situation is never obtained. Therefore, it is recommendable to study the effectiveness curve. An effectiveness of 1 - a very important condition to avoid unreacted silanol groups - only occurs at pretreatment temperatures of 973 K or higher.
Based on these two curves, a pretreatment
temperature of 973 K seems to be the best choice: it is the lowest temperature (highest amount of reactable silanols) at which complete silylation occurs.
274 The stoichiometry curve can be subdivided into three regions. In the temperature region between 473 K and 673 K, bimolecular and/or secondary reactions are sterically possible. The stoichiometry factor of 1.6, found by Hair 49'52for the reaction of silica, pretreated at 573 K, with methyltrichlorosilane, is reflected in these experiments. Equation (13) proves to be a very useful formula for a relatively fast evaluation of the stoichiometry factor, provided that the initial condition (PS + SS = 1) is fulfilled. The question whether these secondary species originate from bimolecular or secondary reactions, cannot be solved by this curve. In the temperature region 673 K - 873 K, the silanols are too far separated to be involved in secondary or bimolecular reactions. In this region the stoichiometry factor is obviously 1. At temperatures above 873 K, f rises again. If the formation of secondary species is excluded for sterical reasons, the side reactions (N) or (P) are possible. The reaction (N) is a reaction with so-called strained siloxane bridges, yielding 3 chlorine groups on the surface and consuming no hydroxyl groups. Close inspection of equations (12) and (13) shows that this reaction results in a decrease off. Reaction (P) is the 'fast initial reaction', suggested by Hair. 4 In this case, a Si-OH group is simply replaced by a Si-CI group. This reaction would indeed increase the stoichiometry factor. It is important to note, that in both cases, the stoichiometry factor no longer has a physical meaning, since it is no longer a reflection of the amount of primary and secondary species on the silica surface (PS + SS is no longer 1). Figure 9.40 shows the ratio C1/OH~ for the reaction on Kieselgel 60 (pretreated at 973 K) with TCS at 623 K at different reaction times. During the first 5 minutes of the reaction, this ratio is close to 1, meaning that 1 OH is replaced by 1 C1 group. It seems very unlikely that this value is due to a combination of primary and secondary reactions. First of all, these reactions are sterically not favoured (certainly not to such an extent) and secondly, there is no reason why the CI/OH~ ratio should increase at higher reaction times. This would mean that the ratio of secondary reactions would decrease discretely as a function of reaction time. Therefore, this value is most probably caused by the reaction (P). This reaction indeed yields a CI/OH value of 1.
275
So, figure 9.40 confirms Hair's 4 statement that reaction (P) should be considered as a fast initial reaction.
1.5 CI]OH,
J
1.4 1.3 1.2 1.1 1
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
11
Reaction time (rain) Figure 9. 40 The ratio Cl over OH(reacted)for the reaction of Kieselgel 60 (pretreated at 973 K) with TCS (at 623 K) as a function of reaction time.
Reaction with strained siloxane bridges
The above does not mean that reaction (N) with the siloxane bridges does not occur. On the contrary, it is possible to present a number of arguments that suggest a reaction with strained siloxane bridges at high pretreatment temperature of the silica: Not only the concentration of the siloxane bridges increases with rising pretreatment temperatures, they also show an enhanced reactivity. It is assumed that with higher degassing temperatures, the remaining isolated hydroxyls are progressively removed and that various types of structural changes must occur, giving rise to the so-called strained siloxane bridges, which exhibit an enhanced activity. Morrow 57 stated that site is assumed to be an unsymmetrical siloxane bridge, containing an electron deficient silicon atom, which can act as a Lewis acid centre.
276 The reaction of strained siloxane bridges with Lewis bases is not restricted to chlorosilanes. For instance, it will be discussed in part 3, that also ammonia reacts to some extent with strained siloxane bridges. A relatively easy way to check the existence of reaction (N) with strained siloxane bridges is to replace and/or to block all surface hydroxyl groups by a reaction with HMDS. This deactivated silica gel is then reacted with trichlorosilane. Kieselgel 60, thermally pretreated at 973 K, was refluxed with HMDS and consequently reacted with TCS at 623 K for 1 h. The Cl-contents on the surface of the silylated samples was determined. The results are presented in table 9.8. Table 9.8 CI contents on silica samples after reaction with TCS at different reaction temperatures; with and without a hydroxyl blocking by HMDS
Reaction temperature (K)
C1 (no H M D S ) (mmol/g)
CI(HMDS) (mmol/g)
TCS reacted (#/nm 2)
Pretreatment temperature: 973 K 423 623
0.34 1.05
0.0 0.57
0.0 0.27
This table shows that a reaction of TCS with siloxane bridges does not occur at reaction temperatures of 423 K. Apparently, this reaction temperature is too low to induce a cleavage of the siloxane bridge. Reaction does occur, however, when the temperature is raised to 623 K. When the CI content is converted to the amount per nm2 and divided by 3, the amount of TCS that has actually reacted with the siloxane bridges can be calculated (table 9.8, last column). For a silica gel, pretreated at 973 K, approximately 0.3 siloxane groups per nm 2 react with trichlorosilane at 623 K. Comparing the Cl-contents on the silica samples, pretreated at 973 K, with and without a pre-modification with HMDS, the reaction with strained siloxane bridges seems to be quite significant. However, in a real situation, the different reactions are competitive. HMDS modification creates a surface where the reaction with siloxane bridges can occur free of competition. Therefore, these values may overestimate the degree of reaction in a 'real' situation. The scientific relevance of these data is concealed in the unambiguous proof that (1) chlorosilanes do react with strained
277 siloxanes bridges and (2) that this reaction increases with higher reaction temperatures. The reaction also increases with higher pretreatment temperatures, creating more ionic siloxanes and thus lowering the required activation energy. ~gsi CP MAS NMR measurements
Complementary information concerning the amount of primary and secondary species on the silica gel surface can be found, using 29Si CP MAS NMR (Cross Polarization Magic Angle Spinning). 29Si CP MAS NMR (79.5 MHz) was performed on a Bruker 400 MSL spectrometer, using a contact time of 5 ms, a recycle time of 3 s, a spinning rate of 3.5 kHz, and a number of scans between 3000 and 8000. Based upon the publication of Maciel and Sindorf, 5g the chemical shift of the different surface species (relative to TMS) could be derived. Table 9.9 summarizes the most important peak attributions. Table 9.9 29Si NMR Peak attributions of the possible surface species on silica gel
Chemical shift -100 -91 -84 -60 -45 -36
Attribution Single silanols (free or bridged) Geminal silanols Hydrolyzed secondary species, (O2)Si(H)(OH) Secondary species, (Oz)Si(H)(C1) Hydrolyzed primary species (O)Si(H)(OH)z and (O)Si(H)(C1)(OH) (too close to separate) Primary species, (O)Si(H)(C1)2
The figures 9.41 (a) and (b) show the NMR spectra of Kieselgel 60, pretreated at 973 K and reacted with TCS for 1 h at 423 K and 623 K respectively. Three bands can be observed in figure 9.41 (a). The bands at -100 ppm and -92 ppm are due to remaining silanols. The effectiveness factor for this reaction, calculated using equation (13), is 0.52. So, almost 50% of the available silanols remains unreacted. The band at -36 ppm is attributed to the primary species. No significant band is
278
observable in the -60 ppm region, indicating that no secondary species are formed on the surface at reaction temperatures of 423 K.
I
2~ "
~
-2~
-4~
-~I PPM
-9~
-I!~ '
-I12~,'
'-I14~'
Figure 9. 41 (a) 29SiMAS NMR spectrum of KG60 (973 K), reacted with TCS (423 K,1 h).
I I
'
" ,:"10 "
'
"
u~
'
'
" -2~I .
,
. -4Bi .
,
. -6ill .
PFM
,
. -Sill .
,
._IBBt .
,
._I12. .
9I14
Figure 9. 41 (b) ~gSiMAS NMR spectrum of KG60 (973 K), reacted with TCS (623 K,1 h).
279 One would expect that a reaction with TCS at 623 K also would cause exclusively primary species, originating from either the main reaction (L) or the side reaction (N). Inspection of the NMR spectrum in figure 9.41 (b) shows that all silanols have disappeared. There is no band in the-100 ppm region, and this is consistent with the earlier calculated effectiveness factor of 1. The main feature still is the -36 ppm band, attributed to the primary species. However, a significant band is situated at -60 ppm, indicative for secondary species. The conclusion, based of the stoichiometry factor f, that no secondary species exist on a silica surface pretreated at 973 K, is therefore not entirely correct. Obviously, the bifunctional reaction (O) is highly improbable, so secondary reactions (M) must occur. This is only possible when a certain mobility of the surface species exists on the surface, since -on average- the distance between the surface species is too large to react with each other.
Reactivity offree and bridged silanols In chapter 4 the ambiguity in literature, concerning the distribution of free and bridged silanols on the silica surface was mentioned. This divergence is even more pronounced when the reactivity of these silanols is investigated. Some authors have stated that chlorosilanes solely react with the free (isolated) silanols on the silica gel surface. 47,59,6~ Others claimed a significant contribution of the bridged (vicinal) silanols. 49'53'54 We have therefore studied in particular the reaction of Kieselgel 60 with trichlorosilane, covering a wide region of pretreatment temperatures and reaction times. 3~ All calculations were performed using the method of FTIR band integration. Figure 9.42 shows the percentage of free and bridged silanols reacted with TCS, after 1 h at 623 K, as a function of pretreatment temperature. The hypothesis that TCS reacts exclusively with free silanols is not reflected in these experiments, but the reactivity of the bridged silanols is obviously quite low. The pretreatment temperature has a large impact on the reactivity of the free and bridged hydroxyls. It must be stressed that statements about reactivity are meaningless without specifying the pretreatment temperature. Earlier statements on the exclusive reaction of TCS with free hydroxyl groups or on the contribution of the bridged hydroxyl groups in the reaction are only valid in a small pretreatment region, and are therefore not necessarily contradictory.
280
% reacted 100
/ _ ~ f
I
I
80
6C 40 20 0
473
I
573
I
673
I
773
873
973
1073
Pretreatment temperature (K) Figure 9.42 Percentage of reacted free (FOH) and bridged silanols (BOH) with TCS. Reactions occurred at 623 K for lh (.bridged OH; + free OH).
The picture on the reactivity of surface hydroxyls (figure 9.42) can be explained in terms of reactivity and availability. At pretreatment temperatures above 873 K, no bridged silanols are present at the silica surface and the lack of reactivity is obviously trivial in this region. Progressively lowering the pretreatment temperature, the relative (and absolute) concentration of the bridged silanols becomes increasingly higher, explaining the higher fraction of bridged silanols that react. An interesting region to study the participation of free and bridged silanols in the reaction, is the pretreatment temperature of 723 K, since it is the only temperature at which equal concentrations of free and bridged silanols are present at the silica surface. Additionally, the total silanol concentration is less than 2.8 OH per nm2, sterically allowing total conversion. Figure 9.42 shows that at this pretreatment temperature, less than 20 % of the bridged silanols react, whereas more than 95 % of the free silanols are converted. As the ratio BOH/FOH becomes higher than 10. The competition becomes so strong that the free silanols are no longer able to react completely. Figure 9.43 shows the effect of changing the reaction time on the percentage of free and bridged silanols that react with TCS. The effect of prolonged reaction times on
281 the conversion of free silanols is very low. The conversion is slightly improved in the low pretreatment region at reaction times of 3 h. Longer reaction times do not induce a further reaction.
% reacted 100 80 6(3 40
I
473
573
I
I
673 773 Pretreatment temperature (K)
873
Figure 9. 43 Percentage offree and bridged silanols reacted with TCS (623 K), as a function of pretreatment temperature and reaction time (= lh-BOH; + 3h BOH; * 17h-BOH; o lhFOH; x 3h-FOH; (> 17h-FOH).
Similar observations can be made for the bridged silanols. One notices a significant enhancement in the conversion degree when the reaction is extended to 3 h, after which the conversion degree approaches a constant value. It is noticeable that-even after 17 h of reaction- only 50% of the bridged silanols have reacted (pretreatment temperature = 673 K), whereas sterically, total conversion should be possible. This could explain the statement of some authors that chlorosilanes react exclusively with free silanols. Most of cited studies described the chlorosilylation of a silica gel, pretreated at 673 K. After the reaction, the infrared spectrum indeed shows only a
282 large remaining bridged silanol band and no free silanol peak. Since most of the cited studies have been performed some decades ago, one could reasonably state that the small diminution of the BOH band could not be detected by older type spectrometers.
2.2 Liquid-phase reaction with alkylchlorosilanes (Cs- Cls) The formation of monolayers by self-assembly of organochlorosilanes on various surfaces 62'63'64'65 and organosulfur compounds on gold 66'67 is well established. The durability of the self-assembled monolayer is highly dependent on the effectiveness of the anchoring to the surface. On gold, the attachment to the surface is due to an interaction of sulphur end groups with the gold surface. However, the nature of the attachment of the organochlorosilane with the surface is ill-defined. 68'69'7~ Octadecyltrichlorosilane (C18H37SIC13, henceforth denoted OTS) is the most common
organosilane used for the formation of self-assembled monolayers and, when reacted with silica surface, finds extensive use as a bonded phase in liquid chromatography applications. 7~ A common mechanism proposed for attachment of the chlorosilane to the surface 69'72 involves the hydrolysis of the chlorosilane groups with water which is already on the surface of the substrate. The silanols which are formed then condense with the surface hydroxyls groups to form stable linkages to the substrate. In practice, a curing process is usually required to condense adjacent silanols attached to the organosilane to form a cross-linked 'mat' on the surface. Part of the difficulty in determining the nature of the attachment to the surface arises from the lack of direct spectral evidence. For high surface area metal oxides such as fumed silicas, infrared spectroscopy 49'73'74'75 and NMR 76'77 have been very successful in determining the nature of the attachment of chlorosilane molecules to the surface. The main problem in using infrared spectroscopy in the study of self-assembled monolayers is that the substrates have low surface area and therefore the bands due to the adsorbed species are low in intensity. Although it is generally believed that the water content on the surface is vital for the formation of a monolayer, and that OTS reacts with the water layer and forms only few bonds with the surface, direct spectroscopic evidence was lacking.
283
In 1992 Tripp and Hair TM unified the two chlorosilane approaches by reacting OTS with a high surface area amorphous silica gel, in order to probe spectroscopically the different surface species. Using a home-made in situ liquid infrared cell, they derived following conclusions: 1. OTS does not react with degassed silica at room temperature. The infrared band of the free hydroxyls shifts to 3690 cm ~ but does not change in intensity. This indicates that the chlorosilane is physisorbed (H-bridged) on the silica surface. Subsequent degassing removes all adsorbed species. This conclusion is not surprising. Also (methyl)chlorosilanes do not react with the silica surface at room temperature. Reaction temperatures > 473 K are required to achieve noticeable reaction. The boiling point of octadecyltrichlorosilane is 433 K. It would be very interesting to see what happens at reflux temperature.
0
OTS does react slightly with 'wet' silica at room temperature, containing multilayers of water on the surface. The broad band at 3650 cm ~ decreases slightly, and a band at 3350 cm ~ arises, attributed to trisilanols. 79'8~Tripp and Hair TM state that the first layer of water is strongly bonded to the surface and does not participate in the hydrolysis of the chlorosilane headgroup of the OTS molecule. Subsequent layers would be less strongly bonded to the surface and would be able to participate in direct hydrolysis of the OTS.
Since the hydrolysis and adsorption of the OTS occurs with the subsequent layers of water, an optimum level is necessary to form robust films" too little water results in the formation of an incomplete monolayer, whereas a thick water layer causes a polymerization of the OTS with the water, resulting in a very poor adherence to the silica surface. Not only octadecyltrichlorosilane is unreactive towards dry silica at room temperature. This is also the case for the chlorosilanes and the methylchlorosilanes. It was stated earlier that the vapour phase reaction occurs at elevated temperatures (> 473 K). This high-temperature constraint limits potential gas phase silanizing agents to those which have a high thermal stability and sufficient vapour pressure.
284
In practice, the common method for silanization of silica is to mix a chlorosilane with a hydrated silica in a suitable organic solvent. A common mechanism reported for this reaction is that the chlorosilane is first hydrolyzed by the water and this is followed by the condensation with the surface hydroxyl groups to form a strong S i - O - S i surface bond. 72 If the starting silane contains a trichlorosilyl headgroup, then further condensation between adjacent silanes can occur, yielding a two-dimensional polysiloxane network. The occurrence of the first step, the hydrolysis of the chlorosilane to a silanol by the surface water is amply supported by the literature. 6s'69,Ts'gl At either the solid/gas or solid/liquid interface the chlorosilane does not adsorb on a completely dehydrated silica and is hydrolyzed to the silanol with the surface water of a hydrated silica. However, Tripp and Hair s2 have shown that the second critical step (i.e. condensation of the silanol with the surface hydroxyls groups) does not occur. At the solid/gas interface, the silanol adsorbs on the surface but does not undergo condensation or polymerization, whereas at the solid/liquid interface, the silanol polymerizes in solution and adsorbs on the surface. In neither case there is a strong Si~-O-Si bond formed with the substrate. It is the absence of Si~-O-Si surface linkages that is responsible for the general lack of robustness of silanized surfaces prepared from solution. In a subsequent publication, Tripp and Hair 83 describe a new method to chemically bind chlorosilanes to the surface under mild reaction conditions. In fact, there are two possible ways for a base-catalyzed chemisorption of chlorosilanes on silica. One possible strategy is to use a base to promote the reaction of chlorosilanes with the surface silanols. In essence, this reaction proceeds by a one-stage nucleophilic mechanism through the formation of a pentacoordinate silicon intermediate. The Si-CI bond is lengthened in the intermediate and is susceptible to attack by a second nucleophile: s4
285
R -
R3SiC1 + Nu
Cl I
\Si-
R
(Q)
RW'Nu ~
R
C1 I
\Si- R
RW'Nu ~
+ -Si-OH
~
-Si - OSiR3
+ HC1 + N u
(R)
An alternative mechanism for the base-promoted reaction of silanes with silica has been described by Blitz et al. 85 In this mechanism, the base attacks directly to the surface silanols. The bonded amine renders the silanol more nucleophilic which then attacks the silicon atom of an approaching silane, giving rise to a pentacoordinate intermediate.
/ O"
.
N(Et)3 / 8 H + ~ C 1 ~ 3
+ N(EO 3_.
/ O 8-
CI "I N(Et)3 H 3C uSi,. ~ H _ /6 +
Cl1"~)/6_
CI CH 3 HCI NSi' N(Et)3 / O "el
In both mechanisms a pentacoordinate intermediate is postulated. The main difference is that the pentacoordinate intermediate is formed by attachment of the amine to the
286
chlorosilane in one case and by attachment to a surface Si-O group in the other. The main problem associated with base-catalized silanization is that it is very difficult to prevent polymerization of the silane in solution. Rapid polymerization of the chlorosilane occurs in solution unless extreme precautions are taken to exclude contact with residual water. Thus, in a typical base-promoted silanization on silica, it is more likely that both polymerization and surface reaction occur to some extent. Both mechanisms can account for polymerization. The intermediate formed by attachment of the amine to the chlorosilane could react with nucleophiles (i.e., molecular water) other than the surface silanols. In the mechanism described by Blitz et al. the chlorosilane (either attached or in solution) could be hydrolyzed to the trisilanol by molecular water and the trisilanol offers an additional source of silanols for base attachment and subsequent polymerization. Polymerization often results in a thick silane layer on the surface that in many cases is undesirable. Polymerization is not possible in the complete absence of water or when reactions are carried out using monochlorosilanes. However, trichlorosilanes are attractive because it is possible to increase the strength of the adsorbed silane layer through cross-linking between adjacent molecules. The other approach, the exclusion of trace quantities of water, especially in solution, is extremely difficult and costly. In 1993, Tripp and Hair g3 described a method to promote the direct reaction of the chlorosilyl headgroup with the surface hydroxyls groups, using a nitrogen-containing base (triethylamine). In this method, polymerization is avoided because the base and chlorosilane are not added simultaneously but subsequentially in a two-step process. The silica is evacuated and exposed to the vapour of a nitrogen-containing base which forms a strong hydrogen bond with the surface silanols. Excess base is removed by evacuation and the silica is then placed in contact with the chlorosilane. It is the evacuation of the excess amine which suppresses polymerization. The base catalyzes the reaction immediately and leaves the silane chemically attached to the surface of the silica. Although the coaddition of the base and chlorosilane under anhydrous conditions gives similar adsorbed species, the two-step process has a number of advantages:
287 in the presence of surface water, polymerization is avoided; in the absence of surface water, the two-step process can be used to build a multilayered silane in a well-defined manner.
C1 / C H 3 \Si ~ I
(Et)3N H 2~ =
C1
O
CH3 H\ O [
~ Si f O
N(Et)3
,I
H
I
o
CH 3 C1--si~C1 O~ CH 3SiCI_3
~ H3
C1
Si OI
0 ~~ S~~'m CH 3 / C1
The creation of such a network of attached silanes on a substrate by consecutive single-step adsorptions is in fact a Chemical Surface Coating (CSC). The principles of Chemical Surface Coating 86'87are explained and exemplified in detail in part 3 of this book.
288
3 Modification with other silicon compounds
3.1 Halogenosilanes (e4_nSinrn, e4.nSiIn) The interaction of the silica surface with trimethyliodosilane and trimethylbromosilane has been described by Tertykh and Belyakova. s8 Both reactions proceed much faster than the previously described chlorosilane reaction. The reaction of silica with trimethylbromosilane is completed after 30 minutes at 323 K and the reaction with trimethyliodosilane even after 10 minutes at room temperature. The authors evidenced, using a methoxylated silica as a substrate, that at these temperatures no reaction occurs of the halogenosilanes with the siloxane bridges of the silica. No pretreatment temperature was mentioned, however. Therefore we cannot exclude a small reaction of the bromo- or iodosilanes with the siloxane bridges of the silica, thermally pretreated at high temperatures. The reactivity sequence of the halogenosilanes can be ordered as (CH3)3SiI > (CH3)3SiBr > (CH3)3SiCI It can be inferred from the data in table 9.10 that the decrease in reactivity can be explained in terms of decreasing Si-X bond length or increasing Si-X bond energy. Also the higher polarizability and proton accepting properties of the larger halogens have to be taken into account. Table 9.10 Some physical and chemical characteristics of silicon-halogen bonds Bond
Length of the bond, nm
Si-C1 0.2020+0.0005 Si-Br 0.216+0.001 Si-I 0.246___0.002
Energy of the bond, kJ/mol
396 289 213
Polarizability, cm3
7.11 10.03 -
Dipole moment of the (CH3)3SiHal molecule, D 2.09 2.36 2.46
289
3.2 Alkoxysilanes (R4..Si(OR).) In a number of cases, (e.g. modification of a silica surface, containing N-functions), alkoxysilanes are more useful than the corresponding chlorosilanes for reacting with the silica surface. The reaction of dimethyldiethoxysilane ((CH3)2Si(OC2Hs)2) with the isolated silanols proceeds under milder conditions than the chlorosilane analogue: dimethyldichlorosilane ((CH3)2SIC12). In the former case, complete conversion is obtained at 373 K, whereas the chlorosilane needs temperatures up to 573 K. 88 However, in the case of a silica containing vicinal silanols, the reactivity is reversed and the chlorosilanes become more reactive than the corresponding alkoxysilanes. The increased reactivity of alkoxysilanes in the reaction with isolated silanol groups can be explained by the higher proton affinity of the oxygen atom of the Si-O-Si group, compared to the Cl-atom in the Si-CI group. This is evidenced by the observation that the physisorption of an alkoxysilane on a silica surface results in a free hydroxyl band shift of approximately 300 cm ~, whereas the physisorption of a chlorosilane induces a shift of'only' 100 c m l . 89 The presence of significant quantities of physisorbed water promotes the chemisorption of alkoxysilanes, especially of the ones with two or three alkoxy groups. Engelhardt and Orth 9~ reported that chemisorption of n-octyltriethoxysilane from a dry toluene solution on a dehydrated silica amounts 0.30/~mol/m 2. However, if a toluene solution containing traces of water is used, the amount of chemisorbed silane increases up to 1.25 #mol/m 2. The process of oligo- and polymerisation can occur either on the surface of the wet silica or in the toluene solution. The formation of polylayered coatings was investigated in detail by Gorski et al., 91 reporting on the chemisorption of 3-methylacryloxypropyltrimethoxysilane from acetone solutions, containing various amounts of water.
290 The rather difficult question how many alkoxygroups of one trialkoxysilane molecule participate in the chemical bonding has been studied by high resolution NMR on 29Si and ~3C nuclei. 92'93'94 Sindorf and Macie192 concluded that in the case of dehydrated silicas, mainly monodentate and some bidentate species are formed. Reactions involving all three alkoxy groups do no occur on the surface of dry silica. However, using a hydrated silica as a substrate results in the complete disappearance of the ~3C resonance of ethoxy groups, indicating that all alkoxygroups have participated in the reaction. In the last decades, the interest in the chemisorption of alkoxysilanes on the silica surface has increased significantly. Many organophylic silicas have been synthesized using alkoxysilanes as modifying agents. They have found applications as fillers of electric isolating resins or as thickeners for organosilicon vaselines. 88
3.3 Alkylsiloxanes The electron-donor ability of oxygen decreases according to the series C - O - C > C-O-Si > > Si-O-Si
This statement was evidenced by a study of West et al. 95 They noticed that the O H - b a n d shift of phenol amounted 329, 261 and 169 cm ~ upon interaction with (CH3)3COC(CH3)3, (CH3)3COSi(Cn3) 3 and (CH3)3SiOSi(CH3) 3 respectively.
It is assumed that this behaviour can be explained by an additional interaction between the undivided p-electrons of the oxygen atom and the vacant 3d-orbitals of the silicon atom (the so called (p:d,)-interaction). 96 The ideas about the nature of the siloxane bond were developed by Voronkov. 97 He stated that (p:d~)-bonds of a donor-acceptor type are formed in a Si-O-Si system owing to the undivided electron pairs of oxygen and the vacant d-orbitals of the silicon atoms. In this case, the oxygen atom is in a state of hybridization, intermediate between sp 2 and sp.
291
This leads to a significant weakening of the electron donor properties of oxygen and to a significant weakening of the electron accepting properties of the silicon. This means that the heterolysis of a siloxane bond proceeds under much more severe conditions than their carbon analogues. However, the heterolytic splitting of Si-O-Si bonds is not impossible. Strong electrophilic reagents, such as BF3 or A1C13, or strong nucleophilic reagents with a possibility of simultaneous electrophilic attack, such as HF, are able to break the Si-O-Si bond quite easily. Moreover, the properties of the Si-O-Si bond are strongly influenced by the nature of the substitutors near the silicon atom. Electron accepting substitutors lead to an increase of the siloxane bond strength, whereas electron donating substitutors lead to a decrease of the siloxane bond strength. Kriegsmann 9s noticed that the siloxane bonds of hexamethyldisiloxane are easily broken in the reaction with BF3, whereas hexachlorodisiloxane does not react at all. Room temperature adsorption of hexamethyldisiloxane mainly results in a physisorption, established by hydrogen bonding. 88 Figure 9.44 clearly shows that the 3750 cm 1 of the free hydroxyls shifts towards 3710 cm" and 3400 cm ' upon siloxane adsorption. At the same time, naturally, the characteristic bands for methyl groups appear. The 3400 cm ~ band has been assigned to a hydrogen bonding between the siloxane oxygen and the silanol hydrogen atoms (figure 9.44 a). The 3710 cm ~ band has been assigned to an adsorption complex between the oxygen atom of the silanol group and the silicon atom of the siloxane (figure 9.44 b). _YOH~ 3400 cm -1
o"t/
(a)
J, ,,,
H--
O
~Si(CH3) 3 ~~
H~
/O
Si(CH3) 3
O~
~OH 3710 c
Si ,,,
I
Si(CH3) 3 Si(CH3) 3
(b)
Figure 9.44 Assignments of the silanol stretching vibrations upon physisorption of hexamethy ldisiloxane. Degassing of the silica results in a complete desorption of the hexamethyldisiloxane. Irreversible chemisorption of alkoxysiloxanes starts at reaction temperatures above
292 673 K. Tertykh ss evidenced that complete removal of silanols is achieved on an aerosil, treated at 923 K, and reacted with hexamethyldisiloxane for 40 minutes at 773 K.
References
o
0
0
E.P. Plueddemann, Silane Coupling Agents, 2nd ed., Plenum Press, New York, 1991. S.W. Morrall, D.E. Leyden, in Silanes, Surfaces and Interfaces, D.E. Leyden ed., Gordon & Breach Science Publ., New York, 1985, 501. K.C. Vrancken, P. Van Der Voort, I. Gillis-D'Hamers, E.F. Vansant and P. Grobet, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1992, 88, 3197.
4.
K.M.R. Kallury, P.M. MacDonald and M. Thompson, Langmuir, 1994, 10, 492.
5.
J.P. Blitz, R.S.S. Murthy and D.E. Leyden, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1987, 121, 63.
6.
D.G. Kurth and T. Bein, Langmuir, 1993, 9, 2965.
7.
P. Trens, Ph-D thesis, Aix-Marseilles, 1994.
8.
C. Chiang, H. Ishida and J.L. Koenig, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1980, 74, 396.
0
E.P. Plueddemann, Silane Coupling Agents, 2nd ed., Plenum Press, New York, 1991, 64.
10.
D.J. Kelly and D.E. Leyden, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1991, 147, 213.
11.
C.W. Chu, D.P. Kirby and P.D. Murphy, J. Adhesion Sci. Technol., 1993, 7, 417.
12.
S. Naviroj, S.R. Culler, J.L. Koenig and H.Ishida, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1984, 97, 308.
13.
C.G. Pantano and T.N. Wittberg, Surf. Interface Anal. 1990, 15, 498.
14.
H.-J. Kang and F.D. Blum, J. Phys. Chem., 1991, 95, 9391.
15.
E.T. Vandenberg, Bertilsson, B. Liedberg, K. Uvdal, R. Erlandsson, H. Elwing and I. Lundstr6m, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 1991, 147, 103.
293
16.
R.S.S. Murthy and D.E. Leyden, Anal. Chem., 1986, 58, 1228.
17.
R.S.S. Murthy, J.P. Blitz and D.E. Leyden, Anal. Chem., 1986, 58, 3167.
18.
M.T. McKenzie, S.R. Culler and J.L. Koenig, Appl. Spectrosc., 1984, 38, 786.
19.
C. Chiang, N. Liu and J.L. Koenig, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 1982, 86, 26.
20.
J.W. De Haan, H.M. Van Den Bogaert, J.J. Ponje6 and L.J.M. Van De Ven, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 1986, 110, 591.
21.
G.S. Caravajal, D.E. Leyden and G.E. Maciel, in 'Silanes, Surfaces and Interfaces', D.E. Leyden ed., Gordon & Breach Sci. Publ., New York, 1985, 283.
22.
G.S. Caravajal, D.E. Leyden, G.R. Quinting and G.E. Maciel, Anal. Chem., 1988, 60, 1776.
23.
E.J.R. Sudh61ter, R. Huis, G.R. Hays and N.C.M. Alma, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1985, 103, 554.
24.
T.L. Weeding, W.S. Veeman, L.W. Jenneskens, H. Angad Gaur, H.E.C. Schuurs, and W.G.B. Huysmans, Macromolecules, 1989, 22, 706.
25.
B. Pfleiderer, K. Albert, E. Bayer, L. Van De Ven, J. De Haan and C. Cramers, J. Phys. Chem., 1990, 94, 4189.
26.
K.C. Vrancken, K. Possemiers, P. Van Der Voort and E.F. Vansant, Coll. Surf., in print.
27.
F.D. Blum, W. Meesiri, H.-J. Kang and J.E. Gambogi, in Silanes and Other Coupling Agents, K.L. Mittal ed., VSP, Utrecht, The Netherlands, 1992, 181.
28.
K.C. Vrancken, P. Van Der Voort, K. Possemiers and E.F. Vansant, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1995, 169; in print.
29.
T.G. Waddell, D.E. Leyden and M.T. DeBello, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1981, 103, 5303.
30.
P. Van Der Voort, I. Gillis-D'Hamers, K.C. Vrancken, E.F. Vansant, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1991, 87, 3899.
31.
B.A. Morrow and I.A. Cody, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 1998.
32.
L.H. Dubois and B.R. Zegarski, J. Phys. Chem., 1993, 97, 1665.
33.
P. Van Der Voort, K.C. Vrancken, E.F. Vansant, J. Riga, J. Chem .Soc. Faraday Trans., 1993, 89(14), 2509.
294 34.
P. Fink, I. Plotski and G. Rudakoff, Wiss. Zeitschr. Friedrich-Schiller Univ. JenaNaturwiss., 1990, R-39, 217.
35.
K.C. Vrancken, P. Van Der Voort, K. Possemiers, P. Grobet and E.F. Vansant, in Chemically Modified Surfaces, J.J. Pesek and I.E. Leigh eds., The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 1994, 46.
36.
S. Kondo, T. Ishikawa, N. Yamagami, K. Yoshioka and Y. Nakahara, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 1987, 60, 95.
37.
for method see also chapter 9 paragraph 1.4.1.
38.
H.R. Anderson, F.M. Fowkes and F.H. Hielscher, J. Polym. Sci., Polym. Phys. Ed., 1976, 14, 879.
39.
P.R. Moses, L.M. Wier, J.C. Lennox, H.O. Finklea, J.R. Lenhard and R.W. Murray, Anal. Chem., 1978, 50, 576.
40.
D.E. Leyden, D.S. Kendall and T.G. Waddell, Anal. Chim. Acta, 1981, 126, 207.
41.
H. Linde, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 1990, 40, 613.
42.
S.R. Culler, H. Ishida and J.L. Koenig, Appl. Spectrosc., 1984, 38, 1.
43.
S.R. Culler, S. Naviroj, H. Ishida and J.L. Koenig, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1983, 96, 69.
44.
K.P. Battjes, A.M. Barolo and P. Dreyfuss, J. Adhesion Sci. Technol., 1991, 5, 785.
45.
K.C. Vrancken, L. De Coster, P. Van Der Voort, P.J. Grobet and E.F. Vansant, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1995, in print.
46.
B.A. Morrow and A.J. McFarlan, J. Phys. Chem., 1992, 96, 1395.
47.
A.A. Chuiko, V.A. Tertykh, V.A. Khranovskii, Yu.P. Egorov and L.M. Roev, Teoreticheskaya i Eksperimental'naya Khimiya, 1966, 2, 247; Engl. transl., p. 189.
48.
M.J.D. Low, A.G. Severdia and J. Chan, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1982, 86, 111.
49.
M.L. Hair and W. Hertl, J. Phys. Chem., 1969, 73, 2372.
50.
M.L. Hair and W. Hertl, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 2070.
51.
M.L. Hair and W. Hertl, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1965.
52.
M.L. Hair, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1977, 60, 154.
53.
M.L. Hair, Silica surfaces, in Silanes, Surfaces and Interfaces, ed. D.E. Leyden, Gordon and Breach science publishers, 1985.
295 54.
B. Evans and T.E. White, J. Catal., 1968, 11,336.
55.
P. Van Der Voort, K.C. Vranken and E.F. Vansant, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1995, in press.
56.
P.H. Emmet and S. Brunauer, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1937, 59, 1553.
57.
B.A. Morrow, I.A. Cody and L.S.M. Lee, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 2692.
58.
G.E. Maciel and D.W. Sindorf, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1983, 105, 3767.
59.
V. Davydov, A.T. Zhuravlev, A.V. Kiselev, Zh. Fiz. Khim., 1964, 38, 2047.
60.
K. Yoshinaga, H. Yoshida, Y. Yamamoto, K. Takakura, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1992, 153, 207.
61.
P. Van Der Voort, I. Gillis-D'Hamers and E.F. Vansant, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1990, 86, 3751.
62.
R. Maoz and J. Sagiv, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1984, 100, 465.
63.
N. Tillman, A. Ulman and T. L. Penner, Langmuir, 1989, 5, 101.
4.
S.R. Wasserman, G.M. Whitesides, I.M. Tidswell, B.M. Ocko, P.S. Pershan and J.D. Axe, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1989, 111, 5852.
65.
G.A. Carson and S. Granick, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., 1989, 37, 2767.
66.
M.D. Porter, T.B. Bright, D.L. Allara and C.E.D. Chirdsy, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1987, 109, 3559.
67.
C.D. Bain and G.M. Whitesides, Science, 1988, 240, 62.
68.
P. Silberzan, L. lager, D. Ausserre and J.J. Benattar, Langmuir, 1991, 7, 1647.
69.
D.L. Angst and G.W. Simmons, Langmuir, 1991, 7, 2236.
70.
C.R. Kessel and S. Granick, Langmuir, 1991, 7, 532.
71.
J. Nawrocki and B.J. Buszewski, J. Chromatogr. Rev., 1988, 449, 1.
72.
J. Sagiv, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1980, 102, 92.
73.
J.B. Peri, J. Phys. Chem., 1966, 70, 2937.
74.
C.G. Armistead and J.A. Hockey, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1967, 63, 2549.
75.
C.P. Tripp and M.L. Hair, Langmuir, 1991, 7, 923.
296 76.
D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1981, 103, 4263.
77.
R.K. Gilpin and M.E. Gangola, J. Chromatogr. Sci., 1990, 28, 277.
78.
C.P. Tripp and M.L. Hair, Langmuir, 1992, 8, 1120.
79.
H. Ishida and J.L. Koenig, Applied Spectroscopy, 1978, 32, 462.
80.
H. Ishida and J.L. Koenig, Applied Spectroscopy, 1978, 32, 469.
81.
C.P. Tripp and M.L. Hair, Langmuir, 1992, 8, 1961.
82.
C.P. Tripp and M.L. Hair, Langmuir, 1992, 8, 1961.
83.
C.P. Tripp and M.L. Hair, J. Phys. Chem., 1993, 97, 5693.
84.
J.M. Kinkel and K.K. Unger, J. Chromatogr., 1984, 316, 193.
85.
J.P. Blitz, R.S. Murthy and D.E. Leyden, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 126, 387.
86.
P. Van Der Voort, I. Gillis-D'Hamers, K.C. Vrancken and E.F. Vansant, Ceramic Industries International, 1992, 102, 17.
87.
P. Van Der Voort, E.F. Vansant and J. Riga, Ceramic Industries International, 1993, 103, 17.
88.
V.A. Tertykh and L.A. Belyakova, Chemical reactions involving the silica surface, Naukova Dumka Publishers, Kiev, 1991. (in Russian)
89.
W. Hertl and M.L. Hair, J. Phys. Chem., 1968, 72, 4676.
90.
H. Engelhardt and P. Orth, J. Liq. Chrom., 1987, 10, 1999.
91.
D. Gorski, E. Klemm, P. Fink and H. H6rhold, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1988, 126, 445.
92.
D.W. Sindorf and G.E. Maciel, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1983, 105, 3767.
93.
E.I.R. Sudh61ter, R. Huis, G.R. Hays and N.C.M. Alma, J. Colloid Interface Sci., 1985, 103, 554.
94.
J.M.J. Vankan, J.J. Ponjee, J.W. De Haan and L.J.M. Van de Ven, J. Colloid Interface Sei., 1988, 126, 604.
95.
R. West, L.S. Whatley and K.J. Lake, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1961, 83, 761.
96.
W. Noll, Angew. Chem., 1963, 2, 73.
297 97.
M.G. Voronkov, Chemistry and practical applications of organosilicon compounds, 1961, 6, 136. (in Russian)
98.
H. Kriegsmann, Z. Anorg. Algem. Chem., 1959, 299, 139.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
299
Chapter 10
Modification with boron compounds
1 Introduction Boron containing molecules, such as B2H6, BCI3, and BF3, have often been used as modifying agents. Much of these efforts have been motivated by the possibility of developing new catalytic materials, based on the properties of the electron deficient boron atom. Researchers ~'2'3'4'5noticed that silicas, containing boron at their surface, interact much more strongly with organic bases, water, ammonia and all other molecules, capable of either proton- or electron - transfer. Therefore silicas modified with boron containing molecules could perhaps yield catalysts in which the active centres exist at the surface in a discrete array and possibly with determinable structure and coordination. 2 The greater part of the modification studies of silica with boron compounds has been directed towards achieving an understanding of the surface structure of silica and silica based adsorbents, utilizing the quantitative reactions with boron containing probe molecules. Because hydroxyl type specificity occurred in some reactions, boron compounds were used to make a distinction between isolated and vicinal surface hydroxyls. Diborane was even utilized as a probe to distinguish surface silanols from hydration water. 6'7 Besides, further reaction of the chemisorbed surface species with other compounds is also possible and interesting.
300 The following overview of the modification reactions of silica with boron compounds will be focused on B2H 6 and BX 3 (X -- C1 and F).
2 Modification with boronhalides
2.1 Reaction mechanisms
The boronhalides (BX3) are volatile, highly reactive, monomeric compounds, which show no detectable tendency to dimerize. In this they resemble organoboranes, BR3, but differ sharply from diborane, B2H 6. The molecules have a planar trigonal structure with the boron atom (sp2 - hybridization) in the centre. This class of compounds also exhibits partial double bond character due to p,- p~ interactions of the empty pz-orbital of boron and the filled pz-orbital of the halogen. Because of the incomplete octetstructure of the central boron atom, borontrihalides behave as strong Lewis acids. In the discussion no subdivision will be made for BC13 and B F 3. Both molecules are strong lewis acids and follow the same reaction mechanisms. BCI 3 may be taken as the more reactive species of the two. The B-F bond is stronger, due to a higher p~- p, interaction. This overlap of the p-orbitals is lost during the reaction stage, where a pyramidal shaped transition state is found. Since the stabilisation effect of the overlap is stronger for BF3, this molecule is more reluctant to react compared to BCI 3. BX 3 notations will be used in what follows to describe the reaction mechanisms. The specific halogen forms will be used where appropriate. In the past, several
studies 1'2'3'4'5'8'9'10'11'12'13'14'15'16'17'18'19'20 w e r e
devoted to the reaction
of BX3 with silica powders, pressed silica discs and porous glasses by means of physical and chemical methods. A fast reaction of the BX3-molecules with the oxygen atoms of surface silanols, surface siloxane groups and hydration water takes place, giving rise to chemisorbed surface species. Morrow and McFarlan 2~ followed the reaction of self supported silica discs (evacuated at 353 K) with a threefold excess of BCI 3 at room temperature using fast scanning FTIR spectroscopy. They reported that the modification reaction was already completed after 30 seconds, since they observed no further changes in the infrared spectra for longer reaction times. Hair and Hertl 4
301 also stated that reaction with BC13 is very rapid at all temperatures studied. Reactions went to completion after 2 - 10 minutes respectively for 133 and 13 Pa of BC13. All surface hydroxyls were modified. After B F 3 modification times as small as 10 seconds, Morrow and Devi ~4 reported the formation of significant B-O and B-F IRvibration bands from chemisorbed B F 3 in the spectra. One can state that reaction of silica with boronhalides is very rapid due to the reactivity of the compounds, which makes it difficult to study the course of the reaction. interacts mainly with the attainable surface hydroxyl groups. The chemisorbed species exist in two forms, according to the reactions (A) and (B).
BX 3
=- S i O H
+ B X 3 --,
--- S i O B X 2 + H X
(A)
2 --SiOH + BX3 --, ( m S i O ) 2 B X + 2 HX
(B)
Both monodentate (reaction (A)) and bidentate (reaction (B)) species are formed. Reactions (A) and (B) are not the only reactions yielding this surface species, as will be evidenced further in the text (reactions (C), (D) and (G)). The formation of tridentate surface species is sterically not possible. 21 The occurrence of the two reactions is based on different observations. Especially infrared spectroscopy has been used to study the modification reactions with borontrihalides. Much of the published infrared w o r k 1'2'4'8'11'21'22'23 has been concerned with the spectral changes in the OH stretching region (3800 - 3200 cml). Some authors ~'2~
focused their attention
on the spectral regions of the adsorbed species. Figure 10.1 shows the infrared spectra of Kieselgel 60 pretreated at 473 K before (a) and after (b) reaction with excess BC13 at 293 K. Spectrum (c) is the difference spectrum of (b) and (a). The disappearance of the bands at 3747 cm -1 and 3550 cm ~ clearly demonstrates that both free and bridged hydroxyl groups have reacted. While all the free hydroxyl groups have disappeared from the surface, still a residual band is seen in the region of the bridged surface hydroxyls. Besides reacting with the hydroxylic surface groups, BX3-molecules are known to react with siloxane groups. The reaction of B X 3 with siloxane groups was first witnessed by Morrow and Devi in 1971.14 Treating totally dehydroxylated (1523 K) samples with B F 3 they found IR-bands, characteristic for the monodentate surface groups. Furthermore they reported the formation of new silica bands at 888 and 908 cm ~ due
302
t~msity(a.u.)
4000
38'00
36'00 3i00 Wavenumber (can")
32'00
3000
Figure 10.1 FTIR-PA spectrum of the hydroxyl stretching bands of silica gel, (a) pretreated at 473 K, (b) reacted with BCl3 at 293 K. Spectrum (c) is the difference spectrum of (a) and (b) .
to the formation of 'reactive (strained) siloxane groups'. 25'26'27 Titrating the totally dehydroxylated surface with small doses of BF 3 led to an increasing reduction of the 888 and 908 cm ~ bands, indicative for the reaction with the surface siloxanes. For silica surfaces carrying also free silanol groups the intensity of the free hydroxyl band did not change. Only if larger quantities of BF3 were added the free hydroxyl band did disappear, showing the higher reactivity of the siloxanes towards BF 3 compared to the residual hydroxyl groups. This is true for strongly dehydroxylated silicas, evacuated at temperatures > 973 K, ~4while for hydroxylated surfaces reaction occurs predominantly with the silanol groups. The same results were found for BC13 .14'27 Figure 10.2 presents the IR-spectrum of Kieselgel 60 (pretreated at 973 K), treated with hexamethyldisilazane (HMDS) before and after B C I 3 treatment at 293 K. HMDS removes all hydroxyl groups, creating a hydrophobic silica surface (cfr. chapter 4). After reaction with B C I 3 at room temperature and degassing at 373 K to remove physisorbed species, a B-O vibration band is formed, while the bands of the methyl groups at 2900 cm ~ remained the same in intensity. This indicates that chemical bonds are formed with the surface by reaction with the siloxane surface groups. No bands were observed that could indicate any hydrolysis of the B C I 3. Chloride analysis of the HMDS-surface after BCI 3 modification led to a value of 0.05 mmol/g of
303
siloxane sites that reacted, assuming that three chloride groups are found on the surface when one siloxane group reacts (reaction (C)). This value has to be treated with care, however, since the HMDS treated surface is chemically different from the surface of pure silica. Furthermore the trimethylsilyl-groups on the HMDS surface are bulky groups, possibly hindering the BC13 molecules to react with all available siloxanes. - S i - O - S i ~-
+
BX 3
--~
-
Si-OBX2 + X-Si-
(C)
The reaction path under mild conditions is shown in reaction (C). At higher reaction temperatures of 670 - 720 K, the silicon-oxygen framework of silica is attacked by the strong Lewis acids BF3, BCI3, or A1CI3, accompanied with the elimination of SiF 4 or SIC14. These reaction products do not react with the silica structure, being too weak Lewis acids. 13
Intensity(a.u.)
a
4000
35'00
3000 2500 Wavenumber (era t )
20()0
15100
Figure 10.2 (a) FTIR-PA spectrum of silica gel, pretreated at 973 K, modified with HMDS, (a) after reaction with excess BCL3 at 293 K.
It is interesting to note however that reaction occurs with siloxane groups at room temperature for silica samples pretreated at high temperatures. If the so formed monodentate (see reaction (C)) groups are close enough to a residual SiOH group, reaction may occur with the formation of bidentate groups on the surface.
This
304 reaction was pointed out by Morrow and Devi ~4and possibly explains, together with the bifunctional reaction with geminal hydroxyls (see chapter 9), the occurrence of bidentate species at high evacuation temperatures. Since the C1/B ratio is 3 for a reacted siloxane group, the reaction with siloxanes can also account for the high CI/B ratio's ( > 2) found for the high pretreatment regions. 4
2.2. Influencingfactors 2.2.1 The effect of the pretreatment temperature Peglar et al. 2 stated that BC13 reacts completely with the free and bridged surface hydroxyls of self supported discs. They assigned the residual band at 3650 cm 1 to intraglobular hydroxyls, since the band could be reduced in intensity after heating and rehydrating the pure silica samples. Rhee and Basila 16 reported that a BF amodification of silica, pretreated at 773 K in vacuo, removes all hydroxyl groups. A more detailed study was made by Tyler et al. s They first exchanged the surface hydroxyls for deuteroxyls treating the silica discs with D20, followed by a reaction with BC13. D20 treatment exchanges all surface hydroxyls, giving rise to new IR bands at 2755 cm ~ and 2620 cm ~ assigned to the free and bridged deuteroxyls respectively. All deuteroxyls are removed from a silica, pretreated at 973 K and consequently reacted with BC13 at room temperature. Silicas pretreated at 298 K show a residual OD-band after BC13 reaction. In the latter case, all free deuteroxyls react, while some hydrogen bonded groups remain. This study proves that there are some surface hydroxyls available for interaction with D20, although they are unavailable for interaction with a larger molecule such as BC13. The authors stated, based on IR band integration of the OH/OD-regions: 'D20 can underestimate by as much as 100% the total concentration of bulk hydroxyls that are unavailable to absorbing molecules larger than D20, even those that are still relatively small in absolute terms, such as BCI 3 which is about 0.5 - 0.6 nm in diameter. Morrow and McFarlan 21 also reported the complete disappearance of the free hydroxyls and a residual band at 3660 cm ~ after modification of aerosil (pretreated at 423 K) with excess BC13 at 293 K. If a difference in reactivity exists between free and bridged hydroxyls, this might have a chemical origin or might arise from steric
305 factors either related to the proximity of the silanols or to the size of the reactant itself. After examining the reaction with several hydrogen sequesting agents Morrow and McFarlan concluded that three factors play a role in determining the number of nonisolated hydroxyls which react with a given product: (1)
The ability of the reactant to penetrate into regions of interparticle contact, that is, to reach the inaccessible silanols. The smaller the reactant, the more groups are modified.
(2)
The ability to react bifunctionaly, i.e. the ability of a reactant to react with two surface hydroxyls. This causes a higher degree of modification.
(3)
The capability of a chemisorbed species to prevent a neighbouring silanol from reacting for steric reasons. The bigger the chemisorbed group the less silanols can react.
The residual band after BCl3-modification of D-exchanged silica is the result of the different dimensions of BC13 and D20. D20 , being a smaller molecule, can penetrate better into the interparticle regions than BC13 and reacts with more surface hydroxyls. The disappearance of the hydroxyl bands in the IR-spectra shows that BCI 3 interacts with the surface hydroxyls, but the residual OD-band indicates that BCI 3 does not react with all surface hydroxyls at room temperature. All free hydroxyls react, while some hydrogen bonded groups remain on the surface. Together with the disappearance of the OH bands in the infrared spectra, the formation of the mono- and bidentate groups, following reactions (A) and (B), was shown through the formation of different BO and BX bands. After the reaction of BF 3 with cabosil, Morrow and Devi 14'17 noticed some remarkable changes in the IRspectrum. Apart from the changes in the OH-stretch region, several new bands were found, especially in the 1400- 1500 cm -~ region. Table 10.1 lists the wavenumbers of the different bands after modification.
306 Table 10.1 IR band assignment of BF3 treated cabosil according to Morrow and Devi 14'17
Pretreatment temperature
11BF3
I~
T_>973 K
1452 1393 685
1500 1448 710
BO stretch monodentate BF asym. stretch monodentate OBF2 bending monodentate
T < 973 K
1452 1409 1393 1341 685
1500 1485 1448 1387 710
BO stretch monodentate OBO stretch bidentate BF asym. stretch monodentate BF stretch bidentate OBF2 bending monodentate
Modifications were performed with BF 3 containing 11BF3 and I~
in a ratio of 4:1.
Exact band assignment was made with the use of isotopically pure BF 3 and performing reactions on 180 exchanged silica. A splitting of the free OH-band due to the Si16OH (3749 cm -1) and SilgOH (3738 cm -1) surface silanols was found after this 180 exchange. 17 Modification of this surface with 11BF3 (1~
split the band at 1452 cm -~
(1500 cm -1) into a doublet with a new band at 1434 cm 1 (1485 cm 1) (see figure 10.3). The bands at 1393 and 1448 cm -1 did not show any splitting. Furthermore the ratio of the intensity of the 1434/1452 cm -1 (1485/1500 cm -1) bands after modification was the same as that of the 3738/3749 cm ~ bands before reaction. And this for different degrees of 180 exchange. The splitting after 180 exchange into a low wavenumbe