Chemical Physics of Nanostructured Semiconductors
Editors: Alexander I. Kokorin and Detlef W. Bahnemann
/// vsP/// Utrecht
Boston, 2003
VSP BV P.O. Box 346 3700 AH Zeist The Netherlands
Tel: +31 30 692 5790 Fax: +3 1 30 693 208 1
[email protected] www.vsppub.com
0VSP BV 2003 First published in 2003 ISBN 90-6764-382-3
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.
Printed in The Netherlands by Ridderprint bv, Ridderkerk.
Chemical Physics ofNanosfructured Semiconductors, pp. xi-xv A.1. Kokorin and D.W. Bahnemann (Eds.) 0 VSP 2003.
About the Authors Alonso-Vante, Nicolils: was born in Oaxaca, Mexico and educated in Mexico-city. He received his Dr. Xs Sc. (1984) from the Louis Pasteur University of Strasbourg, France. He then joined the research group of Prof. H. Tributsch at the Hahn-Meitner-Institut in Berlin, Germany, as an Alexander von Humboldt fellow. Thereafter, he continued as a senior scientist. He is presently Professor of Chemistry at the Chemistry faculty of the University of Poitiers, France. His research interest has concentrated, these late years, on material science research for (photo)electrocata-lysis, and the in situ investigation of interfacial processes combining spectroscopy with electrochemical techniques. E-mail:
Bahnemann, Detlef W.: studied chemistry at the TU Berlin, Germany, where he received his Ph.D. in 1981. From 1981 to 1988 he worked as a Senior Scientist at the Hahn-Meitner-Institute (HMI) Berlin with Prof. Arnim Henglein. He joined the group of Prof. M. R. Hoffmann at the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena, USA as a Visiting Associate (1985-1987). In 1988-2002 he was a Department Head at the Institute for Solar Energy Research (ISFH) in Hannover, FRG. Since June 2002 he became an Academic Director at the Institute for Technical Chemistry of the Hannover University where he is responsible for the research field of Photochemistry and Nanotechnology. Prof. Dr. Bahnemann is Honorary Visiting Prof. at the Robert-Gordon Univ. in Aberdeen (UK), Lecturer for Physical Chemistry at the Carl-vonOssietzky University in Oldenburg, FRG. His research interests include Free Radical Chemistry, Fast Reaction Kinetics, Photocatalysis and Inorganic Nanomaterials. E-mail: Bavykin, Dmitry V.: is a Ph.D. researcher in the Laboratory of photocatalysis on semiconductors at the Boreskov Institute of Catalysis, Novosibirsk, Russia. The title of his PhD thesis (1998): “Luminescent and photocatalytic properties of CdS nanocolloids”. Area of his interests is the photophysical-photochemical properties of nanosized sulfide semiconductors, including synthesis of particles with definite size and surface properties, their characterisation; the study of the photoexcited states dynamics, relaxation in quantum dots by the luminescence and flash photolysis measurements; studies of the interfacial charge transfer from colloidal semiconductor particles by the steady state photolysis, luminescence quenching method. E-mail: Dillert, Ralf: studied chemistry at the Technical University Braunschweig and received his Dr. rer. nat. in 1988. He worked as a scientist at the Gesellschaft fur Biotechnologische Forschung mbH (GBF) at the Institute of Physical Chemistry of the TU Braunschweig, and at the Institut fur Solarenergieforschung GmbH (ISFH) Hannover, FRG. He was a lecturer for wastewater treatment at the University of Applied Science in Flensburg. In 1986 he founded EcoTRANSfair Gesellschaft fur Umwelt und Gesundheit mbH, an environmental service
xii
About the authors
company, and is actually its managing director. His research interests are chemical technologies in water and wastewater treatment and especially photocatalysis. E-mail: Kokorin, Alexander I.: was born in 1947. Was graduated as a biophysicist in 1970; Ph.D. (Candidate of Sciences) in 1974; D.Sc. degree (Doctor of Sciences) in physical chemistry - in 1992. At present: Principal Researcher and Deputy Head of the Division of Kinetics and Catalysis, N. Semenov Institute of Chemical Physics of Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia. Area of research interests: chemical methods of solar energy conversion; chemical physics of organized molecular systems, including nanosized oxide semiconductors doped with transition metal ions, and polymer-metal complexes; the study of their structure, absorptive, catalytic, photocatalytic and photoelectrochemical properties. EPR spectroscopy and spin-spin interaction between paramagnetics. He is the author and co-author of more than 170 publications, including two books and several reviews and book chapters. E-mail: Lindgren, Torbjorn: was born in 1972, received a M.Sc. (chemical engineering) in 1999 at Chalmers University of Technology, Gtiteborg, Sweden. He continued education in Uppsala University, Sweden as a Ph.D. student with Sten-Eric Lindquist and Anders Hagfeldt as supervisors. His Ph.D. project is concerned with direct solar induced water splitting on semiconductors. E-mail: Lindquist, Sten-Eric: Professor of the Department of Physical Chemistry, Uppsala University (UU), Sweden. In 2001 was retired. As professor emeritus he is currently active doing research in the fields of electrochemistry and photoelelctrochemistry in UU. His main research field is solar energy, in particular - photoelectrochemical (PEC) cells for electrical power or hydrogen generation, and also in the field of redoxpolymer wired enzyme based amperometric biosensors. He has been the leader of a number of national research programs and the Swedish coordinator for several European JOULE programs including a research program on dye-sensitized solar
About the authors
...
Xlll
cells within Angstrom Solar Center in Uppsala. He is at present working within the framework of the Swedish research program “Sustainable Energy Conversion with Hydrogen as a Storage Agent”, studying PEC systems with the aim of producing H2 from water with solar light. He is also engage in studies of photocatalysis at gas/semiconductor interfaces at nanostructured thin films. E-mail: <sten-eric .Lindquist @ fki.uu.se>
Martyanov, Igor N.: is a Ph.D. researcher and recently worked in the laboratory of photocatalysis on semiconductors at the Boreskov Institute of Catalysis, SB U S , Novosibirsk, Russia. The title of his PhD Thesis (1998) was: “Kinetics of photocatalytic redox reactions of organic molecules in semiconductor suspensions (CdS and TiO2)”. Areas of his interests: kinetics of photocatalytic reactions in liquid phase at deep conversion; the influence of the surfactants. Parmon, Valentin N.: Professor, the Academician of U S (from 1997), Director of the Boreskov Institute of Catalysis (BIC), Siberian Branch of Russian Academy of Sciences, Novosibirsk, Russia. He was born in 1948 and graduated from the Moscow Physical-Technical Institute in 1972 as a chemical physicist. He received Ph.D. in 1975 at NSemenov Institute of Chemical Physics (Moscow). In 1977 he organized the Laboratory of Catalytic Methods of Solar Energy Conversion in BIC. He is the author or co-author of more than 500 publications, including 5 monographs in chemical kinetics and catalysis, photochemistry and radiation chemistry, chemical radiospectroscopy and physical chemistry of energy production, as well as renewable energetics and transfer of new technologies to industry. He is a Chairman of the Russian Scientific Council on Catalysis. E-mail: <[email protected]> Poluektov, Oleg G.: he started his research career in the NSemenov Institute of Chemical Physics RAS, Moscow, in 1983, after receiving a Ph.D. in physics from the Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology. In 1991-1996 he was a visiting scientist in the Physical Department of the University of Leiden, The Netherlands, and in 1997-1998 a visiting scientist in the Chemistry Division at Argonne National Laboratory (CD ANL),USA. In 2000 he joined the CD ANL as a research scientist. His specialization is magnetic resonance and especially very high frequency EPR spectroscopy, where he contributed significantly in the development and application of new technique. His research interests have covered a broad range of physics and chemistry: the molecular dynamics and structure of glass, crystal, liquid crystal, polymer and biopolymer systems; the mechanisms and kinetics of chemical reactions in liquid phase. His current research is focused on the relation of function, structure, and dynamics in photosynthetic reaction center proteins. He is the author of more than 70 scientific articles and book chapters. E-mail: <[email protected]>
xiv
About the authors
Rajh, Tijana: is a physical chemist in the Chemistry Division of Argonne National Laboratory, USA. She received her Ph.D. from Belgrade University while working at the Vinca Research Institute in Belgrade on the synthesis and characterization of 11-VI semiconductor quantum dots. In 1984-85, Dr. Rajh was a visiting scientist at the Solar Energy Research Institute (now known as NREL), Golden, Colorado, USA. In 1987 she worked at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem as a visiting scientist on the investigation of quantization effects in the initial stages of semiconductor particle growth. Currently, she studies the encapsulation of metal oxide semiconductor nanoparticles with organic ligands which result in strong electronic coupling, and allowing the electronic linking of the nanoparticle into molecular circuits. These systems can be applied for remediation of various organic and inorganic pollutants. She is the author of more than 45 scientific articles and book chapters. E-mail: Robertson, Peter K. J.: B.Sc., D.Phil., Eng. On completing his D.Phi1. in Chemistry at the University of Ulster (1989) he joined the Faraday Centre in Carlow, Ireland, where he was involved in electrochemical research on bulk electrolysis processes and environmental treatment systems. In 1991, he moved to the Industrial Research and Technology Unit in Northern Ireland as a Higher Scientific Officer in the Material ScienceDnorganic Chemistry Section, where he managed a range of research projects on photocatalytic and electrochemical waste treatment for industry; he was involved in environmental assessments of contaminated land sites. He joined the School of Applied Sciences at R. Gordon University in 1995 where he was involved in research in environmental science and technology and photocatalysis. From 2000, he is a Professor at the Chair of Energy and Environmental Engineering in the School of Engnieering at RGU. His research interests focus on advanced oxidation technologies for water treatment, specifically by-products generated by the offshore oil and gas industry and toxic compounds in drinking water, and also in the development of sensor technologies for marine and fresh water environments. E-mail:
About the authors
xv
Thurnauer, Marion C.: is a Senior Scientist and Division Director of the Chemistry Division of Argonne National Laboratory, USA. She received her B.A., M.S., and Ph.D. (1974) degrees from the University of Chicago. She has authored over 100 publications including journal articles and book chapters, primarily on the subject of solar energy conversion in natural and artificial photosynthesis. Her research interests include the photochemical energy conversion and photocatalysis in natural and artificial photosynthetic systems; the development and application of time resolved magnetic resonance techniques to study photochemical charge separation; and electron spin polarization as observed in photosynthetic and model systems. Dr. Thurnauer was honored with many American and International Awards. Her recent honor was receiving the 2002 F. P. Garvan - J. M. Olin Medal Award from the National American Chemical Society. E-mail: <[email protected]> Vayssieres, Lionel: born in 1968, received a B.Sc. in physical chemistry in 1989 and a Ph.D. in chemistry in 1995 on the thermodynamic control of metal oxide nanoparticles at the University Pierre et Marie Curie in Paris, France with Jacques Livage. He joined Uppsala University, Sweden as a researcher for 5 years at the department of Physical-Chemistry with Sten-Eric Lindquist and, with Hans Siegbahn and Joseph Nordgren at the Physics department, developing novel metal oxide nanomaterials for photovoltaic devices and characterizing their electronic structure by x-ray spectroscopies. He worked as a visiting researcher with Adam Heller at the chemical engineering department of the University of Texas at Austin, USA and at the department of Biochemistry at Stellenbosch University, South Africa with Pieter Swart on bionanocomposite materials. Recently he joined the Texas Materials Institute at the University of Texas at Austin as a visiting scientist. He is the author of 20 scientific articles, and performed many invited lectures and seminars. Wang, Heli: he has worked at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) in the United States. He received a Ph.D. in corrosion science and materials chemistry from the Helsinki University of Technology in Finland. From 1998, he had worked with nanostructured semiconductors of metal oxides at the Department of Physical Chemistry, Uppsala University, Sweden. His research work has been in materials, electrochemistry, photoelectrochemistry, as well as fuel cell components. E-mail:
Chemical Physics of Nanostructured Semiconductors, pp. ix-x A.I. Kokorin and D.W. Bahnemann (Eds.) 0 VSP 2003.
Preface The idea to write this book arose during the participation in several Workshops on Quantum Solar Energy Conversion, organized in the Alps by the European Society for Quantum Solar Energy Conversion (ESQSEC). Deep and detailed discussions on chemistry, chemical physics, photoelectrochemistry, photophysics, photocatalysis and possible applications of nanostructured semiconductor materials have shown the increasing interest in the matter by scientists representing various research areas as well as industrial enterprises. Indeed, solar energy conversion and chemical methods for its realization became very popular again after the “great jump” of renewable energy sources between the middle of the 1970s and the beginning of the 1980s. Several excellent books have been published since these years; for example, Energy Resources through Photochemistry and Catalysis, by M. Gratzel (1983), Photocatalysis: Fundamentals and Applications, by N. Serpone and E. Pelizzetti (1989), Photoelectrochemical Conversion of Solar Energy, by Yu. V. Pleskov (1990), Photochemical Conversion and Storage of Solar Energy, by E. Pelizzetti and M. Schiavello (199 1) and Photocatalytic Purification and Treatment of Water and Air, by D. F. Ollis and H. Al-Ekabi (1993). Nevertheless, in these books no attempt was made to approach this research area from the point of view of classical chemical physics. When we decided to edit this book we aimed for three main goals: a) to generate an adequate scope of the modem trends and data obtained during the last years in the area of chemical physics of nanostructured materials, in particular, nanocrystalline semiconductors; b) to select an equal mix of scientists from Western and Eastern countries, all of them experts in their respective research areas, and c) to present to the international scientific community many interesting and important results which have been obtained by former Soviet Union researchers, but are not well known because they had originally been published in Russian books and journals. Many different experimental methodologies, each with special utility, are currently being used for the determination of structure, of physicochemical properties and of functionality in the area of solar energy conversion. The editors invited the authors to contribute reviews from the field of their own expertise, including specific and typical examples from their own experimental data (mainly). It will be left to the readers to decide whether or not our attempt has been successful.
X
Preface
Acknowledgements for the financial support are given at the end of each chapter. We are also thankful to Prof. Dr. Tjeerd Schaafsma (President of the ESQSEC) and Prof. Dr. Helmut Tributsch, who continuously supported our idea to write this book, and to Mr. Ilja A. Kokorin for technical assistance in the preparation of the book. We hope this book will be interesting and useful for scientists working in the area of semiconductor nanotechnology, photoelectrochemistry, photocatalysis, photochemistry of water and air purification, as well as for graduate and post-graduate students who are planning to join these research areas.
Alexander I. Kokorin Moscow, Russia
Detlef W. Bahnemann Hannover, Germany
Contents Preface
ix
About the authors
xi
Chapter 1. Charge Separation in Titanium Oxide Nanocrystalline Semiconductors Revialed by Magnetic Resonance (T. Rajh, 0. G. Poluektov and M. C. Thurnauer) 1.1. Introduction 1.2. Basic Mechanisms of Semiconductor-AssistedPhotocatalysis 1.2.1. Energy Band Structure of Ti02 Nanoparticles 1.2.2.Photogeneration of Charge Pairs and Intrinsic Properties of Semiconductors 1.2.3. Space Charge Layer and Band Banding 1.3. Charge Separation and Carrier Trapping in Ti02 Nanoparticles 1.3.1. Nature of Trapping Sites 1.3.2. Hole Trapping Sites 1.3.3. Hole Trapping Sites 1.3.4. Charge Separation in the Surface-ModifiedTi02 Colloids 1.4. Kinetic and Mechanism of the Charge Separation in Ti02 Colloid Nanoparticles as Studied by Time-Resolved EPR Technique 1.5. Summary References
23 30 31
Chapter 2. Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions on CdS Nanocolloids (D. V. Bavykin, E. N. Savinov, I. N. Martyanov and V. N. Parmon)
35
2.1. Introduction 2.2. Synthesis of CdS Colloids 2.2.1. Thermodynamic Calculation of Equilibrium Size of CdS Colloidal Particles in the Presence of Cadmium Components 2.2.2. Method of CdS Preparation 2.3. Reaction of Interfacial Electron Transfer as the First Stage of Redox Photocatalytic Processes 2.3.1. Photobleaching Relaxation of Colloids 2.3.2. Physical Causes Resulting in the Observable Kinetic Peculiarities of Photobleaching Relaxation 2.3.3. Effect of CdS Adsorption Properties on the Kinetics of Its Photobleaching Relaxation in the Presence of Various Electron Acceptors 2.4. Luminescence Quenching of CdS Colloids 2.4.1. Regularities of Luminescence Quenching of Colloidal CdS Particles 2.4.2. Effect of Surface Properties of Ultradispersed CdS on Regularities of Luminescence Quenching 2.4.2.a. Luminescence Quenching of Colloidal CdS by Quenchers of Various Nature
4 5 6 6 7 12 14
35 35 36 39 40 40 45 48 51 52
59 59
vi
Contents
2.4.2.b. Effect of the Surface Charge of Colloidal CdS on the Efficiency of its Luminescence Quenching by Various Quenchers 2.4.3. Effect of Excitation Wavelength on the Luminescence Spectrum of CdS/Cu,S 2.4.4. Conclusion 2.5. Kinetics of Photocatalytic Reactions at Stationary Illumination 2.5.1. Photoreduction of Methyl Orange on CdS Colloids in Deep Conversion 2.5.1.a. Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Processes on Ultradispersed CdS Colloids at Stationary Illumination 2.5.1.b. Semiquantitative Description of the Kinetics of Photocatalytic Processes on CdS Colloids in Terms of Adsorption-Desorption Processes in the System 2.5.l.c. Analysis of Kinetic Regularities of the System under Study 2.5.2. Photoreduction of Methylviologen and Phosphotungstic Acid on CdS Colloids; Effect of Surface Charge 2.5 -3.Effect of Excitation Light Wavelength on the Rate of Photocatalytic Reaction 2.6. Conclusion References
Chapter 3. Photooxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes (T. Lindgren, L. Vayssieres, H. Wang and S.-E. Lindquist) 3.1. Introduction 3.2. General Background of Photooxidation of Water 3.3. Structural and Physical Properties of Hematite 3.3.1. Crystal Structure 3.3.2. Electronic Structure 3.3.3. Electrical Properties 3.3.4. Flat-band Potential 3.4. Photoresponse of Hematite Materials 3.4.1. Colloidal Solutions of Hematite 3.4.2. Hematite Single Crystal Materials 3.4.2.a. Hematite Single Crystal 3.4.2.b. Doped Hematite Single Crystal 3.4.2.c. Mixed Hematite Single Crystal 3.4.3. Polycrystalline Hematite Materials 3.4.3.a. Polycrystalline Hematite 3.4.3.b. Polycrystalline Hematite Thin Film 3.4.3.c. Polycrystalline Doped Hematite 3.4.3.d. Mixed Polycrystalline Oxides of Hematite 3.4.4. Nanostructured Thin Films of Hematite 3.4.4.a. Nanostructured Films of Spherical Particles of Hematite 3.4.4.b. Hematite Nanorods 3.5. Conclusion and Future Scopes References
61 62 64 65 65 66 69 72 77 80 80 80 83 84 85 89 89 90 92 92 95 96 97 97 97 98 98 98 98 100 102 102 102 104 106 107
Contents
Chapter 4. Photoelectrochemistryof Nanocrystalline Aggregates of Cyanine Dyes on the Semiconductor Electrodes (D. V. Sviridov) 4.1. Introduction 4.2. Spectroscopic Properties of Aggregated Cyanine dyes 4.3. Effect of Aggregate Formation upon Electronic Energy Levels of Cyanine Dyes (CDs) 4.4. Aggregates of Cyanine Dyes as the Sensitizing Agents in the Photoelectrochemical Systems 4.5. PhotoelectrochemicalSpectral Sensitization by Partially Aggregated CDs 4.6. Spectral Sensitization of Semiconductor by Mixture of J-aggregated CDs 4.7. PhotoelectrochemicalBehaviour of Thin Films of Aggregated CDs 4.8. Conclusions References
Chapter 5. Physico-Chemical Properties of Novel Nanocrystalline Ruthenium Based Chalcogenide Materials (N. Alonso-Vunte) 5.1. Introduction 5.2. Clusters or Particles 5.2.1 Size Comparison 5.2.2. Metal and Semiconductor Nanoparticles 5.3. A Non-aqueous Chemical Route of Synthesis 5.3.1. Synthesis Ideals 5.3.2. The Chemical Route 5.3.3. Morphology and Stoichiometry 5.4. Electrocatalysis and Photoelectrocatalysis 5.4.1. Thin to Ultra Thin Layers of Chalcogenide Materials 5.4.2. Electrocatalysis via Thin and Ultra Thin Layers of Chalcogenide Materials 5.4.3. (Photo)Electrocatalysison Nanostructured Ti02 Surface Modified via Chalcogenide Materials 5.4.4. Implications of Molecular Oxygen for Photooxidation Process 5.5. Summary References
Chapter 6. Metal Nanoparticles on Semiconductor Surfaces: Electrochemistry and Photocatalysis (A. 1. Kulak) 6.1. Introduction 6.2. Dependence of Nanoparticles Morphology and Behavior in Electron Transfer Processes on the Mean of Metal Nanophase Deposition onto Semiconductor Surface (ScS) 6.2.1. Contact Deposition of Metal Nanoparticles onto ScS 6.2.2. Galvanic Deposition of Metal Nanoparticles onto ScS 6.2.3. Photocatalytic Formation of Metal Nanophase on Semiconductor Surfaces
vii
111 111 111 114 116 120 125 127 132 132
135 135 136 136 138 139 139 140 140 142 142 144 145 147 150 150
153 153 155 155 158 161
viii
Contents
6.3. Formation of Electronic Surface States in Semiconductor Band Gap as a Result of Deposition of Metal Particles on Semiconductor Surface 6.4. Electrocatalytic Activity of Semiconductor Electrodes Modified by Surface-Deposited Metal Nanophase 6.5. Impedometric Investigation of Titania Electrodes Surface-Modified with Metal Particles 6.6. Interaction of Metal Nanoparticles with the Associates of Donor Defects in Wide-Band-Gap n-type Semiconductors 6.7. Conclusion References
Chapter 7. Photocatalysis: Electron Transfer Serving the Environment ( D . W. Bahnemann, R. Dillert and P. K. J. Robertson) 7.1. Introduction 7.2. Primary Processes upon Band Gap Irradiation of Semiconductor Particles 7.3. Chemical Nature of Trapped Charge Carriers 7.4. Fate of Trapped Charge Carriers 7.4.1. Recombination Kinetics 7.4.2. Charge Transfer Kinetics 7.4.2.a. Interfacial Electron Transfer 7.4.2.b. Direct Interfacial Hole Transfer 7.4.2.c. Hole Transfer through the Intermediate Formation of Hydroxyl Radicals 7.5. Conclusions References
Chapter 8. Electron Spin Resonance of Nanostructured Oxide Semiconductors (A. I. Kokorin) List of General Symbols 8.1. Introduction 8.2. EPR Signals of Oxide Semiconductors 8.3. EPR of Small Molecules Adsorbed on the Semiconductor Surface 8.3.1. Oxygen Radicals 8.3.2. N,O, Radicals 8.4. Structural Aspects in the Study of Nanocrystalline Materials 8.4.1, The Measurement of Local Concentration of Paramagnetic Centers 8.4.2. Regularities and Peculiarities of Spatial Distribution of PCs 8.5. Vanadium Ions “Behaviour” i d o n Oxide Semiconductors 8.5.1. Titanium Dioxide 8.5.1.a. Substitutional and Interstitial Centers 8.5.1.b. Surface Doping 8.5.2. Other Oxides 8.6. Other Paramagnetic Dopants 8.7. Identification of Adsorbed Gun+ Ions at the Ti02 Surface and ElectroChemical Behaviour of Copper-Modified Electrodes 8.8. General Conclusions References
166 17 1 174 177 179 180 183 183 184 187 189 189 191 191 192 195 199 200 203 203 204 205 209 209 21 1 215 219 22 1 224 225 227 230 236 23 8 242 252 253
Chemical Physics of Nanostructured Semiconductors, pp, 1-34 A.I. Kokorin and D.W. Bahnemann (Eds.) 0 VSP 2003.
CHAPTER 1
Charge Separation in Titanium Oxide Nanocrystalline Semiconductors Revealed by Magnetic Resonance Tijana Rajh, Oleg G. Poluektov and Marion C. Thurnauer Chemistry Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne IL 60439, USA Keywords: Kinetics, mechanism, charge separation, Titanium dioxide, nanocrystals, photocatalysis, semiconductors, Magnetic resonance
1.1. Introduction Semiconductor photocatalysis using nanoparticlate Ti02 has proven to be a promising technology for use in photocatalytic reactions, in the cleanup of water contaminated with hazardous industrial by-products [ 1-61, or as a photoactive material in nanocrystalline solar cells [7-141. Titanium dioxide, in particular, could be the catalyst of choice for a large variety of applications because it is cheap, non-toxic, and has redox properties which are favorable both for oxidation of many organic pollutants and for reduction of a number of metal ions or organics in aqueous solution. Due to the large oxidation potential of photogenerated holes, oxidative degradation of the most resistant pollutants by photocatalysis can be achieved. To date, the primary focus of Ti02-assisted photocatalysis studies has been on the destruction of organic pollutants in solutions using photocatalytic oxidation. Numerous reports of organic pollutant degradation with mineralization to organic products in several cases have been published [ 15-19]. The common feature of the photocatalytic process always involves reactions via surface trapped photogenerated holes. To maintain neutrality, both photogenerated electrons as well as positive holes have to be consumed efficiently in redox processes on the semiconductor surface. Usually photogenerated electrons were consumed in the reaction with dissolved oxygen in order to achieve fast oxidation of organic compounds. However, organic pollutants are often accompanied by heavy metal ion contaminants that can be reduced by photogenerated electrons into their less toxic, nonsoluble metallic form. TiOz-assisted photoreductive catalysis was found to be useful in the removal of certain heavy metals including mercury, silver, platinum, palladium, rhodium, and gold via their reduction followed by deposition at the catalyst surface [20-221 or photoreduction of nitroaromatic compounds [23-261. The use of photogenerated electrons for deposition of metal layers on
2
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
TiOz nanocrystalline substrate have new potential applications such as photolithography (nanowriting) - formation of conducting patterns in chips or integrated circuits. In these systems a photochemical reaction is limited to the size of the semiconductor particle. Thus, the metallic conductor size can be obtained in the nanometer size regime [27]. Although TiOz is very effective from an energetic point of view, it is relatively inefficient. The main energy loss in all investigated particulate systems is due to the recombination of charges generated in the illumination of semiconductor particles which is manifest as relatively low efficiency of pollutant decomposition. Therefore, the main focus of future research for the application of semiconductor assisted photocatalysis is to improve separation of charges and at the same time preserve or improve their redox properties. Understanding the events that take place in the early stages of photocatalytic reactions is necessary step for the design and optimization of an efficient artificial photocatalytic system. These primary events involve electron transfer reactions with the creation of paramagnetic species. For this reason Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) is an important technique for the study of the transient species and examining mechanisms of light-induced sequential electron transfer leading to stabilized charge pair formation [27]. On one hand, EPR spectroscopy allows unique identification of the paramagnetic species involved in the charge separation. On the other hand, interconversion between species and the kinetics of the chargetransfer reaction can be recorded in the wide time range (from ns to days) by monitoring the intensity of the EPR signals, thus providing a detailed description of the charge-separation reaction.
1.2. Basic Mechanisms of Semiconductor-AssistedPhotocatalysis 1.2.1. Energy Band Structure of Ti02 Nanoparticles
Titanium dioxide exists in three crystal modifications, anatase, brookite, and rutile. In bulk crystal rutile is the most thermodynamically stable form. Very few laboratories have been able to synthesize anatase single crystals. However, in the nanocrystalline particle regime the anatase crystal structure is dominant. For this reason, the anatase structure mainly will be discussed below. Anatase crystal modification is a tetragonally distorted octahedral structure in which every titanium atom is surrounded by six oxygen atoms in an elongated octahedron geometry (DZd).Due to the resultant crystal field, the 3d levels of Ti4+that form the conduction band of TiOz are split into 3tZgand 3e, sub-levels. The unequal length of the six cationic ligand bonds to titanium produces a splitting of the tzg and eg orbitals into two subsets (Fig. 1.1). Symmetry considerations show that the p orbitals of the central Ti atom mix with d orbitals of neighboring Ti atoms and 3d-4p hybridized subbands form the conduction bands of anatase TiOz. This is exhibited in the near edge structure of X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure (XANES) spectrum of T i 0 2 [28]. The lowest band of Ti02 is formed by the bl and e subbands that have mainly x character and can overlap in p-type fashion with oxygen p i orbitals having anionic character. The result is a series of bands in reciprocal space with the maximum of the valence band and
Chapter I ; T. Rajh, et al.
Oh
D2h (rutile)
D2d (IMtasB)
3
u
55
49M1
4965
4970
4975
4980
Fig. 1.1.Energy level diagram of the LUMO of a [TiOs]*-cluster with Oh,Dzh(ruti1e) and Dzd(anatase) symmetry in conjunction with (b) experimental K-edge XANES spectra.
minimum of the conduction band in the center of the Brillouine zone (BZ). However, this direct transition F3-r1is dipole forbidden. (The HOMO is formed as a mixture of oxygen px and pr orbitals that correspond to bl in DU symmetry, and the LUMO is formed from the lowest of 3t, orbitals that correspond to bl in D2d symmetry, and therefore dipole forbidden.) The first allowed transitions are the indirect transitions from the X point at the edge of the BZ to the I? point in the center of BZ. The two lowest transitions are X1-Fl observed with light absorption with an energy of 3.026 eV and perpendicular to the crystalline c axes and X2-rl observed with light absorption with an energy of 3.06 eV and parallel to the crystalline c axes. However, the transition r3- X1 of 3.19 eV is allowed both with parallel and perpendicular light accounting for the increase of the transition probability at this energy corresponding to the band gap energy of anatase TiOz. The curvature of the bands at these extremes is very small indicating large effective masses that are determined by different authors to range from 5m, to 30m, [29, 301. The precise value of the electron effective mass in anatase remains elusive primarily because of difficulty in the preparation of anatase single crystals. Because of the large effective masses, however, the quantization effect in titania particles is negligible for particle sizes > 15 A, and therefore unimportant. The other significant feature of Ti02 particles is that the curvature of the wavefunctions on the top of the valence band is larger than the curvature of the bands in the conduction band. This is different from most semiconductors and indicates that the effective mass of the hole is smaller than the effective mass of the electrons. In the formation of the exciton pairs, a dominant process in small semiconductor particles, it will lead to the orbiting of the photogenerated holes around the heavier photogenerated electrons. This suggests that in small titania particles, photogenerated holes would more likely be trapped at the surface of the particle, while electrons would first find trapping sites in the particle interior.
4
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
1.2.2. Photogeneration of Charge Pairs and Intrinsic Properties of Semiconductors
Semiconductor particles behave as microelectrochemical cells. Absorption of light energy greater than the band gap of semiconductor materials generates conduction band electrons and valence band holes. Semiconductor particles are light harvesting units offering distinct advantages in the heterogeneous photocatalyzed process: (1) high absorption cross section of the incident photons; (2) fast carrier diffusion; and (3) suitable redox levels of the valence and conduction band edges that can yield high efficiencies in converting light energy to useful redox events. Metal oxides have band structures that are characterized by the existence of an energy gap that separates the highest occupied energy levels (valence band) from the lowest unoccupied energy levels (conduction band). For example, excitation of Ti02 with W light with energy greater than the band gap (> 3.2 eV) promotes electrons from the valence into the conduction band and generates electron-hole pairs that can be exploited in various processes at the particle interface:
where e,<are conduction band (CB) electrons and hvb+ are valence band (VB) holes. Photogenerated carriers migrate to the particle surface and participate in reduction and oxidation processes at the surface. The thermodynamic limit for the reaction that can be carried out with the photogenerated charge carriers is given by the position of the band edges (Le., flat band potential). For example, if a reduction of a particular species (A) in the adjacent solution is to occur, the conduction band of the semiconductor must be more negative than the relevant redox level, while the oxidation of a particular species @) by valence band holes requires that the valence band be more positive than the relevant redox potential (Fig. 1.2). Thus, the relative position of the band edges in a given semiconductor determines their redox functioning.
Fig. 1.2. Salient features of the electronic structures of semiconductors.
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
5
The threshold energy needed for light absorption (Le., the band-gap energy) and the relative positions of the band edges (i.e., the flat band potential) are intrinsic material properties of each semiconductor. 1.2.3. Space Charge Layer and Band Banding
When a semiconductor is brought into contact with an electrolyte a migration of charge carriers occurs until the Fermi level of the semiconductor is equilibrated with the chemical potential of the electrolyte [31]. This results in the formation of a depleted space charge layer in the surface region of a semiconductor and a Helmholtz double layer in the electrolyte adjacent to the semiconductor surface (Fig. 1.3). The depletion of the surface region creates a barrier for further transfer of electrons to the electrolyte which is manifest by band banding in the space charge layer. Photons absorbed in the depletion layer produce electron hole pairs that separate under the influence of the electric field.
Semiconductor
Bulk SC - n o electroiyte
(b)
Bulk SC - equilibrium condition m dark
Nanocrystalline SC- equilibrium in dark
Fig. 1.3. Space charge layer formation in a bulk and nanocrystalline semiconductor particle with band gap E, and flat band potential of Ufbin equilibrium with a solution redox system for which Fermi level is E+ Vbis the band banding caused by depletion of charge carriers.
The space charge region in the crystalline solid phase is fairly large, approximately lOOOA, while the Helmholtz double region together with the diffuse layer is 100 A [32]. However, when the size of a semiconductor approaches the size of the space charge layer the small particle is depleted almost completely of charge carriers and band banding is negligible. The particles are too small to develop a space charge layer and, in this case, the potential difference resulting from transfer of a charge from a semiconductor to electrolyte has to drop within the Helmholtz layer (neglecting diffuse layer contributions). As a consequence, the position of the band edges of semiconductor particles will shift with the shift of the Fermi level and will not enhance charge separation [33].
6
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
1.3. Charge Separation and Carrier Trapping in Ti02 Nanoparticles 1.3.1. Nature of Trapping Sites
When the size of the semiconductor nanoparticles is in the nanometer regime, their photoelectrochemical properties may not be the same as those of bulk material. The particle diameter can be smaller than the thickness of the space charge layer and in that case the details of charge separation may not be the same as in a compact semiconductor electrode. When the metal oxide particles are in the nanocrystalline regime, the large fraction of the atoms that constitute the nanoparticle are located at the surface with significantly altered electrochemical properties. In the colloidal solution, due to the weaker covalent bonding of surface atoms with solvent molecules compared to the bonding within the lattice, the energy levels of the surface species are found in the mid-gap region. This decreases the reducing and oxidizing abilities of the surface atoms [34]. Therefore, once the electrodhole pairs are generated in the conductiodvalence bands, in the absence of an electric field produced by band banding, the loss of excess energy through localization on the trapping sites is more favorable than their direct chemical reaction with redox couples dissolved in the adjacent solution [27]. Due to the small size of the particles, the surface trapping sites of electrons and holes are not physically separated to distances required for stabilization of charge separation. They experience a strong electrostatic attraction leading to fast recombination. Understanding the properties of the surface states is therefore especially important in the interpretation of photoelectrochemical behavior of particulate semiconductors. In order to be able to block the surface trapping sites and convert them into coupling agents for interfacial electron transfer, one must understand the nature of trapping sites at the molecular level. The primary photochemical events that occur in colloidal TiOz particles upon band gap irradiation is the production of holes and electrons with the subsequent reactions they may undergo, such as recombination, trapping, and reactions with adsorbed molecules on the surface of the particles. It was suggested that interfacial electron transfer in Ti02 colloids occurs via surface Ti atoms which are coordinated with solvent molecules [35]. Meanwhile, the hole transfer occurs via surface oxygen atoms covalently linked to surface titanium atoms [36, 371. The structure of trapped electron and hole centers has attracted much attention during the last two decades. Both trapping sites have been investigated using several spectroscopic techniques such as flash photolysis [38, 391, pulse radiolysis [40-421, and EPR techniques [36, 37, 43-46]. While pulse radiolysis and optical spectroscopy enables investigation of the kinetics of both hole trapping and reactions of trapped holes, EPR spectroscopy provides detailed information of the molecular environment and the electronic structure of paramagnetic intermediates in electron transfer reactions. Below we review the last two decades of the study of charge separation and stabilization processes in nanoparticles of TiOz under light excitation revealed by the EPR technique.
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
7
1.3.2. Electron Trapping sites
The first identification of the electron centers formed under irradiation of colloidal Ti02 was reported by R.F. Howe and M.Gratze1 [44]. Pure colloidal solutions and aqueous solutions with additions of polyvinyl alcohol, iodine anion, acetate or methanol as a hole scavenger were studied. The authors found that depending upon the system, two different types of EPR spectra can be measured. All g-values of these spectra are less than 2, which is an indication that the signal arise from the electron centers. The first signal that was observed upon low temperature UV illumination in hydrated anatase, had narrow lines, and did not depend upon pH. The g-components of an axially symmetric tensor (gll= 1.957, gi = 1.988) were similar to previously reported centers in the niobium, antimony, or tantalum doped polycrystalline anatase [43,47,48]. This signal was described as an electron center trapped by a Ti4' ion, thus forming a Ti3' electron center. The narrow linewidth (around 5 G) and insensitivity to the deuteration of the colloid surface indicates that this center occupies a single site, and is located in the interior of an anatase particle. On warming to room temperature this signal decayed either through recombination or reduction of H20 at the surface. The authors [44, 491 tentatively assigned this center to the interstitial ion Ti3+,although they acknowledged that there is not much evidence in favor of the interstitial position as compared to substitutional. The concentration of the centers formed was low and the maximum measured number of Ti3' sites is of the same order as the number of colloid particle. Thus on average there is only one interstitial Ti3' ion produced per colloid particles. This observation explains the low intensity of the EPR signal in light illuminated polycrystalline anatase powders. With a decrease in the size of the particles the concentration of the particles increases and so does the EPR signal. The second type of EPR signal is observed in the presence of scavengers and has an intense broad (linewidth of around 100 G), asymmetric line, whose g-tensor parameters depends slightly upon the solution pH and scavenger molecules. The dependence of the signal on the properties of colloidal solution suggests that this signal can be attributed to the Ti3+ion sites on the surface of the particles. The values of the g-factors for these surface Ti3' particles are significantly lower than those usually found in solid TiO2. The only exception is a signal with g = 1.92 and linewidth of 100 G found in platinized Ti02 [50], which was attributed to the Ti3' ions formed in the vicinity of the platinum clusters. A deuteration experiment did not lead to the expected decrease of the linewidth. On the basis of this experiment the unusually broad linewidth of the surface Ti3+was explained by the distribution of the surface Ti3' sites with slightly different geometries, surroundings, and g-tensor components. Based on the EPR experiment the authors [44,49] presented the following description of the electron trapping process in colloidal TiO2. Band-gap irradiation produces hole-electron pairs, most of which recombine in the absence of the hole scavengers. Upon low temperature irradiation just a few electrons are trapped in the interior of the particles, producing interstitial Ti3' ions. The concentration of these ions is equal or less than the number of particles. In the presence of a hole scavenger many more electrons are trapped on the surface Ti4+, thus producing octahedral distorted Ti3' surface sites. These surface sites are not detected in neutral and alkaline solutions. Both surface and lattice centers are stable at room temperature in the presence of hole scavengers.
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
8 Table 1.1.
g-values of the electron centers in the Ti02 nanoparticles System
gl
82
g3
Ref.
Ti3+interstitial, colloidal Ti" in Ti02 dopped with Sb
1.957
1.988
1.988
44
1.959
1.989
1.989
48
Ti3+in Ti02 dopped with Nb
1.962
1.992
1.992
47
Ti3' in hydrated anatase
1.960
1.990
1.990
49
Ti3' in heat treated Ti02
1.961
1.992
1.992
60
Ti3+in Ti02 before heat treatment Ti3+in surface-modified Ti02 Ti3+in surface-modified Ti02 Ti(H20)63+in frozen solution Ti3+on the surface in colloidal Ti02
1.957
1.990
1.990
60
1.96 1
1.988
1.988
57
1.958
1.988
1.988
57
1.892
1.892
1.988
75
1.885
1.925
1.925
44
Ti3+on the surface in colloidal Ti02
1.885
1.930
1.930
44
Ti3+on the surface in colloidal Ti02
1.880
1.945
1.945
44
Ti3+surface in cysteine-modified Ti02 Ti3+(surface) in cysteine-modified TiOz
1.958
46
1.934
46
Colloidal T i 0 2particles doped with transition metals, Fe, Mo, and V, have been studied by EPR [51-531. It was demonstrated that the dopant ions can participate in different ways in the low temperature electron and hole generation and trapping processes. Both hole and electron trapping by the dopant ions have been observed. Irradiation of the aqueous Fe-doped colloids causes the growth of Ti3+ signals, including a signal due to the aqueous Ti3+(HzO), complex with reversed values of the g-tensor (see Table 1.1). These changes where attributed to the inhibition of the hole-electron recombinations by Fe3+ions. Vanadium doping of colloids causes a similar inhibition. The decrease of the V5* signal upon irradiation was associated with the hole or electron trapping. Interstitial Mo& ions produced durin preparation of the colloid are extremely effective and irreversible electron traps, while Mo', on the other hand, is a reversible hole trap. Similar electron centers trapped on the surface or interior Ti3+ions were also observed in TiOz particles having modified surfaces [26, 36, 46, 54-57], anchored Ti02 particles supported on porous Vycor glass [58] or incorporated into silica gel pores by impregnation [59]. A small change in the g-values of the axially symmetrical g-tensor (previously identified as interstitial interior Ti3+ ions) upon the sample heating was reported [60] (gll= 1.957, g l = 1.990 for untreated sample and gll= 1.961, gl= 1.992 for sample heated at 700°C for 5 h). Authors attribute the first signal to the photogenerated electron trapped on the surface Ti3+ions, and the second one to the inner Ti3' ions.
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
9
The same type of signals were found in TiOz colloid particles, whose surface was modified with vitamin C [57]. Two typical electron centers in the unmodified TiOz particles were reported- broad surface and narrow interior. After surface modification with vitamin C the surface signal disappeared, instead two well resolved in the parallel orientation signals can be observed (gill = 1.9615, gIl = 1.9885 and 81'1 = 1.9581, gZL= 1.988). The signal with a parallel component at higher field was identified with an interstitial internal Ti3' ion. Meanwhile the narrow component at g = 1.9615 tentatively was associated with a signal motionally narrowed by an electron hopping from one center to another. A similar signal has been observed before from partially reduced rutile Ti02 and attributed to an electron loosely bound to an interstitial titanium ion or completely delocalized electron [61,62].
structure I
structure I1
structure I11
Fig. 1.4.Coordination of surface Ti atoms in TiOz nanoparticle. Dotted lines denote bonding to Ti02
lattice. The presence of a surface modifier also affects the electron surface trapping sites. In [46] it was shown that modification of the surface with cysteine leads to the two distinct surface electron trapping sites. In this case two asymmetric EPR signals with g = 1.958, and g = 1.934 are recorded. The same type of signals have been reported previously for Ti02 colloids in the presence of methanol [37]. In the latter case it was shown that these two signals belong to two distinct species which decay with different kinetics at different temperatures. While the g-factor of the interstitial Ti3+centers is not affected when the TiOz surface is modified with cysteine, the g-factor for surface Ti3' centers changes. This was explained as the result of the change in the axial crystal field that becomes stronger than in the OH coordinated structure. Two surface structures that contribute to the surface Ti3+ signal after surface modification have been proposed. The first signal, having the EPR signal at g = 1.934, was attributed to the case of one cysteine molecule coordinated to the surface Ti ion (Fig. 1.4, Structure 11) , and the second (g = 1.958) with two cysteine molecules coordinated to Ti atom (Fig. 1.4, Structure 111). The fate of the trapped electron with an increase in temperature was followed in work [46] for cysteine-modified TiOz aqueous colloid with lead ion added into solutions. It was shown that in this case lead is chelated with the carboxyl and mercapto groups of cysteine, and
10
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
in the Ti02/cysteine/Pb2+ system cysteine acts as a bridging bidentate ligand. The low temperature EPR signal for trapped electrons did not change after the addition of lead ions, and the electrons were trapped on lattice and/or surface Ti atoms (Fig. 1.4) according to the equation:
I
I
ecb-+ (Ti02),Ti(IV)-O-CO-CH(NH2)CH~SPb-+
I
I
Ti(III)~att02(Ti0~),-ITi(IV)-O-CO-CH(NH~)CH~SPb or
I
I
(TiO2),Ti(III),~O-CO-CH(NH2)CH2SPb At 120 K, however, the relative intensity of the signal for lattice type Ti3' trapped electrons decreased, and surface trapped Ti electrons with g = 1.958 (associated with Structure 111) and g = 1.934 (associated with Structure 11) increased (Fig. 1.5): Ti(III)latt -+ Ti(III)sd
(1.3)
When the temperature was raised to 200 K the signal for the surface trapped electrons at the sites chelated with two cysteine molecules (Fig. 1.4) disappeared, while the signal for surface trapped electrons at the sites chelated with one cysteine molecule increased four times relative to the trapped hole signal:
These results indicate that the transition from surface state I11 to surface state I1 is thermodynamically favorable. The redox potential of the trapped site coordinated with one carboxyl groups is less negative than the redox potential of the site coordinated with two carboxyl groups simultaneously. On this basis the energy level diagram of the electron trapped sites was proposed (Fig. 6). Such temperature transformations are typical for Pb doped and pure aqueous colloidal solutions. When the temperature is raised to room temperature for Pb ion doped solution, all photogenerated electrons are scavenged by metal ions,
2Ti(III)1a~t0~(TiO~),Ti(IV)-O-CO-CH(NH~)CH~SPb -+
11
Chapter I ; T. Rajh, et al.
I
I
2(TiO~),Ti(III),~O-CO-CH(NH~)CH2SPb + 2(TiO2),Ti(IV)-O2C-CH(NH2)CH2SH + Pbo and precipitation of metallic lead is observed.
30 0 K+8 K
31 00.00
3200.00
3300.00
3400.00
Magnetic Field (C auss) Fig. 1.5. EPR spectra of degassed aqueous Ti02 colloids (0.2 M) in the presence of (0.1 M) cysteine and Pb2*ions (0.05 M) illuminated with 308 nm excimer laser at 77 K, recorded at different
temperatures indicated at the figure. Formation of metallic lead was identified by a Pb containin dark brownish-gray precipitate formed after steady state illumination of the TiOdcysteinePb system. It should be noted that P b 0 2 could not be reduced directly to metallic Pb because addition of sodium borohydride to the solution of Pb2' ions in the presence of Ti02 does not produce metallic lead.
f+
12
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
The possibility of forming PbS was ruled out by the following experiments. Formation of PbS requires generation of HS- from cysteine. Illumination of cysteine-modified Ti02 did not lead to the reduction of cysteine which would result in H S formation, but led to the accumulation of trapped electrons having a broad optical absorption band at=,A 700-800 nm.
J
hv
Fig. 1.6. Energy level diagram of the observed electron trapping sites
In conclusion, in spite of the variety of EPR signals, the nature of the trapped electron in the Ti02 nanoparticles is well understood. There are two general types of traps - internal, having a narrow axially symmetric EPR signal, and surface with broad EPR lines. Reported gvalues of the trapped electron signals are summarized in Table 1.1. Magnetic resonance parameters of the internal, interstitial Ti3’ ions slightly vary due to the different delocalization of the unpaired electron density and symmetry of the local surroundings (presence of vacancies and impurities in the nearest coordination sphere). The same is true for the surface electron trap. In this case, g-values and the linewidth of the surface Ti3’ ions mainly depend upon surface modification. Conduction band electrons have not been recorded with EPR techniques probably owing to the fast recombination and trapping mechanism. 1.3.3.Hole Trapping Sites
Many publications are devoted to the EPR study of the hole trapped centers in Ti02 nanoparticles after low temperature irradiation [36,37,44-46,49,63-721. The interpretations of the observed EPR signals and assignments of the photogenerated hole species are less clear than electron traps, and several contradictions can be found in the literature. As it was shown recently [36,37,46,54,55,57] the main reason for the controversy is that holes are localized in the surface region of the nanoparticles and the structure of the hole centers strongly depends upon surface treatment and modification.
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
13
The studies of the radicals formed in aqueous colloids of Ti02, which was carried out with the use of an indirect spin-trapping technique, indicated the presence of OH' and HO; radicals [73, 741. Studies of the hole centers in hydrated anatase Ti02 nanoparticles were done in several labs [49,63,64]. While the authors of [63] reported observation of the H02 and 0 or 0;. species generated upon illumination of hydrate anatase in 02,Anpo et al. [64]for the same system observed a spectrum, which was assigned to the OH' radical. On the other hand Howe and Gratzel [49], observed similar EPR spectra with an asymmetric g-tensor: 2.002, 2.012, 2.016. This signal was assigned to the hole, which is localized on the oxygen anion not on the surface, but in the immediate subsurface layer. The hole was trapped in the following proposed structure: Ti4'0' Ti4+OH. Recently Micic et al. [37] reconsidered the assignment of the hole traps in the Ti02 colloids of anatase and rutile powders. The sensitivity of the EPR spectra was improved by preparing aqueous colloidal solutions with a large surface area owing to the smaller particle size and, as a consequence, larger concentration of the particles. For identification of the surface centers, colloidal systems were prepared in isotopically exchanged water: heavy water DO2 and " 0 enriched water H1702. It was demonstrated that holes produced by band gap irradiation of Ti02 colloids move from the oxygen lattice to the surface and are trapped directly on oxygen atoms bound to surface Ti4+ ions. Trap holes in anatase and rutile systems exhibit similar properties. The results obtained with Ti02 colloids prepared with 170enriched water confirms the assignment of trapped holes as oxygen surface anion radicals covalently bound to Ti4+ions in the form: Ti4+02Ti4+0-*.The intensity of the EPR signal from holes is very sensitive to hydration and total surface area. This signal completely disappears with the addition of the hole scavengers that are strongly bound to the surface, such as polyvinyl alcohol or vitamin K1. This was the first direct demonstration of the influence of surface modification on the charge transfer reaction and hole stabilization in the Ti02 colloidal nanoparticles. Table 1.2. g-values of the hole trap centers in the Ti02 nanoparticles. System
Ref., comments
gl
gz
Hydrated TiOl AN (Degussa P-25)
2.007
2.014
2.024
63, recorded at 12 K
Hydrated TiOz AN (Degussa P-25)
2.004
2.016
2.028
63, recorded at 77 K
Hydrated Ti02 AN particles
2.002
2.012
2.016
49, rec. at 4.2&77 K
Hydrated Ti02 AN particles
2.003
2.0146
2.0146
64, recorded at 77 K
Hydrated Ti02 AN (Degussa P-25)
2.007
2.014
2.024
36, recorded at 6 K
A1 doped Ti02
2.0034
2.0261
2.0297
66, recorded at 10 K
A1 doped Ti02
2.003
2.0189
2.0197
66, recorded at 30 K
g3
AN Ti02 before heat treatment
2.004
2.014
2.018
60, recorded at 77 K
AN Ti02 after heat treatment
2.004
2.018
2.030
60, recorded at 77 K
AN is anatase
14
Charge Separation in T i 0 2Revealed by EPR
The work of Nakaoka and Nosaka [60], in which anatase Ti02 powder was treated by heating at various temperatures in the air, should be mentioned. Two different signals in the region of the g-values corresponding to hole centers were detected in pretreated samples and samples heated at 700OC. On the basis of the comparison of g-tensors, the spectrum in the sample before heating was assigned to the subsurface Ti4+0' Ti4+OH structure, and after heating to the surface Ti4+02Ti4+ structure (see Table 1.2). 0 - O
1.3.4. Charge Separation in the Surface-Modijied Ti02 Colloids The approach that takes advantage of the presence of surface defect sites and converts them into coupling sites for selective bindings of photodegradable substrates is based on surface modification of nanocrystalline Ti02. Photogenerated electrons and holes lose significant energy in the trapping processes at the surface and cannot be used to carry out effective redox chemistry. By blocking the surface defect sites with appropriate surface modifiers one can enhance the redox properties of photogenerated charges, and, at the same time, enhance the rate of photodegradation by increasing the local concentration of pollutants on the particle surface. Metal oxide colloids have been effectively coupled with multifunctional ligands containing carboxyl groups that bind to the surface of nanoparticles [46].One can rationally design optimal photocatalysts by tailoring functional groups for selective adsorption of specific
rrapped holes
2
I
r1.987
trapped electrons
IIK-8
2.022
IIK-8K
2.008
d I I K - 8K
3200.00
3300 00
3 4 0 0 00
M a g n e t i c F i e l d (Gauss)
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
15
T i 0 Zleysteine
n/J---thiolac tate -ir r adiate d
3200 00
3300.00
3400 00
Magnetic Field (Gauss)
3500 00
Fig. 1.7. Surface modification of 45 8, TiOz colloids with different mercapto-carboxylic acids. EPR spectra of degassed aqueous TiOz colloids (0.3 M) illuminated with 308 rn excimer laser (a) in the presence of different surface modifiers illuminated at 77K and recorded at 8K (b) the same samples recorded at 150 K; at the bottom irradiation of pure TLA acid in N 2 0 leads to formation of sulfur centered radical dimmer of TLA.
pollutants. Extensive work on surface modification for efficient charge separation resulting in the removal of heavy metal ions has recently been performed [54, 5 5 , 761. The surface of colloidal Ti02 were modified with a series of bidentate and tridentate compounds having mercapto, carboxyl, and amino groups in different relative positions and appendant hydrocarbon chain lengths. EPR results have indicated principles for design of an optimal surface modifier for the reduction of heavy metal ions such as lead or cadmium [ 5 5 ] . Surface modifiers are effectively linked to the Ti02 surface via a carboxyl group. EPR results indicated that upon illumination of cysteine and S-methyl cysteine the carboxyl group acts as the primary trapping site for photogenerated holes (Fig. 1.7) at low temperatures (4-77 K). The holes are trapped on cysteine as a carboxyl radical (gx = 2.022 and g, = g, = 2.004) [77-791, while the electrons are trapped on the Ti02 particle. In cysteine-modified TiOl the charge separation distance increases further with increasing temperatures, due to the existence of the appending mercapto group.
16
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
The formation of a sulfur centered radical at 150 K was observed. The increased separation distance prevents recombination of trapped charges and enhances the lifetime of trapped electrons. In the presence of metal ions the signal for trapped electrons disappears indicating their reaction with metal ions reducing them to the metallic state. However, when intraparticle charge transfer in the surface modifier is prevented by blocking the mercapto group which acts as the hole trap (S-methyl cysteine), stabilization of charge separation is not achieved and precipitation of lead is much less effective (Fig. 1.7). Stabilization of the charge pairs was also achieved by using modifiers in which mercapto groups chelate Ti surface atoms concomitantly with the carboxyl groups. This bidentate binding of surface modifiers such as mercaptoacetic acid (MAA) and thiolactic acid (TLA) restructures undercoordinated defect sites in nanocrystalline titania [801. EPR spectra reveal that at low temperatures (4-77K) photogenerated holes in MAA-modified colloids are trapped at the carboxyl group with the signal having g, = 2.022 and g, = g, = 2.004. In TLAmodified colloids, however, the transfer of the holes within the surface modifier molecule occurs even at low temperatures (77K). The EPR spectrum of TLA-modified T i 0 2 now is composed of five lines with hyperfine coupling of aH= 22 G. Because the signal for trapped electrons is still present indicating that electrons cannot be involved in the reduction of TLA, we attribute this radical to a =CH*CH2 radical [81], the product of oxidation of TLA. The sulfur radical of TLA would have the EPR spectrum either at g 2.17 in RS. form or g, = 2.052, g, = 2.021 and g, = 2.001 in RSa-SR form [82] none of which were observed upon illumination of surface-modified TiOl. These results show that once the mercapto group is bound to the Ti surface atom it does not act as a trap for photogenerated holes. Instead, the hydrocarbon group in a position a to the mercapto group which is also the group furthest from the particle surface, becomes the hole-trapping site. The oxidation potential of this radical is more positive than the corresponding sulfur centered radical and therefore can be scavenged with a variety of electron donating compounds. In MAA-modified colloids in which a side hydrocarbon group does not exist, the charge transfer ends at the carboxyl group and the photogenerated electrons at 150 K recombine with holes trapped close to the particle surface. Additionally investigation of the primary trap for photogenerated holes in TLA by illumination at 4.2 K has been carried out (Fig. 1.8) [83]. At helium temperatures a very rich hyperfine structure for photogenerated holes was observed. This spectrum was deconvoluted into a quartet representing a radical species that survives up to 30 K and a quintet representing a species that is present up to 200 K, when it probably disappears in a radical recombination reaction. The quartet signal with 20 G hyperfine coupling fits the signal that can be associated with the holes located at the backbone carbon of thiolactic acid (=CCH3), while the quintet with a hyperfine coupling of 22 G corresponds to the holes trapped on the appending hyrocarbon group in a position, the same signal observed at elevated temperatures (=CH.CH2). As the distance between charges is enhanced, charge separation becomes more efficient and more charges are available for reactions at the colloid surface. These EPR studies have shown that the surface modifier must contain a carboxyl group to bind to the colloid surface and at the same time to bind to the metal ions. The surface modifier has to have a hole trap that enhances photogenerated charge pair separation distance. A mercapto group that is in an a position relative to a carboxyl group enhances adsorption of
-
Chapter 1; T.Rajh, et al.
17
Fig. 1.8. EPR spectra of thiolactic acid modified Ti02 colloids illuminated with 308 nm excimer laser at 4.3 K and annealed at different temperatures indicated at the figure
both surface modifiers and heavy metals to small particle Ti02 colloids. In these systems, side hydrocarbon groups such as the -CH3 group in thiolactic acid provide a trapping site for holes that can be used for the design of systems in which the hydrophobic aliphatic or aromatic part of a surface modifier will be selectively used for oxidation of organic compounds. Using electrochemical methods we have also found that surface derivatives modify the redox properties of TiOz particles and the redox properties of metal ions [ S I . The crucial parameter for effective removal of heavy metal ions is the trade off between enhanced redox properties of Ti02 by surface modification and enhanced redox potential of chelated metal ions. EPR studies were also performed to determine the principles for the design of optimal surface modifiers for deposition of metal layers on a Ti02 nanocrystalline substrate having the potential applications in the formation of conducting patterns in integrated circuits [27]. The mechanism of charge separation that leads to reduction of copper and silver ions was investigated by EPR spectroscopy (Fig. 1.9). Different surface modifiers containing the carboxyl, phosphono, and amino groups were used. Illumination (355 nm) of alanine-modified Ti02 colloids at 10 K in the presence of copper ions leads again to the formation of signals associated with trapped electrons (see above) and a signal associated with holes trapped on the carboxyl groups (gx = 2.022 and g, = g, = 2.004). This result suggests that the carboxyl group is again participating in the collaborative binding of alanine to the Ti02 surface.
18
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
Fig. 1.9. EPR spectra of Ti02 colloids modified with alanine (upper) and amino phosphono propionic acid (lower) in the presence of copper ions illuminated with 355 nm laser at 10 K and recorded at different temperatures indicated at the figure.
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
19
The g-factor for the surface trapped electrons was found to be g = 1.924, the same as in the unmodified TiOz colloids. These trapping sites are not significantly affected by adsorption of alanine, probably because of the low surface coverage of alanine. However, in the presence of copper, heating of the sample to room temperature resulted in the disappearance of the signal for trapped electrons. Under the same conditions, the reduction of copper ions to a metallic state was confirmed using X-ray absorption spectroscopies (XAS) [27]. When a carboxyl group in alanine was replaced with a phosphono group, much stronger adsorption of surface modifiers was observed. However EPR results show more hindered hole transfer to the phosphono group. Photogenerated holes in this system were primarily trapped as a symmetrical oxygen centered radical on the Ti02 surface (gx = g, = 2.029, g, = 2.007, Fig. 1.9), suggesting that hole transfer to the linking phosphono group is an activated process. Upon raising the temperature to 77 K, the surface trapped radical possibly is transformed to an oxygen centered radical on the phosphono group. The same radical was previously obtained by illumination of semiconductor colloids stabilized with trioctyl phosphine oxide [84].These results indicate weaker coupling of the phosphono groups to surface titanium atoms as compared to carboxyl groups from alanine.
3100.00
3200.00
3300.00
3400.00
3500.00
Magnetic Field (G ) Fig. 1.10. EPR spectra of TiOz colloids modified with alanine in the presence of methanol and metal ions illuminated with 355 nm laser at 77 K and recorded at different temperatures.
20
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
In order to protect the surface modifier (cysteine, thiolactic acid or alanine) against oxidation, a sacrificial electron donor that can also enhance the reduction yield of metal ions can be introduced into the solution. We investigated the surface-modified TiOz in the presence of methanol. Methanol is a known current doubling agent [85] and can be easily oxidized by photogenerated holes. In the presence of methanol, the EPR signal of the surface-modified Ti02 colloid at 8.9 K (Fig. 1.10) is composed of a partially obscured set of three lines with separation of -18 G, and a set of two lines with 136 G separation (arising from the methanol radical (CH20(H)) and formyl radical (CHO), respectively). The signals associated with trapped electrons are those due to Ti3' in the bulk lattice (g = 1.988), and of Ti3+ at the surface with g = 1.924. Thus, the holes are transferred to adsorbed methanol which becomesis oxidized rather than the surface modifier (similar signals were obtained in cysteine, thiolactate and alaninemodified colloids). The large negative potential of the methanol radical (-0.95 V vs. NHE) [86] induces electron injection into colloidal Ti02 at 120 K with formation of surface trapped electrons and formaldehyde. Consequently, the yield of electrons is doubled (Fig. 1.10). This spectrum
Fig. 1.11. Schematic presentation of copper deposition on TiOz nanoparticles in the presence of methanol as current doubling agent.
disappears at room temperature indicating the reduction of metal ions as confirmed in XAS measurements. Based on these results, the following mechanism has been proposed (Fig. 1.11). Effective coupling of a carboxyl group to the surface Ti atoms was also demonstrated in the work of Konovalova et al. [56]. In this work surface modification of TiOz nanoparticles with carotenoids containing terminal -C02H groups was found to bind strongly to the nanocrystalline surface. Full electron transfer from carotenoid to the Ti02 nanoparticle in the ground state was demonstrated. The EPR spectra (77 K) prior to irradiation exhibit the signal of the carotenoid radical cation with g = 2.0028 and a broad line with g < 2 due to the electrons trapped on the Ti02 nanoparticles. The optical absorption spectra of TiOz nanoparticles modified by these carotenoid carboxylic acids show a broad absorption band with a maximum near 650 nm that is characteristic of the absorption of surface trapped electrons. Other carotenoid/TiOz systems do not produce any EPR signals in the absence of irradiation. However, illumination (400-600 nm) of aldoxime carotenoid-modified Ti02 colloids
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et aZ.
21
(-NOH linking group) with light energy less than the Ti02 band gap at 77 K leads to the formation of the carotenoid radical cation with additional signals attributed to trapped electrons. Thus, EPR measurements demonstrate charge separation on the carotenoid-modified TiOz surface. Trapped electrons can reduce the acceptor molecules such as 2,5-dichloro-l,4-benzoquinone, nitrobenzene, and oxygen. The EPR signals associated with trapped electrons disappeared as a result of the reaction with the acceptors, and new EPR peaks, assigned to radical anions of the acceptor molecules, are observed. In this process TiOz nanoparticles act as mediators in the reduction sensitized by carotenoids. This EPR study has resulted in the design of alternative nanocrystalline photovoltaic cells photosentisized with carotenoids [ 871. The effects of surface modification of nanocrystalline Ti02 with specific chelating agents on photocatalytic degradation of nitrobenzene (NB)was investigated to design a selective and effective photocatalyst for removal of nitroaromatic compounds from contaminated waste streams [26]. The coordination sphere of the surface titanium atoms is incomplete and thus exhibits high affinity to oxygen containing ligands to form chelating structures. Three compounds were investigated to enhance adsorption of NB:a long chain carboxylic acid (lauryl sulfate) to make the surface of the TiOz particles hydrophobic; an amino acid (L-arginine) with a high affinity for hydrogen bonding and electron donating properties; and a benzene derivative (salicylic acid) that may form n-n donor-acceptor complexes. Arginine, lauryl sulfate, and salicylic acid were found to bind to Ti02 via their oxygen containing functional groups. The NB degradation on unmodified Ti02 follows both an oxidative and reductive mechanism but is completely altered to a reductive pathway over arginine-modified Ti02 and this reduction is enhanced upon addition of methanol. Arginine improved the coupling between NB and Ti02, and facilitated the transfer of photogenerated electrons from the T i 0 2 conduction band to the adsorbed NB. Modification with salicylic acid provided the greatest enhancement of NB adsorption over unmodified Ti02. However, only arginine-modified Ti02 resulted in enhanced photodecomposition of NB when compared to unmodified TiO2. The initial quantum yield for photodegradation of NB over arginine-modified TiOl was enhanced to @idt= 0.28 compared to the one obtained for Degussa P25 of @*, = 0.15. These results indicate that surface modification of nanocrystalline T i 0 2 with electron donating chelating agents is an effective route to enhance photodecomposition of nitroaromatic compounds. Surface modification can also result in a charge transfer complex with small particle TiOz colloids. In that case the optical absorption threshold is shifted to the visible range of the light spectrum, i.e. improved optical properties for solar energy conversion [55-57,881. These composite systems have a core of Ti02 and a shell of organic modifiers and exhibit hybrid properties that differ from the properties of both constituents. Using EPR we have shown that excitation of these composite systems results in charge separatio, electrons localized in the Ti02 core, and holes localized in the organic shell. It was found that nanosize Ti02 particles experience an adjustment in the coordination geometry of the Ti atoms near the particle surface from octahedral to square-pyramidal in order to accommodate the large surface curvature [57]. X-ray absorption near edge structure reveals that surface modification with enediol ligands (ascorbate, ortho-hydroxy cyclobutene dione, catechol, etc.) restores the pre-edge features of octahedrally coordinated Ti in the anatase crystal environment. Specific binding of the enediol modifiers to surface “corner defects”
22
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
induces a 1.6 eV shift in the onset of absorption, compared to unmodified nanocrystallites. The red shift of the onset of absorption is explained by a charge transfer (CT) mechanism, as with CT salts [57].
Fig. 1.12. Light-induced EPR (X-band) spectra of degassed aqueous Ti02 colloids (0.3 M) modified with (top) ascorbic acid (0.1 M) or (bottom) dopamine, irradiated with white light (cut off filter 400 nm) at 4.2 K.
These newly developed systems have an important feature in that charge pairs are instantaneously separated into two phases following photoexcitation. Electron paramagnetic
resonance spectroscopy (EPR) was used to obtain a molecular understanding of the origin of the charge transfer complex and the corresponding electron accepting and donating sites. Contrary to optical measurements, EPR spectroscopy has the ability to unambiguously identify the species involved in the charge separation processes. It was found using EPR that excitation with visible light, A > 500 nm of the charge transfer complex of 45 A Ti02 nanoparticles with ascorbic acid, resulted in low temperature reversible charge separation in which an electron was excited from a donor to the acceptor site. This was manifest by the appearance of two signals in the continuous light photoinduced CW EPR spectrum, one for lattice trapped electrons (g = 1.988 and AHpp= 2.5 Gauss g = 1.958) and a signal at g = 2.004 with small hyperfine coupling
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
23
(Fig. 1.12). This latter signal has linewidth and g-value consistent with a carbon-centered radical. As electrons are involved in the reduction of Ti, this signal can be reasonably assigned to the reversible trap for photogenerated holes. The EPR signal at g = 2.004 was dependent on the ligands used for surface modification. In the case of modification with ascorbate ligands AHppwas 11 Gauss. A similar but broader signal with g = 2.004, AHpp=16 Gauss was obtained when dopamine was used as surface modifier. The linewidth decreased to AHpp= 10 Gauss upon using deuterated dopamine (ring-D2 or 2,2-D2). As the signal was dependent on the nature of the surface modifier and photogenerated electrons were found to be involved in the reduction of Ti, this signal can be assigned to the reversible trap for photogenerated holes. The fact that the trapping is reversible, suggests that oxidation is not followed by proton loss forming an allylic radical. The number of holes trapped on the surface modifier was rough1 equal to the number of trapped electrons and for the ascorbate modifier was found to be 4x10 Y to lx1015 spins cm-' in systems containing l O I 4 to 5 ~ 1 0 Ti02 ' ~ particles cm-' as determined by comparison to a calibrated sample. Under the same conditions, no EPR signals were observed from 20 8 Ti02 particles modified with ascorbate, probably because of the fast recombination rate due to the short charge separation distance (10 8). 1.4. Kinetic and Mechanism of the Charge Separation in Ti02 Colloid Nanoparticles as Studied by Time-Resolved EPR Technique.
Application of EPR spectroscopy provides not only data on the structure of the charge separated states in the Ti02 nanoparticles, but it can be a valuable source of information on the mechanism and kinetics of photoinduced electron-transfer reactions in such particles. Martino et al. [89] reported the first application of the time-resolved Fourier Transform EPR (FTEPR) in the study of room temperature formation of free radicals after laser excitation of the TiOl colloid. High spectral and time resolution of the technique allows authors to identify free radicals formed and to deduce the time constant of the electron-transfer reaction. Colloidal solution of Ti02 in ethanol containing methyl viologen (MV2') and coumarin 343 dye together with MV2' have been studied. In both cases the reduction of MV" was observed. The kinetics indicate that the trapped electrons responsible for MV2' reduction are generated by excitation of adsorbed dye molecules, which leads to electron injection into the conduction band of the semiconductor nanopartcles. Dye modification of the Ti02 surface strongly increases the free radical yield. However, the rate of the electron-transfer from semiconductor particles to acceptor in solution is strongly attenuated as the coverage of the surface approaches saturation level. These results provide the first direct experimental confirmation of the suggestion [go] that the efficiency of Gratzel photovoltic cells depends on the degree of coverage of the TiOz anode by an insulating layer which inhibits the direct return of the electron, injected to the conduction band, to I i present in solution. The mechanism of the charge separation in the colloidal Ti02 particles was studied at low temperature by direct time-resolved and light-modulated EPR techniques [91]. The recombination kinetics in the nanocrystalline semiconductor particles usually is very fast, on
24
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
the order of picoseconds [38]. The efficiency of charge separation is low [89] and can not be observed by the time-resolved EPR techniques, unless the charge separation is enhanced by reaction with adsorbed species. As described above enhanced charge separation and improved optical properties of nanocrystalline TiOz that involve photoinduced interfacial electron transfer from surface modifiers into the conduction band of nanocrystalline Ti02 particles have been reported [57]. These systems have an important feature that charge pairs are instantaneously separated into two phases, the holes on the donating organic modifier and the electrons in the conduction band of TiOz. The charge separation is reversible in these systems at low temperatures. Surface modification with bidentate ortho- substituted hydroxylated electron donating ligands allows observation of electron spin polarization phenomena in continuous wave time- resolved EPR experiments [91]. The obtained data reveals the mechanism of the charge separation process. This is the first direct observation of transient species involved in the early stages of charge pair formation in surface-modified nanocrystalline TiOz using timeresolved EPR techniques. In contrast to the optical measurements that give extensive kinetic information on transient species, EPR spectroscopy can unambiguously identify paramagnetic species involved in the charge separation processes, monitor their molecular environment and spin dynamics. Using conventional continuous wave EPR spectroscopy two li ht-induced reversible signals attributed to oxidized donors and reduced acceptors in 45 TiOZ nanoparticles modified with ascorbic acid or dopamine were obtained at helium temperatures. As discussed above, the first signal ( g i = 1.988, g', = 1.961 and gZ1= 1.958, with a line width AHpp= 2.5 Gauss) is characteristic of a radical in which the unpaired electron occupies the d-orbitals of lattice Ti atoms [57] having a strong component of angular momentum due to the spin orbit coupling. No EPR signals associated with the surface components were observed indicating that both ascorbate and dopamine ligands raise the energy of the surface trapping sites. The EPR signal at g=2.004 was dependent on the ligands used for surface modification and was assigned to the reversible trap for photogenerated holes. By applying time-resolved (TR) EPR techniques (insert Fig. 1.13), the formation of the initial radical intermediate has been observed. The EPR spectrum obtained one microsecond after the laser excitation at helium temperatures (Fig. 1.13) is composed of two emissive lines and one absorptive line and the overall spectrum exhibits excess emission. The emissive line at g = 2.004 and absorptive line at g = 1.988 are observed at the same g values as the signals associated with the holes on the ascorbate modifier and electrons in the TiOz lattice, respectively. The algebraic average (gave= (gh+ g,)/2) of the low-field and high-field lines is very nearly equal to the central emissive line at g=1.995, which was not observed in continuous light measurements. This suggests that the origin of the signal comes from the exchange interaction in electrons and holes, otherwise localized Ti d-orbitals (electrons) and carbon centered 71: orbitals of the organic modifier (hole). The EPR spectrum of photoexcited 45 A Ti02 modified with dopamine (Fig. 1.14) shows similar properties, except that the linewidth of the signal attributed to the dopamine radical cation is larger, as observed in corresponding continuous light EPR measurements. Because of the broader signal for trapped holes, the two emissive signals overlap. However, the shoulder in the spectrum has a g-value of 1.995, the same value as observed in ascorbate-
x
Chapter I ; T. Rajh, et al.
25
modified TiOz. Again, the algebraic average of the low-field and high-field lines is very nearly equal to the central emissive line at g = 1.995. hv I
I
IA
\I
3300.00
Emission
3320.0vv
TR g=1.995
Fig. 1.13. Comparison between integrated continuous light-induced (upper trace) and time-resolved pulsed laser-induced (lower trace) EPR spectra from 45A Ti02 (0.3M) modified with ascorbic acid (0.08 M). The lower trace was obtained with a 550 nm laser (laser intensity 10 rnJ per pulse, 10 ns pulse duration, 20 scans), 1 ps after the laser pulse. Both spectra were recorded at 8 K. Insert: schematic presentation of events in time-resolved direct detection. The spectrum is taken at the time T after the laser pulse for each magnetic field using gate integrators. Magnetic field (H) is not
modulated. These observations suggest that the polarization features presented in Fig. 1.13 and 1.14 can be explained by the following (see Fig. 1.14). Light absorption in Ti02 yields the formation of conduction band electrons and holes that form singlet exciton states. Strong spin orbit coupling of Ti facilitates intersystem crossing to the triplet exciton. The triplet excitons are longer lived and have the potential to undergo further chemical transformations. The paramagnetic species thus produced are trapped holes and electrons, which have not recombined due to their triplet spin character. The trapped holes and electrons have very different environments, different g factors, which foster S-To Ag mixing in the radical pairs [92-971 giving rise to the emission in the higher g-factor hole and the absorption in the lower g-factor trapped electron signals [98]. There is
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
26
Emission
hv ->exciton
TR
s
ISC ->excitonT
Fig. 1.14. Comparison between integrated continuous light-induced (upper trace) and time-resolved pulsed laser-induced (lower trace) EPR spectra from 45A TiOz (0.3M) modified with dopamine (0.08 M).The lower trace was obtained with a 550 nm laser (laser intensity 10 mJ per pulse, 10 ns pulse duration, 20 scans), 1 ps after the laser pulse. Both spectra were recorded at 8 K. Right section shows how triplet radical pair mechanism of CIDEP in addition to fast exchange can contribute to the observed polarized spectrum.
Chapter I ; T. Rajh, et al.
27
also an apparent overall emission character to the spectrum which could arise from the triplet polarization induced in the triplet exciton which is the precursor of the charge separated trapped holes and electrons. Some radical pairs also exhibit exchange effects giving rise to the EPR line at the midpoint between the lines of non-interacting radicals. This fast exchange feature was previously reported for analogous corehhell quantum dots systems using optically detected magnetic resonance. Lifshitz et al. [99] have suggested that the fast exchange signal features may be a consequence of the substantial electron-hole coupling in the exciton. The separation distance for exciton interaction in anatase was previously found to be -15 8, [loo].
n
/ vA
g
R , = Holes on modifier
A
I 3260 00
I
1 3280 00
I
I 3300 00
I
I 3320 00
I
1 3340 00
I
I 3360 00
Magnetic Field ( G a u s s ) Fig, 1.15. Integrated LFM EPR spectru? of dopamine- modified (upper trace) and 6-pamitate ascorbic acid modified (lower trace) 42A TiOz Insert: Schematic presentations of events in LFM EPR. Both magnetic field (H) and light (hv) are modulated with frequencies a f i e l d and a l i g h t , respectively.
A subset of electron-hole radical pairs exhibits features of Spin Correlated Radical Pair (CRRP) electron spin polarization mechanism [ 1011 which can be observed at somewhat longer times via lighvfield modulated (LFM) EPR measurements. This technique is only sensitive to the light dependent part of the EPR spectrum on the time scale of the light modulation frequency (millisecond regime, insert Fig. 1.15). Using LFh4 EPR it was observed that both the transitions of the holes localized on the surface modifier and electrons localized on the TiOz
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
28
lattice were split into antisense doublets (two sets of absorptive (A) and emissive (E)lines, Fig. 1.15). The electron spin polarized spectrum obtained with ascorbate used as the surface modifier in conjunction with the energy level diagram for triplet born CRPP dominated charge pair polarization is shown in Fig. 1.16.
I
I
T-triplet S -singlet
R
I 3260.00
I
I 3280.00
I
I 3300.00
I
I 3320.00
I
I 3340.00
I
I 3360.00
Magnetic Field (Gauss)
Fig. 1.16. Integrated LFM EPR spectrum of ascorbate-modified 42A TiOz in conjunction with energy level diagram for triplet born CRPP dominated charge pair polarization.Light was modulated with frequency 0.5 KHz.
The low-field signal associated with photogenerated holes varies for different surface modifiers; the presence of hyperfine interactions in the samples modified with 6-palmitate ascorbic acid (6-PAA) have induced further splitting of the absorptive and emissive signals, while in dopamine-modified samples the signal was significantly broadened (Fig. 1.15). On the other hand, the signal associated with photogenerated electrons trapped in Ti02 lattice shows the same features regardless of the surface modifier. The A/E/A/E pattern of the photogenerated EPR signal reflects the existence of weak spin-spin interaction between photogenerated holes (on organic modifier) and electrons (in T i 0 2 lattice) [101-1031. This weak interaction and presence of CRRP mimics the characteristics of the EPR signal observed for charge separated state P'Q- (where P is chlorophyll electron donor and Q is quinone electron acceptor) in natural photosynthetic systems [ 1041 and has been replicated in a molecular donor-acceptor model system.
Chapter I ; T. Rajh, et al.
29
The theoretical modeling of the spin polarized LFM EPR spectrum of Ti02 nanoparticles modified with ascorbic acid has been carried out with a general analytical treatment of spin-correlated radical pair EPR spectra having weakly coupled spins [105]. According to the treatment each spin polarized signal consists of three independent contributions. The first contribution is determined by the exchange interaction, second -by the electron dipole-dipole interaction, and the third - by the contribution of the thermalized spectra. Individual equilibrium spectra of the hole stabilized on the ascorbic acid radical and trapped = (1.988, 1.988, electron were simulated with axial g-tensors: &ole = (2.004,2.004, 2.000), gelectr. 1.958) according to the data experimentally determined earlier [57]. Some anisotropy of the linewidths originating from unresolved hyperfine interaction was assumed to improve the fit: = (4.3 Gs, 4.3 Gs, 5.6 Gs), = (2.5 Gs, 2.5 Gs, 7.0 Gs). This set of individual magnetic parameters was used to simulate the equilibrium, exchange derivative, and dipole derivative lines for both radicals according to the previously formulated approach, formulated in [106]. The best fit (shown on Fig. 1.17) was simulated without any contribution of the equilibrium spectrum and with the dipole (HD)contribution dominating over that of exchange (H,): HD/HJ= -15. One very important conclusion from the analyses is that the presence of spin polarization assumes a nonvanishing angular average . With enhanced coupling between the donating and accepting site attained, one can expect that the rate of forward electron transfer is enhanced. In the Ti02 system with a modified surface the strong electronic coupling between ortho-substituted hydroxylated aromatic ligands and metal oxide particles leads to the instantaneous forward electron transfer from ligand to semiconductor nanoparticles. On the other hand, charge separation upon electron trapping leads to formation of radical pairs with negligible coupling. The magnitude of electron interaction is smaller than lo4 meV, which is four orders of magnitude smaller than the exciton binding
K
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
30
1
3280
' 3300
3320
'
3340
'
3360
3380
'
3100
Magnetic Field (G)
Fig. 1.17. Simulated (solid line) and experimental (dotted line) spectra of radical pairs in colloidal TiOz
modified with ascorbic acid. The g-tensors were taken as an axially simmetric with: g(R'+)=(2.004,2.004,2.000), g(R") = (1.988, 1.988, 1.958)according to the data experimentally determined earlier [57]. Anisotropic line width was obtained from the simulation of the equilibrium spectrum: AH(R'+) = (4.3Gs, 4.3 Gs, 5.6 Gs),AH(R'-) = (2.5 Gs, 2.5 Gs,7.0 Gs). The best fit of the polarized spectrum was simulated without any contribution of the equilibrium spectrum and with the dipole (H,) contribution dominating over the exchange (HJ) one: H a J -15. Good fit can be obtained only when HDsmaller than 3.5G. 15:
energy in bulk TiOl [105]. Thus, small exchange interaction J may stabilize the charge separated state resulting in prolonged lifetimes. A long lifetime of the fully charge separated state significantly enhances the probability of reaction with chemical species present in the surrounding environment, Le. more efficient chemistry. In this way a very important feature of the highly optimized photosynthetic system in natural photosynthesis is replicated - fast charge separation rates and slow charge recombination rates. These findings suggest that the investigated surface modifier ligands can act as conductive leads that may allow electronic linking of the Ti02 nanoparticle into molecular circuits. When covalently linked (wired) to electron donating moieties, photoinduced electron transfer of stabilized radical pairs can further extend the lifetime of charge separation. Summary The EPR technique is a valuable tool for gaining a better understanding of the mechanism and kinetics of photoinduced electron-transfer reactions in colloidal TiOl systems. There are two main features of the EPR technique which are indispensable in these studies.
Chapter 1; T. Rajh, et al.
31
First, due to the specificity of the EPR spectra, the paramagnetic species, involved in the charge separation, can be uniquely identified. Second, interconversion between species and kinetics of the charge-transfer reaction can be recorded in the wide time range (from ns to days) by monitoring the intensity and changes of the EPR signals. It is worth mentioning that in the past two decades many new modern methods of EPR spectroscopy have been developed. Among them are multifrequency EPR spectroscopy, multidimensional pulsed Electron Spin Echo spectroscopy, pulsed double resonance techniques (ENDOR and ELDOR), and high frequency EPR spectroscopy. In the near future application of the modern methods of the EPR spectroscopy can be anticipated to provide more detailed characteristics of the electron transfer processes in nanoparticles. Most of the efforts of researchers, working in the field of semiconductor colloids, are directed to the chemical modification of the system to make photoproduction reactions more efficient. EPR spectroscopy will certainly contribute to the development of new nanoscale materials which can effectively undergo charge separation for wide application in photocatalysis and solar energy conversion.
Acknowledgement This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Division of Chemical Sciences under contract W-3 1-109-Eng-38. The authors acknowledge the insights gained form discussions with A. Trifunac. REFERENCES
10.
Gerisher H. and Heller A. J. Electrochem. SOC, 139, No. 1, 113-118 (1992). Photocatalysis -- Fundamentals and Applications, N. Serpone and E. Pelizzetti (Eds.), John Willey & Sons, New York (1989). Fox M. A. Top. Curr. Chem., 142, NO. 1,72-99 (1987). Ollis D. F. Environ. Sci. Technol., 19, No. 6,480-484 (1985). Photocatalytic Purification and Treatment of Water and Air, D. F. Ollis and H. Al-Ekabi (Eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam (1993). Kormann C., Bahnemann D. W. and M. R. Hoffmann, Environ. Sci. Technol., 25, No. 3,494-500 (199 1). O’Regan B. and Gratzel M. Nature, 353, No. 6346,737-740 (1991). Rehm J. M., McLendon G. L., Nagasawa Y., Yoshihara K., Moser J. and Gratzel M. J. Phys. Chem., 100, No. 23, 9577-9578 (1996). Nasr C., Liu D., Hotchandani S . and Kamat P. J. Phys. Chem., 100, No. 26, 11054-11061 (1996). Burfeindt B., Hannappel T., Stork W. and Willig F. J. Phys. Chem., 100, No. 41, 16463-16465
11. 12.
Mayer G. J. J. Chem Education, 74, No. 6, 652-656 (1997). Martini I., Hodak J., Hartland G. V. and Kamat P. V. J. Chem. Phys., 107, No. 19, 8064-8072
1. 2.
3. 4.
5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
(1996). (1997).
13. 14.
Huang S. Y., Schlichthorl G., Nozik A. J., Gratzel M. and Frank A. J. J. Phys. Chem. B, 101, No. 14,2576-2582 (1997). Ellingson R. J., AsbuIy J. B., Ferrere S . , Ghosh H. N., Sprague J. R., Lian T. Q.and Nozik A. J. J. Phys. Chem. B, 102, No. 34,6455-6458 (1998).
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
32 15. 16. 17.
Pelizzetti E., Borgarello M., Minero C., Pramauro E., Borgarello E. and Serpone N. Chemosphere, 17, NO.3,499-5 10 (1988). Matthews R. W. WaterRes., 25, No. 10, 1169-1176 (1991). Carey J. H., Lawrence J. and Tosine H. M. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol., 16,No. 6, 697-701 (1976).
23.
Sclafani A., Palmisano L. and Schiavello M. J. Phys. Chem., 94, No.2, 829-832 (1990). Serpone N. Res. Chem. Zntenned., 20, No. 9, 953-992 (1994) and references within. Domhech J. and AndrCs M. Gauetta Chimica Ztaliana, 117, No. 8,495-498 (1987). Serpone N., Ah-You Y. K., Harris R., Hidaka H., Pelizzetti E. and Tran T. P. Solar Energy, 39, NO. 6,49 1-498 (1987). Prairie M. R., Pacheco J. and Evans L. R. Solar Detoxification of Water Containing Chlorinated solvents and Heavy Metals via Ti02 Photocatalysis, Prepared for the 1992 ASME Intl. Solar Energy Conf., April, SAND91-1285C, Sandia National Laboratory, Albuquerque, NM (1992). Hoffmann M. R., Martin S. T., Choi W. and Bahnemann D. W. Chem. Rev., 95, No. 1, 69-96
24.
Schmelling D. C., Gray K. A. and Kamat P. V. Environ. Sci. Technol., 30, No. 8, 2547-2555
25. 26.
38.
Piccinini P., Minero C., Vincenti M. and Pelizzetti E. Catal. Today, 39, No. 3, 187-195 (1997). Makarova 0. V., Rajh T., Thurnauer M. C., Martin A., Kemme P. A. and Cropek D. Environ. Sci. Technol., 34, No. 22,4797-2803 (2000). Rajh T., Nedeljkovic J., Chen L. X., Tiede D. M. and Thurnauer M. C. J. Adv. Oxid. Technol., 3, NO. 3, 292-298 (1998). Wu Z. Y., Ouvrard G., Gressier P. and Natoli C. R. Phys. Rev. B, 55, No. 16, 10382-10389 (1997). Pascual J., Camassel J. and Mathieu H. Phys. Rev B, 18, No. 10, 5606-5614 (1978). Boudreaux D. S., Williams F. and Nozik A. J. J. Appl. Phys., 51, No. 4,2158-2163 (1980). Nozik A. J. Ann. Rev. Phys. Chern., 29, 189-222 (1978). Morrison S. R., Electrochemistry at Semiconductor and Oxidized Metal Electrodes, p. 56, Plenum Press, New York (1980). Hagfeldt A. and Gratzel M. Chem. Rev., 95, No. 1,49-68 (1995). Morrison S. R., Electrochemistry at Semiconductor and Oxidized Metal Electrodes, p. 12, Plenum Press, NewYork (1980). Kolle U., Moser J. and Gratzel M. Znorg. Chem., 24, No. 14,2253-2258 (1985). Micic 0. I., Zhang Y., Cromack K. R., Trifunac A. D. and Thurnauer M. C. J. Phys. Chem., 97, NO.28,7277-7283 (1993). Micic 0. I., Zhang Y., Cromack K. R., Trifunac A. D. and Thurnauer M. C. J. Phys. Chem., 97, NO. 50, 13284-13288 (1993). Rothenberger G., Moser J., Gratzel M., Serpone N. and Sharma D. K. J. Am. Chem. SOC.,107, No.
39. 40.
Bahnemann D., Henglein A., Lilie J. and Spanhel L. J. Phys. Chem., 88, No. 4,709-71 1 (1984). Dimitrijevic N. M., Savic D., Micic 0. I. and Nozik A. J. J. Phys. Chem., 88, No. 19, 4278-4283
41.
Micic 0. I., Rajh T. and Comor M. V., in: Electrochemicstry in Colloids and Dispersions, R. A . Mackay and J. Texter (Eds.), p. 457, VCH Publ., New York (1992). Lawless D., Serpone N. and Meisel D. J. Phys. Chem., 95, No. 13,5166-5170 (1991). Meriaudeau P., Che M. and Jorgensen C. K. Chem. Phys. Lett., 5, No. 3, 131-133 (1970). Howe R. F. and Gratzel M. J. Phys. Chem., 89, No. 21,4495-4499 (1985). Gonzales-Elipe A. R., Soria J. J. and Munuera G. Chem. Phys. Lett., 57, NO. 2,265-268 (1978).
18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
(1995). (1996).
27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37.
26,8054-8059 (1985).
(1984).
42. 43. 44. 45.
Chapter I ; T. Rajh, et al.
46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82.
33
Rajh T., Ostafin A. E., Micic 0. I., Tiede D. M. and Thumauer M. C. J. Phys. Chem., 100, No. 11, 4538-4545 (1996). Kiwi J., Suss J. T. and Szopiro S. Chern. Phys. Lett., 106, No. 1,2, 135-138 (1984). Che M., Gravelle P. C. and Meriaudeau P. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris C, 268, No. 9,768-771 (1969). Howe R. F. and Gratzel M. J. Phys. Chem., 91, No. 14, 3906-3909 (1987). Huizinga T. and Prins R. J. Phys. Chem., 85, No. 15,2156-2158 (1981). Moser J., Gratzel M. and Gallay R. Helv. Chim. Acta, 70, No. 6, 596-604 (1987). Gratzel M. and Howe R. F. J. Phys. Chem., 94, No. 6,2566-2572 (1990). Soria J., Conesa J. C., Augugliaro V., Palmisano L., Schiavello M. and Sclafani A. J. Phys. Chem., 95, NO. 1,274-282 (1991). Rajh T., Tiede D. M. and Thumauer M. C. J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 207, No. 2, 815-820 (1996). Rajh T., Tiede D. M. and Thumauer M. C. Acta Chem. Scand., 51,610-618 (1997). Konovalova T. A., Kispert L. D. and Konovalov V. V. J. Phys. Chem. B, 103, No. 22,4672-4677 (1999). Rajh T., Nedeljkovic J. M., Chen L. X., Poluektov 0. and Thurnauer M. C. J. Phys. Chem. B, 103, NO. 18, 3515-3519 (1999). Anpo M., Shima T., Fujii T., Suzuki S. and Che M. Chem. Lett., Chem. SOC.Japan, No. 10, 1997 (1987). Ahn S. W. and Kevan L. J. Chem. SOC.,Farad. Trans., 94, No. 20,3147-3153 (1998). Nakaoka Y. and Nosaka Y . J. Photochem. Photobiol. A: Chem., 110, No. 3,299-305 (1997). Kerssen J. and Volger J. Physica, 69, No. 2,535-561 (1973). Yagiu E. and Hasiguti R. R. J. Phys. SOC.Japan, 43, No. 6, 1998-2005 (1977). Gonzales-Elipe A. R., Munuera G. and Soria J. J. J.Chern.Soc., Faraday Trans. I , 75, 748-761 (1979). Anpo M., Shima T. and Kubokawa Y. Chem. Lett., No. 12, 1799-1802 (1985). Gratzel M. and Howe R. F. J. Phys. Chem., 94, No. 6,2566-2572 (1987). Zwingwl D. Solid State Commun., 20, No. 4,397-400 (1976). Aundaithai M. and Kutty T. R. N. Mater.Res.Bull., 23, No. 11, 1675-1683 (1988). Anpo M., Shima T., Kodama S. and Kubokawa Y. J. Phys. Chem., 91, No. 16,4305-4310 (1987). Nikisha V. V., Shelimov B. N. and Kazanskii V. B. Kineticu i Kataliz, 15, No. 3, 676-680 (1974) (in Russian). Meriaudeau P. and Verdine J. C. J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. II,72, No. 2,472-480 (1976). Lumpov A. I., Mikheikin I. D., Chuvylkin N. D., Zhidomirov G. M. and Kazanskii V. B. Kinetica i Kataliz, 17, No. 3, 803-805 (1976) (in Russian). Berdnikov V. M. and Schastnev P. V. Kinetica i Kataliz, 16, No. 1, 83-91 (1975) (in Russian). Jaeger C. D. and Bard A. J. J. Phys. Chem., 83, No. 24, 3146-3152 (1979). Harbour J. R., Tramp J. and Hair M. L. Can. J. Chem., 63, No. 1,204-208 (1985). Wilson R. C. and Meyers R. J. J. Chem. Phys., 64,No. 5,2208-2211 (1979). Chen L. X., Rajh T., Micic O., Wang Z., Tiede D. M. and Thurnauer M. C. Nucl. Znstr. Meth. Phys. Res. B, 133,No. 1-4, 8-11 (1997). Box H. C., Freund H. G., Lilga K. T. and Budzinski E. E. J. Phys. Chem., 74, No. 1,40-52 (1970). Box H. C., Budzinski E. E. and Lilga K. T. J. Chem. Phys., 57, No. 10,4295-4298 (1972). Kou W. W. H. and Box H. C. J. Chem. Phys., 64,No. 7,3060-3062 (1976). Chen L. X., Rajh T., Wang Z. and Thumauer M. C. J. Phys. Chem., 101, No. 50, 10688-10697 (1998). Ayscough P. B. and Evans H. E. J. Phys. Chem., 68, No. 10,3066-3068 (1964). Nelson D. J., Petersen R. L. and Symons M. C. R. J. Chem. SOC.,Perkin Tr. II, No. 15,2005-2015 (1977).
34 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99.
100. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106.
Charge Separation in Ti02 Revealed by EPR
Rajh T. and Thumauer M. C., unpublished work. Rajh T., Micic 0. I. and Thumauer M. C., unpublished work. Nogami G. and Kennedy J. H. J. Electrochem. Soc., 136, No. 9,2583-2588 (1989). Breintkamp M., Henglein A. and Lilie J. Ber. Bunsenges., Phys. Chem., 80, NO. 10, 973-979 (1976). Gao F. G., Bard A. J. and Kispert L. D. J. Photochem. Photobiol., 130, No. 1,49-56 (2000). Rajh T., Thumauer M. C., Thyagarajan P. and Tiede D. M. J. Phys. Chem., 103, NO. 12, 21722177 (1999). Martino D. M., van Willigen H. and Spitler M. T. J. Phys. Chem. B, 101, No. 44, 8914-8919 (1997). Nazzeruddin M. K., Kay A., Rodicio I., Humphry-Baker R., Muller E., Liska P., Vlachopoulos N. and Gratzel M. J. Am. Chem. SOC.,115, No. 14, 6382-6390 (1993). Rajh T., Poluektov 0. G., Dubinski A. A,, Wiederrecht G., Trifunac A. D. and Thumauer M. C., Chem. Phys. Lett., 344, No. 1,2,31-39 (2001). Fessenden R. W. and Schuler R. H. J. Chem. Phys., 39, No. 9,2147-2195 (1963). Eiben K. and Fessenden R. W. J. Phys. Chem., 75, No. 9, 1186-1201 (1971). Atkins P. W., Buchanan L. C., Gurd R. C., McLauchlan K. A. and Simpson A. F. Chem. Comm., NO.9, 513-514 (1970). Atkins P. W. and McLauchlan K. A., in: Chemically Induced Magnetic Polarization, A. R. Lepley and G. L. Closs (Eds.), p. 41, John Wiley & Sons, New York (1973). Trifunac A. D. and Thumauer M. C., in Time Domain Electron Spin Resonance, L. Kevan and R. N. Schwartz (Eds.), p. 107, John Wiley & Sons, New York, (1979). Trifunac A. D. and Avery A. C. Chem. Phys. LRtt., 27, No. 1, 141-143 (1974). Trifunac A. D. and Thumauer M. C. J. Phys. Chem., 62, No. 12,4889-4895 (1975). Lifshitz E., Porteanu H., Glozman A., Weller H., Pflughoefft M. and Echymuller A. J. Phys. Chem. B, 103, No. 33,6870-6875 (1999). Tang H., Prasad K., Sanjines R., Schmid P. E. and Levy F. J. Appl. Phys., 75, No. 4, 2042-2047 (1994). . . Thurmauer M. C., Katz J. J. and Norris J. R. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 72, No. 9, 3270-3274 (1975). Thumauer M. C. and Noms J. R. Chem. Phys. Lett., 76, No. 3,557-561 (1980). Noms J. R., Moms A. L., Thumauer M. C. and Tang J, J. Chem. Phys., 92, No. 7, 4239-4249 (1990). Snyder S. and Thurnauer M. C., in: The Photosynthetic Reaction Center, J. Deisenhofer and J. R. Noms (Eds.), Academic Press, , Vol. 11, p. 285 (1993), and references therein. Pascual J., Camassel J. and Mathieu H. Phys. Rev. B, 18, No. 10, 5606-561 1 (1978). Dubinski A. A., Perekhodsev G. D., Poluektov 0. G . ,Rajh T. and Thumauer M. C., J. Phys. Chem B, 106, NO. 5, 938-944 (2002).
Chemical Physics of Nanostructured Semiconductors, pp. 35-82 A.I. Kokorin and D.W. Bahnemann (Eds.) 0 VSP 2003.
CHAPTER 2
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalitic Reactions on CdS Nanocolloids D. V. Bavykin, E. N. Savinov, I. N. Martyanov and V. N. Parmon Boreskov Institute of Catalysis, Novosibirsk, Russia Kevwords: Kinetics, photocatalysis, Cadmium suljide, nanoparticles, colloids, electron transfer, photoreduction
2.1. Introduction Kinetic studies of photoreactions on semiconductor nanoparticles are important for both science and practice. Of scientific interest are the so-called quantum size effects, which are most pronounced on these particles: shifting the edge of adsorption band, participation of <> electrons in the reactions and recombination, dependence of the quantum yield of luminescence and reactions on the excitation wavelength, etc. In one way or another all these phenomena affect the features of photocatalytic reactions. At present photocatalysis on semiconductors is widely used for practical purposes, mainly for the removal of organic contamination from water and air. The most efficient commercial semiconductor photocatalysts (mainly the Ti02 photocatalysts) have primary particles of size 10-20 nm, i.e., they consist of nanoparticles. Results of studying the photoprocesses on semiconductor particles (even of different nature) are used to explain the regularities of photocatalytic processes. This indicates the practical significance of these processes. In this work the authors summarize their own studies of photoprocesses on CdS colloids with particles of various size. In these studies, attention was given precisely to photocatalytic reactions on CdS, the photocatalytic reactions on TiOz were considered concurrently with the reported ones. In most cases photocatalytic reactions on semiconductors are the redox reactions. So of special interest was to study the regularities of reactions of interfacial transfer of photoexcited electron by the pulse photolysis and luminescence quenching methods. Many interesting phenomena were found while studying the model photocatalytic reactions by the method of stationary photolysis, i.e., under the conditions of real photocatalysis. The authors hope that results of their studies will be of interest to the experts in both nanotechnologies and photocatalysis. 2.2. Synthesis of CdS Colloids Colloidal solutions of semiconductor particles are of great interest mainly as photocatalysts of various processes. Of special interest are the so-called Q-particles of semiconductors (for CdS with the size 2R c 50 A), some of their properties being considerably different from
36
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
those of bulk semiconductors. However, the lack of simple and reliable methods of reproducible preparation of semiconductor nanoparticles restrains the comprehensive experimental investigation of their physico-chemical properties. Unfortunately, there are no complete and consistent quantitative theories describing the growth of colloidal particles in the preparation process; generally, only semiquantitative concepts are used which assume the size of colloidal particles to depend mainly on the number of their growth sites at the initial moment of the colloid formation. It is well known [ 11 that high supersaturation of the parent solution and restraint of the forming particles growth rate are needed to obtain the highly dispersed difficultly soluble substances. Typically, these conditions are reached via mixing a rather highly concentrated solution of one substance with very diluted solution of another substance, with which the first one forms a difficultly soluble compound. High concentration of the first substance provides high superaturation of the solution and high rate of nuclei formation, while low con-centration of the second substance restrains the growth rate of the formed nuclei. In this chapter we consider the feasibility of easily controlled and reproducible synthesis of CdS colloids. To provide control and restrain the growth rate of the CdS nanoparticles, we used the complex salt of a colloid-forming component (Cd2+)instead of its diluted solution; actually, in this case the rate of colloid growth may be limited by the decay rate of the initial cadmium complex.
2 2 . 1 . Thermodynamic Calculation of Equilibrium Size of CdS Colloidal Particles in the Presence of Cadmium Components Upon the formation of CdS colloids, at the point when the colloidal particles stop their growth and the system reaches the quasiequilibrium state, the total amount of cadmium is distributed over CdS particles and the aqueous phase of the solution, where it appears both as activated Cd2+ion and as the compounds with complexing admixtures. One may assume the thermodynamic equilibrium is reached between the different possible forms of cadmium occurrence. Assuming the presence of only one complexing agent L, which participates in a stepwise complexing, we may describe the above equilibrium by a system of chemical equations:
[ Cd2+ + L
@
CdL2+
K
1
where ti are the chemical variables of the indicated reactions equal to the variation of the initial concentration of the reaction components divided by the stoichiometric coefficient; Ki and SP are the stability constants and solubility product of respective compounds. Note that solubility product of dispersed particle depends on its size [2]:
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
37
where SP, is the solubility product of bulk particle (for CdS at 298 K SP, = 1.6.10-28M2 [3]), CJ is the excessive surface energy (surface tension) at the solution-particle interface, i7 is the partial molar volume of the phase composing the particle (for CdS i7 = 30.1 cm3/mol), R is the particle radius, Rr is the universal gas constant, T is the temperature (hereinafter taken as 298 K). For the case when the cadmium salt, sulfide ion and complexing agent L are the initial compounds for colloid formation, the following set of equations is valid:
where [CdO], [Lo] and [So] are the initial concentrations of the cadmium salt, complexing agent and sulfide anion, N is the concentration of the colloidal particles. The above set of equations may be simplified by some assumptions not changing the equilibrium qualitatively. Indeed, let us assume that the whole complexing process is described by the addition of a single ligand and [LO], [So] >> [CdO]. In this case, the set of equations (2) reduces to a single equation interrelating the particles radius R and the stability constant K1of the complex: 2.a.B ~. .
4 - a
3
x
N a-
e
R3
+ [l + [L]. K,].-.eSP,
5
iiTp
= [CdO]
7
(3)
[SI
where [L] and [SI are the equilibrium concentrations that, under our assumptions, are approximately equal to the initial concentrations [Lo] and [So] of the ligand and sulfide anion. Specifying a reasonable N value and substituting in Eq. (3) the value CJ = 1.09 t 0.24 J/m2 estimated from the data of [4], one may determine by Eq. (3) the equilibrium size of the colloidal particle, which appears to be dependent on the stability constant of the complex. A detailed analysis of this calculation is reported elsewhere 121. The CJ value was estimated as follows. According to the data of [4], the range of solubility product (SPcdS) values was found from the condition of dissolving the cadmium sulfide particles of size 2R = 25 A by the added Na2EDTA and concurrent stability of these particles to alkalization: [CdEDTA]
Kl .[EDTA]
SP,
<-
[SI
< SPWOW2 [0Hl2 '
38
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
where K1 = 5.1016 M-I [9] is the stability constant of cadmium complex with the ethylenediaminetetracetate anion, SPcd(oHp= 2.l0l4 M3 [3] is the solubility product of cadmium hydroxide, [Cd EDTA], [S2-], [OH] and [EDTA] are the equilibrium concentrations of the appropriate reagents. Using the concentration values corresponding to experimental conditions in [4],we obtained 2.10” MZc SPcds < 2.lO-l’ M2. Then, by Eq. (l), the o range was estimated for the calculated SP value: 0.85 c o c 1.32 (J/m2). Note that, in general terms, the estimated o value is nearly an order of magnitude greater than the known typical o values for the aqueous phase - inorganic solid interface. Nevertheless, this experimentally determined value will be used in our further calculations. Unfortunately, the calculation scheme under consideration does not allow an a priori determination of the colloidal particles equilibrium concentration, or the nuclei concentration N, which is controlled most likely by the kinetics of the colloidal particles growth rather than by thermodynamics of the process. Nevertheless, even a simplified calculation scheme shows that (1) thermodynamically stable colloidal particles of the minimum acceptable sizes may form only in the presence of complexing agents characterized by rather low values of the stability constant; (2) in the presence of highly concentrated strong complexing agents, thermodynamically stable are only the colloids with the particle size no less than that specified by the value of the stability constants of substances present in the solution (see Fig. 2.1). So, this allows to answer whether it is possible for colloidal particles of a specified size to exist in the presence of a certain amount of complexing agent with the known stability constant.
Fig. 2.1. The calculated dependence of the upper limit of stability constant K1making possible the existence of CdS particle of radius R. Calculation was made for various CT values at the fixed values of [Lo]= [So] = 5.10” M,[CdO] = 5.104 M.o (J/mz)= 0.2 (1); 0.6(2), 1.1 (3); 2.0(4).
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et a1
39
2.2.2. Method of CdS Preparation Typically, CdS colloids were prepared by the following method. 10 ml of solution with M CdC12, 2-10” M stabilizing surface active substance, and the required amount of complexing admixtures was prepared in a 100 ml vessel at room temperature. 10 ml of 2.lo3 M Na2S was added to the solution under vigorous stirring. The color of the produced colloidal CdS solution depended on.the type and amount of admixtures and varied from yellow to colorless. The produced colloidal solutions were stable, in some cases for more than six months. Fig. 2.2 shows the adsorption spectra of a colloidal CdS solution prepared by the above method in the presence of cadmium complexones of various nature. The position of the colloids adsorption band indicates that the equilibrium size of the colloidal particles decreases as the stability constant of the complex increases. This may relate to the fact that it is precisely the decay rate of the cadmium complex that determines the number of nuclei N and, hence, the size of the forming particles. This is supported by the fact that with the fixed initial (before the addition of the sulfide anion and after the addition of the ligand) concentration of activated Cd2+ (lg[CdL]/[Cd2’]) = const and [Cd’] = const), for complexones of various nature, the sizes of colloidal particles differ: the stronger the initial complex, the smaller the particle size. DI
I
. 1.8
- 1.6 . 1.4 . 1.2 . 1.0 .0.8 .0.6
. 0.4
- 0.2 300
400
Fig. 2.2. Adsorption spectra of colloidal CdS (5.10-4M) obtained at the addition of thioglycerol TG to 10” M solution of CdC12 to provide concentrations: 1) 5.10’ M, 2) 5 1 0 3 M, 3) 2S.10-4 M, 4) 2.5.10” M. Room temperature. [So] = 2.10” M.
In terms of the preparation, some organic sulfur-containing compounds appeared to be the best complexing admixtures allowing to control the size of CdS colloidal particles. Note that the colloids, produced in the presence of sulfur-containing compounds, exhibit a much higher stability compared to those prepared in the presence of ligands which contain no sulfur. It seems interesting that the cadmium sulfide colloids produced by the addition of thioglycerol (see Fig. 2.2) can be dried in air to form solid films capable of further reversible dissolving. In this case, the size of colloidal particles after drying and dissolving remains approximately constant.
40
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
2.3. Reaction of Interfacial Electron Transfer as the First Stage of Redox Photocatalytic Processes 2.3.1. Photobleaching Relaxation of Colloids Shifting the edge of optical adsorption to the ultraviolet region at loading an excess electron on the nanoparticles is a well known manifestation of the quantum size effect in the nanoparticle optical characteristics. This results in shift of the absorption spectrum near the edge of absorption. When the excess electron emerges at the colloidal particle due to its illumination, the effect is called photobleaching. There are several explanations of this effect in literature. Photogenerated auxiliary current carriers in an ultradispersed semiconductor particle generate large local electric fields. In principle, the presence of an electric field inside the ultradispersed semiconductor particle should increase the exciton energy [5], which shifts the absorption band to the ultraviolet region. On the other hand, it was shown in [6] that in the presence of an surface trapped electron-hole pair, the exciton energy shifts to the cuedn region only by ca. 15 meV, with the oscillation strength decreasing by 90% for CdS clusters with 2R = 50 A. The Burstein-Moss model [7, 8, 91 presents the third explanation of shifting the absorption spectrum of ultradisperse semiconductors to the ultraviolet region. According to this model, when an excess electron occupies a lower vacant state in the conduction band, a greater energy is needed for excitation of the next electron to a higher state (band filling). This leads to shifting the band edge of semiconductor adsorption to the ultraviolet region. In this case, a change of optical density AD is taken to be proportional to the concentration of excess electrons n [lo]. However, a more thorough consideration [ l l ] shows that the relation between the observed signal AD and the electrons amount n may be more complicated and vary with experimental conditions. Indeed, in a general case, the amplitude of the observed signal is determined by the dependence of the level densities on the level energies, by the dependence of the semiconductor absorption coefficient on the light wavelength (or frequency), by the number of trapped electrons. The conventional relationships applied to the CdS absorption properties are as follows:
p ( E ) = B(E - E,
y2
I
where a is the absorption coefficient at frequency o,oh is the threshold frequency, p(E) is the density of the energy level in the conduction band, E is the level energy, E, is the energy of the conduction band bottom. According to [7], a change in oh caused by the electron trapping in concentration n comprises
Here y is a coefficient which depends on the effective electron mass in the conduction band.
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et a1.
41
By the above equations one may readily find a relation between the concentration n of the excess electrons and the change in the sample absorption which reflects the variation of a at the oh changing: n-
In our case, the measurements were done mainly at the colloid adsorption edge. In this region, for CdS it seems more correctly to approximate a(o)by a linear function
and thus Aa- A ' . y . nu3- PAD, n
- AD)^^ .
(2.6)
Relation (2.6) corresponds to the case when the shape of the absorption spectrum near the bandedge is determined by the presence of size distribution in the region of variation bandgap with varying particle size. In this case, relation (2.3) may be taken as valid. This is true for the case when the long wavelength bandedge of absorption is caused by a wide distribution of particle sizes. If the a(o)dependence in the region of absorption edge is caused by dope absorption, a relation between AD and n may be more complicated since the function p(E) for the doped levels will differ from (2.2), and relation between AD and n will differ from (2.4) and (2.6). In our opinion, in a general case, the question for relation between the AD and n can be solved only via direct experiment. For this purpose, we studied concurrently two series of samples with the same CdS colloid solutions, 2R = 10 nm, stabilized by PAA an L-c steine, as an electron donor. The first series of samples contained methylviologen MV" as an electron acceptor, the second one contained no MV''. All the samples in these experiments were saturated by the argon to remove dissolved oxygen. The number of trapped and then transfered to methylviologen electrons was identified with the amount of reduced methylviologen. Fig. 2.3 presents a correlation between the electron concentration in the sample and the absorption change just after a flash, with the flash energy being varied. It follows from this correlation that n (AD)x,where x 0.8. Note, that it will be shown below any of x value in the range of 0.8-1.5 makes practically no changes in the shape of the kinetic curves and in the resulting conclusions. Fig. 2.4 shows the typical kinetic curves of the electron concentration in the samples calculated at x = 1.5. Here one may see initial (immediately after the flash) changes of optical density ADo of the samples of 1=1 cm thickness. Fig. 2.5 shows the same kinetic curves (dots) for the sample with 2R-10 nm obtained at a higher flash energy (ADo (1 = 1 cm) 0.057) and calculated for = 0.8 and x = 1.5. The kinetic curves exhibit fast decay at the initial part and very long cctailw after that. Figs. 2.6 and 2.7 present the relative rate W of electron concentration decay vs. the relative concentration of electrons in the sample calculated at different x values for the kinetic curves from Fig. 2.4. For CdS colloid with 2R 10 nm, the dependence of W on n is fitted by a function:
-
-
-
x
-
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
42
W- n regardless of
. ,S.
x, where q is an experimental constant. I
Fig. 2.3. Correlation between the electron concentration n in the sample and the absorption change just after a flash AD. The n was calculated fromparallel experiments using MV=5. 10-3M as electron acceptor. The nf and ADf is the electron concentration and differential absorption at maximum energy of pump light. The pump light is at h<400nm using glass cut-off filter UFS-6, intensity of pumps is varied. 2R-lOnm, [CdS] = 2.5. lo4 M, [L-cys] = 2.5.10-* M, [PAA] = M, pH=6. Cell length 1 is 1 sm. T = 2OoC.
In the CdS colloid with 2R c 5 nm, the rate at the initial part of the kinetic deviates from relation of type (2.7), however, at n/no c 0.4 ( x = 1.5)or n/no c 0.7 (x = 0.8), the electron concentration dependence of the rate is also fitted by an equation similar to (2.7). Fig. 2.8 shows the same dependencies for the kinetic curve from Fig. 2.5 calculated for x = 0.8. In this case,
w
I
fj. @'' n .
(2.8)
where 0, q' are experimental constants. The following equation of kinetic curve corresponds to relation of type (2.8):
n -=1--.
1
ln(1 + q'Wot) = 1- A.ln(l t Bet),
q'n,
n0
0 0
where Wo = p * e
.
In Fig. 2.5 the solid lines show the time dependence of n/no calculated by Eq. (2.9) with optimized coefficients A and B. These data indicate also that the x values are noncritical for the functional form of the kinetic curves described by equations of (2.7) and (2.8) type.
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
in I,"
43
L
I
aD'=2, 6.10" I
1.0
-
20
1,o
L
A
GO
00
loo
120(JJSl
2
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
20
2.4(mS
-
Fig. 2.4. Kinetic curves of electron transfer reaction for CdS colloid (1) - 2R 5nm, hobs = 450nm (2) - 2R IOnm, kobs = 470nm. [CdS] = 2.5. lo4 M, [L-cys] = 2.5.10-2 M, [PAA] = M, [O,] 10-4MpH 6. Cell length 1 is 1 sm. T = 2OoC. hex< 400nm
-
-
I
0.5
1.0
1.5
tlm/S)
-
Fig. 2.5. Kinetic curves of the interfacial electron transfer reaction from CdS 2R 10nm. The electron concentration was calculated using formula n = ADx,o - = 0.8, - x = 1.5.hobs = 470 nm. [CdS] = 2.5. lo4 M, [L-cys] = 2.5.10-'M, [PAA] = M, [02] 10-4M pH 6. Cell length 1 is 1 cm. T = 2OoC. hex<400 nm. Dots are the experimental data. Line is a fit by formula (2.9)
x
-
Note that kinetic curves obtained for the same colloid with 2R 10 nm, presented in Figs. 2.4 and 2.5, were recorded at varying the flash energy and accordingly ADO.The ADO difference exceeding an order of magnitude corresponds approximately to a similar change of the electron concentration in the sample. For the kinetic curves in Fig. 4, the electron
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
44
-
Fig. 2.6. The rate of the interfacial electron transfer reaction from CdS 2R 10 nm. as a function (1) - 2R of the electron concentration, which was calculated using formula n = 5nm, hob$= 450 nm, (2) - 2R 10 nm, hobs= 470 nm. [CdS] = 2.5. lo4 M, [L-cys] = 2.510M, [O,] lo4 M pH 6. Cell length 1 is 1 cm. T = 2OOC. hex< 400 nm M, [PAA] =
-
-
'
7 6
2 1
0.2
0.4
0.6 nlno
0.8
-
Fig. 2.7. The rate of the interfacial electron transfer reaction from CdS 2R 10 nm. as a function of the electron concentration, which was calculated using formula n = ADo.*.(1) - 2R 5 nm, hobs= 450 nm, (2) - 2R 10 nm, hobs= 470 nm. [CdS] = 2.5. lo4 M, [L-cys] = 2.5-10-* M, [O,] 104M pH 6. Cell length 1 is 1 cm. T = 2OoC.hex<400 nm M, [PAA] =
-
-
-
concentrations measured with MV2+appeared to be 2.6.10" M and 5.10-7M in the CdS colloids with 2R < 5 nm and 2R 10 nm respectively. According to these data, 27 excessive electrons are photoexcited per one CdS nanoparticle with 2R 10 nm, which provides the volume and surface concentrations of electrons in the particle 5.4-1019cm-3 and 8.7.10" cmS. In the colloids with 2R < 5 nm, the respective values are: 13.5 per the ~, cm-'. particle and 2.5.10m~ m - 2.1.10'3
-
-
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et al.
45
5
-5 -4 -3
4
z3
5:!
-2 -1 -0 - -1
31 0 -1
02
0.4
9.6 n/no
0.8
5
1.0
-
Fig. 2.8. The rate of the interfacial electron transfer reaction from CdS 2R 10 nm. as a function of the electron concentration,which was calculated using formula n = ADo,’. 2R lOnm, hobs = 470 nm. [CdS] = 2.5. lo4 M, [L-cys] = 2.5.10-* M, [PAA] = M, [O,] 104M pH 6. Cell length 1 is 1 cm. T = 2OoC.he,<400 nm
-
-
2.3.2.Physical Causes Resulting in the Observable Kinetic Peculiarities of Photobleaching Relaxation The main reason of appearance of exponential multiplier eqnin Eqs. (2.7) and (2.8) for the rate of interfacial electron transfer from semiconductor particles to dissolved oxygen molecules or protons seems to the electric charge of these electrons. This causes considerable changes in the potential of the nanoparticles double layer, which, in turn, affects directly the rate of electron transfer [12-151. Actually, in a semiconductor particle with 2R-10 nm, 27 excess electrons would cause the following change of the double layer potential (Acp): Acp 27e/Cl 700-70 mV ,where c1 is the electric capacity of the particle double layer (c1 = cgc- S = (6-30)-IO-’’ F, where cgc- (2-20). IO4 F/cm’ are the typical values of the double layer capacity, S 3.10-” cm’ is the overall surface area of a particle). In the CdS nanoparticles with 2R < 5 nm, the change of the double layer potential can be even greater, according to the similar estimation. Remind, that kT at room temperature is only 25 mV. So, a several hundred millivolt variation in Acp can change the rate constant of the interfacial electron transfer by several orders of magnitude, since Acp directly enters the apparent activation energy of the reaction. It seems rather difficult to explain the appearance or disappearance of the electron concentration before exponent in expressions for reaction rate (2.7) and (2.8). As noted above, the reaction rate is directly proportional to the electron concentration (2.7) at low initial electron concentrations. At higher concentrations, the direct proportionality between the reaction rate and electron concentration disappears, and the reaction rate is described by Eq. (2.8). In the colloid with 2R e 5 nm (Figs. 2.6 and 2.7), at the starting part of the kinetic, the reaction rate depends on n more weakly than it is predicted by Eq. (2.7), while at n/no 0.5 it approaches the dependence similar to (2.7). Such switching occurs at the surface electron concentration cm-’. Note, for the colloid with 2R 10 nm, the initial surface electron concentration of 8.7.10’’ cm-’ < 1013cm-’ corresponds to the kinetic curve in Fig. 2.4, while n > l O I 3 cm-’ for all points of the kinetic curves presented in Figs. 2.5 and 2.8, since no 9.1013 cm-’.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
46
The switching between dependencies (2.7) and (2.8) at the surface electron concentration ca. l O I 3 cm-’ may be explained as follows. According to the interpretation of the mass action law, the total probability of two particles A and B to enter the surface reaction is the product of the probability of particle B to appear in the reaction space S* around particle A, which equals CB.S* (where CBis the surface concentration of particles B), and the probability of this pair to react for time period t - P(t) [16]: P(t).C,
*s* *
(2.10)
At CB.S* > 1, the concentration of particles B is so high that particle B locates in the reaction space around particle A with probability ca. 1. At such large values of B concentration (CB> 1/S*), the reaction rate becomes independent of the B concentration. In our case, electrons play the role of particles B, while molecules of oxygen, protons or other added electron acceptor play the role of particles A. The absence of linear dependence of the reaction rate on the electron concentration (Eq. (2.8)) implies that for the O2 molecule or H+ ions located at any point of the nanoparticle surface, at the distance of electron transfer there are one or more excess electrons trapped by the surface. As noted above, the switching from dependence (2.7) to (2.8) occurs at n l O I 3 ern-', which corresponds to the cm2 reaction surface of the reaction between electron and electron acceptor. For this case the distance of electron transfer is 1.7 nm. The assumption on the electric charge effect of excess electrons on the rate constant of their interfacial transfer is supported by an evident similarity of these semiconductor colloidal systems with metal colloids, for which effect of the <> of electrons captured by the particle is well known and agrees with the <microelectrode theory,,. Moreover, lunetic curves similar to those we found for CdS colloids were observed previously for silver colloids in ref. [17], where the particles charge q was shown to decrease by the law
-
-
The formal bulk concentrations of electrons captured by CdS particles -lo2’ cm1.3are close to the electron concentration in a metal. In this case, the semiconductor degradation or its metallization is implied [7]. In [18], we generated such excess electrons in a semiconductor colloidal CdS nanoparticles coated with thioglycerol by a short (- 5 ps) flash of light. In this case, photogenerated holes were rapidly (for the time less than the resolution of our devices) transferred to thioglycerol molecules. Fig. 2.9 shows the photobleaching spectra of colloidal CdS prepared in an excess of the cadmium ions with the particles of variable size. Photobleaching spectra were obtained by approximation of kinetic curves to the zero time point. One can see that as the CdS particles decrease in size, the photobleaching spectrum of colloidal CdS shifts to the short wavelength region. This is because the location of the maximum of the semiconductor photobleaching spectrum corresponds rather accurately to the location of the edge of semiconductor colloid absorption. Due to the quantum size effect, the edge of the nanocolloid adsorption shifts to the ultraviolet region as the nanoparticle size decreases; thus, the photobleaching spectra are expected to behave in a similar manner.
47
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et al.
400
420
440
460
460
500
520
540
Wavelength, nm
Fig. 2.9. Photobleaching spectra of a CdS colloid obtained in the excess of Cd2*ions with the particles of various sizes at the zero time point. [CdS] = lo4 M, [SDS] = 2.10-3 M, [TG] = 5.10-3M. Illumination at h < 360 nm (UFS-l), Cell length 1 is 10 cm, T = 2OoC.
1E-4
i 100
1000
10000
T ime, )IS
Fig. 2.10. Photobleaching relaxation kinetic curves at the bandedge of absorption spectrum of a CdS colloid obtained in the excess of CdZ+ions with the particles of various sizes. [CdS] = lo4 M, [DCH] = 2.10-3 M, [TG] = 5.10-3 M. Illumination at h < 360 nm (UFS-l),Cell length 1 is 10 cm, T = 2OoC.
48
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
The rate of the photobleaching relaxation of ultradispersed CdS, and hence the rate of the electron interfacial transfer from CdS to the surrounded media (finally, to protons yielding the hydrogen) appeared to depend on the size of the colloidal particles (see Fig. 2.10). The photobleaching relaxation rate increases as the size of the CdS semiconductor particles decreases. Such behavior may be caused by the increasing of reductive potential of photoexcited electron with decreasing size of semiconductor nanocolloids. In this case, according to the modern concepts of electron interfacial transfer reaction [19], the rate of electron transfer to the surrounded media should increase. 2.3.3. Effect of the CdS Adsorption Properties on the Kinetics of its Photo-bleaching Relaxation in the Presence of Various Electron Acceptors
To study the regularities of photoexcited electron relaxation in the reaction of the electron transfer by the method of flash photolysis in microsecond timescale, we had to change the electron acceptor concentration in a liquid phase. The ability of the acceptor molecules to adsorb at the surface of the semiconductor colloidal particle was found to determine the character of changes in the photobleaching relaxation kinetic curves.
0.01
0.00
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
Time, ps
Fig. 2.11. Photobleaching relaxation kinetic curves of colloidal CdS with excess of Cd2+ions at 470 nm wavelength after the addition of MV and PW12.The concentration of the added M; PW12:0,4.10-', 8.10-', acceptor along the arrows: MV: 0, 2.10-', 5.10-', 8.10-', 3.10-7M. [CdS] = lo4 M, [SDS] = 2.10-3 M, [TG] = 5.10-3M. Illumination at A c 360 nm (UFS-l), Cell length 1 is 10 cm., T = 2OoC.
Fig. 2.11 shows the photobleaching relaxation kinetic curves of colloidal CdS obtained in an excess of the cadmium ions (the positive surface charge of the colloid) at adding of two different electron acceptors. One may see that the addition of negatively
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
49
charged ions of PWlz phosphotungstic acid, which are well adsorbed on such colloids, results in a decrease of the initial degree of bleaching, with no changes in the photobleaching relaxation rate and the shape of the kinetic dependence. Such behavior may be explained by complete adsorption of the added PWlzat the surface of the CdS nanoparticles and its fast reduction (for the time less than the resolution of our equipment); the observed kinetics of the photobleaching relaxation is determined by the transfer of remaining electrons to oxygen or protons in surrounded media. The addition of positively charged methylviologen ions, which are poorly adsorbed on the colloid under consideration, changes the kinetic dependence of the photobleaching relaxation. The kinetic curves obtained do not obey the logarithmic law (Eq. (2.9)), and are expressed by an exponential dependence on time, (2.1 1) where kffis an effective rate constant of the photobleaching relaxation, and AD0 is photobleaching at the zero time point. In this case, bffincreaseslinearly with increasing the concentration of the added methylviologen (see Fig. 2.12). This evidences that the electron transfer to the molecules of added nonadsorbed methylviologen MV is limited by the diffusion of its molecules to the surface of colloidal CdS (at the experimental concentration of MV).
2,oxiO' 4 , o ~ i o " ~ , O X I O - ' 8 , o ~ i o " i , o ~ 1 0 " MV"
Fig. 2.12. The apparent rate constant of the interfacial electron transfer from the CdS particles prepared with the excess of Cd** ions as a function of the methyl-viologen concentration. M, [SDS] = 2 ~ l O M, - ~ [TG] = 5.10-3M. Illumination at h c 360 nm (UFS-l), [CdS] = Cell length 1 is 10 cm., T = 2OoC.
A kinetic study on the photobleaching relaxation at the addition of PWlz and MV to colloidal CdS prepared in an excess of the sulfide ions, when the colloidal particles have the negatively charged surface, shows the opposite results as compared to those obtained
50
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
for colloidal CdS prepared with the cadmium ions excess. Thus, the addition of methylviologen cations leads to a decrease in the initial degree of the colloidal CdS photobleaching, while the rate constant of the photobleaching relaxation does not change. However, the addition of PWlz anions up to a certain concentration causes no changes in the kinetics of photobleaching relaxation of colloidal CdS produced in the excess of sulfide ions. After the addition of a certain amount of PWlZrcolloid photobleaching disappears sharply. This seems to be the result of the effect of ccrecharging,, the surface of colloidal CdS, which is discussed below. Indeed, the negatively charged PWlz ions don't adsorb at the CdS surface rich in the sulfide ions. However, addition of PWlz may change pH of the solution and stimulate the adsorption of H+ ions at the surface of CdS particle, changing its charge. Changing of CdS surface charge would result in the adsorption of phosphotungstic acid and a rapid (for the time less than the resolution of our devices) transfer of photoexcited electrons to the PWlz anions. This leads to the fast decay of the ultradispersed CdS photobleaching.
-0,Ol 0'0°
F9t A
-0302
-0,03 0,oo
-0,Ol
a -0,02 -0,03 200
400
600
o'ooll
-0,Ol
-0,02
I
I
I
200
400
600
Time, ps Fig. 2.13. Photobleaching relaxation kinetic curves of colloidal CdS with an excess of CdZ+ions at various temperatures and at the addition of various electron acceptors: a) without acceptors; b) MV, lod M; c) PW12, 3.104 M. The temperature variation along the arrows: 20, 30,40, 50,60,and 70OC. [CdS] = lo4 M, [SDS] = 2.10-3M, [TG]= lo-' M.
To verify the effect of the ions adsorption on the regularities of photoexcitation relaxation, we studied the temperature effect on the kinetics of the ultradispersed CdS photobleaching relaxation at the addition of electron acceptors of various nature. Fig. 2.13 presents the kinetic curves of the colloidal CdS photobleaching relaxation prepared with an excess of cadmium ions at different temperatures and at the addition of different
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et al.
51
electron acceptors (MV and PW12). One may see that without the addition of electron acceptors the temperature variation causes no changes in the photobleaching relaxation kinetics, while at the addition of both acceptors increasing temperature increases the rate of photobleaching relaxation. Two factors seem to determine such behavior. First, elevating the temperature may increase the rate constant of electron transfer to the acceptor. Second, at elevating the temperature, the amount of adsorbed thioglycerol may decrease faster than that of the adsorbed acceptor, which increases the fraction of the CdS surface occupied by the acceptor. Unfortunately, the actual value of the changes observed at temperature elevation is negligible compared to experimental errors, which makes difficult a quantitative analysis of the temperature effect on the kinetics of the photobleaching relaxation.
2.4. Luminescence Quenching of the CdS Colloids Studies on luminescence of CdS colloids provide useful knowledge on the energy and nature of recombination sites of charge carriers in the colloidal particles. The regularities of the colloid photoluminescence quenching provide the information on the dynamics of electrons and holes in semiconductor particles as well as on the kinetics of interfacial electron transfer. Of a particular interest are studies on the luminescence of colloidal solutions of the so-called Q-semiconductors, their properties depending on the size of semiconductor particles due to the quantum size effects. One may expect a very pronounced effect of the surface properties of semiconductor particle on its luminescence peculiarities. This relates to the fact that in semiconductor nanoparticles, the sites of trapping the current carriers locate mainly at the surface. In addition, a very high ratio of the particle surface area to its volume is typical for nanoparticles. In other words, in such particles, a considerable fraction of atoms locates at the surface. E.g., the 20 8, CdS particles contain ca. 170 sulfur and cadmium atoms, 110 of them (67%) locating at the surface. In this connection, the luminescence properties of such particles are to be strongly depending on the nature and contents of adsorbates and on the structure and composition of the particle surface. This could explain numerous contradictions in the literature on luminescence properties of ultradispersed semiconductors. Actually, the composition and the state of the semiconductor nanocolloid surface depend strongly on the particle prehistory: like the preparation method and the way of various admixtures adding during the particle synthesis. Luminescence measurements performed by various authors use the semiconductors prepared by various methods. Nevertheless, some regularities in the semiconductor colloid luminescence are common for all authors. In semiconductor nanoparticles, the luminescence spectrum shifts to the ultraviolet region as the particle size decreases. This phenomenon is a manifestation of the quantum size effect in the nanoparticles luminescence properties. That is, with decreasing the size of nanocolloids, an energy increase is observed not only between the bottom of conductivity band and the top of valence band, but also between various sites of radiative recombination of trapped carriers. This effect was observed with the following semiconductor nanocolloids: CdS [20], CdSe [21], Cd3As2 [22], InP [23], and ZnO 1243. Generally, several luminescence bands are distinguished in the spectra of semiconductor nanocolloids. First, comparatively narrow luminescences band with the energy of several meV less than the band gap [25,26]. This band is commonly observed at low temperatures.
52
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
Such short wavelength luminescence of ultradispersed semiconductors is usually assigned to the radiative recombination of delocalized exciton [27, 281 or free (not captured) electrons and holes. The short wavelength band has been studied most thoroughly on isolated nanocrystals at low temperatures (ca. 20 K) in ref. [29]. It was shown that, without the broadening produced by a distribution in particles size, this short wavelength band is split into the quartet of bands. The main band (with the highest intensity), two IOWfrequency satellites (the main one and the first harmonic component from longitudinal optical phonons), and a satellite in the high-energy range (biexciton). The properties of these luminescence bands depend only slightly on the characteristics of the colloidal particle surface. Studies on the luminescence of ultradispersed semiconductors at room temperature in various media (solutions, matrices, films) reveal a group of broad long wavelength luminescence bands which are commonly assigned to radiative recombination of the photoexcited charge carriers captured at deep traps [30, 311. The nature of these recombination sites is still unclear. For example, numerous hypotheses concerning CdS are reported in the literature [32]: cadmium vacancy, sulfur vacancy, interstitial cadmium, interstitial sulfur. The only item in explanation of the nature of these long wavelength luminescence bands all the authors agree on is that the sites of radiative recombination of photoexcited charge carriers locate at the surface of colloidal particle [33]. This chapter presents results of the studies on photoluminescence spectra of CdS Q-colloids in the size range of 2R = 20-100 8,as well as on the luminescence quenching of Q-CdS by various quenchers under variation of the colloidal particle sizes. 2.4. I . Regularities of Luminescence Quenching of Colloidal CdS Particles
In most cases, quenching of luminescence of CdS colloids is determined by the reactions of interfacial electron transfer involving either electron or hole. So, study of this process is a convenient method for establishing the regularities of key steps of redox photocatalytic reactions over CdS. In addition, using of various luminescence quenchers (anions, cations, and neutral molecules) allows to reveal the nature of electron capture sites at the CdS surface. Analysis of the dependencies of CdS colloidal solutions luminescence spectra (with varying particle size) on the methylviologen concentration (Fig. 2.14) allows to conclude that the efficiency of luminescence quenching raises with increasing wavelength and particle size. For a quantitative interpretation of the results obtained, let us consider the processes that may occur with excited electron in a colloidal semiconductor particle under stationary illumination. First process is the bulk recombination of nonequilibrium charge carriers (radiative and nonradiative). Since in our experiments the luminescence is quenched completely, one may assume that a fraction of radiative recombination in the particle volume is negligible. Thus, we may take into account only the nonradiative recombination in the bulk proceeding with the rate kb,n*V*e.h, where kb,nis the rate constant of nonradiative recombination in the bulk, V is the volume of colloidal particle, e and h are the stationary concentrations of electrons and holes in colloidal particle. Note also that, according to [34], it seems reasonable to assume the constant concentration of electrons and holes inside the particle along the radius under stationary illumination for the particles of the size order of several hundred angstroms.
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
I.
53
3,008
1 " " " '
0,025
2.006
3,004
3.002
1.000 1.0012
).OW9
LOW6
).OW3
4 b
5 b
6 b
7b
&
).OMx) 6b
760
Wmdengttr, nm
Fig. 2.14. Luminescence spectra of the Q-CdS colloidal solutions with 2R = 20 A, hexc=345 nm (a), 2R = 23 A, he, = 375 nm (b), 2R = 34 A, he,, = 380 nm (c), 2R = 44 A, he, = 400 nm (d) after the addition of the methylviologen. The concentrations of the added MV along the arrows: a) 0, lo", 5.10", lo4, 2.104, 5.104, 2.10-3 M; b) 0, 5.10-7, lo", 2.10", 5.10-6, lo-', 2.10-7, 5.10-', lo4, 2.10", 2.lO-', 4.10-', 8.10-', 1.5.104, 2.104, 3.104, 4.104 M; c) 0, 2.10-7, 5.10-7, lo", 5.10" M. [CdS] = 5.104 M, T = 23°C. 5.10", lo-' M; d) 0,
Another way of disappearance of nonequilibrium charge carriers is their recombination at the particle surface (radiative with the rate constant k,,r,and nonradiative Of basic importance is the question of whether the surface with the rate constant k,,,-,). recombination sites are the sites of the quencher adsorption. In other words, is the quencher adsorption able to result in disappearance of the surface recombination sites. With positive answer, the expression for the surface recombination rate should be written as (ks,T+ k,,,).S.(l - O,).e.h, where S is the particle surface area, and 0,is the surface fraction occupied by the quencher (electron acceptor). Otherwise, the latter multiplier (1 - 0,) should be excluded. Further we will consider the both cases (1 and 2), compare them with experimental data and choose the case providing a better description of the phenomena observed. The third way of the nonequilibrium electron disappearance is their transfer to the quencher molecules. The expression for the rate of quenching could be written as (b,Red&O,-e + b,[email protected]),where kQ,Redand kQ,oxare the heterogeneous rate constants of
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
54
electron transfer to acceptor and hole transfer to electron donor, respectively; @d is the surface fraction occupied by the electron donor. Under stationary illumination, the rate of appearance of nonequilibrium charge carriers is equal to the rate of their disappearance. Thus, for case 1, the following equation holds true: (2.12) while for case 2 (2.13) Here, R is the particle radius, is the intensity of the incident radiation, a is the light absorption coefficient of the CdS particle. In addition, under stationary conditions, the rate of the electron disappearance is equal to the rate of the hole disappearance: kQ,Red
- 0, e = kQ,ox' 0 , h . *
(2.14)
Equation (2.14) allows to exclude the hole concentration h from Eqs. (2.12) and (2.13).The resulting square equations are solved with respect to the electron concentration e. Therewith, for case 1 we obtain: a'
I+-+ e=
b'(1-0,)
0,
-1
0, 9
(a'+b'.(l- 0,)) * kQ,Red
For case 2 it holds true
e=
/+:-
1
, where
a ' kQ,Red
Using the approach similar to the deduction of the Stern-Folmer's equation 1351, one may easily show that quantum yield CP of the luminescence under stationary regime for case 1 may be expressed as
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
55
(2.15)
while for case 2, as
(2.16) where 0 ' is the quantum yield of the luminescence with no quencher addition. Dependence of 0,on the quencher concentration in a solution may be determined, to a first approximation, by the Langmuir adsorption isotherm: 0, =
A .K , * C, l+K,.N, '
(2.17)
where CQ is the concentration of a quencher in the solution, Kads is the adsorption equilibrium constant of a quencher at the CdS surface. An approximation of the experimental data by the expressions obtained by substitution of Eq.(2.17) into Eqs. (2.15) and (2.16) are presented in Fig. 2.15.
5 -
4 -
Y
3 -
4 .
0 .
e
2 -
1 -
00
1
2
3
4
5
Concentration of MV, IO' M
Fig. 2.15. The Stern-Folmer's presentation of the dependence of the luminescence quantum yields of the Q-CdS colloidal solutions with 2R = 23 A on the methylviologen concentration at h,, = 440 nm. Dots are the experimental data, curve (a) is fitted by Eq. (2.15) with a' = 0.11 1, b' = 2.973, Kads= lo5;curve 0) is fitted by Eq. (2.16) with a' = 0.111, Kads= 3 . 6 2 ~ 1 0curve ~ ; (c) is fitted by Eq.(19) with a' = 6.36, Kads= 6.07.103.The CdS concentration is 5104 M, T = 23OC.
One may see that within the limits of experimental error, the both expressions describe adequately the quencher concentration dependencies of the luminescence quantum yields.
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
56
However, the expressions derived from Eqs. (2.15) and (2.16) are rather cumbersome, inconvenient for experimental application, and low informative. So further we use a simplified expression to describe the concentration dependencies of the luminescence derived from expressions (2.12) and (2.13) under the assumption that the recombination rates are linear in the current carriers concentration, Le., the addends kb,n*h. e and (ksr,r+ksr,n). h. e are substituted by kb,,’. e and (ksr,r’+k,,,,’). e, respectively. Linear recombination in the current concentration does often occur at a minor level of generation of the carriers, when recombination rate is limited by the rate of capturing one of nonequilibrium carriers by recombination site [7]. The appropriate expressions are as follows. For case 1: R
cpo --
cp
kQp e d + kb,n 1=
’
7
R kbrn * - + ck$-,r -t k$-,n 1
(2.18) ’K adsaCQ
For case 2:
One may see that in Eq. (2.18) @‘/adepends linearly on the concentration of the quencher, which is inconsistent with the experiment (see Fig. 2.15). Therefore, in further description of experimental data we use Eq. (2.19), which corresponds to the case when the recombination sites are not identical to the adsorption sites. In this case, A and Kadsare the varied <
57
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et al.
8
I
.
1
.
I
.
I
.
1
4
,
n
A
K
.5. '
5,
- 14
4
7 ,
A
A K
tmd420nm 74763 t 02848 58506 t 3934 tmd480nm 1 0 1 8 6 t 1180 51060 f 9994
.
n
A
,
K A
'
1- 1 '
A K
tmd440nm 63.514 t 06128 60664 t 1345 !xnd500nm 22323t1357 31484 t 3069
A
.
- 12 - IO
7
e e
0 .
4 -
1 P
3-
I
2-
B
1 -
0:
-8
I-:
-6
A 0
a
:: 1 : ip A
.
-4
- a n
12
-2
-0
7
tmd560nrn
10 A
8
bndMOnm
I
1 14E5 t 4214E4
7
i
0 .
e
6
4
J
T
2
0
Concentration of MV, M Fig. 2.16. The Stern-Folmer's presentation of the dependence of the luminescence quantum yields of the Q-CdS colloidal solutions with the particles of different size on the methylviologen concentration. The size of the particles: a) 2R t: 20 A, b) 2R -- 23 A, c) 2R = 44 A. The CdS concentration is 5.104 M, T = 23'C. Dimensionality of Kadsis M-'.
Indeed, the greater the deepness of recombination site energy level, the less the difference in the energies of the given level and the quencher molecule level, hence, under the assumption of activation electron transfer occurring in the inverted region, the lower the activation energy of such transfer. However the dependence of the parameter A on the deepness of the energy of the trapped carriers could be related with the dependence of the surface recombination constants (k,,, + k,,,) on the deepness of recombination sites. According to the ref. [39] the radiative lifetime of trapped carriers is longer for the deeper traps. This could be interpreted as tunneling recombination of trapped carriers [40].The deep electron trap is the electron trap with a large distance to the nearest occupied hole trap (due to the Coulomb interaction) and the shallow trap is the electron trap with small
58
Next Page
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions 2K,A5 0 4 5 40
35
30
25
20
14
12
10
8
6
0,02
0,04
0,03
~
0,o
1/2R,A-'
Fig. 2.17. The calculated constant Kadsof methylviologen adsorption on the CdS colloids vs. the size of the colloidal particles. The Kadsvalue is obtained by approximation of experimental data on the luminescence quenching to Eq.(2.19). Dimensionality of Kadsis M-'.
- 3
- 2
- 1
/
-0- 2R = 20A -0- 2R 23A E
-A- 2R -V-
2R = 44A
- -1
V
0,2
0,4
-0
= 34A
0,6
0,8
1,0
1,2
The deepness of the trapped carriers, eV
Fig. 18. The parameter A as a function of the deepness (in energetic scale) of the level of
w.
recombination sites for CdS particles. Parameter A is calculated from (2.19).A is proportional to the ratio between the rate of interfacial electron transfer to the rate of trapped carriers recombination. The location of energy level of recombination site is measured from the bottom of conductivity band.
Previous Page
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
59
distance to the nearest occupied hole trap. The tunneling motion to the larger distance requires longer time. Note that this reasoning on the dependence of parameter A on the location depth of the recombination site has only a qualitative character. The actual samples of CdS have always a particle size distribution. Both the quencher adsorption constant and the luminescence emission spectrum depend on the particle size. This introduces a certain error into the A value obtained from fitting by the Eq. (2.19). The error should be particularly great for the ‘deep’ and ‘shallow’ energy levels of the surface recombination site. 2.4.2. Effect of Surface Properties of Ultradispersed CdS on Regularities of Luminescence Quenching
Note that there are alternative considerations of luminescence quenching not taking into account the adsorption of quencher molecules on the surface of nanoparticles [41, 421. They evaluate nonlinear equations, which are the same to equation (2.19). However below we show that in aqueous solutions it is necessary include the surface properties of CdS and adsorption of electron acceptor molecules. As noted in the previous section, the adsorption constant of the quencher molecules at the surface of a luminescent colloidal particle explicitly enters the expression for the luminescence quenching. Therefore, the adsorption-desorption equilibriums established in a colloidal solution should have a considerable effect on the regularities of the luminescence quenching and, hence, on the regularities of interfacial electron transfer. 2.4.2.a. Luminescence Quenching of Colloidal CdS by Quenchers of Various Nature
Methylviologen is a bication and thus it is well adsorbed at the surface of negatively charged particles. Now consider the regularities of the luminescence quenching by other kinds of electron acceptors, anions, exemplified by heteropolyacids. At the addition of phosphotungstic acid PW12to colloidal CdS, a step dependence of the luminescence intensity on the amount of introduced PW12 is observed: up to the PW12 concentration 2.10-4M, the luminescence intensity is practically constant and drops sharply as the concentration increases up to 4.104 M (Fig. 2.19a). Therewith, the pH values change approximately from 9 to 6. However, when H2S04 is being added gradually to the colloid with Z104 M PW12 (Fig. 2.19b), the relative intensity of luminescence also decreases with the same changes in pH of the solution. This result may be explained by
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
60
4 400
500
600
700
800
4&3
660
i
Wavelength, n m
Fig. 2.19. Changes in the luminescence spectrum of Q-CdS colloidal solutions under the addition of PWI2. (a) Successive addition to give the concentrations: 2-10-5,lo4, 2.104, 4.104 M; (b) successive addition of PW12to the point of 2.104 M, followed by the addition of H2SO4 to give 2.5.104, 5.104, 7.5.104 M. CdS concentration is 5104 M, A,,, = 350 nm, T = 23'C.
effect of the electron acceptor adsorption on the rate of photocatalytic redox processes over semiconductor colloids. We carried out a series of experiments on the luminescence quenching of colloidal CdS by quenchers of different nature (see Table 2.1). Table 2.1. Adsorption constants Kadsfor quenchers of various nature and parameters of electron transfer A obtained from FQ.(2.19).In the experiment, [CdS] = 5.104 M, 2R = 23 A, T = 23'C, A,, = 360 nm, A,,,, = 500 nm Quencher
Kads
(M-')
A
65 f 60
15 f 12
8200 f 6900
0.15 f 0.02
1200 f 300
11 f 2
2000 f 500
8.5 f 1.3
23 f 250
0.35 f 3
One may see that cations (MV2+,BV2+)are characterized by high values of both the adsorption constant and the rate of the luminescence quenching, while anions (K3[Cr(SCN),]) are characterized by a low value of the adsorption constant and a high
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
61
value of parameter A. The substances which are inactive in the reactions of electron transfer (Et4NCl and Pyr), possess low values of parameter A. PWlzhas low values A.Kad,
To prove the above statement on the determining effect of electric charge of both the CdS colloidal particle surface and the quencher molecule on the adsorption of these molecules from aqueous solution, we have modified the surface of colloidal CdS during its preparation. The most efficient method of such modification consists in changing the surface charge of the colloidal particle via the preparation of nonstoichiometric colloid. In this case, the surface charge is determined by the charge of excessive ion (either S-' or Cd"). The experimental values of adsorption constant Kadsfor the quencher molecule at the surface of ultradispersed colloidal CdS prepared by two different methods as well as the values of the electron transfer parameter A are listed in Table 2.2. One may see that the efficient luminescence quenching occurs only when the surface of the colloidal particle and the quencher molecule have opposite charges. If the charges of the colloidal particle surface and quencher molecule have the same sign, it is difficult to determine a precise value of adsorption constant Kadsand electron transfer parameter A due to a significant calculation error caused by minor changes of relative intensity of the luminescence at the addition of the quencher. In other words, when the charges of the luminescent particle surface and quencher ion have the same sign, no significant luminescence quenching occurs. It seems interesting that at the luminescence quenching of colloidal CdS by the PWlz ions, the dependence of adsorption constant on the size of colloidal particle is lacking (see Table 2.2). On the other hand, as noted in Fig. 2.17, the methylviologen adsorption constant at the surface of colloidal CdS depends on the particle size. This difference may relate to the different size of methylviologen and phosphotungstic acid molecules. Actually, the size of the phosphotungstic acid molecules in aqueous solution is 5-6 A [MI, which is comparable with the size of a colloidal particle. Therefore, the suggested equation (2.19) reflects adequately a variation in the properties of luminescence quenchers and describes well the experimental data as a whole. In addition, the data suggest that for the colloids obtained with an excess of the sulfide ions, the quencher adsorption site is represented most likely by the negatively charged surface sulfur atoms, on which the cations adsorb readily while the anions adsorb poorly. Actually, in this case, the dominant surface defects are either the vacancies of the cadmium ions, or
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
62
the interstitial sulfur. According to the literature [32,45], the both kinds of surface defects may serve as recombination sites of photoexcited charge carriers. However, while the surface cadmium vacancy may be potentially substituted by the quencher cations, the latter are expected to have no effect on the interstitial sulfur. Under the assumption that the quencher adsorption does not result in disappearance of recombination sites of charge carriers, the interstitial sulfur seems to be a more probable recombination site. Similarly, one may assume the surface positively charged cadmium ions, which are well adsorbing the anionic electron acceptors, to be the surface recombination sites for the CdS colloids prepared in the excess of cadmium ions. Table 2.2.
The quencher adsorption constant Kads and parameter of electron transfer A obtained via Eq. (2.19) from the data on the luminescence quenching of colloidal CdS by two methods (method 1 -with the excess of S2- ions, method 2 - with the excess of Cd2+ions) by quenchers of various nature Quencher
*
Method Of CdS preparation
hobs(nm) 2 ~ ( h A
Kads
A. Kads
MVZ+
1 (NSC)
480
20
10
510
MV2+
1 (NSC)
500
23
22
3100
MV2+
1 (NSC)
550
26
7
11000
MV2+
1 (NSC)
560
34
7
1o5
MV2+
1 (NSC)
560
44
1
%lo5
MV2+
2 (PSC)
550
21.5
<<1
MV2+
2 (PSC)
550
24
<<1
MV2+
2 (PSC)
550
26.5
<<1
MV2+
2 (PSC)
550
32
<<1
PW12-*
1 (NSC)
550
23
<<1
pwl;-
2(PSC)
500
21
0.88
18000
pwl;-
2(PSC)
500
22.5
0.8
18000
pw12-
2(PSC)
550
26.5
1.5
16000
Under experimental conditions (pH 5-7, T = 23OC), phosphotungstic acid in aqueous solution is mainly in a completely dissociated form (PW120403-)[43].NSC means negative surface charge; PSC means positive surface charge.
2.4.3. Effect of Excitation Wavelength on the Luminescence Spectrum of CdS/Cu,S Substitution of the lattice cadmium ions in a CdS colloidal particle by the ions of another metal is often accompanied by the formation of the so-called <> particles CdS/Me,S,. Such particles are readily produced via the substitution of cadmium ions by other ions if only their sulfide are less soluble compared to the cadmium sulfide. Our studies on the luminescence properties of such particles and regularities of their luminescence
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
63
quenching were reported in detail in [46]. Here we note only a remarkable feature of such nanosystems, the effect of excitation wavelength of CdS/Cu,S colloids on their luminescence spectrum.
0,Oj
, 400
,
, 500
,
~
600
,
, 700
,
,I 800
Wavelergtb nm
Fig. 2.20. Luminescence spectra of colloidal CdS/Cu,S obtained at two different excitation wavelengths 1) 380 nm, 2) 410 nm. The luminescence intensity of the both spectra is divided by the actual optical density of the sample at the excitation wavelengths. [CdS] = 5104 M, [TG] = 2.5-10-*M, [SDS] = lo-' M, [CUI= 1% mole, 2R = 26.5 A, T = 20'C.
Fig. 2.20 shows the luminescence spectra of colloidal CdS/Cu,S (2R = 26.5 A) measured at two different excitation wavelengths. To normalize the luminescence spectra to the amount of light absorbed the luminescence intensity of each spectrum is divided by the optical density of the sample at the appropriate excitation wavelength. The luminescence spectra of the colloid are seen to be shifting to the long wavelength region as the wavelength of the excitation light increases. According to the spectra of the colloidal CdS/Cu,S absorption (2R = 26.5 A, Cu = 1% mole), at the 410 nm wavelength, ca. 10% of the light is absorbed by the Cu,S phase, while at 380 nm wavelength, only ca. 4% of the light is absorbed by the Cu,S phase. One can suppose that the shift of the luminescence spectrum of CdS/Cu,S results from the difference between quantities of the light quanta absorbed by Cu,S at different excitation wavelengths and the shift of luminescence spectra due to the Cu,S phase luminescence. However this assumption contradicts with that the pure Cu,S colloids has no luminescence spectrum at all. Note, that under an increase of the temperature the difference between the two spectra at two excitation wavelengths is reduced (see Fig. 2.21). This means that the processes of the excited electron capture on the surface recombination sites is activated. This observation seems to prove the existence of the <
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
64
r 00400-04
I 5M) 600 700 800
p1
Wuvelength, nm Fig. 2.21. Normalized luminescence spectra of colloidal CdSICu,S at different excitation wavelengths and different temperatures: 1) 350 nm, 2) 400 nm. [CdS] = 5-104 M, [TG] = 2.5.10-2 M, [SDS] = lO-’M, CU= 1%, 2R -- 26.5 A.
2.4.4. Conclusion
The above data reveal evident distinctions in the efficiency of the quenching the different luminescence bands of the same colloid, as well as distinctions in the efficiency of the luminescence quenching of Q-colloids of various size. The regularities of the CdS luminescence quenching by the methylviologen can be described adequately by the expressions similar to the Stern-Folmer’s equation, taking into account the shape of the isotherm adsorption for the quencher molecules at the surface of the CdS particles. We suggested an expression for the efficiency of such quenching under the assumption that the recombination rate depends linearly on the concentration of nonequilibrium current carriers in a semiconductor particle. The validity of this assumption is supported by a good agreement between the experimental and calculated data. Moreover, the calculated values of bS and parameter A have a clear physical meaning which is consistent with the previous concepts on the nature of quenching of the semiconductor particle excitation. This hypothesis is additionally supported by the data of [47],indicating that the kinetics of photoluminescence decay of CdS colloids at a flash excitation can be also described under the assumption of linear (with respect to the concentration of current carriers) rate of the current carriers recombination.
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
65
Equation (2.19) allows to determine the particle size dependence of Kad,. Good agreement of Eq. (2.19) to the experiment suggests that for colloidal CdS particles, the sites of recombination and adsorption are not identical, at least, for the studied quenchers. Of importance is the value of parameter A, which is equal to the ratio between the probability of electron transfer to a quencher and the probability of disappearance in a recombination process. The value of this parameter depends on the energy of the luminescence quantum for the semiconductor colloids. Therewith, the higher the energy of recombination site level, the lower the value of parameter A, which formally corresponds to either decreasing rate of electron transfer or increasing the rate of recombination of trapped carriers. The ability of a luminescence quencher molecule to adsorb on the surface of ultradispersed colloidal semiconductor in aqueous solutions was shown to depend mainly on the charge of the colloidal particle surface and the charge of quencher ions. The luminescence spectrum of colloidal CdS/Cu,S depends on the wavelength of excitation light and shifts to the caed>>region as the excitation light wavelength increases.
2.5. Kinetics of Photocatalytic Reactions at Stationary Illumination 2.5.1. Photoreduction of Methyl Orange on CdS Colloids in Deep Conversion
The reduction of organic dye methyl orange (MO) over CdS colloids with the particles size d = 2R 5 nm has appeared to be a convenient reaction for detail studying the kinetics of photocatalytic processes. This dye is readily reducible with no dimers formation. The MO adsorption spectrum in the pH range of 10-12, practically does not change. This allows simplifying the interpretation of the experiments on redox transformations of MO and considering the reaction of photostimulated reduction of MO as a model one. Sodium sulfide was used as the electron donor in the reaction under study. In aqueous solution with pH 10-12, the sulfide ion occurs mainly as HS- anions [48]. Photochemical processes in the presence of CdS colloids are caused by the generation of nonequilibrium holes (h) and electrons (e) in CdS:
-
CdS
hv
>
h+e,
In the course of the photoinduced process, HS- ion is oxidized by holes to give elementary sulfur HS-+2h-+ S+H+. Further, the formed sulfur is removed from the surface of CdS colloidal particle due to reaction with the sulfite ion added [49]
s +so:- + s,o:As result, in this reaction, two CdS nonequilibrium electrons reduce methyl orange to a noncolored MOHz leucoform MO+ 2e + 2H'
+
MOH, ,
66
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
which has no adsorption at the wavelength h = 500 nm. The protonation of the MO reduced form occurs very fast immediately after the electron transfer [50]. In the literature there is no description of a stable one-electron reduced form of MO. So further we will assume that under the action of light, the photocatalyst provides transfer of one electron only, while the two-electron MO reduction and the two-electron HS- oxidation occur as an overall processes in the rate not limiting steps. Therefore, in the context of the assumptions indicated, the overall reaction of the process under study may be written as follows: MO + HS-
+ ,9032- + H+
hv, CdS
>
MOH, +S,Oi-
The estimates of the molar concentration of colloidal particles in the solution and the amount of light quanta adsorbed by each colloidal particle in a unit time are essential for the further discussion. Taking the volume of the colloidal particle with 2R 5 nm as 100 nm3, CdS density 4.8 g/cm3, CdS molar weight 144.4 g/mol, at the CdS concentration in solution [CdS] = 0.4.104 M, molar concentration K of colloidal particles can be estimated as K = 2.2.10-' M. Under the indicated conditions, the amount v of light quanta adsorbed by colloidal particle per second at the intensity of irradiating light b 3 mW/cm2= 0.8.10-*Einstein-s' 'ern-' may be easily found as:
-
-
(2.20) Here, AI4 is the amount of light quanta adsorbed by the CdS colloid, and K 4 . L is the amount of colloidal particles entering the light beam. 2.5.1.a. Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Processes on Ultradisperse CdS Colloids at Stationary Illumination
A typical experimentally observed kinetic curve of the MO reduction is composed of three sections: section AB with the fast initial decay of the MO concentration (see Fig. 2.22), a linear section BC extending to the point of complete decomposition of the dye, and final section CH with fast decrease in the process rate. This kinetic dependence takes a more clear, typical stepped configuration at turning from coordinates <> to coordinates ccquantum yield cp - current MO concentration>>using the formulas for evaluation of quantum yield: (2.21) where S = 1 cmz is the cross section of incident light, V = 2 ml is the volume of sample, L = 1 cm is the length of optical path, = 6 . 103 1. M ' . sm-' absorption coefficient, AI intensity of absorbed by CdS light. Fig. 2.23 presents such kinetic
67
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
t(min) Fig. 2.22. A typical kinetic curve of MO photoreduction in the presence of CdS colloid in coordinates (optical density D, time t) in the system with Na2S as electron donor. [CdS] = 0.4.10-3 M, [PAA] = 2.4~10-~ M, [Na2SIo= M, [Na2S0310= M, [MOlo = M, IO = 0.8.10-'Einstein.s-'.cm-'. Optical density was measured at the wavelength h = 500 nm.
00
0,2
0.4
0,6
0.8
1,0
1,2
1,4
1,6
[MO] .l04(M) Fig. 2.23. Initial quantum yield cpo vs. the MO initial concentration (dotted line), and typical
kinetic curves (solid lines) obtained at different values of the MO initial concentration in the system with Na2S as electron donor. [CdS] = 0.4.10"M, [PAA] = 2.4.10-3 M, M, Io = 0.8.10-'Einstein.s-'.cm-2. [Na2SIo= l o 2 M, [Na2S0310= M. In these coordinates, the change in the curve for initial concentration [ M o l o = M to [MO] = 0.6.10-4 M is methyl orange concentration from the initial [Mol0 = accompanied by a two-fold change of the reaction quantum yield from the initial cpo = 0.03 to the stationary cpst = 0.015 value, then by the quantum yield stabilization at the level qst = 0.015 for the MO concentrations ranging from 0.6.10-4M to 0.1.10'4M , and finally, by a sharp decrease in the system quantum yield to cp = 0 at the MO dye concentration decreasing from 0.1.10-4M to 0.
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
68
In our study, for all applied intensities of the irradiating light in the range 0.2.10-8 Einstein.s-'.cmp2 c Io c 1.6.10-8 Einstein.s-'.cm-2, the experimental-ly obtained initial reaction rate WOwas found to be proportional to the intensity IOof irradiating light (Fig. 2.24), Le., the initial quantum yield of the reaction cpo is independent of this intensity.
Fig. 2.24. Initial rate Wo of methyl orange reduction vs. intensity Io of irradiating light with h = 365 nm. [CdS] = 0.4.10-3 M, [PAA] = 2.4.10-3 M, [NazSlo= 10" M, [NazSO3I0= M, [Mol0 = M.
1
I
2yo
o,o+
0,O
"
"
0,2
0,4
"
0,6
"
0,8
"
'
1,o
[MO] 104(M)
Fig. 2.25. Initial quantum yield cpo vs. the MO concentration in the system with KzC2O4 as electron M,IO = 0.8.10-8 donor. [CdS] = 0.4.10"M, [PAA] = 2.4.103M, [KzCz04]0= Einstein. s-'.cm-'.
A comparison of the experimentally obtained dependence of the initial quantum yield cpo on the MO concentration (Fig. 2.23) with the shape of the MO adsorption isotherm over an aqueous suspension reveals a qualitative similarity in the form of indicated curves.
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
69
A characteristic increase of q o after the horizontal section is apparently more pronounced when the potassium oxalate K2C204is used as the electron donor instead of the sulfide ions (Fig. 2.25). A qualitative similarity of the adsorption isotherms and the MO concentration dependence on the initial quantum yield indicates that the adsorbed dye molecules take part in the reaction. Note that all kinetic curves attain the same value of the stationary quantum yield qstregardless of the initial MO concentration (Fig. 2.23). Therewith, the q s ~ qratio o depends on the nature of polymeric surfactant used for stabilization of CdS colloid. With PAA, this ratio equals ca. 0.5, and 0.6 with PVS. An interesting feature of the reaction under study is the occurrence of some slow relaxation processes. If the illumination of the sample is terminated when its kinetics reaches the stationary section characterized by qst (at point 1 in Fig. 2.26), and recommenced after an hour, the process quantum yield exceeds qstimmediately after resumption of illumination, but later tends to qstagain.
0,O
0,2
0,4
0,6
0,8
1,0
[MO]. l04(M)
Fig. 2.26. Effect of illumination termination on the brutto-reactionquantum yield cp. Point 1 corresponds to the termination of sample illumination;point 2 corresponds to the resumption of illumination after 1 hour. [CdS] = 0.4.10” M, [PAA] = 2.4.10-3M, [Na2SIo= lo-’ M, [Na2S0& = lo-’ M, I, = 0.8.10-* Einstein.s-’.cm-’.
The experiments with noncolloidal CdS suspensions revealed that the latter feature of the systems under study as well as the establishing of the stationary quantum yields of the process qstare observed only in the presence of a macromolecular surfactant. One may assume that slow conformational transformations in the surfactant macromolecules may affect considerably the adsorption-desorption equilibria at the surface of the semiconductor particles under consideration and thus affect the course of redox processes generated by these particles under the action of light. We present below an attempt in a semiquantitative description of the observed processes. 2.5.1.b. Semiquantitative Description of the Kinetics of Photocatalytic Processes on CdS Colloids in Terms of Adsorption-DesorptionProcesses in the System
For the description of photocatalytic action of semiconductor particles in the reactions of electron transfer from a certain donor to acceptor, it is convenient to recognize three states of photocatalyst particle:
70
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
state 1, ground state. state 2, photoexcited state. 0 state 3, state with trapped carriers at the surface of the CdS particle Reaction (2.20) accompanied the 3+1 states transition, its probability described by the quantum yield cp of the reaction. Consider the possible ways of the transition from state 3 to state 1 in order to determine the dependence of the quantum yield on the ions concentration of acceptor Aad (in our case, MOad)or donor Dad(in our case, HS,:) at the surface of a colloidal particle. Let us assume the state 3 could decay by three channels: 1. by the recombination of an excessive electron and excessive hole with the first order effective rate constant k, (hereinafter the dimensionality of effective rate constants of type k is s-'); 2. by the initial oxidation of the donor by an excessive hole with the rate constant kD, followed by the reduction of either the MO molecule by an excessive electron with the rate constant klM0,or the side acceptor (e.g., 02,HzO, H') with the rate constant VS; 3. by the initial oxidation of MO and the side acceptor with characteristic rate constants kMo and k,, respectively, followed by oxidation of electron donor by hole with the rate constant k'D. In this case, the kinetic of the colloidal particle transition from state 3 to state 1 is described by the following set of equations (2.22): 0 0
dP = ph-, * (kMo+ k,) - ph * kb dt (2.22)
dpD - ph-,
dt
k, + ph * kb
In these equations, Ph-e, Pe, and Ph are the probabilities of detecting, respectively, the electron-hole pair, the hole, or the electron in the semiconductor particle at time t; PMOand ODare the probabilities of detecting, respectively, the reduced acceptor and oxidized donor at the surface of the colloidal particle at the same time moment; kx = k, + kD + kMo + k,. At the initial time t = 0, it may be assumed that Ph-e = 1, Pe = 0, Ph = 0, PMO= oi and PD = 0. At termination of the process generated by one light quantum, i.e., at t >> 10s, one may observe Phe = 0, Pe = 0, Ph = 0, PMO = APMo,and PD = APD. The equations could be solved via successive calculation of the values: Pe-h(t) from the first equation, Pe(t) and Ph(t) from the second and third equations, PMO(t) and PD(t)from the forth and fifth ones. The integration of probability PMO(t) over t from 0 to 00 gives the value of theoretical surface quantum yield cpT, which is determined as the ratio of the
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
71
probability to detect the reduced MO ion to the initial number of electron-hole pairs at the surface of the semiconductor particle. This value is specified by expression (2.23)
Here, the first term of the sum reflects the probability of the MO reduction by the second channel of the process (see above), while and the second term reflects the probability of the MO reduction by the third channel. Since, as indicated above, qint= 1, expression (2.23) reflects the total theoretical quantum yield of the process under study on a single semiconductor particle. To find the theoretical quantum yield of the process for the whole sample, one should average cpT over all colloid particles. Under the assumption that this averaging does not change considerably the form of function (2.23) and instead of effective constants k one may use their averaged values over all colloidal particles, we find:
1 rp' =-.
1+ "
K,,MO,,
-1
(2.24)
Here, "KMO, "KD, "KMo, and ''K'Mo are the heterogeneous rate constants of appropriate reactions. Expression (24) takes into account that the observed quantum yield cp of the reaction is rather low (cp = 0.03); this allows to take kz = k,; the reaction rate is taken to be proportional to the concentration of adsorbed reagents:
Expression (2.24) gives at least a qualitative description of the experimentally observed dependence of the initial quantum yield cpo of reaction on the concentration of MO acceptor. Indeed, the number (concentration) of dye ions MOad adsorbed at the surface of a colloidal particle before the light illumination, is a function of the MO concentration in a the solution and follows the dye adsorption isotherm at the same surface. Since MOad increases with increasing MO concentration, at surpassing of a certain concentration [MO]', the ratio kj/"K,,MO, can appear to be much less that unity. If the Dadvalue is fixed, the second term of sum (24) becomes constant, and hence (2.25) P
Thus, theoretical quantum yield cpoT at [Molo > [MO]', with an accuracy of an additive constant and a numerical multiplier, follows actually the MO adsorption isotherm over the CdS colloid.
72
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
Note, that at [MO] = 0 the qoT value also equals zero. Therefore, the [Molo dependencies of qo,qoT,and MOadare expected to be qualitatively similar. 2.5.l.c. Analysis of Kinetic Regularities of the System under Study
As noted above, upon oxidation of the hydrosulfide anion, elementary sulfur forms at the surface of the colloidal particle:
HS; +2h+S,
+Ht
A fraction of elementary sulfur atoms is easily accessible for the sulfite anions from the solution and is rapidly removed from the surface in the course of reaction:
s, +so;-+s,o,2followed by fast adsorption of a new hydrosulfide anion. However, another fraction of the sulfur atoms may appear to be <> (<>) by one or several links of the stabilizing polymer, e.g., PAA. Such <> of the formed sulfur may consist in the surfactant adsorption over the sulfur atoms s a d from near the surface space. The latter process creates steric obstacles for the SO3*- anion to approach the Sad particle, Le., for the removal of s a d from the semiconductor surface. Actually, it means a passivation (decrease) of the <<working>> (active) surface of the colloidal particle, which finally may decrease the reaction quantum yield. If the number of PAA blocking segments is limited and the surface area that can be <> by all these segments being less than the working surface area of colloidal particle, a decrease in the quantum yield at the initial part of kinetic dependence will occur to a certain qst.The value of qstis determined by some stationary state of the working surface not <> by PAA. This agrees with experimental data. Naturally, the fraction of the surface area blocked by the polymer surfactant, and hence the value qSl/qodepend on the nature of the surfactant used. A slow dark relaxation can be naturally explained within the suggested model by the unblocking the sulfur atoms shaded from interaction with SO;- during the some <> process, followed by sulfur removal from the colloidal particle surface in the form of thiosulfate anion and adsorption of a new hydrosulfide anion. A large size of the surfactant polymer molecules (e.g., the PAA molecule consists of ca. lo5 monomers units) and interaction between the segments of these molecules decrease considerably the conformational mobility of both the whole molecule and single segment of its chain. This may increase the characteristic time of sulfur atoms and other particles adsorption-desorption to 1 hour and more, i.e., to the time typical for the observed dark relaxation process. Consider Fig. 2.27 for a semiquantitative description of the initial section of the experimental kinetic curve. One can see from this figure that the kinetic dependencies in coordinates
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et a1.
73
adsorption layer at the colloidal particle surface are a function of the MO concentration in the sample and do not depend explicitly on the time required for attaining this MO concentration. Obviously, at the given light intensity from the studied range of I~,,c I, c I, and fixed initial concentrations of reagents [reaglo, the content of adsorption layer at the colloidal particle surface during MO reduction depends on the current MO concentration in the sample [MO] in two cases. First, in the case of fast (as compared to the rate of the overall reaction) desorption of the reaction products from the colloidal particle surface, when further decrease of the typical time of establishing the adsorption-desorption equilibrium has no effect on the cp([reagIo, [MO]) dependence. Second, in the case of slow (as compared to the rate of overall reaction) desorption of the reagents, when a further increase of the time of adsorption-desorption process also has no effect on the cp( [pearlo, [MO]) dependence.
Fig. 2.27. The rate of methyl orange reduction vs. the MO current concentration at various values of light intensity Io in the system with NazS as electron donor. [CdS] = 0.4.10-3M, [PAA] M. 1) IO = 0.2.10-' = 2.4.10'3M, [Na2S]o = 10" M, [NazS0310= lo-' M, [Mol0 = Einstein.s-'.cm-'; 2) Io = 0.6.10-' Einstein.s-'.cm-'; 3) I, = 1.6.10' Einstein.s".cm".
In the first case, the chemical reaction practically does not disturb the adsorptiondesorption equilibrium between the colloidal particle adsorption layer and the liquid phase. The composition of the adsorption layer during the MO reduction may be expressed in terms of the reagents initial concentrations and the current [MO] value. In the second case, the reaction volume of the colloidal particle is limited by its adsorption layer, which composition during MO reduction may be found from the known [reagIo and [MO]. In the intermediate case, the current composition of the colloidal particle adsorption layer and hence the cp([pearIo, [MO]) value will explicitly depend on Io. The aforesaid may be schematically presented as a time scale hierarchy, where the characteristic times of overall T,,,, and establishment of the adsorption-desorption equilibrium T,d&s are indicated. Let us estimate these times for the reaction system under study.
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
74
Define T , as ~ ~the~ time, when a dramatic change in the adsorption layer composition takes place in the absence of the adsorption-desorption processes. Therewith, easily estimated by dividing the total number of the reagent ions (MOad, HS, ) adsorbed at the colloidal particle surface by the total rate W = cp-v of photoinduced process. Tahng into account that cp 0.03, and the v value for the range of intensity IAn 0.2. einst. s-’sm-2 c Io
-
-
-
-
~ f- z ~ ~ ~
Estimate also the time
PAA
of establishing the adsorption-desorption
equilibrium for low-molecular components of the system: MO, HS-, and SO3’-. The limiting adsorption rate Wad of noncharged particles on an arbitrary colloidal particle with a low-molecular component, e.g., with the MO ions, is given by the known formula:
where rk, rMO, XK,and XMO are the sizes and diffusion coefficients of colloidal particle and MO ions, respectively. Assuming rk + rMO = rk = 2 nm, XK + XMO = XMO = l o 5 cm2/s and [MO] = l o 4 M, we find that per 1 s each colloidal particle undergoes more than lo’ collisions with the MO ions. Assuming the adhesion coefficient at the collision equal to unity and taking into account that at the stationary state about 100 MO anions are adsorbed at the colloidal particle surface, we find the characteristic time of changing the adsorption layer compo-sition of the colloidal particle surface due to adsorption: Tad 100/105 10” s. Note, that the variation in the concentration of the MO at the initial part of the kinetic from [MO] = 1 0 4 Mto [MO] = 0.8.10m4M- A[MO] = 0.2.10-4Mcorresponds to the MO amount initially adsorbed at the colloidal particle surface: [K]-MO,d = 2.lO-’ M . 100 = 2-10” M. In this case, one may see from the experimental data obtained (see, e.g., Fig. 2.23) that at the initial step of the reaction, the reaction quantum yield decreases only two-fold. Therefore, the desorption rate of the low-molecular components can not be much lower than the rate of the reaction proceeding on the CdS particle. Since the reaction quantum yield does not change with the varying the light intensity, the desorption of the lowmolecular components is a much faster than the redox transformations at the photocatalyst surface. Thus, the hierarchy of characteristic times in the system under study may be expressed as
-
TF- 10-3s, TC-<< TE- 70s <::T
-
- 500s << z;Fdes - 4000s
Thus, the adsorption layer at the colloidal particle surface is represented by the segments (areas) of at least two types, which differ significantly in the time of establishing the adsorption-desorption equilibrium with respect to the characteristic time of photocatalytic overall reaction. A part of the surface of particle is not coated with the PAA molecules, and for this part
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
75
At this surface fraction, the photocatalytic reaction does not disturb the adsorptiondesorption equilibrium. Another part of the surface adsorption layer is created during the reaction due to blocking the forming elementary sulfur by PAA segments. For this surface fraction -z:Zdes-4000s >> 7:, -500s (case 2). The adsorption layer composition at the segments of various types in the studied range of reaction time will be again determined by the initial concentrations of reagents [reaglo and the current concentration [MO] of methyl orange, and not depend explicitly on the light intensity and hence the time of attaining the specified MO concentration. Thus, the cp dependence on [MO] will remain unchanged for any light intensity I,, in the range of Ifin e I,, c I-, which is supported by similarity of the lunetic curves in Fig. 2.27. Within the model of a semiconductor particle with two surfaces of different (< and >) adsorption layer types, one may quantitatively describe the initial part of kinetic curves. Denote the total surface area of the colloidal particle as Q, and the surface area of the colloidal particle blocked by PAA as QpAA. Let us call the colloidal particle surface area free of PAA as the <<working>> surface and denote it as Qw = Q - QPAA. Denote the area of the <<working>> surface before the illumination as Q", Some special experiments have revealed that the MOHz and SZO3'- products formed at the photocatalytic reaction have only a slight influence on the adsorption layer composition free of PAA. Indeed, a complete restoration of EM010 = l o 4 M after which the illumination was switched off, keeping the sample in darkness for 3 hours, addition of the oxidized MO form to give the initial concentration [Mol0 = M, and further restoration under similar conditions showed that the repeated restoration process changed the form of the MO concentration dependence of the reaction quantum yield only slightly. This supports the conclusion that the reaction products compete weakly with the starting reagents for the reaction sites at the CdS surface. In this case, the amount of reagent ions adsorbed at the surface of a single colloidal particle in the course of the photocatalytic process MOldnads,Dldnadswill be determined by both the current concentrations of reagents and the value of the photocatalyst particle surface not blocked by PAA. Assuming the values MOkinads, Dldnadsand the effective rate constant k,' to be proportional to Q , we find: (2.26)
where
$!n
is the restoration rate of side acceptor at the working surface area Q,.
Substitution of MOkinads, Dkinads and
$!n
into (2.24) gives (2.27)
where [reag] is the current concentration of reagents, [reag]~ is the reagents concentration at the reaction onset, Qw([reag]) is the current area of working surface, QwO([reag])is the working surface area of the colloidal particle at the moment of the reaction onset, cpT([reag])is the reaction quantum yield for the arbitrary degrees of the reagent conversion,
76
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
cpTo([reag]) is the reaction quantum yield for the working surface area of colloidal particle SZwo and the current concentration of the reagents. The expression derived demonstrates that a decrease in the quantum yield during the photocatalytic reaction (i.e., at decreasing [reag]) which is caused by two cofactors. The first one reflects a decay of the quantum yield due to descreasing the total concentration of the reagents (mainly of MO) in the sample, while the second one reflects a decrease of the colloidal particle <<working>> surface area due to a partial blocking of the surface by the PAA macromolecules. The dependence of the initial quantum yield of the photocatalytic reaction on the MO concentration was measured experimentally (see Fig. 2.23) and may be used as a function of cpoT in expression (2.27). Consider the variation of SZ,,, during the reaction. During the reaction, elementary sulfur forms at the surface of the colloidal particle. Denote the fraction of the newly formed sulfur atoms which will be <
the formed sulfur atoms, k,[S032-] is the rate of where kpAA(PAA)'is the rate of <> the reaction between sulfur and S032-anion. Here (PAA)' is the average number, calculated with respect to a single colloidal particle, of the PAA segments capable of blocking the forming sulfur, kPAAis the rate constant of the blocking. At high SO?-concentrations, the rate of blocking the forming sulfur with surfactant molecules may appear to be much lower as compared to the rate of the reacting with S032-.In this case, the fraction of the blocked sulfur atoms is small and proportional to the (PAA)' value:
At the steady state the number of the sulfur atoms produced in the reaction course equals the number of the reduced MO molecules: K.dSad = K*(-dMOad)= -dMO . Hence. dSad = -d(MO/K)=d([MO]/[K]) ,
(2.28)
where MO and K are the total number of the MO molecules and colloidal particles in the system, [MO] and [K] are the MO and colloidal particles concentrations averaged over the sample volume, the differentially small values dSad and dMOad are recognized as the changes in the number of the adsorbed sulfur atoms and MO ions per one colloidal particle, on the average. Taking the surface area blocked by the PAA molecules at closing>>one adsorbed sulfur atom equal to o,it can be easily found that at the formation of dSadsulfur atoms, the working surface area SZ, of the colloidal particle is decreased by the value
Chapter 2, D.V. Bavykin et al.
77 (2.29)
Here, R t is a certain stationary value of the working area of colloidal surface. Integration of (2.29) gives: (2.30) Thus, the working surface area of the colloidal particle decays exponentially with the current MO concentration in the sample decreasing from 52: to The result obtained agrees with the experiment. Consider, e.g., the kinetic dependence of the quantum yield for the system with [Mol0 = 1 0 4 Mand [NazS]o= lo-’ M, [Na2S0310= lo-’ M (Fig. 2.23). Since the value cpo([MO]) depends slightly on the MO concentration in the range 0.5.10-4 M e [MO] e l o 4 M (see Fig. 2.23), according to expression (2.27), the variation in the quantum yield at this section is caused by changing the working surface area of the colloidal particle and, according to (2.30), depends exponentially on the difference ([Molo - [MO]). This conclusion is supported by an appropriate analysis of the shape of the initial section of the curve shown in Fig. 2.23. Thus, the data of above study reveal a pronounced effect of adsorption-desorption processes and, in particular, their dynamic characteristics, on the occurrence of photocatalytic redox reactions, which proceed at stationary illumination over colloidal semiconductors, stabilized by surfactant molecules. The observed linear dependence of the rate of the studied model photocatalytic reaction on the light intensity indicates an apparent single-quantum nature of photocatalytic processes sensitized by colloidal semiconductors. Similarity of the dependence of the reaction quantum yield on the methylviologen concentration in the solution and the MO adsorption isotherm on the CdS aqueous suspension demonstrates the dominating effect of adsorbed MO molecules on the process rate. The observed dynamic regularities of the process at continuous illumination of the system allow assumption on existence of at least two segments at the colloidal particle surface: the surface segment which is free of stabilizing surfactant molecules and is characterized by a short (e< 70 s) time of establishing the adsorption-desorption equilibrium with the liquid phase; and the surface segment which is blocked by the surfactant molecules and is characterized by large (ca. 1 hour) time of establishing the adsorption-desorption equilibriums with the liquid phase. In the course of photocatalytic reaction, the surfactant molecules provide, most likely, a reversible bloclung of photocatalyst surface, which considerably decreases the process quantum yield.
at
I
2.5.2. Photoreduction of Methylviologen and Phosphotungstic Acid on CdS Colloids, the
Eflect of Surface Charge
The surface properties of ultradisperse semiconductor CdS which are determined in during its preparation, were shown to make a decisive influence on the regularities of interfacial transfer of photoexcited electron. In this section, we consider the effect of surface properties of ultradisperse CdS on the regularities of photoreduction of various substances under stationary illumination of CdS.
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
78
As the reducible reagents, we have chose the methylviologen and phosphotungstic acid (cationic and anionic reagents), which were used in the experiments on the luminescence quenching and photoexcitation relaxation. The adsorption ability of the reagents also appeared to have a pronounced effect on the feasibility of the photocatalytic reaction on ultradisperse CdS. In particular, on colloidal CdS prepared in an excess of the sulfide ions (i.e. the particles with the negatively charged surface), photoreduction of methylviologen bication proceeds efficiently (see Fig. 2.28), with no reduction of phosphotungstic acid anions. Conversely, on colloidal CdS produced in the excess of cadmium ions (with positively charged surface), photoreduction of methylviologen cations practically does not occur, while photoreduction of phosphotungstic acid anions proceeds with a considerable rate (see Fig. 2.29). According to the adsorption spectra of reduced PWlz [51] (see Fig. 2.29), initially an one electron reduced form of PWI2 .-is formed, and then further reduction of PWlz b; two electrons occurs (the absorption spectrum shifts to the longer wavelength region).
D
Wwelength, nm
Fig. 2.28. Adsorption spectra of MV photoreduced at CdS. The spectra were recorded in 10 min at 2OoC. Illumination with DRSh-500; UFS-2 and SZS-20 glass cut-off filters. [CdS] = 5.10-4M, [PAA] = l o 3 M, [TG] = 5.10-4M, [MV] = 2.5.10-4 M.
Since the surface properties of the colloid have a strong influence on the photoreduction kinetics, it seemed interesting to elucidate the effect of the added surface-active substances on the kinetic regularities of the reactions photosensitized by semiconductor colloid. The surfactant molecules are known to concentrate near the surface of the colloidal particle, so they may affect strongly the kinetics of photocatalytic reactions proceeding at the particles surface [52,53]. Fig. 2.30 presents the temperature dependencies of the initial rate of the MV photoreduction over colloidal CdS prepared at the excess of the sulfide ions. These dependencies were obtained at the addition of different amounts of PAA. One may see that both the initial rate and the observed activation energy of the methylviologen photoreduction do not depend, within the experimental error, on the concentration of
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
79
admixed PAA. In other words, the addition of the surfactant has no effect on the methylviologen ability to adsorb at the C d S surface. Probably, these data agree with the ideas that the admixed surfactant can not compete with thioglycerol in the adsorption at the surface of ultradisperse CdS.
'
I
'
,
500
400
'
,
'
600
,
700
'
,
'
800
Wwelength. nm
Fig. 2.29. Adsorption spectra of PWlz photoreduced at CdS. The spectra were recorded in 10 min at 2OoC. Illumination with DRSh-500; UFS-2 and SZS-20 glass cut-off filters. [CdS] = 5.10-4 M, [DCH] = 10" M, [TG] = 5.10" M, [PW1,] = 2.5*10'4M.
3,6-
3,3
3
Uiithwt PAA
E,=8.25+1.75 k J W
0
PAA3.10?
E,=9.75*1.47 k J m
A
PAA lo-?
E,=8.189.86 kJhrol
-
C
-J
3,O-
2,7
I
I
I
Fig. 2.30. Temperature dependence of the initial rate of methylviologen photoreduction over colloidal CdS with an excess of S2- at the addition of variable PAA amounts. [CdS] = 5.10-3 M, [TG] = 5.10-2M, [MV] = 2.5.104 M. Dimensionality of W is M.s-'.
80
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
The results of this section reveal that relaxation of photoexcited states of ultradispersed CdS in processes of interfacial charge transfer strongly depends on CdS particles adsorption properties and ability of substances, involved in redox transformations, to adsorb at the CdS surface. The adsorption properties of ultradispersed CdS can be varied during its preparation. 2.5.3. Effect of Excitation Light Wavelength on the Rate of Photocatalytic Reaction
It was found that quantum yield q(h) of the reaction of methyl orange MO reduction on CdS is monotonically increase with an increase of the wavelength of excitation light. A considerable monotonous growth of q(h) at h increasing and approaching the adsorption edge was observed also for other electron acceptors: chrysoidin and methylviologen. This fact can not be explained by the sensibilization by dye, since methylviologen initially has no adsorption band in the region under study. The observed phenomena may be caused, e.g., by increasing recombination rate of auxiliary charge carriers at their energy growth, and possible participation of nonthermalized <> electrons in the reaction of interfacial electron transfer.
2.6. Conclusion The data reported in the work indicate that CdS nanocolloids are very mobile systems with many interesting properties, which may be found in various time ranges when studying the photoprocesses. Such properties involve changing the equilibrium size of CdS particles at the addition to the solution of Cd2+complexones - electron donors like EDTA; the effect of nonequilibrium electron charge on the rate of interfacial electron transfer; a dramatic effect of the surface charge of colloidal particle on the efficiency of photoluminescence quenching (charge transfer); the dependence of the efficiency of photoluminescence quenching on the wavelength of emitted by colloidal particle light; the occurrence of slow relaxation processes in photocatalytic reactions on CdS colloids in the presence of surfactants in the solution; the effect of wavelength of excitation light on the photoreaction quantum yield. Interpretation of some of these regularities may be debatable. However, these regularities can be shown in the experiment, while rigorous description of the kinetics of photoprocesses on semiconductor nanoparticles is still a challenging task. Studying the photoprocesses on semiconductor nanoparticles remains a fruitful and very interesting field. REFERENCES 1 . Schukin E. D., Pertsov A. V. and Amelina E. A., Colloidal Chemistry, Vyschaya Shkola, Moscow (1992) (in Russian). 2. KarapetjantsM. H., Chemical thermodynamic, Nauka, Moscow, (1975) (in Russian). 3. Hand-book of chemistry, B. P. Niclolsky (Ed.), pp. 119-166, Khimija, Moscow (1964) (in
Russian). 4. Vucenilovic M.I., Vukelic N. and Rajh T. J. Photochem. and Photobiol., 42,No. 1, 157-161 (1988). 5. Bahnemann D.W., Kormann C. and Hoffmann M. R. J. Phys. Chem., 91,3789-3798 (1987).
Chapter 2, D. V. Bavykin et al.
81
6. Wang Y. and Herron N. J. Phys. Chem., 95,525-532 (1991). 7. Gurevich Yu. A. and Pleskov Yu. V., Photoelectrochemistry of Semiconductors, Nauka, Moscow (1983) (in Russian). 8. Moss T. S.Proc. Phys. SOC.B (London),67, 775 (1954). 9. Burstein B. E. Phys. Rev., 93, 632 (1954). 10. Grenn A. and Mills A. J. Photochem. Photobiol A: Chem., 64, 211-221 (1992). 1 1 . Savinov E. N., Photocatalysis of redox reactions in aqueous solutions with dispersed metals and semiconductors, D.Sc. Thesis, Novosibirsk (1993) (in Russian). 12. Dounghong D., Ramsden J. and Gratzel M. J. Am. Chem. SOC.,104,2977-3001 (1982). 13. Moser J. and Gratzel M. J. Am. Chem. SOC.,105,6547-6555 (1983). 14. Mulvaney P., Swayamcunathan V., Grieser F. and Meisel D. J. Phys. Chem., 92, 6732-6740 (1988). 15. Kamat P. V., Dimitrijevic N. M. and Nozik A. J. J. Phys. Chem., 93,2873-2875 (1989). 16. Vedeneev V . I., Lebedev Ya. S. and Entelis S. G., Lectures in Chemical Kinetics, MPTI, Dolgoprudny (1974) (in Russian). 17. Nanadovic M. T., Micic 0. I. and Adzic R. R. J. Chem. SOC.Far. Trans., 76, No. 4, 1065-1069 (1982). 18. Bavykin D. V., Savinov E. N. and Parmon V. N. J. Photochem and Photobiol A: Chem., 130, No. 1,57-61 (2000). 19. Siders P. and Marcus R. A. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 103,741-747 (1981). 20. Stramel R. D., Nakamura T. and Thomas J. K. Chem. Phys. Lett., 130, No. 5,423-425 (1986). 21. Blanton S.A., Degestani A., Lin P. C. and Guyot-Sionnest P. Chem. Phys. Lett., 229, No. 2,317322 (1994). 22. Fojtik A. and Weller H. Chem. Phys. Lett., 120, No. 6,552-554 (1985). 23. Micic 0. I., Cheong H.M., Fu H., Zunger A., Sprague J. R., Mascarenhas A. and Nozik A. J. J. Phys. Chem. B, 101,4904-4912 (1997). 24. Hotchandani S.and Kamat P. V. J. Phys. Chem., 96, 6834- (1992). 25. Anpo M. and Kubokawa Y. J. Phys. Chem., 88,5556-5560 (1984). 26. Hiramoto M., Hashimoto K. and Sakata T. Chem. Phys. Lett., 133, No. 5,440-444 (1987). 27. Wang Y., in: Photochemical Conversion and Storage of Solar Energy, E. Pelizzetti and M. Schiavello (Eds.),pp. 295-305, Kluwer, Dordrecht (1991). 28. Tian Y., Wu C. and Fendler J. H. J. Phys. Chem., 98,4913-4918 (1994). 29. Tittel J., Gohde W., Koberling F., Basche Th., Kornowski A,, Weller H. and Eychmuller A. J. Phys. Chem., 101, No. 2,313-316 (1997). 30. Becker W. G. and Bard A. J. J. Phys. Chem., 87,4888-4893 (1983). 31. Ferrer I. J. and Salvador P. Chem. Phys. Lett., 141, No. 5,399-404 (1987). 32. Aven M. and Prener J. S.,Physics and chemistry of II-VI Compounds, Amsterdam (1967). 33. Rossetti R. and Brus L. J. Phys. Chem., 86,4470-4472 (1982). 34. Gerischer H., Conditions for efJicientphotocatalytic activity of TiOzparticles, in: Photocatalytic Purification and Treatment of Water and Air, D. F. Ollis and H. Al-Ekabi (Eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, (1993). 35. Rabek J., Experimental methods in photochemistry and photophysics, Mir, MOSCOW (1985) (in Russian).
82
Kinetic Peculiarities of Photocatalytic Reactions
36. Rips I., Klafter J. and Jortner J. Solvation dynamics and solvent-controlled electron transfer, in: Photochemical Energy Convertion, J . R. Noms and D. Meisel (Eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, (1989). 37. Tachiya M. J. Phys. Chem., 97, 5911-5916 (1993). 38. Siders P. and Marcus R. A. J. Am. Chem. SOC.,103,748-752 (1981). 39. Chestnoy N., Harris T. D., Hull R. and Bms L. E. J. Phys. Chem., 90, 3393-3399 (1986). 40. Nemec P. and Maly P. J. Appl. Phys., 87, 3, 3342-3348 (2000). 41. Christy F. Landes, Markus Braun, and Mostafa A. El-Sayed, J. Phys. Chem. B, 105, 10554-10558 (2001). 42. Landes C., Burda C., Braun M. and El-Sayed M. A. J. Phys. Chem. B, 105, 2981-2986 (2001). 43. Kozhevnikov I. B., Acid and Basic catalysis, Novosibirsk State University (1991) (in Russian). 44. Harmalker P. S.and Pope M. J. Phys. Chem., 82, No. 26,2823-2825 (1978). 45. Ramsden J. J. and Gratzel M. J. Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans., 80, 1,919-933 (1984). 46. Bavykin D. V., Savinov E. N. and Parmon V. N. Lungmuir, No. 6,4722-4727 (1999). 47. Gmzdkov Yu. A., Savinov E. N. and Parmon V. N. Chem. Phys., 7, No. 1, (1988). 48. Sharlo G., Methods of Analytical Chemistry, Khimiya, Moscow (1965) (in Russian). 49. Nekrasov B. V., Fundamentals of General Physics, Vol. 1-3, Khimiya, Moscow (1973) (in Russian). 50. Gruzdkov Yu. A., Ph.D. Thesis, Institute of Catalysis, Novosibirsk (1987) (in Russian). 51. Savinov E. N., Catalytic and photocatalytic properties of heteropolyacids of 12'h series in the reaction of hydrogen extraction from aqueous and water-alcohol solutions, Ph.D. Thesis, Institute of Catalysis, Novosibirsk (1983) (in Russian). 52. Savinov E. N., Nagomy E. N., Martyanov I. N. and Parmon V. N. Chem. Phys., 14, No. 4,78-86 (1995). 53. Martyanov I. N., Kinetics of photocatalytic redox reactions of organic molecules on suspensions of CdS and Ti02 semiconductors, Ph.D. Thesis. Institute of Catalysis, Novosibirsk (1998) (in Russian).
Chemical Physics of Nanostructured Semiconductors, p p . 83-1 10 A.I. Kokorin and D.W. Bahnemann (Eds.) Q VSP 2003.
CHAPTER 3
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes Torbjorn Lindgren, Lionel Vayssieres, Heli Wang and Sten-Eric Lindquist Department of Physical Chemistry, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden
Kevwords: Photoelectrochemistry, photocatalysis, Nanostructured electrodes, Hematite, thin films, Water oxidation List of Abbrevations
CB EE IPCE NHE PEC SC SE SEI
uv VB
conduction band electrolytelelectrode incident photon-to-current conversion efficiency the normal hydrogen electrode photoelectrochemical semiconductor substrate/electrode illumination semiconductor/electrolyteinterface ultra violet valence band
List of Symbols
E,, h hv I
J
quantum yield dielectric constant the permittivity of free space absorption coefficient frequency wavelength absorption capacitance of the space charge layer applied potential conduction band edge band gap of the semiconductor standard electrode potential valence band edge Planck constant light illumination energy light intensity photocurrent
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
84
Boltzmann constant donor density light power intensity elementary charge surface area temperature flatband potential onset potential
3.1. Introduction Today, the major part of the energy consumed comes from chemical energy stored in fossil fuels. These fossil reserves are being rapidly depleted and the combustion has led to a severe pollution and disturbance of the environment. It is generally accepted that C 0 2 (besides CH4, NO, and FCH) to a great extent contributes to the greenhouse effect. Due to the climate change, likely caused by the greenhouse effect, a growing interest has developed for new alternative energy sources not based on fossil fuel. Solar energy is a candidate of interest. Although solar energy has many advantages, it is an abundant resource and it is renewable, it is neither permanent nor constant in intensity over the world. Therefore, a suitable energy carrier for storage and transport is likely needed. Such an energy carrier could be dihydrogen. An energy system consisting of solar energy in combination with dihydrogen as an energy carrier would be an environmental friendly and attractive energy carrier for the future. Accordingly, the search of methods to produce dihydrogen using sunlight as energy source, for instance by direct photo-oxidation of water, has been a long-term research goal. In the quest for suitable semiconductor anode materials for direct photo-oxidation of water as well as for solar energy conversion, hematite (aFe203)has been a candidate of interest considering the following reasons: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi)
band gap of 2.0-2.3 eV [l-111; chemical stability in aqueous solutions in a wide pH range [12, 131; stability towards photocorrosion [ 121; thermodynamic stable crystallo-graphic phase [ 141. thermal stability [ 151; abundance of the material and low cost synthesis.
Different procedures have been established; chemical vapor deposition [5, 161, powder sintering combined with pressing [ l , 2, 6, 7, 12, 17-25], sputtering [9, 261, flux and melt grown [lo, 27, 281, chemical deposition [ l l , 14, 29, 301, sol-gel techni-ques [31], mechano-chemical pro-cessing [321, forced hydrolysis [33,34], spray pyrolysis [35-411, and thermal and hydro- thermal oxidation [3,4, 8, 10, 17,42-581. However, hematite exhibits several disadvantages. For instance, like many n-type oxides, the flat-band level of &Fez03 is unsuitable for direct photoelectrolysis of water since an external bias is needed to generate dihydrogen at the counter electrode, which reduces to overall efficiency [4, 8, 591. Hematite was investigated intensively in the 1970’s but is nowadays often not even mentioned in many reviews about potential semiconductor
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
85
materials for water splitting applications. The main reason is that hematite, independent of the methods of preparation, has shown a poor photoresponse due to the following facts: (i) (ii) (iii) (iii)
high resistivity [2,5, 17, 18,431, as high as lo6 SZcm for single crystals [5]; low electron mobility, 0.01[60] to 0.1 cm2/V.s[5, 171; short hole diffusion length, 2-4 nm [6]; high rate of charge carrier recombination [6,29,44,46, 611.
Numerous attempts to increase the photoresponse and the quantum yield of hematite have been performed by: (i)
(ii) (iii) (iv)
varying the doping density or changing the dopants to decrease the bulk resistivity [ l , 2,5-7, 10, 12, 18-24,26,37,61-631; using thin films and/or nanosized particles and colloidals to match the hole diffusion length and increase the surface area [3, 4, 11, 14, 29, 30, 35-38, 44, 511; heat treatment and modification of the surface [18-21, 611; mixing with other oxides like Ti02 to form complex oxides [16, 19, 24, 27, 28,45,50].
However, most of these attempts were found unsuccessful. This is mainly due to the fact that the mechanisms and processes responsible for the low photoresponse of hematite are far from being clearly understood. A deeper understanding of the semiconducting properties of this material is needed, such as its surface structure and a better description of the hematite/electrolyte interface. Extensive knowledge is also required to understand the photoelectro- chemical behavior of hematite and the kinetics involved in the photo-oxidation of water. Finally, for effective oxidation of water an efficient catalyst must most probably be coated onto the surface of hematite. In this review, a literature survey of the water oxidation reaction at iron oxide photoelectrodes is reported. 3.2. General Background of Photo oxidation of Water The first report of direct photoconversion of water into dihydrogen and dioxygen was studied on Ti02 (n-type) electrodes by Fujishima and Honda [64]. Although the overall efficiency of the system was low, their results initiated the interest in photoelectrochemical cells for conversion of solar energy to chemical energy (or to electrical energy). Solar-induced photo-oxidation of liquid water to gaseous dihydrogen and dioxygen: H 2 0 + H2 + 0.5 02,(AG = +237.7 Hmol'')
(3.1)
at semiconductor electrodes is a possible practical application for dihydrogen generation and it has been extensively studied [59, 65-72]. Photo-assisted generation of dihydrogen and dioxygen from water can be achieved in various ways [70]. In a photoelectrochemical (PEC) system, both excited electrons in the conduction band (CB) and holes in the valence band (VB) directly participate in the water splitting process, as illustrated in Fig 3.1.
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
86
I
anode
cathode
Fig. 3.1. A photoelectrochemical (PEC)cell for photo assisted water splitting.
For an n-type semiconductor, the semiconductor electrode acts as a photoanode. Accordingly, when an n-type semiconductor electrode is under band gap illumination, photogenerated holes in the VB will oxidize water into O2 and electrons in the CB will move towards the counter electrode to reduce water into H2. In the case of a p-type semiconductor, the holes in the VB are the majority charge carrier and the semiconductor acts as a photocathode. Accordingly, the photo process at p-type semiconductor is just opposite to that of n-type. In order to successfully split water upon irradiation, the quasi Fermi level of holes p E has ~ to be located at a lower energy level than the electrochemical potential of dioxygen evolution (H20/02), and the quasi Fermi level of electrons "EF has to be positioned at a higher energy level than the electrochemical potential of dihydrogen evolution (H2/H+), see Fig. 3.1. The energy difference between hydrogen evolution and oxygen evolution is 1.23 eV and that is accordingly the theoretical energy needed for direct splitting of water. If the position of the energy levels of the quasi Fermi levels are not fulfilled an external bias (Ebias)has to be applied in order to induce the photo oxidation process. For long-term 0 2 and Hz generation, the electrodes must also be chemically stable and resistant to photo-corrosion. The kinetics and mechanisms behind oxidation of water by photo-generated holes are not fully understood and vary most probably with interfacial properties of the semiconductor [73]. Four adsorbed photons and two molecules of H20 are involved to yield one molecule of gaseous dioxygen and four protons. hv
+ a-FezO3 + 4 h+(a-Fe203)+ 4 e-
4 h+(a-Fe203)+ 2 H20 + 4 H+ + O2
(3.2a) (3.2b)
This is, by nature, a very complex reaction. The elementary steps in the detailed mechanism are far from known. However, the kinetics can be improved by surface modification. For instance by surface coating with an efficient catalyst for dioxygen evolution, e.g. Ru02 [74], or increasing the surface area, which facilitate a lower current density which in
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
87
turndecrease the overpotential [75].The reduction of water into Hz is a kinetically simpler process compared to the four-electron redox process to evolve 02. It is generally accepted that three major processes limit the photoelectrochemical current in semiconductors after a bandgap excitation [76]. These processes are schematically illustrated in the band diagram shown in Fig. 3.2. The bold arrows show the desired processes for efficient water splitting PEC cell after a bandgap excitation: the transport of electrons to the back contact, the transfer of the hole to the semiconductor surface and the oxidation of water at the semiconductor/electrolyte interface. The three major limiting processes are a) bulk recombination via bandgap states, or b) directly electron loss to holes in the valence band (eventually followed by emission of light), and c) surface recombination. These three limiting factors are general for all light absorbing semiconductor materials. If a proper electron scavenger is present (in Fig. 3.2 represented by 02),electrons can also be lost from the conduction band (process d). In addition, photocorrosion of the semiconductor itself and dissolution reactions can also occur (process f). This leads to a degradation of the electrode, which is a major stability problem in some PEC systems, e.g. InP, CdSe and n GaAs [77].
Fig. 3.2. Schematic representation of the different pathways for the photogenerated electron-hole pair for a planar n type semiconductor in electrolyte solution.
The photoelectrochemical properties of different semiconductor materials have been widely reported, for single crystal, polycrystalline, as well as for nanostructured materials. In the literature various methods for measuring the efficiency are found. The most common is the IPCEh (incident photon-to-current conversion efficiency) or quantum efficiency, which is defined as hc J p h J IPCE =-I. 4 PIA
(3.3)
where J p h ,is~ the photocurrent in AmpBre, PA is the light power intensity in Watt, A.is the wavelength in nanometer and h, c, and q have their usual meaning of Planck’s constant,
88
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
speed of light in vacuum and the elementary charge. The IPCE plotted versus the wavelength is called an action spectrum. Another common and scientifically more relevant parameter is the quantum yield, $A or APCEk (absorbed photon to current efficiency) where the optical absorption (An) of the film is taken into account: (3.4) Also frequently used is the photocurrent response at a given potential and light condition (intensity and wavelength). The photocurrent obtained with illumination of the ntype hematite used as anodes are directly proportional to the amount of dihydrogen that can be produced by reduction of protons in the electrolyte. Also commonly used is the overall efficiency, 17 where the relation between the energy content of dihydrogen produced in relation to the incident irradiation energy is reported [38]. If a potential is applied (Ebins)then the electrical power input at the given potential should be withdrawn from the total power output (Le. the energy content of the dihydrogen produced). ?=
total power output - electrical power input - j p (Eonset - ~ light power input IO
)
b
i
~
~
(3.5)
where j p is the current density, E,,,, the onset potential, Eappliedthe applied potential and IO the light power input. For any practical applications, an overall efficiency of at least 10% [66] is required to compete with conventional ways of producing dihydrogen, for instance by steam reforming of natural gas. Theoretically, it should be possible to design a device with an overall efficiency of 10% or higher. The peak efficiency for photovoltaic cells would occur for a single bandgap photoconverter in the range 1.4 to 1.6 eV [78] where an efficiency of up to 31% would be achieved. For a tandem device, where two light harvesting semiconductors operate in series to cover a broad range of the solar spectrum, the theoretical upper limit is around 41%. If energy should be stored in a chemical fuel (e.g. dihydrogen or a hydrocarbon like CH4 or C~HSOH), further energy losses must be encountered. Memming, see reference [79] and references therein, calculated the theoretical conversion efficiency (one photoactive electrode and no overpotentials) for photoelectrochemical water splitting to about 27%, which is not far from the maximum theoretical efficiency of 31% for conversion of sunlight into electrical energy. For splitting of water with sunlight, the maximum realizable efficiencies, taking into consideration all possible losses, have been estimated to be about 10% for a single-bandgap and 16% for a two-bandgap system [80]. However, stability problems, both chemically and low stability towards photocorrosion, as well as high costs have so far prevented the commercial breakthrough of photoelectrochemical (PEC) devices for direct conversion of solar energy to dihydrogen. The report by Fujishima and Honda [64] of direct photoconversion of water into dihydrogen and dioxygen was performed at Ti02 (n-type) electrodes with a chemical bias. A disadvantage of the Ti02 system was the wide band gap of 3.2 eV, where only the UV light contributes to the photo process. After the first successful photoelectrochemical cell
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
89
by Fujishima and Honda a large number of semiconductor materials, like InP [77, 811, SrTiO3 [82, 831, Fez03 [ l , 4, 9, 20,22, 25, 29, 35-38, 44, 841, W03 [85-881 and GaN [89, 901 have been investigated for H2 and 0 2 generation in order to improve the efficiency of the PEC cell. As for photoelectrolysis of water at p-type semiconductors, Heller and co-workers studies of InP electrodes should be mentioned [77, 811. A solar to chemical conversion efficiency as high as 12% was reported for this system [77, 811, with relatively low stability. Combinations of a photoanode (n-type) and a photocathode (p-type) of doped hematite have been studied [ 1, 20, 221. External bias was not needed for photo-oxidation of water. Both H2 and O2 were detected with this PEC diode assembly. However, the overall conversion efficiency was reported as low as 0.05%[ 11. Recently, the most interesting findings in the field of direct solar induced water splitting is the reports by Turner et a1 [91] and by Grtitzel and co-workers [92]. Both groups used multiple-junction systems, yet based on completely different materials. Turner and coworker used a highly efficient solid-state photovoltaic cell integrated to a photoelectrochemical device consisting of p-GaInP2 [91]. Efficiencies of 12% were obtained but the cost of the system is at present too high to compete with conventional renewable techniques. The tandem device described by Gratzel et a1 [92] was based on nanocrystalline W03 biased by dye-sensitized nanocrystalline Ti02 to absorb transmitted light from W03. The overall solar light to chemical conversion efficiency of this device was reported to be 4.5%. Arakawa et a1 [93] demonstrated that doping of indium-tantalum-oxide with nickel yields a series of photocatalysts, Inl-,Ni,Ta04 (x=O-0.2), which induces direct splitting of water into stoichiometric amounts of oxygen and hydrogen under visible light irradiation with a quantum yield of about 0.66 %. The result is interesting, despite the low quantum yields, since it points out that metal oxides indeed could be used for the purpose of direct splitting water under visible light irradiation. Another interesting work is the recent report by Licht et al [72, 75, 941. Although the system they studied was not a strict photoelectrochemical one, since the photovoltaic system was separated from the water electrolyser, their study is of general interest for the water oxidation field. The photovoltaic cell was connected to a water splitter catalyst system of considerably larger area than the solar cell. With this design, it was possible to combine a high solar cell efficiently with a low photocurrent density over the electrolyzer Ciph = 0.44 mA/cm2), which minimized the overpotential needed for water oxidation. An overall efficiency as high as 18.3% was obtained.
3.3. Structural and Physical Properties of Hematite 3.3.1. Crystal Structure
Hematite crystallizes in the trigonal crystal system, space group R$ I D&, and is isostructural with corundum (a-Al203) see Fig. 3.3. The unit cell can be described as rhombohedral with three equal axes a = 5.43 A and an angle between edges a = 55'18' containing two formula unit (Z = 2), or as hexagonal with a = 5.038, and c = 13.75 8, (Z = 6). The lattice is built on a hexagonal close packed (HCP) array of dioxygen with four of
90
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
every six available octahedral sites around 0 atoms occupied with Fe [95]. The octahedral and tetrahedral sites are above and below one another in a HCP lattice, the tetrahedral sites remaining empty. Octahedra are sharing faces along a threefold axis and are distorted to trigonal antiprisms because of the Fe-Fe repulsion occurring across one shared face and not the others.
Fig. 3.3. Crystal structure of hematite (a-Fe203).
This yields to a very dense structure (Le. high dioxygen packing index), showing a high polarisability and a high refractive index. The main intrinsic defect in hematite is oxygen vacancies, which in turn increase the n-type behavior by donated electrons to the conduction band [ 171. High temperature treatment increases the oxygen vacancy concentration [ 17, 201. However, the oxygen deficiency at elevated temperatures (TL15OO0C) may result in the formation of a surface region of magnetite, Fe304 [25] It has been suggested that the presence of Fe304in the surface layer decrease the photoresponse due to extensive recombination of holes and electrons in the highly conductive surface region [25]. The intrinsic doping density varies with preparation and doping densities of about 1.1OI6cm-3for single crystal [9] and as high as 2.2.10'' for pyrolytical synthesized hematite have been reported [381. 3.3.2. Electronic Structure
It was found by ultraviolet photoemission spectroscopy (UPS) that the valence band of well-ordered, nearly stoichiometric hematite consists of overlapping 0 2 p and Fe 3d orbitals which give rise to a complicated structure about 10 eV wide [96]. Gardner et al [17] observed optical absorption peaks for polycrystalline hematite at 2.4, 3.2, and a strong broad absorption band centered at 5.8 eV. Molecular orbital studies explained these energy levels as Fe 3d 3 3d, 0 2p Fe 3d, and 0 2p Fe 3d transitions, respectively [95]. Similar energy levels where obtained with ellipsometry for both single crystals and polycrystalline films, see ref. [95] and references therein. A more recent study based on computational analysis of the density of electronic states, using the ab initio periodic
+
+
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
91
unrestricted Hartree-Fock approach, showed that the bandgap is of p-d rather than d-d type [97]. Accordingly the authors suggested that hematite should be classified as a charge transfer rather than a Mott-Hubbard insulator where the conduction and upper valence edge are of the same character. Matsumoto [98] tried to summarize the work done on the electronic structure of iron oxides and concluded that the about 2 eV in the bandgap of the hematite semiconductor measured in photoelectrochemistry indeed is based on the 3d band transition between the Fe3+ions, which supports a Mott-Hubbard insulator. It has been noticed that the optical absorption of hematite has a much wider spectrum than the photocurrent response [6, 441. It was suggested that more than one optical transition occur in hematite, but only one results in the creation of an electron-hole pair where the hole is capable of evolving dioxygen from water [6].The absorption peak around 2.4 eV is located slightly high but in agreement with the bandgap measured for the semiconductor. The bandgap of hematite determined by various methods is found to be in the range of 1.9 2.3 eV (Table 3.1). The energy of the bandgap allows absorption of all the UV light and the blue part of the visible region, which gives hematite its brownish red color.
-
Table 3.1. Bandgap of hematite materials in eV Bandgap, eV
Material
Characteristics
Reference
1.9
Not mentioned
Anodic oxide, 3 nm thick
10
2.0
Amorphous
RF sputtered, 1 pm
9
2.0
Single crystal
Hydrothermal synthesis
8
2.0
Polycrystalline
Size 140 nm
3
2.1
Single crystal
Ti-doped
7
2.1
Single crystal
Zr-doped
5
2.1
Polycrystalline
Thermal grown, 3pm
10
2.2
Polycrystalline
Nanorod-may 3 nm @ x 500 nm length
11
2.2
Single crystal
Flux grown from an Li2M04melt
9
2.2
Polycrystalline
Size 100 nm
4
2.2
Polycrystalline
Undoped
6
2.2
Polycrystalline
Si- and Ge-doped
2
2.3
Polycrystalline
Mg- and Si-doped
1
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
92
The bandgap (E,) of a semiconductor is usually determined by means of optical absorption. The following equation gives a satisfactory description of the absorption behavior near the threshold [85]:
where a is the optical absorption coefficient, h the Planck’s constant, v the frequency of light, A an constant, and E, the bandgap energy, n = 0.5 for a direct transition and n = 2 for an indirect one. Hematite has been suggested to have an indirect bandgap [5, 61. However, there is also reported a direct bandgap for hematite [ l l ] . In the latter report, hematite nanorods were studied and it was stated that the quantum size effects due to the aspect ration of the single nanorod (3 nm in diameter x 500 nm in length) might be the reason for the unusual behavior. The bandgap of a semiconductor can also be determined photo-electrochemically [ l , 2, 5, 7, 81, which is based on the fact that the wavelength corresponding to the onset of photocurrent agrees well with the optical absorption edge. For colloids and powders, diffuse reflectance spectroscopy method has been used to characterize the hematite bandgap [4].
3.3.3. Electrical Properties In general, it is accepted that recombination of electrons and holes, trapping of electrons by oxygen deficiency sites and a low mobility of the holes, cause a low conductivity and accordingly a low photoresponse for hematite. Electron mobility in the range 0.01[60] to 0.1 cm2/V.s [ 171 has been reported. In the latter case, it was found that the electron mobility was independent of donor concentration. More recently, an electron mobility of about 0.1 cm2N.s has been measured with doped single crystals and the mobility was also here independent of donor concentration [5]. A diffusion length of holes has been determined to be only of 2-4 nm [6], which is about 100 times lower than many other (III-V) oxides. 3.3.4. Flat-band Potential of Hematite
The flat-band potential (U,) is a very important parameter for a semiconductor in contact with an electrolyte. U, is directly related to the conduction band (CB) level for an n-type semiconductor or the valence band (VB) level for a p-type semiconductor. A classic method to determine U, is by means of Mott-Schotky plot [99] according to:
--1 C&
-
2
.(U-U,
EE~~N,S’
kT
--)
(3.7)
4
where C, is the capacitance of the space charge layer, E the relative dielectric constant, EO the permittivity of free space, q the elementary charge, No the donor concentration, S the surface area of the electrode, U the electrode potential, U, the flat-band potential, k the Boltzmann’s constant and T the absolute temperature. The term kT/q is 25.7 mV at room temperature. Plot of I / Csfzvs. U (Mott-Schottky plot) will give a straight line where the intercept with the potential axis corresponds to the flatband potential (U’) and from the slope of the line the donor concentration, (No) can be determined. The value of C,,can be
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
93
determined experimentally as a function of potential (U) from impedance measurements. McCann et a1 [ 1001studied the impedance responses of a a-Fe203/ 1 M NaOH / Pt cell and the general equivalent circuit was determined. There are assumptions, which must be satisfied in the application of the Mott-Schottky plot. For instance, the semiconductor must contain a space charge region. In nanostructured materials there is likely no space charge layer formed [loll and therefore may the Mott-Schottky plots show dispersion and low coefficients of correlation [U]. Table 3.2. pH dependence of on-set potential, U , , and flat-band potential, Up vs. NHE for various hematite materials PH
uom
sc*’
v PC*’
ut& v
sc*’
2.7 0.44
4 6.3
6.7
0.24 0.46
Ref.
PC*’ 0.29
Nanostructured
Not mentioned
44
0.18
Sintered and pressed pellets
0.1 M KzS04, Buffered
7 102
0.04
Sintered and pressed pellets
Complex
**)
0.14
7 102
7
0.04
8.4
-0.07
Thermally grown
1M NaN03, borate buffer
10
8.4
-0.02
Anodic oxide
1M NaN03, borate buffer
10
8.6
0.36
61
102
-0.17 -0.20
Sintered and pressed pellets
0.1 M KzS04 Buffered
7
10.7
-0.31
Nanostructured
Not mentioned
44
12
-0.41
Nanostructured
0.01 M NaOH
44
-0.2 1
Firing of iron foil
0.1 M NaOH
45
Nanostructured
0.1 M NaOH
44
Sintered and pressed pellets
Complex
7
10
0.04
13
-0.06
13
-0.46
14
-0.16
14 *)
Electrolyte
0.14
0.47
6.7
Material
-0.12
-0.36 -0.43
**)
102
SC - single crystal; PC - polycrystalline; **) 0.1 M K2S04 adjusted with NaOH.
The location of U ’ can also be obtained by studying of the potential dependence of the photocurrent. Under monochromatic illumination for wavelengths close to the band
94
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
gap, the following relation applies [28, 851:
u-ufi-(JphB)2
(3.8)
where B is a function of wavelength and light intensity and Jph the photocurrent. For semiconductor colloidal particles pulsed radiolysis techniques [ 1031 have also been used to derive the flat-band potential. Due to the simplicity to determine the onset potential ( Uon)experimentally, it has been widely accepted to substitute U, with Uon.Ideally, U,, should coincide with U, [61]. In most n-type semiconductors, however, U,, is shifted a few tenths of a Volt, to more anodic potentials than U, [104]. This represents the situation when sufficient band bending has been established in the semiconductor space charge layer, which enables an efficient hole transfer to the reduced species in the solution. Table 3.2. shows that data collected from the literature for onset and flatband potentials for various pH generally are related. However, there are some discrepancies, especially for the onset potential of nanosized hematite in pH 13 solution. One may conclude that the onset and flat band potential are dependent on the crystal structure, surface morphology and electrolyte medium. The data listed in Table 3.2. are plotted and shown in Fig. 3.4.
0.6
w
0.4
1 0
A
*
cri
0.0
.. . 0
AA M
0
0
I
0
E
3
-0.6
~ , . , . , . , , , . , . l , , , ~ . l , , , , ’ 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4
PH Fig. 3.4. pH dependence of on-set potential, U,,and flat-band potential, U, vs. NHE for various hematite materials as collected from Table 2. The solid line, with a Nernstian slope of -59 mV/pH-unit, shows the potential for hydrogen generation as a function of pH. Ebim stands for the bias, which at least is needed at pH 10 to photogenerate hydrogen at the polycrystalline hematite electrode described by McGregor et a1 [7]. Uo, A U ,single crystal, 0 U,, AU’, polycrystalline.
It can be concluded that the onset and flat band have a close to Nemstian shift with pH. Generally, the pH dependencies of onset and flat band for single crystals have higher slopes. Since a change of pH also changes the electrode potential of the H2D-I’ couple according to:
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
95
it is generally accepted that it is not possible to directly generate hydrogen on hematite electrodes. For instance, McGregor et al [7] determined a flatband potential for polycrystalline hematite at pH 10 to -0.20 V vs. NHE, which is 0.39 V positive of the potential for hydrogen evolution. Accordingly, a bias of 0.39 V is at least needed (likely more due to energy barriers in the system) to generate hydrogen. See Fig. 3.3. Matsumoto [98] showed that there is a linear relationship between bandgap and band edges for oxide semiconductors. The relationship between the conduction band edge (E,), the valence band edge (E,,) and the bandgap (E,) was described as:
E, (V vs. NHE) = 1.23 - E, (eV)/2
(3.10a)
E, (V vs. NHE) = 1.23 + E, (eV)/2
(3.10b)
These equations indicated that a bandgap higher than about 2.46 eV is necessary for direct splitting of water without bias voltage. A bandgap energy of 2.46 eV is double the energy theoretically needed for direct splitting water and corresponds to an irradiation wavelength of about 500 nm, which means that a large part of the visible range could not be utilized for direct water oxidation. However, Arakawa et al. [93] showed that nickel doped Inl.,Ni,Ta04 (x = 0-0.2) with a bandgap energy around 2.25 eV indeed split water upon visible light (A > 420 nm) irradiation so there seems to be exceptions from the equations proposed by Matsumoto. 3.4. Photoresponse of Hematite Materials.
Poor charge transport, due to charge recombination, together with a low heterogeneous rate constant for hole transfer from the valence band of hematite to the hydroxide ion seem to cause the low quantum yield for hematite when used for the aim of direct water oxidation [18, 21, 36, 43, 44, 611. The oxidation of water by holes is a very slow process, with a heterogeneous rate constant for hole transfer from the valence band of hematite to OH' being 0.1 1 c d s ; compared with lo3 lo4 c d s for W 0 3 and Ti02 [61]. K. Itoh and J. M. Bockris [36] found a similar value for the hole-water oxidation transferrate constant at hematite thin film electrodes. Such a slow process accumulates holes at the valence band of hematite, which will either recombine or induce competing reaction at the hematite surface. Recently, it was shown that transient absorption decay for hematite nanoparticles was very fast, 70% of the transient absorption disappeared within 8 ps and no measurable transient absorption remained beyond 100 ps [43]. This represented a much faster decay than many other semiconductors, which is consistent with the observed poor charge transfer properties in hematite. It should be mentioned that this decay was independent of the excitation power, which suggests alternative relaxation mechanisms compared to those observed for Ti02 and ZnO for instance [43]. Since the relaxation was independent of pump power, probe wavelength, pH and surface treatment the fast decay was interpreted to be due to intrinsic mid-bandgap states and trap states rather than surface defects. This is in agreement with earlier investigations [ a ] .
-
-
96
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
Hematite has a good chemical stability in aqueous solutions over a broad pH range [12, 131. Ishikawa and co-workers [13] studied the solubility of hematite in LiOH, NaOH and KOH solutions. An excess of regular powder a-FezO3 and 20 cm3 of alkali hydroxide solution were put in a water bath shaker for 5 hours. The solubility increased with increasing temperature (studied between 303-349°K) and alkali hydroxide concentration, although it remained very low. The solubility was less than l . l ~ l O M - ~ Fe(m> in 10.1 M NaOH at 349°K. Most of the photoelectrochemical studies of hematite have been performed in sodium hydroxide solutions with a concentration less than 1.0 M. In those cases the dissolution in darkness should be negligible. However, when used for photoelectrochemical purposes the degradation becomes more complicated and the current density as well as the photon flux has to be taken into account. It was stated by Kennedy et al [12] that hematite likely was more stable toward photocorrosion than wider bandgap materials like W 0 3 and that its stability towards photocorrosion was comparable to Ti02. However, in the presence of chloride ions the photocorrosion accelerates and degradation was noticed during visible-light irradiation of hematite colloidal solution at pH 0.3 [105]. Apart from photoelectrochemical and electrochemical systems solar generated dihydrogen can also be produced by biochemical and thermochemical methods [106]. For the latter, non-stoichiometric highly solar energy absorbing iron oxide, Fel.,O, as well as nickel and manganese ferrites have been used and studied [ 107-1091. Semiconductor photocatalysis has been successfully applied in degradation of pollutants e.g. SO2 and phenolic waste [69]. It is mainly TiO2, which have been used and studied for this purpose, but there are reports where hematite has been used for photodegradation [52-54, 56, 57, 110, 1111. Hematite has also been studied as a gas sensing material [40]. In this section a more detailed description of the photoresponse for the various hematite materials, which have been studied for the aim of photooxidation. Due to the different ways of presenting the efficiency, a direct comparison of the photoelectrochemical properties of the materials when used for water oxidation is somewhat difficult. 3.4.1. Colloidal Solutions of Hematite A high quantum yield (more than 80% in UV light) was observed by Moser and Gratzel [84] in photoinduced oxidation of iodide on 120 nm-sized iron colloids in suspension in strongly acidic environment. They concluded that the advantage of employing Fe203-sols is that the dimension can be reduced to a size where practically all the photoinduced charge carriers attain the particle surface before recombination can occur. It was stated that such systems could be suitable to become the 02-producing part in a complete water cleavage system. The work was continued by Gratzel et al [112] who found that H2 gas was evolved, despite the unfavorable position of the conduction band, in aqueous solution on irradiation of 80-120 nm colloidal hematite with a solar simulator (100 mW/cm2). The colloidal suspension was obtained after 24 hours hydrolysis of FeC13 at 125°C. It is interesting to notice that H2 was formed under illumination of the colloidal Fez03 particles even in the absence of nobel-metal catalysts and sacrificial electron donors. It was suggested that the small size of the colloidal Fez03 particles induced a shift in the flat-band position towards more negative potentials. However, Nozik and co-workers [ 113, 1141 determined the flatband potential for particles in the size range of 50 to 350 8, to -0.35 V (vs. NHE) at pH 11, which is in close agreement with the value derived for the bulk
Chapter 3; T.Lindgren, et al.
97
material. It should also be mentioned that contrary to the study by Gratzel and co-workers [ 1121 it was found in a photochemical study of colloidal hematite of similar dimensions to those used by Gratzel and co-workers [47] that without an electron relay (MV”) no dihydrogen gas was produced at all upon irradiation. Suspensions of hematite have also been used and studied for other aims than photooxidation of water, e.g. catalytic oxidation of sulphur dioxide in aqueous solutions [52]. Aqueous dispersion of semiconductor particles could be an easy and attractive way to photooxidise water, but they have the drawback that dihydrogen and dioxygen are produced simultaneously in the same suspension. Apart from the separation problem the two produced gases may create a pathway for back reactions that reduces the yield of the overall photo-oxidation process. The latter obstacle can partly be avoided by addition of Na2C03, which was successfully shown by Arakawa et a1 [115]. 3.4.2. Hematite Single Crystal Materials 3.4.2.a. Hematite Single Crystal
The quantum efficiency of the single crystal hematite electrodes [9] in 0.1 M NaOH aqueous solution polarized at 0.64 V vs. NHE was less than 0.005 at 380 nm and was decreasing with increasing wavelength of monochromic light. These single crystals were obtained by flux growth from a Li2Mo04flux melt and had a doping density of 1 ~ 1 0 ’ ~ cm-3 and a band gap around 2.2 eV. Single crystals of hematite grown by chemical vapor deposition (CVD), were prepared by Launay and Horowitz [5]. However, they reported that the crystals of undoped hematite were not suitable for photoelectrochemical purposes due to their high resistivity, lo6SZcm. 3.4.2.b. Doped Hematite Single Crystal
An investigation of 2-doped single crystal hematite grown by CVD at 1300 K was reported by Launay and Horowitz [5]. The quantum efficiency in 1M NaOH at 0.64 V were about 0.12,0.16 and 0.21 for doping densities of 1 . 5 ~ 1 0 ’3~., 5 ~ 1 0and ’ ~ 6.5~10’~cm”, respectively. It is interesting to note that the quantum efficiency increased with the square root of the reciprocal donor concentration. The resistivity, measured by four point probe technique, varied with the doping density and was found in the range of 75-4 Qcm for the samples mentioned. The bandgap was determined photoelectrochemically to 2.1 eV. It was stated that the stability towards photocorrosion was good in alkaline solution. The corrosion current was lower than 0.1% of the total photocurrent. In order to reduce the bias needed for photo-oxidation of water at hematite electrodes single crystals of YFe03 were flux and melt grown [28]. The bandgap was determined to 2.58 eV for YFe03 and the flat-band in 1 M NaOH was located at -0.22 V vs. NHE. Low photocurrent densities (1 pA/cm2 at 0.74 V) and accordingly low IPCEvalues (less than 0.01) was related to the high resistivity (around 40 k!2. cm) of the material in combination with trap states. The results indicate that this material is not a suitable candidate for photoassisted water splitting in the visible region of the solar spectrum. The results obtained by doping with 2 are promising [5]. It can be concluded that single crystals of hematite generally exhibit low current response and high resistivity, which make them a less attractive candidate for photo-
98
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
electrochemical purposes. However, the PEC response of hematite single crystals can be improved by doping [5, 91. Preparation of single crystal of hematite, like single crystal of many other materials, can be complicated and expensive. A polycrystalline material is usually more suitable for industrial production. 3.4.2.c. Mixed Hematite Single Crystal
Single crystals of corundum iron titanates, FeTi03 (ilmenite), FeZTiO4 and FezTi05, were synthesized by heating in vacuum to 1450°C for 15 min the appropriate stoichiometric mixtures of Fe, FezO3, and Ti02 [27]. The single crystals were then grown from the melt under an argon atmosphere by the Czochralski technique [ 1161. Bandgaps for these materials were 2.16 eV for FeTi03, 2.12 eV for Fe2Ti04and 2.18 eV for FezTiO5 similar to the value of hematite. The flatband potential at pH 14 (1 M NaOH) was in the range of 0.34 to 0.74 V, indicating that a larger bias is required to split water at these materials than at hematite. Resistivities for the samples were determined by four probe techniques and were typically of the order of 10-100 Qcm. The best result among these materials was recorded for FeTi03. However, the photocurrent and the IPCE values were low (pA/cm2). A linear relationships of iphoto a light intensity for all three materials up to 1200 mW/cmz where found. The authors interpreted this as if the intrinsic bulk properties of the semiconductor rather than the electrode kinetics at the interface, were limiting the photocurrent. 3.4.3. Polycrystalline Hematite Materials 3.4.3.a. Polycrystalline hematite
In photo-assisted water splitting, high purity hematite anodes resulted in a very low quantum efficiency of 0.03 [ l ] at a wavelength of 380 nm and a bias of 1.25 V vs. NHE in 0.01M NaOH, or even no photoresponse at all [2, 191. Those electrodes were prepared by pressing high purity a-FezO3 powder, the pellets were then sintered at high temperature (T 21000°C). Although the photoresponse of plain polycrystalline hematite has been poor, doping and thin films of poly-crystalline hematite have proven to be efficient ways to decrease recombinations of photogenerated charges and increase the photoresponse, see below. 3.4.3.b. Polycrystalline Hematite Thin Films
To reduce the loss of recombination, one method suggested by Itoh and Bockris [35, 361 was to use very thin film anodes. In this way, the space charge layer can be adjusted to be of the same thickness as the film. Thus recombinations are restricted. Stacking and interconnecting a number of thin film electrodes after each other can compensate the absorption loss due to the small electrode thickness [35]. Thin film iron oxide electrodes were easily made by spray pyrolysis of a 0.1 M FeC13 ethanolic solution containing 0.1 M HC1 onto hot SnO2-coated glass (35OoC, in air) using NZas carrier gas. It was mentioned that approximately 40A of Fe203film was deposited by one spraying; 1-2 min intervals were taken between each spraying to avoid excess cooling of the substrate [36]. Nothing was mentioned about the form of iron oxide obtained by spray pyrolysis. However, considering the preparation procedure one might conclude that hematite was
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
99
formed. The thickness of the films was controlled by observing interference colors. Their study showed a photocurrent of 0.3 mA/cm2 for a 60 nm thick film at pH 13 at 0.84 V versus NHE and 1 sun from a solar simulator. Ten stacked electrodes gave 1.6 mA/cm2 under the same condition. This can be compared with a photocurrent density of about 0.5 mA/cm2 for a single anode of thickness 600 nm at similar conditions [35, 361. This represents a significant contribution for the application of hematite. The spray pyrolised thin film electrode of hematite has been further investigated by Khan et al with undoped and iodine-doped [37, 381 iron oxide thin films. For the undoped iron oxide [37, 381 (for the doped spray pyrolised iron oxide see next paragraph) a similar deposition technique as described above was used. However, O2 was used instead of nitrogen as carrier gas. Raman spectroscopic analysis indicated the formation of a hematite film. It was concluded that the rates of photoelectrochemical oxidation of water at these spray-pyrolised thin film electrodes were dependent on the spray time, substrate temperature, solvent composition in the spray solution, and the concentration of the spray solution. Using the optimum conditions, a maximum photocurrent density for the hematite was as high as 3.7 mA/cm*. This was obtained in 1 M NaOH solution at a bias of 0.7 V vs. SCE and at a light intensity of 500 W/m2. The photoresponse corresponded to an overall efficiency (light energy to chemical energy) of 1.84%. The study showed an optimum film thickness which was related to the balance between light absorption by the film and recombination losses due to reduction in the electric field gradient in thicker films. There was no information given about the film thickness in this specific paper. However, referring to the earlier investigation of the same group [117] where a growth rate of 100 d m i n was assumed, it may be estimated that the optimum film thickness in the latest described investigation was in the range 50-100 nm. It was neither stated which form the formed iron oxide had. Considering the preparation temperature and the bandgap of the obtained film it should be hematite. A substrate temperature of 35OoC, a total spray time of 60 s and a spray solution of 0.11 M FeC13 in 100% ethanol was suggested as the optimum parameters. The duration of each spray was kept at 10 s, with a 5-min interval to maintain a constant substrate temperature. The distance between the substrate and the spray nozzle was not mentioned, neither was the spray rate (ml/min) and carrier gas. It should be ' (measured at frequency mentioned that the donor density (Nd) was as high as 2 . 2 ~ 1 0 ~cm-3 of 1000 Hz) [38]. This reduces the resistivity of the film and makes the space charge layer very thin. The authors consequently suggested that high donor density of the pyrolytically synthesized films may be one reason behind the high photocurrent density due to its low resistivity. The bandgap for the spray-pyrolysed thin films of hematite was found to be 1.97-2.05 eV [37, 381 regardless of the doping density. There are others reports on hematite prepared by spray-pyrolysis [39, 401. Although no photoelectrochemical measurements were done these reports are interesting due to the findings and the rigorously material characterizations of the prepared films. Wang et a1 [40] reported successful formation of a highly nanocrystalline a-FezO3 thin films successfully onto Si(ll1) substrates. AFM studies confirmed that the porous film consisted of spherical particles of about 60nm diameter having columnar ordered structure and preferred orientation [ 1041. In the preparation, an aqueous ethanol solution of iron acetylacetonate (0.01 M) was chosen as the precursor. Air was used as carrier gas and typical substrate temperature was around 380°C or higher to obtain the spherical nanoporous structure. The film thickness was around 300 nm. The thin films showed good sensitivity to CH4 and it was suggested that the spray pyrolysed nanocrystalline hematite
100
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
films could be promising thin film gas-sensing material. Considering the earlier successful results with spray pyrolised hematite [35-381, it would be interesting to also study the photoelectrochemical properties of the material synthesized by Wang and co-workers [40]. 3.4.3.12.Polycrystalline Doped Hematite
The most frequently used substances for n-doping of hematite are oxides of silicon and titanium. Photo-oxidation of water at Si- and Ti-doped hematite has accordingly been studied extensively [ l , 6, 7, 12, 18, 20, 21, 611. In general, the conductivity is improved by these dopants. However, there seems to be a limit for the improvement by doping. For example, concentrations over 0.5 atom percent of titanium in hematite have been stated to have no effect on the resistivity [7]. Interesting studies of silicon [12, 18, 211 and titanium [6, 211 doped polycrystalline hematite were performed by Kennedy and co-workers. The electrodes were prepared by mixing of a-FezO3 with reagent grade SiOz, or TiOz, pressing and sintering. Sintering was carried out in air at 1250-1350°C from 4 to 24 hours followed by quenching to room temperature. Photoelectrical properties of the doped polycrystalline electrodes were studied. For irradiated silicon doped polycrystalline iron oxide electrodes (Eg-2.2 eV) in HzSO4 and in NaOH over a broad pH range photogenerated dioxygen was collected and a maximum of 100% faradaic collection efficiency [123. This means that all of the photocurrent was utilized for dioxygen evolution at the hematite electrode, this was the case even at high incident light intensities. The photocurrent densities were in the mA/cmz region at a light intensity of 700 mW/cmz. However, after the period of the experiment (80 h) in acid environment traces of Fe(m> were found in the electrolyte which indicate degradation of the electrode. It should be mentioned that low photocurrent and low quantum efficiency for Ti-doped hematite have also been reported [61]. Hematite electrodes doped with Si, Ge, Sn or Pb have been reported by Kennedy et al [2]. Pressed pellets were sintered at 1250-1370°C for 3-40 hours. They showed high photocurrent in 0.1 M NaOH at 400 nm with 4-18 mW/cm2 light intensity. Photocurrent densities at 0.7 V versus NHE were about 160, 115, 110, 90 and 5 pA/cm2 for a-Fez03 electrodes doped with 2% Si, 0.002% Sn, 0.008-0.05% Pb, 0.05% Ge and 1% Ti respectively. The bandgap was similar of all group IV-doped electrodes and was around 2.2 eV. Similarly pressed and sintered iron oxide, doped with 0.1% GeO under 150 mW/cm2 polychromatic illumination in 1 M NaOH, showed a net photocurrent densities as high as 1 mA/cm2 [19]. The resistivity of FeZ-xGex03varied from lo6 SZcm for x = 0 to about 0.1 Qcm for x = 0.05. The solubility limit of GeOz in Fez03was reported to be 5 mol%. The investigations of Fez' as dopant for hematite are interesting due to the ease of preparation [23, 24, 261. Iron oxide pellets were prepared from high purity Fe304, a-FezO3, y-FezO3 and CrzO3 powders. After mixing the powders with B O z to the desired composition the mixtures were pressed and sintered at various temperatures (1300-1600°C) during 24 hr. A doping level of 10'' cm-3 corresponded approximately to 1% Fez+in the structure. The bandgap energy was evaluated to 1.9 eV. The electrode yielded a photocurrent density of around 0.4 mA/cm2 (normalized to 1 W lamp output) in a borate buffer (pH 8.4, 0.6 V versus SCE) at a wavelength of 350 nm [23]. Increased photocurrent with doping concentration was reported. No upper limit for the doping concentration was mentioned. It was stated that the chemical stability of the iron oxide samples in aqueous electrolyte of 5 M HCl decreased dramatically with higher doping densities than 1021cmS3.
Chapter 3; T.Lindgren, et al.
101
However, the stability of Fe2+-dopedhematite could be significantly improved by addition of CrzO3 to the iron oxide samples [23]. The amount of added Cr2O3 was typically of 40%. Thin sputtered Fez03 film electrodes (a RF-magnetron sputtering system was used with a Fez03 target) doped by means of partial reduction treatment at cathodic potentials were prepared by Virtanen and co-workers [26]. The photocurrent behavior of the Fe3'oxides was strongly determined by the presence of Fez+in the oxide. It was shown that the photocurrents were strongly increased after the reduction treatment, as a consequence of increased doping density. A reduction treatment of -0.6 V vs. SCE for one hour gave a photocurrent of 190 pA/cm2 (at a wavelength of 520 nm) measured at 200 mV versus SCE in borate buffer, pH 8.4. The photocurrents were normalized to 1 W lamp power output. The bandgap energies of the electrodes were between 1.8 to 1.9 eV. The authors did not comment on the stability of the material after the reduction treatment nor the doping density was mentioned. The results indicate that hematite doped with Fez+may be prepared from magnetite, Fe304. The p/n assembly described by Somorjai and co-workers [l, 20, 221 was operative only when light created a photopotential large enough. It was reported 111 that the maximum quantum efficiency at 380 nm at a bias of 1.25 V for undoped hematite at pH 12 was 0.03, while a 10% Si-doped n-type hematite electrode resulted in a ten-fold increase in quantum efficiency under the same conditions. The Si-doped n-type iron oxide disk electrodes were prepared by mixing fine powders of a-Fe2O3 and SiOz so that 0 c Si/Si + Fe 5 20 at. % [20]. Similarly, p-type iron oxide disks were produced by mixing powders of a-FezO3 and MgO so that 0 c M g N g + Fe I 20 at. %. The mixtures were pressed into pellets, heated in air at 134O-139O0C and rapidly cooled. The resulting mixed iron oxide disks had resistivities in the range lo3 -lo4Qcm. Both electrodes were found to be indirect bandgap semiconductors, with bandgap of approximately 2.3 eV. The 5% Mg-doped hematite gave at the same wavelengths an IPCE of 0.03 at 0.25 V [l]. No precise illumination conditions were mentioned. Both dihydrogen and dioxygen gases were produced with the unbiased device in 0.01 M NaOH, at the Fermi level of 0.75 V [ l , 221. The photocurrent density measured at a light intensity of 35 mW/cm was stabilized at 15 pA/cm2 for two weeks [ l , 221. The device worked also in 0.1 M NaZSO4solution with a photocurrent density of 5-10 pA/cmZ [20]. Also here the exact illumination condition was not given. Additional work by Somorjai and co-workers on the preparation and the properties of the Mg-doped p-type hematite was reported [25]. It is an interesting work since it is one of the very few articles concerning p-type hematite. Other workers have found p-type behavior of iron oxides, but no photoelectrochemical measurements were reported [9, 171. Sanchez and co-workers [19] tried to synthesize Mg-doped hematite by mixing with metallic Mg or MgO with following firing. However, their attempt was not successful. Iodine-doped hematite has also been studied. The iodine-doped thin films of iron oxide were obtained by spray pyrolysis. The condition for the preparation was not described in detail, apart that a mixture of an 80% ethanolic solution of 0.01 M iodine and 0.1 M FeC13 was used. Undoped films of 50 nm film thickness showed a maximum photocurrent density of 1.1 mA/cmz, while a 100 nm thick iodine-doped films had a maximum photocurrent density of 5 mA/cm2 at 0.82 V vs. NHE at pH 13 [37]. These measurements were performed with a xenon lamp with a light irradiation of only 150 mW/cm2. At the same condition, it was suggested by model calculation that an optimized stack of five iodine-doped hematite electrodes was expected to yield a photocurrent density of 15 mA/cm2.
102
Photo-oxidationof Water at Hematite Electrodes
It can be concluded that doped polycrystalline hematite indeed can be interesting for photoelectrolysis of water. The studied area has been intensively researched and some of the findings represent promising photoelectrochemical properties. In combination with the ease of preparation and good stability towards photocorrosion this make doped polycrystalline electrodes of hematite an interesting material for direct conversion of solar energy into dihydrogen. 3.4.3.d. Mixed Polycrystalline Oxides of Hematite
To improve the photoelectrochemical properties of hematite, mixing with other oxides, like a thin layer of TiOz deposit on polycrystalline hematite has been investigated [45]. The heterojunction electrodes were made by deposition of TiOz with CVD technique on hematite substrates prepared by flame oxidize iron metal. It was reported that holes generated in hematite did participate in the reaction at the TiOz/electrolyte interfacial, though an external bias was still required. The onset potential of the heterojunction moved cathodically to -0.46 V, towards the same value as that of TiOz on Pt in 0.1 M NaOH [45]. This is interesting since the cathodic shift of the onset makes dihydrogen evolution possible. However, the photocurrent remained unchanged at potentials over 0.14 V. No data for the bandgap, the resistivity or the stability of the material were mentioned. More complex oxides have also been investigated, like CdFez04 and PbFelz019 [SI. The former was prepared by solid-state reaction of the respective oxides and the latter was grown from a PbO-PbFz flux. The bandgap was 2.3 eV for both materials. Up in 0.2 M NaOH were 0.8 and 1.0 V, respectively. The photocurrent density of PbFelzO19was good, well established in the mA/cmZregion for an applied potential of 0.75 V vs. NHE. A 100 W Xe lamp was used, but the incident light intensity was not mentioned. The photocurrent density of CdFezO4 was considerable less, which was attributed to the higher resistivity, 500 SZcm compared to less than 10 SZcm for PbFelZOl9. 3.4.4. Nanostructured Thin Films of Hematite 3.4.4.a. Nanostmctured Films of Spherical Particles of Hematite
In nanosized particle film electrodes, photogenerated holes can be rapidly transferred to the semiconductor/electrolyteinterface and there be captured by the redox species in the electrolyte. In this way, the recombination losses can be diminished. This is of great importance for semiconductors like hematite with a very short hole diffusion length (2-4 nm). Another advantage is the large internal surface area, which characterize nanostructured semiconductor film electrodes. The latter decreases the current density per unit area of semiconductor / electrolyte interface. In general, few studies have been conducted on the photoelectrochemical properties of nanosized Fez03. Miyoshi et a1 [58] studied the PEC response of hematite nanoparticles (1.8 - 11.8 nm determined by TEM) prepared in Nafion and attached to a glassy carbon electrode. The photoelectrochemical experiments were carried out in aqueous solution of 0.1 M NazS04 containing 0.1 M sodium tartrate as a sacrificial reagent (pH 7). The photoresponse was in the PA-scale with bias. Interesting was the study of the band gap energy. The maximum size quantization achieved was 1.2 eV with positive shifts in the valence bands and negative shifts in the conduction bands with almost equal rate. Quantum confinement was also reported for nanostructured hematite incorporated in sodium mont-
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
103
morillonite clay interlayers for the aim of photodecomposition of acetic acid [ 1181. The nanosized hematite particles in the clay interlayers was determined to be around 7 8, and they exhibited a bandgap ca. 0.28 eV greater than bulk hematite. Bjijrksten et a1 [44] designed and studied a hematite nanostructured electrode. The synthesis of the nanostructured electrode was clearly stated in the article and based on solgel deposition where the colloidal Fez03 was prepared by hydrolysis of FeC13. Unfortunately, investigation showed that the photoresponse of the nanostructured hematite electrode was very low. Illumination through the substrate/electrode interface (SEillumination) [ 1191 yielded an IPCEsE I 0.8% at a wavelength around 350 nm in 0.1 M NaOH aqueous solution with the potential being fixed at 0.4 V vs. SCE [44]. At the same conditions, illumination through the electrolyte/electrode interface (EE-illumination) [ 1191 gave an IPCEEEI 0.008%. The better efficiency for backside illumination is typical for nanostructured electrodes where the electron transport in the film is described by means of diffusion [ l o l l and where the current generation is most efficient close to the back contact [120]. The pronounced difference in IPCE values under SE and EE illumination showed that the collection of photogenerated electrons across the film is very inefficient. In a porous film consisting of interconnected nanometer sized semiconductor particles the effective surface area can be enhanced 1000-fold [ 1211. Therefore, nanostructured electrodes can be good for unravel the surface phenomena. By scrutinizing the effect of iodine on the performance of the electrode it was concluded that the effect of surface states was small in the nanostructured hematite electrode. It was stated that the bulk and grain boundary recombination remained dominant. This is in consistency with the report from Cherepy et aZ[43]. A large number of researcher groups are currently involved in work on nanostructured iron oxides films [16, 31-34,40,48,49, 118, 122-1291,Apart from hematite (~-FezO3),the iron oxide magnetite (Fe304) is also prepared and investigated in the nanoregime for magnetic studies [42, 130-1331. Recently, 30 nm thin films of Fe2O3-TiOZwere prepared on Pt substrates by coldwall low-pressure metallorganic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) [ 161. Iron(m> acetylacetonate [Fe(OzC5H7)3]and tetraisopropoxytitanium [Ti(0-i-C3H7)4]were used as vapor sources and heated at 130" and 30"C, respectively. Dioxygen was used as a reaction gas and nitrogen was used as a carrier gas. The thicknesses of the films were small, adjusted to around 30 nm by monitoring the deposition time. A maximum quantum yield (defined as percentage of injected electrons per absorbed photon) of 1.1% in 0.5 M HzS04 (pH 0.4) at 1.2 V was obtained for amorphous electrodes with a mole ratio corresponding to 0.2 Fe-0.8 Ti [16]. However, undoped polycrystalline Fez03 showed higher quantum yield (1.6%) under the same condition. Another finding was that the band gaps of films with different composition changed linearly with the fraction of Ti cation, from 1.9 eV for pure Fez03 to 3.1 eV for pure Ti02 [ 161. Although nanostructured films as well as colloidal solution of hematite have improved the understanding of the photoelectrochemical properties and its limiting factors intrinsic bulk recombinations are still the controlling factor of the photocurrent. However, with a deeper understanding of the fundamental properties of hematite and new synthesizing methods, there is still hope for improvements of the nanostructured materials in the application for photoelectrochemical water splitting. One promising approach is the purpose-designed electrodes of hematite nanorods.
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
104
3.4.4.b. Hematite Nanorods
Another work in the nano regime field is the development of hematite nanorods at our department [ l l , 14, 29, 301. Anisotropic crystallites elongated along c axis, e.g., where the dielectric constant is the highest and where the diameter of such nanorods matches the minority carrier diffusion length, reported to be 2-4 nm [30]. For thin film composed of such rod, photogenerated holes have a short distance to travel to reach the electrode/electrolyte interfacial region at the same time the excited electrons can move towards the back contact without passing any grain boundaries, see Fig. 3.5. Thus, the nanorod design facilitates a more efficient charge carrier separation, which should reduce recombinations of photoinduced charge carriers. Accordingly, IPCE measurements were promising. The IPCEsE and IPCEEE at 350 nm in a three-electrode system, with 0.1 M KI in water (pH 6.8) as electrolyte were determined to 13% and 5 %, respectively [ l l ] . Interestingly, in a two-electrode set-up with 0.5 M LiI + 50 mM 12 in ethylene carbonate/propylene carbonate (5050 by weight) as electrolyte a respectable IPCEsE value of 56 % at 340 nm was reported.
I
I
I
I
Fig. 3.5. Schematic representation of the electron transport through (a) spherical particles and (b) nanorods.
Considering there are no grain boundaries present in the material, the quite low photoresponse may be due to i) intrinsic recombinations centers located in mid bandgap states or ii) slow interfacial kinetics at the nanostructured semiconductor/electrolyte interface. To reveal to influence of the charge transfer kinetics on the photoresponse at hematite nanorods IPCEsE was studied as a function of the light intensity in different electrolytes. In an aqueous solution of 0.1 M NaOH (Fig. 3.5a) the highest light intensity yields the lowest IPCE~E,which indicates that most of the produced electron-hole pair recombine. In contrast, in a solution of ethylene carbonate/propylene carbonate (5050 by weight) containing 0.5 M r and 0.5 mM I2 in which r is a well-known hole scavenger [ 111, IPCEsE shows very small dependency with light intensity (Fig. 3.5b). This indicates that the material is able to handle the photogenerated electron-hole pairs fairly well as long as the hole kinetics at the interface is fast. The same result was obtained in a three-electrode set-up and purging the electrolyte in the 3-electrode vessel with N2 or bubbling with 0 2 did not affect the results.
Chapter 3; T. Lindgren, et al.
105
Since the presence or absence of O2 did not alter the photoresponse, it was concluded that the loss of conduction band electrons to dioxygen also in the 2-electrode experiment was negligible. Consequently, the oxidation of water by photogenerated holes causes the strong dependency of the photoresponse on light intensity. The slow water oxidation kinetics at the hematite interface favours the recombination of the photogenerated charges. Experiments on nanoporous Ti02 electrodes showed no dependency between IPCEsE and light intensity in various electrolytes, which confirm the fast oxidation kinetics at the Ti02 semiconductor/electrolyte interface [ 1341. It was also observed that the hematite photocurrent was higher, and a more linear relationship between photocurrent and intensity was observed when r was present as a hole scavenger compared to the experiment when only water was used. Indeed the experiments with 13-/I-indicated that hematite was capable of handling a fairly high rate of photogenerated electrons, as long as the holes are quickly withdrawn at the nanostructured semiconductor/ electrolyte interface (SEI).
400
350
450
500
550
600
650
700
Wavelength I nm
I
204A
i
15
“i
A
25 mWcm” 1 mwcm“
0
v
0.3 mWcm”
u %0
o
0.1 mwcm”
A
b)
E 5 0
350
400
450
500
L 550
600
650
700
Wavelength I nm Fig. 3.6. Action spectra (2-electrode set-up). Illumination from back-side (SE) in a) aqueous 0.1 M NaOH and in b) 0.5 M I-, 0.5 mM I2 in ethylene carbonate/propylene carbonate (5050% by weight).
106
Photo-oxidation of Water at Hematite Electrodes
It was concluded that by combining a hematite nanorod electrode with a suitable water oxidation catalysts, for instance platinum or ruthenium dioxide, the photoelectrochemical activity for direct water splitting applications should increase by a factor of 20. The promising initial study of hematite nanorod initiated a study of hematite nanorods for the aim of water oxidation [29]. IPCEsEand IPCEEEin a three-electrode set-up were determined at 350 nm to 2.3 % and 1.0 %, respectively. The fact that IPCEsE is twice the IPCEEE reveals that the collection of the photogenerated electrons across the hematite film is poor. Nevertheless, the ratio in the quoted investigation [29] is significantly smaller compared to the nanosized isotropic ‘random walk’ hematite particle system reported by Bjiirksten et a1 [44]. The photocurrent density at an intensity of 1 sun was in the pA/cm2 scale in 0.1 M NaOH.
3.5. Conclusion and Future Scopes Hydrogen production from water using hematite and solar energy is still in an experimental stage. Bulk recombination and slow kinetics at the semiconductor/electrolyte interface are the major causes to the low photoresponse for hematite electrodes in aqueous solutions. Due to different ways to report the photoresponse it is difficult to directly compare different studies. In summary it can be said that most attempts to increase the photoresponse has failed or shown little improvement. However, there are some exceptions. Some studies of doped hematite were promising and yielded photocurrents in or just below the mA/cm2region [2, 18, 19,23, 371. The studies of nanostructured hematite are interesting [ l l , 14,29, 30, 43, 441, mainly because they contribute to the understanding of the physical reasons for the poor charge transport properties of hematite, e.g. revealing the low influence of surface states [43, 441 and the importance of fast interfacial kinetics of the hole-water oxidation rate (291. However, it is important to keep in mind that there is no band bending in nanostructured hematite. Therefore, the results from studies of nanostructured hematite materials cannot be considered as valid for hematite materials in general. The most promising studies for water oxidation on hematite are the studies of spray pyrolysed nanometer thin films of hematite [35-381. High efficiency combined with ease of fabrication and low cost of the material make these films very interesting. Conversion efficiencies as high as 4.9% were reached at moderate bias [38]. Since hematite absorbs a great part of the incident solar irradiation energy a similar tandem set-up as described by Gratzel et a1 [92, 1351 would be at least as efficient for hematite as for WO3. The nanocrystalline dye-sensitised Ti02 cell could also be substituted with a long wavelength absorbing p-type material to work in combination with the hematite electrode in a pln assembly. Especially if