Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Cliurcli aru£ Society in Vocuments 100-600 )t[.'lJ.
edited by
Alan L. Hayes
Canadian Scbolan'
~s Inc.
Toronto
1995
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p i. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=2 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 2 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
First published in 1995 by Canadian Scholars' Press Inc. 180 BloorSaect Wes~ Ste. 801 Toron
Main entry under tide:
Church and society in documents: !O
I. Hayes. Alan I.auffer.
BR160.A2C58 1995
270.1 <:95-931898-4
Page layout by Bnul Ho1'11illg Printed and bound in Canada
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p ii. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=3 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 3 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
To Margaret Hayes Parsons MyModlcr
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p iii. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=4 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 4 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
This page intentionally left blank
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p iv. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=5 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 5 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Tab!<: of Contents
Introduction .............. ............................................................................. vii
Chapter 1 The Pliny-Trajan Correspondence ................................................... 1 Chapter 2 I>idacbi ... ............ ..... .... .......... .................................................... . 7 Ignatius, To tbe Epbesians ........................................ ................... 19
Chapter 3 Gospel of Thomas ... .... ............................... ........... ..... ................. 27
Chapter4 justin, S«ond ApOlogy .. .............. ............ ................... ................. 45
Chapter 5 Manyrdcm ofPerpetua ........................................ ............. .. ....... 59
Chapter 6 Hippolytus? Apostolic Tradition?............................ .................. ... 73
Chapter?
Orlgen, "First Homily on the Song of Songs" ........................ ........ 97
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p v. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=6 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 6 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
ChapterS Cyprian, Trealise to Demetrianus ............................................. 115 Chapter9 Acts of the Councilq{A~ua .......................... ............................ 135 Chapter 10
Gregory ~ l.ell8rs JOJ, 102, 202 (Against the ApoiJinarians) ...................................................... 147 Chapter 11 Ambto$e, Letter:< 20, 2] ................... ..... .. ................ .................. 165 Chapter 12 John CluysostOm, Hcnnllies on the Gospel q{St.John. 62 ......... .. 181 Chapter 13 Paulinus ofNola, Letter 29 ........................................................ 197 Chapter 14 Augustine of Hippo, Letter 211 ("The 1/uk") ... ....... ................... 215 Chapter 15 Paaick, Confession ..................... ...................................... ........ 229 Chapter 16
Pope Leo I, "The Tome• ............................................................ 247 Chapter 17 Antonlus, '!be Life and Daily Mode ofliving of 8lessetJ Simeon the s:yllte ...... ................... ............................ .... 259 Chapter 18 1be Penltenlial q{Columbanus ................................................ 273
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p vi. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=7 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 7 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
. r t
bitmdudio
"'
T
bJs book has grown out of an introductol)' course which I teach at the Toronto School of Theology in the hlstofY of Christianity to the year 6oo. When I fust began teaching i~ something over twenty years ago now, I began looking for early Christian documents which would fire my students' interest in that seminal era, prompt the kinds of questions of interpretation that would lead them naturally into the art of hislodographlcal criticism, and give substance and colour to crucial hislodcal events and personalities. If a document worked well in seminar dis<:ussions I continued to use i~ and if it did not, I replaced it. The result is the selection that is offered here.
Out of the lhousands of documents that I might have chosen, I have selected nineteen. Several aitena have guided my selection. First, the documents included here really are primary sources, witnesSeS in the first six centuries conuming the first six centuries. They are not later traditions, paraphrases, or summaries. In them, students can read the very words of early Christians, in uanslation.
Second, these documents are as complete as we have them. They are not excerptS of larger documents. I have thought that documents which were written as a whole should be interpreted as a whole. A problem with excerpts is that it is the one who does the excerpting, not the student, who decides what is important In the documenL An
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p vii. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=8 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 8 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
unabridged document gives the student better bisroriographical criticism.
scope for practicing
1hitd, these documerus are reasonably short, most of them between ten and twenry pages. Even a srudem who is taking a heavy load of other
oourses simultaneously can fmd time to read one of these documentS each week for a term, and re-read it, and reflect on it, and perhaps even write a short essay about it. Powtb, together these documeOIS illustrate the diversity of early Christian literarure, With its many genres, Its many culrural settings, its many purposes and functions, and Its many theological tendencies. More advanced srudents might weD choose to concentrate on a specific institutional structure, pattern of devotional practice, doctrinal principle, or genre. but I have thought that in a survey oourse sruderus should have an overview of the larger landscape.
rafth, the documents open a few Windows onto the ordinary life of ordinary Christian communlties. In former years a function of a book of Church historical documems was usuaUy to explain how m.o dem denominational doadne, worship, and Institutional strUcrures came to be. I have been more intetemQ in !h~ ~ci~8 wmplellity of early Christian community. True, the documents we have were written by the educated, not the oommon, and preserved for their ecclesiastical ltnportance, not for their historical value, but these constraints, though limiting, are not quite fatal Sixth, the documents show a few of the many ways in whlcb Church and society interacted. In Pliny's letter we see dues to why a Roman governor might feel obliged to persecute Christians; In Perperua's diary we see why a Christian might have felt joy in being persecuted. )ustln. In his Apok>gy, attempts to reconcile his faith With the best In paganiSm; Cyprian, in his treatise, prefers to dissociate them. In the Didacbe, the letter of lgnatius, the work known as the Apostolic Tradition, and the documents from the Couocil of Nlcea, we see quite different Christian approaches to Church organization; perhaps these diverse approaches reflect diverse soda! contextS and divetse experiences of the use of power. In the Gospel of 1bomas, by contrast, Church organization and community seem relatively unimportant. In the works by Origen, Nazianzen, Chrysosto01, and Leo we observe different approaches to
viii
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p viii. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=9 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…39f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 9 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
lnterpteting Scripture; in the background we may disctm the methods and premises of conflicting schools of philosophical thought. Ambrose, as we see In his two leners, Invites himself Into the conscience of the Emperor; in Paulinus and Sitneon the Stylite we see a.s<:edcs who in different ways have sought to renounce the Emperor's world altogether. Augustine's vision of Christian community looks in some ways like a re2ction against worldly sOCial ideals, but in other ways like a "duistianiz:ing" of them. With Patrick and even more with Columbanus, Roman government and culture have grown remote, and Cbtistianity has entered the world of the barbarians. finally, most of the documenrs say somethir1g about women, or at least about the issue of gender. I sbare the desire of most.recent historians to discover the usually hidden role of women in sOCiety.
I have added my own introduction to e2ch document, aloog with some srudy questions. My experience is that a neophyte in history faced with a historical document will usually ask, "Wll2t should I be looking fot/" The best answer is that a new·document, like a new friend, will disclose Itself to one who is willing to listen. But I have found that the best answer is oot always the me& pedagogically effective answer. While I believe that beginning students are as capable as seasoned scholars of asking intelligent questions of a document, in bet in some .ways more capable, beginn.ing students also usually need at least a provisional context for interpretation and they need to develop confidence in their own common sense. The introduaions and study questions are Intended to serve these purposes. But it is the document, not the introduction, which Is the primary source, and I hope very much that readers will DOt allow the introduction to control their lntepretation of the documenL I also hope that students will find more helpful approaches to take and better questions to ask than those which I have provided.
=se
lbe documents range in date from very roughly the year lOO up to about the year 6oo. On the earlier end of the chronological range the New Testament is excluded, since by convention NewTestamentstudies comprise an academic field distinct from Church history; those who want to explore the primary documents of the fmt century may want to consult Steve Mason and Tom Robinson, An Early Christian IIBader (CSP, 1990). On the later end of the range, the year 6oo is frequentiy taken as the symbolic end of the early period of Church history, before
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p ix. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=10 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 10 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
which Christlanlty Is a largely Mediterranean reUgion, and after which it becoa>es a lalgely European religion. AnOther teacher would select other documents for a collection such
as this. I would oot at all want to claim th2t these nineteen documents are the nineteen mOS( important shon documents from ihe early Church. Moreover, there are several documents which, although they exceed twenty Jl"ges, are necessary reading for anyone who Is seeking even an elementaly under.;tanding of early Christianity. I always ask my own students to read Athanasius' Uf• ofArUonyand at least books 11 and m of Augustine's ConfessionS. In my own teaching, I use ihese readingS in conjunction with one of sevel'21 available teXIbooks th2t swvey eady Church history in a llllmlive fashion. I do so for the pedagogical reason that students who know little history, and students who in high school or elsewhere learned to think of history as a chrooologieal collection of peiSOnalities With names, events With dates, and ideas with genealogles, fe<:l more secure in new historical teiTirory if they have a story th2t orders the past into a manageable framework. But I know that if they continue in their study of history, they will sooner or later discover that every element of this manageable framework is undependable.Tbey will discover a multiplicity of competing stories of eady Christianity, each one papering over a profusion of cracks in the historical evidence, and each one with its own version of who was important and what motivated people and how things happened and why things happened the way they did. But by then they will have developed their skills in evaluating primary historical evidenoe, and they will be able to test each of these competing stories. To be free from dependence on someone else's understanding of the past, and to be able to build an undersranding of how the world works by reflecting intelligently on dependable evidence, seems to me to be a pre-condition of inteUecrual, emotional. and s pirirual maturity, and a primary goal of education. I am gnteful to my teaching assistants over the years for a number of things, and particularly, so far as this book Is concerned, for helping me see which documents worked best in seminar discussions. They include Lawrin A.nnstrong, Byard Benneu, Craig Cameron, Paull'riesen, Jeannie Loughrey, Mark Steinacher, and Brad Walton. In former years the Toronto School of Theology course in early Christianity was very much a team
X
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p x. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=11 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 11 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
effolt, and even now, when it is divided into independent seCtions, several of us regularly share thoughts about it with one another. So I arn grateful also that several of my colleagues have helped me see how documents might be selected, introduced, used, and interpreted: Phyllis Airllart, Roben Black, Roben Croken,Jobn Gran~ Blian Hogan, Thomas Mclntite, and the late Michael Sheehan. My wife, the Reverend Morar Murray-Hayes, and my children, }essica and Alexandra, have been not only very patient but also extremely supportive, and their love holds the rest of my llfe together. The book is dedicated to my mother, who not only biologically but also intellectually made it possible.
Wrilina a Sboft Essay Where the documents in this book are used for a course in a university, theological school, or elsewhere. the insttuctor may ask students to write short essays on some of them Here are guidelines for writing a shon essay on an hlstorical document 1. In preparatiOn for the essay, read the texl of the document carefully, and ask yowself historiogr•phical questions about it An historiog12pbical question is one which relates the document to its historical context. The following are examples of historiographical questions: Who (or what ldnd of person) wrote it? for what audience? for what reason? at what lime and in what place? with what like.l y effect? What are the author's theological, cultural, and other premises? What particular issues seem to concern the author? Why did the author choose this particular genre of writing? Does the document show signs of being edited? Ifso, is it possible to distinguish the author's premises, purposes, and historical context from the editor's?
Needless to say, documents don't provide sure answers to all these questions, or to the other questions which you might ask of the document For some questions the documeru will provide no evidence at all; for others it may provide ambiguous data that can be interpreted variously. A key skill for the historian is what Herbert Butterfield called "sympathetic Imagination•. The unattain>ble ideal in reading an historical documeru is to know the author's mind from the inside, to know what the author thought and felt, and why.
xi
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p xi. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=12 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 12 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
2. An essay is the statement, developmen~ and argument of a thesis.
3. The essay should include, usually In the IntroductOry paragraph, a clear statement of a thesis. The thesis Statement makes the main point of your essay. lt differs from the statement of a theme (whidl States a topic to be discussed but not what will be said about iO. lt also differs from a summary (which summarizes the document but doesn't have a point to make about lt). You can test whether an Introductory statement is a thesis statement by seeing whether you can truthfully precede it with the clause, "This essay aims to demonsaate that. ..•• The thesis statement should be substantial, not truistic (incapable of being shown false) or trivial. To the question, "Can a valid argument be made against this thesis statement?" the answer should be "yes".
Example of a statement of a theme: "In this paper we will consider Perperua's diary and explore the cost of ber discipleship In a time of persecution." Example of a summary: "Perpetua was a young woman who was arrested as a Christian in North Africa. The authorities tried very hard to make her recant. While she was in prison, she had several visions. which she reoordtd in her diary. In the first vision, she saw, etc., etc." Example of a !hesls -ement: "fThi.s paper aims to demonstrate that) Perpetua's diary was edited by someone wbo wanted to show that
the authority of prophecy and inspired vision authority of the Church's inst!rutlonal order.·
was greater than the
4. After the Slatement of the thesis in the ftrst paragraph, the second and succeeding paragraphs suppon the thesis by clarifying it, developing it, qualifying it, and arguing it, with reference to lhe primary evidence,
that is,lhe evidence of the text itself. This is by far the longest pan of the paper, and is called lhe •exposition.• The exposition must show that lhe chests statemenl, properly understood. is supported by /be primary evidence of /be text you are examining. The views that modem scholars take about lhe text have no value as evidence, even when !hey State their opinions very emphatically and publish them in Influential textbooks or lmpottant journals or expensive encyclopedias. The views of modern scholars may, however, be valuable for sparking your own thinking about lhe document.
xii
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p xii. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=13 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 13 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
l1<11l000Cl10t<
Yout objective is to pemlllde !he reader, no< !hat your interpretation is uue beyond question. but only !hat it is more probable than the alternatives. You should theld"ore identify and examine alternative possible inrerprecalions, and show why you think your own interpma!ion is p!derable. The exposition is thus a movement of persuasive ;ugwnelllli.
5. Each paragraph represents one argument or idea intended to clarify, develop, or suppon the thesis of the paper. This one argument or idea should be stated in a single topic sentence. This topic sentence should be clarified, developed, qualified, and argued in the rest of the paragraph by lderence to one or more examples from the primary"'"' you're considering. ln other words, each paragraph suppons its topic sentence ln the same way that the essay as a whole supports its thesis statement. Any paragraph which isn't clearly related 10 the thesis of the essay should either be omitted or else revised to make its relevance clear.
6. Transitions connect paragraphs smoothly so that the reader can follow the line of your argument and can see how each of your points relateS to your thesis statement. A uansition can be a sentence either at the end of one paragraph or at the beginning of the next. Or it can be a single word or a shon phrase, such as "the!dore" or •nevellheless•. 7. A shon essay should end with a paragraph which states a conclusion. The conclusion restates the thesis, sums up the points in the exposition. and connectS the thesis to a broader perspective.
8. Avoid over-generalizing. The evidence of a single document is not conclusive proof of the mentality of the author, and it cel!3lnly cannot be used for drawing inferences about !he entire history of Christianity or even about the early Church. For instance, lt cannot be assumed that the lirurgical r.m found in Hippolyrus' Apostolic Tradition represent the common practice of worship in !he early centuries of the Church. In fact, it can't be demonstrated that the textS were ever used by any Christian community at all.
9. Stay in one r.nse, either past or present. 10. Don't moralize, and don't pass judgment on histotical figures. You cannot know as much as God does about •the very= of the beart" or about the events and conditions that shaped the authors
xm
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p xiii. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=14 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 14 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
outlook. Don't asswne that out world ;., better than the past or that the past is better than o ur world. Aim to learn from the past, not to teach it something. 11. Be aware of yoor own premises, and of the perspective which you're bringing to your reading of the document. Be aware also of the limitations of your premises and your perspective. A Word on the: T...U
For most of the texts reproduced in thls volume, many uanslations are available. I have tried to choose readable and reliable ones. Most texts are followed by endnotes. These are not my own. They reproduce the notes provided by the uanslator, or, in tile case of Chapter 10, by the editor of the uanslation. Chapter dWions of the Psalms will be inconsistent according to whether the uanslator is referring to a Roman catllolic text or a Protestant text.
xiv
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p xiv. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=15 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 15 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
The Jlllny-Trajan Correspoodence Pliny'sLdt~. Book X. 96-97 (1121' Bllhynla)
P
liny (G2ius Plinius Caecilius Secundus) was bom in 61 or 62 into a wealthy and socially imponant family. His father died when he was youaa. and he was adopted by his uncle, whom we know as "the elder PUny", a natural scientist and writer. He was well educated and won a reputation for his oratorical skills; be served as an advocate or lawyer in · the Roman cowts. He climbed the ladder of social achievement by being appointed to ever more important civil offices, reaching the pinnacle of prestige, the position of consu~ in the year 100. He wrote numerous le~te!S, carefully poUshed according to the highest rhetorical standards, for publication. In 109 or 110 or 111 the Emperor appointed him governor of the province of Bithynia and Ponrus, in northwestern ASia Minor along the south coast of the Black Sea, where he served two years. He carried on a large administrative correspondence with the Emperor, which has been collected into Book X of bis lett47s. This collection Includes 001 only Pliny's leners but also the Empero(s official replies, or "rescripts". This is the only collection of admlnisuative correspondence between a Roman emperor and an imperial officer in Latin literature, and it is therefore an unusually impon:ant historical source. After Writing these letters Pliny abruptly disappears from history, and there is reason to believe that he died in office in Bithynia.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 1. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=16 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 16 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Trajan (5~117) was born in Seville, in Roman Spain, and was adopted as heir by the Emperor Nerva. He followed Nerva to the impe~ throne in 98. He was an efficient admini.suator who had the Roman Wrasuucrure of roads, bridges, and other public works repaired and extended. He was also an accomplished milil2C)' commander, popular Wilh the army, and through conquests in Dacia (modem Romania) and Panhia (modem northeast Iran), enlarged the Roman Ernpite to its Widest historical boundaries. In addition. he established a system of welfare for the poor children of Italy. According to a medieval legend, Pope Gregory the Great (540?-604), impressed With Trajan's love of justice, secured the release of his soul from heU. Pliny, as a governor, enjoyed considerable authority and prestige in the ~ system. A governor was the overseer of a provin<e. The whole Roman Empire outside Italy was divided into provin<es (the word means •spheres of responsibility"), which were arrangements for administralive convetlien<e without much regard to cultural, racial, or linguistic realities. In most provinces, the governor was appointed by the Emperor, as Pliny was. A governor would nonnally expect to serve for about lhree years. Within his jurisdiction the governor was
w
Many scholars have thought that Pliny wrote his letters primarily to impress the Emperor or to gratify his wte for letter-writing, but others have believed that a provincial governor was indeed expected to be in dose contact With the Emperor. The rescripts of the Emperor had legal authority. Trajan's instructions regarding Christians, as reproduced below, guided im~ policy for some time to come. They were reinforced and elaborated by a rescript of Hadrian, Trajan's successor, in 124/125, which can now be read at the end of the Flm ApolcgyofJustin Martyr, or in Euseblus' &cksiaslk;al Histmy, 4, 9. PUny's adminis1J'3tive letters of Book X were not polished literary exercises written for publication, as his other letters were. They were published after his death by an anonymous editor. The editor unfortunately excised the ceremonial greetings and corlclusions, and the
2
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 2. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=17 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 17 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
date and place ofwriting, which the letters originally must have concalned. The letters weno published in the early sixteenth ceruwy from a Latin manuscript of perhaps the sixlh cenrury, which has since been IOSI.
Questions on the readlog Is PUny's letter a serious request for advice? If so, what is the problem that he is trying to solve? What lnformalion does he aaually have about Christianity, and bow credible is itl Is anything surprising in his understanding of Christian beliefs and practices? What impact were Christians having on society? What is PUny's personal attirude toWards the Chrisaans, and why might he feel the way he does about them? What does he think of the informantS? What appears to be the legal conteXt for his correspondence, and bow does be conceive his own role of polilical leadership in the midst of tensions between Olri.sllans and antJ.Christians What legal or poUtical principles lle behind Trajan's ~pt (teply)?
It is roy rule, Sire, to refer to you in rnaaers wbeno I am uncertain. For who can beaer direct my hesitation or insUuct my ignorance? I was never present at any UiaJ of Christians; tberefore I do not know what are the customary penalties or investigations, and what limits are observed. [2) I have hesitated a great deal on the question whether there should be any distinction of ages; whether the weak should have the same treatment as the more robust; whether those who recant should be pardoned, or whether a man who has ever been a Christian should gain nothing by ceasing to be such; whether the name itself, even if innocent of crime, should he punished, or only the Crimes aaacbing to that name.
Source' Pllny·TraJan oonespoodetlce, In Henry Benenson, ed., Documentt of lbe Clmnlan Cburcb, 2nd ed., OXford Uni~ Press, J967, ~-
3
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 3. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=18 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 18 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Meanwhile, this is the course that lluve adopted In tbe =of those brought bdon: me as Christians. 131 I ask them if they are Christians. If they admit Ill repeat the question a second and a third time, thn:atening capital punishment; if they persist I sentence them to death. For I do not doubt tha~ whatever kind of <:rime it may be to which they bave confessed, their pertinacity aod inflexible obstinacy should certainly be punished. [4] There wen: odlers who dispbyed a like madness and whom I reserved to be sent to Rome, since they wen: Roman citizens. Then:upon the usual result followed; the very fact of my dealing Wflh the question led to a wider spread of the charge, and a great variety of cases wen: brought before me. [5] M anonymous pamphlet was issued, containing many names. All who denied that they were or had been Christians I amsiden:d should be discharged, because they called upon the gods at my dlct&tion and did reverence, with incense and wine, to your image which I had ordered to be brought forward for thls purpose, together with tbe starues of the deities; and especially because r.hey cursed Christ, a thing which, it is said, genu.l ne Christians cannol be induced to do. [61 Others named by the informe r first said that they were Christians and then denied it; declaring that they had been but w ere so no longer, some having recanted r.hree years or more before and one o r two as long ago as twenty years. They all worshipped your image and the starues of r.he gods and cursed Christ. !7l But they declan:d that the sum of r.heit guilt or error had amounted only to this, that on an appointed day they had been accustomed to meet bdon: daybre2k, and to recite a hymn antiphonally' to Christ. as to a god, and to bind tben>selves by an oar.h.' not for r.he commiSsion of any crime but to abstain from theft, robbery, adultery and breach of faith, and nor to deny a deposit when it was claimed. After the conclusion of this ceremony it was their custom to depan and meet again to tlke food; but it was ordinary and harmless food, and they bad ceased this practice after my edict in which, in accordance with your orders, I had fo!bidden secret societies. [8] I thought it the more necessary, therefore, to find out what truth there was In this by applying tortUre to two maidsetvants, who were called deaconesses.' But I found nothing but a depraved and extravagant superstition, and I therefore postponed my exlUJlination and had recourse to you for consultltion.
4
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 4. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=19 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 19 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
191 The maner seemed to me to justify my consulting you, especially on account of the number of those imperilled; for many persons of aU ages and classes and of both sexes are being put in peril by accusation,
and this will go on. The contagion of !his superstition has spread not only in the dties, but in the vi.lbges and rural distriCIS as well; yet it seems capable of being ched<ed and set right. 1101 There is no shadow of doubt that the temples, which have been almost deserted, are beginning 10 be frequented once mor<:, !bat the saer<:d rites which have been long neglected are being renewed, and that sacrificial victims are for sale everywhere, whereas, till recently, a buyer was rarely 10 be found Prom this it is easy to imagine what a bost of men could be set righ~ were !hey given a chanoe of recantation.
TrajtJ" to Pftff)l You have taken the right line, my dearPiiny, In examining the cases of those denounced to you as Christians, for no hard and fast rule can be
laid down, of universal application. (21 They are no! 10 be sough! out; if they are informed againSt, and the charge is proved, they are to be punished, with this reservation - that if any one derties that he is a Christian, and actually proves i~ !bat is by worshipping our gods, he shall be pardoned as a result of his r<:eantation, however suspect he may have been with respect to the past Pamphlets published anonymously should carry no weight in any charge whatsoever. They oonstirute a very bad preceden~ and are also out of keeping with this age.
Notes ·carmen •.. dicere secum inVicem'- •carmen; generally translated 'hymn,' may mean any set fo<m of words; her<: permps a responsoria! or antiphonal psalm, or some kind of liuny. 'sacramen
the word chosen by the Chrisljans -
migl1t ouggest 10
Romans a coospiracy. The catllinarion corupitotors rook • ·sacramennml' (Sail. C4l. xxii.).
s Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 5. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=20 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 20 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
'ministrae,' probably represenl$ the Greek &di
6
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 6. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=21 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 21 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Jpat!M, TotbeEplN~
()letween 98 aDd 117, Smyma)
T
bese two documenls may poosibly be rougbly contempowy, and they bolh take an interest in how the Church should be governed. But their assumptions and perspectives are strikingly different (Still a third view of Church government, rougbly contempOrary with lgnatius if not the I>idacbe, can be found in the First l..euer of Clement of Rome, especially se<:tl.ons 40-44.)
"Didache" ls the Gteek word for "teaching" or "instruction", and the full name of the document is "'The Lord's Insti'IICtion to the Genllles through the Twelve Apostles". This very impOrtant document was dJscovered only in modem limes, in 1883. 11 may be a single composition by an individual author, or il may be a compilation of texts by an editor. The name of the author or edilor is unknown. The date of the Didocbe is very contrOVersial, with estimates ranging from the ~d half of the first century to the early third century. Many who prefer an early date argue that the document relleas a primitive approach to Church govemmen~ !lO( an elaborate or stabilized inStitutional development. Among those who disagree wilh thls view, some question the assumption that inslirutions always develop from somethir1g that looks "primitive" to
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 7. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=22 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 22 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
something that looks "elaborate" or "$tabillzed", and othets thlnk that the author or editor of the document for one reason or another was delibentely pretending to be Uvitlgln a generation th2t was already long pasL The geogr.~phial origins of the Didocbiare also controVersial. The best swvivlng manuscript copy, which is in the Greek language, comes from Jerusalem, but most of the text is also found copied into a foullhcentury Syrian work, and some partS of the text are found as well in a fourth-century Egyptian work. Parts have also been found in Latin, Syriac, Arabic, Ethiopic, and Georgie; presumably these fragments represent uanslations from the Greek. Given the number of textual traditions and translations, we cannot know with assurance where the Dldacbewaswtltlen originally, but we are cettalnlyenlitled to conclude that it was widely circulated and weU known. The Dldacbe is often classified as a "Church order", a manual of Church law giVing instructions for governance, liturgy, and discipline. If it is as early as some thlnk, it may be the model for all later Church orders. lgnalius, bishop of Antioch, was mattyredln Rome during the reign of the emperor Trajan, who ruled from 98 to 117. 1bis we know from a friend of Jgnalius' named Polycarp, wrlling a few years later. Before he \vaS tnattyrecl, wbile he was belJ\g uansponed under SUatd ftom Atoliod\ to Rome, lgnatius wrote six letters to Christian churches, and one letter to his friend Polycarp. The one to the Ephesiaos was wrlnen from Smyma, a port city of western Asia Minor (now lunir, Turkey). The authenticity of lgnalius' leners Is now generally recognized: at one time some Protestant scholars doubted that anyone in the early second century could have made such strong cbims for the authority of bishops. The leners are written in Greek, and the manuscript tradition appears to be based on a second-century recension, or manuscript version. The selections raise the question, How was the Church organi2.ed? From reading these selections, you will probQbly agree that their wiiness is inconsistent.
Questions on the readln& How is the Didocbi structured, and what natural divisions are there? To whom is it addressed? What is its purpose? Doe$ it appear to be edited from various documents or Written by a single hand? Looking at
8
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 8. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=23 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 23 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
lgnaliw' Letter, how wooJd you describe his personality? What are Ills chief interestS? Now compare the twO documentS. To whom and for wtlat purpose Is each of the authors writing? How do the circummnots of the Writing inlluenoe what each of them wantS ro say, and bow each of them says it? What ambiguities are thece in the text? What alternative forms of a
Tbe Teacbtng oftbe Twelve A.po$11es, Co~ Called tbe DUI4cbe 'lbeText 1. The Lord's Teaching to the Heathen by the T'Oielve ApoStles: There are twO ways, one of life and one of dea
(LibruyofChMlu>Ciassics, vol. 1), WeStmi.....,., 1953,171-179. Used by petmission ofWes<minslerJohn Knox Press
9
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 9. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=24 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 24 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
you will be perfect.., Ifsomeone "forces you to go one mile with him, go along with him for two"; if someone robs you "of your overcoot, give IW:n your suit as well."' If someone deprives you of "your propaty, do not ask for it back."' (You coold not get it back an)'W:IY!) "Give to everybody who begs from you, and ask for no rerum."" For the Father wants his own gifts 10 be universally sbate
2. The second commandment of the Teaching: "Do not murder; do not oommit adultery"; do not corrupt boys; do not fornicate; "do not sreaJ•; do not practice magic; do not go in for sorcery; do not murder a child by abortion or kill a newborn infant "Do not covet your neighbor's property; do not commit peljury; do not hear false witness":" do not slander; do not hear grudges. Do not be double-minded or doubletongued, for a double tongue is •a deadly snare."" Your woros shall not be dishonest or hollow, but substantiated by action. Do not be greedy or extOrtionate or hypocritical or malicious or arrogant. Do not plot against your neighbor. Do not bate anybody; but reprove some, pray for others, and still others love more !ban your own life. 3. My child, Oee from all wickedness and from everything of !hat sort. Do not be initable, for anger leads to murder. Do not be jealous or contentious or impetuous, for all this breeds murder. My child, do not be lustfu~ for lust leads to fornication. Do not use foul language or leer, for all this breeds adultery. My child, do not be a diviner, for that leads to idolatry. Do not be an enchanter or an astrologer or a magician. Moreover, have no wish to observe or heed such practices, for all this breeds Idolatry. My child, do no< be a liar, for lying leads to theft. Do not be avaricious or vain, for all this breeds thievery.
My child, do not be a grumbler, for grumbUng leads 10 blasphemy. Do not be stubborn or evil-minded, for all this breeds blasphemy.
10
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 10. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=25 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 25 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Dtot~.t:Ht AND To m£ E.PHtstAXS
But be humble since 'the hwnble will inherit the earth."" Be patient, mercifuL baJmless, quiet, and good; and always 'have respect for the teaching"Hyou have been given. Do not put on airs or give yourself up to presumptuousness. Do not associate with the high and mighty: but be with the upright and humble. Accept whatever happens to you as good, in the realization that nothing occurs apart from God. 4. My child, day and night "you should remember him who preaches God's word to you,"'' and bonor him as you ·~;ould the Lord. For where the Lord's nature is discussed, there the Lord is. Every day you should seek the company of saints to enjOy their refreshing conversation. You must not swt a sclllsm, but reconcile thoSe at strife. "Your judgments mUSt be fair.·•• You must no play favorites when reproving transgressions. You must not be of two minds about your decision. 1' Do not be one who holds his hand out to take, but shuts it when it comes to giving. If your labor has brought you earnings, pay a ransom for your sins. Do not hesitate to give and do not give with a bad grace: for you will discover who He is that pays you back a reward with a good grace. Do not rum your back on the needy, but share everything with your brother and call nothing your own. For if you have what is eternal in common, how much more should you have what is transient!
Do not neglect your responsibility" to your son or your daughter, but from their youth you shall teach them to revere God. Do not be harsh in giving orders to your slaves and slave girls. They hope in the same God as you, and tbe result may be that they cease to revere the God over you both. For when he comes to eaU us, he will not respe<:t our station, but will call those whom the Spirit has made ready. You slaves, for your pan, must obey your masters with reverence and fear, as if they represented God. You must hate all hypocrisy and everything which fails to please the Lord. You must not forsake 'the Lord's commandments," but 'observe•
the ones you have been given, 'neither adding nor subuacting anything. ·•• At the church meeting you must confess your sins, and not approach prayer with a bad conscience. That is the way of Ufe.
5. But tbe way of death is this: First of all, it is wicked and thoroughly blasphemous: murders, adulteries, lusts, fomications, thefts, idolatries, magic arts, sorceries, robberies, false witness, hypocrisies, duplicity,
ll
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 11. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=26 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 26 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
deceit, arrogance, malice, stubbornness, greediness, fllthy talk, jealousy, audacity, haughtiness, boastfulness.'"
Those who persecute good people, wbo hate ltulb, who love lies, who ate ignora.nl of !be reward of uprightness, who do not "abide by goodness"" or justice, and are on !be alert not for goodness but for evil: gentleness and patience ate remote from !hem. "Ibey love vanity,"" 'look for profit,"" have no pity for the poor. do not exert !bemse!ves for the oppressed, ignore their Maker, "murder children,"" conupr God's Image, rum their bads on the needy, oppress the affiicted, defend the rich, unjusdy ooodemn the poor, and ate thoroughly wicked. My ch.ildren, may you be saved from all this'
6. See 'that no one leads you asuay~ from this way of the teachln8, since such a one's teaching is godless. If you can bear !be lord's full yoke, you will be perfect. But if you cannot, then do what you can. Now about food: uodertake what you can. But keep saicrly away from what is offered to idols, for that implies worshiping dead gods. 7. Now about baptism; this is how to baprize. Give public instruction
on all these poirus, and !hen "baptize" in running ...-:uer ' in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy SpiriL "" If you do not have running water, baptize in some other. If you cannot in oold, then in warm. If you have neilher, then pour water on the bead three times 'in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit."" Before the baptiSm, moreover, the one who baptizes and the one being baptized must fast, and any others wbo can. And you must tell the one being baptized to fast for one or two days beforehand 8 . Your fasts must not be Identical with those of the hypocrites."' They fast on Mondays and Thursday; but you should fast on Wednesdays and Fridays. You must nO( pray like the hypocrites," but "pray as follows"" as the Lord bid us in his gospe~
"'ur Father in heaven, hallowed be your name; your Kingdom ooroe; your will be done on earth as it is in heaven; give us today our bread for the morrow; and forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors. And do not lead us into temptation, but save us from the evil one, for yours is the power and the glory forever.• 12
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 12. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=27 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 27 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
You should pray in lhis way three times a day.
9. Now about the Eucharist~' 'Ibis is how to give lhanlc.s: FiM in connection with the cup:l1 "We thank you, our Falher, for the holy vine" of Davld, your child, which you have revealed through Jesus, your child. To you be glory
forever.• Then in connection with the piece" (broken off the loaf): "We thank you, our Father, for the life and knowledge which you have revealed through Jesus, your child. To you be glory forever. ".As lhis piece (of bread] was scattered over the hills" and then was brought together and made one, so let your Church be brought together from the ends of the earth into your Kingdom. For yours is the glory and the power through Jesus Christ forever. • You must not let anyone eat or drink of your Eucharist except those baptized in the Lord's name. For in referenoe·to lhis the Lord sa.id, "Do not give what is sacred to dogs.""
10. After you have finished your meal, say grace" in this way:
"We thank you, holy Falher, for your sacred 112tt1e 'M!ich you have lodged'" in our hearts, and for the knowledge and faith and immortality 'Miich you have revealed through Jesus, your child. To you be the glory forever.
• Almighty Master, 'you have created everything'"' for the sake of your name, and have given people food and drink to enjOy that they may thank you. But to us you have given spiritual food and drink and eternal life through Jesus, your child. "Above all, we thank you tbat you are mighty. To you be glory forever. "Remember, Lord, your Church, to save it from all evil and to make it perfea by your love. Make it holy, ·and gather it 'together from the four winds"" into your Kingdom which you have made ready for it. For yours is the power and the glory forever.· "Let Grace" oome and let this world pas$ away.•
"Hosanna to the God of David!"" •If anyone is holy, let him come. If 110(, let him repent."" 13
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 13. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=28 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 28 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
· AJDen....5
In the case ol the prophets, bowever, you should let them give thanks in their own way."
11. Now, you should welcome anyooe who comes your way and teaches you all we have been saying. But if the teacher proves himself a renegade and by teaching odlerwlse conuadla:s all this, pay no attention to him. But if his teaching furthers the Lord's righteousness and knowledge, welcome him as the Lord. Now about the apostles and prophets: Act in line with the gospel precept" Welcome every apostle on arriving, as if he Wete the lord. But he must not stay beyond ooe day. In case of necessity, however, the next day too. If he stays three days, he is a false prophet. On departing, an apostle must not accept anything save sufficient food to~ him till his next lodging. If he asks for money, he is a f.llse prophet. Whlle a prophet is making ecstallc utterances," you must not test or examine him. For "every sin will be forgiven; but this sin "will not be foiJliven. "'' However, not everybody making ecstatic utterances is a prophe~ but only If he behaves like the Lord. It is by their conduct that the false prophet and the [true) prophet can be distinguished For instance, If a prophet marks out a table in the Spirit.'' he must not eat from it. If be does, be is a false prophet. A.galn, every prophet who teaches the truth but fails to practice what be preaches is a false prophet But every attested and genuine prophet who acts with a view to symbolizing the mystery ol the Church." and does not teach you to do all be does, must not be judged by you. His judgment restS with God. For the ancient prophets too acted in this way. But if someone says in the Spiri~ "Give me money, or something else,· you must not heed him. However, if he tells you 10 give for others in need, no one must condemn him. 12. Everyone "who comes" 10 you "in the name of the Lord•" must be welc:omed. AfteJWard, when you have tested him, you will fmd out about him, for you have insight into right and wrong. If it is a traveler who arrives, help him all you can. But he must not stay with you more than two days, or, If necessary, three.lfbewantsto settle with you and is an artisan, he must work for his living. If, however, he has no trade, use your judgment in taking steps for him to live with you as a Ouistian
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 14. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=29 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 29 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
DIDI.CHt AND To THl ~Htsi.J.Nt
without being Idle. If he refuses to do this, he is ttadlng on Christ. You must be on your guard against such people.
13. Every genuine prophet who wants to settle with you "has a right to his support.· Simllsrly, a genuine teacher hlmself, just U.ke a "workman, has a right to his support...,. Hence take all the first fruits of vintage and batvest, and of cattle and sheep, and give these fitSt fruits to the prophets. For they are your high priests. If, however, you have no prophet, give them to the poor. If you make bread, take the first fruits and give In accocdancewith rhe precept.>' Similarly, when you open a jar of wine or oil. take the first fruits and give them to the prophets. Indeed, of money, clothes, and of all your possessions, take such first fruits as you think right, and give In accordance with the precept. 14. On every Lord's Day - his special day" - come together and break bread and glve thanks, first confessing your sins so that your sacrifJCe may be pure. Anyone at variance wirh his neighbor must not join you, until they are reconciled, lest your sacrifice be defiled. For it was of this sacrifice that the Lord sald, ·Always and everywhere offer me a pure sacrifJCe; for I am a great King, says the Lord, and my name is marveled at by rhe nations."" 15. You must, then, elect for yourselves bishops and deacons who are a credit to the Lord, men who are gentle, generous, faithful, and well tri.e d. For rheit ministry to you is identical with that of the prophets and teachers. You must no~ therefore, despise them, for along with the prophets and teachers they enjoy a place of honor among you. Funhermore, do not reprove each other angrily, but quietly, as you find it in the gospel. Moreover, if anyone has wronged his neighbor, nobody must speak to him, and he must not hear a word from you, until be repents. say your prayetS, give your cbaJiry, and do everything just as you find it in the gospel of our Lord 16. "Watch" over your life: do not let •your lamps" go out, and do not keep •your loins ungitded"; but "be ready; for 'you do not know the hour when our Lord is coming..,, Meet together frequently in your search for what is good for your souls, since •a lifetime of faith will be of no advantage"" to you unless you prove perfe;:t at the very last. For in the fmal days multitudes of false prophets and seducers will appear. Sheep will rum into wolves, and love into batted. For with the increase
15
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 15. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=30 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 30 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
of iniquity men will hate, persecute, and betray each other. And then the world deceiver will appear in the guise of God's Son. He will work •signs and wonders"" and the earth will fall into his bands and he will commit outrages such as have never occurred before. Then humankind will come to the fiery trial •and many will fall av.oay"" and perish, "but those who pe=ere• in their faith "will be saved"'' by the Curse himself." Then *there will appear the signs"" of the Truth: first the sign of stretched· out (hands} in heaven,., then the sign of "a trumpet's blast, ..., and thirdly !he resurrection of the dead, !hough not of all the dead, but as it has been said; *The Lord will come and all his saints wi!h him. Then !he world will see !he Lord coming on the clouds of the sky.""
Notes MaiL 2Z,37·39: lev. 19:18. Cf. MaiL 7:12. MaiL 5:44, 46, 47; Luke 6:27, 28, 32, 33. I Peter 2.11. Matt. 5:39. 48; Luke 6.29.
Matt. 5:40, 41.
Luke 6:30. Ibid. M1.tt. 5:26. Thts whole oection 5 !bould I>! ~ will> Henna•, Mand.
'
2 :4·7, on whlcl! k '' 11 11
ts apparenlly dependent.
Sc:lul« unknown. :Ex. 20:1~17; d . Matt. 19:18; 5:33.
Prov. 21:6.
H
Jsa. 66:2.
"
Heb. 17.7. Deut1:16. 17; Prov. ~1:9.
M 11
" ll'
Mearting uncertain.
Litenlly, ·Do 1101 willl
16
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 16. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=31 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 31 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
DllJ.tCHt .um To mz E1fiE::swis
10
Cf. M>tt. 15:19; Marlc 7:21, 22; Rom.l: 29 ·~1; Gal. 5:19-21.
2l
Rom. 12:9.
u
Ps. .f:2.
'1J
lsa. 1:23.
"
Wls. 12:6.
" • ..
M>tt. 2M. Maa. 28:19. Il>ld.
•
I.e., the]ews. Cf. M>tt. &16.
..
Man. &s.
,
Cf. Moll. 6:9-13-.
,,
I.e., "!he lbankssfvins. •The tenn. h.,...,ver, had beoome a technlcal one in Chri5tianiry for the special giVing of !banks • t the l.o!d's Supper. One might render the verbal form <·g;~ thanks"), whldl irnmed;ately fonom, u •say grace,• for ~ wu out of the Jewish forms for grace before and after meals (aewmponied in the one inStlnce by the brealdng of bread and in the olher by sb>.ring a common cup of wine) that the Christian lhanksgiving:s of the Lord's SUpper developed. I! is a CUriOus feature of tl!e PidaeM that the eup has been displaced from
"
"
ihe end of the meal to the very beginning. Equany eurious is ihe absence or any direct referenee ro the body and blood of OlrLsl This may be a mer.phorieal refer
. ~3). It may also refer ro the Messianic promlse (cf.lsa. l1:1), or to the Messlanlc community (d. Ps. 80:8), ie., the Ch=h. /In odd phrase, but one that refers to the Jewish custom (taken ~r in the Chri>ti2n Lord's SUpper) of grace before meals. The head of the house would dlsttlbute to each ollhe guests a piece of bread broken off a loaf, after uttering the appropriate thanksgiving to God.
"
The reference is likely to the sowing of wheat on !he hillsides of Judea.
"
M>tt. 7:6. Or •g;ve thanks.• See nOte 31.
" "
For the phrase cf. Neh. 1:9.
"
Wis. 1:14; Sir. 18:1; Rev. 4:11.
"
M>n. 24:31. A title fO< Chri$1.
.
Cf. Man. 21:9, 15.
17
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 17. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=32 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 32 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
"
Or perhaps "be convened.•
..
Cf. [Cor. 16:2:2..
.. "
'l1>ese terse excbmatiOnS may be vers~le$ and ""f'fnses. More likely they derive frOm the Jewish a>stom of reading ve..es CClrlCe1'ning mel's future redemption and glory, after the final benediction. I.e., rhey are no< bound by the textS given.
Matt. 10:40,41.
Uterally, "speaking in a spiril, • i.e., speaking while~ by a divine or demonic spirit. 'lbls whole passage (eh. 11:7-12} iu sort of P2f2)1el to Matt. 12d1ff. There is an lnlerpmation o f the sln against tbe Holy Ghost, followed by a comment on good and evil oonduct (cf. Matt. 12:33-37>, and ooncluded by the prophels' signs wh;,;h are suggested by the sign of the Son of Man (Matt. 1 2:~ If.}. Matt. 12:31.
"
"
"»
"»
"'
.." ..,," "
The sense is not dear, but SUggestS a dramatic portrayal of the Messiank banquet. 1t was chllnlaerlslic of the BibliCal propbet$ to drive home their reaching by dram.ttlc and symbolic actioos (cf.Jer., eh. 19: AaS 21:11; etc.}. l.lterally, "acts ,.;m a view to a worldly mystery of the Church."The meaning is not certain, but some dramatic actloo, symbollzing the mystiCal marriage of the Church to Christ, is prtlbobly wended. The reference may, indeed, be to the prophet's being ae<:ompanied by a spiriru>.l SISter (cf. I Cor. 7•36 If.}. Matt. 21.9: Ps. us:26; cr.]ohn 5:43. Matt. 10:10. The provision le< the prophet or teacher to settle and to be supported by the congreg2tion implies the birth of the monarchical episOOpate. Note the connectloo of this wirh the high priesthood (cf. Hippolytus, Apost. Trod. 3•4} and tithing. No prov;s;on is made for the support of the local clergy in cb. 15.
Deut.
18:~5 .
Literally, "On every Lord's Day of the Lord.• Mal. 1:11. 14.
Mau. 24:42, 44; LllJre 12:35. Bam. 4:9.
Matt. 24:24. Matt. 2HO.
Matt. 10:22; 24:13. An obscure reference, but poosibly meaning the Chris< who suffered the death of one accuroed (Gal. 3:13; Barn. 7:9}. Cl two other titie$ for the Christ: Groce (eh. 10:6) and Truth (v. 6},
18
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 18. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=33 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 33 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
" '"
Maa. 24,32. Ano!her obscure refereoce, pooslbly to che belief !hac lhe Christ would
appear on a glorified""""· cr. Barn. 12<2-4. "
Man. 24~1 .
"
zedl. 14e5; 1Thess. 3,13; M>lt- 24,30.
The Ll!lter of 1~ Blsbop of.Mrtlocb, To tbe EpHslafiS Heartiest greetings of pure joy in Jesus Christ from lgnatius, the "God-inspired, •• to the church at Ephesus in Asia.' Out of the fullness' of God the Father you have been blessed with large numbers and are
predestined from eternity to enjoy forever continual and unfacling glory. The source of your unity and election is gen~ suffering which you \llldergo by the will of the Father and of Jesus Christ, our God Hence you deserve to be considered happy. I. I gave a godly welcome to your church which has so endeared itself to us by reason of your upright narure, marked as it is by faith in Jesus Chris~ our Saviour. and by love of him. You are lmlc.ators of God; and it wa$ God's blood that stirred you up once more to do the sort of
thing you do naruraUy and have now done 10 perlection. For you were all zeal to visit me when you heard that l was being shipped as a prisoner from Syria for the sake of our common Jl.'ame' and hope. I hope, indeed, by your prayers to have the good fortune to fight with wild beasu in Rome, so that by doing this I can be a real disciple. In God's name, therefore, I received your large congregation in the person of Onesimus,' your bishop in this world,6 a man whose love is beyond SOwce' lptius, "To the Ephesiians•, in Cyril C. Richar
19
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 19. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=34 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 34 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
words. My prayer is that you should love bJm in the spirit of ]esus Cluist and an be like him. Blessed is He who let you have such a bishop. You desetved it. 2. Now about my fellow slave' Burrbus, your godly deacon, who has been riChly blessed. I very much want him to stay with me. He will thus bring honor on you and the bishop. Crocus too, who is a credit both to God and to you, and whom I received as a model o f your love, altogether raised my spirits (May the Father of Jesus Cluist grant him a similar oomfort!), as did Onesimus, Burrhus, Euplus, and Pronto. In them I saw and loved you alL May I always be glad about you, that is, if I deserve to be! It is right, then, for you to render an glory to Jesus Chtist, seeing he has glorified you. Thus, united in your submission, and subject to the bishop and the presbytery, you will be real saints. 3. I do not give you orders as if I were somebody importanL For even if I am a prisoner for the Name, I have 110( yet reached Christian perfection. I am only beginning to be a disciple, so I address you as my fellow students. I needed your coaching in faith, encouragement, endurance, and patience. But since love forbids me to keep silent about you, I hasten to urge you to harmonize your actions with God's rniod ForJesus Christ- that life from which we can't be tom - is the Father's mind, as the bishops too, appointed the world over, reflect the mind of Jesus Christ. 4. Hence you should act in accord with the bishop's mind, as you surely do. Your presbytery, indeed, which deserves its name and is a credit to God, is as closely tied to the bishop •• the strings to a harp. Wherefore your accord and harmonious love is a hymn to Jesus ChrisL Yes, one and all, you should form your.elves into a choir,• so that, in perfect harmony and taking your pitch from God, you may sing in unison and wilh one voice to the Father through Jesus ChrisL Thus he will heed you, and by your good deeds he will recognize you are members of his Son. Therefore you need to abide in itrq>roachable unity if you really w.mt to be God's members forever. 5. If in so shon a time I couk! get so close to your bishop - I do not mean in a natural way, but in a spiritual - bow much more do I oongrarulate you oo having such intimacy with him as the Church enjoys with Jesus CbriSt, and Jesus Christ with the Father. That is how uniry and
20
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 20. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=35 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 35 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
harmony come to prevail evecywhere. Make no mistake about iL If anyone is not inside the sanctU"'Y.' he lacks God's bread." And if the prayer of one or two has great av2il, how much more that of the bishop and the total Church. He who fails to join in your worship shows his arrogance by the very faa of becoming a schismatic. lt is written, moreover, 'God resists the proud. "11 Let us, then, heattily avoid resisting the bishop so that we may be subjea to God. 6. lhe more anyone sees the bishop modestly silent, the more he should revere him. For everyone the Master of the house sends on his business, we ougbt to rtteive as the One who sent him. It Is clear, then, that we should regard the bishop as the Lord himself. Indeed, Onesimus spoke very hlghly of your godly conduct, !bat you were ail Uving by the uuth and barboting no sectarianism. Nay, you heed nobody beyond what he has to say trutbfully about J= Christ." 7. Some, indeed, have a wicked and deceitful habit of flaunting the Name about, while acting in a way unwotthy of God. You must avoid ihem like wild beasts. For they are mad dogs which bite on the sly. You must be on your guard against them, for it is hard to heal their bite. There is only one physician- of flesh yet spirirual, born yet unbegonen, God incarnate, genu!ne Ufe in the midst of death, sprung from M91Y as well as God, fitst subjea to suffering then beyond it -Jesus Christ our Lord." 8. Let no one mislead you, as, indeed, you are not misled, being wholly God's. For when you harbor no dissension that can harass you, then you are indeed living in God's "'•Y· A cheap saaifice" I am, but I dedicate myself to you Ephesians - a church forever famous. Carnal people cannot act spirirually," or spirirual people carnaily, just as faith cannot act like unbelief, or unbellef like faith. But even what you do in the flesh you do spiritually. Fot you do everything under Christ's control.14
9. l have heard that some strangers came your way with a wicked teaching. But you did not let them sow it among you. You stopped up your ears to prevent admitting what they dissernlnated. Like stones of God's Temple, ready for a building of God the Father. you are being hoisted up by Jesus Christ, as with a crane (thafs the cross!), while the rope you use Is the Holy Spirit. Your faith is what lifts you up, while love is the way you ascend to God.
21
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 21. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=36 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 36 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
You are all taking part in a religious prooession," carrying along with you your God, shrine, Christ, and your holy objects, and decked our from tlp to toe in the commandroeniS of Jesus Christ. I too am enjoying it all, because I can talk with you in a ~Iter, and congratulate you on changing your old my of life and seaing your love on God alone.
10. "Keep on praying·•• for others too, for there is a chance of their being convened and gealng to God. Let them, then, learn from you at least by your actions. Return their bad temper with gentleness; their boasts with humility; their abuse with prayer. In the face of their error, be ''steadfast in the faith."" Return their violence with mildness and do not be intent on gening your own back. By our patience let us shoW we are their brothers, intent on imitating the Lord, seeing whlch of us can be the more wronged, robbed, and despised. Thus no devil's weed will be found among you; but thoroughly pure and self-controlled, you will remain body and soul united to Jesus Christ.
11. The last days are here. So let us abaseourselvesandstand in awe of God's patience, lest it turn out to be our condemnation. Either let us f~r the wrath to come or let us value the 8faoe we have: one or the other. Only let our lot be genuine life inJesus Chrtst. Do not let anything c:ttch your eye besides hlm, for whom I carry around these chains- my spiritual pearls! Through them I want to rise from the dead by your prayers. May I ever share in these, so that I may be numbered among the Ephesian Christians who, by the might of]esus Christ, bave always been of one mind with the very apostles. 12. I realize wbo I am and to whom I am writing. I am a convict; you have been freed. I am in danger; you are safe. You are the route for God's victims." You bave been initiated into the (Christian) mysteries with Paul, a real saint and martyr, who deserves to be congratulated. Wben I come to meet God may I follow in his footsteps, who in all bis letters" mentions your union with Christ Jesus.
13. TrytogathertogethermorefmquentlytooelebrateGod'sEucharist and to praise him. For when you meet with frequency, Satan's powers are overthrown and bis destructiveness is undone by the unanimiry of your faith. There is nochingbetterthan peace, by which all strife in heaven and earth is done away.
22
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 22. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=37 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 37 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
DtiMCRt AKD To 7711' UHESJANS
14. You willoot overlookanyoftbis if you have a thorough belief in ]e$us Christ and love him. That is the beginning and end of life: faith the beginning and love the end." And when the two are united you have G<xl, and everything else that has to do with real goodness is dependent on them. No one who professes lialth falls into sin, nor does one who has leatne
15. It is better to keep quiet and be real, than to chatter and be unreal. It is a good thing to teach if, that is, the teachers practice what they preach. There was one such Teacher, who •spoke and it was done""; and what be did in silence" is wottby of the Father. They who have teally grasped whatJ= sald can appreciate his sllence. Thus they will be perfect: their words will mean actiOn, and their very silence will
reveal their character. The Lord overlooks nothing. Even seetets are open to him. Let us, then, do evel}'thll\g as if he were dwelliQg in us. Thus we shaU be his temp~s" and he will be within us as our God - as be actually is. This will he clear to us just to the extent that we love him rightly.
16. Make no mistake, my brothers: adulteters will not inherit G<xl's Kingdom." If, then, those who act carnaUy suffer death, how much more shall those who by wicked teaching conupr G<xl's faith for which Jesus Christ was crucified. Such a vile creature will go to the unquenchable fire along with anyone who listens to him. 17. The reason the Lord let the ointment he poured on his bead was that he might pass on the aroma of inconuptioo to the Church. Do not he anointed with the foul smell of the teaching of the prince of this wodd, lest be captute you and rob you of the life ahead of you. Why do we not all come to our senses by accepting God's knowledge, which is Jesus Christ? Why do we stupidly perish, ignoring the gift which the Lord has te<1Uy sent> 18. I am giving my life (not that it's worth much!)'" for the CtOSS, wtudl unbelievers fmd a stumbling block, but which means to us salvation and eternal life. "Whete is the wise man? Where is the debater?""Where are the boasts of those supposedly intelligent' For our God, J = the
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 23. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=38 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 38 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Cbtist, was conceived by Mary, in GOd's plan being sprung both from the seed of David30 and from the Holy SpitiL He was bom and baptized that by his Passion he might ballow water.
19. Now, Mary's v!tginity and her giving birth eseaped the notice of the prince of this world, as did the Lord's death - those three secrets crying to be told, but wrought in God's silence." How, then, were they revealed to the ages? A star "shone in heaven brighter than all the sraiS. Its light was indescribable and its novelty caused amazement. The rest of the stars, along with the sun and the moon, formed a ring around it; yet it outshone them all, and there was bewilderment whence this unique novelty had arisen. As a result all magic lost its power and all witchcraft ceased. Ignorance was done away with, and the andent kingdom !of e'ii.IJ was utterly deslroyed, for God was revealing himself as a man. to bring newness of eternal life." What God had prepared was now beginning. Hence everything was in confusion as the destruction of death was being taken in hand. 20. If Jesus Christ allows me, in answer to your prayers, and it Is his will, 1 will explain to you more about (God's] plan In a seoond letter 1 Intend to write. I have only touched on this plan in reference to the New Man Jesus Chrlsc, and how it involves belie1.ing in him and loving him, and entails his Passion and resurrection. I will do this espedally if the Lord shows me that you are all, every one of you, meeting together under the inlluence of the grace thai we owe to the Name," in one bith and in union with Christ, who was "descended from David according to the flesh"" and is Son of man and Son of God. At these meetings you should heed the bishop and presbytery attentively, and break one loaf, which is the medicine of immortality. and the antidote which wards off death but yields oontinuous life in union with Jesus Christ. 21. I am giving my life for you and for those whom you, to God's bonor, sent to Smyma. I am writing to you from there, giving the Lord thanks and embracing Polycarp and you too in my love. Bear me in mind, as Jesus Christ does you. Pray for the church in Syria, whence I am being sent off to Rome as a prisoner. I am the least of the faithful thereyet I have been privileged to serve God's honor. Farewell In God the Father and in Jesus Christ, our common hope.
24
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 24. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=39 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 39 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Notes "lbeophorus, " literally "God-Oea~."llls probably not a proper name bot an epilhet indicating his prophetic g;fts. He Is "full of God• (d. (8natius' leaeno the Magr>esians, eh. 14). Perbapslh :uAntiodl dubbed him thus.
Ephesus, the SC>eDe of Paul's mlssioo and lndltionally ofJohn's later activity, was the capital of the Roman provinCe ofAsla. ll was, 100, the central port of the lnde roo<e whkll joU>ed the Aegean wllh the East Hence the reference in eh.l2:2. The """' has a Goosdc ring. pleroma referring In later Gnostic systems to the sphete of the divine. I.e., the name of "Chri...w>.•
In wekomlng Oneslmus, lgnatius fek that he received the whole Ephesian chwdl which the bishop represented.
•
In eonU'aSlto their heavenly bishop, Cluisl.
A Paullne reminisoenoe. All Chrisllans are sla- of Cluisl.
•
The many musical metaphors in lgnatius led to the later legend th:u he had introduced antiphon>~ singing into the Church (Socrates, Hlsl. ecc~. V1, eh.
8). The metaphor is taken from that area of the Temple in which faithful Jews
t
gathe~ fot die \a\Ul st~<:"eS. Ills «lllll'tSted wllh the outet Collit of the
Gentlles. The point here Is that the uue Holy Place is the faithful congregation n:gul.arly assembled under its bishOp.
" "
" 1
'
"
.."
Cf. John 6!~3.
Prov. ~,34, Adopting the reading of LightfOOt. n.e fust of several (."(.))lJ)3ct credal sutement5 in Ignatius. While they ~re !lUmped with his otiginallty,
Cf. Root 8:5, 8 . Literally "in Chri$t," a plua$e whieh has a wide variety of meaning in lgnallus and is derived from S2W Paul. In the laaer, as probably here in lgnatius, the underlying idea parallds that of demon possession (cf. Marlt J,23, "In an unclean sp;rit"). The Christian is "possessed by Chri$t,• Is •under his control" and •influence.•
25
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 25. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=40 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 40 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
17
An abnrpl C'b2nge of meuphe<, $Uggdled by !lie building of a temple. This lime the reference is to a heathen procession - perhaps ill honor of the Epheslan Attemls. The devo!ees would be In festive attire and would any small shrines ~amule<s of !lie goddess.
••
I Thess. 5:17. Col. 1:23.
lf
"'
..
Ephesus by on the route by whlch crimlruls from the provlnces 'OIOUkl be brought to Rome to supply victims for !lie amphitheater. An enggel'2ti
n
Cf. I T'un. l :S.
"
Man. 12:33. Ps. 33:9. Le., unobausiVefy, and with sperul reference to his silence at his trial. Cf. I Cor. 3:16. Cf. 1 Cor. &9. 10.
a.
" ~ 11
" n ~
See noce 1~. I Cor. 1:20. cr.Jtom. 1;3.
~
God's modesty and reserve in the U>camatiotl -..ere somelhmg for which Satan MS unprepared.
"
.J.'
An expansiOn of the $tOI)' in Man. Z:2, and influenced by Gen. 37:9. Cf. Rom. 6:1. Le., the name of "Ovl:stian...
'"
Rom.. 1:3.
»
26
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 26. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=41 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 41 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Gospel of'l1lomM (1501 syria?)
T
be Gospel of Thomas iS one of the New Testament apocrypha. The word ' apoaypha• ~ 'hidden". ln pan an apocryphal work iS hidden in that it U$\Jally intends to communicate seaet knowledge, but more precisely it iS hidden in that it is not in the public use of the Church. In other words, an apocryphal work is not ScriptUte, not recognized as the Church's public written standard of truth or •canon· (a Greek Word meaning 'measuring stick•). Nevertheless, not every non
aas. The Gospel ofThomas is also usually, though not always, considered a product of the school of thought called 'Cluistian Gnosticism•, which was reasonably widespread in the second century. The cenn 'Gnosticism" describes any movement, school of though~ or theological tendency with cetta1n characteristics. There was never a single ocganization or philosophy called ' Gnosticism•, and no single characteristic qualifies a school of thought as Gnostic. Perhaps the most oommon characteristic of Gnosticism, however, is the view that through knowledge of the truth (the Greek word for 'knowledge• is 'gnosis") a person might be redeemed from the limitations of human physical nature, espedally death. By
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 27. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=42 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 42 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
contr2St, the orthodox idea of redemption through tbe death of Christ on the Cross is quite foreign to Gnosticism. It is often suggested that in the serond cennuy Chri$1ian Gnosticism was more likely to appeal to the intellecrual eUte, Chti$tian Otthodoxy to the proletariat. Other common cbatacteristics of Gnosticism include a dualistic view of the universe (spirit Is good. matter Is evil), arcane speculation about the creation of the universe, and claims of a secret tradition of knowledge. The historical origins of Gnosticism are not known. Until a few years ago, Gnostic wrilirlgll were koown almost entirely through the quotations and unsympathetic summaries of Us onhodox Chti$tian enemies. For inslance, the Gospel ofThomas was quoted, on a single occasion. by H.ippolytus, a theological controversialist in Rome at the beginning of the third cennuy. And Greek papyri that were later identified as pieoes of the Gospel of Thomas were discovered in the late nineteenth century at the ancient site of Oxymyncbus (now called Behnasa), in middle Egypt, where several Chrislian monasteries and convents were once located. It was not until December 1945 that the fust complete copy of the Gospel of Thomas was found. The story is that two farmers in upper Egypt, who had gone searching for a kind of soil that was useful for fertilizer, were digging at the base of a cliff across the Nile River from Nag tiammadi. They found an ancient jar, about a meter high. When they broke it open. out fell a horde of fourtb-ceruwy codices (books), most of them previously unknown. The codices were written in Coptic, a fonn of the Egypdan language which developed in the second century C.E., and whlcb, un!Jke its predecessors, was written with the Greek alphabet, supplemented by a feW extra signs. Along with the Gospel of Thomas, there were 52 other texts. lt is believed that most of these Coptic teXtS were translations of Greek documents, but some scholars make an exception for the G06pel of Thomas. Because of a local blood feud, international pob'tics, and academic intrigues, it was several years before the textS began to be made available, and it was only in 1977 that tbe entire collection was published. The collection is now often called "the Nag Hammadi Ubrary". lt is impossible to know when the various books of the Nag Hammadl Ubrary miglu have been written. With the Gospel ofThomas, an impottaru clue is that some of the Oxyrhynchus papyri are believed to date from
28
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 28. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=43 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 43 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
perhaps as early as 150. For this and several ocherreasons, mostscho~ date che Gospel of Thomas no< later than che year 150. Some date it much earlier. GeneraUy, chose who believe chat che Gospel of Thomas is derived from che Gospels of Matthew and Luke date it later: chose who believe that it represents an independent historical tradition, or that it shares a common source wich the canonical gospels, date it as early as 6o o r 70. Many believe, on grounds of language, content, and drcumstance, chat it was wrinen in Syria or Mesopotamia. The Gospel of Thomas Is by no means characteristic of the Nag Hammadl collectlon. Many of che other tractates are highly speculative, nearly to the point of unintelligjbility. The Gospel of Thomas is the one, however, which so fur has auracted the greatest interest, espedally among New Testament scholars, and it is probably the easiest to foUow.
Questions on the reading What is the genre of this work? How might the sayings be categorized? In what various Wllys do the sayings relate to !hose in the canonical gospels of Matthew and Luke? What might explain !he similarities? What might explain the dlfferences? What might have beet& ihe historical relationship between the gospels of Matthew and Luke and !he Gospel o(Thomas? What historical value does it have, if any, as a source for the teaching ofJesus? To what audience does the Gospel of Thomas appear to be addressed? What Is Its p icture of)esus? What Is its understanding of creation: the relation of marter and spirit; revelation: salvation: holiness; gender> From what you know of Gnosticism, Is this is a Gnostic work? Where and when might it have been written or compiled?
29
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 29. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=44 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 44 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
lbe Golpel oflbomas These are the secret sayings which the living Jesus spoke and which Dldymos Judas Thomas wrote down. (I) And he said, "Wb=•er finds the i.nterpretlltion of these sayings will not experience de:uh. • (2) Jesus said, "Let him who seeks continue seeking until he fmds. When he finds, he will become 11ouhled. When he becomes troubled, he will be astonished, and be will rule over the all."
(3) Jesus said, "If those who lead you say to you, 'See, the kingdom is in the sky,' then the birds of the sky will precede you. If they say to you, 1t is In the sea,' then the flsh will precede you. Rather, the kingdom is Inside of you, and it is outside of you. When you come to know yourselves, then you will become known, and you will reali2e that it is you who are the sons of the living father. But if you will not know youiSelves, you dwell in poverty and it is you who are that poverty.• ( 4) Jesus said, "The man old In days will not hesitate to ask a small
child seven days o ld about the place of life, and he will live. For many are firs! Will become last, and they will become one and !he same.·
wno
(5) Jesus said, "Recognize what Is in your (sg.) sight, and that which is hidden from you (sg.) will become plain to you (sg.). For there is nothing hidden which will not become manifest. •
(6) His disciples questioned him and said to him, "Do you want us to fast? How shall we pray? Shall we give alms' What diet shall we obse!Ve?" Jesus said, "DO not tell lies, and dO not dO What you hate, for all things are plain in the sight of heaven. For nothing hidden will not become manifest, and nothing covered will remain without being uncovered." (7) Jesus said, "Blessed is the lion which becomes man when consumed by man; and cursed is the man whom the lion consumes, and the lion becomes man."
Source, "The Gospel ofThomas," trans. H. Koesler and T.O. lllmbdin. in ]omes Robinson, gen. ed., Tbe Nag Hammadi Libmry, Harper San Francisco,
1988, 124-138.
30
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 30. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=45 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 45 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
(8) And be said, '"!be man is like a wise tisberman who cast his net inlo rhe sea and dtew it up from rhe sea of small fish. Amoog rhem rhe wise tlshermao found a floe la1ge fish. He rhtew all rhe amall tlsh back into lbe sea and chose rhe la1ge fish wirhout difficulty. Whoever has ear,; to hear,let him hear.'
run
(9) Jesus said, 'Now rhe sower went out, took a handful (of seeds), . aod scattered !hem. Some fell on rhe road; rhe birds came and ~red rhem up. Others feU on rock, did not take lOO( in rhe soil. aod did nO< produce ears. And orhers feU on rhoms; rhey choked rhe seed(s) and wonns ate rhem. And orhers fell on lbe good soil and it produced good froi~ it bore siJtty per measure and a hundred and rwenty per mearure.• (10) Jesus sa.id, "' have cast fire upon rhe world, and see, I am guardlns it until it blazes.· (ll) Jesus said, 'This heaven will pass away, and rhe one above it will pass away. The dead are not alive, and rhe living will not die. In rhe days when you consumed what is dead, you made it what is alive. When you come to dwell in rhe Ught, what will you do? On rhe day when you were one you became two. But when you become twO, what will you
do?'
(12) The dlsclples said to ]esus, "We know rhat you wiU depart from us. Who is to be our leader?" Jesus said to rhem, 'Wherever you are, you are to go to James rhe righteous, for whose sake heaven and earrh came into being. • 03) Jesus aaid 10 his disdples, "Compare me to someone and tell me whom I am like. •
Slmon Peter said 10 him, "You are like a righteous angel." Matthew said to him, 'You are like a wise philosopher.• Thomas said to him, 'Master, my mourh is wholly incapable of sayins whom you are like.' Jesus said, "' am not your (sg.) master. Be<:ause you (sg.) have drunk, you (sg.) have become intoxicated from rhe bubbling spnns which I have measured out. • And be took him and wirhdtew and told him rhree things. When Thomas returned to his oompaaions, rhey asked him, "What did Jesus say to your
31
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 31. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=46 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 46 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Thomas said to 1hem, "'f I tell you one of the things whlch be told me, you will pick up stODeS and throw them at me; a fire will come out of the stones and bum you up.• (14) Jesus said to them, "'f you fast, you will give rise to sin for yourselves; and if you pray, you will be condemned; and if you give alms, you will do harm to your spirits. When you go into any land and walk about in the districtS, if they receive you, eat what they will set before you, and heal the sick among them. Por what goes into your mouth will not defile you, but that which issues from your mouth- it is that which will defile you.· (15) Jesus said, "When you see one who was not born of woman, Pf0$trale yourselves on your faces and worship him. That one is your father."
(16) Jesus said, "Men think, perl>aps, that it is peace which I have come to cast upon the world. They do not know that it is dissension which I have come to cast upon the earth: fire, sword, and war. For there will be five in a bouse: three will be against two, and two ag;Unst three, the father against the son, and the son against the father. And they will
stand solitary."
(11) Jesus said, "I shall give you what no eye has seen and what no ear has heard and what no hand bas touched and what has never occurred to the human mind.• (18) The disciples said to Jesus, "Tell us how our end will be." Jesus said, "Have you discovered, then, the beginning, that you look for the end? For where the beginning is, there wiU the end be. Blessed is be who will take his place in the beginning; he will know the end and will not experience death. • (19) Jesus said, "Blessed is he who came into being before he came Into being. If you become my disciples and listen to my words, these stones will minister to you. For there are five trees for you in Paradise which remain undisturbed summer and winter and whose leaves do not fall. Whoever becomes acquainled with them will not experience death.· (20) The disciples said to Jesus, "Tell us what the kingdom of heaven is like.• He said to them, "It is like a mustard seed. It is the smallest of an seeds. But when it falls on tilled son, it produces a great plant and becomes a shelter for birds of the sky. •
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 32. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=47 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 47 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
(21) Maty said toJesus, •Whom are your di.sdples likel'" He said, "They are Uke children wbo have settled in a field which is not theirs. When the owners of the field come, they will say, 'Let us have back our field • They (will) undress in their ~nee in order tO let them bave back their field and tO give it back to them. Therefore I say, if the owner of a house knows that the lhlef Is coming, be will begin his vigil before he comes and will n01 let him dig through into his house of his domain tO carry ""''2!' his goods. You (pi.), then, be on your guard against the world. Arm ~Ives with gxeat strength lest the robbers 6nd a way to come to you, for the dllllcu!ty which you expect will (surely) maletialize. Let there be among you a man of undetstanding. When the grain ripened, he came quickly with his sickle in his hand and reaped it. Whoever bas ears to hear, let him hear.•
(22) Jesus saw infants being suckled. He saki to his di.sdples,. "These infants being suckled are Uke those who enter the kingdom. • They said to him, ·shall we then, .as children, enter the kingdom?" Jesus said to them, "When you make the twO one, and when you make the inside Uke the outside and the outside Uke the inside, and the above like the below, and when you make the maie and the female one and the same, so that the male not be male nor the female female; and when you fashion eyes in place of an eye, and a hand in place of a hand, and a foot in place of a foot, and a tikeness in place of a likeness: then will you en.er {the kingdom) ... (23) Jesus said, •1 shaU choose you, one out of a thousand, and two out of ten thousand, and they shall stand as a single one.• (24) His disciples said to him, •show us the place where you are, since it is necessary for us to seek it." He said to them, "Whoever bas ears, let him hear. There is tight within a man of Ught, and he Ughts up the whole world. If he does not shine, he is darkness." (25) Jesus said, "Love your (sg.) brother like your soul, guard him like the pupil of your eye." (26) Jesus said. "You (sg.) see the mOle in your brother's eye, but you do n01 see the beam in your own eye. When you cast the beam out of your own eye, then you will see clearly to cast the mote from your brother's eye." 33
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 33. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=48 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 48 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
(Z7)
<Jesus said,> "If you do not fast as regards the world, you will
no« fllld the kingdom. If you do not observe the Sabbath as a Sabbath, you will not see the father. • (28) Jesus said, •I took my place in the midst of the world, and I appeared eo them in flesh. I found all of them intolticated; I found none of !hem thirsty. And my soul became afflicted for the sons of men, because they are blind in their hearts and do nO! have sigh~ for empty they came inro the world, and empty too they seek to leave the world. But for the moment they are intoxicated. When !hey shake off their wine, !hen !hey will repent.•
(29) Jesus said, "If the flesh came into being because of spirit, it is a wonder. But if spirit came into being because of the body, It is a wonder of wonders. Indeed, I am amazed at how this great wealth has made itS home in this poverty." (30) Jesus said, "Where !here are three gods, they are gods. Where there are two or one, I am with him.•
(31) Jesus said, "No prophet is accepted in his own village; no physician heals those who know him." (32) JesU$ saia, ·A city being buih on a ~gh moulllain cannot fall, nor can it be hidden."
ana fottiliea
(33) Jesus said, "Preach from your Cpl.) housetops !hat which you (sg.) will hear in your (sg.) ear. For no one lights a lamp and putS it under a bushel, nor does he put it in a hidden place, but rather he sets it on a lampstana so !hat everyone who enters and leaves will see itS light.• (34) Jesus said, •If a blind man leads a blind man, they will bOih fall into a pll"
(35) Jesus said, "It is not possible for anyone to enter the house of a strong man and take it by force unless he binds his hands; then be will (be able to) ransack his house." (36) Jesus sala, "Do not be concemea from morning until evening and from evening until morning about what you will wear." (37) Hl$ disciples said, "When will you become reve21ed to us and when shall we see you?" Jesus said, "When you disrobe without being ashamed ana take up your garmentS and place them unaer your feet like little children and
34
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 34. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=49 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 49 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Gosm. OF 7ltoow
r:read on them, then {will you see} the son of the living one, and you will not be afraid." (38) Jesus sal
(40) Jesus said, "A grapevine has ·been planted outside of lhe father, but being unsound, it will be pulled up by its IOOIS and desaoyed." (41) Jesus said, "Whoever has something in his hand will receive more, and whoever has nothing will be deprived of even rhe lillle be
has."
( 42) ]esus said, "Beoome passers-by.• (43) His disciples said to him, "Who are you, that you should say these thiQgs to us?"
<Jem s~id !Q !hem,> "Yov do nol~e;~lize who I am from~ I say to you, but you have become like the Jews, for they (either) love the tree and hate its fruit (or) love rhe fruit and hate the uee." ( 44) Jesus said, "Whoever blasphemes againSt the father will be forgiven, and whoever blasphemes against the son will be forgiven, but whoever blasphemes against the holy spirit will not be forgiven either on earth or in heaven... ( 45) Jesus said, "Grapes are nOI' harvested from thorns, nor are figs gathered from thistles, for they do not produce fruit. A good man brings fonh good from his storehouse; an evil man brings forth evil things from his evil storehouse, which is in his bean, and says evil things. For out of the abundance of the heart he brings forth evil things." (46) Jesus said, • Among rhose bom of women, from Adam until John the Baptist, there is no one so superior to John the Baptist that bis eyes should not be lowered (before him). Yet I have said, whichever one of you comes to be a child will be acquainted with the ldngdom and will become superior to John.•
35
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 35. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=50 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 50 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
( 47) Jesus said, "It is impossible for a man to mount two horses or to suerd> two bows. And it is impossible for a seMtU to serve two masters; otherwise, he will hooor the one and treat the other contempcuously. No man drinks old wine and immediately desires to drink new wine. And new wine is not put into old wineskins, lest they burst; nor is old wine put into a new wineskin, lest it spoil it An old patch is not sewn into a new garmem, because a tear would result· (48) Jesus said, •If two make peace with each other in this one house, they will say to the mountain, 'Move away,' and it will move away.•
(49) Jesus said, ·Blessed are the solitary and ele<:r, for you will find !he kingdom. For you are from it, and to it you will rerum." (50) Jesus said, •If they say to you, 'Where did you come from?', say to them, 'We came from the light, the place where the light came into being on its own accord and established Utselfl and became manifest lbrough their image.' If they say to you, 'Is it you?', say, 'We are its children, and we are the elect of the living father.' If they ask you, 'What is the sign of your father in you?,' say to them, 'It is movement and
reposa.·· (51) His disciples said to blm; "When will the repose of the dead come about, and when will the new world come?" He said to them, "What you look forward to has already come, but you do not recogniZe it." (52) His disciples said to blm, "Twenty-four prophets spoke in Israel, and ali of them spoke in you." He said to them, "You have omitted the one living in your presence and have spoken (only) of the dead.• (53) His disciples said to hiJn, "Is circumcision beneficial or not?" He said to them. "If it were beneficial, tbeit father would beget them already circumcised from their mother. Rather, the aue ci.rcumdsion in spirit has be<:ome completely profitable." (54) Jesus said, "Blessed are the poor, for yours is the kingdom of
heaven."
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 36. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=51 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 51 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
(55) Jesus said, "Whoever does not bate his father and his mother
cannot become a dlsdple to me. And whoever does not hate his brothers and siSters and take up his cross in my way will not be worthy of me.• (56) Jesus said, "Whoever has come to uoclersland the world has found (only) a corpse, and whoever has found a corpse is superior to the world"
(57) Jesus said, "1be kingdom of the father is like a man who bad (goodl seed. His enemy came by nig.hi and sowed weeds among the good seed The man did not allow them to pull up the weeds; he said to them, 'I am afraid that you will go intendillg to pull up the weeds and pull up the wheat along With them: For on the day of the harvest the weeds will be plainly visible, and they will be pulled up and burned." (58) Jesus said, "Blessed is the man who has suffered and found life: (59) Jesus said, "Take heed of the living one wbile you are alive, lest you die and seek to see him and be unable to do so.· (60) a Samaritan carrying a lamb on his W3Y to Judea. He said to his disdples, 'That man is round about the lamb.· They said to him; "So that be may kJil it and eat it.• He said to them. "Wblle it is alive, he will not eat it, but only when be has kJI!ed it and it has become a corpse." They said to him, "He cannot do so otherWise." He said to them, "You too, look for a place for yourselves Within Jep<>Se, lest you become a corpse and be eaten.· (61) Jesus said, "Two will rest on a bed: the one will die, and the other wllllive.·
Salorne said, "\Vbo are you, man, that you ... have come up on my coucb and eaten from my table?" Jesus said to her, "I am be who exists from the undivided I was given some of the things of my father:
< . .. > '1 am your dlsdple." < ... >"Therefore I say, if he Is destroyed be will be filled With light, but if be is divided, be will be IUled With darlmess..
37
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 37. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=52 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 52 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
(62) Jesus said, "lt is to those [who are wonhy of myl mysteries that 1 tell my mysteries. Do no let your (sg.) left hand know what your (sg.) tight band is doing.• (63) Jesus said, "There was a rich man who had much money. He said, 'I shall put my money to use so that I may sow, reap, plant, and fill my storehouse with produce, with the result that I shall lack nothing.' Such were his intentions, but that same night he died. Let him who has ears bear." (64) Jesus said, "A man had re<:eived Visitors. And when he had prepared the dinner, be sent his setVallt to invite the guests. He went to the ~ one and said to him, 'My master invites you.' He said, 'I have claims against some merchants. They are coming to me this evening. l must go and give them my orders. I ask to be excused from the dinner.He went to another and said to him, 'My master has invited you.' He said to him, 'l have just bought a house and am required for the day. I shall n()( have any spare time.' He went to another and said to him, 'My master invites you.' He said to him, ' My friend is going to get married, and I am to prepare the banquet. I shall not be able to come. I ask to be excused from the dinner.' He went to another and said to him, 'My master invites you.' He said to him, 'I have jUSl bought a farm, and I am on my way to collect the rent. I shall not be able to come. I ask to be excused.' The setvant returned and said to his master, 'Those whom you invited to the dinner have asked to be excused.' The master said to his servan~ 'Go outside to the streets and bring back those whom you happen to meet, so that rhey tn2Y dine.' Businessmen and merchants [will) not enter the places of my father. •
(65) He said, "There was a gond man who owned a vineyard. He leased it to tenant farmers so that they might wod< it and he might collect the produce from them. He sent his servant so that the tenants might give him the produce of the vineyard. They seized his servant and beat him, all but killing him. The setvant went hack and told his master. The master said, 'Perhaps he did not recognize them.' He sent another servant. The tenants beat this one as well. Then the owner sent his son and said, 'Perha~ they will show respect to my son: ~use the tenants knew that it was he who was the heir to the vineyard. they seiz.ed him and killed him. Let him who has ears hear.·
(66))esus said, "Show me the stone which the builders have rejeeted. That one is the cornerstone. •
38
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 38. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=53 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 53 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
GOSPEL OF THOMAS
(67) Jesus said, "If one who knows the all still feels a personal defidency, he is completely defiCient.·
(68)Jesus said, "Blessed are you when you are hated and persecuted
Wherever you ha~ been persecuted they will find no place." (69) Jesus said, "Blessed are they who have been persecuted within themselves. It is they who have ttuly come 10 know the father. Blessed are the hungry, for the belly of him who desires will be Oiled. •
(70) Jesus said, "That which you have will save you if you bring it fonh from yourselves. That which you do not have within you (wiliJ kill you if you do not have it within you." (71) Jesus said, "I shall (destroy this I house, and no one will be able to build it I . . . Y (72) (A man said! to him, "Tell my brothers to divide my father's possessions with me."
He said to him, "0 man, who has made me a divider?" He turned to his disciples and said ro them, "I am not a divider, am I?"
(73) Jesus said, "The h;uvest is great but the laborers are Beseech the lord, therefore, to send out laborers to the harvest."
few.
(74) He said, •o lord, there are many around the drinking trough, but there is nothing in the dstem." (75) Jesus said, "Many are standing at the door, but it is the solitary who will enter the btidal chambet. • (76) Jesus said, "The Jdnsdom of the father is like a merchant who had a consignment of merchandise and who discovered a peat!. That merchant was shrewd. He sold the merchandise and bought the pearl alooe for himself. You too, seek his unfailing and enduting treasure where no moth comes near to devour and no worm destroys.• (77) Jesus said, "lt is I wbo am the light which is above them all. It is I who am the all. From me did the all come forth, and uoto me did the all
extend. Split a piece of wood, and I am there. Lift up the stone, and you wiU find me there." (78) Jesus said, "Why have you come out into the desert? To see a reed shaken by the wind? And ro see a man clothed in fine garments (like
39
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 39. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=54 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 54 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
your) kings and your great men? Upon them are the fine gannents, and they ate unable to discem the truth.• (79) A woman from the crowd said to him, "Blessed are the womb which bore you and the breastS which nourished you.·
He said to lherJ, "Blessed are those who have heard the word of the father and have truly kept iL For there will be days when you (pi.) will say, 'Blessed are the womb which has not conceived and the breasts which have not given mllk.'" (80) Jesus said, "He who has recognl2ed the world has found the body, but he who has found the body is superior to the world.• (81) Jesus said, "Let him who has grown rich be king, 2nd let him who possesses power renounce it.•
(82) Jesus said, "He who is near me is near the fue. and he who is far
from me is far from the kingdom.· (83) Jesus said, "The images are manifest to man, but the light in them remains concealed in the image of the light of rhe f2ther. He will become manifes~ but his image will remain concealed by his UghL •
(84) Je$11$ md, "When you ~~ yol!r Ilk~=. yoY rejoi~. But when you see your images which came into being before you, and which neirher die nor become manifest, how much you will have to bear'" (85) Jesus said, •Adam c:une into being from 2 great power and a great wealth, but he did not become worthy of you. Por had he been worthy,lhe would) not (h3ve experienced) death."
(86) Jesus said, "[The foxes have !heir holes) and the birds have their nestS, but rhe son of man has no place tO lay his head and rest.• (ffl) Jesus said, "Wretched is the body that is dependent upon a body, and wretched is the soul that is dependent on rhese two."
(88) Jesus said, "The angels and the prophets will come to you and give to you those things you (already) have. And you too, give !hem !hose things which you have, and say to yourselves, 'When will they come and ake what is theirs?'" (89) Jesus said, "Why do you W3Sh the outside of the cup? Do you not realize that he who made rhe inside is the same one who made the outside?"
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 40. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=55 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 55 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
{90) Jesus said, •come unto me, for my yoke is easy and my lordship Is mUd, and you will find repose for yourselves.• (91) They said to him, 'TeU us who you are so tlut we may believe
in you;• He said to them, "You read the face of the sky and of the earth, but you have not recognized the one who is befo.e you, and you do not know how to read this momenL • {92) Jesus said, "Seek and you will find. Yet, what you asked me about in former times and which I did not tell you then, now I do desire to tell, but you do not ~ after it. •
<93) <Jesus said,> "Do not give what is holy to dogs, lest they throw them on the dung heap. Do not throw the pearls [to) swine, lest they . . . it ( . . . )." (94) Jesus (said], "He who seeks will find, and (he who knocks) will be let in." (95) Uesus saidl, "'f you have money, do not lend it at interest, but give Ut! to one from whom you will not get it back.· (96) Jesus said, 'The kingdom of the father is like [a certain] woman. She took a little leaven, !concealed] it in some dough, and made it into large loaves. Let him who has ears hear.•
(97) Jesus said, "The kingdom of the [father) is like a certaio woman who was carrying a Qarl full of meal While she was walking (on the) road, stili some distance from home. the handle of the jar broke and the meal emptied out behind her [on) the road. She did not realize I~ she had noticed no aocident. When she reached her house, she set the jar down and found it empty.• (98)Jesus said, 'The kingdom of the father is like a certaio man who wanted to kill a powerful man. In his own house he d!ew his sword and stuck it into the wall in order to find out whether his hand could carry through. Then he slew the powerful man. •
<99) The disciples said to him, "Your brothers and your mother are standing outside. • He said to them, "Those he.e who do the will of my falher are my brothers and my mother. lt is they who will enter the kingdom of my father."
41
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 41. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=56 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 56 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
(100) They showed Jesus a gold coin and said to him, 'Caesar's men demand taxes from us."
He said to them, 'Give Caesar what belongs to Caesar, give God what belongs to God, and give me what is mine." (101) <Jesus said,> "Whoever does ncx hate bis [father! and his mother as I do canncx become a ldlsciplel to me. And whoever does (not) love his !father and] his m<Xher as I do cannot become a !disciple to! me. For my mother I , .. I, but (my! true (mother) gave me life." (102) Jesus said, 'Woe to the pharisees, for they are like a dog sleeping in the manger of oxen, for neither does he eat nor does be Oetl the oxen eat.."
(103) Jesus said, "Fortunate is the man who knows where the brigands will enter, so that {he) may get up, muster his domain, and ann himself before they invade.• (104) They said to Jesus, "Come, let us pray today and let us fast."
Jesus said, 'What is the sin that I have committed, or wherein have I been defeated? But when the bridegroom leaves the bridal chamber, then let them fast and pray." (105) Jesus said, "He who knows the father and the m<Xher will be called the son of a harlot."
(lo6) Jesus said, "When you make the two one, you will become the sons of man, and when you say, 'MoutUain, move amy,' it will move away:" (107) Jesus said, 'The kingdom is like a shepherd who had a hundred sheep. One of them, the largest weru astray. He left the ninety-nine and looked for that one until he found it. When he had gone to such trOuble, he said to the sheep, 'I care for you more than the ninety-nine.'" (108) Jesus said, ' He wbo will drink from my mouth will become like me. I myself shall become be, and the things that are hidden will be revealed to him."
(109) Jesus said, 'The kingdom is like a man who had a {hjddenl treasure in his field without knowing it And (after! he died, he left it to his [son!. The son [did] not know (about the treasure). He inherited the field and sold Uti. And the one who bought it went plowing and [found!
42
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 42. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=57 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 57 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
lhe ueasure. He began to lend money at interest to whomever he wished." (110) Jesus Wd, "Whoever fmds the world and becomes rich, let
him renounce the world" (111) Jesus Wd, "The heavens and lhe earth will be roUed up i.n your presence. And the one who lives from lhe living one will not see death." Does not J = say, "Whoever finds himself is superior to lhe world"? (112)}esus said, "Woe to the Oesh chat depends on the soul; woe to lhe soul !hat depends on lhe Oesh.• (113) His disciples said to him, "When will !he kingdom come?"
<Jesus Wd,> "lt will not come by walling for it. lt will not be a matter of saying 'here it is' or 'there it is'. IWher, the kingdom of lhe falher is spread out upon the earth, and men do not see it." (114) Simon Peter said to !hem, "Let Mary leave us, for women ·are 001 worthy of llfe:
Jesus said, "I myself shall lead her in order to make her male, so that she 100 may become a living spirit resembliJ:IS you males. For every woman who will mak~ herself male will enter the kingdom of heaven: The Gospel According to Thomas
43
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 43. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=58 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 58 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
This page intentionally left blank
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 44. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=59 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 59 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
] ustin (Hl0'·165) is usually called "JUS(in Maltyt" because he was inartyred in about 165. He is the most imponant of the second-century •apologists"; "apology" is used in the sense of"defence•, and a Christian apologist is one who defends Christianity against its critics and petSeCUtors. Three ofJustin's works have sUIViVed. His First and Second Apologies are addressed to pagans, and portray Christianity as the fulfilbnent of the philosophical, educational, and humane ideals of pagan culture. In particular, they attempt to relate Christian
and conver.;ion. He was born of pagan parents in Samaria, and as a young man sought the meaning of life in various philosophical schools (Stoicism, Arist<XeiJanlsm, Pythagoreanlsm, Platonlsm). In about 132 be convened to Christianity as the truest philosophy. He became an itinerant
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 45. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=60 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 60 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Christian teacher, but he taught in the style of a pagan philosopher; he even dressed after the manner of a philosopher by wearing a pallium, a kind of cloak. Ill some point Justin seems to have moved to Rome. where he opened a Christian school He wrote a large number of wotl<s, although only the two Apologies and the Diak>gue have survived. His life drew to a close after a pagan philosophical opponeru named Crescens, from the school of thought called Cynicism, denounced him to the authorities as a Christian. Justin was arrested, and be refused to abjure his Christianity. ACcording to a narrative of his martyrdom which appears to be based on coun reco.rds, be was scourged and beheaded, along with six companions. Jusdo wrote in Greek. His three extant wotl<s have oome to us through a manuscript copied in 1364. Although the manuscript distinguishes the Fimand Second llpologi8s, many modem critics belleve that the Second is a conclusion or appendix of the Firsr. Nevenheless, the Second Apo1cgy presented here can be read as a self-rontained whole. The document is addressed to one Urbicus, who was consul under the Emperor Antoninus Pius, who reigned from 138 to 161.
Questions on the readlag What event, acconling to Justin, has prompted his lener? What can
be known from the document about the social COnlext in which it was written? Why does Justin think that the pagans are critical of Christianity? What does be mean, in chapter 12, by the phrase "who approves of the eating of human flesh"? Why does Justin think that Christians are being persecuted? How does justin understand God; Christ; die promised end of the wodd; the Christian faith? How does he relate Christianity to paganism? What kinds of arguments and rhetorical techniques does he use? In what ways might his arguments be persuasive tO his intended readers; in what ways not? How has Justin been influenced by his reading of philosophy? What is the character of the inter-faith dialogue being conducted by Crescens and ]ustin1 Does this reading appear to be a self-oontained document, or might it have at one point belonged to a larger one?
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 46. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=61 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 61 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
JUSTIN'S SfcoND AI'CLOGY
Cbapterl The things that have lately taken place in your city under Urbic:us, and the evil deeds that are likewise being perpetrated without reason by your governors, have fo=d me to compose thls address for you Romans who are men of feelings like ours and are our bfethren, even though you fail to realize it or refuse to admit it because of your pride In your so~ed dignities. Everywhere, indeed, whoever Is chastened by father, or neighbor, or child, or friend, or brother, or husband, or wife for any shortcoming, such as being stubborn, and pleasure-loving, and difficult to urge to good (except those who believe that the wicked and sensual shall suffer the punishment of eternal fire, but that the virtuous and Christ·llke, i.e, those who have become Christians, shall live with God free from all pain)- these and the wicked demons who bate us so, and have as their slaves and worshippers such men as the above--mentioned judges, compel them, like rulers under demoniacal influence, to put us to death. That you may clearly understand the reason for all that took place under Urbicus I will now tell you just what happened.
Chapter 2 There was a certain woman who lived with an unchaste husband, and she, too, bad once been unchaste. After learning the doctlines of Christ, she became a self-<:erurolled person and she tried to effect a simil2r change In her husband, explaining the Christian teachings and warning him of the eternal punishment by fU'e reserved for those who live without chastity or right reason. But by clinglng to the same shameful conduct he lost his wife's affections, and she desired a divorce from him because sbe considered it sinful to live any longer with a husband who sough! in every way those means of sensual pleasure contrary to the Jaw of narure and in violation of every right. However, she foo::ed herself to stay with him after her friends convinced her that it was advisable to remain with him In the hope that at some future time he might change Source:
Justln, Second Apo/Of!)', trans. Thom25 B. Falls (Fathers of !he Churc:h, vol. 6), N.Y.: Ouistian Heritage Inc., 1948, 119-135. Reprin<ed by permission of the CatholiC University of America Press. 47
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 47. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=62 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 62 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
his ways. But when her husband went to Alexandria and che report reached her chat his conduct was worse chan ever, she, in order not to partiCipate in his sinful and impious actS by continuins to live wich him by sharing his table and his bed, gave him what you term a bill of divorce and left him. But chat gallant and gendemanly husband instead of being delighted tbat cho~ evil actions which she used to commit so recklessly with servants and employees in tb~ days when she took pleasure in drunkenness and every wicked action, she had now discontin~d, and wanted him to do the same -when she left him against his will, brought a charge against her, claiming chat she was a Christian. And she presented a petition to you, 0 Emperor, asking that she might he permitted first to set her household affairs in order, and then, after that was done she would defend ~If against the accusation. You gave your permission. When her former husband could nor answer her, he thus tumed his attack oo a oenain Ptolemaeus, who had instructed her in Christian dOctrine, in the foUowing way. He Induced his personal friend, a centurion, to summon Ptolemaeus and ask him just one question: Was he a Christian? And Ptolernaeus, being of a truthful and not deceitful or mendacious nature, confessed that he was a Christian, and was therefore placed in chalns by the cenrurion and mistreated in prison for a long time. At iength, when he appeared before Uroicus for judgment, he was again asked this one question, Was he a Christian? And again, being aware of the benefits he had gained through the teaching of Christ, he confessed to be a member of the school of divine virtue. For h e who denies anything, either does so because he condemns the thing i!Self, or he avoids confessing it because he deems himself unworthy of and alien to it; neither of which applies to the true Christian. When Urbicus ordered him to he led away to execution, a cenain Lucius, also a Christian, realizing how unreasonable the sentence was, said to Urbicus, 'What is the reason for this sentence? Why have you punished this man who is not an adulterer, or fornicator, or murderer, or thief, or robber, nor in a word convicted of any crime at all, but only confesses chat he bears !he name of Christian. Your judgment, Urblcus, does not become the Emperor Pius, nor the Philosopher, son of Caesar, nor the sacred Senate.· The only answer he made to Lucius was this' 'You also seem to be one !of this class).' And when Lucius replied, '! cenainly am,' he ordered him also to be led away to execution. And Lucius expressed his thanks, since he knew that he would soon be freed from such evil rulers,
48
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 48. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=63 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 63 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
and would 80 10 the l'alher and King of Heaven. A third Christian also came forward, and was likewise condemoed to punishment. Chapcer3 I also expect 10 be the victim of a plot and to be affixed 10 the stake by those just metllioned, or perhaps even by Ctesoens, ·that lover of fanfare and ostentadon. For that man does 110! deserve the name oflover of '\Visdom, since he accuses us publicly in matter.; of which be is ignorant, claiming that Christians are atheists and irreligious, and doing this just to please and to gain the support of the deceived mob. If, indeed, be attacks us without srudying the tead>ings of Christ, he is positively wicked, and far worse than illiterate - per.;ons are genesally careful not ro argue or lie about manets of which !hey are Ignorant. On the other hand, if he has srudied them [the teachings of Chti5IJ and has not grasped their grandeur, or, if he has and adS as he does in mder not to appear to be a Chrisdan, he is much more vile and evil, because he is then inferior even 10 a slave In popular and unreasonable opinion and fear. I want you to know that l put certain questions to him on this matter and I learned most assuredly that be truly knows nothing. And 10 show that I speak the truth, l am prepared, if our debate has not already been ~pottell 10 you,
10 ~~~it in your presence. Such ~ permi$$1on wO\!kl
be an act worthy of a royal ruler. But if my quesdons and his repUes were brought to your anendon, it ls evident 10 you that he knows nothing of ·our teachings, or, if he does know them, but, through fear of his bearer.;, dares not utter them, as SocrateS would have, then he proves himself 10 be, as I said before, not a lover of wisdom, but a lover of false opinions, who disregards that praiseworthy saying of Socrates: 'But no, man must be honored before the truth.' However, it is impossible for a Cynic like Crescens, who considers the last end to be indl!ferent, to recognize any
gnod but Indifference.
Cbapcer4 Lest any one should say to us, 'All of you, go, kill yoursetves and thus go immediately to God, and save us the trouble,' I will explain wby we do not do that, and wby, when int.enogated, we boldly acknowledge our faith. We have been taught that God did oot aeate the world without a purpose, but that He did so for the sake of humankind, for we have stated before that God Is pleased with those who imitate His
49
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 49. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=64 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 64 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
perfections, but is displeased wilh !hose wbo choose evil, either in word or in deed. If, lhen, we should all kill owselves we would be !he cause, as far as it is up to us, wby.no one would be bom and be insttucted in !he divine doctrines, or even wby !he human race might cease to exist; if we do act lhus, we ourselves will be opposing !he will of God. But w hen we are interrogated we do n()( deny o ur faith, for we·are not conscious of having done any wrong, but we do consider it ungodly always not to tell !he truth, which we also realize is pleasing to God; and we also now want to free you from an unfair prejudice.
But if anyone should think that, if we profess God to be our prowctor, we should n()(, as we admit, be overpowered and molested by unjust persons - !his difficulty, too, I will remove. When God made !he unlve~ and put all eanllly things under human dominion, and arranged !he heavenly bodies for !he Increase of fruits and the change of seasons, and decreed a divine Jaw for these, which He apparently also created for our nke, He appointed His angels, whom He placed over humankind,
ro look after people and all rhing;s under beaven. Bur tbe angels Vioklred their chatge, feU into sin with women and begot children who ate called demons. Moreover, !hey· suboequendy subjected !he human race to themselves, partly by magic writings, partly by the fear !hey instilled into !hem and the punishments they inflicted upon them, and partly by instructing !hem in the use of sacrifices, incense, and libations, which they reaUy needed after becoming slaves of their lustful passions; and !hey engendered murders, wars, adulteries, all sorts of dissipation, and every species of sin. Thus it was that the poets and writers of legends, unaware that !he bad angels and the demons begotten by !hem did those things to men and women, to cities and nations, ascribed them to (their! god himself !Jupiter! and to those whom they thought were sons of his seed and 10 the children of those whom they called his brothers, Neprune and Pluto, and to !he children of their children. For they called !hem by the name each of the bad angels bad bestowed upon himself and his chUdren.
so Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 50. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=65 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 65 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
JUSTD<'s Stc()ll() Am.oar
Cbapla'6
No proper name has been bestowed upon God. the Father of aU, since He is unbegotten. For, whoever has a proper name received k from a person older than himself. The wools Father, and God. and CJeator, and Lord, and Master are not real rwnes, but rather terms of address derived from His beneficent deeds. But His Son, who alone is properly called Son, che Word, who was with Him [God, the Facherl and was begotten before aU things, when in the beginning He !God. the Father! created and arranged aU lhings through Him !che Son!, is called Christ, because He was anointed and because God the Father arranged aU the things of creation through Him. This name also has an unknown meaning, just as the term 'God.' which is not a real name, but the expression of a human innate opinion of a thing that can scarcely be defined. But jesus,' which is His name bodl as Man and Savlor, has a meaning. For He also became man. as we stated, and was born in accordance with the will of God the Father for the benefit of believets, and for the defeat of che demons. Even now, your own eyes will teach you the truth of this last s!lltemenL For many dernoniacs throughout the entire world, and even in your own dty, were exordsed by many of our Christlans in the name ofJesus Christ, who was crudfied under Pontius Pllate; and our people cured them, and they still cure others by renderirlg helpless and dispelling the demons who bad taken possession of these men, even when they oould not be cured by all the other ~. and exploiters of incantations and drugs. Chapter7
Therefore God postpOnes the oollapse and dissolution of the universe (through which the bad angels, the demons, and people would eease to exist), because of the Christian seed, which He knows to be the cause in narure [of the world's preservation). If such were not the case, it would be impossible for you to do the ch.ings you do and be influenced by the evil demons; but the fire of judgment would descend and would completely dissolve everych.ing, just as the Hood waters onee left no one but hirn, with his family, whom we eaU Noah and you eaU Deucallon, from whom in rum so many have been born, some of them bad, others good. In this manner, we claim that the world will finally be destroyed
51
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 51. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=66 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 66 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
by fire, and not, as the Stoles believe, because aU things change inlo one another acoording to their disgnceful doctrlne of metamorphosis. Nor do we teach [as do the Stoks) that people act and suffer acoording to the dictates of fate, but that by their own free will people act either weD or evilly; and that through the influen<:e of evil demons good people, such as Socrates and the like, are persecuted and imprisoned, while Sardanapalus, Epicurus, and the like seem to be endowed with wealth and glory. But the Stoia., ignotant of this demoniacal influence, claimed that everything takes place by the necessity of fare. But, since God from the very beginning created the race of angels and human beings with free w!U, they will justly pay the penalty In everlasting fire for the sins they have committed. Indeed, every creature is capable, by nature, of vice and of vinue. Nor would any action of theirs be worthy of praise unless they had the power to incline to either [vice or virtue]. The uuth of this is shown everywbere by those legislators and philosophers who, acting accordlng to riglu reason, have ordered some thiogs to be done and others to be avoided. The Stole philosophers also, in their moral teaching. always respea the same principles, so it is easily seen how wrong they are in their teaching on principles and incorporeal beings. For,lfthey stlte that human acts occur by fate, they will admit either that God is nothing else than those things which continually rum and change and dissolve Into the same elements, and will seem to understand only oonuptible things, and to affirm that God himself both in part and in whole is in every sin; or else that neidler vice nor virtue is anything which is against every sound idea, reason, and mind.
Cbaptu8 We know that the followers of the Stole teaching. be<:ause they were praiseworthy at least In their ethics, as were also the poers In some respects, because of the seed of reason implanted In all mankind, were hated and kllled As examples, we could mention Heraclirus, as we already stated, and Musonius, of our own times, and others. for, as we poinled out, the demons always brought it about that everyone, who strives in any way to Uve according to right reason and to avoid evil, be an object of hatted. Nor is it surprising that the demons are proved to be the cause why they are much more bated who do D(){ Uve accordlng to only a part of the seminal word, but by the knowledge and consideration
5Z
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 52. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=67 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 67 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
J'fJ'STIN"s S!CONDA'<'WGT
of the whole Word, whlch Is Christ. But theoe demons sball suffer just punishment and ronnents, confined to everlasting ftre; for the fact that they are overcome even now by people in the name of Jesus Cluist is a. sign that they and their followers will be punished in eternal fire. All the prophets foretold that it would happen thus, and so taught Jesus, our Teacher. 0>ap~9
Lest any one repeat the mistake of those S0<3Iled philosopher.; who claim that our statements that the sinners are punished in everlasting fire are just boastful words calculated to instill terror, and that we want people to live a virtuous life through fear, and not because such a life is
plea.sant,l will make dlis brief reply that, if it Is not as we say, then there i• no God; or, if there Is a God, He Is oot concerned with people, and virrue and vice are nothing, and, a.s we already stated, legislators unjustly punish the tnnSgressors of their excellent precepts. Bur, since these legislators are not unjust, and their Father. instructs them through the Word to do a.s He Himself does, they who comply with these legislators are not unjuSL If anyone should advance the remonstJ:ance that human laws are differen~ ~d Slly that some people coi\Sider one !hing good, another bad, while other people deem as good what the former considered bad, and as bad what they thought good, let him listen to this reply. We realize that the bad angels made laws suited to their own iniquity, which are pleasing to their counterparts among people; and the uue Word, at Hls coming, proved that not all opinions and teachings are good, but that some are bad, and others good. Wherefore, I will repeat the same statements and uner similar ones to such people a.s these, and, If necessat¥. I shall develop them more at length. But for the present I must rerum to my subject.
Chapter 10 Beyond dou~ therefore, our teachings are noble than all human teaching, because Christ, who appeared on earth for our sakes, became the whole Logos, namely, Logos and body and soul. Everything that the philosophers and legislators discovered and expressed well, they accomplished through their discovery and contemplation of some part of the Logos. But, since they did not have a full knowledge of the
53
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 53. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=68 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 68 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Logos, which is Christ, they often oontradlcted themselves. And !hose wbo were born before Chd$1 asswnedhwnan nature were dragged into law coutts as irreligious and meddling persons, when they tried In human narrowness to think out and prove things by reason. Socrares, the most ardent of all in this regard, was accused of the vel)' crimes that ate imputed to us. They claimed that he introduced new deities and rejected the state-sponsored gods. But what he did was to ostradze Homer and the other poetS, and to instnlct people to expel the evil demons and !hose who perpetrated the deeds narrated by the poets: and to exhon people by meditation to learn more about God who was unknown to them, saying: 'It is not an easy matter to find the Father and Creator of all things, nor, when He is found, is it safe to announce Him to all people. 'Yet, our ChdSl did aU this through His own power. There was no one who believed so much in Socrares as to dle for his teaching, but not only philOSOPhers and scholars believed in Christ, of whom even Socrates had a vague knowledge (for He was and is the Logos who is in eve!)' person. and who predicted things to come first through the prophets •nd then in person when He assumed our human nature and feelings, and taught us these docuines), but also workers and people wholly uneducated, who all scorned glory, and fear, and death. Indeed, this Is brought about by the power of the ineffable Father, and not through the instrumentality of human reason.
Cbapterll Neither should we Chdstians be pur to death, nor would evil people and demons prevail over us, were it not for the fact that absolutely eve!)'one who is born must also, by reasoo ofa deb~ be subject to death. Thus, when we liquidate this debt, we render thanlu. Now, for the sake of Crescens and those who rant like him, we deem it proper and fitting to relate here what Xenophon wrote. Hercules, relates Xenophon, once came to a place where three roads met, aod there he found V'utue and Vice, who appeared to him in the guise of women. And Vice, in a costly an d seductive dress, with an expression made alluring by such adornments, and being instantly f.lsdnating to look a~ said to Hercuies that, if he wouid follow her, she would see to it that his whole life would be one of pleasure and that he would be arrayed in !he most brilliant One!)'. such as she herself was then wearing. And Virtue, who was
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 54. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=69 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 69 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
loathsome in appearance and dress, said: 'If you wUI obey me, you will be adorned, noc w11h passing and perisb2ble ornaments or beauty, but wi1h everlasting and precious adoromerus.' Indeed, we believe that 1he one who avoids wil2t only appealS to be good and suives for wil2t is considered difficult and unreasonable, will aaain happiness. for Vice, to disguiSe her own aaioos, appropriated the qualities of V'IIIUe which really are excellent, by imitating wil2t is incorruptible (for Vice neither possesses nor is able to effect incomlptibillty) and enslaves low-minded people, attributing her own evU habits to V'u:tue. But. those who have undetSiood 1he things that really are good ate also llll$poUed in vinue. Such persons, everyone who is intelligent should conclude, were 1he Christians, the athleteS, and those who performed 1he deeds which 1he poets narrate of the so-called gods; and this conclusion should be drawn from the fact that we Christians scorn escaping from death. Chapter 12
Indeed, when I myself revelled in the teachings of Plato, and heard the Christians misrepresenled and watched them stand fearless in the face of death and of every other thing that was considered dreadful, I realized 1he impossibility of their living in sinful pleasure. For, what sensual or self-indulgent person, who approves of the eating of human flesh, would welcome death that he might be despoiled of his pleasures, and would not rather always 1rf to continue in his presenttnanner of life, and to elude the public officers; and much less would he be apt to denounce himself when the penalty was death? The evU demons have caused these things also to be effected by wicked people. For, after inlliaing the death penalty on some because of the false charges lodged against us, they subjected or servants, some of them children and women, to tortUre, and foroed from them by these tetrible torments a confession of those fictitious crimes which they themselves publicly commit But we are not in the lea& concerned about such crimes, since we do nor commit them, having as witness of our thoughts and actions the Unbegotten and Ineffable God. For why did we not acknowledge that we consider these things good, and show how they are divine phUooophy, affirming that the mysteries of Saturn have in homicide and in drinking blood the same effect as what you do before 1he idol you venerate, on which you sprinkle not only the blood of brute animals, but also of
55
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 55. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=70 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 70 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
people, malciiig a libation of !he slain person's blood through the most distinguished and most noble person in your midst? And by lml~ting Jupiter and the other gods in sodomy and sinful relations with women, might they not, in defense of thelt aaions, dte !he Writings of Epicurus and the poetS? But, because ~ persuade people to avoid such custOm$ and those who practice them, together with their imitator$, as we now have striven hard to persuade you with the$e words, we are assaikd in many ways. But we are n()( in the least womed, for we reali2e that God is the just supervisor of all. Would that even now someone would ascend a lofty platform and cry out in loud voice: 'Be ashamed and blush, you who accuse the innocent of !be very crimes you yourselves openly commit; and things of whkh you and your gods are guilty, you charge to those persons who have not the slightest pan in them. Change your ways: and come to your senses.'
apterl' When I learned of the evil caroouflage which the wicked demons bad thrown around the divine docUines of the Cluistians to deter others from following them, I had to laugh at the authOIS of these lies, at the camoullage itself, and at the popular reaction. I am proud to say that I strove with all my might to be known as a Christian, not because the teachings of Plato are different from those of Christ, but because they are not in every way simib.r; neither are those of other writers, the Stoics, the poetS, and !he bistorians. For each one of them, seeing, through hi.s paltidpation of the seminal Divine Word, what was related to it, spoke very welL But, they who eonlr.ldict themselves in impomnr matters evidently did nor acquire the unseen [that is, heavenly] wisdom and the indi.sp=ble knowledge. The truths which people in all lands have rightly spoken belong to us Cluistians. For we worship and love, after God !he Father, the Word who is from the Unbegooen and Ineffable God, since He even became Mall for us, so that by sharing in our sulferings He also might heal us. Indeed, all writers, by means of the engrafted seed of the Word which was Implanted in them, had a dim glimpse of the 11\lth. For !he seed of something and its ~tion, given in proportion to one's capacity, is one rhing, but the thing itself, which is shared and Imitated according to His grace, is quite another.
56
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 56. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=71 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 71 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Chapter 14
We tberef01e beseech you to publish this pronouncement, adding your comment to it, so that ochers may know our customs and be released from the bond$ of false bellefs and of igno1'31\Ce of good; for by their own fault they have become worthy of punishment. Promulgate these wO
sakes.
S1
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 57. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=72 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 72 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
This page intentionally left blank
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 58. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=73 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 73 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Ma•lyrdom ofPerpm.a (:Z02 oc :Z03, ~North Africa)
~unrs of the last days of the Christian manyrs were an imponant genre of e2rly Church literature, quite popular among ordin2ry Christians in the third oentury. Some of the manyrs whose deaths were r..corded in this literature were important Church officials like bishops, but many were simple laypeople, or even catechumens (people learning the faith before being admined into the Church by baptism). These accounts were composed or edited panly to honour the memories of those who had died for their faith, and partly also to inspire those who remained alive and might themselves have to confront the mattyr's <:hoice between denying Christ and suffering death. Were you to read the acoounrs of the manyrs, you would begin noticing in many of them some recurring scenes, stock dialogue sections, and common narrative structureS, with an emphasis on the miraculous. For these reasons, modem historians tre2t them skeptically, although they reoognize that some of them may incorporate more credible evideooe, such as court reoords or eye-witness reportS. But the Mtmyrdom ofPerpetua is not representative of the genre. For instance, there are no miracles in the usual sense, although Perperua does have miraculous visions; and the writing seems fresh and dire<:t, not simply derived from a literary model.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 59. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=74 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 74 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Most of the documetlt (chapter.; 3-10) is represented as an excerpt from the diaty of Perperua, a 20-year-old catechwnen who was the mother of an infant son. Another po!1ion (chapter.; 11-13) is represented as the work of one of her fellow manyrs, named Sarurus. The rest comes from the hand of a Christian editor. The purpose and the theology of the editor may be different from the purpose and the theology of the documents which the editor is lr.UISCribing. The place of martyrdom is Cart.hage, in North Africa, and the year is thought to be 202 or 203, when it is known that Christian and Jewish convertS were suffelillg offidal per.;ecution in various pans of the Empire. Perperua's diary is one of only four surviving documents from the first sill: Christian centuries that are presented as wrinen by a woman. Many other early Christian documents are known to have been written by women, but they were not preserved. There are versions of this text in Latin and Greek. The Latin is usually believed to be the original version. The translation below was made from the Latin.
Questions on the reading What is the editor"s stated purpose for making these documents avallable? What does he or she think the Church might learn from them? What is the editor"s relation to Perperua and Saturu.s? What might be inferred about the edito(s theological position? What might be inferred about the social and e<:clesiliS!ical situation of the readers whom the editor is wanting to address? Is it possible to determine Perperua's and SaturuS' purpose and theological position, or are these obscured by the process of editorial selection and revision? What are Perperua's soda! origins, and why might an early Christian audienoe be in!erested in them? How does Perperua relate to her father and husband? What might be the meaning of the various visions sbe records? How does Perpetua, a female catechumen, relate to male Church officiaLs, and what might be surprising in this respect? What evidence does the document give as to why manyrs were willing to suffer, and as to why persecutors persecuted?
60
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 60. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=75 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 75 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
1. If inslances of aocient faith which both testified eo die grace of God and edified peiS0!1S were written expressly for God's honor and humans' encoungement, why shouldn't recent eveniS be similatly recorded for those same purposes? For dlese everus will likewise become JXIIt of die past and vilalco postetlly, in spice of the fact that cocttemporary esceem for antiquhy cends eo minimize their value. And those who rnaincain thac lhere is a single manifestation of lhe one Holy Spirit cbrougbouc the ages ought to considet chat since a fullness of grace has been decreed for the last days of the world dlese recent events should be considered of greater value because of their proximity to those days. For "In the last days; says the Lord, 'l shall diffuse my spirit over all humanity and !heir sons and daugluers shall prophesy; the young shall see visions, and !he old shall dreatn dreams."'
Just as we valued those prophecies so we ~ledge and reverence the new visions which were promised. And we consider the other powers of the Holy Spirit to be instruments of the Church 10 which chat same Spirit was sent to administer all gifts to all people, just as the Lord alloned. l'or this reason we de
5<Juroe, "The Martyrdom of Pcpetua,: lml$. Rooenwy Rader, in Patrlcla WllsonJ
61
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 61. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=76 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 76 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
married woman about twentyr= old, of good family and upbringing. She had a father, mother, two biOibers (one was a catecllumen like hetself), and an infant son at the breas!. The following account of her martyrdom is her own, a record in her own words of her peroeplions of the event.
3. While I was sliU wkh me police authorities (she said) my father out of love for me tried to dissuade me frotn my resolution. "Father; 1 said, "do you see here, for eJ
4. Then my brother said to me, "Dear sister, you already have such a great reputation that you could ask for a vision indicating whether you wiU be condemned or freed." Since I knew that I could speak wkh lhe
62
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 62. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=77 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 77 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Lord, whooe gte2t favors I had already experienced, I confidently pi'OIIUsed to do so. I salell would tell my brother about it the next day. then I macle my request and this is what I saw.
there was a bronze ladder of emaordinary height reaching up to heaven. but it was so narrow that only one person could ascend at a time. £very conceiVable kind of iron weapon was attached to the sides of the ladder: swolds, lances, hooks, and dagsers. If anyone climbed up carelessly or without looking upmrds, he/she would be mangled as tbe flesh adhered to tbe weapons. Crouching direa!y beneath the ladder was a monstrous dragon who threatened those climbing up and uied to frighten them from ascent. Saturus went up first. Because of his concern for us he bad given himself up voluntarily after we bad ~ arrested. He had been our source of strength but was not with us at the time of the arrest. When he reached the top of the ladder he turned to me and said, "Pelpetua, rm waiting for you, but be careful not to be bitten by the dragon. " !told him that in the name of Jesus Christ the dragon could not harm me. At this the dragon slowly lowered its bead as though afraid of me. Using its head as the first step, I began my ascent.· At the summit I saw an immense garden, in the center of which sat a tall, grey·baired man dressed like a shepherd, milking sheep. Slanding around him were several thousand white·robed people. As he raised his bead be noticed me and said, "Welcome, my child." Then he beckoned me to approach and gave me a small morsel of the cheese he was making. I acxepted it with cupped hands and ate it. When all those surrounding us said "Amen," I awoke, stiU taSting the sweet cheese. I immediately told my brother about the vision, and we both realized that we were to experience the sufferings of martyrdom. From then on we gave up having any hope in this world. 5. A few days later there was a rumor that our case was to be heard.
My father, completely exhausted from his anxiety, came from the city to see me, with the intention of weakening my faith. "Daughter", he said, "have pity on my grey bead. Have piiy on your father if! have the honor to be called father by you, if with these hands I have brought you to the prime of your life, and if I have ahvays favored you above your brolhers, do not abandon me to the reproach of men. Consider your brolhers;
63
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 63. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=78 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 78 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
consider your mother and your aunt; consider your son who cannot live without you. Give up your srubbomness before you destroy all of us. None of us will be able to speak freely if anything happens to you.• These were the things my father said out of love, kissil1g my bands and throwi11g himself at my feet. With tears he called me not daughter, but woman. I was very upset because of my father's condition. He was the only member of my famlly who would 6nd no reason for joy in my suffering. I tried to comfort him saying, "Whatever God wants at this tribunal will happen, for remember that our power comes not from ourselves but from God.· But utterly dejeaed, my father left me.
6. One day as we were eating we were suddenly rushed off for a heating. We anived at the forum and the oews spread quickly throughout the area near the forum, and a h uge crowd gathered. We went up to the prisonetS' platform. All the others confessed when they were questioned. When my rum came my father appeared With my son. Draggil1g me from the step, he begged: 'Have pity on your son!" Hibrion, the govcmor, wbo assumed power after the death o f the proconsul Minucius Timinianus.' said, "Have pity on your father's grey head; have pity on your infant son; offer sacrifice for the emperotS' "-'elfare•. But Ianswered, "I will not• Hilarion asked, •Are you a Chrlstlan?' And I answered, 1 am a Christian.' And when my father petSisted in his attempts to dissuade me, Hllarion ordered him thrown out, and he was beaten with a rod. My father's injury bun me as much as if I myself bad been beaten, and I grieved because of bis pathetic old age. Then the sentence was passed; all of us were condemned to the beasts. We were overjoyed as we went back to the prison cell Since I was still nursing my child wbo was ordinarily in the cell with me, I quickly sent the deacon Pomponius to my father's house 10 ask for the baby, but my father refused 10 give him up. Then God saw to it that my child no longer needed my nur.;ing, nor were my breasts inlhmed. After that I was no longer tortured by anxiety about my child or by pain in my breasts. 7. A few days later while all of us were praying, in the middle of a prayer I suddenly called out the name ' Dinocrates. • I was astonished since I badn1 thought about him till then. When I recalled what bad happened to him I was very disturbed and decided right then that I had not only the right, but the obligation, to pray for him. So I began 10 pn>y repeatedly and to make moaning sounds to the Lord in his behalf.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 64. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=79 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 79 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
During dl21 same night I has this v;s;on: I saw Oinocrates walking away from one of many very dark places. He seemed very hot and thirsty, his face grimy and coioriess. The wound on his face was juSt as it had been when he died. 1bls Dinocrates was my blood-brother who at the age of seven died very tragi~y from a cancerous disease which so disfigured his face that his death was repulsive to everynne. It was for him that 1 now prayed. But neither of us could reach·t he other because of the great distance between. In the pla<:e where Dinocmtes stood was a pool filled with water, and the rim of the pool was so high that it extended far above the boy's height. Oinocrates stood on his toes as if to drink the wa~ but in spite of the fact that the pool was full, be could not drink because the rim was so high! I realized that my brother was in trouble, but I was confident that I could help him with his problem. I prayed for him every day unlil we were transfOTed to the arena prison where we were to light wild animals on the birthday of Geta caesar• And I prayed day and night for him, mooning and weeping so that my petition would be granted. 8. On that day that we were kept in chains, I had the following vision: I saw the same place as before, but Dinocrates was clean, welldressed, looking refreshed. In place of the wound there was a scar, and the fountain which I had seen previously now had its rim lowered to the boy's waist On the rim, over which ~was flowing constantly, there was a golden bowl filled with water. Dinocrates walked up to it and begAA to drink; the bowl never emptied And when he was no longer tbir&y, be gladly went to play as children do. Then I awoke, knowing that be had been relieved of his suffering.
9. A few days passed Pudens, the offici.al in charge of the prison (the offici.al who bad gradually come to admire us for our persistence), admined many prisoners to our ceU so that we might muruaUy encourage each other. AS the day of the games drew near, my fatber;overwhelmed with grief, came again to see me. He began to pluck out his beard and throw il on the ground. Falling on his face before me, he cursed his old age, repeating such things as would move aU creation. And I grieved because of his o ld age. 10. The day before the battle in the arena, in a vision I saw Pomponlus the deacon coming to the prison door and knocking very loudly. l went
6S
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 65. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=80 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 80 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
to open the gate for him. He was dtessed in a loosely fitting white robe, wearing richly decorated sandals. He said to me, "Perperua, come. We're waiting for you!" He took my band and we began to walk over extremely rocky and winding paths. When we fmally anived short of breath, at the arena, he led me to the cenrer saying, "Don't be frightened! I'll be here to help you." He left me and I Slllred out over a huge crowd which watched me with apprehension. Because I Im.ew that I had to fight with the beasts, I wondered why they hadn't yet been turned loose in the arena. Coming towards me was some type of Egyptian. honible to look a~ accompanied by ftghters who were to help defeat me. Some handsome young men came forward to help and encourage me. I was stripped of my clothing, and suddenly I was a man. My asslscants began to rub me with oil as was the custom before a con~ while the Egyptian was on the opposite side rolling in the sand. Then a certain man appe:ued, so tall that be towered above the amphitheatre. He wore a loose purple robe with two p:uaUel stripes across the chest; his sandals were richly decorated with gold and silver. He canied a rod like t1ut of an athletic trainer, and a green branch on whieh were golden apples. He motioned for silence and said, "If !hi$ Egyptian wins, he will kill her with the sword; but if she wins, she will receive !hi$ brand!.· Then he withdrew. We both stepped forward and began to f~ght with our fiSts. My opponent kept uying to grab my feet but I repeatedly kicked his face with my heels. I fek myself being lifted up into the air and began to strike at him as one who was no longer earth-bound. But when I saw that we were wasting time, I put my two hands together, linked my fingers, and put his h ead between them. AS he fell on his face I stepped on his head. Then the people began to shout and my assistants started singing victory songs. I walked up to the uainer and accepted the branch.' He kissed me and said, "Peace be with you, my daughter." And I triumphantly headed towards the Sanavivarian Gate' Then I woke up reali:zing that I would be contending not with wild animals but with the devil himself. I knew, however, that I would win. I have recorded the events which occurred up to the day before the final contest. Let anyone who wishes to record the events of the contest itself, do so." 11. The saindy Sarurus also related a vision which he had and it is recorded here in his own hand. Our suffering had ended (he said), and we were being c:utied tow:uds the east by four 21'Jgels whose hands
66
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 66. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=81 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 81 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
nevet touclled us. And we floated up"Nd, not ill a supine position, but as though we were climbing a gentle slope. As we left the eanh's atmosphere we saw a brilliant light, and I said to Perperua who was at my side, "This is what the lord promised us. We have received his promise."
And whlle we were being carried along by those four angels we saw a large open space like a splendid gartlen landscaped with rose trees and every variety of ftower. The trees were as tall as cypresses whose leaves rustled gendy and incessantly. And there in that garden-sanctuary were four other angels, more dazzling than the re&c And when they saw us they showed us honor, saying to the other angels in admiJation, "Here !hey are! They have arrived." And those four angels who were carrying us began trembling in awe and set us down. And we walked through a violet-sr:rewn field where we met jocundus, Sarumlnus, and AnaXIus who were burned alive in that same persecution, and Quinrus, also a martyr, who had died in prison. We were asking them where they had been, when the other angels said to us, "Flrs1, come lhls way. Go in a.n d greet the Lord."
12. We went up to a place where the walls seemed consr:ructed of light. At the entrance of the place stood four angels who put white robes on those who entered. We went in and heard a unified voice chanting l!nd!OS$ly, "Holy, holy, holy." We saw a white haired man silting there who, in spite of his snowy white hair, had the features of a young man. His feet were nor visible. On his right and left were four elderly gentlemen and behind them stood many more. As we entered we stood in amazement before the throne. Four angels suppon.ed us as we weru up to kiss the aged man, and he gently stroked o ur faces with his bands. The other elderly men said to us, "Stand up.• We rose and gave the kiss of peace. Then they told us to enjoy ourselves. I said to Perperua, "You have your wish. • She answered, "I thank God. for although I was happy on earth, I am much happier here right now. • 13. Then we went our. and before the gates we saw Optarus the bishop on the right and Aspasius the priest and teacher on the left, botb looking sad as they stood there separated from each other. They knelt before us saying. "Make peace between us, for you've gone away and left us lhls way." But we said to them, • Aren't you our spirirual father,
67
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 67. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=82 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 82 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
and our <eacber' Why are you kneeling bd"ore us?' We were deeply toUched and we embraced them. And Perpetua began 10 speak to them in Greek and we invited !hem ullo !he garden benealh a rose tree. While we were
14. The remarkable visions namued above were diose of!he blessed martyrs Saturus and PerpetUa, just as they put them in writing. As for Secundulus, while he was still in prison God gave him the grace of an earlier exit from this world, so that he could escape combat with !he wild beasts. But his body, though n()( his soul, certainly felt the sword. 15. As for Felicitas, she too was touched by God's grace in the foDowing manner. She was pregnant when amsted, and was now In her eighlh month. As the day of the contest appl'O
And so, two days before the contest, united in grief they prayed to the Lord. lmmedi.ately after !he prayers her labor painS began. Because of the additional pain natural for an eigluh-mon!h delivery, she suffered greatly during the birth, and one of the prison guards taunted her; "If you're complaining now, wbar will you do when you'll be thrown to !he wild beasts? You didn't thinkofthemwhen you refusedtosaai!ice." She answered, "Now it is I who suffer, but then anomer shall be in me to bear !he pain for me, since I am now suffering for him.• And she gave birth to a girl whom one of her &stern reared as her own daughter. 16. Since the Holy Spirit has permitted, and by permitting has willed, that !be events of !he contest be recorded, we have no choice but ro
68
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 68. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=83 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 83 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
T'Nr IJJ.KrrMoM OF PERnrfM.
carry out ~ injunction (rather, the sacred uust) of Perpetua, in spite of the fact that it will be an inferior addition to the magnificent events already de scribed. We are adding an instance of Perpetua's perseverance and lively spirit. Al. one time ~ prisonetS were being treated with unusual severity by~ COllllllllnding officer because cetlllin dt we should appear in good condition on that day?" The officer grimaced and blushed, ~ordered that they be treated more humanely and that her brothers and others be allowed to Visit and dine w ith them. By this time the prison warden was himself a believer. 17. On the day before the public games, as they were eating Why are you so eager to see something you hate' Friends today, enemies tomorroW! Take a good look so you'll recognize us on that day. • Then they all left the prison amazed, and many of them began to believe. 18. The day of their victory dawned, and With joyful countenances they matched from the prison to the arena as though on their way to heaven. If there was any trembling it was from joy, not fear. Perperua followed with quick step as a uue spouse of Christ, the darling of God, her brigbdy flashing eyes quelling the gaze of the crowd. Felldtas too, joyful because she had safely survived childbitth and was now able to panidpate in the contest with the Wild animals, passed from one shedding of blood to another: from midwife to gladiator. about to be purified after child-bin:h by a second baptism. As ~y were led through the gate they were ordered to put on different clothes; the men.• those of the priestS of Sarum, the worn
69
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 69. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=84 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 84 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
with. you.· Injustice bowed 10 justice and th.e guatd conceded !hat they could enter th.e arena in th.eir ordinary dress. Perperua was singing vietol)' psalms as if already crushing th.e head of th.e Egyptian. Revocatus, Satuminus and SaturuS were warning th.e spectators, and as they came within sight of Hilarion they informed him by nods and gesrures: "You condemn us; God condemns you.• 1bis so infuriated th.e crowds that they demanded the soourging of these men in front of th.e line of gladiator.;. But th.e o nes so punished rejoiced in that th.ey had obtained yer another share in the Lord's suffering. 19. Whoever said, "Ask and you shall receive," gr:mted to these petitioners the partk:ular death that each one chose. for whenever th.e mafl)'<S were discussing among themselves their choice ofdeath, Sarurus used 10 say that he wished to be thrown in with all the animals so that he mlghr wear a more glorious Acoordlngly, at che outset of the show he was matct>ed against a leopard but then called back; then he was mauled by a bear on the exhibition platform Now Sarurus detested nothing as much as a bear and be had already decided to die by one bite from the leopard. Consequently, when he was tied to a wild boar th.e professional gladiator who had tied th.e two together was pierced instead and died shortly after the games ended, while Saturus was merely dragged abouL And when he was tied up on the bridge in front of the bear, th.e bear refused to come out of his den; and so a second time Sarurus was called back unharmed.
ao""'·
20. For the young women the devil had readied a mad cow, an animal not usually used at these games, but selected so that the women's sex wou.l d be matched with !hat of the animal. After being saipped and enmeshed in nets, the women were led into the arena. How horrified the people were as they saw !hat one was a young girl and the other, her breasts dripping with milk, had just recently given birth to a child. Consequently bo!b were recalled and dressed in l~ly fining gowns. Perperua was t05sed first and fell on her back She sat up, and being more concerned with her sense of modescy than with her pain, covered her thighs with ber gown which had been tom down one side. Then finding her hair-clip which had fallen out, she pinned back her loose hair thinking it oot proper for a martyr to suffer with dishevelled hair; it mlght seem that she was mourning in her hour of aiumph. Then sbe stood up. Noticing that Peliciw was badly bruised. she went 10 her, reached out her hands and helped ner to her feeL As they stood there
70
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 70. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=85 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 85 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
the cruelty of the aowds seemed to be appeased and they were sent to the Sanavivarian Gate. There Perperua was taken care of by a certain cat«
Then Sarurus said to Pudens the soldier, "Goodbye, and remember my faith. Let these happenings be a source of strength for you, rather than a cause for anxiety." Then asking Pudens for a ring from bis finger, he dipped it into the wound and rerumed it to Pudens as a legacy, a pledge and rememb~ of his death. And as he collapsed he was thrown With the rest to that place reserved foe the usual throat·slltting. And when the crowd demanded that the prisoners be brought out into the open so that they might feast their eyes on death by the sword, they voluntarily arose and moved where the crowd warued them. Before doing so they kissed each other so that their martyrdom would be completely perfected by the rite of the kiss of peace. The others, without making any movement or sound, were killed by the sword. Sarurus in particular, since he had been the llrsl to climb tbe ladder and was to be Perpe!Ua's encouragement, was the first to die. But Perperua, in order to feel some of the pain, groanil1g as she was struck between the ribs, lOOk the gladiator's trembling hand and gttided it to her throaL Perhaps it was that so great a woman, feared as she was by 71
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 71. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=86 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 86 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
the unclean spirit, could 110( have been slain had she not herself willed it.
0 brave and fortunate martytS, uuly called and chosen to give honor to our Lord Jesus Christ! And anyone who is elaborating upon, ()(who reverences or "'orshlps that honor, should read lhese more recent examples, along wilh the ancient, as sources of encouragement for lhe Christian community.ln this way, !here will be new examples of courage witnessing to lhe fact !hat even in our day lhe same Holy Spirit is still efficaciously present, along with lhe all powerful God the Father and Jesus Christ our Lord, to whom there will al'll>'llYS be glory and endless power. Amen.
Notes Aas 2:17- 18. ct.Joel2:28. Apparently after baptism the newly baptlzed could pray for a specW grace or gift. et. Terrullian •en Baptism", 20. ~
There is no real infonna.tion about Minucius Timianus, but Hllarion is mentiOned os o.n Afric•n l'fOCO<\$Ul by Teltllllian, Ad Scapula m3;1. Hlbdon W'U evidently temporarily serving as governor urujJ a new one would be
appointed. ThiS incidental reference to the celebration of g>tn"' on Gera ·s birthday helps .,..blisb the date of the manyrdorn some
205. The bc'a.nch was the rewatd presented to the combat or conteSt.
victOt in any kind of offlCial
The Potu SanaViV2ria (Gate of Life) was the gate by wbkh the viaors would exiL Tho6e who _.. defeated were canied 001 through the Poru Libitlnensis.
•
The ag;.pe or ·Jove feast" ..... the common meal shared by the early Ouistia.n communities. lt was the vi$ible expression of the love Cbri5lians felt for each other as co-sharers of the lo'"' of Chri>t. One of the cuStomary greetings of good omen before and after the publi<: haths was ·salvum lorum; here used irOrucany by the crowd in the amphitht:ater.
n Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 72. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=87 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 87 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
The
work we now know as the Apo
Later in the nineteenth centwy schobts discovered manuscripts of the same work (but with detailed differences) in anothet dialect o f Coptic and in Arabic, Ethiopic, and l.atin. The work was also identified as being closely related to three other early Chtlslian documents (knOM> as the Apostolic ConstitUtions Book 8, the EpitorM, and the canons of Hlppo/ylus). And there were •fragments" of the work, that is, quotations in other "-'riting$. It came to be agteed, for various reasons, that the original language of the work must have been Greek; but no manusaipts of the Greek text exist. There is no evidence in !he cen itself for the licie 'Apostolic Tradition,· and oooe for the dare or pl:ace of its composition. But one fragmem, and rwo of the works to which the document is closely "'lated (the Fpilome and the Canons of Hippolytui), do credit the influence of a person named HJppolytus. Now, as it bappens, an ltnportant though noc quite orthodox lheologian named Hippolyrus lived at Rome in the early third century, and several of his works a... knOM>. A S12tue of this Hippolytus
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 73. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=88 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 88 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
was excavated in Rome in 1551, and caNed in its base were the titles of several worlts, some of them known as Hippolytus' and some of them n<X known. One litle which was not known was "Apostolic Tradition". Scholarly studies in 1906, 1910, and 1916 tried to make the obvious connecdon. They argued that the mySteriOU$ work that bad first been published in 1848 flom a Coptic manuscript was in faa a uanslation of the "ApostoUc Tradition· ofHippolytus.
Many liturgical scholm, especially, received the theory e:ogerly. If the ascription to Hippolytus were corre<:t, this work was by far the earliest evidence for the Uturgical Ufe of Rome, and given how frequently it was tr:mslated and how many odler early Christian writerS drew from it, it must have been extremely influential in the early Church. When the modem movement for liturgical revision gathered momentum in the early 1960s, notably in the Roman Catholic, Angllcon, and Lutheran communions, Uturgical revisers embraced the Apostolic Tradition as one of the crucial models for their task. For this reason, few works from the early Church have been more widely read in the past thirty years than this one; several editions, both popular and scholarly, have been published, and numerous books and articles have been written a bout it. More recently, the ascription of this work to Hippolytus has been incteaslngly chaDenged. It reSIS mainly on the ldentlficatlon of the name "Hippolytus•, connected with a few manuscripts of the work. with the Hippolytus wh06e statue was excavated. This identification is by no means sure. The stal\le itself, as a matter of faet, is curious; it seems orlglnaUy to have been the starue of a woman, re· fashioned into a male flgure in the sixteenth century, perhaps on the grounds that a woman could not have written the books wh06e tides were listed. No textual evidence connects the document to Rome or to the early thitcl century. In any event, there Is some reason to believe that the Hippolytus of the statue may have been in schism from the Catholic Church; in this case, if he did write this work, he may have done so simply in order to justify the possibly e«enlric practices ofbis little breakaway constituency.
The English translation below is based on the Latin version of what is believed to be a Greek original. Additions and alterations taken from manuscripts other than the Latin text are printed in italics.
74
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 74. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=89 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 89 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Questions OD tbe reading What aUlhority does the author claim for the regulations given here? Why mighi the document have been written? How does the author undentand the Church? liturgical prayer? What seems to distinguish the offices of bishop, presbyter, and deacon? What conuoveny about confessors appean to be in the historical background? What moral and disciplina.ry standards does the document establlsh? How does the author's church community appear to relate to the secular world? How can the two examples of a Eucharlst prayer be compan:d and contrasted? What is the understanding of Christian initiation? How might one explain the differences in substan ce and tone between the Didaclie and this documenl? Aft ihere clues that this document did or did not have authority foc an historical Christian cormnunity?
1. We have set down those things which were worthy of note about the gifts which God has bestowed on humanity from the beginning according to his own will, presenting to himself ihat image whlch had gone astray. And now, led on by love for all the saints, we have proceeded to the summit of the tradition which befits the churches, in order ihar those who have been well taught by our exposition may guard ihat tradition which has remained up to now, and by recognising it may remain fum - because of ihat backsliding or error which was recently invented through Ignorance - and that those who are ignorilnt (since ibe holy Spirit bestows perfect grace on those who believe righdy) may know how ibose who preside over ibe Church should band down and guard all things. Source: Hippolyws,{Apostollc Tmdl#ond A Text For~ ed. G J. Qlming. Bramco<e, Nons.: Grove Books, 1976, 8-31, omiaing notes.
7S
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 75. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=90 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 90 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Ofllisbops 2. Let him be ordained bishop who has been chosen by all the people; and when he has been named and accepted by all, let the people assemble, together with the presbytery and those bishops who are presen~ on the lord's day. When all give cons~ they shall lay hands on him, and the presbytery shall stand by and be stUl And all shall keep sUence, praying in their hearts for the descent of the Spiri~ after which one of the bishops present, being asked by all, shall lay his hand on him who is being ordained bishop, and pray, saying thus:
The Prayer for Ordination of a Bishop
3. God and Fatbn' of our Lord Jesus Christ, Father of mercies and God of all comfor<, you dwell on bigb and look on that wblcb is k>w/y; you lm<>w all things before they come to pass; you gave ordinanus in tbe Cburr:b through tbe word ofyour grace; you f oro<>rdained from the beginning a race of rlgbt«>us men from Abrabam; you appointed prinus andpri8rifted i" those whom you have chosen, now pour jorlb that power which is from you, of the princely Spirit which you granted through your beloved Son Jesus Christ 10 your holy apostles who established the Church in everyplace as yoursanctuary, 10 the unceasing glory andpraise ofyour
name. You wbo lm<>w the beans of all, be:flow upon Ibis your servanl, whom you have chosen for the episcopal8, 10feed your holy flock and 10 e:xiJrCise the hi(Jb-prl8Sibood before you blamelessly, serving nlgbt and day; IOpropilialeyourcounrmance unceasingly, and tooffertoyou the giftsofyourholyCburr:h; and by the spiritofbigh.pri8stbood to have the power 10 forgive sins according 10 your command, 10 confer orrhM according to your bidding, 10 loose every bond according to the power wblcb you g...., to the apostles, to please you in gentlerJess and a pure bearr, offering 10 you a sweet-smelling .saoour, through your childJesus Christ our l<Jrd, with whom be glory and power and honour to you, with the holy Spirit, both now and ro the ages ofages. Amen. 4. And when he has been made bishop, all shall offer the kiss of peace, greeting him because he has been made wollhy. 1ben the deacons
76
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 76. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=91 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 91 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
shall present the offering to him; and he, laying Ills hands on it with all the presbytery, shall give thank$, saying: The toro be with you;
and all shall say:
And with your spiriL Up with your hearts. We have them with the Lotd. ~~us give thanks to the toro. It is fitting and righL And then he shall continue rhus: We render thanks to you, 0 God, through your beloved child Jesus Christ, whom in the last times you sen1 to us as saviour and redeemer and angel of your will; who is your inseparable Word, through whom you made all things, and in whom you were well pleased. You sent him from heaven into the Virgin's womb; and, conoeived in the womb, he was made flesh and was manifested as your Son, being l:>om of the holy Spirit and the Virgin. Fulfilling your will and gaining for you a holy people, he stretched out Ills hands when he should suffer, that he might release from suffering those who have believed in you. And when he was betrayed to voluntary suffering that he might destroy death, and break the bonds of the devil, and tread down hell, and shine upon the righteous, and fix a tenn, and manifest the resurrection, he rook bread and gave thank$ to you, saying, 'Take, eat; this is my body, which shall be broken for you'. Likewise also the cup, sayin8. 'This is my blood, which is shed for you; when you do this, you make my remembrance'. Remembering therefore Ills death and resuaection, we offer to you the bread and the cup, giving you thanks because you have held us worthy to stand before you and minister to you. And we ask that you would send your holy Spirit upon the offering of your holy Chutch; that, gathering Ot) into one, you would grant to all who partake of the holy things (to partake) for the fullness of the holy Spirit for the strengthening of faith in uuth, that we may praise and glorify you through your child Jesus Christ. through whom be glory and honour to you, with the holy Spirit, in your holy Church, botb now and to the ages of ages. Amen.
77
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 77. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=92 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 92 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Of the Offering ofOU 5. If anyone offers oil, (the bishop) shall render thanks in the same way M for the offering of bre2d and wine, not 5aying it word for word. but to similar effea, saying: 0 God, sanctifier of this oil, M you give health to those who are anointed and receive U.Ot with which you anointed kings, priests, and prophets, so may it give strength to all those who taste it,
and health to all that are anoin ted with it. (Of the Ofl'eriQa of Cheese and Olives)
6. Likewise, if anyone offers cheese and olives, he shall say thus: Sanctify this milk which ha$ been coagulated, coagulating us also to your love. Make this fruit of the olive not to depatt from your 5Weetness, which is an example of your richness which you have poured from the tree for life to those who hope in
you. But in every blessing shall be said:
To you be glory, to the father and !he Son with !he holy Spirit. in the holy Church, both now and always and to all the ages of ages.
Of Presbyters
7. And when a presbyter is ordained, the bishop shall lay his hand on his head, the presbj.1ers aiso touching him; and he sbaU say according to what was said above, as we said before about the bishop, praying and saying: God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, look upon this your servant, and impart the Spirit of grace and counsel of the presbyterate,-that be may help and govern your people with a pure heatt; just as you looked upon your chosen people, and commanded Moses to choose presbyters whom you filled with your Spirit which you granted to your servanL And now, Lord, grant the Spirit o f your grace to be preserved unfailingly in us, and make us wottby to minister to you in faith and in Sill\plicity
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 78. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=93 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 93 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
of heart, praiSing you through your cblld Christ Jesus; through whom be glory and power to you with the boly Spirit, in the holy Churcll, boil\ now and to the ages of ages. Amen. Of Deacons 8. And when a deacon is ordained, let him be chosen •cwrdina to w11at was said above, the bishop alone laying on bands, in the same way as we also directed above. In the ordination of a deacon, the b!sllop alone shall lay on bands, because be is not being ordained to the priesthood, but to the service of the bishop, to do what is ordered by rum. For ne does oot share in tile counsel of tile presbyterate, but a~ and informs the bishop of what is fitting; be does not receive the common spirit of seniority in whicll the presbyters share, but that
whkh is entrusted to him under the bishop's autbodty. For this reason the bishop alone shall ordain a deacon; but on a presbyter the presbyters alone shall lay bands, because of the common and like spirit of their order. For a presbyter has autilority only to =eive; ne has not authority to give. For this reason be does not ordain the clergy, but at the ordination of a presbyter be seals, while tile bisbop ordains. Over a deacon, then, (tile bishop) shall say thus: God, who created all things and ordered them by your Word, Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, whom you sent to serve your will and mal<e known to us your desire, giVe the holy Spirit of grace and caring and diligence to this your servant whom you have chosen to serve your Cllurcll and to present
In )')Ur boly of holies tbat td>icb is off~ «> )')U by )')Ur appointed blgb-prle$1 1<> the glory of>our name; that, :serving blawwkssly and purely, be may atrain the rank of a higber order, and praise andg/.orifyyou through )')Ur Son Jesus Cbrist our ll>rd; through td>om be glory and power and praise 10 you, wUh the boly Spirll, now and always and «> the ages of ages. Amen.
Of Collfesson
9. But a conjeSSQr, ifbe was In chains for the natr!4 oftbe Lord, sba/J not bewe bands laid on him for the diaconate or the presbytemte, for be 79
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 79. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=94 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 94 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
bas t/Hlxmouroflbe~ ~Iris ctmfesskm. BUJ if~M is appointed blsbcp, bands sbaJJ be laid on blm. BUJ iftbtml is a conftJSSOrumo uw not brougbt beforet!H aUJborilies, norpunisbed wilb chains, rwr sbUJ up in prison, rwr condemned 1<> any
otber penally, but bas only b«n derided on occasion for tbe na""' of our L<mJ, andpunisbed wilb a domesticpunisb~~ ifhe am[essed, let hands be laid on him for "'VV order of which " is worthy. And tbe /nshopshaUgive thanks according I<> wbas we said above. It is net at all necessaryfor bim I<> utter tbe same uords as we said above, as though reciting them from memory, when giving thanks to God; hut let each pray according to bis abilgy.lfindeed anyone has lbe ability 1<> pray Ill length and wilb a solemn prayer, it is good. But ifanyone, wben IM prays, uners a br/8fprayer, t:W notprevent bim. On!y, " mustpray what is sound and orthodox. Of Widows
10. WlHm a widow is appointed, ~ is not ordairuld, but is chosen by natM. Ifher husband has t-n dead a long litM, let her not be taken on tntn; 1ll.lfH if~ is iJ/d, let ber be umd for a tii'M, for ofttm the passi<ms grow old with bim !dJo mallss a place for tbem in himself. A widow sbaJJ be appointed /:>y word only, and shall join lbe rest. But bands sbaJJ not be laid on her, because ~ does nol offer the offering, nor has siM a IUUf8kal duty. Ordination isfor the clmgy, on aCC<Junt of their liluJ1iical durws; but a widow is appointed for praJ'"' which beJcngs «>all.
Of a Reader 11. A reader is appointed /:>y tbelnshop giving him the book, for he does not have hands laid on blm.
OfaV!raiA 12. Hands shall not be laid on a virgin: her choice alane mallss IMr a virgin,
80
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 80. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=95 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 95 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Of a SUIM'eaC01l
13. Hands sbaJI not be laid on a subdeacon, but be sbaJJ be named In order that be may fo/Jow the deacons. Of Gifts of lfMiiOS 14. lfanyone says, 'I have received a gift ofbea/ing l>y a revelation', bands sball not be laid on bim, /&r the facts lbemse/ve$ will sbow ~er be bas spoken the tn4lb.
Of Newcomus to tbe Fall:h
15. 7bose who comeforwardf&r the first time to bear the word sbaJI first be lm>ugbtto the teachers bofore aJI the people arrive, and shall be questtoned about their reason for coming 1<> the faith . And those who haw /m>ugbt them sball boar witness about them, whether they are capable ofbearing the word. They sbaJI be questioned about tbelr slate of life: has be a wife? Is be the siaVB ofa believer? Does his mastm' a/Jow bim? Let him bear the word. lf bis master tkJes not boar witness about bim that be iS a good !'JD'I, be sbaJI be rejected. If bis master iS a bealhen, teach bim to please bis master, that them bo no scandal. ifany man bas a wife, or a woman a husband, they shaJI be taught to be contented, the man with his wife and the woman with her husband. But if any man is not living with a wife, be sball be Instructed not to /omicale, but to take a wife lawfully or .r emain as be is. lf an_,.,ne is possessed l>ya demon, be shall not bear the word of teaching until he Is
pure. OfCnlfts and Profc8slons 16, Inquiry sbaJI be matk about the crafts and professions of those who are lm>ught/&r lnslTuaton. lf a man is a lm>tbei-RHper, kt blm cease or be rejected. lf ""-"'"" is a sculptor &r a painter, let them be instructed not to maloe Idols; let them cease &r be rejected. lfan-""'" Is an actor or gives theatrical petformances, kt bim cease &r be rejected. He who teaches cbildren bad best cease; but if be bas no craft, kt him
baVBpermts.ston.
81
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 81. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=96 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 96 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Similarly, a charioteer who compel~!$ in tbe games, or goes to tbem, let him cease or be rejected. One who Is a g/adla!qr or ll!aehes g/adiat<>rs tofigh~ or one who fights with beasts in tbe games,_or a public ojJicial empl
ifanyone is a priest, or keeper of Idols, let blm cease or be rejected. A soldier under authority shall not kill a man. ifbets ordered to, be shall not carry out the order; nor shall he take tbe oath. if be is unwilling, let him be rejected. Hewhobas tbepoweroftbe sword, oris a magislrate ofa clly who~ thepurple, let him coase or be rejected. A cmecbumen or believer who want to become scldlers should be rejected, because they have despised God. A prostitute, a profligate, a eunuch, or anyone else who dces things ofwhich Uis a shame to speak, let them be rejected, for they are impure. Neither shall a 77Ul8ician be brought for examination. A charmer, an astrologer, a diviner, an interpreter ofdreams, a moumebanlt, a CUIIJ!r offringes ofclothes, or a maker ofphylacteries, let them be rejected. A man~ concubine, ifshe is his slave and has reared her children and remainedfaltbfu/ to him alone, may be a bearer; otherwise, let her be rejected. Ut any man wbo has a concubi11e cease, atld take a wife lawfully; but ifbe is unwilling, let him be rejecJed.
ifwe have left anything out, tbe facts themselves will teach you; for we an have the Spirit ofGod. Ot the Time of Rearing the Word after (b:aminatlon of) Crafts and Professions 17. Cotecbumens shall continue to bear the word for three years. Bus ifa man Is keen, a1ldperseveres well in tbe matter, tbe time shall not be judged, but only his conduct.
Of the Prayer of Those Who Hear the Word
18. When the teacher has finished giving instructlcn, let the cat«humens pray by themselves, separatedfrom tbefattbfu/; atld let the women, wbetber faltbful or cat«humens, stand by themselves in some place In the church when they pray. And when they have finished
82
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 82. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=97 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 97 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
AI'Om)UC TR.A.Df7J()N
praying, they shall not gwe lbe Peace.jor their ltlss Is notyet holy. But 18t only the faithful greet one another, mqn with men and womqn witb WOm8n; but the men shall not greet the women. And kt aJI the women cover their beads with a hood, but (no/) jusl with a pkce of linen, for that Is no veil.
Of Laying Haruls OD the Catechumens
19. After their prayer, u:ben the teacher has laid bands on the catecbumens, be sbaJJ pray and dismiss them. Wbether lbe teacher is a cleric or a layman, kt him acttbus.
Ifa cazecbumen Is arrested for the name of the Lord, kt him not be In two minds about his wiln<>ss. For if be suffers vi<Jience and is killed (before be has JYCewed baptism)for lbe fOTTJitieness ofbls sins, be will be jUSlijiBd, for be has received baptism in his blcod. Of Those Who Wlll Itecdve Baptism 20. And when those who are 1<> receive baptism are chosen, kt lbeir life be examined: have they livedgood live$ wben they were wecbumens? Have they honoured lbe widows? Have they visi/Bd the sick? Have they done every ldnd ofgood work? And when those who brought them bear witness to eacb, 'He has', kt them bear tbe gospel. From the time that they were set apart, let bands be laid on them daily wbile they aro exorcized. And when the day of their baptism approaches, lbe bishop shall exorcize each one ofthem, In order that be may Jmow whether be ispure. And if anyone Is not good or notpure, kt blm be put aside, because be has not beard lbe word with faub,for it is itnpOSSibk that tbe Alkn should bide himselffor ever. Those u,1>o are 1<> be baptized should be instnlCted 1<> balbe and
wash themselves on the Thursday. And if a zroman is in her period, let her be put aside, and receive baptism another day. Those who are 1<> receive baptism shallfast on the Friday. On the Saturday those who are
to receive baptism shall be galbered in one placeaJ tbe bishop~ decision. They shall aU be told to pray and kneel. And be shall lay bis band on them and exorcize aU alien spirits, that they may flee out of them and rwuer return into lbem. And when be has finished exorcizing them, be
83
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 83. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=98 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 98 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 10:58
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
shall brealbe on their faces; and wben be bas signed their foreheads, ears, and noses, be shall raise them up. And they shall spend the wb
Of the Conferring of Holy Baptism
21. Attbe ff>M when the coclt crows, first let prtzyer be made
o....,. the
water. I.etlhewaterbejlowing in tbefontorpoured otJeriJ. Let it be thus unless there is SOPM necessity; if tbe neceSSity is permanent and U'1Jent, use what water you can find. They sbaU take off their c/olbes. Baptize lhe littJeonBSfirst.A/1 those who canspealtfortbemselves shall do so. As for those who cannot spealt for themselves, their parents or someo•~e from theirfamily shaU speak for them. Then baptize the men, and lastly the women, who shall have loosened all tbelr hair, and laid down the gold and silver ornaments wblcb they have cm them. Let no-one take any alien obje<:t d<1wn inlo toe wawr, And at the timefixedfor baptizing, tbe bishop shallgive thanlts OtJer the oil, wbicb beputs in a vessel, one calls it 'oil ofthanltsgiuing '. And be shall also takeotheroiland exorcize it: one calls it 'oil ojexorclsm'.And a deacon takes tbe oil of exorcism and stands on tbe priest~ left; and another deacon takes the oil of thanltsgiuing and stands on tbe priest~ right. And when the priest taltes each one of those who are to recelw baptism, be shall bid bim renounce, saying, I nmounceyou, Satan, and allyour service and all .)'?UT works. And when each one has renounced all this, he shall anoint bim wilh lhe oil ofexorcism, saying to him:
Let every spiril depart jarfrom-"'"· And in this way be shall band him o..., naked to the bishop or the priest who stands by the water to baplize. In lhe same U
84
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 84. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=99 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 99 of 99
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
And be wbo receives shall say according to aJJ thiS: I believe In tbiS way.
And the giver,
having his hand placed on his bead, shall baptize him once. And !hen be shall say: Do you believe in Christ Jesus, tbe Son of God, who was born from !he holy Spirit from the Virgin Maty, and was crucified under Ponlius Pilate, and died, and rose again on !he third day alive from !he dc!ad, and ascended into bea~ and sits at !he right band of !he Father, and will come to judge !he living and the dead? And when he has said, 'I believe', he shall be baptized again.
And he shall say again: Do you believe in the holy Spirit and the holy Church and the resurre<:tion of tbe Hesh? Then he who is being baptized shall say, 1 beHeve', and thus he shall be baptized a third lime. And then, when he has come up, he shall be anointed £rom the oil of thanksgiving by the presbyter, wbo says: I anoint you with boly oil in the name of Jesus Christ.
And so each of them shall wipe themselves and put on their clolhes, and !hen they sbaU enter into !he church. And the bishop shall lay his hand on !hem and invoke, saying: Lord God, you bave made them worthy to receive remission of sins lhrough the !aver of regeneration of !he holy Spirit: send upon them your grace, !hat they may serve you according to your will; for to you is glory, to Father and Son with the holy Spirit in !he holy Church, both now and to !he ages of ages. Amen. Then, pouring !he oil of thanksgiving from his band and placing it on his head, he shall say: 1 anoint you wilh holy oil in God the Father almighty and Christ Jesus and !he holy Spirit.
ss Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 85. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=100 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 1 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
ADd haVing signed
rum on the forehead, he shall give rum a kiss and say:
The Lord be with you.
And the one who has been signed shall say: And wllh your spirit. So let him do with each one. N>d then they shall pray together With all the people: they do not pray With the faithful until they have carried out all these things. N>d w~n they have prayed, they shall give the kiss of peace. N>d then the offering shall be presented by the deacons to the bishop; and he shall give thanks over the bread for the representation, which the Greeks call 'antitype', of the body of Chris~ and over the cup mixed with wine for the antitype. which the Greeks call 'likeness', of the biOQd which was shed for all who have believed in him; and over milk and honey mixed together in fulfillment of the promise which was made to the fathers, in which ~ said, 'a land flowing With milk and honey', in which also Christ gave his flesh, through which those who believe are nourished like Uale children, making the binemess of the bean sweet by the gentleness of his word; and over water, as an offering to signify the washing, that the inner person also, which is the soul, may receive the same things as the body. ADd the bishop shall give a reason for all these things to those v.ilo receive. N>d when he breaks the bread, in disaibuting fragmentS to each, he shall say: The bread of heaven in Christ Jesus. hnd he who receives shall answer:
Amen. N>d if there are not enough presbyterS, the deacons also shaD hold the cups, and srand by in gOQd order and =ence: fiM, he who holds the water; second, the milk; !bird, the wine. hnd they who receive shall taste of each thrice, he who gives it saying: In God the Father almighty.
And he who receives shall say: Amen.
N>d in the Lord Jesus ChrisL (Amen).
86
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 86. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=101 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 2 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
And in ~ holy Spirit and the holy Chutch.
And he shall say: Amen: So shall it be done with each one. When these things have been done, each one shall hascen to do good works and to please Gcd and to conduet blms4/f rightly, being :walous for the Church, doing what be bas kamt and advancing in piety.
We have bantkd over to .)011 in brief these things about holy baptism and t1H holy offering, for .)011 bave ahwldy been inslnlcted about tbe resurr«tion of the fiesb and tbe olber tbings as ills wriJ1en. But if there Is anything else wbicb ought to be said, lbe bishop shall say itprif)tttely to those wbo btwe recsived baptism. Unbelievm must not get to know it, unless they first n!Uive baptism. Tbis is lbe wbit4 stone of wbil;b John said, \4 new name is written on it, wbil;b no-one lmcW5 except bim wbo receives tbe stone'.
(Of AdminlsterlnS the Communion) 22. On Saturday and Sunday tbe bishop himself, ifpossible. shall dlstribuJe to all tiH people with bls own band; tiH deacons break, and tbe presbyters shall break tbe bread. When a deacon taJtes it to a pm/Jyler, be shall bold out tbe palen, and tiH presbyter himself shall taJt,g 1t and dlstribuJe it to the people wltb bls own band. On other days they shall n!Uive as lbe bishop directs.
Of Pasting 23. Wld<>WS and vi78ins sballfast ojtnl and pray for tbe Cburcb. Pmbyters shall fast if they wish, and laypeople li/bewi$e. A bishop cannot fast except when aJ1 tbe people do so. It happens tbat someone wishes to malts an offering, and be cannot mfuse bim; but in aJ1 cases be brea.l<s and tastes.
Of Gifts to the Sick
24. In an emef1letlo/ a deacon sbaJJ givt tiH sign to tbe sick with dtltgeme, If no presbyter Is present. And when be has gtven all tbat is 87
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 87. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=102 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 3 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
neetkd for bim 10 receive what is distributed, be sballgive tbanlts, and
they sball consume it there.
That Those Who Have Recehed Should M.lnister Diligendy
Ifanyone bas received anything tx> taltJe 10 a widow, a sick person, or a church worittJr, he sball taltJe it that day; and Ifhe bas not taloen it, he sball taltJe lithe next day, adding to what there was from his own; because the~ ofthe poor remained with him. Of the Bringing-In of Lambs at the Communal Supper 25. Wben the blsb<Jp Is present, and evening has come, a deacon brings in a lamp; and standing in the midst of all the faithful wbo are fJ'f'6SB1Il, (the blsbop) sba/1 give thanks. FITSl he shall say this greeting:
The Lord he with you. And the people sball say: Wlth your spirit. let us give thanlrs 10 the Lord. And they sba/1 say. It is ftlli"8 and right: greatness and e:xaltatio11 with glory arebisdue. And be does not say, 'Up with your beans: because that is said (only) at the offering. And he sbal/ pray thus, saying: We give you thanks, Lord, through your Son Jesus Christ our Lord, through wbom you have shone upon us and revealed to us tbe Inextinguishable ltgbt. So when we have completed the length oftbe day and have come to the beginni ng of the n ight, and have satisfied ouneiiJIIS with the light of day which you created for our satisfying; and since now through your grace we do nollack the light of evening, we praise and glorify you through you Son Jesus Christ our Lord, through whom he g/ary and power and honour 10 you witb the holy Spirit, both now and always and 10 the ages ofages. Amen. And all shall say:
Amen.
88
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 88. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=103 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 4 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
71>ey sbaJI rise, then, vltglns sbaJI saypsalms.
aft8r supper and prr1y; and tbe bo,)<s and tbe
And then tbe de«on, when be r«efves tbe ml:c«i cup of tbe offerin& sbaJI say a psalm from those in wbicb 'AlJsluU.' is wriltsn, and then, if tbe prl&1 so diroas, again from tbe sams psalms. A.nd ajl8r tbe bishop bas offered tbe cup, be sbaJJ say tbe whok of a psalm wblcb appiW. ro lbe cup, wilb 'Alle{u;a; aJJ jOining In. Wben tbey recite psalms, aJJ sbaJJ say, 'Alle{ula; wbicb msans, 'We praise bim wbo is God; glory and praise to bim wbo creatld ....., ase tbroUBb bis word alone'. And when tbe psalm isfinished, be sbaJJ give than/:$ ooer the cup and distribute tbeft"8ments ro aD lbe faitb.fu/. Of the Common Meal
26. A.n d wben tbey have sup.(J
01 the Time ot the Meal It is jilting tbat aJJ, bejOT'll tbey drinlz, sbould ta1o11 a cup and gt.e tbanl:s ooer it, and so eat and drlnll In purity. . . . you who ate p~t, and so feast. But to the catechumens shall be givetl exorcized bread, and e:tcb shall offer a cup. Tbat Qdec:humeas Ou@tlt Not u. Eat with* Faithful
27. A carechumetl shall nor sit at tbe Lord's Supper. But through the whole meal be who eatrsbould remember him who invited him; because that is why he besought him to enter under his roof. Tbat One Should Eat with Temperu.ce aod Mocleration
28. Wbetl you e:tt and drink, do it discteetly and nor to tbe point of drunkenness, and not so that anyone may laugh at you, or that he who invited you may be grieved by your disorderly behaviour, but so that he
89
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 89. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=104 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 5 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
may pray to be made worthy !hat the saints may come in to him; for he said, 'You are the salt of the eanh'. If an offering, which is called in Greek 'apophoreton·, Is made to all in common, accept some. If it is for all to eat, eat enough for there to be some crver, which be who invited you may send to whom he wishes, as it were from the left-overs of the saints, and rejoice in confidence. And let the guests, when they eat, receive in silence, not contending with words, but as the bishop allows; and if he has asked anything, an answer shall be given him. And when the bishop says a word, let all be modestly silent, until be asks another quesllon.
If the bishop is absent, but the faithful are at the supper in the presence of a priest or a deacoo, let !hem eat in the same orderly way. And all shall hasten to recelve the blessed bread from the hand of the priest or the deacon. Ukewise a c:uechumen shall receive the same, exorciZed. If the laity are together, they must behave in an orderly way, for a laypefflon cannot make the blessed bread.
That One Should Eat with Tbanl<sgiving
29. Let everyone eat in the name of the Lord. For this is pleasing to God, !hat we should compete among the heathen in being like-minded and sober. Of Sup per for Widows
30. If anyone wants widows to have a meal, let !hem be ripe in yeaffl, and let him send them away before the evening. And if he cannoi (recelve them) because of the charge which be has been allo«ed, let him give them food and wine, and send them away, and let them partake as they like at home.
Of the Frulrs One Should Olfer t o the Bishop 31. Let all hasten to offer the new fruits to the bishop as firstfruits. And as be offers them, he sball bless them and name him who offered, saying:
90
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 90. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=105 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 6 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
We give you thanks, 0 God, and offer to you the fi!Stfruits which you have granted us to receive; you nourished them by your word, and ordered the earth to bear all fruits for the joy and nourishment of people and for all animals. In aU these things we praise you, 0 God, and in aU the things with which you have helped us, adorning for us the whole creation with various fruits; through your child Jesus Christ our Lord, through whom be glory to you for the ages of ages. Aroen. Of the BlessJoa of fruits
32.. Fruits indeed are blessed. that is, grapes, figs, pomegranate$, olives, pears, apples, mulberries, peaches, cherries, almonds, plums; but not pumpkins, melons, cucumbers, onions, garlic, or any other vegetable. But sometimes Bowers also are offered.
So let roses and lilies be offered, but not others. And in all things which are eaten, they sbaU give thanks to. the holy God, eating to his glory. Tban No-one Should Touch auy Food at the Pascba before the Proper Time for Eating 33. At the Pascha nne may eat before the offering is made. If anyone does so, it does not count for him as fasting. Anyone who is pregnant or ill, and cannot fast for t:wo days, should fast (only) on the Saturday on account of their necessity, confiDing themselves to bread and water. Anyone who was at sea or found himself in some necessity, and did not know the day, when be has learned of it, shall observe the fast after Pentecost. For the type has passed away; that is why it ended in the second month; and when he has learned the truth, he should observe the fast. 1bat Deacons Should Attend on the Bishop
34. Each deacon, with the subdeacons, shall anend on the bishop. They shall infonn him of lhose who are ill, so that, if be pleases, he may visit them. For sick people are greatly comforted when the high-priest remembers them.
91
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 91. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=106 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 7 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Oftbe Time When One OusJn to Pray ~S. The faithful, as soon as they have woken and got up, before they
rum to their wod<, shall pray to God, and so hasten ro their wod<. If there iS any verbal instruction, one should give preference ro this, and go and
hear the word of God, to the comfon of one's soul. Let o ne hasten to the chtuch, where the Spirit flourishes.
That tbe Eucharist Should Be Received First, 'lll'beneYer lt Is Offered, before any Food Is Taken 36. Let all the t'aithful take steps to receive the eucharist before they eat anything else. For if they receive in faith, even if some deadly thing ls given them, after that it shall not overpower them. 1bat the EUc:barist Must Be Carefully Guarded ~7.
Let everyone take care that no unbeliever ears of the eucharist,
nor any mouse or other animal, and dlllt none of it falls and is k>st. For it is the body of Christ, to ~ eaten by believers, and not to ~ despised. NothlJig Must FaD from the CUp 38. For having blessed (the cup) in the name of God, you received
as it were the antitype of the blood of Christ. Therefore do oot pour any out, as though you despised it, lest an alien spirit lick it up. You will~ guilty of the blood, as one who despises the price with which one has been bought. Of the Sign of tbe Cros$ 42A. If you are tempt«J. sign your forehead. For this sign of the passion is displayed against the Devil, if it is made in faith, 110( to please people, but through knowledge, presenting it like a breastplate. For when the Adversary sees the power of the Spirit (which comes) from the bean, outw2tdly displayed in the likeness of baptiSm, h e will tremble and flee, wben you do not strike him but breathe on him. Moses dld this symbolically with the sheep wbich was sacrificed at the Passover. By sprinkling the blood on the threshold and by anoinllng the two doorposts,
92
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 92. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=107 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 8 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:00
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
he signified that faith which is now in us, in the ped'ect sheep. Let us sign forehead and eyes with the hand, and escape from him who is trying to destroy us.
43A. And so, when these thit\gs are heard with thankfulness and true orthodox faith, they provide edification for the Churcll and eternal
life for believers. I oounsel those who •re sensible to gua.td them. For to all who hear the apos(toUc tradition).. .
39. 1be Mt:cons and priests shall assemble daily at tbe place wblcb tbe bishop appoints for them. I.st tbedeacom nolfai/10 asumble at ail limes, unless il1nns binders tbtlm. Wben ail bave assembled, let them teach those wbo are In tbe cburcb, and in this way, wben they bewe prayed, let them go to tbe worlr whicb falls to each one of them. Of Cemeteries
40. No
one may be betwJly charged for burying a
perron in tbe
·c111118teries; it is tbe property ofail tbe poor. But tbe fee of the workman and the price of the tUes shail be pafd to btm wbo digs. 7be bisbop sban provide for those wbo
are in that place and look after it, so that there
may be no beavy cbargefor rbose wbo come to rbose p/llces. Of tbe Time When One Oup! IO Pray
41. 1£1 every faithful man and woman, when they have risen.from sleep in the momJng, before they tx>uch any worlt at ail, wasb their bands and pray to God, and so go to their worlt. But if instruction in the word of God is given, each one sboufd choose to go to that plac4, reckoning In tbe heart that it is God who is beard In the i>Utructor. For the one who pmys In the cburcb wiO be able to pas$ by the wickedness oftbe day. 7bose wbo are pious sbould tbinlt it a groat evil I/ they do not go to tbe place where instruction is given, and especiaJiy if they can road, or if a teacher comes. l£t none of you be /ale in the cburcb, tbe place where teacbing is glrJen. 7ben il sbail be girJen to the speaker to .say that is useful to eacb one; you will bear thingS which you do not thinlt of, and profit.from things wbi<;b tbe holy Spirit will give you tbrougb the instructor. Jn this way your faitb wiJl be strengthened about tbe things you will have beard. You will also be told in that place what
93
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 93. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=108 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto/…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 9 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
you ougbt to do t1t bome. 'lberifors kt each one be diligent in coming to the cburr;h, the place where the holy Splril flourishes. If there is a day wben there Is no ir!Struclion, let each one, wben at bome, take up a holy book and read in it sufficiently what seems to briug profit. And Ifyou are at bome, pray at the /bird hour and bkss God. But If you are somewhere else at tbtlt moment, pray to God In your heart. FOr at that bour Christ was nailed to tbe tree. For Ibis reason also In the Old tTBStam8nV the Law prescribed that the sheu'bread should be offered continually as a type ofthe body and /Jiood ofCbris~ and the slal4gbter of the Iamb without reason is this type of tbe perfect lamb. For Christ Is the shepherd, and also the IJread which came down from heatJen. Pray likewise at the time of the sixth bour. For wben Christ was nailed to the wood oflbe cross, tbe day was divided, and darlmessfell. And so at lbat bour kt them pray a fJOIJNiful prayer, imitating the voice ofbim wbo prayed and made all creation darl
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 94. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=109 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 10 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
AI'OSI'OUc TMDflfON
God with the souls of the righ.~eous in this hour. That is why bellevers should take good care to pray at this hour. Bearing witneSs to this, the Lord says thus, 'Lo, about midnight a shout was made of people saying, Lo, the bfidegroom comes; rise to meet him'. And he goes on, saying, 'Watch therefore, for you know no« at what hour he comes.'
And likewise rise about cockcrow, and pray. For at that hour, as the cock crew, the children ol' Israel denied Christ, whom we know by faith, our eyes looking toW3rds that day in the hope of eternal lighl at the resurrection of the dead. And if you act so, all you faithful, and remember these things, and reach them in your rum, and encourage che catechumens, you will not be able to be tempted or to perish, since you have Christ always in memory.
428. Always reverently observe to sign your forehead. For this sign of the passion iS known and approved against the devil, if you make it in faith, and not so that you may be seen by people, but through knowledge presenting it like a shield For when the Advetsary sees the power which comes from ch.e heart, R!ld wben !le sees 111, inrwr rllliQTHll {)m(m, signed wllbln and wilbout wllh the stgn of the word of God, be jlees at once, expe/Jed by the holy Spiri~ wbo is m (m;ery) person who makes a place for him inside. Moses dld this symboUcally with the sheep which was sacrificed at the Passover; b y sprinkling the blood on the threshold and anointing the doorpoSIS, he signified that faith which is now in us, in the perfect sheep. So let us sign forehead and eyes with the hand. and escape from him who is trying to destroy us.
43B. And so if these things are received with thankfulness and true faith, they provide edif.cation in the Cburcb and eternal life for believers. I counsel that these things should be· guarded by all those who are sensible. For if all of you hear the apostolic tra(dition), andfollow 11 and keep il, no heretic or an~Je at all can lead ~u into error. For in this way many heresies bave grown, because the leaders were not willing IC kam lbe pu7pOS8 of the apostles, but did what they wanted, accordin8 to their own pleasure, and not what was fitting.
Ifwe bave ~d over anytbin8, bel<Jved, God wiU Tf!VI!al it le those wbo are worrby, slnc<1 be s16et'Sibe Cbun;b le tbe ha...,. of quietness.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 95. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=110 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 11 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
This page intentionally left blank
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 96. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=111 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 12 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Orisen, "First Homily on the SOng of So1J85" (:UO?, c.coarea)
Q rigen (Origents Adamantius) was born in or about 185 in Egypt, probably in Alex:ondria. Alex:ondria was the main pon in Egyp~ loc:ued on the west side of the delta where the Nile flowed into the Med!tetranean, and i1 was one of the great cultural cenaes of !he Roman Empire. It boasted !he most important Jewish community ouiSide Palestine, and it. was the home of a brilliant uacli!ion of Jewish BibUcal, !heological, and his!orical scholarship. Philo, a first-centuryJewish scholar who influenced Christian !bought in many ways, had been an Alenndrian; and it was in AleJW>dria that Jewish scholars had tranSlated their Bible intO the very influen!ial Greek version known as the Septuag!nt. The philosophy called neoplaroniSm was born !here, and neopythagoreanism may have been as weU. Other philosophical traditions had academies in !he dry. The Mouseion (Musewn) of Alexandria was one of tbe finest research institutes in the andent world, with a "mother" hbrary that housed half a million scrolls, and a "daughter" Ubrary which w as even larger. Panly because Alexandrian Christianity had to answer !he criticisms of the local non-Chrislian inte!UgeniSia, and partly because it wanted to evangelite people whose way of thinking had been formed by other philo$ophical uaclicions, it grew accustomed to thinking and speaking in the categories of philosophy, especially the philosophy of Pla!o. And because it wanted to unlod< the hidden meanings of Scripture, it borrowed academic tools of literary analysis from i1s cultured milieu.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 97. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=112 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 13 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
According to Odgen's best biographer, the very competent historian Eusebius of Caesarea, writing about ~25. Origen was taised in a Christian home. In about 202, during the persecutlons ~the Emperor Septimius Severus, his father was mattyrecl. About the same time the head of the diocesan school for catechumens fled the per.;ecutions, and Orlgen in effect took his place, although be was still only a teenager. Later, the bishop appointed him to do what he was already doing. Origen proved a btilliant scholar and an inspiring and demanding teacher. He developed a curriculum for carechumetlS which began with philosophy, logic, and science, and then proceeded to ethics and theology. Meanwhile, be eoolinued his own education, studying Hebrew with local Jewish scholrus, attending lectureS by the founder of neoplaionism, and reading Scripture very carefully. HiS lifestyle was highly ascetiC, almost pathologically so. It was said that, inspired by Matthew 19:12, he castrated himself. In 230, on a trip to Palestine, he allowed himself to be ordained Without the permission of the bishop of Alexandria. His biShop was
furious, and in 231 Origen found himself exconununicated. He then moved to Caesarea, the Roman capital of the province of Syria Palaestioa, aboutl05 kilometers nonhwest of}e~em. caes;uca was ~n impoiWlt sea-port and commercial cenue, and it could boas! an apostoUc tradition datitlg back to Peter and Paul. Origen felt as if, Ul<e Israel, be had been released from the bondage of Pharaoh and had found freedom in the laod of canaan. He directed the school for catechumens there, and, being now a priest, began preaching homilies, or explanations of passages of Saiprure. In a lime when different churches and different synagogues weno using diffetertt versions of Saiptute, he used scientific means for establishing the true text. He wrote hundreds, possibly thousands of works. Because doubts later arose about his orthodoxy, and because many of his works were soaked in the philosophy of Plato, only a few of them have survived in their original Greek, and a few more in Latin tranSlation. He is generally considered the most outSWlding Christian scholar and rhlnl<er of the second and third centuries. In 250 he was arrested dutitlg the persecutlons under the Emperor Dedu.s, and suffered long periods of t0f1ure. He died rwo or three years
afterwards.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 98. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=113 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 14 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Most of Orlgen's works were on Biblical subjects, and his preferred method of interpretation w:os allegorical. ibis approach W2S a stand2t
Origen WIQI~ on ~u lh~ boo~ of lh~ Oil! aoo New Teswn~lll. Some of his works were scholia or critical notes, some were homilies, and some were very de
99
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 99. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=114 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 15 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
tbeme and purpose of the book? What dot3 he reg;ud as the significance of the Song of Songs, compared to the other songs recorded in the Bible? What in Origen's view is represented by the Bridegroom; the Bride; ' kisses of his moutb"; "tbe odour of thy pe!fumes"; "embrace"; "little breast'"; "bosom"; ' breasts"; "perfume poured forth"; 'black"; •queen of the south"; •fought against me"; •norse·lider'"? What is the system of Origen's exegesis? What, from this document, appears to be his understanding of the Church (the Bride)? Wbat might be the role of ordained ministry in the Church be envisions? Why might Oligen's bisbop have been glad to be rid of him>
Jert>me'$ Prologue jerome to the Most Blessed Pope Damasus:
While Oligen MJ)a$$ed l!ll Wilier$ in h!:; olher booM, in his Song of Songs he surpassed hlmself. In ten fuD volumes, containing nearly twenty thousand lines, be expounded first the version of the Seventy, then those of Aquila, Symmachus, and Theodotion, and finally a fifth, which be teUs us that he found on the coast near Actium. And this exposition of his is so splendid and so clear, that it seems to me that the words, 1be King brought me into His cbmnber, have found their fuliilmeru in him. I have passed over that work, for it would require far too much time and labour and expense worthily to render into Latin such a mighty theme. It is not strong meat that! olfer here; instead of that, with greater faithfulness than elegance I have ttanslated these two treatises which he composed for babes and sucklings into the speech of every day, to give you just a sample of his thinking, so that you may reflect how highly his great thoughts should be esteemed, when even his little ones can so oomrnend themselves.
Sourw. Origen, 'rii'S< Homily on the Song of Songs; in R.P. I.awson, trans., Origen (Ancielll Chlistian Wrkers, vol. 26), Westminster, MD: Newman
Press, 1957, 265·283.
100
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 100. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=115 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 16 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
fiJST HCMLY OM TKE SoNo Of SoMas
Tbe First Homily On dle beginning of dle Song of So118$ to the place where dle writer sa}'1< Until the Klng rccline at his 01ble.
1. As we have learned from Moses that some places are not merely holy, bUI boly of bofi4s, and that cenain days are not sabbaths simply, but are sabbaths of sabbaths: so now we are taught funbet by the pen of Solomon that ihete are songs which are not merely songs, but songs of songs. Blessed too is the one who enters holy places, but far more blest the one who enters the holy of holies! Blessed is the one who obsetves the sabbaths, but more blest the one who keeps sabbaths of sabbaths! Blessed likewise is the one who understands songs and sings them - of course nobody sings exoept on festal days -but much more ble& is the one who sings the Songs of Songs! And as the one who enters holy places still needs much to be able to enter the holy of holies, and as the one who keeps the sabbath whlch was ordained by God for the peeple still requites many things before being able to keep the sabbaih of sabbaths: so also is it hard to find one competent to scale the heights of the Songs of Songs, even one who has traversed aU the songs in Scriprore.
You must come out of Egypt and, when the land of Egypt lies behind you, you must cross the Red Sea if you are to sing the first song, saying: Let us stng to /be Lord, for He Is gloriously magnified. But though you have unered this fll'St song, you are still a long way from the Song of Songs. Pursue your splrirual tourney through the wilderness, ·until you come to the well which /be kings dug, so that there you may sing tbe second song. After that, come to the threshold of the holy land, that Standing on the bank ofJordan you may sing the song of Moses, saying: Hear, 0 heaven, and 1 will speak, and let the etutb give ear to the words of my mout#. Again. you must fight under Joshua and possess the holy land as your inheritance; and a bee must prophesy for you and judge you- Deborab, you understand, means 'bee' - in order that you may take that song also on your lips, which is found In the Book of judges. Moum up
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 101. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=116 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 17 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
course for greater heights, so that as a fair soul With her Spouse you may sing rhis Song of Songs too. I am not sure bow many persons are concerned in it; but, as far as God has shown me in answer to your prayers, I seem to find four characters - the Husband and the Bride; along with the Bride, her maidens; and With the Bridegroom, a band of itUimate companions. Some things are spoken by the Bride, others by the Bridegroom; sometimes too the maidens speak; so also do the Bridegroom's friends. lt is fitting iodeed that at a wedding the bride should be accompanied by a bevy of maidens and the bridegroom by a company of y<>uths. You must not look without for the meaning of these; you must look no further than those who are saved by the preaching of the Gospel. By the Bridegroom understlnd Christ, and by the Bride the Church wttbout spot orwrink/4, of whom it is written: that He might pment ber ll> Himself a glorious Church, not having spot or wriTJkle or any such thing, hut that she might be holy and without blemish. In the maidens who are with the Bride you must recognize those who, although they are faithful, d o not come under the foregoing description, yec are regarded none the less as having in some sense obuined salvation- in shon, they are the souls of believers. And in the men with the Bric!cgroom you must sec lhc angels anc! those who have come unro tbe perfea man. We have thus four groups: the two individuals, the Bridegroom aod the Bride; two choirs answering each other - the Bride singing with her maidens, and the Bridegroom with His companions. When you have grasped rhis, listen to the Song of Songs and make haste to understand it and to join With the Bride in saying what she says, so that you may hear also what she heard. And, if you are unable to join the Bride in her words, then, so that you may hear the things that are said to her, make haste at least to join the Bridegroom's companions. AJ1d If they also are beyond you, then be with the maidens who stay in the Bride's retinue and share her pleasures. These are the charaCters in this book, which is at once a drama and a marriage-song. And it is from rhis book that the heathen appropriated the ep!thalamium, and bere is the source of rhis
101
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 102. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=117 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 18 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
suffering for her salvation, the compartions reply that 'until the Bridegroom recline at bJs table' and rise from His Passion, they are going to make the Bride some ornaments. 2. We must consider now the actual words with which the Bride first voices her pr.ayer: LtT """ KISS " ' """' tm KlSS!S OP ms Mount. Their meaning is: 'How long is my Bridegroom going to send me kisses by Moses and kisses by the prophets? It is His own mouth that I desire now to touch; let Him come, let Him come down Himself!' So she beseeches the Bridegroom's Father saying: 'Let Him kiss me with the kisses of His mouth.' And because she is such that the prophetic word, Wbile tbou areyer speaking. I will say, 'Lo, here am !!'can be fulfiJied upon her, the Bridegroom's Father listens to the Bride and sends His Son. She, seeing Him for whooe coming she prayed, leaves off her prayer and says to Him directly; TKY 11RE1oSr.i All Bnmt 1lW< WINE, AND TH< OOOUR or n
among them nard and stacte, are taken for the work of the perfumer. And God who made heaven and earth speaks to Moses, saying: I have filled them with the spirit of wisdom and undel'$/andlng, that they may
make the things that belong to the perfumer's art; and God teaches the
perfumers. If these words are not to be spiritually understood, are they oot mere tales? If they coooeal no bidden mystery, are they not unworthy of God? He, therefore, who can discern the splrirual sense of Scriprure or, if he cannot, yet desires so to do, must strive his utmost to live not after flesh and blood, so that he may become worthy ofspiritual mysteries and - if I may speak more boldly - of spiritual desire and love, if such
103
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 103. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=118 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 19 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Indeed there be. And as one sort of food iS camal and anocher Is spiritual, and as there is one drink for the flesh and another for the spirit, so there iS love of the flesh which comes from Satan, and there iS also anocher love, belonging to !he spirit, which has its origin In God; and nobody can be po5sessed by the rwo loves. If you ate a lover of the flesh, you do nor acquire the love of the spirit. If you have despised all bodily things - I do nor mean flesh and blood, but money and property and the very earth and heavett, for these will pass away - if you have sent all th.ese at oouglu and your soul Is not a112ched to any of them, neith.er are you held back by any love of sinful practk:es, then you can acquire spiritual love. We have pur this here, because the opportunity arose 10 say something about spiritual love. And it iS for us to follow SOlomon's injunction, and still more His who spoke through SOlomon concerning wisdom, saying: Love her, and she will keep lbee safe; enfold ber, and she will exalt thee; render her honour; that sbe nury embrace /bee. For there is a certain spirirual embrace, and 0 that the Bridegroom's more perfea embrace may enfold my Bride! Then I too shall be able 10 say what Is written in thls same book: His left band is under my bead, and His right band will embnace me.
3. 'Let Him kiss me,' therefore, 'with the kisses of His mouth.· The Sc.tiprures are wont to use the fonn of command. rather than that of wisb. We have, for instance, Our Father wbo arl in heaven, hallowed he Tby name, instead of '0 thatlt may be hallowed!'; and In the passage before us we read 'Let Him kiss me with the kisses of His mouth.' rather than '0 that He would kiss!' Then she sees the Bridegroom. Fragrant with sweet oils He comes; and He could not orherwise approach the Bride, nor was it fttting for the Father ro send His Son to the marliage in any other wise. He has anointed Him with divers perfumes, He has made Him the Cbrlst, who comes breathing sweet odours and hears the Bride declare: 'Thy breasts are better than wine.' 'The Divine Word rightly has different names for the same thing, according 10 the cont
104
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 104. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=119 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 20 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Fl:R.st Hot.m..Y ON TEE SoNo Of SONOS:
Jiltle breast, but bosom. And again, when the Bride speaks to the BridegtOOm, because it is a marriage-song that is beginning, the word used is not little breast, as in the sacrifice, not bosom, as in the case of the disciple John, but breasts- 'Thy breasts are bener than wine.' Be you of one mind with the BridegtOOm, like the Bride, and you will know that thoughts of this kind do inebriate and make the spirit glad. Wherefore, as the inebriating chalice of the Lcm:l, bow surpassing good ills!- so are the breasts of the Bridegroom bener than any wine. 'For Thy breasts are bener than wine' - this is bow in the midst of her prayers she addresses herself to her Spouse - 'and the odour of Thy perfumes is above aU spices.· Not with one perfume only does He come anointed, but with aU. And if He wiU condescend to make my soul His Bride too and come to her, bow fair must she then be to draw Him down from heaven to herself, to cause Him to come down to earth, that He may visit His beloved one! With what beauty must she be adorned, with what love mUS( she bum that He may say to her the things which He said to the perfea Bride, about thy neck, thine ~. thy cbeeles, thy bands, tby body, thy shoulder, thy feet! God permining, we will think about these questions, and consider why the Bride's members are thus
differenllated and a spectal meed of p!llise accorded ro each pan; thus. when we have thought it out, we may try to have our own soul spoken to in the same way. 'Thy breasts,' then, 'are bener than wine,' If you have seen the Bridegroom, you will know that what is spoken here is true: 'Thy breasts are benet than wine, and the odour of Thy perfumes is above all spices.· Many people have bad spices: the queen of the South brought spices to Solomon, and many others possessed them, but no maner what they bad, their treasures could not be compared with the odours of Christ, of which the Bride says here: 'The odour of Thy perfumes is above aU spices.' I think myself that Moses had spices too, and Aaton, and each one of the prophets; but if I have once seen Christ and have perceived the sweetness of H.is perfumes by their smeU, forthwith I give my judgement in the words: 'The odour ofThy perfumes is above all spioes.'
4. TKY ""'"" rs AS l'flii'VMt POU1\et> FOm<. These words foretell a mystery: even so comes the name ofJesus to the world, and is 'as perfume poured fonh' when it is proclaimed. In the Gospel, moreover, a woman took an alabaster vessel containing preciOus Ointment of pure spikenard and
lOS
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 105. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=120 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 21 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
poured it on Jesus' head, and (anomer) on Hls feet. Note carefully wltich of the two women poured !he perfume on !he Saviour's bead: me sinner poured it on Hls fee~ and she who is not called a s~r poured it on Hls head. Notice, I say, and you will find that in !his Gospel lesson the evangelists have written mysteries, and not just tales and stories. And so the house wru filled witb tbe od<Jur of the (){ntmen( We must take what !he sinner brought with reference to the feet, and what !he woman wbo was not a sinner brought with reference to !he head. Small wonder that the house was filled wirh fragrance, since wilh !his fragrance all the world is filled! The same passage speaks of Simon the leper and his house. I think the leper is me prince of !his world, and that the leper ls called Simon: his house it is that at Christ's coming is filled with sweet odOW$, when a sinful woman repents and a holy one anoints the head of Jesus with sweet perfumes. Thy name is as perfume poured forth.· As perfume when it is applied scatters its fragrance far and wide, so is the name of Jesus poured fotth. In every land His name is named, throughout aU the world my Lord is preached; for His 'name is as perfume poured ford!.' We hear
the name of Moses now. !hough formerly it was not heard beyond the confines of )udea; fo r none of the Greeks makes mention of it. neither do we find anything written about him or about the others anywhere in pagan literarure. But straight away, when Jesus shone upon the world, He led ford! the Law and the Prophets along with Himself, and me words, '11:ty name is as perfume poured forth; were indeed fulfilled. 5. l'>tEREfooE H.
How fine a touch it is that the attendants of the Bride do nOt as yet have the Bride's own confidence! The Bride does not follow behind, she walks side by side with the Bridegroom; she takes Hls right hand, and in
106
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 106. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=121 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 22 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
FJitST' Hown.Y ON THE SoNo OF SoNGs
His right hand her own hand is held. But the bandm2idens follow after Him. TberearetbrHSCOrtlf/U(Im$. andfoursroreconcui>IYUIS, andyoung maidens wilboul number. One is my .UWS, my peifec1 one, sbe is lbe only 0n4 of ber mother, sbelbat conceiwd her batb no other one. 'After thee,' therefore, 'We will run into the fagrance of thy perfumes.' lt was entirely appropriate that these words, 'We will run into the f!'llgrance of thy perfumes,' were used of lovers; they aocord with I bave finished lbe course, and tbey lbal nm In the race all nm indeed, but 0n4 receivlltb lbe prize- which prize is Christ. And these maidens who, as we know, are $landing without bec2use their love is only just beginning, are like tbe friend of lbe !Jrltkgroom, wbo standetb and bearetb Him, and rej0ic8tb wilb joy because of lbe !Jrltkgroom's voice. The maidens undergo a like experience: when the Bridegroom enters, they remain without. But when the Bride, the fuir, the perfect one who is without spot or
wrinkle. has entered the Bridegroom's cllamber, the secret place of the ~ng,
she comes back to the maidens and, telling them the things that she alone has seen, she says: ,.. J<JNG BaOUGKT "" INTO ms owm... She does not say: 'He brought us'- using the plural- 'into His chamber'; the others remain without, the Bride alone is brought into the chamber, that she may see there
'We will be glad and rejoice in thee. WE ww. lOVE 11IV BRtASI'S.' She who is greater is already enjoying the milk of those breasts, and she says in her joy: "Thy breasts are above wine.' But these, because they are young maidens only, defer their joy and gladness; their love also they defer and say: 'We will he glad and rejoice in thee. We will love'- not 'We love; bu< 'We will love' - 'Thy breastS MORE.,.,. woo:.' Then they say to the Bridegroom, 'EQ\JilY HAS LOVED .,...., they praise the Bride by calling her Equity, as denoting the sum of her cllaracteristic vinues-
107
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 107. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=122 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 23 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
'Equity has loved Thee.' 6. The Bride then makes tbe maidens this reply! I "'' BlACK AND we learn now that 'daughters of Jerusalem' is what tbe maidens are-AS'l>l!'!!lmorao.u, AS 'I>!ECtiRTAJNS BEAtnmJt. 0 YE DAUCHTPIS or ]EOUSAWI -
Of SoLOMON. LOOK NOT AT M£, fOK THAT I AM 8LACKtNED; FOit TH2 SUN RAS LOOm>
OOWNONMt.
Beautiful indeed is the Slide, and I can find out in what manner she is so. But tbe question is, in what way is she black and how, Ifshe lacks whiteness, is she fait. She has reperued of her sins, beauty is the gift conversion has bestowed; !hat is the reason she is hymned as beautiful. She is called black, however, because she has not yet been purged of every stain of sin, she has not yet been washed unto salvation; nevertbeless she does not stay dark-hued, she is becoming white. When. therefore, she alises towards greater things and begins to mount from lowly things to lofty, they say concerning he" Who it tbit lbal cometh up, having been washed while? And in order that tbe mystery may be more dearly expressed, they do not say leaning upon her Nephew~ ann, as we read in most versions - that is to say, eplsterlzomble, but epWelblz<mWne, that is, leaning upon Hit bnrast. And ii is signilicant that tfie expression used concerning the blide·soul and the BlidegroomWord is lying upon Hit breast, because there is the seat of our heart. Forsaking carnal things, therefore, we must perceive those of the spirit and understand that it is much better to love after this manner than to refrain from love. She cometb up, then, leaning on her Nephew~ breast; and of her, who at the canticle's beginning was set down as black, it is sung at the end of the marliage·song' Who is Ibis that cometh up, balling been washed u,'blre? We understand, then, why the Blide is black and beautiful at one and the same time. But, if you do not likewise pmctise penitence, take heed lest your soul be desclibed as black and ugly, and you be hideous with a double foulness - black by reason of your past sins and ugly because you are continuing in the same vices! If you have repented, however, your soul will indeed be black because of your old sinS, but your penitence will give it something of what I may call an Ethiopian beauty. And having once made mention of an Ethiopian, l want to summon a Scliprural witness about this word r.oo. Aan>n and Mary murmur against Moses, because Moses has an Elbii:Jpilm wife. Moses
108
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 108. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=123 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 24 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
FILIT lloo&Y C1t1 THI! SoMa 01 SoMas
weds an Ethiopian wife, because his Law has passed over to the Ethiopian woman of our Song. Let the A2ron of the Jewi$11 prieSthood mumrur, and let the Mary of their synagogue murmur too. Moses c:ateS nothing for their murmuring; He loves His Ethiopian WOtlla11, concerning wbom it is said elsewhere through the prophet: From tbe ends of the rivm of Etblopfa shall tbey bring offerings, and again: EJbiopia shall get ber bands In first wllb God lt is well said that sbe shall get in first; for, as in the Gospel the WOOJan With the issue of blood received attemlon before the daughter of the ruler of the synagogue, so also has Ethiopia been healed wblle lsrnel is SliD sick. By tb<Jir offence sa!mlion bas been Bjfet:ted for tlw Gmtiles, so as to malo~ tbmt jM/ous. 'I am black and beautiful, 0 ye daughters of Jerusalem: Address yourself to the daughters of Jerusalem, you member of the Cburcb, and
say: 'The Bddegroom loves me more and holds me dearet than you, wbo are the many daughters of Jerusalem; you stand without and watch the Bdde enter the chamber.' !Let no one doutx that the black one is beautiful, for an sbe is caDed black. For we exist in order that we may acknowledge God, that we may teU fonh songs of a song, that we may be those who bave come from the borders of Ethiopia, from the ends of the earth, to hear the wisdom of lhe true Solomon.) And when lhe Saviour's voice is heard thundering out the words: 71H <JUNn of tbe South shall come to judgement and shaU condemn tbe ,.... of tbls genmztton, because sbe came from tb' ends of the eatfb to bear tb' wisdom of Solomon, and bebold, a gmater tban Solomon Is bere, you must understand wbat Is said in a mystical sense: the queen of the South, who comes from the ends of the eanh, is the Church; and the men of this generatiOn whom she condemns, are the Jews. who are given over to flesh and blood. She comes from the ends of the eanh to hear the wisdom, not of that Solomon about whom we read in the Old Testament, but of Him wbo is said in the Gospel to be greater than Solomon.
'I am black and beautiful, 0 daughters of Jerusalem, black as the tents of Cedar, beautiful as the curtains of Solomon.' The very names aa:ord With the Bride's comeliness. The Hebrews say that Cedar is the word for darkness- 'I am black,' therefore, ·as the tents of Cedar,' as the EthiopianS, as Ethiopian tents; and 'beautiful as the curtains of Solomon,· wbic:b be prepared as adornments of the tabernacle at the time when b.e buUt the Temple with the utmoSt care and toil. Solomon was rich indeed,
109
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 109. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=124 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 25 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
and no one surpassed him In any branch of wisdom. 'I am black and beautiful, 0 daughters ofJerusalem, as the tents of Cedar, as the cunains of Solomon. Look not at me, for that I am blackened.' She apologizes for her blackness; and being turned to beaer tblngs through penitenoe, she tells the daughters ofJerusalem that she is black indeed, but beautiful for the reason which we gave above, and says: 'Look not at me, for that 1am blackened.' 'Do not be surprised,' she says, 'that I am of a forbidding hue; the Sun has looked down oo me. With full radiance His bright Ught has shone on me, aod I am darkened by His heat. I have not indeed received His Ught into myself as it were fining that I should, and as the Sun's own dignity requited.·
By their offence saluaticm has been effected for the Gentiles. And again: Through the unheli4f of the Gentiks is the /mew/edge of lsnl81. You fmd both these texts in the ApoStle. 7. THE SONs Of >fY 'IO'lliEO HAV! FOUCHT AGAINSt ME. We mu& consider in what sense the Bride says: 'The sons of my mother have fought against me; and at what time her brothers launched this aaack. You have only to look at Paul, the persecutor of the Church, to see how a son of her mother fought against her. The persecutors of the Church have repenred, and her opponents have turned to their siste(s banners and have preached the faith which they formerly sought to destroy. .foreseeing this. the
Bride now sings: THEY I{.\V£ COm"EN'OW ACA~'T M£, THEY &vt MAO£ ME TliE vrNEY.UOSo 1(¥ ~nAAO J HAVE NOf lC£P'T, ;l. tbe Church, the
KEEPER Ho: THE
spotless one,' she says, 'have been appoirued keeper of many vineyards by my mother's sons, who once had fought against me. Harassed by the responsibility and care involved in guarding many vineyards, I have not kept my own.' Apply these words to Paul or any other of the saints who care for the salvation of all people, and you will see how he guards others' vine· plantations while not guarding his own; how he himself bears loss in some respectS so that he may gain others; and how, though he was free as to all, he made himself the seJVant of all that be might gain all, being made weak to the weak, a Jew to the Jews, as subject to the Law to those who are so subject, and so forth - how, in a word, he can ~y; 'My vineyard I have not kepL' The Bride then beholds the Bridegroom; and He, as soon as s he has
110
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 110. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=125 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 26 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
seen Him, goes away. He does this frequently duoughout the Song; and that is something nobody can understand wno has not suffered it himself. God is my witness that I have often perceived the Bridegroom dr2wing near me and being most intensely present With me; then suddenly He has Withdlllwn and I could not fmd Him, though I sought to do so. I long, therefore, for Him to come again, and sometimes He does so. Then, when He has appeared and I lay hold of Him, He slips away once more; and, when He has so slipped away, my search for Him begins anew. So does He act with me repeatedly, until in uuth I hold Him and go up, 'leaning on my Nephew's arm.· 8. Tl!lL )of£, THOU WKOW MY SOUl. KAS LOVED, WHlJI£ 11101) FUDEST, W"KD:! nteu lJEST' 1s 'THE MIDDAY. I am not asking about other times, I ask not where Thou feedest in the evening, or at daybreak, or when the sun
goes down. I ask about the full day-lime, when the light is brightest and Thou dwellest In the splendour of Thy roajesty: 'Tell me, Thou whom my soul has loved, where Thou liest in the midday.' Observe attentively where else you have read about midday. In the story of Jooeph his brethren feast at noon; at noon the angels were e nten:tined by Abraham, and there are other instances bes!<Jes. You will find if you look into it, thatHolyScriprure never uses any word haphazard and without a purpose. Who among us, do you think, is worthy to attain the midday, and to see where the Bridegroom feeds and where He lies at noon? 'TeU me. Thou whom my soul has loved, where Thou feedest, where Thou liest in the midday.' For, unless Thou tell me, I shall begin to be a vagrant, dm~n to and fro; while I am looking for Thee, I shall begin to run after other people's flocks and, because these other people make me feel ashamed, I shall begin to rover my f•ce and my mouth. I am the beautiful Bride in sooth, and I show not my naked face to any save Thee only, whom I kissed rettderly but now. 'Tell me, Thou whom my soul has loved, where Thou feedest, where Thou liest in the midday, lfST I HAVE TO GO VEllED Bl.SQ,)!. m! l"'...CKS Of nN OOMPANtONS.'
That {suffer not
these things - that I rnay need not to go veiled nor hide my face; that, mixing With others, I run not the risk of beginning to love also them whom I know not - tell me, therefore, where I may seek and fmd Thee in the mlddoy, 'lest I have to go veiled beside the flocks of Thy companions.•
Ill
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 111. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=126 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 27 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
9. After these words !be Bridegroom wams her, saying: 'Either know thyself, that thou art the Bride of the King and beautiful, an d made beautiful by me because I have presemed to myself a g/criou.s Church, n<>t having spot or wrlnllk; or undetstand that if thou has! 001 known thyself nor gtasped thy dignity, thou must endure the things that follow.· What may these be? (f11fOU Hhvt NOT KNOWN nfY'Sll.P, THE rnJ>S
0
FIJ'R ONE AMONG WO..'IEN, GO f'Oimi IN
or THE FlOCJ(5 """ mo- not the flocks of sheep, nor of l:unbs,
but - 1HY GOA!S. He will set the sheep on the right hand and the goat:s upon the left, assuredly. 'If thou have not known thyself, 0 fair one among women, go fonh in the steps of the flocks and feed lhy goat:s AMONG nu! SHEPHl!I1DS'1!NTS.' 'In the steps of the flocks,' He says, 'wilt thou find thyself at the last, oot among the sheep, but among lhe goat:s; and when thou dweUest with them thou can.st not be with me - that is, wilh lhe Good Shepherd. 10. 1'0 MYCONPAHVOP HOISE'MEN ..ulONO PHAltAO'S atAJUOTS HAVE (
UJCEN!O
nm:. If tbou wouklst understand, 0 Bride, how thou must know thyself, think what it is to which I have compared thee. Then, when thou hast
recognized lhy likeness, thou wilt see that thou a.n such as must not be
disgraced.' What then is lhe meaning of these words: 'To my company of horsemen among Phano's chariotS have I likened lhee? I myself know that the Bridegroom is likened ro a horseman in the words of the propl\et: Thy riding is saltxzti<m, so thou art compared to 'my company of horsemen amoQg Phan.o's chariots.' As different is lhe company of 1\orsemen that belongs to me, who am lhe Lord and drown lhe Pharao and his generals, his riders and his horsemen In the waves - as different, I tell you, ismycavalryfromPhan.o's horses as thou, the Bride, art better than aU daughters, and thou, the soul belonging to !be Church, art better than aU souls that are not of the Church. 'To my company of horsemen among Pharao's chariotS have I likened thee.• He next describes the beauty of the Bride in teons of spiritu21Jove; He pfllises her face, and is kindled to admltation by her rosy cheeks. A woman's beaUty is considered to reside supremely in her cheeks. So let us likewise take !be cheeks as revealing the beauty of the soul; by Ups and toQgUC, however, let the intelligence be represented to us.
1HY QII!ElCS """AS ""' Ttllt1U•OOVE's.
llZ
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 112. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=127 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 28 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
THY N!CI< IS .s • ~- Thy neck, that is to say, even when unadorned is of itself as much an omament as is the Utile necklace called bormislros, that virgins are woot to wear.
After these things the Spouse takes His re~. lie has~ as a lion, and as a lion's whelp lie has slept. so that in due course He may hear. Wbo sbaU arouse liim? While He reposes, His companions the angels appear to the Bride and comfott her with these words: 'We cannot make thee golden ornaments - we are Dot so rich as is thy Spouse, who gives thee a necklace of gold; we will make thee Uke.nesses of gold, for gold we have Dot got. Yet this also is matter for rejOiCing, lf we make likenesses of gold, if we make studs of silver..... W!ll. tMliZ 1II!E UXENESSES o• GOtD """' snro. OF SJLVEO; but not for always, only until thy Spouse arises from His rest. For, when He has arisen, He Himself will make thee gold and silver, He will Himself adorn thy mind and thy understanding. and thou shalt. be rich indeed, the Bride made perfect in the House of the Bridegroom, to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen.•
113
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 113. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=128 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 29 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
This page intentionally left blank
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 114. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=129 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 30 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Cyprian, l'tYaltuiO ~NS (:ZS:Z1, Carthajpo)
Cwrian \llla$cius Cae,ilius Cyprianus, d. 258), bi:ihop of Canhage, followed in a theological ~r.~dltion laid out by an earlier Catthaginian Christian, TerrullW!, who died ftfteen or twenty years before Cyprian's conversion. Ternillian is oonsldered a deeper theologian with a wider range of interests, Cyprian the clearer writer with the more practiC21 bent and the more compassionate heart. Cyprian was born into a cultuted and wealthy pagan family, probably in Carthage, the p remier dty of North Africa, and the second most important dty of the western Roman Empire after Rome. (Its ruins remain on its site on the Bay of Tunis, quite near modem Tunis In Tunisia.) He was ciassically educated, and made his living as a teacher of rhetoric. While the field of rhetoric could be, at its worst, simply the skill of speaking impressively in public and winning argumetliS, it could also be, at its best - as the philosopher Aristotle had explained it more than five centuries earlier - a sophisticated art that integrated philosophy, logic, dialectic, grammar, and literary analysis. Moreover, the rhetorician could be expected to serve as the remembrancer of the politiC21 and social uaditions of the community. A good teacher of thetoric, therefore, was an eminent person in classiC21 culture. Cyprian gave up his social standing when he converted to Christianity at an unknown date under the influence of a Christian presbyter. He stopped read!nS pagan titenture.
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 115. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=130 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 31 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
and devoted himself to !be $tUdy of Scriprure instead He apparently also gave •WliY IIX)SI of his wealth. Soon he was made a presbyter in !he Church, and by early 249, relucranrly and after demonstrations by laypeople who supported him, he was made bishop. He had probably been a Christian only a few years, because several car!haginian clergy opposed his conseaarion as bishop on !be grounds that be was stiU new to !be faith.
Cyprian had been bi.shop for only about a year when the Emperor Oecius unleashed an intense petsecution of the Church. Cyptian went into hiding. Some altidz.ed him as a coward and a bad example, but he defended his decision as good strategy for the church, and he also quored Revebtion 18:4, "Come out of her, my people, .. . so that you do nor share in her pbgues: and Matthew 10:23, "When !hey persecute you in one town, flee to the next.• From his refuge, be oorulnued to administer his diocese. He rerumed to canhage !he foUowing year. In the wake of !be pet>eCUtion, the Church faced a very practical question: what should be done With the "lapsed", those who had in some measure denied their faith under duress? And what should be done with the "llbeUatici", !hose who had nor exactly denied !heir faith, but who bad oblaincd certificates C"libelli") statlng that they had vene!'ited. the RollWl gods? Two exueme posWoo.s sptit the Church In cartilage. Some, who may be called "the bxists; were willing to re-admit the lapsed and the "JibeUatid" immediately. Others, who may be called "the maintained that their sin was unforgiwble. Between the bxists and the rlgourists Cyprian made his way to a mediating position. He persuaded his syood (the church council of his diocese) that aD the lapsed might be reconciled to the Church, but only after a period of penance commensurate With the gravity of the offence, or else on their deathbed
n8ourists:
Two related matters troubled Cyprian. Among the bxists were some •confessors•, Christians who had maintained their faith even through imprisonment and tottute, but had not been martyred; and many of them were claiming authOrity from God 10 forgive the lapsed and 10 readmit them into the Church. Did they reaDy have this authoriry? Cyprian's answer was that they did not. Only the bishop and clergy could reconcile sinners on God's behalf. Moreover, some of !be rigourists were setting up their own churches, in schism from the true Church. Were the people
116
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 116. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=131 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 32 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
they baptUed truly baptized? Cyprian answered that they were not; and should they later want to enter the Catholic Churcll, they would need a proper baptiSm. He thus contradicted the bishop of Rome of his day. In 257 a new Emperor, Valeriatl, began a new persecution of Christians. Cyprian was fon:ed into exile, and !ben finaJJy, in 258, he WliS martyred, by beheading.
Most of Cyprian's works attend to churclly themes, !-ut the treatise To Demetrianus, printed below, is an exception, at least at fust sight. Instead it aims to answer a question which baunted anotbet North Aftican, Sl Augustine, over a century and a half later: if Christianity is from God, then why did so many bad things swt happening as soon as the Church began attr.lcting people away from paganism' Written against a background o f persecution, the work refleas some of the phil060phical and other dlfferences that divided Christian from pagan. Demelrianus was ·the proc:onsul of Aftic:a. The work bears some resemblance to an Apology by T ertullian, whom Cyprian m uch admired. Cyprian. lilce Tertullian, wrote in Latin, .and the manuscript tradition raises no unusual problems.
Questloas on the r
1
1Qg
What prompts Cyprian to write? What, according to Cyprian, has Demetrlanus been saying about the Christians' What tone does Cyprian take? What evidence of the social background of the controversy can be found within the texl? To what extent is Cyprian really addressing Demetrianus personally, and to wbat extent a Christian or pagan public? What does Cyprian understand as authoritative evidence for his position? Would Demetrianus be impressed with citations of Scripture? What common understanding might they share, if any, as a basis of conversation? Is Cyprian·s classical education in evidence in the document? What is Cyprian's understanding of the world, and bow histocy works? What is his view of the day of judgment? What are the apologetic goals and suategies of the treatise? What might be considered distinctive of North African Christianity in this document?
117
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 117. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=132 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 33 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
1. I had frequently, Demetrianus, treated with contempt your railing and noisy clamoor with sacrilegious mouth and impious words against the one and true God, thinking it more modest and better, silently to scorn the ignorance of a mistaken man, than by speaking to provoke the fury or a senseless one. Neither did 1 do this without the authority or the divine teaching, since it is written, "Speak not in the ears or a fool, lest when be hear thee be should despise the wisdom of thy words;"' and again, •AAswer not a fool according to his folly, lest thou also be like unto him."" And we are, moreover, bidden to keep what is holy within our own knowledge, and not expose it to be trodden down by swine and dogs, since the Lord speaks, saying, •Give not that which Is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before swine, lest they trample them under their feet, and rum again and rend you.·• For when you used often to come to me with the deslre or oontradlalng rather than with the wish to learn, and preferred Impudently to insist on your own views, which you shouted with noisy words, to patiently listening to mine, it seemed to me foolish to oontend with you; since it would be an easier and slighter thing to restrain the angry waves or a turbulent sea with shouts, than to checl< your madness by arguments. Assuredly it would be both a vain and ineffecrual labour to offer tight to a blind man, discourse to a deaf one, or wisdom to a bMe; since neither ean a brute apprehend, nor can a blind man admit the light, nor can a deaf man hear. 2. In consideration or this, I have frequently held my tongue, and overcome an impatient person with patience; since I could neither teach an unteachable person, nor check an Impious one with religion, nor restrain a frantic person with gentleness. But yet, when you say that very Source: Cyprlan, Thl
457-465. 118
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 118. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=133 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 34 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
TBA77SB 10 DDif:r'RI.A/Ns
many are complaining that to us it is ascribed that wars arise more &equendy, that plague, that famines rage, and that long ~ghts are suspending the showetS and rains, it is nO€ fitting that I should be silent any longer, lest my silence should begin to be attributed to mistrust rather than to modesty; and while I am treating the false cbalges with contempt, l may seem to be ackno'lllledging the crime.! reply, therefore, as well to you, ~. as to otbetS whom perhaps you have stirred up, and many of whom, by sowing hatred against us with maliciouS words, you have made your own partisans, from the budding forth of your own root and origin, who, however, l believe, will admit the reasonableness of my discourse; foe he who is moved to evil by the deception of a lie, will much more easily be moved to good by the cogency of trUth.
3. You have said that all these things are caused by us, and that to us ought to be attributed the misfortunes wherewith the world is now s haken and dislressed, because your gods are not worshipped by us. And in this behalf, since you are ignorant of divine knowledge, and a scranger to the truth, you must in the first place know this, that the world has now grown old, and does not abide in that scrength in which it formerly stood;. nor has it that vigour and force which it formerly possessed. This, even were we silen~ and if we aDeged no proofs from the sacred Scriptures and from the divine declarations, the world itself is now announcing, and bearing witness to its decline by the testimony of itS failing est2te. In the winter there iS not sudt an abundance of showetS for nourishing the seeds; in the summer the sun has not so much heat for cherishing the harvest; nor in the spring season are the com·fields so joyous; nor are the aurumnal seasons so fruitful in their leafy products. The layers of marble are dug out in less quantixy from the disembowelled and wearied mountains; the diminished quantities of gold and silver suggest the early exhaustion of the metals, and the impoverished veins are straitened and decreased day by day; the husbandman is falling in the fields, the sailor at sea, the soldier in the camp, innocence in the market, justice in the tribunal, concord in friendships, skilfulness in the ans, discipline in morals. Think you that the substantial charaaer of a thing that is growing old remains so robust as that wherewith it might previously flourish in itS youth while still new and vigorous? Whatever is tending down"Mrds to decay, With its end nearly approaching, must of necessity be weakened. 'Tbus, the sun at hls setting darts hls rays with a
119
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 119. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=134 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 35 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
less bright and fiery splendour; thus, In her declining course, the moon wanes with exhausted horns; and the tree, which before had been green and fertile, as ils branches dry up, becomes by and by misshapen in a barren old age; and the fountain which once gushed forth libetally from ils overflowing veins, as old age causes it to fail, scarcely trickles with a sparing moisture. 'lliis is the sentence passed o n the world, this is God's law, that everything that has had a beginning should perish, and things that have grown should become old, and that S!l'Otlg things should become weak, and great things become small, and that, when they have become weakened and diminished, they should oome to an end. 4. You impute it to the Christians that everything is decaying as the world grows old. What if the old should charge it on the Christians that they grow less strong in their old age; that they no longer, as formerly, have the same faculties, in the hearing of their ears, in the swiftness of their feet, in the keenness of their eyes, in the vigour of their strength, in the freshness of their organic powers, in the fulness of their limbs, and that although once a human life endured beyond the age of eight and nine hundred years, it can now scarcely anain to its hundredth year? We see grey hairs in boys - the hair falls before it begins to grow; and life
does not cease in old age, but it begins with old age. Thus, even at its birth hastens to its close;• thus, whatever is now born degenerates with the old age of the world itself; so that no one ought to wonder that everything begins to fail in the world, when the whole world itself is already in process of falling, and in ils end. very commencement,
5. Moreover, that wars continue frequently to prevail, that death and famine aocumulate anxiety, that health is shattered by raging diseases, that the human race is wasted by the desolation of pestilence, know that this was foretold; that evils should be multiplied in the last times, and that misfortunes should be varied; and that as the day of judgment is now drawing nigh, the censure of an indignant God should be more and more aroused for the scourging of the human race. For these things happen not, as your false complaining and ignorant inexperience of the truth assertS and repeats, because your gods are not worshipped by us, bu• because God is not worshipped by you. For since He is Lord and Ruler of the work!, and all things are carried on by His will and direction, nor can anything be done save what He Himself has done or allowed to be done, certainly when those things occur which show the anger of an
120
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 120. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=135 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 36 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
TMATIS£ 10 D£MEriJANfJS
olttnded God, they happen 110( on a=unt of us by whom God is worshipped, but they are called down by your sins and deseMilgs, by whom God is neither in 2ny way sough! DO< feared, because your vain superstitions are not fo!Saken, nor the aue religion known in sudl WiSe that He who is the one God over all might alone be worshipped and petitioned. 6. In line, llslen to Himself speaking; HJmself with a dl\line voice at once iDSli'Ucting and warning us: "Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God,• says He, •and Him only shalt thou serve."' And ag2in, "Thou shalt have none other gods but me." And again, "Go not after other gods, to serve them; and worship them not, and provoke not me to anger with the works of your hands to destroy you."' Moreover, the prophet, filled with the Holy SpUit, attests and denounces the anger of God, saying, "Thus salth the Lord Almighty: Because of mine house that is waste, and ye run every man to his own house, therefore the heavens shall be stayed from dew, and the earth sbaU withhold her fruits: and I will bring a sword upon the earth, and upon the=. and upon the wine, and upon the oi~ and upon people, and upon cattle, and up6n aU labours of their bands."" Moreover, another prophet repeats, and says, • And I will cause it to rain upon one dty, and upon another dty I will cause it nO! to rain. One piece shall be rained upon, and the piece whereon I send no rain shall be withered. And two and three cities shall be gathered into one city to ·drink water, and shaU not be satisfiedi and ye are not converted unto me, saith the Lord.... 7. Behold, the Lord is angry and wrathful, and threatens, because you turn not unto Him. And you wonder or complain in this your obstinacy and contempt, if the rain comes down with unusual scarcity; and the earth falls into neglect with dusty corruption; if the barren glebe hardly bring.> forth a few jejune and pallid blades of grass; if the destroying bail weakens the vines; if the overwhelming whirlwind roots out the olive; if drought stanches the fountain; a pestilent breel\e corrupts the air; the weakness of disease wastes a""'Y man; although aU these things come as the consequence of the sins that provoke them, and God is more deeply indignant when such and so great evils avail nothing! For that these things oocur either for the discipline of the obstinate or for the punishment of the evil, the same God decl2res in the Holy Scriptures, saying, "In vain have I smitten your children; they have not received
t21
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 121. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=136 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 37 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
correcdon. ·•• And the prophet devoted and dedicated to God answers to these words in the same strain, and says, 'Thou has stricken them, but they have not grieved; Thou hast scourged them, but they have refused to receive correction.•n Lo, stripes are inflicted from God, and there is no fear of God. Lo, blows and scourglngs from above are not wanting, and there is no trembling, no fear. What if even no such rebuke as that inte.fered in human affairs>How much greater still would be people's audacity, if it were S«Ure in the impunity of their crimes! 8. You complain that the founrains are now less plentiful to you, and the breezes less salubrious, and the frequent sbowers and the fertile earth afford you less ready assistance; !hat the elements no loJl8er subserve your uses and your pleasures as of old. But do you serve God, by whom all things are ordained to your service; do you wait upon Him by whose good pleasure all things wail upon you' from your slave you yourself require service; and though a man, you compel your fellowman to submit, and to be obedient to you; and although you share tbe same lot in respect of being born, the same condition in respect ofdying; allhough you have like bodily substance and a common order of souls, and although you come into this world of ours and depan from it after a time With equal risJlts, and by the same law; yet, unless you are served by him according to your pleasure, unless you are obeyed by him in conformity ro your will, you, as an imperious and excessive exactor of his service, Dog and scourge him: you afflict and torrure him with hunger, with thirst and nakedness, and even frequently with !he sword and with imprisonment. And, wretch that you are. do you not acknowledge the Lord your God while you yourself are thus exercising lordship?
9. And therefore with reason in these plagues that occur, there are not wanting God's stripes and scourges; and since they are of no avail in this matter, and do not conven individuals 10 God by such terror of desttuctions, there remains after all the eternal dungeon, and the continual flre. and the everlasting punishment; nor shall the groaning of the suppliants be heard there, because here the terror of the angry God was not he:~rd, crying by His prophet, and saying, •Hear !he word of the Lord, ye children of Israel: for the judgment of the Lord is against the inhabitants of the e3tth; because there is neither mercy, nor truth, nor knowledge of God upon the eanh. But cursing, and lying, and killing, and stealing, and committing adultery, is broken out over the land, they 122
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 122. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=137 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 38 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
tnlngle b lood with b lood Therefore shall the land mourn, with every one !hat dweUeth therein, with the beasts of the field, with things !hat creep on the eanh, and with the fowls of heaven: and the fishes of the sea sll2ll languish, so thll.t no one shall judge, no one sll2ll rebuke. •u God says He is wr.uhful and angry, because there Is no acknowledgment of God in the eanh, and God Is neither known nor feated. The sins of lying. of lust, of fraud, of cruelty, of impiety, of anger, God rebukes and finds f.tult with, and no one Is converted to innocency. Lo, those things are happening which were before foretOld by the words of God; nor is any one admonished by the belief of things p<eSent to me thought for what is to come. Amoogsl those very misfonunes wherein the soul, closely bound and shut up, can scarcely bteathe, there is still found opponunity for people to be evil, and in such great dangers to judge not so much of themselves as of others. You are indignant !hat God is angry, as if by an evil life you were deserving any good, as if all things of !hat kind which happen were not inlioitely less and of smaller account thll.n your sins.
10. You who judge others, be for once also a judge of yourself; look into the hiding-places of your own conscience; nay, since now there is not evl!n any shame in yoor Sin, and you are wicked, as if It were rather the very wickedness itself that pleased you, do you, wbo are seen clearly and nakedly by all other people, yourself also look upon yourself. For either you are swollen with pdde, or greedy with avadce, or cruel with anger, or prodigal with gambling, or flushed with intemperanoe, or envious with jealousy, or unchaste with lust, or violent with cruelty; and do you wonder that God's anger increases in punishing the human race, when the sin !hat is punished is dally ln~ing? You complain thll.t the enemy rises up, as if, though an enemy were wanting. there could be peace for you even among the very tOgas of peace. You compl;iln that the enemy rises up, as if, even although external anns and dangers from barbarians were repressed, the weapons of domestic assault from the calumnies and wrongs of powerful cltiuns, would not be more ferocious and more harshly wielded within. You oompl:oin of barrenness and famine, as if drought made a greater famine thll.n rapacity, as if the fierceness of want did not increase more terribly from grasping at the increase of the year's produce, and the accumulation of their price. You complain that the heaven is shut up from showers, although in the same
123
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 123. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=138 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 39 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
way the tx.uns are shut up on earth. You complain that now less is produced, as if what had already been produced were given to the indigent. You reproach plague and disease, while by plague itself and disease the crimes of individuals are either detecred or increased, while mercy is not manifested to the weak, and avarice and rapine a•e waiting opel>'mouthed for the dead. The same men are timid in the duties of affection, but rash In quest of impious gains; shunning the deaths of the dying, and craving the spoils of the dead, so that it may appear as if the wretched are probably forsaken In their sickness for this cause, that they may not, by being cured, escape: for he who enters so eagerly upon the estate of the dying, probably desired the sick roan to perisb. 11. So great a terror of destru'ay that God can prevent adverse things, but that the evil desertS of sinners prevent His bringing aid. "ls the Lord's hand; says he, •not strong ro save you; or bas He made heavy His ear, that He cannot bear you? But your sins separate between you and God; and because of your sins He hath hid His face from you, that He may not have mercy."" Therefore let your sins and offences be reckoned up; let the wounds of your conscience be considered; and let those cease
124
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 124. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=139 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 40 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
complaining about God, or about us, who should perceive that they deserve wbat they suffer. 12. Look what that very mattet is of which is chiefly our dlscoorse that you molest u.s, although innocen~ that, in contempt of God, you attack and oppress God's servants. It is little. In your accorm~ that your life is stained with a variety of gross vices, with the iniquity of deadly crimes, with the summary of all bloody rapines; that uue religion is ovetrumed by false superstitions; that God is neither sought at all, nor feared at all; but over and above this, you weazy God's servants, and those wbo are dedicated to His ltllljesty and His name, with unjUst persecutions. It is not enough that you yourself do not worship God, but, over and above, you per$eCUte those who do worship, with a sacrilegious hostility. You neither worship God, nor do you at all pennit Him to be worshipped; and while Olhers who venerate not only those foolish idols and images made by human hands, but even portents and monsters besides, are pleasing to you. it is only the worshipper of God who is displeasing to you. The ashes of victims and the piles of cattle everywhere smoke in your temples, and God's alws are either nowhere or are hidden. Crocodiles, and apes, and stones, and serpentS are worshipped by you; and God alone in the earth i! not worshipped, or if worshipped, not with Impunity. You deprive the innocent, the jus~ the ~to God, of their home; you spoil them of their e.scue, you load them with chains, you shut them up in prison, you punish them with the sword, with the wild beastS, with the Aames. Nor, indeed, are you content with a brief endurance of our sufferings, and with a simple and swift exhaustion of pains. You set on foot tedious torrures, by tearing our bodies; you multiply numerous punishments, by lacerating our vitals; nor can your brutality and fierceness be oonteru with ordinary tortures; your ingenious cruelty devises new sufferings. 13. What is this insatiable madness for bloodshedding, what this intenninable lust of cruelty? Rather make your election of one of two alternatives. To be a Christian is either a crime, or it is not. If it be a crime, why do you not put the man that confesses it to death? If it be not a crime, why do you persecute an innocent man? For I ought to be put to the torture if l denied it. If in fear of your punishment I should oonceal, by a deceitful falsehood, what I had previously been, and the fact that I had not v.'Orshipped your gods, then I might deserve to be tonnented,
125
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 125. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=140 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 41 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
then I ought to be oompelled to confession of my aime by the power of suffering, as in other examinations the guilty, who deny that they ate guilty of the crime of whlch they are accused, ate tortured in order that the confession of the reality of the crime, which the teU-Iale voice refuses to make, may be wrung out by the bodily sul!ering. But now, when of my own free will I confess, and cry out, and with words frequent and repeated to the same elf~ bear witness that I am a Christian, why do you apply tortures to one w ho avows i~ and who destroys your gods, not in hidden and secret places, but openly, and publicly, and in the very market-place, in !lie beating of your magistrates and governors; so that, although it was a slight thing whkh you blamed in me before, that which you ought nuher to hate and punlsb has increased, that by declaring myself a Christian in a frequented place, and with the people standing around, I am confounding both you and your gods by an open and public announcement? 14. Why do you tum your attentioo to the weakness of our body? Why do you Sllive with the feebleness of this earthly llesb? Contend rather with the strength of the mind, break down the power of the soul, destroy our faith, conquer if you can by discussion, overcome by reason; or, if your gods have any deity and power, let them themselves rise to their own vindication, let them defend themselves by their own majesty. But what can they advantage their worshippers, if they cannot avenge themselves on those who worship them not? For if the one who avenges is of more account than the one wbo is avenged, then you are greater than your gods. ADd if you are greater than those whom you worship, you ought not to worship them, but rather to be worshipped and feared by them as their lord. Your championship defends them when injured, just as your protectioo guaJds them when shut up from perishing. You should be ashamed to worship those whom you yourself defend; you should be ashamed to hope for protection from those whom you yourself protect. 15. Ob, would you but hear and see them wbeo they ate adjured by us, and tortured with spiritual scourges, and are ej~ed from the poosessed bodies with tortureS of words, when howling and groaning at a human voice and the power of God, feeling the stripes and blO
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 126. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=141 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 42 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
demon- who has now possessed your breast, wbo has now darl<ened your mind with tbe night of ignOrance, shall speak concerning yourself in your hearing. You will see that we are entreated by those whom you entreat, that we are feared by those whom you fear, whom you adore. You will see that under our hands they stand bound, and tremble as captives, whom you look u p to and venerate as lords: assuredly even thus you might be confounded in those errors of yours, when you see and bear your gods, at once upon our interrogation betraying what they are, and even in your presence unable to conceal those deceits and trickeries of theirs. 16. What, then, is that sluggishness of mind; yea, what bliod and stupid madness of fools, 10 be unwilling to come out of darkness into light, and to be unwilling, wben bound in tbe toils of eoema! death, to reoeive the hope of immOrtality, and not 10 fear God when He threatens and says, •He that sacrifices unto any gods, but unto tbe Lord only, shall by rooted out?"" And again: "1beyworshipped them whom their fingers made; and tbe mean man bath bowed down, and tbe great man hath humbled himself, and I will n<X forgive tbem.• ., Why do you bumble and bend yourself to false gods? Why do you bow your body captive before foolish images aod cre2tions o f ea!th? God made you upright; and while other animals are downlooking, and are depressed in posture bending towards the earth, yours is a lofty attitude; and your countenance is raised upwards to lleaven, and to God. Look thither, lift your eyes thllherward, seek God in the highest, that you may be free from things below~ lift your heart to a dependence on high and heavenly things. Why do you prostrate yourself into the ruin of death with the 5e1Jl"nt whom you worship? Why do you fall into the destruction of tbe devil, by his means and in his company? Keep the lofty es12te in which you were born. Continue such as you were made by God. To the posture of your countenance and of your body, conform your soul. That you may be able eo ~<no<~.• God, f>rst know yourself. Forsake the idols which human error has invented. Se turned to God, whom if you implore He will aid you. Believe in Christ, wbom the Father has sent to quicken and restore us. Cease to hurt tbe servants ofGod and ofChrist with your persecutions, since wben they are injured the divine vengeance defends them.
17. For this reason it is that none of us, when apprehended, makes resis12nce, nor takes vengeance against your unrigbteous violence,
127
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 127. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=142 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 43 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
although our people are numerous and plenliful. Our cert:ainty of a vengeance 'to follow makes us patienL 1be innocent give place to the gullty; the harmless acquiesce in punishments and tortures, sure and confident that whatsoever we suffer will not remain unav
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 128. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=143 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 44 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
and by you? AmOI\g you there is always a clamorous and complaining impatience; with us ~ is a s1r0ng and rdigious patience, always quiet and always grateful to God Nor does it claim for itself anything joyous or prosperous in this world, but, meek and gentle and stable against all the gusts of this =inS world, it waits for the time of the divine promise; for as long as this body endures, it must needs have a common lot with others, and its bodily condition mUSt be common. Nor is it given to any of the human race to be separated one from another, except by withdrawal from this present life. In the meantime, we are all, good and evil, contained in one household. Whatever happens within the house, we suffer with equal f.ne, until, when the end of the temporal life shall be attained, we shall be distributed among the homes either of eternal death or immotUlity. Thus, therefore, we are not on the same level, and equal with you, because, placed in this present world and in this flesh, we incur equally with you the annoyances of the world and of the flesh; for since in tbe sense of pain is all punishment, it is manifest that one is not a sharer of your punishment who, you see,. does not suffer pain equally with yourselves. 20. There flourishes with us the strength of hope and the fumness of
<h. Amol\g IM$e vety ru!os of a decayillg 'liiOtld out soul Is lifted up, and our courage unshaken: our patience is never anything but joyous; and the mind is always secure of its God, even as the Holy Spirit speaks through the prophet, and exhorts us, strengthening with a heavenly word the finnness of our hope and faith. "The fig-tree; says He, "shall not bear fruit, and there shall be no blossom in the vines. The labour of the olive shall fail, and the fields shall yield no meat The flock shall be ew off from the fold, and there shall be no herd in the StaUs. But I will rejoice in the lord, and I will joy in the God of my salvation."" He says that the man of God and the worshipper of God, depending on the truth of his hope, and founded on the stedfastness of his faith, is not moved by the attacks of this world and this life. Although the vine should fail, and the olive deceive, and the field parched with grass dying with drought should wither, what is this to Christians? what to God's servants whom paradise is inviting, whom all the grace and all the abundance of the ltingdom of heaven is waiting for? They always exult in the Lord, and rejoice and are glad in their God and the evils and adversities of the wodd they brnvely suffer, because they are lookin.g forward to gifts and
t29
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 129. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=144 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 45 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
prosperities to come: for we who have put off our earthly birth, and are now created and regenerated by the Spirit, and no longer live to the world but to God, shall not receh•e God's gift> and promises Wltil we arrive at the presence of God. And yet we always ask for the repulse of enemies, and for obtaining showers, and either for the removal or the moderating of adversity; and we pour forth our prayers, and, propitiating and appeasing God, we entreat constantly and wgendy, day and night, for your peace and salvation. 21. Let oo one, however, flatter himself, be<:ause there is for the present 10 us and 10 the profane, to God's worshippers and to God's opponentS, by reason of the equality of the flesh and body, a common condition of worldly troubles, in such a way as to think from this, that all those things which happen are not drawn down by you; since by the announcement of God Himself, and by propbedc testimony, it has previously been foretold that upon the unjust sbould come the wrath of Gnd, and that perserutions which humanly would hwt us should not be wanting; but, moreover, that vengeance, which should defend with heavenly defence those who were hurt, s hould attend them. 22. And how great, too, are those things which in the meantime are happening in that respect on our behalll Something is given for an example, that the anger of an avenging God may be known. But the day of judgment is still future which the Holy Scripture denounces, saying, "Howl ye, for the day of the Lord Is at hand, and destruction from God shall oome; for, Jo, the day of the Lord oometh, cruel with wrath and anger, to lay the earth desolate, and to destroy the sinners out of iL "" And again: "Behold, !he day of the Lord cometh, burning as an oven; and all the aliens and all that do wickedly shall be as stubble, and the day that cometh shall bum them up, saith the Lord."" The Lord prophesies that the aliens shall be burnt up and consumed; that is, aliens from the divine race, and the profane, !hose who are not spiritually new-horn, nor made children of God. For that !hose only can escape who have been new-horn and signed widl the sign of Christ, God says in anodler place, when, sending forth His angels to the destruction of the world and the death of the human race, He threatens more terribly in !he last time, saying, "Go ye, and smite, and let not your eye spare. Have no pity upon old or young, and slay the virgins and !he little ones and the women, that they may be utterly destroyed. But touch n01 any one upon
130
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 130. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=145 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 46 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Tu.:nss n> D£N~JmANUS
whom is written the mark.• ., Moreover, what this DW"k is, and in what part of the body it is pia~ God sets forth in another place, saying, "Go through the midst of Jerusalem, and set a DW"k upon the foreheads of those that sigh and that ay for all the abominations that be done in the midst thereof..., And that the sisn pertains to the passion and blood of Christ, and that whoevet is found in this sign is kept safe and unharmed, is also proved by God's restlmony, saying, • And the b lood shall be to you for a token upon the houses in which ye shall be; and I will see the blood, and will protect you, and the plague of diminution shall not be upon you when I smile the land of Egypt."" What previously preceded by a figure in the slain lamb is fulfilled in Chris~ the uuth which followed afterwards. As, then, when Egypt was sminen, the Jewish people could not escape except by the blood and the sisn of the lamb; so also, when the world shall begin to be desolated and smitten, whoever is found in the blood and the sign of Christ alone shall escape.>< 23. Look, therefore, while there is time, to the uue and eternal salvation; and since now the end of the world is at band, rum your minds to God, in· the fear of God; nor let that powerless and vain dominion in the world over the just and meek delighl you, since in the field, even among the eultiw.ted and fruitful com, the t2reS and the <Wnel ha~ domln!on. Nor say ye that Ill forrunes happen because your gods are not wot$hipped by us; but know that this is the judgment of God's anger, that He who is not acknowledged on account of His benefits may at least be acknowledged through His judgments. Seek the Lord even late; for long ago, God, forewarning by His prophet, exhons and says, "Seek ye the Lord, and your soul shall Uv~ "" Know God even late; for Christ at His coming admonishes and teaches this, saying, "Thhs is life eternal, that they mighl know Thee, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom Thou has! sent."" Believe Him who deceives not at an. Believe Hlro who foretold that all these things should come to pass. Believe Hlro who will give to an that believe the reward of eternal Ufe. BeUeve Him who will call down on them that believe not, eternal punishments in the ftres of Gebenna. 24. What will then be the glory of faith? What the punishmem of faithlessness? When the day of judgment shall come, what joy ofbelievers, what sorrow of unbelievers; that they should have been unwilling to believe here, and now that they should be W>3b!e to return thllt they
131
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 131. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=146 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 47 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
might believe! An ever-burning Gehenna will' bum up the condemned, and a punishmeru devouring with living flames; nor will !here be :1t1y source whence at any time !hey may have either respite or end to !heir torments. Souls with their bodies will be reserved in infinite tortures for suffering. Thu$the man will be for ever seen by us who here gazed upon us for a season; and !he short joy of !hose auel eyes in !he persecutions !hat they made for us will be compensated by a pe
25. Provide, therefore, wblle you may, for your safety and your life. We offer you the wholesome help of our mind and advice. And because we may not hate, and we please God more by rendering no rerum for wrong. we exhort you wblle you have the power, wblle there yet remains to you something of life, to make satisfaction to God, and to emerge from the abyss of darkling :;uperstition into the bright light of true religion. We do not envy your comforts, nor do we conceal the divine benefits. We repay kindness for your hatred; and for the torments and penalties which are inllicted on us, we point out to you the ways of salvation. Believe and live, and do ye who persecute us in time rejoice
132
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 132. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=147 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 48 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
wilh us for eternity. When you have ooce depaned thither, there is oo longer any place for repentance, and DO possibility of lll$king satisfaction. Here life is either lost or saved; here eternal safety is provided for by the worship or God and the fruits of faith. Nor let any one be rewaioed either by sins or by age from coming to obtain salvation. To the one who still remains in this world oo repentance is too late. Tbe approach to God's mercy is open, and the access is easy to those who seek and apprehend the truth. Do you entteat for your sins, although it be in the very end of life, and at the setting of the sun of time; and implore God, who is the one and true God, in confession and faith of acknowledgment or Him, and pardon is granted to the one who confesses, and saving mercy is given from the divine goodness to the believer, and a passage is opened to immonality even in death itself. This grace Christ bestows; this gift of His mercy He confers upon us, by overcoming death in the trophy of the cross, by redeeming the believer with the price of His blood, by recontiling humanity to God the Father, by quickening our monal nature with a heavenly regeneration. If it be possible, let us all follow Him; let us be registered in His sacrament and sign. He opens to us the way of life; He brings us back to paradise; He leads us on to the kingdom of heaven. Made by Him !he chiJ
Notes Prov. xxili. 9. Prov. lOOi. 4, Mm. vU.6.
Wisdv.I3.
)
Deut '\l'i. 13.
Ex. xxlx. 3.
133
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 133. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=148 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 49 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
]er. xxv. 6.
•
Hag. i.9 .
f
Amoslv. 7.
..
]er. li. 30.
n
jet. V. 3.
11
Hoe. lv. I....(.
".
tsa. llx. I .
••
tsa. a. &
..
lt
b.. lCdi. 20.
n
PlOY. XX. 22.
11
Kab. Hi 17.
"
Isa. xUt 6-9.
•
..
Mal iv. 1.
u
Ezel<. lx. 4.
Ezel<. lx. 5.
Ex. xii. 13.
"
ll!uk. Ill,~; Rev. vU. ,, lx. 4.)
n
A.mosv. 6.
.. "
John xvii. 3.
"'
'IVLSd. v. 1-9.
..... bM. 24.
134
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 134. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=149 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 50 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Aa:. oftbe Oornldl ofNI<¥• (32S, Nk:ea)
The first Ecumenlc31 Council of the Christian Church w.>s convened by !he Emperor Coostantinc iii3Z5, and itS agenda was to a~ss some issues that were dividing the household of faith. Constantine's desire w.>s a united religion in a united Empire. The deleglltes to the Council were bishops, mainly from the eastem pan of the Roman Empire; a number had been victims oi the Great Persecution na so many years before, permanently disabled by torture and the conditions of their imprisonment. The meeting$ were beld at Nicea in Bithynia (now lznik in Turkey), about a hundred kllomecers southwest o f the future cap!W, Constantinople, and quite dose to the then capital, Nioomedia. The politiclting was considerable, but it Is not possible to know exactly how the Council proceeded; there are no records of the debates, and much of the historical evidence that does exist glosses over the disagreements. The outcomes were influenced not only by theological argument but also by the interventions of the Emperor, the interplay of the local interests represented, and personal relationships, among other things. The documents promulgated by the Council were the synodallettet, the creed, and the IWenty canons (laws) presented below. It seems unlikely that there were other acts of the Council,, though conceivably some may have been lost.
The concerns of the Council can be inferred from these documents. Some background may be helpful, however, concerning three specific
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 135. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=150 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 51 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
controVersies: Arianism, the treaunent of the 12psed, and the paschal controversy. Arius was a presbyter in a wealthy parish in Alexandria who, in disagreement with his bishop, asserted that "there was when the Son was not.• He meant that the Son of God. who became incarnate in Jesus Chris~ was not eternal, and therefore must have come into being, and therefore must have been made, and therefore was a crearure, and therefore was not God Controversy flared. Constantine's representatives could not settle the conflict. Perhaps, Constantine thought, a council of b ishops could. During the Decian persecution in 249 and 250, the Church at Rome had been divided between those who wanted to re-admit the lapsed on rebtively lenient tenns, and !hose who did not. The dgourist party went into schism, and consecrated a presbyter named Novatian as lheit own bishop of Rome. Similarly, in Egyp<, during the Great Persecution from 303 to 313, a rigourist bishop named Metitius founded a schismatic chur<:h which refused to recognize lhe aulhority of the more lenient Calholics. The Novatianist and Metitian schisms went onto lhe agenda of Nicea. The paschal controversy was a ctisagreement about wben Easter ought to be celebrated. The chutcbes in Asia Minor, for as long as anyone could remember, had always celebrated Easter on the first day of lhe Jewish Passover, whichever day of the week !hat might be. (That this was the anniversary of the crucifiXion of Christ, not of his resurrection, did not bolher them, since in their view th.e day of the crucifixion was lhe day ofredemption, and therefore the Christian Passove r.) The church in Rome, for as long as anyone could remember, had always lhougbt it more fitting for the Eucharist of Easter to be celebrated on the Lord's Day, Sunday, and therefore commemorated the crucifiXion of Christ on lhe Friday following the Jewish Passover, and Easter on the Sunday. Besides this controVersy on lhe dating of Easter, !here was aoolher. The Jewish date ofPassoverwas dependent on the date oflhespring equinox, but in various parrs of the Empire the date of the spring equinox .•,.as reckoned variously, and therefore the date of Easter was reckoned variously. Constantine lhougbt, and the Council of Nicea agreed, that the Calholic Church should celebrate Easter on a common day. The documents narurally cannot show how effective the Council of Nicea proved to be after it ended. It was certainty nO< very effective in the short run. The Arian controversy continued, and Arianism was
136
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 136. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=151 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 52 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Am OF- c""""'" OF NICU.
supported by some of the Emperoll> who succeeded ~- The Nioene Creed did not ~t loal creeds. The schismatic Novad2n and Melitian churdles survived for de<:ades. Some groups, locluding the Celtic Churclt, which was not represented at N"x:ea, continued to calculate their own date of Easter. The documents of the Council of Nicea were 'lllritten in Greek. They are recorded in letterS of two bishops, Eusebius of Caesarea and Alhanasius, who were in attendance, as well as in early Cbureh histories, in quoouions wilhln the acts of later councils, and elsewhere.
Qaeslloos on tbe reading To whom is the synodal epistle addressed? How does the Council (which bere calls itself "the Synod") undetstand Its own alllhority?Wbat, according to crus epistle, was its agenda? How does it understand its achievement? What appeall> to be the Council's purpose in producing the Nicene Creed? What is its theology? (liow does this creed differ from · what is today often called "the Nicene Creed'?) What might be its sooroes? What errors, scaodals, and disorders are the canons ny1ng to address? What actions does the Council take to corre
Acts of the CoUIICil ofNicea Tbe SyiWilal Bptstle To the holy and great, by the grace of God, the Churclt of Alexandria, and to the beloved brethren who are in Egypt, and Libya, and Peruapolis, Sourceo The Creed and canons of the Council of Niceo, A.D. 32;, in W.A. HaJlllnOfl(!, ed., ~ Deftnili<>ns ofFaUb, and Cotums of I>lscipliM, of rb6 Stx oecumeniCal Councils, o.fO
137
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 137. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=152 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 53 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
the Bishops assembled at Nicaea, and compooing !be great and holy Synod; Health in tbe Lo.rd. Forasmuch as this great and holy Synod has been assembled at Nicza, the grace of God, and our most religious sovereign Constlntine bringing us togedler from different provinces and dtlt$, it has ~ necessary that letters should be sent to you from the whole holy Synod, that you might know what things have been debated, and inquired i.tuo, and also what has been decreed and established. First then, the matters relating to the !mplery and uansgresslon of Arius and his followers have been inquired into by all in the presence of our most religiOus sovereign Constantine; and it has been unatt!mousty decreed, that h!s impious opinion should be anathematized, as well as the blasphemous words which he used, blaspheming tbe Son of God, saying that he had h!s origin from things which did not exis~ and that he had no existence before be was begotten, and that there was a time when be did not exl$t, and that the Son of God is capable by his free will of vice and virtue, and Is created and made. All tht$e tenec:s the holy Synod has anathematized, not enduring so much as to listen to such impious sentimentS, and such madness and blasphemous sayings. As regards however the charges against him, and what has been the result of them, if you have not already fully heard, you shall have a partirular account, that we may not appear to press hardly upon a man who has only received a suitable recompense for his sins. His imp!ery however has prevailed so far as to ruin also Th<:onas of Mannorica, and Secundus of Ptolemals, for they have received the same sentence. The grace of God having thus delivered Egypt from this evil doctrine, and impiery, and blasphemy, and from the persons who have dared to make disorder and division amongst a people heretofore at peace, the matters relating to the insolence of Meletius and of those who have been ordained by him, remained to be settled; and we now infonn you, beloved bretbren, of what has been deereed respecting him by tbe Synod. The holy Synod then, being disposed to deal gently with Meletius, (for according to strict justice be was deserving of no indulgence,) has decreed, that be shall remain in his own city, and shall have no authoriry either to select persons for any ecclesiastical office, or to ordain any one, nor sball appear in any pbce or city for such a pwpose, but shall only
138
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 138. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=153 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 54 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
ACTS OF 711£ CcuNaL ()F NiCtA
enjoy his bare title of honour. That however those who have been appointed by him shal~ after having been conflfiiled by a more holy ordirultion, be admitted to cooununlon upon these tenn.s; viz. that they shaU have both the dignity and the right of officiating, but shall be altogether inferior to those mlnlsters who are enrolled in any parish or Church, and who have been ordained by our mo5t honowable colleague Alexander. That accordingly they shaU have no authority to choose such pei'SOns as please them. or to suggest tbeit names, or to do any thing at all, without the consent of tbe Bishops of the Catholic and Apostolic Church who are under Alexander; but that the authority to select and nominate pe=ns who are 'OIOttby of the Ministry, and in short to do all chings agreeable to the ecdesiastical bws and customs, shaU belong to those Ministers who by the Grace or God and through your prayers have been discovered in no schism, but have continued without spot in the Cadlollc and Apostolic Church. If however it should happen that any of the Mlnl&ers who already belong to the Church should die, then dlose who have been lately received into it shall succeed to the dignity of the deceased, pro\ided they appear worthy, and the people choooe them, and the Bishop of the Catbotic Church of Alexandria agrees to and confirms the nomination. Thus much has been tonceded to the followers of Meletius; but as regards Meletius himself, this Ucente has not been extended to him, on acoount of his former disorderly oondua, and his rash and headstrong disposition; but lt has been decreed that be shall have no power or authority at all, he being a man who is capable of committing again the same disorders. These are the particulars which relate espedally to Egypt, and to the most holy Church of Alexandria; but if any other matters have been established by canon or decree, in the pcesence of our most honourable Lo!d, and colleague, and brother Alexander, he 'Oiill when be comes detaU them more accurately to you, he ha\ing been both Lord, and partaker of those things which have been transacted. We however dedare to you the glad tidings of our agreement respecting our most holy feast of Easter; that by your prayers, this particular also has been rightly settled, so that all the brethren of the East, who formerly kept the feast with the Jews, and did not agree with the Romans, and with you, and with all those who have from the beginning kept it with us, shaU from hencefonh keep it with us.
139
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 139. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=154 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 55 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Rejoicing therefore for these reformations, and for the common peace and agreement, and for the cutting off of every heresy, ~ve ye with greater honour, and "!!re abundant love, our colleague, and your Bishop, Alexander, who gladdened us by his presence, and who has undergone so much labour at such an advanced age for the purpose of settling your alfaits in peace. Pray also for all of us, that the lhings wbich have been decreed may prosper, and be rendered fum by the Almighty God, and our Lord Jesus Christ, having been done as we believe according to the good pleasure o f God the Father, in the Holy Ghost, to whom be glory for ever and ever. Amen. 1l>eN-Crt!M We believe in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things both visible and invisible. And in one Lordjesus Chlist, the Son of God, begotten of the Father, the only begotten, that is of the substance of the Father, God of God, Light of light, very God of very God, begoaen not made, consubstantial with the Father, by whom all lhings were made, both those in heaven and those in earth who for us men, and for our salvadon, came down, and was incarnate, made man. sulfered, and rose aSl'ln the lhird day, ascended into the heavens, and will come to judge the living and the dead And in the Holy Ghost. B\11 those who say that lhere was once a time when he was not, and that he was not before he was begonen, and that he was made out of things which did nO< exist, or who say that he is of another substance or essence, or that the Son of God is created. capable of change, or alteration, the Catholic Church anathematizes.
21>e Canoll.s oftb
140
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 140. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=155 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 56 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
are found worthy, the canon allo'M them to be admitted to the Clerical
office. Since many things have been done by men ei.t her from necessity, or some other pressing cause, conttaty to the canons of the Church, as that persons who have come over to the faith from a heathen life, and have been taught for a sbon time, have been p~dy to the spirlruallaver, and at the same time that they have been baptized, have been promoted to the Episcopate, or Presbytery; it appears rigl1l to detetmine, that nothing of the son shall be done for the future: for some time is neoessaty for the state of a Cated\umen, and a fuller probation after Baptism; for the Apostolic decree is cle2r, which says, 'Not a novice, lest being lifted up with pride be fall into a snare, and the condemnation of the devil." But if in process of time any narural fault should be discovered about the person let him be deposed from the Oergy. Whosoever shall act conttaty to these rules will endanger his own orders, as boldly opposing the great Synod.
m. The great Synod altogether forbids any Bishop, Presbyter, or Deacon, or any one of the Oergy, to have a woman dwelling with him excepting a mother, or sister, or aunt, or such persons only as are above all suspicion. TV. lt is most proper that a Bishop should be constituted by all the Bishops of the Province: but if this be difficult on accounl of some urgent necessity, or the length of the way, that at aU everus three should meet together at the same place, those who are absent also giving their suffrages, and theif consent in writing, and then the ordination be performed. The conllnning however of what is done in each Province, beiongs to the Meu-opotitan of it. V. Concerning those, whether of the Oergy or Laity, who have been excommunicated by the Bishops in the different Provinces, let the sentence of the Canon prevail, which pronounces, that those persons wbo have been cast out by one Bishop are not to be received again into communion by any others. lnquify should h~ever be made whether they have been excommunicated through the peevishness or contentiousness, or other such Uke bitterness, of the B!sbop. And in order that this inquify may be conveniently made, it is decreed to be proper, that Synods should be assembled twice every year in every Province, that all the Bishops of the Province being assembled together,
141
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 141. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=156 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 57 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
such questions may be ex:amine
Aurumn. VI. ~ the ancient C\IStoms be maintained, which are in Egypt and Libya, and Pentapolis, according to which the Bishop of Al=ndri2 bas authority over all !hose places. For!his is also customary to the Bishop of Rome. In like mannerinAntioch, and in the olherProvi.nces, the privileges
are to be preserved to the Churches. But !his is dearly to be understood, !hatif any one be made a Bishop without the oonsent of the Metropotitln, the great Synod declares !hat he shall not be a Bishop. If however two or lhree Bishops shall from private contention oppose the common choice of all the others, it being a reasonable one, and made according to the Ecclesiastial Canons, let the choice of the majority hold good. VII. Since a custom and ancient tradition bas prevailed, that the Bishop of A!lia should be honoured, let him have the second place of honour, saving to !he Meii'Opolis the authority which is due it. VIII. Concerning
142
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 142. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=157 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 58 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Am OF"" C<>lnoot or NICtA
who are called Calbati, sbal1 have the rank ol a Presbyter, unless it sbal1
seem fit to !he Bishop eo allow hlm to partake of the honour of the name. If the Blshop is not pleased to do so. he shall assign hlm !he place of a Choreplscopus or Presbyter, that he may indeed alto~ appear to be in the Clergy, but that there may not be twO Bishops in the city. IX. If any Presbyters have been promoted wirhout inquiry, or lf upon examination they have confessed !heir sins, and notwithstanding !heir having confessed, any man has in opposltlon to the canon laid hands upon !hem, !he canon does not admit persons so o«
if those who ordained them were :~Ware of !he fact, this does not prejudice the eoclesiasti<:al canon; for upon !he circumstance being made known, !hey are deposed. XI. Conceming those who have fallen away without necessity, or without the spoiling of their goods, or without being in danger, or any other such reason, as happened under !he tyranny ofUclnius, the Synod has decreed. tbat although they are undeserving of any ltindoess, they shall nevertheless be dealt with mercifully. As many therefore as shall truly repen~ shall contiitue three years amongst the hearers as believers, and seven amongst the prosuacors, and for two years they shall conununicate with the people in prayer witbouc the offering. XII. Those who have been called by grace, and have at first displ.ayed their ardour, and laid aside their girdles, but afterwards have run like dogs to their own vomi~ (insomuch !hat some have spent money, and by means ol gifts have acquired again their militaty station,) must continue amongst the prostrators for ten years, after having been for three years amongst the hearers. 1.n aU such cases, however,lt is proper to examine into the purpose and appearance of their repentance; for as many as manifest their conversion in deed, and not in appearance ooly, by !heir fear, and tears, and patience, and good 'OIOtks, these having completed the prescribed time as hearers, may properly communicate in the prayers, and the Bishop may be allowed to determine yet more favourably respecting them. But those who bear their sentence with indifference, and think the form of enteting into the Cburcb sufficient for their conversion, muse complete the whole time.
143
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 143. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=158 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 59 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
xru.Conoetnln8 those who are Ukely to die, the old and Canonlc:al law is still to be obs~ that if any one is about to die, be must not be deptived of the pert'ea and most nec=ry provision for his journey. If however after having been given over, and having again received the Communion, be is again restored to health, let him continue amongst those who communicate in pray~ only. But genetally, and as regards every one who Is Ukely to die, and who desires to panake of the Eucharist, the Bishop, after examination, shall lmpatt to him of the offering. XIV. Concerning those who are Calechumens, and who have lapsed, the holy and~~ Synod has de<:teed, that they shaD be only three years amongst the Hearers, and after that shall pray with the Catechumens.
Y:Y. On a.:count of the great d!stulbance and disputes which have occurred, it seems right that the custom which has been admitted in some places cootraty to the Canon, should by all means be done away, and that no Bishop, Presbyter, or Deacon, should remove from one city to another. Bill if any person after the decision of the holy and ~t Synod, shall attempt any such thlng, or allow himself in such a practice, thar which he has attempted shall be made utterly void, and he shaD be restored to the Chwcb in whlch he was otdained Bishop or Presbyter. XVI. If any persons, IaShly and inconsiderately, DO( having the fear of God before their eyes, nor regarding the Canons of the Church, whether they be Presbyters or Deaoons, or any others who are enrolled in the list of the Clergy, shaD remove from their own Church, they ought by no means to be received into any other, but they must be constrained to return to their own parish. or if they continue they must be without communion. And if any Bishop shall dare to usurp what belongs to an(){ber, and to ordain in his Church any such person without the consent of the proper Bishop from whom he has seceded, let the Ordination be void. XVII. Since many persons of the Ecclesiastical order, being led away by covetouSness, and a desire of filthy lucre, have forgotten the Holy Scripture, which says, "he gave not his money to usury," and in leoding require the hundredth part, the holy and ~t Synod considers it right, that if any one after Ibis decision shall be fouod receiv ing money for what he has advanced, or going about the business in any other way, as
144
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 144. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=159 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 60 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Aas OF THB COfJNCIL OF NteBA
by requiting the whole and a half, or using any other device for filthy lucre's sake, be should be deposed from the Clergy, and struck out of the list
xvm. lt has come to the
knowledge of the holy Synod, that in
cenaln places, and cities, the Deacons give the Eucharist to the Presbyters, whereas neither Canon nor custom allows that they wbo have no authority to offer, should give the Body of Christ to those who do offer. lt has also
been made known, that now some of the Deacons receive the Eucharist even before the Bishops. Let all such practices be done away, and let the Deacons keep within their proper bounds, knowing that they are the Ministers of the Bishop, and inferior to the Presbyters. Let them therefore receive the Eucharist according to their order, after the Presbyters, either the Bishop or Presbyter administering it to them. Further, the Deacons are no< to be allowed to sit amongst the Presbyters, for this is done contrary to the Canon and due order. But if any one after this decision will t\0( obey, let him be put out of the Diaconate. }OX Concerning the Paulianists' who have come over to the Catholic Church, the decision is, that they must by all means be baptUed again. But if any of them bave in time past been enrolled amongst the Clergy, if they appear to be blameless and without reproach, after they have been rebaptized, let them be ordained by the Bishop of the Catholic Church. If, however, upon examination they are found to be not qualified, they must be deposed. In like manner as regards the Deaconesses, aod, in short, any who have been enrolled amongst the Clergy, the same fotm is to be observed. And we have mentioned particularly those Deaconesses who are enrolled as far as the dress, since they have not any imposition of bands, they are altogether to be reckoned amongst the laity.
XX. Since there are some persons who kneel on the Lord's day, aod in the days of the Pentecost; in order that all things may be observed in like manner in every parish, the holy Synod has decreed that all should at those times offer up their prayers to God standing.
145
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 145. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=160 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 61 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Notes The Paulia!U$t$ derived !heir name from Paulus Samosatensis, wbo was eleded Bishop of Anlieoh, A.D. 260. The canon ,.,quires !he Paulia!U$t$ to be rebap
146
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 146. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=161 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 62 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Gfesory Nuian%eQ,L
The
Roman
provin~ of Cllppadoci;~, in~ ~enu.l Am Minor, ~ Wll$
centre of Christian theological thought in the third and fourth centuries. How Christianity began there is unknown, but cappadodans were among those who heard Peter's sermon in Jerusalem on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2:9). Among the ~t influential of aD Christian theologians were the three called the cappadocian fathers, Gregoty of Nazianzus, and two brothers, Basil of Caesarea and Gregory of Nyssa. Macrina the Younger, the sister of Basil and Gregory of Nyssa, was repottedly at least as accompli.shed a theologian as her brothers, but whatever she may have written has not survived. The cappadocian synthesis of BibHcal and classical learning, asceticism and culture, Nicene orthodoxy and philosophical vigour, were fonnative in the development of the Eastern Orthodox tradition of Christianity. Gregory of Nazianzus ms bom about 329 into a sociaUy important family. His father was bishop of Nazlanzus in cappadocia, but his mother was the more signlficaru Christian influence on him. He loved literature and study, and pursued his education at Alexandria and Athens, among other places. He was an exceptional orator, teacher, and preacher, but personally he preferred the life of monastic retreat. Against his will he was cornered into ordination in about 361, and then snared into an appointment as bishop of a small cappadocian village in about 371. In
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 147. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=162 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 63 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
379 the tiny Nk:ene Christian community in Constantinople, the capital of the Roma.n Empire, prevailed on him to come to them as their minister. He ha.d to preach in a private house, since .the Arians held all the church buildings. After a new Nlcene emperor, Theodosius, took control of Constantinople at the end of 380, Gregory was finally installed in a church. In 381 he was recognized as bishop of Constantinople, but, v.ith little energy for church politics, he resigned a few days later. He rerumed to look after the church at Nazianzus for two years, and spent most of the rest of his life withdrawn from the world. He died in 389 or 390. He wrote no treatises, only orations, poems, and letters. Of his 245 known letters, the three below proved to be the most imponant theologically. Letter 101 was adopted by lhe E<:umenlcal Council of Cbalcedon in 451. ApoUinaris (315?-392), like the GappadocU.ns, championed the Nicene definition lhat Christ was 11\lly God, but his zeal for that position led him to deny that Christ was fully human. Conflict v.ith the cappadO<:Uins and with lhe other mainstream Nlceans therefore became inevitable. ApoUinaris was born in Laodicea in southwestern Phrygia (near modem Denlzli in Turkey), 18 kilorneters west of Colossae on the Lycus River, in the Roman province of ASill. He WliS ~ man of gte:lt intellectual gifts, strong Christian commitment, pern>nal courage, and political savvy. He maintained his loyalty to the Nicene position even when it was at its most unpopular, and suffered excommunication for his views at the ha.nds of the bishop of Laodicea, who was an Arian. By 363, Apollinaris was expressing the po5ition lhat came to be known as ApoUinamnism. In his view, since Christ was really God, and since God was too holy and perl'ect to be entirely merged into a fallen humanity, Christ could not be fully human. Had Christ really ha.d a human mind, he would ha.ve been infected wilh spirirual weaknesses and the capacity for sin; his wisdom and moral discernment would bave been subject to developmen~ be would ha.ve been •a prey to flilhy thoughts." His huma.n mind and his divine mind would ha.ve been constantly at war. So Christ must ha.ve had, not a human mind, but lhe mind of God. Apollinaris therefore taught that the Logos or Word of God took the place of Christ's hum:an mind. Who, then, was Jesus? He was ooc an amalgamation of divine and human narures, but he was simply of the single narure of God, fused, in the incarnation, with human flesh.
148
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 148. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=163 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 64 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
The details of Apollinaris' position and the arguments he used to suppon it can in some measure be inferred from Nazianzen's letrers below, Nazianzen's hostility and selective quotation notwithstanding. In about 376 Apollirulr!s and his followers separated from the Church, and his position was condemned by a synod in Rome in 377 and by the Ecumenical Council of Constantinople in 381. The Emperor began issuing edicts against his cbutcb in 383, but it continued in Anliocb until 425. Apollinaris' ideas continued to be influential in Alexandria, and survived in some of the churches not in communion witb Rome and Constantinople. Only a handful of his works have survived. The leners below, which Gregocy wrote to a priest or presbyter In Nazianzus named Cledonius, are usually dated to 382 or 383, when Apollinarianism, tbougb condemned, remained active, public, and aggressive. Gregory wrote in Greek.
Questions on the reading What makes Gregocy think that Apollinarianism might be gaining adherents in the Church? What Is at stake in this debate, and what repereussions does Gregocy w6ny there mlgh! be for the Church if Apollinarianism were to prevail? Whom does Gregory address in the tt>ree epistles? What does he understand the doctrine of Apollinarianism to be? What does Gregocy assume will be authoritative evidence and valid method in theology? Do the Apolllnarians, as Gregory represents them, likely share his assumptions? is it possible to judge how fair he is being to the Apollinarians? What are his thoological objections to Apollinarianism? What is his own understanding of the person of Christ, and the relation of Chris~s person to his work of redemption? What do you suppose might be the most important sentence in the entire set of three letters? What are Gregory's theological arguments in favour of his understanding' What is his theology of history?
149
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 149. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=164 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 65 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Epl$tkl01
To Oedmrius agai11st Apo~Jbunoi$ To our most reverend and God-beloved brother and fellow priest Qedonius, Gregory, greeting in the Lord. I desire to learn what is this fashion of imovation in ~concerning the Chun:h, which aDows anyone who likes, or the passer-by, as the Bible says, to tear asunder the flock' that has been well led, and to plunder il by larcenous anacks, or rather by piratical and falladous teachings. For if our presenl assailants bad any ground for condemning us in regard of the faith, it would not have been right for them, even in that case, to have ventured on such a co~me without giving us notice. They ought rather to have first persuaded us, or to have been willing to be persuaded by us (if at least any account is to be r:aken of us as fearing Gcid, laborlng for the faith, and helping the Church), and then, if at all, to innovate; but then perhaps there would be an excuse for their outrageous conduct. But since our faith has been proclaim
The moot grievous part of it is not (though this too is shocking) that the men instill their own heresy Into simpler souls by means of those who are worse; but that they also tell lies about us and say that we share their opinions and serulments; thus baiting their hooks, and by this cloak villainously fulfilling their wlll, and making our slmpUciry, which looked upon them as brothers and not as foes, into a support of their wickedness. And not only so, but they also assert, as I am told, that they have been received by the Western Synod, by which they were fonnetly condemned, as is well known to everyone.lf, however, those who hold the views of Ap011ln2ris have either now or fonnerly been received, let them prove it and we will be contenL For it is evident that they can only have been so received as assenting to the orthodox faith, for this were an impossibility on any other terms. And they can surely prove it, either by the mlnures of Source: Gregory Naziall21JS, ' Letters on the Apollilurian Controversy• (=letter$ 101. 102, 202), in E.R. Hardy, ed, CbriSto/Qgy of lbe Larer FaJbers (library of Chriati>n Ci>$$k$, vol. 3), W~er Press, t9S4, 215-232. Used by permission of Westmins•or John Knox Press.
150
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 150. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=165 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 66 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
tbe synod, or by letters of communion, for this is the regular custom of synods. But If it is mere words, and an Invention of their own, devised for the sake of appearaooes and to giVe them weight with tbe multitude through tbe aedlt of tbe persons. teach them to hold their tongUes, and confute them; fot we believe that such a taSk is well suited to your manner of life and Oltbodoxy. Do not I~ tbe men deceive tbemselves and others with tbe assemon that the "Man of tbe Lord.• as !bey call him, who is rather our Lord and God, is without human mind. For we do not sever the man from the Godhead, but we lay down as a dogma the unity and identity (of person], wbo of old was not man but God, and the only Son before all ages, unmingled with body or anything corporeal; but wbo in these last days has assumed humanity also for our salvation; passible to his flesh, Impassible to his Godhead; citcumscript in the body, uncitcumscript In the Spirit; at once eaJ1hly and heavenly, tangible and intangible, comprehensible and incomprehensible; that by one and the same (Person!, who was perfea human being and also God, the entire humanity fallen through sin might be created anew.
Ifanyone does oot believe that holy Mary is the mother of God, he is severed from the Godhead. If anyone should assert that be passed through lh~ Virgin as through a channel, aod was not at once divinely and humanly formed In her (divinely, because without the intervention of a man; humanly, because in accordance with the Jaws of gestation), he is in like manner godless. If any assert that the humanity was fonned and afterward was dothed with the Godhead, he too is to be condemned. For this were not a generation of God, but a shirking of generation. If any introduce the notion of two sons, one of God the Father, the other of the mother, and discredits the unity and identity, may he lose his part in the adoption promised to those wbo believe aright FOr God and man are two natures, as also soul and body are; but there are not two sons or two gods. For neither in this life are there two personhoods; though Paul speaks in some such language of the inner and outer person.1 And ( if I am to speak concisely) the Saviour is made of (elements) which are distinct from one another (for the invisible is not the same with the visible, nor the timeless '\'>lith that which is subject to time), yet he is not two (persons). God fotbid! For both {natureS) are one by the combination, the deity being made human being, and the humanity deified or bowever one should express it. And I say different (elements). because it is the
151
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 151. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=166 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 67 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
rever.e of what Is the case in the Trinity; for there we acknowledge different [Persons! so as not to confound the Persons; but not different (elements}, for the three are one and the same in Godhead. If any should say that it wrought in him by grace as in a prophet, but let him be empty of the higher energy, or rather fuU of the opposite. If any worship not the Crucified, let him be anathema and be numbered among the deicides. If any assen that he was made perfect by works, or that after his baptism, or after his resurrection from the dead, he was counted wonhy of an adoptive sonship, like those whom the Greeks interpolate as added to the ranks of the gods, let him be anathema. For that whJch has a beginning or a progress or is made perfect is not God, although the expr=ions may be used of his gradual manifestation. If any assen that he has now put off hls holy flesh, and that his Godhead is stripped of the body, and deny that he is now with his body and will come again with ir, let him not see the glory of his coming. For where is his body now, if not with him who assumed it? For it is not laid by in the sun, according to the babble of the Manicbaeaos, that it shooJd be honored by a dishonor; nor was it poured fonh into the air and dissolved. as is the narure of a voice or the flow of an odor, or the coor.e of a lightning flash that never stands. Where in that case were his being handled after the ~urrection, or his being seen hereafter by them that pierced him, for Godhead is in its narure invisible' Nay; he will come with his body- so I have learned - such as he 'ivas seen by his disciples in the Mount, or as he showed himself for a moment, when his Godhead overpowered the camality. And as we say thJs to disann suspicion, so we write the other to correct the novel teaching. If anyone assen that his flesh came down from heaven, and is not from hence, nor of us though above us, let him be anathema. For the words, -rhe se<:<>nd man is the Lord from heaven; and, as is the heavenly, such are they that are heavenly"; and, "No man bath ascended up into heaven save he which came down from heaven, even the Son of Man which is In heaven"'; and the like, are to be understood as said on acoount of the union with the heavenly; just as !hat "All things were made by Christ, • and that "Christ dwelleth in your beans" is said,' not of the visible nature which belongs to God, bur of what is perceived by the mind, the names being mingled like the natures, and flowing into one another, according to the law of their intimate was not and Is not united with him in essence -
union.
152
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 152. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=167 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 68 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
If anyone has put his tru.st in him as a man without a human mind, he is really bereft of mind, and quite unwonby of salvation For that which be has not assumed he has not healed; but lhal which is uolled to his Godhead Is also saved. If only half Adam feU, then lhal which Christ assumes and saves may be half also; but if the whole of his nature feU. it must be uni~ to the whole nature of Him that was begotten, and so be saved as a whole. Let them not. then, begrudge us our complete salvation, or clothe the Saviour only with bones and ~ and !he portl2iture of humanity. For if his humanity is without sou~ even !he Arians admll this, that !hey may attrlbure his Passion to the Godhead. as that which gives motion to !he body is also that which suffers. But if he has soul, and yet is without a mind, how is he a human being. for a human being Is not a mindless anlm21' And this would necessarily involve that while his fonn and tabernacle was human, his soul should be that of a horse or an ox, or some other of !he brute creation. This !hen, would be what he saves; and 1 have been deeelved by !he truth, and led to boast of an bonor which had been beStowed upon another. But ifhis'bwnanity Is inlellectual and not without mind, let them oease to be thus really mindless. But, says such a one, the Godhead took the place of the human l.nteUeet How does this touch me' For Godhead joined ro flesh alone Is not a human being, nor to soul alone, nor to both apart from intellect, which Is the most essential part of a human being. Keep, then, the wbole human being, and mingle Godhead therewith, that you may benefit me in my comp~eness. Bu~ he assens, he could not contain two perfect [naruresl. Not if you only look at him in a bodily fashion. For a bushel measure will not hold two b<Jshels, nor will the space of one body hold two or more bodies. But if you will look at what Is mental and incorporeal, remember that I in my one personality can contain soul and reason and miod and !he Holy Spin~ and before me this world, by which I mean the system of things visible and invisible, contained Father, Son, and Holy Ghosl For such is the nature of intellectual existences, lhal they can mingle with one another and with bodies, incorporeally and invisibly. For many sounds are comprehended by one ear; and the eyes of many are occupied by the same visible objects, and !he smell by odors; nor are the senses narrowed by each other, or crowded out, nor tbe objects of sense diminished by the multirude of the per<:eptions. But where is there mind of human being or angel so perfect in compariSOn of the Godhead
1$3
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 153. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=168 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 69 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
that the presence of the greater must crowd out the other? The llght is nothing compared with a river, that we must first do away with the lesSet, and take the light from a house, or the moisture from the eanh, to enable it to contain the gre;uer and more perlect. For how shaU one thing contain two completenesses, either the house, the sunbeam and the sun, or the earth, the moisrure and the river? Here ls maner for inquiry; for indeed the question is worthy of much consideration. Do they no< know, then. that what is perfect by comparison with one thing may be imperlect by comparison with anocber, as a hill compared with a mountain, or a grain of mustard seed with a bean or any other of the larger seeds, although It may be called larger than any of the same kind? Or, if you like, an angel compared with God, or a human being with an angeL So our mind is perlect and commanding. but only in respect of soul and body; not absolutely perfect; and a servant and a subjea of God, no< a sharer of h1s princedom and honor. So Moses was a god to Pharaoh, but a Servatlt of God, as it is written'; and the stars which illumine the night are hidden by the sun, so much that you could not even know of their exi~nce by dayUght; and a little torch brought near a great blaze is neither destroyed, nor seen, nor extinguished; but is all one bll!ie, me bigger o~W ~over th~ oilier. But, lt may be said, our mind is subject to condemnation. What, then, of our flesh? Is that not subjea to condemnation? You must therefore either set aside the latter on account of sin, or admit the fanner on accou01 of salvation. If he assumed the worse that he might sanctify it by h1s incarnation, may be not assume the beaer that lt may be sanctified by his becoming human? If the clay was leavened and has become a new lump,'O ye wise men, shall not the image be leavened and mingled with God, being deified by his Godhead? And I will add this also, If the mind was uaerly rejected, as prone to sin and subject to damnation, and for this reason he assumed a body but left out the mind, then there is an excuse for them who sin with the mind; for the witness of God according to you - has shown the impossibility of healing it Let me state the greater results. You, my good sir, dishonor my mind (you a Sarcolater (flesh worshipper), if I am ao Anthropolater (person worshipperDtbat you may tie God down to the Oesh, since he canno< be otherwise tied; and therefore you take away the wall of partition. But what is my theory, who am but an ignorant man, and no philosopher?
IS4
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 154. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=169 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 70 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Mind Is mingled with mind, as nearer and more closely related, and through it with Oesh, being a mediator between God and camallty. .Further let us see what ls their accouru of the assumption of humanity, or the assumption of flesh, as they call it. If it was in order that Gocl, otherwise incomprehensible, might be comprehended, and might converse with people through his flesh as through a veil, their mask and the drama which they represent is a preay one, oot to say that it was open to him to converse with us in other ways, as of old, in the burning bush and in the appearance of a man.' But if it was that he might destroy the condemnation by sanctifying like by like, then as he needed flesh for the sake o( the flesh which had incurred condemnation, and soul for the sake of our soul, so, too, he needed mind for the sake of mind, which not only feU in Adam, but was the first to be affected, as the doctors say of Illnesses. For that which received the command was that which failed to keep the command, and that which failed to keep it was that also which dared to transgress; and that which transgressed was that which stOOd most in need of salvation; and that which needed salvation was that which also he took upon him. Therefore, mind was taken upon him. This has now been demonstrated, whether they like it or no, by, to use
their own expte$Sion, geometrlc.1l and nece.swy proofs. But you a.re acting as if, when a man's eye had been injured and his foot had been injured in consequence, you were to attend to the foot and leave the eye uncared for; ot as if, when a painter had drawn something badly, you were to alter the plcrure, but to pass over the att!st as if he had sucoeeded. But if they, overwhelmed by these arguments, take refuge in the proposition that it is possible for God to save humaniry even apan from mind, why, I suppose that it would be possible for him to do so also apan from flesh by a mere act of will, just as he works all other things, and has wrought them "'ithout body. Take away, then, the flesh as well as the mind, that your monstrous folly may be complete. But they are deceived by the letter, and, therefore, they run to the flesh, because they do not know the custom of Scriprure. We will teach thern this also. For what need is there even to mention to those who know it the fact that everywhere in Scriprure he is called •man,• and "the Son of Man'?
If, however, they rely on the passage, "The Word was made flesh and dwelt among us: and because of this erase the noblest part of humanity (as cobblers do the thicker pan of skins) that they may join
155
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 155. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=170 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 71 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
together God and flesh, it is time for them to say that God is God only of flesh, and not of souls, because it is wriaen, •AS thou hast given him power over all flesh,· and, •unto thee shall all flesh come," and, "Let all flesh b less his holy Name; meaning evel)' person.•or, again, they must suppose !hat our fathers went down into Egypt without bodies and invisible, and that only the soul of Joseph was imprisoned by Pharaoh, because it is wrinen, "They went down into Egypt with threescore and fifteen souls," and, "The Iron entered into bls soul,.. a thing which could not be bound. They who argue thus do not know that such expressions are used by synecdoche, declaring the whole by the pan, as when Scripture says that the young ravens call upon God, to indicate the whole feathered race; or Pleiades, Hesperus, and Arctll!US are mentioned, instead of all the SlatS and his providence over them." Moreover, in no other way was it posSible for the love of God toward us to be manifested than by making mention of our flesh, and that for our sake he descended even to our lower pan. For that flesh is less precious than soul, evel)'one who has a spark of sense will acknowledge. And so the passage, "The Word was made flesh," seems to me to be equivalent to that in which it is said that he was made sin, or a cu~U for us: not that the Lord MS transformed lnto either of thesebow could he be? But because by taking them upon him he took away our sins and boxe our iniquities." This, then, iS sufficient to say at the present time for the sake of clearness and of being understood by the many. And I write it, not with any desire to compose a treatise, but only to check the progress of deceit; and if it is thouglu weU, I will give a fuller account of these maners at greater length. But there is a maaer which is graver than these, a special point which it is necess31)' that I should not pass over. I would they were even cut off that trouble you," and w ould reintroduce a second judaism, and a second drcumcision, and a second system of sacrilk:es. For if this be done, what hinders Christ also being born again to set them aside, and again being betrayed by Judas, and crucified and buried, and rising again, that all may be fulfilled in the same order, like the Greek system of cycles, in which the same revolutions of the stars bring round the same events? For what the method of selection Is, in accordance with which some of the events are to occur and others to be omined, let these Wise men who glol)' in the multirude of their books show us.
tS6
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 156. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=171 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 72 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
But since, puffed up by !heir theory of the Trinity, !hey falsely accuse us of being unsound in the faith and entice the multirude, it is necessary !hat people should know that Apollinaris, while granting !he name of Godhead to the Holy Ghost, did not preserve the power of !he Godhead, For to make the Trinity consist of great, greater, and greatest, as of Ught, ray, and sun, the Spirit and the Son and the Fa!her (as is clearly stated in his writings), is a ladder of Godhead not leading to heaven, but down from heaven, But we recogn!u God the Fa!het and the Son and !he Holy GhOSt, and these not as bare titles, dividing inequalities of ranks or of power, but as there is one and the same title, so there is one nature and one substance in the Godhead. But if anyone who thinks we have spoken rightly on this subject reproaches us with holding communion with heretics, let him prove !hat we are open to this charge, and we will either convince him or retire, But it iS not safe to make any innovation before judgment is given, especially in a matter of such importanOe, and connected with so great issues, We have protested and continue to pro<~ this before God and human beings. And not even now, be well assured, should we have written this if we had not seen !hat the Church was being tom asunder and divided, among their other tricks, by their present synagogue of vanity." But if anyone when we say and protest !his, either from some advantage be will thus gain, or through fear of people, or monstrous littleness of mind, or through some negle<:t of pastors and governors, or through love of novelty and proneness to innovations, rejects us as unworthy of credit, and attaches himself to such people, and divides the noble body of the Church, he shall bear his juid, and the grace of their meters, are taken for a third Testament, we too will oompose psalms, and will write much in meter, For we also think we have the spirit of God, if indeed this iS a gift of the Spirit, and not a human novelty, Thls I will that thou declare publicly, that we may not be held responsible, as overlooking such an evil, and as though this wicked doctrine received food and sttength from our indifference,
IS1
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 157. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=172 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 73 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Epistle 102
To aed
accepted but of now repudiating the faith of !heir beloved Vitalius which he handed in in writing at the request of the b lessed bishop Damasus of Rome, 1 will give a short explanotion on this point also. For lhese men, when they are theologizing among their genuine disciples, and those who are initiated into their secrets, like the Manichoeans among those whom they call the "Elect,· expose the full extent of their disease, and scarcely allow flesh at all to lhe Saviour. But when lhey are refuted and pressed with lhe common answers about the incarnation which the Scripture presents, they confess indeed the orthodox words, but they do vio lence to the sens~; for they acknowledge the humanity to be neither
158
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 158. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=173 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 74 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
without soul nor without reason nor without mind, nor imperfect, but they bring in the Godhead to supply the soul and reason and mind. as though it had mingled itself only with his flesh, and not with the other propettles belonging to us human beings; although his slnlessness was far above us, and was the cleansing of our passions. Thus, then, they interpret wrongly the wO
m, He was made man -
explaining it to mean, n01, He was in the
human nature with which he surrounded himself, according to the ScriptUre, "He knew what was l.n man"; but reaching that it means, .H e ·consorted and conversed with people, and taki.n.S refuge in the express loo which says that he was seen on earth and conversed with people.• And what can anyone contend further'! They who take away the humanity and the iorerior image cleanse by their newly invented mask only our outside, 'and that wbicb is seen; so far l.n conflict with themselves that at one time, for the sake of the Oesh, they explain all the rest in a gross and carnal manner (for it is from hence that they have derived their second Judaism and their silly thousand years' delight in paradise, and almost the idea that we shall resume again the same conditions after these same thousand years)"; and at another lime they bring in his flesh as a phantom rather than a reality, as not having been subjected to any of our experiences, nor even such as are free from sin; and use for this purpose the apostolic expression, understood and spoken in a sense which is not apos
159
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 159. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=174 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 75 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Since, then, these expressions, tightly understood, make for orthodoxy, but wroagly inrerpreted are hetetical, wlw is there to be surpdsed at if we received the words of V"ualius in the more Olthodox sense, our desire !bat they should be so mearu persuading us, though others are all8JY at the intention of his writings? This is, I think, the !ea$011 why Danwus bimself, haVing been subsequently better informed, and at the same lime learning that they hold by their former explanations, excommunicated them and oveswmed their written roofession of falth with an anathema; as wen as because be was vexed at the deceit which be had suffered from them through simplicity. Since, then, they have been openly convicted of this, let them not be angry, but let them be ashamed of themselve$; and let them not slander us, but abase themselves and wipe off from their ponals !hat great and masvelous proclamation and boaSl of their ottbodoxy. meeting all who go ill at once with the question and distinction that we must worship, not a God-bearing man. but a flesh-bearing Go
And who will nor ma!Vel at their learning, in that on their own authority they divide the things of Christ, and assign to his humanity such sayings as, he was born, he was tempted, he was hungry, be was rbirsty, he was wearied, be was asleeP'; but reckon to his divinity such as these: be was glorified by angels, be overcame the tempter, be fed the people in the wilderness, and be fed them in such a manner, and be walked upon the sea•; and say on the one hand that the "Where have ye
160
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 160. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=175 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 76 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
laid Lazarusl" belongs to us, but the loud voice "Lazarus, come fonh: and the raising him that bad been four c:bys de.~d,"' is above our ru~rure; and that while "He was in an agony." he was crucif.ed, he was buried," belong to the veil, on the other hand, "He was confiden~ u be rose again, he ascended," belong to the inner treasure; and then they accuse us of Introducing two natures, separate or conflicting, and of dividing the supernatural and wondrous union. They ought either not to do that of which they accuse us or not to accuse us of that which they do; so at least if they are resolved to be consistent and not to propound at once their own and their opponents' prinicples. Such is their want of reason; it conflicts bolh with itself and with the truth to such an extent that they are neither coosdous nor ashamed of it when they fall out with themselves. Now, if anyone thinks that we write all this willingly and not upon compulsion, and that we are dissuading from unity, and not doing our utmost to promote it, let him know that he is very much mistaken, and has not made at all a good guess at our desires, for nothing is or ever has been more valuable in our eyes than peace, as the facts themselves prove; though their actions and brawlings against us altogether exclude unanimity.
Epistle 202 To Nect<Jriu$, Bishop of Constantinople The care of God, which throughout the time before us guarded the Churches, seems to have uuerly fo~aken this present life. And my soul is imm~ed to such a degree by calamities that the private sulferings of my own life haroJy seem to be worth reckoning among evils (though they are so numerous and gte3t, that if they befell anyone else I should think them unbearable); but I can only look at the common sulferings of the churches; for if at the present crisis some pains be not taken to find a remedy for them, things will gradually get into an altogether desperate condition. Those who follow the heresy of Alius or Eudoxlus 0 cannot say who stirred them up to this folly) are making a display of their disease, as if !hey had attained some degree of confidence by collecting congregations as if by pennission. And they of the Macedonian party have reached such a pitch of folly that they are arrogating to themselves
161
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 161. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=176 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 77 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
the name of bishops, and are \Wndering about our districts babbling of Eleusius as to their otdinatlons. Our bosom evil, Eunomius, is no longer contenr With merely existing; but unless he can draw away everyone With him to his ruinous heresy, he thinks hinuelf an injured man. All this, however, is endurable. The most grievous Item of all in the woes of the Chwcll is the boldness of the Apollinarians, whom Your Holiness has overlooked,! know not how, when providing themselves with authority to hold meetings on an equality With myself. However, you being, as you are, thoroughly instructed by the grace of God in the divine mysteries on all points, are well infonned, not only as to the advocacy of the 1rue faith, but also as to all those arguments wbi<:h have been devised by the heretics against the sound faith; and yet perhaps it will not be unseasonable that Your Excellency should hear from my Ualeness that a pamphlet by ApoiUnaris has come into my hands, the contentS of which surpass aU heretical pravity. For he asserts that the flesh which the only-begonen Son assumed in the incarnation for the remodeli.ng of our nature was no new acquisition, but that that 01rnal nature was in the Son from the beginning. And he puts forward as a Witness to this monstrous assertion a garbled quotation from the Gospels, namely, 'No man bath aseended up into heaven save he which 01me down from heaven, even the Son of Man which is in heaven.·• As though even before he came down he was the Son of Man, and wben he 01me down he brought with him that flesh, whicb it appears he had in heaven, as though it bad existed before the ages. and been joined With his essence. For he alleges another saying of an apostle, which he cuts off from the whole body of its context, that the second man is the Lord from heaven.' Then he assumes that that man who came down from above is Without a mind, but that the Godhead of the only-begotten fulftlls the function of mind, and is the third pan of this human composite, inasmuch as soul and body are in it on its human side, but not mind, the place ofwhich is taken by God the Word. This is not yet the most serious pan of it; that whicb is most terrible of all is that he declares that the only-begotten God, the judge of all, the prince of Ufe, the descroyer of death, is mortal, and underwent the Passion in his proper Gndhead; aod that in the three days' death of his body, his Godhead also was put to death with his body, and thus was raised again from the dead by the Father. 1t would be tedious to go through all the other propositions
162
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 162. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=177 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 78 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
wbicb be adds 10 these monsuous absurdities. Now, if they who hold such views have authority to meet, your wisdom approved in Christ must see that, inasmuch as we do not approve tbeir views, any pennission of assembly gtanted to them is nothing less than a declaration that their view is thought more true than ours. For if they are permitted to teach their view as godly men, and with all confidence to preach their doctrine, it is manifest that the doctrine of the Church has been condemned, as though the truth were on their side. For narure does not admit of two conttary doarines on the same subje<:t being both true. How then, could your noble and lofty mind submit to suspend your usual courage in regard to the CO
Notes Eplsde 101 Ps. 81 (80H2. Rom. 7:22; n Cot-. 4:16; Eplt H6.
I Cot-. 15,47, 48;John H3. John 1,$: Eph. $'17. Ex. 7,1, Num. 12,7 (Heb. 36 ) . I Cor. 5,7, mixed with Matt. 13:33. or Luke 1$:21.
Ex. 3:2, and, e.g., Gen., eh. 18 .
•
John 1:14; 17:2; Ps. 65 (~:2; 145 (144):21.
9
Acts 7:14 (Gen. 46;26); Ps. 105 (104):18.
"
Ps.I47(146):9;Job 9:9.
"
John 1:14: U Cor. 5:21; Gal. 3:13; !sa. 53:4, 5 (LXX).
12
Gal. 5:12.
"
Ps. 26 (25):1 (UO().
163
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 163. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=178 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 79 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
Epistle lOZ
!Co<. H6. I CO<. 15:49. Heb. 4:15.
John 2:25; Baruch ~:37.
'
Cl. Mau. 23:25, 26. Cl. p. 222, n. 18. Phil. 2:7,8.
MalL 4:2; U>ke 4:2;John 19:28; 4:6; MaJic 4:38.
wke 2:14 or Mark 1:13; MaJic 6:~5-51 and parallels. ..
John 11:34, 43.
" "
Luke2H4. Cl. Mark 6:50; John 16:33.
Epistle 202 JOhn 3:13. I Cor. 15:47.
'
AS a c=lt of lhls lelter, or $imll~r r<:pre~ntttlon$, a Jaw of 388 (Codex Theodosianus 16.5.14) applied sp<...:iaUy tO Apollinarians the laws previously enacted <~gai""t hen:tics generally.
16<1
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 164. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=179 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 80 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
'il
Ambrose, Utters 20 arut21
(38S. Milan)
~~9
& r < = was b9m in al;>out at Trier in Gaul, the youngest of three children. His family was wealthy and sociaUy imponan~ his father was the praetorian prefect of Gaul. The family was apparently Christian, like a growing mitlority of the Western aristocracy, but Ambrose was not baptized. lt is not that infant baptism was uncommon. Cyprlan, In his Letter 58, had al.'glled passionately against the position that infants should not be baptiZed before the age of eight days, and about the same time Origen had claimed that infant baptism was an apostolic tradition. But it seems that among well-to-do Christians baptism was often deferred untU adulthood, for reasons more guessed than known. No< long after Ambrose was born his father died, and he was raised by his mother and his sister Marcellina, who was ten years older. Marcellina herself was a very committed Christian, and proved sympathetic to an ascetic movement which began around the time that Athanasius, the bishop of Alexandria, was beginning an exile in Rome (339). Living in the house of a well-to-do Christian family, he inspired his hostS and their visitors with stories of the Egyptian asceticS. He even had two Egyptian monks with him. His host's daughter soon committed herself to a lifetime of virginity, and several other daughters of the Roman Christian aristocracy followed her example. In 3;3 Marcel!ina received the virgin's veil from the Pope in a ceremony that Ambr<=
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 165. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=180 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 81 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
attended aod always remembered. She was not, however, a nun living in a religious community according to a Rule; she continued to Uve at home. Later, as a bishop, Ambrose promoted the celibate life and supported the young and still controVersial monastic rnovemenL Ambrose was educated at Rome in rhetoric, philosophy, science, Greek, and jurisprudence, practised law, and, in 370, was appointed consularis (governor) of an area in oorthem ltl!y called Aemilia and Liguria. In Milan, which was the rnosr important city in the region, Niceans and Arians were In sharp conflict, and when the bishop died in 374 and a new bishop needed to be chosen, the baale-lines were drawn. h fracas broke out in the cathedf3! between the riVI>l parties, and Ambrose ~cided that as governor be should intervene. He came to the cathedral and addressed the crowd. Then, according to a contemporary, a child's voice was heard to say, "Ambrose bishop.• Ambrose was a Nlcean, but the idea caught on even among the hrians, and Ambrose was elected. The Emperor, thrilled .that the Niceans and hrians in Mllan had finally agreed on something, released Ambrose from office. In the eight days from November 30 to December 7, 374, Ambr05e was baptized, ordained through the various ecclesiastical orders from lector to presbyter, and co~ted bishop. He donated a Jar~ amount of his wealth to the Church and distributed mostcfthe rest among the poor. and he began a crash course in Scripture and theology. In his preaching Ambrose's classical education in the Latin and Greek writers and his reading In philosophy can often be discerned. He took an interest in liru.rgy, and introduced hymns into his services of worship. He wrote a treatise called On the Du#es ofEcclesiasncswhich set moral and spiritual standards for the clergy. Bur what most distinguished his episcopacy was his outspoken policy of holding emperors accounlllble to the laws and standards of the Church. Here i.s one of the clearest differences which historians have seen between the Church in the western Empire and the Church in the eastern Empire. In the west, from the fourth century through the Middle Ages and down past the Reformation, Church aulhorities grew accustomed to cbalienging the power of the state and ca!Ung emperors, monarchs, and political officials to accounl Eastern bishops, by conrras~ learned to defer to the authority of the state.
166
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 166. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=181 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 82 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
The bishop in Milan was particularly well situated to influence emperors when in 379 Gralian, the young emperor for the western Empire, moved his court to Milan. Ambrose became his teacher, and he influenced him to legislate againSt heretics, to withdraw imperial financing from cenam pagan cultic practices, and to have a pa~n allar removed from the Roman senate. Gralian, however, was murdered in 383. The new emperor, Valentinian, was only eleven ye:us old, and the imperial court in Milan now came under the influence of his mother, the empress Ju.stin2, a supporter of the Arian cause. In 386 a law
large expressive eyes, refined fearures, a black beard and musrache, and an aristocratic bearing. Que$ti<>ns on the readUig
What issue pits the emperor against the bishop? What social circumstances and political dynamics influence events? What is the role of personality? What are the goals and strategies of each side? In Letter 21, what tone does Ambrose rake with the emperor? What is his understanding of the relationship of Church and state? In Letter 20, what Is the clltonology of the events recorded? What leverage does Ambrose
167
Hayes, Alan L.. Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.. Toronto, ON, CAN: Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press, 1998. p 167. http://site.ebrary.com/lib/utoronto/Doc?id=10214794&ppg=182 Copyright © 1998. Canadian Scholars' Press and Women's Press. All rights reserved. May not be reproduced in any form without permission from the publisher, except fair uses permitted under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
http://site.ebrary.com.myaccess.library.utoronto.ca/lib/utoronto…9f12614d84118394d10e100904f4a1eaeb78da16ea4bcd51d42dd7651cb67187
Page 83 of 100
Church and Society in Documents 100-600 A.D.
23/04/2011 11:01
under U.S. or applicable copyright law.
have in this situation? How credible is Ambrose's version of events? In w hat ways might a nanative written b)' the empress differ? What, politically, does Ambrose win in his victory, and what does he lose?
Letter21 To tbe most clemeat Bmpeo M and tbe most bt.!ssed Vallntlialaot Augu.stou, Ambrose, Blsbop (Febrlulry 386) Alleging that he was acting at your command, the tribune and
nowy Dalmatius came to me and asked that I choose judges just as Auxentius has done. Yet he has not .indicated the names of those who have been demanded. But he adds that there will be a discussion in the consistory, and the judgment of your Piety -..ill be the deciding factor. To this I am making, as I think, a SUitable response. No one should find that