CIMA’S Official Study System Managerial Level
Integrated Management David Harris
AMSTERDAM BOSTON HEIDELBERG PARIS SAN DIEGO SAN FRANCISCO
LONDON NEW YORK SINGAPORE SYDNEY
OXFORD TOKYO
CIMA Publishing An imprint of Elsevier Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP 30 Corporate Drive, Burlington, MA 01803 First published 2005 Copyright # 2005, Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing in any medium by electronic means and whether or not transiently or incidentally to some other use of this publication) without the written permission of the copyright holder except in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London, England W1T 4LP. Applications for the copyright holder’s written permission to reproduce any part of this publication should be addressed to the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science and Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone: (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax: (+44) (0) 1865 853333; e-mail:
[email protected]. You may also complete your request on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com), by selecting ‘Customer Support’ and then ‘Obtaining Permissions’
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0 7506 6710 9 For information on all CIMA publications visit our website at www.cimapublishing.com
Important Note A new edition of the CIMA Official Terminology is due to be published in September 2005. As this is past the publication date of this Study System the page reference numbers for ‘Management Accounting Official Terminology’ contained in this Study System are for the 2000 edition. You should ensure that you are familiar with the 2005 CIMA Official Terminology (ISBN: 0 7506 6827 X) once published, available from www.cimapublishing.com
Typeset by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd, Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain
Contents
The CIMA Study System
xv xv xv xvi xvii xviii xxii
Acknowledgements How to use your CIMA Study System Guide to the Icons used within this Text Study technique The Integrated Management Syllabus Transitional arrangements
1 The Nature of Strategic Management 1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
Learning Outcomes What is strategy about? 1.1.1 Some initial definitions 1.1.2 Common themes in strategy 1.1.3 Three elements to strategy 1.1.4 Levels of strategy A model of the rational strategy process 1.2.1 Mission and objectives 1.2.2 Corporate appraisal 1.2.3 Strategic option generation 1.2.4 Strategy evaluation and choice 1.2.5 Strategy implementation 1.2.6 Review and control Approaches to formulating business strategy 1.3.1 A formal top-down strategy process 1.3.2 Benefits of business strategy 1.3.3 Drawbacks of formal business strategy 1.3.4 Strategy and small businesses Alternatives to the rational approach to strategy 1.4.1 Criticisms of the rational model of strategy formulation 1.4.2 Emergent strategies 1.4.3 Logical incrementalism Resource-based versus positioning view of strategy 1.5.1 The source of competitive advantage 1.5.2 Economic profit 1.5.3 Competitive advantage and economic theory 1.5.4 The positioning approach
iii
1 1 1 1 2 2 4 5 6 6 6 6 7 7 7 7 9 9 10 12 12 14 15 17 17 17 18 18
2005.1
CONTENTS
iv
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
1.10
1.11
1.12
1.13
1.5.5 Resource-based theory (RBT) 1.5.6 Some RBT writers 1.5.7 Comments on resource-based views of strategy Stakeholders 1.6.1 The identity of stakeholders 1.6.2 The influence of stakeholders 1.6.3 The Mendelow matrix 1.6.4 Assessing power of stakeholders 1.6.5 Assessing interest of stakeholders 1.6.6 Illustration of the stakeholder matrix 1.6.7 Strategies to deal with stakeholders 1.6.8 Conflict between stakeholders Mission 1.7.1 Terminology 1.7.2 Elements of a mission statement 1.7.3 Roles of mission statements Setting strategic objectives 1.8.1 The link between mission and objectives 1.8.2 The goal structure Critical success factors 1.9.1 Defining critical success factors 1.9.2 Methodology of CSF analysis Meeting the objectives of shareholders 1.10.1 Maximisation of shareholder wealth as an objective 1.10.2 Financial and non-financial objectives Competing objectives 1.11.1 Importance of the existence of competing objectives 1.11.2 Resolving competing objectives Corporate governance 1.12.1 What is corporate governance? 1.12.2 The history of corporate governance 1.12.3 The combined code principles of corporate governance 1.12.4 The benefits of corporate governance Summary Revision Questions
19 19 21 23 23 23 24 24 25 25 25 27 27 27 27 28 29 29 30 31 31 31 32 32 33 33 33 34 35 35 35 38 39 39 43 59
Solutions to Revision Questions
63
Readings
2 Strategy, Structure and Culture 2.1 2.2
2005.1
Learning Outcomes Strategy and structure Organisational structure 2.2.1 Internal structure 2.2.2 Organisational design and contingency theory 2.2.3 Contingency theory
71 71 71 72 73 73 74
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2.4
2.5
2.6
Revision Questions
74 75 76 76 77 78 80 82 84 88 88 88 89 91 94 95 95 96 97 98 99 99 100 101 102 102 103 104 104 104 107 109 110 113 127
Solutions to Revision Questions
131
Readings
3 Contemporary Thinking on Strategy Learning Outcomes 3.1 Trends in the general management and structure of organisations 3.1.1 Changes in the business environment 3.1.2 International structures 3.1.3 Mergers and de-mergers
137 137 137 137 139 139
2005.1
CONTENTS
2.3
2.2.4 Structural characteristics 2.2.5 Strategic choice and the issue of consistency 2.2.6 Entrepreneurial organisation (Figure 2.1) 2.2.7 Functional organisation 2.2.8 Holding companies: ‘federated firms’ and franchises 2.2.9 Divisional organisation 2.2.10 Matrix organisation 2.2.11 Flexible firms, networks and complex organisation forms 2.2.12 Mintzberg’s (1983) structural configurations Organisational culture 2.3.1 The importance of culture in organisations 2.3.2 Determinants of culture 2.3.3 Writers on culture 2.3.4 Models for categorising culture 2.3.5 Culture and control Improving effectiveness 2.4.1 Balancing control with autonomy 2.4.2 Decentralisation 2.4.3 New venturing 2.4.4 Empowerment 2.4.5 Team working 2.4.6 Innovation 2.4.7 Organisational learning and knowledge management 2.4.8 Rosabeth Moss Kanter and entrepreneurship The network organisation 2.5.1 An overview of network organisations 2.5.2 Forms of network relationship 2.5.3 Implications of network organisations 2.5.4 Theoretical basis of network organisations 2.5.5 Transactions cost theory 2.5.6 Transactions cost theory and network organisations 2.5.7 Network organisations and resource-based theory Summary
v
CONTENTS
vi
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
3.2
3.3
3.4 3.5
3.6
3.7
New patterns of employment 3.2.1 The flexible firm 3.2.2 Implications of flexibility for employment 3.2.3 Flexible time arrangements 3.2.4 Homeworking 3.2.5 Core and periphery workers 3.2.6 The knowledge worker 3.2.7 Implications for management accounting 3.2.8 A critical perspective on flexible organisations Competition – Porter’s five forces model 3.3.1 Basic argument of the model 3.3.2 Using the model 3.3.3 Threat of entry 3.3.4 Rivalry among existing competitors 3.3.5 Pressure from substitute products 3.3.6 Bargaining power of buyers 3.3.7 Bargaining power of suppliers 3.3.8 Exercise on confectionery industry 3.3.9 Solution An ecological perspective 3.4.1 Environmental responsibilities Social responsibility 3.5.1 Scope of social responsibility 3.5.2 Must social responsibility conflict with benefiting shareholders? Shareholder wealth and ethics 3.6.1 Nature of ethics 3.6.2 Example of an ethical issue 3.6.3 Friedman: profit is the sole objective 3.6.4 Sternberg: shareholder wealth is natural purpose 3.6.5 A stakeholder view of business ethics 3.6.6 An egoistical view 3.6.7 Implications of ethics for the chartered management accountant Summary Revision Questions
140 140 140 141 141 141 141 142 143 144 144 144 145 146 146 147 147 147 148 148 148 149 149 150 151 151 152 152 152 153 154 154 155 157 169
Solutions to Revision Questions
173
Readings
4 Projects Learning Outcomes 4.1 Definition 4.2 Characteristics of a project 4.3 The project life-cycle 4.3.1 The project life-cycle phases 4.3.2 An alternative project life-cycle – iteration
2005.1
179 179 179 179 180 180 182
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
4.5
4.6 4.7
4.8
182 183 184 184 185 185 185 185 185 188 190 191 191 191 191
Readings
193 211 213
Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
5 People and Projects 5.1 5.2 5.3
5.4
5.5 5.6
5.7 5.8
Learning Outcomes Introduction The roles of the project manager The responsibilities of the project manager 5.3.1 Organisation 5.3.2 Planning 5.3.3 Controlling The skills of the project manager 5.4.1 Leadership skills 5.4.2 Communication skills 5.4.3 Negotiation skills 5.4.4 Delegation skills 5.4.5 Problem-solving skills 5.4.6 Change-management skills Project teams Problems of team-working 5.6.1 Unclear team goals and objectives 5.6.2 Lack of team structure 5.6.3 Lack of definition of roles 5.6.4 Poor leadership 5.6.5 Poor team communication 5.6.6 Lack of commitment Project management and team-building Project stakeholders 5.8.1 Managing stakeholder expectations
215 215 215 215 216 216 217 217 218 218 219 220 220 221 222 222 223 223 223 223 223 224 224 224 224 226
2005.1
CONTENTS
4.4
4.3.3 Project approach 4.3.4 Other frameworks: 4, 5, 7 or 9? The project as a conversion process 4.4.1 Inputs 4.4.2 Constraints 4.4.3 Outputs 4.4.4 Mechanisms Examples of projects 4.5.1 One successful project: ongoing 4.5.2 One not so successful project Why some projects fail Strategy and scope 4.7.1 Strategy 4.7.2 Scope Summary
vii
CONTENTS
viii
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
5.9
Projects and organisation structure 5.9.1 Matrix organisations 5.10 Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
6 The Project Management Process 6.1 6.2 6.3
6.4
6.5
6.6
Learning Outcomes Introduction A definition of project management The project management process 6.3.1 Initiation 6.3.2 Planning 6.3.3 Executing leadership 6.3.4 Controlling 6.3.5 Completing Project planning 6.4.1 Initiation 6.4.2 Detailed project planning 6.4.3 The baseline plan Project objective constraints 6.5.1 Project scope/functionality 6.5.2 Project schedule/time 6.5.3 Project cost 6.5.4 Customer satisfaction/quality Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
7 Identifying and Selecting Projects 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5
2005.1
Learning Outcome Setting project objectives Identifying project proposals Formation of project proposals Setting project requirements The feasibility study 7.5.1 Assessing project feasibility 7.5.2 Technical feasibility 7.5.3 Social and ecological feasibility 7.5.4 Fit with business goals 7.5.5 Financial feasibility
226 227 227 229 247 253 257 257 257 257 258 258 258 258 258 258 258 260 260 264 265 265 265 265 265 266 267 273 277 279 279 279 279 280 280 280 280 281 281 282 282
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
ix
283 283 283 283 283 284 284 285 285 285 285 286 286 287 288 288
CONTENTS
7.6
Types of cost 7.6.1 Capital costs 7.6.2 Revenue costs 7.6.3 Finance costs 7.7 Risk sensitivity 7.8 Financial evaluation techniques 7.9 Risk and uncertainty 7.9.1 Quantitative risk 7.9.2 Socially constructed risk 7.9.3 Qualitative risk 7.9.4 Managing risk 7.9.5 Uncertainty 7.10 SWOT analysis 7.10.1 An example of a SWOT analysis 7.10.2 A contingency plan 7.11 Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
8 Performing the Project 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4
8.5
8.6
8.7
Learning Outcomes Introduction Planning the project Performing the project 8.3.1 An example – development of an information system Monitoring and controlling the project 8.4.1 Making effective control decisions 8.4.2 PRINCE 2 methodology 8.4.3 Other project management methodologies Project closure 8.5.1 Organising project documentation 8.5.2 Collection of receipts and making final payments Post-completion review and audit 8.6.1 Post-project review meetings 8.6.2 Post-completion audit 8.6.3 Justifying the cost of post-completion audit 8.6.4 Continuous improvement Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
289 299 305
313 313 313 313 314 314 315 315 317 317 318 318 319 319 319 319 320 320 321 323 339 343
2005.1
CONTENTS
x
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
9 Project Management Tools 9.1 9.2
9.3 9.4
9.5 9.6 9.7
9.8
Learning Outcome Introduction The planning process 9.2.1 Benefits of planning methods 9.2.2 Communication of project planning Gantt charts Network analysis 9.4.1 Calculation of the EET 9.4.2 Calculation of the LET 9.4.3 Slack or float An alternative method for constructing network diagrams: activity on node Project evaluation and review technique (PERT) Project management (PM) software 9.7.1 PM software functions 9.7.2 Advantages of using PM software 9.7.3 PM software pitfalls Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
10 Management 10.1
10.2 10.3 10.4
10.5
10.6
2005.1
Learning Outcomes Power, authority, responsibility and delegation 10.1.1 Power and authority 10.1.2 Authority as legitimate power 10.1.3 Organisational power 10.1.4 Responsibility 10.1.5 Delegation of authority The characteristics of leaders and managers Personality trait theories of leadership Management styles 10.4.1 Kurt Lewin 10.4.2 Rensis Likert 10.4.3 Tannenbaum and Schmidt 10.4.4 Robert Blake and Jane Mouton Contingency theories of leadership 10.5.1 John Adair action-centred leadership 10.5.2 Fiedler Situational leadership styles 10.6.1 Hersey and Blanchard 10.6.2 Richard Boyd (1987) – transformational leaders
347 347 347 348 348 348 348 349 350 351 352 352 354 354 354 355 356 357 359 365 369 373 373 373 373 373 375 376 376 378 379 380 380 381 382 383 384 384 385 386 386 386
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Classical and contemporary theories of management 10.7.1 Scientific management 10.7.2 The administrative school 10.7.3 Bureaucracy: a culture, process or a form of organisation? 10.7.4 The human relations school 10.7.5 Systems theory 10.7.6 Contingency theory 10.7.7 Peter Drucker: management by objectives (MBO) 10.7.8 Modern perspectives on organisations 10.8 Managing in different cultures 10.8.1 National cultures 10.8.2 Power distance 10.8.3 Uncertainty avoidance 10.8.4 Individualism and collectivism 10.8.5 Masculinity/femininity 10.8.6 Time orientation 10.8.7 Other cultural characteristics 10.8.8 Changing behaviour 10.9 Information gathering 10.9.1 Interviews 10.9.2 Questionnaires 10.9.3 Observation 10.9.4 Other information gathering methods 10.10 Summary Revision Questions
387 387 388 390 391 392 393 395 396 397 397 397 398 398 398 398 398 398 399 399 400 400 401 401 403 411
Solutions to Revision Questions
415
Readings
11 Management of Groups 11.1
11.2 11.3
Learning Outcomes Behaviour in work groups 11.1.1 Informal groups 11.1.2 Formal groups 11.1.3 Formation and development 11.1.4 Integration and organisation 11.1.5 Group dynamics and performance 11.1.6 Formal groups: roles and teams 11.1.7 Team roles – Meredith Belbin (1981) 11.1.8 Vaill (1982): high-performance teams 11.1.9 Problems with groups Communication 11.2.1 Oral and written communication Project meetings 11.3.1 Project status review meetings 11.3.2 Project design review meetings 11.3.3 Project problem-solving meetings
421 421 421 421 421 422 422 423 424 424 425 426 428 428 429 429 429 429
2005.1
CONTENTS
10.7
xi
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
CONTENTS
xii
11.4 11.5 11.6 11.7 11.8
Effective meetings The roles of team members in meetings Problems with meetings Post-project evaluation meeting Project reporting 11.8.1 Project initiation document (PID) 11.8.2 Progress reporting 11.8.3 The final report 11.9 Negotiation 11.9.1 The need for negotiation 11.9.2 Negotiation approaches 11.9.3 The aim of negotiation 11.10 Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
12 Control Systems in Organisations 12.1 12.2 12.3
12.4 12.5
12.6
12.7 12.8
2005.1
Learning Outcomes Objectives of internal control systems Internal control systems Levels of control 12.3.1 Strategic control 12.3.2 Tactical control 12.3.3 Operational control Effective control systems An example of a control system in practice 12.5.1 Strategic level 12.5.2 Tactical level Health and safety 12.6.1 Safety, health and the environment 12.6.2 Safety committee and representatives 12.6.3 Managing safety 12.6.4 Working with contractors 12.6.5 Health and safety training 12.6.6 Managing health 12.6.7 Stress management Dismissal, redundancy and job insecurity 12.7.1 Dismissal Time management 12.8.1 Personal time management 12.8.2 Time management values 12.8.3 Time management action 12.8.4 Time scheduling
430 430 431 433 433 433 434 434 434 434 435 435 435 437 439 443
449 449 449 449 451 451 451 452 452 453 453 453 455 455 456 456 456 457 458 458 460 460 462 462 462 463 463
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Mentoring 12.9.1 Why mentoring? 12.9.2 Benefits of mentoring 12.10 Summary Readings Revision Questions Solutions to Revision Questions
13 Conflict and Discipline 13.1
13.2
13.3
463 463 464 464 465 473 477
Revision Questions
485 485 485 486 486 490 491 494 497 497 497 498 498 500 500 501 502 503 506 509 511 519
Solutions to Revision Questions
523
Learning Outcomes Conflict in organisations 13.1.1 The symptoms of conflict 13.1.2 Forms/sources of conflict 13.1.3 Handling conflict 13.1.4 Resolutions of industrial relations conflict 13.1.5 Managing conflict Discipline 13.2.1 The meaning of discipline 13.2.2 Self-discipline 13.2.3 Disciplinary situations 13.2.4 Taking disciplinary action 13.2.5 Immediacy: Douglas McGregor’s ‘hot stove rule’ 13.2.6 Disciplinary procedures 13.2.7 ACAS code of practice 13.2.8 Grievance procedures 13.2.9 Fairness and commitment in the work place 13.2.10 Diversity and equal opportunities Summary Readings
Preparing for the Examination Revision technique Planning Getting down to work Tips for the final revision phase Format of the examination Structure of the paper Revision questions – mapping grid
529 529 529 530 530 531 531 531
2005.1
CONTENTS
12.9
xiii
CONTENTS
xiv
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
Section Section Section Section Section Section
A type questions B type questions C type questions A solutions B solutions C solutions
Index May 2005 Examination
2005.1
533 535 537 548 549 555 583
The CIMA Study System
Acknowledgements Every effort has been made to contact the holders of copyright material, but if any here have been inadvertently overlooked the publishers will be pleased to make the necessary arrangements at the first opportunity.
How to use your CIMA Study System This Integrated Management Study System has been devised as a resource for students attempting to pass their CIMA exams, and provides:
a detailed explanation of all syllabus areas; extensive ‘practical’ materials, including readings from relevant journals; generous question practice, together with full solutions; an exam preparation section, complete with exam standard questions and solutions.
This Study System has been designed with the needs of home-study and distance-learning candidates in mind. Such students require very full coverage of the syllabus topics, and also the facility to undertake extensive question practice. However, the Study System is also ideal for fully taught courses. The main body of the text is divided into a number of chapters, each of which is organised on the following pattern:
Detailed learning outcomes expected after your studies of the chapter are complete. You should assimilate these before beginning detailed work on the chapter, so that you can appreciate where your studies are leading. Step-by-step topic coverage. This is the heart of each chapter, containing detailed explanatory text supported where appropriate by worked examples and exercises. You should work carefully through this section, ensuring that you understand the material being explained and can tackle the examples and exercises successfully. Remember that in many cases knowledge is cumulative: if you fail to digest earlier material thoroughly, you may struggle to understand later chapters. Readings and activities. Most chapters are illustrated by more practical elements, such as relevant journal articles or other readings, together with comments and questions designed to stimulate discussion. xv
2005.1
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
xvi
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
Question practice. The test of how well you have learned the material is your ability to tackle exam-standard questions. Make a serious attempt at producing your own answers, but at this stage do not be too concerned about attempting the questions in exam conditions. In particular, it is more important to absorb the material thoroughly by completing a full solution than to observe the time limits that would apply in the actual exam. Solutions. Avoid the temptation merely to ‘audit’ the solutions provided. It is an illusion to think that this provides the same benefits as you would gain from a serious attempt of your own. However, if you are struggling to get started on a question you should read the introductory guidance provided at the beginning of the solution, and then make your own attempt before referring back to the full solution.
Having worked through the chapters you are ready to begin your final preparations for the examination. The final section of this CIMA Study System provides you with the guidance you need. It includes the following features:
A brief guide to revision technique. A note on the format of the examination. You should know what to expect when you tackle the real exam, and in particular the number of questions to attempt, which questions are compulsory and which optional, and so on. Guidance on how to tackle the examination itself. A table mapping revision questions to the syllabus learning outcomes allowing you to quickly identify questions by subject area. Revision questions. These are of exam standard and should be tackled in exam conditions, especially as regards the time allocation. Solutions to the revision questions. As before, these indicate the length and the quality of solution that would be expected of a well-prepared candidate.
If you work conscientiously through this CIMA Study System according to the guidelines above you will be giving yourself an excellent chance of exam success. Good luck with your studies!
Guide to the Icons used within this Text Key term or definition Equation to learn Exam tip or topic likely to appear in the exam Exercise Question Solution Comment or Note
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Passing exams is partly a matter of intellectual ability, but however accomplished you are in that respect you can improve your chances significantly by the use of appropriate study and revision techniques. In this section we briefly outline some tips for effective study during the earlier stages of your approach to the exam. Later in the text we mention some techniques that you will find useful at the revision stage.
Planning To begin with, formal planning is essential to get the best return from the time you spend studying. Estimate how much time in total you are going to need for each subject that you face. Remember that you need to allow time for revision as well as for initial study of the material. The amount of notional study time for any subject is the minimum estimated time that students will need to achieve the specified learning outcomes set out earlier in this chapter. This time includes all appropriate learning activities, for example face-to-face tuition, private study, directed home study, learning in the workplace, revision time, etc. You may find it helpful to read Learning to Learn by Sam Malone, CIMA Publishing, ISBN: 1874784434. This book will provide you with proven study techniques. Chapter by chapter it covers the building blocks of successful learning and examination techniques. The notional study time for Managerial level Integrated Management is 200 hours. Note that the standard amount of notional learning hours attributed to one full-time academic year of approximately 30 weeks is 1200 hours. By way of example, the notional study time might be made up as follows: Hours
Face-to-face study: up to Personal study: up to ‘Other’ study – e.g. learning in the workplace, revision, etc.: up to
60 100 40 200
Note that all study and learning-time recommendations should be used only as a guideline and are intended as minimum amounts. The amount of time recommended for face-toface tuition, personal study and/or additional learning will vary according to the type of course undertaken, prior learning of the student, and the pace at which different students learn. Now split your total time requirement over the weeks between now and the examination. This will give you an idea of how much time you need to devote to study each week. Remember to allow for holidays or other periods during which you will not be able to study (e.g. because of seasonal workloads). With your study material before you, decide which chapters you are going to study in each week, and which weeks you will devote to revision and final question practice. Prepare a written schedule summarising the above – and stick to it! The amount of space allocated to a topic in the study material is not a very good guide as to how long it will take you. For example, ‘Summarising and Analysing Data’ has a weight of 25 per cent in the syllabus and this is the best guide as to how long you should spend on it. It occupies 45 per cent of the main body of the text because it includes many tables and charts. 2005.1
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
Study technique
xvii
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
xviii
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
It is essential to know your syllabus. As your course progresses you will become more familiar with how long it takes to cover topics in sufficient depth. Your timetable may need to be adapted to allocate enough time for the whole syllabus.
Tips for effective studying (1) Aim to find a quiet and undisturbed location for your study, and plan as far as possible to use the same period of time each day. Getting into a routine helps to avoid wasting time. Make sure that you have all the materials you need before you begin so as to minimise interruptions. (2) Store all your materials in one place, so that you do not waste time searching for items around the house. If you have to pack everything away after each study period, keep them in a box, or even a suitcase, which will not be disturbed until the next time. (3) Limit distractions. To make the most effective use of your study periods you should be able to apply total concentration, so turn off the TV, set your phones to message mode, and put up your ‘do not disturb’ sign. (4) Your timetable will tell you which topic to study. However, before diving in and becoming engrossed in the finer points, make sure you have an overall picture of all the areas that need to be covered by the end of that session. After an hour, allow yourself a short break and move away from your books. With experience, you will learn to assess the pace you need to work at. You should also allow enough time to read relevant articles from newspapers and journals, which will supplement your knowledge and demonstrate a wider perspective. (5) Work carefully through a chapter, making notes as you go. When you have covered a suitable amount of material, vary the pattern by attempting a practice question. Preparing an answer plan is a good habit to get into, while you are both studying and revising, and also in the examination room. It helps to impose a structure on your solutions, and avoids rambling. When you have finished your attempt, make notes of any mistakes you made, or any areas that you failed to cover or covered only skimpily. (6) Make notes as you study, and discover the techniques that work best for you. Your notes may be in the form of lists, bullet points, diagrams, summaries, ‘mind maps’, or the written word, but remember that you will need to refer back to them at a later date, so they must be intelligible. If you are on a taught course, make sure you highlight any issues you would like to follow up with your lecturer. (7) Organise your paperwork. There are now numerous paper storage systems available to ensure that all your notes, calculations and articles can be effectively filed and easily retrieved later.
The Integrated Management Syllabus Syllabus outline The syllabus comprises: Topic and Study Weighting A The Basis of Strategic Management 30% B Project Management 40% C The Management of Relationships 30%
2005.1
A B
C
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Students should be able to:
identify and apply management techniques necessary for decision-making that cuts across functional areas; analyse data in support of strategic decision-making; contribute to decision-making in these areas by advising management.
Assessment strategy There will be a written examination paper of three hours, with the following sections. Section A – 20 marks A variety of compulsory objective test questions, each worth between 2 and 4 marks. Miniscenarios may be given, to which a group of questions relate. Section B – 30 marks Three compulsory medium answer questions, each worth 10 marks. Short scenarios may be given, to which some or all questions relate. Section C – 50 marks Two questions, from a choice of three, each worth 25 marks. Short scenarios may be given, to which questions relate. Learning Outcomes and Syllabus Content
A – The basis of strategic management – 30% Learning outcomes On completion of their studies students should be able to: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi)
explain the process of strategy formulation; evaluate different organisational structures; discuss concepts in contemporary thinking on strategic management; apply tools for strategic analysis appropriately; explain the purpose and principles of good corporate governance; evaluate competitive situations and apply this knowledge to the organisation.
Syllabus content The process of strategy formulation. The relationship between strategy and organisational structure. The reasons for conflict between the objectives of an organisation, or between the objectives of an organisation and its stakeholders, and the ways to manage this conflict. Strategic decision-making processes.
2005.1
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
Learning aims
xix
xx
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
Approaches to strategy (e.g. rational, adaptive, emergent, evolutionary or system-based views based on Porter, Mintzberg, Bartlett and Ghoshal). Transaction cost view of the firm (e.g. Coase, Williamson) and its implications for organisational structure. Resource-based views of the firm and implications for strategy development. Ecological perspective on the firm. The determinants, importance and role of organisational cultures and ways to improve the effectiveness of an organisation. Introduction to corporate governance, including stakeholders and the role of government. Translating strategy into business (e.g. formation of strategic business units, encouragement of entrepreneurship inside organisations). Contemporary issues in business management (e.g. alliances, demergers, virtual organisations, corporate social responsibility and business ethics).
B – Project management – 40% Learning outcomes On completion of their studies students should be able to: (i) identify a project and its attributes; (ii) apply suitable structures and frameworks to projects to identify common management issues; (iii) produce a basic outline of the process of project management; (iv) identify the characteristics of each phase in the project process; (v) demonstrate the role of key stakeholders in the project; (vi) distinguish the key tools and techniques that would need to be applied in the project process, including the evaluation of proposals; (vii) identify methodologies and systems used by professional project managers; (viii) identify the strategy and scope for a project; (ix) identify stakeholder groups and recommend basic strategies for the management of their perceptions and expectations; (x) produce a basic project plan, recognising the effects of uncertainty and recommending strategies for dealing with this uncertainty, in the context of a simple project; (xi) identify structural and leadership issues that will be faced in managing a project team; (xii) recommend appropriate project control systems; (xiii) evaluate through selected review and audit, the learning outcomes from a project; (xiv) evaluate the process of continuous improvement to projects. Syllabus content The definition of a project, project management, and the contrast with repetitive operations and line management. 4-D and 7-S models to provide an overview of the project process, and the nine key process areas (PMI) to show what happens during each part of the process. Stakeholders (both process and outcome) and their needs. Roles of project sponsors, boards, champions, managers and clients. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Key tools for project managers (e.g. Work Breakdown Structure, network diagrams (Critical Path Analysis), Gantt charts, resource histograms, establishment of gates and milestones). Evaluation of plans for projects. The key processes of PRINCE2 and their implications for project staff. The role of determining trade-offs between key project objectives of time, cost and quality. Managing scope at the outset of a project and providing systems for configuration management/change control. The production of basic plans for time, cost and quality. Scenario planning and buffering to make provision for uncertainty in projects, and the interface with the risk management process. Organisational structures, including the role of the project and matrix organisations, and their impact on project achievement. Teamwork, including recognising the life-cycle of teams, team/group behaviour and selection. Control of time, cost and quality through performance and conformance management systems. Project completion documentation, stakeholder marketing, completion reports and system close-down. The use of post-completion audit and review activities and the justification of their costs.
C – Management of relationships – 30% Learning outcomes On completion of their studies students should be able to: (i) explain the concepts of power, bureaucracy, authority, responsibility, leadership and delegation; (ii) analyse the relationship between managers and their subordinates; (iii) discuss the roles of negotiation and communication in the management process, both within an organisation and with external bodies; (iv) explain how groups form within organisations and how this affects performance; (v) demonstrate personal time management skills; (vi) construct a set of tools for managing individuals, teams and networks, and for managing group conflict; (vii) recommend ways to deal effectively with discipline problems; (viii) explain the process of mentoring junior colleagues; (ix) discuss the importance of national cultures to management style; (x) explain the importance of business ethics and corporate governance to the organisation and its stakeholders; (xi) identify methods of conducting research and gathering data as part of the managerial process. Syllabus content The concepts of power, authority, bureaucracy, leadership, responsibility and delegation and their application to relationship within an organisation and outside it. The characteristics of leaders, managers and entrepreneurs. 2005.1
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
xxi
THE CIMA STUDY SYSTEM
xxii
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT P5
Management-style theories (e.g. Likert, Tannenbaurn and Schmidt, Blake and Mouton). The use of systems of control within the organisation (e.g. employment contracts, performance appraisal, reporting structures). Theories of control within firms and types of organisational structure (e.g. matrix, divisional, network). The advantages and disadvantages of different styles of management. Managing in different countries and cultures. Contingency approaches to management style (e.g. Adair, Fiedler). Theories of group development, behaviour and roles (e.g. Tuckman, Belbin). Disciplinary procedures and their operation, including the form and process of formal disciplinary action and dismissal (e.g. industrial tribunals, arbitration and conciliation). Personal time management. The nature and effect of legal issues affecting work and employment, including the principles of employment law (i.e. relating to health, safety, discrimination, fair treatment, childcare, contracts of employment and working time). The sources of conflict in organisations and the ways in which conflict can be managed to ensure that working relationships are productive and effective. Communication skills (i.e. types of communication tools and their use, as well as the utility and conduct of meetings) and ways of managing communication problems. Negotiation skills. Creativity and idea generation. Information gathering techniques (e.g. interviews, questionnaires). Introduction to corporate governance, including business ethics and the role, obligations and expectations of a manager.
Transitional arrangements Students who have passed the Systems and Project Management paper under the Beyond 2000 syllabus will be given a credit for the Integrated Management paper under the new 2005 syllabus. For further details of transitional arrangements, please contact CIMA directly or visit their website at www.cimaglobal.com.
2005.1
1
The Nature of Strategic Management
L EARNING O UTCOMES By the end of this chapter you should be able to: "
explain the process of strategy formulation;
"
discuss concepts in contemporary thinking on strategic management;
"
apply tools for strategic analysis appropriately;
"
explain the purpose and principles of good corporate governance.
1.1 What is strategy about? 1.1.1 Some initial definitions Consider the following definitions of strategy: 1. Strategy: ‘A course of action, including the specification of resources required, to achieve a specific objective.’ CIMA: Management Accounting: Official Terminology, p. 50. 2. Strategic plan: ‘A statement of long-term goals along with a definition of the strategies and policies which will ensure achievement of these goals.’ CIMA: Management Accounting: Official Terminology, p. 50. 3. ‘The basic characteristics of the match an organisation achieves with its environment is called its strategy.’ Hofer and Schendel (1978, p. 4). 4. ‘Strategy is the direction and scope of an organisation over the long term: which achieves advantage for the organisation through its configuration of resources within a changing environment, to meet the needs of markets and to fulfil stakeholder expectations.’ Johnson and Scholes (1997, p. 10). 5. ‘Corporate strategy is the pattern of major objectives, purposes and goals and essential policies or plans for achieving those goals, stated in such a way as to define what business the company is in or is to be in and the kind of company it is or is to be.’ Andrews, cited in Lynch (2000, p. 8). 1
2005.1
2
STUDY MATERIAL P5
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
6. ‘Corporate strategy is concerned with an organisation’s basic direction for the future: its purpose, its ambitions, its resources and how it interacts with the world in which it operates.’ Lynch (2000, p. 5).
1.1.2 Common themes in strategy Strategy involves the following issues:
It is about the purpose and long-term objectives of the business (definitions 2, 3, 4 and 6). It is concerned with meeting the challenges from the firm’s business environment such as competitors and the changing needs of customers (definitions 3, 4 and 6). It involves using the firm’s resources effectively and building on its strengths to meet environmental challenges (definitions 1, 4 and 6). It is ultimately about delivering value to the people who depend on the firm, its stakeholders, such as customers and shareholders (definition 4).
A case study of strategy The Readings section of this chapter contains an article about the strategy of Abbey National. You should turn to this now.
1.1.3 Three elements to strategy It is possible to perceive of a firm’s strategy as consisting of several different elements (Figure 1.1). Competitive strategy This deals with how the firm competes for business and where its earnings come from. It will involve considerations such as:
how it attracts customers; what it decides to produce or sell; which markets and countries it operates in; how it will win-out against rivals.
For example, Marks & Spencer plc (M&S) traditionally competes on quality, reliability and value. It sells clothes, food, cosmetics, furniture and financial services. Everything
Figure 1.1 2005.1
The elements of strategy
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
3
carries its own brand name that it hopes signifies these brand values to the customer. It operates predominantly in the United Kingdom by selling from shops in the high street and out-of-town malls but is also operating mail order and experimenting with internet shopping. It has attempted expansion into the United States and continental Europe. It seeks to beat rivals by achieving higher margins through using its supply-chain strategy to flexibly deliver the right products at competitive prices. It hopes its brand reputation and wide distribution will give it high volumes and also enable it to charge better prices than other volume outlets or to gain access to higher margin markets such as furniture and financial services.
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Financial strategy This deals with the firm’s relations with its investors and other providers of credit. Clearly management has a major responsibility to meet the wishes of the shareholders of the business. It must also bear in mind the banks and suppliers who are also sources of capital. These issues will be dealt with thoroughly at the Strategic Level, in your Financial Strategy studies. For present purposes we can note that financial strategy deals with considerations such as:
providing an adequate return to shareholders; protecting the value of the shareholders’ investment through avoiding excessive risk; ensuring that the capital structure and range of foreign currency liabilities are appropriate for the needs of the business; obtaining funds in an amount and at a cost and for a duration that meet the needs of the business.
While M&S was pursuing successful competitive strategies its earnings were supportive of its financial strategy. Profits increased year-on-year and investors were prepared to pay a premium price for M&S shares. M&S was seen as a ‘safe bet’ by investors and professional fund managers. They recognised that although M&S was unlikely to deliver the sudden spectacular leaps in profits associated with some other businesses, neither was it likely to disappoint the investors either. This meant that the firm could raise additional capital relatively cheaply by issuing new shares and investors were happy to subscribe to them. Moreover, at dividend time investors were content to allow profits to be reinvested in the business to finance further growth. This again provided funds. Investment and resource strategy This area of strategy concerns how management uses funds retained from profits or otherwise borrowed from investors. Investment and resource strategy covers a wide area and includes:
purchase of land, buildings and other fixed capital equipment; investments in research and development of new products or processes of production; investment in advertising and brand creation and support; the financing of human resource recruitment and development; acquisitions of other businesses; working capital management and inventory.
These provide the resources the firm needs to carry out its competitive strategy. At M&S the funds were used in a variety of ways. Existing stores were always maintained to a high standard by a rolling programme of refitting. New stores in popular 2005.1
4
STUDY MATERIAL P5
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
locations, particularly in out-of-town malls, were opened regularly. Funds were also spent on acquisitions such as the Littlewoods chain. These increased the coverage and floor space of M&S in a way that enabled it to consolidate its position as a major retail force. In its stores staff were well paid and given excellent training, good welfare services and smart uniforms. Elsewhere M&S spent investment funds on developing its own clothes designs and recipes as well as on putting in the information technology infrastructure to support its inventory management systems and its expansion into financial services. A successful business will enjoy a virtuous circle where these three elements work in harmony together. However, if the competitive strategy fails to deliver the customers and earnings necessary the firm faces a vicious spiral of falling share price, inadequate funds and underinvestment.
1.1.4 Levels of strategy Strategy exists at several levels in the organisation. A simplified model of the business organisation is given in Figure 1.2. Corporate strategy The corporate centre is at the apex of the organisation. It is the head office of the firm and will contain the corporate board. A textbook written 20 years ago would have assumed that all competitive strategy was formulated at corporate level and then implemented in a ‘top-down’ manner by instructions to the business divisions. During the 1980s, high-profile corporate planners like IBM, General Motors and Ford ran into difficulties against newer and smaller ‘upstart’ competitors who seemed to be more flexible and entrepreneurial. One consequence was the devolution of responsibility for competitive strategy to business units. Corporate strategy today typically restricts itself to determining the overall purpose and scope of the organisation. Common issues at this level include:
decisions on acquisitions, mergers and sell-offs or closure of business units; conduct of relations with key external stakeholders such as investors, the government and regulatory bodies; decisions to enter new markets or embrace new technologies (sometimes termed diversification strategies);
Figure 1.2 Organisation chart showing corporate, strategic business unit and functional strategies 2005.1
5
development of corporate policies on issues such as public image, employment practices or information systems.
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Business strategy A strategic business unit (SBU) is defined by CIMA as: A section, within a larger organisation, responsible for planning, developing, producing and marketing its own products or services. CIMA: Management Accounting: Official Terminology, p. 39.
Management of the SBU will be responsible for winning customers and beating rivals in its particular market. Consequently it is at this level that competitive strategy is usually formulated. The considerations at this level will include:
marketing issues such as product development, pricing, promotion and distribution; decisions on production technology; staffing decisions.
A business strategy should be formulated within the broad framework of objectives laid down by the corporate centre to ensure that each SBU plays its part. The extent to which the management of the SBU is free to make competitive strategy decisions varies from corporation to corporation and reflects the degree of centralisation in the management culture of the firm. Functional strategies The functional (or sometimes called operational ) level of the organisation refers to main business functions such as sales, production, purchasing, human resources and finance. Functional strategies are the long-term management policies of these functional areas. They are intended to ensure that the functional area plays its part in helping the SBU achieve the goals of its business strategy.
1.2 A model of the rational strategy process Make sure you understand, and can reproduce, this diagram. Figure 1.3 shows a model of the steps which management may take to develop a strategy for their business.
Figure 1.3 A model of a rational strategy process 2005.1
6
STUDY MATERIAL P5
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
1.2.1 Mission and objectives These set the purposes of the organisation to be satisfied by the strategy. A mission is a broad statement of the purposes of the business. It will be open-ended and reflect the core values of the business. A mission will often define the industry that the firm competes in and make comments about its general way of doing business. For example:
British Airways seeks to be ‘the world’s favourite airline’. Nokia speaks of ‘connecting people’. DHL ‘delivers your promises’. easyEverything group wants to ‘paint the world orange’.
Objectives differ from mission because they generally specify quantitative measures of the performance to be achieved and the time frame in which it is to be achieved. For a mobile phone operator these might include goals such as profit and growth but also non-financial targets such as customer service or geographical coverage.
1.2.2 Corporate appraisal During this stage, management assess the ability of the business, following its present strategy, to reach the objectives they have set. They will draw on two sets of information: (a) Information on the current performance and resources position of the business. This will have been gathered in a separate position audit exercise. (b) Information on the present business environment and how this is likely to change over the period of the strategy. This will have been collected by a process of environmental analysis and will include information on: competitors; tastes of customers; state of the economy. This stage is also termed a SWOT analysis, standing for strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats.
1.2.3 Strategic option generation Management seeks to identify alternative courses of action to ensure that the business reaches the objectives they have set. This will be largely a creative process of generating alternatives building on the strengths of the business and allowing it to tackle new products or markets to improve its competitive position.
1.2.4 Strategy evaluation and choice At this point, managements have a number of ideas to improve the competitive position of the business. The evaluation stage considers each strategic option in detail for its feasibility and fit with the mission and circumstances of the business. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
7
By the end of this process management will have decided on a shortlist of options that will be carried forward to the strategy implementation stage.
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
1.2.5 Strategy implementation The strategy sets the broad direction and methods for the business to reach its objectives. However, none of it will happen without more detailed implementation. The strategy implementation stage involves drawing up the detailed plans, policies and programmes necessary to make the strategy happen. It will also involve obtaining the necessary resources and committing them to the strategy. These are commonly called tactical and operational decisions:
Tactical programmes and decisions are medium-term policies designed to implement some of the key elements of the strategy such as developing new products, recruitment or downsising of staff or investing in new production capacity. Project appraisal and project management techniques are valuable at this level. Operational programmes and decisions cover routine day-to-day matters such as meeting particular production, cost and revenue targets. Conventional budgetary control is an important factor in controlling these matters.
1.2.6 Review and control This is a continuous process of reviewing both the implementation and the overall continuing suitability of the strategy. It will consider two aspects:
Does performance of the strategy still put the business on course for reaching its strategic objectives? Are the forecasts of the environment on which the strategy was based still accurate, or have unforeseen threats or opportunities arisen subsequently that might necessitate a reconsideration of the strategy?
1.3 Approaches to formulating business strategy 1.3.1 A formal top-down strategy process Large organisations will formalise the development of business strategies. The following are typical features of the process: 1. A designated team responsible for strategy development. There are several groups of actors in this process: (a) A permanent strategic planning unit reporting to top management and consisting of expert staff collecting business intelligence, advising divisions on formulating strategy and monitoring results. (b) Groups of managers, often the management teams of the SBUs, meeting periodically to monitor the success of the present strategies and to develop new ones. These are sometimes referred to as country weekends because they often take place away from the office to avoid the day-to-day interruptions. 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
8
STUDY MATERIAL P5
2.
3.
4.
5.
(c) Business consultants acting as advisers and facilitators to the process by suggesting models and techniques to assist managers in understanding their business environments and the strategic possibilities open to them. You will be reading about many of these models and techniques later. Formal collection of information for strategy purposes. The management team will call upon data from within and outside the firm to understand the challenges they face and the resources at their disposal. This information can include: (a) Environmental scanning reports compiled by the business intelligence functions within the firm, including such matters as competitor behaviour, market trends and potential changes to laws. (b) Specially commissioned reports on particular markets, products or competitors. (c) Management accounting information on operating costs and performance together with financial forecasts. (d) Research reports from external consultancies on market opportunities and threats. Collective decision-taking by the senior management team. This involves the senior management team working together to develop and agree business strategies. Techniques such as brainstorming ideas on flip charts and using visual graphical models to summarise complex ideas will assist this process. Also, arriving at a decision will involve considerable conflict as particular managers are reluctant to see their favoured proposal rejected and a different strategy adopted. A process of communicating and implementing the business strategy. This can be accomplished using a combination of the following methods: (a) Writing a formal document summarising the main elements of the plan. This will be distributed on a confidential basis to other managers and key investors, but also perhaps to other key stakeholders such as labour representatives, regulatory bodies, major customers and key suppliers. (b) Briefing meetings and presentations to the stakeholders mentioned above. Frequently reporters from the business press will be invited to ensure that the information reaches a broader public. Naturally the fine detail will remain confidential. (c) The development of detailed policies, programmes and budgets based on achieving the goals laid out in the business strategy. (d) The development of performance targets for managers and staff. These ensure that everyone plays their part in the strategy (and perhaps receive financial rewards for doing so). Regular review and control of the strategy. Management will monitor the success of the strategy by receiving regular reports on performance and on environmental changes.
The simple budgetary control systems and monthly variance reports common in management accounting control systems were originally developed to enable managers to control mass production operations. Today the sophisticated competitive strategies of many firms have necessitated the development of more complex performance measurement systems to supplement traditional budgetary control information. These are variously termed enterprise resource management systems and balanced scorecards. There has also been an increased emphasis on competitor and other environmental information to assist managers in steering their businesses. Testing your appreciation of management’s need for non-financial measures and environmental information will be a recurring feature of questions in this examination. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Business strategy formulation obviously uses a lot of organisational resource. What are the benefits? 1. Avoids short-termist behaviour. It ensures that management considers the long-term development of the business rather than focusing solely on short-term results and operational results. This provides the shareholder value referred to in Section 1.3.1 above. 2. Helps identify strategic issues. By encouraging management to consider the business environment in their plans and decisions it will help them keep ahead of change and to be more proactive. 3. Goal congruence. There are many aspects to this: (a) It will help coordinate the different business units, divisions and departments and ensure that they work together to realise the full potential of the corporation. (b) Asset investment decisions will be taken with the long-term needs of the business in mind. This could include design or acquisition of buildings and capital equipment, information systems or acquisitions of other businesses. (c) Tactical programmes will be congruent with the strategy. This might affect the types of staff recruited and developed, the location of production and distribution facilities or the sorts of products and brands created. 4. Improves stakeholder perceptions of the business. If the firm demonstrates that it has a clear idea of where it is going, it enables others to make plans based on its future. This may lead to (a) Higher share price because investors are confident of higher future returns. (b) Attraction and retention of staff and higher morale because employees can see that their career aspirations may be met within the firm. (c) Improved relations with suppliers who feel they can rely on orders in the future. 5. Provides a basis for strategic control. By having a process of formulation and implementation this ensures that: (a) There is someone looking after the development of strategy. (b) There are clear programmes and policies being developed to implement it. (c) There are targets and reports enabling review of the success of the strategy. 6. Develops future management potential and ensures continuity. This relates to the fact that formal strategy formulation is a collective process. This means that: (a) Different functional managers (e.g. finance or marketing) gain an appreciation of the other disciplines of business and so develop into general managers. (b) Providers of information to the strategy process become more deeply involved in the business and develop as a pool of expertise from which the next generation of managers may be recruited. (c) Avoids succession problems when members of senior management retire or move on. The strategy of the firm is understood by all and will outlast the loss of key members of the management team.
1.3.3 Drawbacks of formal business strategy Some writers are critical of the formal process discussed above, because: 1. It is too infrequent to allow the business to be dynamic. This view emphasises the infrequency of the ‘strategy round’, say every 5 years, and the time it takes to achieve any change to the 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
1.3.2 Benefits of business strategy
9
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
10
STUDY MATERIAL P5
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
strategy. If the environment changes unexpectedly, the firm’s performance may deteriorate as it continues to follow a business strategy which has now become inappropriate to its business environment, for example by continuing to make a product no one wants. It forbids the development of radical or innovative strategies. The need to retain consensus among the management team means that radical ideas are too often rejected. Writers who advance this argument remind us of the inherent conservatism of committees and of the fact that some of the success stories of the past few decades such as Microsoft, Intel, Virgin and (at points) Apple and Body Shop have also been firms whose names are associated with radical and visionary entrepreneurs. These business leaders tend to follow the emergent strategy approach discussed in Section 1.4.2. It suffers from difficulties of implementation. The formal process is management-led and seeks to pursue the goals of the business. Successful implementation requires the participation, or at least acquiescence, of middle and junior management together with operative staff. There is a danger that the formal process will not build the support of these people and hence will be misunderstood or resisted. The result will be that the goals of the strategy are not realised. There is loss of entrepreneurial spirit. Entrepreneurs are persons who break rules and make changes to conventional ways of doing business. On the other hand a middle manager in a strategically managed firm will be rewarded for carrying out their allotted part in the strategy and for not breaking the rules. The effect will be to encourage conformity among managers. This will lose the firm potentially successful ventures and perhaps also the services of gifted entrepreneurial managers who may leave in frustration. It is impossible in uncertain business environments. Formal business strategy requires that the strategists are able to make reliable assumptions about the future and particularly about the opportunities and threats facing them. Critics argue that the business environment is now more uncertain than ever before. Because in their view the future cannot be forecast some writers argue that management efforts should be diverted from trying to plan strategies and instead should focus on improving the ability of their businesses to respond and adapt to change. It is too expensive and complicated for small businesses. The manager of a small business is unlikely to be skilled in the techniques needed for developing the kinds of business strategy described above. Moreover the opportunity cost in terms of the time away from direct management of the operational parts of the business are likely to be too great.
1.3.4 Strategy and small businesses According to Birley (1982), the formal process described above may be unsuitable for small businesses for four reasons: 1. Differences in goals. In a small firm the goals of the business are often inseparable from the goals of the owner-manager and immediate family group. Small businesses often do not exhibit the economic rationality and single-minded pursuit of dividends and growth often associated with businesses governed by external shareholders. Birley suggests that small-business goals may pass through a life-cycle from the foundation of the business: (a) Initial desire for independence and a chance to run their own business coupled with a desire for a satisfactory income and lifestyle. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Birley’s observations certainly ring true of many small, family-controlled businesses. However, there are many examples of (initially) small entrepreneurs who have managed to exhibit very different paths of strategic development. For example:
Jeffrey Bezos (Amazon.com) Richard Branson (Virgin Group) Bill Gates (Microsoft Corporation) Stelios Haji-Ioannou (easyGroup – founder of easyJet) Julian Richer (Richer Sounds) Anita Roddick (The Body Shop) Alan Sugar (Amstrad Corporation)
These businesses follow strategies that have been termed variously freewheeling opportunism, proactive management or radical entrepreneurship. One distinguished writer has coined the term ‘The New Alchemists’ to describe them (Handy and Handy, 1999). Increasingly their approaches to strategy have been emulated by the ‘dotcom’ firms of the new e-business world. 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
(b) Mid-life desire to achieve a balance between satisfactory financial returns and a good home life. This means that growth may not be a primary consideration. (c) When approaching retirement, the founder will have a number of possible objectives: to ensure that the business passes to children or loyal employees, regardless of their skills or aptitudes; to find a buyer for the business, often with safeguards for staff. 2. Limited scope of product/market choices. Small-business managers typically consider a much narrower range of strategic options than do their large-business counterparts: (a) Because their business is already narrowly based on the specific trade skills and knowledge of the proprietor. Any new product or market venture will seem very radical. (b) The day-to-day survival of the business will depend on success in this narrow market and management will not want to move too far away from it. (c) Management’s knowledge, skills and horizons will tend to be limited to their current industry. They will not notice wider opportunities. 3. Limited resources. Smaller firms lack the resources to invest in new strategic ventures and rapid growth. Therefore they do not exhibit the sudden strategic leaps envisaged by the rational model: (a) Less capital due to absence of external shareholders. (b) Less managerial resource because proprietor is unwilling to delegate or share control. (c) Smaller current income stream means that any unsuccessful strategic investment may destroy the firm. 4. Organisational structure. Strategic implementation demands the setting up of an appropriate structure and selection of an appropriate team to carry it out. Small firms may not be able to do this due to: (a) Desire by the proprietor to maintain absolute control. (b) Impatience with targets, budgets and other systems that smack of ‘bureaucracy’. (c) Difficulties for other managers to work with founder who may exhibit set ways of thinking and doing business.
11
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
12
STUDY MATERIAL P5
They have particular features in common with one another: 1. They grew in an industry that was already dominated by one or more large corporations. Their success was almost always through exploiting the complacency or errors of the larger corporations. 2. The founder of the business had a particular vision of how they wanted the business to develop, which they stuck to. 3. The products or services they offer tend to be in markets that exhibit spontaneous purchasing behaviour where service and reassurance are important or which have been subject to recent radical changes (or discontinuities) due to emergence of new technologies, tastes or legislative frameworks. 4. They did not rely on conventional financing sources to develop their businesses initially (and several subsequently had unsatisfactory relationships with equity markets). 5. They do not appear to use rational strategy formulation techniques, but rather rely on vision, the skills of the proprietor and a low aversion to risk. 6. The day-to-day involvement of the founder in the detailed running of the business has been critical. This has led to increased criticism of the top-down, rational model and greater interest in bottom-up creative approaches.
1.4 Alternatives to the rational approach to strategy 1.4.1 Criticisms of the rational model of strategy formulation This is likely to be examined quite frequently. Many strategy writers would dispute the model advanced so far by questioning some of the implicit assumptions. They would argue that organisational rationality is merely a textbook assumption from economics, with little basis in the real world. 1. Organisations are incapable of having objectives. This argument is derived from the insight of organisational sociology that organisations are really just collections of people. According to Cyert and March (1963), an organisation does not have goals of its own but rather it is the people within it that have the goals. Notions of profit (or shareholder wealth) maximisation are merely artificially simplified assumptions left over from economics. This leaves us with a picture of the goals pursued by a strategy being in fact the outcome of a bargaining process between various factions around the boardroom table. The consequences of this view are: (a) Objectives may be in conflict with one another. (b) Objectives will change from time to time according to which management faction finds itself in the ascendancy. (c) Objectives are unlikely to be directly related to the economic benefit of the shareholder. (d) Management will inevitably find itself adjudicating between the claims of the various stakeholder groups such as investors, employees, customers and government. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
3.
4.
5.
6.
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
2.
One consequence of this is their adoption of satisficing behaviour where they try to follow strategies aimed at pleasing ‘most of the people most of the time’. (If you consider the way you have to juggle between the elements of your daily life, job, study, home life, leisure, etc., you get the idea of what satisficing means.) A more sophisticated argument is that management will formulate strategy in the light of its beliefs about the status of the firm and the nature of the environment around it. These beliefs are inevitably partially irrational and so any strategy based on them is likewise not completely rational. This is sometimes called an interpretative view of strategy because any attempt to explain a given firm’s strategy must consider the beliefs (or paradigms) in the minds of its management. Senior management should not be the only people involved in setting strategy. Writers argue that by making a separation between strategy formulation and strategy implementation the rational approach is bound to lead to difficulties. In the first place, senior management are too detached and will lack the detailed understanding of the problems of a given business division and the requirements of the particular customers and technologies there. The result will be a strategy that is unlikely to address the division’s needs. Second, and more fundamentally, they will not consider the social processes, values and cultures of the staff in the division or, if considered, these ‘soft’ factors will be misinterpreted. The resulting strategy will have unanticipated harmful effects on the motivation and commitment of those required to implement it. This view favours wider participation in strategy formulation through encouraging emergent strategies to percolate up from below. We shall return to this view in more detail later. In reality, strategy formulation is not a simple step-by step process aimed at finding the best way to meet the firm’s objectives. The model described in Figure 1.3 presents the process as moving in one direction. In reality, strategy formulation is a much more jumbled-up process and can include considerable backtracking and revisiting of earlier stages in the model. Indeed some writers question whether objectives are ever set in advance and suggest that management may revise or set strategic objectives in the light of the corporate appraisal or to match the strategies developed during the strategic option generation stage. Furthermore the strategy formulation process is very political. The main influence on the information considered and the options generated and accepted will be the power of particular personalities and factions in the management team. The strategies that firms eventually follow are not the same as the ones they set out in their plans. At the time of strategy formulation, management suffer from bounded rationality. This means that they cannot have perfect knowledge of the future and so any strategies developed will fail to take into account all eventualities. Consequently, the actual strategy will need to be adapted to suit the circumstances as they unfold. Strategy is not something decided in advance by managers. This view is most famously associated with Mintzberg. He argues that strategy is often recounted by managers long after the event. In this post-rationalisation, they will tend to present all occurrences as intentional action and ignore all the things that happened by chance and those that did not work out. In this view, strategy emerges as a pattern from the piecemeal decisions of management. Another name for this view is adaptive because it sees the organisation as adapting to the circumstances around it. Strategy should not be a rational process. This view is held by writers who are keen to re-establish the role of the individual manager and leadership in determining a firm’s success. The doctrine of action rationality proposed by Brunsson (1985) is a good example of this. Brunsson argues that excessive rationality in decision-making will rob a
13
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
14
STUDY MATERIAL P5
manager of the motivation and commitment necessary to implement the strategy successfully. Instead they will be haunted by doubts that they may have chosen the wrong alternative, aware of some of the inconsistency between objectives and conscious of all the things that might go wrong and the fact that the members of management that disagreed with the strategy are secretly hoping it will go wrong. It is better that managers should select a course of action from a small number of alternatives, focus on just the positive consequences and then formulate objectives based on the likely outcomes of the strategy once it has become established. This is very similar to the ‘ready-fire-aim’ philosophy associated with some successful firms.
1.4.2 Emergent strategies The research of Mintzberg (1987) suggests that few of the strategies followed by firms in the real world are as consciously planned as the rational model suggests. The real strategies of real firms are a long way from ‘mental maps’ designed by a rational process. Instead, they are a combination of the planned strategy and another unanticipated emergent strategy (Figure 1.4). Mintzberg describes emergent strategies as ‘patterns or consistencies realised despite, or in the absence of, intentions’. By this he means us to understand that they just ‘happen along the way’ with differing degrees of management involvement. The failure of intended strategies to be fully realised as deliberate strategies does not surprise Mintzberg. He regards it as unlikely that a firm’s environment can be as totally predictable or totally benign as it would need to be for all intended strategies to work out. The emergent strategy is often a response to unexpected contingencies and the resulting realised strategy may, in the circumstances, be superior to the intended strategy. Mintzberg considers management’s role in this process and suggests that some strategies may be deliberately emergent. By this he means that managers may create the conditions for new ideas to flourish and strategies to emerge. This has the effect of focusing attention on the role of the manager as at the heart of the strategy and reduces the importance of the rational process we have been discussing. According to Mintzberg, the manager should try to ‘craft a vision’ through moulding the organisation and its strategy in the same way as a potter works clay on the wheel, developing it gently and with regard for its own natural characteristics. To do this, a manager must exhibit the following skills:
Manage stability. Managers should be able to master the details of running their business and not feel compelled to constantly rethink the business’s strategic future. As Mintzberg says: ‘ To manage strategy . . . is not so much to promote change as to know when to do so.’
Figure 1.4 2005.1
Mintzberg’s types of strategy
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Detect discontinuity. This is the ability to detect the subtle environmental changes that may affect the business and be able to assess their potential impact on its future performance. Mintzberg states: ‘The trick is to manage within a given strategic orientation most of the time yet be able to pick out the occasional discontinuity that really matters.’ Know the business. Mintzberg believes that the ‘craftsman-manager’ will exhibit a hands-on feel for the business that goes beyond the cold and fragmented analysis available from reports and statistical analysis. He believes that formal strategy systems distance managers from their business and hence ensure that they lack the knowledge they need to run it. Manage patterns. Management should encourage strategic initiatives to grow throughout the business and watch to see how they develop and intervene once this is clear. Mintzberg says: ‘In more complex organisations this may mean building flexible structures, hiring creative people, defining broad umbrella strategies, and watching for the patterns that emerge.’ Reconcile change and continuity. Managers must realise that radical changes and new patterns of strategy will create resistance and instability in the firm. They must keep radical departures in check while preparing the ground for their introduction.
1.4.3 Logical incrementalism Logical incrementalism is the term developed by Lindblom (1959, 1979) to describe how government administrators ‘muddle through’ from year to year rather than carry out bold strategic initiatives. Administrators will avoid radical strategies that take the organisation off in a new direction. Instead they will accept that they cannot foresee the future and survive by muddling through, taking small steps based on what has been done and has worked in the past. Lindblom is not recommending logical incrementalism. Rather he is recording the reality of its existence. As he says, if the environment changes radically (a discontinuity) then logical incrementalism will not respond sufficiently and hence the strategy will drift away from what is required by the environment.
Figure 1.5
Logical incrementalism 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
15
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
16
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Quinn (1978) takes a more positive view of logical incrementalism than Lindblom. For Quinn, a manager must map where he or she wants the organisation to go and then proceed towards it in small steps, being prepared to adapt if the environment changes or if support is not forthcoming. The managerial role functions as a management learning process with the following elements:
The manager sits at the centre of a network of formal and informal communications with staff, customers and others. They will be attuned to the problems and issues confronting the organisation. They may use formal strategy models and techniques to understand these. Once they sense that a need for change has arisen and that events are pushing the firm in a particular direction, they will start to develop a general strategic vision for the organisation. Often they will wait until circumstances have made other managers responsive to ideas for a change to the organisation. Rather than present the strategy full-blown, and risk opposition, the manager will build political support for the ideas by revealing them to key committees or on management retreats. Commitment will be gained to an initial trial of the strategy. This will build further commitment among those charged with making the project a success and erode the consensus in favour of the old way of doing business. This consensus will build and press the strategic change forward incrementally.
The use of formal strategic frameworks is valuable in developing and communicating the changed strategy. This is the logical element in Quinn’s methodology because it ensures that the process leads somewhere. The incrementalism comes from the need to subordinate rapid change to the process of gaining consensus and avoiding resistance (similar to Mintzberg’s ‘Reconcile change and continuity’). Quinn suggests four key roles for the manager in this process: 1. 2. 3. 4.
Improve the quality of information used in key decisions. Overcome personal and political pressures resisting change. Deal with the varying lead times and sequencing of events in the decisions. Build organisational awareness and support for the strategies.
As we can see, Mintzberg and Quinn are essentially making the same point: that strategies are not always planned or revealed in advance and that management skill is crucial. Unlike Lindblom, they do not see this as unacceptably conservative, but see it as realistic. Logical incrementalism has been criticised as potentially being too slow to enable the organisation to cope with rapid changes in its environment. Evaluation of approaches to strategy Much academic research devotes itself to understanding how a business came to pursue a given strategy in the same way as a historian might seek to account for the origins and conduct of a war. Although fascinating, this reflective approach is not the perspective of the syllabus you are following. The syllabus focuses on how strategy may be developed and how as a chartered management accountant you may assist in this process. For this, it is better that we take a rational approach as a basic framework. This said, we should still recognise what 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
1.5 Resource-based versus positioning view of strategy This is likely to be examined quite frequently.
1.5.1 The source of competitive advantage Theorists of business strategy disagree on the origins of competitive advantage. Until the 1990s, most writers took a positioning view; however, more recently, a resource-based perspective has become popular. They may be characterised as follows: 1. Positioning view. Competitive advantage stems from the firm’s position in relation to its competitors, customers or stakeholders. This has broadly been the approach so far of this Study System. It is sometimes called an outside-in view because it is concerned with adapting the organisation to fit its environment. It seems to have grown out of marketing theory. 2. Resource-based view. Competitive advantage stems from some unique asset or competence possessed by the firm. This is an inside-out view of strategy because the firm must go in search of environments that enable it to harness its internal competences. This perspective comes from Economics.
1.5.2 Economic profit Both sets of strategy writers take an economic view of competitive advantage, seeing it as something enabling the firm to generate a superior return on shareholders’ investment through time. Economic profit is essentially the excess of the firm’s earnings over the opportunity costs of the capital it employs. In other words, for an economic profit to be recorded the returns to the shareholder must exceed the rate of return the shareholder could have obtained by investing the same funds in the next best alternative. For example, consider this simple investment situation: Marsh Hall plc has net assets of £520m. Its profits last year were £62.4m. Its direct rival Jevons plc has net assets of £780m and earnings of £70.2m. 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Mintzberg and others have alerted us to, that in the real world strategies can be influenced by irrational factors and that implementation is a crucial step in successful strategies. As Mintzberg has commented, most real-world strategies ‘walk on two feet’, balanced between the rational approach and the emergent approach. As a footnote to the earlier discussion of ‘dotcom’ firms it is worth recalling that during the latter part of 2000 several of the most ambitious examples of such businesses ran into serious financial difficulty and the share prices of the general sector declined sharply. Many business writers put this down to failures by management to develop satisfactory ‘business models’. In other words, the investors had put their money into business ideas that could not make a return for shareholders or which lacked a credible strategy. This could support the view that a more formal approach to strategy brings benefits even in the age of e-commerce and e-business.
17
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
18
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Advise the investors in Marsh Hall plc and Jevons plc on the economic performance of the firms. We need to calculate the economic profit earned by the two firms:
Marsh Hall plc is making a return on net assets of 12 per cent (£62.4/£520). Jevons plc is making a return on net assets of 9 per cent (£70.2/£780). Investors in Marsh Hall are therefore enjoying a positive economic profit of £15.6m, calculated as (12 9%) £520m. In other words, they are £15.6m better off by investing in Marsh Hall than if they had invested in the next-best alternative, Jevons plc. Investors in Jevons are suffering a negative economic profit of £23.4m (i.e. 3 per cent of £780m) because they chose not to invest in Marsh Hall plc.
Investors should switch their investments from Jevons plc to Marsh Hall plc to gain a better return. The effect of this would be to reduce the share price of Jevons and raise the share price of Marsh Hall. The market value of Jevons would fall and the market value of Marsh Hall will rise. In a simple way this illustrates the link between economic profit and shareholder value.
1.5.3 Competitive advantage and economic theory The concept of economic profit is the same as the ‘supernormal profit’ (or ‘economic rent’) enjoyed by the monopolies you studied in Economics for Business at Foundation Level. According to economic theory, supernormal profit arises whenever market power belongs to firms rather than consumers. In the short run, firms in competitive markets can enjoy supernormal profits until competitive entry erodes profits by increasing buyer choice and pushing prices down. However the only firms that can enjoy supernormal profits in the long run are those that have erected barriers to entry. The debate over positioning versus resource-based approaches to strategy also has its origins in economic theory. The two sides disagree on the sources and durability of the competitive advantages that lead to supernormal profits.
1.5.4 The positioning approach The positioning approach to strategy takes the view that supernormal profits result from the following factors:
high market share relative to rivals; differentiated product; low costs.
We will encounter here and in Paper P4 the positioning approach several time in the present text: 1. Porter’s Five Forces theory argues that the long-term return on investment (ROI) of an industry is determined by five forces and so an appropriate strategy for a given firm is to increase its profitability by adopting a strategy that positions it against these forces in the long run better than its rivals. These strategies are the generic strategies of overall cost leadership, differentiation or focus and can be pursued by developing a unique configuration of its value chain or value system. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
The distinctive outside-in perspective of the positioning view consists in its assertion that threats and opportunities are external and that management must mould the organization’s size, structure, culture, skills and products in response to them.
1.5.5 Resource-based theory (RBT) Resource-based theorists make the following criticisms of the positioning view: 1. The competitive advantages are not sustainable. Positioning advantages are short run. These advantages are too easily copied in the long run by rivals or will lose their power as the product life-cycle enters its decline phase. Therefore, superior long-run profitability cannot be explained or assured by possession of a world-beating product, a dominant market position or low-cost position. According to RBT writers (e.g. Barney, 1991), superior profitability instead depends on the firm’s possession of unique resources or abilities that cannot easily be duplicated by rivals. 2. Environments are too dynamic to enable positioning to be effective. Positioning depends on the customer group, buyers, suppliers, rivals, etc., to remain the same long enough for the firm to mount an effective response. However, faster product life-cycles, the impact of IT, global competition and rapidly changing technologies make this impossible. RBT writers (e.g. Stalk et al., 1992) argue that superior competitive performance depends on developing business processes and structures that enable it to spot changing needs of customers immediately and to develop commercially viable responses quickly. 3. It is easier to change the environment than it is to change the firm. Some RBT writers (e.g. Hamel and Prahalad, 1994; Kay, 1997) are suspicious of the positioning school’s implied belief in a ‘rubber organisation’, i.e. one that can have its size and shape changed at will to fit the environment. They argue that such organisational changes are likely to destroy the complex organisational architectures on which the firm’s present and future success depends. It is better to retain these architectures as a unique competitive resource and to leverage them to take the firm into industries where they are valued.
1.5.6 Some RBT writers Stalk et al. (1992) suggest four principles of capabilities-based competition: 1. The building blocks of corporate strategy are business processes not products and markets. 2. Competitive success depends on the ability to transform these processes into strategic capabilities able to provide superior value to the customer. 3. Creating these capabilities requires group-wide investments that transcend traditional functional or business unit boundaries.
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
2. Stakeholder theory suggests that the long-term competitive success of a firm will depend on its developing a sustainable relationship with the key stakeholders on whom it depends for resources, custom and permission to operate.
19
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
20
STUDY MATERIAL P5
4. Therefore the champion of capabilities-based strategy is the chief executive officer (CEO). Superior competitive performance will result from the firm using these competences to outperform rivals on five dimensions: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Speed: more able to incorporate new ideas and technologies into its products. Consistency: all its innovations satisfy the customer. Acuity: ability to see its environment clearly and forecast changing needs. Agility: able to adapt on many fronts simultaneously. Innovativeness: able to generate and combine business ideas in novel ways.
Barney (1991) argues that superior profitability depends on the firm’s possession of unique resources. He identifies four criteria for such resources: 1. Valuable: they must be able to exploit opportunities or neutralise threats in the firm’s environment. Here Barney is accepting the view of resources taken in the SWOT model. However, the point he is making is that it is not enough just to have valuable resources. 2. Rare: competitors must not have them too, otherwise they cannot be a source of relative advantage. 3. Imperfectly imitable: competitors must not be able to obtain them. Generally this will result from them having come into the firm’s possession by a unique historical event (e.g. ability to point to a long history in the business or perhaps past purchase of a unique piece of land), or because they are hard to understand and duplicate if you are an outside competitor (e.g. a particular organisational culture or relationship with stakeholder groups). 4. Substitutability: it must not be possible for a rival to find a substitute for this resource (e.g. not in the way that Microsoft used CD technology to substitute for the sales network, payments systems, printing and logisitics of Encyclopedia Britannica when it launched Encarta). Kay (1997) writes of ‘distinctive capabilities’ arising from four sources: 1. Competitive architecture: These are the relationships that make up the organisation. These can be divided into: (a) internal architecture: relations with employees; (b) external architecture: relations with suppliers and customers; (c) network architecture: relations between a group of collaborating firms. These deliver distinctive capabilities that are greater than the sum of the parts in three ways: (a) through the creation of unique organisational knowledge, which arises from collaboration and interaction; (b) through establishing a cooperative ethic among the participants; (c) by implementing organisational routines. Kay uses the examples of successful football clubs like Liverpool and Manchester United. He suggests that their football league performance is due to the networks they have built with youth clubs and their expenditure on recruiting players, their detailed analysis of other clubs’ games, a cooperative spirit that enables players to pass the 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Prahalad and Hamel (1990) describe ‘core competence’ as ‘the collective learning in the organisation, especially how to coordinate diverse production skills and integrate multiple streams of technologies’. They propose three tests to identify a core competence: 1. Must provide access to a wide variety of markets. This is sometimes called the extendability condition. 2. Must provide a significant contribution to the perceived customer benefits of the final product. 3. Must be difficult for competitors to imitate. The authors cite as examples Honda’s skill with small reliable high-output petrol engines (cars, motorcycles, lawnmowers); Sony’s skills in miniaturisation (radios, televisions, CD players, personal stereos, laptops) and 3M’s skills in coatings (cassette and video tape, Post-It-Notes, photographic film, abrasive papers). These skills enabled the firms to deliver premium profits across and through diverse environments. They argue that core competences can be destroyed by failure to invest in them. They share with Stalk et al. (1992) the view that excessive focus on functional or SBU divisions can cause harm, and describe two concepts of the corporation (Table 1.1). Close inspection of Table 1.1 suggests that Prahalad and Hamel’s formulation carries profound implications for the management accounting function. Management accounting is traditionally built on a responsibility centre model, whereas the view of the authors (and of several of the other RBT writers) is that the object of control should be competences and processes rather than business units and divisions. This issue will be returned to in detail in the next chapter.
1.5.7 Comments on resource-based views of strategy Resource-based theory raises a number of issues: 1. Conflict with conventional product/market-based views of strategy. The notion of core competences spreads beyond the ability of the firm to compete just in particular markets 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
ball rather than waste chances with lone shots at goal and deeply embedded routines of play. 2. Reputation: This is the high esteem that the public have for the firm. Among customers it is a reason to buy the product and to remain loyal, while for investors, suppliers and potential employees it is a reason to become involved and give exceptional levels of support to the firm. Kay argues that reputation must be built and maintained over time and requires detailed attention to all aspects of the firm’s products, procedures and processes. He uses the examples of car hire and accountancy services to demonstrate that reputation drives up margins. 3. Innovative ability: This is the ability to develop new products, services or solutions. These stave off competitors and enable the firm to enjoy the high margins of early life-cycle markets. Innovation frequently demands collaboration among staff and with suppliers and customers. Consequently it builds on the architectures of the firm. 4. Ownership of strategic assets: This is close to the barriers to entry discussed in traditional economic theories of monopoly. The firm may have a unique source of materials or possess exclusive legal rights to a market or invention. Kay observes that these generally occur in markets with strong government involvement (e.g. medicines, defence equipment, etc.) and profits may be limited by government action too.
21
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
22
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Table 1.1
Two concepts of the corporation (adapted from Prahalad and Hamel, 1990) SBU
Core competence
Basis for competition
Competitiveness of today’s products
Corporate structure
Portfolio of businesses related in product – market terms Autonomy is sacrosanct; the SBU ‘owns’ all resources other than cash Discrete businesses are the unit of analysis; capital is allocated business by business Optimising corporate returns through capital allocation trade-offs among businesses
Inter-firm competition to build competences Portfolio of competences, core products and businesses SBU is potential reservoir of core competences Businesses and competences are the unit of analysis: top management allocates capital and talent Enunciating strategic architecture and building competences to secure the future
Status of the business unit Resource allocation
Value added by top management
and industries. Yet many of the models we have used, such as the Porter models and the product life-cycle, tend to discuss particular products and markets and develop strategic prescriptions for them. This leads to two possibilities: (a) By using techniques that focus on products and markets individually we may develop strategies which deplete the firm’s wider core competences (e.g. by deciding to withdraw from a market or to cut costs by outsourcing a crucial source of organisational learning). (b) Even where a firm is involved in a range of industries and has a unique core competence across them all, it is no guarantee of competitive advantage against more focused players in each market (e.g. in the 1980s, IBM had a unique global architecture, reputation and ownership of proprietary technology. This did not stop it being beaten into second or third place by focused rivals in each of its sub-industries of software development, consulting, PCs and mainframe systems). 2. Challenges the rational model of strategy. The RBT view seems to argue that strategy should not be a process of deciding a product/market mission and competing in markets by establishing what the customer wants and exploiting the weaknesses of rivals. Instead it suggests that strategy involves deciding what makes the firm unique and building strategy on that, extending into any products or markets where it will work. The impacts of this are: (a) RBT strategy starts with the corporate appraisal not with the mission of the business. Indeed, the mission must adapt to fit the most recent extension of core competence. (b) There is a much higher emphasis on finding an environment to match the firm rather than vice versa (management seems to be saying ‘all we have is a hammer so our markets are anything that involves hitting things’). This reasoning could lead to very diverse strategies or perhaps a complete drying-up of strategic avenues (as they run out of things to hit). (c) Investors cannot be clear what industry they are investing in. This may increase perceived risk and hence destroy shareholder value by reducing the share price. 3. RBT can lead to different conclusions. The basis of RBT is the suggestion that the firm should retain any unique strategic assets it has, outsource the remainder, and focus on building up relationships with internal and external stakeholders to develop its internal 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
teamworking; collaboration with suppliers and customers; flexible working practices; creation of participative culture.
However, an alternative conclusion might be that unique knowledge is too valuable to risk losing in networks that could easily be ‘burgled’ by rivals through enticing contract staff and suppliers/customers to defect. This might encourage management to deliberately keep knowledge under close control by bringing production in-house, putting staff on restrictive long-term contracts and segmenting trade secrets on a ‘need-to-know’ basis.
1.6 Stakeholders This is likely to be examined quite frequently.
1.6.1 The identity of stakeholders Stakeholders are defined by CIMA as ‘Groups or individuals having a legitimate interest in the activities of an organisation . . . .’ (Management Accounting: Official Terminology, p. 18). They include:
shareholders and other investors; management; staff and organised labour; customers; suppliers; local community; national governments.
The first three items are sometimes called internal stakeholders, while the remainder are external stakeholders.
1.6.2 The influence of stakeholders Present strategic thinking encourages managers to consider stakeholders when setting the mission and objectives of the firm. This is for two broad groups of reasons: 1. Issues of stakeholder power. This view observes that, like it or not, management must recognise that stakeholders can affect the success of a strategy, depending on whether they support or oppose it. For example, customers refusing to buy products, shareholders selling their shares or staff striking would disrupt any strategy. The view concludes that management should consider stakeholders before setting strategic objectives. 2. Issues of organisational legitimacy. This more radical view suggests that firms are required to be good citizens because they are only permitted to exist by society on sufferance of not abusing their power. Consequently, although working primarily for the 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
knowledge to improve performance and innovation. Consequently, it fits well with modern concepts in network organisation management such as:
23
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
24
STUDY MATERIAL P5
shareholders, management must ensure that its decisions do not ignore the interests of other stakeholders.
1.6.3 The Mendelow matrix Make sure that you can draw and apply this model. Mendelow (1991) proposed a diagram to help analyse stakeholders (Figure 1.6). Scholes (1998) suggests that this technique can be used in two situations: 1. To keep a track of changes in the potential influence of different stakeholder groups. By plotting the matrix periodically, management can be alerted to when a strategy may need to change to accommodate (or avoid a threat from) particular stakeholders. 2. To assess the impact of a particular strategic development on stakeholders. For example, managers proposing a factory closure could use mapping to identify where opposition to closure may come from and how it might be managed (e.g. by shifting redundant workers from quadrant D to C or B through generous pay-offs and thus reducing the votes for a strike).
1.6.4 Assessing power of stakeholders Factors that may be associated with a particular group having high power are: 1. Status of the stakeholders, for example: their place in the organisational hierarchy; their relative pay; their reputation in the firm; their social standing (e.g. ministers of religion may carry considerable power due to their social status). 2. Claim on resources, for example: size of their budget; number and level of staff employed; volume of business transacted with them (e.g. suppliers and customers); percentage of workers they speak for (e.g. a trade union).
Figure 1.6 2005.1
Mendelow’s power–interest matrix
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
1.6.5 Assessing interest of stakeholders This will be more complex because it involves two factors: 1. Where their interests rest. We assume that powerful stakeholders will pursue their selfinterest. It is important to consider what they wish to achieve. It is possible to make some generalisations, for example: managers – want to further the interests of their departments and functions as well as their own pay and careers; employees – require higher pay, job security, good working conditions and some consultation; customers – want fair prices, reliable supply and reassurance about their purchases; suppliers – want fair prices, reliable orders, prompt payment and advance notification of changes; local government – wants jobs, contribution to local community life, consultation on expansions, etc. In practice, we would need to interview the powerful stakeholders to find out precisely what they wanted. 2. How interested they are. Not all stakeholders have the time or inclination to follow management’s decisions closely. Again, some generalisations are possible about what will lead to interest, for example: high personal financial or career investment in what the business does; absence of alternative (e.g. alternative job, customer, supplier or employer); potential to be called to account for failing to monitor (e.g. local councils or government bodies such as regulators); high social impact of firm (e.g. well known, visible product, association with particular issues).
1.6.6 Illustration of the stakeholder matrix An illustration of Mendelow’s matrix appears in Figure 1.7. It takes up the idea of a factory closure mentioned earlier (Section 1.6.3) and suggests where management could classify the stakeholder factions and how it might deal with them.
1.6.7 Strategies to deal with stakeholders The purpose is to consider what the matrix will need to look like for the strategy to be a success and then to develop strategies to align the actual matrix with the ideal matrix. In the example in Figure 1.7, the key concerns where alignment is poor are:
the the the the
negative attitudes of skilled labour, key managers and national suppliers; ambivalent attitude of shareholders and customers; potentially negative interventions of national media and central government; possible search for power from local council and media. 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
3. Formal representation in decision-making processes: level of management where they are represented; committees they have representation on; legal rights (e.g. shareholders, planning authorities).
25
STUDY MATERIAL P5
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
26
Figure 1.7
Illustration of Mendelow’s matrix applied to Dyson
Scholes (1998) suggests the following strategies to deal with each quadrant:
Box A – direction. This means their lack of interest and power makes them malleable. They are more likely than others to accept what they are told and follow instructions. Factory management should not reappoint the casual staff but rather provide limited redundancy support. There is no need to tell the small shareholders or customers. Box B – education/communication. The positively disposed groups from this quadrant may lobby others to support the strategy. Also if the strategy is presented as rational or inevitable to the dissenters, or a show of consultation gone through, this may stop them joining forces with more powerful dissenters in C and D. Factory management should brief all groups here on the reasonableness of the case for closure and of the provisions being made for the redundant staff. Advance notice will give each more time for adjustment. Box C – intervention. The key here is to keep the occupants satisfied to avoid them gaining interest and shifting into D. Usually, this is done by reassuring them of the likely outcomes of the strategy well in advance. Factory managers should assure the government and suppliers that the closure will result in a more competitive firm that is able to compete worldwide. A similar message may reassure investors if it is backed up with a reassuring short-term dividend forecast. Box D – participation. These stakeholders can be major drivers of the change and major opponents of the strategy. Initially, there should be education/communication to assure them that the change is necessary, followed by discussion of how to implement it. The factory managers should involve the unions in determining the redundancy package or redundancy policy. Key managers should be involved in deciding the basis on which early retirements should be handled and how redeployment or outplacement should be managed. Key shareholders will be consulted throughout to reassure them that costs will not be excessive.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
The objectives of the stakeholder groups will inevitably be different and may be in direct conflict. For example, the staff’s desire for better pay and work conditions may conflict with the shareholders’ desire for higher profits and the customers’ desire for lower prices. The job of management is to develop and implement strategy with these differences in mind. This can be further complicated in organisations where the employees are also shareholders! Additionally, there will be differences between the goals of members of the same internal stakeholder group. Two examples are particularly important: 1. Differences between shareholders. This commonly manifests itself as a polarisation between those who broadly require their income as short-term dividends and those who are happy for profits to be retained to promote capital growth. 2. Differences between managers. The goals of managers and the departments they lead may conflict. Consequently, many strategic objectives are the outcome of a political bargaining process at boardroom level.
1.7 Mission 1.7.1 Terminology Johnson and Scholes provide the following useful guide to the terminology we shall be using in this section:
Term
Definition
Personal example
Mission
Overriding purpose in line with the values and expectations of stakeholders Desired future state: the aspiration of the organisation General statement of aim or purpose Long-term direction
Be healthy and fit
Vision or strategic intent Goal Strategies
Objective
Quantification (if possible) or more precise statement of the goal
To run the London marathon Lose weight and strengthen muscle Associate with a collaborative network (e.g. join a running club), exercise regularly, compete in marathons, stick to appropriate diet Lose 10 pounds by 1 September and run the marathon in 18 months time
Adapted from Johnson and Scholes (1997 p. 13).
1.7.2 Elements of a mission statement Although there is no standard format for mission statements, most seem to contain the following four key elements. (The following mission statements were taken from the British Airways website in late 1999. It refers to the mission it established in 1997. It will be used here to illustrate the elements in mission statements.) 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
1.6.8 Conflict between stakeholders
27
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
28
STUDY MATERIAL P5
British Airways mission statement The new mission To be the undisputed leader in world travel The new values Safe and Secure Honest and Responsible Innovative and Team-spirited Global and Caring A Good Neighbour The new goals Customers’ Choice – Airline of first choice in key markets Strong Profitability – Meeting investors’ expectations and securing the future Truly Global – Global network, global outlook: recognised everywhere for superior value in world travel Inspired People – Building on success and delighting customers 1. A statement of the purpose of the business. According to conventional economic theories of the firm, this will be to make profit (or shareholder value). For British Airways it is the second of its three goals. The appearance of customers, community and environment in mission statements raises the question of whether satisfying the shareholder is (or indeed should be) still the principal goal of strategic management. 2. A statement of its scope or industrial domain. This is conventionally described as its products and markets. British Airways alludes to creating a global travel network of which airlines seem to be only a part. 3. A statement of its competitive strategy or positioning. British Airways emphasises the way it is viewed by its customers, in particular its superior value and truly global nature. 4. A statement of its principles, ways of doing business and social responsibilities. British Airways communicates this under its values.
1.7.3 Roles of mission statements Research conducted among companies by Hooley et al. (1992) revealed the following purposes of mission statements: 1. To provide a basis for consistent planning decisions. 2. To assist in translating purposes and direction into objectives suitable for assessment and control. 3. To provide a consistent purpose between different interest groups connected to the organisation. 4. To establish organisational goals and ethics. 5. To improve understanding and support from key groups outside the organisation. Mission statements help at four places in the rational model of strategy: 1. Mission and objectives. The mission sets the long-term framework and trajectory for the business. It is the job of the strategy to progress the firm towards this mission over the coming few years covered by the strategy. For example, whatever British Airways decides to do, it must be concerned with delivering customer and financial value in the global travel business. Discussing opportunities for opening a chain of burger bars in London would not be appropriate because it is not British Airways’ business. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
1.8 Setting strategic objectives 1.8.1 The link between mission and objectives A mission is an open-ended statement of the firm’s purposes and strategies. Strategic objectives translate the mission into strategic milestones for the business strategy to reach. A strategic objective will possess four characteristics which set it apart from a mission statement:
a precise formulation of the attribute sought; an index or measure for progress towards the attribute; a target to be achieved; a time-frame in which it is to be achieved. Another way of putting this is to say that objectives must be SMART, that is,
Specific – unambiguous in what is to be achieved; Measurable – specified as a quantity; Attainable – within reach; Relevant – appropriate to the group or individual to whom it is applied; Time-bound – with a completion date. Table 1.2 lists some strategic objectives.
Table 1.2
Examples of strategic objectives
Mission
Attributes
Measure
Growth
Sales volume Share of market Asset base of firm
0 000s of units % of total volume Net assets
Quality
Customer satisfaction Defects Consistency
Repeat purchases No. per 0 000 Adoption of standard procedures
Innovation
Peer group respect Speed to market Successful new products
Industry awards received Development time % of sales from new products
Social responsibility
Non-discrimination Environmental pollution Safety
Workforce composition Cubic metres of waste Notified incidents
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
2. Corporate appraisal. Assessing the firm’s opportunities and threats, its strengths and its weaknesses must be related to its ability to compete in its chosen business domain. Factors are relevant only insofar as they affect its ability to follow its mission. 3. Strategic evaluation. When deciding between alternative strategic options, management can use the mission as a touchstone or benchmark against which to judge their suitability. The crucial question will be, ‘does the strategy help us along the road to being the kind of business we want to be?’ 4. Review and control. The key targets of the divisions and functions should be related to the mission, otherwise the mission will not be accomplished. For British Airways, this implies objectives for customer service and supplier relations in addition to budgetary control.
29
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
30
STUDY MATERIAL P5
1.8.2 The goal structure The goal structure is the hierarchy of objectives in the organisation. It can be visualised as the diagram in Figure 1.8. Objectives perform five functions: 1. Planning. Objectives provide the framework for planning. They are the targets which the plan is supposed to reach. 2. Responsibility. Objectives are given to the managers of divisions, departments and operations. This communicates to them: (a) the activities, projects or areas they are responsible for; (b) the sorts of output required; (c) the level of outputs required. 3. Integration. Objectives are how senior management coordinate the firm. Provided that the objectives handed down are internally consistent, this should ensure goal congruence between managers of the various divisions of the business. 4. Motivation. Management will be motivated to reach their objectives in order to impress their superiors and perhaps receive bonuses. This means that the objectives set must cover all areas of the mission. For example, if the objectives emphasise purely financial outcomes, then managers will not pay much heed to issues such as social responsibility or innovation. 5. Evaluation. Senior management control the business by evaluating the performance of the managers responsible for each of its divisions. For example, by setting the manager a target ROI and monitoring it, senior management ensure that the business division makes a suitable return on its assets. You may be familiar with these five functions (often recalled using the acronym PRIME) from your studies in budgetary control. Budget targets are a good example of operational level objectives. In this chapter, however, we are working at a higher level by considering the strategic objectives of the firm.
Figure 1.8 2005.1
A goal structure
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
1.9.1 Defining critical success factors This approach first emerged as an approach for linking information systems strategy to broader commercial goals by first identifying the crucial elements of the firm’s business strategy. More recently it has been appropriated by strategists in general as an alternative to the goal structure approach described above. According to its originators, critical success factors (CSFs) are: ‘The limited number of areas in which results, if they are satisfactory, will enable successful competitive performance’ (Rockart and Hoffman, 1992). More recently, Johnson and Scholes (1997) have defined CSFs as: . . . those components of strategy where the organisation must excel to outperform competition. These are underpinned by competences which ensure this success. A critical success factor analysis can be used as a basis for preparing resource plans.
The attraction of the approach lies in the fact that it provides a methodology for identifying strategic goals (or CSFs) by basing them on the strengths, or core competences, of the firm. These are implemented though the development of key performance indicators (KPIs) or milestones in the processes delivering the CSFs (Figure 1.9).
1.9.2 Methodology of CSF analysis According to Johnson and Scholes, this is a six-step process. We have illustrated them here using the example of a chain of fashion clothing stores. 1. Identify the critical success factors for the specific strategy. They recommend keeping the list of CSFs to six or less. The store chain might decide that these are: right store locations; good brand image; correct and fashionable lines of stock; friendly fashionable store atmosphere. 2. Identify the underpinning competences essential to gaining competitive advantage in each of the CSFs. This will involve a thorough investigation of the activities, skills and
Figure 1.9 Critical success factors and key performance indicators
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
1.9 Critical success factors
31
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
32
STUDY MATERIAL P5
3.
4.
5.
6.
processes that deliver superior performance of each. Taking just one of the store’s CSFs, the issue of correct stock, as an example: recruit and retain buyers with acute fashion sense; just-in-time purchasing arrangements with clothing manufacturers; proprietary designs of fabrics and clothes; close monitoring of shop sales by item to detect trends in which items are successful and which are not; swift replenishment delivery service to minimise amount of stock in the system. Ensure that the list of competences is sufficient to give competitive advantage. The store needs to consider whether improvement to the systems and processes underlying its CSFs will be sufficient to secure its place in the high street or whether more needs to be done. For example, have they considered whether they need to develop a direct ordering facility to raise profile and gain loyalty? Identify performance standards that need to be achieved to outperform rivals. These are sometimes termed key performance indicators and will form the basis of a performance measurement and control system to implement and review the strategy. KPIs that the clothing store chain might consider to match its key processes (listed above) include: staff turnover among buyers and designers; lead times on orders from suppliers; percentage of successful stock lines designed in-house; installation of a real-time store sales information system by the end of the year; establishment of one-day order turnaround for store replenishment. Ensure that competitors will not be able to imitate or better the firm’s performance of each activity, otherwise it will not be the basis of a secure competitive strategy. Our store would compare its competences against Gap, Miss Selfridge, Next, River Island, etc. It would need to consider whether its present advantages are sustainable. Monitor competitors and predict the likely impact of their moves in terms of their impact on these CSFs. This process is carried out principally by discussions between management, although there is a clear additional role for the special expertise of the chartered management accountant in mapping the key process, developing KPIs and monitoring them.
1.10 Meeting the objectives of shareholders 1.10.1 Maximisation of shareholder wealth as an objective Traditional economic theory specifies that the objective of the firm is to maximise profit. However, this assumption does not accurately reflect the goals of the shareholder for a number of reasons: 1. It is a single-period measure (typically annual). The shareholder wants financial returns across many years. 2. It ignores risk. Shareholders will require higher returns if risks are higher but will be satisfied with lower returns if risks are low. 3. It confuses profit with cash flows to the investor. The investor wants cash flows not a figure for profit on the income statement. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
1.10.2 Financial and non-financial objectives Traditionally, the shareholders’ objectives have been translated into financial objectives such as profit or profitability (e.g. return on capital employed or earnings per share). These accounting measures have several drawbacks when used as strategic targets:
They are not useful for start-up businesses. During their first few years many firms do not make a profit or return a positive cash flow due to the high costs of set-up and getting established in the market. Profitability measures are better suited to mature businesses. They are inherently short-termist. Because profit is an annual measure it encourages management to focus on short-term returns at the expense of the long-term development of the business. Hence, managers may decide to cut product development, promotion or staff development to improve profit performance at the expense of the long term. They provide no control over strategic behaviour. The profit figure is a financial summary of the effects of a year’s economic activity. The competitive strategy of the firm will seek to do business in particular ways in order to make this profit. This strategy should also feature in the goal structure. They can be manipulated by creative accounting. Consequently, the strategic targets of firms usually contain a mixture of financial and non-financial measures of performance. These ensure that: managers follow courses of action consistent with the competitive strategy; shareholders and others can form an opinion of the success of the firm’s strategy even when financial results are low; the strategic objectives can be more easily translated into tactical and operational objectives for divisions and processes without an immediately discernible impact on profits (e.g. human resources, marketing, etc.)
The debate on the primacy of financial targets widens when we recognise the impact of other stakeholders and the issues of corporate social responsibility.
1.11 Competing objectives 1.11.1 Importance of the existence of competing objectives It has been shown that profit-seeking, not-for-profit and public sector organisations may have competing objectives arising from:
conflicts between profit and social responsibilities; differences in the goals of particular managers; conflicts between the goals of influential stakeholder groups. 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
As you will learn in Financial Strategy, a more appropriate version of rational shareholder objectives is either (a) maximisation of the present value of the free cash flows of the business, or (b) maximisation of the share price.
33
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
34
STUDY MATERIAL P5
This has important implications in the following areas: 1. Development of consistent strategies. If the organisation does not have clear objectives, or if its objectives are in conflict with one another, then it will not be able to follow consistent courses of action. For example, a firm that seeks to satisfy objectives for shortterm dividends while also pursuing long-term growth will eventually be forced to sacrifice one or other due to lack of funds. 2. Deciding between strategic options. Options are evaluated against the objectives of the business before management agree to devote resources. However, if one option provides a good financial return while another provides jobs in an area of high unemployment, a firm with both financial and social responsibility objectives will not be able to choose. 3. Development of appropriate performance measures. The more objectives an organisation has, the more control measures it will need to monitor performance towards them. If the objectives are competing there is a danger of conflicting signals or, worse, excessive focus on one at the expense of the rest. For example, a school will have many objectives such as producing good citizens, ensuring emotional development, catering for special needs, etc. However, parents and government prefer to have a single measure to decide whether a school is performing well or badly and tend to focus on examination results. This immediately distorts behaviour in the school towards exam results at the expense of other equally worthy objectives.
1.11.2 Resolving competing objectives There are various techniques available: 1. Prioritisation. Management can specify that any strategy considered must as a minimum satisfy one or more specific objectives before they are prepared to consider it. For example, management may set a minimum profitability threshold for any strategy (say 15 per cent return on investment). Once this is assured they turn their attention to achieving it in a more socially responsible way. 2. Weighting and scoring. Each objective is weighted according to its relative importance to the organisation (a high weight denoting high importance). Each strategic option is scored according to how well its satisfies the objective (a high score showing high attainment). A ranking is calculated for each option by multiplying its weighting by its score, and the strategic option with the highest overall ranking is accepted. 3. Creation of composite measures. These are used for strategy implementation and control rather than for strategy formulation and choice. Approaches include the use of balanced scorecard measures and techniques of data envelopment analysis (DEA). DEA is used to assess performance of a group of branches or divisions (e.g. a group of schools, hospitals or universities), where each has the same set of multiple objectives to achieve. Data is fed into a sophisticated computer program which identifies for each objective the best performer among the group. It calculates the comparative performance of the remaining branches against this ‘best in class’ branch. It can also give an overall performance metric for each branch, based on a composite index of its performance against a notional ‘best in class at everything’ branch. The above techniques are rational, mathematical ones. In their study A Behavioral Theory of the Firm (1963), management researchers Cyert and March identify some less obviously 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Satisficing. Here the strategy selected is the one that keeps all, or at least the most powerful, stakeholders happy. It usually emerges as a result of negotiation between the competing stakeholders. Sequential attention. Stakeholders are kept happy by taking turns to get their objectives realised. Therefore staff may get a large pay rise every 3 years but, in between, pay remains static while dividends are paid. Side payments. Where particular stakeholders’ objectives cannot be addressed, they are compensated in another way. For example, a shareholder may be compensated for a low profit by a higher dividend, or a local community may have a new leisure centre built by a company whose new superstore will inevitably increase noise and traffic congestion in the area. Exercise of power. Where management are deadlocked due to competing objectives, this is often resolved by one or more powerful figures using their power to force through their preferred option.
1.12 Corporate governance This section is based on extracts from the CIMA working party report, Corporate Governance: History, Practice and Future, published by CIMA Publishing and reproduced with permission.
1.12.1 What is corporate governance? This is likely to be examined quite frequently. According to the Cadbury report: Corporate governance is the system by which companies are directed and controlled.
1.12.2 The history of corporate governance Treadway and COSO Some of the earliest considerations of corporate governance come from the United States. The Treadway Commission issued a report on fraudulent financial reporting in 1987, which confirmed the role and status of audit committees. The Treadway Report prompted the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to incorporate in its listing requirements, from 1988, that all SEC-regulated companies should have an audit committee with a majority of non-executive directors. Further work by a subgroup of the Treadway Commission, COSO, developed a framework for internal control, providing detailed criteria for management to assess internal control systems, and gave guidance for reporting publicly on internal control. In the United Kingdom, the corporate governance debate was stimulated by a series of corporate scandals and unexpected corporate collapses in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Press coverage of BCCI, Polly Peck and the pension funds of the Maxwell Communications Group caused much public questioning about how effective the boards 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
rational techniques by which competing objectives are resolved:
35
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
36
STUDY MATERIAL P5
of these companies had been in monitoring the actions of their executive management, and about the difficulties that non-executive directors and auditors faced in ‘standing up’ to dominant chairmen or chief executives. Cadbury The Cadbury Committee was set up in May 1991 by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), the Stock Exchange and the accountancy profession in response to their concern about ‘the perceived low level of confidence both in financial reporting and in the ability of auditors to provide the safeguards which the users of company reports sought and expected’. The committee’s remit was to report on the financial aspects of corporate governance (particularly in relation to financial reporting and accountability), to consider the responsibilities of executive and non-executive directors, the case for audit committees, the principal responsibilities of auditors, the extent and value of the audit, and the links between shareholders, boards and auditors. At the heart of the Cadbury Committee’s recommendations was the Code of Best Practice, with which all listed companies were to comply. The Code was based on three principles:
openness (subject to commercial confidentiality); integrity (honest, balanced and complete financial reporting); accountability (the requirement for directors to provide quality information, and for shareholders to exercise their powers as owners responsibly).
The argument for adhering to the Code was that it would strengthen both confidence and accountability. The board would find it easier to secure assent for its strategies, if its activities were more open and there was a clearer understanding of its responsibilities. And if the general level of confidence in financial reporting were improved, this would facilitate the efficient working of capital markets. One of the recommendations of the Cadbury Code was that ‘directors should explain their responsibility for preparing the accounts next to a statement by the auditors about their reporting responsibilities.’ It intended this requirement to ensure that companies have an appropriate control system in place, and apply it effectively. The committee placed great importance on internal control – both because it is essential to efficient management, and because failures in internal control were one of the reasons the committee was established. The Cadbury Report advised that companies would not be able to comply with their recommendations until further necessary guidance was developed. It felt that this was the responsibility of the accountancy profession, together with preparers of accounts. Specifically, it called upon them to take the lead in developing:
a set of criteria for assessing effectiveness; guidance for companies on the form in which directors should report; and guidance for auditors on relevant audit procedures and the form in which auditors should report.
Rutteman The Rutteman working group published its guidance, Internal Control and FinancialReporting: Guidance for Directors of Listed Companies Registered in the UK, in December 1994. The 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
(a) acknowledgement by the directors that they are responsible for the company’s system of internal financial control; (b) explanation that such a system can provide only reasonable and not absolute assurance against material misstatement or loss; (c) description of the key procedures that the directors have established and which are designed to provide effective internal financial control; and (d) confirmation that the directors (or a board committee) have reviewed the effectiveness of the system of internal financial control. It did not develop from scratch the list of criteria for assessing the effectiveness of internal controls but based them on those set out in the US’ COSO report, Internal Control – Integrated Framework. This guidance has now been superseded by the Turnbull Report. Greenbury The Greenbury Committee was set up in January 1995, on the initiative of, but independent of, the Confederation of British Industry (CBI). Its terms of reference were to ascertain what was good practice in determining directors’ pay, and to prepare a code of practice based on its findings. The committee was not just responding to public and shareholder concern about pay increases and accountability, but also considered the relatively neglected issue of how to appropriately reward performance. The committee’s approach was to strengthen accountability, and encourage improved performance through transparency, the appropriate allocation of responsibilities for determining remuneration, and the proper reporting to shareholders. Specifically, it felt that determining directors’ pay needed to be delegated by the board to a suitably knowledgeable and independent group, non-executive directors, who would have no personal interest in the remuneration decisions they were taking. This group would report to shareholders, providing full disclosure of individuals’ remuneration and the underlying policy. The committee published its report in July 1995, and considered that implementation of its recommendations would improve corporate remuneration practices. Although their research focused on UK listed companies, the committee expected that non-listed and smaller companies would find their conclusions of merit. Hampel The Hampel Committee was established in November 1995, on the initiative of the chairman of the FRC, and followed the recommendations of both the Cadbury and Greenbury Reports for a successor committee. The Hampel Committee’s sponsors included the Stock Exchange, the CBI and the Consultative Committee of Accountancy
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
guidance was addressed principally to listed companies, and those traded on the USM, but was felt to be relevant to all business organisations. It was to be applicable immediately – to accounting periods beginning on or after 1 January 1995. Rutteman did not prescribe the form of the internal controls statement, and advised that readers would expect it to be included within the corporate governance statement, although it might also be included in the operating and financial review, in the directors’ report, or the statement on directors’ responsibilities. The report advised that the statement should contain as a minimum:
37
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
38
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Bodies (CCAB). It consulted widely, sending out a questionnaire to interested parties (including public companies, institutional investors and representative bodies such as CIMA), from which it received over 140 responses. Hampel’s remit was to:
review the Cadbury Code and its implementation to ensure that its original purpose was being achieved, proposing amendments where necessary; keep under review the role of directors (executive and non-executive), recognising the need for board cohesion and the common legal responsibilities of all directors; review the Greenbury recommendations; and address the roles of shareholders and auditors in corporate governance.
The committee felt that it was ‘too soon to reach a considered assessment of the longterm impact of the Cadbury Code’ and ‘even more difficult to reach a definitive conclusion on Greenbury’. However, their report was not as short as these comments suggest. The committee felt that it was important to look at corporate governance from a fresh perspective, not as a ‘response to things which were perceived to have gone wrong’. It started from the beginning to consider what is meant by corporate governance, and to identify broad principles (some familiar from Cadbury and Greenbury) which it hoped would command general agreement. The committee decided to produce a Combined Code embracing Cadbury, Greenbury and its own work and to pass this to the Stock Exchange so that it could sit alongside the Listing Rules. The committee indicated that companies would be required to make a statement to show how they apply the principles and comply with the Combined Code, and to justify any significant variances.
1.12.3 The combined code principles of corporate governance The Combined Code was published in June 1998 and comprised Principles of Good Governance and a Code of Best Practice, which set out Code Provisions for each of these principles. The principles are divided into the broad areas listed below.
Directors: Listed companies should be led by an effective board, with a balance of executive and non-executive directors such that no individuals or small groups can dominate decision-making. There should be a clear division of responsibilities of the two key tasks of running the board and running the business so that no individual has unfettered powers. To enable it to discharge its duties the board should be supplied in a timely manner with good quality information. The procedure for appointing new directors should be formal and transparent and directors should stand for re-election at least every 3 years. Directors’ remuneration: Without paying more than is necessary, the level of remuneration should be that which is necessary to recruit and retain directors of the right calibre. Some element should be performance-related in such a way as to encourage the achievement of corporate objectives and to reward individual performance. Policy on executive remuneration should be clear, and no director should be involved in determining his/her own remuneration. Details of remuneration policy and the remuneration of each director should be stated in the annual report.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Relations with shareholders: Companies should be prepared to enter into a dialogue with institutional investors, and communicate with private investors through the medium of the annual general meeting, encouraging their participation. Accountability and audit: The board is responsible for presenting a balanced and understandable assessment of the company’s financial position and prospects. It is also responsible for maintaining a sound system of internal controls to safeguard the company’s assets and the shareholders’ investments in the company. It should establish through an audit committee formal and transparent arrangements for considering how to apply the principles of financial reporting and internal control and for maintaining an effective relationship with external auditors.
The Combined Code also included Code Principles and Provisions for institutional shareholders, covering matters such as voting, communication between investor and company, and the investor organisation’s responsibilities to evaluate the company’s corporate governance arrangements. Because they were targeted not at the company itself but at organisations representing institutional shareholders, these recommendations were not included in the Listing Rules for companies. However, they were felt to be important by the Hampel Committee.
1.12.4 The benefits of corporate governance Good corporate governance:
Reduces risk. It helps to ensure that the personal objectives of the board and the company’s strategic objectives are brought into line with those of stakeholders. It can help to reduce the risk of fraud. It can provide a mechanism to review risk, and it can provide a framework for reviewing and assessing projects. Stimulates performance. It institutes clear accountability and effective links between performance and rewards, which can encourage the organisation to improve its performance. Improves access to capital markets. It reduces the level of risk as perceived by outsiders, including investors. In particular, corporate governance can be seen as protecting shareholders’ rights, and thus make it easier for companies to raise finance. Enhances the marketability of goods and services. It creates confidence among other stakeholders, including employees, customers, suppliers and partners in joint ventures. Improves leadership. It allows increased expertise to be brought to bear on strategic decision-making, through the influence of non-executive directors (NEDs), and because all board members are encouraged to examine board decisions critically. The wider pool of knowledge and experience available to the board, through the inclusion of external members, helps the board to identify opportunities more readily. Demonstrates transparency and social accountability. This in turn can foster political support for, and public confidence in, the organisation.
1.13 Summary This chapter covered an introduction to strategy. The key points to remember are:
at least one definition of strategy; the stages in the rational strategy model; 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
39
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
40
STUDY MATERIAL P5
the benefits and drawbacks of formal strategies; approaches to strategy, including positioning and RBT; the importance of stakeholders, and the Mendelow matrix; the possible conflicting objectives of the organisation; the principles of corporate governance.
References Asch, D. and Bowman, C. (eds) (1989), Readings in Strategic Management. London: Macmillan. Barney, J. (1991), ‘Firm Resources and Sustained Competitive Advantage’, Journal of Management, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 99–120. Birley, S. (1982), ‘Corporate Strategy and the Small Firm’, Journal of General Management, Vol. 8, No. 2, Winter 1982–3. Reproduced in Asch, D. and Bowman, C. (eds) (1989), Ch. 6. Brunsson, N. (1985), The Irrational Organisation: Irrationality as a Basis for Organisational Action and Change. Chichester: John Wiley. CIMA (2000), Corporate Governance: History, Practice and Future. London: CIMA Publishing Cyert, R.M. and March, J.G. (1963), A Behavioural Theory of the Firm. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Hamel, G. and Prahalad, C.K. (1994), Competing for the Future: Breakthrough Strategies for Seising Control of Your Industry and Creating the Markets of Tomorrow. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Handy, C. and Handy, E. (1999), The New Alchemists. London: Hutchinson. Hofer, C.W. and Schendel, D. (1978), Strategy Formulation: Analytical Concepts. Minnesota: West Publishing. Hooley, G. J., Cox, A. J. and Adams, A. (1992), ‘Our Five Year Mission: To Boldly Go Where No Man Has Gone Before. . .’, Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 8, pp. 35–48. Cited in Corporate Performance Evaluation in Multinationals (1993). London: CIMA. Johnson, G. and Scholes, K. (1997), Exploring Corporate Strategy (4th edn). Hemel Hempstead: Prentice-Hall. Kay, J. (1997), Foundations of Corporate Success: How Business Strategies Add Value (2nd edn). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Lindblom, C.E. (1959), ‘The Science of Muddling Through’, Public Administration Review, Spring, pp. 79–88. Lindblom, C.E. (1979), ‘Still Muddling, Not Yet Through’, Public Administration Review, November/December, pp. 517–26. Lynch, R. (2000), Corporate Strategy (2nd edn). London: Financial Times Management. Mintzberg, H. (1987), ‘Crafting Strategy’, Harvard Business Review, July–August. Reprinted in Mintzberg et al. (1998), op. cit., pp. 110–20. Mintzberg, H., Quinn, J.B. and Ghoshal, S. (1998), The Strategy Process (European edn). Hemel Hempstead: Prentice-Hall. Porter, M.E. (1980), Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analysing Industries and Competitors. New York: The Free Press. Porter, M.E. (1985), Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: The Free Press. Prahalad, C.K. and Hamel, G. (1990), ‘The Core Competence of the Corporation’, Harvard Business Review, May/June.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Quinn, J.B. (1978), ‘Strategic Change: Logical Incrementalism’, Sloan Management Review, No. 20, Fall, pp. 7–21. Rockart, J.F. and Hoffman, J.D. (1992), ‘Systems Delivery: Evolving New Strategies’, Sloan Management Review, Summer, pp. 7–19. Stalk, G., Evans, P. and Shulman, L. (1992), ‘Competing on Capabilities’, Harvard Business Review March/April. Sternberg, E. (1994), Just Business: Business Ethics in Action. London: Little, Brown.
41
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
1
Readings
Approaches to strategic management have changed and evolved considerably over the last 20 years or so. Initially, most writers on strategy emphasised the importance of adopting a deliberate and systemic approach to the process of planning. More recently, there has been a move towards recognising the contribution of a more flexible contingent approach within which strategies can sometimes emerge from chance events and from complex cognitive, cultural and political processes within organisations. An associated change of emphasis has been a switch in the focus of attention from a concern with finding the most advantageous position for the organisation in relation to its environment, to one of exploiting and building the organisation’s competencies and resources. Alan Marsden explains these issues in the following article.
Strategic management – which way to competitive advantage? Alan Marsden, Management Accounting, January 1998
Many readers of this magazine will associate strategic management with strategic planning. This approach to strategy generally involves a deliberate step-by-step approach. It commences with a set of tentative objectives which the CEO or senior management team considers necessary for the organisation to achieve its goals. The external environment is then analysed to determine potential opportunities and threats; an internal audit is conducted to determine the organisation’s strengths and weaknesses; strategic alternatives are evaluated to determine which strategy will best ‘position’ the organisation so as to capitalise on opportunities and strengths while minimising threats and weaknesses and then a plan is prepared to assist in the implementation of the chosen strategy. The approach may be illustrated by a diagram such as Figure 1, which is taken from the Management Accounting Official Terminology (CIMA 1996).1
Development of the planning/positioning approach as the dominant framework
This approach to strategy has provided the dominant framework for textbooks on strategy from the time the subject emerged as a distinct specialism in the 1950s with the work of Igor Ansoff, Kenneth Andrews and others2 through to the early 1990s. Though the basic framework for analysis appears to have been formulated in the early 1950s it has been elaborated and developed by a number of writers. Among these, the most important contributor has been Michael Porter,3 with his development of the concept of the five 43
2005.1
READINGS P5
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
44
Figure 1 Long-term plan
forces model used for industry analysis, the value chain as an instrument for assessing internal organisational strengths and weaknesses, and the generic strategies as a tool to assist in strategy evaluation. Though writers such as Philip Selznick,4 Ansoff, Porter and others discussed the importance of internal analysis and developed both the competencegrid and the value chain as aids to this, the major focus has tended to be on the environment. The common assumption underlying the approach is that the environment largely determines the organisation’s freedom to manoeuvre. Therefore, the structure of the environment is of overwhelming importance and a strategy for delivering competitive advantage will be one that positions the firm within the environment. The problem for the strategist then becomes one of finding a position that is defensible against the threats from existing and potential competitors and from the bargaining power of suppliers and buyers. One of the main purposes of corporate planning was, and is, that of the planning and management of growth. During the 1960s and 1970s diversification was very much in fashion as a means to corporate growth. It is perhaps not surprising, then, that during this period we find the development and use of portfolio planning matrices as frameworks for selecting strategies and allocating resources in the diversified corporations. The approach outlined was taken on board and used by planning departments in some of the world’s largest corporations. This was particularly true in the period of stability and economic growth that characterised the 1960s and early 1970s. A study in 19635 found that the majority of the largest US companies had set up corporate planning departments. The typical format used by these departments was a five-year corporate-planning document that set goals and objectives, forecast the main trends such as those for market demand, the company’s market share and its revenue and net income, established priorities for different products and business areas and allocated resources. The demise of the planning approach
The enthusiasm for corporate planning, however, was not to last. One reason for its demise appears to have been the increasing rate of change and the associated 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
The recognition that strategies can emerge
All these developments affected the practice of strategic planning and led to a reappraisal of the approach by both managers and academics. In many companies, corporate planning departments were dismantled and responsibility for strategy formulation passed to managers who had responsibility for its implementation. A more flexible less formal approach was adopted and the time horizon for long-term plans reduced. Academics charted these developments and conducted empirical research into how strategy was actually formulated in companies. The main findings of this research can perhaps most easily be summarised by the use of a diagram provided by Henry Mintzberg.7 He observed that while strategy is often thought of as a plan or a guide to a course of action into the future, it could also be regarded as a pattern of consistent behaviour over time. The difference between these is that a plan refers to intended future action, whereas strategy as a pattern refers to the observed decisions and actions after they have been taken. Mintzberg suggests that strategy as a plan 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
macroeconomic instability with which companies had to cope from the mid-1970s onwards. Particularly damaging was the first oil price shock of 1974. This produced fuel shortages and inflation which few if any could have anticipated and this rendered the predictions of corporate planners virtually useless. Organisations were faced not only with fluctuations in the economy but also with technological change. One effect of this was that product life cycles became shorter and firms more frequently needed to update their production processes. Developments in transport and communications resulted in the development of global competition for many products and this intensified competition. Another factor adding to this competitive situation was the growth of Japan and other SE Asian countries as manufacturers and exporters of an increasing range of goods. This additional competition resulted in an ever more active search by competitors to secure competitive advantage. The product of all these changes for the organisation was a dynamic and unstable environment in which any long-term plans became quickly outdated. A secondary reason for the fall in popularity of strategic planning was the failure of diversification to increase profitability. The use of portfolio planning models did not guarantee the synergy that companies sought in their various acquisitions and so this only added to the disillusion with the planning approach. There is some evidence that the reason for planning failure was partly influenced by the way in which the planning process was conducted in some organisations. Research by R.T. Lenz and M. Lyles,6 for instance, found that in a number of organisations the planning process developed into an annual ritual for which managers had little enthusiasm because it took up so much time and effort and often seemed to lead nowhere. They found that several factors contributed to this lack of commitment including the professionalisation of planning, the excessive emphasis on quantifiable data, and the drive for administrative efficiency in the planning process and the unqualified acceptance and misapplication of various analytical techniques. The use of professional planners with their use of technical jargon tended to alienate some practising managers. The emphasis on quantifiable data led to the neglect of important qualitative changes in the environment because they were difficult to measure. The drive for efficiency tended to result in the growth of bureaucratic procedures and to be detrimental to creative thinking while the over-reliance on analytical tools like portfolio matrices often seemed to serve as a substitute for critical thought in the analytical process.
45
READINGS P5
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
46
Figure 2 Forms of strategy (Mintzberg, 1994)7
can be called intended strategy, while the pattern of actions which evolve from past decisions might be called realised strategies. The available research shows that few planned strategies work out exactly as expected. That is to say that few plans are realised in all their intended detail. This occurs for a number of reasons, such as an unexpected change in the environment like a sudden fall in demand, a switch in the strategy of a competitor, pressure from a stakeholder group or the fact that the original strategy may have been misconceived. As depicted in Figure 2, intentions that are fully realised can be called deliberate strategies, while those that are not realised at all can be called unrealised strategies. The strategic planning approach recognises both these possible outcomes but it does not account for a third possibility, which Mintzberg calls emergent strategy and which applies to a situation where a realised pattern evolves that was never intended. The most frequently quoted example of this type of strategy development comes from a description provided by Richard Pascale8 of Honda Motor Company’s entry into the US motorcycle industry. The ostensible reason for Honda’s success is that the company redefined the US motorcycle industry via a brilliantly conceived intended strategy. According to Pascale, however, Honda’s intended strategy was nearly a disaster. The strategy that emerged did so, not through planning, but through unplanned action taken in response to unforeseen circumstances. Pascale recounts how, when Honda executives arrived in Los Angeles in 1959, they did so with the intention of setting up a subsidiary to sell 250cc and 350cc machines to existing motorcycle enthusiasts. They had no intention of trying to sell smaller bikes such as the 50cc machines that were so popular in Japan because they could not envisage a market for these in a country where everything was bigger and better than back home. As things turned out, the sales of the 250cc and 350cc bikes were disappointing. One of the reasons was to do with mechanical failure of some of their machines. The intended strategy looked to be failing. In the course of their work, however, the Honda executives were using 50cc machines to run errands around Los Angeles and their presence attracted a lot of attention. One day the Honda team received a call from a Sears’ buyer who proposed selling the 50cc machines through the department chain outlets. For their part the Honda team were reluctant to sell the small bikes because they feared it would alienate serious bikers who 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
might associate the Honda Company with ‘wimp’ machines. Eventually, however, their failure to sell the expected quota of larger machines pushed them into selling the small 50cc machines and to sell them not through specialist motor cycle distributors but through general retailers. Sales took off and a new strategy was born. By 1964 nearly one out of every two motor cycles sold in the USA was a Honda. By chance the Honda team had stumbled on a previously untouched market segment of consumers who were not motorcycle enthusiasts but simply wanted a small machine to nip around to the shops, the leisure centre and the park. The critical point demonstrated by this example is that not all strategies are planned, and also that successful strategy can emerge without prior planning and often in response to unforeseen circumstances. It also illustrates the fact that strategy need not originate in the minds of the CEO or the senior management teams but can arise from the observations and experience of the salesperson. The view that the realised strategies of an organisation depend on many processes in addition to systematic analysis and deliberate planning is supported by the work of other researchers like Gerry Johnson.9 In his examination of how strategy developed in Coopers, the retail clothing company, Johnson concluded that the strategy that emerged could be best explained in terms of the cognitive, political and cultural fabric of the organisation. The cognitive factors referred to consisted of the common sets of assumptions and beliefs that were taken for granted by managers in the retailing organisation studied. This tacit knowledge consisted of agreed notions about trading procedures, and methods of organisation and control that it was believed contributed to the effectiveness and efficiency of the organisation. This set of assumptions and beliefs may be regarded as a sort of paradigm, which influences the perceptions of managers, and therefore the decisions they make and the actions they take. The link between cognitive and political factors in the case of strategy development at Coopers derived from the fact that the buyers of merchandise in the company exercised a great deal of power. What’s more, the buyers shared the common assumption developed over years of experience in the industry that a ‘commodity’ merchandise policy (a ‘pile it high, sell it cheap’ policy) was the one most likely to deliver competitive advantage. Johnson describes how, despite clear signals of fashion changes in the market and continuous pressure from middle management, the buyers, supported by top management, resisted change. Even when sales fell, the response of senior management was not to adopt a new strategy to cope with a rapidly changing market but to pursue the low-price strategy even more vigorously by tightening controls and cutting controllable costs. Johnson explains the reluctance of Coopers’ management to change their strategy as arising from the mind-set produced by the prevailing paradigm. The set of beliefs, assumptions and way of doing things that had served the company well in the past were not easily abandoned. Evidence that the changing market required a change in strategy was dismissed as inconclusive or as temporary phenomena that would revert to its former pattern in the near future. In addition, because the prevailing paradigm was associated most strongly with senior executives in the company, any challenge to it constituted a political threat. Abandonment of the way of doing things, which they had continually defended, would result in a major loss of face. In the case of Coopers the situation was eventually resolved in an incremental fashion by many small adjustments over a period of time. In other organisations it is not uncommon for a failing company to be forced to adopt a new strategy almost overnight. Senior managers committed to a way of doing things, which bring a company to the brink of ruin, are frequently replaced by those with new ideas.
47
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
48
READINGS P5
What now for strategic planning?
The accumulated evidence suggests that the strategic planning approach to the development of strategy has a number of limitations. First, it is becoming more difficult to plan because of the accelerating rate of change. This does not mean that attempts to plan should not be undertaken. What it does mean is that the scanning and monitoring of the environment for trends and potential changes in these trends becomes even more important, and that additional resources have to be devoted to these by the organisation. It also means that organisations have to be flexible and to accept change as something that has to be managed rather than resisted. Second, research has shown that some of the problems experienced by organisations in their strategic planning have to do with the failings of those who use the approach, as the study by Lenz and Lyles has demonstrated. Here again, the problems are not such as to invalidate the approach but do require the effort and attention by managers concerned to avoid the pitfalls. Third, research by Mintzberg, Pascale, Johnson and others has found that in practice, strategies can emerge that derive not only from the systematic and rational analysis used by strategic planners but also from chance observations, trial and error and cognitive and political processes. It is hard to avoid the conclusion from these studies that useful strategies can and do emerge in other ways than via the strategic planning process. But again, these findings do not mean that the strategic planning approach should be abandoned. What these studies do is to inform us of the complex processes at work in the strategy-making process and, knowing of them, to take account of these when formulating plans.
Positioning and its problems
It is not only how managers can best formulate strategy that has concerned academics but also where managers should concentrate their attention. As previously indicated, the focus in the traditional planning approach tends to have been on the environment because research shows that it is more difficult to generate profits in some industries than others. Porter’s five forces model, in particular, suggests that an industry’s profitability potential is a function of the interactions among the five forces (suppliers, buyers, competitive rivalry among firms currently in the industry, product substitutes and potential entrants to the industry). In Porter’s words, ‘the collective strength of these five competitive forces determines the ability of firms in an industry to earn, on average, rates of return on investment in excess of the cost of capital’.10 Because the strength of the five forces varies from industry to industry, and can change as industry evolves, industries vary in their potential for profitability. In some industries, such as soft drinks and pharmaceuticals where the five forces are favourable, many competitors can earn attractive returns. But in industries like rubber, steel and video games the pressure from one or other of the five forces is so intense that few firms can sustain a high level of profit. Given these differences in industry profitability it follows that any entrepreneur seeking to invest in a profitable venture should seek to enter an industry in which the five forces are favourable and the chances of profit-making therefore greater than one in which competitive pressures are intense. Having selected the most favourable industry, the second question the entrepreneur needs to address is how to best position the firm within the industry so as to earn a rate of 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
return above the industry average. A firm that can position itself well can become very profitable even when the industry structure is unfavourable. The key to gaining a good position that will secure a competitive advantage and therefore a good rate of return depends on the strategy adopted by the organisation. The competitive forces operating in a particular industry determine the kind of strategy that will be effective for firms operating in the industry. For instance, producers of standardised silicon chips find themselves driven by competitive forces to adopt a low-cost strategy because price competition is fierce in an industry where the technology allows cheap mass-production. There is, however, a market for a small number of customised chips for specialised equipment. Manufacturers with the knowledge, expertise and appropriate flexibility to produce these can gain a competitive advantage by targeting this niche in the market and supplying at lower cost than the mass producers of standardised chips. In some cases the competitive forces will be such that differentiation is the source of competitive advantage. If this is the case the company will seek to differentiate itself by improving quality, by innovation, advertising and superior after-sales service. This approach, which concerns itself with how companies might best position themselves in the market, the industry and the wider environment and so achieve a strategic fit with the environment, though still very popular among both theorists and practitioners, has come in for criticism in recent years. The main shortcomings of the approach are, first, that it relies on a static picture of competition and thus understates the role of innovation and, second, that it overemphasises the importance of industry structure and the wider environment while deemphasising the significance of individual company differences in the possession of resources, capabilities and competence. The fact that innovation can revolutionise industry structure is now widely recognised. The example of the development of the computer industry is one of the more dramatic recent examples. Where a few companies existed ten years ago, now companies like Compaq, Dell, Sun Microsystems and Silicon Valley have gained market share from the established producers like IBM, Digital Equipment and Wang Labs. Fifteen years ago the industry was dominated by the likes of IBM, but the revolution that Apple computers started when it introduced the first personal computer has transformed the structure of the computer industry. As a result, a five forces analysis conducted in 1980 would look completely different from one done today. Other recent examples are in banking, insurance and other financial services. In the UK, companies like Direct Line Insurance, which pioneered telephone sales in insurance, has sparked off a revolution in the way in which insurance, banking and other financial services can be sold and this is changing the structure of the industry. The second criticism of the five forces model and the positioning approach of which it is a part is that it overemphasises the importance of industry structure as a determinant of company performance. Research by Richard Rumelt,11 for example, suggests that industry structure only explains about 10 per cent of the variance in profit rates across companies. The implication of this finding is that individual company differences explain much of the rest of the variance. Other studies suggest that the variance in performance arising from industry structure is really nearer to 20 per cent, but this still suggests a quite limited influence by the industry structure. These studies have been taken as evidence by a growing number of academics to mean that the individual resources and capabilities of a company are far more important determinants of its profitability than the industry in which it is located.
49
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
50
READINGS P5
The competence-based alternative
These problems with the positioning approach have been one reason for the search for an alternative. Another reason has been the observation that success for many companies appears to have little to do with positioning and much more to do with the exploitation of a company’s resources, competences and capabilities. Thus Prahalad and Hamel12 cite the core competence of miniaturisation as the basis for the success of the Sony Corporation. This competence, it is argued, has allowed Sony to make everything from the Walkman to video cameras to notebook computers. Similarly, Canon’s core competence in optics, imaging and microprocessor controls has enabled it to enter markets as diverse as copiers, laser printers, cameras and image scanners. Marks & Spencer’s competitive advantage has been based on its consistent ability to deliver high-quality clothing and food products at reasonable prices. These examples have led Hamel and Prahalad and other researchers to focus on the resources, capabilities and competences of the organisation as the source of competitive advantage rather than the environment as in the traditional approach. Because the new approach is still in the process of development, there is as yet limited agreement on the terminology to be employed. Similar terms – core competences, distinctive competences, capabilities, resources, strengths, intangible assets, skills – are used interchangeably by different authors. Currently a number of writers are trying to derive a vocabulary for discussing what they have called a ‘competence-based approach to strategic management’.13 Whether or not this attempt will provide a vocabulary on which all can agree remains to be seen. Despite the confusing use of terminology, however, it is possible to describe the main characteristics of what we shall call here the competencebased approach. The approach assumes that an organisation is a collection of resources, capabilities and competences that are relatively unique and that these provide a basis for its strategy and its ability to compete. It is also assumed that firms can acquire different resources, skills and capabilities in the process of their development. But because it takes time to acquire and develop such resources and capabilities it follows that firms that already possess a relevant set of these can gain competitive advantage over rivals. For example, the skills and capabilities required for miniaturisation and considered to be the basis of core competence for Sony take many years to hone to perfection and give Sony an advantage because they are not readily available to competitors. A diagram such as that in Figure 3 can be used to illustrate the competence-based approach. In contrast to the traditional planning model which takes the environment as the critical factor determining an organisation’s strategy, the competence-based approach assumes that the key factors for success lie within the firm itself in terms of its resources, capabilities and competences. The choice of the firm’s strategy is not dictated by the constraints of the environment but is influenced more by calculations of how the organisation can best exploit its core competence relative to the opportunities in the external environment. The resources of the firm in the competence-based approach are typically classified into two types: tangible and intangible resources. Tangible resources are inputs into a firm that can be seen, touched and/or quantified. They include assets like plant and equipment, access to raw materials and finance, a trained and skilled workforce and a firm’s organisational structure. Intangible resources range from intellectual property rights like patents, trade marks and copyrights to the knowhow of personnel, informal networks, organisational culture and a firm’s reputation for its products. The dividing line between the tangible and intangible is often unclear and how they are classified varies a little 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
51 THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Figure 3 The competence-based approach (adapted from R.M. Grant, 1991)14
from one writer to another. Despite the problems with classification, proponents of the competence-based approach are agreed on the relative importance of the two types of resource. Although it is clear that both types of resource are required for any business to operate, competence-based theorists argue that intangible resources are the most likely source of competitive advantage. The reason for this, it is argued, is that, being less visible, they are more difficult to understand and imitate than tangible resources. As such they are therefore more likely to be a source of competitive advantage. A survey of managers by Aaker15 in 1989 appears to confirm this. Aaker found that a reputation for quality was rated as the most important basis for competitive advantage by the managers questioned. Resources alone, however, are not a basis for competitive advantage. It is the way in which resources are integrated with each other to perform a task or an activity that provides the capability for an organisation to compete successfully in the marketplace. This being the case, the most important resource for any organisation is the skill and knowledge possessed by the organisation’s employees. It is this skill and knowledge acquired over time and embedded in the firm’s culture that influences how it operates and determines its success. Whether or not resources and capabilities have the potential to become core competences depends on how difficult they are for competitors to acquire and how valuable they are to the firm as a basis for competitive advantage. When they are rare, difficult to imitate, non-substitutable and they allow a firm to exploit opportunities or neutralise threats, then they can be considered core competences and serve as the basis of an organisation’s sustained competitive advantage. As part of this new approach to strategy development a number of writers have incorporated the notion of strategic intent. This is a term coined by Hamel and Prahalad16 to mean the leveraging of a firm’s internal resources, capabilities and core competences to accomplish what initially appear to be impossible goals in the face of the competitive forces confronting it. Examples cited by various authors of strategic intent include the intention by Intel to become the number-one supplier to the computer industry, the belief and intention of Microsoft that it can provide the Yellow Pages for an electronic marketplace of on-line information systems and the intention of Komatsu to encircle 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
52
READINGS P5
Caterpillar, its main competitor. Strategic intent is said to exist in an organisation when managers and employees have a fervent belief in their organisation and its products and when they are completely focused on doing what they do better than the competition. Because the idea of strategic intent implies ambitions that at a particular moment in time outstrip the organisation’s resources and capabilities for their achievement, theorists have also concerned themselves with how competences might be best acquired. As in the rest of this developing field, a variety of perspectives exist. Thus, some writers such as Senge17 and Argyris18 stress the acquisition of competences through internal mechanisms of individual and collective learning, while others like Hamel and Prahalad19 put greater emphasis on strategic tools like alliances, licensing, mergers and acquisitions. Writers who favour internal means of acquiring competences do so because they claim that such means give the advantages of secrecy, exclusivity and surprise. Those who concentrate on external means of acquiring competences defend their approach on the grounds of flexibility and speed. As markets change, it is argued, old alliances can be discarded and new ones formed. As new resources, capabilities and competences become necessary for competitive advantage it is quicker to buy them than to spend years of trial and error in their development. Such is the diversity of approach to the acquisition and building of competences that a contingent approach has been recommended as a way of selecting the most appropriate means of competence acquisition. This approach assumes that the characteristics and direction of the competence building activity of a company are mainly contingent on its strategic objectives. Some of the claims for the competence-based approach are quite sweeping in nature. For example: ‘Like the ‘‘grand unified theory’’ that modern physicists are searching for to explain physical behaviour at both the subatomic level and that of the entire cosmos, the combination of core competence and capabilities may define the universal model for corporate strategy in the 1990s and beyond’ (Stalk et al.,20 p. 64).
Summing up so far, then, we have the claim that changes in the business environment have rendered the positioning approach irrelevant and that the only sound basis for sustainable competitive advantage is the development and exploitation of those resources and capabilities which are, or will become, the core competences of the organisation. Indeed, the claim is made that core competences are more critical than the external environment as a basis for strategy determination, because the environment is in too much of a state of change to base any strategy on it. The claim for the competence-based model as a superior form of explanation is based on examples of a number of firms that appear to be successful because they are particularly good in one or more functions and/or because they have acquired some unique resource which combined with others gives them a competitive edge. All this adds up we are told to the emergence of a new paradigm in corporate strategy. Problems with the competence-based approach
A review of the literature, however, would suggest that a more cautious view of the so-called new paradigm should be adopted. The reasons for caution include the following. First, it is not a new approach because its key features are the same as those contained in a general framework for strategic management first formulated over 30 years ago. Second, it is partial and one-sided and thus in danger of neglecting the environment, which is still critical to the survival of organisations. Third, the case for its superiority is 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
based on a few examples of successful companies that have been chosen because they appear to confirm the theory. Companies that are successful for other reasons have been neglected. Finally, even when the leading exponents conduct an analysis of the same case, they disagree about the basis of competitive advantage. Turning first to the claim that the competence-based approach represents a new paradigm. Over thirteen years ago Waterman21 noted that the focus on distinctive competence is not new. Under a heading ‘Distinctive competence the forgotten trail’, Waterman recalled that the first writer to discuss the idea of organisational distinctive competences was Phillip Selznick in 1957 when that writer noted that: ‘The terms, institution, organisational character and distinctive competence all refer to the same basic process – the transformation of an engineered, technical arrangement of building blocks into a purposive social organisation.’ Waterman also goes on to confirm that the standard textbook on business policy (another name for strategic management) over 30 years ago was by Learmond et al.22 and that the focus of strategy-making at that time was clearly on analysing and building distinctive competences. Since that time, Waterman argues, the concern with competences has been downgraded as ‘Analysis of strategic position within a competitive system has all but butted out concern with the boring details of execution (which sum up to that elusive competence).’ One of the important premises of the model is that strategies should be unique and built on distinctive (now called core) competences. In their work, both Andrews and Ansoff stressed the importance of internal analysis as part of the strategic planning process. Ansoff22 supplied perhaps the most detailed account. Adopting what students today will recognise as the strengths and weakness approach to the internal analysis of the business, Ansoff describes how to develop what he calls a grid of competences. He recommends that for such a grid to be widely applicable it must be constructed in terms of competence areas, which are common to most industries. To be applicable to a single firm, these areas must list specific skills and resources, which differentiate between success and failure in different types of business. Ansoff recommends taking the fully integrated manufacturing firm as the most comprehensive framework of capabilities and using this as a point of reference. Frameworks for analysis of firms in trade, finance and services can then be obtained through modification of the general model. The individual skills and resources can then be organised according to major functional areas. Functions such as R&D, operations, marketing and so on are listed together with the equipment, personnel skills, organisational capabilities and management capabilities for each function. The list of the major skills and competences identified in the competence profile, as Ansoff called it, can then be rated with respect to those found in other firms which have the same capabilities. This rating will produce a ranking for each skill or capability according to whether it is judged to be outstanding, average or weak. The result of this process of analysis and rating will be to provide a competence profile for the firm which can be used in conjunction with the analysis of the external environment as an aid to strategy formulation and planning. Ansoff seems to use the word competence and capability interchangeably, as many of his modern counterparts do. But whatever the merits of his approach it is evident that he and his contemporaries were very much aware of the need to assess a firm’s capabilities and resources as a basis for planning and strategy formulation. It is also clear that in all fundamental respects the approach adopted was similar to that being promoted by modern
53
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
54
READINGS P5
day competence-based theorists. There are, of course, some differences. Modern theorists have refined the terminology. In particular the importance of intangible resources is stressed and the concept of strategic intent emphasised by Hamel and Prahalad can be seen to have built on Ansoff’s work and added new insights. In brief then, there is nothing radically new in the competence-based approach; it is simply an elaboration of one part of the overall strategic management framework formulated over 30 years ago. The second problem with the competence-based approach is that in seeking to distance itself from the positioning approach it is in danger of overemphasising internal analysis to the extent of neglecting the problems which the accelerating rate of change in the environment poses for organisations. While fully accepting that organisations continually need to adapt to change by developing their core competences, it is also evident that the analysis of the environment is now even more vital in order to know how to adapt! The third concern with the new resource-based approach is a methodological one. In many respects the methodology reminds one of the Peters and Waterman23 study of excellent companies. Existing successful companies are selected and examined. The factors which appear to have contributed to their success are listed and put forward as the key characteristics which contribute to the success of these and other organisations and consultants go on to prescribe these as the basis for future success. Several of these excellent companies have since failed and critics such as Guest24 have pointed out that a major problem with the methodology adopted by Peters and Waterman was that no comparisons were made with companies not considered to be excellent. As a result it is difficult to know whether the characteristics contributing to excellence were evident to a greater extent in excellent companies than in other organisations. The same weaknesses appear to be evident in the approach adopted by the new resource-based theorists. Researchers spot some excellent companies – often Japanese high-tech consumerelectronics companies whose products are characterised by relatively short product life cycles – and abstract what appear to be those resources, capabilities and core competences which contribute to success. A fourth problem with the case made by the resource-based school is that they are unable to agree on what it is that contributes to the competitive advantage of the organisation even when they are conducting an analysis of the very same case. The disagreement between Stalk et al. and Prahalad and Hamel25 in respect of Honda’s success illustrates this point very well. According to Prahalad and Hamel Honda’s competitive advantage derives from core competences which they define as the combination of individual technologies and production skills that underline a company’s myriad product lines. Their example of Sony’s technical competence at miniaturisation suggests that much of competence has to do with the technical knowledge and skill which a firm accumulates over time. By contrast, Stalk et al. attribute organisational success to a capability that is defined as a set of business processes strategically understood. By business processes it is apparent from their Honda example that they are referring to what are usually thought of as business functions such as distribution, after-sales service, research and development and so on. But they also emphasise the effective weaving of business process together and the need for cross-functional integration as prerequisites for a capability to exist. In fact, the definition of capability by Stalk et al. includes so much as to invite confusion. In short, there are some problems with the competence-based approach. There is as yet a lack of agreement on terminology that results in a lack of clarity. Also, the claim 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Conclusions
This review of developments in strategic management suggests the following state of play. The environment in which organisations operate is changing faster than ever and it is therefore necessary for it to be continuously monitored and the position of the organisation within it regularly assessed. Recent studies have re-established the importance of resources, capabilities and competences as critical sources of competitive advantage and concepts for use in their analysis are currently being developed. The planning process has been questioned partly because of its limited success in application but also because it fails to take account of cognitive, political and cultural processes which often influence both how the strategy is formulated as well as its content. The findings do not appear to challenge the need to conduct analysis or to plan, but it is useful for people involved in planning to have knowledge of the cognitive and political processes at work so that they can take account of them and avoid any negative effects.
References 1. Management Accounting Official Terminology, CIMA Publishing 1996, p. 38. 2. Andrews, K.R.: The Concept of Corporate Strategy. Holmwood, IL: Irwin, 1971. Ansoff, H.I.: Corporate Strategy. McGraw Hill, New York, 1965. Learned, E.P., Christensen, C.R., Andrews, K.R. and Guth, W.D.: Business Policy: Text and Cases. Holmwood, IL: Irwin, 1965. 3. Porter, M.E.: Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analysing Industries and Competitors. New York: Free Press, 1980 and Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Free Press, 1985. 4. Selznick, P.: Leadership in Administration: A Sociological Interpretation. Evanston, IL: Row, Peterson, 1957. 5. Gilmore, F.F.: Formulation and Advocacy of Business Policy (rev ed). Ithaca, NY: Cornel University Press, 1979. 6. Lenz, R.T. and Lyles, M.A.: ‘Paralysis by analysis: is your planning system becoming too rational?’, Long Range Planning, August 1985, pp. 64–72. 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
that competences are the critical basis of competitive advantage has not been conclusively established because of the limitations of the methodology applied by some researchers. In fact, it is questionable whether or not it makes sense even to try to establish whether position in the industry/market place or the organisation’s competences are the key to critical advantage when the performance of any company is so evidently dependent on both. There is also a danger of the impact of the environment being neglected because of an overenthusiasm with the rediscovery that the competences of the company are vital in the determination of strategy. These problems are not insurmountable. Some of them, such as the problem with terminology, is currently being addressed and the less extreme advocates of the competence-based model readily agree that the approach can complement rather than conflict with the positioning approach.
55
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
56
READINGS P5
7. Mintzberg, H.: The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning. Pearson Education, 1994. Reprinted by permission of Pearson Education. Copyright (c) 1991, by the Regents of the University of California Managment Review Vol 33, No. 3, by permission of The Regents. 8. Pascale, R.T.: ‘Perspective on strategy: the real story behind Honda’s success’, California Management Review, 26, No. 3 (Spring 1984), pp. 47–72. 9. Johnson, G.: ‘Re-thinking incrementalism’, Strategic Management Journal, January/ February 1988, pp. 75–91. 10. Porter, M.E.: Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analysing Industries and Competitors. New York: Free Press, 1980. 11. Rumelt, R.P.: ‘How much does industry matter?’, Strategic Management Journal, 12 (1991), pp. 167–185. 12. Pralahad, C.K. and Hamel, G.: ‘The core competence of the corporation’, Harvard Business Review, May/June 1990. 13. Sanchez, R., Heene, A. and Thomas, H.: ‘Towards the theory and practice of competence-based competition’ in Sanchez, R., Heene, A. and Thomas, H. (eds): Dynamics of Competence Based Competition: Theory and Practice in the New Strategic Management. Oxford: Elsevier, 1996. 14. Grant, R.M.: ‘The resource-based theory of competitive advantage: implications for strategy formulation’, California Management Review, 33 (Spring), 1991, pp. 114–135. 15. Aaker, D.A.: ‘Managing assets and skills: the key to sustainable competitive advantage’, California Management Review, 31, No. 2, 1989, pp. 91–106. 16. Hamel, G. and Pralahad, C.K.: ‘Strategic intent’, Harvard Business Review, 67, No. 3, 1989, pp. 63–76. 17. Senge, P.: ‘The leader’s new work: building learning organisations’. Sloan Management Review, Fall 1990, pp. 7–23. 18. Argyris, C.: ‘Good communication that blocks learning’, Harvard Business Review, 72, No. 4, 1994, pp. 77–85. 19. Hamel, G. and Pralahad, C.K.: ‘Collaborate with your competitors and win’, Harvard Business Review, 67, No. 1, 1989, pp. 133–9. 20. Stalk, G., Evans, P. and Scholman, L.E.: ‘Competing on capabilities: the new rules of corporate strategy’, Harvard Business Review, March/April 1992, pp. 57–69. 21. Thomas, P.J.: ‘Strategy follows structure: developing distinctive skills’, California Management Review, Spring 1984. 22. Ansoff, H.I.: Corporate Strategy. New York: McGraw Hill, 1965. 23. Peters, T. and Waterman, R.: In Search of Excellence. New York: Harper & Row, 1982. 24. Guest, D.: ‘Right enough to be dangerously wrong: an analysis of the In Search of Excellence phenomena’ in G. Salaman et al (eds): Human Resource Strategies. London: Sage, 1992. 25. Pralahad, C.K. and Hamel, G.: ‘The core competence of the corporation’, Harvard Business Review, May/June 1990. Discussion questions
Explain how strategies can emerge. Contrast the ‘positioning approach’ to strategy formulation with the ‘competence-based’ approach.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
A new strategy for growth Reproduced with permission. # Abbey National Plc. All rights reserved.
We are acting quickly and decisively to address challenges, focusing on our strong personal financial services businesses. Review of 2002
Abbey National’s results for 2002 reflect a resilient UK personal financial services (PFS) business, which was overshadowed by large write-offs and charges relating to Wholesale Banking, Life Assurance and goodwill. These charges reflect the harsh impact on Abbey National of extremely difficult markets. They also reflect recent actions by management to recognise the challenges we are facing, and to reduce risk in the business to protect against future volatility. The organisation has a strong financial base, as we move forward with our new strategy, offering security to our 16 million customers. The loss before tax for the Abbey National Group of £984 million is extremely unsatisfactory. On behalf of the whole Board, we would like to express our regret for the results and dividend cut that we have announced. We are acting quickly and decisively to address these challenges and details are outlined below. Delivering a single-minded strategy
Following an intensive strategic review, the Company will be focused solely on providing a full range of personal financial services in the UK through direct and intermediary channels. This is a radical shift in strategy. The new strategy directs all our resources towards personal financial services – by delivering greater value to our customers, we will earn more value for shareholders. Our focus will make us unique and will enhance business performance and execution. We have a new structure for the Company in place, designed around the customer, which is expected to deliver enhanced performance as well as streamline operations. We are focusing all our energies where we have demonstrated strengths and where we have the greatest opportunity to succeed and distinguish ourselves. Personal financial services
The core ongoing PFS businesses remain sound and have had a good year in terms of new business. Highlights include a 10.6% share of mortgage net lending in the second half of the year and £1.8 billion of deposit inflows, opening almost half a million bank accounts, and issuing a quarter of a million new credit cards in 2002. Credit quality in these businesses remains good. We are reducing the risks in our life assurance business and programmes are in place to protect against downward movements in equity markets.
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
The following Annual Review by Abbey National Group for 2002 contains a useful example of a deliberate change in corporate strategy. Read the review and answer the question which follows.
57
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
58
READINGS P5
Portfolio Business Unit
As a result of the new strategic direction, various operations including those in France and Italy, and the remaining part of the First National business have been deemed non-core due to the lack of synergy with ongoing PFS business. These businesses will be managed for value as part of our newly established Portfolio Business Unit (PBU). It is important to stress that while we will exit these operations, many remain profitable and are open for business as usual. In addition, asset-based portfolios representing a majority of the Wholesale Bank’s risk have also been assigned to the new PBU. This reflects the desire to focus only where we have business advantage, and to align its risk appetite with that of our shareholders and customers. We have made significant progress in terms of managing and reducing the risks in these portfolios. Capital and dividends
The Board is proposing a final dividend of 7.35 pence, to give a full year dividend for 2002 of 25 pence per share (2001: 50 pence). The 25 pence level represents an appropriate starting point based on the trading potential of the ongoing PFS businesses. It is Abbey National’s intention that from 2003 the Group will return to its historical split for dividend payments, between the interim and final dividend of approximately one third/two thirds. At all times we intend to be disciplined in managing the business for shareholder value. If surplus capital arises from our actions, we will favour shareholder distribution unless there is a compelling strategic and economic case for reinvestment. Outlook
Despite the difficulties in 2002, we start this year with a strong base of around 16 million customers, a top five position in many relevant market segments, a distinctive, trusted and powerful brand, and strong product distribution through a variety of channels. Our goal is to deliver a compelling proposition to UK customers, who do not feel that they have been well served by the UK banking industry. Through the highest level of service and advice, we will aim to deliver more value to customers – to earn their trust and commitment. We have absolute conviction that this is the right strategy for Abbey National; for our shareholders, our customers and our employees. It will, however, be a long, hard process that we envisage will span the next three years. We know that our shareholders will want to see tangible progress along the way, and we will be reporting regularly, the first such opportunity being at the time of the pre-close statement in June. The events of 2002 have acted to focus minds, and this is already driving an increased sense of determination and delivery within the business. Our employees are key to our success and we would like to thank them for their continued hard work and commitment. We have aligned all our talent, investment and energies on a clear, single and unifying goal under a suitable organisational structure. We are now strongly focused on delivering. Discussion question
Describe the new corporate strategy of Abbey National Group.
2005.1
Revision Questions
1
Section A type questions Question 1.1 The approach to strategy formulation that bases strategy on the assessment of core competences is known as the (A) (B) (C) (D)
resource-based approach position-based approach rational approach emergent approach
Question 1.2 In the rational strategic planning model, SWOT analysis is normally carried out as part of (A) (B) (C) (D)
mission and objective setting corporate appraisal strategy option generation strategy evaluation and choice
Question 1.3 A strategy that aims at pleasing ‘most of the people, most of the time’ is known as (A) (B) (C) (D)
goal congruence stakeholders satisficing sub-optimisation
Question 1.4 In Mendelow’s stakeholder analysis matrix, what are the two axes of the matrix?
Question 1.5 In strategic management, for what does the acronym SBU stand ? 59
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
60
REVISION QUESTIONS P5
Section B type questions Question 2 Newco plc is a recently privatised company that supplies energy to the general public. One of the objectives underlying Newco plc’s change of ownership was that it would be enabled to set its own goals and targets without reference to third parties. The chief executive of Newco plc has publicly stated that the aim of the business will be ‘to supply the best possible service to the greatest number of consumers at the cheapest possible cost.’ It is believed, within Newco plc, that the cheapest possible cost will only be achieved by the introduction of a number of changes to improve operating efficiency. The holders of this view are, like the chief executive himself, people who have been brought into Newco plc within the last two or three years. This group is small in numbers but seems to be very influential. Requirement Discuss the extent to which the chief executive’s aim is compatible with the interests of the shareholders. (10 marks)
Question 3 Companies have an obligation to provide information to their stakeholders. The financial information provided tends to be of a historical nature. It has been argued that shareholders in particular should be entitled to receive forward-looking information. Some companies wishing to communicate selectively with a subgroup of shareholders are often prevented from doing so, as all shareholders should receive the same financial information. Requirement Explain why a company may wish to disclose forward-looking information to its stakeholders and in particular to its shareholders. (10 marks)
Section C type questions Question 4 Tub plc was founded in the early 1980s by two brothers. As employees in their father’s home-decorating business they became aware of the opportunities available in the growing home improvement and DIY (‘do-it-yourself’) markets. Spotting a gap in the middle-price range of the market for bathroom and kitchen fittings, they set up a company to manufacture these items. The demand for their products outstripped their ability to supply, and they expanded rapidly. Most of this expansion was financed from retained profits but, as they happened to be located in an area of economic decline, they qualified for a state grant towards the cost of their new premises. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Requirements (a) Identify the key issues involved in formulating the corporate strategy of a company such as Tub plc. (8 marks) (b) How would you go about setting the business strategy of the various operating companies within the Tub group? (10 marks) (c) In what ways might the strategies of the organisational functions within each of the operating companies contribute to the overall strategy? (7 marks) (Total marks = 25)
Question 5 BZ Ltd is a service company that was founded by L, its proprietor, investing his redundancy payment to establish the business. In addition to his own capital, L obtained a bank loan, and these were the only two sources of finance used to start the business. The company has achieved success by providing a very differentiated service. L has personally carried out the full range of planning and operational management activities required to develop the business ever since it began. It has become apparent to L that, in order to continue growing, further capital needs to be injected. Additionally, it is clear to L that he needs to appoint other senior managers to maintain the operational side of the business. He believes this will leave him free to pursue BZ Ltd’s strategic development. L’s strategic objective has been to exploit market opportunities, and he has achieved a high level of return on his investment. However, L now considers that in order to continue growing, BZ Ltd needs to raise more capital than he personally is able to introduce. L is actively considering raising the new capital by a public issue of shares.
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
By 1995 Tub plc had organised itself around eight operating companies covering the different products and sales activities of the group. Some of these sold directly to housing developers, some to major retail DIY multiples and one of the companies coordinated the group’s export operations. Each company had its own independent board of directors on which the brothers sat with one vote each. The brothers could be out-voted and in fact had been at various times in the past. The senior management believed in decentralisation, arguing that it promoted enterprise and that it was easier for small companies to grow than for larger ones to do so. Tub plc has invested heavily in new technology, automating processes wherever possible. It has developed good relationships with its suppliers and developed just-in-time purchasing and production systems. It is also able to deliver its products within 48 hours of orders being placed. It has progressive human resource management policies in place. At the present time the company has no new products coming onstream and its research and development function is tiny and confines itself to modifying existing products for what is a difficult overseas market. The environment in which the company operates is currently very difficult. Economic recession in the early 1990s and a housing market which continues to remain stagnant are causes for concern.
61
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
62
REVISION QUESTIONS P5
Requirements (a) Explain in what ways the strategic objectives of BZ Ltd may change if it obtains new capital from the public issue of shares. (13 marks) (b) Describe and comment on the appropriate strategic planning processes that BZ Ltd should adopt in order to satisfy its organisational objectives following the public issue of shares. (12 marks) (Total marks = 25)
2005.1
Solutions to Revision Questions
1
Section A solutions Solution 1.1 (A)
Solution 1.2 (B)
Solution 1.3 (C)
Solution 1.4 Stakeholder power Stakeholder interest
Solution 1.5 Strategic Business Unit
Section B solutions Solution 2 Common errors Not comparing and stating the extent of differences; It is generally assumed that the fundamental objective of a profit-seeking company is to maximise the shareholders’ wealth. The chief executive of Newco plc did not include the 63
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
64
SOLUTIONS TO REVISION QUESTIONS P5
shareholders’ interests in the statement of objectives, but expressed a view which suggests a strong marketing orientation. Stating the objectives of the firm as supplying ‘the best possible service to the greatest number of customers at the cheapest possible cost’, the interests of customers are stressed. This, then, is an intermediate objective which focuses on marketing. However, by emphasising an intermediate marketing objective, management may not focus sufficient attention on the maximisation of shareholders’ wealth. In a public utility company like Newco plc, many shareholders will also be customers and there will be a conflict of interest between these two groups. Expenses incurred to provide the ‘best possible service’, will result in lower levels of profit for shareholders. While this situation may please the customers, it is likely to create dissatisfaction among shareholders. On the other hand, excessive concern with cost-cutting will increase profits available for shareholders, but may cause customers to seek better service from competitors. This could be against the long-run interests of the shareholders as profitability is likely to decrease if sales decline. One of the fundamental beliefs of marketing is that of mutually beneficial exchanges between the supplier and the customer and this is likely to be achieved if the service can be provided at ‘the cheapest possible price’. Both shareholders and customers will obtain benefit from the firm if excellent service is provided at a relatively low price and if the service is available to the greatest number of consumers. It is therefore possible that the chief executive’s statement focuses attention on the best method of achieving the ultimate objective of the organisation, the maximisation of shareholders’ wealth.
Solution 3 The management of a company is usually keen to show stakeholders that the company is being successful and, fundamentally, to publicise the fact that it is being managed efficiently and effectively. The published financial reports of the company are used by the directors and management of the company to disclose information to the stakeholders about the performance of the company. In particular, potential and existing shareholders, who own the company, would appreciate information about the future plans of the company to enable them to be aware of its strategic aims and objectives. Although information is shown in respect of the company’s past achievements, the management may wish to disclose strategically sensitive management accounting information if they believe that this will maximise the long-term wealth of the owners to whom the management are ultimately responsible. It is likely that the stakeholders will be interested in receiving information which will enable them to form better opinions of the future performance of the company, especially regarding the future prospects of the company. In particular, the shareholders, creditors and lenders, employees and customers will be interested in receiving forward-looking information about the company.
Shareholders. As the providers of the long-term finance to the company, the shareholders would be interested in being provided with information relating to the mission and objectives of the company. In particular, the expected changes in the share price and dividends would be of interest to the existing and potential shareholders. In addition, they would be concerned with the investment plans that the management are considering. It is possible that shareholders would be prepared to reduce the rate of
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
In general terms, the management would be motivated to disclose strategic, forwardlooking management information, especially if it presents a favourable picture. However, it is not possible to direct the reports only to these interested parties because competitors, in particular, would be very interested in receiving the company’s future strategy. This would clearly represent a major threat to the successful implementation of the strategic information plan, as it would enable the competitors to develop tactics and strategies which would counteract the company’s plans. This means that the management accountant faces a dilemma in deciding the extent and nature of the strategic information to be disclosed by the company.
Section C solutions Solution 4 Common errors confusion over the word ‘setting’ lack of definitions for levels of strategy; liability to link these levels; lack of application to the case. Hofer and Schendel distinguish between corporate strategy (what business to be in), business strategy (which market segments to serve and how), and functional strategy (detail by department). The corporate strategy of a company like Tub plc will convert its ‘mission’ – what it is all about as a business – into practical policies on markets to be served and how to generate and manage growth. Tub plc’s corporate strategy is to grow its businesses in particular markets in the kitchen and bathroom furnishings sector, building a stronger group by gradually and organically 2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
return expected, as this additional information would reduce the risks faced by investors in the company. Creditors and lenders. This group would appreciate being provided with forward-looking information as they are interested in assessing the ability of the company to repay the amounts owed to them. By having access to information which focuses on future rather than past performance, they would be able to judge the company’s prospects of repayment more effectively. This would benefit the company if it leads to a reduction in the cost of borrowing. Employees. Providing forward-looking information to the employees would enable them to assess their long-term employment prospects which will be linked to the survival of the firm. Although this is difficult to assess, the provision of future-oriented strategic information would aid them and may act as a motivating factor which would benefit the company. Customers. This group of stakeholders would be interested in the forward-looking information as they are concerned with the long-term survival of the company. If they are convinced that the company was being managed effectively, it is possible that they would prefer to place orders with the company and this would represent a competitive advantage as a result of publishing the forward-looking information.
65
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
66
SOLUTIONS TO REVISION QUESTIONS P5
building up stronger individual companies through related diversification, and financing this growth internally. In formulating the corporate strategy of Tub plc, the directors need to consider Tub plc’s overall strengths and weaknesses in relation to competitors, customers and suppliers in each market served, and assess current trends so that opportunities can be maximised and threats minimised. Group corporate strategy will decide such questions as where to focus group resources (core businesses). Other group-level strategic choices cover such areas as:
Degree of investment in automation – Tub plc has favoured automation as a source of competitive advantage. Culture and people strategies – Tub plc has adopted good HR policies, encouraging local empowerment of managers, and has built good relations with distributors. The business also uses a TQM approach. Management structure – Tub plc provides a minimalist superstructure with a coordination role, capable of using its scale advantages wherever useful – for example, buying power, HR standards, technology, marketing.
Within the overall corporate strategy – which appears to be as much a framework of goals as a formal plan – operating companies follow their own business strategies for growth. Thus, while overseas activities are coordinated in one group entity, the emphasis each business puts on overseas activity appears to be determined locally. At group level, Tub plc’s management may well balance ‘cash cows’ with ‘rising stars’ to ensure that the group remains in healthy balance as it goes forward. This is also a key issue in managing corporate strategy. Business strategy refers to how a business unit approaches its markets. For example, Marks & Spencer (a large UK retailer) has extended its presence in out-of-town shopping centres, extended its activities into financial services, and refined the standardisation of its product range and presentation style. As another example, McDonald’s has increased its range of non-beef products in the United Kingdom following a health scare surrounding British beef. I would determine the business strategy of Tub plc’s companies by reference to the group strategy and the capacity of the companies to benefit from collaboration, by reference to their individual competencies and local competitive conditions, and by matching resources to opportunities in each company. I would analyse the strategic position of each company (using techniques such as SWOT analysis, value chain analysis, and Porter’s five forces analysis) to explore the alternatives, and then choose a set of strategic moves that would be clear-cut and measurable in implementation. Each business strategy would be designed (‘crafted’) to build incrementally upon the emergent strategic themes in that business. I would then make sure that the feedback loop worked, so that information from the market on the impact of one strategic decision could be fully and promptly factored in the evolution of future strategic plans. I would not embark upon detailed large-scale planning, but rather seek to keep the entrepreneurial local opportunism that has characterised much of Tub plc’s past success. To support and focus the ongoing process, I would aim to formalise a strategic review exercise on a biennial basis. Porter has identified three generic business strategies (cost leadership, differentiated brand marketing, and niche focus) which a company might adopt in response to its 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Solution 5
Note the phrase ‘L’s strategic objective has been to exploit market opportunities’. This encapsulates the issues clearly: – presently the objectives are set by one man; – the objectives are not really objectives in the sense of targets – they are more like aims. This suggests a style akin to ‘freewheeling opportunism’. Try to visualise the firm. Would thinking of the Virgin Group with L in the role of Richard Branson help? By going to the market, BZ Ltd will need to respond to a wider group of stakeholders, notably its investors. These will require reliable financial returns and more formalised strategies. Keeping the share price high will require that the firm has longer-term strategies in place and shows an ability to achieve them. Also the prevailing rules of corporate governance will frown on an organisation so clearly controlled by one man and will demand that he shares power with a board of executive and non-executive directors.
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
analysis of its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. This is also the resourcebased approach to strategy formation – which tends to focus not so much on where we should be heading in relation to our markets, but on what tools we have to work with. Functional strategies are important as this is the level at which strategy is implemented in detail. The accumulated effect of the strategic steps taken in each function of a business (finance, marketing, production, etc.) determines the strategic development of that business. For example, a finance department strategy may be to buy a new computerised information system that will help control the business better, enabling value to be added in various ways across the company. Similarly, the functional strategy of the production department may be to automate the production of product X so that it can be made in volume around the clock and at lower cost, creating a strategic opportunity for the company to compete on price and a strategic pressure to increase its share of that market and skew its investment in that direction. Steps taken by functional departments need to be tied into the business unit strategy because otherwise departmental actions can thwart or counter the thrust of the overall business (or add too little value within the overall value chain of the business). Functional strategies within operating companies do accumulate upwards (like building blocks) into business unit development and hence into overall group strategy. Sometimes, one development in a corner of a large group can spread out and influence its whole direction, for example, one of the R&D units in a large pharmaceutical group developed a drug that was such a success that it dominated the development of the whole group. In developing functional strategies, there is both a top-down and a bottom-up communications exchange. This helps to ensure that the right strategic decisions are taken, that the detail will work, and that everyone is aware of the plan and personally engaged in its fulfilment. Functional strategies provide readily measurable implementation, are digestible elements of the overall plan, and convert theory into practice at the sharp end.
67
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
68
SOLUTIONS TO REVISION QUESTIONS P5
However, in setting up more formal strategic processes BZ plc will need to ensure that it does not lose its dynamism or lose or demotivate L himself. There are various ways to tackle part (b) of the question: – describe the use of emergent strategies and describe the role of L as a shaper of these; – recommend the rational model of business strategy (but mention that it may lack flexibility); – describe some of the issues that must be overcome to make the transition to a more formal approach to strategy. The solution suggested here takes the last-mentioned approach. This demonstrates that there is rarely just one right answer. (a) BZ Ltd is a firm characterised by freewheeling opportunitism (Peters). It has been successful through the differentiated service that L has provided to his customers. It is clear that this is the source of the firm’s competitive advantage and the success of the company has created an opportunity to expand. This will involve significant changes in the strategic objectives of the firm. 1. Objectives of shareholders become important. Raising capital by means of a public issue of shares will mean that there are additional stakeholders in the company. The shareholders will expect a reasonable return on their investment and so the dividend policy and investment decisions will have to take account of the requirements of the new shareholders. In many instances, equity investors expect higher returns to reward them for taking greater risks. This will mean that BZ Ltd will need to adopt a strategic objective to satisfy these new shareholders. It is possible that there will be a conflict between the long-term success of the company and the short-term needs of the new shareholders. This is the problem of short-termism, which is often encountered in this type of situation. 2. Broader management participation in setting objectives. Until now, L has set the firm’s objectives on his own. The appointment of senior managers to assist in the firm’s expansion will change this. The larger firm and the requirements of the stock market mean that there will now be a number of managers. Each will expect to have their career goals and aspirations met within the firm. This may require the strategic objectives of the company to be modified. L will need to be aware of these matters in developing any strategic plans and also in the management of the organisation. Indeed the process of strategy formulation will now mean the objectives will be set collectively. This will lead to the problem of conflicting objectives. 3. Greater formalisation of objectives. Until now the objective of BZ Ltd has ‘been to exploit market opportunities’. This is not really a formal objective because it is not capable of measurement. Rather it is more of a mission. Furthermore, the objective is not formal but rather exists in L’s head. In future, BZ will need to develop formal objectives with measures and dates and these will need to be formally communicated to management and to investors. 4. Objectives become used for divisional control. The prime responsibility of L will change from the planning and operational management of the company to the strategic planning and management of the firm. L will not exercise the total control and responsibility that he had at the start of the operation, and it is important that he delegates responsibility to the senior managers who are appointed. This will make it necessary for strategic
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
In this more formally structured organisation it is essential that responsibilities are established and recognised by all the management and staff and that adequate control is maintained. Objectives are a method of communicating the priorities of the business and, through performance measurement, can form the basis of control. It is very important that L is able to focus on the strategic issues and leave operational decisions to the senior managers. Although this change in attitude may be difficult, it is important that the founder delegates the responsibilities effectively if the company is to benefit from the changed situation. (b) Since the founding of BZ Ltd, the proprietor has been involved in both operational and strategic decision-making in the company. However, if funds are raised through public issue and the senior managers appointed, these new stakeholders will make it necessary for the strategic planning process to be modified. It will be necessary to consider the roles of the different managers in the development of the firm’s strategy. It is likely that the entire process will become more formalised and structured as the participation of senior managers will be necessary. 1. Assessment of the internal and external environments. The functional specialists will provide information to assess both the external and internal environment of the firm. From their business experience it is likely that they will be able to provide a more effective assessment of the strategic position of the firm in relation to the current competition and technology. 2. Establishing goals and objectives. The shareholders will have expectations of the firm and management will need to develop a strategy that meets the expected levels of growth and profitability. In addition, managers’ career development expectations will need to be considered. 3. Business strategy and implementation. The increased funds will enable the company to pursue more business opportunities. However, it is important that the firm retains some flexibility, so that new ventures can be undertaken. 4. Monitoring and evaluation. It will be essential that reports are produced which analyse the performance of the company, especially in terms of the new ventures. In general terms, L is likely to find that he can no longer make all the decisions within the firm. In particular, there will be other parties that will be concerned with determining the goals and objectives, allocating the resources that are available and assessing the success of the decisions that are implemented. It will be essential that L assume a stewardship role on behalf of the other stakeholders. It will also be necessary for arrangements to be made to ensure the publication of the accounting reports that are required by the regulatory bodies. It is possible that these changes will be unacceptable to L and he may prefer to forgo the opportunity to expand as it will mean that a considerable amount of control will be lost in raising funds from the public issue and by appointing senior managers to manage the expanding firm.
2005.1
THE NATURE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
business units (SBUs) to be created and within them the functional areas of the firm to be delineated.
69
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Strategy, Structure and Culture
2
L EARNING O UTCOMES After completing this chapter you should be able to: "
evaluate different organisational structures;
"
discuss concepts in contemporary thinking on strategic management.
2.1 Strategy and structure This is likely to be examined quite frequently. There are two main views on the relationship between strategy and structure. The first, put forward by Alfred Chandler (1962), was based on a study of the development of large corporations in the United States, from which he concluded that ‘structure follows strategy’. The focus of the study was on the historical development of the corporations and strategy was defined simply in terms of changes in product and market areas. The key stages of development identified by Chandler are summarised below:
Key strategic issue
Structure
Accumulating and controlling raw materials and resources Rationalising the use of resources to improve efficiency Diversification into new products and/or markets Rationalising the use of diversified resources
Entrepreneurial Functional (Holding company) Divisional
Chandler observed that the transition from one form of structure to another usually did not take place as soon as the key strategic issue changed. He suggested that although the founders or entrepreneurs were typically very astute at strategy development and 71
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
72
STUDY MATERIAL P5
implementation, they tended to know very little about organisation structure. As a result the move to a more appropriate structure was often a slow and painful process, which sometimes involved the departure of the founder of the business. Recent research has questioned the view that ‘structure always follows strategy’, and argued instead that ‘strategy often follows structure’. This second view, that ‘strategy often follows structure’, is based on the idea that managers already working within a particular organisation structure will take the structure for granted and only consider strategies that will ‘fit’ with the existing structure. The reason for managerial reluctance to change structure is associated with the time-consuming effort involved in such a process and the fact that some managers will have vested interests in maintaining the structure as it is. Besides choosing a structure, an organisation must also establish appropriate organisational control systems. It must decide how best to assess the performance and control the actions of subunits. The options range from market and output controls to bureaucratic controls and control through organisational culture. An organisation also needs to decide what kind of reward and incentive systems to set up for employees. Finally, a company must achieve a fit, or congruence, between its strategy structure and controls. Since different strategies and environments place different demands on an organisation, they call for different structural responses and control systems. For example, a strategy of cost leadership demands that an organisation be kept simple (so as to reduce costs) and that operations and controls stress productive efficiency. On the other hand, a strategy of differentiating a company’s product by unique technical characteristics generates a need for integrating the company’s activities around its technological core and establishing control systems that reward technical creativity.
2.2 Organisational structure Typically, the term ‘organisational structure’ has been used to describe the internal operational structure, including the structures described under the terms ‘functional, divisional or matrix’ which are discussed below. However, the financial structure of an organisation, not part of the syllabus for Integrated Management, nowadays plays an increasing role in determining the overall forms of an organisation, its boundary with its environment, and even the various environments (or domains) themselves. Organisations seem to be in conflict. There is a never-ending demand for everincreasing economies of scale, while simultaneously customer sophistication leads to the need for reactive and yet also proactive policies. The question is: How can these different forces be contained? We must start with the definition of an organisation and then make some attempt to widen this to include quasi-organisations (‘almost-organisations’) which are appearing today such as franchised firms (like Bodyshop, McDonald’s), integrated dealerships or resellers who are to allowed to sell other products (such as are found in the motor trade), and joint ventures (which involve a separate company usually with shareholdings being set up), partnerships and alliances. In this way it is possible to have a market penetration at lowest cost, and internally to reduce overheads by outsourcing activities considered ‘non-core’ into the market. Other external groupings include ‘bidding consortia’ in construction, purchasing groups in retailing, and employers’ and trade associations (negotiating and lobbying, respectively). With this background we can analyse the way internal structures have been developed to manage the external complexity and turbulence in the environment. We can see from our 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2.2.1 Internal structure All organisations have some form of structure, which should facilitate the implementation of strategy and the achievement of objectives. In simple terms, an organisation’s structure can be defined as ‘the established pattern of relationships among the individuals, groups and departments within it’ or more pragmatically as ‘the arrangements for the allocation and control of resources’. Clearly then there are two structures – a vertical structure of authority and responsibility where clear limits of financial authority exist, and a horizontal structure of groupings of activities designed to use the resources towards goal-attainment. Although the horizontal structures can be changed from time to time, the basic vertical structure of an organisation is a relatively static framework within which processes such as communication, leadership and decision-making take place. Organisation structure is concerned with the way in which work is divided up and allocated, and how coordination to achieve objectives is achieved. This can be described as an organisation’s basic structure, and in some organisations it will be illustrated in the form of a chart (simple organisation charts will be used to describe the main types of structure later in this chapter). Another part of the idea of structure is the process that goes on underneath the signified relationships: these are described more fully in a later chapter. Here, we need to emphasise that the operating mechanisms are used to reinforce the basic structure and to clarify what is expected of employees. Examples include written rules and regulations, job descriptions, reward systems, and so on. Classical management theory was preoccupied with trying to find the best form of organisation structure. Finding the right type of structure for an organisation involves trying to balance pressures for uniformity and standardisation with those pulling towards diversity and uniqueness. The basic types of structure represent some of the responses to these pressures as an organisation develops. In seeking the right balance for a particular set of circumstances, managers have to pay particular attention to the process of delegation and the resultant degree of decentralisation of decision-making in the organisation. Of course, the forms of organisation are not mutually exclusive and it is common to find hybrid forms in which two or more types are combined. For example, a matrix structure can be superimposed on a functional or divisional one. Similarly, a divisional structure could be primarily based on product divisions but have one international division.
2.2.2 Organisational design and contingency theory The basic problem of organisational design is to formulate and establish a structure to facilitate the achievement of organisational goals. This requires two basic issues to be dealt with:
How to divide the work to be performed into a number of distinct tasks. How to group the tasks together to achieve the overall goals in an efficient manner. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
later discussion of chain of command, scalar principle, and line–staff relationships that a key problem for managers arises from the need to have people who specialise in different tasks and then coordinate their activities into a unified whole. Attempts by managers to resolve this problem have produced various forms of organisation. Some of the different forms of organisation are considered below.
73
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
74
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Early contributions to organisation theory, such as the classical management approach, attempted to put forward general principles of management to guide the design of appropriate organisation structures. These principles tended to emphasise tightly organised, bureaucratic structures. At the time many of the principles were first put forward, large organisations were typically entering the strategic phase identified by Chandler as rationalising the use of resources to improve efficiency. Since this usually required a functional structure the classical approach proved quite useful. However, the development of more complex strategies and environments has rendered this approach less useful. In order to understand the requirements of effective organisational design it is useful to consider first of all the main dimensions of organisation structure.
2.2.3 Contingency theory The research into administrative intensity and size illustrates how structural relationships are contingent or dependent on a number of factors. This has contributed to the emergence of contingency theories which stress the importance of finding the best structure for particular circumstances. The key factors to take into account are as follows:
Size – as illustrated above in the discussion of administrative intensity. Technology – the techniques, equipment and specialised knowledge used to transform organisational inputs into outputs that can be returned to customers or clients with added value, will have some impact on the design of an appropriate organisation structure. People – the type of people employed and their skills, competencies and level of motivation. Past experience and pattern of ownership – organisational design rarely starts with a blank sheet of paper; the history of the organisation and whether the owners are directly involved in managing it will exert some influence on organisational design. Environment – the concept of organisations as open systems has been explained in an earlier chapter and this highlights the importance for organisational design of factors in the organisational environment, particularly Burns and Stalker’s studies.
2.2.4 Structural characteristics Academic researchers have attempted to classify the dimensions of organisation structure. One way of doing this is to distinguish between the following structural characteristics:
Specialisation – this reflects the extent of division of labour within the structure. Standardisation – the extent to which specific procedures exist to deal with the tasks to be carried out within the organisation. Formalisation – describes the extent to which procedures and rules are written down. Centralisation – the extent to which authority to make decisions is in the hands of a few senior managers. Configuration – the shape of the organisation as illustrated in a detailed organisation chart.
This type of approach is useful when making comparisons between different organisations as it permits profiles of each organisation to be drawn up using the various structural characteristics.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
The larger the organisation the lower the administrative intensity. Factors other than size also influence administrative intensity (e.g. the organisation’s environment, technology, etc). The rate at which size is changing is an important factor. Administrative intensity is a function of both the size and the complexity of an organisation.
2.2.5 Strategic choice and the issue of consistency Strategic choice is the context within which an organisation exists; it will constrain choices about the most appropriate structure but will not determine them; an element of choice is open to strategic decision-makers both in terms of the environments they choose to operate in and the forms of structure they believe to be best. Certain groups will be better placed than others, because of their power in the organisation, to influence or resist structural changes. This, along with the difficulties of obtaining simple, unambiguous measures of effectiveness against which the appropriateness of different structures can be objectively judged, helps to explain why organisational politics often plays a significant part in decisions about reorganisation. One of the potential problems for managers attempting to adopt a contingency theory approach to organisational design is what to do when faced with contingent factors that pull in opposite directions; for example, large size requiring formalisation and competitive markets requiring flexibility. The danger is that each is taken into account in a way that leads to inconsistencies in organisational design. To avoid this danger managers must take into account the overall configuration of the organisation. In particular, they should attempt to ensure that the structures and systems adopted are consistent with the organisation’s culture and the philosophy of its management. John Child (1984) presents evidence from a study he conducted of four North American airlines and one European airline which lends some tentative support to the importance of consistency between various structural arrangements. In particular, he found that the more successful airlines employed different forms of organisation to each other despite facing the same contingencies: what distinguished them from the less successful ones was that they demonstrated a high degree of internal consistency in the approach to management and organisation they had adopted. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Administrative intensity One of the most intensively researched aspects of organisation structure is the relationship between size and the number of employees in administrative or support roles. This particular personnel ratio is referred to as administrative intensity. Interest in this relationship was initially stimulated by Parkinson’s Law (Northcote Parkinson, 1955) which in its simplest form states that ‘work expands to fill the time available for its completion.’ The consequence of this for organisations is alleged to be that as they grow the proportion of administrative and staff personnel grows more than proportionally. The commonsense appeal of Parkinson’s Law has proved very difficult to verify by research. In fact, one study of a number of hospitals found that administrative intensity actually decreased with increasing size. The following tentative conclusions can be drawn about the impact of size on administrative intensity.
75
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
76
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Figure 2.1
Entrepreneurial structure
2.2.6 Entrepreneurial organisation (Figure 2.1) A small organisation has the entrepreneur at its head, probably a technical manager rather than a financial manager, though this is increasingly possible. Can you think of an example of a technical and a non-technical entrepreneur? Microsoft’s Bill Gates is most people’s choice for the former, or Steve Jobs at Apple. Craig Pollock’s management of Formula One former world champion driver Jacques Villeneuve and the new Formula One BAR team would be an example of the latter – Pollock used to be a schoolteacher. The core of the entrepreneurial organisation tends to be technical, as such expertise is at the heart of the business. External technical advice may be sought from manufacturers of equipment or consultants. Support staff will be very few in number – perhaps a part-time secretary or the owner’s spouse or family or friends helping out with admin. Decisions will be centralised and the culture a mixture of task and power. The entrepreneur will coordinate everything and delegate where s/he feels it is necessary; this may not be on strictly rational grounds. The transition from an entrepreneurial to a functional structure occurs essentially because there are limits to the extent to which one person can personally supervise or carry out all of the organisation’s tasks. When this point is reached it is necessary to start to delegate formal authority to other people and to make them accountable for carrying out specific activities. Although this process is essential for efficient and effective management in all but the smallest of organisations, there is often considerable reluctance by managers to delegate and also for subordinates to accept it. The key reasons for this are probably fear and lack of trust as, although the manager can increase decentralisation by delegating the authority to make decisions to subordinates, the manager is still accountable for the consequences of these decisions. The manager fears losing control and may not trust the subordinate’s ability to carry out the activities. The subordinate on the other hand may be suspicious about the motives behind delegation and unclear about who is ultimately responsible for specific tasks.
2.2.7 Functional organisation The most common form of structure adopted when an organisation has outgrown the entrepreneurial one is a functional structure (Figure 2.2). This divides the organisation up into its main activities or functions (production, sales, accounting and so on) in which all similar specialist activities are grouped together into interdependent departments. A manager is placed in charge of each function under the overall control of 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Functional structure
the owner or a senior manager. This form of organisation has a number of potential advantages:
Specialised resources are used efficiently. Quality is enhanced by other specialists from the same functional area. Opportunities exist for extensive division of labour. A career structure enables people to advance within their functional specialism. It is easier to manage specialists if they are grouped together, especially when the manager has the same experience. It fosters communication between specialists and enhances the development of skill and knowledge. It does not duplicate specialist resources throughout the organisation and promotes economies of scale. It is suited to conditions which stress functional specialism, where the environment is stable, and when the technology is routine, requiring little interdependence between departments.
However, a functional structure promotes a narrow focus on specialist interests. The following problems might arise:
increased need for interdepartmental coordination and scheduling; communication, coordination overload the vertical hierarchy; inefficient coordination of functional departments; responsibility for overall outcomes is unclear; interdepartmental conflicts; little creativity and innovation; difficulties in identifying profitable and unprofitable products.
These problems are likely to occur with professionalism and a role culture where job demarcations are felt to be important. When the organisation reaches a certain size, they are likely to be exacerbated especially if it has developed a wide range of products or services. They may be solved by adopting a holding company or a divisional structure in which profit centres based on particular products or geographical areas are created. Burns and Stalker (1961) devised the term ‘mechanistic’ for firms where the interconnections are strong as they are unsuited to changeable environments and non-routine technologies. A more flexible and responsive form is needed than the rigidly functional.
2.2.8 Holding companies: ‘federated firms’ and franchises Full divisionalisation can solve some of the problems of a functional form but requires the development of new accounting information systems to implement the new systems of management control involved in operating such a structure. While these systems are being 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Figure 2.2
77
STUDY MATERIAL P5
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
78
Figure 2.3 Simplified structure of Mobil Oil Corporation Inc. in the United Kingdom in the 1970s
developed, an intermediate form of holding company structure may evolve (Figure 2.3), in which separate business units exist in a loose ‘federation’. The lack of financial controls and coordinating mechanisms in this arrangement are likely, however, to produce a crisis of control, and jeopardise movement to a fully developed divisional structure. Alternatively, this form may be used to describe some of the more adventurous partnerships and alliances in the supply chain or market referred to in the introduction. Hanson and other conglomerates which actually add value (most such firms do not) arguably exist only by financial measures being tightly controlled from the centre. This was the basis of the financial success of Sir Arnold Weinstock’s GEC empire where the centre had control over the separate businesses which were set up as ‘management companies’. These each had a bank account into which monthly sales revenues were scheduled and from which budgetary amounts were withdrawn for wages and other costs. Where there was any deficit, there was an immediate cash problem which was either solved internally or which had to be referred by the local MD to Sir Arnold personally. In this way extreme cost-sensitivity was instilled in each operating company, but there were no shareholders. In a holding company structure, the headquarters unit will act almost as an investment company for a largely independent group of operating companies. Any businesses that are acquired will probably continue to trade under their original name. The limitations of the holding company approach include the lack of centralised skills to support the business, the individual units being unlikely to add up to more than the sum of the parts and absence of a coherent corporate strategy. Identify some holding company structures. McDonald’s and Body Shop are franchises, Lonrho and BTR are conglomerates where the holding company structure may be ideal for their strategies of acquisition, rationalisation and selling-off of businesses.
2.2.9 Divisional organisation A divisional structure (see Figure 2.4) can help to overcome the limitations of the holding company and/or a functional structure, as it contains within it functional specialists but groups its activities around products or regions. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
79 STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Figure 2.4
Divisional structures – product based
In particular, divisionalisation, with its emphasis on profit centres, should promote clear accountability, longer planning horizons, and the development of future senior executives with general management experience as divisional leaders. Alfred Sloan is widely accepted as developing a true divisional structure for the disparate firms owned by General Motors Corporation in the 1930s, bringing together a central function to garner expertise from the different firms such as Pontiac, Cadillac and Chevrolet. Eventually however, according to John De Lorean, the centre became so powerful that these divisions effectively reverted to becoming departments, with no real autonomy. This tension between the centre and divisions or departments is a crucial problem of control for all organisations. Too much control stifles innovation but too little is a recipe for wild excesses of spending on pet projects such as happened in Rolls-Royce where the RB211 engine project overruns nearly bankrupted the company. Two ways of grouping activities are supposed to ensure a closeness to the customer which is not really possible in a functional structure. These groupings are based on product or location. Product organisation People and resources are grouped according to an organisation’s products. General Motors (GM), for example, has plants combining a variety of specialist resources for specific products (Chevrolet, Cadillac, Pontiac, etc.) or projects (the new compact car, the Vega, was a centrally run project at GM). Divisional managers have considerable authority – in effect a small business (sometimes temporary) is created within a large one. This enables technical excellence and concentration on fewer product lines, and a liaison with a smaller set of customers, realising more creativity in marketing and sales through focus, teamwork and goal consensus. This format is used most successfully where there is a variety of products, each addressing different markets. Regional organisation Where organisations have few products, such as IBM, they may group activities according to sales area and be literally ‘closer to the customer’ (Figure 2.5). This enables regional differences to appear in marketing research and be directly translated into branch-level contact and projects based on local stakeholders. In this way IBM gets to know the details of the businesses in an area and its sales team focus on local chamber of commerce 2005.1
STUDY MATERIAL P5
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
80
Figure 2.5
Divisional structures – geographically based
meetings and social contacts at the golf club or race track, meeting senior people from potential clients informally as well as formally who are decision-makers for IBM’s big customers. Advantages of divisionalisation It provides excellent coordination across functional departments. Since departmental units are often small, as well as self-contained, employees identify with the product or project rather than their own function. Since each division can, for example, react to customer requirements, it is well suited to changeable environments. As such, a move to divisions is particularly useful for large organisations. Cellular manufacturing can even be considered a kind of internal divisionalisation with an emphasis on internal customers, just-in-time links between different ‘products’ and the dynamism created through teamwork. Disadvantages of divisionalisation There may be a costly duplication of resources across departments. Specialists may become isolated from both their colleagues and fail to further their specialist skills. Competing demands on people may create stress. Coordination across divisions is difficult. For many large entities, a divisional structure will be the most appropriate form of organisation, but in certain circumstances it may eventually have to be adapted to include formal mechanisms to promote closer interdivisional collaboration: the result will be a matrix structure in which vertical and horizontal formal relationships are recognised.
2.2.10 Matrix organisation Allegedly this was introduced as the main structure by NASA when President John F Kennedy demanded ‘a man on the moon within ten years’. The achievement of this goal was apparently due to the new structure NASA adopted to link the functional 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
However, many organisations run with a matrix structure implicitly and always have done so. Big factories have zones where maintenance staff are assigned so that they know the equipment and can repair broken machinery quickly – but they report to the maintenance manager as functional head. Universities have courses within which functional staff teach various elements – statistics, law or management, for example – and who report to their functional heads. Such set-ups are not often referred to as matrix organisations because they are at a lower level than the NASA example. A matrix structure seeks to add flexibility and lateral coordination to the traditional vertical hierarchy. One way of doing this is to create project teams made up of members drawn from a variety of different functions or divisions: each individual then has a dual role, as he or she maintains functional/divisional responsibilities as well as membership of the project team. The matrix structure is sometimes appropriate for large multi-product companies which have significant interrelationships between their various operating units. Hence, both vertical and horizontal relationships are emphasised, and employees within a department will report to both a functional and a product manager, each of which has equal authority. There is a dual chain of command which violates classical principles. If implemented successfully this form of structure can:
improve decision-making by bringing a wide range of expertise to problems that cut across departmental or divisional boundaries; replace formal control by direct contact; assist in the development of managers by exposing them to company-wide problems and decisions; improve lateral communication and cooperation between specialists.
A matrix structure (Figure 2.6) suits rapidly changing environments because the equal balance of power between functional and product management aids communication and
Figure 2.6
Matrix structure 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
specialists in the background departments intimately with the problem-solvers on the construction and research and development team for the Apollo mission. This mixture became known as a matrix.
81
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
82
STUDY MATERIAL P5
coordination. It is an organic structure which facilitates adaptation to unfamiliar and unexpected problems. People can be flexibly relocated across products or projects, aiding the speedy implementation of new ones. Employees have the opportunity to develop either functional or general management skills. Consequently, it is useful for medium-sized organisations with a medium number of products or for task-centred organisations where project work is a feature of life, such as in the ‘small batch/unit’ production grouping used by Joan Woodward. Of course there are disadvantages with such a complex structure.
A lack of clear responsibility; Clashes of priority between product and function; Functions lose control of the psychological contract; Career development can often be stymied; Difficult for one specialist to appraise performance of another discipline in multi-skilled teams; Project managers are reluctant to impose authority as they may be subordinates in a later project; Employees may be confused by reporting to two bosses; Managers will need to be able to resolve interpersonal frictions and may need training in human relations skills; Managers spend a great deal of time in meetings to prioritise tasks.
The complexity of the matrix structure makes it difficult to implement successfully. Indeed some commentators are very critical of this form of organisation, and question whether it should be adopted at all. Thus, Peters and Waterman (1982, p. 307) state: ‘Our favourite candidate for the wrong kind of complex response, of course, is the matrix organisation structure. People aren’t sure to whom they should report for what the organisation gets paralysed because the structure not only does not make priorities clear, it automatically dilutes priorities. In effect, it says to people down the line ‘everything is important: pay equal attention to everything.’ How convinced are you by the criticisms of matrix structures put forward by Peters and Waterman? Do you think there are some types of situations when this form of organisation would work well? If the matrix structure is to avoid these problems, the key roles are those of the leaders of the units with cross-departmental or divisional responsibilities: they have to develop effective teams, but at the same time minimise the problems facing team members who also have other responsibilities in their department or division.
2.2.11 Flexible firms, networks and complex organisation forms This is likely to be examined quite frequently. Complex forms of organisation are usually thought of as occupying the ground between pure forms of market transactions and hierarchical organisations. They are regarded as an alternative way of coordinating resources. The idea seems to have grown out of Oliver Williamson’s idea of ‘transaction costs’ – that market relations incur such costs, while in trying to avoid them by internalisation, hierarchical forms of organisation result (see later 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
83 STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Figure 2.7
The flexible firm
(Source: After Atkinson, 1984) NB: The shaded segments are not under contracts of employment with the flexible firm.
in this chapter). Unfortunately, the lack of competition within hierarchical organisations itself results itself in a lack of control on costs, as mentioned above. The complex forms attempt to overcome the inadequacies of both market and hierarchical forms through collaboration between existing organisations. The drivers for cooperation are of two sorts – cost reduction and market penetration. The cutting of costs internally has resulted in a wave of outsourcing of non-core activities and research and development alliances. Market penetration is perhaps more common and allows economies of scale such as ShellMex and BP achieved in the 1950s with their joint distribution network, or more recently where construction consortia bid for motorway contracts. Such organisations would range from cooperatives between organisations and their suppliers, to all forms of partnerships and alliances in which coordination of resources was based on cooperation between the parties concerned. Increasingly, organisations are forming complicated vertical and horizontal relationships through demergers, downsising, delayering and margin retreat from product scope and geographical spread. These pressures are essentially economic and in response to Japanese and Pacific Rim penetration of Western markets. At the same time globalisation means that scale economies are necessary to maintain price differentials and so mergers of parts of businesses where there is strategic fit is becoming commonplace. Mass production and engineering industries have been swift to act, but commodity industries have in particular been slow to respond. Mergers, demergers, joint ventures and partnerships were typical of oil firms in their exploration and production activities and are now increasingly in their downstream operations. Chemicals firms have gone through a series of recent acquisitions and spin-offs; automotive manufacturers have acquired or merged to give scale economies. Examples are the Shell/Exxon 50–50 joint venture in the 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
84
STUDY MATERIAL P5
North Sea called ShellExpro; the acquisition of the ICI ‘cracker’ unit at Wilton works by BP Chemicals; the spin-off of Zeneca pharmaceuticals from ICI. Mergers are a form of complex organisation where, for example, automotive parts are shared across divisions or companies and recently include Daimler-Benz (Mercedes) and Chrysler, Renault taking 37 per cent of Nissan Motor, Ford acquiring Aston Martin and Jaguar and so on. Various partnerships also exist in the automotive industry – Renault engines in Volvo cars, for example. Joint ventures should mean that each sponsoring organisation has a degree of equity participation, while partnerships may not, and may or may not share assets. Consortia are short-term legal entities with sunk costs from each of the partners and which terminate at the end of the project. Alliance is a term used for a weaker non-legal entity kind of operation where firms simply contract to work together on a gain-share/pain-share basis. Termination clauses would vary with the nature of the cooperation, as would sharing of facilities and the purchase of equipment. We do not know the full extent of such complex structures but there is evidence that the gains stated at the outset have not been harvested, indeed that most outsourcing has increased costs and decreased reliability of supply. This may be due to the reluctance in the West to embrace relational contracting, or as it is known in Japan, obligatory contracting, where ‘sunk costs’ on both sides are considerable and the social norms mitigate against overt exploitation by either party. Networks have been described as a link between supplier and purchaser in the supply chain but a more accurate and useful division is between different suppliers, imitating the coordination methods employed within the firms. In Italy experiments have been made to introduce networks in technologically similar industries in areas called ‘business districts’. For example, in the textile industry, contractors are based in the same region as the knitwear firms and often do work for several different firms, sometimes in alliances or partnerships with other contracts, sometimes as sole contract-holder. There exists then a technology transfer opportunity for the major textile firms as contractors learn the businesses of other firms. This saving on learning curve and experience curve effects becomes a competitive advantage for all the firms, provided that they do not compete on goals centred on internal process or system resources. Were this the case, a conflict of interest would arise and textile majors would be reluctant to use the contractors who were not 100 per cent specific to them.
2.2.12 Mintzberg’s (1983) structural configurations This is likely to be examined quite frequently. Mintzberg puts forward a different way of looking at what he calls ‘structural configurations’. He contends that each of these configurations is suitable for an organisation at different stages of its development. The difference between each one is that it achieves coordination and congruence between environment, resources and values in distinct ways. This is reflected in variations in the degree and type of decentralisation. The five configurations described by Mintzberg are as follows:
Simple structure – this is essentially the same as the entrepreneurial structure (Figure 2.8) already described. All important decisions are made by the owner and there will probably be little formal planning or structure. Organisational effectiveness is almost
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Figure 2.9
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Figure 2.8
85
The simple structure
The machine bureaucracy
entirely dependent on the strategic vision of the owner. Specialist management accounting is unlikely to play a part within this form of highly centralised organisation. Machine bureaucracy – in this form, jobs are closely defined and work highly standardised. A functional structure (Figure 2.9) is likely to be adopted with limited decentralisation to functional managers. Strategic decisions will still be centralised. Typically, there will be a powerful group of analysts and specialists whose job is to search for cost savings and efficiency improvements (e.g. work study specialists, management accountants, specialist personnel staff, etc.). This type of structural configuration has been common among large mass-production businesses. The management accounting role and traditional management accounting techniques that have developed mainly in this form of organization are now being challenged by new philosophies such as total quality management. Professional bureaucracy – this form of configuration has developed in organisations such as hospitals and universities, but is being threatened in the United Kingdom by pressures towards greater commercialism and client focus. A professional bureaucracy (Figure 2.10) is much more decentralised than a machine bureaucracy. Power is in the hands of specialist, highly qualified professionals (doctors, professors, etc.), assisted by a group of support administrators. The main method of coordination is by standardising the skills and qualifications required for appointment to specialist positions. Traditionally, the budgeting process in this form of organisation has consisted of some of the key specialists proposing activities and related costs for the coming year; these are then coordinated by the accounting department into an overall budget. This process has, however, been fundamentally changed by the introduction of internal markets and/or new forms of legal organisation (e.g. National Health Service Trusts), which are requiring organisations that have traditionally relied upon professional bureaucracy to look for an alternative structural configuration. 2005.1
STUDY MATERIAL P5
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
86
Figure 2.10 The professional bureaucracy
Figure 2.11 The divisionalised form
Figure 2.12 The adhocracy
Divisional form – as indicated earlier when describing types of organisation structure, this is a method of organisation whereby autonomous units are created around products or markets (Figure 2.11). A great deal of decision-making is decentralised to these units, and the role of the senior managers at the strategic apex at head office is to monitor performance and maintain a strategic overview of the business as a whole. For the management accountant this raises new problems, such as measuring divisional profitability and dealing with issues such as internal transfer pricing. Adhocracy – this is an informal and innovative form of organisation (Figure 2.12) based on teams of specialists and extensive decentralisation. Groups of experts make up the basic operating units, and these are likely to be coordinated through some kind of matrix structure. Authority is based on expertise and the emphasis is on effective task performance. Adhocracy is particularly suited to complex and rapidly changing environments, as strategic changes can originate from any area within it. Businesses such as advertising agencies and management consultancies typically have this form of organisation and management. Adhocracy brings with it problems as well as benefits: the
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
87 STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Figure 2.13 Five basic parts of the organisation
main problem may be the coordination of diverse interests in a situation likely to be conducive to organisational politics. For the management accountant, adhocracy poses a major challenge, both in terms of styles of operation and the applicability of traditional techniques; this is part of a wider and more general challenge facing managers as they seek new paradigms to guide organisations towards the twenty-first century. Mintzberg also suggests that it is useful to view organisations as being made up of five parts (Figure 2.13). The operating core consists of those people who perform the work of rendering the services or producing products. In a small organisation this operating core may represent nearly all of the organisation, but larger size will require more complex arrangements. There will be a requirement to formulate and implement strategy so that the organisation serves its mission in an effective way; this is the role of the strategic apex which may in some circumstances also be responsible for linking the organisation to the needs of those who own or control it. The middle line represents the hierarchy of authority from senior managers to first-line supervisors linking the strategic apex to the operating core. As an organisation continues to grow and develop it is likely to include within its structure specialist staff outside the central line positions (i.e. strategic apex, middle line and operating core). The specialist staff are placed into two categories by Mintzberg:
The technostructure is concerned with coordinating work by standardising work processes, outputs and skills, and will be made up of people such as management accountants, work study engineers, personnel managers, etc. Support staff exist to provide assistance to the organisation outside its operating work flow. Examples would be catering services, legal advice and press relations.
Many organisations are now actively seeking flatter hierarchies, better quality and ways of contracting out of non-core activities. What are the implications of these developments for the five basic parts of the organisation identified by Mintzberg? 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
88
STUDY MATERIAL P5
2.3 Organisational culture 2.3.1 The importance of culture in organisations An organisation’s culture will influence its strategy, its ways of doing business and the way it responds to change. A key factor in determining how effective the organisation is will be the appropriateness of its culture for its stakeholders, and particularly its customers. A strong culture will be beneficial if it focuses on these elements and highlights the need to change proactively. On the other hand, a strong culture that does not have these attributes is likely to be a major barrier to effectiveness. The main effects and characteristics of a strong culture will be as follows:
It will strengthen behavioural regularities organisation. It will minimise some of the perceptual organisation. It will reflect the philosophy and values of group. The particular culture will have a significant ability to respond to change.
and norms among members of the differences among people within the the organisation’s founder or dominant effect on the organisation’s strategy and
Some aspects of an organisation’s culture will be visible and obvious, while many others will be both less tangible and more significant (Figure 2.14).
2.3.2 Determinants of culture McKinsey, a large US management consultancy, produced a framework for understanding organisations (the McKinsey 7-S framework) similar to one used by Koontz since 1955. However, Koontz considers the framework lacking in both depth and precision. The 7-S name is clearly intended to stick in the memory rather than arising strictly from the data.
Figure 2.14 The organisational iceberg. From Organisational Behavior, Canadian Edition 1st edition by Hellriegel/Slocum/ Woodman Brun. # 1998. Reprinted with permission of Nelson, a division of Thomson Learning: www.thomsonrights.com. Fax 800 730-2215 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
systems; structure; style; strategy; staff; skills; shared values.
This of course is the ‘soft’ side of enterprise and includes an early reference to the idea of shared values, which we now call ‘culture’. Organisational culture can be described as what the organisation ‘is’, a ground-up set of factors which employees can readily identify. Writers often distinguish this from ‘corporate culture’, which is the management’s view of what is needed to perform well in present competitive markets and something that an organisation ‘has’. This concept of culture is one that has been borrowed from the discipline of anthropology, where it has long been used to describe the way of life of a particular group of people. Other uses of the word involved ‘high-culture’ or ‘the arts’ and the first use of it to organisations was reportedly by American Marxists who reflected that the interests of the ruling elites were transferred downwards in society. The interweaving of laws, customs, press stories and published books reinforced the national culture.
2.3.3 Writers on culture Edgar Schein (1984), in his analysis of different levels of organisational culture, described the more obvious symbols of an organisation’s culture (its ‘artefacts and creations’ ). These are things such as factory and/or office equipment, head office buildings, the way in which employees dress and the provision of information for customers. However, a real understanding of culture requires a deeper probing to reveal what the ‘values’ and ‘basic assumptions’ of organisational members are, which Schein explains as follows: In stating that basic assumptions are unconscious, I am not arguing that this is a result of repression. On the contrary, I am arguing that as certain motivational and cognitive processes are repeated and continue to work, they become unconscious. They can be brought back to awareness only through a kind of focused inquiry, similar to that used by anthropologists. What is needed are the efforts of both an insider who makes the unconscious assumptions and an outsider who helps to uncover the assumptions by asking the right kinds of questions.
Gareth Morgan (1986, 1997) stresses the point that although managers can influence the evolution of culture they cannot control it. He also argues that our understanding of organisational culture is quite superficial, and there is a danger that some managers will see culture as a simple manipulative device for achieving more control over employees. More recently, Geert Hofstede studied the answers to survey questions by over 10 000 IBM employees in different countries, showing consistent international differences in how they view the world. These international cultures emerge above IBM’s own regional culture (its corporate and organisational cultures) as a consistent set of different ways in which managers acted (see Chapter 10 section 8). William Ouchi in 1980 popularised the idea of culture in his book Theory Z: How American Business can Meet the Japanese Challenge. He suggested that there are a number of characteristics that differentiate the typical American firm (Theory A) from the typical 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
The seven factors referred to are:
89
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
90
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Japanese one (Theory J). Of course, Ouchi is generalising when he speaks of the typical American or Japanese organisation. Looked at more closely, organisations in any one country will have important differences and unique features: these differences represent the culture of the particular organisation. He went on to suggest that it was possible for American firms to modify their culture (Theory Z) to help them compete more effectively with the Japanese. Ouchi’s comparison of US and Japanese organisational cultures and the features of each type of culture are summarised as follows: Theory A (US): Employment: Usually short term, with lay-offs quite common. Evaluation and promotion: Very fast. If individuals are not promoted, they seek employment elsewhere. Career path: Very specialised; people tend to stay in one function for the whole of their career. Decision making: Carried out by individual managers. Control: Very explicit. People are aware of their control responsibilities. Responsibility: Assigned on an individual basis. Concern for personnel: The organisation is only concerned with the workers’ work life. Theory J (Japan): Employment: Usually for life, with lay-offs rare. Evaluation and promotion: Very slow. Career path: Very general. Staff are rotated around the organisation Decision making: Carried out by group or committee. Control: Very implicit and informal. People rely on trust. Responsibility: Shared collectively. Concern for personnel: The organisation is concerned with the workers’ whole life. Theory Z Employment: Fairly long term, to encourage a loyal, committed workforce. Evaluation and promotion: Slower, with an emphasis on development and training. Career path: More general, with elements of job rotation and broad training. Decision making: Carried out by individual managers, but seeking consensus from the group. Control: A balance between formal and informal. Responsibility: Assigned on an individual basis. Concern for personnel: The organisation’s concern is expanded to include aspects of the workers’ home life.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Corporate culture: culture-as-a-variable The task for owners and managers is to achieve the right blend of cultures for the organisation’s task and environment. However, managing culture is not a short-term or straightforward task, since it goes beyond slogans and new mission statements: real change requires modifications to values, basic assumptions and behaviour that are not easy to achieve, but which may be increasingly important for many organisations. Handy expanded this as: deep-set beliefs about the way work should be organised, the way authority should be exercised, people rewarded, people controlled – these are all aspects of the culture of an organisation.
The term ‘culture’ can thus be applied to the study of organisations in several different ways, but interest in organisational culture can probably be traced back to Roger Harrison’s questionnaire for charting of four types of culture in 1972 in which he determined ‘corporate culture’ as ‘organisational ideologies’. This approach uses culture as something that the organisation ‘has’ as opposed to what it ‘is’. Corporate culture can be changed, arguably, whereas organisational culture cannot; it only emerges by dint of the shared experience of employees. People can usually articulate the organisation’s key values, and sometimes these are formally set out. For example, Hewlett Packard makes use of statements called the ‘HP Way’ to clarify corporate values to all employees, and in the area of ‘belief in our people’ the following appear:
Confidence in, and respect for, our people as opposed to depending on extensive rules, procedures, etc. Depend on people to do their job right (individual freedom) without constant directives. Opportunity for meaningful participation ( job dignity).
So explicit an approach to the use of culture is still the exception rather than the rule, but organisations promote and act on values whether or not they are formally documented. Underpinning any set of values will be basic assumptions about things such as the relationship between the organisation and its environment, appropriate human relationships (e.g. individualistic and competitive or collective groups) and what motivates people. These will be very important, but largely unconscious. While culturally each organisation is unique, it is useful for purposes of analysis to attempt to identify the main types of organisation culture. Deal and Kennedy 1982/1988 Strong culture theory In their book Corporate Cultures, Deal and Kennedy state: Companies with very strong cultures – the companies that intrigue us most of all – fit [into cultural types] hardly at all. These companies have cultures that artfully blend elements of all four types and blend them in ways that allow these companies to perform well when the environment around them changes as it inevitably does.
Strong refers to the degree to which members subscribe to the norms and values, in effect a kind of psychological ‘cloning’. These norms and values are importantly defined as those espoused by management, and the idea is to use this commitment in the absence of bureaucratic methods, to provide performance enhancement via improved self-motivation. In this way strong cultures link to work on job satisfaction and may overcome job-design 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
2.3.4 Models for categorising culture
91
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
92
STUDY MATERIAL P5
failure associated with the types of technology identified by Joan Woodward. Organisations with strong cultures are supposed to perform better than those with weak ones but the link has not been proven: successful companies obtain the right blend of appropriate cultures, which has a good deal of support from the relevant research literature. The assertion, however, that companies with strong cultures are more interesting, and by implication more successful, is much more debatable. Cabals are especially strong cliques of self-supporting individuals who may derail the process by charisma or Machiavellian methods, such as the Dutch Admiral Paradigm where two recruits mutually praised each other in meetings and eventually became the two youngest Admirals in the Dutch Navy. In this way, a strong culture might begin to reflect the members’ values rather than the organisation’s. Additionally of course it may produce strong resistance to change, later being a victim of ‘groupthink’. Finally, a strong ‘masculine’ culture may not travel well, especially to areas of the world characterised by Hofstede’s ‘feminine’ dimension. The authors also suggested a typology which was not based on any scientific methodology though the types were categorised to an extent by two variables – risk-taking and feedback of results – and has passed almost unnoticed into the dustbin of history, not being referred to by any of the major texts on organisational behaviour. The four types were:
tough-guy macho – high risk, quick feedback; work-hard–play-hard – few risks taken; bet-your-company – high risk but slow feedback; process – no feedback, bureaucratic.
Roger Harrison’s four types This is likely to be examined quite frequently. Organisational culture is sometimes explained as ‘the way we do things round here’. Culture, however, is represented by the shared values that hold together the other organisational systems; thus Harrison provided a definition as ‘organisational ideologies’. Harrison used a questionnaire method to produce four distinct types:
Power cultures, based on one or a few powerful central individuals who motivate by a combination of patronage and fear, and make little use of written rules (this is likely to be the dominant type of culture in small, family-managed businesses). Role cultures, which are impersonal and rely on formalised rules and procedures to guide decision-making in a standardised, bureaucratic way (e.g. civil service and traditional, mechanistic mass-production organisations). Task or achievement cultures, which are typified by teamwork, flexibility and commitment to achieving objectives, rather than emphasis on a formal hierarchy of authority (perhaps typical of some advertising agencies and software development organisations, and the desired culture in large organisations seeking total quality management). People or support cultures, of two types. The first type is a constellation of stars, based on technical expertise of individual employees – architects’ and solicitors’ practices, IT and management consultants. The organisation is what these few people possess as skills. Other types of organisation exist for the benefit of the members rather than external stakeholders, and are based on friendship, belonging and consensus (e.g. some social clubs, informal aspects of many organisations).
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
1. Bias for action. To facilitate decision-making and problem-solving they avoid selfperpetuating bureaucratic committees. Instead, they promote a ‘ready-fire-aim’ ethos through temporary ad hoc mechanisms. 2. Close to the customer. They listen and learn from customers so that they are market driven. Quality, reliability and service are valued as long-term growth is sought through customer loyalty. 3. Autonomy and entrepreneurship. They regularly reorganise to produce small basic units, like product divisions. 4. Productivity through people. They believe people respond to trust, that those at the frontier know best, and that innovation comes from ‘where the action is’. 5. Hands on value driven. They take ‘value-shaping’ seriously and inspire employees by ‘Management by walking about’ (MBWA) – regular visits to the workplace. 6. Stick to the knitting. They avoid diversification and concentrate on the things they do well. 7. Simple form, lean staff. Simple self-contained but competing structures, like product divisions, have few central ‘staffers’ and intermediate levels of management. Simple structures make reorganisation easier. 8. Simultaneous loose–tight properties. Since autonomy has been ‘pushed down the line’, while the corporate level retains control over a few core values, these organisations are both centralised and decentralised. Two main points can be made about the cultural excellence school.
It reveals the limitations of the traditional ‘rationalist’ approach which only regards measurable and visible aspects of organisations worthy of consideration, the consequence of which has been a restrictive emphasis on rigorous organisational design, financial planning and analysis and information technologies, etc. Hence, insufficient attention has been given to the less quantifiable ingredients of organisational life. Culture has either been neglected or relegated to the ‘art of management’. The emphasis on simple forms of organisation using simultaneous loose–tight controls refocuses the traditional debate about whether or not organisations should operate tight centralised controls or looser decentralised ones which encourage selfregulation.
Whatever the merits of this approach, we need to recognise that it constitutes a resurgence of universalism and is therefore somewhat at odds with contingency theory. Several factors suggest, however, that it is unlikely to replace contingency theory because:
the sample of organisations studied (all high performers) and the character of their employees (self-motivated and highly trained) is not representative; 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Peters and Waterman (1982) The cultural excellence school These former McKinsey consultants suggest that culture, as a form of control, is critical for corporate success. Their research into high-performing American corporations revealed that corporations with a clearly articulated tight culture were able to develop simple, decentralised, flexible and innovative forms of organisation based on trust and participation. These simplified forms of organisation reduced the number of managerial levels and central staff through the avoidance of bureaucracy and, by avoiding complicated matrix structures, lived in line with man’s limitations. The eight key characteristics of excellent organisations are as follows:
93
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
94
STUDY MATERIAL P5
it is quite likely that organisations facing complex environments and undertaking changing tasks will benefit more from such forms than those operating in stable environments; other research, while tending to confirm the relationship between performance and some of the key characteristics, has nevertheless found variations in the degree of centralisation of organisations according to the market operated within.
While Peters and Waterman made an important contribution to the understanding of how large, successful organisations are managed, unfortunately, some of the organisations defined as excellent have subsequently experienced severe operating difficulties. Thus, for example, only two years after publication of the book, the magazine Business Week re-examined the companies against the original criteria used by Peters and Waterman and found that fourteen of the forty-three no longer matched up to the yardstick of ‘excellence’. This merely illustrates the temporary nature of organisational success. Peters (1987) Thriving on chaos Subtitled A Handbook for a Managerial Revolution, Peters produced an amazing 45 prescriptions (his term) under five headings for ‘managing change innovation and survival’. Most of these contain a lot of common sense and are self-evident and revisit previous attempts to define ‘best practice’ or ‘excellence’:
creating total customer responsiveness; using fast-paced innovation; achieving flexibility by empowering people; learning to love change; building systems for a world turned upside down.
Of particular interest to the management accountancy profession is the final set of prescriptions with the unusual heading ‘building systems for a world turned upside down’. This involves control systems, and the need to measure what is most important strategically. Too often management accounting systems are set up to link into financial reporting requirements, a theme pursued by Eli Goldratt in The Goal which he subtitled A Management Accounting Textbook. Peters wants measures of product quality and customer satisfaction and wants these simple. Control should be bottom-up with ‘conservative’ (i.e. achievable) goals. Trust and integrity come high on this list as without control, trust is a de facto requirement without which systems cannot work.
2.3.5 Culture and control How significant is culture for control? Academics and managers have recently suggested that culture is significant because:
it may be appropriate for organisations which have to contend with turbulent environments while employing staff who have a high regard for self-regulation; strong corporate cultures that are closely linked to corporate strategy may be critical for success.
Culture comprises values, which stress what is important for the corporation, and beliefs about how things should work. It is expressed through symbols, rituals, myths, stories and behaviour. It consists of taken-for-granted assumptions and norms about how people should behave, usually on the basis of learning from what has been successful in 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2.4 Improving effectiveness 2.4.1 Balancing control with autonomy This is likely to be examined quite frequently. To understand the tension or potential conflict between control and motivation it is useful to refer to a specific example. During the late 1990s Microsoft, despite its outstanding success as the world’s leading software company, ran into a number of management problems. Microsoft’s innovative and charismatic founder Bill Gates, and Steve Ballmer the company president, adopted a highly centralised approach to the running of the organisation. In particular, they tended to involve themselves in all important organisational decisions to the extent that managers lower down the organisation hierarchy felt themselves unable to influence matters or to contribute in a meaningful way to the company’s development. Some managers even complained that they were inhibited in their decision-making by the interventionist nature of Gates and Ballmer’s management style and others complained that the company was becoming increasingly bureaucratic. These difficulties arose at a critical time for Microsoft as it was faced with increasing competition from rivals in the development of the internet and e-commerce more generally. Quick decision-making was essential if Microsoft was to keep pace with its rivals, and the interventions of Gates and Ballmer often slowed the process down. In order to overcome these problems, the senior management changed the structure of the company. Within their two main product divisions, the Operating Systems division responsible for Windows development and the Product Development division responsible for applications like Word and Internet Explorer, the product teams were replaced by a number of customer-based groups. The newly organised Product Development division was subdivided into six groups based on the needs of different customers, including 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
the past. It is this latter feature which makes corporate culture a double-edged ‘weapon’, because it is difficult to change. Yet many organisations are facing turbulent environments (technological developments, heightened international competition, unpredictable markets, recession, deregulation, etc.) and are attempting to change corporate strategy by, for example, moving into unfamiliar markets. This often proves difficult because the existing culture, which may have been a tower of strength in the past, is not suited to the new strategy. Hence, some corporations have developed an interest in cultural change, though experience suggests it is a difficult and lengthy process which should be undertaken as a last resort. These aspects of organisational culture are ‘taken for granted’ by long-established members of the organisation as representing the normal ways of doing things and behaving. However, new members of the organisation have to learn these norms and be socialised to accept them. Life is generally much more straightforward and easier once the basic ground rules are known; while some of these may be set out in formal documentation, most organisations have important cultural values that are not spelled out in this way. If an organisation has few shared values, and wide differences in ways of thinking and behaving in different departments, it has a ‘weak’ culture. Some organisations, however, have very ‘strong’ cultures, which are an important and systematic influence on employees.
95
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
96
STUDY MATERIAL P5
knowledge workers, home PC users, computer game buyers, Web surfers and cyber shoppers. In this new structure, each group is responsible for interfacing with its customer groups, researching customer needs and then developing state-of-the-art software applications to meet these needs. In order to further speed management decision-making and allow greater involvement and generation of necessary motivation among their staff, Gates and Ballmer also resolved to change their management style and to be less interventionist. As a means to this they decentralised control to the heads of the six market divisions and to the team leaders in each division. The intention of this change is to transfer authority down the line and accelerate the decision-making process. The case of Microsoft illustrates well the problems facing all large organisations at some time in their development: that of balancing the need to ensure adequate direction and control of staff and yet allowing sufficient freedom and discretion of middle managers and other employees to contribute their particular knowledge and expertise to the organisation. Too little direction and control can result in wasted effort as the departments and divisions into which an organisation is subdivided pursue their own particular goals: too much central control and lower level managers become frustrated by rules and procedures forced upon them from on high by those who are too far from the action to make informed decisions. In recent years, companies have become increasingly aware of this problem and like Microsoft have developed ways of dealing with it. Some of the better-known ways of organising to ensure a better balance between control and autonomy are as follows.
2.4.2 Decentralisation One of the most common ways of seeking to balance control and autonomy is via a process of decentralisation. When authority is decentralised, it is delegated to divisions, functions, and the managers at lower levels in the organisation. By delegating authority in this fashion, managers can economise on bureaucratic costs and avoid communication and coordination problems because information does not have to be constantly sent to the top of the organisation for decisions to be made. There are a number of advantages to decentralisation. First, when managers in the bottom layers of the organisation become responsible for adapting the organisation to suit local conditions, their motivation and accountability increase. The result is that decentralisation promotes organisational flexibility and reduces bureaucratic costs because lower-level managers are authorised to make on-the-spot decisions. As AT&T has demonstrated, this can be an enormous advantage for business strategy. AT&T has a tall structure, but it is well known for the amount of authority it delegates to lower-level employees. Operational personnel can respond quickly to customers’ needs and so ensure superior service, which is a major source of AT&T’s competitive advantage. Second, when senior managers delegate operational decision-making responsibility to middle-level managers, they reduce information overload, enabling senior managers to spend more time on strategic decision-making. Consequently they can make more effective decisions. The third advantage of decentralisation is that when lower-level employees are given the right to make important decisions, fewer managers are needed to oversee their activities and tell them what to do. Fewer managers mean lower bureaucratic costs. If decentralisation is so effective, the question arises as to why it is that all companies are not decentralised. The answer is that centralisation also has advantages. Centralised decision-making allows easier coordination of the organisational activities needed to 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2.4.3 New venturing Internal new venturing is a form of entrepreneurship. The idea is to design organisations to encourage creativity and give new-venture managers the opportunity and resources to develop new products or markets. One of the main design choices is the creation of new-venture divisions. To provide new-venture managers with the autonomy to experiment and take risks, the company sets up a new-venture division separate from other divisions and makes it a centre for new product or project development. Away from the day-today scrutiny of top management, divisional personnel pursue the creation of new business as though they were external entrepreneurs. The division is operated by controls that reinforce the entrepreneurial spirit. Thus, market and output controls are inappropriate because they can inhibit risktaking. Instead, the company develops a culture for entrepreneurship in this division to provide a climate for innovation. Care must be taken, however, to institute bureaucratic controls that put some limits on freedom of action. Otherwise, costly mistakes may be made, and resources wasted on frivolous ideas. In managing the new-venture division, it is important to use integrating mechanisms such as task forces and teams to screen new ideas. Managers from research and development, sales and marketing and product development are heavily involved in this screening process. Generally, the champions of new products must defend their projects before a formal evaluation committee, consisting of proven entrepreneurs and experienced managers from the other divisions, to secure the resources for developing them. Companies such as Texas Instruments, 3M and IBM are examples of successful companies that use this method for creating opportunities internally. Care must also be taken to preserve the autonomy of the new-venture division. As mentioned earlier, the costs of research and development are high, and the rewards uncertain. After spending millions of dollars, corporate managers often become concerned about the division’s performance and introduce tight output controls or strong budgets to increase accountability. These measures damage the entrepreneurial culture. Sometimes, however, after creating a new invention, the new venture division wants to reap the benefits by producing and marketing it. If this happens, the division becomes an ordinary operating division and entrepreneurship declines. Strategic managers must take steps to provide a structure that can sustain the entrepreneurial spirit. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
pursue a company’s strategy. If managers at all levels can make their own decisions, overall planning becomes extremely difficult, and the company may lose control of its decision-making. Centralisation also means that decisions fit broad organisation objectives. When its branch operations were getting out of hand, for example, Merrill Lynch increased centralisation by installing more information systems to give corporate managers greater control over branch activities. Furthermore, in times of crisis, centralisation of authority permits strong leadership because authority is focused on one person or group. This focus allows for speedy decision-making and a focused response by the whole organisation. While decentralisation is a long-established and traditional means of seeking to provide middle and lower level managers and employees with a significant decision-making role and thus to ensure their greater involvement and commitment, the idea of new venturing is relatively recent.
97
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
98
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Hewlett Packard has a novel way of dealing with new venturing. In the operating divisions, as soon as a new, self-supporting product is developed, a new division is formed to produce and market the product. By spinning off the product in this fashion, the company keeps all its divisions small and entrepreneurial. The arrangement also provides a good climate for innovation. Internal new venturing is an important means by which large, established companies can maintain their momentum and grow from within. The alternative is to acquire small businesses that have already developed some technological competence and to invest in them.
2.4.4 Empowerment Another recent management trend designed to combat the debilitating effects of overcontrol has been the use of empowerment. This is part of a move towards the development and acceptance of flatter hierarchies and greater devolved power and manifests itself in the use of self-managed teams, organic structures, reduced layers of hierarchy, devolved budgetary control and decision-making. Empowerment occurs where authority to make decisions and to resolve organisational problems is delegated to subordinates. It is believed that giving power to those doing the work of the organisation should improve flexibility, speed of decision-making and the motivation of staff. Research by Conger and Kanungo (1988) indicates that an individual’s need for self-efficacy (a desire to produce results or outcomes) is better satisfied as a result of empowerment. They argue that motivation is boosted as a result of improvements in the individual’s effectiveness and the individual’s ability to choose how to complete the task using his or her creative skills. The reward resulting from personal control and real or perceived effectiveness in turn improves motivation. A virtuous circle of involvement, effectiveness and motivation is apparent. Empowerment has taken different forms in different organisations. At Xerox, employees implement their own solutions to performance problems such as how better to meet deadlines and delivery schedules, and they set their own work hours. At Johnsonville Foods in Wisconsin, USA, teams of employees share the responsibilities for hiring their own team members and for determining which employees are offered permanent employee status. Team members also do their own taste tests to determine whether the product is ready for shipping to the customer. At each of these companies, employee empowerment resulted in increased levels of worker and organisational performance. Furthermore, Tannenbaum and Cooke (1981) argue that empowerment actually increases the total amount of power in an organisation. The suggestion is that power is not a zero-sum game, but that it grows through empowerment. Senior managers gain power because of the resultant increases in morale, flexibility and productivity, whereas subordinates gain the power and authority to make decisions and to act autonomously. According to a number of writers then, empowerment is a most useful way of balancing control and motivation. There is however reason for some caution. Like many other management panaceas, empowerment has not been successful everywhere. Some reports question whether empowerment promises more in terms of performance improvements than it can actually deliver. One study, for example, found that some companies employing empowerment strategies were actually less efficient than companies not using empowerment. Another suggested that empowerment works best only in companies that are already achieving high levels of performance. Lower-performing companies often lack the training resources to make empowerment work. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2.4.5 Team working Associated with empowerment and the need to balance motivation and control is the use of team working (see Chapter 11). Examples of team working include those groupings charged with new-product development, teams charged with the development of new processes or those given responsibility to see projects of various kinds through. Such teams are responsible for the choice, design and marketing of new products. Quite commonly, such teams have a cross-functional basis, the idea being that new ideas are more likely to come from the shared experience of people drawn from different disciplines and that such shared development and learning can help speed products to market. These teams assume the responsibility for all aspects of product development.
2.4.6 Innovation Management gurus increasingly regard the role of innovation as the future basis for competitive advantage. Innovation is the introduction of new and improved ways of doing things at work. Innovation is closely related to creativity but most authors draw a distinction between the two processes. Creativity is widely regarded as the generation of ideas for new and improved ways of doing things, while innovation is defined as the implementation of those ideas in practice. Competition in global markets requires that organisations innovate and adapt if they are to survive and compete effectively. Innovation involves deliberate attempts to bring about benefits from new changes; these include increases in productivity and improvements in the design and quality of products. Innovations may include technological changes such as new products, but may also include new production processes, the introduction of advanced manufacturing technology or the introduction of new computer support services within an organisation. Innovations may also be found in administrative changes. New organisational policies, human resource management strategies, or the introduction of team work, are all examples of administrative innovations within organisations. Innovation does not imply completely new solutions. Change can be deemed an innovation if it is new for the person, group or organisation which is introducing it. If an intranet system is introduced into an organisation it can be considered to be an innovation for that organisation even though many other companies might already be using an intranet system. Innovations vary in their impact and significance, from those which are relatively minor to those which are of great significance. The development of the internet is obviously of great significance, while the improvement of a bottle opener is of relatively little importance in the order of things. It is also the case that some innovations are produced quickly while others take time. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
This last point suggests that the problem may not be with the empowerment strategies themselves, but with implementing them. It is often difficult for managers to give up or even to share the authority and responsibility that have defined the nature of management for nearly a century. In addition, not all workers are eager to take on even part of the responsibility for the problems surrounding their work, especially when they do not feel they will be given the authority to make real changes or improvements.
99
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
100
STUDY MATERIAL P5
For example, it may take only a few months to reorganise the production line in a company but take many years for the same organisation to change its corporate culture. Innovation in organisations has been found to be related to a range of factors, including a challenging environment, an emphasis on quality, good interdepartmental and interdivisional communication, strong managerial support, team working, and an organisation culture that is tolerant of risk taking.
2.4.7 Organisational learning and knowledge management Closely related to the process of innovation is the process of learning. The phrase, ‘learning organisation’ was coined during the 1980s and referred to the aims and aspirations of a growing number of companies that were seeking to transform the nature of their organisations. Such companies realised that the route to a successful future in a less and less predictable world depended on the ability of everyone in the organisation. To cope with change it was realised that experimentation and adaptation were necessary and that new ways of operating would be required. Traditional training and development programmes while useful did not guarantee that staff would possess the knowledge, skills and attitudes required to cope with new challenges. The concept of organisational learning encompasses a range of ideas drawn from a number of sources. Among these, the following are generally acknowledged as being important aspects of learning organisations. First, the learning organisation is regarded as a process rather than a product. The emphasis is on continuous learning rather than a particular end state of knowledge because rapid change demands new ways of doing things and new skills and knowledge to enable the organisation to compete. Second, the learning organisation does not come in turnkey form. In other words, it is not simply a matter of installing it like a piece of equipment but is a continuous process of learning that involves everyone in the organisation on an ongoing basis. Third, it is different from simply the summation of the learning of individuals in an organisation. Though organisations do not have brains, they have cognitive systems and memories that preserve certain behaviours, mental maps, norms and values over time. Individuals may come and go but provided that their learning has been passed on to others in the organisation the benefit of their learning to the organisation continues. Fourth, only when individual learning has an impact on and interrelates with others do organisation members learn together and gradually begin to change how things are done. This increases collective competence as well as individual competence. The notion of organisational learning has been elaborated on by a number of writers including Senge, Argyris and Schon. Knowledge management, though related to organisational learning, lays greater emphasis on the management and sharing of knowledge than does the idea of organisational learning. Knowledge management tends to focus on the use of databases and the use of intelligent search engines. These are technology-based systems designed to facilitate access to expertise by creating a catalogue of specialists each with their own website in the company intranet. Access to this knowledge is usually available by e-mail. An example of such a system is that developed by Zeneca Pharmaceuticals to bring together information on new drug discoveries and licences. Managers around the company are responsible for identifying relevant data and for inputting it into the system. Of course, knowledge management is not just the use of information technology to manage information; all 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2.4.8 Rosabeth Moss Kanter and entrepreneurship Moss Kanter, a Harvard professor, rose to prominence at the same time as Peters and Waterman with her 1983 book The Change Masters. This was subtitled ‘corporate entrepreneurs at work’ and stressed the need for ‘an American renaissance’. She complained about the ‘quiet suffocation of the entrepreneurial spirit’ in what she called ‘segmentalist companies’ – that is, functionally organised firms – particularly the indifference of managements to employee innovations and the stifling of innovation. To counteract this trend she produced various cases (as had Peters and Waterman) to show where and how change could be implemented. Again in concert with the ‘excellence school’ she emphasised culture – but also employee involvement and empowerment, together with a discussion of the managerial skills needed to change culture and strategy. In this context she described the ‘integrative’ approach to problems (as Lawrence and Lorsch had developed in their 1967 book Organisation and Environment). This was ‘moving beyond conventional wisdom’, using ‘ideas from unconnected sources’. Her later book, When Giants Learn to Dance, revisits these ideas but they tend to remain at a general level. Moss Kanter’s prescriptions for encouraging organisational creativity are as follows:
Develop an acceptance of change. Encourage new ideas at all levels of the organisation. Permit more interaction between individuals and groups. Tolerate failure, as experimentation requires trying out new ideas, not all of which will work. Offer recognition and rewards for creative behaviour.
These prescriptions will be difficult to implement in a traditional, bureaucratic, role culture. Attempts at managing a change in culture may in these circumstances have to go side by side with attempts to improve innovation and creativity. In The Change Masters, Moss Kanter neatly summarises some typical managerial behaviours and policies that will effectively stifle innovative efforts. These are summarised below. Rules for stifling innovation 1. Regard any new idea from below with suspicion – because it is new and because it is from below. 2. Insist that people who need your approval to act first go through several other levels of management to get their signatures. 3. Ask departments or individuals to challenge and criticise each other’s proposals. ( That saves you the job of deciding; you just pick the survivor.) 4. Express your criticisms freely, and withhold your praise. ( That keeps people on their toes.) Let them know they can be fired at any time. 5. Treat identification of problems as signs of failure, to discourage people from letting you know when something in their area is not working.
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
other ways of collating, analysing, storing, distributing, sharing and using information would be included. It is perhaps the power of information technology and the additional ease of using information that has given added prominence to the idea of knowledge management in recent years.
101
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
102
STUDY MATERIAL P5
6. Control everything carefully. Make sure that people count anything that can be counted, frequently. 7. Make decisions to reorganise or change policies in secret, and then spring them on people unexpectedly. (That also keeps people on their toes.) 8. Make sure that requests for information are fully justified, and make sure that it is not given out to managers freely. (You do not want data to fall into the wrong hands.) 9. Assign to lower-level managers, in the name of delegation and participation, responsibility for figuring how to cut back, lay off, move people around, or otherwise implement threatening decisions you have made. And get them to do it quickly. 10. And above all, never forget that you, the higher ups, already know everything important about this business. Many of her ideas therefore seem recycled from earlier studies, but her populist appeal to American managers at a time of national crisis over entrepreneurship is indisputable. Perhaps the most original idea was to create a ‘vehicle’ for change, which can act as a Trojan horse and allow the infiltration of other ideas. Examples would be to go for a training accreditation such as a National Training Award or Investors in People certificate, either of which would force managers to consider their training and development expertise, and perhaps encourage a degree of self-analysis and a preparedness to go for other such changes. Rover cars used the possibility of employees learning anything, either on in-house adult education classes ( Japanese was taught to ease the partnership Rover had with Honda at the time) or at local colleges, supported by a grant from the company, only to get them started again down the road of learning after years away from school, thus in effect unfreezing their mind-sets.
2.5 The network organisation 2.5.1 An overview of network organisations Externally, network organisations are organisations that rely on relationships with other organisations in order to carry out their work. A good example is the on-line bookseller Amazon.com. Amazon provides a customer website interface that enables the visitor to search and browse the catalogue of books (and other items such as CDs and collectibles). The customer can order the product on-line and expect to receive it by courier within a few days. Amazon sits in the middle of a network of other organisations. It has contract arrangements with book warehouses throughout the world to process and dispatch its orders so that it need keep only the 80 000 top-selling titles in stock. These warehouses keep Amazon notified of their stock position (which is automatically transferred to the customer web pages as approximate delivery times). It also has arrangements with couriers, credit card operators and publishers to provide it with the information and services it will need. From the customer’s point of view it ‘feels’ like one organisation: the books arrive in an Amazon carton and they have their own account with the company. The company also keep them informed about new books in areas similar to ones they have bought before. Yet in fact Amazon owns relatively few physical assets and staff to back up its service (an alternative term ‘virtual organisation’ perhaps expresses this).
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
UK local government authorities (LGAs): The local taxpayer receives environmental health, library, leisure, law and order and education services. However, the LGA relies on a series of contracts with private and public sector contracting companies to provide this service. UK hospitals: A patient in the hospital will receive medical treatment, food and accommodation services. However, the hospital may use private contractors for cleaning, laundry and catering while at the same time relying on other hospitals for the use of specialist scanning and dialysis equipment. Many of its staff will be employed on a contract basis from agencies. Airlines: The customer of the airline will have the impression that everything is supplied by the airline itself. In fact it is likely that the telephone booking service, aircraft maintenance, on-board catering, check-in, luggage handling and departure lounges are provided under contracts from other firms. The passenger may also find that part of their journey is provided by another carrier under a similar arrangement. UK railways: A passenger will buy their ticket from a train-operating company and travel according to the timetable the company has laid down. The train itself may be owned by a separate leasing company, depart from a station and along lines operated by a third company yet maintained by a fourth. The on-board catering will be provided by a fifth firm and the train cleaned by a sixth firm. Ghoshal and Bartlett (1997) describe another form of network organisation which they term an individualised corporation. They argue that networks will take the place of formal organisational structures such as hierarchies and rigid divisions. Corporations will allow their individuals to form virtual teams in order to become more creative, inspiring them to use their initiative and knowledge to build organisational learning and competences.
2.5.2 Forms of network relationship The examples in Section 2.5.1 demonstrate that network organisations can choose to ‘buy-in’ a range of value-creating activities: 1. Contract staffing. The use of contract staff (or ‘temps’ ) to cope with pressure points in the workload is a long-established practice. Network organisations will often take this as the norm and extend it beyond operative staff to include workers with considerable intellectual capital such as systems experts and lawyers while retaining only a very small cohort of core staff. This ‘shamrock organisation’ will be discussed below. 2. Use of specific capital assets. The leasing of assets has been common for many years in high capital cost industries like airlines and shipping. However, the network organisation frequently leases IT facilities, turnkey factories and specially built machines and highly customised office accommodation. 3. Outsourcing elements of production or service provision. Ancillary services such as office cleaning have often been outsourced by management who do not wish to be bothered with it. However, the network organisation goes considerably further by outsourcing the production of its products or the distribution of its products. For example, many processed food companies no longer make the food they brand and sell and fast-food restaurants do not operate their restaurants. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
A similar analysis can be applied to the following industries:
103
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
104
STUDY MATERIAL P5
4. Reliance on outside organisations for referral of business. Many network organisations have mutual customer-sharing arrangements and will cross-sell their products. For example: through-ticketing on airlines and railways; car-hire firms, airlines and hotel chains network for corporate travel and fly-drive holidays; finance houses network with car and electrical retailers to provide low-cost consumer credit and joint promotions. Writers refer to the ‘permeable organisation boundary’ because it becomes hard to see where one organisation ends and another begins. Staff from one organisation physically work at the other’s offices, customers are seemingly passed from organisation to organisation without realising it, and data about customers and products are passed around in order to coordinate activities.
2.5.3 Implications of network organisations There are a number of issues posed by the development of network organisations: 1. How do firms decide which activities and assets to ‘buy-in’ and which to own and operate directly? 2. Why have network organisations become so important in recent years? 3. How can management develop systems to control operations in a network organisation?
2.5.4 Theoretical basis of network organisations There are two sets of theoretical perspectives that help us to understand the development of and decisions surrounding network organisations: 1. Transactions cost theory (see below). 2. Resource-based views of strategy. (These were reviewed in Section 1.5.) To a great extent these overlap and you should not worry too much if you do not see them as being different.
2.5.5 Transactions cost theory This approach is rooted in the institutional economics of Ronald Coase and Oliver Williamson. Williamson (1981) suggests that organisations choose between two mechanisms to control resources and carry out its operations – hierarchies or markets. 1. Hierarchy solutions. Here management decide to own the assets (or employ the staff directly) and use the policies and procedures of the firm to control their use and performance. Vertically integrated companies are ones which have a high reliance on the managerial hierarchy for control. 2. Market solutions. Management decide to buy-in the use of the assets or staff from outside companies under the terms of a contract. Outsourcing is a contemporary example of increased reliance on the market. Hierarchies will be used if the transactions costs of the market solution are too high. It may be helpful to think of Williamson’s theory as a more complex version of the familiar ‘make-or-buy’ decision from your management accounting studies. Management will make in-house the things that cost them more to buy from the market. However, 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
(a) Negotiating and drafting a legal contract with the supplier. (b) Monitoring the supplier’s compliance with the contract (quality, quantity, reliability, invoicing, etc.). (c) Pursuing legal actions for redress due to non-performance by the supplier. (d) Penalty payments and cancellation payments if the firm finds it later needs to change its side of the bargain and draft a new contract with the supplier. These costs arise because both the firm and its supplier wish to be protected against loss and use the contract to define the risks each mutually takes on. These risks are increased by two factors: 1. Bounded rationality. At the time the contract is negotiated neither party is able to perfectly anticipate the future and how the contract will unfold. For example, a firm seeking to buy components cannot know for sure the volumes they will need because they cannot perfectly forecast final product sales. Likewise, the innovations of a competitor may force them to vary the specification of their product that may require differently specified inputs. Similarly the supplier will not know their production costs with certainty. 2. Opportunistic behaviour. Each agent is seeking to pursue their own economic self-interest. This means they will take advantages of any loopholes in the contract to improve their position. For example, a small change in the specification of the product will be alighted on by the supplier as an opportunity to charge higher prices because they know the buyer is bound by contract to purchase from them. The more that these two factors are present, the greater will be the transactions costs arising from a market solution. This is because: (a) Bounded rationality makes the parties quibble more over the drafting of the contract and over the interpretation of it ( particularly if circumstances have moved against them since the contract was drawn up). (b) Legal enforcement of the contract will become more expensive. (c) Opportunistic behaviour will lead to expensive variations in contract terms or damages claims for breach of contract. If these transaction costs become too high the organisation may reduce its costs by taking the supply in-house through development of its own upstream supply facility under the direct control of management (a hierarchy solution). The decision of which mechanism to use, markets or hierarchies, is (or should be) based on management’s desire to minimise transactions costs. Williamson considers the circumstances that lead one firm to trade with another and therefore to incur transaction costs. This he roots in the concept of asset specificity. Asset 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Williamson looks beyond just the unit costs of the product or service under consideration. He is specifically interested in the costs of control that (together with the unit costs) make up transactions costs. Transaction costs are the organisational counterpart of friction in a physical system. They are costs arising at the interface between economic agents, particularly between stages in a production or supply process. Where the enterprise relies on outside suppliers for an input or service (a market solution), in addition to the price for the bought-in input, it will incur the following transaction costs:
105
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
106
STUDY MATERIAL P5
specificity is the extent to which particular assets are only of use in one specific range of operations. Consider the example of Eurotunnel plc. This company has a single asset, a tunnel under the English Channel linking the British Isles to the main European continent, which opened in 1994 having cost nearly £5bn to build. Apart from some telecommunications potential, this extremely expensive asset has no conceivable alternative use other than as a rail tunnel. In addition to operating its own shuttle services for passengers and freight, over 30 per cent of the company’s revenues come from other railway companies which pay Eurotunnel to use the tunnel. This includes the Eurostar consortium that operates specially built trains between London and various destinations in France and Belgium. This is a situation of high asset specificity. High asset specificity arises where a supplier must invest in expensive assets with no alternative use in order to supply a client. This poses a substantial risk to the supplier because if the contract is withdrawn it will not be able to recoup its investment. Few will take this risk without a guarantee of orders in the long term. Eurotunnel plc is locked into the train operators. At the same time the train operators are locked into Eurotunnel because their investment in rolling stock and stations would be useless without the tunnel. Williamson examines the effect of such high ‘asset specificity’ on transaction costs. Williamson predicts that such high asset specificity will therefore result in bilateral (or quasi-bilateral) contracts between the firm and its supplier. High asset specificity results in the buyer being denied the opportunity to periodically choose between rival producers on an external market, instead being forced to enter a long-term contract with the sole supplier. Eurotunnel has the exclusive right to operate the tunnel until 2086, but perhaps more significantly the rail operators signed Usage Contract agreements with Eurotunnel in 1994 until 2006 under which they are committed to certain minimum financial payments to Eurotunnel. In return they have the right to use up to 50 per cent of the tunnel capacity. It can be seen that the high asset specificity of Eurotunnel has led to high transactions costs in the form of the contracts and franchise agreements around it. Williamson’s conclusion is that high asset specificity will lead firms to bring supply inhouse rather than bear the high transactions costs of the market. Indeed he suggests that extremely high asset specificity may result in no suppliers coming forward on the market. In this connection it is significant to note that Eurotunnel began life as a political creation of the British and French governments rather than as a private business initiative. Williamson suggests that asset specificity can be of six types: 1. Site specificity: the assets are attached to a particular geographical location, for example: locating a components plant near the customer’s assembly plant; building hotels near a certain theme park or tourist attraction; building of pipelines and harbours to service an oilfield. 2. Physical asset specificity: this is a physical asset with unique properties, for example: reserves of high-quality ores; a unique work of art or building. 3. Human asset specificity: particular skills or knowledge, for example: specific technical skills relevant to only one product; knowledge of systems and procedures peculiar to one organisation. 4. Dedicated asset specificity: a man-made asset which has only one application, for example: Eurotunnel; military defence equipment; Sydney Harbour Bridge. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Williamson admits that these categories often occur together. For example, Eurotunnel combines temporal (limited franchise till 2086), dedicated asset and site specificity. Transaction costs approaches to organisation theory are being enlisted in support of a number of ends by strategy writers and business consultants. 1. Identification of distinctive competences. According to the transactions cost approach this will be an operation or asset that cannot be provided by another organisation without increasing the transactions costs or risks of the firm. Any asset or operation that does not have these characteristics is not a suitable basis for a competitive strategy because a rival will be able to buy it in cheaper. 2. To support organisational restructuring. Organisations should sell-off upstream or downstream divisions that can be provided at lower transactions costs by the market. The same argument applies to particular business processes such as IT, logistics and human resource development which are increasingly outsourced. 3. To predict the impacts of developments in information technology. It is believed that the costs of searching the market for suppliers, maintaining the supplier/buyer relationship and monitoring fulfilment have been reduced by developments in information technology (IT). These are often put under the umbrella of e-commerce or e-business. Predicting the reduction in the costs available from the substitution of these virtual value chains is used to drive strategic initiatives and investments.
2.5.6 Transactions cost theory and network organisations According to Williamson, corporations reduce transactions costs by vertically integrating and in doing so become more multi-divisionalised and more internally complex. This casts an interesting light on organisational behaviour; for example:
Does Disney Corporation operate visitor and cast accommodation at its theme parks because it is cheaper than offering the financial safeguards necessary to encourage hotel operators to invest in such specific assets? Is the reason that Procter and Gamble develops its own brands for foods and detergents that the uncertainties about brand values and strategy make it very expensive to draft contracts to lease brands from brand owners? Did the same consideration lie behind Grand Metropolitan’s decision to buy Pillsbury rather than simply license the Burger King brand from it? Do large firms undertake in-house staff and management development programmes because colleges and potential recruits are unwilling to bear the costs of training themselves in such specific skills? Are some staff paid far more than they could otherwise get on the job market because they possess specific skills which the firm cannot buy from the labour market? 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
5. Brand name capital specificity: a brand and associations that belong to one family of products and would lose value if spread wider, for example: Coca-Cola; McDonald’s. 6. Temporal specificity: the unique ability to provide service at a certain time, for example: the right to conduct radio broadcasts at an allotted time; rights to exploit an asset for only a limited number of years.
107
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
108
STUDY MATERIAL P5
The network organisation, however, seems to challenge Williamson’s theory because it represents a breakdown in hierarchies and features a much greater use of the market to provide inputs and customers. Several transaction costs based explanations may be offered for this phenomenon: 1. Organisations may have underestimated the costs of internal control. Firms undertake activities internally when the transactions costs of external provision are too great. However, this assumes that management can accurately quantify the costs of controlling the internal operation. These costs will include: – – – – – – –
staff recruitment and training; provision of managerial supervision; production planning; payments and incentive schemes to motivate performance; the development of budgetary control systems to coordinate activity; divisional performance measurement and evaluation; provision and maintenance of fixed assets such as premises and capital equipment.
These costs of managerial control are traditionally regarded as overheads rather than something resulting from the decision to undertake production internally. A conventional absorption costing system may allocate overheads to products, but these overheads are not relevant costs for decision-making purposes such as ‘make or buy’. Hence the decision to produce internally overlooks many of the costs associated with it. More modern management accounting techniques recognise the costs of control and this may have led to increased recognition of the savings from outsourcing. 2. Transaction costs may have been reduced by the impact of information technology. Examples include: computer integrated manufacturing (CIM) enables ordering of components and coordination of suppliers to be streamlined by automatic triggering of electronic orders transmitted by electronic data interchange and, more recently, the internet. Common computer assisted design (CAD) systems allow collaboration in research and development with geographically remote suppliers. Communications technology such as teleconferencing, e-mail and intranets permit much lower cost and timely maintenance of supplier relationships than was possible using face-to-face methods. Firms now have access to global partners because the cost of searching for suitable suppliers or buyers is reduced by IT. One example provided by Hagel and Armstrong (1997) is the possibility of industry members forming virtual communities by using common websites to advertise their requirements and to invite tenders from suppliers. One influential theory adopting a transaction costs perspective is the Electronic Markets Hypothesis of Malone et al. (1987). This suggests that more firms will be prepared to undertake asset specific investment because the electronically facilitated global market makes them less reliant on a single customer. Similarly, the buyer will have a choice of suppliers rather than a single monopoly supplier. The authors suggest a significant shift to increased outsourcing will occur as firms become able to network in an ‘unbiased market’ rather than being faced with the choice between internal production or reliance on a monopoly partner. 3. Transaction costs may have been reduced by the development of trust in contractual relations. Williamson suggests that a major source of transactions costs is the potential for opportunistic behaviour by the contracting parties, and the legal and monitoring cost that arise from these. Nirmalya (1996) and others suggest that the mutual suspicions that give 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
(a) that management structure organisations in this way because they seek to improve shareholder value; or (b) only those firms that succeed in minimising costs will survive in the long run (i.e. firms that fail to do so are no longer around because market forces have eliminated them). Neither assumption can go unchallenged. First, many writers, including Williamson himself, have suggested that the lax framework of corporate governance allows the management of a firm to pursue personal goals rather than maximise the wealth of shareholders (e.g. Williamson, 1964). Therefore, it is quite possible that many hierarchies were created to enhance managers’ feelings of prestige and power rather than in an attempt to avoid transactions costs. Indeed the suspicion arises that many organisations developed as they did from reasons of history and circumstance rather than to serve any particular purpose. Second, the notion of market forces driving high-cost firms out of business overlooks the fact that vertically integrated firms have substantial market power and may avoid these competitive pressures. Transaction cost analysis may explain the trend to network organisations if it can be shown that external pressures are forcing firms to reduce costs. For example, it may be that increased shareholder pressure or market competition is forcing managers to break down their empires in order to gain the lower transaction costs available from external partnerships.
2.5.7 Network organisations and resource-based theory Recurring questions raised by discussions of virtual organisations and network organisations are:
What exactly does a firm do if it relies on others for carrying out most of its operations? Is the firm vulnerable to being cut out of the network if its partners decide to deal with each other directly? Will not the relationships eventually decline into conventional adversarial relations if the firm becomes too dependent on its partners?
According to resource-based theory (RBT) these problems do not need to trouble us. RBT argues that organisations are always just a ‘nexus of contracts’. If all activities are undertaken in-house then these contracts are principally employment contracts monitored by the apparatus of corporate governance. However, it is a poor and expensive use of management time to monitor such contracts and operations if they can be done better by a partner and diverts attention from leveraging the firm’s competences. A firm need not fear being cut out of a network, provided that it confines itself to excellence in the use of its core competences. This is because partners will incur higher costs if they try to carry out the activity themselves. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
rise to these costs can be removed if a relationship of trust is developed between the contracting parties. This is also picked up by Ouchi (1980) who suggests that the high uncertainties and impossibility of measuring performance means that contract relations must be based on shared values, or clan control, rather than either of Williamson’s market or bureaucratic means. 4. The creation of hierarchies was not economically justifiable at any time. For Williamson to argue that organisations are structured in such a way that they minimise transactions costs, he depends on one of two propositions:
109
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
110
STUDY MATERIAL P5
Avoiding the decline of trust-based relationships into adversarial (or dyadic) relationships depends on the maintenance of the right atmosphere between the parties. Things that will encourage this include:
Open-book accounts where each can see the other is not taking excessive profit from the relationship. Continued reciprocity in trading relations (i.e. we learn to trust as we experience the plain dealing of our partner). Deliberate policies to integrate the cultures and staffing of the organisations. This gives a leading role to human resources functions.
2.6 Summary The key points to remember are:
the relationship between strategy and structure; the features and advantages of the different organisation structures; the definition and classification of culture; approaches to improving organisational efficiency.
References Atkinson, J. (1984), ‘Manpower Strategies for the Flexible Organisation’, Personnel Management, August. Burns, T. and Stalker, G.M. (1961), The Management of Innovation. London: Tavistock. Chandler, A. (1962), Strategy and Structure: Chapters in the History of the Industrial Enterprise. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Child, J. (1984), Organisation – A Guide to Problems and Practice. New York: Harper & Row. Coase, R. (1991), The Nature of the Firm. In O.E. Williamson and S.G. Winter (eds.). The Nature of the Firm. New York: Oxford University Press. Conger, J. and Kanungo, R.N. (1988), Charismatic Leadership: The Elusive Factor in Organisational Effectiveness. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Deal, T.E. and Kennedy, A.A. (1982), Corporate Cultures (new edition, The New Corporate Cultures, 2000, Texere Publishing). New York: Perseus Books. Ghoshal, S. and Bartlett, C.A. (1997), The Individualised Corporation. London: Random House. Goldratt, E. and Cox, J. (1984), (2nd edn 1993), The Goal: A Management Accounting Textbook. Aldershot: Gower. Hagel, J. and Armstrong, A.G. (1997), Net Gain: Expanding Markets Through Virtual Communities. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Hellriegel, D., Slocum, J.W. and Woodman, R.W. (1992), Organisational Behaviour. New York: West. Hofstede, G. (1980), Motivation, Leadership, and Organisation: Do American Theories Apply Abroad?, Organisational Dynamics, Vol. 9, No. 1, Summer 1980, pp. 42–63. Lawrence, P.R. and Lorsch, J.W. (1967; rev edn 1986), Organisation and Environment: Managing Differentiation and Integration. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Mintzberg, H. (1975), ‘The Manager’s Job: Folklore and Fact’, Harvard Business Review, July–August. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Mintzberg, H. (1982), Power in and around Organisations. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Mintzberg, H. and Waters, J.A. (1985), ‘Of strategies deliberate and emergent.’ Strategic Management Journal, vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 257–72. Mintzberg, H. (1994), The Rise and Fall of Strategic Planning. Pearson Education. Reprinted by permission of Pearson Education. Morgan, G. (1986), Images of Organisation. London: Sage. Moss Kanter, R. (1983), The Change Masters. New York: Simon and Schuster. Moss Kanter, R. (1998), When Giants Learn to Dance. London: ITBP. Nirmalya, K. (1996), ‘The Power of Trust in Manufacturer–Retailer Relationships’, Harvard Business Review, November/December. Ouchi, W. (1981), Theory Z: How American Businesses can Meet the Japanese challenge. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Pub Co. Peters, T. (1987), Thriving on Chaos: A Handbook for a Managerial Revolution. London: Pan. Peters, T. and Waterman, R. (1982), In Search of Excellence. New York: Harper & Row. Schein, E. (1984), Organisational Culture and Leadership. (2nd. edn). San Francisco, CA: Jossey Bass. Senge, P.M. (1990), The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organisation. New York: Doubleday. Tannenbaum, A.S., and Cooke, R.A., Control and participation. Journal of Contemporary Business, Vol. 3, (Autumn 1974), pp. 35–46. Weihrich, H. and Koontz, H. (1993), Management: A Global Perspective. New York: McGrawHill, Inc. Williamson, O.E. (1964), The Economics of Discretionary Behaviour, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Williamson, O.E. (1981), ‘The Economics of Organisation: The Transactions Cost Approach’, American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 87, No. 3, pp. 548–77. Williamson, O.E. and S.G. Winter (eds.). The Nature of the Firm. New York: Oxford University Press.
111
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
2
Readings
The importance of having a structure that will facilitate the achievement of organisational objectives has long been recognised. The models of structure advocated by early classical management writers tended to be based on military command and control principles. This type of ‘bureaucratic’ organisation with clearly defined roles, responsibilities and rules can operate quite successfully in stable predictable conditions, but will be ineffective in more competitive and turbulent environments. All organisations face the basic problem of finding the right balance between centralisation and decentralisation; this is sometimes described as the ‘trust-control dilemma’. There is no one right answer to this dilemma for all organisations in all circumstances. Consequently a particular organisation will be likely to move from one form of structure to another as its strategy and circumstances change and develop. This process is examined in the following article based on the experience of Procter and Gamble.
In search of structural excellence Aelita G B Martinsons and Maris G Martinsons, Leadership and Organisation Development Journal, 15(2), 1994. Reproduced by kind permission of the authors.
Even the most superficial scans of the management literature reveal scores of articles addressing the topic of organisational structure, and one can easily be led to believe that there must be an ideal structure for every organisation. By following well-documented prescriptions for success, managers should theoretically be able to easily identify and realise the ideal structure for their organisation. However, further consideration finds that theory does not necessarily lend itself effectively to practice (Mintzberg, 1991). Certain structures undoubtedly are more conducive to realising popular corporate goals and strategies. However, because of the complexity of an organisation’s situation, it is difficult to identify the single ideal structure. Dynamic changes in organisational goals and resources as well as its environment may preclude a static ideal structure. Recent literature tends to focus on after-the-fact cases, basing theories on descriptive analyses rather than prescription. Theorists look for critical factors in successful organisations and then try to generalise their findings to produce an ideal structure and success formula (Peters and Waterman, 1982). Unfortunately, what works in one company may not work in another owing to the slightest of differences. The contingency approach sees no one right structure for all organisations. Instead, the ‘right’ structure depends on contingency factors. By matching an organisation’s contingency factors with those prescribed by management theorists the ideal structure for an organisation could be found. Contingency or situational factors may include the 113
2005.1
READINGS P5
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
114
Table 2.1 Common wisdom prescriptions for organisational structures BASED ON Strategy: Single business Vertical by-products Related business Linked business Size: Small Medium Large Level of technology: Low High Business environment: Stable Dynamic Industry type: Container Plastic Food Stage of organisational development: Birth Growth Maturity Decline Death Organisational fad 1970s 1990s
STRUCTURE
Functional Functional Divisional Mixed structures Simple Functional Divisional Centralised Decentralised Mechanistic Organic Bureaucracy Decentralised bureaucracy Bureaucracy Entrepreneurial-dominated Functional management Dencentralised into profit or investment centres Structural surgery Dismemberment of structure Matrix Clustering
organisation’s strategy, size, technology and environment, type of industry, the organisation’s and industry’s stage of development, and the latest organisational fad. A detailed account of the common wisdom relating these factors to organisational structure is given in Table 1. The three most common generic organisational structures are the functional structure, the divisional structure and the matrix structure. Functional structure
The functional structure is a direct descendant of the bureaucratic structure. It is based on a group’s function or dedicated activities in an organisation, such as sales and marketing, finance and operations. The structure’s effectiveness is based on this division of labour. Smaller to medium-sized organisations with limited product ranges tend to favour the functional structure. The structure allows for specialisation within the functional areas and facilitates coordination among its members. However, in reality, individuals become insulated in their functional groups and fail to see or understand the other functions’ jobs. This can lead to co-ordination problems. As Wilson (1986) explained: . . . operating efficiencies afforded by grouping specialists together in functional areas with a traditional chain of command becomes a barrier to cross-function communication and co-ordination needed effectively to implement multiple product – multiple marketing strategies. For such reasons, the divisional structure is appealing to some organisations. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
This structure is used as companies become larger and begin to diversify their product line. The company is divided into separate units based on different products or markets. The company breaks up its operations into manageable units or little companies (Pascale, 1990) which then operate under a mechanistic structure. The units may share some corporate resources, such as research and development facilities, but overall, they are relatively autonomous. The units are guided by a corporate-level strategy which outlines the desired results. However, the units are free to realise corporate-level objectives of their own choosing. Hence, this structure is much more flexible and adaptable to market and product needs than the functional structure. Within the units a functional form is often adopted. However, corporate efficiency decreases as many functions are duplicated in different units. Also, as with the functional structure, it is difficult to generate an overall corporate identity as each unit is preoccupied with creating and maintaining its own. This could create difficulties in co-ordinating the different units. The matrix structure
The matrix structure was the structure of the 1970s (Miller, 1986). It was seen as a way of bridging the advantages of the functional and divisional structures. The matrix structure is based on a dual chain of command. The functional departments are used to gain economies of specialisation while the project teams focus on particular products or markets. Each employee in the matrix structure is responsible to one functional department and one project manager, hence the dual chain of command. Although the matrix structure is usually a combination of functional and divisional groupings, it can also be a combination of product and market groupings. These matrix structures can be temporary or permanent, depending on the needs of the organisation. It was this flexibility that made the matrix structure very popular initially. However, many companies soon found the structure to be more burdensome than helpful (Peters, 1979). The biggest problem was the level of ambiguity inherent in the structure. The relationship between functional and project managers was not clearly specified by rules and procedures, creating power struggles and a blurred sense of accountability. This decreased both efficiency and effectiveness. Also, the staff in a matrix structure were unclear as to where their loyalties should lie – whether it is with their functional department or the project team. This led to lowered morale and job satisfaction. The quest for the ideal organisation structure should be seen as a means of increasing business efficiency and effectiveness. The evolutionary nature of the corporate structure at Procter & Gamble illustrates this thesis. Organising Procter & Gamble
As the previous descriptions suggest, each structure has its own merits and drawbacks. Procter & Gamble (P&G), a large multinational manufacturer of consumer goods, has a rich history of structural change, and provides a useful illustration of the periodic decisions which senior management must make with respect to organisational structure. P&G was founded in 1837 as a soap company. After focusing solely on soap for the first century, P&G began to expand by vertically integrating back into manufacturing its own chemical processing and seed crushing in the 1930s. From these humble beginnings the company has diversified in various directions. Initially, P&G modified its basic product offering (adding flaked soap and beauty soap), then later it diversified its product line (into 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Divisional structure
115
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
116
READINGS P5
cleaners, shampoos, toothpaste). More recently, it has achieved industry diversification, entering the paper, food, beverage and pharmaceutical businesses. Even this latest move may be termed ‘related’ diversification, since all the businesses are built on the same ‘centre of gravity’ (Galbraith, 1991). Centre of gravity refers to a company’s starting supply stage in an industry chain. For a manufacturing firm, six such stages may be identified: raw materials, primary manufacturing, fabrication, product producer, market distributor, and retailer. The first three stages belong to the upstream segment which adds value by reducing raw materials into simpler components, while the last three stages belong to the downstream segment which add value by adding extras to the product to meet specific customer needs. Upstream and downstream companies are fundamentally different. It can be hypothesised that a company’s culture, strategy and structure are shaped by its initial focus in the industry chain. P&G has been classified as a downstream company, originating as a market distributor (Galbraith, 1991). Downstream companies, like P&G, have multiple products and multiple markets. They are also customer-oriented and concerned with tailoring their products to meet target market needs. Because of their diversity and need to be more flexible and adaptable than traditional manufacturing companies, downstream companies adopt a divisional structure based on vertical integration, geographic location and industry. Within P&G’s divisional structure, there are product-function matrices. The matrices are in the second phase of development whereby cross-functional task forces are permanent but there is not yet any dual authority. Products are looked after by brand managers. Each brand manager is responsible for a particular brand and its extensions. The brand manager oversees a brand group, reports to an associate advertising manager and interacts with functional departments such as research and development, and finance. Product management should be viewed as an addition to functional management. The use of brand managers fits P&G’s culture, which may be termed an Academy – a term coined by Jeffrey Sonnenfeld. Within the academy culture, the company guides its employees through a myriad of specialised jobs within a particular function. Competitive advantages and co-ordinating liabilities
The matrix structure may be seen as one of P&G’s competitive advantages, the brand managers were product specialists, completely familiar and up-to-date with their products’ external and internal environments. Also, they were totally dedicated to co-ordinating the product’s marketing mix and the product’s profitability. The functional departments were again specialists in their own right, complementing the brand managers’ duties. Between 1930 and 1970, this structure proved to be very successful for the organisation. All of P&G’s strategic decisions are made at the top in the Cincinnati Head Office, while the operational ones are made by the brand managers (The Economist, 1989, p. 76). They practised a decentralised bureaucracy. Although this ‘loose-tight’ fit is seen as a mark of an ‘excellent’ or successful company (Peters and Waterman, 1982), it is sometimes difficult to strike the right balance. According to some sources, P&G’s decision-making power was skewed towards top management (Griffin and Ebert, 1993). Although some control is necessary at the top to co-ordinate the organisation’s activities and overall strategy, too much centralisation would be detrimental to its responsiveness. Part of the problem was that brand managers were given the responsibility but not necessarily the authority to manage their products, making them less responsive to environmental changes. This is a common problem in organisations which have 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Integrating the organisation
Another contributing factor to the loss of market share was the harsh competition between the individual units. P&G encouraged this competition, believing it would motivate the managers to be more responsive to customer needs. Brand managers were not to compete head-on with one another. Instead, the individual brands were thought to be positioned differently in consumers’ minds so that the brand managers would compete against other companies’ brands, not their own company’s brands. However, the brand managers were not encouraged by the company to co-operate among themselves. This may have sent brand managers the wrong message, that they were to compete directly against other P&G brands. The units became insulated, focusing more on their own goals than on the larger corporate goals. Fierce competition ensued between the individual units, leading to cannibalisation. The units robbed customers from one another rather than trying to gain market share from other companies’ brands. Initially the strategic planners at P&G did nothing in response to this cannibalisation. However, in the mid-1980s, John Smale, P&G’s chairman, restructured the corporation. One of the first things he did was to add a category management system. He added what were called category managers, who were responsible for co-ordinating the efforts of brand managers in a particular product line and sharpening its strategic focus. The primary responsibility of this integrating manager was to allow for greater co-ordination and quicker decision making. The category managers were delegated enough authority to make decisions previously done at higher levels. Initially, there was some difficulty between category managers and brand managers as category managers focused on profit while brand managers focused on market share. However, P&G overcame this by defining work processes and designing new work systems. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
brand managers. Brand managers occupy staff-like positions, with no formal authority over their resources or other functional departments. This creates conflict and frustration, lessening the brand managers’ effectiveness in quickly reacting to product problems. P&G’s strategic orientation is that of prospector and a market-leader, requiring it to be both innovative and responsive to the environment. Therefore a decentralised and minimum top-down control structure would seem more suitable. However, P&G’s structure no longer matched its growth strategy. Also the environment had changed considerably, making its structure less effective. The distribution channels had greater bargaining power and customers were less brand-loyal. Companies with structures like those of P&G often became inflexible and unresponsive. It may be for this reason that P&G lost considerable market share in the 1970s. The problem is inherent to the matrix structure. Peters and Waterman (1982, p. 76) comment that it ‘virtually always ceases to be innovative, often after just a short time. . . It also regularly degenerates into anarchy and rapidly becomes bureaucratic and non-creative’. P&G’s decline may also be discussed in terms of Miller’s (1986) Four Trajectories of Decline. P&G had moved from being a ‘salesman’ to that of a ‘drifter’, becoming oppressively bureaucratic and losing its ability to be innovative. Although P&G, which mass-produced standardised consumer goods, may find a mechanistic, bureaucratic system more efficient, it must also be responsive to its highly competitive market. Therefore, a more decentralised structure, or a decentralised bureaucracy, was better suited to their situation.
117
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
118
READINGS P5
P&G extended this new matrix structure to its international divisions, giving them more autonomy and flexibility. It also increased individual units’ communication across different countries. In P&G’s European structure: Each local manager wears two hats – one for his product, one for his region. The French manager now reports both to his country manager and to a category manager who looks after a basket of related brands. The category manager is a mini-profit centre, reporting to one of P&G’s central division managers. So fewer layers separate the top of the (management) pyramid from the market. (The Economist, 1989, p. 77). Although P&G’s vice-chairman recognised the problems associated with their staff reporting to two managers, he felt the matrix structure would allow P&G to be more responsive to international market trends. P&G tried to reduce some of the matrix structure’s difficulties by making the category managers directly responsible for the profitability of their products. Also, by having the category managers report to P&G’s central division managers, they felt they could maintain sufficient control and coordination over them. However, the matrix structure can reduce organisational flexibility and generate conflicts between managers. P&G’s turn-around success in the short term has been promising. Much of it can be attributed to its restructuring. However, it is premature to declare this structure as ideal. There are other strategies it could have chosen which may have been still better. However, P&G’s management believed that this current structure was suitable, not necessarily ideal. It fitted P&G’s culture, supported its strategy and was flexible enough to adapt to the environment. Where do we go from here?
The latest structural fad is clustering. Clustering evolved from the matrix structure but is believed to allow for more creativity, innovation, communication, and productivity than the former structure (Mills, 1991). The cluster is much looser and more autonomous than the matrix structure. A cluster is a group of 30 to 50 people of different specialities who work together on a semi-permanent basis. Within each cluster are smaller work teams of five to seven people. Upper levels of management are lean and there is little hierarchical control. Would this structure suit P&G? In terms of its environment, this structure would help P&G be more responsive to the global market. With globalisation, P&G has had to venture into unfamiliar and underdeveloped markets. In the 1970s and 1980s, P&G experienced some difficulties in responding to international demands (Peters, 1987). Its new structure alleviated the problem. However, this may be temporary. The clustering structure may allow it to be even more flexible and adaptable, helping it achieve its strategy better. However, clustering would require P&G to change its corporate culture to be less paternalistic. Culture is very difficult to change and requires strong commitment from upper management. As clustering removes a lot of the power from upper management, it may be reluctant to endorse the change. Management would have to be shown that by being top-heavy, the company would decline, creating more serious problems in the future. The demise of the hierarchical structure has been heralded (Peters, 1992). Organisations wanting to survive and thrive in the 1990s must change. To what and how are the questions strategists must answer. The bottom line
Over the years a steady stream of structural models or frameworks have been conceived, each promising to be better than the previous ones. In theory, they may be ideal. In reality, an organisation faces an array of dynamic variables, including environmental factors 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Discussion questions
Why is it difficult to find and maintain an ideal organisation structure? What is the category management system and why was it introduced? Why would it be difficult to introduce clustering in P&G?
In the next article, John Storey looks at how the fragmentation of markets, shorter product life-cycles and greater variability in demand have precipitated changes in organisational structures. The large hierarchical multi-divisional structures of the midtwentieth century have been forced to give way to smaller enterprises, outsourcing, joint ventures and alliances. These structural forms allow a more rapid and flexible response to changes in the market place. Storey then considers the impact of these structural changes on the management of human resources.
Network structures John Storey, The Financial Times, 19 November, 2001, p. 2 Full Text # 2001 Financial Times Information Ltd. Information may not be copied or redistributed. Reprinted with permission.
When internal boundaries become network relationships Structured companies are dissolving into fluid networks of alliances. John Storey contends that managers have much to learn about coping with these changes. (SURVEY – MASTERING PEOPLE MANAGEMENT) John Storey. Even a casual observer of international business cannot help but notice that organisations seem forever in the process of reorganising. Why should this be so? Does it reflect economic reality or a superficial rearranging of the corporate furniture? Might these reforms simply be part of a cyclical fluctuation between centralisation and decentralisation? Do new organisational forms require different HR capabilities? Certainly, in many cases reform disguises routine behaviour: some changes may simply correct the deficiencies of the last attempt at restructuring. However, it would be cynical to dismiss all restructuring in this way. One explanation is that there is no ‘‘best’’ structure. Economic and industrial changes have produced patterns of organisational restructuring. For example, after the second world war, growth in international markets based on mass production was accompanied by an expansion in the number of multinationals and led to the near-ubiquitous multi-divisional form (the ‘‘M-Form’’). This was associated with hierarchy, planned career structures and large, centralised personnel departments overseeing expatriates and home-based staff. However, with fragmenting markets, shorter product life cycles and greater variability of demand, the unwieldy nature of the multinationals became apparent. Since the 1990s, other forms have been ascendant, characterised by smaller enterprises, outsourcing, joint ventures and alliances. These require new capabilities among managers, which, in turn, require changes in people management. Figure 1 indicates the relationship between drivers, forms, capabilities and HR management. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
beyond its control. This makes it difficult to find and especially maintain an ideal structure. Instead, organisations commonly settle for structures which satisfy their current needs (satisfices) and provides a reasonable degree of flexibility for its future. This then is a structure that may be termed suitable rather than ideal. The theorised ‘ideal structure’ acts as a guide, to help business managers to interpret their situation and to give them direction in organising their resources.
119
READINGS P5
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
120
While the drivers create ‘‘needs’’ for forms and capabilities, there is also an interactive relationship between these forms and capability requirements. New methods of working and organising require new capabilities; likewise, the capabilities required by the external drivers constitute a pressure for experimenting with forms. It is worth reviewing the main elements in Figure 1. Drivers
As mentioned, global markets have become more fragmented and turbulent. Product life cycles are shorter and customers require more options during the life cycle of a product. Meanwhile, technological change and the number of components in a product or service mean that few single businesses can fulfil customer demands on their own. Similar challenges face the public sector: many governments have outsourced public services to the private sector and reformed organisations that remain. These reforms are explained as attempts to make bureaucracies more responsive to the public’s needs. Nonetheless, they create pressure for new organisational forms and capabilities. Forms
Over the past 15 years, when measured by employee numbers, the size of companies and workplaces has decreased. Further, companies no longer rely on hierarchy and command as prime sources of direction and control. They have responded to turbulence and fluctuations in demand by empowering employees, establishing cross-functional teams and taskforces, outsourcing non-core functions and focusing on processes rather than product lines. In the 1980s and 1990s, the ‘strategic business unit’ became the focus in divisionalised corporations. This period also saw dramatic growth in new enterprises funded by venture capital. These smaller, fragmented units, while more responsive, were severely limited in their access to resources and capabilities. The trend towards vertical integration, which characterised the corporations of the early to middle part of the 20th century, is being reversed. The value chain is becoming more clearly desegregated, as each component becomes the prime responsibility of a relatively independent unit or set of units. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Capabilities
Companies need to be more agile and flexible under these conditions. Standard operating procedures and long reporting lines are no longer suitable. Rapid changes in customer demand require knowledge, or access to knowledge, to be distributed around the company. In addition, since managers increasingly work across boundaries, their ability to manage a complex supply chain is at a premium. Separate units need ‘absorptive capacity’ – that is, the ability to make sense of, and internalise, information from partner organisations. They must be able to assimilate the knowledge they require and use it. Where outsourcing has been established, employees must become skilled managers of contracts. Beyond formal contractual skills, they must be good at managing relationships across unit boundaries, which is where appropriate human resource management policies can help. Organisations may no longer need to own certain resources, but they do need to be able to access and use them effectively. Examples of these trends can be found in many countries though it is important not to assume that large organisations have abandoned traditional structural characteristics. Forms are still evolving. In a survey of 458 companies in Europe by academic Andrew Pettigrew and colleagues, 74 per cent reported an increase in horizontal linkages such asjoint purchasing, sharing R&D across units and sharing marketing information. The survey also found extensive evidence of increased outsourcing (65 per cent) and formation of strategic alliances (65 per cent rise). Reinforcing these findings, an Open University Business School survey of 2,700 companies in the UK revealed that 61 per cent were sharing knowledge with suppliers and 41 per cent were sharing it ‘with other organisations in the network’. These developments were found to have implications for HR policies. HR policies
As companies become more dependent on each other, managing relationships becomes critical. Responsiveness and flexibility are required. Trust becomes important, and the communication and sharing of knowledge. What are the people management implications? How, and by whom, is behaviour to be influenced? Conducting relationships through the supply chain or through a network makes hierarchical control impractical. Equally, relationships are more complex than market transactions. Organisational structures are only one part of design. Other aspects include measurement, norms, expectations, culture and power – and these are often crucial in affecting behaviour. Some organisational reforms may present problems for HR. For example, the shift from a product-based mode to a process-based one can provoke anxiety and resistance. Employees may fear that re-engineering will result in job losses and extensive change. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
In consequence, new kinds of relationship between organisations are flourishing, including joint ventures and strategic alliances. The archetypal form is now the network organisation or ‘N-Form’, characterised by relationships that extend beyond market or contractual obligations. Companies in network relationships expect to share information, knowledge and learning. They expect to reduce risk by collaborating across the supply chain and thereby find mutually profitable solutions. Under these circumstances, competition is less between individual organisations and more between entire supply chains. But managing these new forms requires new capabilities.
121
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
122
READINGS P5
Maintaining commitment to the job and organisation may be difficult during and after such reforms. Narrow job descriptions usually have to be abandoned. For example, re-engineering consultants sometimes recommend that ‘workers’ become ‘process performers’. If managed skilfully, this offers opportunities as well as threats; roles may be enlarged as well as changed, and employees given more autonomy, responsibility and decision-making power. In the modern company, claims Michael Hammer, there is no organisation chart, no departmental manager and virtually no hierarchy. The new psychological contract offers initiative in exchange for opportunity. In the long run, he maintains, ‘the quality of an organisation’s coaching is a key determinant of whether it succeeds or fails. Process design alone is not enough. As more companies learn how to create the art of processes, the advantage will belong to those with an institutionalised capacity for staffing these processes with well-selected and well-trained people.’ In place of hierarchy, the process-focused organisation will use cross-functional teams and taskforces. While some of Hammer’s claims exaggerate actual practice, there is substantial evidence of extensive take-up of these forms. Managers face important HR challenges as a result of these changes: how should they manage people who are not direct employees, and how can they maintain and develop relationships across traditional boundaries? Should outsourced workers on the premises be included in communications, invited to meetings and expected to be involved in commitment-building initiatives? Where activities are outsourced, a critical issue is the potential loss of expertise. Once lost, certain activities and their associated capabilities may be difficult to recover. There is danger of ‘hollowing-out’ the organisation. Innovation may be jeopardised if there is heavy reliance on strictly delineated services from external suppliers – even if service-level agreements are maintained and monitored. There is a major challenge for HR here if the organisation becomes dependent on consultants and contractors. The management writer Peter Drucker argues that companies will eventually outsource all functions that do not have a career ladder up to senior management. He contends that corporations once built like ‘pyramids’ will become more like ‘tents’ and managers will take responsibility for their own career development by exploring their competencies and making good deficiencies. Outsourcing has other implications for HR. For staff transferred from the original employer to a service provider, different countries present different legal regulations. These typically require that prevailing terms and conditions of employment are preserved. In some cases, a task may be outsourced and the employees nominally transferred for day-to-day management purposes, while retaining their employment contract with the original employer. Network organisations often grow out of the fact that resources and knowledge are difficult to locate within the boundaries of a single organisation. These capabilities are more likely to be found distributed across a network of different businesses and contractors. If this is so, HR managers have a major task to identify, retain and develop such resources. Part of a company’s know-how resides in being able to bring relevant people together and enabling them to work together. In the boundaryless organisation there are huge uncertainties surrounding who, if anyone, is managing these processes. In traditional organisations there were relatively clear boundaries between insiders and outsiders. Roles and lines of accountability were relatively clear. Under the network form, ‘contracts’ (formal and tacit) are hybrid, that is to say, part market-based and part relational. In this environment, neither the traditional notion of win-lose competition nor hierarchical command is appropriate. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
The HR function
To what extent do the new forms represent a threat or an opportunity for HR? In some respects these developments allow HR to adopt a more strategic role. Many failures in strategic alliances, mergers and joint ventures have been traced to a neglect of HR issues. This seems to present an opportunity. In addition, many of the challenges thrown up by the new forms put a premium on strategic thinking about human resources. On the other hand, new forms – with an emphasis on devolved authority, flexibility and variability – may be inimical to HRM policies and procedures. In the past, personnel departments grew to a size where systems were uniformly applied across corporations. The classic age of the personnel department was that of the procedure manual. Contractual relationships are less conducive to investment in training, for example. There is a paradoxical relationship between HRM as a relatively new movement and changing organisational forms. Old-fashioned personnel management flourished in bureaucratic structures with rigid job boundaries and detailed negotiations over minor contract variations; the HRM movement sought to overturn assumptions about its role in this environment. Yet, large corporations favoured notions of ‘the human resource’, career planning, commitment building and other tenets of HRM. A shift to small-scale enterprises interacting through short-term market transactions does not create a favourable climate for the exercise of HRM. Conclusions
New organisational forms require new ways of influencing behaviour. The traditional reliance on consistent procedures and rules seems misplaced when corporations are increasingly fashioned around devolved, empowered and agile business units. Companies already face this dilemma. Following a period when many aspects of HR such as selection, development and career management have been devolved, downsised HR departments are often uncertain about intervening in operational units. Some establish call centres to deal with enquiries; other routine processes are being handled via corporate intranets. When activities such as recruitment, induction, relocation and payroll have been outsourced, what role will remain for the HR specialist? In a single organisation, the question is difficult enough. When it comes to a supply chain or a network, it is evident that HR specialists have a great deal yet to learn.
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Instead of developing plans and strategies independently, planning in the network organisation has to be co-ordinated and shared with other participants in the network. Information must be shared to allow managers to solve problems jointly. For example, GE Appliances collaborates with major suppliers. Together they plan for, and respond more quickly to, changes in demand and production schedules. Design, production, scheduling and sales data can be co-ordinated. Monthly sales data are shared with 25 suppliers. Co-ordination of a value chain or network means employees need to be familiar with customer and supplier needs and preferences. One way in which this can be done is to invite suppliers and customers to meetings with employees, where outlines of goals, plans and problems can be explained and discussed. Workers can also be sent on customer and supplier field trips or seconded to these organisations. Further, companies may collaborate by giving taskforces specific aims across the value chain. A more ambitious step is to integrate information systems.
123
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
124
READINGS P5
Further reading
Chandler, A.D. (1986) ‘The evolution of modern global competition’. in Porter, M.E. (ed.) Competition in Global Industries, Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Child, J. and Faulkner, D. (1998) Strategies of Co-operation: Managing Alliances, Networks and Joint Ventures. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Drucker, P. (1993) Post Capitalist Society. New York: HarperCollins. Hammer, M. (1996) Beyond Re-engineering. London: HarperCollins. Pettigrew, A.M. and Ferlie, E.M. (2000) The Innovating Organisation. London: Sage. Storey, J. (ed.) (2001) Human Resource Management: A Critical Text. London: Thomson Learning. Storey, J., Quintas, P., Taylor, P. and Fowle, W. ‘Flexible employment contracts and their implications for product and process innovation’. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 13, 1.
Discussion questions
Describe the key drivers of organisational restructuring in recent years. Explain the implications of outsourcing and the development of network organisations for human resource management.
Give and take Richard Smith, CIMA Insider, March 2002.
A learning outcome in the ‘evaluating strategic options’ section of the Business Strategy syllabus is ‘evaluate and recommend appropriate changes in organisational structure’. The syllabus content refers to ‘the basics of transaction cost analysis and the implications for the location of assets, knowledge, people and activities inside or outside the organisation’. So, what is the connection – what is transactions cost theory? The root of the theory is vested in market economics. In simple terms, markets operate where there are buyers and sellers. A market price is produced for a good or a service, but a contract must be established to ensure effective and efficient performance associated with the agreement or deal struck. These agreements can be regarded as transactions. There are costs associated with making a transaction and acting under its terms. Apart from the costs of ordering, there may be costs associated with negotiations resulting from changes or unforeseen events, or incremental variations to the contract. The Economics of Strategy (D Besanko, D Dranove and M Shanley, New York, John Wiley, 2000) defines an arm’s-length market transaction as ‘one in which autonomous parties exchange goods or services with no formal agreement that the relationship will continue into the future.’ Such arm’s-length transactions are regulated by contract law and this results in costs being incurred by the litigants. In any transaction, a contract protects the parties to the agreement. Contracts permit transactions to proceed in a sequential manner. A supplier provides goods or services and the purchaser then has a contractual obligation to pay, providing that the terms of the agreement have been met. the contract protects the supplier in case the buyer refuses to pay. A payment made on receipt of the goods or services, as in a shop, is a simultaneous contract rather than a sequential one. Establishing contracts for performance results in costs for both parties. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Site specificity: location of assets close together to cut transport and stock costs. Physical asset specificity: changing the construction or engineering of an asset to tailor it to the transaction. Dedicated assets: acquiring an asset in order to complete the contract. Human asset specificity: teaching employees skills to carry out the contract. These may be tangible, such as handling a new piece of equipment, or intangible, such as intellectual property. Brand name capital specificity: when a brand is associated with a specific family of products or services, such as the international goods courier DHL. Temporal specificity: providing services at a specific time – for example, airlines need to book landing slots at an airport.
R-SAs may therefore relate to the buyer of goods and services as well as the supplier. Network organisations are defined in Management Accounting Business Strategy (A Sims and R Smith, CIMA Publications, 2001) as ‘those which rely on relationships with other organisations to carry out their work’. Such organisations may rely on others for core as well as ancillary services. Examples of such organisations include local government authorities and UK hospitals, airlines and railway. Many higher education establishments employ teachers on part-time contracts. Network organisations can involve contract staffing, using particular capital assests, outsourcing and relying on external organisations for referred business. This is nothing new. Networking relies on market forces to meet customer demands. If another supplier is cheaper than the in-house source at an adequate standard, it should be performing the activity. This will improve long-term shareholder value. Transactions cost analysis requires firms to assess supply costs and consider how they can improve shareholder value. Traditional organisational hierarchies must be broken down to establish network organisations. It would be interesting to know whether the development of transactions cost analysis has influenced this process. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Contract law reduces unforeseen problems, but it does not prevent them. If the contracting parties do not foresee all circumstances and contingencies, the contracts will be incomplete. Incomplete contracts lead to transactions costs. The Economics of Strategy states that a relationship-specific asset (R-SA) is ‘an investment made to support a given transaction’. It explains that such an asset cannot be employed on another transaction without some opportunity cost resulting from loss of productivity from the R-SA, or the need to incur further cost to change its use. Therefore an R-SA ties the parties together. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism (O Williamson, Free Press, New York, 1985) explains how a relationship changes from a ‘bidding situation’ where buyers select from a number of suppliers to a ‘small numbers’ bargaining situation after investment by one or both parties in R-SA as a ‘fundamental transformation’. The Economics of Strategy states that suppliers view this situation as a long-term arrangement and may reduce quotes to win a contract. Subsequently, they may use unforeseen events as a reason to increase the price. The buyer, reluctant to incur the costs of changing supplier, may agree. At the bidding stage, the buyer may share information with other suppliers in case the contract breaks down. This causes the supplier and the buyer to be suspicious of each other after the contract is established and may mean that they miss opportunities to improve efficiency. R-SAs may be in various forms:
125
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Revision Questions
2
Section A type questions Question 1.1 Important contingency factors in the design of organisational structures include (A) (B) (C) (D)
Rate of change in the market Size of organisation Strategy of organisation All of the above
Question 1.2 A business organisation with a functional structure has just increased its product lines from two to five. The senior management of the company is considering changing the structure to accommodate this increase. Which of the following structural types would be most appropriate? (A) (B) (C) (D)
Network Divisional Global Virtual
Question 1.3 In a professional bureaucracy, co-ordination is achieved by (A) (B) (C) (D)
Standardisation of skills Standardisation of work processes Direct supervision Standardisation of outputs
Question 1.4 Which of the following organisational structures violates the ‘unity of command’ principle as stated by Henry Fayol? (A) Functional (B) Matrix 127
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
128
REVISION QUESTIONS P5
(C) Geographical (D) Divisional
Question 1.5 The division of an organisation into various departments such as purchasing, manufacturing, marketing, finance, research and development results in what kind of organisational structure? (A) (B) (C) (D)
Network Functional Product Matrix
Section B type questions Question 2 Handy lists four distinct cultural types:
power culture role culture task culture person culture
How would you categorise the following organisations? Briefly explain your choice in each case: (a) a multinational insurance company (2 marks) (b) an advertising agency (2 marks) (c) a medium-sized computer company, selling highly tailored bespoke software to a diverse range of clients (2 marks) (d) a small ‘general store’ (corner shop) (2 marks) (e) a large national driving school (2 marks) (Total marks = 10)
Question 3 X is a small, owner-managed, family restaurant business which employs 10 people. Y is a university with 800 academic, 200 administrative and 100 ancillary staff. The academic staff teach a wide range of courses and conduct research. The administrative staff ensure that university policies and procedures are observed and provide administrative support for teaching and research functions. The ancillary staff provide other necessary services such as security, maintenance, catering and cleaning. Z is a large manufacturing company which produces a wide range of products and employs 30 000 people in its various business divisions. Each of its eight divisions produces a different product and serves a different market. The business divisions enjoy a fair degree of autonomy but are expected to operate within the overall umbrella of the company’s corporate strategy. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Section C type questions Question 4 The Boffin shop (BS) Ltd is the creation of a brilliant electronics engineer by the name of John Goodworth. His particular interest is in the field of microelectronic control systems and he has successfully applied his knowledge to a range of products from washing machines and compact disc players to the programming of military hardware. The early success resulted from his development of a system for controlling gambling machines. The bulk of the initial capital to start the business came from Ron Smart. In return for a half-stake in the business, Smart provided financial backing for the development of a working prototype for the gambling machine control system and its subsequent manufacture. Goodworth and Smart exhibited their product at a trade exhibition and secured enough orders to begin manufacturing with confidence. From the beginning, BS Ltd manufactured only the electronic control system and some of the equipment required for interfacing with the variety of appliances or machines for which they were designed. The manufacturer of some parts required specialised equipment so this work was subcontracted mainly to local firms but sometimes to companies elsewhere in the country but increasingly also to countries in the Far East. John Goodworth acted as managing director taking responsibility for all aspects of the company’s activities from R&D through production to sales and marketing. His wife Annie acted as secretary and general administrator. Ron Smart had the title of nonexecutive director but played little active part in the business. The day-to-day financial transactions of the company were dealt with by a young geography graduate but the company hired a professional accountant for a few days each month to provide advice and to prepare the company’s accounts. The rest of the employees were employed in manufacturing except for a young engineer who worked closely with John Goodworth on the development of control systems for a wider range of applications. In 1997, two events triggered the start of a period of sustained growth for BS Ltd. The first of these was the receipt of a substantial order from South Africa for gambling machines incorporating BS’s electronic control system. The second was the securing of a contract with the Ministry of Defence to develop a control system for a new range of military hardware. The first of these events required a substantial expansion of the firm’s manufacturing capacity while the second led to the recruitment of 15 engineers to help in the development of the control electronics for the new military equipment. The newly recruited engineers made progress on the military hardware systems and developed control systems for programming washing machines, dryers, compact disc players and several other applications. The expansion also brought with it several management problems. The extra work brought in over the 3 years from 1997 required an increase in personnel from a mere twelve to nearly a hundred by the year 2000. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Requirement Using Mintzberg’s typology of organisational configurations, identify the most appropriate configuration for the X business, Y University, and Z Company. Justify your choice in each case. (10 marks)
129
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
130
REVISION QUESTIONS P5
Requirements (a) Describe the term ‘organisation structure’ and explain how a well-designed structure can assist in the efficient operation of an organisation. (12 marks) (b) Describe an entrepreneurial organisation structure. (4 marks) (c) Describe the type of organisational structure you would recommend for BS following its recent process of growth and provide reasons for your choice. (9 marks) (Total marks = 25)
Question 5 ‘‘Asset specificity’’ is a term used within Transactions Cost Theory. It has been defined as the extent to which particular assets are only of use in one specific range of operations. It has further been suggested that asset specificity falls into six categories: site specificity, physical asset specificity, human asset specificity, dedicated asset specificity, brand name capital specificity and temporal specificity. Supporters of resource-based views of strategy contend that a firm’s sustainable competitive advantage is generated from its possession of unique assets that cannot be easily irritated by other firms. These unique assets have been called core competencies or distinctive capabilities. Network organisations have been defined as those which are reliant on relationships with other organisations to carry out their work. Requirements (a) Briefly explain what transaction costs are and how resource-based views of strategy can be used for competitive advantage. Interpret the six categories of asset specificity by explaining what they mean. (15 marks) (b) Discuss whether analysis of transactions cost has any influence on the increase in numbers of network organisations. (10 marks) (Total marks = 25)
2005.1
Solutions to Revision Questions
2
Section A solutions Solution 1.1 (D)
Solution 1.2 (B)
Solution 1.3 (A)
Solution 1.4 (B)
Solution 1.5 (B)
Section B solutions Solution 2 Common errors Running out of time by spending too much on one sub-part; inability to justify reasons for clarification; inability to identify the main cultures in the five different situations. (a) The multinational insurance company is likely to have a role culture. The bureaucratic nature of the insurance company stems from its size; the sheer bulk of processing required for new insurance, renewals and claims implies a complex framework of written rules and regulations. 131
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
132
SOLUTIONS TO REVISION QUESTIONS P5
(b) The advertising agency is a good example of ‘person culture’. Individuals will typically be striving to achieve their personal ambitions. The culture may be intense and aggressive, with office politics being an important cultural constituent. Alternatively, the agency could be described as a task culture, whereby obedience to particular accounts (i.e. clients) would take precedence over rules or procedures. (c) The computer company designs and sells software according to the highly specific requirements of each customer. Thus the overriding cultural influence is that of commitment to task (i.e. the prevailing culture is ‘task culture’). This project orientation allows flexibility, which is vital in meeting the various needs of different customers. (d) The ‘corner shop’ is likely to be managed by its owner (owner-entrepreneurial control). Because ownership and management are combined, there is likely to be limited formalisation, with most decision-making by the owner. The business will therefore have a power culture. (e) The large national driving school is a good example of role culture. Driving lessons are standardised, the cars will be bought in bulk (leading to operational savings), staff are trained in a standardised way, and advertising will be centrally controlled.
Solution 3 The configuration that would best describe X Company in Mintzberg’s terms is the ‘simple structure’ because it is a small organisation with an owner/manager who can be regarded as constituting the strategic apex. He is also likely to wish to retain control over decisionmaking given that it is a family business; a characteristic described by Mintzberg as a pull to centralise. With only 10 employees, little of the behaviour in the organisation will be formalised. Most of the 10 employees can be regarded as part of the operating core, with very little in the way of the techno-structure or support staff. Such division of labour as exists will probably be in terms of that between kitchen staff involved in food preparation and washing dishes and those waiting on table. In addition to the owner manager, who will probably be involved in all managerial activities, there may be one or two employees who occupy what Mintzberg calls the middle line such as the chef and the supervisor of the table waiting staff. The most likely configuration for Y University will be the ‘professional bureaucracy’ because the tasks of teaching and research that characterise the core tasks of the University rely on a body of trained professionals to undertake them. The key feature of this kind of configuration is that it has to rely on trained professionals in order to attain its objectives. This gives the professionals an unusual degree of power and so a common problem for professional bureaucracies like Y University is how to ensure control of the professionals who constitute the operating core of this kind of organisation. The professional bureaucracy arises in circumstances in which the environment is stable, yet complex. The complexity of the task requires reliance on trained professionals, but the relatively stable demand for teaching and research enables the application of standardised skills. There is little need for a large techno-structure since standardisation occurs as a result of training that takes place outside the organisation. Because the academics in Y University work independently, the operating core will be fairly large, but the middle line will be relatively small. The support staff in the way of administrative and ancillary staff, however, will be fairly large to provide support to the academic staff. 2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Section C solutions Solution 4 (a) The term ‘organisation structure’ is defined as the established pattern of relationships within an organisation including those between job roles, sections and departments. It is a framework that facilitates processes such as communication, leadership and decision-making. Organisational structure also reflects the way in which work is divided up, in other words the division of labour. This enables specialisation to take place so that individuals and departments can become efficient by their concentration on particular tasks. This division of labour necessarily requires coordination of activities and so the structure also contains mechanisms such as liaison committees for ensuring this takes place. Particularly important to ensure direction and coordination is the existence of hierarchy in the structure so that those occupying superior positions have the authority and power to see that all activities are directed at ensuring the fulfilment of the organisation’s objectives. It is common to see organisation structure depicted in an organisation chart. This is a useful picture of the bare bones of the hierarchy and reporting relationships but such charts cannot of course capture the complexity of the relationships within the structure. It is also necessary to observe that what is often set out in company documents, as the organisation structure may not in fact reflect the true nature of actual power and reporting relationships. Organisations are dynamic entities containing people with their own motives and agendas for achieving personal objectives. Thus it is not unusual to find those individuals or groups exercising power in a way that is not set out on any company organisation chart. (b) An entrepreneurial structure is sometimes described as not having a structure at all. This is because the owners or managers like John and Annie Goodworth can deal with most issues on a face-to-face basis. In the early development of an organisation it is common for the founder of the firm to make all the decisions and to have every employee directly answerable to the owner-manager. Relationships tend to be informal and there tends be an absence of rules and procedures. (c) The most common form of organisational structure adopted when an organisation starts to outgrow the ability of the owner-manager to cope with the growing number of employees and issues facing him/her is the functional structure. Though the case scenario gives us limited information it looks as if this occurred in BS before the expansion of 1997. We are told that, although John Goodworth acted as MD for the company as a whole, Annie was taking responsibility for much of the general administration and that some semblance of a finance/account department was emerging as were separate R&D and manufacturing departments. 2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
The most likely configuration for Z Company will be the ‘divisional structure’, because it has probably found that the easiest way to cope with producing a number of different products aimed at different markets is best achieved by a degree of specialisation. In this case, specialisation is enabled by a division of labour into eight different divisions each charged with producing a different product or set of products for a particular market.
133
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
134
SOLUTIONS TO REVISION QUESTIONS P5
The growth following the events of 1997 have led to a proliferation of products and a growth in business. The fact that the control systems produced have been for markets as diverse as the Ministry of Defence, the manufacturers of gambling machines and the manufacturers of washing machines and compact disc players, suggests the need for specialisation to cope with the very different demands of these diverse markets. It is difficult to say without further information but it does appear that BS is now reaching a point where a divisional structure may be more appropriate. Even a simple divisional structure with three divisions serving the Ministry of Defence, the manufacturers of gambling machines and miscellaneous control systems may be enough. The advantages of such a division would include clear responsibility based on profit centres, development of product-based expertise, clearer strategic focus and fewer co-ordination problems.
Solution 5 Requirement (a) Transactions Cost Analysis is concerned with more than just unit costs of products or services. It is also concerned with the costs of control specifically relating to the delivery of a product or provision of a service. Transaction costs come about between stages in a production or supply process and it may be both internal to, and external from, the firm itself. In respect of an external supply, such costs may include drafting legal contracts and monitoring supply and quality. Similarly, internal costs of quality control and human resource management may be included as transaction costs. Such costs exist because all parties want to have protection against loss, and contractual arrangements may be used by each to protect their position. Resource-based views of strategy take the view that unique assets which cannot be easily replicated by other firms can act as a defence. They may be viewed in Porter’s terms as a defence barrier allowing the firm to reduce threats and exploit opportunities within a highly competitive environment. Such unique assets may enable a firm to achieve supernormal profits, that is those which cover more than the normal opportunity cost of capital. The six categories of asset specificity may be interpreted as follows: 1 Site specificity relates to the assets which are connected to a particular geographical position, for example, locating a goods distribution organisation close to a motorway network; 2 Physical asset specificity is concerned with identifying particular physical assets or possessions with particular attributes such as valuable mineral deposits or natural ingredients with particular healing qualities; 3 Human asset specificity is associated with very specialist knowledge or skills such as that possessed by surgeons or an employee who has particular knowledge of a specialist process; 4 Dedicated asset specificity relates to an asset which was built for a single purpose or application, such as bridges or dedicated buildings; 5 Brand name capital specificity concentrates a brand name to one family of products or services such as might be employed by a food manufacturer, type of engine or air travel service provider; 6 Temporal specificity is concerned with providing a specialist product or service at a specific time as might be employed by a television broadcaster.
2005.1
INTEGRATED MANAGEMENT
Requirement (b) Network organisations establish relationships with other organisations to supply goods and services. They are concerned with more than just outsourcing as they look to other organisations to supply core products as well as ancillary services. There are many examples of such organisations, particularly in respect of leisure services and supply of produce such as flowers being delivered to domestic households through a worldwide network. Oliver Williamson stated that the reduction of transaction costs occurs by vertical integration resulting in organisations becoming more divisionalised and complex. Many organisations do carry out their own branding, training, ancillary service provision and often pay more than the going market rate in order to retain key staff. This approach seems to be at odds with the theory of networking as described. Networking is reliant on market forces to provide goods and services in order to meet customer demands. The principle is quite straightforward: if the market can supply the product or service at an appropriate level of quality more cheaply than the firm itself, then let it do so. This aims to increase shareholder value by reducing organisational costs. The reasons for the diversity existing may be as a result of: Firms underestimating the cost of internal control to provide goods and services inhouse. This is a constant concern of organisations which may have been exacerbated by the traditional form of absorption costing. Essentially, many firms believe that the provision of a good or service by an outside contractor may be ‘‘more expensive’’, but this may be based on false assumptions regarding in-house costs because of arbitrary and sometimes absurd apportionments of fixed overheads. Activity based costing has done much to identify true overhead costs associated with specific products and services. Advances in information technology have led to a reduction in transaction costs. The perception of the need to rely on a single source of supply, possibly a monppoly supplier is no longer as prominent as it once was. Electronic developments have in themselves led to greater awareness of choice and outsourcing. The development of trust between contracting partners have also led to greater outsourcing. Many organisations have entered long-term relationships with suppliers and customers resulting in much higher degrees of trust and collaboration for mutual benefit. The traditional economic theory of a hierarchical organisation as provided by classical organisational theorists has become outdated. Although such organisations have been able, in general, to provide management with high degrees of control, they have not necessarily operated in the best interests of shareholders. In fact, large hierarchical organisations have often developed as a result of agency theory and managers building their own empires, securing their own positions and creating power domains. These have not necessarily had increasing shareholder value as the main driver. Such organisations may have, in fact, been operating inefficiently, but they survive because of their sheer size and market power.
2005.1
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
Some of these categories may be employed together by the same provider, for example, a broadcaster might employ human asset specificity in terms of a presenter delivering the broadcast at a specific time (temporal specificity) from a purpose-built studio (dedicated asset specificity).
135
STRATEGY, STRUCTURE AND CULTURE
136
SOLUTIONS TO REVISION QUESTIONS P5
Transaction Cost Analysis has forced firms to look more seriously at their own supply costs. It has caused them to look in more detail at how well they meet their shareholder requirements. This, in turn, has led them to take note of market forces in delivering their product or service in a cheaper manner. Thus, it can be argued that Transaction Cost Analysis has to some extent influenced the increase in the number of network organisations. Transactions Cost Analysis firmly embraces the concept of continual improvement. This, in itself, may be facilitated by networks of contracts, both internal and external. All employees within an organisation have customers whether they are internal or external. The increasing development of network organisations is clear, but firms must be wary of losing their core competencies by other network firms recruiting key staff. Some staff, for example, are placed on restrictive long-term contracts to protect the firm. This, in turn, may lead to reduced overall efficiency, but it is a natural response by a firm to protect its position.
2005.1
3
Contemporary Thinking on Strategy
L EARNING O UTCOMES After completing this chapter you should be able to: "
discuss concepts in contemporary thinking on strategic management;
"
evaluate competitive situations and apply this knowledge to the organisation;
"
explain the importance of business ethics and corporate governance to the organisation and its stakeholders.
3.1 Trends in the general management and structure of organisations The selection and interpretation of trends in the general management and structure of organisations varies from author to author but an examination of a number of accounts provides us with the following general picture.
3.1.1 Changes in the business environment Most commentaries on such trends commence with observations about changes in the business environment. Changes in this environment are seen as the result of a number of developments. These include the drive by multinational companies for new markets as domestic markets become saturated, the liberalisation of trade and the deregulation and privatisation of industries and developments in the technology of communication and transportation. Such developments it is argued have helped to produce a global market. Geographical space, it is claimed, has been eliminated or at least reduced by such technical developments as the internet and jet-propelled aircraft. These developments mean that companies are able to compete more easily anywhere in the world, with the effect that competition becomes ever fiercer. Technological developments in the mass media, particularly in satellite television, spur the development of global markets by advertising the 137
2005.1
CONTEMPORARY THINKING ON STRATEGY
138
STUDY MATERIAL P5
lifestyle of people in the more affluent countries. This image of a better life generates a desire for ever-more consumer goods, and with rising affluence comes increasing demand. Removal of protectionism and deregulation have eased access to foreign markets and again made for increases in competition between domestic producers and foreign suppliers. Presented with opportunities for greater and cheaper access to foreign markets on the one hand and with the threat of increasing competition on the other, companies have been forced to change the way they manage and operate their businesses and the way they structure their organisations. The kinds of changes that are taking place in organisations and in their management are elaborated upon in the later sections of the Study System, so it will suffice here to introduce and to outline the more important of these. One of the most frequently mentioned changes concerns developments in the structure of organisations. Increasing competition it is argued requires organisations to be more flexible so that they can be more responsive to changes in the market place. In particular, organisations need to be flatter, leaner, fitter, less bureaucratic and more organic in the way they operate than in past more settled times. The shift from mechanistic, tall, rigid, hierarchical forms of organisation to flatter, more task-orientated organic organisations has been achieved to some extent by downsising, delayering and outsourcing. These changes are discussed in Chapter 2. Also covered in Chapter 2 is the shift towards ‘network’ forms of organisation. Domestic organisations long ago found that it could be to their advantage to form collaborative relationships with suppliers and buyers but with the globalisation of markets the need for international strategic alliances has also increased. Access to markets can be greatly facilitated by developing an alliance with a local partner who is familiar with the market that a company wishes to enter. The economic rationale for such developments therefore has to do with access to markets, with the sharing of knowledge and expertise and with economies of scale and scope. The increase in the number of these networks has been greatly facilitated by developments in communication technology. Such networks, sometimes called ‘virtual organisations’, consist of a number of partner organisations that collaborate with each other to produce, market and distribute goods and services. The links between the