Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging: 3-Volume Set by Robert R. Edelman, John Hesselink, and Michael Zlatkin ●
Hardcove...
335 downloads
2430 Views
214MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging: 3-Volume Set by Robert R. Edelman, John Hesselink, and Michael Zlatkin ●
Hardcover: 4200 pages
●
Publisher: Saunders; 3 edition (October 21, 2005)
●
Language: English
●
ISBN-10: 0721603068
●
ISBN-13: 978-0721603063
Description: The MRI reference that the American Journal of Roentgenology called "hard to beat" is back in a state- of-the-art New Edition! It comprehensively examines all of the newest technologies and clinical applications relevant to MR imaging of the heart, brain, head and neck, spine, body, and musculoskeletal system. 4,700 beautifully reproduced illustrations - including hundreds of new full-color images - help readers accurately diagnosis a broad spectrum of conditions. This exhaustively revised 3rd Edition delivers more than 70% new content and authors and a new full-color format that covers all the important technologies as you see them. Audience: Diagnostic Radiologists, Radiology Residents, Health Science Libraries.
Table of Contents
VOLUME 1 I. PHYSICS, INSTRUMENTATION, AND ADVANCED TECHNIQUES 1. History 2. Basic Principles 3. Practical Considerations and Image Optimization 4. Instrumentation: Magnet, Gradients, and Coils 5. Pulse Sequence Design 6. Biochemical Basis of the MRI Appearance of Cerebral Hemorrhage 7. Advanced Imaging Techniques 8. Parallel Imaging Methods 9. Principles of Functional Imaging of the Brain 10. Diffusion-Weighted Imaging 11. Diffusion Tensor Imaging 12. Perfusion Imaging of the Brain 13. Contrast Agents: Basic Principles 14. Tissue-Specific Contrast Agents 15. Molecular Imaging 16. Functional Imaging of the Body 17. Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy: Basic Principles 18. High-Field Imaging 19. MRI-Guided Interventions 20. MRI-Guided Intravascular Interventions 21. Screening MRI 22. Image Artifacts and Solutions 23. Image Processing: Principles, Techniques, and Applications 24. Bioeffects, Safety, and Patient Management 25. The MR Imaging Center 26. Measuring the Capacity, Productivity, and Costs of Service of an MRI Center: The Service Costing Approach II. HEART 27. Magnetic Resonance Angiography: Basic Principles 28. Basic Principles and Clinical Applications of Flow Quantification 29. Principles and Optimization of Contrast-Enhanced Three-Dimensional Magnetic Resonance Angiography 30. Magnetic Resonance Angiography of the Body 31. Magnetic Resonance Venography of the Body 32. Cardiac Imaging Techniques 33. Coronary Arteries 34. Myocardial Perfusion 35. Myocardial Viability 36. Valvular Heart Disease 37. Adult Heart Disease 38. Pediatric Congenital Heart Disease VOLUME 2 III. BRAIN 39. Brain: Indications, Technique, and Atlas 40. Adult Brain Tumors 41. Brainstem, Cranial Nerves and Cerebellum 42. Pituitary Gland and Parasellar Region 43. Perfusion and MRS for Brain Tumor Diagnosis 44. Infectious & Inflammatory Diseases 45. Intracranial Hemorrhage 46. Trauma 47. MR Imaging of Epilepsy 48. Practical Clinical Applications of Functional MRI 49. Aneurysms & Vascular Malformations
50. Stroke & Cerebral Ischemia 51. MR Angiography of the Head and Neck 52. Diffusion & Perfusion MRI 53. White Matter Disease 54. Diffusion Tensor Imaging 55. Neurodegenerative Disorders 56. Toxic and Metabolic Disorders 57. Developmental Disorders 58. Pediatric Brain Tumors 59. Pediatric Anoxic/Ischemic Injury 60. Functional MRI in Neuropsychiatric Disorders 61. MR Spectroscopy of the Brain IV. HEAD AND NECK 62. Orbital and Intraocular Lesions 63. Skull Base & Temporal Bone 64. Paranasal Sinuses & Nasal Cavity 65. Nasopharynx & Deep Facial Compartments 66. Lower Face & Salivary Glands 67. Neck V. SPINE 68. Spine Atlas 69. Spinal Cord and Intradural Disease 70. Degenerative Disease 71. Positional and Kinetic Spin Imaging 72. Post-operative Spine 73. Pediatric Spine: Congenital and Developmental Disorders 74. Vertebral & Paravertebral Abnormalities 75. MR Neurography VOLUME 3 VI. BODY 76. Chest, Including Lung Function 77. Breast Cancer 78. Breast Implants 79. MR Cholangiopancreatography 80. Gallbladder 81. Focal Liver Disease 82. Diffuse Liver Disease 83. Liver Transplant Imaging 84. Pancreas 85. Bowel, Peritoneum, and Mesentery 86. Kidneys 87. Adrenal Glands 88. Bladder 89. Prostate 90. Scrotum and Testes 91. Malignant Disorders of the Female Pelvis 92. Female Pelvis: Benign Conditions 93. Pelvic Floor Imaging 94. Fetal MRI 95. Pediatric Body VII. MUSCULOSKELETAL SYSTEM 96. Musculoskeletal MRI Techniques 97. MR Arthrography 98. Kinematic MRI 99. Shoulder 100. Elbow 101. Wrist and Hand 102. Hip 103. Knee 104. Ankle and Foot 105. TM Joint 106. The Musculotendinous Unit 107. Bone and Soft Tissue Tumors 108. Marrow Disorders 109. Cartilage 110. Pediatric Musculoskeletal Disorders 111. Synovial Disorders 112. Extremity Scanners
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...
1 of 1
http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=S1
HYSICS NSTRUMENTATION AND
DVANCED
ECHNIQUES page 1 page 2 page 2 page 3
ISTORY OF
AGNETIC
ESONANCE
Roy Irwan Matthijs Oudkerk Great advances have been made in recent decades in the development of (nuclear) magnetic resonance (imaging). The imaging community often omits the word "nuclear" and attaches the word "imaging" so that NMR becomes MRI. The former change is largely due to public relations concerns, while the latter refers to the imaging. For convenience and consistency, MR is used for both NMR and MRI throughout this chapter unless otherwise stated. A knowledge of the history of MR allows us to better appreciate the remarkable progress in the field. According to the Roman philosopher, Marcus Tullius Cicero (106-43 BC), those who have no 1 knowledge of the things that took place before their birth will remain a child. 2-5,14-36
The fundamentals of conventional MR have been expounded in a number of texts. It is our intent in this chapter to chronologically review the most important milestones related to the development of MR, including the first commercially available MR scanners. Such a review, especially in a relatively short chapter, inevitably leads to difficult compromises. Those interested in more detailed discussions are referred to the cited references and references therein. We confine the scope of the discussion in this chapter to a description of the relevant contributors to the physics both before and after the Nobel Prize in 1952, a year that is often regarded as the birth of MR. In addition, a guided tour of the Fourier transform will be given in a separate section, before we discuss the development of MR imaging. Many manufacturers have developed pulse sequences and have often used different names for the same technique. For this reason we strive to classify the main classes of pulse sequences and list them according to the major manufacturers. Finally, it is not our goal to cover clinical applications or contrast agents, which are dealt with in other chapters later in this book.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:22
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
1 of 17
OVERVIEW OF THE HISTORY OF MAGNETIC RESONANCE
Early Scientific Contributions Although the basic discovery of MR was often related to the Nobel Prize in 1952, the fundamental phenomenon of MR is much older and may be traced back to the Fourier transform which is a real watershed in the history of MR.
Fourier Jean Baptiste Joseph Fourier (Fig. 1-1) was born on March 21, 1768 in Auxerre and died on May 16, 1830 in Paris. Fourier served three years as the secretary of the Institut d'Egypte at the beginning of the 19th century and later became prefect of the Isère département in France.6 Furthermore, he was one of the chief engineers on Napoleon's expedition to Egypt, where the torrid climate appealed to him. The focus of his life, however, was mathematics and without his Fourier transform we would not be able to create MR images. A brief overview of the Fourier transform will be given in a separate section later in this chapter. The 1920s were extremely fruitful scientifically, particularly due to the success of quantum theory and quantum mechanics. The milestones in the field of MR are summarized below.
Pauli In 1924, an Austrian physicist, Wolfgang Pauli (Fig. 1-2), proposed a quantum spin number for electrons. He is best known for the Pauli exclusion principle, proposed in 1925, for which he received 12 the Nobel Prize in 1945. page 3 page 4
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-1 J Fourier,1768-1830, the founder of the Fourier transform, which is the basis of most (medical) imaging modalities today.
This principle says that two identical particles (fermions) cannot exist in the same quantum state.4
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
2 of 17
Furthermore, prior to World War II, Pauli was the first to recognize the existence of the neutrino, an uncharged and massless particle that carries off energy in radioactivity.12
Uhlenbeck In the same year as Pauli proposed his exclusion principle, George Uhlenbeck (Fig. 1-3), introduced the concept of a spinning electron, with resultant angular momentum and a magnetic dipole moment arising from the spinning electrical charge. It was Pauli's exclusion principle that led Uhlenbeck to arrive 4 at this idea. He wrote : "… it occurred to me that, since (I had learned) each quantum number corresponds to a degree of freedom of the electron, Pauli's fourth quantum number must mean that the electron had an additional degree of freedom - in other words the electron must be rotating." The concept immediately excited a number of great scientists at that time such as Bohr, Pauli, Einstein, Heisenberg and others interested in quantum theory. Besides this work, Uhlenbeck also contributed significantly to atomic structure and the kinetic theory of matter. He extended Boltzmann's equation to dense gasses and wrote two papers on Brownian motion.11
Rabi
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-2 W Pauli, born on 25 April 1900 in Vienna, received the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1945 for his exclusion principle. (Reproduced by permission of the Nobel Foundation.)
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
3 of 17
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-3 G Uhlenbeck (left) and N van Kampen (right) during the Boltzman conference in Vienna in 1973. Uhlenbeck proposed the concept of electron spin in 1925. (Courtesy of N van Kampen.)
During the early 1930s Isaac Rabi (Fig. 1-4), born in Raymanov, Austria, on July 29, 1898, set up a laboratory at Columbia University in New York which later became a major center for atomic and 13 molecular studies. page 4 page 5
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-4 I Rabi was born in Austria in 1898 and awarded the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1944 for his investigation on molecular beam magnetic resonance methods. (Reproduced by permission of the Nobel Foundation.)
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
4 of 17
Rabi's successful research was influenced by the visit of Cornelis Jacobus Gorter (see below), a Dutch physicist, in September 1937. Gorter and his co-worker Broer reported unsuccessful attempts to observe nuclear magnetic resonance in pure crystalline materials.7 This first publication with the name "Nuclear Magnetic Resonance" in Gorter's paper provided important clues to Rabi, who accepted and realized Gorter's suggestions concerning his experiments, modified them and was finally able to 2 observe resonance experimentally. This led to the publication of "A New Method of Measuring Nuclear Magnetic Moment" in 1938 where the first MR signal from LiCL (lithium chloride) (Fig. 1-5) was reported.8 Although this publication refers to Gorter's visit and unsuccessful experiment, it does not acknowledge his suggestions. Gorter's reaction to Rabi's publication was rather furious9: "I cannot deny that I felt some pride, mixed with the feeling that my contribution was somewhat undervalued though my advice was acknowledged in the Letter." Rabi was eventually awarded the Nobel Prize for physics in 1944 for his investigation on the molecular beam magnetic resonance methods.
Gorter Gorter himself (Fig. 1-6) was born in Utrecht on August 14, 1907. He went to school in The Hague and studied physics in Leiden. He was the first to demonstrate the phenomenon of paramagnetic relaxation10 and narrowly missed the discovery of nuclear spin resonance.
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-5 First reported MR signal from LiCl by Rabi. The beam intensity is measured as a function of various values of the magnetic fields.2,11 One ampere corresponds to approximately 1.84 × 10-4 Tesla (T).
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
5 of 17
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-6 C Gorter, a Dutch physicist, attempted to observe resonant heating of a substance in a strong magnetic field, without success. His negative result, however, provided the important clues to Rabi's successful experiments. (Courtesy of Leiden University.)
His approach was to use a resonance property of the nuclear spins when they are placed in a magnetic field B0. At the Larmor frequency, where γ is the gyromagnetic ratio, Gorter knew that a magnetic dipole transition should occur if an alternating radiofrequency (RF) field B1 is applied perpendicular to B0. page 5 page 6
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-7 First measurement for electron paramagnetic resonance on copper at 4.76 mT carried out
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
by Zavoisky at the Kazan State University.
Gorter expected to detect the heat produced by resonant absorption in the sample by using a sensitive calorimetric method that he had successfully employed in studies of electron paramagnetic relaxation. Unfortunately, he did not observe heat absorption from the resonant process and concluded that a long spin-lattice relaxation time caused the spin system to be partially saturated when RF energy was 4 absorbed. Later it appeared that he used excessively pure samples that produced longer relaxation times, causing the partial saturation mentioned before and therefore no detectable resonance. He then missed the Nobel Prize. As a person, Gorter was both an experimentalist and skilled at developing theoretical ideas. He died in Leiden on March 30, 1980.
Zavoisky The first detection of electron paramagnetic resonance (Fig. 1-7) was carried out at Kazan State University, Russia, by Evgeny Zavoisky (Fig. 1-8) in 1944-1945. Zavoisky had first attempted to detect MR in 1941 but, like Gorter, he had failed. He used a sample of water to which paramagnetic ions were added to shorten the completely unknown relaxation time. He was inspired by Rabi's resonance studies in molecular beams but he was also aware of Gorter's unsuccessful 1936 attempt to detect MR. After the German invasion of Russia caused several laboratories to move from Moscow to remote Kazan, he continued trying to detect electron resonance in both solids and solutions of paramagnetic salts. Eventually, he obtained signals with equipment working in the range of 1 GHz and published a paper13 which is generally accepted as the first reported observation of electron paramagnetic resonance.
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-8 E Zavoisky, born on 28 September 1907, a major contributor to MR from Kazan, which was part of the former Soviet Union.
Zavoisky's name is written in the history of science because of his detection of electronic paramagnetic
6 of 17
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
7 of 17
resonance and his brilliant work on nuclear physics, controlled thermonuclear synthesis and physical electronics.4 His work resulted in important progress in MR, although Russian contributions to MR were hardly discussed in the West. The practical application of the discoveries made so far came from a breakthrough for which two American physicists received the Nobel Prize.
The Nobel Prize for Physics 1952 Although an incredible amount of fundamental work on MR had been done long before World War II, 1946 is commonly regarded as the year in which MR was discovered. During this year, Felix Bloch14 15 (Fig. 1-9) and Edward Purcell (Fig. 1-10) independently detected the MR phenomenon, for which both shared the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1952.12 Their work was particularly accredited to a property of atomic nuclei having an odd number of nucleons that precess at RF in a magnetic field, the frequency depending on the magnetic strength.
Purcell Purcell was born in Taylorville, Illinois, USA, on August 30, 1912. 12 As a leader of a fundamental research group at the MIT Radiation Laboratory, he proposed trying an experiment to detect the transition between nuclear magnetic energy levels using RF methods. He was initially unaware of Gorter's similar unsuccessful experiment. page 6 page 7
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-9 F Bloch first observed the property of atoms in a magnetic field, which he referred to as "nuclear induction." Together with E Purcell, he shared the Nobel Prize for Physics in 1952. (Reproduced by permission of the Nobel Foundation.)
Together with his colleagues Torrey and Pound, he prepared a resonant cavity to study the absorption of RF energy in paraffin. After some trial and error, they verified the signal and found the resonance. 15 Their report of this discovery was published in Physical Review in 1946.
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
Bloch Bloch was born in Zurich, Switzerland, on October 23, 1905 and taught at the University of Leipzig until 12 1933. He came to the US in 1933, joined Stanford University at Palo Alto in 1934 and became a US citizen in 1939. He died in 1983 in Zurich.
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-10 Purcell independently discovered the MR phenomenon in 1946. (Reproduced by permission of the Nobel Foundation.)
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-11 Bloch's schematic representation describing how the RF field B1 induces rotation of magnetization towards the transverse plane (left) and the rotating frame behavior (right).
In contrast to Purcell's experiment, Bloch and his colleagues used what they called "nuclear induction."
8 of 17
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
9 of 17
Bloch described the experiment as measuring an electromotive force resulting from the forced precession of the nuclear magnetization in the applied RF field.14 This principle is shown in Figure 1-11, which is a schematic representation most commonly used to describe the concept of MR today. Furthermore, the behavior of the magnetization vector M shown in Figure 1-11 is described by the so-called simplified Bloch equation, given by: where B includes the various magnetic fields applied. page 7 page 8
Although Bloch and Purcell were the first to see the possibility of using MR for medical imaging, it was not until the 1960s that the first MR prototypes were built for medical purposes.
First Magnetic Resonance Images Lauterbur The year 1973 was very important for medical imaging technology. In that year X-ray based computed tomography (CT) was introduced by Hounsfield27 and MR imaging (MRI) was first demonstrated on two small tubes of water by Paul Lauterbur (Fig. 1-12), who used a backprojection technique similar to that of CT.28 Lauterbur published his work in Nature, in an article entitled "Image formation by induced local interaction; examples employing magnetic resonance."28 Despite the fact that the paper was nearly not published, having been initially rejected by the editor as not of sufficiently wide significance for inclusion in the journal, his work represented the foundation for a revolution in imaging. In this paper Lauterbur described a new imaging technique which he termed zeugmatography (from the Greek zeugmo meaning joining together), which was later replaced by MRI. This zeugmatography referred to the joining together of a weak gradient magnetic field with the stronger main magnetic field, allowing the spatial localization of two tubes of water (Fig. 1-13). Moreover, he introduced the use of gradients in the magnetic field. By analysis of the characteristics of the emitted radio waves, he could determine their origin. This made it possible to build up two-dimensional pictures of structures that could not be visualized with other methods.
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-12 P Lauterbur, at that time a professor in chemistry at the University of New York at Stony
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
10 of 17
Brook, first demonstrated MRI on small tube samples in 1973, the same year that CT was invented. (Copyright Bruno Press.)
This imaging experiment, therefore, moved from the single dimension of MR spectroscopy to the second dimension of spatial orientation and thus became the foundation of MR imaging. MR also owes a debt to CT as it was developed initially on the back of CT but quickly outpaced that technique. For this reason, Lauterbur shared the 2003 Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine with Peter Mansfield (discussed below) for their discoveries concerning MRI.
Mansfield
Add to lightbox page 8 page 9
Figure 1-13 The first MR image of two tubes of water demonstrated by Lauterbur using a backprojection technique, upon which CT is based.
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-14 Sir Peter Mansfield devised a new MR imaging technique called echo-planar imaging (EPI) in the late 1970s. EPI is considered to be the first ultra high-speed imaging technique and was used to demonstrate the first clinical MR images. (Copyright Bruno Press.)
The contributions of Sir Peter Mansfield (Fig. 1-14) and the Nottingham group are numerous and fundamental. They include: NMR diffraction in solids slice selection active magnetic shielding of gradient coils echo volume imaging active acoustic shielding methods that lower noise levels produced by gradient coils. Of great relevance to the field of fast MR imaging, and in particular to diffusion, perfusion and functional imaging of the brain, Mansfield further developed the utilization of gradient magnetic fields. He showed how the signals can be mathematically analyzed which later gave rise to the echo-planar imaging (EPI) technique in 1977.35 EPI was the first ultra high-speed imaging technique and many of its 28 variants are now in use. Furthermore, Mansfield was the first to demonstrate clinical MR images using his technique. A color version of a cross-sectional MR scan of a human finger in vivo is shown in Figure 1-15. Thus, modern MR imaging of human internal organs with exact and noninvasive methods was born. For this reason, the Nobel Assembly at the Karolinska Institute decided to award the Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine for 2003 jointly to Mansfield and Lauterbur, as discussed earlier.
First Commercial Magnetic Resonance Scanners Aberdeen Prototype The first MR scanners appeared almost at the same time in the 1970s. However, the whole-body magnet (Fig. 1-16) was first built by Oxford Instruments Ltd in cooperation with the University of 16 Aberdeen. Work first began in Aberdeen in 1972 by a group under the direction of John Mallard (Fig. 1-17) and led by James Hutchison. They originated the "spin-warp" method of spatial localization for MRI, now universally used.
11 of 17
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
12 of 17
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-15 First clinical MR image showing a cross-section of a human finger as demonstrated by 38
Mansfield in a color version.
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-16 The Aberdeen MR imaging prototype. Hutchison himself is in the position of the patient.
The group was very interested in the T1 relaxation time and extensive studies were performed on normal and pathologic tissues.16 T1 values of normal and malignant animal and human tissues have been presented and their implications for in vivo clinical MR imaging have been discussed. 17
FONAR In 1971, Raymond Damadian (Fig. 1-18) reported a marked difference in relaxation times between normal and abnormal tissues of the same type, as well as between different types of normal tissues. 18
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
13 of 17
page 9 page 10
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-17 J Mallard at Aberdeen University led research on the first whole-body MR prototype depicted in Fig. 1-16.
This discovery is the basis for the tissue contrast of every MR image today and hence the creation of the MR industry. This milestone is also often regarded as the first successful MR method for medical diagnosis in which MR could detect disease.20 Damadian filed a pioneer patent for the practical use of his discovery in 1972 (Fig. 1-19). Moreover, he noticed that centering the MR object in the magnet produced a good signal and moving the object too far off center caused it to vanish. Based on this idea, he designed a scan using a saddle-shaped magnetic field so that only the center was at the resonant frequency, later known as Field fOcusing Nuclear mAgnetic Resonance (FONAR).18
Philips
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-18 R Damadian, an American medical doctor at the State University of New York in Brooklyn, demonstrated MR of the whole human body.
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-19 Damadian patented the relaxation differences and their use in MR scanning.22 (Courtesy of FONAR Corporation).
The pioneering MR scanner, the result of a joint project between Philips Research Laboratories Eindhoven and Philips Medical Systems Best, is shown in Figure 1-20. Luiten led the PROTON Project which commenced in May 1978 and used a resistive magnet with coils of copper tubing which acted as the conductor and also conveyed the coolant, producing a magnetic field strength of 0.15 T.21 The magnet had a field diameter of approximately 1 m and at that time, it was the biggest and the
14 of 17
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
15 of 17
strongest scan magnet in the world with a power of 60 kW. A couple of years later superconducting magnets were designed which allow for much higher magnetic field strengths. page 10 page 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-20 The first Philips MR 0.15 T scanner built in 1978 at Philips Research Laboratories, Eindhoven. Frame dimensions are 1.5 × 1.9 × 1.9 m (l × w × h). (Courtesy of Philips Medical Systems, Best.)
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-21 The first transverse MR image (Luiten's head) acquired using a 0.15 T Philips resistive magnet in 1978. Slice thickness was 10 mm. The method was selective excitation and 2D Fourier imaging.24 (Courtesy of Philips Medical Systems, Best.)
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
16 of 17
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-22 One of the early resistive 0.2 T MR scanners built in 1979. (Courtesy of Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen.)
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-23 Siemens' first transverse MR image of a volunteer acquired using a 0.2 T in 1980. (Courtesy of Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen.)
Unlike the backprojection technique proposed by Lauterbur, which used one-dimensional Fourier transform (1D-FT), the first successful MR image produced by Philips was obtained with the two-dimensional Fourier transform (2D-FT) imaging.21 Despite a relatively low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), the image shows many anatomical details, such as optic nerves, skull bone and internal carotid arteries (Fig. 1-21). Not until after the advent of superconducting magnets in 1982 could better MR images be produced.
Siemens Siemens' involvement with MR development began in the late 1970s. An early resistive 0.2 T prototype magnet is shown in Figure 1-22. This prototype was the first Siemens MR to be installed in a clinical environment.22 page 11 page 12
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001001
17 of 17
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-24 The first MR image of Siemens, acquired in 1979 and recalculated in 1980. (Courtesy of Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen.)
22
The first Siemens head image (Fig. 1-23) was produced using this prototype in March 1980. The first images of a red pepper (Fig. 1-24) in 1980 were the signal to get Siemens off to a flying start on the next phase of MR product development, which culminated in the Magnetom. The first Magnetom, with a superconducting 0.35 T magnet (Fig. 1-25), was delivered to the Mallinckrodt Institute in St Louis, USA.22
General Electric Although General Electric (GE) Medical Systems had built one of the early electromagnets (Fig. 1-26), they did not become really interested in the MR market until 1982. The GE Research and Development center in Schenectady began to explore the fields of MR imaging and spectroscopy following the arrival in 1980 of Paul Bottomley and Bill Edelstein, who had had significant experience in Aberdeen.4 By November 1982, they had obtained MR images that were shown at the annual meeting of the Radiological Society of North America. A year later, GE succeeded in producing images with 256 × 23 256 resolution with 4 mm slices and 100-s scan times using a 1.5 T magnet. Bottomley et al reported 1 31 13 the first H MR imaging and localized P or C chemical shift spectroscopy as two new noninvasive 1 diagnostic tools in 1983. Previously, H MR imaging systems all operated at magnetic field strengths below 0.65 T.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001021
1 of 4
A GUIDED TOUR OF THE FOURIER TRANSFORM
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-25 The first Magnetom with a superconducting 0.35 T magnet. (Courtesy of Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen.)
Add to lightbox 4
Figure 1-26 The early electromagnet built by General Electric in 1947 and designed for 0.15 T.
The Fourier transform (FT) is a major foundation of most modern imaging techniques. Introduced into the MR field by Richard Ernst,34 it is now possible to go back and forth between time signal and its frequency spectrum with enough speed to create a whole new range of applications for this mystical mathematical device. An overview of the development of algorithms to perform FT faster and faster can be found in a paper by Cooley et al.26 Although its role in MR is of considerable importance, many MR physicians simply regard the FT as a mystical mathematical tool without any real understanding of it. For this reason we attempt here to explain briefly the basic principles of the FT without going into great detail, before we move on to the next section. page 12 page 13
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001021
2 of 4
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-27 Three cosine waves with their corresponding Fourier transform. A, 2 Hz frequency cosine wave with its FT being two spikes. B, 4 Hz cosine wave with half the amplitude of A. The spikes are twice as far apart than in A because the frequency of the curve on the left is twice as large as that of the curve in B. C, Their sum (A + B) and its frequency spectrum.
The discussion in this section is centered around the following questions. What is the Fourier transform? What can it do? What is its relevance to MR? A more in-depth coverage can be found in many texbooks.24,25,29 For some time the FT has served as a bridge between the time domain and the frequency domain. The FT shows how any signal, one-, two- or three-dimensional, can be broken down into a sum of sine waves of different frequencies, phases and amplitudes. These waves are called frequency components because they are identified by frequency, as explained later. For convenience, let us discuss 1D-FT first. Time-signal cosine waves (Fig. 1-27A) correspond to a pair of spikes in the frequency domain positioned exactly at the frequencies of the cosine wave (Fig. 1-27B). This pair of spikes is symmetrical about zero because the cosine wave is identical for positive and negative frequencies. For example, a cosine wave that has a frequency of 2 Hz (there are two cycles per second) corresponds to a pair of spikes at ±2 Hz at the frequency axis (Fig. 1-27A). The height of the spike is proportional to the amplitude of the cosine wave. Similarly, Figure 1-27B depicts a cosine wave with a frequency twice as high and an amplitude half that of Figure 1-27A. As expected, there are a pair of spikes at ±4 Hz at the frequency axis. Furthermore, Figure 1-27C demonstrates a very important property of the FT stated earlier, namely that the FT of the sum of two or more signals is the sum of each signal's FT.
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001021
3 of 4
The left-pointing arrow in Figure 1-27 symbolizes the inverse FT which returns a Fourier spectrum expressed by its frequency components to its original temporal representation. Mathematically, the FT results in complex numbers that consist of real and imaginary parts that are always 90° out of phase. In practice, complex numbers are just another way of representing a magnitude and a phase of a signal. To understand how the FT can be related to the MR, it is necessary to expand 1D-FT into 2D-FT which is often referred to as a data matrix or an image, as will be discussed below.
Magnetic Resonance Imaging page 13 page 14
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-28 k-space representation. Each row in the data matrix is associated with a phase-encoding gradient pulse applied to a MR signal. Each column in the data matrix represents the frequency of each sample of the signal.
A data matrix is an alternative representation for an MR image and is often called a frequency domain or 29,30 The samples in a data matrix are identified by co-ordinates kx k-space representation of an MR image. and ky. The frequency domain is interesting in MR imaging because MR images begin as data samples in this domain. The concept of k-space was patented by Likes31 and later, independently, proposed by Tweig.32 In principle, a data matrix can be performed in any order depending on the pulse sequence design, as explained later in this section. Furthermore, because a phase-encoding gradient is applied to each row in a data matrix, the vertical axis (ky) is referred to as phase-encoding. Similarly, a frequency-encoding gradient is applied to each column in a data matrix and therefore the horizontal axis (kx) is referred to as frequency encoding (Fig. 1-28). The phase and frequency encoding will be explained later. Since the early 1980s a typical size for the data matrix has been 256 × 256 (phase × frequency encode). After data acquisition is finished, an MR image can be reconstructed using 2D-FT which transforms any image from the frequency domain to the image domain and vice versa. Since the data matrix consists of rows and columns, 2D-FT normally performs each row of the data matrix, from top to bottom. Sometimes it is said that inverse 2D-FT should be performed to obtain a MR image. Both statements are correct as the alternatives differ mainly by a scale factor. Figure 1-29 demonstrates the 2D-FT in which a row in the k-space is shown simply as a 1D-FT of the same row in the image space. In other words, the frequency signal on the left shows a projection of anatomy in the
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001021
4 of 4
image space. Before a MR signal that comes from the coils, often referred to as the free induction decay (FID) signal, can be meaningfully interpreted by the Fourier transform, it has to undergo several processing stages, two of which are discussed below.
Frequency Encoding Frequency encoding in MR imaging is a procedure to resolve spatial information along one direction (usually horizontal) of a MR image. In the absence of any gradients, the excited protons are spinning at the same frequency and the received signal is an exponentially decaying curve. This MR signal is often referred to as T2* FID signal and is illustrated in Figure 1-30. The frequency of a MR signal is equal to the Larmor frequency at the location from which the signal is emitted.30 It is the function of the frequency-encoding gradient to spread out the Larmor frequency to distinguish different locations along one direction. In this case, the protons will be spinning at frequencies that depend upon their position along the gradient. The received signal is thus the sum of the signal at each frequency (Fig. 1-31). The FT is then used to break up the sum signal into its separate frequency components.
Phase-Encoding Spatial information is encoded into the phase of MR signals by the process of phase-encoding. Phaseencoding resolves structures along the direction that is perpendicular to the frequency encoding. As phase is related to angle, phase-encoding can be most easily understood, for instance, as viewing the object from a series of perspectives at different angles (Fig. 1-32). Hence, the steps involved in phaseencoding along the vertical direction (see Fig. 1-28) can be roughly compared to the rotation steps in CT. While the phase-encoding gradient is on, each position along the phase-encoding direction has its own unique Larmor frequency, a point that is similar to the frequency encoding. In contrast, when the gradient is switched off, each position along the phase-encoding direction has an identical Larmor frequency. However, the phases of nuclei in different spatial positions are not identical once the phase-encoding gradient has been turned off. The amount of the phase shift caused by the phase-encoding gradient is the key to identifying the location of structures along the phase-encoding direction of a MR image. The effect of the phase-encoding gradient causing a position-dependent phase shift is illustrated in Figure 1-33. The phase shift increases as long as the phase-encoding gradient is applied. The figure on the left represents the phase dispersion after a brief period of t seconds, while the figure on the right shows the accumulated phase difference after 2t seconds.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
1 of 11
DEVELOPMENT OF MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING Since its introduction as a diagnostic tool in the 1970s, MRI has undergone dramatic improvements in all the features that define image quality, such as resolution, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and speed. page 14 page 15
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-29 Fourier transforming each row in the k-space projects the anatomy along the frequencyencoding direction. The data samples of each row in the k-space are converted into a plot of intensity in the image domain.
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
2 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-30 No gradient is applied during data acquisition which produces a T2* FID signal.
Add to lightbox page 15 page 16
Figure 1-31 A frequency-encoding gradient is applied during data acquisition to spread out the Larmor frequency into distinguishable frequencies. The received signal is broken up into signals at different frequencies.
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
3 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-32 Phase-encoding can be thought of as viewing an object from different angles.
This improvement in resolution and speed has been made possible by the development of stronger magnets and faster gradients producing higher gradient amplitudes (mT/m) and shorter rise times (ms). Simultaneously, the pulse sequences have also grown rapidly over the years since the EPI discovery by Mansfield. For this reason, we have organized our discussion of the development of MRI into three parts, i.e., the magnet, gradient and pulse sequences that make up the main components of a MRI scanner.
Magnets As the most important and expensive component, the magnet predominantly determines SNR and therefore the image quality. The SNR increases approximately linearly with field strength, provided the 37 same sampling bandwidths are used. However, the stronger the magnetic field, the greater the static field inhomogeneity. Resistive magnets were used in the beginning (see previous section). However, these are limited by their electrical power requirements to around 0.3 T and hence are only suitable for low field strength.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
4 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-33 After a phase-encoding gradient pulse has been applied, phase shifts along the vertical direction occur and keep increasing. Left: after t seconds, right: after 2t seconds.
Subsequently, permanent magnets were proposed, which consist of large blocks made from ferromagnetic alloys, e.g., in the form of a C-shaped magnet.33 These types of magnets have a permanent magnetic field with field strength below 0.5 T. The last category and the most widely used are the superconductive magnets with field strengths between 0.5 T and 3 T (research systems may reach 7 T or more). This type of magnet arose from the pioneering contribution to the theory of superconductors and superfluids of Abrikosov, Ginzburg 22 and Leggett (Fig. 1-34), for which they were awarded the Nobel Prize for Physics in 2003. A superconducting magnet has a strong magnetic field generated by the electric current flowing in large coils. In contrast to resistive magnets, superconducting magnets have no resistivity at very low temperatures close to absolute zero. Therefore, a constant, high current will flow for years without an electrical voltage. The early superconducting magnets were very long (2.55 m) and heavy (≈ 8 tons for 1.5 T). However, magnet design has made considerable progress over the years since passive iron shielding was introduced (Fig. 1-35). Therefore, the magnet length has also been reduced to an overall length of around 1.6 m for 1 T and 1.5 T.22 In summary, in the last two decades a gradual increase in static field strength for MRI has occurred, ranging from 0.15 T to 1 T and later 1.5 T. The typical field strength for routine clinical imaging is now 1.5 T, whereas 3 T and more is commonly used for research activities.
Gradients The gradients used for spatial encoding are one of the essential components in MRI as they determine the resolution of the image reconstruction. The spatial resolution is inversely proportional to the gradient time integral over the readout period, TRO. The hatched areas shown in Figure 1-36 represent this time integral. page 16 page 17
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
5 of 11
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-34 A Abrikosov (A), V Ginzburg (B) and A Leggett (C) shared the Nobel Prize for Physics in 2003 for their pioneering contribution to the theory of superconductors and superfluids which are used, for example, in MRI. (Copyright Bruno Press.)
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
6 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-35 Magnet with passive shielding allowing smaller and lighter magnets. (Courtesy of Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen.)
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-36 Gradient time integral (hatched area). To attain the higher level of spatial resolution, gradient amplitude GR (mT/m) must increase and simultaneously the rise time Trise (ms) must decrease.
Table 1-1. Development of MR Gradient Amplitude and Rise Time GR (mT/m)
Trise (ms)
1983 - 85
3-6
1.5 - 1.6
1986 - 89
10
1
1991 - 93
25
0.6
1999 - now
40
0.1 - 0.2
Period
Moreover, as the gradients cannot turn on and off in zero time, i.e., it takes time to ramp the gradients up to the desired amplitude, the rise time, Trise, has become an issue. When the measurement time for a particular MR image is to be shortened without sacrificing resolution, the gradient amplitude, GR, must increase and the rise time must decrease as again demonstrated in Figure 1-36. For this reason, much research has been carried out to develop and implement higher gradient amplitudes and shorter rise times. One major problem is that large numbers of turns in the gradient
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
7 of 11
coils tend to cause high inductance per unit gradient strength, resulting in difficulty in ramping quickly. The development of gradient amplitudes and the rise times commercially available are summarized in Table 1-1.22 As development continues, a gradient amplitude of 80 mT/m and a rise time of 0.1 ms have been prototyped and tested, particularly for head and small animal studies. 22 However, the price of these systems is still too high to allow them to become widely available commercially.
Sequences As mentioned earlier, in order to form an image, a number of MR signals must be acquired. This signal acquisition can be programmed using pulse sequences, which is often considered as the heart of a MR measurement. page 17 page 18
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-37 EPI k-space trajectory maps using the single-shot method (A) and the blipped phaseencoding (B).
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
8 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-38 EPI pulse sequence used to create the k-space trajectory of Fig. 1-37B. Excitation is limited to a single slice by transmitting the RF pulse in the presence of GS. The brief pulses or "blips" of GP cause the trajectory to move up one line at a time in the k-space.
Using the concept of k-space, Mansfield36 introduced the first rapid imaging technique (EPI), which uses a series of gradient echoes to traverse the whole of k-space in a rectangular raster. This technique is achieved by using single-shot methods that generate trains of echoes after a single RF pulse. Each echo is then encoded with different phase-encoding information. A k-space trajectory map of the single-shot method is depicted in Figure 1-37A. Another variant of the single-shot sequence is blipped phase-encoding where small-amplitude steps are applied between readout gradient reversals. A sketch of the k-space trajectory of this sequence is shown in Figure 1-37B. Figure 1-38 shows a straightforward version, using only a single excitation pulse to produce a blipped k-space trajectory shown in Figure 1-37B. The RF pulse is made slice selective by simultaneously turning on a gradient along the slice selection axis. Note that the positive/negative alternation of the readout gradient gives the alternating positive and negative velocities in the readout direction, while the brief pulses or "blips" of the phase-encoding gradient move the data from line to line along that axis.
Table 1-2. Echo-Planar Imaging Terminology Term
Characteristics
Single shot
one excitation pulse
Multishot
more than one excitation pulse
Blipped phaseencoding
small amplitude steps supplied between readout gradient reversals
Spiral phase-encoding phase-encoding gradient has alternately positive and negative polarity Note: terminology is the same for all the manufacturers.
The multishot EPI sequence acquires more points at the same time in the k-space and is therefore
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
9 of 11
faster. This sequence uses more than one excitation pulse to acquire echoes. When EPI was first developed, it was thought that it would have its greatest impact in providing real-time MR images. In practice, its greatest application appears to be in the area of functional MR imaging of the brain. However, because of the gradient-echo nature of the detection technique, all EPI techniques are sensitive to T2* effects, such as field inhomogeneity. Table 1-2 summarizes the various EPI techniques that have been implemented on commercially available systems by various manufacturers.
Spin-Echo Nearly as early as Mansfield's description of EPI, the use of (multiple) 180° refocusing RF pulses following an excitation pulse to generate (multiple) spin-echoes was proposed as shown in Figure 1-40.38 This concept was then implemented at the Delft University of Technology where multiple echo single shot (MESS) and multiple echo multiple shot (MEMS) were developed.40 Hennig et al39 (Fig. 1-39), from the University of Freiburg, modified and improved the sequences and designated them as RARE (rapid acquisition with relaxation enhancement). This technique is better known under the commercial names of fast or turbo spin-echo (TSE), fast spin-echo (FSE) and Half Fourier acquisition turbo spin-echo (HASTE) (Table 1-3). The main difference from the multi-echo SE sequence is that the multiple echoes per excitation are separately phase-encoded, so that data are collected faster (see Chapters 3, 5 and 7). This is achieved by applying a number of consecutive 180° refocusing pulses per excitation, in order to create shots or segments with a corresponding number of differently phase-encoded echoes. Additionally, in terms of scan time, the TSE method reduces the scan time for T2-weighted imaging by an order of magnitude, allowing measurements of eight slices with a 256 × 256 matrix in about one minute.40
Gradient-Echo Sequences page 18 page 19
Table 1-3. Spin-Echo Sequences Single-echo Manufacturer spin-echo
Multi-echo spin-echo
Hybrid Gradient Echo train spin-echo echo - Spin-echo
Siemens MS Single spin-echo
Spin-echo
Turbo spin-echo (TSE)
Turbo Gradient spin-echo (TGSE)
Half Fourier acquisition turbo spin-echo (HASTE) Philips MS
Spin-echo
Multi spin-echo (MSE)
Turbo spin-echo (TSE)
Gradient spin-echo (GRASE)
Ultrafast spin-echo (UFSE) GE MS
Spin-echo
Multi-echo multiplanar (MEMP)
Fast spin-echo (FSE) GRASE
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
10 of 11
Single shot FSE (SS-FSE)
Table 1-4. Gradient-Echo Sequences Manufacturer Spoiled
Post-excitation
Pre-excitation
Magnetization
Siemens MS Fast low angle shot (FLASH)
Fast imaging with steady-state precision (FISP)
Reversed FISP (PSFIF)
TurboFLASH
T2 contrastenhanced (T2 CE-FFE)
Turbo field echo (TFE)
Philips MS
T1 contrastenhanced fast field echo (T1 CE-FFE)
Fast field echo (FFE)
GE MS
Spoiled GRASS (SPGR) Fast spoiled GRASS (FSPGR)
Gradient acquisition Steady state free IR-prepared in the steady state precession fast (GRASS) (GRASS) (SSFP)
Multiplanar spoiled GRASS (MSPGR) Fast multiplanar spoiled GRASS (FMSPGR)
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-39 J Hennig, who designated the improved spin-echo sequence as RARE. (Courtesy of J Hennig.)
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001025
11 of 11
At about the same time, FLASH (fast low angle shot) appeared, creating a new class of pulse sequences, i.e., gradient-echo sequences. This sequence was developed at the Max Planck Institute by Haase, Frahm (Fig. 1-41) and their co-workers.41 The gradient-echo sequences collect only one gradient echo per RF excitation. 42,43 Moreover, as opposed to spin-echo sequences, gradient-echo sequences do not use a 180° refocusing pulse; the echo signal is, however, formed by applying gradient pulses of opposite polarity in the readout direction (Fig. 1-42).
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-40 Multi-echo spin-echo pulse sequence timing diagram, two echoes illustrated. The repetition time (TR) and the echo time (TE) are the two variables of interest.
There are a number of both positive and negative effects caused by the absence of the 180° pulse. For instance, it reduces the RF power deposited in the patient and therefore lessens tissue heating. The absence of the 180° refocusing pulse, in contrast, makes the relative contributions from fat and water in gradient-echo sequences dependent on TE. Table 1-4 summarizes several common gradient-echo sequences, including the terminology currently used.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001031
1 of 5
CONCLUSION page 19 page 20
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-41 A Haase (A, Courtesy of Bayerische Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg, Fakultät für Physik und Astronomie, Würzburg, Germany) and J Frahm (B, Courtesy of Biomedizinische NMR Forschungs GmbH, Max-Planck-Institut für biophysikalische Chemie, Göttingen, Germany, 44
Copyright 2003) devised and developed gradient-echo sequences, FLASH.
11-04-2010 23:33
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001031
Add to lightbox
Figure 1-42 Gradient-echo pulse sequence timing diagram. This class of sequences is characterized by the absence of a 180° refocusing pulse. Echo is formed, however, by applying gradient pulses of opposite polarity in the readout direction.
In this chapter we have tried to put together the fundamental research, evolution and latest developments of various aspects of MR. It is impossible to cover all aspects in detail, so there are many aspects that we have not even mentioned. The timeline of the most important milestones in MR as a growing science is given in Box 1-1, a list of Nobel Prizes related to MR in Box 1-2, and of Nobel Prizes in other fields for individuals also active in MR in Box 1-3. The first commercial MR scanners appeared about 20 years or so after the work of Bloch and Purcell. A research group at Aberdeen started to build a MR prototype in 1972 whereafter several other manufacturers followed.
Box 1-1 Historical overview: the development of MR. As a comparison, the invention of CT is included 1800s
Fourier transform - Fourier
1920s
Basics of MR established by various scientists
1946
MR phenomenon - Bloch and Purcell
1952
Nobel Prize - Bloch and Purcell
1973
CT - Hounsfield
1973
First MR images on samples - Lauterbur
1975
Ernst's introduction of FT methods to MR
1977
First clinical MR images - Mansfield
2003
Nobel Prize - Lauterbur and Mansfield
Furthermore, the FT revolution has certainly opened up the bridge between a k-space and the image reconstruction, thus making MR a far more dynamic and innovative technique. For this reason, we have also presented a basic understanding of the FT without any mathematical formulas. The development of MR pulse sequence design continues at a fast pace and the clinical demand for MR imaging continues to grow throughout the world. Scan times were very long in the early 1980s
2 of 5
11-04-2010 23:33
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001031
when a T2-weighted scan using a spin-echo took at least 15 minutes. Today, single-shot scan times can be as fast as 50 ms for a single image using EPI. In conclusion, MR continues to thrive on innovation and to broaden its scope, apparently without limit. The foundation laid down by the contributions of the scientists mentioned above, however, still remains.
Acknowledgments We are grateful to several people for supplying images and making this chapter more readable, including N van Kampen from Utrecht University, H Diebels from Philips Medical Systems, P Kreisler from Siemens Medical Systems and M Greuter from Groningen University Hospital. page 20 page 21
Box 1-2 Nobel Prizes Directly Related to MR. (From ref. 44 with permission) Name
Year Category Description
Norman F Ramsey
1989 Physics
"For the invention of the separated oscillatory fields method and its use in the hydrogen maser and other atomic clocks"
Hans G Dehmelt 1989 Physics
"For the development of the ion trap technique"
K Alexander Müller
1987 Physics
"For their important breakthrough in the discovery of superconductivity in ceramic materials"
Nicolaas Bloembergen
1981 Physics
"For their contribution to the development of laser spectroscopy"
John H Van Vleck
1977 Physics
"For their fundamental theoretical investigations of the electronic structure of magnetic and disordered systems"
Alfred Kastler
1966 Physics
"Optical methods for studying Hertzian resonances"
Box 1-3 Nobel Prizes in Other Fields, Awarded to Individuals Who Also Contributed to the Development of MR. (From ref. 44 with permission) Name
Year Category Description
Paul C Lauterbur
2003 Medicine "For their discoveries concerning magnetic resonance imaging" Glasgow 2001
Sir Peter Mansfield
2003 Medicine
Kurt Wüthrich
2002 Chemistry "For his development of nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy for determining the three-dimensional structure of biological macro-molecules in solution"
Richard R Ernst
1991 Chemistry "For his contributions to the development of the methodology of high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy"
Felix Bloch
1952 Physics
"For their development of new methods for nuclear magnetic precision measurements and discoveries in connection therewith"
Edward Mills 1952 Physics Purcell
3 of 5
11-04-2010 23:33
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001031
4 of 5
Isidor Isaac 1944 Physics Rabi
"For his resonance method for recording the magnetic properties of atomic nuclei"
REFERENCES 1. Clayton E: The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available at http://www.utm.edu/research/iep/c/cicero.htm 2. Ramsey NF: Early history of magnetic resonance. Phys Perspect 1:123-135, 1999. 3. Partain CL, James AE, Rollo FD, Price RR (eds): Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Imaging. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1983. 4. Grant DM, Harris RK (eds): Encyclopedia of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance: Historical Perspectives, Vol. 1. Chichester, UK: Wiley, 1996. 5. Vaughan B: A short illustrated history of magnetic resonance. Australas Radiol 33(4):390-398, 1989. 6. Herivel J: Joseph Fourier. The Man and the Physicist. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1975. 7. Gorter CJ, Broer LJF: Negative result of an attempt to observe nuclear magnetic resonance in solids. Physica 9:591-596, 1942. 8. Rabi II, Zacharias JR, Millman S, Kusch P: A new method of measuring nuclear magnetic moments. Phys Rev 53:318, 1938. 9. Gorter CJ: Bad luck in attempts to make scientific discoveries. Phys Today 20:76, 1967. 10. Gorter CJ: Paramagnetic Resonance. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1947. 11. The MacTutor History of Mathematics archive. Available at http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/~history/ 12. Nobel Prize website. Available at http://www.nobel.se/ 13. Zavoisky EK: Discovery of electron spin resonance. J Phys USSR 9:211, 245, 1945. 14. Bloch F: Nuclear induction. Phys Rev 70:460-473, 1946. 15. Purcell EM, Torrey HC, Pound RV: Resonance absorption by nuclear magnetic moments in a solid. Phys Rev 69:37-38, 1946. 16. Mallard JR: NMR Imaging at Aberdeen: A Historical Perspective. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1983, pp. 15-25. 17. Mallard JR, Hutchison JMS, Edelstein WA, et al: In-vivo NMR imaging in medicine: the Aberdeen approach, both physical and biological. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B 289:519, 1980. 18. Damadian R: Tumour detection by nuclear magnetic resonance. Science 171:1151, 1971. Medline
Similar articles
19. Damadian R: Apparatus and method for detecting cancer in tissue. US Patent 3,789,832, 1972. 20. Damadian R: Nuclear magnetic resonance: a noninvasive approach to cancer. Hosp Pract 12:63-70, 1977. Medline Similar articles 21. Luiten AL, Locher PR, van Uijen C, et al: NMR Clinical Results: Eindhoven. Philadelphia: Saunders, 1983, pp. 250-260. 22. Kreisler P: 20 Years of Development and a Constantly Improving Performance. Magnetom. Magnetom Flash, Siemens Medical 1:124-127, 2003. 23. Bottomley PA, Hart HR, Edelstein WA, et al: NMR imaging/spectroscopy system to study both anatomy and metabolism. Lancet 2(8344):273-274, 1983. 24. Papoulis A: Signal Analysis. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1977. 25. Bracewell RN: The Fourier Transform and Its Application. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1986. 26. Cooley JW, Lewis PAW, Welch PD: Historical notes on the fast Fourier Transform. IEEE Trans Audio Electroacoustics 15:76-79, 1967. 27. Hounsfield GN: Computerized transverse axial scanning (tomography). Part I, Description of system. Br J Radiol 46:1016-1022, 1973. Medline Similar articles 28. Lauterbur PC: Image formation by induced local interactions: examples employing nuclear magnetic resonance. Nature 242:190-191, 1973. 29. Nishimura DG: Principles of Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Course notes, Stanford University, 1995. 30. Liang Z-P, Lauterbur PC: Principle of Magnetic Resonance Imaging: A signal processing perspective. New York: IEEE Press Series, 2000. 31. Likes RS: Moving gradient zeugmatography. US patent 4,307,343, August 1979. 32. Tweig DB: The k-trajectory formulation of the NMR imaging process with applications in analysis and synthesis of imaging methods. Med Phys 10:610-621, 1983. Medline Similar articles 33. Redpath T: MRI developments in perspective. Br J Radiol 70:S70-S79, 1997. 34. Kumar A, Welti D, Ernst RR: NMR Fourier zeugmatography. J Magn Reson 18:69-83, 1975. 35. Mansfield P, Maudsley AA: Medical imaging by NMR. Br J Radiol 50:188-194, 1977. Medline
Similar articles
11-04-2010 23:33
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC001031
5 of 5
36. Mansfield P: Multi-planar image formation using NMR. J Phys C Solid State Phys 10:L55-L58, 1977. page 21 page 22
37. Hoult DI, Chen D-N, Sank VJ: The field dependence of NMR imaging II. Arguments concerning optimal field strength. Magn Reson Med 3:730-746, 1986. Medline Similar articles 38. Mansfield P, Picket IL: Biological and medical imaging by NMR. J Magn Reson 29:355-373, 1978. 39. Hennig J, Nauerth A, Friedburg H: RARE imaging: a fast imaging method for clinical MR. Magn Reson Med 3:823-833, 1986. Medline Similar articles 40. van Vaals JJ, Groen JP, van Yperen GH: Recent progress in fast MR imaging. Medica Mundi 2:152-167, 1991. 41. Haase J, Friedburg H, Stroebel B: Rapid non-tomographic approach to MR myelography without contrast agents. J CAT 10:375-378, 1986. 42. Elster AD: Gradient-echo MR imaging: techniques and acronyms. Radiology 186:1-8, 1993. Medline Similar articles 43. Haacke EM, Frahm J: A guide to understanding key aspects of fast gradient-echo imaging. J Magn Reson Imag 1:621-624, 1991. 44. Boesch C. Nobel Prizes for nuclear magnetic resonance: 2003 and historical perspectives. J MRI 19:517-519, 2004.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:33
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00203068
1 of 1
ASIC
RINCIPLES
John P. Mugler III Our goal in this chapter is to provide a basic understanding of how magnetic resonance (MR) images are generated and to lay the foundation for the discussion of advanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques in subsequent chapters. The chapter is divided into four main sections that address the following questions: How is the nuclear magnetic resonance signal generated? What are the important characteristics of the signal behavior? How can we determine the origin of signals from within the body to form an image? How can the signal be manipulated to create different types of image contrast? In-depth discussions of the salient physical principles are presented through detailed descriptions of the concepts and liberal use of diagrams, avoiding extensive mathematical formulations. In some sections, additional technical or mathematical detail is provided for the interested reader. To facilitate recognition of this advanced material, the text passages are clearly labeled and set in smaller type; these passages can be skipped without loss of continuity. In certain discussions, particularly early in the chapter, reference is made to classical versus quantum physics. The classical viewpoint (that is, not involving the fundamental quantization of various physical quantities), although not correct for rigorously describing the behavior of subatomic particles such as protons and neutrons, is nonetheless useful to provide an intuitive grasp of many concepts. However, the quantum viewpoint will be necessary in some instances.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:35
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
ORIGIN OF THE NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE SIGNAL
Nuclear "Magnets" The starting point for our discussion is the nucleus of an atom. The nucleus is composed of some number of protons and neutrons, each of which intrinsically possesses angular momentum. Recall that angular momentum, commonly symbolized by a vector directed along the axis of rotation, is a quantity that represents the intensity of rotational motion. In classical physics angular momentum is equal to the product of the angular velocity of a rotating body, for example a toy spin top, and its moment of inertia with respect to the axis of rotation. The intrinsic angular momentum of a proton or neutron is called spin. page 23 page 24
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-1 A, Conceptual representation of a proton "spin" and its magnetic moment vector. B, In the absence of an applied magnetic field, nuclear spins move in response to thermal energy exchanges and are randomly oriented. Thus, the sum of their magnetic moments, also known as the net magnetization M, is zero.
Protons and neutrons also possess a magnetic dipole moment that is proportional to their intrinsic spin. From a classical-physics perspective, a proton or neutron can be regarded as a particle that contains charge and possesses angular momentum, therefore giving rise to a magnetic moment. (A neutron has no net charge, but is composed of charged particles. Although the topic of our discussion is nuclear magnetic properties, note that electrons also possess intrinsic spin and thus a magnetic moment.) Qualitatively, the magnetic properties of a proton or neutron can be thought of as arising from a tiny bar magnet. Because spin gives rise to the magnetic properties of nuclei, which, as we will see later in the chapter, in turn yield the nuclear magnetic resonance signal, nuclei with magnetic moments are often loosely referred to as simply "spins" in the MRI literature. Figure 2-1A shows a conceptual representation of a proton inspired by the classical viewpoint; the arrow through the sphere denotes its intrinsic magnetic moment and the curved arrow indicating rotation about the axis of the moment denotes its intrinsic spin. An important physical quantity in MRI is the ratio of the magnetic moment to the spin, which is called the gyromagnetic ratio, conventionally denoted by the symbol γ. In a nucleus, the magnetic moments of proton-proton or neutron-neutron pairs tend to align in opposition such that the net magnetic moment of the pair is zero. Hence, nuclei with an even number of 12 16 protons and neutrons such as C or O possess no net magnetic moment. On the other hand, when a nucleus has an odd number of protons or an odd number of neutrons, there is an unpaired proton or neutron and the nucleus has a net magnetic dipole moment. Note that the net magnetic moment may come from a proton, as for 1H, or from a neutron, as for 3He. Table 2-1 lists the nuclei that are 1 primarily of interest for medical imaging along with their characteristic gyromagnetic ratios. Table 2-1. Gyromagnetic Ratio and Spin for Nuclei of Interest in Medical
1 of 11
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
2 of 11
Imaging Isotope
Gyromagnetic Ratio (Mhz/T)
Spin
1
42.58
1/2
3
H
32.44
1/2
13
10.71
1/2
17
5.77
5/2
19
40.08
1/2
23
11.27
3/2
31
17.25
1/2
11.86
1/2
He C O F Na P
129
Xe
So far we have discussed that the nuclei of certain atoms, such as those of hydrogen atoms in a water molecule, possess a magnetic moment and angular momentum, or from the classical-physics viewpoint might each be regarded as a tiny ball of electric charge that is spinning about its axis, which gives rise to magnetic properties. Because of the high concentration of hydrogen nuclei in the body in water and fat molecules, and their relatively high gyromagnetic ratio, these nuclei are the source of signal for nearly all clinical MRI exams. Therefore, the remainder of our discussion focuses on the behavior of hydrogen nuclei, although most of our comments apply equally to the other nuclei listed in Table 2-1. Since hydrogen nuclei are protons, descriptions of MRI often use the term "proton" interchangeably with the term "hydrogen nuclei." Next, we explore how proton spins react when placed in an externally applied magnetic field, beginning with the classical-physics perspective.
Behavior of Nuclear Spins in a Magnetic Field In the absence of an externally applied magnetic field, the proton (hydrogen nuclei) spins in a substance, such as the tissues of your body, move in response to thermal energy exchanges and are oriented in random directions (Fig. 2-1B). The vector sum of the magnetic moments in a volume of interest, for example the sum of the magnetic moments shown diagrammatically in Figure 2-1B, is called the net macroscopic magnetization, conventionally denoted by the symbol M. This quantity, which is among the most important in the theory of MRI, is often referred to as the net magnetization, or simply the magnetization. For the randomly oriented spins in Figure 2-1B, M equals zero. Now let us consider what happens if a static (that is, constant in time) external magnetic field, denoted by the symbol B0, is applied to one of our proton spins. The external magnetic field exerts a torque on the magnetic moment, but instead of aligning it with the applied magnetic field, this torque causes the spin (magnetic moment) to move at a right angle to the plane that, at any instant, contains the magnetic-field and angular-momentum vectors, as shown in Figure 2-2. (Note in Fig. 2-2 that we introduced a standard Cartesian [rectangular] x-y-z coordinate system. By convention, the applied magnetic field B0 is directed along the positive z-axis. B0 is the symbol typically used to denote the static magnetic field produced by the main magnet of an MRI scanner.) This motion of the spin about the axis of an externally applied magnetic field is called precession, and its frequency ω0 is given by the well-known Larmor equation: The frequency of precession, also known as the Larmor frequency, is directly proportional to the gyromagnetic ratio for the nucleus (Table 2-1) and the applied field strength. page 24 page 25
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-2 Precession of a nuclear magnetic moment μ about an externally applied magnetic field B0. The angular frequency of precession is ω 0. The dashed oval shows the path that is traced out by the tip of the magnetic-moment vector as it precesses about the z-axis.
Precession occurs due to the combination of the magnetic forces and the angular momentum of the proton. This behavior may not be intuitively obvious, but it is identical to that which occurs for a toy spin top or toy gyroscope under the influence of gravity. Anyone who has played with one of these will remember that such a spinning toy neither remains standing straight up, nor does it fall over; it instead wobbles around, or in other words precesses, as it spins. In this case, gravity is analogous to the applied magnetic field and the top possesses angular momentum because it is spinning. For the interested reader: The vector form of Equation 2-1, ω0 = -γB0, shows that the angular velocity vector is antiparallel to the applied magnetic-field vector, which explains the sense of the rotation as shown in Figure 2-2. The equation is written in terms of the magnetic-field induction B instead of the magnetic-field strength H because we are interested in the magnetic fields that exist (or, in other words, are induced) within substances such as biological tissue. In the MRI literature, the magnetic-field induction is often loosely referred to as the magnetic-field strength, although this is not strictly correct. Nonetheless, we will follow this widespread nomenclature. With regard to the classical-physics perspective portrayed in Figure 2-2, it is inappropriate from the quantum viewpoint to describe the behavior of a single nuclear spin in the manner shown. However, the time-dependent behavior of the expectation value for the magnetic moment of a single spin, or of the expectation value for the average moment resulting from an ensemble of noninteracting spins, can be described by the classical law of motion for a nuclear magnetic dipole in an external magnetic field.2 Thus, in the interest of understanding the main concepts involved, it is reasonable to use the classical-physics viewpoint.
3 of 11
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
4 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-3 Measurable energy states of hydrogen nuclei (protons) in an externally applied magnetic field B0. The high- and low-energy states are commonly referred to as "spin down" and "spin up," respectively. [hstrok] denotes Planck's constant divided by 2π.
The next step is to explore the behavior for a collection, or population, of nuclear spins. For this task we must draw upon quantum physics, which tells us that a nuclear spin in a uniform static magnetic field B0 has a discrete number of measurable energy states, equal to twice the nuclear-spin value plus one. The spin of a nucleus with an odd number of protons or neutrons depends on the detailed structure of the nucleus. Most nuclei of medical interest have a spin of ½ (see Table 2-1), and thus the number of measurable energy states in a uniform magnetic field is two. Figure 2-3 illustrates this concept. As shown in the figure, the difference in energy between the two states is directly proportional to the gyromagnetic ratio for the nucleus and the applied field strength; this is the same dependence on these two quantities that we saw above for the frequency of precession. Drawing on the concepts from classical physics, several terms are commonly used to refer to a spin measured in one of the two possible energy states. The high-energy state is called "spin down" and the spin is said to be aligned away from or "antiparallel" to the external field. Analogously, the low-energy state is called "spin up" and the spin is said to be aligned toward or "parallel" to the external field. Connecting the energy-state and precession concepts, there are two energy states because the angular momentum is quantized, that is, it can only have one of two values. This is what the spin number tells us-it indicates the number of allowable angular momentum values. This is in contrast to a toy top, which for practical purposes has a continuously variable angular momentum. At typical applied field strengths, for example 1.5 tesla, and body temperature, the energy separation ∆E between spin states is relatively small compared to the level of thermal energy in the system. If we were to compare a collection of spins at two points in time, we would find that a number of the spins that were initially in the high-energy state had made transitions to the low-energy state by exchanging energy with their surroundings, and vice versa. Nonetheless, at any instant in time, the mean number of spins in each energy state remains constant, with slightly more spins in the low-energy state. Under these conditions, the spin system is said to be in thermal equilibrium. page 25 page 26
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-4 When your body is placed in the magnetic field B0 created by the main magnet of an MRI scanner, a net thermal-equilibrium magnetization M0 is induced within the tissues. A, B0 is parallel to the long axis of the body as occurs in a standard cylinder-shaped high-field MRI magnet. B, B0 is perpendicular to the long axis of the body as occurs in a C-shaped low-field MRI magnet. In either case, the magnetization is aligned with the applied field and is directly proportional to its magnitude. For example, the smaller B0 in B compared to A results in a smaller thermal-equilibrium magnetization. (The actual magnitude of M0 compared to B0 is much smaller than depicted in this diagram.)
For a large population of spins, the net excess in the low-energy state can be calculated by using the Boltzmann distribution. We find that this net excess is only a few spins out of each million for the field strengths typically used in MRI. Recalling that the net magnetization is the vector sum of the individual magnetic moments, the excess of spins in the parallel state results in a net magnetization, M0, aligned with the external field B0 (Fig. 2-4). M0 is called the thermal-equilibrium magnetization; it is directly proportional to B0 and inversely proportional to temperature. As discussed later in the chapter, the signal that is measured in MRI is directly proportional to M0. The fact that M0 increases in direct proportion to B0 is one of the primary motivations for developing MRI systems with increasingly higher field strengths. For the interested reader: At thermal equilibrium, the ratio of the mean number of spins in the spin-up state (Nup) to that in the spin-down state (Ndown) is given by the Boltzmann distribution as: where [hstrok] is Planck's constant divided by 2π, k is Boltzmann's constant, and T is the absolute temperature. Using this result along with the quantum mechanical expectation values for the magnetic moment of a proton spin in the spin-up or spin-down state in a static magnetic field,2 we can derive the magnitude of the thermal-equilibrium magnetization as: for γ[hstrok]B0 « kT, where N is the total number of spins. Note that M0 increases with the square of the gyromagnetic ratio. Another quantity of interest is the fractional excess of spins, (Nup - Ndown)/N, which is called the nuclear polarization. Now we know that a net magnetization aligned with the applied magnetic field is created in a subject's body when it is placed in the magnet of an MRI scanner (see Fig. 2-4). With this and the concept of precession in hand, our next step is to understand how we can manipulate the net magnetization to move it away from alignment with the applied magnetic field. This is a necessary step in producing a signal from the body that can be measured. Before proceeding, however, let us discuss briefly why the phenomenon is called magnetic "resonance."
Magnetic Resonance In an electrical or mechanical system (for example, the suspension system in a car), recall that resonance is defined as a vibration of large amplitude caused by a relatively small periodic stimulus, wherein this stimulus has approximately the same period as one of the so-called natural vibration periods of the system. In other words, if the stimulus to an electrical or mechanical system is at the "resonant" frequency (for instance, if you push down on the fender of a car at just the right frequency), the transfer of energy between the stimulus (your hand) and the system (suspension of the car) is enhanced. In analogy, nuclear magnetic resonance is the enhanced exchange of energy by the nuclei of atoms within an externally applied magnetic field that occurs for a specific frequency of applied radiant energy. From our discussion in the previous section, we know that the energy difference corresponding to a
5 of 11
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
6 of 11
transition between the low- and high-energy states (Fig. 2-3) is ∆E = γ[hstrok]B0. The frequency of a photon (a quantum or packet of radiant energy) that possesses this energy is ∆E/[hstrok] = γB0. So, photons with this frequency are absorbed by the spin system and stimulate transitions between the two energy states; this is magnetic resonance. Note that γB0 is the Larmor frequency as defined in Equation 2-1. Thus, the frequency of precession for a nuclear magnetic dipole moment in an applied magnetic field, as viewed from the classical-physics perspective, is the same as the frequency of radiation necessary to induce transitions of a nuclear magnetic moment between energy states in the same applied field. In MRI, the required frequency corresponds to that for radiofrequency (RF) electromagnetic radiation. The resonant frequencies for nuclei of medical interest can be calculated from the gyromagnetic ratios listed in Table 2-1 by simply multiplying the values provided by the field strength in tesla. For example, the resonant frequency for hydrogen nuclei (protons) at 1.5 tesla is 64 MHz. (In terms of precession, a resonant frequency of 64 MHz means that a magnetic moment would rotate about the direction of the applied field 64 million times in one second.) Although the frequencies of interest correspond to those for radio, the physics of MRI, at least for the field strengths in common use today, does not involve the wave properties of electromagnetic radiation. In other words, MRI does not use "radio waves," even though it has often been stated in the literature that transmission and absorption of radio waves is the basis for MRI. Up to this point, concepts from classical and quantum physics have been intermingled to form a compact and easy to follow explanation of the principles at hand. Nonetheless, we caution the reader that extrapolating this hybrid framework can lead to incorrect conclusions about more advanced aspects of the behavior of spin systems. Fortunately, a classical-physics perspective is sufficient for many of the remaining topics in this chapter. page 26 page 27
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-5 A, The stationary (x, y, z) and rotating (xrot, yrot, zrot) frames of reference. The z and zrot axes are coincident and the rotating frame of reference revolves about the z-axis with a constant angular velocity ω 0. B, The time-varying magnetic field B1 that is produced when an RF pulse is applied to a coil. B1 appears stationary when viewed from the rotating frame of reference. In this example, the RF pulse is applied in a manner that causes the B1 field to lie along the xrot-axis.
Response of the Magnetization to a Radiofrequency Pulse To help us understand the important principles of this section, we need to introduce a conceptual tool called the rotating frame of reference. Figure 2-5A shows a standard Cartesian (rectangular) x-y-z coordinate system, which we will call the stationary frame of reference, along with the rotating frame of reference, which has axes labeled xrot, yrot, and zrot. The z and zrot axes are coincident; relative to the stationary frame of reference, the rotating frame of reference revolves about the z-axis with a constant angular velocity, typically equal to the Larmor frequency, ω0. Instead of xrot, yrot, and zrot, the axes of the rotating frame are sometimes labeled x', y', and z'. The stationary frame of reference is sometimes called the laboratory frame of reference. A real-world situation analogous to our conceptual stationary and rotating frames of reference is a merry-go-round or carousel. When standing on the ground, next to the merry-go-round, you are in the
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
7 of 11
stationary frame of reference, whereas riders on the merry-go-round are in the rotating frame of reference. From the perspective of one of the riders who is standing on the merry-go-round, another standing rider is stationary, whereas from the perspective of a person standing on the ground, both of these riders are rotating about the axis of the merry-go-round. From this point forward, much of our discussion will pertain to events that are viewed in the rotating frame of reference. The use of the rotating frame of reference in the explanation of MRI phenomena is so pervasive that in much of the literature it is not explicitly stated that the rotating frame is being used. The next concept we need to discuss is that of a radiofrequency, or RF, pulse. Consider a subject that is placed within the magnet of an MRI scanner and surrounded by an RF coil. This RF coil may be as simple as a loop of wire or as complicated as the sophisticated commercial designs with which you are probably familiar from using an MRI scanner. If an alternating voltage is applied across the RF coil, causing an alternating electric current to flow through the coil, a magnetic field will be produced within the coil (namely, within the subject's body) that oscillates at the frequency of the applied voltage. Specifically, if the voltage is applied at the Larmor frequency (which, as discussed above, is in the range of frequencies associated with radio), it results in a magnetic field that, when viewed from our rotating frame of reference, appears to be stationary (Fig. 2-5B). This magnetic field is typically represented by a vector called B1. A radiofrequency voltage applied across the RF coil for a short period of time, typically on the order of a millisecond, is called an RF pulse. As we will see later, it is possible to vary the amplitude of the voltage over the duration of the RF pulse, thereby causing the amplitude of the B1 vector to vary in a desired way during the RF pulse. Also, by manipulating the characteristics of the applied voltage, it is possible to make the B1 field have any desired orientation within the xrot-yrot plane (for example, the B1 field could be applied along the yrot-axis, instead of along the xrot-axis as shown in Fig. 2-5B), or even change orientation during the RF pulse. For the interested reader: A simple RF coil design produces what is called a linearly polarized (LP) RF field, which is composed of two counter-rotating circularly polarized (CP) components. One of these magnetic field components is the B1 field depicted in Figure 2-5B. More sophisticated coil designs generate only one circularly polarized component. This is desirable because the counter-rotating component deposits energy in the tissue, but is not of use for manipulating the magnetization vector. The amount of energy deposited is of particular concern for imaging at very high fields. So how does an RF pulse affect the net magnetization that is generated in a subject's body when it is placed in the magnet of an MRI scanner? Recall from our discussion above that a magnetic moment precesses about an externally applied magnetic field. Just as a magnetic moment will precess about the static field B0 that is produced by the main magnet of the MRI scanner (see Fig. 2-2), it will also precess about the time-varying field B1 that is produced by applying an RF pulse. In the rotating frame of reference, we do not "see" the precession about B0 because the frame of reference is rotating about the axis of the applied static magnetic field at an angular frequency ω0, synchronous with the precession. Thus, in the absence of B1, the net magnetization appears to be stationary in the rotating frame. Once the RF pulse is turned on, the magnetization M begins to precess about B1. (Once the magnetization is perturbed from alignment with the static magnetic field B0, it is called M instead of M0.) The larger the magnitude of B1, the faster M precesses. By analogy to the Larmor equation (Eq. 2-1), the precessional frequency of M in the rotating frame is γB1. By varying the duration or strength of the RF pulse (that is, by varying the time of application or the magnitude of B1), we can cause the magnetization to precess a selected amount about the axis along which B1 is applied. page 27 page 28
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
8 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-6 The effect of an RF pulse on the magnetization. A, Viewed from the stationary frame of reference, the magnetization M precesses about both the static magnetic field B0 and the time-varying magnetic field B1. (B0 is directed along the z-axis; it is omitted to simplify the diagram.) The dotted line shows the path that is traced out by the tip of the magnetization vector as it nutates toward the x-y plane. B, Viewed from the rotating frame of reference, the magnetization M precesses only about B1. The dashed line shows the path that is traced out by the tip of the magnetization vector as it rotates toward the yrot-axis. The angle between the z-axis and the magnetization, measured at the end of the RF pulse, is called the flip angle, α.
Figure 2-6 illustrates the effects of an RF pulse on the magnetization in both the stationary and rotating frames of reference. In the stationary frame, M precesses about B0 and B1 simultaneously (Fig. 2-6A). The resulting spiraling movement of M toward the x-y plane is called nutation. (For clarity, the frequency of precession of M about B0 [γB0] is shown to be only a few times faster than that of M about B1 [γB1]. In reality, γB0 is typically about a thousand times faster than γB1.) In the rotating frame, only the precession about B1 is seen (Fig. 2-6B). The angle between the z-axis and M at the end of the RF pulse is called the flip angle for the pulse. The symbol α is commonly used to denote the flip angle. Before proceeding further, it is useful to introduce some nomenclature associated with the effects of RF pulses. Figure 2-7 shows a B1 field applied in the xrot-yrot plane (B1 is oriented about 30° toward the negative yrot-axis) that causes the magnetization to precess through the flip angle α. The resulting magnetization M can be represented by the two components Mz and Mxy. Mz is the projection of M onto the z-axis, which is often called the longitudinal axis. Thus, Mz is called the longitudinal component of the magnetization, or simply the longitudinal magnetization. Similarly, Mxy is the projection of M onto the xrot-yrot plane, which is commonly called the transverse plane. Thus, Mxy is called the transverse component of the magnetization or the transverse magnetization. Mxy can be further decomposed into projections along the xrot and yrot axes, called Mx and My, respectively (Fig. 2-7).
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
9 of 11
Figure 2-7 The magnetization M can be represented by a component parallel to the z-axis, called the longitudinal magnetization, Mz, and a component that lies in the xrot-yrot plane, called the transverse magnetization, Mxy. The transverse magnetization can be decomposed as shown into the components Mx and My.
Add to lightbox page 28 page 29
Figure 2-8 Common types of RF pulses used in MRI. A, A 90° excitation RF pulse converts longitudinal magnetization into transverse magnetization. B, A 180° inversion RF pulse rotates the longitudinal magnetization from the positive z-axis to the negative z-axis. C, A 180° refocusing RF pulse flips transverse magnetization to the other side of the xrot-yrot plane. D, For this 90° excitation RF pulse, the B1 field is applied along the yrot-axis, instead of along the xrot-axis as in A. That is, the phase of this RF pulse is different than that for the pulse shown in A. The magnetization precesses to the negative xrot-axis, instead of to the positive yrot-axis.
The most common RF pulses used in MRI are 90° and 180° pulses. A 90° RF pulse is typically used to move the magnetization from alignment with the longitudinal axis into the transverse plane (Fig. 2-8A). As will be discussed shortly, transverse magnetization is required to generate a magnetic resonance signal. An RF pulse whose purpose is to convert longitudinal magnetization into transverse magnetization is called an excitation RF pulse. In techniques designed for fast imaging, the flip angle of an excitation RF pulse may be less than 90°. A 180° pulse is called an inversion RF pulse when it is used to move the magnetization from the positive z-axis to the negative z-axis or, in other words, to invert the longitudinal magnetization (Fig. 2-8B). In contrast to inversion, Figure 2-8C illustrates the use of a 180° pulse to "flip" transverse magnetization about the axis along which the RF pulse is applied. This form of 180° pulse is called a refocusing RF pulse. We will discuss the purpose of refocusing RF pulses later in the chapter. The reason for using the terms "excitation" and "inversion" to describe RF pulses can be appreciated by referring back to Figure 2-3 and, for the moment, considering the quantum-physics perspective. Following an excitation RF pulse, the longitudinal component of the magnetization is smaller than its thermal-equilibrium value. Since the net magnetization is the sum of the individual magnetic moments, the number of spins in the high-energy state must increase in order to achieve this reduction in the
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
10 of 11
longitudinal component of the magnetization. The high-energy state is also called an "excited" state, hence the origin of the term excitation. By the same reasoning, to invert the longitudinal magnetization, an inversion RF pulse must reverse, or in other words cause an inversion of, the spin population. Specifically, the number of spins that were in the low-energy state before the inversion pulse equals the number that are in the high-energy state after the pulse, and vice versa. As mentioned above, the B1 field may have any desired orientation within the xrot-yrot plane. The orientation of the B1 field is called the phase of the RF pulse; the phase is often measured relative to the xrot-axis. For example, the 90° RF pulse shown in Figure 2-8A has a phase of 0° whereas the one shown in Figure 2-8D has a phase of 90°. Another common name for the RF pulse shown in Figure 2-8A is a pulse, denoting that it is applied along the xrot-axis. Similarly, the pulse in Figure 2-8D is pulse. called a We have seen how RF pulses permit us to manipulate the longitudinal magnetization that is generated in a subject's body when it is placed in the magnet of an MRI scanner, and to thereby create transverse magnetization. The final topic to be discussed in this section is how the magnetization can be used to produce a measurable signal from the body.
Generation of the Magnetic Resonance Signal
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-9 A, Precessing transverse magnetization Mxy induces a radiofrequency voltage across a nearby coil of wire. B, Conceptually, the precessing transverse magnetization produces the same effect as a tiny spinning bar magnet.
In the frame of reference of the RF coil, that is, in the stationary frame, the transverse magnetization created by an excitation RF pulse precesses about the axis of the applied static magnetic field at the Larmor frequency. This precessing transverse magnetization creates a time-varying magnetic field. As discovered by Michael Faraday in 1831, such a time-varying magnetic field induces a voltage across a nearby coil of wire (Fig. 2-9A). This is Faraday's law of electromagnetic induction, which states that if
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002001
11 of 11
a conducting wire loop or coil is in a magnetic field and the magnetic field changes relative to the coil, then a voltage is induced across the coil. This voltage induces an electric current to flow through the coil, if it is part of a closed circuit. This is the exact same principle that is used in an electric generator to produce electricity. Conceptually, the precessing magnetization can be thought of as a tiny spinning bar magnet (Fig. 2-9B). Note that transverse magnetization is required to generate the magnetic resonance signal because it is the precession of this magnetization that results in the requisite time-varying magnetic field. The coil, as shown in Figure 2-9, may be the same one that was used to generate the RF pulse, or it may be a separate coil that is optimized for the region of anatomy being imaged. The signal that is measured just after an excitation RF pulse, and as a result of the precessing transverse magnetization, is called a free induction decay, abbreviated FID. The term "free" refers to the fact that after the B1 field is turned off at the end of the RF pulse, the magnetization precesses freely in the applied static magnetic field. The term "induction" is used because the precessing magnetization induces a voltage across the coil. The term "decay" is used because, as we will discuss in the next section, the magnitude of the transverse magnetization, and thus the signal strength, gradually decreases. The measured FID oscillates at the Larmor frequency, so the FID appears as a sinusoidal waveform that slowly decays as illustrated in Figure 2-10A. Before processing the magnetic resonance signal, for example to calculate an MR image, the oscillatory component of the signal at the Larmor (resonant) frequency is removed by a procedure called demodulation. The resulting demodulated FID exhibits the signal decay with time (Fig. 2-10B). page 29 page 30
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-10 Original (A) and demodulated (B) free induction decay (FID) signals generated by the precessing transverse magnetization (see Fig. 2-9). For clarity, the period of signal oscillation in A is shown to be only a few times shorter than the decay time; in practice the period of oscillation is at least one thousand times shorter.
We can now appreciate the fundamental symmetry involved in generating the magnetic resonance signal. Summarizing what we have discussed, thermal-equilibrium magnetization is created from the spins of hydrogen nuclei by placing a subject in the magnet of an MRI scanner, and a radiofrequency voltage is applied across a coil surrounding the subject, thus resulting in a time-varying magnetic field within the subject. This time-varying magnetic field perturbs the thermal-equilibrium magnetization, thereby creating transverse magnetization, which precesses in the scanner's magnetic field and itself generates a time-varying magnetic field. This second time-varying magnetic field then induces a radiofrequency voltage across the coil surrounding the subject, and in doing so produces the magnetic resonance signal that can be measured. Additional information on the concepts discussed in this section can be found in references 2 to 5.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:37
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
1 of 14
BASIC CHARACTERISTICS OF THE MAGNETIC RESONANCE SIGNAL
Longitudinal and Transverse Relaxation Now that we know how an excitation RF pulse can create transverse magnetization, and how this magnetization can generate a magnetic resonance signal, our next task is to discuss what happens to the magnetization following the RF pulse. For example, after a 90° excitation RF pulse, the resulting transverse magnetization precesses about the z-axis at the Larmor frequency. Can this go on indefinitely? The answer of course is no, because to maintain the excited state would require a continual input of energy to the spin system. If only the static magnetic field B0 is applied after the RF pulse, the original thermal equilibrium value of the magnetization (that is, aligned parallel to the z-axis) must be eventually reestablished. Between the 90° RF pulse and reestablishment of thermal equilibrium two things must occur: 1. the longitudinal component of the magnetization Mz must grow back to its original value, and 2. the transverse component Mxy must die out, or decay, to zero. The processes by which these events occur are termed longitudinal and transverse relaxation. First let us consider longitudinal relaxation as illustrated in Figure 2-11A. Immediately following a 90° RF pulse, Mz is zero and the number of spins in the high-energy state equals that in the low-energy state (Fig. 2-11A, time = 0). As time passes, and the numbers of spins in the two energy states begin to approach the values that correspond to thermal equilibrium, the longitudinal magnetization grows back toward M0. This regrowth involves a loss of energy from the spin system. As discussed earlier in the chapter, the number of spins in the high-energy state increases when the magnetization is disturbed from thermal equilibrium. As longitudinal relaxation occurs, the number of spins in the high-energy state decreases and energy is transferred from the spin system to its environment, which is referred to as the "lattice." Because it involves energy transfer between the spin system and the lattice, longitudinal relaxation is also called spin-lattice relaxation. Longitudinal relaxation is characterized by an exponential regrowth of Mz with a time constant that is traditionally called the T1 (or equivalently, T1) relaxation time. Hence, another common name for longitudinal relaxation is T1 relaxation. The T1 time is an intrinsic property of any given tissue; different types of tissue typically have different T1 values. For example, at 1.5 tesla, brain white matter has a T1 of roughly 600 ms and brain gray matter has a T1 of roughly 1000 ms. The T1 value that a given tissue possesses depends on the details of the tissue's molecular structure. (The factors involved in determining the T1 of a particular tissue are beyond the scope of our discussion.) In addition, the T1 values for most tissues increase as the 6,7 field strength is increased (see Chapter 18, High-Field Imaging). By plotting the length of the longitudinal magnetization vector (as shown in Fig. 2-11A) versus time, we can appreciate the exponential time course of T1 relaxation as depicted in Figure 2-12A. When the time elapsed -1 after the RF pulse equals T1, the ratio of Mz to its thermal equilibrium value is (1 - e ), which equals 0.63 or -n
63%. Generalizing this statement, at n times T1 after the 90° RF pulse, the ratio equals (1 - e ). For example, as illustrated in Figure 2-12A, at 2 T1 and 3 T1 after the 90° RF pulse, the longitudinal magnetization has regrown to 86% and 95% of its thermal-equilibrium value, respectively. page 30 page 31
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
2 of 14
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-11 Schematic of the time course of the longitudinal and transverse components of the magnetization as they relax toward their thermal equilibrium values following a 90° excitation RF pulse. A, Behavior of the longitudinal magnetization (black vector aligned parallel to the z-axis). Longitudinal relaxation involves the transfer of energy from the spin system to its surroundings. B, Behavior of the transverse magnetization (black vector aligned parallel to the yrot-axis). Transverse relaxation involves the loss of phase coherence among the spins.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
3 of 14
Add to lightbox page 31 page 32
Figure 2-12 Plots of the time course of the longitudinal (A) and transverse (B) components of the magnetization as they relax toward their thermal-equilibrium values following a 90° excitation RF pulse.
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-13 Time course of the longitudinal magnetization as it relaxes toward its thermal equilibrium value following a 180° inversion RF pulse. At the "null" point for the tissue (arrows), the longitudinal magnetization passes through zero.
When the flip angle of the RF pulse is greater than 90°, for example 180° as for an inversion RF pulse, the initial longitudinal magnetization is aligned parallel to the negative z-axis (Fig. 2-8B). For this case, the longitudinal magnetization exhibits an exponential regrowth toward its thermal-equilibrium value in the same general manner as discussed above. However, in contrast to the behavior described for a 90° pulse, the magnitude (length) of the longitudinal-magnetization vector passes through zero during the relaxation process (Fig. 2-13). The regrowth of the longitudinal magnetization following an inversion RF pulse is called inversion recovery. Since the rate of regrowth depends on the T1 for the specific tissue, the longitudinal magnetization corresponding to different tissues passes through zero at different times as shown in Figure 2-13. As will be discussed in later chapters, there are several important MR imaging techniques that take advantage of this behavior to acquire an image at the time (sometimes called the tissue's "null" point) when the relaxing longitudinal magnetization for a given tissue passes through zero. In such an image, the signal from the tissue is suppressed. Specific examples include the "STIR" technique,8,9 for which the signal from fat is 10 suppressed, and the "FLAIR" technique, for which the signal from cerebrospinal fluid is suppressed. For the interested reader: In the more general case of T1 relaxation following an RF pulse having a flip angle other than 90°, the longitudinal magnetization that remains just after the pulse is not zero, as indicated above for the case of a 180° RF pulse. The corresponding regrowth of the longitudinal magnetization can be thought of as the sum of an exponential regrowth from an Mz value of zero, just as if a 90° pulse had been applied, and an exponential decay of the initial value of the longitudinal magnetization following the RF pulse. This is written:
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
4 of 14
where t is time and Mz0 is the initial value of the longitudinal magnetization following the RF pulse. The first term on the right-hand side is the exponential regrowth and the second term is the exponential decay. For the case of T1 relaxation following an inversion RF pulse, Mz0 equals -M0 and the equation for relaxation becomes: From Equation 2-5, the time for which Mz passes through zero is T1 times the natural logarithm of 2 (ln 2 ≈ 0.69).
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-14 A, Magnetization vectors precessing with random phases. B, Magnetization vectors precessing in synchrony. This second group of vectors exhibits phase coherence. (The dashed circles show the paths that are traced out by the tips of the magnetization vectors as they precess.)
Next let us turn to transverse relaxation, as illustrated in Figure 2-11B. Immediately following a 90° RF pulse, the magnitude of the transverse magnetization is equal to that of the longitudinal magnetization just before the pulse (Fig. 2-11B, time = 0). This transverse magnetization, which, as we already know, precesses at the Larmor frequency, exists because there is phase coherence among the magnetic moments associated with the protons (hydrogen nuclei). The idea of phase coherence is central to understanding several concepts in the remainder of the chapter, so we will pause for a moment to discuss it further. In our context, phase coherence refers to the relationship among precessing transverse-magnetization vectors. Recall that the phase of a vector is its orientation in space relative to a reference axis. The term "coherence" means that the phases of the magnetization vectors under consideration have a definite, as opposed to random, relationship with each other. In its simplest form, this relationship is that the phases of all magnetization vectors are identical, and that the vectors are precessing in synchrony. As an example, consider the precessing magnetization vectors illustrated in Figure 2-14. In Figure 2-14A, there is no definite relationship among the phases of the vectors or, in other words, their phases are random. In contrast, in Figure 2-14B, the vectors are shown precessing in synchrony. This group of magnetization vectors exhibits phase coherence. Vectors precessing in synchrony are said to be "in phase." If some process disrupts the phase relationship among precessing vectors that were originally in phase, the vectors are said to have been dephased. Returning to our description of transverse relaxation (see Fig. 2-11B), we see that the transverse magnetization decays toward its thermal equilibrium value of zero as time passes following the 90° RF pulse. This decay process involves an irreversible loss of phase coherence (that is, an increase in randomness of the phases) among the magnetic moments. In other words, the spin system has undergone irreversible dephasing. (Later in the chapter we will see that under certain conditions dephasing can also be reversible.) Magnetic interactions between the spins are a mechanism for this irreversible loss of phase coherence, and thus transverse relaxation is also called spin-spin relaxation. page 32 page 33
Transverse relaxation is characterized by an exponential decay of Mxy with a time constant that is traditionally called the T2 (or equivalently, T2) relaxation time. Hence, another common name for transverse relaxation is T2 relaxation. Analogous to the situation for the T1 time, the T2 time is an intrinsic property of any given tissue and different types of tissue typically have different T2 values. For example, at 1.5 tesla,
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
5 of 14
brain gray matter has a T2 of roughly 100 ms and cerebrospinal fluid has a T2 of roughly 2000 ms. Also analogous to T1, the T2 value that a given tissue possesses depends on the details of the tissue's molecular structure. The T2 times for most tissues remain approximately constant as the field strength is increased up 6,7 to roughly 1.5 tesla. With further increases in field strength, the T2 values for many tissues decrease. For example, the T2 values for brain matter at 7 tesla are markedly less than those at 2 tesla.11 For the interested reader: Representing T2 relaxation by using an exponential decay with a single time constant is, in fact, an approximation. For many biological tissues the T2 relaxation 6 curve is multi-exponential. Specifically, the curve is represented by the sum of two or more exponential decays with different time constants. The exponential decay approximation is not valid for solids. By plotting the length of the transverse magnetization vector (as shown in Fig. 2-11B) versus time, we can appreciate the exponential time course of T2 relaxation as depicted in Figure 2-12B. When the time elapsed after the RF pulse equals T2, the ratio of Mxy to its initial value is e-1, which equals 0.37 or 37%. Generalizing this statement, at n times T2 after the 90° RF pulse, the ratio equals e-n. For example, as illustrated in Figure 2-12B, at 2 T2 and 3 T2 after the 90° RF pulse, the transverse magnetization has decayed to 14% and 5% of its initial value, respectively. Considering the longitudinal and transverse relaxation processes together as they act to return the spin system to thermal equilibrium, note that transverse relaxation is ultimately limited by longitudinal relaxation. Specifically, when the longitudinal magnetization is fully relaxed, there can be no transverse magnetization. Therefore the T2 value is always less than or equal to the T1 value. In biological tissues, except fluids, the T2 is typically five to ten times shorter than the T1. In summary, putting T1 relaxation in its simplest terms, we can state: if you "knock down" the longitudinal magnetization by using an RF pulse, it will grow back within a time period that is characteristic of the particular tissue. Similarly, for T2 relaxation, we can state: once you create transverse magnetization by using an RF pulse, it decays toward zero within a time period that is characteristic of the particular tissue. Later in the chapter, we will discuss how a difference in either the T1 or T2 values among tissues can be exploited to create contrast in the image. Disease processes often alter both T1 and T2, thus providing a 7,12,13 mechanism for the detection of disease. A discussion of fundamental mechanisms underlying relaxation can be found in reference 14.
Dephasing and T2*
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
6 of 14
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-15 A, The square represents a cross-section through a voxel of tissue that possesses a transverse magnetization vector Mxy. B, The voxel can be divided into an arbitrary number of subvolumes, each of which possesses a proportionate fraction of the total transverse magnetization. For this example, four subvolumes are shown. C, The representation of transverse magnetization vector Mxy in the rotating frame of reference. D, The sum of the transverse magnetization vectors from the four subvolumes equals the total transverse magnetization. In D, we could have drawn all of the vectors superimposed at the origin of the coordinate system.
We just discussed how T2 relaxation results in the decay of transverse magnetization through irreversible dephasing among the magnetic moments associated with the spins. Now we will discuss another process that results in the decay of transverse magnetization, but in this case the dephasing is reversible, meaning that, under appropriate circumstances, the effects of the dephasing can be undone. Consider a volume of tissue, for example a cubic centimeter of brain tissue, in which transverse magnetization has been created by applying a 90° RF pulse. In practice, our volume of tissue might correspond to an individual volume element, or voxel, of an MR image. The total transverse magnetization vector Mxy corresponding to any chosen volume of tissue can be thought of as the sum of several smaller transverse magnetization vectors, each of which corresponds to a subdivision of the volume. For example, in Figure 2-15, we show that the magnetization vector for our voxel of brain tissue can be conceptually divided into four smaller transverse magnetization vectors for which the sum equals the original vector. page 33 page 34
So, why would we want to divide a volume of interest into several subvolumes? Recall from Equation 2-1 that the frequency of precession for transverse magnetization is directly proportional to the applied magnetic-field strength. Up to this point we have implicitly assumed that the static magnetic field B0 is perfectly uniform in space. Consider, for example, a subject's head in an MR scanner-we have assumed that the magnetic field within the cerebellum is exactly equal to that within the temporal lobes. This, however, is generally not the case; for various reasons that are discussed later in the chapter, the magnetic-field strength within tissue typically varies among locations. Thus, the frequency of precession for transverse magnetization within tissue also varies among locations. In the context of Figure 2-15, we could just as easily have divided the voxel into 40 or 400 subvolumes. Into how many parts should a selected volume of tissue be divided? Conceptually, the volume should be divided into increasingly smaller parts until all of the spins within each subvolume experience the same magnetic-field strength, and hence all precess at the same frequency.
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
7 of 14
Now, imagine that the magnetic field within our voxel of brain tissue varies so that at some positions it is greater than that ideally produced by the main magnet of the MRI scanner, while at other positions it is less. The magnetic field within this voxel is said to be inhomogeneous, and the tissue within the voxel therefore experiences magnetic-field inhomogeneities. The spins within each subvolume precess at a frequency that corresponds to the local magnetic-field strength. Thus, the transverse magnetization corresponding to some subvolumes precesses faster than ω0 (see Eq. 2-1), while that corresponding to other subvolumes precesses slower than ω0.
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-16 Dephasing of the transverse magnetization due to magnetic-field inhomogeneities. Just after a 90° RF pulse, the Mxy vectors that correspond to the various subvolumes that make up the voxel are in phase. As time progresses, transverse magnetization that experiences a higher than average magnetic-field strength precesses faster than ω0 (light gray vectors), while transverse magnetization that experiences a lower than average field strength precesses slower than ω0 (dark gray vectors). The total transverse magnetization (lower portion of diagram), which is the sum of the transverse magnetization vectors corresponding to the subvolumes, gradually decays as dephasing progresses. (For simplicity, the effects of T1 and T2 relaxation are not included. The scale for the magnetization vectors corresponding to the subvolumes is different than that for the other vectors in the diagram. In the first time frame after the RF pulse, the magnetization vectors corresponding to the subvolumes are superimposed such that only one vector is visible.)
The behavior of the transverse magnetization that results from precession in an inhomogeneous magnetic field is illustrated in Figure 2-16. Just after the RF pulse creates transverse magnetization, the Mxy vectors that correspond to the voxel subvolumes are aligned or, in other words, are in phase. As time passes, the spins within different subvolumes precess at different frequencies and the associated Mxy vectors get out of phase with each other or, in other words, dephase. As shown in the lower part of Figure 2-16, the total transverse magnetization for the voxel, which is the sum of the Mxy vectors corresponding to the subvolumes, gradually decreases as dephasing progresses. When the Mxy vectors are fully dephased, that is, when they point in directions that span 360° as shown on the far right of Figure 2-16, the total transverse magnetization for the voxel has decayed to zero. Since the MR signal from our voxel is directly proportional to the total transverse magnetization, it likewise decays following the RF pulse due to the effect of field inhomogeneities. page 34 page 35
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
8 of 14
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-17 In the presence of field inhomogeneities, the FID (shown in gray) generated by an excitation RF pulse decays with the time constant T2*, which is shorter than T2. Dotted and solid lines depict the exponential decays associated with the T2* and T2 relaxation times, respectively.
For simplicity, the effect of T2 relaxation was not included in Figure 2-16. Considering both T2 relaxation and the effect of field inhomogeneities, we find that the FID generated by an RF pulse decays at a rate faster than that which results from T2 relaxation alone (Fig. 2-17). This decay is characterized by a time constant that is traditionally called the T2* (or equivalently, T2*) relaxation time, which incorporates both the tissue T2 value and the contribution from field inhomogeneities as: Because the inhomogeneity term cannot be negative, Equation 2-6 requires that T2* be less than or equal to T2. Unlike the T1 and T2 relaxation times, the T2* time is not necessarily an intrinsic property of a given tissue; T2* may depend on factors other than the tissue structure itself.15,16 Often, the size of the inhomogeneity contribution, and thus the value of T2*, depend on the magnitude and distribution of field inhomogeneities as well as on the size and shape of the voxel. Common sources of field inhomogeneities will be discussed later in the chapter. As long as the field inhomogeneities are static (that is, as long as they do not change over time), the dephasing, and thus the associated portion of the MR signal decay, is reversible. This reversibility of the dephasing brings us to our next topic-the formation of what is called an echo.
Spin-Echoes Let us continue where we left off on the far right of Figure 2-16, with a collection of dephased transverse magnetization vectors that belong to a collection of subvolumes within a voxel. Now imagine that a refocusing RF pulse, as introduced in Figure 2-8C, is applied to this set of transverse magnetization vectors such that the B1 field is directed along the yrot-axis. This RF pulse "flips" the vectors such that those precessing slower than ω0 (dark gray) swap positions with those precessing faster than ω0 (light gray) as illustrated in Figure 2-18. The vectors continue to precess in the same way that they did before application of the RF pulse. Namely, the slower vectors continue to precess counterclockwise and the faster vectors continue to precess clockwise. However, instead of driving the vectors further out of phase with each other, precession now brings the vectors back toward their starting positions. In other words, the vectors rephase. When the time period following the refocusing RF pulse matches that between the excitation and refocusing RF pulses, all of the transverse magnetization vectors have returned to the positions that they had just after the excitation RF pulse and thus a spin-echo is formed. Figure 2-19 illustrates how the total signal from the voxel evolves in relation to the application of the excitation (90°) and refocusing (180°) RF pulses, now including the effect of T2 relaxation. As already described in Figures 2-16 and 2-17, application of the excitation RF pulse results in an FID that decays toward zero with a time constant T2*. As seen in Figure 2-18, application of the refocusing RF pulse swaps the positions of transverse magnetization vectors that precess slower than ω0 with those that precess faster, and this leads to a regrowth of the signal and formation of the spin-echo at a time that is traditionally labeled TE, standing for "time to echo" or "echo time." As time progresses beyond TE, the transverse magnetization vectors again begin to dephase and the signal decays toward zero with a time constant T2*. The
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
9 of 14
fundamental symmetry of the spin-echo process requires that the refocusing RF pulse be applied at time TE/2, halfway between the excitation RF pulse and the echo. As shown in Figure 2-19, the signal strength at the echo is decreased relative to that just after the excitation RF pulse due to T2 decay (that is, irreversible dephasing). Note that at any time following TE, another refocusing RF pulse can be applied to cause a second echo to form. Extending the concepts illustrated in Figure 2-19, we find that this second echo would occur at a time equal to the first echo time plus twice the time between the first echo and the second refocusing RF pulse. (In other words, the second refocusing RF pulse must be halfway between the first and second echoes.) Likewise, additional refocusing RF pulses can be applied to form additional echoes; this principle is discussed further in Chapter 5, Pulse Sequence Design. In summary, two RF pulses are required to form a spinecho. The first RF pulse, the excitation pulse, "excites" the spin system and creates transverse magnetization that dephases due to field inhomogeneities as time progresses. The second RF pulse, the refocusing pulse, "flips" the precessing transverse magnetization vectors so that they can rephase or, in other words, refocus to form the echo. A spin-echo is often called an RF echo, since RF pulses are required to form the echo, or a Hahn echo, after Erwin Hahn 17 who discovered this phenomenon in 1949. For the interested reader: In general, any pair of two RF pulses, not just a 90°, 180° pair of pulses, creates a spin-echo. Excitation pulses less than 90° create a smaller transverse magnetization vector than that produced by a 90° pulse, and refocusing pulses other than 180° rephase only a fraction of the transverse magnetization. The dependence of the signal S on the excitation flip angle α and the refocusing flip angle β is: where the sin(α) term gives the relative amount of transverse magnetization that is created by 2 the excitation RF pulse and the sin (β/2) term gives the fraction of this transverse magnetization that is refocused. Note that the right-hand side of Equation 2-7 is equal to one when α is 90° and β is 180°.
Mechanisms of Dephasing page 35 page 36
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
10 of 14
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-18 Formation of a spin-echo. Just after a 90° RF pulse, the Mxy vectors that correspond to the various subvolumes that make up the voxel are in phase. As time progresses, transverse magnetization that experiences a higher than average magnetic-field strength precesses faster than ω0 (light gray vectors), while transverse magnetization that experiences a lower than average field strength precesses slower than ω0 (dark gray vectors). A 180° refocusing RF pulse flips the vectors such that those precessing slower swap positions with those precessing faster. As time progresses further, the transverse magnetization vectors rephase and form an echo when the time period following the 180° RF pulse matches that between the 90° and 180° RF pulses. The total transverse magnetization (lower portion of diagram), which is the sum of the transverse magnetization vectors corresponding to the subvolumes, gradually decays as dephasing progresses and then grows back to its original length as the echo is formed. (For simplicity, the effects of T1 and T2 relaxation are not included. The scale for the magnetization vectors corresponding to the subvolumes is different than that for the other vectors in the diagram. In the first time frame after the RF pulse, the magnetization vectors corresponding to the subvolumes are superimposed such that only one vector is visible.)
Our last topic for this section of the chapter is a brief discussion of the typical sources of dephasing in MRI. Anything that causes the magnetic field experienced by the spins to vary from one position to another (or, in other words, causes the magnetic field to be inhomogeneous) is a mechanism for dephasing. The primary mechanisms of dephasing include: 1. inhomogeneities in the field produced by the magnet of the MRI scanner-these are commonly called main-field inhomogeneities; 2. differences in magnetic susceptibility among various tissues or materials in the body; 3. chemical shift; and 4. magnetic-field gradients that are applied for spatial encoding. The last item, magnetic-field gradients applied for spatial encoding, is discussed in detail in the next section. Ideally, the field produced by the magnet of an MRI scanner would be perfectly homogeneous over the
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
11 of 14
imaging volume, meaning that it would have exactly the same value at all positions within the magnet. In practice, this cannot be achieved. The magnetic-field homogeneity is typically specified for a conceptual spherical volume that is centered in the magnet. Quantities related to magnet-field (or frequency) variations in MRI are often stated in terms of parts per million, abbreviated ppm; one ppm is one ten-thousandth of a percent or, literally, one in a million. For example, over a 50-cm diameter spherical volume, a state-of-the-art whole-body 1.5-tesla magnet has a homogeneity of a few parts per million. page 36 page 37
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-19 Signal evolution during the formation of a spin-echo. Just after a 90° RF pulse, precessing transverse magnetization creates an MR signal that decays with a time constant T2* due to dephasing in the presence of field inhomogeneities. The 180° RF pulse applied at time TE/2 swaps the positions of transverse magnetization vectors that precess slower than ω0 with those that precess faster, leading to a regrowth of the signal and formation of a spin-echo at time TE. Due to T2 relaxation, the signal strength at the echo is decreased relative to that just after the 90° RF pulse.
In general, main-field inhomogeneities result in signal loss (T2* decay) or geometric distortion within the image. Geometric distortion, which causes signal from one physical location to appear in a different physical location, can result in relative increases or decreases in signal intensity. The extent of signal-loss and distortion effects depends on the type of imaging technique and its parameter values, although for a modern MRI magnet the effects of main-field inhomogeneities are often negligible; as discussed next, the principal cause of field inhomogeneity in clinical MRI is the interaction of the magnetic field with the human body when it is placed in the scanner. 18
Magnetic-susceptibility differences are the most important source of field inhomogeneity in clinical MRI. The magnetic susceptibility of a substance, such as your brain tissue, is a measure of the degree to which it is magnetized when placed in an external magnetic field, such as that produced by the magnet of an MRI scanner. In other words, when you place a substance within a magnetic field, the substance interacts with the magnetic field and so the total magnetic field within the substance is different than the applied field. The relationship between the magnetic field induced within a substance and the externally applied field strength is given by a material property called the volume magnetic susceptibility. Three ranges of susceptibility values are of interest: diamagnetic, paramagnetic, and ferromagnetic. Diamagnetic materials, which include water and most biological tissues, have a small (on the order of a few ppm), negative magnetic susceptibility. A negative susceptibility means that the magnetic field induced within the material is slightly less than the externally applied magnetic-field strength, as illustrated in Figure 2-20. Paramagnetic materials, which include
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
12 of 14
O2 and gadolinium-based contrast agents, have a small, positive magnetic susceptibility, and thus the induced magnetic field is slightly higher than the applied field. Finally, ferromagnetic materials like iron have a large, positive magnetic susceptibility. Note that the presence of ferromagnetic material of either biological (for example, chronic hemorrhage) or nonbiological (for example, dental work, prostheses, surgical clips, or clothing) origin produces pronounced local distortions in the magnetic field. page 37 page 38
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-20 The magnetic field that is induced within a material when placed in an external magnetic field, such as that produced by the magnet of an MRI scanner (B0), depends on the magnetic susceptibility of the material. Brain tissue has a diamagnetic (negative) susceptibility, and thus the magnetic-field strength induced in brain tissue (Bbrain) is slightly less than B0, and also slightly less than that induced in air (Bair), which has a magnetic susceptibility close to zero. The magnetic-susceptibility difference at the interface between brain tissue and air in the sinus creates a localized magnetic-field gradient that can cause dephasing of the transverse magnetization (see Fig. 2-21). The difference between Bbrain and Bair is exaggerated in this figure for clarity.
When two materials with different magnetic susceptibilities are adjacent to one another (for example, air in the sinuses next to tissue [Fig. 2-20], or a metallic clip imbedded in tissue), the change in susceptibility at the interface between the materials results in a localized magnetic-field gradient that causes dephasing of the transverse magnetization. The term "magnetic-field gradient" means that the strength of the magnetic field varies with position along a specific direction. The term "localized" denotes that the magnetic-field gradient exists only in the region surrounding the susceptibility interface, and also differentiates magnetic-field gradients generated by a susceptibility interface from those that we apply to perform spatial encoding. As an example, Figure 2-20 illustrates that when your head is placed in the magnet of an MRI scanner, the magnetic-field strength induced in brain tissue (Bbrain) is slightly smaller than that induced in air in the frontal sinus (Bair). The difference between Bbrain and Bair results in a magnetic-field gradient at the interface of the brain tissue with the air in the sinus. If you were to measure the magnetic-field strength along a line segment that starts in the brain tissue and ends in the frontal sinus, you would find that the field strength increases from Bbrain to Bair in the vicinity of the air-tissue interface.
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
13 of 14
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-21 Axial spin-echo (A) and gradient-echo (B) images of the brain that illustrate the effect of magnetic-field inhomogeneities created by air-tissue susceptibility interfaces. Gradient-echo imaging is much more sensitive than spin-echo imaging to field inhomogeneities. As a result, localized magnetic-field gradients in the vicinity of air-tissue interfaces cause dephasing of the transverse magnetization, and thus signal loss, as indicated by the arrows. (From Mugler JP III: Overview of MR imaging pulse sequences. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am 7:661-697, 1999)
Analogous to main-field inhomogeneities, localized magnetic-field gradients that result from susceptibility differences can result in signal loss (T2* decay) or geometric distortion within the image. This effect is illustrated in Figure 2-21, which shows axial images of the brain that were acquired using spin-echo (abbreviated SE) and gradient-echo (abbreviated GRE or GE) techniques. The next section of this chapter will explain the basic mechanics of these fundamental MRI methods, and additional information on their characteristics can be found in Chapters 3 and 5. For the moment, we only need to know that GRE imaging is much more sensitive than SE imaging to field inhomogeneity, such as that caused by a susceptibility interface. (As its name implies, SE imaging is based on the spin-echo mechanism that was discussed above. Recall that a spin-echo permits the effects of dephasing from magnetic-field inhomogeneities to be reversed [see Fig. 2-18].) Comparing the GRE image (Fig. 2-21B) to the SE image (Fig. 2-21A), areas of signal loss (marked by arrows) are seen in the GRE image in the vicinity of air-tissue interfaces. As discussed above, the susceptibility differences at these interfaces result in localized magnetic-field gradients (that is, field inhomogeneities) that cause the transverse magnetization in these regions to dephase (see Fig. 2-16). Without a spin-echo to reverse this dephasing, signal from the affected regions is lost. In practice, field-inhomogeneity effects can be either an advantage or a disadvantage. Signal loss secondary 19 to the ferromagnetic nature of hemorrhage byproducts can aid in their detection. The high sensitivity of GRE imaging to susceptibility effects is fundamental to the implementation of several important techniques, including those for perfusion imaging20 and brain functional MRI.21 On the other hand, the substantial signal18,22 to-noise loss and geometric distortion that can occur in GRE images, especially at high-field strengths, can render them unusable. page 38 page 39
Our final topic for this section is the concept of chemical shift. When placed in an external magnetic field, the electrons in a molecule or compound partially "shield" the nuclei so that the field strength experienced by a given nucleus is slightly modified, or "shifted," compared to the field strength that is applied. Hence, the Larmor frequency for the nucleus is also shifted. This phenomenon is called chemical shift because the magnetic field that a nucleus experiences is dependent on its chemical environment. Like field inhomogeneity, chemical shift is expressed in ppm. Of particular relevance to clinical MRI, the chemical shift for hydrogen nuclei (protons) in fat is 3.5 ppm less than that for hydrogen nuclei in water. Thus, in the magnetic field of an MRI scanner, the frequency of precession for transverse magnetization associated with fat is slightly lower than that for transverse magnetization associated with water. This slight difference in resonant frequency, which leads to a time-dependent phase difference between the transverse magnetization associated with fat and that associated with water, gives rise to a chemical-shift artifact as discussed in Chapter 22, Image Artifacts and Solutions. The time-dependent phase shift causes periodic dephasing and rephasing of fat magnetization relative to water magnetization as time progresses following an excitation RF pulse. If fat and
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002007
14 of 14
water are present in the same voxel of a GRE image, this dephasing and rephasing leads to a periodic signal modulation (see Chapters 7 and 22).23
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:38
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
SPATIAL LOCALIZATION OF THE MR SIGNAL TO FORM AN IMAGE In this section we discuss spatial encoding-the process by which the spatial locations of MR signals from the body are determined in order to create an image. Building upon our knowledge of how the MR signal is generated and its basic characteristics, the key additional ingredient that is needed for 24 spatial encoding is an externally applied magnetic-field gradient.
Magnetic-Field Gradients The concept of a magnetic-field gradient was introduced in the previous section when we discussed magnetic-susceptibility interfaces. Recall that the term "magnetic-field gradient" refers to the situation wherein the magnetic-field strength varies with position along a specific direction. To perform spatial encoding, an MRI scanner uses three gradient coils, called the x-, y-, and z-gradient coils, to generate linear magnetic-field gradients along each of the axes of a standard Cartesian (rectangular) x-y-z coordinate system. Conceptually, these gradient coils are simply large coils of wire. Considering, as an example, a conventional cylinder-shaped MRI magnet, these coils of wire are wound onto a tube having a diameter slightly smaller than the internal diameter of the magnet, so that they can be positioned inside the bore of the magnet.
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-22 Spatial variations in the total magnetic-field strength for linear magnetic-field gradients applied along the x-axis (A), y-axis (B), or z-axis (C). The total magnetic-field strength includes B0 and the magnetic field generated by the respective gradient coil. The diagrams depict cross-sections through a conventional cylinder-shaped MRI magnet. The amount of field-strength variation is exaggerated for clarity.
For a conventional cylinder-shaped MRI magnet, Figure 2-22A illustrates the variation in total magnetic-field strength (specifically, the combination of B0, created by the magnet of the MRI scanner, and the magnetic field produced by the gradient coil) that results when electric current flows through the x-gradient coil. We see that the magnetic-field strength, represented by the length of the arrows in
1 of 24
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
2 of 24
the figure, varies along the x-axis but is constant along the y- and z-axes. Similarly, for a y-gradient the field strength varies along the y-axis but is constant along the x- and z-axes (Fig. 2-22B), and for a z-gradient the field strength varies along the z-axis but is constant along the x- and y-axes (Fig. 2-22C). Two or all three of the gradient coils can be turned on simultaneously to create a magnetic-field gradient along any direction; this capability is used to achieve arbitrary image orientations. Figure 2-22 uses the standard convention for labeling the x-, y- and z-axes of the magnet; when facing the front of the magnet, the positive x-axis points to the right, the positive y-axis points upward, and the positive z-axis (the axis parallel to B0) points toward you. The amount of field-strength variation that occurs with the application of a gradient is exaggerated in Figure 2-22 for clarity. In practice, the difference between the minimum and maximum field strengths would be no more than approximately 2% (20,000 ppm) of B0. page 39 page 40
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-23 A, Plot of the total magnetic-field strength versus distance during the application of a linear magnetic-field gradient. At the isocenter of the magnet, the applied gradient has no effect on the magnetic-field strength. B, The slope of the line that depicts the relationship between field strength and distance gives the strength of the magnetic-field gradient; a steeper slope corresponds to a stronger
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
3 of 24
gradient. The slope of the line, and hence the polarity of the magnetic-field gradient, can be positive or negative. C, A gradient timing diagram shows how the strength and polarity of a magnetic-field gradient change over time. The strengths for the portions of the gradient waveform labeled "strong," "weak," and "negative" correspond to the three lines shown in B. In A and B, the amount of fieldstrength variation compared to B0 is exaggerated for clarity.
Another way to represent the effect of a magnetic-field gradient is to plot the variation in field strength versus position as shown in Figure 2-23A. Gradient coils are designed to yield a linear variation in field strength with distance, as illustrated in the figure. At the center of the magnet, which is called its isocenter, the magnetic field from the gradient coil is zero and hence, even with the gradient activated, the total magnetic-field strength equals B0. By varying the amplitude and polarity of the electric current applied to the gradient coil, the gradient strength, which is the slope of the line that relates field strength to distance, can be controlled. In Figure 2-23B, the black line labeled "strong gradient" has the steepest slope, and hence represents the highest gradient strength of the three lines shown. The dark gray line represents a weaker gradient, and the light gray line illustrates that the gradient can also be negative. Gradient strengths are typically specified in units of milliTesla per meter (abbreviated mT/m) or gauss per centimeter (abbreviated G/cm); state-of-the-art clinical scanners have a maximum gradient strength of approximately 40 mT/m, which equals 4 G/cm. High gradient strengths are useful to achieve short acquisition times (that is, rapid imaging) and high spatial resolution. The characteristics of an applied magnetic-field gradient are commonly represented by a timing diagram, as shown in Figure 2-23C. This diagram depicts when the gradient is switched on and off, how quickly it is switched on and off, and the strength of the gradient. The times required to switch the gradient on and off are called its ramp up and ramp down times, respectively. Ideally, we would like to switch the gradient on and off instantaneously, but this is not physically possible because a finite period of time is required to increase the current flowing through the gradient coil to the desired level. The slope of the ramp up (or ramp down) portion of a gradient waveform is called its slew rate. Slew rates are typically specified in units of tesla per meter per second (abbreviated T/m/s) or milliTesla per meter per millisecond (abbreviated mT/m/ms); state-of-the-art clinical scanners have a maximum slew rate of approximately 200 T/m/s. To facilitate fast imaging techniques, it is desirable to have a high slew rate. In the timing diagram, the height of the plateau relative to zero denotes the gradient strength. Note that the strengths (and polarities) of the gradient waveforms labeled "strong," "weak," and "negative" in Figure 2-23C correspond to the three lines in Figure 2-23B that have the same labels.
Slice Selection To form an image the MR signals from the body must be localized in three dimensions. Much of clinical MRI is performed by using two-dimensional (abbreviated 2D) techniques wherein the first step is to localize the signals along one of the dimensions by exciting the magnetization only within a thin slice of tissue25,26-a process called slice selection. (In this context, the terms "slice" and "section" are interchangeable; which term is used is simply a matter of preference.) We can understand how slice selection works by considering the effect of a linear magnetic-field gradient together with the Larmor equation (Eq. 2-1). As shown in Figure 2-23A, activating a given magnetic-field gradient creates a linear correspondence between the magnetic-field strength and the position along the gradient. Since, as given by the Larmor equation, the frequency of precession is directly proportional to the field strength, the magnetic-field gradient likewise creates a linear correspondence between the resonant frequency and the position along the gradient. Therefore, as indicated in Figure 2-24, an RF pulse that is applied at a selected center frequency (ωC) affects only spins located at a specific position (zC), called the slice position, because only these spins possess a resonant frequency that matches the frequency of the RF pulse. By changing the center frequency of the RF pulse, the position of the slice along the direction of the gradient can be chosen freely. When you select specific slice positions for an MR exam, the scanner software calculates the required center frequencies. The gradient that is applied during the RF pulse is called the slice-select (or section-select) gradient, typically abbreviated GS or GSS, and may be the x-, y-, or z-gradient depending on the slice orientation that is desired, or may be some combination of these gradients if an oblique slice is desired. page 40
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
4 of 24
page 41
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-24 Slice selection. When applied in the presence of a linear magnetic-field gradient, an RF pulse with center frequency ω C excites spins located at position zC along the direction of the gradient. The RF-pulse bandwidth ∆ω and the strength of the gradient determine the slice thickness ∆Z.
An RF pulse consists of not just a single frequency, but instead a range of frequencies; this range is called the transmit bandwidth of the pulse and is denoted by the symbol ∆ω in Figure 2-24. Because the RF pulse contains a range of frequencies, a range of positions is excited along the direction of the gradient; this range is the slice thickness (∆Z in Fig. 2-24). The RF-pulse bandwidth can be used to control the slice thickness-increasing the transmit bandwidth increases the slice thickness. For a given shape of RF pulse, the transmit bandwidth is inversely proportional to the duration of the pulse. Therefore, making the RF pulse longer decreases the transmit bandwidth and results in a thinner slice. As is apparent from Figure 2-24, the gradient strength can also be used to control the slice thickness. Increasing the gradient strength localizes the range of frequencies excited by a given RF pulse to a smaller range of positions and thus results in a thinner slice.
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-25 Timing diagram for slice selection. A 90° excitation RF pulse is applied simultaneously with the slice-select gradient (GS). Following the RF pulse, a rephasing gradient is applied along the slice-select axis to restore phase coherence across the thickness of the slice.
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
5 of 24
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-26 Plot of the flip angle generated by a 90°, slice-selective, excitation RF pulse versus distance perpendicular to the slice for an ideal rectangular slice profile (A) and a realistic slice profile (B).
Extending the concept of the timing diagram that was introduced in Figure 2-23C, the process of slice selection can be depicted as an RF pulse applied simultaneously with a linear magnetic-field gradient as illustrated in Figure 2-25. This figure highlights the fact that the RF-pulse waveform possesses a particular shape. This shape depicts the time course of the amplitude of the magnetic-field B1 (see the first section of this chapter), and determines the slice profile for the RF pulse which, in general, refers to how well the pulse achieves its intended effect, measured as a function of distance across the thickness of the slice. To put this in concrete terms, consider a 90° excitation RF pulse that we want to use to select a 5-mm thick slice. Ideally, this RF pulse would produce a flip angle of exactly 90° within the desired 5-mm thick slice and exactly 0° everywhere outside of the slice. Thus, a plot of the flip angle for this pulse versus distance perpendicular to the slice would have the shape of a rectangle as shown in Figure 2-26A. An infinitely long RF pulse is required to obtain a perfect rectangular slice profile-obviously this is not practical. For a realistic slice profile (Fig. 2-26B), the flip angle varies from the intended value to zero over some finite distance. In addition, the flip angle decreases to zero beyond the slice thickness, meaning that the RF pulse has an effect on tissue outside of the desired slice. page 41 page 42
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-27 The profiles of closely spaced slices overlap, which can result in slice-to-slice interference, also known as slice crosstalk. This interference can cause decreased signal intensities, decreased contrast, and other image artifacts.
In clinical MRI the slice profile is of particular importance because we typically want to acquire a set of closely spaced slices. Therefore, the trade-offs between the RF-pulse duration, the RF power required for the pulse (which directly affects the energy deposited in the patient), and the quality of the slice profile are considered in the design of the RF-pulse waveform. Nonetheless, due to the inevitable excitation of some tissue outside of the desired slice, the profiles of closely spaced slices always overlap to some degree (Fig. 2-27), which results in slice-to-slice interference, often called slice crosstalk. Crosstalk can cause decreased signal intensities, decreased contrast, and other image artifacts27-29; this source of image degradation is one of the reasons that gaps between the slices are often used. (The other reason for using gaps between slices is to increase anatomic coverage for a given number of slices.) Nonetheless, ongoing improvements in RF pulse design continue to lessen the impact of slice crosstalk on image quality. Before concluding our description of slice selection, there is one last detail to be discussed. In Figure 2-25, there is a negative portion of the gradient waveform that is applied immediately following the RF pulse. This part of the gradient waveform is called a rephasing gradient. Consider, as an example, that the excitation RF pulse in Figure 2-25 is a pulse as discussed earlier in the chapter (Fig. 2-8A), which is intended to convert longitudinal magnetization into transverse magnetization that is aligned parallel to the y-axis of the rotating frame of reference. Because this RF pulse is applied in the presence of a magnetic-field gradient to achieve slice selection, the frequency of precession for magnetization located at any given position along the direction of the slice-select gradient will be different than that for magnetization located at any other position. During the application of the RF pulse, this effect results in dephasing of the transverse magnetization across the thickness of the slice, which is clearly undesirable because it reduces the signal from the slice. At the end of the RF pulse, only a small fraction of the magnetization remains in the desired configuration, aligned parallel to the y-axis. The rephasing gradient reverses this dephasing and thereby restores phase coherence across 30 the thickness of the slice, permitting the maximum signal to be obtained. Note that only excitation RF pulses require a rephasing gradient; this gradient is not required for a slice-selective refocusing RF pulse (that is, a refocusing RF pulse applied in the presence of a magnetic-field gradient). In closing, let us summarize the main features of slice selection: the slice-select gradient localizes the effect of the RF pulse; the slice position is determined by the center frequency of the RF pulse and the strength of the gradient; the slice thickness is determined by the bandwidth of the RF pulse and the strength of the gradient; and the slice profile is determined by the shape of the RF-pulse waveform.
The Fourier Transform and an Introduction to k-Space Slice selection provides the means to excite magnetization within a thin section of tissue; to form an
6 of 24
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
image the next task is to spatially encode the MR signals from this slice in the remaining two dimensions so that the locations from which the signals originate can be determined in all three dimensions. Before describing the details of this process, we need to discuss the Fourier transform and k-space-concepts that lay the foundation for us to understand how spatial encoding works. page 42 page 43
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-28 The Fourier transform (FT) allows us to determine the frequency components contained in a signal. A, When sunlight is refracted by a glass prism or by raindrops in the atmosphere to form a rainbow, the prism or raindrop in essence physically performs a Fourier transform, letting us see the various frequencies of electromagnetic radiation, and thus the various colors, of which white light is composed. B, An MR image is composed of a collection of spatial intensity variations. The image's spatial-frequency spectrum specifies the amplitudes, orientations, and spatial frequencies of these intensity variations. Because the signals that are acquired during an MRI exam are the k-space -1
components of the image, the image itself is obtained by applying an inverse Fourier transform (FT ).
The Fourier transform is a mathematical tool, typically implemented in the form of a computer program, that allows us to calculate the frequency components contained in a signal. Here, "signal" is used as a general term that includes many different types of information, including an MR image. Some examples may be helpful to gain an intuitive understanding of the Fourier transform. When you listen to music on the radio, the sound is reproduced by applying an electrical signal to the speaker. If you were to apply a Fourier transform to this electrical signal, the result would be the spectrum of the music, which indicates how much of each audio frequency is contained in the music. For example, if bass instruments were dominant in a song, its spectrum would contain a large low-frequency component. Note that the Fourier transform can be inverted, meaning that the inverse Fourier transform of the music's spectrum yields the original electrical signal. As a second example, consider sunlight being refracted by a glass prism, or by raindrops in the atmosphere, thus forming the familiar "rainbow" of colors. White light is composed of a range of frequencies of electromagnetic radiation; these frequencies correspond to the colors that we see in the rainbow. In essence, the prism or raindrop physically performs a Fourier transform, letting us see these various frequencies (colors) that make up white light (Fig. 2-28A). Finally, consider an MR image. In mathematical terms, an MR image is a set of intensity values, each of which is assigned to a specific x, y co-ordinate in space. The Fourier transform of an MR image is its spatial-frequency spectrum (Fig. 2-28B), which specifies the amount of each of the various spatial-frequency components that make up the image. The term "spatial frequency" is commonly abbreviated by using the letter k. The MR image is a representation of the anatomy of interest in (physical) space, whereas its spectrum is a representation of the same
7 of 24
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
8 of 24
information in spatial-frequency space, or k-space. So, what does understanding MRI have to do with k-space? The signals that are received from the body by an RF coil during the MR imaging process are in fact the k-space components of the image-the image itself is obtained by applying an inverse Fourier transform to these k-space data, as indicated in Figure 2-28 by the arrow pointing from the k-space spectrum to the image. Analogous to the rainbow example above, the process of receiving MR signals in combination with an appropriate configuration of magnetic-field gradients physically performs a Fourier transform on the transverse magnetization vectors within the slice of interest. An inverse Fourier transform, performed by the image-reconstruction computer that is part of the scanner, is thus required to obtain the image that we desire. Taking these concepts a step further, we can state that an MR image is composed of the sum of a large number (typically equal to the number of points in the image, for example, 256 × 256 = 65,536) of sinusoidal intensity oscillations with various spatial frequencies and orientations. Each point in the k-space spectrum tells us the amplitude, spatial frequency, and orientation for one of these intensity oscillations that make up the image. The amplitude of the intensity oscillation is given by the magnitude of the k-space component. For example, in the spatial-frequency spectrum shown in Figure 2-28B, different points in k-space have different levels of brightness, which reflect the different magnitudes of these components. The frequency of a given intensity oscillation in the image is proportional to the distance of the associated k-space component from the center of k-space. Thus, a component at the center of k-space corresponds to a uniform intensity throughout the image, a component close to the center corresponds to a low spatial-frequency oscillation, and a component far from the center corresponds to a high spatial-frequency oscillation. The orientation of the intensity oscillation in the image is determined by the position of the k-space component relative to the k-space axes. Some image examples will help to provide a feeling for these concepts. Figure 2-29 shows a number of individual k-space components (each marked by a white dot in k-space) and their associated sinusoidal intensity oscillations in the image. In Figure 2-29A, we see that a k-space component located on the kx-axis, very close to the center of k-space, results in a low-frequency intensity oscillation whose pattern of light-dark bands is oriented perpendicular to the x-axis in the image. A k-space component located on this same axis, but farther from the center, results in a higherfrequency oscillation with the same orientation in the image (Figs. 2-29B and C). Keeping the k-space component the same distance from the center of k-space, but locating it instead on the ky-axis, yields an intensity-oscillation pattern that is oriented perpendicular to the y-axis in the image as shown in Figure 2-29D. Finally, if the k-space component is located between the kx and ky axes, for example along a line oriented 30° counterclockwise from the kx-axis, the corresponding intensity-oscillation pattern in the image is oriented perpendicular to a line that is 30° counterclockwise from the x-axis. Generalizing the concepts illustrated in Figure 2-29, we can state the following relationships between the k-space data and the image, which are illustrated in Figure 2-30. The data in the central region of k-space, namely, the low spatial-frequency components, represent the gross structure and contrast in the image (Fig. 2-30B). On the other hand, the data in the outer regions of k-space, namely, the high spatial-frequency components, represent the detailed structure and contrast in the image. The position of the k-space data relative to the k-space axes corresponds to the orientation of the structures that the data represent in the image (compare Fig. 2-30C to Fig. 2-30D). For example, in Figure 2-30C, only high spatial-frequency k-space data in the vicinity of the horizontal (kx) axis are included. Thus, only features with rapidly changing intensity values (that is, "edges," particularly in the vicinity of the bright subcutaneous fat) oriented perpendicular to the horizontal (x) direction are visible in the associated image. page 43 page 44
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
9 of 24
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-29 Examples of individual k-space components (denoted by small white dots in k-space and highlighted by yellow arrows) and the corresponding sinusoidal intensity oscillations in the image. A, A spatial-frequency component located on the kx-axis and very close to the center of k-space yields a low-frequency intensity oscillation whose pattern of light-dark bands in the image is oriented perpendicular to the x-axis. B and C, When the spatial-frequency component is located at increasingly higher spatial frequencies, intensity oscillations with correspondingly higher frequencies result in the image. D, A spatial-frequency component located on the ky-axis yields an intensity-oscillation pattern that is oriented perpendicular to the y-axis. E, A spatial-frequency component located between the kx and ky axes, at a particular angle relative to the kx-axis, yields an intensity oscillation that has a matching angulation in the image.
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
10 of 24
The final issue associated with k-space that needs to be addressed before turning our attention to the details of spatial encoding concerns the amount of k-space data that must be collected to make an MR image. Specifically, how close does any given data point in k-space need to be to its neighbor (in other words, how densely must k-space be sampled) and how far out in k-space do we need to collect data? The distance in k-space between adjacent data points (∆k) is inversely proportional to the extent of the image (namely, its field-of-view, abbreviated FOV) in the corresponding direction as illustrated in Figure 2-31A. (As you probably already know from practical experience, if the FOV is too small then tissue from one side of the image wraps around to appear on the opposite side of the image-see Chapter 22.) As shown in Figure 2-31B, the inverse relationship also holds, specifically, the distance in the image between adjacent points (∆y in Fig. 2-31B), which gives the spatial resolution, is inversely proportional to the extent of k-space that is collected in the corresponding direction. Conceptually this makes sense-high spatial frequencies are required to represent fine details in the image and thus achieve high spatial resolution. In general, the k-space components on the positive side of k-space have a specific mathematical relationship to those on the negative side. Thus, components on one side of k-space can be used to calculate those on the other side, permitting an image to be reconstructed from a fraction of the "full" (that is, containing equal portions of positive and negative spatial frequencies) data set. 31,32 Common names for this type of acquisition include partial-Fourier, half-Fourier, fractional-NEX, half-NEX, fractional-echo, half-echo, and asymmetric-echo imaging, depending on the details of the acquisition and whether the intent is to shorten the imaging time or decrease the echo time. Although a fractional acquisition is advantageous for specific applications, many common techniques acquire full k-space data sets. For the interested reader: Because k-space data represent the spatial distribution of the transverse magnetization, which is a vector quantity, these data, and likewise the inverse Fourier transform of these data (the image), are complex. For simplicity, the magnitude of the k-space data was presented in Figures 2-28, 2-30, and 2-31. For most clinical applications, the magnitude of the MR image is used. Considering Figure 2-29, all of the real-valued intensity oscillations shown are even because real-valued k-space components were used. By using such intensity oscillations we can describe only objects that also possess this symmetry; obviously complex k-space components are required to describe realistic objects. (In Fig. 2-29, complexvalued k-space components would result in intensity oscillations that are displaced relative to the center of k-space.) Nonetheless, in the ideal case, the MR image is real valued, and so the corresponding spatial-frequency spectrum possesses Hermitian (complex conjugate) symmetry. Specifically, a k-space component at co-ordinate (kx, ky) is the complex conjugate of the component at (-kx, -ky). This symmetry is the basis for the fractional-acquisition methods discussed above. In reality, the image data typically possess some imaginary component, although in many cases this can be adequately described by only low spatial-frequency data. Thus, fractional-acquisition methods collect somewhat more than one half of the k-space data to permit accurate reconstruction of the actual (non-real-valued) image data.
Spatial Encoding page 44 page 45
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
11 of 24
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
12 of 24
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-30 The relationship between the data location in k-space and the resulting features in the MR image. The k-space data (upper row) and corresponding images (lower row) are shown for: A, a complete 256 × 256 data set; B, the central 64 × 64 values in this data set; C, two 96 × 32 data blocks centered on the horizontal (kx) axis; and D, two 32 × 96 data blocks centered on the vertical (ky) axis. The k-space data is displayed using a logarithmic intensity scale to provide an improved visualization of the high spatial-frequency components. (From Mugler JP III: Overview of MR imaging pulse sequences. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am 7:661-697, 1999)
As introduced during our discussion of k-space, the spatial-encoding process used in MRI involves collecting k-space data that correspond to the desired image. The key element of this process is the relationship between k-space and applying a linear magnetic-field gradient. Let us consider in detail how the transverse magnetization along the direction of a magnetic-field gradient is affected during the
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
13 of 24
application of this gradient. In particular, Figure 2-32 illustrates the behavior of transverse magnetization vectors located along a line that is parallel to the x-axis (Fig. 2-32B) during the application of a constant magnetic-field gradient (Gx) along this axis. Just after application of the excitation RF pulse, the transverse magnetization vectors are in phase (time point 1, Fig. 2-32D). Note that the labels 1, 2, 3, and 4 in Figures 2-32A, C, and D designate successive points in time and emphasize the relationship between the application of the gradient (Fig. 2-32A), the state of the transverse magnetization vectors (Figs. 2-32D and E), and the associated positions in k-space (Fig. 2-32C). Once the gradient is turned on (lower portion of Fig. 2-32B), transverse magnetization vectors located at positions greater than zero along the x-axis (positions F through I in Figs. 2-32B and D) precess faster than ω0 and, conversely, those located at positions less than zero (positions A through D) precess slower than ω0. As a result, magnetization vectors located at positions other than zero gradually accumulate phase relative to that located at zero (position E), magnetization vectors at negative positions accumulate phase in a counterclockwise sense, and those at positive positions accumulate phase in a clockwise sense (Fig. 2-32D).
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 45 page 46
Figure 2-31 Relationships between the density and extent of data in k-space, and the field-of-view and spatial resolution in the image. A, The distance in k-space between adjacent data points (∆ky) is inversely proportional to the field-of-view of the image in the corresponding direction (FOV y). B, The distance in the image between adjacent points (∆y), which gives the spatial resolution, is inversely proportional to the extent of k-space in the corresponding direction (2ky,max).
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
14 of 24
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-32 The spatial-encoding effect of a linear magnetic-field gradient on the transverse magnetization. A, An excitation RF pulse followed by a constant, linear magnetic-field gradient that is applied along the x-axis. The effect of this gradient is evaluated at the four time points labeled 1, 2, 3, and 4. B, A linear relationship between position (x) and frequency (ω) is created by the gradient applied in A. The resulting behavior of the transverse magnetization along a line parallel to the x-axis is considered at nine positions (A through I) that are equally spaced along the direction of the gradient. C, The positions in k-space that correspond to the four time points. D, The positions of the transverse magnetization at positions A through I as time progresses. Using position E as reference, magnetization at positions F through I precesses faster than ω 0 (clockwise) while that at positions A through D precesses slower than ω 0 (counterclockwise). The dashed circles show the paths traced out by the tips of the precessing magnetization vectors. E, Plots of the tips of all magnetization vectors between positions A and I versus distance along the x-axis for the four time points. The gradient twists the magnetization vectors into a helical pattern that becomes tighter and tighter as time progresses.
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
15 of 24
The reciprocal of the spatial wavelength for this helix gives the spatial frequency that is plotted in C. The effects of field inhomogeneities, and of T1 and T2 relaxation, are neglected. Variations in the relaxation times among the tissues would result in different lengths for the vectors associated with these tissues.
It is instructive to consider the behavior for the complete set of transverse magnetization vectors located between positions A and I, not just those at the selected nine points. By plotting the positions of the tips of all magnetization vectors versus distance along the x-axis, we obtain the diagrams shown in Figure 2-32E. At time point 1, when the magnetization vectors are in phase, the tips of the magnetization vectors lie along a straight line. As time progresses, we see that the tips of the vectors trace out a helix, which is twisted tighter and tighter as the effects of the gradient accumulate. Adjacent equivalent positions on the helix define a spatial wavelength, which is the reciprocal of spatial frequency. As the wavelength decreases from time points 1 to 4, the associated spatial frequency increases as shown in Figure 2-32C; this situation is directly analogous to that depicted in Figures 2-29A through C. Thus, and this is the critical point, applying a linear magnetic-field gradient twists the magnetization vectors along the direction of the gradient into a pattern in space that, as the effects of the gradient accumulate, corresponds to increasingly higher spatial frequencies. By receiving the MR signal when the magnetization exists in a configuration associated with a particular spatial frequency, the value of the k-space component for that spatial frequency is obtained. Stated in a more general way, the process of applying a linear magnetic-field gradient to transverse magnetization and receiving the MR signal physically performs a Fourier transform on the spin system,33 and hence this method is also known as Fourier encoding. page 46 page 47
Since the accumulation of phase discussed above is, in other words, dephasing, you may wonder why dephasing caused by the magnetic-field gradients allows us to perform spatial encoding while that caused by field inhomogeneities, as discussed at the end of the previous section, results in image artifacts such as signal loss. The essential difference between these two mechanisms is that dephasing due to the application of a linear magnetic-field gradient occurs uniformly across the fieldof-view of the image and to an extent that is under our full control, while dephasing from undesired field inhomogeneities, such as those created by a susceptibility interface, are localized to a particular region and cannot be changed in magnitude or switched on and off.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-33 Relationship between applied magnetic-field gradients and the resulting path through k-space. A, Timing diagram for the spatial-encoding configuration used for a GRE-type acquisition. B, Path through k-space that corresponds to the timing diagram in A. C, Timing diagram for the spatialencoding configuration used for a SE-type acquisition. D, Path through k-space that corresponds to the timing diagram in C. The labels 1, 2, etc., emphasize the association between the application of the magnetic-field gradients and the resulting positions in k-space. ADC, analog-to-digital converter; Gx, magnetic-field gradient applied along x-axis; Gy, magnetic-field gradient applied along y-axis; RF, radiofrequency pulses.
Generalizing the concept presented in Figure 2-32, we find that by applying linear magnetic-field gradients one can "navigate" through k-space and visit the desired spatial frequencies. Immediately following an excitation RF pulse (and its associated rephasing gradient) the transverse magnetization vectors are in phase throughout the slice, and we are thus positioned at the center of k-space. At any future point in time, our position in k-space along a particular axis depends on the accumulated effect of the gradient applied along the associated spatial axis. Specifically, for a constant gradient the spatial frequency is directly proportional to the product of the strength of the gradient and its duration and, in more general terms, for any arbitrary gradient waveform the spatial frequency is directly
16 of 24
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
17 of 24
proportional to the area under the gradient waveform. Note that a negative gradient (Figs. 2-23B and C) permits us to move toward negative spatial frequencies in k-space. As an example, consider the timing diagram shown in Figure 2-33A. The negative portion of the gradient Gx moves our position in k-space from the center (point 1 in Fig. 2-33B) along the negative kx-axis. At the same time, the gradient Gy moves our position along the positive ky-axis. The net result is a movement from point 1 to point 2 as illustrated in Figure 2-33B. Next, the positive portion of the gradient Gx moves our position from left to right in k-space, parallel to the kx-axis. Since our fundamental goal is to collect the k-space data needed to form an image, we could instruct the scanner to measure MR signals during the positive portion of the gradient Gx, and thereby acquire the portion of the spatial-frequency spectrum that lies along the "line" of k-space between points 2 and 4 in Figure 2-33B. These data are sampled and converted to numbers that the reconstruction computer can process by an analog-to-digital converter, abbreviated ADC. In Figure 2-33A, the raised portion of the ADC line that coincides with the positive portion of the gradient Gx denotes the time period during which the ADC is turned on to sample data. This data-sampling period typically ranges between 1 and 25 milliseconds. For the interested reader: Considering, for example, the gradient Gx, the associated value for the spatial frequency as a function of time, kx(t), can be written: Generalizing this expression to three dimensions gives: where k(t) = kxi + kyj + kzk (i, j and k are the unit vectors along the x, y and z directions, respectively) and G(t) = Gxi + Gyj + Gzk. By using this expression for k, the signal S received from the body can be written (neglecting relaxation):
where V is the volume of interest, r = xi + yj + zk, and FT stands for Fourier transform. Thus, the received signal is the Fourier transform of the spatial distribution of the transverse magnetization. The exponential term in Equation 2-10 indicates the effect of the magnetic-field gradients, which twist the magnetization vectors relative to one another to achieve the desired spatial frequencies, and the integral corresponds to receiving the MR signal by using an RF coil. The gradient configuration shown in Figure 2-33A uses a gradient-polarity reversal (that is, a negative portion of Gx followed by a positive portion) to permit a complete line of k-space to be sampled. In the context of dephasing and rephasing, the negative portion of Gx dephases the transverse magnetization and its positive portion rephases the magnetization such that phase coherence (aside from the effects of field inhomogeneities) along the direction of the gradient is restored at point 3 in Figure 2-33B. In other words, an echo is formed at point 3 by the gradient reversal. For this reason, imaging techniques that are based on this gradient configuration are typically called gradient-recalled echo or, more simply, gradient-echo (GRE) methods. page 47 page 48
The gradient that is active during the time period when data is sampled, or "read out," is commonly called the readout gradient, abbreviated GR or GRO. Since the frequency of precession varies along the direction in which it is applied, another common name for this gradient is the frequency-encoding gradient, abbreviated GFE. The gradient that is applied in a direction perpendicular to that for the readout gradient is called the phase-encoding gradient (Gy in Fig. 2-33A), abbreviated GP or GPE. The term "phase-encoding" is used because this gradient does not affect the frequency of precession during the time period when data are sampled; its effects are manifested through the phase shifts that accumulate prior to the data-sampling period. Analogous to the situation for the slice-select gradient, the readout and phase-encoding gradients may be any of the x-, y-, or z-gradients, depending on the slice orientation that is desired, or may be some combination of these gradients if an oblique slice is
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
18 of 24
desired. To complete our basic understanding of how to navigate through k-space, we need to discuss the effects of a 180° refocusing RF pulse as used to form a spin-echo. Consider the timing diagram shown in Figure 2-33C, which is the same as that in Figure 2-33A except a 180° RF pulse has been added and the polarities of Gy and the initial portion of Gx have been reversed. The combination of Gy and the portion of Gx before the 180° RF pulse move our position from the center of k-space to point 2 in Figure 2-33D. The effect of a refocusing RF pulse is to "flip" our position in k-space about the center. Thus, as illustrated in Figure 2-33D, the 180° RF pulse moves our position from point 2 to point 3. Next, the second portion of the Gx waveform moves us along a line in k-space parallel to the kx-axis, as already seen in Figure 2-33B. At point 4 in Figure 2-33D, phase coherence is restored with respect to the effects of both the gradient Gx and field inhomogeneities. In other words, a spin-echo is formed at point 4. Therefore, imaging techniques that are based on this gradient and RF-pulse configuration are called spin-echo (SE) methods.
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-34 Relationship between the amplitude and polarity of the phase-encoding gradient (GPE) and the spatial frequency for which data are acquired. High gradient amplitudes with a positive polarity correspond to high positive spatial frequencies. Likewise, high gradient amplitudes with a negative polarity correspond to high negative spatial frequencies. Low gradient amplitudes correspond to the central portion of k-space.
Now that we know how to navigate k-space, the remaining task necessary to complete the spatialencoding process is to choose the path in k-space that will be used to collect the required data, and the order in which this data acquisition will occur. Collectively, the path and order of data acquisition is called the k-space trajectory. As long as the requirements are met concerning the density and extent of sampling that were outlined at the end of our discussion of k-space, any trajectory can, in principle, be used.34,35 Many clinical MRI techniques use a simple k-space trajectory that consists of collecting the data sequentially, line-by-line, moving from one extreme of k-space to the opposite extreme. A trajectory that collects the data along parallel, straight lines in k-space is commonly called a Cartesian or rectilinear trajectory. The rectilinear case will be discussed here; more complicated trajectories are discussed in Chapter 7, Advanced Imaging Techniques. Consider again Figures 2-33A and B. To sample the required area of k-space, we can simply repeat the configuration shown in Figure 2-33A multiple times and, with each repetition, change the amplitude of the gradient Gy in equally-spaced steps from a high positive value to a high negative value. In this way, parallel lines in k-space are acquired, extending from high positive to high negative ky values. For example, if a 256 × 256 image matrix is desired, the gradient Gy steps through 256 values and during each data-sampling period 256 k-space components are sampled. Figure 2-34 illustrates the relationship between the amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient and the corresponding lines of k-space data. As will be discussed in the next section, the time between successive repetitions (and thus the time between adjacent lines of k-space in the phase-encoding direction), called the repetition time (abbreviated TR), is chosen based on the
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
19 of 24
image contrast that is desired and may be as long as several seconds. Note that the time to acquire a full set of k-space data is equal to the TR times the number of phase-encoding lines. The fact that k-space data corresponding to the readout direction are collected as time evolves following the excitation RF pulse, but over a relatively short period of a few milliseconds or less, while the data corresponding to the phase-encoding direction are collected each repetition at the same time relative to the excitation RF pulse, but over a total time that can be up to several minutes, leads to different properties for the image artifacts that may appear due to motion, field inhomogeneities, or chemical shift. The appearance of these artifacts and their relationship to the timing of the data collection process are discussed in Chapter 22. page 48 page 49
Table 2-2. Formulae for the Pixel Dimensions and Fields-of-View along the Readout and Phase-Encoding Directions for Standard Fourier Encoding Pixel Dimension
Field-of-View
Readout Phase-Encoding
∆GP, difference between consecutive phase-encoding gradient strengths; ∆t, time between consecutive samples during TS; GP,max, maximum strength of phase-encoding gradient; GR, strength of readout gradient; TP, duration of phase-encoding gradient; TS, data-sampling period.
It is useful to have an intuitive feel for the relationships between spatial resolution and the gradient characteristics. We learned above that the spatial frequency value is directly proportional to the product of the gradient strength and duration for a constant gradient. Since high spatial frequencies are required to represent details in the image, it follows that increasing the strength or duration of a spatial-encoding gradient, thus permitting higher spatial frequencies to be sampled, will result in higher spatial resolution (that is, smaller pixel dimensions). It is beyond the scope of our discussion to derive the associated mathematical relationships, but they are nonetheless presented in Table 2-2 for reference, along with those governing the image field-of-view. The interested reader should find that these formulae are straightforward to derive from the k-space relationships presented in Figure 2-31. To wrap up our discussion, we describe another formalism that is commonly used to explain spatial encoding along the readout direction. Recall from our discussion of slice selection that the application of a linear magnetic-field gradient creates a linear relationship between resonant frequency and position along the gradient. Therefore, as illustrated in Figure 2-35, if MR signals are received in the presence of a gradient, the signal from any given position along the gradient corresponds to a unique frequency. As a result, by applying a Fourier transform to these MR signals, the positions from which they originated can be recovered. Although this explanation of spatial encoding along the readout direction is easy to grasp, it is not particularly helpful for understanding phase-encoding or other advanced techniques such as spiral imaging, or even for understanding the function of the initial portions of the Gx gradients shown in Figures 2-33A and C.
The Pulse-Sequence Timing Diagram
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
20 of 24
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-35 Frequency encoding. When MR signals are received in the presence of a linear magnetic-field gradient, the signal from any given position along the gradient corresponds to a unique frequency. For example, tissues located at position x1 resonate at frequency ω 1.
The temporal sequence of the RF, magnetic-field gradient, and data-sampling events that compose a given technique for MR imaging is called a pulse sequence. A pulse-sequence timing diagram, which depicts these events in a graphical format, is the most commonly used method for describing the characteristics of pulse sequences. The primary elements of the pulse-sequence timing diagram were already introduced during our discussions of the slice-selection and spatial-encoding processes (Figs. 2-25 and 2-33). We can combine these pulse-sequence elements to form the timing diagrams for two fundamental techniques in MRI, gradient-echo and spin-echo imaging. page 49 page 50
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
21 of 24
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-36 Pulse-sequence timing diagrams for gradient-echo (A), single spin-echo (B), and double spin-echo (C) techniques. ADC, analog-to-digital converter; GP, phase-encoding gradient; GR, readout gradient; GS, slice-select gradient; NPE, number of times that the basic pulse-sequence timing is repeated, which equals the number of phase-encoding lines; RF, radiofrequency pulses; TE, echo time; TR, repetition time.
Figure 2-36A shows the pulse-sequence timing diagram for a basic GRE technique. The first line, labeled RF, illustrates the time of application and the waveforms for the RF pulses-in this case an excitation RF pulse with a flip angle α. The next three lines depict the time of application and the waveforms for the linear magnetic-field gradients applied along three mutually-orthogonal axes. These are labeled GS, GP, and GR, for the slice-select, phase-encoding, and readout gradients, respectively, although other labels, for example Gx, Gy, and Gz, are often used to indicate the assignment of the gradients for a particular slice orientation. As discussed above, the slice-select gradient is applied in synchrony with the RF pulse to spatially localize its effects, thus "selecting" the slice of interest. As also discussed above, the gradient waveforms applied along the phase-encoding and readout axes spatially encode the magnetization within this slice along the remaining two directions. The gradient waveform on the phase-encoding axis uses a symbolism that we have not yet discussed. The series of closely spaced horizontal lines is the graphical symbol for what is called a gradient table. This representation means that the strength of the gradient is stepped through a series of values (as shown in Fig. 2-34) as the basic pulse-sequence timing is repeated to collect the k-space data required to form the image. With each repetition, another line of data is collected. The fifth line in the timing
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
22 of 24
diagram shows when the MR signals occur. Although some pulse sequences generate a number of distinct signals, typically only the signals of interest are depicted. The last line of the timing diagram, labeled ADC, illustrates the time period during which the data are collected. It is not uncommon for either or both of the signal and ADC lines to be omitted. Finally, the square brackets around all of the timing events with the NPE label in the lower right corner indicate that these events are repeated NPE times, which is the number of phase-encoding lines or views. The pulse-sequence timing diagram for a conventional single-SE technique is presented in Figure 2-36B. As explained when we discussed Figure 2-33, the polarity of the initial portions of the GR and GP waveforms for the SE pulse sequence is reversed compared to those for the GRE pulse sequence to account for the effect of the refocusing RF pulse. The other pulse-sequence events for the single-SE technique are directly analogous to those for the GRE technique. As discussed earlier in the chapter, successive spin-echoes can be formed following a given excitation RF pulse by applying successive refocusing RF pulses. One of the most common implementations of this principle is the double-SE pulse sequence, shown in Figure 2-36C, which is used to collect a pair of images-the first having a relatively short echo time and the second having a relatively long echo time. page 50 page 51
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-37 The three basic strategies used to obtain a set of MR images: two-dimensional (2D) slices, three-dimensional (3D) single-slab, and 3D multi-slab. This example illustrates the possibilities for acquiring axial images of the brain. Acquisitions using 2D slices or 3D multi-slab often employ a gap between the slices or slabs, as shown, to increase the anatomic coverage and to decrease crosstalk effects, although the use of contiguous slices or slabs (that is, no gaps) is appropriate for some applications. (From Mugler JP III: Overview of MR imaging pulse sequences. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am 7:661-697, 1999)
The double-SE timing diagram illustrates two important pulse-sequence features that are used for a variety of applications. Comparing the slice-select and readout gradient waveforms for the second echo to those of the first echo, several differences are seen. The gradient waveforms applied following the first echo, aside from those during the refocusing RF pulse and the data-sampling period, perform what is commonly called flow compensation. The goal of flow compensation is to manipulate the
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
23 of 24
transverse magnetization such that the gradient-induced phase shift at the echo time for moving material is equal to that which would have occurred if the material were stationary. 36,37 Thus, associated motion artifacts are suppressed. This process, which is applicable to most types of MRI 36 pulse sequences, is also called motion artifact suppression technique (abbreviated MAST) or gradient moment rephasing (abbreviated GMR). Additional information concerning motion artifacts and the details of flow compensation can be found in Chapter 27. Another difference between the first and second echoes in Figure 2-36C is that the data-sampling period for the second echo is longer.38 Pulse sequences with data sampling periods of different durations are often called variable-bandwidth techniques. In a double-SE pulse sequence, the variable-bandwidth strategy is implemented by using a short data-sampling period for the first echo, which permits a short TE value, and a long data-sampling period for the second echo, which increases the signal-to-noise ratio since the noise level varies inversely as the square root of the data-sampling period. A lower noise level is beneficial for the later echo because the signal intensity is, by design, attenuated by T2 decay. Optimization of the signalto-noise ratio is discussed further in Chapter 3.
Multislice, Sequential-Slice, and Three-Dimensional Imaging To obtain MR images that cover the anatomic region of interest, either a set of 2D slices or a threedimensional (abbreviated 3D) volume is typically acquired as illustrated in Figure 2-37. Compared to 2D slice-selective imaging as discussed in detail above, a 3D acquisition uses an additional phaseencoding gradient table that is applied along the third dimension. This additional gradient performs spatial encoding along the slice-select direction, thereby generating a set of contiguous slices within the volume. These slices are often referred to as partitions to distinguish them from image slices derived from a fundamentally 2D acquisition. The motivations for performing a 3D acquisition include the availability of thin, contiguous slices, which can be used to obtain high-resolution images of 39-41 arbitrary orientations through post-processing and, for equivalent pulse-sequence parameter values in the 2D and 3D cases, an increase in the signal-to-noise ratio by a factor equal to the square root of the number of partitions.42 Note, however, that the time to acquire a full set of k-space data for 3D imaging is equal to the TR times the product of the number of phase-encoding steps for the second dimension and that for the third dimension. Thus, if a large number of slices are desired in the third dimension, the imaging time will be quite long unless TR is relatively short. A hybrid of 2D and 3D imaging is also sometimes used, called 3D multi-slab. 43,44 For this type of acquisition a set of slabs is acquired, and each slab is in turn phase-encoded along the third dimension to yield a set of contiguous partitions (Fig. 2-37, right). In this context, a "true" (single-volume) 3D acquisition is sometimes referred to as 3D single-slab imaging. page 51 page 52
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002012
24 of 24
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-38 The order of data acquisition for 2D multislice and sequential-slice imaging. A hypothetical case is illustrated where three images are to be acquired, and the k-space data corresponding to each image are composed of three segments. One data segment of an image slice is acquired following each application of the excitation RF pulse, and thus nine excitations are required to collect the data for all three images. A, The k-space data layout corresponding to the three images. B, The data acquisition order for 2D multislice imaging. C, The data acquisition order for 2D sequential-slice imaging.
Two-dimensional acquisitions can be subdivided into two important forms: sequential-slice and multislice45 (Fig. 2-38). In a sequential-slice acquisition, all of the data required for a given image are collected before proceeding to the next image (Fig. 2-38C), analogous to the operation of conventional X-ray computer tomography. In contrast, a multislice acquisition collects only a portion of the data required for a given image, typically one or several phase-encoding lines, before collecting the corresponding data for each of the other images. This process is repeated until all of the data for all of the images are collected (Fig. 2-38B). Obviously, a given image can be acquired more rapidly by using the sequential-slice method, and this approach is typically used when short acquisition times are critical, for example in some implementations of MR angiography or for imaging rapidly moving structures. On the other hand, a multislice acquisition is typically used when a relatively long time period (on the order of 1 second) is required between the interrogations of a particular slice to permit T1 relaxation to occur and thereby generate the desired image contrast, as discussed in the next section. While waiting for the magnetization in a given slice to recover, slices at different positions can be excited and encoded. Thus, for the multislice method, the imaging time for several slices is the same as that for one slice, which is an important feature of this strategy. Another practical aspect of sequential-slice and multislice acquisitions is the temporal order in which the data for the slices is collected. This may be important, for example, if there is blood flow perpendicular to the slices,46,47 or if there is a significant degree of crosstalk between slices.27,29 The most common acquisition orders are consecutive, beginning at either end of the image set, and interleaved, for example collecting all odd-numbered slices followed by all even-numbered slices, although arbitrary acquisition orders can be used. Note that the sequential-slice and multislice concepts are also applicable to 3D multi-slab acquisitions.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
1 of 8
BASIC FORMS OF IMAGE CONTRAST The contrast between two tissues is defined as the difference between their signal intensities divided by their average signal intensity. For example, two tissues with very different signal intensities exhibit high contrast, while two tissues with similar intensities exhibit low contrast. One of the principal advantages of MRI over other imaging modalities, such as X-ray computed tomography, is the high level of contrast among soft-tissues that can be obtained. By using appropriate pulse-sequence designs, many different physical and physiologic parameters can be encoded in the form of image contrast. The most basic form of contrast in MRI, and most widely used, is that based on the tissue relaxation times T1 and T2. Due to the requirements of the spatialencoding process, it is not possible to generate contrast in a straightforward manner that depends solely on one of these parameters. Instead, images are typically created whose contrast depends largely on a given parameter, for example T1, and such images are said to be weighted by this parameter. For instance, the contrast in a T1-weighted image primarily reflects differences in the T1 relaxation times among the tissues. page 52 page 53
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-39 Plots of T1 (A) and T2 (B) relaxation following a 90° excitation RF pulse for three relaxation times. Equal proton densities are assumed for the three curves in each plot.
In Figure 2-39 we review the effects of T1 and T2 relaxation on the magnetization, as discussed earlier in the chapter. The longitudinal magnetization corresponding to a tissue with a short T1 relaxes rapidly
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
2 of 8
toward thermal equilibrium (upper curve in Fig. 2-39A) in comparison to a tissue with a long T1, which relaxes more slowly (lower curve). Similarly, the transverse magnetization corresponding to a tissue with a short T2 decays rapidly toward zero (lower curve in Fig. 2-39B) in comparison to a tissue with a long T2, which decays more slowly (upper curve). For both T1 and T2 relaxation, the amplitudes of the magnetization vectors are the same at time equal to zero (assuming equal proton densities; see below), before any relaxation has occurred, and when the elapsed time is several times the longest relaxation-time value, such that the magnetization has returned to thermal equilibrium. As a result, for times that are very short or very long compared to the values of T1 or T2, the difference between the relaxation curves, and hence the corresponding image contrast due to differences in T1 or T2, is small. Further, the maximum difference between the curves associated with two different relaxation times occurs at an intermediate time, which falls between the two associated relaxation times. The T1 and T2 relaxation curves for a given tissue can be used to calculate the associated signal intensity in the image. A description of the evolution of the magnetization during a pulse sequence will help us to understand how this calculation is performed. Consider, as an example, the single-SE pulse sequence discussed in the previous section (see Fig. 2-36B). The pulse-sequence events, including the RF pulses, are repeated many times to collect the k-space data required to form the image. Because the time period (TR) between successive corresponding pulse-sequence events, such as two successive 90° RF pulses, is constant, the magnetization is put into a steady state. This means that if the longitudinal or transverse component of the magnetization associated with a given tissue is measured at corresponding time points in any two repetitions of the pulse sequence, the same value will be obtained. In other words, the time course of longitudinal and transverse relaxation for each tissue is the same for each repetition of the pulse sequence. With this in mind, note that the transverse magnetization created by a given 90° excitation RF pulse is equal to the longitudinal magnetization that existed just before this pulse. In addition, recall that the MR signal is directly proportional to the transverse magnetization. Thus, to determine the relative value of the signal intensity for a given tissue, we can plot the T1 relaxation curve for the time period TR followed immediately by the T2 relaxation curve for the time period TE, as illustrated in Figure 2-40. The T1 relaxation curve provides the value of the longitudinal magnetization that is available for any given excitation RF pulse (except the first one) to convert into transverse magnetization. The T2 relaxation curve indicates the degree to which this transverse magnetization decays before the echo is acquired. Thus, the final value of the combined T1, T2 relaxation curve is directly proportional to the signal intensity for the tissue. page 53 page 54
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-40 Calculation of the tissue signal intensity for a single spin-echo pulse sequence by combining the associated T1 and T2 relaxation curves. The T1 relaxation curve (gray) shows the evolution of the longitudinal magnetization following a given excitation RF pulse. (The small discontinuity in the curve near time zero represents the effect of the refocusing RF pulse.) At time TR, the subsequent excitation RF pulse converts the available longitudinal magnetization into transverse magnetization; the magnitude of the transverse magnetization is directly proportional to signal intensity
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
3 of 8
and thus the final value of the T2 relaxation curve gives the relative signal intensity in the image.
Another important factor that influences the basic contrast behavior of MR images is the relative fraction of signal-producing protons (that is, hydrogen nuclei) in one tissue compared to another. Only the protons in water and lipids produce an MR signal that can be detected by the commonly used pulse sequences; the number of these signal-producing protons per unit volume of tissue is called the spin density or proton density. (The T2 times for signals from the protons in macromolecules are too short to be detected, but these protons can nonetheless affect image contrast through the magnetization transfer mechanism discussed in Chapter 7.) For example, gray matter has a proton density that is roughly 15% larger than that for white matter. The MR signal from a given tissue, and hence the corresponding image signal intensity, scales directly with the proton density. Typically, proton-density values are stated as a percentage or fraction of that for cerebrospinal fluid (abbreviated CSF). For the interested reader: The signal intensity S for a single-SE pulse sequence can be written: where ρ is the proton density. The term in parentheses, just after ρ, corresponds to T1 relaxation and the last term accounts for T2 relaxation. This is the equation that was used to generate the curves in Figures 2-40 and 2-41. If the effect of the refocusing RF pulse is neglected, the term in parentheses simplifies to that in parentheses in Equation 2-4 for t = TR. With these underlying concepts in hand, we will now discuss how relaxation-time-based forms of image contrast are generated, including proton-density, T1, and T2 weighting for SE imaging, and T2* weighting for GRE imaging. Three basic principles determine the degree to which proton-density, T1, and T2 (or T2* for GRE imaging) contribute to the image contrast: 1. the proton-density contribution is always present; 2. the amount of T1 weighting is controlled by varying the TR; and 3. the amount of T2 weighting (or T2* weighting for GRE) is controlled by varying the TE.
Proton-Density-Weighted Imaging
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
4 of 8
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-41 Calculated evolutions of the magnetization, and the resulting image signal intensities, for A, proton-density-weighted (TR/TE = 2500/15 ms), B, T1-weighted (TR/TE = 500/15 ms), and C, T2-weighted (TR/TE = 2500/90 ms) spin-echo brain imaging. The curves for fat, gray matter (GM), white matter (WM), and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) were derived from estimated relaxation times (1.5 tesla) and proton densities. Simulated brain images, based on the calculated signal intensities, are shown to the right of each plot. For clarity, the time scale for T2 decay is expanded relative to that for T1 decay.
A proton-density-weighted image is obtained by minimizing the contributions from T1 and T2 relaxation, thus yielding an image wherein tissues with high proton densities are relatively bright and those with low proton densities are relatively dark. Differences in signal intensity due to differences in T1 are minimized by using a TR that is long compared to the T1 values of interest; differences in signal intensity that arise from differences in T2 are minimized by using the shortest TE permitted by the pulse sequence. (The minimum TE depends on the durations chosen for the RF pulses and the data-sampling period, on the capabilities of the scanner's gradient system, and, to some extent, on the desired spatial resolution.) Thus, in general, proton-density weighting is obtained by using a long TR and a short TE. page 54 page 55
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
5 of 8
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-42 The image contrasts typically created using conventional spin-echo imaging. Axial brain images are shown for T1 (A), proton-density (B), and T2 weighting (C). The image in A was obtained by using a single-SE sequence (TR/TE 500/15 ms) and those in B and C were obtained by using a double-SE sequence (TR/TE1/TE2 2500/15/90 ms). (From Mugler JP III: Overview of MR imaging pulse sequences. Magn Reson Imaging Clin N Am 7:661-697, 1999)
By implementing for brain MRI the concept illustrated in Figure 2-40, Figure 2-41 depicts the calculated evolutions of the magnetization and the resulting relative image signal intensities for fat, gray matter, white matter, and CSF based on estimated relaxation times (1.5 tesla) and proton densities. For a TR of 2500 ms and a TE of 15 ms, values that are typical for proton-density-weighted brain imaging at 1.5 tesla, Figure 2-41A shows that the calculated signal intensities for fat, gray matter, and white matter correlate with their established proton densities. However, for this TR, the signal intensity for CSF does not reflect its proton density because the T1 of CSF is approximately 4 seconds. Thus, the image is proton-density weighted for fat, white matter, and gray matter, but T1 weighted for CSF. Despite this ambiguity, images produced by using this parameter combination are traditionally called protondensity weighted and are useful for the detection of various pathologies. Figure 2-42B shows an axial brain image acquired using these parameter values.
T1-Weighted Imaging A T1-weighted image is obtained by minimizing contributions from T2 relaxation while emphasizing those from T1 relaxation, thus yielding an image wherein tissues with short T1 values are relatively bright and those with long T1 values are relatively dark. As discussed above, differences in signal intensity due to differences in T2 can be minimized by using the shortest TE permitted by the pulse sequence. To emphasize differences in signal intensity secondary to differences in T1, a TR in the vicinity of the T1 values of interest is chosen. The exact value of TR is not critical, and its choice is often influenced by the number of slices that can be acquired within the TR as well as by the desired contrast. For example, a TR between 400 and 700 ms is commonly used for T1-weighted brain imaging at 1.5 tesla; the associated T1 values for white matter and gray matter are approximately 600 and 1000 ms, respectively. In general terms, T1 weighting is obtained by using a short TR and a short TE. For a TR of 500 ms and a TE of 15 ms, Figure 2-41B shows that the calculated signal intensities for fat, white matter, gray matter, and CSF are inversely related to their T1 relaxation times, with fat having the highest signal and CSF the lowest. Figure 2-42A shows an axial brain image acquired using these parameter values.
6 of 8
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
7 of 8
T2-Weighted Imaging In contrast to a T1-weighted image, a T2-weighted image is obtained by minimizing contributions from T1 relaxation while emphasizing those from T2 relaxation, thus yielding an image wherein tissues with long T2 values are relatively bright and those with short T2 values are relatively dark. As discussed for proton-density-weighted imaging, differences in signal intensity that arise from differences in T1 can be minimized by using a TR that is long compared to the T1 values of interest. To emphasize differences in signal intensity due to differences in T2, a relatively long TE is chosen. For example, a TE of approximately 100 ms is commonly used for T2-weighted brain imaging at 1.5 tesla. The associated T2 values for white matter and gray matter are approximately 90 and 100 ms, respectively, and those for various pathologies are often substantially longer. The choice of TE represents a trade-off between increased contrast at longer TE values and increased signal-to-noise ratios at shorter TE values. In general terms, T2 weighting is obtained by using a long TR and a long TE. page 55 page 56
For a TR of 2500 ms and a TE of 90 ms, Figure 2-41C shows that the calculated signal intensities for the four tissues correlate with their T2 relaxation times. Even though this TR is short compared to the T1 for CSF, its signal intensity ends up as the brightest in the image due to the very long T2 relaxation time of CSF (approximately 2000 ms). Figure 2-42C shows an axial brain image acquired using these parameter values. Note that proton-density-weighted and T2-weighted spin-echo images are typically collected during the same acquisition by using a double-SE pulse sequence as described in Figure 2-36C.
T2*-Weighted Imaging
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002019
8 of 8
Add to lightbox
Figure 2-43 Coronal gradient-echo (TE 4 ms) (A) and spin-echo (TE 36 ms) (B) images of the chest demonstrating the short T2* value for lung tissue.
Conceptually, T2*-weighted imaging is identical to T2-weighted imaging; contributions from T1 relaxation are minimized while those from T2* are emphasized. The practical difference is that T2* values are often much shorter than the underlying T2 values. Thus, what is considered a long TE for T2*-weighted imaging is often much less than that used for T2-weighted imaging. For example, Figure 2-21B illustrates the signal loss that occurs in GRE images in the vicinity of air-tissue interfaces. The tissue surrounding such an interface effectively has a very short T2* value. (The term "effectively" is used because in this case the T2* value is not an intrinsic property of the tissue.) The TE for Figure 2-21B was only 12 ms, which, in the context of T2-weighted SE imaging, is a short TE. Figure 2-43 shows an example where the T2* value is an intrinsic property of the tissue. Lung parenchyma has a very short T2* (~1 ms)48,49 due to microscopic susceptibility-induced field gradients, which arise from the countless air-tissue interfaces that characterize the lung. Thus, even with a relatively short TE of 4 ms, lung tissue appears black in a GRE image (Fig. 2-43A). In contrast, in the SE image (TE 36 ms) shown in Figure 2-43B, we can see the lung parenchyma (along with numerous pulmonary blood 50 vessels), demonstrating that the T2 value for lung tissue is much longer than its T2* value. Nonetheless, the signal intensity for lung tissue in the SE image is low compared to that for other tissues such as fat because the proton density of lung tissue is relatively low.
Mixed Weighting The goal of many clinical MRI exams is to detect and characterize a pathologic process. In this context, it does not matter what type of contrast weighting is used as long as the pathology can be detected against a background of normal tissue. As a result, it is not uncommon for imaging parameter combinations to be used that are optimized to detect a certain pathology, but that do not fit into one of the categories described above. In the nomenclature of our discussion, such a parameter combination can be considered to yield mixed weighting. Finally, summarizing the general parameter choices for obtaining relaxation-time-based contrast, proton-density weighting requires a long TR and short TE, T1 weighting is obtained with a short TR and short TE, and T2 weighting is achieved with a long TR and long TE. Since T1 values generally increase with field strength, the TR value appropriate for a particular type of image contrast must be scaled accordingly.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:39
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002025
1 of 2
CONCLUSION In this chapter we have outlined the major issues involved in generating the magnetic-resonance signal and in manipulating the underlying source of this signal, the magnetization, to create images that convey medically useful information. The topics discussed should provide a solid foundation for understanding subsequent chapters that deal with MRI physics or advanced clinical applications. Hopefully, this introductory material has provided a flavor of the tremendous versatility that characterizes MRI. page 56 page 57
REFERENCES 1. Lide DR (ed): CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 84th ed. Boca Raton, Fla: CRC Press, 2003. 2. Slichter CP: Principles of Magnetic Resonance, 2nd ed. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1980. 3. Abragam A: The Principles of Nuclear Magnetism. London: Oxford University Press, 1961. 4. Andrew ER: Nuclear Magnetic Resonance. London: Cambridge University Press, 1955. 5. Farrar TC, Becker ED: Pulse and Fourier Transform NMR: Introduction to Theory and Methods. New York: Academic Press, 1971. 6. Bottomley PA, Foster TH, Argersinger RE, et al: A review of normal tissue hydrogen NMR relaxation times and relaxation mechanisms from 1-100 MHz: Dependence on tissue type, NMR frequency, temperature, species, excision, and age. Med Phys 11:425-448, 1984. 1
7. Bottomley PA, Hardy CJ, Argersinger RE, et al: A review of H nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation in pathology: Are T1 and T2 diagnostic? Med Phys 14:1-37, 1987. 8. Bydder GM, Pennock JM, Steiner RE, et al: The short TI inversion recovery sequence-an approach to MR imaging of the abdomen. Magn Reson Imaging 3:251-254, 1985. Medline Similar articles 9. Bydder GM, Young IR: MR imaging: clinical use of the inversion recovery sequence. J Comput Assist Tomogr 9:659-675, 1985. Medline Similar articles 10. Hajnal JV, Bryant DJ, Kasuboski L, et al: Use of fluid attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) pulse sequences in MRI of the brain. J Comput Assist Tomogr 16:841-844, 1992. Medline Similar articles 11. Malisch TW, Hedlund LW, Suddarth SA, et al: MR microscopy at 7.0 T: Effects of brain iron. J Magn Reson Imaging 1:301-305, 1991. 12. Damadian R: Tumor detection by nuclear magnetic resonance. Science 171:1151-1153, 1971. Medline Similar articles 13. Eggleston JC, Saryan LA, Hollis DP: Nuclear magnetic resonance investigations of human neoplastic and abnormal nonneoplastic tissues. Cancer Res 35:1326-1332, 1975. Medline Similar articles 14. Bloembergen N: Nuclear magnetic relaxation. New York: WA Benjamin, 1961. 15. Yablonskiy DA, Haacke EM: Theory of NMR signal behavior in magnetically inhomogeneous tissues: The static dephasing regime. Magn Reson Med 32:749-763, 1994. Medline Similar articles 16. Sukstanskii AL, Yablonskiy DA: Gaussian approximation in the theory of MR signal formation in the presence of structurespecific magnetic field inhomogeneities. J Magn Reson 163:236-247, 2003. Medline Similar articles 17. Hahn EL: Spin echoes. Phys Rev 80:580-594, 1950. 18. Schenck JF: The role of magnetic susceptibility in magnetic resonance imaging: MRI magnetic compatibility of the first and second kinds. Med Phys 23:815, 1996. Medline Similar articles 19. Edelman RR, Johnson K, Buxton R, et al: MR of hemorrhage: A new approach. Am J Neuroradiol 7:751-756, 1986. Medline Similar articles 20. Edelman RR, Mattle HP, Atkinson DJ, et al: Cerebral blood flow: Assessment with dynamic contrast-enhanced T2*-weighted MR imaging at 1.5T. Radiology 176:211-220, 1990. 21. Ogawa S, Tank DW, Menon R, et al: Intrinsic signal changes accompanying sensory stimulation: Functional brain mapping with magnetic resonance imaging. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:5951-5955, 1992. Medline Similar articles 22. Posse S, Aue WP: Susceptibility artifacts in spin-echo and gradient-echo imaging. J Magn Reson 88:473-492, 1990. 23. Wehrli FW, Perkins TG, Shimakawa A, et al: Chemical shift-induced amplitude modulations in images obtained with gradient refocusing. Magn Reson Imaging 5:157-158, 1987. Medline Similar articles 24. Lauterbur PC: Image formation by induced local interactions: Examples employing nuclear magnetic resonance. Nature 242:190-191, 1973. 25. Lauterbur PC, Kramer DM, House WV Jr, et al: Zeugmatographic high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Images of chemical inhomogeneity within macroscopic objects. J Am Chem Soc 97:6866-6868, 1975.
11-04-2010 23:40
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC002025
2 of 2
26. Mansfield P, Maudsley AA, Bains T: Fast scan proton density imaging by NMR. J Phys E - Sci Instrum 9:271-278, 1976. 27. Kneeland JB, Shimakawa A, Wehrli FW: Effect of intersection spacing on MR image contrast and study time. Radiology 158:819-822, 1986. Medline Similar articles 28. Crawley AP, Henkelman RM: A stimulated echo artifact from slice interference in magnetic resonance imaging. Med Phys 14:842-848, 1987. Medline Similar articles 29. Kucharczyk W, Crawley AP, Kelly WM, et al: Effect of multislice interference on image contrast in T2- and T1-weighted MR images. Am J Neuroradiol 9:443-451, 1988. Medline Similar articles 30. Hoult DI: Zeugmatography: A criticism of the concept of a selective pulse in the presence of a field gradient. J Magn Reson 26:165-167, 1977. 31. Margosian P, Schmitt F, Purdy D: Faster MR imaging: Imaging with half the data. Health Care Instrum 1:195-197, 1986. 32. Feinberg DA, Hale JD, Watts JC, et al: Halving MR imaging time by conjugation: Demonstration at 3.5 kG. Radiology 161:527-531, 1986. 33. Brown TR, Kincaid BM, Ugurbil K: NMR chemical shift imaging in three dimensions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 79:3523-3526, 1982. Medline Similar articles 34. Ljunggren S: A simple graphical representation of Fourier-based imaging methods. J Magn Reson 54:338-343, 1983. 35. Twieg DB: The k-trajectory formulation of the NMR imaging process with applications in analysis and synthesis of imaging methods. Med Phys 10:610-621, 1983. Medline Similar articles 36. Pattany PM, Phillips JJ, Chiu LC, et al: Motion artifact suppression technique (MAST) for MR imaging. J Comput Assist Tomogr 11:369-377, 1987. Medline Similar articles 37. Haacke EM, Lenz GW: Improving MR image quality in the presence of motion by using rephasing gradients. Am J Roentgenol 148:1251-1258, 1987. 38. Mugler JP III, Brookeman JR: Implementation of mixed bandwidth MRI pulse sequences using a single analog lowpass filter. Magn Reson Imaging 7:487-493, 1989. Medline Similar articles 39. Kramer DM, Schneider JS, Rudin AM, et al: True three-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance zeugmatographic images of a human brain. Neuroradiology 21:239-244, 1981. Medline Similar articles 40. Buonanno FS, Pykett IL, Brady TJ, et al: Clinical relevance of two different nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) approaches to imaging of a low-grade astrocytoma. J Comput Assist Tomogr 6:529-535, 1982. Medline Similar articles 41. Pykett IL, Buonanno FS, Brady TJ, et al: True three-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance neuro-imaging in ischemic stroke: correlation of NMR, X-ray CT and pathology. Stroke 14:173-177, 1983. Medline Similar articles 42. Parker DL, Gullberg GT: Signal-to-noise efficiency in magnetic resonance imaging. Med Phys 17:250-257, 1990. Medline Similar articles 43. Oshio K, Jolesz FA, Melki PS, et al: T2-weighted thin-section imaging with the multislab three-dimensional RARE technique. J Magn Reson Imaging 1:695-700, 1991. Medline Similar articles 44. Yuan C, Schmiedl UP, Weinberger E, et al: Three-dimensional fast spin-echo imaging: pulse sequence and in vivo image evaluation. J Magn Reson Imaging 3:894-899, 1993. Medline Similar articles 45. Crooks LE, Ortendahl DA, Kaufman L, et al: Clinical efficiency of nuclear magnetic resonance imaging. Radiology 146:123-128, 1983. Medline Similar articles 46. Axel L: Blood flow effects in magnetic resonance imaging. Am J Roentgenol 143:1157-1166, 1984. 47. Bradley WG Jr, Waluch V: Blood flow: magnetic resonance imaging. Radiology 154:443-450, 1985. Medline Similar articles 48. Bergin CJ, Glover GH, Pauly JM: Lung parenchyma: magnetic susceptibility in MR imaging. Radiology 180:845-848, 1991. Medline Similar articles 49. Stock KW, Chen Q, Hatabu H, et al: Magnetic resonance T2* measurements of the normal human lung in vivo with ultra-short echo times. Magn Reson Imaging 17:997-1000, 1999. Medline Similar articles 50. Shioya S, Christman R, Ailion DC: An in vivo NMR imaging determination of multiexponential Hahn T2 of normal lung. Magn Reson Med 16:49-56, 1990.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:40
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00303068
1 of 1
RACTICAL
ONSIDERATIONS AND MAGE
PTIMIZATION
Robert R. Edelman Eugene E. Dunkle Wei Li Kraig V. Kissinger Kathleen Thangaraj Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a dynamic field of study, continually evolving with an ever-increasing range of clinical applications. Improvements in both software and hardware have resulted in enhanced image quality and shorter scanning times, providing healthcare professionals with information not previously available with this modality. Developments such as multichannel phased-array coils, MR angiography, functional imaging (fMRI), parallel imaging, ultrafast imaging, and spectroscopy give the technologist and imaging specialist a number of new and exciting approaches that place MRI at the forefront of medical imaging. It is imperative, in these rapidly changing times, that the imaging technologist keep informed of new developments in design and technology and successfully apply these skills to provide both quality care of patients and diagnostic imaging. Several regularly updated web sites are available to provide a variety of useful information to the 1-3 technologist. This chapter serves as an overview of performing an examination in a typical MRI environment (Fig. 3-1). It is organized in the sequence of the patient and technologist experience, from the initial encounter with the facility, basic safety issues, preparation and positioning on the table, choice of imaging technique and means for image optimization, and specialized acquisition techniques.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:41
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
THE FACILITY
Facility Design The needs for equipment and facility organization will differ somewhat, depending on an MRI facility's affiliation with a clinic, a hospital environment, or a freestanding imaging center. Facility location not withstanding, most MRI centers have a mix of patients consisting of a larger percentage of outpatients than inpatients. Decisions on size and scope of resources should be made with an understanding of market demand for the MRI facility location and population served. page 58 page 59
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-1 Flow chart for patient imaging.
A floor plan common to all facility types has several basic features (Fig. 3-2). The first is a reception area, where patients register for an appointment and non-MRI healthcare providers may make inquiries, receive information, and ask for assistance and direction from reception staff. A waiting area should be located adjacent to the reception desk. This area should be large enough to serve as a place for patients to complete questionnaires and for their companions to wait comfortably while a patient undergoes the procedure. Rest rooms are necessary outside the suite for visitors or patients not yet cleared by MRI staff for entrance into the MRI suite. Additional facilities should be located within the suite to provide convenience and privacy for gowned patients.
1 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-2 Typical MRI unit floor plan.
Every MRI department should provide a physical barrier between the reception area and the scanner environment. Warning signs should be posted at or before the entrance to the MRI suite notifying all persons entering the area of the potentially hazardous magnetic field. These signs should clearly state that no ferromagnetic object can be brought into the area and that all patients, personnel, and visitors are required to stop at the reception area and check with department personnel before proceeding. Entry doors should be installed with an electronic, manual, or combination lock controlled by appropriate department personnel. An informed staff member, such as a receptionist, should be located near this physical barrier. The reception staff monitors the passage of patients and personnel beyond the barrier. In addition, the boundary may aid in preventing unauthorized patients and personnel from straying into the magnet's fringe field. The reception area should be located at a safe distance 4 from the 5 gauss (5-G) line, the defining line for safety purposes. The major concern of entering a fringe field beyond the 5-G line is specific to individuals with a pacemaker, because its function may be altered. This line may be defined by measuring the magnetic force with a magnetometer. page 59 page 60
The location of the defining line depends on the magnet strength and the type of shielding. Manufacturers offer actively shielded magnets, which consist of additional superconducting loops of wire around the magnet. These coils partially negate the magnetic fringe field, bringing the 5-G line closer to the magnet. Passive shielding is another way to bring the 5-G line closer to the magnet. This method utilizes large pieces of iron placed in strategic locations around the magnet. A major drawback with this system is that the quantity of iron needed greatly increases the overall weight of the system.
2 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
The excess weight limits its placement in certain locations because it is more challenging and costly to install such heavy equipment several floors above ground level. Permanent magnets tend to have much more tightly confined fringe fields than superconductive ones. Receptionists need to monitor pedestrian traffic continually. Communication and team support with other team members such as technologists and radiologists are essential. Therefore, it is important to make this area easily accessible to MRI healthcare workers as well. A technologist should be available to reception staff to assist with scheduling and patient-related questions. Dressing rooms and lockers are needed, because a patient undergoing MRI will need to remove personal belongings such as credit cards with a magnetic strip; clothing with zippers, snaps, or hooks; jewelry; hairpins; and any other metallic objects. A room designated for preparation of patients should be provided for the following instances: interviewing patients, explanation of procedures, preparation for intravenous (IV) access for examinations that require IV administration of contrast medium; administration and pre- and post-examination monitoring of conscious sedation; and a pre-procedure interview and physical examination of the patient by the radiologist. Ideally, the preparation room is located close to the MRI examination room, to reduce movement of patients between the two areas. The MRI examination room should be as esthetically pleasing to patients as possible. It must be functional for the technologist's use, as well. Certain stringent technical requirements must be met so the system may perform reliably and produce artifact-free images. Equipment and supplies specifically designed for the MRI environment should be stored within the MRI examination room, including all radiofrequency (RF) coils, MR-compatible vital sign monitoring equipment, earplugs, prism glasses, blindfolds, positioning sponges and sandbags, and injector kits. Other items that are not unique to the MRI examination requirements but are universal to the hospital or clinic setting should also be stocked in this room. Examples include clean and dirty linen stores, blankets, antibacterial cleaning fluids, emesis basins, glucagon, IV supplies, disposable needle containers, contrast agent reaction kits, and denture cups. A technologist should need to exert minimal effort in gaining access to these items to perform an examination adequately in a comfortable, clean, and safe environment without delay. A well-organized examination room is more reassuring to a patient because it is less technically foreboding. Another advantage is that a technologist familiar with the location of equipment can more easily provide timely, competent, and professional care. Some surface coils are awkward and heavy. Therefore, proper storage location is an important consideration. If coils are stored in an inconvenient location, they may be subject to damage, or worse, the technologist may suffer injury. Heavy coils should be stored as nearby as possible and at waist height. There should be no hindrance between the coil storage area and the examination table. Adequate shelving for coil storage is also important in preventing coil damage. Coils should not be stacked on top of each other in any way, nor should other equipment be stored on top of the coils, or vice versa. When planning for shelf space, it is wise to allow for more than what seems needed in the immediate future to allow for growth of services and changes in technology. Room decor also plays a role in reducing a patient's level of anxiety. Indirect room lighting has a softer, less abrasive tone. Plants, skylight windows, or wall hangings depicting relaxing scenery may assist to focus and calm the anxious patient. Assisting a patient to perceive the environment as spacious and nonconfining enhances the patient's overall MRI examination experience. An MR-compatible stereo system provides the patient with relaxing music and better communication capabilities. Patients reported lower levels of anxiety after the MRI scan when able to listen to music of choice during the procedure compared with patients who had no music during MRI. 5 It is also helpful to tell patients ahead of time to bring their own music so they can listen to music of choice. Some facilities actually create a music library with a wide range of musical choices to choose from. In addition, stereo systems that provide ear protection are an important consideration, because some scanning techniques are loud enough to cause temporary hearing loss. 6 7
Room ventilation is an important factor to consider for comfort of patients. Air exchange is impeded
3 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
by the room's copper shielding, which prevents RF interference from the outside environment. It is helpful to have a separate dedicated temperature control for the examination room. In addition, most manufacturers' equipment specifications call for cooler temperatures and higher humidity than in other areas of the hospital. Collaborating with architects and engineers about such requirements during the facility planning stages will prevent future problems in meeting the demands on the heat, ventilation, and air conditioning system, which also controls humidification, required in the MRI environment. The humidity required is higher than most other environments. A scan room with humidity below 50% will likely produce unpredictable image artifacts. This point should be stressed with planning engineers and vendor service engineers because each system's specification may be slightly different and correcting an inadequate system after it is implemented is costly and disruptive to this environment.
Monitoring Equipment page 60 page 61
A sedated patient's vital signs should be monitored by reliable equipment. Critical care/intensive care patients must also be monitored. The nature of the MRI environment makes it difficult, if not impossible, to have proximity to a patient to check for level of responsiveness. Also, each scan typically lasts from a few seconds to 10 minutes or more, with complete examination times running 30 to 60 minutes or longer. This is too long to wait to monitor a patient's level of consciousness. The Joint 8 Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations has recommended a protocol for conscious sedation. To keep within compliance of these guidelines, the MRI facility must have the capability to monitor pulse rate, oxygen saturation, respiration, blood pressure, and electrocardiogram (ECG). MR-compatible monitoring devices come equipped with fiberoptic cables from the equipment to the patient's contact areas, thus preventing skin burns that might result from monitoring equipment used in other areas of the hospital. In addition, the use of monitoring equipment not specifically designed for the MRI environment during image acquisition may result in gross image artifact. Display screens for the measured vital signs must also be designed for this environment to avoid a distorted ECG and other displayed information. MR-compatible anesthesia machines and ventilators are safer and more reliable than standard equipment.9 These are highly recommended for institutions that perform any general anesthesia during MRI.
Safety Safety issues are reviewed in depth in Chapter 24, along with sample screening forms. We will only consider some of the key issues here. There are many potential risks in the MRI environment. The first concern is related to the high magnetic field strengths used in the clinical and research settings. Strong magnetic fields are measured in tesla (T), whereas the unit of measure for a small field is gauss (G). One tesla is equal to 10,000 G. Field strengths of magnets used for clinical purposes vary from 0.2 to 3 T, though systems up to 9.4 T are being used for research purposes in human subjects. Magnetic field strengths of 8 T or less are considered nonsignificant risk by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for anyone over the age of 1 month.10-12 A 1.5 T magnet has more than 45,000 times the Earth's magnetic pull. Attention must be given to keeping all ferromagnetic objects away from the magnet. In general, the force on the object is proportional to the product of magnetic field strength and the gradient of magnetic field strength or, for magnetically saturated ferromagnetic materials, just the gradient of magnetic field strength. This gradient is most severe near the entrance to the magnet bore; therefore, the attraction on a ferromagnetic object may not be noticeable until it is brought relatively close to the magnet. While reducing the extent of the fringe field, magnetic shielding actually increases the gradient in the magnetic field and therefore the potential acceleration of a ferromagnetic object. The risk may be worse for some high-field short-bore systems. Personnel should be educated on the types of objects that are potential threats to patients, visitors, or healthcare workers in the examination room, not to mention potential damage to the system. A variety of sources, including books and web sites, are available to assist in determining if an object poses any risk.13 However, in all cases common sense must be used. All metallic objects should be scrutinized
4 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
carefully regardless of size or location. If a patient has an implant and the hazard potential in the MRI environment is unknown, the technologist should postpone the examination until safety can be confirmed. To determine the safety of a metallic implant, it is best to contact the manufacturer of the device to ascertain if it is safe to scan. Many patients will have ID cards indicating where to call for information regarding the device. A technologist may tie a string to a small implant and suspend it while slowly bringing it toward the bore of the 14 magnet as another method for testing magnetic attraction. If the implant in question is pulled to align with the magnetic field by more than 45° from vertical (i.e., indicating the magnetic attraction is stronger than the pull of gravity), the implant should be considered a contraindication. An implant or other device with wires may also be considered a contraindication, because of the possibility of inducing a current in a wire and causing a burn on a patient. The risk of burns is highest when imaging sequences are used that are RF intensive, such as fast spin-echo (SE). Cardiac pacemakers are generally categorized as a contraindication to MRI. One study found that 17% of patients with pacemakers were denied an MRI study in a one year period. 15 Risks arise from the effects of the magnetic field on pacemaker function, electrical stimulation of the heart, and tissue 16 heating around the pacemaker leads from the RF pulses. Several deaths associated with scanning pacemaker patients have been reported. In one case, an elderly patient died after he failed to tell the technologist that he had a pacemaker, despite being asked twice.15 Nonetheless, hundreds of patients with pacemakers have safely undergone MRI with physician supervision. MRI should only be considered if the risk-benefit ratio justifies the test. In a recent editorial by Martin,17 the following recommendations were made for MRI of patients with pacemakers: (i) Document that a clinically necessary MR study is warranted and obtain informed consent; (ii) maintain SAR levels below 2 W/kg; (iii) have emergency equipment and Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS)-trained personnel readily available; (iv) scan only non-pacemaker-dependent patients; (v) interrogate the pulse generator immediately before and after MRI and reprogram if necessary; (vi) disable the minute ventilation feature; (vii) maintain voice contact throughout the procedure and continuously monitor heart rhythm and rate. Pulse oximetry monitoring is not necessary but can be used concomitantly with rhythm monitoring to provide an additional level of safety; (viii) a physician adept in pacemaker programming needs to be present during the MRI; (ix) sub-threshold output programming is reasonable but has not been shown to be necessary if the above guidelines are followed; (x) scan modern pacemakers (manufactured after 2000). page 61 page 62
The use of transdermal patches to deliver medication is increasing. Several reports have indicated that transdermal patches that contain aluminum foil or a similar metallic component may cause excessive heating or a burn in a patient undergoing an MRI procedure. It is recommended that any patient wearing a transdermal patch that has a metallic component be identified prior to undergoing MRI. The patient's physician should be contacted to determine if it is possible to temporarily remove the medication patch in order to prevent excessive heating. The Institute for Safe Medical Practices recently stated that medication patches such as Androderm, Transderm-Nitro, Deponit, Nicoderm, Nicotrol, Catapres-TTS, and possibly others, should be removed prior to an MRI examination. Other patches to be aware of include the nicotine patch marketed as Habitrol and its "private label" equivalents and hyoscine bromide, marketed as TrasDerm Scop. Not all medication patches contain a 18 metallic component. Accordingly, these patches do not need to be removed for the MRI examination. Medical devices that have moving parts, such as a pump, may malfunction in a strong magnetic field causing potentially serious complications for a patient. Therefore, these devices should be tested for magnetic attraction as well as malfunction in the MRI environment. IV infusion control pumps are commonly used for heparin or other medications that require regulated continual infusion rates. If an MR-compatible pump is not available, the referring physician may opt to disconnect the device for the duration of the MRI examination and arrange for another method of administering the medication to the patient in the interim. Alternatively, the medical team can prepare the pump with a sufficiently long
5 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
piece of extension tubing between the patient and the pump so that the pump mechanism remains outside the examination room. Under these circumstances, the IV tubing is unusually long and the flow rate may decrease. This would also require that the examination room door remain open during image acquisition, thus risking image artifact from outside RF sources. Clearly this is not an ideal approach in producing high-quality images, yet it may suffice in obtaining a diagnosis. It is desirable to have a wave-guide between the examination room and control room, so that the IV tubing can go through the wave-guide without suffering RF interference. The wave-guide can also be used for passage of other items such as tubing for IV sedation, and projector cables for fMRI. Some patients are nonambulatory and require assistance with transportation. If the system does not have a table that can be undocked from the gantry and wheeled out of the MRI room, it may be necessary to purchase an MRI-compatible wheelchair and stretcher so patients can enter the magnetic field without risk of injury. In addition, the facility should be equipped with nonferrous IV poles for patients requiring IV fluids. Many equipment suppliers now provide medical equipment specifically designed for the MRI environment. Attention should also be given to the arrangement of the MRI scanner in relationship to the scan console. It is best for a technologist to have visual contact with a patient in the bore of the magnet to detect more easily if a patient is in distress or in need of assistance. One scenario for seeing into the bore is by direct viewing through a window between the control room and the examination room. Another way to see a patient in the bore is through a video camera at one end of the magnet bore with an image display located at the scan console. Also, a patient should be given a call button device to contact a healthcare worker at any time during the scan. This provides a method of communication for a patient who is not able to communicate verbally. All patients may use this as an emergency call button, if claustrophobic, anxious, or in pain. Another concern arises with regard to the cryogens used to cool the superconducting magnets. These systems use liquid helium and possibly liquid nitrogen. During the catastrophic event known as a quench, these supercooled liquids vaporize nearly instantaneously. When a quench occurs, it is usually unmistakable. The cryogen burn-off rate is so rapid that a loud rumbling sound is heard, similar to thunder. The room air pressure may increase rapidly as well if the quench vent is not properly designed to handle a large output of gases. Therefore, it could be difficult to open the examination room door. Technologists should be aware of the potential hazard of a magnet quench or the possibility of a leaking dewar when the magnet cryostat is being refilled during routine maintenance. In both situations, these gases replace oxygen and can cause a brisk decline of oxygen levels in the room. Patients, healthcare workers, or service personnel in the room may lose consciousness rapidly and unexpectedly.19 Therefore, the scan room should be equipped with sensors to measure oxygen levels, with an alarm display panel outside of the scan room accessible to maintenance staff. Because helium rises when released into room air, one sensor should be placed high on a wall. If the superconducting magnet also uses nitrogen, a second sensor should be placed lower on a wall, because the cooled nitrogen is heavier than room air and will fall. In the event of a quench, the MRI examination room should be vacated of all patients and employees as quickly as possible, and the room should be securely closed until sufficient time has passed to allow the oxygen levels to return to normal. Room air normally contains approximately 20% oxygen. MRI facilities should have protocols established as a framework for the MRI team to respond quickly and skillfully in emergency situations such as a quench. Other crisis situations include medical emergencies. These situations present additional challenges to staff because most items of equipment used elsewhere in the hospital for emergency medical care, such as stethoscopes, Kelly clamps, laryngoscopes, and non-MRI-compatible oxygen tanks become harmful projectiles when introduced into high magnetic fields. It has been reported that a 6-year-old boy was killed during a routine MRI procedure when the powerful magnetic field accelerated a non-MRI-compatible oxygen tank into the center of the magnet bore, crushing the child's head.20,21 Other equipment, such as defibrillators and non-MRI-compatible ECG recorders, may malfunction in a
6 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
magnetic field. In the event of a medical emergency, the safest environment for implementation of resuscitation or treatment of unexpected medical complications is outside the 5-G line. The MRI receptionist should place a call to a code team or emergency medical technician for assistance. Each healthcare team member in MRI should be trained in basic cardiac life support or advanced cardiac life support so that resuscitation may begin while a patient is being transported away from the potentially harmful fringe field of the magnet. The patient should be transported immediately from the MRI examination room to an area furnished with all necessary emergency supplies and equipment. This may be in the preparation room or immediately outside the MRI examination room. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation should continue until the specially trained team summoned for this event responds. page 62 page 63
Another potential emergency situation may occur if a large ferromagnetic object is brought into an MRI examination room. If the object were brought close to the magnetic field, it would quite likely become a projectile mass and move rapidly toward the magnet, striking any person or object in its path. It may also become bound to the magnet with a person or object pinned between the two. If an object is pinned to the magnet and cannot safely be removed while the main magnetic field is active, a technologist may need to call a service technician to ramp down the magnetic field. This can be performed safely under controlled supervision. However, if a person is constrained by the object to the magnet, there is a need for rapid response on the part of the MRI team to free the individual and call for emergency medical care due to the trauma likely incurred by the victim. The fastest action would be to quench the magnet, although this may cost tens of thousands of dollars worth of cryogens (all MRI systems have an emergency quench button, and all MRI personnel should know its location), and remove the victim immediately. This is an extremely dangerous circumstance. Precautions should be strictly enforced and measures taken seriously by all MRI staff to avoid accidents.
MR Safety for Pregnant Patients and Technical Staff MRI is believed to be a safe imaging modality because there is no ionizing radiation as is used in general radiology or computed tomography. However, it is a relatively new method, which means that long-term effects are yet to be determined. There are two populations to consider: the pregnant patient and the pregnant healthcare provider. A patient and a healthcare worker have different exposures to different factors in the MRI environment. The patient is placed in the center of the bore of the magnet for approximately 45 minutes. She may also be given IV contrast medium. The potential risks a patient faces are from the static magnetic field, changing electromagnetic fields, RF, and contrast agents. The patient's exposure is usually a one-time occurrence during a pregnancy, whereas a healthcare worker is constantly exposed to the static magnetic field. It is difficult to determine what effects MRI may have on a pregnant woman and her fetus for several reasons. First, the spontaneous abortion rate in the normal pregnant population is approximately 30% during the first trimester. The population of pregnant patients and healthcare providers exposed to MRI is small. A survey of women of childbearing years working in the MRI environment was conducted in 1990.22 The results show no statistically significant variations in reproductive health or menstrual cycles of the respondents compared with the general population. Facilities differ on a policy of restriction of work responsibilities for the pregnant healthcare provider. It has been suggested by Kanal and colleagues in the aforementioned study that activities should be the same for all employees. The pregnant healthcare workers may perform examinations, which include entering the MRI examination room in the absence of scanning and attending to the patient's needs, without concern of harmful effects. Because there is no conclusive evidence that undergoing MRI is completely safe, it is wise to act conservatively in scanning a pregnant patient. Before performing an examination on a pregnant patient, a discussion should take place between a referring physician and a diagnosing radiologist to determine the effect the results would have on treatment of the patient and if MRI is the best modality for the clinical indications. Also, the patient should be made aware that, to date, there has been no
7 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
indication that the use of clinical MR imaging during pregnancy has produced deleterious effects. However, as noted by the FDA, the safety of MRI during pregnancy has not been proved.23
Scheduling Studies are typically scheduled into time slots of between 20 minutes and 1 hour, depending on the complexity of the study and capabilities of the MR system. Certain examinations, such as pediatric sedation and fMRI studies, may require even more time. Once the study is requested, the MRI staff efficiently schedules the study, ensures the appropriateness of the requested examination, and obtains key information about the patient. The scheduler or receptionist staff begins the process by obtaining and validating a significant amount of information from the clinician's office, such as clinical history and reason for examination. If the scheduler is not sure what examination is being requested, he or she should have the ability to ask either the technologist or the radiologist for assistance. This will help avoid problems at the time of the patient's appointment. The demographic and insurance information may be completely or partially procured from the referring clinician's office or from the patient. Either at the time of the initial appointment or when confirming the appointment time with a patient, staff should interview patients briefly for a prescreening of metallic implants, pacemakers, or other electronic implants, claustrophobia, allergies, and whether a patient needs special assistance. Staff may also give some information to a patient about the length of the visit, how a patient should dress (e.g., no jewelry or eye make-up), bringing family members, or directions to the facility. This is a good opportunity for a patient to ask questions on topics that may have been causing some anxiety. A knowledgeable and skilled receptionist will be able to allay some fears a patient may have or have the patient talk to a technologist or nurse for technical questions or questions regarding oral and IV sedation. Some sites may offer sedation, in which case it must be scheduled ahead of time and a nurse should contact the patient to set up the specifics. At most sites where sedation is not offered, it is up to the patient to speak to the ordering physician to prescribe oral medication that they can bring to the examination with them. This should also be mentioned at the time of scheduling so that the scheduler can tell the patient to arrive at least 45 minutes early to take their medication and bring someone with them to take them home. Also, if a patient requires special assistance in ambulating, the appointment time should coincide with adequate staffing. page 63 page 64
It is quite costly to a facility to have an open time slot if a patient does not arrive for an appointment. Because there is seldom advance notice, it is nearly impossible to arrange for another patient to come in for the opening. Therefore, a receptionist or scheduler should call all patients scheduled for the MRI examination approximately 2 days in advance to confirm the appointment date and time. Speaking to a patient directly helps to reduce any potential "no-shows." After the examination is scheduled, the radiologist reviews the indications for the request and decides on a scanning protocol. The team determines if the examination is scheduled appropriately based on such factors as the time of day, available staff, and the length of the examination. Most scheduled examinations will require few alterations when handled by experienced personnel. Applications for MRI are becoming more complex, and certain examinations require detailed clinical information for the MRI team to plan properly for the scanning protocol. Continuous flow of communication among all team members is essential. An adequately prepared team reduces the chance of unanticipated problems, allowing for smooth execution of the examination.
Staffing Technical staffing needs vary from site to site. Factors such as hospital-based versus outpatient center and the type and volume of referrals received help to determine the number of imaging technologists required for various shifts. A hospital-based facility will refer more inpatients, thereby increasing the nonambulatory population and patients requiring more medical attention. In a busy hospital setting it is beneficial to have dedicated nursing assistance. Some of the advantages include improved care of patients by having a nurse monitor vital signs as needed; ability to administer sedation to a claustrophobic or physically distressed patient; and ability to start an IV line when technologists are not
8 of 9
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003001
9 of 9
trained to do so. It is a facility's obligation to provide an inpatient with the same level of care that would normally be received in the inpatient unit. A patient's needs should be met not only during the MRI examination but also before and after the examination while in the department. With these responsibilities removed, the technologist is able to focus on performing the examination in an organized fashion, quickly, and precisely. This is helpful not only for throughput but also for comfort and safety of patients, particularly when a patient's condition is unstable. Regardless of the facility siting, most MRI centers perform more technically challenging examinations during the weekday, while a radiologist is available to monitor the examination. These examinations usually require more involved protocols for preparation of patients. For example, to perform a study of the pelvis or prostate, a radiologist may request that glucagon be prepared for an intramuscular injection. Many examinations require contrast medium administration; therefore, it may be beneficial to have an IV line in place before the examination commences. Abdominal and thoracic cavity imaging usually requires breath-holding by patients. The radiologist may also wish to examine the patient and possibly place a marker over an area of point tenderness or palpable mass. Other examinations may require the use of ECG leads for gated acquisitions, and still other examinations may require unusual positioning of the patient and coil. Each of these steps takes time to execute properly. The MRI examination and all of the previously mentioned steps must be explained to the patient. When scanning has concluded, the technologist may have image processing, transfer to archive and/or a picture archiving and communication system (PACS), and filming yet to complete. Some of this may begin while the scan is active, but for many monitored examinations a second technologist is required to accomplish this task. During a typical weekday shift at a busy MRI center, many other responsibilities and duties arise, as this is the time of day when referring physicians' offices and other services are open and fully staffed. This time may become easily filled with a wide variety of tasks, such as filming requests for referring physicians; 3D reconstructions; testing new scanning protocols; assisting in scheduling of future or emergent examinations; and speaking to patients or referring physicians about examination-related questions. Therefore, two or three technologists should be available to manage a fully scheduled MRI system on a weekday shift. Facilities that have two MRI systems within proximity to each other may require five technologists between the two systems. Technical staffing for evening, night, and weekend shifts will vary. The majority of the examinations performed on these shifts are unmonitored by a physician, resulting in more straightforward examination protocols. Because examination length is more predictable during these time periods, appointment times may be scheduled with more regularity and closer together, thereby increasing examination throughput. However, because the technical staff is always responsible for final screening of the patient for contraindications and for explaining the procedure as well as for filming, image processing, and image archival, if increased examination throughput is expected, then technical staffing should be maintained at a level of two technologists per shift. One technologist working alone will not likely be able to perform more than one routine outpatient examination per hour. Provision should be made on all shifts for the likely possibility of urgent or emergent add-on examinations to the daily schedule of patients. Openings throughout the day may also be used as a buffer for times when the actual schedule is delayed compared with the planned schedule. This may happen for a variety of reasons, such as when a patient arrives late for an appointment; a patient unexpectedly experiences a claustrophobic or anxiety attack; or a monitored examination requires additional series of images for diagnosis.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:43
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003009
PREPARING A PATIENT FOR MRI
Screening the Patient page 64 page 65
When a patient arrives for the scheduled MRI examination, a receptionist should instruct the patient to complete a detailed screening checklist. The checklist is designed specifically for detecting potentially dangerous ferromagnetic implants or objects outside the body that could also be considered potentially harmful to the patient or anyone else in the area. This checklist should also screen for metallic objects that may degrade image quality, such as dentures or braces. Women of childbearing age should be asked if they are pregnant. It is necessary to document the screening process to ensure consistency in quality of care. Before bringing the patient into the fringe field, a technologist should carefully review the completed checklist and obtain verbal confirmation directly from the patient as well. Repetition in questioning the patient is often necessary because a patient may have either skimmed through the forms or misunderstood a specific question. Literature has shown that incomplete or incorrect information has resulted in serious consequences for the patient and staff.24,25 Reception staff also needs to receive visitors and non-MRI healthcare workers and possibly direct them into areas near the magnetic field. For this reason reception staff needs to be well versed on the MRI environment and areas to avoid physical harm or equipment damage. The screening should also ask for a patient's weight. This is needed for several reasons. First, all MRI systems have a weight limit defined by the manufacturer for each model to avoid damage to the mechanics that move the patient table. Second, when a patient is exposed to RF, the body tissue is prone to warming. The patient's weight determines the allowable RF deposition and must be entered accurately into the MR system at the beginning of the examination. Third, contrast material dosage is based on bodyweight, as recommended by the manufacturer. For a cardiac examination, a patient's height is also needed for calculation of ventricular function.
Education of the Patient As with any medical procedure, providing the patient with information about the examination is essential. In doing so, the healthcare provider must address the patient's needs and anxieties. According to Devine and Cook26,27 three psychoeducational interventional domains should be addressed: procedural, sensory, and psychosocial. The healthcare provider must be knowledgeable in the subject matter to inform the patient with clear and concise communication. Addressing the procedural aspect of education of patients entails informing a patient what the procedure is, why it is being performed, and that the examination is not painful. Technical staff should educate a patient about what is required of the patient, such as the specific positioning required for an examination. In some examinations, as in abdominal imaging, a patient may also need to follow breath-hold instructions, preferably explained before the patient is placed into the bore. A patient should also know that the technologist will be in constant communication, giving information on scan lengths and periodic verification of the patient's comfort. The sensory aspect of educating the patient includes information on the physical environment of the machine and the bore size. Some patients consider it confining. Additional sensory information should include the noise associated with the scanning and that it may be considered annoying. Also, a patient should be aware of the expected duration of the procedure. 28
Studies have shown that patients may experience high levels of anxiety while undergoing MRI. The technologist should ascertain specific concerns, using open-ended questions to address the sensory and psychosocial aspects. It may be necessary to use prompts when trying to determine the source of the anxiety. Adverse psychologic reactions to MRI are often lumped together as claustrophobia. However, research has shown that anxiety may also result from other factors.29 A patient may be concerned about the pending diagnosis and the availability of the results. In addition to physical discomfort, noise from the scanner may induce emotional distress. Another common factor may be
1 of 4
11-04-2010 23:45
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003009
that a patient feels a lack of control. A patient may have already experienced significant testing or other medical procedures and may be overwhelmed by yet another test about which he or she knows little. The MRI environment may be even more distressing owing to a feeling of confinement and restrictiveness. Once the patient's concerns are discovered, they must be addressed before the patient can reliably comply with the requirements of the procedure. The technologist should direct efforts to a patient's physical and emotional comfort by asking for suggestions from the patient. The technologist may further assist the patient in alleviating anxieties by using methods described in the section on claustrophobia. Employing psychological methods in addition to education has shown a reduction in anxiety levels, compared with giving procedural information only.30 Once a patient's physical and psychological needs are satisfied, the healthcare provider may focus on performing the MRI. When the patient is in the examination room, certain important information and instructions should be reviewed with the patient for reinforcement. Examples include the importance of remaining motionless during image acquisition; methods of communication available to the patient to reach the technologist; reassurance of the technologist's immediate availability; expected examination duration; and, when applicable, a review of breath-hold instructions with a practice session. In short, both the technologist and patient benefit when the healthcare worker enlists proactive methods in preparation for the MRI examination.
Physical Preparation of the Patient page 65 page 66
Patients should be asked to change from their personal clothing into a gown and robe. Patients who are allowed to wear personal clothing during a scan have been known to harbor ferromagnetic objects in the examination room. Attempts to remove the object free it from restraint, and it then becomes a projectile mass. This is not only a threat to the physical safety of patients and staff but also a means of potential damage to the MRI scanner. A ferromagnetic object could hide in the magnet and may go undetected for a time, resulting in image degradation. Additionally, bra straps commonly contain metal hooks that cause severe artifacts and also may interfere with proper shimming. If a protocol includes IV contrast medium administration, a technologist, nurse, or physician should consider establishing IV access before the examination while the patient is in a preparation room. By starting the IV line in advance, some potential problems may be avoided. For instance, starting an IV line can be time-consuming, depending on the condition of a patient's peripheral veins. It places additional emotional and physical stress on a patient who may already be experiencing some duress. Another potential problem occurs when a patient is taken out of the bore to obtain IV access, potentially decreasing the likelihood of obtaining images at the same anatomic location before and after contrast medium administration. Last, if a healthcare provider, such as an IV nurse, attempting to gain IV access is not familiar with the MRI environment, additional delays and potential safety issues may arise. Before starting the scan, several details should be considered. A marker may be used to aid in 31,32 definition of a mass or as a reference point in relation to anatomic structures. The best materials to use for a marker in MRI are those that have a bright signal on a T1-weighted sequence. Because fat appears bright on a T1-weighted scan, many markers are made of a substance that contains animal or vegetable oil. Some examples are cod liver oil, soybean oil, and various nonroasted nuts (e.g., almonds). Vitamin E capsules are also used. It is helpful to use more than one marker. Placing two or three markers side by side may save scanning time because acquired images often have an interslice gap and may not well visualize a single marker. When the structures in the abdomen and pelvis are imaged, motion of the small intestine can be a significant detractor in image quality. It may be reasonable for the radiologist to give a patient an intramuscular injection of glucagon (1 mg) to slow peristalsis, thereby reducing motion artifact. Alternatively, glucagon may be given IV shortly before the most critical images are acquired, because
2 of 4
11-04-2010 23:45
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003009
3 of 4
the effects of an intramuscular injection given before initial positioning of the patient might not last for a sufficiently long time. Contraindications include patients with a known hypersensitivity to glucagon or history of pheochromocytoma or insulinoma.33 Healthcare workers should exercise caution if a patient has a medical history of diabetes. Some patients have experienced a short duration of slight nausea up to 6 hours after completion of the examination. The patient should be informed of this so as not to be alarmed. If the nausea continues, the patient should contact his or her referring physician or the radiologist supervising the MRI examination.
Claustrophobia Due to the structure of the MRI machine, claustrophobic reactions severe enough to cancel or postpone the study occur in approximately 5% of patients.34,35 Of the patients attempting to undergo a scan, as many as 65% experience some level of anxiety or discomfort. Some manufacturers have designed systems that have a magnet architecture that is shorter or more open. These systems are less threatening for those affected with mild claustrophobia. page 66 page 67
Some suggestions for the MRI technologist to assist claustrophobic or anxious patients through an MRI examination are listed here: 1. Reassure patients that they will not be kept in the machine against their will. The greatest fear patients may have is a feeling of loss of control.36 2. Maintain close, two-way verbal contact with patients throughout the examination, so they do not feel abandoned. 3. Give patients a device that allows them to establish contact at any time, such as a panic button. 4. Whenever possible, try to have patients enter the bore of the magnet feet first, thus giving them the sensation of being farther out of the magnet. 5. Offer the patients a pair of prism glasses, which may be used to look out of the machine through a reflection in the prism. 6. Give patients a blindfold to cover the eyes so they are less aware of the environment. 7. Guide patients through relaxation techniques such as deep breathing exercises immediately 37 before the scan or guided imagery before and during the scan. 8. Give patients either headphones designed specifically for use in the MRI system to play relaxing music or earplugs to reduce the noise level they encounter during imaging. 9. Ask a family member to accompany the patient through the examination, touching and talking to the patient as permitted through the constraints of examination execution. Patients usually find it reassuring to have physical contact with the environment outside of the "tube" of the magnet. 10. Provide good ventilation to patients while in the bore of the magnet. 11. Advise patients to try to "condition" themselves to the MRI environment by resting in a quiet environment at home and practice lying down with a large box over their head for a few minutes at a time. For obese or physically extra large patients, claustrophobia reaction happens even more often. This is because the feeling of confinement and restrictiveness is more serious for them than for average-sized patients. For these patients, in addition to the suggestions listed above, some other means may need to apply. Increasing the space for the patient in the magnet can be obtained by changing the table cushion to a thinner one (e.g., a blanket) or the type of the coil (e.g., torso coil to body coil) when it is acceptable for the type of the study being performed. Asking patients to place arms over the head rather than rest them at the sides is also helpful. Although the amount of space increase with these methods is limited, it can be a key to successfully performing the study. Sometimes applying a body position different from routine use but more comfortable for the patient can help patients stay longer in the magnet. In body imaging, for instance, patients with a protuberant abdomen may feel more comfortable in the lateral position than the routinely used supine position, because patients in lateral position often feel less pressure to their chest so that it is easier to breathe. Providing 2 to 3 L/min of 100% oxygen will reduce the feeling of breathing difficulty, and help patients hold their breath longer. A technologist should acquire the most critical pulse sequences at the beginning of the examination in
11-04-2010 23:45
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003009
4 of 4
case the patient cannot tolerate the full study. If these techniques fail, the patient may need oral or IV sedation.
Sedation A patient could receive sedation for several reasons including: 1. prior history of uncompensated claustrophobia when undergoing MRI; 2. previous reaction of claustrophobia in unrelated situations (e.g., cannot enter an elevator); 3. acute or chronic pain rendering proper positioning intolerable for the duration of the procedure; 4. infant and pediatric patients; and 5. mental incapacitation. Oral sedation is usually given for mild claustrophobia. The referring physician usually prescribes oral medication for a claustrophobic patient. Instructions may be given to the patient about when to take a prescribed oral sedative by either the prescribing physician or a pharmacist. Arrival time of the patient and the actual examination time do not necessarily coincide, owing to examination-related paperwork, removal of worn metallic objects, obtaining IV access for contrast medium administration, or a pre-procedure interview with the radiologist for examination-related medical history. Therefore, the MRI staff may wish to advise the patient on the timing of ingestion of the prescribed oral medication. It is important for the patient to bring a responsible adult with them to drive them home after the procedure. IV sedation may be arranged for a severely claustrophobic or anxious patient. If IV sedation is planned, it is necessary to obtain a more extensive medical history for a history of respiratory problems. It is also necessary to monitor a patient's vital signs during the MRI examination. Due to the strong magnetic field, MRI-compatible equipment is needed to carry out the monitoring. When IV sedation is needed, the examination should be scheduled with a nurse or physician who can administer IV sedation and monitor a patient's response. A patient's vital signs should be recorded before the administration of IV sedatives for a baseline comparison. Vital signs should be continually monitored throughout the procedure and for a period after the examination is completed, ensuring vital signs have returned to baseline. This may take 2 to 3 hours. A patient scheduled for IV sedation should be instructed not to eat for 8 hours before the examination, and a responsible adult should accompany a patient to the procedure and drive the patient home after being released. The effects of the medication may inhibit motor skills for several hours after the sedation has been given. Therefore, a healthcare worker should advise the patient that it is unsafe for the patient to drive or go home alone.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:45
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
1 of 22
SELECTING AN IMAGING PROTOCOL
Outline of Relevant Imaging Principles Several steps are involved in the production of an MR image. Each one relates to the choice of the hardware and software used during the imaging procedure. The technologist will need to choose the most appropriate RF coil; select a pulse sequence; set the imaging parameters such as TR, TE, flip angle (for GRE sequences), sampling bandwidth, echo train length and echo spacing (for fast SE sequences); geometric factors such as slice thickness, matrix size, field-of-view, and orientation of the phase- or frequency-encoding gradient; along with a variety of other imaging options such as ECG gating, partial Fourier, parallel imaging, phase oversampling, and image filtering. page 67 page 68
We will briefly outline how the underlying MR physics relate to the work done by the technologist in preparing the patient and optimizing the data acquisition, and then go into more specific details for the remainder of the chapter. 1. Randomly oriented tissue nuclei are aligned by a powerful, uniform magnetic field, producing equilibrium "magnetization" of the tissue. The magnetic axes of the tissue protons align with the main magnetic field within a few seconds after the patient is placed within the magnet bore. By the time the imaging procedure starts, the tissue spins are fully equilibrated. 2. Properly tuned RF pulses then disrupt the magnetization. As the nuclei recover ("relax") to equilibrium after the application of the RF pulses, they produce RF signals that are proportional to the magnitude of the initial alignment. Tissue contrast (i.e., differences in signal) develops as a result of the different rates at which nuclei relax with the magnetic field. The technologist chooses a pulse sequence in order to generate measurable MRI signals from the region of interest. The pulse sequence is repeated at an interval equal to the repetition time (TR), which largely determines the amount of T1 weighting. The choice of pulse sequence helps to ensure that one obtains appropriate tissue contrast (i.e., differences in tissue signal intensity, which permit tissue characterization and lesion detection). Typical pulse sequences include T1-weighted gradient-echo (GRE), T2-weighted fast spin-echo (SE), and diffusion-sensitive echo-planar imaging (EPI). Additionally, the tissue signals may be enhanced by the administration of a paramagnetic contrast agent. 3. Positions of the nuclei emitting the MR signals are localized during this process by purposely distorting the magnetic field with spatially dependent magnetic fields, called gradients. The gradients encode spatial information into the amplitudes, frequencies, and phases of the MR signals. As addressed in Chapter 2, the magnetic field gradients are the main mechanism for spatial localization. The area under the gradient waveform determines spatial resolution. Generally speaking, the technologist does not directly choose the gradient amplitude (measured in milliTesla/meter) and slew rate (rate of change in gradient amplitude from zero to maximum or vice versa, measured in milliTesla/meter/millisecond or tesla/meter/second). Instead, the amplitude and slew rate are automatically determined from parameters set by the technologist including the pulse sequence, slice thickness, field-of-view, matrix, and sampling bandwidth. Of note, some MR systems permit the use of stronger and faster gradients in a special "research" mode, as compared with the standard clinical mode. In systems with "twin" gradients or insert gradient coils, the gradient capabilities also depend on which gradient mode is selected. 4. MR signals are measured, or read out, after a user-determined time has elapsed from the initial RF excitation. The computer transforms the signal into an image using a mathematical process called the Fourier transform (FT). The time between the RF excitation of the tissue protons and signal readout is the echo time (TE). Echo time largely determines the amount of T2 contrast in the image. In reality, the MR signal is not read out instantaneously, but rather over a period of time lasting at least a few milliseconds. To be precise, the TE is actually the time between the center of the RF excitation and the point at which the signal intensity is maximal. This time point may occur at the middle of the sampling period, in which case the echo is said to be symmetrical or "full" (generally used for SE and balanced steady-state free precession [SSFP] sequences). Alternatively, the echo may deliberately be shifted to occur earlier in the sampling period, in which case the echo is said to be asymmetric or "partial" (often used with MR angiography to minimize flow-related artifacts). The readout period over which the MR signal is measured, along with the desired in-plane spatial resolution, determines the sampling bandwidth. The bandwidth is given in hertz (cycles per second, abbreviated as Hz) or hertz/pixel and is inversely related to the duration of the readout period. In some circumstances, the use of a lower (or equivalently narrower) bandwidth improves image quality, since the SNR is inversely proportional to the square root of the sampling bandwidth. There are drawbacks to the use of lower
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
2 of 22
bandwidths, such as certain artifacts, that will be considered later on.
Selecting a Pulse Sequence The clinical chapters in this text address the specific imaging protocols for each organ system. In this section, we will now consider the general principles underlying the choice of imaging technique and parameters. The basic structure of a pulse sequence consists of RF pulses used to tip the magnetization and generate a signal, and gradients used to spatially localize the signal. As reviewed in Chapter 5, pulse sequences do not measure the free induction decay (FID) that is produced immediately after an RF pulse; instead they produce and measure an "echo" called a gradient-echo or gradient-recalled echo (GRE) or spin-echo (SE) depending on the type of pulse sequence. This echo signal decays away like T2* for GRE, and like T2 for SE. Commonly, additional RF pulses are applied before the standard pulse sequences in order to alter the longitudinal magnetization of the tissue protons and hence image contrast; this process is called "magnetization preparation." For example, a 180° preparation is used for inversion recovery (IR) sequences. Other clinically relevant types of magnetization preparation include chemical shift-selective fat suppression, spatial presaturation, and magnetization transfer. A multitude of pulse sequences and magnetization preparations are available on MR scanners. A summary of the acronyms for various imaging techniques and vendors is given in Table 3-1. In selecting the most appropriate imaging techniques, the technologist and radiologist or other imaging specialists need to consider the anatomy of interest, desired tissue contrast, and level of spatial and temporal resolution. For instance, echo-planar is appropriate for diffusion-weighted imaging of the brain, but would not be appropriate for imaging of the knee or abdomen because of its sensitivity to susceptibility artifact and poor spatial resolution. A fast SE sequence would be ideal for brain imaging, but would be too slow and have inappropriate contrast for MR angiography.
Spin-Echo Spin-echo imaging used to be the "bread and butter" of pulse sequences, but has since been largely supplanted by faster GRE and fast SE sequences. In its most basic form and as elaborated in Chapters 2 and 5, the SE pulse sequence consists of two RF pulses, 90° and 180°, separated in time by equal intervals of TE/2: The 90° RF pulse tips the longitudinal magnetization into the transverse plane. The 180° RF pulse refocuses the transverse magnetization so that dephasing effects resulting from static magnetic field inhomogeneities, caused by the magnet or local differences in magnetic susceptibility, are canceled when the echo peaks at time TE. As a result, an image acquired with long TR and long TE is T2 weighted rather than T2* weighted. Spin-echo scans are usually acquired as sets of 2D slices. The maximal number of slices that can be acquired practically depends on several variables and can be summarized by where ∆ is a factor that is related to the pulse sequence structure and performance constraints of the gradients, RF, and measurement systems. For a given TR, more slices can be acquired if TE is short rather than long and if a higher sampling bandwidth is applied. page 68 page 69
Table 3-1. Acronyms for Pulse Sequences and Options Used by the Various Manufacturers* A. Pulse Sequences Sequence GE Spin-echo
Philips
MEMP,VEMP Spin-Echo
Siemens
Picker
Elscint
Hitachi
Shima
Spin-Echo
Spin-Echo
Spin-E
Spin-Echo
Spin-Echo
Fast spin-echo FSE
TSE
TSE
FSE
Single-shot technique
SSFSE
Single Shot TSE
HASTE
EXPRESS
Coherent gradient-echo
GRASS, GRE, FFE FGR, FMPGR
Incoherent gradient-echo (RF spoiled)
SPGR, FSPGR
T1 FFE
FISP, ROAST FAST RF spoiled FAST
FSE
F SHORT
GFEC
SSFP
GE/GFE
STAG T1W
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
3 of 22
Incoherent gradient-echo (gradient spoiled)
MPGR
FLASH
T1-FAST, NOSE
SHORT
GRE
STAG
Contrastenhanced gradient-echo sequence
SSFP, DE FGR
T2 FFE
PSIF
CE FAST, FADE
E SHORT
GFEC Contrast
STER
Balanced coherent gradient-echo
FIESTA, SSFP
Balanced-FFE True FISP
SARGE, BASG
STER
Ultrafast gradient-echo
TFE FAST, GRASS, SPGR (IR/DE prep), IR FGR
Turbo FLASH, RAM FAST 3D MP RAGE
Gradient and spin-echo
GRACE
GRACE
GSE
GSE
Inversion recovery
MPIR,TIR
IR, IR-TSE, IR-TFE
IR,TIR
Short T1 inversion recovery
STIR
STIR
V-SHORT, RS, SPGR, Turbo-SHORT FAST SPGR
SMAS
IR
IR
IR
IR
STIR
STIR
STIR
STIR
STIR
Phase Contrast
Phase Contrast
VENC
ASSET
SENSE
IPAT
Sequence
GE
Philips
Siemens
Picker
Signal averaging
NEX
NSA
AC
NSA
Partial averaging
Fractional NEX Half Scan
Half Fourier
Phase Conjugate Symmetry
Single Side Encoding
Half Fourier
Partial echo
Fractional Echo
Partial
Echo
Asymmetric Echo
Read Conjugate Symmetry
Single Side View
Rectangular field-of-view
RFOV
RFOV
HFI
HFI (under sampling)
RFOV
RFOV
Off-center shifting slices
Off Center FOV
Off Center Shift
Shift, Offset
FOV Offset
Off Center FOV
Spacing Spacing between slices
Slice Gap
Distance Factor in %
Gap
Slice Interval
Presaturation
REST
SAT
PRE-SAT
Phase-contrast Phase sequence Contrast Parallel imaging technique
VENC
B. Options
Spatial SAT
Fat saturation FAT SAT, CHEM SAT
SPIR, SPAIR, FAT SAT WaterSEL
FAT SAT
Elscint
Hitachi
Shim
NSA
Spatial PRE-SAT
Half E
SAT
SAT
FAT SAT
Moving saturation pulse
Walking SAT
Travel REST
Travel SAT
Walking PSAT
Gradient moment rephasing
FC
FC
GMR
MAST
STILL
GR
Respiratory Gated
Respiratory Gating, PRIZE
FREEZE
Phase Reordering, MAR
PEAR, Respiratory Respiratory compensation Compensation, Respiratory Trigger Respiratory
SMAR
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
4 of 22
Triggering ECG Cardiac synchronization Gated, Triggering
ECG Triggered
Delay after R wave
Trigger Delay Trigger Delay Trigger Window
Trigger Delay
ECG Triggered
Automatic Smart Prep bolus detection
Bolus Track
Care Bolus
Number of echoes
TSE TF
ETL, Turbo Factor
ETL
ECG
ECG
ECG, FPG Gated
ECG
Delay Time
ETL
ETL
Time between Echo Spacing Echo Spacing Echo Spacing IES echoes
Echo Train Internal
Oversampling in frequency direction
Always On
Always On
Over-sampling Anti Aliasing
Anti Aliasing
Frequency Over-sampling
Oversampling in phase direction
No Phase Wrap
Fold Over Suppression
Over-sampling Over-sampling Anti Aliasing
Anti Wrap
Bandwidth
Received Bandwidth
Water/Fat Shift
Bandwidth
BW
Bandwidth
Variable bandwidth
VB
Optimized Water/Fat Shift
Optimized Bandwidth
Variable BW
Variable BW
Segmented k-space data acquisition
Views per Segment
Views, Segments
Lines, Segments
PG
Multislice imaging
Multi Slice
Multiple Slice Multi Slice
2D
3D Imaging
3D
3D
3D Volume
3D
Orientation scan
Localizer
Plan Scan, Survey
Localizer, Scout
Scout
2D 3D
3D
3D
Scanogram page 70 page 71
*Adapted with permission from the Magnetic Resonance-Technology Information Portal.
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
5 of 22
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-3 Spin-echo images acquired at 1.0 T in a patient with periventricular multiple sclerosis plaques. A, TR/TE = 2500/30. B, TR/TE = 2500/80. Note that the plaques appear brighter than cerebrospinal fluid on the proton density-weighted image but are seen less clearly on the T2-weighted image because of isointensity with cerebrospinal fluid.
In an SE pulse sequence, additional 180° RF pulses can be used to generate multiple echoes, with little or no increase in scanning time. Commonly, two echoes are acquired resulting in proton density (early echo) and
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
6 of 22
T2-weighted (late echo) images. For example, a tissue such as liver, which appears moderately bright with an early echo but dark with later echoes, can be inferred to have a short T2. Conversely, a tissue such as cerebrospinal fluid, which appears bright with late as well as early echoes, must have a long T2. Images obtained with a long TE can help discriminate, for instance, cystic from solid components of a tumor. On the other hand, the bright signal from cerebrospinal fluid on a long TE image may obscure lesions near the ventricles, which are better shown on proton density-weighted (Fig. 3-3) or FLAIR images. The appearance of various tissues with T1- and T2-weighted pulse sequences is summarized in Table 3-2. On T1-weighted images, tissues with short T1, such as fat, appear bright, whereas tissues with long T1, such as tumor and edema, appear dark. On T2-weighted images, tissues with long T2, such as tumor, edema, and cyst, appear bright, whereas tissues with short T2, such as muscle, tendon, and liver, appear dark. On proton densityweighted images, tissues with increased proton density such as CSF appear moderately bright. Both T1- and T2-weighted images are always partly weighted toward proton density as well, although the weighting is usually subtle compared with the weighting toward relaxation time. page 71 page 72
Spin-echo images have contrast that is manipulated primarily through adjusting TR and TE (Fig. 3-4) as follows: 1. Images acquired with short TR (TR approximates to T1) and short TE (TE is much less than T2) are T1 weighted (Fig. 3-5A). 2. Images acquired with long TR (TR is much greater than T1) and short TE (TE is less than T2) are proton density weighted or balanced (Fig. 3-5B). 3. Images acquired with long TR and long TE (TE approximates to T2) are T2 weighted (Fig. 3-5C). To produce a T1-weighted image with a SE sequence, the TR typically ranges between 300 and 800 ms (Fig. 3-6) and the TE ranges between 5 and 40 ms. Because the TR is one of the factors determining scan time, the technologist should try to minimize the TR as much as possible within the constraints of having to accommodate an adequate number of slices to span the region of interest. If an insufficient number of slices can be obtained within the TR, one can attempt to use a slightly longer TR or fewer slices. Alternatively, one can use a higher sampling bandwidth and shorter TE, which will allow more slices. As a last resort, one can simply concatenate a second measurement for the remaining slices but at the expense of additional scan time.
Table 3-2. Appearances of Tissue on MR Images Tissue
T1-Weighted Image
T2-Weighted Image
Fat*
Very bright
Intermediate to dark
Watery fluid
Very dark
Very bright
Proteinaceous fluid
Intermediate to bright
Very bright
Bright
Dark
Cysts
Brain White matter Gray matter
Dark
Bright
Cerebrospinal fluid
Very dark
Very bright
Yellow*
Very bright
Intermediate to dark
Red†
Intermediate
Dark
Very dark
Very dark
Fibrocartilage
Very dark
Very dark
Tear of fibrocartilage‡
Intermediate
Intermediate to bright
Hyaline‡
Intermediate
Intermediate
Normal‡
Intermediate
Bright
Degenerated
Intermediate to dark
Dark
Bone marrow
Cortical bone Cartilage
Intervertebral disk
Osteophyte
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
7 of 22
Marrow containing
Bright
Intermediate to dark
Calcified only
Dark
Dark
Tendons/ligaments§
Very dark
Very dark
Muscle
Dark
Dark
Lung[Verbar]
Very dark
Very dark
Normal parenchyma
Bright
Dark
Metastasis¶
Dark
Usually bright, may have dark center
Hemangioma
Dark
Bright
Liver
Fatty infiltration†
Bright
Dark
Iron overload
Intermediate to dark
Very dark
Pancreas
Bright
Dark
Spleen
Dark
Bright
Low concentration
Very bright
Bright
High concentration
Intermediate to dark
Very dark
Dark
Very dark
Contrast-enhanced tissue Gadolinium chelate
SPIO Ultrasmall SPIO
Bright
Very dark
Fluosol
Very dark
Very dark
Hyperacute (<6 h)
Intermediate
Intermediate
Acute (6-24 h)
Intermediate to dark
Dark
Hematoma**
Subacute (1 d-1 mo)
Bright rim
Bright
Chronic (>1 mo)
Dark rim ± bright center
Dark rim ± bright center
*Bright on T2-weighted images acquired using fast spin-echo sequence with short interecho interval. †Dark on out-of-phase image. ‡Bright on proton density-weighted image. §Increased signal, particularly on proton density-weighted images, when tissue is oriented at 55° to B 0 (magic angle effect). [Verbar]Increased parenchymal signal with TE <2 ms or fast spin-echo sequence with very short interecho interval. ¶Hepatocellular carcinoma, melanoma, hemorrhagic lesion may appear bright on T1-weighted image. **Low signal because of magnetic susceptibility effects predominantly seen on high-field images, more pronounced on gradient-echo than spin-echo images. Time frames indicated for hematoma evolution are approximations; in reality the time frames may vary widely from the values shown.
For T1 weighting, the TE should be kept to a minimum to reduce any T2 weighting in the image. This tactic may not be possible for low-field imaging, where low-bandwidth sequences are used to maximize the SNR. If TE is substantially lengthened due to the use of a very low sampling bandwidth, then there may be a loss of lesion conspicuity due to a counterbalancing of T1 and T2 weighting (Fig. 3-7). page 72 page 73
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
8 of 22
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-4 Combined impact of TR and TE on tissue contrast. A, For a short TR of 500 ms, tissue contrast is primarily T1-dependent. The effect of lengthening TE is to introduce T2-weighting and diminish overall tissue contrast. For instance, in this example, tissue contrast disappears at a TE of approximately 35 ms despite good contrast at shorter TE. B, For a longer TR of 2000 ms, tissue contrast is primarily proton-density at short TE or T2-dependent at long TE.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
9 of 22
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 73 page 74
Figure 3-5 Spin-echo images of a glioblastoma of the right cerebral hemisphere, acquired at 1.5 T. A, T2-weighted image. TR/TE = 500/20. B, Proton density-weighted image. TR/TE = 2500/20. C, T2-weighted image. TR/TE = 2500/80. Note signal changes of fat, cerebrospinal fluid, normal brain, cystic tumor, and surrounding edema. Also note that signal is absent from the cortical bone in the inner and outer tables of the skull but that signal is present in the marrow-containing diploic space.
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
10 of 22
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-6 T1 contrast between gray and white matter and TR. At short TR, there is little signal except from short T1 species (fat). Increasing TR to 300 and 500 ms increases both signal and contrast. As TR increases further, however, even though the signal increases, contrast between gray and white does not. (Courtesy of D. Kaufman, Siemens Medical Systems, Iselin, NJ)
Add to lightbox page 74 page 75
Figure 3-7 Comparison of low-bandwidth imaging at 0.2 T (left) using a TE of 30 ms compared with high-bandwidth imaging at 1.5 T (right) using a TE of 15 ms. Conspicuity of the L5 vertebral metastasis is better
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
11 of 22
on the high-field image acquired with the shorter TE.
Fast Spin-Echo Fast SE (also called RARE or turboSE) images can be acquired much more rapidly than conventional SE images, but show similar tissue contrast. A series of spin-echoes (called the echo train) is generated by the application of 180° refocusing RF pulses at regular intervals of several milliseconds or longer. Rather than reconstruct a separate image for each echo, as is done with conventional SE, all echoes are collectively phase encoded for a single image. Therefore, data are accumulated much more efficiently and scan time is greatly reduced. ECHO TIME. Unlike a standard SE sequence where the meaning of TE is obvious, it is less obvious in fast SE since multiple echoes are generated. The nominal TE selected by the technologist for a fast SE sequence represents the echo time when the centerline of k-space (which largely determines image contrast) is acquired. The choice of TE thus alters the degree of T2 contrast, as with standard SE. REPETITION TIME. Compared with standard SE, one typically uses a somewhat longer TR with fast SE. There are two reasons for this. First, the longer TR tends to improve the degree of T2 contrast. The longer TR would unacceptably lengthen scan times with standard SE, but is not a problem with the more efficient fast SE sequence. Another consideration is that the time consumed by the fast spin-echo train reduces the number of slices that can be acquired within a given TR interval. Therefore, a longer TR is needed to compensate. ECHO TRAIN LENGTH AND SPACING. For fast SE, one selects the number of echoes or echo train length (ETL), sampling bandwidth (typically 32 to 64 kHz), and echo train spacing (ETS). Scan times are reduced by a factor equal to the ETL, which typically ranges from 3 to 16 or more. The reduction in scan time is only approximately half as much if the data are shared to reconstruct dual echoes (i.e., proton density-and T2-weighted images). Because of the use of a Fourier transform to reconstruct the data, signal loss from T2 relaxation over the duration of the echo train manifests as image blurring. The blurring worsens as the ETL is increased. In the spine, ETL of 16 or more may be acceptable because CSF has a very long T2, so that the rate of signal loss is modest. On the other hand, such a long ETL might produce unacceptable image quality in the brain, where the T2 of white matter is relatively short. T1-weighted fast SE sequences rarely use ETL much longer than 3. The ETS is on the order of 4 to 10 ms. In some MR systems the technologist may not have direct control over ETS. Instead, it may be automatically determined based on sampling bandwidth, field-of-view, and other user-selected factors. TISSUE CONTRAST. Although the tissue contrast is generally similar to standard SE images, there can be noticeable differences. For instance, fat often appears brighter with fast than conventional SE, particularly with short ETS, due to the reduction in J-coupling effects. Magnetization transfer effects produced by the repeated application of the 180° refocusing pulses modify tissue contrast compared with standard SE, tending to make white matter appear relatively darker than in standard SE images whereas the signal intensity of CSF is unaffected. Susceptibility effects are less apparent with fast SE (especially with short ETS), which is advantageous for minimizing artifact from metallic implants but disadvantageous for detecting hemorrhage. Fast SE images are also more sensitive to eddy currentinduced imperfections in the magnetic field gradients. As a consequence, fast SE sequences often incorporate an automated phase correction to compensate. 3D FAST SE. Like 3D GRE, 3D fast SE permits the acquisition of thin, contiguous slices. However, the need for long TR means that scan times cannot be nearly as short as with 3D GRE. Three-dimensional fast SE may have utility for thin-section imaging of the brain, spine, and biliary system. FAST SPIN-ECHO AND SPECIFIC ABSORPTION RATE. The specific absorption rate (SAR) refers to the amount of RF power deposition per unit mass of biological tissue measured in watts per kilogram. Limits on SAR vary among countries. For instance, current SAR and other MR-related safety restrictions in the European Union tend to be more conservative than in the United States and revisions are under consideration.38,39 In the United States, the FDA has set specific limits on the amount of RF
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
12 of 22
power a patient may receive during each series of images. The current upper limits are 4 W/kg averaged over the whole body for 15 minutes, 3 W/kg averaged over the head for 10 minutes, 8 W/kg per gram of tissue for the head or torso for 5 minutes, and 12 W/kg per gram of tissue for the extremities for 5 minutes. The purpose of setting limitations is so that a patient's core body temperature will increase no more than 1°C. Factors influencing the amount of RF power deposited in the patient include magnetic field strength, type of pulse sequence, type of RF transmitter coil, and patient weight. Stronger magnets transmit at higher radiofrequencies and therefore deposit more power in tissues; lower field systems transmit at lower radiofrequencies, deposit less RF power, and are less likely to encounter SAR restrictions. A 3 T system deposits approximately four times as much RF power as a 1.5 T system for the same pulse sequence, so that SAR limits are a routine consideration. Small transmitter coils (e.g., head coil) deposit less RF energy than larger coils (e.g., body coil). Certain pulse sequences and imaging techniques, in particular fast SE, balanced SSFP, and contrast-enhanced MRA, tend to push the SAR limits more often than others. Fast SE utilizes rapid RF pulses of high power, thus increasing the RF deposition. In order to reduce RF power deposition with fast SE, one can use refocusing RF pulses of less than 180° or fewer refocusing pulses. For instance, one can reduce the refocusing flip angle from 180° to approximately 130° or less and thereby cut RF power deposition by 50% or more. Image quality is largely unaffected. Parallel imaging (see Chapter 8), hyperechoes (see Chapter 5), and gradient and spin-echo (GRASE) are also effective means to reduce RF power deposition. Conversely, RF power deposition is worse with certain imaging options such as magnetization transfer. page 75 page 76
Inversion Recovery One way to produce images that are highly sensitive to T1 relaxation times is to prepare the magnetization before the body of the fast SE pulse sequence with an additional 180° RF pulse as follows: which is repeated at intervals of TR. The technique is called inversion recovery (IR). Because the 180° RF pulse acts on the longitudinally aligned spins, it rotates them from the +z-axis all the way to the -z-axis. This "inversion" of the magnetization and its subsequent recovery dictates the contrast in the images. The waiting period, called the inversion time (TI), allows the protons to realign with the main magnetic field, which they do at rates that depend on T1. After this waiting period, an MR signal is generated by the fast SE pulse sequence. In certain circumstances (e.g., delayed contrast-enhanced imaging of myocardial viability), a GRE sequence is used to generate the signal instead of fast SE. Unlike standard T1-weighted SE sequences, T1 contrast develops during, and is primarily dependent upon, the interval TI (Fig. 3-8) rather than TR. Depending on the choice of TI and the particular T1 relaxation times, the signal from certain tissues will be emphasized, and the signal from other tissues suppressed. It should be noted that the choice of TI has a modest dependency on TR. The TI needed to suppress a particular tissue's signal will be reduced if the TR is shorter and, conversely, increased if the TR is longer. In general, long TR is desirable to maximize tissue contrast and the SNR (within the constraints of an acceptable scan time, which is proportional to TR).
Short-Tau Inversion Recovery (STIR) One particularly useful version of IR is the STIR sequence; the distinguishing feature is the use of a short TI value, typically on the order of 150 to 250 ms. Tissue contrast in STIR images is unusual, in that it appears reversed from the contrast typically seen in T1-weighted SE images. Moreover, STIR offers two general benefits: 1. improved lesion conspicuity through the additive effect of T1 and T2 contrast, and 2. effective fat suppression independent of B0 homogeneity. TISSUE CONTRAST IN STIR IMAGES. In STIR images, tissues with long T1 relaxation times (e.g., gray matter) appear brighter than tissues with shorter T1 relaxation times (e.g., white matter). This point is illustrated in Figure 3-8 for the images obtained with TI values of 150 ms and 250 ms. In these images, gray matter and CSF appear bright, whereas fat and white matter appear dark. By comparison, gray matter is darker than white matter in a T1-weighted SE image. The contrast reversal is a direct consequence of the use of magnitude-sensitive, rather than phase-sensitive, reconstructions of the images. Aside from applications involving flow quantification, MR images are usually reconstructed in a way that makes them insensitive to the phase of the signal. On such magnitude images, information about whether the longitudinal
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
13 of 22
component of M is positive or negative is lost. As a result, Mz can only vary between 0 and 1. (It is also feasible in certain circumstances to reconstruct phase-sensitive images, which can depict whether Mz is positive or negative. As a result, Mz can vary from -1 to 0 to 1; that is, the dynamic range for T1 contrast is doubled (Fig. 3-9). However, phase-sensitive images are more sensitive to image distortions produced by motion or magnetic field inhomogeneity. Although phase-sensitive reconstructions are seldom used, they may be helpful for certain applications such as imaging of delayed myocardial enhancement as addressed in Chapter 35.) How does the use of the magnitude reconstruction cause a reversal of tissue contrast in STIR images? As an example, consider the contrast between a hepatic tumor and normal liver parenchyma (Fig. 3-10). The longitudinal magnetization of a tumor is more negative, i.e., smaller, than that of liver. However, it has a larger absolute value, and hence the signal is greater, when only the magnitude is considered (Fig. 3-10A). The tumor therefore appears brighter than liver (Fig. 3-10B). The contrast reversal only applies with relatively short TI values; with longer TI values, the contrast relationships are similar to standard T1-weighted sequences (Fig. 3-10C). In using a moderately long TE with STIR, the contrast between the lesion and normal tissue is further increased. Thus, T1 contrast is additive with T2 contrast in STIR images, which is beneficial for lesion detection. FAT SUPPRESSION WITH STIR. Fat suppression with STIR relies on the principle that the longitudinal magnetization of any tissue, in crossing from a negative to a positive value, must pass through zero (see Fig. 3-10A). If the MR signal is read out when the magnetization is near zero, little or no signal should be produced. This condition allows signal from a selected tissue to be suppressed based on its T1 relaxation time. The appropriate choice of TI depends on TR and T1. If a tissue is fully magnetized (i.e., TR is long), the signal minimum (null point) occurs at TI = 0.69 × T1. For fat, which has the shortest T1 of any commonly imaged tissue constituent, this TI is quite short, on the order of 150 ms. However, the precise value depends on the choice of TR and the field strength-dependent value of T1. By suppressing the normally intense signal from fat, STIR greatly increases the conspicuity of tissues and lesions that are embedded in fat, such as lymph nodes (Fig. 3-10D), structures within the orbital cone, edema, and metastasis involving the bone marrow. In the abdomen, the method reduces artifacts caused by respiratory motion by suppressing the bright signal from moving abdominal fat. page 76 page 77
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
14 of 22
Add to lightbox page 77 page 78
Figure 3-8 Inversion recovery images. By progressively increasing the inversion time TI, signals from increasingly long T1 are first attenuated (null) and then recover. (Courtesy of D. Kaufman, Siemens Medical Systems, Iselin, NJ)
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
15 of 22
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-9 Longitudinal magnetization versus time after 180° RF pulse in an inversion recovery pulse sequence. For each tissue, there is an inversion time (A and B), which results in negligible signal from that tissue. Phasesensitive image (dashed line) retains sign of magnetization and may result in improved tissue contrast.
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
16 of 22
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 78 page 79
Figure 3-10 A, Illustration of STIR contrast for fat, liver, and a metastasis (met). Immediately after the 180° pulse in an IR sequence, Mz for all tissues is negative. The longitudinal magnetization recovers according to the T1 of each tissue. If a short T1 is used (e.g., 150 ms), then Mz of fat is near zero and its signal is nulled. Mz for other tissues is still negative. However, a magnitude reconstruction displays only positive signals, so the curves are reflected above the zero line. As a result, the contrast relationships are reversed and the metastasis appears brighter than the liver. The lesion-liver signal difference is further improved by the addition of T2 weighting. B, STIR image of patient with a large hepatic tumor (arrow). The tumor and surrounding edema appear brighter than the normal liver parenchyma, as does the spleen. C, Compared with (B), liver-lesion and liver-spleen contrast are reversed on this T1-weighted GRE image. D, Coronal STIR fast SE image (TR/TE/TI = 6000/90/150) of a patient with lymphoepithelial cysts. This sequence is highly sensitive for lymphadenopathy because the lymph nodes appear bright against a dark background of fat.
Unlike other fat-suppression techniques in which frequency-selective pulses are applied (see below), STIR is not dependent on a high degree of B0 homogeneity for effective fat suppression. On the downside, STIR cannot readily distinguish fat from blood products, as both tissues may have short T1 and the signal intensities are suppressed in both cases. STIR sequences should also be avoided in the setting of contrast enhancement. In a STIR image, the shortened T1 of the enhanced tissue can cause it to paradoxically decrease in signal intensity, rather than increase. In these situations, one is better off using chemical shift-selective fat-suppression methods.
Fluid-Attenuated Inversion Recovery (FLAIR) Fluids tend to have the longest T1 values of the visible tissue constituents. For example, the T1 of cerebrospinal fluid is several seconds. Using an IR-prepared fast SE sequence, one can suppress fluid signal by using a long TI (e.g., 750 to 2000 ms, depending on the TR). This technique is called FLAIR.
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
17 of 22
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
18 of 22
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-11 Comparison of T1- and T2-FLAIR with standard sequences in a patient who has undergone resection of an intracerebral glioma. A, T1-weighted SE, TR/TE 500/10. B, T1-FLAIR, TR/TE/TI 2162/10/750. Contrast between gray and white matter is slightly better than in A. C, T1-FLAIR after gadolinium administration shows sensitivity of the sequence to contrast enhancement. D, T2-weighted SE, TR/TE 7500/116. E, T2-FLAIR, TR/TE/TI 10,000/168/1750. The periventricular edema is better shown than in D because of the suppression of CSF signal.
There are two versions of FLAIR in routine use: T1-FLAIR and T2-FLAIR (Fig. 3-11). Sample parameters for the T1-FLAIR sequence would be TR/TE/TI of 2000 ms/10 ms/750 ms, and for T2-FLAIR 10,000 ms/170 ms/1750 ms. Compared with T1-weighted SE for imaging of the brain, T1-FLAIR produces better contrast between gray and white matter and better suppression of CSF signal. T2-FLAIR is helpful because bright periventricular lesions appear bright whereas the signal from the ventricles is suppressed. By comparison, these lesions can be obscured by adjacent CSF signal on T2-weighted fast SE images.
Gradient-Echo Gradient-echo pulse sequences (bearing acronyms such as FLASH, SPGR, FFE, trueFISP, FIESTA, and balanced-FFE) use only a single RF pulse as represented by where α is an RF pulse with a flip angle that is usually less than 90°. Because there is no 180° pulse, much shorter TR (on the order of 3 to 250 ms) can be used than with SE, so that scan times are dramatically lessened. page 79 page 80
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
19 of 22
Despite their simple structure, GRE pulse sequences produce images with complex contrast behavior. For instance, tissue contrast relates more to the choice of flip angle and to the presence or absence of spoiling than to TR and TE.
Incoherent versus Coherent Gradient-Echo As discussed in greater depth in Chapter 5, there are two general types of GRE pulse sequences: incoherent (or spoiled) and coherent (or steady-state free precession, SSFP). With the incoherent sequences (e.g., FLASH, SPGR, T1FFE), a combination of a strong gradient and/or an appropriately randomized RF phase serves to disperse the transverse magnetization after signal readout. Incoherent sequences are used primarily for T1- and proton density-weighted acquisitions. With coherent GRE, the transverse magnetization is refocused and reutilized after each excitation and signal readout. Tissue contrast is a function of the T1/T2 ratio. The sequences can be further categorized into the less commonly used contrast-enhanced version (e.g., PSIF) and the widely used balanced steady-state SSFP version (e.g., trueFISP, FIESTA, balanced-FFE). The latter method provides efficient motion artifact suppression. It also provides the highest SNR per unit time and is therefore particularly beneficial for ultrafast acquisitions. With balanced SSFP sequences, the flip angle is kept large (e.g. 50° to 90°) and the TE is minimized to avoid artifacts (see Chapter 5). Fluids (including blood and cerebrospinal fluid) and fat appear bright. Balanced SSFP can be used as a scout sequence, since the images can be acquired in less than half a second and are motion insensitive. It is also the preferred sequence for cine cardiac imaging given its insensitivity to motion artifact, high SNR, and excellent contrast between myocardium and blood in the cardiac chambers. Since the contrast is neither truly T1 nor T2 weighted, it does not substitute for standard pulse sequences in routine clinical applications outside of the heart. SLICE ACQUISITION MODES. There are three commonly used slice acquisition modes for imaging with incoherent GRE sequences: sequential 2D, multislice 2D, and 3D. Sequential 2D GRE (short TR on the order of 5 to 40 ms) is primarily used for time-offlight angiography. Multislice 2D GRE (moderate TR on the order of 100 to 250 ms) is used for breath-hold imaging of the upper abdomen. 3D GRE (very short TR on the order of 3 to 6 ms) is also used for breath-hold imaging of the upper abdomen, for MR angiography, and for thin slice acquisitions in general. With coherent GRE, the TR must be kept very short in order to maintain the steady state. Consequently, only sequential mode is used, never multislice mode. SUSCEPTIBILITY EFFECTS. Because GRE sequences do not use 180° pulses, GRE images are more sensitive than SE images to signal loss, geometric distortion, and other artifacts (Fig. 3-12) caused by magnetic field inhomogeneities (magnetic susceptibility effects). Sources of such distortions include ferromagnetic implants, air-soft-tissue or bone-softtissue interfaces, or just a poor shim.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
20 of 22
Figure 3-12 Coronal GRE image obtained with TR/TE = 21/12 and a 40-cm FOV. Note the zebra-striped patterns of signal loss at the periphery of the FOV caused by the arms and shoulders lying in an inhomogeneous portion of the static magnetic field. This artifact would not usually be encountered in an SE image.
At times the sensitivity to magnetic field inhomogeneities can be helpful. For instance, GRE images acquired with long TE (e.g., 10 to 30 ms) and low flip angle (e.g., 20°) show heightened contrast between hemorrhagic lesions (short T2*) and brain tissue, even at low magnetic field strengths where SE images are insensitive to blood products (Fig. 3-13).
Three-Dimensional GRE Three-dimensional methods involve the volumetric acquisition of a data set that is reconstructed into thin contiguous slices, also called 3D partitions. The thickness of the region (or 3D slab) encompassed by the 3D acquisition is equal to the product of the number of slices and slice thickness that are selected. Unlike 2D, the slices are truly contiguous and motion artifacts are reduced. Two types of 3D acquisitions are possible: isotropic (i.e., the voxel is a cube) and anisotropic (i.e., the voxel is elongated in one dimension, usually along the slice-selection axis). With isotropically acquired 3D data sets, multiplanar reformations are of uniform quality irrespective of orientation. With anisotropic data, there are some orientations for multiplanar reformations that produce better image quality than others. Compared with isotropic acquisitions, anisotropic ones are less time-consuming. LIMITATIONS OF 3D GRE. page 80 page 81
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-13 Comparison of sequences for sensitivity to hemorrhage. Patient with presumed amyloid angiopathy. Upper left, Proton density-weighted fast SE, 5-mm slice thickness, TR/TE = 4500/22; upper right, T2-weighted fast SE, 5-mm slice thickness, TR/TE = 4500/85; lower left, 3D GRE with 0.8-mm slice thickness, TE = 10 ms; lower right, 2D GRE with 5-mm slice thickness, TE = 28 ms. The GRE sequences are most sensitive to hemorrhage, with 2D more sensitive than 3D because of the longer TE and thicker slice.
Despite the many benefits, there are some drawbacks to 3D acquisitions. For instance, wraparound artifact may
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
21 of 22
occur in the slice direction in addition to the usual in-plane phase-encoding direction. Also, for reasons relating to the imperfect slab profile produced by the RF pulse, the number of useful images may be at least one or two fewer than the number specified. A subtle additional issue is that slice profiles may be degraded by ringing artifact if only a few slices are specified. Image quality tends to be better with a larger number of partitions (e.g., 32 or more). MAGNETIZATION-PREPARED 3D GRE. An inversion recovery, magnetization-prepared 3D GRE acquisition, called MP-RAGE, is a useful alternative to spoiled 3D GRE images. Compared with a typical spoiled 3D GRE sequence, it offers much better contrast between gray and white matter in the brain (Fig. 3-14A). The improved contrast simplifies the task of image segmentation required for fMRI studies of the brain, and is generally helpful for evaluation of cerebral anatomy. The improved T1 contrast is particularly helpful at 3 T, where T1 relaxation times are longer and T1 contrast diminished compared with 1.5 T.
Single-Shot Imaging Single-shot imaging offers the benefits of motion insensitivity and the ability to depict dynamic processes with a temporal resolution of one second or less, though at the expense of worsened spatial resolution. SINGLE-SHOT GRE. An inversion recovery, magnetization-prepared 2D GRE acquisition, called turboFLASH, snapshot FLASH, or FIRM, gives excellent T1 contrast in a scan time on the order of one second (Fig. 3-14B). Although image quality is not competitive with standard but lengthier acquisitions, it is especially useful for applications that require time-resolved imaging of contrast enhancement (e.g., dynamic gadolinium-enhanced perfusion imaging of the heart, liver, or kidney). It is also commonly used with a small test bolus of contrast agent to determine the proper delay time for contrast-enhanced MR angiography, and as a primary T1-weighted imaging technique in patients who cannot cooperate for breath-hold studies of the upper abdomen. SINGLE-SHOT FAST SE. page 81 page 82
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003015
22 of 22
Figure 3-14 A, Comparison of a single slice from a 3D SPGR acquisition (left) with an IR-EFGRE3D (MP-RAGE) acquisition (right). All images were acquired at 3 T. The T1 contrast and gray-white differentiation are superior with the MP-RAGE method. Scan time was 2 minutes 51 seconds for 3D SPGR and 4 minutes 49 seconds for MP-RAGE. B, TurboFLASH imaging at 3 T of a patient with a liver metastasis. Each image was acquired in approximately one second. The TI was 1200 ms (left), 800 ms (middle), and 550 ms (right). The best combination of image quality and tissue contrast was obtained at the TI of 800 ms in this case. Also note the absence of respiratory motion artifact. (A, Courtesy of Dr. Bob Lenkinski, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, MA)
By using a fast SE sequence with long ETL of 80 or more, along with partial-Fourier reconstruction in certain implementations (in which case the sequence is known as half-Fourier acquisition single-shot turbo spin-echo or HASTE), one can acquire all the data needed for an image after a single RF excitation. Scan times are on the order of a second or less, and the method is insensitive to cardiac or respiratory motion. Single-shot fast SE is routinely used for MR cholangiography (see Chapter 79), and imaging of the abdomen and other regions. However, single-shot fast SE shows noticeable blurring related to T2 decay over the duration of the echo train, particularly for tissues with short T2 relaxation times. Blurring can be minimized by the use of a short ETS as well as parallel imaging methods (see Chapter 8). Blurring is less of a concern for imaging of bile (MR cholangiography) and urine (MR urography) where the T2 relaxation times are prolonged. ECHO-PLANAR IMAGING. Echo-planar imaging is another commonly used single-shot method. It acquires a series of gradient-echoes after a single RF excitation so that scans are completed in as little as a tenth of a second or less. It requires especially powerful, fast gradients compared with other imaging methods and thus is not available on all MR systems. Echo-planar imaging has several problems that preclude its routine use: limited spatial resolution, marked sensitivity to artifacts from a poor shim or imperfect fat suppression, as well as hardware-related concerns such as gradient-induced eddy currents. Nonetheless, it is the technique of choice for various functional techniques in the brain, such as diffusion imaging and fMRI (see Chapters 9 to 10). Other fast imaging techniques (see Chapter 7) are too numerous to mention here, but few are in routine use yet. Radial acquisition methods such as PROPELLOR and VIPR show particular clinical promise. They have diminished sensitivity to motion artifact compared with standard Cartesian acquisition methods due to oversampling of the center of k-space. Spiral imaging also manifests diminished motion sensitivity due to oversampling of the center of k-space. It is used in some centers, particularly for cardiac, breast, and functional brain imaging studies. However, it is highly sensitive to artifacts from off-resonance effects if the shim is imperfect, in which case fat signals are not adequately suppressed.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:46
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
IMAGE ACQUISITION In order to obtain images, a technologist must first select an RF coil and position the patient, perform prescan adjustments in a specific order, and then acquire and reconstruct the data. Without the proper implementation, a variety of problems may occur, such as unusable image data or equipment malfunction or breakdown. The following is an overview of the steps involved in acquiring the MR images once the patient has been registered and the imaging protocol selected at the operator's console. page 82 page 83
Positioning of Patients The patient should be made as comfortable as possible to achieve cooperation. For most MRI examinations, the patient lies supine, although other positions are used if supine positioning is not tolerable for the patient. Prone positioning may reduce feelings of claustrophobia since the patient can more easily look out of the bore, but it is less comfortable than supine positioning. Centering is done to the region of interest using a laser cross-hair system; this region will then be moved automatically to the center of the magnet. With certain open MR systems, the patient can actually be outside of the magnet while the structure of interest (e.g., wrist or knee) is positioned within the magnet bore. Phased-array receiver coils with one or more posterior elements must be positioned on the table before the patient lies down. Some systems have the posterior elements built into the table, which simplifies the positioning process. The anterior elements are applied afterwards and are typically stabilized using Velcro straps or by locking into the posterior elements. Adequate cushioning must be placed between the patient and coil to ensure that the patient will be comfortable for the duration of the study.
Receiver Coil Coil Selection The first step to consider is receiver coil selection. A receiver coil acts like an antenna for a radio signal tuned to a specific frequency. There are many receiver coils available, each having a different function determined by both shape and design. Coil designs vary according to the type of magnet as well (see Chapter 4). For instance, solenoid coils are sometimes used in permanent magnet systems, owing to a different orientation of the main magnetic field. These coils are more commonly used in lower field strength magnets. Surface coils, also known as local coils, improve image quality but are limited to a smaller FOV than the body coil. Surface coils are most sensitive to signals arising from tissues close to the coil. The improved image quality in the sensitive region is a result of a better SNR and, compared with the body coil, reduced sensitivity to motion of structures far from the coil. The range of the coil sensitivity directly relates to the size of the surface coil. The SNR typically remains superior to the body coil up to at least the depth of one coil radius. Surface coils are used to image small superficial structures such as the temporomandibular joint or wrist. Flex coils are designed to be flexible, as the name would suggest. The flexible material that encases the receiver coil protects the coil from damage yet allows it to be wrapped around such anatomic structures as the upper and lower extremities. These coils provide more uniform signal than flat surface coils because of their capability of conforming to the shape of the structure. Intracavity coils are placed inside a body cavity such as the rectum to image nearby structures such as the prostate, cervix, or rectal wall. Because of the small radius of the coil, the sensitive region is limited to tissues immediately adjacent to the coil. The sensitive region may be oriented in one particular direction (e.g., rectal coil) or be relatively uniform in all directions (e.g., prostate coil). Given the limited extent of the sensitive region, such coils are commonly combined with a larger external phased-array coil (e.g., torso coil) to provide a more uniform and extensive field-of-view. Also, experimental
1 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
intravascular coils are under development to study plaque characteristics and help guide intravascular procedures (see Chapter 20). A whole-volume coil is used to acquire a uniform signal from a large volume. The body, head, body-phased array, and some knee coils are examples of whole-volume coils. These may function as both transmit and receive coils or as receive-only coils. Coils are designed as linear or quadrature, also known as circularly polarized coils, the latter consisting of two sets of magnetically decoupled coils. Advantages of a quadrature coil over a linear coil design include: 1. a more spatially uniform flip angle from the RF pulse; 2. a reduction in power deposition of up to 50%; 3. increased SNR; and 4. increased homogeneity of the signal. Most head and body coils, as well as many phased-array coils, are quadrature coils. When choosing a surface coil, one should keep in mind that a smaller coil yields a better SNR. Therefore, it is advantageous to select a coil that will cover the area of interest and can be placed at a distance away from the area of interest that is less than the radius of the receiver coil. For larger areas or deeper anatomic structures, volume coils may give better signal uniformity, but they are also more sensitive to noise produced from the patient's motion. Another variable to consider is the filling factor, which refers to the ratio of the volume of the area being sampled to the volume of the coil. It is most desirable to have as high a filling factor as possible to maximize the SNR from a given coil. Therefore, one should not choose a large coil, such as a body coil, for imaging a small structure, such as the head.
Phased-Array Coils Even though they provide a high SNR, one problem with small surface coils is that they cover a limited FOV. However, a series of small surface coils can be combined to form a coil array and thus provide sensitivity for imaging over a large volume. In such coil sets, called phased-array coils or multicoil 40 arrays, the individual coils are magnetically decoupled. Each coil element is typically connected to its own receiver channel (see Chapter 4). Because each coil in the array is magnetically isolated from the other elements, large phased-array coils provide about the same SNR over a large FOV as would be provided by each individual element over its much smaller FOV. Compared with a large, single-channel RF coil covering the same volume as the phased-array coil, the SNR is much better for the phased-array coil. page 83 page 84
With phased-array coils, high-resolution images of the spine, abdomen, pelvis, 41 and other organs can be acquired in just a few seconds to minutes. Drawbacks of phased-array coils are their greater expense and several-fold longer reconstruction times because of the need to combine data from multiple receiver channels. Phased-array coils nowadays may have as few as 4 to as many as 32 or more elements. The development of phased-array coils with such large numbers of elements is partly driven by the development of parallel imaging methods (see Chapter 8). Generally speaking, parallel imaging methods work most effectively (best image quality, highest acceleration factors) with coils that have larger numbers of elements as well as an appropriate geometry. In using phased-array coils that have anterior elements in addition to posterior elements (e.g., torso array coil), breath-holding, respiratory compensation, and/or fat suppression can be essential for optimal chest or abdominal imaging. Otherwise, moving fat in the near field of the anterior elements is very bright and generates substantial ghost artifact. The problem is less severe in the pelvis. By contrast, phased-array coils designed for spine imaging in horizontal-field superconducting magnets have only posteriorly located elements (with the exception in some designs of an anterior neck element) so that sensitivity to motion of the anterior chest and abdominal walls is minimized. For vertical-field magnets, the use of a circumferential, solenoidal design for the spine coil (see "Restrictions in Receiver Coil Design and Positioning") means that the images are more sensitive to the motion of anterior fat, and the imaging technique must take this into account.
2 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
3 of 11
With certain phased-array coils, there may be more coil elements available than receiver channels. Consequently, one should only activate those coil elements that are needed to image a specific region of interest. If too many coil elements are activated, multiple elements are combined into a single receiver channel. Moreover, some coil elements might be located far outside of the magnet isocenter. The result is a worsening of the SNR, along with the potential to introduce artifacts into the image. Moreover, image reconstruction time increases with the number of elements, as does the amount of storage taken up by the raw data. Long reconstruction times can limit the practical application of some advanced imaging techniques, particularly when a large amount of data is rapidly acquired in conjunction with the use of a phased-array coil having numerous elements.
Restrictions in Receiver Coil Design and Positioning There are times when an RF coil designed for a specific anatomic structure should not be used. For instance, a patient with severe scoliosis or with a halo for a cervical fracture or stereotactic frame may not be positioned easily within a head or neck coil. In such instances, the body coil may be used to obtain adequate images by increasing the FOV, increasing the number of excitations, and using thicker slices to improve the SNR. Coil design depends on the magnetic field strength. Low- to middle-field magnets may employ saddleshaped and spherical coils. These coils are incompatible with high-field systems because of self-resonance, which is a physical limitation, preventing the coil from tuning and matching at higher frequencies. The receiver coil is also restricted by design with regard to the orientation of the main magnetic field. The coil will have highest sensitivity to the signal when its magnetic axis (B1) is positioned perpendicular to the main magnetic field. Therefore, different RF coils must be used with different types of magnets. In systems with the main magnetic field, B0, oriented horizontally, the magnetic axis of a coil is oriented vertically. For example, a surface coil, such as a spine coil, is positioned horizontally in the center of the main magnetic field, which results in B1 being positioned perpendicularly to B0 (Fig. 3-15). This is the most desirable position, because tilting the coil away from the perpendicular reduces its sensitivity and effectiveness, thereby reducing the SNR. When the main magnetic field is oriented vertically, such as a permanent magnet, solenoid coils are sometimes used (Fig. 3-16). The magnetic field of these coils is oriented horizontally, which is perpendicular to the main magnetic field and therefore most desirable.
Coil Centering The magnetic field is most uniform at the magnet isocenter. The magnetic field uniformity and linearity of the gradients decline as one moves from isocenter. Therefore, surface coils and the body part of interest should be placed near the center of the magnet to obtain the best image quality possible. Some systems require imaging to be performed at isocenter, whereas this is not a requirement with others. Generally, image quality will not suffer if the body part is a few centimeters away from isocenter. However, with large displacements, SNR may suffer and the shim may worsen, resulting in poor fat suppression. In addition, gradient nonlinearity (which results in stretching, warping, or telescoping of the image) becomes most apparent for structures located the farthest distance from isocenter. The gradient nonlinearity artifact is most apparent in MR systems with short gradient coils. However, imaging away from the isocenter is sometimes unavoidable, e.g., for MRI of the shoulder or wrist owing to physical limitations in positioning the patient.
Coil Tuning and Matching page 84 page 85
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-15 Positioning of a flat "license plate" receiver coil in a superconducting magnet. A, With horizontal positioning of a receiver coil, its B1 RF field is perpendicular to the main magnetic field (B0), resulting in optimal sensitivity for the tissue MR signal. In addition, its B1 field is perpendicular to that of a linear transmitter coil (i.e., physically decoupled), which is required for safety reasons if the receiver and transmitter coils are not electronically decoupled. Note that the B1 field of a quadrature (circular polarized) transmitter coil continually changes (i.e., rotates within the x-y plane). Therefore, it is not possible to decouple the receiver coil physically from the transmitter coil, and electronic decoupling is required. B, The receiver coil can be rotated to a sagittal orientation with no loss of sensitivity. Electronic decoupling of the coils is now required because the B1 field of the receiver coil is aligned with that of the transmitter coil. C, Tilting a receiver coil toward a coronal orientation results in a loss of sensitivity owing to partial alignment of the B1 field of the coil with the B0 field. Optimal sensitivity is attained when the two are perpendicular (θ = 90°), as in A or B.
In order to maximize the sensitivity with which the receiver coil detects the MR signal, the coil impedance must match that of the preamplifier and the coil circuitry be tuned to resonate at the tissue resonance frequency. The MR system measures the RF power reflected from the coil as the feedback to enable coil tuning and matching. The coil is optimally tuned and matched when the reflected power is near zero. Since the RF coil electronically couples to tissue and the coil properties are altered differently for each patient, the coil may be tuned and matched for each individual. This process happens automatically as soon as the patient is positioned within the magnet bore. Some manufacturers design the body and receiver coils so that they do not require tuning for each individual patient. This can save some time during the prescan process. The disadvantage in some cases is a lower quality factor for the coil, which results in a slightly reduced SNR. Rarely, a coil will not tune to a patient. This may be due to incorrect positioning, a loose coil connector, a blown coil diode, or the patient's size being either too small or too large. If the patient is small (e.g., an infant or child), the coil may have difficulty tuning because there is not enough signal returning to the receiver coil. Placing bags of saline within the surface coil area may help load the coil so that it can
4 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
tune. Patients who are too large may need to be slightly adjusted in position to have the coil tune successfully. Another scenario that may create difficulty for coil tuning is a patient with a significantly large metallic implant, such as a hip replacement. Slightly adjusting the patient's position in this situation may be all that is required. Another possible remedy is to use the body coil instead of a surface coil, although the SNR will worsen.
Frequency Adjustment and Shimming
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-16 Flexible solenoid coil used for spine imaging in a permanent magnet system with a vertical main field (B0) perpendicular to B1. (Courtesy of Fonar Medical Systems, Melville, NY)
Introducing a patient into the magnetic field alters its homogeneity. Because each patient is unique in size and shape, it is necessary to make an adjustment of the transmitted frequency. This is accomplished by emitting a wide range of frequencies, and the result is Fourier transformed. The transformed information is displayed as a spectrum on a graph, with peaks representing various signal intensities. Ideally, two peaks are displayed, with the higher frequency peak (right) representing water and the lower frequency peak (left) representing fat. The adjustment process takes this information and adapts the system's RF frequency to match that of water. page 85 page 86
Occasionally, the fat peak is so large or the shim so poor that the system incorrectly centers the frequency on the fat peak, in which case fat suppression will not work properly. In this case, one can add a value of 220 Hz at 1.5 T, or proportionally less at lower field strengths, to center correctly at the water peak. Some systems offer an option to use a STIR-type sequence during the frequency adjustment procedure to suppress the fat signal intensity. Typically, the separation of fat and water peaks is easier at 3 T, since the separation of the peaks is twice that at 1.5 T. Shimming is a process of maximizing the homogeneity of the static magnetic field using active or passive methods. Most systems today have an automated shimming procedure that is used to optimize the uniformity of the magnetic field while the patient is in the bore. A good shim is particularly difficult to achieve with certain body parts such as the foot or neck. It can also be problematic for bilateral breast imaging. Some pulse sequences, such as echo-planar, spiral, and balanced steady-state free precession, are very sensitive to off-resonance effects from magnetic field nonuniformities. As a result, artifacts such as ghosting, dark stripe, or dark flow artifacts may occur. 42 In this case, a better shim setting usually can be achieved by repeating the automated shimming procedure for a volume just larger than the region of interest. The center frequency should be manually adjusted both to ensure that the shim is adequate and that the proper peak is selected.
5 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
In the case of bilateral breast imaging, the shim values can be determined separately for each breast. The values are then averaged to set the shim for bilateral imaging. Some systems contain dedicated shim coils that permit higher-order shimming (in addition to the standard linear shimming that just uses the three gradient coils). Higher-order shimming allows the user to improve B0 uniformity to a value better than 1 ppm over a specified volume. This feature can be helpful for applications that are particularly sensitive to B0 uniformity such as spectroscopy, spiral scanning, and functional brain imaging. Although linear shimming is sufficient for cardiac imaging at 1.5 T, susceptibility artifacts may occur at 3 T especially along the infero-posterior margin of the heart at the interface with the lung. Although time-consuming to perform, the use of higher-order shimming can ameliorate the artifacts. Repeated inability to obtain an adequate shim or proper frequency adjustment may indicate a serious problem, such as magnetic field drift caused by hardware instability or a major change in the magnet environment. The frequency adjustment process is especially important on mobile systems, as the magnetic environment varies from site to site so that the shim is inconsistent. It is always desirable to keep large ferromagnetic objects away from the mobile magnet, and the problem is even worse if the object moves.
Transmitter Adjustment Adjustment of the transmitter is performed to calibrate how much RF power must be applied to produce any desired flip angle. It is necessary to readjust the transmitter each time a patient is repositioned or when scanning a new patient. Some difficulties may arise when adjusting the transmitter. For instance, the RF coil may not tune and match properly because of patient size, presence of a ferromagnetic implant, or electronic failure such as a blown diode or improper decoupling of the transmitter and receiver coils. Under these circumstances, the transmitter subsystem may not be capable of emitting enough power to produce the desired flip angle, or the resultant RF power deposition may be excessive. The service engineer may need to be contacted to evaluate the situation.
Receiver Gain Adjustment During MR imaging, the weak signal from the tissue protons is amplified and then translated from an analogue signal to a digital output by the analogue-to-digital converter (ADC). Digitization makes it possible for the computer to process the data. In certain MR systems, the ADC has a limited capacity for digitizing the received MR signal, so that the receiver gain must be automatically adjusted. Receiver gain adjustment will keep the range of numbers manageable for the ADC; otherwise, the peak amplitude components in the MR signal would be clipped resulting in image artifacts. The duration of the receiver adjustment process typically varies from a few seconds to a minute or longer, and is highly dependent on the particular MR system, pulse sequence, and number of slices. In MR systems with a higher digitization depth for the ADC, the receiver adjustment may not be needed, thereby saving time during the prescan process.
Image Measurement Preparation Scans Most systems have a slight computational delay between when the user activates the measurement process and when the measurement actually begins. In addition, there may be a delay from the application of preparation scans. For certain pulse sequences, a number of preparation scans are applied during the first few seconds after the scan is initiated, but no data are collected. The purpose is to avoid an anomalous change in signal intensity over the first few repetitions of the sequence (Fig. 3-17). Various sequence types employ differing preparation schemes. For instance, with a SE sequence equilibrium is achieved after the first 90° excitation pulse. The first data set is not collected in this case, but all subsequent data are used for image reconstruction. With GRE, the number of
6 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
preparation pulses needed to reach a steady state depends on the particular version, TR, and flip angle. For instance, dozens of RF pulses are needed to reach equilibrium with coherent GRE sequences. However, there are methods to shorten the preparation (e.g., α/2 preparation pulse, see Chapter 7).
Measurement Period page 86 page 87
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-17 Example of the effect of preparation scans. At the start of the measurement process, a number of preparation scans may be applied to establish an equilibrium magnetization, or steady state. The data acquisition is started only after the preparation scans are finished.
A jackhammer-like knocking sound indicates the onset of image measurement. This sound represents the mechanical vibrations of the gradient coils produced by changing magnetic fluxes during gradient pulsing. Gradient-produced noise is most severe with pulse sequences that use rapid switching of high-amplitude gradients (e.g., MR angiography). At the start of each measurement, a technologist should forewarn a patient of this noise to prepare the patient psychologically and to prevent motion due to involuntary reaction. As mentioned earlier, it is advisable to give all patients ear protection against the noise created by the scanning. Some patients may become agitated after the measurement is under way. Several options are then available: 1. On some systems, selection of a "pause" option temporarily interrupts the current acquisition. This allows the technologist to speak with the patient to determine if the request for a pause is of an urgent nature or if the patient needs a moment to cough, for instance. This option is of value only if the patient is able to continue with the procedure without having moved from the original position. Otherwise, the acquisition will need to be restarted from the beginning. 2. Some systems can reconstruct images from incomplete data sets if more than 50% of the information has been collected. The quality of these images improves as the percentage of data acquired approaches 100%. If the patient starts to move toward the end of the measurement period, it may be prudent to abort the acquisition prematurely and use these images reconstructed from the incomplete data set. 3. If the patient moves transiently during the acquisition, the resultant image degradation may be mild, particularly if the movement occurs when the outer portions of k-space are being acquired. Although some blurring will occur, it may not be necessary to abort the acquisition. 4. The acquisition may be repeated using a smaller matrix, fewer excitations, and shorter TR for faster imaging to improve the likelihood of obtaining a motion-free image. Alternatively, a single-shot acquisition may be employed. 5. Motion-suppression techniques such as PROPELLOR, or ultrafast acquisitions such as echo
7 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
8 of 11
planar can be used.
Breath-Hold Imaging Respiration may be voluntarily suspended for a limited time in certain clinical applications. In particular, breath-holding markedly improves the quality of GRE and fast spin-echo images in the chest and abdomen. These techniques can be used to evaluate vessel patency or to detect a lesion in the upper abdomen or heart. Fairly consistent results can be obtained when the duration of the breath-hold is short, perhaps 10 to 20 seconds. Breath-holding at end-expiration tends to produce the most consistent diaphragm position across breath-holds. However, some technologists prefer to have the patient suspend respiration at end-inspiration because the patient may be able to suspend respiration for a longer period of time. A technologist should review the breath-hold instructions with a patient before the start of the examination. If the patient is prepared for the breath-hold instructions, there will be less chance of confusion, especially with systems that may have an inferior quality intercom or if a patient has hearing loss. A technologist should also review the instructions to obtain consistency in breath-holding (e.g., inhale and exhale the same amount each time the patient is directed to do so). The patient is instructed to breathe in (wait approximately 3 seconds), breathe out (again wait approximately 3 seconds), and stop breathing. The instructions should be given more slowly than would be needed outside of an MRI environment; otherwise the patient may not be able to keep up with the instructions. Hyperventilation, commonly used before breath-hold spiral CT acquisitions, is equally helpful for MRI. One can use respiratory bellows to show the respiratory waveform while performing breath-hold imaging. By reading the respiratory waveform, technologists are able to more accurately instruct patients to hold their breath at the end-expiration phase, and to monitor if the patient is really following the instruction correctly. In difficult cases, breath-hold capability can be improved by nasal administration of 100% oxygen.43 The command to stop breathing should be given at the last possible moment, taking into account the intrinsic delays that occur before the start of data acquisition. page 87 page 88
New respiratory compensation techniques such as navigator gating may obviate the need for breathholding in some cases.
Use of Contrast Agents Many different kinds of contrast agents are involved in MR imaging. The following is a brief overview of the administration of gadolinium-based extracellular paramagnetic agents. The details of different contrast agents are discussed in Chapters 13 and 14, as well as in the various clinical chapters. The typical dosage for extracellular gadolinium chelates is 0.1 mmol/kg, but higher or lower dosage can be applied. Double-dose contrast medium may be beneficial for improved detection of small lesions. Also, double- or even triple-dose contrast medium can be used for 3D MR angiography. In certain applications, the dose of contrast agent is much lower since the contrast agent is diluted (e.g., 44 MR arthrography, direct MR venography ). Extracellular gadolinium chelates are typically given as a bolus IV injection over 5 to 30 seconds followed by 10 to 20 mL of normal saline to flush the tubing. The injection rate varies depending on the exam type-usually from 1 mL/s to 5 mL/s with approximately 2 mL/s being typical. The injection can be implemented by hand or a MR-compatible power injector. If a power injector is used, the volume of contrast agent and flushing saline, along with the rate of injection are selected. If contrast agent is to be injected by hand, in addition to preparing the syringe, the technologist may wish to prepare a second syringe of normal saline as a bolus to follow the contrast agent, using a three-way stopcock on the line, and completely flush the tubing.
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
Another technique is to draw up 10 to 20 mL of saline into a 60-mL syringe and then carefully draw up the needed contrast agent so that the two substances are layered one over the other (the contrast agent is heavier than the saline so it will stay closer to the end of the tip of the syringe as long as the syringe is kept in a vertical position with the tip down). This particular method works well with gadopentetate dimeglumine , but not with some nonionic contrast media that are less dense and mix with saline. In brain or spine scanning, post-contrast scanning should begin soon (usually within 1 minute) after the IV contrast agent has been administered. When imaging liver or kidneys, a technologist or radiologist may wish to begin breath-hold imaging within 20 seconds of the bolus of contrast medium. Multiphase imaging of contrast enhancement is particularly important for lesion characterization (e.g., cavernous hemangioma of the liver, breast cancer). In 3D MR angiography, care must be taken to start the acquisition after an appropriate delay to avoid missing the arrival of the contrast bolus. Test bolus and automated triggering methods are reviewed in Chapter 29. A note of caution should be made that a rapid bolus injection sometimes causes a patient to feel nauseated (a nonspecific effect resulting from administering a hypertonic solution, though perhaps more common with some contrast agents than others). The consequences of nausea developing into vomiting are hazardous, as the patient's position in the magnet is supine in most cases and the bore of the magnet is limiting, thus putting a patient at higher risk of aspiration. The technologist should record the volume and name of contrast agent. This information is critical in case of allergic reaction or other complication. This information is also important for the hospital laboratory to know, since certain contrast agents can be associated with spurious hypocalcemia. 45
Image Filtering and Reconstruction Reconstruction times depend on matrix size, as well as on the capabilities of the computer and array processor. Images acquired with a larger matrix will require longer reconstruction times. A variety of filters are available for image smoothing, signal intensity normalization, and reduction of artifacts. The availability of various image filters is system dependent. Some of these filters are selected prospectively and are applied to the data during reconstruction, whereas others are selected after the measurement and are applied directly to the reconstructed image. Noise reduction filters reduce the background noise in the image but may cause artifacts such as excessive smoothing. Renormalization filters correct for the signal nonuniformity typical with surface coils. Caution must be used with all image filters not to introduce clinically confusing artifacts into the image.
Troubleshooting Quality control is a more complex process for MRI systems than for other imaging modalities such as CT. Artifacts may occur in MR images from a variety of causes, as reviewed in detail in Chapter 22. Although many of these artifacts require the attention of service personnel, it is helpful to know when image quality problems are related to hardware rather than to inappropriate selection of pulse sequence or scan parameters or to the patient. Therefore, the technologist and physician should be aware of basic troubleshooting procedures. A consistent downward trend in SNR measurements warrants a call for service. One should note whether the noise exhibits any "structure." For instance, discrete vertical lines oriented to the frequency-encoding axis represent RF noise. RF noise may be caused by a defective RF enclosure for the magnet room, and one should check to make sure that the door is tightly closed and that the copper tabs surrounding the door are intact. One should also check for flickering within the magnet room. page 88 page 89
Repeated artifacts propagating along the phase-encoding axis may represent ghost artifact from respiration or pulsatile flow. If this cause is excluded, the artifacts likely relate to hardware problems,
9 of 11
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
10 of 11
such as RF or gradient instability or inadequate eddy current compensation. Intermittent diagonal lines or "snowstorm" artifacts may relate to hardware problems or to static discharges, which tend to occur during conditions of low humidity. One should check the humidity levels in both the magnet room and the room containing the gradient subsystems and should consult service personnel. Declines in humidity occur more frequently during periods of extremely cold weather. Artifacts that occur only intermittently may be caused by temperature instability in the magnet room or the room housing the computer and other hardware. Ambient temperatures greater than 72°F (25° C) are not usually well tolerated and may result in damage to electronic components. Also, intermittent artifacts can be encountered from a loose screw or other hardware adjoining the body coil or a gradient coil, which results in abnormal mechanical vibration and arcing. These artifacts may be intermittent because the vibrations are problematic only with particular pulse sequences. Direct inspection by service personnel may be required to troubleshoot this problem. Unstructured noise may be due to a variety of causes. Although service is probably required, one can check the integrity of the connectors and cables for the receiver coils, because these, on occasion, are mangled during positioning of the patient. Artifacts may also be caused by malfunctioning monitoring equipment. Metallic implants such as Harrington rods or dental plates produce localized regions of geometric distortion and may also cause poor SNR, owing to improper coil tuning. More generalized evidence of geometric distortion suggests problems with magnet shimming or gradient linearity. If intermittent, this artifact might be caused by the movement of large metal objects, such as cars or elevators, in the vicinity of the magnet. Mobile MR systems may be more affected by this type of incident, as the siting of the magnet is usually in a parking lot adjacent to a building. For any of these artifacts, it is important to save raw data (Fig. 3-18), which often provide additional information about the source of the artifacts. However, in most commercial systems, the raw data must be saved immediately after the scans or even when the scan is prescribed, because the data may be deleted when the next scan is initiated. At times it may be necessary to continue scanning despite problems with image quality. In this case, acquiring thicker slices, larger fields-of-view, or more excitations may be used to improve image quality. If artifacts are particularly severe with certain pulse sequences or planes of section, these should obviously be avoided.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003048
11 of 11
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-18 Diagonal snowstorm artifacts usually suggest a hardware problem or static discharges. In this case, the problem was a loose screw in the body coil, resulting in abnormal vibrations and arcing. A, Sagittal knee imaging is degraded by these artifacts. B, Raw data set corresponding to A. Each column corresponds to a specific time interval or frequency sample; each row or "line" corresponds to data acquired from one phase-encoding step. The semiperiodic nature of the artifacts, suggesting the presence of abnormal vibrations, is evident in the raw data but not the image.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:47
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
1 of 13
HOW TO OPTIMIZE IMAGE QUALITY
Signal-to-Noise Ratio The quality of an MR image is partly determined by the SNR. For clinical MRI, a good SNR is essential for diagnostic image quality, and just about everything affects the SNR. A higher SNR means the image will appear to be less grainy and fine details will be more apparent. Conversely, a low SNR results in a grainy image in which fine details are obscured. Although a high SNR is desirable, increasing the SNR may require more scan time. Given that the human eye is able to detect differences only up to a certain point, it is best to maximize the SNR to an acceptable level for making a diagnosis without increasing scan time to a length that is unacceptable to a patient. A useful (though simplified) expression for signal to noise (S/N) is:
Since the SNR is roughly proportional to magnetic field strength, it makes sense that the choice of a higher field system (e.g., 1.5 to 3 T) is likely to give better image quality (Fig. 3-19). On the other hand, low-field systems (e.g., 0.2 to 0.5 T) may have advantages in terms of convenience, cost and, if open in design, patient acceptance. Intermediate-field (e.g., 0.7 T) open systems provide good image quality and patient acceptance, though the cost can be close to that of a high-field system. Many factors aside from magnetic field strength impact the SNR, such as the choice of pulse sequence, RF coil, quality of the shim, and so forth. For instance, low-bandwidth pulse sequences produce images with a better SNR than high-bandwidth sequences. Coherent noise (e.g., respiratory and pulsatile motion causing ghost artifact) and incoherent noise (e.g., RF leak) reduce the SNR. Receiver coil sensitivity along with the distance from the region of interest to the coil will alter the SNR. As spatial resolution-which is determined by field-of-view, matrix (number of pixels along the frequency and phase-encoding directions), and slice thickness-is improved, the SNR decreases in direct proportion to the volume of the voxel.
Image Contrast
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
2 of 13
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-19 Using a thin slice and small field-of-view, contrast-enhanced MRI of the pancreas at 1.5 T (top) and 3 T (bottom) was performed in the same patient. The 3 T image is obviously less grainy than the one acquired at 1.5 T.
Image contrast refers to differences in signal intensity between tissues. High tissue contrast, or more precisely a high contrast-to-noise ratio (in consideration of both contrast and SNR), is essential for lesion detection. Tissue contrast may be manipulated through selection of scan parameters and pulse sequences. Some factors are choice of pulse sequence, magnetization preparation, TR, TE, and use of a contrast agent. A technologist and radiologist may maximize either the T1 or T2 contrast of different tissues through appropriate choices of scan parameters for the area of interest.
Sampling Bandwidth Low-bandwidth, or narrow-bandwidth, pulse sequences use a weak frequency-encoding gradient and a prolonged readout period to improve SNR (Fig. 3-20). The SNR is inversely proportional to the square root of the sampling bandwidth. Low-bandwidth methods are particularly useful on low-field systems in which the intrinsic SNR is worse than on high-field systems. Another benefit of low-bandwidth sequences is that smaller FOVs can be acquired, since less gradient amplitude is needed than with high-bandwidth sequences. page 90 page 91
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
3 of 13
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-20 Comparison of image acquired with a high sampling bandwidth (125 kHz, left) and one acquired with a low sampling bandwidth (15.6 kHz, right). The lower-bandwidth image demonstrates a better SNR, but shows more flow artifacts from the aorta.
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-21 Abdominal MR images acquired using a 2 mm slice (left), 4 mm slice (middle), and 8 mm slice (right). The images become less noisy and are more easily interpreted as the slice thickness is increased, but partial volume averaging worsens.
As previously addressed, low-bandwidth sequences should not be used when a short TE is desired. The prolonged readout period of these sequences necessitates an increase in the minimal TE. Images obtained with low-bandwidth methods may also be more susceptible to image artifact from the patient's motion, magnetic susceptibility artifacts, and any instrument instabilities such as eddy current effects. Additional drawbacks of low-bandwidth methods include reduced multislice capability and greater chemical-shift artifact, which may be troublesome on high-field systems.
Spatial Resolution Spatial resolution determines the viewer's ability to discern two points as separate and distinct. Spatial resolution is determined by the dimensions of the voxel, so that a small voxel (i.e., thin slice, large matrix, small FOV) is generally desirable. However, it is important to realize that a high level of spatial resolution is useless if there is insufficient SNR to support it. If one increases slice thickness, which is one dimension of the voxel, then the SNR is proportionately improved (Fig. 3-21). The SNR increases according to the square of the FOV, so that small increases in FOV can produce a large increase in the SNR.
Slice Thickness page 91
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
4 of 13
page 92
Thin (e.g., 1- to 2-mm) slices should be used when scanning small structures such as a pituitary gland or the internal auditory canal. However, thinner slices yield a lower SNR. To compensate, the user may increase the number of signals averaged (NEX/NSA). Thicker slices (5 mm) may be used for a routine screening brain study. Even thicker slices (up to 10 mm) may be used for abdominal or thoracic cavity surveys. A low-field magnet may require the use of thicker slices for an adequate SNR. Gradient strength and the RF pulse characteristics will determine the minimal slice thickness, which is usually approximately 2 mm for two-dimensional imaging techniques. Three-dimensional imaging techniques allow acquisition of thinner slices of 1 mm or less.
Interslice Gap, Slice Profile, and Crosstalk It would be ideal to obtain contiguous images in MRI. In practice, it is necessary to insert a gap between slices. The reason for this practice relates to imperfections in slice profiles. A mathematic function known as sinc [sin (x)/x] is commonly used to modulate the waveform of the RF pulse. The Fourier transform of this function is a rectangle. However, a perfectly rectangular slice profile is produced only by an RF pulse of infinite duration, which is impractical. RF pulses of shorter duration always produce imperfect slice profiles, so that the flip angle varies across the thickness of the slice. If narrow gaps between the slices are used, then each slice is contaminated by RF excitations from the edges of the adjacent slices (crosstalk) and tissue contrast is degraded (Fig. 3-22). On T2-weighted images, crosstalk is manifested as a reduction in the signal from structures with long T1 relaxation times, such as CSF and neoplasms (Fig. 3-23). A gap of 20% to 50% will substantially reduce crosstalk. T1-weighted images are less degraded by crosstalk than are T2-weighted images, so that slice gaps of 10% to 30% may be adequate. Crosstalk can be reduced by the use of longer RF pulses at the expense of longer TR and TE. Slice profile can be improved by use of specially tailored RF pulses even if the pulse duration is relatively short. Alternatively, one can use 3D acquisitions, which have no crosstalk between adjacent slices. Use of small gaps may make it difficult to obtain adequate coverage of the region of interest. Total coverage, defined as the space between the centers of the outer slices, may be expressed as For instance, a 20-slice axial acquisition using 5-mm thick slices and no gap would produce coverage of 95 mm, which is less than the vertical extent of the average adult brain. Increasing the interslice gap to 40% of the slice thickness, or 2 mm, will enable coverage of the entire area.
Field-of-View
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
5 of 13
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-22 Slice profiles. A, Sinc pulse of moderate duration. B, Sinc pulse of shorter duration. Crosstalk (shaded area) 1 and 2 is worse in B than A, owing to the worsened slice profile in the latter case. This necessitates increasing the interslice gap. C, Long sinc pulses or computer-optimized RF pulses of shorter duration produce nearly rectangular slice profiles, permitting interslice gaps less than or equal to 10% of the normal slice thickness.
The FOV is defined as the horizontal or vertical distance across an image. The minimal FOV is primarily determined by the peak gradient amplitude and gradient duration. Decreases in the FOV are brought about by increasing the strength of the frequency-encoding and phase-encoding gradients. Spatial resolution improves as the FOV is decreased, within the constraints of the SNR limitations. Reductions in FOV produce a rapid decline in the SNR in proportion to the square of the FOV. Reducing slice thickness also reduces the SNR, but in a one-to-one proportion. page 92 page 93
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
6 of 13
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
7 of 13
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
8 of 13
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 93 page 94
Figure 3-23 Effects of crosstalk on image contrast and SNR. T2-weighted spin-echo images (A to F) and T1-weighted images (G to L) with decrease in interslice gap from 100% (A and G) to 0% (F and L). Note marked worsening in T2 contrast and SNR, even with moderate gaps (e.g., 20% in D), whereas T1-weighted images are less severely degraded at the same gap (J). (From Kucharczyk W, Crawley AP, Kelly WM, et al: Effect of multislice interference on image contrast in T2- and T1-weighted MR images. Am J Neuroradiol 9:443-451, 1988, © by American Roentgen Ray Society)
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
9 of 13
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-24 Pelvic image acquired with a small (28-cm) FOV in the coronal plane. There is severe wrap-around artifact that could be avoided by the use of phase oversampling or a larger FOV. Wrap-around artifact is less commonly a problem in axial or sagittal images.
Small FOVs (e.g., 8 to 12 cm) are used for detailed anatomic evaluation, as needed in the temporomandibular joint or the wrist. Small FOVs may produce wraparound artifacts unless oversampling methods are used (Fig. 3-24). It is common for the minimum TE to lengthen when imaging with small FOVs, since the available gradient is used up and the sampling bandwidth must be reduced. Low-bandwidth sequences, because of the weaker readout gradient, typically permit smaller FOVs than do higher-bandwidth sequences, but chemical-shift artifact is worse. Larger FOVs (e.g., 30 to 40 cm) are used when more spatial coverage is required, such as in chest, abdominal, pelvic, and spine imaging. Good spatial resolution can be maintained despite the large FOV by using a 512-acquisition matrix.
Matrix The image matrix represents the number of pixels along the frequency-encoding and phase-encoding axes. Imaging time is proportional to the number of phase-encoding steps. Most systems allow the user to select from several matrix sizes. Images can be acquired using a 128 × 256 (phase × frequency) matrix in half the time of a 256 × 256 matrix, at the expense of a 50% reduction in spatial resolution. Because of the lower spatial resolution, the SNR improves. However, objectionable truncation artifacts may result from small matrix sizes so that a compromise may be made between spatial resolution and imaging time by using a larger matrix (e.g., 192 × 256). As discussed in "Rectangular Field-of-View", spatial resolution can be improved, despite a reduced matrix, by using an asymmetric (rectangular) FOV. This technique improves resolution along the phase-encoding axis by increasing the amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient, while keeping constant the number of pixels in the matrix.
Tradeoffs among Imaging Parameters There are several ways to adjust the imaging parameters so as to maximize the SNR or spatial resolution, but there may also be undesirable side-effects that need to be understood.
Choosing the Number of Excitations The parameter NEX (number of excitations) refers to the number of times the pulse sequence is repeated in each projection (i.e., phase encode) during the process of acquiring an image. The SNR is improved according to: The use of multiple excitations reduces both incoherent thermal noise (Fig. 3-25) and coherent noise from repetitive motion (e.g., ghost artifacts from respiration; Fig. 3-26). Acquiring multiple excitations is common at low field strengths, whereas a single excitation is typically adequate at 1.5 T and higher fields. Scan time is proportional to NEX, so that using a single excitation cuts the scan time in half compared with that for two excitations. However, the penalty is a reduction in SNR. For instance, if a 2 NEX acquisition had an SNR of
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
10 of 13
141, then a 1 NEX acquisition would only have a SNR of 100 (a reduction of 29%).
Partial Fourier The partial-Fourier method reconstructs an image from only part of the available data. In the specific case of half-Fourier (also called 1/2 NEX), slightly more than half of the data are acquired while the remaining data are mathematically synthesized in mirror-image fashion (conjugate synthesis). Half-Fourier is most robust when used with SE sequences, but can be used with GRE (including balanced SSFP) if the echo is relatively centered and the TE kept short. This technique provides a reduction of nearly 50% in imaging time. However, with the faster acquisition, SNR will be reduced by about 29% (i.e., as if the NEX were cut in half), so the method should be employed only when the SNR is not a limiting factor. Moreover, half-Fourier images are prone to artifacts produced by magnetic field inhomogeneity or motion of the patient; the artifacts worsen with higher field strength (e.g., 3 T). Better image quality is obtained by acquiring somewhat more data with a 3/4 NEX acquisition, at the expense of slightly greater scan time.
Reduced Matrix Size Scan time is proportional to the number of phase-encoding steps, so scan time can be decreased by using a smaller matrix size along the phase-encoding direction (changing the matrix size along the frequency-encoding direction has no effect on scan time). Decreasing the matrix size blurs the image and exacerbates truncation (Gibbs) artifact, which manifests as multiple ghost images of certain features. Truncation artifacts are difficult to discern in images acquired with 256 or more phase encodes but are more apparent in images made with 128 phase encodes. Truncation artifacts can be reduced by utilizing appropriate image filtering and reconstruction algorithms. page 94 page 95
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-25 Effect of averaging on image signal-to-noise and contrast-to-noise ratios. NEX (number of averages) increases from 1 to 8 going from upper left to lower right. (Courtesy of D. Kaufman, Siemens Medical Systems, Iselin, NJ)
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
11 of 13
Add to lightbox page 95 page 96
Figure 3-26 Signal averaging: issues for abdominal imaging. Abdominal images of a normal subject acquired in a multicoil array. Upper left, SE image (TR/TE/NEX = 500/12/1) obtained in 1 minute during breathing shows blurring and ghost artifacts from respiratory motion. Upper right, Same with 4 NEX obtained in 4 minutes shows improved SNR and a reduction in ghost artifacts, but the image remains blurred. Lower left, Breath-hold FLASH image (TR/TE/flip angle/NEX = 120/4.8/80°/1) obtained in 15 seconds shows no ghost artifacts and greatly improved detail. The SNR is better for the FLASH than the SE images despite the much shorter scan time, because of the reduction of coherent noise from respiratory ghost artifacts. Lower right, Breath-holding is not required with such fast acquisitions, but is helpful to ensure proper registration of all the slices. HASTE image (TE/NEX = 60/1) acquired in only 370 ms also shows good SNR and good detail.
For a given FOV, a 256 × 256 matrix has twice the spatial resolution of a 128 × 256 matrix. However, 128 phase encodes can be acquired in half as much time as 256 phase encodes. In many applications, a 128 × 256 matrix provides adequate spatial resolution. Furthermore, despite the shorter scan time, an image acquired with a 128 × 256 matrix will have a higher SNR than one acquired with a 256 × 256 matrix. For instance, if the SNR of the 256 × 256 matrix image were 100, then the SNR of the 128 × 256 image would be 141. The reason is that the increase in SNR resulting from the twofold larger pixel more than compensates for the loss from acquiring half as many lines of data. If the amount of ringing and blurring artifact is clinically unacceptable, then an intermediate matrix (e.g., 160 × 256 or 192 × 256) can be acquired. It is more time-consuming than a 128 × 256 matrix but produces sharper images with fewer artifacts.
Rectangular Field-of-View
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
12 of 13
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-27 Schematic comparison of the effects of acquisition with different matrices on pixel size and image appearance. Note that subtle differences, such as truncation artifacts, are not shown here. A, A 256 × 256 (frequency × phase) image has square pixels (0.9 × 0.9 mm). B, A 256 × 128 image has rectangular pixels (0.9 × 1.8 mm) with half the spatial resolution of A, but the image is acquired in half as much time. The area under the phase-encoding gradient is half of that in A. C, A 256 × 128 image acquired using asymmetric FOV along the phase-encoding direction with one half the FOV in the frequency-encoding direction (24 × 12 cm). The resolution is the same as that in A, but the image is acquired in half as much time. It may not always be possible to reduce the FOV by such a large amount in the phase-encoding direction because of wraparound.
There is one situation in which the matrix size can be reduced with minimal or no loss in spatial resolution. If the anatomy being imaged is elliptical in shape (e.g., head or abdomen), a rectangular or asymmetric FOV can be used to recover some or all of the resolution lost by using an asymmetric matrix (Fig. 3-27). For instance, consider 1. a 256 × 256 image with a symmetric 24 × 24 cm FOV, versus 2. an image with 128 phase-encoding steps and
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003066
13 of 13
a rectangular FOV of 12 cm (phase-encoding direction) × 24 cm (frequency-encoding direction). These images have equal pixel resolutions of 0.9 × 0.9 mm, but the image with the smaller matrix is acquired in half the time. By permitting smaller acquisition matrices to be used without unacceptable compromises of spatial resolution, rectangular FOVs are routinely useful for reducing scan time, provided that the FOV accommodates the anatomy. If the anatomy does not fit in the rectangular FOV, substantial wrap-around artifacts may occur along the phaseencoding direction. Wrap-around is not a problem along the frequency-encoding direction because oversampling in this direction does not require extra time and, in conjunction with the application of a band-pass filter, cuts off signals arising from outside the prescribed FOV. The SNR is a consideration in the use of rectangular FOVs but is not a limiting factor as long as the FOV is not too asymmetric. Consider 1. an image acquired with a 256 × 256 matrix and a symmetric 24 × 24 cm FOV, and 2. an image acquired in half the time with a 128 × 256 matrix and a 17 × 24 cm (29% smaller) FOV along the phaseencoding direction. Surprisingly, these two images have the same SNR. The loss of SNR resulting from the reduced FOV in the second image is precisely compensated by the gain in SNR from the larger pixel size. page 96 page 97
Low-Field MR Imaging MR systems with magnetic field strengths on the order of 0.2 to 0.5 T are commonly referred to as low-field MRI systems, although the nomenclature varies by user and vendor. When imaging at low fields, one should keep in mind that, for given scan parameters, the image has an intrinsically lower SNR than at high field. This disadvantage usually can be compensated by increasing slice thickness, increasing FOV, decreasing matrix, using lower bandwidth, and increasing the number of acquisitions, at the expense of decreasing the spatial resolution or/and 46 increasing the scan time. Users of low-field instruments should also recognize that contrast enhancement with gadolinium-based agents is dependent on the field strength. Contrast enhancement of certain lesions may not be as vivid on the low-field images as on those obtained at high field. Some lesions that enhance only weakly at high field may appear not to enhance at all on low-field images. Therefore, users of a low-field magnet always should endeavor to use post-contrast pulse sequences that are as T1-weighted as possible, and try to use higher dosage of contrast 47 agents for better enhancement.
Scanning at 3 Tesla In the recent past, it was thought that scanning at "high field" meant scanning at 1.5 T. With the introduction of the 3 T scanner for clinical imaging, it is quickly being realized that 3 T imaging is the new "high field" (see Chapter 18). Improved SNR can be used to decrease the scan time and/or increase the spatial resolution of the image. 3 T is already the field strength of choice for clinical brain imaging as well as functional MRI of the brain, spectroscopy, and high-resolution intracranial MR angiography. The increase in SNR and superior fat suppression are beneficial for abdominal and pelvic MRI as well as contrastenhanced MRA in the body. Musculoskeletal imaging also has an advantage at 3 T because of the ability to increase the spatial resolution and more robust fat suppression. A given sampling bandwidth produces double the chemical-shift artifact at 3 T as at 1.5 T. To compensate, higher bandwidths may be used, which lowers the SNR. At 3 T, power deposition is drastically increased, making it necessary to adjust protocols. For example, the user may need to increase the TR to allow time for the heat to dissipate. Smaller flip angles may be required for RF-intensive pulse sequences, such as SSFP, contrast-enhanced 3DMRA, and fast SE. One can set up the protocols so as to alternate high (e.g., fast SE) and low (e.g., GRE) power deposition scans to give the patient time to "cool down." T1 relaxation times are longer at 3 T, which may cause T1 contrast to be slightly diminished. To compensate, slightly longer TR may be desirable or one may choose to use an MP-RAGE or other magnetization-prepared sequence. On the other hand, the longer T1 relaxation times tend to enhance the effects of paramagnetic contrast 48 agents. As a consequence, the dose of contrast agent can be reduced (e.g. to half-dose from single dose).
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
1 of 13
SPECIAL TECHNIQUES
Parallel Imaging The individual elements of a phased-array coil are more sensitive to signal sources that are nearer the coil than those further away. Parallel imaging methodologies use this phenomenon to mathematically generate additional phase-encoding lines independent from the magnetic field gradients, thereby reducing scan time by a large factor (2 to 4 or more). Among the numerous potential and realized clinical applications, the method can be used to reduce magnetic susceptibility artifacts for echo-planar acquisitions, to accelerate contrast-enhanced MR angiography, and to improve the time resolution of realtime cardiac imaging. The main limitations include the need for phased-array coils with proper geometry and large numbers of elements, reduced SNR, and certain kinds of image artifacts. In addition, one may need to acquire an additional calibration scan, though some parallel imaging methods are self-calibrating. Parallel imaging methods are reviewed in detail in Chapter 8.
Fat-, Water-, and Silicone-Selective Imaging In some cases, one chemical species is clinically more interesting and the elimination of other moieties would improve the diagnostic image quality. These techniques are generally selective based on either the T1 relaxation time (STIR) or the chemical shift (chemical-shift-selective imaging, phase-contrast, two- and three-point Dixon techniques). 49 These methods will be considered in greater depth in Chapter 7.
STIR As described previously, STIR can provide robust fat suppression. However, there are several limitations to the use of IR for fat suppression. First, image contrast is substantially altered compared with that for typical sequences, and the SNR tends to be lower for the same scan time. Second, as already addressed, the technique is problematic for contrast-enhanced studies. Finally, the technique does not readily distinguish between fat and tissues with short T1 associated with blood products.
Chemical-Shift-Selective Fat Suppression page 97 page 98
Other techniques are based on chemical-shift differences. For example, fat and water protons have different resonance frequencies. There is a dominant fat peak associated with methylene (-CH2-) protons at a frequency approximately 3.5 ppm lower than that of water protons, corresponding to a frequency shift of 220 Hz at 1.5 T. ("Fat" actually has a complex spectrum, with contributions from methyl, vinyl, and other lipid constituents. 50) As another example, frequencies of the dimethylsiloxy units [-Si(CH3)2-Oy-]n of silicone breast implants are shifted even lower, approximately 80 Hz lower than that of fat at 1.5 T. By using an appropriate pulse sequence one can selectively suppress the signals from water, fat, or silicone.51 The signal intensity of fat, water, or silicone can be selectively suppressed by applying an RF pulse, called a chemical-shift-selective pulse, tuned to the proper frequency. For instance, a narrow-band RF pulse at 220 Hz below the water frequency followed by gradient spoiling will, at 1.5 T, suppress the fat resonance. The main limitations of fat suppression are related to B0 and B1 field inhomogeneities. Because the chemical-shift difference simply makes the spins resonate at the slightly different magnetic field, imperfections in the static field (B0) can mimic the frequency shifts caused by chemistry. That is, nonuniformity of the order of 3.5 ppm will cause the fat suppression pulses to saturate fat protons in some regions and water protons in other regions. This is especially a problem away from the isocenter of the magnet or near air-tissue or bone-tissue interfaces (e.g., skull base, near paranasal sinuses). 52 In addition to static field inhomogeneity, nonuniformity of the RF excitation field (B1) causes the flip angle of the fat saturation pulse to vary across the image, resulting in variable degrees of fat suppression. Even modest B1 inhomogeneity can dramatically limit the effectiveness of fat suppression; for example,
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
2 of 13
a 20% variation in B1 limits fat suppression to about a factor of 3. Consequently, it may be helpful to use a chemical-shift-selective inversion pulse to suppress the fat signal (e.g., "SPIR" technique).
Selective Water Excitation Instead of trying to suppress the signal intensity of fat, some MR systems may offer the capability to selectively excite water protons using a spatial-spectral pulse53 (Fig. 3-28). Selective water excitation often gives more uniform results than fat suppression, because the fat signal is absent regardless of the B1 field inhomogeneities. However, it is less widely available than fat saturation techniques, and is only applicable to a few types of pulse sequences.
Phase-Contrast Imaging Instead of selectively suppressing or exciting the spins of interest, it is also possible to use phase information to distinguish species. Phase-contrast (not to be confused with the entirely different phasecontrast methodology used for flow quantification or angiography) GRE imaging is an example of this strategy (Fig. 3-29). To understand these methods, imagine first that one is imaging with a gradient-echo pulse sequence and the signal is measured immediately after the RF excitation (i.e., TE = 0); the transverse magnetization vectors of fat and water signals would then be precessing coherently, that is, in phase. In this case, the fat and water signals from protons residing in the same voxel would be additive. Because water protons precess 3.5 ppm more rapidly than fat protons, over time the phase of the water protons would advance with respect to the fat protons. At a certain time after excitation, the transverse magnetization vectors of the water and fat protons would be 180° out of phase, resulting in signal cancellation and an out-of-phase or opposed image. (At 1.0 T, signal cancellation occurs at 1/(3.5 × 42.6 Hz)/2 = 3.4 ms.) The water and fat signals thus oscillate in and out of phase with a periodicity (∆TE) determined by the magnetic field strength according to When TE is equal to an even multiple of ∆TE, the fat and water signals are in phase, whereas images acquired at odd multiples of ∆TE show signal loss caused by fat-water phase contrast. For instance, at 1.5 T a TE of 2.2 ms gives an opposed image and a TE of 4.4 ms an in-phase image. The cycling at 3 T is twice as fast (i.e., opposed image at TE of 1.1 ms and opposed image at TE of 2.2 ms). At 1.0 T the corresponding out-of-phase and in-phase TE values are 3.4 and 6.8 ms. Fat-water signal modulation does not occur with SE pulse sequences because of the refocusing effect of the 180° pulse. Opposed images are readily identified by dark borders surrounding organs at fat-water interfaces. This artifact is not limited to the frequency-encoding direction, as is the case for the usual chemical-shift artifact seen with both spin-echo and in-phase gradient-echo sequences. These phase-contrast images can be acquired in just a few seconds. Use of phase-contrast imaging is helpful for detection of fat-water mixtures, as in fatty infiltration of the liver, fat in an adrenal adenoma, and differentiation of normal red bone marrow (fat-water mixture) from infiltrated marrow (mostly water). Phase-contrast imaging would not be useful for detection of fat occupying an entire voxel, such as fat in a lipoma or teratoma, because the modulation must come from the destructive interference of fat and water in the same voxel. The phase-contrast method is at the heart of the more quantitative, but less commonly used, two- and three-point Dixon techniques,54,55 which are discussed in Chapter 7.
Magnetization Transfer Contrast In many tissues, there can be a substantial quantity of MR "invisible" spins. These spins may be bound or closely associated with large proteins, membranes, and so forth. Because of their very slow motion, these spins have a very short T2 (<0.1 ms) and cannot be seen at any typically used TE. However, these spins can nonetheless have a visible effect by a process called magnetization transfer (MT) contrast.56 page 98 page 99
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
3 of 13
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 99 page 100
Figure 3-28 Fat suppression. A, Abdominal MR image without (upper left, gradient-echo, TR/TE/FA= 40/8/30°) and with (upper right) fat saturation, both in body phased-array coil. In an unsuppressed image, the aortic signal is bright because of rapid inflow of unsaturated blood. For the image at the upper right binomial fat suppression was used. Suppression in plane is effective, but fat saturation behaves like water saturation in some other planes. For example, inadvertent water saturation near the heart due to field inhomogeneity causes the aortic signal to be suppressed. The image at the lower left shows the improvement obtained by selectively exciting water (rather than fat suppression), in this case using a spatial-spectral excitation for slice selection, improving in-plane fat suppression and preserving the inflow signal in the aorta. B, Use of fat suppression to differentiate blood products from fat, both of which can be bright on T1-weighted images. Left, T1-weighted axial image showing two hemorrhagic
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
4 of 13
endometriomas (arrows) that appear bright. Right, On a fat-suppressed coronal image, the hemorrhagic lesion appears bright (arrow). In contrast, the fatty signal from a dermoid cyst would have been suppressed.
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-29 A, Calculated signal intensity versus TE at 1.5 T in a gradient-echo image of simulated marrow consisting of 75% fat and 25% water. The oscillations in the signal intensity are due to a slight difference between the resonance frequencies of fat and water (i.e., chemical shift). B and C, A patient with oat cell metastasis to the right humeral shaft. Gradient-echo images are sensitive to bone marrow abnormalities such as metastatic lesions. On T1-weighted SE image (B), normal marrow appears bright and metastasis appears dark. On an out-of-phase proton density-weighted gradient-echo image
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
5 of 13
(C), marrow appears dark and metastasis appears bright.
Magnetization transfer contrast is enhanced by saturating the tissue magnetization with RF pulses applied at a frequency that is far from the center frequency of water (e.g., frequency shift of 1.5 kHz). With such a large frequency shift, one might expect no effect on tissue signal. In reality, the "invisible" spins resonate over a very broad range of frequencies and are saturated by the MT pulses. They then exchange magnetization with the mobile spins, and thereby reduce the signal intensity of the latter spins. MT RF pulses primarily affect tissues that contain both mobile and invisible protons (Fig. 3-30). Such tissues include brain, liver, and muscle, among others. Tissues that have a paucity of restricted protons, such as cerebrospinal fluid, urine, and blood, show minimal if any signal change. In addition, as this effect is essentially an additional path of T1 relaxation, MT RF pulses only minimally affect tissues with short T1. Thus, MT pulses have a minor effect on the signal intensity of fat or that of gadoliniumenhanced tissue. The use of MT RF pulses involves substantial additional RF power deposition, which is more of a limitation in the body than in the head. It becomes a more significant issue at 3 T, where power deposition is so much higher. Some systems reduce power deposition by providing an option to apply the MT RF pulses only during the center lines of k-space. There are several potential clinical applications for MT contrast. 57 It has proved clinically useful for intracranial MR angiography.58 The signal from brain tissue is reduced much more than blood by the MT RF pulses. Contrast between vessels and brain is improved and small vessels in particular are better delineated. MT is also helpful for contrast-enhanced MRI of the brain. The MT pulses only slightly reduce the signal intensity of tissues with short T1 relaxation times, such as enhancing metastases. 59 On the other hand, the signal intensity of brain tissue is substantially reduced, so that the conspicuity of the metastases is improved. Moreover, the amount of MT is affected by the physical and chemical state of the tissue. Thus, the MT rate is apparently lowered in multiple sclerosis and thus may be of value in characterizing the degree of demyelination in plaques. 60 As previously mentioned, MT effects can cause substantial alterations of tissue contrast even in routine imaging61 especially for fast SE where a large number of 180° pulses are applied.
Flow Compensation Flow compensation, also known as "flow comp," gradient motion rephasing (GMR), gradient moment nulling (GMN), or motion artifact suppression technique (MAST), is a method for reducing flow and motion artifacts (see Chapter 27). The method incorporates into the pulse sequence additional gradient pulses that reduce motion-related phase shifts. The effect of flow compensation is to increase signal intensity from flowing blood and CSF. This method is particularly useful for improving the signal uniformity of, and suppressing ghost artifacts arising from, CSF on T2-weighted fast SE images of the spine. When flow compensation is used for nonbreath-hold abdominal imaging, signal intensity from moving organs, such as the liver, is increased and ghost artifacts are reduced. One major limitation of flow compensation is that the minimal TE, slice thickness, and FOV may be increased compared with standard pulse sequences. As a result, it may not be possible to use flow compensation in applications that require extremely high spatial resolution, such as imaging the temporomandibular joint. In addition, in some patients flow compensation may not provide adequate suppression of ghost artifacts from CSF pulsation. In these instances, the combination of flow compensation and ECG or pulse gating may provide better artifact suppression. page 100 page 101
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
6 of 13
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
7 of 13
Add to lightbox
Figure 3-30 Principle of magnetization transfer. A, The mobile protons have a relatively long T2 and resonate over a narrow range of resonance frequencies. This pool of protons continually exchanges magnetization with a pool of protons having restricted motion, short T2, and a wide range of resonance frequencies. Application of an off-resonance MT pulse (black rectangle in lower diagram) saturates the restricted pool. The mobile pool also becomes saturated because of the exchange of magnetization between the two pools. MT contrast can help visualization of small lesions, especially after gadolinium. T1-weighted images without (B) and with (C) MT after gadolinium. Although the image in B does not show a definite metastasis, that in C with MT shows a marked reduction in brain signal, providing much better visualization of this metastasis (arrow).
Flow compensation is routinely used with time-of-flight angiography (though not with contrast-enhanced MR angiography, where a very short TE is more important). On the other hand, one should be aware that the use of flow compensation will reduce or eliminate the CSF flow void sign in the aqueduct of Sylvius. This sign is occasionally used to characterize hydrocephalus. Similarly, flow compensation may not be desirable on T1-weighted images of the spine, because it increases the signal intensity of CSF and may reduce contrast between CSF and spinal cord or cauda equina.
Presaturation Presaturation incorporates additional RF pulses, applied just before the body of the pulse sequence, that saturate tissue magnetization and thereby reduce the signal intensity over user-defined regions. Presaturation applied along the slice-select direction suppresses flow artifacts and is commonly used for imaging the brain, neck, chest, abdomen, and extremities, wherever flow artifacts may limit image quality. page 101 page 102
The effectiveness of flow presaturation depends on the velocity and direction of flow. Therefore, one should not be surprised if the technique fails to eliminate signal from CSF within the thecal sac, where the flow is to and fro rather than unidirectional, or in certain patterns of blood flow. For instance, presaturation does not typically affect artifacts caused by vascular pulsation in the cerebral venous sinuses, because the effects of the presaturation pulses on arteries do not carry through the capillary system into the veins. It may also fail to suppress intravascular signal adequately within large aortic aneurysms, which have slow flow. In the heart, special dual inversion techniques are required to suppress the signal intensity of blood since presaturation is ineffective. Additional limitations of the
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
8 of 13
method include substantially reduced multislice capability and increased RF power deposition. Consequently it is typical in commercial MR systems that the presaturation pulses are applied intermittently (e.g., one presaturation pulse for every four slices). Presaturation becomes ineffective after IV administration of gadolinium chelates, because the T1 of blood becomes too short. One can apply presaturation along directions other than slice. For instance, presaturation applied along the phase-encoding direction anterior to the vertebral bodies may be useful for spine imaging to suppress ghost artifacts arising from vascular pulsation and respiratory motion. Presaturation may also be used to suppress the high signal from subcutaneous fat in the near field of a surface coil, which reduces motion artifacts, and to reduce the severity of wraparound artifact.
Respiration Motion Compensation A simple way of reducing respiratory artifact when imaging the abdominal area is to use a piece of fabric, available through vendors selling positioning devices, with Velcro for keeping a snug fit around a patient's abdomen. This limits the up-and-down motion of a patient's abdomen without increasing image acquisition time and therefore reduces ghost artifact from that type of motion. However, this procedure may not be comfortable for the patient. Depending on the MR system, available respiratory gating methods include using a mechanical bellows and navigator gating. While highly effective in some patients, the results vary according to the regularity and depth of the patient's breathing. Extra time is required to position the bellows optimally and to choose the thresholds for accepting the data, or in the case of navigator echoes, to position the navigator region over the region of interest (e.g., lung-diaphragm interface) and obtain baseline data about respiratory patterns. Moreover, with respiratory gating methods, some data must be rejected so that scan times are increased, typically by a factor of 2 to 4.
Cardiac Gating Synchronization of the data acquisition to the cardiac cycle reduces flow artifact and blurring for the heart and nearby structures including the ascending aorta. It can be used to define cardiac and vessel anatomy more precisely, or to permit dynamic display of cardiac function using cine techniques. Cardiac gating and imaging methods are reviewed in Chapter 32. There is some confusion of terminology with respect to the terms triggering and gating. Although these terms are often used synonymously, some manufacturers use the term triggering specifically to refer to "prospective" methods of cardiac gating (Fig. 3-31). For prospective cardiac gating, data acquisition is initiated after a user-determined time interval following the R-wave of the cardiac cycle. This "trigger delay" can be varied so that an image (e.g., of myocardial delayed enhancement) is obtained within a particular phase of the cardiac cycle. Note that for a multislice acquisition, the images are acquired over a finite period corresponding to the user-selected TR. For retrospective gating (standard for cine imaging), the data are accumulated according to the TR irrespective of the cardiac cycle, while the ECG signals are recorded. The data are subsequently processed using the recorded ECG signals to assign data to the appropriate phases of the cardiac cycle. Retrospective gating has the advantage that the entire cardiac cycle is depicted (essential for measurements of left ventricular function). By comparison, prospective gating may miss the final portion of the R-R interval; triggering is inaccurate if data are acquired too close to the end of the cardiac cycle due to overlap of the RF and gradient pulses with the R-wave.
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
9 of 13
Add to lightbox page 102 page 103
Figure 3-31 Comparison of prospective cardiac gating (A) and retrospective cardiac gating (B) for five-slice acquisition. In prospective gating, the time interval between sequence repetitions is determined by the R-R interval, not the TR. The TR determines the duration of the cardiac cycle during which slices are acquired. In retrospective gating, the time interval between sequence repetitions is determined by the TR, as it would be for an ungated acquisition. Retrospective gating provides more consistent image quality for cine imaging than does prospective gating.
For several reasons, difficulties may be encountered in obtaining satisfactory ECG gating: 1. Poor lead contact may result from inadequate skin preparation. The skin should always be cleansed of oil and debris by using an alcohol swab or by gently scraping the skin with a piece of thin plastic (the cover from some ECG electrodes will suffice) before applying the electrodes. In some instances, the hair should be shaved where lead contact is to be made. Standard ECG electrodes have caused severe burns in some cases; therefore only MR-compatible ECG electrodes should be used. 2. Respiratory motion causes a variation in the ECG baseline, making it difficult for the system to find and follow the R-wave of the cardiac cycle. Attaching ECG leads to the back of a patient or using breath-hold acquisitions may prevent this problem. 3. Gradient and RF pulsing during imaging induces electrical currents in ECG leads, which (depending on the pulse sequence and slice orientation) may completely obscure the ECG tracing. In most cases, such interference can be electronically filtered out of the ECG signal. 4. Magnetohydrodynamic effect. Flow of blood (which is a conducting solution) through the static magnetic field alters the ECG by simulating an augmented T-wave or other nonspecific ECG changes. These distortions worsen with increasing magnetic field strength. 5. Arrhythmias. These cause two problems: 1. the gating system may confuse these extra potentials with R-waves and gate incorrectly; 2. the volume of the heart is different after a premature beat than a normal one, which may cause blurring and ghost artifacts when these data are combined with data acquired during normal sinus rhythm. Before using ECG gating, it is wise to consult applications personnel for the specific MR system. Gating methods vary widely among different manufacturers. Vectorcardiographic gating is an ECG gating method that analyzes the direction of the electrical axis of the heart in order to distinguish the true ECG signal from interference. 62 It is proving to be a particularly robust means for ECG gating and can be used to identify and reject arrhythmias. In some cases, gating using finger plethysmography may be preferred to ECG gating, given its ease of use. However, problems may then be encountered from finger motion or in patients with severe peripheral artery disease and weak pulses. Moreover, one must consider the additional delay in the
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
10 of 13
gating signal with respect to the R-wave (typically a few hundred milliseconds). For pulse gating, it is helpful to place a warm towel on the patient's hand to prevent vasoconstriction, and to instruct the patient not to move the fingers. Some pulse sequences used for the heart are uniquely useful for that organ. They tend to be implemented in a vendor- and application-specific manner, so it is difficult to make generalizations about optimal imaging parameters. Imaging protocols are reviewed in detail in the pertinent clinical chapters. Breath-holding is used for most cardiac imaging sequences. A notable exception is coronary artery MR angiography, where respiratory-gated navigator methods may be preferred. Compared with standard sequences, one must decide whether to acquire cine (e.g., FIESTA, trueFISP, balanced-SSFP) or single-phase acquisitions. Both are useful. Cine is the method of choice for studies of ventricular function, valve motion, and flow patterns and quantification. For cine, the number of phaseencoding lines per cardiac phase must be selected (e.g., 4 to 12). The use of more lines shortens the scan duration (which depends on the number of R-R intervals required to accumulate all the data) at the expense of temporal resolution (equal to the TR × number of lines). For single-phase techniques, one must select a trigger delay. A delay on the order of 60% to 80% of the R-R interval permits imaging during end-diastole, when the motion of the heart is least apparent. In certain circumstances, imaging at end-systole may be preferred. An example would be in the setting of suspected right ventricular dysplasia. Since the right ventricular free wall is extremely thin and difficult to evaluate during diastole, end-systolic imaging may be advantageous since the myocardium is thicker. A similar argument applies for imaging of myocardial delayed enhancement. However, imaging near end-systole entails more risk of motion artifact degrading the image than imaging during end-diastole. Dynamic imaging methods permit evaluation of myocardial perfusion during the first pass of a paramagnetic contrast agent. Stress pharmaceutical agents such as adenosine may also be required. Various fast imaging techniques are employed including echo train gradient-echo (FGRET), inversion recovery-prepared single-shot trueFISP, and others. Despite the obvious benefits and necessity of ECG gating for cardiac MRI, outside of the heart it should only be used when needed. Drawbacks include: 1. more cumbersome and time-consuming patient preparation, 2. lengthened data acquisition, 3. difficulty obtaining a reliable gating signal, and 4. dependence of T1 weighting on the R-R interval instead of TR.
Oversampling to Eliminate Wrap-around Oversampling methods acquire an expanded matrix (typically up to 512 pixels) along either or both the frequency and the phase directions to eliminate wraparound artifact. The extra pixels that contain the wrapped portion of the image are discarded, so that only the central 256 pixels are displayed. In the frequency direction, there is no time penalty for using oversampling. In the phase direction, the scan time increases in direct proportion to the percentage of oversampling, because additional phase encodes must be acquired.
Gradient Rotation (Phase Frequency Swap) page 103 page 104
The user determines the orientation of the phase-encoding axis. By reorienting the phase-encoding axis by 90°, it may be possible to keep ghost artifacts off the region of interest. For axial brain imaging, the phase-encoding axis is typically oriented horizontally (swapped) to direct artifacts from eye motion away from the brain. For spine imaging, the phase-encoding axis may be oriented parallel to the long axis of the spine to prevent ghost artifacts from respiratory motion and vascular pulsation. Axial images of the upper abdomen usually have the phase-encoding axis oriented from anterior to posterior of the patient so that blood flow artifacts from the inferior vena cava and aorta are away from the liver and kidneys. However, if the left lobe of the liver is the area of interest, the user may wish to swap the phaseencoding direction so that it is oriented from left to right, thus moving aortic ghost artifact off the left lobe of the liver.
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
11 of 13
A major limitation of gradient rotation is wrap-around artifact when the phase-encoding axis is oriented along the long axis of the body. Suppression of wrap-around requires concomitant use of oversampling methods. In conclusion, we see that there are numerous practical considerations involved in the production of high-quality MR images. Although this chapter offers recommendations for optimizing MRI examinations, there are no panaceas. One must experiment with different imaging parameters and decide for oneself what best suits the needs of a particular MRI site and the physicians involved there. REFERENCES 1. http://www.ismrm.org/mr_sites.htm 2. http://www.users.on.net/~vision/#education 3. http://www.mr-tip.com/serv1.php 4. Saunders RD, Smith H: Safety aspects of NMR clinical imaging. Br Med Bull 40:148-154, 1984. Medline Similar articles 5. Slifer KJ, Penn-Jones K, Cataldo MF, et al: Music enhances patients' comfort during MR imaging. Am J Roentgenol 156:403, 1991. Letter. 6. Brummett RE, Talbot JM, Charuhas P: Potential hearing loss resulting from MR imaging. Radiology 169:539-540, 1988. Medline Similar articles 7. Freinhar JP, Alvarez WA: Organic claustrophobia: an association between panic and carbon dioxide? Int J Psychosom 34:18-19, 1987. Medline Similar articles 8. Accreditation Manual for Hospitals, Volume I-Standards. Oakbrook Terrace, IL: Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations, 1994. 9. Holshouser BA, Hinshaw DB, Shellock F: Sedation, anesthesia, and physiologic monitoring during MR imaging: evaluation of procedures and equipment. J Magn Reson Imaging 3:553-558, 1993. Medline Similar articles 10. http://www.fda.gov/cdrh/ode/guidance/793.pdf 11. Kangarlu A, Burgess RE, Zu H, et al: Cognitive, cardiac and physiological studies in ultra high field magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 17:1407-1416, 1999. Medline Similar articles 12. Schenck JF: Safety of strong, static magnetic fields. J Magn Reson Imaging 12:2-19, 2000. Medline
Similar articles
13. http://www.mrisafety.com/ 14. http://www.fda.gov/cdrh/ode/odeclip.pdf 15. Sakakibara Y, Mitsui T: Concerns about sources of electromagnetic interference in patients with pacemakers. Jpn Heart J 40:737-743, 1999. Medline Similar articles 16. Luechinger R, Zeijlemaker VA, Pedersen EM, et al: In vivo heating of pacemaker leads during magnetic resonance imaging. Eur Heart J 26:376-383, 2005. Medline Similar articles 17. Martin ET: Can cardiac pacemakers and magnetic resonance imaging systems co-exist? Eur Heart J 26:325-327, 2005. Medline Similar articles 18. Institute for Safe Medical Practices, Medical Safety Alert! Burns in MRI patients wearing transdermal patches. www.ismp.org/msarticles/burnsprint.htm December 7, 2004. 19. Shellock FG, Kanal E: Policies, guidelines, and recommendations for MR imaging safety and patient management. J Magn Reson Imaging 1:97-101, 1991. Medline Similar articles 20. http://www.fda.gov/cdrh/safety/mrisafety.html 21. http://www.mrireview.com/docs/mrideath.pdf 22. Kanal E, Gillen J, Evans J, et al: Survey of reproductive health among female MR workers. Radiology 187:395-399, 1993. Medline Similar articles 23. U.S. Food and Drug Administration: Magnetic resonance diagnostic device: panel recommendation and report on petitions for MR reclassification. Final rule. Fed Regist 54:5077-5078, 1988. 24. Stephenson GM, Freiherr G: Indifference to safety heightens MRI risks. Diagn Imag June:79-83, 1990. 25. Kanal E, Shellock FG, Talagala L: Safety considerations in MR imaging. Radiology 176:593-606, 1990. Medline Similar articles 26. Devine EC, Cook TD: Clinical and cost-saving effects of psychoeducational interventions with surgical patients: a meta-analysis. Res Nurs Health 9:89-105, 1986. Medline Similar articles 27. Devine EC, Cook TD: A meta-analytic analysis of effects of psychoeducational interventions on length of postsurgical hospital stay. Nurs Res 32:267-273, 1983. Medline Similar articles 28. Flaherty JA, Hoskinson K: Emotional distress during magnetic resonance imaging. N Engl J Med 320:467-468, 1989. Medline Similar articles
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
12 of 13
29. Melendez JC, McCrank E: Anxiety related reactions associated with magnetic resonance imaging examination. JAMA 270:745-747, 1993. Medline Similar articles 30. Quirk ME, Letendre AJ, Coittone RA, et al: Evaluation of three psychologic interventions to reduce anxiety during MR imaging. Radiology 173:759-762, 1989. Medline Similar articles 31. Abrahams JJ, Lange RC: Coil holder and marker system for MR imaging of the total spine. Radiology 172:869-871, 1989. Medline Similar articles 32. Henck ME, Simpson EL: Superiority of cod liver oil as a marker for lesions in MR imaging of the extremities. Am J Roentgenol 161:904-905, 1993. 33. Chernish SM, Maglinte DD: Glucagon: common untoward reactions-review and recommendations. Radiology 177:145-146, 1990. Medline Similar articles 34. Brennan S, Redd W, Jacobsen P, et al: Anxiety and panic during magnetic resonance scans. Lancet 2:512, 1988. Medline Similar articles 35. Quirk ME, Letendre AJ, Coittone RA, et al: Anxiety in patients undergoing MR imaging. Radiology 170:463-466, 1989. Medline Similar articles 36. Beck A, Emery G: Anxiety Disorders and Phobias. New York: Basic Books, 1985. 37. Thompson MB, Coppens NM: The effects of guided imagery on anxiety levels and movement of clients undergoing magnetic resonance imaging. Holistic Nurse Pract 8:59-69, 1994. 38. http://www.esmrmb.org/ 39. http://www.esmrmb.org/download/03-12-18-EUR-EMFW-st13599r-text-en.pdf 40. Roemer PB, Edelstein WA, Hayes CE, et al: The NMR phased array. Magn Reson Med 16:192-225, 1990. Medline Similar articles 41. McCauley TR, McCarthy S, Lange R: Pelvic phases array coil: image quality assessment for spin-echo MR imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 10:513-522, 1992. Medline Similar articles 42. Li W, Storey P, Chen Q, et al: Dark flow artifacts in steady-state free precession cine technique: causes and implications for cardiac MR imaging. Radiology 230:569-575, 2004. Medline Similar articles 43. Danias PG, Stuber M, Botnar RM, et al: Navigator assessment of breath-hold duration: impact of supplemental oxygen and hyperventilation. Am J Roentgenol 171:395-397, 1998. 44. Li W, David V, Kaplan R, et al: Three-dimensional low-dose gadolinium-enhanced peripheral magnetic resonance venography. J Magn Reson Imaging 8:630-633, 1998. Medline Similar articles 45. Prince MR, Erel HE, Lent RW, et al: Gadodiamide 2003. Medline Similar articles
administration causes spurious hypocalcemia. Radiology 227:639-649,
46. Rutt BK, Lee DH: The impact of field strength on image quality in MRI. J Magn Reson Imaging 1:57-62, 1996. 47. Alster AD: Field-strength dependence of gadolinium enhancement: Theory and implications. Am J Neuroradiol 15:1420-1423, 1994. 48. Trattnig S, Ba-Ssalamah A, Noebauer-Huhmann I, et al: MR contrast agent in high-field MRI (3 Tesla). Top Magn Reson Imaging 14:365-375, 2003. Medline Similar articles 49. Brateman L: Chemical shift imaging: a review. Am J Roentgenol 146:971-980, 1986. 50. Brix G, Heiland S, Bellemann SE, et al: MR imaging of fat-containing tissues: valuation of two quantitative imaging techniques in comparison with localized proton spectroscopy. Magn Reson Imaging 11:977-991, 1993. Medline Similar articles 51. Pfleiderer B, Ackerman JL, Garrido L: In vivo 1H chemical shift imaging of silicone implants. Magn Reson Med 29:656-659, 1993. 52. Anzai Y, Lufkin RB, Jabour BA, et al: Fat-suppression failure artifacts simulating pathology on frequency-selective fat-suppression MR images of the head and neck. Am J Neuroradiol 13:879-884, 1992. Medline Similar articles 53. Spielman D, Meyer C, Macovski A, et al: 1H spectroscopic imaging using a spectral-spatial excitation pulse. Magn Reson Med 18:269-279, 1991. Medline Similar articles 54. Dixon WT: Simple proton spectroscopic imaging. Radiology 153:189-194, 1984. Medline
Similar articles
55. Schneider E, Chan TW: Selective MR imaging of silicone with the three-point Dixon technique. Radiology 187:89-93, 1993. Medline Similar articles 56. Wolff SD, Balaban RS: Magnetization transfer contrast (MTC) and tissue water proton relaxation in vivo. Magn Reson Med 10:135-144, 1989. Medline Similar articles 57. Balaban RS, Ceckler TL: Magnetization transfer contrast in magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Q 8:116-137, 1992. Medline Similar articles 58. Edelman RR, Ahn SS, Chien D, et al: Improved time-of-flight MR angiography of the brain using magnetization transfer contrast. Radiology 184:359-399, 1992. 59. Tan Hu JI, Sepponen RE, Lipton MJ, et al: Synergistic enhancement of MRI with Gd-DTPA and magnetization transfer. J Comput Assist Tomogr 16:19-24, 1992. Medline Similar articles 60. Dousset V, Grossman RI, Ramer KN, et al: Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis and multiple sclerosis: lesion
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC003082
13 of 13
characterization with magnetization transfer imaging. Radiology 182:483-491, 1992. Medline
Similar articles
61. Dixon WT, Engels H, Castillo M, et al: Incidental magnetization transfer contrast in standard multislice imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 8:417-422, 1990. Medline Similar articles 62. Chia JM, Fischer SE, Wickline SA, et al: Performance of QRS detection for cardiac magnetic resonance imaging with a novel vectorcardiographic triggering method. J Magn Reson Imaging 12:678-688, 2000. Medline Similar articles
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:48
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00403068
1 of 3
NSTRUMENTATION Ricardo J. Becerra Michael J. Harsh Eddy B. Boskamp Ceylan C. Guclu Tomas Duby Timothy J. Havens R. Scott Hinks Jeffrey P. Noonan William T. Peterson Stanley J. Piepenburg Robert S. Stormont Robert M. Vavrek
INTRODUCTION The discovery of magnetic resonance imaging was a spectacular event in the history of medical imaging. In 1946, two scientists in the United States reported the phenomenon called "Nuclear Magnetic Resonance," or 1-4 "NMR" for short. Felix Bloch and Edward M. Purcell were awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1952. Since then, the NMR technique has been extensively used to study molecular chemical structure. In the early 1970s, Raymond Damadian showed the relaxation time differences between normal and cancerous tissues. In 1972, he patented a method of obtaining a localized MR signal using a so-called "single-point" 5 technique. In 1973, Paul Lauterbur demonstrated that the NMR technique, when combined with field gradients, can be 6 utilized to image an object. He called this NMR imaging technique "zeugmatography" derived from Greek word "zeugma," meaning "joins together," due to simultaneous use of static magnetic and radiofrequency (RF) fields. Shortly after this invention, Mansfield's group in Nottingham devised the selective excitation method with 7,8 gradients, which is frequently used in today's MRI scanners. Later the term NMR Imaging was changed to "MRI" (Magnetic Resonance Imaging, sometimes abbreviated further to MR). The word "nuclear" was removed to avoid confusion with other medical imaging modalities using ionizing radiation. 9 From 1974 to 1976, MRI was mainly used for imaging animals and phantoms. In 1977 the first in vivo crosssectional image of a human finger was acquired, followed by an abdominal image by Peter Mansfield and his 10 team.
Since its conception, MRI has witnessed tremendous technical and clinical advancements. This trend continues today as new technologies and clinical applications are discovered. See the reference section of this chapter for additional literature about the history of MR imaging. page 105 page 106
When analyzing an MRI scanner, it should be kept in mind that it is hard to separate the description of MRI hardware from that of MR physics. Hence, it is recommended that the reader first review the MR physics chapter to have an understanding of the origin of the MRI signal, and how the phase and frequency of the MRI signal are controlled. There are three basic field components in MRI: static magnetic field (B0), radiofrequency field (B1), and the gradient field (Gx, Gy, and Gz). These fields put specific sets of requirements on the environment where the MRI system is installed. These requirements are known as "siting" and ensure the safe and proper operation of the MRI system. The hardware structure of an MRI scanner naturally follows a similar pattern. Figure 4-1 shows a typical top-level breakdown of the MRI system. The magnet (1) is the source of the B0 static magnetic field. Although a cylindrical magnet is shown in Figure 4-1 as an example, other configurations are possible as described in the Magnets section.
11-04-2010 23:49
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00403068
2 of 3
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-1 Simplified block diagram of a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) system. 1, Cylindrical magnet; 2, Gradient coil; 3, RF body coil; 4, Patient; 5, Patient table; 6, Head coil; 7, Transmit/receive chain; 8, imaging display.
The RF field B1 is either transmitted by the body RF coil (3) or by an anatomy-specific transmit-receive (T/R) coil. Recent advances in surface coil technology and reconstruction techniques introduced a variety of new coil 11 designs that improve both image quality and reduce scan time, respectively. The gradient fields that are used for spatial encoding, are generated by the gradient coils (2) in the magnet bore. The echo (or FID) detected by the receive coil is linked to and sampled by the receiver. It is then directed to a file called the "raw data" file. All these events happen in synchrony with the pulse sequence prescribed for the exam. Here is a brief functional overview of the sequence of events for a patient (4) scan in an MRI scanner. The patient is prepared first by the technologist who takes care of patient safety, and places the coils on the patient. Once the landmark (origin of the scan location) is set, and the patient is in the scanner, the prescribed protocol is entered. The protocol is a set of parameter settings for the pulse sequence being prescribed. When the protocol is loaded, the "pulse sequence generation and control unit" generates the gradient, and RF waveforms, and prepares the system for data acquisition. The RF pulse generated goes through the RF amplifier and feeds the transmit RF coil. Similarly, the x, y, and z gradient waveforms are amplified by the gradient amplifiers (also known as "gradient drivers") and feed the gradient coils in accordance with the waveforms prescribed by the current protocol. The receive portion of the RF subsystem, consisting of the receive coil, preamplifier, T/R switch (7), and receiver, samples the echo (or FID) to be written into the raw data file. Finally at the end of the scan, the raw data is reconstructed and processed to form the final images displayed on the monitor (8). page 106 page 107
In the following sections, all of the above subsystems shall be explained, including magnet, RF, and gradient. In addition, we will elaborate on siting, pulse sequence generator and system calibration.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010)
11-04-2010 23:49
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00403068
3 of 3
© 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:49
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004001
1 of 3
INTRODUCTION The discovery of magnetic resonance imaging was a spectacular event in the history of medical imaging. In 1946, two scientists in the United States reported the phenomenon called "Nuclear Magnetic Resonance," or 1-4 "NMR" for short. Felix Bloch and Edward M. Purcell were awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1952. Since then, the NMR technique has been extensively used to study molecular chemical structure. In the early 1970s, Raymond Damadian showed the relaxation time differences between normal and cancerous tissues. In 1972, he patented a method of obtaining a localized MR signal using a so-called "single-point" 5 technique. In 1973, Paul Lauterbur demonstrated that the NMR technique, when combined with field gradients, can be 6 utilized to image an object. He called this NMR imaging technique "zeugmatography" derived from Greek word "zeugma," meaning "joins together," due to simultaneous use of static magnetic and radiofrequency (RF) fields. Shortly after this invention, Mansfield's group in Nottingham devised the selective excitation method with 7,8 gradients, which is frequently used in today's MRI scanners. Later the term NMR Imaging was changed to "MRI" (Magnetic Resonance Imaging, sometimes abbreviated further to MR). The word "nuclear" was removed to avoid confusion with other medical imaging modalities using ionizing radiation. 9 From 1974 to 1976, MRI was mainly used for imaging animals and phantoms. In 1977 the first in vivo crosssectional image of a human finger was acquired, followed by an abdominal image by Peter Mansfield and his 10 team.
Since its conception, MRI has witnessed tremendous technical and clinical advancements. This trend continues today as new technologies and clinical applications are discovered. See the reference section of this chapter for additional literature about the history of MR imaging. page 105 page 106
When analyzing an MRI scanner, it should be kept in mind that it is hard to separate the description of MRI hardware from that of MR physics. Hence, it is recommended that the reader first review the MR physics chapter to have an understanding of the origin of the MRI signal, and how the phase and frequency of the MRI signal are controlled. There are three basic field components in MRI: static magnetic field (B0), radiofrequency field (B1), and the gradient field (Gx, Gy, and Gz). These fields put specific sets of requirements on the environment where the MRI system is installed. These requirements are known as "siting" and ensure the safe and proper operation of the MRI system. The hardware structure of an MRI scanner naturally follows a similar pattern. Figure 4-1 shows a typical top-level breakdown of the MRI system. The magnet (1) is the source of the B0 static magnetic field. Although a cylindrical magnet is shown in Figure 4-1 as an example, other configurations are possible as described in the Magnets section.
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004001
2 of 3
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-1 Simplified block diagram of a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) system. 1, Cylindrical magnet; 2, Gradient coil; 3, RF body coil; 4, Patient; 5, Patient table; 6, Head coil; 7, Transmit/receive chain; 8, imaging display.
The RF field B1 is either transmitted by the body RF coil (3) or by an anatomy-specific transmit-receive (T/R) coil. Recent advances in surface coil technology and reconstruction techniques introduced a variety of new coil 11 designs that improve both image quality and reduce scan time, respectively. The gradient fields that are used for spatial encoding, are generated by the gradient coils (2) in the magnet bore. The echo (or FID) detected by the receive coil is linked to and sampled by the receiver. It is then directed to a file called the "raw data" file. All these events happen in synchrony with the pulse sequence prescribed for the exam. Here is a brief functional overview of the sequence of events for a patient (4) scan in an MRI scanner. The patient is prepared first by the technologist who takes care of patient safety, and places the coils on the patient. Once the landmark (origin of the scan location) is set, and the patient is in the scanner, the prescribed protocol is entered. The protocol is a set of parameter settings for the pulse sequence being prescribed. When the protocol is loaded, the "pulse sequence generation and control unit" generates the gradient, and RF waveforms, and prepares the system for data acquisition. The RF pulse generated goes through the RF amplifier and feeds the transmit RF coil. Similarly, the x, y, and z gradient waveforms are amplified by the gradient amplifiers (also known as "gradient drivers") and feed the gradient coils in accordance with the waveforms prescribed by the current protocol. The receive portion of the RF subsystem, consisting of the receive coil, preamplifier, T/R switch (7), and receiver, samples the echo (or FID) to be written into the raw data file. Finally at the end of the scan, the raw data is reconstructed and processed to form the final images displayed on the monitor (8). page 106 page 107
In the following sections, all of the above subsystems shall be explained, including magnet, RF, and gradient. In addition, we will elaborate on siting, pulse sequence generator and system calibration.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010)
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004001
3 of 3
© 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004002
1 of 4
SITING
Overview The MRI scanner is a very sensitive device. The process of detecting the minuscule signal emitted from hydrogen nuclei precessing in a magnetic field creates conditions for sensitivity to external disturbances. Likewise, many devices in the vicinity of an MRI magnet may be sensitive to the magnet's fringe field. Siting considers the impact of the site on the scanner, and the impact of the scanner on the site.
Magnetic Field-Impact of the Scanner on the Site The first considerations deal with the magnetic fringe field. For safety reasons, an exclusion zone is defined around the magnet. The exclusion zone is an area where the magnetic flux density is greater than five gauss. Personnel with cardiac pacemakers, neurostimulators and other biostimulation devices must not enter this zone. Since the magnetic field is three-dimensional, the floors above and below the magnet room would have exclusion zones if the five gauss line intruded into these spaces. This was a problem with early superconductive cylindrical magnets, which lacked the actively shielded coil. Actively shielded magnets have considerably reduced fringe fields. The fringe field may adversely affect equipment in close proximity to the scanner. Likewise, equipment in close proximity may disrupt the performance of the scanner. Proximity limits are distance limitations placed on equipment to minimize the magnet's fringe field effect on certain equipment. A few examples of typical proximity limits are listed in Box 4-1.
Magnetic Field-Impact of the Site on the Scanner Structural steel within proximity of the magnet may have an impact on the homogeneity or uniformity of the field within the magnet bore. The magnet's field homogeneity is an important criterion that impacts the image quality of the scanner. Homogeneity requirements for imaging are just as stringent as the homogeneity requirements for chemical shift analysis (spectroscopy). Since the structural steel usually cannot be removed, its effect must be countered. One approach is to add additional iron to magnetically balance out the structural steel. If the iron is placed within the magnet bore, substantially smaller amounts of iron than that of the structural steel are needed to balance out the disturbance. The MRI scanner may also be sensitive to a changing magnetic environment, such as large ferrous objects. When large metal objects are close to the magnet, the magnet's field homogeneity is affected, sometimes severely. As the large metal object is moved away from the magnet, the severity and complexity of the magnetic field inhomogeneity decreases. At a far enough distance, only a linear gradient across the magnetic field may be detected. Further out, this linear gradient disturbance disappears, but the large metal object may still have an impact on the magnetic field by shifting the static field strength (B0) slightly. If the object doesn't move, the typical scanner prescan self-calibration will adjust for this frequency shift. But if the object moves during a scan, there will be a shift in B0, which may cause some degradation of the image quality. Moving metal refers to metal objects that move inside of the moving metal sensitivity line during system scan. Typically, the moving metal sensitivity line is the 3 gauss fringe field line. For example, cars being driven inside the moving metal sensitivity line are moving metal. However, if a car or truck is within the moving metal sensitivity line and does not move during a scan, it may not be an issue. An MRI suite immediately adjacent to a road requires extra scrutiny with regard to siting. Most alternating current (AC) equipment in sites is not an issue if kept outside the 5 gauss line. Electrical currents flowing in high voltage power lines, transformers, and large generators or motors near the magnet can affect the magnetic field homogeneity that is essential to the proper performance of the MRI system. Magnetic field interference at 50 or 60 Hz usually must not exceed a value in the milligauss range at the magnet location.
Box 4-1 Proximity Limits
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004002
0.5 gauss (0.05 mT) or less* Nuclear cameras 1 gauss (0.1 mT) or less Positron emission tomography (PET) scanner Image intensifiers CRT video display (color, B/W, monochrome) CT (computed tomography) scanner Ultrasound Electron microscope 5 gauss (0.5 mT) or less Cardiac pacemakers Neurostimulators Biostimulators 10 gauss (1 mT) or less Magnetic tapes and floppy discs Hard copy imagers Line printers Video cassette recorder (VCR) Film processor Credit cards, watches, and clocks X-ray tubes 50 gauss (5 mT) or less Telephones Metal detector for screening LCD color monitor *At this low level of magnetic field, the earth's magnetic field (~0.5 gauss) will significantly influence the shape of the 0.5 gauss line. page 107 page 108
Acoustics and Vibrations-Impact of the Scanner on the Site A typical MR suite has two types of acoustic noise issues. The first is the acoustics of the room, where patients and technicians are affected by the noise of the MRI system as the gradients are pulsed. The second is noise transmitted to surrounding spaces via airborne and structure-borne paths. Airborne transmission is defined as air excitation within the magnet room. The magnet and gradient coil generate acoustic noise. Current must pass through the gradient coil to create the necessary imaging gradients and the gradient coil lies within the magnet bore. The result of the interaction between current and magnetic field is a force (Lorentz force law) on the coil. This is the same fundamental principle that makes a loudspeaker work. Noise generated by the MRI system is inherent to the design of the system. The human ear has a large dynamic range covering orders of magnitude of sound pressure levels. A logarithmic scale in decibels (dBA) is often used. The sound pressure level at 120 dBA is one million times greater than the threshold of hearing at 0 dBA. Normal speech is about 60 dBA. It is typically a challenge to reduce the sound pressure level by a factor of 10 (20 dBA). The airborne noise passes through walls via any openings (i.e., small holes, cracks, HVAC ducts, and wave-guides) into surrounding spaces within, and possibly beyond, the confines of the building. Acoustic energy can transmit across significant distances. Acoustic noise control to mitigate noise from being transmitted to other spaces often amounts to paying attention to small details while working with
2 of 4
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004002
ordinary construction materials. The key objectives are eliminating all cracks and gaps in the wall construction while making sure that doors, walls, floor, and ceiling have adequate transmission loss via mass or special double wall construction along with good fitting massive doors. The structure-borne transmission path is the result of mechanical excitation of the floor/building structure causing the building to vibrate. The vibration of the surfaces at surrounding spaces then radiates as acoustic noise. Upper floor MRI installations represent the largest number of sites that experience structure-borne acoustic issues. Typically, an architect, acoustic engineer, or project engineer might suggest placing the magnet on a soft vibration isolator. Although this solution may reduce the magnet-generated vibration from transmitting into the building structure, this solution can produce image quality issues if the magnet "bounces" on the soft isolator.
Acoustics and Vibrations-Impact of the Site on the Scanner Environmental site vibration has the ability to affect the magnet phase stability and ultimately image quality. Certain MRI procedures require a stable environment to achieve high-resolution image quality. The vibration effects on image quality can be minimized early in MRI suite site planning. The magnet may be sensitive to vibration in the frequency range of 0.5 to 100 Hz depending on the amplitude of the vibration. In the physical area where the MRI system is located, every precaution must be taken to ensure that the vibration is minimized. In the magnet siting area, the structural stability and behavioral characteristics should be assessed. Vibration capable of affecting MR image quality can be classified as either steady-state or transient vibration. Steady-state vibration typically refers to disturbances caused by rotating machinery. Examples of machinery known to have generated vibration image quality problems are exhaust fans, air-conditioning blower units, compressors, pumps (air and water), etc. Steady-state vibration would be measurable during long time intervals. Transient vibrations are typically a function of the building structure or the building foundation. They are associated with vehicular traffic, pedestrian motion, patient transport, door slamming, etc. Transient vibration would usually occur during short periods of time, and it typically decays from high vibration amplitude to lower levels. Magnets improperly mechanically coupled to the floor may experience steady-state and/or transient vibration system stability issues.
Radio Frequency Interference The MRI system utilizes RF signals from the patient to create the MR image and is vulnerable to ambient Radio Frequency Interference (RFI). For a 1.5 T scanner, this would be any unwanted RF signal around 64 MHz. There are many electrical devices that create RF noise across a broad range of frequencies in the Megahertz range. Spectroscopy may require multiple frequency bands to be clean for any given field strength. To protect the MRI system from ambient RFI, and to protect any local equipment from MRI RF transmission, sites require an RF enclosure, which is commonly called an RF shielded room or an RF screen room. Radiofrequency signals from sources outside of the RF shielded room are attenuated as they pass into it so they do not interfere with the MRI system. Likewise, RF signals produced by the MRI scanner are kept from interfering with external RF devices. A typical shield attenuation value is 100 dB at 64 MHz. This RF quiet environment is necessary for the MRI system to produce quality images. Radiofrequency shielded rooms come in a variety of shapes and sizes but one common feature is a total RF shield produced by one continuous ground plane. This is achieved by making the walls, floor, doors and ceiling out of an electrically conductive material such as copper, aluminum, brass, or steel. All the room components (walls, floor, ceiling, etc.) must be electrically bonded together to form one solid, common ground plane. Once this is established the ground plane is then tied to earth ground to create the RF shield. This ground point is known as the primary ground. The primary grounding technique works well for any battery powered devices that may be operated within the RF shield room. But since the scanner requires the introduction of facility power into the screen room, a change is
3 of 4
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004002
4 of 4
required. The RF shielded room must now be grounded back to the facility power ground. page 108 page 109
The addition of water systems or other grounds will connect the RF shield room ground to earth ground. These additional grounds are called secondary grounds. It is the secondary grounding that needs to be controlled. If the secondary ground introduces any current to the RF shield, indicating the RF shield is a better ground path than the secondary ground, then the current can set up electrical fields on the surface of the RF shield, which may cause image artifacts.
Other Concerns In the case of a superconducting magnet used in the MRI system, the magnet contains a large amount of liquid helium at 4 kelvin (K) = -452º fahrenheit (F) or -269º celsius (C). During a quench, the magnet quickly boils off 100% of this liquid. Consequently, a very large volume of extremely cold helium gas must be safely vented outside of the building. Failure of the cryogenic vent can result in this cold gas entering the magnet room or another portion of the building, and lowering the ambient oxygen supply to an unsafe and potentially lethal level. When a quench occurs, the helium gas will immediately begin to warm up and expand rapidly. As the gas escapes from the magnet, the helium gas will increase in temperature from 4.5 K to approximately 10 K to 150 K depending on the location along the pipe. As a result, the gas will expand to between 25 and 400 times its original volume. Therefore, it is critical that designers/contractors familiar with industrial piping systems be responsible for the vent system design and installation. Temperature and humidity within the scan room must be controlled, and the MRI manufacturer is responsible for providing the requirements. The air conditioning system must be sufficient to remove any heat created by the scanner to maintain an optimal temperature for the patient. This is not only a comfort issue for the patient, but it is a safety issue that relates to specific absorption rate (SAR). The maximum SAR allowed is a function of the temperature and humidity of the patient environment. The higher either of these are, the more the peak SAR must be reduced. Finally, siting an MRI scanner involves some other issues, such as where to place the equipment. The manufacturer provides the physical, magnetic, electrical data and cryogenic and plumbing (in the case of superconducting magnet) necessary for planning and preparing a site for a magnetic resonance imaging system. Work that may be necessary for site preparation is shown in Box 4-2.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:51
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
1 of 15
MAGNET TECHNOLOGIES
Overview The magnet is the heart of the MRI system, and its function is to provide a strong, uniform and stable magnetic field (B0) for polarizing the nuclei in the patient. Magnetic resonance imaging has been performed in B0 fields lower than 0.1 T, and as high as 9.4 T; however, most diagnostic imaging is performed at B0 fields between 0.2 and 3.0 T. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in the image increases approximately linearly with increasing magnetic field strength. This increased SNR of higher field scanners can be used to improve image quality or image resolution, or to increase scanning speed. These benefits have led to an increase in the use of magnets with field strengths of 1.5 T and higher.
Homogeneity Today, magnet and MRI manufacturers use several methods to specify their products. These methods, although equivalent, express the homogeneity differently. One of the popular methods is simply to specify the maximum variation in the field over the imaging volume. This homogeneity measure is called "peak-to-peak" homogeneity and is typically measured at a number of points on the surface of the imaging volume with a mechanical probe called a "magnetometer" or an array of such probes called a "probe array." Since the homogeneity is measured at a finite set of points on the surface of the imaging volume, it may not measure the absolute minimum and maximum of the field over the entire volume. The measured peak-to-peak value will approach the true peak-to-peak homogeneity value as more points on the surface of the imaging volume are included. A second method of specifying the homogeneity is to take the root-mean-squared (rms) value of the magnetic field values obtained in the above process. This is called the "surface rms" homogeneity, or simply the rms homogeneity.
Box 4-2 Site Preparation Work Site construction or renovation. Installation of the electrical conduit, junction boxes, ducts, surface raceways, outlets, and line safety switches. Installation of nonelectrical lines: water plumbing, helium venting, and air conditioning. Installation of air, vacuum and oxygen lines into the magnet room. Installation of RF shielding in magnet room. Installation of structural reinforcements. Installation of selected magnetic equipment. Installation of water treatment equipment. page 109 page 110
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
2 of 15
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-2 Homogeneous magnetic field (B0) in a cylindrical magnet. Established by using several electrical coils. The direction of the resultant magnetic field (B0) is determined by the direction of the current in the coils, as shown by the arrows. This concept applies to both resistive and superconducting magnets.
A third method of specifying the homogeneity involves computing the rms value of the homogeneity across the whole imaging volume. This is called the "volume rms" or "Vrms homogeneity." Since it is not possible to measure the homogeneity across the entire imaging volume with a mechanical probe, some manufacturers have devised methods for computing the rms value across the imaging volume with the imaging system and a large phantom. However, the Vrms can also be computed from the mechanical field measurements and the mathematical expansion of the magnetic field described in the shimming section at the end of the magnet section.12 Until all manufacturers adopt a standard measurement technique, one must examine manufacturers' homogeneity specifications with care. The method used to express homogeneity in the rest of this chapter is "peak-to-peak."
Image Quality The uniformity or homogeneity of the B0 field, affects image quality via T2* decay, spectral resolution and geometric distortion. For example, water and fat molecules have slightly different resonant frequencies in the same magnetic field, separated by approximately 3.5 parts per million (ppm). In high-field systems (>0.5 T) this frequency separation is high enough to be resolved and used to distinguish between fat and water. Thus most high-field fat saturation techniques, used in high-field systems, for eliminating fat from images require field homogeneity to be less than 3 ppm. Otherwise, the fat suppression will fail as the homogeneity over the image approaches/exceeds this 3.5 ppm field variation. Fortunately, most imaging techniques can be performed adequately within field homogeneity of 10 ppm. The other property of the static magnetic field critical for image quality is the stability. Image artifacts such as ghosting are created by variations in the main magnetic field as low as 0.002 μT. Consequently, the stability of the magnetic field required for imaging is on the order of parts-per-billion (ppb) in the 1 Hz to 100 Hz frequency range.
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-3 Static magnetic field (B0) produced by permanently magnetized pole faces. Orientation of the magnetic field is perpendicular to the pole faces, vertical in this example.
There are several magnet technologies used in the design and manufacture of MRI magnets that attempt to meet these requirements for very high, uniform, and stable magnetic fields. Listed in order of increasing popularity, these technologies are resistive coils (resistive), permanent magnetic material (permanent), and superconducting coils (superconducting). Resistive and superconducting magnets both use electrical coils with circulating direct currents (DC) to establish the B0 field (Fig. 4-2). Permanent magnets on the other hand, use pole faces made of permanently magnetized material to establish the B0 field (Fig. 4-3).
Resistive Magnet Technology page 110 page 111
Technically, resistive coil magnets are the simplest to understand and manufacture. A large and stable DC power supply is required to keep circulating currents in the resistive coils to establish and maintain the B0 field. In addition, a large cooling system is used to remove the large amount of heat dissipated by the resistive coils. Typical stability of the power supply is about 100 ppm and the power required ranges from 40 to 100 kW of electrical power, which is primarily dissipated by the resistive coils. Thus, the stability of the B0 field depends directly on the stability of the power supply and, therefore, it is usually poor. In addition, the large heat dissipated by the resistive coils limit the strength of the B0 field in whole-body MRI systems. The resulting poor B0 field stability, together with the limitations of resistive heating in the magnet winding, severely restricts the usefulness of resistive magnets. In some cases a resistive magnet's field is amplified by the addition of "soft" magnetic material such as iron. The iron is called "soft" because the material is magnetized while a background magnetic material is supplied, but decays after the background magnetic field is removed. Iron can be used in the "poles" of a resistive magnet in a manner similar to that used in a permanent magnet. Resistive magnets are typically smaller and of lower strength than superconducting magnets.
Permanent Magnet Next to superconducting magnet technology, the second most popular technology for MRI magnets is permanent magnetic material. This technology can be used to produce MRI magnets up to approximately 0.5 T. Permanent magnetic material is also called "hard" magnetic material, because,
3 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
4 of 15
once magnetized, it maintains its magnetization almost indefinitely. While several permanent magnetic materials have been known for some time, such as Alnico, barium ferrite (BaF12O19), and the rare-earth samarium cobalt (SmCo5), it wasn't until June of 1983 when Sumitomo Special Metals (SSM) of Japan announced the development of a new rare-earth permanent magnetic material, neodymium-iron boron (NdFeB) that a permanent magnet technology for MRI systems became real, as it is known today. Sagawa et al of SSM subsequently published a paper describing the compositional and processing details of NdFeB.13 This new material can be magnetized to a higher field per unit volume ("maximum energy product" BHmax) enabling higher field strength magnets with lower weight. One disadvantage of this rare-earth material is that its temperature sensitivity is much higher than the other materials listed above, but its ability to produce higher field per unit volume is considered to out-weigh this disadvantage. Therefore, most magnets manufactured for use in MRI systems today use neodymium-iron boron. Permanent magnetic material manufacturers are continually striving to improve the properties of this material to enable MRI magnet developers to design magnets with higher and more stable magnetic fields and lower weights.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-4 Permanent magnet and its associated components. The iron yoke and posts serve as mechanical structure and flux return. The pole pieces shape the B0 field. The permanently magnetized material is the source of magnetic flux, and the heaters keep the magnet at a constant temperature.
MRI magnets made of NdFeB typically have iron "pole pieces" for shaping the magnetic field, and iron yokes to support the pole pieces. The layout of a typical permanent MRI magnet is shown in Figure 4-4. These iron yokes serve not only as mechanical support, but also as flux return paths for the magnetic field. These flux return paths help increase magnetic field in the imaging volume, while reducing stray field from the magnet. The magnetic properties of both the iron and permanent magnetic material are temperature dependent. The magnetization of the iron changes roughly 100 ppm per degree celsius, and the magnetization of NeFeB has a temperature coefficient an order of magnitude higher. Thus, to produce an MRI system with a stable field, the temperature of the magnet must be controlled. Temperature control is accomplished by a closed-loop temperature control system composed of heaters and thermostats mounted on the magnet, and a precise controller. This temperature controller maintains the temperature of the magnet above the magnet room temperature and keeps the temperature constant within 0.1° C. The heaters of the permanent magnet MRI system are also shown in Figure 4-4. This figure depicts typical permanent magnet geometry, which is, in
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
general, more "open" than a cylindrical magnet. Thus, permanent magnet MRI systems are also frequently referred to as "open MRI" systems. Most of the permanent magnet geometries produce a vertical B0 field, compared with cylindrical magnets that produce a horizontal B0 field. This B0 field orientation causes a significant impact in the design of RF coils, which will be discussed later in the RF section. Fields achieved in the imaging region of commercial permanent magnet MRI systems range up to 0.4 T, with the most popular models in the 0.2 T to 0.35 T range. Benefits of the permanent magnets include low initial purchase cost, lower maintenance costs, and its inherent openness, which some patients prefer. The typical vertical patient gaps in whole-body systems are on the order of 45 cm, with imaging volumes on the order of 40 cm diameter spherical volumes. Design geometries include, C-shaped, 4 posts, and two-legged systems with posts at various angles between 90 and 180 degrees. The magnet shown in Figure 4-4 is a two-legged system with posts at 180 degrees. The weight of a typical 0.2 T whole-body system is approximately 10 tons, and the weight of a 0.35 T system is approximately 20 tons. The 5 G stray field region of these whole-body systems is normally constrained to an area within approximately 3 m of the center of the magnet. page 111 page 112
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-5 Example of a dedicated MRI system optimized for orthopedic applications. The system has field strength of 0.2 T and a field-of-view (FOV) in the order of 15 cm. The weight of this magnet is only 2 tons, and the 5 gauss line is only about 1.5 m from iso-center. This MRI product is the E-SCAN manufactured by Esaote.
In addition to the whole-body systems discussed above, smaller orthopedic systems have recently been introduced. One example of these extremity systems is shown in Figure 4-5. These systems offer the benefits of even lower cost and ease of siting. The B0 field of these systems is around 0.2 T and the homogeneity volumes approximately 15 cm diameter spherical volumes. The weights for these systems are on the order of 2 tons, and 5 G stray field lines are approximately 1.5 m from the magnet center.
Superconducting Magnet Technology Superconducting magnet technology is by far the most popular technology used in the MRI industry today, especially in high-field MRI systems. In 1911, the Dutch physicist Kamerlingh Onnes discovered that the electrical resistance of mercury fell to zero as it was cooled below 4.15 kelvin. This complete loss of resistance was termed "superconductivity," and many more materials have since been identified that also exhibit superconductivity. Each of these superconductors exhibits zero electrical resistance below a certain temperature, called its critical temperature. In addition to temperature, the background
5 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
6 of 15
magnetic field also affects the superconductivity of the superconductors. As the background field increases above a certain value called its "critical field," a superconductor becomes resistive and looses its superconductivity properties. Table 4-1 lists critical temperatures and critical fields for a few elements.
Table 4-1. Critical Temperatures and Critical Fields Element
Critical Temperature (K)
Critical Field (mT)
Indium (In)
3.41
28.7
Tin (Sn)
3.72
30.9
Mercury (Hg)
4.15
41.2
Tantalum (Ta)
4.48
82.9
Lead (Pb)
7.18
80.4
The critical fields listed in Table 4-1 for the pure elements are all well below the field strengths required for MRI magnets. These pure elements are labeled Type I superconductors. There is a second class of superconductors, called "Type II superconductors" that maintain their superconducting properties in high magnetic fields. Two commercially relevant Type II superconductors are niobium-titanium (NbTi) and niobium-tin (NbSn). The critical temperature of NbTi is 9 K and the critical field at 4.2 K is 14 approximately 11 T. Other types of superconductors have been discovered with critical temperatures above the temperature of liquid nitrogen (77 K). These types of superconductors are called "high temperature superconductors" (HTS). Today, the wire manufacturers are actively working to develop commercially viable high temperature superconducting wires, but there are still significant cost and manufacturing challenges. There are high hopes in the magnet community that this type of superconducting wire might be manufactured at a cost low enough to be competitive for use in MRI magnets. While it would seem easier to manufacture magnets using the superconductor with the highest critical temperature, most MRI magnets are manufactured using NbTi wire due to cost and reliability. The superconducting wire is made by embedding many small strands of superconductor (also known as filaments) approximately 0.1 mm diameter in a copper matrix approximately 2 mm in diameter. Figure 4-6 shows the relative size of the superconducting filaments and the copper matrix. When the superconducting wire is below its critical temperature, all of the current flows through the superconducting filaments. On the other hand, if the temperature of any section of the superconducting wire is raised above its critical temperature, the current flow transfers to the copper matrix avoiding damage to the superconducting filaments. This "copper stabilizer" significantly reduces a magnet's propensity to quench due to small disturbances of the coils.15 One exception to the use of NbTi is the magnet used in the GE SP interventional system shown in Figure 4-7. The windings in this magnet are made of Nb3Sn, allowing the magnet to operate at 10 K. At this temperature, it is possible to eliminate the use of cryogens and use conduction cooled technique to maintain the coils below their critical temperature. As the technology of manufacturing high temperature superconductors advances, one can expect to see more conduction cooled MRI magnets manufactured from these newer materials. page 112 page 113
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-6 Cross-section of a superconducting wire showing the superconducting filaments embedded in a copper matrix. The copper is the primary current conduction path for temperatures above the critical temperature of the superconducting wire. For temperatures below the critical temperature, the current flows in the filaments.
During the 1970s, significant advancements were made in the manufacturing of superconducting wire. In the 1980s, superconducting whole-body MRI magnets were developed. However, these magnets had large fringe fields and large amounts of iron were needed around the magnet or in the magnet room walls in order to contain the 5 G line inside the magnet room. This method for containing the fringe fields is known as "passive magnetic shielding." In the 1990s, a secondary set of superconducting coils was added to the magnet to contain the fringe fields as close to the magnet as possible. This technology is known as "actively shielded." Figure 4-8 shows the relative location of the primary coils, also known as "main coils" and the secondary coils, also known as "shield coils." Actively shielded magnet technology has eliminated or greatly reduced the need for passive shielding in high field MRI systems. Today, superconducting magnet technology is the only technology used for producing whole-body MRI systems above 0.7 T. Commercially available whole-body MRI superconducting magnets are available in field strengths from 0.3 T to 3 T. In addition, custom systems are available at even higher field strengths, limited only by the critical field of the superconducting wire.
7 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-7 Dedicated MRI system for MRI-guided interventional and surgical procedures. The system's imaging volume is located between the two halves of the magnet (A). The surgeon has access to the patient from both sides of the magnet to perform the intervention (B). This magnet operates at 0.5 T and uses conduction cooling technology, requiring no helium.
Shown in Figure 4-9 is a picture of a 9.4 T magnet produced by GE Medical Systems to perform high-field MRI research at the University of Illinois at Chicago. The total length of wire required to wind this magnet was 540 km or 335 miles. Note that while a superconductor does not have resistance, it is impossible to manufacture wire 300 miles long. Thus magnet manufacturers must join shorter wire lengths with superconducting joints. If any of these joints are not completely superconducting, the magnet will exhibit some downward drift. A large number of joints will increase the probability of downward field drift; therefore, long lengths of wire are very critical. Manufacturers typically specify that the magnet will not drift downward in field strength by more than 0.1 ppm/hour. This extraordinary field stability is achieved because of the "zero resistance" property of superconductivity, and is one of the reasons why superconducting magnet technology dominates the MRI industry. Once current is put into the magnet, and the superconducting switch is closed, the power supply is removed. Thus the magnet's field stability is not governed by a power supply as it was in the case of resistive magnets. Another benefit of the "zero resistance" property of superconductors is its ability to react to external field disturbances. As mentioned previously, field variations of less than 1 μT cause image quality issues. Moving metal objects near a magnet can perturb the field enough to cause image quality problems. However, special superconducting coils can be wound in the superconducting magnet to eliminate more than 90% of this external field fluctuation. These coils are frequently called "moving
8 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
metal" coils. page 113 page 114
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-8 Concept of actively shielded superconducting magnet. The shield coils carry current in the opposite direction to the main coils. The field produced by the shield coils opposes the main field resulting in much smaller fringe field.
Most use of superconducting magnets has been applied to magnets of cylindrical geometry. However, recently, the need for combining the benefits of high-field superconductivity capability in open magnets has been explored. Today, it has been shown that open superconductiving magnets with field strengths up to 1 T are achievable. Several manufacturers now sell superconducting open magnets with strengths above 0.5 T. Shown in Figure 4-10 is a GE OpenSpeed system, which has a field strength of 0.7 T. This system provides the openness of a permanent magnet system but with much higher SNR.
Cryogenics As stated above, NbTi is the superconductor used in most MRI magnets, and this superconductor must be maintained below 9 K to remain superconducting. In fact, most manufacturers immerse the superconducting windings in a liquid helium bath at 4 K. The requirement to keep the superconductor at 4 K adds another demand on the design of the superconducting magnet. Liquid helium is a limited resource, and quite costly in many parts of the world. To reduce ongoing operating costs, manufacturers design superconducting magnets to minimize the loss of liquid helium. Typical boil-off rates range from 0.03 liters/hour to 0.1 liters/hour, although some manufacturers are incorporating re-condensing technology into their designs. This technology virtually eliminates the loss of liquid helium while the magnet is in standard operating mode.
9 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
10 of 15
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-9 Ultrahigh-field magnet for whole-body MRI. This one of a kind magnet operates at 9.4 T. The system was installed at University of Chicago Illinois in 2003.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-10 High-field open MRI system. This system uses an open magnet operating at 0.7 T. The field strength is generated by superconducting coils, which are helium cooled.
The cryogenic design that achieves these low helium losses includes features that minimize the heat transfer, such as convection, conduction and radiation, from the environment to the inner magnet cartridge. A typical magnet includes an outer vacuum vessel, one or more thermal shields, multi-layer insulation, a helium vessel, the magnet cartridge, a suspension system that supports the thermal shields and helium vessel, and a cryocooler for removing heat from the magnet. A simplified crosssection of a typical magnet is shown in Figure 4-11. page 114 page 115
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
11 of 15
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-11 Cross-section of a high-field superconducting magnet. The cross-section shows the location of the shield coils relative to the main coils. The location of the gradient coil and RF body coil, in the magnet, are also shown.
The space between the outer vacuum vessel and the helium vessel is evacuated to eliminate heat transfer by convection. The thermal shields and multi-layer insulation intercept the thermal radiation before it reaches the helium vessel from the environment and transfers the heat to the first stage of the cryocooler, which operates at approximately 50 K. These thermal shields are typically made from a conductor with high thermal conductivity, such as aluminum. The high thermal conductivity is required to minimize the temperature difference across the thermal shield. Unfortunately, high thermal conductivity also implies high electrical conductivity, and any leakage field from the gradient coil induces eddy currents in these thermal shields. The effects of these eddy currents are reduced during the calibration phase when eddy current compensation is set. The suspension system is designed to minimize heat transfer by conduction, while providing enough stiffness to eliminate vibration. The suspension system consists of thin straps or rods, made from materials high in strength, yet low in thermal conductivity. Finally, the second stage of the cryocooler is connected to a second thermal shield (in some manufacturer's designs) or to the helium re-condenser in "zero boil-off" systems. This cryocooler removes the heat from the magnet that cannot be eliminated by the design steps listed above. A recent advance in cryocooler technology is the "pulse tube." Two advantages of the pulse tube are reduced vibration and reduced acoustic noise.
Ramping
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-12 Superconducting switch used to ramp-up and ramp-down the magnet. During ramp-up or ramp-down, the heater is on to open the switch and allow current from the power supply to reach the magnet coils. Once the magnet is up to field, the heater is turned off and the switch closes, effectively shorting out the power supply. At this point, the power supply can be removed.
As stated above, a superconducting magnet only needs a power supply to install current into the magnet. Once the current is installed in the magnet, the power supply can be removed, and the magnet will maintain its field. The act of installing current into the magnet is called "ramping" the magnet. A circuit diagram of a typical superconducting magnet is shown in Figure 4-12. Installing current in the magnet requires a switch that can be "opened" while ramping the magnet, then "closed" after current is installed in the magnet. Closing the switch allows the current to circulate in a closed superconducting loop. This switch must be made of superconductor material so that the closed circuit has no resistance when in operation. The switch is actually a small winding of superconducting wire imbedded in an insulator. The switch is opened by adding heat so that the temperature of the switch winding is increased above the superconducting transition temperature. While the switch is above the superconducting transition temperature, it is resistive, and the current from the power supply will preferentially flow into the superconducting coil windings rather than the resistive switch. After the magnet has been energized, the switch is closed by allowing the switch to cool below the superconducting transition temperature. At this point the switch again has zero resistance and the power supply can be removed. A similar operation is used for putting current into the superconducting shim coils used by some manufacturers.
Quench page 115 page 116
If at any time during operation, any section of the windings of a superconducting magnet are disturbed enough to raise its temperature above the superconducting transition temperature, that winding section will become resistive. Once resistive, this section of the superconducting winding will generate heat, heating more of the winding until all of the energy stored in the magnet is turned into heat. This process happens very rapidly, over a period of seconds and is called a "quench." Surprisingly, an energy disturbance as small as 2 μJ is enough to cause a quench, yet the total energy released can be as high as 130 MJ for the 9.4 T whole-body magnet cited above. The forces on the large coils of a typical 1.5 T actively shielded magnet are on the order of 900,000 Newtons and large coil forces on a 3 T actively shielded magnet are on the order of 3.5 million Newtons. As the superconducting winding becomes resistive and heats up, it causes the liquid helium to boil, expand, and exit the magnet in a burst of helium vapor. Superconducting magnets are designed to expel this helium vapor safely through vents to the outside of the hospital. During a quench, it is
12 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
13 of 15
possible for thousands of liters of liquid helium to turn rapidly to gas and gush from the magnet. As described in the siting section, it is very important that the vents carrying the helium gas from the magnet room are installed properly, and not modified or obstructed, as this could be a life-threatening situation.
Shimming After the magnet is installed and ramped, it is "shimmed." Shimming is the act of bringing the magnet's homogeneity into specification. While a magnet may have been shimmed to specification in the factory, there is always some magnetic material in the hospital building that modifies the magnetic field of the magnet. Examples of this magnetic material are steel structural beams and concrete re-inforcing bars in the building. This environmental steel can modify the homogeneity of the magnet from 10 ppm over the imaging volume to 100 ppm or more. Some manufacturers complete this shimming operation with superconducting correction coils incorporated in the magnet, this technique is called "super-con" shimming; other manufacturers accomplish the shimming operation using small pieces of ferromagnetic material, this technique is called "passive" shimming. In either case, the ramping and shimming phase of the magnet installation is completed over a period of a few days, depending on the type of magnet. The magnetic field of a magnet can be written as an expansion of mathematical functions as shown below:
The summation over n and m is from 0 to some upper limit, typically on the order of 20. The terms with lowest n,m are the terms with the largest contribution to the magnet inhomogeneity that can be modified during the shimming process, and the first few terms are shown below:
This expansion can also be written in Cartesian co-ordinates, and the first few terms can be expressed as follows:
In either formulation, the first term is a constant and represents the magnet's base field, such as 1.5 T. If possible, all terms but the first term should be zero, leaving a perfectly uniform field. In practice, all terms higher than the first are lowered to meet specifications during the installation "shimming" process. However, the human body has magnetic properties and each patient modifies the homogeneity of the magnet to some extent. This effect increases with field strength. Manufacturers have designed their MRI systems to allow some correction of this effect for each patient as will be explained below. The first parentheses [lcub ][rcub ] in Equation 4-3 groups a set of three terms that vary linearly over the homogeneity volume. The gradient coils also vary linearly over the imaging volume, thus the gradient coils can be used to reduce these terms for improved homogeneity for each patient. The next five terms grouped in the second set of parentheses [lcub ][rcub ] have quadratic variation over the imaging volume. Some imaging systems include resistive coils to reduce this field error for each patient also. These coils are usually called "resistive shims" or "high-order shims." Normally there is one coil for each of the five second-order terms, and they are frequently labeled by the term they correct. Thus they are labeled XZ, YZ, Z2, XY and (X2-Y2) in the Cartesian system. Alternatively, they are labeled (2,0), (2,1), (2,-1), (2,-2), and (2,2) in the spherical expansion system. The terms with n equal to three and higher are reduced as much as possible during the shimming process at installation and in general are not adjusted on a per-patient basis.
Magnet Technology Summary
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
Table 4-2. Magnet Type Comparison for MRI Systems Field strength
Resistive
Permanent
Superconducting
Low-field
Low and mid-field
Broad range of fields
<0.3 T
≤0.5T
Mid: 0.5-1.0 T High: 1.5-3.0 T Ultrahigh: 7-10 T
Homogeneity
Medium
Medium
High
≈40 ppm
≈40 ppm
<10 ppm
≈40 cm DSV
≥50 cm DSV
Low
Medium
High
Limited by the power supply
Dependent on the temperature controller
Inherent to the technology
Large
Low
Low with active shield
Requires magnetic shielding
Inherent to the technology
Large without active shield
Low
Very large
Mid to large
<2 tons
10-35 tons
1.5 T ≈3 tons
Imaging volume ≈35 cm DSV Stability
Fringe fields
Weight
3.0 T ≈10 tons Emergency shutdown
Very fast
Not possible
Fast
After power is removed
Can not be tusrned off
Emergency quench <1 minute
Low
Low
40-100 kW
Temperature controller
Air or water cooled 5-10 kW compressor
Low
Medium
High
Low
Medium
Electrical power High
Initial costs
Operating costs High
Electrical power None
Helium refills page 116 page 117
Three main magnet technologies are used to manufacture magnets for MRI systems: Resistive, Permanent and Superconducting. Each magnet technology has its own pros and cons. The right selection often depends on the application and scope of the MRI product. Table 4-2 summarizes the advantages and disadvantage of each technology. Today's MRI industry is being dominated by the superconducting technology, particularly in the high-field systems. Superconducting magnet technology has a high potential to move into high temperature technology if and when the cost and manufacturing (reliability) issues are resolved. The second growing technology is permanent magnet with potential usage of higher "maximum energy product" (BHmax) magnetic materials, which could enable higher field strengths while keeping weight down. The challenge permanent magnet technology faces is controlling the high temperature sensitivity and higher cost associated with higher BHmax materials. Resistive magnet technology is the least used technology today for whole-body MRI systems. The inherent poor stability and high electrical power consumption severely limit the application of resistive magnet technology in today's whole-body MRI products.
14 of 15
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004010
15 of 15
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:52
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
1 of 9
GRADIENT SUBSYSTEM
Overview The gradient subsystem enables spatial resolution of the MRI signal. The two main components of the gradient subsystem are the gradient coil and the gradient driver. Slew rate, peak amplitude, duty cycle, acoustic noise, and heat are determined by the combination of the gradient coil and driver. The gradient coil and driver should be designed as one subsystem for optimal performance and to avoid problems controlling waveform fidelity or with excessive heat dissipation in the gradient subsystem. Gradient amplitude defines the maximum field strength of a gradient system assembly. It is measured in mT/m (millitesla per meter) or G/cm (gauss/cm, where 1 G/cm = 10 mT/m). Gradient slew rate is the rate of change of the gradient strength. It is expressed in T/m/s. For example, the slew rate of a gradient subsystem that can reach gradient amplitude of 50 mT/m in 0.5 ms is:
Gradient Coils The gradient coil assembly is comprised of three independent gradient coils. They are usually referred to as X, Y, and Z gradient coils. Each coil generates a magnetic field gradient that is constant within the imaging volume and proportional to currents Ix, Iy,, and Iz. Mathematically, the z component of the magnetic flux density, Bz, at point (x, y, z) inside the imaging volume is given by: where: Gx, Gy, and Gz are the strength or gain of X, Y, and Z gradient coils, respectively, in units of mT/m/A or G/cm/A. B0 is the z component of the magnetic flux density at the isocenter of the magnet. The Z gradient varies the magnitude of the Bz field along the z-direction while the X or Y gradient varies the Bz magnitude along the x- or y-direction. The variation of the Bz field along an orthogonal axis (x or y) is why the X and Y gradient coils have a different geometry than the Z gradient coil. page 117 page 118
Linearity is the gradient field uniformity inside the field-of-view (FOV). It has a direct impact on image geometrical distortion. The following two linearity definitions are widely used: 1. Linearity or integral linearity affects the perceived location of a voxel. If at some point inside the imaging volume the gradient generates a magnetic field of Bz(x, y, z) per ampere, while a field of Gzz per ampere was expected, then integral linearity is defined as the relative difference of these two fields:
2. Differential linearity affects MRI signal intensity due to the change in gradient strength across a voxel. It is defined for the X gradient, for example, at point (x, y, z) inside the imaging volume as:
where: Bz(x, y, z) is the magnetic field generated by the X gradient coil per 1 A at this point.
Cylindrical Gradient Coils As mentioned earlier, the Z coil has a different geometry than the X and Y coils. The axial or longitudinal gradient coil, the Z coil, consists of a number of current loops wound on the surface of a cylinder, usually connected anti-symmetrically with respect to the Z = 0 plane (for a loop at location z1 that carries current I, there is also a loop at location - z1 that carries current - I).
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
The transversal gradient coils, the X and Y coils, consist of a number of saddle-shaped coils mounted on the surface of a cylinder. These coils are almost identical but mounted at a 90° angle relative to each other.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-13 A Maxwell pair of coils on radius a. The optimum linearity occurs at a spacing of 1.31a between the two coils. This coil pair is a rudimentary axial, or Z, gradient coil.
Since the appearance of the first cylindrical MRI systems in the early 1980s, the gradient coil assembly has undergone major changes. The first cylindrical gradient coils consisted of a Maxwell coil pair acting as Z gradient coils and two sets of two arc Golay coils for X and Y gradient coils.16 These coils, coupled with the gradient drivers of that time, typically had a 5 mT/m maximum strength with a rise time of 1 ms (slew rate = 5 T/m/s). In addition, their fringe field was not contained, and they required a significant pre-emphasis in the current waveform to overcome the adverse effect of eddy currents in conductive surfaces of the magnet. Eddy currents are electric currents induced in metallic objects by time varying magnetic fields, such as gradient waveforms. These currents generate magnetic fields that oppose the gradient field change. Figure 4-13 shows a Maxwell pair of coils on radius a. Mathematically, it can be determined that the optimum linearity occurs at a spacing of 1.31a between the two coils. Note the asymmetry in the current direction with respect to the Z = 0 plane. Figure 4-14 is an example of a two arc gradient coil. Such a coil generates a linearly varying Bz field in the Y direction. The X gradient is rotated by 90° about the Z axis. This gradient coil consists of four "window frame" shaped saddle coils mounted on the surface of the cylinder. A significant improvement came with the introduction of continuous surface current density patterns for longitudinal and transversal gradient coils17 and the invention of actively shielded gradient coils.18 The actively shielded gradient coil is designed to minimize eddy currents by surrounding the outside of the gradient coil with additional coil windings and creating a field counter to that of the gradient. The shield is designed to cancel the external or fringe field of the gradient coil, with optimal cancellation at conductive surfaces within the magnet. However, the shield coil with its reversed polarity decreases the gradient strength in the patient bore and more current is needed to overcome this effect. The benefit of substantially reduced eddy currents more than offset this one disadvantage. Figure 4-15 depicts a view of a transversal gradient coil with distributed current density on a cylindrical surface. The third generation of gradient coils perfected the shielded gradient coil design to better match human anatomy. Several gradient coils were grouped in one assembly: a large FOV whole-body gradient coil and a smaller FOV gradient coil with a higher slew rate.19,20 Figure 4-16 is an example of a dual FOV gradient coil.
2 of 9
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
3 of 9
Add to lightbox page 118 page 119
Figure 4-14 The physical shape of transverse gradient coils, such as the four "window frame" shaped saddle coils mounted on the surface of the cylinder, are quite different from the axial gradient coil.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-15 This flat copper sheet, when rolled into a cylinder, forms a transverse gradient coil. Nearly the entire surface is conductive, resulting in a distributed current density on a cylindrical surface.
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
4 of 9
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-16 These two simple cylinders represent a large field-of-view whole-body gradient coil and a smaller field-of-view specialty gradient coil.
Planar Gradient Coils
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-17 One half of a planar square-shaped Z-gradient coil. The other half is located on the opposite magnet pole but with the current directions reversed.
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-18 One half of a planar square shaped X-gradient coil pair. The other half is located on the other pole face with the same winding pattern and current direction.
Planar Gradient Coils are used in open type magnets. Their topology is therefore quite different from cylindrical coils21 as listed below: 1. Typically the Z gradient coil consists of two disks or square-shaped windings placed on opposite sides of the open magnet pole pieces. To achieve the Z gradient coil effect, the current directions are reversed. Figure 4-17 is an example of a planar square-shaped Z gradient coil. The figure shows one of the boards. The other board, located on the other pole face, has the same winding pattern with reversed current polarity. 2. X and Y gradients consists of two sets of D shaped coils rotated by 90° to each other. Figure 4-18 shows an example of a planar square shaped X gradient coil. The figure shows one of the boards. The other board, located on the other pole face, has the same winding pattern and current direction. Y gradient coil is rotated by 90°. page 119 page 120
Gradient Driver The gradient driver is usually discussed in terms of volts and amperes. But the control of this power must be precise and accurate. The gradient controller takes on this task.
Gradient Controller The gradient controller provides signals to three gradient amplifiers to provide an accurate, linear current output to vary the gradient amplitude over time. How well the gradient in the imaging volume follows the current waveform is referred to as "waveform fidelity." Achieving instantaneous current accuracy requires high resolution, speed, and accuracy of the digital-to-analog converter and the current-sensing circuit. Because of the spatial and temporal manipulation of the magnetic field, with its corresponding impact on the proton precession phase, it is necessary to also accurately control the product of gradient strength vs. time. This corresponds to the area inside of a gradient amplitudeover-time gradient waveform. Gradient control methodologies use an integrator to accumulate and correct for any error in this area. Gradient drivers achieve highly accurate control using a closed-loop, current feedback control architecture (Figure 4-19). A digital representation of the desired gradient command is passed through a highly accurate digital-to-analog converter. The analog command, IREF, is compared with the actual sensed current in the gradient coil, IFEEDBACK. The difference, IERROR, is amplified and integrated. The
5 of 9
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
6 of 9
sum of the error and the integral become the control signal for the gradient amplifier, VCONTROL. The amplifier then generates a voltage proportional to the control signal to drive the gradient coil. The voltage is the electromotive force to drive the current into the coil. Both the integrator and the digital-to-analog converter must be accurate at DC levels, and must also respond accurately and quickly to transient events. Typically, the two devices must be accurate and linear to a few parts per million over their full-scale range. This level of control accuracy is not common in other industries and is a significant design challenge for MRI gradient controllers.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-19 A typical closed-loop, current feedback control functional block diagram.
Another limitation lies in the bandwidth of the gradient feedback control loop. Bandwidth determines the controller's ability to correct for error accumulated at the IERROR signal. At low frequencies, where the closed-loop current control has very high gain, the error between the commanded current and detected current is minimal. At frequencies near the bandwidth of the closed-loop control, the gain of the closed-loop current control is much lower, which results in a relatively slow response to errors. Feedback systems cannot accurately follow commands with frequency content above their bandwidth. This circumstance has a significant impact on the gradient driver's ability to manage instantaneous accuracy during transient current commands. To reduce the effects of this fundamental limitation, the frequency content of the gradient waveform can be limited. As mentioned before, eddy currents generate magnetic fields that oppose the gradient field change. The opposing magnetic field has multiple time dependencies unique from the gradient driver because the induced currents decay in time as a function of the different electrical resistances of the various magnet components. There is no impact to the current through the gradient coil or the current sensed by the controller. So the controller is unaware of the error in the gradient field. Figure 4-20 shows the relationship of gradient coil current and the resulting gradient magnetic field in the presence of eddy currents. Uncorrected eddy currents have a detrimental effect on the MRI image quality. Eddy currents are predictable since they are generated in the invariant magnet structure. Once the impact on imaging has been measured, the three gradient current waveforms can be pre-emphasized with the extra current necessary to produce the desired magnetic flux shape within the patient bore of the magnet. This method is effective only if the opposing eddy current magnetic fields are spatially similar to those of the gradient coil. Due to the variable location and proximity of various metallic components of the magnet that surround the gradient coil, the eddy-current field spatial response is often more complicated than the gradient field.
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
Add to lightbox page 120 page 121
Figure 4-20 The actual gradient magnetic field can be significantly distorted from the intended field in the presence of eddy currents.
Gradient Amplifier The gradient amplifier boosts the current and voltage delivered to the gradient coil. It converts the error signal of the closed-loop current control into a high voltage. This voltage is applied to the gradient coil to force the current to the required amount. The gradient coil inductance, resistance, and the requested peak slew rate determine the maximum voltage needed from the amplifier. The maximum current required is determined by the requested peak gradient amplitude and gradient coil gain. The voltage bandwidth of the amplifier is one of the elements that determines the maximum closed-loop bandwidth of the current control. Since the frequency content of typical MRI pulse sequences is mostly in the audio range, the first systems used existing linear audio amplifiers. Most linear power amplifiers use power bipolar junction transistors (BJT) biased into their linear region. These amplifiers have the advantage of high voltage bandwidths in the 100 kHz range, and are capable of very high fidelity with almost any type of waveform. However, they are very inefficient and have limited voltage and current capability. Many of these devices have to be connected in parallel in order to get a useable peak current. Their inefficiency arises from their variable resistor behavior. Considerable power can be dissipated across this resistance from the high voltages. Linear amplifiers modules are limited to about 150 V and 250 A. To overcome the efficiency issues of linear amplifiers, switching amplifiers were developed. These amplifiers drive the power transistors into either a low resistance "on" state or very high resistance "off" state. Neither state dissipates as much power as bipolar junction transistors. In order to control the amplitude, the transistors are switched continuously at a very high rate between on and off. The amount of dwell time on vs. off determines the amplitude. This approach is known as pulse width modulation (PWM). Switching transistors such as insulated gate bipolar transistors (IGBT) and metal oxide silicon field effect transistors (MOSFET) are well adapted to this type of operation, and are the devices now used for switching gradient amplifiers. Switching amplifiers for MRI have been designed for voltages in excess of 2000 V and currents exceeding 500 A. The on/off nature of a switching amplifier requires the switching frequency to be as high as possible to limit the current ripple on the gradient coil. Ripple frequencies in the 50 kHz to 100 kHz range are typical, and provide acceptable voltage bandwidths with minimal degradation of MR image quality.
Gradient Duty Cycle The term "gradient duty cycle" describes the percentage of time the gradient subsystem can provide maximum gradient strength pulse sequence waveforms. MRI systems typically have a duty cycle of 100%. This duty cycle applies to the pulse sequences provided on the system. A more strenuous
7 of 9
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
criterion is the ability of the gradient driver to sustain maximum amplitude. This is important for diffusion imaging where high amplitude diffusion pulses reduce the echo time. Often, the pulse sequence must be modified to limit the diffusion pulse amplitude at the expense of longer echo times. Duty cycle is often limited by the ability to remove the heat generated by pulsing gradient waveforms, whether in the gradient coil or in the gradient driver. Transient heating and cooling is characterized by the thermal time constant, τ, in the expression: where 63% of a steady-state temperature is reached when the amount of elapsed time, t, is equal to one time constant, τ. After three time constants a system is considered at steady state. For example, if the thermal time constant of a gradient coil is 15 minutes, the coil will reach 95% of steady-state temperature at 45 minutes (3 time constants). Components in an MRI system have thermal time constants ranging from very short (milliseconds) to long (>15 minutes). Peak gradient strength and duty cycle limits are calculated based on where the heat is generated, and the time constant of the respective heat-generating components. Gradient driver and coil heating are two important thermal considerations as both generate heat during scanning that must be removed. Components in the driver used to convert facility electricity into current waveforms have thermal time constants ranging from 30 milliseconds for power electronics to minutes for other components. Gradient coil heating is on a much longer time scale than the gradient driver. Typically, the thermal time constant ranges from 15 to 30 minutes, where steady-state temperatures are reached in over an hour. The amount of heat generated in an axis can be approximated as: where Irms is the root-mean-square current on the axis and Raxis is the resistance of the coil axis, which is a function of the wire temperature (T) and the frequency content (f) of the scan sequence. Skin depth effects reduce the effective cross-sectional area of the current conducting wire, thus increasing the coil resistance as frequency increases. Skin depth effects are proportional to the square root of frequency. Additional heating can come from eddy currents. The amount of heat removed from the gradient coil depends on the capability of the coil cooling system and the temperature limits of the materials used in the coil. The properties of copper with respect to temperature and frequency are given in Table 4-3.
Table 4-3. Copper Properties (Baseline is 20° C) Temperature (°C) Resistance Increase (%) Frequency (Hz) Resistance Increase (fold) 40
7.8 1 (≈DC)
1.0
60
15.6 10
3.2
80
23.4 100
10
100
31.2 1000
32
120
39.0 10000
100 page 121 page 122
8 of 9
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004022
9 of 9
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-21 The peak specific absorption rate (SAR) limit as a function of bore temperature and humidity.
Finally, for patient safety reasons, the FDA limits peak SAR as a function of bore temperature and humidity. A cooler bore temperature allows higher peak SAR (Fig. 4-21).
Acoustics Gradient coils, when pulsed, generate acoustic noise. The source of the noise is the Lorenz force, which is the vector product of the current and the static magnetic field at the conductor carrying the current. Gradient waveform ramp times are often in the hundreds of microseconds. The major frequency content of a waveform often lies within the most sensitive region of human hearing at about 1000 Hz. Various methods have been proposed to lower the acoustic noise level of the gradient coil assemblies.22 Attenuation and absorption of acoustic energy is always fundamental to any method.
Future Developments The evolution path of further developments seems to be the continuation of the historical trends: the quest for stronger and faster gradient coils surely will challenge a number of currently accepted technological limits. As the physical and regulatory limits are reached with today's gradient coils, a more revolutionary approach in coil design is needed. This approach, whatever form it takes, would define the next generation gradient coils.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:53
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
1 of 16
RADIOFREQUENCY SUBSYSTEM
Overview The main functions of the RF subsystem are the spins excitation (transmit phase) and the "echo" reception (receive phase). The excitation function is performed by the MRI system transmit chain, and the reception is performed by the receive chain. During the excitation, the spins of the desired imaging region are flipped into the transverse plane. During the receive phase, as the flipped spins relax back to align themselves in the direction of the B0 field, they generate a small RF signal (MRI signal) which is detected, amplified and processed by the receive chain components. In this section, the terms f0 and ω0 are used interchangeably: f0 refers to the Larmor-frequency in Hz, and ω0 refers to the Larmor-frequency in radians.
Transmit chain The function of the transmit chain is to produce an RF magnetic field (B1) to excite the spins in the sample being imaged. The polarization of the B1 field can be either linear or circular. In linear polarization, the B1 field has a fixed orientation, orthogonal to the B0 field. On the other hand, in circular polarization the B1 field rotates orthogonal to the B0 field at a rate equal to the Larmor-frequency, f0 (64 MHz for 1.5 T). Typically, linear polarization requires the RF power to be delivered to the transmit coil as a single component, whereas the circular polarization requires the RF power to be delivered in two components of equal amplitude and 90° phase difference (I and Q components). Feeding the power in this manner is usually referred to as "quadrature excitation." Linear polarized B1 fields require twice the amount of RF power than circular polarized B1 fields to flip the spins to a given angle. This is an important advantage of circular polarization over linear. The transmit RF coils used to produce linear B1 fields are usually referred to as "linear" transmit coils and the coils used to produce circular B1 fields are called "quadrature" transmit coils. Because circular polarization is twice as efficient as linear, it is the most widely used by all MRI manufacturers. The transmit chain discussion in this section is based on circular polarization of the B1 field produced by quadrature transmit RF coils also known as "resonators." page 122 page 123
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
2 of 16
Add to lightbox page 123 page 124
Figure 4-22 A high-level functional block diagram of the transmit chain: 1, RF synthesizer; 2, the mixer; 3, power amplifier; 4, T/R switch; 5, 3 dB hybrid splitter; 6, transmit RF coil.
The primary characteristics of the B1 field include a stable frequency (f0), finite bandwidth, high uniformity across the imaging volume, and the field intensity measured in micro-tesla (μT). To meet these requirements, the transmit chain uses the following components (shown in Fig. 4-22): 1. A highly stable frequency synthesizer to generate a continuous wave signal (carrier) at the Larmor-frequency (ω0). 2. An RF envelope
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
3 of 16
modulator to convert the carrier signal into an RF pulse with finite bandwidth. 3. A power amplifier to elevate the RF pulse from mW to several kW and a means to monitor the energy content of the transmitted RF power. The power monitor measures the forward power going into the coil to ensure safe operating levels. 4. A transmit/receive switch (T/R SW) to couple the power amplifier to the transmit coil during the transmit phase while protecting the receive chain components, and to couple the receive coil(s) to the receive chain while decoupling the power amplifier from the transmit coil. 5. A power splitter and phase shifter to split the amplified RF pulse into two components of equal amplitude and 90° phase difference (I and Q); this type of power splitter is know as "3 dB 90° hybrid splitter." 6. A quadrature whole-body RF transmit coil, which is fed by the I and Q components to generate the B1 field. Figure 4-22 shows the primary functional blocks of the transmit chain and their corresponding MRI functions. Most MRI manufacturers use a whole-body size resonator operating in quadrature to generate the B1 field. The transmit field has to be highly homogeneous across the imaging volume to provide a uniform flip angle (α) to a selected slice or slab. The flip angle (α) is proportional to the integral of the RF pulse. During the excitation pulse, linear gradients are applied such that they are superimposed on the static magnetic field. Since the Larmor-frequency is proportional to the amplitude of the static magnetic field, exciting a slice or a slab requires that RF pulses have a finite bandwidth. A uniform flip angle over the width of the selected slice is needed to ensure a rectangular slice profile. To achieve this, the RF carrier is modulated with a sinc function (defined as sinx/x) in the time domain, corresponding to a rectangular pulse in the frequency domain. Since a sinc pulse is infinitely long (extending from -∞ to +∞), it is usually truncated after one or two side-lobes, and convolved with a filter to minimize ringing in the slice profile.
Frequency Synthesizer The radio frequency synthesizer generates a sine wave at or near the center of the MRI frequency band of interest (e.g. 64 MHz at 1.5 T). Its function is to provide the highly stable local oscillator for frequency translation of the exciter modulation, and to provide the demodulating local oscillator required to translate the MRI information to a suitable frequency for digitization. In addition, the frequency synthesizer has to be able to provide fast and accurate phase switching and frequency offsets to the center frequency during multislice scans and off-center FOV imaging.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-23 A functional block diagram of an MRI direct digital synthesizer. The function of the synthesizer is to generate an accurate reference frequency for a given set of phase (ϕ), center frequency (ωcenter), and offset frequency (ω offset). The carrier signal, generated by the synthesizer, is modulated with the RF envelope from the pulse sequence generator.
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
4 of 16
Most current MRI systems employ a high-resolution direct digital synthesis technique to allow rapid coherent frequency and phase switching. A coarse synthesizer is typically used to provide gross frequency setting depending on the field strength and nuclei of interest. The high-resolution synthesizer is used during the MRI sequence for dynamic phase and frequency control (e.g. during multislice excitation and off-center FOV reception). Figure 4-23 shows a functional block diagram of a typical MRI frequency synthesizer.
Modulator An amplitude modulator is used to impart a finite bandwidth onto the fixed frequency sine wave provided by the synthesizer. This is accomplished by multiplying the synthesized sine wave by the RF pulse envelope (e.g. sinc pulse). The spectra of the modulation and the sine wave are convolved as a result of this amplitude multiplication, resulting in translation of the modulation spectrum to the center radio frequency of interest (see Fig. 4-22). A common modulation waveform is the sinc (sinx/x) pulse, which provides a uniform band of RF excitation (for slice or slab selection, as an example). A digital modulator is typically employed, which multiplies a digitized version of a sine wave with the digital modulation waveform before digital to analog conversion. This can avoid many of the imperfections in the analog multiplier circuits and provide high waveform fidelity. Frequency and phase modulation can be accomplished in the direct digital synthesizer by adding a recurring phase increment and a fixed phase step respectively (see Fig. 4-23). The frequency multiplier and mixer are fundamental functional blocks commonly used in communication systems. A brief description is included in Figure 4-22. For details on the operation of these functional blocks, refer to the material in the references.23-27 page 124 page 125
Power Amplifier The function of the RF power amplifier is to amplify the modulated MRI excitation signal to a level sufficient to generate the required circularly polarized RF magnetic field (B1). Peak B1 amplitudes between 15 and 30 μT inside a whole-body transmit coil require a peak power of 15 to 20 kW in a typical 1.5 T whole-body MRI system. The RF power requirement is proportional to the square of the B0 strength. This becomes a very important consideration for higher field strengths (e.g. 3 T) whole-body MRI systems. Other significant requirements for the MRI RF power amplifier include the linearity, stability, and efficiency. The linearity is very important to preserve the fidelity of the modulated pulse, since the accuracy of the slice profile depends on it. The amplifier stability contributes to the repeatability of the MRI pulse sequences. The efficiency of the amplifier is important to maintain the cooling requirements, packaging size and cost at a practical level. Class A amplifiers are linear but inefficient (typically 25%). Class B amplifiers are more efficient (up to 60%), but linearity suffers from signal "crossover distortion," which is not acceptable for high-quality MRI applications. In class AB amplifiers, the operating point is adjusted to eliminate the crossover distortion, yet provide efficiency in the 50% range. Therefore, class AB amplifiers are commonly used for MRI systems.26,28,29
Power Monitor The function of the power monitor is to ensure that the amount of average power delivered to any patient during an MRI scan is within the safety limits set by the FDA. Particularly, at 1.5 T and higher field strengths, most of the RF power going into the body coil will end up being dissipated in the patient. Therefore, the FDA has set limits on the specific absorption rate (SAR), specified in watts per kg. The power monitor uses the patient's weight and the efficiency of the transmit chain as inputs to calculate the maximum allowable average power for each patient.
T/R Switch The T/R switch is part of both the transmit chain and the receive chain. It has two functions: 1. During the transmit phase, it couples the RF power amplifier to the input of the 3 dB hybrid splitter ("hybrid splitter") and at the same time it provides protection to the delicate receive chain components. 2. During the receive phase, the T/R switch couples the hybrid splitter to the receive chain and decouples the RF power amplifier from the hybrid splitter. Figure 4-24 shows a typical implementation of a T/R SW.
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
5 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-24 A basic circuit for a transmit/receive (T/R) switch. During the transmit phase, D1 and D2 are on (switch closed), coupling the RF power to the in out ports of the hybrid splitter. During the receive phase both diodes are turned off (switch open) by applying appropriate bias, coupling the hybrid output to the input of the receive preamplifier.
Referring to Figure 4-24, PIN diodes D1 and D2 are used as electronic switches. PIN diodes are diodes with an additional intrinsic (I) layer, which gives the PIN diode its characteristic of being able to transfer high amounts of RF power when a small DC current is applied to forward bias (switch closed) the diode. To turn off the PIN diode (switch open), it requires a bias voltage to reverse the diode. During the transmit phase, D1 and D2 are turned on and both diodes become short circuits and D1 couples the RF power amplifier to the hybrid splitter. Similarly D2 shorted to ground protects the receive preamplifier from the high transmit power. During the receive phase, both diodes are open circuit and thus D1 decouples the RF power amplifier from the hybrid splitter. Similarly, D2 open results in effectively coupling the receive preamplifier to the hybrid splitter.
Hybrid Splitter The 3 dB hybrid splitter has two functions: 1. During the transmit phase, it converts the output of the RF power amplifier into two components (I, Q) of equal amplitude and 90° phase difference. These signals drive two input networks on the transmit coil that are 90° apart, thus generating a circular polarized B1 field. 2. During the receive phase, the hybrid reverses its operation; it takes the two MRI signals from the I and Q ports of the body coil and combines them into a single component of higher amplitude and feeds this signal to the receive chain components for signal amplification and imaging processing. The hybrid splitter can be built using transmission line segments or lumped elements. 25,30 Figure 4-25 shows a typical hybrid splitter using 4 quarter-wavelength (λ/4) sections implemented with lumped elements.
Quadrature Transmit Radiofrequency Coils The transmit RF coil (RF body coil) takes the I and Q power components from the hybrid splitter and converts them into a homogeneous circular polarized RF Magnetic field (B1) with sufficient volume to cover most of the population range. page 125 page 126
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
6 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-25 A lumped-element diagram of a typical 3 dB-hybrid splitter circuit. The hybrid can also be built with transmission lines.
Homogeneity is the most important design parameter in the RF body coil, since an inhomogeneous transmit field would result in contrast variation over the FOV. Homogeneity can be calculated using the Biot-Savart law, or from the vector potential which is the integration over the current paths in all conductors that make 24 up the body coil.
In Equation 4-12,
are the current elements, and
is the distance to the matrix point (ds [Lt ] r). The B1
field can also be calculated from the vector potential by using . This is a DC approximation, since the field is calculated for a direct current in vacuum. However, it is fairly accurate for frequencies up to 64 MHz. An example of Biot-Savart calculation of a 16-rod birdcage resonator is shown in Figure 4-26. Above 1.5 T the homogeneity of the B1 field is affected by the electrical properties of the patient's tissue. Therefore, other methods such as finite-difference time domain (FDTD) or finite-element method (FEM) must be applied 31,32 to calculate the B1 field map. In FDTD and FEM methods the load characteristics, electrical permittivity and conductivity of the tissue, can be included in the calculation. In most cases these techniques are approximations to the solution of Maxwell's equations, but because they include the effect of the load, they yield more accurate field calculations than a pseudo-static application of the Biot-Savart method, especially at field strength above 1.5 T. For instance loading the birdcage head coil with a head-phantom, the momentary B1 field map looks similar to that shown in Figure 4-27 for 1.5 T and Figures 4-28 and 4-29 for 3 T and 7 T respectively.
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
7 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-26 An example of a Biot-Savart calculation of a 16-rod birdcage resonator is shown. This method is a good approximation for 64 MHz (1.5 T). For higher frequencies, field maps are generally computed using numerical techniques, such as finite-difference time domain (FDTD) and finite-element method (FEM).
Add to lightbox page 126 page 127
Figure 4-27 The B1 field plots simulated from a birdcage head coil loaded with a human head at 1.5 T showing excellent B 1 uniformity.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-28 The B1 field plots simulated from a birdcage head coil loaded with a human head at 3 T showing B 1 inhomogeneity.
Birdcage Resonator (Transmit Phase)
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
8 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-29 The B1 field plots simulated from a birdcage head coil loaded with a human head at 7 T showing significant B1 inhomogeneity. Note the gradual increase of the swirling at the center due to the dielectric resonance.
Theoretically, perfect transverse field homogeneity can be obtained for coils used in cylindrical magnets by having an axial current on the surface of an infinitely long cylinder, with amplitude that varies as the sine of the azimuth angle θ.33 The birdcage is an approximation in which the current in the rungs (Fig. 4-30) varies as: Since the coil is not infinitely long, the homogeneity in the Z direction (axial) is not as good as in the XY plane (see Fig. 4-26). To make this structure resonant, capacitors can be placed either in the rungs for "low pass" configuration, or in the end-rings for "high pass" (see Fig. 4-30). Capacitor placement affects the E field 34 generated by the coil, which is important when minimizing local power deposition.
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
9 of 16
Add to lightbox page 127 page 128
Figure 4-30 The structure of a typical birdcage RF coil. The coil can be designed to be either (A) low pass (capacitors on the rungs), or (B) high pass (capacitors on the end-rings). When excited, this coil generates a B1 field on the transverse-plane (xy plane) because of the sinusoidal current distribution along the azimuthal direction (T).
Vertical open magnets require a totally different type of resonator.35 Since the B1 field has to be orthogonal to the B0 field, the coil geometries are different than that for horizontal B0. In addition, since in either B0 orientation (horizontal or vertical), the patient lies in a horizontal plane (ZX), the RF coil design becomes more challenging, particularly for quadrature coils. A popular geometry for vertical B0 field is the "solenoid." A solenoid RF coil is normally placed in the magnet to produce a linear B1 field in the Z direction. A significant disadvantage of the solenoid coil is that it can't be operated in quadrature and, therefore, to generate a circular polarized B1 field, usually a secondary coil must be combined with the solenoid to produce a second B1 field in the X direction. These two fields must be of equal amplitude and must have 90° of phase difference to generate the circularly polarized B1 field rotating around the vertical B0. These design challenges also apply to receive-only coils, such as surface coils and multi-coil arrays. Manufacturers of RF coils are creating very innovative geometries to overcome these difficulties and to take advantage of the quadrature benefits.
Radiofrequency Shield The primary function of the RF shield is to provide an isolated environment (free from coupling) for the RF coils to operate. The RF shield separates the transmit coil from the gradient coil environment. Its purpose is to prevent RF energy from being dissipated in the gradient coil, which is a high loss environment at radio frequencies. At the same time, the RF shield has to be transparent for the gradient fields. Since gradient fields are switched with rise-times on the order of 0.5 ms, the shield has to be transparent for frequencies of several kHz. Otherwise eddy currents may be induced in the shield, causing distortion to the gradient field and giving rise to artifacts in the image. Some RF shield designs contain cuts that are carefully placed to break large copper surfaces to prevent eddy currents, while leaving the RF current distribution intact. Other RF shield designs consist of ultra thin copper sheets or copper wire mesh. An important consideration during the design of an RF coil and shield, is the distance between the coil and the shield "gap" since the B1 field homogeneity and the coil efficiency depend greatly on it.
36
Tuning and Matching To optimize the power transfer between networks in a RF subsystem, all network interfaces and transmission lines have to have the same characteristic impedance (Z0), typically 50 ohms. In general, when designing a transmit coil, attention is focused on the geometry and B1 performance required of the coil structure. The coil elements are "tuned" or resonated utilizing additional reactive components (see Fig. 4-30), allowing current to flow efficiently in the paths required to generate the desired B1 field geometry. This often leaves a network with a different drive-point impedance than the coaxial and equipment interfaces that provide power to the coil. Unless proper impedance "matching" is provided, much of the power provided to the coil for B1 field generation would be reflected at this "mismatched" interface and the desired B1 field amplitude would not be achieved.
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
10 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-31 A surface coil loop with a blocking network circuit. When the diode is on (short circuit), L2 resonates at the Larmor frequency with the capacitor to which it is connected. This introduces a high impedance in the loop, effectively decoupling the receive coil loop.
The coil is usually "matched" to the interface impedance of 50 ohms for best transmit chain efficiency. This is generally accomplished by the application of additional loss-less reactive components between the tuned coil structure and the 50-ohm interfaces. Figure 4-30 shows a typical birdcage resonator with the placement of the tuning capacitors (C), at the end-rings for "high pass" configuration, and in the rungs for "low pass" configuration. A simplified high pass resonator circuit is shown in Figure 4-31. Several distributed capacitors (CT) along the coil inductance (L1) are used to tune the coil. The impedance matching is done with a single capacitor CM. However, other impedance matching techniques are possible. 29,37,38 Other impedance issues often encountered in the receive chain come from the fact that RF coils typically do not have a well-defined ground. This is especially true for receive coils that need to be moved within the patient bore. The only well-defined ground is at the end of the cable, where it is plugged into the system. High voltage may occur on the coil side of the cable shield, setting up a standing wave in the coaxial shield. To prevent this, a balanced to unbalanced transformer can be put in series with the cable. This device, typically a parallel resonant circuit, puts high impedance on the cable shield but lets the signal through unaffected. 39
Transmit Coil Disabling During the reception phase, the transmit coil must be disabled, if receive-only coils are used, to avoid coupling between transmit and receive coils. If the transmit body coil were not disabled during the receive phase, energy would transfer between the two coils severely impacting the SNR. Typically, resonators are enabled and disabled by means of PIN diode networks that are part of a parallel resonant circuit, as in Figure 4-31. When the diode is forward biased, the parallel circuit becomes resonant (the inductance L2 is chosen such that the resonance frequency of the blocking network is the same as that of the imaging coil) and will, therefore, create high impedance at its insertion points, effectively disabling the resonator. During imaging with receive only coils, the enabling and disabling of the RF body coil has to occur very rapidly, this function is usually called "dynamic disable." page 128 page 129
Receive chain The function of the receive chain is to detect and digitize the MRI signal for processing and image reconstruction. The MRI signal is coupled into the RF receive coil. Next the MRI signal is amplified by a high gain, low noise amplifier typically known as a "preamplifier." Once the signal is amplified, it is fed into the receiver-demodulator for signal normalization, demodulation, and digitization. The output from the demodulator is the complex raw data for the reconstruction process. Figure 4-32 is a simplified block diagram of the functions of the receive chain.
Receive Radiofrequency Coils Radiofrequency coils can be classified in many ways depending on their function. One category is based on their T/R properties: 1. transmit, 2. receive, and 3. transmit-receive. Another category is based on their design technology and shape: 1. volume coil, 2. surface coil, 3. phased-array (PA) coils, and 4. parallel imaging optimized PA coils. The last two types are actually multi-coil arrays using the surface coil technology. In the previous section, transmit RF coils were explained from a transmit chain point of view. In some cases, the same coil may be used to transmit and receive (T/R coils). This section discusses T/R coils in receive
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
11 of 16
mode and receive only coils. In an RF coil functioning as a receive coil, there are two important design factors: SNR and receive field homogeneity. These are the equivalent to transmit power efficiency, and transmit field homogeneity for the transmit coils, respectively. In some cases global homogeneity is sacrificed at the expense of higher local SNR in special anatomy-specific coils such as the cervical-thoracic-lumbar (CTL), and shoulder coils. One of the most important characteristics of receive coils, is the quality factor (Q), since it correlates directly to the SNR. Q is a measure of the efficiency of the coil, and it is typically expressed as the ratio of the resonant frequency of the coil (f0) to the bandwidth (BW) in unloaded coil conditions (Q = f0/BW3dB). Considering the coil parameters only, a very general proportionality expression for SNR can be written as:
where: 1/QL = total losses; 1/Q0 = loss in the empty coil; 1/Qpat = losses in the patient; Veff is effective volume of coil; and ROI is region of interest. The SNR is proportional to the square root of the loaded Q (QL). Optimum SNR results when the patient noise is dominant-e.g., for 1.5 T-the loaded QL shall be more than a factor of five smaller than the unloaded Q0. The effective volume of the coil, Veff is the volume integral of the magnetic energy in the entire volume normalized on that of the region of interest (ROI), and is not the same as geometric volume. However, in general this means that the coil has to fit the anatomy of interest. When the coil is loaded with a patient, there are four types of loss that affect the loaded Q: 1. Coil losses: if high Q coil components are used, these losses are usually small; 2. Dielectric losses: these are caused by parasitic capacitance between the patient and the coil, and can generally be avoided by choosing the tuning capacitance an order of magnitude higher than the parasites; 3. Radiation losses: these are usually small except for frequencies much higher than 60 MHz; 4. RF field induced losses: this is by far the most important loss contributor above 0.3 T, and is caused by the RF magnetic fields. In a typical RF coil at 1.5 T, >90% of all losses are due to this mechanism.
Birdcage Resonator (Receive Phase) Most whole-body MRI scanners use a transmit-receive coil. The most popular design is the birdcage coil operated in quadrature. Similar to the transmit phase, in the receive phase the quadrature coil offers significant performance benefit over coils operating in linear mode. The birdcage coil operating in quadrature, provides over 40% higher ( ) SNR than the coil operating in linear mode.
Surface and Multi-Coil Arrays page 129 page 130
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
12 of 16
Add to lightbox page 130 page 131
Figure 4-32 A basic functional block diagram of the receive chain showing the primary processing steps of the MRI signal in the time domain and its corresponding frequency domain representation. The output of the quadrature receiver is a set of complex numbers that are written in file called "raw-data" for a subsequent image reconstruction.
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
13 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-33 In phased-array (multi-coil array) coils, to minimize the next nearest coupling, the preamplifiers used on each coil element should have a very low input impedance (<5 ohms). Therefore, the inductor shown at the input of the preamplifier resonates with the capacitor shown to effectively decouple the loop from its neighboring elements.
Individual single loop surface coils are still used by MRI manufacturers, and they are mostly the building blocks of the multi-coil, also known as "phased-arrays." These arrays consist of a large number of small coil loops together covering a large field-of-view. 40,41 Instead of a single large receive coil, these arrays combine the SNR advantage of the smaller coil with the large FOV of a large coil. Data from the individual receive coils are read out simultaneously, and the image is reconstructed using an algorithm that weighs each coil's contribution depending on its individual SNR. Most of the multi-coil arrays are receive-only coils. In other words, the body coil or a larger coil is used to transmit the RF pulses, whereas the multi-array coils receive the MRI signal. Since both transmit and receive coils are tuned at the same frequency, the receive coils must be decoupled from the transmit coil during the excitation. Otherwise a large current will be induced in the receive coil, which might damage the delicate front-end of the preamplifier, and distort the transmit field. Protection networks, also known as "blocking networks" are used to protect the preamplifier during the transmit phase. In addition, in multi-coil arrays, the individual receive-coil loops have to be decoupled from each other during the receive phase. The receive-decoupling from neighboring receive coils is done by using low impedance preamplifiers in the coils, as shown in Figure 4-33. This method minimizes coupling among the next-nearest neighboring coils. Similarly, overlapping the coil elements until the net flux from one loop through the other loop become zero can minimize the coupling between the neighboring coil loops. The upper plot in Figure 4-34 shows an overlapping configuration. Using the decoupling technique shown in Figure 4-34, and minimum coupling technique, the individual coils do not couple inductively and there is minimal energy transfer between them, i.e., no noise is transferred. This means that each coil maintains the SNR as though it was operating by itself.
Special Coil Designs for Faster Imaging (Parallel Imaging)
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
14 of 16
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-34 One technique to decouple neighboring coil elements is to overlap them such that the flux from one cancels the other. This overlapping design is used very frequently in phased-array coil designs. However, it is not the optimal design for SENSE/ASSET applications (i.e., parallel imaging).
Recently new parallel imaging techniques have been introduced for speeding up the imaging process. One of 42,43 skips lines in k-space to accelerate the acquisition the techniques, called SENSE (SENSitivity Encoding) time. This process shrinks the FOV, which may now be smaller than the sensitivity volume of the coil elements. As a result, aliasing of the signal occurs, and the signal from a certain element may be confounded with that of other elements. In SENSE reconstruction technique, the knowledge of the coil sensitivity profiles and the noise correlation matrix are used to unfold the individual images and reconstruct the final image. Special optimized coil arrays are needed for this technique in which the coil elements are designed and positioned such that signal received from the same area by each coil element is significantly different in amplitude and phase from that received by the other coil elements. The SNR in the accelerated image is degraded compared with the original image as given in Equation 4-16. where R is the reduction factor (acceleration factor) and g is the geometry factor. The geometry factor is very dependent on coil design, and it is found that coils that are separated in the L-R and A-P direction give better g-factor maps than coils that are partially overlapped to eliminate mutual induction. The g-factor maps can be calculated from a matrix product of the sensitivity matrix and the noise correlation matrix as follows:
Here S is the sensitivity matrix and the noise correlation matrix. Note that the g-factor map is dependent on the reduction factor R. As an example, see Figure 4-34 for a four-channel coil in which the elements are overlapped in the acceleration direction, and Figure 4-35 for a case where they are separated. Both cases show a g factor map for R = 3 in the axial plane inside an elliptical phantom with phase-encoding vertical. This indicates that the separated configuration gives better g maps. page 131
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
15 of 16
page 132
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-35 The coil elements optimized for parallel imaging result in no coil-coil overlap for the best g-factor. This is quite different to the overlap required for minimum coupling in Figure 4-34. The acceleration direction is the same as coil separation direction.
Hybrid Splitter (Receive Phase) As explained in the transmit chain hybrid splitter section, the hybrid splitter circuit is used to split the RF power into I and Q channels, which are 90° apart, during the transmit phase. Similarly in the receive phase, the same hybrid splitter can function as a combiner to combine the signals from I and Q receive coils. It is important to note that the I and Q signals from the coil are still in quadrature (90° apart). The hybrid splitter provides additional phase shifts to the I and Q channels and combines them in-phase. If the RF coil is a quadrature transmit-receive (T/R), then the same hybrid splitter circuit can be used for both splitting the RF power during transmit and combining the MRI signal during receive. In quadrature phased-array coils, however, various signal combination techniques can be used.44
The Preamplifier The preamplifier(s) resides in the front of the MRI receive chain. Its primary purpose is to increase the MR signal and its accompanying noise from the receive coil, to a level that dominates the effects of later receive chain noise sources. The noise figure(NF) is defined as the loss in SNR as the information passes through a stage of the system. A modern MR preamplifier will provide an NF of <0.5 dB. The receive chain stages that follow can have higher noise figures since their effects are reduced by the gain of the stages that preceded them. For a complete receive chain with N stages, the total NF will be:
where: F = 10NF/10 It is evident that the system noise figure will approach that of the preamplifier (STAGE1 in the total noise figure expression), if the gain of the preamplifier is sufficiently high. Therefore, a low noise figure, high gain preamplifier is essential for preserving the SNR of the received signal.
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004033
16 of 16
Additionally, the preamplifier may be designed to exhibit very low input impedance. This low impedance (<5 ohms) is utilized in phased-array receive antennas to reduce current in adjacent coil elements, limiting the coupling between them.
Receiver Once the MRI signal is amplified and its noise figure is established, by the preamplifier, the amplitude of the MRI signal is scaled to maximize the receive chain dynamic range. This is usually done by adding further gain blocks to the receive chain followed by a programmable gain block (see Fig. 4-32). The MRI receiver performs the down conversion and digitization of the MRI signal required for computer processing and image reconstruction. The spectrum is down-converted to remove the RF central frequency before digitization, since the relative frequencies of the various spectral components contain the encoded spatial information. The receiver must preserve the amplitude, phase and relative frequency information across a band of frequencies determined by the readout gradient. The quadrature receiver23,26 is an efficient down-converter that minimizes filtering and A/D sampling speed requirements. In-phase and quadrature (I, Q) radiofrequency local oscillators multiply the incoming MRI signal in a pair of mixers (also known as frequency multipliers). If the MRI signal of bandwidth B Hz is down-converted at the central frequency, it results in two base band signals of 0 to B/2 Hz each, containing information from above and below the central frequency. The MRI signal is now represented as an in-phase and quadrature complex pair (I, Q pair). After filtering, these two signals are digitized at their lowest frequencies and bandwidths, allowing high-resolution analog to digital converters to be employed. See Figure 4-36 for a functional block diagram of the quadrature receiver. No loss of relative frequency information occurs by this "folding" of the MRI signal spectrum about the central frequency. A complex fast fourier transform (FFT) performed on the complex data set can discern components from above or below the central frequency. page 132 page 133
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-36 The basic blocks of the receive demodulation components. The signal is split and mixed with two reference signals 90° apart to maintain information about the frequency spectrum of the signal.
The device shown in Figure 4-36 has several practical limitations. The two channels must exhibit very close amplitude and phase tracking, or image ghosting may be present due to the inability to discern whether information is coming from above or below the central frequency. Additionally, since the center of the displayed image is at DC (zero Hertz), other common low-frequency disturbances, such as power line and elevated semiconductor noise, may produce a central image artifact. As analog to digital converter performance has improved, digitizing at intermediate or directly at radio frequencies is becoming more common. The digitized signal can now be down-converted by a digital multiplication and filtered in identical digital filters, avoiding the inaccuracies at DC and analog filter tracking requirements of the conventional quadrature receiver (see Fig. 4-37).
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004055
1 of 3
PULSE SEQUENCE GENERATION
Overview Magnetic resonance imaging requires the controlled application of magnetic field gradients, the transmission of RF energy, and the collection and processing of RF response signals (MRI signal). The pulse sequence generator is responsible for the control and timing of these stimuli and the detected signal (FID or ECHO). The pulse sequence generator translates requested scan parameters into gradient waveforms, RF envelope waveforms, and control sequences that steer the response of the spin system through a desired order in k-space. The waveforms and timing of these sequences depend on many factors, e.g., the pulse sequence type, pulse sequence parameters, imaging options, and the system hardware limitations such as gradient slew rate and peak gradient amplitude.
Add to lightbox
Figure 4-37 A basic block diagram of a digital quadrature receiver. Here the quadrature detection is accomplished using digital multipliers. This technique has significant advantages over the analog detection method shown in Figure 4-36.
Performance characteristics of the pulse sequence generator have a direct impact on the image quality. Some of these characteristics include waveform synchronization, waveform resolution, and waveform update rates. First, the pulse sequence generator must maintain tight time synchronization among individual waveforms and waveform points to provide adequate control of the spin system, and allow proper reception of the system response. Skew or a lack of synchronization can manifest itself in phase artifacts, while jitter between waveform points tends to affect SNR. The dynamic range, resolution, and update rates of individual waveforms also drive image quality limits. The degree to which these parameters affect image quality highly depends on the MR imaging technique employed.
Gradient Waveform Gradient waveform generation is restricted in consideration of patient comfort and safety limits as well as gradient subsystem performance limitations. Some restrictions are placed on gradient waveform generation to prevent peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) in patients. Other restrictions are placed on waveforms due to the slew rate limits, peak amplitude, and duty cycle limits of gradient coils and amplifiers. page 133 page 134
Gradient waveform generation may include a number of realtime computations and corrections to optimize MRI system performance. Some of these waveform manipulations include gradient shim offsets, eddy current compensation, and rotation of gradient axes. Gradient shim offsets are DC offsets applied to compensate gradient waveforms based on measured inhomogeneity of the main magnetic field B0. Eddy current compensation is applied to gradient waveforms to correct for currents
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004055
2 of 3
that are induced in metal surfaces through application of the gradients, since the induced currents can distort the expected gradient field. A calibration procedure is used to characterize and compensate the induced eddy currents as explained in the system calibration section. Additional eddy current compensation can be realized through modulation of the system center frequency synchronized with realtime play out of the gradient waveforms. An additional optimization of system resources may be employed through waveform rotation processing. Since the system gradient coils are oriented in three orthogonal axes, a set of logical gradient waveforms can be defined for slice excitation in any Cartesian plane. Oblique planes can be derived from these logical gradient waveforms by treating each point in the gradient play out as a vector, and rotating that vector to the oblique plane. These gradient waveform corrections and optimizations require realtime processing while maintaining synchronization with the play out of RF waveforms and control sequences.
Radiofrequency Waveform Radiofrequency waveform generation, like gradient waveform generation, observes restrictions to maintain patient comfort and safety and to operate within limits of RF coils and amplifiers. Since RF power is transmitted into patients to create resonance within a selected volume, RF waveform amplitudes, durations, and duty cycles are restricted to prevent patients from exposure above specific absorption rate (SAR) limits. The addition of power monitoring and system interlocks is typically employed to eliminate unintended RF exposure. The purpose of the RF transmit waveform is to create or suppress resonance in tissues with specific MR imaging characteristics within a selected volume. This imaging volume is selected through the combination of gradients and RF excitation during the stimulus portion of the MRI experiment. The RF excitation pulse is provided through control of an RF modulator. Details of the RF modulator hardware may be found in the RF chain section of this chapter. However, the key parameters in the control of the RF excitation waveform are the frequency, the amplitude, and the phase of the RF pulse. The pulse sequence generator may synchronously control some or all of these parameters during the RF excitation pulse. Fat suppression pulses and selection of an off-center slice are examples where the frequency and phase of the RF pulse needs to be controlled in realtime. Also, during the reception of the detected MR signal, additional control of the RF modulator's phase and frequency may be needed.
Control Sequences During an MR imaging experiment, a number of control signals are applied in synchronization with the gradient and RF waveform play out. Some of these control signals protect sensitive electronics, others are key to providing high MR image quality or enable more flexible pulse sequence control, while others control the data flow through the image processing section of the MRI system. Magnetic resonance imaging requires sensitive RF receive electronics to detect small MRI signals with the highest possible SNR. Coil elements and sensitive receive electronics are commanded into a protected mode when RF excitation is played out. During this RF excitation time, the high power RF amplifier is commanded to provide output drive. This output is then disabled or blanked to allow for the quietest possible RF environment during reception of the MRI signal response. In addition, some RF coils provide transmit and receive capabilities. Synchronous control is required to command these coils from the transmit state to the receive state in concert with sequence play out. The control sequencer is responsible for resetting the phase of the RF modulator to maintain control of the RF phase for the excitation and receive portions of the MRI experiment. The control sequencer may also be used to indicate the timing of the receive data window for the filter and reconstruction processors in the system. Other potential uses for sequence synchronous control signals include: triggering external equipment based on scan timing, synchronizing realtime modifications to waveform play out, realtime selection of coil interfaces, and synchronized control of RF transmit and receive gain.
Gating Some MR imaging techniques require pulse sequence play out to be synchronized or gated with external events. The pulse sequence generator may provide sequence-triggering inputs to enable these
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004055
3 of 3
techniques. In the most common case, physiologic gating signals are used to control the effects of cardiac and respiratory motion in imaging. In these cases, the challenge is to generate an accurate and reliable gating signal. Physiologic sensors must provide good signals in the high magnetic field environment. Since physiologic signals within the patient are continuously varying, predictive and post-processing algorithms must often be applied to maintain acceptable gating performance.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:54
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004061
SYSTEM CALIBRATION
Overview Like other medical instrumentations, an MRI scanner needs to be calibrated before it is used for diagnostic purposes. These calibration and tuning procedures can be divided into two categories: 1. Calibrations that are performed after system installation and those performed regularly as a part of plan maintenance; 2. The adjustments and tuning done before each patient scan. Different manufacturers might have different ways of achieving this. In the past, MRI has been used as a qualitative diagnostic imaging tool. Today a state-of-art MRI scanner can perform quantitative measurements such as flow, diffusion, perfusion and pO 2 (oxygen pressure). These techniques may require special calibration procedures. page 134 page 135
System Installation and Regular System Calibrations After an MRI system is installed, the following calibrations need to be performed at the top level: 1. Gradient calibration: gradient coefficients are adjusted so that the slice thickness, and FOV are correct; 2. Main field shimming: main field shimmed to meet the field homogeneity specifications using passive shims, super-conducting shims, or both; 3. B1 RF calibrations: the RF amplifier is calibrated to output predictable RF amplitude; 4. Eddy current calibrations: eddy current coefficients are calculated using a special pulse sequence for compensation. The part of the gradient driver shaping the gradient waveform to reduce eddy currents that induce phase and field shifts is called a pre-emphasis circuit. Generally the calibration values for each subsystem are stored in separate calibration files that are loaded during the system boot. The calibrations should be checked and adjusted if necessary at regular time intervals as a part of preventative maintenance.
Calibrations and Tuning before each Patient Scan MR image quality is sensitive to patient shape and weight, since each patient loads the system differently. Thus the magnitude of the RF pulse, B0 field homogeneity, and the SNR depend on the patient size and positioning. To account for these variations and maximize the image quality, most manufacturers use a portion of the scan time (auto-prescan) to optimize parameters such as the transmit power, receive attenuation, and field homogeneity (shimming) within the specified FOV. This algorithm might be different for various pulse sequences and RF coils. First the required transmit power is determined by varying the transmit gain (TG). Basically the transmit power is increased in steps to obtain the maximum signal (FID magnitude). If sufficiently large TR (repeat time) is used, this ensures that 90° flip angle was attained. Given the shape of the 180° RF pulse, the required amplitude for 180° pulse can then easily be computed assuming good RF amplifier linearity. Similarly, in the case of small flip angles, the amplitude is calculated using the 90° flip angle amplitude as a reference. Once TG has been determined, the MRI signal must be normalized to utilize the entire dynamic range of the analog-to-digital converter (ADC) without over ranging the input of the ADC. To achieve this, receiver gain or attenuation is automatically adjusted. The field homogeneity within the prescribed FOV is shimmed, by applying small currents to the gradient coils. This is also known as gradient shim. Some applications using fat suppression, and others such as spectroscopy, spiral scanning, and functional imaging may require high-order shim. This is achieved by adding extra shim coils and a shim power supply controlled by the scanner during the calibration. All these calibrations are performed with the software without any user interaction prior to each scan to ensure good image quality. Some manufacturers also incorporate, depending on the type of the RF coil and the field strength, an auto-tuning of the RF coil into the algorithm.
1 of 3
11-04-2010 23:55
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004061
2 of 3
REFERENCES 1. Bloch F: The nuclear induction. Phys Rev 70:460-474, 1946. 2. Bloch F, Hansen WW, Packard M: The nuclear induction experiment. Phys Rev 70:474-485, 1946. 3. Bloch F, Hansen WW, Packard M: The nuclear induction. Phys Rev 69:127, 1946. 4. Purcell EM, Torrey HC, Pound RV: Resonance absorption by nuclear magnetic moments in a solid. Phys Rev 69:37-38, 1946. 5. Damadian R: Apparatus and method for detecting cancer in tissue, US Patent# 3789823 filed Mar 17, 1972. 6. Lauterbur PC: Image formation by induced local interactions: examples employing nuclear magnetic resonance. Nature 242:190-191, 1973. 7. Mansfield P, Maudsley AA: Line scan proton spin imaging in biological structures by NMR. Phys Med Biol 23:847, 1976. 8. Mansfield P, Pykett IL, Morris PG, et al: Whole body line scan imaging by NMR. Br J Radiol 52:242, 1979. Medline Similar articles 9. Mansfield P, Pykett IL: Biological and medical imaging by NMR. J Magn Reson 29:355-373, 1978. 10. Mansfield P, Maudsley AA: Medical imaging by NMR. Br J Radiol 50:188-194, 1977. Medline
Similar articles
11. Weigner M, Pruessmann KP, Leussler C, et al: Specific coil design for SENSE: A six-Element Cardiac Array. Magn Reson Med 45:495-504, 2001. Medline Similar articles 12. 2002 ISMRM Tenth Scientific Meeting and Exhibition, paper #834. 13. Sagawa M, Fujimura S, Togawa H, et al: New material for permanent magnets on a base of Nd and Fe. J Appl Phys 55:2083-2087, 1984. 14. Tilley DR, Tilley J: Superfluidity and superconductivity, 3rd ed. Bristol, UK: IOP Publishing, 1990. 15. Dresner L: Stability of Superconductors. New York: Plenum Press, 1995. 16. Gollay MW: Field Homogenizing Coils for NMR Instrumentation. Rev Sci Instrum 29:313, 1938. 17. Schenck JF, Hussain MA, Edelstein WE: Transverse gradient field coils for nuclear magnetic resonance. US Patent 4,646,024. 18. Roemer PB, Hickey JS: Self-shielded gradient coils for nuclear magnetic resonance imaging. US Patent 4,737,716. 19. Katzenelson E, Harvey PR: Modular MRI gradient coils. UK Patent 22950020 A. 20. Liu Q: Gradient coil capable of producing a variable field of view. US Patent 6,630,829B1. 21. Yoda K: Analytical design methods of self shielded planar coils. J Appl Phys 67:4349-53, 1990. 22. Silva AC, Merkle HE: Hardware considerations for functional magnetic resonance imaging. Concepts Magn Res 16A:35-49, 2003. 23. Hoult DI: The NMR receiver: A description and analysis of design. Progress in NMR spectroscopy 12:41, 1978. 24. Bleaney BI, Bleaney B: Electricity and magnetism, 2nd ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1965. 25. Vizmuller P: RF design guide. Boston: Artech House, 1995. 26. Krauss HL, Bostian CW, Raab FH: Solid state radio engineering. New York: J. Wiley, 1980. 27. Stremler FG: Introduction to communication systems. Prentice Hall, New Jersey, 3rd ed, 1990, Addison Wesley, 197. 28. Gonzalez G: Microwave transistor amplifiers. London: Prentice Hall International, 1997. 29. Bowick C: RF circuit design. Boston: Newnes, 1982. 30. Chen C-N, Hoult DI, Sank VJ: A parallel algorithm for rotating frame zeugmatography. Magn Reson Med 1:354, 1984. Medline Similar articles 31. Glover GH, Hayes CE, Pelc NJ, et al: Comparison of linear and circular polarization for magnetic resonance imaging. J Magn Res 64:255, 1985. 32. Jin J: Electromagnetic analysis and design in MRI. New York: CRC Press, 1999. 33. Hayes CE, Edelstein WA, Schenck JF, et al: An efficient, highly homogenous radiofrequency coil for whole-body NMR imaging at 1.5 T. J Magn Res 63:622, 1985. 34. Guclu, C: Effect of body coil electric field distribution on receive-only surface coil heating. J Magn Res Imaging 14(4):484, 2001. 35. Boskamp EB, Schenck JF, Schaefer DJ, et al: ISMRM book of abstracts, 736, 1999. 36. Beresten K, Wright SM, Boskamp EB: ISMRM book of abstracts, 1095, 1994. 37. Caron, WN: Antenna impedance matching. Newington, CT: American Radio Relay League, 1993. page 135 page 136
38. Gunston MAR: Microwave transmission line impedance data. Atlanta: Noble, 1997. 39. Sevick J: Transmission line transformers. Newington, CT: American Radio Relay League, 1987.
11-04-2010 23:55
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC004061
3 of 3
40. Roemer PB, Edelstein WA, Hayes CE, et al: The NMR phased array. Magn Res Med 16:192, 1990. 41. Hayes CE, Roemer PB: Noise correlations in data simultaneously acquired from multiple surface coil arrays. Magn Res Med 16:181, 1990. 42. Pruessmann K, Weiger M, Scheidegger M, et al: SENSE: Sensitivity encoding for fast MRI. Magn Res Med 42:952, 1999. 43. Weiger M, Pruessmann K, Leussler C, et al: Specific coil design for sense: a six element cardiac array. Magn Res Med 45:495, 2001. 44. Guclu CC, Boskamp E, Zheng T, et al: A method for preamplifier-decoupling improvement in quadrature phased-array coils. Magn Res Imaging 19:255-258, 2004.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:55
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00503068
1 of 1
ULSE
EQUENCE
ESIGN
J. Paul Finn Vibhas S. Deshpande Orlando P. Simonetti
INTRODUCTION Since the second edition of this book, continued advances in hardware, computer technology, image reconstruction methods, and the applications of contrast agents have fueled explosive development in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). As most advances are based on sophisticated engineering or physical principles, the gap in understanding between developers and users is greater than ever, and is widening. This would not be a problem were it not for the fact that the choice and interpretation of MRI techniques is best when based on a clear understanding of how these techniques work. This chapter is written with the user in mind. Several excellent recent texts are available for the interested reader with 1,2 a strong technical background who is looking for mathematical rigor. What we aim to do is to introduce the novice to some aspects of pulse sequence design which will give him or her insight into how best to apply MRI in various clinical circumstances. We include, however, more detail on relevant data acquisition, signal processing, and image reconstruction methods than do typical clinical texts. The same basic physical and image reconstruction principles apply over a wide range of techniques, albeit sometimes disguised in a different format. MRI is a multiparametric technique, and many parameters can be associated in a more or less arbitrary manner. A confounding array of different pulse sequences is therefore possible. The process of applications development with MRI has features in common with drug discovery: from a huge pool of potential candidates, relatively few find their way into routine clinical practice. There are several reasons for this: in some cases there is no clear clinical application for a pulse sequence; in some cases there is a substantial time lag between initial concept and availability as a commercial product; and in some cases a technique proves unwieldy or unreliable in a clinical context. Such, however, is the nature of research, and there is no progress without trial and error. Pulse sequence design is a huge topic, comprising elements from many disciplines in the physical and clinical sciences, and a comprehensive treatment of the subject is beyond the scope of any book chapter. However, it is our hope that once the reader has grasped the relevant basic principles, he or she will see how the same tools make subsecond imaging of the heart and spin-echo imaging of the brain equally understandable. In this chapter, we confine the scope of the discussion to a description of the relevant physics, data acquisition, signal processing, and image reconstruction as they relate to conventional and ultrafast MRI techniques. We do not deal with hardware issues or parallel imaging methods, which are covered in detail in Chapters 4 and 8 respectively. We also deal only with those clinical issues relevant to illustrating the applications of specific families of pulse sequences. Some mathematical detail is provided for those who are interested, but those who are not should not be discouraged and should read through. Practical, plausibility comments usually accompany the mathematical statements. We take as our working definition of an MRI pulse sequence a series of radiofrequency (RF) events (pulses) and magnetic field gradient events (pulses) generating nuclear magnetic resonance signals that, when appropriately processed, result in the formation of an image. The details of how the RF and gradient pulses are played out determine the form, speed, and information content of the image. We concern ourselves with these processes.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:56
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005001
1 of 1
INTRODUCTION Since the second edition of this book, continued advances in hardware, computer technology, image reconstruction methods, and the applications of contrast agents have fueled explosive development in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). As most advances are based on sophisticated engineering or physical principles, the gap in understanding between developers and users is greater than ever, and is widening. This would not be a problem were it not for the fact that the choice and interpretation of MRI techniques is best when based on a clear understanding of how these techniques work. This chapter is written with the user in mind. Several excellent recent texts are available for the interested reader with a strong technical background who is looking for mathematical rigor.1,2 What we aim to do is to introduce the novice to some aspects of pulse sequence design which will give him or her insight into how best to apply MRI in various clinical circumstances. We include, however, more detail on relevant data acquisition, signal processing, and image reconstruction methods than do typical clinical texts. The same basic physical and image reconstruction principles apply over a wide range of techniques, albeit sometimes disguised in a different format. MRI is a multiparametric technique, and many parameters can be associated in a more or less arbitrary manner. A confounding array of different pulse sequences is therefore possible. The process of applications development with MRI has features in common with drug discovery: from a huge pool of potential candidates, relatively few find their way into routine clinical practice. There are several reasons for this: in some cases there is no clear clinical application for a pulse sequence; in some cases there is a substantial time lag between initial concept and availability as a commercial product; and in some cases a technique proves unwieldy or unreliable in a clinical context. Such, however, is the nature of research, and there is no progress without trial and error. Pulse sequence design is a huge topic, comprising elements from many disciplines in the physical and clinical sciences, and a comprehensive treatment of the subject is beyond the scope of any book chapter. However, it is our hope that once the reader has grasped the relevant basic principles, he or she will see how the same tools make subsecond imaging of the heart and spin-echo imaging of the brain equally understandable. In this chapter, we confine the scope of the discussion to a description of the relevant physics, data acquisition, signal processing, and image reconstruction as they relate to conventional and ultrafast MRI techniques. We do not deal with hardware issues or parallel imaging methods, which are covered in detail in Chapters 4 and 8 respectively. We also deal only with those clinical issues relevant to illustrating the applications of specific families of pulse sequences. Some mathematical detail is provided for those who are interested, but those who are not should not be discouraged and should read through. Practical, plausibility comments usually accompany the mathematical statements. We take as our working definition of an MRI pulse sequence a series of radiofrequency (RF) events (pulses) and magnetic field gradient events (pulses) generating nuclear magnetic resonance signals that, when appropriately processed, result in the formation of an image. The details of how the RF and gradient pulses are played out determine the form, speed, and information content of the image. We concern ourselves with these processes.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:57
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005002
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND PHYSICS
Magnetization
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-1 Net magnetization vector and spin precession around B0. As shown in A, the torque τ acting on a typical spin is always perpendicular both to the spin and to the main field. This results in a circular motion of the tip of the spin vector around the axis of the main field. As shown in B, there is a slight excess of vectors pointing with the field, giving rise to a net magnetization, M. Because the spins are randomly orientated in the x-y plane, there is no net x-y magnetization.
From a practical point of view, we need only concern ourselves with the "net magnetization vector," M (Fig. 5-1), which is the vector sum of all the individual spins (small arrows) aligned parallel to the main magnetic field, B0. At equilibrium, M is steady along the axis of B0 (conventionally the "z" axis) and experiences no tendency to rotate off axis; i.e., there is no twisting effect or "torque." This is because the main field and the magnetization vector are parallel; in order for there to be a torque, the magnetization must be at least partially perpendicular to the main field. So, when aligned along z, the magnetization is essentially static and does not generate a detectable signal in the presence of the static external field. In order to be detectable, the magnetization must have a net component which lies within the transverse (x-y) plane. If rotated away from z, the magnetization will experience a torque, proportional to its component in the x-y plane, and will precess coherently about B0 and be detectable in the x-y plane by a suitable probe. The Larmor frequency is the resonant frequency with which the spins rotate in the presence of a magnetic field; it is specific for each nuclear species and, for any given nucleus, it increases proportionately with the strength of the applied external magnetic field. At 1.5 Tesla, the Larmor frequency for hydrogen nuclei (protons) is approximately 63.75 megahertz (MHz); at 3.0 Tesla, it is approximately 127.8 MHz. Recall that a changing magnetic field always implies a changing electric field, and vice versa. The changing electric field constitutes a sinusoidally alternating voltage in the transverse plane, and this is detectable by a probe. How might M be rotated partially or fully into the transverse plane? The rotation of the magnetization vector, M, is accomplished by the magnetic field of an RF pulse, generally designated the B1 field. Recall that radio waves are part of the spectrum of electromagnetic radiation, and that all electromagnetic waves are composed of electric and magnetic fields perpendicular to each other, and oscillating sinusoidally at a specific
1 of 4
11-04-2010 23:58
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005002
frequency. The magnetic field of the RF wave, B1, can be thought of as adding to the main field, B0, but in a perpendicular direction. Now we have M and B1 perpendicular to each other, so B1 exerts a torque on M. The direction of the torque is at all times perpendicular both to B1 and M, and is defined by a "vector product" as detailed below (don't worry if you're not familiar with the vector product). So, in order to rotate M away from the z direction: The magnetic field of the RF pulse must lie somewhere in the x-y plane (this is the plane perpenicular to M) The B1 field must stay synchronous with the magnetization by rotating at the same (Larmor) 3
frequency as M (Fig. 5-2A). Otherwise, the effect of the B1 field would average out and produce no net rotation. In this case, as B1 tips M off axis, the motion of M relative to B1 is characterized by a simple rotation around the B1 axis (Fig. 5-2B). At the Larmor frequency, the motion of M describes a cone-shaped "precession" around B1 so that M lies within the y-z plane. The precessional frequency of M around B1 is γB1 and the angle α that M rotates through is given by where t is the duration for which the RF field of strength B1 is applied (see Fig. 5-2B). α is generally referred to as the "flip angle."
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 138 page 139
Figure 5-2 A, The B1 field is synchronous with the magnetization M in the x-y plane to produce a nutation of M. B, The motion of M is due to the torque M × B1, which nutates M through α toward y' at a rate γB1.
Relaxation As we have seen, perturbation of the magnetization by application of a short RF pulse tips it away from the longitudinal axis and generates a transverse component. If this magnetization is allowed to precess freely, there is a regrowth of the longitudinal magnetization called longitudinal relaxation, and
2 of 4
11-04-2010 23:58
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005002
destruction of the transverse magnetization called transverse relaxation. Relaxation is described by exponential time constants: T1 for longitudinal and T2 for transverse relaxation. Exponential processes are those whose rate of change depends on how far they have left to go; the closer they get to their final value, the more slowly they approach it. T1 is defined as the time taken for the longitudinal magnetization to relax from 0 to 63% of the equilibrium magnitude. T2, or the transverse relaxation time constant, is the measure of the time that the transverse magnetization takes to relax (decay) to 37% of its initial magnitude. T2 decay occurs because individual spins (usually referred to as isochromats) rotate at slightly different rates due to their chemical environment, and eventually they get out of sync and begin to point in random directions and cancel each other. This process is referred to as "dephasing," because the spins acquire different phases in the range 0 to 360°. In practice, field inhomogeneities can be another source of transverse relaxation, other than the chemical environment. The dephasing due to this process is accounted for by another time constant, T2'. The total transverse relaxation time constant (T2*) then is the reciprocal sum of T2 and T2' and is given by:
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-3 Typical longitudinal and transverse relaxation curves plotted for T1 and T2 of 500 ms.
Both the longitudinal and transverse relaxations are modeled by exponential functions (Fig. 5-3) given by the Bloch equations, which are stated without further justification:
Mz longitudinal magnetization
3 of 4
11-04-2010 23:58
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005002
4 of 4
Mz0 longitudinal magnetization at t = 0+, i.e., immediately after the RF pulse M0 equilibrium magnetization Mxy transverse magnetization. Different tissues have different relaxation time constants, and these form the basis of some of the contrast mechanisms in MRI.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:58
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
1 of 29
PULSE SEQUENCE DESIGN As mentioned earlier, a pulse sequence is defined as a sequence of radiofrequency and gradient events applied as a function of time. Many different components are involved in sequence design. Each individual component is first briefly introduced here to elucidate the underlying principles of sequence design. This is followed by a summary of the commonly used existing pulse sequences.
Gradients Gradient fields are spatially varying magnetic fields. Linear magnetic field gradients are used in MRI to encode spatial information. The Larmor equation states that the precessional frequency (ω) of a spin is directly proportional to the applied magnetic field strength (B): where G (T/m) is the gradient field, r is the position of the spin along the gradient axis, and γ is a proportionality constant called the gyromagnetic ratio. γ is constant for a given nuclear species, relating the Larmor frequency to the applied field strength. It can be thought of as a scaling factor for field strength. page 139 page 140
Thus, the mapping of position to frequency by a magnetic field gradient follows directly from the Larmor equation. A spatial variation in the magnetic field causes a corresponding spatial variation in precessional frequency. The gradient field is produced by pulsing current through some combination of coils to generate three spatially orthogonal, linear variations in the main field (Gx, Gy, and Gz). Whereas the main magnetic field, B0, is generally fixed in direction and magnitude, the gradient field G can assume a range of values, and any arbitrary direction achieved by a combination of Gx, Gy, and Gz . Note at this point that the field generated by the gradient coils is in the direction of the main field (z), so that the magnitude of the Bz field is made to be a function of position along the direction of the gradient. For example, an x-gradient augments the B0 field such that the magnetic field Bz varies as a function of position in the x direction. Thus, "gradient" refers to the rate of change of the Bz field in the specified direction. When the x gradient Gx is active, the net field Bnet has components from the main field, B0, and Gx such that and combining with Equation 5-6 yields Equation 5-8 expresses resonance frequency as a linear function of position along the gradient direction, where x is the offset from the magnet isocenter. At the isocenter, the net field is B0 at all times, because x (and therefore xGx) is zero. The actual field at any position within the magnet bore is the sum of contributions from all sources including the main field, applied gradients, and intrinsic susceptibility gradients. As Equation 5-8 shows, in the presence of gradients, each isochromat acquires a unique frequency of precession. Thus, when the signal is read out, the position of each isochromat can then be decoded (demodulated) depending on its frequency of precession. This property of "encoding" the position of a spin is among the most important uses of gradients in pulse sequences. For clinical machines, the maximal gradient strength typically lies in the range 20 to 50 mT/m. In typical imaging systems, the gradient field is approximately two orders of magnitude smaller than the main field. For example, if B0 is 1.5 T, the maximal field caused by the gradients is approximately ±12.5 mT, assuming maximal gradient amplitudes of 50 mT/m over a linear range of ±25 cm (Fig. 5-4). The 6 gradient in frequency corresponding to the field gradient is given by γG, where γ = 42 × 10 Hz/T is the 6 gyromagnetic ratio. For G = 50 mT/m = 0.05 T/m, the spatial frequency gradient is therefore 2.1 × 10 6 Hz/m. For a field of view = 50 cm = ±25 cm, the spatial frequency bandwidth = 2.1 × 10 Hz/m × 0.5 m
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
2 of 29
= 1.05 × 106 Hz or ±525 kHz. Sometimes the bandwidth is normalized to the imaging matrix and is expressed in Hz per pixel. For a 256-image matrix, a bandwidth of 1.05 megahertz corresponds to 4.1 kHz/pixel.
Radiofrequency Events and Slice Selection In MRI, RF energy is typically applied as a pulse lasting from tens of microseconds to tens of milliseconds, depending on the application. When the RF is applied on resonance, that is, at the Larmor frequency, the magnetization is rotated α° about B1, as discussed earlier. The degree of rotation of the magnetization depends on the strength of the applied RF field and the duration of the applied field. When α is 90°, all magnetization is rotated into the x-y plane, and the potential signal is maximal. As discussed later, however, for many applications flip angles other than 90° are used. For example, 180° pulses are used for inversion and refocusing, and pulses substantially less than 90° may be appropriate for short repetition time (TR) imaging. Often, the direction of the B1 field in the transverse plane, or what is referred to as its phase, is also important in sequences such as spoiled gradient-echo sequences or steady-state free precession (SSFP) sequences. Many different types of RF pulse are used in MRI. They are broadly classified into two types, "hard" and "soft" pulses, or pulses that are spatially nonselective and selective, respectively. RF pulses of short duration and high amplitude are described as hard pulses. These pulses, on account of their short duration, excite a broad range of frequencies and are therefore referred to as nonselective pulses. In general, the shorter the RF pulse, the larger the range of frequencies that it excites, or what is commonly referred to as a large "bandwidth." Pulses of longer duration allow excitation of only a narrow band of frequencies and are termed "soft" pulses. In the presence of slice selection gradients, these RF pulses can be used for localized imaging. Other, specialized pulses include hyperbolic secant pulses that are used for inversion, and fat suppression pulses that are narrow bandwidth frequency selective pulses. These specialized pulses and their applications will be described in the later sections.
Slice Selection
Add to lightbox page 140 page 141
Figure 5-4 Gradient field. Magnetic field gradient causes the frequency at position x to change by x(δG/δx). The field experienced by spins far off center in the positive direction is therefore greater than that seen by spins close to the magnet isocenter. As illustrated, the gradient strength is 25 mT/m.
One of the advantages of MRI over other imaging modalities is the ability to image planes or slices of tissue with effectively any arbitrary orientation, thickness, and position. The process of slice selection is carried out by applying band-limited RF energy, or soft RF pulses, simultaneously with a magnetic field gradient. A schematic of the slice selection process is shown in Figure 5-5. Recall that a linear gradient makes the precessional frequency of the spins vary with position. Therefore, to excite a slice plane, the resonance frequency of the spin system perpendicular to the slice plane direction (ωs) is made to vary linearly with position by a slice-selection field gradient Gs superimposed on the main field B0:
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
3 of 29
A slice of a given thickness therefore contains spins precessing over a range of frequencies. By applying RF only in this frequency range, the bandwidth ∆f, the slice of interest can be selectively excited. (Note that, in the general case, the bandwidth of the RF pulse bears no necessary relationship to the receiver bandwidth during readout; these are entirely independent events.) The slice thickness (T) is related to the RF bandwidth by
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-5 Slice selection using a gradient and a band-limited RF pulse. Given the strength of the slice selection gradient (Gs), the thickness of the slice (T) will depend on the RF bandwidth, ∆f. The slice position depends on the center frequency of the RF pulse, f. If the center frequency is changed (with the bandwidth remaining unchanged), the position of the slice translates along the gradient axis, with the thickness remaining constant.
Inspection of Equation 5-10 reveals that for a given RF bandwidth, stronger gradients produce thinner slices and, for a given gradient amplitude, narrower bandwidths (longer pulses) produce thinner slices. For example, if we fix the gradient at 10 mT/m (426 Hz/mm), a 5-mm slice spans a 2.1-kHz range of frequencies. If the gradient is increased to 25 mT/m (1064.5 Hz/mm), a 2.1-kHz band covers only 2 mm, and the same pulse and bandwidth now excite a slice only 2.0 mm thick. To excite a 2.0-mm slice using a 10 mT/m gradient, the RF pulse must have a bandwidth of 852 Hz. As shown in Figure 5-5, the position of the slice in space can be controlled by the center frequency of the RF pulse. Altering the center frequency of the RF pulse changes the slice position along the applied gradient axis. However, the slice thickness remains the same as long as the bandwidth of the RF pulse remains constant. Therefore, a slice is defined by its orientation, determined by the gradient direction thickness, determined by the interplay between gradient amplitude and RF bandwidth offset (position along the slice-selection direction), determined by RF center frequency (f). The task is now reduced to limiting the excitation to a frequency band covering no more than the desired slice thickness.
Slice Profile
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
4 of 29
Ideally, one would fully excite all magnetization, M, within the slice of interest and leave everything outside the slice unaffected. The formal representation of this arrangement is a square wave, where M has its full value for all frequencies within the specified bandwidth, ±f0, and is zero for f greater than |f0|. We must now prescribe an RF pulse waveform, played out over time, having this well-defined frequency bandwidth. The frequency content of any time waveform is described by its Fourier transform. For in-depth background on Fourier transforms and their applications, the interested reader is referred to two excellent texts.4,5 It must be noted that the Fourier transform relationship between the RF pulse envelope and the resultant magnetization holds only for flip angles less than approximately 30°. The nonlinearity of the Bloch equations must be accounted for at higher flip angles.6 Nevertheless, the Fourier transform offers a good first approximation to the response of the spin system to RF excitation in the presence of a linear field gradient. For a given desired slice profile and the initial condition of the magnetization, the shape of slice selective RF pulse can be designed by calculating the inverse Fourier transformation of the slice profile. From Fourier transform theory, if we require a square frequency domain waveform, we need to apply a time domain RF pulse as a sinc function of infinite duration, illustrated in Figure 5-6. The sinc function is formally defined as sin(πx)/x. It is a ubiquitous function in Fourier analysis and signal processing theory, and it has several interesting features. Nodes or zero crossings occur when the argument of the sinc function is an integral multiple of π. The bandwidth of the RF pulse is ∆f = ±f0, and this in turn is defined by the (reciprocal) time to the first zero crossing in the sinc function. page 141 page 142
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-6 Rectangular frequency band (A) and its Fourier transform (B). A sinc RF profile over time produces a well-defined spectrum in the frequency domain. The vertical lines in B denote the times of the first zero crossings, which determine the bandwidth, ±(f0/2). The nodes of the sinc function in this example occur at integer multiples of 1/f0. The example illustrated assumes the sinc function is infinite, not truncated.
The broader the sinc function, the narrower the bandwidth, and vice versa. For example, in the above example with a 10-mT/m gradient, the sinc function that produces a 5-mm thick slice has a bandwidth of 2.1 kHz and has its first zero crossing 470 μs after maximal amplitude. To excite a 2.0-mm slice using a 10-mT/m gradient, the RF pulse has a bandwidth of 852 Hz and its first zero crossing 1175 μs after the maximal amplitude.
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
5 of 29
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-7 Slice profile resulting from truncated RF pulse. Because the RF pulse is truncated in time, the frequency convolution theorem implies that the attenuated sinc RF pulse transforms not to the square wave P(f) but to the convolution of P(f) with the transform A(f) of the sampling envelope a(t). This effect introduces ripples into the edges of the slice, most pronounced for extremely short pulses.
However, the definition of the Fourier transform considered here assumes that the RF pulse is played out over infinite time! This is, of course, impractical, and for many applications severe constraints are placed on the time available for RF excitation. A typical pulse lasts several milliseconds and may last as little as a few hundred microseconds. The result of truncating (shortening) the RF pulse is a distortion or "rippling" of the slice profile. The effects of truncation are summarized without mathematical proof in Figure 5-7. The slice profile becomes distorted at the edges due to truncation of the RF pulse. Furthermore, the Fourier transform procedure for RF pulse design does not work for higher flip angles due to the non-linearity of the Bloch equations. In such cases, numerical solutions may be used. The Shinnar-Le Roux algorithm7,8,9 is one such widely used tool to design slice-selective RF pulses. This algorithm enables the quick computation of an RF pulse envelope given input characteristics such as flip angle, RF bandwidth, duration of the pulse, and percent ripples in the stopband and passband. In practice, one cannot spend too long playing out the RF pulse, and the slice profile may be improved by filtering or smoothing in the time domain. Most commonly, the amplitude of the RF time envelope is weighted with a gaussian or Hanning filter function, smoothing out the ripples at the expense of widening the main central lobe of the profile. page 142 page 143
Recall that another factor of practical importance in improving the slice profile is the strength of the slice-selection gradient. Because of the Larmor relationship between magnetic field strength and precessional frequency, a field gradient can be expressed in terms of hertz per millimeter, as discussed earlier. Thus, if the gradient is stronger, for a given slice thickness the bandwidth in the RF pulse is greater. This means more zero crossings can be used for the same pulse duration, decreasing truncation effects. So stronger gradients can be used to obtain thinner slices for a given pulse duration and bandwidth, better slice profiles for a given pulse duration and slice thickness, or shorter RF pulses for a given slice profile and thickness. The price to be paid for this, however, is an increase in the
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
6 of 29
maximum transmitter amplitude and the maximum rate of power deposition. Specific absorption rate (SAR) dose considerations may prove a limiting factor in certain circumstances.
Digitization Constraints The arguments put forward so far are valid for a mathematical pulse envelope with a continuous range of values over the truncation interval. However, because these RF waveforms are generated by computer, the pulse envelopes are specified digitally by a finite number of support points as digitalto-analog converter values, over the duration of the RF pulse. As a result, synthesized pulse waveforms are subject to the limitations of discrete sampling-specifically, aliasing-and they must be designed with this in mind. According to the Nyquist theorem, frequency ambiguity occurs for frequencies greater than half the sampling rate. This is the same phenomenon as occurs with pulsed Doppler or similar sampling schemes. Due to digitization, the waveform is reproduced periodically in the positive and negative frequency domain. In effect, discrete sampling generates an infinite number of copies of the measured signal, each copy separated by the sampling frequency-the greater the sampling frequency, the greater the separation between adjacent copies. If the Nyquist condition is met, there is no overlap between adjacent copies and the high-frequency copies of the pulse waveform are filtered out by low-pass filters-hardware crystals with a well-defined frequency response. This leaves only the desired signal. For example, if the pulse duration is 5120 μs and there are 512 sample points, the sampling frequency -5 is 10 /s = 100 kHz, and no aliasing occurs below 50 kHz. The low-pass filter cutoff frequency is therefore set at 50 kHz. As pointed out earlier, for larger flip angles (>30°), the response of the spin system deviates from linearity and the slice profile can no longer be predicted simply by Fourier transformation of the RF envelope. This is particularly true for 180° pulses. In practice, optimization by numerical methods is often utilized in RF pulse design.
Modulation In addition to defining the thickness of the slice, its offset or displacement along the gradient axis needs to be specified (see Fig. 5-5). To shift the center frequency of the RF pulse by frequency f m, the RF waveform is modulated with a sinusoid of the appropriate carrier frequency fm. Multiplication by a sinusoid in the time domain shifts the frequency envelope of the pulse without distorting its shape. The bandwidth (and slice thickness) is the same, but it is now centered at f = f m, not f = 0. By making fm continuously variable, any slice shift can be defined. The frequency offset, f m, that corresponds to a slice position x is given by As an example, if G(x) is 10 mT/m and x is 20 cm, fm is 85.2 kHz. Because it is necessary to be able to shift the slice several times its thickness, the modulation frequency (slice shift in hertz) is usually significantly greater than the bandwidth (slice thickness in hertz). In practice, modulation may be performed by applying an incremented phase change over time to the RF pulse envelope. For example, assume that we have a 5.12-ms pulse defined by 512 discrete points at 10-μs intervals. The phase at each point is incremented by where ϕ is in radians, τ is the duration of the RF pulse in seconds, and fm is the modulation frequency in hertz.
Gradient Refocusing A conventional approximation used by developers in slice-selection gradient waveform design is that the transverse magnetization is generated instantaneously halfway through the RF pulse. When an RF pulse is applied in the presence of a field gradient, the spins within the slice have a distribution of frequencies determined by their position along the gradient axis. The phases of the transverse
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
7 of 29
magnetization therefore fan out across the slice, but they can be brought back into alignment by a reverse gradient. When the RF pulse is complete and the gradient is turned off, a representative spin at any position has a phase according to its position on the gradient axis and the duration of the RF pulse. This phase can be "unwound" by a gradient of equal and opposite area as shown on the sliceselect axis in Figure 5-8.
Practical Considerations in Radiofrequency Pulse Design page 143 page 144
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-8 Gradient refocusing. ADC, analog-to-digital converter; Gp, phase-encoding gradient; Gr, read gradient; Gs, slice-select gradient. During slice selection, the phases of the spins are dispersed over the width of the slice. For stationary spins, these phases are unwound by a rephasing lobe equal to half the area of the primary lobe and of opposite sign. In the read direction, the phase dispersion caused by the first lobe is reversed by the rephasing lobe at the gradient-echo. As long as the integral of the second lobe exactly counterbalances the first lobe, the relative durations of the gradient lobes may be different. The duration of the readout lobe can therefore be expanded or contracted and its amplitude changed accordingly. In this way the bandwidth of the detected signal may be modified. In the phase-encode direction, a unipolar pulse imparts a constant phase to spins, proportional to position along the gradient axis.
As summarized in Equation 5-2, the integral of the B1 field over time determines the flip angle, and that required for a π pulse is twice that needed for a π/2 pulse. In practice, one typically fixes the duration of the RF pulse and calibrates the B1 intensity. It follows that a flip angle α can be reached with a short pulse of intense B1 or a longer pulse of less intense B1. In most situations, it is desirable to achieve α as quickly as possible. However, a number of factors considered later may limit how quickly this can be achieved: The peak voltage of the RF transmitter sets a limit on the B1 field intensity, such that the flip angle required may not be reached in the allotted time For spatially selective pulses, the slice profile becomes degraded with truncation. The availability of strong slice-selection gradients helps to offset this limitation, but it must still be considered For clinical imaging, the specific absorption rate for RF energy must remain within allowed limits. Shorter RF pulses require higher power, and therefore higher specific absorption rate values, to attain the same flip angle as longer pulses. It is clear from Equation 5-2 that if the B1 field is not homogeneous in the volume of interest, α is not a
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
8 of 29
single flip angle but is a distribution of flip angles. This may have unwanted effects on image contrast. The discussion so far has assumed that the RF is applied uniformly throughout the relevant field of view (FOV), in other words, that α is invariant over space. In practice, this is not the case, and the spatial variation in the B1 field is strongly influenced by the design of the transmitter and how the subject loads the coil. Generally, large transmitter coils have spatial B1 profiles that vary only slowly, whereas the RF field of small transmitter coils may fall off dramatically toward the periphery. It may be important to take these effects into account and, in the case of a surface receiver coil, to determine whether it also serves as transmitter. B1 nonuniformity is more problematic at higher field strengths, i.e., 3.0 T and above.
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-9 Changing effective field. As Beff changes its magnitude and rotates around y', the new effective field is B'eff = Beff-(δθ/δτ)/γ. When the frequency sweep is slow, such that δθ/δt is small, M follows Beff in the Beff-B1 plane.
When the B1 profile of a coil is known, it is possible to generate a correction algorithm for post-processing and normalization in the same way as for a surface receiver coil. Although useful for display purposes, such a scheme does not address SNR or contrast deficiencies that arise as a consequence of the RF field. B1 nonuniformity is most apparent and most damaging when large flip angles are used, as in inversion recovery (IR) imaging. Because the contrast in IR images is largely determined by the inversion pulse, IR images are sensitive to the B1 profile during inversion. Certain pulse envelopes show low sensitivity to B1 nonuniformity. Examples include adiabatic pulses, which are used widely for inversion.
Adiabatic Passage Adiabatic pulses do not obey the conventional relationship between the B1 amplitude and flip angle stated earlier in Equation 5-2, as non-adiabatic pulses do. They follow the adiabatic passage principle, which states that the magnetization vector follows the direction of the effective magnetic field provided that the effective field does not change significantly during the course of one precession of the magnetization about the effective field. The flip angle of an adiabatic pulse is then controlled by the B1 amplitude variation and the frequency modulation during its pulse duration. Even spins experiencing different B1 fields can be excited with the same flip angle if the conditions for adiabatic passage are met. page 144 page 145
Consider the motion of M in the rotating frame as the RF field is swept through resonance. When the frequency offset ∆ω = (ω0 - Ω) is large, there is a large residual Bz field B0 + Ω/γ (Fig. 5-9). Beff is
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
9 of 29
therefore coincident with B0 and M precesses about the main field. As the frequency offset is slowly decreased, Beff approaches B1 but at all times remains the precession axis for M. In other words, M follows Beff as it changes its orientation from along z through B1 to -z. The magnitude of Beff decreases to a minimum when aligned along B1 and then grows again. For M to follow Beff, the rate of precession of M around Beff must be large compared with the velocity of rotation of Beff. This is the adiabatic condition described earlier. Also, the sweep must be fast enough that no significant relaxation occurs during the RF irradiation. These boundary conditions can be summarized as When the offset frequency is incremented linearly over time, the RF power requirements can be significant. Noting that Beff is much larger at the beginning and end of the passage than at the center (when Beff = B1), Hardy and colleagues10 suggested a tangential frequency sweep of the form ωt - ω0 = ω1 tan(αω1t), where ωt - ω0 is the frequency offset at time t during the sweep, ω1 is the B1 frequency, and α is a scaling factor given by α = (2/ω1T0) arctan(θ/ω1), where T0 is the sweep time, 2θ is the range of the angular frequency sweep, and 0 < α < 1. This scheme provides an order of magnitude increased efficiency compared with a linear sweep and has good inversion properties. Because the B1 frequency is offset from the spin (Larmor) frequency, the B1 field is said to be 10
frequency modulated. In the scheme outlined by Hardy and coworkers, the amplitude of the B1 field is constant. Other workers have described adiabatic pulses that are amplitude and frequency modulated.11,12 These pulses provide insensitivity to inhomogeneity in the B1 spatial profile and can therefore be of value when the RF transmitter field is nonuniform. B1 insensitivity is especially important for inversion pulses as described in the following. For spins lying at arbitrary orientations (not along z) at the start of the pulse, the trajectory in the spatially varying B1 field is not defined. Classic adiabatic pulses can therefore be used for inversion and excitation, but because they cannot induce plane rotations about an axis of the rotating frame, they are inappropriate for refocusing. For a detailed analysis of the behavior of several classes of adiabatic 13 pulses, the interested reader is referred to the work of Ugurbil and colleagues. Following their notation, the functions for amplitude and frequency modulation, respectively, of adiabatic pulses have the form where v is the ratio of the peak RF amplitude to the frequency modulation amplitude A, and fB and fω 10 11 12 are time waveforms. Function pairs for fB/fω include constant/tan, sech/tanh, and sin/cos. By reversing the polarity of the B1 field at the half-passage point, Ugurbil and colleagues14 produced refocusing adiabatic pulses. The effect of this pulse scheme is to invert magnetization oriented along z' at the beginning of the pulse as for standard adiabatic passage. Spin vectors orthogonal to Beff at the beginning of the pulse remain orthogonal to Beff throughout, but the phase "scrambling" that occurs during the first half of the rotation is reversed during the second half by reversing the polarity of Beff. Spins within the entire plane are therefore refocused (or inverted). However, this pulse breaks down for spins far off-resonance. 11
Among the adiabatic pulses used, the hyperbolic secant pulse described by Silver and coworkers, is the most widely used pulse. In addition to being insensitive to RF nonuniformity, the hyperbolic secant pulse has excellent slice profile properties for inversion. Above a threshold B1 intensity, the magnetization remains inverted, and outside the slice the spins are returned to their equilibrium position along the z axis. Connolly and colleagues15 described a slice-selective, self-refocusing pulse that leaves no phase variation across the slice and maintains insensitivity to B1 nonuniformity. Their pulse is a composite one of 2π and π pulses; the 2π pulse performs no rotation, just compensates for the phase scrambling caused by the π pulse.
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
10 of 29
Adiabatic pulses have many advantages for certain imaging applications (such as IR sequences and blood-tagging studies16 but they are relatively long, and significant relaxation can take place in some tissues during irradiation. Tissue components with short relaxation times can lose signal during the pulse, insensitivity to B1 variations may be compromised, and spurious high signal intensity may originate from outside the slice.
17
In-Plane Spatial Encoding An MR image is a map of the spatial distribution of spins. Conventionally, the imaging volume is mapped onto a 3D Cartesian grid, the axes of which are labeled logically read, phase-encode, and slice selection. The basis of spatial encoding with MRI is that the Larmor frequency depends on the magnetic field experienced by the spins, and that this field in turn can be controlled. When this field is made to vary with position by a gradient, the local frequency is also made to vary in a known way. By means of the Fourier transform, it is possible to unravel the spectrum of frequencies generated by the encoding gradient and derive from them a map of signal amplitude versus position. We assume for the moment that the process of slice selection has reduced the task to encoding the remaining two dimensions of the slice plane. In this case, the resolution in the slice direction is reflected directly by the slice thickness in millimeters (ignoring complications due to RF truncation, chemical shift and flow).
Frequency Encoding and k-Space page 145 page 146
As discussed earlier, the application of a field gradient makes the precessional frequency a function of position along the gradient axis. Analogous to slice selection, when a linear gradient G(r) is applied in the frequency encoding ("read") direction, the precessional frequency ω(r) of a spin at position r along this direction in the rotating frame is: where ω(r) is in radians per second and f(r) is in hertz. For a read gradient G(r), the precessional frequency in a plane perpendicular to G(r) at a displacement r from the isocenter is uniquely defined. The signal amplitude at a given frequency is proportional to the number of spins at that frequency, as determined by the Fourier transform of the time domain signal. Mathematical analysis shows that immediately after an excitation pulse and ignoring relaxation and flow effects, the signal S sampled at time t after the application of a linear gradient G(r) is the Fourier transform of the spin distribution. 18
Here we introduce the concept of k-space or frequency space as the representation of the gradientencoded image before Fourier transformation. The raw time signal contains all the information about the frequency distribution of the spins in the direction of the read gradient. Each value of k is proportional to the zeroth time moment (or area), which is determined by the strength and duration of the gradient waveform in that direction. But it must be inverted from a map of signal versus spatial frequency into a readable image as signal versus position. A list of such values (spatial frequencies) is collected in the gradient direction to be input to the Fourier transform for this purpose.
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
11 of 29
Add to lightbox page 146 page 147
Figure 5-10 k-space trajectory. Prephasing lobes in the phase-encode (ky) and read (kx) directions assign the spins to the top left corner of the 2D k-space matrix. The read component is unwound by the rephasing read gradient during signal sampling, causing the k trajectory to run from left to right across the matrix. For the next phase-encode step, the amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient is decreased, so that the ky offset is diminished at the start of the readout period. A table of such incremental offsets spans the ky axis from maximal negative through zero to maximal positive values. At each value of ky, an otherwise identical set of points is acquired along kx. The trajectory is therefore a horizontal raster in the read direction, incremented in the vertical direction by each phase-encoding iteration, analogous to scanning lines of print. The gradient-echo occurs halfway along kx, and the maximal signal is generated when ky is zero, corresponding to zero amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient. The ky values close to zero are low spatial frequencies, generally regarded as the primary determinants of image contrast.
Defining k(r) has the dimension of inverse distance or spatial frequency When k(r) is multiplied by a position coordinate r, the result is a phase determined by the magnitudes of k(r) and r (analogous to the product of temporal frequency and time) The temporal sequence in which values for k(r) are encoded is termed the k-space trajectory (Fig. 5-10). However, the same value of k(r) can be arrived at in a variety of ways, with the trajectory controlled by gradient waveforms. This may have an indirect effect on the image in several ways (e.g., contrast and motion sensitivity) The FOV is the longest finite spatial wavelength (reciprocal of spatial frequency) that can be encoded with discrete sampling. This corresponds to the minimum nonzero value of k. If N discretely sampled data points are acquired equally spaced at intervals ∆t during a constantamplitude read gradient, FOV in the frequency-encoded direction can be defined as
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
12 of 29
In the spatial frequency domain, small values of k (low spatial frequencies) are linked to large objects in the image space. For a gradient to rotate the phase through 2π across an object, the object must have a linear dimension λ = 2π/k along the direction of the gradient. The maximum value of k defines the smallest dimension encoded; therefore, kmax defines the spatial resolution (∆x). Again, assuming equidistant discrete sampling and equal coverage of negative and positive spatial frequencies, the resolution in the read direction can be defined as Equations 5-18 and 5-19 define the basic relationships between FOV and resolution, as well as the read gradient strength (G), duration (N∆t), and sampling bandwidth (1/∆t). Equation 5-19 shows that the pixel size is twice the size of 1/(N∆k), because it is only the absolute distance from k = 0 which contributes to spatial resolution. In other words, k = (±) N∆k/2 make the same contribution to spatial resolution; the fact that they are each present in positive and negative forms helps to increase signal and lessen artifact.
Sampling the Signal As described in the previous section, if k-space has to be traversed in the read direction, the data are sampled during the readout gradient. Since k is the gradient-time integral, the signal is sampled over a range of k values during the gradient. If the read gradient is turned on and the signal is sampled immediately after excitation, a free induction decay is acquired. To acquire positive and negative spatial frequencies, usually, a dephasing read gradient is applied before the rephasing read gradient, and an echo rather than a free induction decay is acquired. An echo is said to occur when magnetization becomes coherent in the transverse plane. A gradient-echo occurs when the dephasing effect of gradient activity is exactly balanced by the rephasing effect of later gradient activity. For this to occur, two counterbalancing gradient pulses must subtend equal areas of opposite sign. In the simplest gradient-echo measurement, a read gradient preparatory lobe is applied immediately after RF excitation, as shown in Figure 5-8. This causes the spins to evolve a phase proportional to the gradient area or k-space value as described earlier. If a gradient of opposite polarity is now applied, the spins rephase when the area under the second lobe is the same size as that of the first. As the area of the second lobe exceeds that of the first, the process of spin dephasing recurs, illustrated in Figure 5-8. By acquiring data from the start of the rephasing gradient lobe, the build-up and decay of the magnetization can be sampled. During the first half of the rephasing lobe, the free induction decay is rebuilt to (potentially) its original amplitude, and during the second half it becomes dephased again. In the laboratory frame, the raw time signal is in megahertz. This is down modulated to frequencies in the audio range by a sinusoid at the Larmor frequency. The bandwidth in the signal is then determined by the frequency distribution around the Larmor frequency associated with the read gradient. Although a continuous range of frequencies is contained in the analog signal, the signal is sampled discretely and is digitized by an analog-to-digital converter at a rate determined by the signal bandwidth. The Nyquist condition must not be violated, in order to avoid aliasing. To prevent aliasing, the sampling rate must be at least twice the bandwidth. For example, 256 complex points are typically sampled during the readout period (analog-to-digital converter ON time) by a quadrature detector (see Chapter 7). If the readout time is 5.12 ms and 256 complex points are sampled (256 real and 256 imaginary), the sampling interval is 0.00001 s, the sampling rate is 100 kHz, and the resolvable bandwidth is 50 kHz. Low-pass filters are set to exclude signal (and noise) outside the sampled frequency bandwidth. Occasionally, the sampling rate is inadequate to prevent aliasing of parts outside the region of interest. The low-pass filters are not effective, because the signal is wrapped around into the low-frequency range and appears as a phantom limb or other body part. The only way to prevent this phenomenon is to sample rapidly enough so that the unwanted signal is correctly localized outside the imaging bandwidth. If the sampling frequency is doubled, an FOV twice as large can be correctly localized. Overfolding is therefore prevented by oversampling the signal, which effectively increases the FOV but
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
13 of 29
does not change the resolution, SNR, or gradient strength. Resolution is determined only by the kmax value as described earlier. Oversampling increases both the number of pixels and FOV proportionately. It is convenient to normalize the sampling bandwidth to the number of pixels in the read direction, so that a 50-kHz bandwidth corresponds to 50,000/256 = 195 Hz/pixel in a 5.12-ms readout time. If the readout time is 10.24 ms, the bandwidth is 97.5 Hz/pixel and so on. This nomenclature is desirable because the bandwidth in hertz per pixel is not influenced by oversampling or variations in matrix size the fat-water displacement caused by chemical shift can be conveniently expressed in pixels.
Phase-Encoding Phase-encoding is a process whereby a spatially dependent phase shift in a direction orthogonal to the read gradient is introduced by an additional gradient pulse. A series of such phase-modulated echoes generated by a table of sequential pulses forms the basis for spatial encoding in this second dimension. Each phase-modulated echo translates to one spatial frequency in the phase-encoding direction, so the process must be repeated N times to encode N spatial frequencies (see Fig. 5-10). Again, the FOV is defined by the smallest, non-zero value of k in this dimension. This differs from the read direction, where N values of k are encoded during a single pulse of the read gradient (a single readout period). We now consider this in more detail. We have seen that a given value of k for a spin at position r results in a predictable phase shift. However, as pointed out earlier, the definition of k as used in Equation 5-17 makes no assumptions about how k was generated. Moreover, the expression is a generic one, equally applicable to any spatial orientation. Recall that k is proportional to the gradient-time integral, so k may be made a function of time if the gradient is constant and time is incremented, as is the case during readout, or k may be made a function of gradient strength, G, if the time is constant and the gradient amplitude is incremented. Now suppose that k(p) defines a gradient event in the phase-encoding direction y orthogonal to read; then the phase of the echo is modulated as page 147 page 148
Application of one such gradient event simply shifts the phase of the echo from each pixel in the read direction by an amount determined by the mean contribution from all y offsets, and this provides no useful information. However, if k(p) is successively incremented in value by ∆k(p) during a series of measurements, the phase at position y undergoes periodic change as a function of k(p). This is analogous to the periodic phase change at position r in the read direction as a function of k(r). Therefore, when k(p) steps through a table of 256 values from -k(p)max to +k(p)max in 256 equal increments ∆k(p) and k(r) steps through the same set of values under the read gradient, then successive two-dimensional (2D) Fourier transformation along the read and phase-encoding directions yields an image with isotropic spatial resolution. Although the processes of spatial encoding in the read and phase-encoding directions are mathematically similar, physically they are different and prone to different artifacts. In conventional spin-warp imaging, adjacent values of k along the read direction are typically separated in time by about 20 μs, and this is not long enough for significant changes to occur in the state of the magnetization. In the phase-encoding direction, however, the interval between successive k values is typically the TR of the sequence. Depending on the sequence structure, TR ranges from a few milliseconds to several seconds, and during this interval substantial changes may occur to the amplitude and phase of the MR signal. The sampled function may therefore be modulated by a variety
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
14 of 29
of mechanisms, and the function modulating the signal is convolved in the reconstructed image. Depending on the nature of the changes (e.g., motion, flow, nonuniform relaxation effects), the effects may be manifest in the image as a loss of resolution, altered contrast, or, in the case of periodic fluctuations, ghost artifact projected along the phase-encoding direction. In practice, phase-encoding is carried out by applying a gradient pulse for a time tp after excitation and before readout (see Fig. 5-8). 19 If tp is constant and Gp is varied, the process is termed spin-warp imaging. A 2D image is calculated by carrying out a 2D Fourier transform on the time domain data-first line by line, then column by column.
Three-Dimensional Encoding Phase-encoding can also be applied to the slice-selection direction to add a third dimension of spatial encoding. If a thick slab rather than a thin slice is selected, the slab can be resolved into thin slices (partitions) by incrementing a phase-encoding table in this direction, analogous to the 2D case. The number of iterations (excitations) required to encode a 3D image is NyNz, where Ny and Nz refer to the numbers of iterations in the phase-encoding and slice-selection directions, respectively. With conventional acquisition, the minimal time required for this process is TR × Ny × Nz. Because acquisition times with long TR sequences would be prohibitively long, the applications of 3D imaging techniques were formerly limited to fast gradient-echo techniques.
Phase Accumulation In most imaging pulse sequences, phase-encoding of each echo is accomplished with a single discrete gradient pulse. The amplitude of the pulse is varied from echo to echo to encode a unique line of k-space in each readout. The phase generated with each pulse is typically "rewound" with a pulse of equal and opposite area, or the phase-encoded transverse magnetization is dephased or "spoiled" after each readout. In this manner, no phase is accumulated from one echo to the next. However, phase accumulation is an alternative means of phase-encoding. This strategy is used in echo-planar imaging (EPI) in two modes: "blipped" phase-encoding, in which a series of constantamplitude gradient pulses are used for phase-encoding; and constant phase-encoding, in which a constant-amplitude gradient is applied throughout the entire acquisition. In both cases, phase accumulates from one echo to the next as the total area of the phase-encoding gradient increases. In EPI with constant phase-encoding, it becomes difficult to distinguish the readout gradient from the phase-encoding gradient in the traditional sense. Both gradient axes are active during data acquisition.
Speeding Up the Phase-Encoding Process A practical point to note about phase-encoding is that it is time-consuming. Whereas in the read direction all spatial frequencies are encoded in a matter of milliseconds, in the phase-encoding direction the process may take several minutes. It is the iterative nature of phase-encoding and the influence of longitudinal relaxation that necessitate the use of a TR in pulse sequences. Total acquisition time is determined by TR × N × Acq, where N is the number of phase-encode iterations and Acq is the number of acquisitions or averages (Acq is more than 1 if the SNR needs to be boosted or motion artifacts need to be averaged out). Depending on the required contrast in the image, spins may need to relax for a longer or shorter time between phase-encode steps. For pure T2-weighted images, the TR should be several times the longest T1 in the region of interest. This typically includes water, so TR should be several seconds. Conventional T2-weighted images are therefore time intensive. In the case of IR imaging, the requirements for a long TR are even more stringent. T1-weighted spin-echo measurements are designed to suppress partially the signal from long-T1 tissues, so these are done with a relatively short TR-usually 300 to 600 ms.
Acquiring Multiple Lines Per Excitation page 148 page 149
In conventional gradient-echo and spin-echo imaging, one line of k-space is acquired per α or 90° pulse, and the number of iterations required is equal to the number of phase-encoding steps. If
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
15 of 29
transverse magnetization persists after the signal is read, in principle this can be used to encode further echoes. By reapplying the read gradients, interleaved with additional phase-encode (PE) gradients, several Fourier lines can be acquired in much less time than with conventional encoding. Two extreme forms of this process include the single-shot techniques of EPI 20,21 and RARE (rapid acquisition with relaxation enhancement). Intermediate between conventional and single-shot techniques are the hybrid fast imaging methods of turbo or fast spin-echo and segmented EPI. All of these methods are considered in more detail later.
Rectangular Field-of-View Because the high-cost item in terms of acquisition time is the number of iterations of the excitation process (the number of repetitions of TR), time can be saved by decreasing this number. Reducing the FOV in the phase-encoding direction by phase-encoding along the short axis of the subject (rectangular FOV) yields equivalent spatial resolution in a shorter imaging time. For example, if the FOV in the read direction is 350 mm with 256 points in read and the FOV in the PE direction is 175 mm, then 128 PE steps yield an image with square pixels; the imaging time is halved. Because the SNR is proportional to the square root of the number of PE steps, there is a penalty in the SNR with this method, depending on the aspect ratio. Where the SNR is not limiting, the technique is successful. An important difference to note between frequency encoding and phase-encoding is that hardware crystals cannot be used in the phase-encoding direction to filter out unwanted frequencies. If the FOV is smaller than the object size, overfolding will occur. Note: Another way to speed image acquisition and/or prevent overfolding is by using parallel acquisition techniques. Here, the sensitivity profiles of multiple receiver coil elements are used as a complementary method for spatial encoding. With parallel acquisition, the FOV may be decreased several-fold, effectively skipping points in k-space and using the coil sensitivity profiles to fill in the missing data. Parallel imaging is dealt with in detail in Chapter 8 and is not discussed here further, other than to say it can be used to enhance the performance of a wide variety of pulse sequences (without necessarily changing their design).
Phase-Encode Ordering In conventional gradient-echo and spin-echo imaging, the magnetization is sampled in a steady state and no significant variations in the magnetization occur from one phase-encode step to the next. In this case, the order in which the phase-encoding table is stepped through is unimportant. However, in many fast imaging techniques, such as turbo fast low-angle shot (turboFLASH), segmented RARE, and EPI, the magnetization is not in a steady state during acquisition and relaxation causes a modulation of 22-24 signal amplitude in the phase-encoded direction. Recall that the image contrast is determined mainly by the low spatial frequencies (low phase-encode pulse amplitudes) and resolution by high spatial frequencies (high phase-encode pulse amplitudes). Thus, signal modulation can have a profound effect on the image contrast and effective resolution and can be manipulated by reordering the phase-encoding table. There are various different reordering strategies that have important implications for the image in terms of signal weighting, contrast, effective resolution, or flow and motion properties. Some of the most commonly used reordering schemes are described here.
Linear Reordering Linear or sequential reordering is the most commonly used form of encoding. In linear reordering, k-space lines are acquired sequentially, starting at one end of k-space and progressively acquiring adjacent lines by incrementing the phase-encoding gradient in each step (Fig. 5-11A). It is used in many conventional gradient-echo and spin-echo techniques where the magnetization does not vary much from cycle to cycle. Linear reordering is also ideal for sequences where a steady state must be achieved before data acquisition. A large number of RF pulses before the center of k-space minimize possible signal modulations in the center of k-space. However, this strategy may not be suited for magnetization-prepared (MP) acquisitions for the same reason, because the data acquisition RF
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
16 of 29
excitations modify the MP signal weighting before the central k-space lines are acquired.
Centric Reordering As the name suggests, phase-encoding begins at the center of k-space with the k = 0 line and then progressively acquires the higher lines in k-space, alternating between the positive and negative k lines (Fig. 5-11B). Such a strategy is typically used when a MP is used before the sequence readout. Since the signal weighting from the magnetization preparation is of paramount importance, the central k-space lines must be acquired immediately after the MP. As the data acquisition progresses to the outer region of k-space, the signal weighting is altered by the application of data acquisition RF excitations.
Reverse Centric Reordering In reverse centric reordering the phase-encoding lines are collected starting from the outermost lines, alternating between the positive and negative k lines, and moving inward until the k = 0 line is acquired (Fig. 5-11C). Since the high spatial frequencies are enhanced in this reordering scheme, there is a high-pass filtering effect on the image. The reordering strategies mentioned above fall under the category of Fourier encoding, where the k-space points are sampled on a rectangular grid, which is a requirement for direct Fourier transformation. There are other specialized methods of encoding that deviate from the requirement of sampling points on a rectangular grid. In these methods, the data are either reformatted to fit on a rectangular grid after acquisition for direct Fourier transformation, or special image reconstruction algorithms are used.
Radial Reordering page 149 page 150
Add to lightbox
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
17 of 29
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-11 Reordering schemes. A, Linear reordering. In linear reordering, the ky lines are acquired sequentially starting at one end of k-space and incrementing the phase-encoding gradient in each successive RF excitation. B, Centric reordering. In centric reordering, phase-encoding begins in the center of k-space at the ky = 0 line, and progresses outwards by acquiring lines successively in positive and negative k-space. C, Reverse centric reordering. In reverse centric encoding, data acquisition begins at kymax and progresses inwards, acquiring lines successively in positive and negative k-space.
The radial reordering method is commonly known as projection reconstruction, and is derived from X-ray tomographic imaging. The archetypal Cartesian sampling encodes kx by varying the readout gradient Gx during data sampling and encodes ky by stepping through the phase-encoding gradient Gy in each step. In radial sampling, both the Gx and Gy gradients are switched on simultaneously during sampling. Therefore, there are no specific readout and phase-encoding gradients in radial sampling. The data are acquired as k-space points along the radius of a circle. A complete coverage of k-space is achieved by changing the magnitudes of the Gx and Gy gradients such that the angle of the projection θ is changed by an amount ∆kθ in each step. A schematic of radial k-space coverage is shown in Figure 5-12.
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
18 of 29
SPATIAL RESOLUTION IN RADIAL SAMPLING. Spatial resolution in Cartesian sampling methods depends on the number of points sampled in the readout direction and the number of lines in the phase-encoding direction. However, due to the polar nature of radial sampling, encoding is now in terms of the radial direction, kr, and the angular direction, kθ. The number of points in kr is akin to the number of readout points in Cartesian sampling and determines the resolution in the radial direction, as the distance to the circumference of the k-space circle. However, because the entire circumference is sampled by rays in all directions, spatial resolution in the angular direction does not depend on θ, but is more related to the length of the circumference of the k-space circle, which is also defined by kr. What varies, then, as the interval between points kθ varies, is the FOV in the angular direction. Undersampling in kθ then does not lead to a loss of resolution but streaking artifacts, which are the equivalent of aliasing in Cartesian sampling. As can readily be appreciated from examination of Figure 5-12, the angular FOV decreases with increasing distance from the center of k-space; i.e., higher spatial frequencies are associated with smaller angular FOVs. NYQUIST LIMITS IN RADIAL SAMPLING. page 150 page 151
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-12 Radial scanning. Data are acquired along the radius of a circle. The distance between the samples along the radius defines ∆kr. Multiple projections are acquired as different radii, with the angle between the projections defining ∆kθ.
The Nyquist limits on the step sizes in k-space need to be adapted to polar coordinates for radial sampling. The step sizes in the radial direction ∆kr and the angular direction ∆kθ are illustrated in Figure 5-12. For angular sampling, the maximum angular step that must follow the Nyquist criterion is 1 given by : where L = field of view. Therefore the minimum number of angular views necessary to prevent aliasing is Similarly, the radial step must satisfy
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
19 of 29
and the number of total samples in the radial direction must be This is the same Nyquist condition as that for the readout direction in Cartesian sampling. Again, note from Figure 5-12 that the sampling density varies inversely as the radial distance from the center of k-space. In Cartesian sampling, the sampling density is uniform throughout. The varying density in k-space in radial sampling results in aliasing or streak artifacts in the images. Conversely, the dense sampling in the center of k-space results in relatively higher SNR at the large distance scales as compared to Cartesian sampling. "ALIASING" ARTIFACTS IN RADIAL SAMPLING. Aliasing artifacts appear in images due to inadequate sampling in k-space. Undersampling in the angular direction by acquiring fewer projections than dictated by the Nyquist criterion and the varying density of data sampling in k-space leads to aliasing artifacts in radially sampled images. Angular undersampling in radially acquired data results in radial streak artifacts and decreased SNR as opposed to Cartesian Nyquist violations that result in image wrap-around artifacts. For equal FOV in the radial and angular directions, the number of projections acquired must be π/2 (approximately 1.5) times the corresponding number of phase-encode steps in Cartesian sampling. In principle, radial acquisitions allow a tradeoff between SNR and number of projections acquired rather than the tradeoff between resolution and FOV in Cartesian sampling.
Spiral Reordering Spiral scanning has also shown considerable promise for cardiac imaging, 25,26 functional brain 27 28 imaging, and flow imaging. Spiral scanning takes the blending of frequency and phase-encoding in radial sampling one step further; identical gradient waveforms (with a phase shift between the two) are applied to the two in-plane gradient axes, as shown in Figure 5-13. There are some advantages to spiral scanning, such as the requirement of fewer excitations than in conventional Cartesian encoding, and lower sensitivity to motion and flow artifacts. The main problem is the relatively long readout time as compared to Cartesian sampling, which leads to blurring in the presence of off-resonance, chemical shift, or susceptibility. The blurring is caused by the phase accumulated by off-resonant spins during the entire readout. To reduce the readout time in a single shot, interleaved spirals are often used (see Fig. 5-13).
Segmentation and Interleaving In segmented k-space coverage, groups of lines are acquired in separate segments, and the segments are merged together for a full coverage of k-space, e.g., we acquire lines 1, 3, 5, 7 … in segment 1 and lines 2, 4, 6, 8 … in segment 2. The merger of these two segments then gives a complete data set in k-space. The order in which the segments and lines are acquired may vary depending on what reordering scheme is used, as explained above. Segmented acquisitions form the basis of many multiecho techniques, such as turbo- or fast-spin-echo. They can also be used for gradient-echo methods, when physiologic constraints, e.g., respiratory motion, place constraints on the data acquisition time, and all the lines in an image cannot be acquired continuously. It is then necessary to split the data acquisition into multiple segments, and the segments are combined for image reconstruction, e.g., for a total matrix size of 75 lines, 25 lines are acquired in each segment. A total of 75 lines are acquired in 3 segments and combined to form an image. page 151 page 152
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
20 of 29
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-13 Spiral scanning. Readout occurs continuously during simultaneous application of sinusoidal read and phase-encoding gradients. A phase offset of π/2 between the gradients causes the k trajectory to describe a spiral, starting at kx = ky = 0. As illustrated, the data are acquired in an interleaved mode of four shots. Because the spins pass repeatedly through zero along kx and ky, phase accumulation caused by flow is reversed, and the resulting images are intrinsically flow compensated. Also, the low spatial frequencies are acquired early, so the minimal TE is small.
However, if the lines within each segment are acquired sequentially in k-space, a sharp signal discontinuity will exist at the boundaries where the segments are merged. In the above example, there will be two signal discontinuities, at line 26 and line 51. Such abrupt signal variations in k-space lead to ghosting artifacts. These discontinuities are secondary mainly to the signal modulation by application of successive excitations. To overcome this constraint, data are usually acquired in an interleaved fashion. Interleaving minimizes the signal discontinuities by acquiring adjacent lines from similar echoes within different segments. By appropriately stepping through k-space, the discontinuities in k-space can be minimized and the signal envelope can approach a smooth filter; e.g., a schematic of a linearly segmented interleaved data acquisition is shown in Figure 5-14. The total matrix size of 75 lines is acquired in 3 segments with 25 lines acquired in each segment. As the diagram illustrates, the lines adjacent to any line in k-space are acquired from similar echoes in different segments. This minimizes the periodic signal variations in k-space and consequently reduces image artifacts.
Contrast Mechanisms in MRI Basic Contrast Mechanisms
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
21 of 29
Add to lightbox page 152 page 153
Figure 5-14 Segmented and interleaved data acquisition. Schematic of a linear segmented and interleaved data acquisition with a total matrix size of 75 lines and 25 lines per segment. Each set therefore consists of 3 lines in k-space. In the schematic, each line style signifies lines acquired in one segment, e.g., the solid line represents the first segment, the dotted line the second segment, and the dashed line the third segment. The acquisition is interleaved such that the first echoes acquired in each segment are adjacent to each other, i.e., set 1 consists of echo 1 acquired in 1st, 2nd, and 3rd segments, set 2 contains the second echo from each segment, etc. In this way, the signal discontinuities in k-space are reduced, which in turn reduces the image artifacts.
MRI has the advantage of generating different soft-tissue contrasts. Ignoring flow, chemical shift, and many other subtle mechanisms, there are three fundamental parameters that determine signal and contrast: proton density, T1, and T2 or T2*. In each case, the name suggests the difference in tissue properties that is exploited. To gain an intuitive understanding of how each method of contrast can be achieved, we will consider a simple gradient-echo sequence example. The contrast between two tissues in a gradient-echo sequence is given by:
For a proton-density-weighted image, the above equation must be reduced to: Such a contrast will be achieved if TR>>T1 (e-TR/T1 ~0) and TE<
For T1-weighting, TE<>T1 (e
-TR/T1
~0), and TE~T2a or b.
It must be noted that T1 and T2 weighting cannot be isolated from the spin density ρ. There is always an inherent spin density weighting in the signal. The T1 or T2 weighting can only be increased or decreased to alter the signal. Since the difference in spin densities between various tissues is not very large in practice, this is not a serious limitation.
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
22 of 29
Magnetization Preparations Magnetization preparations (MP) can be used to achieve a desired signal weighting using a combination of RF pulses and gradients to modify the longitudinal magnetization before data readout. Magnetization preparations allow flexibility in using different sequences for data acquisition because the contrast is largely determined by the MP. There are numerous MPs in the literature, but here we focus only on some of the most widely used.
Conventional Inversion Recovery Preinversion may be used to generate T1-based contrast, as in IR imaging. As originally implemented in spectroscopy, IR preparation was used to eliminate spectra from unwanted chemical species, based on their T1. Immediately after inversion, all magnetization lies along the -z axis and spins begin to relax exponentially toward +z (Fig. 5-15). At the halfway stage, the z magnetization is zero, and no longitudinal magnetization is available to tip into the transverse plane. The time between inversion and excitation pulse or TI appropriate to null a species is related to its T1 as TI = 0.693T1, for TR much greater than T1. A long TI is required to null long-T1 components, whereas short-T1 components are nulled in a short TI. Spins with long T1 (e.g., in fluids such as cerebrospinal fluid) may still be aligned along -z and have negative phase at the time of readout. With phase-sensitive reconstruction (as opposed to magnitude 29 reconstruction), the phase as well as the amplitude of the signal is represented in the image. To spins with negative phase, a pixel intensity less than background is ascribed. Spins with positive phase have relaxed past zero (have short T1), and to these a pixel intensity greater than background is ascribed. So the order of pixel intensity for a long-TI, IR brain image (assuming phase-sensitive reconstruction) is white matter greater than gray matter greater than background greater than cerebrospinal fluid. Because long-TI IR imaging has poor slice efficiency and requires long acquisition times, it has come into clinical use only with the advent of segmented RARE techniques. However, short-TI (tau) IR 30-32 (STIR) imaging has found many applications. In vivo, because spins with large T1 values also tend to have large T2 values, contrast between long-T1, long-T2 and short-T1, short-T2 tissues is increased by superimposing T2 effects on a short-TI preparation. In practice, this is done by using a moderately long TE so that long-T2 components retain signal and short-T2 components do not. STIR imaging is generally done with magnitude reconstruction, because the tissues with shortest T1 are near the null point and all other tissues have negative phase; the range in signal is therefore -Mz to zero. Long-T1 and long-T2 tissues appear hyperintense compared with tissues with short T1 and short T2. STIR is typically implemented with a TI value appropriate to null fat, so a narrow-bandwidth readout can be used to boost the SNR without producing a chemical-shift artifact. The longer TE that accompanies long readout times has a beneficial rather than a deleterious effect on contrast with STIR, because the T1 and T2 effects are additive.
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
23 of 29
Add to lightbox page 153 page 154
Figure 5-15 T1 recovery curves. After inversion, spins recover longitudinal magnetization at a rate dependent on their T1. Short-T1 components (such as fat) reach the null point quickly, whereas long-T1 components (such as water) recover slowly. The TI appropriate to null a given component then varies with its T1 and with the TR of the sequence. Assuming TR is much greater than T1, spins with T1 = 300 ms are nulled when TI = 200 ms and spins with T1 = 1000 ms are nulled when TI = 700 ms, as illustrated.
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-16 Double-inversion black blood RF preparation. After non-spatially selective inversion, a spatially selective "reversion" pulse is immediately applied to spins within the slice plane. In-plane spins (in this case in myocardium) effectively see no inversion pulse. Spins outside the slice plane (of relevance to flowing blood) remain inverted and begin to relax. If the acquisition is timed so that the low spatial frequencies are acquired during the null point of blood relaxation, no signal is seen from blood that enters the slice between inversion and readout. ECG, electrocardiography. (From Simonetti OP, Finn JP, White RD, Laub G, Henry DA: "Black blood" T2-weighted inversion-recovery MR imaging of the heart. Radiology 199:49-57, 1996.)
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
24 of 29
STIR has been shown to be an effective and sensitive technique for detection of a variety of disorders in the liver32,33 and musculoskeletal system.34 As a fat suppression technique, STIR is generally more robust than chemical-shift methods because it does not have stringent requirements for B0 homogeneity and is not vulnerable to susceptibility gradients. It can, however, fail with poor B1 homogeneity, and one must be careful in the design of inversion pulses. In general, one should use pulses that are B1 insensitive, particularly with local transmit-receive coils. Specialized adiabatic RF pulses are generally used for inversion because they are insensitive to B1 errors.
Saturation Recovery A saturation recovery preparation consists of a π/2 RF pulse that converts all the longitudinal magnetization into transverse magnetization, after which a gradient spoiler dephases it. The magnetization of the tissues then recovers depending on their respective T1 values. Therefore, if data are sampled after an appropriate time delay, T1-weighted images can be obtained. Although this preparation is not widely used, one of its major applications is in cardiac perfusion imaging.35
Spatial Presaturation Unwanted signal from within or outside the slice plane may be suppressed by means of spatial 36 presaturation pulses. This is typically implemented by selectively exciting the region of interest with a π/2 pulse and then spoiling coherent magnetization with a crusher gradient. The effect persists until longitudinal magnetization is restored and so is T1 limited. The most common application for spatial presaturation is to eliminate artifact from flowing blood or to perform selective MR angiography (see Chapter 27). It can also be used to decrease signals from organs or soft-tissues that are the source of motion artifact, such as the larynx or anterior abdominal fat.
Black Blood Preparation As discussed earlier, blood can be nulled effectively with a nonselective inversion pulse, based on its T1 and independent of flow. A limitation of this process is that all spins in the slice plane are also inverted and have their contrast behavior so determined. Magnetization within the slice plane can be 37 "reset" after inversion by a selective 180° pulse, as described by Edelman and colleagues and shown in Figure 5-16. The effect of the combined pulses on spins within the slice is as if they had seen no RF, while all spins outside the slice (most relevantly in blood) are inverted. As originally described, a fast gradient-echo readout of the slice is timed to coincide with the null point of blood, so that blood that has entered (and exited) the slice during TI gives no signal but the image is otherwise proton density weighted. Excellent contrast between stationary tissue and the blood pool has been shown with this technique, and it has been used to distinguish between blood and thrombus in abdominal aneurysms. In studies of the heart, blood nulling has been used as a preparatory event in vessel wall imaging,38 breath-hold T1- and T2-weighted TSE imaging, and breath-hold STIR imaging by Simonetti and co-workers39 with promising results.
Magnetization Transfer Contrast page 154 page 155
40
Wolff and Balaban were the first to establish the use of magnetization transfer contrast in MRI. This method derives its contrast mechanism by exploiting the difference between the two separate groups of protons present in tissues-the mobile or free protons, and the immobile or restricted protons. The immobile protons are those that are bound to large protein, lipid, carbohydrate, or nucleic acid molecules (macromolecules, e.g., myocardium). Spins that are bound to macromolecules have a short T2 and a broad spectral peak that is distributed symmetrically about the comparatively sharp peak of the free protons at resonant frequency. Unbound spins, on the other hand, have a narrow-frequency bandwidth and must be excited at or near the Larmor frequency. By applying a long RF pulse, typically centered 1.5 kHz off-resonance at 1.5 T, the pool of bound spins can be saturated before exciting the unbound pool by a pulse at the Larmor frequency. When imaging is performed following such
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
25 of 29
excitations, the resulting image will show suppression of the signal from the bound group of protons. The effect of magnetization transfer preparation is to suppress partially the signal from certain "solid" tissues such as muscle and brain, depending on the relative populations of bound and unbound spins. However, the free protons are coupled to the macromolecular protons by means of chemical exchange or dipolar interactions. The result is that there is an exchange of protons between the free and bound proton pools. Saturation of one pool therefore has the effect of reducing the signal of the other group of protons. Applications of magnetization transfer preparation include background suppression in MR angiography,41,42 T2-type contrast in the heart at shorter TE values,43-45 and gadolinium-enhanced 46 T1-weighted imaging of the brain.
Fat Suppression Hydrogen nuclei in different molecules are surrounded by varying electron clouds. These orbital electrons are constantly in motion within the cloud and, when subjected to an external magnetic field, according to Lenz's law adjust their trajectories so as to induce an opposing field. The induced fields shield the nuclei from the applied field B0 to different degrees, expressed by the shielding constant σ, such that the net field seen by the nuclei is B0 (1 - σ). This phenomenon forms the basis for NMR spectroscopy.3 Protons in lipid molecules are associated with denser electron cloud cover than those in water molecules, and so, when placed in a magnetic field, lipid protons precess at a lower frequency. The difference in precessional frequencies between nuclei in various chemical environments is expressed by the chemical shift. The units used to quantify chemical shift are either hertz or parts per million, depending on whether normalization for field strength has been performed. For example, at 1.5 T, hydrogen nuclei in fat molecules precess at approximately 210 Hz below hydrogen nuclei in water. The Larmor frequency for water protons at 1.5 T is 63.75 MHz, and the chemical shift for fat protons is (-210 Hz/63.75 × 106 Hz) × 106 = -3.3 ppm. Conversion from parts per million to shift in hertz is performed simply by multiplying by the frequency of RF irradiation in megahertz. For many clinical applications, it is desirable to eliminate the signal from protons in one or other chemical environment. This most commonly involves suppression of the fat signal either by exciting and 47-49 50,51 then crushing the fat or by exciting the water selectively. Chemical-shift-selective (CHESS) fat saturation is accomplished by applying a frequency-selective, spatially nonselective excitation pulse to the fat protons and then spoiling the transverse magnetization with a strong gradient pulse. The water spins are unaffected and can then be excited and imaged without interference from the fat. The technical challenge in chemical-shift-selective saturation is selecting only the fat or the water without selecting the other species. This is not a problem when there is no overlap between fat and water resonances. For example, at 1.5 T an RF pulse could be centered on the fat frequency with a bandwidth of, say, ±100 Hz. Such a pulse would leave water spins relatively untouched. However, in practice there are nonuniformities ∆B0 in the main field, caused mainly by patient-induced susceptibility gradients that may exceed the fat-water chemical-shift separation. Water protons precessing at (γ/2π)(B0 + ∆B0) may well lie within the bandwidth of the fat saturation pulse. The result is that in some portions of the image fat is suppressed, whereas in other portions water is suppressed. To minimize this effect, B0 homogeneity must be optimized by shimming before all spectral selective measurements. Fat suppression is most often carried out by using either a gaussian pulse centered on the fat frequency or a binomial excitation scheme with short, wide-bandwidth ("hard") pulses. Because the frequency separation of fat and water is small, the RF saturation bandwidth must be narrow (typically less than 200 Hz) to avoid crosstalk. Binomial excitation is performed by applying a series of hard RF pulses.49 The series describes a binomial distribution when the amplitude of the pulses is plotted over time, and the time between pulses corresponds to a chosen phase evolution between the fat and water spins. For example, if the interpulse interval is 2.38 ms, the fat-water phase evolution between pulses is 180° at 1.5 T. The pulses may be designed to excite water or fat selectively by appropriate choice of the RF phase. 51 If the phase is kept constant, the sense of nutation for fat resonances is reversed with alternate pulses,
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
26 of 29
and because the binomial distribution is symmetric, the net flip angle is zero. For the water resonances, the pulses are additive, such that the net flip angle is the sum of the individual pulses. For example, with a 1:2:1 excitation scheme, if each unit contains enough energy for a flip of α, the maximal achievable flip angle is 4α for spins on resonance (Fig. 5-17). To excite and then spoil the fat resonances, the RF phase would be alternated (e.g., from x to -x) so that the phase of the RF always coincides with the phase of the fat spins and the net flip angle for water is zero. Better spectral selectivity is achieved with higher-order binomial schemes such as 1:3:3:1 or higher. However, the time penalty can be costly, and in some cases the minimal TR of a gradient-echo sequence may be more than doubled. This may have undesirable effects not only on acquisition time but also on image contrast in sequences that depend on steady-state effects. The simplest binomial series is a 1:1 "jump return," where one species sees θ/2 + θ/2 = θ and the other sees θ/2 - θ/2 = 0. This approach has been extended by Thomasson and co-workers,52 who offset the phase of the second RF pulse by π/2 or less, shortening the interpulse delay by a factor of 2 or more. They achieved a substantial time saving in short-TR three-dimensional (3D) gradient-echo sequences and extended the concept to spatial-spectral excitation. page 155 page 156
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-17 A 1:2:1 binomial water-selective pulse sequence. Fat spins (f) and water spins (w) evolve a π phase shift in a time τ. When a series of pulses are applied at intervals of τ, the effects on fat and water spins are opposite, so the flip angle for water sums to 90° whereas that for fat is zero.
From a practical perspective, the major disadvantage to using CHESS fat suppression is the additional time required to play out the narrow bandwidth RF pulses. When these pre-pulses are added to short-TR sequences, the penalty in slices (or partitions with 3D) can be prohibitive. Considerable cost savings are possible when the presaturation pulses are played out less frequently, while maintaining sufficient fat suppression.53 Here, the CHESS pulses are shared among several slices or partitions, by 54 nesting the presaturation loop within the slices (or partitions) loop. When used in multislice 2D FLASH
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
27 of 29
or 3D FLASH imaging,55 the cost in time or slices can be negligible.
Spin-Echoes and Gradient-Echoes Based on the method of generation of echoes, sequences are broadly classified into two types: spin-echo sequences and gradient-echo sequences. Before we describe the various different sequences, the basics of spin-echo and gradient-echo are revisited. It should be noted that, without several highly simplifying assumptions, the details of multiecho pulse experiments are extremely involved, and in what follows we consider only the simplest examples. For a detailed description, the interested reader is referred to several outstanding works by Hennig and Scheffler.56-58
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-18 Spin-echo. In A, a 90° pulse has been applied along x' and the magnetization lies along y'. B, At time t = TE/2 later, the spins have dephased in the x-y plane through T2* decay. In C, a 180° refocusing pulse applied along x' reflects the spin vectors through the x' axis. The spins continue to precess as before the refocusing pulse, and in D, at time t = TE, a spin-echo occurs. With multiple refocusing pulses, imperfections in the RF are propagated. When the refocusing pulse is applied along y' as in C', the spin-echo occurs along y' without phase inversion as in D'. Flip angle errors are corrected on alternate echoes and are not propagated. This is the Meiboom-Gill modification of the Carr-Purcell multiecho pulse. It is standard in long spin-echo train sequences.
Spin-Echoes When the magnetization is rotated into the x-y plane, initially all of it is available for detection and the MR signal is maximal. However, through relaxation processes, the signal begins to decay exponentially. The falling signal profile over time is known as free induction decay, and the speed with which the signal falls off is determined by how efficient transverse relaxation processes are. Spins dephase through a combination of T2 decay, main field nonuniformity, and local field distortions caused by susceptibility gradients. The inhomogeneity in the main field ∆B0 causes spins to dephase at a rate γ∆B0 in addition to the intrinsic spin-spin interaction 1/T2. The net rate of decay is therefore the sum (1/T2 + γ∆B0). In the presence of main field nonuniformity, the effective decay time is expressed by T2* = 1/(1/T2 + γ∆B0). The rate of decay of the transverse magnetization is therefore greater in the presence of significant ∆B0. page 156
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
28 of 29
page 157
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-19 Stimulated-echo acquisition mode (STEAM). A stimulated echo is formed by a train of three 90° pulses. In A, B1 is applied along x' and the magnetization is laid down along y'. B, After a suitable time TE/2, the spins have dephased in the x-y plane as a result of T2* processes or applied gradients. A 90° pulse is now applied along y', rotating the plane of magnetization to the y'-z' plane (C). Spins aligned along z' undergo no further phase changes, whereas those along y' dephase completely (D). We refer to this interval as the STEAM time. Another 90° pulse is now applied along y', rotating the z magnetization along x' (E). After TE/2, these spins all have components along positive y' (F), forming a stimulated echo. Note that only half the magnetization is recoverable in this way.
Hahn59 described a technique of RF refocusing to neutralize the effects of B0 inhomogeneity and local susceptibility effects, which is termed spin-echo. After the 90° excitation, a 180° pulse is applied, and an echo is formed at a time determined by twice the interval between the two pulses. As outlined in Figure 5-18, the 180° pulse has the effect of refocusing spins that fanned out before its application. The spin-echo refocuses dephasing caused by fixed differences such as ∆B0, chemical-shift effects, and local susceptibility gradients. It does not refocus dephasing caused by random processes such as spin-spin interaction1 ("true T2") and diffusion.60 The refocusing pulse can be reapplied multiple times 18 to generate a train of spin-echoes as described by Carr and Purcell. The T2 decay envelope can then be measured and values of T2 computed. In the modification of the Carr-Purcell spin-echo experiment described by Meiboom and Gill, 61 the phase of the refocusing 180° pulses is offset by 90° relative to the excitatory 90° pulse (see Fig. 5-17C' and D'). Thus, if a π/2 pulse is applied along x, the refocusing π pulses are applied along y. The effect of the π pulse is to form the complex conjugate M* of M by rotation about y. This serves to prevent propagation of imperfections in the π pulses as follows. Consider a situation in which instead of π refocusing pulses, 150° pulses are applied along x, the same axis as the excitatory 90° pulse. At
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005005
29 of 29
the first spin-echo, the magnetization M lies 30° below the x-y plane, at the second spin-echo M lies 60° above the x-y plane, and so on for subsequent spin-echoes. If the refocusing RF pulses are applied along y, then the undershoot on the first echo is corrected on the second, the undershoot on the third is corrected on the fourth, and so on. Every second spin-echo now has the correct amplitude, and the initial error is not propagated. Formerly, generation of multiple spin-echoes had as its main application the measurement of T2 values. With the development of rapid acquisition with relaxation 57,62 63-65 enhancement (RARE) and related rapid spin-echo imaging techniques, the use of multiecho sequences has increased significantly. This buffering effect of offsetting the phase of the π pulses may be useful clinically when the application of multiple refocusing pulses results in RF energy deposition outside recommended limits. The flip angle of the π pulses can be scaled back as described earlier with little perceptible change in image quality but substantial reduction in specific absorption rate. This is particularly relevant in the design of hybrid fast RF refocused sequences such as turbo (fast) spin-echo.
Stimulated Echoes page 157 page 158
Stimulated echoes occur when a train of three or more RF pulses is applied sequentially.56 Each stimulated echo is formed by three (nominal) 90° pulses. The first pulse nutates the magnetization into the x-y plane so that it initially lies, for example, along y' (Fig. 5-19). Subsequently, over an interval TE/2, where TE is the echo time, the spins fan out in the x-y plane as a result of T2* decay. The second pulse now rotates the plane of magnetization so that it has one axis parallel to z. The components lying along z no longer precess, and those lying along y' undergo irreversible T2 decay. The third pulse recalls the magnetization stored along ±z to ±x'. After another interval TE/2, the magnetization has a component along +y'; this is the stimulated echo. As illustrated in Figure 5-19, the delay between the first two pulses is the same as the delay between the last pulse and the stimulated echo. The following are noteworthy about stimulated echoes: The amplitude of the echo is smaller than that of a spin-echo of comparable TE. This is because only half the available magnetization is used in the stimulated echo For the same reason, not all spins are exactly in phase along y' at the echo (only spins 3 and 7 in Fig. 5-19 are), as would occur with a spin-echo. Rather, there is a distribution of spin vectors oriented in the positive y' direction; the largest are refocused along y' and others also have a component along ±x' The interval between the second and third pulses can be substantially larger than TE. This long interval can be exploited to heighten sensitivity to diffusion and flow effects T1 relaxation occurs between the second and third pulses. If this is significant, the amplitude of the stimulated echo is decreased still further Stimulated echoes occur in a variety of circumstances in which one might not expect them. For example, in multiecho spin-echo imaging, three sequential RF pulses produce a stimulated echo that may be superimposed on a spin-echo. It is important in fast or turbo spin-echo (TSE) imaging to be aware of the effects stimulated echoes can have on image contrast 66-68 and to engineer them appropriately. In certain forms of fast gradient-echo imaging, stimulated echoes modulate the amplitude of subsequent gradient and RF echoes and can alter image contrast and signal-to-noise ratio Stimulated-echo imaging69 has found applications in several areas, including ultrafast imaging, 70 diffusion imaging,71,72 motion tracking,73 brain imaging,74 and cardiac imaging.75
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
11-04-2010 23:59
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
1 of 20
SOME SPECIFIC PULSE SEQUENCE TYPES The building blocks of all sequences in common use have now been described, and several features specific to certain classes of pulse sequences have also been outlined. We now review the major categories of pulse sequences in use or in development for clinical imaging, highlight similarities and differences among them, and allude to their major applications. For detailed treatment of clinical applications of these and other techniques, the reader is referred to the relevant chapters in this edition.
Spin-Echo versus Gradient-Echo A spin-echo occurs by the refocusing effect of a 180° RF pulse as outlined in Figure 5-18. The timing of the spin-echo is determined by the time interval between the 90° and 180° pulses, independent of gradient events. A gradient-echo occurs when the area subtended by a gradient pulse is exactly neutralized by an equal and opposite area. The parameter that determines when the gradient-echo occurs is the rate at which these areas are traced out, and this is proportional to the gradient amplitude. In general, sequences are designed so that the gradient-echo is made to coincide with a spin-echo (if one exists), but this is not always the case. The steps outlined earlier for spatial encoding can be applied to data acquired under either a spin-echo or gradient-echo envelope. With spin-echo refocusing, dephasing effects caused by magnetic field nonuniformities and chemical shift are reversed. Irreversible dephasing persists because of T2 decay and diffusion, providing mechanisms for tissue contrast. Gradient reversal does not undo dephasing effects resulting from chemical shift or magnetic field inhomogeneity, whether caused by nonuniformity of the B0 field or magnetic susceptibility gradients. The choice of TE in a gradient-echo sequence may profoundly influence image contrast, depending on whether fat and water are in phase or opposed in phase.
Gradient-Echo Pulse Sequences FLASH or Spoiled GRASS Gradient-echo techniques have proved useful for fast MRI in a variety of circumstances. Yet another contrast parameter is available with gradient-echoes: the flip angle. The simplest of all gradient-echo imaging techniques is the FLASH76 or spoiled GRASS (gradient-recalled acquisition in the steady state) sequence (see Fig. 5-20), widely used for fast T1-weighted imaging. 77
In short-TR gradient-echo imaging, phase coherences may build up in the transverse magnetization. Depending on the desired contrast in the image, these coherences may be detrimental or beneficial. To generate T1 contrast in a short-TR gradient-echo sequence, it is desirable to eliminate all transverse coherence between phase-encoding steps, because such coherences accentuate signal from long-T2* (and therefore long-T1) components. These coherences can be suppressed by applying a crusher gradient78 after sampling the echo and before the next excitation; this process is termed gradient spoiling. The aim is to cause dephasing of all coherent x-y magnetization. Another technique, called RF spoiling,78,79 uses a table of pseudorandom values for the phase of the B1 field on successive iterations, thus preventing the build-up of transverse coherences. The phase of the echo is varied between phase-encoding steps; this phase is also locked into the receiver reference signal so that image calculation is not affected. Unlike gradient spoiling, RF spoiling is effective even in the center of the magnetic field. Attention must be paid to the details of the B1 phase series over time, to avoid unexpected coherences. page 158 page 159
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-20 2D FLASH sequence structure. After slice selection, the rephasing slice-selection, dephasing read, and phase-encoding gradients are applied simultaneously. This is followed by the rephasing read gradient and signal sample window (ADC on time). To destroy coherent magnetization between excitations, a gradient spoiling table is applied after data acquisition. RF spoiling is typically also employed with this structure.
The spin-warp sequence structure for gradient-spoiled 2D FLASH as outlined in Figure 5-20 provides a good template for illustration of conventional spatial encoding and signal sampling. After slice selection, gradients in slice, phase-encode, and read are applied simultaneously to maximize time efficiency. The rephasing lobe in slice selection is to undo the dephasing effects of the first lobe. Simultaneous application of the dephasing read gradient and maximal-amplitude phase-encoding gradient sets the magnetization to one corner of k-space in a diagonal trajectory, as shown in Figure 5-10. The rephasing read gradient then unwinds the phase of the dephasing lobe and causes maximal rephasing in read at the time of the echo. The k-space trajectory of this last step is linear in the read direction, at an offset in the phase-encoding direction determined by the strength of the phase-encoding gradient pulse (see Fig. 5-10). Because the phase-encoding gradient steps through a table of values from -G(p)max to G(p)max, the k-space trajectory is a linear raster of values. Discrete signal sampling occurs via the analog-to-digital converter during the build-up and decay of the gradient-echo. In Figure 5-20, a gradient spoiling table is shown. When present, this increases the minimal TR of the sequence and slightly decreases slice efficiency. The same basic FLASH structure (typically with a wide bandwidth) is used as the readout module after the preparatory period in turboFLASH.
TurboFLASH TurboFLASH is a gradient-echo sequence that uses an RF preparation followed by multiple, short TE and TR FLASH acquisitions, as depicted in Figure 5-21. The Ernst angle is small because of the short TR, and, without preparation of the magnetization, the images would be basically proton density weighted and appear "flat." To introduce T1 contrast, a single inversion pulse is applied before acquiring all of the image data (k-space lines). This differs substantially from the classic method of IR imaging in which an inversion pulse precedes every line of data (every phase-encoding step). Nonetheless, turboFLASH images have IR-type contrast that is typically greater than can be achieved with non-IR spin-echo or gradient-echo methods. T1 relaxation is changing throughout the acquisition period, and the data are modulated in the phase-encoded direction by the T1 recovery curve. Despite this, image quality with turboFLASH is typically limited more by SNR than by image blurring. The type of T1 contrast generated with turboFLASH depends on how much relaxation has progressed by the time the central lines of k-space are collected. This in turn is influenced by the order in which the phase-encoding steps are acquired. To clarify this point, consider that a nominal delay time TI follows the inversion pulse and that the FLASH readout is acquired with centric phase-encoding. The center of
2 of 20
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
3 of 20
k-space that dominates image contrast is therefore acquired at the nominal TI, and the contrast is comparable to that of an IR image at that TI. If, however, the FLASH readout is acquired with linear phase-encoding, then the central lines of k-space are acquired not at the nominal TI but at an effective TI of TI + (TR × N/2), where N is the number of phase-encoding steps. Thus, if TI = 500 ms, TR = 12 ms, and N = 128, then TIeff = 500 + (12 × 64) = 1268 ms! Therefore, with linear phase-encoding, TIeff scales with the number of phase-encoding steps. If TI = 0, then TIeff = 768 ms, a typical value for T1-weighted abdominal imaging at 1.0 or 1.5 T. It should be noted, however, that with linear ordering TIeff is related to the number of phase-encoding steps and that with reasonable spatial resolution the minimal TIeff is large. TurboFLASH has been extended to a 3D acquisition by Mugler and Brookeman80 for rapid T1-weighted imaging of the brain. The inversion pre-pulse for turboFLASH may be spatially selective or nonselective. A spatially nonselective RF pulse is typically applied over a wide bandwidth in the absence of a field gradient. To excite spins evenly over a wide range of frequencies, the envelope of the RF pulse approaches a spike function in the time domain; its Fourier transform approaches a constant value in the frequency domain. Such a pulse is often referred to as a "hard" pulse, and in practice it is applied as a short rectangular pulse that excites a broad-frequency envelope. Because hard pulses are short, they require relatively high peak transmitter voltage. page 159 page 160
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
4 of 20
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-21 TurboFLASH pulse sequence diagram. After a single magnetization preparation phase (A), a fast FLASH sequence is played out. The time between the preparation event and the zero phase-encoding step (here illustrated halfway through the FLASH sequence) determines the image contrast. For example, in the case of inversion (B), the effective inversion time is the interval from the inversion pulse to the central phase-encode step (arrow). With centric phase-encode reordering, this step occurs at the beginning of the FLASH sequence, and the effective TI is the nominal TI.
In turboFLASH, a hard inversion pulse is combined with spatially selective α pulses for slice selectivity. For single-slice imaging, the main difference between using selective and nonselective inversion pulses is the effect on spins outside the slice. There are two major consequences of using a nonselective inversion pulse: Because the entire FOV of the transmitter is inverted, the blood signal may be uniformly nulled without interference from flow-related effects and independent of the blood flow velocity. Flow artifacts may therefore be completely eliminated by choice of the appropriate TIeff, for example, in coronal imaging of the abdomen Because the entire FOV of the transmitter is inverted, sufficient time must be allowed for relaxation before the next slice is acquired. This decreases time efficiency in multislice applications. If selective inversion pulses are used, sequential slice acquisition may proceed without waiting for adjacent slice positions to relax. The blood signal is less predictable with selective pulses and is often bright because of inflow effects. Selective inversion pulses are best implemented with the hyperbolic secant (sech) or other optimized pulses.
Segmented TurboFLASH By shortening the acquisition window of the FLASH readout, both the T1 filtering effect and the minimal TI limitation can be addressed. This has been accomplished by segmenting81 the acquisition into several sequential windows, each containing a fraction of the data, as shown in Figure 5-22. For example, 128 phase-encoding steps can be acquired as four segments, each containing 32 lines. An inversion pulse precedes each segment and a delay time separates the segments from each other to allow relaxation to occur. The intersegment delay should be several seconds, and one dummy segment should precede the first segment acquisition to establish a steady state for the remaining ones. The concept of segmentation of k-space in the phase-encoding direction has been applied to several other 82 techniques for fast imaging, including breath-hold cine MRI of the heart, breath-hold-triggered MR 83 84 angiography, TSE, and segmented EPI.
TurboSTEAM page 160 page 161
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
5 of 20
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-22 Segmented turboFLASH. The basic structure is similar to that of turboFLASH, but the acquisition is broken into a number of segments, each preceded by magnetization preparation. The k-space is traversed in a number of interleaved shots, and the acquisition window of the FLASH sequence is correspondingly narrowed compared with the single-shot case. Less relaxation time filtering of the data occurs, and image contrast can be more finely controlled.
Stimulated-echo acquisition mode (STEAM) imaging can be carried out, like turboFLASH, as a single-shot technique. In the method described by Frahm and colleagues, 85 two 90° pulses are applied TE/2 apart. A series of fast, low-flip-angle readouts is used to capture the magnetization stored along z, each separately phase-encoded as a stimulated echo (Fig. 5-23). The method can be used for fast diffusion imaging or black blood imaging of the heart.
Fast Imaging with Steady-State Precession
Add to lightbox page 161 page 162
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
6 of 20
Figure 5-23 TurboSTEAM sequence. Slice-selective π/2 pulses are separated in time by TE/2. Sliceselection and read gradient lobes ensure full dephasing of transverse magnetization, which is aligned along the z-axis by the second π/2 pulse. A series of fast, low-flip-angle gradient-echo readouts follows, each separately phase-encoded. Within STEAM time (TM), the slice-selection lobe balances the initial dephasing lobe and the read gradient balances the earlier dephasing read gradient lobe. The gradient-echo occurs at TE/2 after the α pulse, coinciding with the stimulated echo (see Fig. 5-18). Because α is small, only a portion of the stored z magnetization is read with each phaseencode step, so the process can be repeated many times.
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-24 2D FISP sequence structure. Compared with the structure in FLASH, the phase of the RF is alternated from one line to the next, and the gradient spoiling table in the FLASH sequence is replaced by a phase-encoding rewinding table. Coherent magnetization that persists after signal sampling (for example, for fluid) is realigned along z and is made available for re-excitation with the subsequent α pulse. Long-T2* components are therefore accentuated.
Fast imaging with steady-state precession (FISP)86 is a fast gradient-echo technique used to enhance the signal from long-T2* components (such as fluid). When TR is short compared with the rate of decay of transverse magnetization, it is possible to recycle a large part of the magnetization by alternating the phase of the RF pulse on successive excitations; that is, the direction of the B1 field is alternated. The effect is to realign along z the component of magnetization that lies along y at a time TR after the previous excitation, while at the same time tilting longitudinal magnetization from z to -y. It follows that the phase of Mxy is alternated from positive to negative with successive phase-encoding steps; this is accounted for by matching the transmitter and receiver phase. Also, for this scheme to be effective in restoring Mxy along z, Mxy must be made to lie coherently along y, because B1x has no effect on spins aligned along ±x. In general, at the end of a readout period, the spins are dephased in x-y because of a combination of gradient moments from the readout and phase-encoding directions. To rephase Mxy along y, these gradient moments must be reversed before the next excitation (Fig. 5-24). Balancing the gradients rephases spins that have not moved over the duration of the interval. However, flowing spins have acquired a velocity-dependent phase shift that is not unwound with zero-order gradient balancing. As illustrated in Figure 5-24, the gradients in FISP are not fully balanced in the slice-selection and read directions.
Time-reversed FISP (PSIF) Unlike FLASH and FISP, which both acquire the primary gradient-echo, the time-reversed FISP (PSIF) or contrast-enhanced, Fourier-acquired, steady-state (CE-FAST)87,88 acquisition utilizes the RF echo formed by the repeated α pulses. The signal intensity of the RF-refocused echo is weighted by T2 over the interval from one α pulse to the readout after the next α pulse, as depicted in Figure 5-25. Stimulated echoes as well as spin-echoes contribute to the PSIF signal, making the contrast highly dependent on flip angle. PSIF is useful in rapid acquisition of fluid-sensitive images.
Double Echo in the Steady State (DESS)
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
7 of 20
The double echo in the steady state (DESS)89 or fast acquisition double echo (FADE)90 sequence (Fig. 5-26) utilizes both the free induction decay gradient-echo used in the FISP sequence, and the RF echo of PSIF. The gradient-echo is offset from the RF echo, and they may be used to generate separate images that can be combined or displayed separately. The RF echo tends to accentuate long-T2 components such as fluid. This may be superimposed on a more T1-weighted anatomic image related to the FISP echo.
Spin-Echo Pulse Sequences
Add to lightbox page 162 page 163
Figure 5-25 PSIF pulse sequence diagram. In this technique, the RF echo is of prime importance in generating image contrast. It is mainly the RF portion of the steady-state signal that is acquired. The gradient structure is balanced within the TR scope, and the RF echo occurs during readout in the following cycle.
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-26 DESS pulse sequence diagram. The gradients are balanced along all three axes and the gradient and RF echoes are offset from each other. They may be used to generate separate images, which can be combined or displayed separately.
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
8 of 20
Conventional spin-echo pulse sequences have formed the basis for clinical MRI since the modality was introduced. Various derivative techniques have been proposed that dramatically speed up image acquisition and make possible applications that would otherwise not be feasible. Strictly speaking, any technique that uses a 180° refocusing RF pulse and acquires data under the RF echo is a spin-echo pulse sequence. With the explosive pace of development in fast imaging, a rapidly increasing number of techniques now fall within the scope of this definition.
Conventional Spin-Echo Sequences
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-27 Spin-echo pulse sequence diagram. After a π/2 excitation pulse, a π refocusing pulse is applied at TE/2. A spin-echo occurs at TE as outlined in Figure 5-18. By comparison with Figure 5-18, note that the polarity of the dephasing read gradient is the same as that of the rephasing read gradient. This is a consequence of the π pulse, which inverts the phase of the echo.
The design of a conventional spin-echo pulse sequence is straightforward and is illustrated in Figure 5-27. The initial gradient and RF events are similar to the 2D FLASH structure of Figure 5-20, but a refocusing π pulse is applied at time TE/2, immediately after the phase-encoding, slice-rephasing, and read-dephasing lobes. Note that the polarity of the dephasing and rephasing read gradients is the same, because the π pulse has inverted all phase accumulations. Note also that the π pulse is slice selective but does not have a rephasing lobe; π pulses are self-refocusing (for stationary spins). The spin-echo occurs at TE, and the gradient-echo is made to coincide with this. In the sequence diagram in Figure 5-27, the shortest possible TE is used, so this corresponds to the structure for a T1-weighted, short-TR, short-TE sequence. For a T2-weighted spin-echo sequence, a delay time is added on either side of the π pulse. In Figure 5-27, the area of the gradient pulses from the 90° pulse to the center of the echo is zero when the phase-reversal effect of the 180° pulse is taken into account. First-order or higher-order gradient moment nulling may be employed to diminish sensitivity to flow and motion artifact on spin-echo as well as gradient-echo sequences.
Turbo (Fast) Spin-Echo Sequences page 163 page 164
The concept of independently phase-encoding sequential spin-echoes of a multiecho train and using all the echoes to generate one image was first expounded by Hennig and colleagues. 62 Their original implementation of a single-shot technique, which they called RARE, acquired all the data for an image with just one 90° pulse and multiple 180° pulses. The phase-encoding gradient was incremented with each spin-echo, such that all of k-space was traversed in a single excitation. This was an extension of an earlier concept of Mansfield for single-shot imaging, which he called EPI, using a rapidly oscillating read gradient and a constant, low-amplitude phase-encoding gradient. Whereas EPI requires fast
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
gradients and associated hardware, RARE techniques are feasible on conventional MRI machines. Both RARE and EPI are subject to significant artifacts. With RARE, T2 decay progresses between points in k-space, whereas with EPI T2* decay progresses between points in k-space. The net effect of these dependences is that RARE images are highly T2 filtered, causing severe blurring of all but long T2 components, and EPI images are highly susceptibility weighted. Both of these effects are minimized by the use of shorter acquisition windows, either by enhanced gradient performance or by segmenting the acquisition into several narrower windows. This latter technique is employed in TSE and segmented EPI. Whatever technique is used, relaxation time filtering is diminished when the interval between successive echoes is minimized. This requires short gradient rise times and relatively short readout periods (wide bandwidths). The method of TSE or segmented RARE employs a variable number of separately phase-encoded echoes per 90° excitation pulse, as shown in Figure 5-28. The number of spin-echoes per excitation is called the echo train length or turbo factor. If, for example, the turbo factor is 15, then for each pass of the TR, 15 phase-encoding steps rather than 1 are acquired, speeding acquisition of a single slice by a factor of 15. It should be noted, however, that with multislice acquisition, the minimal TR per slice is increased, so that overall multislice acquisition time is decreased by a factor less than the turbo factor.
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-28 Turbo spin-echo. TSE sequence diagram showing T2 decay that occurs from one echo to the next. The exact modulation function that this decay imposes on the image data is determined by the phase-encode ordering.
The T2 contrast in TSE is determined by the TE of the echoes used to encode the center of k-space.23 If, for example, the low spatial frequencies correspond to TE values of about 100 ms, the T2 weighting is similar to that for a conventional spin-echo image with TE = 100 ms. The order in which the echoes are phase-encoded is important in TSE and variants. Sharp discontinuities and periodicities in k-space must be avoided to minimize ring and ghost artifacts, and this generally implies that the acquisition order must be interleaved from segment to segment. Blurring is more of a problem with short TE values because short-T2 components contribute more to the signal, and these are the source of the worst T2 filtering. One feature that distinguishes TSE T2-weighted images from conventional T2-weighted images is the intensity of the fat signal. With conventional T2, fat is subdued, whereas with TSE, fat is intense91; this can be a source of confusion. For this reason, TSE images may sometimes give the false impression of being T1 weighted. Another feature of TSE that has caused some concern in brain imaging is its relative insensitivity to the susceptibility effects of blood products. Repeated and rapid application of refocusing RF pulses prevents the dephasing by diffusion through
9 of 20
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
10 of 20
local fixed field nonuniformities that is responsible for the signal loss in hematomas and hemosiderin. A half-Fourier version of single-shot RARE, termed half-Fourier single-shot TSE (HASTE), can be used to acquire a single image with standard spatial resolution in a few hundred milliseconds. An inversion pre-pulse can be appended to any of the TSE group of sequences to give IR-type contrast. Also, because of the increased time efficiency of TSE, it is feasible to run a 3D version for isotropic coverage of the brain or spine in less than 10 minutes.
Turbo Inversion Recovery Conventional STIR imaging is time inefficient, and this has limited its widespread clinical use. With the advent of TSE techniques, turboSTIR imaging (Fig. 5-29) became an obvious and immediate extension.30 In fact, some of the less desirable features of TSE imaging may be offset by using a STIR preparation. The bright fat signal, distracting on many TSE images, is nulled on turboSTIR, and the T2 filtering effect, caused largely by short-T2 components, is less of a problem. For these reasons, turboSTIR may have higher contrast and less blurring than its TSE counterpart, and turboSTIR is the only TSE technique in widespread clinical use for musculoskeletal imaging. page 164 page 165
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-29 TurboIR pulse sequence diagram. The structure is that of a TSE sequence after an inversion pulse. After a suitable TI, a 90° excitation pulse is followed by a train of refocusing RF pulses, each giving rise to a spin-echo. Each echo is separately phase-encoded, and the effective TE is determined by the low-spatial-frequency echoes.
When used in imaging of the brain, STIR produces bright cerebrospinal fluid, which may render periventricular white matter lesions difficult to see. It has been shown that by using a long TI to null the cerebrospinal fluid, together with a long TE for T2 weighting, periventricular white matter lesions are 92 made conspicuous in the brain. This technique, called fluid-attenuated IR (FLAIR), is time-consuming but is much more efficient when used as a turboIR implementation. Slice looping structures for IR imaging can be optimized at the extremes of TI: For short TI, the most efficient loop structure has the inversion and readout completed on one slice before inverting the next For long TI, an interleaved structure is used, whereby slices 1 to N are first inverted and then slices 1 to N are excited and read. With intermediate values of TI, either limitations are imposed on the number of slices available or acquisition time is prolonged.
Gradient and Spin-Echo (GRASE)
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
11 of 20
One of the limitations of TSE is its high specific absorption rate in multislice applications with large turbo factors. A solution to this problem has been suggested by Feinberg and Oshio93 in a technique that they called gradient and spin-echo (GRASE). By combining data from spin-echo refocusings with gradient-echo refocusings, images can be acquired with fewer RF pulses and more quickly than with TSE (Fig. 5-30). In principle, sensitivity to blood products, which is diminished in TSE, can be recovered in GRASE through the gradient-echo refocusings. Because the polarity of the read gradient in GRASE is alternated, additional steps must be taken to prevent N/2 ghosting. GRASE can also be used as a single-shot technique.
Hyperechoes Spin-echo-based sequences are limited at higher field strengths such as 3T by the specific absorption rate (SAR) limits. Hennig and Scheffler developed a new spin-refocusing strategy using echoes of 94 echoes, called hyperechoes. Hyperechoes can alleviate the SAR limitations of TSE imaging by reducing the flip angles for data acquisition without compromising on the SE-like signal behavior. In a CPMG (Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill) experiment, where a 90° pulse is followed by multiple 180° pulses, images are acquired within a reasonable time while maintaining the spin-echo properties of the signal. As a result of the altered phases of the RF pulses in a CPMG sequence, the sequence develops high signal intensity even for low refocusing flip angles. However, with large turbo factors at low flip angles, the efficiency of signal usage may be reduced due to destructive interference between the spin configurations. Hennig and Scheffler94 showed in their study that the magnetization scrambled by any arbitrary multipulse sequence can be unwound by a 180° pulse and a spin-echo with full intensity can be formed.
Add to lightbox page 165 page 166
Figure 5-30 GRASE pulse sequence diagram. The structure differs from that of TSE in that additional gradient refocusings surround the spin-echoes. These additional gradient-echoes are separately phase-encoded, increasing time efficiency and lowering RF power deposition. Note that the polarity of the additional read gradient refocusings is opposite to that of the central lobe. Time reversal of alternate echoes can give rise to artifacts analogous to those in segmented EPI. Because of the frequent spin-echoes, however, sensitivity to susceptibility gradients is less than with EPI. In general, the low spatial frequencies coincide with the spin-echoes. The k-space offset between adjacent gradient-echo and spin-echo refocusings is constant, and the gradient tables are incremented between adjacent gradient-echo refocusings.
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
12 of 20
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-31 Illustration of a hyperecho sequence. Any sequence of pulses that show the above symmetry and are time reversed centered around a π pulse will act as a single π pulse, as long as relaxation effects are neglected (α = flip angle, Φ = RF phase). The π pulse is applied with a 0 phase. If a π/2 excitation precedes these pulses, a hyperecho will be generated as shown.
A schematic of a hyperecho sequence is shown in Figure 5-31. Low flip angles are used for the refocusing pulses instead of 180° as in a CPMG sequence. If the phase-encoding is such that the k = 0 line is sampled at the (2n + 1) echo, the central 180° pulse is placed before the (n + 1) refocusing period. The hyperecho mechanism time-reverses all the echoes after the 180° pulse and a full-intensity spin-echo is formed at the (2n + 1) echo. Since the contrast behavior of TSE sequences has been shown to be determined by the echoes with no phase-encoding, the spin-echo characteristics of the image are retained, but with a much reduced SAR.
Steady-State Free Precession (SSFP, TrueFISP, Balanced FFE, FIESTA)
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-32 SSFP pulse sequence diagram. The gradients are balanced along all three axes so that steady-state effects related to long-T2* species are emphasized. The gradient-echo and the RF echo are superimposed at TE, and the gradient structure is motion insensitive.
With improved gradient capabilities in recent years that permit the use of ultrashort TRs, SSFP has gained wide popularity for various applications in cardiac imaging,35,82,95 flow imaging,96 T1/T2 quantification,97,98 whole body imaging,99 etc. SSFP is a unique sequence in that it belongs to both the spin-echo and gradient-echo families. In an SSFP sequence, a gradient-echo is acquired similar to a FLASH or FISP sequence. However, the gradient structure is symmetrically balanced in the slice, phase-encoding, and read directions (Fig. 5-32) and no RF spoiling is implemented. Coherences are maintained in successive RF cycles so that the transverse magnetization from one TR contributes to the signal in the succeeding TRs. The RF echoes generated by the train of α pulses in the steady state are then superimposed on the gradient-echo (assuming a uniform main field). Signal is therefore highlighted from long-T2* and long-T2 components. Since there is no magnetization spoiling, there are no saturation effects as in spoiled techniques, and high flip angles can be used in SSFP. The balanced and symmetric gradient structure also generates motion insensitivity because of first-order gradient moment nulling.
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
While the TR remains shorter than T2 and there is no RF spoiling, the magnetization develops a coherent steady state, which is a combination of the longitudinal and transverse components. Starting from equilibrium magnetization, a finite time is necessary for the magnetization to reach steady state, during which RF excitations are continuously applied. In steady state, the SSFP signal is T2/T1 weighted, which is a unique form of contrast and is seeing increasing applications for in vivo imaging. The SSFP signal is a complicated function of parameters such as TR, T1, T2, flip angle, and off-resonance angle β (β = γ×∆B0 ×TR). Despite its many advantages, such as high SNR compared to spoiled gradient-echo sequences and high imaging efficiency, signal sensitivity to off-resonance is one of the major limitations of SSFP. page 166 page 167
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-33 Spectral response of the SSFP signal. Observe that the signal is relatively uniform when the off-resonance angle is around π radians. (TR = 5 ms, T1 = 1200 ms, T2 = 250 ms, flip angle = 50°.)
Off-resonance Off-resonance artifacts often manifest as banding patterns in SSFP images. Since the gradients are balanced in each TR, the resonance frequency offset dominates the phase behavior of the spins in SSFP. One of the main sources of off-resonance is B0 field inhomogeneity. For high flip angles, the signal dependence in SSFP on the off-resonance angle β is shown in Figure 5-33. If β is in the vicinity of 0 or 2π radians, there is a strong signal dependency on the resonance offset that is undesirable. On the other hand, the signal is relatively uniform for a range of β centered around π. The static B0 field varies within an object depending on position. This leads to extraneous signal variations in an image. If there is a changing β across the object, the signal sensitivity to off-resonance will degrade the uniformity in the reconstructed image. However, if β remains close to π, the above problem can be avoided as long as the variation in β across the imaged object is small. The variation in β can be kept small by careful shimming and by keeping the TR as short as possible. To uniformly bias β around π in the entire image, the phase of the RF pulses is incremented linearly by π radians with each excitation. This scheme of incrementing RF phases by π in each cycle is often referred to as alternating RF pulses. It must be kept in mind that for lower flip angles (~10°), the signal is lower for β = π than for β = 0, and the contrast in an image is reversed as compared to that at higher flip angles. However, the signal uniformity is preserved at β = π even for lower flip angles.
Approach to Steady State When the magnetization starting from its equilibrium value M0 experiences repeated RF excitations, it takes time on the order of 3T1 before it reaches steady state.79 During the transient period, the magnetization oscillates as it approaches steady state. The oscillations decay as the number of applied RF excitations increases. Data cannot be collected during this transient period because the
13 of 20
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
14 of 20
signal oscillations in k-space give rise to image artifacts. Due to a prohibitively long preparation time that may be required for tissues with long T1, a few different strategies have been proposed to address the problem of a quick approach to steady state. When alternating RF pulses are applied, the magnetization reaches a steady state where the magnetization vector oscillates between α/2 and -α/2 (α = flip angle) about the z-axis with successive RF pulses. Therefore, if the phase-alternating α pulse train is preceded by an RF pulse with a flip angle of α/2, the magnetization vector will be forced into steady state immediately if the frequency is on-resonance.100 For off-resonant spins, the signal oscillations persist despite the α/2 pre-pulse. Another method that improves over the off-resonant response of the α/2 preparation is the use of a 101,102 Both these magnetization preparations substantially reduce the linear flip angle preparation. magnetization fluctuations in the approach to steady state and permit data acquisition during signal transience to steady state.
Echo-Planar Imaging EPI is the fastest MRI method to have found potential clinical applications. 20,21,103 All of the spatial encoding is carried out after a single excitation under a spin-echo or gradient-echo envelope. The read gradient is oscillated, generating a series of rapid gradient-echo refocusings, during each of which one Fourier line is read. Phase-encoding is carried out with either a constant, low-amplitude pulse or a series of blipped pulses between readouts, which progressively increase the gradient moment in discrete steps (see Figs. 5-34 and 5-35). The polarity of the read gradient is alternated plus and minus, resulting in a rectilinear zigzag raster in k-space. With blipped phase-encoding, the k-space trajectory is mapped directly to a Cartesian grid, so no interpolation is necessary before image reconstruction. With constant phase-encoding, the k-space trajectory is an oblique zigzag, so the k values do not fit exactly on a Cartesian grid and must be interpolated before Fourier transformation. page 167 page 168
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
15 of 20
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-34 Blipped phase-encoding EPI pulse sequence (A). The k-space is traversed by monotonic progression of phase from a series of small, discrete gradient pulses (B). Of particular importance in EPI is the time reversal of the echoes from line to line. The k trajectory in read therefore alternates between left to right and right to left, and the blipped phase-encoding gradient increments the offset in ky between lines. Without proper correction for phase drift between odd and even lines, N/2 ghosts may be severe.
Signal sampling with EPI depends on the read gradient waveform. When "resonant" gradients are used, the fastest waveform is a sinusoidal pattern at the resonant frequency of the gradient coil (see Chapter 7). This generates a smooth transition without sharp discontinuities at plateaus. It also means that the signal can be sampled through the sinusoidal half-period, including the ramps. In this case, correction must be made for the unequal rate of k-space encoding with linear sampling, again with interpolation. An alternative scheme samples nonlinearly in time but linearly in k-space, and this requires matching the sampling window to the gradient waveform with high precision.104 With EPI, a variety of contrast-altering preparatory schemes may be used. These include preinversion and diffusion encoding with either a spin-echo or a stimulated-echo readout.
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
16 of 20
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-35 Constant phase-encoding EPI pulse sequence (A). The k-space is traversed by accumulation of phase throughout a constant, low-amplitude gradient (B). Because ky is incremented continuously and not as a series of discrete steps as with blipped EPI, the k trajectory now oscillates obliquely rather than horizontally. This must be interpolated onto a Cartesian k-space grid before Fourier transformation.
Motion and Flow Because conventional MR image acquisition typically takes several minutes, significant motion and flow can take place within the body, giving rise to a variety of effects and artifacts.105,106 These can be separated into two classes: time-of-flight effects, which are based on the macroscopic motion of fluid and tissue both through and within the image plane; and phase effects, which are due to the motion of spins along the applied imaging field gradients. Both classes of motion effects have been exploited in MR angiographic techniques107,108 and quantitative flow measurement.109,110
Time-of-Flight Effects page 168 page 169
In conventional spin-echo imaging, washout and signal loss occur when spins initially excited in the slice plane move out of the slice in the time interval between the 90° and 180° pulses. This effect can be useful in generating black blood contrast and eliminating motion artifact by suppressing the signal from flowing blood. Washout of flowing blood occurs by the same mechanism in TSE, in which each 90° excitation is followed by a train of 180° refocusing pulses, and in spin-echo EPI, in which the 90° to 180° pulse pair is followed by the readout of multiple echoes. Black blood contrast is deliberately enhanced through the use of spatial presaturation pulses and out-of-slice inversion pulses to reduce selectively the signal from blood flowing into the image plane from either or both sides. Ordering the slice acquisition in the direction of flow also serves to saturate the signal from blood before it enters the slice plane. Alternatively, ordering the slice acquisition opposite to the flow direction emphasizes in-flow enhancement. When TR is short, the signal from stationary tissue saturates, while the blood signal is constantly refreshed by inflow. Inflow enhancement occurs when the TR between RF excitations is sufficient to allow partially saturated spins to be replaced by fully magnetized spins from outside the imaged slice. Inflow enhancement is the mechanism of contrast in time-of-flight angiography techniques. This is described in detail in Chapter 27.
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
17 of 20
For the case of constant flow velocity, bulk motion generates the signal suppression or enhancement patterns just described but no discernible image artifacts. On the other hand, if flow or motion is time varying throughout the image acquisition, the washout and inflow effects are time varying as well and cause a modulation of the amplitude of the MR image data. Any modulation of the signal amplitude not generated intentionally by spatial encoding gives rise to image artifacts. Most physiologic motion is approximately periodic with cardiac and respiratory cycles and generates discrete "ghost" artifacts in the image. Cardiac and respiratory triggering or gating is commonly employed to eliminate this signal modulation by acquiring data at the same point in the cardiac or respiratory cycles. Fast image acquisition techniques can be used to reduce the data acquisition to a reasonable breath-hold period (<20 seconds); this is an effective means of eliminating respiratory motion artifact. A similar approach to avoiding motion can be used in cardiac imaging by gating image acquisition to diastole, when the heart is relatively stationary. Another time-of-flight effect is the misregistration artifact, which is due to motion with components along at least two of the imaging axes. This is often referred to as the oblique flow artifact.111 This artifact occurs because in conventional 2D Fourier transform imaging, the spatial positions along the imaging axes are encoded at different distinct points in time: at the center of the RF pulse on the sliceselect axis, at the center of a unipolar phase-encoding pulse on the phase-encoded axis, and at the echo on the read axis. Motion with directional components along two or three axes causes a misregistration of spins to appear in the image at a location they never actually occupy. This effect is most obvious when blood vessels are lying in the image plane and oriented oblique to the readout and phase-encoded axes. It is possible to design the phase-encoding waveform to encode position at an arbitrary point in time, eliminating misregistration between two of the three axes. By extending this to a 3D Fourier transform pulse sequence, where two of the three axes are phase-encoded, oblique flow misregistration can be eliminated entirely.
Phase Effects In addition to time-of-flight effects, motion in the presence of magnetic field gradients contributes to the phase of the MR signal. The phase of the magnetization at a specific point in space and time is defined in terms of the gradient waveform, G(t), and the position, r, of a spin by the equation This equation is central to the design of gradient waveforms for imaging but is valid only under the assumption that the positions of spins remain unchanged over the interval of integration, that is, during the application of the gradient. When human subjects are imaged, this assumption is frequently violated. If a spin is moving along the direction of a time-varying magnetic field gradient G(τ), Equation 5-26 becomes where τ is the variable of integration and r(τ) is the time-varying position of a moving spin in the direction defined by the gradient. Thus, the phase is a function of not only the applied gradient but also the motion itself. It is important to understand the effects that motion may have on the phase of the MR signal when designing a pulse sequence for clinical application. At times it may be desirable to quantify physiologic motion, to utilize motion as a contrast mechanism, or to minimize the effects of motion in the final image. Gradient waveforms can be defined that exploit the motion dependence of the phase of the NMR signal to achieve these goals. To facilitate an understanding of the effects of motion on the MR signal phase, it is helpful to expand the instantaneous position as a Taylor series, which expresses a function in terms of its value and its instantaneous derivatives. For example, substituting where x0 position at time t0 x'0 v0 = velocity at time t0
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
18 of 20
x'0 a0 = acceleration at time t0 back into Equation 5-27 and rearranging terms yield
page 169 page 170
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-36 FLASH gradient waveforms with first-order moment nulling (velocity compensation). The waveform is designed so that the zeroth- and first-order gradient moments are nulled. Positiondependent phase shifts and velocity-dependent phase shifts (independent of position) are nulled. Note that the echo occurs asymmetrically during the readout window. This is designed to shorten the TE and minimize sensitivity to higher-order motion.
Thus, the phase can be separated into terms proportional to specific instantaneous derivatives of position. The gradient waveform moment integrals define the sensitivity of a gradient waveform to each order of motion. This forms the basis for motion artifact suppression by gradient moment nulling, phase-contrast angiography, and flow velocity quantification.
Gradient Moment Nulling The relationship between data space (k-space) and image space can be corrupted by motion-induced phase, resulting in image artifacts by several mechanisms. Dispersion of phase by spatial variation of motion within a voxel causes a loss of signal intensity. If this phase dispersion is time varying as well, it may cause ghosting and blurring. If all of the spins within a voxel are moving in the same manner, they all acquire the same phase shift as a result of motion. This can result in a misregistration artifact if there is a motion component in more than one imaging axis and in ghosting and blurring if it varies from view to view. All of these deleterious effects of motion can be suppressed by the technique of gradient moment nulling.112,113 Examining Equation 5-29, one can see that phase related to velocity and higher derivatives of position can be nullified by designing the gradient waveform G(t) so that its first-order moment is zero. This can be extended to higher-order derivatives as well, although for the relatively short time intervals defined by the typical TE values used in MRI, most physiologic motion may be represented by a finite Taylor series expansion of two or three terms. A gradient waveform consisting of n + 1 pulses is required to null n moments. For example, a three-lobe gradient waveform is required to achieve zero phase related to position and velocity, as shown in Figure 5-36. Gradient waveforms with any order of motion compensation are easily designed by using linear algebra techniques.112
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
Equation 5-27 is usually evaluated at the echo (t = TE), where the result indicates the phase shift of the dominant kx = 0 spatial frequency component of the image. Phase at other spatial frequencies is measured relative to the linear phase generated by the spatial encoding of stationary spins and cannot be fully compensated by standard moment-nulling techniques. Spins moving along a constant linear field gradient exhibit a nonlinearly varying phase as a function of time, and this causes a blurring in the image. Gradient moment nulling can also be used to compensate for the oblique flow misregistration artifact described in the previous section. Defining the TE as the time origin, or center of the moment expansion, and designing the phase-encoding waveform with the first moment nulled effectively encode the position at TE of spins with a constant velocity component along the phase-encoded axis. Thus, the phase-encoded and readout coordinates of a spin are defined simultaneously, eliminating misregistration. This can be extended to the slice-select direction in a 3D sequence as well. TSE pulse sequences differ from conventional spin-echo imaging in that stimulated echo components are included in the MR signal. Moment nulling for the stimulated echoes must consider only the time that the signal spends in the transverse plane, as this is the only time that phase caused by motion can accumulate. Hinks and Constable114 described a technique for moment nulling the spin-echo and stimulated echoes in TSE; resultant waveforms are shown in Figure 5-37. Despite its speed, EPI can be highly sensitive to flow and motion effects, 115,116 particularly when in-plane velocities are high. The time-of-flight and phase effects found in conventional MRI have analogues in EPI. The washout effect described for spin-echo imaging occurs in spin-echo EPI and can be used to suppress the signal from blood. Inflow enhancement does not normally occur in single-shot EPI because the TR is effectively infinite. However, intentional presaturation of stationary spins can be used to generate inflow enhancement if desired. Misregistration artifacts caused by directional components of motion along multiple axes can occur in EPI, particularly in single-shot techniques, in which the TE values are typically long and the time difference between encodings along the slice-select and phase-encoding axes is significant. page 170 page 171
Add to lightbox
Figure 5-37 Velocity-compensated TSE pulse sequence. First-order moment nulling is applied in slice-selection and read directions. Both the primary spin-echoes and stimulated echoes are flow compensated.
Phase effects of motion in EPI are somewhat different from those in conventional MRI. Whereas the phase-encoded axis in EPI is directly analogous to the conventional readout axis in terms of motion sensitivity, significant differences exist in the EPI slice-selection and readout axes. Single-shot EPI is
19 of 20
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005046
20 of 20
insensitive to motion along the slice direction for two reasons: the high-powered gradient system required for EPI can be used to keep the duration (and motional dephasing) along the slice-select axis to a minimum, and there is no line-to-line variation in effects caused by through-plane motion. Slice selection occurs only once per image, effectively freezing motion and eliminating any signal modulation. The EPI phase-encoded axis, either blipped or constant, can be treated exactly like a conventional readout axis in terms of moment nulling. It should be noted that the duration of the EPI readout is typically on the order of 20 to 100 ms, and significant dephasing can occur. The oscillating EPI readout gradient has no analogue in conventional MRI. The first moment of this waveform oscillates between two values and causes a modulation of signal phase even with constant-velocity motion. Fortunately, these oscillating moments are typically quite small, and high velocities along the read direction are required for this effect to be significant. The line-to-line oscillation results in N/2 ghosts. In practice, the same strategies of keeping TE short, gradient moment nulling, and blood signal suppression are effective in suppressing motion artifacts in EPI.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:00
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005070
1 of 5
CONCLUSION We have seen that, although the details of how a specific pulse sequence is designed may vary greatly from one technique to another, all pulse sequences share a set of common elements. Spins must be excited and the resulting signal spatially encoded, detected, and digitally processed to produce an image. Within this general framework, a variety of RF pre-pulses and gradient pulse modifications may be used for specific purposes, as described. The resulting images may contain information that focuses on detailed anatomic structure or on correlates of organ function such as flow, perfusion, diffusion, oxygenation, muscle mechanics, or kinematics. The power of MRI lies in its flexibility, and its clinical potential will continue to grow with developments in its underlying technology. Pulse sequence design will remain a cornerstone for future development. REFERENCES 1. Haacke EM, Brown RW, Thompson MR, Venkatesan R: Magnetic Resonance Imaging: Physical Principles and Sequence Design. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1999. 2. Liang Z, Lauterbur PC: Principles of Magnetic Resonance Imaging: A Signal Processing Perspective. Piscataway, NJ: Wiley-IEEE Computer Society Press, 1999. 3. Emsley J, Feeney J, Sutcliffe LH: High Resolution NMR Spectroscopy. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1965. 4. Bracewell R: The Fourier Transform and Its Applications, 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1986. 5. Brigham EO: The Fast Fourier Transform and its Applications. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1988. 6. Hoult DI: Solution of the Bloch equations in the presence of a varying B1 field-Approach to selective pulse analysis. J Magn Reson 35:69-86, 1979. 7. Le Roux P: French Patent 8610179, 1986. 8. Shinnar M, Bolinger L, Leigh JS: The synthesis of soft pulses with a specified frequency response. Magn Reson Med 12:88-92, 1989. Medline Similar articles 9. Pauly JM, Le Roux P, Nishimura DG, Macovski A: Parameter Relations for the Shinnar-Le Roux Selective Excitation Pulse Design Algorithm. IEEE Trans Med Imag 10(1):53-65, Mar 1991. 10. Hardy CJ, Edelstein WA, Vatis D: Efficient adiabatic fast passage for NMR population inversion in the presence of radiofrequency field inhomogeneity and frequency offsets. J Magn Reson 66:470-482, 1986. 11. Silver MS, Joseph RI, Hoult DI: Highly selective π/2 and π pulse generation. J Magn Reson 59:347-351, 1984. 12. Bendall MR, Garwood M, Ugurbil K, Pegg DT: Adiabatic refocusing pulse which compensates for variable RF power and off-resonance effects. Magn Reson Med 4:493-499, 1987. Medline Similar articles 13. Ugurbil K, Garwood M, Rath AR: Optimization of modulation functions to improve insensitivity of adiabatic pulses to variations in B1 magnitude. J Magn Reson 80:448-469, 1988. 14. Ugurbil K, Garwood M, Bendall MR: Amplitude- and frequency-modulated pulses to achieve 90° plane rotations with inhomogeneous B1 fields. J Magn Reson 72:177-185, 1987. 15. Connolly S, Nishimura D, Macovski A: A selective adiabatic spin-echo pulse. J Magn Reson 83:324-344, 1989. 16. Edelman RR, Siewert B, Darby DG, et al: Qualitative mapping of cerebral blood flow and functional localization with echo-planar MR imaging and signal targeting with alternating radiofrequency. Radiology 192:513-520, 1994. Medline Similar articles page 171 page 172
17. Norris DG, Ludemann H, Leibfritz D: An analysis of the effects of short T2 values on the hyperbolic-secant pulse. J Magn Reson 92:94-101, 1991. 18. Carr HY, Purcell EM: Effects of diffusion on free precession in nuclear magnetic resonance. Physical Review 94:630-638, 1954. 19. Edelstein WA, Hutchison JM, Johnson G, Redpath T: Spin warp NMR imaging and applications to human whole-body imaging. Phys Med Biol 25:751-756, 1980. Medline Similar articles 20. Mansfield P, Pykett IL: Biological and medical imaging by NMR. J Magn Reson 29:355-373. 1978. 21. Stehling MK, Turner R, Mansfield P: Echo-planar imaging: magnetic resonance imaging in a fraction of a second. Science 254:43-50, 1991. Medline Similar articles 22. Chien D, Atkinson DJ, Edelman RR: Strategies to improve contrast in turboFLASH imaging: reordered phase encoding and k-space segmentation. J Magn Reson Imaging 1:63-70, 1991. Medline Similar articles 23. Mulkern RV, Melki PS, Jakab P, et al: Phase-encode order and its effect on contrast and artifact in single-shot RARE sequences. Med Phys 18:1032-1037, 1991. Medline Similar articles 24. Mulkern RV, Wong ST, Winalski C, Jolesz FA: Contrast manipulation and artifact assessment of 2D and 3D RARE sequences. Magn Reson Imaging 8:557-566, 1990.
12-04-2010 00:01
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005070
2 of 5
25. Yang PC, Meyer CH, Terashima M, et al: Spiral magnetic resonance coronary angiography with rapid real-time localization. J Am Coll Cardiol 41:1134-1141, 2003. Medline Similar articles 26. Spuentrup E, Schroeder J, Mahnken AH, et al: Quantitative assessment of left ventricular function with interactive real-time spiral and radial MR imaging. Radiology 227:870-876, 2003. Medline Similar articles 27. Lai S, Glover GH: Three-dimensional spiral fMRI technique: a comparison with 2D spiral acquisition. Magn Reson Med 39:68-78, 1998. 28. Sommer G, Corrigan G, Fredrickson J, et al: Renal blood flow: measurement in vivo with rapid spiral MR imaging. Radiology 208:729-734, 1998. Medline Similar articles 29. Kellman P, Arai AE, McVeigh ER, Aletras AH: Phase-sensitive inversion recovery for detecting myocardial infarction using gadolinium-delayed hyperenhancement. Magn Reson Med 47:372-383, 2002. Medline Similar articles 30. Walker R, Kessar P, Blanchard R, et al: Turbo STIR magnetic resonance imaging as a whole-body screening tool for metastases in patients with breast carcinoma: preliminary clinical experience. J Magn Reson Imaging 11:343-350, 2000. Medline Similar articles 31. Nakatsu M, Hatabu H, Itoh H, et al: Comparison of short inversion time inversion recovery (STIR) and fat-saturated (chemsat) techniques for background fat intensity suppression in cervical and thoracic MR imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging 11:56-60, 2000. Medline Similar articles 32. Bydder GM, Steiner RE, Blumgart LH, et al: MR imaging of the liver using short TI inversion recovery sequences. J Comput Assist Tomogr 9:1084-1089, 1985. Medline Similar articles 33. Earls JP, Rofsky NM, DeCorato DR, et al: Echo-train STIR MRI of the liver: comparison of breath-hold and non-breath-hold imaging strategies. J Magn Reson Imaging 9:87-92, 1999. Medline Similar articles 34. Dwyer AJ, Frank JA, Sank VJ, et al: Short-Ti inversion-recovery pulse sequence: analysis and initial experience in cancer imaging. Radiology 168:827-836, 1988. Medline Similar articles 35. Fenchel M, Helber U, Simonetti OP, et al: Multislice first-pass myocardial perfusion imaging: Comparison of saturation recovery (SR)-TrueFISP-two-dimensional (2D) and SR-TurboFLASH-2D pulse sequences. J Magn Reson Imaging 19:555-563, 2004. Medline Similar articles 36. Felmlee JP, Ehman RL: Spatial presaturation: a method for suppressing flow artifacts and improving depiction of vascular anatomy in MR imaging. Radiology 164:559-564, 1987. Medline Similar articles 37. Edelman RR, Chien D, Kim D: Fast selective black blood MR imaging. Radiology 181:655-660, 1991. Medline Similar articles 38. Kim WY, Stuber M, Bornert P, et al: Three-dimensional black-blood cardiac magnetic resonance coronary vessel wall imaging detects positive arterial remodeling in patients with nonsignificant coronary artery disease. Circulation 106:296-299, 2002. Medline Similar articles 39. Simonetti OP, Finn JP, White RD, et al: "Black blood" T2-weighted inversion-recovery MR imaging of the heart. Radiology 199:49-57, 1996. Medline Similar articles 40. Wolff SD, Balaban RS: Magnetization transfer contrast (MTC) and tissue water proton relaxation in vivo. Magn Reson Med 10:135-144, 1989. Medline Similar articles 41. Edelman RR, Ahn SS, Chien D, et al: Improved time-of-flight MR angiography of the brain with magnetization transfer contrast. Radiology 184:395-399, 1992. Medline Similar articles 42. Pike GB, Hu BS, Glover GH, Enzmann DR: Magnetization transfer time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography. Magn Reson Med 25:372-379, 1992. Medline Similar articles 43. Balaban RS, Chesnick S, Hedges K, et al: Magnetization transfer contrast in MR imaging of the heart. Radiology 180:671-675, 1991. Medline Similar articles 44. Semple SI, Redpath TW, McKiddie FI, Waiter GD: Comparison of four magnetization preparation schemes to improve blood-wall contrast in cine short-axis cardiac imaging. Magn Reson Med 39:291-299, 1998. Medline Similar articles 45. Wielopolski PA, van Geuns RJ, de Feyter PJ, Oudkerk M: Breath-hold coronary MR angiography with volume-targeted imaging. Radiology 209:209-219, 1998. Medline Similar articles 46. Haba D, Pasco Papon A, Tanguy JY, et al: Use of half-dose gadolinium-enhanced MRI and magnetization transfer saturation in brain tumors. Eur Radiol 11:117-122, 2001. Medline Similar articles 47. Frahm J, Haase A, Hanicke W, et al: Chemical shift selective MR imaging using a whole-body magnet. Radiology 156:441-444, 1985. Medline Similar articles 48. Rosen BR, Wedeen VJ, Brady TJ: Selective saturation NMR imaging. J Comput Assist Tomogr 8:813-818, 1984. Medline Similar articles 49. Hore PJ: Solvent suppression in Fourier-Transform nuclear magnetic-resonance. J Magn Reson 55:283-300, 1983. 50. Meyer CH, Pauly JM, Macovski A, Nishimura DG: Simultaneous spatial and spectral selective excitation. Magn Reson Med 15:287-304, 1990. Medline Similar articles 51. Flamig DP, Pierce WB, Harms SE, Griffey RH: Magnetization transfer contrast in fat-suppressed steady-state threedimensional MR images. Magn Reson Med 26:122-131, 1992. Medline Similar articles 52. Thomasson D, Purdy D, Finn JP: Phase-modulated binomial RF pulses for fast spectrally-selective musculoskeletal
12-04-2010 00:01
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005070
3 of 5
imaging. Magn Reson Med 35:563-568, 1996. Medline
Similar articles
53. Finn JP: Rapid, fat-or water-suppressed multislice MR pulse sequence. US Patent # 5633586, 1997. 54. Finn JP, Thomasson DM, Moore JR: Minimum cost presaturation by slice segmentation in fast 2-D gradient-echo imaging. New York: Proceedings of the ISMRM, 1996. 55. Rofsky NM, Lee VS, Laub G, et al: Abdominal MR imaging with a volumetric interpolated breath-hold examination. Radiology 212:876-884, 1999. Medline Similar articles 56. Hennig J: Echoes-how to generate, recognize, use or avoid them in MR imaging sequences. I. Fundamental and not so fundamental properties of spin echoes. Concepts Magn Reson 3:125-143, 1991. 57. Hennig J, Scheffler K: Easy improvement of signal-to-noise in RARE-sequences with low refocusing flip angles. Rapid acquisition with relaxation enhancement. Magn Reson Med 44:983-985, 2000. Medline Similar articles 58. Hennig J, Weigel M, Scheffler K: Multiecho sequences with variable refocusing flip angles: optimization of signal behavior using smooth transitions between pseudo steady states (TRAPS). Magn Reson Med 49:527-535, 2003. Medline Similar articles 59. Hahn EL: Spin echoes. Phys Rev 80:580-594, 1950. 60. Stejskal EO, Tanner JE: Spin diffusion measurements: spin-echoes in the presence of a time-dependent gradient field. J Chem Physiol 42:288-292, 1965. 61. Meiboom S, Gill D: Modified spin echo method for measuring nuclear relaxation rates. Rev Sci Instrum 29:688, 1958. 62. Hennig J, Nauerth A, Friedburg H: RARE imaging: a fast imaging method for clinical MR. Magn Reson Med 3:823-833, 1986. Medline Similar articles 63. Melki PS, Jolesz FA, Mulkern RV: Partial RF echo planar imaging with the FAISE method. I. Experimental and theoretical assessment of artifact. Magn Reson Med 26:328-341, 1992. Medline Similar articles 64. Melki PS, Jolesz FA, Mulkern RV: Partial RF echo-planar imaging with the FAISE method. II. Contrast equivalence with spin-echo sequences. Magn Reson Med 26:342-354, 1992. Medline Similar articles 65. Oshio K, Feinberg DA: GRASE (Gradient- and spin-echo) imaging: a novel fast MRI technique. Magn Reson Med 20:344-349, 1991. Medline Similar articles 66. Constable RT, Smith RC, Gore JC: Signal-to-noise and contrast in fast spin echo (FSE) and inversion recovery FSE imaging. J Comput Assist Tomogr 16:41-47, 1992. Medline Similar articles 67. Constable RT, Anderson AW, Zhong J, Gore JC: Factors influencing contrast in fast spin-echo MR imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 10:497-511, 1992. Medline Similar articles 68. Williams CF, Redpath TW, Smith FW: The influence of stimulated echoes on contrast in fast spin-echo imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 14:419-428, 1996. Medline Similar articles 69. Sattin W, Mareci TH, Scott KN: Exploiting the stimulated echo in nuclear magnetic-resonance imaging. 1. Method. J Magn Reson 64:177-182, 1985. 70. Hennig J, Hoddap M: Burst imaging. MAGMA 1:39-48, 1993. 71. Ardelean I, Kimmich R: Diffusion measurements using the nonlinear stimulated echo. J Magn Reson 143:101-105, 2000. Medline Similar articles 72. Scheenen TW, Vergeldt FJ, Windt CW, et al: Microscopic imaging of slow flow and diffusion: a pulsed field gradient stimulated echo sequence combined with turbo spin echo imaging. J Magn Reson 151:94-100, 2001. Medline Similar articles 73. Wedeen VJ, Weisskoff RM, Reese TG, et al: Motionless movies of myocardial strain-rates using stimulated echoes. Magn Reson Med 33:401-408, 1995. Medline Similar articles 74. Heiland S, Dietrich O, Sartor K: Diffusion-weighted imaging of the brain: comparison of stimulated- and spin-echo echo-planar sequences. Neuroradiology 43:442-447, 2001. Medline Similar articles 75. Aletras AH, Wen H: Mixed echo train acquisition displacement encoding with stimulated echoes: an optimized DENSE method for in vivo functional imaging of the human heart. Magn Reson Med 46:523-534, 2001. Medline Similar articles 76. Haase A, Frahm J, Matthaei D, et al: Flash imaging-Rapid NMR imaging using low flip-angle pulses. J Magn Reson 67:258-266, 1986. 77. Frahm J, Hanicke W, Merboldt KD: Transverse coherence in rapid flash NMR imaging. J Magn Reson 72:307-314, 1987. 78. Crawley AP, Wood ML, Henkelman RM: Elimination of transverse coherences in FLASH MRI. Magn Reson Med 8:248-260, 1988. Medline Similar articles 79. Zur Y, Wood ML, Neuringer LJ: Spoiling of transverse magnetization in steady-state sequences. Magn Reson Med 21:251-263, 1991. Medline Similar articles 80. Mugler JP III, Brookeman JR: Three-dimensional magnetization-prepared rapid gradient-echo imaging (3D MP RAGE). Magn Reson Med 15:152-157, 1990. Medline Similar articles 81. Edelman RR, Wallner B, Singer A, et al: Segmented turboFLASH: method for breath-hold MR imaging of the liver with flexible contrast. Radiology 177:515-521, 1990. Medline Similar articles 82. Carr JC, Simonetti OP, Bundy JM, et al: Cine MR angiography of the heart with segmented true fast imaging with
12-04-2010 00:01
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005070
4 of 5
steady-state precession. Radiology 219:828-834, 2001. Medline
Similar articles page 172 page 173
83. Li D, Paschal CB, Haacke EM, Adler LP: Coronary arteries: three-dimensional MR imaging with fat saturation and magnetization transfer contrast. Radiology 187:401-406, 1993. Medline Similar articles 84. Wielopolski PA, Manning WJ, Edelman RR: Single breath-hold volumetric imaging of the heart using magnetizationprepared 3-dimensional segmented echo planar imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging 5:403-409, 1995. 85. Frahm J, Hanicke W, Bruhn H, et al: High-speed STEAM MRI of the human heart. Magn Reson Med 22:133-142, 1991. Medline Similar articles 86. Oppelt A, Graumann R, Barfuss H: FISP: a new fast MRI sequence. Electromedica (English ED) 3:15-18, 1986. 87. Gyngell ML: The steady-state signals in short-repetition-time sequences. J Magn Reson 81:474-483, 1989. 88. Gyngell ML: The application of steady-state free precession in rapid 2DFT NMR imaging: FAST and CE-FAST sequences. Magn Reson Imaging 6:415-419, 1988. 89. Bruder H, Fischer H, Graumann R, Deimling M: A new steady-state imaging sequence for simultaneous acquisition of two MR images with clearly different contrasts. Magn Reson Med 7:35-42, 1988. Medline Similar articles 90. Redpath TW, Jones RA: FADE-a new fast imaging sequence. Magn Reson Med 6:224-234, 1988. Medline Similar articles 91. Listerud J, Einstein S, Outwater E, Kressel HY: First principles of fast spin echo. Magn Reson Q 8:199-244, 1992. Medline Similar articles 92. White SJ, Hajnal JV, Young IR, Bydder GM: Use of fluid-attenuated inversion-recovery pulse sequences for imaging the spinal cord. Magn Reson Med 28:153-162, 1992. Medline Similar articles 93. Feinberg DA, Oshio K: Gradient-echo shifting in fast MRI techniques (GRASE imaging) for correction of field inhomogeneity errors and chemical-shift. J Magn Reson 97:177-183, 1992. 94. Hennig J, Scheffler K: Hyperechoes. Magn Reson Med 46:1-12, 2001. Medline
Similar articles
95. Deshpande VS, Shea SM, Laub G, et al: 3D magnetization-prepared true-FISP: A new technique for imaging coronary arteries. Magn Reson Med 46:494-502, 2001. Medline Similar articles 96. Markl M, Alley MT, Pelc NJ: Balanced phase-contrast steady-state free precession (PC-SSFP): a novel technique for velocity encoding by gradient inversion. Magn Reson Med 49:945-952, 2003. Medline Similar articles 97. Scheffler K, Hennig J: T(1) quantification with inversion recovery TrueFISP. Magn Reson Med 45:720-723, 2001. Medline Similar articles 98. Schmitt P, Griswold MA, Jakob PM, et al: Inversion recovery TrueFISP: quantification of T(1), T(2), and spin density. Magn Reson Med 51:661-667, 2004. Medline Similar articles 99. Fautz HP, Leupold J, Hennig J, Scheffler K: Signal behavior in continuously ramped 2D TrueFISP for whole-body imaging. Magn Reson Med 48:1085-1090, 2002. 100. Deimling M, Heid O: True FISP Imaging with Inherent Fat Cancellation. Denver: Proceedings of the ISMRM, 1999, p 1500. 101. Nishimura DG, Vasanawala S: Analysis and Reduction of the Transient Response in SSFP Imaging. Denver: Proceedings of the ISMRM, 2000, p 301. 102. Deshpande VS, Chung YC, Zhang Q, et al: Reduction of transient signal oscillations in true-FISP using a linear flip angle magnetization preparation. Magn Reson Med 49:151-157, 2003. Medline Similar articles 103. Cohen MS, Weisskoff RM: Ultra-fast imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 9:1-37, 1991. Medline
Similar articles
104. Bruder H, Fischer H, Reinfelder HE, Schmitt F: Image reconstruction for echo planar imaging with nonequidistant k-space sampling. Magn Reson Med 23:311-323, 1992. Medline Similar articles 105. Axel L: Blood flow effects in magnetic resonance imaging. Am J Roentgenol 143:1157-1166, 1984. 106. Mills CM, Brant-Zawadzki M, Crooks LE, et al: Nuclear magnetic resonance: principles of blood flow imaging. Am J Roentgenol 142:165-170, 1984. 107. Laub GA, Kaiser WA: MR angiography with gradient motion refocusing. J Comput Assist Tomogr 12:377-382, 1988. Medline Similar articles 108. Dumoulin CL, Hart HR Jr: Magnetic resonance angiography. Radiology 161:717-720, 1986. Medline Similar articles 109. Moran PR: A flow velocity zeugmatographic interlace for NMR imaging in humans. Magn Reson Imaging 1:197-203, 1982. Medline Similar articles 110. Edelman RR, Mattle HP, Kleefield J, Silver MS: Quantification of blood flow with dynamic MR imaging and presaturation bolus tracking. Radiology 171:551-556, 1989. Medline Similar articles 111. Nishimura DG, Jackson JI, Pauly JM: On the nature and reduction of the displacement artifact in flow images. Magn Reson Med 22:481-492, 1991. Medline Similar articles 112. Pattany PM, Phillips JJ, Chiu LC, et al: Motion artifact suppression technique (MAST) for MR imaging. J Comput Assist
12-04-2010 00:01
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC005070
5 of 5
Tomogr 11:369-377, 1987. Medline
Similar articles
113. Haacke EM, Lenz GW: Improving MR image quality in the presence of motion by using rephasing gradients. Am J Roentgenol 148:1251-1258, 1987. 114. Hinks RS, Constable RT: Gradient moment nulling in fast spin echo. Magn Reson Med 32:698-706, 1994. Medline Similar articles 115. Butts K, Riederer SJ: Analysis of flow effects in echo-planar imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging 2:285-293, 1992. Medline Similar articles 116. Duerk JL, Simonetti OP: Theoretical aspects of motion sensitivity and compensation in echo-planar imaging. J Magn Reson Imaging 1:643-650, 1991. Medline Similar articles
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:01
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00603068
1 of 1
IOCHEMICAL EREBRAL
ASIS OF THE
PPEARANCE OF
EMORRHAGE
Keith R. Thulborn
INTRODUCTION The highly variable appearance of cerebral hemorrhage by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) provides a wealth of information about the underlying biochemical processes. This information is often neglected in the MRI evaluation of hemorrhagic pathologic processes. A complete analysis using the full information content of MR images requires an understanding of the biochemical processes influencing the relaxation mechanisms controlling signal intensity. Extrapolating from in vitro studies and clinical observations, researchers have proposed hypotheses to explain the evolution of the features of cerebral hematomas on MR images.1-6 The explanations have emphasized the role of iron from hemoglobin in determining relaxation mechanisms of these variable patterns. This is based on the high concentration and changing magnetic properties of iron as the biochemical form, oxidation state, and spatial distribution change with time. Other pathophysiologic processes such as changes in integrity of the blood-brain barrier with alteration of the degree of edema and protein concentration have explained other features of these images. In this chapter, the physiochemical principles of the magnetic properties of biologic systems are reviewed, the biochemical pathways of iron metabolism in resolving hematoma are discussed, and a non-mathematic scheme is presented for relating these biochemical aspects to the relaxation phenomena that produce the variable signal contrast observed in MR images of hemorrhage. Clinical aspects involved in using MRI to evaluate hemorrhage are considered in Chapter 45.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:02
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006002
1 of 5
BIOCHEMICAL EVOLUTION OF IRON IN CEREBRAL HEMATOMA Hemorrhage is a complex process, biochemically and pathologically, evolving over many months. The pattern of evolution of hemorrhage described by computed tomography is relatively simple, reflecting the protein content of the tissues at the site of the lesion,7,8 as compared with the richness of 3-6 information content reflected in the variability reported for MR images of the same process. The rate of the many biochemical changes depends on the location and size of the lesion and on the physiologic status of the patient.9 Better vascularized areas would be expected to show more rapid repair. Because of the integrity of the blood-brain barrier, repair and clearance processes in the parenchyma differ from those occurring in subarachnoid and subdural hemorrhages. Such variability in hematomainduced repair response has been reported also from biochemical studies of hemorrhage at different 10 sites outside the central nervous system.
Iron Metabolism in Hemorrhage page 174 page 175
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-1 Schematic depiction of iron metabolism in a hematoma showing simplified iron salvage pathways in the red blood cell, phagocyte, and extracellular space. BBB, blood-brain barrier; deoxyHb, deoxyhemoglobin; metHb, methemoglobin; oxyHb, oxyhemoglobin; PO2, partial pressure of oxygen.
Iron is a transition metal with an atomic number of 26 and an electronic configuration described as The distribution of electrons in the outer 3d electronic orbital is dependent on the number of electrons. 2+ As the oxidation state increases, outer electrons are lost, leaving the ferrous ion (Fe ) with six 3d 3+ electrons and the ferric ion (Fe ) with five 3d electrons. Unpaired electrons within the outer 3d orbitals of iron are of critical importance in determining the magnetic properties of this atom. As the most abundant transition metal in the human body, iron is vital for oxygen transport by hemoglobin in the erythrocyte of blood, oxygen storage by myoglobin in the tissues, and multiple catalytic functions in enzyme systems throughout the body. In contrast to its functional chelated form, free iron is toxic, as is evident from toxic ingestions and iron overload states.11-13 Toxicity is believed to
12-04-2010 00:04
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006002
2 of 5
be due to enhanced catalysis of free radical production by unchelated iron. 14 Hemorrhage can be thought of as having a tightly controlled iron salvage pathway, in which iron from the extravasated erythrocytes is mobilized from hemoglobin, detoxified by chelation to short-term iron transport proteins for transfer back to the reticuloendothelial system, or converted to long-term storage proteins for local 12,15,16 deposition. The different forms of iron in this still incompletely understood pathway have different magnetic properties that can influence the magnetic relaxation properties of the proton spin system used to form the MR image. The iron salvage pathway of arterial hemorrhage is now examined stepwise in terms of the magnetic properties of the iron (Fig. 6-1). No time scale is given because this can only be misleading, given the multiple factors that determine rate of repair as described previously.
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-2 Energy diagram of the 3d electronic orbitals of the ferrous form of iron with different ligands. In the absence of ligands, all 3d orbitals have the same energy. In deoxyhemoglobin, the five ligands produce little energy separation between the eg and t2g groups of 3d orbitals, allowing the six electrons to distribute such that four electrons are unpaired (i.e., paramagnetic). In oxyhemoglobin, the six ligands produce marked energy difference E between the eg and t2g groups of 3d orbitals, causing electron pairing in the lowest energy state of the t2g orbitals (i.e., diamagnetic).
Arterial Blood In arterial hemorrhage, the freshly extravasated erythrocytes contain fully oxygenated hemoglobin. Hemoglobin is a tetramer of polypeptide chains, with each polypeptide chain having considerable 17 ordered secondary and tertiary structure. Each chain has a prosthetic heme group bound within a hydrophobic cleft. The heme group is protoporphyrin IX with a centrally chelated ferrous ion. Initially, in arterial blood, iron is bound in octahedral geometry with six ligands. The tetrapyrrole nitrogens of the protoporphyrin constitute four ligands in a plane around the iron. The imidazole group of a histidine from the polypeptide chain is the axial ligand below the protoporphyrin plane, whereas molecular oxygen is the sixth exchangeable ligand above the plane. The interaction of the six ligands with the metal center in oxyhemoglobin causes the six outer electrons of the ferrous ion to pair in the t2g group of 3d orbitals of the lowest energy (Fig. 6-2). Because all the electrons of the iron and other atoms that constitute hemoglobin are paired, oxygenated blood is diamagnetic (χ < 0).
Deoxygenation page 175 page 176
12-04-2010 00:04
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006002
3 of 5
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-3 Schematic representation of the exclusion of water from the paramagnetic iron of deoxyhemoglobin by the surrounding globin protein until the protein undergoes conformational changes that lead to access of water to the heme cleft and oxidation of the ferrous iron to ferric iron in methemoglobin. Water access explains relaxivity effects of methemoglobin and the absence of such effects for deoxyhemoglobin, although both are paramagnetic.
In tissues undergoing aerobic respiration, the partial pressure of dissolved oxygen is lower than that required to fully saturate the oxygen-binding sites of hemoglobin. The binding equilibrium is reversed, and molecular oxygen is delivered to the tissues. A cerebral hematoma has a mass effect compressing surrounding tissue, thereby reducing perfusion to these regions. A gradient in the partial pressure of oxygen from the hematoma to the compromised surrounding tissue results in hemoglobin desaturation. In addition, there is reduced washout of byproducts, such as carbon dioxide from remaining aerobic respiration and lactate from anaerobic glycolysis, which results in a decline in pH as the buffering capacity of the tissue is exceeded. This leads to further deoxygenation of the hemoglobin by displacement of the hemoglobin oxygen-binding equilibrium toward dissociation (the Bohr effect). The removal of molecular oxygen changes the coordinate geometry of the heme ferrous ion to a five-ligand system of deoxyhemoglobin, which decreases the energy separation between the eg and t2g groups of electronic orbitals. The six 3d electrons redistribute among the five 3d orbitals, leaving four unpaired electrons of parallel spin (see Fig. 6-2). These unpaired electrons confer deoxyhemoglobin with its paramagnetic properties (χ > 0). Because the paramagnetic ferrous ion is bound to the heme group in the hydrophobic cleft of the globin protein, water molecules are unable to approach the iron center. This restricts relaxivity effects (Fig. 6-3). As the deoxyhemoglobin is packaged in red blood cells, the magnetic susceptibility of the interior of the cell is different from that of the suspending fluid, resulting in susceptibility variations within the hematoma (Fig. 6-4). The importance of the integrity of the red blood 18,19 cell membrane has been demonstrated in vitro.
12-04-2010 00:04
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006002
4 of 5
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-4 Simplified schematic representation of the different effective magnetic fields Heff produced by tissues of diamagnetic (χ1 < 0) and paramagnetic (χ2 > 0) magnetic susceptibilities in the applied field H0. The signal frequency ω is shifted by Heff according to the Larmor equation (ω = γHeff). The signal intensity of the voxels (4 and 9 of voxels 1 through 12) at the boundaries is reduced owing to diffusion in the field gradients on spin-echo images and, in addition, due to intravoxel dephasing on gradient-echo images.
The time course and distribution of deoxygenation can be used to explain some features of hyperacute hemorrhage20 in which a peripheral rim of reduced signal intensity is observed around parenchymal hematomas of less than 24 hours' duration on T2-weighted images. Histologic examination shows that the hematoma-tissue interface is not smooth but rather shows periodic interdigitation of strands of blood clot containing intact red blood cells with surrounding brain tissue. Due to mass effect of the clot, this tissue can have compromised perfusion resulting in decreasing pH due to accumulation of metabolic byproducts. This periodic geometry and rapid deoxygenation of the periphery of the blood clot due to the Bohr effect from acidification results in magnetic susceptibility effects with concomitant MR signal loss.
Red Blood Cell Lysis page 176 page 177
The tissue damage elicits an inflammatory repair response within the surrounding tissue, with phagocytes, such as macrophages, infiltrating the boundaries of the hematoma to clear extravasated materials and damaged tissues. Glial cells also show phagocytic activity. Red blood cells may be phagocytosed entirely or partially, or lysed by enzymes released into the region by the inflammatory cells.8,9 Loss of red blood cell membrane integrity releases hemoglobin. In the absence of the functional reductase enzymes of the red blood cell (NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase, NADPH-flavin reductase),17 hemoglobin is rapidly converted to methemoglobin, in which the iron, still bound to the heme moiety within the globin protein, is oxidized to the ferric state with five 3d electrons. Once in the ferric oxidation state, the iron is paramagnetic (χ > 0). The protein undergoes a number of changes, ultimately irreversible, in secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structures in which the ferric iron is no 21 longer protected from the surrounding solvent. The electronic configuration of the iron changes from initially five unpaired electrons, one in each of the five 3d suborbitals, to one unpaired electron as the weak sixth ligand of water is exchanged for a hydroxide and then another imidazole nitrogen of a histidyl residue of the protein. These changes define the hemichromes as described by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy.22 The time course of these processes in vivo remains unknown.
12-04-2010 00:04
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006002
5 of 5
Extracellular Iron-Binding Proteins Extracellular protein is further degraded with release of the iron to localized extracellular binding proteins such as lactoferrin and transferrin. Some extracellular ferritin is also present. These binding proteins detoxify free iron for recycling to the reticuloendothelial system through the circulation and for 23-25 local storage by glial cells and macrophages. The chelated iron remains paramagnetic.
Intracellular Iron Processing Red blood cells and hemoglobin, phagocytosed by macrophages and glial elements of the central nervous system, are digested by the lysosomal system, with the iron being stored as ferric oxyhydroxide in the hydrophobic center of the major iron storage protein called ferritin.15,26 Ferritin is a water-soluble protein of approximately 450 kd with 24 polypeptide subunits surrounding a core of as many as 4500 ferric ions. If the quantity of available iron exceeds the capacity of the cell to synthesize apoferritin, excess iron is stored as hemosiderin.16 Hemosiderin is an insoluble larger aggregation of ferric oxyhydroxide with less protein than ferritin and, as yet, a poorly characterized biochemical structure. These storage forms with large aggregates of iron behave antiferromagnetically and ferromagnetically, sometimes with superparamagnetic properties (χ > 0).27-29 These aggregates of iron have reduced accessibility to surrounding water, thereby minimizing relaxivity effects. However, magnetic susceptibility variations can be expected in tissues containing such materials. The iron storage processes occur throughout resolution of hemorrhage but become significant later, presumably reflecting concentration changes and the cessation of other relaxation processes. Much of the ferritin is intracellular within both macrophages and astrocytes, whereas the hemosiderin is in macrophages.30
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:04
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006009
1 of 1
INTEGRITY OF THE BLOOD-BRAIN BARRIER
Edema The loss of the blood-brain barrier around the site of hemorrhage causes vasogenic edema. The damage to the tissue in and around the site from mass effect, reduced perfusion, and inflammation worsens the edema. Although such changes do not affect the magnetic properties of the tissues that remain diamagnetic (χ < 0), other magnetic relaxation phenomena occur to alter the MR image.
Coagulation The extravasated blood initiates the coagulation cascade, leading to clot formation that limits further bleeding. The protein network of the clot with trapped red blood cells is expected to undergo a number of changes, including clot contraction with changes in the concentration and distribution of blood products, which can change magnetic properties of the tissue and thus the MRI characteristics. This has not been systematically studied in vivo.31,32
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:04
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006012
1 of 1
RELAXATION MECHANISMS For totally diamagnetic tissues, the most important relaxation mechanism for both longitudinal and transverse relaxation is attributed to dipole-dipole interactions. 33,34 Other mechanisms of scalar-spin coupling, chemical shift anisotropy, and quadripolar and spin-rotational effects are usually less 33-38 Paramagnetic substances have several important in proton MRI and are described elsewhere. effects of much greater magnitude than diamagnetic substances, as discussed in the Appendix at the end of this chapter. These effects include: 1. relaxivity effects due to dipole-dipole interactions, which produce T1 and T2 relaxation, generally with T1 effects dominating to produce increased signal intensity; and 2. susceptibility effects, which produce only T2 relaxation and signal loss on MR images. The dipole-dipole effects of paramagnetic substances are discussed in the Appendix, but consideration must be given to other exchange processes not involving paramagnetic species. Changes in the protein content within the hematoma are also seen as clot formation, clot contraction, 38 and necrosis occur. From in vitro studies, increasing protein concentration would be expected to promote T1 and T2 relaxation rates, although rigorous in vivo studies have not been reported. It is possible that the exchange of water between bulk and protein-bound phases may be a significant relaxation process in some situations. Increasing edema has been suggested to allow increased diffusion by removing diffusional barriers such as macromolecules and cell membranes, thereby promoting T2 relaxation. In areas of necrosis, diffusional barriers may not be removed to the same degree as in vasogenic edema in intact, albeit damaged, tissue. The relative influences of diffusion and protein exchange on in vivo relaxation processes cannot be predicted as yet.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:05
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006013
1 of 3
SENSITIVITIES OF MRI PULSE SEQUENCES The basic principles of imaging pulse sequences have been presented in numerous excellent texts, 39-43 and only features pertaining to hemorrhage are elaborated on here. page 177 page 178
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-5 Simplified schematic of timing diagrams of the spin-echo (SE) (top), asymmetric-echo (ASE) (middle), and gradient-echo (GRE) (bottom) pulse sequences with slice selection by gradient Gz shown only on the 90° RF pulse, frequency encoding using Gx, and phase-encoding using Gy. The echoes are labeled. The pre-encode Gx gradient is positive for the SE sequence as it is before the 180° RF pulse but negative for the GRE sequence because there is no 180° RF pulse.
Spin-Echo Pulse Sequence The spin-echo (SE) sequence, shown in Figure 6-5, uses a 180° radiofrequency (RF) pulse centered between the initial 90° RF pulse and the center of the acquisition time period to refocus nuclear spins of variable Larmor frequencies into an echo, producing the MR signal. This minimizes the effect of static H0 inhomogeneities on transverse relaxation that would otherwise reduce the signal intensity. By selecting appropriate timing parameters for the pulse sequence, the MR image can be made selectively sensitive to relaxivity and magnetic susceptibility effects. If significant diffusion through field inhomogeneities occurs during the echo time (TE), signal loss occurs, as discussed in the Appendix. As TE is made longer relative to the diffusional correlation time, the pulse sequence becomes more sensitive to these inhomogeneities. Because susceptibility differences are a source of field nonuniformity, increasing TE increases sensitivity of SE images to processes such as hemorrhage that generate such susceptibility variation. The effect is readily recognized as signal loss on T2-weighted images, which is not present on T1-weighted images. Faster spin-echo imaging has been achieved by expanding the single refocusing 180° RF pulse with a train of refocusing RF pulses in which spatial phase-encoding is performed between each refocusing pulse. Although these pulses can be 180° at lower magnetic fields, high power deposition arises from long trains of such pulses at higher magnetic fields, as described elsewhere (Chapter 18). Typically,
12-04-2010 00:05
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006013
2 of 3
RF pulses of lower flip angles such as 120° are used on 3 tesla scanners to maintain the specific absorption rate (SAR) within the Food and Drug Administration guidelines. The echo times between the refocusing RF pulses are short so that little time is allowed for dephasing. Although this is an advantage for maintaining signal-to-noise performance in the images, sensitivity to magnetic susceptibility effects from different phases of the evolution of hemorrhage is lost. If these effects are to be observed, it is advisable always to use GRE sequences in addition to the faster SE sequences based on long RF pulse trains. An alternative sequence that is very sensitive to magnetic susceptibility effects is echo-planar imaging (EPI) in which a single RF pulse is used in either a gradient-recalled echo or a spin-echo format. The echo-planar image is generated using a rectilinear trajectory through the entire k-space by rapid switching of phase and frequency encoding gradients multiple times, as discussed elsewhere (Chapter 7). Because all of k-space is covered in a single RF pulse or pulse pair, phase errors induced by the magnetic susceptibility effects of the various stages of the evolution of hemorrhage accumulate during the acquisition. The phase cancellation results in reduced signal. As both diffusion-weighted and non-diffusion-weighted spin-echo EPI can be rapidly acquired, the non-diffusion-weighted images can be used for detection of hemorrhage. Similarly, dynamic susceptibility contrast perfusion imaging is usually performed with gradient-echo EPI. The images prior to the arrival of the contrast in the tissue are also sensitive to hemorrhage which produces signal loss. Two other imaging sequences can be used to enhance detection of the susceptibility effects on T2 relaxation. These are the gradient- or field-echo (GRE) and the asymmetric spin-echo (ASE) sequences that have been described in detail elsewhere44,45 (see Fig. 6-5).
Asymmetric Spin-Echo Pulse Sequence The ASE sequence offsets the 180° refocusing pulse by a time interval that can be varied to alter the amount of signal refocusing. This sequence is sensitive not only to the effects of diffusion through magnetic field gradients as used by the SE sequence but also to variations of Larmor frequencies within a single voxel due to nonuniform magnetic susceptibility (Fig. 6-6). This results in rapid loss of phase coherence among the nuclear spins within the voxel and hence rapid signal loss. The amount of signal loss, and thus the sensitivity to intravoxel susceptibility heterogeneity, can be altered by varying the size of the offset. Comparison with ASE and SE images of the same TE allows calculation of T2* and has been suggested as a means of quantifying the iron content of tissue.45 page 178 page 179
12-04-2010 00:05
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006013
3 of 3
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-6 Schematic representation of the effects of nondiamagnetic substances on the intravoxel distribution of susceptibility χ, Heff, and resonance frequency ω. Variation of resonance frequencies within the voxel produces signal loss on GRE images.
This sequence has been adapted to an echo-planar sequence for detection of magnetic susceptibility effects arising from tissue oxygenation changes during neuronal activation in functional MRI.46
Gradient-Echo Pulse Sequence The GRE sequence does not use a 180° refocusing pulse and is thus sensitive to both static magnetic field inhomogeneities (magnet imperfections and tissue susceptibility heterogeneity) and the effects of diffusion.44 Magnet imperfections over the volume of the imaging voxel have become less important with improved magnet technology, allowing detection of tissue susceptibility variations by means of the diffusional effects. Even without diffusion, signal cancellation occurs owing to the range of Larmor frequencies caused by susceptibility variations within a voxel, as is also the case for the ASE sequence. This makes the GRE sequence useful for enhancing detection of susceptibility effects that may be less clearly identified on SE images. The artifacts from unwanted susceptibility effects, such 47 as from the paranasal sinuses on intracranial lesions close to the base of the skull, make the GRE sequence less useful for initial clinical screening examinations.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:05
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006017
FIELD STRENGTH DEPENDENCE The development of clinical 3.0 T scanners since 1993 has increased sensitivity to magnetic susceptibility effects. Just as the susceptibility effects of blood oxygenation level dependent (BOLD) contrast used for functional MRI of the brain are improved at 3.0 T, the detection of hemorrhage and its blood products are also improved. Although computed tomography has been used routinely for detection of blood products in the brain and subarachnoid space, clinical experience indicates that MRI at 3.0 T is more sensitive than CT. Whereas CT attenuation of blood is dependent on increased protein content that is rapidly dispersed, MRI is sensitive to the form of the iron products within the tissues which can persist for many years.20 The detection of blood in the subarachnoid space by MRI using FLAIR sequences is not based on iron products of blood but rather on changes in the T1 relaxation properties of CSF by the constituents of blood. page 179 page 180
Table 6-1. The Influence of Iron Metabolism on the MRI Appearance of Hemorrhage* Relaxation Mechanism Biochemical Form
Stage
MR Signal Intensity†
Location
Magnetic Property
R
χ
T1
II
RBC
Diamag
-
-
Dark
Bright
II
Dark
T2
Oxyhemoglobin
Fe oxyHb
Deoxygenation
Fe deoxyHb
RBC
Paramag
-
+
Dark
RBC lysis + oxidation
FeIII metHb, hemichromes
Extracellular Paramag
+
-
Bright Bright
Extracellular iron processing
FeIII transferrin, Extracellular Paramag lactoferrin
+
-
Bright Bright
Intracellular iron storage
FeIII ferritin, hemosiderin
-
+
Iso
Phagocytes Superpar
Dark
*deoxyHb, deoxyhemoglobin; Diamag, diamagnetic; iso, isointense; oxyHb, oxyhemoglobin; Paramag, paramagnetic; metHb, methemoglobin; RBC, red blood cell; R, relaxivity; χ, susceptibility; Superpar, superparamagnetic;T1,T1 weighted;T2,T2 weighted. †
Signal intensities are estimated relative to cerebral cortex.
The variation of 1/T1 and 1/T2 with magnetic field strength is termed nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion. Because the mathematic treatment of nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion is beyond the 27 scope of this chapter, the interested reader is referred elsewhere for a more formal introduction. Only the observations relevant to hemorrhage are discussed here. At the limit of zero field, 1/T1 = 1/T2. As field strength changes, the efficiency of relaxation is dependent on matching correlation times of local fluctuating magnetic fields generated by diffusional processes to the Larmor frequency. This occurs over a wide range (10-10 to 10-11 second) corresponding to low imaging field strengths, and the effects on T1 and T2 relaxation rates are comparable. In contrast, at higher field strengths, 1/T1 tends toward zero and 1/T2 tends to a nonzero value termed the secular contribution to T2 relaxation. Therefore, higher magnetic field strengths emphasize susceptibility effects. In vitro studies of deoxygenated red blood cells indicate a quadratic dependence of 1/T2 on magnetic field strength over a range of 2 to 5 T.18 The susceptibility effects of ferritin as a function of field strength in vivo have 48 been measured, and less than a quadratic dependence was found. The distribution of the iron aggregates in vivo is not known, and modeling is difficult. Although the theoretic treatment is incomplete for susceptibility effects induced by ferritin and hemosiderin (speculated to be due to antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic properties of these iron aggregates), it is clear that higher
1 of 2
12-04-2010 00:06
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006017
2 of 2
imaging magnetic field strengths increase sensitivity of MR images to susceptibility-induced relaxation mechanisms, regardless of the source of the susceptibility variation.27,28
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:06
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006018
EVALUATION OF HEMORRHAGE WITH MRI
Role of Iron Products The magnetic properties of the iron products of resolving hematoma have been discussed earlier. Although deoxygenated hemoglobin and all the products containing iron in the ferric oxidation state are paramagnetic (methemoglobin, hemichromes, transferrin, lactoferrin, low-molecular-weight iron chelates) or antiferromagnetic (ferritin, hemosiderin), the production of relaxivity effects is dependent on the close approach of water protons to the iron and the production of the susceptibility effects is dependent on the distribution of the iron. The relaxation properties and the imaging characteristics are discussed and summarized in Table 6-1.
Oxyhemoglobin The MR image of the center of an acute hematoma is essentially a collection of protein-rich diamagnetic fluid. Relaxivity and susceptibility effects are not observed for the diamagnetic iron of oxygenated hemoglobin. Image intensity is determined by other dipole-dipole mechanisms as operating in normal surrounding tissue. This means a variably long T1 (isointense to dark on T1-weighted images) and relatively long T2 (bright on T2-weighted images). The change in water content and distribution is clearly evident as areas of long T1 (dark on T1-weighted SE images) and long T2 (bright on T2-weighted SE images) in the areas bordering the hematoma.49 Changes in the protein content within the hematoma also occur as clot formation, clot contraction, and necrosis occur. From in vitro 50 studies, increasing protein concentration would be expected to promote T1 and T2 relaxation rates, although rigorous in vivo studies have not been reported. Exchange of water between bulk phase and protein-bound phases may provide an explanation for small modulations in image intensity.
Deoxygenated Hemoglobin The paramagnetic iron of deoxygenated hemoglobin is held within a hydrophobic cleft. The exclusion of water from close approach to the paramagnetic center prevents relaxivity effects. T1 relaxation is not affected so that the hematoma remains dark on T1-weighted images. The packaging of the paramagnetic centers within the red blood cells produces susceptibility variations that produce transverse relaxation. This explains the loss of signal on T2-weighted SE and GRE images (dark on T2-weighted images). The deoxygenation extends inward over time from the periphery of the hematoma where there is close interdigitation of clot and tissue.
Red Blood Cell Lysis page 180 page 181
Loss of integrity of the red blood cells homogenizes the distribution of paramagnetic iron to minimize the susceptibility variations and reduces transverse relaxation. As the enzyme systems employed within the red blood cell to maintain the ferrous oxidation state of the iron become nonfunctional, methemoglobin and other hemichromes are formed. These proteins allow water access to the paramagnetic iron to induce the relaxivity effects that shorten T1 and to a lesser degree T2. Thus, a hematoma at this stage shows increasing brightness on T1-weighted SE images. Although the concomitant shortening of T2 from relaxivity effects may suggest further loss of brightness on T2-weighted SE and GRE images, the loss of red blood cell integrity removes the paramagnetic aggregation responsible for susceptibility-induced relaxation effects. Because this is the dominant T2 relaxation process, loss of this mechanism means that the effective T2 is still longer than with intact red blood cells. Hence T2-weighted SE and GRE images appear brighter after cell lysis has occurred. This effect extends from the periphery inward to the center of the hematoma.
Extracellular Iron-Binding Proteins The specific relaxivity and susceptibility effects of ferric ions chelated to these proteins described in vitro23-25 remain unknown for resolving in vivo hemorrhage. The concentration of these substances may be too low to have a significant role in determining signal intensity within an MR image.
1 of 2
12-04-2010 00:06
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006018
2 of 2
Intracellular Iron Storage The structure of iron storage proteins such as ferritin excludes water from close approach to most of the paramagnetic ferric ions, minimizing relaxivity effects. The antiferromagnetic properties of these crystalline aggregates of ferric oxyhydroxide induce susceptibility variations from surrounding tissue. The implications for imaging of old resolving hematomas are that T1-weighted MR images show isointensity with surrounding tissue owing to the absence of relaxivity effects and that T2-weighted and GRE images show signal loss owing to susceptibility effects. If the T2 is significantly shortened below the TE used for T1-weighted images, then the susceptibility effect is observed on these images. This is not a relaxivity effect. Rather, the term T1 weighted is inappropriate under these conditions. This assumes that cavitation has not occurred. If a cavity develops in the region of tissue loss, then the signal characteristics of cerebrospinal fluid that fills the cavity dominate the image.
Images of Evolving Cerebral Hematoma The best controlled longitudinal study of resolving intraparenchymal hematoma was reported for an experimental model of hemorrhage in the monkey in which venous blood was injected into the right cerebral hemisphere and followed by MRI for several months.49 Selected images from this study are reproduced with permission for discussion. At 2 hours after injection of blood (Fig. 6-7A and B), the acute hematoma has low signal intensity on the T1-weighted and high signal intensity on the T2-weighted images relative to normal cortex. This is consistent with the absence of significant relaxivity and susceptibility relaxation mechanisms in the acute setting. Although the injection used venous blood, marked susceptibility effects are not observed, suggesting that greater deoxygenation is required. The T1-weighted image shows greater signal loss in the periphery consistent with edema in surrounding tissue having slightly different relaxation phenomena from the center of the hematoma. During the next 2 days (Fig. 6-7C and D), the signal intensity of the center of the hematoma on the T1-weighted image increases, presumably from the relaxivity mechanism of methemoglobin, hemichromes, and other paramagnetic centers, allowing close approach of water protons. The signal intensity from the surrounding edematous zone shows little change. In contrast, the same area of hematoma on the T2-weighted image displays decreased signal intensity, presumably from susceptibility-induced relaxation mechanisms as the intact red blood cells become increasingly deoxygenated and from any intracellular methemoglobin that may form as the energy status of the cells declines. It is not clear whether the methemoglobin and hemichromes form intracellularly or that the hematoma is a mixture of intact deoxygenated cells suspended within a solution of hemoglobin degradation products. Over 6 to 10 days (Fig. 6-7E to H), the T1-weighted images show increasing signal intensity due to relaxivity effects from increasing concentrations of hemoglobin degradation products. The T2-weighted images show increasing signal intensity when susceptibility effects diminish as red blood cell integrity is lost within the hematoma. The edematous periphery of the lesion shows minimal changes during this time interval. After 2 months (Fig. 6-7I and J), the T1-weighted image shows little evidence of the lesion, whereas an area of decreased signal intensity remains on the T2-weighted image. This can be attributed to the susceptibility-induced relaxation mechanism of the iron storage products.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:06
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006026
1 of 4
CONCLUSION The basis of the highly variable MRI appearance of resolving intraparenchymal cerebral hematoma reported clinically can be rationalized largely in terms of a model encompassing current concepts of iron metabolism and integrity of the blood-brain barrier. The time scale is dependent on the size of the lesion, its location with respect to both vascular supply and white and gray matter, and the physiologic status of the patient. The model should be regarded as a working hypothesis. The delineation of the in vivo biochemistry of iron metabolism and water balance remains to be performed. It is unlikely that descriptive analysis of the MRI appearance of cerebral hemorrhage can be verified with biochemical studies in patients, making animal models a necessary vehicle for further detailed studies. page 181 page 182
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:07
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006026
2 of 4
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:07
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006026
3 of 4
Add to lightbox page 182 page 183
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:07
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006026
4 of 4
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 6-7 Longitudinal study, using inversion recovery (T1-weighted) SE (A, C, E, G, and I) and T2-weighted SE coronal images (B, D, F, H, and J) of a monkey after injection of 3 mL of venous blood into the right cerebral hemisphere. Images were selected at 2 hours (A and B), 2 days (C and D), 6 days (E and F). 10 days (G and H), and 2 months (I) and (J) from a more complete study. (A to J from Di Chiro G, Brooks RA, Girton ME, et al: Sequential MR studies of intracerebral hematomas in monkeys. AJNR 7:193-199, 1986 © by American Society of Neuroradiology 1986.)
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:07
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006027
APPENDIX Magnetic Properties of Biologic Tissues
Origin of Magnetic Properties A magnetic field is generated by a moving electric charge, that is, an electric charge with momentum.51 The strength of the magnetic field is determined by the magnitude of both the charge and momentum. Such a charge with a magnetic field is termed a magnetic dipole. Electrons moving in orbitals about a nucleus represent moving charges with both orbital angular momentum and spin angular momentum and generate a magnetic field. The nucleus also has momentum and charge. However, because the magnetic moment of the charged particle is inversely proportional to its mass, and the mass of the nucleus is three orders of magnitude greater than that of the electron, the contribution of the nucleus to the magnetic properties of the atom is much less than that of the electrons. Hence, although nuclear magnetic interactions occur and nuclear magnetization is the source of the signal in the MR image, the magnetic properties of tissue are determined predominantly by the electronic configuration of the atoms and molecules. The dominant effects encountered on MR images are discussed below.
Diamagnetism Most biologic materials consist of low-atomic-weight elements such as carbon and hydrogen in which the electrons are paired in atomic and molecular suborbitals. When the electrons are paired, the spin angular momentum is canceled and no magnetic dipole is observed. However, the paired electrons still have orbital angular momentum that produces a magnetic field (termed a Lenz field) opposing the applied magnetic field. The resultant field within such a material is less than that of the original applied magnetic field. Such materials are termed diamagnetic. page 183 page 184
Paramagnetism Some biologic substances have atomic or molecular structures in which some of the electrons are unpaired. Transition metal ions, such as iron with the ferrous and ferric oxidation states, are important examples in which the number of unpaired electrons varies with the biochemical state of the metal ion. An unpaired electron has a spin angular momentum and therefore a magnetic moment that is not canceled as in the paired state. At physiologic temperatures, more electrons align parallel to the applied field, resulting in an enhancement of that applied field. Materials that have no magnetic field in the absence of an applied magnetic field but that respond to enhance an applied magnetic field are termed paramagnetic. Examples of paramagnetic substances include gadolinium, used as an MRI contrast agent, and ferrous and ferric iron. On T1-weighted images, uniform distributions of such species produce increased signal intensity. However, nonuniform distributions of such species alter the MR image by producing a range of effective magnetic fields within the sample and therefore a range of resonance frequencies of the MR signal. Depending on the type of imaging pulse sequence used, the frequency dispersion can be manipulated to decrease signal in the area of the paramagnetic species (see Sensitivities of MRI Pulse Sequences).
Other Forms of Magnetism There are other biologically important closely packed ensembles of atoms, such as crystalline structures, in which unpaired electrons of neighboring atoms interact to minimize the magnetic forces outside the material in the absence of an applied magnetic field. The magnetic forces producing preferred patterns of spin alignments to reach magnetic equilibrium are termed exchange forces.
Antiferromagnetism (Individual Opposition) If unpaired electrons of neighboring atoms interact to align with opposing spins, the magnetic forces are minimized. In an applied magnetic field, spin pairing must be disrupted for realignment. Thus, the response to the applied field is less than that of a paramagnetic substance, but the effective field is still enhanced. Such materials are termed antiferromagnetic. The alignment pattern can be disrupted if the thermal energy is increased, and initially the response to an applied field is enhanced as the
1 of 5
12-04-2010 00:08
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006027
temperature is increased. Above a critical temperature, known as the Neel temperature, adjacent spin pairing is disrupted and the substance becomes paramagnetic. The effects of antiferromagnetic substances on MR images are similar to those of paramagnetic substances although reduced in magnitude and with different temperature dependence.
Ferromagnetism (Group Opposition) If the unpaired electrons of a group of atoms can align in domains, each domain has a net magnetic field. Adjacent domains can then interact by means of these magnetic fields to minimize, although not completely cancel, the field outside the material. If that material is immersed in a high magnetic field, domains respond to both the applied field and neighboring domain fields to markedly enhance the field. Such materials show a magnetic field in the absence of an applied magnetic field and are termed ferromagnetic. The effect of such substances on the MR image is of greater magnitude than that of paramagnetic substances. If a ferromagnetic crystal is reduced in size to that of a single domain, this single-domain particle has a net magnetic dipole equivalent to that of a domain. If a collection of such particles is free to rotate in an applied magnetic field on a time scale that is shorter than the observation time, the magnetic dipoles behave as expected for paramagnetism discussed previously. However, the larger magnetic moments of the particles produce a greater enhancement of the applied magnetic field. Such particles are termed superparamagnetic.52,53 If the size of the particles, usually containing many domains, is reduced below the size of a single domain, the aligning exchange forces and misaligning thermal forces become comparable. If the time scale of the observation is longer than the switching rate of the equilibrium between the aligned and disordered states, then the magnetic properties of the particles are dependent on the temperaturevolume relationships that determine the switching frequency. An aggregate of such particles behaves paramagnetically but with a greater magnetic dipole than if no domain formed at all and thus is termed 51 supermagnetic. Thus, the effects of superparamagnetic and supermagnetic substances on the MR image are similar to those of paramagnetic substances but of a magnitude between that of paramagnetic and ferromagnetic species.
Magnetic Susceptibility Because all biologic materials have at least one of the previously discussed magnetic properties, they interact with a static magnetic field, H0, to produce a magnetization, m, that reduces (diamagnetism) or enhances (paramagnetism, antiferromagnetism, ferromagnetism) the effective magnetic field, Heff, established within the material. Note that m in this sense is usually referring to the effects of electronic configurations, not nuclear magnetization M. This effect can be expressed in terms of the magnetic susceptibility χ of the material in which where χ = m/H0. Thus, χ < 0 for diamagnetic materials, χ > 0 for paramagnetic materials, and χ = 0 for a vacuum. page 184 page 185
When placed in a static magnetic field of the imaging magnet, tissues of different magnetic susceptibility establish different effective magnetic fields experienced by the nucleus under observation. Thus, the response of the nuclear magnetization generated in the MRI study is altered with resultant changes in the image. Susceptibility-induced field variations within a voxel broaden the Larmor frequency range (see Fig. 6-6). SE imaging minimizes this effect by using a 180° RF pulse to refocus the dispersion that occurs in the transverse magnetization Mxy, during the pulse sequence. If significant molecular diffusion occurs during TE (time from initial 90° RF pulse to formation of the echo) through regions of variable Heff, due to either magnet imperfections or susceptibility variations in the tissue, incomplete refocusing results in loss of transverse magnetization and thus signal loss in the MR image. The effect becomes more apparent as the TE exceeds the diffusional correlation time (time taken for a proton to move from one position to the next position). Spins diffusing in the x-y plane experience these
2 of 5
12-04-2010 00:08
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006027
3 of 5
variations in Heff as a fluctuating magnetic field hz, with resultant transverse but not longitudinal 34-36 relaxation. This effect is well known in MR spectroscopy, in which a known magnetic field gradient (G) can be applied to a sample to measure the diffusion coefficient (D) of protons through a solvent. The signal intensity (S) for a Hahn spin-echo at TE is given as Hence, differences in susceptibility at the boundary of a hematoma containing paramagnetic blood products and surrounding normal diamagnetic tissue produce T2 relaxation if sufficient diffusion is permitted to occur during the imaging sequence. Such effects cause signal loss at these boundaries on T2-weighted MR images of sufficiently long TE without corresponding signal loss on T1-weighted images.
Relaxivity The relative rotational and translational motions of water molecules and paramagnetic entities in biologic systems occur on a time scale that produces an apparent isotropically fluctuating magnetic field in the range of the Larmor frequencies for protons at current imaging field strengths. If the water molecules are able to approach the paramagnetic center, then magnetic interactions allow efficient energy exchange to occur and the magnetically perturbed water proton spin system can relax to its equilibrium state.54 The phenomenologic equation for intermolecular relaxation interactions of a paramagnetic agent (P) in bulk solution is where i = 1, 2; R is the relaxivity constant (mM/s); and [P] is the concentration (mM) of the paramagnetic substance P. (1/T)d is the rate attributable to diamagnetic relaxation processes and (1/T)p is the relaxation rate in the presence of P. In the presence of a suitable paramagnetic substance, the paramagnetic term dominates over the diamagnetic term of Equation 6-3. The same equation applies for both longitudinal and transverse relaxation. Because T1 is generally longer than T2, 1/T1 is smaller than 1/T2, and so the constant term R[P] contributes a greater proportion to the longitudinal relaxation rate (1/T1) than transverse relaxation rate (1/T2). The implication for MRI is that the relaxivity effects of paramagnetic substances are detected with greater sensitivity on T1-weighted images than on T2-weighted images. The paramagnetic relaxation rate can be further analyzed mechanistically as inner sphere (ligand exchange in which water molecules are in the first coordination sphere of P) and outer sphere (diffusion with close approach of water near to but without coordination to P) contributions, but it is not the purpose of this review to describe the more mechanistic SolomonBloembergen equations that are presented in detail elsewhere.54 Application of Equation 6-3 in biologic systems as complex as cerebral hematomas can only be approximate because of the heterogeneity in type and distribution of the various paramagnetic substances involved. When water is unable to approach the paramagnetic center, no magnetic interaction and therefore no relaxation occurs by relaxivity mechanisms (see Fig. 6-3). However, susceptibility effects can still be manifested so that, whereas T1 is unaffected, T2 is shortened and the MR signal is decreased. REFERENCES 1. Sipponen JT, Sepponen RE, Sivula A: Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) imaging of intracranial hemorrhage in the acute and resolving phases. J Comput Assist Tomogr 7:954-959, 1983. Medline Similar articles 2. DeLaPaz RL, New PFJ, Buonanno FS, et al: NMR imaging of intracranial hemorrhage. J Comput Assist Tomogr 8:599-607, 1984. Medline Similar articles 3. Gomori JM, Grossman RI, Goldberg HI, et al: Intracranial hematomas: imaging by high-field MR. Radiology 157:87-93, 1985. Medline Similar articles 4. Gomori JM, Grossman RI: Head and neck hemorrhage. In Kressel HY (ed.): Magnetic Resonance Annual 1987. New York: Raven Press, 1987, pp 71-112. 5. Gomori JM, Grossman RI, Hackney DB, et al: Variable appearances of subacute intracranial hematomas on high-field spin-echo MR. Am J Neuroradiol 8:1019-1026, 1987. 6. Zimmerman RD, Heier LA, Snow RB, et al: Acute intracranial hemorrhage: intensity changes on sequential MR scans at 0.5 T. Am J Neuroradiol 9:47-57, 1988. 7. New PFJ, Scott WR: Blood. In New PFJ, Scott WR (eds): Computed Tomography of the Brain and Orbit (EMI Scanning). Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1975, pp 263-267.
12-04-2010 00:08
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006027
4 of 5
8. Enzmann DR, Britt RH, Lyons BE, et al: Natural history of experimental intracerebral hemorrhage: sonography, computed tomography and neuropathology. Am J Neuroradiol 2:517-526, 1981. Medline Similar articles 9. Kreindler A, Marcovici G, Florescu I: Histoenzymologic and biochemical investigations into the nervous tissue round an experimentally-induced cerebral hemorrhagic focus. Rev Roum Neurol 9:313-319, 1972. Medline Similar articles 10. Lalonde JMA, Ghadially FN, Massey KL: Ultrastructure of intramuscular haematomas and electron-probe X-ray analysis of extracellular and intracellular iron deposits. J Pathol 125:17-23, 1978. Medline Similar articles 11. Finch CA, Huebers HA: Iron metabolism. Clin Physiol Biochem 4:5-10, 1986. Medline
Similar articles
12. Trump BF, Valigorsky JM, Arstila AU, et al: The relationship of intracellular pathways of iron metabolism to cellular iron overload and the iron storage diseases. Am J Pathol 72:295-324, 1973. Medline Similar articles 13. Weinberg ED: Iron, infection and neoplasia. Clin Physiol Biochem 4:50-60, 1986. Medline
Similar articles
14. Southern PA, Powis G: Free radicals in medicine. I. Chemical nature and biologic reactions. II. Involvement in human disease. Mayo Clin Proc 63:390-408, 1988. Medline Similar articles 15. Munro HN, Linder MC: Ferritin: structure, biosynthesis and role in iron metabolism. Physiol Rev 58:317-396, 1978. Medline Similar articles 16. Wixon RL, Prutkin L, Munro HN: Hemosiderin: nature, formation and significance. Int Rev Exp Pathol 22:193-225, 1980. Medline Similar articles 17. Bunn HF, Forget BG (eds): Hemoglobin: Molecular, Genetic and Clinical Aspects. Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 1986, pp 13-35, 634-662. 18. Thulborn KR, Wateron JC, Matthews PM, Radda GK: Oxygenation dependence of the transverse relaxation time of water protons in whole blood at high field. Biochim Biophys Acta 714:265-270, 1982. Medline Similar articles 19. Brindle KM, Brown FF, Campbell ID, et al: Application of spin-echo nuclear magnetic resonance to whole cell systems: membrane transport. Biochem J 180:37-44, 1979. Medline Similar articles page 185 page 186
20. Atlas SW, Thulborn KR: MRI Detection of hyperacute parenchymal hemorrhage of the brain. Am J Neuroradiol 19:1471-1497, 1998. Medline Similar articles 21. Koenig SH, Brown RD, Lindstrom TR: Interactions of solvent with the heme region of methemoglobin and fluoromethemoglobin. Biophys J 34:397-408, 1981. Medline Similar articles 22. Blumberg WE: The study of hemoglobin by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. Methods Enzymol 76:312-329, 1981. Medline Similar articles 23. Windle JJ, Weirsema AK, Clarke JR, Feeney RE: Investigation of the iron and copper complexes of avian conalbumins and human transferrins by electron paramagnetic resonance. Biochemistry 2:1341-1345, 1963. Medline Similar articles 24. Aasa R, Aisen P: An electron paramagnetic resonance study of the iron and copper complexes of transferrin. J Biol Chem 243:2399-2404, 1968. Medline Similar articles 25. Koenig SH, Schillinger WE: Nuclear magnetic relaxation dispersion in protein solutions. II. Transferrin. J Biol Chem 244:6520-6526, 1969. Medline Similar articles 26. Harrison PM, Fischbach FA, Hoy TG, Haggis GH: Ferric oxyhydroxide core of ferritin. Nature 216:1188-1190, 1967. Medline Similar articles 27. Koenig SH, Brown RD: Relaxometry of magnetic resonance imaging contrast agents. In Kressel HY (ed.): Magnetic Resonance Annual 1987. New York: Raven Press, 1987, pp 263-286. 28. Gillis P, Koenig SH: Transverse relaxation of solvent protons induced by magnetized spheres: application to ferritin, erythrocytes and magnetite. Magn Reson Med 5:323-345, 1987. Medline Similar articles 29. Weir MP, Peters TJ, Gibson JF: Electron spin resonance studies of splenic ferritin and haemosiderin. Biochim Biophys Acta 828:298-305, 1985. Medline Similar articles 30. Boas JF, Troup GJ: Electron spin resonance and Mossbauer effect studies of ferritin. Biochim Biophys Acta 229:68-74, 1971. Medline Similar articles 31. Darrow YC, Alvord EC, Hodson WA: Histological evolution of the reactions to hemorrhage in the premature human infant's brain: a combined autopsy study and a comparison with the reaction in adults. Am J Pathol 130:44-58, 1988. Medline Similar articles 32. Cohen MD, McGuire W, Cory DA, Smith JA: MR appearance of blood and blood products: an in vitro study. Am J Roentgenol 146:1293-1297, 1986. 33. Hayman LA, Ford JJ, Taber KH, et al: T2 effect of hemoglobin concentration: assessment with in vitro spectroscopy. Radiology 168:489-491, 1988. Medline Similar articles 34. Abragam A: Principles of Nuclear Magnetism. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1985. 35. Becker ED: High Resolution NMR. Theory and Chemical Applications. New York: Academic Press, 1980. 36. Farrar TC, Becker ED: Pulse and Fourier Transform NMR. New York: Academic Press, 1971, pp 2-15. 37. Fukushima E, Roeder SBW: Experimental Pulse NMR. A Nuts and Bolts Approach. London: Addison-Wesley Publishing, 1981, pp 1-125.
12-04-2010 00:08
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC006027
5 of 5
38. Yoder CH, Schaeffer CD Jr: Introduction to Multinuclear NMR. Menlo Park, CA: Benjamin/Cummings Publishing, 1987. 39. Fullerton GD: Basic concepts for nuclear magnetic resonance imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 1:39-53, 1982. Medline Similar articles 40. Bottomley PA: NMR imaging techniques and applications. Rev Sci Instrum 53:1319-1337, 1982. Medline Similar articles 41. Brant-Zawadzki M, Norman D: Magnetic Resonance Imaging of the Central Nervous System. New York: Raven Press, 1987. 42. Pykett IL, Newhouse JH, Buonanno FS, et al: Principles of nuclear magnetic resonance imaging. Radiology 143:157-168, 1982. Medline Similar articles 43. Wehrli FW: Principles of magnetic resonance. In Stark DD, Bradley WG (eds): Magnetic Resonance Imaging. St. Louis: CV Mosby, 1988, pp 1-23. 44. Edelman RR, Buxton RB, Brady TJ: Rapid MR imaging. In Kressel HY (ed.): Magnetic Resonance Annual 1988. New York: Raven Press, 1988, pp 189-216. 45. Wismer GL, Buxton RB, Rosen BR, et al: Susceptibility induced magnetic resonance line broadening: applications to brain iron mapping. J Comput Assist Tomogr 12:259-265, 1988. Medline Similar articles 46. Hoppel BE, Weisskoff RM, Thulborn KR, et al: Measurement of regional blood oxygenation and cerebral hemodynamics. Magn Reson Med 30:715-723, 1993. Medline Similar articles 47. Ludeke KM, Roschmann P, Tischler R: Susceptibility artefacts in NMR imaging. Magn Reson Imaging 3:329-343, 1985. Medline Similar articles 48. Schenck JF, Mueller OM, Souza SP, Dumoulin CL: Magnetic resonance imaging of brain iron using a 4 Tesla whole-body scanner. In Frankel RB, Blakemore RP (eds): Iron Biominerals. New York: Plenum Publishing, 1990, pp 373-385. 49. Di Chiro G, Brooks RA, Girton ME, et al: Sequential MR studies of intracerebral hematomas in monkeys. Am J Neuroradiol 7:193-199, 1986. Medline Similar articles 50. Kamman RL, Go KG, Brouwer W, Berendsen HJC: Nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation in experimental brain edema: effects of water concentration, protein concentration and temperature. Magn Reson Med 6:265-274, 1988. Medline Similar articles 51. Burke HE: Handbook of Magnetic Phenomena. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1986, pp 9-57. 52. Bean CP, Livingston JD: Superparamagnetism. J Appl Phys 30:120S-129S, 1959. 53. Bean CP: Hysteresis loops of mixtures of ferromagnetic micropowders. J Appl Phys 26:1381-1383, 1955. 54. Lauffer RB: Paramagnetic metal complexes as water proton relaxation agents for NMR imaging: theory and design. Chem Rev 87:901-927, 1987.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:08
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio...http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=C00703068
1 of 1
DVANCED MAGING
ECHNIQUES NCLUDING
AST
MAGING Timothy J. Carroll Ken E. Sakaie Piotr A. Wielopolski Robert R. Edelman In the continuing efforts to improve the diagnostic capability of MRI, a number of fast imaging, novel magnetization preparation, and data acquisition strategies have been introduced. Each of the methods discussed here provides new information in terms of image contrast, quality, or time resolution. Because of their clinical relevance, fast imaging techniques will be considered first (exclusive of parallel imaging methods that are reviewed in Chapter 8, Parallel Imaging Techniques). The discussion of magnetization preparation begins with fat-suppression methods, which reduce undesirably bright adipose signal that can exacerbate artifact and reduce contrast. Magnetization transfer, spin lock imaging, and zero quantum coherence imaging provide types of contrast distinct from the standard forms; the methods may prove particularly valuable in differentiating between tissue in which the concentration of proteins and other macromolecules correlates with function. Electric current imaging uses applied or intrinsic currents to provide contrast and may provide insights into the function and viability of certain tissue. Imaging of intrinsic currents among clusters of neurons may provide a new way to detect functional activation of the brain. Changing the manner of data acquisition can have a large impact on image quality. Non-Cartesian trajectories in k-space-namely projection reconstruction and spiral imaging-provide certain advantages, particularly in fast imaging. The oversampling of the center of k-space inherent to the non-Cartesian acquisitions makes these approaches less susceptible to artifact in the presence of motion even for high resolution scans. Time-resolved imaging takes fast imaging a step further, allowing time resolution of dynamic changes and has proven particularly useful in MR angiography. Motion correction techniques, on the other hand, aim to eliminate the effects of dynamic changes on the image, resulting in higher image quality.
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:08
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
1 of 23
PULSE SEQUENCES FOR FAST IMAGING page 187 page 188
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-1 Time line showing the different time frames of certain body functions.
Along with the expansion of clinical applications has come a heightened appreciation of the problems posed by respiratory and cardiac motion and the need for fast imaging to overcome these artifacts and to provide the speed needed for functional imaging studies (Fig. 7-1). Although standard spin-echo (SE) pulse sequences are well validated, they lack the flexibility to address these problems. Fortunately, solutions now exist in the area of fast MRI techniques. It is now possible, for instance, to eliminate artifacts from respiratory motion by use of subsecond imaging methods such as turbo fast low-angle shot (turbo FLASH); cardiac motion can be tamed by use of balanced steady-state free precession (SSFP) sequences such as true FISP or FIESTA in conjunction with cardiac gating. In addition, fast MRI methods can produce images with useful types of tissue contrast and improved spatial resolution, completely aside from the ability to reduce scan times. Practical aspects of imaging techniques, including a basic explanation of fast imaging methods, are presented in Chapter 3, Practical Considerations and Image Optimization. In this section, fast MRI methods are reviewed in greater depth with consideration of technical issues as well as illustration of typical clinical applications. These methods, summarized in Table 7-1, can greatly improve the image quality and breadth of applications of MRI.
Fast Spin-Echo Imaging Methods Though largely supplanted by fast SE, standard SE pulse sequences are still commonly used, particularly for T1-weighted acquisitions (e.g., brain, spine). The single-echo SE sequence consists of a pair of RF pulses and can be represented as: where the echo time (TE) defines the center of the SE signal. For each excitation, the number of times the sequence is repeated is determined by the spatial resolution (specifically the number of pixels) along the phaseencoding axis and is equal to the number of phase-encoding steps. A high level of spatial resolution requires a correspondingly large number of phase-encoding steps. The first RF pulse in the SE sequence, used to excite the spins, is set to 90° to tip the existing longitudinal magnetization completely into the transverse plane. This maximizes the amount of signal that can be obtained per measurement. However, immediately after the 90° pulse, the remaining longitudinal magnetization is zero. If the spins were again excited at this time, no signal would be produced. The next 90° pulse produces a signal proportional to the accumulated magnetization, as expressed by: where S0 is the signal that would be produced by a 90° pulse when the spins are fully aligned with the magnetic field. The signal (S) depends on the amount of T1 relaxation that occurs during the interval TR. To maintain a sufficient degree of tissue contrast and SNR, the TR cannot be made much shorter than approximately 300 to 400 msec. This limitation essentially precludes a conventional SE sequence from being used for fast imaging, the reason being that scan time is proportional to TR, as given by the following equation: where Ny is the number of phase-encoded lines, NEX is the number of excitations (also called Naq, for number of acquisitions). Each 180° pulse in a conventional SE sequence refocuses the MR signal at a time interval TE/2 after the center of the pulse. At the center of the SE, the effects of static magnetic field inhomogeneities (like those occurring at air-soft-tissue interfaces) are eliminated.1 Additional 180° pulses may be applied to generate additional spin-echoes; each echo is used to create a single image. Much faster imaging is possible with fast SE techniques.
2,3
Fast SE (also called turbo SE) is an optimized version of
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
2 of 23
4,5
rapid acquisition relaxation enhancement (RARE). It is a multi-echo SE sequence in which each SE signal is separately phase encoded, rather than being used to produce a separate image. Like SE, fast SE has the advantage over GRE that it uses 180° pulses to eliminate susceptibility artifacts. Multislice 2D fast SE acquisitions can be completed within a period of a few tens of seconds to a few minutes. Thin-section T2-weighted 3D scans, not practical with conventional SE, can be acquired using fast SE in 10 minutes or less. Drawbacks of fast SE include increased RF deposition and magnetization transfer effects arising from the application of multiple 180° pulses, increased signal intensity of fat, and blurring artifacts particularly at short TE. Depending on the sequence implementation and choice of imaging parameters, some lesions may not be seen as well with fast SE as with conventional SE techniques. In spite of these limitations, fast SE has largely replaced conventional SE in most organ systems. The scan time for a fast SE sequence is given by: where ETL is echo train length (also called turbo factor). The ETL (1 for standard SE, 3 to 256 for fast SE) is the number of echoes that are phase encoded after each 90° RF excitation. For instance, if eight echoes are acquired (ETL = 8), the scan time is reduced by a factor of 8. A large ETL provides the greatest reduction in scan time, but, beyond a factor of 16 or so, blurring artifacts may become objectionable for some tissues. The blurring is attributable to T2-dependent signal loss that occurs over the duration of the echo train. page 188 page 189
Table 7-1. Examples of Fast Imaging Techniques Technique
Typical scan times Contrast Uses/limitations
Pulse sequences Fast spin-echo (e.g., Fast SE, Turbo SE)
1-10 min
T1, PD,T2
Standard acquisition method for T2-, PD-, and, to a lesser extent, T1-weighted images; high RF power deposition, MTC effects
Fast-recovery fast spin-echo
20 sec-10 min
PD,T2
Driven equilibrium fast spin-echo, improved T2 contrast for given TR; reduced breath-hold times for abdominal MRI
Single shot fast spin-echo (e.g., SSFSE, HASTE)
200 msec-2.5 T2 sec
Motion insensitive; useful for MRCP and MR urography; suffers from image blurring at short TE
Hyperechoes, TRAPS
1-10 min
T2
Modification of fast SE; useful for 3T since less RF power deposition; longer TE for similar fast SE contrast; fewer MTC effects
GRASE
30 sec-10 min
PD,T2
Reduced RF power deposition; ghosting artifacts with poor fat suppression; high resolution for brain scans
Incoherent gradient-echo (e.g., FLASH, SPGR)
200 msec-30 PD,T1 sec
Standard acquisition method for MRA, T1-weighted breath-hold abdominal MRI
Steady-state coherent gradient-echo (e.g. GRASS, FISP, FSE)
200 msec-30 T1/T2 sec
Generally not used; sensitive to fluid motion
Cardiac cine, rapid scout imaging if single shot, bright blood; velocity insensitive; RF intensive, B0 sensitive; shortest TR possible 200 msec-16 Balanced gradient sec waveform (e.g., SSFP, Fiesta, True FISP, Balance FSE) Magnetization-prepared gradient-echo(e.g. turbo FLASH, MP-RAGE)
2D: 1-3 sec T1 3D: 2-10 min T1,T2
Test bolus for contrast-enhanced MRA, motioninsensitive T1-weighted breath-hold abdominal MRI; more blurring than standard GRE 3D scans with flexible contrast (T1 or T2)
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
3 of 23
Single-shot EPI
50-200 msec T2*,T2
Perfusion/diffusion/BOLD MRI of brain
BURST
<1 sec
Quiet scanning for fMRI; low image quality
T2
k-space sampling methods to reduce scan time Partial Fourier
Reduced by factor of 0.5-0.75
-
Shorten scan time for SE; fast SE; balanced SSFP; contrast-enhanced MRA
Keyhole
-
-
Shorten scan time for contrast-enhanced MRI
Parallel imaging
Reduced by factorof 2-8
-
Shorter scan time requires appropriate phased array coil; ghosting artifacts if inaccurate coil map or inappropriate coil configuration
TRICKS
Reduction 3-4 T1
Shorter scan time for CE-MRA
Special k-space sampling patterns Spiral
-
-
Effective coverage of k-space; good flow properties; sensitive to B0 inhomogeneities and gradientimperfections
Radial (projectionreconstructions)
-
-
Can be used with variety of pulse sequences; motion correction (PROPELLER); reduced motion sensitivity; reduced scan time if undersampling used
VIPR
5-30 sec
T1
Undersampled 3D radial scan for multiphase contrast-enhanced 3D MRA and phase-contrast MRA; requires high vessel-to-background contrast page 189 page 190
BOLD, blood oxygen level dependent contrast; EPI, echo-planar imaging; FISP, fast imaging with steady-state precession; FLASH, fast low-angle shot; GRASE, gradient and spin-echo; GRASS, gradient-recalled acquisition in the steady state; HASTE, half-Fourier single-shot turbo spin-echo; MP-RAGE, magnetization prepared rapid gradient-echo; MRA, magnetic resonance angiography; MRCP, magnetic resonance cholangiopancreaticography; MTC, magnetization transfer contrast; PD, proton density weighted; PROPELLER, periodically rotated overlapping parallel lines with enhanced reconstruction; RF, radiofrequency; SE, spin-echo; SPGR, spoiled gradient recalled; SSFP, steady-state free precession; SSFSE, single-shot fast spin-echo; TE, echo time; TR, repetition time; TRAPS, transition between pseudo steady states; TRICKS, time-resolved imaging of contrast kinetics; VIPR, vastly undersampled isotropic projection reconstruction.
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-2 Edge enhancement on fast SE images. Left, Axial proton density-weighted fast spin-echo (SE) image (4500/22) shows artifactual bright line (arrowhead) around the dark nerve roots. Right, Artifact is less obvious on T2-weighted fast SE image (4500/85). The edge enhancement effect improves the conspicuity of the nerve roots.
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
4 of 23
The echo train spacing (ETS) is also important. Typical ETS is on the order of 4 to 12 msec. With shorter spacing, the duration of the echo train is reduced, thereby minimizing the amount of blurring. Sensitivity to magnetic susceptibility artifact (e.g., from a hip prosthesis) is greatly reduced. The signal intensity from fat tends to increase as the ETS is decreased. It is possible to acquire as many as 80 or more echoes in less than 0.5 s. In conjunction with half-Fourier, one can use this technique called HASTE (half-Fourier single-shot turbo spin-echo). HASTE images provide good depiction of fluids, but other tissues with shorter T2 values tend to show some blurring artifacts. For making thick-slab projection images of fluids such as bile (e.g. MR cholangiography, MR urography, MR myoelography), the single-shot fast SE sequence is acquired with a TE in the order of 1 second and no half-Fourier. Typical ETL is then in the order of 256.
Nominal Echo Time As mentioned earlier, image contrast depends on the characteristics of the MR signals acquired during the central phase-encoding lines. The central lines are selected simply by setting the amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient to low values; this can be done for any of the echoes in the fast SE echo train, although the order must be appropriate to avoid artifacts. The timing of the central phase-encoding lines determines the nominal TE. If the central lines are timed to occur late, allowing T2 decay of the echo, the image appears T2 weighted; if it is timed to occur early, the image appears proton density weighted (or T1 weighted if the TR is short). One can split the echo train, for instance, to acquire proton density- and T2-weighted images simultaneously. However, the reduction in scan time is less than it would be for a single echo acquisition. For faster scanning using a dual-echo acquisition, an echo-sharing technique can be used. 6 Two images with different effective TE values are acquired using the same high-frequency data. The central (low-frequency) lines are acquired twice at different TE as part of the same echo train.
Phase-Encode Order Because the MR signal strength decreases with each successive echo as a result of T2 decay, the image appearance is dramatically altered with changes in the phase-encoding order. The T2-modulated time-dependent decrease in signal intensity acts as a filter of high spatial frequencies, causing blurring. Phase-encoding order is a critical determinant of image quality with fast SE sequences.7-9 The phase-encoding order must be such that abrupt discontinuities in the signal intensity from line to line as well as gradient-induced eddy current effects are minimized. Discontinuities can cause blurring and ghost artifacts. The amount of blurring with fast SE imaging depends on the T2 of the tissue, because signal loss occurs over the duration of the echo train as a result of T2 relaxation. For instance, T2 decay over the echo train is worse for white matter than for cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Thus, one could use a much longer echo train in conjunction with a single-shot fast SE acquisition if a fluid is the tissue of interest than for imaging of white matter lesions. Paradoxically, in addition to blurring, there can be an edge enhancement effect that in some circumstances improves depiction of normal anatomy or lesion detection.10 For instance, blurring is minimal for CSF because of its long T2. On the other hand, nerve roots are blurred because of their shorter T2. The net effect is that the interface between nerve root and CSF is enhanced, thereby increasing the conspicuity of the root; however, there can be artifactually low signal intensity within the root (Fig. 7-2). page 190 page 191
For a given ETL, blurring is less for a short ETS than for a long one. 11 The drawbacks of short ETS are a reduced SNR because the readout bandwidth must be increased (assuming that gradient ramp times are already minimized), brighter fat signal, lower conspicuity of hemorrhagic lesions, and higher power deposition resulting from the use of a shorter RF pulse.
Three-Dimensional Fast Spin-Echo Although 3D imaging with conventional SE sequences is impractical because of the long scan times, 3D fast SE is 12 feasible with scan times less than 10 minutes. The sequence is similar to 2D fast SE but incorporates an extra phase-encoding step in the slice-select direction. Multiple 3D volumes spanning the region of interest are acquired within each TR interval. Compared with 2D fast SE imaging, thinner sections can be obtained and multiplanar reformations can be done.
Fast Recovery Fast Spin-Echo One way to reduce scan time with SE sequences is to decrease the excitation flip angle from 90°, a method known 13 as the fast low-angle multiecho (FLAME) technique. As with GRE sequences, the reduced flip angle decreases
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
5 of 23
saturation effects with short TR. For this approach to work, an even number of 180° RF pulses (e.g., two) must be used. The reduced flip angle excitation tilts the longitudinal magnetization partway into the transverse plane, so there is a transverse component and a longitudinal component (along the +z direction). The first 180° pulse refocuses the transverse component of the magnetization as an SE, which is read out. This 180° pulse also flips the longitudinal component of the magnetization into the - z direction. The second 180° pulse flips the longitudinal magnetization back along the +z direction. Using the FLAME technique, an SE sequence with a TR of 1500 msec and a flip angle of 60° might generate T2 contrast similar to that obtained with a TR of 2500 msec and a 90° flip angle. The advantage of the shorter TR is a reduced scan time; the drawback is a decreased multislice capability because of the shorter TR. Whereas the FLAME technique is outdated, a related but improved method called "fast recovery fast SE" is in widespread use. Following the usual train of 180° refocusing RF pulses, the method applies an additional refocusing 180° RF pulse followed by a 90° RF pulse. The last RF pulse forces the longitudinal magnetization back to the +z axis, thereby shortening the period needed for T1 recovery.14 The method can be used to shorten scan times in general and to permit breath-hold fast SE imaging of the abdomen (Fig. 7-3).
Magnetization Transfer Effects A slice-selective RF pulse excites protons over a range of hundreds to thousands of hertz. Although the frequency of the pulse is selected to be on-resonance (at the Larmor frequency) for the particular slice being excited, it is off-resonance for the other slices of a multislice acquisition. The result is that each slice in a multislice volume experiences some degree of magnetization transfer effect from the RF excitations of each of the other slices, particularly from the 180° pulses, which deposit more power than the 90° pulses. 15 Magnetization transfer effects, which are relatively minor with conventional multislice SE sequences, become much more significant with fast SE sequences because of the larger number of 180° pulses.16 The change in tissue contrast that results may or may not be desirable. Magnetization transfer effects are more pronounced with long ETL and in tissues that contain both mobile and restricted pools of protons. Thus, the signal intensities of brain, liver, or muscle are reduced by magnetization transfer effects, but the signal intensities of tissues that contain only a small pool of restricted protons, such as CSF, blood, or cavernous hemangiomas17 are affected less.
Stimulated Echoes Any combination of three RF pulses has the potential to generate a stimulated echo. With all the RF pulses applied in a fast SE sequence, stimulated echoes are unavoidable. In fact, the stimulated echoes are deliberately 18 overlapped with the SE signals to increase SNR, although some alteration in tissue contrast occurs as a result.
Hyperechoes Fast SE scans are usually RF intensive. In order to reduce SAR, the refocusing angles of the fast SE train (180°) are generally lowered (90° to 160°) to make it possible to scan an adequate number of slices when multislice breath-hold measurements are performed. Although there may be a slight loss of T2 contrast, this can be compensated by an increase in TE. Lowering the refocusing angles will somewhat reduce the SNR. Furthermore, the risk of exceeding the SAR limits increases at higher field strengths (e.g., SAR is 4 times higher at 3 T than at 1.5 T). Lower refocusing flip angles and slightly longer RF pulses are used with 3 T fast SE implementations. However, lengthening the RF pulse to reduce SAR constraints is done at the expense of an increased ETS (providing additional filtering from T2 decay) and, at higher field strengths, additional signal loss in the presence of augmented magnetic field inhomogeneities and chemical shift. Hennig and Scheffler19 have devised a new spin refocusing strategy that maintains the benefits of fast SE by employing echoes of echoes (hence the name, hyperechoes), preserving SNR as in conventional fast SE sequences but with dramatically reduced SAR values (reductions up to 70% to 90%; Fig. 7-4). page 191 page 192
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
6 of 23
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-3 Fast recovery fast spin-echo. A, Pulse sequence timing diagram illustrates the fast-recovery modification. Once the final echo in the fast SE (FSE) echo train has been acquired, an additional 180° (180 deg) pulse refocuses the residual magnetization in the transverse plane, and then a -90° (-90 deg) pulse flips it back to the longitudinal axis instead of allowing it to recover with T1 processes. RF = radiofrequency pulses. B, Comparison of fast SE techniques images in a patient with a small peripheral liver hemangioma (arrow). (Top) respiratory-triggered fast SE (TR/TE = 3,600/90), (middle) breath-hold fast recovery fast SE (3,000/90), and (bottom) half-Fourier single-shot fast SE (TE = 90). Depiction and sharpness of the lesion are best seen with the fast recovery fast SE sequence. (Adapted from reference 14 with permission.)
The principle behind hyperechoes is fairly complex. In essence, a sequence of refocusing RF pulses, played with arbitrary flip angles, phase and gradient pulses following an initial 90° RF excitation pulse, will refocus to a full echo after the application of a 180° inversion pulse if the initial sequence of RF refocusing pulses is applied in reverse order with the opposite amplitudes and phases and the same gradient pulsing scheme. The signal intensity of the generated hyperecho can be thought of as the addition of all individual coherence pathways generated by each RF pulse (mixing of transverse and longitudinal magnetization components and generation of stimulated echoes) at the time of the hyperecho. In general, relaxation and diffusion effects accumulate between RF pulses, and these will provide additional modulation of the amplitude of the hyperecho. To obtain similar T2 contrast as obtained with fast SE, the effective TE is usually increased. Frank et al20 have taken advantage of the increased SNR with hyperechoes to produce a sequence with greater diffusion contrast. In their experience, the incorporation of a 180° RF refocusing pulse in a standard diffusion weighted stimulated echo sequence (resulting in the simplest hyperecho sequence of 90° - [α1,ϕ1] - 180° - [-α1,-ϕ1] - hyperecho) retained the same diffusion weighting for tissues with small T1/T2 ratios but with increased SNR compared with the 50% signal loss typically associated with the stimulated echo approach.
Flow Effects with Fast Spin-Echo Outflow of blood from the slice during the interval TE/2 between the 90° and 180° RF pulses (washout) tends to make flowing blood appear dark in conventional SE images. Washout effects are prominent with fast SE sequences, which use longer echo trains than conventional SE. Thus, fast SE imaging can be a useful way to create
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
7 of 23
"dark blood" angiograms. page 192 page 193
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-4 A, Diagram of the hyperecho pulse sequence showing RF pulse timings, phase and flip angles. B, High resolution 3D turbo spin-echo imaging of the brain using hyperechoes at 3 T with spatial resolution of 0.5 × 0.5 × 1.5 mm showing fine details of brain anatomy without limitation by SAR. (A, Reproduced with permission from Hennig J, Scheffler K: Hyperechoes. Magn Reson Med 46:6-12, 2001; B, Courtesy of Dr. Juergen Hennig.)
Appearance of Hemorrhage with Fast Spin-Echo Intracellular deoxyhemoglobin and methemoglobin are largely responsible for the signal loss in acute hemorrhage 21 seen on T2-weighted SE images. Iron storage products (ferritin and hemosiderin) cause the signal loss in chronic 22 bleeding. The paramagnetic iron in hemorrhage causes local magnetic field distortions (see Chapter 6, Biochemical Basis of the MRI Appearance of Cerebral Hemorrhage). Although static field effects are canceled by the refocusing pulse in SE sequences, diffusion of spins through these regions of inhomogeneous magnetic susceptibility causes dephasing that is not completely refocused by the SE. This dephasing results in signal loss within the hemorrhage.23 Fast SE is basically a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence,24,25 so it also minimizes signal loss resulting from diffusion. The greatest reduction in signal loss from diffusion occurs with fast SE sequences that have a short ETS. The bottom line is that fast SE sequences are less sensitive to T2-dependent signal loss in hemorrhage than are conventional T2-weighted SE sequences. This insensitivity to susceptibility effects may also prove beneficial for other clinical applications, such as imaging in the presence of metallic prostheses and imaging of the lung parenchyma.
Appearance of Fat on Fast Spin-Echo Images One difference in the appearance of fast SE images compared with conventional SE images is the higher signal intensity of fat. Several factors may contribute to this difference, the most important of which are diffusion effects 26,27 Other factors, such as stimulated echoes and steady-state effects, are considered to be less and J coupling. important.
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
8 of 23
page 193 page 194
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-5 Comparison of fast spin-echo (SE) with gradient and spin-echo (GRASE) in a case of a left temporal cavernous hemangioma. A, SE: TR/TE = 3500/119, 23-cm FOV, 250 × 256 matrix, 3 minutes, 3 seconds acquisition. B, GRASE: TR/TE = 3500/110, 24-cm FOV, 420 × 512 matrix, 2 minutes, 23 seconds acquisition. The GRASE image appears slightly more sensitive to blood products. (Courtesy of NYU Faculty Practice.)
Diffusion of fat molecules normally causes some degree of signal loss in conventional SE images. Because the sensitivity to diffusional effects is less with fast SE imaging, fat should appear brighter, although the scale of this loss in vivo is uncertain. J coupling represents the intramolecular interactions of spins with different chemical shifts through their electron bonds. It is responsible for splitting the spectrum of a molecule. Acquisition of a train of SEs with a short inter-echo spacing minimizes J-coupling effects and thereby increases the signal intensity of fat. Again, the relative importance of this effect in vivo is uncertain. Fat suppression can be achieved in fast SE imaging by application of a chemical-shift-selective saturation pulse before each repetition of the sequence. An alternative, though not widely applied, method to reduce the signal intensity of fat is to vary the timing of odd and even echoes so that there is a 90° phase shift between fat and water resonances. This gives a Carr-Purcell, rather than CPMG, condition for fat that increases dephasing.28
Gradient- and Spin-Echo Sequences Fast SE offers a major improvement in acquisition speed over conventional SE, but still faster imaging is possible 29 using the gradient- and spin-echo (GRASE) sequence. With fast SE, the application of multiple 180° RF pulses is time-consuming. Each 180° pulse has a finite duration, typically from 3 to 5 msec; moreover, these pulses are SAR-intensive. If the ETS is shortened too much, the SAR limits may be exceeded, especially when the body coil is used as the transmitter (power deposition is less for small transmit volume coils, such as the head coil). GRASE solves this problem by acquiring several gradient-echoes (e.g., three) in place of the single SE of fast SE. Each of these gradient-echoes is separately phase encoded. Because multiple phase-encoding steps are acquired after each 180° pulse instead of just one, scan times are shorter than with fast SE. For instance, an entire brain study can be completed in as little as 20 seconds, compared with 1 minute or longer with fast SE. There is a price to be paid, however. Unlike SEs, GREs decay according to T2* and are more sensitive to variations in magnetic susceptibility as well as chemical shift. In principle, GRASE sequences are more sensitive to the susceptibility
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
9 of 23
effects of hemorrhage than fast SE, but the sensitivity depends on the particular sequence implementation (Fig. 7-5). Phase or amplitude corrections must be made to the data to eliminate abrupt jumps in phase or signal intensity from one line of data to the next (these procedures are less crucial with fast SE). With GRASE, it is difficult to achieve a smooth transition between the signal intensities of lines containing SE and GRE signals. These signal discontinuities cause ringing artifacts that are more apparent than with fast SE. At present, we find GRASE of limited value because of artifacts that occur if B0 homogeneity is suboptimal (e.g., for imaging near the dome of the liver). Single-shot GRASE using a long ETL allows subsecond imaging, although with considerable blurring except for tissues with long T2 values (i.e., fluids).
Gradient-Echo Pulse Sequences A GRE sequence generates a gradient-echo (also called a gradient-recalled echo or field echo) simply by applying a pair of balanced gradients of opposite sign along the frequency-encoding direction (see Chapter 5, Pulse Sequence Design). The first gradient, called a dephasing or compensatory gradient, spreads out the transverse magnetization over 180° (π) or more and thereby dephases the spins. The readout gradient exactly undoes the dephasing at the TE so that there is no residual gradient dephasing effect. Unlike an SE sequence, which uses at least two RF pulses to generate a spin-echo signal, a GRE sequence uses a single RF pulse to generate the gradient-echo signal, usually with a flip angle less than 90°. A major advantage of GRE sequences is that good image quality can be maintained even with quite short TR (e.g., 3 to 30 msec). Several clinically useful variants of GRE sequences have been developed30-32 as will now be addressed.
Incoherent (Spoiled) Gradient-Echo page 194 page 195
In incoherent GRE sequences such as FLASH or spoiled gradient recalled (SPGR), a spoiler gradient (i.e., a strong gradient that is either constant or stepped through a different value after each excitation) is applied at the end of the readout. The spoiler gradient disperses any residual transverse magnetization that remains after the signal has been read and the analog-to-digital converter is turned off.33 If a spoiler is not applied, buildup of transverse coherences over multiple RF excitations leads to horizontal striping in the image, particularly if short TR and large 34 flip angles are used. Spoiling is most effective if, in addition to the use of a spoiler gradient, the residual magnetization is dispersed by randomizing the phases of the RF pulses, a method called RF spoiling. In a spoiled GRE sequence, the transverse magnetization decays in much the same fashion as in an SE sequence. The signal intensity in spoiled GRE images is given by: where E1 = exp(-TR/T1), E* = exp(-TE/T2*), and α is the flip angle. S0 is the maximal obtainable signal, that is, using a long TR, a short TE, and a 90° flip angle. The term E* contributes the T2* weighting. The T2* weighting is somewhat different from the T2 weighting in an SE because, as denoted by the asterisk, magnetic field inhomogeneity contributes to the loss of signal. The rate of signal loss is given by: where ∆B0 is the magnetic field variation across a pixel and γ is the gyromagnetic ratio for hydrogen (approximately 42 MHz/T). Because artifacts resulting from magnetic field inhomogeneity worsen with long TE, strong T2* weighting is problematic with spoiled GRE sequences. Susceptibility effects are minimized by the use of a short TE, 35 high readout bandwidth, and thin slice. The amount of signal generated by an RF pulse is proportional to the longitudinal magnetization existing at the moment before the pulse is applied. Now consider the effect of a 90° RF pulse in a SE or spoiled GRE sequence. After applying this pulse, one must wait a considerable time, on the order of the tissue T1 relaxation time, before repeating the excitation. Otherwise, as mentioned before, the tissue magnetization becomes saturated (i.e., approaches a value of zero) and insufficient signal is produced (the situation is completely different for steady-state free precession sequences, below). If one uses a smaller flip angle, saturation effects are less and the TR can be substantially shortened (Fig. 7-6). However, a small excitation flip angle will not work effectively with SE sequences due to the confounding effects of the 180° refocusing pulse.
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
10 of 23
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-6 Relationship of flip angle to signal for a spoiled gradient-echo (GRE) sequence. The time between α1 and α2 is TR. Top, Signal is directly proportional to spin density if α2 is much less than 2TR/T1. Only a small amount of transverse magnetization (Mxy) and signal is generated from the first small flip angle RF pulse (α1), but the protons are almost fully magnetized by the time of the second RF pulse (α2) and produce nearly the same amount of signal as from the first excitation. Bottom, More transverse magnetization is initially generated with a large flip angle excitation, but the protons have recovered only a portion of the magnetization by the time of the next RF pulse and produce substantially less signal intensity from this excitation.
With a spoiled GRE sequence, the flip angle that produces the most signal for a given TR and T1 is known as the Ernst angle (αE), as given by: However, the Ernst angle is not necessarily the best choice for flip angle. More critical for lesion detection than the SNR is the signal difference-to-noise or contrast-to-noise ratio (i.e., the difference in signal between two tissues, such as a metastasis and the liver, divided by the standard deviation of the background noise). The flip angle is a key determinant of GRE image contrast36,37 (Fig. 7-7). For T1-weighted spoiled GRE sequences, a flip angle larger than the Ernst angle produces better T1 contrast; for proton density-weighted images, a smaller flip angle is desirable. Note that the image contrast is very dependent on whether the GRE sequence is spoiled or not (Fig. 7-8). Because short TR values are permissible with GRE sequences, 3D acquisitions can be completed in a reasonable time period (e.g., 10 seconds to 10 minutes).38 With 3D, a thick volume of tissue rather than a thin 2D section is excited by the RF pulse. Three-dimensional GRE imaging has the advantage of allowing quite thin (e.g., 1 mm or less) contiguous sections with good SNR, because acquisition of multiple 3D partitions is comparable to using multiple excitations in terms of boosting the SNR:
Coherent (Steady-State Free Precession) Gradient-Echo page 195 page 196
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
11 of 23
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox page 196 page 197
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
12 of 23
Figure 7-7 Simulation of signal strengths from various tissues using different gradient-echo (GRE) methods. All calculations obtained with TR/TE = 50/12. Vertical axis represents signal strength as a fraction of maximal signal intensity (unweighted image). A, Spoiled GRE. T1 contrast is highest with large flip angles. However, signal is maximal at smaller flip angles (Ernst angle), here shown to be approximately 15° to 30°. Note that signal curve in region of Ernst angle is relatively flat, suggesting that there is considerable leeway in the choice of flip angles. B, Steady-state coherent GRE obtained with phase alternation of RF pulses. Note marked enhancement of cerebrospinal fluid because of its small T1/T2 ratio. C, Contrast-enhanced steady-state GRE sequence, first echo. Contrast is similar to that in B. D, Contrast-enhanced steady-state GRE sequence (CE-FAST, PSIF). Note the increased T2 contrast compared with A and B.
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
13 of 23
Add to lightbox page 197 page 198
Figure 7-8 Axial brain images showing comparisons of spoiled gradient-echo (GRE) and steady-state GRE sequences. A, Spoiled GRE (FLASH). TR was 15 msec and the flip angle varied from 90° (upper left) to 10° (lower right). B, Steady-state coherent GRE (FISP). TR was 15 msec and the flip angle varied from 90° (upper left) to 10° (lower right). T1 contrast is inferior to that in A and the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) signal intensity over the cerebral convexities is high. Note that the lateral ventricles do not appear bright because CSF pulsation destroys the steady-state signal.
Rather than discard the transverse magnetization that persists after readout, coherent (steady-state free 39,40 precession; SSFP) GRE sequences recycle this magnetization to increase the signal intensity of certain tissues. 41 One example of a coherent GRE sequence is fast imaging with steady-state precession (FISP), or gradientrecalled acquisition in the steady state (GRASS). There is an extra phase-encoding gradient, of opposite sign to the regular phase-encoding gradient, which has the opposite effect to a spoiler gradient. The purpose of this extra gradient is to eliminate spoiling by the phase-encoding gradient of the transverse component of the steady-state magnetization. The difference in contrast behavior between spoiled and SSFP GRE is manifested only under the conditions of TR [Lt ] T2 and large flip angle excitation (Fig. 7-9). When TR [Lt ] T2, the transverse magnetization persists long enough after the readout that a portion of it can be tipped back onto the longitudinal axis by the next RF excitation; it adds to the magnetization recovered by T1 relaxation over the TR interval. Subsequent RF pulses then tip this enhanced magnetization back into the transverse plane, so that the signal intensity is greater than that produced by a spoiled GRE sequence.
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
14 of 23
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-9 Spoiled GRE (top) and steady-state coherent GRE (bottom) images show divergent contrast behavior with short TR. Parasagittal images of a patient with a brain metastasis. TR/TE/FA = 30/14/90°. Note that the spoiled GRE image appears T1 weighted, but with same scan parameters the steady-state coherent GRE image shows marked enhancement of CSF (large arrow) and edema (small arrow) (small T1/T2 ratio).
Some tissues (particularly fluids) appear bright in SSFP GRE images, but the images are not T2 weighted in the usual sense of T2-weighted SE images. The contrast depends on the ratio T1/T2; only tissues with a small T1/T2 ratio show high signal intensity. With longer TR (e.g., >250 msec), spoiled and SSFP GRE sequences produce images that are more or less identical unless fluids are present (long T2). Moreover, with FISP and GRASS, motion destroys the residual transverse magnetization so that moving fluids do not appear uniformly bright.42
Balanced Coherent Gradient-Echo To compensate for signal loss due to motion, the balanced coherent or balanced SSFP sequence (e.g. true FISP or FIESTA) was developed. This pulse sequence has a symmetrical gradient structure that eliminates phase shifts caused by motion (see Chapter 5, Pulse Sequence Design). Fluids such as bile, blood, or CSF appear bright with this sequence even when moving. Because it has a relatively small T1/T2 ratio, fat also appears bright. Because of this property, the use of fat suppression can be helpful to differentiate flowing blood from fatty tissue. With very short TR and TE (e.g. 3 msec and 1 msec), there are few if any artifacts; moreover, an image can be acquired in as little as a few hundred milliseconds. These properties make balanced SSFP a motion-insensitive technique that is ideal for scout imaging. Using cardiac gating, it is the method of choice for cine MRI43 (see Chapter 32, Cardiac Imaging Techniques). A drawback of this technique is the tendency to have dark stripes in the image, particularly in regions where the magnetic field is inhomogeneous (see Chapter 22, Image Artifacts and Solutions). This "off-resonance effect" is caused by shifts in the resonance frequency of the tissue protons in the presence of a nonuniform magnetic field. The striping can be reduced by the use of a proper shim and frequency adjustment, along with a minimal TR and TE. Alternatively, a maximal intensity projection (or the addition) of two acquisitions (one with alternating RF phase, one with constant RF phase) can be done to eliminate the striping.44
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
15 of 23
Power deposition is high with the large excitation flip angles and ultra-short TR required for this technique. The high power deposition can become a limiting factor at 3 T, so that longer TR than the optimal may have to be used. Under these circumstances, proper shimming is even more essential.
Contrast-Enhanced Steady-State Gradient-Echo Another version of steady-state GRE is time-reversed FISP (PSIF) or contrast-enhanced Fourier-acquired steady-state technique (CE-FAST). This pulse sequence has a structure that is reversed from a standard SSFP GRE sequence.45,46 The result is that a heavily T2-weighted RF echo, rather than a GRE, is generated. The degree of T2 weighting is exponentially dependent on twice the TR ≈ exp(-2TR/T2); thus, the effective TE is actually longer than the TR. Contrast-enhanced steady-state GRE sequences render fluids and tumors bright but have the drawback of being highly sensitive to motion (Fig. 7-10). page 198 page 199
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-10 Patient with three cavernous hemangiomas (H) in the liver. Time-reversed fast imaging with steady-state precession (PSIF) image (left) obtained with TR = 30 msec in less than 10 seconds provides similar contrast to that obtained in 10 minutes using a T2-weighted spin-echo (SE) image (right, slightly different slice position). However, sensitivity to motion (e.g., from pulsatile flow, cardiac pulsations transmitted to left lobe of liver) is much worse with PSIF.
It is also possible to generate two echoes with different degrees of T2 weighting in the same acquisition. The first echo has FISP-like contrast, the second is PSIF-like. These two echoes can be added together (double echo in the steady state; DESS) to produce an image with a good SNR but the high signal intensity of fluid, which may be helpful for the evaluation of hyaline cartilage in the knee when an effusion is present. However, interest in these techniques has waned considerably with the advent of balanced SSFP and fast SE imaging, which respectively are less motion sensitive and provide more robust T2 weighting than the contrast-enhanced GRE sequences.
Reaching the Steady State Depending on the imaging parameters, the application of multiple RF pulses leads to the establishment of a
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
16 of 23
steady-state or equilibrium condition. With both spoiled and SSFP GRE sequences, many (typically dozens of) preparatory RF excitations must be applied before starting the acquisition of data for the spins to reach a steady-state magnetization; otherwise, there are initial fluctuations in the tissue magnetization that produce variations in the signal intensity and hence artifacts.47 With spoiled GRE, the approach to steady state is smooth for any RF excitation flip angle and involves only longitudinal magnetization components. However, for SSFP sequences where TR [Lt ] T2 and the flip angle is large, the approach to equilibrium is rather complex and involves a mixture of transverse and longitudinal magnetization components that regain coherence at every RF excitation, making the approach highly oscillatory with large flip angles (Fig. 7-11). The behavior of the spins during the approach to steady state depends on the initial magnetization, the transient behavior between the application of RF pulses (i.e., the T1 regrowth and T2 dephasing rate-which in turn depends on the field inhomogeneity), the flip angle of the RF pulses, TE, and TR. Initial attempts to drive spins into steady-state used an alpha/2 pulse played out at a time TR/2 before a train of alpha pulses.48 In this case, the magnetization vector approximately follows an exponential decay toward the 49 desired steady-state conditions. However, this decay requires as many as 40 to 50 RF pulses to achieve steadystate, which adds an undesirable amount of scan time to 2D exams. Nishimura has shown that the application of a linearly increasing flip angle can achieve steady state magnetization in 10-15 pulses.50 Furthermore, the linear ramp has shown to be less sensitive to the small off resonance effects that are responsible for artifact. The linear ramp approach to steady-state has proven useful in cardiac MR imaging51 where prolonged magnetization preparation-time could prohibit the use of SSFP acquisitions.
Three-Dimentional Gradient-Echo Three-dimensional GRE acquisitions are routine. They are used for numerous clinical applications, including contrast-enhanced MR angiography, brain imaging, and musculoskeletal imaging. The benefits include the ability to acquire thin slices with adequate SNR. As addressed in Chapters 3, Practical Considerations and Image Optimization and 23, Image Processing: Principles, Techniques, and Applications, the acquisition of thin, continuous slices permits the application of various image processing techniques, including maximum intensity projection, volume rendering, and multiplanar reformation. page 199 page 200
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
17 of 23
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-11 Approach to the steady state for spoiled and steady-state coherent gradient-echo (GRE) sequences. Calculated signal intensity as a function of excitation number for TR/FA = 15/20°. A, Spoiled GRE sequence. Note the smooth approach to the steady state. B, Steady-state coherent GRE sequence. Note the marked oscillation in signal intensity as a function of excitation number, particularly for long-T2 tissues such as blood and cerebrospinal fluid.
Slice Profile Effects in Fast 3D Gradient-Echo Imaging With short TR values as used in most 3D GRE imaging, the profile of the 3D slab may be nonrectangular (i.e. the flip angle is not uniform across the slab). The problem is compounded by the fact that RF pulses of short duration (e.g. 1 to 2 msec) are often used for fast imaging. These short duration RF pulses have poor slab profiles compared with lengthier pulses. page 200 page 201
The degradation in the slice profile is most severe when the TR is short and the flip angle is large. Near the center of the 3D slab, the flip angle is correct, but the edges of the slab experience smaller flip angles. Using a spoiled GRE sequence, one finds that partitions (i.e. slices from a 3D acquisition) near the center of the 3D slab experience the nominal flip angle and show the expected T1 contrast, whereas partitions near the edges of the slab experience smaller flip angles and show less T1 contrast. (Additionally, a dynamic transformation of the slice profile occurs for fast GRE during the approach to steady state.52 However, this additional problem is avoided by the use of preparation scans.)
Turbo FLASH and MP-RAGE With short TR values (e.g., <10 msec), GRE scan times less than 1 second are feasible. However, these images show poor contrast and are best used as localizer scans. The addition of an inversion recovery (IR) magnetization preparation alters tissue contrast so that the images can be clinically useful. This approach is called snapshot FLASH,53 turbo FLASH, or, for 3D acquisitions, MP-RAGE. In using turbo FLASH, one can make a particular tissue appear bright (e.g., liver parenchyma) and another appear dark (e.g., metastasis) by choosing the proper inversion time (TI). There is an important difference from inversion recovery-prepared fast SE. With turbo FLASH, where the data are obtained over a period of up to a second for 64 to 128 phase-encoding steps, it is obviously impossible to acquire the entire image at the zero crossing of the longitudinal magnetization. For instance, consider an IR turbo FLASH sequence with a TR of 7 msec and 128 phase-encoding steps. At 1.5 T, the signal intensity from a metastasis might be minimized at a nominal TI of 700 msec. Using a standard phaseencode order, the effective TI (i.e., the time from the 180° pulse to the central phase-encoding step) of this sequence is equal to the nominal TI of 700 msec + (7 msec × 64 steps) = 1148 msec. On the other hand, it would not be possible to null tissues having a short T1, such as fat or liver, with this sequence. Even with a nominal TI of 0 (effective TI of 448 msec), the longitudinal magnetization of these tissues would already have recovered well past
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
18 of 23
zero by the time the central lines were acquired. This problem can be overcome by reordering the phase-encoding 54 steps to acquire the central lines first. For instance, the so-called centric approach acquires the steps as follows: 0, 1, -2, 2, -2, 3, -3,[mldr ].
Multishot or Segmented GRE The data acquisition can be divided into groups or segments of phase-encoding steps. The advantage of segmentation is that the data are acquired over a shorter time period. For cardiac imaging, the result is less blurring from cardiac motion. Typically, 4 to 12 steps are acquired in each segment. With an inversion recovery preparation, the method is ideal for studies of myocardial viability since it minimizes blurring from cardiac motion as well as strong T1 contrast for detection of delayed enhancement (see Chapter 35, Myocardial Viability).
Miscellaneous Rapid Imaging Sequences BURST BURST is so named because it applies a burst of brief RF pulses. 55-57 Multiple echoes are generated, separated by the interval that separates the RF pulses; each echo can be individually phase encoded. The data acquisition speed is nearly as fast as for echo-planar imaging (EPI) but without the need for high-speed gradients. The whole brain can be imaged using a 3D BURST sequence in just a few seconds. Moreover, the pulse sequence is very quiet since rapid switching of the gradients is unnecessary.
URGE Ultrarapid gradient-echo (URGE) uses a string of short, low-flip-angle nonselective RF pulses during the application of a constant, negative gradient and generates a train of GREs that are equal in number to the RF pulses applied using a constant, positive readout gradient, as in conventional GRE imaging. URGE departs from other concepts-such as utilized in BURST, SUNBURST,58 optimized ultrafast imaging sequence (OUFIS),59 DANTE 60 61 ultrafast imaging sequence (DUFIS), or quick-echo split imaging technique (QUEST) -in which SEs rather than GREs are acquired, so that one obtains maximal spin utilization and consequently better SNRs. Images can be generated as quickly as in EPI but do not require the stringent gradient hardware necessary to achieve the performance of the latter, because the data are acquired during a constant gradient readout. An interleaved trajectory62 produces URGE images of good quality with small effects from field inhomogeneities, T2* decay, or diffusion and flow. Only a 3D version of URGE has been implemented because of the nonselective nature of the RF excitation process. Magnetization-prepared URGE has also been demonstrated with strong T1 weighting.
Fast STEAM 63,64
65
A stimulated-echo acquisition mode (STEAM) can be used for fast imaging. The magnetization is stored along the - z axis using two 90° RF pulses and is then read out using a series of independently phase-encoded low-flip-angle excitations. Subsecond acquisition times are possible with this approach. The images are T1 weighted according to the length of the interval between the second RF pulse and the central phase-encoding step. Flowing blood is effectively dephased with STEAM imaging, so that it appears uniformly dark. Fast STEAM imaging has been proposed for cardiac and perfusion imaging.66 However, image quality is less than can be obtained by other fast imaging methods, so the method has not come into widespread use.
Echo-Planar Imaging page 201 page 202
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
19 of 23
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-12 The k-space trajectories for single-shot echo-planar imaging (EPI). Comparison of blipped (left) and constant (right) phase-encoding.
Echo-planar imaging, proposed by Mansfield and Pykett in 1977,67 is a fast imaging technique that allows one to collect all the data required to reconstruct an image in a brief interval, as short as the duration of a single readout 68-70 With image acquisition times on the order of one tenth of a second, EPI period (approximately 32 to 100 msec). represents the fastest clinically useful imaging technique. A number of new clinical applications have become feasible with the introduction of EPI, with the greatest use being for functional brain imaging (including imaging of perfusion, diffusion, and cortical activation).
Single-Shot Echo-Planar Imaging An EPI image can be acquired in a single measurement or shot, with all the data collected after one RF excitation, or as multiple shots using repeated RF excitations, as discussed later. The single-shot approach differs from standard SE and GRE sequences, with which only a portion of the data is collected after each RF excitation. Echo-planar data are collected during the application of a rapidly oscillating gradient along the readout (frequencyencoding) direction. With each reversal of the gradient polarity from positive to negative and vice versa, a GRE is produced that is independently phase encoded, resulting in the generation of a train of echoes. One can use a terminology for EPI similar to that used in fast SE imaging with respect to the echo train. The image acquisition time is simply the duration of the echo train, typically from 30 to 150 msec. The acquisition is faster than for single shot fast SE (e.g., HASTE, SSFSE).
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-13 Pulse sequence diagram for single-shot gradient-echo echo-planar imaging using a two-echo phase correction to suppress n/2 artifacts. The correction data are acquired without phase-encoding immediately after the 90° RF excitation. A blipped phase-encoding approach is illustrated, but a constant phase-encoding gradient could also be used. (Gp, phase-encoding gradient; Gr, readout gradient; Gs, slice-selection gradient; s(t), MR signal.)
Echo-planar imaging collects data in a markedly different way from standard pulse sequences, but differences exist even among various EPI implementations (e.g., blipped versus constant phase-encoding; single shot versus multishot). Figure 7-12 shows k-space trajectories for single-shot EPI. With single-shot EPI, the need for a TR interval between data collections is eliminated. The TR is essentially infinite, eliminating any degree of T1 weighting. T2 contrast is thereby improved, which is helpful for characterization of long-T1, long-T2 lesions such as cysts and hemangiomas.
Radiofrequency Excitation for Echo-Planar Imaging
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
20 of 23
Virtually any combination of RF pulses used in conventional pulse sequences can be used in EPI (Figs. 7-13 and 7-14). For instance, a 90° pulse and 180° RF pulse can be applied so that the EPI data are collected under the T2-dependent decay envelope of an SE signal (SE EPI). Alternatively, a single RF pulse can be applied with a flip angle of 90° or less so that the EPI data are collected under the T2*-dependent decay envelope of a GRE signal (GRE EPI). Spin-echo EPI is routinely used for diffusion imaging.
Add to lightbox page 202 page 203
Figure 7-14 Diffusion-weighted spin-echo echo-planar imaging sequence. A pair of diffusion gradients (GD) of equal area and separated in time by ∆ are applied around the 180° RF pulse to dephase and cause signal loss from diffusing protons but not from stationary spins.
Echo Planar-Capable Gradient Systems To keep the duration of the echo train as short as possible (necessary because of signal loss resulting from T2* decay), the ramp time (i.e., time from zero to maximum amplitude and vice versa) for the readout gradient must be extremely short. For instance, if the gradient ramp time is 250 μs, one readout gradient pulse can be applied in as little as 0.5 msec, and 128 echoes could be collected in 128 × 0.5 msec or 64 msec.
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-15 Uses of high slew rates. A, Standard gradient systems typically have gradient ramp times on the order of 1 msec from zero to peak amplitude. B, Systems capable of echo-planar imaging have much higher slew rates,
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
21 of 23
so that the duration of the gradient ramps can be shortened. This technique can be used to reduce TE without increasing the signal bandwidth compared with that in A. C, Alternatively, the use of faster ramps allows the plateau sampling period to be extended, thereby lowering the signal bandwidth and improving the signal-to-noise ratio without increasing the total duration of the frequency-encoding gradient waveform compared with that in A.
Not only must the gradient rise times be several times shorter than for standard gradient systems, the gradients must also be capable of reaching higher peak amplitudes. This is because the spatial resolution is determined by the integral of the gradient waveform. Because the duration of each readout gradient pulse is so short, its amplitude must be correspondingly high. The gradient performance may be characterized in terms of slew rate (Fig. 7-15), which is the gradient magnetic field change per unit time, given in tesla per meter per second. For instance, for trapezoidal gradients, a slew rate of 200 T/m/s could mean that the gradient rise time is 0.1 msec for a peak gradient amplitude of 20 mT/m or 0.05 msec for a peak gradient amplitude of 10 mT/m. The definition of slew rate is trickier for sinusoidal gradients, as the slew rate varies over the duration of the sinusoid. Potential advantages of high slew rates include: 1. shorter TE for non-EPI applications; 2. reduction in the echo train duration, so that susceptibility and T2* filtering effects are reduced; and 3. higher spatial resolution, because the gradient can be ramped more rapidly. This allows more time at the plateau of peak gradient amplitude and a larger area under the gradient. Drawbacks of high slew rates include greater risk of neuromuscular stimulation and more stringent hardware requirements. With the use of high-slew-rate gradient pulses, good eddy current compensation is essential to avoid image artifacts. Parallel imaging techniques (see Chapter 8, Parallel Imaging Methods) are particularly beneficial for reducing artifact and improving spatial resolution for EPI.
Phase-Encoding in Echo-Planar Imaging Because the data for EPI are collected as a series of very fast gradient-echoes, the techniques for phase-encoding are different from those used for standard imaging. One of two methods for phase-encoding is generally used: 1. a constant phase-encoding gradient is applied over the entire duration of the EPI readout; or 2. a phase-encoding "blip" of short duration is applied at the end of each readout gradient pulse. The trajectory along the phase-encoding direction is slightly different for each approach and is treated differently during the image reconstruction.46 Echo-planar images can also be acquired in a volumetric mode by applying a standard phase-encoding gradient along the section-select direction, with much shorter image acquisition times (as little as 10 seconds for 128 partitions) than for standard 3D GRE sequences. However, the artifacts are then more severe than with 2D.
Artifacts in Echo-Planar Imaging
N/2 Ghosts page 203 page 204
Ghost artifacts are typically caused by periodic fluctuations in image signal intensity. Because single-shot EPI data are accumulated within an interval that is short compared with periods of physiologic motion, the images do not suffer from ghost artifacts caused by breathing or cardiac pulsation. However, they can suffer from ghost artifacts of a different kind. Odd and even EPI echoes are collected with readout gradients of alternating polarity. Imperfections in the gradients, gradient-induced eddy currents, flow, or field inhomogeneities may cause slight mismatches in the timings of the odd and even echoes, which translate into phase errors after the Fourier transform. These phase errors are manifested in EPI as duplicate images of the object, called N/2 ghosts that propagate along the phase-encoding direction. If N/2 ghosts are severe, they can degrade image quality. To suppress N/2 ghosts, care must be taken to ensure gradient stability and minimize eddy currents. The N/2 ghosts can also be suppressed by a phase correction determined from two echoes collected during a single bipolar readout gradient (or three echoes).
Susceptibility and Chemical-Shift Artifacts The amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient for EPI is much weaker than for standard pulse sequences. As a result, EPI is sensitive to the effects of static magnetic field inhomogeneities (susceptibility and chemical shift artifacts); however, the sensitivity is directed along the phase-encoding rather than the frequency-encoding direction, as is typical of standard pulse sequences. Susceptibility artifacts may be severe at the skull base, near the paranasal sinuses, at the anterior orbits, at the lung-heart interface, and near air-containing bowel loops. Because chemical-shift artifacts with single-shot EPI are many times larger than with standard sequences, efficient fat suppression is essential (Fig. 7-16). Susceptibility artifacts are reduced by proper shimming. Susceptibility artifacts are further reduced by using thin sections, a short TE (which can be achieved by reducing the ETL or by asymmetric k-space sampling along the phase-encoding direction), or augmenting the amplitude of the phase-encoding gradient (e.g., using a rectangular field-of-view; FOV). The TE also can be shortened by increasing the readout bandwidth (i.e., reducing the duration of echo sampling), but this approach is ultimately limited by the gradient capabilities of the system.
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
22 of 23
T2* Filtering
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-16 Abdominal echo-planar image acquired without fat suppression. Note the enormous chemical-shift displacement of the subcutaneous fat (arrows).
Data collection with EPI is fast relative to conventional MRI techniques and to periods of physiologic motion; it is not fast with respect to T2* decay. T2* decay during the echo train causes blurring (filtering of high spatial frequencies) 71 along the phase-encoding direction because the signal intensity changes substantially over this period. With shorter T2* the blurring is more severe. This filtering effect can be minimized by shortening the echo train and TE.
In-Plane Spatial Resolution In-plane spatial resolution along the x and y directions is determined, respectively, by the integrals of the readout and phase-encoding gradient waveforms. Because the echo train must be kept short to minimize T2* decay and resultant blurring, the FOV of single-shot EPI is ultimately limited by the peak gradient amplitude. As a result, the minimal FOV for EPI using whole-body systems is on the order of 25 cm or greater for a 128 × 128 acquisition matrix, giving a typical pixel size of 2 to 3 mm. Spatial resolution can be improved by use of small gradient insert coils, parallel imaging, or multishot approaches.
Multishot Echo-Planar Imaging One can substantially overcome the FOV limits and susceptibility artifacts that occur with single-shot EPI by accumulating the data over multiple shots (each shot corresponds to one RF excitation). This procedure decreases the ETL and duration of echo train in proportion to the number of shots. Multishot EPI greatly reduces the demands on gradient performance and allows in-plane spatial resolution to be improved to a level comparable to that with standard pulse sequences. There are several possibilities for multishot imaging. For instance, one could simply acquire half of k-space in the first shot and concatenate the other half acquired in the second shot. When done along the frequency-encoding direction, this is called mosaic imaging. 72 Half-Fourier imaging can also be used to improve spatial resolution, at the expense of a loss in SNR and some increase in artifacts. Alternatively, a limited portion or segment of data (e.g., 8 to 32 lines) is collected within each TR interval. To smooth out phase and amplitude modulations in the raw data, which otherwise introduce artifacts into the image the technique of echo shifting is used. With this technique, the timing of the echoes is varied slightly from shot to shot.73,74 Multishot EPI 75,76 images of diagnostic quality can be acquired in a single breath-hold period.
Signal-to-Noise Ratio in Echo-Planar Imaging page 204 page 205
1/2
The SNR is proportional to 1/(readout bandwidth) . The duration of each GRE readout in the EPI echo train is many times shorter than that of the readout of a conventional pulse sequence; therefore, the readout bandwidth is correspondingly higher and the SNR lower. Despite this limitation, the SNR of single-shot EPI images can be surprisingly good. One reason is the limited in-plane spatial resolution, as the SNR scales with the pixel area. For instance, a 128 × 128 or 64 × 128 acquisition matrix is commonly used for EPI with pixel dimensions on the order of 2 to 4 mm, versus 1 to 2 mm with standard sequences. Furthermore, at least for single shot EPI, all echoes are collected after a single RF excitation. Although the SNR of EPI images is lower than that of images acquired using standard pulse sequences, the SNR per unit acquisition time is higher. An interesting feature of EPI is that image quality may improve (up to a point), rather than worsen, as the section thickness is reduced. This is because T2*
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007001
23 of 23
decay caused by intravoxel variations in magnetic susceptibility is reduced as the section thickness is decreased.
Safety of Echo-Planar Imaging The RF power deposition with EPI is low because few RF pulses are applied. The gradients are another issue entirely. A change in the magnetic field (B field) can create an electric field (E field) directly proportional to the rate of change of the B field, thus giving rise to electric currents when the changes occur in a conductive surrounding. The fast-changing magnetic field gradients needed for EPI can induce rapidly changing electric currents in the body that are potentially hazardous. These currents can cause neuromuscular stimulation and have raised concerns about the safety of EPI for human studies. Because of the different geometries of the three gradient coils, the stimulation hazard is worst when the z gradient is used for readout (i.e., for sagittal or coronal EPI imaging). Swapping the phase- and frequency-encoding gradients for an EPI axial acquisition increases the risk of neuromuscular stimulation compared with an unswapped axial acquisition because of greater stimulation when the y gradient is used for readout compared with the x gradient. Sinusoidal gradients may have a lower threshold for stimulation than trapezoidal ones.77,78 Safety issues are reviewed in Chapter 24, Bioeffects, Safety, and Patient Management. Studies have reported sensations ranging from mild twitching to pain, depending on the maximal change in B over 79,80 The sensation is felt near the time when the magnetic field gradients oscillate during EPI data collection. physical extremes of the gradient coil, where the gradient field change (and therefore dB/dt) is largest. For instance, the trunk muscles or buttocks are typically affected when the head is positioned at the center of the magnet for brain imaging, because they lie near the edge of the magnet bore and thus the ends of the gradient coils. Similarly, the bridge of the nose may be affected during abdominal imaging. Fortunately, the cardiac stimulation threshold is at least 10-fold higher than for skeletal muscle. The risk of stimulation can be reduced by shortening the gradient coil, which reduces the peak dB/dt at the ends of the coil. Figure 7-17 shows field plots for long and short z gradient coils. A disadvantage of a short gradient coil is that spatial distortions are seen for positions far off center. These distortions can be corrected, at least in part, if the gradient field distribution is known.81
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd edition (on 11 April 2010) © 2010 Elsevier
12-04-2010 00:11
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007041
1 of 18
TIME-RESOLVED IMAGING
Add to lightbox page 205 page 206
Figure 7-17 Field plot of a z-gradient coil. A long gradient coil has a higher dB/dt at its ends than does a shorter gradient coil.
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-18 Illustration of raw data (k-space) showing the relationship of the central lines (weakest phase-encoding gradient amplitudes and strongest signal) to image contrast and of the outer lines to image detail. For a complete image, all (kx, ky) points must be covered by the acquisition.
It is obvious that an MR image must depict anatomy with high spatial resolution to be clinically useful. However, it can also be the case that such static images do not by themselves provide all the information that is needed and some level of temporal resolution may be required in addition. Time-resolved imaging has proven to be an essential tool in several clinical applications, including evaluation of bowel peristalsis, fetal motion, dynamic contrast-enhanced perfusion MRI in suspected stroke, contrast agent kinetics in breast tumors, identifying the true and false lumens of an aortic dissection, distinguishing arterial and venous pathology in the setting of rapid arteriovenous transit, and measurement of transit times.82,83,84 In order to facilitate time-resolved imaging, new techniques have been developed that either speed up the actual data acquisitions, such as echo planar and single shot fast SE (reviewed earlier in this chapter), or reduce the amount of data that are acquired. The latter approach is called "undersampling". In the following section, we will focus on undersampling techniques using both Cartesian and non-Cartesian k-space trajectories and methods to minimize artifacts
12-04-2010 00:12
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007041
2 of 18
associated with them.85,86 Although parallel imaging techniques87,88 also use undersampling, they involve a substantially different set of principles and are reviewed separately in Chapter 8.
k-Space and Undersampled Cartesian Imaging A useful concept for understanding advanced imaging techniques is k-space.89 The raw data (i.e., the data as collected before the 2D Fourier transform) can be depicted as a 2D matrix of spatial frequencies (kx, ky) (Fig. 7-18). In generic form, where γ is the gyromagnetic ratio and G(t) is the time-dependent gradient amplitude. Various parts of k-space influence the appearance of the image in different ways. Because magnetic field gradients cause dephasing, the MR signal is strongest when the weakest phase-encoding gradients are applied. The center of k-space consists of data acquired during the weakest phase-encoding gradients. Because the signals are so large in this part of k-space, these data control image contrast. The weaker signals in the outer part of k-space (strongest phase-encoding gradients) contain the high spatial frequencies that determine image detail (Fig. 7-19). The manner in which the various spatial frequencies are collected determines the k-space trajectory. The MR data are collected to encode both low and high spatial frequencies (i.e., the image should have good tissue contrast as well as high spatial resolution). Independent of the acquisition matrix size selected, the relative speed at which k-space is covered determines the time savings possible with a particular MRI technique.
Add to lightbox
Add to lightbox
12-04-2010 00:12
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007041
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-19 Raw data. A, The amount and manner in which data are acquired can dramatically alter the appearance of the MR image. The raw data (left) are converted into an image (right) by the Fourier transform. B, With removal of the outer lines of the raw data (high spatial frequencies), details are lost but contrast is preserved. C, With removal of the central lines of the data (low spatial frequencies), image contrast is lost, leaving a ghostly image showing tissue boundaries only.
The k-space trajectory for any pulse sequence must span all the (kx, ky) points to generate a complete image. For instance, with standard GRE or SE sequences, one phase-encoding step is applied and one line of data is collected (i.e., all kx points for one value of ky) after each RF excitation. The k-space trajectory thus consists of a series of horizontal lines as shown in Figure 7-20. This is repeated as many times as necessary to complete the full raw data. All frequency samples in k-space are acquired in each readout period, corresponding to one pulse of the readout gradient. At the other extreme, advanced sequences using the EPI encoding, for example, use a strong bipolar oscillating gradient field to generate a train of gradient-echoes that are phase encoded independently after the application of a single RF excitation, thus collecting the full k-space matrix in a single shot.
Partial Fourier page 206 page 207
Add to lightbox
Figure 7-20 The k-space trajectory for standard gradient-echo (GRE) sequence. Data are acquired one line at a time for each TR interval.
When the through-plane resolution of a 2D projection image exceeds a few millimeters, intravoxel dephasing of signal reduces the image contrast. Therefore, in many regions of the anatomy, 2D projection images are not an option and 3D images must be acquired. Since imaging 3D volumes requires an order of magnitude more imaging time than 2D projection techniques, the need for time-resolved MR acquisitions has prompted the use of k-space undersampling. A simple technique to reduce the imaging time while minimizing the loss of resolution is to acquire only a fraction of the full
3 of 18
12-04-2010 00:12
Printed from: Clinical Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 3rd editio... http://www.clinicalmri.com/content/printpage.cfm?ID=HC007041
4 of 18
set of k-space data. If half of the full set of MR image data is acquired, the image acquisition time is cut in half. Normally, the phase-encoding gradient is gradually increased from large negative amplitude, to zero, to large positive amplitude (or vice versa) over the course of an acquisition. Using a partial-Fourier acquisition, fewer data are collected and the remaining data are mathematically synthesized. In the half-Fourier version, for instance, only the positive phase-encoding steps are acquired, along with the 86,90,91 zero step and a few negative ones. A mirror image copy of the positive data is created, and a complete image is reconstructed from the acquired and synthetic data (Fig. 7-21). As only a little more than half the data is acquired, scan time is reduced nearly two-fold. In practice, half-Fourier techniques reduce scan time by slightly less than 50%, because the mirror image symmetry of the data is only true for a hypothetic "ideal" acquisition. The actual MR data have phase offsets that distort the symmetry of the matrix. Most half-Fourier techniques require the acquisition of some extra negative phase-encoding steps to calculate phase corrections for the data (Fig. 7-22). Partial-Fourier is a robust and routinely useful technique for time-resolved perfusion imaging and MRA. Moreo