Integrated Series in Information Systems Volume 25
Series Editors Ramesh Sharda Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK, USA Stefan Voß University of Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany
For further volumes: http://www.springer.com/series/6157
Christopher G. Reddick Editor
Comparative E-Government
123
Editor Christopher G. Reddick Department of Public Administration University of Texas San Antonio, TX 78207, USA
[email protected]
ISSN 1571-0270 ISBN 978-1-4419-6535-6 e-ISBN 978-1-4419-6536-3 DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3 Springer New York Dordrecht Heidelberg London Library of Congress Control Number: 2010930823 © Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010 All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. Printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
This book is dedicated to my father George William Reddick.
Preface
Electronic government or e-government has impacted all countries of the world. E-government is not just a movement that has transpired in one particular country, it is truly a global phenomenon, impacting both developed and developing nations. Essentially, e-government has influenced nations on all corners of the earth to different degrees. The discussion of e-government does not necessarily imply that Web sites are the only mechanism for its expression; many new and emerging technologies have appeared recently and are part of the e-government movement, such as wireless and new social media technologies. This book is one of the first of its kind to examine e-government across different nations. The research on e-government took off with the commercialization and rise of the Internet in the mid-1990s. The Internet became a viable tool for businesses to reach more customers and essentially made it more accessible to a broader array of individuals. Emerging in a new millennium many scholars touted some of the promises of e-government to be revolutionary having the ability to change both the nature of government operations and the way the citizens interact with their government. We now know that e-government as envisioned during this period has not lived up to expectations, but it still resonates given the broad and continued discussion on the topic and its continued application throughout the world. E-government has multiple meanings and has been defined numerous times by both scholars and practitioners. As mentioned, government Web sites were what e-government was originally envisioned upon, but as we know new technologies have emerged and are also part of e-government. One common thread, through most definitions of e-government, indicates its ability to transform government and make it more responsive and accountable to citizens. The chapters in the book address the transformational impact of e-government in many nations of the world. The book Comparative E-Government examines the impact of information and communication technology (ICT) on the governments throughout the world. The focus of this book is to examine the adoption of e-government in countries both by comparing different countries, and by focusing on individual countries and the success and challenges that they have faced. This book has 32 chapters from leading e-government scholars and practitioners from around the world. There is representation of developing and developed countries in this book and their different stages of e-government adoption. There vii
viii
Preface
are three parts in this book. Part I compares the adoption of e-government in two or more countries. The purpose of these chapters is to discern the development of e-government by comparing different countries and their individual experiences. As the reader will see from Part I e-government, although a global phenomena, has more of an impact on some countries than others. Its impact is global, but the degree of adoption varies with the nature of the country, its social and demographic characteristics, and degree of economic development. Part I in its analysis of e-government across different countries had some interesting common findings. The chapters in this part demonstrate that many developing countries are struggling with providing the most basic infrastructure for ICT, which limits citizens’ use of e-government. However, mobile technologies make Internet connectivity more promising for developing countries. E-government development across both developing and developed countries seems to be more at the publishing and two-way interaction stages of development. There is not a lot of wholesale transformation as a result of e-government. Some factors that are associated with more successful e-government adoption are leadership, collaboration, and civic engagement. In order for governments to effectively implement more advanced e-government systems, they need to listen to their stakeholders. One way for more successful e-government adoption is a bottom up approach where adoption is driven by stakeholders and their opinions and uses of systems. The digital divide is one of the most pressing issues that all countries face in the adoption of e-government, an issue that is not likely to go away in the near future. Part II of this book provides more in-depth focus of case studies on the adoption of e-government in select countries. Similarly to part one, the Part II shows that development is global, and varies in the context of the country. The lessons learned here is that e-government cannot just be applied from one country to the next, the context of the country must be taken into account. Essentially, there is no one-sizefits-all approach to e-government that will be successful, therefore, more research should be conducted on providing individual country case studies. For instance, some of the chapters discuss that implementation of e-governance in many developing countries is weakened due to challenges such as the lack of transparency and broadband infrastructure. Another issue addressed in the second part is that many countries are approaching e-government as service delivery rather than enhancing democracy and participation. The cultural and legal aspect of the country has a tremendous impact on e-government adoption. Many chapters discuss the state of the art in e-government development, examining political, infrastructure, and funding issues. Part III, the last part of the book, examines emerging innovations and technologies in the adoption of e-government in different countries. Some of the emerging technologies are the new social media movement, the development of e-participation, interoperability, and geographic information systems (GIS). The purpose of Part III is to leave the reader with some of the new issues that have emerged and will become part of e-government in the future. Some of the issues discussed in Part III are e-government adoption and participation through GIS systems. Usability of e-government and the digital divide in
Preface
ix
general are issues that still need to be addressed. Access to information laws will enhance transparency and accountability of governments and some nations are more developed in this than others. New social media technologies such as Web 2.0 can influence citizen participation in government. Other issues such as performance measurement, accountability, and budget transparency are addressed as important issues for the future of e-government. This book would not be possible without the tireless work of the authors. This book was peer reviewed, with each chapter reviewed by at least three reviewers. Without the helpful comments of these reviewers this book would not be possible. I believe that both scholars and practitioners will find this book useful, having both theoretical and best practices in e-government. In addition, the global coverage of Comparative E-Government provides insights into the development of e-government in both developed and developing countries throughout the world, which is unmatched in existing books. San Antonio, Texas
Christopher G. Reddick
Contents
Part I
Comparing Countries and Regions
1 E-government Maturity over 10 Years: A Comparative Analysis of E-government Maturity in Select Countries Around the World . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . M. Naveed Baqir and Lakshmi Iyer 2 Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level . . . . Hakikur Rahman
3 23
3 A Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites of Middle East and North African (MENA) Countries . . Abebe Rorissa, Devendra Potnis, and Dawit Demissie
49
4 Towards E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Girish J. “Jeff ” Gulati, David J. Yates, and Anas Tawileh
71
5 Evaluation of the Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ourania I. Markaki, Dimitris E. Charilas, and Dimitrios Askounis
91
6 A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road: Lessons Learned from E-governments in China and India . . . . . . . . . . Alankar Bandyopadhyay and Sahar D. Sattarzadeh
115
7 Digital Government in North America: A Comparative Analysis of Policy and Program Priorities in Canada, Mexico, and the United States . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Luis F. Luna-Reyes, Theresa A. Pardo, J. Ramon Gil-Garcia, Celene Navarrete, Jing Zhang, and Sehl Mellouli
139
8 Adoption of Web 2.0 by Canadian and US Governments . . . . . . F. Dianne Lux Wigand
161
xi
xii
Contents
9 E-government and Federalism in Italy and Canada—A Comparative Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Barbara -Chiara Ubaldi and Jeffrey Roy 10
11
Adoption of E-government by Disadvantaged Groups in the United States and the United Kingdom . . . . . . . . . . . . Doria Pilling
201
Implementing E-Government Locally—An Empirical Survey from the European Metropolitan Area Rhine-Neckar . . . Sebastian Olbrich
221
Part II 12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
183
Country Case Studies
E-government Adoption Landscape Zambia: Context, Issues, and Challenges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bwalya Kelvin Joseph
241
Challenges of Effective E-governance: Problems of Transparency, Infrastructure, and Connectivity in Kenya . . . . . David Wachira and Sudha Arlikatti
259
The Politics of E-government in Spain: Between Recent Innovations and Old Inertias . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J. Ignacio Criado
275
Technological Adoption of a Privatised E-government: Implications for Democracy and Socially Marginalised Communities in Brazil . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . José Rodrigues Filho
299
The Challenges of E-governance in a Small, Developing Society: The Case of Trinidad and Tobago . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ann Marie Bissessar
313
Towards E-government Transformation in Turkey: Policy and Implementation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Hatice Özkan Sancak and Sevcan Güleç
331
Measuring E-government Adoption by Governments: The Greek Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Leonidas G. Anthopoulos, Vassilis C. Gerogiannis, and Panos Fitsilis Critical Factors for Adoption of E-government: Validity of Adoption Model in Indian Context . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mahmud A. Shareef, Norm Archer, Vedmani Sharan, and Vinod Kumar
353
371
Contents
xiii
20
Conceptualizing and Implementation of E-government in India . . Subhajyoti Ray
391
21
E-government in the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus . . . . Mustafa Sa˘gsan and Mete Yıldız
409
22
SCRAN’s Development of a Trans-national Comparator for the Standardisation of E-government Services . . . . . . . . . . Mark Deakin
425
Part III Innovations and Emerging Technologies 23
Public Participation Geographic Information Systems: A Literature Survey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sukumar Ganapati
24
Learning with GIS-Based Monitors in the Netherlands . . . . . . . Dennis de Kool
25
Bridging the Other Divide: An Assessment of the Usability of Trinidad and Tobago Government Ministry Websites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Charlene M.L. Roach and N. Joseph Cayer
26
27
28
29
30
E-government in New Zealand: Local Governments, Digital Divides and the National Digital Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kay Fielden and Pam Malcolm A Study of E-government and Political Indicators in Developing Nations with and Without Access-toInformation Laws . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jeannine E. Relly
449 467
483
505
525
Socializing E-governance: A Parallel Study of Participatory E-governance and Emerging Social Media . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Eleni -Revekka Staiou and Dimitris Gouscos
543
E-government, Accountability, and Performance: Best-in-Class Governments in European Union Countries . . . . . Rebecca L. Orelli, Emanuele Padovani, and Eric Scorsone
561
The OECD Budgetary Transparency: An Examination of Online Budgetary Information Across European Union Countries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Carmen Caba Pérez, Manuel Pedro Rodríguez Bolívar, and Antonio Manuel López Hernández
587
xiv
31
32
Contents
Does Size or Geography Matter? Empirical Analysis of Finnish Local Government Services on the Internet . . . . . . . Tommi A. Inkinen E-government Interoperability Framework: A Case Study in a Developing Country . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pavel Shvaiko, Adolfo Villafiorita, Alessandro Zorer, Lourino Chemane, and Teotonio Fumo
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
615
639
663
Contributors
Leonidas G. Anthopoulos Project Management Department, TEI of Larissa, Larissa, Thessaly 41110, Greece,
[email protected] Norm Archer McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada L8S 4L8,
[email protected] Sudha Arlikatti University of North Texas, Denton, TX 76203-0617, USA,
[email protected] Dimitrios Askounis National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, 15780 Athens, Greece,
[email protected] Alankar Bandyopadhyay University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA,
[email protected] M. Naveed Baqir University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716, USA,
[email protected] Ann Marie Bissessar The University of the West Indies, St Augustine, Trinidad, West Indies,
[email protected] Manuel Pedro Rodríguez Bolívar University of Granada, Granada 18071, Spain,
[email protected] N. Joseph Cayer Arizona State University, Phoenix, AZ 85004, USA,
[email protected] Dimitris E. Charilas National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, 15780 Athens, Greece,
[email protected] Lourino Chemane UTICT – ICT Policy Implementation Technical Unit, Maputo, Mozambique,
[email protected] J. Ignacio Criado Department of Political Science and International Relations, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain,
[email protected] Mark Deakin Centre for Learning Communities, Academic Development, Edinburgh Napier University, Edinburgh, UK,
[email protected]
xv
xvi
Contributors
Dennis de Kool Erasmus University Rotterdam, P.O. Box 1738, 3000 DR Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
[email protected] Dawit Demissie University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany, NY 12222, USA,
[email protected] Kay Fielden Unitec Institute of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand,
[email protected] José Rodrigues Filho Universidade Federal da Paraíba, João Pessoa, Brazil,
[email protected] Panos Fitsilis Project Management Department, TEI of Larissa, Larissa, Thessaly 41110, Greece,
[email protected] Teotonio Fumo UTICT — ICT Policy Implementation Technical Unit, Maputo, Mozambique,
[email protected] Sukumar Ganapati Public Administration Department, PCA 363B School of International and Public Affairs, College of Arts and Sciences, Florida International University, Miami, FL 33199, USA,
[email protected] Vassilis C. Gerogiannis Project Management Department, TEI of Larissa, Larissa, Thessaly 41110, Greece,
[email protected] J. Ramon Gil-Garcia Centro de Investigacion y Docencia Economicas, Mexico, DF 01210, Mexico,
[email protected] Dimitris Gouscos University of Athens, Athens 105 62, Greece,
[email protected] Girish J. “Jeff” Gulati Bentley University, Waltham, MA 02452, USA,
[email protected] Sevcan Güleç Gazi University, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Be¸sevler, Ankara, Turkey,
[email protected] Antonio Manuel López Hernández University of Granada, Granada 18071, Spain,
[email protected] Tommi A. Inkinen University of Helsinki, Department of Geosciences and Geography, Helsinki 00014, Finland,
[email protected] Lakshmi Iyer University of North Carolina, Greensboro, NC 27412, USA,
[email protected] Bwalya Kelvin Joseph University of Botswana, Gaborone, Botswana,
[email protected] Vinod Kumar Carleton University, Ottawa, ON, Canada K1C 5X7,
[email protected]
Contributors
xvii
Luis F. Luna-Reyes Universidad de las Americas Puebla, Cholula, Puebla 72820, Mexico,
[email protected] Pam Malcolm Unitec Institute of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand,
[email protected] Ourania I. Markaki National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, 15780 Athens, Greece,
[email protected] Sehl Mellouli Laval University, Quebec, QC, Canada G1V 0A6,
[email protected] Celene Navarrete California State University, Dominguez Hills, Carson, CA 90747, USA,
[email protected] Sebastian Olbrich University of Duisburg-Essen (Campus Duisburg), Mercator School of Management, Lotharstraße, 65 47057 Duisburg, Germany,
[email protected] Rebecca L. Orelli University of Bologna, Bologna 47126, Italy,
[email protected] Emanuele Padovani University of Bologna, Bologna 47126, Italy,
[email protected] Theresa A. Pardo Center for Technology in Government, University at Albany, SUNY, Albany, NY 12205, USA,
[email protected] Carmen Caba Pérez University of Almería, Almería 04120, Spain,
[email protected] Doria Pilling School of Community and Health Sciences, City University London, London EC1A 7QN, UK,
[email protected] Devendra Potnis University of Tennessee at Knoxville, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA,
[email protected] Hakikur Rahman Institute of Computer Management & Science, Mirpur, Dhaka 1216, Bangladesh,
[email protected] Subhajyoti Ray Xavier Institute of Management, Bhubaneswar, Orissa 751013, India,
[email protected] Jeannine E. Relly University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ, USA,
[email protected] Charlene M.L. Roach The University of the West Indies, St. Augustine Campus, Trinidad & Tobago, West Indies,
[email protected] Abebe Rorissa University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany, NY 12222, USA,
[email protected] Jeffrey Roy Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada B3H 3J5,
[email protected]
xviii
Contributors
Mustafa Sa˘gsan Ba¸skent University, Ankara, Turkey,
[email protected] Hatice Özkan Sancak Gazi University, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Be¸sevler, Ankara, Turkey,
[email protected] Sahar D. Sattarzadeh University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA,
[email protected] Eric Scorsone Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA,
[email protected] Vedmani Sharan Carleton University, Ottawa, ON, Canada K1C 5X7,
[email protected] Mahmud A. Shareef McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada L8S 4L8,
[email protected] Pavel Shvaiko TasLab, Informatica Trentina S.p.A., Trento, Italy,
[email protected] Eleni-Revekka Staiou University of Athens, Athens 105 62, Greece,
[email protected] Anas Tawileh Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales CF24 3AA, UK,
[email protected] Barbara-Chiara Ubaldi OECD, 2, rue André Pascal, 75775 Paris Cedex 16, France,
[email protected] Adolfo Villafiorita Fondazione Bruno Kessler IRST, Trento, Italy,
[email protected] David Wachira University of North Texas, Denton, TX 76203-0617, USA,
[email protected] F. Dianne Lux Wigand Institute of Government, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Little Rock, AR 72204, USA,
[email protected] David J. Yates Bentley University, Waltham, MA 02452, USA,
[email protected] Mete Yıldız Hacettepe University, Ankara, Turkey,
[email protected] Jing Zhang Clark University, Worcester, MA 01610, USA,
[email protected] Alessandro Zorer CREATE-NET, Trento, Italy,
[email protected]
Part I
Comparing Countries and Regions
Chapter 1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years: A Comparative Analysis of E-government Maturity in Select Countries Around the World M. Naveed Baqir and Lakshmi Iyer
Over the past decade, we have seen a revolution in the provision of e-government services to citizens. While information communication technologies (ICT) make it possible to develop and deploy e-government services, there are remarkable differences in the reasons behind varying levels of e-government use in different countries. While developed countries, e.g., United States and many European countries, have advanced ICT infrastructures, e-government services usage by citizens is still limited. Developing countries are still struggling to develop and deploy basic infrastructure for ICT, which limits people’s ability to use e-government services that have already been developed. This contrast presents a unique set of issues, which poses challenges to citizens to efficiently and effectively use e-government services. This study examines several developed and developing countries from six continents around the globe on the basis of their past and current e-government initiatives, discuss goals, and objectives as well as benefits and challenges of e-government. The countries we examine include: United States and Canada (North America); United Kingdom and Germany (Europe); India, and Pakistan (Asia); Australia and New Zealand (Australia); Kenya and Nigeria (Africa); Argentina and Brazil (South America). We use published, archival, and current reports to examine the e-government maturity in each of the countries. Understanding the trends and challenges in e-government will help policy makers, developers, and service providers design and deliver better e-government services.
M.N. Baqir (B) University of Delaware, Newark, DE 19716, USA e-mail:
[email protected] L. Iyer University of North Carolina, Greensboro, NC 27412, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_1, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
3
4
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
1 Introduction Recognizing the benefits of improved efficiency in delivering government services through electronic medium, e-government initiatives have increased rapidly in the last decade (Weerakkody, Choudrie, & Currie, 2004). Examples of such public sector services include (but not limited to) tax filing, identity management (including issuance and renewal of identity cards, driving licenses, and passports), online application for government jobs, determination of eligibility for government benefits, obtaining of birth certificates/marriage licenses, renewal of driver licenses, application for high school grants, registering to vote, and in some cases casting of votes. The nature of government service delivery has been facing rapid transformation in the recent years (Heeks & Bailura, 2007; Mosse & Whitley, 2009). New service industries; better delivery of services; and faster, cheaper communication are some of the by-products of this technological revolution (Devadoss, Pan, & Huang, 2002). While the idea of using computers and networks for government service delivery is not new, the challenges in the development, deployment, and use of e-government continues to plague policy makers, developers, and service providers. Due to political, organizational, and technical challenges, many of the e-government initiatives are lagging behind user expectations (United Nations Report, 2008). While similar challenges exist in private sectors, businesses have implemented Business Process Management (BPM) practices to increase agility, productivity, and operational effectiveness and now there is growing pressure from citizens and businesses for public sectors to do the same since e-government builds on e-business principles (Weerakkody et al., 2004). To leverage the effect of modern technologies, it is important that organizational processes are documented, understood, and properly coordinated with its information technology (IT) strategy. The implementation of e-government implies different objectives and levels of transformation. For instance, in the United States, the main objective is to automate and integrate different islands of information to simplify and maximize the benefits of technology (Iyer, Baqir, & Vollmer, 2006; Navarra & Cornford, 2003), whereas in Europe the emphasis is to modernize public services and offer better services to citizens (Cuddy, 2003). However, whatever may be the primary goal, the effective delivery of e-services requires process and information systems (IS) integration and coordination of processes between disparate organizations and stakeholders. Historically, bureaucracies associated within government organizations prevent them from being effective (Wilson, 1989). Even after the emergence of e-government, most of those bureaucratic processes still involve manual work and have abundant (and redundant) checkpoints. When the stakeholders in a process work as separate entities, each managing or dealing with disconnected silos of knowledge and information, it is very hard to deliver a service efficiently. Hence, the first step toward efficient delivery of services is to facilitate a transparent
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
5
networked environment where governments can truly partner with other governments, businesses, citizens, and additional stakeholders (GAO, 2003). Because governments are increasingly looking toward a digital future, e-government yields an interesting area of research. The chapter gives an overview of the major e-government measurement methods that lay the foundation for the e-government maturity model. The chapter also reviews e-government initiatives during the last 10 years in several developed and developing countries from four continents (i.e., North America, Europe, Asia, and Australia) and identifies major issues between the e-government services usage. It also looks at the results of the comparative analysis between these countries and maps them on an e-government maturity model. A discussion of the difficulties and future challenges that citizens face when using e-government services will benefit policy makers, service developers, and service providers in designing and delivering better e-government services. The chapter concludes by highlighting future trends and challenges for e-government.
2 Background E-government definitions have evolved over the last 10 years and efforts to comprehensively describe it in a single statement seem impossible. However, a common understanding is that e-government refers to the use of information and communication technologies (ICTs), particularly Web-based applications, to provide faster, cheaper, easier, and more efficient access to and delivery of information/services to the public, businesses, other agencies (non-profit), and governmental entities (Biancucci et al., 2001; Dearstyne, 2001; Palvia & Sharma, 2007). This in turn, enhances relationships, enlarges the overall customer base, and improves core business operations through re-examination of internal processes. During the last 10 years several ideas of providing modern administration and democracy in public service delivery have emerged with a major component of bringing transparency to public dealing. E-government is considered as a “guiding vision toward modern administration and democracy” (Wimmer & Traunmuller, 2000). E-government has been reportedly instrumental in bringing transparency to public dealing (Cho & Byung-Dae, 2004). The focus of e-government has also shifted toward constituencies and stakeholders at all levels including government at the city, county, state, national, or even international levels (Palvia & Sharma, 2007). Essentially, it is with the transformation that governments and public administration have to undergo in the future. Hence, e-government is not an option but a must for governments to realize the benefits of ICTs to not fall behind. E-government is also seen as “transferring power to people, by operating in a one-stop, non-stop way, and doing more for less” (Lawson, 1998). Research on technology emphasizes that “technology is only one of the structural materials” (Nadler & Tushman, 1997),
6
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
indicating that e-government goes beyond the mere use of IT. The challenge is to effectively redesign the interaction between governments, citizens, and businesses which automatically implies the reorganization of internal processes.
2.1 Stages of E-government In order to evaluate e-government maturity in selected countries around the world, we present the theoretical foundations in this section. Several researchers have developed e-government framework and its evaluation plans (Grant & Derek, 2005). A widely used model which recognizes four stages of e-government development: (1) cataloguing, (2) transaction, (3) vertical integration, and (4) horizontal integration (Layne & Lee, 2001). Within the first stage, governments set up their initial online presence. This includes, and is very often limited, to the online presentation of information. Governments, citizens, and businesses are not able to conduct any transactions. Instead, efforts focus on the internal collection of information, their (re)organization, and final presentation on the Web. However, forms might be downloaded, printed, and then sent back via the normal postal system. The second stage, transaction, includes an increase in services and access to online forms. Citizens and businesses are now able to engage in electronic transactions with governments. Examples include the use of interactive forms and digital signatures for tasks such as registering a business, applying for a building permit, or filing for unemployment benefits. In addition, governments will increase their efforts in linking their internal procedures to the online world. While cataloguing is characterized by sparse integration as well as simple technological and organizational complexity, horizontal integration is characterized by integration within each level. Integration along different levels, local, state, and federal characterizes vertical integration. Figure 1.1 shows the visual representation of this model.
Fig. 1.1 Vertical and horizontal integration (Layne & Lee, 2001)
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
7
Fig. 1.2 Phases of Web measure index (United Nations Report, 2008)
A recent model (see Fig. 1.2) developed by the 2008 United Nations study on e-government, identifies five stages for Web measure index. These stages include: (1) emerging, (2) enhanced, (3) interactive, (4) transaction, and (5) connected. Accordingly to this model, countries face different thresholds in terms of infrastructure development, content delivery, business re-engineering, data management, security, and customer management. In the first stage, government Web sites might make basic information about government department available. In the second stage they might have more public policy governance-related information. In third stage, the governments may provide downloadable forms. In the fourth stage, governments might actually be involved in public–government transactions. In the last stage, different level and departments of governments may transform themselves in the form of an integrated back office infrastructure. It is clear from the descriptions of these two models that during the last decade, while new ideas might have evolved, the basic understanding of the stages remains somewhat same. Therefore, the next section on country comparison provides more insights into how to classify different countries within the described framework. For citizens, businesses, and governments, aggressive moves toward an increased integration are desirable since they offer better access to a broader number of governmental services and reduce functional barriers within governments themselves. During the past 10 years, several authors have reported on the advantages of e-government with concrete examples of actual e-government systems that resulted in real cost savings. At the same time, there have been several publications that report on the challenges e-governments face. Table 1.1 lists a summary these advantages and limitations presented in literature on e-government (Accenture, 2004, 2009; Dhillon, 2001; Dillon, Deakins, & Chen, 2006; Iyer et al., 2006; Seifert & Petersen, 2002; Symonds, 2000; Tillman, 2003). While advantages and challenges as addressed in the literature are given in a single table, their location in the table
8
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer Table 1.1 Summary of advantages and challenges related to e-government initiatives
Advantages
Challenges
Increases efficiency and effectiveness Increases communication Eliminates redundancies and inconsistencies Enhances transparency Yields opportunities to partner with private sector Can have repercussions on entire economy Spurs adoption of internet Reduces costs (communication, information, labor, and material) Improves speed and service delivery, broadens reach, eliminates distance problems Increases convenience Empowers citizens
Privacy/security/confidentiality concerns Information overload How to value information
Attracts investments, businesses and skilled people Increases amount of available information Improves utilization of resources
Web sites do not work/are outdated Benefits often linked only to high stages of development Internal resistance/lack of leadership Lack of resources/capabilities/infrastructure High investments necessary Eliminates personal interaction/contact/possibility to ask questions Threatens jobs Advertising opportunities limited and hence less awareness Vast size and bureaucratic nature of governments reduces flexibility Enhance citizen trust in e-government
does not necessarily indicate rank ordering or imply direct relationship with other advantages and challenges.
3 Country Comparison The core ideas and techniques associated with putting governments online first emerged in the most developed western countries in the mid-1990s. Then, throughout the past years other countries have also established their own e-government Web sites. For developed countries, however, the issue is no longer whether government is or should be online, but in what form and with what consequences. These countries have expanded participatory services online through the use of e-participation portals and online consultation mechanisms encouraging citizen feedback on important economic and social policy issues (United Nations Report, 2008). An Accenture study revealed that in 2004 (Accenture, 2004), 173 of the United Nations’ 191 members operated Web sites and 18 countries, predominantly in Africa, remain completely offline. However, there are only three nations for which governments do not yet have an online presence by 2008, i.e., Central African Republic, Somalia, and Zambia. In 2009, Central African Republic and Somalia are the only two countries that still do not have official government Web sites. Even though most countries have developed some level of online presence, use of
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
9
e-government services is still very limited (United Nations Report, 2008). The reasoning is that very often the public sectors’ offerings differ from what users really want. Also, despite all the improvements that have been made so far only 15 governments in the world accept the publics’ comments on policy issues and only 32 allow online transactions. In developing countries about 60% of all e-government projects fail and about half waste tax payer money (United Nations Report, 2008). Based on the theoretical foundation developed in the previous section, e-government maturity index is developed and shown in Fig. 1.3. This figure displays the relative positioning of selected countries on the “e-government maturity index” that was developed on the basis of Layne and Lee’s (2001) four stage.
Fig. 1.3 2001 E-government maturity model (Layne & Lee, 2001)
Since the UN 2008 study provides more granularity in e-government development stages, the new model we develop a newer model based upon those five stages, as shown in Fig. 1.4. These two models (Figs. 1.3 and 1.4) signify the differences in the comparison between different countries on e-government maturity index and how these countries have further developed or dropped in their e-government maturity. Canada and Singapore, which took the top maturity spots in 2006 have switched places with Denmark, Sweden, and Norway. This switch is consistent with the surveys done by UN in 2005 and 2008. For example, UK dropped in e-participation
10
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
Norway, Sweden, Denmark, United States United Kingdom, Singapore, Australia, Japan, France, Canada, New Zealand, Germany
Mexico, Brazil, South Africa, Argentina, United Arab Emirates
Pakistan, India, China, Jordan, Kenya, Nigeria
Fig. 1.4 An update on e-government maturity
index ranking from 1st position in 2005 to 24th in 2008 (United Nations Report, 2008). The drop in ranking signifies the fact that several countries give up on keeping up with e-government services innovation while others continuously improve (United Nations Report, 2008). These rankings are based upon quantitative data from 2004 Accenture study, UN 2005 study, UN 2008 study, and qualitative evaluation of several countries on the basis of the established e-government services, improvement since 2006 and new e-government initiatives as discussed in the following sections. E-government strategies in countries from six continents, i.e., Africa, Asia, Australia, Europe, North America, and South American are presented in more detail below.
3.1 Africa African continent is home to a very diverse population. Diversity in languages, cultures, histories, religions, resources, and economies are visible in the diversity of government infrastructures across the continent. From stable democracies to monarchies, and from military dictators to warlords waging massacres, the concept of e-government is considered foreign which is built upon imported e-government designs. Africa is the only continent where some countries (Central African Republic and Somalia) do not even have a basic government Web site.
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
11
In some cases individuals or groups have developed Web sites that claim it to be an “official government Website” (e.g., somaligovernment.org) to fill the gap of a properly maintained government Web site. In some parts of Africa extensive e-government infrastructure development efforts started as early as the late 1980s and early 1990s. From using Information and Decision Support Systems (IDSS) to facilitate intra-government communication in Egypt (Kamel, 1998) to the use of geographic information system to register electorates and support elections process in South Africa (Microsoft, 2000) shows that the potential of e-government has increased in Africa over time. While there are still several challenges with regards to technical, legal, institutional, human, and leadership issues, one can expect countries in Africa to leap ahead of others by learning from e-government success and failure stories of other countries.
3.1.1 Kenya E-government in Kenya has grown during the last 10 years. However, most of the growth benefits citizens in the larger urban centers such as Nairobi, Mombasa, Nakuru, and Kisumu. The establishment of e-government directorate has lead to development on several fronts. This directorate has been instrumental in providing computers, software, infrastructure, and training in different government bodies. Presently, e-government directorate offers connectivity to public service jobs search and application; status tracking of identity card; and passport, filing of taxes, and customs. Kenya’s e-government strategy revolves around providing government messaging and collaboration system (EMACS), developing data centers, enhancements of ministerial Web portals, implementation of e-applications, and development of information communication infrastructure (E-government Directorate in Kenya, 2009, www.e-government.go.ke). Kenya has to further develop its ICT infrastructure to expand its services to citizens in remote areas. After a careful review and comparison of government maturity with other countries, we have placed it at “Enhanced” level in Fig. 1.4.
3.1.2 Nigeria E-government in Nigeria has been progressing steadily over the last several years. The e-government implementation framework has rolled-out several “citizen-centric projects” (Agunloye, 2007). While the range of e-government services is limited, the ones that are available are very well-developed. From online registration and record management of citizens and businesses to online passport applications are providing government services to citizens at their door steps. However, the ICT infrastructure is not available to most of the population outside the few large urban areas. After a careful review of e-government maturity in Nigeria, we have placed it in the “Enhanced” category in Fig. 1.4.
12
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
3.2 Asia Asian countries present interesting contrast in the level of penetration and use of e-government services. On one side, there are countries such as Singapore, South Korea, and Japan that have high degree of Internet infrastructure penetration and are attempting to be 100% paperless. On the other side, there are countries such as India and Pakistan where a number of impressive e-government services implementation become spectacular failures because ordinary citizens cannot use them due to the lack of access to ICT infrastructure. We take a look at the e-government maturity in India and Pakistan in detail below. 3.2.1 India According to the Ministry of IT in India (Ministry of IT, 2005), mostly southern states in India have implemented several e-government projects after establishing considerably good IT infrastructure. Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra, and Chandigarh are ranked leaders in e-readiness index for e-government delivery. Even though India was using computerized databases for its military, elections, economic planning, national census, and tax collection, it was not until 1990s that citizens could directly interface with e-government projects. Projects such as Bhoomi (land administration for Karnataka), CARD (land administration for Andhra Pradesh), Gyandoot (computing services for villagers), e-seva (utility bill payments in Andhra Pradesh), Akshaya (computer training for villagers in Kerala), Lokvani (various government services), and SARI (wireless internet link for villagers) are both aspiring and indicative of public–private interest in creating an environment to develop and use e-government services even though teledensity stands at 12.74% (India Core, 2006), telecom growth in certain states is phenomenonal. With approximately 541 Gbps international bandwidth link, all what’s left is to create and establish in-house infrastructure for the people living in far off places in India. We have places in India at the “Enhanced” level in Fig. 1.4. 3.2.2 Pakistan Information technology infrastructure is one of the fundamental requirements for the establishment of e-government deployment and use. The turn of the millennium proved to be a tipping point for Pakistan’s information technology infrastructure. Teledensity in Pakistan has grown from 2.80% in 2000 to 64% in 2009 (Pakistan Telecommunication Authority [PTA], 2009). Internet users grew from 10,000 users in 10 major cities in 1999 to over 5 million (internet service providers’ association claims this number to be 10 million) in over 400 cities in 2009 (PTA, 2009). Increasing deployment of high-speed Internet (mostly DSL/ADSL), is creating an opportunity for the development of e-government environment. Even with expanding use of high-speed Internet, number of companies offering online products/services are negligibly small (less than 1% of the population). With an enormous growth in infrastructure during the past few years, Government of
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
13
Pakistan took multiple initiatives including the establishment of ministry of IT and telecom, national database and registration authority (NADRA—citizens’ database and identity management), national IT policy, electronic government directorate, computerized electoral rolls, and computerization of land ownership records and electronic filing of taxes (Baqir & Parvez, 2000; Election Commission of Pakistan [ECP], 2009; Electronic Government Directorate [EGD], 2009; Mujahid, 2002). These initiatives are in addition to steps in the 5-year plan for e-government implementation strategy plan given in. Even though Pakistani Government’s plans are exciting and aspiring, e-business is almost nonexistent in the country. This leads to a strange situation where government is offering multiple avenues to its citizens to utilize e-government services but citizens are not familiar with what can be done online. Lack of local language content is a major inhibitor in citizens’ ability to use e-government services effectively. There is also a lack of statistical evidence to investigate the extent to which these e-government initiates are actually being used by the citizens. In addition to trust issues on the e-government, access control and security mechanisms prohibit wide spread use of online services. Keeping in view these developments in e-government maturity in Pakistan, we have placed it in “Enhanced” category in Fig. 1.4.
3.3 Australia Australia and New Zealand, in the Australian continent provide their citizens several e-government services. These two countries placed with countries with transactional e-government services. Literature on e-government projects, initiates, and evaluations in Australia and New Zealand is extensive and focuses on the transactional and connectedness issues (Gauld, Graya, & McComba, 2009). 3.3.1 Australia Even though Australian government started providing e-government services for about a decade now, strategy toward e-governance launched in 2006 has led to wide variety of e-government-related research issues. A major challenge faced in Australia is to protect citizens’ data secure, and create a seamless operation between agencies that may currently be working on a number of different software systems or technologies. The focus on the development of integrated and customer-oriented online services to respond faster while reducing costs puts them in “transactional” e-government maturity level in our model. However, the challenge to deal with more sophisticated and complicated integration of government services still remains a challenge and a major hindrance. 3.3.2 New Zealand The e-government services and challenges are not new in New Zealand. Implementation of e-government is an interesting case in New Zealand. It only has
14
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
two levels of government and therefore traditional concepts of local, state, and federal government do not apply. From e-government at local level to the federal level, shifting policy maker’s views are changing the nature of government in this country. New Zealand recognizes the needs or potential needs of information gathering and sharing among its citizens and the global community. Their awareness is evident in the various initiatives they have spearheaded in the country. The projects as such as setting up an infrastructure that provides faster, cheaper broadband to encourage innovation and add value, using familiar social technologies including social networking Web sites and tools like blogs, wikis, and folksonomies—and the full range of digital channels—mobile phones, instant messaging, podcasts, and digital TV, as well as Internet pathways are delivering value. A single library management system provides access to Auckland city, Manukau, North Shore, Rodney, and Waitakere Libraries by using RFID technology to manage their book collections. The challenges however are numerous. The biggest one is the problem of collaboration between agencies; tools have been developed to promote collaboration online but there is a lot of room for improvement in actual use-related statistics. They fall under the “Transactional” category in the e-government maturity level as shown in Fig. 1.4.
3.4 Europe Europe represents a wide level of diversity as far as e-government maturity is concerned. Several countries, particularly in Scandinavia, e-government maturity is very high. Data from UN 2008 survey also suggest that Norway, Sweden, and Denmark now lead United States if citizen participation in e-government is concerned. There are several countries especially in eastern Europe that are still at either emerging or enhanced phase of Web maturity index. In 2000, the European Summits at Lisbon and Feira redefined the continent’s e-government ambitions by setting four guidelines. The new agenda include the continuous development of Internet-based services to improve access to information and services, the improvement of transparency of public administration, the full exploitation of information technology, and the establishment of e-procurement. These objectives show a high similarity to the United States’ objectives. However, as often, these challenging targets could not yet be implemented to their full extend. Overall, Europe’s public sector faces challenging economic and social conditions, institutional change, and of course the impact of information technology. In order to boost growth, efficiency, and productivity, quality of governmental services still need to be improved. Today, about 67% of public services are accessible online. Since such numbers always depend on the underlying assumptions for their calculation they have to be used with caution. Whereas, the percentage is higher by looking at public services merely from a perspective of online availability, the percentage is lower if focus is on public services that are already truly transactional. Among the public service categories, income-generating services (tax and social contributions) are the most developed,
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
15
followed by registration services (car and new company registration) and returns, such as social security. Services related to documents and permits (driver’s license, passports) are the least developed on the Web. Services for businesses reach 79% of online sophistication, whereas the services for citizens reached a level of 58%. In summary, on the one hand, Europe makes progress in e-government. On the other hand, taking the measure of fully transactional services and highly advances stages of e-government development the result seems to be more pessimistic. 3.4.1 United Kingdom Although the United Kingdom (UK) is among those European countries that have higher maturity levels, its e-government growth seemed to have slowed in the last couple of years. The UK government’s initial objective (in 2000) was to make all public services available electronically by the end of 2005. However, the project was delayed several times. Since 2005, over a billion pounds have been invested to boost UK’s central government’s online offerings. However, despite high Internet penetration (70.9% of the population has internet access); the use of e-government services remains low. Several challenges, issues, and complexities in realizing “transformation” stage in e-government are identified (Weerakkody et al., 2004). So far about 70% of government services can be accessed via the Internet. That figure was expected to reach 80% by the end of 2005, the date by which everything was supposed to have been “e-enabled.” However, these projects were not actually completed for inherent inefficiencies in communication modules among various organizations (Mosse & Whitley, 2009). What is more worrying is that where such services have already been put online, hardly anyone seems to be using them. Since the British are, similar to the Americans, rather an Internet savvy society e-government usage patterns are disappointing. The vast amount of different Web sites, the required coordination between several organizations, as well as the necessity to visit multiple sites before finding valuable information, again appear to be the main problems why e-government is not really taking off in UK. In addition, some government’s sites are out of date or do not work properly. Finally, the British have traditionally been skeptical about their governments’ initiatives, given the examples of failures in the past. That is why take-up of e-government services in Britain continuous to be an issue. For the future, the UK government still plans to increase spending on e-government by several billion in the next few years. We have placed it in the “Transactional” category in Fig. 1.4. 3.4.2 Germany Germany is within the cluster of low to medium growth stage countries on the life cycle. Emphasis is still on providing information on the Web and a really noticeable push toward the transaction level is not yet evident. In addition, e-government is not considered as a crucial aspect in the political debate. The transfer of BundOnline 2005 out of the Ministry of Inner Affairs to the Federal Office for Administration supports this view. Fewer than half of the country’s regular Internet users have ever
16
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
used any e-government service at all. One of the problems e-government faces in Germany is that the majority of initiatives have so far been targeted at the federal level. Although the number of government portals and sites is immense, the most significant services for citizens and businesses are provided primarily by municipal governments, however. Also, Germany is a highly unionized country and the extensive amounts of employment laws make a hire-and-fire strategy (like in the United States) impossible. The fear of trading a large number of municipal governmental jobs for advances in e-government thus already restricts some activities in their initial phase. Finally, Germany is often dominated by the call for security, legal certainty, and data privacy, which is in part attributable to the country’s culture and working habits. Nevertheless, some plans such as the introduction of a digital passport in 2008 have already starting giving good results. Thoughts about this type of passport, that requires a digital signature, first emerged after the terrorist attacks in the United States in 2001. Its successful implementation, along with other planned activities, is bringing Germany back into a more desirable position of e-government maturity. The country’s technological infrastructure and capabilities definitely favor a position more toward innovative practices and higher maturity levels and do not resemble the low-maturity status the country currently has. In the recent 2008 UN survey, Germany received very low ranking as far as citizen participation e-government-based democratic interaction with the government is concerned. We have placed it in the “Transactional” category in Fig. 1.4.
3.5 North America The United States (US) and Canada in the North American continent have been leading in e-government infrastructure development for several years. Recently, other countries specially the ones in Scandinavia have left both the US and Canada a little behind in the recent UN e-government survey rankings. However, both countries have developed and enhanced e-government infrastructure significantly during the last years. 3.5.1 United States The United States currently is among the top four countries with regard to e-government maturity. It still leads the field in readiness of the amount of information available, services and products offered, as well as the underlying infrastructure such as telephones, computers, and Internet connections (United Nations Report, 2008). About 73% of the population has access to Internet and e-government use is considerably high (United Nations Report, 2008). Also, the country’s population is Internet savvy and supports the ideas of increased convenience and time and cost savings. Finally, legislation is more in favor of moving e-government strategies forward than putting up restricting barriers. It was the United States together with Great Britain, Canada, and Australia that led the way in one 2006 ranking (Iyer et al., 2006), in establishing a basic information form of Web presence in
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
17
the mid-1990s and in developing what became known as e-government in the late 1990s. In 2001, the country published its first e-government vision statement, which adhered to three principles: being citizen-centered, results-oriented, and marketbased. However, Scandinavian countries, i.e., Norway, Sweden, and Denmark are now leading e-government use and now among the top four countries in providing their citizens the highest level of connected services. In United States, however, the challenge in making e-government a success is only possible if services are citizen-centered (not agency-centered as is the case in most of US e-government infrastructure), enabled through the changing of processes, and effectively marketed to the customer.
3.5.2 Canada Canada’s “Government On-Line (GOL)” initiative started in 1999 became known around the world as the “government most connected to its citizens.” A comprehensive list of 130 different online services ranges from information provision to real-time, secure interaction. Some of the more prominent e-government services include online forms, “my government account,” online tools and calculators, public participation, and Canadian health portal. Canadian approach toward e-government infrastructure development is based upon their strategic design principles of being “client-centered.” Attempts have been made grouped e-government services logically and give the impression of seamless integration among divisions of government. For example, “e-pass authentication” process provides a single sign-on for multiple areas of government. While Canada has been successful in developing a very reasonable e-government infrastructure, the vastness of the land demands continuous expansion of ICT infrastructure to rural areas to counter the effects of digital divide. We have placed Canada under “Transactional” category in Fig. 1.4.
3.6 South America E-government maturity in South America varies greatly. On one end, there are countries that are among the few in the world to have developed completely computerized voting systems and, on the other end, some only have “emerging” level of e-government maturity. Technological advancements among different regions within a single country may differ significantly, which affects citizen’s ability to access and use these services in any meaningful manner. Evaluating the literature on e-government growth in South America reveals that e-government maturity is increasing significantly despite the challenges. We have selected Argentina and Brazil for a closer look at their e-government maturity in the last 10 years.
18
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
3.6.1 Argentina The e-government infrastructure development started with bringing transparency to government services and freedom of information. The national plan for modernization of the state (2006) adopted in 2006 calls for development of ICT and e-government infrastructure to lead the country to modernization. The implementation of digital signatures for inter- and intra-governmental communication and data transfer provide the foundation for further enhancement and development of e-government infrastructure. The central e-government Web site provides interactive links to several government services at the federal and state level. Future plans for e-government enhancement call for more integrated services and applications. While, Argentina needs to enhance its basic ICT infrastructure, due to the recent development of e-government services for citizens we have placed it in the “Interactive” category in Fig. 1.4.
3.6.2 Brazil Brazil’s road to e-governance adoption has been influenced by a number of factors, including its governmental structure, geography, and the education of its people. These have impacted the rate of diffusion of technologies essential to the growth of an e-government infrastructure. Despite technological limitations, the country has undertaken significant implementations. Brazil started experimenting with electronic voting in 1996. It currently holds completely electronic elections. More recent developments include the Web portals. Some of the government portals are interconnected. The main Web portal of the government http://www.e.gov.br provides contact information and support for over 800 different governmental services. While, Brazil has made significant progress in e-government maturity in the last 10 years and e-government interfaces are interactive and in some cases transactional, we have placed Brazil in an over “Interactive” category in Fig. 1.4.
4 Emerging Trends in E-government The e-government life cycle showed the relative positions of countries with regard to their maturity levels. One of the trends emerging in e-government is that larger differences in maturity slowly disappear (Accenture, 2004, 2009). Countries that were once lacking behind have managed to catch up with former industry leaders. This is especially true for some countries in the medium maturity range. Here, countries are very close together, making an appropriate differentiation hardly possible and differences in rankings are often due to differing underlying assumptions. It shall also not be surprising that especially countries in the low- or mid-maturity phases have better chances to make more significant advances. The reason is that it simply becomes harder for countries that are already highly mature to significantly differentiate themselves.
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
19
Second, when governments initiated their first online programs, cost savings have been soaked up by large investments into the e-government structure. While some governments still need to heavily invest, industry leaders now start realizing tangible cost savings. Third, the biggest factors for driving citizens to greater e-government usage are time and cost savings. As already mentioned, a lot of services are hardly known off, however. Therefore, governments are increasing their promotion efforts. Some countries have already reported concentrated marketing efforts that lead to satisfying results. The tools used in such marketing campaigns include television and radio, advertisements magazines, newspapers, and other media. Fourth, moving from the transaction stage to stages of vertical and horizontal integration is for many countries still the major hurdle. However, since these stages characterize the provision of a truly seamless approach to e-government, countries are also increasing their efforts to reach them. For already highly advanced countries the next “battleground” could be integration at the international level (Jaeger & Thompson, 2003). Especially with regard to the current developments within the European Union, international integration will be an interesting field for further future research. Finally, e-government services are starting to get customized (Accenture, 2009). This means that governments are not only trying to serve the overall public in the best way possible, but also try to tailor their services to specific needs and interests. While users benefit from more accurate, appropriate information, and time savings, agencies increase their customer satisfaction ratings and strengthen the user participation layer. In addition, user data becomes more reliable, enabling the better targeting of future services. Segmentation becomes possible through enhanced market understanding.
5 Future Challenges for E-government The idea of a fully integrated e-government assumes perfect coordination, communication, and collaboration among different levels and functions of government and is therefore still a theoretical concept than reality. Future challenges mean different things to different countries. As identified earlier, for developing nations it is important to develop basic telecommunication infrastructure to a level where citizens have access to e-government services. For developed countries where basic connectivity to internet and online services are not a major consideration, the major challenge is the integrated service delivery where citizens’ data is secure and interoperable to allow for the completion of complicated and sophisticated e-government services. As with other sectors, the public sector faces power conflicts, differing goals, functional boundaries, self-centered thinking, etc. The future will show which countries will most likely be able to improve coordination, communication, and collaboration among agencies in order to move ahead. It will require significant resources first to provide valuable information and services that are continuously updated and expanded in order to meet customer needs and second to keep customers informed through marketing initiatives. Another challenge will be
20
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
to overcome issues and concerns of privacy and confidentiality. As with onlineshopping citizens still feel uncomfortable with providing personal data on the Web and are concerned about its usage and storage. Therefore, clear guidelines have to be in place on how to address such concerns internally as well as communicate solutions externally. Technical improvements such as the implementation of security controls, safe document management systems, as well as increased transparency of procedures or allowing independent auditing could solve some of the problems. Internally, it will be crucial to sustain committed leadership and to develop performance evaluation measures. While e-government frees a lot of resources it cannot become a way for employees to avoid taking responsibility or their duties since they are not physically seeing or speaking to the citizen anymore or to blame technology as an excuse for all problems. Among or even within countries variations in both the availability of technology as well as the ability to use them exist. Simply put, not everyone can have access from everywhere in the world. It would be wrong to invest into e-government strategies in those countries that require other services more desperately (Haldenwang, 2004). In addition, a person that simply lacks education or has limited abilities cannot be denied access to governmental services, and in nations in which more than one language is being spoken, ways need to be considered to not exclude a certain part of the population. Finally, different challenges can be linked to the different stages on the life cycle. Countries with low maturity have to initiate activities that can guarantee the foundation for service transformation and provide long-term plans. Focus should be on services with high demand, businesses, and collaborations. Countries with medium maturity will have to target both citizens as well as businesses and ensure that services can be delivered accordingly. Functional barriers need to be removed in order to allow integration. High-maturity countries will have to think of innovative ways in order to not lose their position and second further set themselves apart. New cost-effective strategies need to be sought that replace outdated ones and create a win-win situation. The goal is to achieve strategies that can achieve full integration.
6 Concluding Remarks The chapter explored several aspects of e-government maturity in selected countries in six continents over the last 10 years. Despite many challenges, governments are expanding in both the size and scope of their e-government strategies to not fall behind and grasp some of the advantages. Determinants of how and how well e-government initiatives are realized and utilized include the political ideology, resource availability, the technological infrastructure, and economic/social systems. Further investigation of e-government implementations is needed to explore what works and what does not. The examination of e-government initiatives from different parts of the world offers a method to share knowledge about various e-government strategies. The majority of the current literature takes a rather theoretical than practical approach to e-government. However, it will be interesting to
1
E-government Maturity over 10 Years
21
see how future research on different countries progresses and how the outcomes change the relative positioning of countries on the e-government life cycle.
References Accenture. (2004). E-government leadership: High performance, maximum value. Annual report, 2009. Accenture. (2009). Transforming government service. Online Government Service Delivery. Retrieved March 26, 2009, from http://www.accenture.com/Global/Services/By_Industry/ Government_and_Public_Service/DelawareDelivery.htm Agunloye, O. (2007). An overview of the implementation of e-government program in Nigeria. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Theory and Practice of Electronic Governance; Macao, China. Baqir, M. N., & Parvez, S. (2000). IT policy of Pakistan. Computer News, 10, 15–31. Biancucci, R. J., Goode, L. J., Hunter, P. A., Owings, K., Tucker, A., & Willett, R. B. (2001). CFO survey – A preview: Electronic government. Journal of Government Financial Management, 2, 36–39. Cho, Y. H., & Byung-Dae, C. (2004). E-government to combat corruption: The case of Seoul Metropolitan Government. International Journal of Public Administration, 10, 719–735. Cuddy, I. (2003). New moves for European e-government. Retrieved January, 2008, from http://www.egovmonitor.com/newsletter/yzdqasd86/talrln02.html Dearstyne, B. (2001). E-business, e-government information proficiency. The Information Management Journal, 4, 17–22. Devadoss, P., Pan, S., & Huang, J. (2002). Structurational analysis of e-government initiatives: A case study of SCO. Decision Support Systems, 34, 253–269. Dhillon, G. (2001). Challenges in managing information security in the new millennium. In G. Dhillon (Ed.), Information security management: Global challenges in the new millennium (pp. 1–9). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing. Dillon, S., Deakins, E., & Chen, W. C. (2006). E-local government in New Zealand: The shifting policymaker view. The Electronic Journal of E-Government, 1, 9–8. Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). (2009). Reports retrieved March 29, 2009, from www.ecp.gov.pk. Electronic Government Directorate (EGD) Pakistan. (2009). Briefing for focal persons about e-government strategy and 5-year plan. Retrieved March 29, 2009, from http://www.egovernment.gov.pk GAO. (2003). Electronic government-potential exists for enhancing collaboration on four initiatives. Report to Congressional Committees by the USA General Accounting Office. Gauld, R., Graya, A., & McComba, S. (2009). How responsive is e-government? Evidence from Australia and New Zealand. Government Information Quarterly, 1, 69–74. Grant, G., & Derek, C. (2005). Developing a generic framework for e-government. Journal of Global Information Management, 13, 1–30. Haldenwang, C. V. (2004). Electronic government (E-Government) and development. The European Journal of Development Research, 16(2), 417–432. Heeks, R., & Bailura, S. (2007). Analyzing e-government research: Perspectives, philosophies, theories, methods, and practice. Government Information Quarterly, 2, 243–265. India Core. (2006). Growth in telecom sector. Retrived March 28, 2009, from http://www.indiacore.com/telecom.html Irani, Z., Love, P., Elliman, T., Jones, S., & Themistocleous, M. (2005). Evaluating e-government: Learning from the experiences of two UK local authorities. Information Systems Journal, 1, 61–82.
22
M.N. Baqir and L. Iyer
Irani, Z., Love, P., & Montazemi, A. (2007). E-government: Past, present and future. European Journal of Information Systems, 2, 1003–1105. Iyer, L. S., Baqir, N., & Vollmer, T. (2006). A comparative analysis of e-government strategies. In R. K. Mitra (Ed.), eGovernment macro issues. New Delhi, India: Global Institute of Flexible Systems Management Publishing. Jaeger, P. T., & Thompson, K. M. (2003). E-government around the world: Lessons, challenges, and new directions. Government Information Quarterly, 20(4), 389–394. Kamel, S. (1998). Decision Support Systems and Strategic Public Sector Decision Making in Egypt, iGovernment paper no.3, Institute for Development Policy and Management, University of Manchester. Lawson, G. (1998). NetState. London: Demos. Layne, K., & Lee, J. (2001). Developing fully functional e-government: A four stage model. Government Information Quarterly, 18, 122–136. Microsoft. (2000). IEC of South Africa wins Computerworld Smithsonian award, Government News, 28 June, Microsoft Europe, Reading. Ministry of IT (MIT) – India. (2005). E-readiness index of the states in India 2004. Retrieved March 27, 2009, from http://www.mit.gov.in/ereadiness Mosse, B., & Whitley, E. A. (2009). Critically classifying: UK e-government Website benchmarking and the recasting of the citizen as customer. Information Systems Journal, 2, 149–173. Mujahid, Y. H. (2002). Digital opportunity for Pakistan. The Electronic Journal on Information Systems in Developing Countries, 8(6), 1–14. Nadler, D., & Tushman, M. (1997). Competing by design: The power of organizational architecture. New York: Oxford University Press. Navarra, D., & Cornford, T. (2003). A policy making view of e-government innovations in public governance. Proceedings of the 2003 Americas Conference on Information Systems. Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA). (2009). Telecom indicators, Retrieved March 29, 2009, from http://www.pta.gov.pk Palvia, S. C., & Sharma, S. (2007). E-Government and E-Governance: Definitions/Domain Framework and Status around the World (Foundations of E-government, A. Agarwal & V. V. Ramana). Hyderabad, India: IECG. Seifert, J., & Petersen, E. (2002). The promise of all things E? Expectations and challenges of emergent electronic government. Perspectives on Global Development and Practice, 2, 193–213. Symonds, M. (2000). Government and the internet: Handle with care. The Economist, 355, 33. Tillman, B. (2003). More information could mean less privacy. The Information Management Journal, Retrieved November 9, 2006, from http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3937/is_200303/ai_n9185074 United Nations Report. (2005). UN Global E-Government Readiness Report, United Nations. Available at http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/un/unpan021888.pdf United Nations Report. (2008). Global e-government readiness report, United Nations. Available at http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/UN/UNPAN028607.pdf Weerakkody, V., Choudrie, J., & Currie, W. (2004). Realising e-government in the UK: Local and national challenges. Proceedings of the 2004 Americas Conference on Information Systems. New York, NY. Wilson, J. Q. (1989). Bureaucracy: What government agencies do and why they do it. New York: Basic Books Publishers. Wimmer, M, & Traunmuller, R. (2000). Trends in electronic government: Managing distributed knowledge. New York: Springer.
Chapter 2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level Hakikur Rahman
E-government theories are prevailing in various formats and concepts around the globe, nations, and institutions, but not many examples to emulate in terms of developing a comprehensive framework of e-governance system at the outer periphery of the government tiers. This research would like to carry out a comprehensive analysis on various theories built around the e-governance concept, but the prime focus will be devoted to penetration of e-government system at the grass roots. To narrow down further, the study will conduct analytical observations in a few developed, developing, and transitional economies. Furthermore, to be more concise, the research will specifically focus on e-government implementations at the grass roots that penetrated the lowest tier of the governance system for community empowerment and knowledge enhancement. Before conclusion, it will try to put forward prospective research agenda, including framework of a future e-government system at the local government level.
1 Introduction Despite the popularity, potency, and precision of electronic form of government (e-government), it is yet somehow remained in uncharted territory for many countries in terms of implementing e-governance at the lowest tier of the governance system. In theory it is known as the local government in almost all countries, and in practice the lowest tier of any governance system always lack of proper incentives, adequate resources, satisfactory management, and mainly any standardized framework (Das & Chandrashekhar, 2006; Gessi, Ramnarine, & Wilkins, 2007; Malhotra, Chariar, Das, & Ilavarasan, 2007; Zwahr & Finger, 2004). Governments throughout the world are in quest of finding novel ways to deliver public services more efficiently and effectively to reach the people at large.
H. Rahman (B) Institute of Computer Management & Science, Mirpur, Dhaka, 1216, Bangladesh e-mail:
[email protected]
C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_2, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
23
24
H. Rahman
Incorporation of electronic form of governance (e-governance) in the local governments tier is an option widely discussed, although the expectations often vary. They vary in nature, culture, practice, habits, and habitations among communities, regions, states, and nations. For example, some foresee service-delivery costs to be reduced, many expect for equitable stipulation of public services, and others anticipate better planning across a geographical boundary. Various social motivations and political commitments motivations may also be reasons for the change as well (Bovaird, 2003; Das & Chandrashekhar, 2006; Rahman, 2009). Moreover, due to non-availability of any accepted e-governance framework (this may raise another elaborated dimension of research), some countries and agencies of implementation are yet at the stage of simulation or at stages of experimentation, or at state of confusion, even after years of successful operation of e-government system in many countries. Countries in the developing and transitional economies are major victims of this situation, as most of the time they just try to replicate an established system in a country or try to simply manipulate on their own without enough researches in this aspect or try to popularize a vision without looking into the intricacy within it. The consequences are that, not only governments, but also development actors are revisiting the concept of e-government system as many projects on e-governance have failed throughout the globe. Some of the international agencies have even shifted their focus area of funding. Perhaps, these could be due to factors related to design, perception, culture, economics, transparency, or simple failure due to lack of proper attention (Malhotra et al., 2007; Rahman, 2007). This chapter is intended to look into various aspects of e-government concepts and their frameworks in a few countries, try to analyze them linking better strategy of acceptance, study their parameters for promotion of e-governance at the local government level to yield positive economic benefits. After providing an insight into the e-government meanings, definitions, and clarifications, the chapter intends to focus on e-governance strategies of a few countries. Later on the research goes on making observations related to several e-government parameters, including their e-government frameworks and proposes a five-tier local government structure. The chapter proposes a future e-governance framework with recommendations. Before conclusion, it shades some lights on various challenges on implementing local level e-government.
2 Background Local government can be defined as a city, county, parish, township, municipality, borough, ward, board, district, sub-district, or other general purpose political subdivision of a state or a country.1 In other words, it is a county, municipality, city, town, township, local public authority, school district, special district, intrastate district, council of governments, regional or interstate government entity, or agency 1 Google
definition.
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
25
or instrumentality of a local government; a tribe or authorized tribal organization, native village or organization; and a rural community, unincorporated town or village, or other public entity, for which an application for assistance is made by a state or political subdivision of a state.2 It is the lowest level of formal state institutions, such as district-level officials or local, publicly accountable decision-making and service-delivery organizations constituted in accordance with national laws (such as in local elections). Local government structures take different forms in different countries and vary in their levels of accountability to local people or to immediate upper-tier of governments.3 In administrative sense, four major themes may act as key to run a local government authority; such as leadership, communication and coordination, immediate risk management, and trust, confidence, and transparency (Anttiroiko, 2004; Calista & Melitski, 2007; Chutimaskul & Chongsuphajaisiddhi, 2004; CTG, 2003). While applying thought of ICTs, one can think of the local e-government system be comprised of an online resource designed to assist electronic access to government delivery intermediaries; provide homogeneous linkage to technology, policy, and organizational management; promote inter-organizational integration at the local level to information system development, management, and institutional partnership; accommodate subsidies, grants, and other facilities to empower local communities with greater autonomies; deliver efficient, citizen-centric, and cost-effective contents to accelerate participation and partnership-based e-services; integrate communities, societies, and localities to local, national, regional, and global e-government initiatives; produce strategic plan to support efficient delivery of government services; identify level of organizational readiness at the local context to prepare for the effectiveness and efficient service delivery; and lead toward the ultimate goal of transformation to offer better citizen services at the grass roots (Austin City Council, 2008; CTG, 2002, 2003; Hoogwout, 2003; Kolsaker, 2005; Perotti & von Thadden, 2006; Rahman, 2008). Countries often consider merging of local governments as a means to lower service-delivery costs, improve service quality, increase accountability, improve equity, or enhance participation in government system (Fox & Gurley, 2006). But, concept of e-government is to make them more independent, provide more autonomy, offer them more power to act within, and formalize their institutional framework by upholding all the benefits of local government through elected representatives (Government of Pakistan, 2005; Kim, 2002; Rainford, 2006). However, this study feels that to framework an appropriate e-governance system, these could be supplementary issues that need to clearly justified, attended, and solved by proper authorization, experimentation, and validation. Scope of this chapter will restrain inclusion of similar disputed issues and their justifications. These will demand further extended research on these issues and other concerns that may rise during
2 http://www.fema.gov/oer/reference/glossary.shtm 3 http://www.idrc.ca/en/ev-105151-201-1-DO_TOPIC.html
26
H. Rahman
the investigation. The study would emphasize on conducting a synthesis of core e-government concepts that seem viable and sustainable in countries, and furthermore, it also synthesizes various e-governance frameworks in a few countries focusing consistent e-government strategies.
3 Main Thrust While electronic service delivery remains the main thrust of e-government policies at all levels, greater community contact is usually seen as more practical and desirable at the local level. In recent times, greater focus has been given to local e-government where a significant amount of “citizen to government” or vice versa interaction takes place. Therefore, most of the local governments today are under influence to provide efficient and effective e-government information and services as a result of increased accountability and performance management (Shackleton, Fisher, & Dawson, 2004). The aim is to intensify consumer’s demand and choice, increase local competition, reduce the cost of service delivery at the local level, and better functioning of the government system. Moreover, at the local level, authority, activity, and functioning of the local government are imperative. A comparative study of e-government strategies of six countries is given in Table 2.1. From Table 2.1, one can speculate the emergence of e-governance in those countries. Countries were chosen randomly among Asian countries, which became sustainable in terms of digital readiness and/or framing e-government in their governance system or trying to compete in the global arena. However, for sake of reference, their preference criteria have been described next. Bangladesh, one of the most populous country in the world, has currently taken the initiative of “Digital Bangladesh”4 in 2009, despite fragile information infrastructure and naïve e-government expertise; India – where the government has initiated its Electronic Governance Strategic Plan which provides the roadmap for Electronic Governance during 2003–2007,5 while South Korea (a developed country in Asia) – places several strategic and structured visions in their strategies at appropriate time and effort (see Fig. 2.1 that shows the strategy of closed cycle business process reengineering, an essential catalyst for self-development); Singapore – a leader in e-government implementations and consecutively improving e-governance platform in recent years; Pakistan has incorporated basic strategic steps in their e-government framework, as the starter sequences in 2005, though ICTrelated activities have been initiated there long ago; and Sri Lanka – a forerunner from many years in Asia – has included a few pragmatic endeavors (see also Fig. 2.2 that provide a comprehensive e-government strategy focusing peace, equity, human interaction, and development) are countries of interest in this research (Chauhan,
4 http://www.bcc.net.bd/html/vision.htm 5 http://india.gov.in/govt/national_egov_plan.php
India – 1971 (2006)
South Korea – 1987 (2002)
Strategy: Basic infrastructure development Set up Cyber Kiosks in all Create a modern and Initiation: Post offices, Union efficient Provision of limited complex and Upzila telecommunications information complex to ensure public infrastructure access to information Strategy: Capacity development Take up programs to Provide access to Development: develop quality ICT information to Periodic update of professionals and skilled empower citizens, information personnel enable their participation in government Strategy: Promotion of application and service delivery Develop and encourage Transform citizen Interoperation: E-mails, local software, hardware, services, and provide E-forms and service industries greater attention to improve service-delivery mechanism Strategy: Promotion of electronic transactions Encourage the growth of Use ICT for delivering E-commerce: Internet, ICT industries, government services, Online processing of e-commerce, and exchange of civil service, e-government information and E-payment of taxes communication and fees transactions
Bangladesh – 1990 (2002)
Singapore – 1980 (2000)
Build the ICT infrastructure and an enabling environment
Sri Lanka – 1983 (2002)
Standards: Electronic Aims to grow new Government economic activities Directorate (EGD) to and create jobs be developed
Adopt agency-specific Promoting the Build the national applications and development of useful implementation e-services for citizens applications for work, capacity play, lifestyle, and learning
Common Applications: Encouraging usage of Develop ICT-based A portfolio of applications and human resources applications that are services; and common to many or promoting Infocomm all divisions have literacy been identified
Deploy the basic development of an infrastructure to all Infocomm government agencies infrastructure for pervasive and secure access
Pakistan – 1996 (2005)
Table 2.1 E-government strategies of selected countries of study
2 Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level 27
India – 1971 (2006)
South Korea – 1987 (2002) Pakistan – 1996 (2005)
Singapore – 1980 (2000)
Sri Lanka – 1983 (2002)
Note: Years in the heading indicate various years of those countries’ initiations for informatization. Years within the parentheses are years of entering into the e-government era and digitization. These years have been recorded as per available literature review. They may vary depending on the ground facts and exact dates. Source: Government of Bangladesh (2002), Government of India (2000, 2006), Government of Pakistan (2000, 2005), Rainford (2006), Kim (2002), and Lallana (2004).
a http://www.ida.gov.sg/News%20and%20Events/20050718123446.aspx?getPagetype=21
Strategy: Adoption within the government (cost, efficiency, and transparency) All Government ministries, Make all government Integrated Enabling Environment: Government plays the Reengineering of divisions, departments, services accessible to administration: Federal Government, role of master planner government and autonomous bodies and the common people Interdepartmental and Agency, EGD for the strategies and delivery of citizen all District headquarters, ensuring efficiency, cross-agency online acts as a catalyzing services Upzilla headquarters, and transparency and service, converged agent and facilitator Union Parishad offices be reliability public/civil service for the initiatives networked Strategy: ICTs for social and economic development Leverage ICT for Nation-wide ICT systems Enable access to Promotion of Make participation by E-government Action economic and social be implemented for rural economic and social informatization in all rural and poor Plan to transform development development and opportunities aspects of society for segments of society in public service and livelihood activities increased IT education a become more socio-economic strategic priority for effective in meeting activities, higher both social and the needs of both national performance, economic citizens and and higher quality of development businesses in life contributing to socio-economic developmenta
Bangladesh – 1990 (2002)
Table 2.1 (continued)
28 H. Rahman
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level Process Analysis
Process Reengineering
Remove Overlapping
Process Simplification
29
Informatization
Fig. 2.1 Closed cycle process renovation of South Korean e-government strategy (adopted from Yoon, 2007) Fig. 2.2 E-government strategy of Sri Lanka (adopted from Rainford, 2006)
2009; Government of Bangladesh, 2002; Government of India, 2000; Government of Pakistan, 2005; Kim, 2002; Lallana, 2004, 2005; Rainford, 2006). Nevertheless, the hypothesis is that successful e-government concepts should rely on rigid institutionalization, liberal laws and regulations, adoptive technologies, and promotion of business values, often terms as the four pillars of e-government. Conclusions will try to validate them with some other findings. These e-government concepts and strategies (as depicted in Table 2.1, Figs 2.1 and 2.2) lead to develop a concrete e-governance framework in a country incorporating; development of institutional infrastructure, establishment of adequate information infrastructure, formation of liberal legal and regulatory infrastructure, and creation of business value out of these services. However, this study as stated earlier is focusing e-governance framework at the local government level and, thereby, would like to draw a synthesis of pattern learning from local government infrastructure in a few countries. There could be critics of this particular research of including developed and developing countries into a single dimension. This is to compare the concepts, strategies, and frameworks of those countries, so that readers and other researchers could have a glimpse of the comparison, and at the same time could foresee the intricacies among these patterns. The countries of study are
30
H. Rahman
being highlighted here focusing their government structure and their strategies taken toward promoting e-governance. Bangladesh: The rural/regional local government, as proposed by the latest commission on local government in 1997 has four tiers: Gram (Village) Parishads (being reconstituted in 2003 as Sarkers, and later on changed again) (40,392); Union Parishads (4451); Thana/Upazila Parishads (469); and Zila (District) Parishads (64). Urban areas have a separate set of local governments. The Bangladesh Census Commission recognized 522 urban areas in 1991 (with a minimum population of about 5,000 or more), but only about 269 of the larger urban areas among these have urban local governments. The six largest cities have a City Corporation status, while the rest are known as Pourashavas or Municipalities, which again are classified according to financial strength.6 Note: There are four tiers of government structure existed in the country. Bangladesh Computer Council (BCC), established by Act No IX of 1990 as an autonomous body to encourage and provide support for ICT-related activities in Bangladesh.7 In Bangladesh, the focus of capacity-building through ICT is on socio-economic development. Provision of nationwide infrastructure under a national ICT policy, spearheaded by a National ICT taskforce chaired by the Prime Minister, is designed to facilitate good governance, e-commerce, and e-learning. The human resource development focus of the national ICT policy is to develop ICT professionals and engineers to meet the demand for skilled ICT workers that is growing worldwide, especially for the global software and ICT-enabled services market (Sayo, Chacko, & Pradhan, 2004). The National ICT Policy was adopted in October 2002 (a proposed National ICT Policy has been sent to the government in September 2008). The Policy aims at building an ICT-driven knowledge-based society by the year 2010 (initial target was year 2006). Among 15 priority areas:8 agriculture and poverty alleviation, health care, e-government/e-governance, e-commerce, ICT infrastructure, training and human resources development, environment, social welfare, and regional cooperation are found to encourage local government initiatives to be flourished. Furthermore, ICT Act 2006 has been enacted on 8 October 2006; and formulation of rules and regulations are still going on. Very recently, the government has taken an initiative to formulate the national ICT Roadmap for Bangladesh under the Economic Management and Technical Assistance Program (EMTAP), managed by Bangladesh Computer Council with assistance from the World Bank. Moreover, the newest approach toward e-governance could be adoption of Digital Bangladesh concept by the current government in 2009.
6 http://www.unescap.org/huset/lgstudy/new-countrypaper/Bangladesh/Bangladesh.pdf 7 http://www.bcc.net.bd/ 8 http://www.sdnbd.org/sdi/issues/IT-computer/itpolicy-bd-2002.htm
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
31
Note: Patronization from the highest tier of the government is essential for improved e-governance in a country. India: There are 28 states and 7 Union territories in the country.9 The Union Territories are administered by the President through an Administrator. Each state is broken up into several administrative districts. The bureaucratic head of a district is called the District Collector, while the political head is the President of the Zilla Parishad (or District Council), which is a body of elected representatives, including the local MLA. A new post created is that of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the Zilla Parishad (ZP), filled by a career bureaucrat. A District is divided into several Community Development Blocks, each of which is headed by a Block Development Officer (BDO). Each Block, in turn, is usually divided into several Tehsils, headed by a Tehsildar. It is probably apparent that the political and administrative setups are closely interlinked at the district and sub-district levels. For example, the CEO of the Zilla Parishad is a bureaucrat, although the Zilla Parishad itself is made up of elected representatives, including representatives from the Mandal (Praja) Parishads from the different mandals within the district. The Mandal Parishad or Council comprises the heads of the Panchayat Samitis, and some co-opted resource persons. Each Panchayat Samiti, in turn, has representatives from various Gram Panchayats (Village Councils), which is the basic tier of local government10 (James, 2004). Note: There are five tiers in the government system; however, there are different administrative channels. In India, the Department of Electronics (DoE) was established in 1971 for recommending and implementing policies for the country’s IT sector. The National Taskforce on Information Technology and Software Development was established by the Prime Minister of India on 28 May 1998 to formulate a long-term National IT Policy for the country and to remove impediments to the growth of the IT industry. The main objective was to assist India emerge as an IT software superpower. In 1999 National Telecoms Policy of India was enacted to provide affordable and effective communication systems for citizens; achieve a balance between the provision of universal service to all uncovered areas and of high-level services capable of meeting the needs of the country’s economy; and create a modern and efficient telecommunications infrastructure taking into account the convergence of IT, media, telecom, and consumer electronics and, thereby, propel India into becoming an IT superpower. Later on the IT Act 2000 was adopted focusing the legal recognition
9 http://www.india.gov.in/knowindia/state_uts.php 10 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Administrative_divisions_of_India;
http://www.oifc.in/ViewFolder.aspx?FolderName=Understanding_the_States&FolderID=65
32
H. Rahman
of electronic contracts and digital signatures; created controller for certifying authorities and cyber appellate tribunal (Pertrazzini & Harindranath, 1997; Lallana, 2004). Note: To roll out grass roots e-governance, a comprehensive and long-term vision with requisite action plans are essential.
Republic of Korea: The local government in Korea consists of 248 separate units. The local political system of Korea is broadly distributed into two categories: the general and the special. In Article 117 Paragraph 2 of the Constitution, it is stipulated that the types of local governments in Korea ought to be decided by the law. Based on this provision, the Local Autonomy Act acknowledges the general local governments to comprise of two tiers: the upper-level local governments (i.e., metropolitan cities and provinces) and lower-level local governments (i.e., cities, countries, and districts). There are two levels of local government, Upper-level (provincial) local governments and Lower-level (municipal) local governments.11 Note: There are three tiers in the government system.
Korea’s first national computerization project was initiated in 1987. The South Korean government adopted the first Master Plan for Informatization Promotion in June 1996, following the enactment of the Framework Act on Informatization Promotion in August 1995. To advance the goals of the first informatization plan, the government also established a national organization for planning and implementation. Later on, in March 1999, the government formulated the second informatization master plan called “Cyber Korea 21,” and in order to overcome the Asian economic crisis and transform the Korean economy into a knowledge-based one Cyber Korea 21 provides a blueprint for the new information society of the twenty-first century. Korea’s third informatization master plan, “e-Korea Vision 2006,” embodies the belief that the promotion of informatization in all aspects of the society will lead to an increased effectiveness of all socio-economic activities, higher national performance, and elevated quality of life.12 Prime objectives of e-Korea Vision 2006 were: to maximize the ability of citizens to actively participate in the information society by utilizing ICT; to strengthen global competitiveness of the economy by promoting informatization in all industries; to realize a smart government structure with high transparency and productivity through informatization efforts; to facilitate continued economic
11 http://www.unescap.org/huset/lgstudy/new-countrypaper/RoK/RoK.pdf 12 http://www.mic.go.kr/index.jsp
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
33
growth by promoting the IT industry and advancing the information infrastructure; and to become a leader in the global information society by playing a major role in international cooperation (Lallana, 2004). Note: Informatization, smart government structure, increased transparency, partnership promotion, and information infrastructure development are ingredients of strengthened local e-governance.
Pakistan: Local governments in Pakistan exist under the supervision of the various provincial governments, where provincial governments have simply delegated some of their functions and responsibilities to local governments by the promulgation of ordinances. It was a new model of local government pioneered to ensure direct participation of the people in managing their own affairs through representative’s bodies set up down to the village level. There were two separate laws for rural (i.e., Basic Democracy Ordinance 1959) and Urban Councils (i.e., Municipal Administration Ordinance 1960). It established a four-tier hierarchical system of local council throughout the country, namely, the Union Councils (for rural areas), Town Committees (for urban areas), Tehsil Councils, and/or District Councils and Divisional Councils. The Tehsil Council was the second tier above the Union Council. It was mainly concerned with the development activities in the proclaimed areas.13 Pakistan Telecommunications (Re-organization) Act was enacted in 1996, and Pakistan IT Commission was established in 2000. Eleven working groups were created under auspices of IT Policy 2000 with emphasis on e-government (Government of Pakistan, 2000).14 The E-government Program was launched in 2001 with threefold objectives: to encourage ICTs for enabling information and services delivery to the citizens in a cost-effective manner; to initiate measures for reengineering of work flow in government departments enabling electronic services delivery to citizens for bringing efficiency in operation; and to bring transparency in government functions and access to information.15 Promulgation of Electronic Transactions Ordinance in 2002 was another milestone for promoting economic activities at the grass roots strengthening the local government. Furthermore, Telecom Deregulation Policy was approved in 2003. Note: Inclusion of economic activities is an essential component of electronic government.
13 http://www.unescap.org/huset/lgstudy/new-countrypaper/Pakistan/Pakistan.pdf 14 http://www.apdip.net/projects/dig-rev/info/pk 15 http://www.apdip.net/projects/dig-rev/info/pk
34
H. Rahman
Singapore: Singapore was founded as a British trading colony in 1819. It joined the Malaysian Federation in 1963 but separated 2 years later and became independent.16 Singapore is a city-state with a governing structure following the British system of parliamentary government. In 1989 legislative power was vested in a unicameral Parliament with 81 members who were elected for 5-year terms. The country has only one level of government—national government and local government are one and the same. Below the national level, the only recognized territorial divisions are the 55 parliamentary constituencies. Members of Parliament thus performed some of the same functions as municipal aldermen in foreign cities and often won political support by helping to find jobs for constituents or doing other favors requiring intercession with the powerful civil bureaucracy. The single-member constituencies varied in population from 11,000 electors to as many as 55,000; some of the variability reflected population movement away from the old urban core and out to new housing developments17 (Government of Singapore, 1989). Note: A small area, modest population, consecutive IT plans and foremost combining government rules with industry self-regulations are main catalysts of e-governance advancement in Singapore, despite having a single tier of government structure. In the 1980s, Singapore’s National Computer Board (NCB) was the main body to promote computerization and IT industry development in the island state. Singapore’s first IT master plan was the National Computerization Plan, which was implemented between 1980 and 1985. This plan envisioned the computerization of the public service. It was followed by the National IT Plan (NITP), which was implemented between 1986 and 1991. The NITP was aimed at extending government systems (such as TradeNet and LawNet) to the private sector. The NITP was succeeded by the third IT Master Plan, IT2000 (1992–1999), which envisioned Singapore to be “among the first countries in the world with an advanced nationwide information infrastructure.” This advanced national information infrastructure would be used as the foundation for five strategic thrusts. Singapore is unique in combining government rules with industry self-regulation in managing content. Electronic Transactions Act (ETA) (enacted in 1998), Connected Singapore, Infocomm (a new ICT master plan unveiled in 2000) are among them.18 Furthermore, launching of the Civil Service Computerization Programme (1980–1999), the E-government Action Plan (2000–2003), and the E-government Action Plan II (2003–2006) was to roll out many public services to the citizens. Building on the achievements of the earlier e-government plans, iGov2010, a new 5-year Master plan (2006–2010) was launched in May 2006, aiming to
16 https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/sn.html 17 http://www.mongabay.com/reference/country_studies/singapore/GOVERNMENT.html 18 http://www.ida.gov.sg
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
35
make Singapore Government to be an Integrated Government (Beardsley, von Morgenstern, Enriquez, & Verbeke, 2004; Tan, 2006; Wong, 1996).
Sri Lanka: The organizational structure of local governance consists of three legal instruments: the Municipal Council Ordinance, the Urban Council Ordinance, and the Pradeshiya Sabhas Act. At present there are 18 Municipal Councils, 37 Urban Councils, and 256 Pradeshiya Sabhas. Local governments used to be divided into wards. Wards have been discontinued under the new proportional system. The composition of a local council is based on the total population of a local authority area and not on a ward basis.19 Note: Population is the indicator of local authority area, not geographic boundary.
The Government of Sri Lanka first recognized the need for the development of ICT through the National Computer Policy of 1983 (COMPOL), and this was the first attempt from the government that was taken by the Natural Resources, Energy and Science Authority of Sri Lanka (NARESA) on the instructions of the then President. A committee appointed by NARESA produced the National Computer Policy Report. The acceptance of the COMPOL report by the Government gave rise to the establishment of CINTEC by Act No. 10 of 1984 as the “Computer and Information Technology Council of Sri Lanka” to function directly under the then President. Later on, the Science and Technology Development Act No. 11 of 1994 changed the name to “Council for Information Technology” but retained the acronym CINTEC. The “e-Sri Lanka” project launched in November 2002 was tasked to develop an ICT Roadmap for Sri Lanka. The e-Sri Lanka roadmap resulted in the implementation of the ICT Act No. 27 of 2003, which resulted in the establishment of the Information and Communication Technology Agency of Sri Lanka (ICTA), repealing the relevant section of the Science and Technology Act which established CINTEC. The ICTA has been operational since 1 July 2003. The mandate of the e-Sri Lanka policy is to build a national information infrastructure, create a framework for the promotion of software and ICT-enabled industries, reengineer the Government, and develop ICT-based human resources.20 Note: Information infrastructure development, reengineering of the government, and human resource development are basic ingredients of local e-government development.
19 http://www.unescap.org/huset/lgstudy/new-countrypaper/SriLanka/SriLanka.pdf 20 http://www.ifip.or.at/minutes/GA2005/Rep-SriLanka1.pdf
36
H. Rahman
In order to draw a line of conclusion or provide a set of recommendations, this study would like to proceed with relevant observations as pertinent to develop the e-governance framework. However, the main focus is to promote grass root governance (e-governance at the local government level).
3.1 Observations 3.1.1 Observations Related to Physical Infrastructure In order to achieve maximum capabilities of ICT tools in e-government practice, it is necessary to adjust their organizational structure and usage leading to: actual legal and socio-economic context in which strategic development planning process is to be performed; pragmatic demands that managing of local development has to be fulfilled; include all participants in local management process; and strengthen institutional capacities and procedures (Lalovic, Djukanovic, & Zivkovic, 2004). However, it has been observed that only small percentage of the local governments could meet the criteria for effective e-government management including: leadership, strategic planning, performance measurement, and market promotion. In order to be successful, local e-government objectives require strong leadership that champions e-government and works to increase acceptance among stakeholders. In addition to having a local strategy, individual organizations should also include local e-government approach in their strategic plans to ensure each employee is continuously looking for ways to improve processes and service delivery. Regular performance measures are also essential for evaluating whether the particular egovernment system (segment of the system) is cost-efficient, properly serving customers, and being used effectively (Austin City Council, 2008). Aiming at a fully functioning information system, the following basic technical preconditions should also be met: establishment of a local network connecting all the computers in the local administration, or at least one computer in each organization or office should be in the network; configuring a central server to host the content, information, and supporting software locally; and affordable Internet connection according to the needs of the local government network and its financial capacity. Large municipalities might use a dedicated line (broadband, fiber, ISDN, or other available high speed connectivity), providing 24-h connection with the Internet. Smaller local governments may afford to a more limited connection at an affordable price. Central government may subsidize the entire operation for a while till the local e-government system becomes self-sustainable. If the system is built around the core aspects of the livelihood system, incorporating the people at large has every possibility of sustenance in the long run. However, to implement a pragmatic information system at the local government level, the following information infrastructure could be thought as a prerequisite: at least one computer in each department or office (simple PIII or PIV or even clones); one high-end computer (may be a Pentium V) functioning as server; personnel with minimum working knowledge on computer basics and Internet; a user-friendly
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
37
operating system (perhaps, open source), and a basic operational manual; at least a team of experts (preferably local, if not periodical visits from central) to conduct the basic systemic analysis, install the model, and train the officials (train the trainers, instead of training the entire community). (With over 10 years of experience with SDNP Bangladesh, SDNF Bangladesh, and later SchoolNet Foundation Bangladesh, the last two paragraphs are author’s own recommendations). Furthermore, depending on the governance structure, it has been observed that tiers of the government system may range from three tiers to four tiers. For sake of better governance, a five-tier system may be sought of, as depicted in Fig. 2.3. To reach out to the grass roots, national→ regional/state/division→district/city corporation→sub-district/municipality→village/community would be a thorough, effective, and dynamic route. Along this path to reach the grass roots, the tiers though may not be autonomous in nature, but can form a chain of command or retrospectively path of information flow at the national, regional, and local level. This support system may follow either the top–bottom or bottom–top approach, but e-government researchers indicate that the bottom–top approaches act better in terms of grass-roots governance. Usually, a bottom-up governance system has the chance of growing on its own organically along its lifespan. Figure 2.3 shows the nature of support in each level with an additional vertical communication path.
TIERS
1: Planning, Policies, Legislations, Acts, Management, Monitoring, Controls
2: Policies, Monitoring, Controls, Management, Implementations
LEVELS OF INTERVENTION
National Level
State Level/Division Level
3: Partnerships, Management, Controls, Implementations
District Level/Corporation Level
4: Partnerships, Management, Controls, Implementations, Awareness
Sub-district/Municipality Level
5: Awareness, Promotion, Partnerships, Implementations
Village/Community Level
Fig. 2.3 A five-tier local e-government organizational structure (Source: Author)
38
H. Rahman
3.1.2 Observations Related to E-Government Frameworks South Korea has been successful in keeping their e-government readiness ranking at the top 5 during last consecutive years. They have adopted four dimensional framework focusing demand and supply-driven strategy. Within the system, depending on the supply and demand, requisite infrastructures have developed and change management have been conducted (Fig. 2.4). India, a country in South Asia, is consecutively promoting e-government for many years, and has succeeded in accelerating the pace of development through utilizing ICTs following an established e-government framework (Fig. 2.5). The country has developed a three-tier e-government framework comprising back-ends (databases of different government agencies, service providers, state governments, etc.), middleware (information infrastructure, citizen portal, gateways, integrated services, etc.) and front-end delivery channels (home PCs, mobile phones, kiosks, integrated citizen service centers, etc.) for citizens and entrepreneurs (Das & Chandrashekhar, 2006). Singapore ranked as 23rd among 192 countries under the study of UN E–Government Readiness Index in 2008 and ranked first among 34 surveyed countries under the 2009 Waseda University International E-government Ranking (UN,
Demand-Driven (In consultation with citizens and entrepreneurs)
Supply-Driven (Requisite Government services made online)
Change Management Process (Commitment and drivers of changes)
Front-Office Adequate Infrastructure (Enabling publicly available infrastructure) Back-Office
Fig. 2.4 E-government framework of South Korea (Adopted from Kim, 2002)
Fig. 2.5 E-government framework of India (adopted from Das & Chandrashekhar, 2006)
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
39
2008; Waseda, 2009). Singapore’s success as a leading disseminator of effective egovernment is not only just enabling government services with technology, but also involves a enormous effort to reform the public service, which envisages significant structural and operational changes. Over the last 20 years, the government’s progressive and thoroughly designed national ICT programs have established a strong foundation to transform the public service. However, a holistic e-government framework should not only addresses the technology, but also management, process, governance, social and cultural issues to deliver accessible, integrated, and value added e-services to its stakeholders (James, 2004; Sin, 2007). This study here infers that incorporating appropriate policies, promoting enabled ICT environment, and adopting empowered governance structures at the grass roots e-government can be promulgated broadly, and ultimately a balanced local e-government system will encourage increased e-services leading to e-democracy of a nation (with perfection in logical, physical, and financial accomplishments), as shown in Fig. 2.6. Balanced and value-driven e - government Combination of electronic and participatory service delivery E-Administration E - Democracy Transaction of user-oriented and valueDigitally conveyed information driven services offered by local (transparent) and the political influence government that is based on ICTs (participatory) exerted by citizens and business on the opinion-forming processes of public-state and non-state institutions
Fig. 2.6 Concept of local e-government (Adopted from Open Society Institute, 2007)
4 Future E-governance Framework and Recommendations A three-pronged approach may simplify delegation of local e-government at the grass roots, such as a merit is made between access policies (aimed at improving access to ICTs for all citizens), content policies (directed to improve the use of ICTs in the city administration and semi-public domains), and infrastructure policies (to improve the provision of broadband infrastructure) (Berg, Meer, Winden, & Woets, 2006). In this respect, incorporation of parties actively involved at the grass roots governance processes should be involved. Furthermore, to strengthen local e-government management at the grass roots, three-dimensional approach, as suggested by Austin City Council (2008), may adopt a four-dimensional approach as shown in Fig. 2.7. It has been observed that non-government institutions or civil societies are one of the important drivers of policy engagement to the community people in many countries. Better implementation of local e-government or local e-governance means utilizing the power of ICT to assist in transforming the accessibility, quality, and cost-effectiveness of public service and to help revitalize the relationship among
40
H. Rahman Government
Non-govt.
Local Government System
Academic
Entrepreneurs
Fig. 2.7 Increased partnership at the local level incorporating all stakeholders (Adopted from CTG, 2002; Author)
customers and citizens and the public bodies who work for their benefits. Planned e-governance and appropriate use of ICT at the local level can enhance and support economic and social development, particularly in empowering officials and municipal representatives by ensuring linkages and networking through timely, efficient, transparent, responsive, and accountable services. According to European researches (Open Society Institute, 2007), local governments in developed countries are offering up to 77% of public e-services. Often local government portal is the first step to reach even the central government services. Implementation of e-services and broadband strategy is another possibility to overcome problems of different social groups and remote areas. However, welldeveloped ICT infrastructure with intensive offering of e-services by the local government will remain as challenge for engaging large groups of active citizens into the decision-making processes and supporting development and implementation of proper e-democracy in the locality (Turner, 2004). Moreover, information society development at the grass roots is in large extent remains as an internal issue of local governments in comparison to the central government as local governments are more close to the citizens. Also, after decentralization of local government structures, municipalities will be able to offer new, wider variety of services for their citizens. But, it may become a great challenge as a newcomer to offer those services through progressive information and communication technologies, rather than the age-old traditional way. These issues will need further attention and research in terms of developing new hardware platform, new software platform, and new legislation. In an underdeveloped country scenario, health and education make up about 75% of all services provided by local governments. Other areas include fiscal decentralization, financial management and accountability, good governance and civic education, infrastructure development, communication and information system, capacity-building of local governments, partnership-building, institutional strengthening, coordination, and integration (Chadwick, 2003; Fukao, 1995; Wasukira & Naigambi, 2002).
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
41
To meet the new requirements, an electronic platform needs to be developed, to: allow collection of personal information from the possession of national agencies to be available; allow different degrees of technological maturity among the various services; guarantee high levels of security; deliver high levels of availability; and publish open standards in terms of data format, information exchange, and levels of security. To address these challenges, designs have to be developed by incorporating technological, financial, organizational, and institutional surroundings for implementing an integrated electronic services platform. Furthermore, to complement development of the integrated platform, procedures need to be redesigned, standardized, and digitized for a legally compliant process model with a highly calibrated defined structure (Inter-American Development Bank, 2006; Misra, 2008). Instead of local governments developing e-government applications in a potentially duplicative and isolated manner, central government should assist in promulgating standards and guidelines that encourage local government to collaborate on developing e-services and sharing databases and services across the network (OECD, 2007a, 2007b). Future issues should also incorporate strategies to develop a robust broadband infrastructure with access to all, from all businesses (especially SMEs) to everyone in the community; ensure that the education and the skill base is there to develop and sustain the future workforce; tackle the “digital divide” and ensure that the information society is open to all; create a business-friendly environment for e-commerce and e-business to develop and reach the critical mass, especially in terms of the digital content (Berg, Meer, Winden, & Woets, 2006). In the future local e-government system, local autonomy should persist through participatory budgeting with enhanced participation from women and youth, NGO, and civil society.
4.1 Proposed Framework A future e-government framework could be a four-pronged approach in four dimensions, including access, availability, equity, and democracy (see Fig. 2.8) Furthermore, the future e-government framework may take a four-layer operational strategies, incorporating development, deployment, delegation, and dissemination (see Table 2.2). The future e-government framework could focus on a paradigm shift from the current context to a future scenario, as depicted in the Table 2.3.
5 Conclusion Governance at the local level matters, and e-governance is a better way of providing government services to the common citizens. However, the method by which governments govern their communities, nationally, regionally, and locally, forms an essential element in determining the outcomes which contribute to the quality of life of those communities. In this aspect, good governance, which is governance
42
H. Rahman
Fig. 2.8 A four-dimensional e-government framework (adopted from Nour, AbdelRahman, & Fadlalla, 2008)
Democracy:
Equity:
Promoting– Integrity, Accountability, and Transparency
Enhancing– Responsiveness, Accountability, Transparency, Effectiveness, and Quality of life Availability:
Access: Providing– Information pertaining to the governance system
Increasing– Efficiency, Effectiveness, Quality of system, and Understandability among participants
Table 2.2 Four-layer e-government operational strategies Operational strategy
Actions
Development
Network layer: Information infrastructure, servers, LANs, WANs, intranet, Internet Integration layer: Database development, e-mail, e-forms, e-portals, network-enabled system, legal boundaries, policy issues Management layer: skill development, business process reengineering, demand–supply management User application layer: G2G, G2C, C2G, G2B, B2G, G2NG, NG2G, G2O, O2Ga
Deployment
Delegation Dissemination a This
study would like to incorporate NG (non-government entities), and O (any other parties involved in the governance system of country, including civil societies, and marginalized communities). Source: Sharma & Gupta (2003; Author).
that allows the collective aspirations of people at large to be fulfilled effectively and efficiently, depends on the way in which public institutions are designed and operate. This includes institutions which balance the ability for citizens to exercise influence with the capacity to allow elected representatives to exercise leadership. The approach in which local government institutions develop and deliver services and the structure of the local government sector are matters of concern to all who take an interest in how public sector organizations can achieve effective community outcomes (MDL, 2006; McNabb, 2006). This validates rigid institutionalization for promotion of e-governance at the grass roots. The e-government system at the central should have a clear vision and priorities for local e-government; prepared for the emerging technologies; contain enough political will to lead the e-government endeavors; prioritize selection of
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
43
Table 2.3 Paradigm shift of the current e-government system to a future e-government system Current
Future
Fragmented services: Agent centric, semi-automated
Uninterrupted shared services: Citizen centric, participative, synchronized, integrated, automated
Traditional form of service: Ubiquitous service: Mostly single channel, Multiple channels, pull service (demand-driven), personalized push service service, knowledge-driven (supply-driven), mass service (not personalized) Functionality of service: Mainly focused on demand–supply chain, pushed by the government hierarchy, mostly controlled by the central government
Socially integrated form of service: Focus on value addition to the user and people at large, decentralized, interlinked with the local government autonomy
Source: Government of S. Korea (2006, Author).
e-government projects during implementation stage; competent in planning and managing them; able to overcome resistance from within the government; introduce appropriate monitoring, measurement, feedback, and communication paths to follow up the progress of implementation; promote institutional relationship among all implementing partners, especially the private sector implementers; develop adequate human skills to manage the entire operational chain; and able to improve citizen participation in public affairs (Pacific Council, 2002) thus validating importance of central government’s role in grass roots e-governance. Apart from proper designing, structuring, and launching of an online resource, local e-government initiatives involve much more than just a Website. A June 2006 report, prepared for the Congressional Research Service by a research team from the University of Texas at Austin’s LBJ School of Public Affairs, identified a number of commonly used factors that contribute to the functioning of state e-government initiatives. They were: appropriate strategies, adequate funding, authentic leadership, adoptive technology, and ample performance measurement (Austin City Council, 2008). Each stage of local e-government development should be built upon the previous one, until government reaches a new consensus for providing further improved e-services to citizens and businesses. Thus, technologies need to be adopted as per the requirement of the end-users. However, it has been observed that, at the national level and in the advantaged localities (central cities, capital cities, and urban areas) ICTs are extensively used to address only the key business processes. The national e-government policy does not always apply in devotion to the local government level. Even they are being applied; the policy cannot avoid duplication of efforts, problems of interoperability,
44
H. Rahman
and inability to leverage economies of scale and security. The key components that drive the local governance and ICTs remain access, content, citizen service, and economic and social development, and for proper implementation of the ICT strategies, the need for these initiatives targeting marginalized areas has also remained not properly identified. Furthermore, in spite of the local governments differ considerably in terms of capacity, content, service delivery, and effectiveness; they have to be dynamic and developmental due to their involvement in local economic development. Local governments need to take the role of the key player in developing integrated rural-based, citizen-centric, information-driven, user-friendly, easily accessible, and dynamic e-governance system (CPSI, 2005; Samarajiva & Zainudeen, 2008). Foremost, e-governance at the grass roots needs to accommodate value-driven services. In this aspect the study concludes, there are no straightforward way of improving the e-government system at the local government level, rather many factors control the system, including the structure of the government (tiers of the government system), local demographics (population, size, density), set of responsibilities authorized to local governments (government rule of orders) and the homogeneity of preferences within the area (policies and governance issues) (Commonwealth, 2004; Fox & Gurley, 2006).
References Anttiroiko, A. (2004). Towards citizen-centered local e-government: The case of the city of Tampere. In M. Khosrow-Pour (Ed.), Annals of cases on information technology (Vol. 6, pp. 371–388). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing Austin City Council (2008). Audit report 2008: City of Austin’s e-government initiative. Office of the City Auditor, Austin, Texas. Beardsley, S., von Morgenstern, I. B., Enriquez, L., & Verbeke, W. (2004). Towards a new regulatory compact. The global information technology report 2003–2004: Towards an equitable information society. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 71–86. Berg, L. van den, Meer, A. van der, Winden, W. van & Woets, P. (2006). E-governance in European and South African cities: The cases of Barcelona, Cape Town, Eindhoven, Johannesburg, Manchester, Tampere, The Hague, and Venice, Ashgate Publishing, Ltd., 2006 Bovaird, T. (2003). e-Government and e-Governance: Organisational Implications, Options and Dilemmas. Public Policy and Administration, 18(2), 37–56. Calista, D. J., & Melitski, J. (2007). e-Government and e-Governance: converging constructs of public sector information and communications technologies. Public Administration Quarterly, 31(1), 87–120. Chadwick, A. (2003). Bringing E-democracy back. In: Why it matters for future research on e-governance. Social Science Computer Review, 21(4), 443–455. Chauhan, R. (2009). National E-Governance Plan in India, UNU-IIST. Chutimaskul, W., & Chongsuphajaisiddhi, V. (2004). A framework for developing local e-government. In M. A. Wimmer (Ed.), Proceedings of Knowledge Management in Electronic Government: 5th IFIP International Working Conference, KMGov 2004, Krems, Austria, May 17–19, pp. 319–324. Commonwealth (2004). Commonwealth local government handbook: Modernisation, Council Structures, Finance, E-Government, Local Democracy, Partnerships, Representation, Commonwealth Local Government Forum, Commonwealth Secretariat, 2004.
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
45
CPSI (2005). Local Governance and ICTs Research Network for Africa, LOG-IN Africa, COUNTRY REPORT – SOUTH AFRICA, Produced for the LOG-IN Africa Project Planning, Compiled by: Centre for Public Service Innovation (CPSI) and the LINK Centre, University of the Witwatersrand, Nairobi, Kenya. CTG (2002). New foundations: Annual Report 2002, Center for Technology in Government, University at Albany, State University of New York. CTG (2003). Annual Report 2003, Center for Technology in Government, University at Albany, State University of New York. Das, S. R., & Chandrashekhar, R. (2006). List of Asia Pacific e-government case studies, UNDPAPDIP. Fox, W. F., & Gurley, T. (2006). Will Consolidation Improve Sub-National Governments? World Bank Policy Research Working Paper WPS3913, May 2006, World Bank, Washington DC. Fukao, M. (1995). Financial integration, corporate governance, and the performance of multinational companies. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers. Gessi, T., Ramnarine, D., & Wilkins, J. (2007). Introducing a new e-governance framework in the commonwealth: from theory to practice, Hong Kong journals online. The Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration, 29(2), 1–21. Government of Bangladesh (2002). National Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Policy (October: 2002), Ministry of Science and Information & Communication Technology, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh. Government of India (2000). The Information Technology Act, 2000 (No. 21 OF 2000). Ministry of Law, Justice and Company Affairs (Legislative Department), New Delhi, India. Government of Pakistan (2000). IT Policy and Action Plan, IT & Telecommunications Division, Ministry of Science & Technology, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad. Government of Pakistan (2005). E-Government Strategy and 5-Year Plan for the Federal Government, Electronic Government Directorate, Ministry of IT, Pakistan. Government of Singapore (1989). Based on information from Singapore, Ministry of Communications and Information, Information Division, Singapore, 1989, 53–63. Government of S. Korea (2006). E-Government for participation and inclusion in Korea, E-government headquarters, MOGHA, Republic of Korea. Hoogwout, M. (2003). Super pilots, subsidizing or self-organization: stimulating e-government initiatives in Dutch local governments. In R. Traunmüller (Ed.), Proceedings of Electronic Government: Second International Conference, EGOV 2003, Prague, Czech Republic, September 1–5, 2003, Springer: pp. 85–90. Inter-American Development Bank (2006). Multiphase Program for the Strengthening of Chile’s Digital Strategy, Report # CH-L1001, Document of the Inter-American Development Bank, Washington, DC. James, A. J. (2004) “India’s Sector Reform Projects and Swajaldhara Programme,” case study prepared for the IRC International Water and Sanitation Centre, Delft, the Netherlands, available at http://www.irc.nl/page/23597 Kim, H. -K. (2002). e-Government in Korea, a presentation from the National Computerization Agency, Korea Kolsaker, A. (2005). Third way e-government: The case for local devolution. In M. H. Böhlen, J. Gamper, W. Polasek, & M. A. Wimmer (Eds.), Proceedings of E-Government: Towards Electronic Democracy : International Conference, TCGOV 2005 Bolzano, Italy, March 2–4, 2005, Springer: pp. 70–80. Labelle, R. (2005). ICT Policy Formulation and e-Strategy Development: A Comprehensive Guidebook. United Nations Development Programme-Asia Pacific Development Information Programme (UNDP-APDIP) – 2005, Reed Elsevier India Private Limited. Lallana, E. C. (2004). An Overview of ICT Policies and e-Strategies of Select Asian Economies. United Nations Development Programme-Asia Pacific Development Information Programme (UNDP-APDIP) – 2004, Reed Elsevier India Private Limited.
46
H. Rahman
Lalovic, K., Djukanovic, Z., & Zivkovic, J. (2004). Building the ICT fundament for local E-government in Serbia- Municipality of Loznica example, In M. Schrenk (Ed.), Proceedings of the 9th International Symposium on Planning and IT, Vienna, Austria. Malhotra, C., Chariar, V. M., Das, L. K., & Ilavarasan, P. V. (2007). An evaluatory framework for ICT interventions in the rural areas: Review of literature on e-governance for rural development in the Indian context. In G. P. Sahu (Ed.), Adopting e-Governance (pp. 216–226). New Delhi: GIFT Publishing. McNabb, D. E. (2006). Knowledge management in the public sector: A blueprint for innovation in government. M. E. Sharpe, 2006. MDL (2006). Local Government structure and efficiency, a report prepared for local government new Zealand. McKinlay Douglas Limited, New Zealand. Misra, D. C. (2008). Emerging e-government challenges: Past imperfect, present tense but future promising. A presentation at the 4th International Conference on E-government, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi. Nour, M. A., AbdelRahman, A., & Fadlalla, A. (2008). A context-based integrative framework for e-government initiatives. Government Information Quarterly, 25, 448–461. OECD (2007a). Turkey: OECD E-government Studies, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Paris: OECD Publishing, 2007 OECD (2007b). Hungary: OECD E-government Studies, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Paris: OECD Publishing, 2007 Open Society Institute (2007). ICT for Local Government Handbook, Local Government and Public Service Reform Initiative. Open Society Institute, Budapest. Pacific Council (2002). Roadmap for E-government in the Developing World: 10 Questions Egovernment leaders Should Ask Themselves, The Working Group report on E-government in the Developing World, Pacific Council on International Policy, CA. Perotti, E. C. & von Thadden, E. -L. (2006, March). Corporate governance and the distribution of wealth: A political-economy perspective. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 162(1), 204–217(14), Mohr Siebeck. Pertrazzini, B. A., & Harindranath, G. (1997). Information infrastructure initiative in emerging economies: The case of India. In B. Kahin & E. J. Wilson III (Eds.), National Information Infrastructure Initiatives (p. 220). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Rahman, H. (2007). Role of ICTs in socioeconomic development and poverty reduction. In H. Rahman (Ed.), Information and communication technologies for economic and regional developments (pp. 180–219). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Inc. Rahman, H. (Ed.). (2008). An overview on strategic ICT implementations toward developing knowledge societies. In Developing Successful ICT Strategies: Competitive Advantages in a Global Knowledge-Driven Society (pp. 1–39). Hershey, PA: Information Science Reference. Rahman, H. (Ed.). (2009). Local e-government management: A wider window of e-governance. In Handbook of research on e-government readiness for information and service exchange: Utilizing progressive information communication technologies (pp. 295–323). Hershey, PA: Information Science Reference. Rainford, S. (2006). e-Sri Lanka: An integrated approach to e-government case study, a report of the ICT Agency of Sri Lanka. Samarajiva, R., & Zainudeen, A. (Eds.). (2008). ICT Infrastructure in Emerging Asia: Policy and Regulatory Roadblocks. London: SAGE Publications & IDRC. Sayo, P., Chacko, J. G., & Pradhan, G. (Eds.). (2004). ICT Policies and e-Strategies in the AsiaPacific: A critical assessment of the way forward, United Nations Development ProgrammeAsia Pacific Development Information Programme (UNDP-APDIP) – 2004, Reed Elsevier India Private Limited. Shackleton, P., Fisher, J., & Dawson, L. (2004). E-Government services: One local government’s approach. In H. Linger et al. (Eds.), Constructing the infrastructure for the knowledge economy: Methods and tools, theory and practice. New York: Springer.
2
Framework of E-governance at the Local Government Level
47
Sharma, S. K., & Gupta, J. N. D. (2003, October–December). Building blocks of an e-government – a framework. Journal of Electronic Commerce in Organizations, 1(4), 1–15. Sin, C. Y. (2007). Foundation of effective e-government: The Singapore experience, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs (BCSIA), John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University. Tan, P. (2006). ICA Country Report: Singapore e-Government, iGov2010: From integrating services to integrating government, Infocomm Development Authority of Singapore. Turner, T. J. (2004). Local government e-disclosure & comparisons: Equipping deliberative democracy for the 21st century, University Press of America, 2004 UN (2008). United Nations e-Government Survey 2008: From e-government to connected governance, United Nations, NY. Wasukira, E., & Naigambi, W. (2002). Report on the Usage of ICT in Local Governments in Uganda, IICD, Canada. Waseda (2009). 2009 WASEDA University e-Government Ranking, Waseda University Institute of e-Government, Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan. Wong, P. -K. (1996), Implementing the NII vision: Singapore’s experience and future challenges. In B. Kahin & E. Wilson (Eds.), National information infrastructure initiatives: Vision and policy design (pp. 24–60). Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. Yoon, J. (2007). Korea’s e-Government Strategy, a presentation from the National Information Society Agency, Korea. Zwahr, T., & Finger, M. (2004, June). Critical steps towards e-Governance: a case study analysis, A Proceeding of the 4th European Conference on E-Government 2004. Dublin, Ireland.
Chapter 3
A Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites of Middle East and North African (MENA) Countries Abebe Rorissa, Devendra Potnis, and Dawit Demissie
The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) have historical ties and MENA countries share similarities with respect to socio-cultural characteristics, national economics (mainly based on natural resources such as oil), religious beliefs (predominantly Muslim), national languages (mainly Arabic), form of governance, and affiliation to regional organizations such as the Arab League. Few comparative e-government researchers have addressed e-government services and contents of e-government Websites within the context of MENA countries. This chapter fills in this gap by presenting e-governance as a desired outcome of diffusion of the Internet among MENA countries. It presents comparisons with respect to types of Websites and services, service-oriented features, online executable services, stages of development of e-government service, and e-government rankings of Websites hosted by MENA governments. Results of our analyses suggest that the similarities in e-governance among MENA countries span a number of variables including the stages of development of e-government services provided through Websites. Our recommendations, grounded in careful examination of 230 Websites of 18 MENA nations, could assist them in the provision of better e-government services to their citizens.
A. Rorissa (B) University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany, NY 12222, USA e-mail:
[email protected] D. Potnis University of Tennessee at Knoxville, Knoxville, TN 37996, USA e-mail:
[email protected] D. Demissie University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany, NY 12222, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_3, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
49
50
A. Rorissa et al.
1 Introduction The contemporary comparative e-government research mainly consists of the comparison of different models and frameworks proposed with similar objectives in assessing e-government initiatives. For instance, in the West, models proposed for Public Financial Management Systems are compared widely in regard to their context, content, and supporting analytical disciplines (Bovaird & Loffler, 2009). Digital government researchers have also compared appraisal frameworks for e-governance (Hu, Xiao, Pang, & Xie, 2005). Comparing toolkits that guide practitioners for crafting and executing various strategies in e-governance is another dimension of comparative research in e-governance, which essentially aims to bridge the gap between practice and theory (Gil-Garcia & Pardo, 2005). The degree to which citizens’ and bureaucrats’ perspectives regarding e-government converge or diverge is often compared and contrasted in terms of their knowledge of e-governance, attitudes toward e-governance, concerns about e-governance, and thoughts about the pace of e-governance implementation (Moon & Welch, 2005). However, amid various modes of comparison, it is important to note that existing literature on comparative e-government research mainly focuses on countries or regions with distinct backgrounds. In contrast, our research compares MENA countries with similar contextual features in terms of cultures, languages, capital-driven economies, geography, structures of governance, and overall social structures. Countries in the Middle East (excluding Israel) and in North Africa (MENA) have both historical ties and similar socio-cultural characteristics, economics (mainly based on natural resources such as oil), religion (predominantly Muslim), language (mainly Arabic speaking), and forms of government. Most of the MENA countries also belong to the same regional bodies (e.g., The Arab League). A fair share of the world’s oil and natural gas supply comes from MENA countries. As a result, MENA countries’ economies rely on the export of these natural resources. However, some of the nations like the UAE seem to have diversified their capitalbased economies to skill-based and knowledge-based economies. Irrespective of their types of economies, however, the scarcity of drinking water and arable land pose great challenges to the MENA countries. In addition, many MENA nations are not fully fledged democracies. In fact, MENA countries host a number of theocracies or monarchies while there remains little or no representation for certain parts of society (Robins, 2009). It is evident that despite relatively low political participation, lack of pluralism, and civil liberties, some of the MENA countries have made significant progress in adopting and implementing information and communication technologies (ICTs) (see Table 3.1). Also, their consistently improving e-government rankings attest to their innovative ways of practicing governance using ICTs (West, 2007a). It is important to note that although MENA countries lag behind the world in some key areas of governance (Internet World Stats, 2009; Slate Group, 2008; United Nations, 2009), they are competent enough to provide access to the Internet and deliver government services to their citizens.
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
51
Table 3.1 An ICT profile of the MENA countries
Population Land area
Internet users (as of 30 June 2009) Internet penetration (% of population) Internet user growth (2000–2008) (%) e-Readiness index Web measures index Human capital index Infrastructure index E-participation index Telecom infrastructure index Per capita income Democracy index
Africa
North Africaa Asia
975,330,899 11.7 million sq mi (20.41%) 65,903,900
200,489,280 3.19 million sq mi
Middle Eastb World 6,710,029,070 57.31 million sq mi
33,260,200
3,780,819,792 189,253,348 17.2 million 2.77 million sq mi Sq mi (30%) 704,213,930 47,964,146
6.7
14.21
18.5
23.7
23.8
1,359.9
5410.4
516.1
1,360.2
342.2
0.2740
0.340266667 0.4467
0.597942857 0.4514
0.1875
0.218516667 0.3725
0.542657143 0.3540
0.5909
0.690466667 0.7916
0.906000
0.0529
0.115583333 0.1670
0.446871429 0.2104
0.0952
0.1174
0.2084
0.330514286 0.1909
0.03211
0.18893
0.179332
0.468819
0.570928
$3,433
$5,598(2007) $14,665
$8,200(2007)
3.93
3.143333333 4.01
$22,873 (2008) 3.01100
1,668,870,408
0.7825
5.547664671
a Includes
Algeria, Egypt, Libya, Morocco, Sudan, and Tunisia. Bahrain, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Qatar, Saudi-Arabia, Syria, the UAE, and Yemen. Sources: Internet World Stats (2009), Slate Group (2008), and United Nations (2009). b Includes
Existing literature on comparative e-government research mainly focuses on countries with disparate characteristics. In contrast, our research compares MENA countries with similar contextual features in terms of cultures, languages, capitaldriven economies, geography, structures of governance, and overall social structures. Our goal is to bridge the gap in the literature by comparing the contents of e-government service Websites of MENA countries. The types of Websites, types of services and features, online executable services, stages of development of e-government service, and e-government rankings form the unit of comparison. This chapter is organized as follows: The second section provides an evolving background on ICT adoption by MENA countries, with e-governance and digital
52
A. Rorissa et al.
divide as desired and undesired outcomes of the adoption. It also presents challenges to e-government implementations for MENA countries and public private partnership (PPP) as a catalyst for e-governance. The third section details the design of our research. The fourth section presents the results of our statistical analysis followed by relevant discussions. The last section concludes with the significance of such comparative e-government research studies and offers context-specific recommendations for effective e-government adoption by MENA countries.
2 Background Although service costs and financial affordability to access ICTs have always been major obstacles to the information revolution in MENA countries (Heeks, 2002), the adoption of ICTs in the MENA region by public and private sectors offers a unique opportunity to its citizens. Access to ICTs is typically expected to generate socio-economic opportunities for citizens. However, low literacy levels, lack of training, and low technical skills act as major barriers to applying ICTs toward generating and taking advantage of its socio-economic opportunities. The following section offers an overview of the current status of ICTs in the MENA countries, desired and undesired outcomes of deployment of ICTs in the region, challenges faced by MENA countries for execution of ICTs for effective governance, PPPs as a solution to enhance government efforts for ICTs adoption by MENA countries, and finally, the role of comparative research on e-government adoption by MENA governments.
2.1 ICT in MENA Nations The ICT revolution in MENA countries is lending old technologies new relevance (De Alcántara, 2002). At the beginning of this millennium, email was proliferating, but Telex remained an important means of communication (Burkhart & Older, 2003). While the proliferation of ICTs was initially spurred by the need to disseminate news and information (mostly one-way communication), interactive technologies made their way into areas such as government. A technology plays a more crucial role when it is widely available and used. In this regard, it bodes well for MENA countries because the number of Internet users in MENA nations grew from 16.0 million in 2003 to over 70 million in 2009 (EuroMonitor, 2009). Their share of the world’s total Internet users rose from 2.0 to 4.1% over the same period (see Table 3.1). Some of the authoritarian governments from MENA nations are also expected to crack down on the use of the Internet as a political tool. We believe that while the proportion of users to the total population is still low and some governments continue the crackdown on usage, the impact due to the Internet is, for the most part, positive. An example is the Twitter and Facebook revolution after the controversial Iranian elections in 2009. The Kingdom of Bahrain is also one of the first MENA nations to go online and launch the first Arab E-government Facebook group on the Internet. In fact, social networking services such as Facebook are used
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
53
by MENA governments to introduce and implement emerging web technologies to open more channels of interaction, enabling stakeholder participation (especially citizens), and for opinion sharing purposes (Facebook, 2009). Computers and communication, physical infrastructure, and content are the three main pillars of the information revolution in MENA nations (Burkhart & Older, 2003). At the dawn of the information revolution in MENA countries, they were grouped into three categories: fearful (e.g., Algeria, Iraq, Libya, and Syria), desiring the “best of both worlds,” (e.g., Iran, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, and the UAE), or driven (e.g., Bahrain, Kuwait, and Qatar) (Burkhart & Older, 2003). Fearful countries were the ones with limited Internet connectivity or that prohibited it altogether. The countries labeled as wanting the best of both the worlds attempted to develop a tightly controlled domestic Internet network that enabled them to reap benefits in commerce, academia, and government, while maintaining strict limits on the scope of the Internet. Driven countries wanted an information revolution so badly that they were risk-prone in terms of making investments in ICTs. In general, while applying ICTs for better governance is a desired outcome of the ICT revolution in MENA countries, digital divide has been an undesired outcome of the same phenomenon.
2.2 Digital Divide: An Undesired Outcome of Widespread ICTs in MENA Nations One of the major challenges faced by MENA nations is a growing level of digital divide in media, information, and communication technologies. In the early days of e-government adoption by MENA nations, half of the Arab world’s population was deprived and disadvantaged (UNDP, 2002). It was observed from that point on that having limited local content and languages created obstacles in the widespread use of ICTs (Resnick, 2002). Less than 30% of MENA nations’ population had a telephone line (Burkhart & Older, 2003). It was also predicted that “. . . the region as a whole will deploy telephone service for at least half of the population by 2012, but there will be wide variations between the richest and most liberal countries on the one hand and the poorest and most repressive on the other hand” (Burkhart & Older, 2003). In light of these facts, bridging the digital divide in MENA countries was expected to be a gradual process. It should also be noted that without consistent commitment and fierce support by governments, donors, and the private sector, it may be impossible to overcome the digital divide in MENA countries (LaMotte, 2002). The lack of realization among MENA nations for developing skilled human capital to sustain ICT adoption also contributed to the digital divide.
2.3 E-government for Better Governance in MENA Nations E-government—as a major instrument for achieving “good governance”— accompanied by important investments in media and ICTs could have been an important source of productivity growth and economic growth along with economic
54
A. Rorissa et al.
development and democracy in MENA countries (World Bank, 2003). Most Arab countries in the MENA region strive for an efficient, effective, and results-driven public administration (OECD, 2007). ICTs and e-government play a strong role in achieving this goal (OECD, 2006). To their credit, strong high-level leadership was evident during the last decade in Jordan, Syria, Egypt, and the UAE for the deployment of e-government initiatives (Saidi & Yared, 2002). On the other hand, until 2002, Yemen, Iran, Oman, and Qatar had more than just web-presence on the Internet. These nations had started publishing electronic content whereas Algeria, Egypt, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, and Saudi Arabia had mere online presence through basic Websites (Saidi & Yared, 2002). The current state of affairs with respect to e-government adoption is encouraging. As part of a high-level capacity-building initiative between the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and MENA governments, they recently identified lack of information and data, digital divide, and lack of measurement and evaluation techniques for e-government initiatives as some of the key obstacles to administrative simplification (OECD, 2008b). Specific desirable targets are now emerging for MENA countries, such as applying ICTs for the digitization of entire administrations, and providing better access to services, information and procedures. Solutions such as enhancing communication practices using ICTs, developing standardized data collection policies and procedures, bringing uniformity in e-government practices for international collaboration, better regulatory frameworks, benchmarking government performances, and creating incentives for governments by monitoring their e-government initiatives at various levels are some of the proposed solutions for efficiently deploying ICTs in MENA countries (OECD, 2007). In 2007, after participating in stocktaking activities conducted by OECD, MENA governments identified high priority areas for offering e-governance. These are “(1) institutional arrangements for e-government; (2) e-services, sectoral initiatives, shared applications; (3) e-government strategy formulation and implementation; (4) technical infrastructure for e-government; (5) e-government and administrative simplification; (6) e-government training and capacity building; (7) legislative infrastructure for e-government; and (8) measurement and evaluation of e-government” (OECD, 2008a). This list of prioritized objectives underlines the reliance on widespread applications of ICTs for governance. Since the early stages of e-government adoption, social scientists advised that ICTs need to be tailored according to local socio-economic needs and the political progress of each individual MENA nation (De Alcántara, 2002). In addition, waxing levels of content in Arabic is also expected to increase civic participation in e-government.
2.4 E-government Challenges Faced by MENA Nations The level of economic development and the nature of government and its role in ICT development are the two critical success factors for the adoption of e-governance in MENA nations (Burkhart & Older, 2003). Pricing, affordability, and reliability of
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
55
ICT infrastructure access (Saidi & Yared, 2002) have also been challenges faced by MENA governments while executing IT projects in the public sector. In the 1990s, MENA nations’ overall indicators for access and connectivity were below the world average, keeping them away from the mainstream networked global information society (Foulger, 2001). Domestic and regional broadband networks could be established to foster the growth of trade among MENA countries using ICTs. Business through the Internet or electronic commerce (e-commerce) is an application of ICTs as well as a promoter of widespread usage of ICTs. Most e-government service implementations are based on the e-commerce model whereby both horizontal (across departments or nations) and vertical (across levels of government) integration improve efficiency, cooperation, and convenience. However, existing legal frameworks that act as barriers to regional cooperation among MENA countries need to be addressed as they discourage regional socio-economic collaboration using ICTs. The challenges are not just limited to technologies but also the political, socio-economic, and cultural aspirations of citizens. ICTs’ potential to serve as a medium for realizing the freedom of expression and liberty of MENA citizens could act as one of the major obstacles in widespread usage of ICTs, especially if the authorities consider it a threat to their control of power.
2.5 Public Private Partnerships (PPP) in MENA Nations for E-government Governments from MENA nations perceive PPP as a solution to offer effective e-governance to citizens. To a certain extent, PPP also bolstered governments’ efforts in overcoming digital divide. From the early stages of e-government adoption Egypt, Morocco, Lebanon, and Jordan have significantly benefited from PPPs which led to prolific ICT investments, when compared to others MENA nations (Saidi & Yared, 2002). Government authorities, senior IT officials, and executives from MENA countries have also explored commercial opportunities to weave IT partnerships with western expertise, harnessing e-government adoption, and building back-office information systems. Priorities of such collaborations lay in rural integration and designing security-based integration technologies. Creating systems that run via dial-up and cell-phones, measuring user demand for new and improved e-government systems, linking national and local levels of e-government operations, introducing public information and education programs that mobilize popular support for e-government systems, and considering government options for privatizing operations of selected e-government systems were also among the priorities (USTDA, 2007). The MENA governments, internet societies, the Union of Arab ICT Associations (a union of 13 Arab nations from the region), regional internet service providers, business organizations, and private sector industries often look forward to collaborating on various e-government initiatives through events like
56
A. Rorissa et al.
the Information and Communication Technology Conference for the Middle East and North Africa (ICT-MENA). Such group meetings often serve as platforms to weave strategic partnerships that benefit and take advantage of the technological momentum gained in MENA countries (E-government Authority, 2009).
2.6 The Role of Comparative Research in MENA Countries’ E-government Adoption In general, due to socio-economic, political, cultural, demographic, and infrastructural differences among various nations, it becomes difficult to compare e-government progress made by governments all over the world. There is extraordinary variation in the degree to which governments across the world have embraced e-government as an innovative mode of running governments (Franda, 2002). Comparative research in the area of e-government usually aims to identify existing problems in terms of contextual differences and their implications for implementation of e-government initiatives. Comparative research studies could further contribute to existing bodies of literature by proposing solutions in different forms, after scrutinizing features of e-government initiatives and revealing the overall picture of a particular context through data gathered in search of answers to a specific problem. Comparative studies typically develop different scales for quantifying intangible features related to e-governance, and statistically analyze the quantified features. Based on their analyses, comparative research studies could also advocate a particular set of solutions to e-government practitioners and bridge gaps in existing body of literature. So far, comparative research studies in the area of e-government have identified and categorized changes brought by e-government initiatives into various modes such as incremental, secular, and transformational (OECD, 2003). E-government comparative studies can introduce a minimum degree of generalizability lacking in many studies for implementing e-government initiatives from different parts of the world (West, 2007b). This helps practitioners to learn from others’ mistakes and experiences while planning, designing, developing, and executing a variety of e-government projects. Some of the conclusions applicable to MENA countries’ e-government adoption efforts are: • E-government progress is directly proportional to the capital flow in any nation (LaPorte, Demchak, & Friis, 2001). • Wealth and political developments matter to the incorporation of technology into political activities (West, 2007b). • Economic wealth measured in terms of Gross Domestic Product, telecommunication policy, and political maturity are the best predictors for Internet penetration and hence for e-governance in any country (Hargittai, 1999).
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
57
• Countries that lack wealth have a difficult time justifying investments in new technologies and infrastructure required for e-governance (Katchanovski & LaPorte, 2005). • Nations where citizens, organizations, and politicians do not realize the potential of technologies often face hurdles implementing e-governance (West, 2007b). • Neither education nor the level of democratization is significantly related to citizens’ participation in e-governance (West, 2007b). • There exists a weak link between democratization and e-governance performance (Hargittai, 1999). Using comparative research and comparative practices, the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) champions the development of common standards for evaluating e-government progress made across MENA countries. It also encourages building a common consensus among MENA nations for applying e-government for better governance. According to the OECD (2007), “a range of evaluation methods and tools for e-government are available to Arab countries; however, most countries have not developed significant strategies to use these methods especially more sophisticated user-engaging tools.” In 2007, at the OECD high-level conference, Arab nations decided to focus on collecting comparable measures of e-government arrangements, such as policy, legislative, regulatory, and institutional frameworks, in order to establish a common unit of analysis for e-governance and increasing benchmark learning among Arab countries (OECD, 2007). When it comes to e-government data collection and availability in the Arab region, the results are mixed. Most Arab nations have difficulty forming organizational units supporting e-government practices (OECD, 2007).
3 Methods 3.1 Sample of E-government Websites Data for this study was collected as a part of a comprehensive research on comparative e-government in Africa and Asia. We gathered data from the contents of 582 African and 939 Asian e-government service Websites which were identified by searching Web information-seeking tools such as search engines and web directories. Using the guidelines of Anzinger (2003), we carried out our search for e-government Websites until we reached saturation. A total of 127 and 103 e-government Websites which were either sponsored or hosted by 12 Middle Eastern countries and six North African nations, respectively, constitute the sample. It should be noted that compiling a comprehensive list of e-government Websites is a very resource-intensive activity. Despite our seamless efforts, we cannot claim to have incorporated every possible relevant Website. Our team conducted the search, review, and coding of the contents of e-government Websites over a period of 6 months—December 2008 to May 2009.
58
A. Rorissa et al.
3.2 Data Analysis We relied on native speakers to translate contents of Websites that were published in Arabic. The Google translation facility (http://translate. google.com/translate_t?hl=en) was helpful in translating e-government Websites in French. Coding the contents of the Websites and analyses of data was conducted during the months of February through May 2009. In order to ensure consistency and reliability of our coding, the authors and two graduate students used the same procedures and coding dictionaries for the content analyses of the e-government Websites. Categories were developed for: types of Website, bodies or institutions responsible for its contents and services, types of services, features, number of executable services available on Websites, and the stage of development of e-government services. We assessed coding reliability between the authors and the two graduate students using percent agreement and Cohen’s (1960) Kappa, two of the most widely used measures for inter-coder agreement. All the computed values for inter-coder reliability were above frequently recommended cut-off of 0.70 (Neuendorf, 2002).
4 Results and Discussion Our data analysis was informed by one of the most comprehensive and longitudinal research studies on comparative e-government where 1,687 e-government Websites from 198 countries were analyzed for their usability in terms of online services and features available to citizens (West, 2007a). In accordance with this global egovernment study, we selected types of Websites, types of services and features, online executable services, stages of development of e-government service, and e-government rankings as variables for analyzing the adoption of e-government by MENA nations. T-tests were conducted to compare the two sub-regions of the MENA nations (Middle East and North Africa) in terms of these variables. The following subsections reveal the dynamic interplay among MENA countries for these variables.
4.1 Types of E-government Websites We believe that institutions responsible for creating and maintaining e-government Websites influence the contents and types of the Websites. Hence, we compared MENA nations based on types of e-government Websites. We categorized all Websites into six categories namely, Federal/National government, Local government, Departmental Websites at Federal/National government level, Departmental Websites at local government level, Embassy, and Others. Websites clustered under “Others” category included the ones owned by political parties, television, radio, and print media.
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
59
Federal or national governments from both the North African (57.28%) and Middle Eastern (77.17%) countries control and maintain their e-government Websites, in contrast with local governments or local government departments from North Africa (0.00%) and Middle East (6.30%). These numbers confirm the top-down approach to e-governance observed in MENA countries, where priority for offering e-government services wanes from top to bottom. This analysis also portrays variations in services (see Fig. 3.1) offered through e-government Websites (Rorissa, Gharawi, & Demissie, 2010).
Fig. 3.1 Distribution of e-government Websites by body/institution responsible for their contents
We conducted t-tests (independent samples, unequal variance) on types of egovernment Websites and the results showed that the two regions do not differ significantly with respect to the mean number of Websites by federal/national governments (t(16) = 0.623, p = 0.542), federal/national government departments (t(16) = 0.376, p = 0.712), and local governments (t(16) = 0.986, p = 0.339). However, they do differ with respect to the mean number of Websites by local government departments (t(16) = 2.159, p = 0.046). Compared with respective continents, North Africa did not differ significantly with Africa except for the number of e-government Websites offered by local governments (t(57) = 2.203, p = 0.032). Administrative bodies from the Middle Eastern nations have comparable percentages of e-government Websites which were controlled and maintained by their counterparts in North Africa. The above mentioned categorization of e-government Websites by body or authority has internal and external impacts on any MENA nation. For example, Websites at federal or national, state, and local levels are designed to offer better governance to citizens living in respective countries. On the other hand, Websites for embassies mainly serve the purpose of offering government services to citizens living in foreign nations, and immigration and travel information to potential tourists. Government Websites serving internal stakeholders often act as another mode of executing power, clarifying roles and positions of governments on various
60
A. Rorissa et al.
issues, and delivering information and government services to its citizens. Our analysis shows that MENA government authorities have not only realized the value of the Internet as a powerful communication medium, but also consistently invested resources into this new model of communication with its citizens. Authoritarian structures of governance that exist in most of the MENA nations lead to the centralization of power. This may explain the high density of federal or national level e-government Websites compared to local level Websites in MENA countries. Typically, government IT investments have six different types of impacts of varying degrees on their stakeholders. They are categorized as: financial, political, social, strategic, ideological, and stewardship (Cresswell, Pardo, Burke, & Dadayan, 2007). Types of services offered by MENA governments on their Websites and their features clearly indicate governments’ interests in disseminating information to the public (see Fig. 3.2). Revenue-related features offered on e-government Websites of MENA countries could contribute current and future levels of national income and overall national asset values. A high concentration of investments on national and federal level Websites could also be interpreted as a desire of authoritarian governments to exercise their control over the entire nation, which they may not be able to do through local level Websites. Federal or national level Websites also have economic and political advantages and opportunities. For example, Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan’s National Resource Authority Website demonstrates government’s technologically progressive approach in managing the natural resources of the country as well as the government’s understanding and commitment to development. Websites at national level could impact stakeholders’ beliefs, their moral and ethical commitments, and the overall social outcomes of government policies (Cresswell et al., 2007). For example, lack of “.gov” domains for launching e-government service Websites and offering these services through “.com” domains, which are often used by commercial sites, may indicate lack of commitment by some governments. With this background of a lack of decentralized power in MENA countries, citizens could potentially enjoy the unique advantage of a high percentage of
Fig. 3.2 Features available on e-government Websites of MENA countries
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
61
national or federal level e-government Websites. They could have direct access to national or federal level government officials with the power to make important decisions. This could also further supplant the process of building informed citizenry in MENA countries. However, this advantage also depends upon the quality of services offered, commitment of government officials, and the political will of the authorities to perceive Websites as means for innovative two-way communications with citizens. National or federal level Websites could also inculcate the spirit of nationalism, especially in nations with populations representing diverse linguistic, cultural, and regional values. Some national- and federal-level Websites from MENA countries (e.g., Ministry of Justice, Kuwait) seek public opinion and feedback on various national issues including the state of justice in MENA countries. Such activities help government officials to project themselves as stewards or guardians of the value of governments.
4.2 Types of Services With the advent of e-government, governments at all levels dispense their public duties and responsibilities with the ultimate goal of providing automated, effective, and efficient services. Another common goal is to achieve balance between number, variety, and quality of services that are made available to targeted groups of citizens. E-government Websites need to accommodate users with varying degrees of skills and needs ranging from searching information on services to filing taxes online. We identified 14 e-government services potentially available online and according to the latest available classification, we clustered those services into three broad categories, namely: • Information: consists of services that are publicly accessible to all citizens on the Internet and meant for information dissemination purposes. • General services: consists of services that go beyond the mere delivery of publicly available information but still available to all citizens. No identification and authentication is required to access these services. • Customer-specific services: these are services that require identification and authentication and are available to authorized users only (Isselhorst, 2002). Data suggest that the Middle East is slightly ahead than North Africa in terms of types of services they offer through their e-government Websites. Approximately, 54% of e-government Websites from North Africa are at the primitive stage of just disseminating information to its citizens, whereas 50% of Websites from the Middle East offer customer-specific functionalities and services—the most advanced set of services that can be offered through Websites. A comparable number of Websites from North Africa (35.06%) and the Middle East (50.0%) provide 10 out of 14 “customer-specific services” (namely, tax filing, voter registration, and applications
62
A. Rorissa et al.
for passports, visas, driver’s licenses, business licenses, grants, benefits, trademarks, and webmail). Three services grouped under “general services” (complaint submission, ordering reports and other documents, and job listing and/or application) are provided by 10.34 and 18.6% of the North African and Middle Eastern e-government Websites, respectively. This is one of the reasons for MENA countries being ranked among the lowest in terms of e-government services, when the contents of e-government Websites are taken into account for benchmarking. Statistical analysis confirms that e-government services provided by Middle Eastern and North African nations have no significant difference, when compared at the primitive stage of information services. However, as the level of e-government services advances, Middle Eastern nations assume a superior position over North African nations.
4.3 Features Available on E-government Websites The level of e-government progress attained by nations is also reflected through a number of online executable services available and a number of features present on Websites. In addition, an e-government Website with a greater number of features is likely to have a higher level of e-government services (West, 2007a). West (2007a, 2007b) compiled 18 different features that are available on a typical e-government Website and grouped them into six broad categories: 1. Online information (publications, databases, audio clips, video clips). 2. Privacy and security (having privacy policies, security policies, allowing digital signatures on transactions). 3. Disability access. 4. Foreign language access. 5. No ads, user fees, and premium fees (not having ads, premium and user fees, and an option to pay via credit cards). 6. Public outreach (email contact information, areas to post comments, option for email updates, option for Website personalization, PDA accessibility). Both North African and Middle Eastern countries have more e-government Websites with no premium fees, no user fees, and no ads (Fig. 3.2). These features account for 47.72% and 53.29% of the total number of features available on North African and Middle Eastern e-government Websites, respectively, followed by public outreach (North Africa: 21.01% and Middle East: 16.22%), and online information (North Africa: 17.1% and Middle East: 18.04%) features. The least available features were privacy and security (North Africa: 0.33% and Middle East: 1.82%), and disability access (North Africa: 0.00% and Middle East: 0.28%). With the growing number of tele-center initiatives stimulated by private-sector investments in MENA countries, nations from the region could take advantage of multimedia technologies for involving illiterate, low-skilled citizens in e-governance. Independent
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
63
t-tests revealed that the average numbers of features of North African and Middle Eastern e-government Websites did not differ significantly. This echoes our results for types of Websites and types of services.
4.4 Online Executable Services An e-government service Website with a higher number of features and dynamic features such as online executable services is likely to be at a higher level of e-government service development than a Website with only static information (Affisco & Soliman, 2006; Al-adawi, Yousafzai, & Pallister, 2005). Citizens enjoying advanced e-government service Websites with more online executable services might take fewer, if any, trips to government offices. Moreover, such advanced Websites save time and resources for service providers (e.g., governments at all levels) as well as end-users (e.g., citizens). All MENA nations offer online executable services on their e-government Websites (North Africa: 16.83% and Middle East: 19.58%). It is evident that not much difference exists in the average number of online executable services on e-government Websites from MENA countries, which is also confirmed by t-test results (t(16) = 0.284, p = 0.78).
4.5 Stages of Development of E-government Services Generally, there are four levels or stages of development of e-government services: (1) publishing (web-presence), (2) interacting, (3) transacting, and (4) transforming (integration) (Affisco & Soliman, 2006; Al-adawi et al., 2005). Commonly, a Website at the publishing level presents static information about the government agency; one at the interacting level allows the downloading of forms and provides search functions; a Website at the transacting level allows the completion of an entire task online; and one at the transforming level is often a single-point portal and integrates all e-government services by a number of branches of government at all levels. Financial resources, political leadership, and organizational capacity are some of the factors that significantly shape ICT adoption by nations. More specifically, countries with more financial resources could justify investments in new technologies; hence the larger number of Middle Eastern e-government Websites at higher levels of development (West, 2007b). Interactive e-government Websites in the Middle East are almost 60% more than that of North Africa. This could be due to the disparity in the level of economic development of individual MENA countries. For nations from the Middle East and North Africa, almost 90% of e-government Websites were either at the first stage (e.g., publishing or web-presence) or at the second stage (e.g., interacting) of e-government development (Fig. 3.3). Approximately, two thirds of e-government Websites from North Africa represent the first stage of e-government progress, whereas for the same stage of development there were only half of the Middle Eastern e-government Websites.
64
A. Rorissa et al.
Fig. 3.3 Percentage of e-government Websites categorized into the four levels of e-government development
MENA countries did not significantly differ in terms of the average number of e-government Websites at the four levels of e-government development (1. Publishing: t(16) = 1.754, p = 0.099; 2. Interacting: t(16) = 0.103, p = 0.919; 3. Transacting: t(16) = 1.658, p = 0.117; 4. Transforming/Integrating: t(16) = 0.000, p = 1.000). The results suggest an equal emphasis on both basic government services and advanced types of e-government Websites by MENA countries. The correlation between socio-economic status and the type of e-government Websites as well as their level of development of e-government services remains topics for future research.
4.6 E-government Indices for MENA Nations In order to compare the two regions with respect to their e-government rankings, we computed e-government indices using a framework proposed by West (2007a). This objective framework is entirely derived from the contents of Websites; it is also one of the most widely applied frameworks in e-government research. We first computed an e-government index for each Website and then averaged them across all Websites to compute a single index for each country whose value is a number between 0 and 100. For all 18 features, a Website is assigned four points, for a maximum of 72 (4×18), and this total is then added to the total number of online executable services, producing an index for the Website. To compute an e-government index for the country, we averaged all indices for all of its Websites. We then averaged indices for all MENA countries, calculating a single index for all countries (see Table 3.2). T-test results revealed that the two regions did not differ significantly with respect to their average e-government indices (t (16) = 0.752, p = 0.463). This can be construed as the equal pace acquired by MENA countries in adopting ICTs for governance.
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
65
Table 3.2 E-government index values for MENA countries Sub-continents
Min.
Max.
M
SD
North Africa Middle East
18.80 18.61
29.00 34.73
25.78 24.33
3.61 4.25
5 Conclusions and Recommendations Unlike e-government comparative research in the past, our study compares countries with similar contextual features—culture, religion, government structure, and language—in MENA. There has been a fair amount of comparative research done on Websites as a medium for comparing various aspects and features of e-governance, such as transparency brought by e-governance, openness in governments due to ICTs, degree of accountability created in governments due to e-governance, and governments’ abilities to interact with citizens using e-governance (Wong & Welch, 2009). However, our research relies on contents of e-government Websites, where some Websites represent an excellent blend of contextual features (such as social and religious) with modern ways of offering governance using ICTs. For instance, Website of Ministry of Pilgrimage hosted by Saudi Arabia, Website for the Ministry of Islamic Awqaf Trust Affairs by Jordan, Website for the Ministry of Habousm, Ministy of Diwan of Royal Court by Oman, and Islamic Affairs by Morocco, provide services unparalleled to that offered by government in the West. The following subsections comprise of our reflections on the overall significance of comparative e-government research, recommendations for Website design efforts under e-government initiatives, and brief concluding remarks.
5.1 Recommendations and Concluding Remarks Our context-specific recommendations for design, development, and execution of e-government projects in MENA countries are grounded in our data and statistical analyses. Our recommendations focus on the design, quality, and development issues related to offering e-government services via Websites. Some of the key takehome messages discussed in this subsection can be clustered under the following themes:
1. Recommendations on the design, development, and implementation of Websites for offering government services to citizens. 2. Public–private partnership: A catalyst for ICT adoption in MENA countries. 3. Incorporation of mobile technologies for the comprehensive analysis of e-governance initiatives.
66
A. Rorissa et al.
Our findings show that almost no attention was paid to offering government services to people with disabilities in MENA countries. This could reinforce the digital divide in the region. The quality of content presented on Websites is crucial in building users’ confidence. Spelling mistakes and other grammatical errors on the Websites could hinder the process of citizen participation. Misspelled English words is a pervasive phenomenon observed on MENA nations’ official Websites. This could raise doubts among English-speaking citizens as well as Englishspeaking tourists about the government’s commitment to offering e-government services. Unless privacy and security aspects of Websites are taken seriously, out of fear of breach of confidentiality, citizens may not be willing and comfortable in sharing their private information over Websites. For example, less than 1% of features on e-government Websites in MENA countries address security and privacy issues. To guarantee the use of customer-specific services by citizens, facets of Websites such as data-sharing, data security, authentication, and citizen privacy need to be addressed with great care. On public outreach Websites with contact emails, there needs to be officials accountable for responding to citizens’ questions and/or requests. If citizens do not get responses to their queries directed to email addresses published on Websites, citizens may not build trust in this communication channel with government officials. Some e-government Websites have either large-sized digital images or long-running slide shows, or animated welcome messages on their landing pages. Citizens accessing e-government Websites using their limited bandwidth or slow Internet connections could end up having unpleasant experiences with such unaccommodating government Websites. Uniform templates for all departments’ Websites could also ease users’ navigation experience. For example, none of Algeria’s egovernment Websites have a uniform template. Government Websites offering information content such as forms, reports, etc., in different formats (e.g., Word, PDF, Excel) need to make sure that citizens can also download appropriate software to view those files. It is also important to have dedicated resources for maintaining government Websites. Government Websites that are not seamless (in terms of their availability) may not convince citizens to rely on governments’ efforts to offer e-governance. Finally, well-organized information content with a minimum number of clicks often facilitates users’ surfing experience. For example, the Egyptian government’s sales tax department Website creates a good initial impression on users. The presentation of information content with minimal spelling mistakes makes it easy for citizens to pay taxes. Our literature review suggests that public–private partnerships between IT partners from western countries and the MENA nations are on the rise. This could have the potential danger of MENA countries adopting e-government without the proper assessment of local contexts and conditions. Public–private partnerships should be aware of the inherent differences in public and private sectors. A system that works in the private sector might not work in the public sector (Heeks, 2002). One of the limitations of our study is that it is a snapshot of contents of Websites during a 6-month period and not a longitudinal research study. In order to
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
67
have a complete picture of e-government service development in MENA countries, a longitudinal study is recommended. Another limitation of our comparative study which is mainly based on contents of e-government Websites is that Websites are not the only technologies to deliver e-governance. Citizens from many developing nations around the world enjoy a wider access to mobile technology which is leapfrogging other ICTs as a means of communication. For example, people now can explore socio-economic opportunities with the help of mobile technologies. Furthermore, mobile technologies are inexpensive compared to computers and are easily available and ubiquitous. This makes them even more appropriate for delivering e-government services. We are fully aware that in many nations around the world, mobile technologies (and other nomadic devices such as PDAs) facilitate access to e-government services for majority of citizens who have low literacy levels. For a comprehensive comparison of e-government initiatives, future research on comparative e-government needs to consider alternative means of implementing e-governance. Acknowledgements We would like to thank Mohammed Gharawi, Tarkey Alhozaimy, and three anonymous reviewers for their help and invaluable comments.
References Affisco, J., & Soliman, K. (2006). E-government: A strategic operations management framework for service delivery. Business Process Management Journal, 12, 13–21. Al-adawi, Z., Yousafzai, S., & Pallister, J. (2005). Conceptual model of citizen adoption of e-government. The Second International Conference on Innovations in Information Technology. Retrieved August 23, 2008, from http://www.itinnovations.ae/iit005/proceedings/articles/G_6_IIT05-Al-Adawi.pdf Anzinger, G. (2003). African governments on the www. Retrieved March 25, 2008, from http://www.gksoft.com/govt/en/africa.html Bovaird, T., & Loffler, E. (2009). Public management and governance (2nd ed.). New York: Taylor and Francis. Burkhart, G., & Older, S. (2003). The information revolution in Middle East and North Africa. Prepared for National Intelligence Council by RAND’s National Defense Research Institute. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from http://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1653/MR1653.pdf Cohen, J. (1960). A coefficient of agreement for nominal scales. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 20, 37–46. Cresswell, A. M., Pardo, T., Burke, G. B., & Dadayan, L. (2007). Advancing return on investment analysis for government information technology. In Proceedings of the 8th Annual International Conference on Digital Government Research: Bridging Disciplines & Domains; Philadelphia, PA, May 20–23, 2007. dg.o, vol. 228. Digital Government Society of North America, 244–245. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from http://www.dgsociety.org/documents/p244Cresswell_000.pdf De Alcántara, C. H. (2002). The development divides in a digital age. United Nations Research Institute for Social Development. Retrieved September 25, 2009, from http://www.unrisd.org/unrisd/Website/document.nsf/%28httpPublications%29/19B0B342A4F 1CF5B80256B5E0036D99F?OpenDocument E-Government Authority. (2009). e-Government Authority signs strategic partnership agreement for MENA ICT 2009 Conference, Kingdom of Bahrain. Retrieved August 24, 2009, from http://www.ega.gov.bh/downloads/news/170809E.pdf
68
A. Rorissa et al.
EuroMonitor. (2009). Regional focus: Growing internet usage in the Middle East and North Africa. Retrieved September 29, 2009, from http://www.euromonitor. com/Regional_Focus_Growing_Internet_usage_in_the_Middle_East_and_North_Africa Facebook. (2009). e-Government – Kingdom of Bahrain. Retrieved August 24, 2009, from http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=11662676851 Foulger, D. (2001). The cliff and the continuum: Defining the digital divide. Retrieved August 24, 2009, from http://pages.prodigy.net/davis_foulger/articles/cliffAndContinuum.htm Franda, M. (2002). Launching into cyberspace: Internet development and politics in five world regions. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner. Gil-Garcia, R., & Pardo, T. (2005). e-Government success factors: Mapping practical tools to theoretical foundations. Government Information Quarterly, 22(2), 187–216. Hargittai, E. (1999). Weaving the Western Web: Explaining differences in internet connectivity among OECD countries. Telecommunications Policy, 23(10/11), 701–718. Heeks, R. (2002). E-government in Africa: Promise and practice. Information Polity: The International Journal of Government & Democracy in the Information Age, 7(2/3), 97–114. Hu, Y., Xiao, J., Pang, J., & Xie, K. (2005). A research on the appraisal framework of e-government project success. In Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Electronic Commerce (Xi’an, China, August 15–17, 2005). ICEC 05, vol. 113. ACM, New York, NY, 532–538. DOI= http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/1089551.1089647 Internet World Stats. (2009). Internet usage in the Middle East. Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats5.htm Isselhorst, H. (2002). E-government manual: Classification scheme for e-government procedures. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from https://www.bsi.bund.de/cae/servlet/ contentblob/487830/publicationFile/29241/2_Klass_en_pdf.pdf Katchanovski, I., & LaPorte, T. (2005). Cyberdemocracy or Potemkin e-villages? Electronic governments in OECD and post-communist countries. International Journal of Public Administration, 28(7–8), 665–682. LaMotte, G. (2002). Digital divide in Arab world “staggering”. VOA News (Cairo), 27 June. LaPorte, T. M., Demchak, C. C., & Friis, C. (2001). Webbing governance: Global trends across national-level public agencies. Communications of the ACM, 44(1), 63–67. Moon, M., & Welch, E. (2005). Same bed, different dreams? A comparative analysis of citizens and bureaucrats e-government perspectives. Review of Public Personnel Administration, 25(3), 243–264. Neuendorf, K. A. (2002). The content analysis guidebook. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. OECD. (2003). OECD e-government studies: The e-government imperative. Paris, France: Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development. OECD. (2007). Good governance for development (GfD) in Arab countries initiative: Third steering group meeting at ministerial level. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.arabgov-initiative.org/publications/GfDII/corruption/Cairo/report-en.pdf OECD. (2008a). Fourth regional meeting of the good governance for development (GfD) working group on e-Government and administrative simplification. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.oecd.org/document/20/0,3343,en_34645207_34645466_41073876_1_1_1_1,00. html OECD. (2008b). High level capacity building seminar on “Administrative Simplification: Overcoming Barriers to Implementation”. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www. oecd.org/document/8/0,3343,en_34645207_34744758_41122120_1_1_1_1,00.html Resnick, M. (2002). Rethinking learning in the digital age. In G. Kirkman (Ed.), The global information technology report: Readiness for the networked world (pp. 32–37). New York: Oxford University Press. Robins, P. (2009). The Middle East: A beginner s guide. New York: One world Publications. Rorissa, A., Gharawi, M., & Demissie, D. (2010). A tale of two continents: Contents of African and Asian e-government Websites. In Proceedings of the 43rd Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS 2010), January 5–8, 2010, Koloa, Kauai, Hawaii.
3
Comparative Study of Contents of E-government Service Websites
69
Saidi, N., & Yared, H. (2002). e-Government: Technology for good governance, development and democracy in the MENA countries. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.erf.org.eg/cms.php?id=publication_details&publication_id=322 Slate Group. (2008). The failed states index 2008. Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http://www.foreignpolicy.com/story/cms.php?story_id=4350 UNDP. (2002). Arab human development report 2002: Creating opportunities for future generations. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.nakbaonline. org/download/UNDP/EnglishVersion/Ar-Human-Dev-2002.pdf United Nations. (2008). United Nations e-Government survey 2008: From e-government to connected governance. Retrieved September 18, 2009, from http://unpan1. un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/UN/UNPAN028607.pdf United Nations. (2009). United Nations e-Government readiness knowledge base. Retrieved September 16, 2009, from http://www2.unpan.org/egovkb USTDA (2007). Opportunities for US companies in the e-Government (IT) sector in Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon and Morocco. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.uschamber.com/NR/rdonlyres/e7mhbolv3uyozpcjanxbiv6ll4z656cou3tm77jnylg6 w2opweslvweoxpmm6di4srrko36p5j3vffb35weiobpc4qg/20071029USTDAEventFlyer.pdf West, D. M. (2007a). Global e-Government. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from http://www.insidepolitics.org/egovt07int.pdf West, D. M. (2007b). Digital government: Technology and public sector performance. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. Wong, W., & Welch, E. (2009). Does e-Government promote accountability? A comparative analysis of Website openness and government accountability. Governance, 17(2), 275–297. World Bank. (2003). e-Government: Technology for good governance, development, and democracy in the MENA Countries: Management tool kit by World Bank. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from http://whitepapers.zdnet.co.uk/0,1000000651,260116005p,00.htm
Chapter 4
Towards E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe Girish J. “Jeff” Gulati, David J. Yates, and Anas Tawileh
E-governance is important for enabling governments to communicate with and serve their citizens. In this chapter, we determine critical success factors for and obstacles to effective e-governance in two very different regions of the world, namely, the Middle East and Northern Europe. Specifically, we explore eparticipation in Bahrain, Egypt, Estonia, and Finland. These four countries are interesting cases because they have quite different types of government, yet, according to recent United Nations data, each has succeeded in their development of e-government capabilities. However, the degree to which this development has translated into effective e-participation varies significantly between these countries. We propose a framework for assessing the strategy, policies, and context within which e-governance is being developed and apply this framework to examine e-participation in each country. Using this framework, we show that an administrative culture of high-quality governance is critical to the success of e-participation initiatives. Our research also suggests that factors which promote online citizen participation in the political process include a government commitment to egovernment, policies that encourage e-participation, and investment in e-governance and information and communication technology (ICT) development. Sometimes these conditions are satisfied but e-participation falls short of expectations. We present evidence that this short-fall often reflects problems in the offline relationship between governments and their citizens.
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati (B) Bentley University, Waltham, MA 02452, USA e-mail:
[email protected] D.J. Yates Bentley University, Waltham, MA 02452, USA e-mail:
[email protected] A. Tawileh Cardiff University, Cardiff, Wales F24 3AA, UK e-mail:
[email protected]
C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_4, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
71
72
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
1 Introduction E-government refers to the use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) to improve efficiency and communication within government, enhance communication between the public and the private sectors, and facilitate the availability and delivery of services from government to the public (Garson, 2006; Jaeger, 2003; West, 2005). E-government applications also have the potential to make government more transparent and accountable to its citizens and allow citizens more opportunities to participate in the political process. Applications that broaden and deepen political participation are not simply top-down government initiatives to engage with citizens, but rather a way to include all stakeholders in participatory decision-making. By enhancing government’s ability to request, receive, and incorporate feedback from constituents, policies can be better tailored to meet the needs and priorities of citizens (Curtin, 2006; Macintosh, 2006; United Nations, 2008). Moreover, e-participation offers hope for revitalizing community and promoting social change by facilitating communication and the discussion of policy and politics with neighbors from other communities, near or far, at greater length, and in an ongoing format (Dutton & Peltu, 1996; Heeks & Bailur, 2007; Schech, 2002; Servon, 2002). The United Nations’ 2008 assessment of the extent to which governments have developed e-government revealed that more countries were online in 2008 than in 2005 and that most countries had extensive information on policies and laws available through their national government’s online portals. Their assessment of the extent to which these same governments have proactively solicited citizen input was not as impressive. While many countries showed dramatic increases in implementing products and services related to e-participation, and more specifically e-information, since 2004, 82% of countries received relatively low assessments of their performance in developing tools for e-consultation and e-decision-making. This study seeks to explain what factors determine a country’s success in implementing e-participation initiatives and identify those obstacles preventing successful implementation. These factors are examined within a theoretical framework based on the work of King et al. (1994), which highlights the significance of developing government strategies and policies that enable and advance information technology innovations such as e-government, e-participation, and e-governance more broadly. We show that Egypt, Bahrain, Estonia, and Finland have taken different approaches to incorporating citizen input and feedback and have succeeded in different aspects of e-participation. Moreover, the critical success factors and obstacles to success vary country-to-country, partly reflecting their government structure, governance methods and practices, and also their distinct histories and cultures.
2 Background Our research seeks to understand the impact that government strategy and policy have on e-government and e-participation. By treating e-government and e-participation as information technology innovations, King et al. (1994) highlight
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
73
Regulation
Influence
the importance of developing government strategies and policies that enable and advance such innovations. To apply the institutional theory of King et al., we must distinguish between what a government can regulate versus what a government can influence in order to promote online governance. For example, a government can regulate to what extent it is democratic versus autocratic by choosing whether or not to promote democratic reforms. There is conflicting evidence about the impact that democracy has on e-government and e-participation. West (2005) suggests that there is little connection between a country’s e-government performance and its level of democratization. Prior case studies of European countries, e.g. (Macintosh, 2008), however, suggest that there is a link between democratic reforms and e-participation. We are not aware of similar case studies in non-democratic nations. To provide another example, a government can influence but not, in general, regulate to what degree information and communication technologies (ICTs) are accessed and used by its citizens. Greater diffusion of ICTs within a nation has the potential to increase adoption of online governance. However, we speculate that successful implementation of e-participation requires a citizenry that has a general trust in government and faith that government can be effective. We explore a small number of cases as our research methodology since e-participation is a complex issue that depends on many factors, and is related to many others. We chose our four countries—Egypt, Bahrain, Estonia, and Finland— because of their diverse government structure and also the differences in their national e-participation performance, as measured by the United Nations (2008). In terms of their governance, Bahrain is ruled by a constitutional monarchy whereas Finland’s government is a representative democracy (CIA, 2009). Egypt and Estonia lie somewhere between these two extremes (CSP, 2009). The 2007/2008 e-Participation Index rankings for these countries vary between 49th in the world (for Egypt) and 8th in the world (for Estonia). Even though Egypt’s e-participation score is not very high, Egypt has made significant progress in developing egovernment capabilities in recent years (Glück, Mitwalli, & Stemmler, 2008). Figure 4.1 shows eight factors that government strategy and policy can either influence or regulate in order to advance online governance. The four factors that governments can regulate appear in the lower portion of Fig. 4.1. These factors include, for example, the degree to which a national government is democratic
Voice & Accountability E-participation
E-government ICT Development Democracy
Regulatory Quality
Control of Corruption Government Effectiveness
Fig. 4.1 Institutional factors affecting online governance
74
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
which we determine using the Center for Systemic Peace’s Polity 2 score (CSP, 2009). The four factors that a government can influence appear in the upper righthand box in Fig. 4.1. These include the level of ICT development in a country which we measure using the International Telecommunication Union’s ICT Development Index (ITU, 2009). E-government and e-participation, both of which are central to our case studies, are considered factors that a government can influence more so than regulate, and thus also appear in the upper portion of this figure. The remaining four factors are measures of the overall quality of governance taken from the most recent measurements of the World Governance Indicators (Kaufmann, Kraay, & Mastruzzi et al., 2009). One of these remaining factors—voice and accountability—is a prerequisite for effective e-governance (and in particular, e-participation) that is considered something governments can influence but not regulate. Three of these factors— control of corruption, government effectiveness, and regulatory authority—are governed by necessary regulation. Figure 4.1 presents the institutional factors that will help us understand why and how e-governance is being implemented within the countries in our study. However, the institutional context summarized in this figure is part of a much broader context attributable to many other factors. Many of these factors are complex and multidimensional in their own right and therefore are discussed on a case-by-case basis. For example, we touch on the distinct history and culture of Egypt, Bahrain, Estonia, and Finland, but return to the impact of the specific factors we have described thus far. We also summarize demographic and geographic factors that might enable or inhibit the success of e-governance initiatives in these countries (Curtin, 2006). For example, based on 2005 gross national income data from the World Bank (2009), the average citizen in Finland is more than seven times wealthier than the average citizen in Egypt. It is therefore unreasonable to expect that similar e-governance initiatives in these two countries would yield the same results. Table 4.1 summarizes the present-day context for the case studies we describe below. By analyzing the first four rows of data in Table 4.1, it is easy to understand the challenges that Egypt faces in developing e-government and promoting eparticipation. First, Egypt needs to promote access and use of ICTs for a population that is an order of magnitude larger than any of our other countries. Furthermore, in comparing Egypt to Finland, Egypt’s gross national income and Internet adoption is less than 20% of the same metrics for Finland. A comparison between Egypt and Bahrain highlights other factors that put Egypt at a disadvantage relative to her regional neighbor. Specifically, the population density of Egypt is an order of magnitude less than the population density of Bahrain, making the deployment and repair of ICT infrastructure more expensive. Also, in spite of a recent surge in Internet adoption within Egypt, only 14% of its population regularly use the Internet whereas 33% of Bahrain’s population has access to the Internet (ITU, 2009). The remaining eight rows of data in Table 4.1 summarize quantitative measures of the factors described in Fig. 4.1. The first two rows show the most recent United Nations assessment of e-participation and e-government readiness of the national governments in the four countries. The E-government Readiness Index
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
75
Table 4.1 Data for factors affecting e-governance (and their source) Variable Demographics and geography Population (CIA, 2009) Population density [persons per sq km (CIA, 2009)] Annual gross national income [PPP per capita in 2005 in US$ (World Bank, 2009)] Internet users per 100 [in 2007 (ITU, 2009)] Factors influenced E-participation Index (United Nations, 2008) E-government Readiness Index (United Nations, 2008) Voice and accountability (Kaufmann et al., 2009) ICT development index (ITU, 2009) Factors regulated Democracy [Polity 2 (CSP, 2009)] Control of corruption (Kaufmann et al., 2009) Government effectiveness (Kaufmann et al., 2009) Regulatory quality (Kaufmann et al., 2009)
Egypt
Bahrain
Estonia
Finland
83,000,000 82.9
728,000 982.5
1,300,000 28.7
5,250,000 15.5
$4,310
$27,100
$15,870
$30,810
14
33
64
79
0.250
0.341
0.727
0.273
0.477
0.572
0.760
0.749
–1.19
–0.82
1.03
1.48
2.54
4.69
6.79
5.97
9
10
–3
–7
–0.67
0.44
0.94
2.34
–0.37
0.47
1.15
1.95
–0.17
0.88
1.47
1.58
is a composite index comprising the web measure index, the telecommunication infrastructure index, and the human capital index (United Nations, 2008). The e-Participation Index is a composite index that assesses national government online presence in three dimensions: e-information, e-consultation, and e-decision-making. Helped by smaller populations to manage, the e-government and e-participation scores for Bahrain and Estonia are indicative of important milestones in digital government that belong to these two countries. In 2001, Bahrain was one of the first countries in the world to administer a national referendum online (Kostopoulos, 2004). Estonia was the first country in the world to hold local and parliamentary elections in which citizens had the option to vote online (in 2005 and 2007, respectively). The fact that about 1% of the votes in these elections were cast via the Internet suggests that online voting is an emerging area, to say the least. The last
76
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
six rows of data in Table 4.1 are taken directly from the sources shown (CSP, 2009; ITU, 2009; Kaufmann et al., 2009). We refer the reader to these sources for details about the methodology and also the individual entries in this table. Figure 4.2 graphs data values for the institutional factors affecting online governance in Egypt, Bahrain, Estonia and Finland. The values for each factor are taken from Table 4.1 and are then scaled to a range of [–1, 1] via linear interpolation of the source data as follows. For the Worldwide Governance Indicators from Kaufmann et al. (2009), which are z-scores with a zero mean, the minimum value of –1 in Fig. 4.2 corresponds to values 2.5 standard deviations less than the mean and the maximum value of 1 corresponds to 2.5 standard deviations greater than the mean. Polity 2 scores, as measured by the Center for Systemic Peace (CSP, 2009), have a range of [–10, 10]. Thus, the democracy value for each country in Fig. 4.2 is determined by dividing the Polity 2 score by 10. For the e-Participation Index and the E-government Readiness Index (United Nations, 2008), which both lie between 0.0 and 1.0, a score of 0.0 is mapped to –1 and a score of 1.0 to 1. Finally, the ICT Development Index (IDI) as measured by the ITU (2009), which has a range of [0, 10], is scaled such that –1 corresponds to an IDI value of 0.0 and 1 corresponds to an IDI value of 10.0.
Fig. 4.2 Radar plot of scaled values for institutional factors affecting online governance
Figure 4.2 is a helpful tool for visualizing the institutional context within which online governance is being developed and deployed in the countries we study. This figure also illustrates some of the significant differences between the four countries. Navigating Fig. 4.2 with an imaginary compass, the axis pointing south highlights the differences between the level of democracy in the countries. The axis pointing north shows that Estonia is the only country that achieves an e-Participation Index score that is a greater than the mid-point of this scale (i.e., has a value greater than zero on this axis). This is somewhat surprising since three of the four countries have national E-government Readiness Index scores above the mid-point of its range. (Egypt’s E-government Readiness Index score of 0.477 is the only value that is less
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
77
than 0.5.) It is not difficult to imagine how other institutional factors presented in this figure might be critical in determining the success of online governance initiatives in these countries. Looking west in Fig. 4.2, the “gap” between government effectiveness in Finland and in Egypt is quite wide. Last but not least, Finland’s leadership in some other dimensions gives it an inherent advantage over the other three countries. Finland is one of the best countries in the world at controlling corruption and, according to Kaufmann et al. (2009), scores in the top 3% of nations when considering government voice and accountability. The remainder of this chapter focuses on understanding how the factors in Table 4.1 and Fig. 4.2 impact e-government and e-participation innovations in our case studies. We will see that Egypt’s advances in e-participation (and e-government more generally) have been driven by a “back-to-basics” approach that has centered around two goals: Developing infrastructure to provide access to information and communication technologies, and bridging the digital divide within Egypt to promote the use of and participation in online government (Helbig, Gil-García, & Ferro et al., 2009). Bahrain’s successes in online governance have been driven by a thoughtful national agenda. Specifically, the King and Prime Minister of Bahrain have provided management, resources, and support to a central body that runs government computer and communications systems and regulates ICTs within the government (Al-Amer, 2003), namely, the Central Informatics Organization (CIO). Like Bahrain, Estonia has a bold agenda for e-government (Ernsdorff & Berbec, 2007). It is a young democracy in which the national government has achieved some remarkable successes in e-participation with fewer resources than many of its European Union counterparts (Keefer, 2007; Nixon & Koutrakou, 2007). Political will and energy have contributed to these successes; however, e-participation in Estonia has also been propelled by the trust and faith that its citizens have in their young government relative to their counterparts in Egypt, Bahrain, and Finland. Finland is a more established democracy than Estonia and also has a history of governance by a more bureaucratic national government. Recently, Finland’s national government has undergone many reforms as part of decentralizing government to better address regional and local interests (Pollitt & Bouckaert, 2004). As a result, e-participation accomplishments in Finland have been more prevalent at the local level rather than the national level and have leveraged the Finnish tradition of technological innovation (Hargittai, 1999; World Bank, 2006). The next four sections describe cases that highlight and explain successes and challenges in implementing online governance, country by country.
3 E-participation in Egypt The Middle East has recorded the highest growth rate in Internet use over the past six years (ITU, 2009). This growth is a positive indicator of the increased adoption of ICTs in the region, and of the awareness of the value afforded by utilizing these technologies. Egypt, with more than 80 million people, is the most populous country
78
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
in the region. The country faces significant development challenges, such as closing the gender gap in employment, literacy, and political participation, and providing equitable access to government services and programs (El-Saharty, Richardson, & Chase, 2005). Egypt has a rather low score on the E-government Readiness Index (0.477) and the e-Participation Index (0.250). These index scores rank Egypt 49th in e-participation, and 79th in e-government readiness (United Nations, 2008). Corruption is also a significant issue in this country, as suggested by the significantly lower score on control of corruption than the other three countries (Kaufmann et al., 2009). Controlling corruption is essential to achieving meaningful success in e-participation, because corruption undermines trust between citizens and their governments, and thus reduces the probability of higher uptake of e-governance by the public. Egypt invested heavily over the past decade to improve its ICT infrastructure and to provide affordable access to ICT services. It also launched major initiatives to adopt e-government as a means to leverage ICTs in its development efforts. These initiatives, however, have focused more on basic services—i.e., e-information services—than on e-consultation or e-decision-making. Egypt is also considered a regional leader in providing public information through portals and official sites (Dutta, Shalhoub, & Samuels, 2007). The government has built an integrated portal to act as a one-stop shop for government information (Egypt E-government Portal, 2009). A major e-government plan is also underway to build a media city and several smart villages to offer training and software development services and to link ministries via a centralized network. Cutting costs and fighting corruption are cited as major drivers behind Egypt’s e-government efforts. According to the Egyptian Minister of Administrative Development, Ahmed Darwish, e-government initiatives save 600 million Egyptian pounds per year, and contribute to the elimination of corruption and bureaucracy (Abdoun, 2009). Due to limited availability of utilization data, the impact of the Egyptian e-government initiatives cannot be measured effectively. However, available evidence suggests that the uptake of online services by the population is still very limited. In a recent survey conducted by the Egyptian Cabinet’s Information and Decision Support Center (IDSC), only 38% of the Egyptians were aware of the e-government services (Abdoun, 2009). There is also significant variation in the adoption of different types of government services offered electronically. Information services, for example, are much more frequently accessed and utilized than interactive services (the IDSC survey cites inquiring about phone bills and getting high school exam results). Services that require citizen interaction command higher levels of trust and more dependable infrastructure. The most frequent complaint made by citizens is that e-government Websites take long time to load (Abdoun, 2009). Furthermore, some electronic services rely on cultural norms and habits that may not yet be prevalent in Egypt. Online payment, for example, only works in countries that have a widespread credit and debit card use. This is certainly not the case in present-day Egypt (El-Askalany, Rashad, & Darwish, 2003).
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
79
Interestingly, while increasing community participation in the governance processes in the county was clearly identified as an objective of Egypt’s e-government strategy, the e-Participation Index suggests that the government efforts yielded limited success. Several challenges have been identified as the cause of this problem (El-Askalany et al., 2003). These include the perception of low-quality government service delivery, overlapping authority among government bodies, and reluctance to share information among government agencies. These challenges indicate that successful e-governance efforts depend on previous participation by citizens in offline government activities and also on the government’s ability to improve its effectiveness. Perhaps the most entrenched obstacles to the uptake of e-government services in Egypt are high illiteracy as well as low PC and Internet penetration. The adult illiteracy rate in Egypt in 2006 was close to 30% (IRCT, 2006). This poses a major challenge to service delivery that depends on the user’s ability to read and interact with online content. This problem is complicated further by the low penetration of PCs and Internet connectivity in the country. In 2007, PCs were present in 16% of households, while about 14% of the population had Internet access (ITU, 2009). Addressing these issues requires significant investments in education and infrastructure, and the Egyptian government has embarked on several programs in these areas. Another barrier to e-participation in Egypt is the offline relationship between the government and its citizens, and the perceptions of this relationship by the public. Several authors have identified trust between the citizens and their government as an important factor in the success of e-government programs (Hachigian & Kaplan, 2002; Warkentin, Gefen, Pavlou, & Rose, 2002). This relationship in Egypt is far from ideal, and specific interventions are needed to increase transparency and accountability in governance in order to boost citizen trust in government before e-government and e-participation can achieve their full potential. Analyzing the Egyptian experience in developing and implementing e-government offers some interesting insights. Clearly, the country faces significant challenges that need to be addressed on several fronts. Investing in ICT development and providing affordable and reliable access should create an environment conducive to e-participation. This has been an important focus of the Egyptian government in recent years, evident in the country’s recent E-government Readiness Index scores. It should be noted that bridging the digital divide in Egypt is a substantial challenge partly due the country’s demographics, geography, low GDP, and high illiteracy. Thus, the government’s achievements in this regard are admirable. However, the country still has the potential to boost e-participation by controlling factors that its government can regulate. Specifically, the government should improve its control of corruption, promote democracy, and increase its effectiveness. Improvement on any of these fronts, along with continued expansion of ICT access and use, will likely result in more successful e-government initiatives and higher levels of e-participation.
80
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
4 E-participation in Bahrain Bahrain is a small country in the Arabian Gulf that is home to less than 800,000 people. The country is one of the richest in the region in terms of its per capita gross domestic product (GDP), with an average of US $37,300 (CIA, 2009). Bahrain also enjoys a highly developed infrastructure, and ICT infrastructure is no exception. PC penetration in households exceeds 50%, and more than one third of the population has access to the Internet (ITU, 2009). In terms of market liberalization, Bahrain is one of the most advanced in the region, ranking 13th globally on the Index of Economic Freedom (O’Driscoll, Holmes, & Kirkpatrick, 2009). Bahrain has invested heavily to develop its ICT infrastructure and capabilities. In 2004, the country devoted a remarkable 6% of its GDP to ICT spending (ESCWA, 2005). Similar investments over time are one reason that Bahrain ranks 42nd on the United Nations E-government Readiness Index. Bahrain has a score of 0.341 on the e-Participation Index, which is higher than both Egypt and Finland. The government in Bahrain is a constitutional monarchy, which explains its low score on the Polity 2 index (CSP, 2009). The government, however, is reasonably effective according to Kaufmann et al. (2009). Leveraging its investments in ICT development to provide higher quality of life to its citizens, Bahrain embarked on a comprehensive e-government program, with a mission to utilize “information technologies and new business processes to transform how government delivers services to its citizens & businesses” (Al-Amer, 2003). As part of this program, 30 ministries and government departments have been interconnected to streamline operations and facilitate service delivery processes (Charif & Ramadan, 2003). A pilot project for e-voting was also introduced in 2001 (Motorola, 2001). The system was used by more than 200,000 Bahraini citizens to cast their votes on a referendum about a variety of national issues (Kostopoulos, 2004). The pilot subsequently was expanded by issuing citizens smart identity cards to facilitate their interaction with the government and support the provision of government services (Al-Alawi & Al-Amer, 2007). ICT activities in the Bahraini government are coordinated by a central entity called the Central Informatics Organization (CIO), which was established in 1979 (Al-Amer, 2003). The CIO assumes a leadership role in planning and implementing e-government programs in the kingdom, with a vision to be a pioneer in e-government development in the region. Bahrain’s primary e-government portal (www.bahrain.gov.bh) is hosted by the CIO. This portal has been recently supplemented by a mobile version to allow anyone with a mobile phone to access available government services (FutureGov, 2009). The careful management of this centralized entity has been credited with the success of e-government and e-participation in Bahrain compared to other countries in the region (Sahraoui, 2005). Bahrain’s efforts to build a leading e-government implementation have been criticized, not on technical grounds, but rather on their lack of “an overarching social vision of citizen inclusion and participation” (Sahraoui, 2005). This limits the impact of e-government in delivering government services electronically, since opportunities to stimulate greater citizen involvement and participation are limited.
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
81
Creating the appropriate prerequisites for such participation requires political will and change, which is outside the control of the CIO. While adoption of services offered by Bahrain’s e-government presence is still modest, it has achieved significant growth over the past few years. In 2008, the e-government portal handled 12,550 electronic payment transactions, worth around US $2.5 million. This represents an increase of 250% from the previous year (ITP, 2008). According to the Bahraini e-government authority, awareness levels of e-government services increased from 26% in 2008 to 74% in 2009, and the use of e-government services increased from 7% in 2008 to 40% in 2009. The primary reason cited by survey respondents for not using e-government services was the lack of Internet access or skills, an issue the government is planning to tackle by implementing a low-cost, subsidized PC program (Al-Alawi & Al-Amer, 2007). Bahrain’s achievements in its e-government initiatives can be attributed to a strong commitment by the country’s leadership, which facilitates the mobilization of resources and establishment of entities dedicated to tackling specific challenges. Greater e-participation in Bahrain depends on increased citizen participation in the overall political sphere beginning in the offline world, and then moving online. Our model suggests that the Bahraini government can make progress in this direction by incrementally adopting democratic reforms as well as positively influencing voice and accountability.
5 E-participation in Estonia Of the countries we consider in this chapter, Estonia has made the greatest advances in implementing national e-government. Estonia scores highly on the United Nations’ most recent indices of e-government readiness (0.760) and e-participation (0.727). These scores place Estonia 13th on the E-government Readiness Index and 8th on the e-Participation Index. Estonia also ranks highly on the ICT Development Index and has a high level of Internet penetration. These impressive rankings and commitment to democratic freedoms come despite an annual gross national income per capita of under $16,000. The groundwork for Estonia’s e-government structure stems from the “Today I Decide” (TID) project, also known by its Estonian abbreviation, TOM. Launched in 2001, TID and its successor, “Today I Decide plus” (TID+), are a series of linked initiatives which are designed to promote greater awareness and involvement by citizens in the legislative process from the initial drafting through to its implementation. Over several years, the Estonian government has been successful in building a critical mass of citizens that are engaged in the policymaking process and participate in developing legislation (Ernsdorff & Berbec, 2007). The TID+ tools have given Estonians an opportunity to propose, discuss, and vote on new legislation, after which decision-makers are obliged to deliver a response to the initiatives. This effort has proven to be a success, with over 7,000 registered users proposing and discussing over 1,000 new initiatives. It also has enhanced participation by allowing
82
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
citizens to launch new ideas and to deliberate in an open forum, while guaranteeing a response from the decision-makers. One of the work-in-progress goals for the TID+ project is to increase civic engagement further, in part by making the legislative language and process more transparent, understandable, and accessible to citizens. TID+ is just one of the more than 20 projects that are being supported by the European Union (EU). One of the EU’s larger goals for these various e-participation projects is to enable transparent decision-making and policymaking processes by supporting the drafting of legislative texts for politicians and decision-makers. The resulting solutions should help improve the clarity and understanding of legislative text and content for non-specialists (and in a multilingual environment) thus facilitating citizens’ participation in the process. In addition, the EU is committed to enhancing the direct participation of citizens and civil society in the decisionmaking process itself by improving the access to relevant content and available options and, thus, enabling them to interact with decision-makers in real time. Many of these projects also are being designed with the larger goal of involving citizens in policy-making by enhancing social networking capacities, using new intermediation models, and creating collaborative input to policy-making (e.g., by using automated data gathering, online knowledge management, as well as Web 2.0 technologies). The funding of the TID+ project by the European Union is tied to having Estonia help develop strategies for expanding and scaling the lessons learned in Estonia so that they might be applied by national governments in other EU countries (ePractice, 2010). The EU funding is also tied to technology transfer of TID+. One of the specific goals for the TID+ project is to reevaluate and improve the present situation by making a software solution available free of charge for non-commercial use as an open source toolkit for increasing citizen participation. Another goal is to support citizens in initiating and discussing regulation. To achieve these goals, the online interface should be easy to use and should be easily adaptable by other governments and organizations. A third specific goal is to develop and disseminate the necessary documentation and guidelines that allow a productive and effective use of the toolkit in proposing and discussing government initiatives. This documentation should include past experiences and pointers on how best to take advantage of citizen input and feedback. Much of Estonia’s success in developing and implementing participatory e-government is attributed to decisions made by policymakers and citizens long before the collapse of the Soviet Union. Beginning in the 1960s, Estonia’s Institute of Cybernetics focused its resources on computer programming, spawning a vibrant and technically adept information technology (IT) community that would become crucial in setting government priorities on resource allocation and directing those resources to spending on ICTs in the early 1990s. A special administrative agency within the central government was formed that was responsible for all government ICT expenditures and IT procurement for government agencies (Kitsing, 2004). Also important for developing the ICT infrastructure was the establishment of a unilateral free trade regime in 1995, coupled with fully open telecommunication services in 2001. Trade liberalization enabled the transfer of technology into Estonia and large sums of foreign direct investment into ICTs, specifically from
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
83
neighboring Northern European states, who soon would be e-government pioneers. Furthermore, the Estonian government partially privatized telephone service, beginning with the sale of half of Estonian Telecom to Finish and Swedish telephone companies and then ending the incumbent monopoly in 2000. Privatization and direct foreign investment resulted in additional transfer of skills and technology needed to develop the telecommunications infrastructure. In 1998, an independent regulatory authority—The Estonian National Communications Board—was created (and then restructured in 2000) with authority for regulating all services within the telecommunications sector (Kitsing, 2004). Estonia’s commitment to the development of ICTs seems to have fostered a culture of technology among its citizens. The public’s confidence in the quality of policy formulation and implementation as well as administrative agencies’ independence from political pressures (i.e., government effectiveness), and in the ability of the government to implement sound regulations that promote the ICT sector (i.e., regulatory quality) all seem to have reinforced that culture. But sound public policy decisions and effective oversight cannot explain fully the Estonian people’s embrace of e-government and e-participation. Estonia has demonstrated a clear commitment to democracy and personal freedoms after the exit of the Soviet Union. Independent of the technology culture, there is a participatory culture among the Estonian people that pre-dates the development of the World Wide Web (Lane, Pabriks, Purs, & Smith, 2002; Raun, 2001; Smith, 1996). As can be seen in Table 4.1, Estonia scores very favorably on the two measures of democracy and personal freedom (i.e., Polity 2 and voice and accountability). While the Estonia experience can be seen as a model for achieving success in implementing e-participation, there are clear areas for improvement. Critics of the TID initiatives have suggested that they have been vulnerable to having a vocal minority with its own agenda gain disproportionate influence within the legislative process (Chadwick & Howard, 2008; Ernsdorff & Berbec, 2007). Legislative e-participation seems to be mirroring the lobbying that can influence the legislative process in favor of a particular stakeholder over other stakeholders or even exhibiting some of the same challenges and disappointments experienced by proponents of participatory democracy, where elites emerge and dominate the process and decision-making (Mansbridge, 1983; Pateman, 1976). Still, these disappointments withstanding, the Estonian public seems to have embraced e-governance with vigor in recent years and shows little sign of turning back.
6 E-participation in Finland Of the four countries in this study, Finland has the best scores on the World Governance Indicators (Kaufmann et al., 2009) and has the highest level of democracy (CSP, 2009). Finland’s national strengths, however, go beyond the context presented in Section 2. Finland has an advanced information society and is an ICT development pioneer in many fields (ITU, 2009; World Bank, 2006). Finland’s
84
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
strengths also include a high level of education, regional, and social equality, an excellent administration culture, open access to public information, modern national databases and registers, as well as citizen trust in both offline and online government services. Based on a national survey, Accenture (2006) reported that Finland is a country where citizens are likely to have tried e-government (73%) and has a high percentage of citizens who prefer an electronic government channel over alternative channels (43%). Although Table 4.1 suggests that e-participation is a work-in-progress area in Finnish public administration, past successes suggest there is reason to believe that Finland will succeed in this endeavor. For example, Pollitt and Bouckaert (2004) remind us that reforms of public administration have been featured on the political agenda in Finland since 1987. Furthermore, Finnish reform is not generally led by the civil servants, but by politicians, i.e., by the ministers. This has many implications. One of these is that the point of view of citizens is included in reforms. Another implication is that citizen-centric strategies have been put into practice in enacted legislation. It is therefore reasonable to expect that this inclusive philosophy of government will be reflected in future assessments of e-participation. Improvements in the effectiveness and efficiency of government in Finland have alternately been focused at the local, regional, and national levels. One of the national strategies aims to mirror the high-quality of life in Finland’s offline society in their online society. The main goals of the National Knowledge Society Strategy promise additional government reform and citizen inclusion in the information society. Specifically, the strategy calls for the “reformation of Finland into an internationally attractive, human-centric and competitive knowledge and service society” by 2015 (Information Society Programme, 2006). A critical factor upon which this transformation into a knowledge-based society depends is that organizations and individuals extensively utilize advanced ICTs. We refer our readers to the EU e-practice factsheets for information about this and other important national initiatives in Finland (ePractice, 2010). Finland has made significant advances in regional and local e-government and e-participation. Since the mid-1990s, government administration has been decentralized and thus municipalities enjoy considerable independence. In terms of organization, Finland’s Regional Councils are joint municipal authorities responsible for regional development. There are 19 Regional Councils, which group together the country’s 446 municipalities. There is even a dedicated IT organization, KuntaIT, which is charged with rationalizing and ensuring the compatibility and interoperability of e-government services provided by municipal and regional authorities (Accenture, 2006). Finland’s growing emphasis on customer-focused, participatory, and local service delivery is evident in its use of its network of 200+ Citizen Centres to deliver an increasing number of government services (ePractice, 2010). Delivering such services at scale is embodied in Helsinki’s initiatives over the next few years, which include having it be one of the most connected cities in the world (Holzer & Kim, 2008), with online, anywhere, anytime government being a significant part of these plans. The 2009–2012 plans for Helsinki build on the lessons learned from earlier
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
85
projects in Finland, e.g., the eTampere project (Heikkilä, 2006), including the technologies leveraged by or developed for these other projects (Zwahr, Rossel, & Finger, 2005). The main goal of the City of Helsinki project is to provide universal access to digital government within city limits. To encourage e-participation, this project includes an interactive Service Map of so-called service points, composable services, service chains, service support processes, and data distribution and exchange of public information (Helsinki, 2010). Even though the Helsinki Service Map is just over a year old it contains more than 6,000 registered services and is supporting 5,000 or more searches per day. Although the vast majority of the services are for citizens, some are reserved for use by city planners, operations specialists, and public safety officials. An important benefit of using a map to present government services is being able to provide location-aware services (Virrantaus et al., 2001). For example, along with the service point information, a user can easily request information about how to get to a specific location (including a service point) using public transportation. The notion of universal access to government services is also quite broad. Helsinki intends to provide services to citizens and business users with customized interfaces and personalized content and services that cater to residents, visitors, and tourists. Thus, the Service Map presents government services differently based on the user, their preferred language, their usage, and the type of service. The Helsinki Service Map also includes an open and public feedback system to promote citizen inclusion in improving their online relationship with their government. One benefit of this feedback system is that users sometimes find and point out problems with government services and errors in the information provided, which then can be corrected (Helsinki, 2010). Like the TID+ project in Estonia, the City of Helsinki hopes to establish common practices in public administration and harmonize information and data management for similar projects (ePractice, 2010). Specifically, the information and data models are offered to other stakeholders so that the Service Map concept can be replicated and exploited both regionally and nationally. Within the Helsinki Service Map, there are also service points of private and third-party actors (e.g., businesses and nonprofits), which provide public services for the citizens, thus promoting cross-sector cooperation using open standards for information exchange. Perhaps the most significant goal for e-government and e-participation projects like the ongoing efforts in Helsinki is to make the hierarchical and organizational boundaries of governance invisible to its citizens (Information Society Programme, 2006). The Helsinki planners believe that Service Map users should not need to know which office is responsible for the issue at hand, just that an online user can find and access the service that they need, when they need it. This belief resonates in the broader Helsinki at Your Service vision for 2015, which states that Helsinki intends to offer “extensive, customer-oriented services via information networks for the city’s inhabitants, companies, communities and visitors.” Reflecting national attitudes toward government in Finland, the same Helsinki vision also states that citizens will “trust the services and use them widely” (Helsinki, 2009).
86
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
7 Summary and Implications We have examined e-governance strategies and policies in four countries (Egypt, Bahrain, Estonia, and Finland) to understand what factors contribute to a country’s success in implementing e-participation initiatives and to identify obstacles preventing success. We developed a framework for our analysis based on King et al.’s model for the impact of government regulation and influence on IT innovations. Our framework identifies four factors that governments can regulate to improve their e-governance, namely, the level of democracy, control of corruption, regulatory quality, and government effectiveness. The framework also presents four factors that governments can influence in the same context. These factors are voice and accountability, ICT development, e-government readiness, and e-participation. Differences in the adoption and use of online participation within the four countries were presented in their respective contexts. In Egypt, for example, the skepticism surrounding electronic payment, access limitations imposed by insufficient ICT infrastructure, along with issues of illiteracy, poor governance, and lack of transparency have all seriously affected e-government initiatives and prevented them from achieving their full potential. Of course, expectations for e-governance in Egypt need to be tempered by the reality that any initiative is being undertaken in a country with a large population and relatively limited resources. The Bahraini, Estonian and Finnish experiences, on the other hand, were more promising. Successes in these countries have been built on the high penetration of ICTs as well as sound governance and carefully managed approaches that have been tailored to meet the needs and expectations of their citizens. Although beyond the scope of our research, we expect that one reason that Estonia has the highest e-Participation Index in comparison with the other three countries is that each national government perceives the benefits and value of e-governance differently. In Egypt, for example, the government stresses costcutting and also reducing bureaucracy and corruption. Estonia, while not blind to these issues, also emphasizes greater awareness and involvement by citizens in the political process. Although there are several ways to improve e-participation in the countries we examined, two are worth highlighting. First, in Bahrain, e-governance initiatives clearly need to be designed to stimulate higher levels of citizen involvement and participation. Second, in Finland, the central government’s online capabilities need to expand to include e-consultation and e-decision-making. Our research also validates the utility of a theoretical framework in assessing e-governance performance and understanding factors that contribute to the same. By demonstrating a structured and methodical approach to analyzing e-participation strategies and policies, practitioners and decision-makers can work to improve outcomes by managing the institutional factors that governments can regulate and influence. Finally, researchers can reuse, modify, or extend our proposed framework to evaluate the success of e-participation and e-government initiatives in different countries, and test their own hypotheses regarding the impact of both online and offline factors on such initiatives.
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
87
8 Conclusions and Future Directions Our exploration of e-participation in Egypt, Bahrain, Estonia, and Finland revealed that there is no single path for enhancing a government’s ability to request, receive, and incorporate feedback from citizens. In each country, different factors emerged as critical for developing substantive e-participation capabilities. In Egypt, one important factor in introducing e-participation tools was financial investment in the further development of its ICT infrastructure in order to build its e-government capacity and increase access to ICTs among the wider population. In Bahrain, which already was an e-government pioneer and had experienced wide diffusion of ICTs, the most important factor was a national commitment in terms of both strategic vision and a central entity authorized to implement ICT policy. This suggests that a smaller, more homogenous population and more authoritarian form of government can provide the context for strategic planning and implementation to succeed in developing e-participation capabilities. However, Estonia’s success with e-participation shows that implementing a national vision can also be possible in a democratic state, even one that is relatively young. Finland, which has the most mature democracy of the four cases we examined, found success by providing some broad guidelines and assistance to regional and local authorities but allowing these governments to develop and implement their own e-participation projects. A common theme that emerges from our examination of these four cases is that successful implementation of e-participation requires a citizenry that has a general trust in government and a belief that government can be effective. It is not necessary that the government be democratically elected or closer to the people. What matters is that some form of government-to-citizen communication already has been institutionalized offline. Regardless of how many resources the Egyptian government directs toward ICT development, it is unlikely that effective e-participation tools will be established and utilized until the regime undertakes major political reforms that revitalize the relationship between citizens and their government. Finally, our work suggests that future studies should account for government efficacy and citizen trust in their models of e-government and e-participation. Even with significant e-government capacity, the public’s willingness to use online tools may depend on their confidence in the overall political system. Further research might also focus on studying the level of government at which e-governance initiatives are targeted, and what are the real short- and long-term impacts of each initiative in promoting e-participation and civic engagement.
References Abdoun, S. (2009, August 11). E-government services usage relatively low, says government poll. Daily News Egypt. Retrieved from http://www.thedailynewsegypt.com/ article.aspx?ArticleID=23725 Accenture. (2006). Leadership in customer service: Building the trust. Chicago, IL: Accenture. Al-Alawi, A. I., & Al-Amer, M. A. (2007). Smartcard implementation in Bahrain: Public acceptance and readiness. Electronic Government: An International Journal, 4(2), 227–246.
88
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
Al-Amer, M. A. (2003). Bahrain and the information society. United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia. Baum, M. A., & Lake, D. A. (2003). The political economy of growth: Democracy and human capital. American Journal of Political Science, 47(2), 333–347. Best, S. J., & Krueger, B. S. (2005). Analyzing the representativeness of internet political participation. Political Behavior, 27(2), 183–216. Chadwick, A. & Howard, P. (Eds.). (2008). Routledge handbook of internet politics. New York: Routledge. Charif, H., & Ramadan, M. (2003). E-government attempts in ESCWA member countries. Berlin, Germany: Springer. CIA. (2009). The CIA world factbook. Retrieved October 1, 2009, from https://www.cia.gov/ library/publications/the-world-factbook/ CSP. (2009). Center for systemic peace polity IV project: Dataset users’ manual. Fairfax, VA: George Mason University. Curtin, G. G. (2006). Issues and challenges: Global e-government/e-participation models, measurement and methodology – A framework for moving forward. In Proceedings of the workshop on e-participation and e-government: Understanding the present and creating the future. New York, NY: United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. Dutta, S., Shalhoub, Z. K., & Samuels, G. (2007). Promoting technology and innovation: Recommendations to improve Arab ICT competitiveness. In Arab World Competitiveness Report. Dutton, W. H., & Peltu, M. (1996). Information and communication technologies: Visions and realities. New York: Oxford University Press. Egypt E-Government Portal. (2009). Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.alhokoma.gov.eg/ El-Askalany, H., Rashad, M., & Darwish, A. M. (2003). EISI-Government: The Egyptian information society initiative for government services delivery. Proceedings of the Kuwait Conference on e-Government. El-Saharty, S., Richardson, G., & Chase, S. (2005). Egypt and the millennium development goals: Challenges and opportunities. Washington, DC: The World Bank. ePractice (2010). ePractice.eu factsheets. Web site for eGovernment and eInclusion in Europe, http://www.epractice.eu/en/factsheets, accessed January 31, 2010. Ernsdorff, M., & Berbec, A. (2007). Estonia: The short road to e-government and e-democracy. In P. G. Nixon & V. N. Koutrakou (Eds.), E-government in Europe: Re-booting the state (pp. 171–183). New York: Routledge. ESCWA. (2005). Regional profile of the information society in Western Asia. New York: United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia. FutureGov. (2009). Bahrain e-government services now on mobiles. Retrieved October 1, 2009, from http://www.futuregov.net/articles/2009/may/26/bahrain-e-government-servicesnow-mobiles/ Garson, G. D. (2006). Public information technology and e-governance: Managing the virtual state. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett Publishers. Glück, M., Mitwalli, A., & Stemmler, R. (2008). IT for emerging markets—commentary. New York: McKinsey & Company. Hachigian, N., & Kaplan, J. A. (2002). Roadmap for e-government in the developing world: 10 questions e-government leaders should ask themselves. Los Angeles, CA: Pacific Council on International Policy, USC. Hargittai, E. (1999). Weaving the western web: Explaining differences in internet connectivity among OECD countries. Telecommunications Policy, 23(10/11), 701–718. Heeks, R., & Bailur, S. (2007). Analyzing e-government research: Perspectives, philosophies, theories, methods, and practice. Government Information Quarterly, 24(2), 243–265. Heikkilä, J. (2006). eTampere programme 2001–2005 summary. Tampere, Finland: City of Tampere Information Office.
4
E-participation in the Middle East and Northern Europe
89
Helbig, N., Gil-García, J. R., & Ferro, E. (2009). Understanding the complexity of electronic government: Implications from the digital divide literature. Government Information Quarterly, 26(1), 89–97. Helsinki. (2009). “Helsinki at your service” vision 2015. Helsinki, Finland: Economic and Planning Centre, February 20. Helsinki. (2010). City of Helsinki Service Map. Web site for government service map, http://www.hel.fi/servicemap, accessed January 31, 2010. Holzer, M., & Kim, S. -T. (2008). Digital governance in municipalities worldwide (2007) – A longitudinal assessment of municipal Websites throughout the world. Newark, NJ: National Center for Public Performance, Rutgers University. Information Society Programme. (2006). A renewing, human-centric and competitive Finland: The National Knowledge Society Strategy 2007–2015. Helsinki, Finland: Prime Minister’s Office. IRCT. (2006). Country assessment report: The Arab Republic of Egypt. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.irct.org/Admin/Public/DWSDownload.aspx?File=%2FFiles%2FFiler %2FIPIP%2Freports+documents%2FEgypt_Country_Report.pdf ITP. (2008). Bahrain e-government portal handles $2.5m in 2008. Retrieved October 1, 2009, from http://www.itp.net/542361-bahrain-e-government-portal-handles-25m-in-2008 ITU. (2007). ICT indicators for Africa. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.itu.int/ITU-D/ict/statistics/at_glance/af_ictindicators_2007.html ITU. (2008). ICT Eye database. Retrieved September 30, 2009, from http://www.itu.int/ITUD/icteye/DisplayCountry.aspx?countryId=35 ITU. (2009). Measuring the information society: The ICT development index. International Telecommunication Union Report. Geneva, Switzerland: United Nations. Jaeger, P. T. (2003). The endless wire: E-government as global phenomenon. Government Information Quarterly, 20(4), 323–331. Kaufmann, D., Kraay, A., & Mastruzzi, M. (2009). Governance matters VIII: Aggregate and individual governance indicators, 1996–2008, Policy research working paper 4978. Washington, DC: The World Bank. Keefer, P. (2007). Clientelism, credibility, and the policy choices of young democracies. American Journal of Political Science, 51(4), 804–821. King, J. L., Gurbaxani, V., Kraemer, K. L., McFarlan, F. W., Raman, K. S., & Yap, C. S. (1994). Institutional factors in information technology innovation. Information Systems Research, 5(2), 139–169. Kitsing, M. (2004). The impact of economic openness on Internet diffusion in Estonia and Slovenia. Master of Arts in Law and Diplomacy Thesis. Medford, MA: Tufts University. Kohli, A. (2004). State-directed development: Political power and industrialization in the global periphery. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Kostopoulos, G. K. (2004). E-government in the Arabian Gulf: A vision toward reality. Electronic Government: An International Journal, 1(3), 293–299. Lane, T., Pabriks, A., Purs, A., & Smith, D. J. (2002). The Baltic states: Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. New York: Routledge. Macintosh, A. (2006). eParticipation in policy-making: The research and the challenges. In Exploiting the knowledge economy: Issues, applications, case studies. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: IOS Press. Macintosh, A. (2008). E-democracy and e-participation research in Europe. In Digital government: e-government research, case studies, and implementation. New York: Springer. Mansbridge, J. J. (1983). Beyond adversary democracy. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Motorola. (2001). Bahrainis become Middle East’s first E-voters. Retrieved October 1, 2009, from http://www.symbol.com/news/pressreleases/pr_releases_inter_bahrain.html Nixon, P. G. & Koutrakou, V. N. (Eds.). (2007). E-government in Europe: Re-booting the state. New York, NY: Routledge. O’Driscoll, G. P., Holmes, K. R., & Kirkpatrick, M. (2009). Index of economic freedom. Washington, DC: The Heritage Foundation.
90
G.J. “Jeff” Gulati et al.
Pateman, C. (1976). Participation and democratic theory. New York: Cambridge University Press. Pollitt, C., & Bouckaert, G. (2004). Public management reform: A comparative analysis (2nd ed.). New York: Oxford University Press. Raun, T. U. (2001). Estonia and the Estonians. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press. Sahraoui, S. (2005). e-Government in the Arabian Gulf: Government transformation vs government automation. In Proceedings of the e-Government Workshop. Schech, S. (2002). Wired for change: The links between ICTs and development discourses. Journal of International Development, 14(1), 13–23. Servon, L. J. (2002). Bridging the digital divide: Technology, community, and public policy. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell. Smith, G. (1996). The Baltic states: The national self-determination of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. New York: Palgrave-Macmillan. Virrantaus, K., Markkula, J., Garmash, A., Terziyan, V., Veijalainen, J., Katanosov, A., & Tirri, H. (2001). Developing GIS-supported location-based services. In Proceedings of the Second IEEE International Conference on Web Information Systems Engineering (Vol. 2). United Nations. (2008). UN e-government survey 2008: From e-government to connected governance. UN Publication ST/ESA/PAD/SER.E/112. New York, NY: United Nations. Warkentin, M., Gefen, D., Pavlou, P. A., & Rose, G. M. (2002). Encouraging citizen adoption of e-government by building trust. Electronic Markets, 12(3), 157–162. West, D. M. (2005). Digital government: Technology and public sector performance. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. World Bank. (2006). Information and communications for development 2006: Global trends and policies. Washington, DC: The World Bank. World Bank. (2009). GNI per capita, PPP (current international $). Retrieved October 1, 2009, from http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.PP.CD Zwahr, T., Rossel, P., & Finger, M. (2005). Towards electronic governance – A case study of ICT in local government governance. In Proceedings of the National Conference on Digital Government Research.
Chapter 5
Evaluation of the Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans Ourania I. Markaki, Dimitris E. Charilas, and Dimitrios Askounis
Governments around the world are embracing the digital revolution to enhance services for their citizens. However, the development of quality e-services and delivery systems that are efficient and effective is only one aspect of e-government. The essence of the latter lies as well in engaging citizenry into the use of e-government services. This chapter studies the impact and actual utilization of e-government services in certain countries of the Balkans (Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia) using fuzzy numbers and statistics. Building on the elementary concept of the time that citizens/businesses spend on their transactions with public administration and taking into account the current sophistication stage of online public services, the chapter provides a framework for evaluating (a) e-government services in terms of the benefits that their use involves for citizens/businesses compared to the use of conventional ones and (b) the actual adoption (take-up) of e-government services by the aforementioned stakeholders. In this context, the scheme proposes the use of data expressed in linguistic terms with regard to the time citizens/businesses spend on transactions with public administration using either conventional or e-services, which are then converted to fuzzy numbers to be further processed so as to incorporate the uncertainty factor which is innate in the relevant estimations. The proposed framework is then applied for each one of the aforementioned countries for a basket of 20 basic public services (12 for citizens and 8 for businesses), exploiting the current sophistication stage and the actual utilization of e-government services per sophistication stage, provided
O.I. Markaki (B) National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, 15780 Athens, Greece e-mail:
[email protected] D.E. Charilas National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, 15780 Athens, Greece e-mail:
[email protected] D. Askounis National Technical University of Athens, Zografou, 15780 Athens, Greece e-mail:
[email protected]
C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_5, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
91
92
O.I. Markaki et al.
by the corresponding e-government factsheets and Eurostat, the Statistical Office of the European Communities, respectively, and allowing for useful conclusions to be reached.
1 Introduction In Europe, e-government is considered to be one of the main goals for the future. Hence, a project was launched in 2002 under the title “e-Europe 2005 action plan: An information society for all” (Commission of the European Communities, 2002). Likewise, in June 2005 the “i2010—A European Information Society for growth and employment” initiative was launched by the Commission as a policy framework for promoting the positive contribution that information and communication technologies (ICT) can make to the economy, society, and personal quality of life (Commission of the European Communities, 2005), to be followed by the announcement, in early September 2005, of a Communication call for synchronized actions that can provide broader accessibility to ICT. Main issues in the EU agenda on ICT strongly relate to three contact elements in between government and citizen/business relations, which are attaining information, downloading forms, and returning filledin forms. According to the statistical information provided by Eurostat (2008), the Statistical Office of the European Communities, nevertheless, only 25.5% of individuals are frequently accessing information via e-government’s establishments in the European Union (EU27), while 15.9% are downloading official forms, and even less (11.7%) are returning filled-in forms. The numbers of e-government users in Denmark, Finland, and Sweden as well as the United Kingdom are higher than those in the remainder of the EU member states. The situation is even worse in the Balkans, where administrations have failed so far to provide a variety of fully transactional services to their citizens and businesses. Due to the political and economical status in these countries, until recently there were no infrastructures for e-government transformation. During the last years, however, each country has taken significant steps toward the directions posed by the European Union. The next paragraphs describe briefly the most important achievements and current status of e-government in five countries of the Balkans: Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia. Bulgaria’s E-government Web site (www.egov.bg) was launched in 2007. The Web site in question was the outcome of the Inter-regional System for Electronic Government and the Pilot Integration System for Electronic Regional Administration, two projects run by the State Administration Ministry. According to the e-government strategy of Bulgaria, a number of strategic documents have been developed and adopted to guide the public administration’s activities with regard to e-government transformation. The legal framework in Bulgaria has been largely harmonized with that of the European Union and can rather quickly be developed further to serve the requirements and purposes of e-government transformation. A national asynchronous transfer mode (ATM) network is also in the process of
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
93
development. An integrated optical communication network linking ministries and other state agencies in Sofia is already in operation, while its extension to the regional centers of Bulgaria is currently underway. The Romanian government has been making significant attempts to set up a proper framework for the development of e-government. An e-government portal (www.e-guvernare.ro) was launched in September 2003, providing a one-stop shop to online public services and incorporating a transactional platform that enables users to register for interactive and transactional services. In 2003, Romania’s national portal received an achievement award from the World Summit of the Information Society for its comprehensiveness and innovation and the authorities responsible aim at progressively making all services and information accessible through it (Colesca & Liliana, 2007). Still, with a percentage of e-government utilization at about 9% (Eurostat, 2008), Romania needs to increase its efforts to encourage potential users to use the available online public services. In Slovenia the Ministry of Public Administration is responsible for e-government as well. The ministry was set up in 2004, incorporating all offices whose common goal is to improve public administration. This step indicates an effort to improve and simplify public administration procedures and to develop e-government under one roof and one leadership. In the past years, several e-government applications have been developed; nevertheless, measures are still being taken toward the horizontal integration of several departments and institutions (Dobnikar & Nemec, 2007). In April 2006 the Slovenian government adopted an egovernment strategy covering the period from 2006 to 2010. The purpose of this new strategy has been to lay down the general framework as well as the individual goals for further undertaking new and unfolding existing e-government projects, especially with regard to user satisfaction, rationalization of administration, and development of modern e-services that will raise the quality of everyday life and make the contact with public administration more convenient and citizen-friendly. The strategy in question takes into account modern guidelines and initiatives which have been adopted at EU level. In July 2001, Hungary introduced an e-government program. The program was designed by the Office of the Government Commissioner in charge of information technology, a department of the Prime Minister’s Office, and aimed at integrating the strategies and IT development projects of various sectors and institutions in order to offer better services to citizens. More specifically, the two main objectives of the e-government program were to provide citizen-friendly services and to improve the efficiency of internal administrative procedures. The envisaged services would assist significantly in the resolution of administrative issues, since Hungarian citizens spend around 18 million hours every year on administrative tasks. Although there are recent improvements in certain fields (e.g., the issuing of passports), there still remain plenty of time-consuming, complicated, and complex tasks, such as registering vehicles, issuing birth and marriage certificates, and determining maternity allowances (Erzsébet, 2002). The Hungarian Information Society Strategy is in fact the adaptation of e-Europe Program for Hungary. This Strategy was adopted in 2003 and the basic method for its realization is the so-called moving planning.
94
O.I. Markaki et al.
Currently in Greece, the Operational Program for the Information Society (OPIS) is promoting ICT in the public sector. In Greece, e-government is at an early stage of establishment (Hahamis, Iles, & Healy, 2005). If we consider that e-government has five basic infrastructure elements, in Greece only two are actually functional. It can be argued that Greece had a minor success in getting a functional portal, known as Citizen Service Center (KEP) (www.kep.gov.gr), which provides access to public service information and to a number of standard administrative procedures (Markoulakis, 2005). Beside the e-government strategies and initiatives that have been adopted across the countries around the world, what is really needed is an efficient way to evaluate the impact of e-government transformation so that the achievements of each country in the field can be quantified and thus compared; e-government performance evaluation has become extremely important in guiding and inspecting e-government’s development. A variety of models have been proposed in the literature to assess e-government performance (Panopoulou, Tambouris, & Tarabanis, 2008; Wang, Bretschneider, & Gant, 2005; Wauters, 2006). Such models have an unquestionable usability; nevertheless their use in isolation leaves the impression that e-government is solely about delivering government services over the Internet and that a nicely designed, user-oriented Web site is all that matters. Such an assumption however ignores the substantial investments that are needed in people, tools, and policies. An innovative indicators’ system is proposed by the Greek Observatory (2008) as a measurement and evaluation tool of the national strategic objectives regarding the improvement of the administrative capacity of the Greek Public Administration; the proposed system includes mainly indicators of impacts, rather than indicators of flows, meaning that the actual focus is on the final recipients of the actions undertaken to support these strategic objectives, i.e., the citizens, the enterprises, and the state itself; however a complete framework in terms of measurement methodology and base values to be used is not suggested. Still, the potential impact of e-government transformation on the improvement of the citizens’ quality of life or in the businesses’ productivity and competitiveness is only one side of the problem. The statistical information provided by Eurostat (2008) is rather disappointing, since only a small percent of the population exploit currently the e-government services. At the normative level, concerns have already been expressed about the “digital divide” and whether e-government will exacerbate inequities among citizens (Hubregtse, 2005). Addressing this concern and finding an amicable way out should also constitute a part of the effectiveness of governments. Bringing public services online is thus only one way to enhance the quality of public service delivery. The next challenge that e-government has to tackle is, as implied by Wauters (2006), to shift the focus from “availability” and “quality” of e-government services, through a transition stage of “use,” which refers to e-government services’ take-up and user satisfaction, to a desired end-state of “impact,” which concerns long-term results of e-government initiatives on society. As a consequence and with a scope of application that covers the Balkan countries of Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia, the evaluation analysis presented in this chapter is oriented toward two main axes: (a) the evaluation of
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
95
e-government services in terms of the benefits that their use involves for citizens/businesses compared to the use of conventional ones and (b) the evaluation of the actual utilization of e-government services by the aforementioned stakeholders. More specifically, the chapter builds on the elementary concept of the time that citizens/businesses spend on transactions with the public authorities to provide a quantitative indication of the impact of the modernization of public administration on the improvement of the citizens’ quality of life or the businesses’ efficiency, respectively, taking as well into account the current sophistication stage of online public services. The impact is in fact expressed in terms of the time gained through the use of e-services within the frame of transactions with the public authorities, and time is chosen as the measurement unit to be used, since the resulting time savings constitute a quite comprehensible and tangible benefit for the aforementioned stakeholders. The scheme adopts the collection of information expressed in linguistic terms with regard to the time citizens/businesses spend on transactions with public administration (using either conventional or e-services), which is then converted to fuzzy numbers to be further processed, so as to incorporate the uncertainty factor that is innate in the relevant estimations. On an upper level, statistical information is exploited in order to perform e-government evaluation in the selected countries in terms of e-government services take-up. The discussion in this chapter proceeds as follows: Section 1 is an introduction to the issue of e-government transformation in the selected Balkan countries and to the problem of e-government evaluation. Section 2 presents the e-service sophistication model used to benchmark the sophistication of online public services, as well as the basket of services for citizens and businesses that has been selected for the evaluation analysis. Section 3 provides an insight into fuzzy set theory and linguistics, which constitute important tools in the evaluation attempted, while Section 4 clarifies how information with regard to transaction time, expressed in linguistic terms, can be converted to fuzzy numbers and be exploited by the proposed framework. Section 5 introduces the evaluation framework through the definition of three evaluation metrics. In Section 6 the framework is applied to Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia (for all selected services) and a discussion over the results is made. Finally, Section 7 defines the basic directions for future research and Section 8 summarizes conclusions.
2 E-government Services 2.1 Sophistication of E-government Services In order to measure the sophistication of online public services, an e-service sophistication model is used by Capgemini (2007). This model illustrates the different degrees of sophistication of online public services going from “basic” information provision over one- and two-way interactions to “full” e-case handling, as seen in Table 5.1. More specifically:
96
O.I. Markaki et al.
• Stage 1 corresponds solely to the online availability of the information required to start the procedure to obtain a specific public service. • Stage 2 indicates that the publicly available Web site offers the possibility to obtain in a non-electronic way, thus by downloading forms, the paper form necessary to commence the procedures related to the specific public service. • Stage 3 represents as well the possibility of an e-intake of an official e-form in order to obtain the service, implying the existence of an authentication mechanism for verifying the identity of the person requesting the service. • Stage 4 is indicative of full e-delivery of services, where no other formal procedure is necessary for the applicant via “paperwork.” • Stage 5, built around the concepts of pro-activity and personalization, gives an indication of fully integrated e-procedures that help reduce “red tape” and improve data consistency. Both Stages 4 and 5 represent full e-case handling. • Besides these five stages, a zero stage (Stage 0) may also be introduced to capture two possible research outcomes: (a) total absence of any publicly accessible Web site managed by the service provider and (b) the public service provider has a publicly accessible Web site, but the latter does not offer any relevant information concerning the public service. Stage 0 corresponds in fact to conventional public services.
Table 5.1 The five levels of sophistication in e-government Stage
Degree of sophistication
Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 Stage 4 Stage 5
Information One-way interaction (downloadable forms) Two-way interaction (e-forms) Transaction (full e-case handling) Personalization (pro-active, automated service delivery)
At this point, attention must be drawn to the fact that the existence of an e-public service with a sophistication stage lower than 4 or 5 does not mean that the citizen is not able to complete a transaction, e.g., a third-stage service, implies that the citizen may obtain information on the service, download the paper form necessary to commence the relevant procedures or even fill in and submit this paper form electronically, but also that he afterward has to reach the premises of the responsible public agency to arrange perhaps some economic debt as well. The absence of fully transactional services corresponds obligatorily to the use of both lower level e-services (ideally the highest level e-service available) and conventional methods or mere conventional services. The point in this chapter is to show that the use of e-services offers citizens/businesses the advantage of saving time and that this advantage is more perceptible in case of fully transactional services.
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
97
2.2 Basket of E-services A representative list of public services, suitable for measuring the online sophistication of the latter, should include services in the areas of e-government, e-learning, and e-health. In this frame, the European Commission and the EU Member States developed and published a list of 20 basic public services that covers reasonably well the different tasks and interactions of the public sector with citizens and businesses (Capgemini, 2007). In fact, for 12 of these services, the final recipients are the citizens, while for 8 of them, the target group are businesses. Tables 5.2 and 5.3 provide an overview of the aforementioned 20 basic public services along with an indication of the maximum sophistication stage possible for each service. Table 5.2 Basket of services for citizens Citizen services CS1 CS2 CS3
Max. stage Income taxes: declaration, notification of assessment Job search services by labor offices Social security benefits (unemployment benefits, child allowances, medical costs, student grants) Personal documents (passport and driver’s license) Car registration (new, used, imported cars) Application for building permission Declaration to the police (e.g., in case of theft) Public libraries (availability of catalogues, search tools) Certificates (birth, marriage): request and delivery Enrolment in higher education/university Announcement of moving (change of address) Health-related services (availability of services in different hospitals, appointments for hospitals)
CS4 CS5 CS6 CS7 CS8 CS9 CS10 CS11 CS12
5 4 5 4 4 4 3 5 4 4 4 4
Table 5.3 Basket of services for businesses Business services
Max. stage
BS1 BS2 BS3 BS4 BS5 BS6 BS7 BS8
4 4 4 4 5 4 5 4
Social contributions to employees Corporate tax: declaration, notification VAT: declaration, notification Registration of a new company Submission of data to statistical offices Customs declaration Environment-related permits (incl. reporting) Public procurement
98
O.I. Markaki et al.
3 Fuzzy Numbers In this section the authors set the background for the evaluation framework by presenting basic information on linguistics and fuzzy set theory, which constitute the main tools in the evaluation attempted.
3.1 Linguistics and Fuzzy Set Theory There are some situations in which information may be hard or even impossible to quantify due to its nature, and thus it can only be expressed in linguistic terms (e.g., when evaluating the comfort or design of a car, terms like “good,” “fair,” “poor” can be used). In other cases, precise quantitative information cannot be provided because either it is unavailable or the cost for its computation is too high and an approximate value can be tolerated (e.g., when evaluating the speed of a car, linguistic terms like “fast,” “very fast,” “slow” can be used instead of numeric values). Such qualitative information can be mathematically modeled through the use of fuzzy set theory. The latter handles fuzziness and represents qualitative aspects as linguistic variables, i.e., variables whose values are not numbers but words or sentences according to a natural or an artificial language. More specifically, qualitative information expressed through linguistic terms (e.g., “low,” “medium,” “high”) can be converted to fuzzy numbers using a suitable conversion scale. Processing of the relevant information takes place using these fuzzy numbers, which are finally converted to crisp numbers through the process of defuzzification. Obviously, the same linguistic terms in different conversion scales can have different crisp values.
3.2 Fuzzy Numbers The fuzzy set theory, introduced by Zadeh (1965) as a means of dealing with vagueness, imprecision, and uncertainty in problems, has been used as a modeling tool for complex systems that can be controlled by humans but are hard to define precisely. The main characteristic of fuzziness is the grouping of the individuals’ judgments into classes that do not have sharply defined boundaries. An uncertain comparison can be represented by a fuzzy number. A fuzzy set is one that assigns grades of membership between 0 and 1 to objects using a particular membership function μA (x). The membership function of a triangular fuzzy number is defined by three real numbers as ⎧ x−l ⎫ ⎪ ⎨ m−l , l ≤ x ≤ m ⎪ ⎬ μA (x) = u−x , m ≤ x ≤ u , ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ u−m ⎭ 0, otherwise where l is the lower limit value, m is the most promising value, and u is the upper limit value. Figure 5.1 shows the typical form of a fuzzy triangular number.
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
99
Fig. 5.1 Fuzzy triangular number
˜ (b1 , b2 , b3 ), and Given any two triangular fuzzy numbers à = (a1 , a2 , a3 ), B= a real number k > 0, the basic mathematical operations of fuzzy numbers can be expressed as follows: A˜ ⊕ B˜ = (a1 , a2 , a3 ) ⊕ (b1 , b2 , b3 ) = (a1 + b1 , a2 + b2 , a3 + b3 ) A˜ B˜ = (a1 , a2 , a3 ) (b1 , b2 , b3 ) = (a1 − b3 , a2 − b2 , a3 − b1 ) A˜ B˜ = (a1 , a2 , a3 ) (b1 , b2 , b3 ) = (a1 b1 , a2 b2 , a3 b3 ) A˜ B˜ = (a1 , a2 , a3 ) (b1 , b2 , b3 ) = (a1 /b3 , a2 /b2 , a3 /b1 ), a1 ≥ 0, b1 > 0 ∀ k > 0, k ∈ R : k (a1 , a2 , a3 ) = (ka1 , ka2 , ka3 )
3.3 Defuzzification Methods Defuzzification is the process of producing a quantifiable result in fuzzy logic; in other words, the extraction of a crisp value that represents effectively a given fuzzy number. The simplest but also the least usefuldue to important information loss—defuzzification method is to choose the set with the highest membership. Alternatively, the following common methods of defuzzification may be used.
3.3.1 Center of Gravity (COG) It is one of the most commonly used defuzzification techniques and is based on the determination of the center of the area under the combined membership functions, i.e., the area under the curve. The centroid or the center of gravity of the area is calculated as : −1 FCOG
μA (x) · xdx = x x μA (x) · dx
100
O.I. Markaki et al.
3.3.2 Bisector of Area (BOA) The bisector is the vertical line that divides a region into two sub-regions of equal area. It sometimes coincides with the centroid line. xBOA
β
μA (x)dx = a
μA (x)dx xBOA
4 Expressing Time with Fuzzy Numbers Common approaches for e-government service evaluation rely on questionnaires, in which the citizens are requested to express their overall experience of a service or their opinion on a specific feature on a predefined satisfaction scale (Abhichandani & Horan, 2006) that in several cases consists of a series of linguistic values, similar to those described in the previous section. Final conclusions are then usually reached through statistic processing of these values. Such an approach may be adopted in the framework of this study as well in order to obtain information on the time allocated by the citizens/businesses across the countries under examination on interactions with public administration; however in this case it is suggested that the relevant information, expressed in linguistic terms, is converted to fuzzy numbers to be further processed. As a consequence, this section describes how fuzzy sets theory can be exploited and thus how fuzzy numbers can be extracted so as to model the time required for the completion of a public service. In this frame, the latter is generally defined as the time required for a citizen to obtain information on a specific service, collect—if applicable—the documents necessary for his request to be served, and finally submit either in person or electronically his personal data along with any documents to the responsible public agency so that his request can be processed. Such a definition is quite generic to cover all different services, independently of their outputs, and presupposes furthermore for simplicity reasons that the e-government Web site providing a public service is always available and characterized by low response time as well as that citizens/businesses can access e-public services, if the latter are available. At this point, attention must be drawn to the fact that even if time is a countable quantity, it is considered extremely difficult or even impossible to record accurately the time spent by the citizens/businesses for interactions with public administration; people cannot be constantly monitored and neither can they provide with absolute precision the necessary information when asked to do so. The use of fuzzy instead of crisp numbers is therefore suggested as a means of ensuring that the uncertainty factor that is innate in subjective estimations is incorporated into the analysis and more reliable results are produced. For its ability to handle the fuzziness or subjectivity involved in numerous problems, fuzzy set theory and consequently fuzzy numbers has been applied in various similar or different evaluation contexts
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
101
(Fasanghari & Habibipour, 2009; Kahraman, Demirel, Demirel, & Ate, 2008; Lu, Ruan, & Zhang, 2008; Wu, Tsai, Shih, & Fu, 2010). In the context of the proposed framework, the citizens and businesses may evaluate each one of the pre-selected package of services (“basket of services”), the use of which is suggested for practical reasons, in terms of the time they spend on transactions with public administration using either conventional or e-services, based on a qualitative seven-level scale of linguistic variables that range from “Very Low” to “Very High.” To exclude the factor of subjectivity involved, due to the fact that different people may have a different understanding of expressions such as “Very Low,” “Low,” etc., an indication of the respective amount of time, defined according to the personal experience of the designer of the survey, may also be provided. For the purposes of this study, the authors have used the conversion scales presented in Table 5.4. The latter shows the equivalence between the linguistic variables and the respective fuzzy sets for both citizen and business services. Of course, since the services that are addressed to businesses are in general more time consuming, the relevant scale involves significantly larger amounts of time. Note that all values in Table 5.4 indicate time measured in minutes.
Table 5.4 Relations between linguistics and fuzzy numbers Citizens
Businesses
Linguistic
Abbreviation
Fuzzy set
Fuzzy number
Fuzzy set
Fuzzy number
Very low Low Medium low Medium Medium high High Very high
VL L ML M MH H VH
1–20 10–30 20–40 30–50 40–60 50–70 60–80
(1,10,20) (10,20,30) (20,30,40) (30,40,50) (40,50,60) (50,60,70) (60,70,80)
1–50 25–75 50–100 75–125 100–150 125–175 150–200
(1,25,50) (25,50,75) (50,75,100) (75,100,125) (100,125,150) (125,150,175) (150,175,200)
In this way a citizen may describe, for example, the amount of time required to obtain a birth certificate, using the respective e-service, as “very low,” which means that the time needed does not exceed 20 min and it is approximately around 10 min. The concept of fuzziness is expressed through the term “approximately.” Using the selected conversion scale, such observations obtained from questionnaires for both conventional and e-services are to be transformed into fuzzy numbers and average values are to be calculated for each one of the pre-selected public services. A frequency has to be assigned to each service as well, providing an indication of the number of times that the service is used during a specific period of time. The exact use of the frequency value assigned to each service will be explained in the next section, where the authors define the evaluation metrics.
102
O.I. Markaki et al.
4.1 Forming the Time Matrices As already indicated in the previous paragraph, questionnaires could have been deployed in the frame of this study in order to obtain information on the time allocated by the citizens/businesses on interactions with public administration. Nevertheless, the conduction of a survey across the Balkans would present certain difficulties that would be mainly generated by the large geographical area to be covered as well as by the heterogeneity of the selected public services across the countries under examination and the variance of the relevant service delivery methods. Due to this fact and also based on the assumption that a specific service that possesses the same level of sophistication in two or more different countries shall not differ significantly as far as transaction time is concerned, the authors present in this paragraph a mapping of the estimated transaction time for each one of the selected services per sophistication stage; Tables 5.5 and 5.6 aggregate the estimated average transaction time per sophistication stage for citizen and business services, respectively, expressed in linguistic terms. At this point, attention must be drawn to the fact that the relevant values have been determined based on the authors’ background and personal experience and that the former assumption has solely been made for simplicity reasons, since normally, even if a specific service possessed the same sophistication stage in two or more different countries, the corresponding transaction time would differ slightly as a result of the impact of other factors, such as the complexity of the internal administrative procedures or the variance of the relevant service delivery methods. Of course, as already stated, the relevant estimations could have been extracted through the use of questionnaires. Table 5.5 Time matrix for citizens
CS1 CS2 CS3 CS4 CS5 CS6 CS7 CS8 CS9 CS10 CS11 CS12
Conventional Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Stage 4
Stage 5
High High Very high Very high High High Medium high Medium Medium High High Low
Medium high Medium high Medium high High Medium high Medium high Medium Medium low Medium low Medium Medium high Low
Medium Medium low Medium low Medium low Medium Medium Low Very low Medium low Low Medium low Very low
Very low Very low Low Very low Low Low – Very low Very low Very low Low Very low
Very low – Very low – – – – Very low – – – –
High Medium high High Very high Medium high High Medium Medium low Medium Medium high Medium high Low
In order to render clearer the use of the matrices below, the reader may consider the following example. Assuming that CS1 (income taxes: declaration, notification of assessment) in Bulgaria has reached the second level of sophistication maturity, the time allocated by the citizens on the relevant transaction may be considered,
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
103
Table 5.6 Time matrix for businesses
BS1 BS2 BS3 BS4 BS5 BS6 BS7 BS8
Conventional
Stage 1
Stage 2
Stage 3
Stage 4
Stage 5
Medium Very high High Medium Medium Medium low Medium Very high
Medium low Very high Medium high Medium low Medium Low Medium low Very high
Low High Medium Low Low Low Low High
Very low Medium high Medium Very low Low Very low Low Medium high
Very low Medium Medium low Very low Very low Very low Very low Medium high
– – – – Very low – Very low –
according to Table 5.5, as “Medium high,” which corresponds to 40–60 min, according to Table 5.4.
5 Evaluation Metrics As already stated in Sect. 1, the aim of this chapter is to examine the impact and adoption of e-government services across some countries of the Balkans. In this context, building on the elementary concept of the time allocated on transactions with public administration and taking as well into account the current sophistication stage of online public services, the authors introduce a series of metrics to evaluate i. e-government services in terms of the benefits that their use involves for citizens/businesses as opposed to the use of conventional methods and ii. the actual adoption (take-up) of e-government services. Following the classification of public services in the respective categories, the evaluation metrics are defined for both citizens and businesses and refer to the real impacts that technology brings about in the improvement of the relationship between the state and the aforementioned stakeholders; they provide an indication of the impact of the modernization of public administration on the improvement of citizens’ quality of life and the businesses’ productivity and competitiveness, respectively. The three metrics in question are presented in the following paragraphs along with their mathematical definitions.
5.1 Average Gained Time I The evaluation of the impact of the modernization of public administration with regard to the benefits that the utilization of e-services involves for citizens/businesses as opposed to the use of traditional methods is performed in terms of
104
O.I. Markaki et al.
the time that citizens/businesses save because of the implementation of the relevant transactions with e-services. A composite indicator, called average gained time I, representing the time (%) that citizens/businesses may gain exploiting the current sophistication stage of eservices as opposed to conventional methods is suggested in this frame and is defined as follows: AGTI = 100%
ATcs − APTs ATcs
(1)
where ATcs , is the weighted mean time required per service using conventional services and is calculated as: n i=1 fi ti,c (2) ATcs = n i=1 fi and APTs is the weighted mean time potentially required per service exploiting the current sophistication stage, being calculated as follows: n i=1 fi ti,s APTs = n i=1 fi
(3)
Note that ti c and ti s are fuzzy numbers,extracted after applying the selected conversion scale and cover the pre-selected services, and fi are the corresponding frequencies assigned to the latter. Of course, in case of prior use of questionnaires, the former fuzzy numbers correspond also to the mean values, calculated using the received sample of observations.
5.2 Average Gained Time II The sophistication of online public services is indicated, as already mentioned in Section 2, with regard to the maximum level of sophistication for each specific service. That means that if the sophistication stage that is currently available is not equivalent to the maximum one defined, there is still the potential for greater improvement with regard to the maturity-level e-government services. As a result, we assume the optimal scenario of fully transactional services to provide a quantitative indication of the benefits of the implementation of the relevant transactions exclusively via e-means as well. In this case, the metric in question is referred to as average gained time II, represents the average time (%) that citizens/businesses could potentially gain, in case there were fully transactional services, and is defined as AGTII = 100%
APTs − APTfs APTs
(4)
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
105
where APTs is calculated as above and APTf s is the average time potentially required if there was full e-case handling. As it is assumed that not all public services of the pre-selected package may have reached a stage of transactional maturity, APTf s can only be calculated using the subset of services, for which Stage 4 or 5 is defined as the maximum sophistication level APTfs =
n i=1 fi ti , f s n i=1 fi
, ∀i : Si ∈ (Stage4 ∪ Stage5 )
(5)
Both the above compound indicators may be of great strategic and political significance, since their estimation concerns the general political planning of public administration.
5.3 Average Gained Time III The last evaluation metric of the analysis refers to the evaluation of the actual utilization of e-government services by the citizens/businesses. The goal this time is to estimate the average time (%) that citizens/businesses could potentially save exploiting the current sophistication stage, which however is left unexploited since not all of them make use of e-services and even if they do, they do not necessarily exploit the maximum sophistication stage that is currently available. The metric in question is referred to as average gained time III and may be defined as: AGTIII = 100%
ARTs − APTs ARTs
(6)
where APTs is calculated as above and ARTs , which denotes the actual mean time that is currently allocated by the citizens/businesses on their interactions with public administration, may be determined using relevant statistical information, i.e., the percentage of citizens/businesses that actually benefit from the available sophistication level of a service. Assuming that si (Stagei ) denotes the subset of services that have currently reached the ith stage of sophistication, we define the average real time per service as 1 ARTs = n=4 i=0
Fi
F0 · T0 +
n=4
m=i−1 , pj > pj+1 Fi · pi Ti + pj − pj+1 Tij + (1 − p1 ) Ti,c i=1
j=i
(7)
where Ti is the average time (weighted mean) required for the completion of an i-stage service; Tji is the average time required for the completion of an i-stage service when exploiting the jth (a lower) level of sophistication; Ti,c is the average time required for the completion of an i-stage service with traditional methods; and Fi is the frequency assigned to the ith sophistication stage, as Fi = nk=1 fk , ∀k : sk ∈ Stagei .
106
O.I. Markaki et al.
We also assume that stage i is the maximum stage that is being used by percentage pi of citizens/businesses. In Eq. (7), pi Ti indicates that a percentage pi of citizens/businesses exploit the maximum sophistication stage available and spend m=i−1 (pj − therefore Ti time for the completion of an i-stage service. The sum j=1 pj+1 )Ti, j denotes the time allocated on transactions with the public authorities by the rest of the citizens/businesses who make use of e-government services but do not exploit the maximum sophistication stage offered. Finally, a percentage (1 − p1 ) of citizens/businesses do not rely on e-services at all and therefore the time they spend is (1 − p1 )Ti,c .
5.4 Defuzzification As already implied, all the aforementioned metrics are fuzzy numbers. Given two ˜ B˜ is fuzzy numbers A˜ = (a1 , a2 , a3 ) and B˜ = (b1 , b2 , b3 ), the fuzzy number B˜ − A/ calculated based on operations on triangular fuzzy numbers as B˜ − A˜ = B˜
b1 − a3 b2 − a2 b3 − a1 , , b3 b2 b1
Although this equation possesses mathematical correctness, the values (fuzzy numbers) resulting from its calculation have no physical sense (in fact the lower limit values may even be negative in some cases) and have to be converted to crisp values first so as to allow for useful conclusions to be drawn. In order therefore to obtain the average gained time, a defuzzification method has to be applied. In this study, both the bisector of area (BOA) and center of gravity (COG) defuzzification methods were applied with BOA providing more moderate results (compared to COG) and thus being adopted to obtain the final crisp numbers based on which comparisons among the countries were made.
6 E-government Adoption Across the Balkans 6.1 Sophistication Stage of Services In this section the proposed evaluation framework is applied for Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia using the basket of 20 basic public services for citizens and businesses that has been composed by Capgemini for the European Commission. The services under evaluation along with their sophistication stage, as this is defined in the latest version of the corresponding e-government factsheet of each country (ePractice, 2009a, b, c, d, e), are summarized in Tables 5.7 and 5.8. Tables 5.9 and 5.10 present the actual utilization of e-government services per sophistication stage, according to Eurostat (2008). Note that as far as citizen services are concerned, since no information is available on the use of fully transactional services (Stages 4 and 5), we assume that the corresponding utilization percentage is
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
107
Table 5.7 Sophistication stage for five countries—citizen services
CS1 CS2 CS3 CS4 CS5 CS6 CS7 CS8 CS9 CS10 CS11 CS12 Date Version
Bulgaria
Greece
Hungary
Romania
Slovenia
Frequency
5/5 4/4 4/5 1/4 1/4 1/4 1/3 1/5 2/4 2/4 0/4 2/4 February 2009 v6
5/5 4/4 1/5 1/4 4/4 1/4 1/3 3/5 4/4 2/4 2/4 2/4 July 2009 v12
4/5 4/4 2/5 2/4 3/4 1/4 3/3 3/5 3/4 4/4 3/4 0/4 March 2009 v11
2/5 4/4 2/5 1/4 2/4 1/4 1/3 1/5 – 1/4 1/4 2/4 May 2009 v6
5/5 4/4 4/5 4/4 4/4 4/4 3/3 5/5 4/4 4/4 4/4 4/4 June 2009 v12
30 18 115 7 4 1 8 90 10 1 2 90
Table 5.8 Sophistication stage for five countries—business services
BS1 BS2 BS3 BS4 BS5 BS6 BS7 BS8 Date Version
Bulgaria
Greece
Hungary
Romania
Slovenia
Frequency
3/4 3/4 3/4 2/4 2/5 3/4 1/5 2/4 February 2009 v6
4/4 4/4 4/4 2/4 4/5 4/4 2/5 2/4 July 2009 v12
2/4 4/4 4/4 3/4 5/5 4/4 3/5 2/4 March 2009 v11
4/4 4/4 4/4 3/4 5/5 4/4 2/5 4/4 May 2009 v6
4/4 4/4 4/4 4/4 5/5 4/4 5/5 2/4 June 2009 v12
12 1 4 1 2 5 2 6
Table 5.9 Utilization percentage per sophistication stage—citizen services Utilization percentage (%) Sophistication stage
Bulgaria
Greece
Hungary
Romania
Slovenia
Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 Stage 4,5
6.4 4.6 3.2 0.0
8.8 4.0 3.6 0.0
22.2 17.1 11.1 0.0
8.5 3.6 3.2 0.0
29.2 16.1 6.7 0.0
equal to zero. Note also that, based on the data provided by Eurostat, it is not possible to distinguish between Stages 4 and 5, therefore for the calculation of metric AGTIII , the latter are treated as a single stage (which is referred to as Stages 4 and 5). The time values for Stages 4 and 5, which correspond to full e-case handling, are calculated as the weighted mean of the two separate stages.
108
O.I. Markaki et al. Table 5.10 Utilization percentage per sophistication stage—business services Utilization percentage (%) Sophistication stage
Bulgaria
Greece
Hungary
Romania
Slovenia
Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 Stage 4,5
53 51 43 36
68 66 66 53
56 58 50 25
37 35 23 20
85 82 69 60
The frequency assigned to each service corresponds to the number of times that a specific service is used during a certain period of time. For citizens we have chosen this period to be equal to 30 years, while for businesses 1 year. Note that since a comparison is sought, we have maintained the same frequency values for all countries. If that was not the case, countries with identical sophistication stages for all services would present different results solely due to the use of different frequency values, which would not reflect correctly the impact of e-services.
6.2 Citizen Services In this paragraph, the evaluation methodology is applied for 12 services for citizens in the five selected countries. Note that once the three evaluation metrics have been calculated, using the fuzzy numbers that derive from the combination of Tables 5.5 and 5.7, the goal is to produce (through BOA) for each proposed metric a crisp value. Since the calculating process is the same for all the countries under examination, the intermediary results are presented only indicatively for the case of Slovenia in Table 5.11. The latter contains the fuzzy and corresponding crisp values of all metrics for the specific county (Slovenia). Note that the first four lines of the last column are left blank, since there is no point in providing crisp values for the intermediary results. The final results are aggregated for all five countries in Table 5.12.
Table 5.11 Fuzzy and crisp values of the evaluation metrics for the case of Slovenia (citizen services)
ATcs APTs APTfs ARTs AGTI AGTII AGTIII
L
M
U
Crisp values (%)
38.1383 4.279255 4.10102 27.64711 24.93138 –80.6385 9.27007
48.1383 13.6436 13.3983 35.4172 71.65746 1.798059 61.47745
58.1383 23.64362 23.34511 43.18733 141.2204 456.6822 140.731
78 61 76
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
109
Table 5.12 Synopsis of the evaluation metrics for the selected countries (citizen services) Crisp values (%)
AGTI AGTII AGTIII
Bulgaria
Greece
Hungary
Romania
Slovenia
57 68 57
43 74 42
50 71 47
32 78 31
78 61 76
6.3 Business Services Similarly, the evaluation methodology is applied here for the selected basket of business services in the five countries of interest. In this case, the fuzzy numbers used to calculate the evaluation metrics have been acquired through Tables 5.6 and 5.8. Once again, the intermediary results are provided only for the case of Slovenia in Table 5.13, and the final results for all countries are collected in Table 5.14. Table 5.13 Fuzzy and crisp values of the evaluation metrics for the case of Slovenia (business services)
ATcs APTs APTfs ARTs AGTI AGTII AGTIII
L
M
U
Crisp values (%)
93.18182 31.72727 9.580645 44.63343 8.465608 –25.5267 –56.8159
118.182 56.0606 30.6452 54.3739 52.5641 45.33566 –3.10205
143.1818 81.06061 52.41935 64.11437 119.6098 225.295 72.56242
59 45 42
Table 5.14 Synopsis of the evaluation metrics for the selected countries (business services) Crisp values (%)
AGTI AGTII AGTIII
Bulgaria
Greece
Hungary
Romania
Slovenia
51 46 40
57 45 42
44 46 40
61 46 55
59 45 42
6.4 Discussion The results for AGTI in Tables 5.12 and 5.14 indicate that thanks to the current sophistication stage, there is for citizens and businesses a gain with regard to transaction time, which is not negligible. In fact, as far as citizen services are concerned,
110
O.I. Markaki et al.
Slovenia, Bulgaria, and Hungary have made, as seen in Table 5.12, significant progress in the field of e-government transformation such that it enables their citizens to potentially save more than 50% of the time they spend on transactions with the public authorities, by exploiting the sophistication stage of online public services that is currently available. Presenting an overall sophistication maturity level that corresponds to fully transactional services, Slovenia keeps the leadership among the selected countries toward this direction (78%), while Romania still lags behind with a gain of only 31%. The results seem to be more homogeneous in the case of business services. In this case, the highest percentages are held by Romania and Slovenia (∼60%), and only Hungary possesses for the specific indicator in question a value that is lower than 50%. It is also remarkable that especially for Bulgaria, Hungary, and Slovenia, the citizens are “favored” perceptibly, compared to businesses, while another interesting observation is the fact that Romania, possessing the lowest value of AGTI for citizen services, demonstrates the highest percentage for business services, which indicates the country’s e-government strategy orientation as well as the necessity for the authorities responsible to encourage citizens in using e-services in their everyday life. As far as the second evaluation metric, i.e., AGTII , is concerned, one may state that the relevant percentages (Tables 5.12 and 5.14) illustrate in an explicit way that the actual benefits of e-government transformation are located in the upper stages of sophistication. These percentages indicate the resulting time savings in case all services had reached the highest possible level of sophistication as opposed to the current situation. At this point, attention has to be drawn to the fact that through AGTII , the average gained time in case of fully transactional services is rendered as a percentage of the time allocated by the citizens/businesses on interactions with public administration when exploiting the current sophistication stage. On the other hand, AGTI is estimated as a fraction of the equivalent time using conventional methods, which explains why the sum of these values is not equal to 100%. However, there is still a cross-correlation between the two metrics, since countries with a higher value for AGTI possess a lower value for AGTII , as they do not have major opportunities for improvement. The value of AGTIII incorporates the actual utilization of e-government services and expresses the amount of transaction time, which remains unexploited by the citizens/businesses due to limited use of online public services, as a fraction of the actual mean time that is allocated on the relevant transactions. The values of this metric are high for both citizen and business services and provide strong evidence that, especially in the former case, the authorities responsible should take into account the information and technology literacy of citizens as well as the challenges they encounter with regard to the use of e-government services due to physical impairments. It is not the case that all citizens are familiar with computing and Internet-based technologies nor does the design of e-government Web sites currently encompass all different disability types (associated with aging, visual, auditory, speech, motor, and cognitive deficiencies). Furthermore, issues related to security and privacy continue to be a challenge; users must be confident that the Web sites they visit and transactions they complete are safeguarded against theft, fraud,
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
111
and unauthorized access. Such an aspect is also crucial in business transactions, where financial data are often exchanged. The percentage of AGTIII is particularly high in the case of Slovenia for citizen services, which is quite impressive since, as already mentioned, this country possesses among the selected ones the leadership with regard to the overall sophistication maturity of online public services and presents as well higher utilization percentages per sophistication stage. More specifically, the values of AGTIII for citizen services (Table 5.12) reveal that Slovenia and Bulgaria (>50%) can contribute significantly in the improvement of their citizens’ quality of everyday life, by encouraging them to adopt the use of e-services. On the other hand, the rest of the countries have to focus more on upgrading the basket of services they offer, since an increase in the number of people actually using e-government services would not be enough by itself to bring major improvements, due to the low level of sophistication. With the exception of Romania, the values of AGTIII for business services are in general lower than the ones for citizen services. Of course, this fact was anticipated, given that the utilization percentages for businesses in Table 5.10 are fairly higher than the respective ones for citizens in Table 5.9, suggesting that already a remarkable number of businesses have embraced the use of e-public services. Romania presents an enhancement capacity of 55%, while for the rest of the countries the corresponding percentage is around 40%. As a concluding remark, one could state that the countries under examination have to continue to make sound progress on the supply of online public services, while also putting effort to engaging their citizens into their use. In general, businesses appear better served and more suitably engaged. However, still much remains to be done to serve citizens who are increasingly exposed to and versed in e-services. As a result, the challenge for the aforementioned countries, as for most countries across the world, is to deliver an e-government service experience that attracts and fulfills citizens’ needs efficiently and effectively and reaffirms trust in public services.
7 Future Research Directions The goal of this chapter has been to provide a generic framework that can be used to assess the e-government services implemented by a country. The indicators presented are of great strategic and political value since their calculation reveals the actual impact of e-government transformation for citizens and businesses; the impact is in fact expressed in terms of the time gained through e-services within the frame of transactions with public authorities, which constitutes a comprehensible and tangible benefit for both citizens/businesses and policy makers. Special attention was paid in the frame of the evaluation analysis to address the issue of imprecision in the estimations involved with regard to transaction time and to form solid comparisons.
112
O.I. Markaki et al.
Of course, the framework could be further enhanced and optimized: potential enhancements could be achieved through the creation of more appropriate conversion scales, and consequently fuzzy sets that best suit the information collected. Another aspect would be to carry out a more thorough study on the transaction time that corresponds to each one of the selected services for both citizens and businesses per sophistication stage. A suitable perspective for reaching this goal would be to conduct a questionnaire-based survey across the countries under examination. Further enhancements could be based on the consideration, instead of the time, of different measurement units, such as the cost involved in the relevant transactions or the usefulness perceived by the citizens/businesses as a result of the public administration modernization. It would also be interesting to study the evolution of the proposed metrics across the years, so as to reach useful conclusions especially with regard to the fluctuation of the actual utilization of e-government services. Finally, in case of more accurate information on transaction times, it would be meaningful to compare the average time required per service using conventional services to the equivalent one in case of full e-case handling, so as to provide a quantitative indication of the total impact of e-government transformation.
8 Conclusions This chapter proposed an evaluation framework to project some aspects of the impact of the modernization of public administration on the citizens’ quality of life and the businesses’ efficiency through the adoption of a series of metrics with regard to the time required for the completion of transactions with the public authorities. The framework was applied for the EU member states of Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Romania, and Slovenia, allowing for interesting conclusions to be drawn. In fact, the evaluation analysis pointed out that the benefits associated with e-government transformation are partially counterbalanced by the fact that only a small fraction of the population makes use of e-services and suggested that effort should be put in raising public awareness around e-government services so that both citizens and businesses realize the envisaged e-government benefits.
References Abhichandani, T., & Horan, T. A. (2006). Toward a new evaluation model of e-government satisfaction: Results of structural equation modeling. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 12th Americas Conference on Information Systems, (AMCIS 2006), Acapulco, Mexico August 04th–06th 2006. Capgemini (2007). The user challenge: Benchmarking the supply of online public services, 7th measurement, September 2007. Retrieved 20 March 2009, from http://ec.europa. eu/information_society/eeurope/i2010/docs/benchmarking/egov_benchmark_2007.pdf Colesca, S. E., & Liliana, D. (2007). e-Government adoption in Romania. International Journal of Business, Economics, Finance and Management Science, 1(2), 121–125.
5
Impact and Adoption of E-government Services in the Balkans
113
Commission of the European Communities (2002). eEurope 2005: An information society for all, COM (2002) 263 final, Brussels, 28.5.2002. Retrieved 15 September 2009, from http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/eeurope/2002/news_library/documents/ eeurope2005/eeurope2005_en.pdf Commission of the European Communities (2005). i2010 – A European information society for growth and employment, COM (2005) 229 final, Brussels, 1.6.2005. Retrieved 15 September 2009, from http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri= COM:2005:0229:FIN:EN:PDF Dobnikar, A., & Nemec, A. Ž. (2007). e-Government in Slovenia. Informatica, 31, 357– 365. ePractice (2009a). eGovernment factsheets – Bulgaria. Edition 7.0, August 2009. Retrieved 10 September 2009, from http://www.epractice.eu/en/factsheets/ ePractice (2009b). eGovernment factsheets – Greece. Edition 12.0, July 2009. Retrieved 10 September 2009, from http://www.epractice.eu/en/factsheets/ ePractice (2009c). eGovernment factsheets – Hungary. Edition 12.0, September 2009. Retrieved 10 September 2009, from http://www.epractice.eu/en/factsheets/ ePractice (2009d). eGovernment factsheets – Romania. Edition 6.0, May 2009. Retrieved 10 September 2009, from http://www.epractice.eu/en/factsheets/ ePractice (2009e). eGovernment factsheets – Slovenia. Edition 12.0, June 2009. Retrieved 10 September 2009, from http://www.epractice.eu/en/factsheets/ Erzsébet, C.-V. (2002, January). e-Government programme in Hungary. ERCIM NEWS No. 48. Retrieved 11 September 2009, from http://www.ercim.org/publication/Ercim_News/ enw48/varju.html Eurostat Home (2008). Information society: Structural indicators. Retrieved 30 December 2008, from http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu Fasanghari, M., & Habibipour, F. (2009). E-Government performance evaluation with fuzzy numbers. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 2009 IACSIT Spring Conference (IACSIT-SC 09), Singapore, pp. 231–235.doi: 10.1109/IACSIT-SC.2009.122. Greek Observatory (2008). Indicators for the quantification of G.S.P.A & E.G.’s objectives with regard to eGovernment. The use of Information and Communication Technologies in the Public Sector (eGovernment). Retrieved 18 March 2009, from http://www.observe.gr/files/meletes/eGov_D6_Indicators_EN_v1.0.pdf Hahamis, P., Iles, J., & Healy, M. (2005). e-Government in Greece: Opportunities for improving the efficiency and effectiveness of local government. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 5th European Conference on e-Government (ECEG 2005), 16–17 June 2005, Antwerp, Belgium, pp. 203–212. Hubregtse, S. (2005). The digital divide within the European Union. New Library World, 106(1210/1211), 164–172. Kahraman, C., Demirel, N. C., Demirel, T., & Ate, N. Y. (2008). A SWOT-AHP application using fuzzy concept: E-Government in Turkey. Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision Making, 85–117. doi: 10.1007/978-0-387-76813-7_4. Lu, J., Ruan, D., & Zhang, G. (2008). Fuzzy set techniques in E-service applications. Fuzzy Sets and Their Extensions: Representation, Aggregation and Models, 220/2008, 553–566, Springer Berlin/Heidelberg. doi: 10.1007/978-3-540-73723-0. Markoulakis, N. (2005, October). e-Government in Greece. GPSG Article #002. Retrieved 11 September 2009, from http://www.gpsg.org.uk/docs/Article_002.pdf Panopoulou, E., Tambouris, E., & Tarabanis, K. (2008). A framework for evaluating web sites of public authorities. Aslib Proceedings: New Information Perspectives, 60(5), 517–546. doi: 10.1108/00012530810908229. Wang, L., Bretschneider, S., & Gant, J. (2005). Evaluating web-based e-government services with a citizen-centric approach. Paper presented at the Proceedings of the 38th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS’05), Big Island, Hawaii, January, 3-6, 2005, 5, 129b. doi: 10.1109/HICSS.2005.252.
114
O.I. Markaki et al.
Wauters, P. (2006). Benchmarking e-government policy within the e-Europe programme. Aslib Proceedings: New Information Perspectives, 58(5), 389–403, Emerald Group Publishing Limited. doi: 10.1108/00012530610692348. Wu, J. C. -T., Tsai, H. -T., Shih, M. -H., & Fu, H. -H. (2010). Government performance evaluation using a balanced scorecard with a fuzzy linguistic scale. The Service Industries Journal, 30(3), 449–462. doi: 10.1080/02642060802248017. Zadeh, L. A. (1965). Fuzzy sets. Information and Control, 8, 338–353.
Chapter 6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road: Lessons Learned from E-governments in China and India Alankar Bandyopadhyay and Sahar D. Sattarzadeh
Recent experiments from around the world have offered testimony to the relevance of information and communication technologies (ICTs) in disseminating and simplifying the delivery of government-to-citizen services. Even in developing countries, successful e-government service delivery can, achieve three vital objectives—transparency, accessibility, and development. China and India are the first and second most populous nations in the world, respectively, accounting for over 37% of the world’s total population. Both countries are characterized by urban–rural disparities, income gaps, and inequalities in access of essential services. Toward the goal of bridging these divides in access to the government or its services, ICT opportunities for development are being explored by extensively implementing e-government networks within urban and rural regions. However, both successes and failures are prevalent within their current e-government infrastructures. This chapter probes the question of what determines a project’s success, using Heeks’ “DesignReality Gap” model and infoDev’s criteria for successful e-government projects. An analysis is attempted of two e-government projects each in China and India. The authors’ analyses are solely based on secondary sources from practitioners, scholars, and governments that were involved with the projects in China or India. This chapter aims to emphasize the necessary role of underlying factors relevant to Indian and Chinese e-governments, such as education, funding, connectivity, leadership, and governmental control. In the absence of these factors, it is expected that success might be elusive.
A. Bandyopadhyay (B) University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA e-mail:
[email protected] S.D. Sattarzadeh University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, USA e-mail:
[email protected] C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_6, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
115
116
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
1 Introduction Beginning with the late 1990s, e-government has become the exhortation for public sector reform. It is broadly understood as the use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) to simplify the delivery of government services by making them more simple and accessible (APDIP, 2006; Bhatnagar, 2003; infoDev, 2002). It is a mechanism by which government services are produced and delivered through IT means. Today there exists, numerous examples where governments have invested in creating an online presence. The premise to these experiments is that if implemented appropriately, the integration of ICTs with the day-to-day functioning of the government has great potential in enhancing and improving organizational efficiency and effectiveness. Simultaneously, however, it is evident that e-government does not simply signify an online government presence. Rather, it implies that ICTs provide the opportunity for improvement in the efficiency and effectiveness of how governments are run, thus also transforming the political climate as well as relations between governments and citizens. Additionally, it is predicted that an online public sector would become a cost-effective way of achieving socially inclusive governance, through the facilitation of information dissemination and the opportunity for feedback. Undoubtedly, e-governments also offer governments an opportunity to overturn their often-negative image. In many countries, citizens view their governments as bloated, wasteful, and unresponsive to the needs of its populace (PCIP, 2002). Those that reside in remote areas perceive the government as inaccessible and unapproachable. Skepticism is evident among the business community that views the government with doubt and is not convinced about its capabilities and views civil servants as profiteers (PCIP, 2002). Ho (2002, p. 435) quoting Scavo and Shi (1999) and Seneviratne (1999) observes that with the advent of ICTs, the focus of governance has shifted to its external relationship with citizens. He argues that public administration, and perhaps its image, is undergoing a metamorphosis instigated by technology tools and the Internet. Countries that have afforded the blend with technology have done so partly in the belief that the tools would enable them to become more accessible, accountable, transparent, and efficient. The direct and tangible advantages of e-government include cost effectiveness in public operations, tax collection, simplified communication between governmental entities, and prolonged engagement and interaction with citizens. Indirect benefits comprise greater transparency and accountability in public decisions, a means to fight corruption, and strengthening democracy (infoDev, 2002). The evidence in favor of e-government points toward its ability to impact citizens, businesses, and other governmental departments and organizations. However, the effectiveness of the impact and the success of e-government are dependent on a host of factors that are unique to the context; stakeholder needs; and political, social, and economic climate. The enthusiasm surrounding e-government projects has manifested in both developed and developing countries making considerable financial commitments in ICT-led developmental efforts. By 2003, approximately 90 countries had functional
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
117
national e-strategies with e-government as the most common focus. The emerging economies of China and India have spearheaded efforts across the developing world. However, while success has been a tricky affair, generalizability between project sites is almost non-existent. The complexity is further aggravated on account of country-specific characteristics, which inhibits the transfer of best practices. However, what is emerging from the various e-governments across the world is a checklist of factors that are imperative pre-requisites to success. It is becoming increasingly obvious that success would depend on how the government works, how its officials perceive their jobs, and interact with the citizens. A positive outcome would depend on active, meaningful, and functional partnerships with the various stakeholders, which would in turn ensure a constant process of input, output, and feedback (PCIP, 2002).
2 Role in Development Before addressing how e-government contributes to development, it is important to understand the link between e-government and development. Since the implementation of e-government is dependent upon the ICT resources available, consideration of ICT for development is just as vital to address. First and foremost, however, we must explore what is meant by development. Indicators of human development are true reflections of a country’s overall development, taking into account economic, political, democratic, social, and cultural progress. The World Bank and several UN agencies and regional commissions have been key proponents of utilizing ICT for socioeconomic progress and international development, especially within developing nations. Vrasidas et al. (2009) take it a step further by arguing that ICT, “if critically and strategically approached,” has the likelihood of promoting development and social justice, especially in the education sector, for example. There are various areas where indicators of ICT for overall human development is achievable (Kelles-Vitanen, 2003; Mansell & Wehn, 1998), especially with regards to indicators of health, education, governance, democratic participation, and the like. Despite the numerous critics who warn about the risks of e-government in developing countries, there have also been several successful cases of e-government implementation in Argentina, Brazil, Chile, China, India, and the Philippines, for example (Ndou, 2004). Based on her case study research, Ndou also found regardless of which stage of development a country is in, they all benefit from e-government in the following ways: – – – – – – –
There is an increase in efficiency and a reduction of costs. The quality of service delivery improves. Issues of transparency, anticorruption, and accountability take precedence. The government’s capacity to serve citizens increases. Networks are created within communities across all levels of government. There is an improvement in decision-making processes. ICT use is encouraged and promoted in other sectors of society.
118
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
While e-government has its share of critics, there are proponents who praise the many benefits it has for the social, political, and economic development of emerging economies such as India and China. Some of these advantages are • E-government can offer numerous possibilities for improving a nation’s public sector response to the basic needs of its citizens. People always want information or services delivered quickly and easily. • Today, the governmental agencies are wanted to deliver “outcomes” and outputs, achieve better results for serving people’s various needs. This will involve agencies working more effectively across their traditional boundaries and collaborating with one another. • By fostering transparency, and empowering people to participate in the political processes, e-government will strengthen the legal system and law enforcement; make policy processes more open and consultative. • Under e-government projects, governments will minimize its intervention to business, on the one hand; and promote the development of priority economic sectors and regions, on the other hand. • It can improve the quality of life for vulnerable people and disadvantaged communities. • E-government will eventually transform the processes and structures of government to create a public administration regime with less hierarchical bureacracy, one that is citizen-centered and results-oriented.
3 Factors for a Successful E-government Categorizing outcomes into full failures, partial failures, and successes, analysts (Heeks, 2003) concluded that only 15% of e-government projects succeed in developing or transitional economies. Of the remaining, approximately 50 and 35% of the projects are either partial or full failures. Total failure refers to the failure of a proposed reform to ever take-off. Partial, on the other hand, refers to a situation where only a subset of the intended reform is implemented. The daunting question is what causes a project to fail. Hypothesizing on the reasons, researchers conclude that the cause is partly due to the overemphasis on the “technology” aspect of e-government. Projects are apparently conceived either without a clear understanding of the issue in hand or with the purpose of addressing immediate problems without analyzing deep-rooted causes (De, 20051 ). Some of the crucial factors for success emerging from the various experiments conducted across developing countries include having a clear vision, plan, 1 The impact of Indian e-government initiatives: issues of poverty and vulnerability reduction, and conflict. Name of Journal: Regional Development Dialogue, 2005, UNCRD and UNDP.
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
119
and scope, designing a citizen-centric delivery mechanism, ensuring complete stakeholder participation, willingness on the part of government officials to undergo change, and the need for strong leadership and management. Further, in the backdrop of high costs and constant risks, a prudent approach to integrating ICTs into the day-to-day functioning of the government is to be practical and cautious. An over ambitious project entails too many stakeholders and increases the risks involved. Thus, the emphasis is on identifying feasible goals, which partially minimizes the perils of failure.
3.1 infoDev and E-government in Developing Countries The E-government Handbook for Developing Countries (infoDev, 2002) consolidates the findings from several e-government projects across the world and highlights the commonalities in the factors for success. Dividing the implementation of e-government into three phases—publishing, interacting, and transacting, the handbook emphasizes that five factors integral to ensuring the successful transformation of offline governance into online are: • Process reform: The government must first gauge what processes need to be ICT-ized. The decision to integrate ICTs in certain aspects of government functioning must be driven by end-user needs. After all, the driving force behind ICT integration should be to rid the system of inefficiencies and redundancies than accentuating them. • Leadership: This factor stresses the need for a central agency that has the expertise, manpower, institutional authority, and vision to implement e-government. • Strategic investment: The government should choose projects that have the strongest ability to enhance transparency, citizen participation, diminish corruption, minimize complex, time-consuming bureaucratic procedures, and consider both cost-effectiveness and -feasibility. • Collaboration: The success of an e-government project is heavily dependent on strategic partnerships. The most important partnering sectors include other departments in the government, the private organizations, and nongovernmental organizations that can impact grassroots delivery. Further, successful e-government also requires adequate buy-in from those who are already in the system. There is constant apprehension from government employees that e-government jeopardizes their role in an organization. These concerns cannot be disregarded. On the contrary, the government must do enough to placate such concerns if they want e-government to succeed. • Civic engagement: If citizens are the singular focus of e-government projects, the design phase must accommodate what citizens envision or expect a project to deliver on.
120
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
3.2 Heeks’ Design-Reality Gap Model Heeks (2003) conceptualized the ITPOSMO framework, which is derived from the “Design-Reality Gap” model. Its broad purpose is to give a sense of what factors might inhibit the success of a project. Concentrating primarily on the design phase, Heeks suggests that undertaking such an analysis illustrates the risks a project might run into on account of the mismatches on each of the dimensions. The design gap is an outcome of the interaction of several factors, which lead us to the coinage of ITPOSMO: Information: The relevancy, currency, and accuracy of content Technical: The compatibility of the technology with processes Processes: Objectives, values, and motivations People: Objectives, values, and motivations People: Staffing and skills Management: How successfully are these changes managed? Other resources: Time and money Understanding the design-reality gap entails analyzing the organizational reality and the corresponding project design relating to each of the seven dimensions mentioned above. Following that, Heeks advises assigning a numerical rating that would capture this gap.
4 Case Studies on China and India China and India are different in their implementation of e-government projects. India’s approach until now has been primarily from the bottom up,2 with states taking the lead in implementation of projects. Initiatives in China, on the other hand, have been top-down,3 fully supported by a functional national e-government framework that conceptualizes, implements, and monitors initiatives across the country. India did not have a formal national framework for citizen-centric e-government initiatives until very recently, as national e-government efforts earlier were solely focused around defense, economic monitoring, planning, and deployment of IT to manage data-intensive services such as tax administration, elections, and censusrelated information. China, on the other hand, was driven by a national policy to implement e-government all across the country in gradual stages with the intention of digitizing the entire nation with a focus on areas such as commerce, tourism, and government transparency. This chapter examines four distinct projects—two in China and two in India. In China, Beijing and Nanhai are provincial and municipal
2 Where 3 Where
the effort is far more localized in nature. the effort is dictated by a central government.
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
121
e-government projects, respectively. While in India, both Bhoomi and Gyandoot are spearheaded by state governments.
4.1 China China has been connected to the Internet since 1994. Due to the government’s high motivation to expand economically, ICTs have been employed as popular outlets for networking, communicating, and disseminating information all across China. Both online activists and government officials alike have found the Internet to be a vital means of making their information accessible to the masses in rural and urban regions of the country. Like India, China had various ICT networks already in place prior to the establishment of any formal e-government system. While the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) was determined to control the Internet, it by no means included limiting the technology utilized in the country (Zhou, 2004). If anything, the government was determined to ensure that governments at the provincial, county, and municipal levels were all linked through and controlled by the country’s central government. The government believed that in order to continue developing the country, it was necessary to implement an e-government infrastructure nationally, which was catalyzed by the successful initiation of a few pilot projects for local governments within a select few highly populated, industrialized provinces and municipalities. China’s national e-government policy began in 1999 with the launching of the Government Online Project (GOP) by the State Economic and Trade Commission’s (SETC) Economic Information Center, over 40 government information offices, and China Telecom—the world’s largest ICT service provider and operator. The GOP was designed to be implemented in three progressive stages: (1) connecting 800–1,000 government offices and agencies to the Internet; (2) transferring information systems of government offices and agencies to an electronic format; and (3) ensure that government offices and agencies will become paperless (Lovelock & Ure, 2002). Prior to the public launching of China’s GOP, there were only 145 e-government sites online at the time. By 2002, the number of government sites online dramatically increased to 5864 (ICCCID Consulting Co., Ltd., 2009). The following section will address two special cases on “Digital Beijing,” where the provincial government has proven to implement an overall effective, successful e-government and Nanhai, a district where the e-government process evolved into something that became much more complicated than government officials had initially expected. 4.1.1 The Success of Beijing’s Business E-park Beijing, the capital city of China, began its “Digital Beijing” initiative in the year 2000. The Beijing Municipal Office of Informatization (BMOI) was initially responsible for the development and design of “Digital Beijing” and the Digital Olympics in 2008. As time progressed, an e-government for Beijing was soon to be the next
122
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
big project that BMOI would take on. Currently, Beijing’s e-government functions cover the citywide promotion of e-government, e-business, e-community, infosecurity, IT applications, and administration by provincial laws and standards set by the government. Beijing has approximately 4.5 million citizens in the province, and nearly 29% of Beijing has Internet coverage, accounting for the highest coverage nationwide. Beijing also has the first and second highest number of government domain and general domain names, respectively, in China, but it has been recognized as China’s model e-government ever since it was launched in 2006 (Yan, 2006). The provincial government has especially been committed to establishing an e-government that serves its thriving business sector. Zhongguancun E-park4 is a pilot project that applies the latest computer and Internet technologies to improve the efficiency and responsiveness of the government. Since the e-park system went online in 2000, more than 6,000 businesses in the Beijing hi-tech park of Zhongguancun have been able to apply for a license, file monthly financial reports, submit tax statements, and conduct 32 other “government to business” and “government to citizen” functions online. The e-park, therefore, very much aligned itself with infoDev’s key components of process reform and collaboration. The system has greatly increased government transparency and efficiency, and reduced the opportunities for corruption. The mayor of Beijing announced that in 5 years, most government administrative functions in the city would follow the online model of the e-park (Yan, 2006). The old system was more time-consuming and difficult for businesses to work with the government. There was a much longer wait time in registering and processing business forms, and all departments within the government’s commerce sector were completely independent of one another, so there was no systematic means of communication and resource allocation to efficiently meet the demands of citizens in a timely manner. These obstacles also burdened IT companies that catalyze the science and technology industries—that which the Chinese government believes is vital for the Chinese economy. In 2000, enterprises in the e-park generated a total of $12 billion in revenue and $200 million in foreign investments, significantly contributing to the nation’s economy (Yan, 2006). Therefore, the design and implementation of Beijing’s e-park was seen as prospective solution to such problems, resulting in an increase in interactivity, transparency, and efficiency. In addition to the successes of the e-park, its disadvantages are just as important to consider. However, in the case of Beijing, the problem of digitizing the government yields consequences that all governments will have to face—the replacement of human resources with computerized ones, thus leading to a significant number of job losses for many former government employees. Apparently, China already has a high unemployment rate, so the expansion of e-government systems throughout the country will only further aggravate the problem.
4 www.zhongguancun.com.cn
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
123
4.1.2 Nanhai’s District-Level E-government In 2001, the Chinese government chose Nanhai as the pilot city for e-government and “informatization” at the county level. In 2002, Nanhai was designated as a district by the central government due to its growth and expansion throughout the years. The population is over one million in number, and the area is well-known for its manufacturing and agricultural industries. In 1996, prior to its designation as a pilot e-government project, Nanhai started to build its first network infrastructure followed by the launch of the Nanhai Comprehensive Information Network (NCIN), resulting in the interconnection of all government departments and agencies within the city. Although Nanhai’s local ICT infrastructure and e-government developed rapidly, the application of e-government has found to been rather inadequate. Several employees still prefer working in the “real world” rather than utilizing e-government facilities. Computers are most often used for word processing and e-mail communications internally, but they still print paper files, rather than manage them electronically (Luo, 2009). In conducting interviews with Nanhai e-government employees, Luo (2009) discovered that less than 50% of government departments have effective online interactions with citizens and more than 30% of government Web sites do not update their information on a regular basis. Furthermore, since Nanhai’s government introduced ICTs into the local society, they have shifted their industry emphasis from traditional manufacturing to the emerging ICT industry, where some have expressed their anxiety about the industrial reconstruction under the central government’s control. According to Heeks (1999), e-government is a means to solve such problems and achieve efficiency, accountability, decentralization, and marketization. Although, Nanhai’s e-government officials reinvented the public administration structure through the aid of ICTs, the e-government greatly enhanced the direct supervision of top officials at the municipal level, thus significantly reducing the power and autonomy of all local agencies throughout the district.
4.1.3 Comparative Analysis of Beijing and Nanhai There are some obstacles to realizing the Chinese government’s ambition of e-government. First, there is a fundamental contradiction between the leadership’s intention to promote an e-government and the institutionalized way of thinking and behavior of the central government. A country, known for its centralized government is introduced to the concept of local e-governments, where central government is either not as strong such as in the cause of Beijing or has too much control as in Nanhai’s case. Second, the idea of e-government is based on the belief that government work should be transparent and authorities are obliged to deliver services to citizens (Carrow, 2001). The Internet culture represents modern political culture in which transparency, a fair share of information, and political equality are required. With the case of Beijing and Nanhai, however, there are two distinct cases where
124
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
issues of the actual process, leadership roles, investments, collaboration, and civic engagement are at odds. In the case of the e-park, the process is very much deeply rooted within a business framework, where competition is highly anticipated. At first, it was difficult for the e-government in Beijing to gain the trust and recruit cooperative ideals among businesses involved. However, the relevancy and accuracy of the information, as indicated in Heeks’ model was of such a high caliber, which was interestingly attributed to the contributions of so many transnational and international corporations that offered their expertise as well as their resources to contribute to e-park’s success. Nanhai’s launch of the e-government, however, began quite rapidly and almost effortlessly, where government employees at the local and national levels were working collaboratively to move forward. Unfortunately, however, the quality of information provided in Nanhai was not sufficient or necessarily relevant to the needs and demands of the citizens the e-government was serving. There were too many services offered, which were quite overwhelming for both the users and for government employees to handle. The cases of Beijing and Nanhai indicate that despite their successes, both e-governments are facing major challenges in ensuring that all users have access to online government services. Most importantly, however, is how to offer educational services to best serve and meet the needs of the citizens. Beijing has a greater task than that of Nanhai, yet it still manages to have more resources available and be more successful since the private sector has been working so successfully with the public sector. Additionally, ICT literacy among Beijing’s population is much greater than that of Nanhai’s, because the resources are more readily available. If anything, the success and failures of Beijing and Nanhai, respectively, should also be determined by the influence and role of China’s central government. The amount of time and resources invested in each project revealed great discrepancies and gaps with regards to the types of services offered and the technological capabilities and expertise of both government employees the citizens being served. Neither case addresses how rural, poor populations can benefit from e-government services when factors of ICT proficiency and literacy are vital to even being able to utilize and access e-government services. While the e-park has one of the most advanced innovative technologies available to the public, only an elite few can actually benefit from such an opportunity, and primarily those who are wealthy, successful business owners.
4.2 India The following section compares the success of Bhoomi with the failure of Gyandoot in India. Bhoomi started with the intended purpose of computerizing land records and infusing a sense of transparency and accountability into the land record system. Gyandoot was started with the aim of installing an intranet system that would connect rural Internet kiosks across one of the poorest districts in the central
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
125
Indian state of Madhya Pradesh. Gyandoot won the 2000 Stockholm Challenge IT Award because of its ability to provide “numerous benefits to the region, including a people-based self-reliant sustainable strategy” (Bhatnagar & Vyas, 2001). Their selection as success and failure, respectively, is based on De’s (2005) assessment in the paper titled The Impact of Indian E-government Initiatives: Issues of Poverty and Vulnerability Reduction, and Conflict. 4.2.1 Success of Bhoomi Like the rest of India, the southern state of Karnataka is predominantly agricultural. For its primarily agricultural population, land records are extremely crucial documents that confirm ownership, are decisive during the process of loan procurement, and are extremely vital as protectors of property. Bhoomi (meaning land) was a response to calls for reforms in land administration in India, which was infamous for being outdated, corrupt, and difficult to maneuver. Formerly, village accountants (VAs) in Karnataka maintained land records. Their primary responsibilities entailed maintaining land records and altering these records upon sale or inheritance (also known as mutation requests). However, the VAs were notorious for being inaccessible, procrastinating on basic responsibilities, and extracting bribes from customers (Chawla, 2004; Hanlon, 2004). Often times, the accountants would delay providing land records for up to 30 days. Additionally, they requested “speed money” that ranged from $2 to $40,5 depending on the nature of work. In some cases, bribes exceeded $200, when the task involved entering ambiguous information (Chawla, 2004). Similarly, mutation records would run into severe administrative policies. While a revenue inspector was expected to update mutation records after a 30-day period of enquiry and verification, the process was ordinarily prolonged to more than 2 years (Bhatnagar, 2003). Besides, the lack of transparency in the system aided the scope for further manipulation. The premise for Bhoomi’s implementation was that computerized land records would inhibit the malpractices inherent in the manual system and infuse greater accountability and transparency. The call for electronic land records first emerged in 1989–1990, when India’s Ministry of Rural Development began disbursing funds to state governments to facilitate the process. Using these funds, Karnataka rolledout a pilot in its Gulbarga district. By 1996, the project was expanded to include all the districts in the state. The taluks (towns that serve as headquarters for a cluster of villages), however, remained under the manual system of record keeping. Though funds were sanctioned for digitizing the land records data, there was not enough clarity about their validation and subsequent updating. Due to varying reasons, ranging from apathy to bureaucracy, the project failed in its objective (Gadiyar, 2007). In 2002, the state government issued a directive stating that digitization of land records would be expanded to include sub-districts and a system would be developed
5 $1
= 45 Indian Rupees.
126
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
that would enable a citizen-centric land record keeping. This led to the conceptualization and design of the Bhoomi software by the National Informatics Center (NIC), the government’s Ministry of Information Technology (MIT). While Bhoomi is primarily under the onus of the State government, it is jointly sponsored by Ministry of Rural Development, Government of India and State Government of Karnataka. Subsequently, the objectives of Bhoomi were identified as (Chawla, 2004, p. 8): • • • •
Facilitating easy maintenance and prompt updating of land records. Making land records tamper proof. Allowing farmers easy access to their records. Collating the information to construct database regarding land revenue, cropping pattern, land use, etc. • Utilizing the data for planning and for formulating development programs. • Enabling usage for this database by courts, banks, private organizations and companies, Internet service providers (ISPs). Once the decision to reach the taluks was made, the state government’s Department of Revenue installed computer kiosks across its 177 taluk offices. The primary purpose of these kiosks was to provide farmers with land ownership documents, also referred to as “Record of Rights, Tenancy and Cultivation” (RTC). Simultaneously, the emphasis was on computerizing the 20 million land ownership records of the approximately 6.7 million farmers in the state. Farmers, today, can acquire a copy of the RTC at the computer kiosks in the designated taluks against a payment of $0.33. Similarly, farmers can also place mutation requests at the kiosk. Against that request, a checklist of required documents for manual verification is generated. The mutation request is also assigned a number and farmers can determine the status of their application by feeding in the number into a touch screen device at some kiosks. On completion of the required manual verification, the new information is electronically entered and a notice generated. The notice is delivered to the original applicant, who acknowledges receipt and verifies all the information. In case no further changes are needed, a revenue inspector passes the order immediately after the 30-day expiration from the date of the issuance of the notice. Further, the entire process of land record procurement and ownership mutations are made foolproof by a bio-metric fingerprinting interface that ensures that records are tamper proof. This also infuses accountability of officials into the system. 4.2.2 Failure of Gyandoot Gyandoot (meaning purveyor of knowledge) was started in 2000 in the Dhar district of the central Indian state of Madhya Pradesh (MP). With a population of 1.7 million, which is predominantly tribal (54%), Dhar is also one of the poorest districts in India with approximately 60% of its population living below the poverty
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
127
line. Also, for the primarily rural population, access to basic government services is an arduous task. Requesting official copies of property records, or even securing an appointment with government officials is time consuming. For most of Dhar’s population, the opportunity cost of accessing these fundamental services is huge. The proponents of Gyandoot endeavored to establish community-owned, technologically innovative and sustainable information kiosks in a poverty-stricken, tribal dominated rural area of MP (Bhatnagar, 2004). Yet, again, the purpose of exploring ICT usage in Dhar was to improve the efficiency, effectiveness, accountability, and transparency of local government through increasing access to services, information, and policy documentation by the public (Spence, 2003). The focus of Gyandoot has both been e-commerce and e-government. The overall objectives of Gyandoot were the following (UNDP): • To ensure equal access to emerging technologies for marginalized segments of the society. • To create a cost-effective, replicable, economically self-reliant, and financially viable model for taking the benefits of IT to the rural masses. • To implement a new grassroots entrepreneurial model with the participation of groups of non-traditional entrepreneurs. • To provide self-employment through entrepreneurship to local rural youth. • To improve the quality, speed, and sensitivity of the state delivery apparatus toward the needs of local citizen-customers. • To impact IT on the government–citizen interfaces as the thrust area, so that the benefits of the knowledge economy directly reach the marginalized have-nots and know-nots. • To search for the potential of rural markets in the digital domain. • To analyze the processes and modalities involved in the socio-cultural environment while taking technology to the deprived communities. The State Government, with help from the World Bank, installed the Gyandoot infrastructure. The management of the Gyandoot Intranet comprises the Gyandoot Samiti whose president is the District Collector. He is assisted by a secretary, project manager, an assistant project manager, a technical head, and four computer operators. The kiosks are known as soochanalayas and function at the local level through one of two ownership models—the first model involves financial investment by the village Panchayat on the hardware, and infrastructure. Operation at the kiosk is handled by a trained operator. Expenses on account of day-to-day functioning of the kiosk is borne by both the Panchayat and the operator. The second model of kiosk ownership is a local entrepreneurship model wherein someone from the village invests in the infrastructure and hardware to start a local business. These entrepreneurs are required to pay the Samiti approximately $110 every year. Having identified Dhar as the site for the project, an intranet was installed by stationing computers in 20 selected soochanalayas. By 2002, the number had expanded to 40. The kiosks are especially placed in villages, which hold weekly
128
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
markets, or are in proximity of major roads, to facilitate access for those residents living in far-flung areas (Cecchini & Raina, 2004). On an average, each of the soochanalayas cater to the needs of approximately 30 villages, comprising at least half a million residents. Of the 40 kiosks, the village Panchayat opened 21 and the remaining were privately owned. The server or hub of the Gyandoot intranet network is called Soochana Kosh (“Store of Information”) and is a remote access server (RAS), placed in the Zila Panchayat or “district headquarters” (Jafri, Dongre, Tripathi, Aggrawal, & Shrivastava, 2002). In order to make the kiosk a sustainable business operation, facilities such as long-distance telephony, photocopying, and Internet connectivity are also present. While the district council owns the Gyandoot intranet, each village council is responsible for the functioning of the soochanalayas. A project manager is responsible for database maintenance and safe keeping of the server in the District Council. Assistant managers, who are government servants, aid him. The soochanalayas are staffed by village youth with a minimum school-leaving certificate to their credential. Added qualifications include average proficiency in typing, data entry capability, and managerial skills. The kiosks are operated as businesses and a fee is charged against every service accessed. At the inception of the project it was decided that further expansion of kiosk centers will take place only when local youth come forward to start new centers as private enterprises (Bhatnagar & Vyas, 2001). Among a variety of services, customers coming to the soochanalayas, have the opportunity to place complaints online, access government applications, and send enquiries to the proper authorities. While the electronic front-end allows for these services, the back-end continues to be manually operated. Printouts of the applications, complaints, and enquiries are sent to the appropriate government department. Responses from officials are then manually entered into the Gyandoot intranet. The average time lag between placing a query and receiving a response is approximately seven days. For grievances that are not immediately addressed, the project manager meets with the district collector to ensure follow-up and action. 4.2.3 Impact, Analysis, and Comparison Bhoomi is hailed as one of the most successful e-government projects in India. A finalist in the 2002 Stockholm Challenge Awards, Bhoomi has earned greater laurels, especially because other states have been unable to replicate its implementation and success. Bhoomi has infused a sense of organization into the agricultural sector, which enabled the state to take further steps toward keeping an online database and scrutinizing the sector more closely. Since its inception, Bhoomi has computerized 20 million land records covering 27,000 villages. Overall, 6.7 million farmers from approximately 177 sub-districts in Karnataka have benefited from its services. However, the total number of beneficiaries is well over 35 million. Bhoomi has drastically reduced the time frame
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
129
required to acquire an RTC from 1 RTC in 30 days to 5 RTCs 15 min. Similarly, with Bhoomi, the wait time for mutation requests has been reduced to a maximum of 45 days from the earlier maximum of 2 years. Bhoomi revenues are generated through the user fees charged against the services on offer at the kiosks. Against the total investment of approximately $4 million,6 Bhoomi collects $0.33 million7 every month on account of the 600 million user charges collected (Chawla, 2007). Gyandoot, on the other hand, received the 2000 Stockholm Challenge Award8 in the Public Administration category. The award was a tribute to Gyandoot’s ability in giving the marginalized tribal masses a chance to access information and knowledge. However, since the longevity of the kiosks depended on their economic viability, a host of services are offered to supplement kiosk income. Documents relating to farmer’s land area, including map are available at the kiosks for a marginal rate of $0.33. The bulk of the services on offer at the kiosk span delivery of several e-government services9 including the land records, domicile, and income certificates. Customers also use the kiosks to voice concerns and grievances about services or issues in the community. The services given to the public from the Soochanalayas will be based upon user charge and through this the local matriculate trained village youth will earn his livelihood and will also generate the small amount needed to maintain and run the system. In future, through private investment, bank loan or Panchayats, entrepreneurs may purchase computers, etc. and set-up more Soochanalayas/cybercafe-cum-cyberoffices. Thus, the entire scheme is independent of the government from an economic point of view and is financially self-sustainable and viable. Through this strategy, without any additional burden on the government, a mass-based and public-oriented autonomous and independent information technology system may be established in the rural areas in a short time. In thus designing its business plan, while Gyandoot minimized its financial dependence on the state, it increased it on both the Panchayat bodies and private resources. It was hoped that the myriad services on offer at the kiosks and user fees generated there from would ensure the sustainability of the kiosks.
4.2.4 Analysis and Comparison Bhoomi, today, is one of the most successful e-government projects in India. Perhaps, its most significant impact has been on lending transparency to the system
6 Rs.
180 million (Chawla, 2007). 15 million. 8 http://www.stockholmchallenge.se/project/data/Gyandoot 9 http://www.Gyandoot.nic.in/ 7 Rs.
130
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
of land records, which was wrought with corruption and bureaucratic procedures. Footfalls at Bhoomi kiosks, RTC procurement, and number of mutation requests are testament to the continued relevance of Bhoomi kiosks in Karnataka. Gyandoot, on the other hand, started with immense promise. However, 3 years into its implementation, attrition was high and usage relatively low (Cecchini, 2002; Ratan, 2008). By 2002, of the 40 soochanalayas, almost half had closed down. Services, whose usage had met with initial enthusiasm, waned with time. To begin with, customers were interested in crop prices. That demand also diminished with time because of two crucial factors—first, the installation of these kiosks coincided with the fall in telecom prices in India, which made it possible for farmers to acquire current prices by making local calls at a much cheaper rate than what it would cost them to obtain the same information at the kiosks; second, the Web sites were not updated regularly. Thus, the information available was, often times, dated and irrelevant to farmers. Additionally, challenge on account of distance was a major hindrance to optimal kiosk usage. While both projects began with immense promise, within 2 years of implementation, their trajectories diverged. While Bhoomi, continued to thrive and enjoy adequate demand from among farmers, Gyandoot’s performance dwindled. A matrix is proposed (see Tables 6.1 and 6.2 below) of infoDev factors and Heeks’ IPTOSMO framework to analyze what factors were catalysts and what inhibited success.10 While we understand that not all factors might be contextual in the case of Bhoomi and Gyandoot, the matrix below is only an attempt to gauge the factors that played a role in either project’s performance. The genesis of Bhoomi and Gyandoot was based on the premise that ICTs can play a relevant role in facilitating access to the government and its services. But due to inherent malpractices, access to the government was either delayed or nonexistent. However, in the analysis of the performance of both of these projects, two issues stand out—first, the issues of choice of services that were made available at the kiosks; and second, the mechanism or model of service delivery. As pointed out earlier, the project Bhoomi was singularly focused on making land record available to the farmers in a manner that was both simple and prompt. In the years since its inception, this objective has not been diluted. Further, the Bhoomi infrastructure provided the necessary support for timely and adequate service delivery. Gyandoot, on the other hand, attempted to shuttle between two broad categories of services— e-government and e-commerce. Of course, other services like redressal forums, communication, and entertainment were also offered at the kiosks. Perhaps, offering too many services, instead of concentrating on a select few has jeopardized Gyandoot’s chances of success. The prevalent technical issues have only accentuated these challenges.
10 Table 6.1 refers to the Bhoomi and Gyandoot projects in India as compared to infoDev’s criteria, while Table 6.2 addresses characteristics of Heeks’ model for all the projects in China and India.
Simplified the process of procuring land ownership documents
There was skepticism the system would remove corrupt VA’s. Government officials were apprehensive that the new system would replace their own responsibilities. But the planning assured there was adequate buy-in from existing VAs and government officials because of their inherent importance to the successful implementation of Bhoomi Funds were made available from both center and state
The state government has identified the success of Bhoomi as one of its priorities
E-government Very clear organizational structure
Respond to local needs end-user demand-driven projects
Adequate buy-in from those within the system; e.g., civil servants
Top-brass support integral
Set clear goals Designate an officer/body that will oversee planning and budget
Long-term resource commitment
Bhoomi
Recommendations
The infrastructure has been funded by the state and World Bank. But sustainability of kiosks is entirely dependent on the Panchayats and private entrepreneurs While there is extensive state-government support and commitment for Gyandoot its success depends heavily on local support, i.e., Panchayat bodies, and private entrepreneurs Diluted by the several services on offer With the presence of several private entrepreneurs, the question is who would be responsible for monitoring the performance of the soochanalayas?
Responded to critical needs—agricultural prices and procurement of important official documents. But diluted the entire purpose of addressing key needs by attempting to offer too many services at the same time The buy-in in Gyandoot’s case was mainly a function of selling the concept to the Panchayat bodies and private entities who were ultimately responsible for the last chain in the ICT service-delivery mechanism
Gyandoot
Table 6.1 E-government recommendations for Bhoomi and Gyandoot (based on infoDev factors)
6 A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road 131
Extensively consulted The services were too diverse and not necessarily responses to very critical needs of the end-beneficiary. It would be safe to assume that some services were introduced for the sole purpose of making the kiosks viable business operations It is unclear whether customer feedback is accounted for
The successful implementation of Bhoomi necessitates departmental integration
Ambiguous Ambiguous Center, state, and taluk offices No definite evidence of end-user consultation Very strongly citizen-centric
Involve local leaders Local ownership
Federal agencies, state and municipal agencies need to partner Consult end user Design applications that are citizen-centric
While feedback is forthcoming, there is ambiguity about how much of it is integrated
Government departments would have to be relatively integrated to ensure that services were delivered to the end-beneficiary in a timely manner. But the more varied the nature of the services, the more integrated the departments would have to be, which makes service delivery complicated Very strongly Yes, both through the Panchayat designated operator and the entrepreneur State, Panchayat bodies, local entrepreneurs
Ambiguous
Create incentives for private sector to become an active partnership Encourage participation/integration from other departments
Feedback
Extensively consulted with local communities and end beneficiaries at the planning stage to gauge what services would prove contextual and relevant Micro-enterprise/entrepreneurship model
Ambiguous
Consult with local communities
Gyandoot
Bhoomi
Recommendations
Table 6.1 (continued)
132 A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
Bhoomi
Ensure that RTCs and mutation records—extremely important documents of land ownership—could be easily procured at the kiosks
Bhoomi has ensured the compatibility of front-end and back-end operations
Factor
Information: The relevancy, currency, and accuracy of content
Technical: The compatibility of the technology with processes
Purposes of e-government and e-commerce: With the Gyandoot Web site being updated once in 2–3 days, the content was no more relevant to farmers whose priority was to acquire real-time price information Gaps in processes exist. In certain cases, while customers have the opportunity to place a complaint, the process does not necessarily ensure a solution. Since transactions at the back-end are handled manually, Gyandoot customers have not had the privilege of better service response time. This is further aggravated by issues of power shortage
Gyandoot
Nanhai
Digital Beijing has the most technological innovations in the nation-state that have advanced in such a short period of time
Many citizens are not able to use the tools, due to computer illiteracy and lack of proficiency. The e-government’s technological training for employees is also faulty and disconnected with that of the central government
Resources are readily Information available available to businesses and through the e-government corporations in the private cannot keep up with and public sectors, citizens’ demands specifically targeting science and technology sectors of society
Beijing
Table 6.2 E-governments in China and India compared to Heeks’ ITPOSMO Model
6 A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road 133
Singularly focused on online land record delivery
The purpose of Bhoomi was to rid the land record system of existent corruption and bureaucratic procedures. While overall, customers seem satisfied with the efficiency of land record acquisition through the Bhoomi kiosks, some customers feel that corruption has not been completely dealt with Centralized staffing with control in the hands of the state body
Processes
Objectives, values, and motivations
Staffing and skills
Bhoomi
Factor
Decentralized with more grassroots-level participation
More and more services added under the Gyandoot umbrella because the kiosks function as businesses. Quality suffers on account of a lack of priority between what to offer to customers Because of the varied nature of kiosk operators, it is very difficult to gauge and determine whether objectives, goals, and motivations were the same for everyone
Gyandoot
Table 6.2 (continued)
Centralized at the local and national level. Staff structure of e-government is very hierarchical
Digital Beijing was created to promote transparency and simplified processes between the public and private sector. The cooperation of businesses and government have strengthened the overall goals of the project
E-government has shown to be very effective and characteristic of high levels of transparency
Beijing
Staff is not trained, and there is a shortage in human resources. There is frustration between staff in Nanhai and the central government
Initially, the goals and objectives of Nanhai were realistic and effective. However, as the demand grew, the central government became more involved, causing more obstacles to achieving goals and objectives.
There is a disconnect between the central government and Nanhai’s government as to how to provide resources and which are prioritized
Nanhai
134 A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
With support from both the With kiosk life dependent on center and state, prolonged income makes fund resource engagement has commitment at the kiosk been ensured level erratic. This has resulted in problems of attrition, closure, and even the dilution of “development” as an objective
Other resources: Time and Money
Extremely decentralized
Fairly centralized
Management
Gyandoot
Bhoomi
Factor
Table 6.2 (continued)
The role of the private sector has contributed a high number of resources, including financial and human resources
Controlled by central government, but Beijing has a lot of autonomy to drive and control most of the infrastructure locally
Beijing
Controlled by central government, but Nanhai has some autonomy. Although, the role of the central government seems to be dominant even at the local level Nanhai has an affluent community, which is more dependent on agricultural exports. However, the e-government has become very small scale
Nanhai
6 A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road 135
136
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
5 Overall Summary The cases of Bhoomi and Gyandoot in India and Beijing and Nanhai in China are four examples of where instances of e-government are both a tangible and realistic amidst barriers and obstacles occurring from the planning phase to actual implementation. The five factors of successful e-government as established by infoDev and Heeks’ ITPOSMO framework are only two examples of how effective an egovernment can be in the design and process stages of e-government. Information regarding the actual implementation of an e-government system would require further study. The examples and descriptions provided here from China and India are not homogeneous to existing e-governments in both countries, and they may not fully represent the complexities that each e-government currently faces both in the design and implementation phases, as all case studies were based on secondary sources of data. Therefore, further study and field research may reveal alternative perspectives that may have been lacking in this chapter. Exploration of the experiences of citizens and e-government employees alike would benefit government officials to identify areas for improvement in the planning, design, and delivery phases of e-government. Issues of Internet and computer literacy as well as the role of the central government in e-government implementation are also crucial factors to consider. China’s e-government system is based on a national policy, while India’s e-governments were established by local governments. The debate between centralized and decentralized governments continues, but the rapid rise of e-governments systems across the country have also proven that central and local governments can indeed work collaboratively and successfully as long as there are compromises in what type of resources, values, management and process structures, technology, training, and information is shared and will be most beneficial to citizens, and therefore, the overall development of the country. National and local practices and policies (that compliment rather than contradict each other) should be implemented so that e-government systems run smoothly and interconnectivity across governments is feasible and efficient. Most importantly, national and local governments should have policies in place for ICT training and implementation, ensuring that rural citizens have equal access to e-government resources as their urban counterparts and employees are efficient in service delivery.
References APDIP (2006). Fighting Corruption with e-Government Applications. APDIP e-Note. Bhatia, D., Bhatnagar, S. C., & Tominaga, J. (2009). How do manual and e-government services compare? Experiences from India. In Information and communications for development 2009: Extending reach and increasing impact (pp. 67–82). Washington, DC: World Bank. Bhatnagar, S. (2003). Access to information report: E-government. London: Profile Books Limited. Bhatnagar, S. (2004). E-government: From vision to implementation. India: Sage.
6
A Challenging E-journey Along the Silk Road
137
Bhatnagar, S., & Vyas, N. (2001). Gyandoot: Community owned rural intranet kiosks. Washington, DC: World Bank. Carmine, S., & Yuhang, S. (1999). World wide web site design and use in public management. In G. D. Garson (Ed.), Information technology and computer applications in public administration: Issues and trends (pp. 246–266). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing. Carrow, J. (2001). Five keys to e-government. Interactive Week, 8(2), 86. Cecchini, S. (2002, July 10). Evaluation of Gyandoot and Bhoomi (India). (H. Arazyan, Interviewer) Development Gateway. Cecchini, S., & Raina, M. (2004). Electronic government and the rural poor: The case of Gyandoot. Information Technologies and International Development, 65–75. Center for Democracy and Technology. (2002). The e-government development handbook for developing countries. Washington, DC: The World Bank. Chawla, R. (2004). BHOOMI: Online delivery of record of rights, tenancy and crops to farmers in Karnataka, India. New Delhi: National Institute for Smart Government. Chawla, R., & Bhatnagar, S. (2004). Online delivery of land titles to rural farmers in Karnataka, India. In Reducing poverty, sustaining growth—what works, what doesn’t, and why a global exchange for scaling up success. Washington, DC : World Bank. Chen, A. J., Pan, S. L., Zhang, J., Huang, W. W., & Zhu, S. (2009). Managing e-government implementation in China: A process perspective. Information & Management, 46, 203–212. Ciborra, C. (2005). Interpreting e-government and development: Efficiency, transparency or governance at a distance? Information Technology & People, 18(3), 260–279. Ciborra, C., & Navarro, D. D. (2005). Good governance, development theory, and aid policy: Risks and challenges of e-government in Jordan. Information Technology for Development, 11(2), 141–159. Dada, D. (2006). The failure of e-government in developing countries: A literature review. The Electronic Journal on Information Systems in Developing Countries, 26(7), 1–10. De, R. (2005). E-government systems in developing countries: Stakeholders and conflict. In M. A. Wimmer., et al. (Eds.), Proceedings of Electronic Government, 4th International Conference (pp. 26–37). Berlin: Springer. De, R. (2006). The impact of Indian e-government initiatives: Issues of poverty and vulnerability reduction, and conflict. Regional Development Dialogue. UNCRD and UNDP. De, R. (2006, December 14). Design and evaluation of the societal impact of GII: The case of bhoomi in Karnataka, India. Bangalore, Karnataka, India: Indian Institute of Management Bangalore. Gadiyar, C. (2007, December 10). Bhoomi empowers rural Karnataka. Retrieved August 17, 2009, from Dataquest: http://dqindia.ciol.com/content/top_stories/2007/107121001.asp Hanlon, C. (2004, May 20). On the road to Shanghai: India; closing the digital divide to cut corruption and poverty. Retrieved from http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/ NEWS/0„contentMDK:20204636∼menuPK:34459∼pagePK:34370∼piPK:34424∼theSitePK: 4607,00.html Heeks, R. (Ed.). (1999). Reinventing government in the information age: International practice in IT-enabled public sector reform. London, UK: Routledge. Heeks, R. (2003). Most eGovernment-for-development projects fail: how can risks be reduced? Manchester: IDPM. Ho, A. T.-K. (2002). Reinventing local governments and the e-government initiative. Public Administration Review, 62, 434–443. infoDev. (2002). The e-government handbook for developing countries. Washington, DC: infoDev and Center for Democracy and Technology. Jafri, A., Dongre, A., Tripathi, V. N., Aggrawal, A., & Shrivastava, S. (2002). Information communication technologies and governance: The Gyandoot experiment in Dhar district of Madhya Pradesh, India. London: Overseas Development Institute.
138
A. Bandyopadhyay and S.D. Sattarzadeh
Kelles-Viitanen, A. (2003). The role of ICT in poverty reduction. The Finnish Economy and Society, 82–94. Lan, L. (2004). E-government: A catalyst to good governance in China. In Knowledge management in electronic government (pp. 317–324). Berlin: Springer. Lovelock, P., & Ure, J. (2002). Assessing China’s efforts in constructing an e-government. In M. Woesler & J. Zhang (Eds.), China digital dream: The impact of the internet on Chinese society (pp. 177–200). Bochum: The University Press Bochum. Luo, G. (2009). E-government, people and social change: A case study in China. The Electronic Journal on Information Systems in Developing Countries, 38(3), 1–23. Mansell, R., & Wehn, U. (1998). Knowledge societies: Information technology for sustainable development. New York: Oxford University Press. Ndou, V. (2004). E-government for developing countries: Opportunities and challenges. The Electronic Journal on Information Systems in Developing Countries, 18(1), 1–24. PCIP. (2002). Roadmap for e-government in the developing world: 10 questions e-government leaders should ask themselves. Los Angeles: PCIP. Scavo, C., & Shi, Y. (1999). World Wide Web site design and use in public management. In G. D. Garson (Ed.), Information technology and computer applications in public administration:Issues and trends. Hershey: IDEA. Seneviratne, S. J. (1999). Information technology and organizational change in the public sector. In Information technology and computer applications in public administration: issues and trends (pp. 41–61). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing. Spence, R. (2003). Information and communications technologies (ICTs) for poverty reduction: when, where and how? Ottawa: IDRC. Tan, X. (2002). Development of e-government in China—present status, challenges, and problems. In M. Woesler & J. Zhang (Eds.), China digital dream: The impact of the internet on Chinese society (pp. 177–200). Bochum: The University Press Bochum. Vrasidas, C., Zembylas, M., & Glass, G. V. (2009). ICT for development: Challenges and possibilities. In C. Vrasidas, M. Zembylas, & C. V. Glass (Eds.), ICT for education, development and social justice (pp. 3–17). Greenwich: Information Age. World, T. W.-G. (2002). Roadmap for e-government in the developing world. Pacific Council on International Policy. World Bank. (2009). Definition of e-government. http://go.worldbank.org/M1JHE0Z280 Xu, D., & Astone, M. (2005). E-government in China. Retrieved from http://unpan1.un.org/ intradoc/groups/public/documents/ APCITY/UNPAN022802.pdf Yan, Z. (2006). Municipal e-government in China: The case of Beijing. Beijing: BMOI. Zhou, X. (2004). E-government in China: A content analysis of national and provincial web sites.
Chapter 7
Digital Government in North America: A Comparative Analysis of Policy and Program Priorities in Canada, Mexico, and the United States Luis F. Luna-Reyes, Theresa A. Pardo, J. Ramon Gil-Garcia, Celene Navarrete, Jing Zhang, and Sehl Mellouli International digital government research has increased in the last 10 years. However, international research comparing or analyzing relevant problems for the North American region is scarce. In an effort to lay the foundation for new research in the context of North America, this chapter presents a comparative analysis of policy and program priorities of digital government in Canada, Mexico, and the United States. Common themes in the agendas of the three countries include services to the citizen, improved government operations, transparency, connectivity, and economic development. Main differences can be explained on the basis of differences in development. In general, we could say that the US government is renewing its egovernment agenda, as a component of a wider innovation system. The government of Canada is also in a refreshing process, but more directed to consolidate a digital architecture for government services and operations, and Mexico is in the process of consolidating a digital government program.
L.F. Luna-Reyes (B) Universidad de las Americas Puebla, Cholula, Puebla 72820, Mexico e-mail:
[email protected] T.A. Pardo Center for Technology in Government, University at Albany, SUNY, Albany, NY 12205, USA e-mail:
[email protected] J.R. Gil-Garcia Centro de Investigacion y Docencia Economicas, Mexico DF 01210, Mexico e-mail:
[email protected] C. Navarrete California State University, Dominguez Hills, Carson, CA 90747, USA e-mail:
[email protected] J. Zhang Clark University, Worcester, MA 01610, USA e-mail:
[email protected] S. Mellouli Laval University, Quebec, QC, Canada G1V 0A6 e-mail:
[email protected] C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_7, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
139
140
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
1 Introduction As a research discipline and professional field, digital government has a global reach. In this global arena, researchers have conducted an important amount of international research. In a recent review, Helbig, Dawes, Mulki, Hrdinová, and Cook (2009) discovered that international studies in digital government are very few before 2001, growing in number until 2005, reaching a maximum of 65 studies, and decreasing again from 2006 to 2008. Articles in the sample included comparative and benchmark studies, research focusing on regional issues, best practices, and transnational studies. Although these findings are encouraging, international research efforts are still scarce, particularly in a world where jurisdictional overlaps and collaboration among governments to solve public problems are becoming common (Helbig et al., 2009). Relevant studies are underway in Europe, but very few similar efforts can be found in North America (Helbig et al., 2009; Navarrete, Mellouli, Pardo, & Gil-Garcia, 2009). In order to lay the foundation for understanding these issues in the context of North America, this chapter presents a comparative analysis of digital government in Canada, Mexico, and the United States at the national level. This analysis is based on a set of official documents, press and news reports, as well as three, one-daylong face-to-face meetings with government officials from Mexico, Canada, and the United States, which took place in 2007, 2008, and 2009. The main objective of this analysis is to understand the priorities, policies, and strategies in place in the three countries. The chapter presents a description of the objectives, strategies, themes, budget priorities, and main projects in each of the three countries, including a comparative analysis of these components. In this way, the chapter constitutes a first description of digital government in North America. The chapter is organized into six sections including the foregoing introduction. Section 2 presents some important concepts about digital government. Section 3 describes the research methods used in this chapter. Section 4 provides an introduction to each of the three countries e-government efforts. Section 5 presents comparisons among the three countries in terms of objectives, strategies, projects, budget priorities, and information technology (IT) governance. Finally, section 6 includes the conclusions of the chapter.
2 Understanding Digital Government Information and communications technologies (ICTs) create possibilities and benefits for governments around the world. They are used to improve the quality of services, to reduce costs, and make policies and programs more effective (Gil-Garcia & Helbig, 2006; Lim & Tang, 2008; Roy, 2007). Information and communication technologies are used as a catalyst for organizational change (Dawes, 2002; Rocheleau, 2003). They are also considered a tool to improve democratic
7
Digital Government in North America
141
participation in political and civil organizations (Carbo & Williams, 2004; Hiller & Bélanger, 2001). The terms “digital government” and “e-government” have emerged over the last 15 years to refer to ICT use in government, and its meaning has been evolving over time (Gil-Garcia & Luna-Reyes, 2006; Yildiz, 2007). Conceptualizations of electronic government are diverse (Brown & Brudney, 2004; Edmiston, 2003; Roy, 2003; West, 2004). The more restrictive views of e-government only consider the use of the Internet to provide public services, while others consider any use of ICT in government. The field of e-government is located at the intersection of government, society, and ICT. Some general characteristics of e-government are (1) using information and communication technologies, (2) supporting government actions, (3) improving the relationships between government and citizens, and (4) following a strategy to create public value (Gil-Garcia & Luna-Reyes, 2006). Some other conceptualizations of digital government also involve the creation of a legal framework and a strategy to promote ICT adoption and the knowledge society. For this chapter, digital government is defined as “the selection, implementation, and use of information and communication technologies in government to provide public services, improve managerial effectiveness and promote democratic values and mechanisms; as well as the development of a regulatory framework that facilitates information-intensive initiatives and fosters the knowledge society” (Gil-Garcia & Luna-Reyes, 2006, p. 639). Governments around the world are developing national agendas to ensure that they’re capitalizing on the benefits of digital government. These national agendas integrate different aspects of digital government into a single, nation-wide strategy. In the management area, strategy is associated with the development and achievement of a grand goal, usually called mission or vision, as well as several critical objectives. In general, strategy involves three interrelated activities: strategic planning, strategic thinking, and opportunistic decision-making (Andersen, Belardo, & Dawes, 1994). Making strategy in the public sector, however, is not a straightforward process. One conceptualization is that “strategic management is a way of regenerating an organization, through continuous attention to a vision of what the people who make up an organization wish to do. It is a pro-active process of seeking to change the organization, its stakeholders (in as much as they are different from the organization), and the context, or environment, within which it seeks to attain its aspirations” (Eden & Ackermann, 2000, p. 3). This view recognizes strategy-making as an emergent process of change. In fact, from Eden and Ackermann’s (2000) point of view, strategy-making is a continuous process of sense-making and negotiation among all stakeholders, who consciously explore and reveal emergent and planned strategies. Given that actors and stakeholders may have different or even conflicting views of the mission and critical objectives, strategy-making needs to be understood as a process of continuously developing shared understandings about key problems and objectives (Bryson, 2004; Eden & Ackermann, 2000). Reflection on power relationships and the political environment are important components of strategy-making in
142
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
the public sector because it helps to balance planned with unplanned opportunities. It is common to find, both in the public and private sectors, governance bodies in charge of the development of IT strategy. These groups lead the process, negotiating objectives, priorities, and strategies, as well as main projects. The exploration of digital government in North America presented in this chapter intends to capture and compare the main strategic elements of digital government in each country.
3 Research Design and Methods Digital government research is a very young area of inquiry. As such, there is not yet an agreement in terms of a leading methodological approach (Scholl, 2007). International research efforts in this field are also quite new, and also show a breadth of research methods and traditions (Helbig et al., 2009). The lack of comparative research in digital government may be a consequence of the lack of a tradition in comparative research in other associated areas such as public administration, information science, or computer science; the only e-government-related field with a long tradition conducting comparative research is political science (Eglene & Dawes, 2006). Attending to the tradition of comparative politics, we understand comparative research as one of the basic scientific methods focusing on discovering relationships among variables (Lijphart, 1971). Given that the comparative method is usually applied to few cases, it shares strengths and weaknesses with case studies. Case studies’ main strength rests in their emphasis on deep description and context, helping to bridge theory and practice (Yin, 1994). The particular approach we use in this chapter is compatible with most of the work on comparative politics, mainly descriptive and inductive (Mahoney, 2007; Munck & Snyder, 2005). The three countries in North America are the selected cases. These three countries are different in many aspects (providing good variation), yet they have important similarities in government structures (three levels of government and a federal system). Therefore, comparing these countries may have important policy implications for each of the three countries and North America as a whole. Moreover, analyzing and comparing a developing country, a country with a highly developed presidential-system, and one with a highly developed parliamentarian-system will allow the results to be relevant to other countries around the world. Descriptive information for each country comes from government Websites, government documents, newspapers, and meetings with government officials of Canada, Mexico, and the United States. These meetings took place during the last 3 years as part of the activities of the North American Digital Government Working Group, in November 2007 (Mexico), November 2008 (Canada), and December 2009 (the United States). Each of the three meetings were organized as informal information exchanges, with a focus on common interests and ways to collaborate. In addition to the working group members, government officials also participated in the meetings (eight in Mexico, three in Canada, and ten in the United States).
7
Digital Government in North America
143
The analysis focuses on five main themes: objectives, strategies, main projects, budget priorities, and IT governance structures. These themes constitute the core components of strategy as we described it in the previous section. In the following paragraph, we define each of these themes with more detail. Digital government objectives outline the goals and directions that each country intends to achieve. To a certain degree, objectives indicate the competitive position that each country strives to obtain. Although it is common to understand strategy in the literature as a plan of action, we are referring to strategies in this chapter as main action lines to accomplish objectives. Digital government projects are the building blocks of each country’s digital government program. They indicate priorities, attracted visibilities, provided tangible results, and collected important lessons for future development. Budget priorities refer to the amount of money allocated to e-government and to specific projects. The size of budget dedicated to the egovernment program demonstrates the overall commitment of government to IT as a key enabler of government operations. Allocation of resources to individual projects suggests the strategic importance of each of them. IT Governance structures represent the approach to allocating decision rights and accountability in the process of developing strategy and objectives, identifying budget priorities, making investment decisions, developing policies and technological standards, and managing and coordinating activities to reach objectives and adopt strategies. After a brief overview of the digital government strategies and actions of the three countries, the following sections describe and compare the three countries’ approaches in each of these main themes.
4 Country Overviews The following subsections provide a summary overview of digital government in Mexico, Canada, and the United States. Both official documents and leader speeches in the three countries make continuous linkages between digital government, digital economy, and the information society.
4.1 Mexico Digital government in Mexico has the shortest history from the three countries in North America, starting in the year 2000 with the e-Mexico program and President Fox’s Good Government Agenda (Luna-Reyes, Gil-Garcia, & Cruz, 2007). The use of ICT by government was one of the six key strategies of the Good Government Agenda, and the issues associated with ICT in government were very frequently mentioned in President Fox’s speeches. The e-Mexico program promoted the information society, citizen access to the Internet and a government technology platform.
144
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
In the current presidential administration, however, digital government is much less prominent in the strategy. President Calderon started his administration with an Austerity Decree calling for a reduction in federal government expenditures (Presidencia de la República, 2006). This decree had a negative impact on ICT investments. Current e-government efforts are tied to the 2008–2012 Special Program for Federal Public Management Improvement. However, this special program brings up-front the Austerity Decree, and mainly emphasizes efficiency, reducing operational costs of government, effectiveness, and transforming government to increase the social impact of public programs without making a special reference to the role of ICTs to achieve these goals. In terms of digital economy performance, while Mexico is one of the leaders of Latin American countries, the gap between performance in Mexico and the leading countries is significant. The World Economic Forum 2008–2009 Networked Readiness Index, for instance, ranks Mexico 67 out of 134 economies. The Economist 2007 E-readiness Index ranks Mexico 38th out of the 69 economies. Finally, Mexico ranks 37th considering the UN E-government Readiness Index. Although initial efforts have resulted in significant changes in infrastructure and systems for digital government, Mexican opinion leaders, researchers, and government officials point out the need for a clearer and more coordinated digital government agenda for the country. The lack of this strategy has been associated with a loss of the competitive position of the country (AMITI, CANIETI, & FMD, 2004).
4.2 Canada In the 1990s, Canada was one of the first countries in the world to develop a national strategy for digital government. However, many observers believe that major components of the strategy now require replacement or reinforcement in the face of technological and market change, as well as mounting pressures on the competitiveness of the Canadian economy. Accordingly, both the 2006 report of the Telecommunications Policy Review Panel and the 2007 National Round-Table recommended that Canada refresh its policies and programs and develop a new national strategy for the digital economy. Information and communication technologies are among the priorities of the government of Canada. This priority is reflected in different speeches of the Throne since 2001. In 2004, the government set out a goal of becoming a “model user of information technology and the Internet” and to “be known around the world as the government most connected to its citizens, with Canadians able to access all government information and services online at the time and place of their choosing.” To fulfill its responsibilities, Canada decided to have a public service distinguished by excellence and equipped with the skills for a knowledge economy and society. To this end, the Government of Canada is committed since 2001 to the reforms needed for evolving and adapting to the new conditions. These reforms will ensure
7
Digital Government in North America
145
that the public service is innovative, dynamic, and reflective of the diversity of the country—able to attract and develop the talent needed to serve Canadians in the twenty-first century. Canada stands as one of the leading countries in terms of digital economy performance. The World Economic Forum 2008–2009 Networked Readiness Index ranks Canada 10th out of 134 economies. The Economist 2007 E-readiness Index ranks Canada 13th out of 69 economies. The United Nations (UN) 2008 E-government Readiness Index ranks Canada in the 7th out of 192 countries.
4.3 The United States E-government initiatives in the United States can be traced back to the 1993 ClintonGore administration’s “reengineering through information technology” efforts to enable government to be more customer-oriented and responsive to societal needs (Homburg, 2008). The reform focused on improving efficiency, accountability, and performance in the federal government through the use of information systems. The reengineering effort fueled the development of several national and inter-governmental information systems (Fountain, 2001). The Bush administration adopted the concept of e-government and identified e-government as a critical element in the management of government (“E-government Act of 2002,” 2002). The e-government strategy claimed a focus on cross-agency integration and interoperability to achieve performance and efficiency gains, identifying 24 projects that constituted the so-called “quicksilver initiative” (Executive Office of the President Office of Management and Budget, 2002). The Obama administration is focused on building a new Internet infrastructure and using ICT to improve openness and transparency of government operation. President Obama stated on April 25, 2009, “To help build a new foundation for the twenty-first century, we need to reform our government so that it is more efficient, more transparent, and more creative” (The White House, 2009). On 21 January 2009, the president delivered a Memorandum for the Heads of Executive Department and Agencies, stating his commitment to openness, transparency, public participation, and collaboration (The White House Office of the Press Secretary, 2009). The memorandum also requires the Federal Chief Technology Officer (CTO), in collaboration with the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) and the General Services Administration (GSA), to draft an Open Government Directive to implement the key principles set forth in the memorandum. Prior to the election of President Obama, the World Economic Forum 2008–2009 Networked Readiness Index ranked the United States 3rd out of 134 economies. The Economist 2007 E-readiness Index ranked the United States 2nd out of the 69 economies, and finally, the United States ranks 4th in the UN E-government Readiness Index. The impact of the Obama administration on these rankings is not yet clear, but expectations for change are quite high.
146
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
4.4 Comparing the Three Countries Digital government has played an important role in the three countries of North America, and it is perceived as a central element of economic competitiveness, transparency, democracy, and effectiveness of services and government programs. Although these themes are important across the three countries, national leaders in Canada and the United States appear to position ICT in government as a key enabler to accomplish these important objectives. In Mexico, on the other hand, the centrality of ICTs in terms of achieving leadership objectives is not recognized in the same way. Integration and interoperation of systems to provide better services to citizens and economic development are common themes in the three countries. However, it is important to note that the three countries are in transition, in which the need for renewal and consolidation of a digital government agenda has been made a priority. The emphasis on the United States and Canada is on renewal, while the emphasis in Mexico is consolidation.
5 Understanding Digital Government Related Priorities in the Three Countries of North America The path each of the three countries of North America has taken toward digital government capability is varied. Understanding the characteristics of each provides a foundation for future comparative and transnational research in digital government in the region. In the following sections, we present the digital government programs of the three countries in terms of five key aspects: objectives, strategies, budget priorities, main projects, and IT governance. Each section starts with a description of key aspects of digital government policy, followed by a brief comparison among the three countries.
5.1 Objectives In this section, we first provide the main objectives of e-government in the three countries, and then provide a discussion on these objectives. Although the comparison focuses primarily on current developments, the discussion also includes information of objectives previously established in each of the three countries to provide some sense of the evolution in each of them. In early 2009, the Mexican House of Representatives approved the first Mexican digital government agenda to coordinate digital government efforts at the federal level, including elements to promote links and coordination across the three levels of government. The vision statement in the agenda considers Mexico as a “a competitive information and knowledge society, an inclusive and innovative nation, where public policy has as a fundamental axis the use of information and communication technologies” (Secretaría de la Función Pública, 2009). The general objective is
7
Digital Government in North America
147
much more modest, focusing on “taking advantage from information and communication technologies to improve internal operations of Public Administration to offer better services, to improve access to the information, accountability, transparency and to strengthen citizen participation” (Secretaría de la Función Pública, 2009). Particular objectives of the digital government agenda comprise two main areas: generating government operational efficiencies and providing better citizen services. The first group of objectives responds to the Austerity Decree, but also includes objectives associated with the creation of information systems standards, knowledge management, evaluation, process improvement, training, and IT governance. The objectives grouped under Service to the Citizen include aspects such as service digitalization and integration, the promotion of particular applications such as the advanced digital signature, the incorporation of information technology in agency’s strategic planning, and creating linkages with other levels of government, the industry, and academia. The digital government agenda objectives are different from objectives established during the previous presidential administration. In 2003, the main objectives were oriented to promote ICT adoption in Federal Government Agencies (GilGarcia, Mariscal, & Ramírez, 2008). Security became an important objective—and still is—as a result of the digitalization of services. Themes of customer satisfaction and evaluation are new on the agenda, as well as objectives related to knowledge management, IT governance, and collaboration. Generating efficiencies, cost savings, and increasing accountability and transparency have been important goals since 2000. At the first stages of e-government in Canada—in the 1990s, the objectives were to provide Canadians with online access to public services. As of 2009, with the Gov 2.0 project, the main objectives are to provide a more efficient user experience as a result of effective design and navigation, to capture core content from the authoritative source in order to reduce duplication and inconsistencies, to conduct systematic client engagement to drive continuous improvement, to ensure that the Internet helps fulfill policy imperatives and client needs, to establish clear accountability, roles, and responsibilities for its Internet sites, to allow for more effective resource investments in its Internet sites, to provide for greater integration of services with partner departments, and to yield more operational efficiency through common processes and technology shared with partners. Through Gov 2.0, the Government of Canada aims to use the capabilities of Web 2.0 in order to improve the relations among ministries and agencies of the Government of Canada, and between citizens and these agencies. To this end, the government intends to use social networks and semantic techniques. Prior to the Gov 2.0 project, the Government of Canada adopted the project Canada’s Government On-Line (GOL). This project was deployed from 2000 to 2007 with the commitment that “government will become a model user of information technology and the Internet.” The specific objectives of the GOL project included giving citizens education on Internet skills, connecting government to citizens, providing Internet access to communities, creating an appropriate legal framework for e-commerce, attracting investment, promoting development, and using the Internet to make Canadians more aware of their unique history, identity, and culture.
148
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
In the case of the United States, the Bush administration passed the first Egovernment Act in 2002 and formulated the first e-government strategy. The general objectives of the Bush administration’s e-government expansion are largely citizen-oriented. Those include: “make it easy for citizens to obtain service and interact with the federal government; improve government efficiency and effectiveness; and improve government’s responsiveness to citizens” (Executive Office of the President Office of Management and Budget, 2002). These general objectives are further articulated as value creation in simplifying delivery of services to citizens; eliminating layers of government management; making it possible for citizens, businesses, other levels of government and federal employees to easily find information and get service from the federal government; simplifying agencies’ business processes and reducing costs through integrating and eliminating redundant systems; enabling achievement of the other elements of the President’s Management Agenda; and streamlining government operations to guarantee rapid response to citizen needs. Besides the objectives of service delivery, efficiency, and effectiveness of government management, the new Obama’s Administration has intended to achieve the following objectives: transparency, participation, collaboration, and improving innovation. Two primary objectives for the new administration are deploying a modern information technology infrastructure and fostering innovation in order to achieve the goals of a transparent democracy, greater citizen participation, and collective problem solving for societal challenges such as healthcare, renewable energy, and public safety.
5.1.1 Comparing the Three Countries It appears that all three countries attempted to leverage e-government to achieve objectives along two directions: providing better services to the citizens and improving the government’s internal operations and transparency. However, as it is stated in the objectives, it appears that the Canadian government is more ambitious in setting up the goal to be a leader in using advanced information technology and the goal to make Canada a preferred environment for investment, research, and development. Similarly, the new administration in the United States moves toward the direction to create economic and developmental opportunities, solve social and economic problems, and improve democratic participation for the citizens through the development of an advanced information technology infrastructure. Mexico, on the other hand, only includes the broader idea of information technology as an enabler of competitiveness and knowledge society in its vision, but the objectives are more modest, focusing on the provision of services and improving internal operations and transparency. Moreover, Mexican e-government objectives had a component related to costs savings, which are not as explicit in the other two countries’ objectives. The goal of systems integration is present in the objectives of the three countries. It is explicitly included in the Canadian and US objectives, and included in the Mexican objectives implicit in the goal of improving inter-agency collaboration.
7
Digital Government in North America
149
5.2 Strategies In terms of strategies, the Mexican digital government agenda places the citizen at the core of the strategy, considering an end-to-end coordination process to effectively deliver services to the citizen. Moreover, this general framework calls for the coordination among federal, state, and local levels of government in the provision of services. The agenda establishes seven main strategies to be pursued: • Taking advantage of ICT to increase operational efficiency in government operations, also optimizing ICT investments and contracts. • Developing innovative projects applied to strategic processes in the federal government. • Increasing digital government maturity through models for training, planning, and evaluation of digital government projects. • Developing a legal framework and strengthening the IT governance structure at the federal level. • Promoting digitalization and integration of government services across levels of government. • Increase the participation and faculties of CIOs at Federal Agencies in strategy development. • Promoting partnerships with other levels of government, academia, ICT industry, and international organizations. This set of strategies continues with the main focus of the 2000–2006 strategy. Important additions are the open recognition of the need for a governance structure and an appropriate legal framework, the recognition of the figure and key role of the CIO, and the need for coordination and stakeholder involvement. The Canadian government has defined a set of strategies in order to reach its objectives. As stated earlier, e-government in Canada is now at stage Gov 2.0. The central focus of Gov 2.0 is to improve the relationships between federal employees and transparency on government operations. To this end, the strategy is built on the following elements: • • • •
Business cases must be improved. Departmental capacity must be assessed. Departmental processes are strengthened. Federal government agencies must follow CIO guidance, manage risks, monitor key success factors, and report issues.
These strategies add to the GOL main actions, which included client-centric services, establishing a common secure infrastructure, updating policy, and legislative frameworks to guarantee the security and privacy of information and transactions, the development of a skilled workforce, and providing a single-window for all service channels.
150
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
Looking at the US case, the past two presidential administrations have had important but very different strategies in the area of digital government. The Bush Administration agenda focused on technology as a tool to improve services and performance of federal agencies. This strategy focused on transforming service delivery to citizens and businesses, as well as improving inter-governmental coordination and internal efficiency and effectiveness. While President Obama’s strategy is still emerging, it appears to be focused more broadly on the enhancement of national technology capability in addition to the transformation of US federal government operations. One area where President Obama has broken new ground is in the appointment of the first U.S. federal government CIO—Mr. Vivek Kundra—in charge of the development of the information resource management strategic plan (The White House, 2009). This strategic plan will be organized around six guiding principles: • • • •
Innovation in the economy. Innovation in science. Innovation in public administration. Restoring a culture of accountability through openness and transparency of government operations and information. • Moving toward unprecedented openness. • Making critical government information available. 5.2.1 Comparing the Three Countries All three countries intend to use e-government to deliver an integrated experience for their citizens. They all see the creation of an integrated environment based on policy framework, IT governance structure, and technological standards. Moreover, to different degree, they strive to use e-government as a way to streamline the processes in collecting, handling, and processing information and delivering services that involve multiple levels of government or multiple agencies. In the particular cases of Mexico and Canada, there is an emphasis on improving digital government capabilities across national government agencies. In the case of Canada, it appears to be a consolidation process, while in Mexico it is a process that is just starting. What may appear to be different is the more broad focus presented by the United States, where digital government appears to be conceptualized as a part of a broader innovation system involving the development of infrastructures and science. The Canadian government also includes these objectives and strategies, but focusing on competitiveness, without stating explicitly the role of the science and technology system.
5.3 Projects Mexico, Canada, and the United States have deployed many different projects. The projects relate to different aspects of e-government.
7
Digital Government in North America
151
Several projects have attracted the attention of the Mexican Government. Some of these projects are related to increasing transparency and accountability in government. A second group of projects is oriented to the improvement of government operations. A third group is pursuing improved services to Mexican citizens, and the last group of projects is oriented to increase access to the Internet infrastructure by Mexicans. CompraNet (http://www.compranet.gob.mx) and Declaranet (http://www. secogem.gob.mx/DeclaraNET/) belong to the first group of projects. Compranet was developed to increase transparency in government purchases. Declaranet is a government officials’ financial declaration application. In this system, government officials register their personal financial situation periodically allowing audits and detection of suspicious growth of their assets. DeclaraSat—the Federal Government tax filing system—is one of the main projects to improve government operations. Developing the system involved redesigning the tax-filing process to make it simpler and easier. The advanced electronic signature is also a project to increase efficiency in government operations by defining a secure standard to create paperless processes and operations. Most informational and transactional services to the citizen can be accessed through the citizen portal (http://www.gob.mx) or through the e-Mexico portal (http://www.emexico.gob.mx). The citizen portal has been winner of international recognition for its citizen-centered design and features. Another important project since 2002 consists of the development of an Internet access infrastructure through digital community centers in public schools, public libraries, health centers, regional development centers, and adult education facilities (Gil-Garcia & Luna-Reyes, 2009). Internet access has increased from about 5% in 2000 to about 23% in 2009 (AMIPCI, 2009), but Internet penetration is still low. Finally, government officials show an emerging interest in new projects using virtual communities, mobile technologies, and integrated services across government levels. The focus of e-government in Canada is not only to improve services to citizens but also to improve efficiency of the Federal government functioning. Accordingly, two kinds of projects have been put in place: projects to ease citizen access to federal government services and projects to improve the internal functioning of the federal government. In the first kind of projects, there is the redesign of the Website of the Treasury Board Secretariat (TBS). This project started in the GOL initiative. TBS undertook a thorough examination of its over 40 web sites to determine the best way to consolidate the information. A new design has been developed to facilitate navigation, meeting the needs of main client groups. The second kind of projects in the GOL initiative is to improve the relationships between federal government employees. Federal departments have an obligation to present reports to Parliament on their plans and priorities and on their performance. By providing the information online in a usable format, the timeliness, quality, and usefulness of the documents would improve, saving around $300,000 annually. Canadians, Parliamentarians and others would benefit through better quality planning, decision-making, and financial performance.
152
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
Currently, and since 2007, GOV 2.0 main projects are still under development. The projects include the development of collaboration tools, the GCPedia (wiki for public services), and the use of Web 2.0 technologies such as Facebook. In the United States, from 2001, federal agencies identified 24 Presidential E-government initiatives that promised to deliver high impact, common technology solutions such as tax filing, rulemaking, and electronic training. Examples among these initiatives include GovBenefits.gov, which provides a single entry for citizens to locate information and determine potential eligibility for government benefits and services, Grants.gov, the federal one-stop portal to apply for over 1,000 grant programs from federal organizations, and the Integrated Acquisition Environment (IAE), which provides a secure environment for government procurement. A new set of projects being pursued by the Obama administration is oriented to broadband deployment in rural areas through $7.2 billion stimulus funds distributed by the commerce department and the agriculture department. For example, the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA) Broadband Technology Opportunities Program (BTOP) is targeted toward developing broadband access to improve public safety and stimulate the economy to create new jobs (http://www.ntia.doc.gov/broadbandgrants/). President Obama has launched a number of projects in support of his commitment to transparency and accountability. Recovery.gov, for example, is a federal government Website that provides access to data related to Recovery Act spending and allows for the reporting of potential fraud, waste, and abuse. Additional examples include efforts to use technology to create online communities such as Business.gov, enabling online collaboration among small business owners, government representatives, and industry experts.
5.3.1 Comparing the Three Countries A common set of projects across the three countries is related to a better provision of citizen services, although in the case of the United States, it appears to be a focus on projects to help the poorest in the country, allowing them with improved access to Internet, benefits, and services. Mexico also has a running project oriented to improve Internet access. Another commonality between the United States and Mexico, but not Canada, is projects oriented to improve government transparency and reducing corruption from government officials. The three countries have projects oriented to the improvement of Government operations. It can be inferred from the projects in Canada and the United States that there is an interest in refreshing and reviewing projects from previous presidential administrations, while in Mexico there are no new projects. Finally, a common trend across the three countries is their interest in Web 2.0 tools to get a better communication with and among citizens.
7
Digital Government in North America
153
5.4 Budget Priorities In the following paragraphs we describe and compare budget priorities in Mexico, Canada and the United States. As mentioned before, President Calderon’s Austerity Decree promoted a reduction in ICT investment, making a priority for federal agencies to fund current projects and contracts. In order to spend the money in a more efficient way, government agencies have developed a series of strategies and policies to negotiate better contracts with vendors. The economic crisis of the last year resulted in additional reductions in the federal budget for 2010. Given that there is not a specific budget entry for ICT investments, it is hard to estimate the total ICT investment in the federal government in Mexico. The Mexican budget for Science and Technology has also been gradually decreasing since the early 1990s. In the case of Canada, the 2000 Federal Budget identified $160 million over 2 years to design and launch Government On-Line (GOL). Of that amount, approximately one third was set aside to fund the pilot projects that facilitate cross departmental service integration. In the December 2001, additional $600 million were committed over the fiscal years 2002–2006 to continue and expand the GOL initiative: for building the common secure infrastructure and sustaining service transformation and business practices. In the United States, through the Memorandum for the Heads of Executive Departments and Agencies (http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/assets/ memoranda_fy2009/m09-27.pdf), the director of OMB and the director of the office of Science and Technology Policy provided guidelines for the agencies to build science and technology priorities for FY 2011. Four priority areas are identified: • Applying science and technology to drive economic recovery, job creation, and economic growth. • Promoting innovative energy technologies to reduce dependence on energy imports and mitigate the impact of climate-change while creating green jobs and businesses. • Applying biomedical science and information technology to help Americans live longer, healthier lives while reducing health care costs. • Having the technologies needed to protect troops, citizens, and national interests.
5.4.1 Comparing the Three Countries Budget priorities in Mexico and the United States show that facing economic downturn, these countries have contrasting reactions in ICT spending. In Mexico, the government attempted to cut costs by reducing new spending, while in the United States, the government attempted to boost the economy through science and technology investment, using ICT spending as a driver for economic recovery. Budget
154
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
priorities in the United States are pointing toward a better integrated national innovation system. From the information about the government of Canada, there appears to be a commitment of resources to continue funding digital government projects, which is not linked, at least in the documents we reviewed, with a broader view of an innovation system.
5.5 IT Governance In the following paragraphs, we briefly describe the main IT governance structures in each of the three countries. The discussion about IT governance in the Mexican federal government started in the last years of President Fox Administration. During this same period, two different government agencies were charged with closely related activities, the eMexico Coordination at the Ministry of Communications and Transportation, and the Digital Government Unit at the Ministry of Public Administration. The current IT governance structure is coordinated by the Digital Government Unit at the Ministry of Public Administration, and it is called the E-government Interministerial Committee. This committee started as an informal network with the participation of the CIOs from Federal Ministries and Institutions, and the e-Mexico coordinator, becoming a formal body on December 2005 (Secretaría de la Función Pública, 2005). Committee members are all the State Ministers plus the directors of other important institutions such as the Mexican Oil Company (PEMEX), the Mexican Institute for Social Security (IMSS), and the Internal Revenue Service (SAT). The committee president is the Ministry of Public Administration, and the executive secretary of the Committee is the Director of the Digital Government Unit from the same ministry. The Committee develops general policy and strategy for the federal government, and it is organized in several technical councils in charge of creating recommendations on important themes such as IT function organization, security, IT procurement, privacy, or interoperability. Finally, the committee has a consultant group including members from academia, the private sector, and other members of the civil society. There is a current proposal to move the Digital Government Unit from the Ministry of Public Administration to depend directly from the President’s office. If the proposal is approved, the appointed official in charge of this unit may become the first national CIO. The Chief Information Officer Branch (CIOB) provides strategic direction and leadership for the government-wide pursuit of excellence in information management and information technology in the Government of Canada. CIOB is responsible for policy development, monitoring, management oversight, and leading community development and capacity-building initiatives in information management, information technology, identity management and security, and access to information and privacy to ensure the sound management and stewardship of the Government of Canada’s information and technology assets and its communities of practice.
7
Digital Government in North America
155
In the United States, the Federal Chief Information Officers (CIO) Council serves as the principle interagency coordinating body (Federal Chief Information Officers Council). Its existence was codified into law in the E-Government Act of 2002. The Council is made up of the CIOs and Deputy CIOs from the federal executive agencies, and chaired by the Deputy Director for Management from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). The Council intends to improve the design, use, sharing, and performance of agency information resources through developing recommendations for IT management policies, procedures, and standards; identifying opportunities to share information resources; and assessing and addressing the needs of the federal government’s IT workforce. Another advisory body for federal e-government is the Interagency Management Council (IMC). The voting members of IMC consist of an IT Senior Executive or senior official from 14 Cabinet-level departments and representatives from the legislative and judiciary branch agencies as well as sub-Cabinet and independent agencies. The Council provides input representing the agencies’ and stakeholders’ requirements and interests, and recommends interagency strategies and initiatives to GSA (Interagency Management Council). Additionally, an information technology management and planning approach has been implemented to improve cross-agency collaboration at the federal level (Seifert, 2008). Started in 2002, the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) was initiated by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). The FEA includes five reference models: Performance, Business, Service, Data, and Technical. These reference models provide a common platform for agencies to use in reducing duplicate development and collaborating on shared technology solutions (Federal Enterprise Architecture Program Management Office, 2007).
5.5.1 Comparing the Three Countries It appears that the government of Canada is the only one that relies on a specific government branch to provide direction to digital government strategy. Meanwhile, Mexico and the United States have relied on IT governance structures involving federal CIOs and other stakeholders. A possible explanation of the difference is that Canada is the only country among the three with a consolidated position of a national CIO. It may be the case that with the new CIO position at the United States, and the potential appointment of a first national CIO in Mexico, roles and functions from the existing governance bodies will change. However, the three countries are looking for better coordination and strategic alignment of ministries and agencies.
6 Final Remarks In this chapter we have presented a description of the e-government agendas from Canada, Mexico, and the United States. This first work points to an initial list of similarities and differences on the e-government approaches of the three countries.
156
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
Table 7.1 summarizes the key points for the five selected themes across the three countries. In general, digital government has played an important role in the three countries of North America. Although it is perceived as a central component for economic competitiveness in the three countries, the United States and Canada are taking a stronger stance toward this theme. Other shared themes across the three countries are transparency, democracy, openness, efficiency and effectiveness of services, and government programs. It is interesting to note that the three countries are in a transition process. The transition process in Canada and the United States has a refreshing concern, while in Mexico there is an interest for consolidation. In terms of their main objectives, the three countries are interested in improving services to the citizen and innovative ways of improving government operations and transparency. This later objective of transparency is more clearly stated in both the United States and Mexico agendas. The goal of integration and interoperation is present in the three countries, closely related to the provision of citizen services and the improvement of internal operations. In terms of strategies, all three countries intend to use e-government to deliver an integrated experience for their citizens. They all see the creation of an integrated environment based on a policy framework, an IT governance structure, and technological standards as the key to reach their objectives. Moreover, to different degrees, they strive to use e-government as a way to streamline the processes that involve multiple levels of government or multiple agencies. Mexico and Canada share an interest in improving digital government capabilities across national government agencies. US strategies are different from Canadian and Mexican ones given their emphasis on innovation and transformation. Moreover, the US government appears to be heading to an agenda that integrates digital government with a more wide perspective on the information society, and an integrated innovation system. The three countries are supporting either new or existing projects to improve citizen services and internal government operations. Mexico is the only country in which there are specific projects to increase transparency and accountability (DeclaraNet and CompraNet). A common area for Mexico and the United States is their interest to improve Internet access. Finally, Web 2.0 tools appear as a trend that will be included in the three countries’ agendas, but it is more clearly present in the agendas of Canada and the United States. Budget priorities across the three countries are also different. Particularly, it is interesting to note the difference between Mexico and the United States. In Mexico, government attempts to cut costs by reducing new spending, while in the United States, the government attempts to boost the economy through science and technology investment, using ICT spending as a driver for economic recovery. Budget priorities in Canada suggest the interest in building a shared enterprise architecture for government. In terms of IT governance, Canada is the only country with a consolidated CIO figure. Mexico has created a single interministerial IT governance body, while the United States currently has a more distributed model including the CIO council, the
Mexico
Promote competitive information society, improve government operations, improve access to information, accountability, transparency, citizen participation, and interorganizational collaboration
Citizen at the center, ICT to improve operational efficiency, create standards, transfer best practices, develop training programs, develop appropriate legal framework, digitalization of government services, strengthen the figure of the CIO
CompraNet and DeclaraNet (transparency); DeclaraSat (gov. operations); Citizen and e-Mexico Portal (citizen services); Digital Community Centers (access to Internet); emerging web 2.0
Budget reduction, priorities to improve efficiency in spending and maintaining current systems
Interministerial Committee and current proposals that can consolidate the position of a National CIO
Variable\country
Objectives
Strategies
Projects
Budget priorities
IT governance
Priority given to the areas of cross-departmental service integration, common security infrastructure and transforming business processes Chief Information Officer Branch
TBS Website (services); Parlamentarian Reporting System (gov.operations); GCPedia (wiki for public services) and other Web 2.0 applications
Client at the center, improve business cases, assess departmental capacity, strengthen processes, monitor key success factors and risks, improve policy framework
Improve user experience, consolidate content, enhance accountability, integrate services, increase operational efficiency and take advantage of web 2.0
Canada
Table 7.1 Summary overview of the five themes across countries
Renew infrastructure, promote efficiency and effectiveness in government management, simplify service delivery, promote transparency, participation, collaboration and innovation Enhance national technical capability, transform government operations, transform service delivery, innovate in economy, science and public administration, restore culture of accountability, promote openness and access to information Tax-filing, rule-making, electronic training and Integrated Acquisition Environment (gov. operations); GovBenefits, Recovery. Gov (services); BTOP (broadband access); Business.gov (online communities) Science and technology to drive economic growth, energy technologies, biomedical science and information technology, and security National CIO recently appointed, Federal CIO Council, Interagency Management Council and Federal Enterprise Architecture
USA
7 Digital Government in North America 157
158
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
IMC, and the FEA. With the recently appointed National CIO, this distributed IT governance may change. Although there has been a lot of progress in digital government in the three countries, there are some differences in their current concerns. In general, we could say that the United States government is renewing its e-government agenda as a component of a wider innovation system. The government of Canada is also in a refreshing process, but more directed to consolidate a digital architecture for government services and operations. Finally, Mexico is in the process of consolidating a digital government program. Acknowledgements This work was partially supported by the Inter-Institutional Program of Studies about the Region of North America (PIERAN), Mexico, the National Council for Science and Technology (CONACYT-Mexico), Grant No. I0110/127/08, and the US National Science Foundation (NSF), Grant No. 37656. Any opinions expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of NSF, CONACYT, or PIERAN.
References AMIPCI. (2009). Estudio AMIPCI 2009 de Hábitos de los usuarios de Internet en México. Retrieved September, 2009, from http://amipci.org.mx/estudios/temp/ RESUMENEJECUTIVOEstudioAMIPCI2009UsuariosdeinternetFINAL-0334725001245691 260OB.pdf AMITI, CANIETI, & FMD. (2004). Vision Mexico 2020. Retrieved June, 2009, from http://www.cysp.com.mx/Ima/Amiti/Documentos%20Descargables/Doc_PP_vision_Mexico_ 2020.pdf Andersen, D. F., Belardo, S., & Dawes, S. S. (1994). Strategic information management: Conceptual frameworks for the public sector. Public Productivity and Management Review, 17(4), 335–353. Brown, M. M., & Brudney, J. L. (2004). Achieving advanced electronic government services: Opposing environmental constraints. Public Performance & Management Review, 28(1), 96–114. Bryson, J. M. (2004). What to do when stakeholders matter: Stakeholder identification and analysis techniques. Public Management Review, 6(1), 21–53. Carbo, T., & Williams, J. G. (2004). Models and metrics for evaluating local electronic government systems and services. Electronic Journal of e-Government, 2(2), 95–104. Dawes, S. S. (2002). Government and technology: User, not regulator. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 12(4), 627–631. Eden, C., & Ackermann, F. (2000). Making strategy: The journey of strategic management. London: Sage Publications. Edmiston, K. D. (2003). State and local e-government: Prospects and challenges. American Review of Public Administration, 33(1), 20–45. Eglene, O., & Dawes, S. S. (2006). Challenges and strategies for conducting international public management research. Administration & Society, 38(5), 596–622. E-government Act of 2002, 116 STAT. 2899, Pub. L. No. PUBLIC LAW 107–347 (2002). Executive Office of the President Office of Management and Budget. (2002). E-government strategy: Implementing the president’s management agenda for e-government. Retrieved from http://www.usa.gov/Topics/Includes/Reference/egov_strategy.pdf Federal Chief Information Officers Council. from http://www.cio.gov/aboutus/aboutus.cfm Federal Enterprise Architecture Program Management Office. (2007). FEA practice guidance. Retrieved from http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/assets/fea_docs/FEA_Practice_Guidance_ Nov_2007.pdf
7
Digital Government in North America
159
Fountain, J. E. (2001). Building the virtual state: Information technology and institutional change. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press. Gil-Garcia, J. R., & Helbig, N. (2006). Exploring e-government benefits and success factors. In A. V. Anttiroiko & M. Malkia (Eds.), Encyclopedia of digital government. Hershey, PA: Idea Group Inc. Gil-Garcia, J. R., & Luna-Reyes, L. F. (2006). Integrating conceptual approaches to e-government. In M. Khosrow-Pour (Ed.), Encyclopedia of e-commerce, e-government, and mobile commerce (pp. 636–643). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Reference. Gil-Garcia, J. R., & Luna-Reyes, L. F. (2009). Fostering the information society through collaborative e-government: Digital community centers and the e-learning program in Mexico. In A. Meijer, K. Boersma & P. Wagenaar (Eds.), ICTs, citizens & governance: After the hype (pp. 99–118). Amsterdam: IOS Press. Gil-Garcia, J. R., Mariscal, J., & Ramírez, F. (2008). Gobierno electrónico en México. In Working papers. Mexico: Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económicas. Helbig, N., Dawes, S. S., Mulki, F. H., Hrdinová, J. L., & Cook, M. E. (2009). International digital government research: A reconnaissance study (1994–2008) (p. 63). Albany, NY: Center for Technology in Government. Hiller, J. S., & Bélanger, F. (2001). Privacy strategies for electronic government. In M. A. Abramson & G. E. Means (Eds.), E-government 2001 (pp. 162–198). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. Homburg, V. (2008). Information systems in public administration: understanding e-government (1st ed.). London: Routledge. Interagency Management Council. from https://www.imc.gov/TH/IMC/IMC.nsf/charter?OpenPage Lijphart, A. (1971). Comparative politics and the comparative method. The American Political Science Review, 65(3), 682–693. Lim, J. H., & Tang, S. Y. (2008). Urban e-government initiatives and environmental decision performance in Korea. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 18(1), 109–138. Luna-Reyes, L. F., Gil-Garcia, J. R., & Cruz, C. B. (2007). Collaborative digital government in Mexico: Some lessons from federal web-based interorganizational information integration initiatives. Government Information Quarterly, 24(4), 808–826. Mahoney, J. (2007). Qualitative methodology and comparative politics. Comparative Political Studies, 40(2), 122–144. Munck, G. L., & Snyder, R. (2005). Debating the direction of comparative politics: An analysis of leading journals. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association. Navarrete, C., Mellouli, S., Pardo, T. A., & Gil-Garcia, J. R. (2009). Information sharing at national borders: Extending the utility of border theory. Paper presented at the Hawaiian International Conference on System Sciences-42, Hawaii. Presidencia de la República. (2006). Decreto que establece las medidas de austeridad y disciplina del gasto de la Administración Pública Federal. Mexico: Diario Oficial de la Federación. Rocheleau, B. (2003). Politics, accountability, and governmental information systems. In G. D. Garson (Ed.), Public information technology: Policy and management issues (pp. 20–52). Hershey, PA: Idea Group Publishing. Roy, J. (2003). The relational dynamics of e-governance: A case study of the city of Ottawa. Public Performance and Management Review, 26(4), 391–403. Roy, J. (2007). E-government in Canada: Transition or transformation? In D. F. Norris (Ed.), Current issues and trends in e-government research (pp. 44–67). Hershey, PA: CyberTech Publishing. Scholl, H. J. (2007). Central research questions in e-government, or which trajectory should the study domain take? Transforming Government: People, Process and Policy, 1(1), 67–88. Secretaría de la Función Pública. (2005). Acuerdo que tiene por objeto crear en forma permanente la Comisión Intersecretarial para el Desarrollo del Gobierno Electrónico. Mexico: Diario Oficial de la Federación.
160
L.F. Luna-Reyes et al.
Secretaría de la Función Pública. (2009). Agenda de gobierno digital. Mexico: Diario Oficial de la Federación. Seifert, J. W. (2008). Federal enterprise architecture and e-government: Issues for information technology management. Retrieved from http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/secrecy/RL33417.pdf The White House. (2009). Technology. Retrieved from http://www.whitehouse.gov/issues/techno logy/ The White House Office of the Press Secretary. (2009). Memorandum for the heads of executive department and agencies. Retrieved from http://www.gwu.edu/∼nsarchiv/news/ 20090121/2009_transparency_memo.pdf West, D. M. (2004). E-government and the transformation of service delivery and citizen attitudes. Public Administration Review, 64(1), 15–27. Yildiz, M. (2007). E-government research: Reviewing the literature, limitations, and ways forward. Government Information Quarterly, 24(3), 646–665. Yin, R. K. (1994). Case study research design and methods (2nd ed.). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Chapter 8
Adoption of Web 2.0 by Canadian and US Governments F. Dianne Lux Wigand
The goal of this chapter is to compare the adoption of Web 2.0 information and communication technologies (ICT) by government agencies in Canada and the United States and to explore their respective impact on e-government. Governments at all levels recognize the need to develop and enhance multimedia and multichannel communication strategies to communicate with citizens and provide services as well as enable interaction among employees and to cross agencies’ boundaries. Governments have discovered that Web 2.0 communication channels can have an unexpected reach, and occupy a new and quite possibly an essential space in electronic communications. Government agencies, needing to or requiring to communicate with the public, are finding that Web 2.0 technologies are an effective, efficient, timely, and valuable way to get the word out. This chapter shows that Web 2.0 use is creating entirely new online communities that defy traditional communication reach and organizational boundaries. Web 2.0 ICT can enable collaborative work with external stakeholders as well as within and among agencies. By examining specific examples of Web 2.0 use in Canadian and US governments, analyzing the insights gained, and reflecting on observations and recommendations, both public administrators and IT professionals are provided with a framework to evaluate the benefits and challenges of adopting these new ICT and applications. The fundamental questions are the following: What is Web 2.0? How have government agencies in Canada and the United States adopted these technologies to encourage interaction and collaborative work?
1 Introduction For the past decade, the adoption of electronic governmental services has increased in developed and developing countries to provide and improve the delivery of public services. E-government has been defined as “The use of information and F.D.L. Wigand (B) Institute of Government, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Little Rock, AR 72204, USA e-mail:
[email protected] C.G. Reddick (ed.), Comparative E-Government, Integrated Series in Information Systems 25, DOI 10.1007/978-1-4419-6536-3_8, C Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
161
162
F.D.L. Wigand
communication technologies, particularly the Internet, as a tool to achieve better government” (OECD, 2003, p. 23). It is a digital means for all stakeholders to communicate and work with government through multiple digital channels. The main goal of e-government is to meet citizens’ expectations and to provide more efficient and effective public services. For over a decade, ICT have been key tools for the front- and back offices in government to achieve this goal. Web 2.0 is an umbrella term used to refer to a new era of Web-enabled applications and tools such as blogs, microblogs, podcasts, Really Simple Syndication (RSS), social networking sites, video sharing, web chat, and wikis. Web 2.0 does not refer to a new software version, but rather to a new phase of the evolving and extended Internet. It is more than a mere set of technologies. Web 2.0 includes a social dimension with user-generated content, increased simplicity in design and features as well as participatory, decentralized models and processes. The key components of Web 2.0 are the following: (1) technology and architecture are web based; (2) it is built around communities and social networks and stakeholder-generated content; and (3) it consumes and remixes data from multiple sources (Wigand, 2007, p. 276). The paradigm shift enabled by Web 2.0 technologies is from end users consuming information to producing information and facilitating interaction and collaborative work. For the past 5 years, public and private organizations have been adopting Web 2.0 ICT. Consequently, citizens, particularly in developed countries, have increased their daily online Internet activities. By December 2009 the number of adults in the United States using the Internet was 74%, up from 63% reported in 2003. The types of online activities American citizens are engaged in vary widely: from using e-mail (89%), buying products (75%), searching for news or information about politics or upcoming campaigns (60%), visiting government Web sites (59%), using social networking sites such as MySpace, Facebook, or LinkedIn.com (47%), reading blogs (32%), sharing user-generated content (30%), and using Twitter or other status-update service (19%) (Pew Internet and American Life Project Tracking surveys, 2009). Similarly, Canadians are very active online users with 78% reporting accessing the Internet frequently (Canadian Internet Project, 2008). According to a Forrester Research report, 57% of Canadians participate in social networks at least once a month. Americans’ social network participation follows with 51% (Elliot, Overby, Greene, & Wise, 2009). Hence, the Internet penetration by both countries places them at the leading edge of further adoption of new ICT. This growing role of new web technologies in people’s lives has changed expectations about how to find and use information as well as expectations for the delivery of information and services. In the United States, 70% of Americans report that they expect their government to provide online information and services (Pew Internet American Life Project, 2007, p. 7). As citizens’ Internet activities increase and their usage matures, citizens’ expectations of government to provide information and services online, whenever they need it through multiple channels, also have increased. Since 2004, government agencies at all levels in Canada and the United States are beginning to explore the benefits of Web 2.0 technologies and applications. Governments’ adoption of Web
8
Adoption of Web 2.0
163
2.0 technologies is regarded by some researchers as a move toward more citizencentric and participatory government as well as augmenting existing values of public service agencies (Accenture, 2009; Baumgarten & Chui, 2009). Adoption of Web 2.0 activities requires a shift in focus from publishing information to sharing information and from passive consumers of information to interactive and participative users who may also generate content. Consequently, increased expectations coupled with increased exposure to new online activities in the private sector place pressure on governments to acknowledge this trend in citizen Internet use activity and to consider adopting some of these new channels for government. As the public sector begins to experiment with Web 2.0 technologies, there is an increased understanding of the value of these technologies for their organizations and citizens’ usage trends and expectations. One of the major changes enabled by Web 2.0 technologies is the sharing of information with citizens and expanding the communication outreach to the citizenry. Along with the benefits of these technologies, challenges such as security and privacy issues have to be confronted and addressed. The goal of this chapter is to explore the adoption of Web 2.0 technologies and application by Canadian and US government agencies. To achieve this goal the chapter addresses four objectives: 1. To identify theoretical approaches to explain the adoption of Web 2.0 technologies in government. 2. To provide a descriptive analysis of secondary data to ascertain which Web 2.0 technologies are being used by Canadian and US government agencies, at various governmental levels, and for which purposes. 3. To review relevant patterns of the adoption and implementation of Web 2.0 applications in government agencies in Canada and the United States. 4. To develop a framework for government agencies evaluating the benefits and challenges of the adoption of these new ICT and applications and their respective impact on e-government services. First, a theoretical overview describing four overarching theories is presented: diffusion of innovations, collective intelligence (CI), the technology acceptance model (TAM), and uses and gratification. These theories provide an appropriate theoretical background to explain the characteristics as well as variables that affect the adoption of new technologies such as Web 2.0. Next, definitions of Web 2.0 technologies and applications used in the public sector are presented. This provides a framework for a descriptive analysis of secondary data and the trends to use Web 2.0 by Canadian and US government agencies. Understanding these developments highlights how the public sector can harness the potential of these tools. Then a review of government agencies and individuals in Canada and the United States, specifically those who are early adopters of Web 2.0, presents a picture of prevalent uses in the public sector. The fourth objective builds upon the examples presented in the third objective, i.e., to develop a framework for other public sector agencies to evaluate which applications can be adopted in which settings and for what uses. An understanding of these factors may enhance and further
164
F.D.L. Wigand
the adoption of Web 2.0 technologies by other government agencies. Finally, an understanding of how the adoption of Web 2.0 may impact the delivery of egovernment services for both developed and developing countries. The importance of this chapter for public administrators is realized in that it helps them to ascertain the relevance of these ICT and applications for governmental organizations. For researchers this effort opens new research streams to ascertain how to measure these applications determining the effectiveness and efficiency for the delivery of public services.
2 Theoretical Overview Four theoretical approaches—diffusion of innovations theory, collective intelligence (CI) theory, the technology acceptance model (TAM), and uses and gratification theory—offer insights into the characteristics and variables for how and why new ICT are adopted. The first theory applicable to understanding the adoption of a technology is diffusion of innovations. This theory explains how and why new ideas and technologies spread through certain channels among members of a social system. The model of the innovation-decision process has four stages: knowledge—awareness of an innovation and some understanding of its use; persuasion—the user has a favorable or unfavorable attitude toward the innovation; decision—a choice is made to adopt or reject the innovation; and confirmation—seeks reinforcement for the decision to adopt or not to adopt (Rogers & Shoemaker, 1971, p. 103). According to these authors, the five most important characteristics of innovations explaining the rate of adoption (the speed by which members of a social system adopt an innovation) are relative advantage (amount of improvement over existing technology), compatibility (ability to incorporate the technology into an individual’s life), complexity (how difficult it will be to adopt), trialability (how easy it is to experiment with the technology on a limited basis), and observability (how visible is the technology to other users). In addition, Rogers and Shoemaker (1971) define five adopter categories: (1) innovators—first individuals to adopt, risk takers, and opinion leaders (2) early adopters—second group to adopt and individuals have a high degree of influence on later adopters, (3) early majority—cautious and slower in the adoption process, (4) late majority—adoption occurs after the majority of the group has already adopted the innovation, and individuals are skeptical, (5) laggards— last ones to adopt an innovation and individuals appear to have an aversion to change. These four stages, five characteristics, and five categories of adopters certainly provide a foundation to understand and explain how, why, and when new technologies are adopted. Canadian and US government agencies can be regarded as early adopters of emerging Web 2.0 ICT. The rapid uptake of these technologies by the private sector and citizens provides government agencies at all levels the incentives to adopt. Moreover, government agencies see the relative advantage over existing technology, the ease of use, the compatibility of these technologies with existing communication channels, the ability to experiment with these technologies
8
Adoption of Web 2.0
165
both internally and externally, as well as enhancing the visibility of the organization by using them. Collective intelligence (CI) theory, i.e., group intelligence is generated by the collaboration among many individuals, also provides a theoretical foundation for understanding user-generated content and the use of Web 2.0 technologies to enable collaborative work. According to Atlee and Por (2000), “Collective intelligence is any intelligence that arises from—or is a capacity or characteristic of—groups and other collective living systems” (p. 1). In group behavior, Atlee and Por (2000) argues that CI can overcome “groupthink” and individual bias to focus on collective processes to achieve enhanced performance. From a mass communication perspective, Flew (2008) argues that ICT enable the cooperation among independent individuals and can enhance group performance. Web 2.0 technologies allow the easy collection, storage, and sharing of knowledge and information among users. This creates a form of collective intelligence. It also provides a foundation for understanding the “wisdom of crowds” concept which supports the use of Web 2.0 ICT such as wikis to coordinate collaborative work. According to Surowiecki (2004), there are four key criteria distinguishing decisions made by wise crowds: (1) diversity of opinion—each contributor has private information and opinion about the facts, (2) independence—opinions are not influenced by others, (3) decentralization—contributors have specialized information and can draw on local knowledge, (4) aggregation—a means to change private opinions into a collective decision. Surowiecki focuses on individuals who tended to make decisions independently and their basis of making the decision was not due to the influence of mass crowds. Web 2.0 technologies can enhance the decision-making process of these independent contributors by enabling user-generated content. The technology acceptance model (TAM) developed by Davis (1989) explains how users come to accept and use technology. This theory has been applied to broader information technology (IT) environments and this model supported numerous studies. There is, however, still ongoing criticism and controversy about the use of this model. TAM posits that there are a number of factors that will influence the user as to whether or not to adopt the technology. Davis (1989) found two most common factors: perceived usefulness (the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system would enhance his or her job performance) and ease of use (the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system would be free from effort) would account for the adoption of a technology. In later studies, Venkatesh and Davis (2000) expanded the model to TAM2 and explained usage intentions in terms of social influence. Then Venkatesh, Morris, Davis, and Davis (2003) developed the unified theory of acceptance and use of technology (UTAUT) to explain user intentions to use an information system and usage behavior. The four key components of the UTAUT model are performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, and facilitating condition. Social demographic variables such as gender, age, experience, and voluntariness of use were found to mediate the four key constructs. This model has been used to account for variation in usage intention. TAM, TAM2, and UTAUT are useful models to explain how an end user interacts with a technology and which variables might influence the adoption of the technology.
166
F.D.L. Wigand
Users’ expectations of Web 2.0 and social influence as well as social demographics have increased the uptake of these technologies and created an interest for government agencies to experiment with using them. Uses and gratification theory (Blumler & Katz, 1974) posits that media users actively take part in the communication process and are goal oriented in choosing a media source that maximally fulfills their needs. Moreover, the assumption is made that the user has alternative choices to satisfy his or her needs. Although uses and gratification theory was applied originally to radio and television, the basic features of this theory can be applied to a certain degree for citizens’ efforts to contact and communicate with government as well. This theory lends itself partially for the present setting in that channel choices made by citizens are also likely to be made in the sense that gratification is achieved, but the definition of gratification is different in selecting technologies to contact government agencies. In a governmental context, however, gratification is derived when a solution or a partial solution is found to a citizen’s problem while using a particular communication channel. The citizen deliberately chooses and uses a channel as a means to an end, i.e., to solve a problem or to find information in anticipation to solving it. Thus it can be seen that uses and gratification theory offers some inherent limited utility for the present setting such as channel choice. These four theoretical approaches—diffusion of innovations, collective intelligence, the technology acceptance model, and user gratification—provide conceptual guidance in developing the overall framework for understanding the adoption of Web 2.0 technologies by governments in Canada and the United States.
3 Methodology This chapter provides a descriptive analysis of secondary data derived from multiple reports on the use of specific Web 2.0 technologies by government agencies in Canada and the United States at the federal, state/provincial, and local/municipal levels of government. Before the analysis can be conducted, a brief history of the evolution of the Internet to Web 2.0 and the distinguishing characteristics between Web 1.0 and 2.0 are presented. The selection process of comparable Web 2.0 technologies and the definitions for each technology are presented.
3.1 Evolution of Web 2.0 Since 1969, the Internet, originally labeled Advanced Research Projects Agency Network (ARPANET), evolved from a limited number of connected military and university research computers to a worldwide system of computer networks used by millions of people for a variety of purposes. The Internet was opened for commercial purposes in the late 1980s and gained momentum for public use in the 1990s. The first Web sites were slow, static pages controlled by the owners, large businesses,
8
Adoption of Web 2.0
167
and governments to broadcast information to the world (Drapeau & Wells, 2009). This phase, 1995–2004, of Internet development is now sometimes referred to as Web 1.0. The phrase Web 2.0 was coined at the O’Reilly Media conference in 2004. O’Reilly (2007) originally defined the term: “Web 2.0 is the network as platform, spanning all connected devices; Web 2.0 applications are those that make the most of the intrinsic advantages of that platform: delivering software as a continuallyupdated service that gets better the more people use it, consuming and remixing data from multiple sources, including individual users, while providing their own data and services in a form that allows remixing by others, creating network effects through an “architecture of participation,” and going beyond the page metaphor of Web 1.0 to deliver rich user experiences (p. 17). Today Web 2.0 is an umbrella term defining the various activities that integrate technology, social interaction, and content creation. The web is a platform upon which software applications can be built. Some common applications are web services, social networking, blogs, wikis, video sharing, podcasts, Really Simple Syndication (RSS), mashups, tagging, and wikis. The focus of Web 2.0 is on connecting people and harnessing collective intelligence. Users are the producers of content and not just the consumers of information. Data can be combined from more than one source and integrated into a single source called “mashups.” Users can “tag” or identify their content and can customize the organization of their information—often referred to as “folksonomy” or social bookmarking (Chang & Kannan, 2008). Common examples of technologies introduced to increase the usability of the Internet, integration, and re-use are AJAX (asynchronous JavaScript), XML (extensible markup language), and Open API (application programming interface).
3.2 How Is Web 2.0 Different from Web 1.0? Building upon the basic components, i.e., technologies, concepts of communities and networks, and the production, consumption, and remixing of data, Web 2.0 can be distinguished from Web 1.0 on several core characteristics: control, content, communication, classification systems, data, data searches, diffusion, users, and technologies. Table 8.1 depicts how Web 1.0 is distinguished from Web 2.0. This paradigm shift from a controlled, static web environment characterized by Web 1.0 to a dynamic, decentralized, and networked environment has many implications and challenges for government agencies. The Web 2.0 environment is user centric and offers multiple channels. No longer can government agencies follow a “build it and they will come” mentality. Instead, government agencies need to consider engaging users in their social network sites and online communities. Government agencies need to explore new ways of disseminating information through blogs, microblogs, RSS feeds, podcasts, video files, and wikis. This is a shift from merely presenting information to outreaching and sharing information
168
F.D.L. Wigand Table 8.1 Distinctions between Web 1.0 and Web 2.0
Core characteristics
Web 2.0 characteristics
Web 1.0 characteristics
Control
Centralized and authoritarian
Content Communication
Published by Web site owner (business or government) Unidirectional; talking
Decentralized and democratic Created by end users
Classification systems Data Data searches
Directories and taxonomies Static Portals
Data diffusion Technologies Users
Stickiness HTML Individuals are passive consumers of information
Multidirectional and interactive; listening Tagging and folksonomy Dynamic—remixing Web search engines, web crawlers or spiders Syndication AJAX, XTML, API Networks of individuals and communities are collaborating and producers of content
Source: Adapted from Chang and Kannan (2008, p. 16) and Drapeau and Wells (2009, p. 2).
with citizens. Moreover, governmental organizations will need to find ways to harness the collaborative environment enabled by these technologies, i.e., listen to users and not just talk at them, and use the input to build better services. More importantly, public administrators at all levels of government will have to decide if the benefits are worth the investment and the challenges to be overcome.
3.3 Rationale and Definitions for Comparable Web 2.0 Technologies Eight fundamental Web 2.0 tools/technologies were selected as a means for comparing the adoption by government agencies in Canada and the United States. They are blogs, microblogs, mashups, podcasts, RSS feeds, social networking sites, video sharing, and wikis. These eight tools were selected because each demonstrates one or more of the basic concepts of Web 2.0: enhance user-generated content, extend the reach of communications to new audiences, build relationships via social networks, create collaborative environments with internal and external stakeholders, and increase stakeholder engagement. Before conducting a review of existing Web 2.0 initiatives adopted by Canadian and US governments, a brief summary of common definitions used to describe these eight Web 2.0 tools/technologies is presented (Chang & Kannan, 2008, p. 11; WebContent.gov, 2009): Blogs: Chronological journal entries made on a Web site about a particular topic. Blogs are primarily text and images. Blogs are an historical archive of the topic.
8
Adoption of Web 2.0
169
Microblogs are another form of blogging, but created in a short text message style. Twitter is a prime example of a popular microblog service. Blogs and microblogs are excellent technologies for distributing content to the stakeholders. Microblog sites include Twitter.com, Jaiku.com, Tumblr.com, and Plurk.com. Mashups: A web application combining data from multiple sources to be integrated into a single-integrated service. The data from either source were created for different purposes. An example is using Goog