This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
0, and let d n = d(Kn, OC). Show there is a convex, strictly increasing function 0.) 15. Let T
0'»
satisfies the inequalities p (z) :::: log IAn ,
=
for all z E k n \Kn - I , n 2: 1. (Define Ko ¢.) Why is p a subharmonic function in O? (iii) For 0 C, (rn)n~I' a strictly increasing sequence of positive numbers, convergent to 00, and (IAn).;,::h a sequence of strictly positive numbers, show there is a subharmonic function p in C such that p(z) 2: log IAn,
=
for all Z E 8(0, rn)\B(O, rn-I), n :::: I. (Define ro = -1.) (iv) Let f E &(0), show that there is a subharmonic function p in 0 such that
i
If1 2 e- P dm <
00.
=
Conclude that there is a locally integrable function g in 0 such that og/oi f in the sense of distributions. Use Exercise 2.1.1 (d) to conclude, without appeal to the results in [8G, §3.2.1], that
o oi: COO(n>
--*
C""(O)
is surjective.
3. Let p be a subharmonic function in an open set 0
t= C satisfying (a) log (1 + Iz12) =
O(p(z», ZEn, and (b) there exist constants C" C 2 , C 3 , C4 > 0 such that if ZEn, ~ E C, and Iz - ~I ~ exp(-C1P(z) - C 2 ), then ~ En and ~ C3 P(z) + C4 • Show that Wp(O) nJe'(O) = Ap(O).
pen
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions In [BG, §3.5] we have introduced the concept of a multiplicity variety V. Let us recall that it consists of a collection of pairs (Zk> mk), Zk distinct points of C, mk E N*, called the multiplicities of the points Zko and either the collection is finite or IZk I --+ 00. We shall assume throughout that we are in the latter case. We say that 1; E V to indicate that 1; is one of the points Zk. Given two multiplicity varieties, V = (Zko mdk~l, V' = (z;, mj)j~l' we say that V' C; V when (z;)j~1 is a subsequence of (zkh~l and, for the corresponding indices, we have mj ~ mk. For f an entire function, f ¢ 0, V (f) is the collection of zeros of f, with their respective multiplicities. More generally, we recall that for a collection of functions (h )jeJ. V «h )jeJ) denotes the multiplicity variety of their common zeros (Zdk~l and common multiplicities mk = inf{m(fj. Zk) :
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
119
j E Jl. The Weierstrass theorem [BG, §3.3.l] asserts that for every multiplicity variety V, there is I E Jt"(C) such that V = V (f). Given a multiplicity variety V, we also defined the space A(V) of holomorphic functions on V, i.e., doubly indexed sequences of complex numbers (ak,l )k,[, 0 .::s [ < mk. The reason for this notation is that there is a natural restriction map p: Jt"(C) -+ A(V) given by
g(I)(Zk») peg) = ( - [ - I•
. k,1
Given a sequence a E A(V) we say that the entire function g interpolates it, if peg) = a. The interpolation theorem [BG, §3.4.1] states that p is always surjective. The proof uses in an essential manner that variety V satisfies V = V(f) for some IE Jt"(C)\{Oj. In this section we discuss the corresponding interpolation problem for the space Ap (C). We shall assume throughout that the multiplicity variety V satisfies the non triviality condition V S; V(f)
for some I E Ap(C)\{Oj. We follow [BT 1] and we refer the reader to the references therein for other approaches to the interpolation problem. We start first by defining a space of holomorphic functions with growth conditions on a multiplicity variety. This space must be a good candidate to be the image of Ap(C) by the restriction map p: Jt"(C) -+ A(V). It turns out that there are several natural candidates. The first one is given in the following definition: 2.2.1. Definition. Let V = (Zk> mdk;::l be a multiplicity variety. We denote by Ap(V) the space of sequences (ak,{ h,l E A(V) such that there are constants A, B ~ 0 for which
L
lak'!l.::s
A exp(Bp(Zk»
(k ~
1).
O::;:i<m,
2.2.2. Proposition. For any I that
LI
1(I)(z)
- - I-
1;::0
I.
E Ap(C)
there are constants A ~ 0, B ~ 0, such
I .::s Aexp(Bp(z»
(z E C).
In particular, p(Ap(C» S; Ap(V).
Proof, Assume that I/(t)1 .::s A1eB1p(t) for every t E C. Let z E C be fixed. For any t E B(z. 2) there is { E B(z. 1) such that It - {I .::s 1, hence pet)
.::s
Cop(l;)
+ Do .::s cJp(z) + (Co + l)Do.
Taking these inequalities into account, the Cauchy inequalities 1(/)(z)
I-1-'• -
I
1
:::; 21 II-zl::::2 max 1/(t)1
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
120
yield the following estimate:
~ If(l)(z) I:5 2 ~ where A
I!
max If(t)1 :5 2 max AleB'P(t) :5 AeBp(z) , II-zl:S2
II-zl!:2
= 2Ale(Co+I)Do, B = BleB.
o
In general, as we shall see in some examples below, Ap(V) #- p(Ap(C». The reason is that the definition of Ap(V) was done basically taking only into account local conditions. In order to facilitate the appearance of global conditions we proceed as follows: Let r > 0 and z E C, define p(z, r) := maxp(z 1'1:5'
+ ~).
The same argument as that in Proposition 2.2.2 leads to the existence of A > 0, B > 0, such that f(l)(z) I L r' :5 A exp(Bp(z, r», I t~O I. - - I-
for any
z E IC
and
r > O.
This inequality leads naturally to a different candidate for a space of holomorphic functions with growth conditions on a multiplicity variety.
2.2.3. Definition. Let V = (Zko mdk~1 be a multiplicity variety, denote by Ap,oo(V) the space of sequences (ak,th" E A(V) for which there are constants A > 0, B > 0, such that for every r > 0 and every k E N*
L
lak,dr':5 A exp(B(p(Zko r».
O:sl<mk
The following result is immediate:
2.2.4. Proposition. The following inclusions hold: p(Ap(C»
S Ap,oo(V) S Ap(V).
We are now ready to state the interpolation problems of interest to us.
2.2.5. Definition. Let V = (Zko mkh~l be a multiplicity variety. We say that V is an interpolation variety for Ap(C) if p(Ap(C) = Ap(V). If p(Ap(C» = Ap,oo(V) we say that V is a weak interpolation variety. These are only two, the simplest two, definitions of interpolation variety. We shall only study the problem of deciding when V is an interpolation variety, and relegate the similar study for weak interpolation varieties to the exercises.
2.2.6. Lemma. Let V = (Zk, mk)k~l be an interpolation variety for Ap(IC). There are two constants, Clo C2 > 0, and functions hk E Ap(C) such that for every k 2: 1:
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
(i) Ihk(z)1 :::: CI exp(c2P(Z» (z E C); (ii) for every j ::f. k, one has hj/)(zd
(iii) hfl (Zk) = 0 for all 0 :::: I :::: (iv) him.-1)(Zk) = (mk - I)!.
121
= 0 for 0:::: I :::: mk -
I;
2;
mk -
In other words, (p(hk»j,1
= 8j ,k 81,m.-I,
where 8a ,b is the Kronecker delta symbol.
Proof. We leave it as an exercise for the reader to give a simple proof based on the open mapping theorem. We give here a proof using a minimum of functional analysis. For that purpose, let S := {(ak,/)
L
E Ap(V):
laul:::: I for every
k
~ I}.
O:sl<m.
Consider on S the distance induced by the norm
III (ak,/) II I := sup
L
lak,/l.
k:::I O:;:l<m.
It is easy to verify that S is a complete metric space. For n E N°, let Sn := {p(/): f E Ap(C), If(z)1 :::: n exp(np(z», Vz E
q n s.
We claim that Sn is a closed subset of S. Let (gj)j:::1 be a sequence in Ap(
_J_ _
I!
~a
j_oo k.l·
Therefore, peg) = (au),
and (ak,/) E Sn' Since we are assuming that p is surjective. we have
The Baire Category Theorem [Hor] allows us to conclude there is an no E N* such that Sno ::f. 0. It is obvious that each Sno is a balanced convex set, i.e., it is convex and jf a E Sno and A E
to.
122
For k
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p ~
1, let ak
= (aJ.I)j.1 =
O;.kOI.m,-1 E
S,
and let A be a fixed number. 0 < )... < roo Then Aa k E 8(0, ro). Hence there is IPk E Ap(lC) such that
s
IIPk(Z)1
no exp(nop(z»
and P(IPk)
The choice hk = IPk/)...,
CI
= Aa
k•
= no/A, and C2 = no has the required properties. 0
As we have seen in [BGl, interpolation problems are related to the structure of the ideals in the algebra of holomorphic functions. This is the reason we start by studying the finitely generated ideals of the algebras Ap(iC).
2.2.7. Definition. Let fl,"" fn E Ap(IC). The local ideal generated by h, ... , fm is the set [loc(fl, ... , fm) of all the functions g E Ap(iC) such that for every z E IC there is an open neighborhood Q of z and functions gl, ... ,gm E Jt"(Q) so that glQ =
L
gj(/jIQ).
I::;j::;m
It is easy to verify that [loc(fl •... , fm) is an ideal in Ap(iC). Moreover, if ] is the ideal generated by h, ... , fm in Jt"(IC) we have [loc(!I. ... , fm)
= ] n Ap(iC).
We have shown in the previous volume that any finitely generated ideal in ;f(iC) is closed [BO, Corollary 3.5.8]. Since the injection i: Ap(lC) -+ Jt"(IC) is
continuous, we conclude that [locUI, ... , fm)
= i-Ie])
is closed in Ap(iC). We denote by [(flo ... , fm) the ideal generated by h,.·., fm in Ap(C) and, by l(fl, ... , fm), its closure in Ap(C). In general, we only have the inclusion l(fl, ... , fm) 5:; l)oc(fl, ... , fm), without equality.
2.2.8. Definition. Let fl,"" fm if
E Ap(IC).
We say they are jointly invertible
When m = I, we say that f E Ap(C) is invertible if [(f) = [Ioc(f). For instance, when p(z) = IZI, Lindelof's theorem [BG, §4.5.7J proves that, in the case Ap(C) = Exp(C), every nonzero function f is invertible. Note that f being invertible does not mean I/f E Ap(C). In fact, only if f is invertible and has no zeros then 1/f E A p (IC).
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
123
2.2.9. Lemma. Assume that II, ... , 1m are jointly invertible. Given A > 0, there are B > 0 and C > 0 such that if h E Iloc(fI, ... ,1m) and Ih(z)1 ~ exp(Ap(z»,
there exists gl, ... , gm E Ap(C) with
L
h=
gJfj
I:;;j:;;m
and Igj (z) I ~ C exp(Bp(z»,
lor
I S j
sm.
Proof. We give a proof similar to that of Lemma 2.2.6. Consider
s
S = {h E I(ft, ... , 1m): Ih(z)1 with the metric d(h, g)
= sup(e-Ap(z)lh(z) -
exp(Ap(z))),
g(z)!),
ZEIC
induced by the norm of the Banach space Ap.A(C), Let us verify that S is a complete metric space. Given a Cauchy sequence (hn)n?:1 in S, it is easy to find a subsequence (h",h?:1 and h E Ap(CC) such that Ih(z)1
s
exp(Ap(z»
and as
k --+
00.
If V = V (fl, ... , 1m), (Zj, mj) E V, then hn~ vanishes at Zj with multiplicity ~ m j. It follows the same is true for h. Hence,
hE Iloc(fI, ... , 1m) = l(fl, ... , 1m).
This shows that S is a complete metric space. Consider now the linear continuous and surjective mapping
8: (Ap(C)m --+ /(/10 ... , 1m), 8(gl, ... , gm):=
L
gJfj.
I:;;j :;;m
As pointed out above, the ideal I (flo ... , 1m) = floc (fl, ... , f m) is a closed SUbset of Ap(C). For n E N*, denote Sn
:= {(gl, ... , gm) E (Ap(c»m: Igj(z)1
s
ne np (z)(1 S j S m)} n S.
We claim that S" is a closed subset of S. In fact, let (hl)I>1 ~ S" and h E S 1--+ 00. Each hi = 8(gl./' .. ~, gm,I), Igj,l(z) I S ne"p(z). We can therefore extract subsequences (gj.hh?:J and functions gj E ,w(C) such that
be such that d(h l , h) --+ 0 as
124
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
Hence for all and
L
gj.IJJ -+
t:sj:sm
L
gJj
Z
E
C,
in Jf"(C).
l:sj:sm
Therefore, h = 8(gl, ... , gm). In other words. h E Sn. Since 8 is surjective. S = Un>1 Sn. There is then an integer no such that Sno ¥= 0. As in Lemma 2.2.6. Sn is a balanced convex set. Therefore. for some ro > 0, the ball B(O, ro) = {h E S. d(O, h) < ro} is contained in Sno' Let 0 < A < roo Then for any h E S we have ).h E B(O. ro). This means that there are gt.···. gn E Ap(C). and 8(gl • ...• gm) = )'h.
Letting B = no and C = nol). we conclude the proof of the lemma.
0
Remark. Note that if hE lloc(fl, ...• fm) and h satisfies Ihl:::: De AP • then we can conclude from Lemma 2.2.9 that h = LI:Sj:sm gj/j and Igj I :::: DCe BP • Let us now state the main result of this section. 2.2.10. Theorem. Let !J, ... , fm E Ap(C) and V:= V(fl, ...• fm) be the multiplicity variety of their common zeros. Assume there are e > 0, C > 0, such that for every (Zk. mk) E Vane has
L
l:sj:Sm
limkl(Zk)1 J
,
~eexp(-Cp(Zk».
mk·
Then V is an interpolation variety for Ap(C). Conversely, if V is an interpolation variety for Ap(C) and if the functions fl, ...• fm are jointly invertible, then there are e > O. C > O. such that the inequality (*) holds for every (Zk. mk) E V. Proof. Let us start proving that in case lloc(f" ... , fm) = l(fl, ... , fm). the inequality (*) is a necessary condition for V to be an interpolation variety. If V is an interpolation variety, from Lemma 2.2.6 we conclude there are constants C I , C 2 > 0 and functions hk E Ap(C) such that Ihk(z)1 :::: C I exp(C2P(Z»
and The functions
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
vanish at every Zj with multiplicity over, for some A > 0 we have
125
~ mj'
Hence
rpk
E Iloc(!I, ... , /m). More-
+ IZkD(1 + Izl)lhk(z)1 ::: C I (1 + IZkD exp(Ap(z», used that 10g(1 + IzD = O(p(z». Hence, we can apply
Irpk(Z)1 ::: (1
where we have the previous lemma and the corresponding remark to conclude that there are constants B, C > 0, and entire functions gl,b ... ,gm,k such that rpk
L
=
k
gj,k/j,
~
I
I~j~m
and (Z E C),
with C2 = CCI. The choice of the fonn
hk
ensures that the Taylor expansion of
rpk
about
Zk
is of
Condition (t) now implies that 1_< ' "
1
()ll.rr*)(Zk)l
~ gj,k Zk l:'Oj:'Om
, mk·
::: C3 exp(C4P(Zk»
L
If(m')(Zk)1
l:'Oj:'Om
mk'
J
,
'
using once more that log( I + IZk I) = 0 (P(Zk». This inequality is clearly equivalent to (*). We shall now prove that the inequalities (*) imply that V is an interpolation variety for Ap(C). We start by reminding the reader that a corollary of the Minimum Modulus Theorem is the following: 2.2.11. Lemma. Let 1/1 be a/unction holomorphic in 8(0, 2eR), assume that
max
1~I:'02eR
II/I(~)I.:::
M
and
11/1(0)1
~
{, > 0,
then there is a value r, R/4.::: r .::: R/2 such that (**)
min (log II/I(~)I) ~ 9 log .5 - 8 log M. 1~I=r
PrOOf of Lemma 2.2.11. Let us recall the Minimum Modulus Theorem as stated in ([BG, Theorem 4.5.14] or [Lev, Chapter I, Theorem 11]): If / is a holornorphic function in a neighborhood of 8(0, 2eR), 1(0) = 1, and '1 E ]0, 3e/2[,
126
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
then there is a finite family of exceptional closed disks, the sum of whose radii does not exceed 4'1R, such that for z E 8(0, R) and outside the exceptional disks, the following inequality holds log II(z)1
~-
(2 +
log
~~) log M(f, 2eR).
Let us choose 1'/ so that 811R < R14, e.g., 1'/ = 1/33. The width of the annulus R/4 S Izl S RI2 is R/4 and the exceptional collection of disks can at most have width equal to the sum of their diameters, i.e., at most 811R. Hence, there exists r E [R/4, R/2] such that these disks do not intersect the circle Izl = r, so that log If(z)1 > -8 log M(f, 2eR) for all z, Izl = r. Let f(z) 1/I(z)/fJ, then
=
min (log 11/I(z)l-log8) > -8(logM(1/I, 2eR) -log8). Izl=r
In other words, min log 11/I(z)1 > 910g8 - 8 log M(1/I, 2eR), Izl='
o
which is the desired inequality (**). Note that the same argument shows that one can take r We also need the following lemma:
E
]3RI4, R[.
2.2.12. Lemma. Let g be afunction holomorphic in I~ I < 1, continuous in I~ I ~ 1, and bounded in absolute value by M. Assume further that g has a zero of order q at a point ~ = a, 0 < lal < I, and a zero of order m at the origin. If Ig(m)(O)1
=--,--'-' m. then
~
8 > 0,
8 lal q ~ M'
Proof of Lemma 2.2.12. Define an auxiliary function h by the identity
g(~) = ~m (I~ --a~) q h(n· The function h will then be in the disk algebra, Ih(~)1 S M, h(O) =1= 0, h(a) =1= O. Differentiating m times the defining equation for h and letting ~ = 0, one finds g(m)(o) = (-a)qh(O).
m! Therefore,
o
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
127
Let us now return to the proof of Theorem 2.2.10. Let (Zk. mk)
E
V and define
dk := infll, inflzi -zkll. j#
If dk < I, choose some Zj such that dk = IZj - zd. Since we are assuming that (*) holds, there must be an index j, 1 S j S m, such that If(m;)(zj)1 J
mj!
e
~ _ exp(-Cp(Zj».
m
We shall apply now Lemma 2.2.12 to the function max Ig(OI I{I~I
s
max max Ijj(zj
I~j~m 1,1~2,
+ ~)I s
g(~)
:= jj(Zj
+n
Then
M := Mo exp(NoP(zj»
for some constants Mo, No > 0 that depend only on the bounds for the generators jj. We have now la I = dk and q = mk in the statement of the lemma, hence m e Mdk I ~ - exp(-Cp(Zj». m
Since p(Zj)
s
Cop(z.)
+ Do, we obtain
(tt) for some AI > 0, 0< el S I. Clearly the same inequality holds if dk = I. In order to apply the semi local interpolation Theorem 2. 1.4 we need to show that we can choose £0 > and Ao > 0 such that, for every k ~ I, the connected component Uk of S(lfl, eo, Ao) that contains Zk satisfies Uk £ B(Zko dk/2). Let us choose j so that
°
(#)
and, for
RI s
2e, define
1/1 by the equality ~m'1/I(O
We have for some A2 > 0,
11/1(0)1 =
e2
= jj(Zk
> 0,
If(m ll (Zk )d;"1 J
+dk~)'
mk!
~ e2 exp(-A2P(zk»,
as a consequence of (tt). Moreover, max
RI~2e
11/I(~)1
= (2e)-m, max Ijj(Zk +dkOI 1{1=2,
S max Ijj(Zk Irl~2,
+ r)1
S Moexp(NoP(zk».
It would be tempting to conclude that 1/1 has no zeros in B(O, I), but all We know is that there are no other common zeros to all the jj in B (Zk, dd. Nevertheless, thanks to the Minimum Modulus Theorem we can find r, 1/4 S r :::: 1/2, to which the inequality (**) of Lemma 2.2.11 applies. That is, for all {,I~I = r, log
11/I(~)1 ~ 9 log 11/1(0)1 -
Slog (max
Irl~2e
11/1(1')1) .
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
128
Translating this inequality into an inequality for jj, we have that there are constants e3 > 0 and A3 > 0 so that Ijj(Zk
+ dk~)1
::: e34-mk exp( -A3P(Zk»,
=
whenever I~ I r. We still need to estimate the multiplicity mk to obtain a good estimate. This will depend once more on the inequality (#). We have
-1-1
I/rk)(zk)1 = mk! 2Jri
jj(z) dz iz-zki=e (z - Zk)mk+1 '
so that
In other words, for some A 4 , B4 > O. We conclude that there are Ao, Bo > 0 and r, 1/4::: r ::: 1/2, such that Ilj(z)1 ::: eoexp(-Aop(z»
when Iz - zkl = rdk. This shows that the connected component Uk of the set S(l/I, eo, Ao)
= {Z EC:
(L
Ijj(Z)12)
1/2 < eoe-AOP(z)} ,
I::;J:<:m
which contains Zk. must be contained in B(zko dk/2). To conclude the proof of the theorem, let (ak,lh,1 E Ap(V) and define a holomorphic function Xin S(I/I. Eo, Ao) by ()..IUk)(z)
=
" " ~
ak,l(z - Zk) I
and j. == 0 on S(I/I. eo, AO)\(Uk>l Uk). Since (ak./h.1 E Ap(V), there are constants A, B > 0 such that
L
lak."::: AeBp(Zk)
(k ::: I).
O::;i<mk
Hence I(XIUk)(z)l:::
E
lak."
(~k)':::
O::;i<m,
L
lak."::: AeBp(z,) ::: A'eB'p(z) ,
O:<:/<mk
for some A', 8' > O. Clearly this inequality is valid in the whole of S(I/I, eo, Ao). Applying the semilocal interpolation Theorem 2.1.4 to X, we conclude there exists I E Ap(C) such that p(f)
= (ak,l)k,l.
This concludes the proof of the theorem.
o
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
129
In the case of principal ideals there is a simple analytic condition to ensure that f E Ap(C) is invertible. 2.2.13. Definition. A function f E Ap(C) is said to be slowly decreasing if there are positive constants 6, A, and B such that: (i) every connected component Va of SClfl, 6, A) is relatively compact; and (ii) for every z, ~ E Va, p(~) ~ Bp(z) + B.
2.2.14. Proposition. Any slowly decreasing function is invertible.
Proof. Assume that g
E
.Jt"(C) is such that h = gf
E
Ap(C), i.e., there are
constants C, D > 0 such that Ig(z)f(z)1
~
(z E C).
Cexp(Dp(z»
Let Va be a connected component of the set S(lfl, definition. On the boundary of Va we have If(z)1 hence for z
E
= 6e- Ap
6,
A) given by the previous
(z),
aVa we have
Ig(z)1
~
C
- exp«A 6
+ D)p(z»
~
C
- exp«A 6
+ D) ml:!Xp(~». t;eU.
Since Va is bounded, we can apply the Maximum Principle and obtain C Ig(z) I ~ - exp«A S
+ D) ma,x p(~»,
z EVa'
t;eU.
Using condition (ii) from Definition 2.2.13, we can replace this inequality by Ig(z)1
~
E exp(F(p(z»,
for all z E Va, for some E, F > 0 independent of the component VCt • Therefore, this inequality holds in S(lfl, 6, A). On the other hand, for z ¢ S(lfl, 6, A), CeDp(z) C Ig(z)1 ~ If(z)1 ~ exp«A + D)p(z».
e
o
It is now clear that g E Ap(C) and /U) = iIocU).
2.2.15. Proposition. Let p be a radial weight that satisfies the doubling condition p(2z) = O(p(z», then every f E Ap(iC)\{O} is slowly decreasing. Proof. It is enough to show that there exist a point Zo and two constants 6, A > 0 such that for all r » 1 one can find rl, r2 satisfying r
2 ~ rl inf{l/(z)l: Iz - zol
= rl
< r < r2 ~ 2r,
or Iz - zol
= r2}
~
6exp(-Ap(r».
Since, in this case, we can find a strictly increasing sequence of radii R n , Rn -+ 00, Rn+1 ::: 4Rn, such that I/(zo + ~)I ~ exp(-Ap(Rn if RI = Rn.
»
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A"
130
The doubling condition imposed on the weight p implies that if z and z' satisfy Rn ~ Izo + zl :::: Rn+h Rn ~ Izo + z'l :::: Rn+h then p(z) :::: + C;p(z') for some convenient positive constants C;. Thus, the components of the set S(I/I, e, A) satisfy the requirements of Definition 2.2.13. In order to conclude the proof of the proposition, we choose Izol :::: 1 such that I(zo) =1= O. We can now twice apply Lemma 2.2.11 to the function '1/1(1;) == I(zo +~) to obtain '10 '2. 0
Co
Co'
The conditions imposed on p by Proposition 2.2.15 imply immediately that Ip(z)1 = O(lzl")
for some K > 0, while the inequality p(z) :::: Cop(1;) only implies the growth condition
+ Do whenever Iz -
~I~
1,
Ip(z)1 :::: O(e Alzl )
for some A > O. In fact, for a weight like p(z) = e lzl one does not automatically obtain that every I E Ap(IC)\{O) is slowly decreasing, but only that I is slowly decreasing in Aq(C) with a weight q slightly bigger than p (see [Heyl]). The advantage for the interpolation problems of knowing that a function IE Ap(C) is invertible is that then V = V(f) is interpolating if and only if there are e > 0 and C > 0 such that I/(md(Zk)1 > -Cp(z,) ee mk! -
holds for all (Zk. mk) E V. So the interpolation problem has a clear-cut answer in this case. Whence, the interest of Proposition 2.2.15. It is natural to ask whether condition (*) of Theorem 2.2. IO always holds when V = V(f) is interpolating, even if I is no invertible in Ap(iC). The answer is negative as shown by the following example of Squires ([Sq2], see also [Hey2]). Consider the weight p(z) = 11m zl + log(l + Iz12) and the corresponding space Ap(iC), which coincides with the space F(E/(R» of Fourier transforms of distributions of compact support. If IfJ E V(lR), then there is a constant A > 0 such that for every n 2: 0 IFIfJ(z) I < - (1
Cn
+ Izj)n
exp(AI 1m zj)
(z
E
IC),
for some Cn > O. Clearly FIfJ E Ap(iC), but it cannot be slowly decreasing. (It turns out that in this space, slowly decreasing and invertible are two equivalent conditions, hence no such function is invertible.) Since the derivatives of Frp also satisfy similar estimates, condition (*) of Theorem 2.2. IO cannot hold for FIfJ. Nevertheless, Squires has shown that one can find IfJ E 'D(lR) such that FIfJ(z)
=
sin rr z 00
11 n".l
z2) .
(
1-
n 4
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
131
Hence V(Frp) ~ V(sinJrz) (all the zeros are simple). On the other hand, V(sinJrz) = {k E Z, mk == I} is interpolating for Ap(IC), namely
~ (sin Jrz)lz=k =
JrcosJrk = (-1/,
and condition (*) of Theorem 2.2.10 is satisfied for I(z) = sinJrz. Since any multiplicity variety W contained in an interpolating variety for Ap(1C) is itself interpolating, it follows that V (F rp) is interpolating and condition (*) fails for Frp. In fact, the concept of a slowly decreasing function originated in the work of Ehrenpreis about convolution equations in the spaces £(lR) and 1J'(JR) [Eh3], [Eh4]. He proved that in F(£'(JR» any invertible function is slowly decreasing. Let us mention here that for p(z) = 11m zl + log(l + Iz1 2 ), the condition 1 being slowly decreasing is equivalent to the following: There is A > 0 such that for every x E R. the function 1 satisfies max{l/(x
+ 1)1: t E R It I :::: A log(2 + Ix!)}
2: (A
+ Ixl)-A.
We shall show in the next chapter that every exponential polynomial N
I(z) =
L Cj(z)e
iaj "
j=l
satisfies this type of lower bound condition, and hence is slowly decreasing. More generally, the ideas of this chapter are also well adapted to the Beurling weights, p(z) = I Imzl + w(lzJ), where w: [0,00) -+ [0, 00) is an increasing, continuous, subadditive function such that w(O) 0, w(t) 2: a + b logO + t), for some a E R., b > 0, and
=
1
00
o
w(t) --2
1+ t
dt < 00.
These functions appear when we consider spaces of Coo functions where one introduces conditions on the growth of the derivatives (see [Bj], [BD3], [Chou)). To conclude this section, let us rephrase the interpolating procedure used in Theorem 2.2.11. We used condition (*) to find 8, A > 0 such that for any a E Ap(V), there is a holomorphic function X on S(I/I, 8, A) satisfying the correct growth conditions and p(J...) a. It is clear from the proof that the map a ~ ). is a linear continuous map into Ap(S(I/I, 8, A». It is therefore natural to ask whether the procedure a ~ A of Theorem 2.2.11 can be also made linear and continuous, in other words, whether there exists a right inverse E to p. Or What amounts to the same thing, does it exist as an extension operator,
=
po E
= id,
Where E is linear and continuous, under the assumption that V is an interpolation variety? One way to do this is to define >.. using an interpolation series, typically
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A I'
132
some kind of Lagrange series. For instance, if V = V(sinlTz) = Z, p(z) = Izl, one can see that E(a)(z)
sin IT Z = 2::>k( -Ok _k kEZ IT(z)
( Z ) Ik 1 -k
(where for k = 0 the term (zlk)lk l is considered to be 1) is a right inverse to the restriction operator p. More generally, if V = V(f) = {(Zk. l)), one could try to define E(aHz)
= 2:::ak kEl.
fez) f'(zd(z - Zk)
(.:.)Ilk Zk
for a convenient sequence of integers JLk ~ 0 (see [Ge], [BrK], [Lev]). It turns out that this is not possible for every weight p. In a seminal paper, B.A. Taylor [Ta2] considered the problems of finding a right inverse for p and for the Cauchy-Riemann a-operator in the correct spaces. He found that the situation is very different for p(z) = Izl", ex > 0, and p(z) = 11m zl + log(l + IzI2). In the first case, there is a right inverse for and, consequently, linear continuous extension operators E: Ap(V) ~ Ap(C) exist when V is interpolating. In the second case, the extension operator exists if and only if V satisfies the additional condition of lying in a logarithmic strip about the real axis, i.e., there is A > 0
a
I Irnzkl
~
A log(2 + IZkl)
for all
Zk E V.
Such a variety is V is called hyperbolic. We refer the reader to the work of Taylor, Vogt, Meise, et al. for further ramifications of these two questions (e.g., [MeTl], [MeT2], [MeTV]). EXERCISES 2.2.
=
Throughout these exercises we denote by V (Zk. mdki!l a multiplicity variety, which we assume is infinite and satisfies V <; V(f), for some f E Ap(iC), unless explicitly stated otherwise. I. (a) Show that the failure of the condition IZk I --+ 00 in the definition of a multiplicity variety is equivalent to saying there is no entire function f #- 0 such that V V(f). Prove that in such a case the map p: Jt"(iC) --+ A(V) is injective but cannot be surjective. (b) Assume now that IZkl--+ 00, but that there is no f E Ap(C)\{O} such that V <; V(f). Then: (i) show that p: Ap(iC) --+ A(V) is injective; (ii) let e j E A(V) be defined by eL = 8j,k81.0, prove that no e j E p(Ap(iC).
=
2. (a) Show that if V is an interpolation variety for Ap(C) and W <; V, then W is also an interpolation variety. (b) Prove that W = N (with multiplicity I) is an interpolation variety for the space Exp(C). *(c) Can you find a single function I E Exp(C) such that V(n = N? Can you find two functions I .. 12 E Exp(C) such that VUh h) N? (Hint: Recall from [BG, Exercise 2.5.20] that if (zkh". denotes the zeros of f E Exp(C), repeated according to their multiplicities, then the sums ~O~I'kl
=
133
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
3. Let p(z) = IzIP, P > 0, compute explicitly the function p(z, r) defined just before Definition 2.2.3. 4. Show that if the multiplicities
mk ~
M < 00 for all k, then Ap.oo(V)
= Ap(V).
=
*5. For p(z) Izl, construct a multiplicity variety V such that Ap.oo(V) =f. Ap(V). (Hint: Use a variety for which mk :::::: IZkl.)
*6. Let p(z) = IzI P. Use Exercise 2.2.3 to show that a sequence (au) and only if for some A > 0 exp(AlzkjP)
(*)
+ IZkDI
lak." ~ A (I
Furthermore, show that Ap.oo(V) mk
= 0
E Ap.oo(V)
if
(0 ~ / < mb all k).
= Ap(V) if and only if
COg(~z~IZkD) ,
as
k -+
00.
Show also that in this case, (*) is equivalent to the existence of B > 0 such that laul ~ *7. Let p(z) = I Imzl someA>O
Thus Ap.oo(V)
Bexp(BlzkI P ) (/!)I/P .
+ log(l + IzI2),
then (ak./)
la k.1 I -<
I!
E Ap.oo(V)
if and only if for
AI+ 1 exp(Ap(Zk» .
= Ap(V) if and only if mk -
0 (
-
p(Zt) ) logp(zk)
as
k -+
00.
What restriction on the multiplicities does this condition imply when Zk is on the real axis? (Hint: Compute p(z, r) for this weight function.) 8. Simplify the proofs of Lemmas 2.2.6 and 2.2.9 using the open mapping theorem, i.e., Proposition 1.5.1, instead of the Baire category argument given in the text. 9. Let V be an interpolation variety for Ap(C), dk := min{l, min Iz}· - zkll. j",k
Show that there are positive constants e, A, B, C > 0 such that for all k
and mk ~ Bp(Zk)
+ C.
(Hint: Use Lemma 2.2.6 and reconsider the proof of Theorem 2.2.10 without assuming that V is of the form V (fl ..... 1m), with !J, ... , 1m jointly invertible.) 10. (a) Use the previous exercise to show that a necessary condition for a sequence (zkh~l of distinct points converging to 00 to be an interpolation variety for the space Exp(C) is the existence of a constant A > 0 such that inf{lz· - zkleA
i;4t
}
O.
134
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
(b) Let (zkh~1 be a sequence of distinct real numbers, IZk I -+ 00. A necessary condition for it to be an interpolation variety for the space :F(E'(JR» is the existence of N > 0 such that
11. Let V = V(fl, ... , 1m), It. ... , 1m jointly invertible in Ap(C). Show that V is an interpolation variety if and only if there are e, A > 0 such that: (i) each Zk E V belongs to a component of S(lfl, e, A) of diameter at most I; and (ii) no two distinct points of V lie in the same component of S(lfl, e, A). 12. Let p(z)
= Izl,
V
= {k E Z, mk = 1; ±(k + e(k», mk =
1}, with e(k)
E
JR, 0
<:
IE(k)1 <: ~.
(a) Show that there exists I E Ap(C) such that V = V(f). Find a condition on e(k) so that there cannot exist 8 > 0, such that Vk E Z.
Show that this condition is independent of the choice of f. (b) Choose two functions EI (k), e2(k) as in part (a) with the additional condition that el (k) <: 0 and E2(k) > 0, let flo fz be the corresponding functions of part (a). Show that V(fh fz) = V(sinrrz), which is interpolating. Why is this not a contradiction to Theorem 2.2.10? *13. Find an even entire function f of exponential type such that it vanishes at all the points x + iy E Z + iZ of the form Ix - nJI :S nj' Iyl :S nj, for an increasing sequence of integers nj , such that nj -+ 00 sufficiently fast. Show that V (f) cannot be an interpolation variety for Exp(lC), even though the conditions on dk , mk from Exercise 2.2.9 are satisfied. (Hint: Check whether the value of 1f'(nj)1 is too small. This depends only on the behavior (Z/Zk)2), where Zk lies in the block of zeros surrounding nJ.) of the finite product
no -
= IzI
14. Let).. E JR+ \IQ!, p(z) and
P,
P:::
1,
fez) == sin(rrz) sin(nz/)..),
{I).. - ;; I: m :S n, mEN} ,
n E N°.
Find necessary and sufficient conditions for V(f) to be an interpolating variety in Ap(C) in terms of the behavior of
E
E'CIi..), f(t;) := (Tx' e- ix ,) be the Fouriertransform:FT of T. Let P(D) =
L7~o Gj Dj and be a linear differential operator with constant coefficients.
(a) Show that if there is S E E'(JR) such that peDiS = T, then I(t;)/ P(it;) is an entire function. (b) Let q(z) = amz m + ... + ao be a polynomial of degree m, h a holomorphic function in B(O, 1). Show that lamh(O)1 :S max Iq(z)h(z)l· 1,1';;1
=
=
(Hint: Use that when Izi 1, Iq(z)1 Ir(z)l, r(z) = am + am_Iz + ... + aoz m.) (c) Assume that g(~) := I(r;)/ PUt;) is an entire function. For ~ fixed consider q(z) := P(i (z + r;)) to show that lamllg(~)1
::: max 1/(r; + z)l· Izl!S1
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
135
Conclude that there is S E £'(IR) such that :FS = g, T = P(D)S, and cv(suppS) = cv(supp T). (This proves that any polynomial is invertible in Ap(e), for p(z) I Imzl + 10g(1 + Iz 12 ). In fact, it proves the same result holds for any weight p.) (d) Show that for some constant C > 0, IP(z)1 ~ Cd(z, v(p»m. Use this to prove that P is slowly decreasing in any Ap(e).
=
16. Prove that I sinzl ~ Cd(z, nZ)e11m'l for some C > O. Use this to show that sinz is slowly decreasing in any Ap(e) such that p(z) ~ 11m zl + logO + IzI2). 17. For B > 0 let us define Yl..I := Yl..I(B) := inf{rl exP(Bp(Zb
r»: r > O},
Yk := Yk(B) := Yk.ml-I(B).
Show that a = (au)
E Apoo(V)
implies that for some A> 0, B > 0, lak.ll :::: AYk,I(B).
*18. Let fl' ... , f m be jointly invertible and V = V (fl, ' .. , f m) a weak interpolation variety. Follow the notation of the previous exercise. Show that for every B > 0 there are constants e, C > 0 such that
~
1.fj(mk)(zk)1
j=1
mk·
L.....-
,~eYi
(B)
-ep(',)
e
'.
(Hint: Consider functions hk like those in Lemma 2.2.6 with condition (iv) replaced by (iv)' hlmk-')(zd = (mk - I)! nCB). Follow the proof of the necessity part in Theorem 2.2.10.) *19. For each k
~
1, let Rk
= R.(B)
~
1 be a value such that
R;;(ml-l) exp(Bp(Zko Rk»
:::: 2n(B).
Assume that fl,"" fm E Ap(e), V = V(fl,"" 1m), are such that for each B > 0 there exist constants e, C lo C2 , C3 > 0 so that for all (Zk> mk) E V the following three properties hold: (i) mk :::: C 1P(Zk) + C 2 : (ii) P(Zk: 2Rd :::: CIP(Z) + C 2 Vz E B(Zk, 2R k ): ...
(Ill)
m
Ilmk)(zk)1
j=1
mk·
L: }
,
~ eYk(B) exp( -C 3P(Zk».
Prove that: (a) V is a weak interpolation variety. (b) There are 8, KO, KI, K2 > 0 such that every Zk E V belong to a bounded component of S(I/I, 8, Ko) with the properties: (i) p(z) :::: KIP(l;) + K2 for any two points z and l; in the same component; and (ii) no two distinct points of V lie in the same component of S(I/I, Il, Ko). (Hint: Apply Lemma 2.2.12 to the function g(l;) = jj (Zk + Rkl;), for a convenient choice of j. Conclude that
I/(z)1 ::: Yk(B)
Iz - zkl mk R mk
1}
exp( -Cp(Zk»,
k
for Iz - Zk I < ~ Rko where of Theorem 2.2.10.)
1},
C > 0 are suitable constants. Fol1ow the rest of the proof
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
136
*20. Let p(z) = Izl P , P > 0, and follow the notation of the preceding exercise. (a) Show that mk = O(P(Zk», Rk = O(p(zd), and condition (ii) always holds for this particular weight. (b) Show that condition (iii) is equivalent to ~
f;;(
1ft,) (zk)1 mk!
> eexp(-Ciz,IP) (I + IZk I)m,
for some convenient e, C > O. (Compare with the previous Exercise 2.2.6.) (c) Conclude that when fI. ... , fm are jointly invertible the condition in part (b) is equivalent to V being a weak interpolation variety. "21. Let f be a slowly decreasing function in F(e'(R» and V = V(f). (a) Show that mk = O(P(Zk», Rk = O(P(Zk» and condition (ii) of Exercise 2.2.19 holds (here p(z) = 11m zl + 10g(1 + IzI2». (b) Use Exercises 2.2.7 and 2.2.19 to show that V is a weak. interpolation variety if and only if there are e, C > 0 so that If (m,)(z )1 > eexp(-Clzkl) k
for every Zk
E
-
+ IZkl)C
(1
V.
22. Show that if for some A, B > 0, lak I ~ Ae B1kl for all k ~
sin7fz
fez) := L."ak(-l)k ( _ k)
keZ
(where (z/ k)lkl == 1 for k ak for every k E Z.
7f
E
Z, then the function
(Z) Ikl k
Z
= 0), is an entire function of exponential type such that f(k) =
23. Let V = hh~I. IZkl - 00, mk == I, and let A(V) be the set of all sequences The object of this problem is to prove there are no linear continuous extension operators E: A(V) _ .1t"(C), poE = id ([Rudl]). The topology on V is that of convergence for each index k. (a) Show that the topology we described is the compact open topology on the space of all functions V-C. (b) Let ek E A(V), ek(Zj) = Ojk. Assume E exists, set gk := E(ek). Show there is a E C such that gk(a) =1= 0 for all k. (c) Let fk: ek!gk(a) E A(V). Show It - 0 in A(V). (d) Use the homogeneity of E to verify Efk(a) = I for all k. Conclude that E cannot be continuous. (aklk~I'
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap In this section we follow [Sk2], [Gul], [KTl], [KT2] to obtain sufficient conditions which imply that a function belongs to a finitely generated ideal in a space Ap. We start by generalizing the Hilbert space ideas that led to Theorem 2.1.3. Let HI> H 2 , H3 be three Hilbert spaces. We denote by (·I·)j their scalar products and by II . IIj the corresponding norms, j = I, 2, 3.
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
137
Consider the following situation:
where (i) Tl is a continuous linear operator and we denote its adjoint Tt: H2 ~ HI; and (ii) T2 is a closed linear operator with dense domain, denoted dom(T2). In this situation, T2 also has an adjoint T2*: H3 with dense domain dom(T2*) and, moreover:
~ HI
which is a closed operator,
(a) (Tn· = T2 ; (b) the conditions x E dom(T2) and y = T2(x) are equivalent to (xIT2*(Z»1 = (ylzh for every z E dom(T2·); and (c) the condition x E kerT2 is equivalent to (xIT2*(Z»1 = 0 for every z E dom(T2*), i.e., ker T2 = (1m TnJ. (see [Hor]).
Now let G 2 be a closed subspace of H2 such that Tl (ker T2 ) the following criterion to decide whether Tl (ker T2) = G2: 2.3.1. Proposition. G 2 that
~ G2.
We have
= Tl (ker T2) if and only if there is a constant C > II Tt"(X2) + T2*(X3) II! ::::
0 such
CIIX2112
for every X2 E G2 and every X3 E dom(Tn. In this case, for every X2 E G2 there is Xl E ker T2 such that Tl (Xl) = X2 and
IIxIII! :::
(l/C)lIx2112 .
•Proof. Let G l = kerT2, it is a closed subspace of HI. Denote still by Tl the operator TtlG l : G l ~ H2. The following lemma shows that Tl(G l ) = G2 if and only if there is C > 0 such that:
2.3.2. Lemma. Let T: E 1 ~ E2 be a continuous linear operator between two Hilbert spaces. In order that T be surjective, it is necessary and sufficient that there is a constant C > 0 such that for every y E E 2 , lIyll2 ::: ClIT*(y)1I1. In this case,for y E E2 there is X EEl such that y T(x) and IIxlll ::: Cllyll2.
=
ProOf of Lemma 2.3.2. Assume T is surjective. Then T is an open map, hence there is a constant C > 0 such that if z E £2, IIzll2 :::: 1, there is X EEl, T(x) = z, IIxll ::: C. Given an arbitrary y E £2, Y ¥= 0, let z = y Illy liz. and let x E El as above, then
lIyl12 = I(zlyhl = I(T(x)lyhl = l(xIT*(Y»d :::: CilT*(y) 111.
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
138
To prove the converse, assume the existence of a constant C > 0 such that for every y E E 2, we have lIyll2 ~ CIIT*(y)llI. Clearly T* is injective, hence for every y E E2 the following map is a well-defined linear map on Im(T*): u: T*(z) ~ (zlyh,
which verifies lu(T*(z»1
= I(zlyhl ~ Iizli211yll2 ~ CIIyll2I1T*(z)II2'
Since EI is a Hilbert space, with the help of the Hahn-Banach theorem, we conclude that there is an x E EI representing the linear form u and IIxlli ~ CIIy III, i.e., (T*(z)lx)1 = u(T*(z» =
(zlyh
for all z E E 2 . Therefore, T(x) = y. This concludes the proof of the lemma. 0 Let us now return to the proof of the proposition. G I is also a Hilbert space, hence G I is isomorphic (including the identity of norms) to its dual G;. On the other hand, Gil ;:; HI / Gt, also with equality of norms. Since G I = ker T2 and, by a previous observation (see [HorD, HI = ker T2 EB Im(Tn,
we have
Therefore, TI (G I) = G2 is equivalent to the existence of a constant C > 0 such that for every X2 E G2 and X3 E dom(Tn we have
II Tt(X2) + T2*(X3)i11
::: CII X2112.
In the case where TI(G I ) = G z, we have IITt(X2)III ::: Cllx2112 which, by Lemma 2.3.2, implies the existence of XI E G 1 with IIxdli ~ Clix2112 and T1(Xl)=X2. 0 The preceding considerations will be applied to the following types of spaces. Let Q be an open set in C, as usual dm denotes the Lebesgue measure on 0, and let rp: Q ~ lR be a continuous function (upper semi-continuous would be enough). Denote by L2(Q, rp) the space of functions in n which are square integrable with respect to the measure e-CP dm. Consider 8/oz as an unbounded operator T from L2(0, rp) into itself with domain dom(T) =
{f
E L 2 (n, rp):
:~
E L 2(n, rp) } ,
where af joz is the derivative in the sense of distributions. The following lemma is essentially included in the proof of Theorem 2.1.3:
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
139
2.3.3. Lemma. T is a closed operator with dense domain.
Proof. verify which hence
The subspace dom(T) contains V(Q), hence it is dense in L2(Q, cp). To that T is closed, let {(fn, T(fn»n~d be a sequence in the graph of T converges to (f, g) in the graph norm. In particular, In --+ I in V'(Q), afn/az --+ af/az in V'(Q). But afn/az = T(fn) and T(fn) --+ g in L2(Q, cp) ensures that g af/az in V'(Q). Hence I E dom(T) and T(f) = g.
=
o
n,
Now let CPI, CP2 be two continuous real valued functions in and let gl, ... , gn be holomorphic in a neighborhood of which we assume to be compact. Let
n,
H I =H3:=(L 2(Q,CPI»n,
H2:=L 2(Q,CP2),
and use 11·111 to denote both the norm in U(Q,CPI) as well as that in HI' Consider TI (hi, ... , h n ):= gjhj,
L
l~j9
which is clearly continuous HI -
H2 • Define an operator T2: HI -
H3 by:
(a) h = (hi, ... , h n ) E dom(T2) if and only if hj E dom(T) for every j; (b) T2(h) = (ahl/az, ... , ahn/az).
In this case, the space kerT2 is exactly (L2(Q, CPI) n Je"(Qnn. The operator TI sends ker T2 into a closed subspace G2 of L2(Q, cpz), G 2 := L2(Q, CP2)
n Jt"'(Q).
We are in a situation like that of Proposition 2.3.1, hence, in order that every holomorphic function I in L2(Q, cpz) could be written in the form
1=
L
hjgj ,
I~j~n
with h j E L2(Q, CPI) n Je"(Q), it is enough to prove the estimate in Proposition 2.3.1 . . . We will assume henceforth that Q is an open bounded set with Coo regular ~undary and that CPI, CPi are defined and of class C 2 in a neighborhood of Q. We let cP := CP2 - CPl. For any h = (hi, ... , h n ), denote, as usual, Ihl = (EI~i~n Ih j I2 )1/2. Moreover, we will assume that
Igl > 0
in a neighborhood of
n,
n.
i.e., the functions gj have no common zeros in Let us compute Tt(u) for u E L2(Q, CP2). Tt(u) is defined by the formula (TI(h)lu)Z (hITt(u»I' On the other hand, for h = (hi, ...• h n ) E H], we have
=
(TI(h)lu)Z =
1 (~ Q
I~J~n
hi gj
)
ue-'P2dm
=
1(L Q
I~J=,n
hj(gjUe-
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
140
We conclude that Tt(u) = (glue-
Let v = (Vt, ... , Vn) E dom(TD. Since T2*(v) inequality
= (T*(VI), ... , T*(v n»,
the
becomes in this case
II Tt(u) + T2*(v)lIr
=
L
IIgjue-
+ T*(vj)lIi
2: C2I1ull~,
I~j~n
for u E G2 = L2(Q, Cf.J2) n Jf(Q) and Vj E dom(T*), I :::: j :::: n. Rewriting the left-hand side of this inequality as IITt(u)
+ T2*(v)lIt = II Tt(u) IIi + 2 Re(Tt(u)IT2*(v»1 + IIT2*(v)lIt,
it shows we have to study three terms separately. A. Let us start by rewriting the first one
II Tt(u) IIi =
L 15j~n
1Igjue-
Q
B. Estimation oj2Re(Tt(u)IT2*(v»l. Since u is holomorphic we have T(gjue-
(:z
hence gjue-'P E dom(T). Therefore, 2Re(Tt(u)IT2*(v»1 = 2Re
L (gjue-'PIT*(vj»1 t~j~n
= 2Re
L
(T(gjue-'Plvj)h
15j5n
Recall that for any a, b 2: 0, a > 0, we have 1
2ab < _a 2 -a
Hence
+ ab 2 •
(gje-'P») ,
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
It follows that for any
141
> 0,
(X
2Re(Tt(u)IT2*(v)h :::
-.!. { IgI 2 Iule- 2'P-'P' dm (X
In
C. Evaluation of IIT2*(v)lIr. We are going to show that IIT2*(v)IIT :::
10 IvI2 :::~e-'P'
dm,
IvI2 =
EI:U:5n Ivje. For that purpose, we note that IIT2*(v)IIT = IIT*(vj)lIi, hence it is enough to obtain this estimate for the case of a single function (i.e., n 1). Let £(Q) be the family of all Coo functions on Q (i.e., in a neighborhood of Q). For f E £(Q) n dom(T*) we claim that
with
EI:5i:5n
=
T*(f) = -e'P'
~(fe-'P').
oz
In fact, we must have for every h
E 'D(Q).
Now, (T(h)If)1
=
1. --=oz oh
n
fe-'P' dm
and, from
we conclude that (T(h)lfh = -
= -
1. L n
0 h <>_(/e-V")dml (}z
+
1
0 -::::(h/e-'P')dm n oz
h [:/fe-'P')] dm,
since the other term vanishes, as one sees by applying the Stokes formula.
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
142
Rewriting the resulting identity we obtain
whence
as claimed. We shall admit a technical result whose proof can be found in an even more general setting in [Ho3, Lemma 4.1.3]. 2.3.4. Lemma. (i) The space £(0) is dense in dom(T), endowed with the graph norm
(lIf1it + lIoflozllr)1/2. (ii) The space £(!.1)
norm (II flit
n dom(T*) is dense in dom(T*), endowed with the graph
+ liT" flit)1/2.
Having accepted this lemma, let us give a characterization of the functions in n dom(T*).
£(!.1)
2.3.5. Proposition. A function
o on on.
I
E £(0)
belongs to dom(P)
if and only if I =
Proof. A function I E £(!.1) belongs to dom(T*) if and only if for every g E dom(T) one has (gIT*(f»)) = (T(g)lf)l. Since £(n) is dense in dom(T) (with the graph norm), it is necessary and sufficient to verify that for every g E £(!.1) one has
- (gle911 !...(fe-91I»)
az
I
= (o~ II) . oz 1
In other words, we need to verify the identity 0=
=
i
[g (e911 :Z (fe-91I»)
1. [oza - n
g-::(fe 911»
+ :~
1]
e-91, dm
1. 11 -
og - -] + -;::(fe '1'1) dm = oz
0 - /\ dz = -: 11. --;:(gle-91I)dz az
= -: 21
21
n
We conclude that f
E
an
dom(T*) if and only if
{ gte-911 dz = 0
Jan
0 --;:(gle-91I)dm n dZ
gle-911 dz.
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
143
for every g E t'(Q). Let s be the arc length parameter in an, the function dz/ds is Coo on an, hence we can find a function g E t'(Q) such that g = Jdz/ds on We conclude that J E dom(T*) if and only if J = 0 on 0
an.
an.
We can now show that the estimate we needed for II T2* (V ) II i holds.
2.3.6. Proposition. For every
J
IIT*(j)1I7
E
domCT*) one has the inequality
~ In IJI
2 e-\?1
::~~ dm.
Proof. From Lemma 2.3.4 we conclude that it is enough to prove the inequality for f E c(Q) n dom(T*). Let us recall that we have shown in the proof of Proposition 2.1.2 that for any u E C 2 one has
aq;1 12 + e\?1 lui 2 --_ a2q;1 e\?1 1-au +uaz az ilzilz = a_ [e\?1
az
If u
2 (u auilz +IUI2ilCP')] _~ (e\?lu -au) +e\?'l au az az az az I
= 0 on an, when we apply Stokes's formula we obtain { e\?1 1au 12 dm = { IUI 2 e\?1 a2q;~ dm + { e\?1 1au + acp, 12 dm if! az if! az az if! ilz az ~
When
J
E
t'(Q)
( lul2e
ifl
n dom(T*)
we
J =0
have
on
an
and
-e\?'(a/ilz)(e-\?' j), so we can apply the previous inequality to u = obtain
IIT*(f)lIi
= ~
i
2 le'l'l :z(e-
{ le-
if!
=
i
T*U) = -e\?1
f
and
2 e
= ( IJI 2e
as we wanted to prove.
Summarizing the estimates contained in A, B, and C, we see that for ex ~ I, u E G 2 = L 2 (n,cpz) n ~(n), and v = (Vi, •.. , Vn) E dom(Tt), we have the inequality
II Tt(u)
+ T2*(v)lIr ~
(1 - ~) LIgI IuI e2
2
2
dm
144
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
In what follows we shall take
cp := log(lgI 2 ) = log
(~ Igj 12) . l:OJ:on
2.3.7. Lemma. The following identities are correct: (i)
a2cp _ _ azai Igl 4
(ii)
"
~
Igk agj
l:ok<j:on
_
Bz
g. Bgk 12 J
Bz
Hence,
Therefore,
and the identity (i) follows. (ii) An elementary computation yields
We can now apply an identity due to Lagrange: 2
L l:oj:on
a/Jj
+
L
lakbj - aj b kl 2 =
which is valid for any choice aj, bj ~~
L
lajl2lbd,
l:Oj.k:On
l:ok<j:on E
C, I ::: j ::: n. This concludes the proof
0
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
145
2.3.8. Lemma.Letaj,bj,vj EIC,l:::j :::n,laI2=L:l~j~nlajI2,andsimilarly IvI2 = L:l!U~n IVjI2. Then 2
L Proof. Let S
ak(akbj - ajbk)vj
:::
lal 2 lvI2
L
lakbj - bj akl2.
= L:iik(akbj -ajbk)Vj. We note that
L
2S =
[iik(akbj - ajbk)Vj
+ iij(ajbk -
akbj)vk]
l~j.k~n
L
=
(akbj - ajbk)(iikvj - iijVk)
l~j.k~n
L
= 2
(akbj - ajbd(iikVj - iijVk).
l~k<j~n
From the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality we obtain
ISI 2
::: (
L
lakbj - ajb
L
d) (
l~k<j~n
liikVj - iijVd) .
l~k<j~n
On the other hand, the Lagrange identity used in Lemma 2.3.7 yields 2
L
liikV; - iij Vkl 2 =
lal 21vI 2 -
L
ajVj
:::
lal 21vI2,
which combined with the previous inequality, proves the lemma.
o
These two lemmas allow us to state that
Let us now take CPl :=
with
1/1 a subhannonic
C2
1/1 + acp,
function still to be chosen. Then we obtain 2
a2 cpl - - a Ivi --_ 2 2
az az
Igl
'"' a ~ e'P-(g·e-'P)v-
l~j~n
oz
J
J
Since IgI 2 e- 2'P-'P' = e'P-2I{J, = e-'P2, with cpz := cP fOllowing result:
> -
a2 cp Ivl 2 --_.
oz oz
+ CPl, we have obtained the
146
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
2.3.9. Proposition. Let Q be an open bounded subset in the complex plane with Ceo regular boundary. Let 1/1 be any C 2 function in the neighborhood ofQ. which is subharmonic in O. Assume that gj' 1 :::: j .:::: n, are holomorphic functions in a neighborhood ofQ. such that Igl 2 = ~1:5j:5n Igjl2 > 0 on Q. Fix any a 2: 1 and let CPI = 1/1 + a log(lgl2) and CP2 = 1/1 + (a + 1) 10g(lge). Then,for any u E G 2 and v E dom(Tz*) one has the inequality IIT(u)
+ Tz*IIt
2:
(1 -~) f luI 2e-
As a consequence of these rather technical results, we shall now be able to obtain two theorems guaranteeing that a function belongs to a certain ideal. Here is the first one.
2.3.10. Theorem. Let 0 be an open subset of C. 1/1 a subharmonic function 0, and a fixed constant a > 1. Let gl • ...• gn (resp. (gj )j~l) be a system of n holomorphic functions in 0 (resp. a sequence of holomorphic functions such that the series Igl 2 = ~j~l Igj 12 converges uniformly on every compact subset of 0). For every function J. holomorphic in Q, such that
1.
Ifl2 ->/I d -2--2 e m < 00, n Igl a+
(*)
there exist n holomorphicfunctions hi, ... , h n in 0 (resp. a sequence holomorphic functions) such that
J=
L
(hj)j~1
of
hjgj
l:5j:5n
=
(resp. f ~j:~1 hjgj , the series being convergent in ~(O)). Moreover, the following inequality holds:
f ~e->/I dm
in Igl 2a
< _a_ -
f
J.£t..e-Vt dm.
a-I in Ig1 2a+2
Proof. We consider first a simple case and remove the unnecessary restrictions one by one. Assume that 0 is a bounded open set with Coo regular boundary. the gj form a finite family of n functions holomorphic in a neighborhood of Q. with Igl > 0 on Q., and 1/1 is of class C 2 in a neighborhood of Q.. Since 82 1/1 /8z 8z 2: 0, Proposition 2.3.9 provides the inequality
II T(u) + T2*(V) liT 2:
(I - ~) In
luI 2 e-
We can appeal now to Proposition 2.3.1 to obtain the theorem in this case. Let us now eliminate the condition that n is finite. Let (gj)j~1 be a sequence of functions which are holomorphic in the same neighborhood of Q. and 0 < 2:">1 Igjl2 converges uniformly on Q.. Let f be a holomorphic function satisJ_ • fying condition (*) with respect to this sequence. T!!ere IS an integer no » 1 such that for n ::: no we have LISjsn Igj 12 > 0 on Q and condition (*) holds
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
147
when we replace the infinite sequence by gl, ... ,gn' Hence, there is a sequence (hj,n)j~1 such that hj,n = 0 for j > n:
1= L
(i)
gjhj,n;
I::=,j
(il)
1( n
L Ihj ,nl 2 's]
I::=,~n
)"'-- dm '" a
,1
~
IgJ12
If I
n
C::;~n Igj 12)
•• , ,--dm '" M
<
00
where the bound M is obtained from the Monotone Convergence Theorem. It follows that for n ~ no
In
L Ihj,n 12 I::;j
e-'"
Ig1 2
dm ::: M.
C1
Hence, if B(z, 2r) ~ Q we have, for any ( E B(z, r),
L
Ihj,n«()1 2 :::
j~1
]l'~2 ~8(z,2r) L
j~1
Ihj ,nl 2dm
(We have used that Lj~1 Ih j ,n«()1 2 is a subharmonic function, being a finite sum of subharmonic functions.) Therefore, we can find a sequence (nkh~ I, nk ~ 00, such that for every j, hj,n, converges to a function hj in Jf"(Q). Given K Cc Q and N an arbitrary integer,
~
15J5N
llhj,n,,2Ig,-2C1e-'" dm ::: cx:
I
K
and letting k ~
L
00
f
1<'
f 1/12 ( L Igjf) -Cl-I e-1/I dm in l::;j5n,
one obtains
Ih j I2 Igl- 2C1 e-'" dm ::: _cx_ a -I
Since K is arbitrary and we can let N ~
00,
f
in
IfI 2Igl- 2(a+l)e-1/I dm.
we finally conclude that
{ IhI 2Igl- Za e-'" dm :::: -CX-llf,2Ig,-2(a+l)e-'" dm, cx - 1
in
n
With Ihl 2 = L'>llhj Ih j l2 I2 • In the same way as above, one obtains that L'>l J_ J_ Converges uniformly over compact subsets of Q.
148
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
Let us now show that f = Lj;::1 gjhj . Since, for every n» I, f = LI:':j:,:n gjhj,n, it is enough to show that the sequence (Lj:~! gjhj,n,h;::1 converges locally unifonnly in n, We have already observed that L};::I Ihj,nk 12 is uniformly bounded over any compact subset of n and, moreover, Lj;::1 Igjl2 converges locally uniformly in n by hypothesis, hence
which converges uniformly to zero on every compact subset of n, Let us now assume that 1{1 is defined in a neighborhood of Q, but it is not necessarily of class C 2• One can find a sequence (1{In)n;::1 of subharrnonic functions, Coo in a neighborhood U of Q, such that 'ifrn ~ 1/In+l, 'ifrn(z) ~ 1{I(z) for any Z E U (see, e.g., [BG, §4.4,16]), For every n we can find a sequence of holomorphic functions hj,n such that: (i)
f =
L gjhJ,n; j;::1
(ii)
:::: _Ci_ Ci -1
r
In
IfI 2 Igl- 2a - 2e-'" dm.
As before, for every n the corresponding sequence (hj,n)j;::! is locally uniformly bounded in n, hence we can find nk < nk+! ~ 00 such that hj,nk --+ h j as k ~ 00 in ~(n). A reasoning completely analogous to those above allows us to conclude that the sequence (hj)j;::1 satisfies the two conditions required by the theorem. Let us now assume that n is an arbitrary open set. We claim we can find a sequence of bounded open sets (Qn)n;::1 such that: (a) (b)
Qn £ nn+l;
n = Un>1 nn; (c) for every n, ann is a regular boundary of class Coo.
The idea of the construction of the nn is as follows. First, we construct a function p: n ~ [0, +oo[ of class Coo such that p-I([O, r]) cc n for every r > 0. For this purpose, just take any compact exhaustion (Kj )j;::1 of nand choose rpj E D(n) such that rpj :::: I, rpj == 1, on a neighborhood of Kj, and supp(rpj) £ Kj+l. Let
°: :
p := rpl
+L
j (rpJ+1 - rpj-l).
j;::2
This function is Coo and proper. Moreover, by Sard's lemma the set of critical values of p is of zero measure. Therefore, there is an increasing sequence of
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
149
values rn -+ 00 such that On = p-I([O, rnD fonns an exhaustion of 0 with the desired properties. Now, by what we have already proved, for every n ~ 1 there exists a sequence (hj,n)j?!1 of holomorphic functions in nn such that
1= Egjhj,n
(i)
in On;
r~1
~
_0/_ 0/ - I
r 1/12Igl-2a-2e-Vr dm.
In
For m fixed and n > m, the sequence (h j •n ) is bounded in Om. It follows that we can find an increasing sequence nk -+ 00 such that for every j ~ I the sequence hj,nk has a limit hj in Jt"(0) when k -+ 00. It is easy to see now that the sequence (hj)j?!1 has the required properties. To conclude the proof we only have to eliminate the supplementary hypothesis that Ig I > 0 on O. Let 2 be the discrete set of common zeros in 0 of all the gj' and apply the theorem to 0' = 0\2. Since 1/1 and Igl are locally bounded above, the functions hj are locally square integrable in n, hence their possible singularities at the points of 2 are removable, as shown by the following elementary lemma:
2.3.11. Lemma. Let I be holomorphic in 0 < Izl < r, ~zI
1
r
I/(z)1 2 dm = 21l'1a_11 2 1og -
£:5121:5r
Letting
B -+
+ 1l'
2k + r + E lakI2-"""k--+ 2k 2 -
*7"-1
B
0 we reach a contradiction unless ak
Let us now present two simple corollaries of Theorem 2.3.10.
2.3.12. Corollary. II there exist constants C I, C2 such that ~
Igl
~
eCzVr ,
then,for every holomorphic function f in 0 such that
L
IfI 2 e- C3 tJ! dm
<
2
1
= 0 for every k < O.
This lemma concludes the proof of Theorem 2.3.10.
e-C,Vr
B
00,
0 0
ISO
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A I'
for some C3 such that C3 + C 1 (2a such that f = Lj~l gjh j and
+ 2)
~
0, there are holomorphicfunctions hi
rIhI 2e- c.", dm ::: _a_ inrIfI 2e- C,'" dm,
in where C4 = C3
a-I
+ C 1(2a + 2) + 2aC2.
Proof. Let C; := C3 + C 1(2a
+ 2)
~
0, hence the function C;1/I is subhannonic
and l'f,2Ig,-2u-2e-c;", dm ::: l'f,2e-C'''' dm. Therefore, there are (hj)j~l holomorphic in Q such that f
= Lj~l gjh j and
rIhI 2Igl- 2U e-c;", dm ::: a_a_ rIfI2e-CJ"'. - in
in Let C4 :=
I
q + 2aC2, then 1,h,2e-C'''' dm :::
In
IhI 2Igl- 2u e- C;", dm,
o
which concludes the proof of the corollary. 2.3.13. Corollary. If there are constants c and M such that
o<
c ::: Igl ::: M
< 00,
then,for every function f E L 2(Q) n Jf'(Q), there are holomorphic functions hj such that:
= Lj~l gjhj ; and In Ih 12 dm < 00.
(i) f (ii)
Proof. This is the previous corollary for the case 1/1
= constant.
o
2.3.14. Remark. Let us recall from 1.1 that the Corona Problem consists in finding bounded functions hj such that f = Lj~l gJh j , when f is bounded and 0 < C ::: Ig I ::: M < 00. The proof of the Corona Theorem for L 2 - functions which we have just given is much simpler than the Corona Theorem for bounded functions. As another application of Theorem 2.3.10 we shall see what are some of its consequences for the algebra Ap(Q), Q an open set in C. We assume the weight p satisfies the conditions (i)' and (ii)' of §2.1. That is, there are positive constants KJ, K2, K 3 , K4 such that zEQ,~EC, an
2.3. Ideal Theory in AI'
151
We remind the reader that C ::: 0 such that
I
E Ap(Q)
In
if and only if I
1/1 2e- cp dm
<
E J!'(Q)
and there is
00.
From the second assumption above, it follows that Ap(Q) contains the restrictions to Q of the polynomials. More generally, consider a family P of subharmonic functions such that if PI, P2 E P, then PI + P2 E P and max(PI, P2) E P. We associate to P the algebra Ap(Q) of those holomorphic functions in Q such that III ~ Ce P for some pEP (Le., Ap(Q) = UpEP Ap(Q». It follows that Ap(Q) contains the restrictions of the polynomials and that I E Ap(Q) if and only if there is PEP and C > 0 such that
In
1/1 2e- cp dm
< 00.
That is, one can define the growth conditions in A p (Q) either by pc estimates or by L 2 estimates. As an immediate corollary Theorem 2.3.10 we have the following theorem due to Horrnander [H03]:
2.3.15. Corollary. Let !?I, are equivalent:
... ,
gn E Ap(Q), then thelollowing three conditions
(I) /(gl, ... ,gn) = Ap(Q). (2) There is pEP and A > 0 such that
Igl ::: (3) There is
Ae- p •
a > I and PEP such that
1
-p
e2a+2 dm <
(2lgl
00.
2.3.16. Remarks. (1) Horrnander considered the case P =
{cp: c > OJ, P a fixed subharmonic function. (2) If there is a sequence (t:j)j'!l of holomorphic functions in Q such that
Ale-PI ~
Igl
~
A2eP'
for some constants A" A2 > 0, and PI, P2 E P, then for every IE Ap(Q), there is a sequence (hj)j~1 ~ J!'(Q) such that: (i) (ii)
I
=
Lj>1
e
Ih I ~ A 3
gjh j in Q; and for some P3 E P, A.~ > 0,
P'
which is Horrnander's result extended to the case of infinitely many generators.
Let us now give a situation where the need to consider an infinite sequence arises naturally. Let P be a subharmonic function in an open set Q. Assume that for every j E N*, the set OJ := [z E 0; p(z) < j} is relatively compact in O. We recall
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
152
that Ap(O) carnes an inductive limit topology, which is not metrizable. Nevertheless, the spaces Ap,B (0) are Banach spaces and thus, from Proposition 1.4.13, the closure of any subspace F of Ap(O) coincides with its sequential closure. Therefore, an ideal I in Ap(Q) is dense if and only if it is sequentially dense in Ap(O), i.e., there is a sequence (lkk?1 in I that converges to 1 uniformly over every compact subset of 0 and besides, there are two constants C), C2 :::: 0 such that (z E 0, k:::: 1). In this case, for every j :::: 1 there is kj such that ~
:s Ilk (z)1 2 :s ~,
for all
j
Z E
OJ.
Let
then
Igl'
~ ~ Igil':o (~e
-';) ci
exp(2C,p).
and, moreover, for every z E 0 there is a j such that j - 1 :s p(z) < j, hence -2
Te-ZP(Z)
:s ~e-2j :s e-2jlfk/z)12 =
Igj(z)1 2
:s Ig(z)1 2 •
This shows that the existence of four positive constants, A, B, A', and B' so that A'e-B'p
:s Igl :s Ae BP .
Conversely, Remark 2.3.16(2) shows that if we can find a sequence gj E I, and positive constants A, B, A', and B' such that the previous inequality holds, then I is sequentially dense. Therefore, we have proved the following proposition:
2.3.17. Proposition. Let p be a nonnegative subharmonic function in 0 such that for every c > 0 the set Oc = {z E 0: p(z) < c) is relatively compact in O. Assume p satisfies the other properties stated in the definition of the spaces Ap(O). An ideal I of the algebra Ap (0) is dense if and only if there is a sequence (gj)j?:.) in I and positive constants A, B, A', and B', such that A'e- B' p
:s
(L: Igj 12) 1/2 :s Ae BP .
As an example of application of this proposition, let p(z) = I Imzl
+ log(l + IzI 2 ),
the weight defining the algebra F(e'(JR». For nEZ, let
inez) := - 1
21r
1
2"
0
..
e- IIZ e-· nt dt
=1.- e-
21Ciz
21rI(z+n)
.
153
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
Since for each Z E C, the fn (z) are the Fourier coefficients of the function t ~ e- itz , we can apply Parseval's fonnula and obtain 1
"lfn(z)1 2 = L; 2rr nE ..
12Jr le-
itz l2dt
0
1 e 4Jr (lrnz)
= -4rr
1
- . Irnz
It is easy to verify the inequalities of Proposition 2.3.17 and conclude that the
ideal generated by the In, nEZ, is dense in F(£'(JR». Let us consider a finite family g" ... , gn E Ap(r.l). Denote h = I(g" ... , gn), the ideal generated by them in Ap(r.l) and let Z(h) be the set of their common zeros in r.l. A function f E ./Ti (the radical of I,) if there are k E W, h j E Ap(r.l), such that
fk =
L
gjhj .
We conclude that for some PEP and A > o. Conversely, suppose f E "e(r.l) is such that for some k E N*, A > 0, and PEP, one has Iflk ::s Algle P • In this situation we can apply Theorem 2.3.10 to the function f3k, choose 01 E ]1, 3[ and let 1{1 = Bp for B a sufficiently large integer, and obtain that f3k E I" i.e., f E ./Ti. We have therefore proved the following version of Hilbert's Nullstellensatz:
2.3.18. Corollary (Global Nullstellensatz). In order for a function f in the algebra Ap(r.l) to belong to the radical of the ideal h, generated by g" ... , gn, it is necessary and sufficient that there are k E N*, A > 0, and PEP, such that Iflk
::s Algle P
in r.l. Let now /z be the family of f such that
E
Ap(r.l) for which there are A > 0, PEP
If I ::s Algle P • It is easy to see that lz is an ideal in Ap(r.l) and that I, s; /z. If f E Ii, then there are A > 0, PEP, such that
If I ::s Algl 3e P , which implies, via Theorem 2.3.10, that f statement:
E
I,. Therefore, we have the following
2.3.19. Corollary. The ideals h, lz verify
Ii £; h In particular,
.Jli = .../12.
£;
/z.
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
154
2.3.20. Proposition. If either II or 12 is a principal ideal, then II
= /z.
Proof. We need to show that in either case h 5; II. Let II (h) and let f E h Hence, there are A > 0, PEP, such that
=
If I ~ Alhle P •
=
It is immediate that fI h E )fen) and, if q; f / h, then q; E Ap(Q). Therefore, fEq;hE/I. If h is principal, h (h). Since h S;; h we have that for each generator gj of II there is h E Ap(n) such that
=
gj = ,{jh
(j = I, ... , n)
and, moreover, by the definition of h, there are A > 0, PEP, such that Ihl ~ Algle P • It follows that If I =
(2:I:::;j:::;n
IhI2)1/2 '#
If I =
°
in Q and that
!!l > ~e-p. Ihl - A
Therefore, i.e., there are h j
E
Ap(n) such that
1
=
L
hj,{j,
I:::;j:::;n
and hence
h
L
=
hj/jh
=
L
hjgj
E
h.
I:::;j:::;n
I:::;j:::;n
o
This concludes the proof of the proposition.
= 1. In that case we have
Let us return now to Proposition 2.3.9 and let ex
II Tt(u) +
T2*(v)II~ ~
(
021/1_lvI 2e-rpt dm,
in oz oz
for u E G 2 , V E dom(Tz*), q;1 = 1/1 + log(lgI 2), q;2 = q;1 + log(lgI 2) = 1/f + 2Iog(lgI 2). Let us replace 1/1 by l/f + 210g(l + IzI2). Then, for this new weight, the meaning of G2 changes but, since
02
oz oz (1/f + 210g(1 + Iz12» ~
2
(1
+ IzI2)2'
one obtains the inequality
I Tt(u) + T2*(V) liT ~ 21n (l1 i:1 v
2 )2 e -rpt
dm,
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
155
for u E G 2 , V E dom(TD, ({ll = 1/1 + log(lgI 2) + 2 log (I + IzI2), ({l2 = 'PI + log(lgI 2 ). We apply this observation to prove the following proposition:
2.3.21. Proposition. Let Q be a bounded open set with regular boundary of class Coo, let 1/1 be a subharmonic function of class C 2 in a neighborhood of and let gl, ... , gn be holomorphic functions in a neighborhood of such that Igl 2 = L: l:5j:5n Igj 12 > 0 on Let w = (WI, ... , wn ) be a system of measurable functions such that
n.
Let p := 1/1 + 210g(lgI 2 ) + 2 log (1 + IzI 2 ), then there are functions h) such that: (a)
n,
n
E
Lloc(Q)
ah·
a{ = Wj in the sense of distributions;
(b) In(Ll:5j:5nhjgj)iie-Pdm = Ofor everyholomorphicfunctionU E LZ(Q,p); Ihl 2 e->J! 1 Iw12_ (c) In jgj2 (1 + Iz12)2 dm ~ "2 In Igl2 e >J! dm.
Proof. The hypotheses show that for
'PI
:=
1/1 + log(lgI2) + 2 log (1 + Iz12)
k1W12(l + IzI 2le-'I'1 dm <
00.
We have also that l(wlv)d 2 =
1L 0.
~
2
w/Uje-'I'I dm
l:5j:5n
(inrIw12(1 + IZI2)2e-'I'1
dm) (
r
Ivl2 e-'I'l dm) . in (1 + IzIZ?
Therefore, if we let ({l2 = p, to conform with the notation of Proposition 2.3.9, we have that for u E G2 and v E dom(Tn l(wlv)11 2 S
t (fo. Iw12(1 + IZI2)2e-'I'1 dm) II TtCu) + T2*(V) IIi·
Let E be the linear subspace of (L 2 CQ, ({ll»n of elements of the form Tt(u) + T2*Cv), for some u E G 2 , V E dom(Tz*). Define a linear form (): E --+ C by the relation Then: (i) () is well defined because if Tt(u)
r
+ T2*(v) = 0 then
IvI2 -'1'1 d 0 inCI+lzI2)2e m=, hence v
= 0;
and
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
156
(ii) () is continuous, with nonn ~
-vff72(JnlwI2(l + IZI2)2e-q11 dm)I/2.
The Hahn - Banach theorem allows us to conclude that there is h
=
(hi, ... , h n) E (L2(Q,
(a' ) (wlv)1 = (hITt(u)
(b') IIhllr =
+ T2*(v»J,
whenever u E G2 and v E dom(TD; and
1Inlwl2(l + IZI2)2e-q11 dm.
The identity (a/) is equivalent to the pair of identities
In other words,
a: =
8h (a)
(b)
Wj,
1 ( 2: n
1 ~ j ~ n.
gjhj ) iie-'P2 dm = 0 (u E G 2)·
I:5:J:5:n
The inequality (b /) is simply (c)
Ih 12 e- 1fJ Ih 12 r Ih1 2e-'I'2 dm = r dm < 1 r - e - 1fJ dm In JnlgI2(l+lzI2)2 -2Jnlgl2 '
because of the choice of
o
2.3.22. Theorem. Let Q be an open subset of IC, and let 1/1 be a subharmonic function in Q. Let (g1. ... ,gn) (resp. (gj )j~ I) be a system of n holomorphic functions in Q (resp. a sequence of such functions). Let Z be the set of common zeros of the gj in Q. Then,for every function f E -'f(Q) such that
1
Ifl2
- 4 (1
n\z Igi
there are hi, ... , hn
E
f =
+ ~(Iog Igl)e- 1fJ dm
<
00,
-'f(Q) (resp. a sequence (hj)j~1 in -'f(Q» such that
L
gjhj
l~j~n
and
[lfl2 e- 1fJ [ Ifl2 Igl2 (1 + Iz12)2 dm ~ 2 in\Z Igl 4 (1 + ~(Iog Igl)e- 1fJ dm.
in
Proof. One starts by assuming that Q is a bounded open set with regular boundary of class Coo, 1/1 is C 2 and subhannonic in a neighborhood of Q, the n functions gj are holomorphic in a fixed neighborhood of and Igl > O. Afterward, one eliminates these restrictions one by one as done in the proof of Theorem 2.3.10. We shall just indicate how to prove the first step. One can write f = 2:1:5:j:5: n gjhj with
n,
hj:= f &2' Igi
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
157
Let Wj := ohj/oz. An easy computation shows that
Wi
= L 4 '" Igl
L.J
g. (g. Ogi _ gi Ogj) .
J:::,:::n
'oz
,
8z
Applying the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality one obtains
Iwl 2 =
L
Hence.
i.
Iwl2 -e-l/Idm< Igl 2
Q
-
2
L
-1/12 Igl8 J:::i:::n
Ogj) g. (Ogi g'--g; " 8z OZ J:;:j:;:n
i. Q
-1/12
Igl 4
L -Igl1
J:::i.j:;:n
4
1gOgi ogj '--gi - 12 e-l/Idm. 'OZ
OZ
On the other hand.
Therefore.
From Proposition 2.3.21 we see there are functions h'j. 1 :::: j :::: n. such that:
oh"
( 1) oz'
(2)
1( Q
(3)
= W·· ,.
L
gjh'j) ue-'1'2 dm
=0
(u E G 2 ); and
J:;:j:::n
Ih"1 2 e-l/I Iwl2 r dm < r -e-l/I dm. JQ Igl 2 (l + Iz12)2 - JQ Igl 2
Let hj := hj - h'j. Then (o/8z)hj = O. for j = 1•...• n. We also have that TJ(h") is square integrable in n, and condition (2) can be written as for Hence TJ (h)
=/ -
TJ (hI!)
u
E G2-
is also square integrable in (TJ (h) -
fluh = 0
n. TI (h) -
f
E G2.
and
158
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
=
I,
for all u E G2. Since we can take u T\ (h) conclude the proof we only need to estimate h. We have e-Y, Ih' - h"1 2 e-l/I _Ihl2 dm -
1.
o Igl 2 (1
1.
+ Iz12)2
-
Igl 2
0
(1
lh l12
<2 1 - 0 Igl 2 (1 But
e-l/I
+ Iz12)2
Ih'1 = 111 /181 hence lhl2 e-l/I dm <2 11112 2
2
1
o 181 2 (1
+ Iz12)2
we see that T\ (h) =
dm+2
+ Iz12)2
-
:s 2
e-l/I
(1
1.o 1112 181
- 4 (1
+ Iz12)2
To
dm 2 11h"1 -0
2,
0 Igl 4
I.
dm+2
e-l/I
Igl 2 (l + Iz12)2
1lw 0
dm
.
l2
-e-"'dm Igl 2
+ ~(log 181)e-Y, dm.
As pointed out earlier, the remainder of the proof can be carried out as in the case of Theorem 2.3.10. 0 2.3.23. Corollary.
If g\. ... ,gn
r
}0\2
E Ap(n)
and there is apE P such that
~(log Igj)e- P dm
< 00,
then
EXERCISES
g)
2.3.
1. Let gl, ...• gn. 11 •...• In, and h be hololTlophic functions in a disk B satisfying :::: j :::: n) and for some A > 0,
= /jh (1
Ih(z)1 :::: A
(~n Igj(Z)1
2 ) 1/2
Show that the functions /j cannot have a common zero in B (see the proof of Proposition 2.3.20). 2. (The objective of this exercise is to prove a very simple case of a theorem of Bombieri [Ho3. Theorem 4.4.4].) Let p be a subharmonic function in an open set n. (a) Let U E Jf'(n) satisfy In lul 2 e- p dm < 00. Show that if ~o E n is such that e- P is not integrable on any neighborhood of ~o, then u(~o) = O. (b) Let 8(zo, r) ~ r > O. be such that e- P E LI (B(zo, r), dm). Show that there is U E Jf'cn), such that u(zo) = 1 and
n.
r lu(z)1 e2
p (Z)
Jn '--(-'-1-'-+'--1z-I-:--2)7"3 dm (z)
< 00.
(Hint: Try to find u in the fonn u(z) := I/J(z) - (z - zo)v(z).
where I/J E 1'(B(zo. r».1/J
==
1 in B(zo. r/2).)
159
2.3. Ideal Theory in Ap
Conclude that there is a nonzero U E Je(n) such that U satisfies the condition (*) and vanishes at every point/; En such that e- P ¢ LI(N{) for any neighborhood N{ of /;.
=
=
*3. Let 1/1 be a subhannonic function in B B(O, 1) such that 1/1(0) 0 and 1/I(z) < 1 for every z E B. Let J,L = /l1/l. (a) Show there is a Radon measure da on aB(O, 1), da(/;) =::; Id/;I such that 1/I(z)
= 2:rr1 18r log I1z _- z~/; IdJ,L(n +
1 a8
1 - Iz 12 Iz _ /; 12 da(/;).
(Hint: Use the Riesz decomposition theorem for 8(0, r) and let r -+ 1-. [BG. §4.4.24J.) (b) Show that
r log ~dJ,L(/;) + 1(Id/; I - da) = h. I/; I
18
a8
Conclude that
(c) Show that
da (/;) I =::; 6 1 .!....=J.:.f I~ 2:rr Iz - /;1
if
2
aB
Izl =::; ~.
(d) For R < e- 1/2 , let a = a(R) :=
r
~
1BW.R)
2:rr
dJ,L(/;).
Show that O:::;a=::;(-logR)-J <2. (e) Fix R E has
14,
e- J/2 [.
Show there is a constant C > 0 such that for Z E B(O, 1/2) one
11
I-
Iz-/;I log - - djJ.(r;) < C II-z/;I
R
and exp
(_~
flog 18W.R)
r ( Iz - /;J )
Iz - /;_1 dJ,L(/;») < II - z/;I -
JBW.R)
11- z/;l
-0
dJ,L(/;) < C. 2:rra-
(f) Conclude that
~
e-1/r(:)dm(z) < 00.
18(0.1/2)
(g) Use the previous parts of this exercise. and preceding Exercise 2.3.2, to prove that
if rp is a subhannonic function in a domain n. there is an open set G, G dense in n, and G 2 (z E n: rp(z) > -00) such that e-
r
JQ
U
E
Je(n) such that
lu(z)1 2 e-
(I
+ Iz12)3
dm(z) < 00.
'4. Let rp be a subharmonic function in C and H
for some N ~ O.
U
such
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
160
(a) Let U E ;f(C) be such that Iufe-Ip E L!oc(C)' Fix R > 0 and let X on B(O, R + 2). Let v := XU, f := av/az. For t > 0 define !Pr(Z) := cp(z)
Show that
lim 1-+00
+ max
Jcr IfI
HOO
C
(I
(iii) lim
r_oo
Ur
+ Iz12)2 IUr
12 dm
==
I
(0, t log (RI~ 1) ) .
2 exp(-cpr)dm
(b) Show there exists U r E Coo such that 8u r/az (i) lim]; IUr 12 exp( -l{Jr) dm = 0; (ii) r~ kl
E 1)(C), X
=0.
=f
and satisfies
= 0; and
= 0 uniformly in
Izl < R.
(c) Show that
and
J
(l
Iv -
U r 12
+ IzI2)2+(r/2) e
-Ip d
m<
00.
(d) Conclude that the closure of Hlp in ;f(C) contains the set of all that lul 2e-1p E L!oc(C).
U E
;f(C) such
2.4. Dense Ideals in Ap(Q) In this section we will consider in more detail the question of when an ideal 1 of the algebra Ap(O) is sequentially dense (see [KTl], [KT2] , [Tal)). From Ap(Q), and clearly Proposition 1.4.13 we obtain that this is equivalent to j
=
the necessary and sufficient condition is that the function 1 must be a limit of a sequence in I. Another obvious necessary condition is that the elements of 1 do not have a common zero. This condition is not sufficient for arbitrary weights p, as will be shown in the exercises below. We now introduce a new concept, very useful in this kind of problem. 2.4.1. Definition. A subset S S; Ap (0) is called exhaustive if there is a sequence (Uj)j~I of subharmonic functions in Q, a sequence (Kj)j~l of compact subsets of Q, and two constants C" C2 ~ 0 such that: (1) Q
= Uj~l Kj;
(2) Uj(z) ~ 0 for every z E K j ; (3) Uj(z) :::: C 1 + C2P(Z) for every Z E Q; and
(4) for every j ~ I, there are constants subset Sj of S such that, for every Z Uj(z) :::: Cl,j
C1,j,
C2,j ~ 0
and a finite, nonempty
E Q,
+ C 2,jp(z) + ~ log
(L: feS,
If(Z)1 2)
•
2.4. Dense Ideals in Ap(Q)
161
2.4.2. Remarks. (I) It is clear that we can assume that the sequences (Uj)j:=l, (Kj)j:=l, and (Sj)j:=l are increasing. Under these conditions we shaH denote Sj = (Fl .... , FN), where (Nj)j:=] is an increasing sequence of integers. (2) A set S is exhaustive if and only if the ideal I (S) generated by S in Ap (Q) is exhaustive. Let us show, for instance, that if I (S) is exhaustive, then one can find subsets Sj ~ S, verifying (4) for the same sequence (Uj)j:=1 associated to I (S). In fact, there is a finite, nonempty set 6 j = {iI, ... , INj } ~ I (S) such that
Let us write lk = Li ak,iFk,i, for some finite collections Fk.i E S, Qk.i E Ap(Q), both collections depending on k Let Sj be the (finite) collection of all Fk.i E S appearing in one of the above representations of Jk E 6 j • Then
1~t=Nj 1!k(z)l2 ~ 1~t:Ni (~Iak.i (Z)1 2) (~IFk.i (Z)1 2) for some Aj , Bj > O. This gives a choice of Sj and constants C;.j' q.j for the set S. (3) If S is exhaustive, its elements cannot have a common zero Zo E Q. Otherwise, log
(2:
11(ZO)1 2)
=
-00
jES)
for every j, and this contradicts the fact that Uj ::: 0 on K j • (4) If each Uj is of the form log Igjl, gj E Jf(Q), then gj E Ap(Q) and, moreover, g] E I (S) by Theorem 2.3.10. (5) If S is an ideal without common zeros, the conditions to be exhaustive are easily seen to be equivalent to the following "pointwise conditions": There are constants C I , C 2 ::: 0 such that for every l; E Q there is a function Us which is subharmonic in Q, a compact subset KI; of Q, a nonempty finite subset SI; of S, and constants C I (l;), C2(l;) ::: 0 such that: (I) ul;(z) SCI + C 2 P(z) fOT Z E Q; (2) ul; (z) ::: 0 in a neighborhood of ~; and
(3)
fOT
every
Z E
Q\K, one has ul;(z)
~ CI(~) + C2(~)p(Z) +!
(E jESj
The main result of this section is the following:
11(Z)1 2)
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A"
162
if and only if it is dense.
2.4.3. Proposition. An ideal J in Ap(Q) is exhaustive
Proof. Let us assume first that J is dense. It follows that there is a sequence (hi)j~1 of elements in J which converges to 1 uniformly on compact subsets of Q and such that, for some constants C), C2 ~ 0, one has
We set
Uj
~
(j
Ihj(z)1 :5 CI exp(C2P(Z»
1, z
Q).
E
:= 1 + log Ih j I, and
K j :=
{z
E
Q: Uj(z)
~ O} n {z E Q:
Izl :5 j and d(z,
QC)
~
7}'
It is easy to verify that the conditions of Definition 2.4.1 are satisfied for this choice. Conversely, let us assume that I is exhaustive. Let (Uj)j~), (Kj)j~I' and (Sj )j~1 be the corresponding sequences assumed increasing, satisfying the conditions of Definition 2.4.1. Let us choose a sequence (l(Jj)j~1 5; 1J(Q) such that: (i) 0:5 I(Jj :5 1, j ~ 1; (ii) I(Jj(z) 1 for every z E Kj; (iii) there is a constant Co > 0 such that
=
(Z E Q, j
For j
~
~
1).
1, we can define new subharrnonic functions in Q by Vj(z) := 4
+ IZI2»)) ( Uj(z) + log ( 0d(z, QC)
.
These auxiliary functions have the following property: 2.4.4. Lemma.
lim (lim sup In{ 1alP}az 12 e-
J-+OO
v,
dm) = O.
k-+oo
Proof of Lemma 2.4.4. Choose k(j) ~ 1 such that Uk ~ 0 on sUPP(l(Jj) for all k :::: k(j). Let K; = supp(l(Jj) n (Q\Kj ), then for k :::: k(j) we have
1 n
1
aCP'I2 - ' e- V ' dm <
ai
-
c02
1 ,
K'
e- 4Uk (z)
d(z QC)4 ' Iz1 2)4
d(z, QC)2 (I
+
dm
.
Since Mj = sUPzeO\K, d(z, QC)2/[(1 + IzI2)2]:5 l/j2 and Uk:::: Oon sUPPCPj, we have { 1acpj 12 -Vk < C6 { dm Jo az e dm - j2 In (1 + IzI2)2' This inequality proves the lemma.
o
2.4. Dense Ideals in Ap(S"l)
163
Let Cj := If/. lacpj /aiI 2e- v'(I) dm, with the strictly increasing sequence k(j) chosen as in the proof of the preceding lemma, so that limj .... oo Cj 0 and Vk(j) ::: 0 on the support of CPj. From Theorem 2.4.3 it follows that there are functions l/Ij such that 8l/1j/oi 8cpj/ai and
=
=
r
if/. Il/Ijl
e- VkU )
2
(1
+ Iz12)2 dm
I
~ 'iCj.
The functions hj := CPj - l/Ij are clearly holomorphic in Q. We claim that all h j E I and that the sequence (hj)j~1 converges to I in Ap(Q). Let us prove first
the last item. We need to show first that there exist constants C > 0, B > 0, such that, for every k ::: 1 and every Z E Q, e-V'CJ)
e-Cp(z) < B -----=-"""" -
In fact, letting
(1
+ IzI2)2·
fJ = log B, this inequality is equivalent to -Cp(z) ~ fJ - Vk(Z) - 2 log (1 + Iz12),
i.e., Vk
But, Vk = 4(Uk + log(l B 1 , A2, B2 such that
~
fJ + Cp(z)
- 2log(1
+ IzI 2 )/d(z, QC)) log(1
+ Iz12)
and there are positive constants A"
~ Al
1
d(z, QC) ~
+ IzI 2 ).
+ BIP(z),
A2 exp(B2P(Z)),
by the defining properties of the weight p. Since Uk satisfies the estimate of Definition 2.4.1, it is then clear that for C » 1 and fJ > 0 convenient, the desired inequality holds. Hence,
!oll/ljl2 e-CP dm
~ B !oll/ljl2 (1 :~:jl)2)2 dm ~ BCj,
and, as a consequence
On the other hand,
r11 - cpjl2e-
if/. and, since if C
»
1 we have e- cp
CP
dm
~
r
if/.\Kj
ELI (Q),
e- cp dm,
then
.lim [11 - cp_1 2 e- cp dm = O. )-+00
Therefore,
Jf/.
J
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
164
It follows that hj ~ 1 in Jt"(Q), by a mean-value argument that we used several times. Moreover, from the fact that In 11/1jle- cp dm ::: M < 00 for all j ::: 1, and the estimates of d(z, QC) in terms of p, we conclude that there exist constants A 3 , B3 > 0 such that Ih j I ::: A e e 113P •
This shows that hj ~ I in Ap(Q). To complete the proof of the Proposition 2.4.3 it suffices to show that hj E I. Choosing 01 = 2 in Theorem 2.3.10 allows us to prove that if we can show there are constants Cj > 0 such that
Jr.f n
Ihl 2
3
J
(I~Nj IFk1
2
e- CjP dm <
00,
)
then there are functions hj,I,"" hj,Nj E Ap(Q) such that hj =
L
hj.kFb
l:".k:".Nj
and, moreover,
1 n
L
Ihj.k 12
l:".k5 N)
2
e-C;P dm <
C~N) IFkI2)
-
21 n
2
Ihjl
3
e-Cjp dm.
C5~Nj IFkI 2)
The existence of the constants Cj > 0 follows from property (4) of Definition 2.4.1 and a reasoning entirely similar to those leading to the estimates for 1/Ij. 0
2.4.5. Corollary. Let 1 be an ideal in Ap(Q), which has no common zeros, and for which there exist finitely many F I , •.• , FN Eland E > 0, C > 0, such that every connected component of the set
is relatively compact in
Q.
Then 1 is dense in Ap(Q).
Proof. Let (Dj)j?,1 be the connected components of the open set D, then each
Vj
is a compact subset of Q. Consider the subharmonic function in Q, u(z):=
4log (
L
IFj (Z)1 2) -loge + Cp(z).
i:".j:".N We have D
= {z E Q: u(z) < OJ.
2.4. Dense Ideals in
165
Ap(n)
Define
u.(z).- {U(Z) J .max(O, u(z»
if z ¢ K j , if Z E Kj,
and Sj being equal to the set {FI, ... , F N) to which we have adjoined a finite subset 6 j of J with no common zeros in Kj • It is easy to verify that (Uj)j~), (Kj)j~i, (Sj )j~J, satisfy the condition of Definition 2.4.1. Hence I is exhaustive and the corollary has been proved. 0
2.4.6. Remark. The proof of Lemma 2.4.4 also shows that if satisfy the conditions (I), (2), and (4) of Definition 2.4.1, and if u(z) :=
UI ::: U2 ::: •••
lim Uj(z), J-+OO
then j contains h 3 for every h
E Ap(Q)
such that
Ih(z)1 ::: C) exp(C2 P(z) EXERCISES
+ u(z».
2.4.
I. Prove Remark 2.4.5. 2. Let n ::::: {z E C: Re z > OJ, and recall that C({l) denotes the space of continuous functions in (l. Let Ao(n) :::::: {f E Jf"(n):
lim I(z)::::: OJ
l'l~oo
n C(Q).
tEll
(a) For
1E
Ao(n) define
11/11 = sup I/(z)l. tEO
Show that Ao(n) is a Banach algebra under multiplication, without a unit. (b) Show that the function (z) := e- Z does not belong to Ao(n), but that (·Ao(n) is a proper ideal of Ao(n). (c) Prove that L I : I ~ (·1 is an isometry of Ao(n) into itself. Conclude that ( . Ao(n) is a closed ideal of Ao(n). (d) Let 'P E Ao(Q)\{O} and let I be the ideal (·'PAo(n). Show that the hypothesis 'P E j implies the existence of a sequence (f.)n~1 in Ao(n) such that ('Pln).~1 converges in Ao(n) to an element !PI E Ao(n) verifying 'P ::::: (·'PI. Show that it follows that 'P ::::: lim.-+ oo e2 q;.ln in Ao(n), and infer that ('Pd.)."?1 has a limit ({Jz in Ao(Q), and that rp = (2({J2. Derive by induction the existence of a sequence ('Pkh"?1 <; Ao(n) such that rp t k ·rpk for all k 2: 1. Conclude that, in fact, 'P ¢ i. (e) Let rp be as in part (d), and let J = rpAo(n). Show that t·rp is the limit in Ao(n) of the sequence (e.'P)n~I' en(z) := (n/(z + n»n. Infer that j = LI (J) <; J.
=
3. Let pCz) := log(l + Iz12) and n = (z: Rez > OJ as in the previous exercise. Also let e.(z) = (n/(z +n»n,n 2: 1. (a) Show that en E Ap(n) and lim._ oo en 1 in Ap(Q).
=
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ar
166
=
(b) Find explicitly the function lfJo E Ap(Q) such that lfJo lim n _ oc 0:. (c) Prove that the ideal I = lfJoAp(Q) is different from Ap(Q). (d) Is lfJo invertible in Ap(Q)?
2.5. Local Ideals and Conductor Ideals in Ap Let us recall that in Definition 2.2.7 we defined the local ideal associated to a finitely generated ideal I of ApCQ). In fact, that definition makes sense for any ideal I. 2.S.1. Definition. The local ideal I loc associated to an ideal I in ApCQ) is the collection of all I E ApCQ) such that for every Z E Q there is a neighborhood U of z and there exist functions 11, ... , In E I, gl, ... ,gn E JlfCU), verifying
1=
L
/jgj
in U.
l~j~n
=
It is clear that if V CZk, mkh~l denotes the multiplicity variety of the ideal I, and ICV) (resp. J(V» is the ideal in Ap(Q) Crespo in JlfCQ», corresponding to V, i.e., I (V) = (f E ApCQ):
I
vanishes at every Zk with multiplicity ::: mk},
then I loc = I CV). Moreover, if i: ApCQ) -+ JlfCQ) is the canonical injection, J is the closed ideal generated by I in JlfCQ) (i.e., by i(l», then J = ICV) and Iloc = i-I (I). Hence, I loc is closed in Ap(Q). Furthermore, the identities Iloc
= (lloc)loc = (i)loc,
are immediate consequences that all these ideals have the same multiplicity variety. In particular, if V = 0, then lIoc = ApCQ). Clearly if I = to} then I loc = {OJ. We now introduce another ideal associated to I. 2.5.2. Definition. Given an ideal I in Ap(Q) the conductor ideal (or quotient ideal) of I is the ideal 1* defined by I* := (f E ApCQ): Ig E I for every g E floc}. It is clear that [
~
1*.
2.5.3. Proposition. if [ is a closed ideal in Ap(Q), then 1* is also a closed ideal. Proof. Let (fn)n~l be a sequence in 1* converging to I in Ap(Q). For any g E floe, the sequence (fng)n~l lies in I and converges to Ig. Since I is closed,
IgeI.Hence/EI*.
0
2.5. Local Ideals and Conductor Ideals in Ap
167
2.5.4. Proposition. We have the inclusion
F r;;; (i)*. Proof. We already know that (1)* is closed and that floc = (1)loc' Hence for any f E 1* and g E (i)loc, then f gEl r;;; 1. Therefore, f E (i)*. It follows that
F r;;;
0
(i)*.
The following simple proposition is crucial to the study of localizability of ideals (see Definition 2.5.7). The idea to use it in this context is apparently due to Ehrenpreis [Eh 1). 2.5.5. Proposition. Let [ be an ideal, I
= IIeJC if and only if 1* = Ap(Q).
Proof. If [ = I loc , then for every f E Ap(Q) and g E I loc , we have fg E I, hence f E 1*. Conversely, if 1* = Ap(Q), then 1 E 1*, hence for every g E I loc we have g = 1· gEl. 0
2.5.6. Proposition. If /* is dense in Ap(Q), then Proof. Namely, by Proposition 2.5.4, ifF
i =
i
=
Iloc-
= Ap(Q), then (1)* = Ap(Q). Hence,
(i)loc = Il oc •
0
2.5.7. Definition. We say that an ideal/of Ap(Q) localizes if
i
= I loc •
This concept will play an important role in the study of convolution equations later on. We see that for I to localize it suffices to prove that I * is dense in Ap(Q), but this requires at least that /* has no common zeros. In fact, we can show that this is always the case. 2.5.8. Proposition. For every ideal I of Ap(Q), the ideal 1* has no common zeros.
# {OJ (Why?). Let us argue by contradiction and assume there is Zo E Z(I*). We claim that if g E 1*, then the function G(z) := g(z)/(z - zo) belongs to /*. To continue the proof we need the following very simple lemma:
Proof. We can assume that I
2.5.9. Lemma. /f f
E Ap(Q)
and f(zo) = 0, then F(z) := f(z)/(z - zo) is in
Ap(Q).
Proof of Lemma 2.5.9. Let fJ(zo, r) C; Q, then for z E B(zo, r) we have IF(z)1 ~
max
I/;-zol=r
IF(~)I
1
= -r
max
II;-zol=r
If(~)I,
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A"
168
and for z
E
0\8(zo, r) we have clearly
IF(z)1
~
I
-If(z)l· r
The defining properties of the weight p allow us to conclude that F
E Ap(O).
o We return to the proof of the proposition. Since V(l*) S; V(l), the multiplicity m of I at zo verifies that m :::: 1. Let h E I be such that the multiplicity of h at Zo is exactly m. Then we can write
h(z) = (z - zo)m H(z), with H(zo)
'# 0,
HE Ap(O). Similarly, any f E Iloc can be written as fez) = (z - zo)m F(z),
F E Ap(Q). It follows that the identity
f(z)H(z)
holds. We want to show that Gf we can write
E [,
= h(z)F(z)
for any f
E
G(z)f(z) = g(z)f(z) [H(Zo) - H(Z)]
H (zo)(z
-
zo)
= g(z)f(z) [H(Zo) - H(Z)] H (Zo)(z - zo)
Il oc • Using the previous notation
+(
g(z) ) f(z)H(z) z - Zo
+ h(z)
H (zo)
[G(Z)F(Z)] . H (zo)
Since gf E I and hE I, we obtain Gf E I. Therefore, G E 1*. This shows that the multiplicity variety V (1*) must be 0 empty. In other words, 1* is an ideal without zeros. This proposition allows us to extend Corollary 2.4.5 to an arbitrary ideal in Ap(Q).
2.5.10. Corollary. Let [ be an ideal in Ap(Q) for which there are functions F I , ••• , FN E I and constants s > 0, C > 0, such that every connected componentofthe set D = {z E Q: (Lt:Sj:SN IFj(z)I)I/2 < sexp(-Cp(z))} is relatively compact in Q. Then i = floc' Proof. The preceding Proposition 2.5.8 shows that /* has no common zeros and, since F t , ••• , FN E 1*, we can apply Corollary 2.4.5. We conclude that 1* is sequentially dense in Ap(Q). Hence j = [Ioc by Proposition 2.5.6. 0
In general, it is not true that j = Iloc. We show this with an example due to Gurevich ([Gu2]. see also [KT2] and Exercise 2.4.2).
2.5. Local Ideals and Conductor Ideals in Ap
2.5.11. Example. Let let
n=
169
-n/2 <
{z E C: Rez > OJ. For z = re i9 ,
p(z) := exp( -ar" cos 0
e < n/2,
+ r P) + r Y ,
with 0 < (3 < 01, 0 ~ Y < 1, a > O. Since fJ < 01, the quantity -ar" cos e + rfJ -+ -00 whenever r -+ 00 for 0 fixed in 1- n /2, n /2[. Therefore, every function f E Ap(n) is of order y along every ray starting at the origin, but the type of this function could increase to 00 as this ray approaches the vertical axis. We shall show that the principal ideal I = e- z Ap (n) is not localizable in Apcn). It is clear that I ¥- Apcn) since eZ ¢ Ap(n). Since I has no common zeros, Iloe = Ap(n). We want to show that j =1= Ap(Q). Assume that the opposite is true. We would then have a sequence (gnk::1 in Ap(n) such that: (i) gn (z )e- Z -+ 1, unifonnly on every compact subset of n; and (ii) Ign(z)e-ZI ~ C l eC2P (z) for all n ~ 1 and some C I , C2 > O.
Consider the open set
nl
:= {z
E
n:
Re z > rY}. On the set Q I we have
-ar" cosO + r P < -ar y +a -
I
+ r P.
z
E
Assume that (3
then there is a constant Co > 0 such that p(z) ~ Co
+ rY
for all
nl.
Therefore, we have Ign(z)e-ZI ~ C I exp(COC2 + C 2 r Y )
and for
z
E
ani,
since Rez = r Y on ani' In order to apply the Phragmen-LindelOf principle consider the auxiliary function fez) := exp( -c~zY),
c' _
C2 + 1
2 - cos(ny /2)
We have Ifgnl ~
c;
and the order of fgn is at most y < 1 in asserts that Hence, for
Z E
on
an)
n l . The Phragmen-LindelOf principle
nJ, we have Ign(z)e-ZI ~ C;
e- Rez
If(z)1 ::: C) exp(C~zY - Re z).
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
170
In particular, for z real, gn(z)e- Z ~ 0 as z dicts the condition (i) mentioned above.
~ 00,
uniformly in n, which contra-
The preceding example raises the natural question of whether there are weights p such that every ideal in Ap(C) localizes. In the next section we prove this for p(z) = IzIP,O < P < 00. The very important case p(z) = IImzl + log (1 + Iz12) is left to Chapter 6.
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p We denote here Ap the algebra Ap(C), p(z) = IzI P, 0 < P < 00. Note that all the functions of this algebra are either of order < p or order p and finite type. (In the literature sometimes a function of order p and infinite type is also said to be of order at most p.) For this algebra we want to give more precision to the results of this chapter about interpolation and ideals. Many reasonings extend to the case where p is a radial weight satisfying the doubling condition p(2z) = O(p(z)). We start with a result of Lindelof which we take from [Lin]. and we also suggest [Lev]. [Bo] for a complete study of entire functions and their zeros. Part of this section is based on the doctoral thesis of Squires [Sql], [Sq2]. Let f be a nonconstant entire function and recall that n (r) denotes the number of zeros of f in B(O, r), counted with multiplicities. We assume, for simplicity, that f (0) = I. Let then denote, as usual, M(r)
= max I/(z)1 Izl='
N(r) =
and
l'
net)
-dt. o t
Hence Jensen's formula (see [BO, Chapter 4]) is simply N(r)
= -211'1 12Jr log I/(re i8 )1 dO. 0
2.6.1. Lemma. If I has finite order p > 0 and finite type., then . nCr) hmsup - -
'_00
rP
~
ep •.
In particular, nCr) = O(r P ). Proof. In fact, for e > 0 given there is r(e) > 0 such that
logM(r)
~
~r(8),
(.+e)r P ,
r
.+8,
r ~ r(e).
hence N(r)
-- <
rP
-
171
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
Now let
~
> I and r ~ reel, then nCr) being increasing implies that
n(r)log~:5
1
ft, net) dt:5 ,t
loP' -n(t)d t = t
0
N(~r)
:5
~P(7:
+e)r P.
Therefore
nCr) :5
(7:
rP
+e) inf ( P>I
~PR.) = ep(7: +e),
r
log,...
~
r(e).
o
Since e > 0 was arbitrary, the lemma has been proved.
2.6.2. Lemma. If p > 0, but is not an integer, an entire function f of order at most p (i.e., f E Ap) is of type zero f E Ap if and only if nCr) = O(r P).
if and only if nCr) = o(r P ).
Note that if the order of f is strictly less than p, then of type 7: = 0 with respect to p.
In any case,
f is considered to
be
Proof. We write the Hadamard factorization of f in the form fez) = zmeQ(z) P(z),
Q a polynomial of degree deg Q = q < p, and p the canonical product of genus p, p < p < p + l. Since log leQ(z)IO(r q ) = o(r P) with Izl = r, we only need concern ourselves with the canonical product P(z) = TIn>' E(z/zn, p), where E(z, p) = (l - z) exp(z + (z2/2) + ... + (zP / p» is the Weierstrass primary factor. We know from [Lev, p.12], [BG, §2.6.1O] that for some constant K = K(p) one has log IP(z)1 = '" ~ log IE
(z )I zn' p
r
:5 Kr P { io tn(t) P+ 1 dt
+r
1
00
T
tnet) p+2 dt } .
n;::1
Let nCr) .:5 ArP, nCr)
== 0 for 0:5 r
log IP(z)1 .:5 KArP Since p < p < p
{1:
< ro, then t P- P- I dt
+r
1
00
t p- p - 2 dt }.
+ 1, the second integral is convergent and
p p logIP(z)l:5 KArP {r p-p
+
r P- P }.:5 K,Ar P, p+l-p
so that the type of P is at most K I A. If nCr) = o(r P), for e > 0 given, let rl be such that nCr) .::: er P whenever r ~ rl. Then 10gIP(z)1< Kr P -
--dt + Ker P {IT tp-p-Idt+r L ~n(t) t + T,
:5 KorP
0
P 1
+ Klu P
so that P is of type zero.
.:5 K 2 u
1"" ,
t p- p - 2 dt
}
P,
o
172
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
If the order p of the function f is an integer, one cannot expect such a simple result. The reason is that either the term e Q can dominate or the infinite product P can have infinite order while nCr) O(r P ). These possibilities occur in the O(r) but the function has examples e: and II r(z). In the latter case, nCr) infinite order. There is a classical result of Lindelof that deals with this case.
=
=
2.6.3. Theorem. Let p be a positive integer and let f be an entire function of order ::5 p, f(O) = I, and let (Zn)n~1 be the sequence of its zeros repeated according to multiplicity and with increasing absolute values. Denote by p the genus of the canonical product P and by ao the coefficient of zP in the polynomial Q, where fez) e QC :) P(z). Then:
=
(I) the function f is offinite type if and only if (i) nCr) O(r P ); and (ii) S(r) L:lznl~,(l/z~) is a bounded function.
= =
(2) The function f is of zero type if and only if either (i) p = p, nCr) = o(r P ), and L:n>I(l/z~) = -aop; or (ii) p = p - I and ao = O. -
Note that in case 2(i) we are also assuming that the series is convergent. For the proof we need some preliminary results.
2.6.4. Lemma. Let f be a nonconstant entire function such that f(O) = 1. Let a > 0 and let 27rrf(a, r) denote the linear measure of the set A(a, r) := {z then for r
»
E
aB(O, r): If(z)1 :::: M(r)-I1),
1 one has 1
f(a, r) < - - . -I+a
Proof. Let a(a, r) := (O and _I
r
E
[0, 27r[: re i8 E A(a, r»), then its measure is lea, r)
10glf(reili)ldO:::: -al(a,r)logM(r),
271" JaCI1,r) while on the rest of the circle aB(O, r), one has loglf(reili)1 :::: logM(r).
Hence, _I 27r
r
log If(re i8 )1 dO ::5 (I - lea, r» log M(r).
JaBC(7,r)\aCl1,r)
Therefore, 0= log If(O)1 ::::
2~
fo
21f
log If(reili)1 dO :::: (I - (a
+ l)l(a, r» log M(r).
As a consequence, as soon as log M(r) > 0, we have 1 - (a
+ I)l(a, r)
~
O.
[
173
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
2.6.5. Lemma. Let P E N*, converging to product
00,
(Znk~1
IZnl S IZn+tI. If
IT E ( : ,p -
=
P(Z)
be a sequence of nonzero complex numbers Ln~I(l/lznIP) < 00, then the canonical
n~1
I)
n
has order at most p and type zero.
Proof. The convergence of the series is equivalent to
1
00
o
Therefore, n(r) -
1
00
n(t) --I
t P+
dt <
00.
n(t) - d t=o (I) t P+ 1
r
r -+
as
00.
We also have the inequality (see [BO, §2.6.1O], [Lev, p. 12]) 10gIP(z)1 = LlOgjE ( : ,P-I)j n~l
n
< Krp-I
-
f' n(t) dt + KrP Jo t P
1
00
r
n(t) dt. t P+ 1
Let C > 0 be such that n(t) S CtP, t > O. Oiven E > 0, let R > 0 be such that n(t)/t P S E, then
1R
1 r
-n(t) dt S C o tP 0
dt
1
+E
r
dt = (C - E)R
+ er.
R
Hence, log IP(z)1
s
(C - E)K Rr p- I + Ker P + o(1)r P = o(r P),
o
as we wanted to prove.
2.6.6. Lemma. Let n (t) be the counting function of entire function f of integral order p, f(O)
= I, then for Izi = r we have
L
log jE ( : ,p - I) j +
I::;n::;n(r)
n
< C (r P- 1 -
P
L
log
n>n(r)
r
Jo
n(t) dt tP
+ rP+11OO r
IE (~ , p ) I n(t) dt) . tP+2
Proof. For fixed r > 0 consider two auxiliary sequences: the first, (un)n, is finite, Un = Zn for I S n S n(r); the second, (vn)n, is the cofinal part of (zn)n, for n > n(r). Let J-Lr' Vr be their respective counting functions. Then J-Lr(t)
={
n(t) n(r)
if 0 :::: t :::: r, if t > r.
174
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
o
IJ,(t)
= { n(t) -
if 0 < t < r, if t ;: r.-
nCr)
Then the first tenn we want to estimate corresponds to the canonical product of the sequence (un)n, the second to the sequence (vn)n. Let p = 1, then from [BG, §2.6.lO] (or [Lev, p. 12]) we have
'"'
I!':;;-(,)
I (z 0) I ~ ior -JL,(t) 1 JL,(t) t - dt + r , ~dt 00
log E
zn'
=
'"' L log IE
(z zn' I )
l' {l o
I~ 4
net) -dt+n(r), t
OO
r
v,(t) dt + 2r2 f2
r
n>n~)
1T 00
v,(t) dt }
,
= 4 { 2r21OO n;t) dt - nCr) } . So, certainly the sum can be estimated by 8
{1'
n;t) dt
+ r2100 n~t) dt} .
In case p > I, we have similarly
~ 2P { (p +2
P
~C
P
+1
l)r P - 1
l' nt~) l
{(p + l)r + p
{r P- 1
dt
OO
1
r
+ nCr) }
net) dt - ncr)}
t P+2
dt + rP+1lOO net) dt}. ior net) tP , tP+2
o
Proof of Theorem 2.6.3. Let us first prove that the conditions (i) and (ii) in part (1) are enough to conclude that f is of finite type in the case when p p. We denote P + alz p - I + ... + p =
=
Q(z) aoz
a
and note that E(u, p) = eUP / p E(u, p - 1).
Consider the quantity D := log
If(z)1 - Re [zp
{ao + ~p E z~}] I:;:n:;:n(r)
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
=Re{alz P -
1
L
+ ... + a p + m logz} +
175
log
IE (:n' p -
I) I
l:5n:5n(r)
The first tenn in D is bounded by 0 (r P - I ) when p > I, and by 0 (log r) when p = 1, we shall write this as O(r P - I ). Using now the preceding Lemma 2.6.6, we have D
= O(r P - 1) + C -
(r P-
1
dt + rP+lj"" net) dt) . ior net) t t + P
P
r
P 2
We have net) ~ At P for some A > O. It is clear that the two integrals together are dominated by 2C p Ar P, so that D = O(r P ). Since S(r) is bounded, it follows that: log Ifez)1
= D + Re (zp
{ao+ ~s(r)}) =
O(r P ).
In other words, f has finite type dominated by 2Cp A + S, where S is an upper bound for lao + (\/ p)S(r)l. A similar argument can now be made for part (2), also when p = p. For £ > 0 given, we can find ro such that n (r) = uP for all r ~ roo Then the integral tenns in the earlier estimate of D can be bound by
C r PP
1 ro
1
0
net)
-
tP
dt
+ 2CP up.
Since the series L:n~1 z;P is convergent to -aop, for r ~ rl we have ao
1
+ - '""' ~ p
z-P < £' n -
l:5n:5n(r)
whence, 10glf(z)1 = O(r P -
I)
+ (2C p + i)uP ,
so that f is of type zero. Consider now the case where p = p - 1. Then the series L:n>1 IZnrp < and the infinite product P(z) has type zero by Lemma 2.6.5. Wehave
D = log If(z)l- Re[Q(z)
+ m logzJ
00,
= log IP(z)1 = o(r P ).
Therefore, in part (I) we immediately obtain that log If(z)1 = O(rP), the type of f is exactly laol in this case. In part (2), ao = 0 means that deg Q < p, then log If(z)1 = o(r P ). This last argument concludes the proof of the sufficiency of the given conditions. We now want to show these conditions are also necessary. In part (I), We already know that f being of finite type implies nCr) = O(r P ). The boundedness of S(r) is only a problem when p = p. Returning to the proof of the
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
176
sufficiency, we see that we have shown that - Re
{zp
lao + ~ L z~l} = -log If(z)1 + p I~n~n(r)
O(r P ).
For r ::: I we can estimate log If (z) I :'S log M (r) :'S B r P , but we need to estimate I log If (z) II. We can apply Lemma 2.6.4, with a = 3, and obtain that the measure of the set A(3, r) ~ aB(O, r), where log If(z)1 :'S -3Br P is 2rrrl(3, r), with l(3e, r) :'S Ur>r _0 A(3, r) we have Re
!. Therefore,
{zp [aD +.!.
in the complementary of the set
L z~l} = O(r P).
p I~n~n(r)
We want to conclude from this that S(r) remains bounded. If S(r) is not bounded, then the expression between square brackets is not bounded. This means that for some sequence of values rj ~ 00, we have for some I{Jj E [0,2rr[ and Rj > 0
4}
The measure of the set {O E [0, 2rr [: cos(O + I{Jj) ::: is 2rr /3, hence the set {z: Izl = rj, Rjrj cos(O + I{Jj) ::: iRjrfJ cannot be contained in A(3, rj), and this leads to a contradiction. We conclude that S(r) is bounded, as we wanted to show. (The reader will find an alternate proof of this fact in Exercise 2.6.1.) The necessity of the given conditions in part (2) is proved as follows: In the case p p - 1, we have already seen that the type of f is laol. Hence, 0 when f is of type zero. Let us now consider the case p = p. Since f is of type zero, then nCr) = o(r P ), and as proved earlier this leads to
ao = (*)
=
- Re {zp
lao +.!. L z~l} p I~n~n(r)
= -log If(z)1
+ o(r P ).
Let e > 0 be given, then we have ro > 0 such that the term o(r P ) is bounded by er P for r ::: ro, and we can also assume log M(r) :::: er P for r :::: rD. As above, the measure of the set A(3, r) £ aB(O, r) where
I log If(z)II ::: 3er P ,
Izl = r :::: ro,
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
177
is at most (rr /2)r. We claim that lim sup
(lo + -1 L
p
P l:sn:Sn(r)
r->oo
::: 8e.
Zn
If not, there are rj ~ 00, Rj > 8e, ({Jj E [0, 2rr [ such that for
Re
{Zp [(l0 + ~
L z~l} =
Rjr; cos(8
+ ((Jj)
::::
Z
= rje iB ,
4Rjr;
P l:sn:Sn(r)
>
4er;
on a subset of aB(O, rj) of linear measure (2rr/3h. But, any point of this set belongs to the exceptional set A(3, rj). Using the expression (*) we obtain a contradiction, so that the inequality (**) is true. We need to show that (**) implies that the series l:n>l z;;P is convergent and has the sum -(loP. Consider a finite sum
L
1 p'
l::on::oN Zn
and let r =
IZNI,
then
L
l:Sn:sN
1
zP n
L
l:Sn:sn(r)
if r :::: ro. Hence, lim sup N--+oo
~
z~
::: L
1',I=r Zn
1(l0 + ~ P
It is now clear that
L
1
n~l
p
I
liP:::
L
nCr)
-P- ::: e
r
41::: ge.
l:sn,,;N Zn
= -(lop·
Zn
This concludes the proof of Lindelof's theorem.
o
From the above proof we can extract the following corollary of Theorem 2.6.3:
2.6.7. Proposition. Let the canonical product P(z) = TIn>l E(z/zn, p) represent a/unction in the space Ap, and PN(z) = TIl:sn:SN E(zjzn, p). Then PN
N--+do
P
in the space Ap.
Proof. It is well known that the partial products PN converge to P uniformly Over compact sets. Let VN(t) be the counting function of the sequence (Znh,,;n:sN.
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
178
and let n(t) be the counting function of the whole sequence. First, consider the case p fJ N. Then we have p < p < p + I and some constant K = K(p) > 0, log IPN(z)1 ~ Kr P
-<
K rP
{i
r
VN(t) dt o t P+
{Jo
--I
r
n(t)
( - - dt t p 4-1
1 oo} + J -00
+r
VN(t) } dt t P+
--2
r
n(t)
r
t P+2
dt
r ~
KArP,
where n(r) ~ Ar P, since P in A p , therefore
E
Ap. So that the sequence PN is a bounded sequence
lim PN
N-'>oo
=P
in Ap.
In the case p E N*, p = p, we recall that the function S(r) = I:I:-on:;:n(r) z;;P is bounded, say IS(r)1 ~ C. It follows that the functions ISN(r)1 =I I:1:;:n:;:vN(r) z':;-PI are bounded independently of N, say by a constant C 1 > 0. (Here we use n(r) = O(r P ) as in the proof of the necessity of conditions (i), part (2) of Theorem 2.6.3.) As in Theorem 2.6.3 we rewrite
logIPN(')1
~R{: ".E" ,;,} + "I", log IE (~, I) I + L IE (:n ' I' p-
log
p)
n>VN(r)
and we conclude that
for some constant K = K(p), C 1 > 0, A > 0, as defined earlier. The case p E N*, p = p - I, is treated the same as the case p concludes the proof of the corollary.
fJ N. This 0
In the last chapter (Definition 1.3.24) we found that the space Expo(C) of entire functions of infraexponential type, i.e., order 1 and type 0, is isomorphic to the space of infinite order differential operators. For that reason it is interesting to consider the spaces of functions of minimal type. 2.6.8. Definition. Let Ap,o denote the Frechet space of entire functions of order p, p > 0, and type zero. The norms are given by
Ilfllm
W1m }, = max{lf(z)lezee
It is easy to see that Ap,o is an FS space.
mEN·.
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most
179
p
2.6.9. Proposition. For p rt N, if the canonical product P(Z) = TIn>1 E(z/zn, p) belongs to Ap.o, and we let P N denote its partial products, then -
PN N~60P, in Ap.o. The same statement if true if p E N* and the genus
p
=p-
1.
Proof. It is the same as that of the first part of the preceding proposition. Note that in the case pEN', P = p - I, the products PN E Ap.o. 0
2.6.10. Remarks. (1) In the case p
E N*, we have a difficulty when the genus p p. In this case, the canonical factor E«z/zn), p) does not belong to Ap.o. Hence, in general, we have the same problem for the partial products. On the other hand,let us consider the case of an even function I E Expo(C), 1(0) = l. Then the zeros appear in pairs ±ako and if we order them so that
=
then
1 L-=O, n~1
so that if Ln~l (l/Izn J)
I(z) =
g
E
Zn
= 00, the canonical product has genus p =
(~, 1) =
D{(1 - :J (1 + :J ez/a,
1 and
e- Zja, }
This time, the partial products
IN(z)
= J~L
(1 - (:J 2)
do belong to Expo(C), they converge uniformly over compact sets, and for every (1IINllm)N~l is a bounded sequence. This implies that
mE N*,
IN N-+601 in Expo(C). Note that if we denote by iN (z) = TIk>N(1 - (z/ak)2), then iNez) E Expo(C) and iN -+- 1 in Expo(C). (2) Similarly to the last part of the previous remark we have that if P(z) = 1L.~1 E(z/zn' p) is a canonical product of a function in Ap, p > 0 (resp. Ap.o, P ¢ N*), then PN(Z)
=
II E ( : ,p) -+- I
n>N
in Ap (resp. Ap,o).
n
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
180
(3) A number of the preceding properties, as well as the problems about localizability of ideals in Ap and Expo(IC), and algebraic properties of closed ideals, that shall be considered below, can be generalized to the spaces Ap(IC), where p is radial and satisfies the doubling condition (see [RuT], [KT2], [Bra], [Nil], [KrD. We now return to the question of localizable ideals in Ap. 2.6.11. Proposition. Every ideal in Ap is localizable.
Proof. From the previous section we know that it is enough to prove that if I is a closed ideal without zeros, then 1 = A p. Let f be a nonzero function in I. If I(a) = 0, then there is gEl such that g(a) "# O. As we have done before, we can write
[ g(Z) - g(a)] fez) z-a
= g(z) [/(Z)] _g(a) I(z) . z-a
z-a
The two functions in square brackets belong to Ap, hence g(a)[/(z)/(z - a)] E I. Since g(a) "# 0, I(z)/(z - a) E I. If a "# 0, it is also true that for any pOlynomial Q of degree::::: p, [/(z)/(l - (z/a»]e-Q(z) E I. Therefore, if I has finitely many zeros, we conclude that 1 E I. If I has infinitely many zeros we have
I(z)
= zmeR(z) IT E k~l
(!.., p) , Zn
p ::::: p, deg R ::::: p. We can eliminate zm and eR(z) by the previous remark and assume I coincides with the infinite product. The Remark 2.6.10(2) shows that the sequence III
converges to the function 1 in Ap. Hence, 1 E I.
o
Let us prove that the same result holds for the space Expo(IC). 2.6.12. Proposition. Every ideal in Expo(1C) is localizable.
Proof. Let us assume first that 1 is a closed ideal in Expo(lC) such that V (1) == 0. Let IE I\{O}. Multiplying I by j (j(z) = I(-z», if necessary, we can assume I is an even function. The same reasoning as that of the previous proposition, shows that if Zo is a zero of multiplicity m, then I(z)/[(z - zo)m], as well as f(z)/[(z2 - z~)m], belong to I. Therefore we can assume that 1(0) = 1, that
fez)
= II k~l
(1 -(: r) k
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
181
(why is there no exponential factor?), and that for any n ::: 1,
Since fn ~ 1 in Expo(C), we conclude that I = Expo(C). We now observe that the proofs of Propositions 2.5.3 through 2.5.6 and 2.5.8 can be carried on verbatim for the space Expo(C). It follows that every ideal in Expo(C) is localizable. 0 As a consequence of the localizability of the ideals in Ap one can easily prove that if I is closed ideal in Ap there are two functions fJ, 12 E I such that I = i(fl, h) (see Exercise 2.6.1). In fact, one can do much better, but at the cost of substantial amount of work. Squires [Sq I] proved that one can even find a pair g" g2 E I such that I = I (gl, g2) i.e., they are jointly invertible in Ap. As expected. this has interesting consequences about interpolation. We shall explain this work in the rest of this section. Recently Braun [Bra] has extended the result of Squires to the algebras Ap(C), p a radial weight satisfying the doubling condition. The reader can safely skip the proof of the following proposition in a first reading:
*2.6.13. Proposition (Squires). Given a multiplicity variety V there is a pair invertible.
S; V (g), g E Ap,
ft, hEAp such that V = V(fl. h) and ft, h are jointly
Recall that fl. h being jointly invertible means that if hEAp, V(h) ;2 V, then there are gl, g2 E Ap such that h = gIll + g2/z'
Proof of Proposition 2.6.13. Let V =
(Zk. mdk::I' then its counting function n v is given by nv(r) = Llz'I~" mk. The condition V S; V(g) implies
nv(r) .:'S ng(r) = O(r P ). Hence, if p ¢ N*, we have V = V(f), for a single function f E Ap, as a consequence of Lemma 2.6.2. Moreover, every function in Ap is invertible (see Proposition 2.2.14). Henceforth, we shall assume p E N*. The main part of the proof consists in finding fl E Ap, and 8, C > O. such that S(ft, 8, C) = {z E C: Ifl(z)1 < Ce- W }
has the following properties. Let Z counting multiplicities), then:
= (Zk Jk::I, Z (fl) = set of zeros of fl
(i) there are two disjoint open sets SI, S2. such that
(without
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A"
182
(ii) S2 is the union of disks B(zo, r) with the property that
d(B(zo, r), SI) ~ Kdzol-P for some convenient constant K I > 0; and (iii) for every Zk E Z, the multiplicity of Zk as a zero of fl is exactly mAo Once fl has been found we conclude the proof as follows: Let cp be a COO function which is equal to I on S2, 0 on SI, 0 :::: cp :::: I, and satisfies everywhere
I~~(Z)I:::: K2IzI
P,
for some K2 > O. This is possible due to condition (ii). The function Bcpjaz vanishes on SI U S2, hence the function (l!fI)(BcpjBz), which is well defined outside Z(h), can be extended to be Coo everywhere. Therefore, there is a Coo solution u of the equation BujBz = (l/fd(Brp/Bz), and the function h := cp - ufl is entire. We note that
hl(Z(fI)\Z) = 1
and
hlV
= O.
Moreover, the multiplicity of any ZI E Z(h)\Z as a root of the equation h(zl) = I is at least equal to the multiplicity of ZI as zero of fl. These properties of f2 follow from the fact that u is holomorphic on SI U S2. Hence
V(f ..
h) =
V.
What we need to know is that hEAp, for that we need to choose u satisfying the correct growth conditions, and, furthennore, we would like fl, h to be jointly invertible. Let us estimate 1(l/fd(ocp/Bz)l. Since supp(Bcp/Bz) n S(fl, e, C) = 0, then IfI (z)1 ~ ee- CW on supp lacp/Bzl, therefore
_1_1
acp Ifl(z)1 az
(Z)I <- Ae BW
(z
E
C),
for some constants A, B > O. From here we conclude there is a choice of u satisfying the estimate .
l
lu,2e-MW
C (1
+ Iz12)2
dm <
00
for some M > 0, as well as the equation au/az = (l/fl)(acp/az). It is possible to obtain a pointwise estimate for u from these two properties. Recall the following lemma from [BO, Exercise 3.2.8].
2.6.14. Lemma. Let n be an open set in C and let K be a compact subset ofn, there is a constant C > 0 such that for every function v of class C I in n
s~Plvl5 (s~pl:~I+ llv'dm).
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
183
Proof. Let X E D(Q), X = 1, in a neighborhood of K, 0 ~ X ~ 1. Apply Pompeiu's formula [BO, §2.IAJ to the function XU for a E K, then v(a)
= x(a)v(a) =
1 -. 2m
1.
aX v(z) -::-(z)--dz 1\ dz az z- a
Q
1.
I av dz 1\ dz + -. X(z)-=-(z) . 2m!2 az z- a
Since Iz - al :::: .5 > 0 on supp(aX/az), we can estimate the first term by const. J!2 Ivl dm. Using that 1/(z - a) is locally integrable, we can estimate the second 0 integrand by sUP!2lav/azl. We apply this lemma to Q = B(O, 1), K =
to},
v(z) = u(zo
+ z), for a fixed
Zo E C, and obtain
lu(zo)1
~C(
sup Izo-zl:" 1
IfI a~1 + r 1
az
} B(zo.1)
IUldm).
On the other hand, for some constants A', A" > 0, we have sup Izo-xl:"1
I~ a~ I ~ It
az
sup
AeBlzlP
=
A' eBlzolP
Izo-zl:,,1
and
X
(1
I 12 -MlziP U e
B(zo.l) (1
+ Iz12)2
dm
) 1/2
< A" eM'lzolP
-
with M' = M /2. It follows that lu(z)1 ~ C1ec,W and 12 E Ap. Let hEAp be such that V(h) 2 V. The function h(l - h) E Ap and V(h(l- 12» 2 V(/t). Therefore, there is gl E Ap such that h(l- h) gtfl. Hence h = gtfl +hh,
=
which shows that fl, 12 are jointly invertible. We shall now construct fl. The idea is to add zeros to Z, with convenient multiplicities so that these new zeros are sufficiently distant from Z and the corresponding multiplicity variety V' satisfies V' 2 V and the conditions of Lindelofs Theorem 2.6.3. We call these new zeros {aj )j~1 (not necessarily distinct). There are three conditions to be satisfied: there is a constant K :::: 0 such that: (i)
(ii)
IRe { IZkl:"r L m: + lajlY E a~} I~ K; zk j
IIm{ L m: + L IZklY Zk
(iii) nv,(r) = O(rP).
~}I ~ K; and
lajlyaj
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
184
The reason to separate the real and imaginary part of LindelOf's condition is that for p odd we shall need to place the aj on the real and imaginary axes respectively to satisfy those two conditions, while for p even we need to place them on the rays (J = 0, (J = 7r / p, for the condition (i), and on the rays (J = 7r /2p and (J = 37r 12p, for the condition (ii). We shall show in detail for the case of p odd how to place zeros on the real axis to achieve the boundedness condition. The other cases, being entirely analogous, are left to the reader. The proof is a bit delicate; it takes six steps and follows the blueprint of the proof of the Cartan-Boutroux lemma [Lev], [BG, §4.5.13]. For n ~ I, let An = {z E C: 2n- 1 ::: Izl ::: 2n }, Bn = B(O, 2n ), and denote the points of Z n An by Vn = (b7h~j~An' repeated according to their multiplicities. Therefore, for AO = nv(l), we have Ao
+ AI + ... + An =
nv(2n).
For a disk C we denote by R(C) its radius. First Step. Let 0 < "f/ ::: 1/10 be a fixed constant that will be chosen later. Following Cartan- Boutroux one can find disjoint disks Cf, i = 1, ... , in, such that 2H:= R(Cn = "f/2n+ 1
L
l~i~in
and the number of points of Vn interior to q is exactly (HIAn)R(Cf). Set lln := HI An = "f/2n 1An. It is shown in [BG, §4.S .13] that the q have the property that if z 1- UI~i~ln q, then any disk B(z, kiln), kEN", contains at most k - I points of Vn • We replace the disks q by concentric disks Cf of radii R(Cf) = R(Cn + 311n. For z rt U1
L
R(Cn::: SH
= S"f/ 2n .
l~;~in
The disks
Cf
will be called the "omitted disks."
Second Step. We shall estimate the measure of the intersection of the real axis with the omitted circles. The points in the set
can only appear as points from disks starting from points of Vn_ l , Vn, or Vn+l· The length is at most 2 x 571(2n- 1 + 2" + 2"+1) = 351]2n. This indicates that eventually we shall need 1] < 1/70 to have enough room to maneuver.
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most
185
p
Third Step. Let us estimate the maximum value of IRe El!:j9. 1/(bj)PI. Since Ibjl ~ 2n - l , we have
Re
L
A"
1!:j9,.
( b" )P < - -(--1)-' 2 n- p j
Fourth Step. We are now trying to find where to locate the new zeros. One of the conditions is that the disk of radius 28" centered at a new zero does not intersect any of the omitted circles or any of the other previously added disks ofradius 28". We shall show that the new zeros can be chosen as a subsequence of the sequence «~j)l/p)jEZ' for a conveniently chosen constant 0 < ~ < 1. We shall choose ~ so that d", the smallest distance among the points in «~j)l/P)jEZ n A", is smaller than 8", and this holds for every n EN. For that reason we need to estimate d". The distance between successive points is
(~(j + I))I/p
-
(~j)I/p
= (~d/p
I)l/P ] [( 1 + -: -I
(C')llp
~ _"_1_._
1
Pl
clip
= '~-(l/P)' Pl
Since this distance is decreasing as a function of j, the value dn is as can be estimated taking j = [2 np / Hence,
n
d< "
~l/p
On the other hand, since nv(r) 8
"
~
<---..,.,.
p(2"P /~)(p-l)/p -
= rJAn2n
~ CorP,
> -
r
~
~ = np Co2
p2n(p-l)
1, we have An rJ
C 0 2,,(p-l)
~
Co2 np , and
.
If we take ~ = rJP/Co, we obtain dn < 8n . Note that by choosing the new zeros among the points of {(~j)I/P: j E Z} we automatically satisfy the requirement n v' (r) 0 (r P ). To choose the subsequence (aJ)I!:j!:j. of «~j)l/p)jEZ n An that we shall use as new zeros we impose two extra conditions:
=
(iv) The distance between two of the points (aj)l~j~j, is at least 48n ; and (v)
-I-}I
2: _1_ +Re { 2: II!:j!:}. (aJ)P l!:j!:)". (bJ)P
< _1_. 2(n-1)
We note that (v) implies (i) almost immediately. In fact, if r E [2n , 2n+ 1 [ and, by abuse of language, S(r) denotes the sum in (i), then IS(2") - S(r)1 ~ C2np /2(n-l)p = C2 P , while IS(2")1
~ IS(I)I +
L -(' ~ 1 ~ 2 + ISO)I· )
l!:j!:n2 1
186
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
Since dn < On. we can choose a positive integer e such that 40 n < edn < 8on • By choosing the (aj)j as a subset of the sequence «~ej)llp)jEZ n An. we guarantee (iv). To simplify the notation. let ~ = e;. The idea about how to satisfy (v) consists in showing we can do it in the worst possible case. e.g .• I:1~j~).n l/(bJ)P = -A n/2(n-l)p. (The case An/2(n-l)p is dealt with similarly. since An n «~j)llp)jEZ is symmetric with respect to the origin. and p is odd.) Let us start by proving an auxiliary lemma. 2.6.15. Lemma. Let In = lan• bn[ £; I = la. b[. 0 < a < b. I ~ n ~ N. I:l
- > -10 I~M~A - 2~ g aP+(~/W+l)T
1
1
[
]
.
Proof. The largest measure of a subset of I P = laP, b P[ that can be covered by the union of the intervals = laf, bf [ is obtained when they cover the interval ](b - L)P, bP[, this value is precisely T = b P - (b - L)p.
I:
The minimum value of the sum is obtained when the union of the intervals covers consecutive points of the sequence (~j)j~O starting with a P • The shortest possible length of the intervals I/: is precisely W = (a + a)P - a P. On the other hand. the length of the intervals is less than ~ , since no consecutive pair ~j, i;(j + 1) lies in the same interval. Therefore, the maximum interval covered by the I: in case the sum is minimized. is J = laP, aP(i;/W + 1)T[. Let J' = IP\]. Hence
I:
I:
I 2: -log I {bL -I 2: ~jEJ' L -: l~k~M ~Ok ~J 21; I;
P
[ (a P
+ ( -i; + I ) T)/~ ] W
-I}
I { bP } - -10 - 21; g aP+(I;/W+l)T .
The last inequality is a consequence of the following one:
2: -kI 2: I
ms k ~n
+ 1 -dt = log m+1 t n
(n-m ++-I1 )
(n ) .
2: ~ log m
o
We apply the lemma to the case the omitted circles intersect the interval = 2n - 1, b = 2n ,
[2 n - 1 ,2n ] in a set of the largest possible measure. We have a a 2: 4on , T = 2np (1 - (1 - 3517)P) (from the second step),
W
= (2n-1 + 4o
n
)P - 2(n-l)p 2: p4on2(n-l)(p-I) ,
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
and ~ :::: 8on P2n (p-I), hence ~/W able points (an l::;k ::;kn' we obtain "I
I I
L....- (an)p:::: 2>- og
l::;k::;kn
+I
{2 P
~
k
187
:::: 2P + 1. Therefore, using all the availlog({2P 1(1 + I'}')j 168 2n(p-l) , nP
'}
1(1 + I'})::::
with 1)' = (p2P + 1)2P (I - (1 - 351)P). We need to obtain that this lower bound exceeds AnI2(n-l)p = 1)2nlo n2(n-l)p, i.e., we need log({2 P 1(1
+ I'}')}2n 16p2np
1
I'}2n ----- 2(n-l)p'
~-------------->
It is clear that, after dividing out the common factors, letting .,., ....... 0 makes the left-hand side approach (1/32) log 2, while the right-hand side tends to zero. Therefore, for a convenient choice of I'} > 0 we can achieve 1
L ( n)p +Re L
I::;k::;k;
ak
I (bn)p:::: 0,
l::;j::;An
j
ar
in the case the second term is negative, choosing all the > 0 (as we pointed out, the situation is symmetrical and we only need to consider this case). By eliminating points we decrease this sum and, since each term (ar)-P :::: 2-(n-l)p, we can stop just before the sum becomes negative. In this case we obtain
ar
0< "
-
I --
L....- (n)p I::;j::;jn aj
+ Re
I
"
- - < 2-(n-l)p < 2-(n-1)
L....- (bn)P
l::;j::;An
-,
j
which is the estimate (v).
Fifth Step. Let Wn := UI::;k::;n Vk U {aJ: I :::: k :::: n, 1 :::: j :::: jn}, and Pn(z):=
II (z -
Wk)·
W!EWn
We want to show that for z E A n- I U An and outside any of the omitted disks, corresponding to k :::: n, and any of the disks B(a}, 20k), I :::: k :::: n, I :::: j :::: jn, the polynomial Pn satisfies the inequality IPn(z)l::::
(s: 2n f
n ,
Pn := L:I
aJ
m
188
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
points of Vi. Now, if for some e, we have Iz - yfl < (f.j2)8k. let m = (ej2) or (e + 1)/2, according to e being even or odd, then B(z, m8k) contains at least the e points yt, ... , yf, while 2m - I ~ e. Since (5mj4) - I < 2m - I, this is a contradiction. Hence, the claim is correct. Consider now the polynomial
n
Qk(Z) =
(z - yl)·
I::;i::;qk
As a consequence of the previous claim, outside the excluded disks it satisfies IQk(Z)1 :;:
q, (/8 ) D -f
:;:qk!
(8 )q,
= qk!;
Y/2k- 1 )q, (> qk
:;: qk!
(Y/2k)q, 2Ak
(Y/-2k-I)q, . e
For z E An-I U An, the only values of interest for excluded circles are k = n - 2, n - I, n. For the other values of We we have Iz - wei:;: d(z, Bn - 3) :;: 2n - 3 • Hence
as claimed.
Sixth Step. The estimation of Pn will help us to show that the entire function defined as the canonical Hadamard product with zeros in W = UI
Ii
for every z E An-I U An outside the omitted disks and all the B(aJ, 28 k ), H is a strictly positive constant independent of n. The proof is essentially the same as that of the Minimum Modulus Theorem. We can assume Ii (0) = 1. We have W = {Wk: k :;: I}, IWkl ::::: IWk+d, II(z)
= II E (~, p) = g(z)h(z), Wk
k:::1
g(z) =
IT
O
11 - ~I· Wk
As before, let Pn be the number of zeros of /1 in Bn. For outside the omitted disks and B(aj, 28k), then Ig(z)1 =
IWI' "Wp,I-1
IT
Iz -
wkl > IWp,I-P'
Z
E
An_I U An and
(;2 f'· n- 3
I ::;k::;p,
We have Pn
1 = n(2n)::::: log 2
1
2"+1 n(t)
2"
--dt ~ t
log M(2 n + l ) log 2
,
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most
189
p
YJ) logM(2n+l) log Ig(z)l::: ( log 8e log 2 ' outside the omitted disks and the B(a}, 20k). If we choose 17 > 0 smaller if necessary, we can assume that the sum of the radii of the omitted disks and the disks B(aj, 20k ) which intersect An-I U An is less than 2n-2. Therefore, there is an R, 3 x 2n - 2 < R < 2n such that the last inequality holds on the circle Izl = R. Let us now choose () such that Ih(Re i9 )1 = M(h, R) = sUPlzl=R Ih(z)l. Since M(R, f) = M(R) ::: M(2 n +I ), we have log M(h, R) ::: log M(R) -log Ig(Re i9 )1
(!L)} .
::: log M(2 n+ l ) {I - _I-log log 2 Be
On the other hand, h has no zeros in Bn and h(O) = 1, hence the Borel-Caratheodory lemma [BG, §4.5.9l allows us to conclude that 2r
log Ih(z)1 ::: ---log M(h, R),
Izl ::: r < R.
R-r
Let r = 2n-l, then loglh(z)1 ::: -4IogM(h, R),
Izl ::: 2n- l .
We conclude that for Z E A n- Io outside the omitted circles and B(aj,28k ) we have log If(z)1 ::: -Cllog M(2 n +l ) ::: -C2IzI P - e3, for some el, e2, e3 > O. This shows that if e = e- c.., the set SUI, e, e) has the three required properties, namely, we let S2 = Up B(aj, 20k ) and SI its complement. This concludes the proof of Proposition 2.6.13. 0 2.6.16. Corollary. Given V = (Zk, mkh~1 ~ V(g), g E Ap. The necessary and sufficient condition for V to be an interpolation variety for Ap is the existence of fl' hEAp, and constants e, e > 0 such that V = V(fl, h) and Ifl(m,l(zk)1 mk!
+ I fi m,l (zt> I > mk!-
(CliP)
eexp -
Zk
•
In the context of this corollary, let us introduce another kind of interpolation problem, to distinguish it from those of Section 2.2. We shall call it the universal interpolation problem. The remainder of this section is based on [SqIl, [Sq2J. 2.6.17. Definition. A multiplicity variety V = (zt. mk)k>1 in Q is called a universal interpolation variety for Ap(Q) if for every sequence
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
190
Yk.j(k ::: I, 0
~
j
~
mk - 1) for which there are constants A, B > 0 so that
We note that this concept only coincides with that of interpolation variety if mk = O(exp(Bp(Zk») for some B > 0, for instance, if p(z) = IzlP or p(z) = I Imzl + log(l + Izl). If V = (Zb mkh~l = V(j[, ... , fn), the functions ft, " ., fn are jointly invertible in Ap(C) and V is a universal interpolation variety for Ap(C), then there is F E Ap(C) such that
2.6.18. Proposition.
F(mkl(Zk) ---=1 md
(k ::: 1)
and V(F) 2 V.
We start with two preliminary lemmas:
2.6.19. Lemma. If V is a universal interpolation variety for Ap(C), then for every C > 0 there are constants A, B > 0 and functions fk,j E Ap(C) such that: (i) fi:j(zd = 0 except when k (ii) fk(,jj(Zk) = j!; AeBp(z) (iii) IA,(z)1 ~ (C ( exp P Zk
= I and i = j;
»
Proof. Let Ap,u(V):= {(Yk.j)k,j: 3A, B > 0, IYk.jl ~ Aexp(Bp(zd)} and p: Ap(C) ~ Ap,u(V), p(!) = f(j) (Zk)/j !, which is surjective by hypothesis. For a given C > 0, let D:= ((Yk,j) E Ap,u(V): IYk,jl ~ exp(Cp(Zk»}, topologized by the distance induced by the norm II(Yk,j)11 = sup{lYk.jle-Cp(z.J}. k,j It is easy to see that D is a complete metric space. Let Un := If E .*'(C): If(z)1 ~ n exp(np(z»)}. One shows, as in Lemma 2.2.6, that p(Un ) D is closed in D. By hypothesis, D Un>! (P(Un) D), hence one of the terms has a nonempty interior. Therefore, for some nand e > 0
n
=
n
we have It follows that p(Un/e)
n D = D. Hence there are entire functions .h,j such that
l.frc.j(z)1 ~ ~enP(Z), e
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
if I = k and i otherwise.
h.j(Zt) = {exP(Cp(Zd)
j !
191
0
= j,
The functions fk,j := exp( -Cp(Zk».h,j satisfy the conditions (i), (ii), and (iii) of the lemma. 0
= V (fl, ... , fn). with fl, ... , fn jointly invertible in and V = (Zb mkh::: I is a universal interpolation variety for Ap(IC), then there is a constant Co > 0 such that 2.6.20. Lemma. If V Ap(IC),
L
e-COP(Zk)
<
00.
k:::1
Proof. Since I
E Ap(IC),
it follows that for some
1
e-C1P(Z)
Let dj := infllzk - Zjl: k =1= disks are disjoint, hence
L
j~1
r
lB)
dm <
CI >
0 we have
00.
n, dj := min{l, dj/2}, and Bj = B(zj, dj ). These
e-C1P(z)
dm :::::
1
e-C1P(Z)
dm <
00.
IC
Now, since a universal interpolation variety is an interpolation variety, we know (see proof of Theorem 2.2.10) that there exists 8 > 0, C2 > 0, such that
On the other hand, there are Ao, Bo > 0 such that for any Z E Bj, p(Z) ::::: AOP(Zj) + Bo. Therefore, for some, 8J, 82 > 0,
r
lB
e-C1P(z)
dm 2: "[(dJ81 exp(-C3P(Zj» 2: 82exP(-Cop(Zj».
j
Hence
o We can go back to the proof of Proposition 2.6.18.
Proof of Proposition 2.6.18. Let us consider the series F(z) = Lmk(Z - Zk)!k.mk-1(Z), j:::l
with the functions obtained in Lemma 2.6.12 for a value C > 0 to be chosen below. If this series were uniformly convergent over compact sets and FE Ap(IC), then we could differentiate it term by term and evaluate it at Zk. We would then
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
192
obtain
F(md (zd = Am, -I (Zk) = l. mk! (mk - I)! Let us prove the convergence of the series and estimate F. IF(z)1
:s Lmk(lzl + IZkDIAm,-I(Z)1 k:::1
:s IzlA exp(Bp(z»
mk exp( -Cp(Zk»
L k:::1
+ Aexp(Bp(z»
Lmklzklexp(-Cp(Zk». k:::1
Since we are in the conditions of Theorem 2.2.10, it follows that the property (*) given there holds. In the course of the proof that the property (*) just mentioned implies that V is an interpolation variety, we proved that there are constants E, F > such that
°
for every
k::: 1.
Using that estimate and the fact that from the properties of p we have for some L, K >0,
Izl
:s Lexp(Kp(z»,
we obtain IF(z)!
:s 2A exp«B + K)p(z»
Lexp(-(C - E - K)p(Zk». k:::1
°
Choose C > so that C - E - K ::: Co, Co the constant of Lemma 2.6.20, then the series converges uniformly and IF(z)1
:s A' exp«B + K)p(z».
This concludes the proof of the proposition.
o
2.6.21. Remark. Let us remark that we have also shown that if V:::; V (fl, ... , In), with II, ... , In jointly invertible, then V is a universal interpolation variety if and only if V is an interpolation variety. In order to find necessary and sufficient "geometric" conditions for a multiplicity variety to be an interpolation variety, we need to introduce a little extra notation. Given two positive constants K I , K2 and a point zo, we denote r(zo) the largest positive number such that if z E 8(zo, r(zo» then p(z) :s KIP(zo) + K2· The hypotheses on p guarantee that we can find Kl> K2 > 0 so that r(zo) ::: 2 for every zoo We fix these values henceforth. If V = (Zk. mk)k:::l, we denote rk := r(zk). We also denote n(zt, r, V) the number of points of V, counted with multiplicity, in B(z*, r)\{zd. If V :;: V(h). we write n(z*, r, h) instead of n(zl, r, V).
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
193
2.6.22. Proposition. Let V = (Zk> mkk~1 = V(fl, ... , fn), where fl, ... , fn are jointly invertible in Ap(C). Assume V is an interpolation variety for Ap (
1 r,
(1)
o
n(z
t V)
/." t
(2)
dt ~ Cp(Zk) mk < -
+ D,
Cp(zd + D . logrk
Proof. Let F be the function obtained in Proposition 2.6.18. For every k ::: 1 we have _1_
2;ri
r
J2-:.I=rk U; -
d~
F(O
=
F(mk)(zd
Zk)m,+1
I
Since F E Ap(
+ K2
= 1.
mk!
for
Z
E B(zk, rk),
we obtain
1 ~ A exp(8p(zd)/r;"
for some A > 0, 8 > o. Taking logarithms we obtain (2). Let us now apply Jensen's formula to the function fez) = F(z)/(z - Zk)m,. We have for f (0) = 1, hence
1'; o
n(z t F) 1 k> , dt = t 2;r
12JT 10g1F(Zk +rke,6)lde . -mklogrk. 0
Recalling we have assumed rk ::: 2, we obtain
1
n(zk> t, F) --'---'-- dt o t r,
By construction we have n(zk> t, V)
~
~ Cp(Zk)
+ D.
n(zko t, F), hence (I) also holds.
0
In the case of the algebras Ap, one can obtain now clear geometric conditions to decide when a multiplicity variety is an interpolation variety. Note that these are the conditions that exclude the examples of the type occurring in Exercises 2.2.12 and 2.2.13. 2.6.23. Proposition. Given a multiplicity variety V = (Zk. mkh:::1 ~ V (g) for some g E Ap \{O}, a necessary condition for V to be an interpolation variety for Ap is that (1')
(2')
for some C, D > 0 and alllzkl ::: 2. If V = V(g), these conditions are sufficient.
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A"
194
Proof. From Proposition 2.6.13 we know that V = V (II, h), II, h jointly invertible in Ap. The proof of the necessity is a verbatim copy of the proof of Proposition 2.6.22. To prove the sufficiency of the conditions (I'), (2') when V = V(g), we need to show that for some £ > 0, A > 0, one has
I: : Ig(md(Zk) mk!
(k :::: 1).
ee-A1z!lp
It is enough to prove it for IZkl :::: 2, and also to assume that g(O) = 1 (Why?). We can apply the minimum modulus theorem ([BG, §4.5.l4], [Lev, p. 21]) to obtain constants £1 > 0, A I > 0 (independent of k) such that for Z E B(O, 21zk I) and outside a finite collection of exceptional disks, Bk • l , ••• , Bk,jk the sum of whose radii does not exceed ~IZkl, one has
Ig(z)1 ::::
£le-A11z,IP.
It follows that there must exist a value r, !IZk I < r < IZk!. such that CJB(zt, r)
n Bk,j
= 0,
1 ::: j :::
ik.
Apply now Jensen's formula, [BG, §4.4.30] to g in the disk B(zt, r). One obtains log I
g<md(Zk) mk!
1+ mk logr +
1
r n(V,
Zk,
t
0
t)
1
dl = -2 7r
1
2".
log Ig(Zk
0
.
+ re '8 )1 de.
From this identity, (1'), (2'), and the choice of r, it is clear that log I
g(md(zd mk!
I :::: -AlzklP - B
o
for some A, B > O.
2.6.24. Remark. [Sq2J. For the weight p(z) = I Imzl + 10g(1 + Izl), and a multiplicity variety of the form V = V (h), given by h slowly decreasing for Ap(C), one has that V is a (universal) interpolation variety if and only if
1
P(Z') n(V Zk t) , , dt::: Cp(Zk)
o
and
+D
t
Cp(Zk) + D mk < - - ' - - - - log P(Zk)
for some C, D > 0, independent of k. One can find necessary and sufficient geometric conditions interpolation, generalizing Proposition 2.6.2 for arbitrary radial weights satisfying the doubling condition [BL]. The correct expressions to consider are just the integrated Nevanlinna functions N (V, Zk> r) = (n(V, Zb 1)/1) dt. In this form the criteria obtained extend also for meromorphic functions and to several complex variables. This can be generalized to other radial weights, but the necessary and
J;
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
195
sufficient conditions do not coincide, though they are close to each other. This is a phenomenon characteristic of functions of infinite order of growth [BL]. In [GR] similar conditions for spaces of functions with prescribed indicator of growth have been found. Interpolation in the space of functions of infraexponential type has very interesting applications to the theory of Dirichlet series, as we shall see in Chapter 6. A classical theorem of Polya- Levinson [Levs, Theorem XXXI] states the following: Let V = (Zk}n~1 be a sequence of nonzero complex numbers such that Re Zn > 0,
. -n = 0, lIm
n~oo Zn
I1m Zn I =
ll.m
0
IZn I
n-'oo
and there exists c > 0 such that
Then there is an even function
f
of infraexponential type such that V S; V (f),
-log If'(zn)1 = o(lznl) and for
Z
as h --+
00
such that Re z > 0, dist(z, V) ::: c 18, we have -log If(z)1 = o(lzl)
(tt)
asizi --+
00.
Note that (t) implies that points Zn are distinct. One can prove that the main point (t) of the statement is exactly the condition that V is an interpolation variety for functions of infraexponential type. In [Vi2] it has been proved that the conditions on Rezn > 0 and I Imznl/lznl --+ 0 are not necessary. In fact, given any sequence V = (Zn In:::1 , n(r) = o(r), and {znln:::1 satisfies V, then there is a function f of infraexponential type such that (i) V 5; V (J); (ii) all zeros of f are simple; and (iii) V (J) is an interpolating variety in the space of functions of infraexponential type. (The condition (tt) also holds when dist(z, V(J» ::: c/8.) We provide a proof of this result in Chapter 6.
It is possible also to find necessary and sufficient geometric conditions for a variety to be interpolating in space of type zero for any radial weight satisfying the doubling condition [BLV]. EXERCISES
2.6.
I. Let j be an entire function, j(O) = 1. For r > 0, let ai, ... ,an denote the zeros of f in B(O, r) repeated according to multiplicity. (a) Show that
1121r e- i8 2" 7r
0
log If(re i9 )1 de
= ir/,(O) + i L"( ~ _ -) k=1
ak
ak r
•
Use this formula to show that if f is an entire function of exponential type then SI (r) Lld tl:5r ak' is bounded as r ~ 00.
=
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
196 (b) Let P E N*, find an explicit expression for -
I
27T
121< e-'p& . 10gl/(re,e)ldO . 0
=
involving Sp(r) L:1a,IY a;p. Use this expression to show that Sp remains bounded as r ~ 00, whenever lEAp. (Hint: Divide out the zeros of I to obtain a nonvanishing holomorphic function g in B(O, r). All this exercise requires is to compute the Fourier coefficients of the hannonic function Re(log g) (see also [BG, Exercise 4.6.9)).
2. Let E p , Ex be respectively the spaces of entire functions of order at most p (resp. finite order). For 0 < p < 00, nEW consider the Banach spaces Ep .• of all entire functions such that 11/11. = sup(l/(z)1 exp(-lzIP+'/.» <
00
and F., the Banach space of all entire functions such that 111/111.
= sup(l/(z)le- I: I') <
00.
(a) Show that Ep = nn>' Ep.n , Eoc = Un>1 F•. Ep is an FS space and is a DFS space. (Hint: Use Proposition 1.4.8.) (b) Show that every closed ideal in Ep (resp. E",,) is principal. (Hint: Find g such that V(g) = V(I).)
3. For 0 < p < such that
00,
n
E
II/lIn
N*, let Ap.n be the Banach space of all entire functions
= sup (I/(Z)I exp ( -~IZIP))
<
00.
(a) Show that Ap.o = nn,,' Ap,o is a FS space. (b) If p ¢ N, show every closed ideal is principal. (c) If p E N*, let w = ei21f / P , and assume that I E Ap,o satisfies I(wz) = I(z) for all z. Show that in the Hadamard canonical expansion of I, I(z) == z"'e Q(:) IT'>I E(z/zn, p), the polynomial Q has degree::: p - I, also that by grouping conveniently the Weierstrass factors E(z/zn, p) one can write the infinite product as ITk,,1 f{)" each f{)k E A p.o, and the infinite product converges in Ap.o. (d) Show that every ideal in Ap.o is localizable.
4. Use Proposition 2.6.11 to show that every closed ideal in Ap is principal if p ¢ N. 5. The object of this exercise is to prove that if [ is a closed ideal in Ap (resp. Ap.o), 12 E Ap (resp. Ap.o) such that [ = [(/1, h)· (a) Use Proposition 2.6.11 to show that if V = V(I) then [ = I(V). (b) Let 0 < IZII ::: IZ21 ::: "', IZn I ~ 00, (nkh,,1 a strictly increasing sequence ofpositive integers, €k > 0, E,>, €k < 00. Show that one can find a sequence of distinct Wk E C, 0 < IWk I /' 00, su~h that the set {Wk: k ~ I} is disjoint from {z.: n ~ I}, Iw;P z,;tl < €" and if the series En:::k z;;P converges to the value 01, and (Un)n"l is the sequence given by Un = Zn if n 1: nk(k ~ 1), Un, = Wko then En,,1 u;;P = S. (c) Let II E [\{O}. Use parts (a) and (b) to find 12 E Ap (resp. Ap.o) such that V(/I) n V (h) = V. Conclude that I = 1(11. h)· PEW, then there are two functions II,
6. Let the canonical product of a function I of finite order be I (z) ITn"l E(z/zn, p). Let PR(z) := zm Il1',I:::R E(z/zn, p), R > O.
zme Q
=
2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p (a) Assume
f
E
A p, show that e- Q fI PR e- Q f
.
lIm - - g PR
R-co
E
A p, and that for every g
=g
.
In
197
E
Ap one has
Ap •
(b) Let [ be a closed proper ideal in A p , V = V(l), f E [\{Ol, g E l(V). Write P R as a product PH = Pk P; such that V(P;) = V n B(O, R). Show that fI Pk E I. Use this to prove that gEl. (c) Prove parts (a) and (b) in the case Ap.o, P f/. N, and also when p E N* but P = p-1. (d) Let f E Ap.o, p = p, Q(z) = aoz P + QI (z), deg QI ::: P - I. Show that
pf
exp (zp - ~
z;;P )
E
Ap.o
p l'nl"R
R
and
holds in Ap.o. Use (c) and (d) to prove that all ideals in Ap.o are localizable.
7. Let V = V(jl, ... .jn), fI, ... ,fn jointly invertible in Ap(lC). Show that V is a universal interpolating variety if and only if V is an interpolating variety.
=
8. Let p(z) Izl P , r > 0, kl > \, k2 > 0, compute the function r(z) > 0 that has the property: p(t;)::: kIP(z) +k2 if and only if t; E B(z, r(z».
9. Suppose V C, D>O
= (Zk> mdk~1
1 rl
o
satisfies condition (I) of Proposition 2.6.22, i.e., for some
n(zk> t, V)
---'-''---'-dt ::: C(P(Zk)
t
+ I)
(k ::: 1).
Show that there are e > 0, A > 0 such that for any j =1= k IZk - Zj I ~ u-AP('
10. (a) Use Proposition 2.6.23 to show that the lattice IE + iZ is interpolating for Ap if p = 2. (b) Give a direct proof of the same result by using the Weierstrass a function [Mark].
CHAPTER 3
Exponential Polynomials
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials An exponential polynomial is an entire function
L
I(z) =
1 of the form
Pi (z)e"jt,
I~j~m
where {Xi E 1[, Pi E lC[z J. We assume that the {Xi are distinct and the polynomials Pi not zero. The Pi are called the coefficients of 1 and {Xi the frequencies. (Sometimes the {Xi are called the exponents, especially in the Russian literature. In some contexts {Xi = i)\,i, Ai E JR, and the Ai are called the frequencies and ri = 2rr/Ai (when Ai t= 0) the periods; clearly eiA)t is periodic of period ri') It is immediate that there is a unique analytic functional T whose Fourier-Borel transform J(T) coincides with I, i.e., J(T)(z) = (TI;' e:l;) = I(z). Namely, T is representable as a distribution in I[ of the form T
= '"' a·).v 8(v) a, ~
1
j,v
8t)
where 8a ) is the Dirac measure at the point (Xi' is a "holomorphic" derivative of order v, 8~~) = (a/az)"8"j' and the ai.v are complex constants. In the case where the frequencies {Xi are purely imaginary, i.e., (Xi = iAi' AJ E JR, then 1 is the Fourier transform of a distribution fJ- E £'(lR). That is, we let d L. ai.v iv -d v 81..) X V
fJ- :=
J.v
with fhj the Dirac mass at the point Ai
I(z)
=
E
JR (acting on Coo functions in JR) and
(fJ-x,
e- iXz ).
These simple observations correspond to the fact that if p(z) = Izl, then every exponential polynomial 1 E Ap(C), while if the frequencies are purely imaginary, f E F(£'(lR», i.e., one can use the smaller weight function p(z) = I 1m z I + log(l + Iz 12 ). We shall see in this chapter that, among other properties, a nonzero exponential polynomial is always slowly decreasing in Ap(C). 198
3. I. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
199
We denote by E the ring of exponential polynomials (including the zero function) and by Eo the subring of E consisting of exponential polynomials with constant coefficients (also called exponential sums). Let £*, denote the sets E\{O) and Eo\{O), and U(E) and U(£o) the groups of invertible elements of E and Eo, respectively. It is clear that U(E) = U(Eo) = {ae b:: a E C', bE q. In the set of complex numbers we consider the lexicographical order ~ defined by a ~ fJ if and only if either Rea < RefJ or Rea = RefJ and Ima:5 ImfJ. If a ~ fJ and a =1= fJ, we shall write a -< fJ. From now on, in the above representation of the exponential polynomial f we shall always assume aj -< aj+l, l:5j:5 n -l. We start by studying divisibility in the rings E and Eo. Since eYz is invertible and a -< fJ is equivalent to (a - y) -< (fJ - y), we can assume f has the form
Eo
fez)
=
L
Pj(z)e ajZ ,
0= ao -<
al
-< ... -< am,
O~j~m
for some m
~
1.
3.1.1. Proposition. Let fez) = LO~j~m Pj(z)e ajZ , g(z) = LO~k~n Qk(z)e flkZ be two exponential polynomials of the form (* ).If g divides f in E, then the frequencies fJI, ... ,fJn of g are linear combinations with rational coefficients of the frequencies al,"" am of f·
Proof. Since g divides f in E there is h E E*, h (z) = Lo~/~p R,e Y' z , such that f = hg. Since we are assuming Yo -< YI -< ... -< yp, it is immediate that Yo = O. If P = 0, then the frequencies of f and g are the same, and the coefficients are related by Pj = RoQj. We can assume therefore that p ~ I. Let 0 = Wo -< WI -< ... -< Wr represent all the frequencies of the form fJk + y" 0:5 k :5 n, 0 :51:5 p. Clearly (aD, ... , am) £ (Wo, ... , Wr I. In order to proceed we need an elementary, albeit important, lemma. 3.1.2. Lemma. Let F(z) = LI~j~n cpj(z)e AJZ be a nonzero exponential polynomial with frequencies AI -< A2 -< ... -< An, and coefficients f{Jj(z) = ajzmJ + ... , polynomials of degree mj ~ 0 (aj E C*). For every j, 1 :5 j :5 n, we have
II (~ - Ak)m.+l] fez) = cjeAjZ , [( ~dz - Aj)mJ k#j dz Cj = mj! aj II(Aj - Ak)mk+1 o. =1=
k'f-j Proof of Lemma 3.1.2. One proves by induction on the degree m of P E C[z], P(z) = az m +"', a E Co, that
(:z -
A)
m
(P(z)e AZ ) = m! ae AZ .
200
3. Exponential Polynomials
Hence
)m+1
d ( dz - A Therefore, if i
i=
(P(z)e AZ ) = O.
j, we have
and
~ _ A)ml II (~ - Ak)mdl(p.(z)e AjZ ) = II (~ ~ Ak)m'+I(m'! a·e A1Z ) ( dz dz dz J
J
J
k1'J
J
kh
=mj! aj
IICAj ~Ak)m,+leAJZ.
D
k#j
3.1.3. Corollary. The family CeAzhEIC is a basis of the C[z]-module E.
Proof of Corollary 3.1.3. The spanning property is clear. If an exponential polynomial F with frequencies AI, ... , An is the identically zero function, then Cj = 0 for i :::: j :::: n, which is impossible unless all the coefficients are zero.D Let us now return to the proof of Proposition 3.1.1. We have
hence, from Corollary 3.1.3 we have Qk(z)R/(z) = {
P(Z)
oj
ifwj=aj, . { } If Wi t/. aO,···, an .
Let us assume there is a tho, 1 :::: ko :::: n, which is not a linear combination with rational coefficients of ao, ... , am. Let V be the Q-vector space spanned by ao, ... ,am, and let cl, ... ,Cq be a basis for V. Then fJko,Cl, ... ,Cq is a Q-linearly independent family. Therefore, we can find Cq+l, ... , Cf such that tho, .0 I, ... , Cq, Cq+ I, ... , Cf forms a basis of the Q-vector space W spanned by ao, , .. , am, fJl, ... , fJn, YI, ... , Yp' Let us denote co := fJko' Every fJk, 1 :::: k :::: n, can be written in a unique way as fJk =
L
rkiCi,
O::::i~t
Let Uo := max{rk.O, 1 :::: k :::: n}, Uo 2: I. Consider the nonempty subset of fJk such that the coefficient rkO of co coincides with uo. Among these choose one whose coefficient rj.l of CI is as large as possible, say Ul, UI
:= max{rk,l: for k such that rk,O
= uo}.
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
201
Continuing this way we find a unique {hi denoted f3*, such that f3* =
2:= Uiei, 0:5i:51
whose successive coefficients Ui are maximal. Proceeding in the same way with YI, 0 ::: 1 ::: p, we find y* y* =
= Yk"
2:= Viei, O:5i :5t
whose successive coefficients are maximal. Here Vo ~ 0 since Yo = o. Let w* := f3* + y* = L:O
2:=
Pk R, = Pk, Ril
"# 0,
fh+YI=w*
°
since Pkl "# 0, RI, "# 0. It follows that w* E lao, ... , an}. This means that Wi = for i fj. {I, ... , q}. In particular, Wu = O. This is a contradiction. We conclude 0 that every f3k is in V, and the statement of Proposition 3.1.1 is correct.
We are going to consider now the problem of the factorization of exponential polynomials. 3.1.4. Definition. An element
f
f
E
Eo is normalized if it is of the form
(z) =
2:=
aje"'Z,
O:5j:5m
°
with = ao -< al -< ... -< am and ao = 1. A normalized element f E Eo is said to be simple if all the aj, 1 ::: j ::: m, are commeasurable, i.e., there is A E
= q;A,
E Q, qi > O. Let N be the common denominator of all the qi, then we can write qi = Pi/N, Pi E N*, and
qi
lXi
= Pif.l,
f.l=)"/N,
0< PI < ... < Pm.
202
3. Exponential Polynomials
Hence. if we let l; = eJ1.:. we have f(z) =
1+ a,l;P' + ... + am l; Pm •
which is a polynomial of degree Pm in the variable l;. Therefore. it can be factorized into Pm factors of the form 1 + cl; . In other words. f can be factorized into Pm simple factors of the form 1 + ceJ1.z. The same argument can now be repeated by writing
1 + ceJ1.Z
= 1 + c(eJ1.z j r)'.
for any r E N*. Hence. each of them factorizes into r normalized exponential sums of two terms. Therefore. not only is a normalized simple exponential sum not irreducible. but it admits infinitely many distinct factors (see Theorem 3.1.9 below).
3.1.6. Lemma. Let 0 -< a, -< ... -< am and P := dimQ V. with V =
=
L'~j~mQaj.
the Q-vector space spanned by a, ..... a m. Let Q+ Q n ]0.00[. One can find a basis /-L, ..... /-Lp of V such that aj E L'~k~pQ+ /-Lk. 1 :::: j :::: m.
Proof. For any j we have either Reaj > 0 or Reaj = 0 and Imaj > O. Accordingly. we can find 8 > 0 sufficiently small so that the numbers Aj = e- i8 aj satisfy ReAj > 0.1 :::: j :::: m. It is clear that e- i8 V = L'~j~m QAj also has a Q-dimension equal to p. Let m, •...• m P be a Q-basis of this space. Assume Aj =
L
aj/m/.
'~I~p
with ajl E Q. We shall first find another basis Mi •...• Mp of e- i8 V so that mk E L'~19 Q+ M/. for 1 :::: k :::: p. For that purpose. let us choose rational numbers tl,k so that for every I they approximate Reml for 1 :::: k :::: p. Assume further that det(t/k)/,k =J:. O. Then we can detennine M, . ...• Mp from the system of equations
m, = L
tlkMko
1 :::: I :::: p.
'~k~p
This indicates that the Aj can be written as
Since we want
tlk
approximately equal to Reml. then the rational numbers
bjk := L'~I~p aj/tlk are approximately equal to Re(L'~I~p aj/ml) = Re Aj > O. In other words. if we choose tlk sufficiently close to Reml. 1:::: k :::: p ••we can guarantee that bjk E Q+ and. clearly. this can be done so that simultaneously
the detenninant det(t/k}J,k =J:. O.
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials We now let /-Lk LI!'Ok!'OP Q+/-Lk.
= ei8 Mb
203
I ~ k ~ p. They form a basis for V and Cij
E
0
Let us now return to the situation of Proposition 3.1.1.
3.1.7. Proposition. Let fez) = LO::;j!'Om Pj(z)e Uj ; and g(z) = LO!'Oj::;n Q/z)e PjZ be exponential polynomials of the form (*), with more than one term. Assume that g divides f in E and that Cil, ... , Ci m are linear combinations with nonnegative rational coefficients of p Q-linearly independent complex numbers /-LJ, ••• , /-Lp. In this case, the frequencies /3t, ... , 13m are also Q-linear combinations of /-LI, .•• , /-Lp with nonnegative coefficients. Proof. From Proposition 3.1.1 we conclude that
We want to show that rjk ::: 0 for every j, k, 1 ~ j ~ n, I ~ k ~ p. To fix ideas let us assume rj I < O. We choose among the f:3j, those for which rj I is minimal; among these, those for which rj2 is minimal, etc. One finds in this way, a certain f:3io, denoted 13*, whose coefficients with respect to /-LI, ••• , /-Lp are all successively minimal. Let us write
13* =
UI/-LI
+ ... + Up/-Lp,
Uj
E
Q,
1
~
k
~
p.
We have UI ~ rjo, 1 < O. Let 0 = Yo -< YI -< ' .. -< Yr, and Rk be polynomials such that
We augment the collection /-LI, ••• , /-Lp to a basis /-LI, ., . , /-Lq of the Q-vector space generated by Cil, ... , Ci m, 131, ... , f:3n, YI, ... , Yr' Among Yo, ... , Yr we find Y * whose successive coefficients with respect to /-L I, ••• , /-Lq are minimal. Let y* = VI/-LI + ... + vq/-Lq, with VI ~ 0 since Yo = O. As in Proposition 3.1.1, we can see that 13* for some i, 1 ~ i ~ m. Then
+ y* = Cii
+ VI )JLI + ... + (up + vp)JLp + Vp+1 JLp+1 + ... + Vq/-Lq. = ... = Vq = 0 and UI + VI < 0, which is a contradiction with the
Cii = (u I
Clearly Vp+1 hypothesis that every oti has nonnegative coefficients with respect to JLl, .•. , JLp. Therefore, it must be true that 'ik ::: 0, 1 ~ j ~ n, 1 ~ k ~ p. 0
3.1.8. Remark. It follows from Proposition 3.1.7 that the Yj are also Q-Iinear combinations of the JLk with nonnegative coefficients. We shall accept the following result of Ritt about factorization in the ring Eo. The proof is entirely algebraic and rather long (see [Ril], [Go], [Schi]).
204
3. Exponential Polynomials
3.1.9. Theorem. Every normalized exponential sum f E Eo which is ¥= 0, 1 can be written in one and only one way (up to reordering) as a finite product of normalized exponential sums
where the ai are simple, any two of them have no nonzero common frequency, and the lrj are irreducible in Eo.
3.1.10. Remarks. (1) Let f(z) = 1 + ale"": + ... + ame"'m z , 0 -< al -< •.. -< am. If all the aj, 1 ::s j ::s m, are Q-linear combinations of J-tl, •.. , J-tp with nonnegative coefficients, and f = It ... ft is the decomposition of the previous theorem, then the frequencies of all the jj are Q-linear combinations of J-t I, ... , J-tp with nonnegative coefficients. (2) If P = rank of the additive group generated by al, ... , am, then it coincides with the dimension of the Q-vector space V defined in Lemma 3.1.6. Changing, if necessary, the J-tk obtained in the lemma by a submultiple, we can assume l::sj::sm. aj E N* J-tk>
2:
I~k~p
(3) Every nonzero exponential sum form
f
can be written in a unique way in the
with ae"'z E U(Eo), ai, ... , as normalized, simple, sharing no common nonzero frequencies, and lrl, ... , lrr, normalized irreducible exponential sums. We recall some classical results of commutative algebra that we will use in the sequel, see, e.g., [AM]. Let A be a commutative integral domain with identity and let Jt be the field of quotients of A. Denote A* := A\{O}, U(A) := the group of invertible elements of A, Jt* := the multiplicative group of the nonzero elements of Jt, and A[X], resp. Jt[X], the rings of polynomials in the variable X, with coefficients in A and Jt, respectively. We assume A satisfies the condition (~)
Any two elements of A * admit a g.c.d.
3.1.11. Definitions. (1) The content of a nonzero polynomial f E A[X] is a g.c.d. of the coefficients of f. It is denoted c(f). (2) A polynomial f E A[X] will be said to be primitive if c(f) is invertible. For every f E A[X] we shall write f = c(f)j, with j E A[X] primitive. The product of two primitive polynomials is primitive. If f, g E A[X]\{O}, then c(fg) = ac(f)c(g), a E U(A). Let us recall finally that there is a family P S; A[X] such that every element of P is primitive in A [X] and irreducible in Jt[X] and, moreover, any f E Jt[X]
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
205
can be written in a unique way in the fonn
I
= a II pn(p), peP
with a E .It, n(p) E N, and only a finite number of n(p) are different from zero. It follows that if I E A[X], then
I
cU) II pn(p),
=
peP
and the decomposition is unique. We shall now show that Eo verifies the property (Ll) and that E is isomorphic (as a ring) to Eo[X].
3.1.12. Lemma. Every exponential polynomial lEE can be written in a unique way in the lorm I(z) = lo(z)
+ II (z)z + ... + II(z)/,
where 10, ... , II E Eo. In other words, E is isomorphic to Eo[X].
Proof. Let I(z) = LI
L
(X2
-< ... -< am.
bijzj,
05cj 5cd;
so that if 1:= max{d l , I(z)
... ,
=
dm },
L (L bije";z) zj = L 05cj 5c1
d; ~j
jj(z)zj,
05cj 5c1
with jj(z) := Ld;~j bije<:t;z E Eo. This decomposition is unique. If L05cj5c1 jj(z)zj == 0, then Pi(z) == 0 by Corollary 3.1.3, I :5 i :5 m. Hence, bi • j = 0 for all i, j. Therefore, 1==0 for O:5j:51. Finally, it is now clear that Eo[X]
L
~
jj(z)xj t-+
05cj 5c1
E,
L
jj(z)zj
05cj5c1
o
is a ring isomorphism.
3.1.13. Lemma. Let
I, g E
Eo, then there is a g.c.d. in Eo-
Proof. As a consequence of Theorem 3.1.9 we have to consider the following three cases: (i) (ii) (iii)
I and g are simple; I and g are irreducible; I is simple and g is irreducible.
206
3. Exponential Polynomials
Case (i). Let 1(::.) = I + ale"lo + ... + ame"m o, 0 -< 0'1 -< ... -< am, ai = PiA, Pi E N*, and g(z) = 1 + b1e PIz + ... + bneP"z, 0 -< b l -< ... -< b n, bj = qj/1, qi E N*. We have two possibilities: either 0'1 I {31 E Q or not. The first case is equivalent to ai I (3j E Q and to A//1 E Q. Thus, in this case, there is v E C* such that ai
= riV,
ri,
Sj E
I ::::
N*,
Moreover, we have rl < r2 < ... < r m and consider the two polynomials in l;
SI
j ::::
< ... <
I:::: j :::: n.
m,
Sn.
Let l;
=e
Vz ,
and
F(l;) := 1+ all;r l + ... + aml;'m,
G(l;) := 1 + bll;sl + ... + bnl;Sn.
Let H be the g.c.d. of F and G in IC[l;]. It is clear that h(z) = H(e VZ ) divides I and g in Eo. Furthennore, h is nonnalized and simple. The Bezout identity H=FU+GV
for some U, V E IC[ l;] shows that h = uf
+ vg,
where u(z) := U(e":) and v(z) := V(e VZ ) belong to Eo. Hence if ii E Eo divides I and g, it follows ii divides h. Therefore, in this case, h is the g.c.d. of I and g. We claim that if A//1 ¢ Q, then I is the g.c.d. of I and g. In fact, if h divides both I and g, h is nonnalized and not I, then by Proposition 3.1.7 all the frequencies of h are integral multiples of A, hence h is simple. By the same proposition, all the frequencies of h must also be multiples of /1. Hence A//1 E Q, which is impossible. Case (ii). If I and g are irreducible, then either 1= ag, a E U(Eo), in which case 1= g (if they are nonnalized), or 1 is the g.c.d. of I and g. Case (iii). If I is simple and g is irreducible, the g.c.d. must be g or l. If g divides I, then it is simple by Proposition 3.1.7. Accordingly, the g.c.d. is 1. This concludes the verification that Eo has the property (~). 0
jj
Given lEE, we can write it in a unique way as I(z) = I:o:oj:o/ /j(z)zj, E Eo. We denote by c(f) E Eo the g.c.d. of the coefficients 10, ... , It-
3.1.14. Lemma. Let lEE, g divides c(f) in Eo.
E
Eo. Then g divides I in E if and only if g
Proof. Assume g divides I in E. Therefore, there is h (z) = I:O:oj:or h j (z )zi , hj E Eo, such that g(,)
(,E,
hJ(,),J)
~ /(,) ~ ,E, fJ(,),J,
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
207
By the uniqueness part of Lemma 3.1.12 we have 1= rand g(z)hj(z) = jj(z), I ~ j ~ I. This shows that g divides all the coefficients of f in Eo, hence g divides c(f) in Eo. The converse is clear. D
3.1.15. Lemma. Let f,g
E
E. There is a
E
U(Eo) such that c(fg) = ac(f)c(g).
Proof. This follows from E ;;:: Eo[X] and Eo verifies
(L~).
D
3.1.16. Proposition. Every exponential polynomial fEE can be factorized in a unique way (up to invertible elements) f
= C(f)TC~' ... TC;' ,
where c(f) E Eo, TC!, ... ,TCr are exponential polynomials in E\Eo, which are irreducible in E, mutually coprime, and n!, ... , nr E N*. Proof. Let f(z) = LO::):051 Ii (z)zj, Ii E Eo, and j(X) = LO:Oj:051 fj(z)xj, the corresponding polynomial in Eo[X]. Then, there are unique polynomials if!, ... , ifr , primitive and irreducible in EolX], and n!, ... , nr E N* such that j
= c(f)if~'
... if;' .
Let TCj be the exponential polynomials in E that correspond to ifj via the isomorphism Eo[X] ::::: E. Since this is a ring isomorphism, it follows that TCj are irreducible in E. This proves the factorization. The uniqueness follows the D same way.
3.1.17. Theorem. Every exponential polynomial can be factorized, in a unique way up to invertible factors, as the product of a finite number of simple exponential sums with frequencies pairwise incommeasurable, a finite number of irreducible normalized exponential sums, and a finite number of irreducible exponential sums. Proof. We apply Ritl's Theorem 3.1.9 to c(f) and Lemma 3.1.13. The isomor0 phism E ;;:: EolX] allows us to conclude the factorization is unique.
3.1.1S. Theorem. The ring E also satisfies the condition
(~):
any two exponen-
tial polynomials have a g.c.d. in E. Proof. Given f, g E E*, it is enough, by the preceding theorem, to consider the following two cases:
(i) f E Eo and it is simple. Then f and c(g) admit a g.c.d. in Eo. By Lemma 3.1.14, this is also the g.c.d. of f and gin E. (ii) f is irreducible. If f divides g in E, then f is the g.c.d. If not, is the g.c.d. D
208
3. Exponential Polynomials
We now use Lemma 3.1.2 to obtain some inequalities about exponential polynomials. We first note that if /(z) = LI;Sj;SN Pj(z)e AjZ , AI ~ A2 ~ ... ~ AN, Pj a nonzero polynomial of degree mj ~ 0, then these coefficients are uniquely determined \::y the function / and, in particular, we can define the degree of /, dO/ := mI + ... + mN + N - 1. We can also consider the supporting function H of the convex hull K of the points Xl, ... , XN , conjugates of the frequencies, namely, H(z) := m~xRe(Ajz) = max(Xjlz), J
J
where (,1,) denotes the Euclidean inner product in ]R2. This function is also uniquely determined by /. Recall that M(j, z, r) max{l/(~)I: I~ - zl :s r}.
=
3.1.19. Proposition. Let /(z) = Ll::oj::oN Pj(z)e AjZ E E*. For any ro > 0, there is a constant C > 0 such that/or every z E C and every 0 < r :s ro, the inequality
rdol exp(H(z))
:s CM(j, z, r)
holds.
Proof. Let us denote
Cj,l
E
C. Then
(:z)
Qj
/(z)
= Cje
AjZ
,
=
with Cj mj! aj ITk;l)(Aj - Ak)mk+l as in Lemma 3.1.2. Therefore, we can apply Cauchy's formula and obtain
e AjZ
=~
L
Cj.d(/)(z)
L
r
[!cI· t (~ O:s/:sdOI 2;r I Cj .I1~-zl=r
=
Cj O;st::odOf
This shows that given ro > 0 there is a constant
K
- z)do/-I
(~
/(~;ol Id~. - z)
+
> 0 such that
o Let us remark that the size of K in the last estimate depends on min{lAk - Ajl: k =f:. min{lajl: 1 :s j :s N}, max {!AjI: I :s j :s N} and dot· Let us give here a corollary of the above proof.
n,
3.1.20. Proposition. For any
f
E
E* there is a constant A > 0 such that
AeH(z):s
L
1/(/)(z)l.
O:s/:sdO I In particular, the multiplicity of any zero of f does not exceed dOf.
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
209
Proof. We have already shown that
e AjZ = ~ C. J
hence
leAjZI
~ c-J,/ f(/)(z) , ~
05.i5.dO f
.:s m~x ICj,//Cjl
L
If(/)(z)l,
05.i5.dO f
J.
which implies the required estimate. Moreover, if fez) = 0 and f.L = multiplicity of this zero, then f(l)(z) = 0, o .:s I .:s f.L - 1, which shows immediately that f.L .:s dOf. 0 Let us recall that, as a corollary of the Minimum Modulus Theorem [BG, Theorem 4.5.14], we obtained in Lemma 2.2.11 the following inequality: Let F be an entire function, F(n =j:. O. For any r > 0 there is p E ]r/4, r/2[ such that log (
IF(Z)I) inf - > -8logM ( -F- , l;, 2er ) . IF(l;)1 FU;)
Iz-~I=p
3.1.21. Proposition. Let fez) = L:15.j5. N Pj(z)e AjZ , be a nonzero exponential polynomial, mj = deg Pj, M = maxl5.j5.n mj' Then: (i) there is a constant A > 0 such that for any r E [0, 1] and z Ere we have
M(j, z, 2er)
.:s A(1 + Izl)M eH(z);
(ii) there are constants AI, MI > 0 such that for any r E (0, 1], z Ere, and any function g holomorphic in B(z, r), we have
Ig(z)leH(Z)
.:s
Al (l
+ Izl)Ml M(jg~ z, r), r
with v = 9dof. Proof. The first part is immediate. For the second part, let us choose any l;, Il; - zl = r/4, such that If(nl
= M(j, z, r/4) > O.
From the previous observation, there is apE ]r/4,r/2[ such that minlw-~I=plf(w)1 can be estimated from below. Let us write g = f g / f, then max
Iw-~I=p
If(w)g(w)1
M(jg, z, r) Ig(z)l.:s -'--m-i-n-If-(-w-)-I-.:s -m-in'--"-I-f-(w--)I· Iw-~I=p
Iw-~I=p
From the above estimates, if Iw -Z; I = P. then log If (w) I - log If (z;) I ::: -8 [log M (f,z;, 2er) - log If (z;)I]· Hence log If(w)1 ::: 9 log M(t, z, r/4) - 8 log M(f, l;, 2er).
3. Exponential Polynomials
210
From Proposition 3.1.19, we have log M(f, z, r/4) ::: H(z)
+ (do/) log r + C',
for some C' E IR. (C' = -logC - (do/) log 4, ro = 1, in the notation of that proposition). On the other hand, by part (i) we have
+ M logO + Is I) + A' H(z) + M log(l + Izl) + A",
logM(f, S, 2er) .:::: H(s) .::::
since Is - zl .:::: r/4 .:::: 1/4. It follows that log [ min If(W)I]::: H(z) - MJlog(l Iw-{I=p
+ Izl) + vlogr -
M, = 8M, v = 9dof. This estimate implies that part (ii) is correct.
A",
0
We remark that if f E E~, then M = MJ = 0 in the previous proposition, but dOf = N - 1 > 0 (unless f is just an exponential), hence v > 0 also. The following consequence of Proposition 3.1.21 is an explicit form of the Lojasiewicz inequality for functions in E:
3.1.22. Theorem (Global Lojasiewicz Inequality). Let f E E*, and let V = {z E C: fez) = O} =1= 0. There exists a positive constant C such that
f
I (z)l:::
C d(z, V)" H(') (l + Izl)1' e -,
where v=9dof, /-L=v+8max'~J:"'Nm). Moreover, C can be explicitly estimated in terms of the frequencies and coefficients of f. Proof. Let z ¢ V and consider g = l/f in B(z, d(z, V». Let us choose r = inf(l, d (z, V». We can therefore apply the previous proposition and obtain eH(z)
---- <
If(z)1 -
with MJ = 8 max'.::;).::;N mj, v d (z, V) and we obtain
(1
+ Izl)MI
A1 - - - - - - - -
= 9d of,
rV
and A, > O. If d(z, V) .:::: 1, then r =
1 H(-) d(z, V)V If(z)l::: Ate • (1 + Izi)MI . If d(z, V) > 1, then r = 1, but d(z, V) .:::: Izl we still obtain the required inequality.
+ const, hence letting /-L = M, + v, 0
3.1.23. Remark. If we replace d(z, V) by d(z, V) = inf(1, d(z, V», then one can take /-L = 0 in Theorem 3.1.22 when fEED, at least when V =f 0. When V = 0, fez) = ae AZ , a E C*, then d(z, V) = 00 but d(z, V) = 1, v = 0, /-L = 0, H(z) = Re(Az) and the inequality is trivially satisfied.
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
211
From previous remarks we see that we have a rather precise knowledge of all the constants C, f.1, v in the Lojasiewicz inequality. It is rather annoying that f.1 could be positive. We shall show in what follows that one can take f.1 = 0 (after replacing d(z, V) by d(z, V», but at the cost of losing track of the nature of C. This is an argument due to Grudzinski [Grudl]. Let us consider a vector a = (ai, ... , aN) E eN such that al -< a2 -< ... -< aN, m = (ml, ... , mN) E NN. Set Iml = ml + ... + mN, f.1 = Iml + N1, lIall = maxI:::;j:::;N lajl. Let E(a,m) be the vector space of all exponentialpolynomials of the fonn I(z) = Ll:::;j:::;N Pj(z)e"jZ, deg Pj ~ mj, 1 ~ j ~ N, where we allow some of the Pj to be zero. Denote Pj(z) = LO
3.1.24. Lemma. There is a constant c = c(a, m) > 0 such that lor any IE E(a, m) and any r, 0 < r ~ 1, M(f, 0, r) ~ cr/LIIIII.
Proof. We have (M(f, 0, r)l ~ -
1
1
21l'
2".
I/(re ii1 )1 2 dO =
0
L 1/(1)(0) --, - 12 r21 l. 12:0
L I(~!(O) ~ (L
~
1
12 r21
0:::;1:::;f.L
1I(I:!(O) 12)
r2f.L.
O:::;I:::;/L
On the other hand, the map I 1-+ (Lo:::;I:::;/L 1/(I)(0)/1!12)1/2 clearly defines a seminonn in E(a, m), but the previous observation about the multiplicity of zeros for functions in E(a, m), shows that it is really a nonn. Since any two nonns in E(a, m) are equivalent, there is a constant c = c(a, m) > 0 such that (
0~f.L 1I(~!(O) 12
'/2 )
~ clllll· o
This proves the lemma.
3.1.25. Corollary. For any I
E E(a, m),
0< r
~
1, we have
M(f, 0, r) ~ cr/L max laj I, 15}:::;N with the same positive constant c
Proof. From the definition of
lajl::: II!II.
01 the previous lemma. aj = aj(!) = leading term
of Pj, we have 0
3. Exponential Polynomials
212
3.1.26. Remark. If none of the aj is zero, an inequality of the fonn M(f, 0, r)
~
crl"ll/lI
is still valid for r ~ 1, with c = c(a, m) > 0, independent of I. In fact, in this case I E E(a, m)\{O} cannot be a polynomial, hence
is also a nonn in £(a, m). Moreover, the previous proof yields for r
~
1
which shows the existence of the constant c. The main point of the argument of Grudzinski, to improve the previous Lojasiewicz inequality of Theorem 3.1.22, is the following observation. Let L z (f) be the exponential polynomial defined by Lz(f)(W) := I(w
+ z),
which also lies in E(a, m). Moreover, the leading coefficients of are related by identities
I
and L:(f)
As an immediate corollary of these identities, we obtain: 3.1.27. Corollary. For any r
E
]0, 1],
I
E
E(a, m), and z
E
C, we have
M(f, z, r) ~ erl" max {laj(f)leReajZ} ~ e(f)rl"eH(z), l~j~N
=
where c c(a, m) > 0 is independent of f, and the constant e(f) depends on f, but c(f) > 0 if f =1= O. Let I E £(a, m) be a nonzero exponential polynomial such that f(O) = O. Let v be the multiplicity of the origin as zero of f. Let 0 < r S 1 be given and fix p E ]0. r] such that f has no zeros in 0 < Izl s p. The monic polynomial Qj(z) = ZV has exactly the same zeros as f in 0 S Izi s p, hence f/Qj is a holomorphic nonvanishing function in B(O, p). Therefore, we have inf1z l9 If(z)/Qj(z)1 > O. Since maxlzl=p Ig(z)1 is also a nonn in E(a. m), if IIf - gil is sufficiently small. the function g E E(a. m) does not vanish on Izi = p and has the same number of zeros v as f in B(O, p). Moreover, if Qg is the monic polynomial of degree v whose roots coincide with those of g in B(O. p). we have that Qg is continuous as a function of g, for g close to f. Namely, recall that if ZI •••• , Zv
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
are the roots of g, then for k
E
213
N* the Newton sums of the roots are given by
L zf = -1-1 2:n:i
O:'Olsv
zkg'(z) dz g(z) ,
Izl=p
and the coefficients of Qg are fixed polynomials in the Newton sums. Therefore, one can find a fixed number K > 0 such that inf Izl:'Op
IQg(z) g(z) I >
K
> 0
for any g in E(a, m), which is sufficiently close to f. Now let h be an arbitrary function holomorphic in B(O, r). We have M(gh, 0, r)
~ M(gh, 0, p) = M
( Qg . h·
~g ,0, p) ~ KM(Qg . h, 0, p).
In order to estimate this last quantity, let us prove the following simple lemma: 3.1.28. Lemma. There is a constant C v > 0 such that for any monic polynomial Q of degree v and any p > 0, there exists pi E [p /2, p] for which
IQ(z)1
if lzl
~ Cvpv
= p'.
Proof. (This lemma is also a consequence of the Cartan-Boutroux lemma [BO, §4.5.13].) Decompose the annulus p/2:s lzl :s p into v + I concentric annuli using circles such that the difference of the successive radii is exactly p/2(v + 1). One of these annuli contains no roots of Q. Let pi be the radius of the median circle of one such annuli. Let Q(z) = (z - ZI)" • (z - zv). For lzl = pi we have
Iz - zjl ~
p
4(v
+ 1)
for every j. Hence pV
IQ(z)1 ~
(4(v
+
1))"'
o
Izl = p'.
Returning to the previous inequalities we have M(gh, 0, r)
~
KM(Qg . h, 0, pi)
~
KCvpv M(h, 0, pi)
~
KCvp"lh(O)I.
Since K and p depend on f, all one can conclude is that there is a constant c(f) > 0 such that for every gin E(a, m) sufficiently close to f. one has M(gh, 0, r)
~
c(f)rVlh(O)I,
where c(1) has been chosen so that c(f)r V = KCvpv. Moreover, since r and v :s J.t, we also have M(gh, 0, r)
~
:s
1
c(l)rillh(O)I.
The unit sphere of E(a, m), IIfll = I, is compact, hence there is a constant Co = coCa, m) > 0 such that for any g. IIgll = I, we have M(gh, 0, r)
~
corlLlh(O)I.
3. Exponential Polynomials
214
f
Finally, we can conclude that for any M(fh, 0, r)
~ collfllr
l1
lh(O)1
~
E(a, m),
E
Co
C~~XN laj(f)I) r
l1
lh(O)1
for any h holomorphic in B(O, r). This inequality leads almost immediately to the following:
3.1.29. Proposition ([Grudl]). Let f minl-oj-oN laj (f)I. Then, for any z a neighborhood of B(z, r), we have Co
E(a, m), 0< r ::; I, and let K(f) = C and any holomorphic function g in
E E
M(fg, z, r) ~ K(f)r l1 e H(::)jg(z)l.
Proof. Let h = L:(g), then h(O) = g(z), and M(fg, z, r) = M(L:(f)h, 0, r)
Now, aj(L::(f»
~ Co (max la;(L:(f)I) r l1 lh(O)I. [-o'-oN
= aj(f)ecx}: #- 0 if and only if aj
is a frequency of f. But
max{Reajz: a, is a frequency of f} = H(z).
Hence,
and we obtain the stated inequality.
o
One should compare this statement with Proposition 3.1.21(ii). Here one can take JL = dOf and, moreover, there is no factor (1 + Izl)M,. The trade off is the very unpredictable behavior of the constant Co (see Remark 3.1.21). As a further corollary we obtain a global Lojasiewicz inequality without denominator.
3.1.30. Proposition ([Grudl]). Let f be a nonzero exponential polynomial with frequencies a[ -< 0i2 -< ... -< aN, V = {z E C: f (z) = OJ, and let d(z, V) = inf{l, d(z, V)}. There is a constant c = c(f) > 0 such that
If(z)1
~ c(d(z, V»dO j eH(z).
Proof. It is enough to consider fez) = L[-oi-oN Pi (z)eCX,Z ,mj = deg Pj , Pj #- O. Then JL = Iml + N - 1 = dOf, and the same proof of Theorem 3.1.22 applies, 0 replacing Proposition 3.1.21 by Proposition 3.1.28. We shall now show that the exponential polynomials are not only slowly decreasing in the sense of the previous chapter, but that one can give a very precise description of the size of the components of S(f, e, C) (see Definition 2.2.13).
3.1.31. Proposition. Let f be a nonzero exponential polynomial. For every s > 0, C > 0, one can find s[, C[ > Osuch thatfor every connected component 0 of
3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials
215
S(f, cI, C1) = {Z E C: If(z)1 < cle- Cilz1 } one has IZI - z21 < ee- Cizil for every Zl, Z2 E
O.
°
Proof. We can assume c :s 1. Fix Z E 0 and let < r :s 1, to be chosen later (depending on z). Consider l; E aB(z, r) such that If(nl = M(f, z, r). As pointed out after the proof of Lemma 4.2.11, the Minimum Modulus Theorem yields P E ]~r, 2r[ such that for every w, Iw - l;1 = p, one has If(w)1
log If(nl > -810gM
(
f ) f(l;),l;,4er .
Hence, inf Iw-,I=p
If(w)1 > If(l;W - M(f, C;, 4er)8
We know that for some C > 0, J1 > 0,
If(l;)1 = M(f, z, r):::
Crf.LeH(z),
and, for some D > 0, M(f, l;, 4er) :S M(f, z, 5er):s D(l
+ IzI)MeH(zl.
Therefore,
'w~~f=p If(w)1
Er"e H (:) ::: (l
+ Izl)N
for some E > 0, N ::: 0, v > O. Let us now choose r = r(z) = ce-Clzlj6ec. We are going to choose CI > 0, C 1 > 0 so that for any z E C one has C
_ Er(z)"eH(z) e- C11 - 1 < ---....,-;I (1 + Izl)N .
To verify that this choice is possible, let us observe that there is a > 0 such that for every z E C H(z) :::
Since r(z)
-alzl.
= ee-Clzlj6eC, we have to choose £1,
CI so that
£" E e(C,-a-"C)lzl cI<-----....,.,.- (6e C )" (l Iz I)N .
+
This shows that once we choose C 1 > a + vC, e.g., C 1 = a easily find £1 > 0 satisfying the inequality (t). Hence, inf
Iw-;I=p
+ vC + 1, we can
If(w)l::: cle-C,lzl,
which implies that
o Therefore, if
Zl, Z2 E
IZI - z21
~ B(l;, p) ~ B(z, 3r).
0 we have
:s IZI -
zl
+ Iz -
The last inequality follows from
:s ee- Cizl - C :s ce- C1zil . the fact that Iz - zll < 3r :s 3£/6 .::: z21 < 6r
~.
D
3. Exponential Polynomials
216
3.1.32. Remark. In the case where all the frequencies of I are purely imaginary, then H (z) ::: -O! I 1m z I for some O! > 0 and we can replace Iz I throughout the proof by p(z) = logO Iz12) I Imzl. In this case
+
+
SU, B" C,) = {z
C: I/(z)l <
E
B,e- C1P (:)}
and the diameter condition is IZI - z21 < Be-CP(z,) , EXERCISES
Zl, Z2 E O.
for
3.1.
1. Let f be an exponential polynomial with frequencies AI"", AN, and K = cv{):,J, ... , ):,N J, and let H = HK = the supporting function of K. Show there is a set E ~ [0, oo[ of relative zero measure (see §3.5.9) such that '0
· log If(re' I1m r
r-oo
• 'IE
)1 -_
H(
e
iO)
.
Conclude that f is of completely regular growth and that if /-i E JIf' (C) is such that ;'H/-i) = f. then /-i*: JIf(n + K) -4 .}f(n) is surjective for any open and convex subset n of C.
2. Let f be an exponential polynomial with purely imaginary frequencies. Let g be an entire function such that for some m E Z;, A, B > 0, the product fg satisfies the estimate (z E C).
(a) Show that g satisfies an estimate of the form
Ig(z)1
~ B'(l
+ IzD""e A'11m:l,
and quantify the dependency of B', m' in terms of B, A, m. and constants depending only on f. What can you say about h g? (b) Conclude that if g is an entire function such that fg E .r(e'(~» (resp . .r('D(~») then g belongs to .r(e'(~» (resp. .r('D(~»). 3. Let f be an exponential polynomial, V = V(f) = (Zk> mkh?I' p(z) = Izi. Show that V is an interpolating variety for Ap(C) if and only if there exist E > 0, C > 0, such that for every pair (k, j), k 1= j.
IZk -
Zj
I ~ ee- CI : kl •
What is the corresponding statement for p(z) = Iz IP, P > I? Could V be an interpolation variety when 0 < p < I if f has more than one frequency? 4. Let f be an exponential polynomial, V = V(f) = (z .. md.(':I' p ::c: I. Show that the following two statements are equivalent: (i) There is A > 0 such that IZk - Zj I ~ e-A
°
5. Let f be an exponential polynomial with purely imaginary frequencies, and p(z) = Ilmzl +Iog(l + Izl), V = V(n = (Zk>mdk?l. Show that V is an interpolation variety
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
217
for Ap(C) if and only if there are e > 0, A > 0, such that for every pair (k, j), k #- j. Equivalently, show this condition can be replaced by the existence of 0 > 0, B > 0, such that for every k I/(md(Zk)1 ~ oe-Bp(zd. 6. Let 1 be an exponential polynomial with purely imaginary frequencies, icxj' al < a2 < ... < a., and ml, ... , m., the degrees of the corresponding coefficients, and let J.L > max{mk!(ak - al): 2:5 k :5 n}. Show that if Imz > J.Lloglzl,
Izl» 1,
then I(z) #- 0. (Hint: Consider e- ia1z I(z).) Conclude that there is A > V
= V(j) <; {z:
I Imzl :5 A(I
°such that
+ log(l + Izl)))·
Show that V is an interpolation variety for :F(t:'(~» if and only if there exists e, B > such that IZk - zjl ~ e(IZkl + IZjJ)-B for any pair of distinct zeros of
°
I.
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial Given ep E [-n /2, 3n /2[. f-L E 1R, and 1/ E]O, +00[. we denote by V (ep, J.L, H) the half-strip:
Veep, /-L, H) := {z
E
+ /-Llog Izll ~ HI· angle q; + n /2 with the
C: Im(ze- i ",) ~ 0 and I Re(ze- i ",)
Let 8 denote the ray starting at 0 and making an positive real axis. By T(e) we denote the angular sector of width 2e and having 8 as a bisectrix. (See Figures 3.1 and 3.2.) If /-L = 0, V(cp, 0, H) is a half-strip limited by two half-lines parallel to 8 and equidistant from 8 at a distance H. In this case, it is a straight half-strip. If /-L ::/= 0, the two unbounded portions of the boundary are curves asymptotic to lines paralled to 8. We then say that V(ep, /-L, H) is a logarithmic half-strip. Let us choose argz E [0, 2n[, then lim
Izl-oo
argz
n
= ep + -, 2
ZEV("'.I1. H j
which means that, for every
e>
0, there is an r > 0 such that
Veep, /-L, H) n B(O, r)C
~
T(e).
3.2.1. Lemma. The intersection o/two half-strips V(cp) , f-L), H) is an unbounded set if and only if ep) = cpz and f-L) = f-L2·
n V (ep2, J.L2,
H2)
218
3. Exponential Polynomials
Figure 3.1
T(e)
Figure 3.2
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
219
Proof. From the previous observation, if V = V(CPI, /11, Ht} n V(cpz, /12, H2 ) is unbounded, then
lim arg z ZEV
Izl .... oo
1r
1r
= CPI + -2 = CP2 + -. 2
Moreover, /11
=
.
Re(ze-i\O\)
lIm
log Izl
ZEV
Iz I"" 00
.
=
hm ZEV
Izl .... oo
Re(ze-\02)
log Izl
o
= /12.
We shall now prove a very famous result of P6lya concerning the distribution of zeros of exponential polynomials. Following the work of Dickson [Dill we shall give simultaneously the result for a larger class of functions, those that are asymptotically exponential polynomials (AEP) (see also [RoJ). 3.2.2. Definition. We say that f f E .Tf(C\K) and has the form fez)
=
E
L
AEP if there is a compact set K such that Ajzmj(l +Cj(z»e WjZ ,
l:sj:sn
for a finite collection of distinct frequencies WI, •.. , Wn E C, 2 and the functions Cj are holomorphic in K C and satisfy
~ n, Aj E
C*,
mj EN,
lim Cj(z) = O.
Izl .... oo
Note that any exponential polynomial with more than one frequency is in AEP. It is enough to write the polynomial coefficients Pj as Pj(z)
where
mj =
deg P, Cj(z) =
= ajZmj (l
Pj(z)/ajZmj -
+ Cj(z», 1, which is holomorphic for Izi
»
1.
3.2.3. Definition. For a function f E APE represented by (*), we denote by P := P (f), the P61ya polygon of f, the convex hull of the set WI, ... , Wn , and p := {z E C: Z E PCf)}' the set of conjugates. In what follows we shall assume that WI, ••• ,Wn are indexed in such a way that the following geometric condition holds: the points WI, ... ,wa are the vertices of P and, moreover, the oriented segments LI := [WI, ci}z], ... , L a- I := [Wa-I, w,,], L" := [w", WI], are precisely the successive segments of the posititively oriented boundary ap. The remaining points are ordered arbitrarily. Note that some may still be in aP. Let us denote by hk the ray that starts at the origin and has the direction of the outer normal to aP at any point in the open segment ]Wb Wk+1 [, 1 ~ k ~ a-I, h" is the one that corresponds to [wa , wd. We make a further assumption on the choice of WI. if '!/fl, ..• , '!/fa are the arguments of the points in hI •... , h",
220
3. Exponential Polynomials
respectively, then 0 ::: 1/11 < 1/12 < ... < 1/1" < 2rr. Note that for z E hk one has Re(wkz) = Re(wk+lz) for 1 ::: k ::: a - I (with the obvious extension to the case k = a). Let 51 := {z E c: 1/1" ::: arg z ::: 1/11 + 2rr} and, for k = 2, ... , a,
5k := {z
E
C: 1/Ik-l ::: argz ::: 1/Id.
Fora fixed 0 verifying 0 < 20 < min{1/I1 let us define SI
-1/1" + 2rr, 1/Ik -1/Ik-1 (k =
+ 0 ::: arg z ::: 1/11 + 2rr E C: 1/Ik-1 + 0::: argz ::: 1/Ik - O}
:= {z E C: 1/1"
Sk := {z
2, ... , a)),
O},
(2::: k ::: a).
Note that because n :::: 2 one has 0 < 0 < rr /2. Finally, let us denote
Tk := {z E C: 1/Ik -
(J :::
argz ::: 1/Ik
(See Figure 3.3.)
Figure 3.3
+ O}
(1 ::: k ::: a).
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
221
3.2.4. Lemma. (a) If z E Sk. ~ E P, then Re«wk - ~)z) ~ o. (b) Ifz E Sk. ~ E P,then Re«wk -~)z) ~ Izllwk -~lsinO. (c) If z E Sk n Tk and Wj ¢ Lb then there is a value eo > 0 such that Re«wk - Wj )z) ~ Iz Ilwk - Wj I sin 00 . (d) If z E Sk+1 n Tk and Wj ¢ L k . then there is a value 01 > 0 such that Re«wk+1 - Wj)z) ~ Izllwk+1 - wjl sine l .
Proof. Recall that (·1·) denotes the Euclidean scalar product on ]R2 and that for any a, b E C, Reab = (alb) = (alb). We shall give the proof of the lemma for 2 :::: k :::: a - I, leaving it to the reader to adapt it to the cases k = I, k = a.
Part (a). We observe that if h-I denotes the ray perpendicular to hk-h chosen so that the angle from h-I to h k- I is n/2, and h, the ray perpendicular to hk. so that the angle from hk to h is n /2, then the sector Sk is complementary to the two quadrants determined by h-I and hk-I and by hk and [k. The point ~ E P and, therefore, ~ - Wk belongs to the closed sector determined by h-I and h. This is just the sector opposite to Sk. Hence, the angle between any z E Sk and ~ - Wk is at least n /2. In other words, Re(z(~ - Wk» = (zl~ - wd ::::
o.
This is equivalent to statement (a).
Part (b). Here the angle between z E Sk and ~ - Wk is ~ nl2 + 0, hence (zl~ - Wk) :::: -lzll~ -
wkl sinO.
Part (c). Since Wj ¢ Lko one can immediately see there is a Of > 0 such that
n, _ _ 3n 1/Jk + "2 + 0 :::: arg(wj - wd :::: 1/Jk-1 + T· On the other hand, z E Sk n Tb so that 1/Jk-1
+ e < 1/Jk -
0 :::: arg z :::: 1/Jk.
Hence, the angle between z and Wj - Wk lies between n/2 + 0' and 3nl2 - O. Letting 00 = min{O, O'}, we obtain (c).
Part (d). This time there is Oil > 0 such that ./,
'f'k+1
n + "2 :::: arg (Wj_
_
)
- Wk+1 ::::
./,
'f'k
n + "2 -
nil (7
,
and
1/Jk:::: argz:::: 1/Jk +0 < 1/Jk+1
-e.
Choosing 01 = mintO, Oil) we can proceed as before.
3.2.5. Lemma. (a) Ifz E Sk and j =1= k, then zmjeWjZ = e(z)zm'e w*,. (b) liz E Tk n Sk and Wj If Lb then zmjeWjZ = e(z)zm'eWkZ .
D
222
3. Exponential Polynomials
n Sk+l and Wj f/ Lb then zmjeWjZ = e(z)zmt+JeWk+Jz, where e(z) denotes a quantity, different in each case, such that
(c) If z E Tk
lim e(z) z~oo
= 0.
whenever z is restricted to the corresponding region. Proof. (a) By Lemma 3.2.4(b), we have
which vanishes at 00. (b) It is the same as part (a) using Lemma 3.2.4(c), and (c) Just use Lemma 3.2.4(d).
3.2.6. Lemma. For f
E
APE represented by (*) and any z fez) = Akzmk(l + e(z»e WkZ ,
where lim e(z)
z_oo
eo
instead of e. 0
E Sb
= 0.
ZESt
Proof. This is an immediate corollary of Lemma 3.2.5(a), and the definition (*) ~f.
0
3.2.7. Corollary. Under the same conditions of the previous lemma, there is r > such that
°
for all z
E
Sk
n B(O, r)c.
if
Proof. From Corollary 3.2.7 we have If(z)1 > (IA k I/2)lz mk e""zl whenever z Sk n B(O, ro)c. From Lemma 3.2.4(a), we have
E
T
> 0, such that
1e~~Zz~mk
~
le~ zz~mk
f(z)1 :::
if z E
n B(O, ro)'
and
3.2.8. Lemma. There are ro > 0, ~ E ft, then
Sk
T.
IAkl f(z)1 > -2- exp[Re«wk -
~)z)l :::
IAkl 2'
0
We remark that this lemma shows that all the zeros of f, of large absolute value, must lie within some sector Tk. The condition on T is just 0 < T < infk IAd/2. On the other hand, the definition of Sk depends on e, hence the value ro of this lemma depends on e. We proceed to study what happens in the sector Tk •
3.2.9. Lemma. Let A be the set of indices j such that Wj ELk. For have fez) = LAjzmj(1 + Bj(z»eWjZ , jElk
Z E
Tko we
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
223
with lim £j(z) =0.
zET,
z~oo
Proof. This is a corollary of Lemma 3.2.5(b) and (c), the functions £j are the same as in (*) for j =I k, k + 1, those with these two indices will change. D In order to continue our study of zeros, it is convenient to introduce, for j E i k , the following quantities: 1:j
= Wj + mjei1/l"
which both depend on the frequencies and the degrees of the corresponding coefficients. To simplify the notation we rotate the coordinates and assume 1/Ik = 11/2. Let Qk denote the convex hull of the points Wb Wk+!, and 1:j, j E ik' We choose a new indexing of the vertices of Qb while traversing 8Qk in the positive sense. Start at Wk. We denote Wk,1 = Wb 1:k,l = Wk + imk (it could coincide with Wk,1 if mk 0), and denote the successive vertices 1:k,2, ... , 1:k,(71-1, 1:k.al = Wk+l + imk+l' Denote Wk.al := Wk+l' If ak > 2, all the mj that appear in 1:k,/ for 2 .::; I .::; ak - 1, are positive. We denote Wk,/ the corresponding projection onto the horizontal segment Lk = [Wb Wk+l]. The other Wj, j E iko are indexed arbitrarily as 1:k,/ = Wk.l + imk,l, with ak < I .::; nk. For 1 .::; j .::; ak-I. the segments [1:k,/, 1:k,/+)] are denoted Lk,I and the slopes f.Lk,l. Then
=
mk,l - mk,/+1
f.lk.l
= _
Wk,l - Wk,l+1
=
mk,l -
mk,l+1
Cik.1 - Cik,/+1
= Rewk.l = Rewk,l.
with
Cik.1
... >
Cik,a,.
Note that with our conventions Due to the convexity of Qko these slopes satisfy
ak,l
> CiU >
-cx:; < f.Lk,1 < f.Lk,2 < ... < J-Lk,a-l < 00.
Let z = x +iy, for H > 0 we define Uk•1 := {z E C: y 2: 0 and x + J-Lk.llog Izl > H}, Uk.l
:= {z E C: Y 2: 0, x + J-Lk,l-llog Izl < -H and x + f.Lk,llog Izl > H},
for I = 2, ... , ak
-
1, and
Uk.a, :=
{z E C: y 2: 0, x + J-Lk.a, log Izl < -H}.
Let us also introduce V k./
:=
V(O, f.Lk,/,
H) = {x E C: y 2: 0, Ix +J-Lk,I!oglzll.::; H}.
Figure 3.4 depicts these regions for 1 .::; I .::; ak - 1. The Uk,1 together with the V k .1 cover Tk (see Exercise 3.2.1). For R » 1, the different sets Vk,1 n B(O, Rr, Uk,! n B(O, r)', are connected and disjoint. Remark further that the "median" of Vk,1 is the curve x + J-Lk,/!og Izl = 0, which is asymptotic to the curve x + J-Lk./!Og Y = 0. We keep from now until Remark 3.2.22 the assumption that 1/Ik = 11/2 and the preceding notation.
3. Exponential Polynomials
224
Vk.3
Vk2
"tk.o,_1
"tk•O,
Figure 3.4
3.2.10. Lemma. There is v > 0 such that for every
-v,
mk,p - mk,l+l - I1k,/(ak,p - ak,/+l) < -v.
Proof. Because of our choice of coordinates it is natural to consider variables a, m, so that the a-axis is the real axis. In these variables, the line Lk.l can be represented by either of the two equations
In these coordinates, the point
O.
Since there are only finitely many possible
o
3.2.11. Lemma. Let Z
E Uk,j' then:
(a) If j = l,assume
with
lim e(z) = O.
z.... oo
zeUk,j
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
(b) If I .::: j .:::
Uk -
1 and
Lk.p E L k. j ,
225
or if2 .::: j .:::
Uk
and
Lk,p E Lk,j-h
then
Proof. (a) If j = 1, ... , Uk - 1, there is a iJ- < iJ-k,j (fl- depends on z) such that x + JL log Izi = O. If j = 2, ... ,Uk< there is a iJ- > iJ-k,j-I with the same property. (Just use the definition of Uk . j .) Since Im(wk.p - Wk,j) = 0 and Re(wk,p - Wk,j) = ak,p - ak,j' Iz m , p-m, j e(Wk,p-W, j)Z
I = Izl m! p-mC}-I1-(ak,p-a, j) log Izl
= Izlm,p-mkj-l1-(akP-a,j). Consider the case when ak,p - ak,j < O. Then definitely j Lk. i, and iJ- < iJ-k,j' The previous lemma implies that mk,p - mk.j -
fl-(ak,p -
ak,j)
<
mk,p - mk,j -
i- Uk, hence
iJ-k.) (ak,p - ak,j)
mk,j -
fl-(ak.p - ak,j)
<
mk,p -
mk,j -
iJ-k,j-l(ak,p - ak,j)
¢
< -v
for some v > O. In case ak,p - ak,j > 0, we have j > 1 and use the hypothesis that Lk,j-l when j = 2, . , , ,(Tk. We obtain mk.p -
Lk,p
Lk,p
¢
< -v.
Finally, if ak,p - ak,j = 0, we must have that mk,p < mk,j' Choosing v smaller if necessary, we have in any case, 1£(z)1 < Izl-v. (b) If j = 1, ... ,Uk - 1 and rk,p E Lk,j, then mk,p - mk,j = iJ-k,j (ak,p - ak,j)' On the other hand, we have x + iJ-10g Izi = 0 (with the same choice of iJas in (a» and x + iJ-k,j log Izl :::: H. Hence (iJ-k.j - fl-) log Izi :::: H and, since iJ-k,j - iJ- > 0, Iz I :::: exp(H /(iJ-k,j - iJ-», Because rk,p E Lk,j, we have ak,p .::: ak,j and therefore,
= Iz 111-' j (a, p-ct, j )-I1-(ct k p-ctk j) .::: eH(ct,p-akj)
=
e-HiaLP-akjl
so that
o
The other case is verified in exactly the same way.
3.2.12. Lemma. There exists r > 0 such that if z (a) Izm ,
(b)
jeW! jZ
I ::::
Izmk" ew"lz I;
E
Uk,j
n B(O, rY
then:
and
Izmkjew'.jZI :::: Izmk'"kewk,u,zl.
Proof. (a) If j = 1, the result is obvious. If j = 2, Lk, I E Lk,l, and we can apply (b) of the previous lemma with p = 1, j = 2. Hence
3. Exponential Polynomials
226
If 3 S j S ab then Lk,I ¢ Lk.j-I, and by Lemma 3.2.1l(a), we have zm, I e"'l.I z = £(z)zm"le""jZ, hence the inequality (a) holds if Izl» 1. The proof of (b) is similar, with Lk,rI, replacing Lk,l. 0
3.2.13. Lemma. If z
E
Uk,j n Tko then
f(z) = LAk,pzm,p(l +£k,p(z»e""p Z , where the sum is taken over the indices p such that: (i) Lk,p E Lk,I when j = 1; (ii) Lk,p E Lk,j n Lk,)-I when 2 S j S ak - 1; (iii) Lk,p E Lk,rI,-1 when j = ak; and, as always, lim £k,p(Z) = 0, Izl-H)O
ZEU, jnT,
Proof. It is an immediate consequence of Lemmas 3.2.9 and 3.2,Il(a).
0
3.2.14. Lemma. There are constants ro > 0, Ho > 0, such that if r ::: ro, and H ::: Ho, then for any z E Uk,j n Tk n B(O, r)f one has If(z)l> !IAk,jllzm,jeW,jZI.
Proof. We use the asymptotic development of f given in the previous lemma, and then use Lemma 3.2.11(b). We obtain If(z) I ::: IAk,jZm'j eW'j (1 = IAk,jZm, jeW, j x
+ £k,j (z»1 -
L IAk,pZm"p (l p,;,j
+ £k,p (z»e W, I pZ
I
(11 +£k,;(z)l- L
II~k'Pllll +£k,p(z)lzm"p-m'le(W,p-W,j)zJ) k,J
::: IAk,jZm'le"",jl {II +£k,j(z)l-
L II~k'Pllll +£k,p(Z)le-HIWl.p-Wkll} , ph
k,J
It is clear that by choosing r and H sufficiently big, the required estimate holds.
o
From now on we will assume r ::: ro ::: 1 and H ::: Ho, so that the conclusion of Lemma 3.2.14 holds. Note that the regions Tko and correspondingly the value ro, depend on the opening 9. On the other hand, we can take Ho independent of e. Namely, it is enough to choose it so that
"lax ,J
(E
IAk,pl e-HOlw"P-W"jl) S p,;,j IAk.j I
~,
3:2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
227
since we can take ro so that for Izl :::: ro, z E Tko we have
ISk,)(z)1 :::: ~ forallk,j.
3.2.15. Lemma. Let 0 < P, then
i"
< infk ,) IAk,) 1/2. If z E Uk,) n Tk, Iz I :::: ro, and ~ E le-~z f(z)1 > .,
Proof. If z E Uk,) Lemma 3,2.12(a) le-~z f(z)1
n Tk n Sk we have from the previous lemma and from :::: !IAk,jzmk,je"'k jZe-~ZI :::: !IAk,)zmk.le"'k,'Ze-~zl IAk,) II Imk 'I > . > -z -
2
= IA;,)IIZlmk.leRe«wk-~)Z)
'
where the previous to last inequality uses Lemma 3.2.4(a). If z E Uk,) n Tk n SHI, the reasoning is the same, with mk,! replaced by mk'''k'
o
3.2.16. Proposition. For r » 1,0 < i" < infk ,) IAk,)1/2, by switching the conditions ~ E P and z E (Uk,) Vk,jY n B(O, r)C, then le-~z
f(z)1 > .,
Hence, If(z)1 > uH(z), where H (z) is the supporting function of P. Proof. We fix some () > 0, as we have done above and let Tk = Tk «(}), Then, by Lemma 3.2.8, the inequality le-~z f(z)1 > i" holds if z E Sk, r :::: ro » 1. This value ro depends on the choice of (), but if we make it sufficiently large the conclusion of the previous Lemma 3.2.16 also holds for z E Uk,) n Tk for some k, j. On the other hand, if Z E Vk,j and Izl > rio then z E Tk; if z E Uk,) Vk,) either z does not belong to any Tko i.e., it belongs to some Si, or it belongs for Izl :::: r[, to some Uk,) n Tk. In both cases the inequality le-{Z f(z)1 whenever z rf. Uk,) Vk ,). Recalling that
>.
ma~Re(~z) ~EP
= max Re(wz) = max(wlz) = H(z), WEP WEP
concludes the proof of Proposition 3.2.16.
o
A consequence of the proposition is that all the zeros of f with large absolute value lie in Uk,j Vk,j' Note that because the Vk,j do not depend on e, the rl can be considered independent of e. The reader should verify that for those
228
3. Exponential Polynomials
segments Lb which contain no Wj in their interior, everything we did above works, it is even simpler. We also suggest comparing Proposition 3.2.16 with Corollary 3.1.27, we get more precision on the constants, and not only about local maxima of f, albeit only for r ~ rl. We shall presently study the behavior of f in one of the half-strips Vk.j.
3.2.17. Lemma. Let z (a)
If 'k,p f/
L~.j,
E
Vk,j' Then
then
for some function 8(Z) --. 0 as z --. rt Lk,j, then we also have
00
(z
E
Vk,j)'
(b) If'k,p
same condition on £ as that in the previous item, (c) If,,,p E Lk,j' then
Proof. Since z E Vk,j we have x + /lk,j log Izl = K, for some K such that IK I :s H. By Lemma 3,2.10, if 'k,p f/ Lk,j, we have Izm, p-m'.j e(w, p-OJ, J): I = Iz 1m, p-m, j eX (a, p-a, J)
= Izlm, p-m, j-J.l., j(a, p-ex, j)e(a, p-OI., j)K
This proves part (a). Part (b) is entirely analogous. If 'k,p E Lk,j then mk,p - mk,j = /lk,j(CXk,p - CXk,j), so that the previous computation shows that
o 3.2.18. Lemma. For r
»
1, one has:
(a) Izm"ew"zl:s Izm'iew'Jzl,ijl:sj :sak-l;and (b) Izm'u'ew,u"1 :s Izm, ieWkjZI, ij2:s j :s (J'k,
for every z E Vk,j n B(O, r)C, Proof. (a) If j = 1, the estimate is clear. If2:s j :s ak - 1, then we can use Lemma 3.2.17(a). (b) Similar proof, using Lemma 3.2,17(b).
3.2.19. Corollary. If z
E
fez) =
Vk.j
n Tb then
L fk,pELIt. j
A k • p(1
+ sk,p(z»zmk·peWk pZ,
'k,1
rt L k ,; and 0
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
3.2.20. Lemma. For r
229
» 1, if t; E P and z E Vk,j n B(O, rY, then Izmk,je(wkJ-nzl:::: 1.
Proof If z
E Vk,j
Similarly, if
Z E
n Sk use Lemmas 3.2.18 and 3.2.4 to conclude that Izm!,j errol j-I;)z I :::: Izl m !" :::: 1. Vk,j
n Sk+I, the same argument holds with
mk,l
by mk,lJk'
0
3.2.21. Lemma. Let z f(z)
replaced
E Vk,j
= zmk"eWk.j
n Tb
L
then
Ak,p(l +£k,p(z»e(WkP-Wkj)(Z+/LkjLogz),
fJ..,pELk,j
where hp -+ 0 as z -+ 00 within Yj,k value of the logarithm.
n Tb
and
Log z represents the principal
Proof When
Lk,p E Lk,j, we have mk,p - mk,j = JLk,j(Wk,p - Wk,j)' We then 0 apply Corollary 3.2.19, and we are done.
3.2.22. Remark. If we do not make the assumption that 1{!k = 71: /2, and hence that Im(wk,p - Wk,j) = 0, then we can introduce CPk = 1{!k - 71:/2 in the expansion of f as follows:
2::
f(z)=zm'jeWk,jZ
A k,p(I+£k,p(z»
f1c,p EL k,j
x exp[ei'l" (Wk,p - Wk,j)(ze-i'l"
+ JLk,j logz)].
In this case, ei'l'k(wk.p - Wk,j) E JR, and f becomes, up to a multiplicative factor, a sum of exponentials in the variable ze-i'l'k + /-Lk.j log z, with coefficients almost constant. It also follows that the Vk,j coincide with V(cpt, JLk,j, H). In fact, the main relation to remember is that 1{!k = Arg(wk+l - wd - 71: /2, so that one has CPk = Arg(wk+1 - Wk) - 71:, hence CPk = - Arg(wk,p - Wk.j) (modulo 71:).
=
= +
3.2.23. Proposition. Let g(z) 2:1::;j::;n AjeWjZ , z x iy, Aj "# 0, Wj E JR, WI < W2 < ... < Wn • For H > 0, h > 0, and YI E R consider the rectangles R := {z E C: Ixl :::: H, Iy - YII :::: hI. There is a constant Ho :::: 0, independent of YI and h, such that every zero of g lies in the strip Ixl :::: Ho. Moreover. if H :::: Ho. the number N (R) of zeros of g in the rectangle R satisfies
/N(R) -
~(wn - WI)/ :::: n -
1.
G(z) = (l/AI)e-W1Zg(z) = 1 + 2:2::;j::;n Bje yjz • Bj = AdAI. and Yj = Wj - WI. 0 < Y2 < ... < Yn' Both functions G and g have the same zeros. For Re z = x > 0 we have
Proof Let
3. Exponential Polynomials
230
with lim.l->oo !31 (z) = O. Hence, if x » 1 we have II + !31 (z) I ::: ~, and G cannot have any zeros. Similarly, G(z) = (1 + !32(Z», where !32(Z) -')0 0 as x -')0 -00. Hence, there is Ho > 0 such that if IRe zl > Ho, G(z) #- O. Clearly, if H ::: Ho the number NCR) is independent of H. Let us fix £ > O. Choose H ::: Ho such that ne and I Arg(l + !3j(z))l < 4 on the lines x = ±H, j = 1,2. For a given h > 0, YI E R let us choose 8> 0, 0 < 8 < min{h, ne/2Yn}, with property that G has no zeros on the boundaries of the rectangles RI := [- H, H] X [YI - h - 8, YI + h + 8] and R2 := [-H, H] x [YI - h + 8, YI + h - 8]. This is possible because the zeros of G are isolated. Let us investigate now the variation of the argument of G along aRI. In the vertical portion x = - H, it is at most n e /2. On x = H, it is at most ne/2 + (2h + 28)Yn. On the horizontal sides, the function Re G(z) has the form Re G(z) = 1+
L
EjeYjX,
2sjSn
On the other hand, by Rolle's theorem, a function of the form K (x) = LI:::J:om Fje aJ '\, Fj E R*, al < a2 < ... < am, can have at most m - 1 real zeros (counting multiplicities). We show this by induction on the number of frequencies. It is clear for m = 1. If it is true for m - 1 frequencies, then we consider e- atX K(x) = L(x), L has the same number of zeros as K does. Its derivative L' is an exponential sum of the above type with m - 1 terms, hence L' has at most m - 2 zeros. Since between any two zeros of L there must be one of L', the claim is correct. Return to the function Re G(z) on a horizontal segment of aRlo We have that either Re G(z) == 0 on that segment or it has at most n - 1 zeros. In the first case, the variation of arg G along the segment is zero since G does not vanish on this segment. In the second case, the variation of arg G does not exceed ~ (n - 1)2n. Therefore, the total variation of arg G along aR I does not exceed ne
+ 2hYn + 28Yn + (n
-
1)2n.
Hence, by the argument principle N(R) ~ N(R I ) ~ n - 1 +
-hYn + e. n
By a similar reasoning hYn N(R)::: N(R2) ::: - n
n
+1-
e.
o
Since e > 0 was arbitrary, we obtain the proposition. The reader can easily verify that the example g(z) mate in Proposition 3.2.23 is optimal.
= 1+e
Z
shows the esti-
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
231
We continue toward our goal of understanding the localization of the zeros of f E AEP. We are now trying to prove a sort of Lojasiewicz's inequality (see Proposition 3.1.30). We are still keeping the previous notation, i.e., 1/Ik = If /2. Let us prove a few technical observations about the regions Vk • j , 1 S j S ako which were stated at the beginning of this section. (I) If z = x + iy E Vk,j, then liml:l-+oo Iy/xl = 00. In fact, if J1.k.j = 0 the result is immediate. If J1.k,j :f= 0, let J1. = J1.k,j and let K (z) = x + 4J1.log(x 2 + yZ) E [-H. HI. Therefore, when Izl -+ 00 we also have Ix I -+ 00 and the sign of x must be the opposite to that of J1.. We can solve for y / x and obtain
(~r = x- 2 exp [2KJ1.(Z)
-
~]
The term 2K(z)/J1. is bounded, while -2x/J1. -+ Iy/xl -+ 00 as Izl -+ 00, Z E Vk,j' (2) If Z E Vk,j, then liml:l-+oo Arg Z = If /2. Namely, for large Izl we have 0 < Argz < be that Argz -+ If/2 when Izl-+ 00. (3) The curves x
+ J1.k.j log Izl = ±H
If
-1.
+00 as Izl -+ 00, hence
and, since Iy/xl -+
00,
it must
are a symptotic to the curves x
+
J1.k.j logy = ±H.
Let us show this for x + J1.log Izl = H, J1. = J1.k.j :f= 0, the case J1. = 0 being trivial. Let + (J1./2) log(x; + y2) = H and X2 + (J1./2) log y = H, then we have
Xl
1J1.1 ( 1+ IXI-x21=Tlog since XI/Y -+ 0 as Izi -+
00,
(Xly )2)
-+0
by the previous item (2).
(4) For 2 E Vk.j denote W = z + J1. Logz, J1. = J1.k.j, Logz the principal branch of the logarithm. For 8 > 0, there is rl ::: I such that if IZI - 221 ::: 8, and also zj, z2 E Vk. j n B(O, rr)c, then IWI - w21 ::: 8/2. Let Yj = Imzj. Vj = 1m Wj. If IYI - Y21 ::: 8, then we can use that by (2) VI - V2
= YI
- Y2
+ J1.(ArgzI
- Arg z2) -+ YI - Y2,
as Izl -+ 00, to conclude that IWI - w21 ::: IVI - v21 ::: 8/2 if rl If IYI - Y21 < 8, let q = YI - Y2. We have
:!. = Z2
YI Y2
(Xl + YI
i)
(X2 Y2
+
i) -I = (I + !L) (Xl + i) Y2
YI
In this case, we have XI/YI -+ 0, X2/Y2 -+ 0 and Y2 -+ ZI/22 -+ 1. Therefore, WI -
W2
= 2\
- 22
+ J1.(LogzI
- Logz2) = ZI - Z2
»
(X2 Y2
1.
+ i)-I
00 as rr -+ 00, hence
+ J1. Log (;~)
232
3. Exponential Polynomials
and Log(zl/z2) --+ 0 as r1 --+ IWI - w21 ;::: 8/2 if rl » 1.
00.
Hence, in this case, we can also conclude that
E AEP, Z = Z(n = (z E IC: Izl > R, fez) = O}, and H the supporting function of the P6lya polygon P of f. For any 8 > 0 there exist T > 0, r > 0, such that for Izl > r if d(z, Z) ;::: 8, then
3.2.24. Proposition. Let f
If(z)1 ;:::
reH(z).
Proof. From Proposition 3.2.16 we know the existence of Ho > 0 and TO > 0 such that if we fix H ;::: Ho there is ro > 0, so that Iz I > ro, z if Uk,j VA,j, implies that If(z)1 ;::: ToeH(z). Therefore, it is enough to consider z E Vk,j' Izl --+ 00. Following Remark 3,2.22, we can expand f as follows: fez)
L
= zm, jeW' jZ
Ak,p(1
+ Bk.p(Z»
T/.. pEL/.. j
x exp[ei'l" (Wk,p - Wk,j)(ze-i'l"
+ f.1k.j log z)],
and recall that the "frequencies" ei'l" (Wk,p - Wk.j) are real. Since, by Lemma 3,2.20 we know that for I'; E P, z E Vk,j, and Izl has Iz m , j e(Wk j-~)Z I ;::: I, we can just consider
»
1, one
Then we can change variables and study the sum gl(W)
=
L
Ak,p(l
+ 11k,p(w»exp({J/..,pw),
fl.,pELk,)
where W = ze-i'l'k + f.1k.j log Z, {Jk,p = ei'l" (Wk,p - Wk,j), and 11k,p (w) = £k,p (z), Clearly, 11k,p(W) --+ 0 as Iwl--+ 00, and if d(z, Z(f» ;::: 8, we have dew, Z(gl» ;::: 8/2 as long as Izl » 1. Here Z(n = (z: Izl > R, fez) = OJ, Z(gd = (w: gl (W) = OJ, the variables z, W being restricted to z E Vk,j' Izl > R, and W to the corresponding region. Note that as a consequence, I Re wi ~ Hand 1m W --+ 00, as z --+ 00, We are thus led to introduce the following exponential sum, with real frequencies:
where the summation takes place over the same set of indices as above. From what we have just said, if z --+ 00 in Vk,j, then gl (w) - go(w) --+ 0, Using Remark 3,1.23, we conclude that if Z(go) = (w E C: go(w) 0< 80 ~ 1, then dew, Z(go» ;::: 80 and I Rewl ~ H implies Ig(w) I
;::: c80
= OJ,
and
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
233
for some c > 0, v :::: I. Therefore. there is r :::: 1 such that Iwl :::: r, I Re wi ::: H, and dew, Z(go» :::: 80 • then C
Ig) (w)1 ::::
280'
In fact, it is enough to choose r so that IgI(w) - go(w)1 ::: (c/2)8 0 for Iwl :::: r. As a consequence, we see that if WI E Z(gl), IRe wII ::: H, IWII :::: r, we must have d(w), Z(go» ::: 80 . Hence, if Iwl:::: r, I Rewl :::: r, and dew, Z(gl» :::: 8/2 we will have dew, Z(go» :::: 8/2 - 80 , Take 80 = 8/4, then 8/2 - 80 = 80, so that dew, Z(go» :::: 80, and thus 1!t(z)1 = IgI(w)1 ::::
~ (~r.
for z E Vk • j • Izl» 1, and d(z, Zen) :::: 8 (since this would imply that dew, Z(gl» :::: 8/2). It follows that:
If(z)e-~;;I
=
Izm'je(wkj-~)zfl(z)l:::: ~ (~r
for z E Vk,j. Izi » 1, d(z, Z(f» :::: 8, and ~ E Proposition 3.2.24.
P.
This concludes the proof of 0
Let us define. with the preceding notations for a function
f
E
AEP, ex > 0.
s > 0, H > 0, R.,j (ex, S, H) :=(z E C : Im(ze-i
+ I-ik,j arg z E
+ I-ik.j log Izil
[ex, ex + s],
::: H},
with argz E [qib qik + Jl'], and let N(Rk,j(ex, s, H» be the number of zeros of f in Rk,j(ex, s, H). We are now ready to prove the P6lya-Dickson theorem on the distribution of zeros of functions that are asymptotically exponential polynomials.
3.2.25. Theorem. Let fez) = L:I:::j:::n Ajzmj (l + ej(z»eWjZ , Aj E C*, mj EN, Wj E C, and ej are holomorphic functions in the set Izl > R, such that lim z_ co ej(z) = 0, There are constants H > 0, r :::: R such that: (a) all the zeros of f in B(O, r)' lie in Uk.j Vk,j; and (b) for every e > 0 there is ex (e) > 0 such that ifex :::: ex(e). s > 0,
IN(Rk,j(ex. s. H» - 2:
IWk,j+1 -
Wk,jll ::: nk,j - 1 + e,
where nk,j is the number of frequencies lying in the segment Lk,j [Wk,j, Wk,j+!l.
=
Proof. The statement (a) is a consequence of Proposition 3.2.16. The proof of (b) is a refinement of the proof of Proposition 3.2,24. Using the notation introduced
3. Exponential Polynomials
234
there, let f3k.p = e irp , (Wk,p - Wk,j) gk,j (w)
E
JR, and
2:
=
Ak,pe P, pW.
lk,pELk,j
°
Assume H > so that the conclusion of Proposition 3.2.23 holds for every gk,j' Note that the quantity If3k,HI - f3k,j I = IWk,HI - Wk,j I is the distance between the furthermost frequencies of gk,j' Choosing rI » I we can guarantee that for different choices of (k, j) the sets V (cpt, J-Lk,j, H + 1) n B(O, r])C are disjoint. (Recall Vk,j = V (cpt, J-Lk,j, H).) Note that rI can also be chosen so that for z E V(cpt, J-Lk,j, H + I) n B(O, rI)C we can take arg Z E [CPk, CPk + rr] and that for a convenient choice of ao Im(ze- iCP ,)
+ J-Lk,j argz :::: ao >
0.
Therefore, for a :::: ao, the regions Rk,j(a, s, H) and Rk,j(a, s, H + 1) cover Vk,j n B(O, rIY and V (cpt, J-Lk,j, H + 1) n B(O, r])C, respectively. Once we fix 8 E ]0, rr/2[ we can also choose aI » 1 so that for a :::: aI, S > 0, Rk,j(a, s, H
+ 1) £
Q := V(cpt, J-Lk,j, H
+
1)
n Tk (8) n B(O, rd c .
From Remark 3.2.22 we have fez)
2:
= zm, jeW,,) 'Ct
Ak,p(1
+ ek,p(Z» exp[f3k,p(ze- irp, + J-Lk.j logz)]
pEL" j
=
in the region Q (arg z E [cpt. CPk + rr]). The transformation Fk,j: z 1--+ W + iv := ze- irp, + J-Lk,j logz maps Q conformally into the half-strip lui:::::: H + 1, v :::: ao. The regions Rk,j(a, s, H + 1) are mapped conform ally onto the rectangles U
R(a,s, H
+ 8) = [-H -8, H +8]
+i[a,a +s],
for a :::: ab 8 > 0, 0:::::: 8 :::::: 1. Let fk,j(Z):= f(z)z-m'je-w'jZ and hk,j be defined by hk,joFk.j = fk,j' Hence hk,j(w) = gk,/W) + l1k,j(W), with l1k,j(W) -+ as lui:::::: H + 1 and v -+ 00. We clearly have for a :::: ab s > 0, 8 :::::: 1, that
°: :
Nj(Rk,j(a, s, H
+ 8»
°
= Nj,/Rk,j(a, s, H + 8» = N h, j(R(a, s, H + 8»,
where the index of N indicates the function whose zeros we are counting. Moreover, these values are independent of 8, since all the zeros of f lie in Vk,j' It follows from Proposition 3,2.23, applied to the gk,j, that there is a constant M > 0 such that for any a E JR, < 8 :::::: 1,
°
Ngkj(R(a,
8, H
+ 8)) :::::: M.
Hence, for any a, there is a horizontal line segment A, in R(a, s, H that dew, Z(gk,j» :::: 2(M
+ 1)
+ 8)
such
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
235
for any point W EA. (The line segment A depends clearly on 8, ar, and (k, j).) It is enough to divide the rectangle in parallel horizontal strips of equal width 1/(M + 1), and take as A the bisectrix of a strip void of zeros of gk.j' Fix (k, j), s > 0, and ar ~ arl + 1, let Rex,s be the rectangle whose vertical sides lie in u = ±(H + 8) and whose horizontal sides are given
by the line segments Al and A2 corresponding to 'R(ar - 8,8, H + 8) and + s, 8, H + 8), respectively. We have that ROI,s 2 'R(ar, s, H) and that, for every point W E a ROI,s one has
'R(a
8
dew, Z(gk.j» ~ 2(M From 3.1.3 we conclude that there is r
+ 1)
= r(8)
Igk.j(w)1 ~ r
> 0 such that
on aROI,s.
If v ~ vo» 1, we have IYJk,j(w)1 :5 r/2, hence, for ar ~ ar2 ~ arl
+ 1, we have
Ng,/ROI,s) = Nh, ,(ROI,s)'
We remark that the choice of ar2 depends on 8, and eventually on E. The height of ROI .s lies between sand s + 28, and now from Proposition 3.2.23 we infer that
lN g,
J
SI<
(R OI.S ) - -IWk 21T· j+1 - Wk" .j
81 wk '+1 - Wk .j·1 . - nk .j. - 1 + . j 1T
Given B > 0, we can chose 0 < 8 :5 1 so that the left hand side does not exceed nk.j - I + E. for any (k, j). Hence Nj ('Rk,j (a, s,
H» = N h( /'R(ar, s, H»
:5 N g, j (ROI,s)'
Repeating this construction with 'R(a, 8, H + 8) and 'R(ar + s - 8, 8, H + 8) we obtain a rectangle R~,s ~ 'R(ar, s, H), such that all the previous reasoning applies, so that N g" (R~.s) = Nh, j (R~.s) and the height of R~,s lies between s - 28, s. Therefore
and
,
s
N g, j (ROI,s) ~ 21T IWk,j+1 - Wk,j 1 - nk,j
+ 1-
E.
This concludes the proof of the P6lya-Dickson Theorem.
o
3.2.26. Remarks. (1) We have already used in the proof of Theorem 3.2.25 the factthat for any HI > H, and as soon as ar » I, the number Nj('Rk,j(ar, s, H» = NrC'Rk.j(ar,s, HI»' (2) Taking E = 1 in the statement of Theorem 3.2.25, one gets the bound INjC'Rk,j(ar, s, H» -
for every s > 0, once a
»
1.
2:
IWk,j+1 - Wk,j1i :5 nk,j
236
3. Exponential Polynomials
=!.
Taking £ for those s such that (s/2rr)lwk.j+l -wk,jl sharper bound nk.) - 1 for the above quantity. In any case. we get
E
N* one gets the
We shall give below some consequences of the P6lya-Dickson theorem. 3.2.27. Lemma. Let fez) = Ll::<:}::<:n A}z} (1 + £j(z»e Wj : be an AEP. Assume f has infinitely many zeros going to 00 in a half-strip of the form V ('P. J,L, K), Then there exists (k. j) such that 'Pk = 'P. J,Lk.j = JL
Proof. One starts by remarking that V('P. J,L, K) n (Uk.) Vk,}) is unbounded since it contains a sequence converging to 00. Hence, for some (k, j), the region V ('P. J,L, K) n Vk.} is unbounded. We have shown in Lemma 3.2.1 that this implies that 'P = 'Pb J.L = J.Lk.j' 0 Let f, g be two exponential polynomials, fez)
=
L
Ai(z)ea,Z,
l~i:5m
g(z) =
L
B}(z)e fl,=.
l:5J~n
Let L be a side of the P6lya polygon peg) of g, and denote by l(L) its length. Let us denote by 1/fL the direction of the exterior normal of peg) on this side L. Set 'PL = 1/fL + rr /2. Let 0 < 8 < rr /2 be fixed and denote h(8) := {z E C
I argz -1/fLi
< 8}.
3.2.28. Proposition. If there is ro > 0 such that the function fig is holomorphic in h(8) n (B(O, ro»', then there is a side L * of the Polya polygon P(f) of f such that L * is parallel to Land l(L) ::: l(L *).
Proof. Let i3h, 1 ::: h :::: a', be the vertices of peg), L = Lh = [i3h, i3h+d, and 1/fL = 1/fh' Let Qh(g) be the corresponding polygonal region. constructed as in Lemma 3.2.9, resting on the side L, !'~,p' I ::: p ::: a~, the vertices of Qh(g) lying outside L h• we also denote by L h.p = [!'~,p' !'';,p+l]' Vh,p = V('P~, J.Lh,p' H), the corresponding half-strips, and Th(8) = {z E C: largz -1/fhl < 8} = h(8), We are going to show that if fig is holomorphic in Th(8) n (B(O, r)Y, then there is a side L * = Lk of P (f) such that Lk is parallel to Lh and the corresponding vertices ak, ak+l satisfy 1i3h+l - i3hl :::: lak+l - akl· We assume that H » I and r » I so that we can use the conclusion of Theorem 3.2.26, if necessary (for both f and g). For r» 1 we can also assume that V('P~, J.Lh,p' H) ~ Th(B) n (B(O, r)r. Since fig is holomorphic in this region, then all the zeros of gin V('P;', J.Lh,p' H) are also zeros of f. Therefore, f has infinitely many zeros, in V('P~, J.Lh,pH).
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
237
=
It follows from the previous lemma that there are CPt, /-Lk,) such that cp;' CPk and /-L~,p = /-Lk,). Therefore, there is a side Lk of P(f) directed by CPk, hence parallel to L~. By the same reason, for every p, I :::: p :::: uj, - I, there is j E {I, ... , Uk - I} such that /-L~.P = ILk,). For a » I, s > 0, let
'R~.p(a, s, H)
= (z E
V~,p: Im(ze-i
+ /-L~.P argz
E
[a, a
It coincides with the region 'R k .) (a, s, H), previously defined for every zero of g is a zero of t (counting multiplicities) then
+ sn.
t, and since
Ng('R~.p(a, s, H» :::: NfCRk.) (a, s, H».
By Theorem 3.2.26 we have s
I
-
-
Nil ('Rh,p(a, s, H» = 27T l.Bh,p+J - .Bh,pl Nf('Rk,j(a, s, H»
Since we can let s
~
=
2:
lak,j+J - ak,)1
+ 0(1), + 0(1).
+00, we conclude l.Bh,p+J - .Bh,pl :::: lak,j+J - ak,jl·
Recall that the .Bh,p lie in the segment L'" and are ordered in such a way that
L
e(L~) =
l.Bh,p+J - fJh,pl·
l~p~l1~-l
So that
e(L~)::::
L
lak,)+J - ak,) I::::
L
lak,j+l - ak,)1 = e(Ld,
o
which is what we wanted to prove.
We are now going to give a rather general division theorem in the class of exponential polynomials due to Hajj Diab [Hajj], The first such result was proved by Ritt [Ril], [Ri2], it states the following: Let t, g E Eo be such that fig = h E )fCC), then h E Eo. There have been several successive ameliorations due to [Shi], [BD2], [HRS], among others. We start by describing a division algorithm, a variation of the Euclidean division algorithm for polynomials.
3.2.29. Definition. If fez) = Ll
min (Re(aj)},
l~l~m
i.e., the length of the projection of P(f) onto JR., 8'R,(f) ::: O. By p'R,[aj, ai+d we denote the length of the projection onto JR. of the segment [ai, ai+l]'
238
3. Exponential Polynomials
3.2.30. Lemma. Let f, g be two exponential polynomials, g #- O. There is an exponential polynomial X #- 0, with purely imaginary frequencies, and two other exponential polynomials q and r such that
xf =
qg
+r,
with either r = 0 or 8JR(r) < 8JR(g).
Proof. Let u I, ... , u" be real numbers such that u I < ... < up (if p ~ 2) and let {UI,"" up} = {Re(ai): I :::: i :::: mI. Let us define Ij := {i: Re(ai) = Uj} and
=
LAk(z)exp[i(lmadz]. I.EI]
Then f(z)
= L I::;i::;p
Note that the frequencies of the
Eh(z)eY'Z,O:::: YI < ... < Ys, 8 k E (5\{O}) U {OJ.
1::;I.::;s
Let us write g(z) = LI::;j::;n Wj(z)eWiZ, WI < ... < Wn , Wj E 6\{0}. Assume first that UI = W, = O. Then f, g E F, 8iR(f) = up, and 8JR(g) = W n • If up < W n , then we can choose X = 1, q = 0, f = r, and we are done. If up ~ Wn and n = 1, we can take X = w" q = f, r = 0, and we are also done. Hence, we assume up ~ WIl , n ~ 2. Let up, ... , Up-k be all the Uj ::: Wn . Consider
+ ... +
ro(z)
= Wn(z)f(z)
- (p(z)e UpZ
qo(z)
=
+ ... +
(p(z)e UpZ
Then we have wnf
= qog + ro,
=
F, ro E F, and either ro = 0, or 8JR(ro) :::: up - (w n - Wn-I). If ro 0 or if 8JR (ro) < W Il , we are done. If not, repeat the procedure for ro and thus obtain q" E F, such that WnrO = q,g + r"
qo E
r,
where either r, = 0 or 81R (rl) :::: 81R(ro) - (w n - w n-,). Since Wn - Wn-I > 0 we can continue to the point we find qo, ... , qs-' E F, rs E F, and either rs = 0 or 81R (rs ) < W n , and one can write W~f
= (W~-lqO + w~-2ql + ... + qs-,)g + r s,
which proves the lemma in the case UI = W, = O.
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
239
Let us now consider the case of two arbitrary values UI, WI. The functions F(z) := f(z)e-U\Z, G(z) := g(z)e-W\Z, are now in the previous situation. Hence, there are 1/1 E 6, q, rEF, such that either r = 0 or 8~(r) < 8IR(G), and
1/IF
= qG + r.
It follows that
1/I(z)f(z)
= [q(z)e(U\-w,)Z]g(z) + eU\Zr(z).
Clearly, either eUtZr = 0 or 81R(eU\Zr) = 8IR(r) < 81R(G) = 8IR(g).
0
3.2.31. Theorem. Let f, gEE, g =1= 0, and assume the coefficients of g are relatively prime. If there is R :::: 0, and an angular sector S of opening strictly bigger than T( such that fig is holomorphic in S n (B(O, R)Y, then there is h E E such that f = gh. Proof. Rotating coordinates if necessary, we can assume that the sector is S = {z E C: - 17 < Arg z < T(}, with 0 < 17 < T(. The proof proceeds in three stages. First, we shall show that if f / g is holomorphic in {1m z > 0, Izi > R}, then fig = q /1/1, with q, 1/1 E E, and 1/1 has only purely imaginary frequencies (i.e., 1/1 E 6* in the notation of the previous lemma.) We show later that q /1/1 being holomorphic in {z E
3.2.32. Lemma. If fig is holomorphic when Izl > R, Imz > 0, then there are q E E, X E 6* such that xf = gq. Proof of Lemma 3.2.32. Replacing z by z + i R we can assume f / g is holomorphic in 1m z > O. This transformation is compatible with the condition 1/1 E 6*. We show first the following:
£g is holomorphic in Imz > 0, then 81R(g) .:::: 81R(/)' In fact, let 8R(g) = Wn - W], 8R(f) = up - UI as in Lemma 3.2.30. The convexity of peg) and P(f) tells us that they have vertices PI, ... , Pn (resp. aI, ... , ap ), such that Re Pn = Wn > ... > Re PI = WI (resp. Re ap = up > If
... > Real = UI), hence these vertices span the upper part of peg) and P(f), respectively. For 1 .:::: k .:::: n, let Ok be the line through 0, with the direction of the outer normal to peg) along [Pb Pk+d. Let 1/Ik be the angle it makes with the positive real axis, then 0 < 1/Ik < T(. Choose (J > 0 such that 0 < 1/Ik - (J < 1/Ik + < T(. Let Tk «(J) be the sector of bisectrix Ok and opening 2(). Since fig is holomorphic in Tk«(}), we can apply Proposition 3.2.28 to conclude there is a side [aj" ajl+t] of pC!) which is parallel to LBko .Bk+JJ and whose length laA+t - ah I :::: IPk+l Pkl. Clearly, the length of the respective prOjections on the real axis preserves
e
3. Exponential Polynomials
240
Figure 3.5 the same size relation, let us say PIII.[t3k.t3HIJ ~ pIII.[aj"ajk+,J. Therefore, 8I11.(g) =
L
PIII.[t3b
PHd ~ ~
L
pIII.[aj" aj,+,]
L
pIII.[aj, aj+d
= 8R(f).
I~j~p
Appealing now to the preceding Lemma 3.2.30, we infer there are X E 6*, and exponential polynomials q and r such that
xl
= qg+r,
and, either r = 0, or 8I11.(r) < 8I11.(g). We can rewrite the previous equation as r I -=X--q, g g
which shows that r / g is holomorphic in {1m z > OJ. From what we have just shown we must have We conclude that r = 0. Hence,
xl =
qg,
o
as we claimed.
3.2.33. Lemma. Let h E E, 1/f E 6*, and assume there are 1], 0 < 1] < ']'(, and R > 0, such that h/1/f is holomorphic in {z E C: Izl > R, I Argzl < 1]}. Then there are b E C[z]*, q E E, such that bh
= q1/f.
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
241
Proof of Lemma 3.2.33. Let l/f(z) = b l (z)eii'\z + ... + bn(z)eiA,Z, Al < A2 < ... < An, bj E (:[z]. The P61ya polygon P(l/f) is a segment of the imaginary axis, [-iAn, -iAIl. Proposition 3.2.28 states that there is a side [ab ak+Il of the P6lya polygon P(h) which is parallel to the imaginary axis and lak+1 - akl ::: IAn Ad. Let us change to new variables, ~ = iz, h'(~) = h(z), l/f'(~) = l/f(z). In this case, IAn - Ad = 8JR(l/f*) and lak+1 ~ akl :s 8JR(h*), hence 8JR(l/f*) :s 8R(h*).
Copying tbe proof of Lemma 3.2.30, we can show there is an s E N* and two exponential polynomials q*(n, r*(~), such that b~(-inh'(~)
= q*(~)l/f*(n
+ r*(n
and, either r* = 0, or 8JR(r*) < 8R(l/f*). Let r(z) = r*(iz). Then r(z)/l/f(z) is holomorphic in {z: Izl > R, I Argzl < 17}. From the first part of the proof we can conclude that 8JR(l/f*) :s 8JR(r*). This shows that r* O. Hence,
=
b~(z)h(z)
3.2.34. Lemma. Let f, g, h
E and c(f), c(g), and c(h), respectively, the
E
g.c.d. aftheir coefficients. If fg
o
= q*(iz)l/f(z).
= h, then c(f)c(g) = c(h).
=
=
Proofof Lemma 3.2.34. Let fez) LI~i~m Ai(z)e"'; g(z) L1:5j~n Bj(z)e PJ ; and h(z) = LI~k~p Ck(z)e YkZ • We can assume that al -< ... -< am, fiI -< ... -< f3n, and YI -< ... -< Yp· Consider first the case where c(f) = c(g) = I. We want to show that then the Ck must be coprime, i.e., c(h) = I. Let WI, .•. , Wq be the different values taken by ai + f3j, 1 :s i :s m, 1 :s j :s
n. Assume
WI
-<
W2
-< ... -<
Wq .
We have
From the independence of {eAZhEc over C[z) (Corollary 3.1.3) we obtain that p :s q, that for each frequency Yk = WI.. for some h, and that Ck(z) =
L
Ai(z)Bj(z),
1 :s k
:s p,
",+pj=Wl,
0=
L
Ai(z)Bj(z),
(X,+P,=Wl
Let us suppose that c(h) i= 1. This means there is a value z = a which is a common zero of all polynomials Ck. Since c(f) = 1, z = a is not a common zero of all Ai. Let io be such that Ai (a) = 0 for 1 :5 i < io and Aio (a) =P O. Let WI = exio + f3I. whether I E {h, ... , lp} or not, the corresponding sum vanishes at z = a. On the other hand, if IXi + f3j = IXio + f3I. it is not possible that i > io
242
3. Exponential Polynomials
because of the ordering of the frequencies. Moreover, if i = ;0, then j = I. Then ;<;0 u;+{3j=w/
Since the left-hand side vanishes at z = a, and the second sum also does, we have Aio(a)BI(a) = O. In other words, BI(a) = O. Let us now assume Bj(a) = 0 for 1 ~ j < k ~ n. We want to show that Bk(a) = O. We consider ;<;0
i=;o
i>;o
The total sum vanishes at z = a, as well as the sum for those indices (i, j) with; < io. If i > io, then aio -< ai and, since ai + fJj = aio + fJk we conclude fJj -< fJko i.e., j < k. Hence the sum with indices; > ;0 also vanishes at z = a. For; = io we have only one term AioBk' Therefore, Bk(a) = O. We have arrived at the conclusion that Bda) = 0, 1 ~ k ~ n, thus e(g) i= I, contrary to the hypotheses. Therefore, is must be the case that e(h) = 1. We consider now the case where e(f), e(g) are arbitrary nonzero polynomials. Then F = fle(f) E E, G = g/e(g) E E, e(F) = e(G) = l. Hence, H = FG also has e(H) = l. H = h/(e(f) e(g» is an exponential polynomial, and by Corollary 3.1.3 (i.e., the independence of (eA:helC over C[z]), we conclude that e(f) e(g) divides all the coefficients of h. That is, e(f) e(g) divides c(h). On the other hand, since e(H) = 1, we conclude that we have c(f)e(g) = c(h). 0 Let us now return to the proof of Theorem 3.2.31. By Lemma 3.2.32 we have that there is X E 6*, h E E, such that xf = gh. It follows from the hypotheses that h / X is holomorphic in {Iz I > R, I Arg zI < 1]}. We can apply Lemma 3.2.33 and conclude there are bE C[z]*, q E E
such that bh
=qx.
That is, xbf = Xgq·
Because X i= 0 we have bf
= gq.
From the assumption c(g) = I and Lemma 3.2.34, we conclude that b divides c (q ). Hence, q / bEE and, a fortiori
£g EE, as asserted by the theorem.
o
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
243
3.2.35. Remarks. (1) The condition c(g) = 1 is necessary, as shown by the entire functions (sinz)/z and (1 - eZ)/z that are not exponential polynomials (use Corollary 3.1.3). (2) On the other hand, the proof shows that if f, gEE, and fig is holomorphic in a sector of opening bigger than 7r, then there is h E E, b E e[z] such that fig = hlb. (3) The condition on the opening of the angle is necessary. The function eZ I (1 - eZ+ I) is holomorphic in the half-plane Re z > -I, but it is not an exponential polynomial. (4) There is an open conjecture of H.S. Shapiro that is related to Theorem 3.2.31. Assume f, g E Eo have infinitely many zeros in common, does there exist h E Eo, not a unit, such that h divides both f and g? (See [Sha], [VT].) Let us consider now the question of estimating the number of zeros of an exponential polynomial in a disk. We first note for future reference the following corollary of Proposition 3.2.24: 3.2.36. Lemma. If f E AEP is an entire function, then f is a function of completely regular growth.
Proof. It is immediate that
f satisfies an inequality of the form
If(z)1 < A(1
+ IzI)NeH(Z),
where H is the supporting function of the P61ya polygon P of f. On the other hand, from Proposition 3.2.24 we have that for any k E N* there are rk > 0, Tk > 0, such that if Izl > rk and d(z, Z(f)) ~ 11k, then ~
log If(z)1
log Tk
+ H(z).
It is then clear that hf (e i8) = l'1m sup T--'*'OO
log If(re i8 )1 = H( ei8) . r
We can assume the values rk satisfy rk+l > 2rk and
I log Tkl
1 - k
- - - <-.
rk
Let Z = {zn: n ~ I} be the sequence of distinct zeros of f, IZnl'::: IZn+d, and define Pn = 11k if rk < IZnl :s rk+l' Let E = Un",:,[lznl- Pn' IZnl + Pn], then
." )1 = H(ei6).
lim log If(re' ';:;r r This clearly implies that
L
r, !Slz.l!Sr
f is of completely regular growth. In fact,
Pn = (n(Z, r2) - n(Z, rl»
1
+ ... + k(n(Z, r) -
n(Z, rk»,
244 when rk < r
3. Exponential Polynomials ~
rk+ 1. Hence, given s > 0, let j so that 1/j < I r
""' ~
Pn
neZ, rj)
~
then
neZ, r)
+S---,
r
rl:5lz.l:9
8,
r
o
which shows that E has zero relative measure.
3.2.37. Corollary. Let n(V, Zo, r) denote the number of zeros (counted with multiplicities) of an entire function f E AEP in B(zo, r) and e(p) the length of the boundary of the P6lya polygon of f. Then . n(V, Zo, r) e(p) hm =--.
r
r-->oo
2]I"
Proof. This follows from properties of functions of completely regular growth. See [Lev, p. 288]. 0 Another way to express this corollary is that
n(V, zo, r) =
e(p)
~r
+ 0(1),
so that, in particular, for every Zo there is a constant C :::: 0 such that
n(V, zo, r)
e(p)
~ ~r
+ C,
which is due originally to P61ya. In [Tu] it is shown that if f is an exponential polynomial one can prove that the inequality holds with a constant independent of zoo Tunln also showed that such an inequality has many applications in number theory and elsewhere. The original estimate of Tunin has been improved by Tijdeman [Ti], Waldschmidt [Wa 1], and others. By a very ingenious argument, generalizing Rolle's theorem to holomorphic functions, Voorhoeve [Voor] obtained the following sharpening of Turan's estimate for the number of zeros of an exponential polynomial f: n(V, Zo,
r) ~ inr + 2(JOf, ]I"
where n = max{IO!jl: obtained
O!j
frequency of
n(V, Zo, r)
fl.
Using a geometric argument, he also
e(p)
~ ~r
+ vdof,
where v denotes the number of vertices of the P61ya polygon. Let us start by recalling some notation. If f is a meromorphic function in an open set U of the complex plane, f ¢. 0, then for Zo E U, v(zo) = v(zo, f) is the index of the first nonvanishing coefficients of the Laurent development of f about Zo, i.e., if V(zo) < 0 then Zo is a pole of f and -v(zo) is the order of this pole, if v(zo) > 0, then it is the order of Zo as a zero of f, finally, if V(Zo) = 0, then Zo is neither a zero nor a pole of f. Following [Voor] we introduce a generalization of the total variation of the argument of f along a closed interval [a, b) of the real axis.
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
245
3.2.38. Definition. Let f 1= 0 be a merom orphic function in neighborhood of [a, b] and Xl < X2 < ... < Xm the collection of zeros and poles of f in la, b[. We set A(a, b, f):=
lb Im(f'(~)lf(~»1 d~ I
L
+JT{
IV(Xbf)I+4Iv(a,f)1+4IV(b,f)I}.
l:,:k:,:m
Let V be a complex neighborhood of [a, b], f E M(V), and [a, b) £ ]C, d[ c c V, then if we denote by ~ I, ... the collection of zeros and poles of f in ]C, they are the only poles of 1'(z)lf(z) on ]e, and there is a domain V, ]e, d[ £ V £ V and a function g E Je(V) such that
,;n
dr.
1'~)
L
=
f()
V;~~'
l:,:j:,:n
f) ~J
dr.
+ g(z)
(z E V).
On the real axis the sum is real valued, hence, Im(f'(~)lf(~»
=
Img(~),
and we conclude that Im(f' If) can be considered as a continuous function in ]C, dr. In particular, A(a, b, f) is well defined. It is also clear that A is additive with respect to intervals, i.e., if e < r < s < t < d, then A Cr. t, f)
=
ACr, s, f)
+ A(s, t,
f).
Another useful property is the following. For YJ real, IYJI« 1, the function fry(z) := fez + iYJ) is meromorphic in a fixed complex neighborhood, still denoted V, of ]e, dr. Moreover, we can assume that for 0"# YJ, fry has no zeros or poles on the real axis, so that ACa. b, fry)
=
lb Im(f~(~)1fry(~»1 d~. I
3.2.39. Lemma. lim A(a, b, fry) = A(a, b, f).
ry--+O
Proof. By the additivity of the functional A we can assume that or poles in ]a, b[, so that for some YJo > 0 we have
1'(z) ex f( z) = z-a
ex
= v(a, f), f3 = v(b, f),
and g holomorphic in
a-Y/o::::Rez::::b+y/o,
Then, for
~ E
f3
+ --b +g(z), z-
JR, exYJ
IImzl::::YJo.
f has no zeros
246
3. Exponential Polynomials
For 0 < c « 1, a < ~ < a + c, the last two tenns are bounded for all values of rJ, 0 < IrJl < rJo· So that
+ c, fry) =
A(a, a
l
aH
I Im(f~(~)lfry(~»1 d~
1
!J~
a +o
=O(c)+larJl
rJ2+(~-a)2
a
= O(c) + lal arctan(c/lrJl). Similarly,
+ 1.81 arctan(c/ll7l).
A(b - c, b, fry) = O(c)
Since
= Img(o, we also have
Im(f'(~)lf(~»
1 IIm(f'(~)lf(~»ld~ 1 b
b e -
=
a
a+e
IImg(~)ld~ + O(c).
Therefore, we are led to consider
1 1 b-o'lm(f~(nlf~(~))! -lb-& IImg(~)ld~1 a+&
a+e
:: 1 b
8
-
I
a+8
Im(j~(~)1f~(~»
1
+
1 b
-
a+8
8
rJ2 +
(~ -
g(~)1 d~
1
d~
b- e
::::: larJl a+e
- 1m
d~
h- 8
a)2 + l.8rJl aH
I Im(g(~ + irJ)
-
rJ2 +
(~ -
b)2
g(~»1 d~
We infer that IA(a, b, f~) - A(a, b, j)1 :::::O(c) + O(lrJD
+ (lal + If we let IrJl
+ O(lrJl/c 2 )
I.8DI arctan(e/l rJ I) - n,/21.
= O(e 3 ), then all the tenns above are O(c), which proves that lim A(a, b,
~->o
f~)
o
= A(a, b, j).
3.2.40. Corollary. Let f, g be two nontrivial meromorphic functions on [a, b], and let k E Z, then:
(i) IA(a, b, j) - A(a, b, g)1 ::::: A(a, b, fg) ::::: A(a, b, j) + A(a, b, g); (ii) A(a, b, fk) = IkIA(a, b, j).
Proof. For 0 < rJ « 1 we have that neither in [a, b]. Moreover,
f~
nor
g~
have any zeros or poles
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
247
and
(f;}'fl; = k(f~/I~), hence the identity (ii) is clear for I~ instead of I, and the estimates (i) are a consequence of the triangle inequality for I~, g~. Using the continuity at 1'/ = 0 proved in the previous lemma, we conclude the corollary holds. 0
3.2.41. Proposition. Let I be a meromorphiclunction on [a, b) such that neither I nor f' have zeros or poles at the endpoints 01 the interval. Then A(a, b, f) ::: A(a, b, I') where e(z):= I Arg(f'(z)/I(z»1 argument of ~ ).
(Arg~
+ B(a) -
B(b),
is, as usual, the principal value
01 the
Proof. Note first that I Arg ~ I is a continuous function in C* with values in [0, rr]. Hence, 19 is a continuous function in a neighborhood of a and of b. Moreover, for small T} real, e~(z) := I Arg(f'(z)/I~(z»1 = e(z
+ i1'/),
so that e~(a)
e~(b)
--+ e(a),
--+ e(b)
as
1'/ --+ O.
Therefore, by Lemma 3.2.39, if we can prove the inequality for I~, 0 < 1'/ « 1, it follows for I. Therefore, we assume that I and f' have neither zeros nor poles on [a. b). In other words, we can assume that f' /1 is a holomorphic function on [a, b]. and thus Im(f'/f) has only finitely many zeros on [a, b]. Let a < XI < ... < xn < b be the zeros ofIm(f' If) in la, b[, denote a = Xo, b = Xn+l, which could be zeros of Im(f'/f) or could be not. Whenever Im(f'(~)/I(~» :::: 0 we have Arg(f'(O/I(~»::::O and conversely, so that in any interval]xt,Xk+l[ we have with
ak
= ±1, and
for the sarne value
ak.
Consequently, for
~ E ]Xk, Xk+I[,
~ ee~) = ak :~ Im(Log(f'(~)/I(~)))
(:~ LOg(f'(~)/I(;»)
=ak1m =
ak
Im(f"en/I'(;) - I'(~)/f(~».
Using this identity we obtain,
l
X, + I
x"
I Im(f'(~)/f(~»1 d~ = ak
l
x' + 1 Im(f'(~)/f(~»d~
Xk
3. Exponential Polynomials
248
1 Xk
=ak
+J
~
Im(j"(~)/f'(~»d~-
lx'+J q
d
-8(~)d~ d~
so that A(a, b, f) =
=
~ 1:k+1 I Im(j'(~)/f(~»1 d~
ta 1:'+1 adm(j"(~)/f'(~» d~
~ A(a, b,
1') + 8(a) -
- (8(b) - 8(a»
o
8(b).
3.2.42. Corollary. Let f be meromorphic and not constant on [a, b], then
°
A(a, b, f) ~ A(a. b, f')
Proof. For < T} « 1, the functions From the previous proposition A(a, b, f~) ~ A(a, b, f~)
since
°
~ 8~(~) ~
n. Letting
T} ~
f~, f~
+ 8~(a) -
°
+ n.
have no zeros or poles at a and h. 8~(b) ~ A(a, b, f~)
we obtain the corollary.
+ n,
o
Corollary 3.2.42 is the key to good estimates. It allows us to estimate the variation of the argument of solutions of differential equations, as shown by the following result:
3.2.43. Proposition. Let f he a nontrivial meromorphic function on [a, b] satisfying a nontrivial differential equation of the form
!!... [1/In!!... dz dz
[...
!!...
dz
[1/I1!!... f] ... ]] dz
= 0,
where 1/110"" 1/In are meromorphicfunctions on [a, b]. (For simplicity we shall drop the brackets in the future applications of this proposition.) Then A(a, b, f) ~
L
A(a, b, 1/Id
+ nn.
l:::k::5n
Proof. If n = 0, i.e., df/dz = 0, then f == c =1= 0, and it is easy to see that A(a, b, c) = 0 (see Exercise 3.2.3). The right-hand side is also zero in this case. For n ::: 1, let g = 1/11 f'. If g == 0 then we are in the previous case, so we can assume g is nontrivial. We can apply induction to obtain A(a, h, g) ~
L 2skSn
A(a, b, 1/Ik)
+ (n -
l)n.
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
249
On the other hand, the previous corollary and Corollary 3.2.40(i) and (ii) yield
+ n = A(a, b, g1/f j l) + n A(a, b, g) + A(a, b, 1/fjl) + n A(a, b, g) + A(a, b, 1/f1) + n
A(a, b, f) ~ A(a, b, 1') ~
=
~
L
o
A(a, b, 1/fk) + nn.
One can prove, using this proposition, that if rpl, ... ,rpm are linearly independent meromorphic functions on [a, b], and CI, ... ,Cm are arbitrary constants such that f = 2:: c)rp) ¢:. 0, then an upper bound for A(a, b, f) is independent of the values of the constants. The same holds for an upper bound of the total number of zeros and poles of f on [a, b] (see Exercise 3.2.8). We are now ready to go back to exponential polynomials. We recall from Section 3.1 that we denote
L
fez) =
p)(z)eC(jZ,
1:S):Sn
3.2.44. Proposition. Let a < b, N (a, b, f) be the number of zeros (counted with multiplicity) of the exponential polynomial f in the segment ]a, b[. Set J:= maxIma).
/ := minIma), J
J
Then (b - a)/ = n(dOf - N(a, b, f)
~
lb
~
(b - a)J
Im(f'(x)/f(x» dx
+ n(dOf -
N(a, b, f).
Proof. We can assume the indices have been chosen so that
It is easy to prove that
where D = d/dz (see Exercise 3.2.6 and the proof of Lemma 3.1.2). We are using the notation from the statement of Proposition 3.2.43. Further, one can write D2 = DID, D3 = DIDID, ... , where 1 is the constant function 1 acting as a multiplication operator. Hence (*), has the form described in Proposition 3.2.43, applied to ! (x )e-a,X, where we have a total dO! functions 1/fko some
250
3. Exponential Polynomials
1/Ik == 1, and the others 1/Ik(X) = exp«ak - ak+')x). From Proposition 3.2.43 we conclude that
A(a, b, !(x)e- Ci1X
):5 L
A(a, b, e(Ci.-Cik+il x )
+ ndO!,
l:sk:Sn-l
L
=
(b - a)1 Im(ak - ak+t>1
+ 77:dO!,
l:sk:Sn-'
since A(a, b, 1) = 0 and A(a, b, eWX ) = (b - a)1 Imwl (Exercise 3.2.3). Since 1m ak is increasing, we have
L
1Im(ak - ak+,)1 =
L
(Imak+l - Imak)
= 1m an and hence,
A(a, b, !(x)e- Ci1X ) :5 ndO!
Imal
+ (b -
=J -
/,
a)(J -I).
On the other hand,
lb
Im(f'(x)/!(x» dx
:51
b
1Im«f'(x)/!(x» - a,)1 dx
+ (b -
:5 A(a, b, !(x)e-a1X ) - n N(a, b, f) :5 ndO!
+ (b -
a)J -
77: N(a,
a) Imal
+ (b -
a)/
b, f),
where in the third inequality we used the definition of the functional A and the fact that N(a, b, f) = N(a, b, !(x)e- a1X ). This is half of the inequalities we wanted to prove. To prove the other half, we observe that it is also true that so that As earlier, we have
lb
Im(f'(x)/J(x» dx ::: (b - a) Iman ::: (b - a)J
-lb
1Im«f'(x)/!(x» - an)1 dx
+ 77: N(a, b, f) -
A(a, b, l(x)e-a,X),
which proves (b - a)/
+ nN(a, b, f) -
77:dO!
:51 Im(f'(x)/!(x»dx, b
o
as desired.
3.2.45. Corollary. The number N(a, b, f) o! zeros o! J in a closed interval [a, b] oJthe real line satisfies the inequality -
N(a, b, f) :5 dOl
+ 2n1 (b -
a)(J - I).
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
°
Proof. For s > we have N(a, b, f) :'S N(a - s, b proposition we have (b - a + 2£)1
+ rrN(a -
s, b
+ s, f)
251
+ s,
f). From the previous
-rrdof
:'S (b - a
+ 2£)J + rrdof -
rr N(a - s, b
+ £,
f),
so that 2rr N(a, b, f) :'S 2rr N(a -
Letting
£ -+
£,
b
:'S 2rrdof + (b - a
+ £, f)
+ 2s)(J -I).
0+ we obtain the required inequality.
D
We can obtain from Proposition 3.2.44 inequalities holding in any line segment of the complex plane.
3.2.46. Corollary. Let a, bEe and denote by [a, b] the line segment joining these two distinct points. If f has no zeros on la, b[, then
1m
(1
f'(z) dZ) :'S rrdOf
[a.b)
f
(z)
+ max Im«b -
a)aj)
)
::::: rrdOf
+ max{lm(i(b -
a»: Z E P},
where P is the P6lya polygon of f. Proof. Let g(n = f (a
+ (b -
ag) =
L
p) (1;) exp«b -
a)aj1;),
'~j~n
for some new polynomials
h(n =
eaaj pj(a
+ (b -
a)l;),
of degrees mj as before. The exponential polynomial g satisfies dOf N(O, 1, g) = 0, and
r' g'(~)
Jo
g(n
d~ =
=
r'
Jo
= dOg,
!'(a + (b - a)~) d (b - a) f(a + (b - a)~) ~
r J[a,b]
!'(z) dz.
fez)
Hence, from the second inequality of Proposition 3.2.44 we infer that 1m
(1
[a,b]
Since P
ff'(Z) dZ) ::::: rrdOf
+ max{lm«b -
(z)
= cv{a, ... , an}, we have maxj{Im«b -
a)aj)}.
)
a)aj)} ::::: maxZEP 1m (i(b - a». D
As a consequence, we obtain an estimate of the number of zeros of f in any square with sides parallel to the axes.
252
3. Exponential Polynomials
3.2.47. Theorem. Let Q be the square
Q := (z
E
C: a
~
~
Re z
b, c
~
1m z
~
d)
and N Q the number of zeros of the exponential polynomial f in Q. Further, let t:.y:= max (Re(a, -aj)). IS.j:::n
Then, NQ ~ 2d °f
+ 2rr1 {(b -
a)t:.x
+ (c -
d)t:.y}.
Proof. For 0 < e« 1 we have that if Qe:= {z E C: a -e ~ Rez ~ b+e, c - e ~ 1m z ~ d + e}, then BQe contains no zeros of f. (If BQ contains no zeros of f we can let e = 0.) Rouche's theorem states that N
r
< N = _1_ f'(z) dz = _11m QQ, 2rri laQ, fez) 2rr
(r
/,(z) dZ) . laQ, fez)
We divide BQe into four segments and apply Corollary 3.2.46 to each of them. We obtain 1m
(1
/,(z) dZ) aQ, fez)
~ 4rrdOf + max (lm«b - a + 2e)aj» I:::j:::n
+ I:::j:::n max (Im«a -
b - 2e)aj»
+ l:::J:::n max (lm(i(d -
c - 2e)aj»
+ max (lm(i(c -
d - 2e)aj»
l:::J:::n
= 4rrdOf
+ (b
- a
+ 2e)Llx + (d -
c + 2e)t:.y.
o
It is clear that this inequality proves the theorem.
We now obtain the promised Tunin type inequality. Let, as earlier, denote by V = V(n = the multiplicity variety of f, let n(V, Zo, r) be the number of points of V in 8(zo, r), and let Q = maxj lajl. First, we state a result that the reader should compare with Proposition 3.2.23.
3.2.48. Corollary. If f has real frequencies, then the number Ns of zeros of f in the strip S := (z E C: c ~ 1m z ~ d) can be bounded by Ns
~
2dof
(c - d)
+ -2rr - - l:::i.j:::n max (a,
- aj).
Proof. It is easy to see that there is R > 0 such that f has no zeros in the region I Rezl > R. Let Q = (z E C, -R :5 Rez :5 R, c :5 Imz :5 d), and apply the previous theorem. 0
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
3.2.49. Corollary. For any
Zo E
253
C, r > 0, we have
n(V, zo, r) ::::: 2dof
4Q
+ -r. 7r
Proof. Let Q = {z E C: Xo - r ::::: Re Z B(zo, r) ~ Q, so that
:::::
Xo
+ r, Yo -
r ::::: 1m Z
Yo
:::::
+ r}. Then
Clearly, Llx ::::: 2Q,
Lly ::::: 2Q,
hence, n(V, zo, r) ::::: 2dof
4Qr
o
+ -. 7r
Finally, we need a little geometric argument to obtain Voorhoeve's strengthening of the P6lya estimate involving the perimeter R(P) of the P6lya polygon of f.
3.2.50. Lemma. Let P and Q be convex polygons with exactly v vertices aI, ... , a v and f31, ... , f3v, respectively, where their indexing corresponds to the positive orientation of the respective boundaries. Let av+1 := aJ, f3v+1 := f31. Assume that 1
~
k
~
v.
Then,
L I~k~v
max{lm(z(ak+1 - ad)} = zeQ
L I~k~v
=
L
max{lm(z(f3k+1 zeP
.Bk»}
Im(.Bk(ak+1 - ad)
I~j~u
=L
Im(akCf3k+1 - f3k».
I~k~v
Proof. Let HQ be the supporting function of Q and evaluate it at the exterior unit normal nk to the side [f3k. f3k+d of Q, i.e., consider HQ(nd
= max Re(Znk) zeQ
as, in fact, the maximum is attained at any point of [f3k, f3k+I]. The condition Arg(ak+1 - ad = Arg(f3k+1 - f3k) indicates that
nk
=-
i(ak+1 - ak) . lak+1 - akl
254
3. Exponential Polynomials
Since H Q is a homogeneous function. we have HQ(-i(ak+l - ak»
= Re(-i(ak+l
= Re(-i(ak+l
- adPd
- ak)PHl)
= Im(Pk(ak+l - ak» = Im(Pk+l(ak+l - ak», and also Similarly, max Im(z(.Bk+l - f3d) = Im(ak(f3k+l - f3d) = Im(ak+l (f3kH - f3d). ZEP
Moreover, because of the periodicity of the indices,
L
L
Pk+lak+l =
Pkak,
and for a, bEe, Imiib = - 1m ba.
Consider now the expression we want to identify 'L....J " maxlm(z(aHl - ak» ZEQ
l~k~v
= '" L....J
Im(Pk(ak+l - ak»
l~k~v
L
=
Im(Pk+l (ak+1 - ak»
l~k~v
= 1m
(L
Pk+lak+1 -
l~k~v
= 1m
(L
Pkak -
I~k~v
L
= 1m (
L
Pk+lak)
l~k~v
L
PkHak)
I~k~v
(Pk - Pk+I)ak)
I~k~v
L
=
Im(ak(f3k+l - f3d)
l~k9
= '" L....J
max Im(z(f3k+1 - f3d).
l~k~v
ZEQ
This long chain of identities proves the lemma.
o
We remark that each sum in the previous lemma is invariant under translation of P or Q. e.g., for any Zo, Zl, Z2 E C we have
L l~k~v
max Im«z - zO)(ak+l - ak» ZEQ
=
L l~k~v
Im«ak - ZI)(f3k+l - 13k»
255
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
3.2.51. Theorem. Let v be the number of vertices of the P61ya polygon P of the exponential polynomial f and V = V(f). Then, for any Zo E C l(P) n(V, Zo, r):::: 2rr r + v dOf·
Proof. If v = 1, fez) = e a ,! PI (z), dOf = ml = deg PI and l(P) = 0, so that n(V, zo, f) :::: dOf is best possible. If v = 2, then all the frequencies lie in a straight line in the complex plane. Moreover, considering f(z)e- Cl1Z we can assume that al = O. Rotate the variables, z = (an/lanl)~. Then, in the variable ~ we have an exponential polynomial with real frequencies, say 0 = WI < W2 < ... < W n • Then l(P) = 2wn and we can apply Corollary 3.2.48, which states that in any strip S of the form S = {~ E C: c :::: 1m ~ :::: d) we have ° (c - d) N~::::2df+~wn.
Clearly, B(zo, r) ~ S when c
= Imzo -
r, d
n(V, zo, r) :::: 2dof
= Imzo + r. Thus, l(P)
+ 2rr
r.
Assume now v ~ 3. Let us index the frequencies of f in such a way that ai, .... cl u are the vertices of P in the positive direction, we set av+1 = al. We can find a polygon Q, which circumscribes B(zo. r) and such that if PI, ... , Pv are the vertices of Q, then Arg(uk+1 - ad = Arg(pk+1 - Pk), with Pv+1 = PI. (See Figure 3.6.) If CJQ contains any zeros of f, we replace B(zo. r) by B(zo, p) for p > r and let Q still be the corresponding polygon. We can do this with p so close to r so that n(V, zo, r) = n(V, zo, p), and if we prove the estimate for p we will be done by letting p -+ r. Hence, we may as well assume that CJ Q contains no zeros of f. Therefore, if N Q denotes the number of zeros of fin Q, we have n(V, Zo, r) < N Q
-
1 = -2Jri
1 aQ
1'(z) -dz fez)
av-I
Figure 3.6
= -2rr1 1m
1 aQ
1'(z) -dz fez)
3. Exponential Polynomials
256
::::
L
~dol + _I 2
2n
I:<=k:<=v
max{Im«z - zo)(ak+1 - ak))}. ZEQ
From the proof of Lemma 3.2.50 we know the maxima are achieved at any point of the segment [~k> jjk+tl. Since Q circumscribes B(zo, r) we can choose a point z that belongs to aQ so that Iz - =01 = rand max Im«z - zo)(ak+1 - ad) :::: rlak+1 - akl· ZEQ
As t(P) = L:1:<=k:<=v lak+1 - akl, we obtain v t(P) + --r, r 2n when v ::: 3. It is slightly better than the stated inequality. n(V, Zo, r) :::: -dol
o
Comparing the estimates from Theorem 3.2.51 or Corollary 3.2.49 with the conditions from Squires' Theorem 2.6.23, we see once more that if I is an exponential polynomial and p(z) ::: Izl (or p(Z) ::: I Imzl + 10g(1 + Izl) if the frequencies are purely imaginary), then the only obstruction for the variety V (f) to be an interpolation variety for Ap (iC) is the separation condition of the distinct zeros. That is, we would like to guarantee that if Zj 1= Zk on any two zeros of I, then IZj -
zkl :::
eexp(-Cp(Zk»
for some e, C > 0 independent of j, k. In which case we say that the zeros are well separated for the weight p. The example I(z) = sinz sinAz, A > 0, shows that given p we can choose A so that this condition is not satisfied. Namely, we let A = L:~I IO- n " for a sequence of integers nk t 00 sufficiently fast (depending on p). In fact, the zeros of I are nn, nEZ, and mn lA, m E Z. If A rt Ql then all zeros are simple, with the exception of Z = O. The distance between two zeros is bounded below in each sequence, the difficulty arises between the sequences, so that
Inn - mnlAI = ilnllA -
~I,
and the problem is to see how fast A is approximated by rational numbers. If A is a quadratic irrational one can easily see that [HW] > IA- mj n -
for some e > O.
~ n2 '
n
E
Z*,
mE
Z
3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
More generally, if A E there is 8 > 0 such that
Q, i.e., A is an algebraic number, then for any fJ
I A-~I n
257 > 0,
>_8 - n2+~'
see [Ba]. Note that in this case the frequencies of fare ±i ± iA, which are all algebraic numbers if A E Q. Moreover, the coefficients of f written as an exponential sum are also algebraic numbers. So that for f(z) = sinzsinAz, A E Q, guarantees that the zeros are well separated for any weight. If we consider f(z) = sin(z - a) - sin(J2z - a), a > 0, then the frequencies are again algebraic, but the coefficients are combinations of sin a and cos a with algebraic coefficients, which in general are transcendental numbers. On the other hand the zeros form the sequences 2krr 2a + (2k + l)rr - - - and kEZ. I-J2 1+J2 Again, depending on the choice of a we can make the zeros well separated or not. Moreover, note that from the P6lya-Dickson Theorem 3.2.25 it follows that when the frequencies of an exponential polynomial f are purely imaginary, then there is a positive constant A such that the zeros of f lie in the logarithmic strip
IImzl:::: A(l +log(l + Izl)) so that, if the zeros of f are well separated for the weight p(z) = 11m zl log(l + Izl), it follows that there are 8 > 0, N > 0, such that IZj - zkl
~
+
8
(Izkl
+ IZjl)N
for any two distinct zeros Zj, Zk. These considerations led to the following conjecture of Ehrenpreis [Eh5], [BY2]: 3.2.52. Conjecture. Let f be an exponential polynomial with algebraic frequencies and with polynomial coefficients in Q[z], then the zeros are well separated for the weight p(z) = Izl. That is, there are consta