Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure
Computational Methods in Applied Sciences Volume 9
Series Editor E. Oñate International Center for Numerical Methods in Engineering (CIMNE) Technical University of Catalunya (UPC) Edificio C-1, Campus Norte UPC Gran Capitán, s/n 08034 Barcelona, Spain
[email protected] www.cimne.com
Vladimir Kompisˇ
Composites with Microand Nano-Structures Computational Modeling and Experiments
123
Vladimir Kompisˇ Academy of the Armed Forces Liptovsky´ Mikula´ sˇ Slovakia
ISBN 978-1-4020-6974-1
e-ISBN 978-1-4020-6975-8
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008928508 All Rights Reserved c 2008 Springer Science + Business Media B.V. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 springer.com
Contents
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii 1
Torsional Buckling of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes . . . . . . . . . . . A.Y.T. Leung, X. Guo, and X.Q. He
1
2
Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles: Computer Simulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Roberto Moreno-Atanasio, S.J. Antony, and R.A. Williams
9
3
Method of Continuous Source Functions for Modelling of Matrix Reinforced by Finite Fibres . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 ˇ Vladim´ır Kompiˇs, M´ario Stiavnick´ y, Mari´an Kompiˇs, Zuzana Murˇcinkov´a, and Qing-Hua Qin
4
Effective Dynamic Material Properties for Materials with Non-Convex Microstructures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 Martin Schanz, Georgios E. Stavroulakis, and Steffen Alvermann
5
Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation . . . . . . . . . 67 Jiˇr´ı Vala
6
The Use of Finite Elements for Approximation of Field Variables on Local Sub-Domains in a Mesh-Free Way . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 V. Sladek, J. Sladek, and Ch. Zhang
7
Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 Alexandre Vakhrouchev
8
Modelling of Fatigue Behaviour of Hard Multilayer Nanocoating System in Nanoimpact Test . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 Magdalena Kopernik, Lechosław Tre¸bacz, and Maciej Pietrzyk
v
vi
Contents
9
A Continuum Micromechanics Approach to Elasticity of Strand-Based Engineered Wood Products: Model Development and Experimental Validation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161 Reinhard St¨urzenbecher, Karin Hofstetter, Thomas Bogensperger, Gerhard Schickhofer, and Josef Eberhardsteiner
10 Nanoindentation of Cement Pastes and Its Numerical Modeling . . . . 181 Jiˇr´ı Nˇemeˇcek, Petr Kabele, and Zdenˇek Bittnar 11 Ductile Crack Growth Modelling Using Cohesive Zone Approach . . . 191 Vladislav Koz´ak 12 Composite (FGM’s) Beam Finite Elements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 209 ˇ s Just´ın Mur´ın, Vladim´ır Kutiˇs, Michal Masn´y, and Rastislav Duriˇ 13 Computational Modal and Solution Procedure for Inhomogeneous Materials with Eigen-Strain Formulation of Boundary Integral Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 239 Hang Ma, Qing-Hua Qin, and Vladimir Kompiˇs 14 Studies on Damage and Rupture of Porous Ceramics . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257 Ioannis Doltsinis 15 Computation of Effective Cement Paste Diffusivities from Microtomographic Images . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 281 K. Krabbenhoft, M. Hain, and P. Wriggers Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 299
Introduction
This book contains selected, extended papers presented (with three exceptions) in the thematic ECCOMAS conference on Composites with Micro- and NanoStructure (CMNS) – Computational Modelling and Experiments held in Liptovsk´y Mikul´asˇ, Slovakia, in May 28–31, 2007 and sponsored by the Slovak Ministry of Education. Composite materials play important role in all mechanical, civil as well as in electrical engineering structures especially in the last two decades in connection with the nano-materials and nano-technologies. Of course the chemical engineering is a connecting element for all these applications. Computational methods and experiments are a basis for the Simulation-Based Engineering Science (SBES). SBES can play a remarkable role in promoting the developments vital to health, security and technological competitiveness of nations. Recent experimental and computational results demonstrate that materials reinforced with stiff particles and fibres can obtain substantial improvements in stiffness, thermal conductivity and electro-magnetic properties. Materials reinforced with fibres can have very different properties in different directions. The material can have very good conductivity in one direction and can be isolator in other directions. Most important reinforcing materials discovered less than 20 years ago, which are in the centre of interest in many universities and research institutions are the carbon nanotubes. With these new materials also importance of computational simulations and experimental verifications increases. The book contains 16 papers: The first paper, by Leung et al., employs an atomic-scale finite element method to study torsion buckling of single-walled carbon nano-tubes (SWNTs). The dependence of critical torsion angle on the length is discussed and compared with conventional shell theory. Strain energy and morphologies of the SWNT are discussed. In the second paper, the authors study the structure and mechanical strength properties of Cu nano particulate aggregates. The inter-particle interaction models have
vii
viii
Introduction
been considered to account the long-range forces: electrostatic, van der Waals and coupled Johnson, Kendall and Roberts (JKR) and Brownian force models. The assemblies considered have poly-size distribution of particles. In the third paper the interaction of matrix with fibres and fibre with other fibres in the fibre-reinforced composites (FRC) is numerically simulated using 1D continuous source functions along the fibre axis and 2D source functions inside the ends of fibres. Numerical examples show that the interaction of the end parts of fibres is crucial for evaluation of the mutual interaction of fibres in the composite. Correct simulation of all parts is important for evaluation of stiffness and strength of the FRC. In the fourth paper the effective dynamic material properties for materials with microstructure are assumed. Micro-scale inertia are taken into account and numerical homogenization is performed. The frequency dependent macroscopic material parameters are found for frequency range from 0 up to 1 MHz. The fifth paper describes modelling of diffusive and massive phase transformation of a multi-component system based on the principle of maximum dissipation rate by Onsager; the finite thickness of the interface between both phases can be respected. The mathematical analysis results in an initial-value problem for a system of partial differential equations of evolution with certain non-local integral term; the unknowns are the mole fractions of particular components. Paper number six deals with numerical implementation of local integral equation formulation of 2D linear elastic media with continuous variable Young’s modulus. Two meshless presentations of the formulation are described and accuracy, convergence and numerical stability are investigated. The seventh paper presents methods for the modelling of the processes that accompany obtaining and use of powder nano-composites. For this purpose, a number of physical-mathematical models, including the models of obtaining of nano-sized powders at “up down” processes, the models of the main steps of powder nanocomposites compaction and the models of deformation of powder nano-composites under the ambient action were developed. The eighth paper presents the basis of the nano-impact test and the idea of prediction of fracture occurrence, especially fatigue behaviour of nano-impacted materials. Finite element (FE) model is applied to identification of the material model of hard nano-coating in the multilayer system. In the second part of the chapter a new approach to analysis of fracture phenomena is introduced as the fatigue criteria, which are used in simulation of nano-impact test. Results of simulations with the fatigue criteria implemented into the FE code for the analysed problem are discussed. The ninth paper contains a description of a continuum micromechanics model development and experimental validation of strand-based engineering wood products aimed to improve the mechanical properties of wood products. The model allows considering of the relevant (micro-) characteristics of the wood on the mechanical properties of panels. The tenth paper focuses on experimental investigations and numerical modelling of micromechanical behaviour of cement paste taken as a fundamental representative of building materials with heterogeneous microstructure. The experimental
Introduction
ix
nano-indention and its implications to evaluation of material properties are focused. Better descriptions of indentation based on analytical visco-elastic solution and finite element model with general visco-elasto-plastic constitutive relation are proposed. These models are used for simulation of indentation and for estimation of material parameters at micrometer scale. Paper number eleven studies the prediction of the crack growth of the ductile fracture of forgets steel 42CrMo4. Crack extension is simulated in sense of element extinction algorithm based on the damage model Gurson-Tvergard-Needleman and on the cohesive zone model. Determination of micro-mechanical parameters is based on the combination of static tests, microscopic observation and numerical calibration procedures by FEM. In the twelfth paper a longitudinal polynomial continuous variation of the stiffness properties is considered in the stiffness matrix of the beam element and presented for the analysis of the electric, thermal and structural field. The transversal and longitudinal variation of the material properties is considered. In the thirteenth paper a novel computational modal and solution procedure are proposed for inhomogeneous materials with the eigenstrain formulation of the boundary integral equations. Each inhomogeneity embedded in the matrix with various shapes and material properties described via the Eshelby tensors can be obtained through either analytical or numerical means. As the unknowns appear only on the boundary of the solution domain, the solution scale of the inhomogeneity problem with the present model is greatly reduced. To enhance further the computational efficiency, the overall elastic properties using the present model with eigenstrain formulation are solved using the newly developed boundary point method for particle reinforced inhomogeneous materials over a representative volume element. The fourteenth paper deals with reliability of porous ceramics based on experimentation and analysis. Damage prior to rupture and aging because of corrosive activity in porous materials is discussed. Fracturing processes in the material that result to rupture under pore pressure are studied on the micro-scale by the numerical simulation model. Finally, in the last paper a computational framework for extracting effective diffusivities from micro-tomographic images is presented. Effective diffusivity of a cement paste whose microstructure has been digitized is derived, consistent homogenization and statistical testing and interpretation of results are highlighted. ˇ I would like to thank my colleague Dr. Stiavnick´ y for his help in preparation of the book. Vlado Kompiˇs
Chapter 1
Torsional Buckling of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes A.Y.T. Leung, X. Guo, and X.Q. He
Abstract This paper employs an atomic-scale finite element method to study torsional buckling of single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs). As the torsional angle increases, a spiral will appear and the morphology of SWNT will change abruptly. For SWNTs with fixed diameter and those with fixed aspect ratio, the dependence of critical torsional angle on the length is discussed and compared with conventional shell theory, respectively. Strain energy grows initially as a quadratic function of the torsional angle, and then changes approximately linearly. The morphologies of the SWNT are illustrated in detail.
1.1 Introduction The excellent mechanical properties of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have attracted enormous research interest for both science and technology applications [1–3]. The buckling behavior of CNTs is an important topic for both experimental investigation and theoretical research [4–8]. Compared with extensive experimental research on the buckling of CNTs under compression and bending, experimental studies on their torsional buckling are limited. For example, Yu et al. [9] used atomic force microscopy to observe a fully collapsed CNT section and a twisted and fully collapsed CNT. The limited research on torsional buckling concentrates mainly on theoretical research via molecular dynamics (MD) and continuum mechanics. Yakobson et al. [6] performed MD simulation of torsion of a SWNT and found that it flattened into a straight spiral beyond the critical torsional angle. Shibutani and Ogata [10] presented an MD study on the torsional buckling of a cantilevered SWNT. The initial torsional deformation gives a linear relationship between torsional moment and torsional angle. After buckling, an anti-plane distorted structure is generated. Wang A.Y.T. Leung, X. Guo, and X.Q. He Department of Building and Construction, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
1
2
A.Y.T. Leung et al.
et al. [11] simulated the torsion of SWNTs via MD. After buckling the whole section collapses like a dumbbell and the atoms move with off-plane displacements. Sears and Batra [12] performed molecular mechanics simulation of torsional buckling of a very long SWNT and found that the critical shear strain agreed well with prediction of Donnell’s shell theory. Even for the axial compression and tension of CNTs, MD simulation is so computationally expensive that it is difficult to scale up [13, 14]. Besides the great computational effort, MD simulation of torsional buckling of CNTs involves other difficulties such as realization of torque on an atomistic system and large deformation around the spiral. There is some investigation based on continuum mechanics to study torsional buckling of CNTs. For example, Li and Guo [15] employed conventional shell theory and eigenvalue buckling methodology to investigate large deformation behavior and post-buckling modes of SWNTs under torsion; Han and Lu [16] used Donnell’s shell theory to study torsional buckling of a DWNT embedded in an elastic medium. In the above continuum models, interatomic potential was not employed directly and multi-body interactions could not be considered accurately, so the dependence of critical torsional angle and concrete configuration of buckled CNTs could hardly be achieved. Liu et al. [17, 18] proposed an atomic-scale finite element method. Using interatomic potential to consider the multi-body interactions, it is as accurate as molecular mechanics simulation and much faster than the conjugate gradient method. The present authors [19–21] employed it to study axial buckling and bending buckling of CNTs, and characterized the dependence of critical strain on the length, strain energy curve and the configuration in post-buckling stages. Further, this paper employs it to study torsional buckling of SWNTs. Dependence of critical torsional angle on the length of SWNTs with a fixed diameter is found to be consistent with conventional shell theory. Also, for armchair and zigzag SWNTs with fixed aspect ratios, the critical torsional angles are achieved and compared with conventional shell theory. A (13, 0) SWNT is taken as an example of post-buckling. When the torsional angle is large enough, a spiral is initiated, its morphology changes abruptly, and strain energy has a slight drop. After that the strain energy increases approximately linearly with respect to the torsional angle, and the spiral continues developing. The morphologies of twisted SWNT are presented in detail.
1.2 Simulation Procedure For a straight SWNT in equilibrium, the center of left cross-section is taken as the origin, its longitudinal direction as the z axis, and its cross-section as the x − y plane. In step i, for the left boundary atoms, a rotation increment ∆i around the centre of the cross-section is applied; for the right boundary atoms, the reverse rotation increment ∆i is applied. Then, the x(i) and y(i) of the boundary atoms are kept fixed, the z(i) of the left boundary atoms are kept fixed, while the z(i) of the right boundary atoms are kept free, and the atomic-scale finite element simulation for the whole atomistic system is performed to achieve new equilibrium configuration.
1 Torsional Buckling of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes
3
The covalent bonds among the atoms are described by Brenner et al.’s “second generation” empirical potential [22]. Each atomic-scale finite element consists of 10 atoms including the central atom, the three nearest-neighboring atoms and the six second nearest-neighboring atoms. A schematic diagram of the atomic-scale finite element, the associated element stiffness matrix and the non-equilibrium force vector are therein [17, 18]. The element captures the interactions among the central atom and the other atoms. All calculation is performed by ABAQUS via its UEL subroutine [23]. With the torsional angle increasing, a spiral will appear and morphology of the SWNT will change abruptly at a certain torsional angle, which is the critical angle for torsional buckling.
1.3 Numerical Results and Discussion First, dependence of the critical torsional angle on the length of SWNTs with a fixed diameter is studied. Figure 1.1 shows various critical torsional angles of (13, 0) SWNTs at different lengths l, while their aspect ratios change from about 5 to larger than 20. From Fig. 1.1, it is observed that as the length increases, the critical torsional angle also increases. The proportional function is employed to fit the critical torsional angle. The fitting result is
ψ = 0.07144l
(1.1)
with a correlation coefficient 99.1%. The fitting shows that except the shortest SWNT, there is a good proportional relationship between the critical torsional angle and the length of SWNTs. The above result is compared with the shell theory
1.8
Critical torsional angle
1.6
y = 0.07144l
1.4
R2 = 99.1%
1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 2
4
6
8
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26
Length of SWNTs (nm) Fig. 1.1 Critical torsional angle changes with the length of (13, 0) SWNTs
4
A.Y.T. Leung et al.
results. For torsional buckling of a shell, when overall beam buckling takes place, the critical torsional angle is [24]
ψcr = 2(1 + ν )π
(1.2)
and when cylinder-helix flattening occurs, the critical torsional angle is [24]
ψcr = β l d −2.5
(1.3)
where β is a dimensional parameter that is dependent on parameters other than l and d. The latter occurs first for l < 136d 5/2 nm, which is true for all the tubes here. From Eq. (1.3), for the SWNTs with a fixed diameter, the critical torsional angle is proportional to the length, i.e. the critical torsional angle per unit length is independent of the length. Here, when the length is greater than 10 nm (aspect ratio is greater than 10), the critical torsional angle is approximately proportional to the length, which is consistent with the prediction of conventional shell theory. Secondly, dependence of critical torsional angle on length of SWNTs with a fixed aspect ratio is investigated. For armchair SWNTs with a fixed aspect ratio ∼7.6, the critical torsional angle is related to the length in Fig. 1.2. From Fig. 1.2, it is observed that as the length increases, the critical torsional angle decreases rapidly. The power function is used to fit the critical torsional angle. The fitting result is
ψcr = 12.96965l −1.47366
(1.4)
with a correlation coefficient larger than 0.99. This result is also compared with the shell theory results. For the cylinder-helix flattening of torsional buckling of a shell, the critical torsional angle is expressed as Eq. (1.3). For the current case, the aspect
1.8
Critical torsional angle
1.6
ycr = 12.96965l −1.47366
1.4
R2 = 0.99779
1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Length of SWNTs (nm) Fig. 1.2 Critical torsional angle varies with the length of armchair SWNTs with a fixed aspect ratio ∼7.6
1 Torsional Buckling of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes
5
2.75
Critical torsional angle
2.50
ycr = 25.66043l −1.85374 R2 = 0.99284
2.25 2.00 1.75 1.50 1.25 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Length of SWNTs (nm)
Fig. 1.3 Critical torsional angle varies with the length of zigzag SWNTs with a fixed aspect ratio ∼7.66
ratio is a constant; after replacing the diameter d in Eq. (1.3) with c l (where c is inverse of the aspect ratio), one has
ψcr = β c−2.5 l −1.5
(1.5)
The fitting on the present critical torsional angle, Eq. (1.4), shows that the critical torsional angle is proportional to l −1.47 , which is in good agreement with l −1.5 , predicted by Eq. (1.5). A similar study is performed for zigzag SWNTs with a fixed aspect ratio ∼7.66, and the critical torsional angle varies with the length as shown in Fig. 1.3. It is observed that as the length increases, the critical torsional angle also decreases rapidly. The power function is employed to fit the critical torsional angle. The fitting result is ψcr = 25.66043l −1.85374 (1.6) with a correlation coefficient larger than 0.99. The critical torsional angle is proportional to l −1.85 , so it is also in reasonable agreement with the prediction by Eq. (1.5). In the above two examples, the armchair SWNTs behave more like the conventional shell than the zigzag ones. The main reason might be that the diameter and length of the zigzag SWNTs here are too small compared with those of the armchair SWNTs. Next, the post-buckling behavior of SWNT is studied. A (13, 0) SWNT with a length of 23.23 nm is taken as an example. The average strain energy is calculated as the difference of the average energy per atom in the torsional and un-torsional system as a function of torsional angle as shown in Fig. 1.4. Its morphologies are presented in Fig. 1.5 [25]. At small torsional angle, the SWNT deforms linearly, consistent with Yakobson et al. [6] and Shibutani and Ogata [10], and the strain energy grows quadratically with respect to the torsional angle. At the critical torsional angle of 1.64, a spiral appears, as shown in inset of Fig. 1.4. When the SWNT buckles, there is a very small energy release, which is similar with the research of Yakobson et al. [6].
6
A.Y.T. Leung et al.
Average strain energy (eV)
0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0.00 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
Torsional angle Fig. 1.4 The curve of average strain energy for the (13, 0) SWNT changes with the torsional angle
(a) torsional angle of 2.00
(b) torsional angle of 2.40
(c) torsional angle of 2.80
(d) torsional angle of 3.20
(e) torsional angle of 3.60
(f ) torsional angle of 4.00
Fig. 1.5 The morphologies of the (13, 0) SWNT in torsion
1 Torsional Buckling of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes
7
When the torsional angle increases, the spiral continues developing, as seen in Figs. 1.5a–f, and the morphologies are similar with those in Yakobson et al. [6], Wang et al. [11] and Shibutani and Ogata [10]. The strain energy increases approximately linearly with the torsional angle, in agreement with Yakobson et al. The above is quite similar with our former study on axial buckling and bending buckling of CNTs [19–21], where in each post-buckling stage the strain energy changes approximately linearly with the strain and the bending angle, respectively. When the torisonal angle reaches 4.0, the whole tube shortens by about 1.0% of the original length. For the same SWNT, in the MD simulation of Yakobson et al. [6], the critical torsional angle is larger than 2.5, and as they stated, it is obviously larger than the prediction of Eq. (1.3) (1.28 radian). In the present simulation, it is 1.64 and better than 2.5. An important reason for this improvement is the potential functional that is employed. The Brenner empirical potential [26] was employed in MD simulation of Yakobson et al. while the Brenner et al. “second generation” empirical potential [22] is employed in the present simulation. When Brenner empirical potential is employed in the present atomic-scale finite element simulation, the critical torsional angle is found to be 2.06. The difference of the present prediction and the prediction of the Eq. (1.3) comes from the treatment of the boundary, which is same with Yakobson et al. The circular ends deter the through flattening necessary for the helix to form.
1.4 Conclusion In conclusion, torsional buckling of SWNTs is studied by the atomic-scale finite element method. At the critical torsional angle, a spiral will appear and torsional buckling as cylinder-helix flattening will take place. For slender SWNTs with fixed diameter, the critical torsional angle is approximately proportional to the length, consistent with the conventional shell theory. For armchair and zigzag SWNTs with the fixed aspect ratio, dependence of the critical torsional angle on the length is in good agreement with the conventional shell theory, respectively. After buckling, the strain energy changes approximately linearly with the torsional angle, and the morphologies are illustrated in detail. Acknowledgements A.Y.T. Leung acknowledges the support from Research Grant Council of Hong Kong grant #1161/05E.
References 1. Qian D, Wagner GJ, Liu WK, Yu MF, and Ruoff RS (2002) Mechanics of carbon nanotubes, Appl. Mech. Rev. 55: 495–533. 2. Srivastava D, Wei CY, and Cho K (2003) Nanomechanics of carbon nanotubes and composites, Appl. Mech. Rev. 56: 215–230.
8
A.Y.T. Leung et al.
3. Huang Y and Wang ZL (2003) Mechanics of carbon nanotubes, in Comprehensive Structural Integrity Handbook, B. Karihaloo, R. Ritchie, and I. Milne (eds), Elsevier, Amsterdam, Vol. 8, p. 551. 4. Falvo MR, Clary GJ, Taylor II RM, Chi V, Brooks Jr FP, Washburn S, and Superfine R (1997) Bending and buckling of carbon nanotubes under large strain, Nature (London), 389: 582–584. 5. Lourie O, Cox DM, and Wagner HD (1998) Buckling and collapse of embedded carbon nanotubes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81: 1638–1641. 6. Yakobson BI, Brabec CJ, and Bernholc J (1996) Nanomechanics of carbon tubes: instabilities beyond linear response, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76: 2511–2514. 7. Srivastava D, Menon M, and Cho K (1999) Nanoplasticity of single-wall carbon nanotubes under uniaxial compression, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83: 2973–2976. 8. Ru CQ (2000) Effect of van der Waals forces on axial buckling of a double-walled carbon nanotubes, J. Appl. Phys. 87: 7227–7231. 9. Yu MF, Kowalewski T, and Ruoff RS (2001) Structural analysis of collapsed, and twisted and collapsed, multiwalled carbon nanotubes by atomic force microscopy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86: 87–90. 10. Shibutani Y and Ogata S (2004) Mechanical integrity of carbon nanotubes for bending and torsion, Model. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 12: 599–610. 11. Wang Y, Wang XX, and Ni XG (2004) Atomistic simulation of the torsion deformation of carbon nanotubes, Model. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 12: 1099–1107. 12. Sears A and Batra RC (2004) Macroscopic properties of carbon nanotubes from molecularmechanics simulations, Phys. Rev. B. 69: 235406. 13. Liew KM, Wong CH, He XQ, Tan MJ, and Meguid SA (2004) Nanomechanics of single and multiwalled carbon nanotubes, Phys. Rev. B. 69: 115429. 14. Liew KM, He XQ, and Wong CH (2004) On the study of elastic and plastic properties of multi-walled carbon nanotubes under axial tension using molecular dynamics simulation, Acta. Mater. 52: 2521–2527. 15. Li C and Guo WL (2003) Continuum mechanics simulation of post-buckling of single-walled nanotubes, Int. J. Nonlinear Sci. Numer. Simul. 4: 387–393. 16. Han Q and Lu G (2003) Torsional buckling of a double-walled carbon nanotubes embedded in an elastic medium, Eur. J. Mech. A. 22: 875–883. 17. Liu B, Huang Y, Jiang H, Qu S, and Hwang KC (2004) The atomic-scale finite element method, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 193: 1849–1864. 18. Liu B, Jiang H, Huang Y, Qu S, Yu MF, and Hwang KC (2005) Atomic-scale finite element method in multiscale computation with applications to carbon nanotubes, Phys. Rev. B. 72: 035435. 19. Leung AYT, Guo X, He XQ, Jiang H, and Huang Y (2005) Post-buckling of carbon nanotubes by atomic-scale finite element, J. Appl. Phys. 99: 124308. 20. Guo X, Leung AYT, Jiang H, He XQ, and Huang Y (2007) Critical strain of carbon nanotubes: an atomic-scale finite element study, J. Appl. Mech. 74: 347–351. 21. Guo X, Leung AYT, He XQ, Jiang H, and Huang Y (2008) Bending buckling of singlewalled carbon nanotubes by atomic-scale finite element, Composites Part B: Engineering, 39: 202–208. 22. Brenner DW, Shenderova OA, Harrison JA, Stuart SJ, Ni B, and Sinnott SB (2002) A secondgeneration reactive empirical bond order (rebo) potential energy expression for hydrocarbons, J. Phys.: Condens Matter. 14: 783–802. 23. ABAQUS, ABAQUS Theory Manual and Users Manual, 2005, version 6.5, Hibbit, Karlsson and Sorensen, Pawtucket, RI, USA. 24. Timoshenko SP and Gere JM (1961), Theory of Elastic Stability, 2nd ed., McGraw-Hill, New York. 25. Humphrey W, Dalke A, and Schulten K (1996) VMD – visual molecular dynamics, J. Mol. Graphics. 14: 33–38. 26. Brenner DW (1990) Empirical potential for hydrocarbons for use in simulating the chemical vapor deposition of diamond films, Phys. Rev. B. 42: 9458–9471.
Chapter 2
Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles: Computer Simulations Roberto Moreno-Atanasio, S.J. Antony, and R.A. Williams
Abstract We present a study of the influence of interparticle interactions on the kinetics of self-assembly and mechanical strength properties of Cu nanoparticulate aggregates. Three types of commonly used inter-particle interaction forces have been considered to account for the attraction between particles, namely electrostatic forces, van der Waals forces and the JKR cohesion model. These models help to account for the forces generated due to surface treatment of particles, a process commonly used in fabricating composite particles. The assembly formed using the electrostatic interaction force model has 50% of the particles positively charged and the remaining particles are negatively charged. All the assemblies considered here have a polydisperse size distribution of particles. To be able to compare the bulk properties predicted between these models, the maximum force required to break the interparticle contacts (pull-off force) is kept identical in all the systems considered here. Three assemblies were generated. The assemblies were allowed to self-assemble based on the three interaction force models as mentioned above. We have studied some of the key properties of self-assembled Cu aggregates obtained by using the above mentioned models. The study shows that, although the pull-off force between particles is identical, variations in the long-range forces between particles significantly affect the structural properties and mechanical strength of the self-assembled nanoaggregates. The approach adopted here forms a basis on which to further probe the bulk behaviour of self-assembled particulates in terms of their single-particle properties.
2.1 Introduction The study of nanocomposites is a major and growing topic spanning many scientific disciplines including materials science and chemistry. The reason for an increasing Roberto Moreno-Atanasio, S.J. Antony, and R.A. Williams School of Environmental, Process and Materials Engineering, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
[email protected],
[email protected],
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
9
10
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
interest in the development of composite materials at the nanosize scale is found in the unusual properties that these materials may exhibit due to their small size. On one hand a decrease in particle size produces an increase in the ratio of surface area to volume and thus an increase in the strength of the surface interactions when compared with volume interactions. On the other hand, when a nanocomposite material is formed the properties of the new materials might be due to the fact that one or each individual component grants its properties to the new material or in other cases the properties of the new materials are radically different from those properties shown by the individual components. Therefore, many of the properties of the nanocomposites and especially the interparticle forces present between nanoparticles depend on the processing routes by which the nanocomposites are fabricated, with special attention paid to the surface treatment. A typical nanocomposite material may be a combination of inorganic and organic components, the former usually being a mineral and the latter a polymer [16, 27]. Some organic materials, when free in solution are able to self-assemble, due to the interaction between some of the radicals of the molecules. They can form complex reversible structures which can be controlled by means of an external trigger such as pH [1]. The use of some of these organic molecules to fabricate nanocomposites allows an easy control of the interparticle interactions and therefore they show a great potential for developing new materials with high mechanical resistance or specific functionalities. Some of the organic compounds that cap the inorganic components can form hydrogen bonds in solution which allows self-aggregation of the nanoparticles. This is the case with organic acids or bases which are joined to minerals such as copper or gold through a covalent interaction [4, 10]. As shown in the literature [30] the adhesion between particles through hydrogen bonds can be described by using the well known JKR model [15]. In other cases, the use of more than one type of organic molecule allows the combination of deprotonised acids with protonised amine groups which produces a net attraction between the different organic coatings. Alternatively some coatings could induce hydrophobic interactions between particles, which can also be described by the JKR model [5]. However, although many of these aggregates are formed in solution, their structural integrities remain after they are taken out from solution. The above mentioned studies clearly show the potential of engineering particulate systems by controlling the interparticle interactions through appropriate processing routes. Computer simulation work of the bulk properties of micro- or nano-composite materials can be performed using a discrete approach. In the discrete approach, systems are modelled at a particle level using either Molecular Dynamics or Distinct Element Method [3, 19, 20]. In addition, a mesoscopic approach [27] or the combination of macroscopic and microscopic approaches [22] can be used for the analysis of the mechanical behaviour of nanocomposite materials. Here we present a comparative computational analysis of the influence of the type of interaction on the self-assembly and mechanical strength of nanocomposites made of copper nanoparticles coated with an organic compound.
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
11
There are several models available to define the inter-particle cohesiveforces. Some of these models account for a long-range contribution such as van der Waals and electrical forces and others ignore it as in the case of the JKR model. The presence of long-range forces could significantly influence the kinetics of self-assembly and the mechanical strength of nanoparticulate systems, an aspect which is not yet well studied. We address this problem in the present study using three-dimensional Distinct Element Method (DEM) simulations. We simulate the self-assembly of nanoparticulate systems by considering some of the most commonly used interparticle force-separation relationships. The strength of the interparticle forces are chosen in such a way that the maximum pull-off force acting between the particles is the same, while the nature of the forces acting between the particles depends on the particular type of model used (i.e. electrostatic, van der Waals and JKR). Organically coated copper nanoparticles are chosen as a model material in this study.
2.2 Computer Simulations 2.2.1 Distinct Element Method Distinct Element Method (DEM) is a computer simulation technique (Cundall and Strack 1979) that treats particles individually by assigning them specific physical (e.g. density and size) and material properties (e.g. elastic modulus, friction, Poisson’s ratio) and describing their motion by using Newton’s law. DEM was created by Cundall and Strack [7] to describe rock mechanics problems. Since then this technique has become increasingly popular [24] and has been used in many different disciplines such as food science [6] and particle technology [3, 21], the latter one being the most popular of them. DEM works cyclically and therefore the state of the system is updated each time step. During a time step particle forces and therefore accelerations are considered to remain constant. Particles positions are calculated according to Newton’s Law and using an explicit finite difference scheme. The time step chosen should be smaller than the time needed by Rayleigh waves to propagate from a given point in a particle to the diametrical opposite point of the particle [14]. The equation of motion used in the simulation is an extension of the Langevin equation including terms for contact forces (elasticity, damping and friction) and long range forces (van der Waals, electrostatic). Therefore, the motion equation for a particle of mass, m, can be written in the form: m
d 2x = FContact + FLong range + FBrownian + FDrag dt 2
(2.1)
where x is the particle position vector which is calculated by the double integration of the net forces acting on the particle.
12
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
In our simulations the attractive interactions between particles are governed by theories of contact mechanics (JKR model for cohesive particles) and long range interaction forces (electrostatic and van der Waals forces) depending on the specific case.
2.2.2 Interparticle Forces 2.2.2.1 Contact Forces If within any given time step the position of two particles is such that the particles overlap, the overlap distance is considered as an effective particle deformation. The particle deformation is estimated as the difference of the distance between particle centres and the sum of the radii of the particles. From the value of deformation obtained from the relative particle positions the applied force can be estimated by using Hertz Law as [14]: 4 (2.2) PN = E ∗1/2 R∗1/2 δ 3/2 3 where R∗ and E ∗ are the reduced particle radius and elastic modulus which are defined as a function of the individual particle radii, R1 and R2 , and elastic moduli, E1 and E2 , of the two particles in contact:
1 (1 − ν12) (1 − ν22) = + E∗ E1 ∗ E2 ∗
(2.3)
1 1 1 = ∗+ ∗ ∗ R R1 R2
(2.4)
If the model of Johnson, Kendall and Roberts (JKR) is used to model interparticle cohesion, the normal applied force, PN , in the contact is calculated through the stiffness of the contact according to the expression provided by Thornton and Yin [29]: 1/2 a3 ∗ 2E a 3 − 3 aC3 ∆PN kN = = (2.5) 1/2 ∆δ 3 aC 3 − a3 with aC being
3PADH R∗ (2.6) 4E ∗ where PADH is the adhesion force and is equal to the negative of the pull-off force, POFF or force required to break a contact. According to the JKR model [15] the pull-off force or force required to break the contact between two particles is given by: aC3 =
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
POFF = −PADH = −3πγ R∗
13
(2.7)
where γ is the surface energy or energy per particle and unit area required to separate two particles by an infinite distance [13]. If a tangential traction is acting on the particle and the particle cohesion is defined by the JKR model [15], then the model of Savkoor and Briggs [26] is used to calculate the contact area radius between the particles (see [28] for more details about the tangential deformation model).
2.2.2.2 Long Range Forces Two types of long range forces have been selected to simulate the attractive interaction between particles: electrostatic forces in air and van der Waals forces. These forces decay with distance in different ways. Electrostatic forces decay with the square of the distance between particle centres. However, Van der Waals forces decay with the square of the distance between particle surfaces and therefore they decay faster with distance than the electrostatic forces. Figure 2.1 shows a schematic diagram of the way in which the interparticle forces between two particles, each of 100 nm in diameter, decay with distance. The value of the dispersion of the Brownian forces used in the simulations of the JKR model (see below) and the particle weight has been added for comparison. The van der Waals force equation is given by Hamaker [9] and vastly used in the literature [2]. The exact van der Waals equation given by Hamaker [9] has been implemented in the simulation using in this work. However, when the separation distance between particles, d, is much smaller than the particle size, the van der Waals force FV dW reduces to:
Fig. 2.1 Schematic diagram of the decay of electrostatic and van der Waals forces with the distance between the centres of two particles of 100 nm in diameter. The average particle weight and the value of the standard deviation of the Brownian forces used in the simulations have been added for comparison
14
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
FV dW = −
HR∗ 6d 2
(2.8)
Since Eq. (2.8) tends to infinity when the separation distance between the surfaces of the two particles tends to zero an experimentally determined minimum cut-off distance dmin is assigned equal to four Angstroms [17, 18]. In order to compute the force between two particles, the volume around each particle is scanned at a maximum distance of 400 nm. At this distance the value of the van der Waals forces has already decayed around five orders of magnitude for the properties of the particles used in this work. The electrostatic forces have been simulated using Coulomb’s expression and assuming that the particles have a constant absolute value of surface charge density. Therefore the force between two particles of radii R1 and R2 whose centres are separated a distance, r, is given by: FElec =
1 4πσ 2 R1 R2 ε0 r2
(2.9)
where σ is the surface charge density, ε0 is the permittivity of the vacuum and the minus sign corresponds to the case in which the two particles have opposite charges. In order to compute the electrostatic force between two particles the space around each particle is scanned at a maximum distance of 1 µm (10 particle diameters). At this distance the electrical force between two particles has decayed to a value of around 1% of the value when the two particles are in contact (Fig. 2.1).
2.2.2.3 Brownian Forces The Brownian forces are commonly used to describe the random motion of particles suspended in fluids [8, 11, 23]. However, their use in the present work is not to simulate directly a fluid environment but to induce collision between nanoparticles in the system in which the JKR model (cohesive contact force model) was used. The average value of the Brownian forces is zero and their dispersion is given by Eq. (2.10) for the simulations presented here. < F(t)2 > =
1.55x10−22R ∆t
(2.10)
2.2.3 Simulation Details Three different systems have been considered to study the effect of the interparticle interaction on the kinetics of self-assembly and mechanical strength. Each of them is made of 5,858 spherical particles whose sizes follow a Gaussian distribution with a mean value of 100 nm (Table 2.1). The material properties are given in Table 2.2 and they correspond to copper.
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
15
Table 2.1 Particle size distribution
Particle size (µm)
Frequency
80 85 90 95 97 100 103 105 110 115 120
44 172 458 823 932 1,000 932 823 458 172 44
Table 2.2 Material properties Material property
Value
Density (kg/m3 ) Elastic modulus (GPa) Poisson’s ratio () Friction () Surface energy (J/m2 ) Hamaker constant (J) Surface charge density (C/m2 )
8,930 120 0.35 0.3 0.044 40 × 10−20 0.0034
At the beginning of the simulations the particles are randomly positioned within a prescribed working cubical space and elastic boundaries are set up. The initial particles velocities are set to zero. Once the particles have been randomly positioned within the working space, the motion of the particles is initiated by the action of the long range interparticle forces as described in electrostatic, van der Waals or coupled JKR and Brownian force models. In each system the aggregation has been produced by the influence of a different kind of interaction. In the first case, the particles aggregate only when they come into contact and follow the JKR model [15]. In the second case, the self-assembly is produced by van der Waals forces with the value of Hamaker constant for Cu in air. In the third case particles are considered to have a constant surface charge density where half of the particles are positively charged and the other half negatively charged. In order to be able to compare the three cases, the value of pull-off force between particles is kept identical. Thus, by equating Eqs. (2.7) and (2.8) an expression for the surface energy can be obtained in the form:
γ=
H 18π d 2
(2.11)
Therefore, the value of γ obtained using Eq. (2.11) is 0.044 J/m2 (Table 2.2).
16
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
For the system in which electrical forces are being used the equivalent charge density can be obtained by equating Eqs. (2.8) and (2.9).
σ2 = ±
ε0 H 24π d 2R∗
(2.12)
Therefore, an equivalent value of σ equal to 0.0034 C/m2 is obtained by using Eq. (2.12) and considering a mean particle diameter of 100 nm.
2.3 Simulation Results 2.3.1 Self-Assembly of Copper Nanoparticles Figure 2.2 shows the evolution of the average coordination number as a function of time. It can be seen that the electrostatic forces produce the fastest increase in coordination number until reaching a plateau value which is very similar to the case in which van der Waals forces are acting. However, the self-assembly in the presence of the Brownian forces is the slowest of all cases. The origin for these differences is attributed to the way in which these forces decay with distance. Electrostatic forces decay slower than van der Waals forces. Finally, Brownian forces are random in direction and magnitude and therefore it can be considered that their interaction range is virtually null. The slower the forces decay with distance the faster the selfassembly process is. Figure 2.3 shows the time evolution of the size of the largest fragment in the system as defined by the ratio of the number of particles contained in the fragment, N(t), to the total number of particles in the system, N0 . During the first stages of the
Fig. 2.2 Evolution of the coordination number with time for the three assemblies
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
17
Fig. 2.3 Evolution of the size of the largest fragment in the system for the three systems studied
simulation the size of the largest fragment varies very slowly with time, however a rapid increases in the size of this fragment is observed until a steady state value is achieved. In addition, particles aggregate faster in the system in which electrical forces are acting between particles. However, the slowest self-assembly process corresponds to the case in which the JKR model coupled with Brownian forces has been used. These results corroborate the correlation between the kinetics of selfassembly and the way in which the interparticle forces decay with distance as has already been shown for Fig. 2.2. It has also been observed that in the three systems studied here the size of the second largest fragment never contained more than 10% of the total number of particles in the system. This indicates that the self-assembly process occurs by addition of small clusters to the largest cluster rather than by collision of clusters of similar sizes. It is worth mentioning that in the assembly in which electrical forces are operating, particles of opposite charges come together to form the aggregate as could be expected. This phenomenon can be seen when the pair correlation function is determined as given in Eq. (2.13). g(r) =
V n(r) 4π r2 N∆r
(2.13)
Where n(r) is the mean number of particles within a shell of width ∆ r at a distance r from the origin, V is the volume of the system and N is the number of particles in the system. Figure 2.4 shows the g(r), or pair correlation function, for the assembly with electrical forces and for the cases of particles with the same charges, particles with opposite charges and for all the particles in the system. The g(r) for particles with opposite charges show its first maximum at around 100 nm and the g(r) for particles with the same charges has its first maximum at around 150 nm. The
18
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
Fig. 2.4 Pair correlation function, g(r), of the particles in the system in which electrical forces are acting. The plot contains the g(r) function for particles with opposite sign of the charges, for particles with the same sign of the charges and for all the particles in the system Table 2.3 Comparison of the final states of the self-assemblies Assembly
Pack. fract.
Coord. no.
Mean stress (kPa)
0.20 0.24 0.24
2.13 4.32 4.27
4.0 350 146
JKR model Van der Waals force model Electrical force model
g(r) that considers all particles in the system shows the maxima of the curves corresponding to the same and the opposite charges as would be expected. Since the average particle diameter is 100 nm it is clear that each particle tries to surround itself by particles with the opposite charge. This characteristic suggests that despite the fact that the particles have been randomly positioned, and therefore each particle should have the same number of neighbours with similar and opposite charges, during the self-assembly process a segregation of the material occurs. This segregation makes each particle to be only surrounded by particles with opposite charges. Table 2.3 shows a comparison of packing fraction, coordination number and value of the mean stress (σ11 + σ22 + σ33 )/3, in the assemblies. The stresses have been determined using the expression as given by Satake [25]:
σi j =
2 V
M
2
M
∑ RNni n j + V ∑ RT nit j 1
(2.14)
1
where Rni is the i component of the radius vector of the centre of the particle to the contact, Nni and T t j are the i and j components of the normal and tangential contact forces, respectively and M is the number of interparticle contacts. The sum of the forces in each contact of the assembly is divided by the volume of the assembly, V , and therefore the information is given on the whole state of the stress of the system.
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
19
The assemblies in which long range forces are acting are better packed and their coordination number and the value of the mean stress are larger than the assembly in which the interparticle interaction is given by the JKR model (Table 2.3).
2.3.2 Analysis of the Mechanical Strength of Self-Assemblies In order to analyse the mechanical strength, the unconfined yield stress (UYS) of the assemblies has been determined. Each assembly was placed in between elastic platens at the top and bottom surfaces as schematically shown in Fig. 2.5. The side boundaries were removed and the top platen was moved downwards. The number of interparticle contacts and the force on the platen were monitored during the compression process. The sample was considered to have failed when a sharp peak on the platen force accompanied by a significant drop in the number of contacts was observed. The force at this point divided by the platen area was taken as the UYS. The UYS was determined for different velocities of the platen. Figure 2.6 shows the UYS for values of compression velocities between 1 and 20 m/s. The UYS seems to be larger in the system in which the particles interact using the JKR model and smaller in the system in which electrostatic forces were used. However, these differences in the values of UYS are smaller for large values of compression velocities. As the compression velocity is reduced the differences in UYS between the three systems increases. Amongst the possible reasons for the low value of UYS in the assembly with electrical forces could be found in the attractive/repulsive nature of these forces. This dual nature can make neighbouring particles decrease the net strength of the system with respect to the other assemblies in which the interparticle forces are always attractive. For values of compression velocity smaller than 1 m/s no peak was found during uniaxial compression or in the best of cases only a very small peak accompanied with a very small drop in the number of interparticle contacts occurred. In contrast, the number of interparticle contacts increased with time during compression indicating a continuous deformation of the material. Therefore, no data are shown in Fig. 2.6 for values of compression velocities lower than 1 m/s.
Fig. 2.5 Schematic diagram of the compression of the assemblies
20
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
Fig. 2.6 Evolution of the unconfined yield stress for the three assemblies
Fig. 2.7 Evolution of the contact ratio and force on the top platen as a function of the strain during uniaxial compression at the value of velocity of 5 m/s for the assemblies in which (a) the JKR model has been used, (b) van der Waals forces are acting (c) electrical forces are acting
As an example we show the force and contact ratio versus strain curves at the value of compression velocity of 5 m/s for the three assemblies (Fig. 2.7). It can be seen that despite the fact that the values of UYS are not drastically different, the failure occurs at very different values of strain. In addition, the drop in the number of interparticle contacts is similar for the case of the assemblies in which the JKR model has been used and the one with van der Waals interactions (around 20%
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
21
Fig. 2.8 Evolution of the work carried out during uniaxial compression at the value of velocity of 1 and 5 m/s for the assemblies in which (a) the JKR model has been used, (b) the van der Waals forces are acting (c) the electrical forces are acting
drop in the number of interparticle contacts). However, the drop at peak strength is slightly larger for the assemblies in which electrical forces have been considered. Figure 2.8 presents the work done for producing the failure of the assemblies for a value of compression velocity of 1 and 5 m/s. The work has been obtained by integrating the curve of force versus displacement of the platen. The work required to produce the failure of the aggregates increases with the compression speed. The work obtained for the assembly in which electrostatic forces are acting between particles is more than one order of magnitude higher than the work obtained in the assembly in which the interaction is defined by the JKR model. Therefore, it is clear that the longer the range of the interaction, the larger the work required to produce the failure of the assembly.
2.4 Discussion We have presented a comparative analysis of the influence of the types of interactions on the self-assembly and mechanical strength of particulate solids. Three cases have been considered. In the first case a contact interaction force as defined by the JKR model coupled with Brownian force has been used. In the other two cases, long
22
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
range forces have been considered based on van der Waals and electrostatic force models. However, van der Waals forces have a shorter range of interaction than the electrostatic forces since they decay faster with the distance between particles. Therefore, the effective range of the forces decreases in the following order: electrostatic, van der Waals and JKR-Brownian model. These interactions can be controlled in experiments by using different coatings for the inorganic molecules and therefore creating nanocomposites made of organic and inorganic components [4]. We presented results on the influence of these interactions on the bulk mechanical strength of Cu nanoparticulate aggregates. First of all, we should consider that the JKR model and the van der Waals forces are two different ways of accounting for the cohesion between particles. However, the use of these two models for simulating self-assembly and mechanical strength produces drastic differences. The self-assembly process is very slow and the final coordination number and the value of the mean stress are much lower in the case in which the JKR-Brownian model has been used (Fig. 2.2). It is obvious that the self–assembly behaviour is significantly influenced by the long-range force acting between nanoparticles. In addition, the way in which elasticity and cohesion are described in the system in which the JKR model has been used and the system in which van der Waals forces were used is different. In the former the deformation between particles is based on an energy balance of elastic, mechanical and cohesion energy as described by the JKR model. In the latter case elasticity and cohesion are considered as the arithmetic sum of the elastic force (as defined by the Hertz model) and the attractive van der Waals force. Although there are some ways of combining the JKR model and the van der Waals forces, a deeper analysis of the influence of the use of these models on the self-assembly and mechanical strength of nanocomposites is needed. A comparison with experimental results is also required. When we compare the self-assembly of nanoparticles in the system modelled using electrical forces with the system in which van der Waals forces were used, we observe that the self-assembly is slightly faster than in the former case than in the latter case although the final coordination number and value of contact stresses are similar. The self-assembly properties for system in which cohesion is represented by the JKR model coupled with Brownian forces drastically differ from other models used here. In the case of system with electrical force, the self-assembly process is about three orders of magnitude faster than in the case of JKR-Brownian model based simulations. It is worth mentioning on the lack of a clear quasi-static regime for low values of compression velocity – only continuous deformation of the aggregates was observed at very low compression velocities. This could be due to two factors: a low level of consolidation and the nature of the interparticle interaction. If the compression rate is small and the level of consolidation is also small the particles can produce permanent deformation of the material, forming a new bond or by simply sliding over another particle. With a higher level of consolidation or a high strain rate the particles would not have so much space or time, respectively, to find a new position and the material would accumulate stresses until the bulk failure is produced. Finally, the most important difference that has been shown for the mechanical strength of
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
23
the assemblies is the difference in the value of work required to produce the failure of the assemblies. Therefore, the work required to break the assembly with electrical forces is around 40 times larger than the work required for producing the failure of the assembly in which the cohesion is based on the JKR theory. The larger the range of the interparticle forces, the larger the distance that the particles need to be separated for the interaction with other particles to cease and therefore the larger the work needed to produce the failure of the assembly. However, a more detailed analysis of the influence of the range of the interparticle forces on the crashing stress of the particles is needed.
2.5 Conclusions We have presented a comparative analysis of the influence of van der Waals forces, electrostatic forces and interparticle adhesion as described by the JKR model, on the self-assembly and mechanical properties of Cu nanoparticulate aggregates by using computational modelling. The fastest rate of particle self-assembly as well as the highest values of number of contacts per particle are seen in the assemblies in which long range interparticle forces are acting (electrostatic and van der Waals forces). In contrast, the assembly in which the JKR model has been used produces a structure with a very low coordination number as a consequence of the short range of the cohesive interaction. In addition, the work required to produce the failure of the assemblies also depends on the type of interparticle interaction. The slower the interparticle forces decay with distance, the larger the work required to produce the mechanical failure of the self-assemblies. The generic approach adopted here links the interparticle forces to the bulk strength of the self-assembled aggregates. However, a more detailed study of the relationship between the work to produce the failure of the system and the range of interparticle interactions at the quasi-static conditions is needed in the future. The methodology presented here aids the control of interparticle interactions which is needed to create new nanocomposite materials with a specific level of strength. Acknowledgements We gratefully acknowledge EPSRC (EP/D027411/1) and MiMeMip, UK for their support to this work.
References 1. Aggeli A, Bell M, Carrick LM, Fishwick CWG, Harding R, Mawer PJ, Radford SE, Strong AE, Boden N (2003) pH as a trigger of peptide β-sheet self-assembly and reversible switching between nematic and isotropic phases. J Am Chem Soc 125: 9619–9628 2. Anderson MT, Lu N (2001) Role of microscopic physicochemical forces in large volumetric strains for clay sediments. J Eng Mech 127: 710–719
24
R. Moreno-Atanasio et al.
3. Antony SJ, Sultan M (2007) Role of inter-particle forces and inter-particle friction on the bulk friction in charged granular media subjected to shearing. Phys Rev E 75: 031307 4. Boal A, Gray M, Illhan F, Clavier G, Kapitzsky L, Rotello V (2002) Bricks and mortar selfassembly of nanoparticles. Tetrahedron 58: 765–770 5. Bose K, Moreno-Atanasio R, Antony SJ, Ding Y, Biggs SR, Ghadiri M (2005) Direct Measurement of the effect of adhesion on powder flow behaviour: experimental and DEM investigations. In: Garc´ıa-Rojo R, Hermann HJ, McNamara S (eds) Powder and Grains, vol 1. Taylor & Francis, London, pp. 555–558 6. Cordelair J, Greil P (2004) Discrete Element modeling of solid formation during electrophoretic deposition. J Mater Sci 39: 1017–1021 7. Cundall PA, Strack ODL (1979) A discrete numerical model for granular assemblies. Geotechnique, 29: 47–65 8. Foss DR, Brady JF (2000), Brownian dynamics simulation of hard-sphere colloidal dispersions. J Rheol 44(3): 629–651 9. Hamaker HC (1937), The London-Van der Waals attraction between spherical particles. Physica IV 10: 1058–1072 10. Han L, Luo J, Kariuki NN, Maye MM, Jones VW, Zhong CJ (2003) Novel Interparticle Spatial Properties of Hydrogen-Bonding mediated nanoparticle assembly. Chem Mater 15: 29–37 11. Heyes DM, Branka AC (1994) Brownian Dynamics simulations of self-diffusion and shear viscosity of near-hard sphere colloids. Phys Rev E 50: 2377–2380 12. Hong CW (1998) From long range interaction to solid-body contact between colloidal surfaces during forming. J Eur Ceram Soc 18: 2159–2167 13. Israelachvili J (1985) Intermolecular and Surface Forces. Academic, London 14. Johnson KL (1985) Contact Mechanics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 15. Johnson KL, Kendall K, Roberts AD (1971) Surface energy and the contact of elastic solids. P Roy Soc Lond A 324: 301–313 16. Kotsilkova R (2005) Processing-structure-properties relationships of mechanically and thermally enhanced smectite/epoxy nanocomposites. J Appl Polym Sci 97: 2499–2510 17. Kuhle A, Sorensen AH, Oddershede LB, Busch H, Theil Hansen L, Bohr J (1997) Scaling in patterns produced by cluster deposition. Z Phys D 40: 523–525 18. Lee JM, Curran C, Watkins KG (2001) Laser removal particles from silicon wafers using UV, visible and IR radiation. Appl Phys A 73: 219–224 19. Martin CL, Bouvard D (2004) Isostatic compaction of bimodal powder mixtures and composites. Int J Mech Sci 46: 907–927 20. Martin CL, Bouvard D (2006) Discrete Element Simulations of the Compaction of Aggregated ceramic Powders. J Am Chem Soc 89: 3379–3387 21. Moreno-Atanasio R, Antony SJ, Ghadiri M (2005) Analysis of the flowability of cohesive powders using Distinct Element Method. Powder Technol 158: 51–57 22. Munjiza A, Latham JP (2004) Comparison of experimental and FEM/DEM results for gravitational deposition of identical cubes. Eng. Computation 21: 249–264 23. Pugnaloni LA, Ettelaie R, Dickinson E (2005) Brownian dynamics simulation of adsorbed layers of interacting particles subjected to large extensional deformations. J Colloid Interf Sci 287: 401–414 24. Richards K, Bithell M, Dove M, Hodge R (2004) Discrete-element Modelling: methods and applications in environmental sciences. Phil Trans Roy Soc A 362: 1797–1816 25. Satake M (1982) Fabric Tensor in granular materials. In: IUTAM Conference in Deformation and Failure of granular Materials, Delft, The Netherlands, pp 63–68 26. Savkoor AR, Briggs GAD (1977) The effect of the tangential force on the contact of elastic solids in adhesion. Proc Roy Soc Lond A 356: 103–114 27. Scocchi G, Posocco P, Fermeglia M, Pricl S (2007) Polymer-Clay Nanocomposites: A Multiscale Molecular Modeling Approach. J Phys Chem B 111: 2143–2151 28. Thornton C, Randall CW (1988) Applications of theoretical contact mechanics to solid particle system simulation. In: Stake M, Jenkins JT (eds) Micromechanics of Granular Materials. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 133–142
2 Equilibrium and Kinetic Properties of Self-Assembled Cu Nanoparticles
25
29. Thornton C, Yin KK (1991), Impact of elastic spheres with and without adhesion. Powder Technol 65: 153–166 30. Vezenov DV, Noy A, Rozsnyai LF, Lieber CM (1997) Force titration and ionization State sensitive imaging of functional groups in aqueous solutions by Chemical Force Microscopy. J Am Chem Soc 119: 2006–2015
Chapter 3
Method of Continuous Source Functions for Modelling of Matrix Reinforced by Finite Fibres ˇ Vladim´ır Kompiˇs, M´ario Stiavnick´ y, Mari´an Kompiˇs, Zuzana Murˇcinkov´a, and Qing-Hua Qin
Abstract Fibres are the most effective reinforcing material. Simulation of the interaction of matrix with fibres and fibre with other fibres is a most important problem for understanding the behaviour of fibre-reinforced composites (FRC). Large gradients in all displacement, stress and strain fields and their correct simulation for near and far field action are essential for effective computational modelling. Because of the large aspect ratios in fibre type reinforcing particles, methods using volume discretization are not efficient. Source functions (forces, dipoles, dislocations) describe correctly both near and far field activities and thus help to simulate all interactions very precisely. The method of continuous source functions allows us to satisfy the continuity of fields between very stiff fibres and much more flexible matrix by 1D continuous functions along the fibre axis and local 2D functions in the end parts of a fibre with only few parameters. Two types of examples with rows of non-overlapping sheets of fibre and with overlapping fibres show that the interaction of the end parts of fibres is crucial for evaluation of the mutual interaction of fibres in the composite. Correct simulation of all parts is important for evaluation of stiffness and strength of the FRC. ˇ Vladim´ır Kompiˇs and M´ario Stiavnick´ y ˇ anik, Liptovsk´y Mikul´asˇ, Department of Academy of the Armed Forces of General M.R. Stef´ Mechanical Engineering, Slovak Republic
[email protected] Mari´an Kompiˇs ˇ Siemens Program and System Engineering s.r.o., 01001 Zilina, Slovakia
[email protected] Zuzana Murˇcinkov´a Department of Technical Devices Design, Faculty of Manufacturing Technologies of Technical University Koˇsice with seat in Preˇsov, Slovakia
[email protected] Qing-Hua Qin Department of Engineering, Australian National University, Canberra ACT 0200, Australia
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
27
28
V. Kompiˇs et al.
3.1 Introduction Composites of the future will offer many advances over those in use today. Composite materials reinforced by fibres are important materials possessing excellent mechanical and also thermal and electro-magnetic properties. The outstanding properties of mechanical strength of carbon nano-tubes (CNT) are well known. This allows them to be used as possible reinforcing materials [1]. Reinforcement with nano-tubes facilitates the production of very strong and light materials. These properties of CNTs have attracted the attention of scientists all over the world. Understanding the behaviour of such composite materials is essential for structural design. Computational simulations play an important role in this process [25]. In computational simulations, boundary-type solution methodologies are now well established as alternatives to prevailing domain-type methods such as FEM [3, 33], because of the computational advantages they offer by way of reduction of dimensionality, good accuracy for the whole domain, and simplicity of data preparation for the model. The BEM [2, 5] is the most popular and efficient boundary solution procedure, formulated in terms of boundary integral equations (BIEs). In BEM the integral identities are applied over elements discretizing the boundary of the domain. However, the use of elements in the BEM, with evaluation of weakly singular, strongly singular, hyper-singular and quasi-singular integrals, is a cumbersome and non-trivial task. The integration of elements containing singularity requires special integration models. If a singularity is close to the element (i.e. the element with quasi-singularity), then the integrals with large gradients in points closest to the singularity must be computed by high order quadratures, or by another special technique in order to obtain good accuracy. The boundary contour method (BCM) [20, 22] represents an effort to improve efficiency by transferring the surface integrals into line integrals by application of Stokes’ theorem for 3D problems. The boundary node method (BNM) [21, 32] is a combination of the moving least squares (MLS) approximation scheme and the standard BIE method. This method divorces the traditional coupling between spatial discretization (meshing) and interpolation as commonly practised in the FEM or in the BEM. Instead, a “diffuse” approximation, based on MLS approximants, is used to represent the unknown functions and surface cells, with a very flexible structure used for integration. Thus, the BNM belongs with boundary meshless methods. Using the virtual boundary method and radial basis functions (RBF), the boundary point collocation method has been proposed to construct a boundary meshless formulation [29, 31], in which the boundary conditions and body forces are enforced and coupled with the analogue equation method to construct a boundary-type meshless method for analysing nonlinear problems [30]. Hybrid-Trefftz methods [8, 12, 15, 27] are also boundary-type methods. They use a set of trial functions, singular or non-singular, which a priori satisfy the corresponding linear part of the governing differential equation inside the (sub)domain
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
29
(the large element). Other independent functions maintain the continuity between the subdomains (in a weak and strong sense). The method of fundamental solutions (MFS) [9, 14] is a boundary meshless method which does not need any mesh. In linear problems, only nodes (collocation points) on the domain boundaries and a set of source functions (fundamental solutions) in points outside the domain are necessary to satisfy the boundary conditions. MFS has certain advantages over the BEM, as it completely avoids the need for any integral evaluation and it leads to very simple formulations in some problems. However, large numbers of both collocation points and source functions are necessary if the shape of the domain is complex and moreover, the resulting system of equations is bad conditioned in some problems. The source functions serve as the trial functions and must be placed outside the domain. The location of the source functions is vital to both the accuracy and the numerical stability of the solution. The MFS can be also included among Trefftz-type methods. A novel boundary-type meshless method – the boundary point method (BPM) was developed in [18]. The BPM is based on the direct formulation of conventional and hypersingular BIEs employing favourable features of both the MFS and BEM. It is well known that for the integration of kernel functions over boundary elements, the shorter the distance between the source and field points, the more difficult it is to evaluate them accurately because of the properties of the fundamental solutions. In the formulation, “moving elements” are introduced by organizing relevant adjacent nodes in order to describe the local features of a boundary such as position, curvature and direction, over which the treatment of singularity and integration can be carried out, a benefit not only for the evaluation of integrals in the case of coincidence points, but also for the versatility afforded by using unequally spaced nodes along the boundary. In special problems like composite materials reinforced with short micro-/ nanofibres, all the methods mentioned above require very many elements or boundary points to obtain a sufficiently accurate solution. In such problems the materials of the matrix and fibres have very different electro-magneto-thermo-mechanical properties and very large gradients are present in all fields in matrix and in fibres as well. Domain formulations also require billions of equations after numerical discretization to simulate the decaying effects with increasing distance from the fibre and the gradients along the boundaries. Boundary formulations can simulate the decaying effect well, but they also require a large number of equations to simulate the large gradients on the inter-domain boundaries. Both near and far field effects are important. Near field effects are important for evaluation of the strength of the composite and far fields are important for correct evaluation of the stiffening effect. The fast multi-pole method (FMM) [11] was developed to increase the efficiency of numerical models. A FMM based on the Taylor expansion of kernel functions (the fast multipole boundary integral equation method (FMBIEM)) [7, 10, 19, 23, 24, 26] was developed to solve the problem of composite materials reinforced by many small particles, considerably accelerating BEM solutions. However, near field integrals still have to be solved by classical BEM and the boundaries are also discretized by elements.
30
V. Kompiˇs et al.
In this paper, a novel method of continuous source functions (MCSF) for the modelling of problems such as composites reinforced with short fibres is presented. The source functions (forces and dipoles [4]) are continuously distributed along the fibre axis (i.e. outside of the domain) and their intensity is modelled by 1D quadratic elements along the axis. Moreover, 2D distribution of the source functions are used to satisfy the continuity in the end part of the fibre. The method can be included among BPMs, as inter-domain continuity is satisfied in the discrete points of the inter-domain boundary in the least squares (LS) sense. The model presents a significant reduction (even by several orders) in the resulting system of equations compared to FEM, BEM, and other known mesh reducing methods. The MCFS requires integration over 1D and 2D elements. Analytic integration using symbolic manipulation is used for evaluation of the quasi-singular integrals occurring in the models, and it is a very efficient tool for the evaluation of such integrals. Numerical integration is used for 2D elements because of complex form of the integrands. Recently a procedure of improved efficiency for such problems was also developed [18]. If the source domain and the field point (e.g. the collocation point) are far from each other, the source values can be replaced by their resulting value and the computation is again considerably reduced. The effect is similar to that used in the FMBIEM but the algebraic manipulation is simpler, based on the principles of mechanics in this case instead of the Taylor expansion used in FMBIEM. The model is applied to simulation of the interaction of matrix-fibre-fibre for regularly distributed straight fibres in a patch inside the matrix. Two different problems are studied: (1) fibres distributed in rows without overlap of the fibres and (2) with overlap of the fibres.
3.2 Modelling of Composite Material Reinforced with Short Fibers Let us consider a linear elastic material reinforced by regularly distributed “short” straight fibres. Let the cross sectional dimensions of a fibre be much smaller than its length, the tensional (axial) stiffness of the fibre is much higher than the stiffness of the matrix and ideal cohesion between the matrix and the fibres is assumed in the present model. Then a continuity condition between the matrix and a fibre can be introduced by zero strains (rigid fibre) in the longitudinal direction along the fibre boundary and by zero difference of the displacements in each pair of points on opposite fibre boundaries in the perpendicular direction to the fibre axis. If the fibres are straight then an alternative continuity condition can be expressed by the difference between displacements of a point on the fibre surface and a point in the middle cross-section along the fibre axis. All displacement, strain and stress fields are split into a homogeneous part corresponding to constant stress and strain acting in the matrix without the fibres and local fields corresponding to the stiffening effect. For simplicity, isotropic material properties are assumed in this paper.
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
31 fibre
distributed forces and dipoles
x3
Fig. 3.1 Fibre-matrix interaction simulated by source functions placed inside the fibre (the numbers indicate 1D elements)
The interaction of the matrix and a fibre is simulated by source functions placed inside the fibre along its axis. The source functions are continuous forces and dipoles (Fig. 3.1) acting outside the domain (matrix). The field of displacements in an elastic continuum caused by a unit force acting in the direction of the axis x p is given by the Kelvin solution as it is known from BEM [2, 5, 6] 1 1 (F) [(3 − 4ν ) δip + r,i r,p ] (3.1) U pi = 16π G (1 − ν ) r where i denotes the xi coordinate of the displacement, G and ν are shear modulus and Poisson’s ratio of the material of the matrix. δij is the Kronecker’s delta and r is the distance between the source point s, where the force is acting and a field point t, where the displacement is expressed, i.e. r=
√
ri ri , ri = xi (t) − xi (s)
with the summation convention over repeated indices and r,i = ∂ r ∂ xi (t) = ri r
(3.2)
(3.3)
is its directional derivative. The gradients of the displacement fields are the corresponding derivatives of the field (3.1) at the point t (F)
U pi, j = −
1 1 [(3 − 4ν ) δ pi r, j − δ p j r,i − δi j r,p + 3r,i r, j r,p ] 16π G (1 − ν ) r2
The second derivative of nth power of the radius vector is defined as n n n−1 n n r,k , j = r,k r = δ − r r , j ,k jk j r ,k
(3.4)
(3.5)
32
V. Kompiˇs et al.
The strains are (F)
E pi j =
1 1 1 (F) (F) U pi, j + U p j,i = − 2 16π G (1 − ν ) r2
[(1 − 2ν ) (δ pi r, j + δ p j r,i ) − δi j r,p + 3r,i r, j r,p ]
(3.6)
and the stress components ij of this field are (F)
(F)
S pi j = 2GE pi j +
1 2Gν 1 (F) δi j E pkk = 1 − 2ν 8π (1 − ν ) r2
[(1 − 2ν ) (δi j r,p − δ j p r,i − δipr, j ) − 3r,i r, j r,p ]
(3.7)
The displacement field of a dipole can be obtained from the displacement field of a force by differentiating it in the direction of the acting force, i.e. (D)
(F)
U pi = U pi,p = −
1
1 2 3r,i r,p − r,i + 2 (1 − ν ) r,p δip 2 16π G (1 − ν ) r
(3.8)
The summation convention does not apply over the repeated indices p here or in the following relations. Recall that the derivatives in the direction perpendicular (see, Eq. (3.4)) to the force define a force couple [4, 13], which can be also used in some problems. These derivatives have the physical meaning of corresponding couples of forces acting at a point. The gradients of a dipole displacement field (3.8) are (D)
U pi, j = −
1
1 2 −15r,i r, j r,p + 3r,i r, j 16π G (1 − ν ) r3
2 +2 (1 − 2ν ) δip (δ j p − 3r, j r,p ) + 6r,i r,p δ j p + δi j 3r,p −1
(3.9)
and corresponding strain and stress fields are 1 1 1 (D) (D) (D) U pi, j + U p j,i = − E pi j = [−15r,i r, j r,p + 3r,i r, j 2 16π G (1 − ν ) r3 + 2 (1 − 2ν ) δip δ j p + 6ν (δip r, j r,p + δ j pr,i r,p ) 2 + δi j 3r,p −1 ] (3.10) (D)
2Gν 1 1
(D) 2 δi j − δi j (1 − 2ν ) 2δip δ jp + 3r,p δi j E pkk = − 1 − 2ν 8π (1 − ν ) r3 2 (3.11) r,i r, j ] + 6ν r,p (r,i δ jp + r, j δip ) + 3 1 − 5r,p (D)
S pi j = 2GE pi j +
If unit forces acting at source points (i.e. the fundamental solution satisfying the homogeneous equilibrium equations in the whole domain with the exception of the source point alone) are located in discrete points outside the solution domain for computational models, and also the collocation points (i.e. the points at which the boundary conditions have to be satisfied) are chosen at some discrete points
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
33
of the domain boundary, then the method of solution is known as the method of fundamental solutions (MFS) [9, 14]. This method is very simple. It does not need any elements or any integration and thus is a fully meshless method. These functions are Trefftz functions and they serve as interpolators in the whole domain. Note that any other Trefftz functions can be used for this purpose [15]. On the other hand, dipoles are very effective tools for the modelling of composites reinforced by spherical or ellipsoidal particles [16, 28], and if the density of particles is small a single triple dipole can very effectively simulate a particle. The efficiency of the model is higher than that using the FMBIEM [7, 10, 19, 23, 24, 26] as integration is not necessary. Note that a dipole located inside a particle, i.e. outside of the domain represented by the matrix, gives both zero resulting force and moment along the particle boundary and thus the global equilibrium is not destroyed by local errors, as it can be when using MFS [15]. However, the location of the source points is vital for the best simulation of continuity and equilibrium along interdomain boundaries. However, if the fibres are thin then satisfaction of continuity of displacements, strains and tractions on the surface between the matrix and fibres and corresponding displacements and strains along the fibre would require a very large number of source points to simulate the interaction. Moreover, in the end parts of a fibre the fields have very large gradients [17], which increases the difficulties with accuracy and numerical stability of the solution. In our models, continuous distribution of source points is used for simulation of the interaction. This method is here called the method of continuous source functions (MCSF). It is possible to use both distributed forces and distributed dipoles along the fibre axis (1D distribution) and oriented in the axis direction in the model. Their role is mainly to satisfy continuity in the fibre axis direction. Continuity in directions perpendicular to the fibre axis is served mainly by the continuous dipoles along the fibre axis, but directed perpendicularly to the fibre axis. Recall that continuously distributed dipoles are derivatives of continuously distributed forces. The ends of a fibre can be in the form of half spheres or cylinders. It is important to satisfy the boundary conditions (b. c.) in these parts also. Without taking these b. c. into account, the source functions located along the fibre axis can give incorrect results in evaluation of the stiffening effect. Special b. c. have to be specified for tube-type particles such as carbon nanotubes. Instead of displacements, zero tractions must be prescribed in such cases. The distribution is approximated by piecewise quadratic functions with C0 continuity between the elements. The following integrals need to be evaluated b a
p xns xs − x f m +r dxs = f x f 2 y2 + xs − x2f
(3.12)
where x is the coordinate along the fiber axis, the subscripts s and f denote the source and field point and exponents n, m, p and r are integer numbers. y is the distance of the field point from the axis. The integral (3.12) is transformed for better manipulation to
34
V. Kompiˇs et al. b+x f
n x + x f xp m
a+x f
(y2 + x2 ) 2 +r
dx = f x f
(3.13)
The integrands are quasi-singular with very large local gradients and they are evaluated analytically by symbolic manipulation in MATLAB. Quadratic elements were chosen as the best way of approximation by polynomial functions. It was found that they can better approximate the b. c., as the end parts of fibres transmit the largest forces from the matrix and it was preferable to use large gradients in these parts of fibres when small elements were used for the parts with large gradients than to use larger elements of high order polynomials. Although the integrals give large gradients at the ends of fibres, i.e. if x f → a, or x f → b, the C0 continuity of elements permits a smooth solution to be obtained.
3.3 Numerical Results and Discussion Two different problems were simulated in order to study the interaction of fibres with matrix and also the interaction of fibres: (1) a patch of non-overlapping rows of fibres as shown in Fig. 3.2, and (2) a patch of overlapping rows of fibres according to the Fig. 3.3. In the examples the modulus of elasticity of the matrix was E = 1,000 and the Poisson ratio ν = 0.3. The matrix was reinforced by a patch of straight rigid cylindrical fibres. The length of fibres was L = 100 and L = 1,000 and the radius x3
fibre of interest x1
D3 L
Fig. 3.2 Patch of non-overlapping rows of fibres
D1
BA
B
fibre of interest
BA
Fig. 3.3 Patch of overlapping rows of fibres
B
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
35
R = 1. The distance between fibres was ∆1 = ∆2 = ∆3 = 16 and for longer fibres also ∆3 = 200 in the fibre direction. The fibres in the patch contained approximately 1% of the volume of the composite material. The patches of fibres consisted of 5 × 5 × 7 fibres in the presented examples and the “fibre of interest” (FOI) was chosen in the centre to study the interaction of the fibre with matrix and with the other fibres as well. The domain is assumed to be loaded by far field stress σ33∞ = 10 in the direction (x3 ), which is also parallel to fibres’ axes. The model of the fibre used in these examples contained fewer than 100 unknown parameters (intensities of the source functions) and about 200 collocation points. The problem is solved by the least squares (LS) method. In order to reduce the number of unknown parameters it was assumed that the intensities of source functions are identical in all fibres. That is of course not correct, as the fibres at the patch boundaries will transmit larger loads than those in the middle. An iterative procedure can be used to correct the simulation. But for the purpose of quantitative evaluation of the influence of fibre reinforcement the models give sufficient information. Some results are presented in the next figures. All displacement, strain and stress fields given in the figures are the local components of corresponding fields. Recall that the far fields have to be added in to obtain the total quantities. Figures 3.4–3.10 show the local fields in the vicinity of the fibre of interest (the coordinates’ origin is in the middle of the fibre) for L = 1,000 R with overlay and the distance ∆3 = 200 R. Displacement differences of the points on the fibre boundary were linear along the fibre (Fig. 3.4). As the LS method was used in the procedure, the errors were examined as shown in Figs. 3.4 and 3.5. The circles denote nodal
6
4
2
0
−2
−4
−6 −500 −400 −300 −200 −100
0
100
Fig. 3.4 Local displacements along a fibre (L = 1,000 R)
200
300
400
500
36
V. Kompiˇs et al. 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0 − 0.05 − 0.1 − 0.15 − 0.2 − 0.25 −500 −400 −300 −200 −100
0
100
200
300
400
500
Fig. 3.5 Errors in local displacements along fibre (L = 1,000 R) disp along / parallel to fiber
6
4
2
0
−2
−4 −6 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Fig. 3.6 Displacement field parallel to fibre axis (L = 1,000 R)
points in distributed source functions (fictive forces of the Kelvin functions and dipoles) along the fibre axis. Two different models were used: one with discontinuities (A – red) near the ends of neighbouring fibres where the fields have large gradients, and one with continuous distribution of source functions (B – blue) along whole fibre axis.
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
37
shear stress along / parallel to fiber
60
40
20
0
−20 −40 −60
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
2000
2500
Fig. 3.7 Shear stress parallel to fibre axis (L = 1,000 R) stress along / parallel to fiber
10 0 −10 −20 −30 −40 −50 −60 −70
0
500
1000
1500
Fig. 3.8 Stress in fibre direction parallel to fibre axis (L = 1,000 R)
Displacements, shear stresses and stresses in the fibre direction along the fibre (dashed line) and in the middle between the fibre of interest and the neighbouring fibre are shown in Figs. 3.6–3.8, respectively. Figures 3.9 and 3.10 contain the distribution of intensities of fictive forces along the fibre and the forces in the fibre cross section given by the integral of forces. The discontinuous model contains large local
38
V. Kompiˇs et al. 3000
loads along fiber
2000 1000 0 −1000 −2000 −3000 −4000 −5000 −500 −400 −300 −200 −100
0
100
200
300
400
500
400
500
Fig. 3.9 Intensity of fictive forces along fibre (L = 1,000 R)
10
x 104
forces along fiber
8
6
4
2
0
−2 −500 −400 −300 −200 −100
0
100
200
300
Fig. 3.10 Forces in fibre cross section (L = 1,000 R)
forces in the vicinity of the discontinuities. The maximal forces in the middle of the fibre are important for evaluation of the strength of the fibre. Both continuous and discontinuous models give similar results and the difference in maximal values is less than 3%.
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
39
Figure 3.11 shows the influence of both the gap between the fibres and the overlap for longer fibres. As could be expected, the configuration with overlap gives a much larger reinforcing effect. The fictive forces are concentrated at the end parts of fibres only in the case without overlap of fibres (Fig. 3.12). A configuration without overlap can occur when long fibres are broken by large forces.
9
x 104
forces along fiber
8 7 6 5 4 3 2
c 1
d 0 −500 −400 −300 −200 −100
0
100
200
300
400
500
Fig. 3.11 Forces in fibre cross section with overlap ∆3 = 200 R (red), ∆3 = 16 R (black); without overlap ∆3 = 200 R (cyan), ∆3 = 16 R (blue) by (L = 1,000 R) loads along fiber 8000 6000 4000 2000 0 −2000 −4000 −6000 −8000 −10000 −500 −400 −300 −200 −100
0
100
200
300
400
Fig. 3.12 Intensity of fictive forces along fibre in without overlap (L = 1,000 R)
500
40
V. Kompiˇs et al.
Different transmission of load between matrix and fibres in the cases with and without overlap can be observed in shorter fibres (L = 100 R), as can be seen from Figs. 3.12–3.19. The forces in the fibres with overlap are greater than without overlap, but the difference is not as great as occurs with longer fibres. Two aspects are important for accurate simulation in computational models: (1) how accurately the compatibility conditions in the inter-domain (matrix-fibre)
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 −0.2 −0.4 −0.6 −0.8 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
20
30
40
50
20
30
40
50
Fig. 3.13 Local displacements along a fibre (L = 100 R) 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0 −0.01 −0.02 −0.03 −0.04 −0.05 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
Fig. 3.14 Errors in local displacements along fibre (L = 100 R)
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
41
disp along / parallel to fiber
0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 −0.1 −0.2 −0.3 −0.4 −0.5 0
50
100
150
200
250
Fig. 3.15 Displacement field parallel to fibre axis (L = 100 R) with and without overlap shear stress along / parallel to fiber
15
10
5
0
−5
−10
−15
0
50
100
150
200
250
Fig. 3.16 Shear stress parallel to fibre axis (L = 100 R) with and without overlap
boundary are satisfied, and (2) the numerical stability of the fictive source functions. Instability of the source functions can be observed in the end parts of fibres and between the discontinuous parts of source functions (Fig. 3.9). The instability in the end parts can result in inaccurate estimation of forces in fibre cross-section. The instability shown in the Fig. 3.9 does not influence the results greatly. It was observed
42
V. Kompiˇs et al. strain along / parallel to fiber
0.02 0 −0.02 −0.04 −0.06 −0.08 −0.1 −0.12
0
50
100
150
200
250
Fig. 3.17 Strain in fibre direction parallel to fibre axis (L = 100 R) with and without overlap loads along fiber
500 400 300 200 100 0 −100 −200 −300 −400 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
20
30
40
50
Fig. 3.18 Intensity of fictive forces along fibre (L = 100 R) with and without overlap
that too fine 1D elements in the parts of fibres with large gradients can lead to instability of the source functions whereas too course elements decrease the accuracy of the primary variables. Both these features can destroy the accuracy of estimation of secondary fields (stresses, strains, forces in fibre cross section). No general rule has yet been found for choosing the nodal points for 1D source distribution.
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
43
forces along fiber
1800 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 −200 −50
−40
−30
−20
−10
0
10
20
30
40
50
Fig. 3.19 Forces in fibre cross section (L = 100 R) with and without overlap
Extreme shear forces between the fibre and the matrix can lead to de-bonding of the fibre or to de-cohesion and re-cohesion at the ends and also in the middle of a fibre close to another fibre in materials reinforced with nanotubes, which are typical and very efficient novel reinforcing materials. This middle part of the fibre will carry the largest forces, which can lead to fracture of the fibre. The forces in the fibre can exceed the largest stresses in the matrix and the bonding stresses on the matrix-fibre interface by several orders.
3.4 Conclusions The MCSF enables us to simulate the interactions both of matrix with stiff reinforcing fibres and of fibre with other fibres very effectively. Computational experiments have shown that very large gradients in all fields occur not only in the end parts of fibres, but also in points close to the ends of neighbouring fibres, more precisely in points on the line perpendicular to the axis of the neighbouring fibre. The large gradients in the end parts of fibres also influence numerical models. If polynomial interpolation of source functions is chosen in the models then finer division of the continuous function needs to be defined in these parts. Numerical models used for simulation of all matrix-fibre and fibre-fibre interactions must maintain the gradients in order to correctly estimate the interactions. Because methods using volume discretization such as FEM and finite volume method (FVM) can smooth out the gradients, very fine meshes would be necessary for numerical models.
44
V. Kompiˇs et al.
The extreme shear forces between fibre and matrix can lead to de-bonding or to de-cohesion in the end parts and also in the middle of a fibre close to another fibre in materials reinforced with fibres or nanotubes, which are typical and very efficient novel reinforcing materials. This middle part of the fibre will be subjected to the largest forces, which can lead to its fracture. The forces in the fibre can result in stresses which can be larger by several orders than the largest stresses in the matrix, or in the bonding on the matrix-fibre interface. The optimal aspect ratio of fibres can be found for specific working stress/strain conditions in each part of a structure according to the strength of all fibre, matrix and bond between fibre and matrix. This is another attractive property of this kind of composite material. Two types of problems simulated in our experiments show, as expected, that overlapping fibres reinforce the matrix more effectively. Fibres distributed without overlap can suffer breakage when subjected to high tension. In the present model we have considered straight fibres, rigid in the axial direction. It is not complicated to consider some more general cases, using this model as the first step in the iteration process. However, more effort will be necessary to include features like boundary conditions for more complex shaped regions, curved fibres, nonlinear effects in matrix, and bonding properties. Acknowledgements This research was partially supported by grands APVT-20-035404 and NATO RTA 001-AVT-SVK. The first two authors thank for this support.
References 1. Atieh MA et al. (2005) Multi-wall carbon nanotubes/Natural rubber nanocomposites. AzoNano – Online Journal of Nanotechnology, 1, pp. 1–11 2. Balaˇs J, Sl´adek J and Sl´adek V (1989) Stress Analysis by Boundary Element Methods. Elsevier, Amsterdam 3. Belytschko T, Liu WK and Moran B (2000) Nonlinear Finite Elements for Continua and Structures. Wiley, Chichester 4. Blokh VI (1964) Theory of Elasticity. University Press, Kharkov 5. Brebbia CA, Telles JCF and Wrobel LC (1984) Boundary Element Techniques – Theory and Applications in Engineering, Springer, Berlin 6. Cheng AHD and Cheng DT (2005) Heritage and early history of the boundary element method. Journal of Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, 29, pp. 268–302 7. Fu Y, Klimkowski KJ and Rodin GJ (1998) A fast solution method for three-dimensional many-particle problems in linear elasticity. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 42, pp. 1215–1229 8. Gaul L and Moser F (2002) A Hybrid Boundary Element Approach Without Singular Boundary Integrals. In: Selected Topics in Boundary Integral Formulations for Solids and Fluids, Kompiˇs V. (ed.), Springer, Wien, pp. 107–116 9. Golberg MA and Chen CS (1998) The Method of Fundamental Solutions for Potential, Helmholtz and Diffusion Problems. In: Boundary Integral Methods – Numerical and Mathematical Aspect, Golberg MA. (ed.), Computational Mechanics, Southampton, pp. 103–176 10. Gomez JE and Power H (1997) A multipole direct and indirect BEM for 2D cavity flow at low Reynolds number. Journal of Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, 19, pp. 17–31
3 Method of Continuous Source Functions
45
11. Greengard FL and Rokhlin V (1987) A fast algorithm for particle simulations. Journal of Computational Physics, 73, pp. 325–348 12. Jirousek J and Wroblewski A (1997) T-elements: State of the art and future trends. Archives of Applied Mechanics, 3, pp. 323–434. 13. Kachanov M, Shafiro B and Tsukrov I (2003) Handbook of Elasticity Solutions. Kluwer, Dordrecht 14. Karageorghis A and Fairweather G (1989) The method of fundamental solutions for the solution of nonlinear plane potential problems. IMA Journal Numerical Analysis, 9, pp. 231–242 ˇ 15. Kompiˇs V and Stiavnick´ y M (2006) Trefftz functions in FEM, BEM and meshless methods. Computer Assisted Mechanics and Engineering Sciences, 13, pp. 417–426 16. Kompiˇs V, Kompiˇs M, Kaukiˇc M and Hui D (2006) Singular Trefftz Functions for Modelling of Material Reinforced by Hard Particles. Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Engineering Computational Technology, Topping, B.H.V., Montero, G. and Montenegro, R. (eds.), CD-ROM, Civil-Comp Press, Dun Eaglais 17. Kompiˇs V, Kompiˇs M and Kaukiˇc M (2007) Method of continuous dipoles for modeling of materials reinforced by short micro-fibers. Journal of Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, 31, pp. 416–424 18. Ma H and Qin QH (2007) Boundary point method for linear elasticity based on direct formulations of conventional and hypersingular boundary integral equations, Computers and Mathematics with Applications, submitted 19. Mammoli AA and Ingber MS (1999) Stokes flow around cylinders in a bounded twodimensional domain using multipole-accelerated boundary element method. International Journal of Numerical Methods in Engineering, 44, pp. 897–917 20. Mukherjee S (2002) The Boundary Contour Method. In: Selected Topics in Boundary Integral Formulations for Solids and Fluids, Kompiˇs V (ed.), Springer, Wien, pp. 117–150 21. Mukherjee S (2002) The Boundary Node Method. In: Selected Topics in Boundary Integral Formulations for Solids and Fluids, Kompiˇs V (ed.), Springer, Wien, pp. 151–180 22. Mukherjee S and Mukherjee YX (1998) The hypersingular boundary contour method for three dimensional elasticity, ASME Journal of Applied Mechanics, 65, pp. 300–309 23. Nishimura N (2002) Fast multipole accelerated boundary integral equations. Applied. Mechanics Review, 55, pp. 299–324 24. Nishimura N, Yoshida K and Kobayashi S (1999) A fast multipole boundary integral equation method for crack problems in 3D. Journal of Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, 23, pp. 97–105 25. Oden JT et al. (2006) Simulation – Based Engineering Science: Revolutionazing Engineering Science Through Simulation. Report NSF Blue Ribbon Panel 26. Peirce AP and Napier JAL (1995) A spectral multipole method for efficient solution of largescale boundary element models in elastostatics. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 38, pp. 4009–4034 27. Qin QH (2002) The Trefftz Finite and Boundary Element Method. WIT, Southampton ˇ 28. Stiavnick´ y M, Kompiˇs V, Kaukiˇc M (2007) Global dipole model for composite reinforced by micro/nano particles. International Conference on Computational Modeling and Experiments of the Composites Materials with Micro-and Nano-Structure, May 28–31 2007, CD-ROM 29. Wang H, Qin QH and Kang YL (2005) A new meshless method for steady-state heat conduction in anisotropic problems and inhomogeneous media. Archive of Applied Mechanics, 74, pp. 563–579 30. Wang H and Qin QH (2006) A meshless method for generalized linear and nonlinear Poissontype problems. Engineering Analysis wit Boundary Elements, 30, pp. 515–521 31. Wang H, Qin QH and Kang YL (2006) A meshless model for transient heat conduction in functionally graded materials. Computational Mechanics, 38, pp. 51–60 32. Zhang JM, Tanaka M and Matsumoto T (2004) Meshless analysis of potential problems in three dimensions with the hybrid boundary node method. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 59, pp. 1147–1160 33. Zienkiewicz OC and Taylor RL (2000)The Finite Element Method, 5th edn. ButterworthHeinemann, Oxford
Chapter 4
Effective Dynamic Material Properties for Materials with Non-Convex Microstructures Martin Schanz, Georgios E. Stavroulakis, and Steffen Alvermann
Abstract The determination of macroscopic, effective properties of microstructured materials is referred to as homogenization. Usually in homogenization, it is assumed that on the microscale inertia effects can be neglected. Here, contrary to these approaches, inertia effects are taken into account, leading to a frequency dependent microscopic behavior. Additionally to this effect, non-convex microstructures are considered. It is assumed that the microstructure can be modeled as a beam framework in frequency domain which is exactly solved by a boundary integral formulation. Further, it is assumed that the structures to be treated are made up of identical unit cells. However, due to the inertia effects a mean value of the microscopic response calculated for several unit cells is used. Under these micromechanic assumptions on the macroscopic scale a frequency dependent, i.e. viscoelastic and auxetic behavior is expected. Hence, an analytical homogenization is presumably not possible. Therefore, the homogenization is performed numerically formulated as an optimization process. The classical technique SQP and soft computing methods, in particular a Genetic Algorithm, are used. The frequency dependent macroscopic material parameters are found for a frequency range from 0 up to 103 kHz for a seven parameter model using as well fractional derivatives. The system responses on micro- and macroscale show a good agreement for the considered frequency range. Both optimization strategies are able to find adequate material parameters on the macroscale but the SQP needs, as expected, reliable starting values. On the contrary the Genetic Algorithm is more robust but much slower. Martin Schanz and Steffen Alvermann Institute of Applied Mechanics, Graz University of Technology, Technikerstr. 4, 8010 Graz, Austria
[email protected] Georgios E. Stavroulakis Department of Production Engineering and Management, Technical University of Crete, 73100 Chania, Greece
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
47
48
M. Schanz et al.
4.1 Introduction Nearly all common materials present a certain heterogeneous microstructure. The determination of macroscopic, effective properties of such microstructured materials is referred to as homogenization. The objective of the homogenization process is to find macroscopic properties of a homogeneous material which represents the behavior of the non-homogeneous microstructure. The methodologies to evaluate the effective mechanical properties of heterogeneous materials have attracted attentions from many researchers. A comprehensive overview of different approaches is given in [12, 20] or from a computational point of view in [27]. Many materials exhibit a cellular or foam-like structure in order to provide a certain amount of stiffness with minimal weight. Cork, for example, is a common cellular material having a closed-celled hexagonal (honeycomb) architecture. In addition to natural materials, man-made cellular structures are used in aerospace structures, composite plates, or other lightweight applications. Due to the increasing importance of these materials, several studies have been performed to evaluate their properties. The effective elastic properties of regular isotropic triangular grid structures as well as square cells have been analyzed by Gibson and Ashby [11] and Torquato et al. [26]. Analysis of more general grid structures were provided by Hohe and Becker [14] who uses an energetic concept for the homogenization process. A comprehensive state of the art publication on homogenization methodologies is given by Hohe and Becker [15]. For microstructures composed of beams, it has been postulated that non-convex shapes (with re-entrant corners) are responsible for a negative Poisson’s ratio effect. Several authors have published papers concerning this effect which is also referred to as auxetic material behavior [25]. Materials with a negative Poisson’s ratio are expected to have interesting mechanical properties such as high energy absorption [5] and fracture resistance which may be useful in applications such as packing material, knee and elbow pads, robust shock absorbing material, filters or sponge mops. Nevertheless, until now, no industrial applications have been realized. From a continuum mechanics point of view, there is no restriction for Poisson’s ratio to be positive. This is known for a long time, but nobody made an effort to investigate this behavior. In fact, the earliest example for a material with a negative Poisson’s ratio was published in Science in 1987, ‘Foam structures with a negative Poisson’s ratio’ by Lakes [16]. He converted a synthetic foam from its conventional, positive Poisson’s ratio state to one having a negative Poisson’s ratio by a relatively simple process [4]. In fact, the fabrication process is published in the Internet in form of a ‘cooking recipe’ [17]. Since then several new negative Poisson’s ratio materials have been developed and fabricated (see, e.g. [1, 6, 21]). Most publications on homogenization assume on the microscopic level that the influence of inertia can be neglected [20] which is mostly motivated by the scale separation which is assumed to be large as stated by Miehe [19]. Only a few approaches to study the effect of micromechanical inertia are published, e.g. [18]. In this paper, a dynamical homogenization approach is presented, where dynamical means that, contrary to other approaches, inertia effects on the microscale are
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
49
not neglected. Hence, the micromechanic calculations are performed in frequency domain with harmonic excitations. Therefore, a frequency-dependent behavior is expected also on the macroscale. Accounting for this frequency-dependence, a viscoelastic constitutive law is applied on the macroscale. Since the viscoelastic constitutive law requires a number of parameters to be found, the homogenization is formulated as an optimization problem, i.e. ‘find macroscopic material parameters that describe the micromechanical behavior as good as possible’. The paper is arranged in the following way. First, the calculation of the considered microstructure is elaborated. The constitutive equation to be used for the macroscopic scale is then presented in Section 4.3. Section 4.4 deals with the used methodologies for the optimization, a classical SQP and a Genetic algorithm. Finally, some examples are presented and discussed.
4.2 Calculation of the Unit Cell Within this work, cellular solids are considered which consist of simple beams. Such structures are found quite often in the literature, because they can represent sandwich cores or simplified models of foam-like materials. It is assumed that the material is periodic, i.e. it consists of equally shaped cells. For sandwich cores, this assumption is well justified, real materials, of course, have an imperfect microstructure, where neighboring cells have a slightly different geometry. But, in order to calculate effective, homogeneous material properties, this model should be sufficiently accurate to represent the microstructure. If the assumption of periodicity is made, it is very easy to find a representative volume element (RVE), because if the microstructure consists of identical units, the smallest unit contains all information and is therefore representative. If on the microscale the dynamic effects are neglected, i.e. it is modeled static, effective properties can be calculated from this single unit cell. However, in a dynamic calculation in frequency domain one unit cell does not suffice to obtain representative results. The reason is that different modes of deformation (structural modes) may occur when using a different number of unit cells. This can be explained by considering the example given in Fig. 4.1. A unit cell is loaded with a force on the left and right
Fig. 4.1 Example calculation of 1 and 3 × 3 unit cells
50
M. Schanz et al.
hand side. The cell is calculated in frequency domain, i.e. the load is harmonic and thus, the resulting strain ∆ (4.1) ε= is also harmonic. Another calculation is done using 3 × 3 cells. Both strains are plotted over a frequency range of 0–106 Hz in logarithmic scale in Fig. 4.2. On the left hand side, the whole frequency range is plotted, whereas on the right hand side, only a small range is plotted. It can be seen that the results from both calculations are not identical. At approximately 3.4 · 105 Hz, an eigenfrequency is missing in the single unit cell calculation and at 2.3 · 105 Hz, the eigenfrequencies of both calculations are different. Therefore, it is necessary to calculate multiple unit cells to obtain characteristic microscale results. A simple and pragmatic approach is to calculate a specific number of unit cells and then average the results. The frequency dependent response of the unit cell above as well as in the following is based on a frame model using the Timoshenko theory for the beams. This refined theory is used to take into account the shear deformation and the rotatory inertia which can not be neglected for higher frequencies [8]. Further, for the numerical model the Boundary Element Method for beams [2] is used because it solves the governing equations exactly independent of the load in contrast to a Finite Element model.
4.3 Macroscopic Constitutive Equation Since inertia effects are taken into account on the microscale, the response of the unit cell is frequency-dependent. Thus, the effective properties on the macroscale must also feature a frequency-dependence. One of the easiest constitutive laws exhibiting a frequency-dependence is the linear viscoelasticity. The stress-strain equation of a linearly viscoelastic material can be expressed in the form of a differential equation (see, e.g. the book by Christensen [7]) N
d αk
M
d αk
∑ pk dt k σi j = ∑ qk dt k εi j .
k=0
(4.2)
k=0
In (4.2), M and N can have different values and must be adapted to the application, so their choice is somewhat arbitrary. Also, fractional derivatives as denoted by d αk may be used to better fit a larger frequency range [9]. Details on the definition of fractional derivatives can, e.g. be found by Podlubny [22] and their application in viscoelastic constitutive equations, e.g. in [3]. In frequency domain, viscoelastic effects are described by complex moduli and, especially, fractional derivatives become simple. They are presented by a fractional power [22]. Applying a Fourier-transformation on (4.2), the time dependence is replaced by a frequency dependence. In the present application, the constitutive equation
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
51
0.001 1 unit cell 3x3 unit cells
strain
1e-05
1e-07
1e-09 0
500000
1e+06
frequency (a) Large frequency range 1e-05 1 unit cell 3x3 unit cells
strain
1e-06
1e-07
1e-08 200000
250000
300000
frequency (b) Small frequency range Fig. 4.2 Strain of 1 and 3 × 3 unit cells
350000
52
M. Schanz et al.
σi j (ω) =
E(ω) ν (ω)E(ω) εi j (ω) + δi j εkk (ω) (1 + ν (ω)) (1 + ν (ω)) (1 − 2ν (ω))
(4.3)
is chosen, i.e. a isotropic material is assumed. For the Young’s modulus, in the following, either the viscoelastic model E(ω) =
q1 (iω) + q2(iω)2 + q3(iω)3 + q4 (iω)4 + q5(iω)5 + q6(iω)6 + q7 (iω)7 p1 (iω) + p2 (iω)2 + p3(iω)3 + p4 (iω)4 + p5(iω)5 + p6 (iω)6 + p7(iω)7 (4.4)
with 14 parameters or the model 1 + q1(iω)α1 + q2 (iω)α2 . E(ω) = E¯ 1 + p1(iω)α1 + p2 (iω)α2
(4.5)
with fractional derivatives and 7 parameters is used. The same model but with possible different parameters is used for the Poisson’s ratio
ν (ω) = ν¯
1 + q˜1(iω)α˜ 1 + q˜2(iω)α˜ 2 . 1 + p˜ 1(iω)α˜ 1 + p˜ 2 (iω)α˜ 2
(4.6)
Again, the choice of these models is somewhat arbitrary. For the considered frequency range, they have shown to be sufficient. A number of trials with fewer parameters were not successful, as well as models with more parameters, yet without fractional derivatives. Note that in the above equations a special indication of the Fourier transform is skipped for the sake of brevity.
4.4 Homogenization Using Optimization The connection between the material behavior on the microscale and the macroscale is referred to as homogenization. The aim is to ‘replace’ the heterogeneous microstructure by a homogeneous material which describes the material behavior correctly. Here, the homogenization is formulated as an optimization problem, i.e. ‘Find material parameters on the macroscopic scale which describe the micromechanical behavior as good as possible’. Contrary to the static case where the homogenization is performed analytically [13], the consideration of dynamic effects on the microscale makes it necessary to use an optimization algorithm. There are too many unknown parameters in the macroscopic constitutive equation to perform an analytical homogenization. Within the scope of this work, the Sequential Quadratic Programming Method (SQP) is used. It represents a gradient-based optimization technique. As this algorithm is a quite common for details the reader is pointed towards standard books, e.g. [10, 24]. In the following presented examples, the gradient is calculated by finite differences. Gradient based algorithms often exhibit weaknesses in non-convex
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
53
problems, which means that they run into local minima of the search space. Therefore, also a global optimization technique a Genetic Algorithm is applied to the optimization problem. As expected from literature, tests have shown that the Genetic Algorithm is the robustest (but slowest) technique also compared with Neural Networks as alternative global optimization tool. Genetic Algorithms are stochastic search algorithms based on the mechanisms of nature selection and natural genetics. At the beginning of the algorithm, a population made up of a discrete number of individuals is generated. One individual corresponds to the solution of a problem, and consists of an array of gene values. Just as in nature, the individuals are optimized for their environment by successive modification over a number of iterations. In each iteration or generation, the algorithm evaluates, selects, and recombines the members of the population to produce the succeeding generation. Evaluation of each individual which encodes a candidate solution is based on a fitness function. This function is used to select the relatively fitter individuals, i.e. the individuals with the best fitness value. The selected individuals form the parent generation, and they produce offsprings by rules like mutation, crossover, or gene replacement (for details, see, Sch¨oneburg [23]). The algorithm stops after a specified number of generations or if a certain fitness value is obtained for the best individual. In the present application, one gene corresponds to the value of a material parameter pk , qk , or αk from (4.3) and the whole set of parameters corresponds to one individual. As fitness function, the square difference between the microscopic and macroscopic system response is used. The differences are summed up over the considered frequency range. If a harmonic strain is applied on the unit cell, the minimization function reads f=
ωend
∑
ωstart
2 σmicro (ω) − σmacro (ω, pk , qk , αk ) → 0 .
(4.7)
In (4.7), the stress σmicro (ω) must be calculated only once, whereas σmacro (ω) is calculated for each new individual of the population via Eq. (4.3), using new gene values of pk , qk , and αk . In principle, the procedure can be inverted, i.e. stresses can be applied on the cell and the strain response on the macroscopic scale can be optimized. In case of the SQP, the same fitness function is used. Within the scale consideration in homogenization, a material point on the macroscale is assigned to a volume portion on the microscale. To define a homogeneous mechanical equivalent to the heterogeneous unit cell, a surface average based approach is used. The stress distribution in the unit cell consisting of the given microstructure is assumed to be equivalent to a stress distribution of the effective medium if 1 1 ti d Γ = ti d Γ (4.8) Γ Γ Γ
Γ
holds, where ti is the traction vector on the surface Γ of the unit cell. Equation (4.8) describes a redistribution of the stress components along the surface of the unit cell
54
M. Schanz et al.
during the homogenization process. A second equivalence condition interrelates the strain states on the microscopic and macroscopic scale. An average strain state for the unit cell is defined by means of the difference in the displacements of opposite surfaces of the volume element. If the difference in the displacements of opposite surfaces is not constant along the surface, the surface integral of this quantity is taken. Thus, the macroscopic strain can be expressed by 1 εi j = 2V
(ui n j + u j ni ) d Γ,
(4.9)
Γ
where V denotes the volume of the unit cell and ni are the components of the outward normal vector on Γ. Thus, the heterogeneous microstructure is smeared over the unit cell (see, Fig. 4.3). With the averaged stress and strain, the effective macroscopic material properties are calculated via σi j = Ci∗jkl εkl ,
(4.10)
with the effective material tensor Ci∗jkl which is defined as the relation between the two averaged quantities σi j and εkl . Here, the material tensor is simplified due to the assumption of isotropy and the respective equation is given by (4.3), however without denoting the stress and strain as averaged quantities. The advantage of this approach is that it only requires the tractions and deformations on the boundary of the unit cell. No energetic considerations like in the strain energy based homogenization are made [13]. Thus, it can not only be applied in the static case, but also in dynamics. Since the materials discussed in this work are assumed to have a periodic microstructure, it is meaningful to do a dynamic calculation in frequency domain. The reason is that in frequency domain, periodic boundary conditions can be applied to the unit cell. In time domain, this is not possible because wave propagation phenomena take place. Thus, if a wave is running through the unit cell, the tractions and displacements on one edge are different from the tractions and displacements on the opposing edge. It is not possible to fulfill the periodicity, which is postulated from the fact that the material consists of equally
s, e
Fig. 4.3 Stress and strain on the micro- and macroscale
·s Ò, ·eÒ
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
55
shaped cells. In a frequency domain calculation, in contrast, the unit cell is situated in a steady state where periodicity can be fulfilled. It should be remarked that numerical tests have also been performed based on a volume averaged approach with a map to the boundary. These tests have shown no difference between the surface and volume averaged approach. However, for very high frequencies and soft materials this may change. Some more effort will be put on this aspect in future.
4.5 Numerical Examples Effective properties are calculated in this section. In order to study the effectiveness of different optimization methods in the first subsection only a small frequency range up to the first structural eigenfrequency of the non-convex micro structure is considered. In the second subsection the more realistic case of a wide frequency range is presented for both auxetic and non-auxetic microstructures. The following two microstructures given in Fig. 4.4 are used for the numerical study. Both cells consist of beams with a quadratic cross section of 0.1 × 0.1. The microstructure material is in the first subsection steel and in the second subsection PMMA with a slight damping. The latter material data were measured at the PTB (PhysikalischTechnische Bundesanstalt) in Braunschweig.
4.5.1 Small Frequency Range The non-convex microstructure shown in Fig. 4.4(a) is used for the following considerations. The cell is analyzed in frequency domain. A harmonic strain in one direction is applied to the cell (see, Fig. 4.5).
0.3
0.2 0.1 0.2
0.2
0.5
0.5
(a) Auxetic microstructure Fig. 4.4 Considered microstructures
(b) Non-Auxetic microstructure
56
M. Schanz et al.
Fig. 4.5 Load case
u = u– .eiωt
u– = u .eiωt
Since the considered microstructure is assumed to be periodic, the opposing nodes of the cell must have the same deformation and the forces of the node pairs must be equal in magnitude but opposite in direction. Due to the symmetry of the cell the load periodicity is implicitly fulfilled, e.g. the reaction force of the node on the left hand side corresponds to the applied load on the right hand side. On the macroscale, the one-dimensional version of the constitutive Eq. (4.2) 7
σ(ω) = E(iω) ε(ω) =
∑ pk (iω)k
k=0 7
ε(ω)
(4.11)
∑ qk (iω)k
k=0
with the complex Young’s modulus (4.4) is used. Equation (4.11) has to be fulfilled for a frequency range 0–ωmax . The number of parameters is somewhat arbitrary, it depends on the considered frequency range how many parameters have to be used. For the present case, it has turned out that a total of M + N = 14 parameters is sufficient to deliver good results for the considered frequency range. Two optimization methodologies, a soft computing tool – the Genetic Algorithm and a classical technique – a SQP algorithm, are used in the following to find the macroscopic material data.
4.5.1.1 Genetic Algorithm The fitness value of the individuals quality is calculated via Eq. (4.7). A total number of M + N = 14 parameters is used, so each individual consists of 14 chromosomes. In a trial and error process, the following parameters of the Genetic Algorithm have shown to be suitable for the present application: • • • •
A population size of 1,000 individuals is chosen The starting population is created randomly New individuals are created via 2-point-crossover The mutation of an individual is done accordingly to the standardized normal distribution • 250 individuals are created newly in every generation, the remaining 750 are created as offspring of the previous generation • The optimization is stopped after a maximum of 50,000 iterations or if the best fitness value satisfies f < 10−5.
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
57
45 optimization (1) optimization (2) optimization (3)
40
fitness value f
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
generation Fig. 4.6 Optimization with genetic algorithm
The proceeding of the optimization is shown in Fig. 4.6. Since the first generation is created randomly and also during the optimization, genetic operators are applied randomly, the proceeding of the optimization is different in all the optimization runs. The fitness value of the best individual is plotted versus the number of generations. It can be seen that in all three cases, a relatively small fitness values was obtained, however, after a different number of generations. The obtained values for pk and qk are given in Table 4.1. Contrary to the static case, there is more than one set of parameters which describes the behavior accurately. Figure 4.7 shows the behavior on the micro- and macroscale. The modulus E(ω) is plotted versus the frequency. On the microscale (solid line), E(ω) is E(ω) =
σmicro εmicro
(4.12)
with the stress and strain σmicro , εmicro of the unit cell, whereas for the three macroscale results, Eq. (4.11) was solved for ε(ω) and plotted for the three optimization runs with the respective parameters pk and qk given in Table 4.1.
4.5.1.2 SQP – Sequential Quadratic Programming The Sequential Quadratic Programming method is used to minimize the optimization function (4.7). The following parameters were used: • Random values are used as starting points • The optimization stops if f < 10−5 or a maximum of 1,000 iterations is reached
58
M. Schanz et al.
Table 4.1 Obtained material parameters by Genetic Algorithm (a) Optimization (1) f = 0.02996 (b) Optimization (2) f = 0.08141
k
pk
qk
k
pk
qk
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
1.7617 · 101 2.2672 · 102 −1.7471 · 10−14 1.8300 · 100 3.3705 · 10−3 4.2695 · 10−3 1.7815 · 10−19
1.5469 · 107 1.8152 · 108 1.2785 · 105 1.4790 · 106 1.0693 · 104 3.0166 · 103 4.0734 · 101
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
4.9398 · 100 4.0007 · 102 −1.6224 · 10−14 2.1568 · 100 1.2825 · 10−16 2.9828 · 10−3 5.0153 · 10−5
4.1763 · 106 3.8899 · 108 4.3765 · 105 2.7570 · 106 6.7831 · 103 4.8445 · 103 2.0826 · 101
(c) Optimization (3) f = 0.02313 k
pk
qk
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
7.6350 · 10−5
6.3904 · 101 1.6060 · 108 4.0609 · 105 1.1117 · 106 5.5493 · 103 1.8973 · 103 1.5891 · 101
2.0017 · 102 −7.0055 · 10−14 1.1501 · 100 4.4045 · 10−16 1.7722 · 10−3 2.6157 · 10−5
100 microscale optimization (1) optimization (2) optimization (3)
E
10
1
0.1
0.01 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
frequency [kHz]
Fig. 4.7 Genetic Algorithm results on the micro- and macroscale
14
16
18
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
59
• Formulation as unconstrained problem, i.e. no constraints for values of pk and qk are made Figure 4.8 shows typical optimization runs. The fitness value is plotted versus the number of iterations. The SQP method was able to obtain a value f < 1 in two runs. One optimization run was only able to find a local minimum of the function. This can be seen from the final value of the optimization of f = 31.2730 and also from the results for E(ω) on micro- and macroscale. See Table 4.2 for the obtained values for the parameters pk and qk and Fig. 4.9 for results on both scales. Both optimization procedures were able to find adequate material parameters on the macroscopic scale. It can already be seen from the fitness value or final value of the optimization function, respectively, how good the parameters fit the microscopic properties. The Sequential Quadratic Programming method has problems with local minima. If a ‘wrong’ starting point is used for the optimization, it may deliver poor results. The Genetic Algorithm is the most reliable of both optimization procedures. No starting point is required, and it always delivers good results. However, it takes much more computing time to obtain results. Hence, in the next test only the Genetic Algorithm is used.
4.5.2 Wide Frequency Range A frequency range from 0 up to 3×103 kHz is chosen. Due to the existence of higher eigenmodes for more than one unit cell (see, Section 4.2), the microstructures are 100 optimization (1) optimization (2) optimization (3)
fitness value f
80
60
40
20
0 0
200
400
600 iterations
Fig. 4.8 Optimization using SQP algorithm
800
1000
60
M. Schanz et al.
Table 4.2 Obtained material parameters by SQP (a) Optimization (1) f = 31.2730
k
pk
qk
2.3801 · 103
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
(b) Optimization (2) f = 0.0942 k
−2.1948 · 104
pk 2.7349 · 108
1.7790 · 106
1 2 −7.8132 · 108 3 3.0370 · 108 4 3.0801 · 108 5 1.2956 · 108 6 −3.1951 · 106 7 4.4835 · 105
2.9126 · 106
−3.5378 · 104 9.0371 · 104 −2.0615 · 104 −9.9309 · 105 −6.5232 · 103 −1.7844 · 102 −9.5146 · 102 5.9092 · 103 1.1842 · 104 1.2702 · 100
qk 2.3917 · 1011 −2.5963 · 1011 −1.1559 · 1011 −4.0479 · 1010 7.1634 · 1010 −2.2324 · 108 2.8131 · 108
(c) Optimization (3) f = 0.0961 k
pk
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
−1.7145 · 10−1
qk
−6.7364 · 10−1 −9.4824 · 10−1 1.6859 · 100 −1.8562 · 10−1 2.6000 · 10−5 −6.5400 · 10−4
−1.2534 · 102 −1.0430 · 102 4.1414 · 101 1.8603 · 101 −1.0769 · 102 −2.8079 · 10−2 −4.2114 · 10−1
100 microscale optimization (1) optimization (2) optimization (3)
E
10
1
0.1
0.01 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
frequency [kHz] Fig. 4.9 SQP results on the micro- and macroscale
calculated multiple times. Calculations were done for 1, 2 × 2, . . . , 5 × 5 unit cells and the results were averaged. The load case for both cells is given in Fig. 4.5. A displacement amplitude is applied on the left and right hand side of the cell.
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
61
Based on the results in the small frequency range solely a Genetic Algorithm is applied here to solve the optimization problem (4.7). The following parameters were used to determine the material parameters: • • • •
A population size of 1,000 individuals is chosen The starting population is created randomly New individuals are created via 2-point-crossover The mutation of an individual is done accordingly to the standardized normal distribution, mutation probability is 10% • 150 individuals are created newly in every generation, the remaining 850 are created as offspring of the previous generation • The optimization is stopped after a maximum of 50,000 iterations or if the best fitness value f < 10−5 . The results of the optimization are depicted in the following Figures. Figures 4.10 and 4.12 show the Young’s modulus and the Poisson’s ratio for the auxetic microstructure, while in Figs. 4.11 and 4.13, the Young’s modulus and the Poisson’s ratio for the non-auxetic microstructure are shown. In each diagram, the microscopic and macroscopic results are plotted versus the frequency. As it can be seen, the optimization was not able to fit each single eigenfrequency of the microstructure results. However, the general tendency is preserved. In all four result plots, it can be seen that for small frequencies, the fitted parameters converge into the static solution. The obtained material parameters for ν and E are given in Table 4.3 for the auxetic microstructure and in Table 4.4 for the non-auxetic material. 1e+08 microscale macroscale
E[N/m2 ]
1e+07
1e+06
100000
10000
100
10000 frequency [Hz]
Fig. 4.10 Young’s modulus for auxetic microstructure
1e+06
62
M. Schanz et al.
1e+08 microscale macroscale
E[N/m2 ]
1e+07
1e+06
100000
10000
100
10000
1e+06
frequency [Hz] Fig. 4.11 Young’s modulus for non-auxetic microstructure
1
microscale macroscale
n [−]
0.5
0
−0.5
−1 100
10000 frequency [Hz]
Fig. 4.12 Poisson’s ratio for auxetic microstructure
1e+06
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
63
1 microscale macroscale
n [−]
0.5
0
−0.5
−1 100
10000
1e+06
frequency [Hz] Fig. 4.13 Poisson’s ratio for non-auxetic microstructure Table 4.3 Obtained material parameters for auxetic material Young’s modulus k
E¯
pk
qk
αk
1 2
2.560 · 104
2.358 · 10−14
1.842 · 10−8
1.571 · 100 1.099 · 100
k
ν¯
2.432 · 10−8
8.943 · 10−9
Poisson’s ratio 1 2
−0.376
p˜k
q˜k
α˜ k
4.995 · 10−8
1.598 · 10−8
1.497 · 100 1.335 · 100
1.534 · 10−8
1.162 · 10−7
Table 4.4 Obtained material parameters for non-auxetic material Young’s modulus k
E¯
pk
qk
αk
1 2
1.581 · 105
1.057 · 10−6 1.448 · 10−12
2.666 · 10−8 1.856 · 10−8
1.057 · 100 1.389 · 100
k
ν¯
Poisson’s ratio 1 2
0.307
p˜k
q˜k
α˜ k
1.869 · 10−11
1.407 · 10−8
1.424 · 100 1.573 · 100
5.147 · 10−9
8.443 · 10−10
64
M. Schanz et al.
The slightly viscoelastic material on the microscopic scale had virtually no effect on the homogenization process. There were still eigenfrequencies on the microscale which make the search of the material parameters very difficult. For the optimization, it can be observed that there is no difference whether an auxetic or non-auxetic microstructure is used as input data. This could have been expected a` priori, because the same mathematical problem (with slightly different parameters) needs to be solved by the optimization procedure.
4.6 Conclusions In this paper, a dynamical homogenization for a periodic, auxetic material consisting of simple beams has been performed. Due to inertia effects on the microscale, the behavior of the unit cell is frequency dependent. Thus, a viscoelastic constitutive law had to be applied on the macroscale, requiring an optimization procedure for the homogenization process. The SQP and the Genetic Algorithm are used for the homogenization. Both were able to find adequate material parameters on the macroscale but the SQP needs, as expected, reliable starting values. On the contrary the Genetic Algorithm was more robust but much slower. For the identified material parameters pk , qk , and αk , however, no plausibility check was yet made concerning thermodynamic restrictions. Therefore, further investigations have to be carried out assuring the correctness of the found values, i.e. by setting thermodynamic constraints in the optimization problem.
References 1. Alderson K, Kettle A, Neale P, Pickles A, Evans K (1995) The effect of the processing parameters on the fabrication of auxetic polyethylene. Part II: The effect of sintering temperature and time. Journal of Materials Science 30:4069–4075 2. Antes H, Schanz M, Alvermann S (2004) Dynamic analyses of frames by integral equations for bars and Timoshenko beams. Journal of Sound and Vibration 276(3–5):807–836 3. Bagley R, Torvik P (1986) On the Fractional Calculus Model of Viscoelastic Behaviour. Journal of Rheology 30(1):133–155 4. Chan N, Evans K (1997) Fabrication methods for auxetic foams. Journal of Materials Science 32:5945–5953 5. Chen C, Lakes R (1989) Dynamic wave dispersion and loss properties of conventional and negative Poisson’s ratio polymeric cellular materials. Cellular Polymers 8:343–369 6. Choi J, Lakes R (1991) Design of a fastener based on negative Poisson’s ratio foam adapted. Cellular Polymers 10:205–212 7. Christensen R (1971) Theory of Viscoelasticity. Academic Press, New York 8. Dawson B (1968) Rotary inertia and shear in beam vibration treated by the Ritz method. The Aeronautical Journal 72:341–344 9. Gaul L, Klein P, Kempfle S (1991) Damping Description Involving Fractional Operators. Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 5(2):81–88 10. Geiger C, Kanzow C (2002) Theorie und Numerik restringierter Optimierungsaufgaben. Springer, Berlin
4 Effective Properties of Non-Convex Microstructured Materials
65
11. Gibson L, Ashby M (1988) Cellular Solids. Pergamon Press, Oxford 12. Hashin Z (1983) Analysis of composite materials – a survey. Journal of Applied Mechanics 50:481–504 13. Hohe J, Becker W (2001) An energetic homogenisation procedure for the elastic properties of general cellular sandwich cores. Computing 32:185–197 14. Hohe J, Becker W (2001) A refined analysis of the effective elasticity tensor for general cellular sandwich cores. International Journal of Solids and Structures 38:3689–3717 15. Hohe J, Becker W (2002) Effective stress-strain relations for two-dimensional cellular sandwich cores: Homogenization, material models, and properties. AMR 55(1):61–87 16. Lakes R (1987) Foam structures with a negative Poisson’s ratio. Science 235:1038–1040 17. Lakes R (1987) Making negative Poisson’s ratio foam. http://silver.neep.wisc.edu/lakes/ PoissonRecipe.html 18. Lakes R (1996) Micromechanical analysis of dynamic behavior of conventional and negative Poisson’s ratio foams. Journal of Engineering Mathematics and Technology, ASME 118:285–288 19. Miehe C (2003) Computational micro-to-macro transitions for discretized micro-structures of heterogeneous materials at finite strains based on the minimization of averaged incremental energy. Computational Methods in Applied Mechanical Engineering 192:559–591 20. Nemat-Nasser S, Hori M (1999) Micromechanics: Overall Properties of Heterogeneous Materials, 2nd revised ed. North-Holland, Amsterdam 21. Pickles A, Webber R, Alderson K, Neale P, Evans K (1995) The effect of the processing parameters on the fabrication of auxetic polyethylene. Part I: The effect of compaction conditions. Journal of Materials Science 30:4059–4068 22. Podlubny I (1999) Fractional Differential Equations, Mathematics in Science and Engineering, vol 198. Academic, San Diego New York London 23. Sch¨oneburg E (1996) Genetische Algorithmen und Evolutionsstrategien, 1st edn. AddisonWesley, Bonn 24. Spellucci P (1993) Numerische Verfahren der nichtlinearen Optimierung. Birkh¨auser Verlag, Basel 25. Theocaris P, Stavroulakis G (1998) The homogenization method for the study of variation of Poisson’s ratio in fiber composites. Archive of Applied Mechanics 68(3/4):281–295 26. Torquato S, Gibianski L, Silva M, Gibson L (1998) Effective mechanical and transport properties of cellular solids. International Journal of Mechanical Sciences 40(1):71–82 27. Zohdi T, Wriggers P (2005) Introduction to Computational Micromechanics, Lecture Notes in Applied and Computational Mechanics, vol 20. Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York
Chapter 5
Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation Jiˇr´ı Vala
Abstract Diffusion in multi-component alloys can be characterized (a) by the vacancy mechanism for substitutional components, (b) by the existence of sources and sinks for vacancies, and (c) by the motion of atoms of interstitial components. The description of diffusive and massive phase transformation of a multi-component system is based on the principle of maximum dissipation rate by Onsager; the finite thickness of the interface between both phases can be respected. A new computational model (its one-dimensional, in general non-stationary version is presented here) covers both (a) and (c) and is open to involve (b) in a natural way. The mathematical analysis results in an initial-value problem for a system of partial differential equations of evolution with certain non-local integral term; the unknowns are the mole fractions of particular components (and some additional variables in case (b)). The numerical construction of approximate solutions comes from the method of lines and from the finite difference and other numerical techniques, namely the numerical integration formulae and the spectral analysis of linear operators. The original software code is supported by MATLAB and partially by MAPLE.
5.1 Introduction The basic principles of diffusion controlled phase transformation have been known for a long time. In general the diffusion in a multi-component system can be characterized by the well-known relation from [11], rewritten in some (more or less general) form in most later monographs or papers, as [2, 5] or [3]. The diffusive flux for every component can be evaluated as a product of the matrix of kinetic coefficients and the gradient of chemical potentials of particular components, understood as Jiˇr´ı Vala ˇ zkova 17, Czech Brno University of Technology, Faculty of Civil Engineering, 602 00 Brno, Ziˇ Republic
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
67
68
J. Vala
functions of concentrations (or some equivalent characteristics, as mole fractions). In the more general context the diffusive flux may be substituted by some “extensive quantity” and the chemical potential by some “intensive variable”, for illustration of the terminology cf. [14], p. 5, and [16], p. 1370. Onsager showed that such linear phenomenological equation (originally for a heat production in an anisotropic system) can be derived from the requirement of maximum of a functional, having a close relation to the total entropy production of the system, and formulated the “thermodynamic extremal principle” (TEP). Making simplifying assumptions, in case of binary systems it was possible to derive analytic or semi-analytic solutions, useful in the field of material development. However, under more general assumptions or in systems including more than two components this approach turned out to be insufficient. The thermodynamics of multi-component systems has its own scientific history, covering the evolution of the concept of deriving the thermodynamic functions of a system from all available experimental data, the reliable setting of kinetic parameters, etc.; much more information and references to results from the last four decades can be found in [14], p. 3. Both theoretical and experimental works yield that the diffusion in multi-component alloys can be characterized by three attributes: (a) The vacancy mechanism for “slowly” diffusing substitutional components (b) The existence of certain sources or sinks of vacancies (c) The “quick” motion of atoms of interstitial components In the following formal mathematical description of a system only the attributes (a) and (c) will be incorporated properly; the attribute (b) will be left to the concluding remarks. We also limit the discussion to isothermal and isobaric conditions. Let us notice that most papers, as [14], p. 6, or [16], p. 1373, need simplifying assumptions on the equilibrium of vacancies; only [17], p. 3046, attempt to handle the quite general case with non-ideal sources and sinks and vacancies. Another serious problem is connected with the description of the (usually very thin) interface, separating two phases during the phase transformation. Under the assumption of the sharp interface (whose thickness is assumed to be negligible) it is not easy to formulate realistic interface conditions (as boundary conditions for particular phases) [14], p. 9, introduce three types of such conditions: the so-called local equilibrium conditions with partitioning, the local equilibrium conditions with negligible partitioning and the para-equilibrium conditions. Nevertheless, it is possible to avoid all such (rather tricky) conditions, respecting the finite thickness h of the interface, as explained in [20], p. 3954, where the material behaviour in the centre of the interface corresponds to the ideal liquid phase; consequently the results for the sharp interface can be derived from those for the thick interface, using the limit passage h → 0. Several further simplifications in our considerations could be removed, but has been accepted here to generate a relatively simple mathematical formulation. Following [14], p. 6, we shall assume that the insertion of an interstitial component does not change the lattice geometry. We shall write all relations for a hypothetical one-dimensional problem, thus the interface motion in other directions will be
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
69
Fig. 5.1 One-dimensional computational scheme for a two-phase system
ignored. Unlike the “lattice fixed reference frame by Kierkendall” by [14], p. 5 (later completed by certain “number fixed reference frame”), the Cartesian coordinate system x here is fixed with the moving interface (from the right to the left). Moreover, avoiding the attribute b) enables us to preserve the constant interface thickness h; therefore the interface velocity v, related to the fixed reference frame, will be a function of time t ≥ 0, but not of x. Such simple system geometry is documented in Fig. 5.1: a one-dimensional, two-phase system of unit cross-sectional area with two phases α and γ , separated by the thick interface, and with certain integer numbers r ≥ 0 of substitutional components and q ≥ 0 of interstitial ones is considered; the formal third liquid phase β in the interface centre is added, too. Let us remark that most models of binary alloys are formulated for r = 2 and q = 0; cf. [1] where the effect of solute drag on the grain growth of polycrystals, taking into account migration of a grain boundary, is studied. In real configurations h can be expected to be (unlike Fig. 5.1) much smaller than both −xL and xR , comparable with the size of the whole specimen.
5.2 Gibbs Energy and its Dissipation The formulation of the Gibbs energy and its dissipation presented here is the straight generalization of the approach of [20], p. 3954, where especially the steady-state problem for substitutional alloys is studied. The local chemical composition is described by mole fractions c∗ = (c1 (x,t), . . . , cr (x,t), . . . , cr+q (x,t))T . The corresponding diffusive fluxes will be denoted by j∗ = ( j1 (x,t), . . . , jr (x,t), . . . , jr+q (x,t))T .
70
J. Vala
The symbol ∗ here emphasizes that both column vectors c∗ and j∗ with all r + q components are considered; later we shall need also their subvectors c and j with missing terms cr (x,t) or jr (x,t), respectively – cf. (5.1) and (5.2). The same convention will be used for other column vectors, too. For simplicity of notation we shall obey the Einstein summation rule for all indices k, l, m ∈ {1, . . . , r} (related to substitutional components only), a, b ∈ {r + 1, . . . , r + q} (related to interstitial components only), i, g ∈ {1, . . . , r + q} (related to both substitutional and interstitial components) and f from the set of phase identifiers {α , β , γ }; an underlined index prohibits summation. Moreover, δ.. means the Kronecker symbol everywhere. We assume negligible vacancy fluxes in the system; this together with the vacancy mechanism leads to the constraint
δkk jk = 0.
(5.1)
The analogous constraint for mole fractions is
δkk ck = 1.
(5.2)
The system moves with the velocity v(t), being the velocity of interface migration to the left, relative to the fixed coordinate system. We assume that no external diffusive fluxes are present at both ends of the specimen; this can be expressed as ji (xL ) = ji (xR ) = 0;
(5.3)
consequently xL and xR are variable in t, too. The dot symbol will denote the partial derivative with respect to t, the prime symbol the partial derivative with respect to x : for any scalar quantity u(x,t) we are able to calculate its total time derivative du = u˙ − vu . dt
The chemical potential µi of a component i is supposed to be a function of c∗ and t. One can see immediately that by (5.2) µi can be rearranged as a function of c and t easily. We suppose that the dependencies of the chemical potentials on c∗ are known for both phases α and γ , as well as for the interface – in its centre, referenced by β , we are allowed to assume the ideal liquid behaviour. The well-known Gibbs-Duhem relation, discussed, e.g. in [20], p. 3954, yields ci
dµif = 0, dt
ci µif = 0
(5.4)
The chemical potential µi can be calculated at any point of the specimen as
µi (x, c∗ ) = w f (x)µif (c∗ ),
(5.5)
making use of some reasonably continuous weight functions w f (x), having the properties
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
wα (x) = 1, wγ (x) = 0 wα (x) = 0, wγ (x) = 1 wβ (x) = 1 − wα (x) − wγ (x)
71
xL < x < h/2, h/2 < x < xR , xL < x < xR .
if if if
f
Let us notice that the formal analogy of (5.4) for µi replacing µi may be not fulfilled inside the interface, i.e. in case 0 < x < h. Let Ω be the constant molar volume. The total Gibbs energy G of the system is given by G=
1 Ω
ci µi dx.
If no integral bounds are present then the integration from xL to xR is considered by default. Its time derivative can be expressed as dci 1 dG d µi = µ i + ci dx. dt Ω dt dt Inserting µi into the second additive term from (5.5), we obtain
f d µ 1 dci dG f = µi + ci w f i − vci w f µi dx dt Ω dt dt and consequently (integrating by parts)
f dG 1 dci f d µi f f f f = − vci (w µi ) + vci w µi dx. µ i + ci w dt Ω dt dt By the first Eq. (5.4) the second and fourth additive terms vanish at all; thus, respecting (5.5), we receive 1 dci dG = µi − vci µi dx. dt Ω dt Since w f ∈ {0, 1} for f ∈ {α , γ } if x ≤ 0 or x ≥ h, the second additive term can be simplified according to the second Eq. (5.4) with the result 1 dG = dt Ω
dci v µi dx − dt Ω
h 0
ci µi dx.
(5.6)
The mass conservation law reads dci = −Ω ji ; dt
(5.7)
this enables us to reformulate the first additive term of (5.6). We obtain dG =− dt
ji µi dx −
v Ω
h 0
ci µi dx.
72
J. Vala
Integrating by parts, respecting (5.3), we come to the final form of (5.6) dG = dt
ji µi dx −
v Ω
h 0
ci µi dx.
(5.8)
We have to evaluate also the rate Q of dissipation of the total Gibbs energy. Following [20], p. 3955, based on the more extensive analysis of [19], we have Q=
ji2 v2 dx + Ai M
(5.9)
where
c i Di ; (5.10) ΩRT in this expression Di is the tracer diffusion coefficient, R is the gas konstant (8.3143 kmol−1 K−1 ), T is the absolute temperature and M is the interface mobility. Ai =
5.3 Thermodynamic Extremal Principle We shall use the principle of maximum dissipation rate, as it was first applied by [13] for a diffusional process. The kinetics of our system corresponds to the variation dG Q δ + (j∗ , v) = 0 dt 2 by (5.8) and (5.9) with respect to the constraint for substitutional components (5.1). Introducing one Lagrange multiplier λ , we can rewrite this equation as dG Q δ + + λ δkk jk (j∗ , v, λ ) = 0 dt 2 without any additional constraints. Performing the variation, step by step, for j1 , . . . , jr , . . . , jr+q , v and λ , we obtain
˜ ˜jk µk + jk jk + j˜k λ dx = 0 Ak
for every j˜k , the same with a instead of k and with the missing last additive term for every j˜a , v˜ h vv ˜ − ci µi dx + = 0 Ω 0 M for every v˜ and formally also (5.1), multiplied by λ˜ , for every λ˜ .
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
We have derived
µk +
73
jk +λ = 0 Ak
(5.11)
ja =0 Aa
(5.12)
for all substitutional components,
µa + for all interstitial components and v=
Ω M
h 0
ci µi dx
(5.13)
for the interface velocity. From (5.12) the fluxes ja can be expressed directly as ja = −Aa µa . To get the remaining fluxes from (5.11), we need to evaluate λ . Multiplication of (5.11) by Ak and summation of resulting equations gives
δkk Ak λ = −Ak µk − δkk jk . By (5.1) the last additive term is equal to zero, thus
λ =−
Ak µk . δll Al
This enables us to write in general ji = −Ai
Ak µk µi − χ i δll Al
(5.14)
where χi is equal to 1 for i ≤ r, 0 otherwise. Let us introduce the new quantity Ci (x) as the integral of the partial time derivative of ci from xL to any x. Every upper index L will refer to a value in x = xL , every upper index R to a value in x = xR everywhere. Then (5.7) gets the simple integral form Ci − v(ci − cLi ) = −Ω ji . (5.15) cf. [12], p. 1039, where the first additive term is neglected. In particular for x = xR we have CiR = v(cRi − cLi )
(5.16)
(and for x = xL formally CiL = 0). For practical calculations we need to express ji by means of (5.14), (5.10) and (5.5); for this purpose it is useful to introduce the decomposition µif (c∗ ) = µ0if + RT ln ci + ϕif (c∗ ) (5.17)
74
J. Vala f
f
where µ0i are constants for a given temperature T and ϕi are certain functions of f c∗ (usually not dominant, but non-negligible and rather complicated): ϕk depend on f c1 , . . . , cr , ϕa on cr+1 , . . . , cr+q . More detailed thermodynamic analysis is contained in [8]: in the formulae of type (5.17) the first right-hand-side additive term in the second relation is assigned to the Gibbs energy of a mechanical mixture of all constituents of the phase, the second one corresponds to the entropy of mixing and the last one (called excess term) includes other physical processes. Differentiating of (5.5) gives µi = w f µif + w f µif , differentiating of (5.17) similarly
µif =
RT f c + ϕi,g cg ci i
where any lower index.,g means the derivative by cg , thus RT f µi = w f µ0if + RT ln ci + ϕif + w f ci + ϕi,g c g . ci We know that δ f f w f = 1 and consequently also δ f f w f = 0, therefore RT f µi = w f µ0if + ϕif + c + w f ϕi,g cg . ci i The notation
µˆ i = w f µ0if + ϕif ,
f ϕˆ ig = w f ϕi,g
converts this result into its brief form
µi = µˆ i +
RT c + ϕˆ ig cg . ci i
(5.18)
By means of Di from (5.10) the diffusive fluxes from (5.14), corresponding to both substitutional and interstitial components, can be expressed as c i Di c k Dk µ k , µi − χ i ji = − ΩRT c l Dl i.e. for interstitial ones ja = − and for substitutional ones
c a Da µa ΩRT
ck Dk cl Dl µk − µl · . jk = − ΩRT c m Dm
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
75
The additional notation
Di , η = ζm cm D with some (non-zero) reference value D of the tracer diffusion coefficient enables us to simplify this result into the form
ζi =
ja = − or jk = − in general ji = −
ca ζa D µ , ΩRT a
ck ζk D cl ζl · µk − µl ; ΩRT η
ci ζi D cl ζl · µi − χi µl . ΩRT η
Dividing this equation by −ζi D, according to (5.18) we have ci ji RT = µˆ i + ci + ϕˆ im c m − ζi D ΩRT ci ci ζc RT ζl cl ζl cl − χi l l µˆ i + cl + ϕˆ lm c m ; ΩRT η ci η η using the new notation
µk = µˆ k − extended formally by
ζl cl µˆ , η l
µ¯ a = µˆ a ,
ϕ¯ kl = ϕˆ kl −
ζm cm ϕˆ ml , η
ϕ¯ ab = ϕˆ ab ,
we get (multiplying by Ω) finally Ω ji ci ζl ci µ¯ i ci ϕ¯ il − = c i − χi + cl . cl + ζi D η RT RT The application of (5.15) in form −
Ω ji Ci v v L − + ci = c ζi D ζi D ζi D ζi D i
now results −
Ci v L v ζl ϕ¯ µ¯ i + c i + ci −χi + il c l + + ci = c ; ζi D η RT RT ζi D ζi D i
(5.19)
Now it is useful to introduce sum indices n ∈ {1, . . . , r − 1}. For substitutional components let us notice that (5.2) implies c r = −δnn c n
76
J. Vala
and also
η = ζn cn + ζr (1 − δnncn ) = ζr + (ζn − ζr ) cn without any cr ; this offers a chance to eliminate cr at all. Consequently (5.19) with k < r can be rewritten as Ck ζl ϕ¯ ζr ϕ¯ − + c k + ck − + kn c n − ck − + kr δnn c n ζk D η RT η RT µ¯ k v v L + c . + ck = RT ζk D ζk D k Then the notation Bkn = δkn +
ck (ζr − ζn ) ϕ¯ kn − ϕ¯ kr , + η RT
Kkk =
µ¯ k , RT
Nkk =
1 ζk D
simplifies this result to −NkkCk + Bkl c l + (Kkk + vNkk ) ck = vNkk cLk .
(5.20)
For interstitial components (5.19) degenerates to Ca v ϕˆ ab µˆ a v L + ca + ca cb + + c . − ca = ζa D RT RT ζa D ζa D a The similar notation Bab = δab +
ϕˆ ab , RT
Kaa =
µˆ a , RT
Naa =
1 ζa D
simplifies this result to −NaaCa + Bab cb + (Kaa + vNaa) ca = vNaa cLa .
(5.21)
Let us notice that (5.20) and (5.21) have the same formal structure: they can be rewritten in the common matrix form −NC + Bc + (K + vN) c = vNcL .
(5.22)
Here K and N are two square diagonal matrices of order r − 1 + q, B is a square (in general full) matrix of the same order; their elements undefined by (5.20) and (5.21) are set to zero. The first rough estimate B (by the first additive term in both definitions of its elements) could be a unit matrix; B and K are rather complicated functions of c and x, N depends on x only. Let us also remind (5.16), whose vector form is (5.23) CR = v c R − c L , and (5.13), whose vector form, using a scalar product and one new vector y = (µ0 , . . . , µr )T ,
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
77
containing functions of c, is v=
Ω M
h 0
c · y dx.
(5.24)
5.4 Mathematical Problems and Computational Algorithms Let us recall that our problem is to find in any time t ≥ 0 the unknown mole fractions c (and auxiliary variables C) from (5.22) and (5.23) where the interface velocity v comes from (5.24); the initial values of c in time t = 0 are prescribed. From the mathematical point of view, even in the one-dimensional simplification we have a system of r − 1 + q partial differential equations of evolution with the same number of unknown functions, located in the vector c. The coefficients of these equations are strongly nonlinear; consequently their practical evaluation (especially in case of B, but often also of K) needs complicated MAPLE-supported symbolic calculations. Moreover, a non-local multiplicative term is present in the problem, thanks to the evaluation of v by means of certain integral containing c from 0 to h. Unfortunately, the analysis of solvability of such problem is far from trivial. Only for very special configurations the existence and uniqueness of solution has been verified properly, namely in case r = 2 and q = 0; in particular [10] guaranteed a smooth solution for the diffusion induced grain boundary motion (DIGM) in a polycrystalline material. Nevertheless, the proper mathematical analysis of the general integro-differential problem contains still a lot of open questions. Other difficulties are connected with the methodology of measurements and with the reliable identification of (rather uncertain) material characteristics, included in B, K and N, as well as in the absence of a reliable mathematical homogenization technique, bridging the microstructural phenomena and the macroscopic behaviour of material. The analytic solution of our problem (even in simplified cases, because of its integro-differential character) is unknown, moreover no available software package for the numerical analysis of partial differential and integro-differential problems can solve the above formulated system of equations, thus some computational algorithm (not expensive if possible) for the construction of sequences of approximate solutions of the problem is needed. Here we shall only sketch the principal ideas of an original numerical approach, implemented in MATLAB, including standard functions and methods described in [15] and also functions from the MATLAB toolbox symbolic, referring to the core of MAPLE; no other software means are needed. Since in general case most formulae are rather complicated (some of them are just products of MAPLE supported symbolic manipulations), we shall start with intuitive simple schemes, based on the Crank-Nicholson approach, and then we shall mention (without explaining all technical details) necessary and useful generalizations. Let us consider a uniform net, covering the whole moving interval from xL to xR ; the nodes are numbered by integer indices s from 0 to σ , for simplicity xL coincides
78
J. Vala
with x0 and xR coincides with xσ . Let cs = c(xs ) denote the value of c for x = xs ; here xs = x0 + s∆ (∆ is some positive length) with s chosen from the set {1, 2, . . . , σ }. For any s > 0 and Z ∈ {B, K, N} we can define Zs =
1 (Z(cs ) + Z(cs −1)) . 2
Using the method of lines, in each time t we are able to write the semi-discrete version of (5.22) Bs (cs − cs −1) +
∆ (Ks + vNs ) (cs − cs −1 ) = ∆vNs c0 + ∆Cs , 2
(5.25)
obtained by the inaccurate integration of (5.22) from xs −1 to xs , and that of (5.23) Cσ = v (cσ − c0 ) .
(5.26)
Let τ be the constant time step. The rectangular rule enables us to calculate Cs =
∆ × × × c0 − c× 0 + 2(c1 − c1 ) + · · · + 2(cσ −1 − cσ −1 ) + cσ − cσ 2τ
(5.27)
where all symbols c× . refer to values from the previous time step. The similar approach applied to (5.24) gives v=
Ω∆ (cθ · yθ + 2cθ +1 · yθ +1 + · · · + 2cω −1 · yω −1 + cω · yω ) 2M
(5.28)
where θ and ω are integers, 0 < θ < ω < σ , s = θ corresponds (just in the considered time step) to x = 0 and s = ω to x = h. The above sketched numerical analysis makes it possible to suggest the following algorithm, how to evaluate all mole fractions c in each time step: 1. Set all mole fractions c× s by their initial values (in the first time step t = τ ) or by values obtained in time t − τ , then estimate cs as c× s , repeat the same for Cs by (5.27) (with zero initial values in the first time step if no better information is available) 2. Calculate v from (5.28) 3. Set all Bs , Ks and Ns by cs 4. Set c0 as the vector of r − 1 + q unknown parameters (in the program code this can be simulated using the complex arithmetics) 5. Solve (step by step) each cs with positive s from (5.25) (this is always a linear algebraic system of only r − 1 + q equations with r − 1 + q unknowns) 6. Determine c0 from (5.26), then recalculate all cs 7. Applying some error indicator (incorporating changes in values of v and all cs and Cs ), decide to stop iterations, otherwise return to step 2
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
79
Let us remark that the (seemingly not reasonable) limit case τ → ∞ attempts to find the steady-state solution directly (with zero Cs ); however, this works only in special cases, namely for c0 = cσ . This algorithm is rather simple and not expensive. Unfortunately, some other complications occur in practical calculations which can be more evident from the following groups of arguments, forcing substantial generalizations and new software development: 1. The uniform mesh is not realistic because the interface thickness is much less than the specimen size. However, the uniform mesh is acceptable inside the interface; outside the interface the distance between adjacent nodes xs can increase. Moreover, both locations xL and xR must be updated in each time step, thus they are not identical with some nodes in general. Consequently some additional interpolation near xL and xR is needed. 2. The quality of the discretization scheme, presented in (5.25), etc., could be not sufficient. Some possible improvements are intuitive and simple, e.g. the replacement of the rectangular rule by the Simpson one in (5.28), but their effect is not crucial. In practical calculations both in second derivatives of mole fractions c by x and in their mixed derivatives by x and t unpleasant oscillation occur, suppressed only artificially, by non-physical numerical tricks. Therefore some improvements have been tested: (i) Bs , Ks and Ns constructed as linear splines instead of piecewise constant simple functions (ii) cs constructed as cubic Hermite splines instead of linear ones, with derivatives by x coming from a preceding iteration, using the numerical differentiation technique, similarly also C, obtained from numerical integration (iii) Alternatively to (ii) c constructed seemingly exactly (with piecewise fixed B, K and N) from (5.22) instead of (5.25) For illustration, let us analyze the last improvement in more details. Another (partial) discretization of (5.22) is Bs c s + Ls cs = Fs where Ls = Ks + vNs and Fs = N(vc0 + Cs ). Using the standard spectral analysis of linear operators together with the classical calculus of linear systems of differential equations, we obtain cs = Vs exp (Qs (xs−1 − xs )) V−1 cs−1 − L−1 s s Fs where Vs is the matrix of eigenvectors of the matrix B−1 s Ls and Qs is the matrix of its eigenvalues (exp(.) here is understood as a diagonal matrix, too). This can be useful even in special cases: e.g. for zero Ks (which is true everywhere outside the interface because each µˆ i = 0 and consequently each µ¯ i = 0) and zero Cs (which corresponds to the limit steady-state distribution of c with vanishing time derivatives) we have only L−1 s F s = c0 .
80
J. Vala
3. The rather complicated non-local integro-differential character of the problem does not admit the application of any suitable homogenization technique, as described in [9]. Moreover, the identification of material characteristics, included in B, K and N, is difficult; consequently it is not clear how to formulate and study the inverse problems correctly – the mathematical results offered by [6] are insufficient. Most material characteristics can be classified as semi-empirical ones, based both on some physical considerations and on the extensive experimental study, unfortunately not covering all mole fractions of particular components between 0 and 1. Moreover, no physical barrier is incorporated into the system (5.22), (5.23) and (5.24) to prevent negative or other non-realistic mole fractions. For illustration, a function for evaluation of chemical potentials by (5.17) and their needed derivatives, contains typically several hundreds of lines of the source program code in MATLAB, generated automatically by the original MAPLE-based pre-processing software.
5.5 Illustrative Example The crucial point for numerical simulations is to set reasonable material characteristics. In the following example we shall present the three-component Fe-Cr-Ni system, analyzed in more details in [20], p. 3956. In our notation r = 3 and q = 0, moreover Fe will be dominant, thus the interface mobility (whose proposed values differ dramatically in various research sources) can be derived from that for the pure iron. We have only substitutional components here. The tracer diffusion coefficients can be interpolated using the formula ln Dk = w f ln Dkf , thus it is sufficient to set nine values Dkf . In general we have Ef E f f Dk = D k0 exp − , M = M0 exp − . RT RT The constants Dk0 (in m2 s−2 ) are for Cr (corresponding to k = 1), Ni (k = 2) and Fe (k = 3) β γ D1 = 0.00022, D1 = 0.00035, Dα1 = 0.00032, f
β
γ
Dα2 = 0.000048,
D2 = 0.000022,
D2 = 0.000035,
Dα3 = 0.00016,
D3 = 0.00011,
D3 = 0.00007;
β
γ
the constants E f and E (in J mol−1 ) are E α = 240,000, E β = 155,000, E γ = 286,000, E = 140,000. −1
It remains to set M0 = 0.00000041 (in m2 s kg ).
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
81
Our calculations were performed for T = 1,030 (in K); one exception will be f f mentioned. The complicated MATLAB functions for evaluation of µ0k and ϕk were generated automatically, making use of the experimental results from the Montan University in Leoben (Austria). The initial mole fractions (for t = 0) c1 = 0.001 and c2 = 0.019 (consequently c3 = 0.980) were set everywhere; the interface thickness was h = 5 ·10−10 (in m). The following figures demonstrate the distributions of mole fractions for Cr and Ni at the interface; outside the interface they are much less interesting, being similar to exponential curves (exactly for the unit matrix instead of B). Figure 5.2 shows the development of both mole fractions from the initial status (solid line) through various distributions in time (dashed lines) to the final status (solid line), with no visible changes in time greater then 1 s. All remaining figures correspond to such final status; they may justify the great dispersion of published results in the literature. We know that the values of most material characteristics are more qualified estimates than exact deterministic numbers. Figure 5.3 demonstrates what happens in case that E γ is multiplied by 1.1 (dashed line) or 0.9 (dash-dotted line): one can see immediately that the difference of mole fractions at both ends of the interface, i.e. c(h) − c(0), is very sensitive to small changes in diffusion characteristics. Figure 5.4 repeats the same analysis for small changes of interface mobility, namely for E multiplied by 1.15 (dashed line) or 0.85 (dash-dotted line). Similar global tendencies in the redistribution of mole fractions as on Figs. 5.3 and 5.4 can be seen also on Fig. 5.5 where alternatively T = 1,010 and T = 1,050 are prescribed. The increasing temperature forces the substantial decrease of interface velocity v (in ms−1 ): for T = 1,010 we obtained v = 3.58563 · 10−7 , for T = 1,030 still v = 2.77768 · 10−7, whereas for T = 1,050 only v = 7.74894 · 10−8. Figure 5.6
Fig. 5.2 Development of mole fractions for Cr and Ni in time
82
Fig. 5.3 Mole fractions for varying diffusion properties
Fig. 5.4 Mole fractions for varying interface mobility
J. Vala
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
Fig. 5.5 Mole fractions for varying temperature
Fig. 5.6 Chemical potentials of all components
83
84
J. Vala
shows all chemical potentials for the original setting of material characteristics: the first additive terms in (5.17) (dashed lines), the sum of the first and second additive terms in (5.17), i.e. the potentials with neglected complicated non-linear corrections (dash-dotted lines), and finally the total potentials by (5.17) (solid lines).
5.6 Conclusions and Generalizations The illustrative numerical results presented above are clearly not sufficient to validate the model and to verify the convergence of computational algorithms, implemented in the MATLAB environment. Both in the experimental analysis (methodology of laboratory measurements, identification problems, etc.) and in the theoretical one (existence and uniqueness of solutions in some reasonable sense, quality of convergence of numerical algorithms, etc.), there is a lot of open questions yet. Moreover, the simple way of extension of the results from the micro-scale simulations to the macroscopic analysis is not available. Nevertheless, the created software has been tested for more classes of problems of practical importance. In [20] the stationary solver was applied to the Fe-rich Fe-Cr-Ni substitutional system with various types of chemical potentials and values of material characteristics, which may be rather uncertain in practice, namely in case of the interface mobility and thickness; further numerical simulations has been done also for the similar system with the interstitial C-component and for the binary Al-Mg system yet. For every fixed interface thickness h the numerical simulations show that the interface velocity v decreases with the increasing temperature T ; finally the phase transformation stops at certain critical temperature. This critical temperature increases with the increasing interface thickness h; the limit case h → 0 returns the (less realistic) results for an idealized sharp interface. The simulation of the massive γ → α transformation shows that the existence of the solute drag in the interface influences the contact conditions at the interface allowing the massive transformation to occur also in the two-phase region. By choosing α and γ as identical phases and by imposing fluxes to the interface (grain boundary), DIGM was simulated. The interface and grain boundary Gibbs energy were calculated; their realistic values support the responsibility of the model. The MATLAB-supported non-stationary simulations are now performed in the collaboration of researchers from the Institute of Physics of Materials of the Czech Academy of Sciences in Brno (J. Svoboda), from the Brno University of Technology (J. Vala) and from the Montan University of Leoben (F.-D. Fischer, E. Gamsj¨ager). Further generalizations need to incorporate the elastic and creep strain and consequently the shrinking and swelling rate due to the attribute b) in the Introduction; the theoretical background, referring to [4], has been prepared carefully in [17]. Another important research direction is to admit more complicated thermal processes. This leads (from the point of view of the Onsager’s relation) to the coupling of various fluxes, namely the particle flux due to a temperature gradient (Soret effect) and the
5 Modelling of Diffusive and Massive Phase Transformation
85
transport of heat due to a concentration gradient (Dufour effect); more information is contained in [18]. Another direction of possible generalization leads to the two- or even threedimensional models of phase transformation. The one-dimensional formulation covers a wide class of diffusive phase transformations where the interface is planar or nearly planar and has a negligible or constant (a priori known) thickness. If this is not true some more-dimensional formulation is needed. Seemingly it should be not difficult: all equations of diffusion can be rewritten, following [7], in “grad” and “div” notation (replacing the derivatives with respect to x), the simple finite difference approach can be improved by finite element or finite volume techniques, etc. However, the deeper physical analysis shows that some other phenomena, not discusses in this chapter, must be taken into account: namely an additional driving force due to the curvature of the interface and the diffusion along (not only perpendicular to) the interface. The interface migration is moreover allowed to be non-uniform and the assumption on the constant interface thickness may be discreditable. Consequently this type of generalization is rather complicated and cannot be done without additional both theoretical and experimental preliminary research. Acknowledgements The financial support from the Grant Agency of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Reg. No. IAA200410601, is gratefully acknowledged.
References 1. Fan D, Chen SP, Chen LQ (1999) Computer simulation of grain growth kinetics with solute drag. Journal of Material Research 14: 1113–1123 2. Callen HB (1960) Thermodynamics. Wiley, New York 3. Glicksman ME (2000) Diffusion in solids. Wiley, New York 4. Grinfeld MA (1991) Thermodynamic methods in the theory of heterogenous systems. Longman, New York 5. Groot SR, Mazur P (1962) Non-equilibrium thermodynamics. North-Holland, Amsterdam 6. Isakov V (2006) Inverse problems for partial differential equations. Springer, Berlin 7. Jacot A, Rappaz M (1999) A two-dimensional diffusion model for the prediction of phase transformation: application to austenitization and homogenization of hypoeutectoid Fe-C steels. Acta Materialia 45: 575–585 8. Kattner UR (1997) Thermodynamic modelling of multicomponent phase equilibria. JOM 49: 14–19 9. Marchenko V, Khruslov EYa (2006) Homogenization of partial differential equations. Birkh¨auser, Boston, MA 10. Mayer UF, Simonett G (1999) Classical solutions for diffusion-induced grain boundary motion. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications 234: 660–674 11. Onsager L (1931) Reciprocal relations in irreversible processes. Physical Review 37: 405–426, and 38: 2265–2279 12. Odqvist J, Sundman B, Agren J (2003) A general method for calculating deviation from local equilibrium at phase interfaces. Acta Materialia 51: 1035–1043 13. Onsager L (1945) Theories and problems of liquid diffusion. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 46: 241–265
86
J. Vala
14. Schneider A, Inden G (2004) Fundamentals and basic methods for microstructure simulation above the atomic scale. In: Raabe D, Roters F, Barlat F, Chen LQ (eds) Continuum Scale Simulation of Engineering Materials. Wiley-VCH, New York, Part I, 36 pp 15. Stanoyevitch A (2005) Introduction to numerical ordinary and partial differential equations using MATLAB. Wiley, New York 16. Svoboda J, Fischer FD, Fratzl P (2002) Diffusion in multi-component alloys with no or dense sources and sinks for vacancies. Acta Materialia 50: 1369–1381 17. Svoboda J, Fischer FD, Fratzl P (20061 ) Diffusion and creep in multi-component alloys with non-ideal sources and sinks for vacancies. Acta Materialia 54: 3043–3053 18. Svoboda J, Fischer FD, Vala J (2007) Thermodynamic extremal principle and its application to Dufour and Sorret effects and plasticity. Atti della Accademia Peloritana dei Pericolanti, to appear, 12 pp 19. Svoboda J, Gamsj¨ager E, Fischer FD, Fratzl P (2004) Application of the thermodynamic extremal principle to the diffusional phase transformation. Acta Materialia 52: 959–967 20. Svoboda J, Vala J, Gamsj¨ager E, Fischer FD (2006) A thick-interface model for diffusive and massive phase transformation in substitutional alloys. Acta Materialia 54: 3953–3960
Chapter 6
The Use of Finite Elements for Approximation of Field Variables on Local Sub-Domains in a Mesh-Free Way V. Sladek, J. Sladek, and Ch. Zhang
Abstract The paper deals with the numerical implementations of local integral equation formulation for the solution of two-dimensional (2-d) problems in linear elastic media with continuously variable Young’s modulus. Two kinds of the finite element based interpolation are developed for approximation of field variables on local sub-domains around nodal points. One of these approximations can be classified as meshless, since the elements are generated automatically from the predefined nodal points on the analyzed domain. The other one utilizes the predefined mesh of elements. Besides the element based interpolations we present also the meshless Point Interpolation Method. The accuracy, convergence, numerical stability and efficiency of the proposed techniques are tested by numerical examples with using the exact benchmark solutions.
6.1 Introducion A rapid progress can be observed in the development of various meshless techniques especially in fluid problems. Simultaneously, a considerable expansion of such techniques can be found also in various applications to engineering and science problems. This can be explained by the fact that there are known certain limitations of standard discretization techniques especially when applied to some classes of problems (e.g. problems in separable media, problems with free or moving boundaries; crack problems; problems with large distortions, degenerate elements, etc.). The question about using either mesh or not mesh has been discussed recently in the paper [1], but it seems that this question can not be answered definitely because V. Sladek and J. Sladek Institute of Construction and Architecture, Slovak Academy of Sciences, 845 03 Bratislava, Slovakia Ch. Zhang Department of Civil Engineering, University of Siegen, D-57068 Siegen, Germany V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
87
88
V. Sladek et al.
of advantages and disadvantages on both the sides. Even if the standard discretization techniques are applicable to the numerical solution of complex boundary value problems with including more or less modifications, it is still reasonable to develop new formulations by proper modelling of essential physical properties and advanced approximations of unknown physical fields in a consistent way. Simultaneously, the modelling as well as approximations should be as simple as possible without violating previous assumptions. For instance, in continuously non-homogeneous elastic media, the formulations developed for homogeneous media are not applicable directly, since the governing equations are now given by partial differential equations with variable coefficients. There is not a unique classification of meshless techniques up to now. Mostly they are classified according to the employed approximation. Some of the techniques utilize meshless approximation of field variables but a background mesh is still required for numerical integration especially in approaches based on global formulations. On the other hand, the local formulations bring a possibility to avoid the mesh completely with using nodes alone for approximation. Then, the physical principles can be formulated in integral forms on local sub-domains. A large group of meshless techniques are denoted as meshless local Petrov-Galerkin methods [2, 3] with bearing in mind that the Petrov-Galerkin weak form idea is applied in a local sense with selecting the trial and test functions independently and approximating the field variables in a meshless way. The strong formulations of the problems of mathematical physics and engineering sciences are given by partial differential equations (PDE). Thus, the strong formulations have a local character in contrast to the global character of the standard FEM formulations. Certain globalization is requisite by introducing a finite number of degrees of freedom via discretization, in order to keep an interaction among the discrete degrees of freedom. In present paper, we shall use local integral equations (LIE) considered on certain sub-domains around each nodal point, with nodal values of the field variable being the degrees of freedom. Note that the governing PDE are derived from the integral form of the balance equations valid on an arbitrary small sub-domain. Hence, the consideration of the LIEs on finite size local sub-domains brings a proper physical interaction among the discrete degrees of freedom. It is well known that the polynomial interpolation used for approximation of field variables within finite elements is reasonable and useful because of convergence of numerical results with increasing the density of nodes. The most of the objections against the mesh based methods consists in the criticism of the complexity of mesh generation including re-meshing (meshes must be conforming), degenerate elements (elements must have reasonable shape) and difficulties resulting from respect of boundaries. In this paper, instead of a permanent global mesh of finite elements, we shall use only nodes on the analyzed 2-d domain and triangular finite elements of appropriate shape will be generated automatically around particular nodes independently with simultaneous creation of sub-domains formed from these triangles. Since the dimensionality of employed elements is the same as that of the analyzed domain, the gradients of the field variable can be approximated as
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
89
gradients of the approximated field variable. Thus, both the essential and natural boundary conditions can be involved by collocation at adequate boundary nodes. The present method is applied to two-dimensional problems of linear elasticity. In numerical tests for problems with existing exact solutions, we compare the accuracy and efficiency of the LIE formulations implemented by proposed local finite element meshes and other meshless approximations.
6.2 Governing Equations The elastic processes described within the theory of elasticity are governed by force equilibrium which in the case of static loading is given as
σ ji, j (x) + Xi(x) = 0, in Ω,
(6.1)
where σij is the stress tensor due to cohesive forces as a response to external loadings and Xi (x) are volume forces. The relationship between the inherent forces and deformations of the linear elastic continuum is given by the generalized Hooke’s law
σij (x) = ci jkl (x)uk,l (x),
(6.2)
where uk (x) are Cartesian components of the displacement field and the tensor of material coefficients ci jkl is position-dependent in non-homogeneous media. In case of isotropic media, it is defined by only two coefficients, e.g. Young’s modulus E(x) and Poisson’s ratio ν which is usually taken as constant. Then, the constitutive law can be written as
coijkl
ci jkl (x) = E(x)coijkl , 1 2ν¯ δij δkl , = δik δ jl + δil δ jk + 2(1 + ν ) 1 − 2ν¯
where the new parameter ν¯ is defined by the Poisson ratio as ν /(1 + ν ), for plane stress conditions ν¯ = . ν, otherwise
(6.3)
(6.4)
Einstein’s summation convention rule is assumed, δij stands for the Kronecker delta and the subscript following a comma denotes the partial derivative with respect to the corresponding Cartesian coordinate. Inserting (6.3) and (6.2) into (6.1), we obtain the governing PDE for the displacements (6.5) E(x)coijkl uk,lj (x) + E, j (x)coijkl uk,l (x) = −Xi (x), The standard boundary conditions prescribe either the displacements or the tractions on the Dirichlet and Neumann part of the boundary, respectively
90
V. Sladek et al.
ui (η ) = u˜i (η ) at η ∈ ∂ ΩD , n j (η )ci jkl (η )uk,l (η ) = t˜i (η ) at η ∈ ∂ ΩN .
(6.6)
The fundamental solution for the governing equation is defined as the solution of Eq. (6.5) for point forces Xi (x) = δim δ (x − y), (m = 1, . . . , d) in an infinite space with the dimensionality d. Apparently, the fundamental solution of the PDE with variable coefficients is not available in closed form in the case of general material non-homogeneity. Consequently, the pure boundary formulation based on integral equations is not available. It would appear each numerical solution of BVP in elastic media with arbitrary non-homogeneity should utilize both the boundary and interior degrees of freedom (d.o.f.).
6.3 Domain-Type Approximation of Displacements Let the displacements ui (x) be approximated within a sub-domain Ωs ⊂ (Ω ∪ ∂ Ω). If both Ωs and Ω have the same dimension, then we call the approximation as a domain-type approximation. One of the possibilities to achieve a domain-type approximation is to use standard finite size domain elements like in FEM.
6.3.1 Finite Element Approximation In standard FEM formulations, a 2-d plane domain Ω is assumed to be subdivided into m conforming serendipity elements Se [4] with polynomial interpolation for the approximation of both the geometry and displacements. Then, m
Ω = ∪ Se , e=1
ui (x)|Se =
xi |Se =
n
∑ xaei N a (ξ1 , ξ2 ),
a=1
n
∑ ui (xae )N a (ξ1 , ξ2 ),
(6.7)
a=1
where xae i are the Cartesian coordinates of the ath nodal point on Se and the interpolation polynomials N a represent the shape functions. Since in local formulations, the shape of local sub-domains is arbitrary, they can be formed as union of elements adjacent to the considered node. The finite elements can be created either by pre-discretization of the global domain like in FEM formulations or automatically by using an algorithm and predefined mesh of nodes inside and on the boundary of the global domain. In this paper, we shall apply both these approaches. The latter one will be utilized in automatic creation of linear triangular elements around a considered node (linear interpolation, n = 3). The linear triangular elements are created from the nearest nodes to the considered collocation node xc in such a way that their union results in a local sub-domain Ωc xc (Fig. 6.1).
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
91
Fig. 6.1 Local sub-domains around interior and boundary nodes xc and xb , respectively
Then, the approximation on the local sub-domain Ωc is given by linear interpolations within particular elements forming Ωc . Having known the approximation for displacements (6.7), one can express also the gradients of displacements in terms of the same nodal values [5] as n a ∂ ui (x) ae ∂ N (ξ1 , ξ2 ) = (he )−1 , j p ∑ ui (x ) ∂ x j Se ∂ ξp a=1 (he )−1 jp =
ε3 jl ε3pk hekl (ξ1 , ξ2 ) , ε3mn he1m (ξ1 , ξ2 )he2n (ξ1 , ξ2 )
(6.8)
with (he )−1 being the inverse matrix to the matrix he whose matrix elements are given as n ∂ N a (ξ1 , ξ2 ) , (6.9) heα m (ξ1 , ξ2 ) = ∑ xae m ∂ ξα a=1 which are the Cartesian components (m = 1, 2) of two non-collinear vectors heα (ξ1 , ξ2 ) defined for α = 1, 2 on each domain element. Furthermore, εki j is the permutation tensor, ε312 = −ε321 = 1, ε311 = ε322 = 0. Although the automatic generation of local sub-domains around collocation nodes by creation of linear triangular elements is rather simple, one cannot say it in the case of quadratic and higher order interpolation elements. On the other hand, the use of nonlinear elements is desired for efficiency of computations under guarantee of reasonable accuracy. In order to compare the accuracy and efficiency of computations we shall use also quadratic triangular elements for approximation of displacements. However, instead of automatic generation of quadratic elements, we shall pre-discretize the global analyzed domain into such elements. Then, the sub-domain around a collocation node is formed as a union of elements adjacent to this node. Figure 6.2 illustrates the creation of local sub-domains around collocation nodes in case uniform distribution of nodes within the square domain by using either quadratic or linear triangular elements. The main difference between these two approaches consists in fact that the quadratic elements are taken from the predefined mesh of elements while the linear elements are generated automatically from the mesh of nodes. In order to distinguish these two approaches, we shall refer them as Mesh-Based Finite Element Interpolation (MBFEI) and Mesh-Free Finite Element Interpolation (MFFEI), respectively.
92
V. Sladek et al.
Fig. 6.2 Creation of local sub-domains around collocation nodes by using: (a) uniform mesh of quadratic triangular elements; (b) uniform distribution of nodes and automatic generation of linear triangular elements
Recall that in all meshless approximation techniques, shape functions have to be defined for the approximation of the field variable ui (x) within a sub-domain Ωs ⊂ (Ω ∪ ∂ Ω) using only nodes scattered arbitrarily in the analyzed domain without any predefined mesh to provide a connectivity of the nodes. According to this classification of approximation techniques, both the presented approaches for interpolation of displacements are to be considered as element based even if in MFFEI we use only the mesh of nodes and elements are formed automatically during the creation of local sub-domains around each node. There is no correlation among elements utilized for creation of local sub-domains adjacent to different nodes. Since only the mesh of nodes is to be predefined in the MFFEI approach, it resembles closely the other meshless techniques. The shape functions utilized in the MFFEI are the Lagrange interpolation polynomials (although defined in the intrinsic coordinate space of each element) and so they are much simpler than those used in other meshless approximations. Finally, using the elemental interpolation (MBFEI and/or MFFEI) one reduces the problem of field unknowns to a finite number of unknowns which are represented by nodal displacements. Another kind of meshless approximation will be presented in the next sub-section.
6.3.2 Point Interpolation Method (PIM) q
Assuming a finite series representation of the field variable in a sub-domain Ωs surrounding the nodal point xq , the approximated field can be written as ui (x)|Ωqs =
N
∑ Ba(x)cai (xq)
a=1
(6.10)
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
93
Fig. 6.3 Selection of N nodal points associated with point xq
where Ba (x) are the basis functions defined in the Cartesian coordinate space, N is the number of nodes in the interpolation domain of the point xq , and cai (xq ) are the expansion coefficients at a given point xq . The interpolation domain is defined as a domain that involves nodes which influence the approximation in Ωqs . Usually, the interpolation domain is determined by its radius ri (xq ), as showin in Fig. 6.3. Selecting the basis functions as monomials or radial functions, one obtains the polynomial PIM or radial PIM, respectively [6]. The polynomial PIM exhibits many excellent properties with respect to the consistency and accuracy of the method, as long as the moment matrix is invertible [6]. The possible singularity of the moment matrix is dependent on the distribution of nodal points. In [6], several techniques have been proposed to avoid a singular moment matrix. On the other hand, in the case of radial PIM the moment matrix is nonsingular but the consistency is not guaranteed and the accuracy of the approximation is sensitive to the choice of the shape parameters. One way to ensure the reproduction of the linear field (C1 consistency) in the radial PIM and to avoid singular moment matrix in the polynomial PIM is to use a radial-polynomial basis [6]. Two different types of modifications of the polynomial basis by multiquadrics (radial functions) have been proposed in [7] in order to avoid the singularity of the moment matrix and to stabilize the method with respect to properly selected shape parameters involved in the multiquadrics. According to numerical tests [7] of accuracy and stability, we propose to use a combination of M polynomial basis functions and N radial basis functions with N > M. Let n(q, k) be the global number of the k-th nearest nodal point of N supporting n(q,k+1) q q nodes associated with x . Thus, n(q, 1) = q and x − x ≥ xn(q,k) − xq for k = 1, . . . , N − 1. Taking both the polynomial functions and the multiquadrics as the basis functions in Eq. (6.10), we may write ui (x)|Ωqs =
N
(q,k)
∑ Rn(q,k)(x)αi
k=1
M
(q,k)
+ ∑ Pk (x)βi
,
(6.11)
k=1
where the radial basis is given by multiquadrics [8] m/2 Rn (x) = |x − xn|2 + s2 ,
(6.12)
94
V. Sladek et al.
with s and m being the shape parameters, and the polynomial basis Pk (x) is given by monomials. For k = 1, . . . , 6 and M = 6 we have for instance Pk (x) ∈ 1, r1 , r2 , r1 r2 , r12 , r22 , ri = xi − xqi . (6.13) The choice M = 6 corresponds to utilization of a complete quadratic polynomial basis. Starting from the approximation given by Eq. (6.11), one can get the interpolation of the field variable in terms of its nodal values and the shape functions [7] as ui (x)|Ωqs =
N
∑ ui (xn(q, j))ϕ (q, j)(x).
(6.14)
j=1
Then, the gradients of the field variable are approximated on Ωqs as uk,i (x)Ωq = s
N
(q, j)
∑ uk (xn(q, j))ϕ,i
(x).
(6.15)
j=1
The explicit expressions of the shape functions and their derivatives in terms of the basis functions and their nodal values are given elsewhere [7].
6.4 Discretized Boundary Conditions Assuming arbitrary of the presented interpolations, we recast the field unknowns into the finite number of nodal values of displacements being the discrete degrees of freedom (DOF). Certain relationships among the DOFs are given by the discretized boundary conditions resulting from the prescribed boundary conditions collocated at adequate boundary nodes and implemented with the approximation of displacements and their gradients. Thus, in the case of the finite element interpolations, we may write the discretized boundary conditions (6.6) in view of Eqs. (6.7) and (6.8) as ubi = u˜i (ζ b ),
if ζ b ∈ ∂ ΩD ,
(6.16)
n a n j (ζ b )ci jkl (ζ b ) m e −1 be be ae ∂ N be be = t˜i (ζ b ), (h ) ξ , ξ u (x ) ξ , ξ k ∑ ∑ 1 2 1 2 l p mb ∂ ξp e=1 a=1 b
if ζ b ∈ ∂ ΩN
(6.17)
in which (ξ1be , ξ2be ) are the intrinsic coordinates of ζb ∈ Se , mb is the number of discretization elements adjacent to ζb . The unit normal vector ni (ζb ) is taken as the average of normal vectors evaluated at ζb if mb > 1. Assuming existence of potential
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
95
gradients at corners, one can select arbitrary one of two sides joint at the corner for ¯ b ) in Eq. (6.17) the definition of the normal vector ni (ζb ) and the prescribed flux q(ζ provided that the Neumann boundary conditions are prescribed on both sides of the corner. Similar, the PIM – discretization of the boundary conditions is given by N
ui (ζ b ) = u˜i (ζ b ), since
∑ ui(xn(b,a))ϕ (b,a) (ζ b ) = ui(ζ b )
(6.18)
a=1
in case of Dirichlet condition, whereas in case of Neumann condition, we have N
(b,a)
n j (ζ b )ci jkl (ζ b ) ∑ uk (xn(b,a) )ϕ,l
(ζ b ) = t˜i (ζ b ) at ζ b ∈ ∂ ΩN
(6.19)
a=1
Another possibility to take the traction boundary conditions into account will be discussed later. In order to obey the interaction among the DOFs properly, the governing equations should be considered appropriately. A direct collocation of the governing PDE at each interior node xc and supplemented with a domain-type approximation of the field variable yields usually an ill-conditioned system of algebraic equations and the solution procedure should be supplemented by domain decomposition as well as regularization techniques. In the next section, we present another variant of the governing laws which can be used successfully for the interaction among the DOFs.
6.5 Local Integral Equations In discretized formulations, the governing equations are usually considered in a weak-form sense. In order to exclude physically inadmissible solutions, we shall consider the integral equivalent of the governing equations, i.e. the integral form of the balance equations which are given by an integral form of force equilibrium in case of elasticity problems. Note here that it is not necessary to include any DOF into the mutual interaction with each other. It is sufficient to use a spreading of the interaction throughout the whole body. Thus, a finite-range interaction might be used in the numerical implementation but a coupling at least between neighboring local sub-domains is required. The use of a finite range interaction leads to a sparse system matrix for the computation of the unknown DOF. Therefore, we propose to consider the integral form of the force equilibrium on local sub-domains around each interior knot. Basically, the size, shape and composition of the sub-domains can be chosen arbitrarily, since artificial boundaries are irrelevant to the formulation. Nevertheless, the influence of the choice of these factors on the numerical results cannot be excluded completely from the numerical point of view.
96
V. Sladek et al.
The general physical balance principles of a continuum theory take the form of integral equations. The governing equations or field equations take the form of differential equations which can be derived from these integral equations because they hold for all arbitrary but small material domains Ωc . Following a reverse path, we can get the integral form of the balance principles by integrating the governing differential equations over Ωc ⊂ Ω. Thus, integration of Eq. (6.1) leads to
σ ji, j (x)dΩ(x) = −
Ωc
Xi (x)dΩ(x)
(6.20)
Ωc
By applying the Gauss divergence theorem to Eq. (6.20) and bearing in mind the Cauchy equations for the tractions, ti = σij n j , we obtain an integral form of the balance principle as −
∂ Ωc
−
∂ Ωc
ti (η )dΓ(η ) =
Xi (x)dΩ(x), or
Ωc
n j (η )ci jkl (η )uk,l (η )dΓ(η ) =
Xi (x)dΩ(x),
(6.21)
Ωc
where n j (η ) denotes the Cartesian components of the unit outward normal vector at η on the boundary ∂ Ωc of the sub-domain Ωc . Equation (6.21) is an expression of the force equilibrium in an arbitrary material domain Ωc . Hence, it is a physically admissible constraint that can be used as a coupling equation in the computation of the unknown DOF of the discretized problem. The unknown field variable is involved only in the integral over the boundary of the local sub-domain. In contrast to the integral equations with singular fundamental solutions, Eq. (6.21) is completely nonsingular and moreover, it does not involve the domain integral of unknowns even if the elastic medium is non-homogeneous. In contrast to the global integral formulation, the local one in combination with a meshless approximation of field variables enables us to develop truly meshless formulations, since no mesh of elements is needed for modeling the whole analyzed domain or its boundary. Moreover, the resulting system matrix of the discretized equations can be sparse provided that we use a short range interaction among the degrees of freedom. To complete the system of linear algebraic equations for the computation of nodal values of displacements, we propose to utilize integral equations on local sub-domains surrounding interior nodes and supplement the discretized boundary conditions given in Section 6.4. As regards the numerical implementation of the integral equations on local sub-domains, let us consider firstly the LIE implemented with using the MFFEI. Let mc be the number of linear triangular elements Tec adjamc c c c cent to the interior node x . Then, the local sub-domain Ω = e=1 Te . Denoting the vertex of each element Tec coinciding with xc as the first local node, the boundary of c c c the local sub-domain is given as ∂ Ωc = m e=1 Γe (2,3), where Γe (2,3) is the side of c Te between the local nodes #2 and 3 (see, Fig. 6.4).
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
97
Fig. 6.4 Linear triangular elements in: (a) global coordinate system; (b) local coordinate system
Thus,
·
( )dΓ =
∂ Ωc
mc
∑
·
( )dΓ =
e=1 c Γe (2,3)
mc
∑
e=1
2 0
dΓ ( ) ds
·
ds = Γce (2,3)
mc
∑
2
e=1
0
·
( )ge (s)ds, (6.22)
since dΓ = xk |Γce (2,3) =
(∂ x1 /∂ s)2 + (∂ x2 /∂ s)2 ds, 3
∑ xaek N a (1 − s/2,
√ 3s/2) ≡ xek (s),
a=1
√ √ √ ∂ xk 3 e 1 e e h2k (1 − s/2, s 3/2), = − h1k (1 − s/2, s 3/2) + gk (s) = ∂ s Γce (2,3) 2 2 ge = (ge1 )2 + (ge2)2 , τk |Γce (2,3) = gek (s)/ge (s), ni |Γce (2,3) = εik3 gek (s)/ge (s).
a
N N,1a N,2a
a=1 √ √ √ ( 3 − 3ξ1 − ξ2)/2 3 −1/2 √ −1/2 3
a=2 √ √ √ ( 3 + 3ξ1 − ξ2 )/2 3 1/2 √ −1/2 3
(6.23) a=3 √ ξ2 / 3 0 √ 1/ 3
Now, assuming the body forces to be absent, we may write the discretized LIE (6.21) as mc
coijkl ε jq3 ∑
3
∑ uk (xae )
e=1 a=1
2
√ 1 − s/2, s E (xe (s)) geq (s) (he )−1 3/2 lp
0
⊗
√ ∂ Na 1 − s/2, s 3/2 ds = 0 ∂ ξp
(6.24)
98
V. Sladek et al.
Fig. 6.5 Illustration of local sub-domain around a boundary node on ∂ ΩN
In the case of PIM, the discretization of the LIE is much simpler, because of the integration in the global Cartesian coordinate system. Thus, in view of (6.15), the LIE (6.21) becomes coijkl
N
∑ uk (xn(c,a) )
a=1
(c,a)
E(x)n j (x)ϕ,l
(x)dΓ(x) = 0.
(6.25)
∂ Ωc
Recall that we can use geometrically simple circular sub-domains around each interior node which is also the center of the sub-domain, since size, shape and composition of sub-domains Ωc can be chosen arbitrarily. Then, the integrations over the boundary as well as over the interior of the sub-domains can be performed very easily. Finally, we briefly discuss an alternative implementation of the traction boundary conditions. Within the concept of local sub-domains, it is straightforward to consider the force equilibrium in the integral form on a local sub-domain Ωc surrounding the boundary node xc ∈ ∂ ΩN as coijkl
N
a=1
Lc
∑ uk (xn(c,a))
E(η )n j (η )ϕ,l (c,a) (η )dΓ(η ) = −
t˜i (η )dΓ
(6.26)
ΓcN
where ΓcN = ∂ ΩN ∩ ∂ Ωc , Lc = ∂ Ωc − ΓcN as shown in Fig. 6.5.
6.6 Numerical Examples In order to test the proposed numerical methods, we consider examples for which analytical solutions are available. The body forces are vanishing in Ω, Poisson’s ratio is constant and taken as ν = 0.25 and the gradation of Young’s modulus is given by a prescribed function E(x) = E0 f (x). In the study of the convergence and accuracy of the numerical results with respect to the increasing density of nodal points, we use the average %-error defined as
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
99
Fig. 6.6 Sketch of the analyzed domain with prescribed boundary conditions
GPE = 100
Nt
∑
1/2 ∆uai ∆uai
/
a=1
Nt
∑
1/2 a ex a uex i (x )ui (x )
,
a=1
a ∆uai = unum (xa ) − uex i i (x ),
(6.27)
where Nt is the total number of nodes on the closed domain Ω ∪ ∂ Ω. If we consider an elastic square domain L×L with vertical gradation of the Young modulus and subjected to homogeneous tension load on the top with fixed bottom in vertical direction, the problem is 1-dimensional and we can find the exact solution for some kinds of variation of the Young modulus [9]. Then, the tractions on the lateral sides are given by the analytical solution (see Fig. 6.6). In this paper, we shall consider two variations of the Young modulus as well as homogeneous case: (A) Homogeneous medium (simple tension) u2 (x) =
(1 + ν )(1 − ν¯ ) qx2 , E
u1 (x) =
σij = qδi2 δ j2
−ν¯ (1 + ν ) qx1 , E (6.28)
(B) Exponential gradation of Young’s modulus f (x) = (a exp(δ x2 /L) + b exp(−δ x2 /L))2 A2 1 − e−2δ x2/L u2 (x2 ) = √ , E0 a + be−2δ x2/L A2 =
1 (1 + ν )(1 − 2ν¯ ) Lq √ , ¯ 2(1 − ν ) δ E0 a + b
ν¯ A1 √ u1 (x2 ) = δi1 δ j1 = const, A1 − arbitrary, σij = q δi2 δ j2 + 1 − ν¯ a E0 (6.29)
100
V. Sladek et al.
(C) Power-law gradation of Young’s modulus f (x) = (1 + δ x2/L)2 A2 x2 (1 + ν )(1 − 2ν¯ ) √ , A2 = u2 (x2 ) = √ q, E0 1 + δ x2 /L (1 − ν¯ ) E0 LA1 2ν¯ (1 + ν ) √ δi1 δ j1 . u1 (x2 ) = √ = const, A1 − arbitrary, σij = q δi2 δ j2 + δ E0 (1 − ν¯ ) E0
(6.30) In the presented numerical results, we have used the parameters: a = 1, b = 0, E0 = 1, δ = 0.5, and the plane strain conditions. As regards the discretization, we shall use regular distributions of nodes in both the horizontal and vertical directions, but with different linear densities (see Fig. 6.7a). The number of nodes is Nt = n1 × n2 in case of the MFFEI approach, while the number of triangular elements with quadratic interpolation is m = e1 × l2 in case of the MBFEI approach when Nt = (e1 + 1) × (2l2 + 1). Finally, in the discretization by the PIM, the radius of the interpolation domain a a is taken as ria = 3.001 ha, the radius of circular sub-domains r = 0.98 h , the shape a a b parameter s = 2, m = 5, M = 10 where h = min x − x . ∀b
Figure 6.8 shows the results of the study of convergence of accuracy as the density of nodes is increased. Since the exact solution is given by the linear dependence of displacements on the coordinates, the increasing number of nodes only increases the numerical error. Nevertheless, the accuracy by any of the employed approach is very good for a wide range of the h parameter. It is seen (Fig. 6.9) that the convergence of accuracy is achieved in nonhomogeneous media by each of the applied approaches. The convergence rate by the mesh based approach with quadratic approximation over triangular elements is comparable with that of meshless PIM approach, though the accuracy by the latter one is several orders better. The convergence rate by the mesh free approach with automatic generation of linear triangular elements is much slower. That is why the efficiency of the MFFEI approach is much worse as compared with that of the other two approaches. This can be seen from Fig. 6.10 with bearing in mind both the accuracy and CPU-times. The CPU-times are not affected by the material in-homogeneity. The accuracies shown in Fig. 6.10 corresponds to the exponentially graded Young modulus.
Fig. 6.7 Scheme of the distribution of nodes in: (a) MFFEI approach; (b) MBFEI approach
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
101
Fig. 6.8 Convergence of accuracy in homogeneous square domain with increasing the density of nodes (decreasing h parameter)
Moreover, the efficiency of the PIM approach is much better than that of the MBFEI. This can be illustrated in Fig. 6.10, for instance in the case of accuracy 0.02%, the CPU-time by the MBFEI is more than 1,500 times longer than that of the PIM approach. In order to study the numerical stability of the considered meshless techniques with respect to distribution of nodal points, we have made 7 disturbances of the uniform distribution of nodes (Fig. 6.11). Figure 6.12 shows the accuracies obtained for considered nodal point distributions. In the case of homogeneous medium, the total number of nodes is 36 while in the case of exponentially graded Young modulus it is 676. It is seen from Fig. 6.12 that the PIM approach exhibits numerical stability while the MFFEI approach yield results with unacceptable accuracy for any disturbed distribution of nodes.
6.7 Conclusions The paper presents the development and application of two element based approximations to numerical implementation of local integral formulation for solution of elasticity problems in non-homogeneous media. One of these approximations, the
102
V. Sladek et al.
Fig. 6.9 Convergence of accuracy in non-homogeneous square domain with increasing the density of nodes for: (a) exponential gradation; (b) power-law gradation of Young’s modulus
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
103
Fig. 6.10 Comparison of CPU-times with giving extreme accuracies by three numerical approaches
MFFEI (mesh free finite element interpolation) needs only predefinition of nodal points distribution in the analyzed domain. Then, the linear triangular elements are generated automatically. The second one, MBFEI (mesh based finite element interpolation) utilizes the triangular elements with quadratic interpolation. These elements are taken from the predefined mesh of such elements on the analyzed domain, since the automatic generation of non-linear elements is not simple problem. For comparison of numerical results in test examples, we have considered also the other meshless approximation developed previously (PIM). The following conclusions can be drawn • The formulation is quite general without any restriction to continuous variation of the Young modulus as well as the shape and size of the analyzed domain. • The system matrix of the discretized equations is sparse; the numerical integrations are simple and accurate by using standard quadratures, since there are no singularities. • The accuracies obtained by the developed techniques converge to the exact solution with increasing the density of nodes in both cases of gradation of Young’s modulus. • The convergence rate in case of the MFFEI approach is too slow to yield an efficient numerical computational technique. The CPU-time is very long as compared with that by other presented techniques in order to achieve comparable accuracy.
104
V. Sladek et al.
Fig. 6.11 Uniform distribution of 36 nodal points (A) and its 7 various disturbances (B)–(H)
6 The Use of Finite Elements on Local Sub-Domains
105
Fig. 6.12 Diagrams of accuracies by two meshless techniques obtained for various distributions of nodal points for (a) homogeneous medium; (b) exponentially graded Young’s modulus
• The MFFEI approach does not exhibit the numerical stability with respect to the variations in the distribution of nodal points, though the PIM approach does. Since the Lagrange polynomial interpolations could be effectively utilized in numerical implementation of the solution formulations based on local integral equations, the aim to develop automatic generation of higher order finite elements from the predefined distribution of nodal points is still attractive. Acknowledgements The authors acknowledge support by the Slovak Science and Technology Assistance Agency (APVV-20-035404, APVV-51-021205), the Slovak Grant Agency (VEGA – 2/6109/6), and the German Research Foundation (DFG).
References 1. Idelson SR, Onate E (2006) To mesh or not to mesh. That is the question. . ., Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering 195: 4681–4696 2. Atluri SN, Shen S (2002) The meshless local Petrov-Galerkin (MLPG) method. Tech Science Press, Encino 3. Atluri SN (2004) The meshless method (MLPG) for domain & BIE discretizations. Tech Science Press, Forsyth 4. Hughes TJR (1987) The Finite Element Method. Linear Static and Dynamic Finite Element Analysis. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ 5. Sladek V, Sladek J, Zhang Ch (2005) Local integro-differential equations with domain elements for numerical solution of PDE with variable coefficients. Journal of Engineering and Mathematics 51: 261–282 6. LIU GR (2003) Mesh free methods, Moving beyond the finite element method. CRC, Boca Raton, FL 7. Sladek V, Sladek J, Tanaka M (2005) Local integral equations and two meshless polynomial interpolations with application to potential problems in non-homogeneous media. CMESComputer Modeling in Engineering and Sciences 7: 69–83
106
V. Sladek et al.
8. Hardy RL (1990) Theory and applications of the multiquadrics-biharmonic method (20 years of discovery 1968–1988). Computers and Mathematics with Application 19: 163–208 9. Sladek V, Sladek J, Zhang Ch (2006) A meshless Point Interpolation Method for Local Integral Equations in elasticity of non-homogeneous media. In: Sladek J, Sladek V (eds.) Advances in the Meshless Method. Tech Science Press, Forsyth, pp 263–290
Chapter 7
Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites Alexandre Vakhrouchev
Abstract The methods for the modelling of the processes that accompany obtaining and use of powder nanocomposites are presented. For this purpose, a number of physical-mathematical models, including the models of obtaining of nano-sized powders at ‘up down’ processes, the models of the main compaction steps of powder nanocomposites and the models of deformation of powder nanocomposites under the ambient action were developed. A number of numerical examples of modelling based on the models developed are considered.
7.1 Introduction The use of new composites based on powders, especially powder nanocomposites (PNCs), shows that complete realization of their strength and performance properties requires a significantly higher level of prediction of physical-mechanical properties of these materials and the development of new material-engineering methods, which should include a complex analysis of the processes of the formation of composites and structural components [8, 11, 14]. This is dictated by high sensitivity of physical-mechanical properties of PNCs to the composition and structure variations of parent materials and their components and to the parameters of the technological process of product manufacturing. It also should be noted that the processes that accompany obtaining and use of PNCs are very complex and diverse and their space and time scales embrace a wide range [1, 2, 15, 17]. Therefore, the investigation of the above processes using experimental methods only is difficult. Hence, it is necessary to consider the modelling of physical-mechanical processes in PNCs at different structural levels with regard to a complete analysis of the entire “history” Alexandre Vakhrouchev Department of Molecular Mechanics, Institute of Applied Mechanics, Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
107
108
A. Vakhrouchev
Fig. 7.1 The main steps of the process of formation and use of powder nanocomposites
of their existence, which consists of three main steps (Fig. 7.1): nanopowder obtaining, product manufacturing from nanopowder (presswork and relief) and use of the product [18, 21]. At present, nanosystem simulation at different structural levels is carried out with the use of three main methods: molecular dynamics (MD) that is used to calculate the interaction of atoms and/or molecules [3–5, 7, 12] in nanoelements; mesodynamics (MsD) that is used for calculating nanoelements (nanoparticles) [9–13]; continuum mechanics (CM) that is used for analyzing macro-behaviour of nanosystems [16, 20]. In his previous works [22–26], the author solved some problems on the formation of nanoparticles, problems on static and dynamic interaction of metal nanoparticles and problems on nanoparticle self-organization using manly molecular dynamics and mesodynamics. An object of the present work is to systemize the main theoretical concepts, which allow a simulation of powder nanocomposites formation by continuum mechanics methods.
7.2 Physical Processes and Mathematical Models of Nanopowder Obtaining In the present section, consideration is given to physical processes of nanopowder dispersion at “up down” process at impulsive temperature-force action under isothermal conditions and varying temperature.
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
109
7.2.1 Powder Dispersion Physical Processes The physics and kinetics of the nanopowder dispersion at “up down” process are determined by the following parameters: the particle loading, the ambient pressure and temperature, the rate of the change of the above values with time and the physicalmechanical characteristics of a material particle. Depending on the ratio of the indicated above parameters, one can observe different types of the particle destruction: slabbing destruction of a solid phase of the material particle, fusion of particles, combined destruction of solid and liquid phases and material evaporation from the particle surface, etc. The present section is concerned with the main physical phenomena that accompany the process of destruction of particles.
7.2.1.1 Hard Particle Dispersion Let us consider a hard particle of an arbitrary shape that is in the environment with time-varying pressure and temperature. If the combination of the indicated parameters does not cause a change in the material phase state (its fusion or evaporation) then the analysis of the particle destruction can be carried out within the context of a deformed solid. When there is a change in the material phase state, it is necessary to consider a mutual behavior of solid, liquid and gaseous phases. The main destruction mechanisms of a particle in solid and multi-phase states are presented further. Under the action of the external pressure P0 , the particle under study having a volume Ω0 and a surface S0 is deformed and at the same time accumulates elastic energy (Fig. 7.2). Let us assume that an equivalent stress at a certain point A of the particle reaches the value of its material ultimate stress limit. This causes the division of the particle surface S∗ through the point A into two fragments, which have volumes Ω1 and Ω2 and surfaces S1 and S2 , respectively. In the fragments formed, the pulsing of the stress fields continues, which in its turn can lead to the destruction of the fragments. The process repeats while maximal equivalent stress exceeds the material ultimate stress limit. The level of the equivalent stress results from the storage of the elastic energy of deformation in each new fragment that is formed after the particle destruction. In the process of dispersion, a parent particle loses a part of energy on inelastic deformations of the destruction and on the dispersion of fragments. It is obvious that a moment should come when there is no energy sufficient for further destruction of particles and the dispersion process stops. The kinetics of the solid-phase dispersion process can be influenced by the presence of pores and micro cracks, which usually become starting points of destruction. In addition, the interaction of stress waves with different types of defects can essentially change spatial and time distribution of stresses in the particle. However, it does not influence the physics of the process. Exposure to heat (both the external heat of the environment and the internal heat resulting from the energy dissipation at destruction and inelastic deformations) also
110
A. Vakhrouchev
Fig. 7.2 A hard particle before (I) and after (II) destruction
influences the kinetics and topography of the particle destruction. An increase or a decrease in temperature leads to the formation of additional temperature stresses and to a change in elastic and strength properties of the material. In particular, Young’s modulus and Poisson’s ratio that determine the speed of stress wave propagation, the ultimate stress limit of material and the beginning of destruction essentially depend on temperature. In addition, with increasing temperature the manifestation of material inelastic properties increases.
7.2.1.2 Particle Dispersion with the Change of the Material Phase State At high-rate loading, intensive heat flows and small thermal capacity of material, the temperature of a particle can exceed the melting temperature of its parent-material, which will cause a “solid-liquid” phase transition. There may be different mechanisms of the destruction of a particle that lead to the formation of a liquid phase on the surface and in the bulk of the material (Fig. 7.3a). The latter is observed when a particle is inhomogeneous and the melting temperature on the surface of a particle is higher than within it. As the result of the “solid-liquid” phase transition, the compressibility and other physical-mechanical characteristics of the material vary and additional stresses appear, which are related to the changes in the material volume. When internal regions of the “solid-liquid” phase transition are formed, additional tensile stresses appear in the particle. Let us consider one after another the mechanisms of the destruction of a particle covered with a liquid layer and a particle that contains liquid within itself.
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
111
Fig. 7.3 Schematic view of the destruction of a particle containing (a, b) solid (1) and liquid (2) phases; (c) solid and liquid phases confined in a hard shell (3)
In the first case, after the external pressure has rapidly been removed, the liquid surface layer and the hard nucleus begin to vibrate simultaneously. The destruction of this system caused by the propagation of stress waves in the particle can happen as the result of both the destruction of the hard nucleus and the destruction of the outer layer, the strength of which is conditioned by the action of the surface tension forces of the liquid. It should be noted that the velocities of the waves in the liquid and the hard nucleus are not the same; therefore, they can be reflected from the solid-liquid interface. If the liquid phase has formed within the particle, then the first stage of the destruction is the split of the solid part of the particle (Fig. 7.3c). Then the destruction process develops as indicated above. Many metals are covered with oxides, the melting temperature and strength of which are much higher than those of the bulk material are. Under the external pressure, the “hard nucleus – oxide layer” system (Fig. 7.3c) is compressed and is warmed up due to the heat exchange with the environment. The surface oxide film does not melt. Melting or even evaporation starts under the film in the bulk material. This leads to the appearance of additional stresses than compress the nucleus and stresses that stretch the outer oxide layer, which may be destructed if the volume of the melted material changes greatly, and the destruction of the liquid layer can follow. The outer shell of the particle can also be destructed under the external pressure in the process of vibration of the complex system: a hard nucleus, a liquid layer, a gas interlayer and a surface solid film. After the shell destruction, the gas
112
A. Vakhrouchev
within it disperses into the environment. The liquid surface layer gets broken forming drops, and the hard nucleus breaks down into smaller parts at a sufficient reserve of potential energy. When the environment is cooling down, evaporated substance is condensed on the hard and liquid particles formed. The latter harden on cooling. Thus, the analysis of the physical processes during the dispersion of powder material shows that in order to analyze it, it is necessary to take into account a number of interrelated phenomena such as dynamic deformation and destruction of a solid, heat exchange, thermal conductivity, melting and evaporation of a substance. A determining parameter is the temperature of the process, which has a significant effect on the changes in the material properties and “solid – liquid” and “liquid – gas” phase transitions and influences the kinetics and topography of destruction in many respects. On this basis, it is practical to consider mathematical models for the dispersion process in isothermal and nonisothermal conditions. Now, let us consider these models for a single elastic particle and for a single inelastic particle, which are presented at constant and varying temperature.
7.2.1.3 Mathematical Model of the Powder Dispersion Process in Isothermal Conditions Let us consider a single particle from inhomogeneous material (a general case), which is in an environment with the initial pressure P0 and the temperature T0 and occupies the region Ω0 (Fig. 7.2). The x(x, ¯ y, z) coordinates determine the position of the particle. Due to the compression over the surface S0 , the particle accumulates elastic energy U0 of deformation; the initial fields of displacement vectors u¯0 , tensors of deformation εˆ0 and stresses σˆ 0 correspond to this elastic energy of deformation. The value of the elastic energy accumulated by the particle is determined by the work of the pressure forces on the particle surface U0 =
1 2
P0 n¯ ◦ u¯0 dS0
(7.1)
S0
that is equal to the work of stresses σˆ for the deformations εˆ in the volume Ω0 . A0 =
1 2
σˆ 0 ◦ εˆ0 dΩ0
(7.2)
Ω0
In the above equations, u¯0 is a displacement vector on the surface S0 , n¯ is a normal to the surface S0 and ◦ is a symbol for the inner composition of tensors. At the moment t0 , the pressure P0 varies and the potential energy U0 accumulated in the particle changes into kinetic energy of its elastic vibrations. At the moment t = t∗ under certain conditions, the destruction of the particle takes place and two new particles are formed with the volumes Ω1 and Ω2 and the surfaces S1 and S2 .
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
113
With time, these particles can also break into smaller ones and the process goes on until there is energy that is sufficient for destruction. Vibrations and destruction of particles can be accompanied by inelastic scleronomous or rheonomous deformations, due to which a part of the energy accumulated at compression dissipates, and by the formation of different kinds of defects as well. Taking into account the above-indicated phenomena makes the dispersion process modeling very complicated. Therefore, in order to obtain the solution that will allow carrying out a preliminary analysis of the dispersion process, at the first step we admit that the material is elastic. Non-linear properties of the material are taken into consideration in the statement of the problem of nonisothermal loading. The system of equations that describes a change in the shape of the elastic solid and its destruction with time in isothermal conditions includes: – Differential equations of motion
∂ u¯ ¯ ∗ σˆ = ρ (x) ¯ ∇ ∂ t2 2
(7.3)
– Equations of connection between the deformation tensor εˆ and the displacement vector u¯ 1 ¯ +∇ ¯ ⊗ u¯ u¯ ⊗ ∇ (7.4) εˆ = 2 constitutive equations of elastic body
σˆ = D(x) ¯ εˆ
(7.5)
where D(x) ¯ is the matrix of the material elastic constants. The boundary conditions for the system of Eqs. (7.3)–(7.5) contain: – Force conditions on the surface S0 of the initial particle and the surfaces S1 and S2 of the newly formed particles including the destruction surfaces S1∗ and S2∗ : τn = 0, σn = −P0 , t = 0 (7.6) x¯ ⊂ S0 τn = 0, σn = −P(t) , 0 < t ≤ t∗ where σn and τn are normal and tangential stresses acting on the surfaces of the initial particle and on the surfaces of the particle fragments formed as the result of destruction; t∗ is the moment of the beginning of destruction; – Force and deformation conditions within the initial particle Ω0 and the newly formed particles Ω1 and Ω2 :
σˆ = σˆ 0 , εˆ = εˆ0, t = 0, x¯ ⊂ Ω0 u¯ = u¯∗1 , x¯ ⊂ Ω1 t = t∗ u¯ = u¯∗2 , x¯ ⊂ Ω2
(7.7)
where u¯∗1 and u¯∗2 are displacement vectors within the initial particle at the moment of destruction t∗
114
A. Vakhrouchev
– The condition of destruction
σeq = σb ,
x¯ ⊂ A
(7.8)
where A is a starting point of destruction; σeq is an equivalent stress; σb is an ultimate stress limit of the material of the particle – The condition determining the geometry of the destruction surface S∗ , which can be written with the assumption that the unit vector n¯ S∗ is perpendicular to the destruction surface S∗ and parallel to the maximal principal stress σ¯ 1 n¯σ1 ◦ n¯ S∗ = 1
(7.9)
where n¯ σ1 is a unit vector determining the direction of the principal stress σ¯ 1 . The formation of the surface S∗ starts at the point A, where the condition of destruction (7.8) fulfils. In this case, we believe that the time of the surface formation S∗ is small and the particles of the material located on different sides from the surface S∗ move an infinitely small distance away from one another. Thus, the system of Eqs. (7.3)–(7.5), in view of conditions (7.6)–(7.9), determines the statement of the problem on deformation and destruction of an elastic particle in isothermal conditions.
7.2.1.4 Mathematical Model for Powder Dispersion at Varying Temperature In the present section, a mathematical model for destruction of a particle at timevarying temperature is presented having regard to scleronomous and rheonomous properties of a material (here, the “solid-liquid” and “liquid-gas” phase transitions are not taken into consideration). Let us consider a particle from elastoviscoplastic material occupying a region Ω and having a surface S in the environment with time-varying pressure P(t) and temperature T (t). With a change in the above parameters, the particle may deform and break down and at the same time remains in the solid state. The mathematical statement of this problem is formulated based on equations of motion (7.3), Cauchy equation (7.4), constitutive equations for a viscoelastic body with regard to temperature deformations (for the region of viscoelastic deformation of a particle) εˆ = D(x) ¯ −1 σ + R(x) ¯ ∗ σˆ + εˆ T (7.10) constitutive equations for inelastic deformation (in the region of plastic deformations of a particle) ˆ σ, ˆ εˆ , εˆ˙ , D(x), σˆ = Ψ ¯ R(x), ¯ G(x), ¯ T,t, . . .
(7.11)
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
115
and equations of thermal conductivity
λ ∂T aT ∂ t
(7.12)
εˆ T = αT (T (t) − T0 )Iˆ
(7.13)
λ ∇2 T + q p = where
Here, Ψ is a functional (in a general case), which determines the connection between stress tensors σˆ and deformations εˆ and takes into account the influence of the ¯ rheonomous R(x) ¯ and plasticity deformation rate εˆ˙ , the temperature T, elastic D(x), parameters G(x) ¯ of the material; aT is a temperature conductivity coefficient; λ is a thermal conductivity coefficient; εˆ T is temperature deformation; αT is a coefficient of volume temperature expansion; T0 is an initial temperature; q p is a heat flow from internal heat sources (as the result of plastic deformations); Iˆ is a unit tensor. The system of Eqs. (7.3), (7.4), (7.10)–(7.13) is supplemented with the conditions of plasticity and destruction
σeq = σ p , x¯ ⊂ S p σeq = σb or ω = 1, x¯ ⊂ A,
(7.14) (7.15)
where σ p is a material plastic limit; ω is a parameter of destruction rate; SP is a surface separating the plastic deformation regions from the viscoelastic deformation regions. To calculate the parameter of the destruction rate, the kinetic equation of damage accumulation is used ω = ς (σˆ , εˆ , T, . . .) (7.16) The boundary conditions for this problem includes σˆ = σˆ 0 , εˆ = εˆ0 , T = T0 , x¯ ⊂ Ω t=0 σn = −P0 , τn = 0, x¯ ⊂ S qn = α (TS − T (t)) x¯ ⊂ S, t > 0 σn = −P(t), τn = 0 qn = α (TS − T (t)) x¯ ⊂ S∗ , t > t∗ σn = −P(t), τn = 0 u¯ve = u¯ep ,
σnve = σnep ,
x¯ ⊂ SP ,
(7.17) (7.18) (7.19) (7.20)
where qn is a heat flow normal to the initial surface S of a particle; Ts is a particle surface temperature; T (t) is a temperature of the environment; S∗ is a surface of destruction; u¯ve , u¯ep are displacements on the surface S p ; σnve , σnep are normal stresses perpendicular to the surface S p ; α is a heat-transfer coefficient. The surface S p geometry of a loaded particle is determined by the regularities of the development of plastic deformations in accordance with Eq. (7.11) and the surface S∗ profile of destruction depends directly on the condition of destruction (7.8). Thus, the system of Eqs. (7.3), (7.4), (7.10)–(7.12) together with conditions
116
A. Vakhrouchev
(7.14)–(7.20) determines the statement of the problem on the deformation and destruction of a particle from elastic viscoplastic material at varying temperature.
7.3 Physical and Mathematical Models of the Processes of Powder Nanocomposite Compacting In the present section, physical phenomena are considered and mathematical models of the main steps of the compaction of powder composites are constructed: displacement of a press-tool, removal of pressing force, re-pressing and squeezing a finished product from a die.
7.3.1 The Physics of the Compaction Process The formation of mechanical and other properties of PNCs is realized in the process of their conversion to finished products by methods of pressing. In this case, the technological process of the composite preparation is conducted simultaneously with the product manufacturing and is accompanied by a significant change in a stressed-strained state (SSS) of the powder being pressed. As an example, Fig. 7.4 shows a typical scheme of the process for preparing PNC: 1 – active pressing (in the present case, double pressing with hydro shaping); 2 – instantaneous unloading at the puncheon exit or die splitting; 3 – a relaxation period observed during the product “rest” or other operations. Note that the powder compaction during pressing is characterized by significant volumetric deformations and a continuous change in parameters such as density, elasticity, plasticity,
Fig. 7.4 The stress “time history” σˆ in the powder composites: 0-a, b-c – phases of loading; a-b, c-d-e – unloading; e-f– storing; f-g– loading at operation
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
117
strength and rheonomous properties. Inhomogeneity of the material SSS leads to the nonuniformity of its plastic deformation both in volume and in direction. This results in continuously changing nonuniformity of physical-mechanical characteristics of the material during the process of pressing and in the appearance of residual (technological) stresses in the pressed product. The PNC physical-mechanical characteristics change significantly; normally, it is a powder mixture with high porosity and low density before pressing. During a puncheon stroke the mixture consolidates, which results in the formation of an inhomogeneous compact. At the step of the repeated pressing, after some powder has been added to the die, a product is formed, which consists of two parts with different physical-mechanical properties. This is explained by the fact that one part of the material is pressed again and the second one is in the process of formation, i.e. a powdered body is converting into a compact. An adhesive bond appears at the interface of the materials, which provides the connection of successively compacted parts of the powder material into a single whole. In the process of squeezing a finished product from a die, a significant elastic unloading is observed in it, which changes its form and sizes, and in some cases (e.g. at “overpress”) it leads to the destruction of the product. Hydro shaping should be a final operation in the technological process because it essentially decreases inhomogeneity of the material and significantly decreases or even removes technological stresses. There are some other physical processes accompanying pressing that influence the parameters of the condition of the material pressed and the product SSS formed. First, it is gas release from a pressed product (which is especially characteristic of super disperse systems containing a great initial amount of gas), which can lead to the growth of internal pressure in the pressed product and the appearance of internal hollows and micro cracks in it. Both the external friction occurring due to the interaction of a powder mixture and a press-tool and the internal friction, which results from the displacement of particles relative to one another, essentially influence the pressing process as well. Values of frictional forces depend on the sizes and shapes of particles, the tool surface quality, and they are controlled with various technological additives. Thus, pressing is a set of interconnected physical processes taking place in a material on the background of the essential change of its aggregative state from a loose powder-like material to a compacted inhomogeneous body. The selection of an optimal mode of pressing and the investigation of the kinetics of accompanying processes require making a complete mathematical model of the process of pressing.
7.3.2 Mathematical Model of Pressing Figure 7.5 shows schematic views of the above technological steps and the typical regions of the “material being formed – press-tool” system are highlighted. Here, Ω1
118
A. Vakhrouchev
Fig. 7.5 The scheme of a powder compression: (a) pressing and unloading, (b) an ejection of a finished article
is a region occupied by a PNC; Ω2 , Ω3 and Ω4 are the regions of the die, base and puncheon, respectively; Ω5 is the volume of an resilient member, which is usually present in the system indicated and improves the conditions of pressing. The region Ω1 is subdivided into regions Ω1 1, Ω2 1 and Ωk 1, which are formed during material shaping in “k” press-tool throws. The system of equations describing the problem statement includes the following: equilibrium equations ∇ ∗ σˆ = 0,
(7.21)
geometrical equations
εˆ =
1 u¯ ⊗ ∇ + ∇ ⊗ u¯ + ∇ ⊗ u¯ ∗ u¯ ⊗ ∇ , 2
(7.22)
constitutive equations that describe mechanical properties of the contacting objects, i.e. the press-tool (7.23) and the composite mass compacted during pressing (7.24), and unloading (7.25) ˆ σˆ = 2µn εˆ + λn ε0 I, n = 2, 3, 4, 5,
x¯ ⊂ Ω2 , Ω3 , Ω4 , Ω5 ,
(7.23)
σˆ m = ψˆ (σˆ , εˆ , θ , hi , . . .) , m = 1, 2, . . . , k;
x¯ ⊂ Ω11 , Ω21 , . . . , Ωk1 ,
(7.24)
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
119
where µn and λn are Lam´e constants; ε0 is volumetric deformation; x¯ is coordinates; ˆ is a functional of plasticity of a porous body; θ is current porosity; hi is structural Ψ parameters of a porous material. For writing Eq. (7.24), the theory of plasticity of porous bodies is used [10, 19]. For the regions of the ultimately compacted material, when the nonuniform distribution of density in the compact bulk is taken into account, the functional from (7.24) degenerates into the constitutive equations of an inhomogeneous elastic body ¯ and λm (x): ¯ with variable characteristics µm (x) ˆ σˆ = 2µm (x) ¯ εˆ + λm (x) ¯ ε0 I,
(7.25)
Note that it is sufficient to preserve linear connection for the regions Ω2 , . . . and Ω5 in Eq. (7.23) because the deformations in the press-tool are usually small. Equations (7.21)–(7.25), which determine the problem of the calculation of the system SSS of compacted and elastic bodies, should be supplemented with the equations of thermal conductivity and gas filtration in the mixture being compacted. The thermal conductivity equation for an inhomogeneous porous body pressed, which takes into account heat release during pressing, has the following form:
, ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ λ (θ ) ∂ T λ (θ ) (T ) + λ (θ ) (T ) + λ (θ ) (T ) + qP = ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂z ∂z aT (θ ) ∂ t (7.26) where qP is power of heat sources, which depends on the plastic deformation levels; aT (θ ) and λ(θ ) are coefficients of temperature conductivity and thermal conductivity, which depend on the porosity of a powder material; qP = Φ(εˆ p ),
(7.27)
For the press-tool, the thermal conductivity equation can be written in the form: ∇2 T =
1 ∂T . aT ∂ t
(7.28)
When the equation of gas or liquid filtration through a powder composite is derived, we use Darcy law for a porous medium V¯ = −χ ∇P,
(7.29)
where V is the gas movement velocity; P is the gas pressure; χ is a filtration coefficient depending on the parameters of the gas and the powder medium. The equation of continuity for a porous medium can be written in the form: ¯ ∗ (ρ V) ¯ = − ∂ (θ ρ ) , ∇ ∂t
(7.30)
120
A. Vakhrouchev
Inserting Eq. (7.29) in Eq. (7.30) and taking into account the ideal gas law P = ρ RT,
(7.31)
we obtain a differential equation determining the change in the pressure in the gas medium by the volume of a powder body during the process of pressing ¯ ∗ P χ∇ ¯ ∗P = ∂ θ P , ∇ (7.32) T ∂t T
Equation (7.32) is nonlinear because θ and χ change with time and are not the same at different points of the product pressed due to the nonuniform pressing of its separate volumes. The system of the above equations is closed by the boundary conditions, which are an initial state of the regions under study at each technological step, loading conditions, the interaction of the system of bodies on the surfaces S1 , S2 , . . . of contact (non-interpenetration of contacting surfaces, their unilateral connection, the presence of frictional forces) and the conditions of gas and heat exchange with the environment. Varying boundary conditions in parallel with varying mechanical properties of a powder material pressed determine the deformation behavior of the system of bodies at each step of the process of forming. Let us consider the boundary conditions as applied to the schemes of the process of forming displayed in Fig. 7.6.
Fig. 7.6 The gaseous and fluid substance exchange between the powder composite and the environment: Sc – free surfaces; SL – the isolated surfaces; Sk – surfaces, contacting with other bodies
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
121
A downward puncheon throw (Fig. 7.5a): ⎫ I σˆ lm = σˆ lm , θm = (θ )I m , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ x¯ ⊂ Ωl m = 1, 2, . . . h=0 ⎪ σˆ k = (σˆ k )I , x¯ ⊂ Ωk ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ k = 2, . . . , 5
⎫ u n j = u ni , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ x¯ ⊂ Si , τSi = sign(uSi ) f σni , ⎪ if σn < 0 : 0≤h≤1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ τ = 0, σn = 0 ⎭ Si
σn = 0, τS = 0, x¯ ⊂ Sc
P = P0 /h, x¯ ⊂ S p T = T0 ,
h ↑,
(7.33)
x¯ ⊂ Ωm , m = 1, 2, . . . , k; h = 0;
T = Tc , x¯ ⊂ Sc , 0 ≤ h ≤ 1; where Sc is a free surface of the “pressed product – press-tool” system; Tc is an ambient temperature; h is a parameter of proportional loading. It should also be remembered that if pressing is carried out in different directions then Sp could vary at each step of pressing. Unloading (Fig. 7.5a)
⎫ σˆ 1m = (σˆ 1m )II , θm = (θ )II m, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ x ⊂ Ω1 , m = 1, 2, . . . ,
σˆ k = (σˆ k )II , x¯ ⊂ Ωk , k = 2, . . . , 5 ⎫ u n j = u nl , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ τSi = sign(uSi ) f σni , ⎪
⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭
h = 1,
τSi = 0 at σn = 0
x¯ ⊂ Si , , h ↓ (0 ≤ h ≤ 1) ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭
σn = 0,
x¯ ⊂ Sc ,
at σn < 0 :
τS = 0,
P = P0 /h, x¯ ⊂ S p
(7.34)
h ↓ (0 ≤ h ≤ 1),
T = T1 , x¯ ⊂ Ωm , m = 1, 2, . . . ; h = 0, T = Tc , x¯ ⊂ Sc , 0 ≤ h ≤ 1, where the index I designates variable parameters of the process, which correspond to the end of the active puncheon throw. The index II designates variable parameters of the system state at many times repeated pressing after unloading. For single pressing and the first step of many times repeated pressing, initial stresses in the system are equal to zero and the PNC porosity corresponds to a bulk porosity of the powder composite mixture.
122
A. Vakhrouchev
Squeezing (Fig. 7.5b): ⎫ σˆ 1m = (σˆ 1m )I , θm = (θ )m , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ x¯ ⊂ Ω1 , m = 1, 2, . . . ⎬ h = 0, ⎪ σˆ k = (σˆ k )I , x¯ ⊂ Ωk ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ k = 2, . . . , 5 ⎫ u n j = u ni , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ τSi = sign(uSi ) f σni , ⎬ x¯ ⊂ Si , , 0≤h≤1 if σn < 0 : ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ σn = 0 τSi = 0, σn = 0, τS = 0, x¯ ⊂ Sc (h) , P = P1 /h, x¯ ⊂ S p T = T1 , x¯ ⊂ Ωm
(7.35)
m = 1, 2, . . . ; h = 0,
T = Tc , x¯ ⊂ Sc , 0 ≤ h ≤ 1 where Si is a contacting surface; un is a normal displacement on the surface of the contact; τS and σn are tangential and normal stresses on the surface of the contact; P is a pressure of pressing; P0 is a maximal pressure of pressing; f is a friction coefficient. Here, P1 is a maximal pressure of squeezing. Note that in the process of squeezing, the free surface of pressing essentially increases and the surface of the contact interaction of the PNC and the press-tool decreases. When the product is leaving the instrument, the parameter of loading can increase or decrease within from 0 to 1.
7.4 Physical and Mathematical Models of the Processes Accompanying the Use of Powder Nanocomposites In the present section, the physics of the processes, which take place during the long-term use of the compacted PNCs in an aggressive medium, is considered and the mathematical statement of the problem is formulated.
7.4.1 The Physics of the Processes When in use, PNCs experience the action of various physical and force fields. The characteristics of these materials are essentially influenced by temperature as well, the variation of which in the process of the PNC-product use leads to the formation of the fields of temperature stresses due to the nonuniform heating of the product
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
123
and to restricted conditions of its deformation. In addition, an increase or decrease in the temperature essentially influences the mechanics of the material and the rate of physical-chemical processes accompanying the storage and use of the products. In the product lifetime assessment, it is necessary to take into account the environmental effect, which provokes aging of a material especially of its surface layers: drying of its surface at low humidity and its swelling at high humidity of the environment. This phenomenon is especially important for the technologies of manufacturing nanopowder products (e.g. high-capacity capacitors) since nanopowder materials readily react with moisture. Some PNCs are gasified when stored and react with their coatings, which also influences their properties. The net effect of the service factors leads to changes in the form and geometry of the product, in the properties of the material and in the properties of the product’s armoring with time and causes the degradation of its mechanical characteristics. A complex evaluation of the above phenomena and a reliable prediction of the lifetime of a PNC product require the development of mathematical models, which will allow fast computer-aided evaluation of the influence of the main service factors such as temperature, humidity, force actions, internal technological stresses, etc. on the physics and mechanics of PNCs.
7.4.2 Mathematical Models Let us consider a powder body occupying a spatial region Ω that is restricted by a surface S (Fig. 7.6). The body is in the space where at the moment t = 0, the temperature is T1 and the concentrations of several gaseous and liquid substances are C11 ,C21 , . . . ,Cn1 . Part of the body surface Sk ⊂ S1 k S2 k S3 k . . . Sm k is fixed (nonmoving) oris in the contact with a solid deformable body. The surface Sc ⊂ S1 c S2 c S3 c . . . Sl c of the body is not fixed and reacts with the environment. The rest of the surface SΠ ⊂ S/Sk /Sc ⊂ S1 L S2 L . . . Si L is covered with a coating, which prevents inward penetration of gaseous or liquid substances from the environment. The initial concentrations of the above-indicated substances inside the body are C10 ,C20 , . . . ,Cn0 . In addition, there is an initial field of residual technological stresses σˆ r in the body, to which the field of residual deformations εˆ r corresponds. As the result of diffusion processes, heat exchange and heat conductivity, the temperature of the body and the concentrations of liquid and gaseous substances change. This results in the appearance of the volume deformation of the body in the form of swelling or shrinking εˆ w (x,t) ¯ and the gas release within the volume εˆ g (x,t). ¯ This causes the appearance of stresses in the body due to both the heterogeneity of the volume deformation field and the restricted conditions of the deformation on the surface Sk . The set of the differential equations describing the physical processes indicated above (diffusion, swelling and the formation of stress fields with time) includes the following equations:
124
A. Vakhrouchev
Equations of the diffusion of liquid and gaseous substances into the body from the environment ⎧ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ C1 ⎪ ⎪ , χ1 (θ ) (C1 ) + χ1 (θ ) (C1 ) + χ1 (θ ) (C1 ) = ⎪ ⎪ ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂z ∂z ∂t ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ C2 ⎨ ∂ , χ2 (θ ) (C2 ) + χ2 (θ ) (C2 ) + χ2 (θ ) (C2 ) = ∂ x ∂ x ∂ y ∂ y ∂ z ∂ z ∂t ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ........................ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ Cn ⎪ ⎩ , χn (θ ) (Cn ) + χn (θ ) (Cn ) + χn (θ ) (Cn ) = ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂z ∂z ∂t (7.36) Equation of thermal conductivity ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ λ (θ ) ∂ T , λ (θ ) (T ) + λ (θ ) (T ) + λ (θ ) (T ) = ∂x ∂x ∂y ∂y ∂z ∂z aT (θ ) ∂ t (7.37) Equation of gas release and gas diffusion
χg ∇2Cg + β =
∂ Cg , ∂t
(7.38)
Equation of body swelling (or shrinking)
∂ ε0w = ϕ (C1 ,C2 , . . . ,Cn , T,t), ∂t
(7.39)
a group of equations determining the stressed-deformed state of the product, differential equations of equilibrium (7.21) and Eq. (7.4). Constitutive equations for the material close the set of Eqs. (7.4), (7.21), (7.36)– (7.39). Let us consider the total effect of the service factors. Taking into consideration the fact that the limiting deformations of the destruction of the compacted powder materials are normally small, we will present the tensor of complete deformations as the sum of components resulting from the action of each separate factor.
εˆ = εˆ F + εˆ w + εˆ g + εˆ T + εˆ r
(7.40)
where εˆ is the tensor of complete deformations; εˆ F is the tensor of deformations due to the action of external loadings; εˆ w is the tensor of “swelling” deformations resulting from the processes of gas absorption from the ambient; εˆ g is the tensor of deformations caused by the processes of gas release within the powder composite; εˆ T is the tensor of temperature deformations; εˆ r is the tensor of deformations due to the action of technological stresses. Let us consider the structure of each tensor individually and write the equations, which will connect each tensor with the appropriate service factor.
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
125
7.4.2.1 Temperature Deformations Temperature is one of the main factors that influence the physics-mechanics of PNCs since the properties of these materials are determined by its magnitude to a significant extent. An increase in temperature intensifies diffusion processes, enhances rheonomous properties of the material, depresses its modulus of elasticity, etc. In addition, a change in temperature directly influences the volume and shape of a product due to the respective temperature deformation. The latter is determined by a spherical tensor of temperature deformations ˆ εˆ T = αT ∆T I,
(7.41)
where αT is a temperature coefficient of a linear expansion of the material, ∆T is a change in the temperature relative to the temperature of the product manufacturing; Iˆ is a unit spherical tensor. 7.4.2.2 Deformations of Swelling Being porous materials, PNCs have a capability to absorb gases from the ambient. As this takes place, two principal processes occur: adsorption, i.e. the absorption of gases by the product surface and absorption, i.e. the absorption of gases within the bulk. These processes are simultaneous and they lead to the change in the volume and the swelling of the product. In addition, the capillary condensation and capillary contraction of liquid are very essential for porous bodies since they cause significant volume deformation. Physical equations describing the above phenomena are rather complicated; therefore, it is practical to evaluate the influence of separate factors based on phenomenological equations. The tensor of the deformations due to material swelling can be written in the form ˆ εˆ w = ε0W I, (7.42) where ε0W is the swelling of the material volume unit; the rate of the swelling enlargement with time is determined in accordance with (7.39). 7.4.2.3 Deformations Caused by Gas Release For PNCs that are used in aggressive ambient conditions and at elevated temperatures, gas release is observed. The pressure of the gases released can reach a significant magnitude, which will result in the product volume deformation. The connection between this deformation and the gas pressure Pg within the material can be written in the form Pg ˆ εˆ g = I, (7.43) 3K where K is the modulus of the material volume compression, which depends on temperature and humidity in the general case.
126
A. Vakhrouchev
7.4.2.4 Deformations Caused by a Force Action Let us present the deformation caused by external forces as the sum
εˆ F = ε e + εˆ p + εˆ c ,
(7.44)
where εˆ e are elastic deformations, εˆ p are plastic deformations and εˆ c are rheonomous deformations of a compacted metal-composite. The elastic deformations are linearly connected with the stresses acting in the product εˆ e = Dσˆ , (7.45) The stress dependence of plastic and rheonomous deformations can be written in the general form
εˆ p = R p ∗ σˆ , εˆ c = Rc ∗ σˆ ,
(7.46) (7.47)
where D is the matrix of the material elasticity; R p and Rc are the matrices-operators determining plastic and rheonomous properties of the material, respectively. In the general case, these matrices and operators are temperature-dependent.
7.4.2.5 Deformations Caused by the Action of Technological Stresses Technological (residual) stresses form at the stage of product manufacturing. Their magnitude can be significant, therefore, after the product has been manufactured, its sizes do not match the sizes of a forming tool. During storage and service of the product, the technological stresses relax due to its rheonomous properties. In this case, two processes take place. First, because of the relaxation of the residual stresses and a decrease in their general level, elastic aftereffect that appears right after the product has been manufactured decreases, which leads to a change in the product sizes. On the other hand, the technological stresses cause the material creep, which may result in an increase in the product sizes. The relations determining the magnitude of the residual stresses have the form
εˆ r = −D−1 σˆ r
(7.48)
where σˆ r is the tensor of the residual technological stresses. At the simultaneous action of the above-indicated service factors on the product, the deformation of the latter can be given in the form in accordance with Eqs. (7.41)– (7.48) Pg ˆ I − D−1 σˆ r + D−1σˆ + R p ∗ σˆ + Rc ∗ σˆ εˆ = αT ∆T Iˆ + ε0w Iˆ + 3K
(7.49)
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
127
Combining the summands in Eq. (7.49), which correspond only to volume deformation, we obtain (7.50) εˆ = D−1 (σˆ − σˆ r ) + R p ∗ σˆ + Rc ∗ σˆ + γw Iˆ where
Pg (7.51) 3K is a phenomenological function that takes into account the influence of temperature, swelling processes and gas release on the product deformation during its service and storage. Let us find the stress from Eq. (7.50)
γ = αT ∆T + ε0w +
˜ εˆ − P˜ ∗ σˆ − R˜ ∗ σˆ − γw I) ˆ + σˆ r , σˆ = D(
(7.52)
Equation (7.52) closes the system of Eqs. (7.4), (7.21), (7.36)–(7.39), which is supplemented by the boundary conditions for solving the diffusion and force problems included in it: C1 (0, x) ¯ = C10 (x), ¯
C2 (0, x) ¯ = C20 (x), ¯ ...
Cn (0, x) ¯ = Cn0 (x), ¯
x¯ ⊂ Ω
∂ Ci k = 0, x ⊂ Sk ⊂ S1k S2k S3k . . . Sm ; ∂n
∂ Ci = 0, ∂n
x¯ ⊂ SL ⊂ S1L
S2L . . .
SiL
C1 (0, x) ¯ = C11 (x), ¯ C2 (0, x) ¯ = C21 (x), ¯ . . .Cn (0, x) ¯ = Cn1 (x), ¯ x¯ ⊂ Sc
σˆ (0, x) ¯ = σˆ 0 (x); ¯ εˆ (0, x) ¯ = εˆ0 (x), ¯ un = 0,
τn = σn f ,
x¯ ⊂ Ω; x¯ ⊂ Sk ;
σn (t, x)l ¯ n = 0, x¯ ⊂ Sc ∪ SL ;
(7.53)
where σˆ 0 (x), εˆ0 (x), C10 (x), C20 (x), . . . , Cn0 (x) are initial distributions of tensors, stresses, deformations and gaseous substances in the powder body; ln are the direction cosines of the normal to the surface; un , τn and σn are displacements over the normal, tangential and normal stresses on the contacting surface, respectively; f is a friction coefficient; n is a normal to the surface; Ω is a body volume; Sc is free surfaces; SL is isolated surfaces; Sk is surfaces contacting with other bodies.
128
A. Vakhrouchev
7.5 Numerical Examples Let’s consider the use of the mathematical models offered above for the solution of different problems of a nanopowder pressing. Numerical realization of the problems of pressing is carried out by a finite element method [6, 27]. In details, the application of the finite element method in the problem of powder pressing is given in paper [25].
7.5.1 The Calculation of Pressing in an Elastic Die To exemplify the influence of the die plasticity on the stressed-strained state of the body being compacted, let us consider the case of the compaction of a powder composite using a blind die. In Fig. 7.7a, the scheme (left) and the corresponding finiteelement representation (right) of the object considered are displayed. The calculations have been carried out at the ratio of h/d = 1.5, where h is the height and d is the diameter of the pressing at the end of forming. The sizes of the rest bodies are shown in proportion. The thickness of the contact layer is 0.5 mm. For the material of the puncheon and the die, the value of the elastic modulus is 105 Mpa, and Poisson’s ratio is 0.3. The parameters of the contact layer are determined in process of the numerical experiment [20].
Fig. 7.7 The finite element scheme of a system (a): 1 – the pressing, 2 – the die, 3 – the puncheon, 4 – contact layer. Diagrams of stresses and displacements in a system (b) (−− σ˜ z −− σ˜ ϕ −◦− σ˜ r − − τ˜rz , −•− u). Stresses are given in fractions of maximal pressing pressure; displacements are given in meters. The scale is indicated in the figure
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
129
Fig. 7.8 The scheme of the radial-axial pressing (a) and its finite-element model (b)
The curve of the material strain within the equivalent coordinates [10, 19] has the p following values of the constants: σeq = 7.15 MPa; b1 = 434.5 MPa and b2 = 0.649 p (the strain εeq is given in fractions of unity). The parameter nθ characterizing the shapes of pores of the material [19] is 0.3. The friction coefficient on the “presstool – powder composite” surface was determined by the formula f = 0, 25 − 7 · 10−5 · σ0k , where σ0k is a mean pressure in the elements of the contact layer. The pressure on the puncheon was increased proportionally and at the end of pressing it was 120 MPa. The problem solution for each loading was found by the method of variable parameters of elasticity. At the first step over the loading for all the elements constituting the bulk of the powder body, the same initial porosity θ = 0.36 was given. In Fig. 7.8b, the stressed-strained state is shown for the system ‘tool – compacted body” at maximal pressing pressure P = 120 MPa. The epures of stresses are shown in the fractions of P, i.e. σ˜ = σ /P. The suitability of the algorithm offered for the solution of the problem of contact is confirmed by the following results. In the section A–A, the radial stress σ˜ r , which is normal to the contact surface of the bodies, is continuous when it passes through the lateral contact layer, and it changes monotonically in the diametrical direction from practically constant value in the pressing to zero on the outer surface of the die. In the same section, the hoop stress σ˜ ϕ that is compressive in the pressing becomes tensile in the die, when it passes through the contact layer (CL). The distribution of stresses σ˜ r and σ˜ ϕ thus obtained in the die section A–A is in good agreement with the values calculated analytically from Lam´e formula. In the section considered, the change in the axial stress σ˜ z also corresponds to the physical nature of the process, i.e. the compaction of the powder
130
A. Vakhrouchev
body takes place at the compressive stresses σ˜ z ; in the lateral CL, these stresses are close to zero, i.e. the CL does not prevent free relative displacements of the nodes of finite elements in the pressing and the die. At the left of Fig. 7.8b, the change in the axial stress σ˜ z is shown in the direction of the axis z. Under the puncheon, this stress has a maximal value in the “angular” point of the cylinder pressed. The average value of σ˜ z is close to the pressing pressure value in the layer of the pressing adjacent to the puncheon. In the vicinity of the lower end of the pressing, σ˜ z , on the contrary, has a maximal value in the center of the end, which decreases toward the “angular” points due to the friction on the die surface. When passing through the CL from the pressing to the die, the axial stress is continuous, i.e. the CL transfers the axial pressure to the entire area of the die base. Due to this fact, σ˜ z decreases in the die base since the area taking up the axial pressure increases. In the pressing layer and the die base layer adjacent to the pressing layer (they are separated by the CL), the areas of the epures of the stress σ˜ z differ only by 3.36%. The contact layer also allows modelling real distribution of tangential stresses under the puncheon. In Fig. 7.7, it is seen that in the region of the maximal shear of the material, τ˜rz is maximal, and in an “angular” point and in the center of the product end, τ˜rz is practically zero. It is of interest to trace the change in the article profile (Fig. 7.7). The calculation shows that at pressing with regard for the elasticity of the die, its form is distorted. For example, in the upper part of the cylinder, the diameter becomes larger than in its base. In conclusion, it should be noted that the use of the idea of a contact layer also allows modelling the separation of the bodies on the contact surface. In this case, when positive normal stresses appear on the contact layer surface, the elastic constants of the CL are specified close to zero. This algorithm was used for solving the problem of unloading and squeezing.
7.5.2 Unloading After Radial-Axial Pressing Figure 7.8 displays a scheme of the radial-axial compaction with the use of a blind die (a) and its finite-element model (b). The scheme of the compaction allows producing thin-wall tubes from powders. In this case, the most important stage of forming a thin-wall tube is its release from the press-tool since in the process of unloading, residual stresses can cause product fracture. It is possible to remove the press-tool in different ways. Figure 7.10 shows the finite-element calculations of the change in the stressed state of an insert produced by the radial-axial compacting of the Nb- and Ta-based powder metal-composite at different unloading: (a) the rod is squeezed “upwards” and the die is squeezed “downwards”; (b) both the rod and the die are squeezed “upwards”; (c) the rod is squeezed “downwards”, and the die “immediately” opens; (d) the rod is “immediately” removed, and the die goes “down”.
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
131
For each calculation case, the “line” of the change in the stressed state is traced from the starting point of unloading (the points Sa , Sb , Sc , Sd , respectively) to its end in the most loaded point (the point F in all the cases) according to Mirolubov’s criterion. This point is selected by the comparison of the maximal equivalent stress for all the finite elements in the calculation scheme at each step of unloading. The analysis of the calculation results shows that the unloading schemes “a” and “b” are the most inappropriate. In these cases, on gradual release of the pressing, in accordance with Mirolubov, the equivalent stresses exceed the ultimate stress of the metal-composite, which leads to the fracture of the pressing even before its complete removal from the press-form. The squeezing scheme “a” is especially unfavorable. Here, the unloading path mostly goes through the region where the equivalent stress is much higher than the ultimate stress (Fig. 7.9a). It should be noted that since for all the schemes, the stressed state of the compacted body is the same at the end of unloading, the analysis of the line of the change in the stressed state under unloading only allows to choose the optimal scheme for the removal of the article from the press-tool.
Fig. 7.9 Trajectories of unloading depend on a mode of clearing of a die after a radial-axial pressing
132
A. Vakhrouchev
7.5.3 Compaction with the Use of the “Active” Frictional Forces Compaction based on the use of “active” frictional forces is one of the promising methods for producing powder metal-composites, especially nano-powder ones. In particular, the investigations of the compaction of the Nb- and Ta-based powders, which are used for compacting high-capacity condensers, show that it is impossible to obtain the desired uniformity of porosity in ordinary dies. Large forces of friction prevent it. Thus, it is necessary to use these forces for compaction, which will allow to create the so called “floating” dies. The essence of the method lies in the fact that when the frictional forces reach a certain value, additional movements of the press-tool are switched on. As an illustration, let us consider the compaction of a cylinder pressing, the finite-element scheme of which is displayed in Fig. 7.10. In this scheme, in the beginning of pressing the powder nanocomposite (1) is pressed due to movement of the top puncheon (2). Than, the die (3) begins to move downwards at a certain pressing pressure owing to a resilient member (spring 4) supporting it. In this case, the single-action compaction scheme becomes doubleaction due to the relative movement of the die and the bottom puncheon (5). As the calculations show, when this scheme of compaction is used, the distribution of the residual stresses and physical-mechanical characteristics of the material of the pressing become essentially uniform. Figure 7.11 shows the plots of the porosity change along the cylinder axis in the section a-a (see Fig. 7.11b) at single-action pressing (a) and at pressing with a floating die (b). In the case of single-action compaction, the porosity distribution is not uniform over the height of the pressing. The top of the article is compacted stronger than its bottom. The experimental researches which have been carried out on NANOTEST600 have shown essential change of an elastic modulus of Young on lateral face of an article along its axis at single-action pressing.
Fig. 7.10 “Floating” die (a) for pressing PNCs and finite element model (b): 1 – PNC; 2 – top puncheon; 3 – die; 4 – spring; 5 – bottom puncheon
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
133
Fig. 7.11 The change of porosity along the section A–A (Fig. 7.10): a – single-action pressing. b – pressing with the use of a floating die
Using the active die allows to make the porosity uniform along the axis of the pressing. Experiments have shown that the elastic modulus in this case changes insignificantly, and there are no cracks on a surface of an article.
7.6 Conclusions Based on the models built, numerical schemes, algorithms and programs were developed for the analysis of evolution processes in powder systems during powder obtaining, PNC compacting and use. Numerical investigations of the evolution of residual stresses in PNCs under compaction were carried out. The influence of the contact between a powder mixture and a press-tool, external friction, powder properties, the size and form of a product manufactured on the level and distribution of internal stresses was investigated. This allowed determining the regularities of the powder compaction and the unloading and relaxation processes in powders and establishing reasons for possible product failure at any stage of its manufacturing. The results of modelling and numerical analysis were used for the development of new equipment and procedures that allowed decreasing the level of residual stresses, increasing the homogeneity of compaction and enhancing the strength of powder composites. Acknowledgements The Russian Foundation of Basic Research supported this work: project No 07-01-96015Ural a and project No 05-08-50090.
134
A. Vakhrouchev
References 1. Andreeva AV (2001) Fundamentals of physics-chemistry and technology of composites. IPRJR, Moscow 2. Andrievski RA, Ragulia AV (2005) Nanostructural materials. Academia, Moscow 3. Brooks BR, Bruccoleri RE, Olafson BD, States DJ, Swaminathan S, Karplus M (1983) CHARMM: A program for macromolecular energy minimization, and dynamics calculations. Journal of Computational Chemistry 4: 187–217 4. Case DA, Cheatham TE, Darden T, Gohlke H, Luo R, Merz KM, Onufriev A, Simmerling C, Wang B, Woods R (2005) The Amber biomolecular simulation programs. Journal of Computational Chemistry 26: 1668–1688 5. Cagin T, Che J, Qi Y, Zhou Y, Demiralp E, Gao G, Goddard WA (1999) Computational materials chemistry at the nanoscale. Journal of Nanoparticle Research 1: 51–69 6. Connor JJ, Brebbia CA (1977) Finite element techniques for fluid flow. Newnes-Butterworths, London/Boston 7. Diao J, Gall K, Dunn ML (2004) Atomistic simulation of the structure and elastic properties of gold nanowires. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 52: 1935–1962 8. Gusev AI, Rempel AA (2001) Nanocrystalline materials. Physical Mathematical Literature, Moscow 9. Geckeler Kurt E (2005) Novel supermolecular nanomaterials: from design to reality Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Composites/Nano Engineering; CD-ROM edition 10. Green P J (1972) A plasticity theory for porous solids. Journal of Mechanical Science 14: 215–224 11. Hari SN (2002) Handbook of nanostructured materials and nanotechnology. Academic, San Diego, CA 12. Hoare MR (1987) Structure and dynamics of simple microclusters. ACH Models in Chemistry and Physics 40: 49–135 13. Holian BL (2003) Formulating mesodynamics for polycrystalline materials. Europhysics Letters 64: 330–336 14. Koch CC (2002) Nanostructured Materials – Processing, Properties, and Potential Applications. William Andrew, Norwich, NY 15. Kaygorodov AS, Ivanov VV, Paranin SN, Nozdrin AA (2007) The role of adsorbents in pulsed compaction of oxide nanopowders. Russian Nanotechnology 2: 112–118 16. Kompis V, Kompis M, Kaukic M, Hui D (2006) Singular Trefftz functions for modelling material reinforced by hard particles. In: Topping BHV, Montero G, Montenegro (eds) Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Engineering Computational Technology, CD-ROM Paper 184, Civil-Comp Press, Stirlingshire 17. Morris DG (1998) Mechanical Behaviour of Nanostructured Materials. Trans Tech Publications, Uetikon-Zurich 18. Ozawa E (1986) Properties, production methods, use and application of ultra dispersed powders. Journal of the Japan Society for Technology of Plasticity 27: 1166–1172 19. Petrosian G.F. (1988) The plasticity deformation of powder materials. Metallurgy, Moscow 20. Ruoff RS, Pugno NM. (2004) Strength of nanostructures. Proceedings of the 21st International Congress of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, 303–311 21. Thompson RA (1981) Mechanics of powder pressing. I.-III Model for powder densification. American Ceramics Society Bulletin 60: 237–243 22. Vakhrouchev AV (2006) Simulation of nano-elements interactions and self-assembling Modelling and Simulation in Materials Science and Engnineering 14: 975–991 23. Vakhrouchev AV (2007) Computer simulation of nanoparticles formation, moving, interaction and self-organization. Journal of Physics. Conference Series 61: 26–30 24. Vakhrouchev AV, Lipanov AM (1992) A numerical analysis of the rupture of powder materials under the power impact influence. Computer and Structures 44: 481–486 25. Vakhrouchev AV, Vakhroucheva LL (1992) The finite element analysis of the powder materials compression. Proceedings of NUMINFORM’92, 887–892
7 Modelling of the Process of Formation and Use of Powder Nanocomposites
135
26. Vakhrouchev AV, Vakhrouchev AA.(2006) Computer Simulation of Nanoelements Formation, Interaction and Self-organization. In: Topping BHV, Montero G, Montenegro (eds) Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Engineering Computational Technology, CDROM Paper 875, Civil-Comp Press, Stirlingshire 27. Zienkiewicz OC (1971) The finite element method in engineering science. McGraw-Hill, New York
Chapter 8
Modelling of Fatigue Behaviour of Hard Multilayer Nanocoating System in Nanoimpact Test Magdalena Kopernik, Lechosław Tre¸bacz, and Maciej Pietrzyk
Abstract The chapter presents the basis of the nanoimpact test and the idea of prediction of fracture occurrence, especially fatigue behaviour of nanoimpacted materials. The example of typical nanoimpact test is illustrated. The first part of the investigation is focused on the development of the finite element (FE) model, which is applied to identification of the material model of hard nanocoating in the multilayer system. Beyond this, the model is used to describe the friction contact between die and specimen, the shape of the die, the critical and required number of layers and dimension of investigated domain. Searching for the answers on formulated topics is realized using the inverse and the sensitivity analysis. Selected results indicating the problems with computing time in simulation of nanotests for the multilayer systems are presented in the chapter, as well. The FE model of the test with optimized parameters was developed and the results of chosen macrocrack criterion are shown. In the second part of the work the new approach to analysis of fracture phenomena is introduced as the fatigue criteria, which are used in simulation of nanoimpact test. The review of known fatigue criteria and analysis of fatigue behaviour are presented next and the selection of four of the criteria is justified. Finally, the results of simulations with the fatigue criteria implemented into the FE code for the analysed problem are shown and commented.
8.1 Introduction The impact test performed for mass materials is known as the Charpy impact test. It is a standardized high strain rate test, which determines the amount of energy absorbed by a material during fracture. This absorbed energy is a measure of the considered material toughness and it acts as an aid to study brittle – ductile Magdalena Kopernik, Lechosław Tre¸bacz, and Maciej Pietrzyk Department of Applied Computer Science and Modelling, AGH University of Science and Technology, Mickiewicza 30, 30–059 Krak´ow, Poland
[email protected],
[email protected],
[email protected] V. Kompiˇs (ed.), Composites with Micro- and Nano-Structure – Computational Modeling and Experiments. c Springer Science + Business Media B.V., 2008
137
138
M. Kopernik et al.
transition. Since it is easy to prepare and conduct, this method is widely applied in industry and results can be obtained quickly and cheaply. But a major disadvantage is that all results are only comparative. The nanoimpact test technique is used in the present work to predict fracture resistance of hard nanocoatings. This test is also called high strain rate indentation. It is not possible to use conventional techniques, such as, for example, tensile testing, to investigate the ductile – brittle behaviour of nanocoatings. The nanoimpact test was developed to extend the capability of depth – sensing nanoindentation [14, 33]/scratch instrumentation [15] and to perform fatigue testing in nanoscale. This instrumented test enables repetitive contact testing of the fatigue properties of coatings and allows investigation of failure mechanisms, as well as comparison of fatigue resistance, depending on the applied deposition process. The objective of the present chapter, which is a continuation of the work [26], is to develop the FE (finite element) model of nanoimpact test for the multilayer material system with implemented fatigue criteria and to use all Authors previous experiences in numerical modelling of hard coatings to optimize the simulated process. The advantage of the new approach to fracture of hard coatings using fatigue criteria is a more accurate description of material behaviour during cyclic deformation with stress relaxation in unloading stage of each impact.
8.2 Nanoimpact Test 8.2.1 The Idea of the Experimental Nanoimpact Test 8.2.1.1 Basic Principles The principle of nanoimpact test is based on a pendulum set-up. High and low cycle fatigue tests over a wide range of contact stresses, frequencies, test durations and strain rates are possible. High cycle fatigue tests are performed by oscillating the sample, what causes the diamond probe to repetitively impact the surface at high frequency until failure. Low cycle fatigue tests are performed by providing a controlled impulse to the diamond via solenoid (see Fig. 8.1a). Impact testing allows the identification of: adhesive failure – failure by a single abrupt jump in probe depth (film removal), cohesive failure – failure by a series of several smaller jumps (fracture/partial delamination) and mixed failure modes. Coatings are ranked in terms of: life time (durability), type and energy to failure. The impact test records the evolution of impact induced damage with time (i.e. elastic and plastic deformation, fatigue wear and fracture) during repetitive impact of a test probe. The general response of a brittle material to repetitive contact in the nanoimpact test can be summarized as follows [4, 5]: 1. Initial impact – some plastic deformation occurs and cracks begin to nucleate subsurface
8 Modelling of Fatigue Behaviour
139
Fig. 8.1 (a) Schematic illustration of the Nano Test System showing the configuration for impact testing [5], (b) the real view of Berkovich indent in material [15]
2. Fatigue – growth of crack subsurface and further nucleation with little or no change in probe depth 3. Crack coalescence and fracture – rapid change in probe depth 4. Repetition of the fatigue cycle – long periods separated by abrupt fracturing events Initial probe penetration does not involve dramatic film fracture. Plastic deformation of the subsurface is common in the initial stages of impact wear. As in nanoindentation [14, 33], the maximum shear stress is rather below than at the surface. Initial plastic deformation of the substrate is followed by a fatigue process that ultimately leads to film fracture, without significant additional depth change occurring until the onset of fracture. This suggests that fatigue failure occurs by a brittle process (crack formation, growth and coalescence) rather than further plastic deformation. Mechanisms of film failure under fatigue conditions include: 1. Transition from stable to unstable crack growth, leading to fast fracture 2. Cracks reaching the film–substrate interface and causing spallation 3. The film bending stress being exceeded The fracture probability varies during the impact test (number of impacts), depends on impact load and thickness of coating. The films resistance to impact induced fracture is compared by: probe depth (i.e. surface position) at the end of the test, presence or absence of clear surface failure/fracture, time at which first fracture occurs (time-to-fracture) and probability of fracture within a given time.
8.2.1.2 Materials Investigated in Nanoimpact Test The hard coatings are investigated in experimental nanoimpact test and most of them are compositionally graded coatings. These tests were performed for:
140
M. Kopernik et al.
(a) Super-hard form of DLC–tetrahedral amorphous carbon (ta–C) films [5], which are deposited on silicon by the filtered cathodic vacuum arc (FCVA) technique. They have unique properties, such as high hardness, low coefficient of friction, thermal stability, high electrical resistivity and transparency in a wide spectral range. These coatings may be applied in the hard disc industry. (b) The amorphous carbon (a–C), hydrogenated diamond-like carbon (a–C:H, DLC) and CrAlTiN coatings [2, 4], which are deposited on tool steel using the closed field unbalanced magnetron sputter ion plating (CFUBMSIP) process. The results are that the performance of the CrAlTiN system depends on the impact load. Due to its graphite-like structure, the a–C showed greatly improved impact resistance compared to the a–C:H coating. (c) The monolayer TiCN, bilayer Al2 O3 –TiCN and trilayer TiN–Al2 O3 –TiCN coatings [3] are deposited on cemented carbide by CVD method. These coatings offer promising opportunities for combining layers with different functionality (e.g. thermal barrier, oxidation resistance) together with larger overall coating thickness and hence load-carrying capability. Particularly, these systems are effective in combining a range of properties including high hardness, wear resistance and toughness, to achieve good performance over a wider range of wear situations. (d) Ti1−x Alx N (x = 0.5, 0.67) [6] are deposited on cemented carbide at 25–500 ◦C by PVD (physical vapour deposition) method. Life of the cutting tool life made of this material was studied under conditions of ma