Connectivity in Grammar and Discourse
Hamburg Studies on Multilingualism (HSM) Hamburg Studies on Multilingualism (HSM) publishes research from colloquia on linguistic aspects of multilingualism organized by the Research Center on Multilingualism at the University of Hamburg.
Editors Jürgen M. Meisel Monika Rothweiler Juliane House University of Hamburg Research Center on Mulitlingualism
Volume 5 Connectivity in Grammar and Discourse Edited by Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein and Lukas Pietsch
Connectivity in Grammar and Discourse
Edited by
Jochen Rehbein Christiane Hohenstein Lukas Pietsch Middle East Technical University, Ankara and University of Hamburg
John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdam / Philadelphia
8
TM
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences – Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ansi z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Connectivity in grammar and discourse / edited by Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein and Lukas Pietsch. p. cm. (Hamburg Studies on Multilingualism, issn -3363 ; v. 5) Includes bibliographical references and indexes. 1. Grammar, Comparative and general--Connectives. 2. Discourse analysis. I. Rehbein, Jochen. II. Hohenstein, Christiane. III. Pietsch, Lukas. P302.27.C66 2007 415--dc22
2007060663
isbn 978 90 272 1925 1 (Hb; alk. paper) © 2007 – John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. · P.O. Box 36224 · 1020 me Amsterdam · The Netherlands John Benjamins North America · P.O. Box 27519 · Philadelphia pa 19118-0519 · usa
The production of this series has been made possible through financial support to the Research Center on Multilingualism (Sonderforschungsbereich 538 "Mehrsprachigkeit") by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG).
Table of contents Connectivity as an object of linguistic research in multilingualism Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
1
Section 1. Aspects of language change and language acquisition Grammaticalization of converb constructions: The case of Japanese –te conjunctive constructions Masayoshi Shibatani Contact, connectivity and language evolution Yaron Matras Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian as donor language Thomas Stolz Some notes on the syntax-pragmatics interface in bilingual children: German in contact with French / Italian Natascha Müller
21
51
75
101
Section 2. Pronouns, topics and subjects Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in popular 16th-18th century Greek narratives: A synchronic and diachronic perspective Chrystalla A. Thoma Nominative subjects of non-finite clauses in Hiberno-English Lukas Pietsch
139
165
Section 3. Finiteness in text and discourse Aspectotemporal connectivity in Turkic: Text construction, text subdivision, discourse types and taxis Lars Johanson
187
Connectivity by means of finite elements in monolingual and bilingual Turkish discourse Birsel Karakoç
199
Connectivity in Grammar and Discourse
Section 4. Subordination – coordination Alternative subordination strategies in Turkish Celia Kerslake
231
Studying connectivity with the help of computer-readable corpora: Some exemplary analyses from modern and historical, written and spoken corpora Nicole Baumgarten, Annette Herkenrath, Thomas Schmidt, Kai Wörner and Ludger Zeevaert
259
Discourse coordination in Turkish monolingual and Turkish-German bilingual children’s talk: işte Annette Herkenrath
291
Section 5. Adverbials, particles and constructions Modal adverbs as discourse markers: A bilingual approach to the study of indeed Karin Aijmer
329
„So, given this common theme ...“: Linking constructions in discourse across languages Kristin Bührig and Juliane House
345
An utterance-transcending connector: Particle to in utterance-final position in Japanese business reporting Yuko Sugita
367
Between connectivity and modality: Reported speech in interpretermediated doctor-patient communication Thomas Johnen and Bernd Meyer
395
Matrix constructions Jochen Rehbein
419
Language index
449
Name index
451
Subject index
457
Connectivity as an object of linguistic research in multilingualism Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch Middle East Technical University, Ankara, and University of Hamburg The contributions in this volume investigate the role played by various linguistic elements in interconnecting units of text and discourse. We discuss this role, the linguistic forms involved and their functions under the term of ‘connectivity’. Connectivity concerns issues of linguistic interaction in its different aspects of grammar, prosody, text and discourse. Since it has repercussions on issues of multilingualism and language contact, as well as language change and language acquisition, the topic of connectivity is of relevance to various research projects working within the Research Center 538 ‘Multilingualism’ in Hamburg, out of which the present collection has developed (cf. House and Rehbein 2004). Of particular interest are the various linguistic means individual languages use to express connectivity. To date, even though connectivity is an area of research that has produced a large number of studies, the field is still rather opaque. Thus, a few structuring and systematic introductory remarks are in order. To begin with, we discuss (1) a general outline of an analytic approach to linguistic connectivity, and (2) different aspects through which it manifests itself in language. In an outline of the book (3), we relate specific fields of linguistic research pertaining to connectivity to the article sections and their main topics. As eminent fields of linguistic research, both language change and language acquisition offer a more general perspective on the role of connectivity and connectives (3.1). The subsequent chapters – ‘Pronouns, topics and subjects’ (3.2), ‘Finiteness in text and discourse’ (3.3), ‘Subordination – coordination ’ (3.4), and ‘Adverbials, particles and constructions’ (3.5) – deal with particular linguistic means which are highly language specific. Accordingly, connectives relating to various grammatical concepts are discussed with regard to their discourse functions and effects.
1. Linguistic connectivity During the 1980s, connectivity was addressed frequently as a connection between “clauses”, and discussed in terms of “subordination” (Mackenzie 1984, König and van der Auwera 1988). Phenomena such as “(hypotactic) clause combining” (Matthiessen
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
and Thompson 1988), and procedures of “clause chaining” (Slobin 1988) formed a focus of interest. That is, connectivity between linguistic units internal to the sentence or an utterance, mostly between their constituents, ranked high with a discernible research interest in ‘surface’ structures of language. However, under a contrastive perspective, aiming at the discovery of universals in propositional encoding, entities beyond the clause came into view. Forms used to encode a sequence of propositions were discussed e. g. with regard to the notions of “nexus” (of clauses) and of “linkage” (Foley and Van Valin 1984, Van Valin and LaPolla 1997). Characteristically, utterance-internal connections serve to integrate their conjunct elements into a single, complex hierarchical whole and submit them to a common illocutionary force (cf. Foley and Van Valin 1984: 239f.). Since connectivity is organised in ways highly specific to individual languages, perspectives from non-Indo-European languages and contrastive studies have led to insights in effects on text and discourse structure according to the type of connectivity. For instance, gerund constructions in Japanese, especially the converbial “-te” form, have received a steady and growing interest (cf. Myhill & Hibiya 1988, Hasegawa 1996, Grein 1998, Shibatani, this vol.). Equally, Turkish and Turkic converbs (Johanson 1995) continue to offer new vistas on intricate patternings in discourse up to the point of setting up specific discourse types (cf. Karacoç, this vol.; Johanson, this vol., Kerslake, this vol.). Studies on the phenomenon of textual ‘connexity’ (cf. Conte et al. 1989, Heydrich et al. 1989) and, more prominently, the notions of ‘coherence’ and ‘cohesion’ (Halliday and Hasan 1976) helped to develop a body of research on interrelated topics, dealing with linguistic devices overarching the boundaries of single sentences and single utterances (cf. also, in terms of text linguistics, van Dijk 1979, de Beaugrande 1980, contributions in Cambourian 2001, and others). At the same time, research on “connexion” in terms of information-processing within the confines of sentence-based linguistic units, linking “sentence content”, and leading to “textual coherence”, is still growing (cf. Fabricius-Hansen 2000). – In their extensive study of the language development in English, German, Spanish, Hebrew, and Turkish, based on narratives of frog stories, Berman and Slobin (1994) propose connectivity of the informational structure of discourse as an essential concept of analysis: “... we are studying the development of the capacity to describe situations. We are also concerned with the ways in which individual events are related to each other. That is, we are studying the development of linguistic means to connect events and syntactically “package” them into coherent structures – at the level of scene, episode, and overall plot.” (Berman and Slobin 1994: 1–2). We can conclude that ‘connectivity’ as a notion comprises both utterance-internal and utterance-external linguistic devices of various categories (cf. Rehbein 1999). Cross-linguistically, it can be observed that connectivity manifests itself on the ‘linguistic surface’ along a continuum from subordinating connectives through “serialisation” by means of converbs, to coordinative devices which may span not only clauses and phrases, but may link complete utterances, sentences, even parts of text and dis-
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
course to each other (cf. Rudolph 1996, Bisang 1995, 1998b, Johanson 1995, Haspelmath 1995, Kortmann 1996). The phenomenon of connectivity has been receiving increasing attention from linguists, especially from a typological and contrastive perspective (van der Auwera and Bultinck 2001; Behrens and Fabricius-Hansen 2002; Berman 1998; Rehbein 2002; Unger 1996; Verhagen 2001; Grein 1998; Hasegawa 1996; Horie 2000 etc.). Aspects of meaning and formation of discourse particles more and more come into focus (e.g. Mori 1999; Onodera 2004; Park 1998; Fischer 2006). A new domain of connectivity was opened up by the debate about the pragmatics of “small words”, in the English speaking community about ‘discourse markers’ (Schourup 1985, Schiffrin 1985, Fraser 1990 a.o.) and ‘gambits’ (Edmondson 1978, House and Kasper 1981), in the German speaking community about ‘Partikeln’ (cf. e.g. Weydt (ed.) 1979, 1983, 1987). Moreover, connectivity pertains not only to ‘surface’ elements of language such as phrases, clauses, or sentences. It also applies to illocutions, propositions and mental/ cognitive entities, such as particular elements of knowledge, to patterns of (inter-)action and to types of discourse (cf. Hohenstein 2005, 2006 a,b,c, ch. 6.2). This type of mental/cognitive connectivity is established incessantly during the interaction process between speakers and hearers, writers and readers. Thus, “connectivity” is not to be identified with “context” (cf. Rehbein and Kameyama 2003; House 2006). Rather, the development and expansion of linguistic means of connectivity – in diachronic language change and in ontogenetic language development – actually render ‘text’, at least partially, independent of ‘context’. In the following discussion, emphasis will be laid on discursive and textual connections established by the grammatical and interactional potential of more or less complex linguistic devices. While they all serve to connect linguistic actions in their various dimensions, they belong to different formal and functional categories. They are of different internal make-up, and thus constitute different linguistic activities and processes. The guiding hypothesis in this is that connectivity frequently constitutes hinges within the flow of discourse and text (s. Bührig and House, this volume; cf. the German term ‘Scharnier’ as well as Jakobson’s 1957 concept of ‘shifter’).
2. Aspects of connectivity There is no clear-cut division of labour between grammar and discourse in the sense that grammar would exclusively concern the utterance internal connectivity whereas discourse/text concerned that between utterances. Rather, one may say that there is an intertwining of grammar and discourse/text in linguistic connectivity (or: connectives). Therefore, if one looks at the characteristics of connectivity, one should account for both, grammar as well as discourse and text. As for discourse and text, linguistic connectives can generally be described as joining a linguistic action X with a linguistic action Y. Since what is joined are frequently
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
not full-fledged linguistic actions, but specific dimensions of these, we speak of “dimension X” and “dimension Y” of different linguistic actions being joined. Dimensions of linguistic actions are: a. Constellation: Speech situation, categories of action space (motivations, needs, interactional space, control field etc.) b. Utterance act: Syntax, morphology, phonetics/phonology, prosody etc. c. Illocutionary act: Illocutions, utterance mode, etc. d. Propositional act: Semantics, argument, predicate, predication, symbol fields, etc. e. Knowledge: Presupposition, elements of knowledge, knowledge space, knowledge structure, expectations, knowledge differential, linguistic knowledge, etc. f. Other mental processes: Evaluation, imagination, understanding, planning, etc. g. Cooperation: Back-channel activities, interaction management, speaker-hearersteering devices, reception, etc. All the dimensions mentioned above can become either starting point or target point of a connective: A connective starts out at a dimension X of one linguistic action as a starting point, and joins it to a dimension Y as the target point of another linguistic action. For instance, in the case of a phoric pronoun the starting point is a nominal or another propositional element, while the target point is the phoric expression, which serves to copy the nominal or propositional element into a different syntagm. Connectivity then manifests itself in the process of coreferring, the phoric procedure. In the case of coordination, one propositional element is the starting point, while the target point is a second propositional element of the same grammatical category; in that case, the connective itself implements the process of joining them under a common category of propositionally based knowledge. Thus, the connective acts as a morphosyntactic trigger element of discursive/textual knowledge building. Prosody may be described as a formal domain of its own, since it interacts with the grammatical components, especially in spoken discourse. Quite often we are dealing with a connection between prosodic units joined into a larger schema (cf. Chafe 1988, 1994). Some of the contributions in this volume take into account the connective functions of prosodic and phonetic / phonological resources (e.g. Kerslake, Matras, Thoma, Sugita, cf. this volume). Thus, connectivity between what we may term as the dimensions of a linguistic action X and a linguistic action Y is established by means of different linguistic devices. With regard to their linguistic form, i. e. to grammar, they can be described according to their phonetics/phonology, morphosyntax, constructional make-up and other criteria, depending on the theoretical background of the analyst. As for the functions of linguistic devices realizing connectivity, these may be found – and diagnosed – if one looks at what is done with the forms on the level of discourse and text. Then, functions of connectives can be characterised as the purpose inherent in their forms. Frequently, these inherent purposes are located in the mental-cognitive processes on the part of the hearer/reader which establish connections between different dimensions of linguistic
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
actions as aspects of their own (Givon 1995 pointed out that the connectivity of a text is based on its “structured mental representation... The more connections a node has... the more mentally-accessible it is.” (Givon 1995: 64)). The majority of connectives involves procedures that are operative, in so far as they work on linguistic dimensions, instructing a hearer/reader to process parts of the propositional act in relation to each other (for the ‘field’ characteristics of linguistic procedures cf. Rehbein this vol.). Composite deictic procedures (Rehbein 1995a; for contrasts in English-German translations, cf. Bührig and House 2004, for a comparative analysis in German and English academic articles, cf. Fandrych and Graefen 2002), and connectives of formal cooperation (back channel cues and the like, cf. Ehlich 1986, 1987), can be regarded as typical cases, since, from the point of view of procedural pragmatics, connective devices are rather complex structures, encompassing multi-procedural components as combination, ensemble, integration etc. of linguistic procedures.
3. Outline of the book 3.1
Language change and language acquisition
Several contributions in this volume investigate the relation between connectivity and language change. For instance, Masayoshi Shibatani demonstrates how Japanese converb constructions with motion verbs (-te iku/kuru, conv go/come) undergo several stages of change before they grammaticalize into a new grammatical class of aspectual suffixes. There are, for instance, stages of a solidification of constructions on the phonetic and syntactic level – depending on sucessive changes in the main verb, e.g. a loss of valency – but not on the morphological level. In other cases there is a decreasing degree of congruity of verb and converb. Actually, both grammaticalization types, gradual and instantaneous grammaticalization, are observed with these Japanese converb constructions. That is, the steps leading up to the point where a construction or a part of it finally changes its grammatical category can be revealed only by fine-grained syntactic analysis and if differential linguistic context is taken into account. If, as Bisang 1998a states with regard to serial and relative clause constructions in various African and Asian languages, “constructions and the human equipment are somehow involved in the propagation of linguistic changes” as well as “the factor of sociolinguistics” (Bisang 1998a: 51), in multilingual communities, language change may be induced by contact due to plurilingual people communicating with each other in the contact languages (cf. Stolz and Stolz 1996/97; Stolz, this volume, Matras 2002 and this volume). Many of the connective procedures are sensitive to contact, insofar as they import linguistic devices from a contact language, copy them, integrate them or modify their own forms under conditions of contact (cf. Johanson 1992b, 1999a, Muysken 2000, Clyne 2003, Heine and Kuteva 2005). New connectives are frequently created in mixed languages (cf. Bakker and Mous 1994, Matras 1996, 2000, Matras and
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
Bakker 2003, Bakker 2003, Stolz 2003, etc.). Apparently it is due to the complexity of their linguistic structure (both synchronically and diachronically speaking) and function that connectives are not only sensitive to contact-induced language change but vulnerable to it (Müller 2003). According to Yaron Matras (this volume), certain languages such as Turoyo, Domari, Romani and others have used various languages from their respective environments as sources of new connectives, which belong to the types of coordination, illocutionary modification, and interaction management. The shift of one expression, structure or construction into a new category or a new paradigm often happens in a complex process involving functional shift, splits in syntax, morphology, word boundaries and semantics, to the point of their fusion. Matras also spells out some sociolinguistic conditions for replication and points towards the mental base of contact-induced change: “Connectivity structures, then, appear particularly vulnerable not just to the actual borrowing for formal material such as conjunctions and other particles, but also to the replication of patterns of constituent ordering, agreement and overall form-function mapping that form the mental blueprint from the respective construction.” (Matras, this volume). Thomas Stolz (this volume) points to the interesting fact that the item allora, borrowed from Italian into (Italo-)Greek, (Italo-)Albanian, Cimbrian, Molise Slavic and Maltese, failed to acquire the full range of functions in the receiving languages that it had in the donor language. His findings point to a dominant role played in contact by the category of temporal deixis, which later develops further into functions of coordination and others. In a similar vein, Herkenrath (this volume) observes that the item işte in German Turkish develops a mixed deictic-coordinative type of use, pointing towards an instance of partial contact-induced grammaticalisation. Stolz explains differences observed between contact results in different languages with language-typological as well as sociolinguistic factors. In this respect, his approach differs from that of Matras, who regards interaction management as the dominant category governing contact-induced effects. Ultimately, linguistic elements may shift into a new formal class and thereby change their functional behaviour with respect to connectivity too. Under a functional-pragmatic perspective, grammaticalization can be characterized as a process whereby complex procedures are transposed within a linguistic field or to a new linguistic field (such as procedural ensembles in the case of matrix constructions or composite deictics; cf. Rehbein, this vol., Johnen and Meyer, this vol.). Restructuring within the utterance may then be the consequence of an increase in context dependence, as in the case of shift towards aspect semantics of the converb constructions in Japanese (Shibatani, this vol.). In bilingual language acquisition, connective elements seem to play an important role, all the more so since connective elements make up a large part of all functional elements (Muysken 2000). Natascha Müller (this volume) notes that in certain grammatical domains – e.g. null-subject properties, object clitics, complementation – there is not an absolute separation of languages in bilingual acquisition (cf. Meisel 1989, Genesee 1989, Genesee, Nicoladis and Paradis 1995 etc.), but some amount of positive
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
cross-linguistic influence, which may result in a partial acceleration of acquisition processes on both sides. She relates these findings to the concept of a common syntaxpragmatics interface, where a shared pragmatic module may help in preparing the ground for syntactic acquisition in both languages. Müller also argues, based on Lopez (2003), that “phases” in the sense of Chomsky’s (2001) theory of syntactic derivation can be interpreted pragmatically. Thus, both in German and in French matrix constructions, pragmatically interpreted subordinated structures can be classified as connectives according to factors of presuppositions and language contrast, independently of their formal-syntactic means of expressing subordination (with or without the complementizer dass/que). A comparable finding is the reinterpretation of Turkish aspecto-temporal finite forms as deictic terms in Turkish–German bilingualism (Rehbein and Karakoç 2004, Karakoç, this vol. cf. below).
3.3
Pronouns, topics and subjects
Topic as a central formative element of thematic organization is a subdomain of linguistic information processing. The manifestation of topic connectivity (see e.g. Aarssen 1998) is strongly sensitive to typological parameters. Languages can be ordered typologically along a continuum between “subject-prominent” and “topic-prominent” (cf. Li and Thompson 1976). Of these, the subject-prominent languages make more heavily use of phoric expressions and can therefore also be characterized as “phoric languages”. On this scale, languages like Japanese and Turkish are more on the topicprominent side, while German, English and French are more on the subject-prominent (phoric) side. This distinction partly correlates with the distinction made in UGbased approaches between “Pro-drop” (or “Null Subject”) and “Non Pro-drop” (or “Non-Null Subject”) languages (Jaeggli and Safir 1989, Haegeman 1997, Rizzi 1997). Phoric expressions (~ PRO-elements) are the “pronouns” of the 3rd person (German er, sie, es; English he, she, it; French il, elle; including their case-inflected forms). In many languages these have no free-word counterparts. The difference between phoric and deictic “pronouns” (“pronoms”) was pointed out first by Benveniste (1956). The purpose of phoric expressions is to encode the continuity of a topic in such a way as to keep it mentally activated for the hearer/reader (Hoffmann 1997: 844f.) PRO-elements are thus linguistic devices of connectivity typical of phoric languages. Their syntactic distribution is often identical with that of free noun phrases; in particular, they can take up subject or object positions, typically depending on the valency of the verb. Grammatically, these phoric elements are pronouns in the narrow sense. On the other hand, phoric elements may be clitics (as in the Romance languages, some Semitic languages, or in spoken German): In Greek (Chrystalla Thoma, this volume), cliticized, weak phoric pronouns have developed. They are employed for topicalization procedures under “clitic object doubling” (cf. Haberland and van der Auwera 1990). Thoma states an interrelationship between the preverbal position of unstressed
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
third person (weak) pronouns and the deployment of discourse pragmatic functions within the historical language development. “In Early Modern Greek, fronted elements, not necessarily contrastive, attract clitic pronouns to pre-verbal position, until that position becomes the norm and is grammaticalised in Standard Modern Greek. A similar process has taken place in the Romance languages...” (Thoma, this volume; cf. also Janse 2000). It seems to be of high interest that phoric elements of this kind have been developed in an otherwise topic-based language, and despite the fact that other topic based languages were spoken in the environment of the Greek language. An instance where the coding of connectivity is affected by the case-marking on pronouns comes from Irish English (Lukas Pietsch, this volume). In Irish English (Hiberno-English), gerund constructions are found to have changed their syntactic behaviour under contact with Irish. While Standard English in such constructions displays case marking properties that overtly reflect the subordinate character of the construction (either accusative or genitive), Hiberno-English developed a usage of nominative subject pronouns instead. Pietsch argues that this morphological change reflects a change in the underlying syntactic properties of the constructional pattern, obliterating the effect of “subject-to-object raising” (or “exceptional case marking”) that motivates the predominant accusative marking in the Standard English system. Hiberno-English has replicated a pattern from Irish where subject pronouns fail to mark their subordinate status by means of case. Interestingly, Irish itself, while lacking the device of case marking to make this distinction, employs another, syntactic one, marking subordinate clauses by means of different word order. As this syntactic distinction was not replicated in English, the net effect is that the contact variety shows an overall reduction in the overt coding of subordination, having fewer overt formal differences between non-finite subclauses and finite clauses than either of the two source languages have.
3.4
Finiteness in text and discourse
The connectivity created by finite elements (cf. Bisang 2001, Johanson 1994, 1999b) results from the fact that a finite element is characterised by its role as the carrier of predication, the procedure whereby a predicate is assigned to an argument. Lars Johanson (this volume) discusses a type of “chain sentence” characteristic of Turkish literary language, where there is a series of non-finite utterances anchored in the narrative constellation only through the basic finite element at the very end, thus establishing aspectual/temporal, modal and illocutionary features of the earlier utterances only in retrospect. The role of finiteness may also be sensitive to parameters of text and discourse type. For instance, as Johanson remarks, there was an influence of French prose on the structuring of connectivity in late Ottoman literature. (Cf. also Johanson 1971, 1992a). Birsel Karakoç (this volume) finds that bilingual German-Turkish children acquire finite elements in Turkish later than monolingual Turkish children. In monolingual Turkish these finite elements have a function of establishing connectivity on a discourse-type
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
level. In contrast, the bilinguals develop a stronger use of a range of temporal deictic expressions to extend their linguistic capabilities in Turkish. The difference is most marked in the use of the Turkish evidential suffixes. (Cf. also Rehbein and Karakoç 2004).
3.5
Subordination – coordination
Subordination includes phenomena such as attribution, relativization, and complementation. Depending on the language, these phenomena may manifest themselves in grammatical elements such as complementizers, relativizers, wh-elements, case, non-finiteness, or syntactic position (Mackenzie 1984, Haiman and Thompson 1988, Redder 1990, Fabricius-Hansen 1992, Müller 1993, Verhagen 2001 a.o.). An important typological parameter in this respect is that of “deranking” of verb forms, which can be described along a cline from finite through subjunctive to nonfinite (cf. Croft 2001, ch. 9). Celia Kerslake (this volume) presents a classification of subordinate clauses in Turkish. Of special interest is a type of finite subordinate clause with a subordinator in the initial position, because it does not fit the canonical typological classificatory assumptions of Turkish as a left-branching word order language. This phenomenon is contact-related, as the subordinator in question, ki, which introduces subordinate clauses with a postnominal or postpredicative placement, is borrowed from Persian. In Persian its meanings include ‘that’, ‘who’, ‘which’, ‘when’, ‘so that’, etc. Kerslake concludes: that “wherever Turkish (or another Turkic language) is exposed to prolonged contact with a politically and/or demographically dominant Indo-European language (Iranian, Slavic, Germanic, etc), there is a strong tendency for attrition to occur in the indigenous (left-branching, non-finite) type of subordinate clause in favour of finite right-branching clauses introduced by a subordinating conjunction [...]” (Kerslake, this vol.; for the grammatical background, s. Göksel and Kerslake 2005). In Turkish, ki-constructions serve the language-internal management of pragmatic and rhetorical purposes, in a way that meets psycholinguistic (universal) requirements of language processing in spoken language. This renders ki a linker of finite clauses to a postpredicative subordination and, in this way, enables speakers to process unplannend propositions in a syntactic-semantic relationship. Coordinating connectivity is often described as symmetric, but it may actually link any kind of element (conjunct) to any kind of preceding element (conjunct) (cf. Haspelmath ed. 2004). Coordination is mostly concerned with the linking of propositional elements (cf. Redder 2006). Through coordination, that conjunct which is set off from the coordinator through a structural cesura is categorially upgraded and turned into the lead category for the other conjunct (cf. Matras 1997, 1998). While coordinating connectivity may join individual words or phrases within an utterance, it can also join entire utterances, illocutionary acts or even whole linguistic actions to each other. Annette Herkenrath (this volume), in a corpus-based study comparing bilingual acquisition of Turkish and German in Germany with monolingual acquisition of Turkish in Turkey, finds differences in the functional diversification of the discourse con-
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
nective işte. A specific coordinative use abundant in Turkish narrative discourse seems to be lost or play a minor role in German Turkish (cf. Herkenrath, Karakoç and Rehbein 2003). Acquired late even by monolinguals as a linguistic device of sequential and concatenative discourse connectivity (cf. Özbek 2000, Yılmaz 2004), this kind of discourse coordination thus may be undergoing functional change in German Turkish. Nicole Baumgarten, Annette Herkenrath, Thomas Schmidt, Kai Wörner and Ludger Zeevaert (this vol.) conduct a corpus-based study of functional characteristics of coordinating elements in diverse languages – Modern English and German, Old Swedish and Turkish. They demonstrate how such an approach can lead to conclusions with regard to more general insights into coordination. Thus, they hypothesize that coordinating connectives may undergo functional innovation or diversification triggered by coordination on macrosyntactic textual and discourse level. They also consider general issues regarding computeraided quantitative and qualitative methods of corpus analysis.
3.6
Adverbials, particles, and constructions
Adverbial constructions (cf. e.g. van der Auwera 1998) serve to relate a base construction to preestablished knowledge, and to add a new knowledge relation or evaluation to it. Karin Aijmer (this volume) focusses on the range of functions displayed by the item indeed, drawing particular attention to a number of rhetorical functions associated with it (cf. White 2003). Through a process of gradual grammaticalization, this item has developed functions as a discourse marker (cf. Schiffrin 1987, Fraser 1990, Aijmer and Simon-Vandenbergen 2006). Observing textual choices made by translators, Aijmer finds that indeed tends to attract special attention when used as an adverbial, as it tends to be explicitly rendered more regularly than other types of connectives, which are often omitted in translation. Complex composite adverbials, like in fact, any time, in addition, often stand extra posed at the sentence periphery, joining the base construction to which they are attached, with overarching large-scale textual segments. Thus they act as hinges, joining larger propositional structures (such as argumentations) with the more specific speech actions of which they are part. Kristin Bührig and Juliane House (this volume) call such connectives “linking constructions” (cf. also Bührig 2003, Leuschner 1998 on options of these constructions for grammaticalization). In complex texts, they can also be used as advance organizers which vary cross-linguistically (cf. Gülich 1970, Clyne 1987 a.o.). Particles form another subgroup of connectives to be mentioned here (for literature in a cross-linguistic/contrastive perspective, cf. Fischer 2006, Weydt 1983, 1987, König 1991, Liedke 1994, Nekula 1996, Cardenes Melián 1997, van der Wouden, Foolen and van de Craen 2003, and others). Generally speaking, particles stand in a threefold relation: (1) they establish a relation to a preceding linguistic action, mostly in propositional and illocutionary terms; (2) they modify the propositional content of the utterance of which they are part, by taking a certain part of the propositional content
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
of their utterance into their scope; (3) in addition, they link the content of the utterance with the knowledge of the hearer, especially with respect to the evaluation of the propositional content being received; in doing so they act upon the illocution of the speech action in which they are used. The Japanese language is notorious for its manifold particles, whose functions range from purely grammatical operations, such as ‘case’, to illocutionary tasks, such as ‘interrogative’, and many more. Yuko Sugita (this volume) investigates a functional expansion observed in the Japanese mono-moraic and pitchless ‘quotative’ particle to in oral business reports. She finds that this complementizer is used recurrently in utterance final position, serving as a device for non-linear information processing over larger parts of interrelated concatenative discourse. Matrix constructions, a class of complex formulae which often comprise constructions of reported speech, have connective functions not necessarily limited to the scope of a single utterance. The study of Thomas Johnen and Bernd Meyer (this volume) on interpreted doctor-patient communication shows that different grammatical parts of the reported speech construction may realize different functions in discourse. Especially the lexical (symbol field) component of the matrix reflects the attitude of the interpreter towards what s/he reports in order to qualify the reported information for the hearer-patient: “Whereas Turkish diyor and Portuguese dizer que (to say) are mainly used to trace propositional parts to their source, thus indicating reliability, the German meinen with third person (he/she means) is used mainly to refer to some kind of deficiency in the source language discourse.” (Johnen and Meyer, this vol.). Matrix constructions establish utterance-internal connections between propositional acts and expressions of thinking, believing, speaking, feeling and the like (i.e. the symbol field of knowledge and its verbalization), employing a wide possible range of language-specific means (for a comparative analysis of Japanese and German matrix constructions cf. Hohenstein 2004). Their utterance-external connective function in discourse and text is concerned with joining hearer knowledge unto the speaker knowledge related to the current utterance. Following a proposal by Bührig (2002), this function can be characterized as “interaction coherence” (Jochen Rehbein, this volume). This book assembles a broad range of topics in the domain of connectivity in multilingual constellations and/or in a cross-linguistic perspective. Future research, then, might be directed at establishing a theoretically and empirically based classification of connectives and at elaborating the systematic (and maybe partly universal) architecture of their grammatical forms and communicative functions across languages. Such a classification might also contribute to a better understanding of multilingual language acquisition, of language contact and of the finely granulated stages of grammaticalization, whether instantaneous or gradual. We wish to conclude by deeply thanking our colleagues who agreed to anonymously review the articles in this collection and who by their critical comments and their suggestions helped to achieve a higher degree of clarity and precision. It goes
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch
without saying that the responsibility for any mistakes that may have been overlooked lies with the authors and ourselves.
References Aarssen, J. 1998. Acquisition of topic continuity in Turkish children’s narratives. In The Mainz Meeting. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Turkish Linguistics, L. Johanson (ed.), 501–516. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Aijmer, K. and Simon-Vandenbergen, A. (eds). 2006. Pragmatic Markers in Contrast. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Bakker, P. and Mous, M. (eds.). 1994. Mixed Languages. 15 case studies in language intertwining. Amsterdam: IFOTT. Bakker, P. 2003. Mixed languages as autonomous systems. In The Mixed Language Debate. Theoretical and empirical advances, Matras, Y. and Bakker, P. (eds.), 107–151. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Behrens, B. and Fabricius-Hansen, C. 2002. Connectives in Contrast: A discourse semantic study of elaboration based computer research. In Information Structure in a Cross-Linguistic Perspective, H. Hasselgard, S. Johansson, B. Behrens and C. Fabricius-Hansen (eds), 45–61. Amsterdam: Rodopi. Benveniste, É. 1956. �������������������������� La nature des pronoms. In Problèmes de linguistique générale, 251–257. Paris: Gallimard. Berman R. A. 1998. Typological perspectives on connectivity. In Issues in the theory of language acquisition, N. Dittmar and Z. Penner (eds), 203–224. Bern: Peter Lang. Berman R. A. and Slobin, D. (ed.). 1994. Relating Events in Narrative. A crosslinguistic developmental study. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Bisang, W. 1995. Verb serialization and converbs – differences and similarities. In Converbs in Cross-Linguistic Perspective. Structure and meaning of adverbial verb forms – Adverbial participles, gerunds –, M. Haspelmath, and E. König (eds), 137–188. Berlin: �������������������������� Mouton de Gruyter. Bisang, W. 1998a. Grammaticalization ������������������������������������������������������������������������� and language contact, constructions and positions. In The Limits of Grammaticalization, A. G. Ramat and P. J. Hopper (eds), 13–58. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Bisang, W. 1998b. Structural similarities of clause combining in Turkic, Mongolian, ManchuTungusic and Japanese – a typological alternative to the hypothesis of a genetic relationship. In The Mainz Meeting. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Turkish Linguistics, L. Johanson (ed.), 199–223. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Bisang, W. 2001. ������������������������������������ Finite vs. non finite languages. ��� In Language Typology and Language Universals, M. Haspelmath, E. König, W. Oesterreicher and W. Raible, W. (eds), 1400–1413. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Bührig, K. 2002. Interactional coherence in discussions and everyday story telling: On considering the role of ‘auf jeden Fall’ and ‘jedenfalls’. In ��� Rethinking Sequentiality, A. Fetzer and C. Meierkord (eds)������������������������������������� , 273–290. Amsterdam: �������������������������� John Benjamins. Bührig, K. 2003. ����������������������������������������������������������������������������� Zur Funktionalität von ‘auf jeden Fall’ und ‘jedenfalls’. Untersuchungen ������������������� zur Zusammenhangbildung in Text und Diskurs. Universität Hamburg: Habilitationsschrift.
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
Bührig, K. and House, J. 2004. Connectivity in translation. Transitions from orality to literacy. In Multilingual Communication, J. House and J. Rehbein (eds), 87–114. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Cambourian, A. (ed.). 2001. ������ Textkonnektoren und andere textstrukturierende Einheiten. Tübingen: Stauffenburg. Cardenes Melián, J. 1997. Aber, denn, doch, eben und ihre spanischen Entsprechungen. Eine funktional-pragmatische Studie zur Übersetzung deutscher Partikeln. Münster: ���������������� Waxman. Chafe,W. 1988. Linking intonation units in spoken English. In Clause Combining in Grammar and Discourse, J. Haiman and S. A. Thompson (eds), 1–27. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Chafe, W. 1994. Discourse, Consciousness, and Time. The Flow and Displacement of Conscious Experience in Speaking and Writing. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Chomsky, N. 2001. Derivation by phase. In Ken Hale: A life in language, Kenstowicz, M. (ed.), 1–52. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press. Clyne, M. 1987. Cultural differences in the organization of academic texts. Journal of Pragmatics 11: 211–247. Clyne, M. 2003. Dynamics of Language Contact. English and immigrant languages. Cambridge: CUP. Conte M., Petöfi, J. and E. Sözer, E. 1989. Text and Discourse Connectedness. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Croft, W. 2001. Radical Construction Grammar. Oxford: OUP. de Beaugrande, R. 1980. Text, Discourse, and Process. Toward a multidisciplinary science of texts. London: Longman/Ablex. Edmondson, W.J. 1978. A note on pragmatic connectives. Interlanguage Studies Bulletin, Utrecht 1978: 100–106. Ehlich, K. 1986. Interjektionen. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Ehlich, K. 1987. Kooperation und sprachliches Handeln. In Kommunikation und Kooperation, F. Liedtke and R. Keller (eds), 17–32. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Ehlich, K. 1991. Funktional-pragmatische Kommunikationsanalyse. Ziele und Verfahren. In Verbale Interaktion, D. Flader (ed.), 17–32. Stuttgart: Metzler. Fabricius-Hansen, C. 1992 Subordination. In Deutsche Syntax. Ansichten und Aussichten, L. Hoffmann (ed.), 458–483. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, Fabricius-Hansen, C. 2000. Formen der Konnexion. In Text- und Gesprächslinguistik, Vol. I., K. Brinker, G. Antos, W. Heinemann and S. F. Sager (eds), 331–343. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Fandrych, C. and Graefen, G. 2002. Text commenting devices in German and English academic articles. Multilingua 21: 17–43. Fischer, K. (ed.). 2006. Approaches to Discourse Particles [Studies in Pragmatics 1]. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Foley, W. A. and Van Valin, R. D. 1984. Functional Syntax and Universal Grammar. Cambridge: CUP. Fraser, B. 1990. An approach to discourse markers. Journal of Pragmatics 14: 383–395. Genesee, F. 1989. Early bilingual development: One language or two? Journal of Child Language 16: 161–179. Genesee, F., Nicoladis, E. and Paradis, J. 1995. Language differentiation in early bilingual development. Journal of Child Language 22: 611–631. Göksel, A. and Kerslake, C. 2005. Turkish: A comprehensive grammar. London: Routledge. Givón, T. 1991. Serial verbs and the mental reality of ‘event’: Grammatical vs. Cognitive Packaging. In Approaches to Grammaticalization, Vol. I, E. Traugott and B. Heine (eds). 81–127. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch Givón, T. 1995. Coherence in text vs. coherence in mind. In Coherence in Spontaneous Text, M. A. Gernsberg and T. Givón (eds), 59–115. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Grein, M. 1998. Mittel der Satzverknüpfung im Deutschen und im Japanischen. Eine typologischkontrastive Analyse. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitätsverlag. Gülich, E. 1970. Makrosyntax der Gliederungssignale im gesprochenen Französisch. München: Fink. Haberland, H. and van der Auwera, J. 1990. Topics and clitics in Greek relatives. International Journal of Linguistics, Acta Linguistica Hafniensia. Copenhagen: The Linguistic Circle of Copenhagen: 127–157. Haegeman, L. (ed.). 1997. The New Comparative Syntax. London: Longman. Haiman, J. and Thompson, S. A. (eds). 1988. Clause Combining in Grammar and Discourse. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Halliday, M.A.K. and Hasan, R. 1976. Cohesion in English. London: Longman. Hasegawa, Y. 1996. A study of Japanese clause linkage: The connective TE in Japanese. Stanford: CSLI. Haspelmath, M. 1995. The converb as a cross-linguistically valid category. In Converbs in CrossLinguistic Perspective. Structure and Meaning of Adverbial Verb Forms – Adverbial Participles, Gerunds –, M. Haspelmath, and E. König (eds), 1–55. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Haspelmath, M. 2004. Coordinating Constructions: An overview. In Coordinating Constructions, id. (ed.), 3–39. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Heine, B. and Kuteva, T. 2005. Language Contact and grammatical Change. Cambridge: CUP. Herkenrath, A., Karakoç, B. and Rehbein, J. 2003. Interrogative elements as subordinators in Turkish – Aspects of Turkish-German bilingual children’s language use. In (In)vulnerable Domains in Multilingualism [Hamburg Studies on Multilingualism I], N. Müller (ed.), 219– 267. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Heydrich, W., Neubauer, F., Petöfi, J. S. and E. Sözer (eds). 1989. Connexity and Coherence: Analysis of text and discourse. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Hohenstein, C. 2004. A comparative analysis of Japanese and German complement constructions with matrix verbs of thinking and believing: To omou and ich glaube. In Multilingual Communication [Hamburg Studies on Multilingualism 3], J. House and J. Rehbein (eds), 303–341. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Hohenstein, C. 2005. Interactional expectations and Linguistic Knowledge in academic expert discourse (Japanese/German), International Journal of the Sociology of language, 175/176: 285–306. Hohenstein, C. 2006a. Kausale konnektivität in der deutschen un der japanischen Wissenschaftssprache. In Mehrsprachige individuenrechtsprachige Gesellschaften, D. Wolff (ed.), 155–178. Frankfurt: Peter Lang. Hohenstein, C. 2006b. Sind Handlungsmuster mehrsprachig? Erklären im Wissenschaftlichen Vortrag deutsch/japanisch. In Praxen der Mehrsprachigkeit. K. Ehrlich and A. Hornung (eds), 155–194, Münster-Waxmann. Hohenstein, C. 2006 c. Erklärendes Handeln im ‘Wissenschaftlichen Vortrag’: Ein Vergleich des Deutschen mit dem Japanischen. München: Iudicium. Hoffmann, L. 1997. Thematische Organisation von Text und Diskurs. In Grammatik der deutschen Sprache, G. Zifonun, L. Hoffmann and B. Strecker (eds), 507–591. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Horie, K. (ed.). 2000. Complementation: Cognitive and functional perspectives. Amsterdam: John Benjamins House, J. 2006. Text and context in translation. Journal of Pragmatics 38: 338–358.
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
House, J. and Kasper, G. 1981. Politeness markers in English and German. In Conversational Routine. Explorations in standardized communication situations and prepatterned speech, F. Coulmas (ed.), 157–185. The Hague: Mouton. House, J. and Rehbein, J. 2004. What is ‘multilingual communication’? In Multilingual Communication [Hamburg Studies on Multilingualism 3], J. House and J. Rehbein (eds), 1–17. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Jaeggli, O. and Safir, K. J. 1989. The null subject parameter and parametric theory. In The Null Subject Parameter, O. Jaeggli and K. J. Safir (eds), 1–44. Dordrecht: Kluwer. Jakobson, R. 1957 [1971]. Shifters, verbal categories, and the Russian verb. In Selected Writings II. 130–147. The Hague: Mouton. Janse, M. 2000. Convergence and divergence in the development of the Greek and Latin pronouns. In Stability, Variation and Change of Word-Order Patterns over Time, R. Sornicola, E. Poppe and A. Shisha-Halevy (eds) 230–258. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Johanson, L. 1971. Aspekt im Türkischen. Vorstudien zu einer Beschreibung des türkeitürkischen Aspektsystems. Uppsala: Alquist and Wiksell. Johanson, L. 1992a. Periodische Kettensätze im Türkischen. Wiener Zeitschrift für die Kunde des Morgenlandes 82: 201–211. Johanson, L. 1992b. Strukturelle Faktoren in türkischen Sprachkontakten. Stuttgart: Steiner Johanson, L. 1994. Türkeitürkische Aspektotempora. In Tense Systems in European Languages, R. Thieroff and J. Ballweg (eds), 247–266. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Johanson, L. 1995. On Turcic converb clauses. In Converbs in Cross-Linguistic Perspective. Structure and meaning of adverbial verb forms – Adverbial participles, gerunds –, M. Haspelmath, and E. König (eds), 313–347. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Johanson, L. 1999a. The dynamics of code-copying in language encounters. In Language Encounters across Time and Space. Studies in language contact, B. Brendemoen, B. and E. Lanza (eds), 37–62. Oslo: Novus. Johanson, L. 1999b. Viewpoint operators in European languages. In Tense and Aspect in the Languages of Europe, Ö. Dahl (ed.), 27–187. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Kerslake, C. 1996. The role of connectives in discourse construction in Turkish. In Modern Studies in Turkish Linguistics, A. Konrot (ed.), 77–104. Eskişehir: Anadolu University. König, E. 1991. The Meaning of Focus Particles: A comparative perspective. London: Routledge. König, E. and van der Auwera, J. 1988. Clause integration in German and Dutch conditionals, concessive conditionals, and concessives. In Clause Combining in Grammar and Discourse, J. Haiman and S. A. Thompson (eds), 101–133. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Kortmann, B. 1996. Adverbial Subordination. A typology and history of adverbial subordinators based on European languages. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Leuschner, T. 1998. At the boundaries of grammaticalization. What interrogatives are doing in concessive conditionals. In The Limits of Grammaticalization, A. G. Ramat and P. J. Hopper (eds), 159–187. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Li, Ch. N. and Thompson, S. A. 1976. Subject and topic: A new typology of language. In Subject and Topic, C. N. Li (ed.), 457–489. New York: Academic Press. Liedke, M. 1994. Die Mikro-Organisation der Verständigung. Diskursuntersuchungen zu griechischen und deutschen Partikeln. Frankfurt: Peter Lang. López, L. 2003. Steps for a well-adjusted dislocation. Studia Linguistica 57(3): 193–231. Mackenzie, J. L. 1984. Communicative functions of subordination. In English Language Research: The Dutch contribution 1, J. L. Mackenzie and H. Wekker (eds), 67–84. Amsterdam: Vrije Uni Press.
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch Matras Y. 1996. Prozedurale Fusion: Grammatische Interferenzschichten im Romanes. Sprachtypologie und Universalienforschung 49(1): 60–78. Matras Y. 1997. The function and typology of coordinating conjunctions: Evidence from discourse and language-contact situations. In Discourse and Pragmatics in Functional Grammar, J. H. Connolly, R. M. Vismans, C. S. Butler and R. A. Gatward (eds), 177–191. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Matras, Y. 1998. Utterance modifiers and universals as grammatical borrowing. Linguistics 36: 281–331. Matras, Y. 2000. Mixed languages: A functional-communicative approach. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 3: 79–99. Matras, Y. 2002. Romani. A linguistic introduction. Cambridge: CUP. Matras, Y. and Bakker, P. (eds) 2003. The Mixed Language Debate. Theoretical and empirical advances. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Matthiessen, C. and Thompson, S. A. 1988. The structure of discourse and ‘subordination’. In Clause Combining in Grammar and Discourse, J. Haiman and S. A. Thompson, S. A. (eds), 275–329. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Meisel, J. M. 1989. Early differentiation of languages in bilingual children. In Bilingualism across Lifespan: Aspects of acquisition, maturity and loss, K. Hyltenstam and L. Obler (eds), 13–40. Cambridge: CUP. Mori, J. 1999. Negotiating Agreement and Disagreement in Japanese: Connective expressions and turn construction. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Müller, N. 1993. Komplexe Sätze. Der Erwerb von COMP und von Wortstellungsmustern bei bilingualen Kindern (Französisch/Deutsch). Tübingen: Narr. Müller, N. (ed.) 2003. (In)vulnerable Domains in Multilingualism [Hamburg Studies in Multilingualism 1]. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Muysken, P. 2000. Bilingual Speech. A typology of code-mixing. Cambridge: CUP. Myhill J. and J. Hibiya 1988. The discourse function of clause-chaining. In Clause Combining in Grammar and Discourse, J. Haiman and S. A. Thompson (eds), 361–398. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Nekula, M. 1996. System der Partikeln im Deutschen und Tschechischen. Unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Abtönungspartikeln. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Onodera, N. 2004. Japanese Discourse Markers: Synchronic and diachronic discourse analysis. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Özbek, N. 2000. Yani, işte, şey, ya: Interactional markers of Turkish. In Studies on Turkish and Turkic Languages, A. Göksel and C. Kerslake (eds), 393–401. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Park, Y.Y. 1998. A discourse analysis of contrastive connectives in English, Korean, and Japanese conversation: With special reference to the context of dispreferred responses. In Discourse Markers: Descriptions and theory, A.-H. Jucker and Y. Ziv (eds), 277–300. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Redder, A. 1990. Grammatiktheorie und sprachliches Handeln: ’denn’ und ‘da’. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Redder, A. 2006. Konjunktor. To appear in Handbuch Wortarten, L. Hoffmann (ed.). Berlin: de Gruyter Rehbein, J. 1995a. Über zusammengesetzte Verweiswörter und ihre Rolle in argumentierender Rede. In Wege der Argumentationsforschung, H. Wohlrapp (ed.), 166–197. Stuttgart-BadCannstatt: Frommann-holzboog. Rehbein, J. 1995b. Grammatik kontrastiv – am Beispiel von Problemen mit der Stellung finiter Elemente. Jahrbuch Deutsch als Fremdsprache 21: 265–292.
Connectivity as an object of linguistics
Rehbein, J. 1999. Zum Modus von Äußerungen. In Grammatik und mentale Prozesse, A. Redder and J. Rehbein (eds), 91–139. Tübingen: Stauffenburg. Rehbein, J. 1999a. Konnektivität im Kontrast. Zu Struktur und Funktion türkischer Konverbien und deutscher Konjunktionen, mit Blick auf ihre Verwendung durch monolinguale und bilinguale Kinder. In Türkisch und Deutsch im Vergleich, L. Johanson and J. Rehbein (eds), 189–243. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Rehbein, J. 2002. Pragmatische Aspekte des Kontrastierens von Sprachen – Türkisch und Deutsch im Vergleich. Arbeiten zur Mehrsprachigkeit, Folge B (Nr. 40). In Eröffnungsreden und Tagungsbeiträge des VII. Türkischen Germanistikkongresses, S. Yıldız, N. Ülner, K. Halm Karadeniz u.a. (eds), 15–58. Ankara: Hacettepe University. Rehbein, J. and Kameyama, S. 2003. Pragmatik. In Sociolinguistics / Soziolinguistik. An international handbook of the science of language and society, (2nd ed.), U. Ammon, N. Dittmar, K. Mattheier and P. Trudgill (eds), 556–588. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Rehbein, J. and Karakoç, B. 2004. On contact-induced language change of Turkish aspects: Languaging in bilingual discourse. In Languaging and Language practices [Copenhagen Studies in Bilingualism 36], C. B. Dabelsteen and N. Jørgensen (eds), 129–155. Copenhagen: University of Copenhagen. Rizzi, L. 1997a. A parametric approach to comparative syntax: Properties of the pronominal system. In The New Comparative Syntax, L. Haegeman (ed.), 268–285. London: Longman. Rudolph, E. 1996. Contrast. Adversative and concessive relations and their expressions in English, German, Spanish, Portuguese on sentence and text level. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter Schiffrin, D. 1987. Discourse markers. Cambridge: CUP. Schourup, L. 1985. Common Discourse Particles in English Conversation: like, well, y’know. New York NY: Garland. Slobin D. I. 1988. The development of clause chaining in Turkish child language. In Studies on Turkish linguistics, S. Koç (ed.), 27–54. Ankara: Middle East Technical University (METU). Stolz, T. 2003. Not quite the right mixture: Chamorro and Malti as candidates for the status of mixed language. In The Mixed Language Debate. Theoretical and empirical advances, Y. Matras and P. Bakker (eds), 271–315. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 1996/1997. Universelle Hispanismen? Von Manila über Lima bis Mexiko und zurück. Muster bei der Entlehnung spanischer Funktionswörter in die indigenen Sprachen Amerikas und Austronesiens. Orbis XXXIX, 1996–1997, 1–77. Unger, C. 1996. The scope of discourse connectives. Implications for discourse organization. Journal of Linguistics 32(2): 403–438. van der Auwera, J. 1998. Adverbial Constructions in the Languages of Europe. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. van der Auwera, J. and Bultinck, B. 2001. On the lexical typology of modals, quantifiers, and connectives. In Perspectives on Semantics, Pragmatics, and Discourse, I. Kenesei, R. Harnish and J. Gervain (eds), 173–186. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. van der Wouden, T., Foolen, A. and van de Craen, P. (eds.). 2003. Particles. Belgian Journal of Linguistics 16. van Dijk, T. 1979. Pragmatic connectives. Journal of Pragmatics 3: 447–456. van Valin R. D. and R. J. LaPolla 1997 Syntax. Structure, meaning and function, Cambridge: CUP. Verhagen, A. 2001. Subordination and discourse segmentation revisited: Or, why matrix clauses may be more dependent than complements. In Text Representation: Linguistic and psy-
Jochen Rehbein, Christiane Hohenstein, Lukas Pietsch cholinguistic aspects, T. Sanders, J. Schilperood and W. Spooren (eds), 337–357. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Weydt, H. (ed.). 1979. Die Partikeln der deutschen Sprache. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Weydt, H. (ed.). 1983. Partikeln und Interaktion. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Weydt, H. 1987. Partikel-Bibliographie: Internationale Sprachenforschung zu Partikeln und Interjektionen. Frankfurt: PeterLang. White, P. 2003. Beyond modality and hedging: A dialogic view of the language of intersubjective stance. Text 23(2): 259–284. Yılmaz, E. 2004. A Pragmatic Analysis of Turkish Discourse Particles: yani, işte, and şey. PhD dissertation. Ankara: Graduate School of Social Sciences of Middle East Technical University.
section 1
Aspects of language change and language acquisition
Grammaticalization of converb constructions The case of Japanese -te conjunctive constructions Masayoshi Shibatani Rice University, Austin
This paper examines the patterns of grammaticalization of motion verbs (verbs of coming and going) in Japanese converb complex predicate constructions. The -te converb form is the most widely used connective device in Japanese, and the forms combining with motion verbs are among the most frequently used converb constructions in the language. Among the -te converb constructions involving motion verbs, those that appear to have grammaticalized are most numerous in the corpus data. Detailed examinations of the decategorialization pattern of the motion verbs involved indicate a clear cline of grammaticalization, which contradicts some earlier studies such as Teramura (1984) and Hasegawa (1996). The paper also addresses a number of important issues in grammaticalization studies and questions some of the current understandings of them, which include the following: (1) What drives grammaticalization – frequency of use and metaphor (Traugott and Heine 1991; Heine, Claudi, and Hünnemeyer 1991)? (2) What are the possible paths of grammaticalization in the development of temporal meanings from motion verbs (Bybee, Perkins and Pagliuca 1994)? (3) Are grammaticalization processes always gradual (Bybee, Pagliuca and Perkins 1991; Brinton and Traugott 2005)?
1. Introduction Japanese -te conjunctive constructions, illustrated in (1) below, share functional similarities with both converb constructions of the Altaic family (e.g., Turkic converb constructions) and verb serialization constructions widely observed across languages. Indeed, a legitimate typological question is whether there is any substantial difference between these two types of constructions.1 (1) a. Wareware-wa eki-kara densya-ni not-te Ochanomizu-made it-ta. we-TOP station-from train-on ride-CON Ochanomizu-up to go-PAST ‘We rode on a train and went to Ochanomizu.’
Masayoshi Shibatani
b. Midori-wa sanzi-sugi-ni kaet-te ki-ta. Midori-TOP three-past-LOC return-CON come-PAST ‘Midori returned (return come) at past three o’clock.’ (Haruki Murakami Norwegian Wood) A major reason for our using the label “converb construction” (as opposed to “serial verb construction”) for the Japanese construction involving -te – a conjunctive particle in the parts-of-speech classification of traditional Japanese grammar – is to highlight the presence of this particle, which marks the non-finiteness of the clause, thereby signaling the existence of a following finite verb or (truncated) clause. The presence of the marker with varying names such as conjunction, linker, converb ending, non-finite marker, etc. is relevant to the general discussion of the grammaticalization process of converb and serial verb constructions. In his discussion of the grammaticalization of motion and other types of verbs in Lhasa Tibetan, DeLancey (1991) recognizes a stage where the non-finite marker is lost and a contiguous verb sequence is created. This is an important step in the chain of reanalysis from clause chaining constructions to verb serialization and to auxiliarization of relevant types of verb. A similar verb contiguity requirement is stipulated by Foley and Olsen (1985:45–46) in their reanalysis of core layer junctures to nuclear layer junctures, whereby a verb sequence is created from VP-like conjunctions (see also Lord 1993, Hopper and Traugott 1993). This paper shows that, contrary to these assumptions, both complex predicates and their grammaticalization obtain across a conjunctive or non-finite marker (see Shibatani and Chung 2005). The grammaticalization of certain converb constructions is implied by the term hozyo-doosi ‘helping verbs’ in traditional Japanese grammar in reference to the finite verb involved in these constructions. That is, by calling the verbal form ki-ta ‘comePAST’ in (1b) above a helping verb as opposed to a (main) verb, traditional grammar recognizes some degree of decategorialization of this form in contradistinction to the full verb status accorded to it-ta ‘go-PAST’ in (1a), where no grammaticalization is involved. This paper is concerned with the grammaticalization of converb constructions involving specifically motion verbs of coming (kuru) and going (iku) as in (1) above. The rationale for this focus is manifold, but we first note the fact that converbs are among the most widely used clause linkage devices in Japanese (see Table 1 below). Secondly, according to Grein’s (1998:284) count, 136 out of 203 occurrences of converb forms in her data were instances of the -te form.
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
Table 1. Distribution of clause-linkage devices in Japanese (adapted from Grein 1998:286) Device
Number
Percentage
203 154
40.1% 30.4%
68 50 31 506
14.2% 9.6% 5.7% 100.0%
Converbs Functional nouns Adverbial subordinators Complementizers Coordinators TOTAL
Thirdly, it is also noteworthy that grammaticalized -te constructions most frequently occur in this construction type, as can be seen from the following table from Schmidt (2004), which describes the distribution of different functions in -te converb constructions. Table 2. ���������������� Function of the -te converb (based on Schmidt 2004) Function
Text A
Text B
Text C
Grammaticalized Narrative Subordinate Symmetric
181 102 27 0
54.4% 32.9% 8.7% 0.0%
335 100 34 0
71.4% 21.3% 7.3% 0.0%
80 31 15 0
65.1% 23.5% 11.4% 0.0%
TOTAL
309
100.0%
468
100.0%
132
100.0%
Finally, constructions involving verbs of coming and going are among the most frequently seen in the grammaticalized usage of the -te converb form (see Table 3). The goal of this paper is to explicate the nature and pattern of grammaticalization in converb constructions involving the two motion verbs of iku ‘go’ and kuru ‘come’. This, in turn, will help us better understand the process of “auxiliarization” implicit in the term hozyo doosi ‘helping verb’ in traditional Japanese grammatical terminology. Theoretical questions of wider relevance raised in this paper include the form-function correlation of connected events, instantaneous vs. gradual grammaticalization, contexts facilitating grammaticalization, and the paths of grammaticalization.
Masayoshi Shibatani
Table 3. Token frequency of grammaticalized converb constructions in three texts (according to Christopher Schmidt’s unpublished survey) V-te iru ‘exist’ V-te oru ‘exist’
301 1
(progressive/resultative) (progressive/resultative)
V-te iku ‘go’ V-te kuru ‘come’
48
(deictic)
47
(deictic)
V-te simau ‘finish’
27
(completive)
V-te kureru ‘be given’ V-te yaru ‘give’ V-te sasiageru ‘give’
23
(benefactive)
4 1
(benefactive) (benefactive)
V-te miru ‘look’ V-te goran ‘look’ V-te miseru ‘show’
18
‘try doing V’
V-te morau ‘receive’ V-te ii ‘good’
12
(self-benefactive)
12
‘may V’
V-te oku ‘put’
10
‘V in preparation of X’
V-te aru ‘exist’
9
(resultative)
A-te naranai I ‘won’t
5
‘cannot help but being A’
V-te hosii ‘want�’
1
(desiderative)
1 1
‘try doing V’ ‘show off V-ing’
Topics bearing on the central theme of this paper include the relationship between the grammaticalized constructions and clause chaining constructions of the following type: (2) Sorekara watasitati itumono-yooni syokudoo-de and then we as usual dinning room-in gohan-o tabe-te, ohuro hait-te, sorekara totteokino meal-ACC eat-CON bath enter-CON and then choicest zyootoono wain ake-te hutari-de non-de, superior wine open-CON two-by drink-CON watasi-ga gitaa hii-ta no. I-NOM guitar play-PAST FP ‘And then we ate our meal in the dining room, took a bath, and then opened the choicest super-quality wine (and we) two drank, (and) I played the guitar. ’ (Haruki Murakami Norwegian Wood)
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
Prevailing views (DeLancey 1991 and others) in the field hold that grammaticalized converb/serial verb constructions arise from clause-chaining constructions via reanalysis. While it is necessary for us to contrast grammaticalized constructions with clausal conjunctions throughout this paper, we will not directly address this important question here and refer the readers to Shibatani and Chung (2005), which casts doubt on the reanalysis hypothesis.
2. Grammaticalized converb constructions as complex predicates Before discussing the grammaticalization patterns of converb constructions, it is necessary to point out that there are two kinds of possible verb sequence which are rendered similarly in orthographic or transliterated form. (3) a. Taroo-wa ringo-o tabe-te it-ta. Taroo-TOP apple-ACC eat-CON go-PAST ‘Taro ate an apple (and went away).’ b. Taroo-wa gakkoo-e ringo-o tabe-te, it-ta. Taroo-TOP school-to apple-ACC eat-CON go-PAST ‘Taro, having eaten an apple, went to school.’ c. [ Taroo-wa [ ringo-o tabe-te] gakoo-e it-ta] Taroo-TOP apple-ACC eat-CON school-to go-PAST ‘Taro, having eaten an apple, went to school.’ While (3a) and (3b) have the same verbal series of tabe-te it-ta ‘eat-CON go-PAST’, only the former instantiates a grammaticalized construction whose formal property is in constituting a single complex predicate. (3b) is a paraphrase of (3c), obtainable by moving the goal nominal gakoo-e ‘to school’ to position immediately before the subordinate clause. Indeed, the verb sequences in (3a) and (3b) differ both phonologically and grammatically. In the former, the sequence manifests the pitch pattern of a single word, whereas in the latter the two verbs retain their own pitch patterns: (4) a. b.
tabe-te it-ta ‘ate (and went away)’ LHHHH tabe- te it-ta ‘ate and went’ H L L LH
The Tokyo dialect is typical of many Japanese dialects in allowing a phonological word to have at most one stretch of high-pitched morae; accordingly, once a pitch fall occurs within a word, it can never rise in the subsequent morae of the same word. In (4b) for (3b) we see two high-pitched morae divided by a stretch of low-pitched morae indicating two (phonological) words. In (4a) for (3a), on the other hand, there is only one
Masayoshi Shibatani
stretch of high-pitched morae indicating that the verb sequence here forms a single phonological word. There is further indication that the verb sequence in (3a) forms a single predicate, while the similar sequence in (3b) and (3c) does not. Indirect evidence for this comes from the fact that (3a) is a single clause expression, while (3b) and (3c) involve a biclausal structure. The negative polarity item sika ‘only, save’ requires the presence of the negative morpheme –nai ‘not’ in its own clause at some stage of derivation.2 (5) a. *Taroo-wa [ Hanako-sika kit-a] =koto-o sir-ana-katta. Taro-TOP [ Hanako-only come-PAST] -COMP-ACC know-NEG-PAST ‘Taro didn’t know that only Hanako came.’ b. Taroo-wa [ Hanako-sika ko-na-katta] =koto-o sit-ta. Taro-TOP [ Hanako-only come-NEG-PAST] -COMP-ACC know-PAST ‘Taro found out that only Hanako came/(lit.) Taro knew that everyone save Hanako didn’t come.’ c. Taroo-sika [ Hanako-ga kita] =koto-o sir-ana-katta. Taro-only [ Hanako-NOM come-PAST] -COMP-ACC know-NEG-PAST ‘Only Taro knew that Hanako came/ (lit.) Everyone save Taro didn’t know that Hanako came.’ Now (6a) based on (3a) below is perfectly fine, indicating that sika and the negative ana occur in a single clause. But (6b) and (6c) – based on (3b) and (3c), respectively – are ungrammatical, indicating that sika and the negative morpheme occur in two separate clauses. (6) a. Taroo-wa ringo-sika tabe-te ik-ana-katta. Taro-TOP apple-only eat-CON go-NEG-PAST ‘Taro ate only an apple (and went away)/(lit.) Taro didn’t eat-go anything but an apple.’ b. *Taroo-wa gakkoo-e ringo-sika tabe-te ik-ana-katta. Taro-TOP school-to apple-only eat-CON go-NEG-PAST ‘Taro ate only an apple and didn’t go to school.’ c. *Taroo-wa ringo-sika tabe-te gakkoo-e ik-ana-katta. Taro-TOP apple-only eat-CON school-to go-NEG-PAST ‘Taro ate only an apple and didn’t go to school.’ What is particularly interesting about grammaticalized constructions in Japanese is that while they are words in both phonological and syntactic senses, they do not form morphological words. That is, they do not show the property of lexical integrity characteristic of morphological words. For example, (complex) morphological words involving suffixation and compounding do not permit insertion of a particle or word even at the morphological boundaries, but the converbs under consideration do, as shown below:
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
(7) a. tabe-rare-ru eat-PASS-PRES ‘to be eaten’
a’. *tabe-wa-rare-ru eat-TOP-PASS-PRES
b. tabe-aruk-u b’. *tabe-wa-aruk-u eat-walk-PRES eat-TOP-walk-PRES ‘walk around eating here and there’ c. tabe-te ik-u c’. tabe-te-wa ik-u (keredo) eat-CON go-PRES eat-CON-TOP go-PRES (although) ‘eat (and go away)’ ‘(although) (I) eat (and go away)’ (7a’) and (7b’) are impossible forms, whereas (7c’) is a perfectly formed expression with the topic marker wa inserted between the two verbal forms. Similarly, while morphological words do not permit modification of their parts, converbs permit such modification. For example, the compound form in (8a) below does not allow its second member to undergo the honorification process, although the honorification of the whole word is possible, as in (8a”). In contrast, an honorified finite verb within a converb construction is perfectly well-formed, as in (8b’). Notice furthermore that an entire converb construction cannot be honorified as a whole – see (8b”). (8) a. moti-age-ru a’. *moti-o-age-ni nar-u hold-raise-PRES ‘hold up (something)’
a”. o-moti-age-ni nar-u
b. mot-te ik-u hold-CON go-PRES ‘take (away)’
b”. *o-mot-te iki-ni nar-u
b’. mot-te o-iki-ni nar-u
The morphological modification patterns of the above type provide crucial tests for the degree of grammaticalization of the relevant converb constructions below. Grammaticalized converb constructions are thus interesting linguistic objects; they are words under both phonological and syntactic criteria, but not under morphological criteria.
3. The syntax of grammaticalized converb constructions 3.1
Teramura (1984) and Hasegawa (1996)
Teramura (1984) represents an early effort toward the understanding of the grammatical properties of grammaticalized converb constructions. First, with regard to the question of combinatorial possibilities of iku ‘go’ and kuru ‘come’ with various converbs, he presents the following table, intended to show the combinations of the two motion verbs with different kinds of verb as converbs:
Masayoshi Shibatani
Table 4. Combinatorial possibilities of grammaticalized converb constructions according to Teramura (1984:163)
-te kuru ‘come’ -te iku ‘go’
umareru ‘to be born’
sinu ‘die’
mieru/kikoeru ‘visible/audible’
toozakaru ‘go away’
〇
×
〇
×
×
〇
×
〇
While the restrictions noted by Teramura appear to be correct, a quick Google search reveals that in fact all combinations noted in the table are possible. Teramura’s intuitions on the combinatorial possibilities appear to reflect the typicality of perspective chosen by native speakers rather than grammatical restrictions. For example, in the combinations of umareru ‘to be born’ and the two motion verbs, we are likely to view the birth of an entity from the perspective at which an entity emerges; hence the choice of kuru ‘come’ indicates that a movement toward the speaker is preferred. For verbs of disappearance such as sinu ‘die’, the entity disappearing is viewed from the perspective of existence; hence iku ‘go’ is preferred with such expressions. The following examples from Google indicate that speakers of Japanese can easily reverse these conventional perspectives, however, and allow various combinations that are identified as impossible by Teramura. (9) a. inoti-o sukuu-tabi kiboo-ga umare-te ik-u. life –ACC save-every.time hope-NOM be.born-CON go-PRES ‘Each time a life is saved, a hope is born.’ b.
gen-ga sin-de ku-ru =to rensyuusuru string-NOM die-CON come-PRES =when practice ki-ga use-te ku-ru... motivation-NOM lost-CON come-PRES ‘When strings [of a musical instrument] begin dying, motivation to practice becomes lost…’
c.
tamenteki, bunsekiteki-ni miru =koto-niyotte, zinkenkyooiku-no many.sided analytical-ADV look =COMP-by human.right.education-GEN genzyoo-to kadai-ga yori senmeini mie-te ik-u current.state-COM issues-NOM more clearly visible-CON go-PRES ‘By looking (at the problems) from a many sided and analytical angle, the current state and the issues of human rights education become visible even more clearly.’
d.
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
kyuukyuusya-ga hanare-te ik-u =to sono sairen-no oto-wa ambulance-NOM go.away-CON go-PRES =when its siren-GEN sound-TOP tiisaku kikoe-te ik-u faintly audible-CON go-PRES ‘When the ambulance goes far way, the sound of its siren goes on being audible ever more faintly.’
e. haru-ga tikazui-te samusa-ga toozakat-te ku-ru=to… spring-NOM come.near-CON coldness-NOM go.far-CON come-PRES=when ‘When spring comes near and the coldness goes far away…’ These examples indicate one functional domain in which converb constructions have grammaticalized with a functional shift from a physical spatial domain to an abstract aspectual domain. Our initial focus in this paper, however, is on the degrees of grammaticalization seen in the spatial domain, where their patterns are harder to discern, due to the fact that the relevant motion verbs retain to a greater or lesser extent the original meaning of physical motion. In particular, we are concerned with the following types of expression, for which Teramura (1984) offers an analysis (indicated in the parentheses): (10) a. Taroo-wa koohii-o non-de ki-ta. (V-V) Taro-TOP coffee-ACC drink-CON come-PAST ‘Taro drank coffee (and came).’ b. Taroo-wa gakkoo-e arui-te it-ta. (v-V) Taro-TOP school-to walk-CON go-PAST ‘Taro walked (walk went) to school.’ c. Taroo-ga heya-ni hait-te ki-ta. (V-v) Taro-NOM room-to enter-CON come-PAST ‘Taro came (enter came) into the room.’ According to Teramura (1984: 157ff), expressions like (10a) depict two sequentially ordered actions; accordingly, both the converb and the finite motion verb function like main verbs (indicated by the capital V) connected by -te. In (10b), on the other hand, the converb modifies the motion verb, specifying in this example the manner of the going motion; accordingly, the relevant verbs are connected in a subordinate-main relationship, where the converb is subordinated (as indicated by the small v) to the main motion verb (indicated by V). In the case of (10c), the subordinatemain relationship is reversed, such that the converb (V) expresses the main action whose deictic orientation is indicated by the motion verb (v). According to Teramura’s analysis, the finite motion verbs in the expression type (10c) are most advanced in grammaticalization, turning themselves into something like deictic markers, whereas those in the expression types (10a) and (10b) retain the original verb status.
Masayoshi Shibatani
More recent work of Hasegawa (1996) is couched in the framework of Role and Reference Grammar, which pays special attention to issues of clause-linkage type. Hasegawa’s classification differs somewhat from Teramura’s reviewed above. The main syntactic division she draws is between nuclear coordination and nuclear subordination types. In the former, the converb and the finite motion verb are in a coordinate relation, together forming a complex nuclear (predicate). This analysis resembles Teramura’s V-V analysis in that the full verbal status of both the converb and the finite motion verb is recognized. The nuclear subordination type is similar to Teramura’s V-v analysis; hence the converb alone functions as a nuclear (predicate), with the finite verb functioning as a deictic operator. Hasegawa would classify the three types of expression in the following manner: (11) a. non-de kur-u (Nuclear coordination; Teramura’s V-V) drink-CON come-PRES ‘drink (and come)’ b. arui-te ik-u walk-CON go-PRES ‘go (by) walking’
(Nuclear coordination; Teramura’s v-V)
c. hait-te ku-ru enter-CON come-PRES ‘enter (come in)’
(Nuclear subordination; Teramura’s V-v)
There are both similarities and differences between the two analyses. Both Teramura and Hassegawa recognize a full verbal status for motion verbs in (11a) and (11b). While Teramura recognizes a diminished autonomy of the converb in (11b), Hasegawa considers the converb and the finite verb to be of equal status. As for (11c), Teramura recognizes some degree of verbiness in the finite motion verb, but Hasegawa considers it to have lost the predicate function completely, perhaps along with concomitant decategorialization from verb to deictic operator.3 Whether or not a degree of verbiness is intended in the representations of “v” and “V” by Teramura, or complete decategorialization is recognized for certain motion verbs in the relevant converb constructions by Hasegawa, the following discussion shows that their analyses do not accord well with the facts. In particular, it will be shown below that the iku/kuru ‘go/ come’ verbs in the non-de iku/kuru ‘drink-CON go/come’ type (10a, 11a) are least verb-like (contrary to Teramura and Hasegawa’s analyses), that motion verbs in the arui-te iku/kuru ‘walk-CON go/come’ type (10b, 11b) are most verb-like (agreeing with Teramura and Hasegawa’s analyses), and that those in the hait-te iku/kuru ‘enterCON go/come’ type (10c, 11c) are verb-like to a considerable extent, contra Teramura’s and Hasegawa’s analyses.
3.2
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
Cline of grammaticalization
While there appear to be both instantaneous and gradual aspects to the grammaticalization process (see Section 4 below), the framework of grammaticalization is especially attuned to the task of capturing gradual patterns of change in the status of lexical items. In particular, the changes to the motion verbs of coming and going in converb constructions within the grammaticalization framework reveal that these verbs do not change their category membership instantaneously, and that a synchronic description of them must recognize a cline of categoriality along a path of change from verb to auxiliary. The remainder of this section is devoted to a demonstration that the three relevant construction types are distributed along the following cline of grammaticalization: (12)
Less grammaticalized (More V-like) arui-te iku/kuru
(Teramura’s v-V; Hasegawa’s
walk-CON go/come
Nuclear coordination)
hait-te iku/kuru
(Teramura’s V-v; Hasegawa’s Nuclear subordination)
enter-CON go/come
non-de iku/kuru drink-CON go/come
(Teramura’s V-V; Hasegawa’s Nuclear coordination)
More grammaticalized (Less V-like)
Of the various possible combinations of converbs and motion verbs, we single out the above three patterns, since they exhaust Teramura’s representations of types in terms of the combination of V and v symbols – V-V, v-V, and V-v. In reality, the possibility exists that there are numerous intermediate types of combination interspersed among the three representative ones dealt with here. Of the three combination types, the arui-te kuru/iku ‘walk-CON come/go’ type represents combinations involving a motion verb and a manner of motion verb ( aruku ‘walk’, hasiru ‘run’, hau ‘crawl’, oyogu ‘swim’, tobu ‘fly’, etc.). In the following discussion, this type will be exemplified by expressions and glosses such as arui-te iku ‘walk come’ and hasit-te kuru ‘run come’. The hait-te iku/kuru ‘enter-CON go/come’ type represents combinations of a motion verb and a verb of change-of-location (deru ‘exit’, agaru ‘ascend’, oriru ‘descend’, otiru ‘fall’, etc.), and examples such as hait-te kuru ‘enter come’ and de-te iku ‘exit go’ illustrate this type of construction. Finally, the non-de iku/kuru ‘drink-CON go/come’ type represents combinations of a motion verb and a non-translational action (taberu ‘eat’, asobu ‘play’, sake-o nomu ‘drink sake’, eiga-o miru ‘see a movie’ etc.). In the following discussion, examples such as non-de kuru ‘drink come’ and tabe-te iku ‘eat go’ illustrate this type of construction. Thus even if the examples in the following discussion have the
Masayoshi Shibatani
form of arui-te iku ‘walk go’, non-de kuru ‘drink come’, it should be understood that the relevant points of discussion apply equally to other instances of the same type such as hasit-te kuru ‘run come’ and tabe-te iku ‘eat go’. The methods used in arriving at the pattern of distribution of different construction types seen in (12) typically involve comparison of the grammatical properties of iku/kuru ‘go/come’ in their full-fledged main verb function vs. those in converb complex predicate constructions. The greater the similarity is between them, the less grammaticalized the finite motion verbs in converb constructions are. 3.2.1 Mieru suppletion As mentioned in section 2, grammaticalized converb complex predicates do not show the morphological property of lexical integrity, such that finite motion verbs may undergo morphological processes on their own right. The first of such processes examined here is the suppletion of kuru ‘come’ by the honorific expression mieru ‘(lit.) visible’ shown below, where lexical kuru is suppleted by mieru: (13) Yoru-ni naru-to,
takusan-no kyaku-ga
night-to become-when many-GEN
ku-ru/mie-ru
customer-NOM come-PRES/come.HON-PRES
rasii. EVI ‘I hear that many customers come when night falls (speaking of a restaurant).’ Kuru ‘come’ of the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ and hait-te kuru ‘enter come’ type easily supplete with mieru, but that of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type does not. This indicates that while kuru in the former two types is similar to the main verb kuru, the one in the latter type is not. (14) a. Yamada-sensei-wa gakkoo-ni arui-te ki-ta/mie-ta. Yamada-Prof.-TOP school-to walk-CON come-PAST/come.HON-PAST ‘Professor Yamada walked (walk come) to school.’ b.
Yamada-sensei-ga kyoositu-ni hait-te kit-ta/mie-ta Yamada-Prof.-NOM classroom-to enter-CON come-PAST/come.HON.-PAST toki... when ‘When Professor Yamada came into (enter come) the classroom…’
c. Yamada-sensei-wa ippai non-de ki-ta/*mie-ta.4 Yamada-Prof.-TOP a.drink drink-CON come-PAST/come.HON-PAST ‘Professor Yamada had a drink (and came).’
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
3.2.3 Rassyaru truncation That there is no pragmatic conflict in the honorific expression of non-de kuru ‘drink come’ is shown by the fact that irassyaru, another honorific suppletive form of iku/ kuru ‘go/come’, is perfectly acceptable in this type of converb construction. Indeed, the three types of converb construction under study are all compatible with this honorific form. What is particularly interesting about the irassyaru form is that it truncates to rassyaru by deleting the initial vowel. (15) a. Yamada-sensei-wa gakkoo-ni arui-te ki-ta/irassyat-ta/rassyat-ta. Yamada-Prof.-TOP school-to walk-CON come-PAST/come.HON-PAST ‘Professor Yamada walked (walk come) to school.’ b.
Yamada-sensei-ga kyoositu-ni hait-te kit-ta/irassyat-ta/rassyat-ta Yamada-Prof.-NOM classroom-to enter-CON come-PAST/come.HON.-PAST toki... when ‘When Professor Yamada came into (enter come) the classroom…’
c. Yamada-sensei-wa ippai non-de ki-ta/irassyat-ta/rassyat-ta. Yamada-Prof.-TOP a.drink drink-CON come-PAST/come.HON-PAST ‘Professor Yamada had a drink (and came).’ While the truncated rassyaru versions in (14) are all acceptable, there is a difference in the degree of felicity in these expressions. Rassyaru truncation is least favored with aruite-kuru ‘walk come’ in (14a), though it is not impossible.5 On the other hand, nonde kuru ‘drink come’ is the favored type for a contracted rassyaru expression. The haitte kuru ‘come enter’ type falls in the middle of these two polar types. These impressionistic evaluations of the three rassyaru forms are corroborated by the ratio of contracted rassyaru forms against their non-contracted irassyaru counterparts. The following table is based on a Google search which excluded irrelevant rassyaru/ irassyaru forms such as honorific versions of iru ‘be’.6 Table 5 contains polite imperative expressions (e.g. Go wash your face). While the truncated forms appear regularly with the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type, the ratio of truncated expressions is not as high as with the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type, for which the favored versions are clearly truncated rassyaru forms. The significance of the truncation phenomenon is that the lexical verbs kuru/iku ‘come/go’, which easily supplete for irassyaru, resist truncation: (16) a. Yamada-sensei-ga kyoositu-ni ki-ta/irassyat-ta/*rassyat-ta. Yamada-Prof.-NOM classroom-to come-PAST/come.HON-PAST ‘Professor Yamada came to the classroom.’ b. Yamada-sensei-ga Amerika-ni it-ta/irassyat-ta/*rassyat-ta. Yamada-Prof.-NOM America-to go-PAST/go.HON-PAST ‘Professor Yamada went to America.’
Masayoshi Shibatani
The fact above that the honorific irassyaru of the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type least favors the truncation indicates that the verb kuru here is most similar to lexical kuru, whose honorific irassyaru version never contracts to rassyaru. On the other hand, kuru of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type is least verb-like in that it favors the rassyaru truncation. That kuru of the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type permits the rassyaru truncation, though less frequently, is significant in that this verb has a function different from the main verb kuru. This may mean that the motion verb has been grammaticalized to some extent even in arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type constructions, as the reduction in form permitted in them is certainly an indication of grammaticalization. At any rate, it is clear from the pattern of the truncation of irassyaru that kuru of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type is least verb-like in favoring the truncation, contrary to Teramura’s and Hasegawa’s analyses that this form is similar to lexical kuru. Table 5. Truncation ratio of rassyaru vs. irassyaru (kotti-ni) aruit-te irassyai (kotti-ni) arui-te rassyai ‘ (here-to) walk-CON come.HON’ (kotti-ni) hasit-te irassyai (kotti-ni) hasit-te rassyai ‘(here-to) run-CON come.HON’ de-te irassyai de-te rassyai ‘exit-CON come.HON’ non-de irassyai non-de rassyai ‘drink-CON come.HON’
27 23 5 5 494 1,060 34 84
tabe-te irassyai tabe-te rassyai ‘eat-CON come.HON’
57 155
kao-o arat-te irassyai kao-o arat-te rassyai ‘face-ACC wash-CON come’
23 115
3.2.3 Valency property The lexical motion verbs iku ‘go’ and kuru ‘come’ sanction both goal and source arguments, though the goal argument is rarely seen with the verb of coming due to the lexical specification of the deictic information in it – that the motion is directed toward a deictic center, typically the place of speech. This valency property of these motion verbs
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
plays an important role in Japanese converb constructions. Unlike their English counterparts, manner-of-motion verbs in Japanese such as aruku ‘walk’, oyogu ‘swim’, and hau ‘crawl’ do not allow the specification of a goal argument. In order to express a goal with these verbs, they must be combined with iku ‘go’ or kuru ‘come’, as shown below: (17) a. *Taroo-wa gakkoo-e arui-ta. Taro-TOP school-to walk-PAST ‘Taro walked to school.’ b. Taroo-wa gakkoo-e arui-te it-ta/ki-ta. Taro-TOP school-to walk-CON go-PAST/come-PAST ‘Taro walked (walk went/came) to school.’ The fact that iku of the arui-te iku ‘walk go’ construction licenses a goal argument means that it retains the valency property of lexical iku. Compare this with iku in the other types of converb construction. (18) a. Taroo-wa zibun-no heya-o de-te, Hanako-no heya-ni it-ta. Taro-TOP self-GEN room-ACC exit-CON Hanako-GEN room-to go-PAST ‘Taro exited his room and went to Hanako’s room.’ a’. *Taroo-wa Hanako-no heya-ni zibun-no heya-o de-te it-ta. Taro-TOP Hanako-GEN room-to self-GEN room-ACC exit-CON go-PAST ‘(lit.) Taro went out (exit went) of his room to Hanako’s room.’ b. Taroo-wa ringo-o tabe-te, gakkoo-e it-ta. Taro-TOP apple-ACC eat-CON school-to go-PAST ‘Taro ate and apple and went to school.’ b’. *Taroo-wa gakkoo-e ringo-o tabe-te it-ta.7 Taro-TOP school-to apple-ACC eat-CON go-PAST ‘(lit.)Taro eat-went an apple to school.’ While clausal (or VP) conjunction converb constructions in the (a) and (b) forms are perfectly grammatical, the parallel complex predicate forms (a’) and (b’) do not permit a goal expression, indicating that the motion verbs in the latter have lost the verbal property of licensing a goal argument. These should also be compared with the forms in (17b), which show that motion verbs in it retain this argument licensing property, and thus behave more like lexical iku/kuru. In order to better appreciate the property of valency loss seen in (18), compare them to the following pattern seen in English, where the verb go in combination with eat in (19b) has lost the argument licensing property associated with its lexical counterpart in (19a). (19) a. Let’s go to McDonald’s to eat. b. *Let’s go eat to McDonald’s. c. Let’s go eat at McDonald’s.
Masayoshi Shibatani
3.2.4 Fragments A converb in an ungrammaticalized construction can form a sentence fragment in response to a yes-no question. Compare the following examples: (20) a. Zitensya-ni not-te gakkoo-e kita=no? bicycle-to ride-CON school-to come-PAST=Q ‘(You’ve) come to school riding a bicycle?’ b. Un, zitensya-ni not-te. yeah bicycle-to ride-CON ‘Yeah, riding a bicycle.’ Again, grammaticalized converb constructions do not behave uniformly. The arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type barely allows a fragment expression, while the other two types resist it altogether. (21) a. Arui-te ki-ta=no? walk-CON come-past=Q ‘(You) came walking?” b. *?Un, arui-te. yeah walk-CON ‘Yeah, by walking.’ (22) a. b.
De-te ki-ta=no? exit-CON come-PAST=Q ‘(You) came out?’ *Un, de-te. yeah exit-CON ‘Yeah, (having) exited.’
(23) a. b.
Ippai non-de ki-ta=no? a.drink drink-CON come-PAST=Q ‘(You) had a drink (and came)?’ *Un, non-de. yeah drink-CON ‘Yeah, (having) drunk.’
There may be a number of ways of interpreting this phenomenon, but it can be understood as showing that the converb complex arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ is structurally ‘less tight’, hence the converb and the finite verb are morphologically more autonomous than those involved in the other two construction types. This interpretation is corroborated by a pattern of contracting of iku ‘go’ to -ku. According to the Googlebased survey summarized in Table 6 below, iku of the arui-te iku ‘walk go’ type contracts least while that of the non-de iku ‘drink come’ type contracts most frequently. 8
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
Table 6. Contraction of iku to -ku arui-te iku=to arui-te-ku=to walk-go=when
328,000 956 0.003 %
de-te iku=to de-te-ku=to exit-go=when
58,200 637 0.01 %
tabe-te iku=to tabe-te-ku=to eat-go����� =���� when
17,400 751 0.04 %
Notice that lexical iku never contracts to ku. The fact that iku of arui-te iku ‘walk go’ contracts less frequently compared to that of tabe-te iku ‘eat go’ indicates that the former is structurally more autonomous than the latter. This contraction fact also shows that the tabe-te iku ‘eat go’ type is at a more advanced stage of grammaticalization than the other two types. 3.2.5 Scope of negation The status of the motion verbs in the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type noted above is consonant with the fact that these verbs cannot support negative scope, indicating that they are turning into a suffix status. Observe: (24) a.
Daremo basu-ni not-te ko-na-katta. no one bus-to ride-CON come-NEG-PAST ‘No one came riding a bus.’ (No one came on the bus = wide scope reading) (They came but no one came by bus = narrow scope reading)
b.
Daremo heya-kara de-te ko-na-katta. no one room-from exit-CON come-NEG-PAST ‘No one came out of the room.’ (No one came out = wide scope reading) (No narrow scope reading possible; They came but not exiting a room)
c.
Daremo gohan-o tabe-te ko-na-katta. no one meal-ACC eat-CON come-NEG-PAST ‘No one had a meal (and came).’ No wide scope reading is possible; No one came after having eaten a meal) (They came but no one had a meal = narrow scope reading)
It is clearly seen that while the finite motion verb of the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ can support negative scope also giving rise to a wide scope reading for an expression like (24a), those of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type cannot – (24c) above can never
Masayoshi Shibatani
mean that no one came. The motion verb here is thus behaving more like an affix, which cannot support negative scope independently of the root to which it is attached. The reason that the de-te kuru ‘exit come’ does not allow a narrow scope reading is unclear, but it may have to do with the a higher degree of lexicalization of this form.
3.3
Summary of the syntactic properties of the three types of converb construction
The following table summarizes the findings discussed in this section. Table 7. Summary of syntactic patterns
Lexical kuru ‘come’ arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ de-te kuru ‘exit come’ non-de kuru ‘drink come’
mieru
rassyaru
-ku
Valency
Fragment
〇
✕
✕
〇
〇
N/A
〇
△
△
〇
△
wide/narrow
〇
〇
〇
✕
✕
wide
✕
◎
◎
✕
✕
narrow
Neg. scope
(◎ = super, 〇= O.K., △=grudgingly, ✕ = no)
Table 7 clearly substantiates our earlier claim that converb construction types are distributed along a cline of grammaticalization as depicted in (12) above. In particular, it shows that motion verbs of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type are most advanced in grammaticalization, and are least verb-like – contrary to the analyses of Teramura (1984) and Hasegawa (1996). Moreover, those of the de-te kuru ‘exit come’ type still retain some verbal properties, indicating that they have not decategorialized completely as implied in Hasegawa’s work. Finally even motion verbs of the arui-te kuru type, being susceptible to phonological reduction, behave differently from their lexical counterparts, indicating that they are on the way to being (further) grammaticalized.
4. Methodological and theoretical implications On the methodological front, the discussion above shows the importance of syntactic analysis in grammaticalization studies. On the one hand, intuitive semantic analyses seldom carry over to proper syntactic analyses. For non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type expressions, Teramura (1984: 157) – while recognizing a subtle difference between the relevant converb constructions and their paraphrases – suggests that they can be understood as expressing sequential events, e.g. an action of drinking followed by a mo-
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
tion of coming. In grammaticalized form, however, these expressions do not express sequentially connected events. Specifically, finite motion verbs no longer express the whole meaning of a motion event. The meaning of motion verbs of going and coming comes in two dimensions, one expressing movement of an entity along a spatial path, and the other a deictic orientation of the movement. In the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ construction type, the dimension of physical movement has been completely lost, as reflected in the loss of a goal-sanctioning valency property. The motion verbs in these constructions now have the sole function of indicating deictic information, i.e. indicating where the actor ends up after the execution of the action expressed by the converb. Thus, sake-o non-de ki-ta (sake-ACC drink-CON come-PAST) does not assert that someone performed an act of translational motion toward the deictic center after having drunk sake. Rather, it means that someone ended up in the speaker’s sphere after having drunk sake somewhere away from it. It is for this reason that the translations of relevant examples in this paper parenthesize the motion component as ‘drank sake (and came)’. Syntactic analysis, furthermore, is crucial in showing that the phenomena under consideration fall in the category of grammatical change known as grammaticalization. Meaning shifts and extensions by themselves do not constitute grammaticalization phenomena per se. In order for a semantic change to qualify as a case of grammaticalization, the form in question must be grammaticalized, i.e., change its status from lexical to grammatical. In other words, decategorialization is an important component of the grammaticalization process. Thus, when verbs are involved as they are here, it is important to show that they lose certain verbal properties. There are many theoretical implications of the present study, but here we restrict them to those that appear to be intimately connected. The first concerns the question of the gradualness of grammaticalization.
4.1
Gradual vs. instantaneous grammaticalization
From the time of the Neogrammarians, the question of gradualness of historical change (phonetic or otherwise) has been controversial, the issue itself having multiple facets ranging from the actualization of change to its spread. The same issue arises with changes characterizable as grammaticalization. The pattern in Table 7 indicates that gradual loss of verbal characteristics in finite motion verbs affects different types of converb constructions. However, the question remains as to whether those at an advanced stage in grammaticalization realize each step of the grammaticalization paths. That is, did iku ‘go’ and kuru ‘come’ in the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ construction type once had a stage where they behaved like those in the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type? Was there a stage where kuru in the former type could be suppleted with mieru or where iku sanctioned a goal argument as those in the latter type now do? Alternatively could the change be instantaneous such that as soon as a construction of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ is formed, the finite motion verbs contained therein are used as
Masayoshi Shibatani
deictic markers losing their verbal properties instantaneously?9 Both positions have been maintained in the field. Brinton and Traugott (2005) and others (e.g., Bybee, Pagliuca and Perkins 1991) generally believe that grammaticalization is gradual, while the possibility of instantaneous grammaticalization is entertained by Givón, as shown by the following quotations: Grammaticalization is gradual in the sense that it is non- instantaneous and pro-
ceeds by very small and typically overlapping, intermediate, and sometimes indeterminate, steps. (Brinton and Traugott 2005:100)
[Instantaneous grammaticalization] involves the mental act of the mind recognizing a similarity relation and thereby exploiting it, putting an erstwhile lexical item into grammatical use in a novel context. The minute a lexical item is used in a frame that intends it as grammatical marker, it is thereby grammaticalized. (Givón 1991:122) While changes in the formal properties of a grammaticalized item may be gradual, as shown above in the contraction phenomena of motion verbs (see Tables 5 and 6), there seems to be at least clear cases where instantaneous grammaticalization occurs accompanying the functional shift from the spatial to the temporal domain. As alluded to earlier, Japanese converb constructions of coming and going have also developed a function of aspectual marking. Examples include the following: (25) a.
soredake syabet-te simau-to hidoku hara-ga het-te that.much talk-CON finish-when very stomach-NOM decrease-CON ki-ta. come-PAST ‘(lit.) When I finished talking all that much, my stomach began to decrease/I began to become hungry.’
b.
sikamo sono aida kekkoo ta-no onna-to ne-te moreover that interval well.enough other-of woman-with sleep-CON ki-ta. come-PAST ‘Moreover during that period (I) have been sleeping well enough with other women.’ c. sooyatte iki-te ik-u. that.way live-CON go-PRES ‘(I) will go on living that way.’ d. Atama-ga dandan okasiku nat-te it-te… brain-NOM gradually funny become-CON go-CON ‘My brains gradually keep on turning funny…’ (Haruki Murakami Norwegian Wood)
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
These forms can be considered to have an aspectual function in that iku/kuru ‘go/ come’ add a span to the event expressed by the converbs. The finite expression hara-ga hetta ‘(lit.) the stomach decreased/got hungry’, for example, locates change of state at one point in time. When it combines with kuru ‘come’ as in (25a) hara-ga het-te ki-ta, the whole expression entails change of state over a span of time. Moreover, this expansion of change over time span is conceived to be directed toward the speaker by virtue of the use of kuru ‘come’. When iku is used as in (24c,d), the expansion of the event is viewed to take place in a direction away from the speaker, giving a future-oriented interpretation if the finite form has a present tense ending as in (25c). The widely received scenario for the development of temporal meanings from motion verbs developed by Bybee, Perkins and Pagliuca (1994: 269) holds that meaning elements, e.g. inferences, giving rise to this development already exist in the lexical use of motion verbs. For example, “[w]hen one moves along a path toward a goal in space, one also moves in time.” What happens is the gradual loss of the spatial meaning with increased dominance of the temporal meaning. Under this scenario the only change necessary is the generalization to contexts in which the subject is not moving, as in (25) above, where an aspectual meaning uniquely obtains. This scenario of gradual grammaticalization, however, faces a serious challenge when confronted with a wide range of cases of the development of temporal meanings from motion and other types of verbs. Crucial cases in Japanese relate to examples such as the following, where no aspectual reading is possible: (26) Boku-wa kore-kara-mo eki-e arui-te ik-u. I-TOP this-from-also station-to walk-CON go-PRES ‘I will walk to the station from now on too.’ As detailed in the next section, it is precisely in those contexts where the meaning of spatial movement does not obtain that give rise to the aspectual meaning in question. That is there is no stage where the aspectual meaning has become dominant with concomitant bleaching of the spatial meaning that bridges the gap between literal spatial expressions and aspectual ones, which are purported to derive via generalization of the intermediate expressions. The shift in meaning here, instead, appears best considered as a case of instantaneous metaphorical transfer. That is, once an image schema of motion is metaphorically transferred from the spatial domain to the temporal one, then the grammaticalization takes place instantaneously, as in Givón’s characterization above. Whether a meaning shift such as this would count as a case of grammaticalization is debatable, but if the change were accompanied by a decategorialization process, it would be considered as a case of grammaticalization. Indeed, the Japanese aspectual iku ‘go’ and kuru ‘come’ do not behave like lexical iku/kuru. For example, aspectual kuru ‘come’ does not supplete for honorific mieru, unlike lexical kuru, and honorific irassyaru of aspectual iku contracts to rassyaru, unlike the irassyaru form suppleting lexical iku (see earlier discussions on these phenomena). Observe:
Masayoshi Shibatani
(27) a. Satoo-sensei-wa syoozikini iki-te ki-ta/*mie-ta. Satoo-Prof.-TOP honestly live-CON come-PAST ‘Prof. Sato has been living honestly.’ b. syoozikini iki-te ik-eba/irassyar-eba/rassyar-eba... honestly live-CON go-if/go.HON-if/go.HON-if ‘If (you) keep on living honestly…’
4.2
Contexts facilitating grammaticalization
Our study raises an important question that past studies do not concerning the context or environment which propels grammaticalization. The earlier discussion shows that grammaticalization of motion verbs does not take place uniformly. The verb iku ‘go’ in non-de iku ‘drink go’ constructions is far more advanced in grammaticalization than in the arui-te iku ‘walk go’ constructions. Generalizing the case to include instantaneous grammaticalization, the question can be formulated as: “Which contexts facilitate grammaticalization?” By “facilitate” we refer to two situations, one where a specific context propels grammaticalization at a faster rate than others, the other concerning the context in which instantaneous grammaticalization – including metaphorical extension – is easier to take place. Past grammaticalization studies have raised a similar question but at a very general level. For example, Heine, Claudi and Hünnemeyer (1991) show that metaphorical extension or transfer of an imagine schema from one (concrete) domain to another (abstract) is a major driving force for semantic change and grammaticalization. We have also recognized the effect of such a mechanism in the development of the aspectual use of iku/kuru ‘go/come’ in Japanese. But metaphorical extension does not explain the cline of grammaticalization exhibited by iku/kuru in the spatial domain, where metaphorical extension is not involved. A question also remains as to which contexts favor/disfavor metaphorical extension or instantaneous grammaticalization in the sense of Givón (1991). Another factor invoked in the discussion of both the actualization and spread of a grammaticalization process is textual frequency. Here is a relevant quote from Traugott and Heine (1991: 9): Given that a form A is a candidate for grammaticalization both because of its semantic context and its salience, a further condition has to apply for grammaticalization to take place: The form has to be used frequently. The more grammaticalized a form, the more frequent it is...The seeds of grammaticalization are therefore in a correlated set of phenomena: Semantic suitability, salience and frequency. Only the third actually leads to grammaticalization and hence to fixing, freezing, idiomatization, etc. (Emphasis added)
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
Does this apply to our case? Not really. First, situations concerning frequency are not as straightforward as Traugott and Heine (1991) put it. That is, determining the token frequency of constructions is not simple, since the frequency of use of a construction varies greatly depending on the specific lexical items involved. For example, in one recent Google count hat-te iku (crawl-CON go) occurred 963 times, whereas the same Manner of motion + Motion combination of arui-te iku (walk-CON go) yielded 623,000 instances. In ascertaining the token frequency, then, it is necessary to compare the frequency of different types of verb combination. The following table, from Shibatani and Chung (to appear), shows the token frequencies of the three combination types in a modern fiction in Japanese and Korean: Table 8. Token frequency of three combination types (Japanese; Ito Sei Hanran: Korean; Kim Joo Yong Kokicapinun kaltaylul kkekkci anhnunta)
Japanese V-te iku/kuru V-CON go/come Korean V-e/ko ota/kata V-CON come/go
Manner
Location change
Action
23
109
6
68
358
11
Our case may also be at variance with a generally observed correlation between frequency of use and the size of a grammatical item. For example, Bybee, Perkins and Pagliuca (1994: 20) draw the following conclusion: There is a link between frequency of use and phonetic bulk such that more frequently used material, whether grammatical or lexical, tends to be shorter (phonetically reduced) relative to less often used material.
Determining the frequency of use across construction types is rather difficult, as noted above, but if Tables 5 and 6 above suggest anything, it is that in those expressions that are more advanced in grammaticalization but still occur comparatively less frequently we observe higher rates of occurrence of phonologically reduced forms.10 Neither metaphorical extension nor frequency is thus able to account for the pattern of grammaticalization examined in this paper at both the functional and the formal level. In the balance of this paper, we will explore semantic factors differentiating the contexts that facilitate grammaticalization from those that hinder it. Verbs conjoined by the -te conjunctive in Japanese express different kinds of event combinations. Combinations of the motion verb iku ‘go’ or kuru ‘come’ and manner of motion verbs (aruku ‘walk’, hasiru ‘run’, oyogu ‘swim’, etc.) result in a semantically congruous whole in that there is complete spatio-temporal overlap, such that when one
Masayoshi Shibatani
walks, s/he necessarily moves (goes or comes), and when one goes or comes to some place, s/he does so in some manner (e.g., walk, run, swim). Indeed, English lexicalizes macro-events comprised of these sub-events in manner-of-motion verbs such as walk and swim, which – unlike their Japanese counterparts – sanction a goal argument (e.g. walk to the station, swim to the shore). Combinations of location change and motion are similarly congruous in that there is partial spatio-temporal overlap. But the overlap is not to the full extent as in the Manner + Motion combinations, since it obtains only at the point of threshold in the case of Location change + Motion combinations. Compared to these combinations, those of sequentially ordered events, such as drinking and going to some place or eating and coming back, i.e., those not tied by such unifying relations as cause, purpose, and result lack semantic congruity and do not usually form a macro-event that is lexicalized in a single verb. Indeed, they do not even enter into verb serialization in many languages.11 The three types of converb construction examined in this paper thus have the following patterns of event combination, which can be characterized in terms of degree of semantic congruity: More congruous Manner + Motion Location change + Motion Action + Motion Less congruous
Notice that in Japanese, the combination of action and motion represents a pre-grammaticalization stage. That is, current forms such as non-de kuru ‘drink come’ and tabete iku ‘eat go’ do not combine action and motion in the literal sense, since they have already undergone grammaticalization, as described above. Our characterization of the three types of event combination then allows us to draw the following hypothesis on the context that propels or facilitates grammaticalization: (28) Grammaticalization is facilitated in semantically less congruous environments This hypothesis makes sense for the process of semantic bleaching, whereby a meaning component is more easily lost when there is no semantic support or reinforcement from the surrounding environment. Interestingly it is precisely this kind of semantically incongruous environment where metaphorical extension is also facilitated. As mentioned above, Japanese converb constructions involving verbs of going and com-
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
ing have also developed aspectual meanings (see examples in (25)). In combination with a converb, however, the aspectual meaning of iku/kuru ‘go/come’ obtains most readily in semantically incongruous combinations of events. Indeed, a large majority of the tabe-te iku ‘eat go’ and non-de iku ‘drink go’ forms found in Google are of the aspectual type illustrated in the following examples: (29) a. eigo-de gohan-o tabe-te ik-u English-with meal-ACC eat-CON go-PRES ‘(lit.) to go on eating meals with English/to go on living on the job using English’ b. dondon karee-o tabe-te ik-u steadily curry-ACC eat-CON go-PRES ‘to keep on eating curry steadily’ (30) a non-de ik-u utini azi-ni-mo nare…. drink-CON go-PRES while taste-to-also get.used.to ‘(you) also get used to the taste while (you) keep on drinking’ b. kare-mo dondon biiru-o non-de ik-u he-also steadily beer-ACC drink-CON go-PRES ‘He too keeps on drinking beer.’ There are more instances of spatial expressions than aspectual ones involving nonde kuru ‘drink come’ and tabe-te kuru ‘eat come’ forms, but one still encounters the following kinds fairly frequently: (31) a.
Nan-no tame-ni ima-made gyuunyuu-bakari non-de what-GEN reason-to now-up.to milk-only drink-CON ki-ta=n. desu=ka come-PAST=NMLZ COP=Q ‘For what reason have you been drinking only milk?’
b. Ningen-wa nani-o tabe-te ki-ta=ka. human-TOP what-ACC eat-CON come-PAST=Q ‘What have humans been eating?’ In contrast, there are no instances of the aspectual type for combinations like arui-te iku ‘walk go’ and de-te iku ‘exit go’. Indeed, native speakers of Japanese find a clear difference in grammaticality between the (a) and (b) sentences below: (32) a. korekara-mo dondon sake-o non-de ik-u from.now-also steadily sake-ACC drink-CON go-PRES ‘From now on too (I will) keep on drinking sake steadily.’ b. *korekara-mo dondon eki-e arui-te iku from.now-also steadily station-to walk-CON go-PRES (Intended for) ‘From now on too (I will) keep on walking to the station.’
Masayoshi Shibatani
(33) a. Ano kooen-o sanzyuu-nen-rai zutto arui-te ki-ta. that park-ACC thirty-year-over steadily walk-CON come-PAST ‘(I) have walked in that park steadily for over thirty years.’ b. *Sanzyuu-nen-rai zutto uti-kara gakkoo-ni arui-te ki-ta. thirty-year-over steadily house-from school-to walk-CON come-PAST ‘(I) have walked from the house to the school for over thirty years.’ Notice that in (33a) we have an action expression ‘walk (in) the park’ rather than a translational motion event ‘walk to some place’. The combination of the former with a motion verb expresses an incongruous event combination. In (33b), we have a congruous combination of manner and motion events, which fails to yield an aspectual interpretation. In other words, where a literal interpretation of the V-te iku/kuru form yields an incongruous event combination, aspectual interpretation obtains. This means that instantaneous grammaticalization (or a case involving metaphorical extension) is facilitated in the same environment where non-metaphorical and gradual grammaticalization is propelled, namely a semantically incongruous context. This situation has parallels in the temporal domain in other languages such as Formosan language Atayal and Thai, calling into question the widely accepted scenarios of the development of tense/aspect morphemes offered by Heine et al. (1991), Hopper and Traugott (1993), and Bybee et al. (1994), who suggest that tense/aspect meaning develops first in a semantically congruous environment, where inferences of intention and prediction obtain (see Shibatani and Huang 2006).
5. Summary and conclusion This paper has examined two patterns of grammaticalization in Japanese. One represents a case of gradual grammaticalization in which a meaning component of translational motion verbs of coming and going is lost as they occur as a finite verb in converb constructions. The loss of the motion meaning in these verbs has entailed a loss of valency property such that they can no longer sanction a source or goal argument in constructions at an advanced stage of grammaticalization. Advancement in grammaticalization is also accompanied by a formal reduction in motion verbs, as predicted by the general principle of the grammaticalization process. It was then shown that neither metaphorical extension nor frequency of use is a factor propelling grammaticalization in these converb constructions with motion verbs. Instead, an environment facilitating grammaticalization was identified as one in which an incongruous event combination obtains. It was further demonstrated that plausible cases of instantaneous grammaticalization involving metaphorical extension are also facilitated in an environment where a literal interpretation of the expressions leads to semantically less congruous event combinations. Congruous event combinations, on the other hand, inhibit metaphorical extension and instantaneous grammaticalization.
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
This paper has also shown the importance of syntactic analysis in grammaticalization studies. In addition, it underscores the importance of a meticulous investigation of currently ongoing changes, which are much easier to document than less accessible ones. Finally, dealing with grammatical constructions as a whole as units of analysis affords a more fine-grained perspective than dealing with individual forms in isolation since the constructions provide a linguistic context that may play an important role in grammaticalization.
Notes 1. See Bisang (1995) on the similarities and differences between converb and serial verb constructions and Shibatani and Huang (2006) for the demonstration that the converb complex predicates and serial verbs do not form distinct types of complex predicates. 2. This caveat is necessary because a structure that raises the negative -nai may contain sika and -nai in two separate clauses; e.g. Boku-wa [Taroo-ni-sika aitai]-to omow-anai ‘(lit) I don’t think (I) want to meet only Taro/I think I don’t want to meet anybody but Taro/I don’t think I want to meet anybody but Taro’. See Matsumoto (1996) for similar arguments that (3a) involves a simplex structure. 3. Actually, the categorial status of what she calls operator is not entirely clear in Hasegawa’s work. But if the central definitional property for verbs is their ability to function as a predicate, then Hasegawa’s deictic operators do not count as verbs, since they do not function as predicates. 4. The form non-de mieta is fine if understood as an honorific version of non-de iru (drink be) ‘is drinking’. 5. Be aware that arui-te kuru ‘walk come’, for example, can be ambiguous between a translational motion reading, as in (14a) with a specified goal or source argument, and a nontranslational action reading, as in kooen-o arui-te kuru ‘walk (in) the park (and come)’, which belongs to the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type of (14c). 6. The table lists de-te irassyaru/rassyaru ‘exit come’ rather than hait-te irassyaru/rassyaru ‘enter come’ because the latter are involved in a large number of ambiguous cases between the intended hait-te iku type and the non-de iku type. 7. Expressions like the following are possible with the interpretation that the effect of drinking persists, hence overlaps with the motion event: Gakkoo-ni sake-o non-de ku-ru=to-wa nanigoto=ka? school-to sake-ACC drink-CON come-PRES=COMP-TOP whatever =Q ‘Whatever (is the matter with you) to come to school (after) drinking sake?’ This is similar to the following type of expression, where again the result of an action overlaps with the motion event. Hanako-wa gakkoo-ni mizikai sukaato-o hai-te ki-ta. Hanako-TOP school-to short skirt-ACC wear-CON come-PAST ‘Hanako came to school wearing a short skirt.’
Masayoshi Shibatani To a large extent, these expressions behave similarly to the arui-te kuru ‘walk come’ type, in which there is a complete spatio-temporal overlap between the manner component and the motion component of the motion event. See the relevant discussion in Section 4. 8. The expressions cited here are framed in a complement construction headed by the formal noun to ‘when, as’ in order to exclude extraneous instances of the relevant phenomena. 9. In answering the questions posed here we need historical evidence. Another type of evidence comes from languages having similar construction types. See Shibatani and Chung (2005) for Korean evidence suggesting a gradual loss of valency property in the motion verbs of the non-de kuru ‘drink come’ type construction. 10. As mentioned in the text, determining the correlation between frequency and form size is tricky in that certain expressions occur more frequently across the board. For example, the imperative form De-te ik-e! (exit-CON go-IMP) ‘Get out!’ occurs very frequently despite being of the de-te iku type. The ratio of reduced forms of this expression indeed increases more dramatically than with the other expressions of the same construction type. Google count: de-te ik-e=to (exit-CON go-IMP=COM) ‘(e.g., I was told) to get out’ 16,700; de-te-k-e=to 16,500. 11. In Mandarin, Thai and Atayal, for example, simple sequentially ordered events such as eating and then going to some place do not serialize.
References Bisang, W. 1995. Verb serialization and converbs – differences and similarities. In Converbs in Cross-Linguistic Perspective, M. Haspelmath and E. König (eds), 139–188. Berlin: ��������������� Mouton de Gruyter. Brinton, L. J. and Traugott, E. C. 2005. Lexicalization and Language Change. Cambridge: CUP. Bybee, J., Pagliuca, W. and Perkins, R. 1991. Back to the future. In Approaches to Grammaticalization, Vol. 2, E. C. Traugott and B. Heine (eds), 17–58. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Bybee, J., Perkins, R. and Pagliuca, W. 1994. The Evolution of Grammar: Tense, aspect, and modality in the languages of the world. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press. DeLancey, S. 1991. Origins of verb serialization in Modern Tibetan. Studies in Language 15: 1–23. Foley, W. and Olsen, M. 1985. Clausehood and verb serialization. In Grammar Inside and Outside the Clause: Some approaches to theory from the field, A. Woodbury and J. Nichols (eds), 17–60. Cambridge: CUP. Givón, T. 1991. Serial verbs and the mental reality of ‘event’: Grammatical vs. cognitive packaging. In Approaches to Grammaticalization Vol. 1, E. C. Traugott and B. Heine (eds), 81–127. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Grein, M. 1998. Mittel der Satzverknüpfung im Deutschen und im Japanischen: Eine TypologischKontrastive Analyse. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag. Hasegawa, Y. 1996. A Study of Japanese Clause Linkage: The connective TE in Japanese. Stanford CA: CSLI Publications/Tokyo: Kurosio Publishers. Heine, B., Claudi, E. and Hünnemeyer, F. 1991. Grammaticalization: A conceptual framework. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press. Hopper, P. and Traugott, E. C. 1993. Grammaticalization. Cambridge: CUP. Lord, C. 1993. Historical Change in Serial Verb Constructions. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Grammaticalization of converb constructions
Matsumoto, Y. 1996. Complex Predicates in Japanese: A syntactic and semantic study of the notion ‘Word’. Stanford CA: CSLI Publications/Tokyo: Kurosio Publishers. Schmidt, C. 2004. Cosubordinate converbs in Japanese. Paper presented at the First Rice University and UT Austin Workshop on Language in Use. October 23–24, 2004. Rice University. Shibatani, M. and Chung, S. Y. 2005. On the grammaticalization of motion verbs: A JapaneseKorean comparative perspective. The 15th Japanese/Korean Linguistics Conference. October 7–9, 2005. University of Wisconsin, Madison. To appear in the proceedings. Shibatani, M. and Huang, L. 2006. Serial verb constructions in Formosan languages: their form and grammaticalization patterns. The Linguistics of Endangered Languages (Third OxfordKobe Seminar in Linguistics), April 2–5, 2006. Kobe, Japan. To appear in the proceedings. Teramura, H. 1984. Nihongo-no Imi-to Sintakusu (Syntax and Semantics of Japanese) Vol. II. Tokyo. Kurosio Publishers. Traugott, E. C. and Heine, B. (eds). 1991. Approaches to Grammaticalization. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Contact, connectivity and language evolution Yaron Matras University of Manchester
This paper is concerned firstly with introducing a preliminary sketch of a function-oriented theory of language contact. Second, it will address the position of connectivity devices as mental or cognitive operations, which constitute part of the bilingual’s communicative activity. From the behaviour of connectivity devices in bilingual communication, I will be drawing some conclusions as to their position in the grammatical apparatus. The final issue to be addressed is a rather speculative addendum, a commentary on the possible position of connectivity operations in the ancient architecture of the language faculty itself.
1. Preliminaries: A function-oriented theory of language contact Linguists normally view contact-related change, and often also synchronic bilingual behaviour, through the prism of self-contained linguistic ‘systems’: Contact is envisaged as a partial convergence of two systems. I propose an alternative approach to language contact, one that consistently takes the perspective of the bilingual speaker, and which places at the top of its agenda the task to investigate how speakers act in multilingual settings. To the bilingual speaker, languages are not analytical ‘systems’. They are, rather, components of an overall repertoire of forms, constructions, experience, and skills on which the speaker draws in order to communicate. The bilingual speaker, very much like the monolingual speaker who is familiar with various registers of just one language, acquires rules on the selection of components within this repertoire through experience and socialisation. These rules tend to point toward the selective usage of distinct repertoire components in separate environments, or for separate sets of communicative activities. The key to communicating in a bi-lingual repertoire is therefore the acquisition and the application of skills that enable the bilingual speaker to draw demarcation boundaries within the repertoire, and to maintain those demarcation boundaries in line with the communicative conventions and social expectations of the surrounding speech community.1 Rather than talk about the bilingual’s languages, I therefore choose to discuss the distinct components of a bilingual’s overall repertoire of linguistic-communicative structures.
Yaron Matras
Investigating language contact is therefore not about describing how systems converge, but about investigating how successful bilingual speakers are in maintaining demarcation lines within their linguistic repertoires: Where will speakers fail to maintain the boundary between components of the repertoire? Around which grammatical categories or constructions? For which language-processing operations? When will they license themselves consciously to lift the boundary? And under which circumstances will either the lifting of a demarcation boundary, or the failure to maintain it, become habitual, and lead ultimately to a permanent shift in the position of the boundary – i.e. to language change? My basic assumption is that both the maintenance of demarcation boundaries within the repertoire, and their partial lifting or even longer-term removal around specific structures, are functional to communication in multilingual settings. This is a view of language contact that does not discriminate between diachronic and synchronic aspects of contact, or between idiosyncratic occurrences and widespread variation, but takes an integrated approach to the theme of acquiring, maintaining, and re-setting demarcation boundaries within the repertoire. This is the view that is taken, because any changes in the conventions of linguistic behaviour that become accepted by the speech community will have had their roots in individual innovations that speakers introduce at the level of the single utterance, embedded into a specific communicative event. As in monolingual speech (cf. Croft 2000), changes in bilingual settings too are individual innovations which are imitated, replicated, and ultimately propagated successfully throughout the speech community or in certain sectors of it. Bilingual behaviour is a way to navigate through the challenge of communicating, using a relatively wide and diverse repertoire of linguistic structures, and under a complex set of contextual constraints on variant selection. Contact-induced language change is a set of solutions to this challenge, which have become favoured by a significant number of speakers in a significant set of communicative constellations. The task of contact linguistics is to describe and explain speakers’ communicative navigation strategies in multilingual settings, and the conditions under which they lead to longer-term solutions, and so to change. This begins with the gradual process of the acquisition of the skill that enables the speaker to actively set demarcation boundaries within the repertoire. In respect of the infant acquiring two languages from birth, the agenda for investigation has long been defined as a need to analyse the acquisition of boundaries as a social skill (Ochs 1988, Lanza 1997). In respect of more mature speakers, who are generally self-confident in the skill of maintaining boundaries among repertoire components, the agenda of the contact linguist is to define the conditions under which those speakers license themselves to lift boundaries and make discourse-strategic use of the repertoire in its entirety, or indeed of the contrast between repertoire components (cf. e.g. Maschler 1994, Auer 1999). Discourse-strategic bilingual activities such as situational, conversational, and metaphorical codeswitching, insertions, loan translations or loan blends may be considered in this light.
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
But even in respect of the mature and self-confident speaker, the question arises whether difficulties in maintaining separation between repertoire components might still occur, either in certain situations, or indeed around particular processing functions of language, manifesting themselves around certain grammatical categories or constructions. This would point toward a cognitive trigger, rather than a discoursestrategic one, for certain kinds of language mixing. Are there instances of particular language-processing operations, where under certain conditions even mature and skilled bilingual speakers fail to keep apart their repertoire components? The hypo thesis put forward here is that this is indeed the case with certain types of connectivity markers: When engaging in the linguistic-mental operation known as ‘connectivity’, under certain conditions, bilingual speakers may ‘lose control’ of the selection mechanism that maintains demarcation between the different components of the linguistic repertoire, and select a structure that is cognitively functional (in that it triggers the relevant processing function) but socially inappropriate (in that it is not an acceptable variant in the particular setting). Some types of connectivity devices stand out in their vulnerability in such situations. From this it is firstly possible to derive an hypothesis of contact-induced language change: Should the difficulties in maintaining a boundary between the repertoire components persist around a particular function of language beyond just spontaneous and idiosyncratic use, and should the resulting pattern of ‘language mixing’ become accepted and even propagated within the speech community, then a cognitive trigger may be said to have sown the seeds for language change. Second, it can be argued that language contact can shed light on the internal structure of grammar; such ‘pathological’ errors in navigating through the bilingual repertoire indicate that the mechanism involved in selecting connectivity structures is more error-prone, and so that it is structured differently from that which governs the selection of other grammatical operations or lexical items. On this basis we might hypothesise that connectivity occupies a different kind of position in the speech production mechanism.
2. Connectivity devices in multilingual language acquisition I base this section on informal observations of the language acquisition process of a trilingual child, whom we shall call ‘Ben’. Born and raised in England, Ben is exposed to two languages at the home: German, which he hears from his mother, and Hebrew, which he hears from his father. Both parents speak their respective languages consistently to Ben, consciously trying to avoid mixing. Between the ages of 0:4 and 4:4, input was balanced: During the first two years of his life, Ben spent four days a week with an English-speaking child minder, and was cared for at home during roughly half of the working week primarily by his father, and during the other half primarily by his mother, while weekends were spent with both parents. At the age of 1:11, Ben’s parents split up and moved into separate households, in separate towns. Ben stayed with his moth-
Yaron Matras
er, spending three to four working days at an English-speaking nursery, while six days out of a fourteen-day cycle were spent with his father. Holiday time was split equally among the two parents. Most of the holiday time with the mother was spent in Germany, and around half the holiday time with the father was spent in Israel – in both countries with family and relations. On the whole, then, between the age of 0:4 and 4:4, Ben spent roughly equal amounts of time with each of the two parents (each speaking his/her language consistently) and at the English-speaking nursery, with exposure during holidays to monolingual contexts of German and Hebrew. Ben’s active language acquisition history begins between the age of 1:3–1:6, with the acquisition of lexical items from all three input languages. In the early phase, the lexicon appears mixed, characterised, not surprisingly, by the absence of bilingual synonyms and the indiscriminate use of individual lexical items, irrespective of addressee or context (cf. already Volterra & Taeschner 1978). A consistent desire to separate the languages becomes clear however by the age of 1:9, by which time much of the vocabulary is used selectively according to setting (setting being defined primarily by the parent-addressee, and gradually also by a number of other adults who are associated with one language rather than the other). Bilingual synonyms begin to appear during this period, while there is also a set of preferred lexical items, containing elements from all three languages, which the child continues to use irrespective of context. By the age of 2:4 – 2:6, Ben has acquired a fairly fluent command of both his domestic/parental languages, German and Hebrew, with English lagging somewhat behind in active use. In both German and Hebrew, Ben is able to conjugate verbs in various tenses, to make full use of person inflection and inflected pronouns or pronominal clitics, and to produce complex sentences with the full range of conjunctions. He is fully aware of the context-bound separation of languages, and pursues it consistently. However, lapses do occur: In situations immediately following the transition from one parental household to another, i.e. within a few hours or on the first day, or in other situations of partial ambiguity, such as when speaking on the phone to one parent while in the care of the other, Ben occasionally slips into the ‘wrong’ language, that is, into the language that is not the language of the addressee (i.e. the slips are either into the language of the parent with whom he had been spending the past few days prior to the transition, or, in the case of phone conversations, into the language of the parent at whose house he is currently staying). The slips are unintentional; sometimes they are noticed and self-repaired, but quite often they remain unnoticed by the child, and usually un-commented on by the hearer. The most interesting aspect of these bilingual slips is the fact that they involve almost exclusively a particular class of discourse and connectivity markers. Most frequently affected are the particles ‘yes’ (Hebrew ken/ German ja) and ‘no’ (lo/nein), the conjunctions ‘because’ (ki/weil), ‘and’ (ve/und), ‘or’ (o/oder), and ‘but’ (avál/aber), and occasionally focus particles such as ‘too’ (gam/auch), ‘even’ (afílu/sogar) or ‘at all’ (bixlál/überhaupt):
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
(1) Hebrew; age 2:3, first few days in the father’s care after returning from a 3week holiday in Germany; inspecting the shell of a snail in the garden:
báyit šel xilazón aber éyn xilazón bifním house of snail but [German] is-no snail inside ‘A snail-shell, but there is no snail inside’
(2) German; age 7, on the phone to the mother while at the father’s house, describing a collection of insects:
dann gibt’s Butterfly, ve/ und zwei Craneflies then is and [Hebrew] and two ‘Then there’s a butterfly, and/ and two craneflies’
(3) Hebrew; age 5:2, reaching to inspect his trousers while planning a game in which a toy is to be hidden in a pocket:
yeš li überhaupt kis? there.is to.1sg at all [German] pocket ‘Do I even have a pocket?’
(4) Hebrew; age 7:2, on the phone to his father while on holiday in Germany, about a sports event that was being shown on television there:
Jan Ulrich hayá be’érex mispár šéva oder šmóne/ o šmóne was approximately number seven or [German] eight or eight ‘Jan Ulrich was about number seven or eight/ or eight’ Language choice errors, or rather, speech production errors of the type illustrated in (1) – (4) occur in both directions – German connectors in Hebrew utterances and vice versa – especially during the age period 2:3 – 4:6, but occasionally also later. Of particular interest is the history of the adversative conjunction, Hebrew avál, German aber, at an earlier phase during this period. Both language forms of the conjunction (as well as the English form) had been acquired and used regularly in the individual languages before the age of 2:6. At 2:6, Ben spent a three-week holiday with his mother in Germany. Upon his return, and for the next three months, German aber consistently replaced the Hebrew adversative conjunction in Hebrew discourse. It appears as though the two languages underwent a fusion of the structure expressing contrast between propositional units in discourse.2 The demarcation line between the repertoire components collapsed around the particular processing operation of contrast, allowing aber to function independently of context or setting and so independently of ‘language’ selection. This situation prevailed until the age of 2:10, when Ben left for a three-week holiday with his father to Israel. Within a week of interacting in the monolingual Hebrew environment, Hebrew avál was reinstated in Hebrew discourse. Then, upon Ben’s return home, and for the next 2 – 3 weeks, avál replaced aber in German discourse. Thus, a repetition of the process of fusion took place, with the languages in reverse roles.
Yaron Matras
How can we make sense of the turbulent fate of the contrastive conjunction during this period? We might first establish that, while an entire set of connectivity markers is prone to instability around the transitions between contexts (= between sets of extralinguistic factors that condition the selection of particular elements within the linguistic repertoire), contrast is affected in a special way, and there is greater difficulty in keeping apart the repertoire components, and less flexibility to select the appropriate form and so to accommodate to the new extralinguistic setting. The behaviour of contrast is similar to, but is more extreme than that of the other connectivity markers. Next, we can establish that the child’s difficulty in maintaining separation between repertoire components is not due to the overall dominance of any one set of linguistic structures (= one ‘language’). Rather, ‘dominance’ or loyalty to a particular set of structures is variable and fluid. It is, in a way, this changing loyalty which triggers the confusion in the first place. The child undertakes an effort to accommodate to the constraints of the new setting; consequently, a language becomes dominant – not within the repertoire as a whole, but pragmatically, as the preferred set within the repertoire for a series of ongoing activity domains. It is, in other words, pragmatically dominant (see Matras 1998). In this section we saw that even a bilingual child with maximum domain separation between the languages and a high level of linguistic awareness and avoidance of mixing, encounters certain difficulties in keeping apart two of his languages around connectivity functions, especially contrast. There is a certain difficulty, in situations of relative ambiguity which surround the transition between settings, to disassociate connectivity devices from the pragmatically dominant language – the language in which communicative performance took place until the transition. The speaker/child is thus unable to maintain the demarcation boundary consistently. Instead, the boundary collapses occasionally around a specific function or set of related functions, leading to an instantaneous or temporary fusion – i.e. non-separation – of the structures of connectivity (or certain functions thereof) in the two languages.
3. Fusion in adult speech In this section I will demonstrate that the difficulties encountered by the bilingual child and discussed in the previous section are not particular to children, but may just as well affect adult or mature bilingual speakers. Consider first the case of a young, but linguistically mature Hebrew-English bilingual, brought up partly in Israel and partly in the United States. At the age of around eight, he is addressed, in Israel, by a monolingual Hebrew speaker of a similar age group, who asks him a yes/no question: (5) Hebrew; asked a yes-no question by Hebrew monolingual of same age group: S: uh-húh. [ʔʌ̃ˈhʌ̃] ‘Yes’.
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
H: ((looks puzzled)) ma? ‘What’? The speaker’s reply is an affirmative signal which he attributes to a non-language-specific sector of his linguistic repertoire – a kind of language-independent linguistic gesture. In fact, this sequence of segments is not understood in the Hebrew context/setting, i.e. it is not familiar to the hearer with a monolingual Hebrew repertoire. Virtually the same kind of communicative breakdown occurs at a somewhat later age, here in the United States, when the speaker is confronted with a question by an English monolingual adult: (6) English; having been asked a yes-no question by English monolingual adult: S: ts-. [ʇə] ‘ No’. H: ((awaits response)) The click-related implosive sound indicating a negative reply, which is common in the Mediterranean region, is meaningless to the English monolingual hearer, who continues to await a response. In both situations, the speaker mistook operators that help regulate the interaction, for gestures that are language-independent. This kind of collapse of the demarcation boundaries differs from the type discussed in the previous section; here, there is no realisation that demarcation exists around a particular function. The result in both cases, however, is a fusion of both components for a particular language processing function (or group of functions). Consider now the following excerpts (7) – (8) from a television interview, broadcast in the United Kingdom in the documentary series ‘Dispatches’ on Channel 4 television, on 8 June 1997. The speaker is German, and is being interviewed in Berlin about his part in an arms smuggling scheme: (7) S: Well jus/ just the way ǝ ǝ the m/ the weapons ǝ brought ǝ/ I/ I have brought to London, nǝ, und I/ I have told them the truth, nǝ, that they were brought by car, nǝ and/ and ǝ... H: Were they very interested? S: Yes, they were very interested, nǝ, to know how, nǝ.
(8) At the border in England were by the custom/ they have investigated this car, very very ǝ ǝ thoroughly, and they have removed the panels from the doors, the panels from the luggage room and they in/ investigated in the engine compartments aber they didn’t find anything but they/ they have forgotten to get unten ǝ/ ǝ •/ ((clears throat)) they/ they forgot to look under the • car.
The first excerpt, (7), is characterised by the frequent insertion of the (northern) German tag nǝ. Its consistent appearance suggests that it is not attributed by the speaker to any single component of his repertoire, but has again the status of a sector-independent structure within the repertoire, a kind of universal communicative gesture, appli-
Yaron Matras
cable with no setting-related constraints. In reality, of course, nǝ is completely foreign to English speakers and fails to achieve its communicative function when directed at a monolingual English addressee. In addition to this absence of realisation of a demarcation boundary, in both (7) and (8) the speaker fails to maintain the boundary around altogether three forms/structures: Two of them are connectors – und ‘and’ in (7), and aber ‘but’ in (8).3 It is not clear that in either of the cases the speaker actually noticed his error, as no obvious self-repair is inserted. Still, one can safely assume that the speaker is aware of the German origin of the two words, and aware of their English counterparts. The German insertions convey the impression as though chaining devices in the narrative are being carried out in German, while the actual propositional part of the discourse – though possibly planned in German4 is on the whole communicated successfully in English. The conclusion is that there is a set of connectivity devices which at times escapes the speaker’s control with respect to conscious language choice, and that another subset of connectivity items – those that are less ‘lexical’, and appear more ‘gesture-like’ – are in fact processed by the speaker as ‘untagged’ for any particular language, i.e. as part of the overall linguistic repertoire, rather than of a particular component of that repertoire, constrained to a specific set of communicative domains. More evidence for lapses in adult bilingual’s control of the language selection mechanism around connectors follows. In (9), a Czech academic whose foreign working language is generally English gives a brief survey of her research activities at a German-speaking academic forum: (9) ...in Norwegen/ über diese zwei Sprachen, Bokmål and Nynorsk, und so weiter. ‘...in Norway/ about these two languages, Bokmål and Nynorsk, and so on.’ In (10), a native speaker of Polish who has been living in Germany for the past decade or so meets friends from Germany in London, where she has been attending an advanced English language course and living with an English family during the past two weeks. She crosses the street from the Café where the party is sitting to inspect a restaurant, which is said to be decorated in Polish style. Having returned and confirmed that the style is on the whole indeed Polish, she says: (10) ...bis auf/ bis auf die Tischdecken, because/ eh weil sie... ‘...except/ except for the tablecloth, because/ uh because it...’ The error was noticed by the speaker, and a self-repair is inserted. Note that in both (9) and (10), the target of the error – the prevailing form – does not come from a language that is generally dominant in the respective speaker’s life, but rather from one that has pragmatic dominance in the particular communicative domain: Thus for the Czech academic in (9), English is the usual language of international academic events. For the Polish-German student in (10), English has been the focus of her communicative efforts in London over the past couple of weeks.
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
Consider finally two more examples. In (11), a group of four Israelis – the speaker, her husband, and two friends – are having lunch at a Chinese restaurant in Manchester, England. As they are engaged in conversation in Hebrew, a waiter appears to take their order. The speaker’s husband takes the active role in ordering most of the items, and in (11) the speaker intervenes and adds: (11) …and one Won Ton soup avál/ eh/ the vegetarian one. The Hebrew contrastive conjunction avál appears here, rather than English but; it is possible, though not obvious, that the error was noticed by the speaker, for there is a pause and hesitation, but no explicit repair. Finally, in (12), the Saudi Ambassador to the United Kingdom gives an interview on BBC television (Newsnight, 7 June 2004), commenting on plans for municipal elections in Saudi Arabia. In response to a question challenging him about the authorities’ ability to ensure fair elections, he says: (12) I would beg to say that yaʕni/ the Kingdom is a very big territory. The Arabic discourse marker yaʕni in fact derives from an Arabic inflected verb meaning ‘it means’. Nonetheless, as a discourse marker it appears to be assigned to those gesture-like items of speech that are not consciously assigned to a particular component of the linguistic repertoire; yaʕni appears frequently in foreign-language discourse of Arabs. For a trained diplomat speaking on national television about matters of state, it is certain that the insertion of yaʕni constitutes a non-volitional, potentially embarrassing clash with his own and his audience’s expectations in respect of the wellformedness of his discourse. We can safely assume that the insertion is not intentional nor strategic in any way, but that it represents a lapse in the speaker’s control over the mechanism that governs selection over repertoire components. This brings us to the principal point of this section, and that is, that in all instances documented here, the failure to maintain demarcation boundaries between repertoire components surrounding connectivity devices is not in any way discourse-strategic: It is not pre-planned, it is not conscious, in fact it is often self-repaired, and it does not yield any overt communicative advantages for the speaker, either in terms of prestige or recognition on the part of the hearer, or in terms of efficiency of communication and the ability to express a function or relation that would otherwise have to remain unexpressed (this is already excluded through the potential breakdown in communication or at least the lack of any guarantee that the hearer will be able to decode the foreign structure successfully). We can therefore rule out two factors that are often regarded as principal triggers for language mixing, namely prestige-related or emblematic mixing, and functional gap-filling. There remains therefore what must be regarded as a language-processing related or cognitive trigger, a non-volitional and sub-conscious mechanism which, in its quasi-pathological character remotely resembles some symptoms of bilingual aphasia: the inability, around specific languageprocessing functions (mental operations), to maintain a demarcation boundary between components (sets) within the linguistic repertoire, and to select structures in
Yaron Matras
accordance with the context- or domain-particular constraints that govern their normal use in the speech community.
4. Variation in connectivity marking in bilingual communities It has been argued that in bilingual communities speakers will use discourse markers to flag their linguistic abilities (Poplack 1980), or that they will make use of bilingualism to mark out boundaries between utterances (Maschler 1994), or that frequent use of discourse markers will flag cultural integration (Clyne 2003).5 In the previous section we saw examples of bilingual speech production in which cognitive difficulties of language processing and language production override social-setting related and conversational constraints. I suggest on this basis that bilingual speakers, while generally able to maintain demarcation boundaries within their complex linguistic repertoires, encounter inconvenience when it comes to connectivity devices. The removal of demarcation boundaries is a solution of convenience, and hence at least covertly advantageous to the speaker. This ‘covert’ advantage of course competes with the overt communicative disadvantages of losing face when failing to select correctly (i.e. according to the social norms of the community) among the repertoire components, or of risking a breakdown in the efficiency of communication. But let us assume a situation where a) there is no loss of face, since most speakers are bilingual, hence slips of the kind documented in section 3. are commonplace; and b) there is no breakdown of communication, since all members of the speech community understand the pragmatically dominant language into which the slips are likely to occur. In such cases, the inconvenience of maintaining demarcation boundaries around utterance-organising operations might not be counteracted by factors such as prestige or efficiency of communication. Where can we expect to encounter such situations? They are, in fact, common in minority language settings where several conditions are met: 1) The minority language is an ethnic language, whose primary function is to flag loyalty to a clan or ethnic group; it is mainly used for group-internal communication; 2) It is primarily an oral language, and enjoys minimal institutional support (i.e. little or no support in schools, media, written tradition or other institutions, and no norm dictating language purism); 3) Bilingualism is widespread among all adult speakers of the minority language, and interaction with persons outside the community, and so use of the majority, dominant language, is frequent. Although members of the community might well value the maintenance of their own language, the regular appearance of connectors that are identical to those of the second, external or dominant language might not be regarded as endangering the coherence of the ethnic (minority) language. Indeed, we saw above that in the case of some connectivity structures, especially those that are interaction-related and hearerdirected and have a remote relation to the content of adjacent propositions, the structures involved are sometimes regarded as non-component-specific, i.e. as part of the
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
overall repertoire of linguistic structures, but untagged for a specific component that is limited to particular communicative domains or settings. The motivation to remove the inconvenience of having to maintain strict demarcation boundaries around utterance-organising operations, might then override the wish to preserve the internal, aesthetic coherence of a separate ethnic language, or might indeed not be seen at all as contradicting the latter. Consider the example of Romani, a typical oral minority language lacking the protection of any institutions of literacy or other kind of language regulation, in a permanent situation of bilingualism, its key functions being to serve as family- or clanlanguage, flagging ethnic separateness. Examples (13) – (14) stem from a corpus of recordings of the Lovari dialect, spoken here by a second-generation immigrant from Poland to Germany: (13) Laki familija sas also kesave sar te phenav, artisturi, nǝ? her family were part [German] such how comp I-say artists part [German] Her family were like such how shall I say, showpeople, right? (14)
Taj žasas ande veša taj rodasas, taj dikhasas, khelasas and we-went in woods and we-searched and we-saw played ame halt, nǝ. we part [German] part [German] ‘And we used to go into the woods and search, and look around, we like used to play, right.’
The speaker belongs to the first generation in her family to grow up with both languages, Romani and German (previous generations spoke Romani and Polish, Slovak, and Romanian). Note that the German discourse particles also, halt, nǝ are treated as an integral part of the Romani discourse. They are not regarded as foreign, and they do not disturb the subjective (from the speaker’s point of view) well-formedness of the Romani discourse. Needless to say, they do not cause either loss of face or barriers to comprehensibility within the extended family, which is where Romani is mainly used. On the other hand, there is nothing to suggest that acceptance of German culture, or flagging of German-language competence, are motivating triggers behind the insertion of German particles. Bilingualism is an accepted reality in Romani communities, and at least among members of the second generation of immigrants it is a self-evident norm which does not entail any privileged position. Cultural adaptation is often functional, but a culture of contrast is cherished as a key to the preservation of a diasporic identity. There is therefore, in the Romani-speaking context, no obvious advantage of flagging any form of cultural or emotional accommodation to the outside, non-Romani environment; if anything, community members who do appear strongly integrated into the dominant, surrounding culture are looked down upon as semi-assimilated by other members of the community. What we witness in (13) – (14), therefore, is the
Yaron Matras
emerging acceptance of regular insertions of utterance-organising devices from the contact-language into the home-language discourse. In (13 – (14) we witness the acceptability of those connectors that operate exclusively at the interactional level, like fillers and tags. They convey processing instructions in respect of the roles of the participants and the sequencing arrangement of speech activities, and have a special function as an invitation to the hearer to accept the speaker’s role and point of view. These connectors tend to be less overtly lexical or even grammatical, and we might conclude that it is for this reason that they are more volatile to the mixing of boundaries between repertoire components during conversation, and so also more prone to propagation and ultimately acceptance within the speech community. There is indeed evidence in support of such an hypothesis. Thus, the speaker cited in (13) – (14) uses German sentence particles, but the Polish contrastive conjunction ale ‘but’ (recall that the speaker’s family immigrated to Germany from Poland). However, those connectors that make reference to logical relations among propositions that are part of a propositional chain, are also susceptible when it comes to crossing demarcation boundaries and gaining acceptability. Consider examples (15) – (16) from conversations with two native speakers of Low German originating from the province of Schleswig-Holstein in northern Germany, who immigrated to the United States as teenagers in the mid-1950s:6 (15) IF: (a) und dor arbeidet ik den för hunnertfofti Dåler and there worked I then for hundredfifty dollar de Monat the month DH: (b) jåå, dat weer al wat anners. yes that was already something else IF: (c) dat weer wat anners, und he weer uk en Düütsche that was something else and he was also a German een, ni, and äh ik weer de drüdde, drüdde or one no and uh I was the third third or feerte Düütsche, wat för em arbeiden dee. fourth German who for him work did IF: (a) ‘And there I then worked for one hundred and fifty dollars a month DH: (b) Yes that was already different. IF: (c) That was different, and he was also a German, right, and uh I was the third, third or fourth German who worked for him. (16)
dat weer’n Ünnericht för süstein Stunnen, but ik hef bloos that was a lesson for sixteen hours but I have only acht Stunnen måkt, åber dor hef ik uk nix leert. eight hours made but there have I also nothing learned ‘That was a sixteen-hour class, but I only did eight, but I also didn’t learn anything there.’
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
In (15) we find both Low German und and English and (as well as or), and in (16) both Low German åber and English but. Although some effort is made to select connectors in line with the overall choice of linguistic set (lexical, grammatical), i.e. in line with the selected ‘language’ of the discourse, this effort is not consistent, and the infiltration of English connectors does not seem to be regarded by the speaker as a clash with the norms and expectations on well-formedness of communication structures. Thus, in both the Romani examples and the Low German ones, speakers are licensing themselves to lift the demarcation boundaries within their repertoire around a specific class of grammatical operations. That the adoption of such a licence is gradual, makes common sense, and is also supported by evidence from speech communities where original (native, or inherited) devices continue to be used alongside those markers that are borrowed from the surrounding dominant language. Mosetén is spoken by approximately 800 people in the foothill-region of the Bolivian Andes. It has been in contact with Spanish since the 17th century, but Spanish influence has been particularly strong since the 19th century. The following examples (from Sakel, in press) illustrate the acceptability of Spanish connectors in Mosetén discourse: (17)
Wënjö’ khö’ï mömö’ jishyiti’ y move f only.f comb and [Spanish] me’me’ shiphki’ raej dyaba. so leave all peanut ‘She must have come, [and] she just combed herself and so the peanuts came out [of her hair].’
(18) Chhibin o tsiis ji’jaem’te penne chapatikdyetyi’. three or [Spanish] four good raft big.raft ‘Three or four rafts to make a big raft.’ (19) Me’ jïmë mö’ pero mö’ majjo’ me’. so close 3f.sg but [Spanish] 3f.sg much so ‘This (water-source) is closer, but that one has more (water).’ (20) Tyiñetyi’ pero-ki pen’-ki jai’bai. semi.red but [Spanish]-co side-co white ‘It (the peanut) is semi-red, but one side is white.’ While examples (17) – (19) show plain integration of the Spanish connectors y ‘and’, o ‘or’ and pero ‘but’ into Mosetén discourse, in (20) the Spanish contrastive connector pero is combined with a Mosetén marker of contrast. The two devices are, typologically and apparently also functionally, not incompatible with one another, so that the lifting of boundaries here may be conceived of as making full use of the entire repertoire, with no constraint on domain-specific selection. Anders (1993) documents the speech of ethnic Germans in Russia. Despite the preservation of some literary tradition in German, and a closed and rather isolated
Yaron Matras
community structure, Russian discourse particles are infiltrating German-language discourse and gaining acceptability; this can be seen by examining their frequency, as well as by paying attention to the fact that such elements are rarely accompanied by any self-repairs: (21) T: Der Mann war krank und wir konnten doch nicht. the man was ill and we could part not P: Ja. yes T: Nu und • • wie er gestorben ist, und dann • • • hat es nicht part [Russian] and as he died is and then has it not so lang gedauert. so long lasted T: ‘The man was ill and so we couldn’t. P: Yes. T: Well and • • when he died, and then • • • it took so long.’ Other Russian connectors, such as no ‘but’, appear in the corpus alongside their German equivalents (in this case aber): (22) Ma: Sie wollen jetzt noch Brot holen? you want now still bread fetch No ich hab etwas zu Hause! but [Russian] I have some at home Ba: A, ich han Brot. Aber auf morge. oh [Russian] I have bread but for tomorrow Ma: Do you still want to get bread now? But I’ve got some at home! Ba: Oh, I’ve got bread. But for tomorrow. We have established that a) connectivity devices are prone to lapses in control over the choice of repertoire component in early bilingualism, and to speech production errors involving control over the choice of repertoire component in adult bilingualism, and that b) connectivity devices are subject to variation in communities with stable bilingualism, with markers from the surrounding majority or dominant language gradually gaining acceptance as part of the inventory of linguistic structures of the in-group, ethnic, immigrant or minority language.
5. Connectivity structures and grammatical borrowing My claim in this paper (see also Matras 1998) is that variation of the kind seen in the previous set of examples is an outcome of the gradual acceptance and conventionalisation of spontaneous and unintentional lapses in bilingual speakers’ overall effort
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
to maintain demarcation among their repertoire components. We shall return to a discussion of the reasons behind the pressure triggering such lapses specifically around connectivity devices in the discussion below. Once variation sets in, it motivates change: Where too different forms compete for the same function, speakers are likely to regard one of them as more fashionable than the other. Change is thus likely to affect the inventory of connectivity devices; one might say, therefore, that the connectivity apparatus is particularly prone to grammatical borrowing in language contact situations where the recipient language is the weaker or rather the group-internal language. Turoyo (Christian Neo-Aramaic of Tur Abdin, southeastern Turkey; Jastrow 1992) for example, a minority language in a multilingual region, shares its connective and discourse particles amma ‘but’, ya ‘or’, faqat ‘however’, and ya … ya ‘whether/either … or’, ḥetta ‘even’ and balki ‘maybe’ with the surrounding languages Kurmanji (Kurdish), Turkish, and Arabic, the particles û ‘and’ with Kurmanji and Arabic, the connectors ǝnkān ‘if ’ and lašān ‘in order to’ with Arabic, and the particle disa ‘again’, hēš ‘still’, edi ‘then, so’, šxwa ‘anyway’, tǝ ‘at all’, veğa ‘now’, and žnu ‘only then’ with Kurmanji. Such wholesale adoption of the inventory of connective devices (including coordinating and some subordinating conjunctions, interjections, discourse particles, focus particles, and phasal particles) is common in other languages under similar sociolinguistic conditions (stable and widespread multilingualism, primarily oral tradition, restriction of the language to in-group or family communication). Domari, for instance, the Indic language of the Dom peripatetics of the Middle East, employs the full inventory of Arabic conjunctions and discourse particles, including all coordinating and subordinating conjunctions and co-particle (co-relatives), relative particles, phasal and focus particles, interjections, fillers, and tags (items in italics are grammatical loans from Arabic): (23) law ēr-om xužoti kān laher-d-om-s-a if [Arabic] come.past-1sg yesterday cond [Arabic] see-past-1sg-3sg-ant ‘If I had come yesterday I would have seen him’. (24) warik-ar-a mlāy-ēk minšān mā džan-ad-is wear-3sg-ant veil-pred.m so.that [Arabic] neg [Arabic] know-3pl.subj-3sg ‘She used to wear a veil so that one would not recognise her’ (25) qabel-mā dža-m xałłaṣk-ed-om kam-as before-comp [Arabic] go-1sg.subj finish-past-1sg work-obl ‘Before I left I finished my work’ (26) iza wars-ari, n-aw-am-eʔ if [Arabic] rain-3sg neg-come-1sg-neg ‘If it rains, I shall not come’ (27) na kil-d-om bara liʔann-hā wars-ari neg go.out-past-1sg out because-3sg.f [Arabic] rain-3sg ‘I did not go out because it is raining’
Yaron Matras
(28)
ū daʔiman/ yaʕnī/ kunt ama and [Arabic] always [Arabic] that.is [Arabic] was.1sg [Arabic] I kury-a-m-ēk wala kil-šami wala aw-ami. house-obl-loc-pred.f and.not [Arabic] exit-1sg and.not [Arabic] come-1sg ‘And I was always/ I mean/ at home, not going out nor coming’
(29) mana illi to-r-im iyyā-h bread rel [Arabic] gave-2sg-1sg res-3sg [Arabic] ‘the bread that you gave me [it]’ As a result of this wholesale incorporation of Arabic connectors, along with the syntactic convergence of Domari with Arabic and its replication of Arabic word order and clause structure features, sentence organisation and clause combining is identical in the two languages. For Domari speakers, the in-group component of their linguistic repertoire, or what makes up the ‘Domari language’, therefore does not include a specific inventory of connectors or connectivity structures, but is limited to the internal organisation of clauses or even just constituents. As far as speakers are concerned, speaking ‘internally’ (speaking Domari) and speaking ‘externally’ (Arabic) are identical when it comes to connectors and connectivity devices. From a diachronic viewpoint, Domari has undergone complete fusion with Arabic in the domain of connectivity. Romani, too, tends to borrow connectivity markers from the various surrounding languages with which Romani dialects have come into contact. Most prone to early borrowing are, as we saw above, discourse particles, fillers, and tags. Coordinating conjunctions form an interesting hierarchy of borrowing in Romani. All dialects of Romani borrow the conjunction ‘but’ from a current or recent contact language (e.g. Slavic no, po and ali/ale, Hungarian de, Turkish ama, German aber). A pre-European expression for ‘or’, vaj, is retained in some dialects. Elsewhere, ‘or’ is often found to be a more stable borrowing than ‘but’: For instance, the Ajia Varvara Romani dialect of Athens has ja ‘or’ from its Recent L2 Turkish, but ala ‘but’ from its Current L2 Greek; Helsinki Romani has elle ‘or’ from its Recent L2 Swedish, but mut ‘but’ from its Current L2 Finnish. Pre-European ta(j) ‘and’ is retained in many dialects, though often alongside a borrowed conjunction for ‘and’. The additive conjunction too may be a more conservative, earlier loan than the contrastive or alternative conjunction; thus Bugurdži Romani hem/em from the Recent L2 Turkish, alongside pre-European thaj, but ili ‘or’ and po/ali ‘but’ from the Current L2, Serbian. There is a clear implicational hierarchy for the borrowing of coordinating conjunctions, based on contrast (cf. Matras 1998): If ‘and’ is borrowed, then ‘or’ is also borrowed, and if ‘or’ is borrowed, then ‘but’ is also borrowed.7 Romani is not unique in this regard. A sample of languages under the cultural influence sphere (directly, or via another language) of Arabic (Matras 1998) show a similar hierarchy, with Arabic-derived contrastive expressions such as lakin or amma most widespread (cf. Urdu, Punjabi, Persian, Turkish, Lezgian, Albanian, Somali, Hausa, Ful), followed by Arabic-derived disjunctive expressions (ya), followed by additive conjunctions from Arabic (such as ve/w). In a sample of 29 Mesoamerican languages
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
discussed by Stolz & Stolz (1996), 21 languages borrow Spanish pero ‘but’, 16 borrow o ‘or’, and 12 borrow y ‘and’. The results are by and large implicational: If a language in the sample borrows y, it also borrows pero. There are no exceptions to this rule. If a language borrows y, with only two exceptions it also borrows o. If a language borrows o, it is also very likely to borrow pero, there being only three exceptions. We return to the significance of this hierarchy in the Discussion below. The Macedonian dialect of Turkish has borrowed not only individual connectors from its contact language, Macedonian, but also the design of clause combining, which relies on free-standing, clause initial conjunctions introducing finite clauses (whereas in Turkish clause combining is often achieved through converbal structures, with converbs marked as suffixes to verbs): (30) i şimdi onların atları kaldi “Yürük”. and [Macedonian] now 3pl.gen name.pl.poss stay.past Yürük And so they kept the name “Yürük” (31) a gemide para yok whereas [Macedonian] boat.loc money none whereas on the boats there’s no money In (30) – (31), we find the Slavic (Macedonian) clause-initial conjunctions i ‘and’ and a ‘and, however; whereas’, and so also a contrast between two distinct connectivity types – addition, and contrastive-addition – which do not exist in (Standard) Turkish. The organisation of clause combining structures in Macedonian Turkish replicates the Macedonian blueprint even in those cases where no actual formal material is borrowed. Thus in (30), the first embedded clause (‘what I want to say’) is finite, and is introduced by a conjunction ne, deriving from the interrogative ‘what’8; this conjunction also serves as a relativiser. The second, modal clause (‘I want to say’) is also finite, showing the typical Balkan infinitive-loss and its replacement through a finite (in this case, subjunctive) verb describing the target action (cf. Matras 2003/2004): (32) bilirsin ne istiyom deyim know.aor.2sg what want.prog.1sg say.subj.1sg ‘You know what I want to say.’ Note that Macedonian Turkish remains, in contrast to the other languages of the Balkans, an agglutinating, postpositional, and predominantly SOV language, and so typologically quite distinct. In terms of syntactic typology, the structure of clause combining might be regarded as the first (and so far principal) domain in which convergence with the neighbouring languages takes place. Connectivity structures, then, appear particularly vulnerable not just to the actual borrowing for formal material such as conjunctions and other particles, but also to the replication of patterns of constituent ordering, agreement and overall form-function mapping that form the mental blueprint for the respective construction. We find evidence for this tendency toward con-
Yaron Matras
vergence of clause combining structures in other linguistic areas, too. Consider the structure of complementation in a number of languages in the northern Levant / eastern Anatolian region – Kurmanji (Iranian), Neo-Aramaic (Semitic), Arabic (Semitic), and Domari (Indo-Aryan). (33) Kurmanji: ez di-xwaz-im her-im mal-ê I prog-want-1sg go.subj-1sg home-obl (34) Neo-Aramaic (Zakho, Iraq): ana g-ib-ǝn āz-in l-bēsa I prog-want-1sg go.subj-1sg to-home (35) Arabic: ana biddī a-rūḥ ʕa-l-bēt I want.1sg 1sg-go.subj to-def-home (36)
Domari: ama biddī dža-m kury-ata I want.1sg go.subj-1sg home-dat ‘I want to go home’
Note that the languages differ in basic word order rules, Kurmanji showing predominantly SOV, the others showing mainly SVO. As is the case in Macedonian Turkish, the structure of connectivity appears more prone to convergence than other aspects of syntactic typology. Based on a selection of case studies, we can arrive at the following tentative conclusion about the position of connectivity devices in language contact situations: a. Connective particles are prone to direct borrowing (i.e. replication of form), particularly from a dominant language (whereby the prestige of the dominant language is the key to long-term acceptability of the forms, but not necessarily the trigger for their initial insertion at the utterance level). ‘Smaller’ or ‘weaker’ languages will tend toward fusion of the inventory of connective particles with that of the dominant language. The susceptibility of connective particles to borrowing tends to be hierarchical, with those expressing contrast as well as those with minimal lexical content (i.e. gesture-like) among the most likely to be affected. b. Connectivity structures that operate at the level of the entire organisation of the complex clause are prone to replication of that organisation pattern. Such convergence or pattern replication occurs under the influence of a dominant language, but also in linguistic areas (where relations of prestige and dominance may not be obvious). What is replicated here is primarily the rules of form-function mapping, the ordering of elements and their grammatical meaning. In other words, we are dealing here with the replication or fusion of constructions (in the sense of Construction Grammar; cf. Goldberg 1995, Croft 2001).
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
6. Discussion: The triggers of fusion around connectivity devices Why is connectivity prone to fusion (of the inventory of operators and their functions) and convergence (of the inventory of constructions) in language contact situations? If our hypothesis is correct, and fusion begins as speech production errors where speakers select the correct function, but fail to observe the constraints on the selection of the appropriate form (‘language’), then we must assume that there is a property of the mental processing operation that is associated with connectivity, and which interferes with the mechanism that controls the selection of items within the overall repertoire of forms and constructions in accordance with context- and situation-bound constraints (i.e. the demarcation mechanism). We must therefore search for the answer to the question of the susceptibility of connectivity devices to borrowing in the function of connectivity in processing language in discourse. Approaches to discourse agree that connectivity does not just concern the relation between the content of one clause or phrase and that of another that is adjacent to it. Rather, it concerns the complex communicative interrelations between the speaker and the hearer during the sequencing of units of discourse (cf. already Schiffrin 1987; see also Rehbein 1979, Redder 1989, Ehlich 1986). The speaker has to guide the hearer into processing relations between utterances, or between the propositional components of utterances. With some combinations of propositions, the processing track is more problematic than with others, i.e. some connections are harder to accept against the set of existing presuppositions. This is where the speaker has to ‘work harder’ in order to sustain the supportive participation of the hearer, and the hearer’s acceptance of the speaker’s authority as speaker and point of view. Similarly, the speaker has to ‘work harder’ when his/her own authority is at stake for other reasons, for instance for failing to maintain the flow of the turn, or for failing to provide convincing clarification, on in instances where the speaker may simply wish to ascertain the support of the hearer (circumstances that are often highlighted by means of fillers, hesitation markers, or tags). The inventory of structures and forms involved in such communicative procedures constitute an apparatus through which the speaker can monitor hearer-sided participation in the discourse, guide the hearer and intervene with hearer-sided processing of the discourse – a kind of ‘monitoring-and-directing’ apparatus. It contains the more obvious functions of connectors –inviting the hearer to accept a proposition as a supplementary continuation of a previous proposition (addition), urging the hearer to revise a possible course of processing and accept a broken causal chain (cf. Rudolph 1995) proposed by the speaker (contrast), or inviting the hearer to accept the speaker’s explanation of a state-of-affairs and its relevance (causation/ result). They may also include the more strictly interaction-oriented functions of connectors – inviting the hearer to continue to anticipate the conclusion of the speaker’s turn despite an interruption in the speaker’s flow of speech or clarity of expression (fillers), or inviting the hearer to signal reassurance of having accepted the speaker’s subjective
Yaron Matras
chaining of propositions or portrayal of an overall point of view (tags). The monitoring-and-directing apparatus involves complex processing in that it depends on the speaker’s anticipation of the hearer’s mental processing of and reactions toward the discourse and communicative behaviour; thus, it calls on the speaker to make predictions about the interlocutor’s activities, and to organise actions of speech accordingly. In this light, the borrowing hierarchy of connectors discussed in the previous section has more than just coincidental value. At the top of the cline contrast>disjunction>addition we find, in discourse-pragmatic terms, maximal intervention on the part of the speaker in the hearer-sided processing of propositions, in effect blocking a pathway for processing the proposition that is available (based on presupposition), and limiting interpretation to a particular direction. With disjunction, the option of diverting a course of interpretation is introduced by the speaker, who offers the hearer an alternative pathway. Addition may be considered the most supportive of all three positions on the cline, in terms of the firm and clear direction of processing which the speaker offers to the hearer, and its harmonious relationship to contextual presuppositions. Borrowing thus appears to mirror the intensity of tension between anticipated, presupposition-based hearer-sided processing of propositional content, and the direction that the speaker’s following speech activity takes. If we trace borrowing of connectors back to a lapse in exercising control over the selection mechanism through which bilingual speakers maintain context-bound demarcation among repertoire components, then we come across a link between interactional tension of this kind, and failure at a given instant to maintain control over the demarcation boundary. Compromising demarcation boundaries is thus, we hypothesise, triggered by the mental processing effect of intense monitoring-and-directing by the speaker of hearer-sided participation in the discourse. This explains why alongside connectors and connectivity structures, other operators whose function it is to process, explicitly, hearer-sided expectations, and so to highlight explicitly the relevance of propositional contents (in the sense proposed by Blakemore 2002; cf. also Sperber & Wilson 1986), such as focus particles (even, too) or phasal particles (still, no longer), are similarly prone to bilingual speech production errors (i.e. ‘wrong’ choices) as well as to long-term borrowing in contact situations. It appears, then, that the monitoring-and-directing apparatus is tightly associated with the forms that trigger the individual operations (but for contrast, you know for tags/fillers, and so on), which reduces the ‘reflection time’ that the speaker has at his/ her disposal to contemplate the selection of an appropriate element, and which makes this selection more automaticised or gesture-like, compared with other linguistic selections. At the same time, the procedures involved in monitoring-and-directing appear more abstract and so more loosely associated with any particular subset within the repertoire of linguistic forms and constructions, and so more prone to evading control over the context-bound demarcation among repertoire components. In practice, what this means is that the bilingual speaker, when initiating a monitoring-and-directing procedure, is prone to select the structure that encodes this procedure
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
from the pragmatically dominant language (i.e the language to which strongest mental attention has recently been directed), rather than from the selected language of the ongoing interaction. If the structure is a word-form, that word-form is likely to be inserted. If the structure is a construction, that is a pattern of form-function mapping, then this pattern will be replicated drawing on elements of the selected language of the interaction.
7. Epilogue: Connectivity and language evolution If our interpretation of the data discussed in the sections above is correct, then we can conclude that the position of connectivity devices at the top of the cline of structural borrowing reflects the particular position of connectivity in the grammatical apparatus. What, then, is that particular position, and what can we learn from it about the ancient architecture of the language faculty? The evolution of language is probably the most speculative domain in current linguistic discussions (cf. Wray 2002, Tallerman 2005, for an overview). This final section does not pretend to offer any methodological breakthrough in the study of language evolution. Rather, it relies on an interpretation of the empirical evidence discussed in the previous sections, and joins the pool of speculations on the significance of empirical evidence to theories of the emergence of language. The monitoring-and-directing apparatus, we argued, is more difficult to control as part of the demarcation of repertoire components (= ‘separation of languages’ in the bilingual repertoire). This positions the monitoring-and-directing apparatus in a different category from other types of linguistic structures and constructions, not just functionally, but from the point of view of the nature of its retrievability or mental activation. Indeed, its potential detachability from a closed subset of the repertoire places it in the vicinity of other means of communication, such as gestures, that are tightly associated with a particular interactional function, but only more loosely associated with just a particular set of contexts or settings (a particular ‘system’ or ‘language’). Which other elements of language might be regarded as belonging to this class of gesture-like functions, and is there any evidence linking them with connectivity devices? There is, in fact, some experimental evidence based on neuroimaging of the brain, indicating that the processing of clause conjoining is linked to greater right-hemispheric activity (Friederici 2001). There appears to be rather clear evidence linking the processing of prosody to greater right-hemispheric activity, compared to the processing of melodic features of language (Schirmer et al. 2001; Friederici 2001; cf. also McMahon 2005). There is also cross-linguistic evidence that discourse particles, including clause-initial coordinating conjunctions, tend to be produced correctly by patients suffering from agrammatism (Menn & Obler 1990: 1370), which again supports the impression of some kind of neurofunctional separation of discourse-organisational operators from other function words. Brain lateralisation could therefore be a factor promoting susceptibility to bilingual production errors in some linguistic procedures – those procedures that are more difficult to control in an analytical fashion. Not sur-
Yaron Matras
prisingly, this involves functions that show greater dependency on non-analytical, right-hemispheric processing. We might assume that the source of the neurofunctional distinctness of connectors and discourse markers is related to their function as a kind of verbal gesture expressed by the speaker to accompany the organisation of speech at the discourse level, and especially to direct the attention and participation of the hearer. These are elements with which the speaker may be said to reach out to the hearer. McMahon (2005) argues for a primary function of prosody in an evolutionary sense, one that emerged prior to the emergence of language as an analytical faculty. It is noteworthy that prosody, like connectivity, is particularly susceptible to contact-induced change, and to convergence in linguistic areas. Arguably, contact-susceptibility in these domains is linked to instinctive (rather than analytical), gesture-like communicative activities. If there is indeed a right-hemispheric orientation for connectors and discourse markers, as there is for prosody, one would be tempted to assume that monitoring-and-directing functions evolved prior to the emergence of language as a more analytic (and lefthemisphere-oriented) faculty. The assumption that monitoring-and-directing operations emerged early in the sequence of evolution of communicative functions is not incompatible with Tomasello’s (1999) suggestion that language evolved is response to the emergence in humans of the capacity to ‘identify’ with fellow humans as intentional agents. It is possible that, much like prosody, the gesture-like nature of grammatical elements such as connectors and discourse markers is a residue of the earliest mental ‘tools’ used by human to capture an interlocutor’s attention and to try and influence the course of an interlocutor’s intentions and actions. The interactional aspects of connectivity might therefore belong to the more primitive, more ‘instinct’-driven and less analytical components of human communication; as such, they are more prone to escaping the analytical control of the bilingual who struggles to maintain what is, effectively, a socially constructed demarcation boundary within a repertoire of communicative tools.
Notes 1. Grosjean’s (2001) speaks of ‘language modes’, which involve a cline of different degrees of activation of each language within the bilingual’s repertoire. 2. See Matras (1998) for a discussion of fusion in this sense. Cf. Meisel (1990), who characterises the lack of grammatical separation between languages in Bilingual First Language Acquisition as fusion. 3. The third – unten ‘below’ – reveals that at least part of the utterance was planned in German, and the local expression which serves as a crucial reference point escapes the simultaneous transposition of the original mental plan of the proposition into English. This slip does not escape the speaker’s attention, however, and he pauses to save face, then repairs.
Contact, connectivity and language evolution
4. See previous footnote, and note German word order patterns in … were by the custom, the use of the perfect tense, and the lexical composition luggage room < German Kofferraum. 5. But see also Salmons (1990) for a different approach to bilingual discourse markers, one that emphasises the convergence of communicative strategies. 6.
Examples provided by Dörte Hansen-Jaax, 1995.
7. Aikhenvald (2002: 182) mistakenly cites this hierarchy in reverse order: “In the hierarchy of borrowing suggested by Matras (1998: 303), the coordinating conjunction ‘and’ is considered more likely to be borrowed than ‘or’”, and goes on to say that Tariana is a counterexample, since the coordinating conjunction is not borrowed, neither is the Portuguese contrastive conjunction mas borrowed, although Portuguese o ‘or’ does appear. 8. In Standard Turkish a paratactic construction resembling this structure is possible, but the default embedded clause would be nominal: bil-ir-sin de-mek iste-diğ-im-i know-aor-2sg sayinf want-past.part-1sg-acc.
References Aikhenvald, A.Y. 2002. Language Contact in Amazonia. Oxford: OUP. Anders, K. 1993. Einflüsse der russischen Sprache bei deutschsprachigen Aussiedlern [Arbeiten zur Mehrsprachigkeit 44]. Hamburg: Germanisches Seminar. Auer, P. (ed.). 1999 Codeswitching in Conversation. Language, interaction and identity. London: Routledge. Blakemore, D. 2002. Relevance and Linguistic Meaning. The semantics and pragmatics of discourse markers. Cambridge: CUP. Clyne, M. 2003. Dynamics of Language Contact. Cambridge: CUP. Croft, W. 2000. Explaining Language Change: An evolutionary approach. Harlow: Longman. Croft, W. 2001. Radical Construction Grammar. Syntactic theory in typological perspective. Oxford: OUP. Ehlich, Konrad. 1986. Interjektionen. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Friederici, A. 2001. ������������������������������������������������������������������������ Syntactic, prosodic, and semantic processes in the brain: Evidence from event-related neuroimaging. Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 30: 237–250. Goldberg, A. E. 1995. Constructions: A construction grammar approach to argument structure. Chicago IL: Chicago University Press. Grosjean, F. 2001. The bilingual’s language modes. In One mind, Two languages. Bilingual language processing, J.L. Nicol (ed.), 1–22. Oxford: Blackwell. Hansen-Jaax, D. 1995. Transfer bei Diglossie. Synchrone Sprachkontaktphänomene im Niederdeutschen. Hamburg: Dr. Kovac. Jastrow, O. 1992. Lehrbuch der Turoyo -Sprache. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Lanza, E. 1997. Language Mixing in Infant Bilingualism. A sociolinguistic perspective. Oxford: OUP. Maschler, Y. 1994. Metalanguaging and discourse markers in bilingual conversation. Language in Society 23: 325–366. Matras, Y. 1998. Utterance modifiers and universals of grammatical borrowing. Linguistics 36: 281–331.
Yaron Matras Matras, Y. 2003/2004. �������������������������������������������������������������� Layers of convergent syntax in Macedonian Turkish. Mediterranean Language Review 15: 63–86. McMahon, A. 2005. Heads I win, tails you lose. In Headhood Elements, Specification and Contrastivity, P. Carr, J. Durand and C. Eden (eds), 255–275. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Meisel, Jürgen M. 1990. ��������������������������������������������������������������������� Code switching and related phenomena in young bilingual children. In Papers for the Workshop on Concepts, Methodology and Data [European Science Foundation Network on Code Switching and Language Contact], 143–168. Menn, L. and Obler, L. K. 1990. Cross-linguistic data and theories of agrammatism. In Agrammatic Aphasia: A cross-language narrative sourcebook, L. Menn and L. K. Obler (eds), 1369–1389. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Ochs, E. 1988. Culture and Language Development: Language acquisition and language socialisation in a Samoan village. Cambridge: CUP. Poplack, S. 1980. Sometimes I’ll start a sentence in Spanish y termino en español: Toward a typology of code-switching. Linguistics 18: 581–618. Redder, A. 1989. Konjunktionen, Partikeln und Modalverben als Sequenzierungsmittel im Unterrichtsdiskurs. ��� In Dialoganalyse II, E. Weigand and F. Hundsnurscher (eds), 393–407. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Rehbein, J. 1979. Sprechhandlungsaugmente. Zur Organisation der Hörersteuerung. In Die Partikeln der deutschen Sprache, H. Weydt (ed), 58–74. Berlin: ������������������� De Gruyter. Rudolph. E. 1995. Contrast. Adversative and concessive expressions on sentence and text level. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Sakel, J. In press. The borrowing of Spanish discourse markers in Mosetén. International Journal of Bilingualism. Salmons, J. 1990. Bilingual discourse marking: Code switching, borrowing, and convergence in some German-American dialects. Linguistics 28: 453–480. Schiffrin, D. 1987. Discourse Markers. Cambridge: CUP. Schirmer, A., Alter, K., Kotz, S. and Friederici, A. 2001. Lateralization of prosody during language production: A lesion study. Brain and Language 76: 1–17. Sperber, D. and Wilson, D. 1986. Relevance. Communication and cognition. Oxford: Blackwell. Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 1996. Funktionswortentlehnung in Mesoamerika. Spanisch-amerindischer Sprachkontakt [Hispanoindiana II]. Sprachtypologie und Universalienforschung 49: 86–123. Tallerman, M. (ed.) 2005. Language Origins. Perspectives on evolution. Oxford: OUP. Tomasello, M. 1999. The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press. Volterra, V. and Taeschner, T. 1978. The acquisition and development of language by a bilingual child. Journal of Child Language 5: 311–326. Wray, A. (ed.) 2002. The Transition to Language. Oxford: OUP.
ALLORA On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian as donor language Thomas Stolz University of Bremen
The article addresses the issue of function-word borrowing from Italian into a number of languages spoken in Italy or neighbouring regions. Among the most frequently borrowed items, the discourse particle allora stands out as the most widespread Italian loan. The article explores the properties which make allora a prime candidate for being borrowed. The borrowability of allora is compared to two competing relative chronologies of function-word borrowing whose empirical basis does not contain evidence from language-contact situations with Italian. It is argued that the success story of allora calls for a partial revision of those models which ascribe particular importance to adversative conjunctions and discourse particles (translating English but and however) because the ubiquitous Italian discourse particle is a serious competitor for the role of prime mover in the chronology of function-word borrowing.
1. From Spanish to Italian Some (though by far not all) function words are known for being particularly prone to being borrowed in language contact situations.1 Especially discourse markers / particles lend themselves easily to transfer from one language to the other. On Thomason’s (2001: 70) borrowing scale, they occur as early as stage 2 which is described as a phase of “slightly more intense contact (borrowers must be reasonably fluent bilinguals, but they are probably a minority among borrowing-language speakers)”. Unsurprisingly, discourse markers / particles also count among the most prominent elements in codeswitching because they most often occupy positions at the periphery of clauses, sentences and paragraphs – positions which are frequently involved in codeswitching (Myers-Scotton 1993). Recent research has revealed that discourse markers / particles of one and the same prestigious superstrate or adstrate language are indiscriminately borrowed by recipient languages with very diverse genetic, areal and typological back-
Thomas Stolz
grounds. Matras (1998: 301–305) for instance has studied the almost ubiquitous borrowing of adversative and coordinating conjunctions corresponding to English but / however and and / or in numerous contact constellations. He provides an intriguing cognitive explanation for the prominence of not only adversative conjunctions in the inventories of borrowed function words across languages: [T]he trigger behind language mixing around discourse-regulating grammatical elements is cognitive, not social, in the sense that it derives from the mentalprocessing functions associated with the linguistic expression, or in plain terms from its communicative-interactional function. The ‘donor’ language is the one that is pragmatically dominant in the particular instance in which transfer occurs, that is, it is a linguistic system to which speakers show a special situative commitment and to which their efforts at norm-conforming linguistic behavior are currently directed. Typically, such a donor system belongs to the language in which group-external communication takes place, and where the speakers under consideration, being outsiders, do not participate in defining the norm. Conversely, their own group may be tolerant toward changing norms and may accept such cognitively triggered transfers. If such a constellation persists, recurring transfers may be conventionalized. Prestige is thus not itself a motivation for the transfer of discourse markers […], but at most a background precondition for the wholesale, long-term borrowing of this class of items [inverted commas original] (Matras 1998: 396).
These rather appealing ideas, however, have not been left unchallenged. In her chapter on Portuguese influence on the Amazonian language Tariana, Aikhenvald (2002: 179– 86) observes that her evidence runs counter to the patterns familiar from other contact constellations where discourse markers are prime candidates for being borrowed. Tariana does not seem to have borrowed any discourse markers from Portuguese (although it has borrowed the preposition até ‘until’ [a somewhat doubtful case though], the conjunction ou ‘or’ and the negator nem ‘nor’). Aikhenvald (2002: 182) emphasises that the notorious adversative conjunction has not been borrowed into Tariana. Moreover, she claims that the borrowing of the disjunctive ou ‘or’ without prior borrowing of the coordinating e ‘and’ disproves the validity of Matras’s borrowing hierarchy. However, this latter claim is caused by a misinterpretation of the implication and ⊃ or ⊃ but.2 Matras (1998: 303 and elsewhere) clearly states that but is the unmarked case whereas the borrowed or implies borrowed but and borrowed and implies borrowed or and but. Thus, only the absence of Portuguese mas ‘but’ in Tariana is a challenge to Matras’ model. In the light of such potential counter-evidence it is advisable to extend our empirical basis by reviewing more contact constellations with different donors and recipients and, other sets of function words. With a view to testing Matras’s hypothesis, it is thus necessary to look at function words other than adversative conjunctions and functionally closely related items from a comparative perspective. These additional function words have to be checked in de-
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
tail for their borrowability in order to determine whether or not there is something special about say, adversativity, which facilitates the borrowing of its expressions provided by the prestigious (or in Matras’s terms “pragmatically prominent”) language. If a certain class of markers behaves differently from other function words fulfilling discourse-organizing tasks when it comes to being borrowed, then this evidence has to be checked against Matras’s model and the hierarchies proposed therein. If however there is no evidence for a special status of one class of markers in comparison to other discourse particles then a revision of the model is called for. This will also be the case if it turns out that certain languages – be they recipient or donor languages – yield divergent results in language contact situations. Thus, in this contribution, I will give special attention to a different set of discourse particles whose functional domain does not prototypically revolve around adversativity (see below). I will also look at languages which hitherto have not been prominent in the literature on our topic. In order to guarantee comparability with Matras (1998), I will largely refrain from discussing social factors, whose potential effects in function-word borrowing will be focused upon in a follow-up study. The paradigm case of parallel borrowing behaviour is the Hispanicisation of (many of) the indigeneous languages presently spoken in those territories which once belonged to the erstwhile Spanish colonial empire or which now form part of the officially Spanish-speaking successor states of the former colonies in Latin America (Zimmermann 1987; Th. Stolz 1996, 1997, 1998, 2002; Ch. Stolz 1998; Stolz and Stolz 1995, 1996a, 1996b, 1997, 2001). Owing to the common exposure to Spanish as their prestigious donor language, languages of different genetic affiliation and typological classes on three continents have become similar in spite of their original structural diversity. The features they now share are the ones which they have borrowed independently from Spanish: more often than not, languages in Austronesia (Philippines, Marianas, Easter Island), the Americas (from Mexico to Tierra de Fuego) and – though probably to a lesser extent – Africa (Northern Maroc, West Sahara and Equatorial Guinea) display almost identical and relatively extended sets of Spanish-derived function words with discourse particles ranking highest. The widespread use of Spanish entonces ‘then, therefore, thus’ in Autronesian and Amerindian languages exemplifies this tendency. In (1)-(4) I present sentences from Philippinian, Polynesian, Tupi-Guaranian and Totonac-Tepehuan languages which have integrated entonces into their systems without ever having been in direct contact with each other.3 In these sentences, the usage to which the borrowed versions of entonces are put in the recipient languages largely conforms to the patterns provided by the donor language Spanish, although functional and distributional equivalence is not necessarily strict, as recipient languages may employ borrowed items in a way which is at odds with the rules of the donor language. Note too that direct Spanish influence on Hiligaynon ceased more than a century ago whereas it is very strong (and ever increasing) in the three remaining cases.4
Thomas Stolz
(1)
Hiligaynon [Austronesian, Philippinian – Philippines] (Wolfenden 1971: 79–80)5 Madamo ang bulak dira’ intonsis manguha kita many Det flower at_there therefore Fut:get 1Pl ‘There are lots of flowers there, so let’s get some.’
(2)
Rapanui [Austronesian, Polynesian – Easter Island] (Makihara 2001: 198) entonces ka u’i mo hakapiri o tātou entonces Imp look Subord unite Poss 1Pl.Incl ‘Therefore, let’s look to unite ourselves.’
(3)
Guaraní [Amerindian, Guaraní-Tupi – Paraguay] (Gregores and Suárez 1967: 188) e
tónse ko’éro ‘ó ko’è=muaéro še po-visitá ta entonces tomorrow or day_after_tomorrow I you-visit Fut ‘Then, tomorrow or the day after, I will visit you.’
(4)
Totonac [Amerindian, Totonac-Tepehuan – Mexico] (Levy 1990: 42) entonces tuku li:-cha:’lhka:tnan-a chi? entonces what Ins-work-2Sg.Incomp now ‘What then are you working on now?’
Chances are that we would encounter similar phenomena not only in Rifeño or other varieties of Berber exposed to Spanish influence in Northern Maroc, but also in heavily Hispanicized substandard / regional varieties of Basque where the normative influence of the unified standard Batua is still rather restricted. Given that the recipient languages, or their immediate predecessors, made use of autochthonous means fulfilling functions similar to those of the borrowed Spanish items during pre-contact times (and, in many cases, continue to do so even today), it makes no sense to attribute the astonishing homology among the recipient languages to incidentally shared structural “deficiencies” (since, of course, there are no deficiencies in natural languages). Likewise, it is impossible to identify any “positive” structural feature common to so many dissimilar languages which might have triggered the borrowing process. Is there then anything about the Spanish discourse markers / particles which makes them irresistible when languages come into contact with Spanish? In order to answer this deliberately naive question, it is necessary to turn our attention to a different donor language. If the discourse markers / particles of other donor languages prove less successful in language contact situations, the idea becomes more tenable that there is something about the Spanish elements (or the socio-communicative conditions in the Spanish sphere of influence) which makes them especially attractive for being borrowed. However, if it turns out that (certain classes of) discourse markers / particles rank high on the borrowability hierarchy independent of the donor language, then the Spanish elements are nothing extraordinary – they only corroborate a general tendency. In this contribution, therefore, I look at the impact Italian and its regional varieties have been exerting on co-territorial minority languages and the somewhat outlier heavily Italianized Maltese language spoken on the Mal-
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
tese archipelago just south of Sicily. I haven chosen Italian as the test case because of the following reasons: (i) Like the seemingly problematic Portuguese (according to Aikhenvald 2002, see above), Spanish and Italian are both Romance languages and are thus easy to compare. (ii) The periods of Hispanicization and Italianization are almost co-extensive as both have been in existence for at least half a millennium in some parts of the territories under scrutiny. In addition, there is also an almost identical division into sub-periods of different contact intensity: for the first centuries, both Spanish and Italian were only sporadically present in the non-Romance speech-communities – a situation which changed drastically in the 19th century when official language policy started to aim at an enforced cultural and linguistic homogenization. (iii) The Italian case is different from the Spanish one as it does not reflect a typical colonial situation but a socially assymmetric adstrate constellation within the zone of cultural and / or demographic dominance of the prestigious group. (iv) Except Maltese, the languages influenced by Italian are all of Indo-European stock and thus distantly related to and structurally not too dissimilar from Italian and its dialects. Thus, the Italian situation differs considerably from the ones described in Matras (1998), Stolz and Stolz (1995, 1996a, 1996b, 1997, 2001) and Aikhenvald (2002) whose focus is on genetically diverse contact constellations. On the basis of a genetically less heterogeneous sample, one might expect different behaviour on the part of the recipient languages. If this hypothesis is falsified however, claims with a language-independent scope can be formulated. (v) As with Spanish, the contact situations both actually involve bilingual ones (with Italian or a local variety thereof being one of the languages mastered by the speakers) and historical ones (for which Italian has almost completely disappeared from the inventory of actively used languages of the population).
The languages to which I mostly refer in the remainder of my contribution are in alphabetic order: (Italo)-Albanian (also called Arbëresh), Cimbrian (Germanic) a heavily Italianised variety of Upper German (Bavarian), (Italo-)Greek (also called Griko), Maltese and Molise Slavic, a South Slavic variety.6 (Italo)-Albanian, Cimbrian, (Italo-)Greek and Molise Slavic are minority languages spoken in relatively small and isolated village varieties scattered about various Italian regions, namely the Veneto and Trentino for Cimbrian, Molise, Calabria, Sicily and Puglia for (Italo)-Albanian, Calabria and Puglia for (Italo-)Greek, and Molise for Molise Slavic. Owing to the better accessability of reliable data for Calabria, my discussion of (Italo-)Albanian and (Italo-)Greek focusses on their Calabrian varieties. (Italo)-Albanian has the largest speech-community with about 88,000 speakers whereas Cimbrian, (Italo-)Greek and Molise Slavic together count no more than 20,000 speakers. Maltese is of course the official language (co-official with English) of the Republic of Malta with slightly less than 400,000 resident native speakers. Maltese boasts of a normative grammar and a
Thomas Stolz
relatively rich literary tradition dating back to the late 18th century. It has been experiencing a constant increase in functions and domains ever since the 1930s when its status was made official (to the detriment of the erstwhile dominant Italian). With Malta’s admission to the EU, Maltese has also become one of the official languages of this supra-national organization whereas the above minority languages of Italy are more or less endangered notwithstanding recent legal provisions aiming at their preservation. Literacy in these languages is limited. Practically all speakers of the minority languages also know Italian and / or a regional Romance variety. On Malta, active knowledge of Italian is restricted although a sizeable number of Maltese are still able to understand Italian fairly well (which continues to be present on the islands because of mass tourism, TV and radio). In sociolinguistic terms, the speech-communities of the minority languages in Italy can be compared to the ones of many indigeneous languages in modern Latin America where Spanish is omnipresent in daily life outside the local residence and the autochthonous Amerindian languages are confined to home, family and perhaps the village. Maltese on the other hand compares with those languages which, as a result of the vicissitudes of political history, were able to emancipate themselves from the foreign dominance, for instance Tagalog in the Philippines (where English ousted Spanish as it did with Italian on Malta).
2. Italian The Italian equivalent of Spanish entonces is allora. Allora is multifunctional in the sense that it may be employed as temporal adverb meaning ‘then, at that time’ (Renzi, Salvi and Cardinaletti 1995: 284–286), as a paragraph-connecting discourse particle with a range of consecutive-causal-temporal readings corresponding to English then / thus / therefore and as a marker of turn-taking (Renzi, Salvi and Cardinaletti 1995: 245). Furthermore, it is also used with a certain adversative flair especially in emphatic questions (comparable to English but / still / yet), as a marker of the apodosis in emphatic (often counterfactual) conditional clauses (Renzi, Salvi and Cardinaletti 1991: 781–784) and as a marker of emphatic imperatives. Some of these functions are secondary in the sense that allora fulfills them only if it occurs in combination with other more dedicated elements. In (5), I give examples for most of the above functions of allora. The majority of the examples is taken from the Italian translation of Antoine de Saint-Exupéry’s Le petit prince – a source that will be important in subsequent sections too. (5) (5.1)
Italian [Indo-European, Romance – Italy] Temporal adverb (LPP Italian XIV.34) E dopo di allora è cambiata la consegna? and after of allora be.3Sg change:Part:F Det:F task:F ‘And has the task been changed since then?’
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
(5.2)
Temporal discourse particle (LPP Italian XIV.11) Allora veniva il turno dei lampionai allora come:Past:3Sg Det turn of:Det.M.Pl lamp_lighter:Pl della Russia e delle Indie of:Det.F Russia and of:Det.F.Pl Indies ‘Then it was the turn of the lamp-lighters of Russia and the Indies.’
(5.3)
Temporal-consecutive discourse particle (LPP Italian I.35) E allora non parlavo di boa and allora Neg speak:Past:1Sg of boa ‘And thus I did not talk about boas.’
(5.4)
Causal discourse particle (LPP Italian II.35) Non avevo mai disegnato una pecora Neg have:Past:1Sg ever paint:Part:M Indef:F goat e allora feci per lui uno di quei due disegni and allora make:Perf:1Sg for him one:M of this:M.Pl two painting:Pl che avevo fatto tante volte which have:Past:1Sg make:Part:M so_many:F.Pl time:F.Pl ‘I had never painted a goat and therefore I produced for him one of the two paintings I had made so often.’
(5.5)
Emphatic imperative (LPP Italian IX.51) Hai deciso di partire e allora vattene! have:2Sg decide:Part.M of leave:Inf and allora go:you:Loc ‘You have decided to leave and thus go away!’
(5.6)
Adversative support in questions (LPP Italian VII.8) Ma allora le spine a che cosa servono? but allora Det.F.Pl thorn:F.Pl to what thing serve:3Pl ‘But then what purpose do the thorns serve?’
(5.7) Turn-Taking (LPP Italian X.68–69) King: …i miei ordini sono ragionevoli. Det.M.Pl my:M:Pl order:Pl be.3Pl reasonable:M.Pl Prince: E allora il mio tramonto? and allora Det.M my:M sundown ‘King: My orders are based on reason. Prince: And what about my sundown?’ (5.8)
Conditional (Renzi / Salvi / Cardinaletti 1991: 781) Se fossi un marziano If be:Conj.Past:1Sg Indef Martian allora avrei le orecchie verdi. allora have:Cond:1Sg Det.F.Pl ear:F.Pl green:Pl ‘If I were a Martian, then I would have green ears.’
Thomas Stolz
Owing to this wide variety of functions, it comes as no surprise that allora counts among the most frequent words of modern Italian. In the Italian frequency dictionary (Bortolini, Tagliavini and Zampolli 1971: 232), allora occupies rank 78. Unfortunately, the various functions of allora are not distinguished in the frequency count. Of the 42 occurrences of allora in the Italian version of Le petit prince, 21 (= 50%) are of a causalconsecutive nature, 13 (= 30%) can be classified as temporal whereas the other “secondary” functions are somewhat underrepresented.7 In four cases (= 9.5%), allora adds adversative emphasis to questions. It is also used twice in conditional clauses, once in turn-taking and once for the purpose of rendering an imperative more emphatic. I reckon that this distribution of allora over functions is not too far remote from the one a more extended corpus analysis would yield. The fact that it is often rather difficult to determine whether an instance of allora counts as temporal, consecutive or causal will be important in the subsequent sections. At this point, it suffices to state that allora tends to invite several readings at a time according to the principle of post hoc ergo propter hoc. Allora has a number of partial synonyms which cover different sections of the functional domain of allora. All of these partial synonyms are multifunctional themselves. For reasons of space, I restrict my further comments to three of the many partial synonyms which are particularly interesting for the present purpose. This does not mean that other partial synonyms such as quindi ‘thus’, perciò ‘therefore’, ora ‘now, thus, then’ etc. have nothing on offer for a contact-linguistically inspired investigation. Dunque ‘thus, therefore’ is responsible for the causal-consecutive part but may also be used for the purpose of reinforcement in emphatic questions (Cusatelli 1979: 580), poi ‘then’ is a temporal adverb although it is not free of consecutive and emphatic functions similar to the ones mentioned for dunque (Cusatelli 1979: 1285) and dopo ‘after(wards), behind’ is a temporal (and spatial) adverb, preposition and discourse particle (Cusatelli 1979: 571). In (6), each of these partial synonyms is exemplified in their prototypical function. (6) (6.1)
Italian [Indo-European, Romance – Italy] poi (LPP Italian II.46) Lo guardó attentamente e poi disse it.Obj watch:Perf.3Sg attentively and poi say.Perf.3Sg ‘He watched it carefully and then said:…’
(6.2)
dopo (LPP Italian XXIV.32) e dopo un silenzio disse ancora and dopo Indef silence say.Perf.3Sg again ‘And after a moment of silence he said again:…’
(6.3)
dunque (LPP Italian III.23) Tu vieni dunque da un altro pianeta? you come:2Sg dunque from Indef other:M planet ‘Thus you come from another planet?’
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
As to their frequency, two of the partial synonyms are more frequent than allora itself, namely poi, which occupies rank 54 in the frequency dictionary, and dopo which ranks 74 (Bortolini, Tagliavini and Zampolli 1971: 232). Both are thus high frequency items. Dunque however is much more seldomly used and thus winds up on rank 325 (Bortolini, Tagliavini and Zampolli 1971: 237). Surprisingly, all three partial synonyms fail to come close to the values reported for allora in the above sample text: poi accounts for 25 cases followed by dopo with 14 and dunque with just seven attestations. Only when added up they can compete with allora in terms of statistics. In what follows, I investigate the fate of allora in language contact situations with Italian as the donor language. For this purpose, I compare allora to its supposed competitors in the above mentioned five recipient languages.
3. Contacts 3.1
Quantities
Given the general validity of my above corpus-based layman’s statistics, one expects a similar statistical disproportion for the discourse-regulating items when it comes to borrowing.8 My working hypothesis assumes that if any of the elements discussed in section 2 is borrowed into the languages which have been in contact with Italian, allora is the most likely candidate. Moreover, if more than one of the items are borrowed then allora will not only form part of the set of borrowed items but it will also be the most frequently used. And thirdly, the use to which allora is put in the recipient languages will largely reflect the uneven distribution of this item over its various functions. I check these predictions on the basis of a relatively heterogeneous corpus. The corpus is made up of: anthologies of folklore including recorded native speaker interviews Gradilone (1970) for (Italo-)Albanian spoken in Calabria; 268 pages of original texts; Bellotto et al. (1978: 38–333) for Cimbrian; all prayers, proverbs, sayings and songs have been excluded; where there are two versions of the same story, I have opted for the one recorded in Lusern; 150 pages of original texts; Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi (1994) for (Italo-)Greek spoken in Calabria; 218 pages original texts (discounting prayers, proverbs, sayings and songs); Breu and Piccoli (2000: 421–44) for Molise Slavic, just 12 pages of original texts; All text editions are bilingual and provide faithful Italian translations which allow direct comparison. All sources comprise texts produced by a variety of native speakers of the recipient languages. For (Italo-)Albanian, Cimbrian and (Italo-)Greek, this practice also implies that different village varieties are represented in the collections. The texts were recorded in the decades after the 2nd World War (the [Italo-]Greek ones al-
Thomas Stolz
ready in the 1950s, some of the ones documenting Molise Slavic as late as the 1990s) and thus reflect contemporary usage. Short written texts for religious purposes: these stem exclusively from the (Italo-) Greek dialect spoken in Bova (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 424–486); the translation of Le petit prince into Maltese by Tony Aquilina, 85 pages. Thus, the corpus contains an uneven assortment of very few written texts and an overwhelming majority of recorded spoken language. Owing to this imbalanced mixture of registers and also owing to the difference in size, the direct statistical correlation of the individual results is ruled out as the margin of potential errors is too wide. Nevertheless the absolute figures and the statistical weight of the borrowed items per language are telling in themselves. In table 1, I present the token frequencies of the four items mentioned in the previous section complemented randomly by the functionally unrelated intanto standard Italian ‘(mean)while’; colloquial Italian also ‘however’ (Cusatelli 1979: 878) as an additional control category. Intanto is number 410 in the Italian frequency dictionary (Bertolini, Tagliavini and Zampolli 1971: 239) and is thus an item of medium frequency. For easy reference, I repeat the Italian values in the first line of table 1. The recipient languages follow from top to bottom according to how many of the discourse-regulating elements are attested in the corpus. Boldface marks the highestranking token frequency values per language. Zero frequency is additionally highlighted by grey shading. A comment is called for as to the results I have obtained for Cimbrian. In his descriptive grammar of Cimbrian, Tyroller (2003: 88) states that [o]kkasionell aus dem Italienischen übernommene Wörter, wovon vor allem Konjunktionen wie alora [a’lo: a] dann‘ und dunque [ ] ‚also‘ betroffen sind, werden hier nicht berücksichtigt, da sie nicht zum festen System des Zimbrischen von Lusern gehören, sondern nur gelegentlich in bestimmten Situationen gebraucht werden.9 Table 1. Token frequencies language
allora
dopo
intanto
dunque
Italian (Italo-)Greek (Italo-) Albanian Cimbrian Molise Slavic Maltese
42 1 170 118 12 38
poi
14 130 65
1 3 34
7 26 1
25 153 0
18 3 0
8 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
At least for allora, this statement is clearly contradicted by the statistics. Allora is much too frequent to be just an “occasional” transfer from Italian. The absence of dunque from my Cimbrian corpus however is not only in line with Tyroller’s observation but also fits in with a general trend (see below). The first part of my working hypothesis is borne out by the numerical values. Allora is indeed attested in each and every recipient language. As a matter of fact, allora is the only element which has been reported for all of the languages.10 Were it not for the unique case of (Italo-)Greek, the second part of the working hypothesis would also hold because allora is the most frequently used of the items under scrutiny in four out of five recipient languages. Wherever dopo is attested, it is always second best – outnumbered either by allora (with ratios ranging from 3-to-1 [= identical to the one calculated for standard Italian] to 6.5-to-1) or by poi (with a ratio of 1.7-to-1) in (Italo-)Greek. The position of allora in (Italo-)Albanian, Cimbrian, Molise Slavic and Maltese is very strong whereas it is particularly weak in (Italo-)Greek where it is attested only once. This discrepancy is of course statistically significant as the frequency count for the (Italo-)Greek varieties is based on almost 220 pages of text. Rohlfs (1977b: 142) surveys the (Italo-)Greek equivalents of Italian allora for all (Italo-)Greek varieties including the ones spoken in the Salento. According to his description, all (Italo)Greek varieties make use of autochthonous elements instead of borrowing allora. This marginal status of allora in (Italo-)Greek goes along with exceptionally high figures for poi, dopo and dunque in the same varieties. Poi is the topmost item in terms of token frequency. Moreover, (Italo-)Greek is the only recipient language for which poi is attested as a borrowing in the corpus. Apart from (Italo-)Greek, dunque has made it only into (Italo-)Albanian where I have found one isolated example. Thus, (Italo-)Greek diverges from the rest of the recipient languages (and to some extent also standard Italian) in the sense that it attributes more importance to items which elsewhere are less prominent as to frequency. An explanation that comes immediately to mind is that the differences observed can be accounted for if, in lieu of the standard language, Italian dialects are considered primary contact partners of the recipient languages. The high frequency of dunque in (Italo-)Greek could perhaps reflect the fact that in the southernmost Romance varieties, the cognates of Italian dunque are more frequently used to the detriment of allora. This is a fair guess as for instance Sardinian – a distinct Romance language often associated with the southern Italian varieties in the pertinent literature – avoids allora while it makes ample use of a cognate of dunque. In the Sardinian translation of Le petit prince, there is no trace of allora at all whereas duncas – the Sardinian equivalent of Italian dunque – turns up 24 times. Its functional range in Sardinian seems to cover much of the fuzzy zone of temporal-consecutive-causal relations for which allora is responsible in Italian (as duncas is used in many of the sentences where the Italian version has allora). However, there seem to be some problems with this kind of explanation. Dunque is especially frequent in the (Italo-)Greek dialect of Bova whereas, at Roccaforte, dunque is a low frequency item. Moreover, the Calabrian varieties of (Ita-
Thomas Stolz
lo-)Albanian, which are spoken to the north of the (Italo-)Greek ones, do not favour dunque at all. This supposed riddle is easily solved however. While it is true that both (Italo-)Albanian and (Italo-)Greek varieties in Calabria are spoken in what Italian dialectology calls la zona meridionale estrema (= southernmost dialectal area), they are not immediate neighbours. The (Italo-)Albanian varieties are located in the province of Cosenza i.e. in the northern part of the dialectal area whereas the (Italo-)Greek varieties are spoken in the distant southern tip of Calabria, in the province of Reggio. As it happens, the extant Calabrian dialect dictionaries clearly show that the Romance dialects spoken around Cosenza differ from the ones spoken in the vicinity of Reggio as to the presence of cognates of allora and dunque. Rohlfs (1977a: 72 and 246) reports that dunca (= dunque) is used throughout Calabria whereas allura (= allora) is restricted to the varieties spoken near Cosenza. Accordingly, there is no entry for allura in the dictionary of the Romance variety of Reggio compiled by Malara (1970) whereas dunca forms part of the recorded items. In his comparative grammar of the (Italo-)Greek varieties, Rohlfs (1977b: 146) explicitly states that for Calabria the equation “allora = […] addunca” holds. Thus, the (almost complete) absence of allora from (Italo-)Greek has a trivial explanation: the Romance varieties with which (Italo-)Greek has been in contact most intensively simply lack this item. In its stead, the cognates of dunque and poi are more frequently employed both in the local Romance varieties and their (Italo-)Greek partners in contact. The fact that dunca is common to all Calabrian varieties of Romance may also explain why it is at least marginally attested in Calabrian (Italo-)Albanian. Outside the extreme southern dialectal area, dunque is likely to occur less frequently as opposed to allora. The frequency values given for the standard language support this idea (see above). Independent of the diachronic developments which have to be scrutinized in a separate study, it is possible to interpret the outcome of my frequency count in table 1 as suggestive of an implication, viz. wherever allora is favoured, dunque is much less frequent and vice versa. We may speculate therefore that allora has remained marginal in (Italo-)Greek even after standard Italian became more important in language contact because dunque already occupies good part of the territory. The single occurrence of allora in (Italo-)Greek most probably reflects a recent development. For those varieties where allora is strong however, the reverse is true: dunque is an exception because allora has already been there before. Before I discuss what these facts teach us in more general terms, it is necessary to look at a selection of examples in order to determine which functions of the borrowed items dominate in the recipient languages.
3.2
Qualities
In the recipient languages, allora may come in different phonological shapes – most commonly allura, but also as reduced alure, alor and lor. What strikes the eye immediately is the fact that despite the relatively high token frequency of allora in the various
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
recipient languages, it normally does not have the full range of functions as in the donor language. The overwhelming majority of cases belongs to the area of temporalconsecutive-causal relations which also dominate in the donor language. Thus, the third part of the working hypothesis successfully stands the test. (Italo-)Albanian and Maltese display the widest ranges of functions of allora; the only function shared by all recipient languages including (Italo-)Greek is the consecutive-causal one. Examples for the various functions of borrowed allora are given in (7)-(12). For contrastive purposes, I add fitting examples for the use of (Italo-)Greek dunca in (13). (7) (7.1)
Temporal (Italo-)Albanian [Indo-European, Albanian – Italy] (Gradilone 1970: 52) Allura u martuen e mbetëtin kutjènd allora Pass marry:Aor.3Pl and remain:Imperf.3Pl happy ‘Then they married and remained happy.’
(7.2)
Cimbrian [Indo-European, Germanic – Italy] (Bellotto et al. 1978: 217) Alóra ‘s püable is gãnt huam is o’. allora Det.Nt boy be.3Sg go:Part home it too ‘Then the boy went home too.’
(7.3)
Maltese [Afro-Asiatic, Semitic – Malta] (LPP Maltese XXVI.23) Allura jien stess baxxejt rasi… allora I self lower:Perf:1Sg head:Por.1Sg ‘Then I lowered my head…’
(7.4)
Molise Slavic [Indo-European, Slavic – Italy] (Breu and Piccoli 2000: 429) Alor su prisegl allora be.3Pl marry:Part ‘Then they married.’
(8) (8.1)
Temporal-causal (Italo-)Albanian [Indo-European, Albanian – Italy] (Gradilone 1970: 88) Allura ajo e zeza vate t’ i rrëmbit zogun allora that Det black:Def.F go.Aor.3Sg Subord him catch bird:Def.M: Acc ‘Thus the black one went to catch the bird for him.’ (8.2)
Cimbrian [Indo-European, Germanic – Italy] (Bellotto et al. 1978: 258) Alóra issar aldar darschrakht allora be.3Sg:he right_there frighten:Part ‘Thus he immediately was shocked with fear.’
(8.3)
Maltese [Afro-Asiatic, Semitic – Malta] (LPP Maltese I.35) Allura la kont noqgħod nitkellem fuq sriep boa allora Neg be.Perf:1Sg 1Sg:stand.Imperf 1Sg:speak.Imperf on snake:Pl boa ‘Thus I spoke neither about boas…’
Thomas Stolz
(8.4)
Molise Slavic [Indo-European, Slavic – Italy] (Breu and Piccoli 2000: 432) Alor je mu da ovi praščič allora be.3Sg him give.Part that piglet ‘Thus he gave him this piglet.’
(9) (9.1)
Consecutive-causal (Italo-)Albanian [Indo-European, Albanian – Italy] (Gradilone 1970: 19) Allura u poxhár ditë e natë nd’ atë finester allora Pass put day and night near that.Acc window e nëng tundej and Neg move ‘Thus she stood at the window day and night and did not move.’
(9.2)
Cimbrian [Indo-European, Germanic – Italy] (Bellotto et al. 1978: 310) alóra sain-sa ghebeest naünzekh. allora be.3Pl-they be:Part ninety ‘Well then they were ninety [wolves].’
(9.3) (Italo-)Greek [Indo-European, Greek – Italy] (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 163) Allúra su kófto tin ģefali Allora you behead:1Sg Det.Acc head ‘Thus I decapitate you!’ (9.4)
Maltese [Afro-Asiatic, Semitic – Malta] (LPP Maltese III.18) Allura inti wkoll ġej mis-sema! allora you also come.Part from:Det-heaven ‘Then you too come from the heavens!’
(9.5)
Molise Slavic [Indo-European, Slavic – Italy] (Breu and Piccoli 2000: 422) tvoja divojka lor je ndelidžend your:F daughter:F allora be.3Sg intelligent ‘Thus, your daughter is intelligent!’
(10) (10.1)
Emphatic question (Italo-)Albanian [Indo-European, Albanian – Italy] (Gradilone 1970: 231) Allura çë kem’ bëmi nanì? allora what have:1Pl do:1Pl mommy ‘What then do we have to do, mum?’
(10.2)
Maltese [Afro-Asiatic, Semitic – Malta] (LPP Maltese V.10) Mela allura jieklu l-baobabi wkoll? then allora 3:eat.Imperf:Pl Det-baobab:Pl also ‘Well then, do they eat the baobabs too?’
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
(11) Turn-Taking (11.1) (Italo-)Albanian [Indo-European, Albanian – Italy] (Gradilone 1970: 298) A: Ma u ngë të njoh ngë të pé maj! but I Neg you know.1Sg Neg you see.1Sg.Aor ever B: Allura gjegjnje gjithë njo çë thotë ki… allora listen all know.Imp what say.3Sg this ‘A: But I do not know you, I have never seen you! B: Well, listen everybody, that’s what this one says…’ (11.2) Maltese [cf. 5.7 above] [Afro-Asiatic, Semitic – Malta] (LPP Maltese X.68–69) King: …l-ordnijiet tiegħi huma raġonevoli Det-order:Pl of:1Sg they reasonable:Pl ‘My orders are based on reason.’ Prince: Allura ser tniżżilhieli x-xemx allora Fut 2Sg:go_down:Caus:DO.3Sg.F:IO:1Sg Det-sun li tlabtek? that beg.Perf:1Sg:DO.2Sg ‘Well, are you going to let the sun go down like I asked you to do?’ (12)
Emphatic imperative (Italo-)Albanian [Indo-European, Albanian – Italy] Allura nga me mua bír’ im nga allora come.Imp with me son my come.Imp ‘Then come with me, my son, come!’
(13) (13.1)
(Italo-)Greek [Indo-European, Greek – Italy] temporal (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 434) O Ġoséppi dúnka eyái apissu to lleiδíondu Det.M Joseph dunque go.3Sg behind Det.M.Gen.Pl brother:Gen.Pl: Por.3Sg ‘Then Joseph followed his brothers.’
(13.2)
Temporal-causal (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 430) Ećino dúnka eyérti this dunque raise:Aor.Pass.3Sg ‘He thus raised himself.’
(13.3)
Consecutive-causal (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 394) Dúnka ipiye pánd’ ambró Dunque go:Imperf.3Sg always forward ‘Thus he progressed continually.’
(13.4)
Emphatic question (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 303) Addúnka esù ise o δyávolo? dunque you be.2Sg Det.M devil ‘Then you are the devil?’
(Gradilone 1970: 126)
Thomas Stolz
(13.5)
Emphatic imperative (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 93) Addúnka δotému ta rúxa! dunque give:Imp.2Pl:me Det clothes ‘Then give me my clothes!’
In (Italo-)Greek, dunca covers most of the functions which elsewhere among the recipient languages form part of the domain of allora. With the proviso that some of the languages are clearly underrepresented in my corpus because of the limited size of the available texts, I summarize the results of my investigation of allora in the five recipient languages in table 2. Attested functions are labeled yes in the appropriate cells whereas empty cells – additionally shaded grey – indicate that there is no evidence for such a function of allora in the corpus. Table 2. Attested functions of allora per recipient language language (Italo-) Albanian Maltese Cimbrian Molise Slavic (Italo-)Greek
consecutive-causal
temporal
temporalcausal
emphatic question
turntaking
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes
yes yes yes yes
yes yes yes
yes yes yes
yes
yes
emphatic imperative yes
Unsurprisingly, what seems to be most attractive in the borrowing process is the quirky area of temporal, consecutive and causal relations between which the boundaries are often blurred. I admit that there might be better ways of classifying some of the above examples. However, the reclassification would most probably take place within the said quirky area and not go beyond it. Two things have to be made clear in connection with the above findings. First of all, the examples of allora in the recipient languages are by no means restricted to narrative passages. A considerable number of examples stem from direct speech. The dialogues are very often lively or dramatic and thus invite markers of emphasis. Nevertheless, emphatic allora is relatively rare in my corpus. Thus, there is no additional bias to the detriment of spoken language. Secondly, in none of the recipient languages is allora without autochthonous competitors. For instance, in Cimbrian, alóra and asó (standard New High German also ‘thus’) compete even in one and the same idiolect and in one and the same text. In Maltese, there is Semitic mela ‘thus’ which may even co-occur with allura in a kind of doublet construction (see [10.2] above) familiar from the context of Hispanicization (Ch. Stolz 1998). In (Italo-)Greek too, the combination of borrowed dunque and autochthonous arte ‘then’ is commonplace at least in the few extant written texts. This co-existence of functionally related autochthonous elements
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
supports the view that there is no structural reason for the borrowing of allora and other function words because the recipient languages have a repertoire of adequate means of their own. Irrespective of the difficulty to determine the exact make-up of the class of discourse-regulating elements for the early stages of the recipient languages, it is legitimate to assume that there were no structural gaps even at the time when contact with Romance varieties first began. The modern standard varieties to which the minority languages of Italy are directly related of course display the full array of discourse markers of all kinds among which functionally partial equivalents of Italian allora are well represented.
3.3
Hierarchy
The above is suggestive of a rather strong attraction not only of allora itself but of elements which have a bundle of vaguely contoured temporal-consecutive-causal functions. The ubiquity of such items in the inventories of borrowed function words of the recipient languages of my sample makes it necessary to check whether or not these elements are in an implicational relation to the discourse-regulating elments discussed by Matras (1998), namely coordinating and, disjunctive or and adversative but. Table 3 surveys the presence / absence of Italian e ‘and’, o ‘or’ and ma ‘but’ / però ‘however’ in the recipient languages. Brackets indicate that the evidence is exclusively corpusexternal. Grey shading marks the absence of a borrowing in a given language. Table 3. Distribution of coordinating, disjunctive and adversative elements over recipient languages language
Molise Slavic (Italo-)Albanian (Italo-)Greek Cimbrian Maltese
coordinating
disjunctive
adversative
e
o
ma
però
yes
yes yes (yes)
yes yes yes yes
yes yes yes (yes)
Before I comment on these findings, examples for the borrowings are presented in (14)-(17). For (Italo-)Greek o ‘or’ and Maltese però ‘however’, I was unable to find any evidence in my corpus and thus had to resort to additional sources. The (Italo-)Greek example is taken from the dialect spoken in the province of Otranto in the southernmost part of Puglia, the so-called Salento. For (Italo-)Albanian, I have refrained from interpreting the frequent conjunction e ‘and’ as a loan from Italian because there is an identical conjunction e ‘and’ in standard Albanian – one of two allomorphs of edhe ‘and’ (the other being dhe ‘and’). In Cimbrian, e occurs twice as part of the expression
Thomas Stolz
e bèn ‘well then’ (= Italian ebbene ‘well then’) which does not allow us to count e as a separate morpheme. (14)
Coordinating e Molise Slavic (Breu and Piccoli 2000: 431) E je donija doma e be.3Sg bring:Part home ‘And he carried (it) home.’
(15) (15.1)
Disjunctive o (Italo-) Albanian (Gradilone 1970: 203) Ngapu dí o tri dit e shoqja i thot after two o three day Det.F woman:Def him say.3Sg ‘After two or three days, his wife said to him…’
(15.2)
(Italo-) Greek (Rohlfs 1977b: 210) krási o gála wine o milk ‘wine or milk’
(15.3)
Molise Slavic (Breu and Piccoli 2000: 424) ti maš arsolvit si pula je you have:2Sg decide:Inf if filly be.3Sg do trajina o je do bešče of coach:Gen o be.3Sg of she_donkey:Gen ‘You have to decide whether the filly belongs to the (coach-pulling) horse or to the donkey.’
(16) (16.1)
Adversative ma (Italo-) Albanian (Gradilone 1970: 7) Ma si vate e erdhe? ma how go.Aor.3Sg and come.Aor.3Sg ‘But how did he go and come?’
(16.2)
Cimbrian (Bellotto et al. 1978: 42) Ma alls in an stròach ghit’s-en an schüttlar ma all in one strike go.3Sg:it-him Indef push ‘But all of a sudden, he was hit by something that made him tremble.’
(16.3)
(Italo-) Greek (Rossi Taibbi and Caracausi 1994: 303) Ma kánnome to xartí! but make:1Pl Det.Acc contract:Acc ‘But let us make the contract!’
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
(16.4)
Molise Slavic (Breu and Piccolo 2000: 436) Ma sa jidu cukar ma now eat:3Pl sugar ‘But now they eat sugar.’
(17) (17.1)
Adversative però (Italo-) Albanian (Gradilone 1970: 102) però mos u harrò! però Neg.Imp it forget.Imp ‘But don’t forget it!’
(17.2)
Cimbrian (Bellotto et al. 1978: 202) Di laüt però hãm-en alle pensaart ke… Det people però have-they all think:Part that ‘The people however have all thought that…’
(17.3)
Maltese (Aquilina 1990: 1050) jien niġi però trid tweghedni li… I 1Sg:come.Imperf però 2Sg:must 2Sg:promise.Imperf:me that ‘I will come but you have to promise that…’
(17.4)
Molise Slavic (Breu and Piccoli 2000: 423) però ti inim na pat però you make:1Sg Indef pact ‘However, I make a pact with you.’
Ma is a high frequent item in all of the recipient languages whereas però occurs only occasionally. It comes as no surprise that però is absent from (Italo-)Greek as the extant descriptions of the Romance varieties spoken in Calabria do not mention any cognates of però at all. The mere difficulty in finding appropriate examples for some of the borrowings in relatively sizeable collections of texts is a telling fact. This is also true of the astonishing results obtained for Molise Slavic. The limited character of the available texts notwithstanding, all candidates for borrowing are indeed attested. This difference between Molise Slavic and the other recipient languages is indicative of an advanced stage of Italianization of Molise Slavic. In what way do allora-like elements correlate with the ones surveyed in table 3? The answer to this question is straightforward: wherever allora is borrowed we also find an element with adversative functions and vice versa. Both categories are in an equipollent implication. Synchronically, it is next to impossible to decide whether or not there is a chronology which still gives precedence to one of thet two competing categories. Our present state of knowledge does not allow for any substantial diachronic speculations. Suffice it here to mention some interesting evidence from the early period of written Maltese. Kontzi (1999: 431) looks at the Italianisms in religious texts by the cleric Panzavecchia dating back to the early 19th century. In these old texts, he noticed occurrences of Italian e ‘and’ and o ‘or’ – two elements which today have disappeared from
Thomas Stolz
the Maltese lexicon. As the author of the texts examined by Kontzi had ideas of his own about what should be part of the Maltese language (Kontzi 1999: 428–429), it is difficult to interpret the presence of the two conjunctions in the said texts. As the two conjunctions are also attested in the 18th century religious texts by Ignazio Saverio Mifsud (Zammit Ciantar 2005: 694 and 702) it is possible that they were part of the common Maltese lexicon of the times, and thus lend some support to Matras (1998) as and and or occur together and thus fulfill the required implication. However, the evidence also supports Aikhenvald (2002) because but is never expressed by an Italianism in Panzavecchia’s writings where the Semitic imma and iżda (both ‘but, however’) abound instead, i.e., but is missing from the list of early borrowings whereas and and or are attested. However, in the 18th century, some rare instances of ma però occur in the above mentioned religious texts (Zammit Ciantar 2005: 701): a combination of two adversative conjunctions of Italian, viz. ma ‘but’ and però ‘but, however’. The situation is inconclusive: either but was borrowed from Italian in Maltese already in the 18th century but remained infrequent, and thus did not figure in the texts of Panzavecchia, or the early attestations of but are idiosyncrasies of the Maltese cleric who wrote the texts. Independent of which of the two possibilities actually applies, one thing is clear: e / o – like ma – only had an ephemeral existence in Maltese, and thus chances are that they never were fully integrated elements. This in turn suggests that they were latecomers, whereas other elements – such as the adversative però – became well-established members of the Maltese system of which they still form part today.
4. Conclusions In (18), I summarize the results of the above discussion in the shape of three implicational scales. (18)
Implicational hierarchies
(18.1) Material borrowings poi
⊃
dunque
⊃
intanto ⊃
dopo
⊃
allora
(18.2) Functions of allora
turn-taking emphatic imperative
⊃
temporal-
⊃
causal
⊃
consecutivecausal
poi
⊃
dunque
⊃
intanto ⊃
dopo
⊃
allora
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
(18.2) Functions of allora
turn-taking emphatic
⊃
temporal-
⊃
causal
⊃
imperative
consecutivecausal
emphatic
temporal
question
(18.3) Classes of discourse-regulating elements adversative coordination ⊃
disjunctive
⊃ consecutive-causal
With the notable exception of (Italo-)Greek where the Italian loans o ‘or and ma ‘but’ have ousted completely the autochthonous elements (Rohlfs 1977b: 210), most of the recipient languages add the Italianisms to their inherited inventories and thus enlarge them. They thus have several options among more or less synonymous alternatives. Pragmatical prominence drives the selection mechanism which determines the actual choice the individual speaker makes in a given situation. However, it is still largely unclear to what extent pragmatical prominence correlates with certain functions and thus with clearly defined classes of discourse-regulating elements. While it seems plausible that not anything goes, the evidence at hand suggests that there is more than one possibility for the status of the pragmatically most prominent category. The Italian scenario resembles the Spanish one where temporal-consecutive-causal elements (= entonces and pues) are most widely spread together with the adversative pero ‘but’. The disjunctive o ‘or’ is also quite common as a Hispanism in recipient languages whereas coordinating y ‘and’ is a rare bird among the borrowings (Stolz and Stolz 1996b). In a way, Italian and Spanish as donor languages seem to constitute a common “type” when it comes to borrowing. Matras’s and Aikhenvald’s cases potentially represent different types. Whether the idea that there is a typology can be substantiated is a question which can be answered only by extending our empirical basis.
Thomas Stolz
Future research also has to reveal whether there is a moderate kind of situationdependency of function-word borrowing (as the differences in borrowing behaviour of Matras’s sample, Tariana and the Italian case seem to suggest). Clearly, the issue of universality vs. idiosyncrasy can be tackled properly only if we have access, in addition to more crosslinguistic evidence, to sufficient diachronic data. These data will then help to test the validity of the implicational scales put forward in this section.
Notes 1. This article builds on ideas I have developed in Stolz (2005) and fits in with a large-scale research project on processes of Romanicization worldwide. I am grateful to Ermenegildo Bidese, Walter Breu, James R. Dow, Elvira Glaser, Miki Makihara, Tamar Khizanishvili, Steven Roger Fischer, and Aina Urdze for their kind help with technical and bibliographical matters. A word of thanks is also due to the two anonymous readers of the first draft of this paper and to the editors of this volume for their kind invitation to participate in this undertaking. 2. I am especially grateful to the two anonymous readers for making me aware of the fact that I followed Aikhenvald’s mistaken interpretation too closely in the earlier version of this paper. 3. A word of caution is in order: the term language is used in a very unspecific sense. This is of course a simplification, as the reported cases may be typical only of one variety of a diatopical system, whereas other related varieties do not make use of the borrowed items. It cannot be ruled out completely that, in some cases, idiosyncrasies of an individual speaker come to the foreground and are not representative of any interpersonal variety at all. In the absence of the necessary socio-linguistic clues, I have taken all examples at face value, accepting them as instances of common communicative practice (see also Stolz 2003). 4. For a general outline of the extra-European presence and fate of Spanish, I refer the reader to Quilis (1992). 5. In the examples, boldface marks those items which are focused upon in the discussion. The borrowed function words are glossed with their equivalent form in the donor language. The examples are given in the graphic representation they have in the sources on which I draw. The abbreviations I use in the transmorphemization are spelled out in the appendix. For each example, the object language is identified by its glossonym accompanied by genetic and geographic information in square brackets. 6. This sample of languages is identical to the one I used for my earlier paper on related issues of Italianization (Stolz 2005). For further socio-linguistic information on these varieties, the reader is advised to consult Bellinello (1998). The collection of articles edited by Breu (2005) assembles numerous studies of processes of Italianization in the co-territorial languages of Italy. The Maltese situation and its historical background are described in some detail in Brincat (2000). 7. In some substandard varieties of Italian, the frequency of allora is probably even higher. The translation of Le petit prince into the dialect spoken in the city of Milan contains 47 attestations of alora, the local equivalent of standard Italian allora. Since I have not yet checked spoken language corpora and more sizeable dialect materials, these assumptions of mine must remain conjecture.
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
8. Note that I do not claim that frequency generally dictates borrowing behaviour as one of the anynonymous readers suggests. However, if certain words such as discourse markers are borrowed at all, it makes sense to assume that their frequency in the donor language has a say in their borrowability. Meaning: it is more likely that the most frequent discourse marker is borrowed before a (considerably) less frequent one. On the other hand, it is by no means necessary that the most frequent items of a potential donor language are borrowed at all (especially because the top-ranking elements such as definite and indefinite articles, etc. often lack salience). 9. “Occasional transfers from Italian, especially conjunctions like alora [] ‘then’ and dunque [] ‘thus’, will not be considered here as they do not belong to the established system of the Cimbrian variety of Lusern but are used only occasionally in determined situations” [my translation]. 10. As has been pointed out by one of the anonymous readers, my sources are partly based on oral usage of speakers and thus the possibility is high that at least some of the instances of allora are cases of code-switching and cannot be counted as proper borrowings. Apart from the fact that it might be difficult to determine exactly where to draw the dividing line between the two categories, the evidence is overwhelmingly indicative of borrowing as very often allora comes in a phonological shape that presupposes adaptation and integration. Admittedly, the isolated instance of allora in (Italo-)Greek is problematic and might turn out to instantiate code-switching. These difficulties notwithstanding, the hapax allora in (Italo-)Greek lends additional support to the idea of different adstrate constellations on Italian soil (cf. below).
Abbreviations Acc = accusative, Aor = aorist, Caus = causative, Cond = conditional, Conj = conjunctive, Def = definite, Det = determiner, DO = direct object, F = feminine, Fut = future, Gen = genitive, Imp = imperative, Imperf = imperfect(ive), Incl = inclusive, Incomp = incompletive, Indef = indefinite article, Inf = infinitive, Ins = instrumental, IO = indirect object, Loc = locative, M = masculine, Neg = negation, Nt = neuter, Obj = object, Part = participle, Pass = passive, Past = past tense, Perf = perfect(ive), Pl = plural, Por = possessor, Poss = possessive, Sg = singular, Subord = subordinator,
References (a) Translations of Le petit prince LPP Italian: Nini Bompiani Bregoli. 1994. Il piccolo principe. Milano: Bompiani. LPP Maltese Toni Aquilina. 2000. Iċ-ċkejken prinċep. Msida: Mireva LPP Milanese Lorenz Banfi. 2002. El princip piscinin. Gressan: Wesak. LPP Sardinian Andria Deplano. 1997. Su prinzipeddu. Cagliari: Artigianarte. (b) Quoted literature Aikhenvald, A. Y. 2002. Language Contact in Amazonia. Oxford: OUP. Aquilina, J. 1990. Maltese-English Dictionary. Vol. II: M-Z and addenda. Malta: Midsea Books. Bellinello, P. F. 1998. Minoranze etniche e linguistiche. Cosenza: Editoriale BIOS. Bellotto, A. et al. 1978. I racconti di Luserna. Vicenza: Circolo Culturale M. Ghandi di Luserna, Istituto di Cultura A. dal Pozzo di Roana.
Thomas Stolz Bortolini, U., Tagliavini, C. and Zampolli, A. 1971. Lessico di frequenza della lingua italiana contemporanea. Milano: IBM Italia. Breu, W. (ed.). 2005. L’influsso dell’italiano sulla grammatica delle lingue minoritarie (problemi morfologici e sintattici). Rende: Università della Calabria. Breu, W. and Piccoli, G. 2000. Dizionario croato molisano di Acquaviva Colleroce. Campobasso: s.l. Brincat, J. 2000. Malta – elf sena ta‘ storja. Malta: PIN. Cusatelli, G. 1979. Dizionario Garzanti della lingua italiana. Milano: Garzanti. Field, F. W. 2002. Linguistic Borrowing in Bilingual Contexts. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Gradilone, G. 1970. Novellistica albanese: Racconti popolari die S. Sofia d’Epiro, S. Demetrio Corone, Macchia Albanese, S. Cosmo Albanese, Vaccarizzo Albanese, S. Giorgio Albanese. Firenze: Olschki Editore. Gregores, E. and Suárez, J. A. 1967. A Description of Colloquial Guaraní. The Hague: Mouton. Kontzi, R. 1999. Wort und Schrift. Des Kanonikus Fortunato Panzavecchia Bibelübersetzung ins Maltesische, nach den Handschriften des Kathedralarchivs in Mdina. Tübingen: Narr. Levy, P. 1990. Totonaco de Papantla, Veracruz. México: El Colegio de México. Makihara, M. 2001. Modern Rapanui adaptation of Spanish elements. Oceanic Linguistics 40(2): 191–223. Malara, G. 1970. Vocabolario dialettale calabro-reggino-italiano. Bologna: Forni Editore. Matras, Y. 1998. Utterance modifiers and the universals of grammatical borrowing. Linguistics 36(2): 281–331. Myers-Scotton, C. 1993. Duelling Languages: Grammatical structure in codeswitching. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Quilis, A. 1992. La lengua española en cuatro mundos. Madrid: MAPFRE. Renzi, L., Salvi G. and Cardinaletti, A. 1991. Grande grammatica italiana di consultazione. II. I sintagmi verbale, aggetivale, avverbiale. La subordinazione. Bologna: Il Mulino. Renzi, L., Salvi G. and Cardinaletti, A. 1995. Grande grammatica italiana di consultazione. III. Tipi di frase, deissi, formazione delle parole. Bologna:Il Mulino. Rohlfs, G. 1977a. Nuovo dizionario dialettale della Calabria. Ravenna: Longo Editore. Rohlfs, G. 1977b. Grammatica storica dei dialetti italogreci (Calabria, Salento). München: Beck. Rossi Taibbi, G. and Caracausi G. 1994. Testi neogreci di Calabria. Palermo: Istituto Siciliano di Studi Bizantini e Neogreci. Stolz, C. 1998. Hispanicisation in modern Yucatec Maya: Grammatical borrowing. In Convergencia e individualidad. Las lenguas mayas entre hispanización e indigenismo, A. Koechert and T. Stolz (eds), 165–194. Hannover: Verlag für Ethnologie. Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 1995. Spanisch-amerindischer Sprachkontakt: Die ‘Hispanisierung’ mesoamerikanischer Komparationsstrukturen. Iberoamericana 58/59(2/3): 5–42. Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 1996a. Spanisch-amerindischer Sprachkontakt: Funktionswortentlehnung in Mesoamerika. Sprachtypologie und Universalienforschung 49(1): 86–123. Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 1996b. ‘Transpazifische Entlehnungsisoglossen’. Hispanismen in Funktionswortinventaren beiderseits der Datumsgrenze. In Areale, Kontakte, Dialekte. Dynamik der Sprache in mehrsprachigen Situationen, W. Enninger et al. (eds), 262–291. Bochum: Brockmeyer. Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 1997. Universelle Hispanismen? Von Manila über Lima bis Mexiko und zurück: Muster bei der Entlehnung spanischer Funktionswörter in die indigenen Sprachen Amerikas und Austronesiens. Orbis 39(1): 1–77.
Allora: On the recurrence of function-word borrowing in contact situations with Italian
Stolz, C. and Stolz, T. 2001. Hispanicised comparative constructions in indigenous languages of Austronesia and the Americas. In Lo propio y lo ajeno en las lenguas austronésicas y amerindias, K. Zimmermann and T. Stolz (eds.), 35–56. Frankfurt: Vervuert. Stolz, T. 1996. Sprachkontakt, Sprachwandel und ‘Grammatikalisierung’ als Faktoren bei der Hispanisierung von indigenen Sprachen in hispanophonen Einflußzonen. In Grammatikalisierung in der Romania, S. Michaelis and P. Thiele (eds), 81–106. Bochum: Brockmeyer. Stolz, T. 1997. Grammatical Hispanisms in Amerindian and Austronesian languages. Amerindia 21: 137–160. Stolz, T. 1998. Die Hispanität des Chamorro als sprachwissenschaftliches Problem. Iberoamericana 70: 5–38. Stolz, T. 2002. General linguistic aspects of Spanish-indigenous language contacts with special focus on Austronesia. Bulletin of Hispanic Studies 79: 133–58. Stolz, T. 2003. Not quite the right mixture: Chamorro and Malti as candidates for the status of mixed language. In The Mixed Language Debate. Theoretical and empirical advances. Y. Matras and P. Bakker (eds), 271–315. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Stolz, T. 2005. Italianisierung in den alloglotten Sprachen Italiens. In Das Zimbrische zwischen Germanisch und Romanisch. E. Bidese, J. R. Dow and T. Stolz (eds), 43–68. Bochum: Brockmeyer. Thomason, S. G. 2001. Language Contact: An introduction. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press. Tyroller, H. 2003. Grammatische Beschreibung des Zimbrischen von Lusern. Wiesbaden: Franz Steiner. Wolfenden, E. P. 1971. Hiligaynon Reference Grammar. Honolulu HI: University of Hawai’i Press. Zammit Ciantar, J. 2005. Il-priedki bil-Malti ta’ Ignazio Saverio Mifsud. Eddizzjoni kkumentata bi studju kritiku. PhD dissertation, Fakultà ta’ l-Arti, Università ta’ Malta. Zimmermann, K. 1987. Grammatisch bedeutsame Entlehnungen aus dem Spanischen in Otomí. Ein Beitrag zur Theorie des Sprachkontakts. Neue Romania 5: 20–58.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children German in contact with French / Italian Natascha Müller Bergische Universität Wuppertal
The present article investigates finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses. It will argue that there is cross-linguistic influence in the case of bilingual German-French and German-Italian children. The children use a Romance syntactic derivation for German finite subordinate clauses which is based on an analysis of Romance infinitival clauses in which the prepositional complementizers enter the derivation above the VP, and not as sister to the IP they are associated with. The relation between complementizer and IP is expressed by movement of the IP from within the VP to the specifier position of the complementizer. The generalization of this type of derivation to all kinds of complementizers is enforced by the existence of constructions in the German input of the children which are compatible with this kind of analysis. The result of the child analysis is root word order in German subordinate clauses. We will argue that the children chose the Romance analysis since it minimizes the interaction between syntax and pragmatics.
1. Introducion: Crosslinguistic influence and language separation Research in bilingual first language acquisition has been guided by two main approaches: Either it has been argued that bilingual children are not able to separate their two languages from early on, since the two languages influence each other (e.g. Taeschner 1983), or it has been shown that bilingual children are able to separate their two languages from early on and that there is no evidence for crosslinguistic influence (Meisel 1989, 1994, Genesee, 1989, Genesee, Nicoladis and Paradis 1995). Put differently, language separation and crosslinguistic influence have been considered as being mutually exclusive in describing early child bilingualism. The main reason for the assumption of mutual exclusiveness is that most research has conceptualized separation and influence as involving whole language systems (or languages). Recently, some researchers have
Natascha Müller
become interested in the possibility that only some domains in simultaneous bilingualism are vulnerable for cross-linguistic influence, while others are developed by the children without any sign of influence. The present paper looks at the development of finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses. In particular, it will be argued that the absence of root-/non-root asymmetries in German child grammar is motivated by assumptions which pertain to the syntax–pragmatics interface. More specifically, it will be argued in line with Herkenrath, Karakoç and Rehbein (2003), that cross-linguistic influence may have the effect that “the grammar of the bilingual children becomes ‘larger’ than that of monolinguals” (ibid.: 257), which represents a problem if the child has to unlearn this grammatical option. The kind of cross-linguistic influence discussed in this paper is driven by pragmatics, i.e. by the function of the subordinate clause, and is “created” by the bilingual children as a grammatical option which generalizes to all cases of subordination. Thus, a pragmatically motivated option, which is well-defined for the recipient language (the language which is being influenced), is overgeneralized to the effect that the option is treated as if it was an obligatory syntactic rule.
1.1
Two conditions for cross-linguistic influence
Hulk and Müller (2000) and Müller and Hulk (2000, 2001) have defined two conditions under which cross-linguistic influence is likely to occur. (a) The vulnerable grammatical phenomenon is an interface property, e.g., a grammatical property located at the interface between syntax and pragmatics; (b) The surface strings of the two languages are similar for the expression of the vulnerable grammatical phenomenon. What is meant by interface property? As a first example, let us have a closer look at the null-subject phenomenon. Languages like Spanish and Italian do not express subject pronouns unless subjects carry contrastive stress. In non null-subject languages like English and German, sentences like duerme, dorme are translated as ‘he/she/it sleeps’ or ‘er / sie / es schläft’. The correct interpretation of the Spanish and Italian sentence implies the interpretation of the subject. Thus, null-subjects are part of the syntactic description of these sentences, namely pro. The existence of null-subjects is one property of the so-called null-subject parameter. Null-subjects in null-subject languages are not regulated by syntactic constraints. They are possible whenever the subject can be considered as known to the hearer. Chomsky (1981: 65) has formulated a conversational maxim, the Avoid Pronoun Principle (APP), in order to guarantee that knownsubjects are indeed omitted in null-subject-languages. In other words, syntax opens the possibility to have null-subjects, whereas pragmatics regulates their use. Violation of the APP leads to unacceptable (not ungrammatical) strings, e.g. Giannii ha detto che luii va venire alla festa ‘John has said that he will come to the party’ without contrastive stress of lui, is unacceptable but a grammatical Italian construction. The APP also guarantees that expletive subjects will not be phonetically realized in languages like Spanish and Italian. The interaction between syntax and pragmatics can be summarized as follows: In null-subject-languages like Spanish and Italian, syntax allows for
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
an additional option apart from phonetically realizing subjects, namely to drop them. The choice between the two options, realization or omission, is regulated by pragmatics, not by syntax. The universal principle APP, a conversational maxim, determines that if no further conditions are specified, pronouns will be avoided (for a thorough discussion cf. Pillunat, Schmitz and Müller 2006). In non-null-subject-languages, the subject can also be omitted: Ø Hab das schon gemacht, ‘Have done it already’. One prerequisite is that the subject is the topic. So far, non-null-subject-languages seem to pattern similarly with null-subject-languages. However, contrasting with null-subjectlanguages, the subject in non-null-subject languages can only be omitted in root clauses, i.e. in first position. This syntactic restriction is unknown in null-subject-languages. The question is whether the APP also regulates subject omissions in non-null-subject languages. In German, sentences with a dropped subject and with an overt pronominal subject are discourse-pragmatically equivalent; they reflect a different speech style, the subject omission belonging to an informal register: Ø Hab das schon gemacht / Ich hab das schon gemacht. In other words, it is not pragmatics which regulates subject omissions in non-null-subject-languages, but syntax proper. The interaction of both components, syntax and pragmatics, is minimal in languages like German. We prefer the term ‘minimal’ instead of ‘non-existent’ since it goes without saying that pragmatics regulates whether subjects can be expressed as pronouns or must be expressed as lexical DPs. Notice that the assumption about minimal interaction between syntax and pragmatics in the domain of subjects can also account for the observation that expletives do exist in non-null-subject-languages and that their presence / absence is regulated by syntax, not by the APP. The second example for the interaction between syntax and pragmatics in the above non-trivial sense are object pronouns in the Romance languages. Interestingly, object clitic pronouns (‘weak’ object pronouns which cannot be stressed, co-ordinated, modified, etc., ‘le’/ ‘l’ ‘ in example (1) below) can be construed with noun phrases containing an indefinite article and assume an interpretation as a ‘type’: i.e., ‘un homme’ (‘a man’) is intended as ‘a man in general’. The important point is that the antecedent, the noun phrase the pronoun refers to (and with which it agrees in gender and number), must be an entity that can be presupposed. This explains why the utterance of speaker B in (2) is incorrect. Here, the noun phrase ‘un verre’ (‘a glass’) cannot be presupposed from what has been said before: (1) Un homme, on le reconnaît par sa façon de parler. A man, one him recognises by his way to speak ‘A man can be recognized by his way of speaking.’ (2) Speaker A: Je voudrais boire du vin. I’ d like to- drink some wine ‘I’d like to drink some wine.’ Speaker B: D’accord. *Un verre, je l’ai dans l’ étagère. Alright. A glass, I it have in the shelf
Natascha Müller
Thus, object clitics can only be construed with a noun phrase which can be presupposed. We can push our analysis of object clitics even further and assume that the function of the clitic is that of marking presupposition. López (2003) noticed that Catalan clitics occur in constructions which contain language material which is known (‘presuppositional’). The two constructions discussed are CLLD (Clitic Left Dislocation, in which a noun phrase has been positioned at the left of the clause as in (1) and in (3) ‘les tables’/‘le tavole’) and CLRD (CLitic Right Dislocation, in which a noun phrase is being placed at the right edge of the clause as in (4) ‘ton crétin de stylo’/‘la tua stupida penna’). Clitics appear in order to mark the dislocated noun phrase as presupposed either in the discourse or by the hearer. This is nicely shown by the example (5), indicating that the construction without the object clitic is only grammatical once the object is not presupposed. If the object is presupposed, the clitic must be present; otherwise the construction becomes ungrammatical, as in (6). The examples (3) and (4) are taken from López (2003: 199) and have been translated from Catalan into French and Italian. (3) Speaker A French: Qu’est-ce que tu as fait avec les meubles? Speaker A Italian: Cosa hai fatto con i mobili? ‘What did you do with the furniture?’ Speaker B French: Les tables, je les ai réparées le matin, mais les chaises je les ai réparées le soir. Speaker B Italian: Le tavole, le ho riparate la mattina, ma le sedie Lit.: The tables(I) them repaired in the morning, but the chairs(I) le ho riparate la sera. them repaired at night. (4) Speaker A French: Qu‘est-ce que tu as fait avec le stylo? Speaker A Italian: Cosa hai fatto con la penna? ‘What did you do with the pen?’ Speaker B French: Je l‘ai oublié sur la table, ton crétin de stylo. Speaker B Italian: L’ho dimenticata sulla tavola, la tua stupida penna. Lit.: (I) it forgot on the table, your stupid pen. (5) Speaker A French: Qu‘est-ce qu’il y a? Speaker A Italian: Cos’ è? ‘What happened?’ Speaker B French: J’ ai oublié ton crétin de stylo sur la table. Speaker B Italian: Ho dimenticata la tua stupida penna sulla tavola. Lit.: (I) forgot your stupid pen on the table. Speaker B French: *Je l‘ai oublié sur la table, ton crétin de stylo. Speaker B Italian: *L’ ho dimenticata sulla tavola, la tua stupida penna. (6) Speaker A French: Qu‘est-ce que tu as fait avec le stylo? Speaker A Italian: Cosa hai fatto con la penna?
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
Speaker B French: *J’ ai oublié sur la table, ton crétin de stylo. Speaker B Italian: *Ho dimenticata sulla tavola, la tua stupida penna. Lit.: (I) forgot on the table, your stupid pen. These examples illustrate that object clitics are different from normal pronouns. Normal pronouns, although being used under certain pragmatic conditions, are not obligatory in syntax. Instead of a normal pronoun, a noun phrase can be used and the sentence remains grammatical, although it becomes pragmatically odd, marked as ‘?’, as shown in (7). (7) Speaker A German: Hast du das Buch auf dem Tisch schon gelesen? ‘Have you already read the book on the table?’ Speaker B German: Das habe ich schon gelesen, ja. It have I already read, yes Speaker B German: ?Das Buch auf dem Tisch habe ich schon gelesen, ja. The book on the table have I already read, yes In other words, French and Italian clitics are not just syntactic categories which are used under certain pragmatic conditions which favor pronominalisation, but they also mark certain syntactic constituents in the languages as presuppositional. In other words, pragmatics and syntax interact in such a way that pragmatic factors restrict the possibilities offered by the syntactic system. Both examples, the one of subject omissions and the one of object clitic realizations, illustrate a non-trivial interaction between syntax and pragmatics. These grammatical domains are characterised by the invasive nature of pragmatics onto syntax. It is this non-trivial interaction between syntax and pragmatics which bilingual children − as well as monolingual ones − find problematic in acquisition. In the case that the second language does not present this kind of interface property, the bilingual child may use the grammatical analysis of the less complex language not showing this kind of interaction for both of her/his languages. Grammatical phenomena like the use of object clitics in the Romance languages are vulnerable to cross-linguistic influence due to their interface properties. The second condition which favours cross-linguistic influence is a property of the surface strings of the two languages. Hulk and Müller (2000) assume that the surface strings are similar for the expression of the vulnerable grammatical phenomenon. What is meant by 'similarity of surface strings’ in (b)? In order to illustrate similarity of surface strings, we will take the well-known example of SVO. German is a verb-second language, whereas Romance languages like Italian are generally treated as an SVO language. However, both languages share the word order SVO in some contexts: the German main clause in (8) can be translated directly into the Italian sentence in (9) below: (8) Maria liest das Buch. Mary reads the book
Natascha Müller
(9) Maria legge il libro. Mary reads the book In other words, two otherwise syntactically different languages may share word order on the surface. Generally speaking, the hypothesis of Hulk and Müller (2000) is that word sequences in constructions which represent interface phenomena of grammar and display similarity in both languages are more difficult to process. Confronted with this major computational complexity, the bilingual child will have recourse to the less complex analysis of the grammatical property in question. If language A offers a less complex analysis than language B for the grammatical phenomenon Z, the bilingual child will make use of the less complex analysis for both languages. For example, a GermanItalian bilingual child may opt for one syntactic analysis for SVO constructions in both languages, which requires the less complex analysis. Taking computational complexity as the reason for why bilingual children use one grammatical analysis for both languages implies that monolingual children will also have problems with a grammatical phenomenon which is ‘complex’ in the above mentioned terms. Indeed, Müller and Hulk (2001) make this observation for monolingual children with the more complex language background.
1.2
Cross-linguistic influence and language dominance
Recent studies observing crosslinguistic influence have explained the influence in terms of language dominance, not in terms of properties of the grammatical phenomenon mentioned above (Bernardini Röst 2001, Döpke 1992, Gawlitzek-Maiwald and Tracy 1996, Hulk 1997, Schlyter 1993, Tracy 1995): The stronger or “more developed” language influences the weaker or “less developed” language. Most authors have defined language dominance on the basis of a comparison of MLU values in the two languages of the bilingual child and / or language use (the amount of utterances in the two languages used during a recording session). The first attempts to define ‘language dominance’ were made at the end of the 1980s and during the early 1990s. The authors of these studies chose both quantitative and qualitative ways of measuring language dominance, although there was no clear line with respect to which criterion should be considered as quantitative and which as qualitative. Quantitative criteria were associated with language performance and linguistic production, while the investigation of grammatical phenomena in both languages (considered to be areas of competence) was considered to be qualitative. ‘Language dominance’ was, in this sense, considered to be a type of ‘grammatical predominance’ (see, e.g., Lindholm & Padilla 1978, Petersen 1988, Schlyter 1993). The use of grammatical phenomena to determine language dominance, however, may be criticised because their emergence may differ in the two languages of the bilingual child, even in the respective monolingual children, and it is subject to cross-linguistic variation. An illustrative example is a bilingual child
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
who develops the accurate gender system later in German than in French. It goes without saying that we cannot conclude from this situation that the bilingual child has a dominant language, namely French, because it might be the case that monolingual German children take more time for the acquisition of gender than monolingual French children. Furthermore, the later development of gender in German may be due to cross-linguistic influence in the bilingual child. Another example comes from the article system. As Kupisch (2004) shows, the development of the article system is subject to cross-linguistic influence, with German developing faster in bilinguals than in monolinguals. The result that, due to cross-linguistic influence, convergence to the target is achieved around the same age in both languages does not allow us to conclude that the bilingual does not have a dominant language. Among the quantitative measures for language dominance range are MLU, Upper Bound (the longest utterance in a recording session), absolute number of utterances, MMU (Multi Morphemic Utterances, i.e. the number of utterances with more than one word/morpheme), quantitative aspects of the lexicon (number of verb/noun types) and the amount of mixed utterances (which contain lexical material from language A and language B). Due to space limitations, the present article cannot discuss the issue of language dominance at depth; cf. Genesee, Nicoladis and Paradis (1995), Cantone, Kupisch, Müller and Schmitz (2006). Furthermore, it is impossible to present a more thorough analysis of the bilingual children’s language dominance. Therefore, it will compare bilingual children with different degrees of balance measured on the basis of MLU.
1.3
Effects of cross-linguistic influence
After having explained the conditions for cross-linguistic influence to occur, we may ourselves ask which effects it will have on the language acquisition process. This influence may be quantitative in nature, accelerating or delaying the bilingual’s developmental process in comparison with monolingual peers. It may also have qualitative effects, often called ‘transfer’ in the literature. The term ‘transfer’ has been used in connection with second language acquisition, i.e., the successive acquisition of more than one language, and was applied to the phenomenon in which previously acquired knowledge is extended to a new domain (a new language). Depending on whether the first and the second language are similar or different for the grammatical phenomenon in question, transfer may be positive or negative. To summarise, if quantitative in nature, the acquisition process should be delayed or speeded up in the bilingual, but the data should not contain evidence for the extension of linguistic knowledge from the first L1 onto the second native language. If qualitative in nature, the data should contain evidence for the extension of a grammatical phenomenon X of language A onto language B, e.g., one should find different types of extension, XA, XE, XG, in language B, if we vary the other language, A, E, G, and by this the properties of the grammatical phenomenon, or the developmental path in bilinguals should be different from that in
Natascha Müller
monolinguals in showing a particular type of construction which is absent in monolingual development. The most surprising aspect of cross-linguistic influence is indeed the effect of acceleration of the language acquisition process. A good example for accelerating effects in language development is finite verb placement in German. From monolingual language acquisition we know that children pass through a stage during which they place the finite (and non-finite) verb clause-finally, even in main clauses − which does not correspond to adult language (Clahsen 1982). A typical monolingual child is Chantal, who has been studied by Schmitz (2004): until the age of 2;7, the verb-final pattern prevails, i.e. she produces utterances like 'ich auch mache’, ‘I also make’ (instead of ‘Ich mache [es] auch’) or ‘die Puppe schlafen will’, ‘the doll sleep wants’ (instead of ‘Die Puppe will schlafen’) in 60% of her utterances. This amount will be reduced to 10% at the age of 2;9 and to 5% at the age of 3;0. Schmitz compared the development of verb placement in Chantal with that in German-Italian bilingual children. The child Lukas is representative for the path chosen by German-Italian bilingual children, namely that they seem to skip the stage in the development of German which is characterised by the predominance of verb-final patterns: Lukas reached a developmental stage at 2;3 which Chantal reaches at the age of 2;10. The interesting observation is that the stage with predominant verb-final placement is absent in the German of the bilingual child. Also evident is the fact that verbsecond placement (VS) is used earlier in bilingual child development, to an extent which the monolingual child only reaches after the age of 3. Delay effects are visible in other grammatical domains, like gender marking. In the monolingual French and Italian corpora studied by Kupisch, Müller & Cantone (2002) a very low number of gender errors has been observed (1.3% (385:5) for L1French and 1.9% (362:7) for L1-Italian). The observed children were all younger than 2;7. These monolingual Italian and French children mastered their gender systems very early (before 2;3) without making a significant number of target-deviant gender assignments. This was not the case for bilingual children speaking French-German and Italian-German, respectively, which have been studied by Kupisch, Müller & Cantone (2002) and Müller & Kupisch (2003). Especially the French gender system appeared to be acquired with a delay. Although the bilingual children were also quite accurate with their gender marking if we consider the whole period from 1;6 – 2;6 in Kupisch, Müller & Cantone (2002) and the period from 2;2 – 4;0 in Müller & Kupisch (2003), in particular the German-French children reached an accuracy rate of only 60% at some points in development. One of the French-German children studied by Müller & Kupisch (2003) reached the accuracy rate of 95% only at the age of 3;9. Finally, even qualitative effects of cross-linguistic influence are visible in the corpora of the bilingual children. The grammatical domain presented in this article will be an example of this kind of cross-linguistic influence in bilingual acquisition.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
2. The research project The data to be presented are part of the research project “Die Architektur der frühkindlichen bilingualen Sprachfähigkeit: Italienisch-Deutsch und Französisch-Deutsch in Italien, Deutschland und Frankreich im Vergleich” (The architecture of the early childhood bilingual language faculty: Comparing Italian-German and French-German in Italy, Germany and France).1 The bilingual children are presented in table (1). All children have been raised bilingually (German-Italian/French) from birth in Germany. The parents decided to raise them according to the “une personne – une langue”- strategy (Ronjat 1913). In most cases (Céline is the exception) the mother speaks the Romance language to the child and the father German. The corpus consists of video recordings (made every fortnight). The recordings started, for the most part, at age 1;6. The languages were separated during the recordings. The German interviewer spoke German with the child, while the Romance interviewer interacted with the child in the respective Romance language. Table 1. Children under investigation Alexander Céline Carlotta Lukas Jan
2.1
French/German French/German Italian/German Italian/German Italian/German
recordings started at 2;2,6 recordings started at 2;0,9 recordings started at 1;8,28 recordings started at 1;7,12 recordings started at 2;0,11
Language dominance
In the following we will discuss the German-French children Alexander and Céline (for Céline cf. Cordes 2001). We will confine ourselves to the MLU-values of the children in order to determine their language balance. More details are provided in Cantone, Kupisch, Müller and Schmitz (2006). Figure (1) shows that Alexander is a faily balanced bilingual child, his French MLU being slightly higher at all points in his development as compared to the values reached in German. In contrast to Alexander, Céline has a dominant language, namely German. Her French MLU values differ considerably from those in German, as can be seen in figure (2). In some recordings, the difference between the two languages amounts to more than 1.
Natascha Müller
7,0 6,0
MLU
5,0 4,0
German
3,0
French
2,0 1,0
2; 2, 6 2; 3, 24 2; 5, 25 2; 7, 6 2; 8, 28 2; 10 ,2 3 3; 1, 22 3; 3, 0 3; 4, 19 3; 6, 7 3; 8, 11
0,0
age
Figure 1. MLU: Alexander 6,0 5,0 MLU
4,0
German
3,0
French
2,0 1,0
0, 9 2; 1, 14 2; 4, 19 2; 6, 7 2; 8, 2 2; 9, 20 2; 11 ,3 3; 0, 13 3; 3, 12 3; 4, 23 3; 6, 12 3; 8, 0
0,0
age
Figure 2. MLU: Céline
Let us turn to the German-Italian children (Loconte 2001). Figure (3) shows Carlotta’s MLU in both languages. Even more so than Alexander, she can be regarded as a balanced bilingual child. Figure (4) presents graphically the MLU-values for Lukas. Until the age of approx. 3;3, he can be considered as the most balanced child in the project. After that age, he uses Italian to a declining degree, most of his utterances in the Italian recordings being German or mixed utterances. Finally, figure (5) contains Jan’s MLUvalues. He can be compared with Céline with respect to the considerable difference between the Italian and the German MLU until approx. age 3. His German is stronger than his Italian. However, in contrast to Céline who does not use French but German
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
with the French interviewer, Jan likes to speak Italian and mostly uses Italian during the Italian recording session. 6 5 MLU
4
German
3
Italian
2 1 0 1;
8,
28
1 1;
1,
12
2;
2,
4
2;
4,
7
2;
7,
13
2;
9,
25
1 2;
1,
27
3;
2,
13
3;
4,
8
3;
6,
17
3;
8,
27
3;
11
,6
age
Figure 3. MLU: Carlotta 6,0 5,0 MLU
4,0
German
3,0
Italian
2,0 1,0 0,0
1;
7,
12
1 1;
0,
17
2;
1,
3
2;
4,
23
2;
7,
15
2;
9,
18
1 2;
1,
27
age
Figure 4. MLU: Lukas
3;
3,
2
3;
5,
8
3;
7,
15
3;
9,
20
1 3;
1,
22
MLU
Natascha Müller
4,5 4 3,5 3 2,5 2 1,5 1 0,5 0 0 2;
,1
German Italian
1
4 2;
,1
5
2;
7,
7
9 2;
,1
2 2
1 ;1
,2
7
2 3,
,1
9
4 3;
,2
3
6 3;
,1
1
3;
8,
5
1 3;
0,
7
0 4;
,1
4
age
Figure 5. MLU: Jan
3. Crosslinguistic Influence 3.1
Finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses
Müller (1993, 1994, 1998) has concluded, on the basis of a review of the relevant literature, that bilingual children with French, Italian or English as one of their two native languages have considerable problems with finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children Absolute number
2;4,6
2;6,25 2;7,27
Vfinal target-deviant
2;5,25
2;8,28 2;10,2 2;11,6 3;1,22 Age
3;2,16 3;3,22 3;4,19 3;5,24 3;6,21 3;8,11 3;9,7 3;10,6
3;11,10 4;1,26 4;3 4:4.25
Figure 6. Subordinate clauses Alexander
14
2;2,27
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 2;2,6
Natascha Müller
Absolute number
2;0,11
2;3,2 2;4,7 2;6,9 2;7,13 2;8,21 2;9,25 2;10,30 2;11,27 Age
3;1,16 3;2,13 3;3,11 3;4,8 3;5,6 3;6,17 3;7,13 3;8,27 3;10,22 3;11,26 4;1,14 4;2,11 4;3,9 4;4,6
Figure 7. Subordinate clauses Carlotta
Vfinal target-deviant
2;2,4
20
1;11,12
18
1;10,8
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 1;8,28
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
Adult German is a V2-language and exhibits clause-final finite verbs in subordinate clauses: Heute habe ich Geburtstag ‘Today have I birthday’ – Ich habe dir gesagt, dass ich heute Geburtstag habe ‘I have you told that I today birthday have’. German exhibits a root/non-root-asymmetry with respect to finite verb placement. For the SVO languages like French and Italian, a root/non-root symmetry with respect to word order of finite verbs can be observed, i.e. the verb in subordinate clauses follows the subject, as in main clauses. Müller (1998) concludes her review with the observation that about half of the population of bilingual children have problems with finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses if they acquire a second native language which is an SVO language, i.e. French, Italian or English. Interestingly, two of the five children studied in the present article have considerable problems with finite verb placement in subordinate clauses: Alexander in the French-German study (cf. figure 6) and Carlotta in the Italian-German study (cf. figure 7). As can be seen from the figures (6) and (7), target-deviant verb placement ceases to appear in both children only at the age of 4, i.e. German verb placement in subordinate clauses can be regarded as a grammatical domain with late acquisition. For the other three children, there are either no problems at all, i.e. the placement of finite verbs in subordinates is ‘error-free’ or the development marginally shows root word order in subordinate clauses. This is shown in figures (8), (9) and (10) for the children Jan (German-Italian), Lukas (German-Italian) and Céline (German-French). Since we are dealing with longitudinal data, absence of data should be avoided as an argument for or against hypotheses concerning language development. Let us therefore concentrate on the children Alexander and Carlotta who exhibit problems in subordinate clauses.
Natascha Müller Absolute number
2;5,26 2;7,7
2;11,27 3;1,1 3;3,8 3;4,23 3;6,11 Age
3;7,22 3;9,15 3;10,27 4;0,14 4;2,25 4;4,6 4;5,17 4;7,5 4;9,16 4;10,27
Figure 8. Subordinate clauses: Jan
Vfinal
2;10,8
target-deviant
2;8,18
25
20
15
10
5
0 2;1,3
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
Absolute number
1;10,17 1;11,22
2;4,23 2;5,20 2;7,15 2;8,12 2;9,18 2;10,22 2;11,27 Age
3;1,30 3;3,2 3;4,7 3;5,8 3;6,13 3;7,15 3;8,17 3;9,20
3;10,17 3;11,22 4;1,20 4;3,14 4;4,12
Figure 9. Subordinate clauses: Lukas
Vfinal
2;3,6
target-deviant
2;1,3
14
1;9,13
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 1;7,12
Natascha Müller
Absolute number
2;6,21 2;8,2 2;8,29 2;10,5 2;11,3 Age
2;11,29 3;0,27 3;3,12 3;4,9 3;5,15 3;6,12 3;7,17 3;8,14 3;9,18
3;10,18 3;11,15
Figure 10. Subordinate clauses Céline
Vfinal
2;5,25
target-deviant
2;4,19
18
2;3,15
16
2;1,6
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0 2;0,9
3.2
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
The “errors”: The influence of the other language
In her review of the literature, Müller (1998) finds that the kind of “errors” in German subordinate clauses differs as a function of the second language. Whereas children with French or English as first languages use COMP (complementizer) – X (any constituent) – Vfin –Y (any constituent), dass heute habe ich Geburtstag ‘that today have I birthday’, children with Italian use COMP – Vfin – S – X – Y, dass habe ich heute Geburts tag ‘that have I today birthday’. This is also true for the two bilingual children studied here: Whereas Alexander makes use of 1.9% of VSX(Y) patterns in his German subordinate clauses (only 2 out of 104), Carlotta uses it to a high degree, 32% of her subordinate clauses showing exactly this pattern until the age of 3;7. All bilingual children use SVfinX in their subordinate clauses, dass ich habe heute Geburtstag ‘that I have today birthday’, i.e. this pattern occurs independently of the specific second language, French or Italian.2 A further important result of Müller’s review is that finite verb placement in the Romance language (or in English) is not problematic, i.e. we are dealing with an error-free grammatical domain in these languages. Before we turn to the discussion of the acquisition facts, we will introduce a new view of word order in subordinate clauses and the syntax–pragmatics interface.
3.3
Complementizers in French, Italian and German- adult and child grammar
In generative syntax and other frameworks, complementizers are generally assumed to form a constituent with the infinitival IP they are associated with, e.g. in the sentence Il est important de chanter ‘It is important de sing-inf.’, de is often analyzed as forming a constituent with chanter, since de requires an infinitival, and therefore is not compatible with a finite phrase: *Il est important de vous chantiez ‘It is important de you singsubjunc.’ (Kayne 1999: 41). The same can be proposed for Italian di which, like its French counterpart, is only compatible with an infinitival. Recently, Kayne (1999) has argued that the French and Italian prepositional complementizers de / di enter the derivation above the VP, that is, not as a sister to the IP they are associated with. The relation between complementizer and IP is expressed by movement of the (infinitival) IP to the specifier position of the complementizer. Subsequent movement of the complementizer to a head W, is followed by phrasal movement to Spec, Spec,W accounts for the observed word order in these languages. If prepositional complementizers do not form a constituent with the infinitival IP they are associated with, the following derivational steps are necessary for a sentence like Gianni ha tentato di cantare, ‘Gianni has tried di sing-inf ’: The infinitival IP cantare is merged with the main verb tentato, not with di. Di is subsequently merged with tentato cantare, the result being di tentato cantare. Di then attracts the infinitival IP cantare to its Spec, resulting in cantarei di tentato ti. Di further raises to an immediately higher head W, dij+W cantarei tj tentato ti. Di+W then attracts VP to its Spec, [tentato ti]k dij+W cantarei tj tk.
Natascha Müller
Gianni ha
WP [tentato t i] k
W' DiP
di j
cantare i
Di' dij
VP [ tentato cantare ] i k
Figure 11. Derivation of [...] tentato di cantare
Kayne (1999) advances several arguments for his analysis. The first type of argument relates to the nominal character of French and Italian infinitives. French de and Italian di require an infinitival, and they are not compatible with a finite phrase (Kayne 1999: 40f.). (10) Il est important de chanter It is important de sing-inf. (11) *Il est important de vous chantez It is important de you sing-subjunc. (12) Gianni dice di aver capito Gianni says di have-inf. understood (13) *Gianni dice di (lui) ha capito Gianni says di (he) has understood Both Romance languages have developed a complementizer for finite clauses, namely que and che. The same generalization extends to other prepositional complementizers, like pour and per in the Romance languages. They are restricted to infinitival clauses. If a finite clause is expressed, French uses pour que, Italian perché. The second type of argument in favor of the derivation in figure (11) relates to the observation that in French and Italian, infinitives do not occupy DP positions. Thus, despite the nominal character of French and Italian infinitives, they do not occupy ordinary DP positions. In conclusion, French and Italian infinitives have to be licensed in a special way, one way being to have them preceded by de / di, or, extending Kayne’s proposal, by other prepositional complementizers like pour / per. The new idea of Kayne’s approach is that the prepositional complementizers do not form a constituent with the infinitival IP they are associated with. As a consequence, the complementizer
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
is not part of the argument of the (main) verb, but enters the derivation subsequent to the merger of the infinitival IP and the main verb. Let us assume that Romance language children have the correct analysis of infinitival clauses from the beginning. If Kayne’s analysis is extended to pour / per, which is the first prepositional complementizer in child grammar (Müller 1993), and which emerges about 6 months before the first adult-like finite complementizers, we would have the derivation in figure (12) for a French child sentence: c’est pour dormir, ‘this is for to-sleep’. c'
WP [est t i ]k
W' pour j
PourP dormir i
Pour' pour j [est
dormir i ] k
Figure 12. Derivation of infinitival introduced by pour
This structure would conform to the adult system. Bilingual Romance-German children have been reported to use German für, the equivalent of pour / per as one of the first elements which introduces clauses (cf. Müller 1993). This is also the case for the two children of the present study who exhibit considerable problems with finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses:3 für setzen, ‘for to-sit’ (Carlotta, 2;7,13), für grattieren, ‘for to scratch’ (=kratzen, Alexander, 2;7,6). Since these German constructions are created by the children on the basis of their Romance language – the construction as such does not exist in German –, it seems plausible to extend the pour / per analysis to für in German. Thus, a child sentence like das is für einkaufen ‘this is for to-shop’ has the derivation in figure 13:
Natascha Müller
das
WP [ist t i]k
W' FürP
für j
einkaufen i
Für'
für j [ist
einkaufen i] k
Figure 13. Derivation of infinitival introduced by für
Kayne (1999) mentions the possibility that this kind of analysis extends to the real complementizers que / che in the Romance languages. Let us assume that this is indeed the case. We would like to exemplify this possibility with a French construction: Je sais que tu lis ce livre ‘I know that you read this book’. je
WP [sais t i] k
W'
que j
CP
IP[tu lis ce livre] i
C'
que j [sais IP [tu lis ce livre]i ] k Figure 14. que/che clauses: the Romance derivation
If children extend the analysis of pour / per clauses to für, it is plausible that they also use their analysis of subordinate clauses introduced by que / che for German subordinates. As a consequence, they would merge a finite clause with matrix word order with the matrix verb and subsequently insert the complementizer dass (cf. figure 15), thus the absence of sentence final placement of the finite verb in these children is predicted. In other words, there is a link between the first prepositional complementizer für
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
which is syntactically analyzed like French pour and Italian per, and the persistent problems with finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses: Children who exhibit problems in German subordinate clauses adopt a course to the complementizer system via using für with the same syntactic derivation as pour / per. Indeed, a syntactic derivation of the prepositional complementizer introducing infinitival clauses is extended to real complementizers, as is indicated by the observation that prepositional complementizers can also introduce finite clauses in the children’s grammar, e.g. für das macht musik, ‘for it makes music’ (Carlotta, 2;10,30), für die bahn kann, ‘for the train can (go there)’ (Alexander, 2;11,20).
ich
WP [weiß t i] k
W'
dass j IP[du
DassP
kannst nicht mitkommen]i
Dass'
dass j [weiß
IP[du
kannst nicht mitkommen]i]k
Figure 15. Derivation of finite subordinate clause in German with a Romance pour/peranalysis: *Ich weiß dass du kannst nicht mitkommen, ‘I know that you can not with-come’
Interestingly, the bilingual children have positive evidence for the Romance analysis of complementizers in German. German subordinate clauses are verb-final if they are introduced by a complementizer like dass.
ich weiß
CP dass
IP (head-final) du nicht mitkommen kannst
Figure 16. dass clauses: the German derivation
German subordinate clauses which are not introduced by any lexical element do not show clause-final placement of the finite verb, but main clause word order, as shown in (14) in contrast to (15).
Natascha Müller
(14) ich weiß, du kannst nicht mitkommen I know you can not with-come ‘I know you cannot join us.’ (15) ich weiß, dass du nicht mitkommen kannst I know that you not with-come can Thus, for a sentence without a lexical complementizer, the für-derivation would yield the correct analysis. In other words, the Romance syntactic derivation does not transfer “blindly” into child German, but is supported by positive evidence. ich
WP [weiß ti]k Øj
W' DassP
IP[du kannst nicht mitkommen] i
Dass'
Øj [weiß
IP[du kannst nicht mitkommen]i]k
Figure 17. Derivation of finite subordinate clause in German without lexical complementizer in terms of a Romance pour/per-analysis
One may object that we do not need dassP and WP for the derivation of such sentences. But since these non verb-final clauses have to be distinguished from reported speech (which becomes visible in spoken language from the type of pronoun used: mich fragst du willst du brot oder würstchen, ‘me ask you want you bread or sausages’ (reported speech) versus mich fragst du ob ich brot oder würstchen will, ‘me ask you if I bread or sausages want’), the functional projections may be necessary, but remain empty in the course of derivation. Spoken adult German also has a small class of elements which can introduce subordinate clauses with main clause word order, weil, ‘because’ and obwohl, ‘although’ among them: Ich bin wütend weil ich kann nicht mitkommen, ‘I am angry because I can not with-come’. The next construction which might be regarded as evidence for the Romance fürderivation in German child grammar is the conditional. Rehbein (1992) shows that the German conditional has two possible realizations. Either as a wenn... dann, if... then’ construction, in which wenn would trigger the verb-final pattern typical of German subordinate clauses, or an alternative with a finite verb in clause-initial position: hätte ich im Lotto gespielt, dann hätte ich diesmal bestimmt gewonnen, ‘had I in the lot-
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
tery played, then would I this time for sure won’. Thus, the verb-final pattern competes with non-verb-final alternatives. These alternatives might constitute positive evidence for the Romance für-derivation applied to German complementizers in general. In section 3.2 we have mentioned that the Romance languages, French and Italian, have a slightly different effect on finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses. Whereas Alexander (French-German) did not use VSX(Y) patterns in his German subordinate clauses, Carlotta uses this pattern in about one third of her subordinate clauses. It is not the purpose of the present article to investigate the syntactic derivations for the different word orders. Notice, however, that those languages, which in bilingual combinations regulate that German subordinate clauses are COMP-Vfin-S-X, e.g. Italian, are characterized by the absence of that-t-effects. In turn, language combinations which exclude this pattern, like French, manifest that-t-effects.4 Müller (2005) argues that this difference explains word orders which are specific to the language combinations. We have mentioned the kind of errors bilingual children make in German subordinate clauses, because we wanted to give further evidence for the assumption that we are dealing with cross-linguistic influence, the proof being that a certain language combination matters for a certain kind of error to occur. Let us now turn to the syntax–pragmatics interface, and approach the question why the Romance analysis is extented to German subordinate clauses.
3.4
The syntax–pragmatics interface
In the Principles & Parameters framework and in early work in Minimalism (Chomsky 1995), the syntactic derivation could interface with the interpretive systems only at one point, which was called Spell Out. This operation strips the phonological features off the lexical items and maps them onto a structure called Phonetic Form, which in turn interfaces with the auditory-perceptual system. Spell Out is also the earliest point at which, given that all uninterpretable features are checked off, a structure called Logical Form can be assumed, which in turn interfaces with the conceptual-intentional system. More recently, some researchers like Epstein, Groat, Kawashima and Kitahara (1998) and López (2003) have challenged the view that interfacing with the interpretive systems must wait until the derivation is finished. Epstein et al. (1998) provide the most radical approach in the sense of assuming that the interpretive systems interface invasively with the syntactic derivation after every application of Merge and Move. As a result, there are no PF or LF structures. López (2003), building on recent proposals by Chomsky (2000, 2001) and Uriagereka (1999), defends a more moderate view on the invasiveness of the interpretive systems. He assumes that the derivation spells-out at particular points called phases. More specifically, a phase is headed by the light verb v or by C. These represent the two points at which the derivation can be handed over to the interpretive systems, once vP / CP is being derived. Once a phase is spelled-out, it is opaque. The only exception to this is the edge of the phase, which is defined as the head of the phase and its Specs.
Natascha Müller
It is the more moderate framework which we will adopt in this article. In particular, we are interested in the point CP at which López allows the syntactic derivation to interface with pragmatics, “the interpretive module that deals with focus/ presupposition structures, contrast, and possibly other notions […]” (López 2003: 195). In his approach, pragmatic values – like presupposition and contrast – are regarded as features which are assigned to constituents in the syntactic component and remain as parts of the feature matrix of these constituents. In other words, pragmatics can assign features to constituents in the CHL (computational system for human language) which were absent in the lexical array. The pragmatic component can thus inspect a syntactic structure and attach a (pragmatic) feature to it. Pragmatics can invade the computational system only at two points in the derivation, when the vP / CP phase is being completed. What pragmatic value(s) could be involved in subordinate clauses? Let us exemplify the relevance of pragmatic values by using the example of conditionals. If encoded in a wenn... dann construction, or in the Romance equivalent construction with si / se, the feature “conditional” is introduced via the lexical array of wenn, si, and se. However, German as well as the Romance languages exhibit an alternative construction for which it would be difficult to imagine a feature “conditional” in the lexical array of one element in the clause. This is the following construction hätte ich im Lotto gespielt, dann hätte ich diesmal bestimmt gewonnen which exists in French as a construction with a clause-initial finite verb as well as aurais-je le temps.... ‘had-I the time...’.5 In this case it is necessary to assign features to constituents which are absent in the lexical array.6 López (2003: 204) discusses the case of clitics which spell out the pragmatic feature “presupposition” or “[p]”. The feature [+p] is assigned to the EPP of v. Pragmatics can “invade CHL and assigns [+p] only after the vP phase is completed.” Spec,v also becomes [+p] since this specifier is licensed by an EPP with a [+p] feature. If it is plausible to assume that in case of conditionals the whole sentence containing the verb in the conditional is marked as such, it would be the functional category C or FürP/DassP in Kayne’s analysis, which receives this feature. Pragmatics would have to assign this feature to C/Dass/Für (or the EPP of C/Dass/Für) and the specifier of C/Dass/Für would have the same feature since it is licensed by an EPP with a feature “conditional”. In other words, we would like to suggest that there are two possibilities for features to enter the derivation: either via the lexical array or via pragmatics.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
ich
WP
schrie
W' wenn
CP
ich war baby
C' C+EPP=wenn schrie
[+temporal]
ich war baby
'I cried when I was a baby'
Figure 18. Derivation of a German subordinate clause with [+temporal] inserted via pragmatics
Let us turn to child grammar. Research on early child language has shown that pragmatics, apart from its identifying function, can also license empty constituents (Müller and Hulk 2001). If this is plausible, this would have the following consequences for the grammatical domain of subordinate clauses. We would predict that children will first choose the possibility for features to enter the derivation via pragmatics, and only later study the lexical array in more detail. In fact, researchers find that young children, monolingual and bilingual, start to produce subordinate clauses long before they use complementizers; the position of the complementizer in the target language either remains empty in child language (Müller 1993: sitz da un pa auf papa komm nich (=sitzt da und passt auf dass der Papa nicht kommt), ‘sit there and pay-attention daddy comes not’) or is filled with a dummy complementizer, like là, ‘there’ (Müller 1993: demander maman là il est (=demander maman où il est), ‘ask mummy there it is’). This view would contradict learning models which suppose that lexical learning is the driving force in syntactic development. If the features needed for subordinates are introduced into syntax via pragmatics, or put differently, if the conjunction does not encode the respective features, it is the whole clause which marks the features. The (adult) Romance analysis of subordinates nicely reflects this relation between syntax and pragmatics. In Romance pour / per-clauses, the subordinate clause is merged with the matrix verb and later moved into the functional projection which hosts pour / per. As a consequence of the application of the Romance analysis to German subordinates, bilingual children use root word order with finite verbs in subordinate clauses. Unlike adult German, child language complementizers are not analyzed as elements inserted into a syntactic position where, in ma-
Natascha Müller
trix clauses, the finite verb checks off finiteness. A German-French or German-Italian bilingual child will thus ignore the importance of the complementizer and assume a symmetric analysis of root and non-root clauses due to the insertion of features needed for subordination via pragmatics. Children might opt for invasive pragmatics even in cases for which the feature of subordinate clauses, conditional, temporal, causal, etc. is encoded in the lexical array of a conjunction in adult grammar. A child sentence with an invasively introduced feature [+temporal] would have the structure in figure (18), independently of whether a conjunction is present or not. Müller (1993) shows that the bilingual children who have problems with finite verb placement in German subordinate clauses acquire the target-like verb-final order with each conjunction separately. In other words, the children have to analyze and acquire the features for subordination with each lexical array. The last conjunctions to be integrated into the target-like verb-final pattern are the semantically empty complementizers dass, ‘that’ and ob, ‘if/whether’. The way children revise their analysis of German subordinate clauses may be interpreted as a further indication that the kind of cross-linguistic influence we are facing with finite verb placement in German subordinates is what is defined as transfer in section 1.3. What prediction would follow from the approach outlined here? The prediction would be that monolingual children indeed have problems with those subordinate clauses for which the adult language offers an alternative with features introduced invasively via pragmatics. These are conditionals. Stern & Stern (1928) reported these problems in conditionals in the German monolingual children they studied: wenn ihr würdet immerfort in Berlin geblieben sein, so würdet ihr immerfort Berliner gewesen sein, ‘if you would always in Berlin stayed to-be, then would you always people-fromBerlin been to-be’. Finally, let us come back to the two conditions for cross-linguistic influence to occur. To reiterate, the two conditions presented in section 1.1 were: (a) The vulnerable grammatical phenomenon is an interface properties, e.g., a grammatical property located at the interface between syntax and pragmatics; (b) The surface strings of the two languages are similar for the expression of the vulnerable grammatical phenomenon. We have already mentioned that adult German exhibits subordinate clauses with root word order. These clauses might lead the children into generalizing the Romance analysis onto German subordinates. The first condition is also fulfilled since the grammatical domain studied represents an interface property. As discussed in section 1.1, it is also true for subordinates that pragmatics and syntax interact in such a way that pragmatic factors restrict the possibilities offered by the syntactic system. In section 3.3 we have mentioned the possibility that (adult) German subordinate clauses with root word order can be analyzed à la Kayne, as Romance subordinates in general. If this assumption turns out to be correct, German would be characterized by a non-isomorphic interplay between syntax and pragmatics: If the features needed for subordination are inserted via pragmatics, the finite verb of the subordinate must check off these features (residually, this option exists for Romance conditionals). If the features
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
needed for subordination are inserted via the lexical array of the complementizer, it is the complementizer which guarantees that the construction is well-formed. It is the role of pragmatics which restricts the possibilities offered by the syntactic system. Under the assumption that children find this kind of interaction complex, they will opt for the Romance analysis of German subordinates which minimizes interaction between syntax and pragmatics. Under the Romance analysis, nothing follows for syntax if features for subordination are inserted via the lexical array of complementizers, or via pragmatics. What other consequences follow from the analysis presented here? Cantone (2004) studies code-switching in simultaneous bilingual Italian-German children from age 2;6 to 5. Her results show that children do mix between the functional head C and its complement: (16) perché ihr seid böse because you are bad (17) pecché ich war kleiner =perché because I was younger (18)
(Lu, 3;11,2, Italian recording) (Lu, 4;0,5, Italian recording)
wir sind aus- perché wir sind aus- aus- aus- auf deutsch-auf deutschland We are from – because we are from- from- from in German- in Germany (Ja, 3;1,1, German recording)
(19) hai visto che geht leicht have(you) seen that (it) goes easy
(Lu, 3;4,25, Italian context)
(20) guarda che war hier Look that (it) was here
(Lu, 3;10,3, Italian context)
Cantone hypothesizes that the language of the complementizer determines the word order of its complement. Subordinate clauses are a good testing ground for the hypothesis since German subordinate clauses are verb-final, whereas Italian subordinates are SVO. Since German weil (‘because’)-clauses can be non-verb-final in spoken language, (16) – (18) do not constitute clear examples. (19) and (20), however, might show that an Italian complementizer determines Italian word order in the subordinate clause, although the clause is made up of German lexical items. With German word order, the child should have said hai visto che leicht geht and guarda che hier war. Furthermore, in these examples the German finite verb in the subordinate clause is not accompanied by an overt subject, a possibility characteristic of Italian, not of German, given that Italian is a null-subject language. Cantone specifies that if the complementizer is Italian, then the structure below the functional head C is Italian, too, independent of whether its syntactic positions are filled with Italian or with German elements. In the examples, Italian C can be combined with an underlying structure which contains a null-subject. Under the approach of subordinates presented here, the conclusion that the language of the complementizer determiners word order in the subordinate clause fol-
Natascha Müller
lows rather naturally. If the complementizer is Romance, the Romance analysis will apply: It merges the subordinate with the matrix verb first and later moves the subordinate into the functional projection which hosts the complementizer. Romance word order will result, which is corroborated by the data. The code-switching data thus lend support to the analysis presented here.
3.5
A note on language dominance
In what follows, we would like to exclude the possibility that language dominance is the driving factor for why the children Alexander and Carlotta extend the Romance analysis of subordinates to German. We have illustrated the MLU values of the two children. For Alexander, we could argue that since his German is weaker than his French, he will try the Romance option for German. However, notice that this argument does not generalize to Carlotta’s case. She can be considered as a balanced bilingual, nevertheless, she opts for the Romance analysis. What about the children Céline, Jan and Lukas? Lukas can be compared with Carlotta, at least until the age of 3;3. In both children, the MLUs of both languages nearly match. Jan and, to a greater extent, Céline have a dominant language, namely German. We may speculate that those children who do not show problems in subordinate clauses are children who develop German as a dominant language. Schmitz (2004), analyzing dative case errors in the children Alexander, Céline, Lukas and Carlotta comes to this result, namely that only those children who develop German as a dominant language reach the target stage as quickly as children who are balanced for grammatical domains which are vulnerable for cross-linguistic influence. Notice, however, that Lukas can be considered a balanced bilingual child until the age of 3;3, the age span during which he very rarely produces verb placement errors in subordinate clauses. Under the assumed relation between cross-linguistic influence and language dominance, we would wrongly predict that he should pattern like Carlotta. In conclusion, the balance between the two languages, although an interesting research area as such, does not explain why bilingual children show signs of cross-linguistic influence in their development of verb placement patterns in German subordinate clauses.
4. Conclusion The present investigation has attempted to show that some bilingual children may use a derivation of language A for language B as well. This was the case since language B contained two constructions of which one was the common construction in language A. A further important factor which comes into play is the syntax–pragmatics interface. Children tend to minimize the interaction between pragmatics and syntax if they interact in a way that pragmatic factors restrict the possibilities offered by the syntactic system.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
The remaining problem is why only half of the bilingual population exhibit the kind of developmental path outlined here. We have no solution to offer for the children who do not show signs of cross-linguistic influence. What seems plausible, when looking at the differing degree of balance of the children is that language dominance can be excluded as a reason for absence / presence of language influence.
Notes 1. The project is financed by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft and directed by the present author at Bergische Universität Wuppertal ([email protected]). For further details cf. Müller, Cantone, Kupisch and Schmitz (2002), Müller, Kupisch, Schmitz and Cantone (2006) and Cantone, Kupisch, Müller and Schmitz (2006). 2. Müller (1998) also presents results from monolingual German children on the development of finite verb placement in subordinates. One reviewer formulates the prediction that monolingual German children would have similar problems with verb placement in subordinate clauses as bilinguals in German. One could also predict that there would be a bilingual-monolingual difference in the magnitude of the problem, with Romance-German bilinguals producing significantly more deviant verb placements than monolinguals because of the strengthening effect of the Romance language. It is not possible to discuss this issue in more depth, since the situation is complex. Monolingual children from Northern parts of Germany (the same region as the bilingual children studied here) acquire finite verb placement without error. They use finite verbs clause-finally even at a time when they have not acquired complementizers yet. Monolingual children from Southern parts of German take some time to acquire the correct verb placement in subordinates; this may be the case, because their input contains evidence for non-V-final placement of finite verbs with a considerable amount of lexical elements introducing subordinate clauses. Müller (1998) argues that these monolingual German children have an input in German which the Italian-German bilingual children have in the Romance language, favoring COMP – Vfin – S – X – Y. 3. Für does not figure among the prepositions which introduce infinitival clauses in standard German. Instead, the particle zu is used in German infinitival constructions. für-infinitives are in use in the Ruhr-area: 360 Eier für mitten Auto fahrn ‘360 eggs for with-the car drive’ (Gawlitzek-Maiwald 1997:35). The preposition für replaces um in für-infinitives, the common preposition to introduce infinitival clauses; the infinitival particle zu is often not realized. für-infinitives allow for the realization of the subject, which is otherwise impossible in infinitivals (Voyles 1983, mentioned in Gawlitzek-Maiwald 1997:35): *Menschen zu irren ist möglich ‘People to err is possible’ versus Für Menschen zu irren ist möglich ‘For people to err is possible’. The bilingual children investigated in the present study have been raised in the Northern parts of Germany; they did not have für-infinitives in their input. 4. French and Italian differ with respect to the presence / absence of the so-called that-t-effect: In French, it is impossible to move the subject of an embedded clauses into the front position of the main clause, thus the ungrammaticality of Qui crois-tu que viendras ‘who think you that will-come’. The sentence is grammatical in Italian Chi credi che verrà. Most researchers assume that fronted subjects cannot be moved in one step if two clauses are involved, but that they have
Natascha Müller to land in the specifier position of the functional projection which hosts the complementizer, CP. We can interpret the examples in the sense that the French complementizer que does not license a position preceding it which can host the subject (Bošković & Lasnik 2003 assume that such a head does not have an EPP (Extended Projection Principle) feature (guaranteeing that a specifier will be projected) and therefore will not project a specifier position) whereas Italian che does. The example is ungrammatical because the subject, in order to be fronted, would have to move in one step, which is impossible though *Quii crois tu que ti viendras. An alternative account would be to analyze the trace following the complementizer que as the offending trace: *Quii crois tu ti que ti viendras. Rizzi (1990) has argued on the basis of minimality that the complementizer que does not carry agreement features and therefore cannot properly govern the subject trace, the result being an ungrammatical sentence. French qui and Italian che carry agreement feature, explaining the grammaticality of Qui crois tu qui viendras and Chi credi che verrà. “If Agr is selected for the head of Comp, it must be coindexed with its specifier; […] here the subject trace is properly head-governed by Agr in the head of Comp and antecedent-governed by the specifier of Comp.” (Rizzi 1990:52f.) He summarizes that “a C0 endowed with such features is an intrinsic governor.” (Rizzi 1990:122) Interestingly, Rizzi (1997) has noted that the that-t-effect can also be voided if a TopP (Topic Phrase) intervenes between the position which hosts the complementizer (Force in his approach) and the functional projection which hosts the trace of the fronted subject (Fin in his approach): Who did Leslie say that *(for all intents and purposes) was the mayor of the city? 5. In French, these constructions belong to the register of written language. It would be interesting to study the occurrence of conditionals in the German input of the children. 6. One reviewer remarks that the finite verb is morphologically marked for the conjunctive (II). This observation generalizes to the French example. Notice however that the morphological marking on the verb could not explain the word order. The feature “conditional” would be needed independently of the morphological marking of the finite verb. 7. One reviewer suggests that the variation among children is hard to accommodate with the presented account, given that the reinforcing effect from the Romance language is present in all children. Recent studies in the literature have suggested that the bilingual child’s problem may be related to the processing resources necessary to integrate syntactic and pragmatic knowledge (see Avrutin 1999). The processing domain is open to developmental effects, and therefore to inter-subject variation. The nature of the data, spontaneous production data, makes it impossible to disentangle a representational and a processing approach. Notice however, that a processing approach could not predict the occurrence of different target-deviant word orders, depending on the language combination. In fact, the presence of COMP-Vfin-S-X in German subordinates of German-Italian children and its absence in French-German children reinforces the competence-driven approach presented here.
References Avrutin, S. 1999. Development of the Syntax-Discourse Interface. Dordrecht: Kluwer. Bernardini Röst, P. 2001. Lo squilibrio nell’acquisizione di due lingue nell’infanzia: Indagine longitudinale sullo sviluppo della sintassi nominale. Lund : Licentiatavhandling, University of Lund.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
Bošković, Z. and Lasnik, H. 2003. On the distribution of null complementizers. Linguistic Inquiry 34(4): 527–546. Cantone, K. 2004. Code-Switching in Bilingual Children. PhD dissertation, University of Hamburg. Cantone, K., Kupisch, T., Müller, N; and Schmitz, K. 2006. Redefining language dominance in bilingual children. Submitted Chomsky, N. 1981. Lectures on Government and Binding. The Pisa lectures. Foris: Dordrecht. Chomsky, N. 1995. The Minimalist Program. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press. Chomsky, N. 2000. Minimalist inquiries: The framework. In Step by Step: Essays on minimalist syntax in honor of Howard Lasnik, R. Martin, D. Michaels and J. Uriagereka (eds), 89–156. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press. Chomsky, N. 2001. Derivation by phase. In Ken Hale: A life in language, M. Kenstowicz (ed.), 1–52. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press. Clahsen, H. 1982. Spracherwerb in der Kindheit. Eine Untersuchung zur Entwicklung der Syntax bei Kleinkindern. Tübingen: Narr Cordes, J. 2001. Zum unausgewogenen doppelten Erstspracherwerb eines deutsch-französisch aufwachsenden Kindes: Eine empirische Untersuchung. MA thesis, University of Hamburg. Döpke, S. 1992. One Parent, One Language: An interactional approach. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Epstein, S., Groat E., Kawashima R., and Kitahara H. 1998. A Derivational Approach to Syntactic Relations. Oxford: OUP. Gawlitzek-Maiwald, I. 1997. Der monolinguale und bilinguale Erwerb von Infinitivkonstruktionen. Ein Vergleich von Deutsch und Englisch. Tübingen: Niemeyer. Gawlitzek-Maiwald, I. and Tracy, R. 1996. Bilingual bootstrapping. Linguistics 34: 901–926. Genesee, F. 1989. Early bilingual development: One language or two? Journal of Child Language 16: 161–179. Genesee, F., Nicoladis, E. and Paradis, J. 1995. Language differentiation in early bilingual development. Journal of Child Language 22: 611–631. Herkenrath, A., Karakoç, B. and Rehbein, J. 2003. Interrogative elements as subordinators in Turkish. In (In)vulnerable Domains in Multilingualism, N. Müller (ed.), 221–269. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Hulk, A. 1997. The acquisition of French object pronouns by a Dutch/French bilingual child. In Language Acquisition: Knowledge, representation and processing. Proceedings of the GALA ‘97 Conference on Language Acquisition, A. Sorace A., C. Heycock and R. Shillcock (eds), 521–526. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh Press. Hulk, A. and Müller, N. 2000. Crosslinguistic influence at the interface between syntax and pragmatics. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 3(3): 227–244. Kayne, R. 1999. Prepositional complementizers as attractors. Probus 11: 39–73. Kupisch, T. 2004. The Acquisition of Determiners in Bilingual German-Italian and GermanFrench Children. PhD dissertation, University of Hamburg. Kupisch, T., Müller, N. and Cantone K. 2002. Gender in monolingual and bilingual first language acquisition: Comparing Italian and French. Lingue e Linguaggio 1: 107–149. Lindholm, K. J. and Padilla A. M. 1978. Language mixing in bilingual children. Journal of Child Language 5: 327–335 Loconte, A. 2001. Zur Sprachdominanz bei bilingual deutsch-italienischen Kindern. MA thesis, University of Hamburg. López, L. 2003. Steps for a well-adjusted dislocation. Studia Linguistica 57(3): 193–231
Natascha Müller Meisel, J. M. 1989. Early differentiation of languages in bilingual children. In Bilingualism across the Lifespan: Aspects of acquisition, maturity, and loss, K. Hyltenstam and L. Obler (eds), 13–40. Cambridge: CUP. Meisel, J. M. (ed.) 1994. Bilingual First Language Acquisition: German and French. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Müller, N. 1993. Komplexe Sätze. Der Erwerb von COMP und von Wortstellungsmustern bei bilingualen Kindern (Französisch/Deutsch). Tübingen: Narr. Müller, N. 1994. Parameters cannot be reset: Evidence from the development of COMP. In Bilingual First Language Acquisition. French and German grammatical development, J.M. Meisel (ed.), 235:269, Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Müller, N. 1998. Transfer in bilingual first language acquisition. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 1(3): 151–171. Müller, N. 2005. SELECT und funktionale Kategorien im bilingualen Erstspracherwerb: Französisch, Italienisch und Deutsch im Vergleich. Paper presented at Hamburg University. Müller, N., Cantone, K., Kupisch, T. and Schmitz, K. 2002. Zum Spracheneinfluss im bilingualen Erstspracherwerb: Italienisch – Deutsch. Linguistische Berichte 190: 157–206. Müller, N. and Hulk, A. 2000. Crosslinguistic influence in bilingual children: Object omissions and root infinitives. In Proceedings of the 24th Annual Boston University Conference on Language Development, C. Howell, S.A. Fish and T. Keith-Lucas (eds), 546–557. Somerville MA: Cascadilla. Müller, N. and Hulk, A. 2001. Crosslinguistic influence in bilingual language acquisition: Italian and French as recipient languages. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition 4(1): 1–21. Müller, N. and Kupisch, T. 2003. Zum simultanen Erwerb des Deutschen und des Französischen bei (un)ausgeglichen bilingualen Kindern. Vox Romanica 62: 145–169. Müller, N., Kupisch, T., Schmitz, K. and Cantone, K. 2006. Einführung in die Mehrsprachigkeitsforschung. Deutsch, Französisch, Italienisch. Tübingen: Narr. Petersen J. 1988. Word-internal code-switching constraints in a bilingual child‘s grammar. Linguistics 26: 479–493. Pillunat, A., Schmitz, K. and Müller, N. 2006. Die Schnittstelle Syntax-Pragmatik: Subjektauslassungen bei bilingual deutsch-französisch aufwachsenden Kindern. Zeitschrift für Literaturwissenschaft und Linguistik 143, 7–24. Rehbein, J. 1992. Zur Wortstellung im komplexen deutschen Satz. In Deutsche Syntax. Ansichten und Aussichten, Hoffman L. (ed.), 523–574. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter. Rizzi L. 1990. Relativized Minimality. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press. Rizzi L. 1997. The fine structure of the left periphery. In Elements of Grammar. Handbook in generative syntax, L. Haegeman (ed.), 281–337.Dordrecht: Kluwer. Ronjat, J. 1913. Le développement du langage observé chez un enfant bilingue. Paris: Champion. Schlyter, S. 1993. The weaker language in bilingual Swedish-French children. In Progression and Regression in Language, Hyltenstam K. and Viberg A. (eds), 289–308. Cambridge: CUP. Schmitz, K. 2004. Erwerb der Verben mit zwei Objekten durch bilingual deutsch/französisch und deutsch/italienisch aufwachsende Kinder. Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Hamburg. Stern, C. and Stern W. 1928. Die Kindersprache, neu abgedruckt 1975. Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. Taeschner, T. 1983. The Sun is Feminine: A Study of Language Acquisition in Bilingual Children. Berlin: Springer. Tracy, R. 1995. Child Languages in Contact: Bilingual Language Acquisition in Early Childhood. Habilitationsschrift: University of Tübingen.
Some notes on the syntax–pragmatics interface in bilingual children
Uriagereka, J. 1995. Aspects of the syntax of clitic placement in Western Romance. Linguistic Inquiry 26 (1): 79–124. Voyles, J. 1983. Ansätze zu einer deutschen Grammatik. Göppingen: Kümmerle.
section 2
Pronouns, topics and subjects
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in popular 16th-18th century Greek narratives A synchronic and diachronic perspective Chrystalla A. Thoma University of Hamburg and Berlitz International, Costa Rica
The phenomenon of variation in weak object pronoun placement in Early Modern Greek has been the object of a number of studies. This paper presents some results from a quantitative and qualitative analysis of the phenomenon based on a varied corpus. The perspective taken is functional, focusing mainly on Talmy Givón’s model of referential cohesion in narrative discourse. The findings reveal a consistent pattern of variation that is statistically significant, and they provide a plausible explanation both for a functional distribution as well as the historical change leading to today’s relatively stable patterns.1
1. Introduction In the 16th-18th centuries (with few and sometimes controversial earlier cases) we find increased production of ‘low’ narrative texts, i.e. texts written in a popular, oral-like register in a language that is very similar to Modern Greek (cf. Eideneier 1999). Here ‘low’ is seen as opposed to ‘high’, a written register which attempted to emulate ancient Greek of the Classical and sometimes even of the Homeric period (cf. Toufexis in prep.). The Greek of the 16th-18th centuries is referred to as “Early Modern Greek”2 and this is the term we shall be using throughout this paper. In the ‘low’ narrative texts of our corpus we find great variation in the placement of unstressed, object pronouns before and after the verbal phrase. This ample variation is found in certain texts of the previous period as well (Late Medieval Greek) and has been the object of a number of studies. To date, no conclusive solution has been offered to the problem of possible rules, patterns or functions of the variation. Furthermore, most studies have concentrated on data from the earlier period, mostly poetic in nature, since available ‘low’ prose texts of that time are not very common.
Chrystalla A. Thoma
Our aim with this study is to concentrate on the phenomenon in Early Modern Greek, offering new data and a new perspective to the ongoing discussion. We claim that in order to understand the diachronic mechanisms of language change we need to give more attention to this (immediately intermediate) stage of the language between Late Medieval and Modern Greek. We have little data as to the linguistic situation of this time,3 a situation partly amended through this paper. Hereby we present a quantitative and qualitative analysis of the phenomenon in declarative finite clauses in a corpus comprising new texts4 which we tested with statistical methods. The results were compared to the Escorial Digenis Akritis of the Late Medieval period, the text on which Mackridge (see below) based his pioneer study of the phenomenon. A second important contribution of this study is that it offers a first functional explanation to the phenomenon according to Givón’s Syntax ([1990] 2001). With this study we are able to offer evidence for the distribution and function of the placement of the clitic5 object pronoun in Early Modern Greek in a synchronic analysis, but also a diachronic perspective on the development of its placement and function. We believe that our study complements other studies on the topic discussed below.
2. State of the art The variable placement of the clitic object pronoun in Early Modern Greek narratives has received the attention of a number of scholars who investigated it by means of different methods. Mackridge (1993, 2000) was the first one to formulate rules for the phenomenon concentrating on texts from the 11th to the 15th centuries. Pappas (2001, 2004a, b) was the first to undertake a quantitative analysis of the phenomenon on a large scale and to challenge certain claims concerning the phenomenon in Late Medieval Greek. He focussed on texts from the 12th-16th centuries, unfortunately poetic texts,6 and in one occasion also compared them to data (from both poetic and prose texts) from the 17th century. Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2001, 2004) approach the problem from the point of view of dialect groups of Greek and maintain that Late Medieval Greek appears to be a union of type A dialect syntax (such as Greek Cypriot, generally postverbal clitic placement except with focalized elements) and Type B/C dialect syntax (such as Pontic and Western dialects). Philippaki-Warburton (1995) and Horrocks (1990, 1997) focus on the generative rules governing clitic placement in Late Medieval Greek, therefore we shall not discuss their work here (for a critical view see Pappas 2004a: 93–99). Although Rollo (1989) was the first scholar to write about the phenomenon under study here, noting a similarity between Italian and Greek in this respect, we shall only mention his work very briefly for reasons made explicit in the following lines: Rollo was apparently content with merely offering a list of isolated examples from Early Modern Greek in which the clitic object pronoun appears in preverbal position (OV) and the Greek Cypriot dialect in which just the opposite happens (VO). Neither is any attempt made to offer any explanation as to the possible syntactic or functional rules
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
governing its placement, nor are preverbal object pronouns (OV) examined at all (cf. also Pappas 2004a: 31).7 His work is considered to be pioneer; nevertheless, the topic has since seen a lot of development and analysis from the scholars mentioned above to whom we turn our attention below.
2.1
The beginning: Mackridge (1993, 2000)
Mackridge mentions that he drew his inspiration from a book by Newton (1972) on the Greek Cypriot dialect which prompted him to formulate rules for the Early Modern Greek clitic object pronoun placement.8 His belief was that the rules followed in medieval prose texts we have from Cyprus (mainly Makhairas’s Chronicle), as well as in the modern dialect of Cyprus, are the same as in Early Modern Greek. He proposed that, until the 15th century, texts follow strict rules of clitic placement, something which they somehow stop doing later.9 Our intention is to investigate our data keeping in mind Mackridge’s rules, which were formulated for texts older than the ones under analysis here, in order to see whether they still apply to Early Modern Greek clitic placement variation. As most studies take these rules as their starting point and as there is no other existing set of rules for the phenomenon, we shall largely base the categorisation of our data on them. Our aim is to offer a quantitative and qualitative analysis in search of consistent use patterns of the variable position of clitic object pronouns in Early Modern Greek. However, we also examine the text Mackridge analyses (the Digenis Akritis verse epic, the Escorial version) in order to compare our results with a text of the Late Medieval period in search of similarities and differences. Concerning the Greek Cypriot dialect (in the Late Medieval period as well as today), we, along with other scholars (discussed below), disagree that the rules concerning the phenomenon in question are the same as in Late Medieval or Early Modern Greek. Greek Cypriot represents in all probability an earlier stage in language, also in the domain of unstressed object pronoun placement (cf. also Condoravdi/Kiparsky 2001,10 see also Pappas 2004a: 125) from which Standard Medieval Greek began diverging already at the time the Escorial Digenis Akritis epic was produced (see Discussion below). In Cypriot Greek, unstressed object pronouns are preverbal only in cases of clearly contrastive topics such as finite declarative clauses with strong subject pronouns or focalised NPs, objects and adverbs, or in cases of negation, interrogative, subordination and the subjunctive. If we accept that the Escorial Digenis Akritis indeed originated in the 12th century, then the divergence must have taken place even before that time. We do not wish to reproduce here the list of rules proposed by Mackridge as governing the placement of unstressed object pronouns in Late Medieval Greek (Mackridge 1993: 325). Let us just mention that according to him, postverbal is the default word order, with the verb usually at clause-initial position and following certain conjunctions and complementizers, as well as when preceded by an object to which the unstressed pronoun refers (object is fronted and the pronoun serves a doubling func-
Chrystalla A. Thoma
tion). The order is postverbal with certain elements such as the subjunctive, concessive and future particles να (na), ας (as), θα (tha), the negative particles μη (mi), μηδέν (miden), ουδέν (ouden), δεν (den) ‘not’, interrogative pronouns or adverbs, and semantically and syntactically focalised words or phrases (non-temporal adverbs, nouns or adjectives in an object noun phrase, subject or object complements), while the placement remains variable after subjects or temporal adverbs. Interestingly enough, Mackridge notes that the Escorial Digenis Akritis is the only text that consistently follows the rules.11 This of course poses intriguing questions as to the absolute force of these rules. Since we take a variationist approach to language, we propose that variation is to be expected in language and that, as we discuss below, variation can have a functional role which, we believe, it already played in Late Medieval Greek.
2.2
The quantitative dimension: Pappas
Pappas (2001, 2004a,b) gives a quantitative analysis with the purpose of re-examining and describing the phenomenon and adding a criticism to some previous proposals. Unfortunately Pappas not only uses mainly poetic works due to difficulties in finding prose texts of the period he examines (12th to 16th centuries), admittedly a problem if one wants to say something about the language of the period (cf. also Chila-Markopoulou 2004), but also editions that, to a great extent, are outdated or contain major editorial changes.12 Pappas offers the only statistical analysis of the phenomenon so far. He finds no statistical difference between fronted and focussed elements in determining clitic pronoun placement and remarks that it is in fact impossible in the texts under study to effectively tell them apart.13 Furthermore, in his statistical analysis, he finds no significant difference between the factors “preverbal subject” and “fronted temporal adverb”, possible factors influencing word order proposed by Mackridge (1993). He however finds a tendency for OV with preverbal subjects, which he sees as an epiphenomenon of metrical constraints, a problem particular to poetic discourse and a plausible explanation in view of the corpus he uses. In general, though, he tends to reaffirm Mackridge’s rules, although he states that they point to “poetic convention”, being therefore “stylistic” and not rules of the language as such; a claim however that he has not been able to prove (cf. again Chila-Markopoulou 2004).
2.3
Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2001, 2004)
Condoravdi and Kiparsky examine the phenomenon under study in the generative grammar framework. They focus on a theory of Greek dialects and their differences which, as they propose, explain the particularities of Late Medieval Greek. As mentioned above, they propose that Late Medieval Greek is the result of a mixture of type A and type B/C dialects. We see absolutely no contradiction between their study and
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
ours; indeed, we believe that they complement each other very well, as do the findings of the other studies mentioned above. Condoravdi and Kiparsky endorse the view that preverbal placement of the unstressed object pronoun depends on fronted focalized elements,14 a view not shared by Pappas as we have mentioned above. Indeed, as Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2004: 167) go on to mention, “a constituent may be focussed if the speaker or writer thinks of it as contributing a particularly noteworthy or surprising piece of information, or wishes to represent it as such, but in the absence of enough syntactic and intonational cues one would have to be a mind-reader to predict when that is the case.” The contexts in which the reading is focussed beyond any doubt are not very common in written texts.
3. Type of data and methodology For this study we have opted for the analysis of 3rd person clitic object pronouns. We only analysed narrative parts, to the exclusion of dialogue, examining only finite declarative clauses in order to restrict our analysis. No particular attention was paid to the already relatively fixed word order in the cases of: OV: (δ)εν (den) ‘not’, temporal clauses, ότι (oti) ‘that’ and διότι (dioti) ‘because’, the relative pronoun όστις (ostis) ‘who’, and all subjunctive forms such as ας (as), να (na), θα (tha)‚ and μην (min). VO: participles, (the rare cases of) infinitives, imperatives In Mackridge’s list of rules, in finite clauses, focalised elements apparently correlate with preverbal clitic object pronoun placement, while absence thereof (with the exception of fronted objects) correlates with postverbal clitic object pronoun placement. With preverbal subjects and fronted adverbs there apparently exists variation in the placement. From this list it is easy to see why scholars who have based their studies on Mackridge’s work are convinced that there is no pattern in the correlations. With this set of possible correlations in mind, we have chosen to examine the correlations of placement, in our texts, with: a. b. c. d
Clause-initial verbs, Preverbal subjects, Preverbal adverbs, Preverbal objects.
A point that needs to be discussed, albeit briefly, is Mackridge’s claim that there is variation in the placement of the pronoun after temporal adverbs. This is a tricky point, as Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2004) also mention, but in this case for different reasons to the ones they name. In narrative and especially oral narrative research, one-word temporal adverbials, such as τότε (tote) ‘then’, ευθύς/παρευθύς (efthis/parefthis) ‘immediately/then’ etc., are termed “discourse markers”.
Chrystalla A. Thoma
Discourse markers are “usually lexical expressions, (which) do not contribute to the propositional content of a sentence but signal different kinds of messages” (Fraser 1999: 936). They can be temporal (e.g. ‘then’), coordinating (e.g. ‘and’) or conjoining (e.g. ‘well’); characteristically, their propositional meaning has been attenuated over time due to a process of grammaticalisation (Georgakopoulou 1997: 93). The role of temporal discourse markers is not so much to anchor any statement in time, since paratactically joined clauses in narrative are expected to follow each other chronologically (Berman 1988: 473) as to express subjectivity. Their function is very different to that of long temporal fronted adverbials which give a clear temporal line to the text. These one-word temporal discourse markers show continuity in the same sense that the additive marker και (ke) ‘and’ does: they add similar, non-exceptional information. Thus their distribution between the two word orders is mixed. Temporal discourse markers were therefore not accounted for in our counting of fronted adverbs. The first part of the analysis is quantitative; it consists in a search of trends and patterns in the placing of the pronouns in the chosen texts (given below). For the statistical analysis, Student’s t-Test was used, as the results tested belonged to two distinct categories (i.e. preverbal and postverbal clitic object pronoun placement).
4. Texts under analysis As mentioned in section 2 (“State of the art”), other studies have made use of texts which present some serious problems for the analysis: They are poetic, answering therefore to metrical constraints, and they have undergone major changes by editors. Our aim is to avoid these problems by using a corpus of narrative ‘low’ (i.e. popular) texts that fulfil the requirements of (1) being prose and (2) having undergone virtually no editorial changes. Furthermore, we tried to examine enough texts in order to avoid findings that reflect an author’s personal style or one scribe’s errors. Although they are not as numerous as the texts analysed in Pappas (2004a), they sufficed for significance tests to be run, therefore representing a sufficient minimum. Most of these texts are brought together and examined in this perspective for the first time, thus offering new data to the ongoing discussion. The chosen texts consist of three ‘low’ versions of the Life of Aesop (D:1644, I: 1617 and K: 1600, edition in progress by Hans Eideneier), Maximos Kallioupolitis’s version of Luke’s Gospel (printed 1638) (Kasdaglis 1999), and part of an anthology by G. Kehayoglou (Kehayoglou 2001) which we used as one long text in order to see general tendencies (Ioannis Morezinos’s religious narrative about the Virgin Mary, Nikos Gabrielopoulos’ Chronicle about the plague of 1688, Ierotheos Avvatios’ chronicle about the earthquake of 1648, Dimitrios Pirris narrative about the plague of 1728, Papa-Lavrentios’ personal narrative from 1580, Parthenios Peloponisios’ religious narrative printed 1765, the anonymous narrative about the destruction of the island Santorini from the year 1669, the anonymous vitae of the blessed Josef Pangalos, Ioannis
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
Eleimon and Ieromartyr Vlassios probably from the 17th century, the family chronicle of Konstantinos Theodosis from the end of the 1400s, Ioannikios Kartanos’ religious narrative printed 1536, Agapios Landos’ religious narrative printed 1664), as well as Papasynadinos’s memoirs from the mid 1600s (Odorico 1996). We have also included the verse epic Digenis Akritis, the Escorial version (Alexiou 1985), probably composed in the 12th but transmitted in a single manuscript of the 15th c., in order to compare the phenomenon with that of the previous era.
5. Results In this section we give the findings from our quantitative investigation of the phenomenon, examining each of the four factors of influence on the placement of the clitic object pronoun mentioned in section 3 (“Type of Data and Methodology”). In Table 1 and Figure 1 we give the variation in placement of the object clitic pronoun when the verb is in initial (thematic) position in the clause, either with elided or postverbal subject. This correlation is only strong in the case of Digenis Akritis Escorial version, the one text given by Mackridge as consistent in following the list of rules he sets up, and the three ‘low’ versions of the Life of Aesop.15 However, when our corpus was tested as a whole with Student’s t-Test, no significant variation was found in the distribution of the two word orders with clause-initial verb. Table 1. Clause-initial verb (tokens), in the first four texts very significant variation (** p<0.01) Clause-initial verb
VO
Aesop D Aesop I Aesop K Digenis Akritis
180 ** 164 ** 161 ** 54 **
Kallioupolitis: Luke Anthology Kehayioglou Papasynadinos Memoirs
99 154 17
OV 7 25 32 9 104 165 37
Chrystalla A. Thoma
Figure 1. Percentages of clause-initial verb in relation to the placement of the clitic object pronoun before (OV) or after (VO) the finite verb
The second step, as given in Tables 2, 3 and 4 (below), was to examine the correlation in placement of clitic object pronouns with fronted, preverbal elements. In Table 2 and Figure 2 we give the correlation of clitic object pronoun placement with preverbal subject, as illustrated in example 4. Student’s t-Test showed that preverbal pronouns correlated very significantly with preverbal subjects.16 Table 2. Overt subject in preverbal position (tokens), *significant (p<0.05) Preverbal subject Aesop D Aesop I Aesop K Digenis Akritis Kallioupolitis: Luke Anthology Kehayioglou Papasynadinos Memoirs
VO 7 4 6 2 2 5 1
OV * 3 5 54 16 85 69 19
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
Figure 2. Percentages of overt subject in preverbal position in relation to the placement of the clitic object pronoun before (OV) or after (VO) the finite verb
As shown in Table 3 and Figure 3, preverbal pronouns correlated very significantly with preverbal objects with doubling pronouns.17 The results of preverbal direct object pronouns were pooled with preverbal indirect object pronouns in genitive and the rare cases of non-doubling pronouns following a preverbal object (referring to another element). The latter type occurred almost exclusively in Digenis Akritis, (5 cases with OV and 1 with VO); the reading of these cases, which are probably due to the poetic nature of the text, is not necessarily one of focalisation.18 Not only does this method not affect in any way the significance readings but it is also in accordance with the position that in our texts the placement of the clitic pronoun depends on the position of the fronted element and not on its being focalised (cf. also Pappas 2004a: 38 for a similar statement).
Chrystalla A. Thoma
Table 3. Preverbal object with doubling pronoun (tokens), *significant (p<0.05) Fronted object Aesop D Aesop I Aesop K Digenis Akritis Kallioupolitis: Luke Anthology Kehayioglou Papasynadinos Memoirs
VO 0 0 2 1 0 0 0
OV * 1 5 1 21 3 24 4
Figure 3. Percentages of preverbal object with doubling pronoun in relation to the placement of the clitic object pronoun before (OV) or after (VO) the finite verb
As shown in Table 4 and Figure 4, when tested for significance with Student’s t-Test, the predominant preverbal placement of the clitic object pronoun with fronted adverbs was found to be significantly more frequent.19 As mentioned in the Introduction, one-word adverbs, in reality discourse markers marking continuity such as “then”, were not counted among the adverbs in this table and were taken to have the same function as coordinating conjunctions such as “and” (cf. also Condoravdi and Kiparsky 2001). Indeed, their distribution is similar to that of coordinating conjunctions with clause-initial verbs.
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
Table 4. Totals of correlation with fronted adverb, *significant (p<0.05) Fronted adverb Aesop D Aesop I Aesop K Digenis Akritis Kallioupolitis: Luke Anthology Kehayioglou Papasynadinos Memoirs
VO
OV*
3 7 1 1 0 1 3
8 4 7 47 6 44 17
Figure 4. Percentages of fronted adverb in relation to the placement of the clitic object pronoun before (OV) and after (VO) the finite verb
Finally, we pooled together all the above discontinuity markers (overt subject in preverbal position, preverbal adverb and object) and counted the occurrences, as given in Table 5 and Figure 5. As expected, the tendency to have preverbal object pronouns was very strong, as a Student’s t-Test showed.20
Chrystalla A. Thoma
Table 5. Discontinuity markers (tokens), **very significant (p<0.01) Discontinuity marker
VO
OV **
Aesop D Aesop I Aesop K Digenis Akritis Kallioupolitis: Luke Anthology Kehayioglou Papasynadinos Memoirs
10 11 9 4 2 6 4
12 14 62 84 94 147 40
Figure 5. Percentages of discontinuity markers in relation to the placement of the clitic object pronoun before (OV) and after (VO) the finite verb
6. Discussion 6.1
Placement patterns
As seen in section 5, Results, there is variation in the placement of the clitic object pronoun when the verb is in initial (thematic) position in the clause, either with elided or postverbal subject (given in Table 1 of Results). This correlation, as given in the list of Mackridge’s rules, was expected to be very strong. Indeed, the tendency is strong in the one text Mackridge presents as consistently following the rules, the Escorial Di-
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
genis Akritis, and in the three ‘low’ versions (D, I and K) of one text, i.e. the Life of Aesop. However, when the whole corpus used for this study was tested, no significant tendency was verified. This finding indicates that older texts such as the Escorial Digenis Akritis probably followed this rule quite consistently. This is in fact corroborated by the same strong tendency found in the three versions of the Life of Aesop, which are all Early Modern Greek adaptations of older, linguistically more archaic narratives (Notis Toufexis, pers. comm.). If the tendency we see is not the author’s personal style, then it can be taken to be a remnant of an older feature. However, in our corpus of Early Modern Greek texts no significant tendency was found supporting this rule, suggesting that an important change was already underway: the position of the object clitic was at the time not yet consistently preverbal; still, neither position was preferred over the other. This finding is in direct contrast with Pappas’s findings (Pappas 2004a: 118) for this factor. In his counting, in the beginning of the 16th century we already find a relatively fixed preverbal placement of the clitic when the verb is clause-initial, a fact not corroborated by our texts. An instance from the corpus is given in example (1), taken from Digenis Akritis, in which the clitic object pronoun ‘το’ refers to the word θαμπούριν ‘tamboura’ in the previous clause and is postverbal. As described by Mackridge and also as the findings of this study reconfirm, this is typical in this text when the verb occurs at thematic position or when preceded by a coordinating conjunction such as (in this case) και (ke) ‘and’. (1)
Digenis Akritis Escorial (15. century) (Και επήρεν το θαμπούριν του) και αποκατάστησέν το (And he took his tamboura) and string-3SG-PAST it-PRO-ACC And he took his tamboura and strung it
In contrast, in Kallioupolitis translation of the Gospel of Luke from Hellenistic into early Modern Greek, we find great variation in the placement of the clitic object pronoun. In example (2) we see a sentence in which all placements occur postverbally with the verb at clause initial position. (2) Kallioupolitis: Gospel of Luke (1638) Και έφερέ τον εις την Ιερουσαλήμ και έστησέν τον απάνου εις την άκρην του ιερού και είπε τον: And bring-3SG-PAST him-PRO-ACC to Jerusalem and place-3SG-PAST him-PRO-ACC on the edge of the altar and say-3SG-PAST- him-PRO-ACC: And he brought him to Jerusalem and placed him on the edge of the altar and said to him: In example (3) from the same text and by the same author/translator, in an apparently comparable co-text, the clitic object pronoun τον occurs preverbally. (3) Kallioupolitis: Gospel of Luke (1638) Και τον έδωκαν βιβλίον του Ησαίου του προφήτου·
Chrystalla A. Thoma
And him-PRO-ACC give-3PL-PAST book of Isaiah the prophet; And they gave him the book of Isaiah the prophet; We then showed that the factor “preverbal subject” correlates significantly with proclitic object pronouns (as given in Table 2 of Results). Mackridge (2000: 133) mentions that further investigation is needed in this respect.21 Although Pappas (2001) mentions numbers that speak of the same tendency in his data, he ascribes it to poetic constraints. Indeed, in his corpus analysis he only found limited evidence of such a tendency even though his core corpus reaches into the 16th century, thus already into Early Modern Greek (Pappas 2004a: 42). In our corpus the tendency is significant; the finding is also valid for Digenis Akritis, indicating that already in Late Medieval Greek this factor played an important role in the case of preverbal placement of the object clitic. A functional explanation is given below (section 6.2).22 Examples (4), (5) and (6) illustrate this significant tendency in our corpus. The preverbal subjects are not focussed (i.e. not contrastive) and this is the norm of preverbal subjects in our corpus (cf. also Pappas 2004b)23 despite the fact that the position is still not fixed. (4)
Life of Aesop K (1600) Και ο δεσπότης τον λέγει And the master-NOM him-PRO-ACC say-3SG-PRESENT And the master tells him
(5)
Vita of the blessed Josef Pangalos (ca. 17th century) Και ο άγιος τα εδέχθη και έφαγε And the saint them-PRO-ACC accept-3SG-PAST- and eat-3SG-PAST And the saint accepted and ate them
(6) Papasynadinos`s memoirs (1600s) Και οι τούρκοι το εγύρισαν αλλέως, το πως είπεν τον τούρκον, οπού τα πουλεί, χριστιανόν And the Turks-NOM it-PRO-ACC turn-3PL -PAST differently, it-PRO-ACC that say-3SG-PAST Turk-ACC, who sell-3SG-PAST them-PRO-ACC, Christian-ACC And the Turks distorted it, saying that he had called the Turk who sold them a Christian Preverbal object pronouns correlated significantly with preverbal object with (doubling) pronoun (as shown in Table 3 of Results). This is important because preverbal objects are rarely focussed24 thus dispelling the idea that focusing is the main factor in preverbal placement of the clitic pronoun already in Late Medieval Greek. Pappas (2004a: 42–43) also found the same tendency for preverbal placement, although in a previous study of his (Pappas 2001: 81) he found that in “most of the instances in which the ‘doubling pronoun’ appears preverbally, the doubled element is some form of the adjective όλος.” Still, his latest view, corroborated by our findings, suggests that
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
already in Late Medieval Greek the pattern existed and was retained through Early Modern to Modern Greek, illustrated here by examples (7), (8), (9), and (10). (7) Kartanos (1536) Την τετάρτην την είχαν δια τα ζώα The-ART-DEF-FEM-ACC Wednesday-ACC it-PRO-FEM-ACC have-3PLIMPERFECT for the animals-PL-ACC As for Wednesday, they had it for the animals (8) Gabrielopoulos (1688) Τούτον τον λογισμόν τους τον έβαλαν και εις πράξην This-PRO-MASC-ACC the-ART-MASC-ACC thought-ACC it-PRO-MASCACC put-3PL-PAST and in action-ACC This thought of theirs, they translated it into action (9) Ioannis Morezinos’s religious narrative about the Virgin Mary (ca. 17th century) Τούτα τα είπεν εις όλους την νύκταν απού την επήρασιν These-PRO–ACC-PL them-PRO-ACC say-3SG-PAST to all-ACC the nightACC that her-ACC take-3PL-PAST These, she talked about them to all the night that they took her
(10) Kallioupolitis: Gospel of Luke (1638 ) Και πολλούς τυφλούς τους εχάρισε το φως τους And many-ACC-PL blind-ACC-PL them-PRO-ACC give-3SG-PAST their light-ACC And to many blind, he gave to them their sight The correlation of preverbal object pronouns with preverbal adverbs was also found to be significant (as given in Table 4 of Results). This difference in our findings from the findings of other scholars (for example Pappas 2004b) is probably due to the fact that we pooled together all adverbs since we propose that any preverbal adverb can and does affect the placement of the clitic. Furthermore, since we filtered temporal discourse markers such as “then”, the picture changed even more, finally resulting in a strong tendency. Examples (11), (12), (13) and (14) illustrate the patterning of a preverbal clitic object pronoun following a preverbal adverb. (11)
Life of Aesop I (1617) Πολλά του εβαρυφάνη Much-ADV him-PRO-MASC-GEN (heavy appear)-PAST He took it to heart
(12)
Kallioupolitis: Gospel of Luke (1638) Και με τα μαλλία της κεφαλής της τα εσφούγγιζε And with the hair-ACC of her head them-PRO-ACC-PL wipe-3PL-IMPERFECT And she wiped them with her hair
Chrystalla A. Thoma
(13) Ioannis Morezinos’s religious narrative about the Virgin Mary (ca. 17th century) Και τυφλώνουνται από τον εχθρόν, και μίαν ημέραν τηνε πιάνουσι και λέγουσίν της And blind-3PL-PR-PASSIVE by the enemy-ACC, and one day her-PRO-ACC take-3PL-PRESENT and say-3PL-PRESENT her-PRO-GEN And they are blinded by the enemy and one day they take her and tell her (14) Kallioupolitis: Gospel of Luke (1638) Και από τα κεραμίδια τον εκατάβασαν μαζί με το κρεβάτι εις την μέσην και έβαλάν τον μπροστά εις τον Ιησούν And from the roof tiles-ACC him-PRO-ACC lower-3PL-PAST with the bedACC in the middle-ACC and place-3PL-PAST him-PRO-ACC before JesusACC And from the roof tiles they lowered him with his bed in the middle and placed him before Jesus Supported by our findings given in Table 5 (cf. “Results”), a relatively clear picture of the placement of the clitic object pronoun in Early Modern Greek emerges in our study. Preverbal placement appears with highly significant frequency with preverbal (fronted) elements, which in their majority appear not to be focussed (see Pappas 2004a: 118 for similar findings in a brief overview of 17th century texts). These preverbal elements mentioned above correspond to discontinuity markers in Givón’s (1983, 1992) model of referential cohesion in narrative discourse and are supposed to have a functional role: they indicate junctures in the narrative line which correspond to “major topics”. Givón’s theory as it concerns our findings and the question of the functional role of clitic object placement pronoun is examined below (section 6.2). Our findings present another perspective on the ongoing discussion concerning the factors influencing the placement of unstressed object pronouns in earlier periods of Greek. Let us now see if the patterns presented above fit into a functional, both synchronic and diachronic, framework.
6.2
A functional synchronic explanation
Givón is one of the main representatives of the school of Typological discourse analysis (TDA). TDA pays particular attention to word order phenomena in a variety of languages and connects them to information distribution in discourse and to iconicity principles inside the boundaries of the clause, and in discourse (interclausally and intersententially). TDA pays close attention to referent tracking mechanisms and episodic memory retrieval and activation. According to Givón (1992: 6) “the grammar of referential coherence is not primarily about reference. Rather it is about identifying and activating the locations (“mental files”, “storage nodes”) where verbally coded text is stored in episodic memory.”
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
Narrative discourse is about “referents”, entities stable in time which can be topical (nominal) or adverbial (Givón 1979: 320–324). Referential cohesion tracks these referents and brings them back into the foreground when needed after having been relayed to a backgrounded position for a while or when the mention of other referents interferes and makes their mental retrieval difficult. The junctures in discourse where referents are brought back into the foreground are marked by long fronted discontinuity elements, i.e. nominal and adverbial groups mostly, certainly not pronouns and especially not elements for which mental retrieval is the easiest such as clitic pronouns. According to Givón (2001), in discourse we find chains of ‘primary’ (subjects) and ‘secondary’ (objects) topics. They are tracked according to the principles of iconicity and referential cohesion. The maximum degree of continuity (facility of retrieval) for subjects corresponds to zero anaphora, whereas for objects it corresponds to clitic pronouns (in Greek at least), as illustrated here for Early Modern Greek in an example from The Life of Aesop (also valid for today’s Modern Greek). Continuity (accessible topics): (Ø) ήφερεν τα (no subject) (verb) (clitic pronoun) (He) brought them Discontinuity (non-accessible/salient topics): Κάποιος γεωργός ήφερεν σύκα (explicit subject) (verb) (explicit object) A farmer brought figs We hereby propose a cohesive function of the variation in pronoun placement, an extra dimension added to the already cohesive referential nature of clitic pronouns as continuity markers of secondary topic cohesion, as illustrated above. As we have seen, preverbal clitic object pronouns co-occur with fronted elements in our Early Modern Greek corpus. The larger the fronted element, the more important the break in discourse, and the greater the processing difficulty and mental effort, creating therefore discontinuity junctures. Given by Givón as the “code quantity principle”, the definition is as follows: “The less predictable the information is, or the more important, the more prominent, distinct or large will be the code element(s) that convey it” (Givón 2001: 249). The association of this principle with word order becomes clear in the following statement: “the less predictable the information is or the more important, the more likely it is to be placed earlier in the clause (or in whatever relevant unit of structured information)” (Givón 2001: 250). We suggest that the function of preverbal placement of the clitic object pronoun is to intensify the effect of a discontinuity, or break, in discourse. The placement follows not only prosodic reasons (although this might also be the case), but certainly pragmatic reasons: the preverbal placing of the clitic, which causes it to appear between the fronted, discontinuous element and the verbal group, effectively demarcates the former and plac-
Chrystalla A. Thoma
es it apart, giving it more emphasis. The relation to memory is defined as follows: “more prominent and more distinct coding attracts more attention”, and “information that attracts more attention is memorized, stored and retrieved more efficiently” (Givón 2001: 250). The demarcation is not only effectuated by means of prosody, since the clitic is unaccented, but also by means of a “low” point in information flow: the clitic pronoun is the entity that is easiest to retrieve from the previous clause or a clause that occurred not far back in discourse. The author takes for granted the fact that the reader/listener will not find it difficult to infer which referent is being talked about. With all the attention of the reader/listener already turned to the initial, longer and information-loaded element, a “break” in the reader/listener’s attention is helpful so that another element might follow with new information: a verb perhaps, or an object. We propose, therefore, that by means of syntactic and prosodic management, discontinuous elements (preverbal subjects, objects and adverbs) are made to stand out, creating clear junctures in discourse, a function in which the placement of clitic object pronouns appears to play an important role. This functional role was possible due to the variation in the placement of the clitic for a long period of time until late in the history of the Greek language; indeed, as our study clearly shows, important variation exists at least until the 18th century, as opposed to Pappas’s (2004a: 117) claim (cf. also Chila-Markopoulou 2004 for the same criticism), a claim perhaps based on his choice of poetic texts.
6.3
Diachronic perspective on clitic placement
The lack of stress and placement of clitic pronouns in the clause are very probably intertwined. For some time it has been known that certain positions in the clause correlate with the placement of clitics: mainly clause-second and postverbal (cf. Janse 2000: 237). The first case (clause-second placement) has received most of the attention. The famous Wackernagel’s law, which proposed that the clause-second position is reserved for clitic elements, is quoted in the majority of studies on clitics and is concerned with exactly this position in the clause. This has since been interpreted as “the first position is reserved for stressed elements”. Now, as Janse (2000: 234) accurately observes, the stress on the first position is closely linked to discourse-pragmatic reasons. It seems that prosody, like word order, follows mainly pragmatic reasons.25 The first constituent of a clause is sometimes focalised (contrastive), and for this reason receives the strongest stress in the clause. Most often, though, the literature does not mention anything about the stress of preverbal, non-focalised elements. Yet it is clear that they also carry stress, albeit not as strong as the one of focalised elements. The term “unstressed pronoun” emphasises just that: other elements in the clause carry the stress. The placement of the clitic right after preverbal elements follows, apart from discourse-pragmatic, also prosodic reasons, an opinion shared by Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2004: 175), albeit, in their view, due to syntactic reasons.
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
Now we shall turn our attention to the second option, the postverbal placement. As Givón (2001: 423) points out, weak elements often cliticise on the verb because it is the element that is usually present in a clause; participants such as subjects and objects are often elided in cases of referential continuity. Verbs are hardly ever focalised in Greek, except perhaps in cases of imperative or subjunctive expressing command, and they do not carry strong stress, even if they are at thematic position in the clause. But verbs do carry stress, especially if they stand at clause-initial position with no preverbal, fronted element present. That must be the reason behind the placement of the clitic pronouns in postverbal position; see also Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2004: 179).26 Essentially the first concern of word order is to serve discourse cohesion and therefore the episodic memory (Givón 1992: 5 et passim, for Ancient Greek see Dik 1994, 1995, for Modern Greek see Thoma 2006). Clause prosody, just like word order, serves the same function and places certain groups of grammatical words in certain positions in the clause; in those positions they do not disturb the function of lexical words carrying most of the informational content and cohesive power of the clause in discourse. These positions become later grammaticalised and fixed (as it happened in German and English for instance) and over time lose their discourse-pragmatic power in order to become clitics and affixes, resulting in a renewal of the circle. This “fixing of discourse strategies” (Traugott 1994) allows for new elements to take over the discourse-pragmatic role. This development of clitic pronouns seems to mirror the development of Greek pronouns from ancient Greek to this day. In ancient Greek we find clitics that tend to appear in second position in the clause, enclitic on the first constituent (Horrocks 1990: 36, Janse 2000: 233). The situation apparently changes in Hellenistic Greek, when clitic pronouns (1st and 2nd person, still no 3rd person clitic pronouns) get attached to the verbal group as a result of reanalysis (Horrocks 1990: 41), and appear postverbally even in cases of focalised fronted constituents, probably as a result of language contact with Aramaic and Hebrew, languages which have pronominal suffixes instead of clitic pronouns (Janse 2000: 237). In Medieval Greek we see the emergence of 3rd person clitic object pronouns (Mackridge 2000: 135). As Mackridge (1993: 225) aptly remarks, the placement of clitic pronouns is not really ‘free’. There is a very real possibility that the placement initially followed a pattern similar to today’s Greek Cypriot dialect, in which finite declarative clauses present fixed postverbal placement except in the case of focalised (contrastive) fronted constituents which, for prosodic reasons, attract the clitic to preverbal position. The proposal for this phase in the development of the placement of clitic object pronouns will remain for the time being tentative, since neither is there any proof that postverbal placement became fixed at any one point, offering ground for comparison with Greek Cypriot, nor that preverbal placement correlated at any given time in the history of Standard Greek only with focalised constituents. In Early Modern Greek, fronted elements, not necessarily contrastive, attract clitic pronouns to preverbal position, until that position becomes the norm and is grammaticalised in Standard Modern Greek. A similar process has taken place in
Chrystalla A. Thoma
the Romance languages, most probably due to a similar process (cf. Martins 1994 for Portuguese, Rivero 1991 and Fontana 1993 for Spanish, cf. also Pappas 2004a).
6.4
Possible causes for patterning OV with clause-initial verb
In today’s Standard Modern Greek (in contrast to dialects such as Greek Cypriot), clitic object pronouns have become strictly proclitic on the verb, except in the case of the imperative or participle. In our Early Modern Greek corpus, the placement of the clitic object pronoun after clause-initial verb is variable. However, in certain, especially older texts, there is a tendency for the clitic pronoun to follow the clause-initial verb (see subsection 6.1), while in other, more recent texts we find a tendency to have the clitic pronoun come before the verb. If we accept that the first placement (postverbal) is the older one and that preverbal placement originated in cases of focalised and then fronted elements, the question remains why we find such variation with clause-initial verbs, a variation which obviously led to today’s relatively fixed proclitic placement. We shall propose here very briefly two possible reasons: 1 Analogy (“echo structures”, Janse 1994: 439, 1998: 262): There is the possibility of patterning the clitic object pronoun after the first clause of clause complex, as in example (15): (15) Kallioupolitis: Gospel of Luke 1638 Και ο Ιησούς τον επίασε και τον ιάτρευσε και τον απόλυσε And Jesus-NOM him-PRO-ACC take-3SG-PAST, him-PRO-ACC heal-3SGPAST and him-PRO-ACC let go-3SG-PAST And Jesus took him, and healed him and let him go 2 Hypercorrection: There is the possibility of patterning the clitic object pronoun after the subjunctive structure which is always used with preverbal pronouns when the declarative clause can be interpreted as such: (16)
Pirris (1728) Έτσι έδωκαν θέλημα και την έθαψαν (= έτσι έδωκαν θέλημα να τη θάψουν) Thus give-3PL-PAST order-ACC and her-PRO-ACC bury-3PL-PAST Thus they ordered and they buried her (= that they should bury her)
The above are indications of the process that finally led to the grammaticalisation of the preverbal position of the clitic object pronoun in Standard Modern Greek.
7. Conclusions The findings of this study can be summarised as follows: In the time period under investigation, clitic object pronouns appear quite consistently in postverbal position
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
with verb in clause-initial position in some texts which probably originated in the earlier period; otherwise, the placement appears to be random, indicative of a period of change. A significant correlation was shown to exist between preverbal clitic object pronouns and discontinuity elements (preverbal subjects, objects and adverbs) in clause-initial position. We propose that this correlation can be explained as due to the function of the position of clitic object pronouns which consists in allowing the demarcation of stressed, emphasized chunks of information (mostly topics, i.e. nominal or adverbial groups but also very often verbs in initial position) which indicate junctures of new episodes by re-introducing central referents of a narrative line. Due to their placement and lack of stress and information load, clitic pronouns enable the reader/listener to manage information in the clause better, by creating a “low” in information, reflected also in their lack of stress, signalling the end of an important unit, as well as by creating expectations for more important information to follow. As our findings also show, in Early Modern Greek texts the placement of clitic object pronouns still varies, especially in cases of verbs at clause-initial position; however in some texts they do show a predisposition for preverbal placement, foreshadowing their fixed preverbal position in Standard Modern Greek. The findings of this study are reliable because the editions chosen are without major changes and the texts are prose, avoiding thus metrical constraints on the placement of the clitics. Moreover, the findings are also valid for the Late Medieval epic Digenis Akritis. From the point of view of diachronic change, we propose that postverbal placement of clitic pronouns is probably older (following Wackernagel’s law) than the preverbal. As in Greek Cypriot and other eastern dialects (as Mackridge already proposed), preverbal placement was probably once exclusive to focalised contrastive constructions, such as focalised subjects, objects and adverbs. Later, in the time under study here, it obviously became the norm with general discontinuity patterns of preverbal subjects, objects and adverbs. This pattern was generalised in the end, resulting in today’s fixed preverbal placement in Standard Greek, whereas dialects such as Cypriot or Cappadocian retained the older word order, probably due to linguistic isolation (see Pappas 2004a). We also suggest that the grammaticalisation process of clitisation in Greek was halted due to the emergence of a written (narrative) register which imitated in many ways spoken language (cf. Eideneier 1999, 2002) and by choosing to write clitic object pronouns as separate words stopped the cycle which probably would have led to them being seen as affixes.
Notes 1. This investigation has taken place in the framework of “Research Centre 538: Multilingualism” under the auspices of the German Research Foundation (DFG). Our thanks to Prof. Dr. Hans Eideneier (Hamburg), Dr. Carlos Jiménez (Bremen), Dr. Notis Toufexis (Cambridge) and Dr. Ludger Zeevaert (Hamburg) and the anonymous reviewers for their advice and comments.
Chrystalla A. Thoma 2. According to Horrocks (1997: 291ff.) these texts belong to Early Modern Greek and not to Late Medieval, a period ending with the fall of Constantinople. However, these are conventional distinctions; language does not always change immediately or entirely when a new historical period begins. We thank the anonymous reviewer for their comment. 3. This period has been under intensive scrutiny in the historical project H4: “Forms of Written discourse in Byzantine and Modern Greek Diglossia” under the direction of Prof. Dr. Hans Eideneier at “Research Centre 538: Multilingualism” (University of Hamburg). 4. We thank both anonymous reviewers for their comments on this point. Pappas (2004a) indeed looks at texts from the 17th century, although his sources are not mentioned and our findings are not exactly the same. Most texts here are studied for the first time, and their editions are reliable. 5. Clitic here is understood as bound to the finite verb (cf. Mackridge 1993: 317, Janse 2000: 244) but not as part of it. 6. Pappas (2004a) states that in his main corpus he examines the phenomenon in both Late Medieval and Early Modern Greek. However, his texts of Early Modern Greek are only three poetic texts from the beginnings of the 16th century (Pappas 2004a: 21). 7. “Rollo overestimated the importance of postverbal pronoun placement in a number of environments, most notably those of preceding subject and adverb” (Pappas 2004a: 33). 8. “The realization of the medieval rules came to me after reading Newton (Newton 1972: 64).” (Mackridge 2000: 135). 9. “[...] the rules seem to display a certain instability.” (Mackridge 1993: 326). 10. “[...] the system of the A-type dialects must be the most archaic of the three” […] “the syntax of A-dialects is closest to the medieval Greek system, as sketched out in Mackridge (1993)”. It is mentioned later on that A-type dialects include Greek Cypriot. 11. “[...] the redactor and/or scribe of the Escorial Digenis Akritas displays a remarkable consistency in his application of the rules governing the position of the clitic pronoun, in contrast with the situation prevailing in certain other texts […]” (Mackridge 1993: 338). 12. See also Chila-Markopoulou (2004: 2). It is common knowledge among editors of Late Medieval and Early Modern Greek texts that 19th c. editions (especially those by W. Wagner used by Pappas) are unreliable and should only be used with great caution. For a general discussion of modern editorial practices see Eideneier, Moennig and Toufexis (2001). 13. “In fact, without the necessary prosodic information (i.e. information about sentence stress), this distinction between topic and focus is hard to confirm based on the surrounding context alone.” (Pappas 2001: 86). 14. “If it is a topic, it occurs with postverbal clitics; if it is a focus, it occurs with preverbal clitics.” (Condoravdi and Kiparsky 2004: 166, here referring to preverbal subjects and adverbials). 15. Significance (one tail): df= 4, p= 0.000050872, t= 2.77644511 16. Significance (one tail): df= 8, p= 0.0135777277, t= -2.69806094 17. Significance (one tail): df= 8, p= 0.01768578, t= -2.52788826 18. “A further complication is that in certain types of presentational sentences, even modern Greek literary style allows topicalization of objects without clitic doubling” (Condoravdi and Kiparsky 2004: 167).
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
19. Significance (one tail): df= 8, p= 0.0219835339, t= -2.3883769 20. Significance (one tail): df= 14, p= 0.003740025, t= -3.12316895 21. “Another area that needs investigation is the situation after subjects.” (Mackridge 2000: 136). 22. Janse also brings up the possibility of discourse pragmatic reasons governing the preverbal placement of clitic object pronouns with subject in initial position in two papers (Janse 1994, 1998); in a line of argument similar to that of Mackridge he claims that the reason is that preverbal subjects constitute information focus. As Pappas (2004a: 58) points out, this is not shown to be a sufficient condition for preverbal placement of the clitic; furthermore, he claims, this is apparently not the case in Late Medieval Greek. 23. “[...] fronted constituents are more likely to be focused elements than subjects“ (Pappas 2004b). 24. This is in reality a case of so-called ‘left dislocation’ of the object (Givón 2001), as in the English example “the house, he sold it”, in which the object is not New information, only topicalised. This also explains why it can not be seen as a focussed construction (see also Tzartzanos 1931 for the same idea, i.e. that doubling pronouns are connected to Given information, as well as Philippaki-Warburton 1995 and Haberland and van der Auwera 1990 for the connection of doubling pronouns to Topicality. See discussion of Objects as Secondary Topics in Givón’s model. We thank the anonymous reviewer for this comment). 25. For a different view on this matter see Revithiadou (2006). We are grateful to the anonymous reviewer for bringing this study to our attention. 26. In this sense we take weak object pronouns to be enclitic (so do Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2004) as opposed to Pappas (2004a).
References Alexiou, S. (ed.). 1985. Βασίλειος Διγενής Ακρίτης (κατά το χειρόγραφο του Εσκοριάλ) και το Άσμα του Αρμούρη. Κριτική έκδοση. Athens. Berman, R. 1988. On the ability to relate events in narrative. Discourse Processes 11: 469–497. Chila-Markopoulou, D. 2004. Review of Panayotis A. Pappas. Variation and Morphosyntactic Change in Greek: From clitics to affixes. Journal of Greek Linguistics 5: 199–212. Condoravdi, C. and Kiparsky, P. 2001. Clitics and clause structure. Journal of Greek Linguistics 2:1–39. Condoravdi, C. and Kiparsky, P. 2004. Clitics and clause structure: The late medieval Greek system. Journal of Greek Linguistics 5: 159–180. Dik, H. 1994. Ancient Greek warfare: A case study in constituent ordering. In Function and Expression in Functional Grammar, E. Engberg-Pedersen, L. Falster Jakobsen and L. Schack Rasmussen (eds), 197–213. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Dik, H. 1995. Word Order in Ancient Greek. A pragmatic account of word order variation in Herodotus. Amsterdam: Gieben. Eideneier H. 1999. Von Rhapsodie zu Rap: Aspekte der griechischen Sprachgeschichte von Homer bis heute, Tübingen: Narr. Eideneier, H., Moennig, U. and Toufexis, Ν. (eds.). 2001. Θεωρία και πράξη των εκδόσεων της υστεροβυζαντινής, αναγεννησιακής και μεταβυζαντινής δημώδους γραμματείας. Πρακτικά του διεθνούς συνεδρίου Neograeca Medii Aevi IVa. Αμβούργο 28.-31.1.1999, Ηράκλειο:
Chrystalla A. Thoma Πανεπιστημιακές Εκδόσεις Κρήτης (Theory and practice in the editions of Late Medieval Renaissance and Post-Byzantine popular literature). In Proceedings of the International Conference Neograeca Medii Aevi Iva, Hamburg 28.-31.1.1999. Herakleion: University Press Crete. Eideneier, H. 2002. Rhetorik und Stil – der griechische Beitrag [AZM, Working Papers in Multilingualism. Series B 43]. Hamburg: University of Hamburg, Research Centre 538 Multilingualism. Fontana, J. 1993. Phrase Structure and the Syntax of Clitics in the History of Spanish. PhD dissertation, University of Pennsylvania. Fraser, B. 1999. What are discourse markers? Journal of Pragmatics 31: 931–952. Georgakopoulou, A. 1997. Narrative Performances: A study of Modern Greek storytelling, Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Givón, T. 1979. On Understanding Grammar. New York NY: Academic Press. Givón, T. [11990] 2001. Syntax: A functional-typological introduction. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Givón, T. 1983. Topic continuity in discourse: The functional domain of switch reference. In Switch Reference and Universal Grammar, J. Haiman and P. Munro (eds.), 51–82. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Givón, T. 1992. The grammar of referential coherence as mental processing instructions. Linguistics 30: 5–55. Haberland, H., and van der Auwera, J. 1990. Topics and clitics in Greek relatives. Acta Linguistica Hafniensia 22: 127–157. Horrocks, G.. 1990. Clitics in Greek: A diachronic review. In Greek Outside Greece II, M. Roussou and S. Panteli (eds), 35–52. Athens: Diaspora. Horrocks, G. C. 1997. Greek: A history of the language and its speakers. London: Longman. Janse, M. 1994. Son of Wackernagel: The distribution of object clitic pronouns in Cappadocian. In Themes in Greek Linguistics I, I. Philippaki-Warburton, K. Nicolaidis and M. Sifianou (eds), 435–442. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Janse, M. 1998. Cappadocian clitics and the syntax-morphology interface. In Themes in Greek Linguistic II, B. Joseph, G. C. Horrocks, and I. Philippaki-Warburton (eds), 257–281. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Janse, M. 2000. Convergence and divergence in the development of the Greek and Latin clitic pronouns. In Stability, Variation and Change of Word-Order Patterns over Time, R. Sornicola, E. Poppe and A. Shisha-Halevy (eds), 231–258. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Mackridge, P. 1993. An editorial problem in the Medieval Greek texts: The position of the object clitic pronoun in the Escorial Digenes Akrites. In Neograeca Medii Aevi, N. M. Panayiotakis (ed.), 325–342. Venice. Mackridge, P. 2000. The position of the weak object pronoun in medieval and modern Greek. Yazik I Rechevaya Deyatel’Nost’ [St. Petersburg] 3. Martins, A. M. 1994. Clíticos na história do português. PhD dissertation, University of Lisbon. Newton, B. 1972. Cypriot Greek: Its phonology and inflections. Hague: Mouton. Pappas, P. 2001. Weak object pronoun placement in later Medieval Greek: Intralinguistic parameters affecting variation. OSUWPL 56: 79–106. Pappas, P. 2004a. Variation and Morphosyntactic Change in Greek: From clitics to affixes. Hampshire: Palgrave. Pappas, P. 2004b. Medieval Greek weak object pronouns and analogical change: A response to Condoravdi and Kiparsky (2001). Journal of Greek Linguistics 5: 127–158.
Distribution and function of clitic object pronouns in 16th–18th century Greek narratives
Philippaki-Warburton, I. 1995. Διαχρονική θεώρηση της θέσης των εγκλιτικών μέσα στην πρόταση. Studies in Greek Linguistics 15: 123–134. Revithiadou, A. 2006. Prosodic filters on syntax: An interface account of second position clitics. Lingua 116: 79–111. Rivero, M. 1991. Clitic and NP climbing in Old Spanish. In Current studies in Spanish linguistics, H. Campos and F. Martínez-Gil (eds.), 241–282. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press. Rollo, A. 1989. L’ uso dell’ enclisi nel Greco volgare dal XII al XVII secolo e la legge Tobler-Mussafia. Italoellinika 2: 135–146. Thoma, C. 2006. Combining Functional Linguistics and Translation Theories: A case study of Greek Cypriot and British folktales. Frankfurt: Peter Lang. Traugott, E. C. 1994. Grammaticalization and lexicalization. In The Encyclopaedia of Language and Linguistics, R. E. Asher and J.M.Y. Simpson (eds), Vol. 3, 1481–86. Oxford: Pergamon Press. Toufexis, N. In prep. Defining HIGH and LOW from a typological perspective. A case-study of the Early Modern Greek intralingual translations of the Life of Aesop. University of Hamburg. Toufexis, N. In prep. Register variation and the grammar of Medieval Greek. University of Cambridge. Tzartzanos, A. A. [11931] 1999. Νεοελληνική Σύνταξις (της Κοινής Δημοτικής) (Modern Greek Syntax of demotic Greek) Vol. I – II, Athens: Kyriakides Bros Ltd.
Sources Digenis Akritis: Jeffreys, E. (ed.) 1998: Digenis Akritis: The Grottaferrata and Escorial versions. Cambridge: CUP. Kallioupolitis: Kasdaglis, E. C. (ed.) 1998: Η Καινή διαθήκη του Κυρίου Ημών Ιησού Χριστού. Athens: MIET, 1995–1998. Kehayoglou Anthology: Kehayoglou, G. (ed.) 2003: Πεζογραφική Aνθολογία: Αφηγηματικός γραπτός νεοελληνικός λόγος. Τόμος Α΄: Από τα τέλη του Βυζαντίου ως τη Γαλλική Επανάσταση, σελ. 1–760, Τόμος Β΄: Από τη Γαλλική Επανάσταση ως τη δημιουργία του ελληνικού κράτους, σελ. 761–1504 Aristoteles University of Thessaloniki, Institute for Modern Greek Studies, Manolis Triantafyllides Institute. Life of Aesop: Papathomopoulos, M. (ed.) 1999: Πέντε δημώδεις μεταφράσεις του Βίου του Αισώπου. Athes: Papadimas. Der Äsoproman: Eideneier, H. (ed.) In prep.: (electronic text). Papasynadinos Memoirs: Odorico, P. (ed.) 1996: Αναμνήσεις και συμβουλές του Συναδινού, ιερέα Σερρών στη Μακεδονία, 17ος αιώνας. Association Pierre Belon: Athens, Paris.
Nominative subjects of non-finite clauses in Hiberno-English Lukas Pietsch University of Hamburg
Hiberno-English (Irish English) dialects have developed an innovative grammatical pattern where the pronominal subject of an embedded gerund clause is marked with nominative instead of accusative or genitive case. This paper traces the use of this structure in older forms of Hiberno-English and contrasts it with corresponding patterns in Standard English and in Irish. It is argued that the development of the pattern is indirectly due to structural transfer from Irish, although superficially the resulting distribution of nominative and accusative pronoun forms in Hiberno-English differs crucially from that in both the substrate and the superstrate language.
1. Introduction1 The language contact situation between Irish and English in Ireland has long been recognised as a veritable hotbed of contact-induced language change phenomena. Starting in the 17th and culminating in the mid-19th century, a situation of migration, societal bilingualism and subsequent mass language shift have led to the emergence of a set of highly divergent dialects of English which show very marked traces of influence from the Irish substrate (Filppula 1999, Hickey ed. 2005). Given the intensity of the contact, it is not surprising that these effects have permeated virtually all domains of linguistic organisation, from discourse through phonology and grammar. According to Matras (this vol.), clause-combining strategies, such as complementation constructions, appear to be a domain particularly susceptible to contact-induced change. As Matras notes, such convergence effects need not involve actual borrowing of formal material, but may also happen through a replication of more abstract properties of the constructions involved, or in his words, a “fusion” of rules of form-function mapping. It will be one effect of this kind that will form the focus of this paper. One of the means of coding inter-clausal connectivity employed prominently by English is the use of non-finite verb forms (infinitives, gerunds and participles) in subordinate clauses. As in many other languages, the use of non-finite clauses in Eng-
Lukas Pietsch
lish involves not only a special morphological coding of the verb, but in many instances a re-organisation of the basic clausal architecture as a whole, especially with respect to the licensing and case marking of nominal arguments of the verb. This is a feature that English shares – although with characteristic differences in detail – with its neighboring and contact language, Irish. Certain forms of Hiberno-English dialects seem to have diverged from Standard English in a way that may strike the observer as surprising. While in Standard English, subject arguments of gerund clauses are coded exclusively as either genitives or accusatives, Hiberno-English instead allows nominative-marked subjects in this position, as shown in the 19th-century attestation in (1):
(1) My sister Bridget stopped with her old missus after I leaving [Normil04, 1855]
Although there is a considerable amount of literature on the grammar of HibernoEnglish, and on the question of possible contact-related influences on it, this phenomenon has so far not featured prominently in the discussion. If at all, it has usually been mentioned only in passing, in connection with the somewhat better-known issue of the subordinating use of and (see Section 2.2.2 below). However, the issue of non-finite nominative subject (henceforth NNS) constructions is interesting in its own right, and it has ramifications well beyond the subordinating and cases. In this article, I will provide a contrastive analysis of the relevant aspects of the grammars of Irish, Standard English, and Hiberno-English, focussing first on the morphological system of case-marking, and then on the syntactic structures encountered in non-finite clauses. In doing so, I will also provide a first descriptive outline documenting NNS constructions in older forms of Hiberno-English, based on data from a corpus of subliterary 18th and 19th century texts.2 In conclusion, I shall then sketch out a scenario of how the NNS constructions may have developed in Hiberno-English. I will argue that the use of nominative pronouns is not explainable in a straightforward way as a simple transfer feature from Irish, because (at least at first sight) it would seem that the corresponding structures in Irish should, if anything, have reinforced the use of accusative pronouns in these positions, as they are used in many other present-day varieties of English. I will then argue, on the other hand, that transfer of a rather more subtle kind did take place after all: it proceeded not from a simple equivalence relation between surface grammatical forms of the two languages, but rather from more abstract properties of the constructional frames in which these forms appear. This abstract, indirect transfer seems to have led to a rather paradoxical result, insofar as it has led to a surface distribution of forms that differs crucially both from Standard English and from Irish.
Nominative subjects of non-finite clauses in Hiberno-English
2. English and Irish in contrast English and Irish, while differing sharply from each other in their general typological characteristics in many important ways, nevertheless share a good deal of common ground in the use of non-finite verb forms in embedded clauses. A central role in Irish grammar is played by the verbal noun (VN). Besides being used in a periphrastic construction to mark a progressive, it corresponds in many of its other uses to either an English gerund or a to-infinitive. While there is a great deal of functional overlap between these categories in both languages, both of them also display a fair amount of internal variation in their use. It is with respect to one aspect of this variation that I will compare the grammars of the two languages in this paper: the question of case-marking and syntactic licensing of overt subject arguments of the gerund/verbal-noun clauses.
2.1
The case systems of English and Irish
The apparent paradox which one needs to face in attempting a contact-related explanation of the Hiberno-English NNS constructions lies in the fact that Irish, in the corresponding positions of non-finite constructions, uses forms that are often identified as accusative (object), not nominative (subject) forms. Hence, one might be led to expect that any Irish influence on Hiberno-English should re-inforce the use of accusatives rather than support the innovation of nominatives in these positions. The identification of the relevant Irish forms as accusatives is, however, based on the assumption of a fundamental equivalence between the relevant domains of English and Irish morphology. In order to show that this identification is indeed mistaken (cf. Genee 1998: 15), it is necessary to give a brief analysis of the case systems of both languages. As is well known, English lacks a nominative-accusative case distinction in lexical nouns and in most pronouns, retaining only the genitive as an overtly marked case,3 contrasting with a common or default case. Beyond this distinction, it has preserved a nominative-accusative contrast only in the closed set of personal pronoun forms I/me, he/him, she/her, we/us, they/them (and marginally who/whom). However, this contrast does not follow the functional pattern of a typical nominative-accusative distinction everywhere either, namely that of marking subjects and objects/complements respectively. There has been a rather strong tendency, in many modern varieties of English, to introduce seemingly accusative forms into traditionally nominative environments, especially in those that differ markedly from the prototypical subject position, which is immediately preverbal, topical, and unstressed. Sentences such as me and John are going or it’s me illustrate this tendency, which may be interpreted as a trend towards reanalysing the accusative forms into strong and the nominative forms into weak pronouns. It should be noted that in most environments where accusative forms encroach on traditionally nominative territory, they bear focus and are often phonologically stressed. Irish, too, rather like English, lacks a nominative-accusative case distinction in lexical nouns and in most pronouns. There exists, however, a formal contrast, restrict-
Lukas Pietsch
ed to third person pronouns. This contrast, which has traditionally often been described as one of nominative vs. accusative case, is today treated in the more neutral terms of ‘conjunct’ vs. ‘disjunct’ forms by most descriptive grammars of Irish (following Bráithre Críostaí 1960). However, modern discussions in the generative framework, based on the assumption of a universal repertoire of ‘structural cases’, have continued to discuss it in terms of nominative and accusative. When seen under this perspective, there is a perceived mismatch in ‘case’ usage between Hiberno-English and Irish in the environments in question here. The disjunct (or ‘accusative’) form of Irish is morphologically unmarked and (for the most part) historically older. The conjunct form (or ‘nominative’) is created fairly transparently from the disjunct by the addition of a prefixed element s-. Both disjunct and conjunct forms can be further expanded by another suffix to yield an emphatic, contrastive form: Table 1. Pronoun forms in Irish
Sg. Masc. Sg. Fem. Pl. (M/F)
disjunct
conjunct
disj. contr.
conj. contr.
é í iad
sé sí siad
eisean ise iadsan
seisean sise siadsan
The conjunct forms are used exclusively in the immediately post-verbal subject position of finite lexical verbs (Bráithre Críostaí 1960: 138). The disjunct forms are used everywhere else: as objects of finite verbs, as subjects and predicates in copula clauses (which in Irish have a syntax very different from that of normal verbs); in non-finite clauses; and also as parts of syntactically complex subject NPs after finite verbs, for i