This page intentionally left blank
Conversation Analysis “Conversation analysis” is an approach to the study of socia...
685 downloads
1886 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
Conversation Analysis “Conversation analysis” is an approach to the study of social interaction that focuses on practices of speaking that recur across a range of contexts and settings. The early studies in this tradition were based on the analysis of English conversation. More recently, however, conversation analysts have begun to study talk in a broader range of communities around the world. Through detailed analyses of recorded conversations, this book examines differences and similarities across a wide range of languages including Finnish, Japanese, Tzeltal Mayan, Russian and Mandarin. Bringing together interrelated methodological and analytic contributions, it explores topics such as the role of gaze in question-and-answer sequences, the organization of repair, and the design of responses to assessments. The emerging comparative perspective demonstrates how the structure of talk is inflected by the local circumstances within which it operates. jac k si dn e l l is an Associate Professor in the Department of Anthropology at the University of Toronto.
Studies in Interactional Sociolinguistics editors Paul Drew, Majorie Harness Goodwin, John J. Gumperz, Deborah Schifrin 1. Discourse Strategies John J. Gumperz 2. Language and Social Identity edited by John J. Gumperz 3. The Social Construction of Literacy Jenny Cook-Gumperz 4. Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage Penelope Brown and Stephen C. Levinson 5. Discourse Markers Deborah Schiffrin 6. Talking Voices: Repetition, Dialogue, and Imagery in Conversational Discourse Deborah Tannen 7. Conducting Interraction: Patterns of Behaviour in Focused Encounters Adam Kendon 8. Talk at Work: Interaction in Institutional Settings edited by Paul Drew and John Heritage 9. Grammar in Interaction: Adverbial Clauses in American English Conversations Cecilia E. Ford 10. Crosstalk and Culture in Sino-American Communication Linda W.L. Young (with a foreword by John J. Gumperz) 11. AIDS Counselling: Institutional Interaction and Clinical Practice Anssi Perakyla 12. Prosody in Conversation; Interactional Studies edited by Elizabeth Couper-Kuhlen and Margret Selting 13. Interaction and Grammar edited by Elinor Ochs, Emanual A. Schegloff and Sandra A. Thompson 14. Credibility in Court: Communicative Practices in the Camorra Triales Marco Jacquement 15. Interaction and the Development of Mind Anthony J. Wootton 16. The News Interview: Journalists and Public Figures on the Air Steven Clayman and John Heritage 17. Gender and Politeness Sara Mills 18. Laughter in Interaction Philip Glenn 19. Matters of Opinion: Talking about Public Issues Greg Myers 20. Communication in Medical Care: Interaction between Primary Care Physicians and Patients edited by John Heritage and Douglas Maynard 21. In Other Words: Variation in reference and narrative Deborah Schiffrin 22. Language in Interaction in an urban school Ben Rampton 23. Discourse and Identity edited by Anna De Fina, Deborah Schiffrin and Michale Bamberg 24. Reporting Talk: Reported Speech in Interaction edited by Elizabeth Holt and Rebecca Clift 25. The Social Construction of Literacy, 2nd edition by Jenny Cook-Gumperz 26. Talking Voices, 2nd edition by Deborah Tannen 27. Conversation Analysis: Comparative Perspectives edited by Jack Sidnell
Conversation Analysis Comparative Perspectives Edited by
Jack S i dn ell University of Toronto
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi, Dubai, Tokyo Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521883719 © Cambridge University Press 2009
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provision of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published in print format 2009 ISBN-13
978-0-511-63432-1
eBook (EBL)
ISBN-13
978-0-521-88371-9
Hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
List of figurespage vii List of tablesix List of contributorsxiii Transcription conventionsxv Part I Introduction 1
Comparative perspectives in conversation analysis Jack Sidnell
Part II Repair and beyond 2
Repetition in the initiation of repair Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
3
A cross-linguistic investigation of the site of initiation in same-turn self-repair Barbara Fox, Fay Wouk, Makoto Hayashi, Steven Fincke, Liang Tao, Marja-Leena Sorjonen, Minna Laakso, and Wilfrido Flores Hernandez
4
Repairing reference Maria Egbert, Andrea Golato, and Jeffrey D. Robinson
Part III Aspects of response
1 3
29 31
60
104
133
5
Projecting nonalignment in conversation Anna Lindström
135
6
Two answers to inapposite inquiries Trine Heinemann
159
vi
Contents 7
Gaze, questioning, and culture Federico Rossano, Penelope Brown, and Stephen C. Levinson
8 Negotiating boundaries in talk Makoto Hayashi and Kyung-eun Yoon Part IV Action formation and sequencing 9
Alternative responses to assessments Marja-Leena Sorjonen and Auli Hakulinen
10 Language-specific resources in repair and assessments Jack Sidnell 11 Implementing delayed actions Galina B. Bolden Part V Conclusion 12 One perspective on Conversation Analysis: Comparative Perspectives Emanuel A. Schegloff
187
250
279 281
304 326
355 357
Bibliography 407 Index436
Figures
4.1 4.2 4.3
Open-class repair German “Wa?” page 108 Open-class English “What?” 109 Underspecified referent repair initiation (URRI) German “Was.” 110 4.4 URRI German “Was denn.” 110 4.5 URRI English “What.” 111 7.1 Location of three cultures 204 7.2 Gaze toward other participant, by language 208 7.3 Gaze behavior across the three cultures clustered by participation role 209 7.4 Distribution of actions by languages 214 7.5 Distribution of percentages of each action in which the Q-speaker looks at the addressee, 215 by language 7.6 Distribution of percentages of each action in which the Q-recipient looks at the Q-speaker, 217 by language 7.7 Italian dyads 227 7.8 Tzeltal dyads 228 7.9 Yélî Dnye dyads 229 9.1 Responses to assessments with a verb repeat282
Tables
3.1 Post-beginning and pre-completion repair initiation 3.2 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in English 3.3 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Indonesian 3.4 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Finnish 3.5 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Bikol 3.6 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Japanese 3.7 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Sochiapam Chinantec 3.8 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Mandarin 3.9 Site of initiation of simple recycling repair initiated in monosyllabic words 3.10 Site of initiation of simple replacement repair initiated in monosyllablic words 3.11 Site of initiation in recycling repairs in words of three or more syllables 3.12 Site of initiation in replacement repairs in words of three or more syllables 3.13 Frequency of monosyllabic words for each repair type 3.14 Frequency of multisyllabic words for each repair type
page 68 75 77 77 78 78 79 79 81 82 84 84 86 86
x
Tables
3.15 Site of initiation of recycling repairs in bisyllabic words 89 3.16 Percentage of recycling repairs initiated in bisyllabic words 90 3.17 Recycling repairs: Bisyllabic words by syntactic class 91 3.18 Recycling repairs: Multisyllabic words by syntactic class 92 3.19 English replacement repairs by word type for monosyllabic words 93 3.20 Replacement repairs by word type for monosyllabic words 94 3.21 Word length in recycling repairs 95 7.1 Instances of Q-speaker and Q-recipient gaze toward other participant, by language 207 7.2 Logistic regression analysis predicting gaze toward other participant in relation to role (Q-recipient as reference group), by language 209 7.3 Logistic regression analysis predicting Q-speaker gaze toward Q-recipient in relation to language (Italian and Tzeltal as reference group) 210 7.4 Logistic regression analysis predicting Q-recipient gaze toward Q-speaker in relation to language (Italian and Tzeltal as reference group) 211 7.5 Instances of mutual gaze by language 213 7.6 Logistic regression analysis predicting mutual gaze in relation to language (Italian and Tzeltal as reference group) 213 7.7 Questions in which speakers look at recipients and recipients do not look back, by language 214 7.8 Distribution of actions performed by questions, by language 214 7.9 Q-speaker looking at Q-recipient, by action and by language 215 7.10 Q-recipient looking at Q-speaker, by question type and by language 217 7.11 Distribution of response types by language 218 7.12 Distribution of responses to questions, by language 218
Tables
xi
7.13 Distribution of questions that do not get responded to in which the recipient does not look at the speaker 220 7.14 Logistic regression analysis predicting no response 221 7.15 Logistic regression analysis predicting no response if Q-recipient is not gazing, by language 222 7.16 Q-speaker gaze, by language 222 7.17 Q-recipient gaze, by language 223 7.18 Questions in which lack of Q-speaker gaze toward Q-recipient motivated by question content or competing activity 224 7.19 Questions in which lack of Q-recipient gaze toward Q-speaker motivated by question content or competing activity 224 11.1 Transcription symbols 352 12.1 Distribution of “so”- and “oh”-prefaced sequence initiators388
Contributors
Galina B. Bolden, Department of Communication, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, N.J., USA Penelope Brown, Language Acquisition Group, Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics, Nijmegen, The Netherlands Maria Egbert, Department of Business Communication and Information Science, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark Steven Fincke, Nuance Communications, Cambridge, Mass., USA Barbara Fox, Department of Linguistics, University of Colorado, Boulder, Col., USA Andrea Golato, Department of Germanic Languages and Literatures, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Ill., USA Auli Hakulinen, Department of Finnish Language and Literature, University of Helsinki, Finland Makoto Hayashi, Department of East Asian Languages and Cultures, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champagne, Ill., USA Trine Heinemann, Department of Business Communication and Information Science, University of Southern Denmark, Denmark Wilfrido Flores Hernandez, Department of Applied Language Studies and Linguistics, University of Auckland, New Zealand Minna Laakso, Department of Speech Sciences, University of Helsinki, Finland Stephen C. Levinson, Language and Cognition Group, Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
xiv
Contributors
Anna Lindström, School of Humanities, Education and Social Sciences, Örebro University, Sweden Jeffrey D. Robinson, Department of Communication, Portland State University, Oregon, USA Federico Rossano, Department of Development and Comparative Psychology, Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Leipzig, Germany Emanuel A. Schegloff, Department of Sociology, University of California, Los Angeles, Calif., USA Jack Sidnell, Department of Anthropology, University of Toronto, Canada Marja-Leena Sorjonen, Research Institute for the Languages of Finland, Finland Liang Tao, Department of Linguistics, Ohio University, Athens, Ohio, USA Fay Wouk, Department of Applied Language Studies and Linguistics, University of Auckland, New Zealand Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu, Department of Linguistics and Asian/ Middle Eastern Languages, San Diego State University, Calif., USA Kyung-eun Yoon, Department of African and Asian Languages and Literatures, University of Florida, Gainesville, Fla., USA
Transcription conventions (from Schegloff 2000)
I. Temporal and sequential relationships Overlapping or simultaneous talk is indicated in a variety of ways. [
Separate left square brackets, one above the other on two successive lines with utterances by different speakers, indicates a point of overlap onset, whether at the start of an utterance or later.
] ]
Separate right square brackets, one above the other on two successive lines with utterances by different speakers indicates a point at which two overlapping utterances both end, where one ends while the other continues, or simultaneous moments in overlaps which continue.
=
Equal signs ordinarily come in pairs – one at the end of a line, and another at the start of the next line or one shortly thereafter. They are used to indicate two things:
(1) If the two lines connected by the equal signs are by the same speaker, then there was a single, continuous utterance with no break or pause, which was broken up in order to accommodate the placement of overlapping talk.
(2) If the lines connected by two equal signs are by different speakers, then the second followed the first with no discernable silence between them, or was “latched” to it.
A single equal sign indicates no break in an ongoing piece of talk, where one might otherwise expect it, e.g., after a completed sentence.
(0.5) Numbers in parentheses indicate silence, represented in tenths of a second; what is given here in the left margin indicates 0.5 seconds of silence. Silences may be marked either within an utterance or between utterances.
xvi (.)
Transcription conventions A dot in parentheses indicates a “micropause,” hearable but not readily measurable without instrumentation; ordinarily less than 0.2 of a second.
II. Aspects of speech delivery, including aspects of intonation The punctuation marks are not used grammatically, but to indicate intonation. The period indicates a falling, or final, intonation . contour, not necessarily the end of a sentence. Similarly, a ? question mark indicates rising intonation, not necessarily a , question, and a comma indicates “continuing” intonation, not ¿ necessarily a clause boundary. The inverted question mark is used to indicate a rise stronger than a comma but weaker than a question mark. ::
Colons are used to indicate the prolongation or stretching of the sound just preceding them. The more colons, the longer the stretching. On the other hand, graphically stretching a word on the page by inserting blank spaces between the letters does not necessarily indicate how it was pronounced; it is used to allow alignment with overlapping talk.
-
A hyphen after a word or part of a word indicates a cut-off or self-interruption, often done with a glottal or dental stop.
word
Underlining is used to indicate some form of stress or emphasis, either by increased loudness or higher pitch. The more underlining, the greater the emphasis.
word
Therefore, underlining sometimes is placed under the first letter or two of a word, rather than under the letters which are actually raised in pitch or volume.
WOrd
Especially loud talk may be indicated by upper case; again, the louder, the more letters in upper case. And in extreme cases, upper case may be underlined.
o
The degree sign indicates that the talk following it was markedly quiet or soft.
o
wordo
When there are two degree signs, the talk between them is markedly softer than the talk around it.
Combinations of underlining and colons are used to indicate intonation contours: _: If the letter(s) preceding a colon is/are underlined, then there is an “inflected” falling intonation contour on the vowel (you can hear the pitch turn downward). : If a colon is itself underlined, then there is an inflected rising intonation contour on the vowel (i.e., you can hear the pitch turn upward)
Transcription conventions
xvii
↑ ↓
The up and down arrows mark sharper rises or falls in pitch than would be indicated by combinations of colons and underlining, or they may mark a whole shift, or resetting, of the pitch register at which the talk is being produced.
> < < > <
The combination of “more than” and “less than” symbols indicates that the talk between them is compressed or rushed. Used in the reverse order, they can indicate that a stretch of talk is markedly slowed or drawn out. The “less than” symbol by itself indicates that the immediately following talk is “jump-started,”, i.e. sounds like it starts with a rush.
hhh (hh)
Hearable aspiration is shown where it occurs in the talk by the letter h – the more h’s, the more aspiration. The aspiration may represent breathing, laughter, etc. if it occurs inside the boundaries of a word, it may be enclosed in parentheses in order to set it apart from the sounds of the word. If the aspiration is an inhalation, it is shown with a dot before it.
.hh
III. Other markings (( ))
Double parentheses are used to mark transcriber’s descriptions of events, rather than representations of them: ((cough)), ((sniff)), ((telephone rings)), ((footsteps)), ((whispered)), ((pause)), and the like.
(word)
When all or part of an utterance is in parentheses, or the speaker identification is, this indicates uncertainty on the transcriber’s part, but represents a likely possibility.
(lit/bit)
Where alternate hearings are possible these are enclosed in parentheses and separated by a back slash.
( )
Empty parentheses indicate that something is being said, but no hearing (or, in some cases, speaker identification) can be achieved.
IV. Multi-linear transcription conventions Many of the transcriptions in this book are of talk in languages other than English and include one or two lines of glossing. In three-line transcripts the first line is a broad phonetic representation of the talk in the original language. The second line is a morpheme-by-morpheme gloss using a combination of word-for-word translation and abbreviations such as ASP to indicate particles and other functional items that do not admit of a direct translation into English. Authors who use these abbreviations in the transcripts they present include a key explaining them at the conclusion of the chapter. The third line presents an idiomatic English gloss – an attempt to get as close as possible to the contextual sense or meaning of the utterance. The following example from the chapter by Wu illustrates:
xviii
Transcription conventions 01 L: wo dou hai mei jian guo ta.
I
all still N see ASP he
‘I haven’t met him yet.”
In two line transcriptions the morpheme-by-morpheme gloss is not included. The following example is from the chapter by Sidnell:
01 C: him mada biilongz tuu Hamilton.
his mother is from Hamilton.
Part I
Introduction
1 Comparative perspectives in conversation analysis Jack Sidnell
Introduction Comparison of the various ways in which people talk in different sociocultural and linguistic communities can easily lead to two, apparently contradictory, conclusions. On the one hand, the diversity of conduct is striking. People speak different languages, they are oriented to markedly different sociocultural norms of posture and tone, they inhabit very different social (as well as economic, political, etc.) worlds and thus find occasion to talk in vastly different “contexts.” One need only compare, for instance, the Mayan villagers of Tenejapa with Yélî Dnye speaking Rossel Islanders to see this diversity (as Rossano, Brown and Levinson do in this volume). On the other hand, the commonalities are what are remarkable. Everywhere turns-at-talk are constructed and opportunities to speak distributed, courses of action are launched and co-ordinatively managed, troubles of speaking, hearing and understanding are located and their repair attempted. These commonalities suggest that, for all the diversity we see, people everywhere encounter the same sorts of organizational problems and make use of the same basic abilities in their solutions to them – a capacity for reading other’s intentions, anticipating and projecting actions, calculating inferences and processing information available to them (see Levinson 2006, Schegloff 2006). If these abilities and problems appear universal and generic, the particular ways in which they are implemented or solved is anything but. After all, whatever happens in interaction happens through the medium of some specific set of locally available semiotic resources. Over the past forty years, conversation analysts
4
Jack Sidnell
have shown that actions in talk-in-interaction are formed through the use of distinctive prosodic patterns, lexical collocations, wordorder patterns as well as language-specific objects such as English “oh” (Heritage 1984), Mandarin “ a” (Wu 2004), Finnish “ nii” (Sorjonen 2001) and so on (see Stivers and Sidnell 2005 for an overview). Of course, these semiotic resources vary significantly and systematically across different languages and communities. Some languages such as Vietnamese and Mandarin use a set of distinct tonal contours to signal differences of lexical meaning; others do not. Some languages are, like English, left-headed, whereas others, such as Korean and Japanese , are right-headed. In some languages, such as Vietnamese again, words are typically made up of one morpheme having a single meaning whereas in others words often consist of several morphemes some of which may embody multiple meanings (e.g., -ó in Spanish “habló” expresses indicative mode, third person, singular, past tense, and perfective aspect). Because every turn-at-talk is fashioned out of the linguistic resources of some particular language, the rich and enduring semiotic structures of language must be consequential in a basic way for social interaction. So, although the problems are generic and the abilities apparently universal , the actual forms that interaction takes are shaped by and adapted to the particular resources that are locally available for their expression. The chapters in this book contain detailed analyses of talk in English, Finnish , German , Italian , Japanese , Mandarin , Tzeltal (Mayan ), Russian , Swedish and Yélî Dnye and provide the beginnings of an answer to the question of how the local resources of these particular languages and other semiotic systems shape, constrain, torque or inflect the otherwise generic and universal underlying organization of talkin-interaction. In recent work, both Schegloff (1996c) and Fox (2007) have argued that over time the organizational contingencies of interaction significantly shape (though do not determine) grammar. This book offers a complementary view in which, at some given point in time, the semiotic resources of any particular language – especially grammar – essentially define the possibilities for social action accomplished through talk. Notice, that this way of putting things largely obviates the theoretical syntactician’s appeal to a “deep” level of linguistic structure or “logical form” at which such “surface” differences between
Introduction
5
languages more or less completely evaporate. For social interaction does not work with such “underlying” mental representations; it works with the actual, observable surfaces of grammar and prosody as well as the particular words and phrases that constitute possibly complete turn units and recognizable actions. As we will see in this chapter, it is this surface patterning of language that has consequences for turn-taking , repair and other aspects of the organization of talk-in-interaction. The linguistics that forms a natural companion to conversation analytic studies is thus the descriptive and empirical tradition that investigates not mental models but rather actual living languages in all their peculiarity and nuance often from a comparative perspective.1 In fact, recent work in interactional linguistics has emphasized and shown the value of just this connection (see Ford et al. 2002 for an overview). Some of the complexity of the relationship between (1) the specific semiotic resources of a particular language, (2) language and culture-independent principles, and (3) the contexted courses of action within which language is actually embedded can be seen through a consideration of repetition . Turns designed to show that they are repeats of something that someone has just said are apparently found in all communities and in all languages. But now consider that, strictly speaking, “unmarked” repetition of what someone has just said is interactionally impossible. That is to say, one cannot simply and solely repeat what someone has just said without adding something to it. While it’s possible for a second speaker to do a repeat in such as way as to make it hearable as saying “exactly” what another just said (for example, by preserving not only the words another speaker has used but also the original deictic forms as well the intonation and other aspects of prosody ), to do so is to do something in addition to repetition. Repetition of this kind is hearable as a verbatim repeat and thus possibly as “mimicry.” This points to the fact then that even in repeating what another has said, the speaker necessarily draws on the semiotic resources of some particular language to mark, and thus to frame, the repeat in some way. 2 Typically then, a repeat involves the use of some intonational or periphrastic marking which shows to what end this bit of talk is being repeated. One very common thing is for the repeat speaker to produce his or her talk with what is typically known as “question
6
Jack Sidnell
intonation” as in the following case from an English telephone call in which Ben has called for someone he refers to first as “Mary” and subsequently, after Ann indicates that she does not recognize anyone by that name, as “the tax lady” (Jefferson 1972, Schegloff et al. 1977). (1) XTR1 01 ((click)) 02 Ann: Hello:¿ 03 Ben: hHello, Ma:ry? 04 (0.2) 05 Ann: No: 06 (0.3) 07 Ben: No, not Ma:ry?= 08 Ann: =No, it’s not Ma:ry. There’s no Mary he:re 09 (.) 10 I don’ think:hh 11 (3.0) 12 Ben: The tax lady: 13 (0.2) 14 Ann: → The tax lad(h)y::? 15 Ben: Ya hhh= 16 Ann: =Nah. (.) Wha number were you callin’.
Another common intonation-marking for repeats in English involves stressing the first syllable of a multi-syllabic word. In (2) below Ann and Bev are discussing the diet and regime of a woman who is pregnant. (2) YYZ_T1A_A&D 2.03 01 Bev: anyway [.hhhh [I know. 02 Ann: 03 (0.2) 04 Ann: an’ i- (.) gra:vol an all these (s[ ) 05 Bev: → [gr↑a:vo:l 06 Ann: She takes gravol al- everyda:y.
Notice that whereas in Extract 1 the repeat elicits from Ben a confirmation (“Ya” at line 15) in Extract 2 it does not: instead, Bev continues with the telling. This suggests that in Extract 2 Bev uses the repeat to do something other than check her hearing of “gravol.” While these forms of marking appear to be quite common across a wide range of languages, more obviously language-specific
Introduction
7
resources are used in repeats too. Stivers (2005) for instance has described one kind of repetition in English that involves, among other things, expanding the pronoun + verb contraction of the original utterance (It’s → It is). Consider the following case from a conversation between co-workers. (3) YYZ 27 Clare: Just we’ve got- Michael and I did the resourcing for next 28 → week and it’s just- it’s=just ughu(h)h(hh) .hh and it’s a 29 short wee:k so 30 (.) 31 Alice: → Yeah:- Oh:yeah it is a short week= 32 Clare: Ye[ah 33 Alice: [.hh[hh 34 Clare: [so (.) I’m rilly rilly sorry,
Indeed, for English, next-turn repeats take a great variety of forms and are deployed in a wide range of actions such as confirmation (Schegloff 1996b), other-initiation of repair (Schegloff et al. 1977), correction (Schegloff et al. 1977; Goodwin 1984), displays of appreciation (Jefferson 1972) and agreement (Pomerantz 1984). Coupled with the particular semiotic resources of English grammar, prosody and lexis, the apparently universal practice of repetition is employed to effect a range of interactional outcomes. A number of the chapters in this book consider practices that involve repetition including Hayashi and Yoon on Japanese and Korean , Sorjonen and Hakulinen on Finnish , Wu on Mandarin , Heinemann on Danish , Bolden on Russian . These studies provide further evidence of the ways in which an apparently universal aspect of interactional organization is shaped and, in some ways, constrained by the semiotic resources of a given language thus providing unique possibilities for social action. 3 A comparative perspective in conversation analysis The chapters collected in this book examine the organization of social interaction and, more specifically, talk-in-interaction, from a comparative, cross-linguistic perspective. Although some of them draw at points on a number of other traditions (particularly functional/interactional linguistics ), the analyses they present are largely
8
Jack Sidnell
developed within the framework of conversation analysis (hereafter CA) – an approach to talk and social interaction which emerged in the writings and lectures of Harvey Sacks , Emanuel Schegloff and Gail Jefferson .4 CA takes not language per se as its focus but rather the practical activities in which language (along with gesture , gaze and other aspects of bodily comportment) is deployed, that is, talk-in-interaction. However, comparison of such practical activities across different languages brings the relevance of grammatical (and other) structures into view as the chapters in this book demonstrate. In this chapter, I sketch some of the conceptual background of comparative studies in CA. I begin with a consideration of previous studies distinguishing the approach taken within CA from that known as cross-cultural pragmatics. I then move to consider the CA methodology. Here I note a similarity between structuralist or distributionalist methods in linguistics and the CA approach of using collections. I argue that the former, but not the latter, essentially undermine the very possibility of comparison. Structuralism, taken to its logical conclusion, reveals the particularity of any system (e.g., of pronouns, or verbal tenses) and the elements of which it is composed. Since each element is defined by its relation to all the others, each element is a unique outcome of the particular system in which it is embedded. The result, as is well known, are accounts which are wholly hermetic and incapable of being compared to one another. In contrast, CA focuses on generic interactional problems which find solutions in the local resources of particular languages and social systems. For example, turn-taking and repair address interactional problems which must be solved in any community if its members are to coordinate their actions through talk-in-interaction. This approach actually encourages comparison: by looking across different languages/communities we can see the way in which the same interactional problem is solved through the mobilization of different resources (Schegloff 2006). Conversation analysts are keenly aware of the method ological and theoretical issues raised by a comparative perspective. In an early co-authored paper, Schegloff and Sacks (1974: 234–235) wrote: The materials with which we have worked are audiotapes and transcripts of naturally occurring interactions […] with differing numbers of participants and different combinations of participant attributes. There is a
Introduction
9
danger attending this way of characterizing our materials, namely, that we be heard as proposing the assured relevance of numbers, attributes of participants, etc., to the way the data are produced, interpreted, or analyzed by investigators or by the participants themselves. Such a view carries considerable plausibility, but for precisely that reason it should be treated with extreme caution, and be introduced only where warrant can be offered for the relevance of such characterizations of the data from the data themselves. […] The considerations just adduced […] restrain us from further characterizing it here.
And the authors go on: For example, they restrain us from characterizing our findings as relating to “some general features of conversation rules in American English” – a suggestion offered by Dell Hymes (personal communication), for that suggests implicitly an ethnic or national or language identification as a relevant putative boundary for both our materials and findings. We cannot offer a warrant for asserting such a boundary and we suspect others cannot either.
The passage sums up quite succinctly the distinctive position which conversation analysts have adopted toward what are referred to in this passage as “participant attributes.” Whereas other approaches such as linguistic anthropology and sociolinguistics typically treat participant attributes as self-evident features of “context” or, alternatively, as “external variables” to be correlated with aspects of speech behavior, CA shifts the burden of evidence by requiring researchers to show that putative “characteristics” of the participants (such as race, ethnicity, gender) have some “procedural consequentiality” or demonstrable relevance for the participants themselves in terms of the specific ways in which the interaction is organized.5 In the passage quoted above, Schegloff and Sacks characterized this as a reluctance to invoke a boundary where none seemed to be warranted by the data being examined. Importantly, Schegloff and Sacks were not denying the existence of differences either between groups within a society or between societies. Instead, what they were pointing to were the method ological and theoretical issues involved in making claims about the relevance of such differences for the organization of interaction. Within CA then, researchers have emphasized the various ways in which “participant attributes” are picked out and made relevant to the talk of the moment (see for instance Goodwin 1987; Schegloff 1991, 1992b; Sacks 1995).
10
Jack Sidnell
There were deep underlying issues at stake here – ones that Sacks had initially addressed in his work on membership categorization devices and that Moerman (1974, for instance) had applied to problems of ethnic categorization in anthropology . As Goodwin puts it, “showing that a category can be accurately applied to a participant does not demonstrate either that the participants themselves are dealing with each other in terms of such a category, or that it is in fact a relevant feature of the activity being studied” (1987: 120). A speaker (or recipient) may be Catholic, six feet tall, male, a dentist, a vegetarian or whatever else without this being in any way relevant to the way he talks on some particular occasion. Sacks noted in his lectures that all societies appear to divide people into groups based on at least two axes of difference: gender and age (Schegloff 2002c). It was not an interest in universals of social organization that prompted Sacks ’ noticing of this. Rather, the existence of at least two axes of difference meant that any given individual could be described or categorized in more than one way. As such, any description of a participant (as a male, a child, etc.) required some “warrant” or motivation, some evidence that this and not some alternative was the relevant descriptive category. It is not difficult to see how these considerations bear on the problems of comparison to which the chapters in this book are addressed. How can we, for instance, warrant a description of the data as “requests in Polish,” “French compliments” or whatever where, typically, the participants do not display any overt orientation to the relevance of the language being used or their ethnicity?6 This is a particularly difficult problem and this book does not offer a single, conclusive solution to it. Rather, different authors take somewhat different approaches. One possible solution is discussed in this introduction: this involves linking the practices of talk-in-interaction to particular, distinctive aspects of the language being spoken thus warranting a characterization of those practices in terms of the language employed. The idea then is that particular languages provide specific resources and also establish unique constraints for the organization of interaction. Grammar, culture, and the organization of repair A few years after the Schegloff and Sacks paper cited above was published, Moerman (1977) addressed the issue of comparison
Introduction
11
in a study of repair in Thai -Lue materials. If differences could be located between the Thai-Lue and English materials, these might be related to differences in language structure, social arrangement or, perhaps, culture. However, in the main, the study did not reveal significant differences in the organization of repair and Moerman (1977: 875) was led to conclude: “the detailed, systemic, and massive parallels between” Thai and American English corpora “support the claim that the domain described by Sacks , Schegloff and Jefferson is conversation – without respect to the language, nation, class, or culture in which it occurs.” In contrast to work in both cross-cultural pragmatics and linguistic anthropology, early comparative research in CA provided evidence of massive, underlying structural similarities in interaction from very different communities. Whereas both crosscultural pragmatics and linguistic anthropology tended to work from the assumption of significant differences between communities/cultures, conversation analysts began with a focus on generic interactional problems which had to be, in some way, solved in any community. For instance, the phenomena to which a conversational repair mechanism is addressed – misunderstandings, misspeakings and the like – are universal and ubiquitous. If participants are to engage in coordinated action they will necessarily require some mechanism for dealing with these issues. At a finer level of detail, misunderstandings and misspeakings seem to take similar forms in every community. Misunderstandings arise because the recipient does not know a word the speaker has used or did not hear it adequately. Misspeakings arise when a speaker uses the wrong word or cannot find the one they need and so on. Given that everywhere the issues are more or less the same, it is hardly surprising to find that the solutions developed for dealing with them are also strikingly similar. This is not, however, to say that there are no differences. Here, I will briefly note a few of these staying with the problem of repair; below (see “Mobilization of Local Resources to Solve Generic Problems of Interaction” ) I discuss some claims for profound differences in turn-organization and turn-taking between Japanese and English. In a comparison of repair in English and German, Egbert (1996: 587) argued that “repair is sensitive to the linguistic inventory of a given language” in several different ways. First, Egbert showed that grammatical markings present in German but not English (such
12
Jack Sidnell
as articles marked for gender, i.e. “das” and “der”) were subject to repair. Second, she observed that case-marking in German can serve as a resource for framing, and thus locating, the repairable item. Third, she showed that, in other-initiated repair, grammatical congruities across turns, the marking of an item as masculine singular accusative for instance, may serve as a resource for linking repairable , repair initiator and the repair itself. In a study which I discuss in greater detail below, Fox et al. (1996) noted three differences between self-repair in English and Japanese and link these to the very different “syntactic practices” of the two languages. First, similar to Egbert ’s finding for German, Fox et al. find that certain kinds of morphological repair are possible in Japanese but not English. They illustrate with the following example: (4) K: ja nanji goro ni kurida[shi-*]soo? Then what.time about OBL go.out “Then about what time (shall we) go out?”
The authors (Fox et al. 1996: 202) observe that in this example the “speaker K replaces only the inflection al ending of the verb with another. […] The first form that K produces in this example (kurida-shi) has the adverbial ending -shi. […] However K cuts off the verb and replaces -shi with the ‘cohortative’ ending -soo. In other words, K has replaced one bound morpheme with another.” In English, repair does not operate on inflection al endings. This difference can likely be accounted for in terms of verbal morphology in the two languages. The Japanese verb endings -shi and -soo are full syllables consisting of a consonant and a vowel. In contrast, English verb endings (with the exception of -ing and -s in certain contexts) are, typically, pronounced as a single consonant sound. They are thus unpronounceable independently of the word to which they are attached. This prevents their production as independent units in self-repair as in the following invented example (from Fox et al. 1996: 202). (5) She look[ed]-*s at the table.
Moreover, as the authors point out, Japanese is an agglutinating language in which each morpheme has roughly a single grammatical meaning. In contrast, English is characterized by a relatively
Introduction
13
greater degree of fusion in inflection al morphology (Comrie 1981). So, for instance, verbal -s carries the meaning of present, third person and singular. Bound verbal morphemes are thus semantically complex in English but not in Japanese . English verbal morphemes (or at least verbal -s) may also indicate agreement with the subject (third person) of the clause and thus link back to something earlier in the utterance where as Japanese verbal markers do not. The authors (Fox et al. 1996: 203) conclude that “these […] differences between English and Japanese verb endings suggest to us that at a variety of levels verb endings in English are more tightly ‘bonded’ to the verb than are verb endings in Japanese and hence less available for individual replacement than are verb endings in Japanese.” Another difference noted by these authors involves practices for delaying the production “of next noun” due in self-repair . The following illustrates one common practice in English: (6) on the back of his pickup truck [with a,*] (0.4) with a jack.
Here the speaker begins a prepositional phrase, initiates repair and then recycles the preposition and article before then producing the rest of the phrase. Recycling the preposition (and article) thus “constitutes a procedure for delaying the production of the next item due. This procedure could, for example, be part of a word search , a request for recipient gaze, management of overlapping talk, and/or production of a dispreferred” (Fox et al. 1996: 204). Since Japanese has postpositions rather than prepositions (and no articles), this procedure for delay is not available. Fox et al. show that Japanese speakers often use a quite different procedure to effect the same result: employing a demonstrative pronoun (translated as “that”) as a “place holder while the speaker looks for a lexically specific noun” (Fox et al. 1996: 206). The studies of Egbert and Fox et al. thus link language-specific practices of repair to particular grammatical features of the language in question. Some of the variations in repair observed in the literature are accounted for not by reference to the grammar of the language but rather to the beliefs of the speakers. Ochs (1984: 328–329) writes of the type of other-initiated repair she terms “clarification ’: While clarification is a universal activity, the manner in which clarification is accomplished varies cross-cultural ly. Prefer ences for
14
Jack Sidnell
accomplishing clarification are embedded in local principles of social order and local epistemologies. More specifically, I would like to suggest that both the conditions under which clarification takes place (what gets clarified, who participates in the activity of clarification, in which roles), and the discourse procedures speakers prefer to use, index members’ views of knowledge, particularly members’ views on the limits of knowledge (what can be known) and the paths to knowledge (how knowledge is acquired).
Ochs goes on to contrast two basic practices in clarification – a “minimal grasp strategy” in which the one initiating clarification employs quizzical expressions, statements of non-understanding, WH-questions and other directives “to elicit from the child a reformulation of all or part of the unclear utterance or gesture”, and an “expressed guess strategy” in which it is the one initiating clarification “who attempts a reformulation of the unclear act” (1984: 331). Ochs argues that the more or less total absence of explicit guessing in the clarification practices of Western Samoans in favor of a minimal grasp strategy is linked to, among other things, local conceptions of knowledge: “ Samoans generally display a strong disprefer ence for guessing at what is going on in another person’s mind. This dispreference has reflexes in a range of verbal activities,” including those of clarification (Ochs 1984: 337, see also Ochs 1991). CA and Cross-Cultural Pragmatics I want to briefly discuss here the way in which the approach taken in these chapters differs from that commonly known as crosscultural pragmatics. One major set of differences is method ological. Work done under the rubric of cross-cultural pragmatics typically employs some kind of questionnaire method in which respondents are asked to select the most appropriate or least appropriate response to some described situation. Alternatively respondents may be required to engage in a “discourse completion task.” In contrast, CA employs a method ology of observation and collection of naturalistic interactional data (see below). At an even more fundamental level, these two approaches exhibit quite different conceptualization of the object of study. Cross-cultural pragmatics tends to focus on the different ways in which actions such as
Introduction
15
“promises,” “requests,” “invitations,” “refusals” are managed and understood by recipients, often in terms of their implications for “face” and notions of politeness (see for instance Blum-Kulka et al. 1989). In other words, actions such as “requests,” “invitations” and the like are treated as though they were objective categories of social action providing a template through which one can view interactional data. CA adopts a different perspective. As Schegloff observed in an early paper (1984: 30): “it is misleading to start to account for such categories of action as questions, promises, and so on as the analytic objects of interest. They are commonsense, not technical, categories and should be treated accordingly.” Rather than begin with such “common sense categories of action” as promises and such, CA begins with relatively stable organizations of practice in talk-in-interaction, e.g., answering the phone with “hello?,” referring to persons by name or some alternative recognitional form (see Sacks and Schegloff 1979; Schegloff 1996a; Stivers 2007), multiple sayings such as “no no no” (Stivers 2004), etc.7 The practices of repair discussed in the previous section provide another example. Notice that with a format such as (partial repeat + WH word), a speaker may accomplish a wide range of actions such as expressing surprise in response to a news report (“They’re going where?”), challenging a previous speakers version of events (“You did what?”), requesting clarification (“ Move what”), etc. (see Schegloff 1997b). The contrast here between CA and cross-cultural pragmatics is a decisive one. A focus on practices of speaking, rather than “action-types,” suggests that whatever action a given utterance (or part of an utterance) is understood by the participants to be doing is a contingent outcome. Participants understand some practice of speaking as doing a particular action by considering it in relation to the local sequential context in which it is produced (i.e. after a recognizable news report, an excuse, a suggestion, etc.). In that sense, categories of action are themselves the product of local interpretive work. This perhaps accounts for a basic problem within cross-cultural pragmatics of identifying comparable “actions” in the first place. That is, identifying invitations in Russian , Japanese, Samoan, and Greek so that they can then be compared necessarily involves a reification – a treatment of
16
Jack Sidnell
utterances as if each transparently conveyed a unique “illocutionary force.” Practices, structures, distributions Bloomfield (e.g., 1946, 1970) is often chided today for his distributional method in which one accounts for the function of a given item by looking, one might say, dispassionately, – that is, without regard to its apparent “meaning” – at the positions in which it can be found to occur and the various alternatives for which it may substitute. This basic conceptual framework behind structuralism , in which relations in presentia and in absentia are more important than links between the sign and the object (designatum), has broad theoretical and method ological consequences. Perhaps most importantly, it offers an arguably more objective view than an impressionistic sense of what any given instance of a phenomenon “means” or is “doing.” I do not think it does CA any injustice to say that it employs a, broadly speaking, distributional method – though it is one tempered by detailed attention to each particular case. Analysis is based on a collection of instances. Such a collection not only allows for the identification of an unmarked or default pattern (for discussion of this usage see Stivers , Enfield and Levinson 2007; Stivers 2007; Enfield 2007), it also reveals the operation of underlying prefer ences or principles. Collections allow also for the identification of “deviant” instances in which the practice does not (for whatever reason) follow its normal course – a “deviance” to which participants themselves orient. Such deviant cases frequently reveal participants’ own orientations to the various contingencies involved in the execution of that practice – orientations which are typically unobservable in cases which conform to normative expectations and which are therefore literally unremarkable. In the context of an examination of practices for referring to persons, for instance, a collection of instances allows the analyst to distinguish cases in which just reference is being done from those in which something in addition to this is being accomplished. Consider, for instance, a case in which a spouse returns home from work and is met immediately with, “What did she say?”. Use of a locally subsequent form (the anaphor “she”) in a
Introduction
17
locally initial position (i.e. without any previous use of a name) can bring off that this has “been on my mind throughout the interim,” that this is, in effect, “a continuation of the earlier conversation” (Schegloff 1996a: 451). Referring to oneself by name (“Jack doesn’t like that!”) is another non-default usage that can be used to convey footing shifts of various kinds (see Schegloff 1996a). It is worth noting the clear resonances with structuralism here. Consider Schegloff ’s analysis of continuers such as “uh huh” presented in his paper “Discourse As Interactional Achievement: Some Uses of ‘Uh Huh’ and Other Things That Come Between Sentences” (Schegloff 1982). In characterizing “discourse as an interactional achievement,” Schegloff draws attention to the fact that a spate of talk composed of more than one “sentence” (or turn-constructional unit, etc.) is the product of methodic work by speaker and recipient(s) since it necessarily involves the negotiation of places at which transfer to a next speaker might have otherwise been effected. One key resource in such an accomplishment are vocalizations such as “uh huh,” “mm hmm,” “yeah” and the like typically labeled “backchannels” in the literature. Schegloff (1982: 78) notes that in the literature, two related characterizations have been offered to deal with these bits of behavior. According to one, they are evidence of attention, interest, and/or understanding on the listener’s part. (Thus Fries 1952: 49, “signals of this continued attention,” or Kendon 1967: 44, “appears to do no more than signal […] that he is attending and following what is being said”). A second use of such behavior proposed in this literature is that it “keeps the conversation going smoothly” (Dittman and Llewellyn 1967: 342), or “appears to provide the auditor with a means for participating actively in the conversation, thus facilitating the general coordination of action by both participants” (Duncan and Fiske 1977: 202–203). After noting that while a coherent set of cases can be assembled in which participants use “uh huh” and other such objects to deal with issues of attention (cases in which, e.g., “attention was indeed problematic for the parties” (Schegloff 1982: 79) or in which the “uh huh” responds to the use of a try-marked recognitional person reference), Schegloff goes on to point out a number of problems with such characterizations. They are, in the end, of course largely
18
Jack Sidnell
impressionistic. Schegloff (1982: 81) offers an alternate account, arguing that: perhaps the most common usage of “uh huh,” etc. is to exhibit on the part of its producer an understanding that an extended unit of talk is underway by another, and that it is not yet, or may not yet be (even ought not yet be), complete. It takes the stance that the speaker of that extended unit should continue talking, and in that continued talking should continue that extended unit. “Uh huh,” etc. exhibit this understanding, and take this stance, precisely by passing an opportunity to produce a full turn at talk. When so used, utterances such as “uh huh” may properly be termed “continuers.”
Within such an account, the notion of signaling attention takes on a different cast. Points of possible completion in a continuing speaker’s talk are structurally relevant positions in which the recipient may properly display their understanding of the current state of the talk and “show their intention to pass the opportunity to take a turn-at-talk that they might otherwise initiate at that point” (Schegloff 1982: 81). So, with “uh huh” etc., a recipient passes the opportunity to do any sort of fuller turn. The analysis begins then with a specification of the particular sequential environment in which “uh huh” and other such tokens are deployed. Schegloff then goes on to consider what else can occur in that same position noting that were a fuller turn done it would necessarily be a turn of some particular type and would thus be doing some specific action or actions. Thus, the opportunity being passed up by use of “uh huh” is an opportunity “to do whatever might have relevantly been done at that point” (1982: 87). Schegloff (1982: 87) asks “are there any kinds of actions which have some kind of ‘general relevance’ in conversation,” actions “not made relevant by the particulars of someone’s immediately preceding talk or behavior?” The obvious candidate is other-initiated repair which Sacks described in his first transcribed lecture as an “occasionally usable device” meaning that “there doesn’t have to be a particular sort of thing preceding it; it can come at any place in a conversation” ( 1995: I, 6). As Schegloff (1982: 87) puts it, “it appears that there are no systematic exclusion rules on the possible relevance of nextturn repair initiation in any possible turn position.” “Uh huh,” etc., in passing the opportunity to do a full turn at talk, “can be seen to be passing an opportunity to initiate repair on the immediately preceding talk” thus providing an obvious basis for “the
Introduction
19
ordinary inference that the talk into which they are interpolated is being understood” (Schegloff 1982: 88). Schegloff (1982: 88) concludes: It is not that there is a direct semantic convention in which “uh huh” equals a claim or signal of understanding. It is rather that devices are available for the repair of problems of understanding the prior talk, and the passing up of those opportunities, which “uh huh” can do, is taken as betokening the absence of such problems.8
Schegloff ’s alternative to the impressionistic account in which “uh huh,” etc. are treated as “displays of attention”9 involves identifying a position, the transition relevance place constituted by a turn’s possible completion, and examining the particular object in relation to the other objects which might have occurred there – and which participants themselves can see could have been done in that position. The result is an interactionally generated, positionally sensitive “paradigm”. 1. Continuer (e.g., “uh huh”). 2. Full-turn (whatever might have otherwise been done). 3. Other-initiation of repair. The sense of “uh huh” (as, variously, conveying attention, understanding, agreement ) is a product of its place within a positionally sensitive yet highly restricted set of alternatives – relations in absentia. Though CA draws, as I hope to have shown, in a basic way on a structural or distributional method , it does not fall into the trap of structuralist analysis which, taken to its logical conclusion, reveals the particularity of any system (e.g., of pronouns or verbal tenses) and the elements of which it is composed. Since each element is defined by its relation to all the others, each element is a unique outcome of the particular system in which it is embedded. The result are accounts that are wholly hermetic and incapable of being compared to one another. The item in the phonemic inventory designated as /p/ for a given language will necessarily be unique to that system of distinctions. The consequences of a strict-structuralism have been noted with respect to diachronic comparision – that is, comparisons of the “same language” at different points in time. As Harris and Taylor
20
Jack Sidnell
(1997) note, if the consequences of Saussure’s structuralism are accepted, the comparative assumptions of historical linguists , who happily trace the evolution of consonants and vowels from IndoEuropean to the present, are undermined. Accepting structuralist premises, it makes no sense to suppose that the earlier b was the “same consonant” as its later manifestation p, or that “the same word” appeared in Latin as causa but later in French as chose. For if linguistic units did not exist except as structural units defined within a single linguistic system, it was impossible for any given unit to “survive” from one system A into a different system B at a later point in time. (Harris and Taylor 1997: 215)
Even where a consonant (e.g., m) appears to have survived and maintained its phonetic character from Latin to French because at each stage there was a slot that could be filled by a consonant having those phonetic qualities, we should not suppose that it is the same: “For in spite of this apparent identity of phonetic substance, the consonant in question. […] enters into a different set of contrastive relations with other consonants in Latin from those which characterize its position in the French system” (Harris and Taylor 1997: 216–217). CA avoids this problem of particularism through its focus on generic problems of interaction. For example, Schegloff ’s focus in the argument summarized above is the generic problem of coordination and turn-distribution – a problem that has to be solved within any community. We can look across communities and languages to see how local resources are mobilized to solve the recurrent, generic problems of interaction within human groups. Mobilization of local resources to solve generic problems of interaction Consider the following example (Sacks et al. 1974: 721): (7) [T. Labov: Battersea:B:1] 01 Tourist: Has the park cha:nged much, Parky: Oh:: ye:s, 02 03 (1.0) 04 Old man: Th’Funfair changed it’n [ahful lot [didn’it. Parky: [Th- [That05 06 Parky: That changed it,
Introduction
21
At line 05 of this example Parky begins to speak and finds himself in overlap with Old Man. Where does Parky begin to speak? Not after “The,” not after “Fu” or “Fun,” not after “funfair.” Rather, the beginning of Parky’s turn is designed to coincide with the end of “it,” so, after the “The funfair changed it.” Parky has then targeted the first point of possible completion in Old Man’s turn as a place to begin speaking. Notice that Parky starts up here and again at the next two points of possible completion (after “lot” and “it”), not by virtue of any silence (by the time he starts there is no hearable silence) but by virtue of the possible completion of the turn which he has anticipated. The coordination of speakership – i.e. turn-taking – with minimal gap and overlap thus seems to involve, in some kind of essential way, the participants’ ability to project the possible course of the current turn and to thus anticipate when it will reach a point of possible completion. In their 1974 paper, Sacks et al. (1974: 702) write: There are various unit-types with which a speaker may set out to construct a turn. Unit-types for English include sentential, clausal, phrasal, and lexical constructions. Instances of the unit-types so usable allow a projection of the unit-type under way, and what, roughly, it will take for an instance of that unit-type to be completed. Unit-types lacking the feature of projectability may not be usable in the same way. [Emphasis added]
In this way, they link the notion of turn constructional units – the building blocks out of which turns-at-talk are composed – to a feature of “projectability.” In a paper originally delivered in 1973, Schegloff (1987c: 71) expands on the notion of projectability, writing: One important feature of turn construction […] and the units that turn construction employs (e.g., lexical, phrasal, clausal, sentential constructions) is that they project, from their beginnings, aspects of their planned shape and type. […] There are other sorts of projection that are, or can be involved from the very beginning of a turn. For example, question projection. […] Or: beginnings can project “quotation formats.” Or: a beginning like “I don’t think” can project, in certain sequential environments, “disagreement” as a turn type for its turn. […] Again: turn beginnings are important because they are an important place for turn projection, and, given the importance of turn projection for turn taking, they are important structural places in conversation.
Recent work on Japanese (beginning with Fox et al. 1996) suggests that the grammatical properties that make such “early
22
Jack Sidnell
syntactic projections” possible in English may not be shared by all languages. Fox et al. (1996) and later Hayashi (2003) argue that various “syntactic practices” of Japanese result in a “limited projectability.” These syntactic practices include: 1. a flexible word order particularly at the beginning of the turn; 2. the use of post- rather than prepositions; 3. a prevalence of unexpressed constituents (including subject and object); 4. the use of final particles capable of retroactively transforming the constituents to which they attach. The authors (Fox et al. 1996: 208) argue that: the kind of clausal TCU structure these facts commonly lead to typically […] starts with some kind of discourse marker (e.g., ano, nanka), followed by adverbials, or nouns indicating setting of some kind, followed by the verb, and possibly followed by so-called final particles. So what occurs early in the TCU is often only loosely associated structurally with what is to follow. Conversational utterances in Japanese thus seem not to show tight syntactic organization.
Whereas in English “the subject begins a tightly knit clause structure and hence syntactically is the ‘beginning’ of the clause,” in Japanese “ these is no constituent element that serves as the beginning of a tightly knit syntactic unit – in fact, there is no such tightly knit unit” (Fox et al. 1996: 209). These syntactic practices then mean that turn-taking must be managed in a different way in Japanese than it is in English. The authors (Fox et al. 1996: 213) summarize: English recipients are able to use the beginning of a TCU to project a possible course for that utterance, while Japanese recipients “wait and see” how the utterance develops. It is thus possible that English recipients are able to predict with such accuracy how the utterance-under-construction will come to an end that they are able to plan their own utterance to start up exactly at the moment the current utterance comes to a possible completion point (this is, in fact, the claim made by Sacks et al. (1974) with regard to turn-taking in English conversation), with no pause between the end of the current turn and the start-up of their own turn. In Japanese , on the other hand, since recipients are not able to make such detailed predictions about the course of the current utterance, they wait until they hear the last few syllables of the turn (which often contain such “ending
Introduction
23
signals” as final particles, or special completion-relevant verb forms) before starting their own utterance.
The general interactional consequences of these various syntactic practices then include the adoption of a “wait and see”-type approach to turn-taking (and specifically self-selection), limited mid-turn projectability of turns-in-progress and an “incremental” or “bit-by-bit” approach to turn construction (Tanaka 2000; Hayashi 1999, 2003). The consequences are manifested in an absence of clause-level recycling in self-repair (Fox et al. 1996), various kinds of delay in co-participant completions including a prefer ence for terminal item completions (Hayashi 2003), an orientation to the end of the predicate component as transition relevant and a vulnerability of post-predicate components to overlap (Tanaka 2000: 7–8). Japanese grammar may then help to account for the practices of aizuchi (Miller 1983; LoCastro 1987). As Schegloff et al. (1996: 32) remark: The interpolations which in English conversation ordinarily come at the boundaries of larger chunks of extended turns understood to be not yet complete (Schegloff 1982) are produced – and solicited – for smaller chunks of utterance in Japanese , in part to offset otherwise potentially problematic indeterminacies built into Japanese grammar, indeterminacies which are problematic precisely because of the exigencies of recipient parsing in real time.
As Schegloff (2000c) notes, “the orderly distribution of opportunities to participate in social interaction is one of the most fundamental preconditions for viable social organization.” In other words, for human groups, turn-taking is a generic problem of interaction. Like any other such problem, this one must be solved through the mobilization of available local resources . With respect to turn-taking, one particularly important resource appears to be grammar (or “syntactic practices”). In both English and Japanese, the turn-taking problem gets solved but differently in each case due to the availability of different grammatical resources. And notice then that differences in the organization of turn-taking appear to have consequences for other practices of talk-in-interaction – specifically the deployment of so called “response tokens” (See Hayashi and Yoon, this volume).
24
Jack Sidnell
Overview of the volume The chapters in this volume are divided into three thematically organized sections. In conclusion here I want to briefly point to some of the issues involved in creating such groupings in the first place. The chapters grouped together in the first section of the book share a focus on repair. Each involves a detailed consideration of the various ways in which particular kinds of interactional trouble are addressed in conversation. At the same time, the reader will find that these chapters deal with a wide range of quite varied phenomena. For instance, Fox et al.’s analysis of self-repair initiation in seven typological and genetically distinct languages leads to a consideration of the influence of word length and syllable structure. The examination by Egbert et al. of a species of other-initiation leads to a consideration of prosody and pre-announcements . And though Wu ’s chapter begins with other-initiated repair, it comes eventually to an examination of epistemic issues implicated in talk-in-interaction. The point then is that within a given single domain a very wide range of practices are implicated. Indeed, it is quite impossible to deal solely with the phenomenon of repair, for instance, without at the same time considering the organization of turns and the sequencing of actions. So, while the chapters in each section address particular domains of talk-in-interaction, they do not attempt to reduce the phenomena they examine to that domain. The second section of the book considers responses, and, again, although there is clear thematic continuity across the chapters, each raises distinct issues and locates a particular dimension for comparative analysis. Here the prefer ences for contiguity and agreement described initially by Sacks (1987) are particularly important as are issues of epistemic access. The chapters show that although there is much in common across languages in terms of the resources available for constructing responses, the particular grammatical and lexical characteristics of these languages also result in considerable variability. Hayashi and Yoon compare not only different languages (English, Japanese, Korean) but also different approaches to social interaction. The authors conclude their chapter with a discussion of the ways in which the phenomenon they
Introduction
25
consider in Japanese and Korean has been analyzed in previous studies as an expression of cultural themes (e.g., “mutual dependency”), before offering an alternate account that emphasizes the particular syntactic practices and grammatical characteristics of these languages. Taken together the chapters in this section show that while responding clearly presents similar problems everywhere, interactional solutions are adapted and shaped by the available resources of particular languages. The chapters of the final section maintain a focus on languagespecific resources in the construction and sequencing of action investigating the use of language-specific resources to respond to assessments (Sorjonen and Hakulinen, Sidnell) and to show relations between utterances that are not adjacent (Bolden). Sorjonen and Hakulinen show that, in Finnish, word order does not code basic grammatical relations (as it does in English and many other languages) and can thus be deployed to index subtle distinctions of epistemic access, speaker stance and interactional alignment . While there are roughly comparable practices in languages that use word-order to code grammatical relations, these Finnish practices of responding are intimately tied to the grammar of this language and thus ultimately unique to it. The broad theme relating all the chapters, then, is how the generic problems of interaction among humans (coordination of opportunities to participate, fixing problems, responding in such a way as to convey an understanding of what the previous speaker has done, constructing a course of action in a sequence, etc.) are solved through the mobilization of specific local resources . Those resources include not only the grammar and lexicon of a particular language but also prosody and the body. It is the mutual shaping of these resources, the structures of interaction and the production of coordinated courses of action that these chapters investigate. Acknowledgments I thank Nick Enfield , Chuck Goodwin , Makoto Hayashi , Manny Schegloff, and Tanya Stivers for helpful written comments on an earlier version of this chapter.
26
Jack Sidnell
Notes 1 Variously termed descriptive, functional or cognitive linguistics . For a useful overview of language universals that contrasts these two approaches see Comrie 1981. Some major landmarks in the descriptive/ functional tradition are, for instance, Li and Thompson (1981), Shopen (1985). 2 So-called “non-configurational” languages which exhibit free word order provide a striking illustration of the way grammar shapes the practice of repetition. Thus Hale writes of Warlpiri: “sentences containing the same content words in different linear arrangements count as repetitions of one another” (Hale 1983:5). 3 While each language offers unique possibilities for social action, there are also clear points of convergence as well. Indeed in some cases it is possible to identify the very same practice in typologically and genetically unrelated languages. For instance, Stivers (2004) shows that a practice involving the use of multiple sayings such as “no no no” to halt an ongoing course of action is found not only in English but also in Japanese and Russian . 4 The chapters by Fox et al. and Rossano et al. depart from the collection-based, qualitative CA approach described here and develop their analyses through the use of quantitative methods. For discussion of such methods applied to the materials of social interaction see these chapters as well Schegloff ’s commentary. 5 See Goffman (1964) for an early juxtaposition of two research traditions: one in which features of context are correlated with the features of speech and another in which the focus is on the structures of social interaction themselves, that is, “the neglected situation.” 6 See, however, Egbert (2004) for an examination of some occasions in which just these issues come to the interactional surface. 7 As Makoto Hayashi points out, CA studies do sometimes begin with action-types: Pomerantz (1978) on compliments, Goodwin and Goodwin (1987) on assessments, and Drew (1984) on invitations are examples. These studies differ from those in cross-cultural pragmatics by taking the action-implementing turn as part of a larger organization of the turn at talk (i.e. the Goodwins’ study of assessments) or sequence of action (Pomerantz and Drew). Emanuel Schegloff notes that although the titles of the papers by Pomerantz and Drew refer to compliments and invitations, the actual texts are about responses to compliments and invitations. 8 Schegloff goes on to note “Further, the use of other-initiated repair as one way of pre-indicating the imminent occurrence of disagreement
Introduction
27
(Schegloff et al. 1977: 380) suggests why uh huh’s and the like can be taken as indications of agreement with the speaker of an ongoing extended unit. For if disagreement were brewing, then opportunities to initiate repair would supply a ready vehicle for the display and potential deflection of that disagreement. Passing the opportunity to raise problems of understanding may be taken as indicating the absence of such problems. It may also be taken as indicating the absence of that which such problems might have portended – disagreement – and thus be taken as indications of agreement.” 9 As Schegloff notes, “attention signals” is a gross under-specification. First because it is not clear why attention should be signaled on the occasion in which “uh huh” is used and not others in which it is not and second because it is not clear why “uh huh” should be used rather than some other signal such as gaze.
Part II
Repair and beyond
2 Repetition in the initiation of repair Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
Introduction The organization of repair has received sustained interest in the study of language and social interaction over the past decades. Although, until recently, research in this area has based its claims primarily on English materials, there has been a growing interest, especially in the past ten years or so, in exploring how repair operates in languages other than English. This expanding body of research includes studies of German (e.g., Egbert 1996, 1997b, 2004; Selting 1988, 1992, 1996; Uhmann 2001), Japanese (e.g., Fox et al. 1996), Korean (e.g., Kim 1999a, 2001), Thai (e.g., Moerman 1977), and Mandarin Chinese (e.g., Chui 1996; Tao et al. 1999; Wu 2006; Zhang 1998), among others. Some of these studies have focused on the mechanisms of self- and other-initiation of repair in the languages examined (e.g., Chui 1996; Kim 1999a, 2001; Moerman 1977 ; Zhang 1998), while others have uncovered the linkages between repair and other aspects of interactional practice, such as prosody (e.g., Selting 1996; Tao et al. 1999) and bodily conduct (e.g., Egbert 1996), and still others have explored the relation between repair and syntax from a cross-linguistic perspective (e.g., Fox et al. 1996). As part of this growing effort to understand the organization of repair across languages, this chapter investigates two repeatformatted other-initiated repair practices in Mandarin conversation. Using the methodology of conversation analysis (CA), this study will show that the two Mandarin repair initiations under examination, like other-initiation of repair in English, serve not only to initiate repair but also as vehicles for accomplishing additional
32
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
negatively valenced actions, such as displaying a stance of disbelief or nonalignment . However, in further explicating the common sequential and activity contexts of these two practices, I will also describe a previously undescribed division of labor between repair initiations and demonstrate how the use of these two Mandarin practices is sensitive to two intertwining axes: the epistemic stance of the speaker who initiates the repair and the sequential context and positioning of the initiation of repair. The analysis draws upon a corpus of approximately two hours of telephone conversations and seventeen hours of videotaped face-to‑face conversations among family members, friends, and acquaintances. The data were collected in mainland China , Taiwan, and the USA. In what follows, I will first briefly review previous work on other-initiation of repair and lay out a few initial observations regarding the use of the two Mandarin practices under examination in clear-cut contexts of repair. I will then examine occasions in which they are used to implement actions beyond repair initiations and discuss how these uses can be related to the basic properties they exhibit as repair initiators.1 The candidate phenomenon: repeat-formatted other-initiation of repair In general, research on other-initiation of repair has been pursued along two different lines. The first line of inquiry (e.g., Curl 2005; Egbert 1996; Kim 1999a, 2001; Schegloff 2000b; Schegloff et al. 1977; Zhang 1998) is concerned mainly with the internal organization of repair sequences, exploring issues such as the locus of repair initiation relative to the trouble source turn as well as the repertoire of practices for the initiation or resolution of repair. The second line of inquiry (e.g., Couper-Kuhlen 1992; Drew 1997; Egbert 1997b, 2004; Kim 1999a; Robinson 2006; Schegloff 1997b; Selting 1988, 1992, 1996) focuses not so much on repair sequences per se, but rather on the larger sequential contexts in which such repair initiations and sequences figure, as well as their interactional uses in these contexts. One prominent theme along this second line of inquiry is the double-barreled nature of other-initiated repair – that is, its
Repetition in the initiation of repair
33
capacity for, and frequent use in, implementing additional interactional projects while simultaneously serving to initiate repair. Egbert (1997b), for example, demonstrates how initiating repair in multiparty German conversation can be used strategically not only as an entry or exit device to such conversations but also as a display of affiliation among conversational co-participants. Selting (1988, 1992, 1996) shows that prosodically marked other-initiation of repair in German can carry an emotive overtone of “astonishment” and indicate a problem of expectation on the part of the speaker. Drew (1997) focuses on what he terms “open class” repair initiators in English (e.g., “Pardon?,” “Sorry?,” “What?”) and shows how their use can embody the speaker’s treatment of the turn being targeted as either topically or sequentially disjunctive or in some way inappropriate. And the strong connection between the use of other-initiated repair and the display of incipient nonalignment on the part of its speaker has also been documented in several studies (e.g., Heritage 1984: 339–344; Kim 1999a; Pomerantz 1984; Schegloff 1997b, 2007a; Schegloff et al. 1977 ). The following example, from Schegloff (2007a: 102–103) , is a case in point: (1) Schegloff (2007a:102– 103) 1 Bee: a→ =[Why] whhat’sa mattuh with y- Yih sou[nd HA:PPY,] hh 2 Ava: [Nothing. ] 3 Ava: b→ u- I sound ha:p[py?] 4 Bee: c→ [Yee]uh. 5 (0.3) 6 Ava: d→ No:,
Here, Ava initiates repair (Arrow B) of Bee’s assessment (“Yih sound HA:PPY,” Arrow A) of Ava’s emotional state. To this repair initiation, Bee responds in the next turn (Arrow C) with a confirmation . Although this response by Bee suggests that she is treating Ava’s repair initiation, prima facie at least, as involving a hearing or understanding problem, Ava’s subsequent disconfirmation (Arrow D) nonetheless retroactively indicates that this prior repair initiation serves not merely to initiate a repair but to portend disagreement as well. The present study pursues the second line of research and considers a similar phenomenon in Mandarin conversation as that illustrated in Extract 1. An initial sense of the presence of a similar
34
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
operation – and a further complication – involved in the use of repeat-formatted other-initiated repair in Mandarin is evident in the following two excerpts, both paralleling Extract 1 closely: (2) (CMC01–403A) 1 C:
ta yi xiaoshi:: fu ni duoshao, xianzai. she one hour pay you how:much now “How much does she pay you- for an hour:, now?”
2 W: a→ pianyi de le. sanshi. cheap NOM CRS thirty “Cheap. Thirty dollars.” 3 C: b→ yi ge xiaoshi sanshi? one C hour thirty “Thirty dollars for an hour?” 4 W: c→ (uh [huh) PRT PRT “(uh [huh.]” 5 C: d→ [Bu pianyi. N cheap [ “Not cheap.” (3) (CMC 05–06, 00:20, audio 315a) 1 L: a→ hai, hebei jiu mei shenme hao difang. (sigh) (province) just N what good place “((sighs)) There are not many good places in Hebei.” 2 M: b→ hebei a?= (province) PRT “Hebei A?”= 3 L: c→ =uh. PRT = “Yeah.” 4
(0.5)
5 M: d→ langfang hai xing. (place) still okay “Langfang is okay.”
As with Extract 1, in each of these excerpts, a speaker initiates repair (Arrow B) by repeating part of the prior assessment by another (Arrow A); and in each excerpt, following a recipient confirmation (Arrow C ), the repeat speaker moves to launch a
Repetition in the initiation of repair
35
disagreeing response (Arrow D): In Extract 2, the speaker delivers a straightforward negation of the prior assessment; and in Extract 3 the speaker introduces an exception to the recipient’s just-proffered negative evaluation of the province by claiming that one of its cities – i.e., Langfang – is “okay.” Despite the similarity, it can be noted, however, that the repair initiations in these extracts are not in entirely the same format: Whereas the repeat in Extract 3 is suffixed with the particle a, 2 the one in Extract 2 is not. What Extracts 2 and 3 suggest, then, is both a commonality and variation between English and Mandarin . On the one hand, as in English conversation, repeat-formatted other-initiation of repair in Mandarin apparently can serve not only to initiate repair but also as a vehicle for accomplishing negatively valenced actions such as projecting disagreement . On the other hand, however, in initiating a repair through the use of repeat to accomplish such an action, a Mandarin speaker will have to select between at least two alternative practices: a question-intoned repeat3 and a repeat suffixed with the final particle a. The second of these practices appears to have no direct analogue in English.4 As will be shown below, the selection between these two Mandarin practices in implementing negatively valenced projects is not random; rather, the division of labor appears to be consistent with, and may in fact be carried over from, the basic meanings they index when serving as straightforward repair initiators. To demonstrate such a connection, let us turn first to a brief overview of the use of these practices in clear-cut contexts of repair initiation. Question-intoned repeats and a-suffixed repeats in clear-cut contexts of repair As straightforward repair initiations, question-intoned repeats and repeats suffixed with a commonly adumbrate different problems their speakers are having with respect to the trouble source turns targeted and frequently engender different types of responses from their recipients. Repeats suffixed with a are commonly heard as confirmation questions, i.e. the use of this format makes a recipient’s confirmation or disconfirmation relevant in next position. This is illustrated respectively in Extracts 4 and 5, both from a conversation recorded in
36
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
Beijing between two acquaintances. Immediately prior to Extract 4, M has just asserted that life in Beijing is boring. In Extract 5, the topic has turned to a neighborhood where M used to live. (4) (CMC 05–05, 00:40, audio 243a) 1 L:
suibian ni. as:wish you “Whatever.”
2
(0.3)
3 L: a→ chabuduo zhao ren jia le de le. almost find person marry ASP get CRS “(I’ll) just get married to some guy.” 4
(0.5)
5 M: b→ zhao ren jia le de le a?= find person marry ASP get CRS PRT “Just get married to some guy A?”= 6 L: c→ =uh.= PRT = “Yeah.”= 7 M: d→ =wo zher hen duo ren dasuan qu ne. I here very many person plan marry PRT = “I know lots of guys who are ready to marry.” (5) (CMC 05–03, 01:45, audio 130a) 1 M:
bu, yuanlai women jia zhu nar? no originally we home live where “No, where did we live before?”
2 M:
3 M: a→ =[dongcheng liuyin jie na kuair. (place) (place) street that area = “Near Liuyin Street in Dongcheng.” 4 L:
=[((clears throat))
5
(0.5)
6 L: b→ [[guyun jie a?= (place) street PRT [[ “Guyun Street A?”=
Repetition in the initiation of repair 7 M:
37
[[shi bbe [[ “(It) is-”
8 M: c→ =aiyahh, liuyin jie. (exclamation) (place) street = “aarrgh! Liuyin Street.” 9
(.)
10 L: d→ ao:. PRT “Oh:”
In each of these cases, a speaker displays a hearing or understanding problem with respect to a prior turn (Arrow A) by initiating a repair through a partial repeat suffixed with the final particle a (Arrow B); and, in each case, this a-suffixed repeat is responded to with either a confirmation or disconfirmation (Arrow C). That such a confirmatory type of response is adequate for repair initiations in the form of a-suffixed repeats can be evidenced by the repeat speakers’ subsequent moves (Arrow D): They either proceed to produce a sequentially relevant pending response, as in Extract 4, and, by implication, treat the recipient’s confirmatory response as sufficient for their prior inquiries. Or, as in Extract 5, they receive the confirmation with a free-standing ao “oh,” which, by proposing a change in the speaker’s local state of information as a result of the response, reaffirms the status of the a-suffixed repeat as one which is meant to request a confirmation or disconfirmation . By contrast, a confirmatory type of response is not always adequate for question-intoned repeats. In the database, although some such repeats appear to be treated as candidate hearings offered for confirmation of a prior turn’s talk, the majority of such repeats turn out to involve recognition or understanding problems. Consider, for example, Extract 6 below, in which the participants are talking about a variety of foods in the northeast area of Mainland China . (6) (CMC 01–01, 03:22, audio 034a) 1 Z:→ ranhou ta nar ( . . . ) yi yang, dongbei de ming cai, then it there one C northeast ASSC famous dish “And there’s ( . . . ) another famous northeastern dish,”
38
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
2 Z:→ jiao zuo guobaorou. call CP (dish) “called ‘guobaorou.’” 3
(0.5)
4 N:→ guobaorou? (dish) “‘Guobaorou?’” 5 Z:→ ((nod))= 6 N:→ =she- na shenme [guo? that what (word) = “Wh- which [‘guo’ is that?” 7 Z:
[guo. (word) [ “‘Guo.’”
8 W:
[ ↑nang ba. (word) PRT [ “↑Isn’t it ‘nang’?”
9 Z:
[guo: jiu shi guo: de guo:. (word) just be (word) ASSC (word) [ “‘Guo:’ is just the ‘guo:’ in ‘guo:.’”
In line 4, N initiates repair on the name of the food just mentioned through a question-intoned repeat. Although Z’s response – a simple affirmative nodding (line 5) – displays her treatment of N’s repair initiation as possibly checking a candidate hearing, N’s immediate move to follow Z’s response with a further clarification question (line 6) retrospectively marks that the trouble she has been proposing involves a recognition problem, rather than a hearing problem. Extract 7 provides another instance of question-intoned repeats. Here, despite the non-presence of a follow-up clarification question, the question-intoned repeat is nonetheless treated as embodying an understanding problem. In this excerpt, the participants are exchanging their views of the city of Chengdu, which both of them have been to. (7) (CMC 05–02, 04:40, audio 105a) 1 M:
ni lai nabianr::(.) you come there “(When) you were there::(.)”
Repetition in the initiation of repair 2 M:
ni zui xi(huan) chengdu shenme? you most like (city) what “what did you like most about Chengdu?”
3
(0.5)
4 L:
chi de. qihou.= ou, wo zui xihuan qihou. qici shi eat NOM weather PRT I most like weather next be
39
chi de. eat NOM “Food. Weather. = Oh, I like its weather the best, and then the food.” 5 M:
you tong gan. zhende. have same feeling really “(I) feel the same. Really.”
6 M: → nar qihou jianzhi tai lan le. =zhende. there weather truly too bad CRS really “The weather there is just too bad. =Really.” 7
(.)
< na zhong- [na zhong 8 M: that kind that kind “The kind of- the kind of-” 9 L: (0.3) 10
[↑qihou tai lan le? weather too bad CRS “The weather is too bad?”
11 M: → ni shuo- ni (tian tian jian zhao taiyang mei zai nar)? you say you day day see CP sun N at there “Tell me- did you (see the sun every day there)?” 12
(0.7)
<↑a:, wo jiu xihuan mei taiyang a. 13 L: PRT I just like N sun PRT < “↑Ah::, I just like (the fact) that the sun does not come out.”
Here, consistent with how he behaves in the remainder of this conversation, M interacts with L in an ironic and joking manner. In line 5, M first emphatically aligns with L’s displayed favorable stance toward the weather of the city but then abruptly ends his responses with a sharp contrary view about this topic (line 6). To this unexpected twist, L, after a slight delay, reacts by repeating part of what M has just said with a raised pitch (↑qihou tai lan le,
40
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
“↑the weather is too bad?”; line 9). Note here that M’s subsequent response (line 11), albeit with a shade of challenge , is clarificatory in nature and apparently treats L’s prior repeat as displaying an understanding problem. Contrasting Extracts 6–7 with 4–5, we find that whereas in all of these excerpts a party undertakes to claim some kind of trouble with a prior turn’s talk through a repeat, these differently formatted repeats have different sequential implications. When suffixed by the particle a, the repeat is intended and understood as a candidate hearing or understanding of the trouble source turn, ordinarily making a recipient confirmation relevant in next position. Without the a-suffixing and with question intonation, however, the repeat is commonly offered not as what the speaker proposes to have understood but as the speaker’s momentary breakdown in comprehension of the element being repeated in its current sequential context. Of particular relevance to our discussion below is that, as Extract 7 has also demonstrated, the speaker’s displayed noncomprehension of the trouble source turn embodied in the use of a question-intoned repeat may arise not only from the repeat speaker’s lack of familiarity with a reference previously mentioned (e.g., Extract 6); it may also arise from an apparent sense of abruptness and unexpectedness associated with how the trouble source turn figures in its sequential context (cf. Drew 1997). As noted, M begins his response to L’s favorable view of the weather in Chengdu with an aligning response (line 5), which appears to be leading up to a subsequent reinforcing positive comment. However, just as this response by M appears to be on its way to completion, it takes an abrupt twist and ends with a contradictory comment about this subject (line 6). It is notable that L’s subsequent repeat (line 9) targets just this seemingly incoherent part of the response by M, giving evidence that it is the unexpected twist manifested by this response that has caused her puzzlement. As we will see in the following sections, this use of questionintoned repeats to mark what is being repeated as unexpected or having come out of the blue, as well as the use of a-suffixed repeats to mark a relatively higher degree of speaker certainty, are generic features of these two practices. These features and the different epistemic stances so instantiated are present not only in contexts in
Repetition in the initiation of repair
41
which these two practices serve straightforwardly to initiate repair but also in contexts in which they accomplish actions beyond repair initiation.
The use of question-intoned repeats and a-suffixed repeats in the service of negatively valenced work To explicate the division of labor between the use of question-intoned repeats and a-suffixed repeats in implementing additional negatively valenced work, I will focus on sequences sharing the following features: • The repeat is responded to with a repair-relevant response – which commonly (though not invariably) takes the form of a confirmation or clarification of the matter addressed by the repeat. • While the repair-relevant response displays the repeat recipient’s treatment of the repeat, prima facie at least, as initiating a repair, namely, as indicating a hearing or understanding problem, the repeat speaker’s subsequent move suggests that his or her prior repeat is not merely repair-implicated. • Commonly, the repeat speaker follows the recipient’s response with a negatively valenced response regarding the matter being addressed – a move which suggests that the prior repeat-formatted repair initiation was employed (and perhaps exploited) in the service of projecting the follow-up negative response. In the following sections, I will demonstrate that while a-suffixed repeats and question-intoned repeats both figure in such sequences, they differ along two dimensions: the epistemic stance of the speaker who initiates the repair, and the sequential context and positioning of the repair initiation. I will consider these issues in that order. The effect of the epistemic stance of the repeat speaker We have seen that compared to question-intoned repeats, repair initiations in the form of an a-suffixed repeat commonly convey a stronger epistemic stance on the part of the speaker. To illustrate
42
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
that such a difference is also visible when the use of these two practices implicates a problem of interactional alignment , let us consider first Extract 8 below, which involves a question-intoned repeat that serves to project a negatively valenced response. In this excerpt, the participants are talking about the expense of visiting Jiuzhaigou – a well-known scenic spot in China . (8) (CMC 05–06, 03:30, audio 368a) 1 M: jiuzhaigou, qu na bian, dei hua duoshao qian a? (place) go that side must spend how:much money PRT “How much does it cost to go (on a trip) to Jiuzhaigou?” 2
(.)
3 L:a→ tch! wo juede liang qian yinggai gou le. yi ge ren. I feel two thousand should enough CRS one C person “tch! I think two thousand should be enough, for one person.” 4 L:
[((clears throat))
5 M: b→ [yi (ge) ren liang qian?= one C person two thousand [“Two thousand for one person?”= 6 L: c→ =uh. PRT = “Yeah.” 7 M: d→ na jiu xia bei le. then just next life CRS “Then (wait) until the next life.” 8
(1.0)
9 L:
ganma? what “What?”
10 M:
tai gui le. too expensive CRS “(It’s) too expensive!”
11 L:
↑gui ma? expensive Q “↑Is (it) expensive?”
12 M:
tai gui le. tai gui le. too expensive CRS too expensive CRS “(It’s) too expensive! Too expensive!”
Repetition in the initiation of repair
43
Here, it can be noted that the repeat-formatted repair initiation (Arrow B) is followed by a negatively valenced response produced by the repeat speaker (Arrow D) after the information being targeted is confirmed (Arrow C). It can also be noted, however, that whereas the repeat speaker M subsequently displays a less-thanembracing stance toward the information being targeted, he does not challenge or contest the information itself. Rather, the production of the question-intoned repeat appears to have more to do with the speaker’s display of a sense of unexpectedness toward the information. This is embodied in M’s production of a cry of dismay (na jiu xia bei le, “then (wait) until the next life”; line 7), which, like his subsequent comments (tai gui le, “too expensive”) in lines 10 and 12, apparently treats the estimated travel expense as excessively high rather than untrue. The embodiment of a weaker epistemic stance in the selection of a question-intoned repeat is also apparent in cases in which the repeat speakers subsequently move to convey a sense of doubt about the truth-value of the target information: In these latter cases, it is observed that despite the expression of doubt, the repeat speaker nonetheless commonly designs and/or delivers his or her subsequent query in an epistemic ally downgraded fashion. A case in point is Extract 9, where the two participants, L and M, are talking about a friend of M’s, whose girlfriend was L’s classmate for several years at a university in Chengdu. (9) (CMC 05–09, 00:55, audio 096b) 1 L: wo dou hai mei jian guo ta. I all still N see ASP he “I haven’t met him yet.” 2
(.)
3 M: mei jian guo ta ma?= N see ASP he Q “Haven’t met him?”= 4 L: → =<wo zai chengdu de:shihou jiu lao tingshuo.= I at (city) when then always hear =< “I heard about him a lot when I was in Chengdu.”= 5 L: =ranhou (yao) dao beijing ye chang tingshuo. than will come (city) also often hear = “And then I also heard about him a lot in Beijing.”
44
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
6
(.)
7 M:
[niyou [ “You-”
8 L:
[jiu wen da ming. long hear big name [ “Have heard his name for a long time,”
9 L:
ranhou mei jian guo ren. then N see ASP person “but have never met him in person.”
10 M: → ↑ni zai chengdu lao tingshuo guo? you at (city) always hear ASP “↑You heard about him a lot in Chengdu?” 11 M: → tamen liang [bu shi zai, chengdu bu shi renshi,= they two N be at (city) N be know “Didn’t they [in Chengdu- didn’t (they) know (each other)-”= 12 L: [wo tingshuo guo. I hear ASP [“I did.” 13 M: → =bu shi hen chang shijian (ma)? N be very long time Q = “not for a long time?’” 14 L:
zen::me bu shi hen chang?= how N be very long “How: could it not be a long time?”=
15 L: =dasan jiu renshi le ba. junior then know CRS PRT = “(I think) they knew each other since (they were) juniors.” 16 L:
yi nian duo me. one year more PRT “(They’ve known each other) for more than a year.”
17 M:
shi ma? be Q “Have they?”
Here, L’s claim of having frequently heard about this man in Chengdu (line 4) suggests that the romantic relationship between this man and L’s former classmate had already begun and was possibly even well established at that time. In response to this information and
Repetition in the initiation of repair
45
implication, M produces a question-intoned repeat (line 10), to which L responds with a confirmation (line 12). That this question-intoned repeat by M serves to do more than initiate repair can be seen in the fact that immediately following it, and without waiting for a responsive affirmation, M produces a question (tamen liang bu shi zai, chengdu bu shi renshi, bu shi hen chang shijian [ma], “didn’t they in Chengdu . . . didn’t they know each other . . . not for a long time?”; lines 11 and 13) which can be, and is in fact, heard as a challenge to the validity of L’s prior claim (notice L’s rebuttal in line 14). Note, however, that although this follow-up question by M is challenge -implicating, it is delivered and designed in an epistemic ally weakened fashion: Not only is the question delivered with many hesitations and disfluencies, but the final shape it takes – a double negative construction (bu shi renshi bu shi hen chang shijian (ma), “didn’t (they) know each other not for a long time?”) – is epistemically much weaker than its affirmative version would be (bu shi (zhi) renshi hen duan de shijian (ma), “didn’t (they) know each other for a short period of time (only)?”). In Extract 9, then, there is evidence that even though the question-intoned repeat embodies a certain degree of doubt on the part of the speaker toward the information just received, such a stance , as in many other similar instances in the corpus, is substantially weakened and mitigated. In fact, if we consider the questionintoned repeats examined earlier (e.g., Extracts 7–8), and the fact that across these instances a predominant usage of question-intoned repeats is to embody a sense of unexpectedness on the part of the speaker, there is a sense that the use of the question-intoned repeat in Extract 9 is strategic in nature. That is, by using a question‑ intoned repeat, and thereby invoking a sense of the unexpectedness commonly associated with its use, the repeat speaker in effect marks the newly received information as less than expected and in need of clarification , rather than as less than truthful and in need of correction . This difference, between marking a piece of information as less than expected versus marking it as less than truthful, can be more clearly demonstrated if we compare Extracts 8–9 with those involving an a-suffixed repeat in similar negatively valenced contexts. In
46
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
these latter instances, the repeat speakers commonly follow their a-suffixed repeats with a statement or query which in some way contradicts or compromises the information just received and commonly displays a stronger epistemic stance toward the matter being addressed. Extracts 10 and 11 illustrate. Extract 10 provides an expanded version of Extract 3 and comes from the same conversation as Extract 9. Of particular interest here is that whereas in both Extracts 9 and 10 M initiates repair through a partial repeat of what his interlocutor has said in a prior turn, in Extract 10, below, M suffixes his repeat with the final particle a (line 2), in contrast to what he does (in line 10) in Extract 9. (10) (CMC 05–06, 00:20, audio 315a) 1 L: hai, hebei jiu mei shenme hao difang. (sigh) (province) just N what good place “((sighs)) There are not many good places in Hebei.” 2 M: → hebei a?= (province) PRT “Hebei A?”= 3 L:
=uh. PRT = “Yeah.”
4
(0.5)
5 M: → langfang hai xing. (place) still okay “Langfang is okay.” 6 L:
uh::? (.) bu hui ba.= (PRT) N likely PRT “Mm::? (.) Are (you) serious?”=
7 M: =langfang yinwei xianzai yao jian yi daxue cheng. (place) because now will build one college town = “‘cause now (they) plan to build a college town in Langfang.” 8 L:
diang. (na) xia zhao le.= (exclamation) that scare CP CRS “Right! How impressive!”=
9 M:
=jiu shi li beijing jin.= just be away:from (city) close = “(It’s) just very close to Beijing.”=
Repetition in the initiation of repair
47
10 L: =wo dangnian kao- daxue de:shihou, I that:year test college when = “The year when I applied to- colleges,” 11 L: wo bao le yi ge- wujing kexue yuan. I apply ASP one C police science college “I applied to- the Police Academy.” 12
(0.5)
13 L: qu nar mianshi,<wo jiu faxian,.hhh= go there interview I then find “(I) went there for an interview.< Then I found out .hhh”= 14 L:
=langfang hai meiyou (chengdu) xiancheng- (.) (place) yet N (place) county = “Langfang wasn’t as- (.)”
15 L: ganjing (.) zhengjie- (.) da. clean tidy big “clean- (.) tidy- (.) or as big as (Chengdu) county.” 16 M:
langfang nar mei ren guan.= (place) there N person take:charge “Nobody is in charge in Langfang.”=
17 M: → =xiao shihou wo ye zai langfang dai guo.= little when I also at (place) stay ASP = “When (I) was little, I also stayed in Langfang.”= 18
((The storytelling continues.))
Here, as noted earlier, in response to L’s assessment of Hebei (line 1), M not only produces an a-suffixed repeat (line 2) but, following the recipient confirmation (line 3), also moves to produce a disagreeing response (line 5). Notice that compared with the negatively valenced response which M produces subsequent to his question-intoned repeat in Extract 9, this disagreeing response by M (langfang hai xing “Langfang is okay”; line 5) is designed and delivered with a much stronger epistemic stance : Not only is this disagreeing response delivered in a straightforward manner without significant hesitation or disfluency, it is also cast as a straightforward assertion which presents information contradictory to that which is being targeted, rather than as a query displaying weaker epistemic strength. Notice also that in Extract 10 not only does M have prior firsthand knowledge concerning the city of Langfang, but it is precisely
48
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
by reference to this knowledge that he finds L’s prior comment in line 1 problematic (lines 7, 9, and 16–18). In this respect, therefore, M’s subsequent delivery of firmly asserted information that is contrastive with what L has just said, as well as his move to invoke his prior independent experience of this matter, are compatible with his selection of an a-suffixed repeat as the repair initiator; all of these actions display a stronger epistemic stance on the part of the speaker toward the matter being addressed. Extract 11, from a conversation between two college roommates, provides a similar instance. Where this excerpt begins, H is in the midst of reporting an incident she saw on her way to school one day. In line 6, D interrupts H’s storytelling by first launching a repair initiation clarifying the place where this incident took place. After the place reference is clarified (lines 7–8), D then retrieves a piece of information that H had reported earlier (line 1), by repeating part of that information and suffixing it with a (line 9). (11) (CMC 09 audio 150a) 1 H:
=jiu kan yi liang huang se chuzuche guo:qu le. then see one C yellow color taxi pass:by CRS = “and then (I) saw a yellow cab passing by,”
2 H: .h ranhou faxian libian de n de then find inside ASSC female NOM “.hhh then (I) found the lady inside-” 3 H:
↑zhang de hao yanshou [ou. look CSC very familiar PRT “↑looked really familiar.”
4 D: 5 H:
[↑hhheng:: (exclamation) xiang xiang xiang xiang, think think think think “(I) kept thinking and thinking and thinking,
↑ a:: [( . . . ) (exclamation) oh:.” 6 D: [( . . . ) zai nar a? at where PRT “(. .) where?” 7 H:
jiu- jiu zai na- zanmen xuexiao na ge- (0.3) lu shang. just just at that we school that C road on “(It was) just- just on- the road- (0.3) in the school”
Repetition in the initiation of repair 8 H:
49
xuexiao de lu shang. school ASSC road on “On the road in the school.”
9 D: → ↑huang se chuzuche a? yellow color taxi PRT “↑A yellow cab A?” 10 H:
um.= PRT “Yeah.”=
11 D: → =xiali a? (cab company) PRT = “A Xiali (cab)?” bu shi. huang se de. 12 H: N be yellow color NOM “No. (It was) a yellow one.” 13
(0.5)
chuzuche [a? 14 D: → ↑zher na: you huang se de here where have yellow color ASSC taxi PRT “↑How can there be yellow cabs here?” 15 H:
[you.= have “There are.”
=shang bian yi banr shi huang de, yi banr (bie . . . ) 16 H: top side one half be yellow NOM one half other = “The top of the cab was half yellow, (and) half (another . . . )” 17 D:
ou::. PRT “Oh::.”
In response to H’s affirmation (line 10) of the a-suffixed repeat, D initiates another repair by producing an understanding check (xiali a, “a Xiali (cab)?”; line 11), which takes the form of a best guess about the specific cab company that owns the yellow cab in question.5 This understanding check is disconfirmed by H (line 12), who goes on to reaffirm the color of the cab, and, by implication, the validity of her prior report as well. In answer to this disconfirmation , D produces a question (line 14), which is designed with the question word nar, “where,”6 with slight stretching, as well as stress on the word huang, “yellow,” which represents the issue in question. In and through this design, the question can be heard
50
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
as “pro-forma” in nature. That is, it is not meant to request new information but to question a prior utterance by introducing the relevance of a corresponding negative assertion, namely, the assertion that there are no yellow cabs at all here (cf. Koshik 2003). And this is just the way H treats it: In line 15, she moves to confirm the accuracy of her report, though backing down with a modification of her prior claim (line 16). Extract 11, then, offers us another instance in which the speaker of an a-suffixed repeat displays an orientation to independent knowledge concerning the matter being addressed – and an instance in which the repeat speaker subsequently produces a doubt-implicated disaligning response that displays a stronger epistemic stance . If an epistemically weakened follow-up query, as argued earlier, retrospectively marks the prior question-intoned repeat as the speaker’s display of a sense of unexpectedness toward the information just received (e.g., Extract 9), then the subsequent challenge -implicated query produced by D here, as well as her invocation of prior knowledge on the matter, can be seen as indicating that her previous a-suffixed repeat is not only unexpectedness-implicated but is, in fact, challenge -relevant. This section has shown that the choice between question-intoned repeats and a-suffixed repeats in accomplishing negatively valenced work is largely determined by, and itself embodies, the epistemic stance of the speaker toward the information in question: Whereas the use of a question-intoned repeat is commonly accompanied by a follow-up negatively valenced response that is epistemically weakened or unexpectedness-implicated, an a-suffixed repeat is ordinarily followed by a negative response which displays the speaker’s orientation to prior knowledge of the matter at issue, and which is often built with a stronger epistemic stance . Such a difference, I have also suggested, is consistent with the features these two practices exhibit in the context of straightforward repair initiation. The effect of the sequential context and positioning of the initiation of repair The fact that the speaker’s epistemic stance, albeit relevant, is not the only axis pertinent to the selection between these two
Repetition in the initiation of repair
51
repair initiations is made clear by a subset of cases containing question-intoned repeats. These cases are similar to the previously examined excerpts involving a-suffixed repeats (e.g., Excerpts 10–11) in that the repeat speakers move subsequently to invoke prior knowledge regarding the target information. A unique feature of the majority of these cases is that such questionintoned repeats almost always occur in a sequentially disjunctive position, produced to address a prior turn by another which appears to have been abruptly launched or ill-fitted in its sequential context from the repeat speaker’s perspective.7 This usage of a question-i ntoned repeat, I would suggest, is consistent with its use to mark that which is being repeated as unexpected or having come out of the blue, as we have observed in earlier examples (e.g., Extracts 7–8). Consider Extract 12, from a telephone conversation between two friends who practice a Chinese martial art together at the same association. Prior to this excerpt, B, who had been absent from classes for several days, has just told F that she does not know how to get to the sessions due to a recent change in bus schedules. This excerpt begins with B’s reiteration of her problem with transportation, which appears to be produced here as an implicit request for information, but which apparently is treated by F as an account for B’s absence and is merely responded to with an information receipt (line 4). (12) (T-mom & bo 165) 1 B: dao na ge (wulun) chang a, arrive that C (name) field PRT “(As for) how to get to the (Wulun) Association” 2 F:
um. PRT “Uh huh.”
3 B:
zuo shenme lu hai bu zhidao lei. sit what road still N know PRT “(I) don’t know which bus to take yet.”
4 F:
ou, zhe yangzi ou. PRT this manner PRT “Oh, I see.”
52 5 B: 6
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu ↑wu:lao kongpa y- .hhh ta- ta ye bu zhidao ba? (person) afraid he he also N know PRT “↑Mr. Wu probably also- .hh He- he doesn’t know either, right?” (1.0)
7 F: → w ulun:: chang: wo- (0.5) (name) field I “The Wulun::Association:I- (0.5)” 8 B: → ↑bu shi,= N be “↑No,”= 9 F:
=ta xianzai shi zuo- (.) haoxiang zuo yibai lu. he now be sit seem sit one:hundred road = “Now he takes- (.) seems to take Bus 100.”
10
(.)
11 B: → one:hundred road < “Bus 100?/!”> 12 F:
dui. wu:lao shi zuo yibai. right (person) be sit one:hundred “Yes. Mr. Wu takes 100.”
13
(1.2)
14 B: → ou:? PRT “Yeah?” 15 F:
en ehnhh ((smile voice)) PRT PRT “Uh huh.”
16 B: → oh, ta xianzai gai le yibai lu.= PRT he now change ASP one:hundred road “Oh, now he’s changed to Bus 100.”= 17 F:
=dui::. right = “Right::.”
18 B: → bu shi shiyi lu. N be eleven road “Not Bus 11?” 19 F:
dui, bu shi. right N be “That’s right. No.”
Repetition in the initiation of repair 20 B:
53
haha (laugh) “haha”
Here, not having been provided with any information on the proposed transportation problem, and possibly also taking F’s reaction (line 4) as a sign of her not having a solution, B brings up the name of another fellow practitioner (Wu Lao “Mr. Wu”), asking whether he might know about how to get to the association with the new bus schedules (line 5). Whereas this question by B in line 5 is designed in such a way that requires (minimally) only a confirmation or disconfirmation from the recipient, F appears to exhibit some difficulty in giving a response: Following B’s question, there is first a one-second pause (line 6); thereafter, F attempts to provide a response, which nonetheless ends with yet another pause (line 7). Whereas it is clear from F’s response in line 7 that she is still searching for an answer or searching for a way to deliver a solution, it is opaque as to where her answer-in-progress is headed. In fact, the way in which F has begun her turn in line 7 (wulun:: chang: wo-, “the Wulun:: Association:: I-”) can promote a hearing that what is projected is something about F’s own knowledge in relation to some aspects of this association, rather than about Mr. Wu’s, as B’s prior question (line 5) has asked. On this hearing, then, F can be taken by B as having misunderstood her (B’s) prior question. And, indeed, this seems to be what happens here. In line 8, apparently attempting to remedy such a perceived misunderstanding on F’s part, B initiates what Schegloff (1992a) terms a “third position repair,” which regularly takes the form, “No, I don’t mean X. I mean Y.” However, just as B finishes producing the first component, bu shi, “no,” and is apparently on her way to completing this third-position repair, she is interrupted by F, who moves at this point to resume her earlier-suspended response (line 9). And it is to this interruptive response by F that B launches a question-intoned repeat (yibai lu, “Bus 100?/!”; line 11). It should be noted that F’s response in line 9 is not only interruptive of B’s prior turn in progress (line 8) but also shifts away from the line of response introduced (yet not completed) in F’s own prior turn (line 7). In this regard, F’s response can be seen, from B’s perspective, as “doubly disjunctive” and hence may strike B as having come out of the blue. I would suggest that it is just this (dual) sense
54
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
of the unexpectedness of the occurrence of F’s response at this point in interaction that has prompted B – who otherwise appears to have some prior knowledge of the matter being inquired about (cf. her reactions in lines 14, 16, and 18) – to choose a questionintoned repeat, rather than an a-suffixed repeat, in initiating the repair. As Extract 12 demonstrates, sequential context and positioning appear to play a role in the selection of the two repair-initiation formats under examination. In addition, such an effect can, and often does, prevail in cases where the repeat speakers turn out to have independent prior access to the matter being addressed – cases in which an a-suffixed repeat would otherwise be commonplace, as demonstrated in the previous section. This suggests that although the selection of a question-intoned repeat versus an a-suffixed repeat is closely related to the distribution of knowledge between the repeat speaker and his or her interlocutor, what the selection conveys is not always how the state of knowledge is objectively distributed nor the speaker’s subjective evaluation of it but can rather be a display by the speaker of how he or she perceives the trouble source turn to figure in its sequential context. Question-intoned repeats in the context of intensified nonalignment In the data so far examined, we have observed two major contexts in which question-intoned repeats are commonly chosen over a-suffixed repeats: (i) contexts in which the repeat speaker subsequently delivers a negatively valenced response that is epistemic ally weakened or unexpectedness-implicated, and (ii) contexts in which the repair initiation figures in a sequentially disrupted environment. In both contexts, I have argued, the use of question-intoned repeats frequently serves to embody a sense of unexpectedness on the part of the speaker toward the matter being addressed. However, question-intoned repeats are sometimes observed to occur in contexts which are neither sequentially disruptive nor in which the negatively valenced responses they project appear in any way mitigated. While instances like this initially seem to conflict with the preceding account, upon examination, the use
Repetition in the initiation of repair
55
of question‑intoned repeats in these cases appears again to mark “unexpectedness”. A return to Extract 2, which is reproduced here with a few ensuing turns as Extract 13, provides a case in point. (13) (CMC01–405A). 1 C: ta yi xiaoshi:: fu ni duoshao, xianzai. she one hour pay you how:much now “How much does she pay you- for an hour:, now?” 2 W:
pianyi de le. sanshi. cheap NOM CRS thirty “Cheap. Thirty dollars.”
3 C: → yi ge xiaoshi sanshi? one C hour thirty “Thirty dollars for an hour?” 4 W:
(uh [huh) PRT PRT “(uh [huh.)”
5 C: → [Bu pianyi. N cheap [ “Not cheap.” 6 W: SHENme BU pianyi a. ta yanjiusheng. what N cheap PRT she graduate:student “WHat do you mean by NOT cheap? She’s a grad student.” 7
(.)
8 W: wo jiao ta gudai hanyu. I teach her ancient:time Chinese “I teach her Classical Chinese.” 9
(1.0)
10 C: u-oh.=ta shi yanjiusheng, =zheme da yi ge ren le a. PRT she be graduate:student such big one C person ASP PRT “e- Oh.=She is a grad student?/! Such an old person.” 11
(0.5)
12 W:
ni: yiwei [ne ((infiltrated with laughter)) you think PRT “What did you suppose?”
13 C: [buguo sanshi kuaiqian queshi- suan hen hao de.= but thirty dollar actually count very good NOM “But thirty dollars is truly a very good pay.”
56 14 C:
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu =ni zhiyao- gen: na ge- (0.4)= you only with that C = “If you- with the uh:(0.4)”=
=na shei gei ta zhao le yi ge= 15 C: that who for she find ASP one C = “Who’s the person that has found one for her?”= 16 C:
=luo gei- dan zhao le [yi ge= (name) for (name) find ASP one C “Luo has- found a (tutoring job) for Dan.”
17 W: 18 C:
=gei su:dan zhao [le yi ge, yi ge xiaoshi cai shi wu kuaiqian. for (name) find ASP one C one C hour only fifteen dollar “Found one for Dan Su. Only fifteen dollars an hour.”
19 W: 20
[uh:: PRT “Yeah,”
[uh. PRT “Yeah,”
(.)
21 W: .hhhh jiao shei a. nei ge jiao shenme ia. (in-breath) call who PRT that C teach what PRT “.hhhhh Who’s the person? Er- what does she teach?”
As noted earlier, C follows W’s confirmation (line 4) of her prior repair initiation (line 3) with a straightforward disagreement (line 5). Note here that whereas C chooses a question-intoned repeat in initiating the repair, this excerpt is different from those examined earlier (e.g., Extracts 8–9, 12) in that not only is C’s follow-up negative response not epistemic ally weakened but the question-intoned repeat is also not produced in a sequentially disjunctive context. A remarkable feature of instances like Extract 13 is the striking discrepancy between the information targeted by the questionintoned repeat and what the repeat speaker understands the issue to be. In this excerpt, C subsequently (lines 14–16, 18) reports a case she knows of in which a mutual friend has only been paid half of what W has reportedly received. In light of this background information, and perhaps also in light of the way in which W has initially oriented her recipients to assess the amount of pay to be reported (pianyi de le, “cheap”; line 2), the exact figure
Repetition in the initiation of repair
57
which W ends up reporting can be seen by C as so unlikely that this information may appear initially to have been arrived at out of the blue. Here, I would suggest, C’s question-intoned repeat appears to embody just this kind of initial reaction – that is, marking a sense of unexpectedness on the part of the speaker. And the unexpectedness being so marked here concerns not so much the abruptness with which another’s prior talk is brought up in the local context but the significant gap between the newly received information and the repeat speaker’s prior knowledge of the matter being addressed.8 Before leaving this section, it may be worth registering that given the capacity of question-intoned repeats to mark that which is being repeated as utterly beyond expectation, the possibility can be entertained that this feature may make question-intoned repeats an apt and well-suited resource for projecting intensified or outright disagreement . That is, by (strategically) marking what another has said in a prior turn as having come out of the blue, the speaker can in effect problematize the target information while at the same time reinforcing the adequacy of the position he or she is holding. However, while such a usage seems plausible, and, on occasion, even familiar to the ear, there are no clear exemplars of this kind in the data at hand. This proposal thus awaits further investigation and should be treated as impressionistic at present. Conclusion Over the years, the other-initiation of repair has been a recurrent theme in CA and related fields and is perhaps one of the most well studied interactional phenomena cross-linguistically. Using a CA framework, this study has shown that, like other-initiation of repair in English, the two Mandarin repair-initiation formats under examination can similarly serve not only to initiate repair but also as vehicles for accomplishing additional negatively valenced projects. In further explicating the common sequential contexts of their occurrences, this study has also shown that these two repair initiation formats, while occurring in seemingly overlapping contexts, exhibit a consistent fine-tuned division of labor: Whereas a-suffixed repeats generally embody a stronger epistemic stance on the part of the speaker, question-intoned repeats, across
58
Ruey-Jiuan Regina Wu
various contexts, consistently embody a speaker’s display of a sense of unexpectedness toward the information being targeted. Before closing this chapter, one final note regarding the implications for cross-linguistic and cross-cultural work on repair should be registered. As the foregoing discussion has demonstrated, in both Mandarin and English, repeat-formatted other-initiation of repair can serve not only to locate a hearing or understanding problem but to implicate alignment issues as well. And yet, the linguistic resources in Mandarin provide two alternative repeat formats through which speakers can calibrate a fine-grained epistemic stance toward the matter being addressed vis-à-vis their interlocutors while initiating the repair. These findings raise interesting questions as to whether other languages make a similar distinction in embodying negatively valenced stances in the context of other-initiation of repair, and if so, how this is achieved without the availability of final particles. Clearly, more studies are needed to further our understanding of the organization of repair in Mandarin as well as across languages, and more studies are needed if we are to understand how the organization of repair is, as suggested (e.g., Egbert 1996; Fox et al. 1996), an interactional phenomenon that is universal across languages and cultures while at the same time sensitive to the linguistic and cultural repertoire of each given language. Appendix: Abbreviations ASSC Associative (-de) ASP Aspectual marker CRS Currently relevant state (le) CSC Complex stative construction C Classifier N Negator NOM Nominalizer (de) PRT Particle Q Question marker Notes 1 Part of the analysis discussed in this chapter has appeared in Wu (2006).
Repetition in the initiation of repair
59
2 Over the years, various scholars have proposed different meanings for the particle a. (For a brief review, see Wu 2004.) In a more recent work, Wu (2004: 128) demonstrates that in TCU (turn constructional unit)final position, the particle a generally exhibits a “contrast-invoking” property, used to “mark a discrepancy in knowledge, expectation or perspective regarding some state of affairs between the current speaker (i.e., the a user) and the prior speaker.” 3 The matter of what constitutes “question intonation” in a tonal language such as Mandarin is complicated and remains unsettled. Over the years, different proposals have been made as to how question intonation is realized in Mandarin. These proposals, albeit not in complete agreement with each other, generally point to some exaggerated gestures with which question intonation is realized (e.g., Chang 1998; Gårding 1987; Ho 1977; Schack 2000; Shen 1989; Tseng 2003; Yuan and Shih 2004; Yuan et al. 2002; Zeng et al. 2004). In this study, I have taken into consideration these findings while basing my identification of question-intoned repeats on my auditory perception after repeated listenings. The exaggerated gestures claimed in the literature to be associated with question intonation are reflected in the transcripts in the forms of underlinings, upward-pointing arrows, and/or left-facing arrows. 4 There are other repeat formats in Mandarin , e.g., repeats suffixed with the question particle ma (e.g., line 11 in Extract 8) or the particle ou (see Wu 2004). The exact functional differences among these formats await further investigation. 5 “Xiali” is the name of a cab company whose cabs, however, are red. 6 In this question, D chooses to design the question with nar, which literally means “where” in English but which can also serve to mark a question as being rhetorical. 7 Question-intoned repeats are observed to also occur in contexts in which the repeats are produced in a sequentially abrupt manner. For this usage, see Wu (2006). 8 That the difference between W’s pay and the pay of this friend can be perceived as huge can also be supported by W’s subsequent reaction after she learns of this friend’s pay – a big in-breath (line 21), apparently adumbrating a big surprise.
3 A cross-linguistic investigation of the site of initiation in same-turn self-repair Barbara Fox, Fay Wouk , Makoto Hayashi , Steven Fincke , Liang Tao , Marja-Leena Sorjonen , Minna Laakso, and Wilfrido Flores Hernandez Introduction Same-turn self-repair is the process by which speakers stop an utterance in progress and then abort, recast or redo that utterance. While same-turn self-repair has become a topic of great interest in the past decade, very little has been written on the question of where within a word speakers tend to initiate repair (the main exceptions being Schegloff 1979 and Jasperson 1998). And, to our knowledge, no work has been done on this question from a crosslinguistic perspective. The goal of this paper is twofold: First, we explore existing proposals regarding where in words speakers initiate repair (what we will call the “site” of initiation) using data from our seven languages; and, second, we present and explain site of initiation data from those seven languages. Our findings suggest that there is a great deal of cross-linguistic variation with respect to favored sites of initiation but that most of the variation can be accounted for by a few simple interactional factors. This paper is the first study we are aware of which considers word length in explanations of selfrepair data. The current study is part of a larger project that has as its goal an understanding of the universal principles of self-repair and their language-specific manifestations. Prior studies have shown that the linguistic resources available to speakers of different languages shape the specific methods by which repair is accomplished (Fox et al. 1996; Wouk 2005; Fincke 1999; Egbert 2002; Sidnell 2007c; Karkainnen et al., 2007 ). We hope to learn more about the details of recycling and replacement repairs and how such
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
61
linguistic factors as major constituent order, frequency of ellipsis, use of prepositions or postpositions , and phonological structure of the word impact the organization of repair. The seven languages examined in this study are: Bikol (spoken in the Philippines), Sochiapam Chinantec (spoken in Mexico), English, Finnish , Indonesian, Japanese , and Mandarin . The language sample is one of convenience, but it represents languages from six language families, three continents and three archipelagos. The languages differ in major typological features, such as basic word order , phonotactic structure, and morphological structure. In other words, the sample is genetically, typologically, and areally diverse. Below we give very brief descriptions of each language: Bikol , a language of the Philippine branch of the Austronesian family, is verb-initial and prepositional. As in other Philippine languages, content words are multisyllabic and multimorphemic. Much of the bound morphology is prefixal, although there are infixes, suffixes, and circumfixes as well. Sochiapam Chinantec, of the Chinantecan branch of the OtoManguean language family, is spoken in Oaxaca, Mexico. It is a verb-initial, prepositional language. Words tend to be monosyllabic and monomorphemic, but there is a small amount of derivational and inflection al morphology. Sochiapam Chinantec is a tonal language. Finnish , in the Finno-Ugric language family, is verb-medial, with both prepositions and postpositions . It also has an extremely rich system of inflection al and derivational morphology, much of which is suffixing. Indonesian , an Austronesian language spoken in Indonesia, is verbmedial and prepositional. Words tend to be bisyllabic, although there is a considerable amount of derivational morphology which produces longer words. The genetic classification of Japanese remains in dispute, some treating it as essentially a language isolate, while others believe it belongs to the Altaic language family. Japanese is verb-final and postpositional. Japanese words are not divided into syllables, but rather into units called mora, which determine syllable weight (which, in its turn, determines stress and timing). Words tend
62
Barbara Fox et al.
to consist of a large number of mora, and thus to be quite long in terms of their phonological structure, even though they may look no longer than a two syllable word in English. For example, “Nippon,” which looks like it is only two syllables, is actually four mora, with the double consonant and the final n each constituting a separate mora. Japanese has a rich system of bound morphology, all of which is suffixing. Mandarin , in the Sino-Tibetan language family, is verb-medial and prepositional. It is thought of as a monosyllabic language, but modern Mandarin has such a large number of homophones that the practice of compounding has become quite prevalent, and many content words are compounds. Mandarin is also a tonal language. Data collection As part of a larger project on the syntax of self-repair (cf. Fox and Wouk 2003), we collected 250 instances of same-turn selfrepair for each language (except English, for which we have 500 instances). The instances were taken from recordings of naturally occurring speech. The recordings were not made specifically for this project; rather, they had been collected by the individual researchers at different times and in different places, for a variety of purposes. Each instance of repair was coded for a variety of features. The coding scheme was developed for the larger project, and it included information relating to type of repair and site of initiation. Self-repair can involve a variety of different operations, but the larger study was restricted to quite specific types. Only instances in which there was a clear syntactic relationship between the trouble source (the original utterance) and the repair were included in the collection. Thus, instances in which the speaker started an utterance, cut it off, and started a new utterance were excluded from the larger collection. In fact, the larger study is limited to cases which involve either replacement of one or more elements of the trouble source or repetition of the trouble source (or some part thereof), although either replacement or repetition (which we term “recycling”) may be accompanied by other repair operations.
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
63
In the present study, we further limit our focus to simple repairs, both simple recycling and simple replacement . By “simple” we mean that no other repair operation is involved in the repair. Thus, simple recycling repairs are just repetitions of words, with no add itions, deletion s or replacements; simple replacement repairs are instances in which a morpheme, word or phrase is replaced, without recycling, addition or deletion .1 Since the overall study includes both simple and non-simple repetition and replacement repairs, the total number of simple repairs is less than 250 per language (or 500 for English). In this paper we examine • 146 Indonesian repairs (117 recycling and twenty-nine replacement); • 201 Sochiapam Chinantec repairs (185 recycling and sixteen replacement); • 339 English repairs (285 recycling and fifty-four replacement); • 200 Japanese repairs (147 recycling and fifty-three replacement); • 150 Mandarin repairs (115 recycling and thirty-five replacement); • 185 Bikol repairs (162 recycling and twenty-three replacement); • 162 Finnish repairs (116 recycling and forty-six replacement). As can be seen by these figures, languages differ in the proportion of simple to non-simple repairs and also in the proportion of replacement to recycling repairs, but overall simple recycling is far more frequent than simple replacement. Method ology There is a large body of work on self-repair in the conversation analysis (CA) framework (e.g., Jefferson 1974; Schegloff et al. 1977; Goodwin 1979, 1981; Schegloff 1979, 1987c, 2000c, 2002b). This work is based on qualitative analysis of individual cases in their interactional environment, or of collections of such cases. The studies are grounded in the understanding that orderliness is achieved first in single cases and that a perceived orderliness in the aggregate arises from orderliness on a single case basis. “Quantitative analysis is, in this sense, not an alternative to single case analysis, but
64
Barbara Fox et al.
rather is built on its back” (Schegloff 1993: 102). In other words, we see similar patterns in multiple instances because speakers manage interactional contingencies with recurrent practices. It is entirely possible that orderliness at the single case basis will not lead to orderliness at the aggregate level. In fact, Schegloff (1993) expresses serious concerns about undertaking quantitative analysis of conversational phenomena. In that paper, he raises questions about what counts as numerator and what counts as denominator. As Schegloff (1993) points out, these are not trivial questions, and in many cases the phenomenon may not be well enough understood to identify either all of the environments of relevant possible occurrence (i.e. the denominator) or all of the possible items that could count as instances of the phenomenon under investigation (i.e. the numerator). As Schegloff has suggested “We may need to defer full dress quantitative analysis in many areas until its appropriate constraints can be met” (1993: 119). For these and other reasons, CA researchers have typically avoided quantitative analysis, preferring instead to use “informal quantification.” As Schegloff says: Terminology such as occasionally or massively reports an experience or grasp of frequency, not a count; an account of an investigator’s sense of frequency over the range of research experience, not in a specifically bounded body of data; a characterization of distribution fully though tacitly informed by the analytic import of what is being characterized. (Schegloff 1993: 118–119)
In this paper, however, we take findings from relevant CA work and explore their cross-linguistic implications utilizing quantitative method s. Although we are cognizant of the concerns mentioned above, we have chosen to use a quantitative approach because we are working with phenomena which are difficult for an analyst to notice at a conscious level, and to have a general grasp of, such as how often repair is initiated early in the word in a noun rather than in an article. We thus make use of quantification as a tool to help us arrive at a sense of frequency. Although this paper is full of numbers (and even statistics), we do not believe that the fact that there were, for example, X instances of repair initiated early in a noun and Y instances of repair initiated early in an article in data set P of Language Q is significant in and of itself. It only serves to
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
65
give us a sense of whether both of these syntactic types can be considered frequent sites of early repair initiation in that language. The questions we have asked here are not just linguists ’ questions; they can also be participants’ questions in that they involve the resources for interactional tasks such as delaying next item due or replacing a current item. For example, languages with a large number of verbal prefixes provide speakers with an easy way of delaying the verb root by recycling the prefix, while in languages which lack verbal prefixes speakers will need to find other means to delay production of the verb. We begin our study with an exploration of the first proposal in the literature regarding site of initiation. Site of initiation The first proposal we will explore concerning site of initiation appears in Schegloff (1979). There, Schegloff writes, “Just postinitiation and just pre-completion of various unit types seem to be specially common loci of repair initiation. Thus, just after the start of a turn-constructional unit (e.g., a sentence) or just before its completion; after the first sound of a word or just before its last sound” ( 1979: 275). This is just one point in a long paper covering many topics, and Schegloff does not elaborate on it nor give any examples. Nor is it clear from the paper exactly what is meant by “after the first sound of a word or just before its last sound”; after the first sound could mean after the first sound is recognizable or after the first sound is complete; just before its last sound could likewise mean before the last sound is articulated or before the last sound is complete. However, Schegloff (personal communication ) has suggested that the relevant domain for just post-beginning starts after the first sound is recognizable, thus has begun to be articulated, and continues until the first sound is complete, while the relevant domain for just pre-completion begins just before the final sound is articulated, in the penultimate sound, and continues until just before the final sound is complete. He has further suggested that site of initiation of repair may depend on the type of repair involved. The first goal of our study is to explore Schegloff ’s characterization of English site of initiation in the simple repairs found in the
66
Barbara Fox et al.
seven languages of our sample. In order to avoid confusion of terminology, we will use the term “post-beginning” for just post-initiation of the word and “initiation” only to refer to repair initiation. Post-beginning and pre-completion in English We began our exploration with English. In our collection of 339 simple repairs in English, we found twenty-four simple recycling repairs (8 percent of all simple recycling repairs) and seventeen simple replacement repairs (31 percent of all simple replacement repairs) in which repair was initiated during or right after the first sound (post-beginning). Extract 1 below illustrates a simple recycling repair initiated post-beginning, in this instance in the initial vowel: (1) Chinese dinner Ann: the biggest debate i- in our department. in:, at Trenton was that when we had these faculty meetings.
Extract 2 illustrates a simple replacement repair initiated postbeginning, in this instance just after the bilabial nasal closure (which could be heard to begin the word “my,” replaced by a): (2) Sports Allan: I wish I’d had m- a camera earlier today because
We further found 128 simple recycling repairs (45 percent) and twenty-two simple replacement repairs (41 percent) in which repair was initiated just before the last sound (pre-completion). Extract 3 illustrates initiation in the penultimate sound of the demonstrative determiner “that”: (3) SBC1 [715] Lynne: .hh Not this time of the year, because, you know they’ve had a dry year, bu-< .hhhh usually they’re too we:t, and tha:- (0.7) that shoe can just pull ri:ght o:ff:, because it’s just, .hhh (.) the hoof wa:ll is so so:ft.
Extract 4 shows initiation in the final sound of the pronoun she; the pronoun is replaced with a full noun phrase (this girl):
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
67
(4) HG Hyla: and she- this girl’s fixed up on a da- a blind da:te.
It is worth noting that the vast majority of these pre-completion initiations occur in the final sound of the word, rather than prior to it. Combining post-beginning and pre-completion frequencies for each type, we find that 152 (53 percent) of simple recycling repairs and thirty-nine (72 percent) of simple replacement repairs are in accord with Schegloff ’s proposal. It thus seems that for simple replacement repairs in English, Schegloff ’s proposed description of the common sites of repair initiation provides a rough characterization of our data. However, while post-beginning and precompletion are both common sites of initiation of simple recycling repairs, they comprise only approximately half of these repairs. We thus wondered if other explanations might be available that would account for a greater proportion of the data. We explore other possible explanations for our findings beginning in the section ‘Recognizable Completion’ below. Among simple replacement repairs, on the other hand, the positions mentioned by Schegloff comprise 72 percent of all repair initiations, so it appears that Schegloff ’s generalization holds quite strongly for this category of repair. As Schegloff (personal communication ) noted, it is to be expected that different repair types behave differently. 2
Cross-linguistic comparison Table 3.1 provides the figures for post-beginning and pre-completion sites of repair initiation for both types of repairs in all of the languages in our study. For each language, we give the percentage of all recycling repairs and replacement repairs that are initiated postbeginning and pre-completion. We also combine repairs initiated post-beginning and pre-completion, thus giving the percentage of all repairs initiated in the positions suggested by Schegloff (1979). In the discussion below, we explore the pattern of distribution of post-beginning and pre-completion repair initiation for each language, starting with Indonesian. As can be seen from Table 3.1, in Indonesian , post-beginning is not a common site of repair initiation. Out of 146 repairs, only
Japanese
Finnish
Bikol
Mandarin
Sochiapam Chinantec
Indonesian
English
24 (8%) 17 (31%) 6 (5%) (0%) 2 (1%) 1 (6%) 5 (4%) 2 (6%) 8 (5%) 1 (4%) 21 (18%) 13 (28%) 30 (20%) 2 (4%)
Recycling Replacement Recycling Replacement Recycling Replacement Recycling Replacement Recycling Replacement Recycling Replacement Recycling Replacement
Post-beginning
7 (44%) 33 (29%) 6 (17%) 37 (23%) 11 (48%) 19 (16%) 7 (15%) 39 (27%) 17 (32%)
128 (45%) 22 (41%) 51 (35%) 8 (28%) 22 (12%)
Pre-completion
8 (50%) 38 (33%) 8 (23%) 45 (28%) 12 (52%) 40 (34%) 20 (43%) 69 (47%) 19 (36%)
152 (53%) 39 (72%) 57 (39%) 8 (28%) 24 (13%)
Combined
Table 3.1 Post-beginning and pre-completion repair initiation
16 115 35 162 23 116 46 147 53
285 54 117 29 185
Total repairs
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
69
six simple recycling repairs (5 percent) and no simple replacement repairs were initiated immediately post-beginning. Pre-completion, on the other hand, does seem to be a moderately frequent site, as fifty-one simple recycling repairs (35 percent) and eight simple replacement repairs (28 percent) are initiated pre-completion. Combining post-beginning and pre-completion frequencies for each type, we find that fifty-seven (39 percent) simple recycling repairs and eight (28 percent) simple replacement repairs are in accord with Schegloff ’s proposal. In Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin , as in Indonesian , postbeginning is not a common site of repair initiation; in Sochiapam Chinantec only two simple recycling repairs and one simple replacement repair are initiated post-beginning, while in Mandarin two (6 percent) simple replacement repairs and five (4 percent) simple recycling repairs were initiated post-beginning. The two languages differ from each other in the degree to which speakers seem to orient to pre-completion. In Sochiapam Chinantec, pre-completion is a proportionally more frequent site for replacement repair initiation – being found in seven cases (44 percent) – than for recycling repair initiation, where it is found in twenty-two cases (12 percent). In Mandarin, it is a more frequent site for recycling repair initiation – being found in thirty-three cases (29 percent) – than for replacement repairs, where it is found in six cases (17 percent). Combining post-beginning and pre-completion frequencies for each type, we find that in Sochiapam Chinantec twenty-four (13 percent ) simple recycling repairs and eight (50 percent) simple replacement repairs are in accord with Schegloff ’s proposal, while in Mandarin thirtyeight (33 percent) simple recycling repairs and eight (23 percent) simple replacement repairs are. In Bikol as well, post-beginning is not a frequent site of repair initiation; only nine (5 percent) simple repairs were initiated immediately post-beginning, eight simple recycling repairs and one simple replacement repair. Among simple recycling repairs, thirty‑seven (23 percent) were initiated just pre-completion, while among simple replacement repairs, eleven (48 percent) were initiated pre-completion. Combining post-beginning and pre-completion frequencies for each type, we find that forty-five (28 percent)
70
Barbara Fox et al.
s imple recycling repairs and twelve (52 percent) simple replacement repairs are in accord with Schegloff ’s proposal. In Finnish , as in English, post-beginning is a moderately frequent site of repair initiation, particularly for replacement repairs. We found that thirty-four (21 percent) Finnish simple repairs, twenty-one (18 percent) recycling repairs and thirteen (28 percent) replacement repairs, were initiated immediately post-beginning. Pre-completion is also used with some frequency, although less frequently than post-beginning, as a site of repair initiation in Finnish. Among simple recycling repairs, nineteen (16 percent) repairs were initiated just pre-completion. Among simple replacement repairs, seven (15 percent) were initiated just pre-completion. Combining post-beginning and pre-completion frequencies for each type, we find that forty (34 percent) simple recycling repairs and twentysix (43 percent) simple replacement repairs are in accord with Schegloff ’s proposal. In Japanese , repair is initiated in post-beginning position with moderate frequency for recycling, but not for replacement, as thirty-two (16 percent ) repairs – thirty (20 percent) simple recycling repairs and two (4 percent) simple replacement repairs – were initiated immediately post-beginning. Pre-completion initiation is moderately frequent for both repair types. Among simple recycling repairs, thirty-nine (27 percent) were initiated just pre-completion. Among simple replacement repairs, seventeen (32 percent) were initiated just pre-completion. Combining post-beginning and pre-completion frequencies for each type, we find that sixty-nine (47 percent) simple recycling repairs and nineteen (36 percent) simple replacement repairs are in accord with Schegloff ’s proposal. Summary of cross-linguistic comparison What we have found for simple repairs in our seven languages, then, is that Schegloff ’s proposed description matches English the best and is a particularly useful generalization about site of initiation in simple replacement repairs. However, the pattern is clearly not universal , and most of the matching in our other languages is accounted for by pre-completion, not by post-beginning. In fact, in several languages (Indonesian , Bikol , Sochiapam Chinantec, and
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
71
Mandarin ) speakers do not orient toward post-beginning at all, while in others speakers show an orientation toward it only for one type of repair (simple replacement repairs in English and simple recycling repairs in Japanese), and only in Finnish do speakers seem to orient toward it for both types. In all languages, speakers showed some orientation toward pre-completion, but varied greatly in how much. Furthermore, while speakers of all of the languages in our study show an orientation toward at least one of these two sites of repair initiation, only in English are these sites particularly common. Recognizable completion We have seen that post-beginning is far less relevant crosslinguistically than pre-completion, as illustrated in Table 3.1. Additionally, the majority of the pre-completion repair initiations in all the languages of our study occurred in the final segment, rather than just before it. Furthermore, for several of the languages in our study (Bikol , Finnish, Indonesian, and English) between one quarter and one third of recycling repairs were initiated after the word had been completely articulated, and for Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec the majority of recycling repairs were initiated in this location. Only in Japanese was this site rarely used. It would seem, then, that for most languages recycling repairs tend to be initiated either in the final sound of the word or after it. It might be useful to consider why this is the case. We will refer to initiation in or after the last sound of the word as initiation at recognizable completion. In four of the languages in our study (English, Mandarin , Sochiapam Chinantec, and Indonesian), speakers favor initiating repair at recognizable completion in recycling repairs. However, not all languages in the study showed this orientation; we demonstrate in ‘CrossLinguistic Comparison’ below (as illustrated in Tables 3.4, 3.5, and 3.6), that speakers of Finnish, Bikol, and Japanese seem to have no special prefer ence for sites of initiation after the word is recognizably complete. We will consider a number of factors below in explaining the difference between these two groups of languages.
72
Barbara Fox et al.
Given the work that the concept “recognizable completion” seems to do for speakers of at least four of our languages, it seems promising to broaden Schegloff ’s categories of post-beginning and pre-completion to “before recognizable completion” and “recognizable completion” as possible sites of repair initiation oriented to by speakers. Recognizable completion includes most cases where repair is initiated pre-completion and also those cases where repair is initiated after the word is complete. Initiations in the penultimate sound (part of Schegloff ’s original characterization of pre-completion) would be excluded, but there turned out to be very few of them in our data, in any language. All other sites of repair initiation would be considered a single category, “before recognizable completion,” which would contrast with “recognizable completion.”3 It has long been known (Sacks et al. 1974) that participants orient to recognizable completion in their monitoring of the turn-so-far for transition relevance; however, it could be argued that speakers do not orient to the recognizable completion of a word but rather only to the recognizable completion of a turn constructional unit (TCU), and therefore that the relevant characterization of withinword repair sites would be something else. Another possible characterization, for example, could be that speakers tend to initiate repair late in a word, without regard to projection of completion. Although little research has been done on speakers’ and recipients’ monitoring of word production (but see Jasperson 1998; Jefferson 1974), our findings suggest that “recognizable completion” better captures the phenomenon. If lateness were the appropriate characterization, we would expect to find speakers frequently initiating repair in the position just prior to the final sound, as well as in that sound and after it, since just before the final sound is also late. However, we do not find this. What we find is that speakers overwhelmingly orient to recognizable completion in initiating repair. This is a fact that needs to be captured. So, how is it that speakers and recipients orient to the completion-relevant trajectory of words, in addition to TCUs? We suggest here that while recipients monitor the course of an utterance for where it might come to possible completion, they are also monitoring the unfolding of an utterance for its relevance to other forms of co-participation (e.g., head nod, gaze organization,
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
73
a ssessment‑relevant activity) (cf. Ford et al. 1996), and for the moment-by-moment, word-by-word, shifting course of the construction of the TCU (cf. Ford et al. 1996). Each word shapes the trajectory of the TCU, either renewing the current trajectory or changing it. It thus makes sense that speakers and recipients should orient to the word as a unit of production, and to its completion. Furthermore, although it may not be the case for English, in many languages a word’s identity is not certain until it is complete. For example, in Japanese and Finnish, which make use of a large number of inflection al and derivational suffixes, a word’s syntactic class, and therefore the trajectory of the turn so far, can remain indeterminate until the end. In the remainder of the study, then, we will make use of the concepts “recognizable completion” and “before recognizable completion” as within-word sites of repair initiation. And how do replacement repairs pattern with regard to recognizable completion? It appears that they are treated quite differently from recycling repairs, at least in some languages in our survey. For example, recognizably complete initiations comprise only 35 percent of all simple replacement repairs in English. This interesting difference between recycling and replacement in the use of the category recognizably complete will be discussed further below. We got our inspiration about how to think about this difference between the two repair types from the only major work on site of repair initiation, Jasperson (1998). We turn now to a summary of that work. Site of initiation and repair type Jasperson first introduces a distinction between two different types of cut-offs, word-disruptive cut-off and word-preserving cut-off, a distinction he clarifies as follows: “Word-preserving cut-off is cut-off which occurs upon recognizable completion of the word, so that by the time cut-off occurs, a word has been produced intact. In contrast, word-disruptive cut-off is cut-off which occurs at any point before recognizable completion of the word-in-progress, resulting in a ‘word fragment’” (1998: 140). Repair that is initiated before a word is recognizably complete is thus word-disruptive. During the final sound of a word, speakers
74
Barbara Fox et al.
can produce either word-disruptive or word-preserving cut-off: In word-preserving cut-off, the cut-off is done softly, and the final segment is not shortened or perturbed in any way, while in worddisruptive cut-off the cut-off is louder, the final segment is typically shortened, and glottalization may begin during a vowel preceding the final segment in a consonant-final word. Jasperson then goes on to suggest a correlation between these cut-off������������������������������������������������������������� types and the type of repair they construct: “The orientation of word-disruptive cut-off is typically retrospective, insofar as it routinely initiates repair which operates to change some part of the turn in progress (cf. Schegloff 1979). [. . .] Word-preserving cut-off on the other hand does not seem to have this retrospective orientation” (1998: 77). Jasperson ’s findings thus suggest that repair initiated before a word is recognizably complete tends to be engaged with retrospective work, while repair at recognizable completion is not engaged with retrospective repair. In our study we included a wide variety of initiation types, not just cut-off , and did not make use of phonetic distinctions between different types of cut-offs. Rather, we focused on where in the word initiation took place. This decision was largely practical; many of the data sets being used were not of sufficiently high sound quality to make detailed phonetic distinctions, nor did the researchers all possess the auditory acuity for accurate coding . Therefore, we could not test Jasperson ’s proposal against other languages. However, Jasperson’s findings encouraged us to look for other correlations between repair type and repair initiation. In particular, we looked at whether retrospective vs. non-retrospective repair might correlate with initiation when the word is recognizably complete, or earlier in the word, before it is recognizably complete. We therefore looked to see whether the difference between recycling and replacement noted above could be explained in terms of sensitivity to recognizable completion. Based on Jasperson’s study, we hypothesized that initiation before the word is recognizably complete is associated with repairs that change an element in the preceding talk (for example by replacing it), while initiation when the word is recognizably complete is associated with repairs that operate on upcoming talk, for example by delaying next item due (by recycling current word). The following section tests this hypothesis for English.
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
75
Table 3.2 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in English
Recycle Replace Total
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
58 (20%) 35 (65%) 93 (27%)
227 (80%) 19 (35%) 246 (73%)
285 54 339
Chi-square = 45.09, d.f. = 1, p = .0000
Repair type and site of initiation in English Our English data support this claim strongly; 65 percent of all simple replacement repairs are initiated before the word is recognizably complete, while only 20 percent of simple recycling repairs are (see Table 3.2 below). This difference is significant (p = .0000), and both repair types contribute to the significance. It thus appears that in English there is a strong association between site of initiation and repair type, even when a wide range of types of repair initiation are included. Before examining the patterns in our other languages, it is worth exploring possible explanations for this association in English. One obvious explanation is the function of each repair type. Recycling can be used to elicit gaze from recipients or to treat the start of an utterance not accompanied by recipient gaze as defective (Goodwin 1981); it can also be used to delay the next item due, either in a word search or as an indication that the speaker is choosing between alternatives (Jefferson 1974); further, recycling is found in overlaps, as a device to produce talk in the clear (Schegloff 1987c). While all of these functions are found in our English data, we have found that recycling in English tends to be used to repeat function words, which we hypothesize is most often done in order to delay the production of the next content word due (80 percent of all simple recycling in our English data repeat function words). Because their purpose in most cases is exactly to delay production of next item due, there is no hurry in initiating the repair. Replacement, on the other hand, tends to be used to replace content words (61 percent of simple replacement repairs in
76
Barbara Fox et al.
English replace content words) and may occur in cases where an inappropriate word or pronunciation has been produced. Jefferson (1974) provides some insight into this phenomenon; she suggests that speakers make use of the format word1 + hesitation + word 2 to replace one word with another, and that speakers can employ this device to produce just enough of a word for the word to be recognizable, at least retrospectively, thereby allowing the speaker to produce an inappropriate word without being interactionally accountable for it. Or, for example, one can propose ‘I am not like this but am talking by reference to the fact that you are’ by finding ways to show that the terms one produces are not the terms which first come to mind. (Jefferson 1974: 193) One means of achieving that display may be the production of just enough error to convey one’s habitual terminology without inheriting complaints from its recipient (i.e. not having “officially” produced the word in question) and then correcting it with a term which can be seen as selected by reference to one’s situation or recipient. (Jefferson 1974: 193)
As Jefferson indicates, in such cases there may be pressure to initiate repair as early as possible, to produce a word without being accountable for its production. Of course, not all replacements are so interactionally significant, but speakers may nevertheless prefer to minimize the production of an errorful or inappropriate word (cf. Jasperson 1998).4 However, the pressure may be less in these cases than in the type of instances that Jefferson examines, thus allowing for initiation after recognizable completion. 5 Our explanation for differences in preferred site of repair initiation for recycling and replacement repairs thus appears to rest on what might be universal motivations. But do other languages actually manifest the same patterns as English? The following section examines how the other languages pattern. Cross-linguistic comparison If we look at Indonesian , the results appear promising. Indonesian patterns much like English, as shown in Table 3.3 below, with the majority (74 percent) of recycling repairs being initiated when the word is recognizably complete, while only a minority (28 percent) of the replacements are initiated in that site. As in English, the
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
77
Table 3.3 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Indonesian
Recycle Replace Total
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
30 (26%) 21 (72%) 51 (35%)
87 (74%) 8 (28%) 95 (65%)
117 29 146
Chi-square = 22.37, d.f. = 1, p = .0000
Table 3.4 Recognizable completion repair initiation in Finnish
Recycle Replace Total
and
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
52 (45%) 35 (76%) 87 (54%)
64 (55%) 11 (24%) 75 (46%)
116 46 162
Chi-square = 12.95, d.f. = 1, p = .0003
difference is highly significant (p = .0000), and both repair types contribute to the significance. Finnish is somewhat similar, with speakers strongly favoring initiations before the word is recognizably complete for replacement repairs; recycling repairs, however, are more evenly distributed between initiations before the word is recognizably complete and when the word is recognizably complete, as shown in Table 3.4. Note that while the overall distribution in Table 3.4 is significant (p= .0003), the significance comes entirely from the Replace row. Recycling repairs are actually distributed evenly with respect to repair initiation type (chi-square = 1.24; p = 0.27). However, when we examine Bikol (Table 3.5) and Japanese (Table 3.6), we can see immediately that the pattern as manifested by English and Indonesian is not universal . For Japanese (p = .5649) and Bikol (p = .8428) initiation type does not pattern significantly according to repair type. From Table 3.5 we can see that in Bikol speakers have no prefer ence for either site of initiation, with both recycling and
78
Barbara Fox et al.
Table 3.5 Recognizable repair initiation in Bikol
Recycle Replace Total
completion
and
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
88 (54%) 13 (56%) 101 (55%)
74 (48%) 10 (44%) 84 (45%)
162 23 185
Chi-square = 0.04, d.f. = 1, p = .8428
Table 3.6 Recognizable completion repair initiation in Japanese
Recycle Replace Total
and
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
106 (72%) 36 (68%) 142 (71%)
41 (28%) 17 (32%) 58 (29%)
147 53 200
Chi-square = 0.33, d.f. = 1, p = .5649
replacement repairs being initiated before recognizable completion roughly 55 percent of the time; Table 3.6 suggests that speakers of Japanese favor repair before recognizable completion, with replacement repairs initiated before recognizable completion 68 percent of the time and recycling repairs initiated before recognizable completion 72 percent of the time. The difference between the two languages is highly significant (chi-square = 11.11, d.f. = 1, p = .0009, chi-square calculated on the totals for not recognizably complete and recognizably complete for each language). In fact, Japanese proved to be the only language in our sample where speakers actually favor initiation before recognizable completion for recycling repairs. Turning now to Sochiapam Chinantec (Table 3.7) and Mandarin (Table 3.8), we see yet another pattern, namely that speakers strongly favor initiation when the word is recognizably complete for both recycling and replacement repairs, with no significant difference between the two types of repair (Sochiapam Chinantec p = .2385, Mandarin p = .4006).
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
79
Table 3.7 Recognizable completion and repair initiation in Sochiapam Chinantec
Recycle Replace Total
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
26 (14%) 4 (25%) 30 (15%)
159 (86%) 12 (75%) 171 (85%)
185 16 201
Chi-square = 1.39, d.f. = 1, p = .2385
Table 3.8 Recognizable completion repair initiation in Mandarin
Recycle Replace Total
and
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
12 (10%) 2 (6%) 14 (9%)
103 (90%) 33 (94%) 136 (91%)
115 35 150
Chi-square = 0.71, d.f. = 1, p = .4006
There is no significant difference between Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec with respect to initiation type of simple recycling repairs (chi-square = .840, d.f. = 1, p = 3595, chi-square calculated on the values for recognizably complete and not recognizably complete for recycling repairs in the two languages). There are too many cells with values below 5 to attempt a statistical comparison of the two languages with respect to simple replacement repairs, but the pattern is clear: In both languages speakers strongly favor initiation after recognizable completion for replacement repairs. Summary With a sample of seven languages we have seen five of the logically possible patterns for site of initiation and repair type: 1. no difference, with speakers favoring initiation before the word is recognizably complete for both types of repairs (Japanese);
80
Barbara Fox et al.
2. no difference, with speakers favoring initiation when the word is recognizably complete for both types of repairs (Mandarin , Sochiapam Chinantec); 3. no difference, with speakers favoring neither type of initiation (Bikol); 4. speakers favoring initiation when the word is recognizably complete for recycling repairs and initiation before the word is recognizably complete for replacement repairs (English, Indonesian); 5. speakers favoring initiation before the word is recognizably complete for replacement repairs, and showing no prefer ence for recycling repairs (Finnish). It is difficult to argue for a universal pattern when so many of the logical possibilities are found in such a small sample of languages. Given our discussion of the interactional functions of recycling and replacement repairs in “Monosyllabic Words and Recognizable Completion,” this is a surprising finding. We would have expected that data from other languages would give evidence of speakers orienting to the interactional pressures we discussed, and at least on the surface they appear not to. Nonetheless, we believe that there are underlying universal patterns at work here. Recycling tends to be initiated after recognizable completion, as it is frequently employed to delay the next content word due. The only exception to this is Japanese , where recycling repairs are generally initiated prior to recognizable completion and where function words generally follow content words. Replacement tends to be initiated prior to recognizable completion to reduce accountability for inappropriate words. However, word length, that is the number of syllables in a word,6 and syntactic class of the word in which repair is initiated, are also important factors, and their influence can at least partially explain our surprising finding. In the next section, we explore in detail the underlying universal patterns relating to site of initiation, word length and syntactic class. Word length organization and site of initiation The languages in our sample vary in their morphological structure and especially in the length of words involved in repair: Mandarin ,
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
81
Table 3.9 Site of initiation of simple recycling repair initiated in monosyllabic words Not recognizably complete Sochiapam Chinantec Indonesian Mandarin Bikol English Finnish
Recognizably complete
Total
4 (3%)
137 (97%)
141
1 (4%) 5 (6%) 7 (12%) 39 (16%) 8 (21%)
24 (96%) 86 (94%) 43 (88%) 209 (84%) 30 (79%)
25 91 50 248 38
Chinantec, and English speakers tend to initiate repair in monosyllabic words;7 Indonesian speakers most often initiate repair in bisyllabic words; and Bikol , Japanese, and Finnish speakers tend to initiate repair in multisyllabic words of three or more syllables.8 So, one obvious question to ask of the data is whether word length might play a part in site of initiation for the two types of repair. We explored this question by looking at site of initiation for words of varying length in each language. Our findings suggest that word length is, indeed, a factor in site of initiation and that cross-linguistic patterns underlie that outcome. Monosyllabic words and recognizable completion The first positive result that came from our study was that in all of the languages speakers favor “recognizably complete” initiation for recycling repair initiated in monosyllabic words. Tables 3.9 and 3.10 below provide the data for all seven languages.9 From Table 3.9 it is clear that in all the languages in the sample speakers favor initiation when the word is recognizably complete for recycling repairs in monosyllabic words, although with some variation in the strength of that preference. In four of the languages (Japanese , Sochiapam Chinantec , Indonesian, and Mandarin), speakers show a very strong preference, with well under 10 percent initiation before the word is recognizably complete. In the remaining three (Bikol , Finnish, and English) speakers show a strong preference, with percentages of initiation before the word is recognizably complete above 10 percent but below 20 percent.
82
Barbara Fox et al.
Table 3.10 Site of initiation of simple replacement repair initiated in monosyllabic words Not recognizably complete Indonesian Bikol Finnish Japanese Mandarin Sochiapam Chinantec English
0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%) 1 (8%) 17 (50%)
Recognizably complete
Total
0 (0%) 3 (100%) 4 (100%) 5 (100%) 28 (94%) 11 (92%)
0 3 4 5 30 12
17 (50%)
34
If we consider site of initiation in replacement repairs in monosyllabic words, we find a similar pattern for all languages except English (and Indonesian , which had no instances of replacement repair initiated in monosyllabic words). Note that in some cases it is not possible to determine the number of syllables of a word that gets replaced, since its lexical identity is not always clear. This proved to be a problem particularly for the English and Finnish data sets. Therefore, in this section of the paper, the data reported for English and Finnish includes only cases where word length could be determined (forty-six cases for English and twenty-six cases for Finnish). As shown in Table 3.10, in several of the languages in the study, those where speakers regularly use a large number of longer words in ordinary conversation, speakers rarely initiate simple replacement repairs in monosyllabic words. However, when they do, they follow a consistent pattern. With the exception of English (and Indonesian ), the preference for initiation when the word is recognizably complete in monosyllabic word replacement ranges between 90 percent and 100 percent. Frequencies are too low for reliable statistical analysis, but the difference between English and all the other languages in the study is noticeable, and we expect that larger data sets would bear it out. If we sum the results from the languages besides English and Indonesian , there are three instances of initiation prior to recognizable completion and fifty instances after recognizable completion. It is possible to compare these totals with English, and the result is highly significant (chi‑square = 23.47,
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
83
d.f. = 1, p = .0000). The difference between English and all the other languages in the study in this regard will be taken up in “Explaining English” below. We have thus uncovered our first universal pattern: Recycling repair is initiated when the word is recognizably complete in monosyllabic words. Replacement repairs also tend to be initiated when the word is recognizably complete in monosyllabic words, except in English. This is surprising, as our understanding of the interactional functions of replacements would lead us to expect that other languages would be more like English in initiating repair more often before recognizable completion. However, we will argue later (“Explaining English”) that there are reasons why we see this difference, reasons that are compatible with out understanding of interactional functions of repair. We will suggest that monosyllabic words are typically function words in many languages, and therefore pattern differently than one might expect (for content words), as they are less likely to be interactionally delicate. Multisyllabic words and recognizable completion If we compare the pattern of repair initiation in monosyllabic words to the patterns of repair initiation in multisyllabic words, we come to another important finding. Consider Table 3.11, which provides the frequencies for site of initiation in recycling repair in words of three syllables or more: We can notice first that the numbers for Sochiapam Chinantec , English, and Mandarin are very small, because in those languages speakers tend to use mostly words of one and two syllables in ordinary conversation. In fact, the totals for Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec are so low that one really cannot talk about tendencies in any meaningful way. Therefore, the discussion here will be restricted to the five languages that have ten or more multisyllabic words in which repair is initiated. In all languages except Indonesian (46 percent), speakers show a preference for initiation before the word is recognizably complete in these longer words, with Bikol , Finnish, and Japanese speakers showing the greatest preference for such initiation (between 80 percent and 90 percent). If we compare Table 3.11 to Table 3.10, we see that in each of the languages for which we have sufficient numbers to make a
84
Barbara Fox et al.
comparison, speakers show a dramatic difference in preferred site of repair initiation between multisyllabic words and monosyllabic words, with a higher frequency of initiations before the word is recognizably complete in multisyllabic words. Table 3.12 provides a similar set of figures for replacement repairs in multisyllabic words. For each language, we give the numbers for site of initiation in replacement repair in words of three syllables or more. Table 3.11 Site of initiation in recycling repairs in words of three or more syllables
Mandarin Indonesian English Finnish Japanese Bikol Sochiapam Chinantec
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
1 (33%) 12 (46%) 7 (70%) 24 (77%) 80 (87%) 61 (91%) 1 (100%)
2 (67%) 14 (54%) 3 (30%) 7 (23%) 12 (13%) 6 (9%) 0 (0%)
3 26 10 31 92 67 1
Japanese/Finnish: chi-square = 1.60, d.f. =1, p= 0.2 Finnish/English: chi-square = 0.23, d.f. = 1, p = .63 English/Japanese: chi-square = 2.07, d.f. = 1, p = .1505 Japanese/Bikol: chi-square = 0.65, d.f. = 1, p = .4218 Indonesian/Bikol: chi-square = 22.36, d.f. = 1, p = .0000
Table 3.12 Site of initiation in replacement repairs in words of three or more syllables
Bikol Finnish Indonesian Finnish Japanese English Sochiapam Chinantec Mandarin
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
8 (62%) 7 (64%) 10 (83%) 27 (87%) 31 (89%) 4 (100%) 0 (0%)
5 (38%) 4 (36%) 2 (17%) 4 (13%) 4 (11%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
13 11 12 31 35 4 0
0 (0%)
1 (100%)
1
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
85
When we consider site of replacement repairs, we find that in most of the languages in our study speakers show a preference for initiation before the word is recognizably complete in multisyllabic words, as illustrated in Table 3.12. Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin lack significant numbers of multisyllabic words and are thus not relevant to this question. In all the remaining languages, speakers most frequently initiate repair in multisyllabic words prior to recognizable completion. It is likely that this finding relates to the fact that multisyllabic words are generally content words and thus more likely to be interactionally delicate or potentially inappropriate.10 We now have two important findings: repair is initiated when the word is recognizably complete in monosyllabic words and is initiated before the word is recognizably complete more frequently in multisyllabic words than in monosyllabic ones. We are thus in a position to suggest that if speakers of a language favor monosyllabic words as the site of repair initiation, they will tend to initiate repair when the word is recognizably complete. If speakers of a language favor multisyllabic words, they will tend to initiate repair before the word is recognizably complete. If we look at the languages through this perspective, we will see that the tendencies do hold up, although there are some interesting exceptions. Word length, repair type and recognizable completion In this section we further explore the correlation between repair type and word length in the languages of our study. Tables 3.12 and 3.13 give the percentage of monosyllabic and multisyllabic words in both repairs types for each language. Table 3.12 provides the results for monosyllabic words. From Table 3.13, we can see that in Sochiapam Chinantec, English, and Mandarin , speakers typically initiate repair in onesyllable words, in both kinds of repair. In Bikol , Finnish, and Indonesian, about one-third to one-fifth of recycling repairs are initiated in one-syllable words, and in Bikol and Finnish replacement repairs, an even lower proportion is found (Indonesian has no monosyllabic words in which replacement repairs are initiated). Japanese is unique in having a very low rate of one-mora words in which recycling repairs are initiated; however, this may
86
Barbara Fox et al.
Table 3.13 Frequency of monosyllabic words for each repair type Recycle
Japanese Indonesian Bikol Finnish Sochiapam Chinantec Mandarin English
Replace
N
%
N
%
8 25 50 37 141
5 21 30 32 76
5 0 3 4 12
9 0 13 9 75
91 284
79 87
30 34
86 74
Table 3.14 Frequency of multisyllabic words for each repair type Recycle
Sochiapam Chinantec Mandarin English Indonesian Finnish Bikol Japanese
Replace
N
%
N
%
1
1
0
0
3 10 26 31 67 92
3 4 22 27 41 63
1 4 12 31 13 35
3 9 41 67 56 66
relate to the fact that one-mora words are somewhat rare in Japanese. Moreover, one-mora words are mostly postpositions (e.g., ni, ga, de, no), and because postpositions follow rather than precede their nouns, they are generally not used to delay next content word due. They thus have a limited functionality in recycling repairs. Turning now to multisyllabic words, we see a picture that is complementary to the one in Table 3.13. From Table 3.14 we can see that in Sochiapam Chinantec , Mandarin, and English speakers do not often initiate either recycling or replacement repair in words of three or more syllables. Indonesian and Finnish have a somewhat higher percentage of recycling repairs initiated in long words and a
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
87
substantially higher percentage of replacement repairs; the increase is particularly striking for Finnish, which actually has the highest percentage of multisyllabic words in which repair is initiated in the languages of our sample. Japanese and Bikol have a fairly high percentage of repair initiation in longer words for both recycle and replacement repairs. If we take these findings back to our original question of site of initiation, it seems that we can now explain some of the basic patterns. Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin speakers initiate repair mainly in monosyllabic words, and, since there appears to be a universal tendency toward initiation when the word is recognizably complete when repair is initiated in monosyllabic words, these two languages show an overwhelming prefer ence for initiation at recognizable completion for both kinds of repair. Finnish and Bikol have a moderate number of monosyllabic words in which recycling repairs are initiated and a low number of monosyllabic words in which replacement repairs are initiated. Finnish has a moderate rate of multisyllabic words in which recycling repairs are initiated and a quite high rate of multisyllabic words in which replacement repairs are initiated. Bikol has a moderately high frequency of multisyllabic words in which repair is initiated for both types of repair. We would thus expect an increased frequency of initiation before the word is recognizably complete, when compared to Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin , because repairs in multisyllabic words tend to be initiated before the word is recognizably complete, and both Bikol and Finnish have a greater proportion of multisyllabic words than do Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin. Both languages match this prediction in having an increase in initiation before recognizable completion for both repair types. Japanese is unusual in having an extremely low rate of monomoraic words as sites of initiation for both kinds of repair, and a fairly high rate of multimoraic words as sites of initiation for both kinds of repair. We would thus expect a strong preference for early initiation for both kinds of repair, since repairs in longer words tend to be initiated before recognizable completion, and this is what we find. In Indonesian , speakers initiate recycling repairs in monosyllabic words with only moderate frequency, and no replacement repairs at all are initiated in monosyllabic words. Recycling repairs are
88
Barbara Fox et al.
initiated in multisyllabic words with a moderately high frequency. Indonesian thus clearly does not pattern with English, Mandarin, and Sochiapam Chinantec in terms of the length of word in which repair is most often initiated. Nor does it pattern with Japanese , as the frequency of repair initiation in multisyllabic words is considerably lower in Indonesian than in Japanese. Indonesian is more like Finnish or Bikol , as all three languages have only moderate numbers of monosyllabic words in which repair is initiated and the frequency of multisyllabic words in which repair is initiated in Indonesian is closest to their frequency in Finnish for recycling repairs and in Bikol for replacement repairs. Indonesian might thus be expected to pattern with Finnish and Bikol and to have an increase in initiation before recognizable completion for both repair types compared with Mandarin and Sochiapan Chinantec. However, the Indonesian data does not show the same prefer ence for site of initiation for the two repair types. Instead, Indonesian speakers prefer initiation after recognizable completion for recycling repairs and initiation prior to recognizable completion for replacement repairs. Indonesian speakers’ preference for initiation prior to recognizable completion in replacement repairs fits our prediction, since longer words show a preference for initiation before recognizable completion, but their preference for initiation after recognizable completion for recycling repairs does not (they should show a greater preference for early initiation even in recycling repairs because repairs are initiated in multisyllabic words with moderate frequency). Indonesian thus appears to be an exception to our pattern; below we suggest that there is a competing cross-linguistic factor at work in Indonesian which produces this result. English is another exception to the findings regarding word length. A preponderance of English recycling repairs are initiated in monosyllabic words, so we would expect English speakers to favor initiation after recognizable completion for recycling repairs, which it does. However, as noted above, English speakers favor initiation prior to recognizable completion for replacement repairs, even in monosyllabic words. We have already suggested that this is a response to interactional pressures, and we will further explore the difference between English and most of the other languages in our corpus below.
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
89
Table 3.15 Site of initiation of recycling repairs in bisyllabic words
Indonesian Mandarin Finnish Bikol English Sochiapam Chinantec Japanese
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
17 (26%) 6 (29%) 20 (43%) 20 (44%) 12 (44%) 21 (49%)
49 (74%) 15 (69%) 27 (57%) 25 (56%) 15 (56%) 22 (51%)
66 21 47 45 27 43
26 (55%)
21 (45%)
47
It appears that only five languages (Sochiapam Chinantec, Mandarin , Finnish, Bikol, and Japanese ) fit the predictions from our general findings about word length and site of repair initiation, while two (Indonesian and English) do not. We argue below that there are principled reasons for these two exceptions. Explaining Indonesian: Longer words and recognizable completion We have shown that Indonesian is exceptional in that, according to the word-length criterion, speakers should show a greater preference for initiation prior to recognizable completion in recycling repairs than they do. We propose to explain this exception in terms of word length and syntactic class. The careful reader will no doubt have noticed by now that we have discussed monosyllabic words and multisyllabic words but have ignored bisyllabic ones. The time has come to rectify this matter. Table 3.15 presents the results for bisyllabic words in recycling repairs. Due to the small number of replacement repairs initiated in bisyllabic words, we will not discuss them in this paper. We find two different patterns in our data. In Indonesian and Mandarin , speakers prefer initiation after recognizable completion in bisyllabic words. To put it another way, they seem to treat bisyllabic words much as they treat monosyllabic ones. In the remaining languages, speakers do not show a preference for site of initiation in bisyllabic words, suggesting that for speakers of those languages
90
Barbara Fox et al.
bisyllabic words are treated as intermediate between monosyllables, in which repair is typically initiated after recognizable completion and multisyllabic words, in which repair is typically initiated prior to recognizable completion. The preponderance of initiations after recognizable completion in bisyllabic words in Mandarin is entirely in line with the general pattern of initiation after recognizable completion in Mandarin.11 Indonesian is unusual in our sample in that repair is most often initiated in bisyllabic words, rather than monosyllabic or multisyllabic words (see Table 3.16). More than half (sixty-six or 56 percent) of simple recycling repairs in Indonesian are initiated in bisyllabic words, whereas the proportion for most of the other languages ranges from one fifth to one third, and for English is far lower (twenty-seven or 9 percent). Only Finnish approaches Indonesian in the frequency with which repair is initiated in bisyllabic words, with forty-seven (41 percent), but even in this case the difference between the two languages is statistically significant (chi-square 5.89, d.f. = 1, p = .0152). The fact that Indonesian does not fit our prediction, and that speakers of Indonesian should prefer repair initiation prior to recognizable completion more frequently than they do in recycling repairs appears to be traceable to the high frequency with which repair is initiated in bisyllabic words. Why should Indonesian speakers so frequently initiate recycling repairs in bisyllabic words? We believe the key lies in the nature of function words in Indonesian: Most function words in Indonesian are bisyllabic (including pronouns, prepositions , and determiners). Indonesian is like English in that function words precede content Table 3.16 Percentage of recycling repairs initiated in bisyllabic words
Indonesian Finnish Japanese Bikol Sochiapam Chinantec Mandarin English
Bisyllabic
All recycling
66 (56%) 47 (41%) 47 (32%) 45 (28%) 43 (23%) 21 (18%) 27 (9%)
117 116 147 162 185 115 285
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
91
words, so function words can be used in recycling repairs as they are in English, to delay next item due. This leads to a high rate of recycling of bisyllabic function words, which, like function words in English, generally show initiation after recognizable completion. Consider Table 3.17, which shows how the relative frequency with which recycling repairs are initiated in bisyllabic function words and in bisyllabic content words in each language: If we compare the number of bisyllabic function words and content words in which recycling repairs are initiated in the languages of our sample, we see that it is indeed the case that Indonesian speakers initiate repair far more often in bisyllabic function words than speakers of most of the other languages. Only Finnish has a higher percentage, and Finnish was the other language with an unusually high percentage of bisyllabic words in which recycling repair was initiated (see Table 3.16). This aspect of Finnish repair will be discussed further below. We now consider the relative frequency of repair initiation in multisyllabic function and content words in the languages in our sample. If we look at Table 3.18 below, we see, first of all, that Mandarin and Sochiapan Chinantec speakers initiate repair in multisyllabic words far too infrequently for data from these languages to be relevant to this question. Of the other languages, Japanese , Bikol, and Finnish speakers are much more likely to initiate repair in multisyllabic content words than in multisyllabic function words. In Indonesian and English, on the other hand, speakers initiate repair in multisyllabic content words and function words with almost equal frequency. Table 3.17 Recycling repairs: Bisyllabic words by syntactic class
Finnish Indonesian Bikol English Sochiapam Chinantec Japanese Mandarin
Function
Content
Total
37 (79%) 42 (64%) 18 (40%) 10 (37%) 14 (33%)
10 (21%) 24 (36%) 27 (60%) 17 (63%) 29 (67%)
47 66 45 27 43
15 (32%) 5 (24%)
32 (68%) 16 (76%)
47 21
92
Barbara Fox et al.
Just as with bisyllabic words so too with multisyllabic; Indonesian has an unusually high number of multisyllabic function words compared with most of the other languages in our sample. In fact, Indonesian by itself accounts for 31 percent of the multisyllabic function words in our data, although it only constitutes 11 percent of the multisyllabic words in which recycling repair is initiated. We can now see that the unusual finding that Indonesian speakers initiate recycling repairs after recognizable completion in longer words can be explained by the tendency to recycle function words to delay the next content word due. Explaining English: Syntactic class and recognizable completion So we are left with English as the language which cannot be fully predicted by our cross-linguistic findings about the correlation between word length and repair initiation. English speakers are unusually likely to initiate replacement repairs prior to recognizable completion, given that 62 percent of replacement repairs in English are of monosyllabic words, which would predict a tendency toward initiation after recognizable completion. We believe that English speakers are less attentive to length in replacements than they are to syntactic class; that is, in replacement repairs, English speakers far more frequently engage in initiation prior to recognizable completion whenever the word is a content word (adjective, noun or verb) and make use of initiation after recognizable completion whenever the word is a function word.
Table 3.18 Recycling repairs: Multisyllabic words by syntactic class
Japanese Bikol Finnish Indonesian English Mandarin Sochiapan Chinantec
Function
Content
Total
6 (7%) 5 (7%) 9 (29%) 11 (42%) 4 (40%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
86 (93%) 62 (93%) 22 (71%) 15 (58%) 6 (60%) 3 (100%) 1 (100%)
92 67 31 26 10 3 1
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
93
Table 3.19 gives the relevant data for replacement repairs initiated in monosyllabic words. The majority of replacement repairs initiated in monosyllabic function words are initiated after recognizable completion, and the majority of replacement repairs initiated in monosyllabic content words are initiated prior to recognizable completion. It seems likely that this difference relates to different interactional implications of function words and content words, where content words are more likely to be interactionally sensitive or inappropriate. It would be desirable to compare English with other languages; however, for many of our languages the number of monosyllabic words in which replacement repairs are initiated is so small that the data cannot be considered representative, and any patterns they might seem to show must be treated with caution. Only Chinantec and Mandarin have more than five exemplars. Nonetheless, we have provided data for all five languages below in Table 3.20 (Indonesian has no replacements initiated in monosyllabic words).12 It appears that in Japanese, Finnish and Bikol, speakers show a tendency that is familiar to us by now: Monosyllabic function words are initiated after recognizable completion. Although the numbers are too small to be anything but suggestive, it looks as though speakers of these languages behave like speakers of English. Of course, unlike these three languages, the English corpus shows a large number of replacement repairs initiated in monosyllabic content words, a fact which makes English look, on the surface, quite different. However, in both Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin , repairs in both function words and content words are generally initiated after recognizable completion. In other words, in neither language do speakers seem to be influenced by word type, which is Table 3.19 English replacement repairs by word type for monosyllabic words
Function words Content words Total
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Total
3 (18%) 14 (82%) 17 (50%)
14 (82%) 3 (18%) 17 (50%)
17 17 34
94
Barbara Fox et al.
not surprising, given that we have seen that speakers of these two languages consistently favor initiation after recognizable completion. It is unclear to us at this point why English speakers (and probably speakers of other languages such as Japanese , Finnish and Bikol ) seem to orient to syntactic class, and, thus, to interactional pressures, while Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec speakers orient mainly to word length. Further data from other languages may provide a clue as to why speakers of these two languages are so consistent in their preference for initiation at recognizable completion. Both are tone languages; one possible avenue to explore is whether tonality may be relevant. A closer look at Bikol and Finnish: Word length and site of initiation Bikol and Finnish both require further discussion because, although they match our predictions about site of repair initiation and word length, in Finnish recycling and both types of repair in Bikol speakers show no statistically significant preference for one or another site of initiation when all the data is grouped together. Because both of these languages have many multisyllabic words in their lexicons, according to the word-length criterion, we would have expected speakers to show a clear preference for initiation prior to recognizable completion. The answer to this puzzle lies in the distribution of word lengths of those words in which repair is actually initiated. Table 3.20 Replacement repairs by word type for monosyllabic words
Sochiapam Chinantec Mandarin Japanese Finnish Bikol
Not recognizably complete
Recognizably complete
Function
Content
Function
1
0
5
6
12
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
9 5 2 3
18 0 2 0
27 5 4 3
Content
Total
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
95
Table 3.21 Word length in recycling repairs
Monosyllabic Bisyllabic Multisyllabic Total
Finnish
Bikol
38 (33%) 47 (41%) 31 (27%) 116
50 (30%) 45 (28%) 67 (41%) 162
In both Finnish and Bikol, as shown in Table 3.21, the distribution of site of repair initiation according to word length is fairly even. Repairs initiated in monosyllabic words in these languages tend to be initiated after recognizable completion, those initiated in bisyllabic roots show fairly even division between the two types of initiation, and those in multisyllabic roots are mainly initiated prior to recognizable completion. As a result, although each syllable type follows our predictions, the data for the languages as a whole shows no preference for site of initiation of repair. Other languages in the sample did not show this type of balance between word lengths. In Japanese , for example, almost no repairs are initiated in monosyllabic words (5 percent), while in English (87 percent), Sochiapam Chinantec (76 percent) and Mandarin (79 percent) most repairs are initiated in monosyllables, and in Indonesian , as noted above, repair is most frequently initiated in bisyllabic words (56 percent). Explaining monosyllabic repair initiation One of the central findings of the current study is that speakers of languages of many different genetic, typological, and areal affili ations initiate repair after recognizable completion in monosyllabic words. This striking finding calls out for an explanation. In this section we proffer several hypotheses and examine evidence that might help us choose among them. In our discussion we focus primarily on recycling repairs. Shortness vs beat of delay As Schegloff (1979) has suggested, recycling is done, basically, to delay next item due. For whatever specific interactional or cognitive
96
Barbara Fox et al.
reason a speaker recycles on a particular occasion, recycling always has the function of stopping progressivity of the turn-so-far and delaying next item due. One obvious explanation, then, for our finding regarding site of initiation in monosyllabic words is that speakers shape their repair to give themselves a beat of delay. If we can say that one syllable gives roughly one conversational beat of delay, then initiating repair at the end of a syllable and repeating that syllable provides the speaker with one conversational beat of delay. Of course, speakers may also lengthen the syllable in which repair is initiated and may also allow silence to develop after the repair initiation, thereby increasing the temporal delay beyond a single beat; nonetheless, repeating a single syllable gives at least a minimum of one beat of delay. This proposal finds support in research regarding the management of overlap. The majority of overlaps are resolved in one to two beats (Schegloff 2000c, 2002b),13 and one common device used to provide those one or two beats is turn-beginning recycling (Schegloff 1987c), in which the speaker recycles the first one or two syllables of the turn to secure a turn in the clear. This fact provides some support for our claim that many interactional difficulties can be resolved within one to two conversational beats and thus that recycling monosyllabic words may be used to provide the speaker with one beat of delay. Moreover, in languages where function words precede content words, speakers have highly entrenched recurrent practices for delaying next content word due, practices which involve the recycling of high-frequency monosyllabic function words. For example, English speakers have as highly entrenched recycling devices “I- I,” “the- the,” “what- what,” “that’s- that’s,” “it’s- it’s” (but they do not have a comparable recurrent practice of, for example, “receivereceive”). These devices provide the speaker with one beat of delay just before a content word is due. According to this explanation for our finding, it is beneficial for a speaker to initiate repair in such a way as to create one (or possibly two) extra conversational beats. In other words, a speaker may choose to initiate recycling repair after recognizable completion in a monosyllabic word, in order to achieve just this amount of delay. With longer words, recycling of only the first one or two
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
97
syllables of the word will produce the same kind of delay, thus allowing speakers to initiate repair earlier in multisyllabic words. But a second possible explanation is also plausible. Monosyllabic words are short, often 200 milliseconds or less, and short words pose challenges to speakers who would like to initiate repair: Will the speaker decide to initiate repair in time to do so before the word reaches recognizable completion? If the speaker decides to initiate repair a bit late, it might not be possible to actually initiate the repair before the word is recognizably complete. The recycling still accomplishes delay, but the repair is initiated after recognizable completion because the speaker didn’t recognize a need for delay until the last moment. We thus have two clear possible explanations for our finding. We recognize that in any given case it is impossible to know when or why the speaker decided to initiate repair. However, when we look at the aggregate, we may be able to discover patterns which will provide clues as to what types of pressures speakers respond to most frequently. In the next section we explore three pieces of evidence that address this issue. Three sources of evidence The first piece of evidence comes from comparing sites of initiation for content words and function words in our languages. We have suggested that function words are most likely to be used to delay the next content word due and, therefore, to provide speakers with an extremely useful device. We would expect that content words would not be recycled with the same frequency as function words, because, while they may do important work in providing occasional delay for gaze organization, overlap resolution, etc., such functions are less frequent than the need to delay next content word due. In fact, in our sample of seven languages, in five of them speakers range from moderately to highly more likely to initiate repair in a function word than a content word. The two exceptions are Japanese , where function words follow content words and thus are less likely to be used to delay the next content word due, and Bikol , where one third of simple recycling repairs are initiated in verbs, and which has a rich system of verb prefixes which can be used to delay verbs.
98
Barbara Fox et al.
A related piece of evidence comes from Indonesian . In Indonesian, most function words are bisyllabic. In spite of a cross-linguistic tendency for lack of preference in site of initiation in bisyllabic words, Indonesian speakers prefer initiation after recognizable completion for bisyllabic words, possibly because these tend to be function words that are used to delay the next content word due. This fact provides evidence that speakers indeed use function words to create a beat (or two) of delay. English offers additional support for the idea that speakers use recycling to create a beat (or two) of delay. First, the vast majority of English recycling repairs (80 percent) are initiated in function words, which would be a surprising finding if there weren’t some natural connection between function words and recycling, such as the one we have suggested of delaying next content word due. Second, even when content words are recycled, there is often evidence that they are being used to provide a beat of delay. Of the thirty-four monosyllabic content words in our collection, twenty-one were initiated after recognizable completion. Of those, the majority appear to be designed to provide delay in response to interactional pressures. Twelve are in overlap and attempt to bring the speaker into the clear. Another three occur in word searches within compound or complex noun phrases, where they are delaying the next noun due, and two are recyclings of the phrase “he goes,” which delays an upcoming clause of reported speech . It therefore appears that English speakers often recycle complete words to provide a beat of delay, rather than because they have decided too late to initiate repair. In addition, we have seen evidence from replacement repairs that English speakers are perfectly capable of initiating repair before recognizable completion in monosyllabic content words. One could argue that monosyllabic function words are even shorter than monosyllabic content words, due to frequency-induced phonological reduction, thus allowing for even less time to initiate repair; while this is no doubt true, the evidence from English still suggests that shortness alone is not the crucial factor in site of initiation in monosyllabic words. We have thus found several facts to support the hypothesis that speakers initiate repair after recognizable completion in monosyllabic words in order to provide a beat of delay. While it is impossible to prove, or disprove, a claim that in some cases speakers
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
99
don’t decide to initiate repair until they have reached the end of a word, and it is likely that this type of situation occurs, both when speakers initiate repair in a monosyllabic word and in a longer word, it is unlikely to be the explanation for the frequency with which we find repair initiation after recognizable completion in monosyllables. However, Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec provide evidence that for some languages, neither of our explanations is appropriate. In these languages, repair is consistently initiated after recognizable completion in monosyllabic words, both content and function, and most repair is initiated in monosyllabic words. It seems that for these two languages speakers have a recurrent practice of initiating repair after recognizable completion, a practice that is only rarely overridden. We are not sure why this should be the case. Given that the two languages in question are both tonal, it may relate to tonality. Or it could be a kind of grammaticalization of a highly useful practice. Further research is needed to understand this issue more deeply. Summary and conclusion This is the first study of site of repair initiation from a crosslinguistic perspective that we know of. We began this study by noticing that there is a wide range of variation in relative frequency of site of initiation across the languages in our sample. We then asked the question: Is this variation just random variation, or do universal principles manifesting through language-specific means create the variation? What we have proposed in this study is that there are indeed universal principles at work in shaping site of initiation patterns cross-linguistically. First, we noticed that different repair types can have very different patterns of initiation, probably relating to differences in interactional function. Second, we noticed that length of word is one factor that correlates with site of initiation. We found that in both recycling and replacement repairs monosyllabic words tend to be repaired after recognizable completion in all the languages of our study; furthermore, multisyllabic words tend to be repaired prior to recognizable completion in all but one of the languages that have enough
100
Barbara Fox et al.
multisyllabic words to show a pattern. Indonesian is the only exception; in this language, speakers show no preference for initiation before recognizable completion in multisyllabic words (see Table 3.11). We also observed that in most languages in our sample speakers show no preference for site of initiation in bisyllabic words. In Indonesian , however, which has an unusually high frequency of repair initiated in bisyllabic words, speakers strongly prefer initiation after recognizable completion. This means that in languages in which speakers initiate repair mainly in monosyllabic words (such as Sochiapam Chinantec , Mandarin, and English), they tend toward initiation after recognizable completion, while in languages in which speakers prefer initiation in multisyllabic words (such as Japanese ), they tend toward initiation prior to recognizable completion. On the other hand, if speakers of a language shows no preference as to the length of the words in which they initiate repair (such as in Bikol and Finnish), they will also show no overall preference for a single site of repair initiation, even though for each of the three categories of word length (monosyllabic, bisyllabic, and multisyllabic) they follow the patterns we have observed. Third, we noticed that replacement repair tends to be initiated prior to recognizable completion in four of our seven languages (English, Indonesian , Japanese, and Finnish ). Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin , in which speakers almost always initiate repair after recognizable completion, do not participate in this pattern, nor does Bikol, where speakers show no preference. We offered several possible explanations for these cross-linguistic patterns. First, we suggested that speakers tend to initiate repair after recognizable completion in monosyllabic words because of late decisions to initiate repair. Since speakers may not decide to initiate repair until they have gotten partway through a word, if those words are monosyllabic, then by the time the speaker chooses to initiate repair, the word is recognizably complete. It is worth noting that high-frequency function words are often somewhat and sometimes radically phonologically reduced, at least in English (Jurafsky et al. 1998). Phonological reduction might make it more difficult to initiate repair prior to recognizable completion. Second, we explored the possibility that speakers initiate repair after recognizable completion in monosyllabic words because they want to create a beat of delay. We suggested that there may be a tendency for monosyllabic words to be function words, and that
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
101
function words tend to be recycled to delay next content word due; in such cases – in languages for which function words precede content words – speakers may want a beat (or two) of delay, since one of the main purposes of recycling in these instances is to provide a temporal delay. This same reasoning could explain why in Indonesian repair tends to be initiated in bisyllabic words after recognizable completion, since in Indonesian function words are frequently bisyllabic. Clearly such reasoning does not apply to Japanese , since in Japanese function words follow content words. Japanese has developed other techniques for accomplishing delay (Fox et al. 1996). We proposed that while either of these explanations could be the relevant one in any given case, the overall patterns of repair initiation that we have observed suggest that speakers frequently recycle monosyllabic words to achieve a beat of delay, and that repair initiation after recognizable completion is a recurrent practice. However, Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec , where speakers have a consistent practice of initiating repair after recognizable completion in all word-lengths, under almost all circumstances, seemed to suggest the possibility that in some languages speakers may have generalized the pattern to be a fixed practice. We also suggested that multisyllabic words provide many opportunities to initiate repair before coming to the recognizable completion of the word. It may be that in most cases of repair initiation, the speaker needs only one or two extra conversational beats, and with multisyllabic words a speaker doesn’t need to produce the whole word to get those beats. We further suggested that speakers favor early initiation in replacement repairs in several languages just because replacements are generally of content words, which are generally longer in most languages in our study. Additionally, speakers may choose to initiate repair sooner so as not to be held accountable for alternate formulations or so as not to produce inappropriate terms. In Mandarin and Sochiapam Chinantec this tendency is not expressed. We hope to have demonstrated that site of repair initiation can be a window onto differences across languages, as well as onto universal principles of repair organization. We also hope to have provided evidence that sometimes differences across languages mask the universal interactional patterns that organize them, and that research on cross-linguistic differences also benefits from a search for those universal patterns (cf. Sidnell 2007c).
102
Barbara Fox et al.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank Vincent Sarich for statistical and editorial assistance, Emanuel A. Schegloff for clarifying comments and for providing the original inspiration for this study, and Jack Sidnell for inviting us to participate in this volume and for insightful comments on an earlier draft. Funding was provided by NSF grant number BCS0406512 . Authorship Barbara Fox analyzed the English data. Fay Wouk analyzed the Indonesian data. Makoto Hayashi analyzed the Japanese data. Steven Fincke analyzed the Bikol data. Liang Tao analyzed the Mandarin data. Marja-Leena Sorjonen and Minna Laakso analyzed the Finnish data. Wilfrido Flores Hernandez analyzed the Sochiapam Chinantec data. Barbara Fox and Fay Wouk wrote the majority of the paper with data and input provided by the other co-authors. Notes 1 Replacements and deletions differ in that in replacements the word type remains although the token has been replaced, while in deletions the word type is eliminated. 2 This has been amply demonstrated for English by Jasperson (1998). 3 This might seem to be a substantial change from Schegloff ’s proposal, since the category post-beginning has been expanded from including just the first sound of the word to including all but the very last sound. However, in actual fact, at least for English the difference is not as great as it sounds. It turns out that for English (the language on which Schegloff based his original proposal), initiation after the first syllable but prior to recognizable completion is an extremely rare occurrence; in our corpus of 339 simple repairs, only eight were initiated in these in-between locations. The same is true of Sochiapam Chinantec and Mandarin . It’s only when we turn to languages with large numbers of multisyllabic words that the middle category becomes robust. 4 By inappropriate we do not mean offensive to the recipient; we simply mean that it is not the word that the speaker finds best suited to the context. 5 And in some cases the speaker may wish to be accountable for an inappropriate or offensive term. 6 For Japanese, the relevant category is actually the mora, not the syllable. All Japanese counts in the following discussion represent mora
Initiation in same-turn self-repair
7
8 9
10
11
12
13
103
rather than syllable counts. However, for simplicity of exposition, we will use the term “syllable” throughout when referring to all languages in the study. The term mora will only be used in discussions restricted to Japanese. All three of these languages have a range of word lengths; 80 percent of words in the modern Mandarin lexicon are compound words, thus usually bisyllabic; Sochiapam Chinantec has mainly monosyllabic roots but makes use of a wide range of prefixes to form bisyllabic words; the English lexicon clearly has many words of two or more syllables. However, according to our findings, in these languages repair is initiated primarily in monosyllabic words. Studies of the frequency of different word lengths in everyday conversation in these languages might shed light on this discrepancy. These differences are no doubt in part a reflection of the average length of words in general the different languages. Word length in Mandarin was determined as follows. If the syllable (where repair is initiated) and its following syllable(s) form a tight unit in that they cannot be further divided into sub-components (Adj-N), then it is a bisyllabic or multisyllabic word. If the syllable and its following syllable(s) form a relatively loose unit that allows insertion of grammatical elements into it (i.e., the site of initiation is a syllable that has a meaning of its own to contribute to the whole utterance), then this syllable is a monosyllabic word. Because content words are open class, there are a larger number of potential candidates in any given context than there are for function words. In addition, content words are generally of lower frequency than are function words. Thus speakers face a greater challenge in selecting the appropriate term. In fact, it is more puzzling that Sochiapam Chinantec speakers do not show this preference than that Mandarin speakers do, given the many similarities we have seen between these two languages where repair is usually initiated in monosyllabic words. It would appear that the difference relates to the presence of verbal prefixes in Sochiapam Chinantec and the frequency with which verbs are broken off after the prefix but before the root as a way of delaying the next verb due. However, a complete discussion of this matter is beyond the scope of this paper. Although Mandarin has thirty simple replacement repairs, three had to be excluded from this analysis, as the syntactic class of the word that was replaced was ambiguous. Resolution in the first two beats is done without recourse to techniques of competitive production, while those that go over two beats typically involve competitive production (Schegloff 2000c, 2002b).
4 Repairing reference Maria Egbert, Andrea Golato, and Jeffrey D. Robinson
Introduction Languages provide speakers with resources for both referencing and repairing.1 While referencing is crucial for sustaining intersubjectivity, repairing is crucial for re-establishing intersubjectivity (Auer 1984; Schegloff 1992a; Schegloff et al. 1977). This chapter describes a repair-initiation action that claims that a particular aspect of the prior turn presents “trouble” for its speaker (e.g., understanding the prior turn; for a review of “repair” and its associated terminology, see Schegloff 1992a). The trouble source is treated as being a pro-term/indexical expression (e.g., “it”, “this”, “that”). The repair operation – that is, the interactional move that is performed by the speaker of the trouble source in response to the repair-initiation action being investigated, and that is designed to deal with/resolve the trouble – involves producing a full-reference form/full noun phrase (NP) (e.g., “the folder”, “the token”, “the ticket”) that is relevantly associated with the trouble-source indexical expression. Given that the trouble-source speaker orients to the trouble source as being an indexical expression, and given that the trouble-source speaker resolves the trouble by producing a recipient-designed full-reference form, the repair-related trouble can be characterized as a referent that is (claimed to be) underspecified for the person initiating repair. Languages provide for different types of referents, such as people, places, times, and things. This chapter focuses on a comparative analysis of one repair-initiation action in English and German that always (in our data) is taken by troublesource speakers as targeting underspecified “thing”-referents. The repair-initiation action being examined is implemented by “Was denn” or “Was.” in German and “What.” in English. (For initial
Repairing reference
105
observations, see Schegloff 1997b; Schegloff et al. 1977; Selting 1987a, 1987b, 1987c, 1988, 1992). This repair-initiation action can be characterized as seeking specification of a claimedly underspecified referent. This chapter is organized as follows: After a brief description of the data and transcriptions, the analysis is presented in five steps. First, we show how final intonation plays an essential role in differentiating “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” from open-class repair initiators “Was?”/“What?” delivered with rising intonation (Drew 1997; Schegloff et al. 1977). Second, we analyze cases in both German and English to demonstrate that “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” implement a repair-initiation action that is produced to seek the specification of a claimedly underspecified referent. The third section provides additional evidence that “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” claim trouble with the specificity of an indexical expression by examining repair-initiation turns that contain two succeeding repair-initiation attempts (i.e. doubles ; Schegloff et al. 1977). The fourth section contrasts “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” with a different but allied repair-initiation action implemented by “Für was.”/“For what.”, which receives, as a repair operation, an increment (i.e. an extension) rather than a specification of a referring expression in the trouble-source unit. Finally, the fifth section discusses the commonalities among, and differences between, “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” in terms of range of usage and function. In this section, we also discuss one non-repair-initiation action that can be implemented by “Was.”/“What.”, which is a “go-ahead” to a pre-announcement action. This chapter closes with a discussion of method ological issues related to a comparative analysis.
Data The repair-initiation implemented by “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” appears to be a relatively rare action in conversation. The German data consist of thirty hours of mundane conversation (eighteen hours of videotaped face-to-face interaction and twelve hours of audio-taped telephone conversation), including two-party and multi-party interaction with speakers from different dialectal regions within Germany. These data produced fifteen instances of “Was denn” and six instances of “Was.” used by others to initiate repair.
106
Maria Egbert et al.
The American English data consist of sixty-five hours of mundane conversation (sixty-two hours of audio-taped telephone conversation and three hours of videotaped face-to-face interaction), which yielded a total of seventeen instances of “What.” used by others to initiate repair. The aforementioned numbers do not include instances of “Was denn”/“What.” (“Was.” is not found) used as “go‑ahead” responses to pre-sequence-initiating actions, i.e. instances that do not initiate repair (Schegloff 2007b ). All data were transcribed using the transcription system developed by Gail Jefferson (Atkinson and Heritage 1984). As described below, intonation is a constitutive feature of “Was denn/“Was.”/“What.”. Unit-final intonation is represented with a period for falling intonation and a comma for slightly rising intonation. In the text, German “Was.” and English “What.” are referred to with periods to reiterate their final-intonation contours. For the German transcripts, each utterance is represented by three lines of transcription: The first line presents the original utterance; the second consists of a word-for‑word gloss; and the third provides an idiomatic English translation. When the idiomatic translation corresponds to the gloss, only the idiomatic translation is given. (For reasons to be discussed, “Was denn” is idiomatically translated as “What.”). Sound files were analyzed with the acoustic software Praat (Boersma and Weenink 2006). Final-intonation as a constitutive feature of “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” Final-intonation contour is part of action formatting (CouperKuhlen and Ford 2004; Couper-Kuhlen and Selting 1996; Golato and Fagyal 2008; Schegloff 1998a; Selting 1995) and plays an important role in conveying the precise function of practices of other-initiated repair (Schegloff 1997b; Selting 1987a, 1987b, 1987c, 1988, 1992). The lexical items “Was denn”, “Was”, and “What”, which are used to implement the practice under investigation, can also be used to implement a different repair-initiation practice: open-class (e.g., “What”). However, in contrast to the practice described in this paper, open-class repair initiators are regularly produced with final-rising intonation, such as “Was?”/“What?” (Drew 1997; Schegloff 1997b; Selting 1987a, 1987b, 1987c, 1988,
Repairing reference
107
1992). Furthermore, open-class -repair initiators do not specify what part or aspect of a trouble-source unit is problematic, i.e. they leave “open” the type of trouble in play (Drew 1997; Schegloff et al. 1977). Although repair operations in response to open-class repair initiators can vary (e.g., Schegloff 2004), they frequently take the form of repeats of the trouble source. The following two examples show such a repair operation in response to German “Was?” and English “What?” (1) Konferenz [Kirsten:1:16:24] 01 K: .hhh Du [ich wollt dich was-] .hhh You [I wanted you something] .hhh You [I wanted to (ask) you ] [ ] 02 → R:
[ [
Wie lang wars]ten da? How long were yo]u there?
03 K: Wa? Wha’? 04 (0.2) 05 K: .h Ich war nur [ä:hm .h I was only [u:hm [ 06 → R:
] ] ]
[Wie lang ] warstn>da< [How long ] were you >there<
07 K: Nur- bisschen weniger als ne woche. Only- little less than a week. (2) IMPOSSIBLE [Marcia and Joe] 01 M: 02→ J: 03 04 M: 05→ J: 06 07 M:
He’s just impo:ssible. Did juh tell ’im that? (0.4) Wha:t? D’=juh tell ’im that? (1.4) No:
In response to “Wa?” and “What?”, Rita and Joe respectively produce verbatim repeats of the entirety of their trouble-source units (compare lines 6 and 5, respectively, with line 2 in both cases). There are occasions when open-class repair initiators are treated as
108
Maria Egbert et al.
dealing with reference trouble, as evidenced by responses that are “replacements of ‘specialized’ reference terms – whether technical ones, recognitional ones, uncommon ones, or others – by ones designed to be more accessible, better recipient designed, and so forth” (Schegloff 2004: 96–98). For example, see Extract 3, supplied by Schegloff (2004: 97). (3) SPC, NYE, 6 (NTRI #130b)] 01→ 02 03→ 04
A: Do you have some church affiliation, now? B: What? A: Do you belong to a church now? B: No I went to church I haven’t been …
In contrast, “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” are not delivered with strong final-rising intonation. Furthermore, as shown below, “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” always (at least in our data) target reference trouble of a particular type, i.e. underspecification.
0.254349886
Pitch (Hz)
500
75
0
Time (s)
wa?
Figure 4.1 Open-class repair German “Wa?”
0.5108
Repairing reference
109
The intonation contour of “Was denn” ranges from final-falling to fi nal-slight‑rising, where the slight rise neither exceeds that of the unit’s initial pitch nor reaches the pitch ranges seen in “Was?”/“What?”. Figures 4.1–4.5 exemplify the waveforms, spectrograms, and pitch contours of different practice classes of other-initiated repair presented in this chapter, beginning with open-class repair initiation (Figures 4.1–4.2) and ending with “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” repairs (Figures 4.3–4.5). “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.”: A practice of other-initiated repair As a preview, our argument is that, when co-participants use “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” as a repair initiator, trouble-source speakers understand it to claim that trouble-source units themselves contain a “thing”-referent that is underspecified for the co-participant and, thus, to request its specification. The trouble
0.31
Pitch (Hz)
500
75 0
Time (s)
what?
Figure 4.2 Open-class English “What?”
0.62
110
Maria Egbert et al. 0.238004535
Pitch (Hz)
500
75 0
Time (s)
0.476
was
Figure 4.3 Underspecified referent repair initiation (URRI) German “Was.”
0.383129252
Pitch (Hz)
500
75 0
Time (s)
was
denn
Figure 4.4 URRI German “Was denn.”
0.7663
Repairing reference
111 0.308333333
Pitch (Hz)
500
75
0
Time (s)
0.6167
what
Figure 4.5 URRI English “What.”
sources are almost always, but not necessarily exclusively, proterms/indexical expressions. 2 Before beginning the analysis, two conceptual/definitional issues need to be addressed. First, although “thing”-referents are commonly real-world physical objects (e.g., photo album, parking token, airplane ticket), they can also be more abstract objects, such as sources of humor and characterizations of events. In our collection of “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” that implement repair initiation, the trouble source is never a person, place or time referent. Second, we chose the term “underspecified” for the following reasons. Repair operations consist of producing full-form “thing”-referring expressions that correspond to indexical “thing” -referring expressions in trouble-source turns. Thus, trouble-source speakers orient to the trouble, as made relevant by “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” as being one of underspecification for the people who initiate repair. In addition, we provide evidence (in the form of “doubles”; see below) that interactants who initiate repair orient to “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” as being produced to
112
Maria Egbert et al.
target reference-underspecification trouble. Thus, the characterization “underspecified” is drawn from participants’ orientations, and “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” involve a claim to be experiencing reference-underspecification trouble. Importantly, we do not use the term “underspecified” to suggest that, during the production of trouble-source units, their speakers necessarily design them to contain underspecified referents, as in the case of puzzles (although this can be the case). During the following analysis, readers’ attention is drawn to: 1. the distinctive unit-final intonation contours of “Was denn”/ “Was.”/“What.”, which either fall (in the case of “Was.”/ “What.”) or only slightly rise (in the case of “Was denn”); 2. the trouble-source units, whose grammatical structure embodies “thing”-referents in form of pro-terms or indexical s; 3. the repair operation, which involves trouble-source speakers specifying trouble-source referring expressions and thereby orienting to them as having been somehow underspecified. In each extract, trouble-source units are labeled with Arrow A, “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” with Arrow B and repair operations with Arrow C. This section begins by examining German data, including two cases of “Was denn” and one of “Was.”, and then proceeds to examine three English cases of “What.” Extract 4 is drawn from a family get-together involving Martha, Fina, Elfi, Laura, and Bärbel, who have been looking at pictures and singing songs from a book with memorabilia. Prior to this segment, in line with the activity of reminiscing, Laura is looking for a folder with photos she brought. Laura has first asked Martha where the folder is, to which Martha has referred her to Elfi, who refers Laura to Fina, whose response is displayed in line 1. In line 4, Bärbel is the last one being addressed in Laura’s search for the photo folder. Bärbel has been sitting at the table, displaying listenership. (4) MAPPE [CAE2 5:20] 01 F: Ick häff hier nix liggen. I have here nothing lie. I have nothing lying here.
Repairing reference
113
02 (1.0) ((M, F, and E looking for photo-folder)) F: Nee nee nee nee. 03 No no no no. 04→a L: Bärbel du hast se zuletzt gehabt. Bärbel you had it last have. Bärbel you had it last. 05→b B: Was denn, what PRT, What. 06→c L: Die mappe m- oder hab ich die The folder w- or have i it The folder w- or did i have it 07 ((Bärbel leans forward and reaches out for the folder on the table between herself and Laura))
The trouble-source unit, “Bärbel du hast se zuletzt gehabt.”/ “Bärbel you had it last.” (line 4), contains the direct object “se”/“it.” It is marked for grammatical gender , case, and number to correspond to the locally initial form, “die mappe”/“the folder” (feminine, accusative, singular). In response, Bärbel initiates repair with “Was denn,”/“What.” (line 5). The unit-final intonation slightly rises, but this rise does not reach the same height as the unit’s pitch onset. Laura responds by specifying the trouble-source referring expression in that she produces its full-reference form, “se”/“it,” as “die mappe”/“the folder” (line 6), thereby treating “Was denn,”/“What.” as seeking such specification. This repair operation successfully resolves the trouble in that Bärbel reaches for the folder and hands it to Laura. The larger activity of searching for the photo folder is thus also completed. Here, like almost all other repair-initiators, “Was denn,”/“What.” is treated as a post-first insertion sequence (Schegloff 2007b ), where it serves to resolve trouble in order to continue a larger course of action. Extract 5 is drawn from a videotape of a dinner conversation. Prior to this extract, Sybille and Annette have been talking about parking tokens that local businesses distribute when customers exceed a certain spending limit. Three other speakers are present, including Bernhard, who has up until now been engaged in a side conversation (not displayed in transcript).
114
Maria Egbert et al.
(5) PAULA [Fischessen:1:08:06] 01→a S: Da hättst es kriegn müssen.= There should=have it get must.= There you should have gotten it.= 02 [((A shaking her head)) [ 03→b B: [=Was denn, [=What PRT, [= What. 04→c S: Die stadette. The token.
At line 1, Sybille asserts that Annette should have received a token for purchasing a corkscrew, “da hättst es kriegn müssen.”/“there you should have gotten it.”. Grammatically , Sybille’s “es”/“it” is a direct object of this trouble-source unit. The real-world referent of the pro-form is clear to the addressee Annette, who is responding in line 2 with a headshake and who is not initiating repair. However, Bernhard initiates repair with “Was denn,”/“what.”, which has slightly rising final intonation (similar to Extract 3, above). At line 4, Sybille responds by specifying the trouble-source referring expression, “es”/“it’’, as “die stadette.”/“the token.”. Bernhard’s repair initiation is perhaps not surprising as the turn at line 1 was not addressed to and thus not designed for him. As Lerner (2004: 163–4, 178) noted, turns designed for an addressed party can be problematic for non-addressed parties and hence result in repair. Repair initiation (like Bernhard’s in this case) can be a practice for entering already ongoing conversations or moving out of schisming (Egbert 1993, 1997a). For a final German example, this time of “Was.”, see Extract 6, which is drawn from a coffee-table conversation, at which two women named “Susan” are present and a third is referred to (line 4). Prior to line 1, one of the two co-present Susans (and the only Susan featured in Extract 6) has been the center of attention. When she asked for the sugar pot, other co-participants commented that she is the only one taking sugar with her coffee. Susan responded by disclaiming that she typically takes artificial sweetener for weight reasons; therefore, her taking of sugar is a potentially sensitive topic . The request sequence of asking for sugar and
Repairing reference
115
the topic of taking sugar are complete when Georg launches his turn at line 1, which is addressed to the weight-conscious Susan. Note that Georg’s turn contains the indexical “ d as”/“that”.3 (6) Zucker [CAE1 3_20] (simplified) 01→a G: Du Sue das ham die susans You Sue that have the susans Sue! That seems to be something 02 wohl so an sich.= PRT like that with them.= the Susans have in common.= 03→b S: =Was.= =What.= 04→c G: =Zucker. Sue in Ahaus die nimmt auch zucker= =Sugar. Sue in PLACE she takes also sugar= =Sugar. Sue in Ahaus she always takes sugar too= 05 S: =Nee ich nehm eigentlich süßstoff =No i take PRT sweetener =No i usually take sweetener
At lines 1–2, Georg points out that “die Susans”/“the Susans” share “das”/“that.”. Grammatical ly, Georg’s “das”/“that” is the direct object that refers to a shared habit (i.e. not a real-world object as in the previous examples). At line 3, Sue initiates repair with “Was.”, which is produced with final-falling intonation. Georg responds by specifying his referring expression: “Zucker. Sue in Ahaus die nimmt auch zucker”/ “Sugar. Sue in Ahaus she always takes sugar too”. This operation is successful in that the trouble in understanding is resolved, as can be gleaned from Susan’s rejecting response at line 5. Georg’s turn is interesting in the followings ways. It reopens an already closed topic which is sensitive to Susan; it implies that “all” Susans take sugar although the second co-present Susan does not; and it ignores the first Susan’s explanation that she usually takes sweetener. Note also that Georg turn-initially singles out the first Susan as addressee (“du susan”). Given these features, we may speculate whether his use of the indexical is designedly underspecified and that he sets Susan up to initiate repair and thus taking a bait. The bait would consist in insisting that she has the habit of taking sugar although she says she usually takes sweetener. Georg
116
Maria Egbert et al.
would thus imply Susan has lied, and, in addition, he covertly draws attention to Susan being overweight. In response, Susan insists that she usually takes sweetener, thus rejecting Georg’s assumption, but by initiating repair she has already taken the bait. Such cases where the trouble source may potentially be designed as underspecified are rare. Our collection contains two such cases.4 While these two cases could entail a bait or puzzle, they are nevertheless treated as repair initiations. The repair-initiation action accomplished by the German “Was denn”/“Was.” is paralleled by that of the English “What.”. For the first of three English examples, see Extract 7, which is drawn from a three-way telephone call between a mother, father, and their young-adult son who no longer lives at home. At lines 1–3, the mother reminds her son that he and his sister are supposed to provide their parents with a list of desired Christmas presents. (7) Ticket [CF:5051] 01 M: Uh:m I need you gu:ys to:uh: (0.2) start (.) 02 workin’ on your (0.2) Chris’mas lists:,=small 03 duh big, please, for each of you:,= 04 S: =M[m:that’s ri]ght. 05 M: [Uh:( )- ] 06 M: We’re gunna go:to[: ] 07→a S: [Wel]l you got thuh big one. 08 (0.5) 09 S: .hhhh (0.2) ( )-= 10→b D: =Wha[:t. ] 11 M: [Wel]l12 (.) 13→c S: Thuh- (.) thee:=uh:ticket. 14 (.) 15 M: Mm.= 16 D: =O[h ] 17 M: [W]e:ll °(th)-° some- (.) D: °#Ye[ah.#°] 18 19 M: [That ]’s somewhat. .hhhh Uh:m () 20 >you=know< >we’re gunna< go: to: 21 Spokane ’n another week or 22 so so (.) I’d like tuh start lookin.’ 23 (0.7) 24 S: °(Oh)-° Okay. I:’ll=uh I’ll think about it.
After the son merely acknowledges (but arguably does not agree with) his mother’s reminder/request (Lindström 1997), “Mm: that’s
Repairing reference
117
right.” (line 4), the mother pursues his agreement by beginning to account for needing the list (line 6; see the mother’s later pursuit at lines 20–22, especially her repeat of “we’re gunna go to . . .”). The mother’s request contains an implicit potential offer to buy “big” gifts (lines 2–3, “small duh big”), and, at line 7, the son interrupts her by saying that a large gift has already been agreed upon, “Well you got thuh big one.”. Here, the son refers to an as-of-yet-unnamed “big” present with “the big one” (which turns out to be an airplane ticket). Grammatical ly, “the big one” is the direct object in this trouble-source unit and is a placeholder that is specified in the repair operation with “thee: =uh: ticket.” (line 13). In other words, the reference in the trouble-source unit is a more “granular” reference form (Schegloff 2000a) than the reference form in the repair operation. In this case, “the big one” is treated as being underspecified by the dad, who initiates repair, but not by the mom, who displays that she understands “the big one” by beginning to respond at line 11, “Well-,” which is comparable to how she re-begins at line 17, “We: ll”. At line 10, the dad initiates repair with “Wha:t.” (which is produced with final-falling intonation). The son responds by specifying “the big one” with “thee:=uh: ticket” (line 13). There is evidence that the dad’s “Wha:t.” constitutes repair initiation. At line 16, his “Oh,” which sequentially is a third-positioned action relative to the repair sequence (Schegloff 2007b ), claims a change of state from unknowing to knowing (Heritage 1984). And, at line 18, the dad responds to the son’s “Well you got thuh big one” by partially discounting it with a (delayed and) dismissively produced “°#Yeah.#°”, thereby treating the “Wha:t.” as having delayed the progression of the son’s claim in order to better understand it. (The mom similarly dismisses the son’s claim at lines 11, 17, and 19.) For a second English example, see Extract 8, which is drawn twenty-seven minutes into a telephone call between Sue and her boyfriend Max. Sue has initiated all of the major topics and has done a majority of the talking. (8) Phone (CF:6507) 01 S: 02 03 M: 04 05→a S:
.hhh Anyway there’s nothing on you(r)- more on your mind is there. (0.4) Uh:not really. h=Oh:.=hh (.) .hhh (and) a:re- (.) are all our
118
Maria Egbert et al.
06→a our conversations gunna end up like this, 07 (.) 08 S: On thu[h phone,-] 09→b M: [Wha:t. ] 10→c S: .hhhhhh (0.2) I mea[n] 11 M: [(O]h./No.) h= 12→c S: =.hhh (I’ll=say) something:you know pretty:=h (.) 13→c >somewhat-< (.) you know pretty good that hap14→c you know happened (to you then you) say something 15 .hhhhhhhhhh[h h-=[or ] 16 M: [.pt=We:l[l >you kno]w< you gotta 17 understand th’t I’m:kind=of a little ti:red,
Although Sue’s action at lines 1–2 solicits additional conversational topics (Button and Casey 1984), it is grammatical ly designed to prefer (and thus presume) a “No”-response. Given that Max has not previously initiated any major topic , Sue’s turn can be heard as an interpersonal complaint regarding Max’s lack of enthusiasm or interest in terms of talking to her (for in-depth research on complaints, cf. Heinemann and Traverso, forthcoming; Yoon 2006). In the wake of Max’s (delayed) agreement, “ U h: not really” (line 4), Sue asks/accuses: “are all our conversations gunna end up like this” (lines 5–6; note the extreme-case formulation “all our conversations”; Pomerantz 1986). Grammatically, Sue’s “like this” is an adjunct (in the form of an adverbial expression of manner) and refers to the immediately prior sequence of action (at lines 1–4). In response, Max initiates repair with “Wha:t.” with final-falling intonation (line 9), to which Sue responds by specifying what she “meant” (see line 10, “I mean”) by “this.”. That is, she specifies her complaint by providing a characterization of how the call has “ended up” (lines 12–14). Max orients to his “Wha:t.” as having initiated repair on Sue’s turn and thus as having delayed its progression to better understand it, by subsequently responding to it by defending himself: “We:ll >you know< you gotta understand th’t I’m: kind=of a little ti:red” (lines 16–17). For a final English example, see Extract 9, which is drawn from an American telephone call between two college students, Carla and Rich. (9) Humorous [UTCL:D08] 01 02
C: Peet’s a:lways there. ((i.e. at the apartment)) R: °Y°:eah he is.=
Repairing reference
119
03 C: =B’t your never there. ((i.e. at the apartment)) 04 (1.6) C: (No:pe) 05 06 (1.0) R: Hh hh [hh °hh° ] 07 08 C: [Where are] you. on thuh pho:ne, R: .hhhh ((laugh-relevant inbreath)) 09 C: ↑What’re you↓ sa:ying? 10 R: .huh ((laugh)) 11 12 (0.4) C: Te:ll me:. 13 R: .hhh hh=heh (0.5) .huh (0.2) No:thing I’m 14 15→a j’st- I find it humorous. 16→b C: ↑Wha:t.↓ 17→c R: Just (tw)- listening duh you. C: What I sa:id? 18 R: Yes. 19 C: Peet’s always the:re, 20 R: Yes. an’ I’m n:ever ‘ere. 21 C: So where are you. 22
When Rich fails to respond (at line 4) to Carla’s assertion that Rich is never at his apartment, “B’t your never there.” (line 3), Carla produces a candidate response (for Rich) that aligns with her position: “No:pe” (line 5). After a long gap of silence at line 6, Rich laughs, “Hh hh hh °hh°” (line 7), and continues laughing at lines 9, 11, and 14. Perhaps because of Rich’s displayed lack of attention (i.e. his failure to respond at line 4), or because Rich’s laughter (at line 7) is disjointed from prior talk (i.e. lines 1–5, which neither participant oriented to as being funny), Carla begins to suspect – evidenced by her chastising question “↑What’re you↓ sa:ying?” (line 10) and its pursuit “Te:ll me:.” (line 13) – that Rich might be talking to, and laughing about something with, his roommate Peet. Rich ultimately answers Carla at lines 14–15: “No:thing I’m j’st- I find it humorous.”. Grammatically, Rich’s “it” is the direct object of this trouble-source unit. As a pro-form, “it” is analyzable as being underspecified relative to its full-reference form, which is the source of what Rich finds humorous. Indeed, as the repair operation to Carla’s “↑Wha:t.↓” (line 16), Rich responds by specifying the humor source: “Just (tw)- listening duh you.” (line 17). To review Extracts 4–9, “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” are produced with either clearly falling intonation (in the case of “Was.” and “What.”) or with non-strong-rising intonation (in the case of
120
Maria Egbert et al.
“Was denn”), which differentiates them from open-class forms (Drew 1997). The trouble sources are pro-terms or indexical expressions (e.g., “it”, “that”, “this”; in the data), adverbial expressions of manner (e.g., “like this”), and placeholder nouns (e.g., “the big one”) that refer to “things”, which include not only realworld physical objects (e.g., photo album, parking token, airplane ticket), but also more abstract objects (e.g., a source of humor, a characterization of a telephone call, and a habitual physical action). “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” implement repair initiation by halting the forward progression of a prior course of action (regarding progressivity , see Lerner 1996) in order to deal with a particular type of referential trouble, i.e. its claimed underspecification. “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” are responded to with specifications of referring expressions. The referring expression in the trouble sources may or may not have been used in sequentially proximate prior environments, including the prior turn. Further evidence: The case of “doubles ” So far, we have examined formal features of the repair initiators “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” and their uptake by co-participants. These results are strengthened by observations of a special kind of context in which “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” can occur, and that is when they are produced in the same turn with another repairinitiation action. In such multi-unit turns (called “doubles” by Schegloff et al. 1977), the second repair-initiation attempt is typically “stronger” (more specific) than the first in terms of locating the trouble source . In doubles, “ Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” are placed first, followed by stronger confirmation requests of candidate specifications of trouble-source referring expressions. For a German example, see Extract 10, which is drawn from a dinnertime interaction. (10) WEIN [Fischessen_1.31.10] (simplified) 01→a A: Ptz ptzptzptz ºderº is lecker. der g- der Pts pts pts ºitDEMº is tasty. that- p- that Pts pts pts ºthat oneº’s tasty. that- p- I 02→a schmeckt mir am besten von allen. tastes to me the best of all. like that one best of all of them.
Repairing reference
121
03 B: Ja? Yeah? A: [Mh ºhmmº] 04 [Uh ºhumº] [ ] 05→b D: [Was denn. ] [What PRT. ] [ “What.” ]
[Dieser wein hier? ] [This wine here? ] [This wine here? ] [ ]
06→c A: [((Points at wine)) ] 07→c A: mh ºhmmº uh ºhumº 08 (0.5) ((D starts turning bottle to read label))
As context, two minutes prior to Extract 10, the interactants discussed what they would drink next. Annette had suggested continuing to drink another bottle of the same white wine, whereas Sybille had suggested a bottle of red wine. In Extract 10, at lines 1–2, Annette produces an extreme-positive assessment (Auer and Uhmann 1982; Pomerantz 1984) of the same bottle of white wine that she had suggested earlier: “Der schmeckt mir am besten von allen.”/“I like that one best of all of them.”. Annette produces a slight head nod toward the bottle of wine during the production of “der”/“that one”. Grammatical ly (in German), Annette’s “der”/“that one” is the subject. Note that the German “der” has the same form as the article “der” in “der Wein”. Annette’s “der”/ “that one” relies on a demonstrative determiner to refer to a referent indexical ly (Hanks 1992). In spoken German, this form is often used as a pronoun (i.e. instead of “er”) or as a demonstrative (i.e. instead of “dieser”). German grammar thus provides for an indexical form which is not easily translated directly into English. At line 5, David treats the referring expression as being underspecified by initiating repair with “Was denn” (line 5), but then immediately following it up with a request for confirmation of a candidate referent: “Dieser wein hier?”/“this wine here?”. David’s candidate solution, “Dieser wein hier?” is grammatically congruent with the pronoun “der” in the trouble-source turn in that both are morphologically marked for the grammatical gender masculine and case-marked for the nominative. In moving from “Was denn” to a
122
Maria Egbert et al.
candidate solution, David displays an orientation to his own “Was denn” as doing the job of targeting a “thing” referent in need of specification to him. Note that Annette similarly orients to the function of “Was denn”; that is, immediately after its production, and before David produces his candidate solution, she specifies her “der”/“that one” by pointing at a specific bottle of wine. Thus, in doubles with “Was denn”, the second repair-initiator offers a candidate specification of the troublesome indexical . For an English example, see Extract 11, which is drawn from a phone conversation between Joe and his mother. Prior to this fragment, Joe and Marsha have discussed a variety of topics dealing with Marsha. Deep into the call, Joe asserts that “he can’t talk very long” (line 1). With a delayed “by thuh way” (line 3), Joe orients to his assertion as being “misplaced” relative to prior talk (Schegloff 1984, 1987c), and, at lines 6–7, Joe returns to prior talk by producing a summary assessment of it. (11) Stanford (Marcia and Joe) 01 J: 02 03 04 J: 05 06→a J: 07 08 09→b M: 10→c J: 11 12 J: 13 14 M: 15
Oh we can’t talk very long ‘cause I=‘as jus’ talkin’ tuh gra’ma. (0.4) by thuh way. (0.4) But this sounds like=ay- very interesting situation you’re in you’re in here. (0.2) What. Mi::ne? Ye:ah. (0.5) With Stanford research an’ everything. (1.4) Oh I myself am auditioning for Ca:melot this June.
In the trouble-source unit (lines 6–7), Joe’s “this”, in combination with “a very interesting situation”, alludes to, and thus is analyzable as being underspecified relative to, a particular “situation”. After a slight pause (line 8), Marcia initiates repair with “What.” (line 9), targeting “this” in the trouble-source turn, and then immediately follows it up with a request for confirmation of a candidate domain of “situation”, “Mi::ne?”, which attempts to clarify the nature of the “interesting situation” being referred to. Here, Marcia displays
Repairing reference
123
an orientation to her own “What.” as doing the job of targeting an underspecified referring expression. Joe treats Marcia’s request for confirmation as such by first confirming, “Ye:ah.”, and then by supplying a particular situation: “With Stanford research an’ everything.” (line 12). A contrasting practice with a similar form: “Für was.”/“For w hat.” The function of “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” can be put into relief by examining a different, but allied, repair-initiation action: “Für was.”/“For what.” The comparison of these two different repair‑initiation actions is presented to shed further light on the unique function of “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.”. In Extracts 4–9, repair-related trouble was associated with referring expressions contained in trouble-source units themselves. Alternatively, we will now discuss one other way in which repair-related trouble can be associated with referents. In these cases, none of the referring expressions in the trouble-source action are treated as presenting “trouble”, but, rather, the trouble-source action presupposes a referent (e.g., an elaboration of a direct object), and the knowledge / understanding of this referent is necessary to adequately “grasp” the trouble-source action. This alternative type of reference trouble can be dealt with by an alternative repair-initiation practice, “Für was.”/“For what.”, which prompts (Lerner 2004: 169) the prior speaker to elaborate a prior utterance. The trouble-source utterance is syntactically complete, and the repair operation in the form of an increment provides pragmatic completion. For a German example, see Extract 12. The trouble-source unit is Oma’s announcement: “ Ich hab’ jetz’ wieder ‘nen neues rezept gekriecht”/“I have now gotten another prescription again” (line 4). (12) Für was (Oregon 1A_1:38) 01 M: =.hh Wie oft musst’n zur krankengymnastik. =.hh How often must+you to+the physical therapy. =.hh How often do you have to go to physical therapy. 02 O: Äh dreimal die woche °ne.° Uh three times the week °PRT.° Uh three times per week you know.
124
Maria Egbert et al.
03 (.) 04a→ O: Ich hab’ jetz’ wieder ‘nen neues rezept gekriecht, I have now again a new prescription got, I have now gotten another prescription again, 05b→ M: Für was. For what. (0.5) M: Ach so f[ür die gymnastik. 06 Oh i see f[or the therapy. [ 07c→ O:
[Für die krankengymnastik. [For the physical therapy.
Grammatically, Oma’s “rezept”/“prescription”, is the direct object. Based on the analysis of Extracts 4–9 (above), to initiate repair with “Was denn”/“Was.” would be to claim that “rezept”/“prescription” is itself underspecified. However, Markus initiates repair with “Für was.”/“For what.”, which alternatively claims that the troublesource unit elided a referring expression necessary for his understanding and solicits an increment (Schegloff 1996b; 2001) to the trouble-source unit. In this case, Markus’s “Für was.”/“For what.” is responded to with an elaboration of the direct object (i.e. the source mandating the prescription). Both participants orient to this as the repairable . Oma responds by producing a grammatical increment to her trouble-source question that supplies a new referent: “die krankengymnastik”/“the physical therapy” (line 7). Prior to Oma’s response, Markus himself claims that he has resolved the trouble with “Ach so”/“Oh I see” (Heritage 1984; Golato and Betz 2008), and then repairs the trouble with “für die gymnastik”/“for the therapy”, which displays his understanding of his “Für was.”/“For what.” as seeking an elided referring expression. For an English example, see Extract 13, in which the troublesource unit is Ada’s question at line 6. (13) Loan (CH:4365) 01 A: .mtch So:u- (.) I=s- I:was thinking 02 o[f sen]ding mom an’ da:d (.) uh:m about a 03 M: [.hhh] 04 A: hundred bucks. 05 (.) 06a→ A: .hhh Does that sound reasonable to you,=
Repairing reference
125
07b→ M: =For what. 08 (0.9) 09c→ A: Off of what I owe them.
Grammatically, Ada’s “that” (line 6) is the subject. Based on the analysis of Extracts 4–9 (above), to initiate repair with “What.” would be to claim that “that” is itself underspecified and seek its specification, such as a recharacterization of Ada’s proposal at lines 1–4. However, Max initiates repair with “For what.”, which alternatively claims that the trouble-source unit elided a referring expression necessary for his understanding and solicits an increment to the trouble-source unit. Similar to Extract 12 (above), Max’s “For what.” seeks an elaboration of the subject (i.e. Ada’s reason for sending the money). This is oriented to by Ada, who responds by supplying her reason, “Off of what I owe them.” (line 9). (The) Difference(s) between “Was.” and “Was denn” As mentioned in the introduction, there is an easily describable difference in form between “Was denn” and “Was.”. “Was denn” contains the particle “denn” and is delivered with an intonation contour that ranges from falling to slightly rising. “Was.” does not contain a particle and is always delivered with clear final-falling intonation. Given these form features, German “Was.” is akin to English “What.”. However, distributionally, when used to initiate repair, “Was denn” (75 percent of corpus) occurs much more frequently than “Was.” (25 percent of corpus). Furthermore, and perhaps more importantly, similar to English “What.”, in German only “Was denn” is used to accomplish a specific nonrepair function, namely a “go-ahead” action to pre-sequence-initiating actions (Schegloff 2007), such as a summons, preannouncement , and story/ joke preface (see examples below). In our data, we found no cases of “Was.” used as “go-ahead” action, suggesting that “Was.” is reserved for repair-initiation actions only. Such distributional and action-based differences suggest that “Was denn” (1) is the more generic, common, or default form relative to “Was.”; and (2) may be the more appropriate equivalent of English “What.”. What follows are two examples of pre-announcements (Terasaki 1976) that are relevantly responded to, and progressed, by “Was denn”/“What.”, respectively. As Schegloff (1997b) argues, there is
126
Maria Egbert et al.
not a one-to-one correspondence between practices and actions, and, in the following cases, “Was denn”/“What.” are not used to implement repair initiation. For a German example, see Extract 14, from an interaction between two adults and two children, with one of the children beginning to tell a story. (14) Weisstduwas (SandL_T1_0.22.48) 01→a S: Un weißt du (.) wa:as, An you know (.) wha:t, 02→b A: Was denn, What PRT, What. 03→c S: Und die .hh (ni.hhna) .H hat(te) auch And the .hh ((name .hh)) .H has/had also And .hh ni.hhna has also once 04 mal ihre ((2 syll.)).H[HH PRT her ((2 syll.)).H[HH (had) her ((2 syll.)).H[HH [ 05 A:
[Ja? [Yes? [Really?
Extract 15 is drawn from an English telephone conversation between two sisters, Kathy and Janet, the former of whom is planning a vacation to Cabo San Lucas and has been searching for reasonably priced airline tickets. (15) Cabo (Sister Calls.2) 01→a K: An’ then uhm guess what. 02→b J: What. 03→c K: ’Cause I called ‘er because 04 .hh Kaytlen fo:und uh::m (0.2) 05 things for a hundred an’ fifty. 06 to go duh Cab[o.] 07 J: [.H]HHH She di:d?
In both Extracts 14–15 (above), line 1 involves the first part of a preannouncement sequence, which initiates a course of action and solicits a response. Similar to many preannouncement sequences, these (see “Arrow A”) project the presence of announcables without
Repairing reference
127
explicating them. Here, they are alluded to by “Was denn,” and “What.”, respectively, which refer to actions or events. These preactions function to frame their projected announcements as “news” for recipients (Terasaki 1976) and make use of underspecified referents (actions or events in the lives of the interactants) to which the prefer red response “Was denn,”/“What.” then engenders the actual announcements. At line 2 in both examples, “Was denn,”/“What.” functions as a second-part “go-ahead”, which is oriented to as such by pre-announcers when they proceed to deliver their announcements (lines 3–4 and 3–6, respectively), thereby explicating the referring expression. Rather than halting the progressivity of the pre-announcement sequence, “Was denn,”/“What.” propels the course of action. Extracts 14–15 were presented for two reasons. First, the interactional achievement of “Was denn”/“What.” as second pair parts of a pre-announcement sequence is different from initiating repair, while they share the feature that they request more specification. In response to both functions, a reference is “unpacked”. Second, our preceding comparison of pre-announcement go‑aheads and repair initiators sheds light on a hypothesis of how “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” may differ in their repair initiation function. In German, relative to “Was.”, “Was denn” is the more default repair-initiation form, and it may be the case that “Was.” is doing something unique. This aligns with Thurmair’s (1991: 382) observation that German w-Fragen (wh-questions) typically contain the modal particle “denn” and that such questions without “denn” are marked. All of this, though, begs the question of what “denn”’s uniqueness might be in the context of repair-initiation. Because we have too little data to pursue this hypothesis further, we offer some speculative possibilities. An initial way of getting at differences between “Was denn” and “Was.” is to examine aspects in which they do not differ. Our limited data suggest no differences in terms of idiolectal and dialectal factors, nor medium (i.e. telephone vs. co-present interaction), nor number of participants (i.e. two or more), nor distance between the trouble-source referring expression and the reference form to which it (sometimes) connects back. There also seems to be no difference in prefer ence organization, i.e. “Was denn” and “Was.” can target trouble-source units which are preferred or dispreferred .
128
Maria Egbert et al.
Regarding this last observation, however, relative to “Was denn” both native-speaker authors of this chapter (Maria Egbert and Andrea Golato) perceive “Was.” as sounding more “terse”. Their vernacular understanding is also expressed by research in linguistics , which reports that “denn” makes utterances friendlier and possibly less blunt (Durrell 1992; Helbig 1988: 107; Hentschel and Weydt 1983: 266; Schwitalla 2003: 153). One subtle difference might exist at the sequential level. In each of our six cases of “Was”., the trouble source is always the unit immediately prior to “Was.”. In our fifteen cases of “Was denn”, this is so for thirteen cases, but there are two cases in which the trouble-source unit is farther removed. Thus, it is possible that the effectiveness of “Was.” relies on a more proximate relationship between itself and the trouble-source unit, whereas “Was denn” may remain effective given a more distant sequential relationship. We speculate that the particle “denn” serves to claim that repairinitiators have a general sense of intersubjectivity amid the need for reference specification. Such a sign of general intersubjectivity would not be necessary with “Was.” because the trouble source is immediately prior. Although more research on actual conversation is necessary, the aforementioned speculation is in line with linguistic descriptions of the function of the particle “denn”. When “denn” is used in questions, linguists have argued that it indicates that such questions refer to immediately prior talk (Dittmann 1980; Franck 1980: 222; Helbig 1988: 107; Thurmair 1989: 164, 166), and thus are not asked “aus heiterem Himmel” (“out of the blue”) (Zifonun et al. 1997: 1219). The particle “denn” is also said to target things that are known, or assumed to be known, by hearers (Helbig 1988: 107). Along these lines, Franck (1980: 225) argued that “denn” is frequently used in utterances that request further explanation before its speakers are able to respond to the content of the utterance (i.e. in repairs). Discussion Given the important relevance of referencing to intersubjectivity, it makes sense that the organization of repair provides conversationalists with specific practices for repairing reference-related
Repairing reference
129
troubles. Lerner (2004: 180–181, footnote 25) noted that there are multiple practices with which speakers can deal with “inadequate or insufficiently complete or a not yet response-ready turn that has reached possible completion.” Our small collection of thirty-eight instances from a corpus of ninety-five hours suggests that there is a specific category of repair initiation designed to request specification of “thing”-referring expressions which the repair-initiating speaker claims to be underspecified and thus inhibiting full understanding. In German and English, this can be realized with “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” produced with nonrising intonation. This chapter extends prior research on German (Selting 1987a, 1987b, 1987c, 1988, 1992) and American English (Schegloff et al. 1977; Schegloff 1997b) by comparatively analyzing one particular type of repair initiation that requests the specification of “thing”referents that are somehow embodied in the components of trouble-source units themselves. This practice was implemented by “Was denn”/“Was.” in German and “What.” in English, produced with either final-falling or slight (but not strong)-rising final intonation. Future research needs to examine other types of troublesource specific repair initiators, including those that target person, place, and time-referring expressions (such as “Wo.”/“Where.”, and “Wann.”/“When.”) (See Schegloff et al. 1977, for comments on English “Where”, see also Lerner 2004). For now, we consider the term “thing” (as in “thing”-referent) to be an analytic one. In the data, “things” include not only realworld physical objects (e.g., photo album, parking token, airplane ticket), but also more abstract objects (e.g., a source of humor, a characterization of a telephone call, a habitual physical action, and an action/assertion). Future research needs to explore in more detail how members orient to persons, places, times, and “things”. As argued most forcefully by Selting (1987a, 1987b, 1987c, 1988, 1992), our analysis reiterates that intonation is an important, constitutive feature of practices of other-initiated repair. As suggested by our analysis of “Was denn”, when languages provide particles, they too can be constitutive features of repair initiation. Relative to the distribution of previously analyzed classes of other-initiated repair, such as open-class initiators (Drew 1997), rising‑intoned interrogative words (e.g., “Who?”, “When?”, “Where?”), and various types of repeats and reformulation of trouble
130
Maria Egbert et al.
sources (Sacks and Schegloff 1979), “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” repair initiations seem to be rare. This rarity might be explained by the presence of a set of first-order conversational practices and prefer ences regarding reference that obviate the relevance of “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.”. For example, the preference for selfcorrection (Schegloff et al. 1977) and the associated practice of “try-marking” (Sacks and Schegloff 1979) tend to preclude the need for “others” to initiate repair, for example, through iterations of trouble-source unit completion, recipient silence, and same-speaker continuance (Heritage 2007). Furthermore, there is a preference for using recognitional reference forms (at least when referring to persons; Sacks and Schegloff 1979), which, in our data, are not targeted by “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.”. Finally, there are practices regarding the use of locally initial and subsequent reference forms that promote intersubjectivity (Schegloff 1996a). Thus, “Was denn”/“Was.”/“What.” are only “needed” when other conversational safeguards have “failed”. Our findings add to the growing evidence that at least the context-free, structural organization of repair outlined first for English (Schegloff et al. 1977; see also Schegloff 1992a), and replicated for Thai (Moerman 1977) and for German (Egbert 1996), seems to be universal . Our findings further suggest that different languages (in our case, German and English) may contain similar linguistic and intonational resources (in our case, the lexical item “Was.”/“What.” produced with falling intonation) to accomplish similar repair-initiation actions. Method ological issues in conducting a cross-linguistic analysis One conversation analytic goal is to analyze how linguistic resources are used in talk-in-interaction to achieve social actions, thus contributing to a theory of social order. Since languages provide different resources, cross-linguistic research contributes to the theoretical question of what dimensions of human sociality are universal and what are specific to particular linguistic communities (see the introduction to this volume, see also the collection in Enfield and Stivers 2007, and here in particular, Hanks 2007 and Levinson 2007). Given this theoretical relevance, we would like to make transparent how method ological decisions and procedures in conducting a comparative analysis may influence the analysis
Repairing reference
131
and thus potentially impact the theoretical development. We are addressing how the role of English as data and as a lingua franca in the conversation-analysis community may shape our findings. Similar to many other comparative studies, the present chapter analyzes the commonalities and differences of one phenomenon across two languages. All cross-linguistic studies on repair have taken English as the basis for comparison, for example, Moerman ’s (1977) analysis of repair in Thai, Egbert ’s (1996, 2002) work on repair in German, Kim’s (1993) study of generalized other-initiated repair in Korean , or Sidnell ’s (2007a) analysis of repairing person reference in a small Caribbean community. When doing so, it may be tempting to look for those formats that have been found for English, yet it is vital that the researcher remain open for all kinds of formats, including ones not attested in English. 5 Similarly, it may be tempting to compare items across languages based on form congruities (e.g., downward intoned German “Was.” and downward intoned English “What.”). However, the present chapter has shown that more can be gained by comparing functions of utterances, i.e. actions across languages. Similarly, our analysis cautions against translating utterances based on (perceived) phonological or lexical correspondences. For example, based on having similar lexical forms, linguistic meanings, and prosodic shapes, one might be biased toward translating the German “Was.” as the English “What.”. In contrast, our analysis suggests that the German “Was denn” is a more appropriate translation because it and the English “What.” are more similar in terms of the actions they accomplish. That is, unlike the German “Was.”, the German “Was denn” and the English “What.” accomplish both repair initiation and goahead responses to pre-sequences. In sum, we suggest that translations be based on an analysis of action, sequential placement, and function rather than on perceived form congruities (for a similar argument, see Betz and Golato 2008). Many comparative studies show that it is difficult or impossible to accurately translate interactional data into English. Even when a morpheme-by-morpheme gloss is provided with the transcript, the original language is not fully represented. One way that a reader of English can be made aware of this dilemma is by leaving words such as particles in the original language within the English rendering (Sorjonen 2001). This works well for highlighting the focal phenomenon, yet it would render a transcript illegible if used for all
132
Maria Egbert et al.
items which lack an appropriate translation. Descriptions of what the English translation does not capture can be cumbersome for the reader, and the researcher is forced to find a balance between focusing on the relevant features of the phenomenon and to what level the nature of the data can be sustained. Acknowledgments All three authors contributed equally to this research. We thank Emma Betz for helping with transcription and bibliographic work and Christopher Stewart for creating the PRAAT files. Additionally, we thank Emma Betz, Trine Heinemann, Anna Lindström, MarjaLena Sorjonen, and Jakob Steensig for their feedback on individual data segments. We are grateful to Emanuel A. Schegloff for feedback on an earlier draft and to Jack Sidnell, the Editor, for both feedback and support. All remaining errors are of course our own. Notes 1 “Repair” is defined as the mechanism by which trouble in speaking, hearing, and understanding is claimed and resolved (Schegloff et al. 1977). 2 We intentionally avoid the terms “locally subsequent” (vs. locally initial) and “non-recognitional” (vs. recognitional ) because they have only been empirically verified with regard to person-reference, and this chapter deals with thing-reference (but see Golato 2005 for a discussion of locally initial and locally subsequent forms for thing-references in German). 3 Here and in other data samples we chose to summarize stretches of the interaction which would have been too long to display. 4 We would like to thank Emanuel A. Schegloff for drawing our attention to designedly underspecified references. 5 The idea that our knowledge of talk-in-interaction in most languages may be shaped by what is already described for English is due to the history of the field, whose first-generation researchers have reported profound results mainly on English. Therefore, taking English as a basis of comparison is more a decision due to the history of science than to scientific reasoning.
Part III
Aspects of response
5 Projecting nonalignment in conversation Anna Lindström
Projecting nonalignment Early conversation-analysis (CA) research established that nonaligning actions are typically delayed and that turn-initial objects can project nonalignment. These features provide a resource for recipients, allowing them to anticipate nonaligning responses and to revise their prior action before such a response is realized in this way avoiding the occurrence of rejection or disagreement . Sacks (1987) showed that in conversation there is an association between agreement and contiguity on the one hand, and disagreement and noncontiguity on the other. Agreeing utterances tend to be contiguous while disagreeing utterances are noncontiguous. Consider Extract 1. (1) (Sacks 1987: 58) 01 A: 02 B: 03 04
Yuh comin down early? Well, I got a lot of things to do before gettin cleared up tomorrow. I don’t know. I w- probably won’t be too early.
As Sacks noted, B’s disagreement – “ probably won’t be too early” – is not only weak, additionally, and more important for this study, it is not produced until the end of B’s turn. The disagreement is prefaced by “Well,” an account “ I got a lot of things to do before gettin cleared up tomorrow,” a hedge “I don’t know,” and a selfinterruption “I w-” all of which serve to delay its production. The distinctive features of agreeing and disagreeing turns were explored
136
Anna Lindström
further by Pomerantz (1975, 1978, 1984). Focusing on how predisagreements shape sequence trajectories she noted that: a gap after a first pair part to which agreement /disagreement is relevant may function as an “unstated” or “as yet unstated” disagreement . That is, if a recipient delays in initiating his talk post the completion of a turn to which agreement /disagreement is relevant, that delay-gap may be disagreement implicative for his [sic] co-participant. As such, that co-participant may resume talk post a gap with talk which displays a sensitivity toward a discrepancy between the parties. (Pomerantz 1975: 79)
This is illustrated in the following Extract 2. (2) (SBL:3.1.-8). (Pomerantz 1975:79, line numbers added) 01 B: 02 03 B: 04 A:
. . an’ that’s not an awful lotta fruitcake. (1.0) Course it is. A little piece goes a long way. Well that’s right.
B makes an assertion in line 1 “an’ that’s not an awful lotta fruitcake.” Faced with no uptake from A (line 2), she revises her assertion in line 3 “Course it is. A little piece goes a long way.” B’s revision potentiates A’s agreement in the ensuing turn “Well that’s right.” In Pomerantz’s terms, B’s revision shows her sensitivity toward the discrepancy between A and B’s displayed points of view. In this example, a silence was treated as disagreement implicative. Other devices for projecting nonaligning responses include prefaces, partial repeats, anticipatory accounts , and “pro-forma” agreements (Heritage 1984b, 1988; Levinson 1983; Pomerantz 1975; Schegloff 1995b, 2007b). Pomerantz (1975) argued that modifications and revisions such as B’s “Course it is. A little piece goes a long way.” coupled with the tendency to delay or withhold actual disagreement has “a minimizing effect on the occurrences of disagreements and a maximizing effect for agreements . In such instances, it is not only what would be a disagreement may not get said, it is also that what comes to be said may be said as an agreement” (Pomerantz 1975: 81). In line with this work, alignment can be understood as the product of finely tuned negotiation between speaker and recipient. The present study focuses on how this negotiation is sequentially realized over the course of each emerging TCU by demonstrating how a prosodic variant of the affirmative response
Projecting nonalignment in conversation
137
token “ja” can be used to project a nonaligning responsive action in Swedish conversation. The dictionary-assigned meaning for “ja” is “yes.” There are several prosodic variants of the Swedish “ja”. I use the term “curled” to draw attention to two prosodic features: a lengthened vowel and a slight rise in pitch toward the end of the syllable (represented by colons and underlining in the transcript). The collection of curled “ja” turns include tokens that begin with an open /a/ as well as ones that begin with a soft /j/. The arrowed lines in Extract 3 show a curled “ja” response to a proposal. (3) Visit (MOL:1:A). In line 10, A is referring to the fact that she has to help her children get accustomed to institutional day care by spending time with them at the day care facility. 01 A: → Hörru ja tänkte höra ifall ni ville ha Listenyou I thought hear in case you wanted have Listen I was going to ask if you wanted to be 02
en liten påhälsning¿< a little visit paid a visit
03 V:
↑Ja: de vill vi gärna?↑ Yes that want we gladly Yes we would love to
04 A:
Utav mej å ba:rnen¿ By me and the children
05 V:
Ja::: jättegä:rna? Yes very gladly Oh yes of course
06 A: I veckan¿ In the week This week 07 V: → .hh Ja:: (.) de e lite kärvt ((smilevoice)) men .hh Ja:: (.) ‘t’s little difficult but .hh Ja:: (.) it’s a little tricky but 08
de- vi ska se vicken da hade ‘ru tänkt då, ‘t- we will see which day had “you thought then ‘t- let’s see which day had you thought of then
09 A: Nej ja har inte tänkt nånting