This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
3,
and 2* = +oo if N = 1,2, is called a critical
For AT > 3, let
be the best Sobolev constant. Then, by G. Talenti's results (cf. [362]),
o_l|v^lli
\\u\\l,' where (Ar-2)/4
(iV(iV-2)) U{x) = ^ '
(N-2)/2
Note that if R ^ is replaced by a bounded domain, S is never achieved. Let iVC(a;)e(^-2)/2
^e{x) :--
(£2 + Ixp)
(Af-2)/2'
where A^ = {N{N - 2))^^ ^^^".e > 0 and ^ e Cg°(R^, [0,1]) with i{x) = 1 if |a:| < r/2; ^(x) = 0 if |x| > r, where r can be chosen to meet different requirements. Proposition 1.15. The following estimates are true (see e.g. pp.35 and 52 ofM. Willem [377]):
r
ce2|^n£|+0(e2),
ll^e||i = where c > 0 is a constant.
A^ = 4,
6
CHAPTER
1.
PRELIMINARIES
We shall frequently use the following Gagliardo-Nirenberg Inequality, see L. Nirenberg[262] (see also L. C. Evans [147] and J. Chabrowski [89]). Proposition 1.16. For every u G H^{¥i^)^ \\u\\,
yGR^R ^
where B{y^r) q
\un\^dx ^ 0 ,
n ^ 00,
JBiy^r) JB{y,r)
:= {u e E : \\u — y\\ < r}, then Un ^
0 in I/^(R^) for
Proof. We just consider A^ > 3. Choose Pi,P2,^ > l,t^ > 1 such that Pit = q^p2t' = 2*,l/t + 1/t' = l,pi + p2 = P' By Holder's Inequality and Proposition L13, we have \Un\^dx B{y,r)
<( [
lur^r'dxY^'f [ lur^r^'dxY^'
^JB{y,r)
^
^JB{y,r)
<-^\,
^
'" lB{y,r)
I
<
c
(
•
lB{y,r)
\Unr*dxy"( -
•
/ {ul + ^JB{y,r)
- ' ^ ' ^ ^
^
-
\SJUn\'')dxy''\ - ' ' ' ' '
(In this book, the letter c will be indiscriminately used to denote various constants when the exact values are irrelevant.) Covering R ^ by balls with radius r in such a way that each point of R ^ is contained in at most A^ + 1 balls, then we have /
|u„|^dx<(A^ + l)c sup f /
\un\'^dx)
which impUes the conclusion. This proves the theorem.
1/t
D
1.3. DIFFERENTIABLE
1.3
FUNCTIONALS
7
Differentiable Functionals
Let ^ be a Banach space with norm || • ||. Let U C E he SLU open set of E. The dual (or conjugate) space of E is denoted by E^, i.e., E^ denotes the set of bounded linear functionals on E. Consider a functional I : U ^ H. Definition 1.18. The functional I has a Frechet derivative F ^ E' at u ^ U
heE,h^o
\\h\\
We define r{u) = F or \/I{u) = F and sometimes refer to it as the gradient of / at u. Usually, r{') is a nonlinear operator. We use C^(t/, R) to denote the set of all functionals which have continuous Frechet derivative on U. A point u ^ U is called a critical point of a functional / G C^{U, R), if
r{u) = 0. Definition 1.19. The functional I has a Gateaux derivative G ^ E' atu if, for every h ^ E, t^o
t
^U
^^
The Gateaux derivative ai u ^ U is denoted by DI{u). Obviously, if / has a Frechet derivative F e E^ dit u e U, then / has a Gateaux derivative G e E^ dit u and I\u) = DI{u). But the converse is not true. However, if / has Gateaux derivatives at every point of some neighborhood oi u ^U such that DI{u) is continuous at u^ then / has a Frechet derivative and I'{u) = DI{u). This is a straightforward consequence of the Mean Value Theorem. Let f{x,t) be a function on O x R, where O is either bounded or unbounded. We say that / is a Caratheodory function if / ( x , t) is continuous in t for a.e. x G O and measurable in x for every t G R. Lemma 1.20. Assume p > l^q > I. Let f{x,t) on ft X H and satisfy \f{x,t)\
< a + 6|t|^/^
be a Caratheodory function
V(x,t) G O X R ,
where a, 6 > 0 and O is either bounded or unbounded. Define a Caratheodory operator by Bu:= f{x,u{x)), ueLP{n). Let {i^fcj^o ^ LP{Q). If\\uk -uoWp -^ 0 as k ^ +oo, then \\Buk - Buo\\q -^ 0 as k ^ oo. In particular, if ft is bounded, then B is a continuous and bounded mapping from 1/^(0) to L^{ft) and the same conclusion is true if ft is unbounded and a = 0.
8
CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARIES
Proof. Note that there is a renamed subsequence such that (1.1)
Uk{x) -^ uo{x),
a.e. x e ft.
Since / is a Caratheodory function, (1.2)
Buk{x) -^ Buo{x),
a.e. x e ft.
Let (1.3)
Vk{x) := a + 6|^fe(x)|^/^
A: = 0,1, 2 , . . . .
Then by (1.1)-(1.3), (1.4)
\Buk{x)\ < Vk{x) for all x ^ ft;
Vk{x) -^ vo{x) a.e. x ^ ft.
Since \uk\^ -\- \UO\P — \\uk\^ — |i^o|^| ^ 0, by Fatou's Theorem, we have
/ hminf (\ukf + i^or - ii^^r - i^ori)^^ (1.5)
< hminf /
(\ukf^\uof-\\ukf-\uof\)dx.
Combining (1.1)-(1.5), we see that (1.6)
lim
/ ||^fe|^-|^orM^ = 0.
It follows that (1.7)
/ \v^-v^\Ux
\
\\u^\^-\u^\^\dx^^
as A: ^ oo. Since there are constants C > 0, Ci > 0 such that \Buk-Buo\i
<
C{\Buk\'^ +
\Buon
<
C,i\vk-vo\^
+ \von
a.e. X G O, by Fatou's Theorem, / liminf (Ci{\vk - ^ol' + l^ol") - \Buk (1.8)
< liminf /
Buo\'')dx
(Ci{\vk-vo\''^\von-\Buk-Buo\Adx.
1.3. DIFFERENTIABLE
FUNCTIONALS
9
By (1.2), (1.3), (1.7) and (1.8), we have \\Buk-Bu\\q^O. Finally, if O is bounded, then for any u G 1/^(0), evidently we have (1.9)
\\Bu\U
where c > 0 is a constant. Inequality (1.9) remains true if O is unbounded and a = 0. Therefore, 5 is a continuous and bounded mapping from 1/^(0) to 1/^(0) and the same conclusion is true if O is unbounded and a = 0. D
The following lemma comes from M. Willem [377]. Lemma 1.21. Assume pi,p2,qi,q2 tion on O X R and satisfy \f{x,t)\
> 1- Let f{x,t)
< a|t|^i/^i + 6|t|^^/^%
be a Caratheodory func-
\/{x,t) G O X R,
where a,b > 0 and O is either bounded or unbounded. Define a Caratheodory operator by Bu := / ( x , u{x)),
uen:=
L^' (O) H L^' (O).
Define the space <£::=L^i(0) + L^2(0) with a norm \\u\\s = mf^\\v\\L.iin)
+ \\w\\L.2in) :u = v^weS,ve
L^'{n),w
e L^^(O)}.
Then B = Bi -\- B2, where Bi is a bounded and continuous mapping from L^^iQ) to L^^{Q)^i = 1,2. In particular, B is a bounded continuous mapping from Ti to 8. Proof. Let (f : R ^ [0,1] be a smooth function such that £^{t) = 1 for t G (-1,1); ^(t) = 0 for t ^ (-2, 2). Let ^(x,t) = e ( t ) / ( x , t ) ,
h{x,t) = (1 - e ( t ) ) / ( x , t ) .
We may assume that pi/qi < ^2/^2- Then there are two constants d > 0,m > 0 such that \g{x,t)\ < (i|t|^i/^S \h{x,t)\ < m|t|^2/^^
10
CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARIES
Define Biu = g{x,u),
u G I/^'(0);
B2U = h{x,u),
ueLP^{n).
Then by Lemma 1.20, Bi is a bounded and continuous mapping from L^^^Q) to L^^ (^), ^ = 1, 2. It is readily seen that B := Bi-\-B2 is a bounded continuous mapping from H to S. D The fohowing theorem and its idea of proof are enough for us to see that the functionals encountered in this book are of C^. Theorem 1.22. Assume a > 0,p > 0. Let f{x,t) on ft xH satisfying
(1.10)
be a Caratheodory function
1/(^,01 < «IC + ^l^r. V(x,t) G O X R,
where a, 6 > 0 and ft is either bounded or unbounded. Define a functional I{u) := / F{x,u)dx,
where F{x,u) = /
JQ
f{x,s)ds.
JO
Assume {E, \\ • ||) is a Sobolev Banach space such that E ^^ L^^^iQ) E ^ L^+i(0). Then I G C^{E,Ii) and I'{u)h = I f{x,u)hdx,
and
\/h G E.
JQ
Moreover, if E ^^^^ L^^'^^E ^^^^ L^^^, then I' : E ^ E' is compact. Proof. Since E ^^ L^^^(Q) and E ^^ 1/^+^(0), we may find a constant Co > 0 such that (1.11)
||u;||<,+i
||u;||p+i
^weE.
We make use of Young's Inequahty and
(\s\ + \t\Y <2--\\s\- + \tY),
T>i,s,teR.
Combining the assumptions on / , for any 7 G [0,1], it is easy to check that \f{x,u^-ih)h\
< Ci(|^P+i + l/iP+i + l^l^+i + |/i|^+i),
where Ci is a constant independent of 7. Therefore, for any u^h G E^ by the Mean Value Theorem and Lebesgue's Theorem,
1.3. DIFFERENTIABLE
FUNCTIONALS
I{u + th) - I{u)
lim
lim / / (1.12)
11
f{x,u-\-Oth)hdx
f{x,u)hdx
: Fo{u,h),
where 0 G [0,1] depends on u, h, t. Obviously, Fo(i^, h) is linear in h. Further, by (1.11), \Fo{u,h)\ < I
\f{x,u)h\dx
a+ll
ll^ll^+lll/^ll.+l)
k+1
DI{v))h\
/ {f{x,u) Jn
I
f{x,v))hdx
{Bu — Bv)hdx
Jn {Biu -\- B2U — Biv — B2v)hdx
< / \Biu - Biv\\h\dx ^ / \B2U - B2v\\h\dx < Co\\B,U
- B,v\\^,^,yjh\\
+ Co\\B2U
-
This implies that (1.13)
\\DI{u) -
DI{V)\\E'
<
Co(||Sl^t-Bl^;||(,+l)/,. where || • \\E' is the norm in E\
\\B2U-B2v\\^p^iyp
B2v\\^p^,y4h\\.
12
CHAPTER 1. Uvk^uinEc
PRELIMINARIES
L^+i(0) n L^+i(0), then
Therefore, DI{vk) -^ DI{u). This means that DI{u) is continuous in u. Hence, r{u) = DI{u), i.e., / G C^(^,R). Furthermore, if E ^ ^ L^+\ E ^^^^ 1/^+^, then any bounded sequence {uk} in ^ has a renamed subsequence denoted by {uk} which converges to i^o in L^^^{Q) and in 1/^+^(0). Hence, 5 i K ) ^ BI{UQ) in L ( ^ + I ) / ^ ( 0 ) ; ^ S K ) ^ ^2(^0) in L ( ^ + I ) / ^ ( 0 ) . Finahy, DI{uk) -^ DI{uo) in ^^, i.e., r is compact in ^ . This proves the theorem. D A relation between pointwise convergence of functions and convergence of functionals can be found in H. Brezis-E. Lieb [67]. Sometimes, we wih use the concepts of the second order Frechet and Gateaux derivatives. Definition 1.23. The functional I G C^{U,Il) has a second order Frechet derivative at u e U if there is an L, which is a linear hounded operator from E to E', such that
r(u^h)-r(u)-Lh
^
We write I"{u) = L. We say that / G C^(t/, R) if the second order Frechet derivative of / exists and is continuous on U. Definition 1.24. The functional I G C^{U^Yi) has a second order Gateaux derivative at u ^U if there is an L, which is a linear hounded operator from, E to E', such that (r{u^th)-r{u)-Lth]v Um -^ t^o t We write D'^I{u) = L.
^— = 0,
V/i,
veE.
Evidently, any second order Frechet derivative of / is a second order Gateaux derivative. Using the Mean Value Theorem, if / has a continuous second order Gateaux derivative on [/, then / G C^(t/, R).
1.4. TOPOLOGICAL
1.4
DEGREES
13
Topological Degrees
Since topological degree is an eternal topic of every book on nonlinear functional analysis, we just outline the main ideas and results without proofs. Readers may consult the books of L. Nirenberg [263], K. Deimling [131] and E. Zeidler [379]. To construct the degree theory, Sard's Theorem plays a key role. For this, we introduce the following definition. Definition 1.25. Let U C X := R^ {N > 1) be an open subset and a mapping I G C^{U,X). A point u e U is called a regular point and I{u) is a regular value if I'{u) : X ^^ X is surjective. Otherwise, u is called a critical point and I{u) is the critical value. Here we state a simplified version of Sard's Theorem. It is from A. Sard [305]. Theorem 1.26. Let U C X := R ^ {N > 1) be an open subset and I G C^{U,X). Then the set of all critical values of I has zero Lebesgue measure in X. Definition 1.27. (Brouwer Degree) LetU C X '.= 11^ {N > 1) be a bounded open subset, I G C^{U,X), p e X\I{dU). (1) If p is a regular value of I, define the Brouwer Degree by deg(/, [/,p) :=
^
signdet/'(i;),
where det denotes the determinant. (2) If p is a critical value of I, choose pi to be a regular value (by Sard^s Theorem) such that \\p — Pi\\ < dist{p,I{dU)) and define the Brouwer Degree by degiI,U,p):=degiI,U,pi). In item (1), I~^{p) is a finite set when p is a regular value. In item (2), the degree is independent of the choice of pi. If / G C(f7,X), we may find by Weierstrass's Theorem an approximation of / via a smooth function. Definition 1.28. (Brouwer Degree) LetU C X := R ^ {N > 1) be a bounded Choose I G C^{Lf,X) such that open subset, I G C{U,X), p G X\I{dU). sup \\I{u) - I{u)\\ < ueu
dist{p,I{dU))
14
CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARIES
and define the Brouwer Degree by deg{I,U,p):=deg{i,U,p), which is independent of the choice of I. Proposition 1.29. Let U C X := R^ {N > 1) be a bounded open subset, IeC{U,X),peX\I{dU). (1)
(2) Let Ui, U2 be two disjoint open subsets ofU,p^
I{U\{Ui U U2)). Then
deg(/, U,p) = deg(/, Ui,p) + deg(/, U2,p). (3) LetH eC{[^,l] x f 7 , R ^ ) , P G C ( [ 0 , 1 ] , R ^ ) andp{t) ^H{t,dU). deg{H{t, •), U^p{t)) is independent of t e [0,1].
Then
(4) (Kronecker Theorem) //deg(/, U,p) ^ 0, then there exists a u ^ U such that I{u) = p. Theorem 1.30. (Borsuk-Ulam Theorem) Let U be an open bounded symmetric neighborhood ofO in R ^ . Every continuous odd map f : dU -^ R^"-*^ has a zero. As we know, in treating ODE or PDE, the working space is infinitedimensional. We have to prepare a degree for infinite-dimensional space. Here we introduce a degree for a compact perturbation of the identity. This is the Leray-Schauder degree. Definition 1.31. Let E be a Banach space, M C E. A mapping I : M ^ E is called compact if I{S) is compact for any bounded subset S of M. Further, if I is continuous, we say that I is completely continuous. In this case, id — I is called a completely continuous field. Theorem 1.32. Let E be a Banach space, and let M C E be a bounded closed subset. Let I : M ^ E be a continuous mapping. Then I is completely continuous if and only if, for any £ > 0, there exists a finite-dimensional subspace E^ of E and a bounded continuous mapping I^ : M ^ E^ such that s u p ||/(l^) -In{u)\\ uEM
< S.
1.4. TOPOLOGICAL DEGREES
15
Let ^ be a Banach space, and let U C E he di bounded open subset. Let I : U :^ E he completely continuous and f = id — I. If p e E\f{dU), then by Theorem L32, there exists a finite-dimensional subspace E^ of E and a bounded continuous mapping 1^:1)^ E^ such that sup||/(^)-/^H||
En\fn{dUn).
Definition 1.33. (Leray-Schauder Degree) Let f be the completely continuous field defined as above. Define the Leray-Schauder degree of f at p e E\f{dU) by ^^g{f^U,p) = deg{ fn,Un,p), which is independent of the choice of En^p^I^. Proposition 1.34. Let U C E be a bounded open subset of the Banach space E, f = id — I a completely continuous field, and p G E\f{dU). Then (1)
deg{id,U,p) = ^
J^
P'
(2) Let [/i, U2 be two disjoint open subsets ofU,p^
f{U\{Ui U U2)), then
deg(/, U,p) = deg(/, Uup) + deg(/, U2,p). (3) Let H G C([0,1] X U,E) be completely continuous, p G C([0,1],^) and p{t) i H{t, dU) for each t G [0,1]. Then deg{H{t, •), U,p{t)) is independent oft G [0,1]. (4) (Kronecker Theorem) / / d e g ( / , U,p) ^ 0, then there exists a u ^ U such that f{u) = p. Theorem 1.35. (Borsuk-Ulam Theorem) Let U be an open bounded symmetric neighborhood of 0 in a Banach space E. A completely continuous field f = id — I : U ^ E, where I is odd on dU, p G E\f{dU), then deg(/, U^p) is an odd number. We also refer the readers to N. G. Lloyd [238], L. Nirenberg [264], M. Nagumo [260, 261], D. Guo [177] and C. Zhong-X. Fan-W. Chen [383] for the details of degree theory.
16
CHAPTER 1.
1.5
PRELIMINARIES
An ODE in Banach Space
Let ^ be a Banach space with a norm || • ||. Consider the following Cauchy initial value problem of the ordinary differential equation d(^
-r ^ /
/
NX
(1.14) cr{0,uo) =uo e E, where V is a potential function. We are interested in the existence of solutions to (1.14), which will play an important role in the following chapters. We assume: (V) y : ^ ^ ^ is a locally Lipschitz continuous mapping, i.e., for any u ^ E, there exists a ball B{u,r) := {w ^ W : \\w — u\\ < r} with radius r and a constant p > 0 depending on r and u such that \\V{wi) -V{w2)\\
< p\\wi -W2\\,
y wi,W2 e
B{u,r).
Moreover,
||y(^)|| < a + 6||^||,
yueE,
where a, 6 > 0 are constants. T h e o r e m 1.36. Assume {V). Then for any u ^ E, the Cauchy problem, (1.14) has a unique solution o-{t,u) defined on the interval [0,+00) of t. Moreover, o-{t,u) depends continuously on the initial data u. Hence, a eC\[0,^oo) X E,E). To prove Theorem 1.36, we prepare two auxiliary results. L e m m a 1.37. (Gronwah Inequality) If X > 0, (3 > 0 and f e C([0,r],R+) satisfies
(1.15)
/ ( t ) < A + /3 / f{s)ds,
VtG[0,r],
Jo
then f{t) < Xe^^ for all t G [0,r]. Proof. By (1.15), we observe that
dt
(e~^' / f{s)ds) V
JQ
< Xe-
Integrating both sides on [0,t], we get the conclusion.
D
1.5. AN ODE IN BANACH SPACE
17
Lemma 1.38. (Banach Fixed Point Theorem) Let E be a Banach space, with D C E dosed. Let F : D ^ D satisfy (1.16)
||Fi^ - Fv\\ < k\\u - v\\
for some k G (0,1) and all u,v e D.
Then there exists a unique u^ such that Fu^ = u^. Proof. Choose UQ e D and let i^n+i = Fun. have ll'^^n+m+l - Un\\ < (1 - ky^k'^Wui
Using (1.16) repeatedly, we
- Uo\\ ^
0,
U^
+00.
Therefore, {un} is a Cauchy sequence. The conclusion follows from the continuity of F . n Proof of Theorem 1.36. For any fixed i^o ^ E^ by condition (V), we find a ball B{uo,r) := {w e W : \\w — uo\\ < r} with radius r and a constant p > 0 depending on r and i^o such that \\V{wi) -V{w2)\\
< p\\wi -W2\\,
y wi,W2 e
B{uo,r).
Let A:=
sup
||y||.
B(uo,r)
Then A < +00. Choose £ > 0 such that sp < l^sA < r. Consider the Banach space E := C([0,£],F) := {u : [0,^] ^ F is a continuous function} with the norm ||i^||^ := max^^[o,£] ||'?^(OII for each u e E. Let D := {u e E : \\u — uo\\^ < r}. Define a mapping F : E ^ E hj Fu := 1^0 + / V{u{s))ds, Jo
u e E.
For any u,w ^ D we have \\Fu-uoh<
I Jo
\\V{u{s))\\^ds
and | F ^ - F ^ | | ^ < max /
\\V{u) - V{w)\\^ds < ps\\u - w\\^.
Therefore, F : D ^ D satisfies all conditions of Lemma 1.38. Hence, F has a unique fixed point u^ ^ D, which is a solution of Cauchy problem (1.14).
18
CHAPTER
1.
PRELIMINARIES
On t h e other hand, assume t h a t u{t) and v{t) are solutions of t h e Cauchy problem (1.14) corresponding t o initial d a t a i^o and VQ, respectively. Then
Mt)-v{t)u <\\UO-VO\\E+
I
\\V{u{s))-V{v{s))\\^ds
Jo
\\u{s)-v{s)\\^ds. Jo
By Lemma 1.37, \\uit)-vit)\\^<\\uo-vohe^K This proves t h e continuous dependence on t h e initial d a t a of solution of (1.14). Summing up, (1.14) has a unique solution u{t) on t h e maximal existence interval [0, K.) which is continuously depending on t h e initial data. Next, we just show t h a t n = + o o . Assume t h a t n < + o o . Then u{t) = UQ -\-
V{u{s))ds. Jo
Thus, by ( y ) , ||^(t)|| < WuoW^an^b
[ \\u{s)\\ds. Jo L e m m a 1.37 implies t h a t there is a constant Ci depending on u^^n^a such t h a t \\u{t)\\
and h
It follows t h a t \Ht)-u{s)\\
(1.17) cr(0,l^l) =Ui e E. Similarly, it has a unique solution u{t) on a maximal interval [0,/^i) with initial d a t a ui = u{n — 0). Let
r v{t) = I
u{t),
tG[o,/^),
Then v{t) is also a solution of (1.14) with t h e initial d a t a i^o on t h e maximal interval [0, n -\- ni). This produces a contradiction. D
1.6. THE (PS) CONDITIONS
1.6
19
The (PS) Conditions
Many nonlinear problems can be reduced to the form (1.18)
/'(^)=0,
where / is a C^ functional on a Banach space. Equation (1.18) is called the Euler-Lagrange equation of the functional / . The original idea was to find maxima and minima of / , and the critical point theory was devoted to finding extrema of / . The simplest extrema to find are global maxima and minima if / is semibounded. However, we can derive from the semiboundedness the existence of a sequence {un} C E such that
We now introduce definitions of compactness conditions. Definition 1.39. Any sequence {u^} satisfying (1.19)
sup|/(^^)| < o o ,
l\ur,)^0,
n
is called a Palais-Smale sequence ((PS)-sequence, for short). If any (PS)sequence of I possesses a convergent subsequence, we say that I satisfies the (PS) condition. The original idea of the (PS) condition was introduced by R. Palais [269], S. Smale [343] and R. Palais-S. Smale [272]. One of the weak versions of the (PS) condition was proposed in G. Cerami [86]. Definition 1.40. Any sequence {un} satisfying (1.20)
s u p | / ( ^ ^ ) | < OO, n
(1 + | | ^ n | | ) / ' ( ^ n ) ^
0,
is called a Cerami sequence ((C)-sequence, for short). If any (C)-sequence of I possesses a convergent subsequence, we say that I satisfies the (C) condition. Theorem 1.41. Let E be a Banach space, I G C^(^,R). Assume I'{u) =Lu^J'{u),
ue
E,
where L : E ^^ E' is a bounded linear invertible operator and J' maps bounded sets to relatively compact sets in E'. Then any bounded (PS)-sequence or (C)sequence is relatively compact.
20
CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARIES
Proof. Let {un} be a bounded (PS)-sequence or (C)-sequence, then I'{un) -^ 0. The conclusion fohows from the relative compactness of J' and Un = L-^r{Un)-L-^J'{Un). • It is well known, for a given functional / , there may exist critical points of / which are not even local extrema. The existence of this class of critical points was first studied by A. Ambrosotti and P. H. Rabinowitz [19], where a set of sufficient conditions was provided. We also refer the readers to M. Struwe [352]. This abstract critical point theory was based on the (PS) condition. In this book, we will establish a series of theorems without any (PS) type assumption.
1.7
Weak Solutions
In practice, one of the main research projects using critical point theory is the existence of solutions to elliptic equations. For example, consider (1.21)
-/\u
= f{x,u),
xen.
The corresponding functional is defined by I{u) = ^\\\/uf-
J
F{x,u)dx,
where F{x,u)
= / f{x,s)ds. Roughly speaking, if / is in C^ on a suitable Jo space and I\u) = 0 (a critical point), then (1.22)
/ Vu'VwdxJQ
/ f{x,u)wdx
= 0,
\/w e E.
JQ
The critical point u satisfying (1.22) is called a weak solution of (1.21) and obviously u is not necessarily a classical solution. In general, more assumptions on the smoothness of dfl and of / are needed if we want the weak solution to be a classical solution. It is not an easy task. In this section, we just give a simple example to show how the regularity theory of elliptic equations can be applied to obtain a classical solution from a weak solution. Definition 1.42. Consider a bounded domain ft C R ^ with boundary dft. Let k be a nonnegative integer and o^ G [0,1]. O is of class C^'^ if at each point xo G dft there is a ball B = B{XQ) and a one-to-one mapping Lp from B onto a subset D C R ^ such that
1.7. WEAK SOLUTIONS
21
(1) cp{B n O) C R ^ := {x = (xi, X2,..., XN) eK^ :XN > 0}; (2) ip{B n dn) C dK^ := {x = (xi, X2,..., XN) eK^ :XN = 0};
The following proposition is due to M. D. Gilbarg-N. S. Trudinger [174, Theorems 6.6] (see also M. Struwe [352]). Proposition 1.43. Suppose that u G Hi^^{ft) such that —Au = f in ft with f G I/^(^), 1 < p < 00. Then for any O^ CC ft, we have \\U\\H^^P{Q^) < C{\\U\\LP^Q^ + | | / | | L P ( Q ) ) ,
where C depends on ft,ft\N,p. Assume in addition that ft is a C^'^ domain and that there exists a function uo G H'^'^{ft) such that u — uo ^ HQ'-^{ft). Then \\U\\H^^P{Q)
< C{\\U\\LP(Q)
+ ||/||LP(Q) +
||^0||if2,p(Q)),
where C depends on ft^N^p. The following proposition is found in M. D. Gilbarg-N.S. Trudinger [174, Theorems 6.14 and 6.19]. Proposition 1.44. Assume that ft is a Qk+2,a domain, f G C^'^(O). Then the Dirichlet problem —Au = f
in ft,
u=0
in dft
has a unique classical solution u G C^+^'^(0). The following proposition is also in M. D. Gilbarg-N.S. Trudinger [174, Theorem 9.15]. Proposition 1.45. Assume that ft is a C^'^ domain, f G L^{ft),p > 1. Then the Dirichlet problem —Au = f
in ft,
u=0
in dft
has a unique classical solution u G I^o^'^l^) H W'^^P{n). The following result is due to H. Brezis-T. Kato [66] (see also M. Struwe [352]).
22
CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARIES
L e m m a 1.46. Assume that ft is a domain of R ^ (N > 3) and that f : ft xH ^H is a Caratheodory function such that \f{x,t)\ where a G LfJ^\n).
< a{x){l + |i^|),
If u e HHifl)
a.e. x e Q,
is a weak solution of
—Au = f{x^u)
in O,
then u G L^^^(Q) for any q < oo. If u ^ HQ' (ft) and a G 1/^/^(0), then u G L^{Q) for any q < oo. Next, we give an example to illustrate when a weak solution becomes a classical solution. As we mentioned, it is not a matter of course. Theorem 1.47. Assume that Q is a bounded domain ofH^ {N > 2), Q is is a Caratheodory function such that (1) there exists a r G (0,1] such that f{x,t)
for any
GC^''^(OX [ - M , M ] , R ) ,
M
>0;
(2) there are C > 0 and 2 < p < 2* such that \f{x,t)\
< C ( 1 + |^|^-^),
(3) there exists a function fo{x) G L^{ft) lim
^— = fo{x)
a.e.xeQ;
such that uniformly for x G O.
Assume u G H^' (Q) is a weak solution of (1.23)
-/\u
= f{x,u)
inn,
u=0
on dn.
Then u must he a classical solution of (1.23). In particular, u G C^+^'^(0), where (3 = ar^~^^. Proof. Let
f{x,t) g{x,t)
t /o(x),
'
if t ^ 0, ift = 0.
1.7. WEAK SOLUTIONS
23
Then there are constants a > 0, 6 > 0 such that (1.24)
\g{x,t)\ < fo{x) + a + b\tf-^ < /o(x) + a + b\tf-^
for ah X G 0 , t G R. By assumption, u G HQ' ( O ) is a weak solution of (1.25)
—Au = g{x,u{x))u
in O,
i^ = 0
on dfl.
If N > 3, by Proposition 1.12, u G L'^*{n). By Lemma 1.20 and (1.24), g{x,u{x)) G 1/^/^(0). Then, Lemma 1.46 implies that u G 1/^(0) for ah 5 > 2. This is naturally true if A^ < 2. Noting the conditions (2)-(3) and using Lemma 1.20 again, we see that f{x,u{x))
GL^(O),
V5>2.
Choose 5 > 2 , 5 > p — 1 . By Proposition 1.45, the problem (1.26)
—Aw = f{x,u{x))
in O,
w=0
on dft
has a unique solution
w G w^'^n) n iy2'^(o), v^ =
^ > i, 5 > 2.
Since u is a weak solution of (1.23), we see from (1.26), that u = w.Uwe choose q = j ^ , then q > 2/{p - 1) if N > 2. By Proposition 1.12, u G I^o'^(^) implies that u G C^'^(O); here 1 — N/q = o^. Then we may find a M > 0 such that |^(x)|<M,
\u{x)-u{y)\
VXGO,
<M|x-7/|^,
x.yen.
Note that O is of class C^+^.Q^ with a G (0,1). Thus / satisfies condition (1) with k replaced by 0,1, 2 , . . . , A: - 1 (see M. D. Gilbarg-N. S. Trudinger [174, Lemma 6.35] and W. Lu [245, Theorem 7.5.4]). Hence, there exists a C > 0 such that + \u-vn \f(x,u)-fiy,v)\
Therefore,
\fix,uix)) - f{y,v{y))\ + \u{x)-v{y)n
24
CHAPTER 1.
PRELIMINARIES
in C^'^^(O). By induction, if we assume that u e C*=+i'"'' (f2), we may prove that f{x,u{x)) G C^'^^ (O) and u = w. By Proposition 1.44 once again, we have that u G C^+2'«^ ^ (O). This proves the theorem. D
We refer the readers to M. D. Gilbarg-N.S. Trudinger [174], L. C. Evans [147], M. Struwe [352] and M. E. Taylor [366] for the regularity theory of elliptic equations. We focus on critical point theory in the present volume.
Chapter 2
Functionals Bounded Below If a functional has the same infimum on two bahs Br C BR, we estabhsh the existence result of a bounded (PS)-sequence. On the other hand, we give a new proof for classical results on functionals bounded below.
2.1
Pseudo-Gradients
The existence of a pseudo-gradient vector field is a foundation stone for some variational problems. Lemma 2.1. Let P be a continuous mapping from a Banach space E to its dual E', and let E := {u e E : P{u) ^ 0}. For any a G (0,1), there exists a locally Lipschitz continuous mapping (i.e., pseudo-gradient vector field) V : E ^ E such that \\V{w)\\ < 1,
a\\P{w)\\ < {P{w),V{w)),
\/weE.
Proof. Take ai G {a, 1). For any u e E, there exists an element (j) = (j){u) G E such that mu)\\
= 1,
ai||P(u)|| < {P{u),cf>{u)),ue
E.
The continuity of P{u) implies that there exists an open neighborhood U{u) of u such that a\\P{w)\\ < {P{w),(l){u)), w e U{u). Then we get an open covering {U{u)} oi E. By Proposition 1.3, there is a locally finite refinement {Vi\i^j and a locally Lipschitz continuous partition
26
CHAPTER 2. FUNCTIONALS
BOUNDED
BELOW
of unity {Xi}iej subordinate to this refinement. For each i e J, Vi C U{ui) for some ui. Define
Then V : E ^ E is locahy Lipschitz continuous. By Proposition 1.3,
\\V{w)\\
Moreover, {Piw),Viw))>aJ2Mw)\\Piw)\\=a\\Piw)\\. ieJ
D Notes and Comments. Many books and papers have addressed the existence of the pseudo-gradient vector field which was apphed directly to prove miscellaneous deformation theorems. For examples, see P. Bartolo-V. BenciD. Fortunato [28], V. Benci-P. H. Rabinowitz [55], K. C. Chang [95, 96] (on a Finsler manifold), Y. Du [143], M. R. Grossinho-S. A. Tersian [176], J. Mawhin-M. Willem [252], L. Nirenberg [265], P. Rabinowitz [293], M. RamosC. Rebelo [298], M. Schechter [310], M. Struwe [352] and M. Willem [376, 377].
2.2
Bounded Minimizing Sequences
Let {E, II • II) be a Banach space and / G C^(^,R). Theorem 2.2. Assume that there exist R > r > 0 such that m := inf / = inf / > —oo, BR
B,
where BR := {U ^ E : \\U\\ < R}. Then there exists {un} C BR such that I{un) -^ m,
I'{un) ^ 0
as n ^ oo.
Proof. Let D{R,e) = {u e BR : I(u) < m + e}. Then
inf
||/'(^)|| = 0
for all £ > 0. Otherwise, there would exist an SQ > 0 such that ||/^(i^)|| > £o/{R-r) wheni^ G D{R, SQ). Let u G D(r,£o/2)(^ 0). By Lemma 2.1, there is a V{u) : E :={ue E : r{u) ^ 0} ^ ^ such that 11^(^)11 < 1 ,
{V{u)J'{u))>\\\I'{u)l
yueE.
2.2. BOUNDED MINIMIZING SEQUENCES
27
Moreover, y is a locally Lipschitz continuous map. Let a{t,u) be the solution of the Cauchy initial value problem
a{0,u) =ue
D{r, So/2).
Then ||cr(t,i^)-1^11 < / \\a\s,u)\\ds
=
Therefore,
-{l'{a),V{a))
<-^\\I'(a{t,um ,
3
for u G D(r, £o/2), and therefore, a{t,u) G D{R, SQ) for t e [0, i? — r] and u e D{r, £o/2). Furthermore, 3 1 3 1 l(cr{R - r, u)) < I{u) - -£o < m + -£o - jSo = m - -£o, a contradiction.
D
Consider a family of C^{E, R)-functionals of the form Ix{u) := -\H{u)
- J{u),
XeA.ueE,
where A C (0, oo) is an open interval; H{u) > 0 for all u e E. Assume that one of the following conditions holds. (A) For any /3 > 0,
sup {H'ull :ue
E with H{u) < (3} < +oo.
(B) For any /3 > 0,
sup {H'ull :ue
E with J{u) < (3} < +oo.
Theorem 2.3. Assume that either (A) or (B) holds and that Ix is bounded below for each A G A. Then for each X e A, there exists a sequence {un} such that s u p ||l^n|| < oo,
Ix{Un)
^
Mx
'•= i n f / A ,
Ixi^n)
^ 0 ,
aS Tl ^
OO.
28
CHAPTER 2. FUNCTIONALS
BOUNDED
BELOW
Proof. We only prove the first case. Note that the mapping X ^ Mx is concave with respect to A G A. Therefore, it is Lipschitz continuous on each closed subinterval of A. For A G A, we choose a closed subinterval AA C A containing A as an interior point. Then, there exists a constant Ai^ > 0 depending on A such that
\Mx-My\<M'^\X-X'\, Choose A„ e (A, 2A) n
AA,A„
VA'eA^.
-^ A as n ^
Then l - ^ - - - ^ - ' <
oo.
An — A A^A f^^ ^11 ^- We claim that there exists a sequence {u^} C E such that ll'^nll < ^o(A) := ko and Mx < Ix{un) < hA^n) < Mx^ + (A, - A) < A^A + {M'x + l){Xn - A). In fact, by the definition of AIA^, there exists a Un such that Ix^{un) Mx^ + (An - A). Evidently, Mx < h{un) < h^i^n) and Hiu^)
= 2 ( ^ A . . K ) - ^ A K ) ) < 2M',
<
+ 4;
An — A J{un) =
^^"^-^
7—^—- < -Mx
+ Mx + 1.
An — A
Therefore, by (A), there exists a /CQ = ko{X) > 0 such that ||i^n|| < ^o- Define I^,(A) :={ueE:
\\u\\
Ix{u) < Mx ^ £}•
Then, for any £ > 0, there exists an n large enough such that Un G ^^^(A). Now we claim that inf{||/A(i^)|| : u G ^^^(A)} = 0 for ah e > 0. If not, there exists an £o > 0 such that ||/^(i^)|| > SQ for u G Ds^{X). By Lemma 2.1, there is a locally Lipschitz continuous map VA • ^ •= {'^ ^ ^ • ^A('^) T^ ^} ^ ^ ^^^^ that \\Vx{u)\\ < 1 and {rAu),Vx{u)) > ^ | | / ; H | | for ah u e E. Therefore, for any u G
DSQ{X),
we have that
A:={u:
||VA('^)||
^ - and (/^(i^), VA('^)) ^ ^^o- Define
\\u\\ >ko^2}U{u:
5 := {^ : ll^ll < A:o + 1,
Ix{u) > At A + ^o/3}, A^A < h{u) <Mx^
£o/4}.
Then, An B = 9. Moreover, if u ^ A then i^ G l^£o(A)- In particular, 5 C D^^X). Define ^(^) := dist(^,A) ^^ ^ dist(^,5) + dist(^,A)'
^^ ^
_ e(^)yAH. '^v ; Av ;
2.2.
BOUNDED
MINIMIZING
SEQUENCES
29
Then it is easy t o check t h a t (/^(i^), ^ A * ( ^ ) ) ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ||y^*|| < 1 for ah u e E. F u r t h e r m o r e , for u e B C DSQ{X),
C{^) = 1 ^^^
{I',{U),V^{U))=^{U){I'^{U),VX{U))
II^A('^)II — ^o, we have
> 1\\I',{U)\\ > ^£0.
dfi (t u) Now we consider t h e initial value problem — - ^ — = —Vx{r]) with ?^(0, u) = u for each u ^ E (note t h a t ^ vanishes on an open set containing t h e points where / ^ = 0)- It is well known t h a t there exists a unique solution r]{t,u) for t >0. Moreover, Mx
< Ix{v{t.un))
< lx{r]{0,un))
< IxA^n)
< Mx^ + (A - A,) < A^A + ^
for n large enough. Consequently, = \\ [ dr]{s,Un)\\< Jo
\\r]{t,un)-uj
[ Jo
\\V^{r]{s,Unmds
It follows t h a t \\r]{t,Un)\\ < ||t^n||+^ < A:o + l f o r t < 1. Therefore, r]{t,Un) G B for ah t e [0,1]. Moreover, /A(^(l,^n)) '^
-h{Un)
dIx{r]{s,Un))_^^
0
ds [I'xivis^
Un))^ Vxivis,
Un))j ds
10
1
It follows t h a t Mx
<
Ix{r](l,un))
<
h{Un) - -So
<
AiA + (A^l + 2 ) ( A ^ - A ) - i £ o
<
Mx-
-£o-
This is a contradiction. Thus, we know t h a t there exists a sequence such t h a t sup ||i^n(A)|| < oo,
/A(^^n(A)) ^ A^A,
Ix{unW)
{un{X)}
^ 0 as n ^ oo.
30
CHAPTER 2. FUNCTIONALS
BOUNDED
BELOW
If H^ is invertible and J^ is compact, by standard arguments, there exists a ux such that Ix{ux) = Mx and /^(I^A) = 0D We therefore have Theorem 2.4. Assume that Ix is bounded below for each A G A and that any bounded (PS)-sequence oof Ix is precompact. Then for each A G A, Mx = inf/A E
is a critical value of Ix.
Theorem 2.3 can be easily generahzed to a manifold (see R. Palais [269, 270, 271] for the definition of a Finsler manifold). Let M be a complete Finsler manifold with Finsler structure || • || and / G C^(M, R). Let dl{u) denote the differential of / at u. Define \\dI{u)\\M := sup{|a/(^)(/)| : (/) G T^{M), UW < 1}, where Tu{M) denotes the tangent space of M at u. Let T{M) = UueMTu{M) and M = {u ^ M : | | ^ / ( I ^ ) | | M T^ 0}. Then we have the following theorem. Theorem 2.5. Let M ^ 9 be a complete Finsler manifold with Finsler structure II • II and let Ix G C^(M, R) be bounded below for all A > 0. Assume that either (A) or (B) holds with E replaced by M. Then for each A G A, there exists a Palais-Smale sequence {un} C M such that SUpll'Unll < OO, Ix{Un)
^
MX'=^^fI\,
||^^A('?^n) | | M ^
0
aS U ^ OO.
Proof. For any 0 G (0,1), there exists a mapping Y{u) : M -^ T{S) which is locally Lipschitz continuous and satisfies \\Y{u)\\ < 1,
e\\dIx{u)\\M < {dh{u),Y{u)),
ueM.
This is a generalization of Lemma 2.1 (see also K. C. Chang [96, Lemma 3.1]). In fact, choose 0 < 0' < 1. For u G M, there exists an h{u) G Tu{M) such that
\\h{u)\\ = 1, e'\\dix{u)\\M < {dh{u),h{u)). By the continuity of dlx{u), for each u G M, there is a neighborhood N{u) such that 6'||a/A(^)||M < {dlx{v),h{u)) for v G N{u). Then {N{u) : u e M} is an open covering of M. Since M is a metric space, we may find a locally finite refinement {iV^-}. Let {V^r} be a locally Lipschitz continuous partition of unity subordinate to this refinement. For each r, let u^- be an element for
2.3. AN APPLICATION
31
which Nr C N{ur). Let Y{v) = '^iljr{v)h{ur). Then Y{v) is what we want. Similar to the proof of Theorem 2.3, we can prove that ini{\\dh{u)\\M
: \\u\\
h{u) <Mx+s}
=0
for ah £ > 0 smah enough. It is sufficient to know that the flow r]{t, u) stifl exists on the manifold. D Notes and Comments. By I. Ekeland's variational principle (cf. [145]), if / is bounded from below, then there exists a minimizing sequence {un} for / such that I{un) -^ inf/, I'{un) ^ 0 as n ^ oo. E
It is worth noting that if / satisfles the (PS) condition and maps bounded sets into bounded sets, then inf/ > —oo
<^
I{u) -^ +00
as ||i^|| -^ +oo,
E
that is, / is coercive. This was proved in L. Caklovic-S. Li-W. Willem [77] using gradient flow (see also S. Li [211] and M. Willem [377]) and in D. G. Costa-E. A. B. Silva [114] by Ekeland's variational principle. Other properties for functionals bounded below (combining other assumptions) can be seen in H. Brezis-L. Nirenberg [70] (with local linking and without symmetry), in D. C. Clark [102] and in S. Li-Z. Q. Wang [217] (with locations of the critical points) for even functionals bounded below. Theorems 2.2-2.5 were obtained in M. Schechter-W. Zou [326].
2.3
An Application
We just give a simple example. We study the following elliptic eigenvalue problem: (P/3)
—Au = (3g{x,u)
in O;
i^ = 0
on ^O,
where O is a bounded smooth domain in R ^ and g{x, t) is a Caratheodory function such that ^(x,0) G 1/^(0). Let 0 < Ai < A2 < • • • < A^ < • • • be the sequence of eigenvalues of —A with Dirichlet zero boundary condition. Assume that there exists a constant a such that ^^^
^^ ^ g{x,t)-g{x,s)
^ ^ ^ ^^^^
^^^ ^^^ ^ ^ ^ ^^^ ^ ^ ^^
32
CHAPTER 2. FUNCTIONALS
BOUNDED
BELOW
Theorem 2.6. Assume that (C) holds. Then for each (3 G (1, - ^ ) ; problem (PIS) has a solution Uf^. That is, the eigenvalue problem (P/3) has infinitely many solutions. However, we would like to show it by using Theorem 2.4. We need the following lemma. Lemma 2.7. Let Ei fz = 1, 2) be two closed subspaces of a real Hilbert space E with an inner product (•, •) and the corresponding norm \\ • \\ such that E = El® E2. Let I G C^(^,R). / / there exists an increasing function h : R+ -^ R+ such that h{s) -^ +00 as s ^ +00 and that (2.1)
{I\u^v)-I\u^w),v-w)
> \\v - w\\h{\\v - w\\)
for all u G Ei^v^w G ^2, then we have the following results. (1) There exists a continuous function (j) : Ei ^ E2 such that I{u -\- (j){u)) = min I{u + v). veE2
Moreover, (j){u) is the unique member of E2 such that {I'{u^(j){u)),v)
=0,
\JveE2.
(2) The functional J : Ei ^ H defined by J{u) = I{u-\- (j){u)) is of class C^ and {J\u),v) = {I\u^d^{u)),v), yu.veEi. (3) An element u e Ei is a critical point of J if and only if u -\- (j){u) is a critical point of L Proof. (1) For each u G ^ 1 , define H^ : E2 ^ K by Hu{v) = I{u + v). By the assumption (2.1), Hu is of C^ and has at most one critical point. We claim that Hu is coercive. Note that Hu{v) = Hu{0)^
[ Jo
{Hu{sv),v)ds
>H^{0)-\\H:,m\\v\\+
f\\\v\M\sv\\)ds. Jo
By the hypotheses on /i, we may choose R large enough such that h{\\sv\\) > 8||i:f;(0)|| uniformly for \\v\\ >R,se
[1/2,1].
2.3. AN APPLICATION
33
Hence, Hu{v)>Hu{0)^\\vl which imphes that Hu{v) ^ oo as H^;!! ^ oo. Next, we show that Hu is convex. For given v^w G ^ 2 , define C{s) =
Hu{v^s{w-v)).
For 0 < a < f3 < 1, by (2.1), it is easy to show that
r(/3)-e'(«)>0. This means that ^ is convex in 5, and consequently, H^ is convex in v. Combining the above arguments, we see that Hu has a unique minimizer (l){u) G E2 with Hu{(j){u)) = min{/(i^ -^ v) : v ^ E2]. Therefore, we have (2.2)
{I'{u^(l){u)),w)={),
\IweE2.
To show that (j){u) is continuous in u^ we assume on the contrary, that there are £0 > 0 and Uk ^ u SiS k ^ 00 such that \\(l){uk) -(/>(^)|| >£o. Let P be the projection from E to ^2- By (2.2), we see that \\Pr{uk (/>('^))|| ^ h{£o/2) if A: large enough. Therefore, h{eo)muk)
- c^{u)\\
< {I\uk + (/)(^fe)) - I\uk + (/)(^)), (/)(^fe) - 0(^))
< (-r(^fe + H^)), (i){uk) - (i){u)) <\\PI'{uk^cj,{u))\\U{uk)-cj,{u)\\
{J'{u),w) = {I'(u^(t){u)),w),
w G El.
Indeed, for 5 > 0, J{u + sw) — J{u) s I{u -\- sw -\- (j){u -\- sw)) — J{u -\- (j){u)) s I{U + 51(7 + (l){u)) - J{U + (l){u)) < s (2.4)
= /
{r{u^(l){u)^rsw),w)dr.
+
34
CHAPTER 2. FUNCTIONALS
BOUNDED
BELOW
Similarly, we have /^ ^N
J (U -\- SW)
(2.5)
^
f^
— J (U)
^
,-rf,
^
,/
N
N X ,
{r{u^(t){u^sw)^TSw),w)dT.
^
Jo
Summing up (2.4)-(2.5), we get (2.3).
D
Let E := HQ{Q) be with the usual norm induced by the inner product {u, v) =
\/u ' \jvdx. We denote by E{\i) the eigenspace corresponding to Jn Xi. Set E- = E{Xi)QE{X2)Q- • -©^(Afe-i), E^ = E{Xk) and E^ = ^(A^+i)© ^(Afe+2) © • • • . Then ^ = ^ - © ^^ © ^ + . Solutions of (Pp) correspond to the critical points of the C^-functional h{u) = ^\\ufwhere A = —, G{x,u) = /
J
G{x,u)d:\x,
\/ u e E,
g{x,s)ds.
Proof of Theorem 2.6. Choose A = ( v ^ , !)• Then for A G A and u G E^ ®E-,w,v
e ^ + , by (C), we have that (Ixiu^v)
- Ix(u^w),v
-w)
= X\\v — w\\^ — I (g{x,u-\-v)—g{x,u-\-w)]{v
— w)dx
J S2
> X\\v — w\\'^ — / a{v — w)'^dx JQ
>{X-T^)\\v-Wf. By Lemma 2.7, there exists a mapping 6x : E^ ^ E- ^ E+ such that Ix{u^ ^u-^(t)x{u^ Moreover, (t)\{u^ ^u~)
^u-))=
min /A(^^ + ^ " + ^ ^ ) .
is the unique member of E^ such that
for ah V e E^. Define a functional JA : ^^ © ^ ~ ^ R by Jxiu"" + U-) = Ixiu"" + ^ - + (/)A(^^ + u-)).
2.3. AN APPLICATION
35
Then J is of class C^ and
for all u^ -\-u~,z e E^ ^E~. Moreover, u^ -^u~ is a critical point of J if and only if u^ ^ u~ ^ (l)\{u^ -^ u~) is a critical point of I\. Next, we claim that —I\ is bounded below on E~ ® E^. In fact, by condition (C) we see that Afe^^ < t{g{x,t) - ^ ( x , 0 ) ) < at^. Then G{x,t)=
/ 5^(x,5)—>-Afet2 + t^(x,0). Jo
5
^
Therefore, Ix{u) < \{\ - l)\\uf 2
- I ug{x,0)dx ^ - o o Jn
as 111^11 -^ oo. Hence, —Ix and —Jx are bounded below. Evidently, —Jx satisfies the other assumptions of Theorem 2.3. Therefore, for all A G A, there exists a ux such that —J^^{ux) = 0. This completes the proof of the theorem. D Notes and Comments. Lemma 2.7 was established in A. Castro [81]. Some applications of it can be found in A. Castro-J. Cossio [82] and M. Schechter [315]. Theorem 2.6 was given in M. Schechter-W. Zou [326]. Possibly, it can be proved by other methods such as the degree theory or the contraction mapping principle. We believe that Theorem 2.4 has far more extended applications. We would like to leave them to the readers.
Chapter 3
Even Functionals In this chapter we present some abstract theorems which concern the existence of infinitely many critical points for even functionals. The Palais-Smale type compactness condition is not necessary for the new results. By taking advantage of the abstract theorems, we study the existence of infinitely many large energy solutions for nonlinear Schrodinger equations and of infinitely many small energy solutions for semilinear elliptic equations with concave and convex nonlinear it ies.
3.1
Abstract Theorems
Let ^ be a Banach space with the norm || • || and let {Xj} be a sequence of subspaces of E with dimX^ < oo for each j G N. Further, E = ^j^-^Xj, the closure of the direct sum of all Xj. Set
and Bk := {ueWk:
\\u\\ < pk},
Sk := {ue Zk'. \\u\\ = r/e}, for Pk > Tk > 0. Consider a family of C^-functionals ^\ : E ^Yi $A(W) := J(w) - AJ(w),
oi the form:
Ae[l,2].
We make the following assumptions. (Ai) ^\ maps bounded sets into bounded sets uniformly for A G [1,2]. Moreover, ^ A ( - ' ^ ) = ^A('^) for all (A,i^) G [1,2] x E.
38
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
(A2) J{u) > 0 for all u e E; I{u) ^ 00 or J{u) ^ 00 as ||i^|| -^ 00, or (A3) J{u) < 0 for all u e E; J{u) -^ —00 as ||i^|| -^ 00. Let afe(A) :=
max
^x(u),
bk{X) :=
ueWk,\\u\\=Pk
inf
^x{u).
ueZk,\\u\\=rk
Define Cfc(A) := inf max ^x{j{u)),
where
jeTkueBk
Tk := {7 e C{Bk,E) : 7 is odd,7|a5, = id],
k>2.
Theorem 3.1. Assume that (Ai) and either (A2) or (As) hold. If bk{X) > a/c(A) for all A G [1,2], then Ck{X) > bk{X) for all X G [1,2]. Moreover, for almost every X G [1,2], there exists a sequence {u^{X)}'^^i such that sup ||i^^(A)|| < 00, ^xi^^W)
-^ 0 and ^xi^nW)
^ Cfc(A)
as n ^ 00.
n
Proof. We divide the proof into two cases. Case 1: Assume that conditions (Ai) and (A2) hold. We show that Ck{X) > bk{X) first. For each 7 G r^, let U^ := {u e Bk : ||7('^)|| < 7fe}- Then U^ is an open bounded symmetric neighborhood of 0 in W^. Let P^ : E ^ W^-i be the projection onto Wk-i. Then Pkj : dU^ -^ Wk-i is a continuous odd map. By the Borsuk-Ulam Theorem (cf. Theorem 1.30), there exists a i^ G dU^ such that Pkj{u) = 0, that is, 7(1^) G Z^, ||7(i^)|| = r^. Therefore, j{Bk) nSk j^9. This implies Ck{X) > bk{X). Furthermore, Cfc(A) < max ^A('^) ^ i^ax ^i(i^) := m/c, uEBk
uEBk
where ruk is a constant independent of A. By (A2), Ck{X) is nonincreasing with respect to A. Therefore, c^(A) := ——— exists for a.e. A G [1,2]. dX From now on, we consider those A where the derivative c^(A) exists. Let A^ G [1, 2], A^ < A, A^ -^ A, then there exists an n(A) such that (3.1)
- 4 ( A ) - 1 < " ' - ( y _ - ^ ^ ( ^ ) < -c-(A) + 1
forn>n(A).
Step 1. We show that there exists a sequence 7^ G Tk^m := m(c^(A)) > 0 such that ||7n('^)|| < ^^T. if ^A(7n('^)) ^ ^^(A) — (A — A^) for some u G B^-
3.1. ABSTRACT
THEOREMS
39
Indeed, let 7^ G Tk be such that sup^^^^ ^x^hn{u)) < Ck{Xn) + (A - A^). If ^x{ln{u)) > Ck{X) — (A — An) for some u e Bk, then
.. .NX -^(TnN) = <
^Aj7nH)-^A(7nH) ^^^7^^ -4(A)+ 3
and I{-fn{u))
< <
Cfe(An) + (A-An) + An(-4(A) + 3) Cfe(A) + A(-4(A) + 3).
Recahing (A2), we observe that ||7n('^)|| ^ ^^ for some m > 0. Step 2. Since A^ < A, obviously we have that ^xhn{u))
< ^ A j T n H ) < Cfe(A) + (2 - 4(A))(A - Xn) for ah u e Bk.
Step 3. For e small enough, define ^,(A, k):={ueE:
\\u\\ < m(4(A)) + 4, | ^ A ( ^ ) - Cfe(A)| < e}.
It suffices to prove that inf{||^^^(i^)|| : u G ^^^(A, A:)} = 0. Otherwise, we may assume that there exists an SQ > 0 such that ||^^(i^) || > £o for u G J-SQ (A, A:). Take 7^ G F/^ from step 1 and choose A —A^ < £o,X — Xn < '"'^^^-'"'^^\
(2 - 4(A))(A - A„) < £0. Define
J^{X,k) •.= {ueE:
\\u\\ < m(4(A))+4,Cfe(A)-(A-A„) < $A(W) < Cfe(A)+£o}.
Then J^{\, k) C J^eo{\ k). For any u G J^{\, k), let u;{u) :=
I^IH
12-
Then the mapping v -^ {^^^{v),uu(u)) is continuous for each v G J^{X,k). Moreover, hx{u) := {^'^{u),io{u)) = 2 for i^ G J^{X,k). Hence there exists a neighborhood [/^^ of u such that /IA('^) = ( ^ A ( ' ^ ) ' ^ ( ' ^ ) ) > 1 for 'U G t/t^ H J^{X,k). Therefore, we get an open covering {Uu}ueJ^{x,k) of ^(A, A:). Choose an open set UQ := ^ ^ ^ ( - 0 0 , Cfc(A) - (A - A^)). Then {Uu}ueTix,k) U t/o is an open covering of ^(A, k):={ueE:
\\u\\ < m(4(A)) + 4, ^ A M < Cfe(A) + £0}.
40
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
Hence, there exists a refinement {Nj}j^j such that Nj C Uu or Sj C UQ and a locahy Lipschitz continuous partition of unity {Pj}jeJi where J is the index set. Define UJJ{U) = uj{u) for Nj C Uu] ^j{u) = 0 for Nj C t/o, and set J\f := U^GJ^j- Then ^(A, k) C A/". Let ^*(A, k):={ueE:
^x{u) < Ck{\) - 2(A - A,)}
and . , ^ dist(^,>F*(A,A:)) "^^^^ • " dist(^,J^*(A,A:)) + dist(^,J^(A,A:))' ^^ Define a vector field l^(i^) := '4^{u)^-^j PJ{U)(JOJ{U) : J\f ^ E and consider djTi
the following Cauchy problem — = —V{r]) and r]{0,u) = u for u ^ E with ll^ll < m(4(A)), Cfe(A) - (A - A,) < ^x{u) < Ck{X) + soThen V is locally Lipschitz continuous and for any u as above, there exists a unique solution ?^(-, u). Noting that for any u G J^£Q{X, A:), we have that either 2 2 cjo = 0 or \\iOn\\ = ||c(;(i^)|| = ,, ^, , ,,, < —. Therefore, V is bounded and ^
^
II^AMII
^0
2 11^(^)11 ^ —• It follows that r](',u) exists as long as it does not approach the £o
boundary of M. Moreover, {^'x{u),V{u)) > 0 , for ^ G AT, {^xi^), V{u)) > 1, for u G J^(A, k). Evidently, ^^^(^(^^^)) < Q. For each u G ^ ^ ^ ( - o o , Cfe(A) - 2(A - A^)), we have V{u) = 0 and ^x{r]{s,u)) < ^x{r]{0,u)) = ^x{u)' It follows that r]{s,u) G ^^^(-oo,Cfc(A) - 2(A - A^)) and V{r]{s,u)) = 0. Therefore, (3.2)
v{s,u) =u
for ue ^ ^ ^ ( - o o , Cfe(A) - 2(A - A^)).
On the other hand, since ^A is even, then we may choose r]{s, u) to be odd in u. Consider ?^(2£o,7n('^))- Then we claim that ?^(2£o,7n('^)) ^ ^k- Iii fact, for u G dBk,jn{u) = u, then r]{2£o,jn{u)) = r]{2£o,u). Since a/c(A) < c/c(A) —2(A —An), we have ^A('^) < «fe(A) < c/c(A) —2(A —A^) for i^ G ^ 5 ^ . By (3.2) r]{2£o,u) = 1^. Hence, 7^(260,7n('^)) = '^- Noting that 7n('?^) and r]{2£o,u) are odd, we see that 7^(2^0,7n('^)) is odd. Consequently, 7^(260,7n('^)) G F^. If ^A(7n('^)) < c/c(A) — (A —A^) for some u ^ B^, then r]{s,jn{u)) is well defined and (3.3)
$A(r/(2eo,7n(w))) <$A(r?(0,7n(w))) = $A(7n(w))
3.1.
ABSTRACT
THEOREMS
41
If ^xi^jn^u)) > Cfc(A) — (A — A^) for some u ^ B^, then by the choice of 7^, we know t h a t ||7n('^)|| < ^(c/c(A)). By step 2, (3.4)
^A(7nH)
Thus, jni"^) ^ -^(A, k). Assume t h a t
(3.5)
^A(^(2£o,7n(^))) > Cfe(A) - (A - A^)
for some u ^ Bk- Note t h a t ll^(^,7n(^))-7n(^)|| < / Jo 2t < —.
\\V{r^{t,^n{u))\\dt
From this we see t h a t \\r]{t,jri{u))\\
<
2t
\- ||7n('^)|| < ^(c/c(A)) + 4 for
t G [0, 2^0]. Now, we have t h a t Cfe(A) - ( A - An) < ^A(^(2£o,7n(^))
for t G [0,2£o]. Since {^'^(u),V(u))
> 1
for i^ G
^A(^(2£o,7n(^)))
= ^A(7n(^)) + j
—^A(^(5,7n(^)))
<^A(7n(^))-2£o < Cfe(A) - ( A - An), which contradicts (3.5). Hence, max^^^^^ ^A(^(2£o,7n('^))) < c/c(A) —(A —A^). Therefore, Cfe(A) = inf m a x ^ A ( 7 ( ' ^ ) ) < m a x ^A(^(2£o,7n('?^)) < Cfe(A) - (A - A^).
42
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
This contradicts t h e definition of Cfc(A) and completes t h e proof of t h e first case. Case 2: If conditions (Ai) and (A3) hold, t h e proof is quite similar to t h a t of case 1. We omit t h e details. D By Theorem 3.1, we get bounded Palais-Smale sequences for almost all A. In applications, the bounded (PS) sequence readily has a convergent subsequence if t h e working space has some kind of "imbedding compactness." If ^fe(A) ^ 00 as A: ^ 00, we may obtain infinitely many high energy critical points. T h e next theorem is a dual form of Theorem 3.1, by which we may get critical points with small energy.
T h e o r e m 3 . 2 . Assume
that
( B i ) ^x maps bounded sets to bounded sets uniformly ^x{-u) = ^x{u) for all {X,u) G [1,2] x E; (B2) J{u) > 0; J{u) ^
for A G [1,2].
00 as \\u\\ -^ 00 on any finite-dimensional
Further,
subspace
ofE; (B3) there exist pk > rk > 0 such that afe(A) := bk{X)
inf ^x{u) ueZk,\\u\\=pk
:=
max
> 0,
^A('^) < 0
ueWk,\\u\\=rk for all A G [1,2] and dfe(A):=
inf
$A(n)-0
ueZk,\\u\\
for A G [1,2].
Then there exist A^ -^ l,u{Xn)
G Wn such that
^LLJ^(^^)) =^'
^Aj^(An)) ^Cfe
as n ^ 00, where Ck G [c^/c(2), 6/^(1)]. In particular, if {u{\n)} has a convergent subsequence for every A:, then ^ 1 has infinitely many nontrivial critical points {uk} G ^ \ { 0 } satisfying ^i{uk) ^ 0~ as k ^ 00. P r o o f . Choose n > k > ko dnid let Z ^ := ®]=k^j, pk}' Define c^(A) := sup min ^x{l{'^))i where
B^ := {^ G Z ^ : ||^|| <
r ^ := {7 G C{B^, Wr,) : 7 is odd, 7|a5r^ = id}.
3.1. ABSTRACT
THEOREMS
43
If we now apply Theorem 3.1 to —^x on W^, we get that dk{X) < c^(A) < bk{X) and that, for a.e. A G [1,2], there exists a sequence {u'^{X)}'^^i C Wn such that sup ||t^J^(A)|| < oo and that
^'x\wA<W)
- 0 and $ A « ( A ) ) ^ 4(A)
as m ^ OO. Since Wn is a finite-dimensional subspace and bk{X) < 0, there exists a i^^(A) ^ 0 such that
*Ak„(t^"(A)) = 0,
where c^(A) G [(i/c(A), 6fc(A)] of the theorem.
$A(t^"(A)) = 4(A),
for a.e. A G [1,2]. This completes the proof D
Notes and Comments. Theorems 3.1-3.2 are known as fountain theorems since the critical points spout out like a fountain. The earlier form of the fountain theorem and its dual were established by T. Bartsch in [30] and by T. Bartsch-M. Willem in [48] (see also T. Bartsch-M. Willem [49, 50] and M. Willem [377] ) respectively, where the (PS) condition and its variants play an important role for those abstract results and their applications. They are effective tools in studying the existence of infinitely many large or small energy solutions. Another important result on even functionals is the symmetric mountain pass theorem by taking advantage of the index theory and the (PS) condition (cf. A. Ambrosetti-P. Rabinowitz [19] and M. Struwe [352]). Theorems 3.1-3.2 in this section were obtained by W. Zou in [385]. In proving Theorems 3.1-3.2, a " monotonicity method" is applied which was introduced by M. Struwe in [351, 352] for minimization problems and essentially developed by L. Jeanjean in [191, 193, 196] for one positive solution of mountain pass type. The readers may consult the papers of B. Buffoni-L. JeanjeanC.A. Stuart [74], D. G. de Figueiredo-P. L. Lions [163], L. Jeanjean [194], N. Hirano-S. Li-Z. Q. Wang [185], Z. Liu-S. Li-Z. Q. Wang [236], P. L. Lions [227], M. Schechter [316], M. Struwe [349] and other papers for results without the (PS) condition. The ideas adopted here and in the sequel essentially come from L. Jeanjean in [191] (see also the survey of I. Ekeland-N. Ghoussoub [146]). Further developments were made by A. Szulkin, M. Willem, and W. Zou in [361, 378, 386, 395] for homoclinic orbits of Hamiltonian systems and Schrodinger equations which shall be described in later chapters.
44
CHAPTERS.
3.2
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
High Energy Solutions
Consider the existence of multiple solutions to the nonlinear Schrodinger equations (S)
-Au^b{x)u
= f{x,u),
xeK^.
We make the following assumptions. (Ci) b G C ( R ^ , R ) satisfies inf^-^i^Ar b{x) > c > 0. Moreover, for every M > 0, meas{{x G R ^ : b{x) < M}) < oo, where meas denotes the Lebesgue measure in R ^ . (C2) / G C ( R ^ X R , R ) , | / ( X , ^ ) | < C ( 1 + 1^1^-1) for a.e. x G O and ah ^ G R,
where 2 < p < 2*, / ( x , u)u > 0 for all i^ > 0. fix UiU
(C3) liminf—-^. \u\^oo
\u\^
> c > 0 uniformly for x G R ^ , where /i > 2 is a
constant. (C4) lim li^O
^— = 0 uniformly for x G R ^ ; U
^— is a nondecreasing funcU
tion of u for every x G R ^ . (C5) / ( x , u) is odd in i^ for any u ^ E and x G R ^ . T h e o r e m 3.3. Assume that (Ci)-(C^) hold, then problem (S) has infinitely many solutions {uk} satisfying - I {\\j Uk\^ ^b{x)u\)dx 2 JRN
— I
JRN
F{x,Uk)dx ^ 00
as A: ^ 00,
where F(x, i^) = J^ / ( x , 5)(i5. Let E :={ue
iy^'^(R^, R) : /
(| V ^P + b{x)u^)dx < 00}.
Then ^ is a Hilbert space with the inner product (i^, v) =
{\/u ' \/v -\- b{x)uv)dx
and the norm ||i^|| = {u,uy^'^. Then obviously, E ^^ I/^(R^). By Propositions 1.13 and 1.16 (Gagliardo-Nirenberg Inequality), we see that ^-^L"(R^),
V5G [2,2*].
Without loss of generality, we assume A^ > 3.
3.2. HIGH ENERGY SOLUTIONS L e m m a 3.4. E ^ ^
45
L^(R^) for 2 < s < 2N/{N - 2).
Proof. Let {un} C ^ be a sequence of E such that Un ^ u weakly in E. Then {||i^^||} is bounded and u^ ^ u strongly in Lf^^(R^) for 2 < 5 < 2N/{N-2). We first show that u^ ^ u strongly in I/^(R^). It suffices to prove that ^n •= II'^nII2 -^ II'^112- Assume, up to a subsequence, that 5^ -^ 5. For any bounded domain O in R ^ ,
/ \Unfdx< [
\unfdx -^ 5'^
hence S > \\u\\2. Let A{R,M)
:= {x G n^\BR
: h{x) > M } ,
B{R,M)
:= {x G n^\BR
: 6(x) < M } .
Then
/
'^uldx<\\^.
-Jn-M^
JA(RM)
-
M
Choose t G (1, N/{N - 2)) such that 1/t + 1/t' = L Then, li^^dx
<
( /
\un\'^^dx)
(mesisB{R,M)
^JB{R,M)
B{R,M)
<
lli^^f ('meas5(i?,M)')
Note that {||i^n||} is bounded and that condition (Ci) holds. We may choose
ll'^nlP R^M large enough such that —^-— and meas 5 ( i ? , M ) are small enough. Hence, for an arbitrary £ > 0, we have that u^dx = / II^\BR
JA{R,M)
u^dx -\- /
u^dx < s. JB{R,M)
Therefore, 11^112 = Il^lli2(5^) + ll^lli2(RA^\5^) > Jim^ Il^n||i2(5^) >6^
-s.
It means that 5 = ||i^||2- Finally, by Gagliardo-Nirenberg Inequality (see This completes Proposition LI6): i^^ ^ ^^ in L^(R^) for 2 < s < 2N/{N-2). the proof of the lemma. D Let ^(i^) = - | | i ^ f - /
F{x,u)dx,
ueE.
46
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
Then by Lemma 1.20, ^ G C^{E, R ) and J^ is compact, where we take J{u) = /
F{x^u)dx.
We shah prove Theorem 3.3 by finding t h e critical points of
^. We choose an orthonormal basis {cj} of E and define X^ : = R e ^ . Then Zk^Wk can be defined as in t h e previous section. Consider ^x : E ^ H defined by ^ A H := - l l ^ f - A
T h e n J{u)
> 0, /(i^) ^
/
F{x,u)dx:=I{u)-XJ{u),
A G [1,2].
oo as ||i^|| -^ oo, ^ A ( - ' ^ ) = ^ A ( ' ^ ) for ah A G [1, 2] and
1^ G ^ .
L e m m a 3 . 5 . Under the assumptions of Theorem 3.3, for each A: > 2, there exist A^ ^ 1 as n ^ oo, Ck >bk > 0 and { ^ n } ^ i C E such that
P r o o f . Evidently, by conditions (C2), (C3) and (C4), for any £ > 0, there exists a C^ such t h a t f{x^u)u > Cs\u\^ —£\u\'^ for any u. Therefore, it is easy to prove, for some Pk > ^ large enough, t h a t afe(A) : =
max ^A(^) < 0 ueWkMu\\=pk
uniformly for A G [1,2]. On t h e other hand, by (C4), for any £ > 0, there exists a Cg > 0 such t h a t \f{x,u)\ < £\U\-\-CS\U\P~'^ for any x G R ^ , i ^ G R . Let ak : =
sup \\u\\p, ueZk,\\u\\=i
then ak ^ 0 diS k ^ 00. Indeed, suppose t h a t this is not t h e case. Then there is an £0 and {uj} C E with Uj ± Wk--i, \\uj\\ = 1, \\uj\\p > SQ, where kj -^ 00 as j ^ 00. For any v e E, we may find a Wj G Wk^-i such t h a t Wj ^ i; as j ^ 00. Therefore, \{Uj,v)\ = \{Uj,Wj -V)\<
\\Wj
-V\\^0
as j -^ 00, i.e., Uj -^ 0 weakly in E. Hence, Uj ^ 0 in I / ^ ( R ^ ) , a contradiction. Therefore, for u ^ Z^ and £ small enough, we have t h e following
3.2. HIGH ENERGY SOLUTIONS
47
estimates:
$AW >
l\\uf-^Ml-^\\u\\;
> \hf-c\\u\\i >
\hf-cal\\ur.
If we choose rk := (4cpQ^^)^/^^~^\ then for u e Zk with ||i^|| = r/c, we get that
^xiu)>iAcpalf/(^-''\\-^):=h. It follows that bkW '=
inf
>bk^oo
ueZk,\\u\\=rk
as A: ^ oo uniformly for A. Therefore, by Theorem 3.1, for a.e. A G [1,2], there exists a sequence {u^{X)}'^^i such that sup||«^(A)||<^,$',(«n(A))-0 n
and ^A(4(A))^Cfe(A)>6fe(A)>6fe, as n ^ oo. Furthermore, since Cfc(A) < sup ^{u) := Cfc and J^ is compact, by Theorem 1.41, {u^{X)}'^^i has a convergent subsequence. Hence, there exists a z^{X) such that ^^(z^(A)) = 0 and ^x{z^{X)) G [bk^Ck]. Evidently, we may find A^ ^ 1 and {zn} desired by the lemma. D L e m m a 3.6. The sequence {^n}^i obtained in Lemma 3.5 is bounded. Proof. If not, we consider Wn '•= ,, ^,|. Then, up to a subsequence, we get
IknII that Wn ^ w in E; Wn ^ w in I/^(R^) for 2 < t < 2* and Wn{x) -^ w{x) a.e. X G R ^ . We first consider that case that w ^ 0 in E. Since f
fix z )z
^A (^^) = ^' ^^ ^^^^ ^^^^ /
—
JR^
^^ ^(ix < c. Further, by Fatou's Lemma
ll^nll
and conditions (C2) and (C3), f{x,Zn)Zn
f
I
2f{^^^n)Zn,
48
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
a contradiction. For the second case w = 0 in E, we define ^A^(^n^n) •= max ^x^{tZn)- For any c > 0 and Wn := {Acj^^'^Wn, we have, for n large enough,that
=
2c — Xn
>
c;
F{x,Wn)dx
it follows that lim ^A^(^n^n) = oo. Obviously, t^ G (0,1). Hence, (^';,^(t^Z^),t^Z^) = 0 . Thus, /
{-f{x,tnZn)tnZn
- F{x,tnZn))dx
-^ OO.
^
JUN
By condition (C4), h{t) = -t^f{x^s)s
— F{x,ts)
is increasing in t G [0,1];
hence, -f{x,s)s — F{x,s) is increasing in 5 > 0. Combining these with the oddness of / and noting that ^n
/ JUN
{-f{x,Zn)Zn
- F{x,Zn))dx
= ^x^{Zn)
G [6fe,Cfe],
^
thus we see that
/ ^
\'^J\'^i^nZn)^nZn
-t^
yX^tfiZfi)juX
00.
This provides a contradiction.
D
Proof of Theorem 3.3. This is a straightforward consequence of Lemmas 3.5 and 3.6. D Notes and Comments. An important theory for getting high energy solutions is the well known symmetric mountain pass theorem (SMP, for short) based on the (PS)-condition and index theory, see e.g. A. Ambrosetti-P. Rabinowitz [19]). The readers may find some variants of it in M. Struwe [352]. There is an extensive literature concerning the existence of infinitely many
3.3. SMALL ENERGY SOLUTIONS
49
high energy solutions via SMP and the Fountain Theorem (cf. P. Rabinowitz [293], T. Bartsch [30], T. Bartsch-M. Wihem [48], M. Struwe [352], and also M. Willem [377], etc). In particular, in T. Bartsch-Z. Liu-T. Weth [38], S. Li-Z. Q. Wang [217] and W. Zou [391], sign-changing high energy solutions were obtained. We will address this topic later in this book. Several authors considered the existence of high energy solutions with a perturbation from symmetry. For instance, the special case —Ai^ = \u\^~'^u -\-p{x) in O with 1^ = 0 on dQ was first studied by A. Bahri-H. Berestycki [25] and M. Struwe [348] independently (see also A. Bahri [24] and A. Bahri-P. L. Lions [27]). In P. Rabinowitz [293, 296] and K. Tanaka [364, 365] (and also G. C. Dong-S. Li [139]), the authors considered a general case of perturbed elliptic equations. In [367], H. T. Tehrani considered the case of a sign-changing potential. By using the ideas of P. Bolle [59], C. Christine-N. Ghoussoub [101] also obtained some results on perturbed elliptic equations. Applications of the perturbation theory to Hamiltonian systems are given by A. BahriH. Berestycki [26], P. Rabinowitz [296] and Y. Long [239]. Basically, ah the papers mentioned above only concern the existence of the solutions. In M. Schechter-W. Zou [332], infinitely many high energy sign-changing solutions for perturbed elliptic equations with Hardy potentials were initially obtained. However, whether the symmetry can be cancelled completely is even today not adequately solved (see P. Rabinowitz [293, 296], M. Struwe [352] and M. Schechter-W. Zou [332]).
3.3
Small Energy Solutions
We consider the following elliptic equation with concave and convex nonlinearities: (D)
—Au = f{x,u)-\-g{x,u)
in O,
i^ = 0 on dft,
where O is a bounded smooth domain of R ^ , A^ > L (Di) f,g e C{Q X R, R) are odd in u. (D2) There exist cr,5 e (1, 2), ci > 0, C2 > 0, C3 > 0 such that ci|i^|^ < f{x,u)u
< C2\u\^ -\- csli^l
for a.e. x G O and i^ G R.
(D3) There exists p G [2,2*) such that |^(x, 1^)1 < c(l +|i^|^~^) for a.e. x e ft and 1^ G R. Moreover, lim g{x,u)/u = 0 uniformly for x G O. (D4) Suppose that one of the following conditions holds (1) \im.\u\^00 g{x,u)/u
= 0 uniformly for x G O;
50
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
(2) lim|^|^oo^(x,i^)/i^ = —oo uniformly for x e Q. Furthermore,
fix u) ^—
and
^— are decreasing in u for u large enough; u (3) \im.\u\^oo g{x,u)/u = oo uniformly for x G O; g{x,u)/u is increasing in u for u large enough. Moreover, there exists a > maxjcr, 5} such that _. . ^ g(x,u)u — 2G(x,u) ^ .r i r ^ limmi ^—• > c > 0 umiormly tor x G O.
We let F and G denote the primitive functions of / and g respectively. Consider the example / ( x , u) + g{x, u) = X\u\'^~'^u + fi\u\P~'u. which satisfies (Di)-(D4). For the case of 0 < A < < fi = 1,1 < q < 2 < p < 2*, this problem was solved by A. Ambrosetti-H. Brezis-G.Cerami [15]. They also raised an open problem about the existence of infinitely many solutions for all A > 0. This open problem was studied in T. Bartsch-M. Willem [48]. Theorem 3.7 is an improvement and generalization of the results in [48]. Another example is f{x,u)
=i^|i^|^~^ln(2 + |i^|),
a G (1,2);
g{x,u) =/ii^ln(l + |i^|).
Then (Di), (D2), (D3) and (D4)-(2) hold if /i < 0; (Di), (D2), (D3) and (D4)-(3) hold with o^ = 2 if /i > 0. If we choose g{x,u) = u'^ for |i^| < 1; g{x,u) = c|^|-i/2ln(l + 1^1) for |^| > 1, then (Di), (D2), (D3) and (D4)-(l) hold. Theorem 3.7. Assume that (DiJ-fD^) hold. Then equation (D) has infinitely many solutions {uk] satisfying ^{uk) '•=-\\uk\\^ — I F{x,Uk)dx — I G{x,Uk)dx ^ 0~ 2 JQ JQ
as k ^ 00,
where \\u\\ = (J^ | y i^p(ix)^/^.
We choose an orthonormal basis {cj} of E := HQ{Q). Set Xj = Re^, W^ ®j=i-^j5 ^n = ®^nXj. Consider a family of C^-functionals: ^^[u) := -\\u\\^ 2
/ G{x,u)dx - X / F{x,u)dx JQ
JQ
:= I{u) - XJ{u),
3.3. SMALL ENERGY SOLUTIONS
51
where A G [1,2]. Then J{u) > 0 and J{u) ^ oo as ||i^|| ^ oo on any finitedimensional subspace. Let n > k > 2. Lemma 3.8. There exist Xn -^ l,u{Xn) G Wn such that ^xJwA^iK))
= 0,
^A.(^(An)) ^ Ck
as n ^ oo, where Ck G [(i^(2), 6^(1)]. Proof. We win apply Theorem 3.2. By (D3), for any £ > 0, there exists a Cs such that \G{x,u)\ < £\u\'^ -\- CS\U\P. Therefore, for ||i^|| small enough, ^ A H > ihW^ - c||i^||^ - c||i^|||. Assume a < 5 smd let ak{cr) :=
sup
||^||^, ak{S) :=
ueZk,\\u\\=i
sup
H^H^.
ueZk,\\u\\=i
Then ak{(j) -^ 0, ak{S) ^ 0 as A: ^ 00. For ll^ll := Pfe := (8c<(<7) + 8ca^(^))i/(2-), we have that ^A('^) ^ PI/^ enough, then we have that ^A(^)
<
-\\uf-c 2
< <
^ 0- On the other hand, if i^ G W^, \\u\\ small
I \u\''dx^e Jn
I \u\^^C, JQ
I \u\Pdx JQ
c\\uf+c\\ur-c\\u\r 0.
The above arguments imply that 5fe(A) < 0 < ak{X) for A e [1,2]. Furthermore, a u E Zk with ||M|| < pk, we see that
^x{u)>-caU
/
(^Xnf{x,u{Xn))u{Xn)^g{x,u{Xn))u{Xn)jdx.
If, up to a subsequence, ||i^(An)|| ^ oo as n ^ oo, then by (D2), ||^(A^)f(l + o ( l ) ) = I
g{x,u{Xn)MXn)dx,
52
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
where o(l) ^ 0 as n ^ oo. Evidently, it is a contradiction if (D4)-(l) holds. ?t) for for 22 < Otherwise, set Wn = .. ..^x,,, then Wn ^ w in E; Wn ^ w in L^(Q) t < 2* and i(;n(^) -^ w{x) for a.e. x G O. If i(; ^ 0 in ^ , and
lim |ii|^oo
U
—CO in (D4)-(2), then, for n large enough, by Fatou's Lemma, we have that 1 + 0(1) -g{x,u{X„))u{X„) a ^
'""' ' "
>c+[ ^
2J
-g(a:^A)MA„)^^^^,^^
oo,
a contradiction. It is similar if
lim |ii|^oo
^— = oo in (D4)-(3). Therefore, U
w = 0. Define ^x (tnu(Xn)) := max ^x (tu(Xn)), then lim ^x (^n'^(^n)) = OO,
{^Xn{tnU{Xn)),tnU{Xn))
OO
=
<
tG[0,l] "^ = 0. I t folloWS t h a t .
lim^ ( ^x^{tnU{Xn))
-
l i m Xn I ( -f{x,tnU{Xn))tnU{Xn) n^oo /o V 2
n^oo
-{^xA^nU{Xn)),tnU{Xn))
- F{x,tnU{Xn))
) dx
In
+
/
I -g{x,tnU{Xn))tnU{Xn)
- G{x,tnU{Xn))
] dx.
If (D4)-(2) holds, we have that
- / ( x , su)su — F(x, su) -\- -g{x, su)su — G{x, su) < c
for all 5 > 0 and i^ G R. This provides a contradiction. If (D4)-(3) holds, then we have that
oo < c / \u{Xn)\'^dx^
[-g{x,u{Xn))u{Xn)-G{x,u{Xn))]
dx,
3.3. SMALL ENERGY SOLUTIONS
53
which imphes that / i -g{x, u{Xn))u{Xn) — G{x, u{Xn)) ) dx ^ oo. However, by the property of i^(A^), we have that c / ( -g{x, u{Xn))u{Xn) - G{x, u{Xn)) ] dx - c Jn v2^ / -
2
\ 2^*^^' ^(^ri))u{Xn)
+ ic /
< An /
\u{XnTdx
f -f{x,
-]-C
u{Xn))u{Xn)
-g{x,u{Xn))u{Xn)
- G{X, u{Xn)) I
\u{Xn)Vdx
- F{x,
j dx - \ c
u{Xn))
f
\u{Xn)\'dx
j dx
- G{x,u{Xn)) ] dx
D
Notes and Comments. Condition (Ci) was first introduced by T. BartschZ. Q. Wang in [41] which implies the compactness of imbedding of the working space E. Lemma 3.4 is due to [41]. Condition (Ci) contains the coercivity condition: b{x) ^ oo as |x| ^ oo, which was used by P. Rabinowitz in [295] where a positive and a negative soluton of (S) were obtained under the Ambrosetti-Rabinowitz superquadraticity condition (cf. [19]): 37 > 2 such that 0 < jG{x,u)
< g{x,u)u,yu
G R\{0} and a.e. x G O,
where g is the nonlinear term and G is the primitive function of g; ft C R is bounded or unbounded. The coercivity condition was also used by W. OmanaM.Willem in [268] for Hamiltonian systems and by D. G. Costa in [106] for elliptic systems. In [268], with the aid of the superquadraticity condition, infinitely many homoclinic solutions were obtained if the system is odd. In [106], the existence of one solution was studied. In Z. Q. Wang [375], the author considered the effect of concave nonlinearities for the solutions of nonlinear boundary value problems such as Dirichlet (and Neumann) boundary value problems of elliptic equations. Infinitely many small energy solutions were obtained by different methods. His theoretical tools are D. C. Clark's theory for functionals bounded below (cf. D. C. Clark [102] and also H. P.
54
CHAPTERS.
EVEN
FUNCTIONALS
Heinz [179]), the Fountain Theorem of T. Bartsch-M. Willem [48] and M. Willem [377], and the trick of modifying the nonlinear term. In [375], Hamiltonian systems and wave equations were studied also. In N. Hirano [184], the author got infinitely many small energy solutions for sublinear equations by using relative homotopy groups. Multiplicity results for some nonlinear elliptic equations can also be found in A. Ambrosetti-J. Azorero-I. Peral [11] and A. Ambrosetti-J. Garcia Azorero-I. P. Alonso [17]. In particular, in S. Li-Z. Q. Wang [217], sign-changing small energy solutions were obtained. Theorems 3.3-3.7 of the present chapter were obtained by W. Zou in [385].
Chapter 4
Linking and Homoclinic Type Solutions In this chapter, we first prove a weak finking tfieorem wfiicfi, to some extent, unifies the classical linking theorems. Moreover, it produces a bounded Palais-Smale sequence for a non-even functional. Applications will be given on the existence of homoclinic orbits for Hamiltonian systems and solutions to Schrodinger equations.
4.1
A Weak Linking Theorem
Let ^ be a Hilbert space with norm || • || and having an orthogonal decomposition E = N Q M, where A^ C ^ is a closed and separable subspace. Since N is separable, we can define a new norm \v\w satisfying \v\w < ||'^||, ^ v G N such that the topology induced by this norm is equivalent to the weak topology of N on bounded subsets of N. For u = v -\- w G E = N ® M with V e N,w e M.v^e define \u\l^ = \v\l^ + ||'"^|P, then \u\w < \\u\\, y u e E. In particular, if u^ = v^ -\- w^ is | • 1^^ - bounded and u^ -^ u, then v^ ^^ v weakly in N, Wn ^ w strongly in M, Un ^ v -\- w weakly in E. Let Q C N be a II • 11-bounded open convex subset, po ^ Q be a fixed point. Let F be a I • I ^-continuous map from E onto N satisfying (i) F\Q = id; F maps bounded sets to bounded sets; (ii) there exists a fixed finite-dimensional subspace EQ of E such that
F{u -v)-
{F{u) - F{v)) cEo,\/v,ue
E;
(iii) F maps finite-dimensional subspaces of E into finite-dimensional subspaces of E;
56
CHAPTER
4. LINKING
AND HOMOCLINIC
TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Set A := dQ, B := F~^(po), where dQ denotes the || • ||-boundary of Q. There are many examples. E x a m p l e 4 . 1 . Let N = E-,M = E+, then E = E' © ^ + and let Q := {u e E~ : ||i^|| < i?},po = 0 G Q. For any u = u~ Qu^ e E, define F : E ^ N by Fu := u~^ then A := dQ^B := F~^{po) = E^ satisfy the above conditions. E x a m p l e 4 . 2 . Let E = E' ® E+, z^ G E+ with \\ZQ\\ = 1 , ^ + = R Z Q © E^. For any u ^ E, we write u = u~ ® sz^ © w^ with u~ G E~,s G Il,w~^ G (E-^Kzo)^ =Ef. LetN := E'^HZQ. For R > 0, let Q := {u :=u-^szo : 5 G R + , i ^ ~ G ^ ~ , ||i^|| < i?},po = 50^0 ^ Q, So > 0. Let F : E ^ N be defined by Fu := i^~ + ||5Zo+t^^||^o, then F , (3,po satisfy the above conditions with B = F~^{soZo)
= {u : = szo^w^
: s> 0,w^
G E^, \\szo ^w^\\
= so}.
In fact, according to the definition, F\Q = id and F maps bounded sets into bounded sets. On the other hand, for any u,v G E, we write u = u~ -\szo -\- w~^,v = v~ -\- tzo -\- w^, then F{u) = u~ ^ \\szo + i(;+||zo, F{v) = Therefore, v~ + \\tzo -^w^\\zo^ F(u — v) = u~ —v~ ^ \\{s — t)zo -\-w~^ —W^WZQ. F{u-v)-{F{u)-F{v)) = (^\\{s-t)zo^w^ C Hzo := Eo
For ^ eC\E,Il),
(4.1) r :=
-wtW
- \\szo ^ w^W ^ \\tzo ^
(a one-dimensional
wt\\)zo
subspace).
define h : [0,1] X Q ^ E is \ ' |^-continuous. For any (50,1^0) ^ [0,1] x Q, there is a | • |^-neighborhood Ui^s^^^^^ such t h a t {u - h{t,u) : {t,u) G U^so.uo) n ([o/l] X Q)} ^ ^ / m . /i(0,i^) =u,^{h{s,u)) < ^{u),\Ju G Q\.
Then F ^ 0 since id ^T. We shall always use Efin to denote various finitedimensional subspaces of E whose exact dimensions are irrelevant and depend on (50,1^0)- A variant weak linking theorem is T h e o r e m 4 . 3 . Let the family
of C^-functionals
^x{u):=I{u)-XJ{u), Assume
the following
conditions
hold.
( ^ A ) have the VAe[l,2].
form
4.1.
A WEAK
LINKING
(a) J{u) > 0 , V ^ G ^ ; ^ i
THEOREM
57
:=^.
(h) I{u) -^ oo or J{u) -^ oo as \\u\\ -^ oo. (c) ^\ is\-\w -upper semicontinuous; ^ ^ is weakly sequentially on E. Moreover, ^\ maps hounded sets into hounded sets.
continuous
(d) s u p ^ A < i n f ^ A , V A G [1,2]. A
B
Then for almost all A G [1,2], there exists a sequence {un} such that sup 11^^II < oo,
^ A K ) -^ 0,
^ A K ) -^ Cx;
n
where C\ := inf sup ^ A ( ^ ( 1 , ' ^ ) ) ^ [inf ^ A , s u p ^ ] .
P r o o f . We shall prove the theorem step by step. Step 1. We show t h a t C\ G [inf ^ A , sup ^ ] . Evidently, by t h e definition of C\,
C\ < sup ^ A ( ' ^ ) < sup ^i(i^) = sup ^{u) uEQ uEQ uEQ
<
OO.
To show t h a t Cx > inf^ ^ A for all A G [1, 2], we have to prove t h a t /i(l, Q) H 5 ^ 0 for ah h eV. By hypothesis, t h e m a p F / i : [0,1] x Q ^ AT is | • |^continuous. Let K := [0,1] x Q. Then K is | • l^^-compact. In fact, since K is bounded with respect to both norms | • |^ and || • ||, for any (tn^Vn) G K , we may assume t h a t Vn -^ VQ weakly in E and t h a t tn ^ to e [0,1]. Then VQ e Q since Q is convex. Since on t h e bounded set Q C N, t h e | • |^-topology is equivalent to t h e weak topology, then Un -^ VQ. SO, K is I • l^-compact. By t h e definition of F, for any (SQ, i^o) ^ K, there is a | • |^-neighborhood Ui^s^^^^^ such t h a t {u-h{t,u) : {t,u) G U^so.uo)^^} ^ ^fin- Note t h a t , K C y^^s,u)^KU^s,u)' Since K is | • |^-compact, K C U]^^[/(5.^^.), (si^Ui) G K. Consequently, {u — h{t,u) : (t^u) G K} C Efin. Hence, by t h e basic assumptions (i)-(iii) on F , F{u-h(t,u) : (t,u) G K } C Efin dind {u-Fh{t,u) : (t,u) G K } C Efin. Then we can choose a finite-dimensional subspace Efi^ such t h a t po ^ ^ / m and t h a t Fh : [0,1] x (Q n Efin) -^ Efin- We claim t h a t Fh{t, u) ^ po for ah u G d{Q n Efin) = dQ n Efin, t ^ [O51]- To see this, assume t h a t there exist to G [0,1] and i^o ^ dQ HEfin such t h a t Fh{to, UQ) = po, i-e., h{to,uo) G 5 . It follows t h a t ^i(i^o) ^ ^i(/^(^o,'^o)) ^ inf^ ^ 1 > sup^g ^ 1 , which contradicts t h e assumption (d). Thus, our claim above is true. By the homotopy
58
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
invariance of the Brouwer degree, we get that deg(F/i(l,.),Qn^/,^,Po) = deg{Fh{0,'),QnEf,r^,Po) = deg{id,QnEfin,Po) = 1. Therefore, there exists UQ ^ Q r\ Efin such that Fh{l,uo)
= po-
Step 2. Similar to step 1 in the proof of Theorem 3.1, we may consider only those A G [1,2] where C^ exists and use the monotonicity method. Let \n G [1, 2] be a strictly increasing sequence of such points satisfying A^ -^ A. Then there exists n(A) large enough such that (4.2)
- C ; - 1 < ^ ^ - ~ ^ ^ < - C ; + 1 for
n>n(A).
A — An.
Step 3. There exists a sequence h^ ^V^k := k{\) > 0 such that ||/i^(l,i^)|| < k if ^x{hn{l,u)) > Cx — {X — An). This is an analogue of step 1 in the proof of Theorem 3.1. In fact, by the definition of CA^, let /i^ G F be such that (4.3)
sup ^xAhn{l,u)) ueQ
< Cx^ + (A - A^).
Therefore, if ^x{hn{^,u)) > CA — (A — A^) for some u ^ Q, then for n > n(A)(large enough), by (4.2) and (4.3), J{hn{l,u)) < - C ^ + 3, I{hn{l,u)) < Cx - A(:7^ + 3A. By assumption (b), \\hn{l,u)\\ < k := k{X). Step 4. By step 2 and (4.3), sup^x{hn{hu)) ueQ
< sup^xAhnihu)) ueQ
< CA + (2 - C'x){X - Xn).
Step 5. For £ > 0, define (4.4)
Te{X) :={ueE:\\u\\
4, | ^ A ( ^ ) - Cx\ < s}.
Then we claim, for e > 0 small enough, that (4.5)
i n f { | | $ ^ ( u ) | | : u e ^ e ( A ) } = 0.
Otherwise, there exists an SQ > 0 such that ||^^(i^)|| > SQ for all u G J^SQ{X). Let /in ^ F be as in Steps 3-4 and n be large enough such that A — A^ < ^o and (2 - C'^){X - A^) < ^o- Define (4.6)
J^:^{X) :={ueE:
\\u\\ < A: + 4, CA - (A - A^) < ^ A ( ^ ) < ^A + ^ o } .
4.1.
A WEAK
LINKING
Clearly, J^^^{X) C J^soW(4.7)
THEOREM
59
Consider
^*(A) :={ueE:
^x{u)
< CA - (A - A^)}
and J^*o(A) U j^*(A). Since 11^^(^)11 ^ ^o for u G J^^oW, there is a ^{u) G E with 11^(^)11 = 1 such t h a t {^'^{u),^{u)) _
p f ^
> -\\^'^{u)\\.
We let hx{u)
:=
o
for u e Tl^(A).
Then ($';,(«), /IA(U)) > 2 for U e ^ , ; ( A ) . Since ^'^
is weakly sequentially continuous, if {i^n} is || • ||-bounded and u^ -^ u, then Un ^ u in E. Hence {^^^{un),hx{u)) -^ {^^^{u),hx{u)) as n ^ oo. It follows t h a t (^^(•), hx{u)) is | • |^y-continuous on sets bounded in E. Therefore, there is an open | • |^y-neighborhood Afu of u such t h a t (^^('u), hx{u)) > 1 for 'u G Afu^u G ^ * Q ( A ) . On t h e other hand, since ^ A is | • |^-upper semi-continuous, j^*(A) is I • l^-open. Consequently, Afx := Wu - u G J^toW) U J^*(A) is an open cover of ^ * Q ( A ) U ^ * ( A ) . NOW we may find a | • | ^-locally finite and \-\w open refinement {Uj)j^j with a corresponding | • li^- Lipschitz continuous partition of unity {f3j)j^j. For each j , we can either find Uj G ^ * Q ( A ) such t h a t Uj C A/'ii^, or if such u does not exist, then Uj C JF*(A). In the first case we set Wj{u) = hx{uj); in t h e second case, we take Wj{u) = 0. Let [/* = Uj^jUj, then [/* is I • 1^ - open, and J^*Q(A) U J ^ * ( A ) C U*. Define
(4.8)
rA(^):=E/^^(^H(^)-
Then FA • ^ * ^ ^ is a vector field which has t h e following properties: (i) Yx is locally Lipschitz continuous in both || • || and | • 1^^ topology; (ii) (iii)
{^'^{u),Yx{u))>0,yueU*; ($^(u),FA(ti))>l,Vue^;„(A);
(iv) | F A ( U ) U < \\Yxiu)\\ < 2/eo for u e U* and all A e [1,2]. dfi (t u) Consider the following initial value problem — - ^ — = —Yx{r]) with ?^(0, u) = u for ah u G J^*(A) U J?='(A,£o), where J^*{X) is given by (4.7) and J^(A,£o) := {^ G ^ : ll^ll < A:, CA - (A - A,) < ^ A ( ^ ) < ^ A + ^0} (4.9)
C^;(A).
Then by Theorem L36, for each u as above, there exists a unique solution r]{t,u) as long as it does not approach the boundary of [/*. Furthermore, t -^ ^x{v{^^^)) is nonincreasing.
60
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Step 6. We prove that r]{t,u) is | • |^y-continuous for t G [0, 2£o] and u G j^(A,£o) U j^*(A). For fixed to G [0,2£o] and i^o ^ ^(A,£o) U J^*(A), we see that (4.10)
r]{t,u)-r]{t,uo)
=u-uo^
/
[Yx{r]{s,uo))
-Yx{r]{s,u))jds.
Since the set A := ?^([0,2£o] x {'^o}) is compact and | • |^y-compact and Yx is I • l^y-locally | • l^^-Lipschitz, there exist ri > 0,r2 > 0 such that {u G E : infeGA \u-e\^ < r i } C t/* and \Yx{u)-Yx{v)\w < r2\u-v\w for any i^,v G A. Suppose that r]{s,u) G t/* for 0 < 5 < t. Then by (4.10), \r]{t,u) -r]{t,uo)\w <\u-uo\w^ <\u-uo\w^r2
/ \Yx{r]{s,uo))
-Yx{r]{s,u))\^ds
/ |??(5,^o)-^(5,^)U^5. Jo
By the Gronwall inequality in Lemma 1.37, \r]{t,u) -r]{t,uo)\^
< \u - uol^e'^^'^ < \u - uol^e"^^.
If \u — uo\w < S, where 0 < S < rie"^^, then \r]{t,u) — r]{t,uo)\w < ^iTherefore, if \t-to\ < 5, \r]{t,u) -r]{to,uo)\w < \r]{t,u) -r]{t,uo)\w + \v{t,uo) <\r]{t,u)-r]{t,uo)\w^\
/
-r]{to,uo)\w
Yx{r]{s,uo))ds\w
^0
as (5 ^ 0. It means that r]{t,u) is | • 1^^-continuous for t G [0, 2£o] and u G ^(A,£o)U^*(A). Step 7. Define ( K(2t,u),
0 < t < 1/2,
^*(^,^):=< [ r]{Asot - 2^0, /^n(l, u)),
1/2 < t < 1.
We show that rj* G F. Obviously, for i^ G Q, we have either hn{l,u) G JF*(A) or C'A — (A —A^) < ^A(^n(l5'^))- For the second case, we see that ||/i^(l,i^)|| < k
4.1. A WEAK LINKING THEOREM
61
by step 3 and ^x{hn{l,u)) < Cx -\-SQ by step 4. Therefore, hn{l,u) G ^(A,£o)- In view of step 6, T^* is | • |^-continuous satisfying ?^*(0,i^) = u and ^{r]*{t,u)) < ^{u). For any (5o,i^o) ^ [0,1] x Q, since hn G F, we may find a I • I ^y-neighborhood U} ^ N such that (4.11)
{u-K{s,u)
: {s,u) e [/(!,„,„„) n ([0,1] X Q)} C Efi
Moreover, it is easily seen that there exists a | • |^-neighborhood U? N of (so,tto) (5o,i^o) such that (4.12)
{K{s,u)
- K{2s,u)
: {s,u) G U^^^^^^ n ([0,1] x Q)} C Ef,^.
Next, we have to estimate hn{t,u) — r]{4:£ot — 2^0, hn{l,u)) ^x{hn{l,uo))
^x{v{t, Kihuo)))
< ^x{hn{huo))
for t G [1/2,1]. If
Xn)
fortG [0, 2£o]. Particularly, ?^(t,/i^(l,i^o)) G J^*(A) (see (4.7)). If ^A(/^n(l,^o)) > Cx — {X — An), then by step 3, ||/in(l,'^o)|| < k and by step 4, (4.14)
/in(l,^o)G^(A,eo)c^,;(A).
Since ||?^(t,/ln(l,^o))
II / Jo < I Jo
-hn{l,Uo)\\
dr]{s,hn{l,uo) \\Yx{r^{s,K{hu^)))\\ds
^0
we have (4.15)
2t ||7?(t,/in(l,^o))|| < \\hn{l.uo)\\ + - < A: + 4
for t G [0,2£o]. Further, by step 4, ^A(^(^,/^n(l,^o)) < ^x{K{l,uo)) £o- It follows that (4.16)
r]{t, /in(l, ^o)) e ^*^(A) U ^*(A),
< CA +
t G [0, 2£o].
Consider Ai := {?^([0, 2£o],/^n(l,'^o))}, which is | • |^-compact and contained in [/* of step 5 because of (4.13) and (4.16). Moreover, there are rs > 0, r4 > 0 such that A2 :={ue E : | i ^ - A i | ^ < rs} C t/*; \Yx{u)-Yx{v)\^ < r4\u-v\^
62
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
for all u^v e A2 and ^^(^2) C ^/m- Evidently, by the | • |^ continuity of and hn, there exists a | • |^-neighborhood [/? ^^ such that (4.17)
YX^T],
r]{t,hn{l,u))cA2
for t G [0,2£o] and i^ G ^^5^^^^)- For t G [1/2,1], note that hn{t,u) -r]{A£ot-
2£o,hn{l,u))
= hn{t, u) - K{1, u)^
i
Yx{r]{s, /i^(l, u)))ds,
from which we conclude by (4.17) that (4.18) {hn{t, u) - r]{4.sot - 2^0, /^n(l, u)) : (t, ^) G t/f^^^^^^ n ([1/2,1] x Q)} C Ef,nBy the definition of TJ* , 1^ — r]*{t^u) u-hn{t,u)^hn{t,u) u-hn{t,u)
-^hn{t,u)
-hn{2t,u),
t G [0,1/2],
-r]{4sot-2so,hn{l,u)),
t G [1/2,1].
Combining (4.11), (4.12) and (4.18), we get that {u - r]%t,u) : (t^u) G %^^^^^ n ([0,1] x Q)} C ^ / . . , which implies that 7?* G T, where %o,uo) = ^lso,uo) ^ ^(so,uo) ^^ %o,uo) =
Step 8. We will get a contradiction in this step. If ^A(^n(l5 '^)) < C\ — {\ — \ra) for some u ^ Q, then by (4.7), hn{l,u) G JF*(A) and (4.19)
$ A ( ' ? * ( 1 , U))
= $A(r/(2eo, ft„(l,«)) < $A(ft„(l,«))) <
CA
- (A - A„).
If ^x{hn{l,u)) > CA — (A — A„) for some u e Q, then by step 3 and step 4, ||/i„(l,u)|| < k and sup„gQ $A(/in(l,M)) < Cx+£o- Thus, /i„(l,u) G J^e*oWAssume that $x{ri*{l,u)) > CA - (A - A„). Then for 0 < t < 2so, we have, - (A - A„) <$A(r/*(l,w)) <$A(r/(i,/i«(l,u)))
CA
(4.20)
<$A(??(0,/I„(1,W)))
4.1. A WEAK LINKING THEOREM
63
Moreover, for any t G [0, 2^0], by the properties of Yx, \\r]{t,hn{l,u))-hn{l,u)\\
'^ 0
dr]{s,hn{l,u)) ds ^^"
t
< / \\Yx{v{s^K{l^u))\\ds Jo < 2t/so. It follows that \\r]{t,hn{l,u))\\ < 2t/so^ \\hn{l,u)\\ < A: + 4 for t G [0,2so]. This with (4.20) imply that r]{t,hn{l,u)) G J^toi^) for t G [0,2£o]. Since {^'^{u),Y\{u)) > 1 on J^*Q(A), we see that ^A(^(2£o,/^n(l,^)))-^A(/^n(l,^))) ^^^° d -^x{r](t,K(l,u)))dt (^l(7?(t,/l,(l, ^))), rA(^(t,/ln(l, ^))))^t 0
< -2£o.
Therefore, by step 4, ^A(^(2£0,/^n(l,^))) <^A(/^n(l,^))-2£o < ^A -
^0
Combining this with (4.19), we observe that ^ A ( ^ * ( 1 , '^)) < C'A — (A — A^) for any {t^u) G [0,1] x Q, which contradicts the definition of C\. D
Notes and Comments. The existence of the topology \ - \w can be found in D. Dunford-J. T. Schwartz [144]. Similar weak linking was developed in M. Schechter [310, 313, 314]. In [310, 313, 314], conditions "Fl^v = id'' and "F('u — w) = V — Fw for all V ^ N,w ^ E"" were stated but not needed. All that was used was F\Q = id and F{v — w) = v — Fw for all v ^ Q,w ^ E. This was noted in [314]. In particular, since the monotonicity method was not used in [310, 313, 314], the boundedness of the Palais-Smale sequence was not a consequence of the theorems. Therefore, some compactness conditions were introduced and played an important role. In W. Kryszewski and A.
64
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Szulkin [201] (see also M. Willem [377]), some theorems were given which contained linking, and the boundedness of the Palais-Smale sequence also remains unknown. In [201, 377], a r—topology is specially constructed to accommodate the splitting of E into subspaces and by this, a new degree of Leray-Schauder type is established. The new degree and W. Kryszewski-A. Szulkin's linking theorem are also applied in T. Bartsch- Y. Ding [34, 35], Y.Ding-M.Willem [136]. Another infinite dimensional linking theorem was due to V. Benci-P. H. Rabinowitz [55] where more stronger assumptions were imposed, which eliminates many applications such as Schrodinger equations with pure continuous spectra. Theorem 4.3 was due to M. Schechter-W. Zou [328]. Note that this theorem contains most linking theorems we met before.
4.2
Homoclinic Orbits of Hamiltonian Systems
In this section we are concerned with the application of Theorem 4.3 on the existence of homoclinic orbits of the Hamiltonian system z = JH,{z,t),
(H)
where z = (p, ^) G R ^ x R ^ = R^^ and
^
0
-/
» /
0
is the standard symplectic matrix. We assume that the Hamiltonian H is 1-periodic in t, H e ^(R^^ x R , R ) , H^ e ^(R^^ x R , R 2 ^ ) and H^ is asymptotically linear as \z\ -^ oo. Recall that a solution z of (H) is said to be homoclinic to 0 if z ^ 0 and z{t) ^ 0 as \t\ -^ oo. Let H{z^t) = ^Az' z^G{z^t)^ where A is a constant symmetric 2A^ x 2A^matrix, and assume without loss of generality that H{0,t) = 0. Suppose a{J'A) n zR = 0 (cr denotes the spectrum). Let /ii be the smallest positive /i, and /i_i the largest negative fi such that a{J'{A -\- jil)) H zR ^ 0, and set /io '-= min{/ii, —/i_i}. We introduce the following assumptions. (Ai) A is a constant symmetric 2A^ x 2A^-matrix such that G{JA) H ZR = 0. (A2) G is 1-periodic in t, G{z^ t) > 0 for all z, t and Gz{z^ 0 / k l ~^ ^ uniformly in t as z ^ 0. (A3) G{z,t) = \A^{t)z ' z + F{z,t), where Fz{z,t)/\z\ -^ 0 uniformly in t as \z\ -^ 00 and Aoo{t)z - z > fiz - z for some /i > /ii. (A4) ^Gz{z,t)'
z-G{z,t)
>Ofor ah z,t.
4.2. HOMOCLINIC ORBITS OF HAMILTONIAN
SYSTEMS
(A5) There exists S G (0,/io) such that if \Gz{z,t)\
65
> (/io — ^)|^|, then
Let Cz := —Jz — Az and denote the inner product in I/^(R, R^^) by (•, •). Note that a{JA)niIl = 0. Then E := V{\/:\i) (V denotes the domain) is a Hilbert space with inner product (Z,'U)D := {z^v) + (|£|2z, |>^|^'^) ^ind E = i!f2(R^R2^). Moreover, to C there corresponds a bounded selfadjoint operator L : E ^ E such that (I/Z, i;)!) = / {—Jz — Az) ' vdt, R
E = ^ + 0 ^ ~ , where ^ ^ are L-invariant and ( Z + , Z ~ ) D = (z+,z~) = 0 whenever z^ G ^ ^ . Also, {Lz,z)j) is positive definite on E~^ and negative definite on E~. We introduce a new inner product in E by setting {z,v) := {Lz^,v^)j)
- {Lz ,v~ IV'
Then {Lz^z)^^ = | | z + p — ||z |p, where || • || is the norm corresponding to (•,•). It is easy to see from the definitions of /io, /i±i that | z + f >;,l(z+,Z+),
(4.21)
\\z-f>-^_,{z-,Z-)
_ and
\\z\\^ > fio{z,z).
Let {Ej^ : fi G R } be the resolution of identity corresponding to C Then EQ is the orthogonal projector of E onto E~ and Ei^{E) D ^ ~ whenever /i > 0. If /i is as in (A3), then /i > /ii and since /ii is in the spectrum of £, it follows that E^{E) ^ ^ ~ and there exists a ZQ G ^ + , ||zo|| = 1, such that (4.22)
/
{-JZQ
-
AZQ
-
IIZQ)
• zodt = 1 - /i(zo, zo) < 0.
By (A2) this implies that Hz{z,t) = Az + c>(|z|) as z ^ 0, where A is independent oft. In general, one can assume that A = A{t); however, as observed in V. Coti Zelati-I. Ekeland-E. Sere [116], in many cases one can get rid of t-dependence of A by a suitable 1-periodic symplectic change of variables. If this is not possible, then the hypothesis a {J A) H iH = 0 in (Ai) should be replaced by the one that 0 lies in the gap (/i_i,/ii) of the spectrum of C = —J-^ — ^(^5 ^^d i^ (^3) the constant ji should be greater than /ii. Of course, (A5) should be changed accordingly. Note that the spectrum of C is completely continuous. That is Lemma 4.4. Let A{t) G C(R, R^^) he a 1-periodic symmetric matrix-valued function and let C = —J-^ — A{t) : L'^ D H^ ^ L'^ be the corresponding selfadjoint operator. Then the spectrum of C is continuous.
66
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Proof. Since C is selfadjoint, it has no residual spectrum and the isolated points of (J{JC) are eigenvalues. Therefore, it suffices to show that C has no eigenvalues. Assume that (3 is an eigenvalue with an eigenfunction u G H^. Then (4.23)
-. =
j^A{t)^(3)u.
Let W{t) be the fundamental matrix of (4.23) with 1^(0) = / . By the Floquet theory (cf. P. Kuchment [202]), W{1) = P{t)e^^, where T = InVF(l) and P{t) is a 1-periodic continuous differentiable matrix valued function with a bounded inverse P~^{t). Let v{t) = P~^{t)u{t). Then v{t) -^ 0 and \t\ -^ oo and
With respect to the eigenspaces of T corresponding to the positive, negative and 0 eigenvalues, we may split R^^ as R^^ = M^^M©M^. Assume P*, * = +, —, 0, are the projections from R^^ to M*. Then
Note that v'^{t) ^ 0 as \t\ -^ oo, we must have v'^{t) = 0. This implies i^ = 0, a contradiction. D Theorem 4.5. Assume {Ai)-{A^). clinic orbit.
Then system (H) has at least one homo-
It follows from (^2) and (^3) that \Gz{z,t)\ < c\z\ for some c > 0 and all z^t. Therefore (4.24)
^{z) :=]- I {-Jz 2 JR
- Az) - zdt - [
G{z,t)dt
JR
is continuously differentiable in the Sobolev space H'^iYi^Yi?^)^ and critical points z ^ 0 of ^ correspond to homoclinic solutions of {H). Let '0(z) := / G{z^t)dt. Clearly, V^ > 0, and it follows from Fatou's lemma that V^ is JR
weakly sequentially lower semicontinuous. Since \Gz{z^t)\ < c\z\ and Zn ^ z implies z^ ^ ^ in I/^^^^(R, R^^), it is easily seen that V^^ is weakly sequentially continuous. Thus, (c) of Theorem 4.3 is satisfied. Set
4.2. HOMOCLINIC ORBITS OF HAMILTONIAN SYSTEMS
* A W := l\\z+f
- A ( ^ | | z - f + ^{z)),
67
1 < A < 2.
Then ^ i = ^ (cf. (4.24)). Choose a ZQ G E~^ as mentioned above and let B:={zeE^:\\z\\=r}; M :={z = z- ^ pzo : \\z\\
A = dM,
where R > r > 0 are to be determined. Lemma 4.6. There exist r > 0 and b > 0 such that ^X\B ^ b. Proof. Choose p > 2. By (^2) and (A3), for any s > 0 there exists a C^ > 0 such that G{z,t) < s\z\'^ ^ CS\Z\P. Hence ^{z) = [ G{z,t)dt < e\\z\\l + CM\l
< c{e\\zf +
CMH-
It follows that '0(^) = o(||zp) as z -^ 0 and there are r > 0, 6 > 0 such that ^x{z)>b>OfoT
z e B.
D
Lemma 4.7. There exists an R > r such that ^x\dM ^ 0Proof. Since G{z,t) > 0 according to (^2), we have ^z-)
1, = --\\z-f-
/I
G{z-,t)dt G{z-,t)dt<0.
Note that ^ A ( ^ ) < ^(^) for any z e E, we just have to prove that ^\dM < 0 for R large enough. If this is not true, then there exists Si z^ = p^zo -\- z~, \\zn\\ -^ 00, such that
where 6n = TT^ and v~ = TT^' Therefore Sn > \\v~\\. Since ^n + lbn P = I5 I P n 11
11 ^n 11
5n ^ S > 0 and v~ ^- v~ weakly in E after passing to a subsequence. Set V = SZQ -\- v~. Since (^0,^;") = 0, it follows from (^3) and (4.22) that S^-\\v-f<S'^<0.
f A^{t)vvdt Jn \\v~f - /j.S'^{zo,zo) -
ii{v~,v~)
68
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Thus we may find a bounded interval O such that 5 — H'^" || — / A^{t)v'vdt
<
0. On the other hand, by (4.25), we have that
0 < k -i|k - | P - ./ot IUJI2 ^!^dt 2"" 2"^"" ^^I-^IKf-^//oo(iK--nrf*-/^^"''^-
where v^ = ^n^o + '^n • Since v^ -^ ^^o + '^ = U ' in ^ , we have v^ ^ v in 1.2(0, R 2 ^ ) . By (A2) and (A3) it is easy to check that \F{z,t)\ < c\z\^ for ah z G R^^. Since F ( z , t ) / | z p ^ 0 as \z\ -^ 00, it fohows from Lebesgue's dominated convergence theorem that
lim f ^^dt=
lim [ ^^\v^fdt
= 0,
and therefore that .^ - | K f " / A ^ ( t ) . • vdt > 0, a contradiction. Consequently, there exists an i? > 0 such that ^ A ( ^ ) < ^(^) < 0 for z G dM. D
Combining Lemmas 4.6, 4.7 and Theorem 4.3 we obtain Lemma 4.8. For almost every A G [1,2] ^/lere exists a bounded sequence (zn) C E such that ^'^{zn) -^ 0 and ^x{zn) -^ c\. Let {zn) C ^ be a bounded sequence. Then, up to a subsequence, eiry+R
ther (i) Vanishing: Nonvanishing:
lim sup /
|z-^p(it = 0 for all 0 < i? < oo, or (ii)
there exist o^ > 0, i? > 0 and T/^ G R such that ry^+R
lim /
|z^p(it > Q^ > 0.
Lemma 4.9. For any hounded vanishing sequence {z^) C E, we have lim / G{zn,t)dt=
lim / G^{zn,t) - z^dt = {).
Proof. Recall the concentration-compactness Lemma L17 due to P. L. Lions [228]. Although this lemma is stated for z G H^ ^ by a simple modification, the
4.2. HOMOCLINIC ORBITS OF HAMILTONIAN
SYSTEMS
69
conclusion remains valid in H^. Therefore, if {z^} is vanishing, then z^ ^ 0 in L^ for all 2 < 5 < oo. On the other hand, by assumptions (^42) and (A3), for any s > 0 there exists a C^ > 0 such that (4.26)
\G,{z,t)\<s\z\^C,\zr\
where p > 2. Hence, / G(zn, t)(it < c(£||zn|p + C^Hz^H^) and
// R.
| G , ( z „ , t ) | \zt\dt
< C{S\\Z„\\ \\zt\\
+ Cell^nlirl^lW,
and the conclusion follows.
D
L e m m a 4.10. Let A G [1,2] be fixed. If a bounded sequence {vn} C E satisfies 0 < lim^^oo ^A('^n) ^ cx ^^^ l™n^oo ^A('^^) ~ ^' then there exists a yn ^ Z such that, up to a subsequence, Un{t) := Vn{t -\- y^) satisfies Un^ux^O, ^x{ux)
lim ^x{vn) > 0,
and it follows from Lemma 4.9 that {vn} is nonvanishing, that is, there exist a > 0, R > 0 and yn ^ ^ such that lim /
\vnfdt > a > 0. Hence we
may find yn ^ Z such that, setting Un{t) := Vn{t -\-yn), 2R \Un\^dt
/
> Q^ > 0.
-2R
Since G{z,t) is 1-periodic in t, {un} is still bounded, (4.28)
0 < lim ^x{un) < cx
and
lim ^xM
= 0.
Up to a subsequence, we have that Un -^ ux and Un -^ ux a.e. in R for some Ux G E. Note that u^ -^ ux in I/^^^(R, R^^), it follows from (4.27) that Ux ^ 0. Since IIJ' is weakly sequentially continuous, we have ^^(i^^) ^ ^'-^{ux) and by (4.28), ^^;,(I^A) = 0- Finally, by (A4) and Fatou's lemma, cx
>
>
l i m {^x{Un)
-
-(^l(^n),^n))
X f {lG,{ux,t)-ux-G{ux,t))dt R 2
=$ A K ) . D
70
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Lemma 4.11. There exists a sequence {A^} C [1,2] and {zn} C ^ \ { 0 } such that An ^ 1, ^A^ (zn) < cx^ and ^'^^ (zn) = 0. Proof. This is a straightforward consequence of Lemmas 4.8-4.10.
D
Lemma 4.12. The sequence {z^} obtained in Lemma 4-11 ^s bounded. Proof. Assume \\zn\\ -^ oo and set w^ = ^n/||^n||- Then we can assume, up to a subsequence, that Wn ^ w. We shah show that {wn} is neither vanishing nor nonvanishing, thereby obtaining a contradiction. (a) Nonvanishing of {wn} is impossible. If {wn} is nonvanishing, we proceed as in the proof of Lemma 4.10 to find a > 0, R > 0 and y^ ^ Z such that if Wn{t) := Wn{t -\-i/n), then / \wn{t)fdt > a for almost all n. J-2R Moreover, since ^^ {z^) = ^^ {z^) = 0, where Zn{t) = Zn{t -\- y^), for any ( / ) G C ^ ( R , R 2 ^ ) wehave (4.29)
{w:^,(l)) -Xn{w-,(l))
-Xn /
A^{t)wn'(l)dt
Jn
-An / p^ \Wn\dt = {). Jn \Zn\ Since ||w;^|| = \\wn\\ = 1, Wn ^ w in E, w^ ^ w in Lf^^CR^R?^) and '^n(0 ~^ ^if) ^'^' i^ ^ - I^ particular, w; ^ 0. Since \Fz{z^t)\ < c\z\ for all z,t, by {H^) and Lebesgue's dominated convergence theorem and by passing to the limit in (4.29), it gives (w;^, (j)) — {w~,(j)) — / AoQ{t)w - (j)dt = 0, that is, equation z = J{A-\-Aoo{t))z has a nontrivial solution in E, which contradicts Lemma 4.4. Therefore nonvanishing of {wn} is impossible. (b) Vanishing of {wn} is impossible. Suppose that {wn} is vanishing. Since ^A i^ri) = 0, we have
(^1JZ,),4) = | | 4 f - A, / G.(^n,t) . Z^dt = 0, Jn
{^'^Jzn),z-)
= -Xn\\z-f
- Xn / G,{zn,t)'Z-dt Jn
Since ||i(;nll^ = \\w:^P + ll'^n IP = 1^ we have that
n
G^(z^,t) • (A^^+ -w~)dt=
\\zn\\.
= 0.
4.2. HOMOCLINIC ORBITS OF HAMILTONIAN
SYSTEMS
71
\G (z t)\ Let Sji := {t G R : —^ — < /j^o — S}. By using Holder's inequality, the relation {w~^,w~) = 0 and (4.21), we see that
e.
IknII
< (/io -^)An||^n||2 ^ (/JQ - 5)\n
< 1 for almost all n. Hence (4.30)
hm /
^.(^n,t).(A^+-^-)^^^^^
and since \Gz{z,t)\ < c|z|, it follows that
R\e^
IknII
\Wn\^dt
' Zn
-G{Zn,t))dt
{]-G,{Zn,t)-Zn-G{Zn,t))dt 5dt
-^ 00.
However, recalling that ^A^(^n) ^ c^^ and (^^ {zn),^^) = 0, we obtain 1 {-Gz{Zn,t) R ^
a contradiction.
cx • Zn -G{Zn,t))dt
< —^ < OO, A^
D
72
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Proof of Theorem 4.5. We have proved that there exist A^ ^ 1 and a bounded sequence {zn} such that ^A^(^n) < CA^ and ^^ (zn) = 0. Therefore
= $ ^ j 2 „ ) + ( A „ - l ) ( z - + t/.'(2„)) = (A„-l)(z-+^'(z„))
Since ($^ (^^n), ^^) = 0, by (4.26), we obtain that (4.31)
||z+f = \nj^G,{Zn,t)
• Z+dt < \\\Zn\? + C||z„r,
(4.32)
\\z-f = -j^G,{zn,t)-z-dt<\\\zX
+ C\\znr,
where p > 2. Hence
\Znf
4.3. ASYMPTOTICALLY
4.3
LINEAR SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
73
Asymptotically Linear Schrodinger Equations
Consider the Schrodinger equation (SEi)
- A ^ + V{x)u = / ( x , u),
where x e K^, V e C ( R ^ , R ) and / G C(R^ x R , R ) . Suppose that 0 is not in the spectrum of - A + V in ^ ^ ( R ^ ) (denoted by 0 ^ cr(-A + V)). Let /ii be the smallest positive and /i_i the largest negative /i such that 0 G cr(—A -\- V — fi) and set /io •= min{/ii, —/i_i}. It is well-known that if V is periodic in each of the x-variables, then the spectrum of —A + V (in I/^) is bounded below but not above and consists of disjoint closed intervals (see M. Reed-B. Simon [301, Theorem XIII. 100]). Similarly, we introduce the following hypotheses. (Bi) V is 1-periodic in Xj for j = 1 , . . . , N, and 0 ^ cr(—A + V). (B2) / is 1-periodic in Xj for j = 1,...,A^, F{x^u) / ( x , u)/u -^ 0 uniformly in x as i^ ^ 0. (B3) f{x,u) = Voo(x)u -\- g{x,u), where g{x,u)/u |i^| -^ 00 and 1^00(^) ^ /^ for some /i > /ii.
> 0 for all x^u and -^ 0 uniformly in x as
(B4) ^uf{x, u) — F(x, 1^) > 0 for all x, i^. (B5) There exists a (5 G (0,/io) such that if/(x,i^)/i^ >/io—^, then ^i^/(x,i^) — F{x,u) > S. Theorem 4.13. If the hypotheses (Bi) — (B^) are satisfied, then (SEi) has a solution u ^ 0 such that u{x) ^ 0 as \x\ ^ 0 0 . The functional ^{u) :=l
[
{\Vuf + V{x)u^)dx - [
F{x, u)dx
is of class C^ in the Sobolev space E := H^{Rj^)^ and critical points of ^ correspond to solutions u of (SEi) such that u{x) ^ 0 as |x| ^ 00. If a{—A-\V) n (-00,0) ^ 0, then E = E^ QE-, where E^ are infinite-dimensional, and the proof of Theorem 4.13 follows by repeating the arguments of previous sections. Notes and Comments. If cr(—A+ y ) C (0, 00), then E~ = {0}, /i_i = —00 and ^ has the mountain pass geometry. Theorem 4.13 remains valid in this case, and it is in fact already contained in Theorem 1.2 of L. Jeanjean [191],
74
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
where V = constant. For general asymptotically linear cases with periodic potentials, the first result (Theorem 4.13) was due to A.Szulkin-W. Zou in [361] (and later in G. Li-A. Szulkin [209]). For the asymptotically linear cases of non-periodic potential, see L. Jeanjean-K. Tanaka [195] (where V{x) -^ y(oo) > 0 as \x\ -^ oo), C. A. Stuart-H. S. Zhou [354] (where the problem has radial symmetry) and also F. A. van Heerden [370], F. A. van Heerden-Z. Q. Wang [371]. The superlinear case for (SEi) was studied in S. Alama-Y. Y. Li [6], V. Coti Zelati-P.H. Rabinowitz [118], Y. Ding-S. Luan [135], W. Kryszewski-A. Szulkin [201], C. Troestler-M. Willem [372] and the survey by T. Bartsch-Z. Q. Wang-M. Willem [45]. The variational perturbative methods and bifurcation from the essential spectrum can be seen in A. Ambrosetti-M. Badiale [13]. The existence result of a ground state for nonlinear scalar field equations had been obtained in H. Berestycki-P. L. Lions [58]. The readers will be seeing more notes and comments following the next section.
4.4
Schrodinger Equations with 0 G Spectrum
Consider a nonlinear Schrodinger equation with periodic potential: . ^
. ^^
J —Au-\-V{x)u = g{x,u) \ u{x) ^ 0
for X G R ^ , as \x\ -^ oo.
We assume that 0 is an end point of the purely continuous spectrum of the Schrodinger operator — A + V. We introduce the following conditions. (Co) V G C(R^, R) is 1-periodic in x^,
z = 1 , . . . , AT.
(Ci) 0 G c r ( - A + y ) , and there exists a / 3 > 0 such that (0,/3]ncr(-A+y) = 0 . (C2) g G C ( R ^ x R , R) is 1-periodic in x^, z = 1 , . . . , A^. There exist constants ci, C2 and 2 < /i < 2* such that ci|i^|^ < g{x^u)u < C2\u\^ for all X G R^,i^ G R. (C3) g{x, u)u - 2G{x, u)>0
for ah x G R ^ , u G R\{0}. Q(X
U}U
(C4) There exists a 70 > 2 such that liminf ——^—- > 70 uniformly for u^o G[x,u) XGR^.
/ ^ \ rr^i 1 1 1 ^ g(x,u)u — 2G(x,u) (C5) There exists a c > 0 such that limmi :—: > c uni^
^
\u\^oo
formly for x G R ^ . Here, a > a'' := /i — 1
|l^|«
— — if 2* < 00; a > 2*/i — 2* — /i
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
75
Assumption (CQ) implies that the Schrodinger operator S := —A + V (on I/^(R)) has purely continuous spectrum, written a{—A-\-V), which is bounded below and consists of closed disjoint intervals (cf. M. Reed-B. Simon [301, Theorem XIII. 100]). Assumption (Ci) means that V cannot be constant. It is easy to check that the classical Ambrosetti-Rabinowitz superquadraticity condition (see A. Ambrosetti-P. Rabinowitz [19]): (4.33)
37 > 2 such that 0 < jG{x, u) < g{x, u)u,
\/u G R\{0}, x G R ^ ,
implies (C3) - (C5). But the converse proposition is not true. Here we give an example. E x a m p l e 4.14. Let g{x,t)
=
(4.34)
fi\t\^-H + (/i - 2)(/i -
s)\t\^-^-Hsm\^-^)
+(/i-2)|tr-2tsin2(^),
where 2 * > / i > 2 , 0 < £ < min{/i - 2, /i - /i*}. Hence G{x,t) = | t r + (/i - 2)1^1^-^ s i n 2 ( f f ) . s
Then (C2) - (C5) hold with 70 = /i, o^ = /i — £. However, for any 7 > 2, let tn = (£(n7r + f7r))^^^ Then g{x,tn)tn
-jG{x,tn)
= (/i-7)|tnr + ( / i - 2 ) ( / i - e - 7 ) | t n r - ^ s i n 2 ( ^ ) + (/i-2)|t,rsin2(^)
-^ —00
as n ^
00,
i.e., condition (4-33) can not he satisfied for any 7 > 2. T h e o r e m 4.15. Assume (CQ), (Ci)-(C^). Then solution u e i?ioc(R-^) n L^{R^) for id<s<2*.
(SE2) has a nontrivial
Consider the following cases: (4.35)
g{x,u)=(3o\u\>'-'^u + f{x,u),
/3o > 0,
^£(2,2*).
76
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
(Di) / G C(R^ X R, R) is 1-periodic in x^, z = 1 , . . . , AT. f{x,u)u
= o(|i^|^)
as |i^| -^ 0,
f{x,u)u
= o{\u\^)
as |i^| ^ oo
uniformly for x G R ^ . (D2) 0 < f{x,u)u
< ^ ^ ^ ^ ~ ^ V r for all xeK^.ue
Theorem 4.16. Assume (Co), (Ci), equation r -/\u^V{x)u \
Let X := H^{Ii^).
(Di) and (D2). Then the Schrodinger
= (3o\u\^-^u^ u{x) ^ 0
has a nontrivial solution u G H'^^^{BJ^)
R\{0}.
f{x,u)
forxeK^, as \x\ ^ 00
n I/^(R^) for fi < s <2*.
Then the functional ^ : X ^ R defined by
^{u) = 11
(I V ^ p + V{x)u^)dx - [
G{x, u)dx
is of class C^{H^{¥i^)^ R) and the critical points of ^ are solutions of {SE2). By (Ci), X splits as X = X~ 0 X+ corresponding to the decomposition of cr(-A + y ) n (-00, 0] and cr(-A + V) n [/3, 00). Consider a new norm || • H^; on X^ defined by
h^\\l-=
I
{\Vu^\^^V{x)\u^\^)dx
for
u^eX^.
Then ^ can be rewritten as
Hu) = hu+\\l-h\u-\\l-
f
G{x,u)dx
for u = u'^ -\- u~ G X+ 0 X ~ . Furthermore, since 0 G cr(—A + V) and hence II • 11^; is not equivalent to || • ||i:/i, we let ^ be the completion of H^(Il^) with respect to || • H^;. Then ^ is a Hilbert space with inner product {U,V)E = (16^12 1^, \S\^V)L2, where S := —A + V and (•, ')L2 is the usual inner product of H := I/^(R^). Corresponding to the decomposition of o-{S) we have the orthogonal decomposition E = E~ 0 E~^. Let (PA • H -^ i^)AGR denote the spectral family of S, and set H~ := PQH, H^ := (id—PQ)^- Then
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
77
H = H~ 0 H^ and i!f~ C E~. Since by (Ci), the norm || • H^; is equivalent to the H^-norm on E+, E+ = H^CR^) n H+. But it is not true on E'. So H^{Il^) n H~ = i!f~ is not complete with respect to || • H^;. We introduce a new norm on E by setting ||i^||^ := (||'^|||; + l^lfiV - Here and in the sequel, I • It denotes the usual norm in I/^(R^). Let E~ be the completion of H~ with respect to || • ||^. Then E^ := E' © E^ is the completion of H^(R^) with respect to || • ||^. Moreover, Ej^ is a reflexive Banach space such that i l ^ ( R ^ ) C E^ C E and afl norms || • ||^, || • H^;, || • H^i^i are equivalent on E^. By the above argument, it is easy to check that E~ C E~ and {U,V)E = 0 for any u G E~, v G E~^. The following Lemma 4.17 can be found in T. Bartsch-Y. Ding [34, Lemma 2.1 and Corollary 2.3]: Lemma 4.17. E' ^ Hl^CR^); E' ^ ^ ^ioc(I^^) for 2 < t < 2\ Furthermore, E- ^ L^(R^) for fi
Proof. For u G E~, there exists a sequence {un}ne'N C H~ such that \\un — u\\fi ^ 0 as n ^ 00. For any bounded domain O C R ^ , choose a function r] G C ^ ( R ^ ) with 7^ = 1 in O. Then, for v e H' C H'^{'R^), we see that —A{r]v)r]v = rf'{—/\v)v + v'^{—Ar])r] — 2r]vVv • V?^. Hence,
\V{vv)\l<{Sv,rj\)
+
^\V{vv)\l+c{n)\v\l,
where c(0) is a constant depending on O. It follows that + \v\, + \v\l),
\^{vv)\l
and hence {un} is a Cauchy sequence in H^{ft) and u G H^{ft). o-{S) > —a > —00,
Note that
\S{Un -Um)\l 0 2
A d\Px{Un <-a
\d\Px{Un
-Um)\2 -Um)\2
J—a = a\\Un
-UmWlj'
Then Sun -^ Su in L^. Now we show that u G Hf^^CR^). By the CalderonZygmund inequality (cf. D. Gilbarg-N.S. Trudinger [174]), given r > 0,£ >
78
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
0,7/ G R ^ , we have \\Un -
Um\\H^{B{y,r))
This means that u e Hl^CR^). Finahy, we prove that u e L^(R^) for t G [/i, 2*]. This is clear for t = fi. For fixed r > 0, £ > 0,7/ G R ^ , we have
+
HLf-{B{y,r+s)))-
Hence, |i^| dx B{y,r) < Cr,J\Su\f-^ ^
I JB{y,r+e)
\Su\^dx^\u\^^-^
I J B{y,r+e)
\u\^dx). ^
We cover R ^ by ah bahs B{y,r),y G F C R ^ , such that for e > 0 smah, at most A^ + 1 bahs B{y,r -\- s) intersect nontriviahy. Therefore,
/
\ufdx
i.e., u G I/^*. By interpolation, we readily get u e L^ for any t G [/i,2*]. Finally, if i^ G ^ ^ solves the equation of {SE2), we have esssup^^^(^^i)|^(x)| < c||^||^2(5(^,2)), and by the Holder inequality, \\u\\Loo(Biy,l))
<
c\\u\\Lf.^Biy,2))
for all y G R ^ , where c is a constant independent ofy. For an arbitrary £ > 0, u G I/^(R^) implies that lim /
\u\^dx = 0. Therefore, we may take R
large enough such that ||i^||L/^(|a;|>i?) < ^- Then for y G R ^ with \y\ > R-\-2 we have ||i^||L«=(s(y,i)) ^ ce. This implies that u{x) ^ 0 as \x\ ^ 0 0 . D L e m m a 4.18. There exists a c > 0 such that |5^-|^
for any u' e
E'.
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
79
Proof. By Lemma 4.17, Su' G ^^(R^) for u' e E'. On the other hand, there exists a {vm} C H~ such that H'^m —'^~IU -^ 0- By the proof of Lemma 4.17, Svm -^ Su~ in I/^(R^). Moreover, for a G (—m/cr(6'), oo), we have \SU m 1^
-
\ 2 ^ I D , /., M2 /' X^d\Px{Vm)\l J—a
<
Q^
<
^Ibmlll
2
1^1^^.
It fohows that |6'^-|^
D
We need the fohowing concentration-compactness lemma which is similar to Lemma 1.17. Lemma 4.19. Let r > 0 and {un} C (^^, || • ||^) be bounded. If sup yen^
/
\un\ dx ^ 0
as n ^ oo,
JB{y,r)
then Un ^ ^ in L^{Il^) for ji < t < 2*. In particular, if {un} C E^, Un^^ in L\n^) for2
then
Proof. We consider the case A^ > 3. For 5 G (/i, 2*), by Lemma 4.17 and the Holder and Sobolev inequalities, (^•^^)
where A = —
\^n\is^B(y,r))
^ 1'^^ lL2(5(y,r)) 1'^^ U * (5(y,r))'
• —. We write Un = u:^ -\- u~ with u^ G E^, u~ G E~.
Then (4.37)
Wn\L^*{B{y,r)) <
4K\\Hl^(B(y,r))'
On the other hand, by the proof of Lemma 4.17, for any s > 0 there exists Cr,£ depending on r and s such that (4.38)
\Un\L^*{B{y,r)) <
4^n\\H^B{y,r))
< Cr^e {\Su~\L2^B{y,r+s))
+ Wn\L^^{B{y,r+s))) -
80
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Combining Lemma 4.17, (4.36)-(4.38), we have that Wn\L^*(B{y,r))
Choosing sX = /i, we see that \sX 2* \^n\L2*^B{y,r)) ,+ l|M ^ <^\Wn \\H^^^{B{y,r)) + cCr,s\Su^
^cCr^s\Un
\L^{B{y,r+s))
\L^^{B{y,r+e))
< C\\U^ 11^1 \\U^ \\Hl^{B{y,r)) ^cCr^Su^
+ ^^rA^n
\L^-{B{y,r+e))
\l^2(^^N^^\Su^ lL2(5(y,r+£))-
By Lemma 4.17 and the equivalence of norms || • H^;, || • ||^ and || • WH^^ on ^ + , the boundedness of ||i^nlU implies that sup||i^+||^i < oo,
sup||^~||^ < oo,
sup|^~|^ < oo.
By Lemma 4.18, \Su~\2 ^ <^ll'^n 11^ ^ ^' Therefore, \s\ 2* P^lL2*(5(y,r)) ,+ l|2 ^ 4^n \\Hl^^{B{y,r)) + cCr^Su^
\L^{B{y,r+e))
It follows that.
JBiy.r) 3{y,r) J
|^(^~^^
I7/ 1 ^ ^ ,
^ri\L^(B{y,r))\^n\L^*
-^cCr,s
[ JBiy.r+s)
iB{y,r))
{\Su-\^^\u-ndx]
. /
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
81
Cover R ^ by balls B{y,r), y G R^ such that for e > 0 small enough, at most A^ + 1 balls B(y,r -\- s) intersect nontrivially. Then \Un\ g(l-A)
< (A^ + l)c sup yen^
7
|2.
/
\un\ dx
\JB{y,r)
j
(|V
{\Su-\'^\u-ndx
as n ^ oo, that is, i^^ ^ 0 in L^(R^). Since /i < 5 < 2*, the conclusion follows by Lemma 4.17 , Sobolev, Holder and interpolation inequalities. Since the norms || • \\H^ and || • ||^ are equivalent in ^ + , the second conclusion is obvious by Lemma 1.17 (cf. P.L. Lions [228]) . D
Since ^ := ^ ^ = ^ - © ^ + , we let F = ^ - , Z = ^ + . Consider the functional 1„
^„o
H{u) = -\\u+ l|2_
1, WE •
/
G{x^u)doL
foru = u + 1^+ G Ej^ = E 0 E~^. Then by assumption (Ci) and Lemma 4.17, H eC^E^.K). Set Hx{u) =
l\\u^\\l-xl^l\\u-\\l^J^^G{x,u)dx 1
:= I{u)-XJ{u),
Then Hi = H and J{u) > 0. Since G{x,u) = J^ f{x,su)uds, Cl
by (C2) it is
Co
easily checked that —\u\^ < G{x,u) < —|i^|^. Hence, I{u) ^ 00 or J{u) -^
\u\l^<£.
L e m m a 4.20. Assume (C2). Then Hx is \ • \uj-upper semicontinuous, H'^ is weakly sequentially continuous. Proof. For any c G R, we consider Un ^ {u e E/^ : Hx{u) > c} with Un —^ u. Write Un = u^ ^ u~ with i^+ G E^^ u~ G E~] by the definition of the | • |^topology, we observe that u^ -^ u^ in ^ ^ and hence sup ||i^^||£; < 00. Note
82
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
that Hx{un) > c and G{x, u^) > 0, so we have sup \\u~ H^; < oo. On the other hand,
< I
G{x,Un)da
4111-olKIII
A V2 < OO.
Thus, sup ||i^nlU < OO. Insert Lemma 4.17 and assume that Un ^^ u in E^^
Un ^ u strongly in I/[^^(R ) and
Un{x) -^ u{x) a.e. X G R ^ . By Fatou's Lemma and the weak semicontinuity of the norm, we see that c < Hx{u), i.e., Hx is | • l^^-upper semicontinuous. Let i^^ ^ i^ in Ej^. Then 1^^ ^ 1^ in I / [ Q ^ ( R ^ ) for 2 < t < 2*. Hence, by (C2), g{x,Un) -^ g{x,u) in Li^(R^)and /
g{x^Un)(j)dx ^
I
g{x^u)(j)dx.
Therefore, H'^{un) • (j) -^ H'^{u) • (j) for every (j) G E^^.
D
Lemma 4.21. Assume (C2). Then there exist b > 0, r > 0 such that Hx{u) > 6 > 0 ,
\/ue
E^with \\u\\^ = r , V A G [1,2].
Proof. This is obvious.
D
Lemma 4.22. Assume (C2)- Then there exist R> r > O^d > 0 such that sup Hx = 0
and
dM
sup Hx < d < 00 M
for all A G [1,2], where M:={u
= y^sz^:yeE-,\\u\\^
0}, ZQ G ^ + , ||zo|U = 1-
Proof. For u = y -\- SZQ, by (C2), Hx{u)<-^\\zo\\l-h\y\\l-^
f
ly + szo^dx.
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
83
Since E/^ is continuously embedded in I/^(R^), for /i < t < 2*, we see that there exists a continuous projection from the closure of E~ 0 R z o in Z/^(R^) to HZQ. Thus, 15^01^ ^ c\y -\- 5Zo|^ for some c > 0. Hence Hx{u)
that supil^A < d < oo.
D
M
Combining Lemmas 4.21-4.22 and Theorem 4.3, we get L e m m a 4.23. Assume (Co), (Ci)-(C2). exists {un} C Efj such that sup||i^nlU < ^ '
^xi^n)
For almost every A G [1,2] there
-^ 0 and Hx{un) -^ cx e [b,d].
Lemma 4.24. Suppose (Co), (Ci)-(C^), A G [1,2]. For a hounded sequence {un} C En satisfying lim Hx{un) G [b^d] and lim H'^{un) = 0, ^/lere exists a ux ^ 0 such that H^-^{ux) = 0, Hx{ux) < d. Proof. Write Un = u^ ^u^ with i^+ G ^ + , i^^ ^ F^ . Since sup | then sup ||i^^||£; < oo. If {u^} is vanishing, that is lim sup then by Lemma 4.19, u^ and Holder's inequality.
/
\u'^\'^dx = 0,
0 < i? < oo.
0 in L^(R^) for 2 < t < 2*. Therefore, by (C2)
g{x,Un)u:^dx\ IM-1U/+ i^^|(ix
< C R^
Since
< OO,
84
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
and lim H'y^(un) = 0, we see that ||i^^||£; -^ 0. Consequently,
^AK) 0, R > 0 such that lim /
|i^+p(ix > Q^ > 0.
Hence, we may find a ^^ G Z ^ such that lim /
\v:^\'^dx>a>
0,
where '^^(x) := u^{x -\- y^)• By the periodicity, the set {v^ := Un{x -\- yn)} ^^ still bounded and lim Hx{vn) e [b,d],
lim i / ^ K ) = 0.
Since sup ||i;n||^ < oo,
sup \\vn\\E < oo,
we have sup||i;+||£; < oo, sup||i;~||£; < oo. We may assume that v^ ^- u'j^, v~ ^- u^ in E^. Since E^ is compactly embedded in L\^^(BJ^) for 2 < t < 2*, it means that {)
lim / ^ ^ ^
\v^\^dx=
i
JB{0,2R)
\uX\^ dx < \uX\l, JB{0,2R)
i.e., i^J ^ 0, ux := i^J + i^^ ^ 0. To prove H^^{ux) = 0, it suffices to check that H^~^{ux) • (/) = 0 for any (j) G C ^ ( R ^ ) . In fact, by Lemma 4.17, v^ -^ ux strongly in L[^^(R^) for 2 < t < 2*. Thus, {g{x, Vn)(l) - g{x, ux)(l))dx -^ 0, and then H'^{v,,)-ci^-H'^{ux)'cl^
-A / ^0,
{g{x,Vn)
-g{x,ux))(l)dx
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
85
i.e., that H^^{ux) = 0. Finally, by (C3) and Fatou's Lemma, we have that Hx{ux)
= Hx{ux) - -H'^{ux) • ^A <
lim {Hx{Vn) -
=
lim Hx{vn)
-H'y^{Vn) • Vn)
< d.
n Lemma 4.25. Assume (Co), (Ci)-(C^). Then there exist {\n\ C [1,2], {zn} C ^^\{0} such that Xn -^ l,H^-^^{zn) = 0 and Hx^{zn) < d. Proof. This is a straightforward consequence of Lemma 4.23 and Lemma 4.24. D Lemma 4.26. Assume (CQ), (Ci)-(C^).
Then {z^} is bounded in E^.
Proof. Write Zji ^ z^^ -\- z^ with z+ G ^ + , z~ e E~. Since H(^^{zn) • ^n = 0, (4.39)
| | 4 l l | - A n | k n l l l = An /
g{x,z^)z^dx
> c\z^l^^.
Hence,
(4.40)
k„|^
\\Z-\\E
\Z-\^
We just have to show that {H^-^H^;} is bounded. By (C4), let SQ > 0 he such that 70 — £0 > 2. Hence, there exists an i?o > 0 such that (4.41)
g{x, u)u > (70 - So)G{x, u)
for all X G R ^ and |i^| < R^. By (C5), there exists an Ri > RQ such that g{x^u)u — 2G{x,u) > c\u\^ for ah X e K^ and |i^| > Ri. Noting (Cs), we may choose a c > 0 small enough such that (4.42)
g{x, u)u - 2G{x, u) > c|^|^
for all X G R ^ and |i^| > RQ. Since Hx^{zn) < d and H'^^ {zn) = 0, we have that
(J--^)(ll4ll|-An||^-|||) 1
70-^0 +An
/
(
g{x, Zn)Zn - G{x, Zn) ) dx
86
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Hence, by (4.41) and {C2)-{Cs), we see that
ll4ll|-An||^-|||
+ / ( G{X, Zn) J\z^\>RoJ \
I G{X, Zn) J\z^\>Ro \
g{x, Zn)Zn I dx 70-^0 J
)/ ^
7o-^o
g{x, Zn)Zn ) dx 70-^0 J
g{x, Zn)Zndx
J\Z^\>RQ
\Zn\^dx. J\z^\>Ro
Moreover, H\^{zn) — -H'^^{zn) - Zn < d and (C3) and (4.42) imply that >
/
l-g{x,Zn)Zn-G{x,Zn)jdx
> c/
\zXdx.
J\z^\>Ro
Without loss of generality, we may assume 2* < 00. In particular, since /i < 2*/i(/i-2) ^^ ^ 2*/i-2*c^ < /i, we may assume a < a. Choose t := G 2 , 2*/i — 2* — /i 2*/i — afi (0,1). By Holder's inequality and Lemma 4.17, we have that /
IZn^dx (l-t)/x
<
/
i^nr
\i|2„|>iJo
^
t^x
/
/
1^.
2* \
\J\z„\>Ro
< c\Zn\f,
^1
\^n\' < Il4ll|-An|k-| <
C^ C
\Zn\^dx
J\z^\>Ro
<
c^cWz^C,
4.4. SCHRODINGER
EQUATIONS
WITH 0 G SPECTRUM
87
that is, \zn\,^ < c + c||z+|||;. Further, noting that H'^{zn) • ^^ = 0, we see by {C2) that \z.n
<
WE
c
<
\z.
IM-1U+ z^\dx
c{c^c\\zi\\\Y-'\\zi\\E + l|t(M-l) + l C\\ZZ\\E^C\\Z^\\E
<
Then sup H^^H^; < 00 since t(/i — 1) + 1 < 2.
D
P r o o f of T h e o r e m 4.15. First, we mention that although Theorem 4.3 was built in a Hilbert, it is still true in a reflexive Banach space (cf. M. Willem-W. Zou [378]). We now prove that \\Z^\\E > O {). We flrst note that |z^|^ < ll^nll^, 141^ < 11411^. By (4.39), \\z-\\l < c | | 4 | | | and \z^\^^ < c | | 4 | | | . By (C2) and Holder's inequality. It//,
Zj^
j Zn^
HJILJ
R^
r^\z+\dx
< C /R^
< c(\\z.
^;:iir' + knir')1411^ 2(M-1)
+ lx
It follows that
4111
, /
g{x,Zn)z:^dx
< ci\\z+\r^ + \\z+\\^^ ). Since /i > 2, we have that 0 < c < ||4ll£^ ^ ^Now we show that { 4 } i^ nonvanishing. If { 4 } ^^ vanishing, we see that g{x,Zn)z^dx
-^ 0. Hence ||4ll£^ ~^ ^^ which contradicts the conclusion
JR^
which we have obtained. By standard arguments, there exist a > 0, R > 0,
88
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
i/n G Z ^ such that hm /
\uj^\'^dx > a > 0,
^ ^ ^ J5(0,2i?)
where cj+(x) := z+(x + y^). Set u;-{x) := z-{x + y^), 6J~(x). Then sup p n | U < oo. Assume that (4.43)
uo^ -^ cj^,
uo~ -^ uj~^
Zn -^ ^'^ + ^~ '= z* in ^ ^ .
Note that Ej^ is imbedded compactly in Lf^^(Il^). Z * ,6J, .,+ cj^ strongly in I/J^Q^(R^). Hence, /
\uj~^\'^dx > a > 0,
Zn{x) := cj+(x) +
Thus we have z^ -^
Zn{x) -^ z^{x) a.e. x G R
and it follows that z* ^ 0. Furthermore, since ||i^||^ < 1, we have \\U\\E < 1 for ah u G ^ ^ . Thus, for any h e E* (the dual space of E), h \E^^ ^^, the dual space of Ej^. Hence, 6J+ ^ 6J+, uj~ -^ uj~ in E. By combining H'^^{zn) = 0 and Lebesgue's Theorem, -i7^(z*).(^ = H'^Sz^)^c^-H'{z^)^c^
Xn{g{x,Zn) -
for any
g{x,z*))(i)dx
cf) G C^(R^), i.e., H^z"") = 0 .
Proof of Theorem 4.16. We merely check that ^(x, i^) = (3\u\^~'^u^ satisfies the assumptions of the theorem with ^^ = JJL = a.
D f{x^u) D
Notes and Comments. The equation —Ai^ + V{x)u = / ( x , u) + Ai^, where V is periodic and A lies in the gap of the spectrum (j{S) of S := —A + V^ was first discussed in H. P. Heinz [180, 181] where a nontrivial solution was obtained by using the linking theorem in V. Benci-P. H. Rabinowitz [55]. In particular, he showed that bifurcation may occur. Heinz's approach was subsequently refined in H. P. Heinz-T. Kiipper-C. A. Stuart [182], H. P. HeinzC. A. Stuart [183] and B. Buffoni-L. Jeanjean [73] (and L. Jeanjean [192]). In B. Buffoni-L. Jeanjean-C.A. Stuart [74], they developed an alternative approach which may eliminate the compactness condition. The first result
4.5. THE CASE OF CRITICAL SOBOLEV EXPONENTS
89
assuming that zero is an end point of the spectrum is due to T. BartschY. Ding [34] where the Ambrosetti-Rabinowitz superquadratic condition is essential to their arguments. In B. Buffoni-L. Jeanjean-C. A. Stuart [74] it was assumed that min cr(6') > 0. In A. Alama-Y. Li [5, 6], 0 hes in a gap of the spectrum cr(—A + V) and G{x,u) := J^ g{x,s)ds is strictly convex. Without either the convexity or the compactness condition, C. Troestler-M. Willem [372] got a nontrivial solution by a generalized linking theorem due to H. Hofer-K. Wysocki [188]. W. Kryszewski-A. Szulkin [201] obtained one nontrivial solution by establishing a new degree theory and a new linking theorem. By an approximation technique without the new degree, A. A. Pankov-K. Pfliiger [273] also got a similar result for superlinear cases. In H. Zhou [384], V{x) = constant > 0 and g{x,t) = f{x,t)t with f{x,t) = f{\x\,t). For this case, the working space possesses a compactness of imbedding. In T. Bartsch-A. Pankov-Z. Q. Wang [39], Schrodinger equations with a steep potential well which depends on a parameter were studied (see also F. A. van Heerden [370], F. A. van Heerden-Z. Q. Wang [371]). A. Szulkin-W. Zou [361] were the first to consider the asymptotically linear case (including homoclinic orbits of Hamiltonian systems), when 0 lies in a gap of {—A-\-V). The main results of this section are due to M. Willem-W. Zou [378]. When 0 G cr(—A + V), more problems are still open.
4.5
The Case of Critical Sobolev Exponents
Consider the following Schrodinger equation with critical Sobolev exponent and periodic potential: (SEs)
- A ^ + V{x)u = T{x)\uf-^u
+ g{x,u),
u e ly^'^(R^),
where N > 4; 2* := 2N/{N — 2) is the critical Sobolev exponent and g is of subcritical growth. 0;V,T,g
(Di) y , T G C ( R ^ , R ) , ^ G C(R^ X R,R),A:o := inf^^R^ T(x) > are 1-periodic in Xj for j = 1,..., A^.
(D2) 0 ^ cr(-A + V) and cr(-A -^ V) n (-00, 0) ^ 0, where a denotes the spectrum in I/^(R^). (D3) T(xo) := max T(x) and T(x) — T(xo) = o(\x — XQP) as
X
^
XQ
and
V{xo) < 0. (D4) \g{x,u)\ < co(l + \u\P-^) for ah {x,u) G R ^ x R, where CQ > 0 and p G (2,2*). Further, g{x,u)/\u\'^*~'^ ^ 0 as i^ ^ 0 uniformly for x G R ^ .
90
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE SOLUTIONS
(D5) g{x, u)u > 0 for all x G R ^ and u j^ 0. Theorem 4.27. Suppose that (DiJ-fD^) hold. If ^ A A A\
^0
(4.44)
N —2
— >
g(x,u)u
,
rrig
where
rria : =
2
"^
max
—•—-7-—,
a;GR^,iiGR\{0}
\u\^
then equation (SE^) has a solution u j^ 0. In particular, if T{x) = ko > 0, (Ds) can be dropped and the same result holds. Does Theorem 4.27 remain true for A^ = 3? This is still open. It is worth noting that the equation (4.45)
-Au^Xu=\uf-'^u,
A^O,
has only the trivial solution i^ = 0 in VF^'^(R^) (cf. V. Benci-G. Cerami [53]). Under the hypotheses on V, the spectrum of —A -\- V in I/^(R^) is purely continuous and bounded below and is the union of disjoint closed intervals (cf. Theorem XIII. 100 of M. Reed-B. Simon [301]). The following example satisfies the conditions of Theorem 4.27. . . _ J c\u\'^*u g[x,u).-<^ f(^+|^|-2/3^)
\u\ < 1, 1^1 > 1 .
Let E := VF^'^(R^). It is well known that there is a one-to-one correspondence between solutions of (SEs) and critical points of the C^{E, R)-functional (4.46)
^{u)
:=
I [ ~ ^ ^
{\Vuf^V{x)u^)dx /
^{x)\u\'^*dx-
JR^
/
G{x,u)dx.
JR^
Let {^(A)}AGR be the spectral family of - A + V in ^^(R^). Let E' ^ ( 0 ) L 2 n ^ a n d ^ + := {id-E{0))L'^nE.
Then the quadratic form /
:=
(|Vi^p+
Vv?)dx is positive definite on E^ and negative definite on E~. We can introduce a new inner product (•, •) in ^ such that the corresponding norm || • || is equivalent to || • ||i^2, the usual norm of VF^'^(R^). Moreover, /
(|Vi^p +
JR^
Vu^)dx = ||i^+f - \\u-f, where u^ G E^. Then the functional (4.46) can be rewritten as (4.47)
^u)
= l\\u+f-l\\u-f-^f I
l
l
T{x)\ufdx-f JYIN
G{x,u)dx. JYIN
4.5. THE CASE OF CRITICAL SOBOLEV EXPONENTS
91
In order to use Theorem 4.3, we introduce a family of functionals defined by (4.48) $A(n) = i | | u + f - A ( i | | u - f + l Z
\Z
/
T{x)\ufdx+f
Z J YIN
G{x,u)dx) J YIN
/
for AG [1,2]. Lemma 4.28. ^x is \ - l^-upper semicontinuous. continuous.
^^ is weakly sequentially
Proof. Noting that Un := u~ -\- u^^ -^ u implies that Un ^ u weakly in E and 1^+ -^ u~^ strongly in E, thus we see that the proof is the same as that in the previous section. D Lemma 4.29. Assume that V G I / ^ ( R ^ ) (it need not be periodic). for each /i G R there exists a constant c = c{jii) such that \\u\\g < c{^i)\\u\\2,
Then
\/ueE{fx)L^
where q = 2N/{N — 4) if N > A ( q may he taken arbitrarily large if N = A and q = oo if N < A). Proof. Since {^(A)}AGR is the spectral family of —A -^ V in I/^(R^), we have for a fixed /i G R, that E{jii)L'^ is the subspace of L^ corresponding to A < /i. Note that ( - A + X^)U(^)L2 : E{fi)L^ ^
E{fi)L^
is bounded. Let F be a positively oriented smooth Jordan curve enclosing the spectrum of (—A + V)\E{fx)L^' According to formula (in.6.19) of T. Kato [198] (and J. Chabrowski-A. Szulkin [88, Proposition 2.2]): - — [ {-A^V 27Ti JY
-X)-\dX,
ueE{fi)L'^.
Since V is compact and — A + y — A is invertible for each A G F, we obtain the conclusion by the Sobolev embedding theorem. D
Let S •=
inf
^ ^
be the best Sobolev constant, see Chapter 1. Let ^s{x) :--
(£2 + | x | 2 ) ( ^ - 2 ) / 2 ^
92
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
where N = {N{N - 2))(^-2)/4,£ > 0 and ^ G C ^ ( R ^ , [0,1]) with ^{x) = 1 if \x\ < r/2; ^{x) = 0 if \x\ > r^r sufficiently small. Write 'ds = '^t ~^ '^7 ^^^^ i^t ^ E+,d- e E-. Then by Proposition 1.15,
L e m m a 4.30. Set (4.49)
h{u) := i||^.+ f - i | | « - f " ^ ^ ^ T{x)\uf
dx,
ueE.
Then supii < c :
iV||T||(^-2'/2
/or £ sufficiently small, where Z^ := E~ 0 R'^JProof. We first show that
(4.50)
C, :=
sup
a
/
(|V^p + Vu^)dx < \ 1/2*
T(x)|i^P (ixj
. Note that
R^
l^^{\\/^j\'^V{^jf)dx<0. Then by Proposition 1.15,
/
\v^:\'dx
as £ ^ 0. This implies that
For u ^ Zs with
||I^||2*,T
= 1, we write u = u~ -\- s'd~ -\- si^^.
Then there exists a c > 0 such that ||^"||2*
^
^||(N-2)/iV'
4.5. THE CASE OF CRITICAL SOBOLEV EXPONENTS
93
By convexity, lklli:,T
>
(4.51)
\\s^e\\i:,r
>
+r
[
{S^ef-'u-dx
\\s^sf2:,r-c\mi:zi\\u-h.
By Lemma 4.29,
=0{s^^-'y')\\u-\\2.
In (Ds) we may, without loss of generality, choose XQ = 0. Then V{x) < —c < 0 for 5 G supping. Hence, (4.53)
/
-c£2, -c£'^\ln£\,
Vi^ldx < I
AT > 5, AT = 4,
for some c > 0. Furthermore, by the assumption on T in (-D3), we have (4.54)
||^,"2*
^£||2*,T
= ||T||oo/
^fdx+
>/R«
{T{x)-T{0))^fdx JRJV
= ||T||^5^/2 + o(£2). If Af > 5, by (4.50)-(4.54), we have
<
-
/R^(iv^^i^+^^g)^^
(11 di.Mr-^ii.-iL)^/^-
||T||r^)/^5(^-^)/2+o(e2)^'+'"^^"^^-^"" "'^ - c | | n - f + 0(e(^-2)/^)||u-|b
where c* > 0. Then we get (4.50) . If A^ = 4, the proof is similar. If i^ ^ 0, then N/2
(4.55)
(j^N{\^u\^^Vu^)dx max/(ti^) = -^ t>0
-
'
'
/
\ (A^-2)/2
N(j^,T\urdx)
94
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
as long as the denominator is positive. By (4.50) and (4.55), we obtain the conclusion of this lemma. D Lemma 4.31. Suppose that g{x^u)/u ^ 0 as |i^| ^ 0 uniformly for x G R ^ and that g is of subcritical Sobolev exponential growth. If a bounded sequence {wn} C E andXn G [1,2] satisfy Xn -^ A, ^'^^{wn) -^ 0, ^x^{wn) -^ c(A), where 0 < c(X) < cX :=
nrr^^^vTTT, then iwn} is nonvanishinq.
Proof. If {wn} is not nonvanishing, then i(;^ ^ 0 in I/^(R^) for 2 < r < 2* by Lemma LI7. Then, (4.56)
/
g{x,Wn)vndx ^ 0 and /
G{x,Wn)dx ^ 0
whenever {vn} C E is bounded. Hence, (4.57)
^xA^n)
-
-{^xAWn),Wn)
= ^ [
T{x)\w^fdx^o{l)
^ c(A). For any (5 > 0, we choose fi > ||y||oo(l + ^)/^- Write Wn = w:^ -\- w~ G E^ 0 E~, and let w:^ = w;^ + z^, with Wn G E{fi)L'^,Zn G {id — E{fi))L'^, where ( ^ ( A ) ) A G R is the spectral family of —A -\- V in L^. By Lemma 4.29, Wn G E and (4.58)
\\w~\\q < C | | ^ ~ | | 2 < Cll^^ll
and
\\Wn\\q < cWWnh
< c\\Wn\\,
where q = 2N/(N — 4) if A^ > 4 and q may be chosen arbitrarily large if N = 4. Therefore,
= -{^xA^n),W~)
-Xn /
- Xn /
T{x)\Wn\'^*~'^WnW~dx
g{x,Wn)w~dx
<2\\T\Uwnf;-^w-\U^o{l) where r satisfies (2* - l ) / r + 1/q = 1, 2 < r < 2*. Similarly, (4.59)
ll'^nll -^ O5
and hence,
Wn — Zn ^ 0.
4.5. THE CASE OF CRITICAL SOBOLEV EXPONENTS
95
Thus,
WW = [
{\Vz^f^Vzl)dx
= Xn
T{x)\Wnf*~'^WnZndx
^ 0{1)
J UN
= Xn
T{x)\Wn\
Since z^ G {id — E{/j.))L'^, we have / (5>0and/i> sf
dx^0{l).
(|Vz^p + Vz'^)dx > /ipn||2- For any
\\V\\^{1^6)/6, [
\Wzn\^dx>6{fi-\\V\U\\zJl>-
Vzldx.
It fohows that, (4.60)
(1-^)/
\Vzn\^dx<j
{\Vzn\^^Vzl)dx.
By (4.59) and (4.60), we have the fohowing estimates: (A /
T{x)\wnfdxf^^*
<{X\\T\U'/''\\wJl = {X\\T\W^''\\zJl^o{l) <{X\\T\U'/''\\VzJl/S^o{l)
Let n ^ oo and use (4.57), it follows that (iVc(A))2/2* <
i m ^ N c i X ) ,
which implies that either c(A) = 0 or c(A) > (1 — 6)^^'^c\. Either way, we get a contradiction since 5 is chosen arbitrarily. D For i? > 0, set Q := {i^ = 1^ + SZQ : ||i^|| < R,u e E ,s e R ^ } , where zo := '^^/ll'^^ll G E^. Let po = SQZQ e Q.SQ > 0. For any u e E, we write
96
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
u = u~ -\- SZQ -\- w with u~ G E~,w G {E~ 0 R Z Q ) ^ , 5 G R. Consider a map F : E ^ E~ 0 Rzo defined by F{u~ + 5Zo + i(;) = i^~ + \\szo + i(;||^o- Let 5 := F-^(po). Then 5 = {i^ = 5Zo +1(; : i(; G (^~ 0 R^o)^, ||^^|| = ^o}. It is easy to check that F,PQ, B satisfy the basic assumptions of Theorem 4.3. Lemma 4.32. For almost all A G [1,2], there exists a {un] G E such that sup \\un\\ < oo,
^'x{un) ^ 0
and
^\{un) -^ Cx,
n
where C\ G [inf ^A? sup^]. Furthermore, there exists a (^o > 0 small enough ^
Q
such that, for almost all X G [1,1 + SQ], there exists a ux j^ 0 such that ^ A ( ^ A ) = 0, ^ A ( ^ A ) < supg ^ . Proof. By hypotheses {D4) and (-D5), there exist i? > 0, 5o > 0, such that inf^A>0,
sup^A<0,
for ah A G [1,2].
dQ
^
The first conclusion follows immediately from Lemmas 4.28, 4.31 and Theorem 4.3. We give the proof for the second conclusion. Since g{x^u)u > 0 and Q C Z^, we get that 0 < CA < s u p ^ < sup/i < c*,
(4.61)
where / i , c* and Z^ come from Lemma 4.30. Therefore, there exists SL 60 > 0 such that 0 < CA < c^ for almost all A G [1,1 + So], where c^ comes from Lemma 4.31. For those A, by Lemma 4.31, {un} is nonvanishing; that is, there exist i/n G R ^ , hi > O^Ri > 0 such that limsup /
\un\'^dx > hi > 0. 1)
We may find a T/^ G Z
such that
limsup/ n^oo
Kfd.>.>0,
JB{0,2RI)
where Vn{x) := Un{x-\-yn)- Since V, T and g are periodic, {vn} is still bounded and therefore, lim ^ A K ) e [inf ^A,sup^],
lim ^ A K ) = 0.
4.5. THE CASE OF CRITICAL SOBOLEV EXPONENTS
97
We may assume that Vn ^ ux. Since E is embedded compactly in I/[^^(R^) for 2 < t < 2*, we have 0 < K. < lim / ^ ^ ^
\vn\'^dx = I
JB{0,2RI)
\ux\'^dx < \ux\ 2JB{0,2RI)
Hence, ux ^ 0. Since ^^ is weakly sequentially continuous, then ^'^{ux) = 0. By Fatou's Lemma,
=
^A(^A)-2(^'A(^A),^A)
= A /
(^-(T(x)I^Ar + ^ ( ^ , ^ A ) ^ A ) - — T ( x ) | ^ A r
= A /
lim (-{T{x)\vn\'^*
<
lim
UxiVn)
< lim
-
-G{x,ux)jdx
^ g{x,Vn)vn) - —-T{x)\vn\'^* -
G{x,Vn))dx
-(^'xiVn),Vn))
^AK)
< sup^. Q
D By Lemma 4.32, we have the following immediate consequence. L e m m a 4.33. There exist X^ G [1,1 + ^o] with A^ ^ 1, and z^ G ^ \ { 0 } such that ^A^ (Zn) = 0,
^A^ (Zn) < SUp ^ .
L e m m a 4.34. T/ie sequence {z^} obtained in Lemma 4-33 is bounded. Proof. Let gi{x,u) := and Gi{x,u) /Tf-1 I O^
lim ^ \ '
:= J^ gi{x,s)ds.
T{x)\u\'^*~'^u^g{x,u) Then by the assumption (-D4), we see that
7/17/
\
= 2*
uniformly for x G R ^ . Let £1 > 0 be such that 2* - £ i >
2. Hence, there exists an i?i > 0 such that (4.62)
gi{x,u)u>
(2* - £i)G'i(x,^),
for x G R ^ , |^| < Ri.
On the other hand, since g{x^ u) is of subcritical growth, we must have that
98
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
gi{x,u)u — 2Gi{x,u)
^^
SOLUTIONS
2 2*^
uniformly for x G R . Furthermore, condition (4.44) implies that 0 < g{x, u)u < 2 * for all x G R^,i^ ^ 0. Hence N -2-k{)\u\^ (4.64)
^i(x,i^)i^-2G'i(x,i^) > 0
for ah x G R ^ , i ^ ^ O .
Therefore, (4.63) and (4.64) imply that there exists a c > 0 small enough, such that (4.65)
gi{x,u)u-2Gi{x,u)
Note that ^\^{zn)
> c\uf
for allx G R ^ , |i^| > Ri.
< s u p ^ and ^^^^{zn) = 0. Then
(^-^73^)(ll4f-An|k-f)
+^^ /
(^
g{x,Zn)Zn-G{x,Zn))dx
J^N V2* -£i <sup^.
(4.66)
J
Q
By (4.62), (4.64) and (4.66), we have that
(^-^7^)(ll4f-An|k-f)
+ /
(Gi{x,Zn) ^
J\z^\>Ri
(-gi{x,Zn)Zn^^
c^c
)(Gi(x,z^)-— - — ^ -^1
gi{x,Zn)Zndx. '\z^\>Ri
— ^ -Si
^i(x,z^)z^)(ix
gi{x,Zn)Zn)dx ^ gi{x,
Zn)Zn)dx ^
4.5. THE CASE OF CRITICAL SOBOLEV EXPONENTS Note by (D^) that \g{x,z)z\ < c\zf that
99
for all {x,z) G R ^ x R. Thus we see
ll4f-An|k-f C^
L
C
L L
c^ c c^ c
gi{x,Zn)z
'f2, UjtJ-^
.\>Ri
[i:{x)\Zn .\>Ri
r^
\Zn\^* dx. .\>Ri
However, (4.64)-(4.65) imply that SUp^
>
= >
>
^Aj^n) -
-{^xA^n),Zr,
/
(^-gi{x,Zn)Zn-Gi{x,Zn)jdx
/ J\z^\>Ri
(-gi{x,Zn)Zn-Gi{x,Zn))dx ^
^^
CI
\Zn?* dx.
'\z^\>Ri
It implies that (4.67)
\\z+f-K\\z-f
Note that (^^ (^^), ^^) = 0. Thus we observe that
ll4f-An||^-f
>c
A^ /
[i:{x)\Znf
/
\Znfdx.
^g{x,Zn)Znjdx
By (4.67), J^j^ \znfdx < c. Note that {^'y^^{zn), z^) = 0. By {D4) and Holder's inequality, we obtain that
Il4f = A„ /
T{x)\Znf'~'^ZnZ:^dx
Kf-'\z+\
+ Xn
g{x,Zn)z'^dx
100
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS D.
Therefore, ||z+|| < c, and hence, ||^~|| < c. L e m m a 4.35. The sequence {zn} is nonvanishing. Proof. Since (zn) is bounded, by (4.61) we may suppose that (4.68)
^Xr^{zn) ^ ci < s u p ^ < c*. Q
If {zn} is not nonvanishing, then it follows from Lemma 1.17 that z^ ^ 0 in L^ as long as 2 < r < 2*. The assumption (1^4) implies that (4.69)
/
g{x, Zn)Zndx ^ 0 ,
/
G{x, Zn)dx -^ 0,
and consequently, (4.70)
^^^{zn) -\{^'xSZn)^Zn)
= ^
f
T{x)\Znf
dx ^ o{l) ^
C^.
Since T(x) > 0, then ci > 0. We distinguish two cases. If ci > 0, then by (4.68) and Lemma (4.31), z^ is nonvanishing. If ci = 0, then (4.70) implies that /
(4.71)
\znfdx^O.
J UN
Since ^^ {z^) = 0, by (-D4), for any £ > 0, we have that v+l|2
JR^
Since ||z-|| < ||z+|| and £ is arbitrary, then c||z+f < c | | z + f + c||z+f*, which implies that ||z+|| > c > 0. But, ^'^^{zn) = 0 and {D4) imply that
Il4f = A„ /
(T{x)\zn\'^''~'^Znz:^
+g{x,Zn)z:^jdx
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
101
Proof of Theorem 4.27. Since {z^} is nonvanishing, we may find r > 0, Q^ > 0 and i/n G R ^ such that (4.72)
limsup /
z^dx > a.
We may assume that i/n G Z ^ by taking r large if necessary. Now set Zn{x) := Zn{x -\- Vn)' Since ^\ is invariant with respect to the translation of x by elements of Z ^ , i.e., ^\{u{')) = ^A('^(* + y)) whenever y G Z ^ , we see that ll^nll = \\Znl
^Aj^n) =
^Aj^n).
Without loss of generality, we may suppose that z^ -^ ^* for a renamed subsequence. Then (4.72) implies that z* ^ 0 and ^'{z*) = 0. D Notes and Comments. Note that equation (SEs) was studied in J.Chabrowski-A.Szulkin [88], which also generalized the early results obtained in J.Chabrowski-J.Yang [90, 91]. Lemma 4.29 was obtained in J. ChabrowskiA. Szulkin [88]. Lemma 4.30 was due to J. Chabrowski-A. Szulkin [88] based on M. Willem [377]. Equation (SE^) with T(x) = 0, i.e., the nonlinear term is of subcritical growth, has been studied by several authors, for example, S. Alama-Y. Li [5, 6], T. Bartsch-Y. Ding [34], B. Buffoni-L. Jeanjean [74], V. C. Zelati-P. Rabinowitz [117], L. Jeanjean [191, 192], W.Kryszewski-A. Szulkin [201], C. Troestler-M. Willem [372], M. Willem [377]. In Y. Y. Li [224], the author studied a special case —Ai^ = Ti^^ in R^ (see also Y. Y. Li [225] for a higher dimension case on S^). Theorem 4.27 was established by M. Schechter-W. Zou [328]. Without periodicity, the first result on the Dirichlet boundary value with critical Sobolev exponents was due to H. Brezis-L. Nirenberg [71]. See also J. G. Azorero-L P. Alonso [23], H. Berestycki-P. L. Lions [58], D. Cao-S. Peng [78], G. Cerami-S. Solimini-M. Struwe [87], D. G. Costa-E. A. B. Silva [115], A. Ferrero-F. Gazzola [155], J. P. Garcia AzoreroL Peral Alonso [169], N. Ghoussoub-C. Yuan [172], S. Li-W. Zou [221], P. L. Lions [228], D. Ruiz-M. Willem [304] and E. A. B. Silva-M. S. Xavier [342].
4.6
Schrodinger Systems
Consider the Schrodinger system dfU — AxU -\- V{x)u = Wy{t, X, u, v), (SE4)
; -dfV - AxV + V{x)v = Wu{t, X, u, v),
102
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
where {t,x) G R x R ^ , V : R ^ ^ R and l y : R x R ^ x R ^ ^ ^ R are periodic in t and x. We are interested in finding the non-stationary solution z = {u,v) iKxIl^ ^ R 2 ^ of (6'^4) satisfying z{t, x) ^ 0 as \t\ + \x\ -^ oo. Throughout this section, we need the fohowing basic conditions on V and W. (V) V G C(R^, R) and V is T^-periodic in Xj for j = 1 , . . . , AT; 0 ^ cr(-A^ + V), where a denotes the purely continuous spectrum of — A^^ + V. (W) W G C^(R X R ^ X R 2 ^ , R ) is To-periodic in t and T^-periodic in Xj, j = 1 , . . . , AT. W{t, x,z)>0 for ah (t, x, z), z = {u, v) G R ^ ^ .
4.6.1
The Superlinear Case
We need the following assumptions. (El) Wz{t,x,z)
= o{\z\) SiS z ^ 0 uniformly in t and x.
(E2) \Wz{t,x,z)\ < c\z\^ for ah {t,x) and \z\ > Ro, where Ro > O^fi > 0 are constants, 1 < /i < (A^ + 4)/A^. (E3) ^ i y ^ ( t , x , z ) z - i y ( t , x , z ) >c\z\f^ for ah (t,x,z), where
T h e o r e m 4.36. Assume that {Ei)-{Es) hold. Then {SE4) has at least one nontrivial solution. In the next case, the potential satisfies local conditions both at zero and at infinity. (Fi) There exist z/ > p > 2, z/ < {2N + 4)/Ar, ci, C2, C3 > 0 such that c i k r < W.(^,^,^)^ < \W,{t,x,z)\\z\
< C2\z\^ ^ cs\z\P
for ah (t, X, z) G R X R ^ X R ^ ^ . (F2) W^{t,x,z)z-2W{t,x,z)
>0
for ah {t,x,z)
^ (0,0,0).
(F3) There exists a 70 > 2 such that liminf —TTT^—^—^ > 7o \z\^oo
W{t,X,z)
-
^
uniformly for (t, x) G R x R ^ . ^
^ ' ^
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
103
(F4) There exists an o^ > p such that ^Wz(t,x,z)z — 2W(t,x,z) ^ , . / X -r^ -r^/\r hminf ^ \ , ^ ' ' ^ > c > 0 uniformly for (t,x) G R x R ^ .
Theorem 4.37. Assume that {Fi)-{F4) hold. Then {SE4) has at least one nontrivial solution.
Let
and A := Jo(—A^^ + y ) . Then {SE4) can be rewritten as JdfZ = —Az -\Wz{t^x^z) for z = (u^v). In this way, {SE4) can be regarded as an unbounded infinite dimensional Hamiltonian system in I/^(R^, R ^ ^ ) . Let HQ := L 2 ( R ^ , R 2 ^ ) with the inner product {\J\'^^w, \J\^l^v), Then D{A) = V{JA)
here \J\ =
{-J^f^.
= W^^^ n iyo'^(R^, R^^) and H := L^(R,Ho)
L 2 ( R X R ^ , R 2 ^ ) . Let S = - A ^
=
+ V.
Lemma 4.38. //O ^ cr(-A^ + V), ^/len 0 ^ cr(^) U cr(J'^). Proof. Assume that 0 ^ cr(jr.4). Then there exists z^ = {un^Vn) G ^(^^^4) such that Iknll^ = ll^nll^ + Ibnll^ = 1,
\\JAZr,\\l
= \\Sujl
+ \\Svjl
^
0.
Then, we may assume that ||i^n||2 > c > 0. Let Un := -r.—^. Then ||6'iZn||2 -^ O5 ||'^n||2 = 1- It follows that 0 G cr(6'). This is a contradiction. Similarly, we have 0 ^ cr(^). D Let L = J^t + v4 be the selfadjoint operator on H with domain
V{L) = {ze and norm
iy^'2(R,^o) : z{t) G P(A), / ||^z(t)|||^(it < 00}
104
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
By Lemma 4.38, 0 ^ cr{JA). Then there are r < 0, p > 0 such that (r, p) H crisJA) = 0. Sphtting according to the positive and negative spectrum, we have Let P^ : HQ -^ HQ be the orthogonal projections and {^(A) : A G R } be the spectral family of J A. Then dE(\),
P+ = /
dE{\).
P- = / J — oc
Jp
Set
OO
J{JA) _ I C/(t)=e*^^-^^ = /
^tA, e'^'dEiX). -oo
Then \\U{t)p-U{s)-^\\n
< e-''(*-'*)
for t > s;
\\Uit)P+Uis)-'\\n
< e-''^^-*)
for t < s;
where 0 = min{—r, p}. Lemma 4.39. 0 ^ cr{L). Proof. If it were not true, then there would exist a i^^ G T){L) with ||i^n||2 = 1 and ||I/i^^||2 ^ 0 as n ^ oo. Hence, dtUn = JAun — JLu^ and Un{t)
=
-
I J — oo oo
/
U{t)P-U{s)-^JLUn{s)ds
U(t)P"'U{s)-^JLun{s)ds.
Let (f ^ : R ^ R be the characteristic function of RQ and oo
U{t)P^U{s)-^i'^{t / Then
-
s)JLun{s)ds.
-OO
oo J — OO
If we let C^{t) = e=F^*C=^(t), we have
where * denotes convolution. Note that / ^ C^dt = 1/0, by the convolution inequality. Thus
\\ut\\2<\\Luj2/e^o
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
105
as n ^ oo. This is impossible since Un = u~ ^u^.
D
By Lemma 4.39, there is an associated orthogonal decomposition H = 7Y~ 0 Ti'^^z = z~ + z+, where z^ G 7Y^, such that L is positive in 7Y^ and negative in 7Y~. Furthermore, by Lemma 4.39, there exists a 7 > 0 such that [—7,7] n CF{L) = 0. Let {G^(A)}AGR be the spectral family of L and U = 1 — 2G{0) be the unitary isomorphism of H and L = U\L\ = \L\U. From A2d(G(A)2,z)i2 + / -00
A2d(G(A)2,z)i2 >
j^zg,
«/7
we see that \\Lz\\l<\\z\\l
+
\\Lz\\l<{l+^-^)\\Lz\\l
Hence, V{L) is a Hilbert space with inner product {U,V)L
=
{LU,LV)L2.
For r > 1, we introduce the anisotropic space B^: Bj,
= =
Bj^i^ri. X R , R j iy^'^(R, L^(R, R 2 ^ ) ) n L^(R, ly^'^ n i^o'"^(R, R ^ ^ ) )
with the norm
([
N
{\u\'^\dtu\'^y\diundxdt
1/
L e m m a 4.40. V{L) ^ L^(R x R ^ , R 2 ^ ) for any r > 2 if N = 1,2 and for r G [2, 2{N + 2)/{N - 2)] if N > 2. In particular, V{L) ^ ^ LlocC^ x R ^ , R 2 ^ ) /or any r > 2 if N = 1,2 and for r G [2, 2(Ar + 2)/(Ar - 2)) if N >2. Proof. Let u,v e C^(R) and z,i(; G If we integrate by parts, we obtain
C^(R,R2^).
{{dtu)Jz,
V • ^i(;) + ((i^ • ^ ^ ,
{dtu)vdt\ ( I
{Jz,Aw)dx\
RxR^
/R
(4.73)
= 0.
Note that J^A
u{dtv)dt\ ( I ^ ^Jn^
{Jw,Az)dx\
=
{^tv)Jw)^dtdx
A^J.
106
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Let Co^(R)(g)Co^(R,R2^) n
= [^u,v,
: n e N,u, G C^{Il),v, G C O ^ ( R , R 2 ^ ) } .
i=l
Then for any z in C^(R) (g)C^(R, R ^ ^ ) , by (4.73), n
RxR^
=
Il^t^ll2+M^ll2.
Since C^(R) (g) C^(R, R ^ ^ ) is dense in V{L) = B2, the above identity holds for all z G 1){L). Hence, we may find ci, C2 > 0 such that
Clll^b, <|k|U
D
Let ^ := P(|I/|^/^) be equipped with the inner product
and norm \\z\\ = {z^z)^!^. We have the decomposition E = E^ 0 E~^ where E^ = E n TC^ are orthogonal with respect to both (•, •)L2 and (•,•). Lemma 4.41. E ^ L^(R x R ^ , R 2 ^ ) for any r > 2 if N = 1 and for r G [2, 2(Ar + 2)/N] if N >2. In particular, E ^ ^ L^oci^ x R ^ , R ^ ^ ) /^^ a n ^ r > 2 i/A^ = 1 and for r G [2, 2 (AT + 2)/AT) i/AT > 2. Proof. Note that
E:=V{\L\'/^)^[V{L),L\i2, where [•^•]s represents complex interpolation. By Lemma 4.40,
E^[U,L\i2^L^ for r = 00 if AT = 2; r = 2{N + 2)/{N - 2) if AT > 3 and ^ = 2{N + 2)/N. For 2 < r < g', we have, using Holder's inequality, that \\z\\r < ||^||2~^||^||Q with
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
107
s = q{r- 2)/r{q - 2). That is, E ^ U ioi r e [2, 2{N + 2)/N]. By Lemma 4.40 again, E ^ ^ U for r G [2, 2{N + 2)/Ar). The case of AT = 1 is trivial. D
Let H{z) := i ( | | z + f - \\z-f)
- f
W{t,x,z)dtdx.
Then by standard arguments, H G C^{E,IV) and the critical points of H are weak solutions of (6'^4). To study {SE4), we consider
Hx{z):=h\z+f-x(hz-f+
[
W{t,x,z)dtdx
for a h ^ G ^ , A G [1,2]. L e m m a 4.42. For almost all A G [1, 2], there exist 6 > 0, {z^} C E such that sup\\zn\\
H'^{zn)^^,
Hx{zn) ^ Cx ^ [b, d],
as u ^ oo,
n
where d := supg H, Q := {z = z~ -\- SZQ : 5 G R+, z~ G E~, \\z\\ < RQ}. Proof. By (^1) and (^2), for any £ > 0, there exists a C^ > 0 such that W{t,x,z) < s\z\^ ^ Cs\z\^+K Therefore, A^ll^+lli - ^.ll^+li;::i > ^ > 0, VA G [1, 2] Hx{z^) >l\\z^ffor 6 > 0 and z e B := {z : z e E^^ \\z\\ = r^}. The constants h and TQ are independent of A. On the other hand, by (^1) and (^3), W{t,x,z) > c\z\^ for all (t^x^z). Then for a fixed ZQ G E~^ with ||zo|| = 1 and z = z~ -\- SZQ, we have Hx{z) < -s^ - - | | ^ " f - c\\z\f^ < 0 for z G A := dQ, where Q := {z = z~ +5^0 : 5 G R+, z~ G E~^ \\z\\ < R^} and R^ large enough. Moreover, it is easy to check that Hx is | • 1^^-upper semicontinuous and H'^^ is weakly sequentially continuous. By Theorem 4.3, we get this lemma. D L e m m a 4.43. For almost all A G [1,2], there exists an wx such that H'-^{wx) = 0,Hx{wx)
Izi'l'^dtdx > a > 0, lB{y^,l)
108
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
where B{y, r) denotes the bah centered at y with radius r. Similar to the proof of Lemma 1.17, we have that z+ ^ 0 in L^(Ri+^) for 2 < t < {2N + A)/N. By (^i) and (^2), for any £ > 0, there exists a C^ > 0 such that Wz{t^ X, Zn)z^dtdx <£
: /
\zn\\z^\dtdx^Cs
j R l + Af
[
\znr\z^\dtdx,
j R l + Af
and the left-hand side converges to 0. Therefore, 2H,{Zr,)
< =
||4f H'^{Zr^)zl^\
W,{t,X,Zn)z^tdx^^O,
which is a contradiction and our claim is true. We may assume that there exist an r > 0, independent of n, and a y* := {yo,yi,...,yN)
G TQZ x . . . x TNZ
such that /
\z:^\'^dtdx>a/2,
where By periodicity, {zn} is also bounded and moreover lim Hx{zn) e [b,di lim H'^izn) = 0. Without loss of generality, we may suppose that z+ -^ w^, z~ -^ w^. The compactness of the embedding of ^ + into L[^^(R^+^) for 2 < t < 2{N^2)/N implies that w1^ ^ 0, and it follows that wx := w^ -\- w^ ^ 0. Evidently, i 7 ; ( ^ A ) = 0 . Finally, Hx{wx) = X
lim
= lim Hx{zn)
(-Wz{t,x,Zn)'Zn-W{t,x,Zn))dtdx
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
109
L e m m a 4.44. There exist Xn ^ l^Wn ^ 0 such that Hx^ (wn) < d, H'^ (wn) = 0. Moreover, {wn} is bounded. Proof. By Lemma 4.43, we have only to prove the boundedness of {wn}Since Hx^{Wn)
- -{Hx^{Wn),Wn)
< d,
by condition (^3) we see that \wn\^dtdx < c. R l + AT
By (^2)-(^3), we can suppose /3 < /i + L Thus, /
\Wn\^''^dtd', 2X ( l - t o ) ( l + /x)
'
\wnfdtdx)
^
A^to(/x+l)
(
\wn\^^^^
dtdx)
< cWWr, |(M+l)to
11'^^iP
<
cs
\wn\\w^\dtdx -\- c /
<
\wn\^\w^\dtdx
ce\\wtf+\\wtr+\
Note that tofi -\-1 < 2. We can therefore conclude that both {w^} and {wn} are bounded. D Proof of Theorem 4.36. Since H(^ {w^) = 0, we see that ||i(;+|p
=
K
<
c /
<
ce\\wtf
Wz{t,x,Wn)w^dtdx {e\Wn\^Ce\Wn\^)\w^\dtdx
+
c\\w+r+\
Therefore, \\w^\\ > c > 0. By the Concentration Compactness Lemma L17, we know that there exist an £0 > 0 and a sequence {yn} C R^+^ such that lim /
\w'^\dtdx > £0 > 0-
no
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
By standard arguments, there exists a z* = z+ + z~ such that z+ ^ 0 and H\z*) = 0 . D
Proof of Theorem 4.37. Under the hypotheses (Fi)-(F4), the conclusions of Lemmas 4.42-4.44 are stih true. It suffices to show that {wn} in Lemma 4.44 is bounded. Note that (4.74)
l l ^ + f - A ^ l l ^ - f = A^ /
W,{t,x,Wn)wndtdx
>
c\\wnt.
By (F3), there exist RQ > 0, SQ > 0 such that ro — £0 > 2 and (4.75)
Wz{t,x,Wn)wn
> (ro - £o)W{t,x,Wn)
for \wn\ > Ro-
By (F2) and (F4), there exists a c > 0 such that (4.76)
W,{t,X,Wr^)Wr^-2W{t,X,Wr^)>c\wX
for
\Wr^\ < RQ.
Note that H\^{wn) < d, H'^ (wn) = 0, we see that
il--^)i\\y^if-^n\\w-f) +A„ /
(
JRI+N
)(Wz{t,X,Wn)Wn-W{t,X,Wn))dtdx ro - £
V
By ( F i ) ,
+[
^+ C/
)(Ty(t,x,z.„)-^-(;'"'"")"")citd.
(iy(t,X,^^)
W^{t,X,Wn)Wn)c
Wz{t,X,Wn)Wndtdx J\w^\
{{Wnl""
^\Wnf)dtdx.
J\w^\
Recah that H\^{wn) — \H'^ (wn)wn < d. Therefore by (4.75), (4.76) and (Fi), we see that (4.77)
cj
\wX<
f
(lw,{t,x,Wn)wn-W{t,x,Wn))
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
111
and that
>
C / J\w„.\>Rn '\w^\>Ro
>
C
W{t,X,Wn)
•j'\w^\>Ro
\Wr,
J\w
It follows that / \wn\-^ < c. By (Fi) and (F4), it is easily seen that J\w^\>Ro or a>iy> p. either iy>a>p (i) If j9 < Q^ < z/, then / \wn\^ < c and for t small enough, l\w^\
\w^\
<(f
(Kr)""*""°(/
i»..i'"^"'
(4.78)
/
k„r
J\w^\
/
\wnr
J\iWn\
Combining (4.76)-(4.78), we have the following estimates:
< c||«;+ii( / _^ /
Kr+/ f
^J\Wr^\>Ro
Kr) f
J\w^\
\(P-1)/P ^
Since t is arbitrarily small, both {||'W^^||} and {||'W^n||} are bounded.
D
112
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
4.6.2
SOLUTIONS
T h e Asymptotically Linear Case
We assume the following conditions hold. (Gi) W{t,x,z) = ^/3o|^P + n ( t , x , z ) , where Iiz{t,x,z) = o{\z\) as \z\ -^ oo uniformly for all (t,x); /3o > /ii, where /ii is the smallest positive point in the spectrum of — A^^ + V. (G2) There are m G (2, (2Ar + 4)/N),Ro c | ^ r < W,{t,x,z)z
> 0 such that < \W,{t,x,z)\\z\
for ah {t,x) G R X R ^ and \z\ < RQ. (G3) U^{t,x,z)z-2U{t,x,z)
> 0 for ah {t,x,z)
^ (0,0,0).
(G4) There exists a /i > 2 such that liminf —TTTT-^—^—^ = /^, uniformly for (t, x) G R x R ^ . z^o W{t,x,z) ^' J V . y (G5) There exists an o^ G (0, 2) such that ,. . ^Iiz(t,x,z)z — 2Ii(t,x,z) ^ ., n . / N -r^ -r^/v liminf ^^ ' ' \ . ^ ' ' ^ > c > 0, uniformly for (t, x) G R x R ^ . \z\^oo
|Z|^
T h e o r e m 4.45. Assume {Gi)-{G^). solution.
Then {SE4) has at least one nontrivial
In order to prove Theorem 4.45, we first check the conditions of Theorem 4.3. L e m m a 4.46. There exist ro > 0, 6 > 0 such that H\\B > h for all A G [1,2], where B = {z : z e ^ + , \\z\\ = ro}. Proof.
Trivial.
D
L e m m a 4.47. There exist ZQ G E~^ with \\zo\\ = 1 and R > r^ such that HX\A < 0, where A = d{z = z' ^ SZQ : z' G E-,\\z\\
\\zor-f3o
/
^<0.
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
113
Choose ZQ = zo/||^o||- Now we have only to prove that H\A < 0 for large R, since W is positive. If this were not true, we would find diWn = SnZo-\-w~ with \\wn\\ -^ oo such that H{wn) > 0. Setting tn = Sn/\\wn\\,u~ = w~/\\wn\\, we have tn > \\u~ \\. Since t^ + \\u~ p = 1, we may assume that t^ ^ txj > 0 and u~ -^ u~ weakly in E. Write u = wz^ + u~. Since {ZO,U~)L2 = 0, we have w'^ — \\u~ W'^ — Po /
u • udtdx
= w'^ — \\u~ W^ — (3^ I <w'-\\u-f<w^{l-
• /3otx7^ / (3o /
{wzo-\-u~){wzo-\-u~)dtdx z^dtdx — Po
{u
Ydtdx
z^dtdx)
<0. Therefore, there exists a bounded set O such that txj^ - ||i^~ f - /3o / u'^dtdx < 0. On the other hand, since H{wn) > 0, we see that n
^
^^2
1|| - | | 2
/
W{t,X,Wn),,,
^
1.2
1|| - | | 2
/ ^ ( ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ n ) ,, ,
1,2
1|| - | | 2
f ^Po\Wn\'^
^Il{t,X,Wn)
By the Lebesgue Dominated Convergence Theorem and (G^i), lim / 5 f e ^ d i r f ^ = o. n^oo
n
IhnP
Hence, txj^ — ||i^ P — /3o / ^ t^^ > 0, and we get a contradiction.
D
Lemma 4.48. There exist Xn G [1,2], Wn G ^ \ { 0 } such that Xn -^ I ^ ^ A ('^^) 0 anti H\^{wn) < d. In particular, the sequence {wn} is bounded. Proof. The proofs of the existence of Wn^Xn are similar to those of the previous section. We now prove that {wn} is bounded. Since H'^ (wn) = 0
114
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
and Hx^{wn) < d, we have that (4.79)
(i_i)(||^+||2_AJ|^-f) +An /
(-Wz{t,X,Wn)Wn-W{t,X,Wn))dtdx
On the other hand, by {G2) — (G^s), we may assume that (4.80)
W^{t,X, z)z > fiW{t,X, z)
(4.81)
n^(t, X, z)z - 2n(t, X, z) > c\z\'^
for \z\ < Ro; for |z| > R^.
Therefore, by (4.79) and (4.80),
< C-\- C
(W{t,X,Wn)
Wz{t,X,Wn)Wn
/ + + // '\w^\
C^C(
) dtdx
))(W(t,X,Wn) [W{t,x,Wn)
Wz(t,X,Wn)Wn)dtdx W^{t,x,Wn)wn)c
Therefore, E
/
(W{t,X,Wn)
/ (J\w^\>Ro ^
< c-\- c
Wz{t,X,Wn)Wn)dtdx
)Wz{t,X,Wn)Wndtdx ^
\wn\'^dtdx. J\w^\>Ro
Since C
i^A^(^n) - - ( i ^ A ^ ( ^ n ) , ^ n ) < ^ , >
(Wz{t,X,Wn)Wn—2W{t,X,Wn))dtdx
) ( ^ z ( ^ 5 ^ 5 ' ^ n ) ' ^ n — 2W{t,X,Wn) \Wr^\
>
c
J\Wr^\>Ro
\wn\^dtdx -\- c /
J\w^\
J\w^\>Ro
Choose i :-
{2-a){N^2) {2{N^2)-aN)'
\wn\^dtdx.
j dtdx
4.6. SCHRODINGER
SYSTEMS
115
Then L G (0,1) and /
\wnfdtdx
J\w^\>Ro
= [
\Wr,\^'-'^^\Wr,\^'dtdx
J\w^\>Ro r
(1-02
< ( /
\wXdtdx)
^J\w^\>Ro
^
r
ILN
(2N + 4)
" ( /
\wn\ ^
^J ^\w^\>Ro
\ (2Ar + 4)
dtdxj ^
\\
Wz{t,x,Wn)w^dtdx JRXR^
[
+/
^J\w^\>Ro
)\W,{t,x,Wn)\\wi\dtdx
J\w^\
\wn\\w:^\dtdx ^ c / J\w^\>Ro
\wn\^~'^\w:^\dtdx.
J\w^\
Thus, /
r
ik+ip < c /
'\Wn\
-\-c( /
<
\ (m-l)/m /
iwr^rdtdx]
(/
^
\wn\'^dtdx]
r
\ I/TI
^J\Wn\
( /
iwtrdtdx]
|i(;^p(it(ix)
c||^+ii(i+c||^jr),
which imply that both {w:^} and {wn} are bounded. Proof of Theorem 4.45. £ > 0, we have that ^nlP ^n / Ikn f = K
^nll = -• //
D
By the hypotheses of Theorem 4.45, for any
Wz{t,X,Wn)w:^dtdx W,{t,X,Wn)w:^dtdx < s\\Wnf ^ c\\WnV,
Wz{t,x,Wn)w^dtdx <£\\wn\\ + c | | ^ ^ | | ^ . Wz{t,x,Wn)w^dtdx
JRI+^
where p > 2 is a constant. Hence, ||t^n|| > c > 0. Similarly, there exists a z* ^ 0 such that H{z*) = 0. D.
116
CHAPTER 4. LINKING AND HOMOCLINIC TYPE
SOLUTIONS
Notes and Comments. By Schauder's fixed point theorem, H. Brezis-L. Nirenberg [72] considered the following system dfU - Aj^u = -v^ + / ,
-dtv - A^v = u^ ^ g,
for (t,x) G ( 0 , r ) X 0, for {t,x) e ( 0 , r ) X 0,
satisfying u = v = 0 on {0,T) x dfl and i^(0, x) = v{T, x) = 0 in O. Here O is a bounded domain of R ^ and / , ^ G 1/^(0) . They obtained a solution {u, v) with u e l/^((0,r) X n) and v G L^{{0,T) x Q). In P. Clement-P. Felmer-E. Mitidieir [103], the authors studied the following problem dtu - A^u = \v\'^-'^v, - ^ t i ; - A^i; = \u\P-'^u,
for (t, x) G ( - T , T) x O, for (t,x) G ( - T , r ) x O,
where O is a smooth bounded domain in R ^ and N/{N-\-2) < l/p-\-l/q < 1. By the usual Mountain Pass Theorem, they obtained at least one positive solution. The system {SE4) was explored in T. Bartsch-Y. Ding [35] by a new linking theorem due to W. Kryszewski-A. Szulkin[201], where the AmbrosettiRabinowitz superquadratic condition was imposed and the asymptotically linear case was not discussed. Lemmas 4.38-4.41 were established in T. BartschY. Ding [35]. In particular, a regularity result was found and infinitely many solutions were obtained if there is a symmetry of W in (u,v). Theorems of this section are due to M. Schechter-W. Zou [325].
Chapter 5
Double Linking Theorems If A links B, does B link A7 Can they yield two different critical points without the (PS) type compactness conditions? To find out, read on...
5.1
A D o u b l e Linking
Let ^ be a refiexive Banach space with norm || • ||. Define a class of contractions of E as follows: (5.1)
T
Ti;-)eCi[0,l]xE,E); r(0, •) = id, for each t G [0,1), r(t, •) is a homeomorphism of E onto itself and T~^{t, •) is continuous on [0,1) x E; there exists a XQ G ^ such that r ( l , x) = XQ for each x e E and that r(t, x) ^ XQ as t ^ 1 uniformly on bounded subsets of E.
Definition 5.1. A subset A of E is linked to a subset B of E if An B and, for every F G T, there is at ^ [0,1] such that r(t, A) f^ B ^ ^. Proposition 5.2. Let M G C{E, R^) and Q ^ E be such that MQ = M\Q is a homeomorphism of Q onto the closure of a bounded open subset ft of R ^ . Let pen, then M~^{dQ) links M-^{p). Proof. Assume that M^^{dQ) does not link M~^{p). Then there is a F G T such that (5.2)
T(t,M^^(dn)\nM-^(p) = $, te[o,i].
118
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING THEOREMS
That is, (5.3)
M(r{t,M^\dn))^
n {p} = 0,
te [o, i].
Set 0{t) :=MoT{t,')oM^\
(5.4)
Then we see that 0{t) G C ( 0 , R ^ ) for each t G [0, l]_and (9(0) = id on O. If r ( l , ^ ) = xo, then 0{l)x = MXQ ^ p for dl\ x e Q since by (5.2)-(5.4), M(T{l,M^^{dn)))
n {p} = 0. By the Brouwer degree,
deg(^(t),0,p) = deg(^(l),0,p) = l,V t G[0,l]. This is a contradiction.
D
P r o p o s i t i o n 5.3. Let A, B he two closed, hounded suhsets of E such that E\A is path connected. If A links B, then they link each other. We call them, douhle linking sets. Proof. Assume that B does not link A. Then we may find a F G T such that (5.5)
r ( t , 5 ) n A = 0 , v t G [0,1].
By the definition of T, we assume that r ( l , ^ ) = XQ, hence XQ ^ A. Let O be a closed ball such that A C O. Note that E\A is path connected, then there is a path 7 connecting XQ ^ A to a point xi ^Vt. Let to G [0,1) be such that the diameter of r(to, B) —XQ is less than min{dist(7, A), dist(xi, O)}. Parametrize 7 in such a way that it is given by j{t),to < t < 1,7(^0) = xo,7(l) = xi. Then (5.6)
[T{to,B) + 7(t) - xoj n A = 0,
to < t < 1
and (5.7)
( r ( t o , 5 ) + x i - x o ) n O = 0.
Define r i ( t , x ) = T{t,x) for t G [0,to]; and = r ( t o , x ) - I ^ Q + 7 ( t ) for t G [to,l]. By (5.5), r i ( t , 5 ) n A = 0for ah t G [0,1]. Hence, (5.8)
Bf^V^^{t,A)
= 0 , V t G [0,1].
By (5.7), (5.9)
r i ( i , 5 ) n o = 0.
5.1. A DOUBLE LINKING
119
Let T2 be any map in T such that T2{t,Q) C Q for ah t. Take Ts{t,-) = ri(2t,-)~^ for ah t G [0,1/2] and Ts{tr) = r i ( l , - ) ~ ^ o r2(2t - 1,-) for ah (1/2,1]. It is easy to check that Ts G T. But (5.8)-(5.9) imply that BnTs{t,A)
= 9,
t G [0,1].
This contradicts the fact that A links B.
D
P r o p o s i t i o n 5.4. Let E = M ® N^ where M^N are closed subspaces with one of them finite dimensional. If yo G M\{0} and 0 < p < R, then the sets A B
:= {u = v^syo := Mn dBp
:v e N,s>
0,\\u\\ = R} U
[NHBR],
link each other in the sense of Definition 5.1, where Br := {u e E : \\u\\ < r}. Proof. We first consider the case of dim N < 00 and identify N with some R ^ . We may assume that \\yo\\ = 1- Let Q = {syo ^v:veN,s>0,\\syo^v\\<
R}.
Then A = dQ in R ^ + ^ Let u = v ^ w with v e N,w e M. We define Fu = V -\- ||t^||^o- Then F\Q = id and B = F~^{pyo). We can apply Proposition 5.2 to conclude that A links B. Since A and B are bounded and E\A is path connected, B links A as well. D P r o p o s i t i o n 5.5. Let E = M Q N, where M,N are closed subspaces with dim AT < 00. Let BR = {u e E : \\u\\ < R} and let A = OBR nN,B = M. Then A links B. Proof. We identify N with some R ^ and take Q = BRH N,Q = Q. For u = V -\- w^v e N^w e M, define the projection Fu = v. Since F\Q = id and M = F~^(0), we observe by Proposition 5.2 that A links B. D P r o p o s i t i o n 5.6. Let B be an open set in E and A = {a, b} such that a e B^b ^ B. Then A links dB. Moreover, dB links A if B is bounded. Proof. Let F G T. If F ( l , ^ ) = ^0, then F(t,_a) (F(t,6)) is a curve in E connecting a ( 6, respectively) with i^o- If '^0 ^ B, then F(t,a) intersects dB. If uo G B, then F(t, 6) intersects dB. Hence A links dB. Obviously, E\A is path connected, therefore, dB links A if 5 is bounded. Notes and Comments. Definition 5.1 was introduced by M. SchechterK. Tintarev [323] and Propositions 5.2-5.6 were proved there (see also M. Schechter [309, 310, 312, 317, 319]). More examples can be found in M.
120
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
Schechter [310] and M. Schechter-W. Zou [327]. Note that this kind of new linking includes almost all classical linkings as special cases. It is more general and realistic. Actually, many works of the authors are based on this concept. We refer the readers to the papers of M. Schechter and W. Zou in the Bibliography.
5.2
Twin Critical Points
Suppose that ^ G C^(^,R) is of the form: ^{u) := I{u) - J{u),u G E, where I^Je C^{E, R) map bounded sets to bounded sets. Define
^x{u)=XI{u)-J{u),
AG A,
where A is an open subinterval of (0,+oo). Assume one of the following alternatives holds. (Ai) I{u) > 0 for all 1^ G ^ and either I{u) ^ oo or \J{u)\ ^ oo as ||i^|| -^ oo. (A2) I{u) < 0 for all 1^ G ^ and either I{u) -^ —00 or \J{u)\ ^
00 as
ll^ll ^ 0 0 . Further, we need (A3) ao(A) := sup^A < ^o(A) := inf ^A, A
VA G A.
^
Theorem 5.7. Suppose that (Ai) {or {A2)) and (As) hold. (1) If A links B and A is bounded, then for almost all X ^ A there exists an Uk{X) G E such that sup ||i^fc(A)|| < 00, ^^(i^fc(A)) -^ 0 and that k
^\{uk{\))
-^ a{\) as k ^ 00, where a{X) := inf sup ^xC^is^u)). ^^^ se[o,i],ueA
In particular, if a{\) = 60(A); then d\st{uk{X)^ B) ^ 0 ,
k ^ 00.
(2) / / B links A and B is bounded, then for almost all X e A there exists a Vk{X) G E such that sup ||'U/c(A)|| < 00, ^^i^kW) -^ 0 and that k
^A('^fe(A)) -^ b{X) as k ^ 00, where 6(A) := sup inf ^xC^is^v)). TGT se[o,i],veB In particular, if ao{X) = b{X), then dist{vk{X),A) ^ 0 ,
k ^ 00.
5.2. TWIN CRITICAL POINTS
121
(3) If A^B are bounded subsets which link each other and, for any X e A, every bounded (PS)-sequence of ^\ possesses a convergent subsequence, then for almost all A G A, ^A has two different critical points u\ and v\ satisfying
$AK)=a(A),
$';,K)=0;
$;,(«;,)= 5(A),
$ 1 ^ ) = 0.
In particular, if a{X) = b{X), then v\ ^ A^u\ G B. Proof. (1) We first prove conclusion (1) with (Ai) holding. Obviously, a (A) > 60(A) since A links B. By (Ai), the map A -^ a{X) is non-decreasing. Hence, a\X) := —-—— exists for almost every A G A. We consider those A where a^(A) dX exists. For a fixed A G A, let A^ G (A, 2A) H A, A^ ^ A as n ^ 00, then there exists n(A) such that (5.10)
a\X) - 1 < ^(^^) - ^(^) < a\X) + 1, A„ — A
for n > n(A).
Step 1. We show that there exist r „ G T,w := w{\) > 0 such that ||r„(s,u)|| < w whenever ^x{rn{s,u)) > a{X) — (A„ — A). Indeed, by the definition of a(A„), there exists a r „ e T such that (5.11)
sup $A(r„(s,M))< sup $A„(r„(s,M))
If <^x{T„{s,u)) > a{X) - (A„ - A) for some u e A,s e [0,1], then by (5.10) and (5.11), we have that (5.12)
/(r„(s,u))
and that (5.13)
J{Tn{s,u))
However, by (Ai), (5.10) and (5.11), we have that (5.14)
J(r„(s,u)) >-$A„(r„(s,u)) > - ( a ( A ) + (A„-A)(a'(A) + 2)) > - o ( A ) - A | o ' ( A ) + 2|.
122
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
Combining (5.12)-(5.15) with (Ai), we see that there exists a w{X) := w such that ||r^(5,1^)11 < w. Step 2. By the choice of F^ and (5.10), we observe for all {s^u) G [0,1] x A that (5.15)
^x{Tn{s,u)) <
sup
^xA^n{s,u))
sG[0,l],iiGA
< a{\n) + (A^ - A) 6o(A). For e G (O, (a(A) — 6o(A))/3), we define Q,(A) := {^ G ^ : ll^ll < 117 + 1, | ^ A ( ^ ) - a{\)\ < e}.
(5.16)
Let n be so large that (a^(A)+2)(A^-A) < e, A^-A < s. Then, ^x{Vn{s,u)) < a{X) -\- £ for all {s,u) G [0,1] x A. If there exists a {so,uo) G [0,1] x A such that ^A(rn(5o, ^o)) > a(A) - (A^ - A) > a(A) - s, then by Step 1, ||F^(5o,i^o)|| < tx7(A). It follows that F^(5o,i^o) ^ QsW- By the definition of a(A), we see that the case of ^A(rn(5, u)) < a{X) — (A^ — A) for all {s,u) G [0,1] x A cannot occur. Therefore, Q£{X) ^ 0. Next, we show that (5.17)
ini{\\^'xiu)\\:ueQei\)}=0
for £ G (0,
) sufficiently small. If not, then there exists an SQ G
, , ,^ (a(A)-60(A)), (0, ) such that ||*'A(W)||
>3£o
forallueQeo(A).
Take n so large that (a'(A) + 2)(A„ - A) < £0, A„ - A < SQ. Define (5.18)
Q:„(A)
•.= {ueE:
\\u\\ < t u + l , a ( A ) - ( A „ - A ) < <S>x{u) < a(A)+eo}.
Then Q:O(A) C Qe„(A).
Similarly, Q*Q(A) ^ 0. By Lemma 2.1, we may construct a locally Lipschitz continuous map Hx of E such that
5.2. TWIN CRITICAL POINTS (a)
\\nx{u)\\
(b) {'^'^{u),Hx{u)) >2eo,yu (c)
123
e
QliX);
{^\{u),nx{u))>OyueE.
Consider the Cauchy initial boundary value problem:
dt
-nxm,u)),
^{0,u)=u.
By Theorem 1.36, there exists a unique continuous solution S,{t,u) such that ^\{^{t,u)) is nonincreasing in t. Define f C(2s,w)
0 < s < 1/2,
tis,u):=\ [ C(l,^„(2s-l,^t))
l/2<s
Then it is easy to check that F G T. We shall prove that (5.19)
$A(f(s,u))
W{s,u) e [0,1] x A,
which yields the desired contradiction. Choose any u e A. If 0 < s < 1/2, by (A3), we get that (5.20)
$A(f(s,^t))
< < < <
^x{u) 60(A) a(A) — 3£o a(A)-(A„-A).
If 1/2 < s < 1, then f(s,u) = ^ ( l , r „ ( 2 s - l,u)). «(A) - (A„ - A) for s e [1/2,1], then *A(f(s,^t)) (5.21)
If $A(r„(2s - l,u))
<
$A(C(0,r„(2s-l,w)))
<
a(A)-(A„-A).
<
If there exists an SQ G [1/2,1] such that $A(r„(2so - 1, u)) > a{\) - (A„ - A), then by Step 1, ||r„(2so — 1, w) || < w. Recalling step 2 and (5.18), we see that r „ ( 2 s o - l , w ) e 2*0(A). Since | | C ( t , r „ ( 2 s o - l , ^ * ) ) - r „ ( 2 s o - l , ^ * ) | | = || / dC{a, r„(2so-i,w))||
124
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
we have (5.22)
U{t,rn{2so-l,u))\\
< <
\\r„{2so-l,u)\\+t w+1,
for a l H e [0,1].
Therefore, if $A(^(io,r„(2so-l,u))) < a ( A ) - ( A „ - A ) we must have (5.23)
for some to G [0,1],
$A(f(so,w)) = $A(e(l,r„(2so - l,u)) < a{X) - (A„ - A).
If it is not the case, by step 2, we must have (5.24)
a(A) - (A„ - A) <$A(C(l,r„(2so-l,w))) <$A(^„(2so-l,^t)) < a(A) + £o
for all t e [0,1]. Thus, (5.22)-(5.24) impUes that e(t,r„(2so - l,u)) e QliX) Note that
($^(U),7^A(U))
for all t e [0,1].
> 2eo on Q*,(A). Thus we have
$A(C(i,r„(2so - l,u))) - $A(r„(2so 0 < J
l,u))
da -($A(?('^,r„(2so - l,u))),WA(?(a,r„(2so - l,u))))d(7
< -2teoIt follows that, $A(f(so,u))
< <
$A(r„(2so-l,M))-2£o a(A)-(A„-A).
Combining this with (5.20), (5.21) (5.23) and (5.25), we get $A(f (s,u)) < a{\) - (A„ - A),V(s,u) e [0,1] x A, which contradicts the definition of a (A). This implies that (5.17) holds in the case of a(A) > ho{\). By (5.17) we get the conclusion (1) of this theorem. Step 4' We show that the conclusion (1) of Theorem 5.7 holds true in case of a(A) = 6o(A). For £ > 0 , r > 0, we define (5.25)
Q(£,r,A):= {ueE : \\u\\ <w{X)^4^dA,\^x{u)
- a ( A ) | < 3s,d{u,B)
<4T},
5.2. TWIN CRITICAL POINTS
125
where dA '-= max{||i^|| : u e A}, which is finite since A is bounded. We claim that Q(£, T, A) ^ 0. We choose n so large that (5.26)
sup
^xi^nis^u))
<
sG[0,l],iiGA
sup
^xA^n{s,u))
sG[0,l],iiGA
<
a(A) + 3s.
Since A links 5 , there exists {so,uo) G [0,1] x A such that r^(5o,i^o) ^ ^• Hence, dist(r^(5o,i^o)5 ^ ) = 0 and (5.27)
^A(rn(5o,^o))
> bo{X) inf ^A B
a(A) a(A) - (An --A) a(A) — 3s. By step 1, ||rn(5o,i^o)|| < ^ ; hence, rn(5o,i^o) ^ Q(£,T, A). /S^ep 5. For s, T small enough, we show that (5.28)
inf{||$^(u)||:ueQ(£,T,A)}=0.
If this were not true, there would exist (5 > 0, £i > 0, Ti G (0,1) such that (5.29)
II^A(^)II
> 3(^ for u G Q(£i,Ti, A).
Define (5.30)
{
1^ G ^ :
||i^|| < tx7 + 4 + (iA,
a(A) - (A, - A) < dist(^,5) < 4 r i .
^A(^)
< a{\) + S^i,
Similarly, by (5.26), Q*(£i,ri,A)^0,
Q*(ei,Ti,A)cQ(£i,Ti,A).
Let n be so large that (A^—A) < £i, (a^(A)+2)(An—A) < Si and (A^—A) < 6Ti. We may construct a locally Lipschitz continuous map Hx of ^ such that (d)
\\nx{u)\\
(e) ($^(u),7iA(w)) > 2<5,Vu e Q(ei,Ti,A);
(f)
{^'M,nx{u))>0,'iueE.
126
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
Define
(5.31)
\\u\\ < tx7 + 2 + (iA, I ^ A H - a{X)\ < 2si,
( ueE: Qi := <^ [
dist{u,B)
<3Ti.
It is easily seen that Qi ^ 0 and Qi C Q(£i,Ti,A). Choose a Lipschitz continuous map a from E into [0,1] which equals 1 on Qi and vanishes outside Q(£i,Ti, A). Consider the initial boundary value problem
Let ^i{t,u) be the unique continuous solution. Then we have that '-^^^fl^<-2Sam,u))<0.
(5.32) For u ^ A, by (5.32), we have that (5.33)
^x{Ci{t,u))
< ^x{u) < ao(A) < bo{X) = a(A),
Vt G [0,ri]
and
^A(a(^,^)) = ^ A ( ^ ) + / <
^x{u)-
/
^^^^
^^^^
2fo(^i(cr,l^))(icr
for ah t G [0,ri]. We shah show that Ci{t,u) ^ B for ah 5 G [0,ri] and u ^ A. If this were not true, then there would exist a to G [0, Ti] such that ^i(to,^) G 5 . Then ^xmh.u))
> a{X) = bo{X) = inf ^A. B
By (5.32)-(5.33), we see that
Jo /O Hence, c^(ei(a,^)) = 0,V(7G [0,to], i e . , e i ( ^ , ^ ) ^ Q i V ( 7 G [0,to].
5.2. TWIN CRITICAL POINTS
127
Therefore, one of the fohowing three cases occurs: (5.34) (5.35)
\M<^,n)\\>07 + 2 I'^xiCMu)) -a{X)\
+dA; >2ei; dist(^i(a,u), B) > 3Ti.
(5.36) If (5.34) holds, since
Il?i(a,u)-?i(a', u)\\<\a-a'\,
(5.37) \M'7,u)\\
< \MO,u)\\+T,
V(7 e [0,io],
we get a contradiction. If (5.35) holds, then ^x{^i{a, u)) < a(A) — 2ei. Hence, ^i{a,u) ^ B. Evidently, (5.36) implies that ^i(a,u) ^ B. Therefore, that ^i(t, u) ^ B for all s G [0, Ti] and u E A is true. We are going to show that (5.38)
Ci(Ti,r„(2s - l,u)) ^ B,yu eA,se
[1/2,1].
For any fixed u e A and s G [1/2,1], we distinguish two cases. (I) If Ci((T, r„(2s - 1, u)) G Qi for all a G [0, Ti], by (5.32), we have that $A(?i(Ti,r„(2s-l,u))) C5 (r (0. ^ ,\\M r^ = *A(r„(2s - 1, u)) + / <$A(r„(2s-l,u))- I Jo = $A(r„(2s-l,u))-25Ti
rf^A(gi(a,r„(2s-l,n)))^ da '2Sa{Cii(T,T„{2s-l,u)))da
< a{\) - 2STi + (a'(A) + 2)(A„ - A), then it follows that .^i(ri,r„(2s — l,u)) ^ B since a(A) = bo{\). (II) If there exists a to G [0,Ti] such that ^i(to,r„(2s — l,u)) ^ Qi, then one of the following alternatives holds: (5.39) (5.40) (5.41)
| | e i ( t o , r „ ( 2 s - l , u ) ) | | >w + 2 + dA; |$A(a(to,r„(2s-l,u)))-a(A)| >2ei; d i s t ( 6 ( i o , r „ ( 2 s - l , u ) ) , B ) > 3Ti.
Assume that (5.39) holds. If Ci(Ti,r„(2s - l,u)) G B, then 5o(A)
= < <
a(A) $A(6(ri,r„(2s-l,w))) $A(r„(2s-i,u)).
128
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
Recalling the proof in step 1, thus we see that ||r^(25 — l,i^)|| < ru. Since
||a(to,r,(25-1,^)) -ei(o,r,(25-1,^))|| < to, we get that \\^i{to,Tn{2s — l,i^))|| < tx7 + to < tx7 + l, which contradicts (5.39). Hence, ^ i ( r i , r ^ ( 2 5 - l,i^)) ^ B. Assume that (5.40) holds. Note that
<^A(ei(0,r,(25-l,^))) =
^x{rn{2s-l,u))
< a(A)+£i. Therefore, (5.40) implies that ^x{UTi,Tn{2s-l,u))) <$A(?i(to,r„(2s-l,u)))
>||ei(to,r,(25-l,^))-^||-|t-to|,
[0,ri]. Thus,
dist(a(t,r^(25 - i,u)),B) > 2ri, yt e [o,ri]. In particular, ^i{Ti,Tn{2s
— l,u)) ^ B. This completes the proof of (5.38).
Step 6. Define
r a(25Ti,^), [ Cl{Tl,Tr^{2s-l,u)),
o<5
Then T^ G T. However, by the proofs of step 5, Tl{s,A) 5 G [0,1]. We get the final contradiction.
n 5 = 0 for ah
As for the conclusion (1) with the second alternative (A2), it is quite similar to the first case under the assumption (Ai). We omit the details.
5.3. EIGENVALUE
PROBLEMS
129
Finally, conclusion (2) can be proved immediately by interchanging A and B, replacing ^x by — ^A and using conclusion (1). Conclusion (3) is an immediate consequence of conclusions (l)-(2). D Notes and Comments. Theorem 5.7 was obtained by M. Schechter-W. Zou [324].
5.3
Eigenvalue Problems
Let O C R ^ be a bounded smooth domain and let £ > Ai > 0 be a self adjoint operator on 1/^(0) with compact resolvent and eigenvalues: 0 < Ai < • • • < A^ < • • • . We assume that C^{n)
CD:=
D{C^/^) C H'^{Q)
for some m > 0 {m need not be an integer). Let q he di number satisfying 2
2m/{N - 2m),N < 2m; 2 < q < oo,2m < N,
and let / ( x , t) be a Caratheodory function on O x R. Suppose that (Bi) \f{x,t)\ < Vo{xy\t\^-'^Vo{x)Vi{x), where Vo G L%n),Vi G L^'(Q) and multiplication by VQ is a compact operator from D to 1/^(0). (B2) Xi-it^ - Wo{x) < 2F{x,t) < ue + \V{x)\P\t\P + Wi{x); Xit^-W2{x)<2F{x,t); for all {x,t) G O X R, where u < Xi,p > 2;F{x,t)
= / Jo
f{x,s)ds;
Cj := / Wj{x)dx < 00, j = 0,1 JQ
and ||y^||^ < Co\\C^/^u\\P for ah u e D. (B3) C* + C* < (1 - - ) ( 1 - ii)^/(^-2)( J_)2/(p-2)^ P M P^O Theorem 5.8. Assume that {Bi)-{Bs) hold. Then there exists an SQ > 0 such that, for almost all (3 e [1,1+ ^o], the equation (5.42)
Cu = (3f{x,u)
has two solutions. In particular, the eigenvalue problem (5.4-2) has infinitely many solutions.
130
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
Proof of Theorem 5.8.
THEOREMS
Under hypothesis (5i), the functional defined by
^x{u) '= Xa{u) - 2 /
F{x,u)dx
JQ
is in C^{D, R), and the Frechet derivative on D is given by {^'x{u),v) =2Xh{u,v)
-2{f{-,u),v),
where a{u,v) = {jCu,v),h{u) = h{u,u) := \\u\\'^ for all {u,v) ^ D X D. Let N be the subspace spanned by the eigenfunctions corresponding to the eigenvalues: Ai,...,A/_i and M := N-^ n D he the orthogonal complement of N on D. Choose £i > 0 so small that C* + d
< (1 - ^)(1 - £i - |l)P/(P-2)( A.)2/(p-2) .^ ^^
For w e M with ||u;|| = 5, where 5^''^ = 2(1 - Si - f^)/(j)Co),
we have
$AH > A/.H-Hhlli-r«^ll^-cr > >
(A-f)||u;f-Co||u;r-Ci* Az /^ - Ci*
for A > l-si. Obviously, ^ A ( ^ ) < ^o for ^Wv eN and A < 1. Let A^i := N® {swo : 5 G R } , where w^ is an eigenfunction corresponding to the eigenvalue A/, \\wo\\ = L For any £ G (1 — £i, 1) and v G A^i, ^A(^)
= < = <
\{Cv,v)-\i\\v\\l^B2 \\i\\v\\l-\i\\v\\l^B2 {s-l)Xi\\v\\l^B2 Bo
uniformly for A G (l — Si^s) for H^;!! large enough. By Theorem 5.7, for almost all A G [1 — £i,£), there exist ux ^ vx such that ^^(I^A) = O^^AI'^A) = 0, which implies the conclusions of the theorem. D Notes and Comments. Theorem 5.8 is a simple application of Theorem 5.7. From this we observe that Theorem 5.7 is a powerful tool for studying the eigenvalue problem. It is easy to get infinitely many eigenvalues and each of them has at least two-dimensional eigenspace. Several authors had discussed the eigenvalue problems. See for example, in H. Amann [7], P.
5.4.
JUMPING
NONLINEARITIES
131
Rabinowitz [293], A. Szulkin [356] and E. Zeidler [381], where the nonhnear t e r m is odd. In Y. Li [222], Y. Li [223] (based on K. C. Chang [93]), M. Schechter [306, 310, 314, 316, 318, 321], H. T. Tehrani [368] and E. Zeidler [380] (also E. Zeidler [379, Vol. Ill]), finite solutions were obtained without oddness. Eigenvalue problems with indefinite weight were studied in A. Szulkin-M. Willem [359]. For eigenvalue problems of non-smooth functionals, see M. Struwe [350] and G. Arioli [21]. About the nonlinear eigenvalue problems in ordered Banach spaces, see H. A m a n n [8]. T h e estimates of t h e growth of t h e eigenvalues for linear eigenvalue problems can be found in P. Li-S. T. Yau [210]. Theorem 5.8 was obtained in M. Schechter-W. Zou [324] which extended a result of M. Schechter-K. Tintarev [322, 323].
5.4
Jumping Nonlinearities
Consider the elliptic boundary value problem of t h e form
(5.43) ^ ^
(-An [
= f{x,u), 1^ = 0,
in fi, on ail,
where O C R ^ is a bounded domain with smooth boundary dft, and is a Caratheodory function on O x R such t h a t .
.
J f{x,t)/t^a
a.e. X G O as t ^ —OO,
^ '
'
I f(^x,t)/t^b
a.e. X G O as t ^ OO.
f{x,t)
Recall the Fucik spectrum of —A: (5.45)
E := {(a, b) G R^ : —Ai^ = bu'^ — au~ has nontrivial solutions},
(cf. e.g. S. Fucik [167]). Although t h e existence of solutions of (5.43) is closely related to the equation (5.46)
— Ai^ = bu^ — au~,
where u
= max{±i^, 0},
no complete description of E has been found. So far only some partial results have been obtained. Let 0 < Ai < • • • < A^ < • • • denote t h e distinct Dirichlet eigenvalues of —A on O with zero boundary value conditions. It was proved in M. Schechter [307] t h a t in the square (A/_i, A/+i)^ there exist two decreasing curves Ca,(^Z2, which may or may not coincide, passing through the point (A/, A/) such t h a t all points above or below b o t h curves in the square are not in E, while points on the curves are in E. This is t h e so-called type-(I) region.
132
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
Usually, the status of points between the curves which is referred to as the type-(II) region if the curves do not coincide is unknown. It was shown in T.Gallouet-0. Kavian [168] that when A/ is a simple eigenvalue, points of the type-(II) region are not in E. On the other hand, C. A. Margulies-W. Margulies [250] have shown that there are boundary value problems for which many curves in E emanate from a point (A/, A/) when A/ is a multiple eigenvalue. These curves are contained in the region-(II). In this section, (a, 6) is allowed to be a point outside the square (A/_i,A/+i)^ or inside the region-(II) between the curves Cn and C12 when they do not coincide. Such points may or may not belong to E. We prove an existence result of multiple solutions. Let i^o(^) be the usual Sobolev space with norm || • || and let Ek denote the subspace spanned by the eigenfunctions corresponding to A^, which is contained in 1/^(0) since all of the eigenfunctions corresponding to A^ are bounded. Set Nk = Ei® • • • ® Ek- Then there exists a constant C^ > 0 such that
(5.47)
ll^lloo = m a x | ^ ( x ) |
\/u e
Nk-i.
Define <^k := I inf{ / {u^fdx JQ ^
: u e Ek, \\u\\ = 1}.
Then, 0 < <^k < l/(4Afe) and <;k = l/2M{[{u-f:ueEkA\u\\ Jn
= l},
where u"^ = max{±i^,0}. Set 1/2
^ ' -^ V2(<^fe + C2|0| + l/Ai)J and Efc = E^i U Efc2, where Efei :={(a,6) G R^ : A^ < 6 < a}, Sfe2 := {(a, 6) G R 2 : A^-i < 6 < A^ < a, 7
^k-l^k
XfeAfe + (1 - xD^fe-
I
b> Afe(l - ^<^k)
and
5.4. JUMPING NONLINEARITIES
133
Define (5.48)
n:=
sup xen, |t|>4
^l^, ^
For /3o G (Afc_i,Afc), we choose / G N such that (5.49)
\i > 10Afe(2ri+Afe) , 32A| Afe-i Afc — /3o
Then by (5.47), there exists a Q > 0 such that (5.50)
||^||oo
for ah u G Ni-i. We make the fohowing assumptions. (Di) (a,6)GEfe. (D2) 2F{x,t) > Afe-it^, (D3) 2F{x,t)
V(x,t) G O X R.
< pot'^ + M*(x)
for |t| < 4,x G O, where M*(x) > 0 in O, M* G Li(0), and / M%x)dx < A/c-i(Afc — po)
^>icf
The points of E^ may be outside the square [A/c_i, A^+i]^, may be inside of the type-(II) region of the square [A^, A/c+2]^ or may be on the curves Ck+i^i and Cfc+1^2 which pass through the point (A^+i, A^+i). We have Theorem 5.9. Assume that (Di) — (Ds) hold; /(x,0) ^ 0. Then for almost all A G [1, 3^^A° ]' ^^^ following equation has two nontrivial solutions: (5.51)
—Au = Xf{x,u)
in ft; u = 0 on dft.
If in addition, (D4) 2F(x, t) — / ( x , t)t ^ ±00,
uniformly for x e ft as \t\ ^ 00,
^/len ^/le equation (5.52)
—Au = f{x,u)
in ft; u = 0 on dft
has two nontrivial solutions.
As usual, we seek solutions of equations (5.51) and (5.52) as critical points of the C^ functional ^x defined by
134
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
^A(^)=A||^f-a||^-||^-6||^+||2_2 / Jn for u e
HQ{Q),X>
THEOREMS
H{x,u)dx,
0, where
r
H{x,u) : = h{x,t):
/ Jo
=
h{x,t)dt,
f{x,t)-{bt^
-at-),
and t^ = max{±t, 0}. L e m m a 5.10. Let u = U- -\- UQ e N^ with U- G N^-I^UQ 1, 11'^-II ^ Xfe, ^^e^ 11'^^ 111 ^ ^fe/2, w;/iere i^^ = max{±i^, 0}.
G E^.
If \\u\\
Proof. Since ||i^|| = 1 and ||i^_|| < ^ , ||i^o|| > 0. It follows that, 2<^k{l \\u-f)
< [
{u-^fdx^nd
JQ
({utfdx Jn
=
f {uof Jun>o
<
2 /
u'^dx^2
Juo>0
/
u'idx
JQ
< 2/
u^dx^^Wu-f
< 2/(^+)2^x + 2C,2||^_f|0| + f ||^_f < 2 We have that / {u-^fdx > —, JQ 2
f{u^fdx^2ClxlM^^xl / {u-fdx JQ
>—. 2
D
L e m m a 5.11. Let {a,b) G E^. Then ^x{u) -^ —oo uniformly for A G (0,1] as ||i^|| ^ oo, 1^ G NkProof. We first consider the case of (a, 6) G E/c2- For i^ = i^_ + i^o ^ ^k^
5.4. JUMPING NONLINEARITIES
135
U- G Nk-ijUo G ^fc, we have $AN
=
\\\uf-a\\u-g-b\\u+g-2[Hix,u)dx Jn b)\\u-\\l - b\\u\\l - 2 / H{x,u)dx
<
\\uf -{a-
<
( l - - ^ ) | | ^ , _ f + (l_A)||^„||2 -(a-6)||i^~||2-2 /
H{x,u)dx
JQ
=
(i--^)lluf+
6(-^-J-)||uof
-(a-6)||^-||^-2 / <
H{x,u)dx
|H|2((i__^) + 5 ( ^ _ _ L ) ^k-1
^
^k-1
^k
-(a-6)^1^) -2 I \M ^ Jn If ^ 1 ^ < Xfe, then by Lemma 5.10, \\U\\
||T|^||2
<
b
Wufil
<
> —• It fohows that Z
rU
$A(U)
H(x,u)dx.
(a-b) — )-2
Afe
8A k
I
H{x,u)da
JQ
-Pi\\uf-2 / H(x, u) dx, JQ
where i^i := - ( 1 - ^Afe - ^ V2 ^ * ) > 0' ^^ W > ^fc' *hen ||^*of < (1 ||u|| x D l k f , and ^x{u)
<
{l--^)\\u.f M-1
+
<
(1 - ^)xl\\uf ^k-1
=
\\uf(l-xl-
=
-Jy2\\uf - 2 /
^k
{l-^)\\uof-2[H{x,u)dx Jn
+ (1 - f )(1 - X ^ ) l k f - 2 f H{x,u)dx ^k Jn (l-x|)^)-2/
H{x,u)dx
H{x,u)dx,
JQ
where 1^2 '•= Xk\ Afe-i
^ (1 ~ Xk)\ Xk
1 > 0. We see that there exists an e > 0
136
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
such that (5.53)
^ A ( ^ ) < - ^ l l ^ f - 2 / H{x,u)dx,
It is also true if (a, b) G E^i. Note that lim |t|^oo
\/u G Nk.
h(x,t) ^— = 0. By (5.53), we obtain t
hmsup 11 ..^ < -£
\\u\\^oo Mr uniformly for A G (0,1), which implies the conclusion of Lemma 5.11.
D
As an immediate consequence of condition (-D2), we have L e m m a 5.12.
^A(^^)
< 0 for all u G A^^-i, A G (0,1].
L e m m a 5.13. Under the assumptions of Theorem, 5.9, there exist go > 0,eo > 0 such that ^x{u) > CQ for ||i^|| = po, u e Nj^_-^, where A G 3po + Afc ^2(A, + po)' ^' Proof. By ( 5.48), we see that 2F{x,t) < rit^for \t\ > 4,x G O. Moreover, condition (Di) implies that ri > A^. Choose r2 := 2ri + A^. Then (5.54)
2F(x, t) < r2t^ - 8(r2 - po) for \t\ > 4, x G O.
For any u G N^_-^^ write u = v ^ w with v ^ E^ ® ^fe+i 0 • • • 0 ^ z - i and w G A^^-ii. Let (Az+r2)A-2r2 8
2 , A(Afe - po) 2 4
x
If ^(^Y^"Vl - Apohl > 0, then (5.55)
Vi >
^
w' + (
^
|v|-Apo|w|)|f| > 0 .
If
(5.56)
M^Y^°^H-VoH<0,
by (5.49), we have that (5.57)
(A;+r2)A-2r2 ^
4X^pl -PO)'
A(AA;
5.4. JUMPING NONLINEARITIES
137
It follows by (5.56)-(5.57) that (5.58)
Vi > i^^^+'f-^'^ - ^ # ^ ) « ; ^ + hi^l^v^ 8 X{Xk - po) 4
> 0.
Let ( A z + r 2 ) A - 2 r 2 2 ^2 - Apo 2 (5.59) '02 := ^^^' ' '^^^^—^^w'^ ^'^""v^ - (r2 - \po)vw + 4(r2 - po). Then
It is easy to verify that 0^2 — ^ whenever II II
.
. r-, 4 ( r 2 - p o )
i; 00 < m i n { l , —
(Az+r2)A-2r2
- — , ——-
2|r2 - Apol
- — — } = 1.
8|r2 - Apo|
Let (r2 + Az)A^ 2 , (Afe +Po)A 2 If \v^w\> that
4, then by (5.54), (5.55), (5.58) and (5.59), for ||i;||oo < 1, we get
; . / ( A z + r 2 ) A - 2 r 2 2 , (A^ + po)A - 2r2 2 , /,/ N\ 0^3 > ( T w '^ H T '^ - r2'yt(; + 4(r2 - Po)) = V^l + 0^2 > 0. If IU ' +1(;| < 4, then by condition (-D3), we have that
V^3 >
(r2 + A/)A 2 , (Afe + Po)A 2 1 / , N2 1 ./T*/ N ^ ^ + ^ ^ -2/^o(^ + ^ ) --M [x)
> ^'' + Y - '^%^ + ^^' + ^ f - '^%^ - p,\vw\ - 1M*(X) >
(((^2A + AA - 2po)(A.A + poA - 2po))^^ _ ^^^ |^^| _ 1 ^ . ^ ^ ^ --M%x).
> 2
^ ^
138
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
Choose ll^ll := l/Q ^x{u)
:= ^o, then \\v\\^ < Ci\\v\\ < Ci\\u\\ = 1. By (Ds),
=
X\\vf^X\\wf-2
>
2[h\\vf
>
J A ( 1 - ^)\\vf ^
>
THEOREMS
f
+ h\\wf
:=
eo.
-
Z
Ak -t- PO
^l)\\wf
+
hxi\\w\\l-fF{x,u)dx)
+ I 2i^sdx
Ai
+ h{l
^k
Afc-l(Afc - po)
-
Z
J A ( 1 - ^)\\vf
.
+ hx,\\v\\l
+ h{l
^k
^
F{x,v^w)dx
^l)\\wf
JQ
- I
Ai
Ak
Al
M*{x)dx
JQ
JQ
D P r o o f of T h e o r e m 5.9. By Lemmas 5.11-5.13, we may find Ro > go > 0. Let A = {u = v^syo:ve
N^-us
> 0, ||^|| = Ro} U [N^-i H 5 ^ J ,
B = {ue N^_, : ll^ll = ^o}, where yo G Ek with \\yo\\ = 1. Then (5.60)
" - ^ := ao(A)
. . . ^ n0/ < A f e _ l 4>^2g2 (Afe-po) SUP$A(U)
^ ^o(A) := inf
$A(U),
for A e ( ^^""^'^^,,1]. By Theorem 5.7, for almost all A G [ ^^""^'^'^ 1], 2(Afe+po) 2(Afe+poj there are two different critical points Ux,vx satisfying (5.61)
$1(UA) = 0,
$,(«,) = a ( A ) > 6 o ( A ) > ^ ^ ^ i ^ ^ ^
and (5.62)
^ I K ) = 0,
^x{vx) = b{X) < ao(A) < 0.
This is the first part of Theorem 5.9. For the second conclusion of the theorem, by (5.61), we choose A^ ^ 1 and u^ such that ^x^{un) = a(A^), ^^ (un) = 0, Therefore, «(^n) =
{f{x,Un)Un-2F{x,Un))dx.
Jn
5.4. JUMPING NONLINEARITIES
139
Note that T{s,u) := (1 — s)u G T and that A^B are bounded; by the definition of a(An), a{Xn) is bounded from below and above by two positive constants which are independent of A^. Recah condition {D4). By standard arguments, it is easily seen that {||i^n||} is bounded. This yields a critical point u^ satisfying
Similarly, by (5.62), we get another nontrivial critical point v* of ^1 satisfying ^i(i;*) <0,^;(i;*) = 0. D Notes and Comments. The study of the Fucik spectrum began with A. Ambrosetti-G. Prodi [18], E. N. Dancer [120] and S. Fucik[167]. They first realized that the set in (5.45) is an important factor in the study of semilinear elliptic boundary value problems with jumping nonlinearities. When (a, b) G (A/_i, A/+i)^, some cases have been studied. If (a, 6) G (A/_i, A/+i)^, (a, 6) G region of type-(I) (that is the nonresonant case), see M. Schechter [307], E. N. Dancer [122, 123] and K. Perera-M. Schechter [284, 285]). If (a, 6) G (A/_i, A/+i)^, (a, 6) G region of type-(II), (a, 6) ^ E (also nonresonant case), see M. Schechter [315], E. N. Dancer [122, 123] and K. Perera-M. Schechter [282, 284]. See also N. Hirano-T. Nishimura [186] and A. Marino-C. Saccon [251] for results of multiple solutions for nonresonant case. If (a, 6) G (A/_i, A/+i)^, (a,6) G {Cn U C12) C E (that is resonant case), see K. Perera-M. Schechter [283] and K. Perera-M. Schechter [286]. If (a, 6) G (A/_i, A/+i)^, (a, b) ^ TiH (region of type (II)) (also resonant case), see PereraSchechter [286]. One solution was obtained there. For the Dirichlet problem involving the Laplacian, it was shown in N. P. Cac [75], E. N. Dancer [120], P. Drabek [141], P. Krejci [199] A. C. Lazer[203], A. C. Lazer-P. J. Mckenna [204, 205], T. Gallouet-0. Kavian [168], C. A. Magalhaes [248, 249], A. M. Micheletti [253], A. M. Micheletti-A. A. Pistoia [254], B. Ruf [303] and others that the curves in ^ of (5.45) exist locally in the neighborhood of (A/, A/). They also showed that in the square A/_i < a < A/, A/ < a < A/+i, ^ has one or more curves emanating from (A/, A/), while the square A/_i < a, 6 < A/ and Xi < a^b < A/+1 are free of the Fucik spectrum. It was conjectured that there are at most 2m such curves, where m is the multiplicity of the eigenvalue, see M. Schechter [310, page 267] ( and also E. N. Dancer [123] and C. A. Margulies-W. Margulies [250]). Note that the critical groups for jumping nonlinearities were studied in E. N. Dancer [123, 124], E. N. Dancer-Z. Zhang [128], S. Li-K. Perera-J. Su [214], J. Liu-S. Wu [235], K. Perera-M. Schechter [283, 284]. Theorem 5.9 was obtained by M. Schechter-W. Zou [324].
140
CHAPTER 5. DOUBLE LINKING
THEOREMS
Before closing the chapter, we mention some papers on p-Laplacian problems with jumping nonlinearities and its Fucik spectrum: S. Carl-K Perera [80], M. Cuesta-D. G. de Figueiredo-J. P. Gossez [119], E. N. Dancer-K. Perera [125], P. Drabek-S. Robinson [142], A. M. Micheletti-A. A. Pistoia [255], K. Perera [280, 281] and K. Perera-A. Szulkin
Chapter 6
Superlinear Problems We solve elliptic semilinear boundary value problems in which the nonlinear term is superlinear, but the nonlinearities need not satisfy the superquadracity condition. Because of this, we are able to include more equations than hitherto permitted. The region is not assumed to be bounded.
6.1
Introduction
Let O be a domain (which need not be bounded) in R ^ and .4 be a selfadjoint operator on 1/^(0). Some semilinear elliptic problems can be described in the following way. We assume that ^ > AQ > 0 and that (6.1)
C^{n) CV:=
V{A^I^) C R'^^^iSl)
for some TTI > 0, where Co^(O) denotes the set of test functions in Vi (i.e., infinitely differentiable functions with compact supports in O) and H'^''^{Q) denotes the Sobolev space. If m is an integer, the norm in H^'^^iQ) is given by
(6.2)
||«|U,2 := I E
ll^''"ll^ '
\|//|<m
Here D^ represents the generic derivative of order |/i| and the norm on the right-hand side of (6.2) is that of 1/^(0). If m is not an integer, there are several ways of defining the space H^''^(Q), all of which are equivalent. We shall not assume that m is an integer. A typical example of an operator A satisfying these hypotheses is a second order elliptic operator with smooth coefficients applied to functions satisfying zero Dirichlet boundary conditions
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
142
PROBLEMS
on a smooth bounded domain in R ^ . Only the abstract properties listed above are relevant to our analysis. Let q he di number satisfying (6.3)
2
2m < N, N < 2m.
Assume that O is bounded and has a smooth boundary. Then • if 2m < n,l < q < oo and (n — 2m)q < 2n, then ||^L
ueH^^\n);
• if n < 2m, then sup|^(x)| < C | | ^ | U , 2 ,
ueH'^^^n)
and U{x) - U{y)\ ^ ,, ,, sup ^ ^ < C U m,2.
TTm2/r^\ U G i7^'2 O ,
where ^ < a < 2m — n. By the first item, H^''^ ^^ L^(Q) for the given values of q. In particular, ^m,2 ^^^^ L^{Q) if (n — 2m)q < 2n. The second item implies that every function in H^''^{Q) is a.e. equal to a continuous function bounded in O and satisfies a Holder condition with suitable exponent. Proofs for these statements can be found in R. A. Adams [4] and M. Schechter [308]. Let f{x,t) (6.4)
be a Caratheodory function on O x R. We consider the problem Au = f{x,u),
ueV.
By a solution of (6.4) we shall mean a function u eV such that (6.5)
{u,v)v = {f{',u),v),
\/veV.
The problem (6.4) has been studied by many people. In A. Ambrosetti-P. Rabinowitz [19] the basic assumption was (6.6)
0 < /iF(x, t) < tf{x, t),
\t\ > r
for some ji > 2 and r > 0. This is a very convenient hypothesis since it readily achieves mountain pass geometry as well as satisfaction of the PalaisSmale condition. However it is also a severe restriction; it strictly controls the growth of f{x,t) as \t\ -^ oo. Most authors discussing superlinear problems
6.1.
INTRODUCTION
143
have made this assumption. In this section, we have been able to weaken this assumption considerably by a method different from the previous chapters. We assume either that fiF{x, t) - tf{x, t) < C{t^ + 1),
\t\ > r
for some /i > 2 and r > 0 or that (6.7)
L(x, t) := tf{x, t) - 2F(x, t)
is convex in t. These allow much more freedom for the function f{x,t). make the following assumptions. (Ai) \f{x,t)\
< M{xy{\t\^-^
We
+ 1) for ah (x,t) G O x R and
f{x,t)/M{xY
= o(|t|^-^) as \t\ -^ oo,
where M{x) > 0 is a function in 1/^(0) such that
(6.8)
IIM^II, < C | | ^ | | D ,
(6.9)
ueV,
\\uy:=\\A'/\l
If O and M{x) are bounded, then (6.8) will hold automatically by the Sobolev inequality. However, there are functions M{x) which are unbounded and such that (6.8) holds even on unbounded regions O (cf., e.g., M. Schechter [308]). With the norm (6.9), V becomes a Hilbert space. (A2) The point AQ is an isolated simple eigenvalue with a bounded eigenfunction eo{x) ^ 0 a.e. in O. (A3) There is a (5 > 0 such that 2F{x,t) F{x,t) := jlf{x,s)ds.
< Aot^,
\t\ < 8, x e Q, where
(A4) There is a function W{x) G L^{Q) such that either ,,,, , F(x,t) Wix) <
,,,, , F(x,t) > 00 as t ^ 00; or Wix) <
> 00 as t ^ —00,
for X e ft. The function W{x) need not be positive. (A5) There are constants /i > 2, C > 0 such that
fiF{x,t)-tf{x,t)
ten,
xen.
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
144
PROBLEMS
Theorem 6.1. Under the above hypotheses, the problem (6.10)
Au = f{x,u),
ueV
has at least one nontrivial solution. We also consider the following condition. (AQ)
The function L{x,t) := tf{x,t)
— 2F{x,t) is convex in t.
Theorem 6.2. / / we replace hypothesis (A^) with (AQ), then the problem (6.10) has at least one nontrivial solution.
Problem (6.10) is called sublinear if f{x,t) satisfies | / ( x , t ) | < C{\t\ -\l ) , x G 0 , t G R. Otherwise it is called superlinear. Hypothesis (^4) requires (6.10) to be superlinear. (A7) There are a (5 > 0 and a A > AQ such that 2F{x,t) > At^,
\t\ < S, x e
n. (Ag) There is a function W{x) G L^{Q) such that W{x) > Q{x,t) -^ —00 as \t\ ^ 0 0 , where Q{x,t) := F{x,t)
X G O,
Aot^.
If we drop hypothesis (^5) completely, then we are able to prove the following theorems. Theorem 6.3. If we replace hypotheses (As), {A4) with {A7), (Ag) and drop hypothesis (A^), then problem (6.10) has at least one nontrivial solution.
Notes and Comments. There have been many results studying superlinear elliptic equations under the assumption (6.6) since the celebrated paper by A. Ambrosetti-P. Rabinowitz [19]. In particular, a 3-solution theorem was obtained in Z. Q. Wang [373]. We make no attempt here to give an exhaustive account of this aspect or a complete survey of the literature. Our main aim is to weaken the condition (6.6) via a different way. Notes and comments on this line will be seen at the end of this chapter.
6.2. PROOFS
6.2
145
Proofs
Define (6.11)
^{u) := ll^lll, -2
f
F{x,u)dx.
Under hypothesis ( ^ i ) , we show that ^ is a continuously differentiable functional on the whole of V. Lemma 6.4. Under hypothesis (Ai) , F{x,u{x)) 1/^(0) whenever u, v eV.
and v{x)f{x,u{x))
are in
Proof. By (Ai) we have \F{x,u)\ < c(|M^|^ + |M^||M|^-^). Since M, Mu G L^, |M|^-^ G L^', where q' = q/{q - 1), the right-hand side is in 1/^(0). Similarly, \v{x)f{x,u)\
< \Mv\{\Mu\'^-^ + 1).
Since Mu, Mv are in L^, we obtain the conclusion.
D
Lemma 6.5. ^{u) has a Frechet derivative ^'{u) on V given by (6.12)
{^\u),v)v
= 2{u,v)v - 2(/(-,u),v),
where (•, •) is the usual inner product of L'^. Furthermore, the derivative ^^{u) given by (6.12) is continuous in u.. Proof. We write f{u) := f{x,u{x)). (6.13)
^{u -^v)-
Then we observe that
^{u) - 2{u, v)v + 2(/(^), i;)
= \\v\\% -2
(F{X,U^V)
= o{\\v\\v) — 2 I I
-F{X,U)
lf{x,u-\-rv)
-vf{x,u)\dx,
—
f{x,u)]vdrdx
^
\M-' (/(x, u^rv)-
^
^ 1/q'
fix, u)^ l^'drdx^
\\Mv\\,
m Jo where q' = q/{q — I)- We want to show that
( J J |M-1 (/(X, U + TV)- fix, U)) \l'dTdx) '^' (6.14)
=o{\\vy)
as||w|b^O.
146
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
Otherwise, we may find a sequence {vk} C V such that
(6.15)
/ /
PROBLEMS -^ 0 while
H'^/CUD
\M-^(f{x,u^rvk)-f{x,u))\'^'drdx>s>0.
By (^i), we see that ||M'U/c||g -^ 0- Then, for a subsequence, Mv^ -^ 0 a.e. But by (Ai) the integrand of (6.15) is majorized by \M-'(^f{x,u + TVk)-f{x,u))\'
(6.16)
where the right-hand side converges in L^(Q). Moreover, the integrand converges to 0 a.e. Hence, the left-hand side of (6.15) goes to 0 and (6.14) holds. The continuity of ^\u) is easily observed by the following arguments:
= 2{ui - U2, v)v -2 / v{f{x, ui) - / ( x , U2))dx JQ
<2\\ui-U2\\v\\v\\v^2\\Mv\\,^
\M-\f{x,ui)
-
f{x,U2)W'dxy^\
n Lemma 6.6. Under hypotheses {Ai)-{As), either
the following alternative holds:
(a) there is an infinite number ofy{x) G 1){A) \ {0} such that Ay = f{x,y)
= Xoy
or (b) for each p > 0 sufficiently small, there is an £ > 0 such that ^{u)
>£,
||^||D = P.
Proof. Let Ai > AQ be the next point in the spectrum of .4, and let A^o denote the eigenspace of AQ. Choose M = NQ- HV. By assumption (^2), there exists a p > 0 such that \\y\\v
implies that |7/(x)I < (5/2, y e NQ.
Now suppose u eV satisfying (6.17)
II^IID
< p a n d \u{x)\ > S
6.2. PROOFS
147
for some x G Q. Write (6.18)
u = w^y,
w e M, y e No.
Then for those x e ft satisfying (6.17), 5 < \u{x)\ < \w{x)\ + \y{x)\ < \w{x)\ + 5/2. Hence, \y{x)\ < 5/2 < \w{x)\
(6.19) and
\u{x)\
(6.20)
<2\w{x)\
for ah such x. Furthermore, by assumption (^i),
>\Mv->^o
[ u^dx-cj {\Mu\'^ J\u\<5 J\u\>5
>\\u\\l-\4u\\'-c[
^\Mu\)dx
\Mu\^)dx J\u\>5
(6.21)
> \\w\\% - \o\\w\\^ -c
I \Mw\'^dx J2\w\>5
in view of the fact that \\y\%, = Ao||^|p and (6.20) holds. Note that
In
\Mw\Hx
= o{\\w\\l).
By (6.21), we see that (6.22)
^i^u)>{l-^-o{l))\\w\\l,
\\u\\
If the alternative (b) were not true, then there would be a sequence such that (6.23)
^{uk)^^,\\uk\\v=p.
If p is taken sufficiently small, (6.22) implies that ||I^/C||D -^ ^]\\yk\\v -^ PSince A^o is finite dimensional, there is a renamed subsequence such that Vk -^ yo in A^o. Thus, \\yo\\=P,Hyo)=0,
\yo{x)\<5/2,
xeQ.
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
148
PROBLEMS
Then, hypothesis (As) imphes that (6.24)
2F{x,yo{x))
< XoVoixf,
xeQ.
Since J [Xoyoixf
- 2F{x,yo{x))yx
= ^yo)
=0
and the integrand is > 0 a.e., by (6.24), we see that 2F{x,yo{x))
=Xoyo{xf,
xeft.
Let (/)(x) be any function in Co^(O). Then for t > 0 sufficiently small, t-^ (2F(x, yo + t(/)) - Xo{yo + t(l)f - 2F(x, yo) + Ao?/g) < 0. Letting t ^ 0, we see that (/(x, yo) - \oyo)(t>{x) < 0,
x eVt.
Since yo ^ NQ, it follows that the conclusion (a) of the lemma holds.
D
Proof of Theorem 6.1. We define (6.25)
^{u) = \\u\\l -2
f
F{x,u)dx.
Under our hypotheses. Lemmas 6.1-6.5 apply, and (6.26)
{^\u),v)
= 2{u, v)v - 2(/(.,^),.;),
u.veV.
By Lemma 6.6 we see that there are positive constants e, p such that (6.27)
^u)>s,
\\u\\v = P
unless Au = Xou = / ( x , u ) ,
(6.28)
ueV\{0}
has a solution. This would give a nontrivial solution of (6.10). We may therefore assume that (6.27) holds. Next we note that ^±Reo)/R^
[ {F{x, ±Reo)/R^el}eldx -oo Jn as i? ^ oo. By hypothesis (A4), since eo ^ 0 a.e. Since ^(0) = 0 and (6.27) holds, we can now apply the usual mountain pass theorem to conclude that there is a sequence {uk} C V such that (6.29)
= \\eo\\l-2
^Uk) -^c>e,
^'{uk) ^ 0.
6.2.
PROOFS
149
Then (6.30)
^{uk)
= PI-'^
I F{x, Uk)dx -^ c
and (6.31)
{^\uk),Uk)
= 2pl - 2{f{',Uk),Uk)
= o{pk),
where pk = ||t^fe||D. Assume t h a t pk -^ oo, and let Uk = Uk/pk- Since ||i//c||D = 1, there is a renamed subsequence such t h a t Uk ^ u weakly in P , strongly in Lf^^{n) and a.e. in O. By (6.26)-(6.30), ^loci cy
Let Oi = {x G O : u{x) ^ 0 } ,
Liu
UJJL
7
1.
O2 = O \ O i . Then by hypothesis {A4),
2F{x,Uk)^2
2—^k ^k
^00,
^o
X e
ih-
If Oi has a positive measure, then ^
u1 dx >
u1 dx -\-
^
W{x) dx -^ 00.
Thus, the measure of Oi must be 0, i.e., we must have u = Oa.e. Moreover, / i F ( x , Uk) - Ukfjx,
Uk) ^2 ^
/^
-1
But by hypothesis (E),
^k
%
which implies t h a t (/i/2) — 1 < 0, contrary to assumption. Hence, the pk are bounded. Therefore, there is a subsequence which converges weakly in V to a limit i^. For any compact subset OQ C O , t h e imbedding of HQ^{ft) in I/^(Oo) is compact. Thus, we may find a subsequence which converges to u in I/^(Oo). For a subsequence, Uk ^ u Si. e. in OQ. By taking a set of compact subsets of O which exhaust O, we can find a renamed subsequence which not only converges to u weakly in P , but also strongly in I/^(Oo) for each compact subset QQ of Q and also a.e. in Q. We claim t h a t (6.32)
/ F{x,Uk)dx^ JQ
(6.33)
/ f{x,Uk)vdx^ JQ
(6.34)
/ f{x,Uk)ukdx^ JQ
/
F{x,u)dx;
JQ
/ f{x,u)vdx, JQ
/ JQ
f{x,u)udx.
v ^ V;
150
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
PROBLEMS
To see this, let ^r{t) be the continuous function defined by
(6.35)
Ut)
r = < [
t, r,
\t\ < r, t>r,
—r,
t < —r.
By (Ai), for a given £ > 0, chose r so large that (6.36)
\f{x,t)\<eM'^W-\
\t\>r
and that (6.37)
\F{x,t)-F{x,£^r{t))\<eM^\t\\
\t\>r.
Then (6.38)
/ (F(x, i^fe) - F{x, u))dx
(6.39)
= /
(F(x, ^fe) - F{x,
U^k))dx
J\uk\>r
(6.40)
+ / {F{x, ^r{uk)) - F{x, Jn
(6.41)
+/
Uu))dx
{F{x,Cr{u))-F{x,u))dx.
J\uk\>r
By (6.37), the integrals of (6.39) and (6.41) are bounded by £ / iMukl'^dx < £c\\uk\\^ < £c. The integrand of (6.40) is majorized by cilM^riukM" + \M^r{uk)\ + \M^r{u)\^ + \M^r{u)\) < c{M^r^ + Mr), which is in L^. Thus, the integral in (6.40) converges to zero. These arguments imply that (6.32) is true. In a similar way, we may prove (6.33) and (6.34). Now, by (6.33), we readily have
Hence, i^ is a critical point of ^ . Noting that
6.2. PROOFS
151
we see that (6.34) implies that \Wk\\v^
/ Jn
f{x,u)udx=\\u\\jy.
Thus, Uk ^ u in V. We now obtain a weak solution of (6.10) satisfying ^{u) = c> £. Since ^(0) = 0, we see that u ^ 0. This completes the proof. D We postpone the proof of Theorem 6.2 until the next section. To prove Theorem 6.3, we shall need the following lemma. L e m m a 6.7. Under the hypothesis (A^), there is aT ^ 0 such that ^(Teo) < 0. Proof. We can assume that ||eo||D = 1. Thus, ^(Teo) = T^ - 2 / F(x, Teo) dx
[ eo{xfdx J\Teoix)\<5 M ^ ( | r e o r + |Teo|)
l\Teo(x)\>5
This can be made negative by taking T sufficiently small. L e m m a 6.8. Under the hypothesis (As), ^{u) ^ oo as
||I^||D
D -^ oo.
Proof. Suppose there is a sequence {u^} C V such that pk = \\uk\\ -^ cxo and ^{uk) < K. We write Uk = Wk ^ T^eo, Uk = Uk/pk, Wk = Wk/pk, Tk = Tk/Pki where Wk^e^. If Ai > AQ is the next point in the spectrum of A^ then \i\\w\\^ < \\w\\l, and w^e^. Thus ^{uk) = \\uk\\l - Xohkf
- 2 / Q{x,Uk) dx Jn
>(l-^)lkfe|||)-2 [
>{l-^)\\wk\\l-2
Q{x,uk)dx
[ W{x)dx.
The only way this would not converge to oo is if ||I(;/C||D is bounded. But then II'^/CIID -^ O5 and \Tk\ -^ 1. Since ||i//c||D = 1, there is a renamed subsequence
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
152
PROBLEMS
such that Uk ^ u weakly in P , strongly in I/^^^^(0) and a.e. in O. Since w = 0 and \T\ = 1, we have u{x) = Teo{x) ^ 0 a.e. Hence, \uk{x)\ = pk\uk{x)\ -^ oo a.e. Therefore,
/ Q{x,Uk) dx -^ —oo, showing that ^{uk) -^ oo. This
completes the proof of the lemma.
D
Proof of Theorem 6.3. Let S = infx) ^ . Then we may find a sequence {uk} C V such that ^{uk) -^ S. By Lemma 6.8, we must have ||I^/C||D < C. Hence, there is a renamed subsequence such that Uk ^ u weakly in P , strongly in L'i^^{Q) and a.e. in O. Now,
= \\u\\'^ - 2 /
F{x,u)dx
= hkWv -2((^fe -u),u)v - 2 / F{x,Uk)dx^2 JQ
- \\uk -u\\^ / {F{x,Uk) -
F{x,u))dx
JQ
< ^{uk) - 2{{uk -u),u)v^2
/ (F(x, Uk) - F{x, u))dx. Jn
Similar to (6.32), it is easily seen that / F{x^Uk)dx ^
I
F{x^u)dx.
We therefore have the limit ^(u) < S, by which we conclude that ^\u) = 0 and ^{u) = S. Hence, i^ is a weak solution of (6.4). We see from Lemma 6.7 that 6^ < 0. Since ^(0) = 0, we see that u j^ 0. This completes the proof. D
6.3
The Eigenvalue Problem
Theorem 6.9. Assume that {Ai)-{A4) hold. Then for almost every (3 G (0,1), the equation (6.42) has a nontrivial solution. infinitely many solutions.
Au = (3f{x,u) In particular, the eigenvalue problem (6.42) has
We also make the following conditions. (Ag) There are a (5 > 0 and a A < AQ such that 2F{x,t) < At^,
n.
\t\ < 6, x e
6.3. THE EIGENVALUE
PROBLEM
153
(Aio) Either / F{x, Reo) dx/R^ ^ oo as R ^ oo or /
F{x,-Reo)dx/R'^
oo as R ^ oo.
Theorem 6.10. If we replace hypothesis (As) in Theorem 6.9 with (Ag) and {A^) with (Aio); then (6.42) has a nontrivial solution for almost every
/?e(0,Ao/A). Theorem 6.11. If we replace hypothesis (Ag) in Theorem 6.10 with (All)
F{x,t)/t'^
-^ 0 uniformly as t ^ 0,
then (6.42) has a nontrivial solution for almost every (3 G (0, 00).
We shall also need the following extension of Theorem 6.4. Lemma 6.12. Let 1 < A < B < 00. Under hypotheses {Ai)-{A4), for each tv > 0 sufficiently small (not depending on A), we have (6.43)
^ A ( ^ ) := MMv
- 2 / F{x,u)dx
> (A - 1)/^^
If we replace hypothesis (As) with hypothesis A < B < 00, then we have (6.44)
q>^^u)>lx-^\n\
||^||D = K..
(AQ), assuming 1 < A/AQ <
\\u\\T, = n.
Proof. Let Ai > AQ be the next point in the spectrum of A, and let A^o denote the eigenspace of AQ. We take M = NQ- H V. By hypothesis (^2), there is a ^c > 0 such that ||^||D < n ^ \y{^)\ ^ ^/2, V ^ ^o- Assume that u ^ V satisfies (6.45)
II^IID < /^and \u{x)\ > S
for some x G O. We write u = w -\- y, w ^ M, y ^ NQ. Then for those x G O satisfying (6.45) we have that 5 < \u{x)\ < \w{x)\ + \y{x)\ < \w{x)\ + (5/2).
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
154
PROBLEMS
Hence, \y{x)\ < S/2 < \w{x)\. It follows that \u{x)\ < 2\w{x)\
(6.46)
for all such x. By assumption (^i), we have that
u^dx -c [ (|M^|^ + M'^luDdx > X\\u\\l -Xo [ J\u\<5 J\u\>5 > A||^|||,-Ao||^f-c /
{Mul'^dx
f\u\>6
> (A - 1)11^111, + All^lll, - Aoll^f - c /
\Mw\^dx
J2\w\>5
in view of the fact that ||^|||) = Ao||^|p. Thus, by assumption (Ai) again, (6.47)
$^(u)>{X-l)\\y\\l+(^X-^^-c,\\w\\l-'y\w\\l,
We take /^ > 0 to satisfy 1 —
AQ/AI
^x{u) > (A - l)/^2 ^ f x - ^ -
Mr, < n.
> ci/^^~^. This gives cm^-^ -\^l\\\w\\l>{\-
l)n\
where ||I^||D = n. Hence, (6.43) holds. To prove (6.44) under hypothesis (Ag), let T] = A/Ao and A = (?^, 6 ) . Under hypothesis (Ag) we have in place of (6.47) (6.48) for
||I^||D
$,(^.) > (A - ^)\\y\\l + f A - A _ c,\\wr^^\ < t^. We take ^c > 0 to satisfy
T]
\\w\\l
— A/Ai > ci^c^~^. It follows that
^A(^)
> (A - r^)^^ + (^ - ^ - ^ 1 ^ ' " ' - ^ + ^ ) ll^lll)
for
||I^||D
= n. This gives (6.44), and the proof is complete.
D
We now turn to the proofs of Theorems 6.9 and 6.10. We shall prove Theorem 6.10 first by applying Theorem 5.7 and Lemma 6.12.
6.3. THE EIGENVALUE
PROBLEM
155
Proof of Theorem 6.10. We take ^ = P , A = (?^, 6 ) , where ?^ = A/AQ, B > 1 is a finite number, and I{u) = \\u\\l,
J(u) = 2 / F{x, u) dx.
By Proposition 5.6, the sets A± = [0,^6^060], B = {x e V : \\x\\j) = K.} link each other if 6^0 > tv. In our case the condition (Ai) of Theorem 5.7 is satisfied. To verify (As) of Theorems 5.7, we first observe that ^^(i^) = 0 is equivalent to (6.42) with f3 = 1/A. Now by hypothesis (Ag), at least one of the limits holds: ^ 0 0 as 6^0 ^ 00. Hence, for 6^0 sufficiently large, one of the inequalities ^A(±^oeo)/^o' < ©lleolll) - 2 [{F{x,±Soeo)/S^ <0 Jn holds. Thus, ao{X) < 0, A G A. Furthermore, it follows from Lemma 6.12 that (6.44) holds. Hence, 60(A) > (A - ?^)/^^, A G A. This shows that condition (^3) holds. We now apply Theorem 5.7 to conclude that for almost all A G A, there exists an Uk{X) G V such that sup ||i^fc(A)|| < 00, ^^(i^fc(A)) -^ 0 k and that ^x{uk{X)) -^ a{X) > 60(A). Once we know that the sequence {uk} is bounded, we can apply an idea similar to that used in the proof of Theorem 6.1 to conclude that there is a solution of ^^x{u) = 0, ^A('^) = «(A). From the definition, we see that a(A) > {\ — r])H?. Hence, the equation ^^(i^) = 0 has a nontrivial solution for almost every A G A. Since B was arbitrary, the result follows. D Proof of Theorem 6.9. It suffices to choose A = Ao and show that condition (744) implies hypothesis (Aio). To see this, we note by hypothesis (^4) and the fact that eo(x) ^ 0 a.e. that / ^ F ( x , ±6^060) (ix _ as 6^0 ^ 00.
r F(x, ±6^060) . 2 . n
Proof of Theorem 6.11. We let £ > 0 be an arbitrary number. By condition (All), there is a (5 > 0 such that F{x,t)/t^ < e for \t\ < 5 and x G O. By Theorem 6.10, equation (6.42) has a nontrivial solution for a.e. (3 G (0, Ao/e). Since £ was arbitrary, the result follows. D
CHAPTER 6. SUPERLINEAR
156 Proof of Theorem 6.2. By A G (1,B), there exists a ux (A — l)hi^. Choose An ^ 1, that ^x^{un) = 0, ^x^{un) may assume that bo{l) > £ >
PROBLEMS
Theorem 6.9, for each arbitrary B > 1 and a.e. such that ^^(I^A) = 0 and ^A('^A) = «(A) > A^ > 1. Then there exists a sequence Un such = a{Xn) > a(l) > &o(l)- By Lemma 6.4, we 0. Therefore,
We claim that {un} is bounded. Indeed, if ||i^n||D -^ oo, let w^ = u^/Wu^WvThen Wn ^ w weakly in P , strongly in L'i^^{ft) and a.e. in O. If i(; ^ 0 in P , then c
>
2F{x,Un) , I —^ ^—^^
Jn \K
Wn\ dx
>
[
^^^^^^f^\w^\'dx-
Jw^O -^
^n
[
W,{x)dx
Jw=0
OO
and we get a contradiction. However, if i(; = 0 in P , we define a constant tn G [0,1] satisfying ^A^(^n'^n) = max ^A^(^'^n)- For any c > 0 and iD^ = cwn, we have J^ i^(^, w^) dx -^ 0. Thus, ^X^itnUn)
> ^X^{cWn)
= C^K - 2 / F{x,Wn)dx
> C^/2
for n sufficiently large. That is, lim ^Xr^{tnUn) = OO,
(^';^ ( t ^ ^ ^ ) , ^n) = 0.
It follows that, ^Xr^{tnUn) {f{x,tnUn)tnUn ij\X^
tfiUfij
- 2F{x,tnUn))
dx
dx
OO.
By hypothesis (AQ), ^A^('^n) =
/ L{x^Un)dx
> / L{x^tnUn)dx
-^ oo.
However, we have the following estimates which contradict the above conclu-
6.3. THE EIGENVALUE
PROBLEM
157
sion: <
sup
^x^{{l - s)u)
sG[0,l] ,ueA
<
sup
^Q{{1
- s)u)
sG[0,l] ,ueA < c.
Thus, II^^IID < C. Then, ^^u^) -^ 0, ^{u^) -^ a(l) > 6o(l). We can now use the same arguments as those used in the proof of Theorem 6.1 to obtain the desired solution. D Notes and Comments. There were several papers where the authors tried to weaken the A. Ambrosetti-P. Rabinowitz superquadratic condition. We refer the readers to L. Jeanjean [191, 193] and L. Jeanjean-J. F. Toland [196], Z. Liu-Z. Q. Wang [237], M. Willem-W. Zou [378], H. S. Zhou [384]. The theorems of this section were proved in M. Schechter-W. Zou [329]. The readers may go back to the end of Section 5.3 for the notes and comments about the eigenvalue problems.
Chapter 7
Systems with Hamiltonian Potentials Let ^ be a real Hilbert space with an inner product (•, •) and the associated norm || • ||. Let A and B be two bounded subsets of E such that A links B. We describe the situation in which there are two linear, bounded and invertible operators Bi,B2 : E ^ E and a functional H G C^(^,R) whose values are separated by BiB and B2A, i.e., sup H < inf H. Note that BiB and B2A B2A
BiB
become much more uncontrollable. We prove the existence of a critical point oi H without assuming the (PS) type conditions. This theory fits some special elliptic systems.
7.1
A Linking Theorem
Let E have an orthogonal decomposition E = E^ 0 E~ and let /^ > L Consider a family of C^(^,R)-functionals (7.1)
^x{u):=\{Oxz,z)-^{z),
Ae[l,K]
under the following assumptions: (Ai) There exist two bounded linear and selfadjoint operators 0'^^\0'^'^^ : ^ ^ ^ such that OA = A O ^ ^ ^ - O ^ ^ ) , A G [1,/^], where (O^i)^,^) > 0 for dl\ z e E and either {O'^^^z.z) ^ 00 or |(0^^^z,z) + ^ ( ^ ) | ^ 00 as
(A2) ^' is compact.
160
CHAPTER?.
SYSTEMS
WITH HAMILTONIAN
POTENTIALS
(A3) There exist two linear bounded invertible operators Bi,B2 : E ^ E such that the hnear operator B{X,u) := p-B^^e'^^^B2 : E' ^ E' for ah 6J > 0 and A G [1,/^] is invertible, where P~ is the projection over E-. For each p > 0, set (7.2)
S:={Biz:\\z\\=p,zeE+}.
Choose a fixed (7.3)
ZQ G ^ + \ { 0 }
and define
Q := {B2{TZQ + Z) : 0 < r < CT, ||Z|| < M , Z G
^-}
for cr > p and M > p. By dQ we denote the boundary of Q relative to the subspace B2{E~ 0span{zo}). Define Q :={i9 e C([0, l]x E,E) :i9 satisfies (Bi), (62) and (63)}, where (61) i^{t,z) = exp(^u;i{t,z)Os,)z
^W{t,z),
where 5^ G [l,/^],cj^ : [0,1] x
i=l
E -^ [0, +00) is continuous and maps bounded sets to bounded sets; l y : [0,1] X ^ ^ ^ is compact; 1^(0, z) = 0 for any z e E; W{t, z) = 0 for any {t,z) G [0,1] x dQ. (62) i9{t,z) = z,
\/zedQ,\/te
[0,1].
(63) i?(0,z) = z,VzGQ. We note that 'd := id e 6 . Moreover, f3{t,'d{t,u)) G 6 for each 1^,(3 e S. We also recall the following proposition. Proposition 7.1. Le^ E be a Hilbert space and let P : E ^ E be compact. Then for any £ > 0, there exists a PQ : E ^ E such that PQ is compact, locally Lipschitz continuous and | | P ( ^ ) - P o ( ^ ) | | <s,
\/ueE.
Proof. For any i^ G ^ , set Uu:={veE:
\\v - u\\ < 1, \\P{u) - P{v)\\ < s}.
Then {UU}U€E is an open covering of £^ and then has a locally finite refinement {Vi}. Let Pi{u) = dist(u, E\Vi),
7i(^t) = ^ ^ ^ ^ .
7.1. A LINKING THEOREM
161
Then {jiiu)} is a locally Lipschitz continuous partition of unity (cf. Proposition 1.3). By the construction, for each Vi we have di Ui e E such that {P{u) - P{u,),v)
< s\\vl
\/ueV,,veE;
V, C U^^.
Evidently, -f^{u){P{u) - P{ui),v) < e-i,{u)\\vl
\/u,v e E.
It follows that (P(u) -J2^iiu)Piui),v)
< e\\v\\,
Wu,veE.
i
Define i
Then PQ is a convex combination of compact mappings. One readily checks that Po satisfies all the requirements of this proposition. D Theorem 7.2. Assume that {Ai)-{As) S > g > 0 such that ^ A ( ^ ) ^ ^5 ^A(^)
^
Wz e S
Q^
VZ G
dQ
hold and that there exist constants
uniformly for A G [1, /^], uniformly for A G
[1,K];
then for almost all A G [l^f^], there exists a bounded sequence {zn} such that ^ ^ ( z , ) ^ 0;
^A(^n) ^ ^A := inf sup
^ A ( ^ ( 1 , Z))
> S.
Hence, ^\ has a positive critical value > 5 for almost all A G [I, K]. Proof. We first show that (7.4)
i9{l,Q)nS^9,
Wee.
For any 'd{t, z) = exp C^uji{t, z)Os,)z + W{t, z) G 6 , where (jOi{t^ z) > 0, 5^ G [1, ^i^] for z = 1 , . . . , n-,^, define w{t,z) :=
^Ui{t,z). i=l
162
CHAPTER?.
SYSTEMS
WITH HAMILTONIAN
POTENTIALS
For any fixed (t, z), if w{t, z) = 0, then ^{t, z) = z -^ W{t, z); if w{t, z) ^ 0, we let K{t,z) :=
(^uji{t,z)si)/w{t,z).
Then K{t,z) G [l,n] and '^(t, z) = exp(tx7(t, ^)OA(t,^))z + W{t, z). Define 5 := B{t,s,z)
:= P~5]"^exp(^tx7(t, ^2(5^0 + z))OA(t,52(5zo+^)))^2,
for t G [0,1], 5 > 0, z G E~. By assumption (A3), 5 is invertible for any (t, 5, z) e [0,1] X [0, a]xE~. Consider the map H{t, 5, z) : [0,1] x [0, a]xE~ -^ E defined by H{t, 5, z) := stzQ + B-^p-B:[^W{t,
^2(5^0 + z)).
Then H is compact. Let
B^, := {zeE-:
\\z\\ < M}
and define Kt : [0, cr] x B^ ^ R x ^ as follows: i^t(5, z) := ( t | | 5 f i/i(t, ^2(5^0 + z))\\ + 5(1 - t),
z + y(t, 5, z)) .
To prove (7.4), it suffices to show that the equation Ki{s,z) = (p, 0) has a solution in [0, cr] x B^. Obviously, the operator Kt is a compact perturbation of the identity which has the following properties: Ko{s,z) = {s,z), i.e., KQ = z(i. Moreover, for any (5, z) G ^([0,cr] x 5 ^ ) , ^2(5^0 + ^) ^ dQ and hence iy(t, ^2(5^0 + z)) = 0,
i^(t, ^2(5^0 + z)) = B2{szo + z).
If Kt(5, ^) = (p, 0) for some (5, z) G ^([0, cr] x 5 ^ ) , that is, 5tZo + Z = 0,
t||5i-^52(5Zo + ^)|| + 5(1 -t)
= p,
then we get a contradiction since 0 < p < a. By the properties of the LeraySchauder degree: deg(K,,[0,(7] x 5 ^ , ( p , 0 ) ) = deg(Ko,[0,(7] x 5 ^ , ( p , 0 ) ) = deg(z(i, [0, cr] X 5 ^ , ( p , 0 ) ) = 1.
7.1. A LINKING THEOREM
163
It follows that the equation Ki{s,z) = (p, 0) has a solution in [0,cr] x 5 ^ , which implies (7.4). Obviously, by (7.4), we see that dx > S > 0 uniformly for A G [1,K].
_ ddx Since the mapping X ^ dx is non-decreasing, the derivative d^ : ^ ' dX exists for almost every A G [1,/^]. We just consider those A where (i^ exists. For a fixed A G [1,/^), let A^ G [l,/^],An > A and A^ ^ A as n ^ oo, then there exists n(A) such that (7.5)
^1 - 1 < "^^ ~ t^ < d'x + 1. for ^ > ^(^)An — A We show, for almost all A G [1,/^], that there exist 'dn ^ B,/i:o := /i:o(A) > 0 such that (7.6)
||^n(l,^)|| < ko
whenever
^xiM^.u))
> dx - (A^ - A).
For this, by the definition of dx^, there exists i^n ^ ^ such that (7.7)
SUp^A(^n(l,^)) < S U p ^ A j ^ n ( l , ^ ) ) < ^ A . + ( A n - A ) .
ueQ
ueQ
If ^A('^n(l,'^)) ^ dx — (An — A) for some i^ G Q, by assumption (^i), (7.5) and (7.7), we have that (7.8)
(0(l)i^n(l,^),^n(l,^))<^l+3.
Therefore, (7.9)
(0<2^^„(1, w), ^„(1, u)) + $(u) < K(d^ + 3) - dA + 'J
and (0(2)t?„(l, u), t?„(l, u)) + $(u) > -dA - K\d'^ + 2|.
(7.10)
Combining {Ai) and (7.8)-(7.10), we may find a A:o(A) := /CQ, which depends only on A, such that ||'^n(l5'^)|| ^ ^o- By the choice oi'd^ and (7.7), it follows that (7.11) ^ A ( ^ n ( l , ^ ) ) < ^ A j ^ n ( l , ^ ) ) < G^A. + ( A n - A ) < (iA + ( ^ + 2 ) ( A n - A)
for all u ^ Q. For each e > 0, let (7.12)
n,{X) :={ueE:
\\u\\ < A:o + 3, | ^ A ( ^ ) -
^A|
< s}.
164
CHAPTER?.
SYSTEMS
WITH HAMILTONIAN
POTENTIALS
By the definition of dx and (7.6), it is easily seen that ^^(A) ^ 0. Now w