Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page i
THE CULTURES AND GLOBALIZATION SERIES
...
43 downloads
3599 Views
26MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page i
THE CULTURES AND GLOBALIZATION SERIES
CULTURAL EXPRESSION, CREATIVITY AND INNOVATION
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page ii
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page iii
THE CULTURES AND GLOBALIZATION SERIES
CULTURAL EXPRESSION, CREATIVITY AND INNOVATION Edited by
HELMUT ANHEIER YUDHISHTHIR RAJ ISAR Guest editor Christopher Waterman
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Introduction and Editorial Arrangement © Helmut Anheier and Yudhishthir Raj Isar 2010, Chapters © Contributors 2010 First published 2010 Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form, or by any means, only with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction, in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers. SAGE Publications Ltd 1 Oliver’s Yard 55 City Road London EC1Y 1SP SAGE Publications Inc. 2455 Teller Road Thousand Oaks, California 91320 SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd B 1/I1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area Mathura Road New Delhi 110 044 SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd 33 Pekin Street #02-01 Far East Square Singapore 048763
Library of Congress Control Number 2009925322 British Library Cataloguing in Publication data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 978-1-4129-2085-8 ISBN 978-1-4129-2086-5 (pbk)
Typeset by C&M Digitals (P) Ltd, Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain by Ashford Colour Press Ltd Printed on paper from sustainable resources
Page iv
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page v
CONTENTS
Foreword by Stuart Hall Acknowledgements Contributors List of boxes, figures, photos, plates and tables
Introduction
ix xiii xvi xxiv
1
Yudhishthir Raj Isar and Helmut K. Anheier PART 1
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
Overarching Issues
17 19
1
Creativity: Alternative Paradigms to the ‘Creative Economy’ Rustom Bharucha
21
2
Recognition and Artistic Creativity Joni Maya Cherbo and Harold L. Vogel
37
3
Walking with the Devil: Art, Culture and Internationalization Gerardo Mosquera
47
4
… But What Is The Question? Art, Research and the Production of Knowledge Gilane Tawadros
57
5
Improvising in a World of Movement: Transit, Transition and Transformation Maruška Svašek
62
6
Diasporic Spaces: Migration, Hybridity and the Geocultural Turn Keith Nurse
78
7
Creativity and Intellectual Property Rights Jason Toynbee
86
8
Exile, Culture and Identity Rasoul Nejadmehr
99
9
The ‘Creativity’ of Evil? Dragan Klaic
105
Regional Realities
111
10
The ‘Creator’ as Entrepreneur: An African Perspective Paul Brickhill
113
11
The Turn of the Native: Vernacular Creativity in the Caribbean Annie Paul
124
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page vi
vi CONTENTS 12
Creative Contemporary Design in the Arab World Huda Smitshuijzen AbiFarès
13
Cultural Policing in South Asia: An Anti-globalization Backlash Against Freedom of Expression? Laurent Gayer, Christophe Jaffrelot and Malvika Maheshwari
14
The Struggle to Express, Create and Represent in the Balkans Zala Volcic
15
Creative Economy, Global City: Globalizing Discourses and the Implications for Local Arts Lily Kong
131
148
158
166
Genres and Issues
177
16
The Cycles of Creativity in the Music Industry Peter Tschmuck
179
17
Creative Communities and Emerging Networks Clayton Campbell
189
18
Creative Spaces Nancy Duxbury and Catherine Murray
200
19
Literary Hybrids and the Circuits of Translation: The Example of Mia Couto Stefan Helgesson
215
20
Emergences in Digital Culture Ivani Santana
225
21
Fashion and Ethics: Reinventing Models of Consumption and Creativity in a Global Industry Mo Tomaney and Julie Thomas
235
22
Creativity and Innovation: The Role of Philanthropy Diana Leat
245
23
Digital Networks and Social Innovation: Strategies of the Imagination Eugenio Tisselli
261
24
Closing Reflections Christopher Waterman
273
Colour Plate Section
287
PART 2
299
2.1
INDICATOR SUITES
Cultural Indicator Suites: An Introduction Helmut K. Anheier and Michael Hoelscher
301
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page vii
CONTENTS
vii
2.2
Creativity Indexes Enrico Bertacchini and Walter Santagata
307
2.3
Measuring Creativity and Innovation Michael Hoelscher
317
Data Suites
329
Policy Regulatory Frameworks, Levi Brooks and JJ Kaye, designers Digest: Regulatory Frameworks Intellectual Property, Levi Brooks and JJ Kaye, designers Digest: Intellectual Property
330 330
Investment Education, Luca de Sanctis Barton, designer Digest: Education Philanthropy, Leon Hong and Camile Orillaneda, designers Digest: Philanthropy Research & Development, Leon Hong and Camile Orillaneda, designers Digest: Research and Development
338 338
Diversity Institutions, Mylinh Trieu Nguyen, designer Digest: Institutions Membership in Organizations, Donnie Luu, designer Digest: Membership in Organizations Practices & Participation Events, Jono Brandell, designer Digest: Events Places: Indicators for six cities, Ryan Weafer, designer Digest: Places Migration, Fei Liu, designer Digest: Migration
352 352
Creativity and Hybridity Creativity & Innovation Indices, design Christo Allegra, designer Digest: Creativity and Innovation Indices Hybridity Languages, Vincent Cordero, designer Digest: Languages The Blogosphere, Lindsay Harvey, designer Digest: The Blogosphere ECO Trends and Innovation, Derek Heath and Katherine Wu, designers Digest: ECO Trends and Innovation Music, Alok Jethanandani, designer Digest: Music New & Syncretic Religions, Christopher Tuyay, designer Digest: New and Syncretic Religions Dance, Sheriah Altobar, designer Digest: Dance Forms
374 374
334
344 348
356
360 366 370
378 382 386 390 394 398
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page viii
viii CONTENTS Hip Hop, Alyssa Wang, designer Digest: Hip Hop Reality TV, Jason Hanakeawe, designer Digest: Reality TV Body Art, Tiffany Payakniti, designer Digest: Body Art Web 2.0, Stephen Sulistiawan, designer Digest: Web 2.0 2.4
Creativity, Innovation, Globalization: What International Experts Think Helmut K. Anheier and Michael Hoelscher
403 406 410 414
421
References: Data Suites & Digests
437
Index
453
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page ix
FOREWORD Stuart Hall
This collection of essays follows through the line of inquiry opened up by the two previous volumes in The Cultures and Globalization Series. The aim of the series is to track the complex inter-relations between globalization and culture in its many forms in the contemporary world. Volume 3 identifies a particular site of such interactions defined by the inter-relationships between three aspects of the wider question: creativity and innovation, cultural expressions and globalization. The essays and papers collected here offer, from a variety of perspectives, a rich exploration of this field. They present a diverse set of examples and deepen our understanding and conceptualization of the complexities involved in these relationships. The three terms are fully defined in the wide-ranging introductory essay which frames the volume. Here, we try to set the stage for that investigation by looking briefly at the way the concepts have undergone significant changes of meaning in recent years and how these shifts affect their field of operations in the contemporary period. Creativity refers to the capacity, through imagination or invention, to produce something new and original (hence its close relationship to innovation). Innovation underscores the role which the idea of novelty has come to play in modern creative practices and the high value accorded to originality, Modernism’s injunction to ‘make it new’, the significance placed on breaking traditions and the construction of radically new forms. Cultural expressions refer to the many forms in which the values, experiences, ideas, identities, beliefs, hopes, achievements and aspirations of a people or social group find expression and take significant – and signifying – form. Globalization marks the emerging inter-relationships and inter-dependences – economic, political, cultural – between different societies and parts of the world. Its contemporary form defines the new terrain on which cultural practices interact and the ‘global’ character which creativity, innovation and cultural expressions assume in their contemporary form. In western culture, much reinforced by Romanticism, creativity has been associated with the gifted individual, touched by genius, who is uniquely capable of bringing aesthetic expression to a high pitch of excellence. This excludes many of those civilizations in which the association of creativity with the individual is not so strong (which,
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
x
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page x
FOREWORD
of course, does not mean that individual practitioners have not been of significance in cultural practices and expression). In western societies, creativity implying a social group, rather than an individual authorship, is relatively new. More recently the terms creativity and innovation have been expanded to include many fields other than the aesthetic; and, more recently still, assimilated to technological, commercial, managerial practices, in self-inflating and commodified ways which make them virtually unusable. All these terms have been significantly redefined in recent decades and in general the principal shift of direction is from the individual to the social and collective. This reflects the application of sociological and anthropological concepts to cultural fields, originally thought of primarily in aesthetic terms. It entails the shift from ‘culture’ as the sum of particular works, texts and objects which constitute an ideal order against which universal judgements of value can be made – what Matthew Arnold once called ‘the best that has been thought and said’ – to what Raymond Williams called the social definition of culture: ‘a particular way of life which expresses certain meanings and values not only in art and learning but also in institutions and ordinary behaviour’1: culture as ‘ways of life’. This has shifted the location of cultural creativity and expressions, from the domain of high culture to the terrain of the popular, collective and everyday life. The redefinition also has to do with the transformation – one might even say the collectivisation or ‘massification’ – of social processes, which emerged in developed western societies at the end of the nineteenth/beginning of the twentieth centuries. This process has given us such terms as mass production, mass society, mass politics – and of course, mass media, mass communication and mass culture. It marked the reorganization of social production and consumption along more ‘Fordist’ lines, and was facilitated by the rise to dominance of the new mass technologies of culture. In his famous essay, ‘The Work of Art In The Age Of Mechanical Reproduction’, Walter Benjamin, anticipating the explosion in visual culture which was to come in the twentieth century, saw film as one of the earliest manifestations of this collective and technological transformation. He identified this not only in terms of the collective nature of cultural production and its relationship to its audiences but also in terms of the effects he predicted this would have in destroying what he called the ‘authenticity’ associated with the idea of ‘originality’ in art, the detaching of the work from, and the shattering of, tradition, and the destruction of the ‘aura’ of the individual artist and the individual work of art, still very much alive and kicking today. Theodor Adorno called these new technologies ‘the cultural industries’ but he intended to contrast these typical products of an ‘administered’, one-dimensional mass society with the critical and dialectical function which he thought could only be performed by the individual artist and the work of art. Though the tensions between high, mass and popular culture continue to resonate in cultural debates, few would find it possible these days not to regard these new media and technologies as potential sites of creativity and innovation. So when we say creativity, innovation or cultural expressions today, we must be conscious of the fact that we say them, as it were, after these great transformations in meaning, technologies and relationships have occurred. Globalization is the most radically transformed and transforming of all the terms. Ever since the moment of European exploration and conquest at the end of the fifteenth century, (which Marx identified as the beginning of a struggle to make the globe ‘a world market’), there have been successive waves of what can only be called ‘globalizations’. And since they involved, in different forms, conquest and the crossing of frontiers, the clash of cultures and traditions and the exercise of power in the ‘conscription’ of traditional cultures to modernity, they still have something important to tell us about what happens to cultural processes when distances, societies and economies are brutally condensed. However, there is nothing to compare with the scale and depth of contemporary globalization. The time–space condensations, the new global division of labour, the speed of the flows of capital, investment, profits, goods, services, images, messages
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xi
FOREWORD
and stories, the driving power and trans-national reach of the new cultural industries, the emergence of a ‘global’ consumer market inter-connected with the permeation of cultural models, information, goods, symbols, stories and languages across frontiers, the collision when different cultures, traditions, religious systems and forms of life are convened in the same space and struggle for rights and recognition, and – the dark underside of globalization – the trans-national character of migration and the movement and displacements of peoples: these constitute, if not an absolutely new historical reality, then a momentous epochal shift in global relations, which leave no relationships untouched. One feature is the way culture has become part and parcel of, harnessed to and mediating economic, geo-political and social relationships; and consequently the way the exercise of creativity, innovation and cultural expression has become intensely related to and caught up with the ‘play’ of power. These new features of contemporary globalization have transformed the meanings of these concepts out of sight. Globalization has therefore created new sites and arenas which, on the one hand, provide and enhance creative expressive possibilities, with groups and communities functioning as innovators in the role which the Introduction calls ‘social authorship’; at the same time – and for the same reason – they mark arenas of huge tension, resistance and difficulty. One powerful tendency in contemporary globalization follows from the permeation of cultural expressions in the flows across boundaries and frontiers. This is sometimes said to be a precondition of that ‘one world’ towards which globalization is supposed to be pointing us. It is sometimes argued that, in the post-colonial, free trade world, cultural globalization now operates on an ‘even playing field’; that the new global culture has no centre. This is to suggest that the one-way cultural flows characteristic of the imperial and colonizing moments have been surpassed. The most powerful tendency is certainly towards a kind of one-directional cultural homogenization, powered by trans-national flows, the cultural industries of the developed world and the new digital means of communication. It tends to favour the transmission of standardised products, standardized western models and meanings, using standardized western technologies and reflecting standardized western forms of everyday life. This has the effect of eroding local particularities and differences, producing in their place a western-oriented ‘world culture’, which bears the strong imprint of its sources of origin. The interplay between new cultural expressions and the rise of new consumer markets are part and parcel of the same process. The fact that cultural globalization has no one centre certainly does not mean that somehow cultural power has ceased to operate and that the power of the industrial and technological forces of modernity mediated by the western cultural industries have been suspended. The cultural field is not open or equal. It is not an ‘even playing field’. Contemporary globalization in all its aspects is a process of ‘combined and uneven development’ – ‘combined’ because it draws huge differences, disparities, historical divergences and temporalities together; ‘uneven’ because it creates greater disparities and inequalities – in resources, wealth, income, health, welfare, material well-being and cultural power – greater even than the differences and inequalities it claims to be surpassing. Paradoxically, however, creativity itself is not mal-distributed in this way. Those most marginalized in the global pecking order can, precisely, use their powers of creativity and innovation to describe and protest against the grim conditions of life these inequalities impose. The cultural fields into which these global forces penetrate are not an open, unstructured terrain either. They are densely constructed of impacted traditions, aesthetic values, belief systems, ways of life and creative forms and expressions which have long histories and coherences of their own. Though often represented as fixed and unchanging, they have in fact been modified over time, evolving and appropriating new materials. The consequences of the homogenizing processes, like the economic processes they mirror, are neither uniform nor are their effects as easy to predict as the power and
xi
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xii
xii FOREWORD reach of their economies and technologies would suggest. They have generated powerful defensive responses and resistances – fundamentalist or progressive – in the development of which creativity and innovation are necessary ingredients. In many places, the ‘debased’ cultural forms can and have been appropriated to local uses and meanings, borrowed, translated, indigenized and ‘vernacularized’ so as to express a very different kind of outlook and reality. To take just two examples: in what sense can the ‘soap opera’ about daily life, now a ubiquitous global popular form, any longer be said to be exclusively an ‘American’ form (though, in another perspective, it was indeed one of the great forms of American popular radio and television)? Or, to take another case: that great practitioner and innovator of reggae music, Bob Marley, used the most modern technological means of production (the sound system) and distribution (vinyl, the transistor radio) to make local rhythms ‘global’ and to transmit the styles, ways of life and troubles of Trench Town, a tiny, poverty-stricken and unknown urban community in the little-known island of Jamaica, familiar across the globe. Creative practitioners and innovators have been busy making the same forms and technologies speak of other different worlds. Diasporas where different peoples and cultures meet, occupy the same space and are often obliged to struggle against discrimination and racialized marginalization are, paradoxically, highly productive spaces, creatively producing a variety of new cultural forms and expressions which mark creative cross-overs. By translating between cultural languages, they create genuinely novel forms which, because they are hybridized, cannot be reduced to the original cultural sources and traditions which went into their making. Are these diasporas not also places where groups and communities can gradually lose touch with their authentic cultural origins and roots? This is never quite the zero-sum game which the beneficent term ‘creativity’ suggests. These crossings of cultural forms and models, the samplings and ‘versionings’, emerging where people are obliged to live together, struggle for space and speak across cultural languages are some of the most creative sites in the contemporary world. They may be the only places where displaced traditions – which in any event are not fixed forever in amber, but are more like what Paul Gilroy has called ‘the changing same’ – lose their absolute authority and inner certainties, and become more negotiable, translatable and open-weave. Perhaps this is indeed the nature of culture in modern global conditions: where that which seems unalterably fixed in the past, becomes an opening to the future. All displacements of peoples and migrations, as they say, ‘free’ or forced, always involve gains and losses. Indeed, to take the paradox one step further, the finding of significant form and voice for this sense of ‘loss’ and the ways memory intervenes to give it shape, are some of the most powerful sources of contemporary creative cultural expression. The terms creativity and innovation may soften or disguise the degree to which, in cultural collision of this kind, questions of identity, recognition and power are always ‘in play’. In this globalization ‘game’ there are no absolute winners and losers. Neither homogenization nor diversity can capture its contradictory movement and character. We lose everything if we force the contemporary forms of creativity and cultural expression into one or other end-point of this binary schema. Cultural globalization, like other aspects of the process, is profoundly and unalterably contradictory. We must continue to ‘speak it’ in this way. This volume of essays, in all their diversity of contents and theoretical perspectives, demonstrates the rich value of this paradoxical, oxymoronic approach.
Note 1
Williams, Raymond (1945) The Long Revolution. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xiii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Cultures and Globalization Series has relied on the support, advice and contributions of numerous individuals and organizations. We would endeavour to acknowledge and thank all of them here. In the ultimate analysis, however, the co-editors alone are responsible for this final version of the publication.
International Advisory Board Hugo Achugar (Uruguay) Arjun Appadurai (India/USA) Benjamin Barber (USA) Hilary Beckles (Barbados) Tony Bennett (United Kingdom) Craig Calhoun (USA) Georges Corm (Lebanon) Mamadou Diouf (Senegal) Yehuda Elkana (Israel/Hungary) Yilmaz Esmer (Turkey) Sakiko Fukuda-Parr (Japan/USA) Mike Featherstone (United Kingdom) Anthony Giddens (United Kingdom) Nathan Gardels (USA) Salvador Giner (Spain) Xavier Greffe (France) Stuart Hall (Jamaica/United Kingdom) Seung-Mi Han (Korea) David Held (United Kingdom) Vjeran Katunaric (Croatia) Nobuku Kawashima (Japan) Arun Mahizhnan (Singapore) Achille Mbembe (Cameroon/South Africa) Candido Mendes (Brazil) Catherine Murray (Canada) Sven Nilsson (Sweden) Walter Santagata (Italy) James Allen Smith (USA) Prince Hassan bin Talal (Jordan) David Throsby (Australia) Jean-Pierre Warnier (France) Margaret Wyszomirski (USA) Yunxiang Yan (China/USA) George Yudice (USA)
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xiv
xiv ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Additional Support Text Boxes Karin Becker, Meghan Corroon, Todd Lester, Mailyn Machado, Ricardo Mbarkho, Peter Moertenbock, Helge Mooshammer, Ari Seligmann, Cylena Simonds, Nicole Vazquez, Indrasen Vencatachellum, Tereza Wagner
Research Coordination for Indicator Suites Meghan Corroon, Michael Hoelscher and Tia Morita
Research Assistance Antje Groneberg, Manar Nidah, Simon Scholtz, Nicole Vazquez, Elise Youn, Filip Zielinski, David Zimmer
Design and Production In this issue, indicator suites were designed by students and alumni of the Design and Media Arts programme (DMA) at UCLA under the direction of Willem Henri Lucas Alumni Christo Allegra, DMA MFA 2010 Jono Brandell, DMA 2008 Levi Brooks, DMA 2006 Luca de Sanctis Barton, DMA 2008 Leon Hong, DMA 2007 JJ Kaye, DMA 2007 Fei Liu, DMA 2008 Donnie Luu, DMA, 2008 Camile Orillaneda, DMA 2008 Mylinh Trieu Nguyen, DMA 2007 Ryan Weafer, DMA 2006 Students Sheriah Altobar, DMA Vincent Cordero, DMA Jason Hanakeawe, DMA Lindsay Harvey, DMA Derek Heath, DMA Alok Jethanandani, DMA Tiffany Payakniti, DMA Stephen Sulistiawan, DMA Christopher Tuyay, DMA Alyssa Wang, DMA Katherine Wu, DMA
Cover, chapter and divider artwork Emilia Birlo with input provided by Paul Kästner, Rudolf M. Anheier, Manual Birlo and Stella Birlo
Administration Jocelyn Guihama
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Financial Support We gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the following institutions: Asia Research Fund The Bank of Sweden Tercentenary Foundation Compagnia di San Paolo The Fritt Ord Institute The London School of Economics The Prince Claus Fund for Culture and Development The Sasakawa Peace Foundation Swedish International Development Agency UCLA International Institute UCLA School of the Arts and Architecture UCLA School of Public Affairs We would also like to acknowledge the support of: • Henrietta Moore and the faculty and staff of the Centre for the Study of Global Governance at the London School of Economics; • Stuart Cunningham and the entire faculty and staff of the Australia Research Council Centre of Excellence for Creative Industries and Innovation; • Sarah Gardner and Diane Dodd of the International Federation of Arts Councils and Culture Agencies; • Ursula Fischer of the Centre for Social Investment at Heidelberg University; • the University of Turin. Special thanks are owed to individuals and institutions in Sweden, who made it possible for the co-editors to organize the authors’ meeting for this volume at the Museum of World Culture in Gothenburg on 11–12 April 2009. On 10 April, the Series was presented at a public symposium on ‘Cultural Policy and Globalization’ held at the Museum, where participants were welcomed by Dr Lars Nordström, President of the Cultural Committee of the Västra Götaland region, where the city is located. The idea of such a symposium-cum-authors’ meeting was first discussed with Anna Thelin, then working at the Museum, at the 2008 Gothenburg Book Fair, where the Series was presented under the aegis of the Swedish International Development Agency (SIDA); the idea came to fruition thanks to the support of the Director of the Museum of World Culture, Margareta Alin, David Karlsson, then Secretary of Sweden’s Commission on Cultural Policy, and Mats Rolén of the Bank of Sweden Tercentenary Foundation. Catharina Bergil and Anna Thelin expertly coordinated the Museum’s support team which provided flawless logistics. Finally, the co-editors are most grateful to Tereza Wagner, Senior Programme Specialist in the Culture Sector of UNESCO. Formerly responsible for that organization’s activities in favour of artistic creation, she played a key role in helping us identify authors from around the world as contributors to the present volume (see also her text box, 20.1).
xv
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xvi
CONTRIBUTORS
Huda Smitshuijzen AbiFarès is founder and director of the Khatt Foundation, Center for Arabic Typography. She is the author of Arabic Typography: A Comprehensive Sourcebook, Experimental Arabic Type, Typographic Matchmaking, and many other articles on multilingual communication in the Middle East. She holds degrees in graphic design from Yale University’s School of Art and the Rhode Island School of Design and specializes in bilingual typographic research and design. She has taught typography and graphic design at the American University of Beirut. She was chair of the Visual Communication Department for three years at the American University in Dubai where she is Associate Professor of Graphic Design. Helmut Anheier (PhD Yale University, 1986) is Professor of Sociology at UCLA and Heidelberg University. He is the academic director of the Center for Social Investment at Heidelberg University, and director of the Center for Civil Society at UCLA’s School of Public Affairs. From 1998 to 2002 he was the founding director of the Centre for Civil Society at the London School of Economics, where he now holds the title of Centennial Professor. Prior to this he was a senior research associate at the Johns Hopkins University Institute for Policy Studies, and Professor of Sociology at Rutgers University. Before embarking on an academic career, Dr Anheier served as a Social Affairs Officer with the United Nations. Rustom Bharucha is an independent writer, director, and cultural critic. His publications include Theatre and the World; The Question of Faith; In the Name of the Secular; The Politics of Cultural Practice; Rajasthan: An Oral History and Another Asia. He is a leading authority on interculturalism and has been a consultant for the arts service organization Leveraging Investments in Creativity, New York, sponsored by the Ford Foundation. He was on the consultancy team of a report on cultural diversity commissioned by the Arts Council in Ireland. In India, he is the Project Director of Arna-Jharna: The Desert Museum of Rajasthan, committed to the traditional knowledge systems of the desert. Karin Becker is Professor of Media and Communication Studies at Stockholm University and was previously a professor at the National College of Art, Craft and Design (Konstfack) in Stockholm. She began her career in the mass communication and journalism programme at the University of Iowa, specializing in documentary photography and photojournalism, and moved to Sweden in the mid-1980s. Her research focuses on cultural histories and contemporary contexts of visual media practices, in the press, in museums, in private settings and in ethnographic research. Her English publications include Dorothea Lange and the Documentary Tradition (Louisiana State University Press, 1980), Picturing Politics: Visual and Textual Formations of Modernity in the Swedish Press (JMK/Stockholm University, 2000), as well as numerous journal articles and anthology contributions, and she is co-author of Consuming Media: Communication, Shopping and Everyday Life (Berg, 2007). Enrico Bertacchini is a researcher at the Department of Economics ‘Cognetti de Martiis’ at the University of Torino and a fellow of the EBLA Center and NEXA Center for Internet and Society. His main research interests are cultural economics, law and economics and economic issues concerning intellectual property rights and knowledge
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xvii
CONTRIBUTORS
sharing, with a particular focus on biodiversity and biotechnologies. He has recently worked as an external advisor for the Italian Ministry of Culture on the report on the role and impact of creative and cultural industries on the Italian economy released in May 2008. Paul Brickhill has worked continuously for twenty-eight years in African arts and culture. In 1997, he established Book Café, Zimbabwe’s largest performing arts programme, and founded African Synergy in 2002 which focused on intra-African cultural exchange and media. He also co-founded Luck Street Blues in 1995, a jazz band in Zimbabwe, playing tenor sax. He has worked at a senior policy level in book policy in Tanzania, Zimbabwe, Zambia and Mozambique. He has co-authored a 13-country study on African textbook provision (published 2005) and has written about 250 features on the performing arts and publishing. He helped set up the Zimbabwe International Book Fair 1990, the African Publishers’ Network (37 countries) in 1992, and the Pan-African Booksellers Association (14 countries) in 1997. Clayton Campbell is Artistic Director of the 18th Street Arts Center, Santa Monica; Artist Residency Advisor at United States Artists; Consultant to the Rockefeller Foundation Bellagio Residency Center; and a past President of the International Network of Residential Arts Centers (Res Artis). He has curated and organized over 250 artist residency projects within 26 countries. A visual artist himself, he also writes extensively for a range of arts journals. In 2002 he was named Chevalier de Arts et des Lettres by the French government for his work in international cultural exchange. Joni Maya Cherbo is an independent educator, writer and researcher who specializes in the arts and cultural policy. Dr Cherbo has had teaching positions at Hunter College, Columbia Presbyterian Hospital, the State University of New York and Purchase, and New York University, Arts Administration Program. She was the research director for the American Assembly’s think tank meeting, ‘The Arts and the Public Purpose’, developed the National Arts Policy Roundtable for Americans for the Arts, and is currently engaged in an initiative to enhance international cultural diplomacy efforts. Meghan Corroon is the research coordinator for The Cultures and Globalization Series. She recently obtained her Master’s degree in urban planning from the University of California, Los Angeles, and is pursuing a second Master’s degree in public health. Her research and professional interests are focused on global city networks and the effects of urbanization on health outcomes in Sub-Saharan Africa. She has worked on several international development projects for both USAID and the World Bank. Additionally, she has conducted research for organizations such as WaterAid UK, the International Medical Corps, and the International Council for Science. Nancy Duxbury is an adjunct professor in the School of Communication at Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, Canada. From 2005 to 2008 she was the executive director of the Centre of Expertise on Culture and Communities, a three-year research project on cultural infrastructure in Canadian cities and communities. Prior to that, she was Director of Research of the Creative City Network of Canada, and Cultural Planning Analyst at the City of Vancouver’s Office of Cultural Affairs. Her research has focused on cultural infrastructure, cultural policy, cultural indicators, the involvement of municipalities in cultural development, and book publishing. She is the lead author of Under Construction: The State of Cultural Infrastructure in Canada, and editor of Making Connections: Culture and Social Cohesion in the New Millennium (2005).
xvii
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
xviii
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xviii
CONTRIBUTORS
Laurent Gayer is a research fellow at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), attached to the Centre D’études et de Recherches Administratives et Politiques de Picardie (CURAPP), and a research associate at the Centre D’études de l’Inde et de l’Asie du Sud, Paris. He recently co-edited, with Christophe Jaffrelot, Milices Armées d’Asie du Sud: Privatisation de la Violence et Implication des Etats. Stefan Helgesson is a research fellow in the Department of Literature at Uppsala University. He has published widely on South African literature, lusophone literature, postcolonial theory and theories of world literature. He is the author of Writing in Crisis: History and Ethics in Gordimer, Ndebele and Coetzee (UKZN Press, 2004) and the editor of Volume 4 of Literary History: Towards a Global Perspective. His latest book, Transnationalism in Southern African Literature (Routledge), appeared in 2009. Michael Hoelscher is a lecturer in the Department of Sociology, Heidelberg University, Germany, and senior research fellow at the University of Oxford. His main fields of interest are cultural sociology, economic sociology, globalization processes, especially European integration, higher education and quantitative comparative methods. His publications include Wirtschaftskulturen in der Erweiterten EU (2006). Yudhishthir Raj Isar is Professsor of Cultural Policy Studies at the American University of Paris and Maitre de Conférences at the Institut d’Etudes Politiques de Paris (Sciences Po). An independent cultural advisor and public speaker, he also serves on the boards of several international cultural institutions and writes on a range of cultural topics. From 2004 to 2008 he was president of the international association Culture Action Europe. Previously, at UNESCO, he was Executive Secretary of the World Commission on Culture and Development; in 1986–87 he was Executive Director of The Aga Khan Program for Islamic Architecture at Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Christophe Jaffrelot is director of CERI (Centre d’Etudes et de Recherches Internationales) at Sciences Po (Paris), and research director at the CNRS (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique). He teaches South Asian politics to doctoral students at Sciences Po. His most recent publications include The Hindu Nationalist Movement and Indian Politics, 1925 to 1990s; India’s Silent Revolution: The Rise of the Lower Castes in North India; and Dr. Ambedkar and Untouchability: Analysing and Fighting Caste. He has also edited Pakistan: Nationalism Without a Nation; Hindu Nationalism: A Reader and, with Alain Dieckhoff, Revisiting Nationalism. Dragan Klaic is a theatre scholar and cultural analyst. He serves as a permanent fellow of the Felix Meritis Foundation in Amsterdam and is a professor of the arts and cultural policy at the University of Leiden’s Faculty of Creative and Performing Arts. He lectures widely at various universities, speaks at conferences and symposia, and serves as advisor, editor, researcher and trainer. His fields of engagement are contemporary performing arts, European cultural policies, strategies of cultural development and international cultural cooperation, interculturalism and cultural memory. Lily Kong is a professor of geography at the National University of Singapore. She is a social and cultural geographer who has published widely in a number of areas, ranging from cultural policy and creative economies, to music, religion, place histories and national identities. Her work has focused on the Asian cities of Singapore, Shanghai,
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xix
CONTRIBUTORS
Hong Kong, Taipei and Beijing. Her recent books include: Creative Cities, Creative Economies: Asian-European Perspectives; Singapore Hawker Centres; Landscapes: Ways of Imagining the World; and The Politics of Landscapes in Singapore: Constructions of ‘Nation’ Diana Leat is a visiting professor at the Centre for Charity Effectiveness, Cass Business School, London, and a visiting research fellow at UCLA. Diana has held research and teaching posts at a number of universities and research centres in the UK, the USA and Australia. Most recently, Diana has been Research and Development Director at the Carnegie UK Trust. She is the author of over 100 articles and books on the non-profit sector and social policy. She is a trustee of the Diana, Princess of Wales Memorial Fund in the UK. Todd Lester is the founding director of freeDimensional. He is currently a fellow at the Gerhart Center for Philanthropy and Civic Engagement in Cairo and is a candidate for a doctorate on public and urban policy at the New School for Social Research from which he received a Film Production Diploma. He is a project leader at the World Policy Institute and a member of both the 21st Century Trust and Think Tank 30. He serves on the international advisory committee of the Club of Rome and was recently named an Architect of the Future by the Waldzell Institute. Todd is an adjunct instructor in media studies at the New School. Willem Henri Lucas (designer) is a professor in the Design Media Arts department at UCLA. He studied at the Academy of Visual Arts in Arnhem, and did his post academic studies at the Sandberg Institute (Rietveld Academy), in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. He works for clients mostly based in the fields of Culture and the Arts. From 1990 to 2002 he served as a professor and chair of the Utrecht School of the Arts’ graphic design department. He won several ‘Best Book’ awards in the Netherlands and the US. Mailyn Machado is an art critic, curator and academic. She has a degree in Art History from the University of Havana, Cuba and was also awarded a Diploma in Art Criticism by the University of Girona, Spain. She currently teaches Art Theory at the University of Havana and is the editor of the Cuban magazine La Gaceta de Cuba. Her essays have appeared in many national and international publications. Malvika Maheshwari is a doctoral candidate in Political Science at CERI, Sciences Po, Paris working on the Hindutva movement and freedom of expression of artists in India. Ricardo Mbarkho was trained at the Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Beaux-Arts and Ecole Supérieure d’Etudes Cinématographiques, Paris and Institut Supérieur des Beaux-Arts, Beirut. He also completed an exchange study program at Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, USA. He currently lives in Lebanon and teaches art, video, and new media at the Académie Libanaise des Beaux-Arts, Beirut. Peter Mörtenböck is Professor of Visual Culture at the Vienna University of Technology and visiting fellow at Goldsmiths College, University of London. His recent practical and theoretical work has focused on spatial conflict, urban informality, models of networking and relational theories. He is author/co-editor of Die virtuelle Dimension: Architektur, Subjektivität und Cyberspace (2001), Visuelle Kultur: KörperRäume-Medien (2003) and Networked Cultures: Parallel Architectures and the Politics of Space (2008).
xix
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
xx
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xx
CONTRIBUTORS
Helge Mooshammer is director of the research project ‘Relational Architecture’ at the Vienna University of Technology. He teaches at Goldsmiths, University of London and has been research fellow at the International Research Centre for Cultural Studies (IFK), Vienna, in 2008. His research and writing have focused on relational architecture, sexuality and urban culture. He has authored Cruising: Architektur, Psychoanalyse und Queer Cultures (2005) and co-edited Visuelle Kultur: KörperRäume-Medien (2003) and Networked Cultures: Parallel Architectures and the Politics of Space (2008). With Peter Mörtenböck he initiated the ‘Networked Cultures‘ project, an international research platform on the potential of translocally networked spatial practices, based at Goldsmiths College (www.networkedcultures.org). Gerardo Mosquera is a freelance curator and art critic based in Havana; Adjunct Curator at the New Museum of Contemporary Art, New York; advisor at the Rijksakademie van Beeldenden Kunsten, Amsterdam; and member of the advisory board of several art journals. He was a founder of the Havana Biennial, and has curated many celebrated exhibitions. Author of numerous books and texts on contemporary art and art theory, Mosquera edited Beyond the Fantastic: Contemporary Art Criticism from Latin America and co-edited Over Here: International Perspectives on Art and Culture. Catherine Murray is a professor in the School of Communication, co-director of the Centre for Policy Studies on Culture and Communities, and an associate of the Masters of Public Policy Program at Simon Fraser University in Vancouver, Canada. Her research interests include cultural participation and creative labour, cultural infrastructure and creative cities, cultural industries and especially broadcast policy, communication rights and global trade, and research design in policy evaluation. Dr Murray is a co-author of From Economy to Ecology: A Policy Framework for Creative Labour; Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Media in BC; and Researching Audiences. Rasoul Nejadmehr has a PhD in the philosophy of education from the University of London. He is an independent researcher, bringing together philosophical research and studies in cultural and educational policies. He is the author of Education, Science and Truth, published as part of Routledge’s International Studies in the Philosophy of Education. He is a member of the Swedish Committee of the Inquiry on Cultural Policy, commissioned by the Swedish government to survey Swedish cultural policy. He is also a board member of University College Dance, Stockholm. Keith Nurse is the director of the Shridath Ramphal Centre of the University of the West Indies, after having served at the Institute of International Relations as academic coordinator of the postgraduate diploma in Arts and Cultural Enterprise Management. He has taught at the Institute of Business and the Department of Government, UWI, and the Institute for International Development and Co-operation, University of Ottawa. He has published widely on the trade policy and global political economy of the clothing, banana, tourism, copyright and cultural/creative industries; and on the impact of global restructuring on migration and diaspora, HIV/AIDS and security, and youth, gender and poverty. He is the author of Festival Tourism in the Caribbean and The Caribbean Music Industry. Annie Paul works at the University of the West Indies, Mona, Jamaica, where she heads the publications section of the Sir Arthur Lewis Institute of Social and Economic Studies (SALISES). She is also a founding editor of the journal Small Axe (Indiana University Press). Paul is the recipient of a grant from the Prince Claus Fund
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xxi
CONTRIBUTORS
(Netherlands) in support of her book project, Suitable Subjects: Visual Art and Popular Culture in Postcolonial Jamaica. Walter Santagata is Professor of Cultural Economics at the University of Turin, Italy. He also serves as chairman of the Commission on Creative Industries of the Italian Ministry of Culture. His recent books include: La Fabbrica della Cultura (Il Mulino, Bologna, 2007) and La Mode, une économie de la créativité (La Documentation Française, Paris, 2005). Ivani Santana is a dancer and choreographer working in the field of dance-technology. She is a professor in the department of dance at the Federal University of Bahia. She has created and directed the Group of Technological Poetics in Dance since its inception in 2004. She is the author of Corpo Aberto: Cunniningham, Dança e Novas Tecnologias [Open Body: Cunningham, Dance and New Technologies], and Dança na Cultura Digital [Dance in the Digital Culture], and has written many articles for international journals. She was awarded the UNESCO Prize for the Promotion of the Arts – New Technologies 2006, as well as the artistic residence at the Centre Chorégraphique National, Aix-en-Provence, France. Ari Seligmann is an architecture critic engaged in broadening perspectives on global architecture and investigating the impacts of globalization on the built environment. He has participated in various international conferences and his work has been published in a range of journals. He has taught at the University of California, Berkeley; Woodbury University, the Otis College of Art and Design; and the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA). He served as coordinator for the Laboratory for Cross-Cultural Studies in Architecture and Urban Design at UCLA, and currently is a lecturer at Monash University, Australia. Cylena Simonds is an independent curator and writer engaged in the politics of representation and the representation of politics, with special interests in moving image media, diasporic cultures and conditions of practice in developing countries. From 2004–2008 she was the exhibitions curator at Iniva, heading their on-site and touring exhibition programmes, as well as programming off-site public art projects. Her latest project was States of Exchange: Artists from Cuba, which was the first exhibition of contemporary art from Cuba to be shown in the UK since 1997. Maruška Svašek is senior lecturer in social anthropology at Queen’s University, Belfast. Her principal research interests are in emotions, migration, art and material culture. Her current research concerns experiences of belonging and non-belonging amongst migrants in Northern Ireland. She is associate editor of the journals Focaal, European Journal of Anthropology and Identities: Global Studies in Culture and Power. Her major publications include Anthropology, Art and Cultural Production; and the edited volumes Postsocialism: Politics and Emotions in Central and Eastern Europe and Mixed Emotion Anthropological Studies of Feeling (with K. Milton). Svašek is coinitiator and director of the Cultural Dynamics and Emotions Network. Gilane Tawadros is a curator and writer. She was joint chief executive of Rivington Place and the founding director of the Institute of International Visual Arts, a contemporary visual arts agency in London. She has curated numerous exhibitions and written extensively on contemporary art. Recent titles include Changing States: Contemporary Art and Ideas in an Era of Globalisation and Life is More Important Than
xxi
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
xxii
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xxii
CONTRIBUTORS
Art. She is currently president of the International Foundation of Manifesta (Amsterdam) and a board member of the Forum for African Arts (New York), Photoworks (Brighton) and A Foundation (London). Julie Thomas (MA Harvard, MLitt Trinity College Dublin, PhD University of London) is Associate Professor of Global Communications at the American University of Paris, where she teaches courses on fashion, material culture, the museum as medium, and colour. She writes on colour in cultural space, digital interactivity (guest editor with Claudia Roda of the special issue on ‘Attention Aware Systems’ of Computers in Human Behaviour), the museum and cultural identity, and in 2004 organized the international conference Mediating Fashion, Mediating Paris at the American University of Paris. Eugenio Tisselli is a computer scientist and digital artist. He is a teacher and co-director of the Master’s in Digital Arts at the Pompeu Fabra University, Barcelona. He has contributed an on-line seminar about digital interactivity to the UNESCO DigiArts programme. He has held the position of associate researcher at the Sony Computer Science Lab in Paris. His artistic work has been featured in multiple exhibitions and festivals throughout the world; it is available at http://www.motorhueso.net. He is the developer of Antoni Abad’s zexe.net project, in which digital technologies and networks are used to give a voice to marginalized communities. Mo Tomaney originally trained in fashion textiles at St Martins School of Art; she has over twenty years’ experience as a successful fashion and textile designer and has an MSc in social anthropology. Consultancies in South Asia and the Far East led to an awareness of labour standards in the fashion supply chain. She has held full-time positions at The Body Shop, where she was a fair trade development manager, and Levi’s, where she worked on fabric development and sourcing. She is currently a research fellow in ethical issues and fair trade at Central St Martins and a senior lecturer at UCCA (Epsom) where she runs an MA in ethical fashion. Jason Toynbee is senior lecturer in media studies in the sociology department of the faculty of social science at the The Open University, UK. His research interests centre on problems of creativity and authorship in the media, with a special focus on copyright and cultural production. Much of his work takes popular music as a case in point. Among Jason’s books are Bob Marley: Herald of a Postcolonial World? (Polity, 2007); Analysing Media Texts (with Marie Gillespie, Open University Press, 2006); and Making Popular Music: Musicians, Institutions and Creativity (Arnold, 2000). Peter Tschmuck is associate professor at the Institute of Culture Management and Culture Studies at the University of Music and Performing Arts, Vienna. He also teaches courses at the University of Economics and Business Administration in Vienna, the University of Innsbruck, the University of Klagenfurt, and the Donau-University of Krems. His research focuses on the structure and processes in cultural institutions, arts management, the economics of the music industry, and cultural statistics. Nicole Vazquez is a 2009 graduate of UCLA’s School of Public Affairs, with Master’s degrees in social welfare and public policy with a concentration in international policy. She worked as a graduate student researcher for the school’s Center for Civil Society during her tenure at UCLA, conducting research, writing, and editing for Center publications and reports. She intends to apply a global framework to civic engagement and
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xxiii
CONTRIBUTORS
community development work in Los Angeles by addressing social justice issues that disproportionately affect communities of colour. Indrasen Vencatachellum was born in Mauritius in 1946, completed his Master of Arts at the Sorbonne in Paris, and since 1976 has been involved in international cooperation for cultural development. He was formerly in charge of UNESCO’s Division of Cultural Expressions and Creative Industries. In 1990 he launched the ‘Plan of Action for Crafts Development in the World’, and in 1995 the ‘Design 21’ programme; he was also managing editor for the practical guide entitled Designers Meet Artisans. Harold L. Vogel is the author of Entertainment Industry Economics: A Guide for Financial Analysis and of the companion volume, Travel Industry Economics: A Guide for Financial Analysis. He was ranked as top entertainment industry analyst for ten years by Institutional Investor magazine, was the senior entertainment industry analyst at Merrill Lynch for seventeen years, and earned his PhD in economics from the University of London. His forthcoming book is Financial Market Bubbles and Crashes. Zala Volcic is a postdoctoral fellow at the Centre for Critical and Cultural Studies, University of Queensland, Australia. In her research she focuses on international communication, media and cultural identities. Her recently published articles include ‘Blaming the media: Serbian narratives of national(ist) identity’, in Continuum: Journal of Media & Cultural Studies; ‘Yugo-nostalgia: cultural memory and media in the former Yugoslavia’, in Critical Studies in Media Communication; and ‘Technological developments in Central-Eastern Europe: A case-study of a computer literacy project in Slovenia’ (with Karmen Erjavec), in Information Communication & Society. Tereza Wagner is a senior programme specialist at UNESCO dealing with arts and creative issues. Her graduate and undergraduate degrees are from Paris V University, France, including a doctorate in the anthropology of contemporary arts. She is currently in charge of coordinating events within the Cultural sector of UNESCO. She was part of the team that initiated the UNESCO Prize for the Promotion of the Arts and helped develop the DigiArts UNESCO Knowledge Portal (http://portal.unesco.org/digiarts), a web-based initiative which aims to promote ICT creative tools among young people at school level and disseminate on-line teaching and information on digital creation world wide. She has also published articles on African cinema, African contemporary arts and arts education. Christopher Waterman is an anthropologist and musician who specializes in the study of music and popular culture in Africa and the Americas. He is currently dean of the School of the Arts and Architecture at UCLA, which comprises six degree-granting departments: Architecture and Urban Design; Art; Design Media Arts; Ethnomusicology; Music; and World Arts and Cultures. The school also houses the UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music (including the departments of ethnomusicology, music and musicology); five research centres (the Art Global Health Center, the Art Sci Center, the Center for Intercultural Performance, the Experiential Technologies Center and the Grunwald Center for the Graphic Arts); and three internationally acclaimed public arts presenters (the Fowler Museum, the Hammer Museum, and UCLA Live).
xxiii
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xxiv
LIST OF BOXES, FIGURES, PHOTOS, PLATES AND TABLES
Boxes 1.1
Cultures and globalization: the knowledge gap
2
2.1 2.2
Digital arts and the cultural expression of young people, Indrasen Vencatachellum Inspiring innovation and creativity in the workplace, Nicole Vazquez
44 45
6.1
Proxy servers: contemporary art practices in service economies, Cylena Simonds
84
13.1
Culture workers in distress, Todd Lester
155
15.1
Kumamoto’s Artpolis: mediating innovative architecture and creative cultural expression, Ari Seligmann
173
17.1
Networked Cultures, Peter Mörtenböck and Helge Mooshammer
198
18.1 18.2
204
18.4
Méduse Coopérative, Quebec City, Canada and Arts House, Melbourne, Australia The Artscape Wychwood Barns, Toronto, Canada and The Waag Society, Amsterdam, The Netherlands TOHU, Montreal, Canada and Haida Heritage Centre at Kaay Llnagaay, Haida Gwaii, Canada Art in the underground, Karin Becker
19.1
Manga, graphic novels and the album, Meghan Corroon
222
20.1 20.2
Science and art in the digital era, Tereza Wagner Art and nanotechnology, Nicole Vazquez
232 233
23.1 23.2
From mouth to mouth, from hand to hand, from computer to computer, Mailyn Machado A different kind of media creativity in the Lebanon, Ricardo Mbarkho
268 270
18.3
205 207 209
Figures 7.1 16.1 16.2 16.3
Expansion of copyright term in the USA The emergence of cultural paradigms in the twentieth century music industry The elements of a creative path in the music industry A model of paradigm shift in the music industry
88 182 184 185
Photos 12.1 12.2 12.3 12.4
Spread Spread Spread Spread
from from from from
the the the the
book book book book
Sabaa+7 [Seven+7] Al-Kharbasha [Doodles] Sabaa+7 [Seven+7] Qalb Al Madina [Heart of the City]
133 133 134 134
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xxv
LIST OF BOXES, FIGURES, PHOTOS/PLATES AND TABLES
12.5 12.6 12.7 12.8 12.9 12.10 12.11 12.12
12.13 12.14
13.1
Furniture pieces designed by Nada Debs Arabic Bling-Bling jewellery design playing with Arabic vernacular text and handwritten lettering designed by Nadine Kanso Three handbags from Sarah’s Bag with reference to Arab vernacular visual culture and icons Accessories from Pink Sushi using a mix of Arabic vernacular text, lettering and images. ‘Salon’ installation Africa Remix, Hayward Gallery Left ‘Ahmed Lightin Up’ 2000. Right: ‘Ilham’ 2000 Two examples of Dia Diwan website’s newsletter displaying a range of products and topics Six examples from the winning designs of the ‘Project Muslaq’ Middle Eastern design competition, launched in June 2008 for the special edition of the Khatt Design Collection of vinyl wall stickers (for interior decoration) Cover of Typographic Matchmaking, written and designed by Huda Smitshuijzen AbiFarès Three different spreads from Typographic Matchmaking, written and designed by Huda Smitshuijzen AbiFarès Issa Nyaphaga with hands crossed in front of his face, Angele Etoundi Essamba
xxv 135 136 138 139 140 140 143
144 145 145
156
List of Colour Plates 3.1 Apolitical, 2001, Wilfredo Prieto.
287
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4
287 288 288 289
The Visitor, from The Benin Project, 2007, Uriel Orlow. The Visitor, installation view, Friborg. Perdre sa Salive (Wasting One’s Spittle),1994, Shen Yuan. Transmission, 1990, Hamad Butt.
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4
Hidden Agendas, 2008, painting, George Hughes. Trophy Seekers, 2008, painting, George Hughes. Mother Earth, 2008, painting, George Hughes. A participant from the School of Anthropological Studies in Belfast with the school flag, showing the image in Alder’s book that inspired the flag design. 5.5 Fante Flag, 2009, Marushka Svasek. 5.6 George Hughes during the What You Perceive is What You Conceive performance in Belfast, 2007.
289 290 290 291 291 292
10.1 A scene from the ‘subterranean’ satire Great Escape performed at the Book Café: the two central characters decide to ‘tunnel their way out’ of Zimbabwe… 10.2 Flyer with Kaya logo, Book Café. 10.3 Barsiranai traditional dance group, Book Café. 10.4 African jazz/blues guitarist David Ndoro improvises, Book Café.
292 293 293 294
14.1 Mostar, where the statues of Bruce Lee were unveiled in 2005. Mostar is also famous for its historic bridge which was destroyed by the Croatian army in 1993 and since rebuilt. Photo: Zala Volcic, 2008.
294
Anheier & Isar-3927-Prelims:Anheier-Prelims.qxd
xxvi
20/10/2009
2:22 PM
Page xxvi
LIST OF BOXES, FIGURES, PHOTOS/ILLUSTRATIONS AND TABLES
18.1 The historic Wychwood TTC streetcar repairs barn in Toronto before transformation into the Artscape Wychwood Barns. Photo: Edward Burtynsky. 18.2 Plan for the Artscape Wychwood Barns, opened 2008. Photo: Nancy Duxbury.
295 295
20.1 Versus, 2005, telematic dance, Ivani Santana. 20.2 Versus, 2005, Ivani Santana.
296 297
Tables 6.1 19.1 22.1 22.2
The economic impact of diasporic Caribbean carnivals Manga market data Spending on the arts as a percentage of total foundation spending Foundations’ international giving
81 222 250 250
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 1
INTRODUCTION Yudhishthir Raj Isar and Helmut K. Anheier
A triad of terms The relationships between cultural change and globalization remain inadequately understood. Often reduced to the seemingly one-way impact of globalization processes on the world’s cultures, these relationships are in reality reciprocal and far more complex and multi-faceted: for one, cultures do shape globalization processes and patterns, and vice versa; what is more, the relationships in turn involve many interactions with economic, political and other factors as well – be they the impacts of regulatory environments, financial flows, migration, technology or social inequality. Addressing the richness of these relationships in the context of contemporary developments is the main purpose of The Cultures and Globalization Series (see text box for more details).
Our third volume takes up the relationships between cultures and globalization with respect to ‘cultural expression, creativity and innovation’. Why this particular combination of terms? The question is not difficult to answer, but before doing so we first need to remind the reader of the two previous themes. The inaugural theme of the Series, ‘conflicts and tensions’, addressed the broad understandings of culture as a ‘ways of life’ or identity-based concept, as commonly employed in the social and human sciences.The exponential growth in affirmations of, or claims to, cultural difference in the face of the forces of globalization has given rise to multiple ‘conflicts and tensions’ in recent years. These various manifestations of identity politics loom large in current anxieties. As we put it, ‘behind the concern for “culture” that is increasingly evoked in contemporary public debate lurks the specter of conflict: the cultural dimensions of conflict on the one hand, and the conflictual dimensions of culture on the other’ (Anheier and Isar, 2007: 19). By contrast, the ‘cultural economy’, our theme in 2008, related rather more to the ‘arts and heritage’ understanding of culture. Here it was a question of the ‘substantive centrality’ (Hall, 1997) of goods and services based on cultural content, or outputs with significant aesthetic or semiotic content. In this case as well, the issue appeared to hinge upon global imbalances and/or divides. Given the existing patterns of market domination how can all societies possibly produce such ‘symbolic outputs’? In both cases, authors analysed the variegated landscape of cultural change in relation to globalization. They demonstrated the ways in which this complex interplay between cultures and globalization is at once unifying and divisive, liberating and corrosive, homogenizing and diversifying. The relationships also crystallize both positive aspirations and negative anxieties. The interplay transforms patterns of sameness and difference across the world, and modifies the ways in which cultural expression is created, represented, recognized, preserved or renewed. It also contributes to generating powerful new culturalist discourses that evoke ‘the power of culture’ – both in relation to conflictual phenomena (our topic in 2007) or when the cultural is at once a resource and a vector of major economic flows (the theme in 2008).1
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
Box I.1
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 2
Cultures and globalization: the knowledge gap
While a substantial evidence base has been developed on the economic, political and social aspects of globalization, the cultural dimension continues to be the object of many unsubstantiated generalizations and unquestioned assumptions. This is the key knowledge gap the Series is designed to fill. The complex, two-way relationships between cultural change and globalization have remained largely uncharted empirically and under-analysed conceptually. One reason for this dual neglect at the global level is that conventional understandings of culture are still connected principally to the sovereign nation-state. However, today this nexus of culture and nation no longer dominates: the cultural dimension has become constitutive of collective identity at narrower as well as broader levels. What is more, cultural processes take place in increasingly ‘deterritorialized’ transnational, global contexts, many of which are beyond the reach of national policies. Mapping and analysing this shifting terrain, in all regions of the world, as well as the factors, patterns, processes, and outcomes associated with the ‘complex connectivity’ (Tomlinson, 1999) of globalization, is therefore a main purpose of this Series. In sum, the Series aims to meet three goals: to highlight key contemporary cultural changes and their policy implications; to channel and encourage cutting-edge research; and to contribute to the development of information systems in the field of culture. In so doing, it will seek to build bridges between the social sciences, the arts and the humanities, and policy studies. Indeed, our approach is based on our awareness that the social sciences and the humanities have become too compartmentalized – a state of affairs that we seek to overcome by the kind of inter- and cross-disciplinary thinking required for a project of the kind proposed here that seeks to explore the nexus of cultures and globalization. We therefore encourage ‘out of the box’ thinking and approaches that cut across established disciplines and methods. The present volume, as with the others in the Series, is more than a compilation of separate conceptual chapters. An analytical framework and a set of over-arching questions spell out the organizing principles and substantive priorities. The present volume is also more than a compendium of country or ‘area’ studies. While such aspects are important, they take second place here to a pronounced transnational, comparative and evidence-based perspective as our key signature. A key factor responsible for the knowledge gap in the field of cultures and globalization is the paucity of comparative information. It is for this reason that, alongside the ‘narrative’ chapters, all based on freshly observed empirical phenomena, each volume of the Series includes a significant data section. Departing from conventional approaches, we have developed a new way of compiling, analysing and presenting quantitative data on specific aspects of the cultures and globalization relationship. These ‘indicator suites’ make up Part 2 of the volume and are based on the premise that much information on many facets of the cultures and globalization nexus is already ‘out there,’ but is not being processed in appropriate ways. Another point of departure is that for most readers interpretative information graphics are far easier to understand than ‘raw’ data in tabular form. Initiated in 2007, the methodology has been refined with each successive volume. More details will be provided in Part 2, which, among other topics, presents indicator suites on aspects of cultural expression, creativity and innovation, with a special emphasis on hybridity.
2
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 3
INTRODUCTION
Now let’s turn to the theme of the present volume. Current cultural discourse has turned the notions of ‘creativity’ and ‘innovation’ into keywords in recent years – although neither figured in Raymond Williams’s classic (1988) reference work on the subject. Indeed, the two terms have been taken up enthusiastically by advocates, analysts and policy makers alike, particularly with reference to the cultural economy; both terms have become crucial to how the latter is represented, and represents itself. The notion of creativity draws heavily, though not exclusively, on artistic quality, but in a specifically modernist reading: ‘the shock of the new, the disruptive, the counter-intuitive, the rebellious and the risk-taker’ (O’Connor, 2007: 32). Yet today, judging from the many ways creativity is evoked, it is no longer the privileged domain of art and artists. Instead, the organization of cultural commodity production on a mass industrial scale seems to have pushed artistic practice into the sidelines – despite the continuing popular veneration of the artist as demiurge. Hence it appeared essential to us to continue the Series by refocusing on cultural expression, almost as if it were the missing player at the table. We say cultural expression deliberately, instead of ‘the arts’ or ‘artistic creation’, because the latter two terms foreground the individual creative act or impulse, whereas today the emphasis is placed equally on group manifestations. Besides, in many organizational milieus (art and design schools or architectural collaboratives), genres (film, theatrical and musical performances) and in non-Western societies more generally, artistic work can be a collective project, not just an individual one. This last point is important because the notion of creativity is still tinged with mystical overtones – as Jason Toynbee points out in Chapter 7, ‘the individual artist is the locus of creativity, and her/his genius consists in extraordinary powers of autonomous expression’. However, as several other chapters in this volume demonstrate, creativity is arguably much more a matter of ‘social authorship’ than transubstantiation of the soul or expression from within. This has long been recognized with respect to the cultural traditions of Asia, where creativity ‘involves a state of personal fulfillment, a connection to a primordial realm, or the expression of an inner essence or ultimate reality’ (Lubart, 1999: 340).2 But in the West as well as in the East, a more sociological awareness is now called for. There has been a tendency
3
to think of creativity and innovation as things ineffable, embodied only in the individual, as the emanation of an inner inspiration. But recent thinking opens up the analytical frame to include the sociocultural context, interpreting creativity in conjunction with collective action and defining it as a process in which novelty is recognized and acknowledged collectively. As the anthropologists observe, their discipline needs to ‘contribute to debates around creativity by challenging – rather than reproducing – the polarity between novelty and convention, or between the innovative dynamic of the present and the traditionalism of the past, that has long formed such a powerful undercurrent to the discourses of modernity’ (Ingold and Hallam, cited by Svašek, in Chapter 5 below). At the intersection, then, of cultural expression on the one hand, and creativity and innovation on the other, understood in both its individual and social manifestations, our motivations were threefold. First, we wished to analyse the interactions between globalization and arts practice (or, more broadly, cultural expression). Second, we wished to better understand the interactions between the forces of globalization and the emergence of creativity and innovation in cultural expression itself. Third, we sought to join up the two sets of questions. How are artistic practice and behaviour evolving in relation to globalization? Within cultural practice, how is globalization shifting the ground in which creativity and innovation arise and are nurtured? Whilst questions about artistic creativity and innovation are not new in aesthetics and cultural sociology, the encounter with contemporary globalization takes such questions to a different plane. It creates new conditions of great potential as well as challenges of at least equal magnitude; also it makes a far more broadbased perspective on these matters indispensable. These motivations crystallized before we learned that the European Parliament and Council would label 2009 the European Year of Creativity and Innovation with the combined goals of raising awareness of the importance of creativity and innovation for personal, social and economic development, disseminating good practices, stimulating education and research so our project precedes the EU’s, it does not follow it. In sum, the choice of the topic ‘cultural expression: creativity and innovation’ to follow the volume on ‘the cultural economy’ is based on the following reasons:
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
4
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 4
INTRODUCTION
i) cultural expression provides the basic human inputs to the cultural economy, and particularly so in the ‘creative industries’; ii) the predominance of the cultural economy in current policies and practices is transforming the conditions for creative cultural expression itself, how it takes place and unfolds; iii) this transformation has both negative and positive consequences, as it encourages some forms of cultural expression and discourages others, opens up new opportunities for some and marginalizes others; iv) throughout this process, creativity must be identifiable and become recognized as such, and requires innovation processes to become culturally and socially sustainable as well as economically viable, while at the same time; v) globalization generates new frameworks for creativity and innovation in cultural expression that vary across fields and genres. ‘Creativity’, ‘Innovation’. We are all too aware of the inflated, and often imprecise, uses of these two terms, particularly in the popular management literature as well as in some cultural policy work.3 Writing as long ago as 1971, Raymond Williams pointed out that ‘no word in English carries a more consistently positive reference than “creative”… yet, clearly, the very width of the reference involves not only difficulties of meaning, but also, through habit, a kind of unthinking repetition which at times makes the word seem useless’ (1971: 19). More recently – and more polemically – John Tusa has observed (2003: 5–6): ‘Creative’, ‘creation’, ‘creativity’ are some of the most overused and ultimately debased words in the language. Stripped of any special significance by a generation of bureaucrats, civil servants, managers and politicians, lazily used as political margarine to spread approvingly and inclusively over any activity with a non-material element to it, the word ‘creative’ has become almost unusable. Politics and the ideology of ordinariness, the wish not to put anyone down, the determination not to exalt the exceptional, the culture of oversensitivity, of avoiding hurt feelings, have seen to that.
What kind of creativity and innovation? Despite and indeed because of such difficulties, we confine ourselves essentially in this volume to the
notion of creativity in cultural expression broadly understood, a field in which its meaning is relatively unambiguous, rather than extending it to practically every sphere of human and social endeavour. We take creativity to be the generation of novel ideas and artefacts; innovation is the process by which new ideas and artefacts lead to new cognitive and behavioural practices such as genres, ways of going and organizing, conventions, models, etc. In much of the current cultural policy literature, however, particularly in relation to city planning and management, the concept of creativity is used both more broadly to encompass far more than the arts (see, for example Florida (2002), and more loosely as well (for example Landry, (2000)). Such usages are somewhat metaphorical, lacking the kind of analytical rigor displayed by the recent boom in creativity research in the natural sciences through to psychology and other cognitive sciences. Different approaches have analysed individual creativity in a broad range of task domains, including of course the arts (Sternberg and Lubart, 1999), linking them to the societal as well. Hence our advocacy of an essentially sociological perspective, rooted in the interactions between individual and society rather than in the individual alone, where Eureka or ‘Aha’ moments are sufficient to convey the idea of the creative act. We have been able to take a cue here from confluence approaches to the study of creativity in contemporary psychology (Sternberg and Lubart, 1999), foremost among which is the ‘systems perspective’ pioneered by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (1996; 1999). Here the interactions between, first, the creative person, second, the domain (a specific cultural symbol system) and third, the field (defined as made up of domain gate-keepers such as art critics, gallery owners, star performers, etc.), are what determine the emergence and in particular the recognition of a creative act or product. The creative individual takes information in a domain and transforms or extends it; the field validates and selects the new ideas and methods; the domain then in turn preserves and transmits creative products to other individuals, societies and generations. In this perspective, says Csikszentmihalyi, ‘creativity is any act, idea or product that changes an existing domain, or that transforms an existing domain into a new one’ (1996: 28). As Howard Gardner has shown, ‘the development of creative projects may stem from an anomaly within a system (e.g., tension between competing critics in a field) or moderate
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 5
INTRODUCTION
asynchronies between the individual, domain and field (e.g., unusual individual talent for a domain)’ (1993, cited in Sternberg and Lubart, 1999: 10). Similarly, research in organizational sociology and management demonstrates that creativity and innovation emerge at the crossroads of social, cultural and political forces, and more frequently at the margins and boundaries rather than at the centre of systems, be they political entities, organizations or professions (Nelson and Winter, 1982; Pettigrew and Fenton, 2000). Studying the question of how organizations evolve, Romanelli and Tushman (1994) introduce the notion of punctuated equilibriums to refer to discontinuous transformations. They assume that organizations pass through relatively long periods of stability in terms of structure and activity. These are punctuated by short bursts of fundamental changes during revolutionary periods, triggered when several key organizational domains are threatened or otherwise become critically uncertain, particularly in terms of available resources. In response, some but not all organizations will seek to adapt by introducing changes in terms of strategy, structure, incentive and control systems, as well as power relations that are more far-reaching than would have been the case otherwise. Organizational theorists suggest that revolutionary periods are times of greater creativity and improved innovation performance in those organizations that manage to break the structural and cultural inertia of embedded routines. Cultural creativity, too, is surely embedded in social, cultural, and political phenomena and is related to specific configurations in terms of structure, power and meaning. However, while embedded, creativity seems, at the same time, more likely to be fostered in situations of change, tension and discontinuity, when overlapping and criss-crossing configurations create interstitial spaces. In the context of globalization, the question is: what happens to these configurations and relationships? That is the question many of our authors address, while others focus more exclusively on cultural expression alone. In relation to this usage, we should recall the working definitions of the two central concepts that we have adopted for this Series, drawing largely on the systematic coverage proffered by Held et al. (1999). We take globalization to be the highly accelerated movement of objects (goods, services, finance and other resources, etc.), meanings (language, symbols, knowledge,
5
identities, etc.) and people across regions and intercontinental space. In other words, the various processes of time–space compression. The working concept of culture we have adopted is the following: Culture is the social construction, articulation and reception of meaning. It is the lived and creative experience for individuals and a body of artefacts, symbols, texts and objects. Culture involves enactment and representation. It embraces art and art discourse, the symbolic world of meanings, the commodified output of the cultural industries as well as the spontaneous or enacted, organized or unorganized cultural expressions of everyday life, including social relations. It is constitutive of both collective and individual identity.
Creativity and innovation in cultural expression To be sure, creativity continues to manifest itself as an individual product, in which latent and manifest talents, expertise and serendipity combine in often seemingly unpredictable ways. Yet alongside and perhaps gradually superseding this image of the individual genius kissed by the muse is a new one: it is based on the understanding that the likelihoods of creativity to emerge, of creative acts to be recognized, and of both leading to innovation, yielding sustained change, are all closely linked to the organization of economy and society as well as patterns in the cultural domain itself.4 In other words, art is itself a ‘set of historically specific ideas and practices that have shifted meanings across the course of the centuries’ (Errington, 1998: 63) and creativity varies across cultures. And as cultures interact with globalization the ensuing cultural change in turn enriches or impoverishes the conditions in which creativity can emerge. As Stuart Hall (1997) has observed, the means of producing, circulating and exchanging cultural products and processes have been dramatically expanded in our time through new media technologies and the information revolution. Directly, a much greater proportion of the world’s human, material and technical resources than ever before goes into the ‘cultural’ or ‘creative’ industries sectors, while indirectly these have become the mediating element in every other process. Moreover, as a result of today’s technological upheaval, the nature and
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
6
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 6
INTRODUCTION
forms of cultural expression are changing profoundly. Take, for example, the world of virtual reality in which actors are free to make choices and play roles normally unavailable to them in the social world of everyday life and in which technology turns many individuals into ‘creators’ themselves. From the personal computer and digital camera to the cell phone, humankind inhabits an increasingly networked world in which communication and personal expression and development reign supreme. YouTube, for example, offers those so inclined the possibility of directing and producing their own movies, while Karaoke machines have unleashed the inner singer within each of us and the literary shibboleth of the day is ‘Every blogger is a star’. Yet what are the standards by which creativity is identified and assessed; how do we know if something is truly novel? Do the creators themselves care about standards, or are creative acts more play for entertainment than work inspired by the muses, and more about escaping the status quo than changing it? Market-driven phenomena may well be creating new figures of the symbol creator as a ‘motor of innovation’ and altering the profile of the ‘creative subject’. The World Wide Web with its attendant domains of the internet and cyberspace may signal a ‘brave new world’ to some, though beyond its virtual borders significant areas nevertheless still manifest age-old problems – a persistent scarcity of food, shelter and clothing haunts the planet. Does artistic creativity today channel in relation to this dark side of things some of the visionary edge that has energized the arts since the Enlightenment? Artistic creativity, according to Adorno (1991) and other critical thinkers, reveals and helps us appreciate the possibility of a better world – be it through literature, music, painting or other genres. What happens to this premise in the face of the globalized cultural industries? In this volume, our authors also interrogate the perceptions of globalization as a threat to ‘diversity’, as it erodes cultural identity and distinctiveness across the world. This ‘homogenization-produced-by-cultural-imperialism’ view takes it for granted that distinctive repertoires and potentials of creative expression are being eliminated by globalization. Yet many observers point to the processes of re-pluralization that are occurring, dialectically, as the values of different ways of life have risen into consciousness and have become the rallying cry of diverse claims to a space
in the planetary culture. ‘Before, culture was just lived. Now it has become a self-conscious collective project. Every struggle for life becomes the struggle of a way of life’ (Sahlins, 1994: 6). While the changing relationships between creativity and diversity are particularly clear in domains such as literature, the visual arts and music, the politics of identity maintenance practised by governments tend to privilege not just the arts but also the audiovisual sector and more broadly, the cultural industries (as was analysed in the 2008 volume of The Cultures and Globalization Series). The core tension between current opportunities and threats is now enshrined in the 2005 UNESCO Convention on the Protection and Promotion of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions, whose Preamble observes that ‘while the processes of globalization … afford unprecedented conditions for enhanced interaction between cultures, they also represent a challenge for cultural diversity … ’ The very process of globalization of communication makes the maintenance of cultural identity more difficult. Although the cultural imperialism thesis may be an oversimplification, the question remains as to the real nature of the new repertoires of cultural expression that appear to be emerging. What is the true composition of the hybridities and intercultural fusions that are being produced? Should we expect a global culture that resembles ‘the eclectic patchwork we are witnessing in America and Western Europe today – a mixture of ethnic elements, streamlined and united by a veneer of modernism on a base of scientific and quantitative discourse and computerized technology’? (Smith, 1992: 573). Are globalized consumer industries moulding motifs as well as tastes, and thereby steering most of the creative talent and innovation their way? It is clear that many aspects of contemporary EuroAmerican cultural expression, especially popular music, films, videos, fashion and some foods, are being spread worldwide in the guise of consumer commodities, art styles in media and tourism – well illustrated by Barber’s stark (1995) imagery of McWorld. Or are we moving towards a multi-polar world of cultural expression with competing centers, as Allen Scott suggested in the 2008 volume of this Series (Scott, 2008)? Yet at the same time, expressive forms from many other places are exerting a trans-national influence, and encouraging creativity and innovation, often in hybrid forms that work with, or blend in
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 7
INTRODUCTION
with, Western and other forms and repertoires that are now being re-interpreted in terms of locally specific perceptions, understandings and styles. These new hybridities involve adaptations that are often accompanied by the often very self-conscious rediscovery of and return to indigenous expressive forms; while such processes of culture-based identity building have been ongoing since the nineteenth century, there can be no doubt that they have multiplied exponentially in our time, often occurring with sufficient depth and force to occasion the ‘conflicts and tensions’ we explored in 2007 (Anheier and Isar, 2007). lmages and pictorial representation have never been more dominant in day-to-day life. No longer is the circumscribed world of art and art history capable of decoding and interpreting the extremely visual culture that environs us. Strategies of representation are no longer, if they ever were, neatly divisible into the ‘seeable and the sayable’. Art critic Gerardo Mosquera, a contributor to this volume, wrote earlier of the world being divided into curating cultures and curated cultures (1994). The former have actively created narratives into which the latter would passively let themselves be inserted. Could it be that the forces of globalization continue to favour a ‘one-way decoding’ where ‘other’ cultures are translated into a standard lingua franca, generating easily swappable and exchangeable packets of virtual meaning? At the same time it may well be simplistic to pretend that globalization has not also had unintended spin-offs that empower and connect marginalized groups, communities and individuals in ways never before imagined. How, then, has popular or subaltern creativity globalized itself in different forms and avenues of cultural expression? Finally, copyright, as Sundara Rajan argues, is the ‘legal face of globalization’ subjecting creative products as intellectual ‘property’ to the strict legislation of their circulation and reproduction. In the past, it was argued that copyright was necessary in order to promote creativity; only by guaranteeing the creator or inventor’s copyright could the author of a work be compensated financially for her creativity. Without this financial incentive, it was argued, the creative impulse would wane. Yet it is precisely the copyright regime and the organizations and interests that benefit from it most that seem subject to the punctuated equilibrium observed by the organizational theorists mentioned above. In other words,
7
what was meant to protect and provide incentives for creativity now opens up new creative opportunities while also posing new threats. There are other areas of cultural creativity, however, that would seem to resist trends towards greater use of property rights altogether and irrespective of the regulatory framework in place. These suggest the existence of other communal circuits of creativity that ought to be investigated. Humour as manifested in the jokes that circumnavigate public culture and recipes used in the preparation of food are two examples in the sense that they are not attributable to single authors or identifiable with particular property rights yet there is no dearth of new, innovative material in either of these areas. How can we learn more about the way creativity works in such domains and cultural commons more generally, and how are these affected by globalization?
Questions Against this background, we posed several sets of questions as a ‘brief’ for those authors who would be contributing analytical chapters to Part 1: •
•
Creativity. What does creativity mean in a globalizing economic, cultural and artistic landscape? How does creativity manifest itself empirically, and what are the economic, sociological and cultural factors that help account for variations in creativity across genres, fields, regions, and societies over time? Are transnational milieus and clusters of creativity emerging? What institutions, organizations and professions as well as artistic, political or economic interests are behind such milieus, and how are they inter-linked? Is the changing ‘map’ of creativity related to the various drivers and patterns of globalization? How does cultural/ artistic creativity differ from creativity in other fields, in particular the sciences, the business world and in politics? Diversity of cultural expressions. What are the dimensions and manifestations of diversity in cultural expression in terms of artistic languages, repertoires and practices? Are there diversifying genres, or fields, or regions or localities as well as professions and organizational systems or clusters? Conversely, are
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
8
•
•
•
•
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 8
INTRODUCTION
there fields and domains in which diversity is stable or even regressing? How are such patterns related to the other forms of globalization? What are the cultural, sociological, economic and political correlates of the nexus between creativity and diversity, and how is globalization affecting it? Innovation. What kinds of innovation are taking place in cultural expression? As globalization propels the growth of the increasingly powerful cultural industries, how are artistic languages, repertoires and practices being affected? Are the cultural industries factors of dynamism and growth for cultural expression or are they factors of constriction instead? What are the threats to the diversity of cultural expressions in this respect? To what degree does commodification stifle or foster creativity? Artists as entrepreneurs. The Western notion of cultural creativity has long celebrated what some analysts have called the ‘cult of originality,’ and the rejection of the past. In other cultures, by contract, artistic creation is closer to the shared, living identity and re-enactment of past lessons projected and made meaningful to the here and now. Are these visions converging? Is cultural expression increasingly becoming both individualistic and social, community-based entrepreneurship? Hybrids. What new hybridities are emerging? What sorts of boundary crossings, disruptions, flows and displacements are taking place in artistic practice? Is more cross-cultural collaboration being promoted in the contemporary global landscape? What organizational and/or collaborative forms have developed trans-culturally and what factors are encouraging and discouraging speciation processes? Are these hybrids stable, pointing to consolidations in the way creativity and innovation are institutionalized in inter-cultural or transnational contexts? Agency and dominance. In what forms are agency and dominance exerted in cultural expression today? How do certain actors seek to encourage, control or discourage creativity as a matter of policy? How do such effects occur unintentionally? Is cultural expression becoming homogenized across the world as a result of globalization? What countervailing forces are now challenging hegemonic tendencies? Who are the cultural-political
entrepreneurs, institutions and organizations in this respect, and how are they achieving specific goals? • Outcomes. Are some expressive forms and genres being marginalized, or becoming increasingly excluded, while others move to the centre of cultural attention, political salience and economic investment? Who and where are the ‘winners’ and ‘losers’? • Policy implications. Finally, what, are the policy implications that follow from the questions above, and what policy recommendations can be made at local, national and international levels as a result?
Responses As in most such anthologies, not all of our contributors have addressed the questions exactly as they were asked. Most of them have addressed a subset of the questions above, and some have chosen to tackle other, perhaps equally important ones, that are also relevant to the issues at hand. The Series has always been eclectic in its embrace of many different disciplines and intellectual perspectives. It represents no single school of thought. It is also resolutely international in its coverage; in each volume we seek to explore the issues from a true world diversity of geo-cultural perspectives. Hence here too the sheer variety of apparent universals such as cultural expression, creativity and innovation is made plain by the diversity of contributions from all the world’s regions. Although academybased, our enterprise has always welcomed contributions from public intellectuals, journalists, activists and indeed artists. In this volume, as befits the topic, there are even more contributions from artists and/or arts activists than in the previous two; and precisely because artistic expression is the core issue, we are also pleased to include 16 extra pages of colour plates at the end of Part 1. In line with previous volumes, we solicited and then organized the contributions under several different structural headings. The first set includes chapters tackling overarching, general issues across a range of genres or disciplines. Next, and by contrast, we have placed contributions that analyse issues that are specific or at least particularly salient in different world regions – though here too, it must be said, some of the phenomena
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 9
INTRODUCTION
described could well occur, although perhaps less strikingly, in any other part of the world. The third section includes chapters that deal with particular artistic genres or issues.
Overarching Issues Appropriately for a volume which seeks to challenge the monopoly which the ‘creative industries’ discourse has acquired, Rustom Bharucha opens the Overarching Issues section with his ‘Creativity: Alternative Paradigms to the “Creative Economy” ’ an essay that analyses the everyday traditional Indian art of floor-drawing, kalam, which is not linked to an individual artist, but to the cultural expression of an entire community which earns its livelihood through the perpetuation of this practice. He highlights creative principles like impermanence, ecology, and humility that are exemplified by this expressive language, which because it is also religious operates at both ‘material and immaterial’ levels. While it could be argued that a vast body of creative practices in the ‘global South’ are no longer as resilient as the kalam – and therefore, a policy for their preservation and the income generation of their custodians becomes mandatory – the articulation of such policy should come from the communities themselves. However, in the top-down expertise that marks the rhetoric and legislation of many policies that purport to preserve or strengthen cultural expression, people’s considerations are all too often erased. ‘Recognition and Artistic Creativity’ is the topic Joni Maya Cherbo and Harold L. Vogel explore. Their treatment focuses on the USA, yet they also reject the methodological individualism of the Romantic solitary genius perspective. Inspired by Csikszentmihalyi’s systemic approach, they foreground the importance of social recognition in the phenomenon of creativity. Even in contemporary Western society, artistic creativity is a high risk endeavour; most artistic products fail to cover their investment. Analysing the social context, the authors identify the various stages involved in the process of bringing an artistic work to fruition: origination, presentation/promotion, distribution and evaluation. At each stage various social factors can assist or hinder the reception of any artistic product. In different ways, these conditions are being enhanced by an increasing global interconnectivity
9
between peoples, as technology enables and encourages access to new audiences and provides outlets for artistic careers. Gerardo Mosquera’s metaphor of ‘walking with the Devil’ further problematizes issues such as these. Based on his long experience as a leading international curator, his chapter analyses contemporary globalized art circuits. It explores the tensions between cultural homogenization and the countervailing efforts of new cultural subjects who are diversifying international art practice, and also discusses the new epistemological grounds in which artistic discourses unfold. The dramatic expansion in the creation and circulation of contemporary art has developed ever-increasing globalized art scenes while stimulating new local energies. However, instead of a global mosaic of distinct artistic practices, what we see is the plural construction of international art and its language. The Devil in his title is an allegory for hegemonic, internationalized Western metaculture (while God is the local and the singular): in an old fable, a peasant invokes both, contradictorily, in order to cross a perilous bridge. But in the new version of the fable, the Devil tells the peasant, ‘Follow your own path, but let me accompany you, accept me, and I will open the doors of the world for you’. And the peasant, somewhat fearful, yet at the same time pragmatic and ambitious, accedes. Walking with the Devil has become a plausible strategy for visual artists everywhere … Gilane Tawadros also walks the terrain of contemporary visual art in her chapter entitled ‘… But What is the Question? – Art, Research and the Production of Knowledge’, but interrogates this domain as a form of knowledge production. How does artistic knowledge production differ from textbased forms of research and knowledge production? she asks. What new insights or investigations are made possible by the processes of making artworks (or, indeed, of making exhibitions)? What are the implications of this for the ways in which we have traditionally understood and validated knowledge? How does globalization contribute to our understanding of visual art as a form of knowledge production? This chapter takes specific artworks and exhibitions as its ‘evidence’ base for exploring these questions and investigates the role that artworks and exhibitions play in the production of knowledge in a globalized world. Maruška Svašek’s ‘Improvizing in a World of Movement: Transit, Transition and Transformations’
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
10
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 10
INTRODUCTION
sees improvisation as the key to interpreting how globalizing forces stimulate cultural production, appropriation and recontextualization. To what extent are these processes controlled, welcomed or criticized by the various actors involved? She argues that creativity should be measured across the entire production process, exploring the active embodied engagement of cultural producers with their work in progress and explores three projects in which two flag makers and one contemporary artist from Ghana have interacted with individuals and groups in Northern Ireland. Svašek defines ‘transit’ as the movement of people, objects and images across space and time; ‘transition’ refers to transit-related changes in the products of cultural production in terms of their meaning, value and emotional efficacy; ‘transformation’ concerns the dynamic ways in which people in transit relate to changing social and material environments. Through ‘improvisation’ they react to new challenges and demands, taking on contextuallyspecific roles and identities, and gaining various degrees of ownership over the working process and its outcomes. Transit is also the concern of the West Indian political economist Keith Nurse, who recounts how the intersection of globalization and diasporas in our time has led to new geo-economic, political, social and cultural spaces that link societies, transcend the boundaries of nation-states and hybridize cultural identities. This domain shows how cultural influences move in many different directions nowadays, bringing about rather more artistic hybridization than homogenization. Much of the literature tends to see global flows principally in a North to South or core-to-periphery direction and fails to capture the tremendous impact of migration and the growth of contemporary diasporas on the North. While the periphery is greatly influenced by the societies of the core, the reverse is also the case and as a consequence it is critical to examine the counter flow, the periphery-to-core cultural flows. Nurse therefore analyses the transfer of popular culture forms from the Caribbean and Latin America to the North Atlantic on the basis of reggaeton, which has risen to prominence and influences Latino and worldwide youth audiences, and on the transnational success of Caribbean carnivals. He argues that diasporic cultures in general, often embodied in popular cultures, employ an ‘aesthetic of resistance’ that confronts and subverts
hegemonic modes of representation and thus acts as a counter-hegemonic tradition to the geocultural constructions embodied in notions of empire, nation, class, ‘race’, gender, sexuality, and ethnicity. They express what Stuart Hall (1997) calls the ‘redemptive move’ … ‘born of travelling, rupture, appropriation, loss, exile’. In this sense, the popular cultures of the diaspora are not just an aesthetic and commercial space where artistic expressions and psychic and bodily pleasures are enacted, represented and marketed, but also an arena where social values and meaning are put on public display, negotiated and contested. Nurse concludes that diasporic cultural expressions and practices facilitate aesthethic innovation as well as sociopolitical change in both receiving and sending countries. Copyright, the main form of intellectual property in cultural production, has played a key part in globalization. Although it is presented as an unalloyed good by its powerful defenders in corporations and states, Jason Toynbee’s chapter argues to the contrary that copyright is of dubious value. For in fact, he argues, the expansive copyright regime which characterizes the present era threatens vulnerable cultures – both traditional and hybrid – around the world. He refutes the conventional rationales for copyright, both economic and aesthetic, drawing supporting evidence from the cases of music making in Jamaica and Bollywood films. These surprisingly parallel examples suggest that creative cultures can flourish in, and may even depend upon, the absence of effective copyright. While IP has been expanding since the mid-1980s, no case has been made as to how extensive IP rights actually need to be in order to overcome the economic ‘problem’ of non-rival, non-excludable cultural goods. Copyright has grown longer, and covered more forms of cultural practice and technologies of replication. It has also extended its reach into the poorest countries of the world. Yet there is no evidence that we have seen a concomitant increase in creativity. Indeed, some economists argue that the current ‘big copyright’ regime is leading to less innovation in cultural markets. Two essays on generic issues close this overview section. The first, ‘Exile, Culture and Identity’, consists of reflections on the part of a diasporized philosopher, Rasoul Nejadmehr, now a leading cultural actor in Sweden, whose itinerary has taken him from his native Iran to Scandinavia.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 11
INTRODUCTION
He explores the cognitive values of being born in a nomadic family, of being a political exile and of organizing a music festival, Culture in Exile. The argument is that exile and nomadic thought are two key inter-connected features in a world characterized by movement and the dissolution of boundaries, where few stable positions can be adopted by the individual. Dislocation is a creative state of mind that enables a radical critique of the dominant discourses on culture and identity. Ever thoughtprovoking, the theatre scholar and cultural activist Dragan Klaic interrogates a raft of recent and ongoing manifestations of evil. How ‘creative’ are these behaviours on the part of both small and big time crooks who indulge in various forms of crime and destruction? Evil, affirms Klaic, can be surprising and innovative, but not creative. Creativity needs to be affirmed in its utopian core, in benefits to be shared as a common good. In this perspective, he sees combating climate change and its consequences as the major challenge to artistic creativity today.
Regional Realities Paul Brickhill, a life-long cultural entrepreneur in Zimbabwe, opens the Regional Realities section with his treatment of ‘The “Creator” as Entrepreneur: an African Perspective’, an exploration of how artists across the continent have succeeded in creating a diversity of hybrid continuously evolving art forms and techniques in the face of grinding economic poverty and an extremely limited infrastructure, both of which have led to the large emigration of many others. How do those who stay and survive as artists make their livelihood? What is the social interplay between livelihood and the creative process? What types of connections and contradictions exist between African art and global influences? In what ways is African art both ‘universal’ and ‘African’? A starting point for Brickhill is storytelling – in which artist and audience are interwoven – for this is how all African art is understood by Africans themselves. The historic migration of peoples has created an awareness of art as being transient, informed by memory, captured by stories, crafted by improvisation and retold in limitless variation of forms. While there is a distinctive connectedness between culture and social life in Africa, individual creative genius also drives the artistic
11
process. The author looks at the ways the practices involved are imagined, lived and retained and linked to globalization, taking examples drawn from stone sculpture, township jazz, Ghanaian highlife, Afro-beat, Zimbabwean mbira, marimba, books and literature, stories and story-telling, youth poetry and Nigerian film. In ‘The Turn of the Native: Vernacular Creativity in the Caribbean’, Annie Paul, a writer and critic at the University of the West Indies, takes up similar issues. In the island countries of the Caribbean, ‘low-budget’ people have creatively married oral traditions with the most advanced technology to create a highly mobile, popular, hybrid musical product that is competitive internationally with similar products from the most affluent societies. Utilizing the transistor set, the recording studio and the gigantic sound system, Jamaican music has disseminated itself to a multitude of audiences – spanning the local, the national, the regional, and the diasporic and transnational with an ebullience and success unmatched by the formal, official, ‘standard’ English-speaking circuits of culture. Jamaican music has also subverted standard notions of copyright, creativity and originality, adapting the Western music model to the new hybridities thrown up in the syncretistic plantation spaces of the Caribbean. The ‘vernacular’ that Paul uses refers precisely to subaltern practices of expressive engagement that reflect the dynamic, adaptive, character of Jamaican patois, in constant dialogue and negotiation with the diasporic, the transnational and the global. The experience of socially conscious graphic designers is the topic of Huda Smitshuijzen Abifarès’s chapter entitled ‘Creative Contemporary Design in the Arab World’. Herself a skilled practitioner from the region, she sheds light on yet another variant of the encounter between locally anchored creativity and the challenges of globalization. Historically, the interaction of Arab peoples with others has shaped and consolidated the visual aspects of the rich traditions of Islamic art. This type of mixing and assimilation of foreign aesthetic repertoire is still part of the Arab visual culture. How are these creative practices being renewed today in the Arab world and in the Arab diaspora? The work of a new generation of cultural entrepreneurs, their networks and other cross-cultural collaborations, together represent a striving to shape visual culture in ways that capture and express contemporary
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 12
INTRODUCTION
identity, as young designers embrace Western design ideologies, yet subvert them to their own ends and needs. The resultant hybrid creative practices are being steadily recognized, building up a following, and putting into motion new forms of globalized creative production. Cultural freedom, the artist’s licence to express, comment and critique, is clearly under siege in many parts of the world. One of the factors working against artistic freedom is the perceived threat of ‘contamination’ by globalization. Political scientists Laurent Gayer, Christophe Jaffrelot and Malvika Maheshwari explore how in South Asia, Islamist and Hindu fundamentalist movements have exerted an ever stronger influence, introducing novel forms of ‘cultural policing’ that reject artistic freedom, and in the process erode the colonial legacy of judicial activism. They understand ‘cultural policing’ as all attempts at imposing ways of thinking and behaving on behalf of value systems pertaining to religion or morality that resort to symbolic or physical violence, blackmailing or any other form of constraint. Significantly, agencies of this form of governmentality are non-state actors – fundamentalist groups, guerrillas, militias – which may, however, be used by government in an indirect manner. In this sense, cultural policing represents a certain privatization of the implementation of law and order. Thus, in Bangladesh, India and Pakistan, writers, painters and filmmakers have been attacked for ‘blasphemy and outraging religion’. They have also faced the wrath of the moral police for interpreting homosexuality and widow remarriage. The state apparatus in these countries has not necessarily protected the victims of this form of social control; in a sense cultural policing has become part of the state’s authority. South Asia thus finds itself in the situation of negotiating permissible boundaries for artistic creativity, whose integrity is now more than ever dependent on the rule of law. Taking us from cultural constraint to cultural change, Zala Volcic explores ‘The Struggle to Express, Create and Represent in the Balkans’. How have peoples in the countries of the former Yugoslavia managed to symbolize the subsumption of politics to popular culture? Where once the landscape bristled with statues of political heroes and military leaders, now a new breed of statuary has emerged in the form of a bronzed homage to icons of the global pop culture: Bruce Lee, Bob Marley,
Rocky, etc. Rather than dismiss these often kitsch sculptures as symbols of the victory of commercial culture at ‘the end of history’, Volcic sees them as evidence of a particular kind of cultural expression, creating bricolage in a region still searching for a twenty-first century sense of identity. What we are witnessing, the author suggests, is a global diffusion and a local creative appropriation of popular culture. At the same time, and taking a cue from geographers, she analyses the importance of various sites of mourning and remembering, exploring how new monuments are being built, how new holidays and ceremonies are being introduced, how new creative symbols are being developed, and how new hybrid identities are emerging. Another general question is that of how certain discourses of creativity and culture become globalized. Geographer Lily Kong’s ‘Globalizing Discourses and the Implications for Local Arts’ asks how the notions of ‘creative economy’ and ‘global city’ get diffused and circulated across the world. She is concerned in particular with two key elements of these discourses: the development of creative industry clusters and the attraction of the ‘creative class’ as residents. She asks how these Western European notions (cf. our Introduction to The Cultural Economy volume in 2008) have migrated into contexts which are generally quite different from their origins, and the implications of their importation for local creative cultural work. She examines the ways in which monumentality constitutes symbolic capital for the global city, evidenced, for example, in the development of urban mega projects, and interrogates the accumulation of cultural capital through the construction of a largescale cultural infrastructure in the East Asian cities she observes. The global city, it is believed, must endow itself with cultural institutions such as museums, theatres and libraries, in order to support cultural activities, to exude cultural ambience, and to develop cultural ‘ballast’. In the cities Kong has observed, as the creative class component of creative economy discourse and the monumental component of global city discourse intersect, the development of indigenous creative cultural work actually takes a back seat.
Genres and Issues Peter Tschmuck’s exploration of creativity in the music industry opens the Genres and Issues
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 13
INTRODUCTION
section both because it represents another ‘take’ on the creative industries discourse and because it also anchors the creative act in its broader political economy context. The history of the music industry since its emergence in the late nineteenth century reveals a business cycle in which different configurations – from tight oligopolies to highly competitive markets – correpond to different degrees of creative output. While during oligopolistic phases more or less one music style (Swing in the 1940s or superstar-pop in the 1990s) dominates the scene, in more competitive phases such as we are experiencing today there is a great diversity of music expressions. Tschmuck explores the interrelationship between changing industry structure and changing creative expression, and uses this to generate a model of innovation and creativity. He also explicates the new network of production, distribution and reception that dominates the music industry today, reconfiguring the relationships between artists, record labels, music publishers, concert promoters, property rights agencies, etc. In ‘Creative Communities and Emerging Networks’, Clayton Campbell, a practising artist and pioneer of the global artists’ residency movement, reveals analogous transformations in the notfor-profit arts sector, as he examines a range of networks and ‘creative communities’ founded by artists, and discusses how their formation is informed by artist practice. The ‘divergent thinking’ that forms a cornerstone of artistic creativity engages globalization in imaginative ways, as these alternative artist spaces construct new forms of international collaborations and partnerships. Campbell provides ‘snapshots’ of such alternative art centres and networks that take a holistic view of global thinking, share a common concern for social justice, and seek to replace the global models of market capitalism with the global principles of community and inclusion. Reading globalization from the vantage point of the creative artist, the chapter presents examples of how artists themselves are providing innovative templates for interaction, stimulated by the propensity in contemporary art-making towards collaboration and team building. These are communities and networks informed by the direct practice of the artist, and they are stimulating the growth of new kinds of inter-cultural connection. Different sorts of ‘creative spaces’ are explored by Canadian scholars Nancy Duxbury and Catherine Murray. What are the forces structuring
13
those sites which appear to foster new types of collaboration between and among individual creative acts? In these creative spaces the design of place, contextualization and aesthetics of space all have a strong bearing on creativity and innovation. This chapter outlines the conceptual underpinnings of creative spaces as physical, embedded places where creative production, exhibition and consumption occur. Their scale can range from the global hierarchy of cities, their emergent rivals and the satellite communities or cracks at the margins and boundaries of systems, to the sub-city-scale hubs and particular places of connection in which global and local flows of creativity and innovation mix and are facilitated. The chapter examines a knowledge production process consisting of ideas (embedded intelligences and imagination), planning (patterns of involvement and intervention), and policy (integration). The authors argue for a ‘cultural ecology’ that is constructivist, holistic, and based on both physical and social infrastructure. They argue that creative space-making as a policy subfield must more adequately incorporate issues of locality, sociality, cultural diversity, and equity while bridging disparate professional vocabularies or grammars of space. Translation is central to understanding how cultural expression travels and is transformed. While much critiquing of the globalization of literature focuses on the hegemony – and homogenizing tendencies – of the English language, Stefan Helgesson’s close comparative study of actual translation patterns tells a different story. Taking the Mozambican writer Mia Couto’s work as its main example, this chapter on literary hybrids and the circuits of translation shows how each translation may allow different meanings and emphases to emerge. Even Couto’s own writerly practice, with its hybridized language, can be read as a translation of sorts that addresses the consequences of an earlier globalization, i.e. colonialism. Hence, translation functions creatively and sometimes critically at many levels of a ‘globalized’ literature. Digital culture is a ‘brave new world’ in the making, explored in this volume by the Brazilian dancer and performance theorist Ivani Santana, who discusses the reconfigurations of cultural expressions emerging as a result of the intertwining of visual and digital culture. Santana illustrates her argument with her personal experience of telematics, deployed in order to stage a dance spectacle with
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
14
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 14
INTRODUCTION
dancers and musicians in three different Brazilian cities: dance in Salvador and Brasilia, music in João Pessoa. In Brasilia the public watched the spectacle in a theatre where some dancers interacted with (the image) of their colleagues located in Salvador. While the public was present in Brasilia, the space in Salvador was configured as the studio of an ‘intelligent stage’. The image of the video-scenography was processed in real time; the result on the Internet was the sum of these layers of images. Creativity in fashion is so spectacularly at the forefront these days that our volume would be incomplete without an exploration of this domain. Mo Tomaney and Julie Thomas do not merely tread celebratory ground, however, for their concern in the ‘Fashion and Ethics’ chapter is to raise key ethical debates relating to the production and consumption of fashion and textiles in the context of fashion as a global industry. Fashion, by its nature and definition, gives clothing a status that represents more than just protection from the elements or modesty; rather, it is a vehicle for self-definition, a sophisticated form of self-expression that touches most people, while at its most expressive, clothing and fashion can be used as a creative instrument that emulates or becomes artistry or performance. The consumption of clothing is universal; however, the way people consume fashion is not. The authors also evoke possible new models for creative practice and fashion consumption in relation to craftsmanship, ‘slow fashion’, recycling, the secondhand clothing trade, and the clothing industry. There is an interface between organizational creativity and innovation and the cultural sector. Private foundations have long claimed the privilege of more creative ways of working. In ‘Philanthropy and the Promotion of Cultural Expression’, Diana Leat addresses these claims, as she discusses the role of philanthropy in cultural expression, creativity and innovation. This interplay in the context of globalization is more complex than it might first appear. Foundations are indeed subject to global homogenizing trends in the way in which they work – their standards and processes – but that this does not (yet) necessarily imply a similar homogeneity in what they fund. While some philanthropic giving reflects homogenizing trends there are at least four factors that limit these: the variety of philanthropic structures; real and imagined legal restrictions restricting global reach; a variety of approaches and purposes in funding artistic and cultural
expression; and the resistant creativity of, in particular, endowed foundations. In point of fact, foundations act as small but significant buffers against the centralizing tendencies of the global art and media markets; sources of both innovation and preservation, independent of the market; forces for increased democratization, access to and recognition of artistic and cultural expression and forms; and bridge-builders between traditions and cultures, and between competing frameworks for the evaluation and legitimation of the value of artistic endeavour. Without straying too far from artistry, our core concern, we have chosen to highlight broader forms of expressive social behaviour by asking the Mexican cognitive scientist and digital researcher Eugenio Tisselli to explore the ways in which digital social networks can be seen as ‘strategies of the imagination’ – his chapter’s title. These now pervasive networks offer tools enabling millions of users to publish online all types of content and personal information. Making ‘friends’ on these networks is as simple as pointing and clicking. Yet the participative facade of these online applications conceals a set of disciplining technologies for contemporary capitalism, he argues, where the apparent excess of socialization really stands for the multiplication of weak and disengaged relationships. His chapter explores how the standard modes of operation of digital networks can be and are being overridden through appropriation, and how this appropriation can lead to socially relevant innovation and change. An example is zexe.net: a project in which digital networks and technologies are appropriated and used by marginalized communities to speak out and raise public awareness about their specific issues. Part 1 is brought to a close by Guest Editor Chris Waterman, a professional double-bass player and ethnomusicologist, currently Dean of the School of the Arts and Architecture at the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA). His own chapter is based on a set of vignettes reflecting different types of engagements between popular cultural expression and globalization processes. These range from a comedy/music group in pre-World War II Japan and their pastiche of American popular culture, to community musicians in rural Peru inserting commentary on 9/11 in their locally grounded creativity, and to a Yoruba taxi driver’s intense emotional identification with the power of
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 15
INTRODUCTION
the praise poems sung at his father’s funeral. For Waterman, all three examples testify to the prosthetic power of the many forms of cultural expression that cut across the local and the global, occupying the interstitial spaces, the in-between, and also challenging the established categories of cultural hierarchies and institutions. These expressive forms, as well as all those discussed by the contributors to this volume, are living testimony to the ways in which cultures, instead of being taken as fixed essences, are lived and experienced as ‘worldly, productive sites of crossing: complex unfinished paths between local and global attachments’ (Clifford, 1998: 362, 365). These are the routes of a ‘discrepant cosmopolitanism’ that ‘gives us a way of perceiving, and valuing, different forms of encounter, negotiation, and multiple affiliation in the place of simple difference’. Indeed it is these pathways of creative expression that challenge those global scripts of the culture concept itself, understood both as ‘ways of life’ and as ‘arts and heritage’, those conflated understandings that, as we observed in our Introduction to the inaugural volume of this Series, have generated such a range of expectations, anxieties and illusions across the world. The expectations are tied to what Stuart Hall (1997) has called the
15
‘centrality of culture’. The anxieties arise from its frequent abuse, while the illusions are the result of overblown visions, of simplifications that are reductive, and readings that are instrumental. We can only reiterate our conviction that the expectations can be justified, the anxieties allayed and the illusions dispelled by the patient and methodical marshalling of evidence in informed and conceptually sensitive ways. It is our hope that this volume in its turn will contribute meaningfully to this task.
Notes 1
2
3 4
The theme for the 2010 volume is ‘heritage, memory, identity’ and in 2011 the fifth volume of the Series will tackle the topic of cultural policy. As O’Connor also observes, though, most traditional notions of art also emphasized skill, craftsmanship, balance, harmony, the golden mean, the middle way. All are qualities which tend to be excluded from this new use of creativity (2007: 32). These include Brown and Dugiud (2002), Burt (2005), Kanter (1983), Kao (1991), and Landry (2000). See National Bureau of Economic Analysis (2006) Symposium on ‘New Ideas about New Ideas’, 10–11 March 2006. Available at http://www.nber.org/~sewp/ newideas.html.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Introduction:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
16
12/10/2009
12:28 PM
Page 16
INTRODUCTION
REFERENCES
Adorno, T. (1991) The Culture Industry. London: Routledge. Anheier, H. and Isar, Y.R., (2007) Conflicts and Tensions. The Culture and Globalization Series, 1. London: SAGE. Barber, B. (1995) Jihad vs. McWorld. New York: Times books. Brown, J.S. and Dugiud, P. (2002) ‘Creativity versus structure: a useful tension’, in E.B. Roberts (ed.), Innovation Driving Product, Process and Market Change. San Francisco, CA: MIT Sloan Management Review. Burt, R. (2005) Brokerage and Closure: An Introduction to Social Capital. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. Clifford, J. (1998) ‘Mixed feelings’, in P. Cheah and B. Robbins (eds), Cosmopolitics: Thinking and Feeling Beyond the Nation. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. pp. 362–370. Czikszentmihalyi, M. (1996) Creativity. New York: Harper Collins. Errington, S. (1998) The Death of Authentic Art and Other Tales of Progress. Berkeley: University of California Press. Florida, R. (2002) The Rise of the Creative Class. New York Basic. Gardner, H. (1993) Creating Minds. New York: Basic. Hall, S. (1997) ‘The centrality of culture: notes on the cultural revolutions of our time’, in K. Thompson (ed.), Media and Cultural Regulation, Buckinghamshine: Open University Press. Held, D., McGrew, A., Goldblatt, D. and Perraton, J. (1999) Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, and Culture. Cambridge: Polity. Kanter, R.M. (1983) The Change Masters: Innovations for productivity in the American corporation. New York: Simon and Schuster. Kao, J. (1991) Managing Creativity. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Landry, C. (2000) The Creative City: A Toolkit for Urban Innovators. London: Comedia, Earthscan Publications Ltd. Lubart, T.I. (1999) ‘Creativity across cultures’, in R.J. Sternberg (ed.), Handbook of Creativity, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Mosquera, G. (1994) ‘Some problems in transnational curating’, in J. Fisher (ed.), Global Visions: Towards a New Internationalism in the Visual Arts. London: Kala. Nelson, R.R. and Winter, S.G. (1982) An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change. Cambridge, MA: Belknap. O’Connor, J. (2007) The Cultural and Creative Industries: A Review of the Literature. London: Creative Partnerships, Arts Council England. Pettigrew, A.M. and E.M. Fenton (eds) (2000) The Innovating Organization. London: SAGE. Romanelli, E. and M.L. Tushman (1994) ‘Organizational transformation as punctuated equilibrium: an empirical test’, The Academy of Management Journal, 37 (5): 1141–1161. Sahlins, M. (1994) ‘A brief cultural history of culture’. Unpublished paper prepared for the World Commission on Culture and Development (UNESCO). Scott, A. (2008) ‘Retrospect and prospect’, in H.K. Anheier and Y.R. Isar (eds), The Cultural Economy. The Cultures and Globalization Series, 2. London: SAGE. Smith, A. (1992) ‘National identity and the idea of European unity’, International Affairs, 68. Sternberg, R.J. and Lubart, T.I (1999) ‘The concept of creativity: prospect and paradigms’, in R.J. Sternberg (ed.), Handbook of Creativity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Tomlinson, J. (1999) Globalisation and Culture. Cambridge: Polity Press. Tusa, J. (2003) On Creativity. London: Methuen. Williams, R. (1988) Keywords: A vocabulary of culture and society. London: Fontana Press. Williams, R. (2001) The Long Revolution. Calgary: Broadview.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
PART 1 ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
Page 17
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 18
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
OVERARCHING ISSUES
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 19
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 20
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 21
CHAPTER 1 CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’ Rustom Bharucha
through new modes of production and distribution, even as it upholds the need for context-sensitive economies. Highlighting alternative paradigms of creativity in the cultures of the ‘South’, the chapter concludes with a few reflections on how these paradigms can provide new directions for the shaping of a more dialogic cultural policy.
Building on the premise that creativity is not the prerogative of any particular class, any more so than it can be mobilized equitably by the pseudo-democratic and instrumentalist agendas of the state, this chapter argues against the appropriation of creativity within the premises of the ‘creative economy’. In opposition to the profit-making propensities of the global market, it highlights creative principles like impermanence, ecology, and humility, drawn out of everyday cultural practices in the Indian context, notably floor-drawings. Complicating the argument, it does not rule out the possibilities of either the commodification or innovation of traditional artefacts
Against the growing discourse that has emerged around the ‘creative economy’ (Howkins, 2001), this essay reflects on ‘creativity’ through a web of intersecting concepts and practices. The ‘creative economy’ has been catalyzed by a series of theoretical interventions which have parasitically drawn on the ‘culture industry’ (Adorno, 1991), ‘cultural industries’ (Garnham, 2000; 2005), ‘creative industries’ (Caves, 2000; Hartley, 2004), the ‘creative class’ (Florida, 2002; 2005), and the ‘cultural economy’ (Anheier and Isar, 2008; Cunningham et al., 2008). Oscillating between ‘cultural’ and ‘creative’, ‘industry’ and ‘economy’, this nit-picking juxtaposition of terms has assumed discriminations and implications of power in policy-making and managerial services relating to the profit-making and social propensities of cultural goods and services. Increasingly, the dissemination of this discourse has assumed a global scale, which would seem to have increased in almost direct proportion to its media-driven and corporate hype. The purpose here is to work against this hype in order to highlight those particular modes and modalities of creativity in the cultures of the ‘South’ which do not lend themselves to the imperatives of the global economy, even as they seek out their own modes of sustainability within – and against – the logic of commodification. Arguably, the ‘creative economy’ (and its concomitant ‘creative industries’ and ‘creative class’) have very little to do with the multi-dimensional complexities of creativity as it unfolds and manifests itself in a multitude of artistic and cultural practices. As used by a coterie of predominantly neo-liberal economists, the ‘creative’ component in the ‘creative economy’ is at best a catch-word, if not a logo, clubbing together distinct categories like
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
22
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 22
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
‘skill’, ‘talent’, and ‘innovation’,1 which masquerade an affinity to the world of artists but with no real evidence of the labour and imagination that go into art-making. At one level then, the thrust of my critique in this essay is leveled against the appropriation and decontextualization of ‘creativity’ from its diverse manifestations as well as the phenomenological processes underlying artistic and cultural expression. At another level, however, I am equally concerned with the singularization of the creative economy within the strictures of the so-called ‘knowledge economy’ or ‘information society’, consolidated and driven by the technologies of ‘copyright, patent, trademark, and design industries’ (Howkins, 2001: xiii). This equation of creativity with intellectual property would seem to be totally indifferent to other cultural understandings of the economy, where the mechanisms of markets and trading practices may be mediated by the communitarian values of generosity, altruism, and sharing. These values complicate the neo-classical premises of economics regulating the transactions of everyday life cultures. Indeed, without this melding of cultural values and economic mechanisms, as I will demonstrate in the course of this chapter, a vast body of cultural expressions and rituals from diverse cultures in the global ‘South’ could not have survived over the years. In the process, the livelihoods of artisan communities and subaltern artists from the most downtrodden sectors of society would have been seriously jeopardized. It is necessary, therefore, to keep in mind that while the emergence of the ‘creative economy’ discourse goes back barely to the late 1990s, symptomatic of neo-liberal global capitalism and market-friendly New Labour policies, the temporalities of creativity encompass a much vaster history of time. I will provide a few glimpses of those creative practices whose legacies go back hundreds of years, testifying to the truism that ‘living traditions’ have fairly resilient economies or else they could not have survived and grown over the years. While highlighting the endurance, reinvention and altered manifestations of traditional practices in the cultures of everyday life, I will also attempt to stretch their assumptions of creativity in relation to the more pragmatic possibilities of commodification and innovation. My purpose is not to demonize the commercial or marketing propensities of the creative economy, but to question their viability at
material and social levels. Arguably, the mandate of the creative industries has not been fulfilled, and its attempt to formulate a ‘policy’, as pointed out by Andrew Ross, has been ‘mercurial’ rather than sustainable: The carefully packaged policy of creative industries will not generate jobs; it is a recipe for magnifying patterns of class polarization; its function as a cover for the corporate intellectual property grab will become all too apparent; its urban development focus will price out the very creatives on whose labour it depends; its reliance on self-promoting rhetoric runs far in advance of its proven impact; its cookie-cutter approach to economic development does violence to regional specificity; its adoption of an instrumental value of creativity will cheapen the true worth of artistic creation. (Ross, 2007: 18)
The systematic failure of the creative industries is substantiated by the even more ‘mercurial’ transition from ‘the rise of the creative class’ (Florida, 2002) to the ‘flight of the creative class’ (Florida, 2005), all in a matter of three years. Richard Florida’s predictions indicate the ephemerality of this ‘class’, even as the statistical evidence of socalled ‘creative cities’ indicates that rumours of their economic productivity have been grossly exaggerated: the European Commission’s evaluation of 29 Cities of Culture discloses that ‘their principal goal – economic growth stimulated by the public subvention of culture to renew failed cities – has itself failed’ (Miller, 2007: 45). Even if these cities do manage to generate more jobs as Andrew Ross candidly points out, the ‘polarization of city life between affluent cores and low-income margins’ (Ross, 2007: 28) can only intensify. Florida’s euphoric notion of creativity as ‘everyone’s natural asset to exploit’ (2007: 28) is proving to be thoroughly unproductive and may even disappear in due course just as the bubble of the New Economy promoted by the advocates of New Labour in Britain has already burst. Instead of pursuing this critique of the creative industries and economy,2 my purpose in this chapter is to focus attention on the alternative paradigms of creativity to be found in so-called ‘traditional’ sectors of everyday life cultures in the ‘South’. As we will discover, the ‘traditional’ can also be deeply contemporary, not only in its registers of
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 23
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
resistance to an obligatory globalization but also in its potentially disruptive and subversive affirmation of value-systems which counter the assumptions of the creative economy. Let me emphasize that I look upon this economy not as a threat but as a necessary provocation which compels me to be more circumspect about what I assume by ‘creativity’ in the first place.
Complicating the epistemologies of creativity If one acknowledges that creativity is not an essentialized quality, or immutable property, but is better regarded as a faculty of imagination which catalyzes a process of interactions, we would still be relying on a thoroughly nebulous notion of creativity. The rigor in articulating creativity can begin to emerge only when this ‘process of interactions’ is contextualized within the specific disciplinary procedures of the arts, encompassing components like training, transmission, technique, and conditions of work, among other factors that go into the production and reception of any work of art. While these components appear to be abstract, they gain very concrete, if not tangible, manifestations within the vocabulary and grammar of specific disciplines. To spell out my position more clearly, the creativity of a musician – and not just any musician, but, let’s say, a cellist – would need to be recognized and accounted for in ways that would be quite significantly different from, say, that of a poet or potter or video artist. The terminology of art practices is, more often than not, a highly honed and textured field of critical discriminations which facilitates the evaluation of the creativity in question. This precision can border on the prescriptive, as we will examine later. Let me provide at this point some evidence of the ‘texturality’ of creativity, drawing on my own affiliation to the performing arts. For my evidence, I turn to a few creative categories from the ancient Indian tract of the Natyasastra (circa first century BC–second century AD), one of the earliest encyclopedias of performance in the world. What concerns me here are not the minutiae of technicality relating to the micro-movements of eyes, neck, chest, hands, hips, legs, feet, down to the most infinitesimal signs of psychophysical expressivity. The terminological virtuosity of the Natyasastra in Sanskrit would be somewhat out of place in this chapter; it would also
23
be misleading because the sheer knowledge of all these hundreds of movements and micro-movements does not necessarily ensure the ‘creativity’ of the performance. Rattling off the minute categories can be an act of pedantry, but where creativity counts is in the actual embodiment or expression of these movements. Therefore, while the fingers in one hand or both can be positioned in any number of combinations to create hastas (hand-gestures), denoting a vista of objects and phenomena and emotional registers, it is hasta-prana which makes the gestures come alive through the infusion of breath (prana). (In a sense, this is not very different from that excruciatingly beautiful line attributed to Emily Dickinson when she asked, ‘Do my poems breathe?’) In this embodiment of emotions through breath, one is alerted to the enormously subtle, if not evanescent dimensions of creative expression in performance. Even when dealing with the practicalities of dramaturgical structure, it is telling how the primary ingredients of creativity appear to be elusive, beginning with kama (desire), bija (seed), and bindu (drop), which dilate and catalyze a chemistry of actions constituting the plot of the play. This play, however, only begins to make sense when the entire process is received – or more specifically tasted – by the spectators through the experience of rasa (literally, ‘juice’). I realize that I am merely sketching the mutations of one of the most complex aesthetic categories from the Indian subcontinent, but for my purpose here, I would stress that creativity is not an inherent category, but more of a relational process in which the thing perceived is shared through a transpersonal exchange and abstraction of emotions. Who shares? Is it the actor or the spectator or both? Or some other third entity that emerges out of the imaginary of the experience in which the actor, character, fictional situation, reception, and the suspended historical moment of time, are all immersed in one transcendent moment of bliss? While the philosophical intricacy of such questions cannot be answered within the framework of this chapter, they indicate that creativity is not just the agency of the so-called creator, it also encompasses the capacity to receive – and induce – the process of creativity through the imaginative inputs of the spectator/listener. Creativity is, therefore, a deeply participatory process, which at one level can be linked to the
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
24
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 24
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
more current vogue for ‘interactivity’, as in video games (one of the most lucrative multi-billion products of the creative industries). The difference, however, is that the images of the video game, more often than not linked to raging battles and galactic missiles in outer space or terrorist zones, have already been created by the designer(s), whose creativity is patented and branded. While these images can be manipulated by the reflexes of those who are playing the game, the images themselves are already fixed, though reassembled, quite unlike the emotions and sensations shared in the exchange of rasa which are not spelled out in advance. Rather, they can exist only in the process of their evolution in an imaginary space, where the pleasure of the aesthetic experience is at once ‘disciplined’ and ‘trained’ through specific protocols, and yet free of these constraints in the actual moment of enjoyment.
The problem of exclusivity Returning to my broader purpose of attempting to assess the modalities of creativity in the contemporary world, I would acknowledge that there are at least two difficulties with the invocation of rasa (or, other such traditional aesthetic categories like hana, or ‘flower’, as formulated by Zeami in the context of Noh theatre). One problem could be that these categories are far too refined and, almost inevitably, they are at once exclusionary and exclusivist. They demand specific modes of enculturation which are, more often than not, linked to the privileges of class and a particular education of the senses. Representing a more heightened form of ‘distinction’ than Bourdieu (1984) could have imagined in his examination of social and cultural capital in a predominantly bourgeois milieu, one should acknowledge that the acquisition of rasa (as a discourse rather than a lived practice) can result in a brahmanical assertion of cultural supremacy, which exudes violence in its regimentation of the senses passing as authentically ‘Indian’. One caveat needs to be added here to qualify the argument. Exclusivity, I would argue, is not the domain of traditional aesthetics alone. Indeed, it can exist in all kinds of liberal modes and forms of creative assertion, exemplifying a plurality of lifestyles and democratic interaction with other cultures and ethnicities. What, indeed, could be more
exclusivist than the notion of a ‘creative class’? Despite his pitch for the innovation of new modes of living and generating capital, Richard Florida ultimately lands up asserting one of the most emphatic categories by which people are differentiated and divided: ‘class’. Only his criteria are a lot less exacting than those of Marx. Not only does he have no difficulty in restricting this class to 38 million metropolitan Americans, including architects, doctors, lawyers, and engineers, among other professionals who share some nebulous ‘creative’ affinities to artists, he also hypothesizes his theory on the basis of geographical proximities between metropolitan gay life-styles and wealth-generating creative innovations. It is a sad reflection of the neo-liberal state of our times that an ostensibly gayfriendly and pluralist approach to culture should rest on unsubstantiated differences between those gays who are willy-nilly ‘creative’ because they live in cool cities like San Francisco, while their counterparts in Kansas City or Poughkeepsie lie ipso facto outside the purview of creativity. Both in terms of the politics of sexuality and the equations between sexuality and economics, this theory is frightfully thin. Having acknowledged that the problem of exclusivity does not have to be restricted to traditional contexts of knowledge, let us now spell out yet another difficulty in invoking categories like rasa within the context of creativity in our time. It could be argued that creativity cannot be confined to those art practices which have defined disciplinary procedures, as I have argued earlier. What about those acts of creativity that remain unrecognized, embedded in the habitus of everyday life, where there is no necessary cognizance or recognition of actions relating to cooking, dressing, washing, ritual worship, and the nurturing of children and old people? Are these actions, the outcomes of deeply internalized modes of enculturation, to be automatically relegated to the domain of ‘the social’? And is the social to be equated with the necessities of the functional and the communicative, as opposed to the gratuitous benefits of the creative? Such dichotomies are untenable, as will become evident later, in my description of one particular traditional cultural practice. Before doing so, let me further complicate the thrust of my argument by posing the reverse problematic of exclusivity: namely, the ubiquity of creativity as a universal human resource.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 25
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
The problem of pseudo-democracy If the exclusionary dimensions of creativity should compel us to be more critically vigilant of its larger democratic access, it is equally necessary not to automatically uphold the reverse position that ‘everyone is creative’, which amounts to a kind of pseudo-democratic position. And yet, this is precisely the assumption underlying a Green Paper (April 2001) put forward by the British government’s Department of Culture, Media and Sport in its advocacy of ‘creative industries’. While the mantra of ‘everyone is creative’ could be rejected outright for its self-serving rhetoric in making all citizens appear to be equal contributors to the national economy,3 it would be useful to juxtapose its hype with a statement that would appear to be similar, even though its context is radically different. I am referring to the much-quoted statement by Joseph Beuys, one of the most prominent German political artists of the late twentieth century, who in one of his many discursive reflections on art practice had suggested the potentiality that ‘every human being is an artist’ (Harlan, 2004: 2). At first glance, it would seem that Beuys is merely echoing the rhetoric of New Labour, playing into populist notions of access and non-hierarchical and nonqualitative assessments of the social instrumentalization of art. However, this would be a serious distortion of Beuys’s position, which can be more accurately assessed through a scrutiny of his practice and politics. If ‘every human being is [potentially] an artist’, this cannot be assumed or legislated outside the actual practice in which the economy of artistic form has to emerge through engagements with materiality, ecology, public discourse, and political engagement. For Beuys, this engagement demanded nothing less than an unsparing opposition to the capitalist mode of production in which the cultures of everyday life are cosmeticized and reduced to consumerist banality. In one of his many measured yet radical statements, drawn out of conversations with the public which he regarded as part of his art practice, Beuys said: The concept of economic growth and the concept of capital and all that goes with it, does not really make the world productive. No, the concept of art must replace the degenerate concept of capital. Art is really tangible capital, and people need to
25
become aware of this … [C]apital is human dignity and creativity. And so, in keeping with this, we need to develop a concept of money that allows creativity, or art, so to speak, to be capital. Art is capital. This is not some pipe dream; it is a reality. In other words, capital is what art is. Capital is human capacity and what flows from it. (2004: 27)
The uncompromising tenor of these reflections, and their immersion in an anti-capitalist ideology, which does not stop Beuys from countering another notion of art as capital, is as removed from the slippery rhetoric of Cool Britannia as one can possibly imagine. While it is not possible here to provide a detailed inventory of Beuys’s art practice, which could demonstrate how his politics was actually embodied in his ‘social sculpture’ (or ‘expanded conception of art’), suffice it to say that his alchemical use of substances like wax, fat, felt, bone, copper, fossils, and his active ecological practice in the planting of ‘7,000 oak trees’, along with his blackboard drawings in public forums, provide one of the most exacting, if idiosyncratic, examples of how the socalled ‘ordinariness’ of culture, as evoked by Raymond Williams, can mobilize ‘warmth’ (Beuys, 2004). ‘Warmth’, not in the psychological sense of conviviality and bonding, now fetishized in the much-hyped experiments in ‘relational aesthetics’ (Bourriaud, 2002) in established museums. For Beuys, warmth is made of sterner stuff and has a profoundly social dimension as well as a spiritual propensity in its capacity to incorporate the world within one’s own self-transformative capacities. This process of self-transformation is achieved primarily through the dynamics of seeing whereby the phenomenon being observed is ‘inhabited’ by the observer, who lives its ‘activity’ and ‘interconnections’, creating an ‘inner image of what has been observed’ (Sacks, 2007: 1). Through the process of creating an inner image, the self is transformed at perceptual levels which defy the discursive strictures of the ‘creative industries’ and the ‘creative economy’. What is missing in these new assertions of creativity is a theory of seeing in relation to the ‘inner space of perception and imagination’ (2007: 1). One may not have the courage to affirm the act of seeing quite so unequivocally as Beuys does, but it underlies his advocacy of ‘human dignity and creativity’ in his celebration of ‘art as capital’ (2004: 27). While his vision remains
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
26
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 26
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
intransigent, it provides alternative points of reference which enable us to work against the grain of the pseudo-democratic platitude that ‘everyone is creative’.
Three principles of creativity Having outlined some concepts of creativity punctured by counter-references to the creative economy, I would now like to highlight three principles of creativity grounded in the cultures of everyday life through a focus on one particular practice: traditional floor-drawing. This practice is so widespread and commonplace in different parts of India that its creativity is not even acknowledged. Certainly, it attracts far less attention than the contemporary pavement drawings that one is likely to come across on city streets, where some itinerant pavementartist sketches the figure of a god or a film hero in chalk. While this form of site-specific, freestyle sketching could be regarded as subaltern art, traditional floor-drawings are more likely to be regarded as part of a household routine. Almost exclusively performed by women, they are to be found outside the threshold of homes, where the floor is cleaned and then sprinkled with rice-flour, which is used to create an infinite number of geometric, floral, iconographic, and decorative patterns. The entire process, which can be completed in a matter of a few minutes, with matter-of-fact and apparently improvized gestures, has no other ritual purpose apart from providing a touch of positive energy to the household by warding away evil spirits. While the floor-drawings used in everyday household contexts are identified differently in various regions of India – kolam (Tamil Nadu), kalam (Kerala), alpana (West Bengal), rangoli (North India) – the fundamental ‘creativity’ of this everyday cultural practice can be attributed to the tension between the intentionality of the practitioner and the ‘self-generative capacity’ of the floor-drawing’s form as it evolves in actual practice (Mall, 2006: 74). This evolution is as much an expression of a deeply internalized body-memory of previously learned or copied patterns, as it is a response to the unpredictability of the form as it emerges through a flow of dexterous gestures, occasional mistakes and visual surprises (2006: 74). In this chapter, I will not be focusing on the phenomenology of floor-drawing in which creativity is at
once captured and embodied. Rather, I will concentrate on a far more elaborate ritual performance tradition from the southwestern state of Kerala called kalamezhutu pattu or kalam pattu in which a large-scale kalam (floor-drawing) of a deity is made not by household women but by particular castes of artisans, notably the Mannaan from the low-caste Harijan community.4 The crucial point that needs to be emphasized is that the artistic creativity in question is not linked to an individual artist, but to a specific community which earns its livelihood through the perpetuation of this practice. In this regard, the category of ‘cultural expression’, as defined by the editors of this volume, could be regarded as appropriate for the kalam, in so far as it evokes a ‘collective project’ incorporating multiple inputs at the level of community. More precisely, given the religious dimensions surrounding the worship of the kalam, the expressivity in question operates at both ‘material and immaterial’ levels. I will not be describing here how the kalam is made after hours of painstaking labour, in which the body and visage of the goddess Bhagawathy or Bhadrakali (the auspicious and ferocious aspects of the goddess Devi, respectively) emerge out of the earth in an intricate filigree of five vibrant colours – red, black, white, yellow, and green. Nor will I be providing a detailed contextual background relating to the rituals, songs, chants, invocation of the goddess, and oracular transmission of messages by which the kalam is worshipped as an offering (vazhivadu) by the family or temple sponsoring the performance. What does concern me here, however, is the crucial moment in the final stage of the ritual performance when the kalam is erased, generally by the oracle or ritual attendant who dances on the floor-drawing and wipes the goddess away with his stamping feet and occasionally frenzied movements. It is out of this void, an empty space, which is all that remains of the kalam, that I would like to draw out some principles which seem crucial to my understanding of creativity in contradistinction to the tenets of the creative economy.
1. Impermanence First of all, it becomes necessary to focus on the implications of impermanence as a creative principle. When the kalam is erased, nothing remains of
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 27
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
its original form beyond the traces of colour smeared on the floor. These traces are collected by the spectators and smeared on their foreheads as Prasad, indicating their physical imbibing of the sacred presence in the ritual. Beyond these traces there is no object, sign, or artistic signature that remains, which leaves open the critical question of whether the kalam can be regarded as a commodity. Certainly, if one had to follow the traditional Marxist definition of commodity as ‘a product intended principally for exchange’ within ‘the institutional, psychological and economic conditions of capitalism’ (Appadurai, 1986: 6), then the kalam is neither an instance of decommodification nor anticommodification. Rather, in its inability to be bought or sold through the very dissolution of its materiality, it would seem to exist outside the logic of commodification altogether. This argument, however, could be complicated by other processual readings of commodity, which leave open the possibilities of objects ‘moving both into and out of the commodity state’ (Kopytoff, 1986, cited in Appadurai, 1986: 17). This fluidity informs postmodern readings of commodity, which are determined neither by the material concreteness nor the price of the commodity, but rather by its potentiality for exchange in situations in which ‘its exchangeability (past, present, or future) for some other thing is its socially relevant feature’ (Appadurai, 1986: 13). In this imagined state of perpetual mobility, the commodity is identified and discriminated not as ‘one kind of thing rather than another’ but rather as ‘one phase in the life of some things’ (1986: 17). While I will leave open the ‘commodity potential’ of the kalam, which I will discuss later within the hypothesis of a reinvented design, I would nonetheless claim that the kalam in its traditional ritual context does not readily lend itself either to the idea or practice of commodity precisely because it does not conform to the principles of ‘exchange’ at a material level. The only transaction that does take place in the course of this offering is, at best, symbolic, in so far as the sponsors of the kalam pay for its performance in order to receive favours from the gods. However, there can be no unequivocal guarantee that their desires will be granted beyond the reassurances of the oracle. One should also keep in mind that the kalam is not just an opportunity for wish-fulfillment but an act of gratitude for favours already received, which rules out the necessity of a
27
clearly defined ‘exchange’. Offerings can be unidirectional in their focus and intensity. However, this premise opens up the possibility of whether the kalam would not be more appropriately defined as a ‘gift’, which is the term that is constantly countered in relation to ‘commodity’, at times with unproductive results. Here there is a growing literature with at least two diametrically opposed readings of the gift: those that favour the belief that it is non-returnable, as exemplified in Derrida’s eloquent exhortation that ‘there must be no reciprocity, return, exchange, countergift, or debt. If the other gives me back or owes me or has to give me back what I give him or her, there will not have been a gift’ (Derrida, 1992: 12, cited in Frow, 1997: 107). Against this assertion of non-reciprocity, there is the more coercive view emphasized by the master theoretician of the gift, Marcel Mauss (1967), for whom ‘there is no gift without bond, without bind, without obligation or ligature’ (Frow, 1997: 108). If one had to link the kalam to the Derridean perspective of ‘the first gift’, then one would have to qualify that it is not ‘purely gratuitous, non-reciprocal and atemporal’ (1997: 108), but, on the other hand, if we had to link it to Mauss’s somewhat more paradoxical perspective on the gift, one would have to resist the reduction of the entire kalam performance to a deliberately calculative and strategic act, despite the intentionality underlying the sponsorship of the performance. Certainly, the uppercaste sponsors of any kalam stand to enhance their cultural and spiritual capital and social prestige through the sponsorship of the performance, but these benefits would need to be seen in the context of self-gratification rather than exchange. Returning to the motif of impermanence, but problematizing it in a somewhat different direction from the gift/commodity debate, it could be argued that the ‘invisible’ and non-material dimensions of knowledge traditions are not necessarily divested of economic value. Indeed, the knowledge component of the creative economy is deeply invested in the future, in what does not as yet exist, which could include unknown enzymes, genes, and software. The fact that these phenomena have yet to be discovered or invented does not stop them from being patented in their embryonic states. This investment in the future, or more precisely, the domain of the Not-Yet, needs to be contrasted with the kalam’s deep investment in the Now, in which all times (past, present, and future) coalesce.5
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
28
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 28
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
The impermanence of the kalam, therefore, has to be linked not to an invisible future, but to a vanishing present, which is consciously erased even after it has been brought into fruition. There is a different temporality at work here, which compels one to differentiate between the multitudinous instants of creativity which suggest an ‘eternal time’, and the more pragmatic, long-term investments of the cultural economy which more often than not disappear into evanescence or crash out of existence.
2. Ecology The second principle of creativity that I would like to draw out of the example of the kalam concerns its ecological foundations. Indeed, the colours that enhance the kalam’s vibrant form are made out of natural substances: rice powder (white), burned rice husk (black), turmeric powder (yellow), powdered dry leaves (green), and a mixture of turmeric powder and lime (red). When the kalam is erased, these natural substances are returned to the earth, providing an unobtrusive yet concrete example of ecological art, which is now being explored by many metropolitan artists through different methods of disintegration and self-destruction in the creation of fragile installations, and the use of perishable materials in art works. These experiments, however, continue to be on the margins of the art world, which defines its capital more assertively than ever before through what is visible and permanent. The technologies feeding the ‘mechanical reproduction’ of art in the age of globalization have far exceeded what was available in Walter Benjamin’s time. Today the original art work gains additional market value through the surfeit of discursive and media representations that surround its replication through the catalogue, the poster, the website, CDs and DVDs – apart from the obligatory invitation card specially designed for the opening party of the exhibition. If the art market would appear to disdain the less lucrative path of ecology, it is because ‘alternative’ activist experiments in this field have yet to be adequately projected. Far outdoing the art world in this regard is the thriving business of eco-friendly products in the cosmetics industry, along with other modes of pampering the body through holistic massage services and Ayurveda, in addition to the spaand resort-related pleasures of eco-tourism and
yoga retreats. Tellingly, the state of Kerala is at once the site for the non-commercial, predominantly ritual practice of the kalam, as well as the headquarters of the Ayurveda industry. Cashing in on ‘knowledge about commodities’ which is itself ‘increasingly commoditized’ according to a global ‘traffic in criteria’ (Appadurai, 1986: 54), the promoters of Ayurveda in Kerala have capitalized on ‘innovations’ of traditional health systems ostensibly re-designed to suit New Age lifestyles. However, these innovations can never afford to ignore the lure – and competitive economic value – of ‘authenticity’, which is subjected to what Appadurai has described as a ‘complication of criteria’ (1986: 45). Hence, the ‘prestige economies of the modern West’ can be guaranteed ‘100% traditional Ayurvedic massage’ but with all the amenities of a luxurious spa thrown in as part of the deal, including subliminal erotic pleasures. While the repackaging of traditional modes of expertise, spurious or otherwise, is part of the marketing game, what is harder to accept is the glib use of ‘ecology’ in the discourse of the creative economy where there is no demonstrable evidence of any altered mode of cultural production or distribution. Such is the case with the so-called ‘revitalization of city landscapes’ (Scott, 2008) through a proliferation of ‘new shopping malls, restaurants, cafes, clubs, theaters, galleries, boutiques’, the obligatory manifestations of the hedonistic logic upheld by the creative class. However, this is not an adequate explanation, as the following passage reveals: When the landscape develops in this manner, significant portions of the city (though rarely, if ever, all portions) start to function as an ecology of commodified symbolic production and consumption, in which, and in contrast to the classical industrial metropolis, the functions of leisure and work seem to be converging to some sort of (historically-specific) social equilibrium. Even advertising becomes part of the general spectacle that is one of the important ingredients of this ecology. (Scott, 2008: 314, my emphasis)
Indeed, one is hard pressed to understand how ‘ecology’ can be invoked in such a context without any critical engagement with the energy resources that are surely spent, if not wasted, in the abundance of neon displaying this ‘revitalization’ of the
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 29
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
city landscape. The society of the spectacle is not known for its economy of resources. More critically, one wonders how ecology can be inserted into this valorization of the cultural economy without any consideration of the social consequences of any gentrification process, in which local inhabitants of particular neighbourhoods are invariably evicted to make room for the lifestyles of the ‘creative class’. The pretence of fashionable ‘slumming’ in formerly derelict and working-class neighbourhoods now sexed up with trendy bars and clubs is scarcely a symptom of revitalization. Indeed, one could argue: revitalization for whom? Neither can social ecology be equated with the ‘social equilibrium’ between ‘work and leisure’ for a particular class, as the passage above emphasizes. If we have to use the word ‘ecology’ in the context of this economy, then we are compelled to address the very palpable social and economic disequilibrium that exists between the ‘creative class’ and the servicing sectors. It is these disparities that need to be addressed, instead of being camouflaged within the up-market, crime-free, enclaves of liberal surveillance, whereby new gated communities are surrounded by the proliferating hinterlands of the poor.
3. Humility Against the implicit arrogance of the creative economy, I would emphasize the third creative principle exemplified by the kalam: humility. I realize that there are possible misperceptions in such a dichotomy of values, which would seem to play into the reductionism which Appadurai so rightly warns against in ‘the tendency to romanticize small-scale societies; to conflate use-value (in Marx’s sense) with the gemeinschaft (in Toennies’s sense)’ (1986: 11). Indeed, one does need to be on the alert in order to highlight ‘the calculative, impersonal and self-aggrandizing features of non-capitalist’ societies, which is Appadurai’s predilection (1986: 11). At the same time I would argue that the ‘calculative dimension’ (1986: 13) cannot be imposed as the only valid way of reading human and cultural interactions within these societies. Indeed, in a more conciliatory register, Appadurai does acknowledge Kopytoff’s somewhat broader perspective of ‘a perennial and universal tug-of-war between the tendency of all economies to expand the jurisdiction of
29
commoditization and of all cultures to restrict it’ (1986: 17). This ‘tug-of-war’ raises the critical question of ‘the extent to which the logic of the “cultural” is able to restrict the logic of the economic; and of the possibilities of movement out of the commodity state’ (Frow, 1997: 144). Furthermore, as John Frow pushes the question into an even more precise problematic: ‘To what extent … can cognitive, ethical, affective, and aesthetic processes resist commodification? ... And what sort of value judgment should be made of these processes?’ (1997: 144–5). In response to these questions, let me qualify that when I invoke humility as a creative value within the framework of the kalam, I am not referring to it as a moral virtue, as if all the custodians of the production and performance of the kalam are intrinsically good and simple people uncontaminated by the realities of modern life. This would amount to a caricature of the context being described. On the contrary, I would argue that the practice of the kalam is inserted into modern life, within a specific space–time continuum, and that it answers the psychological and social needs of people facing the pressures of everyday life. Furthermore, I would acknowledge a dimension of social power upheld by the upper-caste hegemony that continues to patronize the practice of the kalam with the support of predominantly low-caste artisans. In other words, even though the kalam is a ‘traditional’ practice in so far as it has a long legacy of conventions and rituals with ‘religious’ significance, it can in no way be regarded as antithetical to modernity. Rather, it is inscribed within modernity whose dominant values are implicitly questioned, even as they are not directly opposed. Humility in the context of the kalam is better understood not in the context of morality but in its denial of authorship and ownership. Nobody owns the kalam; it belongs to all those who participate in its production and performance, including the bystanders, onlookers and spectators who may assemble to see its performance with no caste restrictions whatsoever. This compels one to open the modalities of belonging as opposed to ownership, a distinction that is almost totally absent in the discourse of the creative economy. One could push the point further by focusing on ‘collective belonging’ as opposed to individual spectatorship and critical scrutiny. What is the place for such belonging in the mechanisms of the creative economy, which
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
30
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 30
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
have themselves been decisively challenged through new affirmations of the creative commons, if not an abolition of copyright altogether? Finally, in unearthing the inner values of the kalam, one is compelled to open its dimensions of the spiritual and the sacred as opposed to the institutionally and contextually bound rules and regulations of religious practice. These dimensions call into question the implicit secularity underlying the logic of the market outside its religious inflections in certain Islamic contexts of finance and banking. As an offering to the deity, the kalam submits to a reality that is larger than the efforts that go into the materiality of its production. This scenario inevitably opens up metaphysical values relating to ‘worship’ and ‘sacrifice’ which do not readily enter the predominantly acquisitive and competitive priorities of the creative economy.6 On the other hand, it could also be argued that the dimensions of the sacred are not entirely immune to the possibilities of commodification, as we shall examine in the following section within the larger framework of re-inventing traditions through processes of innovation.
Innovating tradition ‘Innovation’ has become the symbiotic catch-word for ‘creativity’, particularly in the rhetoric surrounding the creative economy and other managementrelated sectors of the arts. It would seem that if you’re not innovative, your creativity is not of much use. Drawing on the proliferation of new technologies available for artistic practices in the age of globalization, the editors of this volume call attention to the truism that, ‘Market-driven phenomena may well be creating new figures of the symbol creator as a “motor of innovation” and altering the profile of the “creative subject”.’ And yet, there are some rash assumptions in assuming that innovation inevitably has to follow creativity, which would seem to deny the fact that all artistic practices are constantly in the process of innovating their rules and regulations. How else would they remain alive and capture attention through the dynamics of surprise? Perhaps one needs to accept that the valorization of ‘innovation’ in recent cultural theory has less to do with the inner mutations of artistic and cultural practice, and more to do with an extrinsic, self-conscious manipulation of particular practices in relation to both marketing demands and the
relentless search for curiosity and novelty in the public sphere. From the encapsulation of the three principles – impermanence, ecology, and humility – which I have extrapolated from the kalam, problematizing their premises both within and against the capitalist logic of the creative economy, it could be argued that, despite all my qualifications, my position remains idealistic, if not utopian. As much as I have tried to argue against the reduction of the kalam to some esoteric folklore steeped in the rituals of the past, I realize that it is bound to seem somewhat quaint and economically counter-productive in relation to the glitz and financial power of, say, Bollywood and Twenty20 cricket, two of the most lucrative manifestations of the creative industries in the Indian context today. The latter refers to the new version of superfast cricket in 20 overs which has been blatantly constructed as spectacular entertainment, sponsored by liquor barons and some of Bollywood’s biggest stars. Sold both as ‘live performance’ and prime-time TV, cricket has now been ‘re-invented’ within a larger spectacle of fireworks, gymnastics, stunts, dance performances, and even imported cheer-leaders. Keeping the sheer innovation of this hybrid Bollywood–cricket entertainment model in mind, one could be challenged into imagining more commercially lucrative avatars of the kalam. For instance, one could think of a ‘designer-kalam’, with all the computerized software and technology that India is now capable of displaying, with a virtuoso play of laser lights and digitalized sound effects. This innovation could look appropriately exotic, yet ‘cool’, in the precincts of a 5-star hotel lobby, exuding the aura of some New Age Orient. Needless to say, unlike its traditional counterpart, the ‘erasure’ of this ‘designer-kalam’ is not likely to be prioritized because the costs of production would be too extravagant to be wished away. Likewise, the expertise of traditional artisans is entirely expendable because this high-tech kalam would demand significantly different skills, if not a totally different conceptual orientation and aesthetics. While my hypothesis of a designer-kalam may seem cynical, I should emphasize that I am not arguing against either commodification or innovation. In principle, it would be both counterproductive and unrealistic to imagine that so-called traditional cultural practices are incapable of transgressing their boundaries or that they are somehow ethically
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 31
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
and morally resistant to the global economy. This is clearly not the position voiced by many traditional artisans and performers who want to be part of a more established modern and global circuit.7 Drawing on the commercial success of Aboriginal dot-paintings reinvented through the introduction of acrylic paint, for instance, John Frow is clearly on target when he questions the pertinence of conservationist positions: ‘Is the commodity form necessarily and always less humanly beneficial than non-commodified use values, and is its historical extension necessarily and under all circumstances a change for the worse?’ (1997: 136). I would argue that any absolutist position in restricting the mobility and transformation of non-commercial traditional cultures into commodified forms needs to be opposed. At the same time I would qualify that there are certain contexts and particular circumstances in which the transition of these practices into the market economy cannot be readily assumed or endorsed. Having acknowledged the ambivalence posed by the processes of commodification, let me provide a vibrant example of the ‘invention of tradition’ (Hobsbawm and Ranger, 1983) through innovation, which contributes enormously to the regional cultural economy of West Bengal in India. I have in mind the sculpturesque effigies (murti) of the goddess Durga in the public celebration of the pujas (religious worship) on the streets of Calcutta, which are now subject to all kinds of experiments and innovations in material and design (Bose, 1997; Guha-Thakurta, 2004). Earlier the effigies were made out of clay with a very precise traditional iconography mastered by the legendary artisans of Kumartuli, a cultural district in Calcutta where these artisans have lived for generations. Today, however, some of the younger artisans of this community have been exposed to modern notions of art education, and along with a growing number of selfperceived ‘designers’ who have graduated from the Government College of Art in Calcutta, have embarked on different experiments in re-inventing the goddess. Apart from clay, she can now be sculpted in terracotta and slate stone, and her styles of representation can be inspired by anything from Mughal miniatures and Madhubani painting to Kerala-inspired dance poses and Kalighat pats (folk paintings) (Guha-Thakurta, 2004: 34–56). Even more ‘innovative’ are the pandals (pavilions) enclosing the goddess, some of which have
31
been made of sugar-cane and broken gramophone records, emulating all kinds of grand edifices from the Calcutta High Court to the famous Buddhist stupa of Sanchi (Guha-Thakurta, 2004: 35–6). These spectacular enclosures have acquired all the virtuosity and secular entertainment value of theme-parks, which form the primary motif around which Tapati Guha-Thakurta has envisioned the new manifestations of the puja. However, there is not one mega theme for the pujas, but multiple themes which are the brainwaves of puja committees, which form the nucleus of local neighbourhoods in and around Calcutta. Along with national issues like the communal genocide in Gujarat, or local events like the mauling of a drunk man by a tiger in the Calcutta zoo, the themes for the pujas draw on the most alluring global icons, including the Titanic, the Bamiyan Buddhas, Princess Diana, and even Harry Potter (whose visual representation within a Disneyland version of Hogwarts Castle in a puja pandal was subjected to a law suit by Warner Brothers because of an alleged breach of copyright).8 It becomes clear from such examples that the local imaginary is more than ready to absorb global resources, controversies, and stimuli. The question remains, as in the case of the Harry Potter episode, whether global corporations are as ready to support the localization of their brands with generosity and humour, instead of holding on to the mercenary and mean-spirited norms of ‘intellectual property’. Despite the re-invention of the spectacle of the pujas, whose secularization has been intensified through local corporate support and the shopping frenzy that enormously boosts the sales of clothing, food, sweets, gift items, cosmetics, and electronics (Ghosh, 2006), what needs to be kept in mind is that the goddess Durga continues to be ritually immersed at the end of the pujas, not unlike the kalam which is erased. This continued adherence to ritual practice whereby the goddess is returned to her heavenly abode needs to be kept in mind in order to work against the somewhat too unproblematized transformation of the puja into secular festivity and the equation of the pandals with heterotopias, divested of religious or spiritual dimensions.9 At a museological level as well, which is yet another form of secularization along with the market forces, one should keep in mind that only a few established artists in Bengal have succeeded in
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
32
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 32
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
museumizing the goddess in a permanent abode, though this practice is more evident abroad than in India itself (Guha-Thakurta, 2007). Ironically, the zeal in authenticating the ‘purity’ of the Durga image is more likely to be found outside India rather than in Bengal itself. The agencies of authentication abroad would include NRBs (Non-Resident Bengalis), whose diasporic zeal in holding on to rituals of their childhood, imagined or real, contributes to the perpetuation of traditional iconography in a nostalgic mode. A more self-conscious mode of authentication, however, has been perpetuated by coteries of Euro-American curators, whose affirmation of religiosity in the secular space of established museums has been legitimized as a means of countering the colonial episteme of museology. New modes of recontextualizing non-Western religious and cultural artefacts are now offered as alternative modes of worship in the museum space.10 While acknowledging these innovations in what could be called the ‘god industry’, I would caution against the valorization of all tradition-inspired innovations as ‘creative’ in opposition to those traditional practices which may not be consciously innovative at all. Indeed, the absence of innovation does not imply that traditions are necessarily fossilized because they can continue to grow within deeply internalized rules and regulations, not unlike the kalam which continues to be improvised within set patterns. Indeed, there is a danger in capitalizing on innovation through its compatibility with the larger global cultural discourse relating to hybridity, pastiche, kitsch, and public culture. The fact that a traditional cultural practice on the lines of the kalam may not necessarily imbibe the global through innovations, either in terms of its marketing or reinvented aesthetics, should not be seen as an anachronistic aberration. Rather, I would like to highlight both the flexibility and adaptability of local cultural practices as well as their intransigence and resistance to glib translation. Even as I would leave open the possibilities of their collaboration with national and global agencies, I would also value their right to negotiate creativity on their own terms within their own contexts.
Rethinking cultural policy through creativity Drawing some broader lessons from the kalam in relation to the increasingly vexed and bureaucratized
field of policy making, I would urge a greater sensitization towards the visceral, sensuous and spiritual dimensions of creativity. Let us acknowledge that these dimensions cannot be measured in purely economic terms, which doesn’t mean that the absence of distinct standards of measurement should be regarded as the sine qua non of authentic creativity. On the contrary, it would be disingenuous to deny that the most market-driven cultural phenomena like blockbuster movies or Broadway musicals can be creative in their own right. The point is that not every manifestation of creativity can be placed on the same scale and measured according to fixed criteria. The economic dimension is just one among many other criteria of value, which may be elusive, if not unquantifiable. Nor would I favour an instrumentalist approach towards creativity along the lines of the British creative industries policy of the late 1990s, for the simple reason that there can be no causal relationship made between the experience (and cultural value) of watching a play or listening to music with the social imperatives to remove crime or drug abuse or unemployment. There are very subtle institutional and political mediations that need to be explored between art practice and the possibilities of social transformation, which need to be implemented at concrete levels. Furthermore, if we are concerned about social transformation outside the narrow matrix of ‘problem solving’, then we cannot simply relegate the transformative process to something outside ourselves, to those sectors of society which have been categorized as ‘undeveloped’ or ‘marginal’. Rather, the process of transformation has to begin with ourselves through the embodiment of creative energy and the sharing of its processual dynamics through actual acts of social bonding and dialogue. These human interactions are more likely to provide a ground for change in perception and consciousness than the mere articulation of blueprints of ‘creative cities’. Recommendations for ‘inter-sectoral’ collaborations across new systems of ‘governance’ (Pratt, 2007) would also appear to privilege the already empowered role of policy makers at the expense of benefiting artists and the public more directly. For policy to be shaped in a more grounded and comprehensive way, yet another consideration needs to be a far greater openness to those locations and sectors of the world’s population which do
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 33
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
not necessarily embrace the cultural values of the metropolitan global cosmopolis. Creativity, in short, is not the prerogative of the city alone, even though it is within this valorized site that ‘creative industries’ have been expected to thrive within highly funded infrastructures of technology, communications and global serving agencies. Instead of privileging these already media-saturated and overly funded sites, far more attention needs to be given to the regional and rural sectors of any cultural economy, not just in the cultures of the ‘South’ but also in the marginalized regions of ‘developed’ nations as well.11 Finally, it would be useful if ‘creative economists’ could acknowledge the numerous local and communitarian economies prevailing in the cultures of the ‘South’, but also to be found in the non-commercial and non-profit alternative sectors of the ‘North’ where there are diverse resistances towards monopolistic markets as, for instance, in the recent upsurge of community-related cultural activities and the ubiquitous phenomenon of farmers’ markets. Thriving bazaars in Indian cities along with markets of epic proportions in sites like the mela (fair) – not just linked to pilgrimages but also to cultural forums representing handicrafts and books – are not exclusively dependent on either the agencies of the state or the market. These local, event-related markets constitute a massive informal economy, which has sustained artists, artisans, and street vendors over the years. Consolidated by communities with a loose network of local organizations, this economy demonstrates a highly interactive mode of independent self-sufficiencies, which is probably one of the closest economic equivalents to what Mahatma Gandhi recognized as swaraj (‘self-rule’). While it could be argued that a vast body of creative practices in the ‘South’ are no longer as resilient as the kalam – and therefore, a policy for their preservation and the income generation of their custodians becomes mandatory – it is necessary to remember, at the risk of reiterating a massively ignored truism, that the articulation of such a policy should come from the communities themselves. However, in the top-down expertise that marks the rhetoric and legislation of such policies, the considerations of people are invariably erased. This erasure is ruthless compared to that of the kalam, which works through cultural consensus and the beauty of a dissolving form. In our search
33
for more context-sensitive policies, therefore, let us remember the kalam in its celebration of the immediacies of the Now, constantly dying and ceaselessly renewed, within an endless cycle of creativity.
Notes 1
2
3
4
The categories of ‘skill’ and ‘talent’ were specifically linked to ‘individual creativity’ in the Creative Industries Task Force Mapping Document published by the Department of Culture, Media and Sport in the UK in 1998. Without being defined or discriminated, these creative faculties were identified as contributing towards ‘the potential for wealth and job creation through the generation and exploitation of intellectual property’. One of the most thorough and politically inflected critiques of the ‘creative industries’ discourse has been provided by Nicholas Garnham (2000, 2005), who points out how its ‘ideological power’ is directly related to its absence of critical reflexivity. Garnham locates this power in the decisive shift from the state to the market under the Thatcher government, which was further ‘accelerated’ by Tony Blair’s New Labour policies. Under the sign of Cool Britannia, ‘creativity’ as opposed to ‘culture’ was prioritized with specific reference to ‘the information society’, ostensibly benefiting all citizens through its focus on ‘access’, ‘excellence’, ‘education’, and ‘economic value’. The ubiquity of ‘creativity’ under the auspices of New Labour’s cultural policy making has received a series of responses from Angela McRobbie (2002, 2004, 2007), with particular reference to youth culture and the fashion industry in Britain. Moving beyond the ‘mantra of losses’ lamented by the ‘Old Left’ in terms of declining trade unionism and the cult of apolitical individualism, McRobbie links the ‘enforced entrepreneurialism’ of the creative industries to ‘extraordinary degrees of selfexploitation’ in highly ‘de-regulated’ and ‘unprotected’ conditions of work. Even while engaging with the possibilities of ‘new productive singularities’, as posited by Hardt and Negri (2000), the evidence provided by McRobbie would seem to suggest that the cult of creativity has resulted in an intensification of atomism subsumed within the masquerades of pleasure and desire. In addition to the Mannaan community, other ritual practitioners of the kalam in Kerala include the Velan, the Malaya, and the Perumannaan, who are all from lowcaste communities. In most rituals, the kalam is erased by the oracle, who mediates between the actual performance of the kalam and the invocation of the goddess. However, in the case of the pampin kalam, associated with the serpent worship of the Pulluvan community, two young girls are made to sit on the drawing of the holy serpents whereupon they become ‘possessed’ and begin to voice oracular predictions. In this state, the girls drag their bodies and roll over the kalam, erasing it in the
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
34
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 34
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
process. For a description of one particular kalam performance, including all its intermediary stages but with a perfunctory reference to its erasure, read Zarrilli (1990). I am extremely grateful to Sri L.S. Rajagopolan and Purushothaman Avaroth for their considerable inputs on the ritual context of the kalam. 5 The categories of the ‘Now’ and the ‘Not Yet’ are borrowed from Chakarabarty (2000), who uses them to situate different moments of time in colonial historiography and global modernity. While the ‘Not Yet’ is symptomatic of those colonial states which have yet to enter the trajectory of world history in terms of democracy or modernity, the ‘Now’ is more linked to the immediacies of political or revolutionary struggle. 6 Significantly, ‘sacrifice’ can be also rendered in an economic context, as, for instance, when Arjun Appadurai (1986: 3–4) interprets George Simmel’s (1978) understanding of economic value in terms of an ‘exchange of sacrifices’: ‘one’s desire for an object is fulfilled by the sacrifice of some other object, which is the focus of the desire of another’. Needless to say, this is an anti-metaphysical reading of sacrifice. 7 In her brief perspective on ‘Globalization and Crafts in South Asia’ (Dhamija, 2008), the author calls attention to an ironic moment in a conference celebrating fifty years of handicrafts development in India, where a traditional designer specializing in jacquard making in Varanasi countered the notion that globalization was having a negative impact on the crafts sector. On the contrary, as the designer argued, ‘It is our fault that Varanasi is in difficulties. It is because we have not globalized’. While the actual negotiation of a level-playing field between indigenous craftsmen and globalizing agencies raises a number of logistical challenges, which Dhamija does not address, the point is that globalization is not rejected outright as a source of exploiting the crafts sector. The more critical question concerns the role of the national government in ‘protecting’ the crafts industry from unfair competition and the export of essential raw materials. When does protectionism cease to be economically and creatively productive? 8 In October 2007, in the thick of the Durga puja celebrations in Calcutta, the puja committee of Salt Lake’s FD Block was charged with copyright violations for its use of Harry Potter memorabilia, including the magic broom, the Hogwarts Express Train, and hanging magic candles. For the pujas in previous years, the pandal (pavilion) of this particular committee had recreated Swami Vivekananda’s residence and a model of the Titanic.
9
10
11
In 2007, Harry Potter was selected by the popular demand of the children living in the neighbourhood. Totally non-commercial in its priorities, the puja committee was relieved when Delhi’s High Court gave permission for Harry Potter to be celebrated under its auspices, ostensibly with the goddess Durga’s blessings. However, the judge also qualified that any public display of Harry Potter after the pujas would require the prior permission of J.K. Rowling. While both Guha-Thakurta (2004) and Bose (1997) are correct in foregrounding the secularization of the pujas, their readings need to be complicated through an acknowledgement of the religious residues underlying the altered forms of the goddess. In the absence of any oral history or multiple modes of perception, the ‘themepark’ rendering of the pujas is privileged somewhat too literally in a predominantly descriptive mode. At a more complex hermeneutic level, Bose’s attempt to read the multiple abodes of the goddess within Foucault’s construct of ‘heterotopia’ fails to engage with the dissonance and subversive possibilities of such sites. The predominantly magical, fabulous, and illusory spectacles of the puja would seem to lend themselves more to simulacra rather than to heterotopias – a distinction that needs to be problematized. While Guha-Thakurta (2007) focuses deftly on the dichotomy of ‘our gods’ and ‘their museums’ to highlight some of the challenges of transporting ancient Indian religious sculptures and icons to festivals and exhibitions abroad, there are emergent modes of religiositydriven museumization in India itself, which are responses to a wide range of movements including Hindutva (the ideology of the Hindu Right), the assertion of Buddhism for dalit (low-caste) politics, and the militant history of religious Sikh leaders. See Mathur and Singh (2007) for a representation of these emergent museums. Stuart Cunningham emphasizes this precise point in the Australian context when he argues against ‘the further consolidation of cultural industries in one or two spatial hotspots in the country – Sydney and Melbourne’ (2001: 30), as opposed to the redistribution of cultural resources at a regional level. While he equates the marginalization of ‘regionalism’ with the ‘class-based dispositions of cultural capital’, it is unclear whether his understanding of the ‘region’ would include rural sectors, which tend to be totally obliterated in almost any analysis of the cultural or creative industries.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 35
CREATIVITY: ALTERNATIVE PARADIGMS TO THE ‘CREATIVE ECONOMY’
35
REFERENCES
Adorno, T.W. (1991) The Culture Industry: Selected Essays on Mass Culture. London: Routledge. Anheier, H. and Isar, Y.R. (2008) ‘Introduction’ to The Cultural Economy: The Cultural and Globalization Series, Vol. 2. London: SAGE. Appadurai, A. (1986) ‘Introduction: commodities and the politics of value’, The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 3–63. Beuys, J. (2004) What is Art? Edited with essays by Volker Harlan. Forest Row: Clairview Books. Bose, P. (1997) Pujor Kolkatar Bikolpolok [The Heterotopia of Puja’s Kolkata]. Baromas. Bourdieu, P. (1984) Distinction: A Social Critique in the Judgement of Taste. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Bourriaud, N. (2002) Relational Aesthetics. Dijon: Les Presses du Reel. Caves, R. (2000) Creative Industries. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Chakrabarty, D. (2000) Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Cunningham, S. (2001) ‘From cultural to creative industries: theory, industry, and policy implications’, in C. Mercer (ed.), Convergence, Creative Industries and Civil Society: The New Cultural Policy (Special issue of CULTURELINK). Zagreb: Institute for International Relations. Cunningham, S., Banks, J. and Potts, J. (2008) ‘Cultural economy: the shape of the field’, in H. Anheier and Y.R. Isar (eds), The Cultural Economy: The Cultures and Globalization Series, Vol. 2. London and New York: SAGE. DCMS (2001) Green Paper Document on ‘Culture and Creativity: The Next Ten Years’. London: DCMS. Derrida, J. (1992) Given Time: 1. Counterfeit Money, (trans. Peggy Kamuf). Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Dhamija, J. (2008) ‘Globalization and crafts in South Asia’, in H. Anheier and Y.R. Isar (eds), The Cultural Economy: The Cultures and Globalization Series 2. London: SAGE. Florida, R. (2002) The Rise of the Creative Class: And How It’s Transforming Work, Leisure, Community and Everyday Life. New York: Basic. Florida, R. (2005) The Flight of the Creative Class: The New Global Competition for Talent. New York: HarperCollins. Frow, J. (1997) ‘Gift and commodity’, in J. Frow, Time and Commodity Culture: Essays in Cultural Theory and Postmodernity. Oxford: Clarendon. Garnham, N. (2000) ‘Concepts of culture: public policy and the cultural industries’. (Originally published as a pamphlet by the Greater London Council. Reprinted in Cultural Studies, 1,(1): 23–37. Garham, N. (2005) ‘From cultural to creative industries: an analysis of the implications of the “creative industries” approach
to arts and media policy making in the United Kingdom’, International Journal of Cultural Policy, 11 (1): 15–29. Ghosh, A. (2006) ‘Durga Puja: a consuming passion’, Seminar, No. 559, March. Guha-Thakurta, T. (2004) ‘From spectacle to “art”’, Art India, 9 (3). Guha-Thakurta, T. (2007) ‘“Our gods, their museums”: the contrary careers of India’s art objects’, Art History, 30 (4). Hardt, M. and Negri, A. (2000) Empire. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Harlan, V. (2004) ‘A note on the text’, What is Art?, edited with essays by Volker Harlan. Forest Row: Clairview Books. Hartley, J. (ed.) (2004) Creative Industries. Oxford: Blackwell. Hobsbawm, E. and Ranger, T. (1983) The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Howkins, J. (2001) The Creative Economy: How People Make Money from Ideas. London: Allen Lane, Penguin. Kopytoff, I. (1986) ‘The cultural biography of things: commoditization as process’, in A. Appadurai (ed.), The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. McRobbie, A. (2002), ‘From Holloway to Hollywood: happiness at work in the new cultural economy?’, in P. du Gay and M. Pryke (eds), Cultural Economy. London: SAGE. pp. 97–114. McRobbie, A. (2004) ‘ “Everyone is creative”; artists as pioneers of the new economy?’, in T. Bennett and E. Silva (eds), Contemporary Culture and Everyday Life. London: Routledge. McRobbie, A. (2007) ‘The Los Angelisation of London: three short waves of young people’s micro-economies of culture and creativity in the UK’, Transversal, January. Mall, A.S. (2006) ‘Structure, innovation and agency in pattern construction: The Kolam of Southern India’, in E. Hallam and T. Ingold (eds), Creativity and Cult Improvisation. Aberdeen: Berg. pp. 55–78. Mathur, S. and Singh, K. (2007) ‘Reincarnations of the museum: the museum in an age of religious revivalism’, in V.N. Desai (ed.), Asian Art History in the Twenty-First Century. New Haven and London: Yale University Press. pp. 149–168. Mauss, M. (1967) The Gift: Forms and Functions on Exchange in Archaic Societies (trans. Ian Cunnison). New York: Norton. Miller, T. (2007) ‘Can natural Luddites make things explode or travel faster?’ in G. Lovink and N. Rossister (eds), MyCreative Reader: A critique of creative industries. Amsterdam: Institute for Network Cultures. Pratt, A.C. (2007) ‘The state of the cultural economy: the rise of the cultural economy and the challenges to cultural policy making’, in A. Pinto Ribeiro. The Urgency of Theory. London: Carcanet. pp.166–90.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-01:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
36
20/10/2009
11:37 AM
Page 36
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
Ross, A. (2007) ‘Nice work if you can get it: the mercurial career of creative industry policy’, in G. Lovink and N. Rossiter (eds), A Creative Reader: A Critique of Creative Industries. Amsterdam: Institute of Network Cultures. Sacks, S. (2007) ‘Seeing the phenomenon and imaginal thought: trajectories for transformation in the work of Joseph Beuys and Rudolf Steiner’. Exhibition catalogue for Intuition, Imagination, Inspiration: Joseph Beuys and Rudolf Steiner, National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne, Australia.
Scott, A.J. (2008) ‘Cultural economy: retrospect and prospect’, in H. Anheier and Y.R. Isar (eds), The Cultures and Globalization Series, Vol. 2, The Cultural Economy. London and New York: SAGE. Simmel, G. (1978) The Philosophy of Money. London: Routledge. Zarrilli, P.B. (1990) ‘Ayyappan Tiyatta’, in F.P. Richmond, D.L. Swann and P.B. Zarilli (eds), Indian Theatre: Traditions of Performance. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. pp. 151–65.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 37
CHAPTER 2 RECOGNITION AND ARTISTIC CREATIVITY Joni Maya Cherbo and Harold L. Vogel
reception. Artistic creativity is seen as being enhanced by an increasing global interconnectivity between peoples, as technology enables and encourages access to new audiences and provides outlets for artistic careers. Globalization is also fostering creative expression through the acceptance of a widening range of artistic fare such as master crafts and ‘native’ art, along with national and international policies designed to assist artists’ careers.
On creativity
Is creativity defined simply by the innate capacities of individuals to discover and invent something new and different or also by how such innovation is received within a specific social context? While the first understanding of creativity is highly valued in the industrially developed world, there have been and remain many societies where other interpretations are the norm – as Bharucha’s chapter has just argued. In contemporary society, artistic creativity is a high risk endeavour as well. Most artistic products fail to cover their investment let alone find recognition. Analsying the social context, the authors identify stages in the process of bringing an artistic work to fruition and illustrate the many social factors that can assist or hinder its
Creativity has become a contemporary buzzword. It is seen as being an essential ingredient for spurring economic growth and gains in productivity. Everything from corporate innovation and technological advancement, to the rehabilitation of cities and advancing education and learning, is seen as dependent on creative endeavours. In addition, in most societies creativity is seen as being a desirable personal trait – and also perhaps as something that can be taught. Yet the term is often too casually applied, and finer distinctions ought to be drawn – becoming a blogger, or creating a movie for YouTube, is not necessarily being creative or producing a creative product. By creative we mean a combination of distinct individual attributes that have produced something which their social world has labeled as creative. Howard Gardner reminds us that individuals are born with different capabilities. Some have enhanced mechanical aptitudes, others visual acumen; some a remarkable ability to retain factual information, others mathematical aptitudes (Gardner, 2006). The arts do not have a monopoly on creativity. Creativity is possible within any of these ‘intelligences’. Individuals are born with innate capacities, but the social worlds in which they live may enhance or hinder these coming to fruition, let alone being acknowledged as remarkable or creative. A mathematically gifted individual may have gone unnoticed living in a farming community in fourteenth-century Europe.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
38
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 38
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
Creativity can be thought of as a two-sided coin; one side representing individual capacities, the other the reception of something new within its social context. The creative can be conceptualized on a continuum ranging from something such as the ‘Stikki-Clip’, a patented office product, to Einstein’s theory of relativity. In the cultural areas, as distinct from the physical sciences, any artistic product depends more on its reception than its ability to prove something that can be scientifically replicated. Some cultural expressions and products will find acclaim in certain eras and communities while not in others. Had the Impressionists plied their artistic visions one hundred years earlier, when the French Academy was in control of artistic expression and before the advent of paints that could be used outdoors, they would have ended up on the scrapheap of visual arts history rather than among its acclaimed masters. Mozart’s genius today is elevated way beyond the esteem shown him in his own lifetime. Some artists and art works acclaimed in their own eras fall into oblivion in other times or simply become a part of the historical record: the largescale history paintings of the French Academic period provide one such an example. Works created for reasons other than recognition also often become valorized inadvertently. Samuel Beckett, for instance, wrote Waiting for Godot for relaxation and considered it a bad play (Throsby, 2001). How then does a creative expression come to be found boring or irrelevant, derivative or novel, creative or iconic? There is a long tradition of modernist thought that claims that true artistic expression is based on absolute and intrinsic aesthetic qualities which are fixed and inherent to a cultural work. This tradition claims that truly creative works are transcendent, will have universal appeal, and will generally encounter worldwide agreement as to their stature as masterpieces. Some aestheticians and art historians have attempted to codify what constitutes absolute aesthetic value in various artistic disciplines. In the last couple of decades, however, this tradition has been challenged by practitioners from different disciplines, in particular the social sciences and linguistics, who have put forth a more relativistic position. They claim that cultural value is a shifting phenomenon and that no absolute, inherent value can be placed on a work of art, as it is subject to the values, taste, and conditions of its time and place. Acceptance of this
school of thought has led to what some have called a ‘crisis of value in cultural theory’ as it denies any accepted hooks on which to judge artistic products. Although a visual object can be looked at using aesthetic properties – harmony, line, colour, balance, form, etc. – the valuation of these properties is seen as a sociological phenomenon (Peterson and Anand, 2004). Our absorption with creativity and creative genius, both products of the Renaissance and the Enlightenment, has blinded us to the crucial role of society in determining the worth of any artistic product. In effect, the valorization of creativity and innovation is a cultural phenomenon itself. In most artistic traditions prior to the nineteenth century, the repetition of established cultural expressions was the norm. Deviations from tradition were discouraged or nominal. While acknowledging differences among individuals in artistic abilities, the focus of this chapter (based on US data) is primarily on what social factors will aid or hinder the ascendancy of select artistic expressions.1
Creative expressions are high risk In the contemporary West, creative products are often defined as ‘experience goods’, meaning that the reception of these products is subjective – no one will know their outcome until it has been put forth for public consumption. Film and music companies, book and magazine publishers, video game designers, casino and theme-park operators, fine artists alike, do not so much sell goods and services as they do ‘experiences’. Creative expressions, therefore, are seen as high-risk ventures because tastes are constantly changing and often fickle: what resonated with the audiences of yesterday, might not resonate as well with those of today or tomorrow. The list of disappointments in all the arts is extensive. Even the most seasoned artistic practitioners have trouble predicting the outcome of an artistic work. For example, Star Wars, Back to the Future, and Lord of the Rings were all at one point or another rejected by major studios as being too expensive or were perceived at the time as being too outside of the mainstream. And even highly promoted works, like the extensively marketed feature film Last Action Hero (1993, Sony) starring Arnold Schwartzenegger, are not assured of success and may indeed turn out to be box-office
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 39
RECOGNITION AND ARTISTIC CREATIVITY
duds. Contrarily, the list of unexpected successes, such as The Blair Witch Project movie, The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles animations, or the Harry Potter series of books, reminds us of the occasional happy serendipity of artistic fare. On average, out of every ten major-distributed films only three might do better than break even, and that includes the revenues generated in domestic, international, DVD/VHS, television, and nascent Internet markets (De Vany, 2004: 82). The success ratio is actually lower if the number of ‘independent’ films that are produced but not able to find distribution are also counted. In US television as well, Seinfeld began its NBC network run inauspiciously, gaining poor ratings (and with Fox declining a later offer to pick it up). The ABC network was meanwhile uneasy about the contents of All in the Family, which was then selected by CBS because the network badly needed to replace fading shows and update its image. Historically, only about 20 to 25 per cent of all new live theatre pieces that preview on Broadway make back their investment (Rosenberg and Harburg, 1993). West Side Story – which ultimately became one of the most revered and successful musicals – had a tortuous time finding backers and was almost abandoned. In the 1990s, of the 125 new American operas that premiered, only 12 had a second production. And of the 82 new operas presented since 1999 by the New York City Opera’s Vox performance series, only 39 received full stagings. The hit ratio in American publishing isn’t much better. About 35 per cent of popular books are returned to the warehouse unsold (Carvajal, 1996), and in music it is estimated that at most perhaps 2 per cent of the new releases (i.e., excluding catalogues) might account for the more than 80 per cent of the sales. In all the creative fields, only a few artists out of many aspirants become highly acclaimed. Novelists such as John Grisham, Danielle Steele, Phillip Roth, and Harold Robbins have, for examples, all written widely popular bestsellers. Yet even in a group of this kind only a handful have received professional peer-based awards. And few will receive the iconic status of an Ernest Hemingway or F. Scott Fitzgerald. Consider the multitude of visual and performing artists – musicians, actors, painters, photographers – who vie to make a living selling their art. Most have to supplement their income by other work to exist. And success can be transient; today’s hot new artist can be forgotten
39
tomorrow, and conversely those previously overlooked can suddenly ‘be found’. Still, those fortunate enough to reach the very top of their profession often remain in demand and command astronomical fees. This is what Frank and Cooke (2005) called the winner-take-all phenomenon. For example, auction prices of newly recognized and select established painters can command millions. In the recording field, the largest advance was reportedly the $10 million per album for six albums (if said albums sold over 5 million units each) on the deal that Prince signed with Warner Brother Records in 1992. And more recently, Madonna’s 2007 package deal with concert-promoter Live Nation Inc. reportedly included a general advance of $17.5 million, advance payments for three albums of $50 to $60 million, and an additional payment of $50 million in cash and stock for the right to promote her tours (Smith, 2007). In films, stars such as Tom Hanks, George Clooney and Julia Roberts receive in the vicinity of $20 million in acting fees, a percentage of the distributor’s gross return after a certain sum has been reached, and an unusually large percentage of the ‘back end’ (DVDs, syndication, etc.) – all for what might amount to at most just a few weeks or months of ‘work’. Indeed, television’s back end syndication payments for project participants (including actors, producers, writers, and directors) can be even more remunerative than their participation in movies. Shows such as Cosby, Seinfeld, Friends, Cheers, Everyone Loves Raymond, and Frasier all earned more than $1 billion each over their subsequent (sometimes third or fourth) syndication cycles. Artistic recognition takes the form of a pyramid with numerous aspirants on the bottom and few on the top. In economic terms, supply far exceeds demand: we overproduce aspiring artists given what the society can sustain. One of the more interesting questions, then, is why so many young people desire to become artists or work in the arts even when knowing that they may not be able to support such a career choice let alone become ‘recognized’. The other curiosity is why most of the West has become so invested in sustaining the careers of artists, which are normally quite fragile, unpredictable, and unsupportable. In the past, official academies and guilds used to control the supply of artists in their respective eras and societies, but this is no longer the case. The explosion of art
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
40
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 40
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
schools in the 1970s in the USA, for instance, made it possible for almost anyone to train for a career in the arts and to dream of artistic success. The current system perpetuates this disjunction between supply and demand.
Conceptualizing artistic careers Careers in the arts do not happen by chance; they are created. To understand the elusiveness of artistic success or how a creative expression becomes designated as creative we need to grasp the complexity of the artistic career path – the many steps that may allow a work of art to come to fruition, to find an audience, to attain a critical reception. Making a career in the arts, becoming established, and building a reputation are all exceedingly difficult. There are many contenders, the career obstacles are formidable and not well understood by most new-comers, the risk of failure is high, and randomness and luck are part of the process. The artist who plies his trade well, maximizing all the opportunities available to him, may still end up disappointed. And some whose work is deeply admired by peers can fail to find larger recognition. Career paths will differ among arts disciplines and within different countries and regions. For instance, in the USA, commercial artists have different career paths from those who work in the nonprofit world; individual artists face different career issues to those who work in teams; and a painter’s career issues will vary from those of novelists or jazz musicians. Even so, there are some conceptual similarities. Artists must obtain training in their craft. They must find time to create – origination – either as solo individuals or as teams. They must also find a way to exhibit and show their work and to create an audience for it – presentation/ promotion. Selling the artistic work is contingent upon effective distribution networks, and evaluation is central to gaining recognition and acclaim. Although the following examples of artistic career trajectories are US-based, the conceptual framework for artists’ careers presented here – along with the high risk involved in creative recognition – are no doubt applicable to most of the industrially developed world. How various nations manage these career passages has a strong bearing on an artist’s potential for career building and creative recognition.
Training Aspiring artists will attend a credited university or college art programme or train in a professional art school not connected with institutions of higher education. Aspiring ballerinas, for instance, generally start training at a very young age and continue into professional dance schools in their teens. Their careers start and end early due to the physical demands of their art. By contrast, architects, who must become certified to practise, require extensive advanced training beyond college but can practise well into their later years. Attending a school of repute can also be a career bonus for artists. Connections and close friendships with fellow artists and professional mentors during the formative training period and beyond can become essential assets, early on putting aspiring artists in touch with wellconnected individuals in their fields. And artists may continue taking auxiliary courses throughout their careers to either enhance their existing skills or learn new ones. After their initial education, for example, it would not be unusual to find actors studying with a renowned teacher or taking seminars on how to audition and put a portfolio together. Origination Origination is the R&D phase of an artist’s career. Research and development refers to the entire range of support necessary for an artist or an artistic team to bring a work to fruition. This can include mentors, working spaces and raw material supplies, feedback, creative partnerships, technical assistance, funding, and so forth. The solitary novelist obviously has needs which are different from those who are part of a team producing a new opera or movie. Financial support is crucial to this career stage. It can come from a variety of sources – foundation grants, state and local arts agencies, residencies, investors, clients, awards from service associations, and paid work that allows time for artistic creation. The Ford Foundation in conjunction with a consortium of other foundations recently made a commitment to fund emerging artists. The Theatre Communications Group gives awards to new directors and theatre writers. Publishing houses offer advances to those writers whose work they think will be profitable. Theatre angels give enhancement monies for promising plays. Local and state arts agencies fund artists, and some municipalities provide cultural districts where art can be bought and sold without incurring taxes.2
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 41
RECOGNITION AND ARTISTIC CREATIVITY
Universities are often generators of new works. Yale Repertory Theatre, Harvard’s American Repertory Theatre, and Brown University’s collaboration with Trinity Repertory or New York University’s Gray Arts Gallery have well established performing arts venues on campus. Universities also support cutting-edge works and are often the first line of origination and presentation. Modern dance, for instance, originated in elite girls’ colleges on the Eastern seaboard. Nevertheless, resources for origination are frequently problematical. Broadway has seen a continual decline of new plays and musicals originating on the Great White Way. Insiders attribute this to conservative producers unwilling to speculate on new and relatively expensive productions. The film and television industries, moreover, spend exorbitant sums on R&D, sifting through an abundance of script submissions, overbearing script notes, producer pitches and pilot programmes, and rewrites. Top writers can receive over $1 million for a draft and over $150,000 a week for rewrites. But even so, there is no assurance of ultimate success. A project can burn through millions and still be discarded, and what survives at the end is not necessarily the best artistically. Presentation/promotion Art must be seen and heard and experienced. It must also be promoted to create an audience. Sometimes presenters are also promoters; other times these functions are done by separate agencies. Intermediaries such as dealers, investors, and agents all become important at this stage. Acting as gatekeepers, it is they who select and promote art work and artists they think have a chance to become successful. Each art discipline has its own traditional venues such as opera houses, galleries, museums, and theatres along with designated alternative spaces where new art can be previewed. As already noted, colleges and university theatres and art galleries will often provide previews of new works. There are also more than 2500 film festivals internationally for aspiring filmmakers, and numerous art fairs and summer festivals for visual and performing artists. Coffee houses will often display new art on their walls and entertain a musical ensemble. Airports have been known to show fine artists. And the Internet is increasingly a presentation and promotion vehicle for visual artists, film makers, musicians and writers. Established arts institutions, such as the large opera houses, will typically feature a new opera as
41
part of their yearly programming. Similarly, successful dance companies may introduce a new work in their season. The reputations of these institutions, combined with their marketing, promotional, and publicity budgets, can provide a potential lift to an artist’s career. The mission of select nonprofit theatres is precisely to feature new artists and art work, while in commercial theatres, angels and other financial backers function as promoters of new artistic fare. Gallery dealers are always scouting for new, compelling artists whom they can assiduously promote through their sponsorship of shows and connections to potential collectors, museums, and journal writers. The role of book editors and agents is to discover promising writers and to promote their books in the media and at venues around the country. The same goes for movie agents and the actors they represent. Sometimes talent is so overwhelmingly above average that the artist receives almost immediate and widespread attention and backing. Contracts are granted and extended, endorsement fees are readily forthcoming, and a major career is launched. Singer Luciano Pavarotti was a case in point. Yet other music successes, especially in the pop field, may depend on a carefully designed and nurtured process of promotion. Disney’s recent Hannah Montana (Miley Cyrus) or High School Musical franchises, or the late 1990s bands such as ‘N Sync and the Backstreet Boys, fit this description. On occasion a celebrity has provided a significant promotional resource. Oprah Winfrey’s book club, begun in 1996, has helped many new writers garner attention and sales. In view of the diminishing venue for new writers in part due to the consolidation of publishing houses and bookstores, her club has proven to be an important channel for authors to reach audiences for literary fiction. Distribution Often the agency that presents and promotes the art will act as its distributor but sometimes these functions are separated. In either situation, however, it is the distributor’s mandate to find the most advantageous and lucrative markets, whether domestic or international. Operas, theatre companies and symphonies that have showcased a new work will often look to make additional presentations beyond their halls. Gallery owners will often open or align with galleries elsewhere, or will provide funding to advance a painter
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
42
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 42
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
and exert better control over his output and pricing. Entertainment conglomerates will also test various markets, promoting and distributing films, music, television programmes, and books internationally. No matter what the product is, however, technology is transforming presentation, promotion, and distribution while at the same time diminishing the influence of those gatekeepers of the past. The Internet is already a primary new channel for the distribution of music, films, other visual arts, and books. And its far-reaching effects can be seen from the fact that video stores are being rapidly rendered obsolete, that audiences can now rent DVDs and download favourite programmes and songs from practically anywhere, and that some independent producers are already commercially and creatively active and able to bypass the major studios by using the Internet as a possible distribution pathway. The effects can also be seen in the book publishing industry, where editors and agents are overwhelmed by submissions from eager new authors seeking access to the marketplace. Many such authors will abandon their dreams or hone their writing skills elsewhere, yet some will persist in finding new outlets for their work. The Internet is the logical place to carve out a viable channel to promote and distribute books and stories. Evaluation There are a number of formal and informal reputationmaking awards given by each arts discipline. The Oscars and Golden Globes for film, the Pulitzer Prize for literature, the Tonys for live theatre, The Emmys for television, the Grammys and Country Music Awards in music, and the Pritzker Prize for Architecture – all are examples of a recognition that helps to confirm, and sustain, an artist’s career and reputation. Established theatre, music and visual arts critics who work for journals, newspapers, and media outlets are also creators and purveyors of value. It is often said that praise by a New York Times drama critic can make or break a Broadway or off-Broadway show. However, sometimes wordof-mouth can outstrip the official critics; Rent, for example, while not generally favoured by the critics, nevertheless went on to be a long-running box office success. This is similar to Steven Sondheim’s theatrical pieces, where many received mixed notices from critics who considered his lyrics far superior to what was at first thought to be unusual
and unmelodic music. Their reception and evaluation among his peers, however, were significant, and over time the critics began to acclaim his uniqueness and creativity. Awards followed, and today Sondheim is considered an icon in the musical theatre field along with other lions such as Richard Rodgers, Oscar Hammerstein, Lorenzo Hart, and Jerome Kern. Broadway’s long-running Cats, produced by the formidable Andrew Lloyd Webber, was initially greeted inhospitably by the theatre world’s resident experts. Good promotion and word-of-mouth held the day, however, and Cats has ultimately become the longest running musical on Broadway. The same thing has also frequently happened in films. No one expected Casablanca to attain the recognition that it did. And Star Wars, initially turned down by Universal, touched an audience nerve and became the pivotal film of its time, on a par with the reception Gone With The Wind had received in its day.
Creativity and globalization: trends and policy What are the forces that relate to creativity and globalization? This question may be more amenable to concrete, individual examples of cultural connections, hybrids, rejections, etc. than to an assessment of broader trends. However, with that caveat in mind, we offer a few considerations. Connectivity An essential characteristic of globalization is the enhanced connectivity between peoples, cultures and nations around the globe. All of this is encouraged and supported by the Internet-based expansion of international business firms, increased tourism, the proliferation of civil society organizations, and professional networks. Increased connectivity makes the artistic fare of different peoples, nations and places more available to others and heightens the potential for a cross-fertilization of creative expressions. Connectivity facilitates the formation of creative unions and hybrid artistic expressions, and both multiplies and complexifies the number of possible career paths and outlets for artists. For instance, digital recording and playback devices now allow different world musical expressions to be co-opted, blended, and mixed in ways that have never before been possible. And international
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 43
RECOGNITION AND ARTISTIC CREATIVITY
financial and creative alliances between different cultural traditions are being formed in films and television programming. Hollywood – with the second largest number of feature film releases (around 600 a year) – is beginning to co-finance and distribute joint projects with India’s Bollywood (around 1,100 releases a year) (Schuker, 2008). Technology Technology is key to shifting creative possibilities globally. Creative efforts have always been affected by the technological environment in which they are produced. Outdoor painting had to wait for paints that did not dry out readily. Movies did not exist until lenses, cameras, film stock, lighting, and electric motors had been developed. In the 1930s television could at best be described as a radio service with pictures, but of course it has turned out to be much more than that. And in little more than twenty years the Internet’s effect on the ways we produce and receive and respond to arts and culture and the ways in which we conduct our businesses and our lives has already been at least as profound. The global trends in technology continue, now and in the future, to affect artistic efforts globally – in ways yet to be experienced or understood. Technological advances in products and services related to cell phones, DVDs, iPods, digital books, and the Internet are dramatically connecting individuals worldwide and transforming all stages of creative careers. And the changes extend well beyond the most affluent populations as the new technologies – faster, cheaper, and more portable – empower and enable people in poorer countries to jump directly into the age of digital communications. More than ever before in human history, art, in the form of music recordings, video presentations, reading and visual materials and books, and net conversations, can occur across time zones – anytime and anywhere. An outgrowth of this is that there is an accompanying gradual movement away from textbased to more visually-based information delivery systems. The latest technologies make it possible to involve the consumer of art and cultural products and services in much more intensely visual and audible experiences. This shift is reflected in the global interest in social networking sites and services like Facebook, MySpace, and YouTube. And it is evident in the growth of video games, and in the declining readership of newspapers and books. For the legacy media and entertainment companies,
43
this has created a huge challenge – to adapt to this new world order by developing business models that can sustain and grow profitability. Thus far, however, the dollars being lost in the fading legacy businesses are being replaced only by pennies from the digital arena. As for artists, it is evident that career trajectories at all stages are being affected. Thanks to the new technologies artists can, for example, easily set up their own web sites, show and sell their work, and endlessly chat and blog and evaluate the works of others. Singers and musicians can sell their CDs and link to iPods. Filmmakers can use some of the new software to create and sell affordable films. And authors can digitally post their works to a worldwide audience of readers. It is not yet entirely clear, however, as to how and to what extent such new technologies will transform traditional career paths. Everything is still embryonic. Policy Creative expressions will obviously blossom more readily in situations that value them. Many countries do not put a premium on promoting the new. Some lack an infrastructure that supports artistic creativity, while others value traditional modes of expression over the new. One of the normative assumptions in the West is a belief in experimentation and innovation. Here there is a tacit acceptance that creative content is an engine of the knowledge economy and that artistic skills will be essential to the new order; that artists bring a special worth and meaning to life; that we need to level the playing field to give all artistic aspirants a chance to find their voice and create; and, that many artistic endeavours, even those that do not make it in the marketplace, might be worthy of public support.3 Where experimentation is valued and where artists are supported at various junctures of the career process, the soil is ripe for the creative work of many varieties to root and blossom. Many affluent countries have numerous policies and programmes that that can help to promote creative expressions and artistic careers. Assistance can range from programmes that provide direct funding to artists; tax structures that provide guaranteed minimum wages for new artistic entrants; loans for new art collectors; municipal cultural districts with tax benefits for artists and purchasers; organizations that assist with employment, grants, health, housing and retirement benefits; government-sponsored cooperatives that support indigenous art forms; and so forth.
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
44
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 44
ISSUES AND PATTERNS IN CULTURAL EXPRESSION
Policies that support artistic creativity exist at the trans-national level as well. The World Observatory on the Social Status of the Artist, resulting from UNESCO’s World Congress 1997 on that topic, provides an informational overview of the status of artists worldwide on a variety of issues. Also, the European Institute for Contemporary Culture (ERICarts), a nonprofit research institute established in 1997 and located in Bonn, Germany, started on-going, comparative research for the European Parliament in 2006 on the challenges facing European artists in relation to labour, tax and social security legislation. Inclusiveness Since the turn of the twentieth century, artistic value has widened its boundaries considerably. Expressions once considered as outside of official canons of acceptance – originally based on European high art – have entered the mainstream. For instance, hip hop, pop art, jazz, the tango, bossa nova, the blues, outsider art, photography, and modern dance have all evolved beyond their roots and become internationally accepted, and even sometimes
Box 2.1
acclaimed (Zolberg and Cherbo, 1997). And the trend continues. More recently, vernacular art forms emanating from grassroots community-based arts activities such weaving, wood working, basket making, jewellery design – and also indigenous arts including native American Indian, Alaskan, and Australian aboriginal art – have found worldwide audiences and markets.
Summary The human creative faculty is like a weed, capable of growing practically anywhere. A remarkable voice, an unusual colourist, a compelling storyteller, are often immediately identifiable. Creativity, it seems, is a generic and genetic part of our species. Yet creative potential can remain stillborn or slip through the cracks. What is worth remembering is that no artist or art forms are inevitable successes. The infrastructure that can bring them to acclaim is essential in understanding the life of any creative endeavour.
Digital arts and the cultural expression of young people
The creative potential in all of us needs to be nurtured. Today, the digital environment has opened up new fields of meaning, enabling us to apply, modify and combine elements from various converging sources, drawing them from a variety of different contexts and making them useable. Local culture and environment are among the principal sources for developing the diversity of knowledge and creativity and therefore serve as a key point of departure for creative digital expressions. It is important to help young people realize that the realities and experiences within their own immediate environment can be valid topics to talk about and share with peers from different parts of the world. Digital content can be simply produced through acquired knowledge and trained skills without context. However, creative aspirations and empirical reflections relevant to local cultures can guarantee socio-cultural awareness and promote an equitable digital environment. In this context, is technology merely a useful tool in the digital creative process? Is its contribution limited to giving form to original ideas and acts? In the digital age, it is even more essential to see how creative content is communicated and received by others. Young people should be encouraged in their freedom to actively deliver their creative expressions as much as to develop them, whether within or outside the formal education system. Bridging the digital divide does not necessarily mean possessing the most updated equipment or being an expert in digital software. A greater barrier is the creative content gap. Young people should be aware of their right to the opportunity of developing their own creative talents even with limited digital means. This is truly decisive to the long-term diversity of creative digital expressions. Today we have more trans-spatial connections than ever before in human history. The Internet might not be able to provide a physical meeting space but it has the potential to enlarge the range of participants and audiences, to encounter people from diverse geographical locations and cultural backgrounds. This is why supporting young people’s access to cross-cultural knowledge-sharing and exchange platforms is crucial. This is the lesson of UNESCO’s ‘Young Digital Creators’ programme, an online initiative that encourages young people from all over the world to connect with each other in exploring key societal issues, e.g.,
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 45
‘The sound of our water’ programme that invited young people to reflect on water issues, either connected to daily life or related to specific issues such as environment, culture, industry, etc., and to integrate digital sound into their own creation of a water soundscope. ‘Scenes and sounds of my city’ allows them to create their own digital art pieces reflecting on the urban environment and to discover experiences across a diverse range of cultural identities while ‘Youth communicating on HIV/AIDS’ is designed for young people to express their thoughts and feelings on this world phenomenon in relation to specific social and cultural issues. Indeed, young people everywhere can raise questions, exchange views, make collective reflections, join their efforts and act together, acting as responsible global citizens – provided the development of their digital creativity embedded in local cultures is properly nurtured. Indrasen Vencatachellum
Box 2.2
Inspiring innovation and creativity in the workplace
With fierce competition among businesses worldwide, firms are on a never-ending search for the most effective ways to raise productivity and, ultimately, profit. In recent years the workplace has seen the emergence of various methods to inspire creativity and imagination among employees for this purpose. As playing video games, also known as gaming, has increased amongst individuals of all ages, even non-technology-based businesses in the United States have begun to use this pastime to their advantage by designating office space for the sole purpose of gaming. The experiment seems to be working, as firms report that not only do their game rooms help boost morale and camaraderie, but are also helping to attract younger workers and increase productivity (Edelhauser, 2007). Pandemic, a major video game developer with offices in Los Angeles and Brisbane, Australia, even employs a full-time Quality of Life Manager to coordinate a range of sporting and recreational activities including soccer, softball, and basketball. Further, Pandemic sponsors numerous company clubs and activities such as poker nights, movie nights at local theatres, excursions to local theme-parks, and national league sporting events. These benefits seem to be having some positive impact, as Pandemic was named Best Developer in both 2004 and 2005 by industry experts (Pandemic Studios, 2008b). A company that goes even further in inspiring creativity and innovation in non-traditional ways in the workplace is Google, a global enterprise with offices ‘from Bangalore to Zurich’. It is described as being ‘among the best-run companies in the technology sector’, and ‘a model for smart innovation in challenging times’ (Hammond, 2003). Some of the perks Google employees receive include all-organic food, massages, a gym and free medical care. Google’s Human Resources Director Stacy Sullivan hires 100 people a week for various positions worldwide. She believes that ‘passion is the quality that leads to innovation’ (Gruca, 2006). In addition to the flexibility and financial security they enjoy, employees are allowed to spend one day a week on a project of their choice, and are encouraged to work on projects that will contribute to their personal growth. These projects can lead to life-changing opportunities within the company. For example, an assistant to co-founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin had an idea to form a ‘green strategy’ team. Her bosses fully supported her efforts. The flexibility for mobility enabled her to move up and she now heads the team that continually searches for ways to reduce the company’s carbon footprint (money.cnn.com, 2008). Nicole Vasquez
Bibliography Edelhauser, K. (2007) ‘Video games at work?’, Entrepreneur. com. Retrieved 16 October 2008, http://www.entrepreneur.com/human resources/managingemployees/article179274.html Google.com (2005) Google Continues International Expansion, Opens Offices in Latin America. Retrieved 17 October 2008, http://www.google.com/press/pressrel/latam_office.html Google.com (n.d.) Life at Google. Retrieved 17 October 2008, http://www.google.co.kr/support/jobs/bin/static.py?page= about.html
45
Anheier & Isar-3927-Ch-02:Anheier & Isar(3) Sample.qxp
20/10/2009
11:40 AM
Page 46
Google.com (2008) Financial Tables. Retrieved 18 October 2008, http://investor.google.com/fin_data.html Gruca, T. (2006) Peek Inside Google’s Workplace (CBS Broadcasting Inc). Retrieved 17 October 2008, http://wcco. com/seenon/Google.Silicon.Valley.2.372411.html Hammond, K.H. (2003) ‘How Google grows … and grows … and grows’, Fast Company.com. (Issue 69). Retrieved 17 October 2008, http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/69/google.html money.cnn.com (2008) What Makes Google Great. Retrieved 17 October 2008, http://money.cnn.com/video/ft/#/video/ fortune/2008/01/22/bpw.google.fortune Pandemic Studios (2008a) Lifestyles. Retrieved 16 October 2008, http://www.pandemicstudios.com/corp/lifestyles.php Pandemic Studios (2008b) Press & Awards. Retrieved 16 October 2008, from http://www.pandemicstudios.com/corp/press.php
Notes 1
The concepts of creativity, innovation and research and development are often used interdependently. While there is no agreement on the definition of each, there are distinctions and usages. For instance, creativity is generally considered a property of individuals; innovation is spoken of as the process of taking a creative idea and bringing it to fruition; research and development usually refers to team work within an organizational framework, such as teams developing video games or a movie. All three refer
2
3
to what we have conceptualized as the ‘origination’ stage of creative expression. In 1995, the National Endowment for the Arts in the USA stopped supporting individual artists due to a rash of controversial art. In the real world, budgets are limited and policy tradeoffs must be made. It may eventually be seen as more important for a government to support performing arts centres, or indeed spend more on elementary education, on feeding the poor and homeless, or on providing more healthcare services for the elderly than on supporting artists’ careers.
REFERENCES
Carvajal, D. (1996) ‘Many, Many Unhappy Returns’, New York Times, 1 August. De Vany, A.S. (2004) Hollywood Economics: How Extreme Uncertainty Shapes the Film Industry. New York: Routledge. Frank, R.H. and Cooke, P.J. (2005) The Winner-Take-All Society. New York: Penguin. Gardner, H. (2006) Multiple Intelligences: New Horizons in Theory and Practice. New York: Basic. Peterson, R.A. and Anand, N. (2004) ‘The production of culture perspective’, Annual Review of Sociology, 30: 311–34. Rosenberg, B. and Harburg, E. (eds) (1993) The Broadway Musical: A Collaboration in Hits and Flops. New York: New York University Press. Schuker, L.A.E. (2008) ‘Spielberg, India’s Reliance to Form Studio’, Wall Street Journal, 20 September. Smith, E. (2007) ‘Madonna Heads for Virgin Territory’, Wall Street Journal, 11 October. Throsby, D. (2001) Economics and Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Zolberg, V. and Cherbo, J.M. (eds) (1997) Outsider Art: Contesting Boundaries in Contemporary Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Select bibliography for further reading Bart, P. (2006) Boffo! How I Learned to Love the Blockbuster and Fear the Bomb. New York: Hyperion. 46
Becker, H.S. (1982) Art Worlds. University of California Press.