Dangerous Dilemma

7KH6HTXHOWR,QVSLUHG/XVW 'HVHUW/XVW

&RS\ULJKW‹/LVD.HQQHG\

7KHPRUDOULJKWRIWKHDXWKRUKDVEHHQDVVHUWHG$OOFKDUDFWHUVLQWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQDUHILFWLWLRXVDQGDQ\ UHVHPEODQFHWRUHDOSHUVRQVOLYLQJRUGHDGSODFHVHWFLVSXUHO\FRLQFLGHQWDO $OOULJKWVUHVHUYHG 1RSDUWRIWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQPD\EHUHSURGXFHGVWRUHGLQDUHWULHYDOV\VWHPRUWUDQVPLWWHGLQDQ\IRUPRU E\DQ\PHDQVZLWKRXWSULRUSHUPLVVLRQLQZULWLQJRIWKHDXWKRUSXEOLVKHUQRUEHRWKHUZLVHFLUFXODWHGLQ DQ\IRUPRIELQGLQJRUFRYHURWKHUWKDQWKDWLQZKLFKLWLVSXEOLVKHGDQGZLWKRXWDVLPLODUFRQGLWLRQ EHLQJLPSRVHGRQWKHVXEVHTXHQWSXUFKDVHU

KWWSZZZ2QOLQHHERRNVWRUHFRP



3URORJXH µ6RPHZKHUH¶PXUPXUHG*X\GHSRVLWLQJSDSHUVLQWRDEULHIFDVH µWKHUH¶VDPDQXVFULSW,ZRXOGQ¶WPLQGJHWWLQJDSHHNDW¶ +HZDVIDLUO\VXUH0HUFHGHVKDGVDLGVKHZRXOGEHDZD\IRU WKUHHKRXUVRUWKHUHDERXWVDQGJLYHQWKDWVKHKDGEHHQJRQHOHVVWKDQ IRUW\PLQXWHVKHUHFNRQHGLIQRWKLQJHOVHKHKDGWLPHWRVSDUHIRUD JRRGORRNVHHLIKHFRXOGORFDWHWKHGDPQWKLQJ+HJXHVVHGULJKWO\ WKDWLWZDVQ¶WLQDQ\RIWKHGHVNGUDZHUV2WKHUOLNHO\KLGLQJSODFHV ZLWKLQWKHURRPVRRQGHFODUHG]LOFKWRR :KHUHWKHQZKHUHLQKHOOFRXOGLWEH" +HFDVWKLVPLQGEDFNWRPRPHQWVEHIRUHVKHKDGOHIWIRUDQ XQNQRZQGHVWLQDWLRQKHUVHOIOHVVWKDQIRUWKFRPLQJDERXWZKHUHVKH ZDVRIIWRRUIRUZK\+HUHFDOOHGWKHHYHQWDVUHODWLYHO\QRUPDOLQ WKDWVKH¶GVDLGURXJKO\KRZORQJVKHZRXOGEHKDGSLFNHGXSKHUFDU NH\VEDJDQGVQDWFKHGXSKHUODSWRSWKRXJKZK\VKHQHHGHGLWZDV VRPHZKDWRIDP\VWHU\6KHKDGWKHQJUDEEHGDWDFRXSOHRIVPDOO HQYHORSHVIRUSRVWLQJDQGIOHGDVWKRXJKODWHIRUDQDSSRLQWPHQW



'DPQKHWKRXJKW0D\EHVKH¶VVHQGLQJWKHILQDOVFULSWRQDGLVN 1RQRQRWLIWKHPDVVSULQWRXWDFRXSOHRIGD\VDJRZDVDQ\WKLQJ WRJRE\ +HRQFHDJDLQVXUYH\HGWKHFRV\OLYLQJURRP,WZDVDVKDGEHHQ IRU\HDUVTXDLQWZLWKORZEHDPVZKHUHLQSODFHVLIWDOORQHQHHGHGWR GXFNWRDYRLGVWDUVSLQQLQJVHFRQGVRILPPRELOLW\DQFLHQWROG VLGHERDUGQHDUWRWKHNLWFKHQGRRUZD\WKDWNQHHFDSSHGZKHQFXWWLQJ FRUQHUVWKHVXPSWXRXVWKUHHSLHFHVXLWHWHPSWLQJIRUFRXFKOL]DUGV LWVVRIDQRZVWUHZQZLWKSDSHUZRUNSDSHUZRUNZKLFKKHIXOO\ LQWHQGHGFOHDULQJXSEHIRUH0HUFHGHVUHWXUQWKRXJKSOHQW\RIWLPH IRUWKDWODWHU +LVH\HVWKHQVHWWOHGRQWKHZLQGRZDQGWKHEXLOWLQVHDWEHORZ FRVLO\WRSSHGRIIZLWKSOXVKFXVKLRQV+HZDVEHWWLQJKLVOLIHRQWKH PDQXVFULSWEHLQJWKHUHLQWKHURRPDQGLIODG\OXFNZDVRQKLVVLGH KH¶GIRXQGLW+HKXUULHGO\FDVWFXVKLRQVDVLGHOLIWHGWKHOLGRQWKH ZLQGRZVHDWDQG/RDQG%HKROGDODUJHEURZQMLII\HQYHORSHZDV WKHUHDQGEXOJLQJDWWKHVHDPV2K\HVWKHHOXVLYHPDQXVFULSWLQKLV JUDVSDWODVW+HWKHQUHWUHDWHGWRKLVIDYRXULWHDUPFKDLUEHVLGHWKH RSHQVWRQHIODJJHGILUHSODFH,QKDVWHKHWKUXVWVHYHUDOGULHGWLQGHU VWLFNVRQWRPHUHVPRXOGHULQJHPEHUVWKHQDFRXSOHRIORJVDQGDV 

ZRRGVPRNHLGO\GULIWHGXSWKHFKLPQH\WRWKHVRXQGRIKLVVLQJDQG FUDFNOLQJKHFDUHIXOO\ZLWKGUHZWKHPDQXVFULSW 7KLVZDVWKHPRPHQWWRRQFHDJDLQGHOYHLQWRWKHZHLUGJRLQJV RQRIXQGHUFRYHUMRXUQDOLVWVDQGDGHFLGHGO\SHUYHUWHGFRSSRVLQJDVD WUDQVYHVWLWH+H¶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¶WORRNDWWKHPDQXVFULSWHYHQLIVKHOHIWLWULJKWLQ IURQWRIKLP /LDUWKDWKHZDVKHGHOYHGLQZLWKUHOLVK 

 :KDW¶VLWFDOOHGDJDLQ" KHVDLGDQKRXUODWHUEDFNWUDFNLQJWRWKH WLWOHSDJH:LWKPLQGDOUHDG\ZKLUOLQJWKRXJKQRWWKHOHDVWVXUSULVHG WRILQG0HUFHGHVKDGZULWWHQRYHUWUDXQFK\VH[+HZDVVXIIHULQJ VXIIHULQJJRRGDQGZLWKRXWWKHNH\WRKLVSDGORFNHGFRFNKDUQHVV WKHUHZDVQRZD\KHFRXOGHIIHFWSOHDVDQWSK\VLFDOUHOLHI  'DQJHURXV'LOHPPDKRZDSW KHFKXFNOHG FRQVLGHULQJWKDW SRRUEDVWDUGRIDFRSKDVDOUHDG\VDXQWHUHGURXQG/RQGRQLQ ODFHWULPPHG)UHQFKNQLFNHUVVXVSHQGHUVDQGD39&VNLUWYHU\ QHDUO\XSWRKLVMLQJOHEHOOV+H¶VDZKDWDOLYLQJFDQGHODEUD"¶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¶*X\VHQVHGWURXEOHELJWURXEOH+H¶GVWHSSHGRXW RIOLQHDQG0HUFHGHVKDGWKHORRNWKDWVDLG\RX¶UHIRULWELJER\µ, OO 

VD\DQ\WKLQJ\RXZDQWWRKHDUDQ\WKLQJEXW\RXQHYHUWROGPH\RX ZHUHZULWLQJHURWLFD,W¶VZD\EH\RQGDQ\RIWKRVHIRUPXODWHGWKULOOHUV \RX¶YHEHHQFKXUQLQJRXW

6KHVFRZOHGDWKLPWKRXJKVHHPLQJO\DPXVHGE\SDXVHVLQ VSHHFKDQGVDLGPXFKWRKLVVXUSULVH *ODG\RXOLNHLWDQG\RX¶UH ULJKWDERXW/XNH+H¶VGHDGO\DWWUDFWLYHDQGKDVDKHDYHQO\ERG\6RUW RIILWV\RXUGHVFULSWLRQZRXOGQ¶W\RXVD\"


 2K,GRQ WNQRZZKDWGRHVKDLUFRORXUPDWWHU"

 $UH\RXVD\LQJLWLVPH" KHTXHULHGLQGLJQDQWWKDWKHZDVEHLQJ SRUWUD\HGDVDQLQVXIIHUDEO\DUURJDQWDOSKDPDOHZLWKDNLQN\VH[XDO KDQJXSFRUUHFWRQDOOSRLQWVSHUYHUVHSRVVHVVLYHO\MHDORXVRIKHU \HVZRPHQNHSWDWDUPVOHQJWKRWKHUWKDQGXULQJPRPHQWVRIGLUH FDUQDOQHHGWUXHLQWKHSDVWEXWRQO\EHFDXVHJHWWLQJKRRNHGLQD PDULWDOVHQVHQRWDFDUGKH¶GORRNHGWRGUDZ  ,I\RXVHH\RXUVHOILQ/XNHWKDW VQRWP\IDXOW VKHUHSOLHG $IWHU DOOZHDOOKDYHOLWWOHSRFNHWVLQWKHVXEFRQVFLRXVZKHUHVSHFLILF PHPRULHVOXUNOLNHSKDQWRPVZHZLVKZRXOGIDGHWRREVFXULW\ 6KH UHDFKHGXSFXSSHGKLVIDFHWKHQIOHHWLQJO\NLVVHGKLP :KDWZRXOG OLIHEHOLNHZLWKRXWQRYHOLVWVH[RUFLVLQJJKRVWV"



 'R\RXPLQGLI,UHDG'DQJHURXV'LOHPPDWRQLJKWRQO\,JHWWKH IHHOLQJ, YHMXVWEHHQJLYHQDOLWHUDU\SX]]OHWRSLHFHWRJHWKHU   0D\EH, OOUHDGLWWR\RXODWHUE\WKHILUH VKHVXJJHVWHG 6WRU\ WLPHDQGVQXJJOHWLPHIRUVODYHDQGPLVWUHVV

 'LG\RXVD\VQXJJOHRUVQXIIOH"

 :KDWHYHU

 $Q\WKLQJPD DP

 6QXIIOHLWLVWKHQDQG,¶OOVQXJJOHDQGODWHUZKRNQRZV   6HUYLFHZLWKDVPLOHLI\RXKDYHQ¶WORVWWKHNH\WRWKH FRFNKDUQHVV

 6DIHDQGVRXQG VKHFRQILUPHGGDQJOLQJLWIURPDFKDLQDURXQG KHUQHFN 3DLQIXOGD\"

 $WWLPHVOLNHWKLVH[FUXFLDWLQJ7KHUHPDLQGHUOLNHQHGWRWKHPDQ LQWKHLURQPDVNRQO\DVVDERXWIDFH

 6RUU\"

 +HZDVDGLFNLQKDQGIHOODDQGIUXVWUDWHGO\XQDEOHWRJRWUXIIOH VQXIIOLQJLQPRVV\JURYHV   *X\\RXFDQEHXQEHOLHYDEO\VH[\DWWLPHV

µ/LNHQRZIRULQVWDQFH"¶ µ8KKXKEXWILUVWWKLQJVILUVW,¶YHJRWDSUHVHQWIRU\RXRXWVLGHLQ WKHFDU:HOOIRUERWKRIXVUHDOO\¶ 

µ'RHVWKLVSUHVHQWKDYHVRPHWKLQJWRGRZLWKWKHH[HUFLVHWKLQJ \RXPHQWLRQHGWKLVPRUQLQJ"¶ µ2KDEVROXWHO\2I'DQLVKRULJLQDQGZHDULQJDFKDLQFROODU¶ µ,W¶VQRWEORQGHDQGEHDXWLIXOLVLW"¶ µ.LQGRIDQGZKLOH\RXFOHDUXSLQKHUH,¶OOJRJHWLW¶ ,QGHHGZKLOH0HUFHGHVZDVJRQH*X\WLGLHGWKHURRPDVHQVHRI H[KLODUDWLRQJULSSLQJGHHSGRZQLQKLVJURLQ ,WZDVEXWDIHZPRPHQWVEHIRUH0HUFHGHVUHWXUQHGKDOIFDUU\LQJ KDOIGURSSLQJDEHLJHFRORXUHGIXUU\EXQGOH µ0HHW'DQWH¶ µ+PPVHHZKHUHWKHH[HUFLVHELWFRPHVLQ+RZPDQ\PLOHV WRPRUURZ"¶ µ:HOOWKDWZLOODOOGHSHQGRQKRZZHOO\RXVQXIIOHWRQLJKW¶ µ$P,WREHLQFRPSHWLWLRQZLWK:KDW¶VKLVQDPH"¶

'DQWH+H¶VJRUJHRXVDQGZLOOWXUQLQWRD*UHDW'DQHDQGWR UHPDLQXQFRUUXSWHGDWDOOWLPHV¶ µ7U\WHOOLQJKLPWKDWLQVL[PRQWKVZKHQWKHORFDOVKHHSGRJELWFK LVRQKHDWDQGKH¶VGUDJJLQJPLVWUHVVKHDGORQJLQWRDGRJJ\VKDJ GDWH¶

'DQWHZLOOEHDVZHOOWUDLQHGDV\RXE\WKHQ¶ µ
µ,IQRW,¶OOJHWDGRJJ\FRFNKDUQHVVPDGHXS¶ µ7KLQNLQJRIZKLFK,QHHGDVODVK¶ µ$KZHOOLQWKDWFDVH,¶GEHVWOHW'DQWHJHWDFTXDLQWHGZLWKWKH SODFHZKLOH\RXDQG,SRSXSVWDLUVWRWKHEDWKURRP¶ µ'RQ¶W,JHWSRVVHVVLRQRIWKHNH\IRUWRQLJKW"¶ µ$EVROXWHO\QRW3RLQWVIRUVQXIIOLQJZLOOEHDZDUGHGODWHUDQGLI OXFN\\RXPD\JHWDUHZDUG¶ µ&DQ,VWDUWMXLFLQJ\RXXSQRZ"¶ µ3RVVLEO\ ,WZDVSDVWQLQHR¶FORFNZKHQ0HUFHGHVVHWWOHGKHUVHOIGRZQWREHJLQ UHDGLQJWKHUHPDLQGHURI'DQJHURXV'LOHPPDWR*X\HDFKKDYLQJ DOUHDG\LQGXOJHGWKHRWKHUWKURXJKRXWDQDPXVLQJDQGHQWHUWDLQLQJ HYHQLQJRI³QRWLQIURQWRIWKHSXSS\´ 0HDQWLPHWKHSXSKDGH[SORUHGHYHU\URRPKDGVHWWOHGIRUD EHGQHDUWRWKH$JDFRRNHUKDGFRQVXPHGWZRPHDOVKDGSLGGOHGRQ WKHEDFNGRRUPDWDQGKDGVOHSWPRUHWKDQH[SHFWHGEHWZHHQEULHI PRPHQWVRIPDGJDPHSOD\RIHLWKHUVKDNLQJWKHOLIHRXWRIDQROG VOLSSHURUWU\LQJWRUHWULHYHLWIURP*X\¶VILUPJUDVS 

7KHVODYHQRZDWKLVPLVWUHVV¶IHHWWKHQVDLGµ6WDUWDWWKH EHJLQQLQJSOHDVH,MXVWORYHLWZKHQ\RXWDONGLUW\¶ µ:KHQ\RXSXWPRXWKWRFXQWOLSVWKHQ,¶OOEHJLQ¶ $QGWRKLVGHOLJKWVKHGLG



2QH

3OHDVH&KDUOLHNHHSKHOSLQJPHRXWRQWKLVEL]DUUHVH[\DVVLJQPHQW DQG, OOUHDOO\PDNHLWZRUWK\RXUZKLOH
 +HOOVEHOOV3DXOD/LYLQJDORQHLQWKHEDFNRIEH\RQGGRHVQ W PHDQWKDW, PWZLGGOLQJP\KDLUDQGZRQGHULQJZKDWWRGRQH[W 1HLWKHUDP,KDELWXDOO\

:DQNLQJDOOGD\" FXWLQ3DXOD $VWLIOHGJLJJOHZDVFOHDUO\DXGLEOHE\ZD\RIWHOHSKRQHWRKHU VLVWHUOLYLQJRQWKHHGJHRI([PRRU0HDQZKLOH&KDUOLHH\HVRQKHU FRPSXWHU VPRQLWRUZDWFKHGDQRWKHUHPDLOZLQJLQJLQRQWKH67' OLQH6KHJULSSHGWKHSKRQHWLJKWHUDVXUJHRIDGUHQDOLQHSXOVLQJ WKURXJKKHUDVWKRXJKWKHILUHVRIKHOOZHUHDWKHUKHHOV

7RWHOO\RXWKHWUXWK, YHJLYHQXSRQPHQ ZKRDGYHUWLVHLQ ORQHO\KHDUWVFROXPQVLQP\VHDUFKIRUDVRXOPDWH7KH\¶UHVXFKVDG SHRSOHDQGWKHHQGOHVVZULWLQJRIOHWWHUV+HOODQGWDONLQJWR 

LQFUHGLEO\ERULQJPHQRYHUWKHSKRQHZDVMXVWWRRPXFKWREHDU  &KDUOLHKDOIODXJKHGVHOIFRQVFLRXVO\DZDUHRIDQHZRYHUULGLQJ FRPSXOVLRQµ 7KDWLVZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKDWFHUWDLQLQGLYLGXDO\RX DVNHGPHWRPDNHFRQWDFWZLWKDQGZRXOG\RXEHOLHYHLWKH¶V DGPLWWHGWRSODFLQJDGVLQ7KH6XQGD\7LPHV &KDUOLHSDXVHG UHDFKHGIRUKHUFRPSXWHUPRXVHFRQWURORQWKHGHVNWKHQFOLFNHGLWWR RSHQDSDUWLFXODUHPDLOPHVVDJH ,¶PIDLUO\VXUHWKDWKHGRHVQ¶WNQRZ WKDW,¶YHVXVVHGKLPDQGJXHVVZKDW" 6KHVPLOHGDZDUHWKDW LQWHQGHGSUH\KDGGHILQLWHO\PDGHFRQWDFWDJDLQ  $UH\RXRQWKH,QWHUQHWULJKWQRZ" TXHULHG3DXOD&KDUOLH HYLGHQWO\GLVWUDFWHGE\VRPHWKLQJRUVRPHRQHHOVH


:KRKDV",QZKDWZD\"

, PIDLUO\VXUHWKHPDQ\RX YHDOOEHHQORRNLQJIRUUHVLGHVLQ /RQGRQGXULQJWKHZHHNDQGJRHVQDWLYHDWZHHNHQGV:KHUHWRDV \HW¶VKHSXUUHGµ,KDYHQ¶WDFOXHEXW\RXNQRZVRPHWKLQJ" 5HVHDUFKLQJWKURXJKWKH,QWHUQHWLVIXQDQG,¶PMXVWEHJLQQLQJWR UHDOO\OLNHSOD\LQJFDWDQGPRXVHJDPHVZLWKWKLVJX\




 3RVLWLYH+HILWVWKHJHQHUDOGHVFULSWLRQRIGDUNKDLUGDUNH\HV WDOOSK\VLFDOO\ILWUHJXODUZRUNRXWVLQWKHJ\PHFOHFWLFWDVWHLQPXVLF DQGZRPHQDQGXQGHUO\LQJVH[XDODSSHWLWHLPSO\LQJKH¶VYHU\ GHILQLWHO\ELVH[XDO7KHRQO\GLIIHUHQFHEHLQJKH VUROHSOD\LQJDVD VXEPLVVLYHDWWKHPRPHQW,JHWWKHIHHOLQJKHPLJKWZHOOEHPDUULHG DVZHOO3XWLWGRZQWRLQWXLWLRQ

,WFDQ WEHKLPWKHQ%HOLHYHPH&KDUOLH7KHJX\ZHZDQWLV IDUIURPVXEPLVVLYHDQGVXSSRVHGO\DVLQJOHJX\&KULVW6LVWKLQN DERXWZKDWKHGRHV9LUWXDONLGQDSSRVVLEOHUDSHDQG

,NQRZ,NQRZEXWWKDWGRHVQ¶WPHDQKH¶VQRWPDUULHGMXVW EHFDXVHKHFODLPVWREHVLQJOH 7KHSODLQIDFWLVQRQHRIWKHJLUOV IRXQGZDQGHULQJWKHVWUHHWVLQDGUXJRUGULQNLQGXFHGVWXSRUZHUH HYHUZLOOLQJWRDGPLWWRDQ\WKLQJEH\RQGWKHIDFWWKH\KDGEHHQWRD SDUW\KHOGDWDODUJHKRXVHVRPHZKHUHRXWLQWKHVWLFNV%HKRQHVW 1RWRQHRIWKHPKDGDFOXHDVWRKRZORQJLWKDGWDNHQE\FDUWRUHDFK WKHLUVRFDOOHG SODFHRIFRQILQHPHQWULJKW"$QGRIIWKHUHFRUGSROLFH ZLVH RUVR\RXVDLGDOO WKHJLUOVGHVFULEHGWKHLQWHULRURIWKHSUHPLVHV LQGHWDLO 5LJKWDJDLQ"




 $OVR FXWLQ&KDUOLHH[DVSHUDWHGE\VXFKQHJDWLYLW\IURPKHU VLVWHU WKH\GHQLHGSK\VLFDODVVDXOWDQG\HWWKHLURXWZDUGDSSHDUDQFH LPSOLHGRWKHUZLVHULJKW"


1REXWVKHUH3DXOD,IWKH\ZHUHVXEMHFWHGWRGUXJVDQGWKHQ UDSHGDJDLQVWWKHLUZLOO&RPHRQORYHZKDWKDSSHQHGZRXOGQ¶W KDYHERWKHUHGDWRXJKFRRNLHKRRNHUZRXOGLWQRWLIZHOOSDLGWR UHPDLQVLOHQW":KHUHDVDJHQXLQHUDSHYLFWLPDIWHUWKHLQLWLDOVKRFN RIKDYLQJEHHQGUXJJHGDQGVXEMHFWHGWRLQGHFHQWVH[XDODVVDXOW ZRXOGZDQWVRPHVRUWRIMXVWLFHOHYLHGHYHQWXDOO\LHDWOHDVWD FULPLQDOFRQYLFWLRQXQOHVVWRRWUDXPDWLVHGWRDGPLWDQ\WKLQJ KDSSHQHGLQWKHILUVWSODFH"/HW¶VEHKRQHVWWKHVHJLUOVGLGQ¶WUHDFW OLNHYLFWLPVRIVH[XDOFULPHGLGWKH\"7KH\ZHUHQHLWKHUVFDUHGQRU ZLOOLQJWRSUHVVFKDUJHVDQGWKH\PXVWKDYHKDGDGDPQJRRG GHVFULSWLRQRIWKHSHUVRQZKRSLFNHGWKHPXSLQWKHILUVWSODFH VXUHO\",VXJJHVWWKH\FKRVHWRJREXWZK\"¶  +RZWKHKHFNGR,NQRZ VFUHDPHG3DXODDVLIXQGHUDWWDFN UDLVLQJKHUYRLFHDFRXSOHRIGHFLEHOV 9HUEDOO\WKUHDWHQHG".QRZ ZKRKHLV"3HUKDSVPLVJXLGHGOR\DOW\WRDORYHURUPDVW"



&KDUOLHVHQVHGKHVLWDWLRQRQ3DXOD VSDUW
 2ND\VR, YHGDEEOHGLQPDVRFKLVWLFSUDFWLFHVDQG\HV,WKLQN WKLVJX\LVDEGXFWLQJ\RXQJZRPHQWRVDWLVI\VRPHSHUYHUVHVODYH IDQWDV\WKDWJRHVDOLWWOHEH\RQGZKDWLVFODVVHGDVDFFHSWDEOHLQRXU WHUULEO\SUXGLVKLVODQGVRFLHW\$IWHUDOO%ULWDLQDVDQDWLRQLV JRYHUQHGWRVZHHSVH[XQGHUWKHFDUSHWUDWKHUWKDQDGPLWOXVWLVWKH GULYLQJIRUFHEHKLQGKXPDQH[LVWHQFH0HDQZKLOH+ROODQGDQG *HUPDQ\DUHUHQRZQHGIRUUHGOLJKWGLVWULFWVDQGKDYHORZVH[FULPH ILJXUHV'DPQLWWKHUH¶VDKXJHIROORZLQJLQWKHVDGRPDVRFKLVWLF VFHQHLQWKLVFRXQWU\QRWWRPHQWLRQDSOHWKRUDRIWUHQG\IHWLVK QLJKWFOXEVDQGZKDWRIWKHOHDWKHUZHDUVKRSVVSHFLDOLVLQJLQNLQN\ HTXLSPHQWZKLFKDUHERRPLQJ

7HOOPHDERXWLW*RGDOOWKHWLPHV\RXORFNHGWKHEDWKURRP GRRUWRSUHYHQWDQ\RQHVHHLQJZHOWVRQ\RXUEDFNVLGHWUHPEOLQJ HYHU\WLPHWKHSKRQHUDQJDQGEOHDWLQJ ³\HVPDVWHUQRPDVWHU´DQG RWKHUOXGLFURXVDQVZHUVWRVRPHZDFN\SHUYHUW

+DUGO\VTXHDN\FOHDQDUH\RX6LV" :KRZDVLWZKRSXWD KRUVHZKLSWRDER\IULHQGDQGPDGHKLPJRGRZQRQKLVNQHHVLQWKH 

WDFNURRP"1RWWRPHQWLRQWKHIDFWWKDW\RXSXWDVDGGOHRQKLVEDFN DQGURGHURXQGRQKLP

 7KDWZDVMXVWDELWRIIXQ

 0D\EHEXWKHHQMR\HGWKHVXEMXJDWLRQRIHQIRUFHGRUDORQ \RXUVH[\VHOILQIURQWRI\RXUEDE\VLVWHUDQGWKHZKROHVFHQDULRZDV SURRISRVLWLYHWKDWEHLQJLQFRQWUROHQKDQFHGRUJDVPLFSOHDVXUHIRU \RX


 :K\FKDQJHWDFWLF"3UHVXSSRVLQJKHLVRXUPDQRIFRXUVH

+H VRQWKHPDNHOLNHPRVWJX\VDQGSUREDEO\VKDIWLQJ DQ\WKLQJKDOIGHFHQWDQGZLOOLQJLQDVWUDLJKWVHQVH\HWKHZDQWVPRUH WKDQMXVWD\HVJLUO µ0HDQLQJ"¶ µ0HDQLQJJLUOVKHFDQSLFNXSHDVLO\DWDGURSRIWKHSURYHUELDO KDWDUHQRORQJHUVDWLVI\LQJDGDUNHUGHHSHUGHVLUH6RIRUWKHPRPHQW KH VUHODWLYHO\VDWLVILHGZLWKEHLQJLQFRQWURORIDIHPDOHVXEPLVVLYH DQGVXIILFLHQWO\VWLPXODWHGE\LQVWLOOLQJIHDUDQGGUHDGLQDQRWKHUWR VDWHKLVRZQLQQHUVH[XDOGHVLUH %XW,WKLQN KH¶VLQWRDXWRHURWLFD   :KDWPDNHVVRPHRQHZDQWWRJRWKDWIDUIRU&KULVW VVDNH"

+H¶VZLWQHVVHGQHDUGHDWK EXW



 2K*RG¶H[FODLPHG3DXODµ
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

6RGGLQJKHOO&KDUOLH,WKLQN, OOSXOORXWRIWKLVDVVLJQPHQW, P QRWXSIRUEHLQJEDLWWRVRPHRQHOLNHWKDW/XNHFDQJRZKLVWOH DQG

 :KDWGR\RXPHDQEDLW" &KDUOLHVFDQQHGDYHU\GLVWXUELQJ HPDLOEHIRUHKHUFRQYLQFHGWKDWWKHVHQGHUQRWRQO\XWLOLVHGWKHQLFN 5HIOH[PDQRQWKH,QWHUQHWEXWKDGDOVRDGYHUWLVHGKLPVHOIDVVHHNLQJ 

&LQGHUHOODLQDFOHYHUO\ZRUGHGDGZLWKLQ7KH6XQGD\7LPHV7KH WKRXJKWRIKHUVLVWHUEHLQJZLWKLQWRXFKLQJGLVWDQFHRID&KDUPLQJ 3ULQFHRI'DUNQHVVZDVRXWRIWKHTXHVWLRQ  /XNH" VKHDVNHGDQDIWHUWKRXJKW  0\ERVV
, YHQHYHUPHWKLP:K\WKHQLFN"

&ROGEDVWDUGZLWKSUHVHQFH$Q\KRZWKLQNLQJRIFROGVODEVDQG SRVVLEOHGHDGERGLHVJLYHVPHWKHFUHHSV*RWWDJR6LVDQG, OOWHOO $UFWLF$XUD, PRIIWKHFDVH


:LOOGR /XNHZLOOSUREDEO\JHWLQWRXFKSHUVRQDOO\ HYHQWXDOO\'RQ WKROG\RXUEUHDWKWKRXJK+H VQRWRQHIRURIIHULQJ OXQFKRUGLQQHUHQJDJHPHQWVWRDQ\RQHEXWMRXUQDOLVWFURQLHVIURP ZD\EDFNZKHQKHZDVQLQHW\ 3DXODODXJKHG :K\LVLWVRPHPHQ DUHROGEHIRUHWKHLUWLPH"

0DULWDOUHVWUDLQWRIFXFNRRVLQWKHORYHQHVWHYHU\FRXSOHRI \HDUV"0DOHUHVLVWDQFHWREHLQJRXVWHGE\RIIVSULQJSHUKDSV" IROORZHGE\PLVWUHVV GLYRUFH DQGPDLQWHQDQFH" :KRFDQVD\"
IXQQ\VLGHRISDVWHQFRXQWHUVµ:KHQLWFRPHVWRVH[LQRURXWRIWKH PDULWDOEHGDQGERWK\RXDQG,KDYHKDGWKHRGGGDOOLDQFHZLWK PDUULHGPHQ7KLQNDERXWLW6LVVHULRXVO\:HGLVFRYHUHGPLVVLRQDU\ IHYHUDIIOLFWHGWKHWUXO\KDUQHVVHGIDPLO\PDQDQGODUJHUWKDQOLIH SHJRV\QGURPHZDVWKHEUDLQLQSDQWDGGLFW¶VLGHDRIVH[ULJKW"¶ µ7UXH¶JLJJOHG3DXOD¶$QGSHUYSODJXHVHHPLQJO\EHIHOOWKH UHPDLQGHUOLNH/XNH¶VEURWKHU1LNR

µ+DYHQ¶W,PHWKLPVRPHZKHUH"7KHQDPHULQJVDPLJKW\ELJ EHOO¶ µ'RQ¶WWKLQNVRDQGDVIRU/XNHKH V VXIIHULQJQRQHRIWKRVH FRPSODLQWVWKDW,¶PDZDUHRI0RUHDFDVHRIDOOSRZHUIXOEHLQJDQG XQWRXFKDEOHE\PHUHPRUWDOV+H¶VELWWHUDERXWVRPHWKLQJWKRXJKRU VRPHRQHEXWDQH[FHOOHQWERVV $Q\ZD\DVPXFKDVOORYH JRVVLSLQJ,UHDOO\PXVWGDVK%\HORYH6HH\RXVRRQ

&KDUOLHVLJKHGSXWGRZQWKHSKRQHKHDUGLWFOLFNKHUH\HVRQ WKHFRPSXWHUPRQLWRUKHUWKRXJKWVRQWKHPDQEHKLQGDGLVWXUELQJ PHVVDJH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB



WR9DPSHUHOOD#VH[PDLOFRP 5H\RXUFRPPHQW

!³2IZKDW"&RQWURORYHUPHQZRPHQ\RXQJDQGROGDOLNH",W MXVWKDSSHQV,GRQ¶WZRUNDWLW&DOOLWP\VWHULRXVDSSHDOWRERWK JHQGHUVµFRV,VXUHDVKHOONQRZZKHQDVWUDQJHUZKHWKHU DJJUHVVLYHO\GRPLQDQWRUQRWLVVXFFXPELQJWRVRPHWKLQJ"´

1RZZHDUHJHWWLQJWRLWLW¶VQRWWKDW:20(1DUHDOZD\VLQ FRQWUROZKLFK5HIOOH[PDQNQRZVLVIDOVHEXWWKDW<28DUH:HOO WKDWPLJKWEHWUXHLQIDFW\RXPD\LQVLVWRQLWDQGUHIXVHWRSOD\DQ\ RWKHUZD\7KDW¶VQRWVRG\VIXQFWLRQDO 2QWKHRWKHUKDQG\RXVD\!³
+HQFHQRRQHZLOOHYHUFRQWURO\RXUPLQG0LQHHLWKHUEXW,FDQ JLYHWKHLPSUHVVLRQWKDWWKH\DUHDOWKRXJK,¶PIDLOLQJPLVHUDEO\DW 

WKDWLQWKHVH HPDLOVZRQGHUZK\,DPEHLQJVRKRVWLOH,VLWWREXLOG XS\RXUUHVHQWPHQWIRURXUILUVWPHHWLQJ"+RSHQRW2XFK ,QUHSO\WRP\SURSRVHGVFHQDULRRI\RXUVXEPLVVLRQWRPH\RX ZURWH !³,¶GUHEHOZKDWWKHQ:RXOG\RXDGPLQLVWHUSDLQ",¶GUHEHO DJDLQ&DOO\RXDQLQFRPSHWHQWQRYLFHXQZRUWK\WRFDOO\RXUVHOI PDVWHU0RUHSDLQ,SUHVXPHQRZ\RX¶YHORVWLW ,¶PFDOOLQJWKH VKRWV
$IWHURXUODVWLQWHUDFWLRQWKHIROORZLQJLPDJLQHGVFHQDULRRI µ6ODYH5RXOHWWH¶FDXVHGPDMRUKDUGRQ

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

+HEHJLQVWRORRVHQKHUERQGVWKUXVWVDQGWKUXVWVKLVPLJKW\ ZHDSRQLQWRKHUXQWLORUJDVPULSVWKURXJKKLVIUDPH,QWULXPSKKH ODXJKVUHPRYHVKHUEOLQGIROGWKHQEDFNVDZD\+HUFKRVHQRQH ORRNLQJRQODXJKLQJLQVWLJDWHGWKHSURFHHGLQJVDVHDFKUHMHFWHG PDOHUHDGLO\VDWHWKHLURZQLQQHUQHHGIRUUHYHQJHE\WDNLQJKHURQH E\RQH(QG

*RRGKXK"1LFHWZLVW,¶GVHWWOHIRUVLPLODUDW\RXUKDQGV/HW PHNQRZZKDW\RXWKLQN,¶OOFDOO\RXWRQLJKWRQWKHQXPEHU\RXJDYH DWWKHDJUHHGWLPH 5HIOH[PDQ 

&KDUOLHUHDFKHGIRUDFLJDUHWWHVRPHWKLQJVKHKDGQ¶WGRQHLQD ORQJZKLOHRQO\WRGLVFRYHUWKHSDFNHWZDVHPSW\µ%ODVWWKLVJX\ :KDWLQKHOODP,GRLQJ"¶VKHVDLG 6KHSRQGHUHGKLVHPDLOVFHQDULRKHUWHHWKFOHQFKLQJDELURIRUD IHZPLQXWHV µ7ULFN\EDVWDUGWKLVRQHDQGWKHURSHERQGDJHKH¶VMXVW KLJKOLJKWHGLQGHWDLOFRXOGFDXVHVHOILQGXFHGVWUDQJXODWLRQ
SURYLGHGDPLVWUHVVZKRLVVHHPLQJO\LQRYHUDOOFRQWURORIHYHU\RQH SUHVHQW¶ 7KHPRUH&KDUOLHWKRXJKWDERXWWKHXQGHUFRYHULQYHVWLJDWLRQ VKHKDGEHFRPHLQYROYHGLQKHUVLVWHUKDYLQJHQOLVWHGKHUKHOSLQ DQVZHULQJDGVLQVDGRPDVRFKLVWLFDQGVZLQJLQJPDJD]LQHVWKHPRUH VKHSRQGHUHGZK\3DXOD¶VERVVZDVVRDSSDUHQWO\REVHVVHGDERXWD IHZZRPHQIRXQGZDQGHULQJWKHVWUHHWVRI/RQGRQ $WILUVWJODQFHDILOHFROODWHGRYHUWKUHHPRQWKVDQGSODFHG EHIRUHKHUZRPHQLQWRUQIHWLVKJHDUDQGVWRQHGRXWRIWKHLUPLQGVRQ GULQNRUGUXJVKDGVWLUUHGOLWWOHLQWHUHVW:KHQLWZDVODWHUSRLQWHGRXW WRKHUWKDWDOOWKHZRPHQKDGDWWHQGHGDVSHFLILFQLJKWFOXEWKH HYHQLQJWKH\KDGGLVDSSHDUHGLWZDVWKHQ&KDUOLHKDGEHFRPH FRQYLQFHGWKDWPD\EHWKHUHZDVDVWRU\WREHWROGHYHQLIWKHZRPHQ LQTXHVWLRQZRXOGQ¶WWHOOLWWKHPVHOYHV :KDWKDGLQWULJXHG&KDUOLHWKHPRVWZDVZKRWKHRZQHURIWKH QLJKWFOXELQTXHVWLRQPLJKWEHVRPHWKLQJWKDWZDVVWLOODP\VWHU\ DQGVHFRQGO\ZKRZHUHWKHERXQFHUVRQWKHQLJKWVWKHZRPHQZHQW PLVVLQJ"$IWHUDOO\RXQJZRPHQGHSDUWLQJLQDVWUHWFKOLPRFRXOG KDUGO\EHPLVVHGXQOHVVWKHERXQFHUVMXVWKDSSHQHGWREHORRNLQJWKH ZURQJZD\6RZKDWLQKHOOZDVUHDOO\JRLQJRQDW5LW]\¶V3OHDVXUH 'RPHRQIHWLVKQLJKWV" 

$VIDUDVWKHODZZDVFRQFHUQHGWKHUHZDVOLWWOHSROLFHRIILFHUV ZHUHDEOHWRGRIRUZRPHQXQZLOOLQJWRSUHVVFKDUJHV7KHZRPHQ KDGGHQLHGWKH\KDGEHHQDEGXFWHGDQGKDGUHIXVHGWREHFRHUFHG LQWRSURYLGLQJDQ\LQIRUPDWLRQWKDWPLJKWKDYHOHGWRDQDUUHVW +HQFHLQGLYLGXDOFDVHVZHUHGURSSHGDQGQROLQNFRXOGEHIRXQG EH\RQGDPHUHPHQWLRQRI5LW]\¶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

0\UHVSRQVHWR\RXUODVWHPDLOWKHIROORZLQJIDQWDV\IRU\RXU GHOHFWLRQ

'DQDVRIWO\VWURNHGKHUSXELFPRXQGUHGILQJHUQDLOVGHOYLQJLQWRWKH GHZ\PRLVWXUHRIDYHU\ZHWGHOWDKHUOHJVVHGXFWLYHO\SDUWHGWR UHYHDOVZROOHQIOXVKHGODELDSHWDOVµ
VOLW"¶6KHFHDVHVVWURNLQJKHUVHOIOLIWVILQJHUVVWLFN\ZLWKVH[XDO QHFWDUWRKHUOLSVDQGVDODFLRXVO\VXFNVHDFKEHIRUHDJDLQWKUXVWLQJ WKHPEHWZHHQIOHVK\IROGV $ZDUHRIGDUNH\HVIROORZLQJWKHGHIWPRYHPHQWRIILQJHUV GDQFLQJRQDMXLF\SHDUOLVHGQXEFRQVFLRXVRIWKHPDOHIRUPPRYLQJ IRUZDUGVKHUHDFKHVRXWWRVWURNHDGHOLFLRXVHQJRUJHGSXOVLQJ PDQKRRG µ6RKDUGVRULSHVRHDJHUWRSOHDVH¶VKHSXUUV +HPRYHVFORVHUVWLOOEUXVKLQJWKHSXUSOHFURZQHGKHDGRIKLV DURXVDOXSDJDLQVWKHUILQJHUVµ1RWVRIDVW0D¶DP¶KHJURZOVµ,JHW WKHIHHOLQJ\RX¶UHWKHZDQWRQRQHDURXQGKHUH¶ 6KH\LHOGVWRKLVVH[\DGYDQFHKHUILQJHUVPRYLQJXSZDUGWR DOLJKWRQQLSSOHVSUHVVLQJDJDLQVWWKHVLONRIKHUGUHVV6KH SXUSRVHIXOO\VLJKVORXGO\DVKLVKDUGQHVVVNLPVDFURVVKHUFOLWRULV PRLVWXUHWULFNOLQJIURPKHUOLNHDVSULQJ¶VRXUFHHQWLFLQJKLPWR ZDOORZLQVOLSSHU\ZHWQHVV+HGRHVWKHKHDGRIKLVFRFN PRPHQWDULO\VOLGLQJLQWRWKHGDUNQHVVWKHQKDVWLO\ZLWKGUDZQDVKH VXUYH\VKHUYXOQHUDEOHSRVLWLRQRQWKHERQQHWRIWKHOLPR :LWKOHJVVSUHDGZLGHWKHODG\ORXQJLQJEDFNLQDFDUHIUHH PDQQHUKHJHQWO\UHPRYHVKHUVWLOOHWRKHHOHGVKRHVXQFODVSVKHU 

VXVSHQGHUVDQGSHHOVRIIVKHHUVWRFNLQJVKLVWRQJXHLQWHUPLWWHQWO\ WDVWLQJWKHKRQH\GHZGUDZQIRUWKE\KLVWKUREELQJPHPEHU µ7DNLQJ\RXIRUDGULYHLVQRWZKDW\RXKDGLQPLQGLVLW"¶KH VWDWHVKDXOLQJKHUIRUZDUGKHUIHHWVOLGLQJWRWKHIORRUµ,WKLQN 0DGDPZDQWVWREHGULYHQWRWKHHGJHLVQ¶WWKDWVR"¶+HZUHQFKHV KHUKDQGVEHKLQGKHUEDFNDVWRFNLQJVZLIWO\XWLOLVHGWRELQGKHU ZULVWVIDVWWLJKWO\ µ6RKRZLVP\FKDXIIHXUJRLQJWRDFKLHYHVXFKDGDULQJIHDW"¶ µ2Q\RXUEXWWEDFNDJDLQVWWKHVLGHRIWKHFDU¶KHVQDSVKLV WRQHVXGGHQO\LF\FROGDQGPDWWHURIIDFWµ
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

PHUFLOHVVO\XQUHOHDVHGVKH¶VVXUYLYHGHQIRUFHGGHHSWKURDWHYHU\ EUHDWKGUDZQDVHHPLQJPLUDFOH µ3HUKDSVQRZ0DGDPZLOOEHOHVVHDJHUWRREOLJHZLWKRXWILUVW SXWWLQJXSDOLWWOHUHVLVWDQFHWRUHVWUDLQW"¶ µ,KDGQRLGHDWKDW\RXLQWHQGHGJRLQJVRIDU¶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µ
PDQQHU$WRQHGHHSHUWKDQEHIRUHRULVLWWKDWKHUKHDULQJLVSOD\LQJ WULFNVRQLPDJLQHGSRVVLELOLWLHV7KDWKHLVQRWZKRVKHWKLQNVKHLV" µ7KDWLVWKHTXHVWLRQ:KDWDP,VD\LQJ",VWKLVDSUHOXGHWRP\ GDUNHUVLGH
:HOOWKHUH\RXJR5HIOH[PDQ:KDWZLOOKDSSHQWRWKHPLVWUHVVDQG KHUVODYH",¶OOEHLQ/RQGRQIRUDFRXSOHRIGD\VDVIURPWRPRUURZ WDONWR\RXVRRQ UHJDUGV 9DPSHUHOOD BBBBBBBBBBBB



,WZDVWZLOLJKWDV&KDUOLHGDVKHGDFURVV.HQVLQJWRQ+LJK6WUHHW $IOXUU\RIVQRZIODNHVLOOXPLQDWHGE\WKHEULJKWQHVVRIFLW\ OLJKWVZKLUOHGDWH\HOHYHO$ODWHXQVHDVRQDEOHIDOORIHDUO\$SULO VQRZZDVE\IDUDSUHWWLHUVLJKWDWJURXQGOHYHOLQWKHFRXQWU\WKDQ KHUHZKHUHLWVRRQWXUQHGJUH\RUPXGG\EURZQLQFRORXU:KLOH GRGJLQJVOXVK\KHDSVRIZKHHOFKXUQHGVQRZKHUWKRXJKWVZHUHDV DOZD\VSUHRFFXSLHGZLWKWKRXJKWVRI5HIOH[PDQ +HUUHVHDUFKFDUULHGRXWRYHUWKHSDVWIHZZHHNVZRXOGVRRQEH VFUXWLQLVHGE\KHUVLVWHU¶VHPSOR\HU:KDW/XNHPLJKWWKLQN SHUVRQDOO\PDWWHUHGOLWWOHWR&KDUOLH$IWHUDOOLIWKHHGLWRULQFKLHIRI D6XQGD\VXSSOHPHQWZDVQ¶WWKDWLQWHUHVWHGLQKHUILQGLQJVVKHNQHZD VRPHRQHZKRZRXOGEH 7RKHUZD\RIWKLQNLQJ5HIOH[PDQKDGWREHSUHYHQWHGIURP FRPPLWWLQJPXUGHULIKHKDGQ¶WDOUHDG\GRQHVRDQGDVIDUDVWKH SROLFHZHUHFRQFHUQHGWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJWKH\FRXOGGRXQOHVVDFULPH KDGEHHQUHSRUWHG7KHQDJDLQ 5HIOH[PDQPLJKWMXVWEHDQRWKHUVDG ZDQNHULQQHHGRIEL]DUUHIDQWDVLHVWRVDWLVI\LQQHUFUDYLQJVWKDWKH ZRXOGQHYHUDFWXDWHLQUHDOLW\ $V&KDUOLHSRQGHUHGZK\LQKHOOVKHFRXOGQ¶WOHW5HIOH[PDQVOLS IURPKHUWKRXJKWVIRUPRUHWKDQILYHPLQXWHVVKHVKLYHUHGGUHZKHU FRDWDURXQGKHUVHOIDQGKXUULHGRQZDUG7KHUDLOLQJVVXUURXQGLQJ 

3DXOD¶VEDVHPHQWIODWZHUHPHUHO\WHQPHWUHVGLVWDQW6KHILQDOO\ UHVLJQHGKHUVHOIWRWKHUHDOLW\WKDWWKLVEODVWHG,QWHUQHWSKDQWRPKDG EHFRPHDQREVHVVLRQVRPXFKRIDQREVHVVLRQWKDWVKHLQWHQGHG SOXJJLQJLQKHUODSWRSDQGSLFNLQJXSDUHSO\WRKHUODVWRXWZDUG ERXQGHPDLO$6$37KHUHZRXOGEHDUHSO\6KH¶GEHWKHUOLIHRQ WKDWIDFW 0HDQZKLOHWKRXJKWVRI5HIOH[PDQKDGFDXVHGKHUWR PRPHQWDULO\ORVHFRQFHQWUDWLRQZKLOVWQHJRWLDWLQJLF\VWHSVOHDGLQJ GRZQWRKHUVLVWHU¶VEDVHPHQWIODW$WWKDWVDPHXQWLPHO\PRPHQWWKH GRRURIWKHIODWVXGGHQO\RSHQHGEULOOLDQWOLJKWFDVWLQJDFURVVKHU GHVFHQW,WZDVWRVD\WKHOHDVWVRPHZKDWVWDUWOLQJ$VKHUULJKWIRRW VOLGRXWIURPXQGHUKHUWKHSDGGHGODSWRSFDVHVOLSSHGIURPKHUJUDVS DQGVOLGWRWKHEDVHPHQWIORRUOLNHDPLQLVOHGJH&KDUOLHKDYLQJORVW KHUEDODQFHSOXQJHGWZRVWHSVGRZQZDUGDQGIOHZKHDGORQJLQWRWKH QRZIORRGOLWDUHD ([SUHVVLRQRIDPXVHPHQWVSUHDGDFURVVWKHIDFHRIWKHVROLG PXVFOHEXIIHUVKHVXGGHQO\FROOLGHGZLWKVRPHRQHZKRKDGQ¶W H[SHFWHGWREHUDPPHGXSDJDLQVWDZDOOZLWKGXVWELQOLGVFODWWHULQJ DOODURXQGKLP$VIRUZKDWKHPLJKWEHWKLQNLQJZHOOVKHFRXOGQ¶W KDYHLPDJLQHGDVKHHQGHDYRXUHGWRNHHSWKHPRQWKHLUUHVSHFWLYH 

IHHW+HSDVVHGQRFRPPHQWRQWKHLUFROOLVLRQZKHQDJDLQVWDQGLQJ XSULJKWEH\RQGDTXHU\DVWRZKHWKHUVKHZDVRND\ 6KHKDGQRLGHDWKDWKLVLOOWLPHGH[LWKDGDORWWRGRZLWKKHU LPPLQHQWDUULYDODQGKLVQRWZDQWLQJWREHFRPHSHUVRQDOO\LQYROYHG ZLWKWKLUGSHUVRQV%LJVLVWHU¶VHDUO\DUULYDOKDGPDGHIRUDQ XQH[SHFWHGHQFRXQWHUQRWHDVLO\WREHIRUJRWWHQDQG$UFWLF$XUDZDV PLJKW\VWURQJRIDUPVPHOWJRRGDQG&KDUOLHZRXOGZLOOLQJO\SODFHD EHWRQWKHIDFWWKDWKHEXUQHGKRWLQVLGHLIVH[XDOO\DURXVHG3DXOD¶V GHVFULSWLRQRIKHUERVVZDVVSRWRQ $V/XNHWKHQH[WULFDWHG 9DPSHUHOODIURPKLVILUPJUDVSVKH FRQFOXGHGWKDWLIE\DQ\FKDQFHKHKDSSHQHGWREH5HIOH[PDQVKH ZRXOGEHZD\RXWRIKHUGHSWK3DXODWKHQEULGJHGDQXQFRPIRUWDEOH VLOHQFHZLWK µ:RZ6SHFWDFXODUGHVFHQW6LV¶ &KDUOLHVWUDLJKWHQHGXSPRUHHPEDUUDVVHGE\KHUVLVWHU¶V FRPPHQWWKDQZKDWKDGDFFLGHQWDOO\RFFXUUHG$JOLWWHURIDPXVHPHQW GDQFLQJLQWKHGDUNEURZQH\HVRIWKHPDQVWDQGLQJEHIRUHKHU VRPHZKDWLUULWDWLQJ µ6RUU\EXW,MXVWORVWP\IRRWLQJDQG¶ +HVLGHVWHSSHGVFRRSHGXS&KDUOLH¶VODSWRSFDVHDQGSDVVHGLW WR3DXOD7KDWLQLWVHOIZDVDQDLOLQKLVFRIILQLQ&KDUOLH¶VERRND 

PDQZKRFRXOGQ¶WRUZRXOGQ¶WDFFHSWDQDSRORJ\DQGZKRGLGQ¶W GHVHUYHDVHFRQGJODQFHHYHQLIKHZDVDQROGHUYHUVLRQRIDKXQN\ ORRNDOLNHPRGHOXVXDOO\VHHQLQPDJD]LQHVDGYHUWLVLQJ&. +HVWUDLJKWHQHGKLVWLHORRNHGWR3DXODVDLGµ&RPSOHWHGE\ 0RQGD\¶WKHQVSXQRQKLVKHHOVDQGOXQJHGXSWKHVOLSSHU\VWHSVDV VXUHIRRWHGDVDPRXQWDLQOLRQKLVXQEXWWRQHGRYHUFRDWIODSSLQJ RPLQRXVO\OLNHDEODFNFDSH+HSDXVHGDWWKHWRSOHDQHGRYHUWKH VSLNHGUDLOLQJVDGGHGµ,¶OOJLYH\RXDFDOOSRVVLEO\WRPRUURZLI, GRQ¶WVHH\RXWRQLJKW¶+HWKHQFDVWDJODQFHDW&KDUOLHZKR SXUSRVHIXOO\LPSOLHGGLVLQWHUHVWDWKLVGHSDUWXUHµ+DYHQ¶WJRWWLPHWR LQWURGXFHP\VHOIDQG,¶PVXUH3DXODZLOOILOO\RXLQRQGHWDLOVDOUHDG\ GLVFXVVHGEHIRUH\RXUDUULYDO¶ ,QVWDQWDQHRXVPDJQHWLVPKDYLQJEL]DUUHO\VSDUNHGOLNHSRZHU OLQHVLQDWKXQGHUVWRUPEHWZHHQWKHPKHYDQLVKHGIURPYLHZDQG 3DXODZKLVSHUHGµ'RQ¶WZRUU\DERXWKDYLQJRJOHGKLP:RPHQDUH DOZD\VHQDPRXUHGE\KLVGDVKLQJSUHVHQFHOHWDORQHJRRGORRNV¶ &KDUOLHVQDUOHGµ,WDNHLWWKDWZDV/XNH"¶ µ+RZGLG\RXJXHVV"¶PXVHG3DXOD µ$UFWLF$XUDUHPHPEHU"6RPHWKLQJWRGRZLWKDUURJDQFH XQGHQLDEOHGRPLQDQFHWRRLQWKDWKHRUGHUHG\RXWRFRPSOHWH VRPHWKLQJE\0RQGD\DQGKH¶VVRJRRGORRNLQJWKDW,GHVSHUDWHO\ 

ZDQWWRNQRZPRUHDERXWKLPEXWZDVGDPQHGLI,ZDVJRLQJWROHW KLPVHHGURROLQJZHQFKHPEOD]RQHGRQP\IRUHKHDG¶ 3DXODFODVSHG&KDUOLH¶VKDQGGUDJJHGKHULQVLGHµ-XVWFRPHLQ ILUVWDQG,¶OOWHOO\RXZKDW,NQRZDERXWKLPODWHU/XNHQHHGVWREH GLVFXVVHGRYHUDERWWOHRITXDOLW\ZLQH¶ &KDUOLHPRFNLQJO\JURSHGKHUZD\DORQJWKHGLPO\OLWKDOO µ6WLOOXVLQJORZZDWWEXOEV,VHH"¶ µ6DYHVRQSRZHUDQGDOVRGLVSOD\VDQDPELHQFHRIEHLQJDELW¶ µ6XOWU\VH[\DQGGHFLGHGO\DUW\%RKHPLDQ"¶FXWLQ&KDUOLH µ,GRQ¶WNQRZDERXWWKHDUW\ELWEXWWKHVXOWU\DWPRVSKHUHGRHV KDYHDQLPSDFWRQWKHPHQLQP\OLIH¶ &KDUOLH¶VH\HVURYHGRYHUYDULRXVQXGHHWFKLQJVGHFRUDWLQJGDUN UHGZDOOVEXWKHUVLVWHU¶VVWDWHRIGUHVVLQPHUHO\DVLONZUDSDQGD SUHYLRXVVHQVHRIFORVHQHVVEHWZHHQKHUVHOIDQG/XNHSURPSWHGµ,V /XNHLQ\RXUOLIHURPDQWLFDOO\VLQFHZHODVWVSRNHRQWKHSKRQH"¶ µ
3DXODSODFHG&KDUOLH¶VODSWRSFDVHLQWRDODUJH4XHHQ$QQH W\SHFKDLUGUDSHGZLWKDUHGDQGJROGFKHQLOOHFRYHUOHW$WWKHVDPH WLPHDIDWWDEE\FDWVWUHWFKHGUROOHGRYHUDQGSURPSWO\IHOORIID VLPLODUO\GUDSHGVRID &KDUOLHVFRRSHGKLPXSµ:KHUH¶VWKHSHUYSDUW\WRQLJKWWKHQ"¶ µ6HFUHW¶UHSOLHG3DXODUHWUHDWLQJWRWKHNLWFKHQ µ6ZDQN\"¶DVNHG&KDUOLHJODQFLQJURXQGDURRPVRFOXWWHUHG ZLWKIXUQLWXUHDQGERRNVWKDWLWZDVDOPRVWLPSRVVLEOHWRHYHQ FLUFXPQDYLJDWHVLGHZD\VDURXQGDFRIIHHWDEOHFHQWUHURRP µ1RZDQN\PRUHOLNH¶JLJJOHGKHUVLVWHU µ,VWKDWDOO"¶VDLG&KDUOLHSODFLQJWKHFDWEDFNRQWKHVRID 3DXODUHDSSHDUHGJULPDFHGµ2KQRVKRXOGEHDFODVVDFW WRQLJKW7KHKRVWHVVLQTXHVWLRQKDVDWHQGHQF\WREHWKHVKLQLQJOLJKW DWVPDOOSDUWLHVDQGWKHUHIRUHUDUHO\DOORZVDQ\RQHEXWKHUVHOIWRWDNH FHQWUHVWDJHEXWWRQLJKWLVDELWRIDUDYHGR¶ &KDUOLHVWURNHGWKHFDWDOUHDG\FXUOHGXSDJDLQWKHQWXUQHGDQG FROOLGHGZLWKDUHGODPSVKDGH:KLOVWVWHDG\LQJWKHWKLQJLWVEODFN WDVVHOWULPEHFDPHDWWDFKHGWRWKHFXIIRIKHUMXPSHU µ6RZK\DUHZHJRLQJ"¶VKHDVNHGGHVSHUDWHO\GLVHQWDQJOLQJ QRWRQO\WKHEODFNWDVVHOWULPEXWDJROGFXIIOLQNIURPKHUMXPSHU VOHHYHWRR 

µ%HFDXVH,ZDQW\RXWRPHHW/XNH¶VEURWKHU¶ 3DXODEOXVKHGDVWKHLUH\HVPHW µ


µ$K¶UHSOLHG3DXODµ+H¶VFDOOLQJLQRQKLVZD\EDFNIURPD WUDQVDWODQWLFWULSRQO\KHLVQ¶WEHFDXVHKH¶VKHUHLQ/RQGRQ6RZRQ¶W EHJRLQJKRPHXQWLO6XQGD\DIWHUQRRQ¶ µ+DUGO\ZRUWKLWXQOHVVVFDUHGKLVZLIHZLOOH[HUWILQDQFLDOO\ FULSSOLQJUHYHQJHLIKH¶VIRXQGWREHSOD\LQJDZD\,IKHµVO\LQJ DERXWLPPLQHQWGLYRUFHRIFRXUVH¶ 3DXODWXUQHGIDFHRQKHUVHDOSXSFRORXUHGH\HVGHILDQWO\ ORRNLQJGHHSLQWRJUHHQIHOLQHRQHV6KHORRNHGDOPRVWFRQIXVHGE\ WKHLURYHUDOOGLIIHULQJDSSHDUDQFH\HWGHILQLWHO\IURPWKHVDPH EORRGOLQHV&KDUOLHWKRXJKWKHUVLVWHUEHDXWLIXOKHUORQJOHJVDQGOLWKH ERG\ZRUWK\RIDEDOOHULQDKHUIHDWXUHVWKDWRIDSRUFHODLQGROOEXW KHUGUHVVVHQVHDE\VPDO µ)URPZKDW,¶YHJDWKHUHG¶VDLG3DXODDKDOIODXJKµVKH¶V DOUHDG\DERXWWRFUXFLI\KLPLQDILQDQFLDOVHQVH6WLOOWKDW¶V1LNR¶V SUREOHPQRWPLQH$VIRUWRQLJKW:KHQZHDUULYHDWWKHSDUW\, ZRQ¶WWHOODQ\RQH\RX¶UHP\VLVWHU(YHQLI/XNH¶VWKHUHKHFDQ¶W NQRZIRUVXUHWKDW\RXDUHZKR\RXDUHEHFDXVHKHGLGQ¶WDVN¶6KH JODQFHGDWDSKRWRJUDSKRI&KDUOLHRQWKHPDQWHOSLHFHDERYHD ERDUGHGXSILUHSODFHµ:HOODWOHDVW,GRQ¶WWKLQNKHZLOO7KDWSRVHG JODP SLFRI\RXLVQRWKLQJOLNHWKHEHVFDUIHGZRROO\KDWWHGSHUVRQ ZKRWKXQGHUHGLQWRKLPRXWVLGH6RMXVWIRUWKHKHOORILWZK\GRQ¶W 

ZHSUHWHQGZH¶UHVRUWRIFORVH\RX NQRZELVH[XDOFORVH"¶ &KDUOLHUHIUDLQHGIURPSDVVLQJIXUWKHUFRPPHQWRQKHUVLVWHU¶V UHODWLRQVKLSZLWK1LNREXWWKHSURVSHFWRILPSO\LQJ3DXODZDVKHU VODYHQRWKLVMXVWFRXOGQ¶WEHPLVVHG $VVKHWKHQERXQFHGDJROGFXIIOLQNLQWKHSDOPRIKHUKDQG 3DXODFKXFNOHGµ/XNH¶OOEHORRNLQJIRUWKDWODWHU¶ µ+HFDQFRPHDQGJHWLWDQ\WLPH¶ µ,I,WHOOKLPZKHUHLWLV¶ µ$QG\RXZLOO¶ µ2IFRXUVHPRUHVRDIWHUWKHZD\KHORRNHGDW\RX:KRNQRZV SHUKDSV\RX¶OOEHWKHRQHWRFUDFNKLVLF\VKHOO"¶ µ0D\EH,ZRXOGQ¶WZDQWWRWU\"¶ µ$K¶FKDUJHG3DXODµVR\RXWKLQNKLPWRRDKDUGDQXWHYHQIRU \RX"¶ µ,GLGQ¶WVD\WKDW¶UDOOLHG&KDUOLH µ,¶PVXUHKHKDVDVRIWFHQWUHZLWKLQWKDWKHDYHQO\ERG\RIKLV :KLFKUHPLQGVPH,QHHGWRWRSXSP\WDQ6RZKLOH\RXJRKDYHD EDWK,¶OOJRVXQP\VHOI¶ &KDUOLHWKRXJKWDERXWGDUNKDXQWLQJH\HVDQGZRUOGO\ZLVH SHUVRQD
µ7KLQNLQJDERXWVKDG\FKDUDFWHUV,I,SOXJLQWKHODSWRSZHFDQ VHHLI5HIOH[PDQKDVDQVZHUHGP\ODVWHPDLO &KDUOLHLPPHGLDWHO\ GLVFDUGHGKHUUHGZRROO\KDWDQGVOLGRXWRIKHUEODFNZRROFRDW µ*RG,KRSHWKHPDFKLQHLVQ¶WGDPDJHGIURPVNLGGLQJGRZQWKH VWHSV¶ µ,¶OOPDNHDFXSRIFRIIHHZKLOH\RXVHWLWXS¶3DXODVFXUULHGWR WKHNLWFKHQVKRXWHGEDFNµ'R\RXNQRZZKDWKHUHDOO\ORRNVOLNH EH\RQGKLVGHVFULSWLRQ:KDW,PHDQLVLV5HIOH[PDQDJRUJHRXVKXQN RUZKDW"+DVKHVHQW\RXDSLF\HW"¶ µ7REHKRQHVWKLVGHVFULSWLRQFRXOGEHFODVVHGDVWKDWRI$UFWLF $XUD
&KDUOLHORVWLQKHUREVHVVLRQLPSDWLHQWO\FRXQWHGWKHVHFRQGV WRFRQWDFW6KHUDQILQJHUVQHUYRXVO\WKURXJKKHUORQJGDUNKDLUKHU JUHHQH\HVDZDLWLQJWKHDUULYDORIDFRQGHPQLQJHPDLOFRQVFLRXV WKDWKHUVLVWHUKDGPRYHGFORVHU µ2KP\\RXZHUHULJKWWRJRORRN¶UHPDUNHG3DXODIDVFLQDWHG E\WKHWH[WEHIRUHWKHP WR9DPSHUHOOD#VH[PDLOFRP UH/RQGRQWULS

6KDPHDERXW\RXUEHLQJLQWKHFLW\,ZLOOEHWLHGXSOLWHUDOO\ EXVLQHVVZLVHQH[WZHHN+DYLQJVDLGWKDWKDYHDUUDQJHGWRWDNHWLPH RXWDWDSDUW\LQ.HQVLQJWRQRQ6DWXUGD\+DG\RXVDLG\RXZRXOGEH LQ/RQGRQDZHHNDJRFRXOGSUREDEO\KDYHZDQJOHGDQH[WUD LQYLWDWLRQIRU\RX
HVWHHP6KHVD\VLWVRVKHVWDUWVWRZDQWLW,I\RXGRXEWKHUVKH DWWHPSWVWRSURYHLW,IVKHZRQ¶WWDONWR\RXVLPSOHEXWVOLJKWO\ IHDUIXOSDLQIXO SXQLVKPHQWVDUHLQUHVHUYH ³6RUU\PDVWHUWKDW, GLGQ¶WVSHDNEHIRUH
6KHSXUFKDVHGKLVIDYRXULWHWLSSOHDWWKHEDUUHWXUQHGWRKHU PDVWHUDZDLWHGKLVVLJQDOIRUKHUWRGHSRVLWKHUFXWHOLWWOHEXWWLQWKH FKDLURSSRVLWH8QFRPIRUWDEO\DZDUHWKDWKHUSDUWLDOO\XQEXWWRQHG FRDWFRXOGSDUWWRUHYHDOKHUQDNHGIRUPEHQHDWKVKHVHQVHGVRPHRQH EUXVKFORVHSUD\HGKHUPDVWHUZRXOGWHOOKHUWRVLWGRZQ 6KHVKLYHUHGKHUPDVWHU¶VKXVN\YRLFHGHDGO\SUHFLVHLQKLV UHTXHVWWKDWVKHOHDYHWKHEDUDZDLWKLVSUHVHQFHLQWKHSDVVDJHZD\ OHDGLQJWRWKHEDFNH[LWDQGWRIXOO\XQEXWWRQKHUFRDW6KHIROORZHG WKURXJKKLVLQVWUXFWLRQVZDLWHGDQGZDLWHG6HYHUDOPHQZDONHGSDVW EXWQRQHSDVVHGDFRPPHQWRUDFFRVWHGKHUDQGVKHEHJDQWRZRQGHU LIKHUPDVWHUKDGDEDQGRQHGKHU 

1HUYRXVO\FODVSLQJKHUFRDWDURXQGKHUVHOITXLYHULQJLQ DQWLFLSDWLRQZKLOHDQJU\WRRVKHVXGGHQO\QRWLFHGKLPSXVKRSHQWKH GRRU+HVDLGQRWKLQJDGYDQFHGDQGSDVVHGKHUDEOLQGIROG6KH LQVWDQWO\NQHZZKDWWRGRZLWKLWDQGRQFHVHFXUHGVKHVHQVHGKLV KDQGFODVSKHUV *XLGHGRXWVLGHKHUFRDWSDUWLQJLQWKHFKLOOQLJKWDLUVKH VKLYHUHGDJDLQ%OLQGO\QHJRWLDWLQJDFREEOHGDOOH\LQKLJKKHHOHG ERRWVDIIRUGHGOLWWOHWLPHWRDVVHVVZKHWKHUHFKRLQJIRRWVWHSVZHUH WKHLU¶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

$ERXWWRUHPRYHWKHEOLQGIROGIHDUJULSSHGKHUZKHQDKDQG SUHYHQWHGWKDWYHU\DFW6KHZDVWKHQKHOSHGWRKHUIHHWDQGEDFNHG DJDLQVWWKHZDOO 5HVFXHU"$QRWKHUDVVDLODQWLQWHUHVWHGLQKHUQXGHIRUPDQG KHUYXOQHUDELOLW\" 


µ*RG&KDUOLH,GRQ¶WNQRZDERXW\RXEXW,¶PSRVLWLYHO\ GURROLQJDWWKHLGHDRIEHLQJSXWWKURXJKDVFHQDULROLNHWKDW¶ µ2QUHIOHFWLRQ¶VDLG&KDUOLHFRQVLGHULQJWKHHWKRVRIVXSHUHJR DQGWKHIHPDOHPLQGµ,VXSSRVHLI\RXUERVVZDVLQYROYHGWKHQ\HV, PLJKWEHLQWHUHVWHGLQSOD\LQJDORQJ¶ µ,¶OOWHOO\RXRQHWKLQJ6LV¶PXVHG3DXODDVHQVHRI DQWLFLSDWLRQVHWWLQJKHUDOODWUHPEOHµ5HIOH[PDQLVJRLQJWREH SUHVHQWDWWKHVDPHSDUW\ZH¶UHDWWHQGLQJEHFDXVHWKHFKDQFHRIWZR SHUYSDUWLHVLQ.HQVLQJWRQRQWKHYHU\VDPHQLJKWLV]LOFK¶ µ:HOO,QHYHU$QG\RXNQRZVRPHWKLQJ",OLNHG\RXU VXJJHVWLRQHDUOLHUDERXWXVQRWEHLQJVLVWHUVEXWYHU\FORVH¶ µ%ULOOLDQW,GRVRORYHSXOOLQJVWXQWVRQSHRSOHDQG1LNRZLOOEH IXULRXVDQGERXQGWRZUHDNUHYHQJH¶3DXODJODQFHGDWKHUZDWFK µ
&KDUOLHWHUPLQDWHGWKHHOHFWURQLFHPDLOSURJUDPPHDQGFORVHG WKHOLGRIKHUODSWRS$FKDQFHPHHWLQJZLWK5HIOH[PDQDWD .HQVLQJWRQSDUW\FRXOGEHDWKULOOLQJHQFRXQWHUDQGLQQHUGUHDGRI WKHXQNQRZQVHWKHUSXOVHUDFLQJ



7ZR $V&KDUOLHFOLPEHGWKHGLPO\OLWVWDLUZD\KHUVLVWHUQDNHGGDVKHG IURPWKHEDWKURRPDQGSDXVHGHQURXWHWRKHUEHGURRP µ7KHEDWKLVDOPRVWIXOOVRKXUU\XS¶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¶VSUHIHUHQFH IRUVHFRQGKDQGFORWKHVNLQGRIHQGHDULQJWKRXJKUHF\FOLQJRIWHQ WDNHQWRH[WUHPHV &KDUOLHUHHOHGTXLFNO\WXUQHGRIIWKHWDSVWKHZDWHUIURWK\ZLWK EXEEOHVKHUH\HVDOLJKWLQJRQDFROOHFWLRQRIDQLPDOIULHQGO\SURGXFWV 

DGRUQLQJDYHUWLFDOFRUQHUEDWKWLG\$ERXWWRLQYHVWLJDWHIXUWKHU VKHKHDUGWKHGRRUEHOOVKRXWHGµ6KDOO,JHWLW"¶ 7KHUHSO\µ
µ,ZDVQ¶WDZDUHWKDW,ZDQWHGIRUDQ\WKLQJIURP\RXRUDQ\RQH HOVH¶&KDUOLHVKLYHUHGµ1RZLI\RXFDUHWROHDYH,FDQFORVHWKHGRRU LQWKHNQRZOHGJHWKDW,KDYHQ¶WVODPPHGWKHGRRULQ\RXUIDFHZLWKRXW \RXUNQRZLQJLW¶VDERXWWRKDSSHQ¶ +HOXQJHGKLVIRRWRQWKHVWHSWKHGRRUDEUXSWO\KDOWHG PLGFORVXUHµ7KHWUXWKEHLQJ,¶PWRREXV\IRUSOD\LQJJDPHVEXWLI \RXLQVLVWXSRQDVLJQRIVLQFHULW\IRUP\SDUW¶KHVDLGVOLGLQJD OHDWKHUFODGKDQGIURPKHUNQHHWRXSSHUWKLJKµWKHQPD\EHWKLVLV SURRIHQRXJK"¶ &KDUOLHZDQWHGWRUHVLVWZDQWHGWRWHOOKLPWRJRWRKHOOZDQWHG WRSXVKKLPDZD\DQGVODPWKHGRRUWLJKWVKXWDQGEROWLW%XWVKH FRXOGQ¶WDQ\PRUHWKDQVKHFRXOGUHVLVWKLVPRXWKWDNLQJSRVVHVVLRQ RIKHUOLSV/XNHKDGZDONHGULJKWRXWRIKHUQLJKWPDUHVRIODWHEXW FRXOGKHLQGHHGEH5HIOH[PDQ"+DGKHUVHOIDQG3DXODEHHQGXSHG ERWKZDONLQJLQWRDFDUHIXOO\ODLGWUDS" 6KHUDOOLHGWRUHVLVWDQFHKLVKDQGVOLGLQJLQWRKHUGHOWDWRR GDPQVH[\DQGSXVKHGKLPDZD\ +HODXJKHGVWHSSHGEDFN µ4XLWHWKHZDUULRUZRPDQ,PXVWVD\EXW\RX¶OOEHEDFNIRU PRUHRIWKHVDPHZKHQJLYHQWKHRSSRUWXQLW\¶ µ'RQ¶WKROG\RXUEUHDWK¶ 

µ,ZRQ¶WQHHGWR¶ +HWXUQHGDZD\JRQHLQWKHEOLQNRIDQH\H $WWHQPLQXWHVSDVWSP&KDUOLHDQG3DXODDOLJKWHGIURPDWD[L WKHFDEGULYHUXQDEOHWRDYHUWKLVH\HVIURPWKHLUUHVSHFWLYHRXWILWV µ3XVVLQERRWVWRQLJKWLVLW"¶7KHFDEE\KDOIFKXFNOHGSURFHHGHG WREULHIWKHPRQHDUOLHUDUULYDOVVDIHO\GHOLYHUHGE\KLPVHOIWRWKHYHU\ VDPHDGGUHVVµ%URXJKWDJHH]HUKHUHDZKLOHEDFNDQGWDONDERXW VWXGLQKDUQHVV¶+HWKHQWRRNDORQJGUDJRQDKDOIVPRNHGFLJDUHWWH µ,WKRXJKW,¶GVHHQLWDOOWLOOWKDW\RXQJFRFNDKRRWVWUXWWHGRIIZLWKD JLUOKROGLQJDOHDVKDWWDFKHGWRDFROODU:KDWLVLWZLY\RXNLGV WRGD\"¶ 3DXODDPXVHGE\KLVFRPPHQWKDOIJLJJOHGµ0RUHWKHPDFKR PDQ\RXUVHOIDUH\RX"¶ µ1DKQRWUHDOO\:LIHZHDUVWKHSDQWVLQRXUKRXVH¶+HORRNHG WR&KDUOLHVWDQGLQJDWDGLVWDQFHDOUHDG\JD]LQJXSDWEULJKWO\OLW ZLQGRZVRQWKHVHFRQGIORRURIDODUJHWHUUDFHGGRXEOHIURQWHGKRXVH FXUOHGEXOOZKLSFOXWFKHGLQKDQGµ0LQG\RXFRXOGTXLWHIDQF\ ZHDULQJDOHDVKIRUKHU¶ 

µ:KDWPDNHV\RXVD\WKDW"¶DVNHG3DXODIROORZLQJZLWKµ7KDW¶VD EXOOZKLSQRWDGRJOHDG¶ +HDOPRVWFKRNHGFRXJKHGFOHDUHGKLVWKURDWµ3ULQFLSDOER\VLQ SDQWRPLPHVZDVDOZD\VIDVFLQDWLQJIRU\RXQJER\V:KDWZLY ZDWFKLQ¶ZRPHQNLVVZRPHQDQ¶WKHPORQJERRWVWKH\ZRUH %XOOZKLS"*HWDZD\ZLY\D,¶PRIIWKHQ6HH\D GDUOLQ¶ 3DXODWXUQHGWRZDUG&KDUOLHWKHWD[LDOUHDG\PRYLQJDZD\µ
µ1LNRVKRXOGDOUHDG\EHLQVLGH¶VKHUHPDUNHGµ7KLVLVWKHELJ RQH&KDUOLH0DNHWKHPRVWRI\RXUVHOIIRUWRQLJKW\RX¶OOPHHWPRUH PRQH\WKDQ\RX¶YHVHHQLQDORQJZKLOH¶ µ/LWHUDOO\RUPHWDSKRULFDOO\VSHDNLQJ"¶ µ7KHUH¶VERXQGWREHDVODYHDXFWLRQ¶ µ
µ)RUJHWLW¶VDLG&KDUOLHJODULQJDWKHUVLVWHUµ


µ8SPDUNHWKRRNHUV7KHOLNH\RX¶OOPHHWLQVLGHDORQJZLWKVRPH RIWKHLUFOLHQWV:KDWWKHKHOOGRHVLWPDWWHU"$WOHDVWZHNQRZDVGR RXUIULHQGVWKDWZKDWZHGRLVIRUIXQQRWIRUILQDQFLDOJDLQ¶ 3DXOD¶VVRDSER[UHQGLWLRQZDVEURXJKWWRDQHUXSWHQGDVWKH KRVWHVVJUHHWHGKHUZLWKEDUHO\DSHFNWRKHUOHIWFKHHN:HDULQJDUHG UXEEHUPLQLGUHVVODFHGGRZQWKHIURQWZKLFKOHIWOLWWOHWRWKH LPDJLQDWLRQWKHKRVWHVV¶PDQQHUZDVWKDWRIDGUDPDGLYD µ'DUOLQJ¶VKHJXVKHGDW3DXODDOXNHZDUPVPLOHµ
µ6KDPHRQ\RXIRUFKHDWLQJ¶SXUUHGWKHKRVWHVV6KHPRYHGLQ IRUDFORVHUORRNDWEHDXWLIXOO\FUDIWHG9LFWRULDQDFOLSRQHDUULQJV DGDSWHGDVQLSSOHULQJVµ6R1LNRKDVQ¶WVWDNHGKLVFODLPRIILFLDOO\"¶ µ1RWLQDQ\FRQYHQWLRQDOVHQVHRIRZQHUVKLS¶ =DUDLPPHGLDWHO\ORRNHGEH\RQG3DXODWR&KDUOLHDQRWLFHDEOH YHLOHGH[SUHVVLRQRIGLVDSSRLQWPHQW6KH¶GDOUHDG\DSSUDLVHGWKH EODFNOHDWKHUFODGDWWLUHZRUQE\DUHFRJQLVDEOHGRPPHDQGQRWKLQJ DERXW&KDUOLH¶VVWDQFHVXJJHVWHGDQLQNOLQJRIVXVFHSWLELOLW\WR DSSURDFKIURPDQRWKHUGRPPHLQDQ\VH[XDOVHQVH6KHKDGEHHQ ZDUQHGHQURXWHWKDW0DGDP=DUDSUHIHUUHGEHLQJGRPLQDQWZLWK RWKHUZRPHQZKLOHUHQRZQHGIRUVXEPLWWLQJWRDQ\PDQZLWKOLWWOHRU QRIRUHSOD\UHVLVWDQFHPRUHVRLIWKHUHZDUGLQDPRQHWDU\VHQVHZDV VXEVWDQWLDO µ$QG\RXUFRPSDQLRQ"¶VKHTXHULHGVHHPLQJO\DWDGGLVWXUEHG E\&KDUOLH¶VSUHVHQFH µ6RVRUU\,VKRXOGKDYHLQWURGXFHG\RXILUVW¶UHWXUQHG3DXOD QRWLFHDEO\DZDUHRIDQRWKHUJXHVWSHHULQJDORQJWKHKDOOµ0HHW &RXQWHVV'DQWHDµ6KHIDOWHUHGKDGDOPRVWVDLG6LVEHIRUH JHVWXULQJWRZDUG&KDUOLHµ7KLVLV0DGDP=DUD¶FRQFOXGHG3DXODDV LI&KDUOLHZRXOGKDYHJXHVVHGRWKHUZLVH 

&KDUOLHH[FKDQJHGQLFHWLHVDWWKHVDPHWLPHVHQVLQJWKHKRVWHVV IODLOLQJLQEHFDOPHGZDWHUVOLNHZLQGOHVVVDLOV6KHZDVXQVXUH ZKHWKHU3DXOD¶VUHIHUHQFHWRFRXQWHVVPHDQWDQ\WKLQJPRUHWKDQLW ZDVDOXGLFURXVWLWOHLQOLNHIDVKLRQWRZRUNLQJGRPLQDWUL[VHHNLQJ ZHDOWK\FOLHQWVZLOOLQJWRYHQWXUHLQWRHODERUDWHO\HTXLSSHGGXQJHRQV µ:HOO¶VLJKHGWKHKRVWHVVFOXWFKLQJ&KDUOLH¶VDUPDVVKHZDWFKHG 3DXODQHUYRXVO\ILGGOLQJZLWKDVWXGGHGFROODUµ,WKLQNLW¶VWLPH, LQWURGXFHGWKH&RXQWHVV'DQWHDWRP\RWKHUJXHVWV7KH\¶OOEH GHOLJKWHGDQGFKDUPHG,¶PVXUH$QGLI,¶PQRWEHLQJGXSHGKHUH WKHFRXQWHVVLVQRZRUNLQJJLUO¶=DUDWKHQJODQFHGWRZDUGDPDOH JXHVWQRZVWDQGLQJPLGKDOOZD\ZKLFKDPXVHG&KDUOLHDV=DUD SURIIHUHGµ
VHQVHRIGUDPDWLFIODLUµ$GHOLJKWIXOVXUSULVHPD¶DPDQGQR ERG\JXDUGWRSURWHFW\RX7KHQDJDLQPRUHEHILWWLQJIRUD FKDXIIHXUFXPERG\JXDUGWRSDWLHQWO\ZDLWZLWKWKHOLPRXVLQHXQWLO PDGDPUHTXLUHVKLVVHUYLFHVFRUUHFW"¶ &KDUOLHUHVSRQGHGZLWKDVHGXFWLYHVPLOHµ1LNR,SUHVXPH"¶ 7KHXQNQRZQPDQEHIRUHKHUKLVIDFHPDVNHGZLWKDOHDWKHUKRRG ZDVXQGRXEWHGO\KDQGVRPHKD]HOH\HVVWXG\LQJKHUVLQWHQWO\DQG VRPHZKDWGLVWUDFWLQJ6KHTXLWHXQGHUVWRRG3DXOD¶VLQWHUHVWLQVXFKD SUHGDWRU\FUHDWXUHDQGVRPHWKLQJDERXW1LNRVHWDODUPEHOOVULQJLQJ &KDXIIHXU":K\ZRXOGKHPHQWLRQDFKDXIIHXUDVDPHDQVRI LQWURGXFWRU\FKLWFKDW" µ6SRWRQRKEHDXWLIXORQH¶KHUHSOLHGJXHVVLQJVKHKDGEHHQ WKRURXJKO\GHEULHIHGE\3DXOD+HOHDQHGKLVPXVFXODUERG\ZHLJKW DJDLQVWWKHZDOODQH[WHQGHGDUPVWLOOEDUULQJIRUZDUGDGYDQFHµ7LPH HQRXJKIRUDFRQWHVWEHWZHHQRSSRVLQJLIPXWXDOO\LQWHUHVWHGSDUWLHV¶ &KDUOLHJDWKHUHGKHUVHOIIRUUHWDOLDWRU\RIIHQVLYHKLVH\HVKDUGO\ ILWWLQJ5HIOH[PDQ¶VSHUVRQDOLVHGGHVFULSWLRQEXWKDGQ¶WVKHWKRXJKWLQ WHUPVRI5HIOH[PDQDVEHLQJD4XDVLPRGRZKRHPSOR\HGKDQGVRPH EDLWWKRXJK/XNHZDVQR4XDVLPRGRHLWKHU"1LNRKDGWREHWKHEDLW RUZDVVKHOHWWLQJKHULPDJLQDWLRQUXQULIH"$Q\ZD\DV3DXOD¶VORYHU 1LNRKDGWREHLQWKHNQRZDERXW5HIOH[PDQ 

µ&KDXIIHXU",IRQO\¶VKHVDLGDFKDOOHQJLQJJOLQWLQKHUJUHHQ H\HVµ
1LNRDFTXLHVFHGDOORZLQJDOOWKUHHODGLHVWRSDVVKLPE\D ZKLVSHUHGFRPPHQWLQ&KDUOLH¶VHDUWKRXJKGHDGO\FKDUPLQJWRVD\ WKHOHDVW µ,IWKHFRXQWHVVWDVWHVDVJRRGDVVKHORRNVVKHFRXOGKDYH1LNR RQKLVNQHHVEHIRUHWKHQLJKWLVRXW¶ &KDUOLHVPLOHGDPXVHGE\DFKDOOHQJHWKDWH[SUHVVHGVH[XDO XQGHUWRQHV$VIDUDVVKHZDVFRQFHUQHG1LNRZDV3DXOD¶VDQGYLFH YHUVDDQGKHUVLVWHU¶VSUHVHQWZLOIXOJDPHSOD\VKHLPDJLQHGDV QRWKLQJPRUHWKDQDSOHDIRUFRPPLWPHQWIURPWKHPDQVKHKDGIDOOHQ LQORYHZLWK +DG3DXODWKRXJKIDOOHQLQORYH" &KDUOLHKDGKHUGRXEWVDVWRZKHWKHU3DXODFRXOGHYHUEHWUXO\ FRPPLWWHGEH\RQGUROHSOD\LQJKHUFDUHHUDOZD\VWKHGULYLQJIRUFHRI KHUYHU\H[LVWHQFH1HLWKHUGLGVKHYLVXDOLVH1LNRDVWKDWVLQFHUHQRW ZLWKDZLIHDQGIDPLO\QHDWO\WXFNHGDZD\&KDUOLHKDGORQJVLQFH JLYHQXSWU\LQJWRIDWKRP3DXOD¶VLQVWDQWLQIDWXDWLRQZKHQXQGHUWKH VSHOORIDQHZPDVWHURUKRZVKHDFTXLUHGVRPDQ\RIGLIIHULQJ DSSHDUDQFHDVWKRXJKQRVSHFLILFLGHDOHQWHUHGLQWRWKHHTXDWLRQ 0RPHQWVODWHUEHILWWLQJO\LQWURGXFHGWRDURRPIXORIJXHVWV &KDUOLHQRWLFHG3DXODWU\LQJWRVQHDNLQZLWKRXWGUDZLQJWRRPXFK DWWHQWLRQWRKHUVHOI$EOXHH\HGEORQGHZRPDQRIDURXQGWKLUW\LVK 

VXGGHQO\OHDSWWRKHUIHHWHPLWWLQJDVFUHHFKRIGHOLJKW6KHWKHQ WRWWHUHGDFURVVLQEODFNVWLOHWWRJUDQQ\ERRWVDWWLUHGLQDEODFNUXEEHU PLQLVNLUWWKHGHSWKRIDFXUWDLQSHOPHWWRSSHGRIIZLWKDUXEEHU ERREWXEHDQGDVVRUWPHQWRIILQHOLQNHGFKDLQVDWWDFKHGWRDVWXGGHG FROODU µ2K3DXOD\RXURXWILW¶VKHVTXHDOHGQRWKLQJOHVVWKDQDVLUHQWR VXUURXQGLQJHDUVQRWWRPHQWLRQWKHLQVWDQWDQHRXVPDJQHWLFOXUHRI 3DXOD¶VVFDQWLO\FODGIRUPWRDOOH\HVZLWKLQWKHURRPµ'DUOLQJLW¶V GHOHFWDEOH¶ 3DXODSURYRFDWLYHO\VZD\HGKHUSHUWEUHDVWVWRHQVXUHWKH 9LFWRULDQDDPHWK\VWHQFUXVWHGGURSOHWVFDXJKWWKHEORQGH¶VHDJHUO\ DSSUDLVLQJH\HVµ/LNHWKHP"¶ µ8KKXK¶PXUPXUHGWKHEORQGH6KHWKHQOHDQHGIRUZDUGUDVSHG KHUWRQJXHVDODFLRXVO\DURXQGDEXUJHRQHGRUELQDEULHIPRPHQWRI VH[XDOKHDWIRUDQRWKHUZRPDQµ,¶PJRLQJWREHSXQLVKHGIRU GHVHUWLQJP\PDVWHU¶VODSµVKHVDLGDTXLFNJODQFHEHKLQGWRVHHKLP DGYDQFLQJFDQHLQKDQGµEXWLWZDVZRUWKLW¶'HILDQWVKH SURYRFDWLYHO\ZLJJOHGKHUERWWRPDSRUN\ORRNLQJEDOGKHDGHGPDQ LQOHDWKHUWURXVHUVDQGEODFNVLONVKLUWDOPRVWXSRQKHUµ2KORUG\ KH¶VIXULRXV6WLOOPLJKWMXVWDVZHOOJRWKHZKROHKRJ¶ 

&KDUOLHVDZWKHIXQQ\VLGHRIWKHEORQGH¶VVZLIWHPEUDFHRI 3DXODWKHHQVXLQJHURWLFLPDJHRIWZRZRPHQVDODFLRXVO\PRXWKWR PRXWKVHHPLQJO\HQMR\HGE\PRVWRIWKRVHZDWFKLQJZLWKWKH REYLRXVH[FHSWLRQRIWKHHQUDJHGPDOHVWDQGLQJEHKLQGZLWKDVRXU H[SUHVVLRQ$KHIW\VODSVZLIWO\DQGDFFXUDWHO\DSSOLHGWRWKHEORQGH¶V VOHQGHUEXWWRFNVEURXJKWKHUXSVKDUS6KHLPPHGLDWHO\XQKDQGHG 3DXODDQGGURSSHGWRKHUNQHHVJURYHOOLQJDWKHUPDVWHU¶VIHHW µ3OHDVHPDVWHU1DXJKW\WKDW,DP,EHJWKDW\RXVHHILWWRH[FXVH PHWKLVRQHLQGXOJHQFH3OHDVHGRQ¶WSXQLVKPH¶ µ)RUJLYH\RXVOXW"+RZGDUH\RXHYHQDWWHPSWWRGLVVXDGHPH IURPDGPLQLVWHULQJGXHSXQLVKPHQWIRUVXFKRXWUDJHRXVEHKDYLRXU ZLWKDQRWKHUVODYH¶ µ%XWPDVWHU¶SOHDGHGWKHEORQGHNLVVLQJKLVVKLQ\SDWHQWERRWV µ
µ1REXWVVODYH¶KHVQDSSHGSXOOLQJDFKDLUFOHDURIWKHGLQLQJ WDEOHVXLWDEO\ODGHQZLWKVDYRXU\QLEEOHVDQGVZHHWPHDWVµ3UHSDUH \RXUVHOI¶ 7KHEORQGHTXLFNO\GUDSHGKHUVHOIRYHUWKHVHDWKHUEXWWRFNV ZULJJOLQJDVVKHVWUXJJOHGWRHDVHWKHUXEEHUPLQLVNLUWFOHDURIKHU URXQGHGPRRQV3URVWUDWHUHDG\IRUDVVDXOWXSRQNQLFNHUOHVVIOHVK VKHVDLG µ6SDUHPHPDVWHU3OHDVH,EHJRI\RX¶ µ6SDUH\RXVOXW"%\-RYH,¶OOWKUDVK\RXUEHDXWLIXOKLGHXQWLO MXVWO\YLQGLFDWHGIRUVXFKZDQWRQEHWUD\DORIP\WUXVW¶ $VEORZDIWHUEORZUDLQHGGRZQRQEDUHGHUULqUHWKHEORQGH HPLWWHGJDVSVWKHQSDLQIXOFULHVDVWKRXJKVXIIHULQJWHUULEOHDJRQ\ 'HVSLWHVHHPLQJGLVWUHVVQRWDWHDUZDVHYLGHQWVRIWPHZLQJWKHRQO\ VRXQGZKHQKHUSXQLVKPHQWZDVILQDOO\RYHU,WZDVSDWHQWWRDOOWKDW PDVWHUDQGVODYHZHUHPRUHWKDQDZDUHWKDWRQORRNHUVKDGVZHOOHGLQ QXPEHULQGHHGDYHU\VROLFLWRXVDXGLHQFHWKHSHUIRUPDQFHKDYLQJ VHWWKHSDUW\LQPRWLRQEH\RQGPHUHVRFLDOLVLQJ &KDUOLHGLVFUHHWO\JODQFHGDURXQGWKHDVVHPEOHGQRWLFHGKDQGV ZDQGHULQJFDUHVVLQJWHDVLQJPRPHQWDU\H[FKDQJHRINLVVHVEHWZHHQ SDUWQHUV:KDWVKHGLGQ¶WVHHZDVDPDQPRYLQJLQWRDVKDGRZ\ FRUQHUKLVH\HVZDWFKLQJKHUHYHU\PRYHPHQW 

0HDQZKLOHWKHEDOGLQJSDXQFKRUGHUHGKLVEORQGHVODYHWR JDWKHUDSODWHRIWDVW\QLEEOHVIROORZHGE\EXOOLVKFRPPDQGµ0DNH WKDWRUGHUXSZLWKDJODVVRIFKDPSDJQHIRUWZR¶+HZDGGOHGRYHU WRZDUG3DXOD1LNRE\QRZVWDQGLQJQH[WWRKHUµ$KP\VZHHW RQH¶SURIIHUHGWKHEDOGLQJSDXQFK1LNR¶VFORVHSUR[LPLW\VHHPLQJO\ RIOLWWOHRUQRFRQVHTXHQFHµ&RPHWRGDGG\¶ µ
HQJDJHPHQWZLWKLQWKH%'60VFHQHRUWKRXJKWKLPVHOIEH\RQGWKH UHDOPVRIIDQWDV\JDPHSOD\ZKHQLWVXLWHGKLVSXUSRVH µ6ODYH3DXODZLOORQO\GRDV,ELG¶VDLG&KDUOLHOD\LQJDKDQGRQ 3DXOD¶VDUP 7KHEDOGLQJSDXQFKIDOWHUHGKLVDWWHQWLRQFHQWUHGRQ1LNRDV WKRXJK&KDUOLHZDVWRWDOO\XQDSSUHFLDEOHµ


$PXVHG&KDUOLHOHWKHUFRLOHGEXOOZKLSXQIXUOIURPDURXQGKHU ZULVWµ
FRPHKHUZD\DQGPD\EHHYHQKHUSUHVHQWFRQWULEXWLRQZRXOGEH FDVWDVLGHLQIDYRXURIDPRUHUHWLFHQWPLQGHGSHUVRQDJH 3DXODWKHQVDLGµ+H¶VDGLUHFWRULQQDPHRQO\DQG,FDQDVVXUH ERWKRI\RXKHKDVQRFORXWZLWKLQ/XNH¶VGRPDLQ¶ µ%XW,WKRXJKW¶UHWXUQHGWKHKRVWHVVDV&KDUOLHFXWDFURVVKHU ERZVDWIXOOVWHDP µ,IXQIDPLOLDUZLWKWKHVWDWXVTXRRIDQ\RQHERDUGURRPEHVWWR SOHDGLJQRUDQFHZRXOGQ¶W\RXVD\"¶ 7KHVPLOHEHVWRZHGXSRQ&KDUOLHERUHPDOLFHDNLQWRFODZV H[WHQGHGDQGPHWDSKRULFDOVODVKLQJRIIDFLDOIOHVKWKHKRVWHVV¶WRQH RIYRLFHDGHFHSWLYHNLWWHQOLNHSXUU µ:RXOGWKH&RXQWHVVEHVRJUDFLRXVDVWRDOORZ6ODYH3DXODD PRPHQWRUWZRLQP\FRPSDQ\"¶ µ$V\RXDVNHGVRQLFHO\\HV2QRQHFRQGLWLRQ¶DGGHG &KDUOLHµVRORQJDV\RXUHPDLQZLWKLQWKLVURRP¶ =DUDOHDGLQJ3DXODRXWRIVLJKWSHUKDSVKRSHIXOO\RXWRIPLQG IRUDFRQVLGHUDEO\ORQJHUWLPHVSDQZDVQRZXQOLNHO\3DXODORRNHG UHODWLYHO\LQDWWHQWLYHKHUH\HVFHQWUHGRQ1LNRVWDQGLQJQHDUWRWKH WDEOHDQGVHHPLQJO\PRUHLQWHUHVWHGLQWKHGHOLJKWVRIILOOLQJKLV VWRPDFKEXWDV=DUDJUDEEHGKHUKDQGDQGOHGRII&KDUOLHJRWWKH 

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µ,UDWKHUJDWKHUHGWKH&RXQWHVV¶FKDXIIHXUZRXOGKDYHWRZHDU WUDGLWLRQDODSSDUHO6RPHZKDWVXJJHVWLYHRIWKH7KLUG5HLFKKLJKO\ SROLVKHGERRWV¶QDOO"¶ µ$VWXWHREVHUYDWLRQ¶VKHUHSOLHGGHOLEHUDWHO\OHDQLQJEDFNZDUG LQDSRVHRIDFFHSWDQFHWRKLVXQGLYLGHGDWWHQWLRQV¶FRQVLGHULQJPHUH EULHIH[FKDQJHVLQSDVVLQJ¶ (YHU\PRYHPHQWDQGHYHU\ZRUGVSRNHQE\1LNRKDGDOUHDG\ FRQMXUHGYLVLRQVRIDOLPRXVLQHKHUVHOIZLWKOHJVVSUHDGHDJOHGRQLWV 

ERQQHWKLVKHDGEXULHGEHWZHHQKHUWKLJKV6KHIHOWLIVKHWXUQHG DURXQGULJKWQRZVKHZRXOGLQGHHGEHORRNLQJLQWRVPRXOGHULQJ GDUNEURZQH\HVEXWWKLVZDVQRPDVWHURIFKDWURRPIDQWDV\7KLV ZDV1LNRDQG1LNRKDGKD]HOH\HVPRUHJUHHQWKDQEURZQ  32IDFHKDVSRZHUDQGZLOOVWRSDWQRWKLQJWRSUHYHQW\RXU JHWWLQJDQ\IXUWKHUDVVLJQPHQWVRQWKHPDJ

&KDUOLHSRSSHGKHUSODWHGRZQUDLVHGJODVVWROLSVDQG QRQFKDODQWO\VLSSHGZLQH6KHWKHQVOLGKHUIUHHKDQGEHKLQGKHU EDFN1LNRJURDQHGPRUHWKDQDSSUHFLDWLYHRIILQJHUVVWURNLQJWKH RXWOLQHRIKLVHQJRUJHGWKUREELQJOLIHIRUFH  7KDW VEHORZWKHEHOWEXWGHFLGHGO\SOHDVXUDEOH

 1RWKDOIDVZLFNHGDV,FDQEH%XWVHHLQJDV\RXGHULYHSOHDVXUH IURPLWWKHQ,VHHQRSRLQWLQFRQWLQXLQJWKLVLQWLPDWHOLDLVRQ 6KH SLFNHGXSKHUSODWHWXUQHGDQGJODUHGDWKLVJUHHQH\HV 1LNRVWHSSHGDVLGHZLWKDEURDGJULQDQGZDWFKHG&KDUOLHPDNHKHU ZD\WRZDUG3DXOD+HFRXOGZDLW7KHQLJKWZDV\RXQJ\HWDQGKH QHHGHGWRZRUNRXWDVWUDWHJLFSODQWROXUHWKLVRQHLQWRDIDOVHVHQVH RIVHFXULW\SOXVSDUW\JRHUVKDGVWDUWHGDUULYLQJLQHDUQHVWDQGWKH 

KRXVHZDVVXGGHQO\DOLYHZLWKIHPDOHVDQGLWORRNHGDSURPLVLQJ QLJKW $VPDOOFORFNRQDPDQWHODERYHDERDUGHGXSILUHSODFHVWUXFN WZHOYHPLGQLJKWWKHFKLPHVDXGLEOHRQO\WRWKRVHVWDQGLQJQHDUE\ :DVLWSRVVLEOHWRVOLQNDZD\KDLODWD[LDQGYDQLVKLQWRWKHQLJKW" &KDUOLHRKVRZLVKHGVKHFRXOGGRMXVWWKDW 7KHJRLQJVRQLQWKHURRPHQWHUWDLQLQJHQRXJKDVDPDVTXHUDGH RIVRUWVWKRXJKQRFULHVRI³KH¶VEHKLQG\RX´LQJRRGROGSDQWR VW\OH1HYHUWKHOHVVDIHZZRPHQSUHVHQWYHU\GHILQLWHO\KDGWKDWKH¶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

URXQGHGPRRQVDOUHDG\JORZLQJIURPDWKRURXJKVSDQNLQJ EHIRUHKDQG $ORXGFKHHUIURPDFURVVWKHURRPWKHQVWROH&KDUOLH¶V DWWHQWLRQ6KHPRYHGDOLWWOHFORVHUWRDFUHVFHQWRIRQORRNHUVDOORI ZKRPZHUHPHQDQGLPPHGLDWHO\PDGHZD\IRUKHUDQGRWKHUVWR ZLWQHVVORQJVOLPOHJVVSUHDGZLGHWRUHYHDOIOXVKHGIHPDOHJHQLWDOLD 6KHVHQVHGVRPHRQHEUXVKLQJDJDLQVWKHUWXUQHGVOLJKWO\PLJKW\ WKDQNIXOWKDWLWZDVRQO\=DUDQRW1LNRHGJLQJDORQJVLGH 7KHKRVWHVVVPLOHGZLWKDZLFNHGJOLQWLQKHUH\H ,WZRQ¶WEH ORQJEHIRUHWKHERVVPDQZLOODVNIRUDZRPDQWRVDPSOHWKDW VXFFXOHQWVOLW

µ5HDOO\"

 $EVROXWHO\DQG,¶PILUVWLQOLQH¶  ,WDNHLW\RX YHDOUHDG\VWUXFNDGHDOWKHQ"

 ,ZRXOGQ¶WSXWLWTXLWHOLNHWKDW7KHZKROHHYHQLQJLQDQ\FDVH LVVRPHZKDWPDNHEHOLHYH¶=DUDUDQKHUWRQJXHDFURVVORZHUOLSKHU WHHWKJOLVWHQLQJDOPRVWYDPSLUHOLNHWKHQHPEHOOLVKHGIRUHIIHFWµ6KH ORRNHGVRKRQH\GHZVZHHWRQDUULYDODQGLWLVDKRVWHVV¶SUHURJDWLYH WRUHDSDUHZDUGIRUKDYLQJSURYLGHGDGHQIRUIHOORZ%'60 EHQGHUV¶ 

&KDUOLHVWXGLHGWKHKDUVKO\GHILQHGEHDNOLNHQRVHRIWKHPDVWHU LQIXOOUHOLVKRIPLON\ZKLWHWKLJKVVWUHWFKHGRYHUKLVNQHHVHDJOHOLNH H\HVLQJHVWLQJHYHU\VWURNHGHOLYHUHGXSRQEDUHIOHVK\EXWWRFNV +H V DZHLJKW\ORRNLQJJX\

=DUD¶VH\HVQDUURZHGDVLILQDGPLUDWLRQ 4&GDUOLQJ7KHEHVW PRQH\FDQEX\)RUPLGDEOHSURVHFXWLRQFRXQFLODSSDUHQWO\

 ,QDQGRXWRIFRXUWE\WKHORRNRIWKDWSURELQJILQJHU¶UHPDUNHG &KDUOLHµ+HFRXOGVRHDVLO\SDVVDVDPHGLFDOPDQ

 +HLVTXLWHWKRURXJK JLJJOHG=DUDµ&DQ\RXLPDJLQHZKDWLW PXVWEHOLNHZKHQKHKROGVRQHRIKLVFRXUWURRPGUDPDSDUWLHV"¶ µ
WKRXJKQHYHURQFHFHDVHGKHUDVVDXOWXSRQKLVVODYHZKLOHKHLQWXUQ KHH[SORUHGDQ\YDFDQWRULILFHZLWKLQKLVUHDFK=DUD¶VXOWLPDWHSUL]H FDPHLQQRWLPHDWDOODVWKHRWKHUZRPDQ VERG\TXLYHUHGEHQHDWK DPLGVWFULHVWHVWDPHQWWRRUJDVPLFEOLVV  &HDVHSOHDVXULQJKHULPPHGLDWHO\ FRPPDQGHGHDJOHH\HZKLOH YLJRURXVO\WKUXVWLQJDILQJHULQDQGRXWRI=DUD¶VSXFNHUHGDQDOOLSV +LVVODYHPHDQWLPHZKLPSHUHG 3OHDVH0DVWHUQRPRUHRIWKLV, FDQQRWFDQQRWHQGXUH

(DJOHH\HJODQFHGWRZDUGDPLVWUHVVVWDQGLQJQHDUE\DPDOH VODYHRQKLVNQHHVEHVLGHKHUDOHDGDWWDFKHGWRDVWXGGHGFROODU µ%ULQJKLPIRUZDUG0DGDPLI\RXZLOODQGOHWXVSDUWDNHRI JRRGVSRUWLQJSOD\¶ :KLOH=DUDSDLGQRKHHGWRWKHIHPDOHVODYH¶VSOHDVIRUPHUF\ KHUPDVWHUVXUYH\HGWKHVOHQGHUIRUPRIWKHHDJHUPDOHVODYHDOOWKH ZKLOHDJOHDPLQKLVH\HVGHQRWLQJKHLJKWHQHGVH[XDODURXVDO 7KHPDOHVODYHWR&KDUOLH¶VZD\RIWKLQNLQJKDGDSSHDOLQJEOXH H\HVUHIOHFWLYHRIER\LVKLQQRFHQFHKLVOHDQPXVFOHGORLQVPLVVWDWLQJ ZKROHVRPHPDQZLWKLQ%XWZRXOGWKHPLVWUHVVDFFHSWHDJOHH\H¶V WHQGHUHGVSRUWRISXWWLQJKHUVODYHWRZRUNIRUKLP"(DJOHH\H REYLRXVO\WKRXJKWVRIRUKHVODSSHG=DUDVPDUWO\XSRQKHUEDFNVLGH 

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¶VIDFHDV RIWKDWPLUURUHGLQOLWWOHVLVWHU¶VJOLWWHULQJJUH\H\HV%LJVLVWHU JXHVVHG3DXOD¶VFRUHZRXOGEHEXUQLQJGHHSZLWKLQPRUHVRZKHQWKH PDOHVODYHVKXIIOHGLQWRSRVLWLRQIRUWKHPRXQWLQJFHUHPRQ\6KH TXLWHEHOLHYHGVKHVDZ3DXODKROGLQJKHUEUHDWKWKHVODYH¶VHQJRUJHG 

SKDOOXVEUXVKLQJXSDJDLQVWWKHIHPDOHVODYH VYDJLQDOFDYLW\DOPRVW WRRPXFKWREHDU6KHIHOWVXUHWKDWLISODFHGLQWKDWVDPHSUHGLFDPHQW 3DXODZRXOGEHEHJJLQJWREHVSDUHGVXFKSXEOLFKXPLOLDWLRQWKHUHE\ LQFLWLQJWKHZUDWKRIWKHPDVWHUWRH[SHGLWHLQVHUWLRQRIDJORULRXV NQREDOUHDG\JOLVWHQLQJZLWKSHDUOOLNHGHZGURSV $VWKHHDJOHVORZO\LQVHUWHGWKH\RXQJPDOHVODYH¶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¶WHYHQORRNXSWRVHHZKR ZDVEUXVKLQJSDVWWKHP&KDUOLHVHQVHGWKH\ZHUHVPRNLQJGHFLGHGO\ GRGJ\FLJDUHWWHVDVLFNO\VZHHWLQFHQVHZDIWLQJRQXSZDUGWKHUPDOV 6KHWKHQQRWLFHG/XF\VHDWHGRQWKHIURJ¶VODS7KH\ZHUHQHDUWR VHYHUDOFRXSOHVRQDODUJHVRIDNLVVLQJ2WKHUVFRXSOHVZHUHVDW 

DURXQGRQIORRUFXVKLRQVDQGJHQHUDOO\JURSLQJHDFKRWKHUDPLGVW DGROHVFHQWVJLJJOHV $V&KDUOLHPDGHKHUZD\DFURVVWRDVSDUHVHDWLQDGDUNHQHG FRUQHUVKHKDOIVWXPEOHGRYHUDQRXWVWUHWFKHGOHJ6KHVSHHGLO\ UHJDLQHGDVHQVHRIEDODQFHE\VXSSRUWLQJKHUVHOIRQWKHSHUVRQ¶VEHQW NQHH6KHWKHQWXUQHGWRDSRORJLVHDQGZLVKHGLWFRXOGKDYHEHHQ DQ\RQHDQ\RQHEXWWKHRQHPDQVKHKDGSUD\HGZRXOGQ¶WEHWKHUH +HODQJXLGO\H[KDOHGFLJDUVPRNHDOOWKHZKLOHORRNLQJKHULQ WKHH\HDQGWKHQJULQQHG  +DYHQ WZHEHHQKHUHEHIRUH"¶ &KDUOLHDERXWWRVD\VRUU\LQVWHDGVWUDLJKWHQHGKHUEDFN VWHSSHGRYHUKLVOHJDQGPDGHWRZDONDZD\ZLWKRXWDZRUGSDVVLQJ KHUOLSV2QHVHQWHQFHRQHGDPQVHQWHQFHDQGKHUKHDUWZDV SRXQGLQJOLNHDVFDUHGDQLPDOFDXJKWLQWKHJODUHRIKHDGOLJKWV$ VXGGHQJULSRQKHUOHIWZULVWSUHYHQWHGIXUWKHUIRUZDUGPRWLRQKLV YRLFHDLULQJLQGLJQDQWVFKRROPDVWHUO\WRQH 
6KHZUHQFKHGKHUZULVWIUHHDQGUHWDOLDWHGZLWK]HVW $WUXH JHQWOHPDQZRXOGDSRORJLVHSURIXVHO\IRUEHLQJVWUHWFKHGRXWOLNHD GHOLTXHQWORXW%XWQRW\RX2KQR\RXFRXOGQ¶WSRVVLEO\DGPLWWR EHLQJLQWKHZURQJFRXOG\RX"¶ 

+HFKXFNOHGDQGJUDEEHGKHUZULVWDJDLQ7KLVWLPHWKHUH ZDVQRHVFDSLQJDVKHSXOOHGKHUFORVHU
 /D\DILQJHURQPHDQGVRKHOSPH, OO¶  :KDWVODSP\IDFH"%XW\RXZRXOGQ¶WZRXOG\RX1RWPLQH

 :RXOGQ W,"

 1RWHYHQLI,NLVVHG\RX¶ µ7U\PH¶ µ'RQ WLQWHUUXSWOLNHDVSRLOWFKLOG &KDUOLHUDLVHGKHUIUHHKDQG LQUHDGLQHVVWRVWULNHKLVH[SUHVVLRQWKDWRIKLJKO\DPXVHGLQGLYLGXDO VROLFLWLQJIHPDOHZUDWK\HWKLVWRQHRIYRLFHVRPHZKDWWKUHDWHQLQJ

*RDKHDGDQGVHHZKDW\RXJHW +HSODFHGKLVFLJDUWRUHVWLQD QHDUE\DVKWUD\µ7KDW¶VEHWWHU¶KHDGGHGDVVKHORZHUHGKHUKDQG µ&RPHDQGEHQLFHWRPH¶ &KDUOLHKDGQRLQWHQWLRQRIEHLQJQLFHQRPDWWHUKRZORQJKH KHOGRQWRKHUKLVJULSWLJKWHUWKDQEHIRUH7RQRDYDLOVKHVWUXJJOHGDV KHKDXOHGKHULQWRKLVODS+LVVSHHG\DFWLRQH[FLWHGKHUEH\RQG EHOLHIDQGUHVLVWLQJWKHLQHYLWDEOHNLVVZDVLPSRVVLEOH,QWUXWKWKRXJK LWHQGHGDOOWRRVXGGHQO\IRU&KDUOLHEXWVKHGDUHGQRWOHW/XNHVHH GLVDSSRLQWPHQWHWFKHGRQKHUIDFHZKHQKHILQDOO\GHLJQHGWRUHOHDVH KLVKROG 

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¶WOHWJRFDQ


 /RRN0LVV¶ µ0V :DOWHUV VKHUHWRUWHGPRYLQJVOLJKWO\WRWKHVLGH  'R\RXZDQWDMRERUQRW"

6KHVWXGLHGKLVH\HVKHUVHOIUHQGHUHGVSHHFKOHVV+DGVKHKHDUG FRUUHFWO\RUZDVKHSOD\LQJJDPHV" +HOHDQHGIRUZDUGUHVWLQJKLVHOERZVRQKLVNQHHV :HOOGR \RX"



 ,GLGFRPHXSWR/RQGRQLQWKHKRSHRISLFNLQJXSVRPH IUHHODQFHZRUNRQWKHPDJ

 , PQRWWDONLQJDERXWWKHPDJD]LQH +HJHVWXUHGWRDIRRWVWRRO EHVLGHKLVFKDLUZKLVSHUHGµ6LWGRZQWKHUHLILWPDNHV\RXIHHOVDIHU WKDQRQP\NQHHDQGOLVWHQJRRG¶ 6KHVDWGRZQDVELGGHQ %XW,WKRXJKW   (YHU\RQHZRUNHGIRUWKDWOLWWOHSHUYHUWRYHUWKHUH"

&KDUOLHJODQFHGDFURVVDWWKHIURJVDODFLRXVO\GHYRXULQJRQHRI /XF\¶VQLSSOHV $UHQ WZHDOOSHUYHUWVKHUHWRQLJKW"

 7KDWDOOGHSHQGVRQKRZRQHSHUFHLYHVWKHZRUGSHUYHUW

 2K*RG\RXUHQRWJRLQJWRJLYHPHDOHFWXUHRQWKHLVVXHRI VWHUHRW\SLQJDUH\RX"

 2IFRXUVHQRW
 6XFKDV"

+HUHSODFHGWKHJODVVRQWKHFRUQHUWDEOHOHDQHGWRZDUGKHUDQG WKHQWRXFKHGKHUFKHHNZLWKKLVOHIWIRUHILQJHU $SURSRVLWLRQWKDW,¶P IDLUO\VXUH\RXZRQ¶WEHDEOHWRUHIXVH

 +RZGR\RXNQRZ,ZRQ W"

+HOHWKLVILQJHUFDUHVVKHUFKHHNERQH %HDWP\RIILFHDWWHQ SUHFLVHO\RQ0RQGD\7KDWLVLI\RXZDQWWRNQRZPRUH



+LVWRXFKZDVIRU&KDUOLHOLNHDOLJKWQLQJVWULNHKDYLQJEXUQWWKH LPDJHRIKLVILQJHULQWRKHUIOHVK%XWZKHQKLVOLSVEUXVKHGKHUVVKH KDGQRLQWHQWLRQRINHHSLQJWKHDSSRLQWPHQWQRPDWWHUKRZPXFKVKH QHHGHGVRPHWKLQJWRGR$MRE",IDVKHVDLGLWKDGQRWKLQJWRGRZLWK WKHPDJD]LQHZKDWVRUWRIMRE"+HWXUQHGDZD\JRWWRKLVIHHWDQGDV KHZDONHGIURPWKHURRP&KDUOLH VVXEFRQVFLRXVVFUHDPHGDWKHUWR ILQGRXWPRUHDERXWWKHSURSRVLWLRQEHIRUHKHOHIW 'DPQLWVKHKDGWRNQRZPRUH+HFRXOGQ¶WMXVWOHDYHKHU SRQGHULQJZKDWLWZDVWKDWKHKDGWRRIIHU"6KHPDGHKHUZD\RXWRI WKHURRPFRXOGKHDUKLPSOXQJLQJGRZQWKHVWDLUFDVHD³JRRGQLJKW´ KHUHDQGWKHUHDQG³OXQFKVRPHWLPH"´WRPL[HGJURXSVDVFHQGLQJ 6KHZDLWHGIRUWKHUHYHOOHUVWRUHDFKWKHVXPPLWDQGSDVVE\WKHQ GDVKHGDIWHUKLP%\WKHWLPHVKHUHDFKHGWKHIRRWRIWKHVWDLUFDVHWKH IURQWGRRUVODPPHGVKXW :HOOWKDWZDVWKDWWKHQ7RXJK ,QDQ\FDVHVKHPXVHGKHFDQVWLFNKLVMREZKHUHWKHVXQGRQ¶W VKLQH,GRQ¶WUHDOO\ZDQWDIXOOWLPHMRELQ/RQGRQ)UHHODQFLQJWKH RGGDUWLFOHRUWZRIURPKRPHVXLWVPHVRPXFKEHWWHU 6KHWKHQWXUQHGDQGHQWHUHGWKHGLQLQJURRP 1LNR VH\HVVSDUNOHGDVKHPRYHGWRZDUGKHULQDSUHGDWRU\ORSH VDLG 2QWKHZDQGHUORRNLQJIRUFRPSDQ\"



 1RWUHDOO\¶VKHDQVZHUHGSRVLQJDTXHU\µ:KHUH V3DXOD"

 ,QWKHNLWFKHQZLWK-DPHV

µ-DPHVZKR"

 $FORVHIULHQG2UDWOHDVWKHZLOOEH

&KDUOLHZDONHGVZLIWO\WRZDUGWKHNLWFKHQZLWKWKHIXOOLQWHQWLRQ RIEUXVKLQJSDVW1LNREXWVHQVHGWKDWWDFNDPLVWDNHWKHPRPHQWVKH GUHZOHYHO+HZDVVOLJKWO\WKHZRUVHIRUDOFRKRODQGRQHWKLQJRQKLV PLQG+HU 7KHSUHVVXUHRQKHUZULVWVKHOGQRVHQVHRISOHDVXUHDVKDG /XNH¶VJULSDQGZKHQ1LNRIRUFLEO\GUHZKHUWRDVWDQGVWLOOLQWKH GRRUZD\OHDGLQJWRWKHNLWFKHQVKHUHDOLVHGZKDWKHKDGPHDQWDERXW 3DXODDQG-DPHVEHLQJFORVHIULHQGV%RWKZHUHERXQGWRJHWKHUKHDG WRWRHRQWKHEUHDNIDVWEDUJURDQVHPLWWHGQRWKLQJOHVVWKDQUDSWXURXV RUJDVPLFPHORG\ 1LNRNLVVHG&KDUOLH VQHFNZKLOVWNHHSLQJDILUPJULSRQKHU ZULVWVWKHQVDLGLQDKXVKHGZKLVSHU )UHVKFUHDPVSUD\HGRQWRIOHVK DOZD\VGRHVWKHWULFN


&KDUOLHVWDUWHGZULJJOLQJYLROHQWO\LQWHQWRQUHOHDVLQJKHUVHOI IURPKLVFOXWFKHV7KHLQHYLWDEOHEDWWOHKDGFRPPHQFHGKLVDURXVHG 

VWDWHEHFRPLQJPRUHGDQJHURXVZLWKHYHU\KHDY\EUHDWKWDNHQ8QOLNH /XNH VFRROPDVWHUO\LILQGLIIHUHQWDSSURDFKVKHNQHZWKHUHZDVD SRVVLELOLW\WKDW1LNRZRXOGQ WWDNH1RIDUDQDQVZHU 6KHKHDUGKHUVHOIVD\LQJ 'RQ WGRWKLV1LNR\RX OOUHJUHWLWLQ WKHFROGOLJKWRIGD\¶ $ERYHWKHSRXQGLQJRIKHUKHDUWWKHVRXQGRIKHUERGLFH]LS VOLGLQJGRZQWKHUDWFKHWVZDV1LNRJRLQJWRRIDU6HQVHRISDQLFZDV RQHWKLQJVXGGHQO\DZDUHWKDWDQRWKHUPDOHKDQGZDVJHWWLQJ LQYROYHGGRZQULJKWVFDU\7KHQWKHUHZDVDVLFNHQLQJWKXGDV1LNR¶V KHDGVODPPHGDJDLQVWWKHGRRUMDPE+LVJULSPHDVXUDEO\VODFNHQHG DPLGVWEODVSKHPRXVRXWEXUVWDQG&KDUOLHVHQVHGWKHKDQGRIWKH XQNQRZQPDOHJUDVSLQJDURXQGKHUZDLVW6KHZDVVXGGHQO\VQDWFKHG IUHHIURP1LNR¶VFOXWFKHVWKHVWUDQJHUWKHQVSXQKHUDURXQGDQG SXOOHGKHUWRZDUGKLVOHDWKHUFODGWRUVR,WDOOKDSSHQHGLQPRWLRQEOXU DQGLWFURVVHGKHUPLQGLQDIODVKWKDWWKLVZDVZKDWLWZDVOLNHWREH 5DSHG"7ZRPHQDERXWWRVKDUHWKHERRW\" 1RZD\ZRXOGVKHJRGRZQZLWKRXWDYLFLRXVQDLOODVKLQJILJKW 6KHWKHQUHDOLVHGQRWKLQJDEVROXWHO\QRWKLQJZDVKDSSHQLQJ H[FHSWDKDQGKDGFODVSHGKHUKHDGILQJHUVWKUHDGLQJLQWRKHUKDLU 7KLVXQNQRZQSHUVRQKROGLQJKHUKHDGILUPO\DJDLQVWKLVWRUVRKDG QRWKLQJEXWKHUZHOIDUHLQPLQG 

$NLQGRIVHQVXDOUHOLHIPDGHKHUZDQWWRFOLQJWRWKHSURWHFWLYH ERG\HQYHORSLQJKHUV/XNH¶VYRLFHDEUDVLYH$VIDUDVKHZDV FRQFHUQHG1LNR¶VSULYDWHSDUW\IXQZDVRYHUDQG&KDUOLHZDVWUXO\ WKDQNIXOWKDWLWZDVQ¶W/XNHZKRKDGKDVWLO\GHSDUWHGWKURXJKWKH IURQWGRRUPRPHQWVEHIRUHKDQG $VKH]LSSHGXSWKHEDFNRIKHUOHDWKHUEDVTXHVKHIHOW ULGLFXORXVO\FKLOGOLNHDQGFRXOGRQO\PXVWHUDVKDN\µ7KDQNV¶  7RKHOOZLWKWHQR FORFN0RQGD\, OOWDNH\RXZLWKPHQRZMXVW DVVRRQDV, YHUHVFXHG\RXUVLVWHU

1LNRKDYLQJUHFRYHUHGIURPWKHVKRFNRI/XNH VDJJUHVVLRQ UHDFWHGE\EORFNLQJDQ\DGYDQFHE\KLVEURWKHUWRZDUG3DXODDQG ERRPHG 3DXODQHHGVQRZDQQDEHNQLJKWLQVKLQLQJDUPRXUWRVSRLO KHUIXQ +HGLUHFWHGKLVVHFRQGFRPPHQWDW&KDUOLHµ

H\HVPRFNLQJ&KDUOLH
&KDUOLHGLGQ WZDQWDQ\WKLQJDQGIHOWUDWKHUVLOO\DVVKHUHDOLVHG 1LNRKDGRQO\EHHQZLQGLQJKHUXS,WZDVVREODWDQWO\REYLRXVWRKHU QRZ6RZK\KDGVKHSDQLFNHG":DVLWFRQQHFWHGWRGUHDPVRIODWH GUHDPVDLULQJRQQLJKWPDUHV"6KHDOVRNQHZLQKHUKHDUWRIKHDUWVWKH VDPHVFHQDULRZLWK/XNHZRXOGKDYHLQFLWHGPLOGUHVLVWDQFHVDPHDV EHIRUH :KHQ/XNHDYHUWHGKLVJD]HIURP3DXODVWLOOKHUDOGLQJHFVWDV\LQ RUJDVPLFEOLVVKLVEURZVNQLWWHGWRJHWKHUZKLOVWFRQIURQWLQJ1LNR

2.\RXZLQZLWK3DXODEXWWKLVRQHLVFRPLQJZLWKPH¶ $V/XNHOHGDGD]HG&KDUOLHWRZDUGWKHKDOOZD\1LNRVWRRGWR DWWHQWLRQERZHGDQGVQHHUHG /DG\\RX OOEHEDFNZKHQKH¶V MHWWLVRQHG\RXOLNHDOOWKHRWKHUV%HDVVXUHGKHHDWV\RXQJMRXUQRV IRUEUHDNIDVWOXQFKDQGDFURVVKLVGHVNEHIRUHGLQQHU

&KDUOLHKDGQ WUHDOO\DEVRUEHG1LNR VRXWEXUVWDVVKHDQG/XNH JUDEEHGWKHLUFRDWVDQGOHIWWKHKRXVHQRZKLV\RXQJHUEURWKHU¶V ZRUGVNHSWULQJLQJLQKHUHDUVOLNHDODUPEHOOV6KHKDGQRLGHDZKHUH 

/XNHZDVWDNLQJKHUDQGKDGQ¶WKHDUGZKHUHKHKDGGLUHFWHGWKH FDEE\WR $VWKHWD[LVSHGWKURXJKVOXVK\VWUHHWVKHUPLQGVWDUWHGUHHOLQJ ZLWKSRVVLELOLWLHV:DVVKHDERXWWREHOHGWRKLVODLUWREHVHGXFHGDV 1LNRKDGLPSOLHGRUZDVKHPHUHO\HVFRUWLQJKHUEDFNWR3DXOD¶VIODW" /XNHZDVGLVSOD\LQJQRVLJQRIGHYLRXVLQWHQW6HDWHGEHVLGHKHUKLV OHIWDUPUHVWLQJDORQJWKHEDFNRIWKHVHDWDQGQRFRQWDFW:KHUHKH OLYHGVKHKDGQRWDFOXHEXWNQHZLQGHHGWKDWWKH\ZHUHQRORQJHU KHDGLQJWRZDUG3DXOD¶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

ZRQGHULQJZKDWOD\LQVWRUHDVGLIIXVHGOLJKWRIGDZQVWUHDNHGWKH QHDUKRUL]RQ $VWKHWD[LGURYHDZD\/XNHFDXJKWKROGRIKHUHOERZDQG XVKHUHGKHUWRZDUGDKRXVHZLWKSLOODUHGHQWUDQFH :HGRQ WZDQWDQ\ PRUHFROOLVLRQVVRZDWFKRXWIRUWKHLF\VWHSVDKHDG

6KHGLGDQGIHOWJUDWHIXOIRUWKHEODVWRIZDUPDLUWKDWKLWDVWKH\ HQWHUHGLQWRDGLPO\OLWKDOOZD\/XNHFORVHGWKHGRRUVRTXLHWO\LW UHPLQGHGKHURIDWLPHZD\EDFNZKHQ3DXODDQGKHUVHOIKDGVQHDNHG LQWRWKHLUROGKRPHDVWHHQDJHUVKRSLQJWRLQQRZD\URXVHWKH KRXVHKROG  $UH\RXDOZD\VVRTXLHWZKHQHQWHULQJ\RXURZQKRXVH"

/XNHJULQQHGDQGVOLGDZKLWHVLONVFDUIIURPDURXQGKLVQHFN

2QO\ZKHQP\VRQLVLQUHVLGHQFH

 6RQ"

 'RQ WORRNVRVKRFNHG,WGRHVKDSSHQ\RXNQRZRQHSDUHQW PDOHRIWKHGLYRUFHGVSHFLHV

 +RZROGLVKH"

 7HQDQGWKHUH VQRQHHGWRZKLVSHU 7KH\ERWKVPLOHGZLWK PXWXDODPXVHPHQW +DYLQJVDLGWKDWH[SODLQLQJ\RXUSUHVHQFHLV JRLQJWREHVRPHZKDWWULFN\

 /RRN,




&KDUOLHDOWKRXJKWLUHGDQGTXLWHUHDG\IRUDEHGZRXOGKDYH SUHIHUUHGLWLI/XNHKDGVKRZQDQLQNOLQJRILQWHUHVWLQKHU$VLWZDV KHOHGWKHZD\KHOGRSHQWKHEHGURRPGRRUDQGWKHQUHWUHDWHGOLNHD WUXHJHQWOHPDQ +RXUVODWHUZLWKH\HVVWLOOFORVHGDQGVWDUNQDNHGEHQHDWKDZDUP GXYHWIXOO\DZDUHRIWKHIDFWVKHZDVLQ/XNH VGRPDLQ&KDUOLHIHOW QRFRPSXOVLRQWROHDSRXWRIEHGIUHVKHQXSDQGJRVHHNKLV ORUGVKLS 6KHOD\TXLWHVWLOOLQKD]\SRVWZDNHXSPRGHWKHQVHQVHGD SUHVHQFHVRFORVHVKHFRXOGKHDUEUHDWKLQJ :K\ZRXOG/XNHEHLQWKHURRP" 6KHNHSWKHUH\HVVKXWIHLJQLQJGHHSVOHHS  +HOOR¶VHQWDFKLOOOLNHULSSOHGRZQKHUVSLQHWKH¶:KRDUH \RX" VRPHZKDWDFFXVDWRU\ 

,WKDGWREH/XNH VVRQEXWKRZWKHKHOOGLGKHDQGZKDWZDV KHGRLQJLQWKHURRP"

 ,NQRZ\RX UHDZDNH\RXUH\HVDUHPRYLQJDQG,DOZD\VFKHFN RXWWKHVSDUHURRPZKHQGDGJHWVLQMXVWEHIRUHGDZQ

$PXVHGE\KLVFKHHN&KDUOLHRSHQHGKHUH\HV 'RQ W\RXWUXVW KLP"

 6RUWRIEXWPXPDOZD\VZDQWVWRNQRZLIDZRPDQKDVVWD\HG WKHQLJKWZKLOH, PKHUH

&KDUOLHFRXOGVHHWKHOLNHQHVVEHWZHHQ/XNHDQGKLVVRQ\HWIHOW VKHZDVORRNLQJLQWR1LNR VJUHHQH\HV :HOO, P&KDUOLHDQGZKDW V \RXUQDPH"

 0LOHV KHUHSOLHGVHDWLQJKLPVHOIRQWKHEHG 'R\RXZDQWWR NQRZZK\"

&KDUOLHVPLOHGJXHVVHGVKHZDVJRLQJWRKHDUDQ\ZD\µ, PDOO HDUV¶ :KHQKHJODQFHGDZD\VKHVHQVHGDQDLURIVDGQHVV 0XPVDLG VKHFKRVHP\QDPHEHFDXVHGDGZDVDOZD\VPLOHVDZD\ 0LOHVWR\HG ZLWKDSLHFHRIVWULQJ
&KDUOLHDERXWWRFRPPLVHUDWHZLWK0LOHVGHFLGHGDJDLQVWLW $IWHUDOOVKHGLGQ WNQRZWKHIDFWVVKHNQHZOLWWOHDERXW/XNHDQG 

QRWKLQJRIKLVSULYDWHOLIHEXWDVNHGµ$QGGR\RXILQGZRPHQLQ KHUHYHU\RIWHQ"¶ 7KHVRXQGRI/XNH VYRLFHERRPLQJIURPVRPHZKHUHLQWKHKRXVH KDG0LOHVRQKLVIHHWDQGVFDPSHULQJWRZDUGWKHEHGURRPGRRUOHIW DMDUDVWKRXJKIRUKDVW\UHWUHDWLIQHFHVVDU\8QIRUWXQDWHO\IRU0LOHVLW VXGGHQO\RSHQHGZLWKJXVWRDQGKHZDVVWRSSHGLQKLVWUDFNV  2XW, OOVSHDNWR\RXGRZQVWDLUV /XNHVWHSSHGWRRQHVLGH DOORZLQJKLVVRQWRSDVV $VIRU\RX0V:DOWHUVGRQ WJRJHWWLQJDQ\ LGHDVDERXWLQWHUURJDWLQJP\VRQ

&KDUOLHSXVKHGKHUVHOIXSFOXWFKHGWKHGXYHWEHWZHHQKHUILQJHUV ZLWKUDJH -XVWDPLQXWHZKDWPDNHV\RXWKLQN,ZRXOGVLQNVRORZ DQGZKDWWKHKHOOPDNHV\RXWKLQN, PLQWHUHVWHGLQ\RXUSUHVHQWOLIH OHWDORQH\RXUSDVW"

 ,NQRZ\RXDUHQRZJHWGUHVVHG%UXQFKLVUHDG\LQWKH NLWFKHQ

&KDUOLHFRXOGQ¶WKHOSKHUVHOILWKDGWREHYRLFHG $UH\RXVD\LQJ \RXZDQWPHWRDSSHDULQP\OHDWKHUJHDU"

 1R\RX OOILQGVRPHWKLQJVXLWDEOHLQWKHZDUGUREH +HVSXQRQ KLVKHHOVZLWKDQDUURJDQWDLUSDXVHGWKHQWXUQHGWRIDFHKHUDJDLQ

$QGQRLW VQRWZKDW\RXWKLQN +HQRGGHGWRZDUGDVHFRQGGRRU

%DWKURRPWKRXJKWKHUH



$ORQHDJDLQ&KDUOLHSRQGHUHGWKHH[LVWHQFHRIDVRQDPRWKHU VRPHZKHUHHOVH7LPHZRXOGUHYHDOVRPHRI/XNH¶VVWRU\LIQRWPRVW RILWLIEUHDNIDVWLQKLVKRXVHZDVDQ\WKLQJOLNHEUHDNIDVWLQKHU FKLOGKRRGKRPH$IWHUDOOVKHDQG3DXODZHUHRIWHQKHOGUHVSRQVLEOH IRUKDYLQJOHWVOLSLQWHUQDOIDPLO\JRVVLSLQIURQWRIJXHVWVWKRXJK LQYDULDEO\ORRNHGXSRQE\WKHLUSDUHQWVDVDEOHVVLQJLQGLVJXLVH :KDWHYHU/XNH¶VIDPLO\DUUDQJHPHQWVZHUHWKHRQO\WKLQJVKHFRXOG UHDOO\WKLQNDERXWZDVDORQJKRWVRDNLQDWXE7KHIDFWWKDW/XNHZDV GRZQVWDLUVZHOOEHVWQRWGZHOOHGXSRQ+HZDVDIWHUDOODUFWLFDXUD DQGOLYLQJXSWRKLVWLWOH



7KUHH /XNHEUHH]HGLQWRWKHNLWFKHQMXVWDV&KDUOLHGHVSHUDWHO\OLFNHGMDP IURPKHUILQJHUVPRUHGDPQGHGO\RR]LQJIURPDGRXJKQXW  0HVV\JLUO\RX UHZRUVHWKDQ0LOHV

0LOHVFKXFNOHGFKHHNVIOXVKHGDVKHDQG&KDUOLHH[FKDQJHG FRPPLVHUDWLQJJODQFHV :KLOHKLVIDWKHUKDGDQVZHUHGDWHOHSKRQHLQWKHKDOO0LOHVKDG LQIRUPHG&KDUOLHWKDWKH¶GOLNHGWKHZD\VKHKDGVSRNHQWRKLP HDUOLHU7KDWVKHKDGQ WWUHDWHGKLPOLNHVRPHDOLHQIURPDQRWKHU SODQHWDVGLGKLVPRWKHU¶VPDOHIULHQGVQHLWKHUKDGVKHLQWHUURJDWHG KLPDERXWKLVIDWKHURUPRWKHU&KDUOLHWRRKDGOLNHGKLVKRQHVW\ GXULQJKLVIDWKHU¶VEULHIDEVHQFHIURPWKHURRPDQGKDGVXVVHGD VHQVHRIGLYLGHGOR\DOW\WKH\RXQJODGVHHPLQJO\GHSHQGHQWXSRQ HPRWLRQDOVWDELOLW\IURPKLVIDWKHUQRWKLVPRWKHU$QHZZRPDQDQ\ ZRPHQWR0LOHVLPSUHVVLRQDEOH\RXQJPLQGFRXOGGHVWUR\WKH UHODWLYHO\KDSS\H[LVWHQFHKHVKDUHGZLWKKLVIDWKHU  0LOHVKDYHQ W\RXDQ\KRPHZRUNWREHJHWWLQJRQZLWK" FKDUJHG KLVIDWKHU 0LOHVJODQFHGDW/XNHDQGVHQVLEO\WZLJJHGWKHQRGRIWKHKHDG 

PHDQWJHWORVWIRUDZKLOH&KDUOLHJRWWKHIHHOLQJWKDWQRUPDOO\KH ZRXOGKDYHSXWRQDVKRZRISURWHVWEXWVRPHWKLQJDERXWKLVIDWKHU V H\HVKDGGDUHGKLPWRHYHQWKLQNLW$V0LOHVVKXIIOHGIURPWKHURRP /XNHWXUQHGWRIDFH&KDUOLHZLWKDQDQ[LRXVH[SUHVVLRQ  $ERXWWKHMRE,PHQWLRQHGODVWQLJKW,I\RXVD\QR, OOTXLWH XQGHUVWDQG

&KDUOLHOLFNHGVXJDUIURPKHUILQJHUVVWXGLHGKLVH\HV $Q\RQH ZRXOGWKLQNLW VDGDQJHURXVDVVLJQPHQWJRLQJE\WKDWIDWKHUO\ORRNRQ \RXUIDFH +HFOHDUHGKLVWKURDWDVLIQHUYRXVDWWKHVDPHWLPH VHHPLQJGLVWUDFWHG6KHVLJKHGVDLG 6SDUHWKHGUDPDWLFVDQGVSLWLW RXW, OOVD\QRLI,GRQ WZDQWWKHMRE

+HPRPHQWDULO\JODQFHGWRZDUGWKHKDOOGRRUKLVWRQHPDUNHGO\ FRRO /LWWOHER\VZKRHDYHVGURSHQGXSZLWKHOHSKDQWHDUV 7KH VRXQGRIIHHWVKXIIOLQJXSWKHVWDLUVGUHZIRUWKVPLOHVDV/XNHPDGH KLVZD\WRWKHGRRU /LWWOHVRGLVWRRGDPQHGQRV\DQG,GRQ WZDQW KLPNQRZLQJDQ\WKLQJDERXWWKLVXQGHUFRYHUMRE

 8QGHUVWDQGDEOH

/XNHFORVHGWKHGRRUVKRYHGKLVKDQGVLQKLVWURXVHUSRFNHWV DQGVWRRGIDFLQJKHU ,W VDWDGWULFN\WKLVPXOWLSOHDEGXFWLRQFDVHDQG EHVLGHV\RXUVHOIVRPHRQHHOVHKDVUHFHLYHGUHJXODUDQVZHUVWR 

DGYHUWVSODFHGLQVHYHUDOVH[\FRQWDFWPDJV/LNH\RXZH¶UHIDLUO\ VXUHLW¶VWKHVDPHSHUVRQZKRDQVZHUHGDGYHUWVLQQHZVSDSHUVWRR

 6R"

 3HUVRQDOO\,WKLQNWKHJX\LVGDQJHURXVDQGWKLVDVVLJQPHQWLV JRLQJWREHDUHOHPHQWVRIULVNLIZHGRQ¶WJHWLWULJKW$VLQP\ JHWWLQJLWULJKW6RPHRQHYROXQWHHUHGIRUWKHMREEXW,WKLQNVKH VDWDG WRRVXEPLVVLYHWREHJRLQJRIIRQDVRORDVVLJQPHQW,WQHHGVDSHUVRQ FDSDEOHRIGHFHSWLRQDQGZHOODEOHWRVXSSO\EDFNXSIRUWKHQH[W YLFWLPZHSXWKLVZD\

 9LFWLP"

/XNHUHPRYHGKLVKDQGVIURPKLVSRFNHWVDQGPRYHGIRUZDUG EURZVIXUURZHGDVWKRXJKDKHDY\ZHLJKWOD\XSRQKLVVKRXOGHUV :KDW&KDUOLHIHOWDVKHOHDQHGWRZDUGKHUKLVKDQGUHVWLQJRQKHU FKDLUZDVQRWKLQJOHVVWKDQPDJQHWLFSXOOEXW/XNH¶VZRUGVVODPPHG KRPHZLWKSURIRXQGLPSDFW  +H VUDSHGRUDWOHDVWZH UHIDLUO\GDPQHGVXUHKHKDV7KH SUREOHPEHLQJDOOWKHZRPHQKH¶VOXUHGWRDFRXQWU\SDGVHHP LQFDSDEOHRIUHPHPEHULQJDQ\WKLQJWKDWPLJKWVHWXVRQWKHULJKWURDG QHLWKHUFDQWKH\UHYHDOPXFKDERXWWKHMRXUQH\VLQFHWKH\ZHUHQRW RQO\EOLQGIROGHGHQURXWHWKH\DOOFODLPWKH\IHOWQXPELQOLPEWRWKH H[WHQWRIVSHHFKOHVV¶ 

µ'UXJJHG"¶ µ
 ,QZKDWZD\"

 +XVN\:KLVSHU\DVLIKHKDVDFRQVWDQWVRUHWKURDW

&KDUOLHIHOWDFROGVKLYHUULSSOHGRZQKHUVSLQH+HUWKRXJKWV LPPHGLDWHO\GULIWHGWR4XDVLPRGR +RZGLGWKH\GHVFULEHKLP ERGLO\WKDWLV"

 9DULHGVRPXFKLWZDVLPSRVVLEOHWRJHWDVHQVLEOHSURILOH$SDO RIPLQHLQWKH0HWGUHZDEODQNDQGQRQHRIWKHZRPHQZDQWHGWR SUHVVFKDUJHV

 6RZKDW\RX UHVD\LQJLV\RXZDQWPHWREHDZLOOLQJYLFWLP"

/XNHSXVKHGKLPVHOIXSDQGPRYHGDZD\IURPKHUDVWKRXJKD VHFRQGDU\WKRXJKWKDGVWUXFNOLNHDWKXQGHUEROWIURPWKHEOXH&KDUOLH VHQVHGDQ[LHW\HPDQDWLQJDFURVVWKHWDEOHVDLG 'R,JHWDWULDOUXQ EHIRUHEHLQJWKURZQWRWKHZROI"

 $UH\RXVD\LQJ\RX OOGRLW"

 2QO\LI\RXJLYHPHDUXQGRZQRQKLVWDFWLFVDQGZKDWH[DFWO\ EDFNXSPHDQV



 $WUDQVYHVWLWHZLOOEHZRUNLQJDORQJVLGH\RXDQG,SURPLVH SURPLVH,¶OOEHZLWKLQFDOOLQJGLVWDQFH+DYLQJVDLGWKDW\RX¶UH QXPEHUWZREDLW   %XW,WKRXJKW\RXMXVWVDLG

/XNHFOHDUHGKLVWKURDWDJDLQORRNLQJXQHDV\DVKHOHDQHG DJDLQVWWKHZRUNWRS

 6KH VDWUXHVXEPLVVLYH:KHUHDV\RXUROHSOD\DQGZLWKVNLOODW WKDW,ZDWFKHG\RXFKDOOHQJH1LNRHDUOLHU\HW\RXKDYHDWUDFWDEOH VLGHWRROLNHZKHQ,FDPHRYHUDOOPDVWHUIXO,JRWWKHGLVWDQWIHHOLQJ, FRXOGKDYHWDNHQ\RXZLWKRXWSURWHVWULJKW"%XWWKDW¶VQRWDQLVVXHDW SUHVHQW

&KDUOLH VFKHHNVIOXVKHGDQGWKHUHZDVQRSRLQWLQGHQ\LQJKH ZDVDEVROXWHO\FRUUHFWLQHYHU\WKLQJVDLGDERXWODVWQLJKW 6RGR,JHW DWULDOUXQ"

 6RUU\"

 $UH\RXJRLQJWRH[SODLQKLVWDFWLFVLQWKHRU\RUSK\VLFDOO\VKRZ PHZKDWKHGRHVWRKLVYLFWLPV"

/XNHJULQQHG7KHVSDUNOHLQKHUH\HVDQGWKHGHYLRXVDWWHPSWDW OHDGLQJKLPLQWRDWUDSQRWLFHDEO\DPXVLQJWRKLP 'RQ WWHPSWPH



 $UH\RXDIUDLGRI\RXURZQIDQWDV\"

 :KDWPDNHV\RXWKLQNDUDSHVFHQDULRLVRQHRIP\IDQWDVLHV"

&KDUOLHVWRRGXSDQGPRYHGWRZDUGKLP /RRNPHLQWKHH\HDQG GHQ\LW VKHVDLGOHWWLQJKHUILQJHUVGULIWDORQJKLVDUP /XNHJULQQHGDJDLQGUHZKHUFORVHDQGUHIUDLQHGIURP DQVZHULQJWKHTXHVWLRQ
$ERXWWRTXHVWLRQKLPIXUWKHUKLVPRXWKHQYHORSLQJKHUVZDV WRWDOO\LUUHVLVWLEOHKLVZKDWZHFDQ¶WKDYHDSX]]OH/XNH¶VVKHHU SUHVHQFHDUURJDQFHDQGGHVLUDELOLW\ZDVXQGHQLDEOHEXWQRW QHFHVVDULO\WKDWH[FOXVLYH$VDKDQGFDUHVVHGKHUOHIWEXWWRFNWKHQ FUHSWXSZDUGWRWKHVPDOORIKHUEDFNLWVFRXQWHUSDUWJULSSHGKHUKHDG SUHYHQWLQJDQ\OLNHOLKRRGRIHVFDSH6KHKDGQRLQWHQWLRQRIHYHQ WU\LQJWRULGKHUVHOIRI$UFWLF$XUDZKRZDVVHHPLQJO\PHOWLQJZLWK HYHU\SDVVLQJPRPHQW &KDUOLHKDGGDUHGWRWRXFKILUVWKDGQ¶WH[SHFWHG/XNHWRUHVSRQG ZLWKVXFKKXQJU\HDJHUQHVVDQGHYHU\WKLQJKH¶GMXVWVDLGZDV SDUWLDOO\WUXHIRUKHUSDUWEXWKRZPXFKZDVWKHUHDOKLP" +HOOZDVKROGLQJKHUFORVHWKHQ/XNHUHWUHDWHGDQGKLVH\HV RSHQHGZLGH$VKHSXOOHGDZD\NLVVHGKHUQRVHDQGVPLOHGKH VXUSULVHGKHUZLWK
VHQVHLQQRWLPHDWDOO +HWKHQEUXVKHGSDVWKHUDQGSLFNHGXSD IROGHU $WHPSWLQJDGLQRQHRIWKHVLPPDJD]LQHVKDVJRQHGHDGRQ XVEXW3DXODWKLQNVVKH¶VILQDOO\JRWWKHHGJHRQ\RXU5HIOH[PDQ

 :KDWPDNHVKHUWKLQNLW¶VKLP"

 6KHFRSLHG\RXUVW\OHRIZULWLQJ¶ µ
 %XW3DXODLV1LNR VJLUOIULHQGVRKRZLQKHOOLVVKHJRLQJWR NHHSWKLVMXVWEHWZHHQXV"¶ 

 $UH\RXGRXEWLQJP\SRZHUVRISHUVXDVLRQDQGMXGJHPHQWRI \RXUVLVWHU¶VOR\DOW\WRPRL"

 ,NQRZP\VLVWHUDQG\HVOR\DOW\LVDVWURQJSRLQWEXWVKH¶V LQIDWXDWHGZLWK1LNR

 3DXODZRQ¶WIRXOXS

&KDUOLHVHQVHGFROGQHVVLQKLVWRQHKLVH\HVEXUQLQJLQWRKHUVDV LIWKHGHYLOKDGWDNHQSRVVHVVLRQRIKLVPLQG6KHVWLOOZRQGHUHGLI WKHUHKDGDWRQHWLPHEHHQPRUHEHWZHHQ3DXODDQGWKLVVH[\PDQ EHIRUHKHUDQGZKHWKHUKHUVLVWHUKDGGHOLEHUDWHO\GHQLHGLWIRU UHDVRQVEHVWNQRZQWRWKHP/XNHWKHQGXPSHGDIROGHURQWKHWDEOH DVLIWKURZLQJGRZQDJDXQWOHW  'R\RXZDQWWKLVDVVLJQPHQWRUQRW"

6KHGHILDQWO\JODUHGEDFNDQGWKHQVPLOHG .LVVPHDJDLQDQG , OOWHOO\RX

 &RPHKHUH\RXLPSXGHQWKXVV\

&KDUOLHPRYHGIRUZDUGWKHQSDXVHG'DPQLWVKH GPHDQWIRU KLPWRPDNHWKHPRYHWRZDUGKHU +HJULQQHGUHOD[HGRQHOHJDQGOHLVXUHO\OHDQHGRQWKHZRUN WRS 'RQ WMXVWVWDQGWKHUHORRNLQJFKXUOLVKVPLOHDQGFRPHWR\RXU 0DVWHU



7KLVZDV27DVIDUDV&KDUOLHZDVFRQFHUQHG ,GRQ WPL[ EXVLQHVVZLWKSOHDVXUH

+HODXJKHGKHDUWLO\ $KVRWKHSURPLVHRIDNLVVZDVDWHVW"

 2QO\LI\RXZDQWWRVHHLWWKDWZD\

 5LJKW0V:DOWHUVWKHVRRQHU\RXUHDGWKRVHOHWWHUVWKHEHWWHU LQIRUPHG\RXZLOOEH +HWXUQHGSLFNHGXSWKHSKRQH , OOFDOODWD[L DQG\RXFDQEHRQ\RXUZD\5LQJPHLIDQGZKHQ\RXPDNHFRQWDFW ZLWKVDLGILHQGDJDLQ

6WXQQHGE\KLVPDWWHURIIDFWPDQQHU&KDUOLHSLFNHGXSWKH IROGHUDQGEURZVHGWKURXJKWKHSDSHUVDVKHUHSODFHGWKHWHOHSKRQH +HWKHQZDONHGEULVNO\LQWRWKHKDOOZKHUHKHVKRXWHG  0LOHV¶QRUHSO\DQGµ0LOHV¶ERRPHG7KHUHZDVDSDXVHD GLVWDQWUHVSRQVHWKHQµ%ULQJGRZQ0V:DOWHUVKDQGEDJ

&KDUOLHZDONHGWKURXJKWKHGRRULQWHQWRQOHDYLQJDVTXLFNO\DV SRVVLEOH,QKDVWHVKHFROOLGHGZLWK/XNH¶VEXONDVKHWXUQHG7KHUH ZDVQRHPEUDFHQRZDUPWKMXVWLQGLIIHUHQFHDVKHVLGHVWHSSHG 


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¶WZDQWWRGHOYH LQWR6KHZDVO\LQJWRKHUVHOIEXWZKDWWKHKHOO$UFWLF$XUDFRXOG VWD\IUR]HQIRUDOOVKHFDUHG+HQHHGHGKHUQRWWKHRWKHUZD\DURXQG HYHQLIRQO\IRUWKLVSUHVHQWDVVLJQPHQW 0LOHVKHOGRXWKHUEDJDQGJULQQHGEURDGO\ *RRGE\H&KDUOLH ,¶PJODG,PHW\RX

7KHDUURJDQWVWDQFHZDVVROLNHKLVIDWKHUKLVH\HVWKRVHRIKLV XQFOH *RRGE\H0LOHVDQGWKDQN\RXIRUIHWFKLQJWKLV 6KHFODVSHG KHUEDJWKHQNLVVHGKLPRQWKHFKHHNEHIRUHWXUQLQJWRZDUG/XNH , OO NHHSLQWRXFKWKURXJK0DQG\


/XNHFODVSHGKHUHOERZDQGJHQWO\OHGKHUWRWKHIURQWGRRUWKH VRXQGRI0LOHVWKXQGHULQJXSWKHVWDLUFDVHDVLJQWKDWKHKDGRWKHU PRUHLPSRUWDQWWKLQJVWRGRWKDQKDQJDURXQGSROLWHO\XQWLODJXHVWRI KLVIDWKHU¶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¶



 +L VDLGDGHHSUDVS\YRLFH , P0DQG\/XNH VMXVWJLYHQPHD EX]]:HOOQRWTXLWHGDUOLQJKH VQRWLQFOLQHGP\ZD\EXWZHGRJHW RQTXLWHIDYRXUDEO\ZKHQ, PGXOOROG0DUWLQDWWKH0HW

&KDUOLHUHIUDLQHGIURPODXJKLQJDQGELWKHUOLS 2KULJKWKH V FHUWDLQO\GHWHUPLQHGWRJHWXVDFTXDLQWHG$6$3

 ([DFWO\KRZDERXWFRIIHHRQPH"¶  :KHUH"

 6WD\WKHUHDQG, OOSLFN\RXXS6HH\RXLQDELW

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

 0DQG\:HOO0DUWLQDFWXDOO\,ZDVQHDUKHUHVRMXPSHGDWD[L ,¶YHJRWDNH\E\NLQGSHUPLVVLRQDQGGLGQ¶WWKLQNWRULQJWKHJRQJ SHUKDSV0DGDPZLOOSHUPLWPH" 0DQG\LPPHGLDWHO\UHDFKHGIRUWKH KDLUEUXVKWLJKWO\FODVSHGEHWZHHQ&KDUOLH VEODQFKHGILQJHUV 'RQ¶W ORRNVRVFDUHGRIPH, OOGRDQ\WKLQJWRDSSHDVHDEHDXWLIXOZRPDQ

 $Q\WKLQJ"  µ3UHWW\PXFKDQ\WKLQJ¶ &KDUOLHUHOLQTXLVKHGKHUJULSDQGKDQGHGRYHUWKHEUXVK0LQXWHV ODWHUVKHZDVWKLQNLQJLWZRQGHUIXOWRKDYHVRPHRQHDFWXDOO\ZLOOLQJ WRVSHQGWLPHORYLQJO\EUXVKLQJDQGVWURNLQJKHUKDLU,WZDVDOVR GLVFRQFHUWLQJWRVHHWKHH[WUHPHO\JODPRURXVIHPLQLQHIDFHUHIOHFWHG LQWKHPLUURU0DQG\ZLWKDPDOHERG\EHQHDWKWKHFKLFEHLJHVXLW

'R\RXHYHUILQGLWFRQIXVLQJRU¶  (PEDUUDVVLQJ"2QHJHWVXVHGWRLW UHSOLHG0DQG\JODQFLQJ DURXQGWKHURRP :KDWZHUH\RXSODQQLQJRQZHDULQJ"

&KDUOLHVWRRGXSDQGPRWLRQHGWRZDUGWKHZDUGUREH ,KDYHQ W GHFLGHG\HW

 7HOOPHDQG

µ,FDQPDQDJHDQG\RXFDQZDLWGRZQVWDLUV

 3DUGRQPHIRUEHLQJUDWKHUSUHVXPSWXRXVEXWLWZRXOGEHEHVWLI 0DGDPJHWVXVHGWRKDYLQJPHDURXQG





 , PVXUH,ZLOOEXWQRWZKHQ, PLQWKHQRGG\

 ,¶PQRWWKDWSDUWLDOWRIXOOQXGLW\HLWKHU$WP\EHVWZKHQD PLVWUHVVLVZHDULQJKHUIOLPVLHV¶  ,VWKDWVR" VDLG&KDUOLHPRYLQJIRUZDUG6KHGHOLEHUDWHO\ VWURNHGXS0DQG\¶VVWRFNLQJFODGOHJZLWKWKHLQWHQWLRQRIVHHNLQJ WKHHUHFWLRQVKHJXHVVHGZRXOGEHWKHUH $UH\RXVD\LQJWKLVLVQ W GRLQJDQ\WKLQJIRU\RX"

0DQG\VWRSSHGKHUKDQGPLGWKLJKJULQQHGDQGZLJJOHGKHU KLSV +DUGDWWKHPRWKRXJKWU\LQJQRWWREH

&KDUOLHVXGGHQO\VDZWKHIXQQ\VLGHRIWKHVLWXDWLRQDQGGXO\ RUGHUHG0DQG\WRWXUQDQGORRNDZD\6KHWKHQVOLGDVOLSIURPWKH ZDUGUREHVOLSSHGLQWRLWDQGVDWEDFNRQWKHEHG 2.VHHWKRVH VWD\XSVWRFNLQJVKDQJLQJRYHUWKHPLUURU3XWWKHPRQIRUPH  6KHSURPSWO\GDQJOHGDIRRWDV0DQG\FDUHIXOO\FURXFKHGGRZQ DQGSURFHHGHGWRUROORQWKHILUVWVWRFNLQJ:LFNHGO\&KDUOLHGUHZ WKHVLONRIKHUVOLSKLJKHUDQGKLJKHUXQWLO0DQG\FRXOGVHHVKHKDG QRSDQWLHVRQXQGHUQHDWK0DQG\QRWLFHDEO\VZDOORZHGKDUGWKHQ SURFHHGHGWRUROOXSWKHVHFRQGVWRFNLQJ 

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¶VYHU\FRUH 6KHUHFOLQHGIXUWKHUIOH[LQJKHUVSLQHIHOWKHUEUHDVWVVZHOOLQJ DQGVWUDLQLQJDJDLQVWWKHVLON\ERQGDJHRIWKHODFHWULPPHGVOLS6KH PRDQHGUHVSRQVLYHO\VDLG 0DQG\VWRSWKDWDQGOLFNP\FXQW\RX WHDVLQJZKRUH &KDUOLHFODVSHG0DQG\ VKHDGIRUFLQJKHUPRXWKWR TXLP6KHWKHQDOPRVWVFUHDPHGDVDVODYHULQJWRQJXHSORXJKHG 

WKURXJKWKHIOXVKHGDQGWKUREELQJODELDIROGV7KHVHQVDWLRQZDVXWWHU HFVWDV\EHIRUHLWZKLUOHGEDFNDQGIRUWKDFURVVKHUVZROOHQEXG

+DUGHU0DQG\KDUGHU¶&KDUOLHWKUXVWKHUSHOYLVIRUZDUG0DQG\¶V ILQJHUVFOXWFKLQJKHUEXWWRFNVEXWDVJRRGDVLWZDV&KDUOLHZDQWHG /XNHZLVKHGKLPWKHUHWRGULYHKLPVHOILQWRKHUWRVHQGKHUERG\DQG PLQGFUDVKLQJLQWRDZKLUOSRRORIOXVW6KH\HOOHGµ*LYHLWWRPHJLYH LWWRPH¶$OOWKHZKLOHDEXUQLQJDFKHGHHSZLWKLQUDJHGDQGURVHXS WRWKHVXUIDFHDVVKHVHQVHGDZRQGHUIXOPRPHQWRIFRPSOHWH VXIIHUDQFHRQWKHHGJHKHUERG\KDUGO\DEOHWRUHVLVWDQGWKHQ VXFFXPELQJWRWKHWUHPEOHVDQGVKXGGHUVRIHFVWDWLFSOHDVXUH /LNHDOOJRRGWKLQJVFRPHWRDVSHHG\HQG&KDUOLH¶VRUJDVPLF VWDWHRIHXSKRULDDLUHGWRZDUGLWVHQGWRR 2KKHOO0DQG\\RX FHUWDLQO\NQRZKRZWRJLYHDQRWKHUJLUODJRRGWLPH VKHVDLGDOPRVW EUHDWKOHVV  ,I0DGDPLVZDQWLQJPRUHRIWKHVDPH, OOFRQWLQXH

 'RQ W\RXQHHGDQ\WKLQJ"

 $JRRGVSDQNLQJ",I,¶YHIDLOHGWRSOHDVXUHVXIILFLHQWO\

 :KDW,PHDQLVGRQ W\RXZDQWD¶  )XFN",ZRXOGQ WVD\QREXW\RXGLGQ WDVN

 ,GLGVD\SHQHWUDWHPH

 0DGDPVKRXOGEHPRUHVXFFLQFW



 ,QWKDWFDVHQH[WWLPHGRLWSURSHUO\

µ
 :KDWKDV/XNHJRWWRGRZLWKDQ\WKLQJ"

 ,JRWWKHLPSUHVVLRQKHDQG\RXZHUH

 $EVROXWHO\QRWDQGQHYHUZLOOEH

 ,I\RXVD\VR0DGDP6KDOO,FRQWLQXHQRZ"

 2IFRXUVHKRZHOVHDUHZHJRLQJWRJHWWRNQRZRQHDQRWKHUDQG EHDEOHWRZRUNWRJHWKHU"

7ZRKRXUVODWHU&KDUOLHZDVUHFOLQLQJRQWKHVRIDDQG0DQG\KDGMXVW ILQLVKHGJRLQJWKURXJKDSRVVLEOHLWLQHUDU\RIODWHQLJKWIHWLVKFOXEV ZRUWKYLVLWLQJ 7KDWFRQFOXGHVDQ\OLNHO\QLJKWVSRWVWKLVFKDSKDV EHHQNQRZQWRDWWHQG

 :KDWDUHWKHFKDQFHVRIDFWXDOO\PHHWLQJWKLVJX\"

0DQG\ORRNHGXSIURPZKHUHVKHZDVVLWWLQJRQWKHIORRU1R LGHDEXW\RXUVLVWHUKDVGHILQLWHO\PDGHFRQWDFWDQG¶VGXHWR UHQGH]YRXVZLWKKLPWRQLJKW

 :KHUH"

 2QO\VKHDQG/XNHNQRZWKDWZKLFKUHPLQGVPH 0DQG\ 

JODQFHGDWWKHPDQWHOFORFN :H¶UHVXSSRVHGWRPHHWXSZLWKKLPLQ WZHQW\ILYHPLQXWHV

&KDUOLHVPLOHGDVDKDQGVWURNHGKHUDQNOH :K\GLGQ W\RXWHOO PHWKDWEHIRUH"

 :KHQ\RXVDLG/XNHDQG\RXZHUHQ¶WZHOO,WKRXJKWZKDWWKH KHOOLIZHHQGXSLQEHGDOOGD\

 $QG"


 .HHSGRLQJWKDWDQGZH OOQHYHUJHWWRPHHW/XNH

 $UH\RXVD\LQJ\RXZDQWPHWRJRIXUWKHU" DVNHG0DQG\DV WKRXJKDOLWWOHZDU\RI&KDUOLH VPRWLYHV 0HDQWLPH&KDUOLHVWXGLHG0DQG\¶VORQJODVKHVDQGKHDYHQO\EOXH H\HVDVWKRXJKSX]]OLQJZKDWOD\EHQHDWKWKHUHGZLJ +RZROGDUH \RX"

 0DQG\OD]LO\UDLVHGKHUH\HVIURP&KDUOLH VVOHQGHUOHJVDQGOHW KHUKDQGGULIWXQGHUWKHVRIWZRROOHQGUHVV0DUWLQZRXOGKDYH SUHIHUUHGWRODQJXLGO\WRQJXHWKHZDQWRQSXVVDJDLQEXWUHSOLHG µ7KLUW\HLJKWQH[WZHHNZK\"

 :KDWGRHV0DUWLQORRNOLNH"

 :KR V0DUWLQ KHUHSOLHGGHVSHUDWHO\EDWWOLQJWKHPDOHSHUVRQD WRWKHGHHSHVWGHSWKV 

 , PVRUU\,VXSSRVH,WKRXJKW\RXZHUHMXVWZRUNLQJXQGHUFRYHU DQGQRWUHDOO\DWUDQVYHVWLWH &KDUOLHPRDQHGVRIWO\DV0DQG\VOLG WKHIROGVRIKHUGUHVVKLJKHUDQGKLJKHUXQWLOKHUSXOVLQJVH[KLGGHQ EHKLQGEURQ]H FRORXUHGSDQWLHVFRXOGEHVHHQVWUDLQLQJIRUUHOHDVH 'RQ WMXVWWHDVH GRVRPHWKLQJVXEVWDQWLDO

µ,¶PQRWVXUH,¶PDWUXHWUDQQ\WKRXJK,¶YHEHFRPHVRDGHSWDW VZLWFKLQJ,JHWVHULRXVO\FRQIXVHGDWWLPHV6RUWRIVSOLWSHUVRQDOLW\ DQGZKHQEDWWOHVDUHUDJLQJLQP\KHDGOLNHHDUOLHU
&KDUOLHKDGEHHQJLYHQDSOHDVXUHWR\ZKLFKQHYHUVDLGQRWR DQ\WKLQJVKHZDQWHGDQGZKDWVKHZDQWHGDWWKDWPRPHQWVKHZDV MROO\ ZHOOJRLQJWRKDYHLI0DUWLQKDGDQ\WKLQJWRVD\DERXWLW  0DQG\GDUOLQJUDLVH\RXUVNLUWIRUPH 0DQG\YLVLEO\ORRNHG VWDUWOHGDQGWDNHQDEDFNDV&KDUOLHVZXQJKHUOHJVRIIWKHVRIDDQG OHDQHGIRUZDUG &RPHRQGRQ WEHVK\ &KDUOLHZDLWHG 1RZVKRZ PHZKDW\RX YHJRWKLGGHQLQWKRVH)UHQFKNQLFNHUV 6KHZDLWHGWKHQ JDVSHGZKHQ UHDOLW\RIDFRFNUHVWUDLQHGLQDOHDWKHUKDUQHVVZDVEUDQGLVKHGEHIRUH KHU 7DNHWKDWRIILW VVWUDQJOLQJ\RX

 ,W VVDIHUZKHQVWUDSSHG

 7DNHLWRII


0PPWKDW VKHDYHQ 6KHUXEEHGWKHZDUPWKRIKLVHQGRZPHQWEDFN DQGIRUWKDFURVVKHUSXELFPRXQGWKHQOHWLWHYHUVRVORZO\GULIWGRZQ 

WKURXJKWKHRUDOMXLFHVFOLQJLQJWRDQGPRLVWHQLQJKHUVHFUHWSDVVDJH ZKLFK0DQG\KDGSOHDVXUHGVRHDJHUO\EHIRUHKDQG ,QWRUPHQW0DQG\ZDWFKHGDV0DUWLQ VHQJRUJHGFRFNZDV IRQGOHGDQGWHDVHGZLWKWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIVOLGLQJLQWRWKHZDUPWKRI &KDUOLH VLQQHUVDQFWXDU\'DPQLW0DQG\KDGWULHGKHUEHVWWRWRQJXH DYLWDO*VSRWEXWDOZD\VRQIXWLOHTXHVWV 0DGDPLVWHPSWLQJ0DUWLQ RXWWRSOD\

&KDUOLHVPLOHGODVFLYLRXVO\ 7RKHOODQGEDFNLWLVWKHQIRU 0DUWLQWKLVWLPH

7KHPRYHPHQWRI&KDUOLH VERG\DQGWKHSUHVVXUHDVVKHLPSDOHG KHUVHOIFRXOGVRHDVLO\GULYH0DQG\WREHFRPHLQVDQHO\MHDORXVRI 0DUWLQ¶VVXGGHQSURPLQHQWUROH+HZDVQ WVXSSRVHGWREHLQFRQWURO DQGFRXOGQ¶WEHDOORZHGWROHDG0DQG\LQWRXQFHUWDLQW\DOORYHUDJDLQ 'DPQ0DUWLQWKRXJKW0DQG\KHKDVQ WWDNHQFKDUJHLQDORQJZKLOH EXWZKDWVKHDQGKHZHUHIHHOLQJZDVVRJRRGLQDVHQVHD UHDZDNHQLQJEH\RQGPHDVXUHRIULJKWRUZURQJLQZDUGO\RU RXWZDUGO\DKHRUDVKH &KDUOLHZDVWKHVRUWRIZRPDQZKRFRXOGPDNH0DUWLQDQG 0DQG\GRWKLQJVHDFKLQWXUQZRXOGKDYHUHVLVWHGZLWKPDQ\RWKHUV +HUHZDV0DUWLQDOLYHDQGIXFNLQJDEHDXWLIXOZRPDQZLWKDOOWKH 

SRZHUKHKDGOHIWLQKLVERG\ZKLOH0DQG\FRXOGRQO\ORRNRQLQ KRSHOHVVGHMHFWHGOLPER &KDUOLHWKHQPRDQHGDQGJURDQHGDQG0DUWLQNQHZVKHKDGUHDFKHG WKHSLQQDFOHRIKHUUHVLVWDQFH2K\HVVKHZDVVDYRXULQJKLVWKUXVWLQJ PHPEHUSXOVDWLQJDQGYLEUDWLQJXQWLOKHWRRZRXOGILQDOO\EHVSHQW,W FDPHVRRQHUWKDQKHZRXOGKDYHZLVKHGIRUVKRXOGHUVVDJJLQJDV ERWKIORDWHGOLNH$XWXPQOHDYHVVZLUOLQJRQZDWHUVRIOXVW7KH\ZHUH XQLWHGLQIULHQGVKLSWUXVWDQGPXWXDOVDWLVIDFWLRQZLWKQRHPRWLRQDO WLHV:KDWWKHKHOOGLG0DUWLQFDUHWKDW0DQG\¶VZLJKDGIDOOHQIURP KLVKHDGZKLOVWLQWKHWKURZVRIPDQO\RUJDVPRUWKDW&KDUOLH¶VH\HV ZHUHVSDUNOLQJZLWKDPXVHPHQWDWEODFNFORVHFURSSHGFXUOV  :H UHJRLQJWREHODWHIRURXUDSSRLQWPHQW KHVDLGRQWKHSRLQW RIIXOOZLWKGUDZDOIROORZHGE\DYDQTXLVKHG0DUWLQVOXPSLQJGRZQ RQWKHUXJ  6RWKHPLJKW\/XNHZLOOKDYHWRZDLW

 +HZRQ WEHWHUULEO\SOHDVHG

 ,W VDODG\ VSUHURJDWLYHWREHODWHDQGVHHLQJDVWKHUHDUHWZRRI XVWKDWPHDQVGRXEOHG\ODWH PXVHG&KDUOLHSORSSLQJ0DQG\¶VZLJ RQKLVKHDG 2KKHOO,QHHGDGULQN



 1HYHUPLQGJHWWLQJDGULQNKHUHKLVORUGVKLSFDQSLFNXSWKH WDE¶0DUWLQVWUXJJOHGWR0DQG\¶VVWLOHWWRKHHOHGIHHWµ+HOSPH 0DGDPIRUJDZG¶VVDNH, PEORRG\EXVKHG

&KDUOLHEXUVWRXWODXJKLQJ &RPHRQVH[\OHW VEHKDYLQJ\RX

1RQR,FRXOGQ W VDLG0DUWLQKXUULHGO\UHGUHVVLQJ0DQG\¶V KDLUµ,¶PRXWRISUDFWLVHRQWKHVKDJJLQJIURQW¶  2KEXW\RX¶GVKDJPHDJDLQLI,WROG\RXWR¶ 0DUWLQVFUDPEOHGWRKLVIHHWFKHFNHGKLVDSSHDUDQFHLQWKH PLUURUWRSSHGXS0DQG\¶VOLSVWLFNDQGJUDEEHGDWKLVKDQGEDJLQ SDVVLQJµ'RQ¶WWHOOPHWRGRDQ\WKLQJZLFNHGLQSXEOLFEHFDXVH EHOLHYHPHMXVWEHLQJZLWK\RXZLOONHHS0DQG\RQDKLJKZLWKRXW \RXULQFLWLQJ0DUWLQWRFRPHOHDSLQJRXWIURPEHQHDWK0DQG\¶VVNLUW¶ µ*HH,QHHGDORQJSLVV¶ µ0HWRR¶FKXFNOHG&KDUOLHµ%HWWHUKDYHDTXLFNLHGRXFKHDV ZHOORUZH¶OOVPHOOOLNHZHOOIXFNHGZKRUHV¶ )LIWHHQPLQXWHVODWHUWKH\ZHUHWHDULQJDORQJLQDWD[LKHDGLQJIRU WKHLUPHHWLQJZLWK/XNHDQG&KDUOLHZRQGHUHGZKDWKHUUHFHSWLRQ ZRXOGEHOLNH6KHQHHGQ WKDYHZKHQ0DUWLQ VPRELOHSKRQHUDQJ 

WHOOLQJWKHPWRFKDQJHWKHLUURXWHDQGWRPHHW3DXODQHDU:HVWPLQVWHU %ULGJH  :KDWRQHDUWKLVVKHGRLQJWKHUH" DVNHG&KDUOLHDV0DUWLQ LQIRUPHGWKHWD[LGULYHURIWKHLUUHYLVHGURXWH µ7KDW VZKHUHWKHSLFNXSLV3DXODUHIXVHGWRPHHW5HIOH[PDQDWD FOXESUHPLVHVZKLFKLVWRRXUEHQHILW,W¶VGDPQDEO\HDV\WRORVHVLJKW RIVRPHRQHLQDFURZGHGHQYLURQPHQWQRPDWWHUKRZPDQ\RSHUDWLYHV RQHPLJKWKDYHRQWKHJURXQG


 8QIRUWXQDWHO\/XNHLVMDPPHGLQDTXHXHGXHWRDWUDIILF DFFLGHQW

 :KDWLQKHOOLVKHSOD\LQJDWOHWWLQJ3DXODJRZLWKRXWEDFNXS"

 +DUGO\/XNH¶VIDXOW3DXODLQIRUPHGKLPWKDWVKHZRXOGEH PHHWLQJWKLVJX\DW3DGGLQJWRQVWDWLRQWKHQVKHFRQWDFWHGZLWKODVW PLQXWHLQVWUXFWLRQVWKDW5HIOH[PDQKDGSUHIHUUHG:HVWPLQVWHU%ULGJH $Q\KRZVKH¶VTXLWHFDSDEOHDQGLQFUHGLEO\VHQVLEOH

 6KHFDQEHVRPHZKDWQDLYHDWWLPHVWRRDQG/XNHVKRXOGQ¶W KDYHOHWKHURXWRIKLVVLJKW

 6KHZDVLQ1LNR VDSDUWPHQWHDUOLHUZKLFKPHDQW/XNHKDGWR VWD\RXWRIVLJKWDQGUHO\VROHO\XSRQWKHLUPRELOHVIRUFRQWDFW



 'DPQ/XNHKHPXVWKDYHNQRZQZKHQVKHOHIW1LNR VDSDUWPHQW WKDWKHVKRXOG¶YHIROORZHGRQIRRWQRWE\FDU

 :HOOZKDWHYHUKDSSHQHGZHQHHGWRORRNLQFRQVSLFXRXVXSRQ DSSURDFKWR3DXODDQGKHUHZHDUH 7KH\DOLJKWHGIURPWKHWD[LDIWHU 0DUWLQKDGSDLGWKHIDUHKHWKHQJODQFHGWRZDUGWKHEULGJH %XJJHU 6KH VQRWRQWKHQRUWKVLGHXQOHVV, PJRLQJEOLQG

&KDUOLHVFDQQHGWKHHPEDQNPHQWHLWKHUZD\DQGSURFHHGHG RQZDUGDFURVVWKHEULGJH +XUU\,KDWHWRWKLQNRIP\VLVWHURQKHU RZQZLWKVRPHSHUYHUW

 'RQ WUXVKMXVWNHHSFDOPDQGORRNDVLI\RX UHRXWHQMR\LQJ \RXUVHOI VDLG0DUWLQKLVH\HVSDQQLQJWKHIDUVLGHRIWKHEULGJHIRU VLJQVRI3DXOD 0HDQZKLOHFDUVDQGWD[LVVZHSWSDVWWKHWZRIHPDOHILJXUHV VWUROOLQJDFURVVHDFKFRQFHUQHGRQO\IRU3DXOD¶VVDIHW\ZKHQ VXGGHQO\DIODVK\VSRUWVFDUEUDNHGYLROHQWO\ZLWK\RXQJODGVLQVLGH

+RZPXFKGDUOLQ¶ " DVNHGWKHSDVVHQJHUH\HLQJ0DQG\ VOHJV 0DUWLQPRYHGWRZDUGWKHPDQGWRVVHGEDFN0DQG\¶VORQJWUHVVHV GUHZXSKHUVNLUWDQGGLVSOD\HGPRUHOHJ 7KDWDOOGHSHQGVORYH\

 2QZKDW" DVNHGWKHEUD]HQ\RXQJSDVVHQJHUOHWWLQJKLVKDQG GULIWXS0DUWLQ VOHJ  :KHWKHU\RXOLNHFKHZLQJRQPHDWEDOOV



7KHFDUVSHGDZD\DQG0DUWLQEXUVWRXWODXJKLQJ 'LG\RXVHH KLVH[SUHVVLRQ"

 +RZFRPHWKH\GRQ WVXVV\RXUGHHSUDVS\YRLFH"

 $IDLUIHZIDPRXVDFWUHVVHVKDYHHTXDOO\UDVS\WRQHVRQHLQ SDUWLFXODUZKRP,XVHGDVDUROHPRGHO

 &RPHWRWKLQNRILW VDLG&KDUOLHJODQFLQJDWKLVUHGORFNV FDVFDGLQJGRZQDURXQGKLVIDFH ,FRXOGJLYHDJRRGJXHVVDVWRZKR \RXPRGHOOHG\RXUVHOIRQJLYHQ\RXUVOLPEXLOGDQGKROORZIHDWXUHV

0DUWLQWKHQQRWLFHGDORQHILJXUHDKHDGDZKLWH0HUFHGHV DSSURDFKLQJ 7KLVLVLW KHVDLGZDWFKLQJDVOHHNVWUHWFKOLPRXVLQH VORZGRZQDQGSXOOXSDWWKHIDUHQGRQWKHRSSRVLWHVLGHRIWKHURDG +HZDVDOUHDG\UHWULHYLQJDQRWHSDGIURPKLVEDJWRSHQGRZQWKH UHJLVWUDWLRQQXPEHU 'RQ WUXVKIRUZDUGMXVWIODJGRZQDSDVVLQJ WD[L:H OOVRRQJHWLWWRWXUQDURXQG

&KDUOLHOHDSWDWWKHILUVWRQHDSSURDFKLQJEXWLWVZHSWSDVW6KH IUDQWLFDOO\WULHGVHYHUDOPRUH0HDQWLPHWKH\NHSWZDONLQJWRZDUGWKH OLPRXVLQHZKLFKZDVQRZSXOOLQJDZD\IURPWKHNHUEWRZDUGWKHP +HUOXFNVHHPHGWREHRXWZLWKHYHU\WD[LVKHDWWHPSWHGKDLOLQJWKHQ DVLIE\PDJLFD6DDEURDUHGWRZDUGWKHPDQGEUDNHG7KHSDVVHQJHU GRRUZDVIOXQJRSHQDQGVKHUHFRJQLVHG/XNH VYRLFHDVKHVKRXWHG IRUWKHPWRJHWLQ 

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¶WDQG RQFHRQWKHPRWRUZD\LWVVSHHGLQFUHDVHGPHDVXUDEO\VR &ORVHSUR[LPLW\LQWKHFRQILQHVRI/XNH¶VFDUDQGKLVVHHPLQJ FRQFHUQIRUKHUVLVWHUOHG&KDUOLHWREHOLHYHWKHUHFHUWDLQO\ZDVPRUH WKDQPHUHIULHQGVKLSEHWZHHQ$UFWLF$XUDDQGKHUVLVWHU6XFK WKRXJKWVKXUWDQGVKRXOGQ WKDYH:K\FRXOGQ WVKHOHWXQVDYRXU\ WKRXJKWVDERXW/XNHGULIWDIWHUDOOVKH GMXVWVDPSOHG0DUWLQZKR KDGQ¶WVRXJKWDQ\NLQGRISRZHUJDPHSOD\+H¶GJHQXLQHO\ZDQWHG WRSOHDVHQRWQHFHVVDULO\ZLWKDQ\NLQGRIUHZDUG:LWKWKDWWKRXJKW LQPLQGVKHUHDFKHGRXWWRKLPLQDPRPHQWRIQHHG\FRPIRUW+H LPPHGLDWHO\FODVSHGKHUKDQGVTXHH]HGLWUHDVVXULQJO\DQGVDLG 

 3DXOD VJRWDVHQVLEOHKHDGRQKHUVKRXOGHUV6KH¶OOPDNHFRQWDFW WKHILUVWFKDQFHVKHJHWV

&KDUOLHZRQGHUHGKDG/XNHQRWLFHGWKHFORVHQHVVEHWZHHQKLV WZRFRPSDQLRQVEXWKHVDLGQRWKLQJDQGVHHPLQJO\NHSWKLVH\HVRQ WKHFDUDKHDGVLJQDOOLQJWRWXUQRIIWKHPRWRUZD\ %HIRUHORQJWKH\ZHUHQHJRWLDWLQJFRXQWU\URDGVUHOLDQWXSRQ WKHUHDUOLJKWVRIWKH0HUFHGHVIRUGLUHFWLRQEHFDXVH/XNHKDGGRXVHG WKH6DDE¶VKHDGOLJKWV:KHQWKH0HUFHGHVVXGGHQO\YDQLVKHG/XNH SXOOHGLQWRWKHURDGVLGHDQGVZLWFKHGRIWKHLJQLWLRQ,WWRRNEXWDIHZ VHFRQGVWRORFDWHWKHEHDPRIKHDGOLJKWVZHQGLQJWKURXJKZRRGODQG DVKDGRZ\VWUXFWXUHZLWKOLJKWHGZLQGRZVDWJURXQGOHYHOLPSO\LQJ ODUJHFRXQWU\KRXVHDWDERXWIRXUKXQGUHGPHWUHV  ,GRQ¶WNQRZKRZZHPLVVHGWKHWXUQEXWMXVWDVZHOOWKDWZH GLGRUZHPLJKWKDYHHQGHGXSDWWKHIURQWGRRURIZKDWHYHUOLHV \RQGHU¶UHPDUNHG/XNHGLVFDUGLQJKLVVHDWEHOWµ
 :KHUHDUH\RXJRLQJ" DVNHG&KDUOLHSODFLQJKHUKDQGRQ/XNH V DUP



3DWWLQJKHUKDQGLQDFRQGHVFHQGLQJPDQQHUKHLJQRUHGKHU TXHVWLRQ -XVWEHDJRRGJLUODQGZDLWKHUH :LWKWKDWVDLGKHOHIW WKHPLQWKHGDUNQHVVDQGGLVDSSHDUHG



)LYH 7HQPLQXWHVKDGSDVVHGDQGDOPRVWIUR]HQWRGHDWK&KDUOLHDQG 0DUWLQFXGGOHGXSFORVHRQWKHEDFNVHDWPRUHOLNHDGROHVFHQW PLVFKLHYRXVVFKRRONLGVDVHDFKSK\VLFDOO\DQGYHUEDOO\WHDVHGWKH RWKHUEHWZHHQILWWLQJO\MXYHQLOHVSDWHVRIWKHJLJJOHV 
UHPDUNHG&KDUOLH  6XFKDV"


2RK\RXQDXJKW\WKLQJ$OOKDUGDQGSXOVLQJKXK"

 0DQG\VD\V0DUWLQKDVWREHKDYHZKHQLQ/XNH¶VFDUVRQR KDQN\SDQN\QRWMXVWQRZ¶ 

 :KDW VZURQJZLWKQRZ"¶UHWRUWHG&KDUOLHKHUVXON\WRQH LQGLFDWLYHRIZRUVHWHDVHWRFRPH $UH\RXVD\LQJ0DQG\LVQRWXS IRUGRLQJGLUW\WKLQJVLQWKHEDFNRIDFDURUMXVWQRWLQ/XNH¶VFDU"

 'RQ WGRWKLVWRPH0DGDPLW VEORZLQJP\PLQG¶  $UH\RXDIUDLGRIEHLQJFDXJKW"

 1R0DGDPEXW, PQRWVXUH,FDQNHHS0DUWLQLQFKHFNLI\RX NHHSWDQWDOLVLQJWKHERWKRIXV

&KDUOLHVOLGKHUKDQGEHWZHHQKHUOHJVDQGIHOWIRU0DUWLQ¶V XQUHVWUDLQHGHUHFWLRQSXVKLQJXSZDUG :HOOLQWKDWFDVHOHW0DUWLQRXW WRSOD\ VKHZKLVSHUHG6KHWKHQUDLVHGKHUEXWWRFNVVOLJKWO\LQRUGHU WRVOLGH0DQG\¶VVNLUWKLJKHU 7KDW VPRUHOLNHLWQRZ0DUWLQFDQ VOLGHLQWRPHZLWKHDVHDQG0DQG\DQG&KDUOLHFDQEDWWOHLWRXW PRXWKWRPRXWK¶ 0DQG\¶VURXJHGOLSVSXUVHGFRQVSLFXRXVO\DVVKHKHOGKHUEUHDWK XSRQIHHOLQJ&KDUOLH¶VILQJHUVFODVS0DUWLQ¶VWKUREELQJVKDIW6KH WKHQVLJKHGDV0DUWLQVHQVXDOO\VDYRXUHGPRLVWIOHVKVWUHWFKLQJILUVWO\ DURXQGEHIRUHWKHILQDOH[TXLVLWHVHQVDWLRQRI&KDUOLH¶VFXQWOLSV VORZO\VZDOORZLQJKLPZKROH&KDUOLHPXUPXUHGVRPHWKLQJ LQGLVFHUQLEOHDVVKHVOLGGRZQLWVULJLGSURSRUWLRQVDQGZKHQVKH JURXQGKHUKLSV0DQG\UHYHOOHGLQ0DUWLQ¶VXQGRXEWHGSOHDVXUHRID 

FRFNKHDGVXEMHFWHGWRVHQVXDOXSDQGGRZQFDUHVVHVHQRXJKWR GLVWUDFWDQ\PDQIURPWKRXJKWVRWKHUWKDQLPPLQHQWJUDWLILFDWLRQ 0DQG\¶VOHIWKDQGVRRQGULIWHGWRDEUHDVWVKURXGHGE\ZRROOHQ IDEULFILQJHUVDOOWKHZKLOHPDQLSXODWLQJDEXUJHRQHGRUEEHQHDWK ,QQHUXUJHWRXQEXWWRQ&KDUOLH¶VGUHVVDQGIRQGOHEDUHIOHVKZDV XWWHUO\LUUHVLVWLEOHDQGGXO\UHFWLILHGE\KDVW\SRSSLQJRIEXWWRQV WKURXJKEXWWRQKROHV &KDUOLHLPPHGLDWHO\UHVSRQGHGWR0DQG\¶VDGYDQFHE\ UHSRVLWLRQLQJRIKHUGHOWDUHJLRQ+HUVXEWOHPRYHPHQWGRXEO\ HIIHFWLYHDV0DUWLQJURDQHGWRWKHVZLYHOPRWLRQDSSOLHGWRKLV XSVWDQGLQJURGDQG0DQG\JDLQHGRUDODFFHVVWRKHDYLQJEUHDVWV$ UDVSLQJWRQJXHVZLIWO\GHOLYHUHGPRLVWHQHGQLSSOHVIRUWKHVXFNLQJRI EXWWKHFRXSIRU0DQG\ZDVWKHUHODWLYHHDVHZLWKZKLFKVKHFRXOG VOLGHILQJHUVEHWZHHQ&KDUOLH¶VOHJV µ
ZDVVXIIHULQJSK\VLFDOWRUPHQWDQG&KDUOLHVDZQRUHDVRQIRUPHUF\ µ6R0DQG\FDQOLFNXSKLVPHVVWKHQFDQ¶WVKH"¶ &KDUOLHKDOIODXJKHGIRUKHUVXJJHVWLRQVHQW0DUWLQLQWRDOPRVW LPPHGLDWHRYHUVSLOO$V0DQG\JDVSHGIRUEUHDWKPLGVXFNOHRID URV\QLSSOH&KDUOLHURVHWRWKHFUHVWRIDJLJDQWLFRUJDVPLFZDYH 7KHLUOLSVVXGGHQO\PHUJHGWRQJXHVSURELQJWKHQWKDWKHDYHQO\ PRPHQWRIVOLSSLQJLQWRWKHGHSWKVRIPXWXDOSOHDVXUHWRRNKROG 0DUWLQ¶VERG\FRQWLQXHGVKXGGHULQJEHQHDWKIRUORQJHUWKDQ H[SHFWHGDQGZKHQ0DQG\VWDUWHGVKHGGLQJWHDUV&KDUOLHIHOWDVHQVH RIH[WUHPHJXLOW  2K0DQG\0DUWLQ¶&KDUOLHPDGHWRJHWRII0DQG\¶VODS, GLGQ¶WPHDQWRXSVHW\RX¶ 
 ,ZRQ W,SURPLVH VDLG&KDUOLHUHDVVXULQJO\IRULWZDVWKHILUVW WLPHVKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGDPDQVKHGGLQJWHDUVDIWHUVH[6KHJXHVVHG DOOPDQQHURIPL[HGHPRWLRQVZHUHZKLUOLQJLQDKHDG\FRFNWDLOIRU 0DUWLQDQG0DQG\µ,JXHVVLW¶VKDUGWRGLIIHUHQWLDWHEHWZHHQ0DQG\¶V DQG0DUWLQ¶VQHHGVVRPHWLPHV"¶ 

µ
ZLWKDJX\0DUWLQDYRLGVSHQHWUDWLRQHLWKHUZD\ZLWKGLFNPXVFOH\HW 0DQG\JRHVDEXQGOHRQDGLOGRVKRYHGXSKHUDVV¶ µ$KTXLWHDGLOHPPDWKRXJKLWFRXOGEHWKDW\RXVLPSO\ZDQW 0DQG\DURXQGWRMXVWLI\WKHDQDOSHQHWUDWLRQIDFWRU0DUWLQWKHUHDO \RXLVWKHQVHWIUHHIURPDQ\JXLOW¶ µ6RXQGVVLPSOHSXWOLNHWKDWEXWLW¶VIDUPRUHFRPSOLFDWHGWKDQ \RXPLJKWWKLQN7DNHQRZIRUH[DPSOH0DUWLQ¶VVHPLIODFFLGEXW VWLOOLQVLGHRI\RXEHFDXVHKHFDQ¶WEHDUWRORVHSK\VLFDOFRQWDFWWKH LQWLPDWHSK\VLFDOFRQWDFWRIKDYLQJLPSODQWHGKLPVHOILQVLGHD ZRPDQ$VIRU0DQG\6KHZDQWVWRJHWDW\RXUFXQWZLWKKHUPRXWK ZDQWVWRIXFN\RXUHYHU\RULILFHZLWKILQJHUVDQGWRQJXHDWWKHVDPH WLPHVKHZRXOGQ¶WPLQGLI\RXVSURXWHGDGLFNDQGVKDIWHGKHUJRRG¶ µ6R"¶ µ'RQ¶W\RXVHHWKDW¶VZKHUHWKHFRQIXVLRQOLHV¶ µ:HOODFWXDOO\,¶GVD\0DUWLQLVJHWWLQJRIIRQWKLVFKLWFKDWµIRU KLVWKLUGOHJLVEHJLQQLQJWRFOLPEVWHDGLO\XSZDUGDQGRQO\\RXFDQ WHOOPHLILW¶V0DUWLQRU0DQG\ZKR¶VGLGGOLQJZLWKP\FOLW¶ µ1RWVXUHDWWKLVMXQFWXUH¶UHSOLHG0DUWLQEDFNKDQGLQJVPXGJHG OLSVWLFNIURPKLVPRXWKµ)HHOVJRRG¶XWWHUHGPLGJURDQDVKHWRRN &KDUOLH¶VPRXWKZLWKIRUFHIXOLQWHQW7KHFOLQFKODVWHGEXWDPHUH GHOLJKWIXOPRPHQWEHIRUHKHILQDOO\VDLG
PDNH\RXUVHOIGHFHQW¶+LVDWWHQWLRQZDVVXGGHQO\GLVWUDFWHGWKRXJK DFRXSOHRIXSZDUGWKUXVWVVXFFHVVIXOO\DFKLHYHGEHIRUH&KDUOLHWRR FDXJKWDJOLPSVHRIZKDWORRNHGGHFLGHGO\OLNHDFLJDUHWWHJORZLQWKH VXUURXQGLQJGDUNQHVV 6KHLPPHGLDWHO\OHDSWIURP0DUWLQ¶VODSERWKLQWHQWRQ UHDUUDQJLQJWKHLUFORWKLQJDVRQFHDJDLQ0DQG\¶VSHUVRQDZDV SUHVHQWHGWRWKHRQFRPLQJVKDGRZ\SUHVHQFH &KDUOLHJODQFHGWRZDUGWKHVKDGRZ\ILJXUHE\QRZPDNLQJLWV ZD\DORQJWKHVLGHRIWKHFDUDQGZKLVSHUHG +RZORQJGR\RXWKLQN KHZDVVWDQGLQJWKHUHEHIRUHKHHPHUJHGRQWRWKHURDG"

 +HZDVQ WDVIDUDV,NQRZ-XVWDSSHDUHG

&KDUOLHKDGDOUHDG\EXWWRQHGXSDQGGXO\VOLGWRWKHRWKHUVLGHRI WKHEDFNVHDWIHHOLQJVOLJKWO\JXLOW\EXWZK\"'DPQLWWKH\ GKDGWR GRVRPHWKLQJWRNHHSZDUP /XNHWKHQRSHQHGWKHFDUGRRUDQGVOLGLQWRWKHGULYLQJVHDWIXOO\ DZDUHRUVR&KDUOLHLPDJLQHGWKDWLQGHHGVRPHWKLQJKDGEHHQJRLQJ RQLQWKHUHDURIWKHFDU+LVWRQHRIYRLFHWKRXJKLPSOLHGQR NQRZOHGJHRIZLFNHGGRLQJV  3DXOD VLQWKHUHDQGQRZDOOZHQHHGLVIRURQHRI\RXWRPDNH FRQWDFWDQGJHWLQWKHUHZLWKKHU

 7KDW VJRLQJWREHHDVLHUVDLGWKDQGRQH VQDSSHG&KDUOLH 

/XNHWXUQHGDUPUHVWLQJRQWKHIURQWVHDW


6L[ :KHQWKH\DUULYHGDW3DXOD VIODW/XNHDFFHSWHG&KDUOLH¶VLQYLWDWLRQWR VWD\IRUDFRIIHH6KH¶GVHQVHGZLWKGUDZDOIRUKLVSDUWWKURXJKRXWWKH MRXUQH\DQGKHVWLOOVHHPHGPLOHVDZD\LQWKRXJKWZKHQVKHSDVVHG RYHUDPXJRIPLON\FRIIHHDVUHTXHVWHG6KHEULHIO\WRXFKHGKLVKDQG LQSDVVLQJKHWKHQORRNHGXSDVLIILQDOO\KDYLQJUHJLVWHUHGKHU SUHVHQFH &KDUOLHVHWWOHGGRZQRSSRVLWHSRQGHULQJZK\0DUWLQKDGPDGH KLVH[FXVHVDQGVLGOHGRIKRPHUDWKHUWKDQVWD\1RWWKDWLWPDWWHUHG WKH\ GJUDEEHGDEDUVQDFNDQGDTXLFNGULQNLQDFRXQWU\SXEHQ URXWHDQG/XNHKDGQ¶WVDLGDQ\WKLQJWRVXJJHVWKHKDGWZLJJHGVXEWOH LQWLPDWHWRXFKLQJEHWZHHQKLVSDVVHQJHUV 6KHJODQFHGDW/XNHDQGDOLWWOHVXUSULVHGWRVHHKHZDVZDWFKLQJ KHUVKHVHQVHGDIOXVKWRKHUIDFH7KHUHZDVQRWDJOLPPHURID VSDUNOHRUDQ\WKLQJWRLQGLFDWHDVLJQRIZDUPWKHPDQDWLQJIURPKLP  3DXODRQ\RXUPLQG" VKHWHQGHUHG 
&KDUOLHVLSSHGFRIIHHWKHQVDLG 6RWHOOPHZKDW\RX UHWKLQNLQJ



/XNHWHQWDWLYHO\VPLOHGWKHQUDNHGILQJHUVWKURXJKKLVGDUNKDLU EHIRUHFKXFNOLQJRXWORXG :KDW, PWKLQNLQJDWWKLVPRPHQWPLJKW QRWEHWR\RXUWDVWH

 7U\PH FKDOOHQJHG&KDUOLHFXUOLQJXSKHUOHJVWRVOLGHWRHV XQGHUWKHHYHUSUHVHQWWDEE\ VORQJIXU  :KHQ,JRWEDFNLQWRP\FDUHDUOLHU,FDQ¶WIDWKRPZK\EXW, LPDJLQHG\RXUKDYLQJKDGVH[ZLWK0DQG\$WXUQRQLQRQHVHQVH WKRXJK,KDGQ WUHFNRQHGRQ\RXUIDQF\LQJ\RXURZQNLQG

&KDUOLHIHOWWKHIOXVKWRKHUFKHHNVDQGEOXUWHG 0DUWLQLVQ W

EHIRUHWKHUHDOLW\RIZKDWKDGSDVVHGKHUOLSVDQGWKHLQWHQVLW\LQ /XNH VH\HVVWRSSHGKHUZDONLQJGHHSHULQWRDPLQHILHOGRIKLV PDNLQJ  0DUWLQLVQ WZKDW"

&KDUOLHSODFHGKHUPXJRQWKHRFFDVLRQDOWDEOHDQGOHDSWWRKHU IHHW
/XNHVDWTXLWHVWLOOKLVGDUNH\HVURYLQJRYHUKHUFRQWRXUVDV WKRXJKHYLGHQFHRIWDPSHULQJZDVWKHUHIRUDQ\RQHORRNLQJIRUFOXHV

$QG\RXWHPSWHGKLPWRSOD\MXVWWRVHHLIKHZDVIDNLQJ KH FKDUJHGZKLFKIXHOOHGFRQWHPSW  :KDW VZURQJZLWKWKDW",ZDQWHGWRWHVWKLPVHHLI0DQG\KDG RWKHUIHHOLQJVDQGQHHGV



$QGGLGVKH"


.QRZZKDW" VDLG/XNHEHIRUHWDNLQJDORQJGUDXJKWRIFRIIHH 
1RZNLVVPHOLNH\RXZDQWWR

&KDUOLHVWHSSHGEDFNLQKDOHGGHHSO\H[KDOHGQHUYRXVO\WKHQ VDLG
&KDUOLHZDQWHGWRODVKRXWDWKLVVPXJVHOIVDWEHIRUHKHUIRUKLV H\HVZHUHJORZLQJZLWKWKHILUHVRIKHOODQGGDQJHURXVO\SXVKLQJKHU WRKHUOLPLWVRIWROHUDQFH+HNQHZDOOULJKW+H GEHHQVWDQGLQJ 

ZDWFKLQJWKHPDQGQRZKHZDVZDLWLQJIRUWKHFRQIHVVLRQVRWKDWKH FRXOGUHMHFWDQGKXPLOLDWHKHU6WRUPRXWRI3DXOD VIODWDQGOHDYHKHU LQDKLJKO\DURXVHGVH[XDOIHYHU+RZGDUHKHKDYHWKHSRZHUWRVWLU HPRWLRQVDQGWKHQTXHOOWKHPZLWKKLVLF\WRQJXH,IRQO\KHZRXOGGR ZKDWVKHZDQWHGDQGQHHGHGLQVWHDGRIWU\LQJWRPDNHKHUPDNHWKH ILUVWPRYH6KHVWXEEHGRXWWKHFLJDUHWWHZLWKDIUXVWUDWHGJHVWXUHDQG WXUQHGWRIDFHKLP  , PJRLQJWREHGVREHDJRRGER\DQGOHW\RXUVHOIRXW


7KHWLJKWKROGRQKHUZULVWDVKHGUDJJHGKHUWRZDUGWKHVWDLUFDVH KXUWPRUHVRDVKHUIUHHKDQGIODLOHGDQGODVKHGRXWDWKLP:KHQKHU QDLOVDFFLGHQWDOO\VODVKHGKLVFKHHNKHLJQRUHGDWKLQWULFNOHRIEORRG UXQQLQJGRZQKLVIDFHDQGRQWRKLVFROODUXQWLOWKH\UHDFKHGWKH ODQGLQJ  0DNHDPHQGV\RXZLOGFDW1RZ KHGHPDQGHGGUDZLQJKHU FORVHDJDLQVWKLVERG\ 

&KDUOLHFRXOGQ¶WEHVXUHKHKDGVHHQKHUDQG0DQG\GRLQJWKHVH[ WKLQJLQWKHEDFNRIKLVFDUEXWVKH¶GDVJRRGDVFRQILUPHGVKHKDGE\ GHIDXOWRIGHIHQGLQJKHUVHOILQWKHIDFHRIKLVVRFDOOHGFRQIHVVLRQRI LPDJLQHGVH[XDOJDPHSOD\6KHUDLVHGKHUILQJHUVWRKLVFKHHN VHQVHGPRPHQWDU\YXOQHUDELOLW\DERXWKLP /XNH, PVRUU\ VKH ZKLVSHUHGOHWWLQJKHUOLSVEUXVKKLV7KHPRPHQWDU\VHQVXDOHPEUDFH WKDWIROORZHGZDVRQHRIWUXFHDQGHPRWLRQDOUHVSRQVHWKDWKDG IRUPHUO\NHSWWKHPDSDUWµ6RUU\IRUEHLQJVRSULFNO\¶ /XNHHDVHGDZD\IURP&KDUOLHDQGNLVVHGKHUQRVH %HG\RXQJ ODG\DQGGRQ WDUJXH, OOVHH\RXLQWKHPRUQLQJ

 %XW,WKRXJKW

 7KDW,ZDQW\RX" 7KHVPLOHDQGNLVVEHVWRZHGZDVWKDWRID YLFWRUNQRZLQJKHFDQWDNHZKDWKHZDQWVZKHQKHZDQWVDQGQRW EHIRUH ,GREXW,FDQZDLWDQG\RXKDYHDEXV\VFKHGXOHDKHDGRI \RXZKDWZLWK\RXUWULSEDFNWRWKHFRXQWU\WRPRUURZDQGWKHQEDFN KHUHWRPH\HVPH2XUZDQWLQJDOLWWOHORQJHUZLOOEHDOOWKHPRUH JUDWLI\LQJFRPHWKHULJKWPRPHQWLQWLPH

&KDUOLHWKRXJKW2.LIWKDW¶VWKHZD\KHZDQWVWRSOD\,¶PDOO IRULWEXWWKDWGRHVQ¶WPHDQKH¶OOZLQKDQGVGRZQZKHQKLVPRPHQWLQ WLPHKDSSHQVDORQJ ,VWKDWDGHILQLWHGDWHWKHQ"



 -XVWUHPHPEHUZKHUH3DXODLVDQGZKDW\RXKDYHWRDFKLHYH ILUVW

 /XNHKDYH\RXDQG3DXOD:KDW,PHDQLV

 1HYHU¶KHFXWLQµ6WULFWO\EXVLQHVV +HWKHQWXUQHGDQGKHDGHG GRZQWKHVWDLUFDVHWRWKHPDLQGRRU , OOULQJ\RXWRPRUURZDERXW ILYHDQGZKHQ\RXFRPHEDFNPDNHP\SODFH\RXUEDVH*RRGQLJKW P\OLWWOHZLOGFDW¶



6HYHQ 7KHVQRZFUXQFKHGXQGHU&KDUOLH¶VIHHWDV'DQWHVNLGGHGWRDKDOW EHIRUHKHUZLWKDWZLJLQKLVPRXWK+HZDVHDJHUWRHQJDJHKLV PLVWUHVVLQPXWXDOSOD\LQZKLFKVKHZRXOGVHQGKLPIODLOLQJWKURXJK WKHZKLWHIXQVFDSHWRUHWULHYHKLVSUL]HGSRVVHVVLRQRIWKHGD\ $V&KDUOLHFRPSOLHGZLWKKLVZLVKHVVKHKHDUGWKHSKRQHULQJLQJ LQGRRUV6KHGDVKHGIRULWRQO\WRUHDFKDGHDGOLQH 'DPQ,EHW LWZDV/XNHKXVWOLQJIRUQHZV

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

LQWRWKHGHSWKVRIWKH&RWVZROGV:KHQKHUPRELOHVXGGHQO\UDQJD VHQVHRIIRUHERGLQJJDYHULVHWRQHUYRXVWHQVLRQWKRXJKZKHQVKH ILQDOO\SLFNHGLWXSKHDUWPLVVLQJEHDWDIWHUEHDWVKHOHWRXWDVLJKRI UHOLHI  2K*RG,WKRXJKWLWZDVKLP

 1RVXFKOXFNEXWVRPHWKLQJ VKDSSHQLQJ¶  6XFKDV" VKHVDLGFXWWLQJ/XNHPLGVHQWHQFH  1RWVXUH,WKLQNLW VWLPHZHWRRNDFORVHUORRNDWWKDWPDQVLRQ KRXVH&DQ\RXJHWXSKHUHE\WRQLJKW"

 ,FDQEHWKHUHE\WKLVDIWHUQRRQLI,EULQJ'DQWHZLWKPHRQO\P\ GRJVLWWHUQHHGVDOLWWOHQRWLFHEHIRUHVKH OOFRPHRYHU

 )LQHZHFDQXVHKLPDVDQH[FXVHIRUZDONLQJWKHIRRWSDWKV

 :KHUHVKDOO,PHHW\RX"

 , YHUHQWHGDOLWWOHFRWWDJHFORVHWRWKHHVWDWH5LQJPHZKHQ\RX JHWLQWR&LUHQFHVWHUDQG, OOGLUHFW\RXLQ  6HH\RXODWHUWKHQ¶  :HDUVRPHWKLQJZDUPEXWHDVLO\DFFHVVLEOH

 :KDWDUH\RXVXJJHVWLQJ"

 %HDJRRGJLUODQGVHHZKDWFDQKDSSHQZKHQLQWKHZRRGVZLWK DZROIDWODUJH



&KDUOLHUHSODFHGWKHSKRQHZLWKDZDUPJORZHQYHORSLQJ :HOO 'DQWHZH UHRIIRQDQHZDGYHQWXUHWRJHWKHU¶ %HIRUHVKHUHDFKHGWKHVWDLUVWKHPRELOHUDQJDJDLQDQGZLWKD VHQVHRIWUHSLGDWLRQVKHNQHZZKRLWZDVEHIRUHKHVSRNH+LVYRLFH VHHPHGKXVNLHUWKDQHYHUDVKHJDYHLQVWUXFWLRQVWREHIROORZHG GLUHFWO\LQFOXVLYHRIVHWWLPHIRUKHUSLFNXS+LVPDQQHUZDVYHU\ PDWWHURIIDFWDQGVHHPLQJO\QRWLPHIRUVH[\FKDWWKRXJKLPSOLHG SOHDVXUHDSOHQW\XSRQWKHLUILQDOO\JHWWLQJWRPHHW 6R''D\ZDVSODQQHG4XDVLKDGUXQJDVSURPLVHG$WWKUHH R¶FORFNVKDUSVKHZDVWRVWDQGRXWVLGHWKH+RUVH 3ORXJKSXEOLF KRXVHFORVHWR7HWEXU\QRWDQLJKWFOXE6RZK\WKLVVXGGHQFKDQJH RISLFNLQJSHRSOHXSLQWKHRSHQ" $WSUHFLVHO\WKUHHR FORFN&KDUOLHVSRWWHGDVWUHWFK0HUFHGHV DSSURDFKLQJDQGWKHFKDQFHVRIWZRRQWKDWVHFWLRQRIURDGZDVQRW LPSRVVLEOHEXWPRVWXQOLNHO\:KHWKHULWZDVRQHDQGWKHVDPHDV ZKLVNHGKHUVLVWHUDZD\ZDVWRWDOO\LUUHOHYDQWVKHZDVQRZDERXWWR GLVDSSHDUIURP/XNH¶VYLVLRQ 

$VH[SHFWHGWKH0HUFHGHVGUHZXSDORQJVLGHDQGDFKDXIIHXU OHDSWRXW:KDWZDVEHIRUHKHUZDVXQNQRZQDQGRQFHVKHVWHSSHG LQVLGHWKHOLPRVKHZDVRQKHURZQIRU/XNHFRXOGRQO\IROORZLQD KLUHGFDUDWDGLVFUHHWGLVWDQFH+H¶GVDLGKHZRXOGPDNHVXUHVKHZDV WDNHQWRWKHPDQVLRQKRXVHQRWHOVHZKHUHDQGKH¶GIXUWKHUSURPLVHG KHZRXOGQHYHUEHWRRIDUDZD\WKRXJKVKHFRXOGQ¶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



 7KHUHDUHVODYHVHQRXJKGHDUODG\DQGPHWKLQNV\RXPRUH VXLWHGWRPLVWUHVVRIWKHKRXVHKROG7KRXJKKRXVHUXOHVZLOODSSO\WR \RXVDPHDVRWKHUYDOXHGVWDII

&KDUOLHVHQVHGWKLVPDQWREH4XDVLDELJERVVPDQ¶VHTXHUU\ HLWKHUWKDWRUKHZDVSXUSRVHIXOO\LPSO\LQJOHVVHUVWDWXV6KHZDV IDLUO\VXUHVKHNQHZZKRWKHKRRGHGPDQZDVDQGWXUQHGWRIDFHKLP  (YHQDPDVNFDQ WKLGH\RXUGLVWLQFWLYHYRLFH


 ,GRQ WQHHGWR1LNREXW,GRZDQWWRNQRZZKHUH3DXODLVDQG ZKHWKHUVKH VDOOULJKW

 2IFRXUVHVKHLV
 ,GRQ WUHDOO\NQRZ\RXRUZKDW\RX¶UHFDSDEOHRI


&KDUOLHVXGGHQO\UHDOLVHGKHZDVJRLQJWRVHHKHUDOORIKHULQ WKHFDUULJKWQRZ7KHUHZDVQRZD\RIHVFDSLQJKLPZLWKFHQWUDO ORFNLQJDQGVKH¶GKHDUGLWFOLFNWKHYHU\PRPHQWWKHFKDXIIHXUJRW EDFNLQWRWKHGULYLQJVHDWDQGSDUWLWLRQJODVVEHWZHHQWKHFKDXIIHXU 

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
 6KXWXSDQGHQMR\\RXUVHOI KHVDLGVWUHWFKLQJRXWERWKKHU DUPV ,I\RXPDNHWRRPXFKQRLVH, OOSXQLVK\RXODWHU¶ 6KHLQVWDQWO\VHQVHGPHWDOWRXFKIOHVKDQGWRRODWHWRSURWHVWLW VXGGHQO\RFFXUUHGWRKHUWKDWWKLVSDUWLFXODUFDUZDVDPRELOH SOD\URRPIRUNLQN\PLQGHGSDVVHQJHUV:LWKLQVHFRQGVKHUOHJVZHUH VSUHDGZLGHKHUSHOYLVIRUFHGIRUZDUGWRWKHHGJHRIWKHVHDW GLVSOD\LQJDOOKHUJORU\IRUWKHOHDWKHUFODGILHQG :LWKZULVWVDQFKRUHGWRULQJVDWHLWKHUVLGHRIWKHUHDUVHDWDQNOHV PDQDFOHGWRFKDLQVDWWDFKHGWRULQJVLQWKHFDUSHWHGIORRUVKHZDV 

EHLQJVWUHWFKHGDVDKLGGHQZLQFKWLJKWHQHGWKHVODFNLQFKDLQV6KH ZDVUHVWUDLQHGOLNHQHYHUEHIRUHWKLJKVDFKLQJOHJPXVFOHVWDXWDV WKHILHQG¶VILQJHUVJHQWO\IXUURZHGIOHVK\ODELDIROGVDOOWKHZKLOH PHUFLOHVVO\WHDVLQJKHUQXE,WZDVVXEWOHWRUWXUH\HWSOHDVXUDEOHDQG KHZDVRKVRVNLOIXODQGWRRGDPQJRRGDWOHWWLQJKHUDOPRVWSHDNWR RUJDVPEHIRUHFOHQFKLQJDQLSSOHEHWZHHQKLVWHHWK  1LNRGRQ WMXVWWHDVH\RXEDVWDUG$WOHDVWILQJHUIXFNPHLI \RX¶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¶WEHVXUHWKH\ZHUHLQWKHZRRGODQG VXUURXQGLQJWKHPDQVLRQRUWKDWWKHLUGHVWLQDWLRQZDVFORVHHQRXJKWR DOOD\DOPRVWXQEHDUDEOHVXIIHUDQFHWRIXUWKHUWRUWXRXVEOLVV 

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¶WJRLQJWREHOLNHWKDWZDVLW"2K\HVVKHFRXOGIHHOKLP IHHOWKHKHDGRIKLVFRFNWHDVLQJWKHWHQGHULVHGIOHVKKHZDVQRZ VSUHDGLQJZLGHZLWKEUXWDOILQJHUWLSV )XFNPH\RXEDVWDUGIXFNPH

7KHFRQWLQXDOVLOHQFHZDVDOPRVWXQEHDUDEOHDVVKHVHQVHGKLVKRRGHG IDFHPRYLQJFORVHUWRKHUVWKHKHDGRIKLVFRFNQXGJLQJEXWQHYHU TXLWHHQWHULQJLQWRKHU7KHNLVVWKDWIROORZHGFDXVHGPRPHQWDU\ EUHDWKOHVVQHVVWKHQ 'DPQ\RXWRKHOO&DQ¶W\RXDWOHDVWWKUXVWRQFH RUWZLFH"




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

1RZGHDUODG\¶VDLG4XDVLVZLIWO\UHPRYLQJWKHVLONEOLQGIROG µFRPHDQGPHHWWKRVHZKRZLOODWWHQGWR\RXUHYHU\QHHGZKHQ\RXU PDVWHULVRWKHUZLVHHQJDJHG

 7DNHRII\RXUKRRG1LNR,NQRZLW V\RX

 )LUVWWKLQJVILUVWDQGUXOHQXPEHURQH
LIWKH\GLVSOHDVH\RX,WKLQNWKDWZLOOVXIILFHIRUQRZWKHUHVW\RX ZLOOTXLFNO\OHDUQXQGHUWKHJXLGDQFHRI$KPHG

 :KRLV$KPHG"


7KHVXGGHQDXWRPDWLFUHOHDVHRI&KDUOLH VDUPVDQGOHJVDOORZHG KHUERG\WRVLQNLQWRWKHSOXVKOHDWKHUVHDWDQGLWZDVDJDLQKHDYHQWR EHIUHHIURPERQGDJHEXWZKDWOD\DKHDGZDVPRUHWKDQWKRXJKW SURYRNLQJ7KHFDUGRRUVXGGHQO\RSHQHG$FROGLF\GUDIWFLUFXODWHG WKHLQWHULRUDVWKHFKDXIIHXULPPHGLDWHO\KDQGHGKHUDVLOYHUIR[IXU FRDW µ$FFHSWWKLVDVDWRNHQRIP\JUDWLWXGH¶VDLG4XDVL %L]DUUHDVLWIHOWVKHZDVZDONLQJLQWRDUHDG\PDGHIDQWDV\QRW KHUVE\DQ\VWUHWFKRIWKHLPDJLQDWLRQIRUVKHZDVWKHUHPHUHO\WRILQG 3DXODDQG0DUWLQ(YHQVR4XDVLGHVHUYHGIXOOPDUNVIRULQQRYDWLRQ HQURXWHWKRXJK1LNRGLGQ¶WGHVHUYHWREHWKRXJKWRIDV4XDVL+H ZDVWKHJRRGORRNLQJRQHWKHFKDXIIHXUPRUH4XDVLOLNH $VFHQGLQJVHYHUDOVWHSVWRDKXJHRDNGRRUKHOGRSHQE\DPDOH GUHVVHGLQPHUHO\DOHDWKHUKDUQHVV&KDUOLHQRWLFHGDORQHQXGH ZRPDQVWDQGLQJLQWKHPLGGOHRIWKHYDVWKDOO+HUVLOKRXHWWHZDV EHDXWLIXOZLWKWKHOLJKWIURPIOLFNHULQJIODPHVLQDVWRQHKHDUWK VHHPLQJO\VHWWLQJKHUKDLU 

DOLJKW  3DXOD"

$V&KDUOLHPDGHWRPRYHWRZDUGKHU1LNRFODVSHGKHUKDQG DQGVQDSSHG :DLWKHUH

 %XW,QHHGWRNQRZ3DXODLV2.DQGQRWKHUHDJDLQVWKHUZLOO

 &DQ\RXVHHDQ\IRUPRIUHVWUDLQW"

 1RWIURPKHUHQREXW

+HFOLFNHGKLVILQJHUV7KHPDOHVODYHVWDQGLQJE\WKHRDNGRRU WKHQZDONHGSDVWWKHPDQGILQDOO\WXUQHGWRIDFHWKHP1RWRQFHGLG &KDUOLHGRXEWLWZDV1LNRVWDQGLQJEHVLGHKHULQWKHOHDWKHUPDVN7KH VODYHWKHQGURSSHGWRRQHNQHHEHIRUHKLP&KDUOLHJODQFHGDW1LNR ZKRVDLG 6KRZ\RXUQHZPLVWUHVVKRZWKHVFXOOHU\PDLGOLNHVWREH VH[XDOO\URXVHGWKHQJLYHKHUDVSHFLDOUHZDUGLIVKHWKDQNV\RX FRUUHFWO\


 ,PSXGHQWGRJ¶EDUNHG1LNRDVKHFUDFNHGDULGLQJFURSDFURVV WKH VODYH VVKRXOGHUµ2Q\RXUNQHHVZKHQDGGUHVVLQJ\RXUPLVWUHVV¶ 

 ,DPTXLWHFDSDEOHRIFKDVWLVLQJVODYHVP\VHOI VQDSSHG &KDUOLHGLUHFWLQJKHUDWWHQWLRQWRWKHVODYH¶VLQWHQVHH\HFRQWDFW DQG LWZRXOGJLYHPHJUHDWSOHDVXUHWRQRWRQO\FKRRVHWKHWDZVHEXW GHFLGHZKDWPHDVXUHVDUHQHFHVVDU\UHJDUGLQJ\RXUEHKDYLRXU 6KH VPLOHGODVFLYLRXVO\OHWWLQJWKHIROGVRIWKHIXUFRDWSDUWVXIILFLHQWO\WR GUDZDJOLQWIURPWKHPDOHVODYH VH\HV 
6KHJODQFHGEDFNWRVHHWZRPDOHVODYHVDSSHDUIURPWKHLQWHULRU WRGUDJWKHNQHHOLQJVODYHERGLO\WRZDUGWKHILUHSODFH1LNRZDVDV JRRGDVD4XDVLLQKHUHVWLPDWLRQIRUKHZDVGLVSOD\LQJDMHDORXVXJO\ VWUHDNDVKHVWURGHDORQJWRFHQWUHJDOOHU\DQGWKHUHSDXVHGWRORRN RYHUWKHZURXJKWLURQEDOXVWUDGH+HSODFHGRQHIRRWRQWKHEDFNRID 

FDUYHGOLRQGLUHFWLQJKLVDWWHQWLRQWR&KDUOLH 1RZ\RXZLOOVHHKLP SXQLVKHGIRUOHWFKLQJ\RXUERG\GHVSLWH\RXUGHOLEHUDWHGLVSOD\IRU KLVH\HVRQO\

&KDUOLHPRYHGFORVHUWR4XDVLDIIRUGLQJKHUIXOOYLHZRIWKH VSHFWDFOHEHIRUHWKHP$OOWKHZKLOH3DXODKDGUHPDLQHGVWDQGLQJ PRWLRQOHVVZKLOVWWKHVODYHZDVPDQKDQGOHGDQGVSUHDGHDJOHGDQG FODSSHGLQLURQVVRFORVHWRWKHILUH&KDUOLHLPDJLQHGLWZRXOGEH XQEHDUDEOHZLWKLQPLQXWHV7KHVODYH¶VVKDGRZFDVWRQWRWKHIDUZDOO DQGSDUWRIWKHFHLOLQJDVKHZULWKHGDQGSXOOHGKLVZHOOPXVFOHGDUPV DJDLQVWUHVWUDLQWVLQDIXWLOHDWWHPSWDWIUHHLQJKLPVHOI7KHPXVFOHVLQ KLVOHJVWHQVHGDVZKLWHNQXFNOHGJULSRQWKHFKDLQVVXVSHQGHGIURP WKHVWRQHZDOODERYHUHYHDOHGLQQHUGHVSDLUDVKHDZDLWHGLQHYLWDEOH SXQLVKPHQW &KDUOLHIHOW4XDVL VKDQGVOLGHDFURVVKHUEDFNWRHYHQWXDOO\JULS KHUVKRXOGHUKLVIUHHKDQGVOLGLQJLQVLGHRIWKHIXUFRDW6KHVKUDQN DZD\IURPLQWHQGHGLQWLPDF\JODGWKDW3DXODFRXOGQ¶WVHHWKHPIURP ZKHUHVKHZDVSRVLWLRQHGEXWXQFRPIRUWDEO\FORVHDOOWKHVDPH4XDVL LPPHGLDWHO\KHOGKHUILUPDQGXQGDXQWHGE\UHVLVWDQFHFDOPO\ FDUHVVHGDEUHDVWIROORZHGE\GHOLEHUDWHSDLQIXOWRUWXUHRIDEXUJHRQHG RUEEHWZHHQILQJHUDQGWKXPE+LVFUXHOW\VWROH&KDUOLH¶VEUHDWKIRUD PRPHQWRUWZRDQGDOWKRXJKLWFURVVHGKHUPLQGWRUHWDOLDWHE\ 

JUDEELQJDWKLVFRFNWRJLYHDVJRRGDVUHFHLYHGVKHWKRXJKWEHWWHURI LWDQGERUHWKHSDLQLQVLOHQFH  ,WKLQNLWZRXOGEHMXVWSXQLVKPHQWIRUWKHVFXOOHU\PDLGWR ZDWFKXVWRJHWKHUGRQ W\RX KHVDLGOHWWLQJKLVPRXWKEUXVKKHU QHFN  'RQ WGRWKLV1LNRQRWLQIURQWRI3DXOD6KHORYHV\RXLWZRXOG EHWRRFUXHODQG,ZRXOGQ WHQMR\LWRQHELW

 &UXHOLIVKHKDGQ¶WVLJQHGDFRQWUDFWRIFRQVHQWWRDFFHSWZKDW HYHUEHIDOOVKHUKHUHLQWKLVKRXVH¶KHVDLGORZHULQJKLVKDQGWRWKH VPDOORI&KDUOLH¶VEDFNµRUIRUWKDWPDWWHUWRZKRHYHUZHFKRRVHWR VHQGKHU¶  :HOO, YHVLJQHGQRWKLQJDQGKDYHQ WDJUHHGWRDQ\WKLQJ


 0D\EH KHJURZOHG EXW\RXFDQ WVD\QRWRSOHDVXUHFDQ\RX"

+HGHOLEHUDWHO\DSSOLHGWRQJXHWRKHUOHIWQLSSOH 7HOOPHWRVWRS +H WKHQGUHZLWLQWRKLVPRXWKUDVSHGLWVKDUGQHVVEHIRUHVXFNOLQJ 

JHQWO\DOOWKHZKLOHOHDWKHUFODGILQJHUVLQVLGLRXVO\YHQWXUHGIURP SXELFPRXQGWRWKUREELQJFOLWRULV 
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¶WKDSSHQQRWHYHUQRWIRU1LNR 1HYHUWKHOHVVVKHVHQVHGKHUVHOIRQWKHEULQNRIJLGG\VH[XDOEOLVV WUHPEOHVRILPPLQHQWRUJDVPLPSRVVLEOHWRKROGEDFNDQ\ORQJHU 

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
WKHUPDOVWRVZLUOLQHFVWDWLFHXSKRULDEXWLWZDVWREHGHQLHG6KHZDV DEDQGRQHGDQGWKHOHDWKHUFODGILJXUHGLUHFWHGKLVDWWHQWLRQWR VRPHRQHHOVHVWDQGLQJFORVHE\3DXODZDVLW3DXOD"'DPQVKH FRXOGQ¶WVHHFOHDUO\FRXOGQ¶WGHILQHWKHQDNHGIRUPDVDQ\WKLQJRWKHU WKDQIHPDOH )UXVWUDWHGE\GHQLDORIRUJDVPLFSOHDVXUH&KDUOLHILQJHUHG KHUVHOIDVEHVWVKHFRXOGDVVKHZDWFKHGKLPOD\WKHRWKHUIHPDOHIRUP IDFHGRZQOHQJWKZD\VRQDFDUYHG-DFREHDQFKHVW6KHKDGYDJXHO\ QRWLFHGLWXSRQHQWU\WRWKHURRP,WZDVSODFHGDWWKHIRRWRIWKHEHG DQG1LNRRQKLVNQHHVIRUFHGKLPVHOILQWR3DXODWKRXJK&KDUOLH FRXOGQ¶WEHDEVROXWHO\VXUHLWZDVKLPDVKHUYLVLRQEOXUUHG (YHU\WKLQJZDVVRPLVW\ZLWKGDUNVKDGRZ\FRUQHUV6KH GHVSHUDWHO\EOLQNHGVHYHUDOWLPHVWU\LQJWRJDLQFOHDUIRFXVRIWKHWZR SHRSOHEHIRUHKHUEXWWRQRDYDLO 1LNRWKHQVDLG 6WRSSOHDVXULQJ\RXUVHOIDQGVWDQGLQIURQWRI PH DQG&KDUOLHNQHZLWZDVGHILQLWHO\KLPIXFNLQJWKHRWKHUZRPDQ 6KHVOLGIURPWKHSOXVKIRXUSRVWHUZLWKJUHDWVWUHQJWKRIPLQGRYHU PDWWHUDQGVWUXJJOHGWRVWDQGEHIRUHWKHPZLWKWKHVLOYHUIR[IXUFRDW DOPRVWEUXVKLQJWKHWKLFNFDUSHWEXWWKDWZDVQ¶WTXLWHZKDWKHKDGLQ PLQGµ*HWXSKHUHQRZULJKWLQIURQWRIPH¶+HFRQWLQXHGKLV WKUXVWLQJDVVDXOWXSRQ3DXODPDNLQJKHUJDVSIURPWLPHWRWLPHDV 

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

FULVSZKLWHKDQGNHUFKLHI+LVKXVN\YRLFHDVKHPRYHGWRZDUGWKHP VHQWDVKLYHUGRZQ&KDUOLH¶VVSLQH  ,¶OOWDNHKHUDZD\QRZ KHVDLG]LSSLQJKLVSDQWVµ6KHFDQ VHUYHWKHPDVWHULQWKHPDQQHUKHKDVEHFRPHDFFXVWRPHGWR¶  'RQ¶WIRUJHWWKHFDUIRUVHYHQWRPRUURZPRUQLQJ VDLG1LNR :KHQWKHFKDXIIHXUVDLGµ2QHRIWKHVHGD\V,PD\FKRRVHWR H[FKDQJHSODFHV¶&KDUOLHWKRXJKWVKHKDGPLVXQGHUVWRRGEXW HYLGHQWO\QRWZKHQ1LNRUDOOLHGZLWK µ
6WXQQHGE\WKHZD\3DXODZDVWKHQOHGDZD\&KDUOLHTXLFNO\ JDLQHGWKHLPSUHVVLRQVKHGLGQ¶WPLQGLQWKHOHDVWLQIDFWDVO\ZLQN DVVXUHGWKDWHYHU\WKLQJZLWK3DXODZDV$2.&KDUOLHVOLGWKH OX[XULRXVIXUIURPKHUVKRXOGHUVDQGODLGLWDFURVVWKHIRRWRIWKHEHG 8QVXUHRIZKDWZDVH[SHFWHGRIKHUVKHVDWDQGZDWFKHGOHDWKHUDWWLUH KDVWLO\UHPRYHGE\1LNRDPXVFXODUIXOO\VKDYHQERG\VRRQUHYHDOHG EXWWKHKRRGLWZDVPDGHSODLQZRXOGUHPDLQDVZDV+HWKHQJURSHG DURXQGLQVLGHWKHFKHVWILQDOO\PRYHGWRZDUGKHUZLWKDSDLURI OHDWKHUFXIIVDQGVKHZDVQRQHWRRKDSS\ZLWKWKHSURVSHFWEHLQJ UHVWUDLQHG 

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

$VKHERGLO\UROOHGRYHUDQGDZD\IURPKHUKHGHFODUHG %H DVVXUHG,ZLOOEHEDFNIRUPRUHRIWKHVDPHEXWQRWWRQLJKW¶+HWKHQ VWURGHDFURVVWRZDUGWKHGRRURSHQHGLWDQGSDXVHGRQH[LWµ6ZHHW GUHDPVP\ODG\VZHHWGUHDPV¶+HSURPSWO\EOHZDNLVVERZHGDQG YDQLVKHG



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

GD\WRGD\+H¶GODXJKHGVDLGWKDWLIHYHUWKHGRRUDWWKH:HVWHQGRI WKHFRUULGRUZDVIRXQGWREHXQORFNHGVKHZRXOGDQVZHUWRKLP SHUVRQDOO\LIVKHGDUHGYHQWXUHEH\RQGLW1HHGOHVVWRVD\VKHKDGQ¶W HYHQWULHGWKHGRRUEHFDXVHKLVOHFKHURXVORRNKDGLPSOLHGVH[XDO GHOLJKWVIRUKLPZLWKXQVDYRXU\IODYRXUIRUKHU 7HOHSKRQHVZHUHVHHPLQJO\IHZDQGIDUEHWZHHQRQWKHJURXQG IORRUDQGZKHQDOORZHGEHORZVWDLUVVKHZDVDOZD\VXQGHUJXDUGDQG VKHKDGQ¶WDV\HWKDSSHQHGXSRQDSKRQHRQWKHXSSHUIORRUV6KHKDG QRZD\RIFRPPXQLFDWLQJZLWKWKHRXWVLGHZRUOGVLPSO\EHFDXVHWKH ZHHNHQGEDJVKH¶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

+HUH\HVVHWWOHGRQDPHDQGHULQJEURRNDQGZRRGHQIRRWEULGJH OHDGLQJIURPWKHZRRGODQGLQWRWKHODZQHGJDUGHQ6KHWKHQQRWLFHG PRYHPHQWQHDUWRDQRYHUJURZQVKUXEEHU\EXWLWZDVGLIILFXOWWR GHILQHZKRLWZDVLQWKHGXVN\JORRPRIHYHQLQJ-XVWWKHQWKHGRRU RSHQHGDQGWKH$KPHGVWHSSHGLQVLGHFORVHO\IROORZHGE\0DQG\ FDUU\LQJDWUD\&KDUOLH¶VKHDUWVNLSSHGDEHDWIRUVKHKDGQ¶WVHHQD IDPLOLDUIDFHVLQFH3DXOD¶VGHSDUWXUHIURPWKDWYHU\VDPHURRP 0DQG\ZHDULQJDEODFNPLQLVNLUWZLWKDIULOO\ZKLWHSLQQ\ VWRFNLQJVDQGVWLOHWWRVVKRZHGQRVLJQRIUHFRJQLWLRQDVVKHSODFHG WKHWUD\RQWKHRFFDVLRQDOWDEOHEHVLGHWKHILUHSODFH 7KHFKDXIIHXUJODQFHGDW&KDUOLH VEDUHIHHWDQGWKHORRVHO\WLHG EXUJXQG\FRORXUHGVLONZUDS ,FRXOGEHWHPSWHGWRVWD\KDG,QRW SURPLVHG\RXWR1LNR+HZLOOH[SHFWWRVHH\RXZHDULQJWKHPLGQLJKW EOXHVDWLQJRZQIRUGLQQHUWKHVLOYHUVWUDSSHGVDQGDOVEODFN ODFHWRSSHGVWD\XSVDQGQRXQGHUZHDU


 +HKDVQRWIRUJRWWHQ\RX7RQLJKW\RXDUHWRSOD\KRVWDQGKHOS HQWHUWDLQRXUJXHVWV


 *XHVWV" FKDUJHG&KDUOLHµ:KDWJXHVWV"¶$KPHGWXUQHGZLWKRXW UHSO\DQGZDONHGIURPWKHURRP$VWKHGRRUFORVHG&KDUOLHDYHUWHG KHUJD]HWR0DQG\ :KHUHKDYH\RX  6KHVWRSSHGPLGVHQWHQFHGXHWR0DQG\KDYLQJUDLVHGILQJHUVWR KHUOLSVIRUFRPSOHWHVLOHQFH0DQG\WKHQSRXUHGPLONIROORZHGE\WHD LQWRDFXSDQGZKLVSHUHG 'RQ WDVNTXHVWLRQV7DNHDJRRGORRNDW WKHJDUGHQERXQGDU\ZKLOHVLSSLQJWHDWKHQIROORZPHLQWRWKH EDWKURRP

&KDUOLHJODQFHGRXWRIWKHZLQGRZH\HVVHDUFKLQJWKHVKUXEEHU\ ZKLFKZDVKDUGO\YLVLEOHLQWKHGDUNHQHGJDUGHQEXWDGLVWDQW PLQXVFXOHJORZJDYHKHUKRSH:DVLWDFLJDUHWWH":DVLW/XNH"7KHQ VKHQRWLFHGWKHTXLFNPRYHPHQWDQGVKDGRZRIDODUJHGRJVNXONLQJ DORQJWKHHGJHRIWKHODZQ6KHZDQWHGWRFDOORXWEXWLIVKHGLGLW ZRXOGRQO\GUDZDWWHQWLRQWR/XNHDQG'DQWH6KHUHOXFWDQWO\PRYHG DZD\IURPWKHZLQGRZSODFHGWKHFXSRQWKHEHGVLGHWDEOHDQG VWUROOHGDFURVVWRWKHEXUJXQG\UHGEDWKURRP 6WHDPZDVDOUHDG\ULVLQJIURPWKHKRWVZLUOLQJZDWHULQWKH VXQNHQEDWKDQG0DQG\PRYHGWRZDUG&KDUOLH ,I0DGDPZLOODOORZ PH  &KDUOLHUHOHDVHGWKHEHOWHGNQRWDQGOHW0DQG\VOLGHWKHUREHIURP KHUVKRXOGHUV 

 7KLVLVEORRG\WRUWXUH ZKLVSHUHG0DQG\ DQG, PGDPQHGJODG , PZHDULQJDFKDVWLW\EHOW

 :KHUHKDYH\RXEHHQ"

 :RXOGQ W\RXOLNHWRNQRZDQGZKDW, YHEHHQGRLQJ7RWHOO\RX WKHWUXWKLWVEHHQUHDVRQDEO\SOHDVXUDEOHVRIDULIVRPHZKDWEL]DUUH, KHDUG\RXUYRLFHVHYHUDOWLPHVEXWXQIRUWXQDWHO\QHYHULQDSRVLWLRQ WRFDWFKDJOLPSVHRI\RX

 :KHUH V3DXOD"

 $OORYHUWKHSODFHDQGWRWDOO\VPLWWHQE\WKHPDVWHULWZRXOG VHHP6KH¶VVLJQHGDFRQWUDFWIRUD\HDU,I\RXJHWFORVHWRKHUDWDOO WRQLJKWGRQ¶WPHQWLRQDQ\WKLQJDERXW/XNHEHLQJLQWKHYLFLQLW\, GRQ¶WNQRZZKHWKHUVKH¶VGUXJJHGRUQRWEHFDXVH,KDYHQ¶WEHHQDEOH WRJHWQHDUKHU:KDWHYHUVKH¶VIDLOHGWRUHVSRQGWRH\HFRQWDFWVR EHVWZHDFFHSWZH¶UHRQRXURZQIURPQRZRQ1RZJHWLQWRWKH ZDWHUDQG, OONQHHOGRZQWRVRDS\RX

6R/XNHNHSWKLVSURPLVHDERXWEHLQJFORVH"

 +H VRXWWKHUHDOOULJKW¶0DUWLQGUHZDVKDUSLQWDNHRIEUHDWKD KDQGGHSOR\HGLPPHGLDWHO\WRKLVFURWFKµ2K*RGZK\GLGWKH\JLYH PHWKLVMRERIVHHLQJWR\RXUSUHSDUDWLRQ

&KDUOLHVPLOHGDV0DQG\LQQHDWSLQQ\VRDSHGKDQGVDQG FDUHVVHGKHUVKRXOGHUVDQGGRZQDFURVVKHUEUHDVWV ,V0DUWLQ 

IUXVWUDWHGDQGZDQWLQJWRSOHDVXUHPHRULV0DQG\TXLWHFRQWHQWWR VHHWRP\HYHU\QHHG

 0DUWLQLVIHHOLQJWKHVWUDLQ0DGDP,I\RXFDUHWRVWHSLQWRWKH UHFHVVEHWZHHQWKHGUHVVLQJURRPDQGEDWKURRPDIWHU, YHILQLVKHG EDWKLQJ\RX0DQG\ZLOOQRORQJHUEHSUHVHQW:HFDQGRQRWKLQJLQ EDWKURRPRUEHGURRP

 :K\QRW"

 %HFDXVHZH UHEHLQJPRQLWRUHG



 'DPQKLPGDPQKLPWRKHOO VDLG&KDUOLHUHDFKLQJIRUWKH WRZHO  'RQ WUXVKWDNH\RXUWLPHDQG, OOVRRWKH\RXUWHPSHUEHIRUH \RXUPDVWHUJHWVEDFN  &KDUOLHUHOD[HGDVEHVWVKHFRXOGEDWKWLPHDWOHDVWDPRPHQWRI UHVSLWHIURPORQHOLQHVV 0DQG\FODVSHG&KDUOLH¶VKDQGWRKHOSKHUDOLJKWIURPWKHEDWK 0DUWLQ VKHDUWWKXGGLQJDVKHVXUYH\HGWKHGDPSHQHGGRZQFORWKLQJ KHUSXELFPRXQG 

 1RZJRDQGZDLWLQWKHVSDFHEHWZHHQWKHGRRUV

&KDUOLHGLGDVELGZDLWLQJIRUERWKGRRUVWRFORVHWKHQ VKHOHWWKHWRZHOIDOODZD\IURPKHUVKRXOGHUV 7KHURWWHQVWLQNLQJ EDVWDUG VKHZKLVSHUHG KH OONQRZHYHU\WLPH, YHKDGDZDQNKDGD SHHDQG

 )RUJHWWKDWIRUQRZ, OOVHHWR\RXUQHHGVLQDPLQXWHEXWILUVW WKLQJVILUVW7RQLJKWWKHPDVWHUKDVDSULYDWHGLQQHUSDUW\DUUDQJHGDQG \RXPD\JHWWKHFKDQFHWRHVFDSHSURYLGLQJ\RXNHHS\RXUKHDG/XNH ZLOOEHZDLWLQJE\WKHZDOOHGNLWFKHQJDUGHQZKLFKLVQRWWKDWIDUIURP WKHFRQVHUYDWRU\

 , PQRWVXUH,FDQUHPHPEHUWKHOD\RXWRIWKDWSDUWRIWKHKRXVH


 ,WLVUDWKHUFRV\ VDLG&KDUOLHUHDFKLQJRXWWROHWKHUKDQGGULIW XSXQGHU0DQG\ VPLQLVNLUW 3DXOD¶VPHUHO\SOD\DFWLQJVKHZLQNHG DWPHWKHRWKHUQLJKW

 'RQ¶WEHWRQLWDQGGUXJVFDQORRVHQDWRQJXH

 %XWVKHNQRZV\RXDQG\RXPXVWKDYHJXHVVHGWKHPDVWHULVQ¶W 1LNRVXUHO\"

 7RRULJKW,GR  

µ,IVKHSOD\VKHUSDUWZHOOHQRXJKRXUFRYHUFDQQHYHUEHEORZQ DQGVKHLVDQDWXUDOVXEPLVVLYH6KHORYHVEHLQJGRPLQDWHG,NQRZ P\VLVWHUNQRZVKHZRXOGQ¶WEHWUD\XV¶&KDUOLH VILQJHUVVRXJKWRXW 0DUWLQ VFKDVWLW\EHOWDQGVWURNHGKLVFRFNDOUHDG\VWUDLQLQJDJDLQVW WKHVWUDSSLQJ ,WKLQN0DQG\KDVJRQHKRPHDQG0DUWLQLVDKXQJU\ ER\

 'RQ WGRWKLVWRPH,QHHGWRNHHSP\PLQGFOHDU

 6RGR,DQGLWVIDLUO\KD]\DWWKHPRPHQW VKHVDLGXQEXFNOLQJ KLVFKDVWLW\EHOW 7HOOPHWKDW0DUWLQGRHVQ¶WZDQWWRVOLGHKLV WKUREELQJFRFNLQWRPHDQG,¶OOVWRSWHDVLQJ

 0DGDPLVDPHUFLOHVVWHDVH UHSOLHG0DUWLQOHWWLQJKLVOHIWDUP FLUFOHKHUVKRXOGHUVKLVIUHHKDQGGHOYLQJEHWZHHQKHUOHJVVHHNLQJ WKHPRLVWRSHQLQJKHFRXOGWRRHDVLO\EHOHGLQWR 5HVLVWDQFHFRXOGQ WKDYHEHHQIXUWKHUIURPKLVPLQGDVKHIHOWWKH UHVWULFWLQJVWUDSVIDOOLQJDZD\IURPKLVWRUWXUHGPHPEHUµ:K\ILJKW WKHLQHYLWDEOH"¶+HVOLSSHGKLVILQJHUVLQWRWKHZHWQHVVRIKHUKRW ERG\EHIRUHFODVSLQJKLVFRFNWRJXLGHLWWRLWVLQWHQGHGGHVWLQDWLRQ  6RWHOOPHZKDW\RX YHEHHQGRLQJ VDLG&KDUOLHUDLVLQJKHUVHOI RQWLSWRHWROX[XULDWHLQWKHVHQVDWLRQRI0DUWLQVOLGLQJKLVFRFNKHDG LQWRKHU 7KDW VZRQGHUIXO0PPWKUXVWJHQWO\ VKHVLJKHGFORVLQJ KHUH\HV 

 0DGDP\RX UHGHOLFLRXVDQGDOOWKHWLPH,ZDVFKDLQHGXSGRZQ LQWKHFHOODU,NHSWWKLQNLQJRI\RXHYHQPRUHVRZKHQDFRXSOHRIWKH VODYHVGHFLGHGWRJLYHPHDJRRGVHHLQJWR

 ,QZKDWZD\" DVNHG&KDUOLHJ\UDWLQJKHUKLSVZKLOVWVWURNLQJKLV ERWWRP  ,WZDVXWWHUWRUWXUHZKHQRQHRIWKHPZUDSSHGKLVOLSVDURXQGP\ NQRE:RUVHZKHQKHSHUIRUPHGGHHSWKURDWIHOODWLR$OO,FRXOGWKLQN RIZDVWKHWLPH,IXFNHG\RXLQWKHEDFNRI/XNH VFDU

 )XFNHGPH",URGH\RXRII

 0DGDPPD\,UHTXHVWDIDYRXU"

 6XFKDV"

 0D\,DWOHDVWEHDOORZHGWRUXQP\WRQJXHRYHU\RXUFOLWEHIRUH \RXULGHPHRIIDJDLQ"

&KDUOLHRSHQHGKHUH\HVDQGVWXGLHGKLVDSSHDOLQJEOXHRQHVDV VKHKHUVHOIHDVHGDZD\IURP0DUWLQ¶VKRWWKUREELQJFRFN 6WRSZKHQ ,WHOO\RXWKRXJKEHFDXVH,ZDQWXVWRFRPHWRJHWKHUOLNHEHIRUH

0DQG\KDGORQJJRQHDV0DUWLQIHOORQKLVNQHHVKXQJU\IRUWKH VRIWQHVVRIKHUVXFFXOHQWFODP+HQX]]OHGLQWRWKHVRIWGRZQWR LQKDOHKHUVZHHWQHVVWKHQOHWKLVOLSVEUXVKDFURVVKHUQXEEHIRUHKLV WRQJXHVOLSSHGEHWZHHQPRLVWZRPDQO\SHWDOV$VKHSUREHGGHHSLQWR 

WKHZDUPWKDQGVWDUWHGVDYRXULQJWKHWH[WXUHRIKHULQQHUIOHVKWKH GRRUWRWKHEHGURRPZDVVQDWFKHGRSHQ 
UHPRYLQJKLVVNLPS\XQGHUSDQWVDQGLQXWWHUVLOHQFHSURFHHGHGWR XQ]LSWKHOHDWKHUKRRG&KDUOLHZDLWHGZLWKEDWHGEUHDWKIRU1LNR V EORQGKDLUWRHPHUJHDQGZKHQKHUDLVHGKLVKHDGDQGORRNHGVWUDLJKW DWKHUVKHJDVSHG 0\*RGZKHUHGLG\RXJHWWKDWVFDUIURP"

 7KLVP\EHDXW\ KHVDLGUXQQLQJKLVIRUHILQJHUGRZQWKHWKLQ OLQHVWUHWFKLQJGLDJRQDOO\IURPKLVULJKWH\HWRHDU LVWKHKDQG\ZRUN RIRXUJXHVWWRQLJKW

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¶VODVFLYLRXVWRQJXH6KH FRXOGIHHO1LNRSORXJKLQJWKURXJKWKHIXUURZVRIKHUPRLVWODELD SXUSRVHIXOO\UXEELQJKLVOHQJWKXSDQGGRZQDFURVVKHUEXG+HZDV LQWHQWRQRQFHDJDLQGULYLQJKHUWRGLVWUDFWLRQLQDVH[XDOO\IUXVWUDWHG 

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
 2KEXW,GLG


&KDUOLHVOLJKWO\DPD]HGKDGQRLQWHQWLRQRIGHQ\LQJKLPRU KHUVHOIWKHSOHDVXUHRIOHWWLQJKLVWRQJXHGRXVHWKHILUHVWLOOEXUQLQJ GHHSLQVLGH6KHVWUDGGOHGKLVIDFHDQGVRIWO\PRDQHGZLWK FRQWHQWPHQWDVKLVPRXWKORFNHGRQDQGKLVWRQJXHOHLVXUHO\VRXJKW WKHLUPLQJOHGMXLFHV7KH VHQVDWLRQVHWKHUPLQGUHHOLQJZLWKYLVLRQVRI/XNH7KHYHU\VHFRQG VKHVXFFXPEHGWR\HWDQRWKHURUJDVPKHUROOHGKHURIIDQGUHJDLQHGD GRPLQDQWSRVLWLRQ µ6KRZVLJQVRIWRRPXFKV\PSDWK\WRZDUG0DQG\WRQLJKWDQG ,¶OOKDQGKHURYHUWR$KPHGIRUWUDQVSRUWDWLRQ

 7UDQVSRUWDWLRQ"

 6KH OOJRZLWK3DXODWRWKH0LGGOH(DVW


 ,NQRZDQ\WKLQJWKDWKDSSHQVKHUHLQWKHKRXVHLVZHOOIDQWDV\ %H\RQGWKHVHZDOOVWKRXJKUHDOLW\DQGIDQWDV\DUHZRUOGVDSDUW

1LNROHDSWWRKLVIHHWFODVSHGKHUKDQGDQGKDOIGUDJJHGKHU WRZDUGWKHEDWKURRP 3DXODFKRVHWRVLJQKHUVHOIRYHUWR$KPHGDIWHU VSHQGLQJWKHODVWWKUHHQLJKWVZLWKKLP6KHZDVQHYHUVXLWHGWRWKH SRVLWLRQRIPLVWUHVVKHUHEHFDXVHXQOLNH\RXVKHFDQQRWLQLWLDWHVH[ 

QRULVVKHHYHUOLNHO\WREHDEOHWRDGPLQLVWHUDWKUDVKLQJWRDQRWKHU SHUVRQ

 0D\EHQRWEXW\RXFDQ WGLVPLVVKHUMXVWOLNHWKDW6KH VLQORYH ZLWK\RX

1LNRIRUFHG&KDUOLHWRVWDQGLQIURQWRIKLPDQGVXUYH\HGKHU SK\VLFDOIHPLQLQHYXOQHUDELOLW\DORQJZLWKWKHZLOGORRNLQKHUH\HV

6KH VLQORYHZLWKWKHZKROHVFHQHRIEHLQJXVHGE\DKDQGVRPH PDVWHUDQG$KPHGLVKDQGVRPHO\HQGRZHGZLWKWKHELJJHVWSULFN,¶YH HYHUVHHQSOXVKHFDQJLYHKHUDOLIHVW\OHEH\RQGKHUZLOGHVW LPDJLQDWLRQ

 0D\EHVREXW,PD\QHYHUVHHKHUHYHUDJDLQ   6KHDFFHSWHGKLVRIIHUVRZKRDUHZHWRGLVSXWHWKHORYHWKH\ VHHPLQJO\KDYHIRUHDFKRWKHU"¶ µ:HOO,FDQIRURQH,¶PKHUVLVWHU¶ µ


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¶VRZQZHDNQHVVDQGSUHGLOHFWLRQWRJRGRZQRQKLVNQHHV KDGVKRZQZKHQKH GWDNHQKHUWRKHLJKWVRIVH[XDOLQVDQLW\ZKLOVWLQ WKHVKRZHU,QDOOIDLUQHVVWR$KPHGLQDWWHQGDQFHIRUPXFKRI 1LNR¶VDEVHQFHKH¶GRQO\LPSOLHGKHFRXOGWDNHKHULILQFOLQHGEXW KDGQ¶WDQGVKHZDVJUDWHIXOIRUWKDWVPDOOPHUF\LIQRWKLQJHOVH6KH UHDOO\KDWHGWKHSODFHDQGKDGQ¶WDFKLHYHGKHULQWHQGHGDLPVDWDOO EXWKRZFRXOGVKHZKHQXQGHUFRQVWDQWJXDUGDQGFRQILQHGWRWKH XSSHUIORRUVDQGKHURZQFRPSDQ\"6KHZDVWRWDOO\LQHIIHFWLYHDVD VS\6KHKDGQ¶WJOHDQHGDGDPQWKLQJDERXWRWKHUVZLWKLQWKHKRXVH DQG1LNRZDVOHVVWKDQIRUWKFRPLQJ6RKRZORQJZRXOGVKHQHHGWR 

EHWKHUHWRZLQKLVFRQILGHQFHLIHYHUWKDWZHUHWUXO\SRVVLEOH7KH RQO\SLHFHRILQIRUPDWLRQVKHKDGJDLQHGZDVWKDW$KPHGZDVWKH ERVVPDQ1LNRWKHKDQGVRPHEDLWWROXUH\RXQJZRPHQLQWRWKHLUODLU DQGEL]DUUHDVLWVHHPHGWKHERVVPDQQRWHYHQDWWKHGLQQHUWDEOH 6KHJODQFHGDW1LNRKHDGLQJWKHJDWKHUHGZHLUGRHV+HZDV VLSSLQJUHGZLQHKLVH\HVGLVFRQFHUWLQJO\GLUHFWHGDWKHU6OLJKWO\ LQHEULDWHGDQGIHHOLQJGHFLGHGO\VH[\VKHKDOIZRQGHUHGLIKHKDG VOLSSHGDQ\QR[LRXVVXEVWDQFHLQWRKHUJODVV7KHORZFXWJRZQZLWK VSOLWVXSWRERWKWKLJKVFOXQJMXVWDOLWWOHWRRWLJKWO\IRU&KDUOLH¶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

1LNRLPPHGLDWHO\FOLFNHGKLVILQJHUV7KHVXPPRQHGVODYHWKHQ ZDONHGWRZDUGWKHWDEOHZLWKDUHPRWHFRQWUROXQLW:KHQ1LNR VHOHFWHGDEXWWRQVXGGHQO\WKHVRXQGRIYRLFHVFRXOGEHKHDUGDQGD ODUJHVFUHHQEHFDPHYLVLEOHDVDSDQHOOHGZDOOPRYHGWRRQHVLGHDW WKHIDUHQGRIWKHRUQDWHO\SDQHOOHGGLQLQJURRP  6HHKRZ\RXUVLVWHULVWUHDWHGZKHQVKHVHUYHV$KPHG  &KDUOLHJD]HGDW3DXODFODGLQFKLIIRQSDQWDORRQVZLWKFRLQ EHGHFNHGDQNOHWV6KHWKHQQRWLFHGWKHSLHUFHGQLSSOHVZLWKMHZHOOHG GURSSHUVDVKHUVLVWHUNQHOWGRZQOHDQHGIRUZDUGDQGNLVVHGWDQ ERRWVMXVWYLVLEOHEHORZ$KPHG¶VIORZLQJZKLWHUREHV 1LNRVPLOHGDQGSDWURQLVLQJO\SDWWHG&KDUOLH VNQHH
 %UDQGHG"
6WXQQHGE\KLVVWDWHPHQWRQ0DUWLQWREHEUDQGHGDQGZKDWGLG KHPHDQE\JRRGE\H&KDUOLHTXLFNO\IROORZHGWKHPDOHVODYHZKR ZDVQRZOHDGLQJWKHZD\RXWRIWKHJUDQGGLQLQJURRP+HFURVVHG WKHJUHDWKDOOVWURGHDORQJDSDVVDJHDQGWKHQXSDWXUUHWVWDLUZD\ 

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¶WWKHPDLQSDUWRIWKHKRXVHDQGVKHIHOWGHFLGHGO\XQHDV\ 1LNRKDGOLHGWRKHU\HWDJDLQ $V&KDUOLHFDUHIXOO\WUHDGKHUZD\GRZQWKHVWHHSWXUUHWVWHSVOHDGLQJ WRWKHJURXQGIORRUVKHPXOOHGRYHUZKDW3DXODKDGVDLGDERXWZKLWH VODYHU\DQGKRZLWZDVDFKLHYHGZLWKYDVWVXPVRIPRQH\FKDQJLQJ KDQGV3DXODKDGVDLGVKHKDGQRLQWHQWLRQRIWU\LQJWRHVFDSHEXWKDG VXJJHVWHGELJVLVWHUVKRXOGDWWHPSWWRJHWRXWRIWKHKRXVHLIDWDOO 

SRVVLEOH,IQRWVKHZRXOGXQDEOHWRDVVLVWZKHQDQGLIOLWWOHVLVWHU QHHGHGWRPDNHDILQDOEUHDNIRUIUHHGRP µ:KDWLQKHOOKDGWKH\JRWWHQWKHPVHOYHVLQWR"¶&KDUOLHKDGVDLG DQG3DXODKDGEHHQOHVVWKDQUHDVVXULQJLQKHUVWDWHPHQWWKDWJRLQJ DZD\ZLWK$KPHGZDVWKHIROORZWKURXJKWKDWKDGWREHPDGHµ:K\ ZKHQ\RXGRQ¶WNQRZZKHUH\RX¶UHJRLQJ¶ELJVLVWHUKDGFKDOOHQJHG 3DXODKDGPHUHO\VKUXJJHGKHUVKRXOGHUVKHUODVWZRUGVµ7UXVW PH,NQRZZKDW,¶PGRLQJ¶ $V&KDUOLHRQFHDJDLQVWHSSHGLQWRWKHJURXQGIORRUFRUULGRUVKH ZDVVXUSULVHGWKDWQRRQHKDGEHHQGLVSDWFKHGWRHVFRUWKHUEDFNWR WKHGLQLQJURRP7KHSODFHZDVXWWHUO\VLOHQWRWKHUWKDQWKHFOLFNFOLFN RIKHUKHHOVRQWKHIODJVWRQHIORRUZKLFKLPPHGLDWHO\OHGKHUWR VSHFXODWHRQWKHFKDQFHVRIEHLQJFDXJKWLIVKHPDGHKHUZD\WRWKH FRQVHUYDWRU\6KHSDXVHGTXLFNO\VOLSSHGRXWRIWKHVWUDSS\VDQGDOV WKHQSURFHHGHGWRZDUGWKHVLWWLQJURRPLQVWRFNLQJHGIHHW$OWKRXJK VKHIHOWVKHKDGWRWDNHWKLVPRPHQWDU\FKDQFHVRPHWKLQJHOVHWRR ZDVGULYLQJKHUWRILQG/XNH6KHUHDOO\GLGQ¶WOLNHWKHLGHDRI3DXOD JRLQJRIILQWRWKHELJZLGH\RQGHUDQGZLWK0DUWLQEHORZVWDLUVWKHUH ZDVRQO\KHUVHOIDEOHWRPDNHDEUHDNIRUIUHHGRP6KHQHHGHG/XNH QHHGHGKLVVWUHQJWKDQGHQFRXUDJHPHQWWRVHHWKLVVWXSLGWKLQJ WKURXJKWRDVHQVLEOHFRQFOXVLRQHYHQLILWPHDQWVKHZRXOGKDYHWR 

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¶WVXUHLILWSXUHLPDJLQDWLRQEXWVKHIHOWDV WKRXJKWLQ\FUHDWXUHVZHUHFUDZOLQJDOORYHUKHU6KHIUDQWLFDOO\ IOLFNHGKHUKDQGVGRZQDFURVVEDUHDUPVDQGLQHYLWDEO\GURSSHGRQH RIWKHVDQGDOVDPRQJVWWKHIURQGVRIDJLDQWIHUQ$QQR\HGVKH IUDQWLFDOO\JURSHGIRUWKHVDQGDODQGWRKHUKRUURUWKHZDUPWKRI PDVFXOLQHILQJHUVFODVSLQJDURXQGKHUVKDGKHUWRRWHUULILHGWRXWWHUD VRXQG7KHQPXFKWRKHUUHOLHIDIDPLOLDUYRLFHZKLVSHUHG  *UHDWPLQGVWKLQNDOLNH¶ 
&KDUOLHZRXOGQ WDUJXHDVKHHPHUJHGIURPEHKLQGWKHIHUQZLWKKHU VDQGDO  +RZGLG\RXJHWDZD\"

 ,ZDVVHQWWRWKHEDWKURRPWRFOHDQP\VHOIXSIRU0DGDP %HOLQGD VSOHDVXUH0HOWHGZD[RQP\GLFN¶KHVDLGVXGGHQO\ IUHH]LQJRQWKHVSRWHDUVSULFNHGOLNHDJXDUGGRJWKHQDWQRRWKHU VRXQGVKHFRQWLQXHGµQRWDSUHWW\VLJKWDQG,FKRVHWRRSWRXWWKH EUDQGLQJFHUHPRQ\

 7KH\ OOEHORRNLQJIRUERWKRIXVLIZH UHJRQHWRRORQJ

µ,¶PEXJJHUHGLI,¶PFRPLQJEDFNRQFH,¶PRXWRIKHUH¶ µ


7KHVHFXULW\OLJKWVDOVRKDGVHQVRUVZKLFKKHNQHZLQGLFDWHG WKHLUURXWHVR0DUWLQKDXOHGKHULQWRWKHVKUXEEHU\ 6WD\KHUH KH ZKLVSHUHG DQG, OOOHDGWKHPWRZDUGWKHVWDEOHEORFN

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¶VKHDUWVWDUWHGIOXWWHULQJKHUNQHHVZHUHDOUHDG\VKDNLQJ KHUZKROHERG\WUHPEOLQJEXWQRWIURPIHDU7KHVKHHUSK\VLFDO FRQWDFWEHWZHHQ/XNHDQGKHUVHOIILUHGDWHUULEOH\HDUQLQJ6KHVPLOHG 

LQZDUGO\DVKHPLVWRRNKHUVKLYHULQJIRUPDVWKDWRIDFKLOOHGSHUVRQ DQGZUDSSHGKLVOHDWKHUERPEHUMDFNHWDURXQGKHUVKRXOGHUV,WZDV FROGYHU\FROGDQGVKHZDVYHU\QHDUO\QXPEDQGIHOWDVLIKHUWRHV KDGIURVWELWHEXWLQVLGHVKH JORZHG +HUXEEHGKHUKDQGVEHWZHHQKLVEHIRUHVFRRSLQJKHURIKHUIHHW +HWKHQFDUHIXOO\QHJRWLDWHGKLVZD\WKURXJKWKHVKUXEEHU\DQGLQWR WKHZRRGODQG &DQ WKDYH\RXZDQGHULQJDURXQGKDOIQDNHGOLNHD Q\PSKLQWKHPRRQOLJKWFDQZH"1RWZLWKEURWKHU1LNRKXQWLQJ\RX GRZQIRUKLVRZQSOHDVXUH¶ 
 2IFRXUVH0DUWLQPDQDJHGWROHDYHDPHVVDJHLQDIORZHUXUQMXVW RXWVLGHDZLQGRZZKLFKHQDEOHGPHWRVLGOHWKURXJKWKHVKUXEEHU\WR SLFNLWXSZLWKRXWVHWWLQJRIIWKHEORRG\VHFXULW\OLJKWV3DXOD PHDQZKLOHXVHGKHULQLWLDWLYHE\PDNLQJDFDWDSXOWDQGDEODVWHG OLSVWLFNWXEHDOPRVWFDXJKWPHIXOOLQWKHH\H

 0DUWLQHDUOLHUWKRXJKW3DXODZDVKRRNHGRQ$KPHGDQGZRXOG GRDQ\WKLQJIRUKLPWRWKHH[WHQWWKDWVKHKDGDEDQGRQHGDQ\LGHDRI H[SRVLQJKLP$Q\ZD\LWORRNVDVWKRXJKWKHUHPD\EHQRWKLQJWR 

H[SRVHEH\RQGWKHIDFWWKDWWKH\¶UHDORDGRINLQN\SHUYHUWVZKRPDNH XSVLOO\FRQWUDFWVEHWZHHQWKHPVHOYHVDQGZLOOLQJVODYHV

/XNHSDXVHGE\DVHPLGHUHOLFWIROO\IRUDPRPHQWWU\LQJWRVWXG\ KHUIDFHLQWKHPRRQOLJKW +DYH\RXIDOOHQXQGHU1LNR VVSHOORULVLW VRPHWKLQJHOVHWKDW¶VEOLQGLQJ\RXDOORIDVXGGHQ"

 /XNHGRQ WDFFXVHRUMXGJHPHRQWKLV,¶PMXVWUHSHDWLQJZKDW 3DXODVDLG$QGWKDW¶VZK\,HVFDSHGEHFDXVH,UHDOO\GRQ¶WVHHZK\ VKHKDVWRJRZLWK$KPHGLIWKDW¶VDOOLWLVOHWDORQHWKHOXGLFURXV DPRXQWVRIPRQH\WKH\VXSSRVHGO\WUDGHWKHVHVODYHVIRU¶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



/XNHDQG&KDUOLHUHPDLQHGWRWDOO\VLOHQWXQWLOWKH\ZHUHDEVROXWHO\ VXUHWKHWZRPHQZHUHJRQHWKHQWKH\QRWLFHGDVKDGRZPRYLQJ DFURVVWKHZDOORSSRVLWHZKLFKJDYHULVHWRDIHZPLVVHGKHDUWEHDWV EXWZKHQLWVWD\HGVWDWLRQHU\LQWKHGRRUZD\EHVLGHWKHP/XNH FKXFNOHG  :HOO, YHVHHQHYHU\WKLQJWRQLJKW$Q\PSKDQGDQDNHGIDLU\

 6WLPXODWLQJROGER\QRWKLQJOLNHLWRQDIURVW\QLJKWDQGHYHQP\ ZDQGJORZHGEULHIO\GXULQJWKDWFORVHHQFRXQWHU VDLG0DUWLQDVKH VWHSSHGIURPWKHPRRQOLJKWLQWRWKHVKDGRZ :KHUH V\RXUFDU":H QHHGWRWDON

 1RWWRRIDUIURPKHUH UHSOLHG/XNHEHIRUHUHPRYLQJKLVWKLFN ZRROO\-XPSHU 3XWWKLVRQEHIRUH\RXIUHH]HWRGHDWK,EURXJKWD IHZFORWKHVOLNH\RXVXJJHVWHG

&KDUOLHIHOWJUDWHIXOIRU/XNH VMDFNHWEXWKHUIHHWZHUH SURJUHVVLYHO\JHWWLQJFROGHU ,GRQ WVXSSRVH\RXWKRXJKWWREULQJDQ\ VRFNV

 *LYHPHFUHGLWIRUFRPPRQVHQVH, YHJRWUXJVLQWKHFDUMXVWLQ FDVH\RXJLUOVZHUHXQVXLWDEO\GUHVVHG$QG,GRNQRZ1LNROLNHVKLV ZRPHQZLWKYLUWXDOO\QRWKLQJRQ

 $QG\RXGRQ WRIFRXUVH" UHWRUWHG&KDUOLH 

 6WRSPDNLQJFRPSDULVRQV VQDSSHG/XNH DQG, OOJLYH\RXD SLFN\EDFNWRWKHFDU

$IHZPRPHQWVODWHUWKH\ZHUHGULQNLQJKRWVRXSIURPDIODVNDV /XNHLQIRUPHGWKHPRI3DXOD VSODQV7KHIDFWWKDWVKHZDVWRIO\RXW RI+HDWKURZERXQGIRUWKH0LGGOH(DVWWKHIROORZLQJHYHQLQJQRWWR &KDUOLH¶VOLNLQJ  :K\GRHVVKHKDYHWRJRDWDOO" VKHDVNHGVXGGHQO\DZDUHRI /XNH VXQGRXEWHGIDLWKLQKHUVLVWHU &KDUOLH¶VRZQHJRZDVDOLWWOHEUXLVHGIRUKDYLQJDFKLHYHGOLWWOH NQRZOHGJHRWKHUWKDQWKHIDFWWKDW1LNRUHDOO\KDGQ WFRHUFHGDQ\RQH LQWRGRLQJDQ\WKLQJWKH\GLGQ¶WZDQWWRZHOOQRWPXFK+HKDG DGPLWWHGO\XVHGVH[XDOWHDVLQJWRWKHQ¶WKGHJUHHXSRQKHUVHOIDQGQR GRXEWWKHVDPHZLWKRWKHUZRPHQ6KHZRXOGQ WQRUPDOO\KDYH VXFFXPEHGLILWKDGQ WEHHQIRUWKHIDFWWKDWVKHKDGZDQWHGWRSOHDVH /XNH 6LWWLQJLQWKHEDFNRI/XNH VFDUZUDSSHGLQEODQNHWVDQG VQXJJOHGXSWR'DQWHVKHOHWKHUILQJHUVGULIWLQWRKLVWKLFNFRDW+H ZDVDFRPIRUWLQJIDFWRUZKLOHWKHWZRPHQLJQRUHGKHU6KHZRQGHUHG 

LI/XNHZRXOGHYHUUHDOO\VKRZDQ\LQWHUHVWLQKHUDQGZKHQWKHWZR PHQOLWFLJDUVDVLILWZDVWLPHWRFHOHEUDWHVKHORVWKHUUDJ  $UHZHHYHUJRLQJWROHDYHWKLVSODFH", PIUR]HQ

/XNHWXUQHGVOLJKWO\WRZDUG0DUWLQ 7DNHWKHZKHHODQG, OOVHHWR PDGDPLQWKHUHDU KHVDLGTXLFNO\RSHQLQJWKHGULYHU VGRRU +HVWXEEHGRXWKLVFLJDUWKHQRUGHUHG'DQWHRXWRIWKHUHDUDQG PXFKWR&KDUOLH VVXUSULVH'DQWHVFXUULHGWRWKHSDVVHQJHUVHDWZKHUH KHLPSDWLHQWO\DZDLWHG0DUWLQ¶VUHWUHDWWRWKHGULYLQJVHDW/XNH PHDQWLPHFODPEHUHGLQEHVLGHKHUDQGDVWKHFDUILQDOO\VNLGGHGDQG VOLWKHUHGDFURVVWKHPXGG\JURXQGEHIRUHWXUQLQJDORQJDQDUURZODQH KHFXGGOHG&KDUOLHDQGVOLSSHGKLVKDQGXQGHUWKHZRROOHQWUDYHOUXJ  :KDW\RXQHHG KHZKLVSHUHG LVDOLWWOH7/&WKHQ\RX OOEH QLFHO\ZDUPHGXSIRUODWHU

 3URPLVHVSURPLVHV JDVSHG&KDUOLHVLPPHULQJZLWKWKHZDUPWK HPDQDWLQJIURPKLVKDQGDVLWVWURNHGGRZQDFURVVKHUGRZQ\SHOW 6KHVTXLUPHGKHUKLSVDQGOHWKHUOHJVSDUWHQRXJKWRDOORZHDV\ DFFHVVDVKLVPRXWKVRXJKWKHUV6KH¶GFUDYHGWKLVYHU\PRPHQWVLQFH WKHQLJKWKHKDGIRUFHGKHUWRVLWRQKLVODSDWWKHSDUW\7RKDYHKLP WRXFKKHULQWLPDWHO\DQGWRIHHOKLVKRWEUHDWKDJDLQWRMXVWWRIHHOKLV ERG\DJDLQVWKHUVZDVVSHFLDO 

+H¶GGHOLEHUDWHO\WHPSWHGKHURQ3DXOD VGRRUVWHSDQGIRUWKH ILUVWWLPHKHZDVUHDOO\H[SORULQJKHUFRQWRXUVVHQGLQJKHUPLQGLQWR DZKLUODVKLVILQJHUVIOXWWHUHGRQKHUEXGRQHPRPHQWGHOYHGLQWRKHU VOLFNQHVVWKHQH[WWKHQVORZO\SXOOHGXSZDUGIRUFLQJKHUFOLWRULVWR VOLGHRXWIURPEHQHDWKLWVSURWHFWLYHKRRG+HUQLSSOHVEXUQHGWRRDV IODPHVRIGHVLUHNHSWKHURQDQHYHUHQGLQJSODWHDXRIEUHDWKOHVV WLPHOHVVSOHDVXUH6KHVHQVHGQHHGIRUKLVSDUWZKHQKHNLVVHGKDUG DQGGHHSEHIRUHKHZKLVSHUHG  1RWVXFKDZLOGFDWDIWHUDOO

6KHGHOLEHUDWHO\ELWKLVHDUPXUPXUHG :DLWDQGVHHZKHUH,ELWH \RXQH[WWLPH

+HJODQFHGDKHDGDVWKH\DSSURDFKHGWKHYLOODJHZKHUHKHNQHZD FRVLO\OLWFRWWDJHDZDLWHGWKHLUDUULYDOVDLG 6WHHUWKHFDUXSEHKLQG WKHSXEDQGLW¶VWKHVHFRQGJDWHZD\RQWKHULJKWDWDERXWDKXQGUHG PHWUHV

0DUWLQIROORZHGWKURXJKRQLQVWUXFWLRQVDV&KDUOLHRQFHPRUH SRQGHUHG3DXOD¶VSUHGLFDPHQWµ,¶PUHDOO\QRWKDSS\DERXWKDYLQJOHIW 3DXODEHKLQG¶ µ6KHNQRZVH[DFWO\ZKDWVKH¶VDERXWZKLFKLVPRUHWKDQFRXOG EHVDLGIRU\RXUVHOI¶ µ0HDQLQJ"¶ 

µ0HWKLQNV\RXOHW1LNRJHWWR\RX¶ µ2KDQGVKHGLGQ¶W"¶ µ*RRGDFWUHVVLVRXU3DXOD¶ µ7RRULJKW¶UHPDUNHG0DUWLQµ6KHKDGPHIRROHG¶ µ$JRRGXQGHUFRYHUMRXUQR¶VDLG/XNHDELJJULQµFDQRIWHQUXQ ULQJVURXQGXQGHUFRYHUFRSVZLWKRXWWKHLUHYHQNQRZLQJLW¶ µ7UXH¶FXWLQ0DUWLQµDQGVRPHKDYHDFKLHYHGGDPQJRRG FULPHEXVWLQJVFRRSVDWWKHH[SHQVHRIDIDLUIHZSROLFHPHQSORGRYHU WKH\HDUV¶ µ:KHQ\RX¶YHILQLVKHGDFFODLPLQJWKHPHULWVRIP\VLVWHUDQG FROOHDJXHVRI/XNH¶VKHUH¶VQDUOHG&KDUOLHµQRWWRPHQWLRQ0DQG\¶V EUDYHHIIRUWVGR\RXWKLQNZHFRXOGJHWGRZQWRWKHEUDVVWDFNVRI ZKDWKDSSHQVQH[W"¶ µ1H[WP\VZHHW"¶UHSOLHG/XNHµ2KDKRWEDWKDELWHRIVXSSHU DQGEHG¶ µ%HGIRUPH¶FKLUSHG0DUWLQµ3OHDVHSOHDVH,KDYHQ¶WVHHQD EHGLQGD\V¶ &KDUOLHORRNHGWR/XNHGLVEHOLHYLQJZKDWVKHZDVKHDULQJµ%XW ZHFDQ¶WMXVWJRWREHGDVLIQRWKLQJKDVKDSSHQHG¶ µ&DQ\RXWKLQNRIDQ\WKLQJEHWWHUWRGRRQIURVW\QLJKW"¶ 

µ
&KDUOLHIHOWDVXGGHQSDQJRIJXLOWµ2KWKDWOLWWOHHSLVRGH,VHH
µ6R\RXZHUHDEOHWRFRPPXQLFDWHZLWKHDFKRWKHUWKHQ"¶TXHULHG /XNHDVKHPDGHWRH[LWWKHFDUKLVH[SUHVVLRQWKDWRIDSX]]OHG LQGLYLGXDOµ2QO\\RXVDLG¶ µ%ULHIO\¶FXWLQ0DUWLQWXUQLQJVOLJKWO\LQKLVVHDWWRIDFHWKHP µ%HDVVXUHGLWZDVEXWDEULHIPRPHQWDU\H[FKDQJHRISOHDVDQWULHV¶ 
µ'DPQULJKW,GR¶ µ,I\RX¶UHULJKWZKDWZLOOKDSSHQWR1LNR¶ µ$VKDSSHQVWRDQ\EDGJX\VZKHQWKH\¶UHILQDOO\FDXJKWLQWKH DFWRUVXIILFLHQWHYLGHQFHSXWVWKHPDZD\IRUDYHU\ORQJWLPH¶ µ%XWKH¶V\RXUEURWKHU¶ µ+DOIEURWKHU¶ µ$QGLIKLVVODYHVZLOOLQJO\VLJQHGDZD\WKHLUULJKWV"¶ µ:H¶OOFURVVWKDWEULGJHLIHYHUZHUHDFKLW¶KHUHSOLHGPDNLQJWR H[LWWKHFDU $WKRXJKWVXGGHQO\VWUXFN&KDUOLHVSXUULQJµ0\*RGLIWKH WUDFNLQJGHYLFHV\RXPHQWLRQHGDUHZLWKLQ3DXOD¶VOXJJDJHWKHQ\RX KDYHQ¶WJRWDKRSHLQKHOORINQRZLQJZKHUHVKHLVRQFHVKHOHDYHV WKDWGDPQKRXVH0\EDJVZHUHWDNHQDZD\ZKHQ,DUULYHGWKHUHDV ZHUHKHUVQRGRXEWDQG,IHHOVXUHWKDWLI$KPHGKDGFKRVHQWRWDNH PHWRWKH0LGGOH(DVWZLWKKLPKHZRXOGKDYHSURYLGHGDZKROHQHZ VHWHVSHFLDOO\IRUWKHRFFDVLRQ¶ /XNHLPPHGLDWHO\OD\KLVKDQGKHDYLO\WRUHVWXSRQ0DUWLQ¶V VKRXOGHUDVKHTXHULHGµ7KHODVWWLPH\RXVDZ3DXODZDVVKH ZHDULQJPDNHXS"¶+LVWRQHWKDWRIDYHU\ZRUULHGPDQµ7HOOPHVKH ZDV¶ µ$WDOOWLPHV¶UHSOLHG0DUWLQ 

µ7KDQN*RGIRUWKDW)RUDPLQXWHWKHUH\RXKDGPHZRUULHG¶ µ:KDWKDVPDNHXSJRWWRGRZLWKWUDFNLQJGHYLFHV"¶DVNHG &KDUOLHWRWDOO\IOXPPR[HG µ/LSVWLFNWXEHH\HOLQHUVWLFNDQGRWKHULWHPVRIFRXUVHWKDW ZRXOGQ¶WHYHQUDLVHDVHFRQGJODQFHIURPPDOHH\HVDQGP\GDUOLQJ JLUOWKDW¶VKRZ0DUWLQ¶VFROOHDJXHVZLOOEHNHHSLQJWDEVRQ\RXUOLWWOH VLVWHU¶ µ
µ7KDW¶VHDV\IRU\RXWRVD\\RXZHUHQ¶WLQVLGHWKDWKRXVH¶ TXLEEOHG&KDUOLHVWXPEOLQJDORQJEHKLQGKLPDVKHVWURGHWRWKHIURQW GRRURIWKHFRWWDJHµ


7HQ /XNHJURDQHGUHVSRQVLYHO\DQGOHWRXWDJDVSDV&KDUOLH¶VWRQJXH IROORZHGWKHVDPHURXWHKHUOLSVKDG,WKDGEHHQDORQJWLPHVLQFHKH KDGDOORZHGDZRPDQWRYHQWXUHVRFORVHWRKLVPDQO\SULGHZLWKD PRXWKDQGKDWHGKLPVHOIIRUKLVZHDNQHVV %HIRUHHQJDJHPHQWPDUULDJHDQGWKHELUWKRI0LOHV RSSRUWXQLWLHVWRIXFNZRPHQKDGEHHQRQDSDUZLWKWDNLQJDFRIIHH EUHDN
2K\HV&KDUOLHKDGVHQVHGWKHWHQVLRQLQKLVOHJPXVFOHVDQG JXHVVHGKHZDVZUHVWOLQJZLWKLPSHQGLQJHMDFXODWLRQ2KKRZULJKW VKHZDVDQGQRZD\ZDVKHJRLQJWRDOORZWKDWWRKDSSHQQRWLIKH FRXOGGDPQZHOOSUHYHQWKLPVHOIIURPJLYLQJLQWRLQVWDQW JUDWLILFDWLRQ +HWKRXJKWEDFNWRWKHVLJKWRIKHUZKHQEHDXWLIXOO\IOXVKHGIURP FDVFDGLQJKRWZDWHUDQGWKHZD\VKHKDGLQFLWHGDWWHQWLRQZLWK


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¶WLWSUREDEOHWKDWVKH ZRXOGH[SORUHWKDWZLOGIDQWDV\RIKLVVWLOOIXUWKHUZRXOGVRRQH[HUW QHZIRXQGSRZHURYHUKLP"+HUH\HVLPSOLHGVKHNQHZZKDWPDGH 

KLPWLFNOLNHDWLPHERPEEXWZDVWKDWPHUHZLVKIXOWKLQNLQJIRUKLV SDUWDQGZDVWKLVVKRZRIH[KLELWLRQLVPWKHSUHFXUVRUWRSXVKLQJKLV EXWWRQ"6KHZDVWHDVLQJJRRGKLVWKRXJKWVPLUURUHGZLWKHYHU\MXLFHG XSILQJHUVOLGLQJRYHUKHUDQDODSHUWXUH+LVFRFNZDVWKUXPPLQJ KHDGEX]]LQJDVVWLJKWO\FOHQFKHGZLWKORQJLQJWKHZDLWLQJ XQEHDUDEOH0D\EHVKH¶GPLVVHGWKHFOXHVPLVVHGHYHU\IUDFWXUHG EUHDWKRIKLVZKHQXQGHUH[WUHPHGXUHVV :KDWKDSSHQHGQH[WKHNQHZZRXOGWDNHKHUE\VXUSULVHDQGLQD ILWRISHDNVKHUHDFWHGE\OHDSLQJXSJUDEELQJDWRZHODQGVWRUPLQJ RXWRIWKHEDWKURRPLQKLVZDNH
+LVVLOHQFHGUHZIRUWKH[SHFWHGUHVSRQVH+HUKDQGVOLFHG WKURXJKWKHDLUDQGPDGHFRQWDFWZLWKKLVIDFH7KHIRUFHRIWKHVODS ZDVKDUGHQRXJKWROHDYHKLVFKHHNVPDUWLQJMXVWDWWKHYHU\PRPHQW KHIHOWDVLIKLVEDOOVZHUHDERXWWREXUVWEXWVKHKDGQ¶WJLYHQKLP ZKDWKHZDQWHGQRW\HWDQGKHZDVQ¶WDERXWWRWHOOKHUZKDWKH ZDQWHG6KHKDGWRZRUNWKDWRXWIRUKHUVHOIHYHQLIWKDWPHDQWKLV KDYLQJWRWDNHWKHOHDGWRLQFLWHKHUZUDWK 


 , OOIXFN\RXOLNHDRQHQLJKWVWDQGWKHQZDONDZD\,W V\RXU FKRLFHDQGRQO\\RXFDQNQRZLI\RXZDQWPRUHWKDQWKDW +HZDLWHG SRLVHGPLGSOXQJH 2.LIWKDW VWKHZD\\RXZDQWLW +HWKHQWKUXVW KLPVHOIGHHSZLWKLQKHUKDOIH[SHFWLQJEODVSKHPRXVDEXVH6XUSULVHG E\XWWHUVLOHQFHKHVORZHGKLVUHWUHDWIRUDVHFRQGSOXQJHLQWKHPDLQ EHFDXVHKHZDVVDYRXULQJWKHVKHHULQWLPDF\DQGVHFRQGO\EHFDXVHKH GLGQ¶WZDQWDRQHQLJKWVWDQGVLWXDWLRQZLWKKHUµ:HOODUH\RX VRUU\"¶ 

$VWHDUVXQH[SHFWHGO\ZHOOHGVKHEOXUWHG , PVRUU\/XNH,GLGQ W PHDQWRKXUW\RX 7KHUHZDVQRWLPHWRWKLQNWKLVWXUQRIHYHQWVWKURXJKWRDQ\ VHQVLEOHFRQFOXVLRQIRUKHFRXOGZLQRUORVHKHURQRQHNLVV+LV PRXWKHQYHORSHGKHUVDQGDVWKHWHQVHQHVVZDQHGIURPKHUVRIW FRQWRXUVEHQHDWKKLVKDUGHQHGPXVFOHVKHDOORZHGKLVOLSVWREUXVK GRZQKHUQHFNKLVWRQJXHWKHQGULIWLQJHYHUGRZQZDUG+HUILQJHUV GXJLQWRKLVIOHVKWU\LQJWRSUHYHQWKLVSXOOLQJDZD\IURPKHU+H SDXVHGVPLOHGDQGNLVVHGDZD\WKHWHDUVVDLG µ%HOLHYHWKLV:KHQ\RXUDJHDWPHOLNHDWHPSHVW,JRIXFN ULJLG

 +RZVR" VKHVDLGDVWKRXJKVWXQQHG  :KRNQRZVRQHGD\\RXPD\EHFRPHVRIXULRXV\RX OOFKDLQPH XSDQGGRZKDWHYHU\RXWKLQNILWWLQJ

 $UH\RXMRNLQJ"

 1RWLQWKHOHDVWP\ORYH KHUHSOLHGEHIRUHNLVVLQJKHUQRVH

'RHVP\FRQIHVVLRQVKRFNDQGGLVDSSRLQW


 1REHFDXVH\RX¶UHYHU\DVWXWHDQGLWZRXOGQ¶WVXUSULVHPHRQH LRWDLI\RXVDLGWKHRXWHURIILFHVZHUHEXJJHG,QIDFWLI,KDGVRPH FKDLQVULJKWQRZ, GSDGORFN\RXXSWKLVLQVWDQWDQGUHDOO\SXQLVK \RX

 +RZ" +HZDVDWRSKHUDJDLQDQGWKUXVWGHHSPRPHQWDULO\ GLVWUDFWLQJKHU :KDWZRXOG\RXGRWRPH"

 , GOHWP\KDQGVZDQGHUDOORYHU\RXUERG\EHIRUHVXEMHFWLQJ\RX WRDEOLQGIROG7KHQ,ZRXOGGHOLEHUDWHO\OHWP\FXQWEUXVKXSDJDLQVW \RXUFRFNXQWLO\RXEHJJHGIRUDIXFNQRWWRPHQWLRQWKHUXWKOHVVDQG PHUFLOHVVWRUWXUH,¶GVXEMHFW\RXWRZLWKDOOPDQQHURIGHYLFHWRKDQG
+HUROOHGRYHUWDNLQJKHUZLWKKLP 6RGRLWWHDVHPHDQGULGH PHLI\RXGDUH,PDJLQHWKHFKDLQVDUHWKHUHKROGLQJPHGRZQ %HFDXVH,VXUHDVKHOOZLOOZDQWWRKROG\RXWLJKWDQGWDNHFRQWURO

&KDUOLHODXJKHGVRIWO\


&KDUOLHVOLGIURPKLVERG\DQGOHDSWWRZDUGKLVFORWKHVRQWKH FKDLU:LWKEHOWLQKDQGVKHWKHQWXUQHGWRVHH/XNHKDGWXUQHGRQKLV VLGHDQGORRNHGWREHDVOHHS 'RQ W\RXGDUHJRWRVOHHS¶H[FODLPHG &KDUOLHOXQJLQJKHUVHOIDWWKHEHG  ,ZDVMXVWWDNLQJDORQJEOLQN

6KHTXLFNO\ERXQGWKHEHOWDURXQGKLVZULVWVXQWLOWKHEXFNOH PHWWKHODVWEXWRQHKROH %OLQNDJDLQDQGLW¶OOEHWKHZRUVHIRU\RX

6KHWKHQVXUYH\HGKLPKDQGVDERYHKLVKHDGKLVERG\VWUHWFKHG PXVFOHVWDXWKHUKDQGLGO\GULIWLQJGRZQWRKLVHQJRUJHGHUHFWLRQ

:KDWWKLVQHHGVLVDJHQWOHZKLSSLQJ

6KHUHDFKHGDFURVVWRWKHGLVFDUGHGWKHEDWKUREHDQGGHIWO\VOLG WKHEHOWIURPLWVORRSV/XNHVKHWKRXJKWORRNHGDWDGFRQFHUQHGDV VKHWZLVWHGWKHHQGVRIWKHEHOWLQRSSRVLWHGLUHFWLRQVEHIRUHIROGLQJLW LQKDOI6KHGDQJOHGLWFORVHWRKLVDURXVDODQGEHIRUHKHFRXOGXWWHUD IXOOVHQWHQFHLQWHUPL[HGZLWKIRXOODQJXDJHWKHEHOWKDGIORZQ WKURXJKWKHDLUDQGFDXJKWKLVHQGRZPHQWEURDGVLGH+HGUHZLQD GHHSEUHDWKDVDVHFRQGVWUHDNRIEOXHVHDUHGDFURVVKLVHUHFWLRQWKHQ DWKLUGDQGDIRXUWKKDGKLPFOHQFKLQJKLVILVWV6KHFRXOGQ¶WEH DEVROXWHO\VXUHEXWJXHVVHGKHZDVEDWWOLQJDJDLQVWRYHUZKHOPLQJ GHVLUHWRHMDFXODWHDVVKHQRWLFHGKLPFXUOXSKLVWRHVDVWKRXJK EUDFLQJKLPVHOI 

6KHLPPHGLDWHO\OHWWKHEHOWIDOOIURPKHUJUDVS6KHVDZLQWHQVH FRQFHQWUDWLRQIDGHIURPKLVIDFHDVVKHORZHUHGKHUKHDGDQGEUXVKHG KHUOLSVDFURVVKLVVZROOHQWKUREELQJHUHFWLRQ6KHVDYRXUHGGURSOHWV RIVDOW\SUHFXPZLWKKHUWRQJXHEHIRUHGUDZLQJKDOIKLVOHQJWKLQWR KHUHDJHUPRXWK+HJURDQHGUHVSRQVLYHO\ZULWKLQJKLVKLSVDVKHU WRQJXHUROOHGDQGKHUFKHHNVKROORZHGZLWKHYHU\VXFNLQJPRWLRQ 6KHKDGKLPDWKHUPHUF\DQGFRXOGQ WEHOLHYHKHUOXFNEXWVKHUHDOO\ ZDQWHGWRULGHKLPWRKHOODQGEDFN6KHZRXOGDOOLQJRRGWLPH WKRXJK 6KHVOLGIURPWKHEHGKXUULHGDFURVVWRWKHKROGDOOVKH¶GOHIWLQ KLVFDUHEHIRUHVHWWLQJRIIWRPHHWXSZLWK5HIOH[PDQDQGIURP ZLWKLQUHWULHYHGDUXEEHUGLOGRDQGDUHGVLONVFDUI /XNHFRXOGQ¶WIDLOWRNQRZKLVYXOQHUDELOLW\ZDVH[FLWLQJWRKHU DSSUHFLDWLYHO\VRZKHQVKHVOLGEDFNRQWRWKHEHGDQGVWUDGGOHGKLV JURLQ+HJURDQHGKDOIH[SHFWLQJZKDWZDVWRFRPHZKHQVKH JDWKHUHGWKHVFDUIWRJHWKHUDQGREOLWHUDWHGDQ\FKDQFHRIKLVZDWFKLQJ KHUH[SUHVVLRQVZKLFKFRXOGUHYHDOVRPXFKDERXWKHUKLJKVDQGORZV RIDURXVDO6KHVHQVHGFRQIXVLRQDVVKHUHDGMXVWHGKHUSRVLWLRQWRWKDW RIIDFLQJWRZDUGKLVIHHWKHUEXWWRFNVOLJKWO\UHVWLQJRQKLVORZHU WRUVR 

$VKHUILQJHUVJULSSHGKLVFRFNVKHVXFNHGRQWKHVLPXODWHG UXEEHUSHQLVWRWKRURXJKO\OXEULFDWHLWVNQREHQGDQGKHZDVVDOLHQWO\ OLVWHQLQJIRUWKHVOLJKWHVWRIVRXQGVWKDWPLJKWLQGLFDWHKHUQH[WPRYH $VH[SHFWHGKHJURDQHGORXGO\ZKHQVKHQHVWOHGWKHUXEEHUGLOGR EHQHDWKKLVEDOOVDFNDQXGJHDJDLQVWKLVDQDODSHUWXUHGUDZLQJIRUWK HYHQORXGHUJURDQVWKRXJKQRWRISURWHVWDWLRQ%OLQGIROGHGKHZDV JDJJHGQRWDQGZLWKHYHU\VXEWOHLQZDUGSUREHKHJURDQHGVRPH PRUH:LWKWKHGLOGRILQDOO\VXQNKDOIZD\VKHUDLVHGKHUEXWWRFNV DQGJXLGHGKLVFRFNEHWZHHQKHUPRLVWODELDOLSVWKHQHDVHGKHUVHOIWR LWVEDVH

6WD\VWLOO VKHGHPDQGHGDZDUHWKDWKHZDVORZHULQJKLVORLQVWR HQDEOHDQXSZDUGWKUXVWHIIHFWHGXSRQUHWXUQWRKLVRULJLQDOSRVLWLRQ +HWKHQPDGHWRLJQRUHKHUVWD\ VWLOOFRPPDQGDTXLFNWKUXVWRIWKH GLOGRVXIILFLHQWWRFDXVHKLPDEUHDWKOHVVPRPHQWWKRXJKZKHWKHULW UHIOHFWHGUHVSRQVHWRSOHDVXUHRULOOJRWWHQJDLQZDVKDUGWRJDXJH 6KHWKHQVWDUWHGULGLQJKLPWRWKHWURWZLWKDVPRRWKJOLGLQJDFWLRQ KLVUHVSRQVHIDLUO\SUHGLFWDEOHXQWLOWKDWLVVKHVWDUWHGIXFNLQJKLP ZLWKWKHGLOGR +LVVHFUHWGHVLUHZDVILQDOO\RXVWHG/XNH¶VJURLQVXGGHQO\FDPH DOLYHWKHVWUHQJWKLQORLQVXQEHOLHYDEOHDVKHZLOIXOO\WKUXVWXSZDUG ZLWKDOOKLVPLJKWWRLQFLWHVDPHIURPWKHGLOGR$GLOGRJUDVSHG 

ILUPO\ZLWKLQKHUKDQGUDPPLQJKLPZLWKGHHSWKUXVWVZDVREYLRXVO\ KRZ/XNHZDQWHGLWWREHVRLWKDGWRVWRS$IWHUDOOVKHZDVJRLQJWR GLFWDWHZKHQDQGLIKHZDVWREHJHWIXUWKHUSOHDVXUHSDLQRUERWKDW RQHDQGWKHVDPHWLPH  &ORVH\RXUOHJVDQGKROGLWLQSODFH

6KHVHQVHGIXUWKHUUHVLVWDQFHDVVKHUDLVHGKHUKLSVDWWKHVDPH WLPH/XNHWLJKWHQHGKLVDVVWRUHWDLQWKHVKHDWKHGVROLGLW\RIWKHGLOGR +HDOVRUDLVHGKLVORLQVWRNHHSKLVWKUREELQJFRFNZLWKLQKHUKRWOLWWOH FURWFKEXW&KDUOLHZDVKDYLQJQRQHRIKLVZLOIXOVWUHDN6KH LPPHGLDWHO\VOLGIURPKLVWRUVRWXUQHGKHUVHOIWRIDFHKLPDPXVHGE\ KLVDJRQLVHGH[SUHVVLRQRIXWWHUIUXVWUDWLRQ µ:KR¶VDQDXJKW\ER\WKHQ"¶VKHWHDVHGRQFHDJDLQVWUDGGOLQJ KLVRXWVWUHWFKHGOHJVKHUYXOYDEUXVKLQJKLVHQJRUJHGNQRE µ7HDVLQJELWFK¶KHVDLGQXGJLQJKLVJURLQXSZDUGDVQDUOOLNH JURZOEHIRUHµ&RPHFORVHU¶ 6KHOHDQHGIRUZDUGWREUXVKKHUOLSVDFURVVKLVZLWKQRLQWHQWLRQ RIDOORZLQJKLPWRVOLSKLVHQGRZPHQWLQVLGHRIKHUEXWKHPRYHGKLV DUPVVRTXLFNO\VKHZDVILUPO\WUDSSHGE\ERXQGZULVWVORFNHGEHKLQG KHUKHDG+HGURYHKLVWRQJXHGHHSLQWRKHUPRXWKKLVEROGHUHFWLRQ DOOWKHZKLOHQXGJLQJVHHNLQJHQWU\XQWLORQFHDJDLQVOLSSLQJLQWRKHU VOLFNTXLP7KHQZLWKRQHDOPLJKW\XSZDUGWKUXVWKHDFKLHYHGKLV 

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¶GVRRQEHZRQGHULQJZRXOGKH VXEPLWVRHDVLO\DJDLQRUZDVWKLVDRQHRIIWHVWLQWKHZDWHUW\SH VFHQDULR":RPHQZHUHOLNHWKDWQHYHUTXLWHWUXVWLQJWKHPHQWDO SRZHUWKH\FRXOGZLHOG /XNHJURZOHGDFRQWHQWHGVRUWRIJURZOUDLVHGKLVDUPVWRUHOHDVH KHUDEURDGVPLOH


 6XEMHFW"¶KHVWRUPHGH[SHFWDWLRQRIUHWDOLDWLRQHWFKHGRQKLVIDFH IDGLQJXSRQQRVODSDSSOLHGWRFKHHNµ, PQRWDUHVHDUFKSURMHFWIRU RQHRI\RXU]DQ\DUWLFOHV

 +RZGR\RXNQRZ\RXUQRW"

 %HFDXVHP\ORYH\RXUVWLOOVWUDGGOLQJP\FRFNDQGQRWGDVKLQJ RIIWRWKHEDWKURRPIRUDVZLIWGRXFKH :LWKKLVZULVWVIUHHIURP ERQGDJHKHFODVSHGKHUWLJKWDQGNLVVHGILHUFHO\EHIRUHIROORZLQJXS ZLWK $QG,WROG\RX,NQHZZKDW\RXZDQWHGEHVLGHVDMRE

 %LJVKRW7DONLQJDERXWMREVZKHUHGR,JRIURPKHUH"

 7RPRUURZZHVWDON+HDWKURZDQGVHHZKRZLOOEHWDNLQJWKH VDPHIOLJKWDV$KPHG

 :KHQGR,JHWSDLGIRUDOOWKDWWLPHVSHQWRQUHVHDUFK"

 :DVQ WDOOWKDWGHOLFLRXVVH[SD\PHQWHQRXJK" +HFKXFNOHGDWKHU HQUDJHGH[SUHVVLRQUDLVHGKLVKDQGVVXEPLVVLYHO\ 7UXFH KHVDLGDV WKHSLOORZEODFNHGRXWKLVYLVLRQ  'DPQ\RXGDPQ\RXWRKHOO VKHVDLGVOLGLQJIURPWKHEHG
+HVDWXSKHDUWLO\ODXJKHG +RQHVWO\MXVWOLVWHQWR\RXUVHOI


&KDUOLHGDVKHGLQWRWKHEDWKURRPWKHLQVWDQWVKHKHDUGVZLIW PRYHPHQWIURPEHKLQGWKHQWXUQHGWRIDFHKLPZLWKDQLUUHVLVWLEOH VPLOH &DOOPHDEUDWDVHFRQGWLPHDQG, OOEHWHPSWHGWRVODS\RXU VPXJIDFH

 ,¶OOFDOO\RXDVSRLOWEUDWZKHQHYHU\RXDFWOLNHRQHWKRXJK,¶G PXFKSUHIHUWRKDYH\RXDVDVSRLOW¶ +HUUHDFWLRQZDVLQVWLQFWLYHO\ELWWHUDQGVKHVWUXFNZLWKIRUFH TXLWHH[SHFWLQJKLPWRUHVLVWDQGZDVVXUSULVHGDWWKHVRXQGRIKHU KDQGVWULNLQJIOHVK+HUHPDLQHGPRWLRQOHVVKLVGDUNH\HVVWXG\LQJ KHUVKLVH[SUHVVLRQWKDWRILQMXUHGLQQRFHQWFKLOGOLNHTXDOLW\ 6KHWHQWDWLYHO\OHDQHGIRUZDUGDQGNLVVHGGHILQHGSLQNILQJHU PDUNVHWFKHGRQKLVIDFH , PVRUU\GRQ WPDNHPHKXUW\RX

 ,ZDVDERXWWRWHOO\RXKRZ\RXFRXOGEHDVSRLOWPLVWUHVVLI\RX HYHUILQDOO\JURZRXWRIEHLQJDEUDW

6KHFRXOGQ WDQGZRXOGQ WULVHWRWKHZRUGEUDWWKLVWLPHIRUVKH VXGGHQO\UHDOLVHGKHZDVPDQLSXODWLQJH[DFWO\ZKDWKHZDQWHGIURP KHU .LVVPH VKHVDLGVOLSSLQJKHUKDQGEHKLQGKLVKHDG  1RWXQOHVV\RXNLVVPHWRR

7KHLUPRXWKVPHWWRGHYRXUHDFKRWKHUWKHLUERGLHVLQWLPDWHO\ WRXFKLQJDVKHSXOOHGKHULQWRDYLFHOLNHJULSKHDUWVSRXQGLQJJURLQV EUXVKLQJKLVGHSOHWHGSURZHVVVHHPLQJO\QROHVVWDPHWKDQEHIRUH 

WKHLUYLJRURXVFRXSOLQJDQGMRLQWRUJDVPLFSOHDVXULQJ&KDUOLHFRXOG IHHOWKHSUHVVXUHRIKLVPDQKRRGVOLSSLQJEHWZHHQKHUOHJVVHQVXDOO\ EUXVKLQJXSDJDLQVWKHU,WZDVXWWHUKHDYHQWRKDYHLQGXOJHGZLWK VRPHRQHVKHKDGZDQWHGVLQFHDEULHIFRXSOLQJLQGXVWELQDOOH\ WKRXJKVKHKDGQ¶WLPDJLQHGKHZRXOGHYHUEHDWWDLQDEOHWRKHUDQ\ PRUHWKDQVKHKDGLQWHQGHGJLYLQJVZD\WRDQ\DGYDQFHIURP$UFWLF $XUDWKHLUJHWWLQJWRJHWKHUWKRXJKWRIDVPRVWXQOLNHO\ $V/XNHOHWKHUVOLSIURPKLVJUDVSKHVPLOHGVWURNHGKHUIDFH , ZDQWDEDWK,ZDQWPRUHRI\RXDQGWKHQ, OOZDQWEUHDNIDVW

 %XWLW VWKHPLGGOHRIWKHQLJKW

 ([DFWO\$ORQJVRDNZLOOWDNHXSKDOIDQKRXURUVRZLWK GLVWUDFWLRQV

 5LJKWGRZQWRWKHODVWOLWWOHGHWDLOHYHQ\RXUWDNLQJ3DXODEDFNWR WKHFRXQWU\IRUDFRXSOHRIGD\VWRUHVWXS

 :KDWDERXWWKHDUWLFOH\RXKDGSODQQHG\RXFDQKDUGO\JRDKHDG ZLWKLWQRZWKDWZHDOONQRZ1LNRLV5HIOH[PDQ"



 ,WJRHVRQWKHEDVLVWKDWP\VOLP\KDOIEDVWDUGEURWKHUXVHGP\ SURILOHIRUKLVUROHSOD\LQJRI5HIOH[PDQ'DUNH\HVEHEXJJHUHGKH¶V DKD]HOH\HGVKLW

&KDUOLHVDWRQWKHHGJHRIWKHEDWKDV/XNHWXUQHGWKHWDSVRQ %XW KH VIDPLO\DQGKHKDVQ WUHDOO\GRQHDQ\WKLQJLOOHJDODVIDUDV,FDQ PDNHRXW6ODYHVLQWKHKRXVHDOOVLJQHGFRQWUDFWVWRWKHHIIHFWWKDW WKH\ZHUHWKHUHRIWKHLURZQYROLWLRQ$Q\ZD\LWZDVQ¶W\RXUSURILOH KHXVHGLWZDV$KPHG¶V6WDQGVWRUHDVRQKH¶VGDUNH\HG

 +H¶VDVTXDWIHOORZDQG5HIOH[PDQ¶VGHVFULSWLRQZDVPHGRZQ WRWKHODVWEORRG\GHWDLORIKHLJKWWRWKHLQFK%DFNWRWKHSORWWKRXJK FDQ\RXSURYH1LNRKDVQ WFRHUFHGDQ\RQH"3OXVKRZGR\RXWKLQN KHDGOLQHVZLWK6FDQGDORI0DJD]LQH(GLWRULQYROYHGZLWK:KLWH 6ODYHU\LVJRLQJWRORRNRQWKHQHZVWDQGV"%HVWZHRXWWKLVELWRI QHZVWRWKHZRUOGDWODUJHRXUVHOYHVVHHLQJDVKH¶OOPRVWOLNHO\HQG XSEHKLQGEDUV¶/XNHORRNHGGLUHFWO\DWKHUDVLIWU\LQJWRJXHVVKHU WKRXJKWSDWWHUQVµ$QGIRU\RXULQIRUPDWLRQODG\, YHQHYHURXVWHG SHUVRQDONLQN\WDVWHVWRDQ\RQHEHIRUH

 6RZKHUHGLG\RXUNLQN\WDVWHVFRPHIURPLIDV\RXVD\\RX UH RQO\KDOIEURWKHUV"%HDVVXUHGEDVHGRQP\H[SHULHQFHDWWKHKRXVH WKHUHLVOLWWOHWRFKRRVHEHWZHHQHLWKHURI\RX"



/XNH¶VH[SUHVVLRQVZLWFKHGIURPWKDWRITXL]]LFDOWRGHHSO\ WKRXJKWIXO 0RWKHUJDYHXVDWDVWHRIWKHULGLQJFURSORQJEHIRUHZH ZHUHHYHUVHQWRIIWRDERDUGLQJVFKRRO,¶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¶WDGUHDPDQ\PRUHWKDQWKHPDQRQKLVNQHHV KHDGEXULHGEHWZHHQKHUVSUHDGWKLJKVZDVDILJPHQWRIP\ LPDJLQDWLRQ0DNHVPHKDUGMXVWWKLQNLQJDERXWWKDWGD\PRUHVR EHFDXVHVKHZDVDELWFKDWUXHELWFK6KHFRQWLQXDOO\VODSSHGKLVIDFH IRUQRWOLFNLQJKHUULJKWRUIRUVXFNLQJKHUFOLWZKHQKHZDVVXSSRVHG WREHWRQJXHIXFNLQJKHUDQGWKHQRLVHVKHPDGH:HOOOHW¶VMXVWVD\ VKHDOZD\VFDPHUHDOJRRG7KHWURXEOHEHLQJ,ZDVDERXWWRFRPH JRRGWRRRQWKDWGD\DQGPDGHPRUHQRLVHWKDQKHULWEHLQJP\ILUVW WLPHZLWKRXWDJLUOLHPDJWRKDQG¶ 

µ6KHPXVWKDYHEHHQPRUWLILHGWRNQRZWKDW\RXZHUHHYHQWKHUH OHWDORQHVKRRWLQJ\RXUDOO¶ µ6KHZDVOLYLGDQGWKHZRUVHWKLQJIRUPHZDVWKDW,KDGQ¶W PDQDJHGWRVSXQNZKHQVKHVXGGHQO\RUGHUHGKLPZKRPVKHKDG WUHDWHGOLNHDVH[VODYHWRKDXOPHRXWIURPEHKLQGWKHEXVKHV:HOO DV\RXFDQLPDJLQH,ZDVPRUWLILHGWREHKDXOHGXSLQIURQWRIKHU ZLWKD\RXWKIXOERQHUSRNLQJRXWWKURXJKP\SDQWV6KHGLGQ¶WHYHQ ERWKHUWRKLGHKHUH[SRVHGEUHDVWVDQGZKHQVKHOXQJHGDWPHWKH\ ZREEOHGOLNH,¶GQHYHUVHHQEUHDVWVGREHIRUH,ZDVPHVPHULVHG TXDNLQJLQP\VKRHVDQGZKHQVKHODVKHGRXWDWP\FRFNZLWKKHU KDQG,ZDVPRPHQWDULO\VWXQQHGE\WKHSDLQEXWWKDWZDVQ¶WDOOWKDW WRRNP\EUHDWKDZD\6KHWKHQFDXJKWKROGRILWDQGOHGPHLQGRRUV FDOOLQJPHHYHU\IRXOQDPHDSSURSULDWHIRUGLUW\ER\DQGEHIRUHZH JRWKDOIZD\WRWKHVWDLUV,VKRWP\DOOEHFDXVHLQKHUKDVWHDQGP\ UHOXFWDQFHWRFRPSO\ZH¶GHIIHFWLYHO\ZDQNHGPHRIIJRRGDQGPRVW XQSURSHUOLNH6KHZDVDYHU\VHQVXDOZRPDQPXFKOLNH\RXUVHOI FKLFDQGODG\OLNHEXWRQWKLVSDUWLFXODUGD\VKHVXGGHQO\EXUVWRXW ODXJKLQJOLNHDFRPPQWDUWDQGRUGHUHGPHWRP\NQHHV

µ%XW,WKRXJKW¶FXWLQ&KDUOLHDPXVHGLIDOLWWOHFRQIXVHGE\KLV FRQIHVVLRQµ\RXZHUHJRLQJWRVD\VKHEHDWWKHVKLWRXWRI\RX¶ 

µ6KHGLGQ¶WQRWWKDWGD\EXWVKHPDGHPHOLFNXSHYHU\GURSRI VSXQNIURPWKHWLOHGIORRUDQGWKHQPDGHPHOLFNLWIURPKHUIRRWDQG OHJ¶ µ


(OHYHQ +HDWKURZZDVLQFUHGLEO\EXV\DQGDOWKRXJKWKH\ZDWFKHGDOOWKH SDVVHQJHUVPDNHWKHLUZD\WRWKHFRUUHFWWHUPLQDOIRUWKHIOLJKWZKLFK 3DXODKDGLQIRUPHGWKHPVKHZRXOGEHRQWKH\GUHZDEODQN&KDUOLH VWDUWHGWRSDQLFVR0DUWLQFDOPHGKHUGRZQE\VKRZLQJDQLGHQWLW\ FDUGDWWKHFKHFNLQFRXQWHU$SUHYLRXVO\XQVHHQPDQWKHQDSSHDUHG WKH\H[FKDQJHGZRUGVDQGWKHOLVWRISDVVHQJHUVZDVLPPHGLDWHO\ JLYHQLQWR0DUWLQ¶VKDQGV +HUHWXUQHGWR&KDUOLHDQGWRKHUFRPSOHWHVXUSULVHQRQHRIWKH SHRSOHRQ3DXOD VOLVWZHUHWREHSDVVHQJHUVRQWKHIOLJKW)UDXJKWZLWK GHVSDLUVKHZHQWDQGDVNHGLIDQ\PHVVDJHVKDGEHHQOHIWIRUKHUVHOI DQGXSRQIXUWKHUHQTXLU\E\DXQLIRUPHGJLUOWRDQRWKHUDQHQYHORSH DGGUHVVHGWR&KDUOLHZDVKDQGHGRYHU 6KHGHVSHUDWHO\WRUHDWWKHVHDODV/XNHUHDSSHDUHGIURPKDYLQJ PDGHDSKRQHFDOOIURPDSD\SKRQH 7RKHUGLVPD\WKHOHWWHUUHDG



'HDU6LV

6RUU\IRUWKHGHFHSWLRQDQGWKLVEULHIQRWHLWZDVQHFHVVDU\1LNR ZDVPHUHO\DEULHISOHDVXUDEOHLQWHUOXGHLQP\OLIHDQG,FDQGRQR PRUHWKDQWKDQNKLPIRUJLYLQJPHWRWKHPDQRIP\GUHDPV,VKDOO EHJHWWLQJPDUULHGWR$KPHGVRRQDQGZLOOVHQGDQLQYLWHWR\RXDOO 1LNRLVLQFDSDEOHRIJLYLQJKLVDOOLQWKHORYLQJVWDNHVEXWFDQEHNLQG DQGJHQHURXVDV\RXSUREDEO\GLVFRYHUHG+HLVQ WGRLQJDQ\WKLQJ RWKHUWKDQZKDWKLVVODYHVZDQW,QDQ\FDVHZRPHQZLOODOZD\VKROG WKHDFHFDUGRISRZHU ,ORYH\RXDQGZLOOZULWHRIWHQDQGOHW\RXNQRZZKHQ, POLNHO\WR EHEDFNLQ(QJODQG 3DXOD

 6KH VPDG VDLG&KDUOLHVHQVHRIORVVGHHSHQLQJDVVKHVSXQRQ KHUKHHOVDQGVWURGHRII,QSDVVLQJVKHKDQGHGWKHOHWWHUWR/XNH 0DUWLQDQJOHGKLVKHDGUHDGLWDV&KDUOLHNHSWZDONLQJ6KHZDV 

ILJKWLQJEDFNWKHWHDUVIRUIHDURIJLYLQJYHQWWRRYHUZKHOPLQJ HPRWLRQVDQGWKHUHDOLVDWLRQWKDW3DXODKDGGXSHGDOORIWKHP&KDUOLH MXVWFRXOGQ WDFFHSWWKHIDFWWKDW3DXODDQGKHUVHOIKDGEHHQOHIWDORQH WRJHWKHULQWKHWRZHUDSDUWPHQWDQGWKDWVKH GVDLGQRWKLQJDERXWD SURSRVHGPDUULDJH $V&KDUOLHOHIWWKHWHUPLQDOEXLOGLQJ/XNHFDXJKWXSZLWKKHU ZUDSSHGKLVDUPDURXQGKHUVKRXOGHU ,ZDVQ WH[SHFWLQJWKLVHLWKHU 3DXODVDLGVKHZRXOGRQO\EHHVFRUWLQJWZRZRPHQWRWKH0LGGOH (DVWDQGDVVXUHGPHVKHZRXOGEHEDFNDWWKHKRXVHWRKHOSSUHSDUH RWKHUZRPHQIRUVLPLODULQIXWXUH6KHZDVVXSSRVHGO\EHLQJWUDLQHG DVDWUXVWHGFKDSHURQHKHUWULSQRWKLQJPRUHWKDQDWULDOUXQ¶ +HVHQVHG&KDUOLHZDVJXWWHGE\WKHQHZVDQGLWZDVYLWDOIRUKLP WRJHWEDFNLQWR/RQGRQDQGTXLFNDWWKDW+H¶GDOUHDG\H[SODLQHG HDUOLHUWKDWKHKDGWRJRDQGZDVQRZIHHOLQJJXLOW\WKDWKHFRXOGQ¶W GHYRWHKLVWLPHWRKHUDORQH &RPHLQWRWRZQWRWKHKRXVHDQGWKHQ ZH OOJREDFNWRWKDWFRWWDJHIRUDFRXSOHRIGD\V'DQWHHQMR\HGLW WKHUHDQG,SURPLVHGWRWDNH\RXEDFNWRSLFNXS\RXUFDU

6KHKDOIVPLOHG ,QHHGWRJREDFNKRPH$6$3WRWKLQN,MXVW GRQ WXQGHUVWDQGZK\VKH VGRQHWKLV2K*RGVKHRQO\PHW$KPHGD IHZGD\VDJR



 7DNHWKHFDUDQGZDLWDWWKHFRWWDJH,ERRNHGLWIRUDIRUWQLJKW, FDQKLWFKDOLIWRII0DUWLQDQG, OOFRPHGRZQRQWKHWUDLQWRPRUURZ QLJKW KHVDLGILVKLQJIRUFDUNH\VLQKLVSRFNHW µ1RKRQHVWO\,¶GUDWKHUJRKRPHDVVRRQDV,¶YHFROOHFWHGP\FDU IURPWKHFRWWDJH'DQWHGRHVQ¶WPLQGWUDLQVDWDOOVRLI\RXGURSPH RIIDWWKHVWDWLRQ,¶OOEHILQH¶ µ,I\RX¶UHDEVROXWHO\VXUHRQWKLV¶ µ/RRN¶VDLG0DUWLQEXWWLQJLQWRWKHLUYHU\SULYDWHFRQYHUVDWLRQ µ,¶OOWDNH\RXEDFNWRWKHFRWWDJHDQGLI\RXFKDQJH\RXUPLQG\RX FDQEX]]/XNHWRFRPHRQGRZQ8QIRUWXQDWHO\,FDQ¶WVWD\PRUH WKDQDIHZKRXUVEXWWLPHHQRXJKIRU\RXWRWKLQNHQURXWHZKDW\RX ZDQWWRGR +RPHDJDLQ&KDUOLHVHWWOHGKHUVHOIGRZQLQIURQWRIWKHKHDUWKD ZRRGILUHFUDFNOLQJDVVKHVWURNHG'DQWH VKHDG +HOHDQHGDJDLQVWKHUNQHHDZDUHRIXWWHUGHVSRQGHQF\ HPDQDWLQJIURPKLVPLVWUHVV6KHLQWXUQFORVHGKHUH\HVLQ FRQWHPSODWLRQWKHGD\VKDYLQJSDVVHGVRVORZO\LWZDVDVLIWKHZRUOG KDGVWRSSHGWXUQLQJDQGVKHIHOWVRWLUHGRKVRWLUHGIURPVOHHSOHVV QLJKWV 

6KHSRQGHUHGWKHOHDYLQJRIDPHVVDJHDWWKHFRWWDJHLQWKH &RWVZROGVDQGKHUKDVW\UHWUHDW/XNHKDGUXQJKHUWKHUHRQDQHZ PRELOHWKH\¶GKXUULHGO\SXUFKDVHGEHFDXVHVKH¶GORVWKHUVDW*UHVKDP *UDQJHEXWQHZVWKDWKHFRXOGQ¶WJHWDZD\IRUDFRXSOHRIGD\V LQFHQWLYHHQRXJKWRVHQGKHURQKHUZD\+HKDGQ¶WVDLGZK\KH FRXOGQ¶WMRLQKHULPPHGLDWHO\DQG0DUWLQKDGEHHQOHVVWKDQ IRUWKFRPLQJZKHQKH¶GUXQJWRVHHKRZVKHZDVFRSLQJZLWKQRQHZV RI3DXOD 8SRQDUULYDOKRPHVKH GVZLWFKHGRIIWKHEHOOVRQKHUWHOHSKRQHV WRHQVXUHVKHZRXOGQ WEHGLVWXUEHGZKLOVWVOHHSLQJEXWVKHKDGQ¶W KDGVKHDQGWKHSKRQHVKDGQ WUXQJDQGVKH GUHFHLYHGQRPDLORIDQ\ FRQVHTXHQFH"  'DPQGDPQ VKHVXGGHQO\H[FODLPHGOHDSLQJXSIURPKHUFKDLU 'DQWHIROORZHGKHUHYHU\PRYHPHQWZLWKVRXOIXOH\HVDVVKHFKHFNHG WKHSRVLWLRQRIWKHEHOOEXWWRQRQWKHODQGOLQH %ODVW,OHIWWKHEORRG\ WKLQJVZLWFKHGRII1RZRQGHU,KDYHQ¶WKHDUGDQ\FDOOHUV 6KHUDQ ILQJHUVWKURXJKKHUKDLULQDIUXVWUDWHGJHVWXUHRIKRSHOHVVXQFHUWDLQW\ 6KHFKHFNHGKHUPRELOH,WZDVVZLWFKHGRQULQJHUVZLWFKHGRII +RZFRXOGVKHKDYHEHHQVRVWXSLG -XVWWKHQVKHWKRXJKWVKHKHDUGWKHIDLQWVRXQGRIDFDU VHQJLQH 6KHJODQFHGRXWRIWKHZLQGRZ6KHWKHQGDVKHGIRUWKHGRRUKHDUWLQ 

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

RULHQWDOUXJVRQWKHIORRURWKHUVGUDSHGRQQDWXUDOVWRQHZDOOVZKHUH ERRNVKHOYHVKDGQ WVWUD\HGORZEHDPVFULVVFURVVLQJWKHURRPORJV VSLWWLQJDZHOFRPH  'RQ WMXVWVWDQGWKHUH VKHVDLGFORVLQJWKHGRRU $UHWKRVHURVHV IRUPH"

µ2IFRXUVHWKH\DUHDQGWKLV KHVDLGDQRWLFHDEOHVSDUNOHLQKLV H\HV 6KHDFFHSWHGWKHIORZHUVVWXGLHGDYHU\VPDOOSDFNDJHLQKLV KDQG :KDW¶VWKDW"

 $VPDOOWRNHQRIP\DIIHFWLRQ

6KHSODFHGWKHURVHVRQDFKDLUDQGVPLOHG ,VWKDWDOOLWLV"

 )LQGRXW

6KHTXLFNO\XQUDYHOOHGWKHVLOYHUSDWWHUQHGSDSHURSHQHGDVPDOO ER[WRUHYHDODJROGORFNHW¶ µ2SHQWKHORFNHW¶  2K/XNH\RXROGURPDQWLF$ORFNRIKDLU

 ,VQ WLWWUXHDPDQZLOODOZD\VEHDIDLWKIXOORYHULIDZRPDQ NHHSVDORFNRIKLVKDLU"

 /XNH,W VEHDXWLIXOEXW\RXGLGQ WQHHGWR¶  5HDGWKHLQVFULSWLRQILUVW KHVDLGURWDWLQJDILQJHU 6KHIOLSSHGWKHORFNHWUHDGWKHLQVFULSWLRQ$OZD\V/XNH 

 :KDWGLG\RXZDQWPHWRVD\" KHTXHULHGDQ[LRXVH[SUHVVLRQ KDYLQJUHWXUQHGWKURXJKRXWDPRPHQWRIXWWHUVLOHQFH:KHQVKH WKUHZKHUDUPVDURXQGKLVQHFNDQGNLVVHGDQGKXJJHGKLPWLJKWVKH FRQILUPHGKH GPDGHDPHQGV %\WKHZD\\RXUVLVWHUZLOOEHGRZQ KHUHLQDFRXSOHRIGD\V

 3DXOD"%XWKRZ"

 6KHIROORZHGWKURXJKDQGDFKLHYHGDUHDOVFRRS&RQQHGWKH EORRG\ORWRIXV
 6RZKDWGRHVKHJHWRXWRIVXFKDGHVSLFDEOHHQWHUSULVH"

 %LJPRQH\DQGDOLIHVW\OHKHFRXOGQ WSRVVLEO\DIIRUGRQDPHUH HGLWRU¶VVDODU\

 +RZ"

 7KHJLUOVDUHQRWVROGIRUKDUGFXUUHQF\VRWKDWJHWVKLPRIIWKH KRRNRIWUDGLQJLQHVFRUWJLUOVDQGDOWKRXJKHVFRUWDJHQFLHVDUH WHFKQLFDOO\LOOHJDOLQWKDWZKRHYHULVUXQQLQJDQ\RQHVKRZLV SLPSLQJDQGOLYLQJRIILPPRUDOHDUQLQJV1LNRWKHMDPP\VRDQGVR 

DFFHSWVSD\PHQWLQNLQG/LNHUDFHKRUVHVFDUVDKDOIVKDUHLQWKH PDQVLRQDQGDOX[XU\DSDUWPHQWLQ0RQDFR

 )RUJHWDOORIWKDWVLWGRZQDQGPDNH\RXUVHOIFRPIRUWDEOHZKLOH ,JRJHWXVERWKDKRWPXJRIFRIIHH

 'RQ WEHWRRORQJ,QHHGUHDVVXUDQFH

 2IZKDW"

 7KDW, YHGRQHVRPHWKLQJWRSOHDVH\RX 
 6KRZPH


 -XVWJRHVWRVKRZKRZOLWWOH3DXODNQHZDERXWWKHUHDO/XNH

 6RWHOOPHZKDW,GRQ WDOUHDG\NQRZ



 , PIDLUO\VXUH\RXNQRZ,FRXOGQHYHUEHKDSS\LQDFRQYHQWLRQDO PDUULDJH,VSHQGP\OLIHFRQWUROOLQJDQGPDQLSXODWLQJSHRSOH PDNLQJGHFLVLRQVDQGWKHODVWWKLQJ,ZDQWLVWRLQLWLDWHHYHU\ SHUYHUWHGVH[XDOPDUDWKRQZHPLJKWYHQWXUHLQWR +HVWXGLHGD PLVFKLHYRXVJOLQWLQKHUH\HV +DYLQJVDLGWKDW,GRQHHGVHFXULW\LQ DORYLQJUHODWLRQVKLSRULWZRQ WVXFFHHGDQGEHDVVXUHG, OOGRP\ GDPQEHVWWRVKRZ\RXKRZPXFKLWPHDQVWRPH

&KDUOLHVWURNHGKLVKDLUDIIHFWLRQDWHO\NLVVHGKLVIRUHKHDG µ'DUOLQJLVLWVRGLIILFXOWWRVD\ZKDW\RXUHDOO\ZDQWIURPD UHODWLRQVKLS"
+HVZDOORZHGKDUGUHSOLHGµ0RWKHUXVHGGDUOLQJLQKHU YRFDEXODU\ZLWKYHQRPRXVFODULW\EHIRUHJUDVSLQJZKDWHYHUFDPH ZLWKLQUHDFKRIKHUKDQGVRXVHWKDWHQGHDUPHQWLQDQJHUDQG, OO DOZD\VREH\P\OLWWOHZLOGFDW

 2K/XNHEXWGDUOLQJFRPHVQDWXUDOO\ZKHQ,ORYHVRPHERG\

µ'RQ¶WHYHUGRXEWVKHORYHGPHVKHMXVWKDGDVWUDQJHZD\RI VKRZLQJLW¶ µ%XW,¶PQRW\RXUPRWKHU¶ µ1RDQG\RX¶UHLQWHOOLJHQWHQRXJKWRZRUNRXWIRU\RXUVHOIZKDW ,¶PVD\LQJKHUH¶ 

&KDUOLHNQHZDOOULJKWNQHZH[DFWO\ZKHUH/XNHZDVFRPLQJ IURP (SLORJXH 0HUFHGHVILQLVKHGUHDGLQJGUHZLQDGHHSEUHDWKWKHQH[KDOHGVORZO\ 3URPSWHGE\VLOHQFH*X\VDLG ,YHU\QHDUO\ORVW\RXVKRUWO\ DIWHURXUILUVWPHHWLQJULJKW"

µ1RWUHDOO\DQGLWZDV\RXU3$ZKRUHDVVXUHGPH\RXZHUHD SOHDVXUHWRZRUNIRUDIWHU, GZDONHGLQWR\RXUOLIH

 3DXOWROG\RXWKDW"

 +HZDVQ WZURQJZDVKH"  +HIHOWKHUKDQGJULSSLQJWKHEDFNRIKLVQHFN,WVHQWDWLQJOH GRZQKLVVSLQHMXVWOLNHLWKDGRQWKHLUILUVWPHHWLQJZKHQWKH\ G FROOLGHGDW+HDWKURZDQGVKDUHGDWD[L



1RSHDQG,VXSSRVH,GLGVSHQGWKHILUVWIHZGD\VRQDKLJKDV, ZKLVWOHGP\ZD\DURXQGWKHRIILFHOLNHDGHPHQWHGORYHVLFN VFKRROER\

 ,WDEEHGOXQFKIRU3DXORQHGD\DQGKHJDYHPHWKHORZGRZQRQ \RXUVXSSRVHGO\OLFHQWLRXVVHFUHWOLIH"

µ+HZKDW"¶0HUFHGHVZDVXQNQRZLQJO\WUHDGLQJGDQJHURXV JURXQGDQGZLWKPHPRULHVRIVODYHVKH¶GRQFHKDGDQG0HUFHGHVQRW DFOXHWRWKHIDFWWKH\¶GH[LVWHGLQKLVOLIHKHUHVSRQGHGQHUYRXVO\DV VKHGUHZKLPFORVHµ+HNQHZQRWKLQJDERXWP\SULYDWHOLIH¶ µ:KHQGRHVD3$QRWNQRZDERXWDERVV¶SULYDWHOLIH"¶ *X\ZDVRQFHDWDGOLNH1LNRDQGODWWHUO\OLNH/XNHHTXDOO\DV SUHGDWRU\RUVXEPLVVLYHO\PDQLSXODWLYHDQGKDGJRWWHQH[DFWO\ZKR KHKDGZDQWHGLQWKHHQGEXWKDSS\HQGLQJVGLGQ¶WQHFHVVDULO\PHDQ KDSS\HYHUDIWHU µ$P,PLVVLQJDFOXHKHUH"¶KHWHQGHUHGKRSLQJWRKHOOKHKDGQ¶W MXVWZDONHGLQWRDPHWDSKRULFDOPDQSLW +HVWXGLHGDZLFNHGVSDUNOHLQ0HUFHGHVH\HVDQGJXHVVHGKH ZRXOGVRRQEHFKDLQHGWRWKHFURVVVXIIHULQJVH[XDOWRUWXUHIRU KDYLQJVOLSSHGIURPGXWLIXOO\DWWHQGLQJWRKHUVXFFXOHQWO\ZHWFODP DQGSHDUOLVHGQXE7KHVWRU\KDGNLQGRIJRWWHQKROGRIKLVDWWHQWLRQ PLGERRNWKRXJKVRPHVWRULHVWRGRZLWKVODYHVZHUHEHVWOHIWXQWROG 

1RZD\ZDVKHHYHUJRLQJWRSXWSHQWRSDSHUEHFDXVHLIKHGLGKH¶G VXUHDVKHOOUHYHDOWKLQJVKHZRXOGQ¶WZDQWDQ\ERG\WRJHWWKHLUKDQGV RQOHDVWRIDOO0HUFHGHVZKRPLJKWZHOOSXWWZRDQGWZRWRJHWKHUWR PDNHILYHDQGZKDWZRXOGEHFRPHRIWKHGRJZLWKRXWSURSHUORYLQJ SDUHQWV" µ,ZDVQ¶WDZDUHWKDW,¶GVHWDSX]]OHWREHVROYHG¶VDLG0HUFHGHV ORRNLQJVRPHZKDWFRQIXVHG 3KHZKHWKRXJKWOLSVHPEUDFLQJKHUV