A CONCISE HISTORICAL GRAMMAR OF THE ALBANIAN LANGUAGE: Reconstruction of Proto-Albanian
VLADIMIR OREL
BRILL
Orel 1.v...
138 downloads
1474 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
A CONCISE HISTORICAL GRAMMAR OF THE ALBANIAN LANGUAGE: Reconstruction of Proto-Albanian
VLADIMIR OREL
BRILL
Orel 1.vw
14-03-2000 11:05
Pagina 1
A CONCISE HISTORICAL GRAMMAR OF THE ALBANIAN LANGUAGE
This page intentionally left blank
Orel 1.vw
14-03-2000 11:05
Pagina 3
A CONCISE HISTORICAL GRAMMAR OF THE ALBANIAN LANGUAGE Reconstruction of Proto-Albanian
BY
VLADIMIR OREL
BRILL LEIDEN • BOSTON • KÖLN 2000
Orel 1.vw
14-03-2000 11:05
Pagina 4
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Orel, Vladimir E. A concise historical grammar of the Albanian language : reconstruction of Proto-Albanian / by Vladimir Orel. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 9004116478 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Albanian language—Grammar, Historical. I. Title. PG9519 .O74 2000 491'.9915—dc21 99-053799 CIP
Die Deutsche Bibliothek - CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Orel, Vladimir E.: A concise historical grammar of the Albanian language : reconstruction of Proto-Albanian / by Vladimir Orel. - Leiden ; Boston ; Köln : Brill, 2000 ISBN 90-04-11647-8
ISBN 90 04 11647 8
© Copyright 2000 by Koninklijke Brill nv, Leiden, The Netherlands All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Brill provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910 Danvers MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change. printed in the netherlands
To Dad
“The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master—that’s all … [Words have] a temper, some of them—particularly verbs, they’re the proudest—adjectives you can do anything with, but not verbs—however, I can manage the whole lot!” Lewis Carroll
This page intentionally left blank
contents
vii
&217(176 3UHIDFH ;, 5HIHUHQFHV ;9 $EEUHYLDWLRQV ;;, 3KRQRORJ\ 9RZHOV 6KRUWYRZHOV /RQJYRZHOV 'LSKWKRQJV 'HYHORSPHQWRIWKH(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQYRFDOLVP 1.1.5. Unstressed vowels ........................................................ 20 9RFDOLVPRIORDQZRUGV 9RZHOVLQ*UHHNORDQZRUGV 9RZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV 6KRUWYRZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV /RQJYRZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV /DWLQGLSKWKRQJV 3RVLWLRQDOFKDQJHVRIYRZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV 9RZHOVLQ6ODYLFORDQZRUGV 6RQRUDQWV 6\OODELFVRQRUDQWV $V\OODELFVRQRUDQWV $V\OODELFVRQRUDQWVLQORDQZRUGV &RQVRQDQWV 6SLUDQWV 2FFOXVLYHV ODELDOVDQGGHQWDOV 2FFOXVLYHV YHODUV 3DODWDOL]DWLRQV 1.4.5. Rhythmic rule ............................................................... 78 &RQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV &RQVRQDQWVLQORDQZRUGV ............................................. 102
viii
contents
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
contents
ix
'HPRQVWUDWLYHDQGUHODWLYHSURQRXQV'HILQLWH IRUPV .......................................................................... 245 1XPHUDOV 9RFDEXODU\ 6HOHFWHGOH[LFDOLVRJORVVHVRI$OEDQLDQ 6HOHFWHGVHPDQWLFILHOGVLQ$OEDQLDQ 3KRQHWLFWDEOHV ,QGH[RI$OEDQLDQIRUPV ,QGH[DWHUJR
This page intentionally left blank
35()$&( The present book was started in 1982, in Mikhalevo (Russia), and its first (Russian) variant was finished in 1989 when it was submitted as a second doctoral dissertation to the linguistic department of the Institute for Slavic and Balkan studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences (OREL Alb.). At the same time, the typescript was smuggled across the border to the United States (as some other works of the present writer) but, unfortunately, got lost on way to its destination. I continued my work on the historical grammar of Albanian while simultaneously writing an etymological dictionary as well: one project fostered the other. Until 1996, I had to concentrate on the etymological dictionary which eventually saw the light in 1998 (OREL AED). Meanwhile, the English text was quickly finished in 19971998. The present grammar was used as the basis of several courses in the historical grammar of Albanian (Institute of Slavic and Balkan Studies, Moscow, 1987 and V.A. Dybo’s Nostratic Seminar, 1988) and of a graduate seminar at UCLA in 1999. The main objective of the book is to analyze the lexical material of the new etymological dictionary (the latter should be used as a data base immediately connected with the grammar), and to give a new detailed description of the linguistic development from ProtoIndoEuropean to ProtoAlbanian to modern Albanian. Different stages of this development were not of equal interest to the writer. The history of the Albanian language understood as a description of its evolution from the earliest attested monuments (Old Albanian) to its present form remained beyond the reach of this study. For that—perfectly legitimate—kind of linguistic history of Albanian we will need another book. In my work, I deal with the transition from IndoEuropean to ProtoAlbanian and the correspondences between ProtoAlbanian and modern Albanian. Therefore, many important features of modern Albanian are not discussed here: they are relatively recent and therefore irrelevant for my main task, the reconstruction of ProtoAlbanian. Not all important features of the ProtoAlbanian structure can be revealed and properly described today. Our knowledge is still very insufficient, especially in the field of ProtoAlbanian morphology. The study of Proto-Albanian syntax remains in its infancy. Hence, there are natural limitations to the present work: I give a relatively full description of historical phonetics but the third chapter of the book («Morphology») is only a very brief and incomplete sketch, in particular, as far as the
xii
preface
ProtoAlbanian verb is concerned. Two central notions of my work are ProtoIndoEuropean and ProtoAlbanian. As far as Proto-IndoEuropean is concerned, its definitions or descriptions are beyond the scope of this work. The phonetic and morphological reconstruction of ProtoIndoEuropean used here delineates a late stage in the development of the language, a stage in which certain areal changes have already occurred, such as the loss of Indo-Europen laryngeals. ProtoAlbanian is viewed as a language already possessing several features typical of the Albanian linguistic type. We reconstruct it in two forms: Early ProtoAlbanian—immediately before the beginning of linguistic contacts with speakers of Latin/ProtoRomance (1st century CE), and Late ProtoAlbanian—following the contacts with ProtoRomance and ancient Slavic dialects still close to ProtoSlavic (6th-7th centuries CE). Major changes shattered the structure of ProtoAlbanian during this short but eventful period. The work is based on the results of my own research (including the data of the Albanian Etymological Dictionary and numerous papers on the reconstruction of ProtoAlbanian) as well as existing literature, including studies by such outstanding students of Albanian from its IndoEuropean perspective as MEYER, PEDERSEN, JOKL, ÇABEJ, and HAMP. In many cases, the book suggests new solutions for complicated problems of Albanian historical phonetics, and sometimes proposes revisions of my earlier studies. An attentive reader will easily notice them, especially if the literature I have adduced has been properly studied. However, references are very far from being complete; the reader should consult my etymological dictionary for more infromation. The book contains four chapters—«Phonetics», «Morphonology and wordformation», «Morphology» and «Vocabulary». My knowledge of the Proto-Albanian syntax is so insufficient that a separate chapter on the subject would be totally irrelevant. Inside each chapter, the text is divided into sections and paragraphs. The beginning paragraph of every section (its number always ending in zero) includes a brief list of relevant literature, some of it—with very short summaries. The book concludes with an index of Albanian forms. Whenever Tosk and Geg forms coincide, one Albanian form is quoted. If there are phonetic differences between Tosk and Geg, two forms are adduced separated by a tilda, with the Tosk form coming first, e.g. OO¬U¬ ~ OODQ¬If the word only exists in Tosk or in Geg, it is marked correspondingly. Forms from the various IndoEuropean daughter languages are given according to their traditional transliterations. The
preface
xiii
same applies to Proto-IndoEuropean reconstruction. As the reader will notice, I tend to use what could be labelled as «late» or «Brugmannian» IndoEuropean. Such a reconstruction does not take into account the comparative evidence provided by Hittite and Tocharian. Albanian is a product of this «late IndoEuropean» and it seemed counterproductive to make our reconstruction deeper than really necessary. I use three types of arrows in the text in order to distinguish between historical development, borrowing and morphological derivation. I do not have any illusions as to the future of this little innovation—it won’t be taken up. However, I want to give it a try. Usual arrows > < are reserved for historical change as they are normally used today. Thus, !Rmeans the development of
in time. Arrows ÖÕ are used to describe the act of borrowing. The formula WHUUDH PAWXP Ö W¬UPHW deals with loanwords. Finally, arrows ¾½ appear in my description of wordformation. They indicate «derived from», e.g. bir ¾ birth. While working on the book, I was able to use the excellent facilities of the Greek-Slavonic Annexe of the Taylor Institute (Oxford), McMaster University Library (Hamilton, Ontario) and the Hebrew University Libraries (Jerusalem). I am indebted to all the above institutions as well as to my former university (Bar-Ilan University in Ramat-Gan) for their support of my research. I am also grateful to the Egged Bus Co-operative (Israel) in whose buses and coaches I wrote substantial parts of this work. I want to express my gratitude to several people whose combination of advice, help and fierce criticism were important at various stages of my research in the field of the historical grammar of Albanian during the last seventeen years: Çlirim Bidollari (Tirana), Vladimir Dybo (Moscow), D. Ellis Evans (Oxford), John Greppin (Cleveland), Viacheslav Ivanov (Los Angeles), Irina Kalu°skaia (Moscow), Evgenii Khelimski (Moscow), Alexander Rusakov (St. Petersburg), Vitaly Shevoroshkin (Ann Arbor), Vladimir Toporov (Moscow), Brent Vine (Los Angeles), Charles Xu (Calgary) and Andrei Zalizniak (Moscow). I am also grateful to Susan Rothstein and Adam Wyner of Bar-Ilan University (Ramat-Gan). Some of my advisors and friends have passed away. My gratitude to Leonid Gindin (Moscow) is mixed with the bitter taste of remembrance. I am particularly indebted to my friend Jay Friedman (Los Angeles) who has edited the whole text (but not this sentence) and encouraged me to make numerous important changes in it. Calgary, Alberta November 30, 1999
This page intentionally left blank
5()(5(1&(6 $$UE6W – $UKLY]DDUEDQDVNXVWDULQXMH]LNLHWQRORJLMX,–,,,%HRJUDG – $,$. – $NWHQ GHU LQWHUQDWLRQDOHQ DOEDQRORJLVFKHQ .ROORTXLXPV ,QQVEUXFN $QF,(– $QFLHQW,QGR(XURSHDQ'LDOHFWV%HUNHOH\ $QWL¨EDON– $QWL¨QDMDEDONDQLVWLND0RVNYD $QWL¨EDON– $QWL¨QDMDEDONDQLVWLND0RVNYD $17.2:6.,–$17.2:6., ) /D FKURQRORJLH GH OD PRQRSKWRQJDLVRQ GHV GLSKWRQJXHVGDQVOHVODQJXHVLQGRHXURS©HQQHV3R]QD¼ %$– %DONDQ$UFKLY/HLpziJ,–,9 – %DOFDQLFD– %DOFDQLFD/LQJYLVWL¨HVNLHLVVOHGRYDQLMD0RVNYD %DOWLVWLFD– %DOWLVWLFD9LOQLXV BARIC´ $56W– BARIC´+$OEDQRUXP¥QLVFKH6WXGLHQ,6DUDMHYR > =XU .XQGHGHU%DONDQKDOELQVHO4XHOOHQXQG)RUVFKXQJHQ9,,@ %$5,Ç+\PMH– %$5,Ç,++\PMHQ¬KLVWRULQ¬HJMXK¬VVKTLSH3ULVKWLQ¬ BARIC´ ,VW– BARIC´ +,VWRULMDDUEDQDVNRJMH]LND 6DUDMHYR > %DONDQR ORhNL,QVWLWXW'MHOD;,,@ %233 – %233)¡EHUGDV$OEDQHVLVFKHLQVHLQHQYHUZDQGWVFKDIWOLFKHQ%H]LH KXQJHQ .µQLJOLFKH 3UHXßLVFKH $NDGHPLH GHU :LVVHQVFKDIWHQ $EKDQG OXQJHQGHU3KLORVRSKLVFKKLVWRULVFKHQ.ODVVH%HUOLQ – %6/– %XOOHWLQGHOD6RFL©W©OLQJXLVWLTXHGH3DULV3DULV %86K7– %XOHWLQL8QLYHVLWHWLW6KWHW¬URUW¬7LUDQ¬V6HULDVKNHQFDWVKRTHURUH 7LUDQD>IURP FRQWLQXHGDV6WXGLPHILORORJMLNH@ &DKLHUV3X×FDULX– &DKLHUV63X×FDULX,–,,%XFDUHVWH &$0$-$OE:RUWE– &$0$-0$OEDQLVFKH:RUWELOGXQJ:LHVEDGHQ > $OEDQLVFKH)RUVFKXQJHQ9,@ &$3,'$1$URP–&$3,'$17+$URPDˆQLL 'LDOHFWXODURPDˆQ%XFXUH×WL &,(% – $FWHV GX , &RQJUªV ,QWHUQDWLRQDO GHV ©WXGHV EDONDQLTXHV HW VXGHVW HXURS©HQQHV9,/LQJXLVWLTXH6RILD &,02&+2:6., 'XVKPDQL–&,02&+2:6., : /H GLDOHFWH GH 'XVKPDQL '©VFULSWLRQGHO XQGHVSDUOHUVGHO $OEDQLHGX1RUG3R]QD¼ &,320RUIRORJMLD–&,32.0RUIRORJMLDKLVWRULNHHVKTLSHV7LUDQ¬ &2:*,// – &2:*,// : & 7KH ,QGR(XURSHDQ /RQJ 9RZHO 3UHWHULW
xvi
references
'(0,5$-*U+LVW– '(0,5$-6+*UDPDWLN¬KLVWRULNHHJMXK¬VVKTLSH7LUDQ¬ '(0,5$- 0RUI KLVW – '(0,5$- 6+ 0RUIRORJLMD KLVWRULNH H JMXK¬V VKTLSH , 7LUDQD '(61,&.$-$ $MD] – '(61,&.$-$ $9 $OEDQVNLM MD]\N L HJR GLDOHNW\ /HQLQJUDG '(61,&.$-$ 6UDYQ – '(61,&.$-$ $9 6UDYQLWHO’QRH MD]\NR]QDQLH L LVWRULMD MD]\NRY/HQLQJUDG '2=21 0DQXHO – '2=21 $ 0DQXHO GH OD ODQJXH VKNLSH RX DOEDQDLVH 3DULV ÈWLPRORJLMD – ÈWLPRORJLMD 0RVNYD ÈWLPRORJLMD – ÈWLPRORJLMD 0RVNYD (Ê ™*8 – 1DX¨Q\M HÊHJRGQLN ™HUQRYLFNRJR *8 ]D ™HUQRYF\ )HVWVFKU .QREORFK – 6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH )RUVFKXQJHQ )HVWVFKULIW IºU -RKDQQ.QREORFK,QQVEUXFN )HVWVFKU5R]ZDGRZVNL – 6\PERODH JUDPPDWLFDH LQ KRQRUHP ,RDQQLV 5R]ZD GRZVNL,–,,&UDFRYLDH – )HVWVNU7KRPVHQ– )HVWVNULIWWLO9LOKHOP7KRPVHQ.øEHQKDYQ )/+– )ROLD/LQJXLVWLFD+LVWRULFD.UDN²Z *$0.5(/,'=( – ,9$129 – *$0.5(/,'=(79,9$12999,QGRHYURSHMVNLM MD]\N L LQGRHYURSHMF\ 5HNRQVWUXNFLMD L LVWRULNRWLSRORJL¨HVNLM DQDOL] SUDMD]\NDLSURWRNXO’WXU\,–,,7ELOLVL *HGHQNVFKU %UDQGHQVWHLQ–6WXGLHQ ]XU 6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW XQG .XOWXUNXQGH *HGHQNVFKULIWIºU:%UDQGHQVWHLQ,QQVEUXFN > ,%.;,9@ *HGHQNVFKU &RZJLOO–6WXGLHV LQ 0HPRU\ RI :DUUHQ &RZJLOO %HUOLQ–1HZ
references
xvii
-2./ /.8%$ – -2./ 1 /LQJXLVWLVFKNXOWXUKLVWRULVFKH 8QWHUVXFKXQJHQ DXV GHP%HUHLFKHGHV$OEDQLVFKHQ%HUOLQ–/HLS]LJ -2./ 6WXGLHQ – -2./ 1 6WXGLHQ ]XU DOEDQHVLVFKHQ (W\PRORJLH XQG :RUW ELOGXQJ:LHQ > .DLVHUOLFKH$NDGHPLHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQLQ:LHQ 6LW]XQJVEHULFKWH3KLORVRSKLVFKKLVWRULVFKH.ODVVH&/;9,,,@ ./,1*(16&+0,779HUEXP– ./,1*(16&+0,77*'DVDOWDUPHQLVFKH9HUEXP :LHVEDGHQ .ROO ,GJ *HV–5$60866(1 -( HG ,Q KRQRUHP +ROJHU 3HGHUVHQ .ROOR TXLXPGHU,QGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*HVHOOVFKDIW:LHVEDGHQ .85</2:,&=,QIO&DW– .85</2:,&=-7KH,QIOHFWLRQDO&DWHJRULHVRI,QGR (XURSHDQ+HLGHOEHUJ /$3,$1$6WXGL– /$3,$1$06WXGLOLQJXLVWLFLDOEDQHVL,3UROHJRPHQLDOOR VWXGLRGHOODOLQJXLVWLFDDOEDQHVH3DOHUPR /$3,$1$6W9DULD– /$3,$1$06WXGLOLQJXLVWLFLDOEDQHVL9DULD3H]]LQR– 3DOHUPR /DU\QJHDOV– :,17(5: HG (YLGHQFHIRU/DU\QJHDOV7KH+DJXH /%– /LQJXLVWLTXHEDONDQLTXH6RILD /LQJXLVWLFD– /LQJXLVWLFD/MXEOMDQD /LQJYLVVOHG– /LQJYLVWL¨HVNLHLVVOHGRYDQLMD,–,,0RVNYD /,V – /LQJYLVWL¨HVNLH LVVOHGRYDQLMD 6UDYQLWHO’QRLVWRUL¨HVNRH L WLSRORJL¨HVNRHL]X¨HQLHMD]\NRY0RVNYD /3– /LQJXD3RVQDQLHQVLV3R]QD¼. 0$11 +LVW *U – 0$11 6( $Q $OEDQLDQ +LVWRULFDO *UDPPDU +DPEXUJ 0$7+,$66(1 – 0$7+,$66(176WXGLHQ]XPVODYLVFKHQXQGLQGRHXURS¥LVFKHQ /DQJYRNDOLVPXV2VOR 0(,' )OH[LRQ – 0(,' : 'LH LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ *UXQGODJHQ GHU DOWLULVFKHQ DEVROXWHQXQGNRQMXQNWHQ)OH[LRQ:LHVEDGHQ 0©ODQJHV 3HGHUVHQ–0©ODQJHV OLQJXLVWLTXHV RIIHUWV £ 0 +ROJHU 3HGHUVHQ .øEHQKDYQ > $FWD-XWODQGLFD,;@ 0(<(5 $OE *U – 0(<(5 * .XU]JHIDßWH DOEDQHVLVFKH *UDPPDWLN PLW /HVHVWºFNHQXQG*ORVVDU/HLS]LJ 0(<(5$OE6W,– 0(<(5*$OEDQHVLVFKH6WXGLHQ,'LH3OXUDOELOGXQJHQGHU DOEDQHVLVFKHQ 1RPLQD 6LW]XQJVEHULFKWH GHU SKLORVRSKLVFKKLVWRULVFKHQ &ODVVH GHU .DLVHUOLFKHQ $NDGHPLH GHU :LVVHQVFKDIWHQ &,9 – 0(<(5 $OE 6W ,, – 0(<(5 * $OEDQHVLVFKH 6WXGLHQ ,, 'LH DOEDQHVLVFKHQ =DKOZµUWHU 6LW]XQJVEHULFKWH GHU SKLORVRSKLVFKKLVWRULVFKHQ &ODVVH GHU .DLVHUOLFKHQ$NDGHPLHGHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ&9,, – 0(<(5 :E – 0(<(5 * (W\PRORJLVFKHV :µUWHUEXFK GHU DOEDQHVLVFKHQ 6SUDFKH6WUDßEXUJ 06/–0©PRLUHVGHOD6RFL©W©GHOLQJXLVWLTXHGH3DULV3DULV 1XPHUDOV – ,QGR(XURSHDQ 1XPHUDOV %HUOLQ–1HZ 7UHQGV /9,,@ 2UELV– 2UELV/RXYDLQ 25(/$('– 25(/9$OEDQLDQ(W\PRORJLFDO'LFWLRQDU\/HLGHQ
xviii
references
25(/ $OE – 25(/ 9 6UDYQLWHO’QRLVWRULFKHVNDMD JUDPPDWLND DOEDQVNRJR MD]\ND IRQHWLND L PRUIRORJLLD 'LVVHUWDFLMD >@ GRNW ILO QDXN 0RVNYD >PDQXVFULSW@ 3('(56(1$OE7H[WH– 3('(56(1+$OEDQHVLVFKH7H[WHPLW*ORVVDU/HLS]LJ 3('(56(1.HOW*U– 3('(56(1 +9HUJOHLFKHQGH *UDPPDWLN GHU NHOWLVFKHQ 6SUDFKHQ*µWWLQJHQ 3('(56(1 3URQ – 3('(56(1 + /HV SURQRPV G©PRQVWUDWLIV GH O’DQFLHQ DUP©QLHQ.RSHQKDJHQ 3(.0(=,– 3(.0(=,**UDPPDWLNGHUDOEDQHVLVFKHQ6SUDFKH:LHQ 3,6$1,6DJJL– 3,6$1,96DJJLGLOLQJXLVWLFDVWRULFD7RULQR 325=,* *OLHGHUXQJ – 325=,* :3 'LH *OLHGHUXQJ GHV LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ 6SUDFKJHELHWV+HLGHOEHUJ 3ULW – .DWHJRULMD SULWMDÊDWHO’QRVWL Y VODYMDQVNLNK L EDOWLMVNLNK MD]\NDNK 0RV FRZ 3UREOKLVW– 3UREOHPHW¬KLVWRULQ¬V¬JMXKHVVKTLSH3ULVKWLQ¬ 3UREOUHN– .RQIHUHQFLMD“3UREOHP\UHNRVWUXNFLL”0RVFRZ 3URF ,; 8&/$ – 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH 1LQWK $QQXDO 8&/$ ,QGR(XURSHDQ &RQIHUHQFH/RV$QJHOHV 36)LO– 3UREOHP\VUDYQLWHO’QRMILORORJLL/HQLQJUDG 5$60866(1 0RUSK – 5$60866(1 -( 6WXGLHQ ]XU 0RUSKRSKRQHPLN GHU LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ*UXQGVSUDFKH,QQVEUXFN 5%– 5RPDQR%DOFDQLFD9RSURV\DGDSWDFLLODWLQVNRJRMDV\NRYRJRªOHPHQWDY EDONDQVNRPDUHDOH/HQLQJUDG 5(6O– 5HYXHGHV©WXGHVVODYHV3DULV 55/– 5HYXHURXPDLQHGHOLQJXLVWLTXH%XFDUHVWH 56KN– 5HYLVWDVKNHQFRUHH,QVWLWXWLW3HGDJRJMLN'\YMHçDU6KNRG¬U 6$1')(/' /EDON – 6$1')(/' . /LQJXLVWLTXH EDONDQLTXH SUREOªPHV HW U©VXOWDWV3DULV 6%-D.RQWDNW\– 6ODYMDQVNRHLEDONDQVNRHMD]\NR]QDQLH3UREOHP\ MD]\NRY\[ NRQWDNWRY0RVNYD 6&+0,' %DOW – 6&+0,' :3 6WXGLHQ ]XP EDOWLVFKHQ XQG LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ 9HUEXP:LHVEDGHQ 6(/,Û&% (9 6ODY 1DVHOHQLH – 6(/,Û&% (9 $0 6ODYMDQVNRH QDVHOHQLH Y $OEDQLL 6RILMD 6&/– 6WXGLL.L&HUFHW:UL/LQJYLVWLFH%XFXUH.WL 62/7$ %DONDQOLQJXLVWLN – 62/7$ *5 (LQIºKUXQJ LQ GLH %DONDQOLQJXLVWLN PLW EHVRQGHUHU %HUºFNVLFKWLJXQJ GHV 6XEVWUDWV XQG GHV %DONDQODWHLQLVFKHQ 'DUPVWDGW 6RYVODY– 6RYHWVNRHVODYMDQRYHGHQLH0RVNYD>IURP –6ODYMDQRYHGHQLH@ 6SUDFKH– 'LH6SUDFKH=HLWVFKULIWIºU6SUDFKZLVVHQVFKDIW:LHQ 66*/– 6WXGLHVLQ6ODYLFDQG*HQHUDO/LQJXLVWLFV$PVWHUGDP–$WODQWD 66/– 6WXGLHVDJJLOLQJXLVWLFL3LVD 6WDOE– 6WXGLDOEDQHVL1DSROL 6W)– 6WXGLPH)LORORJMLNH7LUDQD 6W,(– 6WXGLDLQGRHXURSHMVNLH:URFwDZ–:DUV]DZD–.UDN²Z–Gda¼sk
references
xix
6=(0(5É1<,1XPHUDOV– 6=(0(5É1<,26WXGLHVLQWKH,QGR(XURSHDQ6\VWHP RI1XPHUDOV+HLGHOEHUJ 7$*/,$9,1,'DOPD]LD– 7$*/,$9,1,&/’DOEDQHVHGL'DOPD]LD)LUHQ]H > %LEOLRWHFDGHOO $UFKLYXP5RPDQLFXP;;,, VHU @ 7$*/,$9,1, 6WUDWLILFD]LRQH – 7$*/,$9,1, & 6WUDWLILFD]LRQH GHO OHVVLFR DOEDQHVH(OHPHQWLLQGRHXURSHL%RORJQD 9$,//$17*UFRPS– 9$,//$17$*UDPPDLUHFRPSDU©HGHVODQJXHVVODYHV ,–,,,3DULV–/\RQ – 9$5%27 3UDVODY – 9$5%27 ää 3UDVODYMDQVNDMD PRUIRQRORJLMD VORYR REUD]RYDQLHLªWLPRORJLMD0RVNYD 9$60(5 $OE :RUWIRUVFK – 9$60(5 0 6WXGLHQ ]XU DOEDQHVLVFKHQ :RUW IRUVFKXQJ'RUSDW $FWDHW&RPP8QLY'RUS6HULH%, 9-D–9RSURV\MD]\NR]QDQLMD0RVNYD 92521,1$ 0HVKDUL – 92521,1$ ,, 6LVWHPD DUWLNOHM Y UDQQHQRYRDOEDQVNRP MD]\NH ;9, YHND QD PDWHULDOH MD]\NRYRJR SDPMDWQLND ;9, YHND–0HVKDUL *M%X]XND0RVFRZ 96-D– 9RSURV\VODYMDQVNRJRMD]\NR]QDQLMD9\S0RVNYD :$7.,16 *HVFKLFKWH – :$7.,16 & *HVFKLFKWH GHU LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ 9HUEDOIOH[LRQ+HLGHOEHUJ :(,*$1' *U – :(,*$1' */ $OEDQHVLVFKH *UDPPDWLN LP VºGJHJLVFKHQ 'LDOHNW 'XUD]]R(OEDVVDQ7LUDQD /HLS]LJ ;+89$1, Ç$%(- 3DUDVKW – ;+89$1, $ Ç$%(- ( 3DUDVKWHVDW H JMXK¬V VKTLSH Ç$%(-6W,,, ;+89$1, Ç$%(- 3UDSDVKW – ;+89$1, $ Ç$%(- ( 3UDSDVKWHVDW H JMXK¬V VKTLSH Ç$%(-6W,,, =I%DON– =HLWFKULIWIºU%DONDQRORJLH:LHVEDGHQ =I3KRQHWLN – =HLWVFKULIW IºU 3KRQHWLN XQG DOOJHPHLQH 6SDUFKZLVVHQVFKDIW %HUOLQ > =HLWVFKULIW IºU 3KRQHWLN 6SDUFKZLVVHQVFKDIW XQG .RPPXQLND WLRQVIRUVFKXQJ@
This page intentionally left blank
$%%5(9,$7,216)25/$1*8$*(6$1'',$/(&76 Afgh – Afghan Alb – Albanian Anat – Anatolian Arm – Armenian Att – Attic Av – Avestan Balt – Baltic Bret – Breton Bulg – Bulgarian Corn – Cornish Dac – Dacian Dor – Doric E – English EPA – Early Proto-Albanian Fr – French G – German Gk – Greek Gmc – Germanic Goth – Gothic Hitt – Hittite Hom – Homeric IE – Indo-European Illyr – Illyrian Ion – Ionic Iran – Iranian Ir – Irish Lat – Latin Latv – Latvian Lith – Lithuanian LPA – Late Proto-Albanian Lyd – Lydian MDu – Middle Dutch Mess – Messapic MGk – Middle Greek MIr – Middle Irish MLG – Middle Low German MW – Middle Welsh NIr – Modern Irish OAlb – Old Albanian OCorn – Old Cornish OE – Old English OFris – Old Frisian OHG – Old High German OIr – Old Irish OLat – Old Latin
xxii ON – Old Norse OPers – Old Persian OPrus – Old Prussian OS – Old Saxon Osc – Oscan Osset – Ossetic Phryg – Phrygian Rom – Romance Rum – Rumanian SCr – Serbo-Croatian Scyth – Scythian Skt – Sanskrit Slav – Slavic Thrac – Thracian Toch – Tocharian Umbr – Umbrian W – Welsh
references abbreviations
3+212/2*<
9RZHOV ,QGR(XURSHDQ YRFDOLVP DV LW FDQ EH UHFRQVWUXFWHG DIWHU WKH ORVV RI ODU\QJHDOV ZDV UHODWLYHO\ ZHOO SUHVHUYHG LQ (DUO\ 3URWR $OEDQLDQ +RZHYHU LWV HYROXWLRQ IURP (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WR /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DQG WKHQ WR $OEDQLDQ LV TXLWH FRPSOLFDWHG 1XPHURXV SKRQRORJLFDOFKDQJHVREVFXUHPDQ\GHWDLOV
6KRUWYRZHOV 7KH V\VWHP RI VKRUW YRZHOV H[SHULHQFHG WZR PDMRU WUDQVIRU PDWLRQV WKHPHUJHURI ,( D R DQG LQ VRPH SKRQRORJLFDO FRQWH[WV
i DW WKH (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ OHYHO DQG ODWHU FRPSOH[ SKRQRORJLFDO FKDQJHVRI H /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 $OE 6W ,,, 0$11 /DQJXDJH ;;9, ;;9,,, +LVW *U %$5,&´ ,VW H ! L LQ PLVK 3,6$1, 6DJJL +$03 .= /;;;,9 FRQGLWLRQV RI WKH GLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQRI H *(25*,(9 7UDNLWH $OEDQLDQ'DFLDQ SDUDOOHOLQWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI H Ç$%(- 6W,,, 25(/ 6%MD .RQWDNW\
,( D ZDV SUHVHUYHG DV (3$ D ! $OE D (3$ D FKDQJHV WR
$OE H XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI YDULRXV SKRQHWLF RU PRUSKRQRORJLFDO IDFWRUV DFDU ‘VKDUS’ (3$ DWVDUD ,( D LG 2,U DLFKH ‘VKDUS’ *N CMTQP‘SRLQWWRS’/LWKDhU¸V‘VKDUS’6ODY RVWUÙLG DVKN¬ ‘ZRRG VSOLQWHU’ (3$ D N hN ,( DV ‘D[LV’ 6NW ¢N¿D *NCEYP/DWD[LV EDWK¬‘EURDGEHDQ’ (3$ EDWV *NHCMJ ‘GLVKRIOHQWLOV’HCMQX ‘OHQWLO’ GKDOO¬‘EXWWHUPLON’ (3$ G]DO *NICNCLG HOE‘EDUOH\’ (3$ DOEL *NCNHK NDS ‘WR VHL]H WR JUDVS’ (3$ NDSD ,( NDS ‘WR VHL]H’ *N MCRVY ‘WR VQDS’ /DW FDSLA ‘WR VHL]H WR WDNH’ *RWK KDEDQ‘WR KROGWRKDYH’ NHT‘EDGHYLO’ (3$ NDNMD *NMCMQXLG
2
chapter one
PDM ~ PDˆM ‘WR IHHG WR IDWWHQ’ (3$ PD]GQMD ,( PD]G ‘IHHGLQJ’ 2+*PDVW6NWP©ÅDV‘IDWPDUURZ’
,( R\LHOGHG(3$ D7KHODWWHUUHIOHFWVDV$OEDEXWUDLVHVWR
$OEHLQFHUWDLQSKRQHWLFFRQGLWLRQV VHH (3$ DDSSHDUVDV¬~ â EHIRUHQDVDOFRQVRQDQWV
GHUU‘SLJ’ (3$ GDUMD ,( ½KRURVLG *NZQK`TQX JM¬~JMâ‘WKLQJ’ (3$ VDQ V ,( VRQWV‘EHLQJ’ 6NWVDQW*N YP PDUGK¬‘FKLOOIURVWLFH’ (3$ PDUG] 6ODY PRU]Ù‘IURVW’ QDW¬ ‘QLJKW’ (3$ QDNWL FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR ,( QRNÆW LG 6NW Q¢NW*NPWE/DWQR[ QHV¬U ‘WRPRUURZ’ (3$ QDWhAU ,( QRNÆWAU : QHLWKLZU QHLWKZ\U‘ODVWQLJKW’%UHWQHL]œUQHL]ºULG SD ‘ZLWKRXW EHIRUH WKHQ’ (3$ DSD UHIOHFWLQJ ,( DSR 6NW ¢SD ‘DZD\ RII’ *N C RQ ‘IURP’ *RWK DI ‘IURP ZLWKRXW EHIRUH WKHQ’
,( i JDYH VLPLODU UHIOH[HV LH (3$ D ODWHU EHFRPLQJ D
VRXUFHRI$OEDRULQVSHFLILFDOO\GHILQHGFRQGLWLRQV EHFRPLQJ $OEHRU¬ IODN‘WRWKURZWRIOLQJ’ (3$ DZDODND]HURJUDGHRI,( ON~
OiNWREHQGWRMXPS’ 0+*OHFNHQ‘WRWKURZEDFNWRVSULQJ’ /LWKOHNL¸O|NWL‘WRIO\’/DWYOªNW‘WRVSULQJWRMXPS’ NHP‘LQFHQVH’ (3$ NDSQD]HURJUDGHRI,( NÆS *NMCRPQX ‘VPRNH’ OHK~OHI‘WREDUN’ (3$ ODMD 6NWUd\DWLLG/LWKO²MXO²WLLG6ODY
ODMDWL PDV‘WRPHDVXUH’ (3$ PDWMD ,( PiWAGHQRPLQDWLYHRI P LG 6NWPPWL7RFK$PH UUDK‘WREHDWWRVWULNH’ (3$ ZUDJVND]HURJUDGHRI,( ÆUJK LG *NT CUUY VKWD]¬ ~ VKWDˆ]¬ ‘DQLPDO’ EDVHG RQ (3$ VWDQD IURP ,( VWiQR ,( VW K ‘WRVWDQG’ WDOO¬‘SHHOHGFRUQFRE FRUQVWUDZ’ (3$ WDO]HURJUDGHUHODWHG WR*NVJ`NKX‘IHQXJUHHN’/LWKDW²ODV‘ILUVWJUDVVHPHUJLQJDIWHU KD\PRZLQJ’
phonology
3
,WPD\EHVXVSHFWHGWKDWGLIIHUHQWO\FRORUHGODU\QJHDOV RUVFKZD FRXOG \LHOG GLIIHUHQW UHIOH[HV LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,QGHHG ZH ILQG DW OHDVW RQH FDVH ZKHUH WKH UHIOH[ VHHPV WR EH (3$ H FRQWLQXLQJ D “SDODWDO” ODU\QJHDOLQD]HURJUDGHIRUPRI,( GK L GKH+L GMDO¬ ‘ER\ \RXWK’ (3$ GHOD ,( GKL ‘WR VXFN’ /DWY G?OV ‘VRQ’/DWIOLXVLG
+RZHYHU LQ VRPH RWKHU FDVHV ,( i LV ORVW LQ $OEDQLDQ ,W VHHPV SUREDEOH WKDW “VFKZD” LV ORVW ZKHQHYHU LW IROORZV D VWUHVVHG V\OODEOHDVGHPRQVWUDWHGE\WKHIROORZLQJWZRH[DPSOHV EDOW¬ ‘VZDPS PDUVK GLUW HDUWK’ (3$ EDOW ,( EK²OiWRP LG 6ODY EROWRFI/LWKE¢OWDV‘ZKLWH’ EDUGK¬‘ZKLWH’ (3$ EDUG]D EK²Ui½R‘VKLQLQJ’ 6NWEK¢UJD
,( H ZDV SUHVHUYHG XQFKDQJHG LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ
+RZHYHU ODWHU LW XQGHUZHQW FRPSOLFDWHG WUDQVIRUPDWLRQV 7KH GHYHORSPHQW RI (3$ H ZDV PDLQO\ GLUHFWHG DW GLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQ 7KLV FKDQJHKRZHYHUGLGQRWRFFXULQFHUWDLQFRQGLWLRQVDQGLWLVQRWTXLWH FOHDU ZKHWKHU WKHUH H[LVWHG ILOWHUV SUHYHQWLQJ GLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQ RU UDWKHUWKDWWKHSURFHVVWRRNSODFHHYHU\ZKHUHDQGWKHQZDVUHYHUVHGLQ FHUWDLQ SKRQHWLF FRQWH[WV ,Q WKH SUHVHQW JUDPPDU , SUHIHU WKH ODWWHU VROXWLRQ EXW DOWHUQDWLYH RSWLRQV VKRXOG EH WDNHQ LQWR FRQVLGHUDWLRQ DV ZHOO
(3$ H\LHOGHG H ~ LH LQ/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQ ELH ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ EHUMD ,( EKHU ‘WR EULQJ WR FDUU\’ 6NW EK¢UDWL*NHGTY/DWIHUA GMH‘\HVWHUGD\’ (3$ GH 6NWK\¢VLG*NZSGXLG/DWKHULLG GKMHV ‘WR GHIHFDWH’ (3$ G]HWhD ,( ½KHG LG 6NW KDGDWL *N ZG\Y PMHN¬U ‘FKLQ EHDUG’ (3$ VPHNU ,( VPHUX LG +LWW ]DPDQNXU ‘EHDUG’ 6NW yP¢yUX LG $UP PDZURZ LG /LWK VP¦NUDV‘FKLQ’ VMHOO ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ WhHOD ,( NÆHO 6NW F¢UDWL ‘WR PRYH WR ZDON’*NRGNY‘WRFRPHLQWRH[LVWHQFHWREHFRPH’/DWFROA ‘WRFXOWLYDWHWRWLOO’
4
chapter one
YMHUU‘WRKDQJ’ (3$ ZHUD ,( V ÆHU *NC GKTY ‘WRUDLVHXS’ /LWKYHUL¸Y©UWL‘WRZHLJK’VYHUL¸VYH¼WL‘WRRSHQWRWKUHDG’ YMHW‘\HDU’ (3$ ZHWD ,( ÆHWLG +LWWÆLWW*NGVQX ,WLVXQNQRZQXQGHUZKDWFRQGLWLRQVWKHUHVXOWLQJGLSKWKRQJVDSSHDUDV LHRUMH1RFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWLRQFDQEHHVWDEOLVKHGLQVRIDUDVZH KDYHGLHOO‘VXQ’ YV GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ SMHOO ‘WR EHJHW WR SURGXFH WR EHDU’ DQGELHYVGMH‘\HVWHUGD\’DQGEMHUU‘WRORVH’4XLWHSUREDEO\WKLVGLI IHUHQWLDWLRQ JRHV EDFN WR UHODWLYHO\ UHFHQW GLDOHFWDO YDULDWLRQV ODWHU XQLILHGDQGOH[LFDOL]HGLQPRGHUQ$OEDQLDQ
,QQXPHURXVZRUGVWKHQHZGLSKWKRQJ H\LHOGHGMDLQVWHDGRI
MH ,Q D IHZ FDVHV LW FDQ EH GHPRQVWUDWHG WKDW WKLV FKDQJH WRRN SODFH EHIRUH LRIWKHQH[WV\OODEOHDVVKRZQE\WKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV GMDWK¬‘FKHHVH’ (3$ GHGL 6NWG¢GKL‘VRXUPLON’ EXWFI23UXV GDGDQ‘PLON’ MDP‘,DP’ (3$ HVPL ,( HVPLLG 6NW¢VPL*NGK OK PMDOW¬‘KRQH\’ (3$ PHOLWD ,( PHOLWLG +LWWPLOLW*NOGNK *RWKPLOLÈLG $OEDQLDQMDLVVLPSOLILHGWRDDIWHUJM JMDOS¬‘EXWWHU’ (3$ VHOSL 6NWVDUSV‘FODULILHGEXWWHU’ EXWFI *N GNRQX GNCKQP UVGCT GW SJPKC +HV 2+* VDOED ‘RLQWPHQW’ JMDVKW¬ ‘VL[’ (3$ VHNVWL GHULYDWLRQDOO\ FORVH WR 6NW ¿D¿WL ‘VL[ WHQV’
/3$ H ~ D ORVW LWV ILUVW HOHPHQW EHIRUH G] WV QG QW
PE7KLVUXOHLVFRUURERUDWHGE\WKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EUHGK ‘WR MXPS WR VSULQJ’ EUHG]D (3$ EUHGD 6ODY EUHG_
EUHVWL‘WRZDGHWRIRUG’/LWKEUHQG¸EU®VWLLG EUHQGD‘LQVLGH’ (3$ HQ SHUHQWD ,QGR(XURSHDQVHTXHQFHRI HQFO\WLFV HQSHUHQWRG çDQG¬U‘SURSVXSSRUW’ (3$ hWhHQWUD ,( HQWURP *NMGPVTQP ‘JRDGVSXU’ GHQG ‘WR VWXII’ (3$ HQ WHQGD ,( WHQG 6NW WDQGDWH ‘WR ZHDNHQ’/DWWHQGA‘WRVWUHWFK’
phonology
5
GUHGK‘WRWXUQWRURWDWH’ (3$ GUHG]D ,( GUH½K $UPGDàQDP ‘WRWXUQ’ GKHPE ‘WR DFKH’ (3$ G]HPED ,( ½HPEK 6NW M¢PEKDWH ‘WR VQDS DW’ /LWK ÊHPEL¸ ÊHÄEWL ‘WR FXW’ 6ODY ]?E_ ]?EWL ‘WR IUHH]HWRIHHOFROG’ OHQG‘DFRUQ’ (3$ OHQWD ,( OHQW‘OLQVH’ /DWOQVOQWLV2+* OLQVL6ODY O?WMD PEOHGK ‘WR JDWKHU WR FROOHFW’ (3$ DPELOHG]D ,( OH½ *N NGIYLG/DWOHJA‘WRUHDG WRJDWKHU’ WUHPE‘WRIULJKWHQ’ /3$ WUHPED (3$ WUHPD ,( WUHP 7RFK $ W¥UP ‘WR JHW DQJU\’ *N VTGOY ‘WR WUHPEOH RI IHDU ’ /DW WUHPALG 7KLVPDWHULDOLVRSSRVHGWRIRUPVZLWK3URWR$OEDQLDQFOXVWHUVXVXDOO\ EHJLQQLQJ ZLWK OLTXLGV— OQ UG UJ UG] UN UP UQ UHWDLQLQJ /3$ H~ D GMHUU‘WRGHVWUR\’ (3$ GHUQD ,( GHU 6NWGodWL‘WREXUVWWR WHDU’*NFGTY‘WRVNLQ’*RWKJDWDLUDQ‘WRWHDU’ MHUP ‘GHOLULXP DEVHQWPLQGHGQHVV’ (3$ HUPD /LWK H¼PDV ‘PRQVWHU’/DWY?UPV‘ZRQGHUIXODSSDULWLRQ’ SMHOO‘WREHJHWWRSURGXFHWREHDU’ (3$ SHOQDWR/DWSHOOA‘WR GULYHWRSXVK’ SMHUGK ‘WR IDUW’ (3$ SHUGD ,( SHUG LG 6NW S¢UGDWH *N RGTFQOCK2+*IHU]DQ/LWKS©UGÊLXS©UVWL WMHUU‘WRVSLQ’ (3$ WHUND ,( WHUNÆ‘WRWXUQ’ 7RFK%W¥UN/DW WRUTXHA ]YMHUGK ‘WR ZHDQ’ (3$ YHUG]D /LWK YHUÊL¸ YH¼ÊWL ‘WR ODFH WR WLH’/DWYYU]W‘WRWXUQ’6ODY YHU]WL‘WRELQG’ MDUJ¬‘VSLWSKOHJP’ (3$ HUJ $YiUi]DQW‘EDG’2+*DUJ‘EDG HYLO’/LWKDUʸV‘OXVW\’ /3$ H~ DLVDOVRSUHVHUYHGEHIRUHWKHFOXVWHUVZKLFKWHQGWREHJLQ ZLWKYHODUV GMDWKW¬ ‘ULJKW’ (3$ GHWVD ,( GHV LG 6NW G¢N¿LoD *N FGEKQX/DWGH[WHU MDVKW¬‘RXWVLGH’ (3$ H N hWLWR,( H½KV‘RXW’ *NGE/DWH[
6
chapter one
PMHN¬U ‘FKLQ EHDUG’ (3$ VPHNU ,( VPHUX LG +LWW ]DPDQNXU ‘EHDUG’ 6NW yP¢yUX LG $UP PDZURZ LG /LWK VP¦NUDV‘FKLQ’
$WDODWHUVWDJHWKHILUVWHOHPHQWRIWKHGLSKWKRQJZDVORVWDIWHU
DIIULFDWHVFçSDODWDOVJMTDQGOLTXLGVOU EXWDIWHUWKHODWWHURQO\LILW LV WKH VHFRQG HOHPHQW RI D FOXVWHU 7KLV FDQ EH REVHUYHG LQ WKH IRO ORZLQJH[DPSOHV VRPHRIWKHPKDYHDOUHDG\EHHQDGGXFHGLQ FHUP¬‘FROGFRRO’ çDM‘WRVSOLWWRFOHDYH’çDO¬‘ODPH’çDQG¬U‘SURSVXSSRUW’çDS‘WR FKHZ’çDUV‘WRGHVWUR\WRVSRLO’çHO‘WRRSHQ’çHP‘WREULQJWR OLJKWWRGLVFORVH’ JMDOS¬ ‘EXWWHU’ JMDUS¬U ‘VQDNH’ JMDVKW¬ ‘VL[’ JMHWK ‘IROLDJH JUHHQ OHDYHV’ TDV ‘WR DSSURDFK’ THOO ‘WR KDOW WR KROG XS WR FDUU\’ THS ‘WR VHZ WRJHWKHU WRVHL]H’VKTDUU‘PDUWHQ’VKTHUU‘WRWHDU FORWK ’ IOH‘WRVOHHS’IOHW¬‘ZLQJOHDI’OHQG‘DFRUQ’PEOHGK‘WRJDWKHUWR FROOHFW’ EUHGK ‘ILUWUHH’ EUHGK ‘MXPS VSULQJ’ EUHQGD ‘LQVLGH’ GUHGK ‘WR WXUQWRURWDWH’NUHK‘WRFRPE’VKWUHN‘FRUSVHFDUULRQ’WUHPED ‘WRIULJKWHQ’ 7KHUHLVRQHH[FHSWLRQWRWKLVGLVWULEXWLRQ çMHUU‘WRWHDUXS’
,QDIHZFDVHV/3$ H~ DORVHVLWVILUVWHOHPHQWGHVSLWHWKH
UXOHV GHVFULEHG LQ 7KXV LQ WKDUN ‘HQFORVXUH HVSHFLDOO\ IRU PLONLQJ ’ZHILQGDWKDWFDQEHRQO\H[SODLQHGIURPHDUOLHU DLIWKDUN LVWREHGHULYHGIURPWKXUDVVXJJHVWHGLQ$('VY7KHUHIRUHLWFRXOG EH QHFHVVDU\ WR UHYLVH WKLV HW\PRORJ\ DQG WR UHWXUQ WR DQRWKHU LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ 0(<(5 $OE6W,,, IURP,( ÆRUNRV 7KHIRUPHVK ‘KHGJHKRJ’LVHYHQPRUHGLIILFXOWLQYLHZRIZLGHO\DWWHVWHGLQLWLDO HLQ ,QGR(XURSHDQFI*NG ZK`PQXLG2+*LJLOLG/LWKHÊmVLG6ODY HÊÚ LG 7KH VDPH LV WUXH RI PH ‘ZLWK’ (3$ PH W HW\PRORJLFDOO\ FRQQHFWHG ZLWK *RWK PLÈ LG *N OGVC ‘LQ WKH PLGGOH EHWZHHQ’ (YHQ PRUH FRPSOLFDWHG LV WKH FDVH RI IHUU¬ ‘WKRUQ WKRUQ\ EXVK’ ZKLFK LV FRPSDUHGZLWKIRUPVGLVSOD\LQJDOHVVFOHDUURRWYRZHOFI21VSM_UDV RSSRVHGWR/DWVSDUXV‘VKRUWVSHDU’
phonology
7
,Q D IHZ ZRUGV L VHHPV WR UHIOHFW RULJLQDO H ! H ,Q YLW ‘\HDU’LEHORQJHGRULJLQDOO\WRWKHIRUPRISOXUDO7KHSDUDGLJPRIWKLV QRXQ GLVSOD\HG DQ DOWHUQDWLRQ RI VJ H ~ SO L DQG ZDV ODWHU UHVWUXF WXUHG XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI SDUDGLJPDWLF DQDORJLHV 7KXV VJ YLW LV D VHFRQGDU\ IRUPDWLRQ UHSODFLQJ ROGHU YMHW (W\PRORJLFDOO\ UHODWHG YLç KDV LWV L RI WKH VDPH RULJLQ ,Q ]L ‘EODFN’ WKH YRZHO UHVXOWV IURP WKH FRQWUDFWLRQRIHDUOLHU ]¬L (3$ GÊHGD ÞHGLRV$VWRWKHLLQLWK ‘EHKLQG’ LWV YRZHO PDNHV LW IDLUO\ FORVH WR 6ODYLF MÚ] DQG %DOWLF 23UXVLV/LWK®h(/DWYL] $WWKHVDPHWLPHDUDWKHULQIUHTXHQWFKDQJHRI HWRLLVDWWHVWHG7KLV SURFHVVWRRNSODFHEHIRUH PIROORZHGE\DVLELODQWRUDQDIIULFDWH,WV HDUO\ GDWH LV FRUURERUDWHG E\ WKH IDFW WKDW WKH VLELODQW IROORZLQJ HPHUJLQJ LZDVVXEMHFWWRWKH“UXNL”UXOH7KHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHVFDQ LOOXVWUDWHWKLVSKRQHWLFGHYHORSPHQW JMLWK¬JMLGK¬‘DOO’ (3$ VHPG]D ,( VHP½KR‘RQH’ $UPH]
VHP½KR PLVK ‘IOHVK PHDW’ (3$ PHPVD ,( PHPVR LG 6NW P$VD ‘IOHVKPHDW’$UPPLV*RWKPLP]6ODY P?VR )RUWKHHDUO\FKURQRORJ\RIWKHDERYHVKLIWLWLVLPSRUWDQWWRWDNHLQWR DFFRXQW D GLIIHUHQW FKDQJH LQ /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV ZLWK D VLPLODU FOXVWHU ZKHUHKRZHYHUWKHVRXUFHYRZHOZDVORQJ SHVK¬‘ZHLJKW VWRQHERXOGHU’Õ/DWSHQVXPLG
6KRUW,( L\LHOGV(3$ L!$OELDVVKRZQE\VHYHUDODWWHVWHG H[DPSOHV
ELQG‘WRFRQYLQFHWRSHUVXDGH’ (3$ ELQGDDQDVDOSUHVHQWEDVHG RQ,( EKHLGK‘WRSHUVXDGHWRIRUFH’ GKL‘VKHJRDW’ (3$ DLG]LM *NCKELG$UPD\FLG JML‘EUHDVWFKHVW’ (3$ VLQD /DWVLQXV‘FXUYHIROG’ KL‘DVK’ (3$ VNLQD /DWFLQLV‘GXVW’ ]L‘EODFN’ VHH PEL‘RQXSRQ’ (3$ DPEL ,( DPEKL *NC OHK‘DERXWDURXQG’ *RWKEL2,ULPP &HOW EL
8
chapter one
6KRUW ,( X UHPDLQHG XQFKDQJHG LQ (3$ X ! $OE X DV FRURERUDWHGE\WKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV
EXW¬’VRIWVPRRWK’ (3$ EXJWD ,( EKXJK 1,UERJ‘VRIW’$UP ERZ‘EOXQW’ EX]¬ ‘OLS HQG HGJH EDQN VWLWFK URFN’ (3$ EXGM /LWK EXG| ‘WUHHIXQJXVWLQGHUZKHWVWRQH’ GUX‘WUHH ZRRG’ (3$ GUXZD ,( GUXLG 6ODY GUÙYR‘ZRRG’ 6NWGUXLG$YGUXLG*NFTW`X‘WUHHRDN’ JMXP¬‘VOHHS’ (3$ VXSQ ,( VXSQR *NWRPQX‘VOHHS’6ODY
VÙQÙLG KX ~ KXl ‘SLFNHW VWDNH SROH SHQLV’ (3$ VNXQD 6ODY [XMÚ ‘SHQLV’ VNRXRV VXW¬‘IHPDOHGHHUGRH’ (3$ WhXNW‘KRUQHGDQLPDO’ ,( XN /LWKh¸NRV‘FRPE’h¸N^‘FURFN’hXNHWDV‘GHQWHGFKLSSHG’
/RQJYRZHOV 7KH KLVWRU\ RI ORQJ YRFDOLVP LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LQFOXGHV WKH PHUJHU RI ,( DQG DV ZHOO DV WKH GLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQ DQG SDODWDOL ]DWLRQRIURXQGHGYRZHOVDWDODWHUVWDJH /LWHUDWXUH 3('(56(1 .= ;;;9, GLVWULEXWLRQ RI \L :(,*$1' *U /2:0$11 /DQJXDJH 9,,, WHUWLDU\ RSSRVLWLRQ LQ OHQJWK LQ *HJ 0 $11 /DQJXDJH ;;9, +LVW *U 32/Á. 6&/;, FRPELQDWRULDOPHFKDQLVPVRI*HJ OHQJWKHQLQJ Ç$%(- %86K7 ;,,, FKURQRORJ\ RI ! º 6W) 9,, *HJ OHQJWKV DV FRQWLQXDQWV RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ ORQJ YRZHOV 3UREO KLVW 6W ,,, '2', &,(% *HJOHQJWKV
,( ZDV SUHVHUYHG LQ (3$ /DWHU LW ZDV ODELDOL]HG DQG FKDQJHGWR/3$ Di DQGWKHQWR$OER IWRK ~ IWRI ‘WR FRRO WR PDNH FROG’ (3$ DZDWMD ,( W ‘WR PHOW’ 6ODY WDM_ WDMDWL2VVHWWDM\QLG NROO¬ ‘FRXJK’ (3$ NVO ,( NÆVO LG 6ODY NDhOÚ /LWK NRVXOmV PRW¬U‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU‘PRWKHU’ 6NWPW¢U*N OJVJT/DWPWHU SORMH‘VODXJKWHUFDUQDJH’ SORH (3$ SOJ *NRNJIJ‘EORZ’ /DWSOJD‘EORZVODXJKWHU’
phonology
9
VKNRS‘VWLFNFDQH’ (3$ VNSD *NUMC`RQX MNCFQX/DWVFSXV ‘VKDIWVWHP’2+*VNDIW‘VKDIWVSHDU’ VKWRM‘WRLQFUHDVH’ (3$ VWQMD ,( VW 6NWWL¿bKDWL‘WRVWDQG’ *NKUVJOK‘WRSXW’/DWVWA‘WRVWDQG’2+*VWQLG/LWKVW²MX VW²WLLG6ODY VWRM_ VWRMDWLLG
$V LV FOHDU IURP WKH DWWHVWHG GHYHORSPHQW RI ,( LQ WKH
SRVLWLRQ EHIRUH FOXVWHUV LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ VWLOO GLIIHUHQWLDWHG EHWZHHQ ,( DQG ,( 7KXV ZH KDYH WR UHFRQVWUXFW (3$ +RZHYHUDWODWHUVWDJHVLWFKDQJHGWR/3$ å DQGPHUJHGZLWK,( ! (3$ $V GLVFXVVHG DERYH WKH ODWWHU GHYHORSHG LQWR /3$ å DQG HYHQWXDOO\WR$OER7KHHYROXWLRQRI,( WRRFDQEHFRUURERUDWHG by numerous examples: ERM ‘WR GULYH WR PDWH’ (3$ EJQMD ,( EKHÞ ZLWK D OHQJWKHQLQJVLPLODUWR/LWKE{JWL‘WRUXQ’/DWYEêJWLG ORGK‘WRWLUHWRZHDU\’ (3$ OGD ,( OG *RWKOHWDQ‘WROHW’ *NNJFGK`P MQRKC`PMGMOJMGPCK PRV ‘QRW’ SURKLELWLYH (3$ PWh ,( P NÆH ‘DQG QRW’ *N OJVG QJURK‘WRZDUP’ (3$ HQJUMD 6ODY JUpM_ JUpWLLG SORW¬ ‘IXOO’ (3$ SOWD ,( SOWR ‘IXOO’ 6NW SUW¢ /DW FRP SOWXV WKRP ‘WR VD\’ (3$ WVQVPL ,( HQV 23HUV SWL\ ‘WR VD\ WR VSHDN’/DWFQVHA‘WRDVVHVVWRYDOXH’
,( AZDVSUHVHUYHGDVVXFKLQ/3$ A$WDODWHUVWDJHLQWKH
HQG RI WKH /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SHULRG LW ZDV GLSKWKRQJL]HG DQG UHVXOWHG LQ /3$ ÆH 7KLV SURFHVV ZDV VWUXFWXUDOO\ SDUDOOHO WR EXW QRW VLPXOWDQHRXVZLWKWKHGLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQRI WKDW PXVW KDYH KDSSHQHG ODWHULIZHFDQUHO\RQWKHGDWDRI/DWLQORDQZRUGV VHH 7KHQ /3$ ÆHWXUQHGLQWR ö DQGILQDOO\LQWR$OEH EOHUW¬ ‘JUHHQ’ (3$ EOAUD ,( EKOAURV /DW IOAUXV ‘VKLQLQJ EULJKW’2,UEO¢U‘JUD\’:EODZULG KHOO‘VSHDUVSLW’ (3$ VNAOD *NUMY`NQX‘SRLQWHGVWDNHWKRUQ’ NUHGK ‘WR SOXQJH WR LPPHUVH WR VWHHS WR VPRWKHU WR EHVSDWWHU’ (3$ NUAGD 6ODY NUDG_ NUDVWL ‘WR VWHDO’ UHIO NUDG_ V?
NUDVWLV?‘WRVQHDNWRVWHDOXSWRDSSURDFKXQQRWLFHG’
10
chapter one
QJMHVK ‘WR JLUG’ (3$ HQMhD ,( AV $Y \vKDLLHLWL LG *N \YPPWOKLG/LWKM·RVWLLG6ODY MDVDWL‘WRWHDUFORWKHV’ PHKHP ‘WR IDLO’ (3$ PAMD 2+* PXRDQ ‘WR ZRUN GLOLJHQWO\’ 6ODY PDMDWL‘WRZRUNVORZO\’ WHW¬‘HLJKW’ (3$ DNWA WL ,( RWA X ‘HLJKW’ 6NWD¿bd$UPRZ *NQ MVY WUHV ‘WR PHOW WR ORRVHQ WR GLVVROYH’ (3$ WUAWMD 6ODY WUDWM_
WUDWLWL‘WRVSHQGWRZDVWH’ ,QWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHZRUG/3$ ÆHZDVSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEYHDVLQ WKHZRUGIRU‘HDU’ZKHUHDGLSKWKRQJZLWKDORQJILUVWHOHPHQWLVWUHDWHG OLNHDFRUUHVSRQGLQJORQJYRZHO VHH YHVK¬ /3$ ÆHVD (3$ AXVDFORVHWR*NY?XLG
,( GLG QRW FKDQJH LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DQG ZDV ODWHU SUHVHUYHGDV/3$ LDQG$OEL
GL ‘WR NQRZ’ (3$ GMD ]HURJUDGH RI ,( GKHLi ‘WR VHH’ 6NW GK\WL GK\\DWL ‘WR REVHUYH WR IHHO WR WKLQN’ $Y G \ ‘WR VHH’ GLN¬‘GHVLUHOXVW’ (3$ GNVXEVWDQWLYL]HG DGMHFWLYH UHODWHG WR /LWKGmNDV‘LGOHHPSW\’6ODY GLNÙ‘ZLOG’ GLW¬ ‘GD\’ (3$ GW *PF WGL] ‘WLPH’ 2+* ]W 2( WG DQG 6NWGWL‘EULJKWQHVVVSOHQGRU’ KLMH KH ‘VKDGRZ’ (3$ NVLM ,( VL ~ V LG 6NW FK\d *NUMKC KLUU¬‘ZKH\’ (3$ NVLU 6NWN¿U¢‘PLON’2VVHWæ[hLULG SL‘WRGULQNWRVXFN’ (3$ SMD ,( SA L ~ S‘WRGULQN’ 6NW SdWL‘WRGULQN’*NRKPY/DWELEA
,( ZDVSUHVHUYHGDV(3$ EXWODWHUGLSKWKRQJL]HGWR/3$
ÆLVLPLODUWR/3$ ÆH A7KLVGHYHORSPHQWLVSURYHGLQGLUHFWO\E\ WKHVLPLODUHYROXWLRQRIJURXSVLQFOXGLQJ ÆLDQGDOVRGLUHFWO\E\2OG $OEDQLDQVSHOOLQJXL(YHQWXDOO\ ÆLFKDQJHGWR7RVN\~ *HJ\>ü@RU PRUHRIWHQ*HJL&IVHYHUDOH[DPSOHVEHORZ IU\M‘WREORZ’ (3$ VSU JQMD /LWK VSU JVWX VSU JWL‘WR HVFDSH WRJHWRXW’6ODY SU\JDWL‘WRMXPSWRVSULQJ’ JM\VK‘JUDQGIDWKHU’ (3$ V VD 6NWV ¿d‘SURJHQLWRU’
phonology
11
QJU\GK‘WRZRUNXSWRIRPHQWWRIHUPHQW’ (3$ HQNU GD /LWK JUgÊLXJUgVWL‘WRVWDPSWRSXQFK’/DWYJUûVWLG U\V ‘WR SUDFWLVH WR H[HUFLVH’ (3$ U WMD ,( UHÆi U /DW UXA‘WRUXVKGRZQWRIDOOGRZQ’6ODY U\WL‘WRGLJ’/LWKU¢XWL ‘WRWHDUWRSXOO’ WU\V‘WRSUHVVWRFRPSUHVVWRVTXHH]H’ (3$ WU WMD ,( WUHX~
WU *N VTWY ‘WR ZHDU RXW WR H[KDXVW’ /LWK WU QL¸ WU Q{WL ‘WRURWWRJRIRXO’
,QDXVODXW VRPHWLPHV IRUPHG E\ WKH HDUO\ ORVV RI ILQDO V LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKH ILUVW HOHPHQW RI WKH GLSKWKRQJ GLVDSSHDUHG DQG /3$ ÆL\LHOGHG$OEL PL ‘PRXVH’ (3$ P V ,( P V LG 6NW Pg¿ *N OW`X /DW P V WL‘WKRX’ (3$ W FRQWLQXLQJ,( W LG $YW *NUW/DWW 2,U W· WKL‘SLJ’ (3$ WV V ZLWKGLVVLPLODWLRQRIVLELODQWV ,( V VLG *NW=X/DWV V2+*V 7KHJOLGHRI/3$ ÆLZDVDOVRORVWDIWHUDODELDO ELP¬‘SODQW’ (3$ E P ,( EK PR *NHW`OCLG ELVKW‘WDLO’ (3$ E hWDGHULYDWLYHRI,( EK ‘WRJURZ’ PELM ‘WR WKULYH WR JURZ WR VKRRW’ (3$ HQE QMD ,( EK ‘WR JURZ’ PL]¬‘IO\’EDVHGRQ(3$ P M 21P\LG*NOWK`CLG/DWPXVFD LG RUEHIRUHLW NULS¬ ‘VDOW’ (3$ NU S ,( NUHXS 21 KUXID ‘VFDE’ /LWK NUDXS¸V ‘URXJK’ NUDXSLV ‘VFDE’ /DWY NUD-SLV ‘IUDLO EULWWOH’ 6ODY NUXSD‘JURDWV’ TLSL ‘VWDFN’ GHULYHG IURP (3$ N SD 23HUV NDXID ‘PRXQWDLQ’ 2+*KXIR‘KHDS’2(K©DSLG 7KHFDVHRIPL]¬KRZHYHUFDQDOVRLOOXVWUDWHDQRWKHUSKRQHWLFFRQWH[W LQZKLFK/3$ ÆLFKDQJHGWRL7KLVGHYHORSPHQWWRRNSODFHEHIRUH M DQG LDVLQWKHIROORZLQJZRUGV
12
chapter one
GULQM¬‘EUXVKZRRG’ (3$ GU QMGHULYDWLYHRI,( GUHX‘WUHH’ SOLVK ‘NLQG RI UHHG 3KUDJPLWHV FRPPXQLV’ (3$ SO hL /LWK SO L h®V‘UHHG’ VKL ‘UDLQ’ (3$ V MD ZLWK GLVVLPLODWLRQ ,( V LG *N WGK 7RFK$VZDVH7RFK%VZHVH‘UDLQ’V ‘WRUDLQ’23UXVVXJH ‘UDLQ’ >V M@
'LSKWKRQJV 7KH V\VWHP RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ GLSKWKRQJV ZDV IXOO\ SUHVHUYHG LQ(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQEXWODWHUZDVWRWDOO\UHRUJDQL]HGDQGHYHQWXDOO\ GHVWUR\HG DW WKH /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ VWDJH 'LSKWKRQJV LQ FKDQJHG WRIURQWPRQRSKWKRQJVZKLOHDOOGLSKWKRQJV ÆORVWWKHLUJOLGH /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 $OE 6W ,,, 3(.0(=, (3$ DX ! H 0(<(5%58*0$11,)/ ,( HX!H 0$11/DQJXDJH;;9, +LVW *U $17.2:6., 3,6$1, 6DJJL (3$
DL!D Ç$%(- 6W)9,, VDPHDV3,6$1, 6W,,, +$03 (WLPRORJLMD ORVV RI WKH VHFRQG HOHPHQW LQ ORQJ GLSKWKRQJV *(25*,(97UDNLWH 'DFLDQ$OEDQLDQSDUDOOHOLVP LQWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI DX!D UHIOH[HVRI(3$ DLGHSHQGLQJRQ WKHSRVLWLRQRIVWUHVV
7KHUDUH,QGR(XURSHDQGLSKWKRQJ DLZDVSUHVHUYHGLQ(DUO\
3URWR$OEDQLDQ EXW ODWHU \LHOGHG $OE H DV VKRZQ E\ WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV HGK‘KHJRDW’ (3$ DLG]D *NCKE‘JRDW’$UPD\FLG HWKH‘IHYHU’EDVHGRQ(3$ DLGD ,( DLGKRV 6NWHGKDV‘ILUHZRRG IXHO’*NCK?SQX‘ILUH’
,( RLFRLQFLGHGLQ(3$ DLZLWK,( DL,WUHVXOWVLQ$OEH EH ‘RDWK’ (3$ EDLG 6ODY EpGD ‘GLVDVWHU’ /DW IRHGXV ‘OHDJXH WUHDW\’ OHGK‘PXGDOOXYLXPFOD\ ZDOOHDUWKPRXQG ULYHUPRXWKEDON’ (3$ ODLGD 23UXVOD\GLV‘FOD\’ OHVK ‘ZRRO IOHHFH KDLU’ (3$ ODLhD WKH %DOWR6ODYLF ZRUG IRU ‘IROLDJH’ /LWK OD&hNDV ‘OHDI’ /DWY OD&VND ‘OHDI RQ D OLQHQ VWDON VWDON’6ODY OLVWÙ‘OHDI’
phonology
13
THW¬ ‘ MDJJHG URFN’ (3$ NODLW ,( ORLWRV : FOXG ‘KHDS’ /LWKhOD&WDV‘VORSH’ VKWHJ‘SDWKURDG’ (3$ VWDLJD ,( VWRLJKR‘ZD\’ *NUVQK ZQX ‘URZOLQH’*RWKVWDLJD‘ZD\’/DWYVWD&JD‘ZDONLQJ’ YHU¬ ‘ZLQH’ (3$ ZDLQ FRJQDWH ZLWK *N QKPJ ‘YLQH’ QK?PQX ‘ZLQH’/DWYQXP‘ZLQH’$UPJLQLLG
,( HL\LHOGHG(3$ HLWKDWFKDQJHGWR/3$ L!$OEL FLW¬ ‘IXOO EULPIXOO’ (3$ WVHLWD ,( NÆHiWRV 6ODY ¨LWÙ ‘ZKROH’/LWNHWDV‘KDUG’ GLP¬U ‘ZLQWHU’ (3$ GHLPHQD ,( ½KHLPHQ LG 6NW K©PDQ HQGLQJOHVVORF‘LQZLQWHU’*NZGK`OC‘ZLQWHU’ KLPH ‘EUDQ’ (3$ VNHLGPD ,( VNHLGPHQ /LWK VNLHPX¶ ‘RSHQLQJXVHGWRLQVHUWWKHVKXWWOH’ LN¬M‘WRJRDZD\WRUXQDZD\’ (3$ HLNDFORVH WR /LWK H&N H&NL ‘JR’ ZLWK WKH LPSHUDWLYH VXIIL[ RI %DOWR6ODYLF UDWKHU WKDQ )LQQR8JULFRULJLQ OLO¬‘VPDOOLURQULQJORRSULQJOLQN’ (3$ OHLO /LWKOH&ODV‘WKLQ VXSSOHIOH[LEOH’
$V IDU DV ZH FDQ MXGJH ORQJ GLSKWKRQJV LQ ORVW WKHLU ODVW
HOHPHQW DQG ZHUH WUHDWHG DV XVXDO ORQJ YRZHOV 7KHUH LV RQO\ RQH UHOLDEOHH[DPSOH UURM ‘WR OLYH WR VWD\’ (3$ UQMD ,( UL /LWK U²MX U²WL ‘WR FRSHWREHUHDG\’UHWL‘WRVWDFN ZRRG ’
5DUH,( DXZDVSUHVHUYHGDV(3$ DXEXWWKHGLSKWKRQJORVW
LWV JOLGH DQG WXUQHG LQWR /3$ D ! $OE D RU H XQGHU FHUWDLQ SKRQHWLF FRQGLWLRQV &IWKHIROORZLQJFDVHV DJ‘WZLOLJKWGXVN’ (3$ DXJD ,( DXJ *NCW IJ‘UD\RIOLJKW’ WKDM ‘WR GU\’ (3$ VDXVQMD ,( VDXVR ‘GU\’ *N CW=QX 0+* VôU/LWKVD-VDV6ODY VX[Ù HUU‘GDUNQHVV’ (3$ DXVUD /LWKDXhU£‘GDZQ’*NGYXLG OHU¬‘GLUWPXG’ (3$ ODXU /LWKOD-U^‘GLUW\SHUVRQ’ PEDWK‘WRSXWRQ VKRHV ’ (3$ DPE L DXWVD ,( DX +HX+ LG $UP DJDQLP ‘WR SXW RQ FORWKHV ’ /LWK DXQ¸ DWL 6ODY
XWL
14
chapter one
,( RX PHUJHG ZLWK DX LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,WV IXUWKHU
GHYHORSPHQWZDVWKHVDPHDVLQ
GDVK ‘UDP’ (3$ GDXhD ,( GKRXVR ~ GKHXVR *RWK GLXV ‘ZLOG DQLPDO’ /LWK SO GD-VRV ‘SDUDGLVH’ 6ODY GX[Ù ‘EUHDWK VSLULW’ JHU‘VTXLUUHO’ ‘IXUU\’ (3$ JDXUD /LWKJD-UDV‘KDLUGRZQWXIW RIKDLU’/DWYJDXUL‘SXELFKDLU’0,UJ·DLUH‘KDLU’ ODVKW¬ ‘ROG HDUO\ SUHPDWXUH RI IUXLW ’ (3$ ODXhD *RWK ODXV ‘HPSW\ORRVH’ SDK‘VFDEGXVW’ (3$ SDXMD ,( SRXR $UPKRJL‘EUHDWK’ VKWUHS ‘PDJJRW ODUYD’ (3$ VWUDXSD FORVH WR 6ODY VWUXSÙ ‘ZRXQGVFDESRLVRQ’
,( HX ZDV SUHVHUYHG DV (3$ HX 7KHQ LW ORVW LWV VHFRQG HOHPHQW WRR DQG LV QRZ UHIOHFWHG DV $OE H 7KLV GHYHORSPHQW LV FRUURERUDWHGE\VHYHUDOUHOLDEOHHW\PRORJLHV EUH]‘EHOW’ EUHXQD ZLWKDODWHVXIIL[ /LWKEULDXQ£‘HGJH’ GHU¬ ‘ELWWHU GLIILFXOW’ 7RVN RQO\ (3$ GHXQD 26 WLRQR ‘HYLO’ 2(WHRQD‘ZURQJ’ GHUL‘WRXSWRWLOO’ (3$ GHXU H L *NFGW`TQFGW`TGFGW`TK‘KHUH’ IURP,( GHXUR KHGK‘WRWKURZWRVKRRW’ (3$ VNHXGD ,( VNHXG‘WRWKURZWR VKRRW’ 21VNM²WD2+*VFLRfDQ WUHGK‘WRFDVWUDWH’ (3$ WUHXGD ,( WUHXG /DWWU GA‘WRSXVK’ *RWKXVÈULXWDQ‘WREXUGHQ’6ODY WUXGÙ‘ODERUZRUN’
'LSKWKRQJVLQ ÆZLWKORQJILUVWHOHPHQWVWHQGHGWRORVHWKHLU
JOLGHV DQG ZHUH FRQVHTXHQWO\ WUHDWHG DV FRUUHVSRQGLQJ ORQJ PRQRSKWKRQJV ORTH‘SHQLV WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ OXND /LWKOLDXN£‘JODQG’ SHO¬‘PDUH’ (3$ SAXO *NRY`NQX‘IRDO’*RWKIXODLG
'HYHORSPHQWRIWKH(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQYRFDOLVP 7KH /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SHULRG LQFOXGLQJ WKH WXPXOWRXV DQG OHQJWK\ HSRFK RI 5RPDQL]DWLRQ ZDV FKDUDFWHUL]HG E\ QXPHURXV
phonology
15
VWUXFWXUDO FKDQJHV LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SKRQRORJ\ &HUWDLQ SRVLWLRQV LQ WKHZRUG DQODXWODVWV\OODEOH DVZHOODVFHUWDLQSKRQHWLFFRQWH[WV HJ DOO YRZHOV EHIRUH QDVDO VRQRUDQWV ZHUH VXEMHFW WR D P\ULDG RI DOWHUDWLRQV 6RPH RI WKH /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SURFHVVHV KDYH DOUHDG\ EHHQ GHVFULEHG LQ $W WKH HQG RI WKH SHULRG 3URWR$OEDQLDQ YRFDOLVPORVWLWVTXDQWLWDWLYHRSSRVLWLRQ /LWHUDWXUH 63,7=(5 ,) ;;;,; RQ XD ~ XH -2./ ,) ;/,; KLVWRU\ RI XD ~ XH 3('(56(1 %86K7 ;,9 VHFRQGDU\MDIWHUDXVODXWXD~ XH 3,6$1,6DJJL QDVDOL]DWLRQRI YRZHOV 32/Á. 2UELV ;,, VLPLODU GHYHORSPHQW RI DQ LQ 5XPDQLDQ DQG 7RVN +$03 55/ ;; 0$11 +LVW *U \H H H[SODLQHG E\ WKH ORVV RI WKH IROORZLQJ V\OODEOH RULJLQRI¬~ D Ç$%(-6W,,, 25(//%;;9,, \ 9Z9 ;;,; XD ~ XH 6ODY RYD /LQJXLVWLFD ;;,9 \ 9Z9
)ROORZLQJWKHVLPSOLILFDWLRQRIVRPHLQODXWFOXVWHUVSUHFHGLQJ YRZHOVZHUHOHQJWKHQHGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQ
GRU¬‘KDQG’ (3$ GAU ,( ½KHVULG *NZGK`T+LWWNHhhDU$UP MHUQ NUXD ~ NUXH ‘VSULQJ IRXQWDLQ’ (3$ NUAQD *N MTJPJ LG 2( KUæQ‘ZDYH’ *PF [UD]QA NU\H‘KHDG’ (3$ NUQM NUDVQM *NMTC PKQP‘VNXOOKHDG’
,Q /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DOO YRZHOV SUHFHGLQJ QDVDO VRQRUDQWV
ZHUH QDVDOL]HG ,Q WKLV SRVLWLRQ VKRUW YRZHOV D H EHIRUH LWV GLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQ L DQG X FKDQJHG WR /3$ *â, *ê, *î, *û FRUUH VSRQGLQJO\7KHVHQHZQDVDOYRZHOVZHUHFRPSOHWHO\SUHVHUYHGLQ*HJ LQWKHRUWKRJUDSK\,DPXVLQJWKH\DUHPDUNHGDVâ (derived from both *â DQG *ê , î, û RQO\ZKHQ QRW IROORZHG E\ D QDVDO FRQVRQDQW EXW ORVW WKHLUQDVDOL]DWLRQLQ7RVNZKHUHWKH\ZHUHUHSODFHGE\¬LDQGX(3$
HLQWKLVSRVLWLRQFRXOGDOVRRFFDVLRQDOO\\LHOG7RVN¬H~*HJê$WWKH VDPH WLPH WKH RULJLQDO QDVDO FRQVRQDQW ZDV ORVW LQ FHUWDLQ PRUSKRQR ORJLFDOFRQWH[WV JM¬~JMDˆ‘WKLQJ’ (3$ VDQ V ,( VRQWV‘EHLQJ’ 6NWVDQW JML~JMî‘EUHDVWFKHVW’ (3$ VLQD /DWVLQXV‘FXUYHIROG’ JMX ~ JMû ‘NQHH’ (3$ JOXQD GLVVLPLODWHG IURP J D QXQD ,( ½HQXLG +LWWJQX6NWMdQX*NIQPW/DWJHQ
16
chapter one
KX~Kû‘SLFNHWVWDNHSROHSHQLV’ (3$ VNXQDEDVHGRQ VNXMD 6ODY [XMÚ‘SHQLV’ K¬Q¬ ~ KDQ¬ ‘PRRQ’ (3$ NVDQG 6NW F¢QGDWL ‘ KH VKLQHV LV EULJKW’FDQGU¢‘VKLQLQJ PRRQ’ O¬QG¬ ~ ODQG¬ ‘ZRRG WLPEHU PDWHULDO’ (3$ OHQW ,( OHQW 2+*OLQWD‘OLQGHQ’/LWKOHQW£‘ERDUG’6ODY O_WÙ‘EDVW’ ULM ~ Uî ‘WR PDNH KXPLG’ (3$ ULQMD 6NW ULodWL ‘WR VWUHDP WR UHOHDVH’6ODY ULQ_WL‘WRIORZ’
7KLV GHYHORSPHQW ZDV VKDUHG E\ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ GLSKWKRQJVHYHQWKRXJKUHOLDEOHH[DPSOHVDUHQRWYHU\IUHTXHQW GU¬QM¬ ‘FRUQHOFKHUU\ KHDOWK\ VRXQG’ (3$ GUDXQM GHULYHG IURP,( GUHX‘WUHH’ JM¬U ‘VRXS’ ~ JMDQ¬ ‘PXGEHG DOOXYLXP’ (3$ MDXVQD 6NW QHXW \ ¿‘VRXS’/DWL VLG/LWKMgh^‘ILVKVRXS’ K¬~Kê‘QRZ’ (3$ VNDLQDLGDWLYHORFDWLYHRIDQRXQUHODWHGWR *RWKVNHLQDQ2+*VNQDQ‘WRVKLQH’ O¬~ODˆ‘WROHW’ (3$ ODLGQD /LWKO©LVWLLG/DWYODîVWLG*RWKOHWDQ LG Q¬QW¬ ~ QDQG ‘QLQH’ (3$ QHXQWL ZLWK DQDORJLFDO UHVWUXFWXULQJ RI WKH FOXVWHU LQ 7RVN ,( QHÆ LG 6NW Q¢YD /DW QRYHP *RWKQLXQ
%HIRUH D QDVDO FRQVRQDQW RU U VWUHVVHG (3$ DQG A LQFOXGLQJ ORQJ GLSKWKRQJV DQG ORQJ YRZHOV UHVXOWLQJ IURP D FRPSHQVDWRU\OHQJWKHQLQJ PHUJHGLQWR AZKLFKFKDQJHGWR/3$ ÆH 7KH ODWWHU GHYHORSHG LQWR ÆDˆ DQG HYHQWXDOO\ \LHOGHG 7RVN XD ~ 2*HJ XR*HJ XH ,Q XQVWUHVVHG SRVLWLRQV (3$ DQG A GLG QRW PHUJH DQG GHYHORSHGDVLQDOORWKHUSKRQHWLFFRQWH[WVLH\LHOGHG$OERDQGH7KH UHVXOWLVDSDUDGLJPDWLFDQGGHULYDWLRQDODOWHUQDWLRQOLNHWKDWREVHUYHGLQ GRU¬VJvs. duar ~GXHUSO,QPDQ\FDVHVDOWHUQDWLRQVRIWKLVNLQGOHG WR WKH ULVH RI QHZ DQDORJLFDO IRUPV 6LPLODU UHVXOWV GHULYHG IURP WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI GLV\OODELF JURXSV ZLWK PLGGOH Æ LQ WKH DXVODXW 7KH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHVGHPRQVWUDWHWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI(3$ DQG ALQ WKLVSRVLWLRQ GXDM ~ GXHM ‘VKHDI’ (3$ GAQMD 6NW GKQd ‘JUDLQ FHUHDOV’ GKQ\¢‘JUDLQ’/LWKG·RQD‘EUHDG’
phonology
17
SOGXDU~GXHU‘KDQGV’ (3$ GAUL ,( ½KHVULG *NZGK`T+LWW NHhhDU$UPMHàQ KXDM~KXHM‘IRUHLJQVWUDQJH’ (3$ NVAQ Z MDZLWK*NEGPQX'RU EGP®QX‘VWUDQJHUJXHVW’ NUXD ~ NUXH ‘VSULQJ IRXQWDLQ’ (3$ NUAQD *N MTJPJ LG 2( KUæQ‘ZDYH’ *PF [UD]QA PXDM ~ PXHM ‘PRQWK’ (3$ PAVQMD IURP WKH PHWDWKHVLV RI ,(
PQV‘PRRQPRQWK’ 6NWPV*NOJP/DWPQVLV2,UP TXDM~TXHM‘WRFDOOWRJLYHDQDPH’ (3$ NOAXVQMDDGHQRPLQDWLYH EDVHGRQ,( OHÆRV‘JORU\ZRUG’ 6NWyU¢YDV*NMNGQX6ODY
VORYR
,QVRPHZRUGVVWUHVVHG(3$ LQDVLPLODUSRVLWLRQEHIRUH Q DQG O \LHOGHG \H :H GR QRW KDYH D VDWLVIDFWRU\ H[SODQDWLRQ RI WKH GLIIHUHQFHV LQ WKH UHIOH[DWLRQ RI ,W PD\ EH VXVSHFWHG WKDW \H RULJLQDOO\ DSSHDUHG LQ ZRUGV ZKHUH L ZDV SUHVHQW LQ WKH IROORZLQJ V\OODEOH HVSHFLDOO\ DV LW VHHPV WR DOWHUQDWH ZLWK H DV LQ GHU¬ VJ YV G\HU SO ZKLOH XD ~ XH LV LQ DOWHUQDWLRQ ZLWK R 7KLV K\SRWKHVLV LV FRUURERUDWHG E\ ZKDW ZH REVHUYH LQ /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV +RZHYHU WKH RULJLQDO SLFWXUH KDV EHHQ FRPSOHWHO\ GLVWRUWHG E\ DQDORJLFDO WUDQVIRUPDWLRQV DQG RWKHU NLQGV RI ODWHU FKDQJHV +HUH DUH VRPH H[DPSOHVRI\H I\HOO ~ I\OO ‘IOXWH’ (3$ VSOL *N URJNCKQP ‘FDYH FDYHUQ’
‘KROORZ’ NU\H‘KHDG’ (3$ NUQM NUDVQM *NMTC PKQP‘VNXOOKHDG’ T\H ‘VXPPLW SHDN’ (3$ NOLQL ,( ORLQR ‘VODQWLQJ VNHZ’ *RWKJHQSOKODLQH‘KLOO’ WK\HM‘WREUHDN’ (3$ WV L QMD ,( L‘WRVKDUSHQ’ 6NWyLyWL ‘WRVKDUSHQ’$UPVRZU‘VKDUS NQLIH’ ,QRQHFDVHWKHRULJLQRI\HUHPDLQVWRWDOO\XQH[SODLQHG S\HV‘WRDVN’ (3$ S WD +LWWNDSSXZHD‘WRFRXQW’ SX+ /DWSXWA‘WRUHFNRQWRSRQGHU’6ODY S\WDWL‘WRDVN’
&HUWDLQJURXSV9Æ9DQG99 ZKHUH9LVDORQJPRQRSKWKRQJ
RU D GLSKWKRQJ FKDQJHG WR VLQJOH YRZHOV :H KDYH RQO\ RQH VXFK H[DPSOH RI 99 ZKLFK LQ IDFW PLJKW KDYH D FRPSOHWHO\ GLIIHUHQW
18
chapter one
H[SODQDWLRQ LQVRIDU DV LV H[SHFWHG WR IDOO EHWZHHQ WZR IURQW YRZHOV +RZHYHUZHDGGXFHLWKHUH WUH‘WKUHH’ (3$ WUHMH ,( WUHHVLG 6NWWUD\Då*NVTGK`X/DW WUV *URXSV9Æ9\LHOGHGXD~ XHLIWKHILUVWYRZHOZDVQRQIURQWDQGQRQ ODELDOZKLOHWKHVHFRQGYRZHOZDVQRQIURQW7KLVLVZHOOFRUURERUDWHG E\WKHGHYHORSPHQWRIHDUO\6ODYLFORDQZRUGVEXWZHDOVRKDYHDWOHDVW RQHJRRGH[DPSOHIURPWKH,QGR(XURSHDQOH[LFRQ JUXD ~ JUXH ‘ZRPDQ ZLIH’ (3$ JUZ *N ITCW`X ‘ROG ZRPDQ’ ,IWKHILUVWYRZHOZDVODELDODVZHOODVWKHVHFRQGRQHWKHUHVXOWZDV\ DVLQWKHZRUGIRU‘WZR’ G\‘WZR’ (3$ GXZA ,( G X ÆA X LG ,IWKHILUVWYRZHOZDVDGLSKWKRQJWKHJURXSGHYHORSHGLQWR\H O\HM ‘WR VPHDU WR RLO’ (3$ HODLZDQMD EDVHG RQ HODLZ ERUURZHGIURP*NGNCK 8 QP‘RLO’ U\HM‘WRVXIIHU’ UDÆQMD (3$ UDXGLQMD 6NWU²GLWL‘WRZHHSWR URDU’ /DW UGA ‘WR VKRXW WR FU\’ /LWK UDXG£ ‘ZHHSLQJ’ 6ODY
U\GDWL‘WRZHHS’ )LQDOO\ LI ERWK YRZHOV ZHUH SDODWDO WKH JURXS \LHOGHG \ DV LQ WKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV JU\N¬ ‘WKURDW’ (3$ JUZN ,( ÞUÆ ‘QHFN’ 6NW JUYd $Y JUY/DWYJUYD‘ULYHUPRXWK’6ODY JULYD‘PDQH’) K\M ‘WR HQWHU’ (3$ HLZQMD FORVH WR 6NW ©YD ‘VSHHG\’ /LWK DW H&YLV DW©LYD ‘QHZFRPHU VWUDQJHU’ SHUHLYLV S©UHLYD ‘WUDPS YDJUDQW’ PE\OO‘WRVKXWWRIDVWHQ’ (3$ DPELZOD 6NWYDODWL‘WRWXUQ’*N GK NGY‘WRUROOWLJKWXSWRFORVH’2,UILOOLG‘WREHQG’ PE\V ‘WR VWUDQJOH WR GURZQ WR NLOO’ (3$ DPELZWMD 6NW Y\¢WKDWH‘WRVZD\WRURFN’*RWKZLÈRQ‘WRSRXU’.
phonology
19
T\U‘WRORRN’ (3$ NHZUD *NMQGY‘WRQRWH’/DWFDYHA‘WREH DZDUH’*RWKKDXVMDQ‘WRKHDU’ \OOK\OO ‘VWDU’ (3$ VNZLODGHULYHGIURPKLMH‘VKDGRZ’
,Q PRUH WKDQ RQH HW\PRORJLFDOO\ UHOLDEOH FDVH ZH ILQG \ UHVXOWLQJ IURP /3$ ÆL L LUUHVSHFWLYH RI LWV (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ VRXUFH 7KH GHYHORSPHQW RI D QHZ JOLGH DV\VWHPDWLFDOO\ DSSHDULQJ LQ RQH RU LQ ERWK VWDQGDUG $OEDQLDQ GLDOHFWV LV REYLRXVO\ FDXVHG E\ D IROORZLQJODELDOFRQVRQDQW O\S ‘WR EHJ WR DVN WR VHHN WR QHHG’ (3$ OHLSD ,( OHLS *N NKRVQOCK ‘WR EH HDJHU IRU WR ORQJ IRU’ /LWK OLHSL¸ OLSWL ‘WR RUGHU’ NULPE ~ NU\P ‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULP ,( NÆPL LG 6NW N¤PL /LWKN®UPLV UU\S ~ UULS ‘EHOW’ (3$ ZULSD *N T CRVY ‘WR VHZ WRJHWKHU WR VWLWFK’/LWKYH¼SWL‘WRVSLQ’ 7KH VDPH GHYHORSPHQW WRRN SODFH DW WKH HQG RI 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ZRUGV QRW WR EH FRQIXVHG ZLWK WKH SRVLWLRQ EHIRUH M ZKLFK EHFDPH WKH 0RGHUQ$OEDQLDQDXVODXW D\‘KH’ (3$ DHL ,( HL 6NWD\¢P‘KH’/DWLV V\‘H\H’ (3$GXDO DWh 6NWDN¿À$YDhL/LWKDN®6ODY R¨L
,QLWLDO,( ÆRFKDQJHGWR(3$ ZDDQGWKHQWR$OEX XGK¬‘ZD\’ (3$ ZDGD ,( ÆHGK‘WREHDWWREUHDN’ XPDV‘WREDUN’IURPDQXQDWWHVWHG XP¬ (3$ ZDP 6NWY¢PLWL ‘WRYRPLW’$YYDP‘WRVSLW’*NG OGY‘WRVSLWRXW’/DWYRPHA ‘WRYRPLW’. XQD]¬‘ILQJHUULQJVPDOOLURQULQJ’EDVHG RQ XQ¬ (3$ ZDQG $UPJLQG‘ULQJ’*RWKELZLQGDQ‘WRXQZUHDWKH’ XQ¬ ‘SLHFH RI D EURNHQ SRW’ (3$ ZDQW $UP YDQGHP ‘WR GHVWUR\’2+*ZXQG‘ZRXQG’0:JZHLQWSUDHW‘ , SLHUFHG’ XU¬‘EULGJH’ (3$ ZDU *RWKZDUMDQ‘WRSUHYHQWWRGHIHQG’21 Y_U‘URZRIVWRQHV’YHU‘GDP’2VFYHUX‘GRRU’ XUL~û ‘KXQJHU’ (3$ ZDQD ,( ÆHQ‘WRZDQWWRGHVLUH’ 6NW Y¢QDWLYDQ²WLLG/DWYHQXV‘ORYH’
20
chapter one
8QVWUHVVHGYRZHOV 6WUHVV KDV SOD\HG DQ LPSRUWDQW UROH LQ WKH HYROXWLRQ RI WKH SKRQHWLFV\VWHPDQGRIWKHYRFDOLVPLQSDUWLFXODU7KHKLVWRU\RI3URWR $OEDQLDQ VWUHVV LV SUHVHQWHG LQ +HUH RQO\ LWV LQIOXHQFH RQ WKH YRFDOLVPZLOOEHRXWOLQHG /LWHUDWXUH -2./ )HVWVFKU 5R]ZDGRZVNL LQLWLDO YRZHOV LQ 2OG $OEDQLDQ Ç$%(- 3UREO KLVW DSKHUHVLV LQ 0¬VKDUL 6W ,,, FRQWUDFWLRQ 25(/ 6RY VODY UHGXFWLRQRIDXVODXWYRZHOV
7KH LQKHULWHG V\VWHP RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ DFFHQW ZDV
UHFRQILJXUHGLQ(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQWKRXJKLWVQDWXUHGLGQRWFKDQJH 7KH (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DFFHQW ZDV SDUDGLJPDWLF– LWV SDWWHUQV ZHUH OLQNHGWRPRUSKRORJLFDOFODVVHVDQGVXEFODVVHV,QVRPHSDUDGLJPVWKH VWUHVV ZDV EDU\WRQLF LQ RWKHUV – R[\WRQLF RU PRELOH :KLOH LQODXW YRZHOVLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQGHYHORSHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHUXOHVGHVFULEHGLQ WKH KLVWRU\ RI WKH YRZHOV DW WKH HQG RI WKH ZRUG ZDV PRUH FRPSOLFDWHG ,Q DXVODXW 3URWR$OEDQLDQ YRZHOV ZHUH QRW FKDQJHG LI WKH\ ZHUH VWUHVVHG :KHQ XQVWUHVVHG LQ FHUWDLQ EDU\WRQLF DQG PRELOH DFFHQWXDO SDUDGLJPV DOO YRZHOV ORVW RQH PRUD RU LQ RWKHU ZRUGV VKRUW YRZHOV ZHUHFRPSOHWHO\ORVWZKLOHORQJYRZHOVZHUHVKRUWHQHG)RUH[DPSOH (3$VJ VN¢O‘ILVKERQH’! VN¢OD (3$SO VNDOdV‘ILVKERQHV’! VNDO¢ V (3$VJ GZ¢LJ‘EUDQFK’! G©JD (3$SO GZ¢LJL‘EUDQFKHV’! G©JDL (3$VJ G¢XVDV‘UDP’! GDXh (3$SO G¢XVDL‘UDPV’! G¢XhL
,Q /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKH ZKROH DFFHQWXDO V\VWHP ZDV
UDGLFDOO\ FKDQJHG XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI /DWLQ 7KH VWUHVV LQ 3URWR $OEDQLDQ ZDV QRZ ZLWK VRPH LPSRUWDQW H[FHSWLRQV VKLIWHG DXWR PDWLFDOO\ WR WKH VHFRQG V\OODEOH RI DQ\ ZRUG ,Q QHZ SDUR[\WRQD WKH SURFHVVRIUHGXFWLRQRIWKHQHZXQVWUHVVHGYRZHOVOHGWRWKHIROORZLQJ UHVXOWVLQWKHHQGRIWKHZRUG XQVWUHVVHGD\LHOGHG¬RWKHUXQVWUHVVHG YRZHOVJDYH]HUR6WUHVVHGYRZHOVZHUHDOWHUHGDVIROORZV DZDVSUH VHUYHGDVDDLFKDQJHGWRHHZDVSUHVHUYHGDVQRQGLSKWKRQJL]HGHL
phonology
21
DSSHDUHGDV¬RULQVRPHFDVHVL7KHIRUPVDGGXFHGLQZRXOG QRZORRNDVIROORZV (3$VJ VN¢O‘ILVKERQH’! VN¢OD!KDO¬ (3$SO VNDOdV‘ILVKERQHV’! VNDO¢ V !KDOD (3$VJ GZ¢LJ‘EUDQFK’! G©JD!GHJ¬ (3$SO GZ¢LJL‘EUDQFKHV’! G©JDL!GHJ¬ (3$VJ G¢XVDV‘ram’! GDXh!GDVK (3$SO G¢XVDL‘rams’! G¢XhL!GHVK
3RVWWRQLF LQODXW YRZHOV ZHUH DOO UHGXFHG WR ¬ ZKLFK LV VWLOO SUHVHUYHG LQ WKH 2OG $OEDQLDQ WH[WV EXW FRPSOHWHO\ ORVW DIWHUZDUGV 1XPHURXV FDVHV RI WKLV UHGXFWLRQ DUH IRXQG LQ /DWLQ SURSDUR[\WRQD ERUURZHGWR$OEDQLDQ N¬US~NDQS‘KHPS’Õ5RP FDQQDSLVLG NXPW¬U‘JRGIDWKHU’Õ/DWFRPSDWHULG SULIW‘SULHVW’Õ/DWSUHVE\WHULG VKSUHWN¬ ~ VKS¬QHWN¬ ‘VSOHHQ’ Õ /DW VSOQWLFXP ‘UHODWHG WR WKH VSOHHQ’ YRVKW¬U *HJ ‘/LJXVWUXPYXOJDUH’Õ/DW²OHDVWHULG
3UHWRQLF QRQKLJK YRZHOV ZHUH DOVR UHGXFHG RU ORVW LQ VRPH FDVHV DV LQ P¬UGKLM ‘WR IUHH]H’ ½ PDUGK ‘FROG IURVW’ $JDLQ PDQ\ H[DPSOHVDUHIRXQGLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV N¬UNRM‘WRORRNIRUWRVHHN’Õ5RP FLUFUHLG N¬VKW¬U~N¬VKW¬Q‘&KULVWLDQ’Õ/DWFKULVWLQXVLG N¬VKWMHOO¬‘FDVWOHIRUW’Õ/DWFDVWHOOXPLG N¬VK\UH ‘PRXQWDLQ SDWK SDWK LQ WKH UDYLQH’ Õ /DW FODXV UD ‘ORFN EDUEROW FDVWOHIRUW’ P¬UNRVK ‘PDQ O\LQJ LQ ZLIH’V EHG DIWHU FKLOGELUWK DQG UHFHLYLQJ YLVLWRUV ORYHU’Õ5RP PULFAVXV‘KXVEDQGOLNH’ Q¬P¬URM‘WRQXPEHUWRFRXQW’Õ/DWQXPHUUHLG 3UHWRQLF R LQ /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV D SKRQHPH PLVVLQJ LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ZDVQRUPDOO\VXEVWLWXWHGZLWKXDVLQWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV NXURU¬~ NXQRU¬‘FURZQ’Õ/DWFRUAQDLG NXPHUT‘WROOGXW\’Õ/DWFRPPHUFLXP‘WUDGHFRPPHUFH’
22
chapter one
PXUWDM¬‘SODJXH’Õ5RP PRUWOLDLG SXOT\HU‘WKXPE GZDUI’Õ/DWSROOLFULV‘EHORQJLQJWRDWKXPE’ SXVKWHW‘SRZHU’Õ/DWSRWHVWWHPLG YXOOQHW‘ZLOO’Õ/DWYROXQWWHPLG
8QVWUHVVHGYRZHOVLQWKHDQODXWZHUHVXEMHFWWRDSKHUHVLV7KH
SURFHVV GDWHV EDFN WR 2OG $OEDQLDQ ZKHUH YRZHOV EHIRUH QDVDO DQG OLTXLG VRQRUDQWV ZHUH DIIHFWHG /DWHU LW FRYHUHG LQLWLDO YRZHOV EHIRUH RWKHUW\SHVRIFRQVRQDQWV PEL‘RQXSRQ’ (3$ DPEL ,( DPEKL *NC OHK‘DERXWDURXQG’ *RWKEL2,ULPP &HOW EL QJURK~ QJURI‘WRZDUP’ (3$ HQJUMD 6ODY JUpWLLG URV¬‘GXFN’ (3$ DQWM ,( D QiW 6NWW‘ZDWHUELUG’*N PJ`UUC‘GXFN’ 7KHVDPHSURFHVVDIIHFWHG/DWLQORDQZRUGV EODW¬‘ZDIHU’Õ/DWREOWDLG NLVK¬‘FKXUFK’Õ/DWHFFOVLDLG OWHU‘DOWDU’Õ/DWDOWULXPLG SULOO‘$SULO’Õ/DWDSUOLVLG SXS¬‘KRRSRH’Õ/DWXSXSDLG VKHP¬‘VZDUP RIEHHV ’Õ/DWH[PHQ‘VZDUP’
$IWHU WKH UHGXFWLRQ RI LQODXW YRZHOV KDG EHHQ FRPSOHWHG
JURXSVRIYRZHOVZHUHFRQWUDFWHGZKHUHYHUWKH\KDGEHHQIRUPHGGXH WR WKH IDOO RI LQWHUYRFDOLF YRLFHG VWRSV 7KH TXDOLW\ RI WKH UHVXOWLQJ YRZHO GHSHQGHG RQ WKH VWUHVVHG HOHPHQW LQ WKH JURXS 7KH XQVWUHVVHG HOHPHQWKDGDOUHDG\EHHQUHGXFHGWR¬,Q*HJZKHUHQHZORQJYRZHOV H[LVWFRQWUDFWHGYRZHOVDUHORQJ EH ‘RDWK’ (3$ EDLG 6ODY EpGD ‘GLVDVWHU’ /DW IRHGXV ‘OHDJXH WUHDW\’ GHW ‘VHD’ (3$ GHXEHWD ‘GHSWK’ ,( GKHXE ‘GHHS’ FI *PF
GHXSLÈA‘GHSWK’!0'XGLHSGH0/*GSHGH(GHSWK U\HM‘WRVXIIHU’ UDÆLQMD (3$ UDXGLQMD 6NWU²GLWL‘WRZHHSWR URDU’ /DW UGA ‘WR VKRXW WR FU\’ /LWK UDXG£ ‘ZHHSLQJ’ 6ODY
U\GDWL‘WRZHHS’ VRW‘WRGD\’ (3$ WVM L GWL ,( GWL‘WKLVGD\’
phonology
23
YH ‘ZLGRZ’ (3$ ZLGHZ 6NW YLGK¢Y LG /DW YLGXD LG *RWK ZLGXZRLG ]L ‘EODFN’ (3$ GÊHGL ,( ÞHG 0+* TXW ‘GLUW’ 2( FZ©DG ‘EDG’ /LWK J{GD ‘VKDPH’ 6ODY JDGÙNÙ ‘GLVJXVWLQJ’ JDGÙ ‘UHSWLOHZRUP’
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¬P‘RLOIRUDQRLQWPHQW’Õ*NDCRVKUOC‘EDSWLVP’ ODN¬U~ODN¬Q‘FDEEDJHJUHHQV’Õ*NNCZCPQP‘JUHHQV’ PRN¬U~PRN¬Q‘PLOOVWRQH’Õ*NOJZCPJ‘GHYLFHLQVWUXPHQW’ SUHVK‘OHHN’Õ*NRTCUQPLG
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
24
chapter one /LWHUDWXUH 0,+$ [ (6&8 6&/ ;;;, /DW L LQ $OEDQLDQ %$1),$,$.
6KRUWYRZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV 6KRUW/DWDLVQRUPDOO\UHQGHUHGDV$OED DIW¬‘FDSDEOHSURSHU’Õ/DWDSWXVLG EDUN¬‘ERDW’Õ/DWEDUFDLG IUDVK¬U~IUDVK¬Q‘DVKWUHH’Õ/DWIUD[LQXVLG KDUP¬VKRU‘VWDOOLRQVWXGKRUVH’Õ5RP DUPHVVULXVLG NDO¬‘KRUVH’Õ/DWFDEDOOXVLG VKDJ‘FRDUVHOLQHQIDEULFVSUHDGRQWKHIORRU’Õ/DWVDJXP‘FORDN PDGHRIFRDUVHIDEULF’
/LNH(3$ D/DWDFRXOGEHLQIOXHQFHGE\WKHIURQWYRZHORI WKHQH[WV\OODEOHDQGFKDQJHGWRH HPW¬‘DXQW’Õ/DWDPLWD‘SDWHUQDODXQW’ JMHOE¬U~JMHOE¬Q‘JUHHQ’Õ/DWJDOELQXV‘JUHHQLVK\HOORZ’ THOT‘JODVV’Õ/DWFDOLFHP‘ERZOFXS’ 7KHVDPHUHVXOWZDVDFKLHYHGGXHWRWKHJHQHUDOL]DWLRQRISOXUDOIRUPV RI ZKLFK WKH /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ HQGLQJ L FDXVHG XPODXW FI WKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EHOE¬‘VWDPPHULQJGXPE’Õ/DWEDOEXV‘VWDPPHULQJVWXWWHULQJ’ EUHN¬‘SDQWV’Õ/DWEUFDH‘WURXVHUVEUHHFKHV’ GUHT‘GHYLO’Õ QRPVJ /DWGUDFA‘GUDJRQ’ HQJM¬OO‘DQJHO’Õ/DWDQJHOXVLG JMHO‘URRVWHU’Õ/DWJDOOXVLG THUU‘ZDJRQFDUW’Õ/DWFDUUXV‘WZRZKHHOHGZDJRQ’ $ GLIILFXOW\ LV SUHVHQWHG E\ WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI /DW D LQ EMHVKN¬ ‘PRXQWDLQSDVWXUH’Õ5RP SDVWLFDEDVHGRQ/DWSDVWXV‘SDVWXUH’
%HIRUH QDVDOV /DW D \LHOGHG /3$ Dˆ ZKLFK GHYHORSHG DV LQ RWKHUFDVHVLQWR7RVN¬~ *HJDˆ :
G¬P~GDP‘GDPDJH’Õ/DWGDPQXP‘KXUWKDUPGDPDJH’ JM¬QG¬U~JMDQG¬U‘JODQG’Õ/DWJODQGXOD‘JODQGRIWKHWKURDW’
phonology
25
N¬QGHOO¬ ~ NDQGHOO¬ ‘ODPS’ Õ /DW FDQGOD ‘ZD[OLJKW WDOORZ FDQGOH’ N¬QJ¬~NDQJ¬‘VRQJ’Õ/DWFDQWLFXPLG P¬QJ¬~PDQJ¬‘DUPIXOVOHHYH’Õ/DWPDQLFDH‘VOHHYH’ P¬QJRM DUFKDLF PXQJRM‘WRODFN’Õ5RP PDQFUHLG
/DWHZDVUHQGHUHGDV/3$ HDVDJHQHUDOUXOH N¬VKWMHOO¬‘FDVWOHIRUW’Õ/DWFDVWHOOXPLG SMHS¬U ~ SMHS¬Q ‘VZHHW PHORQ’ Õ 5RP SHSLQHP LG FI /DW SHSAQHP‘NLQGRIODUJHPHORQSXPSNLQ’ SMHUJXOO ‘YLQHDUERU SHUJROD’ Õ /DW SHUJXOD ‘VKHG ERRWK YLQH DUERU’ SMHV¬‘SDUW’Õ5RP SHWLDLG SMHVKN¬‘SHDFK’Õ5RP SHVFD /DWSHUVLFDLG YMHUVK¬‘SRHP’Õ/DWYHUVXV‘YHUVH’ 7KHGLSKWKRQJWKHQGHYHORSHGLQWR D MDY¬‘ZHHN’Õ/DWKHEGRPDVLG
7KH JOLGH ZDV ORVW LQ WKH SRVLWLRQV GHVFULEHG LQ RU VLPLODUFRQWH[WV EHIRUHQJDIWHUVK
EOHW¬‘EHHVZDUPKLYH’ PEOHW¬Õ 5RP PHOHWWXP GUHMW¬‘VWUDLJKWULJKW’Õ/DWGLUHFWXPLG JMHVKW¬U ‘EURRP’ Õ 5RP JHQLVWUD EDVHG RQ /DW JHQLVWD JHQHVWD ‘EURRPSODQWEURRP’ JMXYHQJ¬‘KDUORW’Õ/DWDGMIHPMXYHQFD‘\RXQJ’ NUHO‘FXUOORFN’Õ5RP FHUHEHOOXV NXYHQG ‘VSHHFK FRXQFLO PHHWLQJ’ Õ/DW FRQYHQWXV ‘PHHWLQJ DVVHPEO\’ OHSXU‘KDUH’Õ/DWOHSRUHPLG PHQG‘PLQG’Õ/DWPHQWHPLG VKHVK‘SODLQSODQHIODWQHVVVTXDUH’Õ/DWVHVVXV‘VHDW’ 7KHVDPHDSSOLHVWRWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI D TDUU‘7XUNH\RDNELWWHURDN’Õ/DWFHUUXVLG
26
chapter one
VKDO¬ ‘VDGGOH LQQHU VLGH RI WKLJK SDLU RI OHJV’Õ/DW VHOOD ‘VHDW VDGGOH’ VKDUWRM ‘WR FURVV RI DQLPDOV WR HQJUDIW RI SODQWV ’Õ5RP
LQ VHUWUHEDVHGRQ/DWVHUHUH‘WRVRZ’ VKDUU¬‘VDZ’Õ/DWVHUUDLG VKDW‘KRH’Õ/DWVHFWRU‘FXWWHU’
,Q D IHZ ZRUGV ZH ILQG /DW H UHQGHUHG DV $OE H LQ FRQWH[WV GLVDJUHHLQJZLWKWKHUXOHVHVWDEOLVKHGIRU(3$ H VHH ,Q RQH FDVH $OE H UHIOHFWV DQ XQVWUHVVHG FRQWUDFWHG JURXS HL HEL UDWKHU WKDQ /DW H VR WKDW LW FDQ EH FRPSOHWHO\ LJQRUHG DV IDU DV WKH KLVWRU\RIHLVFRQFHUQHG GHW\U¬‘GXW\GHEW’Õ5RP GHELW UDLG ,QDQRWKHUFDVHZHKDYHWRVXSSRVHVRPHNLQGRIDQDORJLFDOLQWHUDFWLRQ REVFXULQJWKHRULJLQDOYRFDOLVP HJM¬U‘/ROLXPWHPXOHQWXP’Õ/DWHEULDIHP‘GUXQN’LQIOXHQFHGE\ HJ¬U ,Q WZR PRUH ZRUGV ZH ILQG QR SKRQRORJLFDO H[SODQDWLRQ (YHQ WKRXJK LQ ERWK IRUPV WKH QRQGLSKWKRQJL]HG H LV IROORZHG E\ D FOXVWHU EHJLQQLQJZLWKUWKLVLVKDUGO\GHFLVLYHLQVRIDUDVVXFKFOXVWHUVGRQRW EHKDYH WKLV ZD\ LQ /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ZRUGV RI RWKHU RULJLQV 7KLV PD\PHDQWKDWWKHFDVHVEHORZEHORQJWRDODWHUKLVWRULFDOVWUDWXP IHUU‘KHOO’Õ/DWLQIHUQXPLG NXPHUT‘WROOGXW\’Õ/DWFRPPHUFLXP‘WUDGHFRPPHUFH’
$GLIIHUHQWOD\HURIWKH$OEDQLDQYRFDEXODU\UHIOHFWV/DWHDV
$OE L 6HHPLQJO\ WKRVH ZRUGV ZHUH ERUURZHG DW D GLIIHUHQW WLPH DW D GLIIHUHQW SODFH RU IURP D GLIIHUHQW NLQG RI DQFLHQW 5RPDQFH +\SRWKHWLFDOO\IRUPVZLWKLFRXOGSHQHWUDWH$OEDQLDQDWWKHVWDJHZKHQ WKH(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQSKRQRORJLFDOV\VWHPKDGQRVKRUWH LHDIWHU WKHGLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQRI(3$ H! HEXWEHIRUHWKHUHYHUVHSURFHVVLQ FHUWDLQ SKRQHWLF FRQWH[WV ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV ERUURZHG IRUPV ZLWK L H EHORQJWRDODWHUOD\HUWKDQWKHUHVWRI/DWLQZRUGVERUURZHGZLWKMHH H
phonology
27
JULJM‘IORFNKHUG’Õ/DWJUHJHPLG JMLQGH‘SHRSOH’Õ/DWJHQWHPLG P¬VKLU¬‘SLW\PHUF\’Õ/DWPLVHULD‘ZUHWFKHGQHVV’ QLS‘QHSKHZJUDQGVRQ’Õ/DWQRPQHSAV‘JUDQGVRQ’ SULIW‘SULHVW’Õ/DWSUHVE\WHULG SULQG‘IDWKHUSDUHQW’Õ/DWSDUHQWHPLG
6WUHVVHG/DWLQR\LHOGHG$OER EROO¬ ‘NLQG RI KDUPOHVV VQDNH’ Õ 5RP EROD FI /DW EROHD ‘VDODPDQGHU’ IORN‘KDLU’Õ/DWIORFFXV‘ORFNIORFN’ NRUEXOO‘NHJFDVNZRRGHQSDLO’Õ/DWFRUEXOD‘OLWWOHEDVNHW’ NXOORVKW¬U‘ELHVWOLQJV’Õ/DWFRORVWUDLG SRVKW¬‘GRZQEHORZXQGHU’Õ/DWSRVWSRVWH‘EHKLQGEDFN’ UURW¬‘ZKHHO’Õ/DWURWDLG 8QVWUHVVHG/DWLQRZDVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEX JXOWRM‘WRJHWULGRII’Õ/DWFROOXFWUL‘WRVWUXJJOHWRFRQWHQG’ NXODU‘FXUYHGSLHFHRIZRRGR[FROODU’Õ/DWFROOUH‘FROODU’ NXQDW‘EURWKHULQODZ’Õ/DWFRJQWXV‘NLQVPDQEORRGUHODWLRQ’ OHSXU‘KDUH’Õ/DWOHSRUHPLG PXOOL~PXOOî‘PLOO’Õ/DWPROQXPLG SXOT\HU‘WKXPE GZDUI’Õ/DWSROOLFULV‘EHORQJLQJWRDWKXPE’ ,Q WZR FDVHV SUREDEO\ ERUURZHG DW D ODWHU VWDJH XQVWUHVVHG R LV UHIOHFWHGLQ$OEDQLDQDVR QRWRM‘WRVZLP’Õ5RP QRWUHUHSODFLQJFODVVLFDO/DWQDWUHLG SHVKNRS‘ELVKRSRIWKH2UWKRGR[FKXUFK’Õ/DWHSLVFRSXV‘ELVKRS’ ,QRQHFDVHRKDVEHHQUHGXFHGWR¬ N¬UUXW¬‘HZHZLWKKRUQV’Õ/DWIHPDGMFRUQ WD‘KRUQHG’
6WUHVVHG /DWLQ R FDQ EH DOVR UHQGHUHG DV $OE X :RUGV UHIOHFWLQJ WKLV GHYHORSPHQW VHHP WR IRUP D VHSDUDWH OH[LFDO OD\HU
28
chapter one
SUHVXPDEO\RIHDUOLHURULJLQWKDQWKHUHVWRI/DWLQZRUGVZLWKR&IWKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV IXUULN IXUULT ‘FKLFNHQFRRS IRZOSHQ URRVW QHVWLQJER[’ Õ /DW IRUQLFHP‘DUFKYDXOW’ IXVK¬‘SODLQRSHQILHOGPHDGRZ’Õ/DWIRVVD‘GLWFKWUHQFKJXWWHU IXUURZ’ NXT‘UHG’Õ5RP FRFFHXVFI/DWFRFFLQHXV‘VFDUOHW’ NXUW‘\DUG’Õ/DWFRUWHPLG UUXPEXOO ‘UROOHG LQWR D EDOO’ Õ 5RP URPEXOXV EDVHG RQ /DW UKRPEXV‘PDJLFZKLUOLJLJRUZKHHO’ VKSX]¬‘KRWDVKHV’Õ/DWVSRGLXP‘DVK’
,QWZR UHODWHG ZRUGVVWUHVVHG/DWRVHHPVWREHUHIOHFWHGDV
$OEH
EUHWN‘IURJ’Õ5RP EURWDFXVLG EUHVKN¬ ‘WRUWRLVH’ Õ %DONDQ 5RP EURWDVFXV RU EURVDFXV ‘WRUWRLVHIURJ’ ,W LV SUREDEOH WKDW R RI WKH ILUVW V\OODEOH ZDV IRU VRPH UHDVRQ OHQJWKHQHGWR ALQWKH5RPDQFHGLDOHFWVRI$OEDQLD
/DWL\LHOGHG$OEL ELVKWDM¬ ‘SRG KXOO SHD JUHHQ EHDQ’ Õ 5RP SLVWOLD ! 5XP S:VWDLH‘SRGKXOO’ GLVKW¬GLVKN¬‘PLOOIXQQHO’Õ/DWGLVFXV‘GLVN’ LULT‘KHGJHKRJ’Õ/DWULFLXVLG LVKXOO‘LVODQG’Õ/DWLQVXODLG N¬VKLOO‘FRXQFLO’Õ/DWFRQVLOLXPLG UULT¬U~UULT¬Q‘WLFN’Õ/DWULFLQXVLG YLUJM¬U~YLUJMLQ‘PDLGHQ’Õ/DWYLUJLQHPLG
7KHUH H[LVWV KRZHYHU DQRWKHU OD\HU RI /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV LQ
ZKLFK/DWLLVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEH,WLVSUREDEOHWKDWWKLVJURXSRIZRUGV EHORQJVWRDODWHUSHULRGZKHQRQWKHRQHKDQGQHZVKRUWHUHDSSHDUHG LQ3URWR$OEDQLDQDQGRQWKHRWKHUKDQGVKRUWLLQ/DWLQPHUJHGZLWK VKRUWH,WLVLQWHUHVWLQJWKDWORDQZRUGVZLWKLÖHEHORQJIRUWKHPRVW SDUWWRFRPSOHWHO\GLIIHUHQWVHPDQWLFILHOGV
phonology
29
IH‘EHOLHIUHOLJLRQ’Õ/DWILGHP‘IDLWK’ NUHVKS¬ ‘VKHHS ZLWK ORQJ DQG URXJK ZRRO’ Õ /DW IHP DGM FULVSD ‘FXUOHGFULVSXQHYHQ’ PHVK¬‘PDVV’Õ/DWPLVVDLG VKHQM¬‘VLJQ’Õ/DWVLJQXPLG XSHVKN‘ELVKRS’Õ/DWHSLVFRSXVLG YHV‘EDGKDELW’Õ/DWYLWLXP‘IDXOWGHIHFWYLFH’ 5HVXOWLQJHZDVRFFDVLRQDOO\FKDQJHGWR¬EHIRUHVRQRUDQWV N¬UNRM‘WRORRNIRUWRVHHN’Õ5RP FLUFUHLG N¬VKW¬U~N¬VKW¬Q‘&KULVWLDQ’ N¬UVKW¬QÕ/DWFKULVWLQXVLG VKWU¬QJRM‘WRSUHVVWRVTXHH]H’Õ/DWVWULQJHUH‘WRVWUHWFKWRSUHVV WRVTXHH]H’
,Q WZR FDVHV DSSDUHQWO\ UHSUHVHQWLQJ UHODWLYHO\ HDUO\
ERUURZLQJV EHWZHHQWKRVHZKHUH/DWLÖ$OELDQGWKRVHZKHUH/DWL Ö$OEH /DWLLVUHQGHUHGDV/3$ H~ D PMHU¬‘XQKDSS\XQIRUWXQDWH’Õ5RP PLVUHP /DWPLVHUHPLG TDUN‘FLUFOH’Õ/DWFLUFXVLG
/DWXLVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEXLQPRVWFDVHV EXO¬‘EXG’Õ/DWEXOOD‘EXEEOHERVVNQRE’ EXW‘ELJEDUUHO’Õ/DWEXWWLVLG VKXP¬‘PDQ\PXFK’Õ/DWVXPPXV‘XSSHUPRVWKLJKHVW’ NXQM‘SHJZHGJH’Õ/DWFXQHXV‘ZHGJH’ PXVKW‘PXVWQHZZLQH’Õ/DWPXVWXPLG JMXYHQJ¬ ‘KDUORW’Õ/DW DGM IHP MXYHQFD ‘\RXQJ’ DOVR ‘\RXQJ FRZ’ ,QDIHZFDVHVZHILQG$OERDVDUHIOH[RI/DWX,WLVFOHDUWKDWVXFK ZRUGV EHORQJ WR WKH VDPH FKURQRORJLFDO OD\HU DV WKH IRUPV ZLWK H UHQGHULQJ/DWL JRP¬‘UHVLQ’Õ5RP JXPPDDYDULDQWRI/DWJXPPLLG WURIW¬‘WURXW’ÕLat WUXFWDLG
30
chapter one
]PRMOH ‘IDOORZ ODQG ’ Õ 5RP H[PXOJLD D GHULYDWLYH RI /DW [ PXOJUH‘WRPLONRXWWRGUDLQRXW’
%HIRUHVRQRUDQWVXQVWUHVVHGXZRXOGRFFDVLRQDOO\\LHOG¬ Q¬P¬URM‘WRQXPEHUWRFRXQW’Õ/DWQXPHUUHLG UU¬PEHM‘WRUREWRVHL]H’Õ/DWUXPSHUH‘WRWHDUWRWHDUDZD\’ ,QWZRFDVHV/DWXZDVOHQJWKHQHGDQG\LHOGHG$OE\ NU\T‘FURVV’Õ/DWFUXFHPLG P\VKNPXVKN‘PRVVPXVN’Õ/DWPXVFXVLG
/RQJYRZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV /RQJ /DWLQ YRZHOV DOVR UHIOHFW GLIIHUHQW FKURQRORJLFDO VWDJHV DQG SUREDEO\ GLIIHUHQW DUHDV RI /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DQG 5RPDQFH SKRQHWLFGHYHORSPHQW 7KH QRUPDO UHIOH[ RI /DW LV $OE D DV LQ WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV EODW¬‘ZDIHU’Õ/DWREOWDLG IDP¬‘JRRGUHSXWDWLRQUXPRU’Õ/DWIPD‘UXPRUIDPH’ IDW‘IDWH EULGHJURRPKXVEDQGIULHQG’Õ/DWIWXP QDW\U¬‘QDWXUH’Õ/DWQW UDLG VKNDOO¬‘VWDLUVVWDLUFDVH’Õ/DWVFODH‘VWDLUV’ VKWUDW‘EHG OD\HU’Õ/DWVWUWXPLG
$VLQWKHFDVHRIVKRUW/DWD VHH /DWLVRIWHQUDLVHG WR$OEHEHIRUHIURQWYRZHOVRIYDULRXVRULJLQV
N¬OTHUH‘OLPH’Õ/DWIHPDGMFDOFULD‘SHUWDLQLQJWROLPH’ OWHU‘DOWDU’Õ/DWDOWULXPLG PDUWHV¬‘PDUULDJH’Õ5RP PDULWWLALG SXVKWHW‘SRZHU’Õ/DWSRWHVWWHPLG VKHP¬‘VZDUP RIEHHV ’Õ/DWH[PHQ‘VZDUP’ YXOOQHW‘ZLOO’Õ/DWYROXQWWHPLG
phonology
31
,Q D OLPLWHG QXPEHU RI FDVHV VWUHVVHG /DW \LHOGHG $OE \H EHIRUHU FIDVLPLODUGHYHORSPHQWIRU(3$ LQ PXVKN¬OO\HU ‘GXQ JUH\EURZQ UHGEURZQ’ Õ 5RP PXVFHOOULXV ‘FRORUHGOLNHDPRXVH’FI/DWPXVFHOOULXP‘PRXVHWUDS’ SXOT\HU‘WKXPE GZDUI’Õ/DWSROOLFULV‘EHORQJLQJWRDWKXPE’ %HIRUHQDVDOVLQDXVODXW/DWVHHPVWREHKDYHDVVKRUWDLHLW\LHOGV /DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQDˆ RUê (if raised), which then developed as described in 1.1.4.2: SH~Sê‘WKUHDG’Õ/DWSQXV‘WKUHDGZRXQGXSRQWKHEREELQ’ VKXOO¬~VKXOODˆ‘VXQQ\VSRW’Õ/DWVROQXV ORFXV LG 3UHWRQLF/DWZDVUHIOHFWHGDV¬ P¬UNRVK ‘PDQ O\LQJ LQ ZLIH’V EHG DIWHU FKLOGELUWK DQG UHFHLYLQJ YLVLWRUV ORYHU’Õ5RP PULFAVXV‘KXVEDQGOLNH’
$OO WKH DERYH ORDQZRUGV PXVW KDYH SHQHWUDWHG $OEDQLDQ DIWHU WKH SURFHVV RI ODELDOL]DWLRQ RI (3$ ZDV FRPSOHWHG +RZHYHU ZH NQRZ RI DW OHDVW RQH FRQVLGHUDEO\ HDUOLHU FDVH RI D /DWLQ ORDQZRUG ZKLFKDSSHDUVWRUHIOHFW/DWÖ$OER PROO¬‘DSSOHDSSOHWUHH’Õ/DWPOXPLG
7KHVWDQGDUGUHIOH[RI/DWLV$OEH IHP¬U~IHP¬Q‘ZRPDQ’Õ/DWIPLQDLG N¬QGHOO¬~NDQGHOO¬‘ODPS’Õ/DWFDQGOD‘ZD[OLJKWWDOORZFDQGOH’ SU¬QGYHU¬ ~ SUDQGYHU¬ ‘VSULQJ’ Õ 5RP SUPD YUD ! ,WDO SULPDYHUD5XPSULP:YDU: THW¬‘TXLHW’Õ/DWTXLWXVLG VKSUHWN¬ ~ VKS¬QHWN¬ ‘VSOHHQ’ Õ /DW VSOQWLFXP ‘UHODWHG WR WKH VSOHHQ’ YUHU~Y¬QHUP‘JDOOELOH’Õ/DWYHQQXP‘SRWLRQSRLVRQ’ 8QGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRIIROORZLQJLRU/DWZDVUHIOHFWHGDVL
32
chapter one
ELVK¬‘EHDVWZLOGDQLPDO’Õ/DWEVWLDLG LULT‘KHGJHKRJ’Õ/DWULFLXVLG NLVK¬‘FKXUFK’Õ/DWHFFOVLDLG OLJM‘ODZ’Õ/DWOJH P LG DIIHFWHGE\LRIWKHREOLTXHFDVHV
7ZRVPDOOHUJURXSVRIZRUGVZLWKGLIIHUHQWUHIOH[HVEHORQJWR HDUOLHU VWDJHV RI $OEDQLDQ FRQWDFWV ZLWK 5RPDQFH 7KH ROGHVW OH[LFDO OD\HU GHPRQVWUDWHV WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI /DW WR $OE R VLPLODU WR WKH FKDQJHRI(3$ ORJRUL‘ZDLOLQJPRXUQLQJGLUJH’Õ/DWDOOJRULD‘DOOHJRU\’ PEORM‘WRILOO’Õ/DWLPSOUHLG TRM‘WRZDNHXS’Õ/DWFLUH‘WRPRYHWRDJLWDWH’ $QRWKHUJURXSRIZRUGVSUHVXPDEO\ZDVERUURZHGDIWHUWKHVKLIW ! (3$ KDG WDNHQ SODFH EXW EHIRUH WKH GLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQ RI VKRUW (3$
HLHDWWKHWLPHZKHQ(3$ HZDVWKHEHVWSRVVLEOHVXEVWLWXWHIRU/DW NDVKQMHW‘FKHVWQXWJURYH’Õ/DWFDVWDQWXPLG UUMHW¬‘QHW’Õ/DWUWHLG WMHJXOO‘EULFN’Õ/DWWJXODLG %HIRUHQDVDOVLQDXVODXW/DWEHKDYHVDVVKRUWHDQG\LHOGV/DWH3URWR $OEDQLDQê: IUH~IUê‘EULGOH JUDSHVWDON FRPE’Õ/DWIUQXPLG
7KHROGHVW/DWLQORDQZRUGVGLVSOD\HDVDUHJXODUUHIOH[RI/DW AFIIRUH[DPSOH KHU¬‘WLPHPRPHQWRIWLPHKRXU’Õ/DWKAUD‘KRXU’ SHP¬‘IUXLWWUHHIUXLW’Õ/DWSAPXP‘IUXLW’SAPXV‘IUXLWWUHH’ SOHS‘SRSODU’Õ5RP SOASXVPHWDWKHVLVRI/DWSASXOXVLG SUHPWRM‘WRSURPLVH’Õ/DWSUAPLWWHUH‘WRIRUERGHWRSURPLVH’ W¬UPHW‘HDUWKTXDNH’Õ5RP WHUUDHPAWXVLG WPHUU‘KRUURUIULJKW’Õ/DWWLPAUHPLG
,QDVPDOOQXPEHURIORDQZRUGVZHILQGDVXEVWLWXWLRQRI/DWA ZLWK$OEX
phonology
33
NDQXVK¬‘VWRUN’Õ5RP FQAVXVGHULYDWLYHRI/DWFQXV‘ZKLWH’ XUGK¬U~XUGK¬Q‘RUGHU’Õ/DWAUGLQHPLG XW‘RZO’Õ/DWAWXV‘KRUQHGRZO’ &IDOVRRQHFDVHLQZKLFKZHILQG\DVDFRQWLQXDWLRQRI/DWASUREDEO\ WKHUHVXOWRI$OEXEHIRUHDV\OODEOHFRQWDLQLQJL ]JM\U¬‘UXVW’Õ/DWVFAULD‘GURVVVODJ’
7KH PRVW UHFHQW OD\HU RI /DWLQ ERUURZLQJV UHIOHFWV /DW A H[DFWO\DVVKRUW/DWR VHH 6WUHVVHG/DWAJLYHV$OER NXURU¬~ NXQRU¬‘FURZQ’Õ/DWFRUAQDLG P¬UNRVK ‘PDQ O\LQJ LQ ZLIH’V EHG DIWHU FKLOGELUWK DQG UHFHLYLQJ YLVLWRUV ORYHU’Õ5RP PULFAVXV‘KXVEDQGOLNH’ UUREXOO ‘PRXQWDLQ SLQH’ Õ /DW UAEXU ‘RDN’ ZLWK D GLVVLPLODWLRQ RI VRQRUDQWV VK¬QGRVK‘KHDOWK\’Õ5RP VDQLWAVXVLG VKTRS¬‘EULDU’Õ/DWVFASD‘WZLJEUDQFK’ ZLWKVHFRQGDU\T 8QVWUHVVHG/DWALVUHIOHFWHGDVXFIWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV GKXURM‘WRPDNHDSUHVHQW’Õ/DWGAQUHLG NXMWRM‘WRUHPHPEHUWRWKLQN’Õ/DWFAJLWUHLG NXOORM‘WRVLHYHWRVLIWWRILOWHU’Õ/DWFAOUH‘WRILOWHUWRVWUDLQ’ XVKWRM‘WRVRXQGWRVKRXW’Õ/DWAVFLWUH‘WRVKRXWWRRSHQPRXWK WR\DZQ’
,QDQODXWEHIRUHQDVDOV/DWA\LHOGV$OEXD~ XH GUDJXD~ GUD Q JXH‘GUDJRQ’Õ5RP GUDQFAQHPDPRGLILFDWLRQRI /DWGUDFAQHPLG IDMNXD~IDMNXH‘IDOFRQ’Õ/DWIDOFAQHPLG IWXD ~ IWXH ‘TXLQFH’ Õ 5RP FRWAQHXP LG QDPHO\ ‘&\GRQLDQ DSSOH’ NDSXD~NDSXH‘URRVWHU’ Õ/DWFSAQHP‘FDSRQ’ 8QGHUXQFHUWDLQFRQGLWLRQV DIWHUL " ZHDOVRILQG\H
34
chapter one
DUV\H‘UHDVRQXQGHUVWDQGLQJ’ÕUDWLAQHPLG
7KHKLVWRU\RI/DWLQ$OEDQLDQLVLGHQWLFDOZLWKWKDWRIVKRUW /DWL VHH ,QPRVWFDVHVLWJLYHV$OEL
çLPN¬‘EXJ’Õ/DWFPLFHPLG IVKLN¬‘EOLVWHUEXEEOHEODGGHUEUXLVH’Õ/DWYVFD‘EODGGHU’ LM¬‘KLSVLGH’Õ/DWSOOLD‘JURLQIODQN’ OLO‘OLO\’Õ/DWOOLXPLG PLN‘IULHQG’Õ/DWDPFXVLG VKSLUW‘VRXOVSLULW’Õ/DWVSULWXVLG 2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG LQ VHYHUDO ZRUGV ERUURZHG DW DQRWKHU VWDJH RI FRQWDFWVZHILQG$OEHDVDUHIOH[RI JMHU‘GRUPRXVH’Õ/DWJOUHPLG SUHY¬ ‘RSHQ ZD\ WUDFN IRUG’ Õ /DW SUYXP LWHU ‘SULYDWH URDG SDVVDJH ’ VKRUHWN¬ ‘KROH RI D KRQH\FRPE’ VKRUWHN¬ Õ 5RP VRUWFD ‘RXWOHW’GHULYHGIURP VRUWUH‘WRJRRXW’
(DUO\ORDQZRUGVZLWK/DW UHIOHFWDFKDQJHWR\ EU\P¬‘IURVW’Õ/DWEU PD‘FROGIURVW’ IU\W‘IUXLW’ Õ/DWIU FWXVLG I\W\U¬‘IDFH’Õ/DWIDFW UD‘IRUPDWLRQFUHDWXUH’ ODW\U¬‘ULQVHZDWHU’ Õ5RP ODYW UDIURP/DWODYUH‘WRZDVK’ P\OO‘PXOH’Õ/DWP OXVLG QDW\U¬‘QDWXUH’Õ/DWQW UDLG ,Q ODWHU ORDQZRUGV /DW LV UHQGHUHG DV $OE X FI WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV GXURM‘WREHSDWLHQW’Õ/DWG UUHLG N¬UUXW¬‘HZHZLWKKRUQV’ Õ/DWIHPDGMFRUQ WD‘KRUQHG’ NXNXW¬‘IHQQHO’Õ/DWFLF WDLG QXVH ‘EULGH \RXQJ ZRPDQ \RXQJHU GDXJKWHULQODZ’ Õ 5RP
Q SWLD D ORFDO YDULDQW RI /DW Q SWD ‘PDUULHG ZRPDQ ZLIH EULGH’ UUXJ¬‘VWUHHW’Õ/DWU JD‘ZULQNOH’
phonology
35
UUXVKNXOO ‘D NLQG RI WKRUQ\ SODQW’ Õ 5RP U VFXOXV GHULYDWLYH RI /DWU VFXV‘EXWFKHU’VEURRP’
/DWLQGLSKWKRQJV 7KHRQO\GLSKWKRQJWKDWH[LVWHGLQ/DWLQDQGHDUO\5RPDQFHDW WKHWLPHVRI$OEDQLDQ/DWLQFRQWDFWVZDVDX2WKHUGLSKWKRQJV WKRXJK ZH GR QRW KDYH H[DPSOHV IRU RH KDG DOUHDG\ EHFRPH PRQRSKWKRQJV VHH /DWDXVKDUHGWKHIDWHRI(3$ DXDQGZDVUHQGHUHGDV$OED DU‘JROG’Õ/DWDXUXPLG JD]‘MR\ODXJKWHU’Õ/DWJDXGLXP‘MR\’ ODU‘ODXUHO’Õ /DWODXUXVLG SDN‘DOLWWOHIHZ’Õ/DWSDXFXV‘IHZOLWWOH’ VKNDJRM ‘WR UHIXVH WR GHFOLQH’ Õ /DW H[FDXGLFUH ‘WR XSURRW WR HUDGLFDWH‘ 8QVWUHVVHGDXZDVUHGXFHGWR¬ZKLFKZDVWKHQODELDOL]HGWRXXQGHU WKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHSUHFHGLQJV\OODEOH N¬VK\UH ‘PRXQWDLQ SDWK SDWK LQ WKH UDYLQH’ Õ /DW FODXV UD ‘ORFN EDUEROW FDVWOHIRUW’ VKXUXNRM‘WRWKXQGHUWRPDNHQRLVH’Õ5RP VXEUDXFUH‘WRPDNH KRDUVH’FI,WDOGLDOVXUUDJDUH /DWHU ORDQZRUGV ERUURZHG DW WKH WLPH ZKHQ (3$ DX KDG DOUHDG\ EHFRPH DUHIOHFW/DWDXDV DY! DIXQVWUHVVHG¬Y!LY NDIVK¬‘DQLPDOWKLQJ’Õ/DWFDXVD‘FDXVH’ OLITHU OLITDU ‘ZDWHUIDOO’ Õ 5RP ODYFUXP /DW ODYFUXP ‘EDWK’ ZLWKL ¬
/DWDHFRLQFLGHGZLWKVKRUWH LQRSHQ5RP ? ORQJEHIRUHWKH
EHJLQQLQJ RI $OEDQR5RPDQLDQ FRQWDFWV ,WV UHIOHFWLRQ LV LGHQWLFDO WR WKDWRI/DWH JUHN‘*UHHN’Õ/DWJUDHFXVLG SUH‘SUH\ERRW\SOXQGHU’Õ/DWSUDHGDLG
36
chapter one
TLHOO‘VN\KHDYHQ’Õ/DWFDHOXPLG VKHNXOO‘DJH’Õ/DWVDHFXOXPLG
3RVLWLRQDOFKDQJHVRIYRZHOVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV $V QRWHG DERYH WKH SKRQHWLF DGDSWDWLRQ RI /DWLQ ZRUGV LQ $OEDQLDQLVRIFRQVLGHUDEOHLPSRUWDQFHIRUWKHKLVWRU\RIWKH$OEDQLDQ YRFDOLVP 6HYHUDO LPSRUWDQW SKRQHWLF FKDQJHV RI SRVLWLRQDO QDWXUH DUH GHVFULEHGEHORZVRPHRIWKHPEHLQJFKDUDFWHULVWLFH[FOXVLYHO\RI/DWLQ ORDQZRUGV /LWHUDWXUH -2./ ,) ;;;9,, SURWKHWLF Y LQ QRQ/DWLQ ZRUGV '(61,&.$-$ 9-D SURWKHWLF Y 6<729 3UREO UHN SURWKHWLFYLQYHWH
/DWLQ YRZHOV GLYLGHG E\ Y RU DQ\ RWKHU FRQVRQDQW ZKLFK GURSSHG LQ /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ GHSHQGHG XSRQ WKH TXDOLW\ RI ERWK YRZHOV ,I WKH VHFRQG YRZHO ZDV D WKH UHVXOW RI FRQWUDFWLRQ ZDV LGHQWLFDOZLWKWKHILUVWYRZHORIWKHJURXS DUQRM‘WRPHQGWRUHSDLU’Õ/DWUHQRYUH‘WRUHQHZ’ DUULM‘WRFRPHWRDUULYH’Õ5RP DUULYUHLG EOHM‘WREX\’Õ5RP DEOHYUH‘WROLIWXSWRUHOLHYH IURP ’ IHO¬‘KRQH\FRPE’Õ5RP IDYDOLDFI,WDOILDOHLG ,IWKHVHFRQGV\OODEOHZDVLWKHJURXSZDVUHIOHFWHGDV$OE\ JM\NRM‘WRMXGJHWRWU\’Õ/DWM GLFUHLG Q\W¬URM‘WRPXUPXUWRZKLVSHU’Õ/DWUHLWHUUH‘WRUHSHDW’ S\ON¬‘ZHGJH HQGRIDQD[HKDQGOH’Õ/DWSDYFXOD‘UDPPHU’ T\WHW‘FLW\’Õ/DWFYLWWH P LG
:KLOHLQLQODXW/DWRZDVVXEVWLWXWHG DWGLIIHUHQWHSRFKV E\R RUX,QLWLDOO\LWEHFDPH/3$ ÆH YHUE¬U~YHUE‘EOLQG’Õ/DWRUEXVLG YHS¬U‘ZRUN’Õ/DWRSHUDLG /DWHULQLWLDO/DWRZDVVXEVWLWXWHGE\7RVNYD~*HJYR 2*HJYH DVLQ WKHIROORZLQJFDVHV
phonology
37
YDM~ YRM‘RLO’Õ/DWROHXPLG YDUI¬U~YRUI¬Q‘SRRU’Õ/DWRUSKDQXV‘RUSKDQ’ YRVKW¬U *HJ ‘/LJXVWUXPYXOJDUH’Õ/DW²OHDVWHULG YH~YR‘HJJ’ YDH~ YRH Õ/DWAYXP‘HJJ’ /RDQZRUGV IURP RWKHU ODQJXDJHV WKDW SHQHWUDWHG $OEDQLDQ GXULQJ WKH VDPHSHULRGZHUHWUHDWHGOLNHZLVH YDGK¬~YRGK¬‘VRUEDSSOH’Õ*NQKJLG YDW¬U~YRW¬U‘KHDUWKILUHSODFH’Õ,UDQGLDO RWDU ,UDQ DWDUFI $YWDU‘ILUH’
,QJURXSVRQDQGRPWKH/DWLQYRZHOZDVDOZD\VUHQGHUHG
DV $OE X ZKLOH WKH VRQRUDQW ZDV RQO\ SUHVHUYHG LI LW ZDV WKH ILUVW HOHPHQWRIDFOXVWHULQFOXGLQJDQRFFOXVLYH QRUPDOO\QWRUQF NUXVKN ‘EULGH’V PDQ XQPDUULHG UHODWLYH’ NXVKN ¬ U Õ /DW FRQVRFHU‘IDWKHULQODZ’ NXQG¬U‘DJDLQVW’Õ/DWFRQWUDLG NXQJRM‘WRFRPPXQLFDWH’Õ/DWFRPP QLFUHLG NXVKXOO‘FRQVXO’Õ/DWFRQVXOHPLG NXYHQG ‘VSHHFK FRXQFLO PHHWLQJ’ Õ /DW FRQYHQWXV ‘PHHWLQJ DVVHPEO\’ UUXIH ‘OLJKWQLQJ’ Õ /DW URPSKDHD ‘ORQJ VZRUG’ DGDSWDWLRQ RI *N T QOHCKCLG /DWHUWKLVJURXSZDVUHQGHUHGDV¬ N¬VKLOO‘FRXQFLO’Õ/DWFRQVLOLXPLG
9RZHOVLQ6ODYLFORDQZRUGV 7KH PDMRULW\ RI 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV LQ $OEDQLDQ EHORQJ WR D UHODWLYHO\ ODWH SHULRG SUHVXPDEO\ DIWHU WKH 9,,, FHQWXU\ &( DQG UHIOHFW IXOO\ GHYHORSHG 6RXWK 6ODYLF GLDOHFWV ZLWK VXFK DGYDQFHG SKRQHWLF IHDWXUHV DV GHQDVDOL]HG ? DQG _ ORVW ZHDN “MHUV” IXOO\ YRFDOL]HGVWURQJ“MHUV”, metathesized groups of vowels with liquids and the like.
38
chapter one
+RZHYHUWKHUHDOVRH[LVWVDOLPLWHGJURXSRIORDQZRUGV EHORQJLQJ WR WKH 9, 9,,, FHQWXULHV UHIOHFWLQJ VRPH RI WKH PRUH DUFKDLF SKRQHWLF SKHQRPHQDRI6ODYLF7KH\DUHGHVFULEHGEHORZ,WLVLPSRUWDQWIRUWKH UHODWLYH FKURQRORJ\ RI WKH $OEDQLDQ YRFDOLVP WKDW 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV EHDUQRWUDFHVRIGLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQRIH
6HYHUDO 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV UHIOHFW XQVWUHVVHG 6ODY R DV $OE D
MXVWOLNHLQRWKHUQHLJKERULQJODQJXDJHVWKDWERUURZHGIURP6ODYLFDIWHU WKH 6RXWKHUQ PLJUDWLRQV DQG H[SDQVLRQV RI 6ODYV FI 6ODY VORYpQH ‘6ODYV’Ö*N5MNCDJPQKLG EDJ¬WL ~ EDNWL ‘GRPHVWLF DQLPDO KHDG RI FDWWOH’ EDVHG RQ EDJ¬W Õ6ODY ERJDWÙ‘ULFK’ NDçXE¬‘EXVK’Õ6ODY NR¨XEÙ NR¨XED‘FUHVWWXIW’ NDUUXS‘ILVKWUDS’Õ6ODY NRUXSÙLGDWWHVWHGLQ%XOJNRUXS NDUUXW¬‘IHUPHQWHU’Õ6ODY NRU\WR‘WURXJK’ PDWXN¬‘PDWWRFNKRH’Õ6ODY PRW\NDLG UDJDO‘NHQQHO’Õ6ODY URJDOÚ‘FRUQHU’
6ODY R DSSHDUV DV $OE ¬ LQ RQH H[DPSOH OLNHO\ GXH WR YRZHO DVVLPLODWLRQ S¬J¬M~SXJâM‘WRPDNHGLUW\WRVRLO’Õ6ODY SRJDQLWLLG :HDOVRILQGWZRLQWHUHVWLQJFDVHVRI6ODY D RULJLQDOO\DORQJYRZHO UHIOHFWHGDV(3$ !R NRV‘\RJXUWFORWWHGFXUGV’Õ6ODY NYDVÙ‘VRXUVXEVWDQFH’ YRUE¬‘FOD\SRW’Õ6ODY YDUÚED‘FRRNLQJ’
,QHDUO\ORDQZRUGV6ODY \ LVUHQGHUHGDV$OEX EXVKW¬U‘UDJLQJZLOG’Õ6ODY E\VWUÙIHP E\VWUD‘TXLFN’ NDUUXW¬‘IHUPHQWHU’Õ6ODY NRU\WR‘WURXJK’ NXO¬‘KHUQLD’Õ6ODY N\ODLG OOXN¬‘OLPHWUHH’Õ6ODY O\NR‘EDVW’ PDWXN¬‘PDWWRFNKRH’Õ6ODY PRW\NDLG SRVXOO¬‘ELOOVOLSQRWHOHWWHU’Õ6ODY SRV\OD SXUU¬‘KRWDVKHV’Õ6ODY S\U’ÚLG
phonology
39
6ODYLF “jers” Ú DQG Ù ROG VKRUW L DQG X DUH UHIOHFWHG DV L DQG X FRUUHVSRQGLQJO\FIWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV PX]J‘GXVN’Õ6ODY PÙ]JD‘UDLQ\ZHDWKHU’ RSLQJ¬ ‘VDQGDO’ Õ 6ODY RE Ù SÚQÙNÙ ‘VDQGDO VKRH’ FI 6&U RSDQDN WULVKH‘VKRRWLQJVSURXW’Õ6ODY WUÚVÙ‘JUDSHVWDON’FI6&UWUV
*URXSV 7HU7 7RU7 DQG 7RO7 DUH SUHVHUYHG LQ HDUO\ 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGVEXWRFKDQJHVWR$OEDDVLQGLFDWHGDERYH DUTLW¬ ‘URG IRU EDVNHW ZHDYLQJ ’ Õ 6ODY RUN\WD ‘EURRP SODQW NLQGRIZLOORZ’ çHUGKH‘QHVW’Õ6ODY ¨HUGD‘URZKHUGIORFN’ GDOW¬‘FKLVHO’Õ6ODY GROEWRLG VKDUN‘ZRROHQFORDN JUHHQVNLQRIQXWV’Õ6ODY VRUND‘VKLUW’ YDOONXD ~ YDOONXH ‘ILVK WUDS’ Õ 6ODY SO YRONRYH ‘REMHFWV WKDW FDQ EHGUDJJHGRUFDUULHGQHWV’ 2FFDVLRQDOO\ 7RU7 ZDV UHQGHUHG DV DQ XQXVXDO 6RXWK 6ODYLF “SROQRJODVLH”DUD KDUDEHO‘VSDUURZ’Õ6ODY YRUEÚOÚLG NDUDYHO¬‘VPDOOURXQG EUHDG’ NDUDYDO¬Õ 6ODY NRUYDMÚ ‘URXQG EUHDG’ ,QWZRFDVHV RULVUHIOHFWHGDVUR2QH RIWKHPVHHPVWRUHIOHFWD VWDQGDUG2OG&KXUFK6ODYLFGHYHORSPHQWRIDQODXWLQJ RU URE‘VHUISULVRQHU’Õ6ODY RUEÙLG 7KH VHFRQG ZRUG LV PXFK PRUH FRPSOLFDWHG DQG VHHPV WR UHIOHFW DQ XQDWWHVWHG 6ODYLF GLDOHFW LQ WKH %DONDQV LQVRIDU DV DOO 6RXWK 6ODYLF ODQJXDJHVGHYHORSHGUDKHUH JURVK¬ ‘EHDQ OHQWLO’ Õ 6ODY JRUhÚ DQ DGMHFWLYH GHULYHG IURP
JRU[Ù‘SHD’
*URXSVRI“MHUV” IROORZHGE\OLTXLGVLQHDUO\6ODYLFORDQZRUGV DUHDOOUHSUHVHQWHGDVXODQGXUFIWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV
40
chapter one
EXOORJ ‘GUDJRQ’V GZHOOLQJ’ Õ EÙUORJÙ 6ODY EÚUORJÙ ‘GHQ GZHOOLQJ’ JUXVKW‘ILVW’Õ6ODY JÙUVWÚ‘KDQGIXOKDQG’ NXOE¬‘NLQGRIIUHVKZDWHUILVK’Õ6ODY NÙOED~ NÙOEÙLGFI3RO NLHOE5XVNROED YXUNROODN‘YDPSLUH’Õ6ODY YÚONRGODNÙ‘ZHUZROIYDPSLUH’ ,Q RQH ZRUG KRZHYHU ZH ILQG D GLIIHUHQW SKRQHWLF GHYHORSPHQW UHIOHFWLQJDGLDOHFWDOVRXUFHYHU\FORVHWR2OG&KXUFK6ODYLF WUHJ‘PDUNHW’Õ WUÙJÙ 2&6WUÚJÚ 6ODY WÙUJÙLG
,Q VHYHUDO FDVHV QDVDO YRZHOV RI 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV DUH WUDQVIRUPHGLQWR$OEDQLDQJURXSVYRZHOQDVDOVRQRUDQW O¬QGLQ¬‘XQWLOOHGODQGIDOORZILHOGJUDVVODQG’Õ6ODY O?GLQDLG RUHQGL‘HTXLSPHQWXWHQVLOV’Õ6ODY RU_GÚMHLG SHQGDU‘ZDWFKPDQ’Õ6ODY S_GDUÚLG SRUHQG‘WKRUQKHGJH’Õ6ODY SRU?GÙ‘RUGHUURZ’ VHPE¬U ‘WZR SHDVDQWV XVLQJ WKH VDPH SDLU RI R[HQ RU KDYLQJ FRPPRQFDWWOH’Õ6ODY V?EUÙ‘QHLJKERUFRPUDGHSHDVDQW’ +RZHYHU WKLV VXEVWLWXWLRQ LV QRW GLUHFWO\ UHODWHG WR WKH FKURQRORJ\ RI ERUURZLQJ VLQFH LQ PDQ\ FRQWHPSRUDU\ 6RXWK 6ODYLF %XOJDULDQ 0DFHGRQLDQ GLDOHFWV VLPLODU UHIOH[HV DUH IRXQG $Q HDUO\ GDWH RI ERUURZLQJLVPRUHSUREDEOHZKHQWKHYRZHOLQ/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQLV
DRU X6XFKJURXSVPD\UHIOHFWHDUO\6ODYLFRU6RXWK6ODYLFJURXSV
RQRU ÙQFIWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV N¬QG~NDQG‘FRUQHUDQJOH’Õ6ODY N_WÙLG VXQGRM‘WRUXOH’Õ6ODY V_GLWL‘WRMXGJH’ WDQJ¬‘UHVHQWPHQWSUHMXGLFHGDPQDWLRQ’Õ6ODY W_JD‘JULHI’ ]KXPELQ¬‘JXP’Õ6ODY ]_ELQDLG 2WKHU FRQVLGHUDWLRQV WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI 6ODY ¨ SURYH WKDW WZR ZRUGVZLWKRUHSODFLQJ6ODY _PXVWEHTXLWHDUFKDLFFI SRURVLW‘WRRUGHUWRGHPDQG’Õ6ODY SRU_¨LWLLG VRGLW‘WRREVHUYH’Õ6ODY V_GLWL‘WRMXGJH’ FIVXQGRMDERYH
phonology
41
7ZR SRVLWLRQDO FKDQJHV LQ HDUO\ 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV GHVHUYH
VSHFLDODWWHQWLRQ
(YHQ WKRXJK ZH KDYH RQO\ RQH UHOLDEOH H[DPSOH WKHUH VHHPV WR EH D VSHFLDOWUHDWPHQWRILQLWLDOXZKLFKLVUHQGHUHGDVYR YREHNW¬‘SRRU’Õ6ODY XERJÙLG $OOJURXSVKDYLQJDVWUXFWXUH9Æ9\LHOGXD~ XH EXDOO~EXHOO‘EXIIDOR’Õ6ODY E\YROÙLG JDWXDM ~ JDWXHM ‘PDNH UHDG\ SUHSDUH’ Õ 6ODY JRWRYDWL JRWRYLWL ‘PDNHUHDG\SUHSDUH’ SDWNXD~SDWNXH‘KRUVHVKRH’Õ6ODY SRGÙNRYÙLG S¬UUXD~S¬UUXH‘EURRN ULYHUEHG’Õ6ODY SRURYÙ~ SDURYÙFI 3ROSDU²Z‘UDYLQH’QDPHRIDVRXUFHLQ*UHHFH2QTóDQX WRUXD~WRUXH‘WUDFH VHFUHWSDWK’Õ6ODYSO WRURYH‘SDWKVWUDFHV’ YDOONXD ~ YDOONXH ‘ILVKWUDS’ Õ 6ODY SO YRONRYH ‘REMHFWV WKDW FDQ EHGUDJJHGRUFDUULHGQHWV’ YLUXD ~ YLUXH ‘EURRN ULYXOHW’ Õ 6ODY SO YLURYH RI YLUÙ ‘ZKLUOSRROZDWHUSLW’ ,QRQHFDVHWKHVDPHGHYHORSPHQWLVDWWHVWHGIRUDJURXSZLWK MLQWKH PLGGOH ]DEXD~]DEXH‘OLQFKSLQ’Õ6ODY ]DERMÚ
6RQRUDQWV 7KHKDUPRQLRXVVWUXFWXUHRI,QGR(XURSHDQVRQRUDQWVZLWKWKHLU
RSSRVLWLRQ RI V\OODELF DQG DV\OODELF IXQFWLRQV KDG EHHQ FRPSOHWHO\ GHVWUR\HGDOUHDG\LQ(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQEHFDXVHRIWKHGHYHORSPHQW RIRULJLQDOV\OODELFVRQRUDQWV
6\OODELFVRQRUDQWV 7KHKLVWRU\RIV\OODELFVRQRUDQWVLQ$OEDQLDQLVUHODWLYHO\FOHDU EXWTXLWHFRQWUDGLFWRU\DVIDUDVWKHDUHDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRI$OEDQLDQDUH
42
chapter one
FRQFHUQHG,QLWVWUHDWPHQWRIQDVDODQG OLTXLG VRQRUDQWV $OEDQLDQ GLV SOD\VIHDWXUHVSURSHUWRWZRVHSDUDWHJURXSVRI,QGR(XURSHDQGLDOHFWV /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5$OE6W,,, !¬Q L55L `
3('(56(1.=;;;9, !L )$<,);;;,, FRQWUD 3('(56(1 -2./5HDOOH[9RUJHVFK, X55X ` /.8%$ LUXUIURP iUULIURP Ö !¬Q 6SUDFKH,; L5 5L `EXWDU ¹ 9$60(5$OE:RUWIRUVFK DQG ! D 0$11/DQJXDJH;9,, X55X ` !¬Q +LVW*U `!L5X5EXW5L5\EHIRUHODELDOV 1°!¬1~D1 %$5,C´ ,VW IROORZV9$60(5 Ç$%(-+\UMH !XQ 6W,,,,9 (DJDLQVW !UL .$/8ä6.$-$25(/$QWL¨EDON6%-D .RQWDNW\ WLPEUHLLQVKRUWDQGWLPEUHXLQORQJV\OODELF VRQRUDQWV IROORZ9$60(5
%RWK QDVDO VRQRUDQWV DQG \LHOGHG (3$ D 7KH ODWWHU ZDVSUHVHUYHGDV$OED&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV DYXOO‘VWHDP YDSRU’ (3$ DEXODFRQWLQXLQJ EK X OR FORVH WR 2+*QHEXO‘IRJ’26QLIRO *PF QHEXOD] JDW¬ ‘KHURQ’ (3$ JDW ,( ½KW D YDULDQW RI ,( ½KDQV ‘JRRVH’FI*PF JDQWD ,( ½KDQG JMDW¬‘ORQJ’ (3$ GODWD ,( GOJKWR ,( G ORQJKR LG /DW ORQJXV*RWKODJJV PDW‘EDQNVKRUH’ (3$ PDWD PWR /DWPAQV‘PRXQWDLQ’ VKWDW¬ ‘VHYHQ’ (3$ VHSWDWL GHULYHG IURP ,( VHSW LG 6NW VDSW¢*NG R VC/DWVHSWHP 7KH YRFDOL]DWLRQ RI QDVDO VRQRUDQWV SUHFHGHG WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI XQYRLFHGRFFOXVLYHVDIWHUVRQRUDQWVWR P E Q G Q J
,QVHYHUDOFDVHV(3$ D ,( ZDVUDLVHGWRHDVGHPRQ VWUDWHGE\WKHIROORZLQJZRUGV HSULYDWLYHSUHIL[‘QRQXQ’ LQHJM¬OO‘RQDQHPSW\VWRPDFK’DQG HV¬OOLG (3$ D ,( OHKW¬‘OLJKW DGM ’ 3$OE ODJD ,( OÞK 6NWUDJK·‘KDVWHQLQJ’ ODJK·‘OLJKW’*NGNCZWXLG/DWOHYLVLG WKHN ‘WR URDVW WR WRDVW EUHDG ’ (3$ WVDND ,( N FI *N MGIMGK RGKPC`^ MCIMQOGPJX EJTC`X VY`^ HQDY^ +HV RQNWMCIMJX‘EXUQLQJVWURQJO\’ +RP ]HW ‘WZHQW\’ (3$ Z GÊDW ,( ÆW LG 6NW YLayDW *N GKMQUK/DWYJLQW
phonology
43
7KH KLVWRU\ RI V\OODELF OLTXLG VRQRUDQWV LV H[WUHPHO\ FRP
SOLFDWHG $OUHDG\ LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKH\ KDG FKDQJHG WR IXOO\ YRFDOL]HGJURXSV ,( â!(3$ LODQG XODQG,( !(3$ LUDQG XU /DWHU LQ VRPH FDVHV WKH QHZ JURXSV ZHUH PHWDWKHVL]HG VHH EHORZ 7KHGLVWULEXWLRQEHWZHHQSDODWDODQGODELDOYDULDQWVKDVEHHQ FRQVLGHU DEO\ REVFXUHG E\ YDULRXV VHFRQGDU\ SURFHVVHV +RZHYHU VRPH LP SRUWDQWIDFWRUVWKDWLQIOXHQFHGWKHGLVWULEXWLRQEHWZHHQ L5RU X5FDQ EHHVWDEOLVKHG (3$ L5 DSSHDUV EHIRUH FRQVRQDQWDO FOXVWHUV DV LQ WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV ELU¬‘KROH’ (3$ ELUM ,( EKHU /DWIRUA‘WRERUHWRSLHUFH’ 2+*ERUAQLG GULWK¬ ‘JUDLQ’ (3$ GULWV ,( ½K]G ‘EDUOH\’ /DW KRUGHXP 2+*JHUVWD GULW¬‘OLJKWOXVWUHSXSLO RIDQH\H ’ (3$ GULNW ,( GHU‘WR ORRN’ GUL]¬‘EODFNWKRUQVORH’ (3$ GULG]M ,( GHU½K‘WRKROGWREH ILUP’ 6NW GK\DWL ‘WR EH ILUP’ 6ODY GÚUÊDWL WR KROG’
GÚU]MDWL DQG LQ SDUWLFXODU GÚU]D ! 5XVV GHUH]D ‘NLQG RI WKRUQ\SODQW’ JULM~JUîM‘WRFXWLQWRSLHFHVWRJQDZWRHDWDZD\’ (3$ JULQMD ,( ÞHU ‘WR VZDOORZ’ 6NW JLU¢WL $UP HNHU /DW YRUA /LWK JHUL¸J©UWL‘WRGULQN’6ODY ÊHUWL SLU¬‘SRUH’ (3$ SLUM *NRGKTY‘WRERUH’6ODY SHUM_LG UULV‘WRSXOOXSWRPRYHXSWRLQFUHDVHWRJURZ’ (3$ ZULWMD ,( ÆHUW ‘WR WXUQ’ 6NW YDUWDWH /DW YHUWA *RWK ZDLUÈDQ ‘WR EHFRPH’ VKWULM‘WRVSUHDGWRVWUHWFK’ (3$ VWULQMD 6NWVWQdWL‘WRVSUHDGWR VFDWWHU’*NUVQTPWOK‘WRVSUHDGWRVWUHWFK’/DWVWHUQALG 7KHVDPHUXOHDSSOLHVWRWZRZRUGVZLWKDVHFRQGDU\GHYHORSPHQWRIL LQWRH VHHDOVREHORZ JUHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH’ (3$ JULWO /LWK JXUNOmV ‘FURS’ 23UXV JXUFOH ‘WKURDW’ 6ODY JÙUGOR LG FI DOVR ÊHUGOR ‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’ JUHU¬~JUHQ]¬‘ZDVSKRUQHW’ JULVQ /DWFUEUA‘KRUQHW’2+* KRUQDfLG/LWKhLUhX¶LG6ODY VÚUhHQÚLG
chapter one
44
(3$ L5 DOVR UHIOHFWV ,QGR(XURSHDQ OLTXLG VRQRUDQWV ZKHQ IROORZHGE\ LRU LQWKHQH[WV\OODEOH
ELUT ‘KHDS KHDS RI VDQG VDQGGXQH’ (3$ ELUNL 6ODY EÙUNÙ ‘PRXVWDFKHKDLUWUXQN’ NULPE ~ NU\P ‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULP ZLWK XQH[SODLQHG *HJ \ ,( áPLLG 6NWN¤PL/LWKN®UPLV UL‘QHZ\RXQJUHFHQW’ (3$ ULMDGHULYDWLYHRI,( HU~ RU‘WR ULVHWRPDNHPRYH’FI21_UU‘TXLFN’26DUXLG UULPH‘UDLQZRUP’ (3$ ZULPL ,( ÆPL ÆPR‘ZRUP’ /DW YHUPLVLG*RWKZD·UPV‘ZRUPVQDNH’/LWKYD¼PDV‘LQVHFW’ 7KHUHDUHVRPHFDVHVLQZKLFKWKHUHDUHQRREYLRXVWUDFHVRI L UULE¬‘JDOHZLQGZDWHUIDOOWRUUHQW’ (3$ ZULE L ,( ÆHUE K ‘WRWXUQWREHQG’ WKLUU‘VRRW’GHULYHGIURP(3$ WVLUZ L /LWKhL¼YDV‘JUD\’
,Q DOO RWKHU SRVLWLRQV ,QGR(XURSHDQ OLTXLG VRQRUDQWV \LHOGHG (3$ X5
JUXU¬ ~ JUXQ¬ ‘ZKHDW’ (3$ JUXQ ,( ½¹QRP ‘JUDLQ’ /DW JUQXP2,UJU¢Q*RWKNDXUQ/LWKÊ®UQLV6ODY ]ÚUQR NXOS¬U ~ NXOS¬Q ‘LY\ FOHPDWLV’ (3$ NXOSD /LWK N®OSD ‘ORRS’ /DWYFLËSDLG KXGK¬U‘JDUOLF’ (3$ VNXUG *NUMQTQFQPLG PXUJ ‘GDUN JUH\’ (3$ PXUJD /LWK P¢UJDV ‘PXOWLFRORUHG’ PLUJ·RWL ‘WR VSDUNOH WR VKLQH’ /DWY PLUJD ‘JOHDP’ P¸UJV ‘IDQWDVWLFLPDJH’ QGXONHP‘WRULSHQ’ (3$ HQWXOND /LWKWHONL¸WHËNWL‘WRJDWKHUWR EULQJWRJHWKHU’6ODY WHONWL‘WREHDWWRSRXQG’ XMN‘ZROI’ (3$ Z XOND ,( ÆâáRVLG 6NWY¤ND*NNWMQX/DW OXSXV*RWKZXOIV XO]¬‘NLQGRIPDSOH’GHULYHGIURP(3$ XOPD ,( âPR‘HOP’ /DW XOPXV21DOPU2,UOHP
,QIRXUFDVHVWKHLLQULKDVEHHQUHSODFHGE\H JUHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH’ (3$ JULWO /LWK JXUNOmV ‘FURS’ 23UXV JXUFOH ‘WKURDW’ 6ODY JÙUGOR LG FI DOVR ÊHUGOR ‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’
phonology
45
JUHU¬~JUHQ]¬‘ZDVSKRUQHW’ (3$ JULVQ /DWFUEUA‘KRUQHW’ 2+*KRUQDfLG/LWKhLUhX¶LG6ODY VÚUhHQÚLG GUHJ¬ ‘VFDE’ (3$ GULJ :HVW *PF WDUJMDQ ‘WR SXOO WR VWLU’ 6ODY GÚUJDWL‘WRSXOOWRWXJ’/LWKG®UJLQWL‘WRPRYHWRLUULWDWH’ GUHN¬‘OXQFKGLQQHUPLGGD\PHDO’ (3$ GULN ,( GáFORVH WR%UHWGLEUL‘OXQFK’2%UHWGLSULP‘WRHDW’ 7KHSKRQHWLFFRQGLWLRQVRIWKLVFKDQJHUHPDLQXQFHUWDLQ ,Q KDOI RI WKH NQRZQ ZRUGV UHIOHFWLQJ ,QGR(XURSHDQ OLTXLG VRQRUDQWVWKHUHVXOWLQJ(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQJURXSVZHUHPHWDWKHVL]HG H[FHSW IRU (3$ LO 7KHUH LV QR GHILQLWH SKRQHWLF IDFWRU ZKLFK FDQ H[SODLQ WKLV SKHQRPHQRQ 7KH VLWXDWLRQ LV LOOXVWUDWHG E\ WKH IROORZLQJ FRQWUDVWLYHSDLUV LU ~ UL WKLUU‘VRRW’ (3$ WVLUZL /LWKhL¼YDV‘JUD\’ WULP‘KHUREUDYHFRXUDJHRXV’ (3$ WULPD ,( WPRFI$UP DUP‘\RXQJIUHVKJUHHQ’ XU~UX SXUWK ‘GLDUUKRHD’ GHULYHG IURP (3$ SXUZD /LWK SX¼YDV ‘ILOWK GLUW’/DWYS¸UYV‘VZDPSPDUVK’ EUXP¬ ‘GRXJK’ (3$ EUXPD *PF EDUPD ‘\HDVW’ DQG /DW IHUPHQWXP‘OHDYHQ\HDVW’ XO~ OX NXOS¬U ~ NXOS¬Q ‘LY\ FOHPDWLV’ (3$ NXOSD /LWK N®OSD ‘ORRS’ /DWYFLËSDLG JMXK¬ ‘WRQJXH ODQJXDJH’ (3$ JOX[ WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ GLDOHFWDOZRUGIRU‘VRXQG’ JROVR 21NDOO‘VKRXW’/LWKJDËVDV ‘HFKR’6ODY JROVÙ‘YRLFH’
$V\OODELFVRQRUDQWV $V\OODELF VRQRUDQWV ZHUH ZHOO SUHVHUYHG LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKRXJKVRPHRIWKHPXQGHUZHQWVHULRXVFKDQJHVGXULQJODWHUVWDJHVRI SKRQHWLFGHYHORSPHQW)RUSRVLWLRQDOFKDQJHVRIDV\OODELFVRQRUDQWVVHH
46
chapter one /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 $OE 6W ,,, :(,*$1' %$ ,,, 5XPDQLDQ UKRWDFLVP UHVXOWLQJ IURP $OEDQLDQ LQIOXHQFH 3 ('(56(1 %86K7;,9 P!PE +$03.=/;;9, Ö!UHEHIRUH ORQJ /;;9,, VDPH ,) /;9, 0$11 /DQ JXDJH ;9,, 0,16+$// /DQJXDJH ;;;,, GHYHORS PHQWRI LQFOXVWHUVZLWKODU\QJHDOVLQ$OEDQLDQ Ç$%(-%6KN6K, ,( ! $OE ] ;9 H[SUHVVLYH UU U =I3KRQHWLN ,; RQ,( LQ$OEDQLDQ 56KN FOXVWHUPE
P 6W ,,, 25(/ )/+ 9,,, ,( LQ $OEDQLDQ
,( UHPDLQHG XQFKDQJHG LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ IRU ZKLFK ZHUHFRQVWUXFW(3$ M+RZHYHULWVIXUWKHUKLVWRU\LVTXLWHFRPSOLFDWHG ,QPRVWFDVHV EHIRUH(3$ D HDQG A LW\LHOGHGJMLQDQODXWDVFRU URERUDWHGE\VHYHUDOUHOLDEOHH[DPSOHV JMHP‘EULGOH’ (3$ MHPD 6NW\¢PDLG JMHU ‘WLOO’ (3$ D MHUL *N J?TK J?GTK ‘HDUO\’ IXUWKHU UHODWHU WR *PF DLUL]‘EHIRUHHUH’ *RWKDLU21¢U DQG$YD\DU‘GD\’ JMHVK‘WRNQHDG’ (3$ MHVMD 6NW\¢V\DWL‘WRERLO’*N\GY‘WRERLO WRFRRN’ JM¬U‘VRXS’ 7RVN (3$ MDXVQD 6NWQHXW\ ¿‘VRXS’/DWL VLG /LWKMgh^‘ILVKVRXS’ JMXDM~JMXHM‘WRKXQW’ (3$ MAJQMD 2+*MDJAQ‘WRKXQW’ QJMHVK‘WRJLUG’ (3$ HQMAhD $Y\vKD\HLWLLG*N\YPPWOKLG /LWK M·RVWL LG 6ODY MDVDWL ‘WR WHDU FORWKHV’ ‘WR WHDU LQWR EDQGV’ SRMDVÙ‘EHOW’ %HIRUH(3$ DQG X(3$ MZDVSUHVHUYHGDV$OEM DMR‘VKH WKDW’ (3$ DM ,( LGIHPVJRI R MRVK‘WRFXUOWRIRQGOHWRFDUHVV’ (3$ MXGVMD ,( HXGK 6NW \·GK\DWH‘WRILJKWWRVWUXJJOH’7RFK$\XWN‘WRWDNHFDUHRIWR WURXEOHDERXW’/LWKM¢XGLQWL‘WRH[FLWHWRDURXVH’ MX‘\RX’ (3$ MX ZLWKVHFRQGDU\VKRUW X /LWKM
VLG*RWKMXV LG*NWOGK`XLG6NWDFF\X¿PdQLG
,QWKHLQODXW(3$ MZDVORVWDIWHUIURQWYRZHOVFIWKHIROORZ LQJH[DPSOHV GL‘WRNQRZ’ (3$ GMD ,( GKHi 6NWGK\WLGK\\DWL‘WRRE VHUYHWRIHHOWRWKLQN’$YG LL ‘WRVHH’ IOH~IOHl ‘WRVOHHS’ (3$ DZDOHMD 6ODY OpM_ OpMDWL‘WRGR]HWR VOXPEHU’
phonology
47
UL‘QHZ\RXQJUHFHQW’ (3$ ULMDGHULYDWLYHRI,( HU~ RU‘WR ULVHWRPDNHPRYH’FI21_UU‘TXLFN’26DUXLG VKL ‘UDLQ’ (3$ V MD ZLWK LUUHJXODU GHYHORSPHQW RI WKH LQLWLDO
V ,( V ‘UDLQ WR UDLQ’ *N WGK 7RFK $ VZDVH 7RFK % VZHVH‘UDLQ’V ‘WRUDLQ’23UXVVXJH‘UDLQ’ >V M@
$IWHU DOO RWKHU YRZHOV PHGLDO M JDYH $OE K *HJ I LQ WKH DXVODXWRIPRVWYHUEV EDKH‘VOLQJ’ (3$ EDMHW\PRORJLFDOO\FORVHWR6ODY ERMÚ‘ILJKW’ WR,( EKHL‘WRVWULNHWREHDW’ IWRK ~ IWRI ‘WR FRRO WR PDNH FROG’ (3$ DZDWMD ,( W ‘WR PHOW’ 6ODY WDM_ WDMDWL2VVHWWDM\Q QJURK‘WRZDUP’ (3$ HQJUMD 6ODY JUpM_ JUpWLLG SDK ‘VFDE GXVW’ (3$ SDXMD ,( SHX ‘WR EORZ XS’ FI LQ SDUWLFXODU$UPKRJL‘EUHDWK’ ,( SRÆR VKWURK¬~VKWURI¬‘NHQQHO’ (3$ VWUM /DWYVWUDMD‘VWDOOFRYHUHG ZLWKVWUDZ’6ODY VWURMÚ‘FRQVWUXFWLRQ’ YHKWH‘VHOI’ (3$ VZDMD ZLWKDVHFRQGDU\VXIIL[W ,( VÆRRV ‘RZQ’ 6ODY VYRMÚ23UXVVZDLV $QLPSRUWDQWH[FHSWLRQFRXOGEHSUHVHQWHGE\DQHZHW\PRORJ\RIWKH IROORZLQJZRUG '(0,5$-$( GHM‘WKH GD\ DIWHU WRPRUURZ’ (3$ GDMDXFRQWLQXLQJ ,( ORF GXDO
GÆRRXV +RZHYHU D EHWWHU H[SODQDWLRQ FDQ EH JLYHQ LQWHUSUHWLQJ GHM DV (3$
GHMZHL GHÆHLZLWKDVSHFLILFGHYHORSPHQWRIWKHFOXVWHU Æ
,( Æ JDYH Z LQ (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,Q DQODXW WKLV VRXQG \LHOGHG$OEY YHU¬ ~ YHQ¬ I ‘ZLQH’ (3$ ZDLQ FRJQDWH ZLWK *N QKPJ ‘YLQH’ QK?PQX‘ZLQH’/DWYQXP‘ZLQH’$UPJLQLLG YHVK ‘WR SXW RQ FORWKHV ’ (3$ ZHVMD ,( ÆHV 6NW Y¢VWH ‘WR ZHDUWREHGUHVVHGLQ’*NGPPWOK‘WRGUHVV’ YMHGK ‘WR VWHDO’ (3$ ZHG]D ,( ÆH½K 6NW Y¢KDWL ‘WR GULYH’ /DWYHKA‘WREHDUWRFDUU\’*RWKJDZLJDQ‘WRVWHDO’ YMHO‘WRSOXFN IUXLW WRYLQWDJH’ (3$ ZHOD *NGKNY‘WRVKXWLQ WRSUHVV’/LWKVXYDOØWL‘WRKDUYHVWWRUHDS’ YMHOO‘WRYRPLW’ (3$ ZHOZD /DWYROYA‘WRWXUQ’ YMHUU ‘WR KDQJ’ (3$ ZHUD *N CGKTY ‘WR UDLVH XS’ /LWK YHUL¸ Y©UWL‘WRZHLJK’VYHUL¸VYH¼WL‘WRRSHQWRWKUHDG’
chapter one
48
,QDQODXW,( ÆR!(3$ ZDEHFRPHVX XGK¬ ‘ZD\’ (3$ ZDGD ,( ÆHGK ‘WR EHDW WR EUHDN’ FI 6ODY
WUHSDWL‘WREHDW’~ WURSD‘SDWK’ RU,( ÆH½K‘ZD\’ XO‘WRORZHU’ (3$ ZDOD ,( ÆHO *NGKNY‘WRVKXWLQWRSUHVV’ /LWKYDOØWL‘WRFOHDQ’LhYDOØWL‘WRFDUU\DZD\’ XQD]¬ ‘ILQJHUULQJ VPDOO LURQ ULQJ’ GHULYHG IURP (3$ ZDQG $UPJLQG‘ULQJ’*RWKELZLQGDQ‘WRXQZUHDWKH’ XU¬‘EULGJH’ (3$ ZDU 21Y_U‘URZRIVWRQHV’YHU‘GDP’2VF YHUX‘GRRU’ XU¬‘EXUQLQJORJ’ (3$ ZDU $UPYDàHP‘WRNLQGOH ILUH ’+LWW ÆDU‘WREXUQ’ XUL~ û‘KXQJHU’ (3$ ZDQD ,( ÆHQ‘WRZDQWWRGHVLUH’ 6NW Y¢QDWLYDQ²WLLG/DWYHQXV‘ORYH’
7KH GHYHORSPHQW RI ,( Æ VXUURXQGHG E\ ORQJ YRZHOV RU GLSKWKRQJV KDV EHHQ GHVFULEHG DERYH VHH :KHQ SUHFHGHG E\ VKRUW(3$ D ZZDVSUHVHUYHGDV$OEY DY¬U‘LFHIORH’ (3$ DZHUD ,( DÆHU DÆHG‘WRPDNHZHW’ JUDY¬ ‘FDYH GHQ ODLU’ (3$ JUDYL /LWK JULRY£ /DWY JUDYD ‘UDYLQHSUHFLSLWRXVYDOOH\’23UXVJUDXZXV‘VLGH’ YUDV‘WRNLOO’ (3$ DZDUDXWMDGHULYHGIURP,( UHX‘WRWHDUWRGH VWUR\’ 6NWUXW¢‘EURNHQ’/DWUXA‘WRIDOOGRZQWRUXVKGRZQ’ %HIRUH XQYRLFHG VWRSV DZD LV DWWHVWHG DV I %\ DQDORJ\ LW DOVR DVVXPHVWKLVIRUPLQFHUWDLQZRUGVEHIRUHVRQRUDQWV IODN ‘WR WKURZ WR IOLQJ’ (3$ DZDODND GHULYHG IURP ,( ON
OiNWREHQGWRMXPS’ 0+*OHFNHQ‘WRWKURZEDFNWRVSULQJ’ /LWKOHNL¸O|NWL‘WRIO\’/DWYOªNW‘WRVSULQJWRMXPS’ ,QRWKHUFDVHV ZZDVORVW GUX ~ GUû ‘WUHH ZRRG’ (3$ GUXZD 6ODY GUÙYR ‘ZRRG’ 6NW GUXLG$YGUXLG*NFTW`X‘WUHHRDN’ NUL ~ NUî ‘ZRRGZRUP PRWK’ (3$ NULZL ,( áÆL 6ODY
¨ÚUYÚ‘ZRUP’ YH ‘ZLGRZ’ (3$ ZLGHZ 6NW YLGK¢Y LG /DW YLGXD LG *RWK ZLGXZRLG
,( PZDVSUHVHUYHGDV(3$ P!$OEPLQDOOSRVLWLRQV GHP ‘\RXQJ EXOO’ (3$ GDPD 2,U GDP ‘R[’ DQG *N FCOCNQX ‘FDOI’
phonology
49
GLP¬U‘ZLQWHU’ (3$ GHLPHQD ,( ½KHLPHQLG 6NWKHPDQORF ‘LQZLQWHU’*NZGK`OC‘ZLQWHU’ PDUGK¬‘FKLOOIURVWLFH’ (3$ PDUG] 6ODY PRU]Ù‘IURVW’ PL ‘PRXVH’ (3$ P V ,( P V LG 6NW Pg¿ *N OW`X /DW P V PRW¬U‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU‘PRWKHU’ 6NWPW¢U*N OJVJT/DWPWHU PXW‘H[FUHPHQW’ (3$ PXNWD 6NWPXNW¢‘UHOHDVHG’IXUWKHUFI 6NWPX±F¢WL‘WRORRVHWRIUHH’/LWKP¸NWL‘WRJHWIUHHWRIOHH’ $WWKHHQGRIWKHZRUG PRFFDVLRQDOO\EHFRPHVPE NULPE ~ NU\P ‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULP ZLWK XQH[SODLQHG *HJ \ ,( áPLLG 6NWN¤PL/LWKN®UPLV VKNUXPE‘EODFNDVKHVDQ\WKLQJEXUQHGWRDVKHV’ (3$ LhNUXPD ,( NUHP /DWFUHPA‘WREXUQ’ WUHPE‘WRIULJKWHQ’ (3$ WUHPD 7RFK$W¥UP‘WRJHWDQJU\’*N VTGOY‘WRWUHPEOH IURPIHDU ’/DWWUHPALG
,( Q ZDV SUHVHUYHG DV (3$ Q ,Q DQODXW LW LV FRQWLQXHG E\ $OEQ
QDW¬ ‘QLJKW’ (3$ QDNWL FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR ,( QRNÆW LG 6NW Q¢NW*NPWE/DWQR[ QH‘ZH’ (3$ QA V 6NWQDV$YQA/DWQAVLG QHV¬U ‘WRPRUURZ’ (3$ QDWhAU ,( QRNÆWAU : QHLWKLZU QHLWKZ\U‘ODVWQLJKW’%UHWQHL]œUQHL]ºULG Q¬P¬ ~ QDP¬ ‘FXUVH’ (3$ QDP ,( QHP *N PGOY ‘WR GLVWULEXWH’FIPGOGUKX‘ZUDWK’*RWKQLPDQ‘WRWDNH’ Q¬QW¬~QDQG‘QLQH’ (3$ QHXQWL ZLWKDQDORJLFDOFKDQJHRI QW LQ7RVN ,( QHÆLG 6NWQ¢YD/DWQRYHP*RWKQLXQ QXN ‘QRW’ (3$ QXND FRPSRVHG RI QX ,( QHFRORUHG E\ WKH IROORZLQJODELRYHODUDQG ND áRDSURQRPLQDOVWHP
%HWZHHQ WZR YRZHOV (3$ Q ZDV SUHVHUYHG LQ *HJ DV Q EXW FKDQJHG WR 7RVN U 7KLV SURFHVV LV NQRZQ DV 7RVN UKRWDFLVP $V GHPRQVWUDWHG E\ /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV UHIOHFWLQJ WKH VDPH SURFHVV LW WRRN SODFHDIWHUXQVWUHVVHGYRZHOV GLP¬U‘ZLQWHU’ (3$ GHLPHQD ,( ½KHLPHQLG 6NWKHPDQORF ‘LQZLQWHU’*NZGK`OC‘ZLQWHU’ JMDUS¬U ~ JMDUS¬Q ‘VQDNH’ (3$ VHUSHQD ,( VHUS ‘WR FUDZO’ /DWVHUSQV‘VQDNHVHUSHQW’VHUSA‘WRFUDZO’ JMHU¬~JMDQ¬‘EURDGZLGH’ (3$ VDLQD ,( VL‘ORQJODWH’ 2( VG ‘ORQJ ZLGH’ *RWK VHLÈXV ‘ODWH’ 2,U VWK ‘ORQJ’ /DW VHUXV ‘ODWH’
chapter one
50
OO¬U¬ ~ OODQ¬ ‘IRUHDUP HOO’ (3$ DOHQ *N YNGPJ ‘HOERZ’ /DW XOQD2+*HOLQD WK¬UL~WK¬QL‘ORXVH’ (3$ WVDQLG *NMQPKX‘QLW’2+*KQL]LG YHU¬ ~ YHQ¬ I ‘ZLQH’ (3$ ZDLQ FRJQDWH ZLWK *N QKPJ ‘YLQH’ QK?PQX‘ZLQH’/DWYQXP‘ZLQH’$UPJLQLLG $IWHUVWUHVVHGYRZHOV QZDVORVWLQ/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQ EOL~EOî‘OLQGHQ’ (3$ EOLQL /LWKEOLQG®VEOHQG®V‘6DOL[FDSUHD’ GUH~GUê‘GHHU’ (3$ GUDQL CTCPKX>IRUFT@ GNCHQX JML~JMî‘EUHDVWFKHVW’ (3$ VLQD /DWVLQXV‘FXUYHIROG’ JMX ~ JMû ‘NQHH’ (3$ JOXQD GLVVLPLODWHG IURP J D QXQD ,( ½HQXLG +LWWJQX6NWMdQX*NIQPW/DWJHQ KX~Kû‘SLFNHWVWDNHSROHSHQLV’ (3$ VNXQDUHSODFLQJHDUOLHU
VNXMD 6ODY [XMÚ‘SHQLV’ WUX ~ WUû ‘EUDLQ’ (3$ WDUXQD 6NW W¢UXoD ‘\RXQJ WHQGHU’ $Y WDXUXQD ‘\RXQJ’ FI DOVR *N VGTJP ‘WHQGHU’ VGTW CUSGPGX NGRVQP +HV
,( O\LHOGHG(3$ O7KHODWWHULVQRUPDOO\SUHVHUYHGDV$OEO LQDQODXW
ODVKW¬ ‘ROG HDUO\ SUHPDWXUH RI IUXLW ’ (3$ ODXVWD *RWK ODXV ‘HPSW\ORRVH’ OHGK‘PXGDOOXYLXPFOD\ ZDOOHDUWKPRXQG ULYHUPRXWKEDON’ (3$ ODLGD 23UXVOD\GLV‘FOD\’ O¬~ODˆ‘WROHW’ (3$ ODLGQD /LWKO©LVWLLG/DWYODîVWLG ORGK‘WRWLUHWRZHDU\’ (3$ ODGD *RWKOHWDQ‘WROHW’*NNJFGK`P MQRKC`PMGMOJMGPCK +HV DQGWKHOLNH OXJ ‘WURXJK ZDWHUWURXJK ORQJ JXWWHU SLSH’ (3$ OXJD 6ODY
OÙJD‘VSRRQEODGH’ OÙÊLFDLG OXV‘WRSUD\WRLQYRNHWREHJ’ (3$ OXJWMD /LWKO J²WL‘WRDVNWR SUD\’/DWYO¸G]XO¸JW‘WRDVNWRLQYLWH’2+*ORFNAQ‘WROXUH WRHQWLFH’ ,QDIHZFDVHV EHORQJLQJWRWKHH[SUHVVLYHYRFDEXODU\ ZHILQGLQLWLDO OO OOXN¬‘IRXOHJJ’ (3$ OXN ,( OHX i ‘GLUW’ OOXS‘WRJXOSGRZQWRVZDOORZ’ (3$ OXSD 6NWOXPS¢WL‘WREUHDN WR LQMXUH’ /LWK O¸SWL ‘WR SHHO’ /DWY OXSW ‘WR SHHO WR HDW’ 6ODY
OXSLWL‘WRSHHO’ ,QRQHZRUGLQLWLDOOOUHPDLQVXQH[SODLQHG
phonology
51
OO¬U¬ ~ OODQ¬ ‘IRUHDUP HOO’ (3$ DOHQ *N YNGPJ ‘HOERZ’ /DW XOQD2+*HOLQD
%HWZHHQWZRYRZHOV(3$ ORULJLQDOO\\LHOGHG$OEOO EDOO¬‘IRUHKHDG’ (3$ EDO 6NWEKODLG23UXVEDOORLG GKDOO¬‘EXWWHUPLON’ (3$ G]DO *NICNCLG KHOO‘VSHDUVSLW’ (3$ VNAOD *NUMY`NQX‘SRLQWHGVWDNHWKRUQ’ P¬OOHQM¬ ‘EODFNELUG’ (3$ PHODQM ,( IHP DGM PHOiQ ‘EODFN’ *NOGNCKPCLGFIDOVR6NWPDOLQ¢IHPPDOLQ‘GLUW\ XQFOHDQ/DWYP?ËQV‘EODFN’ VMHOO ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ WhHOD ,( NÆHO 6NW F¢UDWL ‘WR PRYH WR ZDON’*NRGNY‘WRFRPHLQWRH[LVWHQFHWREHFRPH’/DWFROA ‘WRFXOWLYDWHWRWLOO’ Y¬OOD‘EURWKHU’ (3$ VZHODXGFRPSRVLWHRISURQRPLQDO,( VÆH DQG ODXG ,( OHXGK 2+*OLXW‘SHRSOH’6ODY OMXGÙLG /DWHUGXHWRLQWHUGLDOHFWDOLQIOXHQFHVDQGYDULRXVDQDORJLFDOSURFHVVHV LWZDVVRPHWLPHVUHSODFHGE\O EDO ‘GRJ ZLWK D ZKLWH VSRW RQ LWV IRUHKHDG ZKLWHKDLUHG’ (3$ EDOD FORVH WR /LWK E¦ODV ‘ZKLWH’ /DWY E£OV ‘SDOH’ *N HCNQX NGWMQX +HV SHO¬‘PDUH’ (3$ SAXO *NRY`NQX‘IRDO’*RWKIXODLG ,Q /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LQWHUYRFDOLF O FKDQJHG WR M LI IROORZHG E\ D IURQW YRZHO RQO\ L" 7KLV SKRQHWLF FRQWH[W W\SLFDOO\ LV UHSHDWHG LQ SOXUDOVRIPDVFXOLQHQRXQV HQGLQJLQ(3$ DL!/3$ L ZLWKDVWHP HQGLQJLQOOFIIRUH[DPSOH DYXOO SO DYXM‘VWHDPYDSRU’ EXDOO~EXHOO SOEXDM~EXHM‘EXIIDOR’ GHOO SOGHM‘WHQGRQ’ GLHOO SOGLHM‘VXQ’ HKXOO SOHKXM‘LFLFOH’ Q\HOO SOQ\HM‘DQNOHJQDUONQRW’ ,QDIHZQRXQVOOZDV UHVWRUHG LQ WKH SOXUDO DV D UHVXOW RI DQDORJ\ DQG FKDQJHVLQGHFOHQVLRQW\SH KLV¬OO~KîV¬OO SOKLV¬OOD~KîV¬OOD‘EXUQLQJQHWWOH’ N¬VKLOO SON¬VKLOOD‘FRXQFLO’ QGU\VKNXOO SOQGU\VKNXOOD‘ERLODEVFHVV’
52
chapter one
,QIHPLQLQHQRXQVZKHUHWKHSOXUDOZDVIRUPHGE\WKH(3$HQGLQJ V !/3$ DILQDOOOZDVSUHVHUYHG EUXVKWXOO SOEUXVKWXOOD‘KHDWKHU’ NRUEXOO SONRUEXOOD‘NHJFDVNZRRGHQSDLO’ PMHJXOO SOPMHJXOOD‘FORXG’ PRGKXOO SOPRGKXOOD‘YHWFKFKLFNOLQJFKLFNSHD’ QGULNXOO SOQGULNXOOD‘JRGPRWKHU PLGZLIH’ QRIXOO SOQRIXOOD‘MDZMDZERQHFKHHNERQH’ (3$ ODOVRJLYHV$OEOLQFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV XQOHVVWKH\GHYHORSDV GHVFULEHGLQSDVVLP EOHUW¬ ‘JUHHQ’ (3$ EOAUD ,( EKOAURV /DW IOAUXV ‘VKLQLQJ EULJKW’2,UEO¢U‘JUD\’:EODZULG HOE‘EDUOH\’ (3$ DOEL *NCNHK‘NLQGRIJUDLQ’ ¬PE¬O~DPE¬O‘VZHHW’ (3$ DPOD 6NWDPO¢‘VRXU’ JMDOS¬‘EXWWHU’ (3$ VHOSL 6NWVDUSª‘FODULILHGEXWWHU’ EXWFI*N GNRQX GNCKQPUVGCTGWSJPKC +HV 2+*VDOED‘RLQWPHQW’ PMDOW¬‘KRQH\’ (3$ PHOLWD ,( PHOLWLG +LWWPLOLW*NOGNK *RWKPLOLÈLG
,( UGLGQRWFKDQJHLQ(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ,QDOOSRVLWLRQV (3$ U LV UHIOHFWHG DV $OE U RU DV $OE UU ,Q FRQVRQDQWDO FOXVWHUV ZH QRUPDOO\ILQGU EU\GK ‘ZHDN SOLDQW PLOG’ (3$ EU G]D /DW IU [ ‘IUXLW’ *RWK EUXNMDQ‘WRXVH’ çDQG¬U‘SURSVXSSRUW’ (3$ hWhHQWUD ,( HQWURP *NMGPVTQP ‘JRDGVSXU’FIDOVR/DWYVWV‘VSHDUODQFH’ %DOW hLQWDV GUX‘WUHH ZRRG’ (3$ GUXZD ,( GUXLG 6ODY GUÙYR‘ZRRG’ 6NWGUXLG$YGUXLG*NFTW`X‘WUHHRDN’ GK¬QG¬U ~ GKDQG¬U ‘EULGHJURR~ VRQLQODZ’ (3$ G]DQUD ,( ½HQiU‘VRQLQODZ’ /DWJHQHU NUHGK‘WR SOXQJH WR LPPHUVH WR VWHHS WR VPRWKHU WR EHVSDWWHU’ (3$ NUAGD 6ODY NUDG_ NUDVWL ‘WR VWHDO’ UHIO NUDG_ V?
NUDVWLV?‘WRVQHDNWRVWHDOXSWRDSSURDFKXQQRWLFHG’ SMHUGK ‘WR IDUW’ (3$ SHUGD ,( SHUG LG 6NW S¢UGDWH *N RGTFQOCK2+*IHU]DQ/LWKS©UGÊLXS©UVWL
7KH GLVWULEXWLRQ RI WKH WZR UHIOH[HV U DQG UU UHPDLQV XQ NQRZQ:RUGVZLWKUUDUHVRPHZKDWPRUHQXPHURXV
EDUU¬‘ORDGEXUGHQ’ (3$ EDU *NHQTC‘ORDG’
phonology
53
KLUU¬‘ZKH\’ (3$ NVLU 6NWN¿U¢‘PLON’2VVHWæ[hLULG N¬UU‘GRQNH\DVVIRDO JUD\’ (3$ NDUD 6NWNK¢UD‘GRQNH\’$Y [DUALG6F\WK [DUD2VVHW[æUæJLG UUHN ‘WR VWUDLQ WR ERWKHU’ (3$ UDLND /LWK UHLN£ ‘QHHG QHFHVVLW\’UHæNWL‘WREHQHFHVVDU\’IXUWKHUH[SODLQHGLQ UUMHGK‘WRIORZ’ (3$ UHG]D /DWULJUH‘WRZHWWRPRLVWHQ’21 UDNL‘ZHWQHVV’ YMHK¬UU ‘PRWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZH[XU ZLWK DVVLPLODWLRQ IURP H[SHFWHG VZHWVXU ,( VÆHU 6NWyYDyUgPRWKHULQODZ’ /DWVRFUXVLG ([DPSOHVRI(3$ U!$OEUDUHDOVRUDWKHUFRPPRQ DU¬‘ILHOG’ (3$ DU /DWYDˆUDLG+LWWDUD‘ERUGHUDUHD’/\G DDUD‘IDUPVWHDGODQG’0HVVDUDQ EDU ‘JUDVV’ (3$ EDUD /DW IDU ‘VRUW RI JUDLQ VSHOW’ 21 EDUU ‘VSHOW’ IDU¬ ‘VHHG VHPHQ NLQ’ (3$ VSDU ,( VSHU *N IHP URQTC ‘VHHG’URGKTY‘WRVSLOOWRVRZ’URGTOC‘VHPHQVHHG‘ PLU¬ ‘JRRG’ (3$ PLUD IRUPLQJ D VHSDUDWH LVRJORVV ZLWK 6ODY
PLUÙ IXUWKHUWR,( PL P‘PLOGZHDNQLFH’ UMHS‘WRVWULSRII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’ (3$ UHSD ,( UHS *NGTGRVQOCK‘WRHDW’/DWUDSLA‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’/LWKU{SWL ‘WRJUDVS’ WMHW¬U‘RWKHU’ (3$ HWHUD 6ODY HWHUÙ‘VRPHVRPHERG\’
,Q WKH ILQDO SRVLWLRQ DIWHU H (3$ U ZDV UHJXODUO\ ORVW DV GHPRQVWUDWHGE\WKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV
ELH ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ EHUD ,( EKHU ‘WR EULQJ WR FDUU\’ 6NW EK¢UDWL*NHGTY VKWLH‘WRSRXULQWRSXW LQ WR WKURZ’ (3$ VWHUD 6NWVWodWL ‘WR VSUHDG WR VFDWWHU’ *N UVQTPWOK ‘WR VWUHWFK WR VSUHDG’ /DW VWHUQA‘WRVSUHDG’6ODY VWÚU_ VWHUWLLG ]LH‘WRERLOWRFRRN’LG (3$ GÊHUD ,( ÞKHU *NSGTQOCK‘WR EHFRPHKRWWRZDUPWREXUQ’2,UIRJHLU‘ KH ZDUPV’ +RZHYHUUZDVDQDORJLFDOO\UHVWRUHGLQVHYHUDOYHUEVDVLQWKHIROORZ LQJFDVHV çMHUU ‘WR WHDU XS’ (3$ hWhHUD 2,U VFDUDLP ‘WR VHSDUDWH’ 21 VNHUD‘WRFXW’/LWKVNLUL¸VN®UWL‘WRVHSDUDWH’ GMHUU ‘WR GHVWUR\’ (3$ GHUD 6NW GodWL ‘WR EXUVW WR WHDU’ *N FGTY‘WRVNLQ’*RWKJDWDLUDQ‘WRWHDU’
chapter one
54
$V\OODELFVRQRUDQWVLQORDQZRUGV Greek borrowings contain only marginal information on the development of asyllabic sonorants. At the same time, Latin and early Slavic loanwords are rich with phonetically representative material which adds to our understanding of the Proto-Albanian development. )RU SRVLWLRQDOFKDQJHVRIDV\OODELFVRQRUDQWVLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGVVHH ,QWKHEHJLQQLQJRIDZRUG/DWMLVUHQGHUHGDV$OEJM&IWKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV
JMXYHQJ¬‘KDUORW’Õ/DWDGMIHPMXYHQFD‘\RXQJ’ JM\NRM‘WRMXGJHWRWU\’Õ/DWM GLFUHLG JM\PW\U¬‘MRLQWOLPE’Õ/DWMXQFW UD‘MXQFWXUHMRLQW’ QJM¬URM~ JMLQRQM‘WRWU\WRVDPSOHWRWDVWH’Õ/DWMM QUH‘WRIDVW’ ZLWKDVHFRQGDU\SUHIL[LQ7RVN ]JMXD~]JMXH‘EHHKLYH’Õ/DWMQXD‘GRRUHQWUDQFH’ ZLWKDQHZ SUHIL[] ,QWKHPLGGOHRIWKHZRUG/DWMLVHLWKHUUHWDLQHGDV$OEMRUGURSSHG +RZHYHU WKH PDWHULDO LV VLPSO\ WRR OLPLWHG IRU XV WR REWDLQ D FOHDUHU SLFWXUH7KHIROORZLQJZRUGVFDQEHDGGXFHG PDM‘0D\’Õ/DW0MXVLG WDIWDU‘IXQQHO’Õ5RP WUDLHFWULXPLGIRU/DWWUDLHFWAULXPLG 7KH ORVV RI LQWHUYRFDOLF M PD\ EH FKDUDFWHULVWLF RI WKH FKURQRORJLFDO VWDJHZKHUHWKHFKDQJHFW!IWWRRNSODFH
In the beginning of a word, Lat v is always preserved in Alb v: YD‘IRUG’Õ/DWYDGXPLG YMHUVK¬‘SRHP’Õ/DWYHUVXV‘YHUVH’ YMHW¬U‘ROG’Õ/DWYHWHUHPLG YUHU~Y¬QHU‘JDOOELOH’Õ/DWYHQQXP‘SRWLRQSRLVRQ’ YXOOQHW‘ZLOO’Õ/DWYROXQWWHPLG YULJXOO‘IODSOREH’Õ/DWYHUULFXOXP‘VHLQH’ 7KHUHVXOWLVWKHVDPHIRUZRUGVUHVXOWLQJIURPODWHUXQLYHUEDWLRQ LIY ZDVLQWKHEHJLQQLQJRIDOH[HPHLQ/DWLQ SU¬QGYHU¬ ~ SUDQGYHU¬ ‘VSULQJ’ Õ 5RP SUPD YUD ! ,WDO SULPDYHUD5XPSULP:YDU:
phonology
55
,I/DWYLVIROORZHGE\DJURXSYRZHOQDVDOVRQRUDQWLW\LHOGV$OEP P¬QMLOO‘YLJLO IDVW’Õ5RP YLQJLOLDFI/DWYLJLOLD‘YLJLO’ P¬VKLN¬ ‘EXEEOH EOLVWHU EODGGHU’ Õ 5RP YQVFD IRU /DW YVFD ‘EODGGHU’
In inlaut, Lat v was only preserved after u: JMXYHQJ¬‘KDUORW’Õ/DWDGMIHPMXYHQFD‘\RXQJ’ ,WZDVORVWDIWHURWKHUYRZHOV ODW\U¬‘ULQVHZDWHU’ Õ5RP ODYW UDIURP/DWODYUH‘WRZDVK’ QRVKW¬U‘VSURXW\RXQJSODQWVDSOLQJ’Õ5RP Q²YDVWHU!,WDOGLDO QRYDVWURLG VKLM¬‘WDVWH’Õ5RP VXYLOLDEDVHGRQ/DWVXYLV‘VZHHW’ VKTD‘%XOJDULDQ’ *HJ Õ/DWVFODYXV‘6ODY’ XOOL~XOOî‘ROLYH WUHH ’Õ/DWROYXV‘ROLYHWUHH’ YXDM~YXHM‘WRVXIIHU’Õ/DWYYHUH‘WROLYHWRVXUYLYH’
/DWPKDVEHHQSUHVHUYHGLQDOOSKRQHWLFFRQWH[WV IDPXOO‘JRGFKLOG’Õ/DWIDPXOXV‘VHUYDQWDWWHQGDQW’ NXOP‘ULGJHSHDN ZDYH’Õ/DWQRPFXOPHQLG PDVKNXOO‘PDQPDOH’Õ/DWPDVFXOXV‘PDOHPDVFXOLQH’ PHVK¬‘PDVV’Õ/DWPLVVDLG P¬QG‘PRPHQW’Õ/DWPAPHQWXPLG TXP¬VKW ‘PLON ZKH\’ Õ 5RP FORPRVWXP /DW FRORVWUXP FRORVWUXm,EHHVWLQJV’
,QLWLDO/DWQZDVSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ QDW\U¬‘QDWXUH’Õ/DWQW UDLG Q¬P¬URM‘WRQXPEHUWRFRXQW’Õ/DWQXPHUUHLG QLS‘QHSKHZJUDQGVRQ’Õ/DWQRPQHSAV‘JUDQGVRQ’ QRWRM‘WRVZLP’Õ5RP QRWUHIRU/DWQDWUHLG QXVH ‘EULGH \RXQJ ZRPDQ \RXQJHU GDXJKWHULQODZ’ Õ 5RP
Q SWLDYDULDQWRI/DWQ SWD‘PDUULHGZRPDQZLIHEULGH’ Q\MH‘NQRW’Õ/DWQAGXVLG
,QWHUYRFDOLF /DW Q ZDV SUHVHUYHG DV *HJ Q EXW UKRWDFL]HG LQ 7RVNDIWHUXQVWUHVVHGYRZHOV
DUE¬U~DUE¬Q‘$OEDQLDQ SDUWLFXODUO\RI,WDO\DQG*UHHFH ’Õ5RP
DOEDQXVUHQGHULQJ,OO\U #NDCPQK 3WRO
56
chapter one DUPLN~DQ¬PLN‘HQHP\’Õ/DWLQLPFXVLG JMHOE¬U~JMHOE¬Q‘JUHHQ’Õ/DWJDOELQXV‘JUHHQLVK\HOORZ’ N¬US~NDQS‘KHPS’Õ5RP FDQQDSLVIRU/DWFDQQDELVLG P¬VKWHN¬U ~ P¬VKWHN¬Q ‘ELUFK’ Õ /DW PDVWLFLQXV ‘UHODWHG WR WKH PDVWLFWUHH’ PXUJ~PXQJ‘PRQN’Õ/DWPRQDFKXVLG
+RZHYHU LQWHUYRFDOLF /DW Q ZDV ORVW DIWHU VWUHVVHG LH XVXDOO\ ORQJ YRZHOVDWWKHHQGRIWKHZRUG IOL~IOî‘VDFULILFH’Õ5RP ILULJLOQXP IUH~IUê‘EULGOH JUDSHVWDON FRPE’Õ/DWIUQXPLG NXVK¬UL~NXVK¬Uî‘FRXVLQ’Õ/DWFRQVAEUQXVLG O¬WL~O¬Wî‘,WDOLDQ/DWLQ&DWKROLF’Õ/DW/DWQXV‘/DWLQ’ OL~Oî‘IOD[OLQHQ’Õ/DWOQXPLG SH~Sê‘WKUHDG’Õ/DWSQXV‘WKUHDGZRXQGXSRQWKHEREELQ’ ,IWKHZRUGFRQWDLQHGDQRWKHUQRUULQWHUYRFDOLFQ\LHOGHG7RVNUHYHQ LILWDSSHDUHGDIWHUDVWUHVVHGYRZHO N¬VKW¬U~N¬VKW¬Q‘&KULVWLDQ’Õ/DWFKULVWLQXVLG U¬U¬~UDQ¬‘VDQG’Õ/DWDUQDLG UU¬VKLU¬~UU¬VKLQ¬‘UHVLQ’Õ/DWUVQDLG UULT¬U~UULT¬Q‘WLFN’Õ/DWULFLQXVLG YUHU~Y¬QHU‘JDOOELOH’Õ/DWYHQQXP‘SRWLRQSRLVRQ’ ,QWKHLQWHUYRFDOLFSRVLWLRQERWKPDQGQFRXOGGHYHORSDKRPRUJDQLF RFFOXVLYHDIWHUWKHP SHQG¬‘IHDWKHU SDLU RIR[HQ ’Õ/DWSLQQDSHQQD‘IHDWKHU’ UUHPE~UUHP‘EUDQFK’Õ/DWUPXVLG VKHPE¬OOHM‘WRUHVHPEOH’Õ/DWVLPLOUHLG XPE‘SORXJKVKDUH’Õ/DWQRPYAPLVLG
,QLWLDO/DWOLVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEO ODIVK¬‘FUHVW RIELUG FRPE’Õ/DWOD[D FXWLV ‘ORRVH VNLQ ’ ODU‘ODXUHO’Õ/DWODXUXVLG OHS¬U‘OHSURV\’Õ/DWOHSUDLG OHSXU‘KDUH’Õ/DWOHSRUHPLG OLJM‘ODZ’Õ/DWOJH P LG OXF¬‘PXGPLUH’Õ/DWOXWHD‘PXGG\’ ,QFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV/DWOWHQGVWREHSUHVHUYHGDVO
phonology
57
EOHM‘WREX\’Õ5RP DEOHYUH‘WROLIWXSWRUHOLHYH IURP ’ JMHOE¬U~JMHOE¬Q‘JUHHQ’Õ/DWJDOELQXV‘JUHHQLVK\HOORZ’ NDOW¬U ‘EOXH VN\ EOXH’ 7RVN Õ 5RP FDOWKLQXV ‘\HOORZ \HOORZ LVK’EDVHGRQ/DWFDOWKD‘&DOHQGXODRIILFLQDOLV’ THOT‘JODVV’Õ/DWFDOLFHP‘ERZOFXS’ +RZHYHU WKHUH LV RQH H[FHSWLRQ ZKHQ /DW O LV VXEVWLWXWHG E\ OO LQ D FOXVWHU SOODM¬‘XSODQGJHQWOHVORSH’Õ SODJLXVLG
,QRWKHUSRVLWLRQV/DWOLVXVXDOO\VXEVWLWXWHGE\$OEOO GMDOO‘GHYLO’Õ/DWGLDEROXVLG N¬UVK¬QGHOOD‘&KULVWPDV’Õ/DW&KULVWQWOHLG PUHNXOO‘PLUDFOH’Õ/DWPLUFXOXPLG SOODM¬‘XSODQGJHQWOHVORSH’Õ5RP SODJLXVLGFI5XPSODL,WDO SLDJJLD SULOO‘$SULO’Õ/DWDSUOLVLG VKSDWXOO‘VKRXOGHUVKRXOGHUEODGH’Õ5RP VSDWXODLG ,QODWHUORDQZRUGV/DWOFDQEHDOVRUHSUHVHQWHGE\$OEORUHYHQM O KLQJ¬O‘JLUWK’Õ5RP KLQQLFXODGHULYDWLYHRI/DWKLQQXV‘PXOH’ NDO¬‘KRUVH’Õ/DWFDEDOOXVLG NXODU‘FXUYHGSLHFHRIZRRGR[FROODU’Õ/DWFROOUH‘FROODU’ PDQGLOH‘NHUFKLHI’Õ/DWPDQWOH‘WRZOQDSNLQ’ PEXORM‘WRFRYHUWREXU\’Õ5RP PDQLSXOUH‘WRGLJLQKDQGIXOV’ FI/DWPDQLSXOXV VKWLM¬‘VSHDUUD\’Õ/DWKDVWOH‘VSHDU’ ,QROGDQGQHZO\IRUPHGFOXVWHUV LQFOXGLQJJ" /DWOLVUHQGHUHGDVU G¬UJRM‘WRVHQG’Õ/DWGOJUHLG JU¬P¬UDW¬ ‘EHHVWLQJV FORWV RI FXUGOHG PLON’ Õ /DW JORPHUWXP SDUWLFLSOH RI JORPHUUH ‘WR ZLQG LQWR D EDOO WR JDWKHU LQWR D URXQGKHDS’
7KH SKRQRORJLFDO RSSRVLWLRQ EHWZHHQ U DQG UU LV ZHDN DQG RIWHQORVWLQGLDOHFWV$VDUHVXOWWKHROGGLVWULEXWLRQRILQLWLDOUUYHUVXV PHGLDO UZKLFKFRQWLQXHV/DWUKDVVHYHUDOH[FHSWLRQV ,QDQODXWWKHUHJXODUUHIOH[RI/DWULV$OEUU UUH]H‘UD\VSRNH’Õ/DWUDGLXVLG
58
chapter one UU¬VKDM¬‘3HQWHFRVW’Õ/DW5AVOLD‘5RVDOLHV’ UU¬VKLU¬~UU¬VKLQ¬I‘UHVLQ’Õ/DWUVQDLG UULS¬‘SUHFLSLFHVWRQHZDOO’Õ/DWUSD‘EDQNFRDVW’ UULT¬U~UULT¬Q‘WLFN’Õ/DWULFLQXVLG UUXPEXOO‘UROOHGLQWRDEDOO’Õ5RP URPEXOXVEDVHGRQ/DWUKRP EXV‘PDJLFZKLUOLJLJRUZKHHO’
7KHUHDUHWKUHHH[FHSWLRQVLQZKLFKZHILQG$OEULQDQODXW UHJM‘NLQJ’Õ/DWUJHPLG U¬P¬U~U¬PHQ‘9DODFKLDQ VKHSKHUG’Õ/DW5RPQXV‘5RPDQ’ UXQJRM‘WRZHHG’Õ/DWUXQFUHLG
,QLQODXW/DWUQRUPDOO\JLYHV$OEU DUP¬‘ZHDSRQ’Õ/DWDUPDLG EU\P¬‘IURVW’Õ/DWEU PD‘FROGIURVW’ IUXHU‘)HEUXDU\’ *HJ Õ/DWIHEUXULXVLG I\W\U¬‘IDFH’Õ/DWIDFW UD‘IRUPDWLRQFUHDWXUH’ JMHU‘GRUPRXVH’Õ/DWJOUHPLG LU¬‘ZUDWKKHURLVP’Õ/DWUD‘ZUDWK’ ]KXU‘JUDYHO’Õ/DWVDEXUUD‘VDQGEDOODVW’ 7KHUHH[LVWVHYHUDOH[FHSWLRQVZLWK/DWUÖ$OEUU NDQG¬UU‘LQVHFW’Õ/DWFDQWKDULV‘EHHWOHZRUP’ NUURNXOO‘VDIIURQ’Õ5RP FURFXOXPGHPLQXWLYHRI/DWFURFXPLG QG¬UURM‘WRFKDQJHWRDOWHU’Õ/DWDOWHUUHLG SDUUL]‘SDUDGLVH’Õ/DWSDUDGVXVLG S¬UUDOO¬‘WDOHVWRU\’Õ/DWSDUDEROD‘SURYHUEVSHHFK’ WPHUU‘KRUURUIULJKW’Õ/DWWLPAUHPLG
*HPLQDWHG /DWLQ VRQRUDQWV OO DQG UU KDYH D KLVWRU\ RI WKHLU RZQ/DWOOJDYH$OEO EXO¬‘EXG’Õ/DWEXOOD‘EXEEOHERVVNQRE’ JMHO‘URRVWHU’Õ/DWJDOOXVLG NUHO‘FXUOORFN’Õ5RP FHUHEHOOXV‘UHODWHGWRWKHKHDG’EDVHGRQ /DWFHUHEUXP‘EUDLQVNXOO’ SXO¬‘KHQ’Õ5RP SXOOD‘KHQ’ THO‘VFDE’Õ/DWFDOOXP‘FRUQKDUGVNLQ’ WU\HO¬‘ERUHGULOO’Õ5RP WHUHEHOOXPLG ,QRQHFDVHZHILQGMUHSODFLQJO OO P\M¬I‘KDUGZRRGLQWHULRURIWUHHVPHGXOOD’Õ/DWPHGXOODLG
phonology
59
*HPLQDWH/DWUULVUHIOHFWHGLQ$OEDQLDQDVUU DUULM‘WRFRPHWRDUULYH’Õ5RP DUULYUHLG NDUU¬‘FDUW’Õ/DWFDUUXP‘WZRZKHHOHGZDJRQ’ SRUULTP‘OHHN’Õ5RP SRUULFLXPGHULYHGIURPSRUUXPLG TDUU‘7XUNH\RDNELWWHURDN’Õ/DWFHUUXVLG THUU‘ZDJRQFDUW’Õ/DWFDUUXV‘WZRZKHHOHGZDJRQ’ VKDUU¬‘VDZ’Õ/DWVHUUDLG
(DUO\ 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV UHIOHFW VRPH UHPDUNDEOH IHDWXUHV
GLIIHUHQWLDWLQJ WKHP IURP ODWHU ZRUGV RI WKH VDPH RULJLQ LQVRIDU DV DV\OODELFVRQRUDQWVDUHFRQFHUQHG
:KLOH LQ ODWH 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV WKH UHJXODU VXEVWLWXWLRQ RI 6ODY MZLWK $OEMLVDWWHVWHGWKHUHDUHVHYHUDOZRUGVLQZKLFKWKHUHIOH[HVRI6ODY M FRLQFLGHZLWKWKRVHRI(3$ M,QRQHZRUGDQODXW6ODY M\LHOGV$OEJM JMH]GLV‘WRJRIRUDZDONWRURDP’Õ6ODY Mp]GLWL‘WRULGH’ ,QLQODXW6ODY MLVFKDQJHGWR$OEK NUDK‘DUmVKRXOGHUVLGH’Õ6ODY NUDMÚ‘HQGVLGHH[WUHPLW\’ NUDKLQ¬‘UHJLRQDUHD’Õ6ODY NUDMLQDLG NUDKLV‘WRVZHHSXS ZKHDW WRFXW EUDQFKHV ’Õ6ODY NUDMLWL‘WR FXWWRZLQQRZ’ OORK¬ ‘UDLQ ZLWK VQRZ VQRZEURWK GDPSQHVV’ Õ 6ODY ORMÚ
‘DQ\WKLQJOLTXLG’ !‘IDW’ SRVWDKH‘EODQNHWTXLOWXVHGIRUVLWWLQJ’Õ6ODY SRVWDMD‘EHGFRYHU’ ,Q RQH FDVH WKH IDOO RI LQWHUYRFDOLF 6ODY Y LV DWWHVWHG EHWZHHQ VKRUW YRZHOV VKN¬UGKHF‘NHJEDUUHO’Õ6ODY VNRYRUGÚFÚ‘SDQ’ ,QHDUO\6ODYLFORDQZRUGV OLVXVXDOO\UHIOHFWHGDVOO EXDOO~EXHOO‘EXIIDOR’Õ6ODY E\YROÙLG OORK¬ ‘UDLQ ZLWK VQRZ VQRZEURWK GDPSQHVV’ Õ 6ODY ORMÚ
‘DQ\WKLQJOLTXLG’ !‘IDW’ OOXN¬‘OLPHWUHH’Õ O\NR‘EDVW’ ,QWHUYRFDOLF6ODY ULQHDUO\ORDQZRUGVLVUHJXODUO\VXEVWLWXWHGE\$OE UU NDUUXS‘ILVKWUDS’Õ6ODY NRUXSÙLG NDUUXW¬‘IHUPHQWHU’Õ6ODY NRU\WR‘WURXJK’ RUUO‘HDJOHEX]]DUG’Õ6ODY RUÚOÙLG
60
chapter one S¬UUXD~S¬UUXH‘EURRN ULYHUEHG’Õ6ODY SRURYÙ~ SDURYÙ SXUU¬‘KRWDVKHV’Õ6ODY S\U’ÚLG
'HVSLWH -2./ ,) ;;;9,, DQG 6(/,Û&% (9 6ODY QDVHOHQLH WKHUHDUHQRWUDFHVRI7RVNUKRWDFLVPLQ6ODYLFORDQZRUGVLQ$OEDQLDQ 7KHLUFODLPKDVEHHQEDVHGRQHUURQHRXVHW\PRORJLHVVXFKDV9$60(5’V $OE :RUWIRUVFK H[SODQDWLRQ RI YU¬U¬W ~ YUDQ¬W ‘GDUN FORXG\’ IURP 6RXWK 6ODY YUDQÙ ‘EODFN’ 7KH $OEDQLDQ DGMHFWLYH LV D GHYHUEDWLYHZKLOHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJYHUELVEDVHGRQUH‘FORXG’ 25(/ $(' 6LPLODUO\ 7RVN W¬UVLU¬ ‘URSH’ LV QRW ERUURZHG IURP 6ODY
WUD¨LQD GHVSLWH -2./ $$UE6W , EXW LV GHULYHG IURP W¬U¬VL ‘ZKROHQHVV WRWDOLW\ XQLW\’ WKH ODWWHU EHLQJ UHODWHG WR W¬UH ~ WDQ¬ ‘DOO ZKROH’
&RQVRQDQWV 7KHFKDQJHVLQWKHFRQVRQDQWV\VWHPRI3URWR$OEDQLDQDUHHYHQ
PRUH UDGLFDO WKDQ WKRVH IRXQG DPRQJ LWV YRZHOV DQG VRQRUDQWV $W WKH VDPH WLPH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ UHIOHFWV WKRXJK LQGLUHFWO\ FHUWDLQ SKRQR ORJLFDO RSSRVLWLRQV RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ ZKLFK ZHUH ORVW LQ PRVW RI WKH RWKHUEUDQFKHVRIWKHIDPLO\VXFKDVWKHWULSOHRSSRVLWLRQVRIYHODUV
6SLUDQWV (DUO\ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ PDLQWDLQHG ,( V LQ VRPH SRVLWLRQV +RZHYHU E\ WKH WLPH RI /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,( V KDV EHHQ ORVW RU UHSODFHGLQDOOSRVLWLRQV
/LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 :E V ! K EHIRUH X $OE 6W ,,, GLVVLPLODWLRQLQWKL 3('(56(1 .=;;;9, V!KEHIRUH X GLVVLPLODWLRQRILQLWLDO V!WKL V!JMLIWKHILUVW V\OODEOHLVVWUHVVHG 7$*/,$9,1, 6WDOE99, V! h!WKLQWKL DQGWKDM 0$11/DQJXDJH;;9,,,+LVW*U &,02&+2:6., 6W,( V!KEHIRUHX +$03 (WLPRORJLMD UHMHFWV
VDVDVRXUFHRILQWHUYRFDOLF$OE K ÇABEJ St. III 137-139; 25(/ 6RYVODY “UXNL” UXOHLQ$OEDQLDQ ,-D.6SUDFKH ;;;,
,Q LQLWLDO SRVLWLRQ ,( V ZDV SUHVHUYHG DV V LQ (DUO\ 3URWR
$OEDQLDQ/DWHUKRZHYHULWPHUJHGZLWKWKHFRQWLQXDQWRI,( LQ/3$
M!$OEJM
phonology
61
JMDN‘EORRG’ (3$ VDND *NQRQX‘MXLFH’/LWKVDND&‘UHVLQ’6ODY
VRNÙ‘MXLFH’ JMDOS¬ ‘EXWWHU’ (3$ VHOSD *N GNRQX GNCKQP UVGCT GWSJPKC +HV 6NWVDUSª‘FODULILHGEXWWHU’2+*VDOED‘RLQWPHQW’ JMDUS¬U ~ JMDUS¬Q ‘VQDNH’ (3$ VHUSHQD ,( VHUS ‘WR FUDZO’ /DWVHUSQV‘VQDNHVHUSHQW’VHUSA‘WRFUDZO’ JMHUE ‘WR JXOS WR GULQN’ (3$ VHUED /DW VRUEHA ‘WR VXS XS WR VXFNLQ’*NTQHGYLG/LWKVXUEL¸VX¼EWLLG6ODY VÚUEDWL‘WR JXOSWRVXSXS’ JM¬~JMâ‘WKLQJ’ (3$ VDQ V SDUWLFLSOHRI,( HV‘WREH’ VRQWV 6NWVDQW*NY=P JMXP¬‘VOHHS’ (3$ VXSQD ,( VÆHS‘WRVOHHS’FI VXSQR *N WRPQX‘VOHHS’6ODY VÙQÙLG ,Q WKUHH FDVHV ZRUG LQLWLDO ,( V GLG QRW EHFRPH $OE JM GXH WR GLVVLPLODWLRQ VKL‘UDLQ’ (3$ V MD ZLWKGLVVLPLODWLRQLQWKHODWHUIRUP M MD ,( V LG *NWGK7RFK$VZDVH7RFK%VZHVH‘UDLQ’V ‘WR UDLQ’23UXVVXJH‘UDLQ’ >V M@ WKDM ‘WR GU\’ (3$ VDXVQMD ,( VDXVR ‘GU\’ *N CW=QL 0+* VôU/LWKVD-VDV6ODY VX[Ù WKL ‘SLJ’ (3$ WV V ZLWK GLVVLPLODWLRQ RI VLELODQWV ,( V V LG $YJHQVJK *NW=X/DWV V2+*V
,Q WKH LQWHUYRFDOLF SRVLWLRQ ,( V EHFDPH (3$ [ ZKLFK LV UHIOHFWHGDVKRUDOWRJHWKHUORVWDOUHDG\LQ2OG$OEDQLDQWH[WV JMXK¬ ‘WRQJXH ODQJXDJH’ (3$ JXO[ WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ GLDOHFWDOZRUGIRU‘VRXQG’ JROVR 21NDOO‘VKRXW’/LWKJDËVDV ‘HFKR’6ODY JROVÙ‘YRLFH’ ND‘R[’ (3$ ND[D ,( NRVRGHULYDWLYHRI,( NHV‘WRVFUDWFK WR FXW’ FI 6ODY YROÙ ‘R[’ ~ YDOLWL ‘WR WKURZ GRZQ’ ! ‘WR FDVWUDWH’ NH]¬ ‘ZRPDQ’V KHDGGUHVV ERQQHW KDLUQHW’ GHULYDWLYH LQ ]¬ RI (3$ ND[‘SODLWHGKDLU’ 6ODY NRVDLG21KDGGU‘ZRPDQ’V KDLU’ NRK¬‘WLPH’ (3$ N[ 6ODY ¨DVÙLG YDM]¬ ‘JLUO’ EDVHG RQ YDU¬ (3$ VZHVDU 6NW VY¢VDU $UP R\U/DWVRURU
chapter one
62
YMHK¬UU ‘PRWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZH[XU ZLWK DVVLPLODWLRQ IURP H[SHFWHG VZHWVXU ,( VÆHU 6NWyYDyUgPRWKHULQODZ’ /DWVRFUXVLG
+RZHYHUDIWHU DQG DVZHOODVGLSKWKRQJVLQ LDQG X
,( V FKDQJHG WR h 7KXV 3URWR$OEDQLDQ KDG D NLQG RI “UXNL” UXOH VLPLODU WR WKDW RI %DOWR6ODYLF DQG ,QGR,UDQLDQ &I WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV GDVK‘UDP’ < *dauhD (3$ GDXVD ,( GKRXVR~ GKHXVR *RWK GLXV ‘ZLOG DQLPDO’ /LWK SO GD-VRV ‘SDUDGLVH’ 6ODY GX[Ù ‘EUHDWKVSLULW’ JM\VK‘JUDQGIDWKHU’ V hD (3$ V VD 6NWV ¿d‘SURJHQLWRU’ OHVK ‘ZRRO IOHHFH KDLU’ <*laihD (3$ ODLVD /LWK OD&hNDV ‘OHDI’ /DWYOD&VND‘OHDIRQDOLQHQVWDON VWDON’6ODY OLVWÙ‘OHDI’ SLVK¬ ‘SLQH’ < *p h¸ (3$ S V *N RKVWX /DW SQXV IURP
SLWVQRVRU SLVQRV SOLVK‘NLQGRIUHHG3KUDJPLWHVFRPPXQLV’ < SO hL (3$ SO VL /LWKSO L h®V‘UHHG’ SUXVK‘HPEHUJORZLQJFRDO’ < SUXhD (3$ SUXVD /DWSU QDLG SUXVQ6NWSOR¿DWL‘WREXUQ’
2FFOXVLYHV ODELDOVDQGGHQWDOV 7KHWHUWLDU\RSSRVLWLRQRI,QGR(XURSHDQXQYRLFHGYRLFHGDQG DVSLUDWH YRLFHG RFFOXVLYHV QHXWUDOL]HG LWV DVSLUDWHQRQDVSLUDWH FRP SRQHQWLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQDVLQ%DOWR6ODYLF /LWHUDWXUH 0$11 /DQJXDJH ;;9,,, VSLUDQWL]DWLRQ RI G +LVW *U Ç$%(- 6W ,,, 25(/ 6%-D .RQWDNW\ FRQGLWLRQVRI G!GK
,QGR(XURSHDQXQYRLFHGODELDO SZDVSUHVHUYHGDV(3$ S! $OES
JOHS¬‘PDWWHUIURPH\HVUKHXP LQH\HV ’ (3$ NDODLSGHULYHG IURP,( OHLS‘WRVPHDUZLWKIDW’ DSMDS‘WRJLYH’ (3$ DSD ,( DS~ S‘WRVHL]HWRWDNH’ +LWW S ~ DS ‘WR VHL]H’ 6NW SQ²WL ‘ KH UHDFKHV RYHUWDNHV’ *N CRVY‘WRIDVWHQWRELQG’/DWDSVFRU‘WRJUDVS’
phonology
63
NULS¬~NU\S¬‘VDOW’ (3$ NU S 21KUXID‘VFDE’/LWKNUDXS¸V ‘URXJK’NUDXSLV‘VFDE’/DWYNUD-SLV‘IUDLOEULWWOH’6ODY NUXSD ‘JURDWV’ SODN‘ROGPDQ’ (3$ S H ODND ,( S H OiNRV /LWKS®ONDV‘JUD\’ SâiNRVFI*NRQNKQX‘JUD\JUL]]OHG’ SORW¬ ‘IXOO’ (3$ SOWD ,( SOWR ‘IXOO’ 6NW SUW¢ /DW FRP SOWXV SULVK ‘WR GHVWUR\ WR VSRLO WR ZDVWH’ (3$ SUhD *N RTKY ‘WR VDZ’ UMHS‘WRVWULSRII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’ (3$ UHSD ,( UHS *NGTGRVQOCK‘WRHDW’/DWUDSLA‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’/LWKU{SWL ‘WRJUDVS’
$ UDUH ,QGR(XURSHDQ SKRQHPH E \LHOGHG (3$ E DQG IXUWKHU$OEE EDMJ¬‘GXQJ’ (3$ EDOJ *NDQNDKVQP‘FRZGXQJ’ ,( EROÞ UUDEH‘URFN\GHVHUW ZLWKEXVKHV ’ (3$ UDXED *RWKUDXSMDQ‘WR ULS’2+*URXIHQLG VKN¬OER]¬ ‘EDUN’ (3$ VNDOE 21 VNDOSU ‘VKLS’ VNHOSD ‘JULPDFH’ ‘FUDFNVSOLW’0/*VFKROSH‘PXVVHO’
,( EKPHUJHGZLWK,( ELQ(3$ EGHYHORSLQJLQWR$OEE EDUGK¬ ‘ZKLWH’ (3$ EDUG]D ,( EKHUi½ ‘WR VKLQH ZKLWH’ 6NW EKUMDWH ‘ KH VKLQHV EHDPV JOLWWHUV’ *RWK EDLUKWV ‘OLJKW VKLQLQJ’ E¬M~EDˆM‘WRGRWRPDNH’ (3$ EDQMD *NHCKPY‘WRDSSHDU’ EUHM ~ EUêM ‘WR JQDZ’ (3$ EUDLQMD ,( EKUHL ‘WR FXW’ 6NW EKUodWL‘ KH LQMXUHV’/DWIULA‘WRUXE’6ODY EULWL‘WRVKDYH’ HOE‘EDUOH\’ (3$ DOEL *NCNHK‘NLQGRIJUDLQ’ JMHUE‘WRJXOSWRGULQN’ (3$ VHUED ,( VHUEK /DWVRUEHA‘WR VXSXSWRVXFNLQ’*NT QHGYLG/LWKVXUEL¸VX¼EWLLG6ODY
VÚUEDWL‘WRJXOSWRVXSXS’ KXPE‘WROHDYHWRORVHWRVSRLOWRPLVVWRGURZQ’ (3$ VNXPED QDVDOSUHVHQWRI,( VNHXEK *RWKDIVNLXEDQ‘WRSXVKDZD\WR UHMHFW’/LWKVNXPE¸VN¸EWL‘WRKXUU\WRKDVWHQ’ ,IIROORZHGE\ X(3$ EFKDQJHVWRYDIWHUDYRZHO
chapter one
64
DYXOO ‘VWHDP YDSRU’ (3$ DEXOD FRQWLQXLQJ EK X OR FORVH WR 2+*QHEXO‘IRJ’26QLIRO *PF QHEXOD]
8QYRLFHG ,( W ZDV SUHVHUYHG DV (3$ W ! $OE W &I WKH IROORZLQJFDVHV GLW¬‘GD\’ (3$ GW GWL *PF WGL]‘WLPH’ 2+*]W2(WG DQG6NWGWL‘EULJKWQHVVVSOHQGRU’ MHW¬ ‘OLIH’ (3$ HWD UHODWHG *N GVGQX ‘WUXH UHDO’ G VC C NJSJ` C ICSC +HV GVC\Y‘WRWHVW’ PRW¬U‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU‘PRWKHU’ 6NWPW¢U*N OJVJT/DWPWHU WHW¬‘HLJKW’ (3$ DNWAWL ,( RWA X LG 6NWD¿bd$UPRZ*N Q MVY WUDS‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSD 6ODY WURSD‘SDWK’ WUH‘WKUHH’ (3$ WUHMH ,( WUHHVLG 6NWWUD\Då*NVTGK`L/DW WUV WXQG‘WRPRYHWRVWLUWRVZLQJ’ (3$ WXQGD 6NWWXQGDWH‘WRSXVK WRVWULNH’/DWWXQGA‘WRSXVK’
,( G\LHOGHG(3$ G!$OEG GHP ‘\RXQJ EXOO’ (3$ GDPD 2,U GDP ‘R[’ DQG *N FCOCNQL ‘FDOI’ GMDWKW¬ ‘ULJKW’ (3$ GHWVD ,( GHV LG 6NW G¢N¿LoD *N FGEKQX/DWGH[WHU GMHUU ‘WR GHVWUR\’ (3$ GHUD ,( GHU 6NW GodWL ‘WR EXUVW WR WHDU’*NFGTY‘WRVNLQ’*RWKJDWDLUDQ‘WRWHDU’ GUHGK‘WRWXUQWRURWDWH’ (3$ GUHG]D ,( GUH½K $UPGDàQDP ‘WRWXUQ’GDUΑFXUYHWXUQ’ G\ ‘WZR’ (3$ GXZA ,( GÆA X LG 6NW GY¢X $Y GYD *N FWY/DWGXR PXQG ‘WR EH DEOH’ (3$ QDVDO SUHVHQW PXQGD /LWK PXG£ ‘SRVVLELOLW\’ PXG·RWL ‘WR WU\ WR DWWHPSW’ 6NW P²GDWH ‘WR UHMRLFHWREHPHUU\’
7KH ,QGR(XURSHDQ YRLFHG DVSLUDWH GK PHUJHG ZLWK G LQ
(3$ G!$OEG
phonology
65
GDO‘WRJRRXW’ (3$ GDOD *NSCNNY‘WREORRP’LH‘WRDSSHDU WRFRPHRXW’ GDVK ‘UDP’ (3$ GDXhD ,( GKRXVR ~ GKHXVR ‘EUHDWK EUHDWKLQJDQLPDO’ *PF GHX]DQ‘ZLOGDQLPDO’/LWKSOGD-VRV ‘SDUDGLVH’6ODY GX[Ù‘EUHDWKVSLULW’ GMDO¬ ‘ER\ \RXWK’ (3$ GHOD ,( GKL ‘WR VXFN’ /DWY G?OV ‘VRQ’/DWIOLXVLG GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ (3$ GHJD ,( GKHÞK ‘WR EXUQ’ 6NW G¢KDWL 7RFK$%WVDNWV¥N/LWGHJ¸GªJWL GXDM ~ GXHM ‘VKHDI’ (3$ GAQMD 6NW GKQd ‘JUDLQ FHUHDOV’ GKQ\¢‘JUDLQ’/LWKG·RQD‘EUHDG’ HQG‘SROOHQ’ (3$ DQGD 6NW¢QGKDV‘KHUE’*NCPSQX‘IORZHU’
,QWKHLQWHUYRFDOLFSRVLWLRQDQGDIWHUU3URWR$OEDQLDQ GZDV DOVR SUHVHUYHG VHH WKRXJK $W D YHU\ ODWH VWDJH SUHVXPDEO\ LQ WKH ; ;,, FHQWXULHV WKLV VRXQG ZDV VSLUDQWL]HG SUREDEO\ XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFHRIPHGLHYDO*UHHN7KHUHVXOWZDV$OEGK JDUGK ‘IHQFH’ (3$ JDUGD *RWK JDUGV ‘KRXVH’ /LWK JD¼GDV ‘IHQFH’6ODY JRUGÙ‘WRZQIHQFH’ JOHGK¬ ‘FDUHVV’ (3$ JODG /DW JODEHU ‘VPRRWK’ 2+* JODW ‘VKLQLQJ HYHQ VPRRWK’ /LWK JORG¸V ‘VPRRWK’ 6ODY JODGÙNÙ LG JODGLWL‘WRFDUHVV’ KHGK‘WRWKURZWRVKRRW’ (3$ VNHXGD ,( VNHXG‘WRWKURZWR VKRRW’ 21VNM²WD2+*VFLRfDQ KHUGKH‘WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ DUG]DL ,( RU½KL~ ½KLLG $YGXDO iUi]*NQTZKX$UPRUML0,UXLUJJHLG NURGK¬ ‘EHHKLYH’ (3$ NUG *RWK KURW ‘URRI’ 6ODY NUDGD ‘KHDSSLOH’ WUHGK ‘WR FDVWUDWH’ (3$ WUHXGD /DW WU GA ‘WR SXVK’ *RWK XV ÈULXWDQ‘WREXUGHQ’6ODY WUXGÙ‘ODERUZRUN’ 2FFDVLRQDOO\ (3$ G DSSHDUV DV $OE GK LQ DQODXW ,W ZDV VSLUDQWL]HG LQWHUYRFDOLFDOO\E\WKHORVVRIWKHLQLWLDOYRZHO GKXQ¬‘ODERUSDLQVVKDPHGLVJUDFH’ (3$ HGXQWLRU DGXQWL *N Q FWPJ‘ODERUSDLQV’$UPHUNQLG $QDORJLFDOIRUFHVDUHDWZRUNLQWKHZRUGIRU‘WHQ’
66
chapter one GKMHW¬ ‘WHQ’ (3$ GHWVW L ,( GH ‘WHQ’ 6NW G¢yD *N FGMC /DWGHFHP
7KH LQIOXHQFH FDPH IURP FRPSRXQGV VXFK DV QM¬PE¬GKMHW¬ ‘HOHYHQ’ G\PE¬GKMHW¬‘WZHOYH’DQGVRRQ,QVXFKFDVHV GZDVVLWXDWHGEHWZHHQ WKHWZR3URWR$OEDQLDQYRZHOVRI DPELGHNWL
2FFOXVLYHV YHODUV 7KH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ YHODUV UHWDLQHG DQ LPSRUWDQW WHUWLDU\ RSSRVLWLRQ WKDW RI “pure” YHODUV SDODWDO YHODUV DQG ODELRYHODUV WKH ODWWHUDUHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGIURPRWKHUYHODUVEHIRUHIURQWYRZHOVEXWPHUJH ZLWK“pure” velars elsewhere ,QWKLVVHQVHWKH3URWR$OEDQLDQV\VWHP RI RFFOXVLYHV VXSSRUWV WKH /XZLDQ HYLGHQFH WKDW 3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQ SRVVHVVHGWKUHHGLVWLQFWYHODURSSRVLWLRQV /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 $OE 6W ,,, YRLFHG DQG YRLFHG DVSLUDWHV LQ DQODXW 3('(56(1 .= ;;;9, SDVVLP UHIOH[HV RI ODELRYHODUV GHVSLUDQWL]DWLRQ RI $OE GK LQ DQODXW +(50$11 .= ;/, FULWLFL]HV 3('(56(1’V DQDO\VLV RI ODELRYHODUV LQ $OEDQLDQ - 2./ 0©ODQJHV 3HGHUVHQ GHYHORSPHQW RI ODELRYHODUV UHFRQ VWUXFWLRQ RI Wh GÊ LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,) ;;;9,, 0$11 /DQJXDJH;;9,,,Hist. Gr. 3334 Ç$%(-6SUDFKH;9,,, St. III 127-128, IV 212-218 -8&482,60XV©RQ/;;9,,, FDVDQHDUO\SUHVHUYHGUHIOH[RI /%(5**HGHQNVFKU%UDQGHQ VWHLQ EHIRUH X DQG Æ 0$57,1(7 ,QGR&HOWLFD 586$.29 /,V VHFRQGDU\F WK -D/% LQLWLDOG DQG GK 25(/ 6%-D .RQWDNW\ GLVWULEXWLRQ RI G DQG GK LQ DQODXW
“3XUH” YHODUVDUHZHOOSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ8QYRLFHG,( N
DVZHOODV NKLIVXFKDSKRQHPHH[LVWHG JDYH(3$ N!$OENDVLQ WKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EDUN ‘EHOO\ ZRPE DEGRPHQ’ (3$ EDUXND DCTWMC CK FQK`QP RCTC>6CTCSPVKPQKX GLN¬ ‘GHVLUH OXVW’ (3$ GN /LWK GmNDV ‘LGOH HPSW\’ 6ODY
GLNÙ‘ZLOG’ NDP ‘WR KDYH’ (3$ NDSPL ,( NDS ‘WR VHL]H WR JUDVS’ /DW FDSLALG*RWKKDEDQ‘WRKDYH’
phonology
67
N¬UU‘GRQNH\DVVIRDOJUD\’ (3$ NDUD 6NWNK¢UD‘GRQNH\’$Y [DUALG6F\WK [DUD2VVHW[æUæJLG NRUU ‘WR UHDS WR KDUYHVW’ (3$ NVUD /LWK NDV¸ N£VWL ‘WR GLJ’ 6ODY NRVD‘VF\WKH’ NUHGK ‘WR SOXQJH WR LPPHUVH WR VWHHS WR VPRWKHU WR EHVSDWWHU’ (3$ NUAGD 6ODY NUDG_ NUDVWL ‘WR VWHDO’ UHIO NUDG_ V?
NUDVWLV?‘WRVQHDNWRVWHDOXSWRDSSURDFKXQQRWLFHG’ ,QWKHSUHYHUE NRP!(3$ ND,( N!$OEJ J¬VKWDOO¬ N¬VKWDOO¬ ‘VSOLQW SLHFH RI ZRRG’ (3$ NDVWDOQ ,( VWHO *N UVGNNY ‘WR SXW WR VHW’ 2+* VWHOOHQ ‘WR SXW’ 23UXVVWDOOW‘WRVWDQG’ JOHS¬ ‘PDWWHU IURP H\HV UKHXP LQ H\HV ’ (3$ NDODLS ,( OHLS‘WRVPHDUZLWKIDW’ JORT ‘UKHXP LQ H\HV WHVWLV’ (3$ NDOXNMD ,( OHXN ‘WR VKLQH VKLQLQJZKLWH’
9RLFHG,( J\LHOGV(3$ JZKLFKLVSUHVHUYHGDV$OEJ DJ‘WZLOLJKWGXVN’ (3$ DXJD ,( DXJ‘WRLQFUHDVH’ *NCW IJ ‘UD\RIOLJKW’ JMXK¬ JOXK¬ ‘WRQJXH ODQJXDJH’ (3$ JXO[ WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ GLDOHFWDOZRUGIRU‘VRXQG’ JROVR 21NDOO‘VKRXW’/LWKJDËVDV ‘HFKR’6ODY JROVÙ‘YRLFH’ OLJ ‘EDG LOO’ (3$ OLJD *N Q NKIQX ‘VPDOO IHZ’ NQKIQX ‘GHVWUXFWLRQGHDWK’/LWKOLJ£‘LOOQHVV’/DWYOLJDLG SORJ ‘JUDQDU\ EDUQ KHDS’ (3$ SOJD *N RNCIKQX ‘SODFHG VLGHZD\VVORSLQJOHDQLQJ’/DWSODJD‘TXDUWHUUHJLRQ’ VKWDJ¬ ‘SROH VWLFN’ (3$ VWDJ 21 VWMDNL LG /DWY VW?JD ‘ORQJ SROH’ VKWUHJ¬‘SLOHRIZRRG’ (3$ VWUDJ 0+*VWUDF‘WLJKW’2(VWUHF ‘KDUGVWURQJ’
9RLFHGDVSLUDWH,( JKPHUJHGZLWK,( JLQ(3$ J!$OEJ FIWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV
GUHJ¬ ‘VFDE’ (3$ GUDJ :HVW *PF WDUJMDQ ‘WR SXOO WR VWLU’ *HUP]HUJHQ 6ODY GÚUJDWL‘WRSXOOWRWXJ’/LWKG®UJLQWL‘WR PRYHWRLUULWDWH’
68
chapter one JUDE¬‘HURVLRQKROORZLQJRXW’ (3$ JUDE ,( JKUHEKWRGLJ’ 2+*JUDE‘JUDYH’6ODY JUREÙLG JULK ‘WR VKDUSHQ’ (3$ JUHLVND *N ZTKY ‘WR UXE WR DQRLQW WR SULFN’ /LWK JULHM¸ JULWL ‘WR VFRRS FUHDP IURP PLON WR WDNH KROGRI’ JXDOO ‘VKHOO VNXOO’ (3$ JAO Z D $UP JORZ[ ‘KHDG’ JKAOX /LWKJDOY£LG6ODY JROYDLG PMHJXOO‘FORXG’ (3$ PHJO *NQ OKZNJ ‘IRJ PLVW’ /LWK PLJO£ LG6ODY PÚJOD‘GDUNQHVVPLVW’ QJDM ‘WR UXQ’ (3$ HQJDQMD 6NW M¢KWL ‘WR OHDYH WR DEDQGRQ’ 2+*JQJQ‘WRJR’
,QRQHFDVH(3$ JKDVEHHQXQYRLFHGLQDQODXW NUHK~NUHI‘WRFRPE’ (3$ JUHEVND /LWKJU{EWL‘WRUDNH’6ODY
JUHE_ JUHEWL‘WRURZWRUDNH’
3DODWDO YHODUV GHYHORSHG ZLWK RQH LPSRUWDQW SRVLWLRQDO H[FHSWLRQ LQWRVLELODQWDIIULFDWHV8QYRLFHG,( JDYH(3$ WVZKLFK EHFDPH$OEWK DWK¬W‘KDUVKVRXUUDQFLG’ (3$ DWVHWD ,( D‘VKDUS’ FI/DW DFLGXV‘VRXU’ THWK ‘WR FXW KDLU ’ (3$ NDLWVD 6NW N©yD ‘KDLU RI WKH KHDG ’ /LWKN¢LVWL‘WRVFUDSHWRVKDYH’ WKHN¬‘IULQJH’ (3$ WVDN 6NWydNK‘EUDQFK’/LWKhDN£LG WKHS‘SHDNSRLQWFRJWRRWK’ (3$ WVDLSD 6NWy©SD‘WDLOSHQLV’ /DWFLSSXV‘SROH’ WKMHUP¬‘JUD\’(3$ WVHUPD /LWKhL¼PDV‘JUD\’ WKMHUU¬ ‘OHQWLO’ (3$ WVHU ,( LHU /DW FLFHU ‘SHD’ $UP VLVHàQLG ,QVHYHUDOFDVHVWKHRULJLQDODIIULFDWHLVUHWDLQHGLQPRGHUQ$OEDQLDQDV F DFDU ‘VWHHO’ (3$ DWVDUD ‘VKDUS’ 2,U DLFKH ‘VKDUS’ *N CMTQP ‘SRLQWWRS’/LWKDhU¸V‘VKDUS’6ODY RVWUÙLG FHUP¬‘FROGFRRO’ (3$ WVHUP /LWK hDUP£ ‘IURVW’ /DWY VDUPD LG
phonology
69
F¬ULM‘WRPHOWEXWWHU’ (3$ WVLUD 6NWyUd\DWL‘WRFRRNWRIU\’*N MKTPJOK‘WRPL[’
9RLFHG ,( ½ \LHOGHG (3$ G] LQ DOO SRVLWLRQV /DWHU G] EHFDPH$OEGK
EDUGK¬ ‘ZKLWH’ (3$ EDUG]D ,( EKHUi½ ‘WR VKLQH ZKLWH’ 6NW EKUMDWH ‘ KH VKLQHV EHDPV JOLWWHUV’ *RWK EDLUKWV ‘OLJKW VKLQLQJ’ GKHPE ‘WR DFKH’ (3$ G]HPED 6NW M¢PEKDWH ‘WR VQDS DW’ /LWK ÊHPEL¸ÊHÄEWL‘WRFXW’DQG6ODY ]?E_ ]?EWL‘WRIUHH]HWRIHHO FROG’ GK¬PE~GKDPE‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPED ,( ½RPEKR‘SHJWRRWK’ 6NWM¢PEKD‘ELWSHJ’*NIQOHQX‘SHJ’7RFK$NDP‘WRRWK’ %NHPHLG/DWY]¸REVLG6ODY ]_EÙLG GK¬QG¬U ~ GKDQG¬U ‘EULGHJURRP VRQLQODZ’ (3$ G]DQUD ,( ½HQiU‘VRQLQODZ’ /DWJHQHU NHGK‘NLG’ (3$ NDG]D 6ODY NR]D‘VKHJRDW’ UUXGK¬‘ZULQNOH’ (3$ UXG] /DWU JDLG
9RLFHGDVSLUDWH ½KPHUJHGZLWK ½LQ(3$ G]!$OEGK GUHGK‘WRWXUQWRURWDWH’ (3$ GUHG]D ,( GUH½K $UPGDàQDP ‘WRWXUQ’GDUΑFXUYHWXUQ’ GKMHV‘WRGHIHFDWH’ (3$ G]HWMD 6NWKDGDWLLG*NZG\YLG KHUGKH‘WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ DUG]DL ,( RU½KL~ ½KLLG $YGXDO iUi]*NQTZKX$UPRUML0,UXLUJJHLG PDUGK¬‘FKLOOIURVWLFH’ (3$ PDUG] 6ODY PRU]Ù‘IURVW’ YMHGK ‘WR VWHDO’ (3$ ZHG]D ,( ÆH½K 6NW Y¢KDWL ‘WR GULYH’ /DWYHKA‘WREHDUWRFDUU\’*RWKJDZLJDQ‘WRVWHDO’ ]YMHUGK ‘WR ZHDQ’ (3$ YHUG]D /LWK YHUÊL¸ YH¼ÊWL ‘WR ODFH WR WLH’/DWYYU]W‘WRWXUQ’6ODY YHU]WL‘WRELQG’ ,QRQHFDVH(3$ G]LVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEG GLP¬U ~ GLP¬Q ‘ZLQWHU’ (3$ GHLPHQD ,( ½KHLPHQ LG 6NW KHPDQORF‘LQZLQWHU’*NZGK`OC‘ZLQWHU’
70
chapter one
,Q DQODXW (3$ G] ZDV GLVVLPLODWHG WR G LI IROORZHG E\ D VLELODQW +HQFH QXPHURXV FDVHV ZLWK LQLWLDO $OE G UHIOHFWLQJ ,( ½ RU
½K GRU¬ ‘KDQG’ (3$ GU ,( ½KHVU LG *N ZGK`T +LWW NHhhDU 7RFK$WVDU%¿DU$UPMHàQ GMHUU ‘IDOORZ ODQG’ (3$ GHUVD ,( ½KHUVRV *N ZGTUQX ‘GU\ ODQG’ GULWK¬ ‘JUDLQ’ (3$ GULWV ,( ½K]G /DW KRUGHXP ‘EDUOH\’ 2+*JHUVWDLG GXD~GXH‘WRORYH’ (3$ GXVQMD GXVQMD ,( ½HXV‘WRWDVWH’ 6NWM²¿DWL‘WREHIRQGRI’*NIGWQOCK G\OO¬‘ZD[’ (3$ G OD GXVOD *NZWNQX‘MXLFH’
%HIRUH X LQFOXGLQJWKHQHZO\GHYHORSHGJOLGHRIV\OODELF !
XU (3$ WVDQG G]EHFDPH WhDQG GÊ FIDVLPLODUIDWHRIFOXVWHUV
WVZDQG G]Z VXN¬ ‘ORZ KLOO’ (3$ WVXN 6NW y ND ‘DZQ RI JUDLQ VSLNH RI LQVHFW’$YV N‘QHHGOH’ VXPEXOO‘URXQGEXWWRQ EXG’ (3$ WVXPEDFRQWLQXLQJ,( XPE FI*NMWODJ‘ERZO’2,UFRPP‘YHVVHO’ VXS ‘VKRXOGHU’ (3$ WVXSD 6NW yXSWL LG $Y VXSWL LG 0/* VFKXIW‘IURQWVKRXOGHUEODVH RIDQLPDOV ’ VXUP¬‘GDUNJUH\’ (3$ WVXUPD ,( PR /LWKhL¼PDV‘JUH\’ VXW¬ ‘IHPDOH GHHU GRH KRUQOHVV’ (3$ WVXNW ,( XN /LWK h¸NRV ‘FRPE’ h¸N^ ‘FURFN’ hXNHWDV ‘GHQWHG FKLSSHG’ /DWY VXND‘EUXVK’ ]XO¬‘VKRXWJORU\’ (3$ G]XO ,( ½KDÆi ½KHX+‘WRFDOO’ 6NWK¢YDWH$Y]DYDLWL6ODY ]ÙYDWL
$WDYHU\HDUO\VWDJHLQPDQ\ZRUGVFRQWDLQLQJVRQRUDQWVDQG
LQ SDUWLFXODU LQ WKH LPPHGLDWH FRQWDFW ZLWK VRQRUDQWV SDODWDO YHODUV ZHUHGHSDODWDOL]HGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQDQGPHUJHGZLWK“SXUH” YHODUV IOXJ¬‘VKLQJOH’ (3$ DZDOXJD ,( OHX½ 6NWUXM¢WL‘WREUHDN’ /DWO JHA‘WRPRXUQWRGHSORUH’ JDU¬ ‘FRPSHWLWLRQ UDFH’ (3$ JDU ,( ½KHU ‘WR ZLVK WR IHHO LQFOLQDWLRQ’ *N ZCKTY ‘WR UHMRLFH’ ZCTOJ ‘MR\ RI EDWWOH EDWWOHILJKW’
phonology
71
JUXU¬ ~ JUXQ¬ ‘ZKHDW’ (3$ JUXQ ,( ½¹QRP ‘JUDLQ’ /DW JUQXP2,UJU¢Q*RWKNDXUQ/LWKÊ®UQLV6ODY ]ÚUQR JMX ~ JMXl ‘NQHH’ (3$ JOXQD GLVVLPLODWHG IURP J D QXQD ,( ½HQXLG +LWWJQX6NWMdQX*NIQPW/DWJHQ NU\H‘KHDG’ (3$ NUQM NUDVQM *NMTC PKQP‘VNXOOKHDG’ PMHN¬U ‘FKLQ EHDUG’ (3$ VPHNU ,( VPHUX LG +LWW ]DPDQNXU ‘EHDUG’ 6NW yP¢yUX LG $UP PDZURZ LG /LWK VP¦NUDV‘FKLQ’
%HIRUH QRQIURQW YRZHOV ODELRYHODUV PHUJHG ZLWK “SXUH”
YHODUVLQ(3$ N J7KHLQWHUPHGLDWHVWDJHRIWKLVGHYHORSPHQWFDQEH UHFRQVWUXFWHG DV NZ JZ ,Q DOO SRVLWLRQV RWKHU WKDQ EHIRUH IURQW YRZHOV Z ZDV ORVW 7KH UHVXOWLQJ FRQVRQDQWV ZHUH LGHQWLFDO ZLWK “SXUH” YHODUV ,( á\LHOGHG(3$ N!$OEN GDUN¬‘VXSSHU’ (3$ GDUN ,( GRUáRPUHIOHFWHGLQ*NFQTRQP LG JMDN‘EORRG’ (3$ VDND *NQRQX‘MXLFH’/LWKVDND&‘UHVLQ’6ODY
VRNÙ‘MXLFH’ NROO¬‘FRXJK’ (3$ NVO ,( áV 6ODY NDhOÚLG/LWKNRVXOmV LG NULPE ~ NU\P ‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULP ZLWK XQH[SODLQHG *HJ \ ,( áPLLG 6NWN¤PL/LWKN®UPLV QGMHN‘WRIROORZWRFKDVHWRSXUVXH’ (3$ HQWHND ,( WHá‘WR UXQ WR IORZ’ 2,U WHFKLP ‘WR IOHH’ /LWK WHN¸ WHN{WL ‘WR UXQ’ 6ODY WHN_ WHNWL‘WRIORZWRUXQ’ SMHN‘WREDNHWRFRRN’ (3$ SHND ,( SHáLG 6NWS¢FDWL*N RGUUY/DWFRTXA6ODY SHN_ SHNWL
,QWKHVDPHSRVLWLRQ,( ÞJDYH(3$ JSUHVHUYHGDV$OEJ EDMJ¬‘GXQJ’ (3$ EDOJ *NDQNDKVQP‘FRZGXQJ’ EROÞ JRV¬ ‘ZDWHUKROH SLW’ (3$ JWM ,( Þ 6ODY JDWÚ JDWÙ ‘GDPSRRO’DQG6NWJW·‘SDVVDJHZD\’ JUDK~JUDI‘WRVSXURQWRFDOOWRURDU’ (3$ JUDVND ,( ÞHUi 6NWJodWL‘WRFDOOWRLQYRNH’JLUDV‘VRQJ’/LWKJLUL¸J®UWL‘WR SUDLVH’
chapter one
72
JUHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH’ (3$ JULWO /LWK JXUNOmV ‘FURS’ 23UXV JXUFOH ‘WKURDW’ 6ODY JÙUGOR LG FI DOVR ÊHUGOR ‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’ JULM~JUîM‘WRFXWLQWRSLHFHVWRJQDZWRHDWDZD\’ (3$ JULQMD ,( ÞHUi ‘WR VZDOORZ’ 6NW JLU¢WL $UP HNHU /DW YRUA /LWK JHUL¸J©UWL‘WRGULQN’6ODY ÊHUWL JXU‘VWRQHURFN’ (3$ JXUD ,( ÞHUi‘PRXQWDLQ’ 6NWJLU$Y JDLUL/LWKJLUL£‘ZRRG’/DWYG]LULDLG6ODY JRUD‘PRXQWDLQ ZRRG’
7KHVDPHFRQWLQXDQW$OEJ (3$ JUHVXOWVIURP,( ÞK GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ (3$ GHJD ,( GKHÞK ‘WR EXUQ’ 6NW G¢KDWL 7RFK$%WVDNWV¥N/LWGHJ¸GªJWL JDUEH ‘IORZHUSRW’ (3$ JDULE ,( ÞKHU ‘WR EXUQ’ FI 6ODY
JÙUQÙ‘RYHQSRW’ QJURK~QJURI‘WRZDUP’ (3$ HQJUMD ,( ÞKHU 6ODY JUpM_
JUpWL‘WRZDUP’
3DODWDOL]DWLRQV &KURQRORJLFDOO\WKHILUVWSDODWDOL]DWLRQLQ$OEDQLDQZDVWKDWRI
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
WVZ DQG G]Z ZKLFK \LHOGHG (3$ Wh DQG GÊ DV GLG WKH FOXVWHUV FRQWLQXLQJ ÆDQG ½Æ /LWHUDWXUH 0$11 +LVW *U 25(/ =I%DON ;;,,, GLIIHUHQWUHIOH[HVRI UMGHSHQGLQJRQWKHSODFHRIVWUHVV
%HIRUH IURQW YRZHOV ,( á JDYH (3$ Wh ZKLFK ODWHU GHYHORSHGLQWR$OEV
phonology
73
PRV ‘QRW’ SURKLE (3$ PWh ,( P áH FI *N OJVG ‘DQG QRW’ SHV¬~SêV¬‘ILYH’ (3$ SHQWhH ,( SHQáH‘ILYH’ 6NWS¢±FD*N RGPVG/DWTXQTXH VDUN¬ ‘EXLOG IUDPH ILJXUH RI KXPDQ ERG\ ’ (3$ WhHUN ,( áHU‘WRPDNHWREXLOG’ 6NWNDUeWL/LWKN¸UWL VMHOO ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ WhHOD ,( áHO 6NW F¢UDWL ‘WR PRYH WR ZDON’*NRGNY‘WRFRPHLQWRH[LVWHQFHWREHFRPH’/DWFROA ‘WRFXOWLYDWHWRWLOO’ VRUU¬ ‘FURZ’ (3$ WhUVQ FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR 6NW N¿o¢ ‘EODFN GDUN’23UXVNLUVQDQ‘EODFN’6ODY ¨ÚUQÙLG V\‘H\H’ (3$ DWhZL 6NWDN¿À$YDhL/LWKDN®6ODY R¨L ,QRQHFDVHWKHRULJLQDO3URWR$OEDQLDQDIIULFDWHPLJKWEHSUHVHUYHG 笑ZKDW’ (3$ WhL ,( áLG +LWWNXLW*NVK/DWTXLG +RZHYHU ç¬ DSSHDUV WR FRQWLQXH D V\QWDFWLF FRPSOH[ SUREDEO\ ,(
áRGVR 1HYHUWKHOHVVWKHDIIULFDWHDSSHDUVWREHSUHVHUYHGLQDWOHDVWRQHFDVH FLW¬‘IXOOEULPIXOO’ (3$ WVHLWD ,( áHiWRV 6ODY ¨LWÙ‘ZKROH’ /LWKNHWDV‘KDUG’ 7KHDIIULFDWH Wh!VUHVXOWHGIURP áEHIRUH QLV ‘WR VWDUW WR EHJLQ WR SUHSDUH IRU MRXUQH\’ (3$ QHLWhD ,( QHLáA /LWK VXQ®NWL ‘WR VHW XSRQ WR DWWDFN’ 6ODY QLNQ_WL ‘WRULVHWRJURZ’ YGHV ‘WR GLH’ (3$ DZDWDNMD ,( WHá ‘WR UXQ WR IORZ’ 2,U WHFKLP‘WRIOHH’/LWKWHN¸WHN{WL‘WRUXQ’6ODY WHN_ WHNWL‘WR IORZWRUXQ’
%HIRUHIURQWYRZHOVDQG M,( ÞEHFDPH(3$ GÊ!$OE][ P]LWK‘DQNOH’EDVHGRQ(3$ GÊLMD ,( ÞL‘WHQGRQERZVWULQJ’ 6NWM\d$YÎ\*NDKQX Q[LW‘WRXUJHWRVWLPXODWHWRKXUU\’ (3$ GÊLWD,( Þ‘WROLYH’ 6NWMÀYDWL/DWYYA2(FZLFX‘DOLYHOLYLQJ’!(TXLFN
chapter one
74
]¬~]Dˆ ‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVSWRWRXFK’ (3$ GÊHLQD ,( ÞHi‘WR RYHUSRZHU’ 6NWM\d‘IRUFHSRZHU’M¢\DWL‘WRZLQWRFRQTXHU’ *NDKJ‘SRZHU’ ]L ‘EODFN’ (3$ GÊHGL ,( ÞHG 0+* TXW ‘GLUW’ 2( FZ©DG ‘EDG’ /LWK J{GD ‘VKDPH’ 6ODY JDGÙNÙ ‘GLVJXVWLQJ’ JDGÙ ‘UHSWLOHZRUP’ ]RUU¬ ‘JXW’ (3$ GÊUQ ,( ÞHUi ‘WR VZDOORZ’ /LWK ÊDUQ£ ‘JXW’
,( ÞK PHUJHV ZLWK Þ LQ (3$ GÊ ! $OE ] EHIRUH D IURQW YRZHORU M
QGH] ‘WR VHW DOLJKW WR LJQLWH’ (3$ HQGDGÊMD FDXVDWLYH ,(
GKRÞKHA ,( GKHÞK‘WREXUQ’ ]MHM‘WRERLOWRFRRN’ (3$ GÊHUQMD ,( ÞKHU *NSGTQOCK‘WR EHFRPHKRWWRZDUPWREXUQ’2,UIRJHLU‘ KH ZDUPV’ ]MDUU ‘ILUH’ (3$ GÊHUD ,( ÞKHUHV 6NW K¢UDV ‘IODPH KHDW’ *NSGTQX‘VXPPHU’$UPÎHULG
(3$ W GDQG [ V \LHOGHG Wh GÊDQG hEHIRUH M,(
W!(3$ Wh!V
GMHUV¬‘SHUVSLUDWLRQ’ (3$ ZLGHUWM *NKFTYXLG VÆLGUAWV QXV ‘WKUHDG VWULQJ’ *HJ (3$ VQXWMD ,( VQHX ‘WR WXUQ WR VSLQ’ 6NWVQdYDQ‘EDQGVLQHZ’ SUHV ‘WR ZDLW WR H[SHFW’ (3$ SUDWMD *RWK IUDÈMDQ ‘WR WKLQN WR XQGHUVWDQG’/LWKSUDQW¸SU£VWL‘WRJHWXVHGWRXQGHUVWDQG’ S\HV ‘WR DVN’ (3$ S WD /DW SXWA ‘WR UHFNRQ WR SRQGHU’ 6ODY
S\WDWL‘WRDVN’ VKNDV‘WRVOLSWRVOLGH’ (3$ VNDWMDFRUUHVSRQGLQJWR/DWVFDWHA ‘WRVWUHDPWRIORZRXW’/LWKVNDQW¸VN£VWL‘WRVSULQJWRMXPS’ WUHV ‘WR PHOW WR ORRVHQ WR GLVVROYH’ (3$ WUAWMD 6ODY WUDWM_
WUDWLWL‘WRVSHQGWRZDVWH’ 2FFDVLRQDOO\DPRUHDUFKDLFVWDJHRI(3$ Wh!$OEFLVSUHVHUYHG FI WKHVLPLODUGHYHORSPHQWRI á! Wh!FEHIRUHDIURQWYRZHORU M EDF‘HOGHUEURWKHUXQFOH’ (3$ EDWMD 6ODY EDW’D~ EDWMD‘HOGHU EURWKHUIDWKHU’ PMDOF¬‘EHH’ (3$ PHOLWM *NOGNKUUC OGNKVMCLG
phonology
75
,Q WKH VDPH SRVLWLRQ (3$ G JRLQJ EDFN WR ,( G DQG GK EHFRPHV GÊ!$OE] EUX] ‘EOXH LQGLJR’ (3$ EUXGMD ,( EKURXGK 6ODY EUXGÙ ‘GLUW’ EUXGÚQÙ‘GLUW\’ EX]¬ ‘OLS HQG HGJH EDQN VWLWFK URFN’ (3$ EXGM /LWK EXG| ‘WUHHIXQJXVWLQGHUZKHWVWRQH’ JMD]¬ ‘ULYHUVLGH IRUHVW’ (3$ VHGMD ,( VHG ‘WR VLW WR EH VHWWOHG’FILQSDUWLFXODU6ODY VDGÙ‘JDUGHQJURYH’ OR] ‘WR PRYH WR VKDNH WR SOD\’ (3$ OGMD 6ODY ODGÙ ‘RUGHU SHDFH’ ODGLWL‘WRPDNHRUGHUWRPDNHSHDFH’ P¬]~ PDˆ]‘IRDO’ (3$ PDQGMDGHULYHGIURPP¬QG‘WRIHHGWR VXFNOH’ ,( PD]G
7KH GHYHORSPHQW RI ,( VM ! [M LQWR h ! $OE VK LV ZHOO DWWHVWHG JMHVK‘WRNQHDG’ (3$ MHVMD 6NW\¢V\DWL‘WRERLO’*N\GY‘WRERLO WRFRRN’ VKRVK‘WRVLIW’ (3$ VMVMD *NJ SGYLG/LWKVLM²MXVLM²WLLG6ODY
VpMDWLLG VKRW¬‘ELJGXFN’ (3$ VMXW :KZ\DGLG2&RUQKRHWLG%UHW KRXDWLG YHVK‘WRSXWRQ FORWKHV WRFRYHU’ (3$ ZHVMDWR ÆHV 6NWY¢VWH ‘WR ZHDU WR EH GUHVVHG LQ’ *N GPPWOK ‘WR GUHVV’ DQG LQ SDUWLFXODU6NWYV¢\DWLDQG*RWKZDVMDQLG (3$ WVDQG G]UHIOHFWLQJ,QGR(XURSHDQSDODWDOV\LHOGHG WhDQG GÊ EHIRUH M GUL]¬‘EODFNWKRUQVORH’ (3$ GULG]M ,( GHU½K‘WRKROGWREH ILUP’ 6NW GK\DWL ‘WR EH ILUP’ 6ODY GÚUÊDWL WR KROG’
GÚU]MDWL DQG LQ SDUWLFXODU GÚU]D ! 5XVV GHUH]D ‘NLQG RI WKRUQ\SODQW’ VLYMHW‘WKLV\HDU’ (3$ WVMHLZHWHLGDWORFVJFRQWLQXLQJ,( HL ÆHWHL VRW ‘WRGD\’ (3$ WVM L GWL GDWORF VJ FRQWLQXLQJ ,( GWL YLVH ‘SODFH’ (3$ ZWVM ,( ÆHL VLPLODU WR *N QKMKC ‘GZHOOLQJKRXVH’
76
chapter one
+RZHYHU LQ FHUWDLQ FDVHV SDODWDO YHODUV ZHUH GHSDODWDOL]HG LQ 3URWR $OEDQLDQ DQG WKHLU GHYHORSPHQW EHIRUH M ZDV LGHQWLFDO ZLWK WKDW RI “SXUH”YHODUV N¬QDT ‘WR SOHDVH WR VDWLVI\’ (3$ NDQDNMD *RWK JDQDK ‘WR EH HQRXJK’2+*JLQDKLG)XUWKHUUHODWHGWR,( QH 6NWQ¢yDWL ‘WRUHDFK’
8QGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRI/3$ MVRQRUDQWVZHUHDOVRSDODWDOL]HG ZLWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI P %HIRUH M /3$ O ZDV UHWDLQHG /DWHU LW RFFDVLRQDOO\FKDQJHGWRMWKRXJK çDO¬‘ODPH’ (3$ hWhDOMD *NUMQNKQX‘FURRNHG’/DWVFHOXV çHO‘WRRSHQ’ (3$ hWhHOMD +LWWLhNDOOL‘WRWHDUXS’21VNLOMD‘WR VSOLW’/LWKVNHOL¸VN©OWLLG GDO‘WRJRRXW’ (3$ GDOMD *NSCNNY‘WREORRP’ KDO¬ ‘ILVK ERQH VSOLQWHU SLQH’ (3$ VNDOM /LWK VNDO£ ‘VWLFN RI ILUHZRRG’/DWYVNDOD‘VSOLQWHU XVHGWRIXUQLVKOLJKW ’ PDM¬‘WLSWRSSRLQWSHDNVXPPLW’ (3$ PDOM /LWKPDO£‘ODQG’ /DWYPDOD‘EDQNVKRUH’ YMHO‘WRSOXFN IUXLW WRYLQWDJH’ (3$ ZHOMD *NGKNY‘WRVKXWLQ WRSUHVV’/LWKVXYDOØWL‘WRKDUYHVWWRUHDS’
,Q WKH VDPH SRVLWLRQ Q FKDQJHG WR $OE QM 7KH ODWWHU GHYHORSHGLQWRMLQVRPHGLDOHFWVDQGLQFHUWDLQPRUSKRORJLFDOFODVVHV &IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV E¬M~EDˆM‘WRGRWRPDNH’ (3$ EDQMD *NHCKPY‘WRDSSHDU’ EUHM ~ EUêM ‘WR JQDZ’ (3$ EUDLQMD ,( EKUHL ‘WR FXW’ 6NW EKUodWL‘ KH LQMXUHV’/DWIULA‘WRUXE’6ODY EULWL‘WRVKDYH’ KXDM ~ KXHM ‘IRUHLJQ VWUDQJH’ (3$ NVQMD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK LVRODWHG*NEGPQX'RUEGP®QX‘VWUDQJHUJXHVW’ P¬OOHQM¬ ‘EODFNELUG’ (3$ PHODQM ,(IHP DGM PHOiQ ‘EODFN’ *NOGNCKPCLGFIDOVR6NWPDOLQ¢IHPPDOLQ‘GLUW\ XQFOHDQ/DWYP?ËQV‘EODFN’ QMHU QMHUL ‘PDQ SHUVRQ KXPDQ EHLQJ’ (3$ QHUD 6NW Q¢U ‘PDQ’*NC PJTLG$UPD\ULG WKLQM¬ ‘JUD\ KDLU’ (3$ WVLQMD 6NW y\Y¢ ‘GDUN EURZQ’ $Y V\YD‘EODFN’6ODY VLYÙ‘GDUNJUD\’
phonology
77
,Q/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQ QZDVDOVRSDODWDOL]HGDQGFKDQJHGWRQMDWWKH HQG RI WKH ZRUG EHIRUH DXVODXWLQJ L DL IRXQG LQ SOXUDOV RI VXEVWDQWLYHV +RZHYHU LI L ZDV IROORZHG E\ D FRQVRQDQW WKH SUHFHGLQJ QZDVQRWSDODWDOL]HG+HQFHQXPHURXVSOXUDOVLQQM QL (3$ QDLRIQRXQVLQQDUHLQFRQWUDVWZLWKSOSUHVHQWRIYHUEVLQ Q QLW (3$ QW
,( UEHIRUH MJLYHV$OEUU GHUU‘SLJ’ (3$ GDUMD *NZQK`TQXLG ,( ½KRURV ¬QG¬UU ~ DQG¬UU ‘GUHDP VOHHS’ (3$ DQUM ,( RQHUR *N QPGKTQPQPGKTQX$UPDQRZUÎ VKSHUU‘WRZLQ PRQH\ WRJDLQ’ (3$ VSDUMD *PF VSDUAMDQ‘WR OHDYH XQKDUPHG WR NHHS’ 21 VSDUD 2+* VSDUAQ 2( VSDULDQ VKTHUU‘WRWHDU FORWK ’ (3$ LhNHUMD 6NWNoWL‘WRGLPLQLVK’*N MGKTY‘WRFXW’
$W D ODWHU FKURQRORJLFDO VWDJH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ YHODUV ZHUH
SDODWDOL]HG EHIRUH M ~ RI DQ\ RULJLQ LQFOXGLQJ DV WKH ILUVW FRPSRQHQWRIDGLSKWKRQJ EHIRUHGLSKWKRQJVLQ LDVZHOODV DQG
ºERWKROGDQGQHZ,QWKLVHQYLURQPHQWJM JDQGT N
GHUJM‘WROLHGRZQWROD\VLFNWREHLOO’ (3$ GHUJMD /LWKG®UJLQWL ‘WR PRYH’ G®UJWL ‘WR ORVH HQHUJ\ WR EHFRPH ZHDN’ 6ODY
GÚUJDWL‘WRSOXFNWRSXOO’DQG*PF WDUJMDQ‘WRWHDU’ NHT‘EDGHYLO’ (3$ NDNMD *NMCMQX‘EDG’ THOO ‘WR KDOW WR KROG XS WR FDUU\’ (3$ NHOD 6NW NDO¢\DWL ‘WR LPSHO’*NMGNQOCK‘WRGULYHRQ’ THWK ‘WR FXW KDLU ’ (3$ NDLWVD 6NW N©yD ‘KDLU RI WKH KHDG ’ /LWKN¢LVWL‘WRVFUDSHWRVKDYH’ TLSL ‘VWDFN’ (3$ N SD 23HUV NDXID ‘PRXQWDLQ’ 2+* KXIR ‘KHDS’ 2( K©DS LG DQG DOVR KRXI LG /LWK N¢XSDV LG 6ODY
NXSDLG T\O‘VOLPHPXG’ (3$ N OD /LWKNgOD‘RXWJURZWK‘6ODY N\ODLG UHJM‘WRWDQ’ (3$ UDXJMD 21UH\NU‘VPRNH’2+*URXKLG
78
chapter one
5K\WKPLFUXOH $ VSHFLDO FKDQJH DIIHFWLQJ LQWHUYRFDOLF YRLFHG RFFOXVLYHV LQ
FHUWDLQ FRQGLWLRQV FDQ EH REVHUYHG LQ /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,W WDNHV SODFH ERWK LQ $OEDQLDQ ZRUGV RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ RULJLQ DQG LQ /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV ZKHUH LWV HIIHFWV FDQ EH EHWWHU IROORZHG 7KH FKDQJH LV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK WKH V\OODELF VWUXFWXUH RI ZRUGV DQG WKHUHIRUH PXVW EH OLQNHG WR WKH WUDQVIRUPDWLRQ RI DFFHQWXDO SDWWHUQV LQ /DWH 3URWR $OEDQLDQ /LWHUDWXUH Ç$%(- 6W ,,, 25(/ 6%-D .RQWDNW\ DFFHQWXDOFRQGLWLRQVRIWKHUK\WKPLFUXOH .$/8ä6.$-$$QWL¨EDON ORVVRILQWHUYRFDOLFRFFOXVLYHV 586$.295%
3URWR$OEDQLDQLQWHUYRFDOLFYRLFHGRFFOXVLYHVDUHSUHVHUYHGLQ GLV\OODELF ZRUGV ZKHUH WKH\ GHYHORS DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH UXOHV RI /3$ E\LHOGV$OEE GJLYHV$OEGKDQG JUHPDLQVXQFKDQJHGDV$OE J GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ (3$ GHJD ,( GKHÞK ‘WR EXUQ’ 6NW G¢KDWL 7RFK$%WVDNWV¥N/LWGHJ¸GªJWL GUHJ¬ ‘VFDE’ (3$ GUDJ :HVW *PF WDUJMDQ ‘WR SXOO WR VWLU’ *HUP]HUJHQ 6ODY GÚUJDWL‘WRSXOOWRWXJ’/LWKG®UJLQWL‘WR PRYHWRLUULWDWH’ JOHGK¬ ‘FDUHVV’ (3$ JODG /DW JODEHU ‘VPRRWK’ 2+* JODW ‘VKLQLQJ HYHQ VPRRWK’ /LWK JORG¸V ‘VPRRWK’ 6ODY JODGÙNÙ LG JODGLWL‘WRFDUHVV’ JUDE¬‘HURVLRQKROORZLQJRXW’ (3$ JUDE ,( JKUHEK‘WRGLJ’ 2+*JUDE‘JUDYH’6ODY JUREÙLG UUDEH‘URFN\GHVHUW ZLWKEXVKHV ’ (3$ UDXED *RWKUDXSMDQ‘WR ULS’2+*URXIHQLG WUHGK ‘WR FDVWUDWH’ (3$ WUHXGD /DW WU GA ‘WR SXVK’ *RWK XV ÈULXWDQ‘WREXUGHQ’6ODY WUXGÙ‘ODERUZRUN’
7KHVDPHUHVXOWVDUHREVHUYHGLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGVZKHUH/DWG DQGJDUHVXEVWLWXWHGE\$OEGKDQGJ ZHKDYHQRUHOLDEOHH[DPSOHVIRU ELQWKLVSRVLWLRQ ELJ¬ ‘IRUNHG VWLFN EUDQFK GRXEOHFUHVWHG PRXQWDLQ’ Õ /DW EJD ‘SDLURIDQLPDOV WHDPIRUSORXJKLQJ’
phonology
79
PRGK‘EXVKHO’Õ/DWPRGXV‘PHDVXUH’ SODJ¬‘ZRXQG’Õ/DWSOJDLG UUXJ¬‘VWUHHW’Õ5RP U JDLG /DWU JD‘ZULQNOH’
,Q SRO\V\OODELF ZRUGV LQWHUYRFDOLF YRLFHG RFFOXVLYHV FKDQJHG WR IULFDWLYHV D F I ZKLFK HYHQWXDOO\ PHUJHG ZLWK /3$ [ DQG HLWKHU ZHUH ORVW RU LQ D IHZ FDVHV ZHUH SUHVHUYHG DV $OE K 7KH IROORZLQJFDVHVFRUURERUDWHWKHUK\WKPLFUXOH GHW ‘VHD’ (3$ GHXEHWD ‘GHSWK’ ,( GKHXE ‘GHHS’ FI *PF
GHXSLÈA‘GHSWK’!0'XGLHSGH0/*GSHGH(GHSWK NLM ‘WR SUXQH WR WULP’ (3$ GHQRPLQDWLYH NDGLQMD UHODWHG WR NDGK¬ ‘SUXQLQJNQLIH ELOOKRRN ZLWK ORQJ KDQGOH’ ,( V NH Q G 6NW VNKDGDWH ‘WR VSOLW’ *N UMGFCPPWOK ‘WR VFDWWHUWRGLVSHUVH’ QJH ‘WLPH OHLVXUH FKDQFH RSSRUWXQLW\’ (3$ HQJDG 6ODY
JRGÙ‘WLPH\HDU’ UUXVK‘JUDSH’ (3$ UJXhD *NT CELG,QWHUPHGLDWHVWDJHVRIWKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ GHYHORSPHQW DUH UHIOHFWHG LQ WKH QDPH RI ,OO\U 5DJXVD~ 5DJXVLXP‘4CQWUC VRW‘WRGD\’ (3$GDWORFVJ WVM L GWL ,( GWL Y¬OOD‘EURWKHU’ (3$ VZHODXGFRPSRVLWHRISURQRPLQDO,( VÆH DQG ODXG ,( OHXGK 2+*OLXW‘SHRSOH’6ODY OMXGÙLG $ OLPLWHG QXPEHU RI H[FHSWLRQV DUH NQRZQ ,Q WZR FDVHV WUDGLWLRQDO UHFRQVWUXFWLRQVPXVWEHPRGLILHGLQRUGHUWRFRPSO\ZLWKWKHUK\WKPLF UXOH EH ‘RDWK’ (3$ EDLGHV UDWKHU WKDQ EDLG 6ODY EpGD ‘GLVDVWHU’ /DW IRHGXV ‘OHDJXH WUHDW\’ 7KH $OEDQLDQ ZRUG LV D UHVKDSHGVVWHPVLPLODUWRWKDWRI/DWLQ GUD ~ GUDˆ ‘RLOFDNH PHOWHG EXWWHU’ (3$ GUDJLM UDWKHU WKDQ
GUDJ 21SOGUHJJLDU‘\HDVW’23UXVGUDJLRV‘\HDVW’2/LWK GUDJ^VLG/HWWGLDOGUDG]L‘VHGLPHQWLQPHOWHGEXWWHU’ 2QHFDVHUHPDLQVREVFXUHDQGPD\QHHGDUHYLVLRQRILWVHW\PRORJ\ KD‘WRHDW’ (3$ HGVNDGHULYHGIURP,( HGLGUDWKHUWKDQ(3$
HGD
80
chapter one
7KHVDPHFKDQJHWRRNSODFHLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV EXMN‘SHDVDQW’Õ/DWEXEXOFXV‘SORXJKPDQKHUGVPDQ’ NDO¬‘KRUVH’Õ/DWFDEDOOXVLG NUHVKP¬‘IDVW’Õ/DWTXGUJVLPD‘/HQWIDVWRIIRUW\GD\V’ PMHN‘SK\VLFLDQGRFWRU’Õ/DWPHGLFXVLG PMHVKW¬U‘PDVWHUEXLOGHU’Õ/DWPDJLVWHU‘PDVWHU’ S\OO‘IRUHVW’Õ5RP SDG OHP /DWSDO GHP‘VZDPS’ :RUGV ZLWK QR WUDFHV RI WKH UK\WKPLF UXOH EHORQJ WR D ODWHU OD\HU RI /DWLQORDQZRUGV DGKXURM‘WRDGRUH’Õ/DWDGRUUHLG UUHJXOO‘UXOHQRUP’Õ/DWUJXODLG UUREXOO‘PRXQWDLQSLQH’Õ/DWUAEXU‘RDN’ WUDVK¬JRM‘WRLQKHULW’Õ/DWWUQVLJHUH‘WRUHDFKDQDFFRUGWRFDUU\ RXWWUDQVDFWLRQ’ ,QWZRFDVHV$OEDQLDQZRUGVVKRXOGEHUHLQWHUSUHWHGDVGLDOHFWDO,WDOLDQ ORDQZRUGVUDWKHUWKDQERUURZLQJVIURP/DWLQ IH‘EHOLHI’YD‘IRUG’
&RQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV &RQVRQDQWDO FOXVWHUV XQGHUZHQW GUDVWLF FKDQJHV LQ 3URWR $OEDQLDQDQGDWODWHUVWDJHV /LWHUDWXUH 3('(56(1$OE7H[WH FOXVWHUVZLWK Z .=;;;9, VÆ! G PHUJHURI VNDQG V ,( WW!V GHYHORSPHQW RI JQ -2./ 6WXGLHQ VÆ ! G ,) ;;; RQ VN V /.8%$ FOXVWHUV ZLWK OLTXLGD ,( WW 0©ODQJHV 3HGHUVHQ GHYHORSPHQW RI Æ WR Wh %$5IC´ $$UE6W ,,, GHYHORSPHQW RI VN V 7$*/,$9,1, 'DOPD]LD FOXVWHUVZLWK Z 0$11/DQJXDJH;9,, UQ!UU ;;9,,, GHSDODWDOL]DWLRQRISDODWDOV GHYHORSPHQWRI VU VO +LVW *U &,02&+2:6., %86K7 ;,,, *C7(56 .= /;;,,, GHYHORSPHQW RI,( UÆ 62/7$ ,) /;; $OEDQLDQ$UPHQLDQ SDUDOOHOV /%(5* *HGHQNVFKU %UDQGHQVWHLQ +$03 .=/;;9,, ,( WW Ç$%(- 6SUDFKH;9,,, UHIOH[HVRI VN V 6W,,,,9 JURXSV QG QJ ,9 VN!VK QW!XQUKRWDFL]HGQ ÆU
phonology
81
!UU 586$.29 /,V 25(/ $QWL¨EDON ,( GÆ !$OEEEHIRUHIURQWYRZHOV /%;;9,,, FOXVWHUV VS VW
VN
$OOFOXVWHUVFRQVLVWLQJRIOLTXLGVRQRUDQWVIROORZHGE\(3$ Z FKDQJHG LQ WKH VDPH GLUHFWLRQ WKH\ ORVW WKHLU VHFRQG HOHPHQW ZKLOH PRGLI\LQJWKHILUVWRQH(3$ OZ\LHOGHG$OEOO DPXOO ‘VWDJQDQW RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ DPXOZD /LWK PXËY^ ‘VLOW PDUVK’P¸OWL‘WRJHWGLUW\’ GLHOO‘VXQ’ (3$ GHOZD 6NWK¢UL‘SDOH\HOORZLVK’$Y]DLULLG /DWKHOYXV‘\HOORZLVK’/LWKÊHËYDVLG JMDOO¬‘DOLYH’ (3$ VDOZD 6NWV¢UYD‘FRPSOHWHZKROH’*NQNQX ‘ZKROH’/DWVDOYXV‘KHDOWK\’7RFK$VDOX‘FRPSOHWHO\’ PLHOO‘IORXU’ (3$ PHOZD ,( PHOÆR 2+*P¬ORLG21PM_O LG6ODY PHOYR‘JUDLQIRUJULQGLQJ’ YMHOO‘WRYRPLW’ (3$ ZHOZD /DWYROYA‘WRWXUQ’ $VIDUDV(3$ UZLVFRQFHUQHGLWLQYDULDEO\JDYH$OEUU DUU¬ ‘ZDOQXWWUHH ZDOQXW’ (3$ DUZ *N CTWC VC> * TCMNGYVKMC>MCTWC+HV EHUU ‘VKHHS JRDW’ (3$ EDUZD 21 ERUJU ‘KRJ’ 2+* EDUXJ EDUXKLG6ODY ERUYÙ‘ERDU’ PRUU‘ORXVH’ (3$ PUZD 2,UPRLUE‘DQW’6ODY PRUYÙLG WKLUU‘VRRW’ (3$ WVLUZD /LWKhL¼YDV‘JUD\’ YHUU¬‘KROH’ (3$ ZHUZ 6NWXU·‘ZLGH’Y¢UDV‘VSDFHZLGWK’ *NGWTWX‘ZLGH’ (3$ ZUJDYHWKHVDPHUHVXOWVDV UZ UUD‘EHOO\ZRUP’ (3$ ZUDJ 2,UIULJH‘YHUPLQIOHVKZRUP’
ÆJ UUDK ‘WR EHDW WR VWULNH’ (3$ ZUDJVND *N TCUUY LG ,(
ÆUJK UU¬QM¬~UUDQM¬‘URRW RDN’ (3$ ZUDGQM *NTCFKE‘EUDQFK’LG /DWUG[‘URRW’:JZUDLGG UULPH ‘UDLQZRUP’ (3$ ZULPD ,( ÆPL ~ ÆPR ‘ZRUP’ /DW YHUPLV LG *RWK ZD·UPV ‘ZRUP VQDNH’ /LWK YD¼PDV ‘LQVHFW’
82
chapter one UULV‘WRSXOOXSWRPRYHXSWRLQFUHDVHWRJURZ’ (3$ ZULWMD ,( ÆHUW ‘WR WXUQ’ 6NW YDUWDWH /DW YHUWA *RWK ZDLUÈDQ ‘WR EHFRPH’ UUXP ‘FODSSHU PDL]HFRE VWULSSHG RI FRUQV’ (3$ ZUXEQD *N TCO PQX‘WKRUQ\EXVK’ ÆEQR
(3$ ZORVWEHIRUHDOOYRZHOVZKHQIROORZLQJDQRFFOXVLYH ERW¬‘HDUWK ZRUOG’ (3$ EZWEDVHGRQ,( EKHXi~ EK ‘WR EHWRJURZ’ GDN ‘ELJ UDP’ (3$ GZDND /LWK GY|NWL ‘WR EUHDWKH’ GY¦NDV ‘EUHDWK’ GHJ¬‘WZLJEUDQFK’ (3$ GZDLJ 2+*]ZJLG*HUP=ZHLJ GHU¬ ‘GRRU’ (3$ GZAU ,( GKÆHU LG 6NW GYdU *N SWTC 7RFK%WZHUH JMHWK‘IROLDJHJUHHQOHDYHV’ (3$ JDG]D 2+*TXHVWD‘WXIW’21 NXLVWU‘EUDQFK’6ODY JYR]GÚ‘ZRRGIRUHVW’ NHP‘LQFHQVH’ (3$ NDSQD ,( NÆS *NMCRPQX‘VPRNH’ W¬U¬ ~ WDQ¬ ‘ZKROH DOO’ (3$ WZDQD WÆRQR ,( WHXi ‘WR VZHOO’ FILQSDUWLFXODU/LWKWY®QWL‘WRULVHWRVZHOO RIZDWHU ’ WY¦QDV‘IORRG’ (3$ VZ LV FRQFHUQHG LW ORVW LWV ILUVW HOHPHQW DQG JDYH $OE Y FI WKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV YDM]¬ ‘JLUO’ EDVHG RQ YDU¬ (3$ VZHVDU 6NW VY¢VDU $UP R\U/DWVRURU YHKWH‘VHOI’ (3$ VZDMD ZLWKDVHFRQGDU\VXIIL[W ,( VÆRRV ‘RZQ’ 6ODY VYRMÚ23UXVVZDLV Y¬OOD‘EURWKHU’ (3$ VZHODXGFRPSRVLWHRISURQRPLQDO,( VÆH DQG ODXG ,( OHXGK 2+*OLXW‘SHRSOH’6ODY OMXGÙLG YMHK¬UU ‘PRWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZH[XU ZLWK DVVLPLODWLRQ IURP H[SHFWHG VZHWVXU ,( VÆHU 6NWyYDyUgPRWKHULQODZ’ /DWVRFUXVLG :KHQIROORZHGE\ Z3URWR$OEDQLDQDIIULFDWHV WVDQG G]FKDQJHGWR
Wh DQG GÊ H[DFWO\ DV LQ WKH SRVLWLRQ EHIRUH X 7KH VDPH SURFHVV DIIHFWHGZRUGVEHJLQQLQJLQ ZLWV! ZG]! G]Z! GÊ
phonology
83
VDP¬‘GRJ’VH[FUHPHQWV’ (3$ WVZD Q PDDGHULYDWLYHLQ PR RIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQZRUGIRU‘GRJ’FI6NWyY*NMWYP2,U F·/LWKhX¶ ]HW ‘WZHQW\’ (3$ Z WVDW ,( ÆW LG 6NW YLayDW *N GKMQUK/DWYJLQW ]¬~]Dˆ‘YRLFH’ (3$ G]ZDQD ,( ½KÆHQ $UPMDLQ‘YRLFH’6ODY
]YRQÙ‘ULQJLQJVRXQG’ ]RW‘ORUGPDVWHUJRG’ (3$ Z L WVSDWL 6NWYLySDWL‘ORUGRIWKH KRXVH’
&RQVRQDQWDO FOXVWHUV M XVXDOO\ ORVW RU PRGLILHG WKHLU ILUVW HOHPHQW7KHQWKHSDODWDOL]DWLRQWRRNSODFH (3$ EQM!$OE Q M JMDM‘WRUHVHPEOHWREHOLNH WRVXLWWREHFRPH WRVHHP WRKDSSHQ’ (3$ JDODEQMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH YHUE EDVHG RQ ODE /LWK O¦EDV‘JRRG’/DWYODEVLG NUXDM~NUXHM‘WRVFUDWFK’ (3$ NUEQMDIXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK,(
JKUHEK YHM ‘WR ZHDYH’ (3$ ZHEQMD 6NW XEKQdWL ‘WR ODFH XS’ 2+* ZHEDQ‘WRZHDYH’7RFK%ZSLG (3$ GQM!$OE Q M JMHM~JMHˆj ‘WRILQG’ (3$ JDGQMD *NZCPFCPYDRUGZCFQP‘WR VHL]HWRJUDVS’/DWSUHKHQGALG21JHWDLG OHM‘WR JLYH ELUWK WR EH ERUQ WR ULVH RI WKH VXQ ’ (3$ ODLGQMD /LWKO©LVWL‘WROHW’/DWYODîVWLG OXDM ~ OXHM ‘WR PRYH WR VKDNH WR SOD\’ (3$ OGQMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH YHUE FRQQHFWHG ZLWK 6ODY ODGÙ ‘RUGHU SHDFH’
ODGLWL‘WRPDNHRUGHUWRPDNHSHDFH’ UU¬QM¬~UUDQM¬‘URRW RDN’ (3$ ZUDGQM *NTCFKE‘EUDQFK’LG /DWUG[‘URRW’:JZUDLGG (3$ JQM!$OE Q M ERMERKHW‘WRPDWH’ (3$ EJQMD /LWKE{JWL‘WRUXQ’/DWYEHl JW LG23UXVEHJH\WHLG6ODY EpJWLLG*NHGDQOCKLG
84
chapter one HQM¬‘MXQLSHU\HZ’ (3$ DLJQMUHODWHGWRWKH*HUPDQLFZRUGIRU ‘RDN’ 21HLN2+*HLK HQM¬~êM¬‘GDLU\JRDW’ (3$ DJQM *NCOPQX‘ODPE’/DWDJQXV LG UXDM~UXHM‘WRJXDUGWRNHHSWRREVHUYH’ (3$ UJQMD 21Uø´NMD ‘WRWDNHFDUHRI’*NCTJIY‘WRDVVLVWWRGHIHQG’ XM¬‘ZDWHU’ (3$ XGQM ,( ÆHG~ ÆRGLG (3$ NQM!$OEQM SU¬QMN¬ ‘IUHFNOH VXQVSRW’ GHULYDWLYH LQ N¬ RI (3$ SULNQM 6NW S¤yQL‘VSRWWHGVSHFNOHG’*NRGTMPQX‘GDUNVSRWWHG’:HUFK ‘VSRWWHG’ (3$ UQM!$OE Q M PEDM‘WRKROGWRFDUU\’ (3$ HQEDUQMDDFDXVDWLYHUHODWHGWR,(
EKHU‘WREHDU’ ]LHM‘WRERLOWRFRRN’ (3$ GÊHUQMD ,( ÞKHU *NSGTQOCK‘WR EHFRPHKRWWRZDUPWREXUQ’2,UIRJHLU‘ KH ZDUPV’ (3$ VQM!$OE Q M PXDM ~ PXHM ‘PRQWK’ (3$ PAVQMD IURP WKH PHWDWKHVLV RI ,(
PQV‘PRRQPRQWK’ 6NWPV*NOJP/DWPQVLV2,UP TXDM~TXHM‘WRFDOOWRJLYHDQDPH’ (3$ NOAXVQMDDGHQRPLQDWLYH EDVHGRQ,( OHÆRV‘JORU\ZRUG’ 6NWyU¢YDV*NMNGQX6ODY
VORYR WKDM ‘WR GU\’ (3$ VDXVQMD ,( VDXVR ‘GU\’ *N CW?QX 0+* VôU/LWKVD-VDV6ODY VX[Ù (3$ VQM!$OE Q M PDM~PDˆM‘WRIHHGWRIDWWHQ’ (3$ PD]GQMDDGHYHUEDWLYHEDVHG RQ,( PD]G‘IHHGLQJ’ 2+*PDVW6NWP©GDV‘IDWPDUURZ’
phonology
85
(3$ GWM JWM NWM!$OEV OXV‘WRSUD\WRLQYRNHWREHJ’ (3$ OXJWMD /LWKO J²WL‘WRDVNWR SUD\’/DWYO¸G]XO¸JW‘WRDVNWRLQYLWH’2+*ORFNAQ‘WROXUH WRHQWLFH’ QHV¬U ‘WRPRUURZ’ (3$ QDWhAU FRQWLQXLQJ QRáWAU FI : QHLWKLZUQHLWKZ\U‘ODVWQLJKW’%UHWQHL]RHUQHL]ºULG ]K\V ‘WR GLYH’ (3$ GLh GWMD GHULYHG IURP ,( ÆHG ~ XG ‘ZDWHU’ (3$ GVM NVM!$OEVK MRVK‘WRFXUOWRIRQGOHWRFDUHVV’ (3$ MXGVMD ,( HXGK 6NW \·GK\DWH‘WRILJKWWRVWUXJJOH’7RFK$\XWN‘WRWDNHFDUHRIWR WURXEOHDERXW’/LWKM¢XGLQWL‘WRH[FLWHWRDURXVH’ SXVK ‘IOXII GRZQ QDS SLOH’ (3$ SXNVMD 6NW S·FFKD ‘WDLO’
SXNVNR6ODY SX[Ù‘GRZQ’ SRXNVR THVK ‘WR ODXJK’ (3$ NDNVMD FI VLPLODU RQRPDWRSRHLF YHUEV LQ 6NWN¢NKDWLLG*NMCZC\YLG WHVK¬I‘VSHFNRIGXVWOLWWOHVSOLQWHU’ (3$ WDNVM ,( WHV 6NW WDN¿DWL‘WRFDUSHQWHUWRFXW’/DWWH[A‘WRZHDYH’/LWKWDhØWL‘WR KHZ’ ,Q (3$ QUM WKH VHJPHQW UM FKDQJHG WR UU DQG WKHQ HSHQWKHWLF G ZDV DGGHGVRWKDW QUMUHVXOWHGLQQG¬UU ¬QG¬UU ~ DQG¬UU ‘GUHDP VOHHS’ (3$ DQUM ,( RQHU ‘ZRUG’ *NQPCT ~ RQHURLG *NQPGKTQPQPGKTQX$UPDQRZUÎ
$QODXWFOXVWHUVFRQVLVWLQJRIYHODURFFOXVLYHVIROORZHGE\(3$
ODUHUHODWLYHO\ZHOOSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ:KLOHLQVRPHDUHDVWKH\ UHPDLQXQFKDQJHGLQWKHPDMRULW\RIGLDOHFWV OJDYHMDQGWKHFOXVWHUV HYHQWXDOO\\LHOGHGJMDQGT WKHODWWHUFRXOGODWHUEHFRPHGHSDODWDOL]HG DQGWXUQWRN &IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV JMHPEJO¬PE‘WKRUQ’ (3$ JODPEDFRPSDUDEOHZLWK6ODY JO_E RNÙ ‘GHHS’ ‘KROORZHG’ JO_EÙ ‘WUXQN VWXPS FDEEDJH VWXPS’FIDOVR*NINCHY‘WRVFUDSHXS’ THS ‘WR VHZ WRJHWKHU WR VHL]H’ (3$ NOHSD 6ODY NOHSDWL ‘WR EHDWWRNQRFN’
86
chapter one THW¬‘ MDJJHG URFN’ (3$ NODLW :FOXG‘KHDS’DQG/LWKhOD&WDV ‘VORSH’ TRV ‘WR HQG WR ILQLVK’ (3$ NO X WMD GHULYHG IURP WKH ,QGR (XURSHDQ ZRUG IRU ‘NH\’ *N MNJKX /DW FOYLV &I /LWK NOLDXGØWL‘WRVWRSWRSUHYHQW’ TXDM ~ TXHM ‘WR FDOO WR JLYH D QDPH’ (3$ NOXVQMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH EDVHG RQ ,( OHÆRV ‘JORU\ ZRUG’ 6NW yU¢YDV *NMNGQX6ODY VORYR T\H ‘VXPPLW SHDN’ (3$ NODLQD WR ,( ORLQR ‘VODQWLQJ VNHZ’ *RWKJHQSOKODLQH‘KLOO’
7KHRQHH[DPSOHRIPHGLDO JODWWHVWVDQDQDSW\FWLFYRZHO PMHJXOO‘FORXG’ (3$ PHJO *NQ OKZNJ ‘IRJ PLVW’ /LWK PLJO£ LG6ODY PÚJOD‘GDUNQHVVPLVW’ (3$ JUDQG NUDUHZHOOSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ JUDE¬ ‘HURVLRQ KROORZLQJ RXW’ (3$ JUDE 2+* JUDE ‘JUDYH’ 6ODY JUREÙLG JUDK~JUDI‘WRVSXURQWRFDOOWRURDU’ (3$ JUDVND 6NWJodWL ‘WRFDOOWRLQYRNH’/LWKJLUL¸J®UWL‘WRSUDLVH’ JULM~JUîM‘WRFXWLQWRSLHFHVWRJQDZWRHDWDZD\’ (3$ JULQMD ,( ÞHU ‘WR VZDOORZ’ 6NW JLU¢WL $UP HNHU /DW YRUA /LWK JHUL¸J©UWL‘WRGULQN’6ODY ÊHUWL NUL ~ NUî ‘ZRRGZRUP PRWK’ (3$ NULZL WR ,( áÆL 6ODY
¨ÚUYÚ‘ZRUP’ NULS¬~NU\S¬‘VDOW’ (3$ NU S 21KUXID‘VFDE’/LWKNUDXS¸V ‘URXJK’NUDXSLV‘VFDE’/DWYNUD-SLV‘IUDLOEULWWOH’6ODY NUXSD ‘JURDWV’ NUXD~NUXH‘VSULQJIRXQWDLQ’ (3$ NUQD NUDVQD *NMTJPJ LG2(KUæQ‘ZDYH’ *PF [UD]QA ,QLWLDO NURFFDVLRQDOO\EHFDPHYRLFHG JUHU¬~JUHQ]¬‘ZDVSKRUQHW’ (3$ JUDLVQ /DWFUEUA‘KRUQHW’ 2+*KRUQDfLG/LWKhLUhX¶LG6ODY VÚUhHQÚLG ,QWKHLQWHUYRFDOLFSRVLWLRQWKHYHODULQ JUZDVORVWFIWKHIROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV
phonology
87
EORU¬‘VOLQJ’ (3$ EOJUFRPSDUDEOHZLWK/DWIODJUXP‘ZKLS’ FIIXUWKHU21EOHNNMD‘WREHDWWRVWULNH’ S¬UPMHUU ‘WR XULQDWH’ (3$ SHUPHJUD ,( PHL½K LG 6NW P©KDWL*NQOGKZY/DWPHLA21PJD
7KH QXPEHU RI H[DPSOHV LOOXVWUDWLQJ WKH HYROXWLRQ RI FOXVWHUV
LQFOXGLQJ GHQWDOV DQG O LV YHU\ OLPLWHG 7KH UDUH LQLWLDO FOXVWHU GO PHUJHGZLWK JO JMDW¬ JODW¬ ‘ORQJ’ (3$ GODWD FRQWLQXLQJ ,( GOJKWR FI
G ORQJKR /DWORQJXV*RWKODJJV $VWR WOLWGHYHORSHGLQWROOLQWKHPLGGOHRIWKHZRUG JUHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH’ (3$ JULWO /LWK JXUNOmV ‘FURS’ 23UXV JXUFOH ‘WKURDW’ 6ODY JÙUGOR LG FI DOVR ÊHUGOR ‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’ (3$ VO\LHOGV$OEOOLQDOOSRVLWLRQV GHOO‘WHQGRQ’ (3$ GDLVOD /LWKJØVOD‘EORRGYHVVHOWHQGRQ’6ODY
ÊLOD‘WHQGRQ’ G\OO¬‘ZD[’ (3$ G OD GXVOD *NZWNQX‘MXLFH’ NROO¬‘FRXJK’ (3$ NVO 6ODY NDhOÚLG/LWKNRVXOmVLG OO¬QM¬]‘PXGVLOW’ (3$ VOLQM /LWKVOLQDV‘VDOLYDPXFXVVOLPH’ 6ODY VOLQD‘VDOLYD’ TXOO ‘SRUULGJH’ (3$ NOXVOD *N MNW\Y ‘WR ULQVH’ /DW FOXA ‘WR FOHDQ’ ,I ZDV QRW GHSDODWDOL]HG EHIRUH O WKH UHVXOWLQJ FOXVWHU WVO \LHOGHG
VO!OO SHOO¬‘FRPE’ (3$ SHWVO *NRGMY‘WRFRPE’/LWKSªhWL‘WRSXOO WRSOXFN’/DWSHFWHQ‘FRPE’ WROO¬‘EDOGVSRW GUXPPHPEUDQH’ (3$ WVO WVO /DWWOD ‘FORWK’2+*GHKVDOD‘D[H’6ODY WHVODLG
1XPHURXV FOXVWHUV LQFOXGLQJ GHQWDOV DQG U ZHUH ZHOO SUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ(3$ GUJDYHGU
chapter one
88
GUDQJ ‘EDUJHSROH SXQWLQJSROH \RXQJ FUHDWXUH FXE’ (3$
GUDQJD 21 GUDQJU ‘VWRQHSLOODU’ GUHQJU ‘WKLFN WUXQN’ /LWK GU¢QJD‘SHUFKSROH’6ODY GU_JÙ~ GU_JD GUH~GUê ‘GHHU’ (3$ GUDQL CTCPKX>IRUFT@ GNCHQX GUHGK ‘WR WXUQ WR URWDWH’ (3$ GUHG]D FRQWLQXLQJ ,( GUH½K $UPGDàQDP‘WRWXUQ’GDUΑFXUYHWXUQ’ GULW¬ ‘OLJKW OXVWUH SXSLO RI DQ H\H ’ (3$ GULNW EDVHG RQ ,(
GHU ‘WR ORRN’ FI LQ SDUWLFXODU 2( WRUKW ‘EULJKW’ 2+* ]RUDKW GUX ~ GUû ‘WUHH ZRRG I SO GUX ’ (3$ GUXZD 6ODY GUÙYR ‘ZRRG’6NWGUXLG$YGUXLG*NFTW`X‘WUHHRDN’ GUH GURH ‘IHDU’ 3$OE GUZ /DWY GUXYDV ‘IHDU’ DQG /LWK GUDXGÊL¸GUDX~VWL‘WRIRUELGWRGHWHUWRVFDUHRII’ (3$ WUGLGQRWFKDQJH WUDS‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSD 6ODY WURSD‘SDWK’IXUWKHUUHODWHGWR,(
WUHS‘WRWUHDG’ WUH‘WKUHH’ (3$ WUHMH ,( WUHHVLG 6NWWUD\Då*NVTGK`X/DW WUV WUHGK ‘WR FDVWUDWH’ (3$ WUHXGD /DW WU GA ‘WR SXVK’ *RWK XV ÈULXWDQ‘WREXUGHQ’6ODY WUXGÙ‘ODERUZRUN’ WUHPE‘WRIULJKWHQ’ (3$ WUHPD 7RFK$W¥UP‘WRJHWDQJU\’*N VTGOY‘WRWUHPEOH RIIHDU ’/DWWUHPALG WUHV ‘WR PHOW WR ORRVHQ WR GLVVROYH’ (3$ WUAWMD 6ODY WUDWM_
WUDWLWL‘WRVSHQGWRZDVWH’ WULP ‘KHUR’ DGM ‘EUDYH FRXUDJHRXV’ (3$ WULPD ,( WPR $UPDUP‘\RXQJIUHVKJUHHQ’ ,Q LQODXW DQDSW\FWLF ¬ GHYHORSHG ZLWKLQ $OE WU DQG GU DW D YHU\ UHFHQW VWDJH WMHW¬U‘RWKHU’ (3$ HWHUD 6ODY HWHUÙ‘VRPHVRPHERG\’ PRW¬U ‘VLVWHU’ PWU (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU ‘PRWKHU’ 6NW PW¢U*NOJVJT/DWPWHU 7KHFOXVWHU VUJLYHV$OEUULQDOOSRVLWLRQV HUU‘GDUNQHVV’ (3$ DXVUD /LWKDXhU£‘GDZQ’*NGYXLG
phonology
89
NRUU ‘WR UHDS WR KDUYHVW’ (3$ NVUD /LWK NDV¸ N£VWL ‘WR GLJ’ 6ODY NRVD‘VF\WKH’ UUDJ ‘DSURQ’ (3$ VUDXJD /LWK VU·RJD ‘VNHLQ KDQN WXI KDLUORFN’VUDXJDLG UU\P¬ ‘IORZ RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ VU P *N TGW`OC ‘VWUHDP’ 21 VWUDXPULG/LWKVUDXPX¶‘IDVWVWUHDP’ 7KHGHYHORSPHQWRI VWULVRIVSHFLDOLQWHUHVW,WVHHPVWRUHIOHFWGKU
G]U WVUZLWKDVHFRQGDU\YDULDQWGU EDGK¬U EDG¬U ‘QDUFLVVXV GDIIRGLO’ (3$ EDVWU 6NW EK¢VWU ‘EHOORZV’IXUWKHUEDVHGRQ EKHV‘WREORZ’ WKDG¬U ‘D NLQG RI GRXEOHVLGHG D[H’ (3$ WVHVWU 6NW yDVWU¢ ‘NQLIHVZRUG’ ,QLWLDOFOXVWHUVZLWKVHFRQG UFDQRFFDVLRQDOO\ORVHWKHU S¬USXVK‘WRSRNHWRVWLUXS’ S¬USUXVKFISUXVK‘HPEHUJORZ LQJFRDO’ VKNHS VKNUHS ‘WR UHVHPEOH’ D SUHIL[HG GHULYDWLYH RI NUHS (3$ NUHSD‘ERG\’ 6NWNS‘VKDSHEHDXWLIXODSSHDUDQFH’/DW FRUSXV‘ERG\’2+*KUI‘ERG\ODS’ VKSDOO ‘WR DQQRXQFH WR GHFODUH’ VKSUDOO EDVHG RQ SUUDOO¬ ‘WDOH VWRU\’
:KHQDSSHDULQJLQFOXVWHUVZLWKQDVDOVRQRUDQWVOLTXLGVFUHDW HGKRPRUJDQLFHSHQWKHWLFFRQVRQDQWV GK¬QG¬U ~ GKDQG¬U ‘EULGHJURRP VRQLQODZ’ (3$ G]DQUD ,( ½HQiU‘VRQLQODZ’ /DWJHQHU ¬PE¬O~DPE¬O‘VZHHW’ (3$ DPOD 6NWDPO¢‘VRXU’ 5DUHO\DWWHVWHG UO\LHOGHGOM ELO¬ELM¬‘GDXJKWHU’ (3$ ELU L OGHULYHGIURPELU‘VRQ’
:KHQIROORZHGE\RFFOXVLYHV(3$ ODQG UZHUHSUHVHUYHG
+RZHYHU$OEOFDQFKDQJHWRMLQPRVWGLDOHFWV
90
chapter one DMN¬ ‘FUHDP ZRRO IDW’ (3$ DON UHODWHG WR /LWK ¢ONWL ‘EH KXQJU\’DËND‘KXQJHU’6ODY RONWL‘EHKXQJU\’ DUJ¬VK ‘FUXGH UDIW VXSSRUWHG E\ VNLQ EODGGHUV FUXGH EULGJH RI FURVVEDUVKDUURZ’ (3$ DUJXVD 6NWDUJDOD‘EROW’2(UHFHG ‘EXLOGLQJKRXVH’ EDMJ¬EDOJ¬‘GXQJ’ (3$ EDOJ *NDQNDKVQP‘FRZGXQJ’ ,(
EROÞ GDUN¬‘VXSSHU’ (3$ GDUN ,( GRUáRPUHIOHFWHGLQ*NFQTRQP LG KHTKHOT‘WRGUDZWRSXOO’ (3$ VNDONMD *N QNMGY VRONHA EDVHGRQGNMY‘WRGUDZ’7KHYDULDQWKHTJRHVEDFNWR KHMT
,QRQHFDVHKRZHYHU(3$ UN\LHOGHGUU WMHUU ‘WR VSLQ’ (3$ WHUND 7RFK % W¥UN ‘WR WXUQ’ RQO\ DV SDUW SUHW /DWWRUTXHALGDQGWKHOLNH &OXVWHUVFRQVLVWLQJRIDOLTXLGIROORZHGE\ VRUE\DQDIIULFDWHGHYHO RSHGLQWRO O DQGU U GMHUU ‘IDOORZ ODQG’ (3$ GHUVD ,( ½KHUVRV *N ZGTUQX ‘GU\ ODQG’ NDOOL‘HDURIJUDLQ’EDVHGRQ(3$ NDOVD 6ODY NROVÙ‘HDURIJUDLQ’ PDUUW¬‘PXUN\FORXG\GLPGXOO’GHULYHGIURP(3$ PDUVD 6ODY
PRU[Ù‘GXVNIRJ’ PMHO‘WRPLON’ (3$ PHOJD *NCOGNIYLG/DWPXOJHALG/LWK P©OÊLXP©OÊWLLG WHU‘WRPDNHGU\’ (3$ WDUVMD 6NWWDU¿¢\DWLLG/DWWRUUHALG21 ÈHUUDLG ,QLQODXWWKHUHIOH[RI(3$ UWhLV U V7KLVPD\EHWKHUHVXOWKRZHYHU RISUHVHUYHGGHULYDWLRQDOFRQQHFWLRQV GDVP¬GDUVP¬‘ZHGGLQJ’ (3$ GDUWhLPGHULYHGIURPGDUN¬ /RQJHUFOXVWHUVEHJLQQLQJZLWKOLTXLGVZHUHUDGLFDOO\VLPSOLILHG EDUP¬ ‘EDVW’ (3$ EDUG]P GHULYHG IURP EDUG]D ! EDUGK¬ ‘ZKLWH’
phonology
91
EDVKN¬ ‘IOHHFH’ (3$ EDU X hN EDUXN¬ LG DQG GHULYHG IURP EHUU‘VKHHSJRDW’ HW‘WKLUVW’ (3$ DONWL /LWK¢ONWL‘WREHKXQJU\’6ODY RONDWLLG 2+*LOJL‘KXQJHU’ NDVKW¬‘VWUDZ’ (3$ NDOVWGHULYDWLYHRINDOOL‘HDURIJUDLQ’
7KHJURXSV OQDQG UQKDYH EHHQSUHVHUYHGXQWLODYHU\ODWH
VWDJH SUREDEO\ XQWLO WKH HDUO\ 0LGGOH $JHV 7KHQ ERWK FOXVWHUV ZHUH VLPSOLILHG(3$ OQGHYHORSHGLQWROO EROOH ‘WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ EOQDL *N HCNNQX ‘SKDOOXV’ /DW IROOLV ‘EHOORZV’2,UEDOO‘OLPEPHPEHU’ J¬VKWDOO¬‘VSOLQWSLHFHRIZRRG’ (3$ NDVWDOQ ,( VWHO KDOO‘WURXEOHPLVHU\SOLJKWVRUURZ’ (3$ VNDOQD *PF VNDOOD] ‘WKLQGU\VKDOORZ’~ [DOOD]‘ZHDNWLUHG’ NDOO ‘WR LQVHUW WR WKUXVW WR SODFH WR LQFLWH WR VHW RQ ILUH’ (3$
NDOQD ,( áRORGHULYHGIURP áHO‘WRWXUQ’ SMHOO ‘WR EHJHW WR SURGXFH WR EHDU’ (3$ SHOQD /DW SHOOA ‘WR GULYHWRSXVK’*NRCNNY‘WRSRLVHWRVZHOOWRVZLQJ’ (3$ UQJDYH$OEUU EDUU¬‘IHWXV’ (3$ EDUQFRJQDWHZLWK*PF EDUQDQ‘FKLOG’ GMHUU ‘WR GHVWUR\’ (3$ GHUQD 6NW GodWL ‘WR EXUVW WR WHDU’ *N FGTY‘WRVNLQ’*RWKJDWDLUDQ‘WRWHDU’ NXUU¬‘QHYHUHYHU’ (3$ NXUQHDFRPSRXQGRINXU‘ZKHQ’DQG WKHQHJDWLRQSDUWLFOH QH PDUU‘WRWDNHWRJUDVS’ (3$ PDUQDDGHQRPLQDWLYHEDVHGRQWKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ KHWHURFOLWLF VWHP PiUQ +LWW PQLDKK ‘WR KDQGRYHU’*NOCTJ/DWPDQXV YHUU ‘DOGHU’ (3$ ZHUQD %UHW JZHUQ LG : JZHUQHQ LG 0,U IHUQLGDQG$UPJHUDQ‘EHDPWLPEHU’ ]RUU¬‘JXW’ (3$ GÊUQ /LWKÊDUQ£LG 7KHFOXVWHU UVQDOVRSURGXFHG$OEUU VRUU¬ ‘FURZ’ (3$ WhUVQ FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR 6NW N¿o¢ ‘EODFN GDUN’23UXVNLUVQDQ‘EODFN’6ODY ¨ÚUQÙLG
92
chapter one
$OO FOXVWHUV FRQVLVWLQJ RI DQ RFFOXVLYH IROORZHG E\ (3$ P GHYHORSHGLQWR$OEP DP¬] ‘RGRXU DURPD’ GHULYHG IURP (3$ DGP *N QFOJ LG /DW RGRULG/LWK·RVWL‘WRVPHOO’ EUDP‘UHVLGXHVFRULDUXVWHDUZD[’ (3$ EUDGPD 6NWEUDGKQ¢ ‘UHGGLVK\HOORZ’6ODY EURQÙ‘FRORUHG’ EURGQÙ KLPH ‘EUDQ’ (3$ VNHLGPD ,( VNHLGPHQ *RWK VNDLGDQ ‘WR GLYLGH’ /LWK VNHGÊX VNHVWL ‘WR PDNH WKLQ’ FI /LWK VNLHPX¶ ‘RSHQLQJXVHGWRLQVHUWWKHVKXWWOH’ VNHLGPHQ NDP ‘WR KDYH’ (3$ NDSPL ,( NDS ‘WR VHL]H WR JUDVS’ /DW FDSLALG*RWKKDEDQ‘WRKDYH’ /LNHZLVH(3$ QP!$OEP HP¬U ~ HP¬Q ‘QDPH’ (3$ HQPHQ RU LQPHQ 2,U DLQP LG 6ODY MÚP?LG23UXVHPQHVLG (3$ VP!$OEPLQDOOSRVLWLRQV LPW¬ ‘WLQ\ VPDOO’ (3$ PD FRQWLQXLQJ VPRV FI 6NW ¿¢W ‘OLWWOHDOLWWOHVOLJKWO\’/LWKL VDV‘VKRUW’/DWYîVVLG MDP‘WREH’ (3$ HVPL ,( HVLG 6NW¢VPL*NGKOK PMHN¬U ‘FKLQEHDUG’ (3$ VPHNU +LWW]DPDQNXU‘EHDUG’6NW yP¢yUXLG$UPPDZURZLG/LWKVP¦NUDV‘FKLQ’ PXJ ‘WZLOLJKW’ (3$ VPXJD 2( VPRFD ‘VPRNH’ 2,U P·FK LG $UPPRZ[LG (3$ QVPVLPSOLILHGWR$OEP WKRP‘WRVD\’ (3$ WVQVPL 23HUVSWL\‘WRVD\’/DWFQVHA‘WR DVVHVVWRYDOXH’ %HIRUHVSLUDQWVDQGDIIULFDWHV PZDVGURSSHG JMLWK¬‘DOO’ (3$ VHPG]D ,( VHP½KR‘RQH’ $UPH] PLVK ‘IOHVK PHDW’ (3$ PHPVD ,( PHPVR LG 6NW P$VD ‘IOHVKPHDW’$UPPLV*RWKPLP]6ODY P?VR
phonology
93
7KH KLVWRU\ RI FOXVWHUV ZLWK Q LV PRUH FRPSOLFDWHG WKDQ WKRVHLQ P*URXSVFRQVLVWLQJRIDODELDODQG Q\LHOGHGP JMDOP‘URSHODFH’ (3$ VDOSQD 6ODY VROSLWL‘WRVWLFNRXW’ /LWK LhVHOSLQ{WL‘WRJHWGLYLGHG’ JMXP¬ ‘VOHHS’ (3$ VXSQD ,( VXSQR LG *N WRPQX 6ODY
VÙQÙ NDUP¬‘URFN’ (3$ NDUSQIXUWKHUUHODWHGWRNDUS¬LG NHPTHP‘LQFHQVH’ (3$ NDSQD *NMCRPQX‘VPRNH’ N¬UP¬‘FDUFDVVFDULRQFDGDYHU’ (3$ NDUSQ 6NWN¤S‘VKDSH EHDXWLIXO DSSHDUDQFH’ /DW FRUSXV ‘ERG\’ 2+* KU¬I ‘EHOO\ ERG\’ OXP‘EOHVVHGKDSS\OXFN\IRUWXQDWH’ (3$ OXEQDDQDGMHFWLYH LQ QRGHULYHGIURP,( OHXEK‘WRORYHWRZLVK’ (3$ JQ ZLWK JRIDQ\RULJLQ FKDQJHGWRQM HQM¬‘MXQLSHU\HZ’ (3$ DLJQM 21HLN2+*HLK HQM¬~ êM¬‘GDLU\JRDW’ (3$ DJQM *NCOPQX‘ODPE’/DWDJQXV LG QMRK~QMRI‘WRNQRZ’ (3$ JQVND ,( ½HQi~ ½QALGFI*N IKIPYUMY(SLGDXUIPYUMY/DW J QAVFA (3$ VQEHFDPH QZKLFKLVSUHVHUYHGDVVXFKLQDQODXW QXV‘WKUHDGVWULQJ’ (3$ VQXWMD 6NWVQdYDQ‘EDQGVLQHZ’ ,QDXVODXWKRZHYHU QZDVRFFDVLRQDOO\ORVW:KHQLWZDVSUHVHUYHGLW ZDVUKRWDFL]HGLQ7RVN JUHU¬~JUHQ]¬‘ZDVSKRUQHW’ (3$ JUDLVQ /DWFUEUA‘KRUQHW’ 2+*KRUQDfLG/LWKhLUhX¶LG6ODY VÚUhHQÚLG JM¬U ‘VRXS’ ~ *HJ JMDQ¬ ‘PXGEHG DOOXYLXP’ (3$ MDXVQD 6NW QHXW\ ¿‘VRXS’/DWL VLG/LWKMgh^‘ILVKVRXS’ NUXD ~ NUXH ‘VSULQJ IRXQWDLQ’ (3$ NUAQD *N MTJPJ LG 2( KUæQ‘ZDYH’ *PF [UD]QA NU\H‘KHDG’ (3$ NUQM NUDVQM *NMTC PKQP‘VNXOOKHDG’ PXDM ~ PXHM ‘PRQWK’ (3$ PAVQMD IURP WKH PHWDWKHVLV RI ,(
PQV ‘PRRQ PRQWK’ 6NW PV *N OJP /DW PQVLV 2,U P
94
chapter one
7KHGHYHORSPHQWRI GQZDVVLPLODUWRWKDWRI VQ O¬~ODˆ ‘WROHW’ (3$ ODLGQD /LWKO©LVWLLG/DWYODîVWLG*RWKOHWDQ LG
&OXVWHUV LQ ZKLFK Q LV IROORZHG E\ YHODUV LQFOXGLQJ WKRVH GHULYHGIURPROGSDODWDOV HPHUJHGDVQJ
DQJ ‘IHDU QLJKWPDUH’ (3$ DQJD FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR 6NW ¢$KDV ‘IHDU’ /DW DQJRU ‘XQUHVW IHDU’ 2,U FXPFDH JO ‘DQJRU’ &HOW
NRPRQJ DQJ¬UU‘VNLQLQWHVWLQHV’ (3$ DQJDUUHODWHGWR$UPDQMQ‘VRXO SHUVRQ’21DQJL‘VPHOORGRU‘ EXQJ ‘NLQG RI RDN 4XHUFXV VHVVLIORUD’ (3$ EXQND $UP ERZQ ‘WUXQN’ QJD ‘RXW’ (3$ HQND D FRPSRXQG FRQVLVWLQJ RI HQ LGHQWLFDO ZLWK,( HQ‘LQ’DQG(3$ NDZKLFKLVUHODWHGWR6ODY NÙ‘WR WRZDUGV’ QJXO‘WRWKUXVWLQWRVWLFNLQ’ (3$ HQNXOD /LWKN¸OWL‘WRWKUHVK’ /DWYNXËW‘WRVWULNH’ ,IWKHSDODWDOFKDQJHGWRDQDIIULFDWH QZDVORVW SHV¬~SêV¬‘ILYH’ (3$ SHQWhH ,( SHQáH‘ILYH’ 6NWS¢±FD*N RGPVG/DWTXQTXH ,QDXVODXWWKHFOXVWHU QWQRUPDOO\JLYHVQ DQ¬‘VLGH’ (3$ DQW 6NW¢QWD‘HQG’*RWKDQGHLVLG EDQ¬‘GZHOOLQJ’ (3$ EDQWLGHULYHGIURPE¬M‘WRPDNHWRGR’ GKXQ¬ ‘ODERU SDLQV VKDPH GLVJUDFH’ (3$ HGXQWL *N QFWPJ ‘ODERUSDLQV’$UPHUNQLG PDQ‘PXOEHUU\’ (3$ PDQWD 'DFOCPVGKC‘EODFNEHUU\’ YRQ¬‘ODWH’ (3$SDUWLFLSOH ZQWL 6NWYd\DWL‘WRYDQLVKWREHFRPH H[KDXVWHG’/LWKY²MXV L ‘DLOLQJ’/DWYYDˆMh‘PHDJHUZHDN’ ,ISUHFHGHGE\ H(3$ QWEHFDPHQG EUHQGD‘LQVLGH’ (3$ HQ SHUHQWDDVHTXHQFHRIFOLWLFV
phonology
95
çDQG¬U ‘SURS VXSSRUW’ (3$ LhVNHQWUD ,( V HQWURP *N MGPVTQP‘JRDG’ OHQG‘DFRUQ’ (3$ OHQWD ,( OHQW‘OHQWLO’ /DWOQVOQWLV2+* OLQVL6ODY O?WMD O¬QG¬~ODQG¬‘ZRRGWLPEHUPDWHULDO’ (3$ OHQW *PF OHQGA ‘OLQGHQ’ 2+* OLQWD 2( OLQG /LWK OHQW£ ‘ERDUG’ 6ODY O_WÙ ‘EDVW’ YHQG‘SODFH’ (3$ ZHQWDEDVHGRQY¬‘WRSXW’ (3$ ZHQD
7KH KLVWRU\ RI FOXVWHUV EHJLQQLQJ LQ V VHHPV WR EH SDUWLFXODUO\FRPSOLFDWHG'HVSLWHPDQ\DWWHPSWVDWWKHLUHOXFLGDWLRQRXU XQGHUVWDQGLQJUHPDLQVLQFRPSOHWH 7KHFOXVWHU VSUHJXODUO\UHIOHFWVDVILQDQODXW,WLVOLNHO\WKDWDPHGLDO VWDJH SVH[LVWHG FIEHORZ IDU¬‘VHHGVHPHQNLQ’ (3$ VSDU ,( VSHU‘WRVSLOOWRVRZ’ *NURGKTYLGURGTOC‘VHPHQVHHG‘ IHQG ‘WR IDUW’ (3$ VSHQGD 6NW VSDQGDWH ‘WR VKLYHU’ *N UHCFC\Y‘WRDKLYHUWRWUHPEOH’ IHUU¬‘WKRUQWKRUQ\EXVK’ (3$ VSHUQ ,( VSHU‘VSHDUVWLFN’ /DWVSDUXV‘VKRUWVSHDU’*PF VSHUX‘VSHDU’!21VSM_U IMDO¬ ‘ZRUG VSHHFK WDOH’ (3$ VSHO *RWK VSLOO ‘VWRU\ IDEOH’ 21VSMDOO‘VWRU\VSHHFK’2(VSHOOLG2+*VSHOVSHOOLGDQG $UPDàDVSHO‘IDEOH’ IU\M~IU\HM‘WREORZ’ VSU JQMD /LWKVSU JVWXVSU JWL‘WRHVFDSH WRJHWRXW’6ODY SU\JDWL‘WRMXPSWRVSULQJ’ IXV ‘WR SXW LQ WR WKUXVW LQ WR LQVHUW WR SODQW’ (3$ VSXWMD /DW SXWA‘WRWULPWRSUXQH’7RFK$%SXWN‘WRGLYLGH’ I\W‘WKURDWJXOOHW’ (3$ VS WD /DWVSXA‘WRVSLW’VS WXP‘VSLWWOH’ *NRVWY‘WRVSLW’ (3$ SV\LHOGHGI DI¬U‘QHDU’ (3$ DSVHUDDFRQWDPLQDWLRQRI DSVDYDULDQWRI,(
DSR DQG RI DSHUR 6NW ¢SDUD ‘SRVWHULRU ODWHU’ *RWK DIDU ‘DIWHU’ 1RH[DPSOHVRIPHGLDO VSDUHDWWHVWHG7KHUHDUHDOOHJHGFDVHVZKHUH
VS \LHOGV $OE VKS KRZHYHU WKHVH H[DPSOHV DUH EHWWHU H[SODLQHG DV
96
chapter one
GHULYDWLYHV ZKHUH D PRUSKRORJLFDO ERXQGDU\ VHSDUDWHV WKH V DQG S &IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOH VKSDUGK VKSDUU ‘RDN’ (3$ LVSDUG]D 21 IRUNU ‘VWLFN SROH’ FRQWLQXLQJ,( SHU½ 7KHUHPD\EHKRZHYHURQHH[DPSOHZKLFKVXSSRUWVWKLVSRVLWLRQ VKSHUU‘WRZLQ PRQH\ WRJDLQ’ (3$ VSDUMD *PF VSDUAMDQ‘WR OHDYHXQKDUPHGWRNHHS’ 21VSDUD2+*VSDUAQ2(VSDULDQ
7KHFOXVWHU VWJDYHVKWLQDOOSRVLWLRQV DVKW‘ERQH’ (3$ DhWLRU DhWD ,( RVW L ‘ERQH’ +LWWDhWDL6NW ¢VWKL*NQUVGQP EUXVKWXOO ‘KHDWKHU’ (3$ EUXVWXOD 6ODY EUÙVWÚ ‘VSURXW EXG’ DQG26EUXVWLDQ‘WRVKRRWWRVSURXW’ N¬VKWDOO¬‘VSOLQW LQPHGLFLQH ’ (3$ NDVWDO *RWKVWROV‘FKDLU’ /LWKVW¦ODV‘WDEOH’6ODY VWROÙ‘WDEOHSROH’ VKWDJ¬ ‘SROH VWLFN’ (3$ VWDJ 21 VWMDNL LG /DWY VW?JD ‘ORQJ SROH’ VKWDQJ ‘KDUG’ (3$ VWDQJD 21 VWLQJD ‘WR SXW WR VWLFN’ /LWK VW©QJLXVW©QJWL‘WREHDEOH’VWL±JWL‘WREHFRPHKDUG’/DWYVWL±JW LG VKWHJ‘SDWKURDG (3$ VWDLJD ,( VWRLJKR‘ZD\’ *NUVQK`ZQX ‘URZ OLQH’ *RWK VWDLJD ‘ZD\’ /DWY VWD&JD ‘ZDONLQJ’ VWîJD ‘SDWK’6ODY VWÚ]DLG $OEVKWLVDOVRWKHHQGSURGXFWRIWULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVHQGLQJLQ VW JMDVKW¬ ‘VL[’ (3$ VHNVWL GHULYDWLRQDOO\ FORVH WR 6NW ¿D¿WL ‘VL[ WHQV’ MDVKW¬‘RXWVLGH’ (3$ HNVWDGHULYHGIURP,( H½KV‘RXW’ *NGE /DWH[DQGWKHOLNH NDVKW¬‘VWUDZ’ (3$ NDOVWGHULYDWLYHRINDOOL‘HDURIJUDLQ’ UUDVKW‘ERQHVNXOOVNHOHWRQVKHOO’ (3$ ZUDJhWDGHULYDWLYHRI UUDK‘WREHDWWRVWULNH’ ZUDJVND 7KHYRLFHGFRUUHODWHRI VWUHIOHFWHGDV ]G! G]!GK
phonology
97
SLGK‘IHPDOHSXGHQGD’ (3$ S H L]GD 6ODY SL]GDLGDQG23UXV SHLVGD‘ERWWRP’ +RZHYHUZKHQSUHFHGHGE\YRLFHGFRQVRQDQWV ]GZDVGLVVLPLODWHGWR
WV!WK GULWK¬‘JUDLQ’ (3$ GULWV /DWKRUGHXP‘EDUOH\’2+*JHUVWDLG ,( ½K]G JMHWK‘IROLDJHJUHHQOHDYHV’ (3$ JDG]D 2+*TXHVWD‘WXIW’21 NYLVWU‘EUDQFK’6ODY JYR]GÚ‘ZRRGIRUHVW’
,QDQODXW(3$ VNRIDQ\RULJLQ LHUHIOHFWLQJ,( VNRU V
FRXOGHLWKHUGHYHORSLQWRVKNRUEHFRPHPHWDWKHVL]HGDQGFKDQJHWRK WKURXJK WKH LQWHUPHGLDWH VWDJH RI NV $V ZH NQRZ WKH ODWWHU ZRXOG JLYH$OEKDVSURYHGE\WKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOH KLUU¬‘ZKH\’ (3$ NVLU 6NWN¿U¢‘PLON’2VVHWæ[hLULG 0HWDWKHVLV GLG QRW QRUPDOO\ WDNH SODFH LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ URRWV FRQWDLQLQJDQXQYRLFHGFRQVRQDQW VKNDN‘UHDVRQFDXVH QRRVHVQDUHWUDS’ (3$ VNDND 21VNDJD ‘WR SURWUXGH’ 6ODY VNRNÙ ‘MXPS’ ,( VNHN ‘WR MXPS WR EH DJLOH’ VKNDV‘WRVOLSWRVOLGH’ (3$ VNDWMDFRUUHVSRQGLQJWR/DWVFDWHA ‘WRVWUHDPWRIORZRXW’/LWKVNDQW¸VN£VWL‘WRVSULQJWRMXPS’ VKNHS ‘WR ULS RSHQ WR XQULS WR WHDU’ (3$ VNDLSD 21 VNID ‘WR VSOLW’2)ULVVNYLD‘WRGLYLGH’ VKNRS‘VWLFNFDQH’ (3$ VNSD *NUMC`RQX MNCFQXUMJ`RVTQP ‘VWDII’/DWVFSXV‘VKDIWVWHP’ VKNXQG ‘WR VKDNH WR VZLQJ’ (3$ VNXQWD QDVDO SUHVHQW RI ,(
VNHXW 0,UVFRWKDLG‘WRFXWRII’/LWKVNXW¸VN¸VWL‘WRVFUDSH’ 7KHUHLVQRPHWDWKHVLVLQZRUGVEHJLQQLQJZLWK VNU VKNUDE¬‘VFUDZO’ (3$ VNUDE /DWVFURELV‘SLW’2(VFUHSDQ‘WR VFUDWFK’/LWKVNUHE{WL‘WRUXVWOH’6ODY VNUHEWL‘WRVFUDWFK’ (3$ VN LV UHJXODUO\ PHWDWKHVL]HG WR NV ! $OE K LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ URRWVZLWKYRLFHGRFFOXVLYHV
98
chapter one KHGK‘WRWKURZWRVKRRW’ (3$ NVHXGD 21VNM²WD2+*VFLRfDQ DQGRWKHUFRQWLQXDQWVRI*PF VNLXWDQ‘WRVKRRW’ KLPH ‘EUDQ’ (3$ VNHLGPD *RWK VNDLGDQ ‘WR GLYLGH’ /LWK VNHGÊXVNHVWL‘WRPDNHWKLQ’FI/LWKVNLHPX¶‘RSHQLQJXVHG WRLQVHUWWKHVKXWWOH’ VNHLGPHQ
7KH VDPH GHYHORSPHQW WDNHV SODFH LQ URRWV ZLWK VRQRUDQWV O U P
Q M Z KDUU‘WRZHHGWRFXWGRZQ’ (3$ VNDUQD ,( VNHU‘WRFXW’FI *RWKXVVNDUMDQ‘WRWHDURXW’/LWKVNLUL¸VN®UWL KHOO‘VSHDUVSLW’ (3$ VNAOD *NUMY`NQX‘SRLQWHGVWDNHWKRUQ’ K¬Q¬ ‘PRRQ’ (3$ NVDQG 6NW F¢QGDWL ‘ KH VKLQHV LV EULJKW’ FDQGU¢‘VKLQLQJ PRRQ’ KLMH‘VKDGRZ’ (3$ NVLM ,( VL~ V 6NWFK\dLG*N UMKCLG KLU ‘JUDFH IDYRU PHUF\’ (3$ VNUD *RWK VNHLUV ‘FOHDU’ 6ODY
h¨LUÙ‘FOHDQ’ KX ~ Kû ‘SLFNHW VWDNH SROH SHQLV’ (3$ VNXMD 6ODY [XMÚ ‘SHQLV’ KXPE ‘WR OHDYH WR ORVH WR VSRLO WR PLVV’ ,( VNHXEK *RWK DI VNLXEDQ‘WRSXVKDZD\WRUHMHFW’/LWKVNXPE¸VN¸EWL‘WRKXUU\ WRKDVWHQ’ 7KHUHDUHDIHZH[FHSWLRQVWKDWPD\UHTXLUHDUHYLVLRQRIWKHSUHVHQWO\ DFFHSWHGHW\PRORJLHV KLS ¬M ~ K\SL ‘WR JR XS’ (3$ VN SD /LWK N¸SWL ‘WR ULVH’ /DWY NXSW‘WRJDWKHUWREXLOGXS’ VKN¬OER]¬ ‘EDUN’ EDVHG RQ VKNDOE¬ (3$ VNDOE 21 VNDOSU ‘VKLS’ VNHOSD ‘JULPDFH’ ‘FUDFN VSOLW’ 0/* VFKROSH ‘PXVVHO’ 7KH HPHUJLQJ QHZ VRXQG K ZDV H[WUHPHO\ XQVWDEOH LQ DQODXW DQG ZDV GURSSHGLQYDULRXVZRUGVLQDOPRVWDOORIWKH$OEDQLDQGLDOHFWV$WWKH VDPH WLPH D QRQHW\PRORJLFDO K DSSHDUHG LQ TXLWH D IHZ $OEDQLDQ ZRUGVFIIRUH[DPSOH KHUGKH‘WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ DUG]DL ,( RU½KL~ ½KLLG $YGXDO iUi]*NQTZKX$UPRUML0,UXLUJJHLG
phonology
99
KLN¬UU‘VRXUPLON EXFNZKHDW’ (3$ HLNUDQUGHULYDWLYHRILN LN¬M ‘WR JR’ IRU WKH VHPDQWLF GHYHORSPHQW FI *HUP JHULQQHQ ‘WRFRDJXODWH’ ULQQHQ‘WRUXQ’
$OEVKN~ VKTLQDQODXWPD\DOVRUHVXOWIURPWKHGHYHORSPHQW RIWKHSUHIL[ LhDQGDURRWLQLWLDO N VKNDO‘WREULQJGRZQWRGUDJWRUROOWRFKDUP RIIDLULHV ’ (3$
LhNDOD ,( áHO‘WRWXUQWRUROO’ VKNHO ‘WR PDNH D VWHS WR ZDON’ (3$ LhNDOMD 6NW NDO¢\DWL ‘WR GULYH’*NMGNNYLG VKNXO ‘WR WHDU RXW WR SXOO RXW WR HUDGLFDWH’ (3$ LhNXOD /DW FHOOA‘WRULVHKLJK’/LWKNHOL¸N©OWL‘WROLIW’ VKTHUU‘WRWHDU FORWK ’ (3$ LhNHUMD 6NWNoWL‘WRGLPLQLVK’*N MGKTY‘WRFXW’ ,I WKH SUHIL[ Lh ZDV IROORZHG E\ D URRW LQLWLDO VN WKH QHZ FOXVWHU \LHOGHG$OEç çDM‘WRVSOLWWRFOHDYHWRVPDVKWREDWWHUWRFKRSXS’ (3$ Lh VNHGQMD ,( VNHG‘WRVSOLW’ 6NWVNKDGDWH*NUMGFCPPWOK çDO¬‘ODPH’ (3$ LhVNDOD *NUMQNKQX‘FURRNHG’/DWVFHOXV çDQG¬U ‘SURS VXSSRUW’ (3$ LhVNHQWUD WR ,( V NHQWURP *N MGPVTQP‘JRDG’ çDUV‘WRGHVWUR\WRVSRLO’ (3$ LhVNHUWMD 21VNHUD‘WRFXW’/LWK VN®UWLLG çHP‘WREULQJWROLJKWWRGLVFORVHWRUHYHDOWREURDFK’ (3$ Lh VNHSQD 6ODY h¨HSDWL‘WRVSOLW’ çMHUU ‘WR WHDU XS’ (3$ LhVNHUD 2,U VFDUDLP ‘WR VHSDUDWH’ 21 VNHUD‘WRFXW’/LWKVNLUL¸VN®UWL‘WRVHSDUDWH’
0HGLDOO\ DQ RULJLQDO FOXVWHU ZLWK D “SXUH” YHODU VN GHYHORSHG LQWR $OE VKN WKH VDPH DSSOLHV WR WULFRQVRQDQWDO FOXVWHUV HQGLQJLQ VN
DVKN¬ ‘ZRRG VSOLQWHU’ (3$ D N hN D GHULYDWLYH RI ,( DV ‘D[LV’ 6NW¢N¿D*NCEYP/DWD[LV EDVKN¬‘IOHHFH’ (3$ EDUhN EHUU‘VKHHSJRDW’ EDVKN¬‘WRJHWKHU’ (3$ EDNVN /DWIDVFLV‘EXQGOH’IDVFLD‘EDQG EDQGDJH’
chapter one
100
HVKNH‘NLGQH\’ (3$ DLhN 6ODY MÚVWRLGDQG21HLVWD‘WHVWLFOH’ RLGVWR ILVKNHP~ I\VKNHP‘WRZLWKHUWRIDGH’ (3$ VS hND /LWKS¸hNDV ‘EOLVWHUILQSLPSOH’/DWYSXVNV‘WXIW’ IODVKN¬W ‘VOXJJLVK ODPH’ SODVKN¬W (3$ SODNVND /LWK SO²Nh¨LDV ‘IODW’ 6ODY SORVNÙ LG DQG 6ODY SOR[Ù ‘IODW EDG HYLOSRRU’ 7KH FOXVWHU V ZDV PHWDWKHVL]HG DQG JDYH $OEK WKH VDPH DSSOLHV WR WULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVHQGLQJLQ V 7KLVGHYHORSPHQWLVFRUURERUDWHG E\QXPHURXV$OEDQLDQYHUEVLQ VHR JUDK~JUDI‘WRVSXURQWRFDOOWRURDU’ (3$ JUDVND 6NWJodWL ‘WRFDOOWRLQYRNH’/LWKJLUL¸J®UWL‘WRSUDLVH’ JULK ‘WR VKDUSHQ’ (3$ JUHLVND *N ZTKY ‘WR UXE WR DQRLQW WR SULFN’ /LWK JULHM¸ JULWL ‘WR VFRRS FUHDP IURP PLON WR WDNH KROGRI’ NUHK~NUHI‘WRFRPE’ (3$ JUHEVND /LWKJU{EWL‘WRUDNH’6ODY
JUHE_ JUHEWL‘WRURZWRUDNH’ PHK ~ PHI ‘WR VRDN’ (3$ PHXVND /DWY PDûW ‘WR GLYH’ 6ODY
P\WL‘WRZDVK’ QMHK ~ QMHI ‘WR FRXQW WR FRQVLGHU’ (3$ QHPVND *N PGOY ‘WR GLYLGH’*RWKQLPDQ‘WRWDNH’/DWQXPHUXV‘PHPEHUHOHPHQW QXPEHU’DQGQXPPXV‘FRLQPRQH\’ VKRK ~ VKRI ‘WR VHH’ (3$ VNVND 6NW V¢FDWH ‘WR DFFRPSDQ\ WR IROORZ’*NGRQOCK/DWVHTXRU*RWKVDLxDQ‘WRVHH’
&OXVWHUV FRQVLVWLQJ RI DQ DIIULFDWH DQG V GHYHORS LQWR D VLPSOHDIIULFDWH
GMDWKW¬‘ULJKW’ (3$ GHWVD GHWVVD ,( GHVLG 6NWG¢N¿LoD *NFGEKQX/DWGH[WHU LWK‘EHKLQG’ (3$ LWVDIRUPRI,( H½KV‘IURPRXWRI’ ,QROGGHULYDWLYHVZLWKWKHSUHYHUE LhZHFDQREVHUYHDSKHQRPHQRQ ZKLFKZDVODWHUREVFXUHGE\DQDORJLFDOSURFHVVHVWKHXQYRLFLQJRIWKH IROORZLQJYRLFHGFRQVRQDQWV VKNDE¬ ‘HDJOH’ (3$ LhJDE D SUHIL[DO IRUPDWLRQ UHODWHG WR JDERQM¬LG
phonology
101
VKNDUGK¬ ‘GRJFKDLQ D ORQJ VWLFN DWWDFKHG WR D GRJ’V QHFN WR SUHYHQW LW IURP ELWLQJ LWV PDVWHU’ (3$ LhJDUG 6ODY MÚ] JRUGD‘IHQFH’ VKSLH‘WREULQJDZD\’ LhEHUDGHULYDWLYHRIELH‘WREULQJ’
&OXVWHUVRIWZRVWRSVQRUPDOO\ORVHWKHILUVWHOHPHQW EXW¬ ‘VRIW VPRRWK’ (3$ EXWD ,( EKXJKWR FRPSDUDEOH ZLWK 1,UERJ‘VRIW’ EKXJKR$UPERZ‘EOXQW’ GMH‘\HVWHUGD\’ (3$ GH 6NWK\¢VLG*NZSGLLG/DWKHULLG GULW¬ISOGULWD‘OLJKWOXVWUHSXSLO RIDQH\H ’ (3$ GULNWEDVHG RQ,( GHU‘WRORRNFILQSDUWLFXODU2(WRUKW‘EULJKW’2+* ]RUDKW IOHW¬ ‘ZLQJ OHDI’ (3$ DZDOHNWD D SUHIL[HG GHULYDWLYH RI ,(
OHN‘WRIO\’ /LWKOHNL¸O|NWL/DWYOªNW2+*OHFNHQ‘WRMXPS WRNLFN’ JMDW¬ JODW¬ ‘ORQJ’ (3$ GODWD FRQWLQXLQJ ,( GOJKWR FI
G ORQJKR /DWORQJXV*RWKODJJV QDW¬ ‘QLJKW’ (3$ QDNWL FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR ,( QRNÆW LG 6NW Q¢NW*NPWE/DWQR[ WHW¬ ‘HLJKW’ (3$ DNWAWL ,( RWA LG 6NW D¿bd $UP RZ *N Q MVY &OXVWHUV RI WZR GHQWDOV KRZHYHU \LHOGHG (3$ Wh WKURXJK D VHULHV RI HDUOLHUFKDQJHVIURP WhW WVW W VW EHV¬‘SOHGJHWUXFHWUXVW’ (3$ EDLWhFRQWLQXLQJWR,( EKRLGK WIXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK,( EKHLGK‘WRSHUVXDGHWRIRUFH’ SDVXU~ SDVXQ SDUWLFLSOHRINDP‘WRKDYH’ (3$ SDWhFRQWLQXLQJ
SRWWRFI/DWSRWLRU‘WRWDNHSRVVHVVLRQRI’ 7KH$OEDQLDQZRUGIRU‘HDUWK’DWWHVWVDVSHFLILFGHYHORSPHQWRIWKHUDUH ,QGR(XURSHDQFOXVWHU GK½K GKH ‘HDUWK ODQG’ )URP 3$OE G]A UHIOHFWLQJ ,( GK½KAP ‘HDUWK’ +LWWWHNDQ7RFK$WNDP%NHP6NWN¿DP*NZSYP
102
chapter one
&RQVRQDQWVLQORDQZRUGV 7KHKLVWRU\RIFRQVRQDQWVLQORDQZRUGVLVFRPSOLFDWHGWKRXJK SDUWLFXODUO\LQVWUXFWLYHDVIDUDV/DWLQERUURZLQJVDUHFRQFHUQHG7KH\ DOORZXVWREXLOGWKHZKROHV\VWHPRIUHODWLYHDQGDEVROXWHFKURQRORJ\ IRUWKH$OEDQLDQFRQVRQDQWLVP /LWHUDWXUH :(,*$1' %$ ,,, SURWKHWLF K EHIRUH D X \ 586$.295% /DWVLQ$OEDQLDQ
*UHHNORDQZRUGV $VWKHQXPEHURIDQFLHQW*UHHNORDQZRUGVLVYHU\OLPLWHGZH FDQ RQO\ PDUN VRPH VHOHFWHG EXW LPSRUWDQW IHDWXUHV 7KH PRVW LQWHUHVWLQJ RQH LV WKH ZD\ LQ ZKLFK $OEDQLDQ WUHDWV *UHHN XQYRLFHG DVSLUDWHV ODWHU IULFDWLYHV 7KH ROGHVW ORDQZRUGV UHIOHFW *N S Z DV $OEDQLDQXQYRLFHGVWRSVWN&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV ODN¬U~ODN¬Q‘FDEEDJHJUHHQV’Õ*NNCZCPQP‘JUHHQV’ O¬SMHW¬‘RUDFKGRFN’Õ*NNCRCSQPLG PRN¬U~PRN¬Q‘PLOOVWRQH’Õ*NOJZCPJ‘GHYLFHLQVWUXPHQW’ ,WLVDOVRLPSRUWDQWWRQRWLFHWKDW*NULVUHQGHUHGDV$OEVK SUHVK‘OHHN’Õ*NRTCUQPLG $VIDUDVFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVDUHFRQFHUQHGLWLVLQWHUHVWLQJWKDW*NRV GRHV QRW GHYHORS WKH VDPH ZD\ DV /DW SW 5DWKHU LW JLYHV DQ XQXVXDO UHVXOW$OEJ VHFRQGDULO\YRLFHGGXHWRWKHDVVLPLODWLRQZLWKWKHDQODXW FRQVRQDQW" EDJ¬P‘RLOIRUDQRLQWPHQW’Õ*NDCRVKUOC‘EDSWLVP’ 7KHVDPHZRUGLOOXVWUDWHVWKHHYROXWLRQRI*NUOWR$OEP
/DWLQORDQZRUGV ,Q/DWLQORDQZRUGVXQYRLFHGVSLUDQWVDUHQRUPDOO\UHIOHFWHGDV $OEVKLQDOOSRVLWLRQV
phonology
103
G¬VKLURM‘WRZLVK’ Õ /DWGVGHUUH‘WRORQJIRUWRGHVLUH’ IXVK¬ ‘SODLQ RSHQ ILHOG PHDGRZ’ Õ /DW IRVVD ‘GLWFK WUHQFK JXWWHU’ SDVK ‘IDWKRP SDFH RXWVWUHWFKHG DUPV’Õ/DW SDVVXV ‘VWHS SDFH’ VKHVK‘SODLQSODQHIODWQHVVVTXDUH’ Õ /DWVHVVXV‘VHDW’ VKXOO¬~VKXOODˆ‘VXQQ\VSRW’ Õ /DWVROQXV ORFXV LG VKXVKXQM¬‘OHHFK’ Õ 5RP VDJXLVXQJLD /DWVDQJXLVXJDLG ,QVHYHUDOFDVHVVKZDVUHSODFHGE\çDWDODWHUVWDJHRIGHYHORSPHQW EDOç¬PEDOVK¬P‘EDOP’Õ /DWEDOVDPXPLG NDçLOHNDVKLOH‘EDVNHWKDQGEDVNHW’ Õ /DWTXDVLOOXP‘VPDOOEDVNHW’ NDçXOH‘KRRG’ Õ /DWFDVXOD‘KXW’ODWHU‘KRRGHGFRDW’ 2QHGLIILFXOWH[FHSWLRQVKRZV]KLQVWHDGRIVK ]KXUVKXU‘JUDYHO’ Õ /DWVDEXUUD‘VDQGEDOODVW’ 7KHUDUH/DWLQSKRQHPH] XVXDOO\LQWKHVXIIL[L]UH LVUHQGHUHGDV[ ~ ]: SDJ¬]RM‘WREDSWLVH’ Õ /DWEDSWL]DUHLG U¬Q[RM ‘WR FDXVH D KHUQLD’ Õ 5RP KHUQL]UH EDVHG RQ KHUQLD ‘UXSWXUHKHUQLD’
/DELDO FRQVRQDQWV DUH ZHOO SUHVHUYHG LQ /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV VHH DVIDUDVWKHUK\WKPLFUXOHLVFRQFHUQHG /DWEJLYHV$OEE ELVK¬‘EHDVWZLOGDQLPDO’ Õ /DWEVWLDLG EU\P¬‘IURVW’ Õ /DWEU PD‘FROGIURVW’ EXN¬ ‘EUHDG PHDO PHDOWLPH’ Õ /DW EXFFD ‘PRXWK’ LQ %DONDQ 5RPDQFH‘IRRG’ EXO¬‘EXG’ Õ /DWEXOOD‘EXEEOHERVVNQRE’ JMHOE¬U~ JMHOE¬Q‘JUHHQ’ Õ /DWJDOELQXV‘JUHHQLVK\HOORZ’ NRUEXOO‘NHJFDVNZRRGHQSDLO’ Õ /DWFRUEXOD‘OLWWOHEDVNHW’ /DWSLVUHQGHUHGDV$OES
chapter one
104
NUHSXOO ‘LQHEULDWHG’ Õ 5RP FUSXOXV FI /DW FUSXOD ‘H[FHVVLYH ZLQHGULQNLQJLQHEULDWLRQ’ SDN‘DOLWWOHIHZ’Õ/DWSDXFXV‘IHZOLWWOH’ SDT‘SHDFH’Õ/DWSDFHPLG SMHUJXOO ‘YLQHDUERU SHUJROD’ Õ /DW SHUJXOD ‘VKHG ERRWK YLQH DUERU’ SULQG‘IDWKHUSDUHQW’Õ/DWSDUHQWHPLG WXUS‘VKDPH’Õ/DWWXUSHLG ,QRQHFDVH/DWSLVXQH[SHFWHGO\UHIOHFWHGDV$OEP P¬NDW‘VLQ’Õ/DWSHFFWXPLG $ VLJQLILFDQW QXPEHU RI /DWLQ ZRUGV ZLWK LQLWLDO ODELDOV XQGHUZHQW WKH SURFHVV RI XQYRLFLQJYRLFLQJ LQ $OEDQLDQ 7KHLU GHYHORSPHQW LV SUREDEO\ H[SODLQHG E\ YDULRXV DVVLPLODWLRQV DQG GLVVLPLODWLRQV ZLWK QHLJKERULQJFRQVRQDQWV ELVKWDM¬‘SRGKXOOSHDJUHHQEHDQ’Õ5RP SLVWOLDFI/DWSLVWUH ‘WRSRXQG’ EMHVKN¬ ‘PRXQWDLQ SDVWXUH’ Õ 5RP SDVWLFD EDVHG RQ /DW SDVWXV ‘SDVWXUH’ EXOE¬U‘VWUHHWGXVW’Õ/DWSXOYHUHP‘GXVW’ SDJ¬]RM‘WREDSWLVH’Õ/DWEDSWL]DUHLG SURN¬‘QDLOIRUN’Õ5RP EURFFD EURFFLD‘IRUNURDVWLQJVSLW’ /DWILVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEI IDW‘IDWH EULGHJURRPKXVEDQGIULHQG’Õ/DWIWXP I¬PLM¬‘FKLOGIDPLO\VSRXVH’Õ/DWIDPOLD‘IDPLO\’ IORN‘KDLU’Õ/DWIORFFXV‘ORFNIORFN’ IRUW¬‘VWURQJ’Õ/DWIRUWLVLG IXQG‘ERWWRPHQG’Õ/DWIXQGXV‘ERWWRP’ IXUN¬‘GLVWDIIIRUN’Õ/DWIXUFD‘IRUN’
/DWLQGHQWDOVWRSVDUHZHOOSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ/DWG\LHOGHG $OEGLQDQODXW
GHQM¬‘ZRUWK’Õ/DWGLJQXVLG GHW\U¬‘GXW\GHEW’Õ5RP GHELW UDLG
phonology
105
G¬P~GDP‘GDPDJH’Õ/DWGDPQXP‘KXUWKDUPGDPDJH’ GLVKW¬GLVKN¬Õ/DWGLVFXV‘GLVN’ GUDJXD~GUD Q JXH‘GUDJRQ’Õ5RP GUDQFAQHPFI/DWGUDFAQHP LG GXURM‘WREHSDWLHQW’Õ/DWG UUHLG ,QWKHLQWHUYRFDOLFSRVLWLRQDQGDIWHUU/DWGEHFDPH$OEGK NRUGK¬‘JXWVWULQJ’Õ/DWFKRUGD‘JXWFDWJXW’ ODUGK‘IDWEDFRQ’Õ/DWOULGXPOUGXPLG PRGK‘EXVKHO’Õ/DWPRGXV‘PHDVXUH’ SURGKRM‘WRSURGXFH’Õ/DWSUAGUHLG VKXUGK¬UVKXUGK¬W‘GHDI’Õ/DWVXUGXVLG YHUGK¬‘\HOORZ’Õ/DWYLULGLV‘JUHHQ’ /DWW\LHOGHG$OEWLQDOOSRVLWLRQV IVKDW‘YLOODJH’Õ/DWIRVVWXP‘GLWFK’ ‘VXUURXQGHGE\DGLWFK’ N¬UUXW¬‘HZHZLWKKRUQV’Õ/DWIHPDGMFRUQ WD‘KRUQHG’ W¬UPHW‘HDUWKTXDNH’Õ5RP WHUUDHPAWXVLG WPHUU‘KRUURUIULJKW’Õ/DWWLPAUHPLG WXUP¬‘FURZGKHUG’Õ/DWWXUPDLG WXUS‘VKDPH’Õ/DWWXUSHLG ,QRQHFDVHKRZHYHU/DWWEHFDPHYRLFHGLQLQLWLDOSRVLWLRQ G¬VKPRM‘WRWHVWLI\’Õ5RP WHVWLPAQLUHLG ,Q WKH LQODXW /DW W FRXOG EH GURSSHG ZKHQ IROORZLQJ WKH VWUHVVHG V\OODEOHRISURSDUR[\WRQDLIWKHIROORZLQJFRQVRQDQWZDVF,QIDFWWKH YRZHO RI WKH VHFRQG V\OODEOH ZDV UHGXFHG WR ]HUR DQG WKH UHVXOWLQJ FOXVWHUWFJDYH$OEN&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV NUHN¬‘PDSOH’Õ/DW DFHU &UWLFXP‘&UHWDQPDSOH’ VKHP¬U~VKHP¬UN‘PLVWUHVVFRQFXELQHULYDO’Õ VXEPDUWLFDFI /DWPDUWD‘PDUULHGZRPDQ’
/DWJLVUHQGHUHGDV$OEJ
chapter one
106
JU¬P¬UDW¬ ‘EHHVWLQJV FORWV RI FXUGOHG PLON’ Õ /DW JORPHUWXP SDUWLFLSOH RI JORPHUUH ‘WR ZLQG LQWR D EDOO WR JDWKHU LQWR D URXQGKHDS’ JULJM‘IORFNKHUG’Õ/DWJUHJHPLG JXVKW‘$XJXVW’Õ/DWDXJXVWXVLG P¬UJRM‘WRH[LOHWRGULYHDZD\’Õ/DWPHUJHUH‘WRWKUXVWWRSXVK’ PXUJ~PXQJ‘PRQN’Õ/DWPRQDFKXVLG UUHJXOO‘UXOHQRUP’Õ/DWUJXODLG /DWFDQGTXJDYH$OEN DUN‘ERZ’Õ/DWDUFXVLG G¬NRM ‘WR KLW WR VWULNH’ Õ /DW LQGLFHUH LQ LWV VSHFLILF PHDQLQJ ‘WR LPSRVHWRLQIOLFW’! ‘WRLQIOLFWSDLQ’ NDUULJ¬‘FKDLU’Õ/DWTXDGUJD‘VHWRIIRXU’ KHUH‘RIIRXUOHJV’ N¬UNRM‘WRORRNIRUWRVHHN’Õ5RP FLUFUHLG NUHVKP¬‘IDVW’Õ/DWTXGUJVLPD‘/HQWIDVWRIIRUW\GD\V’ NXT‘UHG’Õ5RP FRFFHXVFI/DWFRFFLQHXV‘VFDUOHW’ 6RPHWLPHV /DW F FRXOG EH YRLFHG DV D UHVXOW RI D FRPSOLFDWHG DVVLPLODWLRQDVLQWKHIROORZLQJFDVHZKHUHDIWHUWKHIDOORIDYRZHO GF\LHOGHGGJDQGWKHQJ P¬JDVKW¬U‘VDJH’Õ5RP PHGLFVWHUUHIOHFWHGLQ,WDOPHGLFDVWUR +RZHYHU LQ VHYHUDO FDVHV /DW F ZDV YRLFHG IRU XQNQRZQ UHDVRQV LQ DQODXW J¬UVK¬U¬ ~ J¬UVKDQ¬ ‘VFLVVRUV’ Õ 5RP FDUVQLD DQ LUUHJXODU SKRQHWLFWUDQVIRUPDWLRQRI FDHVQLD J¬VKWHQM¬‘FKHVWQXW’Õ/DWFDVWDQHDLG JM¬PRMÕ/DWFOPUH‘WRFU\WRVKRXW’ 7KHUH LV QR H[SODQDWLRQ IRU WKH IDOO RI LQWHUYRFDOLF F LQ WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHXQOHVVLWLVLQIDFWDODWHUERUURZLQJIURP5RPDQFH JULOO‘OXPS\VRLOZDVWHODQGVODWH’Õ/DWJUDFLOLV‘SRRU RIVRLO ’
,QLWLDO/DWKZDVORVWLQ$OEDQLDQ2FFDVLRQDOO\WKHIROORZLQJ YRZHOZDVORVWDVZHOO
phonology
107
MDY¬‘ZHHN’Õ/DWKHEGRPDVLG VKWLM¬‘VSHDUUD\’Õ/DWKDVWOH‘VSHDU’ XUUHM‘WRKDWH’Õ/DWKRUUUH‘WREHDIUDLGWREHDVWRQLVKHG’ +RZHYHUDQHZSURWKHWLFKUHDSSHDUHGLQ$OEDQLDQVRPHWLPHVLQWKRVH $OEDQLDQZRUGVZKHUHRULJLQDOKKDGEHHQORVW KHU¬‘WLPHPRPHQWRIWLPHKRXU’Õ/DWKAUD‘KRXU’ KLQJ¬O‘JLUWK’Õ/DW KLQQLFXODGHULYDWLYHRI/DWKLQQXV‘PXOH’ $OEKDOVRDSSHDUVLQPDQ\ZRUGVZKHUH/DWLQQHYHUKDGK KDUNDUN‘ERZ’Õ/DWDUFXVLG KDUP¬VKRU ‘VWDOOLRQ VWXGKRUVH’ Õ 5RP DUPHVVULXV D SKRQHWLF YDULDQWRI/DWDGPLVVULXVLG KDUURM‘WRIRUJHW’Õ/DWDEHUUUH‘WRIRUJHW IRUDWLPH ’ KHUPRM ‘WR GLJ’ Õ 5RP H[UPU ‘WR KRH WR GLJ RXW’ FI /DW UPU‘WRKRH’ KHWRM ‘WR VHDUFK WR LQTXLUH WR GLVFRYHU’ Õ /DW GLFWUH ‘WR DQQRXQFH’ 3URWKHWLFKFDQDOVRDSSHDULQ$OEDQLDQZRUGVRIGLIIHUHQWRULJLQ DMN¬‘FUHDP’!KDN¬LG DUU¬]¬~ DQ¬]¬‘ZDVS’!KDQ¬]¬LG \OO‘VWDU’!K\OOLG
/DWLQGHQWDOVYHODUVDQGVRQRUDQWVZHUHSDODWDOL]HGLQFHUWDLQ SRVLWLRQV MXVW OLNH WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ FRQVRQDQWV LQ ZRUGV RI ,QGR (XURSHDQRULJLQ /DWLQGHQWDOVZHUHSDODWDOL]HGEHIRUHM JUDSKLFDOO\/DWLRUH /DWGM \LHOGHG$OE] JD]‘MR\ODXJKWHU’)URP/DWJDXGLXP‘MR\’ P¬U]HM ‘WR UHVW DW QRRQ RI DQLPDOV ’ Õ /DW PHULGLUH ‘WR WDNH D PLGGD\QDS’ PL]RM‘WRUDJHWRVQDUOWRKDWH’Õ5RP LQYLGLUHLG UUH]H‘UD\VSRNH’Õ/DWUDGLXVLG VKSX]¬‘KRWDVKHV’Õ/DWVSRGLXP‘DVK’
108
chapter one ]¬U¬ ~ ]DQ¬ ‘JRGGHVV RI IRUHVWV IDLU\ EHDXWLIXO PDLGHQ’ Õ /DW 'DQD
,QRQHFDVHKRZHYHUGMXQH[SHFWHGO\JLYHVJM DJM¬URM~DJM¬QRM‘WRIDVW’Õ5RP DGL QUHLG /DWWMDQGWULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVLQWMEHFDPH$OEV PDUV‘0DUFK’Õ/DW0DUWLXVLG QXVH ‘EULGH \RXQJ ZRPDQ \RXQJHU GDXJKWHULQODZ’ Õ 5RP
Q SWLD D ORFDO YDULDQW RI /DW Q SWD ‘PDUULHG ZRPDQ ZLIH EULGH’ IRUWKHIRUPDWLRQFIQ SWLDH‘ZHGGLQJ’ S¬VRM‘WRVXIIHUWRHQGXUH’Õ5RP SDWLUHFI/DWSDWLRULG SMHV¬‘SDUW’Õ5RP SHWLDLG SXV‘ZHOOIRXQWDLQ’Õ/DWSXWHXV‘ZHOO’ VKNRUV¬‘UXJPDGHRIJRDWZRRO’Õ/DWVFRUWHDIHPDGM‘PDGHRI IXURURIKLGH’ YHV‘EDGKDELW’Õ/DWYLWLXP‘IDXOWGHIHFWYLFH’ $IHZZRUGVSUHVHUYHWKHLQWHUPHGLDWHVWDJHEHWZHHQWMDQG$OEVZKLFK VHHPVWREH WV!F OXF¬‘PXGPLUH’Õ/DWOXWHD‘PXGG\’ PDOFRM‘WRLQIODPHWRPDNHVRUH’Õ5RP PDOLWLUHFI/DWPDOLWLD ‘EDGQHVVVSLWH’
9HODUV ZHUH SDODWDOL]HG EHIRUH M DQG IURQW YRZHOV LQFOXGLQJ WKHIURQWYRZHOVRIDFFXVDWLYHDQGREOLTXHFDVHVLQ/DWLQIRUPVZKLFK ODWHU JHQHUDOL]HG WR WKH ZKROH $OEDQLDQ SDUDGLJP DV ZHOO DV WKH IURQW YRZHOVUHVXOWLQJIURP$OEDQLDQXPODXW /DWFFKDQJHGWRT IDTH‘IDFHFKHHN’Õ/DWIDFLV‘IDFH’ ITLQM¬‘QHLJKERU’Õ5RP YFQLXVEDVHGRQ/DWYFQXVLG LULT‘KHGJHKRJ’Õ/DWULFLXVLG NXPHUT‘WROOGXW\’Õ/DWFRPPHUFLXP‘WUDGHFRPPHUFH’ NXT‘UHG’Õ5RP FRFFHXVFI/DWFRFFLQHXV‘VFDUOHW’ THOT‘JODVV’Õ/DWFDOLFHP‘ERZOFXS’ ,QGLDOHFWVTZDVRFFDVLRQDOO\UHSODFHGE\çDQGHYHQE\VK
phonology
109
çLPN¬TLPN¬‘EXJ’Õ/DWFPLFHPLG PO\çPO\VK‘NLQGRIILVKSLNH’Õ5RP PDULVO FLXV‘VHDSLNH’ $QDORJLFDO SURFHVVHV OHDGLQJ WR WKH JHQHUDOL]DWLRQ RI WKH SDODWDOL]HG IRUP LQ D SDUDGLJP FRXOG DOVR ZRUN WKH RWKHU ZD\ URXQG WKRXJK OHVV IUHTXHQWO\ VKRNVKRT‘FRPUDGHIULHQG’Õ/DWVRFLXV‘FRPUDGHFRPSDQLRQ’ /DWJEHFDPH$OEJM JMHO‘URRVWHU’Õ/DWJDOOXVLG JMLQGHSO‘SHRSOH’Õ/DWJHQWHPLG OLJM‘ODZ’Õ/DWOJH P LG P¬QJML ~ PDQJML ‘VRUFHU\ ZLWFKFUDIW PHGLFLQH’ Õ /DW PDJD ‘PDJLFVRUFHU\’ ZLWKVHFRQGDU\QDVDOL]DWLRQ UHJM‘NLQJ’Õ/DWUJHPLG XQJMLOO‘JRVSHO’Õ/DWHYDQJHOLXPLG ,QDIHZFDVHVWKHUHVXOWLQJJMGHYHORSHGLQWRM SOODM¬‘XSODQGJHQWOHVORSH’Õ5RP SODJLDLG
7KHVRQRUDQWVUDQGOUHPDLQHGXQDIIHFWHGEHIRUHIURQWYRZHOV DQG M ,Q FRPELQDWLRQ ZLWK M /DW O ZRXOG QRUPDOO\ JLYH $OE O ZKLFK RIWHQFKDQJHVWRM
IDM‘JXLOWVLQ’Õ5RP IDOOLDGHULYDWLYHRI/DWIDOOHUH‘WRGHFHLYH WRWULFN’ PHO‘PLOOHW’Õ/DWPLOLXPLG PLO¬PLM¬‘WKRXVDQG’Õ/DWPOLDLG UU¬VKDM¬‘3HQWHFRVW’Õ/DW5AVOLD‘5XVDOLHV’ VKN¬QGLM¬ ‘VSDUN’ Õ 5RP VFLQWLOLD LG LQVWHDG RI WKH PRUH ZLGHO\ NQRZQ/DWVFLQWLOODLG W¬UIRM¬‘WUHIRLOVKDPURFN’Õ/DWWULIROLXPLG /DWQM DQG5RP QMIURPYDULRXV/DWLQVRXUFHV LVDOZD\VUHIOHFWHGDV $OEQM
chapter one
110
ITLQM¬‘QHLJKERU’Õ5RP YFQLXVEDVHGRQ/DWYFQXVLG J¬VKWHQM¬‘FKHVWQXW’Õ/DWFDVWDQHDLG NXQM‘SHJZHGJH’Õ/DWFXQHXV‘ZHGJH’ OLQM¬‘OLQHQVKLUW OLQHQ’Õ/DWOQHXP‘OLQHQJDUPHQW’ WHQM¬‘PRWKZRRGHQJUDYHU’Õ/DWWLQHD‘PRWKZRUP’
7KHGHYHORSPHQWRI/DWLQFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVLQ$OEDQLDQLV TXLWHZHOODWWHVWHG
&OXVWHUVZLWKMZHUHSDUWO\GHVFULEHGDERYH7ULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVDUH PRVWO\ VLPSOLILHG E\ ORVLQJ WKHLU ILUVW HOHPHQW DQG E\ XQGHUJRLQJ SDODWDOL]DWLRQ:HRQO\KDYHDIHZDWWHVWDWLRQVRIWKLVGHYHORSPHQW ELVK¬‘EHDVWZLOGDQLPDO’Õ/DWEVWLDLG JXOçRM‘WRZRUU\WRGLVWXUE’Õ5RP FROOXFWLUHFI/DWFROOXFWUL ‘WRVWUXJJOHWRFRQWHQG’ PDUDM ‘IHQQHO’ Õ 5RP PDUDWKULXP GHULYDWLYH RI /DW PDUDWKUXP LG 7KHUDUHFOXVWHUEMVHHPVWRKDYHXQGHUJRQHDSHFXOLDUGHYHORSPHQWWR YJMLQWKHIROORZLQJFDVH YJMH ~ YJMê ‘SLQH’ Õ /DW DELHJQXP ‘UHODWHG WR ILU’ GHULYDWLYH RI DELHWHP‘ILU’ &OXVWHUVFRQWDLQLQJ/DWY JUDSKLFDOO\XRUY DUHQRWQXPHURXV,QWKH RQHFDVHZKHUHYIROORZVDYHODULWLVGURSSHG LQVRIDUDVWKHFOXVWHUJY ZDVLQIDFWRQHSKRQHPH>Þ@!>J@LQ/DWLQ O¬QJRM ‘WR ZHDNHQ WR ODQJXLVK’ Õ /DW ODQJXUH ‘WR EH IDLQW ODQJXLG’ ,QWKHPLGGOHRIWKHZRUGFOXVWHUVOYDQGUYJDYH$OEOEDQGUE XQOLNH WKH/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQ OZDQG UZ EXOE¬U‘VWUHHWGXVW’Õ/DWSXOYHUHP‘GXVW’ NRUE‘UDYHQ’Õ/DWFRUYXVLG VK¬OERM‘WRVDYHWRGHOLYHU’Õ/DWVDOYUHLG VK¬UEHM‘WRVHUYH’Õ/DWVHUYUHLG
phonology
111
+RZHYHULQWKHQHZDQODXWFUHDWHGE\WKHDSKHUHVLVRIWKHLQLWLDOYRZHO OYDQGUY\LHOGHG OO!Q E\GLVVLPLODWLRQ DQGUU QXOO¬I‘JXP’Õ/DWDOYHROXP‘GHQWDODOYHROH’ UU\O¬~UULOO¬‘OHQWLO’Õ/DWHUYLOODLG ,QVLPLODUFRQGLWLRQV/DWQYSURGXFHG$OEP P¬VRM‘WRWHDFKWRWUDLQ’Õ5RP LQYLWLUHLG PL]RM‘WRUDJHWRVQDUOWRKDWH’Õ5RP LQYLGLUHLG
&OXVWHUV FRQWDLQLQJ OLTXLG VRQRUDQWV DUH QXPHURXV WKRXJK WKHLUKLVWRU\LVQRWDOZD\VFOHDU
,QDQODXW/DWEUDQGGUZHUHSUHVHUYHG EUHN¬‘SDQWV’Õ/DWEUFDH‘WURXVHUVEUHHFKHV’ EUHWN‘IURJ’Õ5RP EURWDFXVLG EU\P¬I‘IURVW’Õ/DWEU PD‘FROGIURVW’ GUDJXD~GUD Q JXH‘GUDJRQ’Õ5RP GUDQFAQHPFI/DWGUDFAQHP LG +RZHYHU PHGLDOO\ YRLFHG ODELDOV DQG GHQWDOV ZHUH GURSSHG EHIRUH U \LHOGLQJU U IDUN¬‘VPLWK\’Õ/DWIDEULFD‘ZRUNVKRS’ KDUURM‘WRIRUJHW’Õ/DWDEHUUUH‘WRIRUJHW IRUDWLPH ’ NDUULJ¬‘FKDLU’Õ/DWTXDGUJD‘VHWRIIRXU’ KHUHRIIRXUOHJV NUHVKP¬‘IDVW’Õ/DWTXGUJVLPD‘/HQWIDVWRIIRUW\GD\V’ O¬UXVKN¬ ~ ODUXVKN¬ ‘ZLOG YLQH NLQG RI JUDSH FOHPDWLV’ Õ /DW OEUXVFD‘ZLOGYLQH’ VKXUXNRM‘WRWKXQGHUWRPDNHQRLVH’Õ5RP VXEUDXFDUH‘WRPDNH KRDUVH’ ,QRQHFDVHKRZHYHUEU\LHOGV JU!JM ¬ U HJM¬U‘/ROLXPWHPXOHQWXP’Õ/DWHEULDI‘GUXQN’ 7KHJURXSVUZDVUHGXFHGWRU
112
chapter one PMHU¬‘XQKDSS\XQIRUWXQDWH’Õ/DWPLVHUHPLG!5RP PLVUHP
,QDQODXWFOXVWHUVUVSRUDGLFDOO\GLVDSSHDUHGDIWHUXQYRLFHGVWRSV N¬VKW¬U~N¬VKW¬Q‘&KULVWLDQ’Õ/DWFKULVWLQXVLG SDOOS¬UUDOO‘WRMHVWWRWULIOH’EDVHGRQS¬UUDOO¬‘WDOHVWRU\’Õ/DW SDUDEROD‘SURYHUEVSHHFK’ 7KH/DWLQFOXVWHUUQJDYHUU RURFFDVLRQDOO\U LQ$OEDQLDQ IHUU‘KHOO’Õ/DWLQIHUQXPLG IXUU‘RYHQ’,IXUU¬LGÕ/DWIXUQXVLG IXUULN‘FKLFNHQFRRSIRZOSHQURRVWQHVWLQJER[’Õ/DWIRUQLFHP ‘DUFKYDXOW’ N¬UUXW¬‘KRUQHGHZH’Õ/DWIHPDGMFRUQ WD‘KRUQHG’ OXTHU¬‘ODPSODQWHUQ’Õ/DWOXFHUQDLG Y¬UUL ~ Y¬UUî ‘ZLQWHU SDVWXUH’ Õ 5RP KLEHUQQXP GHULYDWLYH RI /DWKLEHUQXP‘ZLQWHU’ ,QWULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV/DWUZDVXVXDOO\ORVWLQWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKH FOXVWHU SMHVKN¬‘SHDFK’Õ5RP SHVFD /DWSHUVLFDLG
/DWLQ FOXVWHUV FRQVLVWLQJ RI YHODUV IROORZHG E\ O UHPDLQHG
XQFKDQJHGWLOOWKHHQGRIWKH0LGGOH$JHV/DWHULQVRPHGLDOHFWVOJDYH MZKLFKSDODWDOL]HGYHODUV\LHOGLQJJMDQGT7KH XQYRLFHG SDODWDOZDV WKHQGHSDODWDOL]HGLQDQHYHQPRUHOLPLWHGQXPEHURIGLDOHFWVUHVXOWLQJ LQ N 6RPH ZRUGV ZLWK N /DW FO ZHUH RFFDVLRQDOO\ DEVRUEHG E\ VWDQGDUGOLWHUDU\GLDOHFWVRI$OEDQLDQ JMHOE¬U~JMHOE¬Q‘JUHHQ’Õ/DWJDOELQXV‘JUHHQLVK\HOORZ’ JMHU‘GRUPRXVH’Õ/DWJOUHPLG JM¬QG¬U~JMDQG¬U‘JODQG’Õ/DWJODQGXOD‘JODQGRIWKHWKURDW’ZLWK WKHGLVVLPLODWLRQRIOLTXLGD N¬VK\UH‘PRXQWDLQSDWKSDWKLQWKHUDYLQH’Õ/DWFODXV UDFO V UD ‘ORFNEDUEROW FDVWOHIRUW’ NLVK¬TLVK¬‘FKXUFK’Õ/DWHFFOVLDLG TDUW¬‘FOHDU’Õ/DWFOUXVLG THQJM‘ODPE’Õ5RP FLQJ X OXV /DWJQLFXOXVLG
phonology
113
TXP¬VKWNOXP¬VKW‘PLONZKH\’Õ5RP FRORVWUXP /DWJOEHFDPHMOLQWHUYRFDOLFDOO\ ]PRMOH ‘IDOORZ ODQG ’ Õ 5RP H[PXOJLD D GHULYDWLYH RI /DW [ PXOJUH‘WRPLONRXWWRGUDLQRXW’ 7KH /DWLQ FOXVWHU OF LQLWLDOO\ EHFDPH ON /DWHU O FKDQJHG WR M LQ PRVW GLDOHFWV EXMNEXON‘SHDVDQW’Õ/DWEXEXOFXV‘SORXJKPDQKHUGVPDQ’ IDMNXD~IDMNXH‘IDOFRQ’Õ/DWIDOFAQHPLG $WOHDVWLQRQHFDVHM OZDVGURSSHGEHIRUHDYHODU IXTL‘SRZHUVWUHQJWKIRUFH’Õ5RP IXOFLXVGHULYHGIURPIXOFUH ‘WRSURSXSWRVXSSRUWWRPDNHVWURQJ’ ,QWKHLQLWLDOSRVLWLRQ/DWPO HPHUJLQJDIWHUWKHORVVRILQODXWYRZHOV FKDQJHGWR$OEEO EOHW¬ ‘EHH VZDUP KLYH’ Õ 5RP PHOHWWXP FI PHOODULXP ‘EHH KLYHDSLDU\’ EOXDM~EOXHM‘WRJULQG’Õ/DWPROHUHLG ,QWKHLQLWLDOSRVLWLRQ/DWVODQGVFOQRUPDOO\JDYHVKTRUIRUUHDVRQV XQFOHDUVT VKTXIXU VTXIXU ‘VXOSKXU’ Õ 5RP VOXIXUHP LQVWHDG RI /DW VXOSKXUHP VKTD‘%XOJDULDQ’Õ/DWVFODYXV‘6ODY’ VKTHSRM‘WREHODPH’Õ5RP VFOASXV 7ULFRQVRQDQWDO FOXVWHUV ZLWK LQLWLDO O DSSHDULQJ DIWHU WKH ORVV RI RI LQODXWYRZHOV GURSWKHLUPLGGOHHOHPHQW NXOWH ‘ZDWHU PHORQ JRXUG’ Õ 5RP FXFXOELWD D YDULDQW RI /DW FXFXUELWD‘JRXUG’ NXOW¬U‘SLOORZFXVKLRQ’Õ/DWFXOFLWUDLG
114
chapter one
+RZHYHU LQ RQH FDVH WKLV SURFHVV ZDV DFFRPSDQLHG E\ WKH YRLFLQJ RI DQXQYRLFHGRFFOXVLYH YLJMH ‘JLIWV RQ PDUULDJH RU ELUWK GLQQHU RQ WKH WKLUG GD\ DIWHU FKLOG’VELUWK’Õ/DWYFWXOLD‘YLFWXDOV’
/DW PQ GURSSHG WKH VHFRQG QDVDO DQG RFFDVLRQDOO\ D VHFRQGDU\KRPRUJDQLFRFFOXVLYHIRUPHG
G¬P~GDP‘GDPDJH’Õ/DWGDPQXP‘KXUWKDUGDPDJH’ VKN¬PE ~ VKNDPE ‘VHDW WKURQH URFN’ Õ /DW VFDPQXP ‘EHQFK WKURQH’ ,QFOXVWHUVFRQVLVWLQJRIDQDVDOVRQRUDQWDQGDQXQYRLFHGVWRSWKHODWWHU EHFDPHYRLFHG JMLQGH‘SHRSOH’Õ/DWJHQWHPLG JMXYHQJ¬‘KDUORW’Õ/DWIHPMXYHQFD‘\RXQJ’DOVR‘\RXQJFRZ’ N¬PERU¬~N¬PERQ¬‘EHOO’Õ5RP FDPSRQDDGHULYDWLRQDOYDULDQW RI/DWFDPSDQDLG PEUHW‘NLQJ’Õ5RP LPSHUWXVIRU/DWLPSHUWRU‘HPSHURU’ UU¬PEHM‘WRUREWRVHL]H’Õ/DWUXPSHUH‘WRWHDUWRWHDUDZD\’ VK¬QGRVK‘KHDOWK\’Õ5RP VDQLWAVXVLG WUXQJ‘WUXQN’Õ/DWWUXQFXVLG ,QKHWHURUJDQLFFOXVWHUVUHJUHVVLYHDVVLPLODWLRQVWRRNSODFH PEHV¬‘QLHFHJUDQGGDXJKWHU’Õ/DWQHSAWLDLG PEXORM‘WRFRYHUWREXU\’Õ5RP PDQLSXOUH‘WRGLJLQKDQGIXOV’ FI/DWPDQLSXOXV‘KDQGIXO’ &OXVWHUVZLWKYRLFHGRFFOXVLYHVGLGQRWFKDQJHVLJQLILFDQWO\+RZHYHU QJ EHIRUH IURQW YRZHOV KDYLQJ FKDQJHG WR H[SHFWHG QJM IXUWKHU GHYHORSHGLQWRQM P¬QMLOO‘YLJLO IDVW’Õ5RP YLQJLOLDFI/DWYLJLOLD‘YLJLO’ VKXVKXQM¬‘OHHFK’Õ5RP VDJXLVXQJLD /DWVDQJXLVXJDLG XVKXQM¬~XVKûMI‘ODUG’Õ/DWD[XQJLDLG
phonology
115
2ULJLQDOQJMIURPQJRUIURPDVVLPLODWHGQJ QGZDVRQO\UHWDLQHGLQD OLPLWHGQXPEHURIZRUGV PDOO¬QJMHM ‘WR WRXFK WR PRYH WR VWLU’ Õ /DW PDOXP DQJHUH ‘WR FDXVHSDLQ’ UU¬QJMHM‘WRVKLQH’Õ/DWUHQGUH‘WRVKLQH’ &OXVWHUVZLWKQDVDOVIROORZLQJJKDYHDFRPSOLFDWHGKLVWRU\%HIRUHP WKHYRLFHGYHODUZDVORVW WLP¬U~WLP¬Q‘ZHIWZRRI’Õ/DWWHJPLQHP‘FRYHU’ ,Q VRPH ZRUGV WKH VDPH GHYHORSPHQW FKDUDFWHUL]HG JQ 7KLV FOXVWHU FKDQJHG WR Q DQG FRXOG GLVDSSHDU DW WKH HQG RI WKH ZRUG H[DFWO\ OLNH VLPSOHQ NXQDW ~ NXQHW¬Q ‘EURWKHULQODZ’ Õ /DW FRJQWXV ‘NLQVPDQ EORRG UHODWLRQ’ YJMH ~ YJMê ‘SLQH’ Õ /DW DELHJQXP ‘UHODWHG WR ILU’ GHULYDWLYH RI DELHWHP‘ILU’ ,QRWKHU ROGHU" ORDQZRUGV/DWJQ\LHOGVQM GHQM¬‘ZRUWK’Õ/DWGLJQXVLG VKHQM¬‘VLJQ’Õ/DWVLJQXPLG ,QDQRWKHUFDVHZHILQGQJUHIOHFWLQJ/DWJQ SHQJ‘SOHGJHSDZQ’Õ/DWSLJQXVLG 7KHFOXVWHUQVZDVUHJXODUO\VLPSOLILHGDQGFKDQJHGWRVK LVKXOO‘LVODQG’Õ/DWLQVXODLG P¬VKHUH‘VPDOOSLHFHRIFKHHVH’Õ5RP PHQVAUDIRU/DWPHQV UD ‘PHDVXUH’ P¬VKRM‘WREHKHDY\WREHDUGRZQ’Õ5RP SHVUH /DWSHQVUH ‘WRZHLJK’ SHVK¬‘ZHLJKW VWRQHERXOGHU’Õ/DWSHQVXPLG WUDVK¬JRM‘WRLQKHULW’Õ/DWWUQVLJHUH‘WRUHDFKDQDFFRUGWRFDUU\ RXWWUDQVDFWLRQ’
116
chapter one
1XPHURXVWULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV PDQ\RIWKHPUHVXOWLQJIURPWKHORVV RI XQVWUHVVHG LQWHUFRQVRQDQWDO YRZHOV FRQWDLQLQJ QDVDO VRQRUDQWV GHYHORSHGDVVXFK EHNRM‘WREHQHGLFW’Õ/DWEHQHGFHUHLG NXPW¬U‘JRGIDWKHU’Õ/DWFRPSDWHULG N¬QJ¬~NDQJ¬‘VRQJ’Õ/DWFDQWLFXPLG $VSHFLDOFDVHLVWKHHYROXWLRQRI/DWQFW7KHKLVWRU\RIWKLVFOXVWHULV GLVFXVVHGEHORZWRJHWKHUZLWK/DWFW
7KH PRVW LQWHUHVWLQJ GHYHORSPHQW DPRQJ /DWLQ FOXVWHUV
FRQVLVWLQJ RI WZR RFFOXVLYHV LV WKDW RI FW 6HFRQGDU\ FOXVWHUV UHVXOWLQJ IURPWKHORVVRILQODXWYRZHOVDVZHOODVFW JWDUHDOVRLQFOXGHGKHUH 7KHGHYHORSPHQWRIWULFRQVRQDQWDOQFWLVFRQVLGHUHGKHUHDVZHOO/DWFW KDVVHYHUDOUHIOH[HVLQ$OEDQLDQ MWIWDQGW 6HYHUDO/DWLQORDQZRUGVUHIOHFWLQJFWDVIW DQGQFWDVPW QIW FDPH IURP WKH (DVW %DONDQ DUHD ZKHUH LQ 5XPDQLDQ FW LV QRUPDOO\ UHSUHVHQWHGE\5XPSW G¬IWRM‘WRVKRZWRSRLQW’Õ5RP LQGLFWUHLG IWXD ~ IWXH ‘TXLQFH’ Õ 5RP FRWAQHXP LG QDPHO\ ‘&\GRQLDQ DSSOH’ JM\PW\U¬‘MRLQWOLPE’Õ/DWMXQFW UD‘MXQFWXUHMRLQW’ OXIW¬‘ILJKWZDU’Õ/DWOXFWD‘ZUHVWOLQJ’FI5XPOXSW:‘ILJKW’ WDIW‘VWHQFK VFRUFKLQJKHDW’Õ/DWWFWXV‘WRXFKIHHOLQJ’ WDIWDU‘IXQQHO’Õ5RP WUDLHFWULXPLGFI/DWWUDLHFWAULXPLG WURIW¬‘WURXW’Õ/DWWUXFWDLG $GLIIHUHQWGHYHORSPHQWRIQFWÖIWLVIRXQGLQWKHIROORZLQJFDVH SXIW¬ ‘HPSW\ KROORZ’ RQO\ LQ WKH H[SUHVVLRQ DUU¬ SXIWH ‘HPSW\ QXW’ Õ/DWIHPSXQFWD‘SXQFWXUHGKDYLQJDKROH’ ,QDOORWKHUFDVHVFWFKDQJHGWRMWDQGQFWWR Q MWDFFRUGLQJWRWKH:HVW %DONDQ DQG:HVW5RPDQFH QRUP GUHMW¬‘VWUDLJKWULJKW’Õ/DWGLUHFWXPLG
phonology
117
PDMW¬ ~ PDˆMW¬ ‘OHIW’ Õ 5RP PDQFWXV EDVHG RQ /DW PDQFXV ‘PDLPHGLQILUP’ SDMWRM‘WRDSSHDVHWRUHFRQFLOHWRKLUHWRHQJDJH’Õ5RP SFWUH VKHQMW¬‘VDLQW’Õ/DWVDQFWXVLG VKWUHQMW¬ ‘GHDU H[SHQVLYH’ Õ 5RP VWULQFWXV ‘QDUURZ’ 5XP VWUîPW9HQHWVWUHQWR6,WDOVWULQWR WUDMWRM‘WRGHDOZLWKWRWUHDW’Õ/DWWUDFWUHLG /DWHU M ZDV ORVW VR WKDW FW \LHOGHG W DQG QFW JDYH QG LI WKH FOXVWHU IROORZHGHLXRU IOXWXURM ‘WR IO\’ Õ 5RP IOXFWXOUH /DW IOXFWXUH ‘WR PRYH LQ ZDYHVWRPRYHWRDQGIUR’ IU\W‘IUXLW’Õ/DWIU FWXVLG I\W\U¬‘IDFH’Õ/DWIDFW UD‘IRUPDWLRQFUHDWXUH’ KHWRM ‘WR VHDUFK WR LQTXLUH WR GLVFRYHU’ Õ /DW GLFWUH ‘WR DQ QRXQFH’ NXQGRM‘WRKHVLWDWH’Õ/DWFXQFWULLG SLWH‘KRQH\FRPE’Õ/DWSHFWHQ‘FRPE’ VKDW‘KRH’Õ/DWVHFWRU‘FXWWHU’ VKHWH‘EUDQ’Õ/DWVHFWXPSDUWLFLSOHRIVHFA‘WRFXW’ XQG\U¬‘IDW’Õ/DWXQFW UD‘RLQWPHQW’ YLWRUH‘P\WKLFDOVHUSHQW NHHSHURIWKHKRXVH IDLU\IDWH PRWKHURI PDQ\FKLOGUHQ’Õ/DWYLFWRULD‘YLFWRU\’ 7KH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOH DSSHDUV WR EH DW YDULDQFH ZLWK WKLV UXOH +RZHYHUWKLVLVLOOXVRU\,QWHUYRFDOLFJZDVORVWEHIRUHWKHUHGXFWLRQRI XQVWUHVVHGYRZHOVDQGWKHVHTXHQFHRIWZRYRZHOVFRQWUDFWHG7KHIRUP EHORZQHYHUKDGWKHFOXVWHUJW!FW NXMWRM‘WRUHPHPEHUWRWKLQN’ NXLWRMÕ/DWFAJLWUH 6HFRQGDU\T WEHIRUHDIURQWYRZHODSSHDUVLQWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOH SOLT ‘WZLVWHG ZRROOHQ FRUG’ Õ /DW SOHFWD ‘ERUGHU RI LQWHUZRYHQ OLQHVLQUHOLHI SODLW’ 2QH PRUH FDVH VHHPV WR SUHVHUYH N LQ WKH FRQVRQDQWDO JURXS IRU DQ XQNQRZQUHDVRQ
chapter one
118
OLNW\U¬I‘URSHIRUELQGLQJDEXQGOHRIZRRG EDQGEDQGDJH’Õ/DW OLJW UD‘EDQGEXQFK’ 7KH/DWLQFOXVWHUWWUHIOHFWVDVVLPSOHWLQ$OEDQLDQ EOHW¬‘EHHVZDUPKLYH’Õ5RP PHOHWWXPFIPHOODULXP‘EHHKLYH DSLDU\’ EXW‘ELJEDUUHO’Õ/DWEXWWLVLG JXW¬‘JRXW’Õ5RP JXWWD‘GURS’XVHGDVDQDPHRIWKHGLVHDVHFI 5XPJXW:LG /DWSW\LHOGHG$OEIW DIW¬‘FDSDEOHSURSHU’Õ/DWDSWXVLG TLIW‘NLWHNLQGRIYXOWXUH’Õ/DWDFFLSLWHU‘YXOWXUH’ ,Q RQH FDVH SW ZDV SUHVHUYHG DIWHU WKH IDOO RI WKH LQODXW YRZHO 7KLV DOORZVXVWRHVWDEOLVKUHODWLYHFKURQRORJ\RIWKHSURFHVV OHSW\U¬ ‘PXGG\ SODFH’ Õ 5RP OLSSLW UD FI /DW OLSSLW GR ‘EOHDU HGQHVVUKHXP’ 7KHIROORZLQJFDVHFDQEHH[SODLQHGRQO\LIZHSUHVXPHDFKDLQRIDVVL PLODWLRQVDQGUHFRPELQDWLRQVIURPEDSWWR SDEW! SDJG! SDJ SDJ¬]RM‘WREDSWLVH’Õ/DWEDSWL]UHLG
&OXVWHUV FRQWDLQLQJ V UHIOHFW D FRPSOLFDWHG SLFWXUH *URXS [ FV \LHOGHGWZRUHIOH[HV,QVRPHZRUGVIVK [LVIRXQGVLPLODUWRIW FW,WSUHVXPDEO\SDVVHGWKURXJKWKHVWDJHRI SVK NRIVK¬‘KLSWKLJK’Õ/DWFR[D‘KLS’ ODIVK¬‘FUHVW RIELUG FRPE’Õ/DWOD[D FXWLV ‘ORRVH VNLQ ’ P¬QGDIVK‘VLON’Õ/DWPHWD[D‘UDZVLON’ ZLWKVHFRQGDU\Q ,QRWKHUFDVHVWKHUHIOH[LVVK7KLVGHYHORSPHQWLVSDUDOOHOWRWKDWRIFW LQWRMWW&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EXVK‘ER[ZRRG’Õ/DWEX[XVLG IUDVK¬U~IUDVK¬Q‘DVKWUHH’Õ/DWIUD[LQXVLG
phonology
119
SURVKPRMSUR]KPRM‘WRVODQGHUWROLEHO’Õ/DWSUR[LPUH‘WRFRPH QHDUWRDSSURDFK’ VKLM~VKî ‘WRWKUHVK’Õ/DWH[LJHUH‘WRGULYHDZD\WRSXVKRXWWR WKURZ’ VKTLSRM‘WRVSHDNFOHDUO\WRXQGHUVWDQG’Õ/DWH[FLSHUHLG ,QRQHFDVHUHSUHVHQWLQJDERUURZLQJRIDODWHUGDWH[EHFDPHYRLFHG] EHIRUHDVRQRUDQW ]PRMOH I ‘IDOORZ ODQG ’ Õ 5RP H[PXOJLD D GHULYDWLYH RI /DW H[PXOJUH‘WRPLONRXWWRGUDLQRXW’FI5XP]PXOJH 7KHFOXVWHUSV\LHOGHGIVKLQ$OEDQLDQMXVWOLNHVRPHRIWKHZRUGVZLWK FV JULIVK¬‘MD\PDJSLH’Õ5RP JULSVDEDVHGRQ/DWJU\SV‘JULIILQ’ NDIVKRM‘WRELWH’Õ/DWFDSHVVHUH~FDSLVVHUH‘WRVHL]HWRVQDWFKDW’ /DWVWLVQRUPDOO\UHIOHFWHGDV$OEVKW SDVKWUDN‘SDVWXUHUHQWSDVWXUDJHPRQH\’Õ5RP SDVW UFXVEDVHG RQ/DWSDVW UD‘SDVWXUH’ SRVKW¬‘GRZQEHORZ XQGHU’Õ/DWSRVWSRVWH‘EHKLQGEDFN’ VKWDOO¬‘VWDOO’Õ/DWVWDEXOXPLG VKWDW‘ILJXUHLPDJH’Õ/DWVWDWXV‘KHLJKWVWDWXUH’ 2FFDVLRQDOO\KRZHYHU/DWVW!VKWLVUHSODFHGE\ç çPRM‘WRHVWLPDWH’Õ/DWDHVWLPUHLG 7ULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUVEHJLQQLQJZLWKV LQFOXGLQJWKRVHUHVXOWLQJIURP WKHORVVRILQODXWYRZHOV WHQGWRORVHWKHLUVHFRQGGHQWDOHOHPHQWFIWKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EMHVKN¬ ‘PRXQWDLQ SDVWXUH’ Õ 5RP SDVWLFD EDVHG RQ /DW SDVWXV ‘SDVWXUH’ G¬VKPRM‘WRWHVWLI\’Õ5RP WHVWLPAQLUH PXVKOOLQ]¬ ‘FODPEHULQJ YHWFK’ EDVHG RQ PXVKOOî Õ 5RP PXV WOQDGHULYDWLYHRI/DWPXVWOD‘ZHDVHO’
120
chapter one
$OOWKUHHFRQVRQDQWVDUHSUHVHUYHGLQ/DWVWUÖ$OEVKW ¬ U NXOORVKW¬U‘ELHVWOLQJV’Õ/DWFRORVWUDLG PMHVKW¬U‘PDVWHUEXLOGHU’Õ/DWPDJLVWHU‘PDVWHU’ VKWUDW‘EHG OD\HU’Õ/DWVWUWXPLG VKWU¬QJRM‘WRSUHVVWRVTXHH]H’Õ/DWVWULQJHUH‘WRVWUHWFKWRSUHVV WRVTXHH]H’ YRVKW¬U‘/LJXVWUXPYXOJDUH’ *HJ ÕODWH/DW²OHDVWHU ,IWKHVHFRQGHOHPHQWZDVDODELDODWULFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUORVWLQLWLDOV SULIW‘SULHVW’Õ/DWSUHVE\WHULG 7KHJURXS[F FVF JLYHV$OEç çRM‘WREULQJWRULVHWRVHQG’Õ/DWH[FUHH[FLUH‘WRFDOORXWWR FDXVHWRZDNH’
6ODYLFORDQZRUGV 6ODYLFRFFOXVLYHVDUHZHOOSUHVHUYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ7KHFKDQJH
RI6ODY GDIWHUYRZHOVDQGUWR$OEGKFDQEHH[SODLQHGE\SRVLWLQJDQ HDUOLHUERUURZLQJSHULRG çHUGKH‘QHVW’Õ6ODY ¨HUGD‘URZKHUGIORFN’ J¬UPDGK¬‘UXLQ’Õ6ODY JURPDGD‘KHDSPDVV’ NRUGK¬‘VZRUG’Õ6ODY NRUÙGDLG VKN¬UGKHF‘NHJEDUUHO’Õ6ODY VNRYRUGÚFÚ‘SDQ’ ,QHDUO\6ODYLFERUURZLQJV6ODY NJLYHV$OEJ
ERULJ¬‘NLQGRISLQH VSOLQWHU’Õ6ODY ERULND‘ILUWUHHSLQH’ JDMJ¬ ‘NLQG RI QXW’ Õ 6ODY JDOÚND GHULYHG IURP JDO’D ‘OXPS SHEEOH’ J¬OED]¬‘a OLYHULOOQHVVRIVKHHSFDXVHGE\ZRUPV’Õ6ODY NÙOEDVD ‘VWXIIHGJXWVDXVDJH’ J¬UçDN‘MXJSLWFKHU’Õ6ODY NÙU¨DJÙ‘FOD\YHVVHOSLWFKHU’ J¬UKDV‘WRVQRUH’Õ6ODY NÙU[DWL‘WRFRXJKWRH[SHFWRUDWH’ UDYJ¬‘SDWK LQPRXQWDLQV ’Õ6ODY URYÙNÙ‘GLWFK’
phonology
121
(DUO\6ODY VLVUHIOHFWHGDVVKLQ$OEDQLDQ NROHVKN¬‘FDUW’Õ6ODY NROHVÙNDLG VKDS ‘GLVHDVH RI WKH FDWWOH $SKWD HSL]RRWLFD’ Õ 6ODY VDSÙ ‘JODQGHUV’ VKDU¬‘RIIHQFH’Õ6ODY VRUDFI5XVVVVRUD‘URZ’ VÙVRUD VKDUN‘ZRROHQFORDN JUHHQVNLQRIQXWV’Õ6ODY VRUND‘VKLUW’ WULVKH‘VKRRWLQJVSURXW’Õ6ODY WUÚVÙ‘JUDSHVWDON’ 2QH6ODYLFDIIULFDWHLQHDUO\ORDQZRUGVKDVDQXQXVXDOUHIOH[LQ$OED QLDQ,QWKHHDUOLHVWORDQZRUGV6ODY ¨LVVXEVWLWXWHGE\(3$ Wh!$OE V ELVN‘EUDQFKWZLJ’Õ6ODY EL¨ÚNÙGHULYHGIURP EL¨Ú‘ZKLS’ EULVN‘UD]RUSHQNQLIH’Õ6ODY EUL¨ÚNÙGLPLQXWLYHRI EUL¨ÚLG SRURVLW‘WRRUGHUWRGHPDQG’Õ6ODY SRU_¨LWLLG /DWHUDWDVWDJHZKHQ$OEDQLDQKDVDOUHDG\GHYHORSHGDQHZDIIULFDWHF EXWVWLOOKDGQRç6ODY ¨ZDVUHIOHFWHGDV$OEF FDUH‘ZLWFK’Õ6ODY ¨DUD‘ZLWFKFUDIW’ FHUP¬‘DUWKULWLV’Õ6ODY ¨ÚUPÙ‘LQIODPPDWLRQ’ F¬ULO‘WKUXVK’Õ6ODY ¨ÚUQLGOR‘EODFN REMHFW ’ FXE ‘ZLWK D VKRUW WDLO ZLWK WKH WDLO FXW RII’ Õ 6ODY ¨XEÙ ‘WXIW RI KDLUVWXPSDFXWRIISLHFH’ N¬UF‘VWXPS’Õ6ODY NÙU¨ÚLG N¬UFDV ‘WR FU\ WR VKRXW WR UDWWOH WR WKXQGHU WR VRXQG’ Õ 6ODY
NUL¨DWL‘WRFU\WRVKRXW’ ,QRQHFDVHZHDOVRKDYH6ODY ÊUHSODFHGE\$OE] QR]LN¬ ‘NQLIH ZRUQ LQ WKH EHOW’ Õ 6ODY QRÊLNÙ D GLPLQXWLYH RI
QRÊÚ‘NQLIH’ ,QDOLPLWHGQXPEHURI6ODYLFORDQZRUGVVHYHUDOFOXVWHUVFKDQJHGLQD ZD\ WKDW FRXOG LQGLFDWH WKHLU HDUO\ SUHVHQFH LQ $OEDQLDQ &I WKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EXVKW¬U‘UDJLQJZLOG’Õ6ODY E\VWUÙ‘TXLFN’ GURPF¬‘FUXPEELW’Õ6ODY GUREÚQLFD‘WULIOHVPDOOREMHFW’
122
chapter one JDUULV‘WRQHLJK’Õ6ODY JDYÚULWL~ JDYÚUDWL‘WRWHDVHWRVSRLO’ JRUULF¬‘ZLOGSHDU’Õ6ODY JRUÚQLFDLG NRF‘ERQHVNXOO’Õ6ODY NRVWÚLG Y¬UV¬~Y¬UF¬‘DJH’Õ6ODY YÚUVWD‘DJHNLQGNLQ’
0253+212/2*<$1':25')250$7,21 6WUHVV 2XUNQRZOHGJHRIKRZWKH$OEDQLDQVWUHVVV\VWHPGHYHORSHGLV
XQIRUWXQDWHO\ YHU\ OLPLWHG 6LJQLILFDQW SDUWV RI RXU GHVFULSWLRQ DUH WKHUHIRUHD UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ UHTXLULQJ IXUWKHU UHVHDUFK DQG FRPSDUDWLYH PDWHULDO
/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQ6WUHVV $W WKH WLPH RI /DWLQ$OEDQLDQ FRQWDFWV WKH /DWH 3URWR $OEDQLDQ VWUHVV PXVW KDYH UDGLFDOO\ FKDQJHG LQ FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK LWV HDUOLHUVWUXFWXUH VHHEHORZ 1XPHURXVORDQZRUGVLQIOXHQFHGWKHVWUHVV SDWWHUQV VR WKDW WKH VWUHVV EHFDPH G\QDPLF DQG OLQNHG WR WZR IL[HG V\OODEOHVLQWKHZRUG WKHSHQXOWLPDWHDQGSUDHSHQXOWLPDWH /LWHUDWXUH -2./ /.8%$ Ç$%(- +\UMH 6W ,,, &$0$-$OE:RUWE 25(/=I%DON;;,,,
7KH GLVWULEXWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKHVH WZR W\SHV RI VWUHVV LV
SDUWLFXODUO\ZHOOSUHVHUYHGLQ/DWLQORDQZRUGV$OOGLV\OODELFZRUGVDUH SDUR[\WRQD GHQM¬‘ZRUWK’Õ/DWGLJQXVLG NDUU¬‘FDUW’Õ/DWFDUUXP‘WZRZKHHOHGZDJRQ’ PDOO ‘KRPHVLFNQHVV ORQJLQJ DIIHFWLRQ’ Õ /DW PDOXP ‘HYLO PLVIRUWXQH’ QDS¬ ‘FORWK QDSNLQ WRZHO NHUFKLHI’ Õ 5RP QDSSD ! )U QDSSH ‘WDEOHFORWK’ SDN‘DOLWWOHIHZ’Õ/DWSDXFXV‘IHZOLWWOH’ SDOO¬‘SROH FOXE ZDVKLQJVWLFN VZRUG PDOOHW’ Õ /DWSOD‘VSDGH VKRYHO’ 2QH DOVR ILQGV QXPHURXV SDUR[\WRQD LQ ZRUGV ZLWK PRUH WKDQ WZR V\OODEOHV IDMNXD~IDMNXH‘IDOFRQ’Õ/DWIDOFAQHPLG
124
chapter two
QDW\U¬‘QDWXUH’Õ/DWQW UDLG SDUUL]‘SDUDGLVH’Õ/DWSDUDGVXVLG SDVKWUDN ‘SDVWXUHUHQW SDVWXUDJH PRQH\’ Õ 5RP SDVW UFXV EDVHGRQ/DWSDVW UD‘SDVWXUH’ T\WHW‘FLW\’Õ/DWFYLWWH P LG U¬U¬~UDQ¬‘VDQG’Õ/DWDUQDLG 7KHVHFDVHVDUHRSSRVHGE\DODUJHJURXSRISURSDUR[\WRQD EDOç¬P‘EDOP’Õ/DWEDOVDPXPLG HPW¬‘DXQW’Õ/DWDPLWD‘SDWHUQDODXQW’ HQJM¬OO‘DQJHO’Õ/DWDQJHOXVLG OHSXUOHSXM‘KDUH’Õ/DWOHSRUHPLG PDVKNXOO‘PDQ’‘PDOH’Õ/DWPDVFXOXV‘PDOHPDVFXOLQH’ QGULNXOO‘JRGPRWKHU PLGZLIH’Õ/DWPWUFXODXVHGLQWKHVHQVHRI 5RP PWUQDLG!,WDOPDGULQD :KHQ ERUURZHG LQWR /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ /DWLQ ZRUGV SUHVHUYHG WKH SODFHRIWKHLUVWUHVV
$VLPLODUSLFWXUHLVIRXQGLQWKH,QGR(XURSHDQYRFDEXODU\RI $OEDQLDQ$OOGLV\OODELFZRUGVDUHSDUR[\WRQD
GDUN¬ ‘VXSSHU’ (3$ GDUN ,( GRUáRP UHIOHFWHG LQ Gk GRTRQPLG GKDOO¬ ~ GKDOOW¬ ‘EXWWHUPLON’ (3$ G]DO Gk ICNC JHQ ICNCMVQX‘PLON’ HGK‘KHJRDW’ (3$ DLG]D GkCKE‘JRDW’$UPD\FLG IDU¬ ‘VHHG VHPHQ NLQ’ (3$ VSDU Gk IHP URQTC ‘VHHG’ DQG IXUWKHU UHODWHG WR VSHU ‘WR VSLOO WR VRZ’ Gk URGKTY LG URGTOC‘VHPHQVHHG‘ JMDN‘EORRG’ (3$ VDND GkQRQX‘MXLFH’/LWKVDND&‘UHVLQ’6ODY
VRNÙ‘MXLFH’ MHUP ‘GHOLULXP DEVHQWPLQGHGQHVV’ (3$ HUPD /LWK H¼PDV ‘PRQVWHU’ /DWY ?UPV ‘ZRQGHUIXO DSSDULWLRQ’ ?UPL ‘ZRQGHUV PLUDFOHV’ 7KHUHDOVRH[LVWSRO\V\OODELFSDUR[\WRQD
morphonology and word-formation
125
JOHS¬‘PDWWHUIURPH\HVUKHXP LQH\HV ’ (3$ NDODLSGHULYHG IURP,( OHLS‘WRVPHDUZLWKIDW’ N¬SXUGK¬‘IXQJXVPXVKURRP’ (3$ NDSXUG /LWKNªSXU^‘FDS’ /DWYF?SXUHLG OXPDN‘EXGVKRRW OLFKHQPRVV’ OXEQDNDEDVHGRQ,( OHXEK‘WR SHHOWRVNLQ’ /LWKOXE£‘ERDUG RIDFHLOLQJ ’/DWYOXED‘EDUN ERDUG’23UXVOXEER‘ERDUG’6ODY OÙEÙ‘IRUHKHDGVNXOO’ P¬OOHQM¬ ‘EODFNELUG’ (3$ PHODQM IURP ,( IHP PHOiQ ‘EODFN’ ! Gk µεNCKPC LG FI DOVR 6NW PDOLQ¢ IHP PDOLQ ‘GLUW\XQFOHDQ/DWYP?ËQV‘EODFN’ WHW¬ ‘HLJKW’ (3$ DNWAWL ,( RWA LG 6NW D¿bd $UP RZ Gk QMVY XUHO¬‘ZDWHUSLW’ (3$ XUHO 21·U‘GUL]]OH’23UXVZXUV‘SRRO’ GkCPCWTQX‘GHYRLGRIZDWHU’ 2WKHUSRO\V\OODELFZRUGVDUHSURSDUR[\WRQD DWK¬W ‘KDUVK VRXU UDQFLG’ (3$ DWVHWD ,( D ‘VKDUS’ ZLWK VRPH GHULYDWLYHV GHYHORSLQJ WKH PHDQLQJ ‘VRXU’ VXFK DV /DW DFLGXV JDUEH ‘IORZHUSRW’ (originally, *‘pot’ (3$ JDULE FI 6ODY
JÙUQÙ‘SRW’GHULYHGIURP,( ÞKHU‘WREXUQ’ PRGKXOO ‘YHWFK FKLFNOLQJ FKLFNSHD’ (3$ PG]XOD FORVH WR /LWKPDʸOLV‘VPDOO’DQGIXUWKHUUHODWHGWR/LWKP¦ÊDVLG PRW¬U‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU‘PRWKHU’ 6NWPW¢UGk OJVJT/DWPWHU WMHW¬UMHW¬U‘RWKHU’ 3$OE HWHUD 6ODY HWHUÙ‘VRPHVRPHERG\’ WKHOE‘NHUQHO RIDQXW ’ (3$ WVDOLEDDGHULYDWLYHRI,( HO‘WR FRYHU’ $WDODWHUVWDJHXQVWUHVVHGSHQXOWLPDWHYRZHOVRISURSDUR[\WRQDZHUH UHGXFHG DQG ORVW ZLWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI WKH ZRUGV ZKHUH WKH YRZHOV ZHUHIROORZHGE\OLTXLGVRQRUDQWV FIH[DPSOHVDERYH
,W LV FOHDU WKDW—XQOLNH /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV—WKH RSSRVLWLRQ RI
SDUR[\WRQDDQGSURSDUR[\WRQDLQWKH$OEDQLDQZRUGVRI,QGR(XURSHDQ RULJLQZDVQRWFDXVHGE\WKHTXDQWLW\RIWKHSHQXOWLPDWHYRZHO:LWKRXW DQ\GRXEWWKLVRSSRVLWLRQJRHVEDFNWRWKH(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQVWDJH ZKHQWKHVWUHVVPXVWKDYHEHHQSDUDGLJPDWLFDOO\PRELOH
126
chapter two
,Q /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKHUH UHPDLQ RQO\ D IHZ LQGLYLGXDO WUDFHV RI SDUDGLJPDWLFPRELOLW\$QLQWHUHVWLQJFDVHLVWKDWRIWMHW¬UMHW¬U‘RWKHU’ WKHIRUPWMHW¬UUHVXOWVIURPFUDVLVZLWKWKHSUHFHGLQJSDUWLFOHW¬DQGRU IURP WKH DQDORJLFDO LQIOXHQFH RI WKH SOXUDO ,W FRQWLQXHV /3$ ©WHUD ZLWK WKH VWUHVV RQ WKH LQLWLDO V\OODEOH +RZHYHU LWV LUUHJXODU SOXUDO LV WMHU¬ 7KH RQO\ UHDVRQDEOH H[SODQDWLRQ RI WKLV IRUP LV WR VXSSRVH D 3URWR$OEDQLDQ VRXUFH UHFRQVWUXFWHG DV HW©UDL ZLWK WKH VWUHVV RQ WKH SHQXOWLPDWHV\OODEOH7KXVWKH/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQSDUDGLJPFRQVLVWHG RIWZRRSSRVHGIRUPV VJ
SO
©WHUD
HW©UDL
$QRWKHU LQWHUHVWLQJ H[DPSOH RI WKLV NLQG LV WKDW RI 7RVN Y¬VKW ~ *HJ YêVKW‘YLQH\DUG’$VLWLVFOHDUO\UHODWHGWRYHU¬~YHQ¬‘ZLQH’ ZDLQ HW\PRORJLFDOO\ ZH VKRXOG UHFRQVWUXFW 3URWR$OEDQLDQ Z¢LQHVWD DV LWV VRXUFH QRWHWKDWWKHSRVLWLRQRIWKHVWUHVVLVGHILQHGE\WKHQDVDOTXDOLW\ RI WKH *HJ YRZHO 2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG WKH SOXUDO IRUPV RI WKLV ZRUG 7RVN YUHVKWD ~ *HJ YQHVKWD FDQ EH RQO\ H[SODLQHG LI ZH DFFHSW D UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RI 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ZDLQ©VWDL $JDLQ IXUWKHU HYLGHQFH IRUDFFHQWXDORSSRVLWLRQLQD/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQSDUDGLJP VJ
SO
Z¢LQHVWD
ZDLQ©VWD
(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ6WUHVV :H DVVXPH WKDW WKH IHDWXUH RI SDUDGLJPDWLF PRELOLW\ ZDV LQKHULWHGIURP(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQDVWDJHIRUZKLFKRXUUHFRQVWUXF WLRQ FDQ EH PRUH GHWDLOHG $ PRUH RU OHVV IXOO UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ FDQ EH VXJJHVWHG IRU WKH QRPLQDO DFFHQW 7KH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH YHUE’V DFFHQWLVRIQRKLVWRULFDOYDOXHDVLWZDVSDUDGLJPDWLFDOO\IL[HGHYHQLQ (DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ /LWHUDWXUH 25(/ 6RY VODY /LQJY LVVOHG ,, =I%DON ;,; ;;,, ;;,,,
morphonology and word-formation
127
$VGHVFULEHGLQ$OEDQLDQQRXQVFDQEHGLYLGHGLQWR
WZRDFFHQWXDOSDUDGLJPVDFFRUGLQJWRWKHGHYHORSPHQWRIWKHLUDXVODXW YRZHOV LQ VLQJXODU DQG SOXUDO IRUPV 2Q WKH RQH KDQG WKHUH H[LVWHG EDU\WRQLFQRXQVWKDWKDGWKHVWUHVVOLQNHGWRWKHVWHPRIWKHZRUGERWK LQ WKH VLQJXODU DQG LQ SOXUDO DFFHQWXDO W\SH $ FI WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV VJ GZ¢LJ! G©JD!GHJ¬‘EUDQFK’ SO GZ¢LJL! G©JDL!GHJ¬‘EUDQFKHV’ VJ G¢XVD V ! GDXh!GDVK‘UDP’ SO G¢XVDL! G¢XhL!GHVK‘UDPV’
2QWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHUHH[LVWHGPRELOHR[\WRQLFQRXQVZKLFKKDGWKH VWUHVVRQWKHVWHPLQWKHVLQJXODUEXWRQWKHHQGLQJLQWKHSOXUDO DFFHQ WXDOW\SH% VJ VN¢O‘ILVKERQH’! VN¢OD!KDO¬‘ILVKERQH’ SO VNDOdV‘ILVKERQHV’! VNDO¢ V !KDOD‘ILVKERQHV’ VJ PdWDV! PD° W!PRW‘\HDU’ SO PW¢L! PD° W©!PRWH‘\HDUV’ ,Q QXPHURXV PDVFXOLQD WKH RULJLQDO HQGLQJ H ZDV UHSODFHG GXH WR DQDORJ\E\DZKLFKZDVRULJLQDOO\FKDUDFWHULVWLFRIVWHPVRQO\ VJ G¢UMDV! G©UMD!GHUU‘SLJ’ SO GDUM¢L! GHUM©!GHUUDLQVWHDGRI GHUUH‘SLJV’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
128
chapter two
ORDQZRUGV THQ ‘GRJ’ SO THQ DQG W\SH % ORDQZRUGV ODIVK¬ ‘FUHVW RI ELUG FRPE’SOODIVKDPDM‘KDPPHU’SOPDMD
'HULYDWLYHVLQWK XVXDOO\GLPLQXWLYHV SUHVHUYHWKHDFFHQWXDO W\SHRIWKHRULJLQDOQRXQV1RXQVRIWKHW\SH$SURGXFHGHULYDWLYHVRI WKHW\SH$ EUL‘KRUQ’SOEULEULU¬¾EULUWK‘IHHOHUWHQGULO’SOEULUWK¬ OH]‘ZDUW’SOOH]¬¾O\WKLGO\WK¬ V\‘H\H’SOV\¾V\WK‘ORRSEXG’SOV\WK¬ WUD‘EHDPSRVW’SOWUHU¬WUDU¬WUHQM¾WUDWK‘ODWKVODW’SOWUDWK¬ XUL‘PROH’SOXULQM¾XULWKLGSOXULWK¬ YH‘HJJ’SOYH¾YHWK‘PDJJRW’SOYHWK¬ YHVK‘HDU’SOYHVK¬¾Y¬WK‘HDUULQJ’SOY¬WK¬ 1RXQVRIWKHW\SH%SURGXFHGHULYDWLYHVRIWKHW\SH% ELU¬‘KROH’SOELUD¾ELUWK‘SLPSOH’SOELUWKD KDO¬‘ILVKERQH’SOKDOD¾KDOWK‘QHHGOH’SOKDOWKD NDS‘FRYHU’SONDSD¾NDSWK‘SDWK LQDVZDPS ’SONDSWKD NUDQG ‘EUXVKZRRG WZLJ’ SO NUDQGH ¾ NUDQWK ‘OLWWOH OHDI’ SO NUDQWKD ODN‘WUDSVOLQJ’SOOHTH¾ODNWKLGSOODNWKHODNWKD VKWHJ ‘SDWK ZD\’ SO VKWLJMH VKWHJMH ¾ VKWHNWK ‘VLQFLSXW’ SO VKWHNWKD WKLQG‘EHDN’SOWKLQGD¾WKLPWK‘WKRUQ’SOWKLPWKD 7KHUHDUHDIHZH[FHSWLRQVZLWKGHULYDWLYHVRIWKHW\SH$EHORQJLQJWR WKHJHQHUDOO\PRUHSURGXFWLYHW\SH% JXU‘VWRQH’SOJXU¬¾JXUWKLGSOJXUWKD ]RJ‘ELUG’SO]RJM¾]RNWK‘OLWWOHELUG’SO]RNWKD
$ VLPLODU GLVWULEXWLRQ LV IRXQG LQ VHFRQGDU\ SOXUDOV ROG FRO OHFWLYD LQ]1RXQVEHORQJLQJWRWKHDFFHQWXDOW\SH$GHYHORSDSOXUDO LQ¬] ELU‘VRQ’¾SOELMELM¬] GMDO¬‘ER\’¾SOGMHOGMHOPGMHOP¬] LM¬‘KLSVLGH’¾SOLM¬LM¬]
morphonology and word-formation
129
QMHU‘PDQ’¾SOQMHUQMHU¬] WKXD‘QDLO’¾SOWKRQMWKRQ¬] YH‘HJJ’¾SOYHYH]YH¬] YHVK‘HDU’¾SOYHVK¬YHVK¬] +RZHYHUGLDJQRVWLFDOO\WKHVHSOXUDOVDUHLUUHOHYDQWVLQFHQRXQVRIWKH DFFHQWXDOW\SH%IRUPSOXUDOVLQD]EXWXVXDOO\ZLWKDSDUDOOHOIRUPLQ ¬] JUHU¬‘ZDVS’¾SOJUHUDJUHUD]JUHU¬] YDVK¬‘JLUO’¾SOYDVKDYDVKD]YDVK¬] YDUU‘WRPE’¾SOYDUUHYDUUD] ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV RQO\ SOXUDOV LQ D] FDQ VHUYH DV DQ LQGLFDWRU RI WKH RULJLQDODFFHQWXDOVWDWXVRIDQRXQ
:LWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI D IHZ DGMHFWLYHV ZKLFK UHIOHFW DQ
RSSRVLWLRQRIDFFHQWXDOSDUDGLJPVVLPLODUWRWKDWRIWKHQRXQVPRVWRI DGMHFWLYHVKDYHGHYHORSHGQHZDFFHQWXDOIHDWXUHV 7KH ROG GLVWULEXWLRQ RI DFFHQWV LV VWLOO UHSUHVHQWHG E\ WKH PDVFXOLQH DGMHFWLYHV PDGK ‘ELJ’ DQG OLJ ‘EDG HYLO’ :KLOH OLJ KDV WKH SOXUDO OLJM DQGEHORQJVWRWKHDFFHQWXDOW\SH$PDGKZLWKLWVSOXUDOP¬GKHQMEDVHG RQHDUOLHU P¬GKHUHIOHFWVDFFHQWXDOW\SH% $ VJ SO
OLJ OJD OLJM OJDL
% PDGK P¢G]D
P¬GKH PDG]¢L
,Q RWKHU DGMHFWLYHV ZH REVHUYH FRPSOHWHO\ GLIIHUHQW DFFHQWXDO VWUXF WXUHV0DVFXOLQHDGMHFWLYHV RVWHPV KDYH¬LQWKHVLQJXODUJRLQJEDFN WRVWUHVVHG(3$ ¢ ,( RV,QWKHSOXUDOHUHIOHFWV(3$ ¢L ,(
RL ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV PDVFXOLQH DGMHFWLYHV EHORQJ WR DQ DFFHQWXDO SDUDGLJP ZKLFK LV XQDWWHVWHG LQ VXEVWDQWLYHV $OO IRUPV RI WKLV DFFHQWXDO W\SH & DUH R[\WRQLF $W WKH VDPH WLPH IHPLQLQH DGMHFWLYHV VWHPV KDYH¬IURPXQVWUHVVHG(3$ ,( LQWKHVLQJXODUDQG D LQ WKH SOXUDO IURP VWUHVVHG (3$ d V ,( V ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV IHPLQLQH DGMHFWLYHV EHORQJ WR WKH DFFHQWXDO W\SH % 0DVFXOLQH DQG IHPLQLQHIRUPVDUHDFFHQWXDOO\FRQWUDVWHG
130
chapter two
7KHVLWXDWLRQLVWRWDOO\GLIIHUHQWLQDGMHFWLYHVZLWKWKHVXIIL[HV PDQG
L VDP ! VK¬P 0DVFXOLQH DGMHFWLYHV EHORQJ HLWKHU WR DFFHQWXDO W\SH $ LH KDYH D ]HUR HQGLQJ RU ¬ LQ WKH VLQJXODU IURP XQVWUHVVHG (3$ D ,( RV RUWRW\SH% ZLWKVWUHVVHG(3$ ¢LQWKHVLQJXODU DQGD]HURHQGLQJLQWKHSOXUDOIURPXQVWUHVVHG(3$ DL ,( RL 7KH YDULDWLRQVRIVWUHVVLQWKHVLQJXODUZLWKLWVVHFRQGDU\¬ZKDWHYHUWKH H[SODQDWLRQPLJKWEHLVRIQRUHOHYDQFHWRWKHDFFHQWXDOW\SH)HPLQLQH DGMHFWLYHVLQ PDQG L VDPKDYHHLQWKHVLQJXODUDQGLQWKHSOXUDO (YHQWKRXJKWKHUHLVQRFHUWDLQW\DVWRWKHVRXUFHRIWKLVHQGLQJ LWPD\ EHFRQQHFWHGZLWKVWHPVLQ MRULQ L M LWLVLQGXELWDEO\R[\WRQLF LHIHPLQLQHDGMHFWLYHVEHORQJWRWKHDFFHQWXDOW\SH& &IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV PLU¬‘JRRG’DQGNROP¬‘SUHWW\ZLQVRPH’ PDVF
IHP
PDVF
IHP
VJ PLU¬ PLU¢ PLU¬ PU NROP ¬ NOPD NROPH NOLPLMd SO PLUH PLU¢L PLUD PLUdV NROP ¬ NOPDL NROPH NOLPLMdV
7KXVLQERWKW\SHVRIDGMHFWLYHVPDVFXOLQHDQGIHPLQLQHDUHDFFHQWXDOO\ FRQWUDVWHG , ,,
& $
% &
$V IDU DV WKH DFFHQWXDOO\ DUFKDLF DGMHFWLYH OLJ SUHVHUYHG DQ RSSRVLWLRQ RI DFFHQWXDO W\SHV $ DQG % EHWZHHQ LWV PDVFXOLQH DQG IHPLQLQH IRUPV DQG&DSSHDUVWREHFRPSOHPHQWDU\GLVWULEXWHGZLWK$DQG%LWFDQEH DVVXPHG WKDW & LV D VHFRQGDU\ DFFHQWXDO W\SH UHSODFLQJ $ LQ WKH ILUVW JURXSRIDGMHFWLYHVDQG %LQWKHVHFRQG , ,,
$ $
%
%
1RXQV EHORQJLQJ WR DFFHQWXDO W\SH $ FRUUHVSRQG WR ,QGR (XURSHDQ ZRUGV GHILQHG DV DFFHQWXDOO\ R[\WRQLFPRELOH QXPEHUV DQG OHWWHUV LQ SDUHQWKHVHV IROORZLQJ %DOWLF DQG 6ODYLF IRUPV UHIHU WR WKHLU
morphonology and word-formation
131
DFFHQWXDO SDUDGLJPV 7KLV FDQ EH FRUURERUDWHG E\ WKH IROORZLQJ UHOH YDQWPDWHULDO &RQVRQDQWDQGURRWVWHPV NUL ~ NUî SO NUL ~ NUî ‘ZRRGZRUP PRWK’ (3$ NULZL 6ODY
¨ÚUYÚ‘ZRUP’ F 2$OE QMHU SO QMHU ‘PDQ SHUVRQ KXPDQ EHLQJ’ (3$ QHUD Gk CPJT‘PDQ’JHQCPFTQX LQ6DQVNULWWKHVWUHVVRIQ¢UFDQEH H[SODLQHGE\WKHJHQHUDOL]DWLRQRIWKHQRPLQDWLYH VVWHPV KL~Kî‘DVK’SOKL~KîKLQ (3$ VNLQD VNLQHV /DWFLQLV‘GXVW DVK’ FHQHV ZLWK DQ XQVWUHVVHG VKRUWHQHG YRZHO IURP
V QHV XVWHPV JUXD~JUXHSOJUD‘ZRPDQZLIH’ (3$ JUZ GkITCW`X‘ROG ZRPDQ’ YDO¬SOYDO¬‘ZDYH’ (3$ ZDO 6ODY YDOÙLG F RVWHPV PDVFXOLQH EUL ~ EUî SO EUL EULQM EULU¬ ~ EULQ¬ ‘KRUQ’ (3$ EULQD *HUP
ÉUHQÌ¢ 6ZHGEULQG‘GHHU’1RUZEULQJHLG GMDO¬SOGMHPGMHOPGLDOGMHO‘ER\\RXWK’ (3$ GHOD /DWYG?OV ‘VRQ’6ZHGGLDOGHOG¥O‘QLSSOH’ *HUP ÌO¢] GXDM~GXHMSO‘VKHDI’ (3$ GAQMD 6NWGKQ\¢‘JUDLQ’ GK¬PE ~ GKDPE SO GK¬PE¬ ~ GKDPE¬ ‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPED 6ODY ]_EÙLG F LQRWKHUODQJXDJHVWKLVZRUGLVEDU\WRQLFFI 6NWM¢PEKDLG7KH6ODYLFDFFHQWLVKDUGO\LQQRYDWLYH GK¬QG¬U ~ GKDQG¬U SO GK¬QGXU¬ ~ GKDQGXU¬ ‘EULGHJURRP VRQLQ ODZ’ (3$ G]HQUD 6NW MU¢ ‘VXLWRU’ Gk ICODTQX ‘VRQLQ ODZ’ HVKSOHVK¬‘KHGJHKRJ’ (3$ HG]MD ZLWKSKRQHWLFGLIILFXOWLHV /LWKHÊmVLG 6ODY HÊÚLG F
$UUDQJHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHSDUDGLJPDWLFFODVVHVRI,QGR(XURSHDQSDUDOOHOVQRW3URWR $OEDQLDQVWHPV
132
chapter two
JML~JMîSOJML~JMî‘EUHDVWFKHVW’ (3$ VLQD /DWVLQXV‘FXUYH IROG’ZLWKWKHVKRUWHQLQJRIXQVWUHVVHG JM\VKSOJM\VK¬JM\VK¬U~JM\VK¬Q‘JUDQGIDWKHU’ (3$ V VD 6NW V ¿d‘SURJHQLWRU’ NRK¬ SO NRK¬ ‘WLPH’ (3$ N[ 6ODY ¨DVÙ LG WUDFHV RI D PRELOH SDUDGLJP LQ 2OG 5XVVLDQ )URP WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ SHUVSHFWLYHWKHZRUGFRXOGEHDQROGQHXWHU SODN SO SOHT ‘ROG PDQ’ (3$ S H ODND SHOiNRV /LWK S®ONDV ‘JUH\’ SâiNRV WHU SO WHU¬ WHUD ‘EXOO’ WDXUD /LWK WD-UDV LG 6ODY WXUÙ LG F GkVCW`TQXLGLVEDU\WRQLF XMN SO XMT XMT¬U ~ XMT¬Q ‘ZROI’ (3$ Z XOND /LWK YLËNDV LG 6ODY YÚONÙ LG F DV RSSRVHG WR EDU\WRQLF 6NW Y¤ND LG GkNWMQXLG YMHK¬UUSOYMHK¬UU‘IDWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZHVXUD VZHWVXU Gk G MWTQX LG /LWK hH∼hXUDV LG 6ODY VYHNÙUÙ LG F EXW FI EDU\WRQLF6NWyY¢yXUDLG2+*VZHKXULG *HUP VZ©[XUD] ]MDUP SO GLDO ]MHUP ]MHUP¬ LQQRYDWLYH ]MDUPH ‘ILUH’ (3$
GÊHUPD 6NW JKDUP¢ ‘VXQKHDW’ Gk SGTOQX ‘ZDUP’ $IJK IDUP¢‘QRRQKHDW’IUPi RVWHPV QHXWHU EDOO¬ SO EDOO¬ ‘IRUHKHDG’ (3$ EDO *N HCNQX ‘ZKLWH’ /LWK E¦ODV‘DQHPRQH’ FIWKHVDPHVHPDQWLFGHYHORSPHQWLQ6NW EKODLG23UXVEDOORLG GDVK SO GHVK ‘UDP’ (3$ GDXhD *PF ÌHX]¢Q ‘ZLOG DQLPDO’ *RWKGLXV21GØU 6ODY GX[Ù‘EUHDWKVSLULW’ F IMDO¬ SO IMDO¬ ‘ZRUG VSHHFK WDOH’ (3$ VSHO *RWK VSLOO ‘VWRU\ IDEOH’21VSMDOO‘VWRU\VSHHFK’2(VSHOOLG2+*VSHOVSHOO LG *PF VSHOO¢Q JUXU¬~JUXQ¬‘ZKHDW’ VLQJXODUL]HGSO (3$ JUXQ 6NWM Uo¢ MUo¢ ‘ROG GHFD\HG ZLWKHUHG’ $IJK ]i'D\ ‘VHHG’ EDVHG RQ
]iUQ¢P +RZHYHU/DWJUQXP2,UJU¢Q/LWKÊ®UQLV 6ODY
]ÚUQRDUHEDU\WRQLF JMXK¬SOJMXK¬‘WRQJXHODQJXDJH’ (3$ JXOV 21NDOO‘VKRXW’ *PF NDO]¢Q6ODY JROVÙ‘YRLFH’ F KLUU¬SOKLUU¬‘ZKH\’ (3$ NVLU 6NWN¿U¢‘PLON’
morphonology and word-formation
133
LVWHPV ERW¬ SO ERW¬ LQQRYDWLYH ERWD ‘HDUWK ZRUOG’ (3$ EZWL 6NW EK W ‘H[LVWHQFH’ /LWK E W®V LG ! ,U EXLWK LG ZLWK WKH VKRUWHQLQJRIWKHXQVWUHVVHGYRZHO GLW¬SOGLWGLW¬‘GD\’ (3$ GWL *PF WÌW]‘WLPH’ 2+*]W2( WG DQG6NWVXGW‘IDLUGD\’ JUDWKSOJUDWK¬‘WRRWKSURQJ RIDGHYLFH EULVWOH’GHPLQXWLYHRI (3$ JUDED 6ODY JUREÙ F JXUSOJXU¬‘VWRQHURFN’ (3$ JXUL 6NWJLU‘PRXQWDLQ’ JMROO¬SOJMROO¬‘FOHDULQJRUSDVWXUHZKHUHVDOWLVVWUHZQIRUVKHHS SDWFKRIJURXQGIRUVRZLQJ’ (3$ VOL 6ODY VROÚ‘VDOW’ F QDW¬SOQHWQHW¬‘QLJKW’ (3$ QDNWL 6ODY QRNWÚLG F RSSRVHG WREDU\WRQLF/LWKQDNW®VLGDQG6NWQ¢NW V\SOV\‘H\H’ (3$GXDO DWhZL /LWKDN®VLG GXDODN®6ODY
RNRLG F GXDO R¨L YHVK SO YHVK¬ ‘HDU’ (3$ ZDXVL /LWK DXV®V LG /DWY £XVV 6ODY X[RLG F GXDO XhL ]HW‘WZHQW\’SO G\ ]HW‘IRUW\’ (3$ Z L GÊDWL 6NWYLayDWLG $IJKZhWLGGkGKMQUKLG VWHPV EDUU¬SOEDUU¬‘ORDGEXUGHQ’ (3$ EDU GkHQTC‘ORDG’ EDWK¬ SO EDWK¬ ‘EURDG EHDQ’ (3$ EDWV Gk HCMJ` ‘GLVK RI OHQWLOV’HCMQX‘OHQWLO’ IDU¬ SO IDU¬ VHFRQGDU\ IDUD ‘VHHG VHPHQ NLQ’ (3$ SVDU Gk URQTC‘VHHG’ JU\N¬ SO JU\N¬ VHFRQGDU\ JU\ND ‘WKURDW’ (3$ JUZN GHULYDWLYH RI JUZ 6NW JUYd ‘QHFN’ $IJK JiUZ¢ ‘FODYLFOH’ /DWYJU&YD‘ULYHUPRXWK’DQG6ODY JULYD‘PDQH’DUHEDU\WRQLF JXDOO SO JXDM ‘VKHOO VNXOO’ (3$ JOZD /LWK JDOY£ 6ODY
JROYD F NDS¬ SO NDS¬ ‘DUPIXO RI FRUQ VKRFN SLOH’ (3$ NDS 6ODY
NRSD ‘PRZ VKRFN VWDFN’ F EXW *N MCRJ ‘PDQJHU FULE’ LV EDU\WRQLF O¬QG¬ ~ ODQG¬ SO O¬QG¬ ~ ODQG¬ ‘ZRRG WLPEHU PDWHULDO’ (3$
OHQW *PF OHQÌWA ‘OLQGHQ’ 2+* OLQWD 2( OLQG /LWK OHQW£ ‘ERDUG’ ORS¬SOORS¬‘FRZ’ (3$ OS /DWYOX¶SV‘FDWWOH’
134
chapter two
Q¬P¬ ~ QDP¬ SO Q¬P¬ ~ QDP¬ ‘FXUVH’ (3$ QDP *N PQOJ ‘PHDGRZ’ %RWK ZRUGV GHVSLWH WKH VHPDQWLF GLIIHUHQFHV DUH FRQQHFWHG ZLWK Gk PGOY ‘WR GLVWULEXWH’ *RWK QLPDQ ‘WR WDNH’ FILQSDUWLFXODU*NPGOGUKX‘ZUDWK’ SDO¬ SO SDO¬ ‘SDLU IROG JURXS FODVV SDUW\’ (3$ SDO 6ODY
SROD‘IODSWDLO’ F SRUGK¬SOSRUGK¬‘IDUW’ (3$ SUG *NRQTFJLG WKHN¬SOWKHN¬‘IULQJH’ (3$ WVDN /LWKhDN£‘EUDQFK’ 6ODY
VR[D‘EUDQFKSORXJK’ F 6NWydNK‘EUDQFK’LVEDU\WRQLF VKWD]¬VKW¬]¬~VKWDˆ]¬SOVKWD]¬VKW¬]¬~VKWâ]¬‘DQLPDO’ (3$
VWDGM ZLWK VHFRQGDU\ QDVDOL]DWLRQ *PF VWÌM¢ ‘VWHDG\ IDVW’ 2+*VWWL ]RUU¬SO]RUU¬‘JXW’ (3$ GÊUQ /LWKÊDUQ£LG 6HYHUDODUFKDLFIRUPVVKRZXVWKDWZRUGVEHORQJLQJWRDFFHQWXDOW\SH$ RULJLQDOO\ KDG D WHQGHQF\ RI VKLIWLQJ VWUHVV WR WKH SUHFHGLQJ FOLWLF LH WKHVWUHVVRIWKLVW\SHZDVRULJLQDOO\PRELOHDVLQRWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQ ODQJXDJHV VRQWH‘WKLVQLJKW’ (3$ WVM L QDNWLGDWORFVJ VRW‘WRGD\’ (3$ WVM L GWLGDWORFVJ G\]HW‘WZHQW\’ (3$ GXZAZLWVDWL
1RXQV EHORQJLQJ WR DFFHQWXDO W\SH % FRUUHVSRQG WR EDU\WRQLF ZRUGV LQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ 7KLV FDQ EH FRUURERUDWHG E\ WKH IROORZLQJ PDWHULDO &RQVRQDQWDOVWHPV JM¬~JMDˆSOJM¬UD~JMDQD‘WKLQJ’ (3$ VDQ V *PF V¢QÈ‘WUXH’ 21VDQQUVDÔU2(V²Ô NU\HSONUHU¬~NUHQ¬‘KHDG’ (3$ NU V Q *NMTCPC MGHCNJ $UHPDGHFRQVRQDQWDOVWHP PDGK‘ELJODUJH’SOP¬GKHQM EDVHGRQ P¬GKH (3$ PDG]D 6NWP¢KL‘JUHDWODUJH’GkOGICXLGQHXWOGIC WK¬UL~WK¬QLSOWK¬ULD~WK¬QLD WK¬UL~WK¬QLLVVHFRQGDU\ ‘ORXVH’ (3$ WVDQLG GkMQPKX‘QLW’
morphonology and word-formation
135
+HWHURFOLWLFVWHPV HOE SO HOE¬UD ~ HOE¬QD ‘EDUOH\’ (3$ DOEL Gk CNHK ‘NLQG RI JUDLQ’ HVKW¬SOHVKWD‘ILEUHPXVFOHILEUH’ (3$ DVWL 6NW¢VWKLLG QDQGUVWHPV GLP¬U ~ GLP¬Q SO GLPUD ~ GLPQD ‘ZLQWHU’ (3$ GHLPHQD 6NW K©PDQORF‘LQZLQWHU’GkZGK`OC‘ZLQWHU’ HP¬U~HP¬QSOHPUD~HPQD‘QDPH’ (3$ HQPHQ 6ODY MÚP? LG E" PRW¬U SO PRWUD ‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU $IJK PAU ‘PRWKHU’ /LWK P²W^LG /DWYP¦WHLG6ODY PDWLLG D +RZHYHUVHYHUDO ,QGR(XURSHDQ IRUPV DUH R[\WRQLF 6NW PW¢U Gk OJVJT OJVTQX UU\P¬ SO UU\PD ‘IORZ RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ VU P *N TGW`OC ‘VWUHDP’ VVWHPV DQJ‘IHDUQLJKWPDUH’ (3$ DQJD V 6NW¢PKDV‘IHDU’ HQG ‘SROOHQ’ (3$ DQGD V 6NW ¢QGKDV ‘KHUE’ Gk CPSQX ‘IORZHU’ HWKH SO ‘IHYHU’ (3$ DLGD V 6NW ©GKDV ‘ILUHZRRG IXHO’ Gk CK?SQX‘ILUH’ YLWYMHWSOYLWH‘\HDU’ (3$ ZHWD V GkGVQXLG ]MDUUSO]MDUUH‘ILUH’ (3$ GÊHUD V 6NWK¢UDV‘IODPHKHDW’Gk SGTQX‘VXPPHU’
XVWHPV PMHN¬USOPMHNUD‘FKLQEHDUG’ (3$ VPHNUX 6NWyP¢yUXLG RVWHPV PDVFXOLQH DUSODUD‘EHDU’ (3$ DUD 6NW¤N¿DLG$IJK\iÊLGGkCTMVQX LG GHUUSOGHUUD‘SLJ’ (3$ GDUMD GkZQK`TQXLG
136
chapter two
GUDQJSOGUDQJMH‘EDUJHSROHSXQWLQJSROH \RXQJFUHDWXUHFXE’ (3$ GUDQJD /LWKGUD±JDV‘SHUFKSROH’ 6ODY GU_JÙ E JDUGK SO JDUGKH JMHUGKH ‘IHQFH’ (3$ JDUGD /LWK JD¼GDV ‘IHQFH’ ! 6ODY JRUGÙ‘WRZQIHQFH’ F KHOO SO KHOOH KHMH VHFRQGDU\ KHM ‘VSHDU VSLW’ (3$ VNAOD Gk UMY`NQX‘SRLQWHGVWDNHWKRUQ’ N¬UU SO N¬UUD ‘GRQNH\ DVV IRDO JUD\’ (3$ NDUD 6NW NK¢UD ‘GRQNH\’ NUHSSONUHSD‘URFN’ (3$ NUHSD *PF [U©ID]‘ERG\’ 2(KULI 2+*KUHI SUREDEO\DUHPDGHURRWQRXQ ODS¬SOODSD‘KDUGSLHFHRIPHDWRUVNLQ SHULWRQHXP OHDI’ (3$
ODS /LWKO¦SDV‘OHDI’ GkNQRQX‘VKHOOKXVNEDUN’ PDUGK¬‘FKLOOIURVWLFH’ (3$ PDUG]D: 6ODY PRU]Ù‘IURVW’ D PLW¬SOPLWD‘VKRRW’ (3$ PHLWD /LWKPLWDV‘SRVWVWDNH’ THW¬SOTHWD‘ MDJJHG URFN’ (3$ NODLW /LWKhOD&WDV‘VORSH’ UULPHSOUULPH‘UDLQZRUP’ (3$ ZULPD *NTQOQX‘ZRUP’ VKWHJSOVKWLJMH‘SDWKURDG (3$ VWDLJD GkUVQK`ZQX‘URZOLQH’ VKWURK¬~ VKWURI¬SOVKWURKD~ VKWURID‘NHQQHO’ (3$ VWUM /DWY VWUDMD‘VWDOOFRYHUHGZLWKVWUDZ’6ODY VWURMÚ‘FRQVWUXFWLRQ’ WXOSOWXOHWXOD‘PHDWIOHVKSXOS’ (3$ WXOD GkVWNJ‘VZHOOLQJ’ 6ODY W\OÙ‘EDFNVLGH’ D WKHS SO WKHSD ‘SHDN SRLQW FRJ WRRWK’ (3$ WVDLSD 6NW y©SD ‘WDLOSHQLV’ YLGKSOYLGKD‘HOP’ (3$ Z Q G]D 6ODY Y?]ÙLG D ]¬ ~ ]â SO ]¬UD ~ ]DQD ‘YRLFH’ (3$ G]ZDQD 6ODY ]YRQÙ ‘ULQJLQJVRXQG’ D RVWHPV QHXWHU GDUN¬SOGDUND‘VXSSHU’ (3$ GDUN GkFQTRQPLG ¬QG¬UU~DQG¬UUSO¬QGUUD~DQGUUD‘GUHDPVOHHS’ (3$ DQUM GkQPGKTQPQPGKTQX JUDE¬ SO JUDED ‘HURVLRQ KROORZLQJ RXW’ (3$ JUDE 6ODY
JUREÙ‘SLWWRPE’ E JUHOO¬SOJUHOOD‘GHHSSODFH’ (3$ JULWO 6ODY JÙUGOR‘WKURDW’ D ÊHUGOR‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’ E JMHWKSOJMHWK‘IROLDJHJUHHQOHDYHV’ (3$ JDG]D 6ODY JYR]GÙ ‘ZRRGIRUHVW’ E KXGK¬USOKXGKUD‘JDUOLF’ (3$ VNXUG GkUMQTQFQPLG
morphonology and word-formation
137
VKWDJ¬ SO VKWDJD ‘SROH VWLFN’ (3$ VWDJ 6ODY VWRJÙ ‘PRZ VWDFN’ E LVWHPV EHV¬ SO EHVD ‘SOHGJH WUXFH WUXVW’ (3$ EDLWhL Gk RKUVKX ‘IDLWKIXOWUXVWZRUWK\’ KHUGKHSO‘WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ DUG]DL GkQTZKX NULPE~NU\PSONULPEDN¬UPLQM~NU\PD‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULPL 6NWN¤PL/LWKN®UPLVJHQNL¼PLHV ! PRWSOPRWH‘WLPHZHDWKHUVWRUPWKXQGHUEROW’ (3$ PWL 6NW PWL‘PHDVXUH’GkOJ`VKXLG Y¬QJ ~ YDQJ SO Y¬QJMH ~ YDQJMH ‘KRRS WLUH ULQJ ULP’ (3$
ZHQJ /LWKY®QJLV‘DUF’ ]RWSO]RW¬ULQM]RW¬U2$OE]RWD‘ORUGPDVWHUJRG’ (3$ Z L Wh SDWL 6NWYLyS¢WL‘ORUGRIWKHKRXVH’/LWKYLhSDWV‘ORUG’ DQGVWHPV EDUNSOEDUTH‘EHOO\ZRPEDEGRPHQ’ (3$ EDUXND DCT W!MC CKFQK`QPRCTC>6CTCPVKPQKX JULP¬ SO JULPD ‘FUXPE ELW’ (3$ JULP *N DTY`OJ ‘IRRG PHDO’ KXUE¬ SO KXUED ‘VZDOORZ PRXWKIXO’ (3$ VNXUE /DWY hNL¼ED ‘ILVVXUHVORW’6ODY h¨ÚUEDLG E NDUS¬ SO NDUSD ‘URFN’ (3$ NDUS /LWK N¢USD ‘ZDUW’ ND¼SDV ‘FXWKDFNQRWFK’ 0/*VFKDUI‘SRWVKHUG’ *PF VN¢UID] NHGK SO NHGK¬ NHGKD‘NLG’ (3$ NDG]D 6ODY NR]D ‘VKHJRDW’ E NULS¬ ~ NU\S¬ SO NULS¬UD ~ NU\SQD ‘VDOW’ (3$ NU S 6ODY
NUXSD‘JURDWV’ E NUXD~NUXHSONURMH VHFRQGDU\IRUPNURQM ‘VSULQJIRXQWDLQ’ (3$ NUQD *NMTJPJLG NXOS ‘LY\ FOHPDWLV’ SO NXOSD EDVHG RQ WKH SDUDGLJP RI WKH GLPLQXWLYH NXUWK SO NXUWKH (3$ NXOSD /LWK N®OSD ‘ORRS’ OHU¬SOOHUD‘KHDSRIVWRQHVSHEEOHEDQN’ (3$ ODXU *NNCWTC ‘DOOH\SDVVEHWZHHQURFNV’ OLQJ¬SOOLQJD‘VPDOOEHOO’ (3$ OLQJ /LWKO®QJ^‘IOH[LEOHSROH EHQG’ /DWYOL±JD‘ORRS’
138
chapter two
ORTHSOORTH‘SHQLV WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ OXND /LWKOLDXN£‘JODQG’ ! OO¬U¬~OODQ¬SOOO¬UD~OODQD OO¬U¬~OODQ¬LVVHFRQGDU\ ‘IRUHDUP HOO’ (3$ DOHQ GkYNGPJ‘HOERZ’ P¬OOHQM¬ SO P¬OOHQMD ‘EODFNELUG’ (3$ PHODQM Gk fem. OGNCKPC‘EODFN’/DWYP?ËQVLG%XW6NWPDOLQ¢LVR[\WRQLF PMDOF¬SOPMDOFD‘EHH’ (3$ PHOLWM *NOGNKUUC OGNKVMCLG PMHJXOO SO PMHJXOOD ‘FORXG’ (3$ PHJ X O Gk QOKZNJ ‘IRJ PLVW’/LWKPLJO£LG 6ODY PÚJOD‘GDUNQHVVPLVW’ E PRGKXOO SO PRGKXOOD ‘vHWFK FKLFNOLQJ FKLFNSHD’ (3$
PG]XOD /LWKPDʸOLV‘VPDOO’ SLGKSO SLGKH‘IHPDOH SXGHQGD’ (3$ S H L]GD 6ODY SL]GD LG E URV¬SOURVD‘GXFN’ (3$ DQWM *NPJ`UUC‘GXFN’ VRUU¬SOVRUUD‘FURZ’ (3$ WhUVQ $IJKNQ‘OHIW’IHPNQD 6ODY ¨ÚUQÙ‘EODFN’IHP ¨ÚUQDRSSRVHGWR6NWN¿o¢‘EODFN GDUN’ WUDSSOWUDSD‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSD 6ODY WURSD‘SDWK’ E YHU¬~YHQ¬‘ZLQH’ (3$ ZDLQ GkQKPJ‘YLQH’ YH SO YD YHMD ‘ZLGRZ’ (3$ ZLGHZ 6NW YLGK¢Y LG 6ODY
YÚGRYDLG E ]RQM¬‘ZLIH’SO]RQMD (3$ Z L WhSDWQM 6NWS¢WQLGVDS¢WQ ‘RQHRIWKHZLYHV’
&DVHV DW YDULDQFH ZLWK WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ RI $ DQG % DUH QRW QXPHURXV DU¬SODUD‘ILHOG’ (3$ DU /DWYDˆUDLG EHSOEH‘RDWK’ (3$ EDLG 6ODY EpGD‘GLVDVWHU’ E GHU¬SOG\HU‘GRRU’ (3$ GZAU 6NWGYdUGkSWTC JMDN SO JMDTH JMDNUD ~ JMDNQD ‘EORRG’ (3$ VDND Gk QRQX ‘MXLFH’/LWKVDND&‘UHVLQ’ 6ODY VRNÙ‘MXLFH’ F KDO¬ SO KDOD ‘ILVK ERQH VSOLQWHU SLQH’ (3$ VNDO /LWK VNDO£ ‘VWLFNRIILUHZRRG’ KX ~ Kû SO KXQM ‘SLFNHW VWDNH SROH SHQLV’ (3$ VNXMD 6ODY
[XMÚ‘SHQLV’ E THQJM¬ SO THQJMD ‘EHHKLYH’ (3$ NHQDJ *PF [XQDJ¢Q ‘KRQH\’ 21KXQDQJ2(KXQLJ2+*KRQDJ
morphonology and word-formation
139
UUHWKSOUUDWK¬‘KRRSULP RIZKHHO FLUFOH’GLPLQXWLYHRIW\SH$ 6NWU¢WKD‘ZDJRQ’
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¬‘VXSSHU’ (3$GDUNYVGD U VP¬ ‘ZHGGLQJ IHDVW’ (3$ GDUWhLP UHIOHFWLQJ DQ DOWHUQDWLRQ N V (3$
N Wh $VLPLODUDOWHUQDWLRQRIYRLFHGFRQVRQDQWVJ ] (3$ J GÊ LVIRXQGLQGMHJ‘WREXUQ’YVQGH]D‘WRVHWDOLJKWWRLJQLWH’ (3$ HQ GDGÊMD7KLVDOWHUQDWLRQKRZHYHUFDQEHFKDUDFWHUL]HGDV“WUDGLWLRQDO” DQG “QRQSDUDGLJPDWLF” LQVRIDU DV LW KDV QRW EHFRPH D VWUXFWXUDOO\ UHOHYDQWGHYLFHLQZRUGIRUPDWLRQRUPRUSKRORJ\ /LWHUDWXUH '20, 5(6 ;/9 WLPEUH DOWHUQDWLRQ '(61,&.$-$ ,), VXUYH\ RI DOWHUQDWLRQV /(.20&(9$ %DOFDQLFD W\SRORJLFDOSDUDOOHOVWRWKHWLPEUHDOWHUQDWLRQ
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
140
chapter two
(3$ WM,Q7RVNWKHVJSUHVHQWKDVEHHQDQDORJLFDOO\FKDQJHGXQGHU WKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHVJ&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV VJSUHV ‘WRSUD\’ ‘WRPHDVXUH’ ‘WRXUJH’ ‘WRSUDFWLVH’ ‘WRSXOOXS’ ‘WRIULJKWHQ’
OXW OXWHW PDW PDWHW QJXW HQJXWHW U\W U WHW UULW ZULWHW WXW WXWHW
VJDRU OXWD OXWD PDWD PDWD QJXWD HQJXWD U\WD U WD UULWD ZULWD WXWD WXWD
VJSUHV OXV OXWMD PDV PDWMD QJXV HQJXWMD U\V U WMD UULV ZULWMD WXV WXWMD
$VLPLODUDOWHUQDWLRQLVHVWDEOLVKHGEHWZHHQQDQGGLDOQMMOLWM7KH VHFRQG HOHPHQW RI WKH DOWHUQDWLRQ LV DWWHVWHG LQ VJ SUHVHQW ZKLOH WKH ILUVW HOHPHQW GRPLQDWHV WKH UHVW RI WKH SUHVHQW SDUDGLJP WKH DRULVWLF IRUP KRZHYHU EHORQJ WR RWKHU PRUSKRORJLFDO W\SHV VRPHWLPHV EXLOW RQWKHEDVLVRIWKHVJSUHV VJSUHV ‘WRPDWH’ ‘WRJQDZ’ ‘WRILQG’ ‘WRZDVK’ ‘WRIHHG’ ‘WRGLYLGH’
ERQ E J QHW EUHQ EUHQHW JMHQ JDGQHW ODQ ODXQHW PDQ PD]GQHW QGDQ HQGDQHW
VJDRU
VJSUHV
ERYD EUHMWD JMHWD ODYD PDMWD QGDMWDQGDYD
ERM E J QMD EUHM EUHQMD JMHM JDGQMD ODM ODXQMD PDM PD]GQMD QGDM HQGDQMD
$SURGXFWLYHDOWHUQDWLRQDWWHVWHGLQWKHQRPLQDOV\VWHPLVWKDW RIYHODUV SDODWDOL]HGYHODUVLHN TJ JM7KHVHFRQGHOHPHQWRIWKH DOWHUQDWLQJSDLUVDSSHDUVLQWKHSOXUDODVRSSRVHGWRWKHVLQJXODU
‘WZLOLJKW’ ‘EHOO\’ ‘EDUJHSROH’ ‘RDN’ ‘ROGPDQ’ ‘KHDS’
VJ
SO
DJ DXJD EDUN EDUND GUDQJ GUDQJD GXVKN GXVND SODN SODND WRJ WJD
DJMH DXJDL EDUTH EDUNDL GUDQJMH GUDQJDL GXVKTH GXVNDL SOHT SODNDL WRJMH WDJDL
morphonology and word-formation
141
7KHVDPHDOWHUQDWLRQRIYHODUVDQGSDODWDOL]HGYHODUVLVDOVRDWWHVWHGLQ WKH YHUEDO V\VWHP ZKHUH LW LV FKDUDFWHULVWLF RI WKH RSSRVLWLRQ EHWZHHQ SUHVHQWDQGDRULVWIRUPVRIFHUWDLQYHUEJURXSV
‘WREXUQ’ ‘WREDNH’ ‘WRIROORZ’
SUHVHQW
DRULVW
GMHJ SMHN QGMHN
GRJMD SRTD QGRTD
2QH PRUH SURGXFWLYH DOWHUQDWLRQ LV IRXQG LQ WKH QRPLQDO V\VWHP EHWZHHQOODQGM7KHVRXUFHRIWKLVSDODWDOL]DWLRQLVPHGLDO OEHIRUH L LQ/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQ
‘SHRSOH’ ‘PXOOHW’ ‘SLQH’ ‘VHDPHGJH’ ‘UDJFORWK’ ‘WLWOH’
VJ
SO
SRSXOO THIXOO UUREXOO VNXQGLOO VXNXOO WLWXOO
SRSXM THIXM UUREXM VNXQGLM VXNXM WLWXM
$QRWKHU VRXUFH RI SURGXFWLYH DOWHUQDWLRQV LQ $OEDQLDQ
FRQVRQDQWLVPLVWKHYRLFLQJRIXQYRLFHGRFFOXVLYHVDIWHUQDVDOV,WRIWHQ RFFXUVDWWKHMXQFWXUHEHWZHHQSUHIL[HVDQGQRPLQDOVWHPV ND‘RXW’ NRUGK‘WRGLH RIDQLPDOV ’ NXQMRM‘WRFORVHZLWKDSHJ’ SDV‘DIWHUEHKLQG’ SMHOO‘WREHJHW’ SURGK‘WRSURGXFH’
QJDid. QJRUGK‘WRGLH’ QJXMRM‘WRHQFORVH’ PEDVLG PEMHOO‘WRVRZ’ PEURGK‘WRKHOS’
8QYRLFLQJLVIRXQGLQWKHSRVLWLRQDIWHUWKHSUHIL[VK ELH‘WREULQJWRFDUU\’ JDUGK¬‘IHQFH’ J¬UU\HM‘WRVFUDSH’ JOHS¬‘PDWWHUIURPWKHH\HV’
VKSLH‘WRFDUU\DZD\’ VKNDUGK¬‘GRJFKDLQ’ VKNU\HM‘WRPDNHGLUW\’ VKNOHS¬LG
142
chapter two
9RFDOLFDOWHUQDWLRQV 1XPHURXVYRFDOLFDOWHUQDWLRQVZHUHFDXVHGE\UHODWLYHO\UHFHQW IDFWRUVVXFKDVWKHUHGXFWLRQRIYRZHOVDQGGLSKWKRQJL]DWLRQRI3URWR $OEDQLDQORQJPRQRSKWKRQJV ,QWKHQRPLQDOV\VWHPRQHVXFKDOWHUQDWLRQLVWKDWEHWZHHQXD ~ XHDQGR
‘IDOFRQ’ ‘KRQH\FRPE’ ‘URHEXFN’ ‘URRVWHU’ ‘VWDEOH’ ‘VSULQJ’
VJ
SO
IDMNXD~ IDMNXH KXDOO~ KXHOO NDSUXDOO~ NDSUXHOO NDSXD~ NDSXH NDWXD~ NDWXH NUXD~ NUXH
IDMNRQM KRMH NDSURM NDSRQM NDWRQM NURQM
7KHVDPHDOWHUQDWLRQLVSURGXFWLYHLQWKHYHUEDOPRUSKRORJ\,WFKDUDF WHUL]HVWKHSUHVHQW/DRULVWRSSRVLWLRQ
‘WREHDIUDLG’ ‘WRJULQG’ ‘WRSUHSDUH’ ‘WRKXQW’ ‘WRVFUDWFK’ ‘WRZULWH’
SUHVHQW
DRULVW
GUXDM~ GUXHM EOXDM~ EOXHM JDWXDM~ JDWXHM JMXDM~ JMXHM NUXDM~ NUXHM VKNUXDM~ VKNUXHM
GURYD EORYD JDWRYD JMRYD NURYD VKNURYD
,Q ZRUGIRUPDWLRQ DQRWKHU UHODWLYHO\ UHFHQW DOWHUQDWLRQ LV
EDVHG RQ WKH UHGXFWLRQ RI XQVWUHVVHG YRZHOV 7KH PRVW IUHTXHQW DOWHUQDWLRQW\SHLVD ¬DVLQWKHIROORZLQJSDLUV IDM‘JXLOWVLQ’ NDOE‘WROHWURW’ NDOO‘WRLQVHUW’ ODNXU‘QDNHG’ ODS‘WRVOXUS’ ODS¬‘OHDI’
I¬MHM‘WRPDNHDPLVWDNH’ N¬OERTH‘VSXWXP’ N¬OODV‘WRSXWLQWR’ O¬NXU¬‘VNLQEDUN’ O¬SLM‘WROLFN’ O¬SLWN¬‘VOLSSHU’
morphonology and word-formation
PDUGK¬‘FROGIURVW’
143
P¬UGKLM‘WRFKLOO’
$WWKHVDPHWLPHRWKHUSDLUVVXFKDVH ¬L ¬R ¬DQGX ¬DUHDOVR DWWHVWHG GHOO‘WHQGRQ’ IXQG‘ERWWRPHQG’ ORS¬‘FRZ’ OXIW¬‘ILJKW’ UUHP‘IDOVH’ UULS¬‘SUHFLSLFH’ UUXIH‘lightning’
G¬OOLQM¬‘MXQLSHU’ I¬QG\HOO‘DZO’ O¬SHF‘ROGR[RUFRZ’ O¬IWRM‘WRILJKW’ UU¬PDç‘OHIWKDQGHG’ UU¬SLU¬LG UU¬IHVKN‘NLQGRIWKLVWOH’
9RFDOLFDOWHUQDWLRQV 8PODXW $OEDQLDQXPODXWGHYHORSHGLQWKH/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQSHULRG ZKHQXQVWUHVVHGDXVODXWYRZHOVORVWRQHPRUDDQG$OEDQLDQGLSKWKRQJV ZHUH PRQRSKWKRQJL]HG %RWK IDFWRUV OHG WR WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI IURQW YRZHOVLQWKHQRPLQDOHQGLQJV/DWHUXQGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRIVWUXFWXUDO SDUDOOHOLVPVXPODXWZDVDOVRLQWURGXFHGLQWRVHYHUDO6ODYLFORDQZRUGV ,Q$OEDQLDQWZRW\SHVRIXPODXWDUHDWWHVWHG WKHUDLVLQJRI(3$ D!H DQGRI(3$ H!L /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 $OE *U H ! L EHIRUH FOXVWHUV 3(.0(=, Ç$%(- 56KN/39,,9,,, JHQHUDOL]DWLRQRI H D DQG L H LQ QRPLQDO SDUDGLJPV Û,52.29 (Ê ™*8 '20, 5(6 ;/9 IROORZV 0(<(5 '2', &,(% '(61,&.$-$ 9-D *HUPDQLF SDUDOOHOV WR WKH $OEDQLDQ XPODXW ,), ÇABEJ St. III 114-115, 309-402
7KHXPODXWD HLVIRXQGLQQRXQVDQGLQYHUEV1RPLQDOO\LWLV FKDUDFWHULVWLF RI WKH SOXUDOV RI R DQG LVWHPV EXW RFFDVLRQDOO\ DOVR DSSHDUVLQRWKHUW\SHVRIVWHPV
‘ERQH’ ‘IDWKHU’ ‘UDP’ ‘WUDSVQDUH’ ‘QLJKW’
VJ
SO
DVKW¬ DW GDVK ODN QDW¬
HVKWUD~ HVKWQD HW¬U~ HW¬Q GHVK OHTOHTH QHW
144
chapter two
VTDS
‘JRDW’
VTHSVTHSH
,QQXPHURXVQRXQVDZDVUHVWRUHGLQWKHSOXUDOE\DQDORJ\
‘WZLOLJKW’ ‘EHOO\’ ‘FDW’ ‘JXLOW’ ‘IDWKRP’ ‘HQFORVXUH’
VJ
SO
DJ EDUN GDF IDM SDVK WKDUN
DJMH EDUTH GDFD IDMH SDVK WKDUTWKDUTH
,Q PDQ\ RWKHU QRXQV WKH UDLVHG H D RI WKH SOXUDO ZDV JHQHUDOL]HG DQGDQLQQRYDWLYHSOXUDOLQDZDVRIWHQLQWURGXFHG
‘VKHHSJRDW’ ‘\RXQJEXOO’ ‘VTXLUUHO’ ‘IROLDJH’ ‘URFN’ ‘EXOO’
VJ
SO
EHUU EDUZD GHP GDPD JHU JDXUD JMHWK JD]GD NUHS NUDSD WHU WDXUD
EHUUD GHPD JHUD JMHWK NUHSD WHU¬
,QYHUEVWKHVDPHDOWHUQDWLRQD HLVZLGHO\DWWHVWHGLQSUHVHQW YHUEDOIRUPVLQ DWM DVZHOODVVRPHRWKHUOHVVIUHTXHQWW\SHV 7KH IRUPLQDFKDUDFWHUL]HVWKHVJLQ DWMDZKLOHWKHIRUPLQHDSSHDUV LQWKHVJLQ DWV DWW VJ ‘WRVKRXW’ ‘WRJRRXW’ ‘WRWDON’ ‘WRVZHOO’ ‘WRXUJH’ ‘WRNQRFN’
E¬UWDV GDO IODV PEXIDV QJDV WURNDV
VJ E¬UWHW GHO IOHW PEXIHW QJHW WURNHW
145
morphonology and word-formation
7KHXPODXW M H LLVHYHQOHVVUHJXODUWKDQD H &KURQRORJ
LFDOO\ LW EHORQJV WR D ODWHU SHULRG LQ WKH KLVWRU\ RI $OEDQLDQ ,W DIIHFWV $OE H RI YDULRXV RULJLQV LQ SDUWLFXODU H UDLVHG IURP D :H GR QRW NQRZ H[DFWO\ ZKDW SKRQHWLF PHFKDQLVP OHG WR WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI WKLV XPODXW4XLWHSUREDEO\LGHULYHGIURPWKHGLSKWKRQJL]HGURRWYRZHOMH ZKLFKKDGEHHQLQIOXHQFHGE\DQHZLRUMLQWKHIROORZLQJV\OODEOH
,Q YHUEDO PRUSKRORJ\ ZKHUH WKLV W\SH RI WKH XPODXW ZDV RULJLQDOO\ GHYHORSHG M H LDSSHDUVLQFHUWDLQYHUEIRUPVFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\LRUM LQWKHVXIIL[VXFKDVLQWKHSOSUHVHQWDQGVJLPSHUIHFW
‘WRJRRXW’ ‘WREXUQ’ ‘WREDNH’ ‘WRJLYHELUWK’ ‘WRWXUQ’ ‘WRGLH’
VJSUHV
SOSUHV
GHO GMHJ SMHN SMHOO VMHOO YGHV
GLOQL GLJMQL SLTQL SLOOQL VLOOQL YGLVQL
VJLPSI GLOMD GLJMD SLTMD SLOOMD VLOOMD YGLVMD
7KHVDPHXPODXWDSSHDUVLQVRPHDRULVWVWHPV TXLWHRIWHQIROORZHGE\L RIWKHQH[WV\OODEOH
‘WRURFN’ ‘WRVZHOO’ ‘WRUDLVH’ ‘WRVSULQNOH’ ‘WRNQRFN’ ‘WRGLH’
VJSUHV
VJDRU
OXKHW PEXIHW QJUH VS¬UNHW WURNHW YGHV
OXKLWL PEXILWL QJULWL VS¬UNLWL WURNLWL YGLT
'XH WR DQDORJ\ WKH XPODXW M H L ZDV WUDQVIHUUHG WR WKH
QRPLQDO V\VWHP ZKHUH LW DIIHFWHG D UHODWLYHO\ VPDOO QXPEHU RI VXEVWDQWLYHV$OORUQHDUO\DOORIWKHPHQGLQDYHODU+HQFHWKHXPODXW LVSDUDOOHOHGE\WKHDOWHUQDWLRQRIYHODU SDODWDOL]HGYHODU6WUXFWXUDOO\ WKH XPODXW M H L LV LGHQWLFDO ZLWK WKH XPODXW D H DV LW VXSSRUWV WKH RSSRVLWLRQVLQJXODUYVSOXUDO&IWKHIROORZLQJFDVHV
146
chapter two
‘EDQNKLOO’ ‘SLJOHW’ ‘DYDODQFKH’ ‘ILVK’ ‘SDWK’
VJ
SO
EUHJ GHUN RUWHN SHVKN VKWHJ
EULJMHEUHJMH GLUT RUWLTH SLVKTSHVKT VKWLJMHVKWHJMH
,Q D IHZ ZRUGV L ZDV JHQHUDOL]HG DQG LV QRZ IRXQG LQ WKH IRUPV RI VLQJXODU7KLVVHHPVWREHWKHFDVHRILU¬‘GXQ’,ILWLVWREHFRQQHFWHG ZLWK HUU ‘GDUNQHVV’ WKHQ WKH VRXUFH PXVW KDYH EHHQ (3$ DXVUD 7KH ILUVWXPODXWFUHDWHGDSDUDGLJPRIVJ DU¬~ SO HU¬7KHHRIWKHSOXUDO ZDVJHQHUDOL]HG VJ HU¬~ SO HU¬)LQDOO\WKHUHZDVDVHFRQGXPODXW VJ HU¬~ SO LU¬)URPWKLVVWDJHWKHQHZVLQJXODULU¬ZDVH[WUDFWHG
9RFDOLFDOWHUQDWLRQV $EODXW $OEDQLDQ KDV WR D FRQVLGHUDEOH H[WHQW LQKHULWHG WKH ,QGR (XURSHDQV\VWHPRIDEODXW+RZHYHULWKDVEHHQVLJQLILFDQWO\PRGLILHG E\ SKRQHWLF IRUFHV 6RPH W\SHV RI DEODXW QRW VR LPSRUWDQW LQ ,QGR (XURSHDQKDYHIORXULVKHG2WKHUW\SHVRQFHSURGXFWLYHKDYHEHHQORVW DOWRJHWKHURUDUHVHYHUHO\IUDJPHQWHG /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5,)9 ORQJJUDGHLQDRULVWV & $0$-$OE :RUWE ÇABEJ St. III 124 25(/=I%DON;;;,,, ORQJ JUDGHUHSODFLQJ]HURJUDGHLQQRXQV
,QGR(XURSHDQHJUDGHLVUHIOHFWHGLQQXPHURXVSUHVHQWVWHP IRUPV ELH ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ EHUMD ,( EKHU ‘WR EULQJ WR FDUU\’ 6NW EK¢UDWL*NHGTY/DWIHUA EUHGK‘WRMXPS WR VSULQJ’ (3$ EUHGD 6ODY EUHG_ EUHVWL‘WR ZDGHWRIRUG’/LWKEUHQG¸EU®VWLLG GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ (3$ GHJD ,( GKHÞK ‘WR EXUQ’ 6NW G¢KDWL 7RFK$%WVDNWV¥N/LWGHJ¸GªJWL PEOHGK ‘WR JDWKHU WR FROOHFW’ (3$ DPELOHG]D ,( OH½ *N NGIYLG/DWOHJA‘WRUHDG WRJDWKHU’ PMHO‘WRPLON’ (3$ PHOJD *NCOGNIYLG/DWPXOJHALG/LWK P©OÊLXP©OÊWLLG
morphonology and word-formation
147
VMHOO ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ WhHOD ,( áHO 6NW F¢UDWL ‘WR PRYH WR ZDON’*NRGNY‘WRFRPHLQWRH[LVWHQFHWREHFRPH’/DWFROA ‘WRFXOWLYDWHWRWLOO’ ,QGR(XURSHDQHJUDGHLVDOVRDWWHVWHGLQDIHZQRXQV PLHOO‘IORXU’ (3$ PHOZD ,( PHOÆR 2+*P¬ORLG21PM_O LG6ODY PHOYR‘JUDLQIRUJULQGLQJ’ PMHGK¬U ‘PXOEHUU\ WDUHV’ D VXIIL[HG GHULYDWLYH RI PMHGK /LWK PGLV‘WUHH’/DWYPHÊV‘ZRRG’
2FFDVLRQDOO\H[SHFWHGHJUDGHLVUHSODFHGE\D]HURJUDGH GMDO¬‘ER\\RXWK’ (3$ GHOD /DWYG?OV‘VRQ’/DWIOLXVLG OHK~OHI‘WREDUN’ (3$ ODMD 6NWUd\DWLLG/LWKO²MXO²WLLG6ODY
ODMDWL QGXN ‘WR SOXFN RXW WR SXOO RXW WR WHDU’ (3$ HQGXND *RWK WLXKDQ‘WRSXOO’/DWG FALG +RZHYHU SUHVHQW VWHPV PRUH IUHTXHQWO\ VKRZ OHQJWKHQHG JUDGH 8VXDOO\ORQJJUDGHSUHVHQWVDUHGHULYDWLYHV RIWHQGHULYDWLYHVLQ QMD RULQ MD IURPRULJLQDOIXOOJUDGHSUHVHQWV ERMERKHW‘WRPDWH’ (3$ EJQMD /LWKE{JWL‘WRUXQ’ /DWY EêJW LG23UXVEHJH\WHLG6ODY EpJWLLG*NHGDQOCKLG MRVK‘WRFXUOWRIRQGOHWRFDUHVV’ (3$ MXGVMD ,( HXGK 6NW \·GK\DWH‘WRILJKWWRVWUXJJOH’7RFK$\XWN‘WRWDNHFDUHRIWR WURXEOHDERXW’/LWKM¢XGLQWL‘WRH[FLWHWRDURXVH’ NUXDM~NUXHM‘WRVFUDWFK’ (3$ NUEQMDIXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK,(
JKUHEK TXDM ~ TXHM ‘WR FDOO WR JLYH D QDPH’ (3$ NOXVQMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH EDVHG RQ ,( OHÆRV ‘JORU\ ZRUG’ 6NW yU¢YDV *NMNGQX6ODY VORYR ,Q RWKHU W\SHV RI SUHVHQWV OHQJWKHQLQJ LV OHVV IUHTXHQW &I VRPH H[DPSOHV GXD~GXH‘WRORYH’ (3$ GXVQMD GXVQMD ,( ½HXV‘WRWDVWH’ 6NWM²¿DWL‘WREHIRQGRI’*NIGWQOCK
148
chapter two
VKRK ~ VKRI ‘WR VHH’ (3$ VNVND 6NW V¢FDWH ‘WR DFFRPSDQ\ WR IROORZ’*NGRQOCK/DWVHTXRU*RWKVDLxDQ‘WRVHH’ VKSRUU‘WRPRYHDZD\WRGULYHDZD\’ (3$ SUD 6NWSSDUWL‘WR EULQJRYHUWRVDYH’*NRGTCYRGKTY‘WRSHQHWUDWH’ /HQJWKHQLQJRIWKHIXOOJUDGHLVDOVRDWWHVWHGLQVHYHUDOQRXQV KXDM ~ KXHM ‘IRUHLJQ VWUDQJH’ (3$ NVQMD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK LVRODWHG*NEGPQX'RUEGP®QX‘VWUDQJHUJXHVW’ WRJ‘KHDSSLOH’ (3$ WJD *NVGIJ‘URRI’2,UWHFK‘KRXVH’ ,(
WHJRV
/HQJWKHQHG JUDGH LV W\SLFDO RI DRULVWV FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR WKHPDWLF SUHVHQWV ZLWK D SODLQ IXOO JUDGH ,W LV JHQHUDOO\ EHOLHYHG WKDW WKLV ORQJ JUDGH LV RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ RULJLQ UHODWHG WR WKH OHQJWKHQHG JUDGHVIRXQGDPRQJ*HUPDQLFVWURQJFODVV,9DQG9SUHWHULWHVDQGWR VRPHRIWKH/DWLQORQJYRZHOSHUIHFWV VJSUHV ‘WRMXPS’ ‘WREXUQ’ ‘WRGUDZ’ ‘WRVWULSRII’ ‘WRWKURZ’ ‘WRZHDQ’
EUHGK GMHJ KHT UMHS VKWMHOO ]YMHUGK
VJDRU EURGKD GRJMD KRTD URSD VKWROOD ]YRUGKD
,Q 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKH DRULVWLF OHQJWKHQLQJ EHFDPH SURGXFWLYH DQG VSUHDGEH\RQGWKHDRULVWVZLWKDFFRPSDQ\LQJWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWV VJSUHV ‘WRJRRXW’ ‘WRWDNH’
GDO PDUU
VJDRU GROD PRUUD
6RPH OHQJWKHQHG JUDGHV KDYLQJ H[WHUQDO FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV WR RWKHU ,QGR(XURSHDQGLDOHFWV ORTH‘SHQLVWHVWLV’ VLQJXODUL]HGSO(3$OXNDLFORVHWR/LWKOLDXN£ ‘JODQG’ OXNORQJJUDGHRI OHXN‘ZKLWH’
morphonology and word-formation
149
,Q $OEDQLDQ RJUDGH LV W\SLFDO RI GHYHUEDWLYH QRXQV HVSH
FLDOO\QRPLQDDFWLRQLV
GDN ‘ELJ UDP’ (3$ GZDND /LWK GY|NWL ‘WR EUHDWKH’ GY¦NDV ‘EUHDWK’ GDUN¬‘VXSSHU’ (3$ GDUN ,( GRUáRPUHIOHFWHGLQ*NFQTRQP LG PDUGK¬‘FKLOOIURVWLFH’ (3$ PDUG] 6ODY PRU]Ù‘IURVW’ Q¬P¬~QDP¬‘FXUVH’ (3$ QDP *NPGOY‘WRGLVWULEXWH’*RWK QLPDQ‘WRWDNH’ SDK‘VFDEGXVW’ (3$ SDXMD ,( SRXR $UPKRJL‘EUHDWK’ WUDS‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSD 6ODY WURSD‘SDWK’DQGIXUWKHUUHODWHGWR ,( WUHS‘WRWUHDG’ ,QPDQ\FDVHVRJUDGHLVFKDUDFWHULVWLFRISUHVHQWVWHPVVRPHRIWKHP EXWQRWDOO UHSUHVHQWLQJRULJLQDOFDXVDWLYHVDQGGHQRPLQDWLYHVLQ QMD ~ MD EUHM ~ EUêM ‘WR JQDZ’ (3$ EUDLQMD ,( EKUHL ‘WR FXW’ 6NW EKUodWL‘ KH LQMXUHV’/DWIULA‘WRUXE’6ODY EULWL‘WRVKDYH’ OHM‘WR JLYH ELUWK WR EH ERUQ WR ULVH RI WKH VXQ ’ (3$ ODLGQMD /LWKO©LVWL‘WROHW’/DWYODîVWLG PEDM‘WRKROGWRFDUU\’ (3$FDXVDWLYH HQEDUQMD ,( EKHU‘WR EHDU’ QGH] ‘WR VHW DOLJKW WR LJQLWH’ (3$ HQGDGÊMD FDXVDWLYH ,( GKRÞKHA ,( GKHÞK‘WREXUQ’ UHJM‘WRWDQ’ (3$ UDXJMD 21UH\NU‘VPRNH’2+*URXKLG WHU‘WRPDNHGU\’ (3$ WDUVMD 6NWWDU¿¢\DWLLG/DWWRUUHALG21 ÈHUUDLG 6RPHRJUDGHQRXQVZHUHWUDQVIRUPHGLQWR]HURJUDGHVLQ$OEDQLDQ EUX] ‘EOXH LQGLJR’ (3$ EUXGMD ,( EKURXGK 6ODY EUXGÙ ‘GLUW’ EUXGÚQÙ‘GLUW\’ JMXK¬ ‘WRQJXH ODQJXDJH’ (3$ JXO[ FRQQHFWHG ZLWK WKH ,QGR (XURSHDQ GLDOHFWDO ZRUG IRU‘VRXQG’ JROVR 21 NDOO‘VKRXW’ /LWKJDËVDV‘HFKR’6ODY JROVÙ‘YRLFH’ JMXUP¬‘WUDFH’ (3$ VXUPD 6NWV¢UPD‘IORZ’*NQTOJ‘DVVDXOW DWWDFN’IXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK,( VHU‘WRIORZ’
150
chapter two
2QHQRXQDWWHVWVOHQJWKHQHGJUDGHLQSODFHRIDQRULJLQDORJUDGH ]RUU¬ ‘JXW’ (3$ GÊUQ ,( ÞHUi ‘WR VZDOORZ’ /LWK ÊDUQ£ ‘JXW’
0DQ\$OEDQLDQWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWVDUHGHULYHGIURP]HURJUDGH
VWHPV
IODN ‘WR WKURZ WR IOLQJ’ (3$ DZDODND GHULYHG IURP ,( ON
OiNWREHQGWRMXPS’ 0+*OHFNHQ‘WRWKURZEDFNWRVSULQJ’ /LWKOHNL¸O|NWL‘WRIO\’/DWYOªNW‘WRVSULQJWRMXPS’ QGXONHP‘WRULSHQ’ (3$ HQWXOND /LWKWHONL¸WHËNWL‘WRJDWKHUWR EULQJWRJHWKHU’6ODY WHONWL‘WREHDWWRSRXQG’ QJXO‘WRWKUXVWLQWRVWLFNLQ’ (3$ HQNXOD /LWKN¸OWL‘WRWKUHVK’ /DWYNXËW‘WRVWULNH’ VKWULM‘WRVSUHDGWRVWUHWFK’ (3$ VWULQMD 6NWVWQdWL‘WRVSUHDGWR VFDWWHU’*NUVQTPWOK‘WRVSUHDGWRVWUHWFK’/DWVWHUQALG WKHN ‘WR URDVW WR WRDVW EUHDG ’ (3$ WVDND ,( N FI *N MGIMGK RGKPC`^ MCIMQOGPJX EJTC`X VY`^ HQDY^ +HV RQNWMCIMJX‘EXUQLQJVWURQJO\’ +RP 7KH QXPEHU RI ]HUR JUDGH QRXQV LQKHULWHG IURP ,QGR(XURSHDQ LV LQVLJQLILFDQWFIIRUH[DPSOHWKHIROORZLQJIRUP EXUGK¬‘NLQGRIVDFN’ (3$ EXUG ,( EKGK 21ERUÔ‘ERDUG HGJH’2(ERUGLG 2QWKHRWKHUKDQGVHYHUDOROG]HURJUDGHQRXQVZHUHWUDQVIRUPHGLQWR OHQJWKHQHGJUDGHVRURJUDGHV EROOH ‘WHVWLFOHV’ (3$ EOQDL *N HCNNQX ‘SKDOOXV’ /DW IROOLV ‘EHOORZV’2,UEDOO‘OLPEPHPEHU’ GHOO‘WHQGRQ’ (3$ GDLVOD /LWKJØVOD‘EORRGYHVVHOWHQGRQ’6ODY
ÊLOD‘WHQGRQ’ JUHU¬~JUHQ]¬‘ZDVSKRUQHW’ (3$ JUDLVQ /DWFUEUA‘KRUQHW’ 2+*KRUQDfLG/LWKhLUhX¶LG6ODY VÚUhHQÚLG N¬UP¬‘FDUFDVVFDULRQFDGDYHU’ (3$ NDUSQ 6NWN¤S‘VKDSH EHDXWLIXO DSSHDUDQFH’ /DW FRUSXV ‘ERG\’ 2+* KU¬I ‘EHOO\ ERG\’
morphonology and word-formation
151
VRUU¬ ‘FURZ’ (3$ WhUVQ 6NW N¿o¢ ‘EODFN GDUN’ 23UXV NLUVQDQ‘EODFN’6ODY ¨ÚUQÙLG 2FFDVLRQDOO\WKLVOHQJWKHQLQJLVFDXVHGE\DIROORZLQJVFKZD&IEROOH (3$ EOQD EKROiQRV
$IIL[DWLRQ 7KH PDLQ LQVWUXPHQW RI ZRUGIRUPDWLRQ LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LV
DIIL[DWLRQ 1XPHURXV SUHIL[HV DQG VXIIL[HV ZHUH LQKHULWHG E\ 3URWR $OEDQLDQ IURP ,QGR(XURSHDQ 7KH SURFHVV RI DIIL[DWLRQ KDV VLQFH EHFRPHH[WUHPHO\SURGXFWLYH
,QVRPHDIIL[HVDQ$OEDQLDQ PRUSKHPHDQGDERUURZHG HOHPHQW KDYH PHUJHG VR FRPSOHWHO\ WKDW ZH DUH XQDEOH WR GLIIHUHQWLDWH WKHP 7KXV $OE S¬U FRQWLQXHV ERWK (3$ SHU ~ SUD DQG /DW SHU ~ SUA $OE VK JRHV EDFN WR ERWK (3$ LV DQG /DW H[ %RUURZHG DIIL[HV LQWURGXFHG YLD ORDQZRUGV KDYH DOVR EHFRPH SURGXFWLYH &I VXFK IRUPV DV SDOF¬ ‘PDUURZ’ GHULYHG IURP SDO¬ ‘SDLU IROG’ E\ PHDQV RI D 6ODYLF VXIIL[
ÚFDÖ$OEF¬ODMWKL‘KD]HOWUHHKD]HOQXW’EXLOWIURPODNWK~ ODTWK ‘ORRSQRRVH’ZLWKWKHKHOSRIWKH/DWLQVXIIL[LDÖ$OELDQGQG¬U]HM ‘WRPDWH’DGHULYDWLYHRIWKHOH[HPH]¬~]Dˆ‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVSWRWRXFK’ FRQWDLQLQJWKH/DWLQSUHIL[LQWHUÖ$OEQG¬U
6XIIL[DWLRQRIQRXQV 9HUEDO VXIIL[HV DUH GHVFULEHG LQ VHFWLRQV 1RPLQDO
VXIIL[HVDUHFODVVLILHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLU“PDLQHOHPHQW”7KLVLVSXUHO\ DFRQYHQWLRQ2IWHQWKLV“PDLQHOHPHQW” happens to be, historically, an old suffix of Indo-European origin. /LWHUDWXUH ;+89$1,Ç$%(- 3UDSDVKW SDVVLP &$0$- $OE :RUWE '(61,&.$-$6UDYQ
/DELDOVXIIL[HV
7KHQXPEHURIZRUGVSUHVXPDEO\FRQWDLQLQJWKHVXIIL[ E
,( EKR ~ EK DV DWWHVWHG LQ %DOWR6ODYLF FI /LWK G¢UEDV ‘ZRUN’ DQGHOVHZKHUHFI*NGN CHQX‘VWDJ’/DWPRUEXV‘LOOQHVV’EHVLGHPRULRU ‘WRGLH’ LVYHU\OLPLWHGLQ$OEDQLDQ
152
chapter two
WKDUE¬W‘VRXU’EDVHGRQ WKDUE¬GHULYHGIURPWKDU‘WRDGGIHUPHQW WRPLON’ WKXPE‘VWLQJWKRUQ’GHULYHGIURPWKXD~WKXH‘ ILQJHU QDLO’ (3$
DWVQDWR,( D‘VKDUS’ VWUXFWXUDOO\VLPLODUZLWK*NCMCPQX ‘WKRUQ\IUXLW’CMCKPC‘WLSSRLQW’ $VLQ%DOWR6ODYLFLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQRQH ILQGV D QXPEHU RI H[DPSOHV FRQWDLQLQJ WKHPDWL]HG VXIIL[HV DE DQG LE 7KHVH VXIIL[HV DUH LGHQWLFDO ZLWK WKRVH IRXQG LQ WKH 6ODYLF QRPLQD DEVWUDFWD RE D DQG
ÚE D FI 6ODY ]ORED ‘DQJHU’ ERUÚED ‘ILJKWLQJ’ DQG WKH %DOWLF QRPLQDDFWLRQLVIRXQGLQ/LWK\ED JDUEH ‘IORZHUSRW’ (3$ JDULE ,( ÞKHU ‘WR EXUQ’ FI 6ODY
JÙUQÙ‘RYHQSRW’ N¬UUDE¬‘KRRN VWDII VWDII’ GHULYHG IURP NDU¬ (3$ NDU 6ODY
NRUD‘EDUN’/LWKNHU¸N©UWL‘WREHFRPHVHSDUDWHG’DQGIXUWKHU ZLWK,( V NHU‘WRFXW’ OOXUE¬‘VHGLPHQWPXG’ (3$ OXU L EGHULYHGIURP OXUDFORVH WR/LWKOD-U^‘GLUW\SHUVRQ’ WKHOE‘NHUQHO RIDQXW ’ (3$ WVDOLEDDGHULYDWLYHRI,( HO‘WR FRYHU’FI2+*KXOVD‘VKHOO’2(KXOXLG
7KHXQYRLFHGODELDO SLVYHU\UDUHDVDVXIIL[,WKDVQRFOHDU ,QGR(XURSHDQSDUDOOHOV FXS ‘RGG XQHYHQ ’ (3$ WVXSD IURP ,( H XSR EDVHG RQ
HX i ‘WRVZHOO’FI6NWy Q\¢‘HPSW\’ VKWDOS ‘UHQQHW’ (3$ VWDOSD *N UVGNNY ‘WR SXW WR VHW’ 2+* VWHOOHQ‘WRSXW’23UXVVWDOOW‘WRVWDQG’ 6HFRQGDU\VXIIL[HVEDVHGRQ SDUHDOVRYHU\UDUH N¬UF‘VWXPS’¾N¬UçHS‘VWXPSORJEUDQFK’ NDVKW¬‘VWUDZ’¾NDVKWXS‘VNLQRIFRUQFRE’ 'HQWDOVXIIL[HV
7KH ,QGR(XURSHDQ VXIIL[ GK LQ VRPH FDVHV GHILQLWHO\ FRQWLQXLQJ,( GK‘WRSXWWRVHW’ LVUHWDLQHGLQ$OEDQLDQDV(3$ G !GK
morphonology and word-formation
153
KXUGK¬‘SRQGSRRO’ (3$ ZXUG 6ODY YLUÙ‘ZKLUOSRRO’ YDULWL ‘WRFRRN’/LWKY©UGXY®UWLLG N¬SXUGK¬‘IXQJXVPXVKURRP’ (3$ NDSXUG /LWKNªSXU^‘FDS’ /DWYF?SXUHLG 7KLV VXIIL[ VHHPV WR EH JHQHWLFDOO\ XQUHODWHG WR (3$ GM D DQG LWV GHULYDWLYHV 7KH ODWWHU LV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK *N -CF- -KF- FI PQOCX ‘SDVWXULQJ’ CURKX ‘VKLHOG’ DQG WKHLU OHVV IUHTXHQW SDUDOOHOV LQ ,QGR $U\DQDQG,WDOLF(3$ GM D !¬]LVRIWHQXVHGLQGHYHUEDWLYHV EOXDM‘WRJULQG’¾EOR]¬‘VRRW’ GUHGK‘WRWXUQ’¾QGUL]¬‘EDQGEDQGDJH’ OHM‘WRJLYHELUWK’¾OH]OHP]¬‘ELUWKPDUN’ UXDM~ UXHM‘WRJXDUGWRNHHS’¾UXD]¬‘JODVVEHDG’ VKNRM‘WRZDON’¾VKNR]¬‘EHHFK’ VKT\HM‘WREUHDN’¾VKTH]¬‘KDUURZ’ 4XLWHRIWHQ]¬¬]DSSHDUVLQGHQRPLQDWLYHVZKHUHLWUHIOHFWVWKHPDWLF (3$ DGMDRU DGM DP¬‘RGRU’¾DP¬]‘RGRU’ JMHOO¬‘IRRG’¾JMHOO¬]‘VDOW’ P¬OOHQM¬‘EODFNELUG’¾P¬OOH]¬‘EODFNELUG’ PLHOO‘IORXU’¾PLHOOD]¬‘ILQHVQRZ’ SH~ Sê‘WKUHDG’¾SHM]¬‘PXVFOHVLQHZ’ WKHOO¬‘GDUN’¾WK¬OO¬]¬‘SDUWULGJH’ YDM¬‘JLUO’¾YDM]¬‘JLUO’ 5DUHUIRUPVDUHEDVHGRQ(3$ LGMD!L]
NXUU¾NXUUL]‘VSLQH’ PXUU¬W‘GDUN’¾PXUUL]‘EULDU’
2QH RI WKH PRVW ZLGHVSUHDG VXIIL[HV LQ WKH $OEDQLDQ QRPLQDO V\VWHPLV WD~ WZKLFKFRQWLQXHVWKH,QGR(XURSHDQYHUEDODGMHFWLYH VXIIL[ WR EXW¬ ’VRIW VPRRWK’ (3$ EXWD ,( EKXJKWR FRPSDUDEOH ZLWK 1,UERJ‘VRIW’ EKXJKR$UPERZ‘EOXQW’
154
chapter two
IOHW¬ ‘ZLQJ OHDI’ (3$ DZDOHNWD ,( OHN ‘WR IO\’ /LWK OHNL¸ O|NWL/DWYOªNW2+*OHFNHQ‘WRMXPSWRNLFN’ KXW‘YDLQHPSW\’ (3$ XWDEDVHGRQ,( HXi Æ‘HPSW\’FI 6NW Q¢‘PLVVLQJ’/DWYQXV‘HPSW\’ ODW¬ ‘VPDOO D[H’ (3$ ODSW FORVH WR WKHPDWLF 6ODY ORSDWD ‘VSDGH’/LWKO²SHWDLGDQG DWKHPDWLF 23UXVORSWR ORW‘WHDU’ (3$ O L WDEDVHGRQ,( OL‘WRSRXUWRIORZ’ PXW‘H[FUHPHQW’ (3$ PXNWD 6NWPXNW¢‘UHOHDVHG’ 7KH VDPH VXIIL[ WD RU LWV WKHPDWLF YDULDQW DWD" LV SURGXFWLYH LQ $OEDQLDQDGMHFWLYHV GLDOEOHU¬‘JUHHQ’¾EOHUW¬LG FHUP¬‘FROG’¾FHPW¬LG 2$OEGMDWK¬‘ULJKW VLGH ’¾GMDWKW¬‘ULJKW’ KLGKHP‘WRMXPSWRRYHUIORZ’¾KLGK¬W‘ELWWHUVDG’ ODVK¬‘ROGHDUO\’¾ODVKW¬LG PHN‘WRPDNHZHW’¾PHN¬W‘ZHW’ &RUUHVSRQGLQJ WKHPDWLF VXIIL[HV LQ VXEVWDQWLYHV DUH UHODWLYHO\ UDUH 7KH\ LQFOXGH (3$ HWD ! HW DQG DW ! DW¬ 7KH ODWWHU LV LGHQWLFDO ZLWK WKH 6ODYLF VXIIL[ RI QRPLQD DEVWUDFWD RWD FI RUERWD ‘ZRUN ODERXU’ NUDVRWD‘EHDXW\’DQGWKHOLNH GHW ‘VHD’ (3$ GHXEHWD ‘GHSWK’ ,( GKHXE ‘GHHS’ FI *PF
GHXSLÈA‘GHSWK’!0'XGLHSGH0/*GSHGH(GHSWK O¬JDW¬ ‘PDUVK’ (3$ OHXJDW ,OO\U GNQL .QWIGQP ZCNQWOGPQP 6WUDER /LWKOL
JDV‘PDUVK’6ODY OXÊD‘SRRO’ O¬QJDW¬ OLJDW¬ ‘LOOQHVV VLFNQHVV DLOPHQW’ (3$ OLJDW GHULYHG IURP OLJD!OLJ‘LOOEDG’ (3$ XWD ! XW LV DWWHVWHG RQO\ RQFH WKRXJK LW LV SUREDEO\ UHODWHG WR %DOWR6ODYLF ÙWÙ ÙWD PDNXW ‘JUHHG\ JOXWWRQRXV’ EDVHG RQ PDN GHULYHG IURP PDM ‘WR IHHG’
,QDOLPLWHGQXPEHURIVXEVWDQWLYHVZHILQGWKHROGVXIIL[ WL FRQWLQXLQJ,( WLFI6NWVUXW‘IORZLQJVWUHDPLQJ’*NTWU KXLG/DW
morphonology and word-formation
155
YWLV ‘YLQH’ 2,U I©LWK ‘VLQHZ’ /LWK YØWLV ‘WZLJ RI ZLOORZ WUHH’ DQG WKH OLNH EHV¬‘SOHGJHWUXFHWUXVW’ (3$ EDLWhLFORVHWRGkπιUVKX‘IDLWKIXO WUXVWZRUWK\’ ERW¬‘HDUWK ZRUOG’ (3$ EZWL 6NWEK W‘H[LVWHQFH’/LWKE W®V LG,UEXLWKLG GKXQ¬‘ODERUSDLQVVKDPHGLVJUDFH’ (3$ HGXQWLRU DGXQWL *N Q FWPJ‘ODERUSDLQV’$UPHUNQLG HW‘WKLUVW’ (3$ DONWL /LWK¢ONWL‘WREHKXQJU\’6ODY RONDWLLG 2+*LOJL‘KXQJHU’ +LVWRULFDOO\EDVHGRQ WLLV WMD~ WM GMHUV¬‘SHUVSLUDWLRQ’ (3$ ZLGHUWM *NKFTYXLG VÆLGUAWV GRV¬ ‘SLJ VRZ’ (3$ G L WM GHULYHG IURP ,( GK L ‘WR VXFNOH’ QXV ‘WKUHDG VWULQJ’ (3$ VQXWMD 6NW VQdYDQ ‘EDQG VLQHZ’ DQG IXUWKHUWR,( VQHX‘WRWXUQWRVSLQ’ SOLV‘FORGRIHDUWKVRGSLHFHRIWXUI’ (3$ SOLWMD 6NWSK¢ODWL‘WR EXUVWWRVSOLW’/DWVSROLXP‘VWULSSHGVNLQRUKLGHVSRLO’ THUV¬ ‘IDOORZ ODQG’ (3$ NHUNWMD 6ODY NÙU¨Ú ‘VWXEEHG SORW’ /DWYN¸UNW‘WREHFRPHHPSW\ RIDWXUQLS ’23UXV&XUFKH‘WKH ODVWVKHDILQZKLFKDGHLW\KLGHV’ 7KHVHFRQGDU\VXIIL[ DWMLVEDVHGRQ WM G¬UUDV¬ ‘ERDUG VWRQH SODWH’ (3$ GHUDWM EDVHG RQ ,( GHU ‘WR WHDUWRVSOLW’ J¬UUHV¬ ‘VFUDSHU’ (3$ JDUDWM GHULYHG IURP JULM ‘WR FXW LQWR SLHFHV’ ,( ÞHU JM\VP¬JM\P ¬ V¬‘KDOI’ (3$ M PDWM /DWYMXPLV‘GRXEOHIUXLW’ 6NW \DP¢ ‘GXSOLFDWH WZLQ’ 0,U HPRQ ‘WZLQV’ /DW LPJA ‘LPLWDWLRQFRS\’ VKNOHV¬‘URRIVKLQJOH’ (3$ VNDODWMGHULYHGIURPVKNHO‘WRPDNH DVWHSWRZDON’ (3$ VNDOD
156
chapter two
9HODUVXIIL[HV
:RUGV ZKHUH ZH ILQG VXIIL[HV EDVHG RQ D YRLFHG YHODU (3$
J ,( J DUHYHU\IHZ7KHVDPHVXIIL[LVUDWKHUZHOODWWHVWHGLQ %DOWR6ODYLFFI6ODY VWUXJD‘FXUUHQWVKLS’ ¨HWYÚUJÙ‘7KXUVGD\’7KH IROORZLQJWZRFDVHVDUHIDLUO\UHOLDEOH YDU‘WRKDQJ’¾YDUJ‘URZFKDLQULQJ’ P¬OO¬~ PXOO¬‘VZHOOLQJOXPS’¾P¬OOXJ¬‘VFDOHVFDUPDUN’
7KHSULPDU\VXIIL[ NDUHODWHGWR,( NRLVDWWHVWHGLQPDQ\ $OEDQLDQZRUGV$PRQJWKHRWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQGDXJKWHUODQJXDJHVLW LV SUHVHUYHG QHDUO\ HYHU\ZKHUH FI 6NW GKN¢ ‘UHFHSWDFOH’ *N SJMJ LG/LWKS®ONDV‘JUH\’6ODY ]QDNÙ‘VLJQ’DQGWKHOLNH JDN‘ERDU’ (3$ JDXND ,( ÞAX‘FRZ’VLPLODUWR0DFHGγοτα∼ν ∼ταν ·WP +HV ÞRXWR OHJγου VDUN¬‘EXLOGIUDPHILJXUH RIKXPDQERG\ ’ (3$ WhHUNGHULYHG IURP,( áHU‘WRPDNHWREXLOG’ 6NWNDUeWL/LWKN¸UWL VKWUHN ‘FRUSVH FDUULRQ’ (3$ VWUHND GHULYHG IURP ,( VWHU ‘XQFOHDQOLTXLGPDQXUH’ WKDUN ‘HQFORVXUH HVSHFLDOO\ IRU PLONLQJ ’ (3$ WVHUND GHULYHG IURP WKXU ‘WR IHQFH WR HQFORVH WR SODLW WR ZHDYH’ (3$
WVXUMD WKLN¬‘NQLIH’ (3$ WVLNGHULYHGIURP,( L‘WRVKDUSHQ’ 6NW yyWL‘WRZKHWWRVKDUSHQ’$UPVRZU‘VKDUS NQLIH’ WKLUTH‘FKLFNSHD’VLQJXODUL]HGSOXUDORI WKLUNGHULYHGIURPWKMHUU¬ ‘OHQWLO’ (3$ WVHU D QRQUHGXSOLFDWHG SDUDOOHO RI /DW FLFHU ‘SHD’$UPVLVHàQLG ,( LHU 7KLV VXIIL[ VHUYHG DV D EDVLV IRU WKH IRUPDWLRQ RI VHFRQGDU\ VXIIL[HV
LN DQG XN VLPLODU WR /LWK LNDV XNDV 6ODY ÚFÚ DQG ÙNÙ ,(
LNR LV SUHWW\ ZHOO DWWHVWHG FI 6NW YdVDQWLND ‘EHORQJLQJ WR VSULQJ’ YdU¿LND ‘EHORQJLQJ WR WKH UDLQ\ VHDVRQ’ *N KRR-KMQX ‘EHORQJLQJ WR KRUVHV’PWOH-KMQX‘EULGDO’&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHVRI LN EHUN‘EDVW’ (3$ EDUG]LNDGHULYHGIURP3$OE EDUG]D!EDUGK¬ ‘ZKLWH’ EUHQJ¬‘JULHIVRUURZ’ (3$ EUDLQLNFRQQHFWHGZLWK EUDLQMD! EUHM‘WRJQDZ’
morphonology and word-formation
157
EXQJ‘NLQGRIRDN4XHUFXVVHVVLIORUD’ (3$ EXQLNDGHULYHGIURP ,( EKHX‘WRJURZ’DQGFORVHO\UHODWHGWR$UPERZQ‘WUXQN’ JU\N¬‘WKURDW’ (3$ JUZ N ,( ÞUÆ‘QHFN’ 6NWJUYd$Y JUY/DWYJU&YD‘ULYHUPRXWK’6ODY JULYD‘PDQH’ SHWN‘FORWKHVJDUPHQW’ (3$ SDWLNDGHULYDWLYHRISHW¬‘OD\HU RI DIODN\SâW© PHWDOSODWH IODWVWRQH’ (3$ SDWL‘IODWREMHFW’ FRPSDUHGZLWK,( SHW~ SHWi‘WRVWUHWFK’ *NRGVCPPWOKLG /DWSDWHA‘WRVWUHWFKWREHVSUHDG’ VKWDON¬ ‘IUDPH’ (3$ VWDOLN QRPLQDO GHULYDWLYH EDVHG RQ ,(
VWHOFI6NWVWK¢OD‘HOHYDWLRQ’*NUVQNJ ‘HTXLSPHQW’0/* VWDOH‘SRVW’ (3$ XNLVOHVVIUHTXHQW EDUN‘EHOO\ZRPEDEGRPHQ’ (3$ EDUXND DCT W!MC CKFQK`QP RCTC>6CTCPVKPQKXFRQWLQXLQJ EKRUXNR EDUXN¬‘IOHHFH’ (3$ EDUXNGHULYHGIURP EDUZD!EHUU‘VKHHS JRDW’ 7KH RULJLQV RI WKH VXIIL[ DN ~ DN¬ DUH QRW TXLWH FOHDU ,W PD\ EH ERUURZHG IURP 6ODYLF WKRXJK RQH FDQQRW H[FOXGH LWV FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK VXFKPRUSKHPHVDV6ODY RNÙFRQWLQXLQJ,( RáUDWKHUWKDQ RN E¬UUDN¬‘PXGG\SRROSRQGVZDPS’ (3$ ELUDNGHULYHGIURP ELU¬‘KROH’ O¬PDTH‘H[SDQVHRIUXEEOHVWRQHVOLGH SLOH RI VWRQHV’ VLQJXODUL]HG SOXUDO RI O¬PDN GHULYHG IURP O¬P¬ ~ ODP¬ ‘WKUHVKLQJIORRU ZLQHSUHVV’ (3$ ODP 2+* ODP ‘ODPH’ 6ODY ORPÙ ‘EUHDNLQJ FURZEDU EURNHQEUDQFKHV’ OXPDN‘EXGVKRRW OLFKHQPRVV’ (3$ OXEQDND ,( OHXEK‘WR SHHO WR VNLQ’ FI /LWK OXE£ ‘ERDUG RI D FHLOLQJ ’ /DWY OXED ‘EDUN ERDUG’ 23UXV OXEER ‘ERDUG’ 6ODY OÙEÙ ‘IRUHKHDG VNXOO’ $V WR WKH VXIIL[ RN RU RT LQ VLQJXODUL]HG SOXUDOV LW FRQWLQXHV (3$
NLGHQWLFDO ZLWK *N -CE /DW FXV &HOW NRV /LWK RNDV 6ODY
DNÙ FI *N PGCE ‘\RXWK’ /DW RSFXV ‘VKDGRZ\’ 2,U FXPDFKWDFK ‘PLJKW\’/LWKMXRG²NDV‘EODFNLVK’6ODY QRYDNÙ‘QRYLFH’
158
chapter two
KDUURN ‘KHJRDW’ (3$ VNDUND /LWK VNHUmV ‘UDP’ /DWY hNULV LGIXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK*NUMCKTY‘WRVSULQJWRGDQFH’ N¬OERTH‘VSXWXP’VLQJXODUL]HGSOXUDORI N¬OERN (3$ NDOEND GHULYHGIURPNDOE‘WROHWURW’ WDURN‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ WDXUNDUHODWHGWRWHU‘EXOO’ WKHURN¬ ‘3DVVHULQD KLUVXWD VZHHSLQJV’ (3$ WVHUN GHULYHG IURPWKHU‘WRVODXJKWHUWRSLHUFH’ (3$ WVHUD 6NWyÖodWL‘WR VPDVKWRFUXVK’*NMJT‘GHDWK’2,UGRFHU‘ KH IHOO’
2QHRIWKHPRVWSURGXFWLYHVXIIL[HVLQWKHV\VWHPRI$OEDQLDQ QRXQLVWKFRQWLQXLQJ(3$ WV ,( +RZHYHUWKHODWWHULVQHDUO\ QRQH[LVWHQWDVDQ,QGR(XURSHDQVXIIL[ ZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIVXFKUDUH FDVHV DV 6NW\XYDy¢ /DWLXYHQFXV ‘\RXWKIXO \RXQJ’ ,Q PDQ\ FDVHV WKLVXVHGWRIRUPGLPLQXWLYHV NUDQG‘5HLVLJ%ODHWWHU]ZHLJ’¾NUDQWK‘OLWWOHOHDI’ ODN‘WUDSVOLQJ’¾ODNWKLG OH]‘:DU]H’¾O\WKLG V\‘H\H’¾V\WK‘0DVFKH.QRVSH’ XUL‘0DXOZXUI’¾XULWKLG YH‘HJJ’¾YHWK‘0DGH)OLHJHQPDGH’ ,QPDQ\RWKHUZRUGVLWDOWHUVWKHPHDQLQJRIWKHQRPLQDOVWHPFIWKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV ELU¬‘KROH’¾ELUWK‘SLPSOH’ EUL‘KRUQ’EULU¬¾EULUWK‘WHQWDFOH’ KDO¬‘ILVKERQH’¾KDOWK‘QHHGOH’ NDS‘OLGFRYHU’¾NDSWK‘path, mule track’ VKWHJ‘SDWKZD\’¾VKWHNWK‘parting (of hair)’ WUD‘EHDPSRVW’¾WUDWK‘URRIVODW’ YHVK‘HDU’¾Y¬WK‘HDUULQJ’ 6XIIL[HVLQV
2QH RI WKH PRVW IUHTXHQW VVXIIL[HV LQ $OEDQLDQ LV XV ! X VKRULJLQDOO\UHIOHFWLQJWKHSHUIHFWSDUWLFLSOHIRUPDQW ÆHV~ XV
morphonology and word-formation
159
DUJ¬VK ‘FUXGH UDIW VXSSRUWHG E\ VNLQ EODGGHUV FUXGH EULGJH RI FURVVEDUVKDUURZ’ (3$ DUJXVD 6NWDUJDOD‘EROW’2(UHFHG ‘EXLOGLQJKRXVH’ O¬SXVK¬ ‘PXOOHLQ EURDGOHDIHG SODQW’ ODSXV GHULYHG IURP ODS¬ ‘KDUG SLHFH RI PHDW RU VNLQ SHULWRQHXP OHDI’ (3$ ODS /LWKO¦SDV‘OHDI’*NNQRQX‘VKHOOKXVNEDUN’ PHNVK ‘EXIIDORFDOI’ (3$ PDJXVD 2,U PDXJ ‘VODYH’ *RWK PDJXV‘\RXWK’ IURP,( PDJKX PDJKRV P¬UVK¬‘FRUSVHFDUULRQ’ (3$ PHUXVDEDVHGRQ,( PHU‘WRGLH’ 6NWPUL\¢WH/LWKPL¼WL6ODY PHUWL PRVK¬‘DJH’ (3$ PWXVGHULYHGIURP PWL!PRW‘WLPH’ UUXVK‘JUDSH’ (3$ UJXVD *NT CELG YLç‘FDOI’ (3$ YHWXVDIXUWKHUUHODWHGWR ZHWD!YLW‘\HDU’ ,QRQHFDVHWKHVDPHVXIIL[DSSHDUVZLWKDORQJYRZHO V!\VK N¬O\VK‘\RXQJRIDQLPDOFXE’ (3$ NXO VD *NMWNNC UMWNCE * NGK QK+HVIXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWKUMWNCE‘\RXQJGRJFXE’ $UDUHVXIIL[(3$ HVMDLVXVHGWRIRUPQRPLQDDJHQWLV OXSHVK‘JOXWWRQ’ (3$ OXSHVMDGHULYHGIURPOOXS‘WRJXOSGRZQ WRVZDOORZ’ (3$ OXSD 6NWOXPS¢WL‘WREUHDNWRLQMXUH’/LWK O¸SWL‘WRSHHO’/DWYOXSW‘WRSHHO WRHDW’6ODY OXSLWL‘WRSHHO’
6HYHUDOVXIIL[HVLQFOXGHVDVWKHLUILUVWHOHPHQW(3$ VN!
VKN LV SUREDEO\ UHODWHG WR WKH IRUPDQW LQ *N FKUMQX ‘TXRLW’ DQUMJ ‘IRGGHU’ LIQRWIURP V GXVKNGUXVKN‘RDN’ (3$ GUXVNDDGHULYDWLYHRIGUX‘WUHH’ EDVKN¬‘IOHHFH’ (3$ EDUXVNGHULYHGIURPEHUU‘VKHHSJRDW’ (3$ EDUZD 7KH IROORZLQJ VXIIL[ LVN RULJLQDOO\ DQ DGMHFWLYDO VXIIL[ LV EDVHG XSRQ VNDQGFDQEHLPPHGLDWHO\FRPSDUHGZLWKDSURGXFWLYH%DOWR 6ODYLF DGMHFWLYDO IRUPDQW /LWK OLHW¸YLhNDV ‘/LWKXDQLDQ’ 6ODY GpWÚVNÙ ‘FKLOGLVK’
160
chapter two
GU\VKN ‘UXVW’ (3$ GU G]LVND GHULYHG IURP GU G]D ! GU\GK¬W ‘HDV\ WR SODQH RI ZRRG ’ (3$ GU G]D FORVH WR 6ODY
GU\]JDWL GUX]JDWL‘WRVTXHH]HWRFUXVK’ NUHVKN¬ ‘IROLDJH’ (3$ NDUDQGLVN GHULYHG IURP NU¬QG ~ NUDQGH ‘IROLDJH EUXVKZRRG OHDYHV XVHG DV IRGGHU FKLSV EUDQFK ZLWKRXW OHDYHV’ (3$ NDUDQGD D SUHIL[ IRUPDWLRQ FRQQHFWHGZLWK,( UHQGK‘WRWHDU DVXQGHU ’DQGLQSDUWLFXODU ZLWK2+*ULQGDULQWD‘ULQG’2(ULQGHLG 6XIIL[ VWD~ VWZDVRULJLQDOO\DQDGMHFWLYDOVXIIL[,QVRPHFDVHVLW PLJKWEHFRQQHFWHGZLWK,( VW‘WRVWDQGWRSXW’ ELVKW‘WDLO’ (3$ E VWDGHULYDWLYHRI,( EK ‘WRJURZ’ EUHVKW¬ ‘ZLOG URXJK UXJJHG UXGH’ (3$ EUDLhWD GHULYHG IURP EUHM (3$ EUDLQMDIXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK,( EKUHL‘WRFXW’ 6NW EKUodWL ‘ KH LQMXUHV’ /DW IULA ‘WR UXE’ 6ODY EULWL ‘WR VKDYH’ ODJVKW¬‘ZHW’ ODJVWDGHULYHGIURPODJ‘WRZHW’ 6HYHUDO QRXQV ZLWK LQVWUXPHQWDO PHDQLQJ DUH IRUPHG ZLWK WKH VXIIL[
LVW JDVKW¬‘ZKHWVWRQH’ (3$ JDOLVWDVXIIL[HGGHULYDWLYHUHODWHGWR /LWKJ¦ODV‘HQG’/DWYJDOVLG KHVKW¬‘VSHDU’ (3$ VNAOLVWGHULYHGIURPKHOO‘VSHDU’ VNAOD NDELVKW ‘HDUZLJ’ (3$ NDELVWD /LWK NDE{WL ‘WR KDQJ’ NDED ‘FURRNHGWUHH’ NDVKW¬‘VWUDZ’ (3$ NDOVLVWGHULYDWLYHRINDOOL‘HDU RIJUDLQ ’ ODNVKWH‘GHZ’ (3$ ODXJLVWDGHULYHGIURPODJ‘WRZHWWRVRDNWR EDWKHWRZDVK’ (3$ ODXJD 1RXQV GHQRWLQJ ORFDWLRQ RU SHULRG RI WLPH DUH IRUPHG ZLWK WKH VXIIL[
HVW!VKWFI6ODY LVWMH! Lh¨H EOLVKW¬‘OLQGHQZRRG’ (3$ EOLQHVWEDVHGRQEOL‘OLQGHQ’ NRSVKW‘JDUGHQ’ (3$ NSHVWD *NMJ`RQXLG2+*KXRED‘SORW RIODQG’ Y¬VKW~YêVKW‘YLQH\DUG’ (3$ ZDLQHVWDGHULYHGIURP ZDLQ! YHU¬~YHQ¬‘ZLQH’
morphonology and word-formation
161
YMHVKW¬ ‘DXWXPQ’ (3$ ZHOHVW GHULYHG IURP YMHO ‘WR SOXFN IUXLW WRYLQWDJH’ (3$ ZHOD *NGKNY‘WRVKXWLQWRSUHVV’ /LWKVXYDOØWL‘WRKDUYHVWWRUHDS’ ,Q $OEDQLDQ ZH ILQG LVRODWHG WUDFHV RI D VXIIL[ VOD ZKLFK LV KLVWRULFDOO\ LGHQWLFDO WR 6ODY VOR PD]VOR ‘EXWWHU’ SU?GVOR ‘VSLQ GOH’DQG/DW VORLQOXP‘ZLOGJDUOLF’SUOXP‘ZLQHSUHVV’ TXOO ‘SRUULGJH’ (3$ NOXVOD *N MNW\Y ‘WR ULQVH’ /DW FOXA ‘WR FOHDQ’ 6XIIL[HVLQOLTXLGD
7KHSULPDU\VXIIL[ OLVTXLWHSURGXFWLYHLQ$OEDQLDQ+LV WRULFDOO\ LW LV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK ,( OR FI *N UVW`NQX ‘SLOODU’ /DW FDHOXP‘FKLVHO’*RWKVWROV‘VWRROVHDW’DQGWKHOLNH
EXN¬O‘ZHDVHO’ (3$ EXNOFRQQHFWHGZLWKEXNXU‘EHDXWLIXO’ PLOO‘VKHDWK’ (3$ PHLOD 6NWPLQeWL‘WRIDVWHQ’2,UWXLGPHQLG SHOO¬‘FRPE’ (3$ SHWVO *NRGMY‘WRFRPE’/LWKSªhWL‘WRSXOO WRSOXFN’/DWSHFWHQ‘FRPE’ WROO¬ ‘EDOG VSRW GUXP PHPEUDQH’ (3$ WVO ,( WVO /DW WOD‘FORWK’2+*GHKVDOD‘D[H’6ODY WHVODLG YRJ¬O‘VPDOO’ (3$ ZJOD /DWYDJRU‘WRURDPDURXQG’2,UI¢Q ‘VORSH’ ÆJQR ]XO¬‘VKRXWJORU\’ (3$ G]XO ,( ½KHÆi‘WRFDOO’ 6NWK¢YDWH $Y]DYDLWL6ODY ]ÙYDWL $PRQJWKHVHFRQGDU\VXIIL[HVEDVHGRQ(3$ OWKHPRVWSURGXFWLYH LV XO HK‘WRVKDUSHQ’¾HKXOO‘LFLFOH’ JUHK‘WRFRPE’ YDULDQWRINUHK ¾JUHKXOO‘WKLFNHW’ KD‘WRHDW’¾KDPXOO‘VWXEEOHILHOG’ SHQG¬‘IHDWKHU’¾SHQGXOOLG SL]J¬‘VSOLQWHU’¾SL]JXOOLG VXN¬‘ORZKLOO’¾VXNXOO‘OXPS’ WKXPE‘WKRUQ’¾WKXPEXOO‘EXWWRQ’ XWK¬W‘VRXU’¾XWKXOO‘YLQHJDU’
162
chapter two
$QRWKHU LPSRUWDQW VXIIL[ LV LO ~ O 7KH ODWWHU FDQ EH FRPSDUHG ZLWK\ODLQ/LWKDNØODV‘REVHUYDQW’ ELM¬‘GDXJKWHU’ (3$ ELULOGHULYHGIURP ELUD!ELU‘VRQ’ N¬UPLOO‘VQDLOVOXJ’ (3$ NULPODGHULYHGIURPNULPE‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULPD N¬UUO¬‘VORSS\PXGVOLPH’ (3$ NDULO 21KRUU‘VQLYHO’2+* KRUR‘H[FUHPHQW’*NMQTW\C‘VQLYHO’ \OO‘VWDU’ (3$ VN ZLODDGHULYDWLYHRI VNLM!KLMH‘VKDGRZ’ ,Q D IHZ ZRUG ZH ILQG HO ZKLFK LV UHODWHG WR WKH IRUPDQW RI /LWK G®GHOLV‘JUHDW’SDUhOLV‘SLJOHW’ JREHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH LQ ZDWHU ’ (3$ JXEHO /LWK JD-EWL ‘WR FRYHUWRZUDS’6ODY JÙEQ_WL‘WREHQG’ XUHO¬ ‘ZDWHUSLW’ (3$ XUHO 21 U ‘GUL]]OH’ 23UXV ZXUV ‘SRRO’*NCP-CWTQX‘GHYRLGRIZDWHU’
7KH ,QGR(XURSHDQ DGMHFWLYDO VXIIL[ UR LV FRQWLQXHG E\ (3$ UD ,Q ,QGR(XURSHDQ LW LV ZLGHO\ DWWHVWHG FI 6NW Y¢MUD ‘WKXQGHUEROW’ *N GNCHTQX ‘OLJKW EULVN’ /DW VDFHU ‘VDFUHG KRO\’ DQG WKHOLNH ODU¬ ‘ZKLWH VSRW’ ‘VSRWWHG PRWOH\’ (3$ ODXU EDVHG RQ ODM ‘WR ZDVK’ (3$ ODXQMD *NNQWYLG/DWODYALG PDN¬UU ‘VWDJQDQW JUHHQ RQ SRQGV’ (3$ PDNUD GHULYHG IURP PDN¬‘JOXHVFXPVNLQ RQWKHPLONRURWKHUOLTXLGV ’&I6ODY
PRNUÙ‘ZHW’ PLU¬ ‘JRRG’ (3$ PUD IRUPLQJ D VHSDUDWH LVRJORVV ZLWK 6ODY
PLUÙ‘SHDFH’ UHODWHGWR,( PHL VKWDOE¬U‘ZRRGHQVQDUH’ (3$ VWDOEUD 21VWROSL‘EHDPJLUGHU’ /LWKVWXËEDV‘SRVWSROH’6ODY VWÙOEÙLG WKHPE¬U ‘KHHO’ (3$ WVDPEU ,( V DPE ‘WR EHQG’ *N UMCODQX‘EHQWFURRNHG’2,UFDPPLG $VHFRQGDU\VXIIL[ XULVUDWKHUSURGXFWLYH EOHKXU¬‘SDOH’ (3$ EODLGXUD 6ODY EOpGÙLG2(EOWLG EXNXU ‘EHDXWLIXO ILQH’ (3$ EXNXUD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK EXN¬O ‘ZHDVHO’
morphonology and word-formation
163
ODNXU‘QDNHG’ (3$ ODXNXUDGHULYHGIURP,( OHXN‘WRVKLQHWR EHZKLWH’ ,Q D OLPLWHG QXPEHU RI ZRUGV ,( WUR ! (3$ WUD LV DWWHVWHG ,W LV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK VLPLODU PRUSKHPHV LQ PDQ\ RWKHU ,QGR(XURSHDQ ODQJXDJHV FI *N TQR VTQP ‘WDPERXULQH’ /DW UAVWUXP ‘EHDN’ 2,U FULDWKDU‘VLHYH’/LWKY{WUD‘VWRUP’ NHW¬U ‘VTXLUUHO GRUPRXVH’ (3$ NANWUD /LWK NXRNDV ‘GDQFH’ UHFRQVWUXFWHGIURPNXRN®Q^‘GDQFLQJSDUW\’ DQG6ODY VNDNDWL ‘WRMXPSWRVSULQJ’ SLW¬U‘IUHTXHQW’ (3$ SLPWUD 2,U©LP‘TXLFNIDVW’21ILPULG WKDG¬U ‘D NLQG RI D GRXEOHVLGHG D[H’ (3$ WVHVWU 6NW yDVWU¢ ‘NQLIHVZRUG’ 6XIIL[HVLQQDVDOVRQRUDQWV
'HYHUEDWLYH DGMHFWLYHV DQG RWKHU RULJLQDOO\ DGMHFWLYDO GHUL
YDWLYHV DUH IRUPHG ZLWK (3$ PD ,( PR +LVWRULFDOO\ WKH VDPH VXIIL[LVDOVRXVHGWRIRUPQRXQVIURPRULJLQDOYHUEVDQGQRXQV&ILQ RWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHV 6NW¢MPD‘SDWKFRXUVH’*NHNQIOQX ‘EUDQG’*RWKGRPV‘MXGJHPHQWVHQWHQFH’ EDUP¬ ‘EDVW’ (3$ EDUG]P GHULYHG IURP EDUG]D ! EDUGK¬ ‘ZKLWH’ ELP¬‘SODQW’ (3$ E P ,( EK PR *NHW`OCLG EUDP‘UHVLGXHVFRULDUXVWHDUZD[’ (3$ EUDGPD 6NWEUDGKQ¢ ‘UHGGLVK\HOORZ’6ODY EURQÙ‘FRORUHG’ EURGQÙ EULP¬ ‘KROH’ (3$ EULPD DQ DGMHFWLYH LQ PR EDVHG RQ ,(
EKHU JULP¬ ‘FUXPE ELW’ (3$ JULPD GHULYHG IURP JULM ~ JUîM ‘WR FXW LQWRSLHFHVWRJQDZWRHDWDZD\’ ,( ÞHUi‘WRVZDOORZ’ 6NW JLU¢WL $UP HNHU /DW YRUA /LWK JHUL¸ J©UWL ‘WR GULQN’ 6ODY
ÊHUWLLG VDP¬‘GRJ’VH[FUHPHQWV’ (3$ WVZD Q PDDGHULYDWLYHLQ PR RIWKH,QGR(XURSHDQZRUGIRU‘GRJ’FI6NWyY*NMWYP2,U F·/LWKhX¶ WHUP‘IRXQGDWLRQSORWRIODQG’ (3$ WDUVPDGHULYHGIURPWHU‘WR PDNH GU\’ (3$ WDUVMD FDXVDWLYH RI WHUV FI 6NW WDU¿¢\DWL LG/DWWRUUHALG21ÈHUUDLG
164
chapter two
,Q D IHZ FDVHV (3$ PD VHHPV WR UHVXOW IURP WKH DQDORJLFDO PRGLILFDWLRQRI,( PHQFIIRUH[DPSOH KLPH ‘EUDQ’ (3$ VNHLGPD ,( VNHLGPHQ *RWK VNDLGDQ ‘WR GLYLGH’ /LWK VNHGÊX VNHVWL ‘WR PDNH WKLQ’ FI /LWK VNLHPX¶ ‘RSHQLQJXVHGWRLQVHUWWKHVKXWWOH’ VNHLGPHQ SMDOP ‘GXVW WKLQ GXVW ILQH IORXU’ (3$ SHOPD 6ODY SROP? ‘IODPH’ *N RCNJ ‘ILQH IORXU’ 6NW SDODOD ‘JURXQG VHVDPXP’ /LWKSHOHQD&‘DVKHV’/DWYS?OQLLG/DWSROOHQ‘GXVWILQHIORXU’ ,QVHYHUDOZRUGVDVHFRQGDU\VXIIL[ LPLVDWWHVWHGFI/LWKLPDVLQ DEVWUDFWYHUEDOVXEVWDQWLYHV /LWKVXN®PDV‘WXUQLQJ’ GDVP¬GDUVP¬‘ZHGGLQJ’ (3$ GDUWhLPGHULYHGIURPGDUN¬ KHOP ‘SRLVRQ JULHI VRUURZ’ (3$ VNDOLPD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK KDOO ‘WURXEOH PLVHU\ SOLJKW VRUURZ’ (3$ VNDOQD FI *PF
VNDOOD]‘WKLQGU\VKDOORZ’ (VKDOORZ ~ [DOOD]‘ZHDNWLUHG’ 0+*KHOKHOOHF NROP¬‘SUHWW\ZLQVRPH’ (3$ NOLPDGHULYDWLYHRI,( NDO 6NW NDO\¢‘KHDOWK\’*N+RPMC NQX‘EHDXWLIXO’ OLVP¬‘VODWHIUDJLOHHDUWKVWRQ\ILHOGFOD\’ (3$ OLWhLPUHODWHG WR OLT ‘ZRRI ZHIW’ VLQJXODUL]HG SOXUDO RI OLN ,( OHLá ‘WR OHDYH WR UHPDLQ’ 6NW ULo¢NWL ‘WR OHDYH’ /DW OLQTXA LG 2+* OKDQ $Q LPSRUWDQW SURGXFWLYH VXIIL[ RI DGMHFWLYHV LV VK¬P ~ ç¬P (3$
L VDPD FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR ,WDOLF DQG &HOWLF VXSHUODWLYHV LQ LVPR &IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV PHQç¬PPHQGVK¬P‘FOHYHULQWHOOLJHQW’½PHQG‘PLQG’ DUV\HVK¬P‘UHDVRQDEOH’ ½DUV\H‘UHDVRQ’ IXTLVK¬P‘QDWXUDO’ ½IXTL‘QDWXUH’
$QRWKHUW\SHRIGHYHUEDWLYHDGMHFWLYH ODWHUH[SDQGHGWRRWKHU
W\SHVRIQRXQV LVUHSUHVHQWHGE\(3$ QDFRQWLQXLQJ,( QRFI6NW GLQ¢‘ERXQG’*NURCTPQX‘VFDWWHUHG’/DWSOQXV‘IXOO’ JMDOP‘URSHODFH’ (3$ VDOSQD 6ODY VROSLWL‘WRVWLFNRXW’/LWK LhVHOSLQ{WL‘WRJHWGLYLGHG’
morphonology and word-formation
165
JMHU¬~JMDQ¬‘EURDGZLGH’ (3$ VDLQD ,( VL‘ORQJODWH’FI 2( VG ‘ORQJ ZLGH’ *RWK VHLÈXV ‘ODWH’ 2,U VWK ‘ORQJ’ /DW VHUXV‘ODWH’ JM¬U ‘VRXS’ ~ *HJ JMDQ¬ ‘PXGEHG DOOXYLXP’ (3$ MDXVQD 6NW QHXW\ ¿‘VRXS’/DWL VLG/LWKMgh^‘ILVKVRXS’ NDUP¬ ‘URFN’ (3$ NDUSQ IXUWKHU UHODWHG WR NDUS¬ LG (3$
NDUS FI /LWK NHUS¸ NL¼SWL ‘WR FXW’ /DWY F®USW ‘WR VKHDU WR FOLS’21KDUIU‘KDUURZ’ OXP‘EOHVVHGKDSS\OXFN\IRUWXQDWH’ (3$ OXEQDDQDGMHFWLYHLQ
QRGHULYHGIURP,( OHXEK‘WRORYHWRZLVK’ WUX ~ WUû ‘EUDLQ’ (3$ WDUXQD 6NW W¢UXoD ‘\RXQJ WHQGHU’ $Y WDXUXQD ‘\RXQJ’ FI DOVR *N VGTJP ‘WHQGHU’ VGTW CUSGPGX NGRVQP +HV W¬U¬ ~ WDQ¬ ‘ZKROH DOO’ (3$ WZDQD WÆRQR ,( WHXi ‘WR VZHOO’ FILQSDUWLFXODU/LWKWY®QWL‘WRULVHWRVZHOO RIZDWHU ’ WY¦QDV‘IORRG’ (3$ QD ZDV WKH EDVLV RQ ZKLFK WKH VHFRQGDU\ VXIIL[ HQD ZDV IRUPHG,WLVFRQQHFWHGZLWK6ODYLFSDUWLFLSOHVLQ HQÙ EUHVK¬U~EUHVK¬Q‘KDLO’ (3$ EUDXVHQD ,( EKUHXV‘WREUHDN’ 2,UEU·XLG0:EUHX‘IUDJLOH’2+*EURVPD‘FUXPE’ NXOS¬U~NXOS¬Q‘LY\FOHPDWLV’ (3$ NXOSHQD /LWKN®OSD‘ORRS’ /DWYFLËSDLG SUHK¬U ~ SUHK¬Q ‘ERVRP ODS DSURQ’ (3$ SUAMHQD ‘IURQW’ RULJLQDOO\ DQ DGMHFWLYH EXLOW RQ WKH EDVLV RI WKH ORFDWLYH *N RTYï´‘HDUO\LQWKHPRUQLQJ’ 2+*IUXRLLG $QRWKHU VHFRQGDU\ VXIIL[ LQD ! L LV IRXQG LQ PDVFXOLQH QRXQV &I 6ODY ÚQÙ/LWKLQD /LWKN¸SLQDV‘KHDSHGXS’6ODY GÙOÊÚQÙ‘PXVW’ DUL ‘EHDU’ (3$ DULQD GHULYHG IURP DU LG 6NW ¤N¿D LG Gk CTMVQXLG EDUL‘VKHSKHUG’ (3$ EDULQD 2+*EDUR‘ IUHH PDQ’ NDOOL‘HDURIJUDLQ’ (3$ NDOVLQD 6ODY NROVÙ‘HDURIJUDLQ’
(3$ QMLVTXLWHSURGXFWLYH GU¬QM¬‘FRUQHOFKHUU\ KHDOWK\VRXQG’ (3$ GUDXQM ,( GUHX ‘WUHH’
166
chapter two
GULQM¬‘EUXVKZRRG’ (3$ GU QM ,( GUHX‘WUHH’ HQM¬‘MXQLSHU\HZ’ (3$ DLJQMUHODWHGWRWKH*HUPDQLFZRUGIRU ‘RDN’ 21HLN2+*HLK UU¬QM¬~UUDQM¬‘URRW RDN’ (3$ ZUDGQM *NTCFKE‘EUDQFK’/DW UG[‘URRW’:JZUDLGG (3$ QM LV XVHG LQ GHQRPLQDWLYHV GHULYHG IURP QRXQV RI ,QGR (XURSHDQRULJLQDVZHOODVIURPORDQZRUGV EHURQM¬ ‘EDUUHQ ZRPDQ KROO\ NLQG RI VHUSHQW’ (3$ EDUQM EDVHG RQ EDUD ‘QDNHG EDUUHQ’ ERUURZHG IURP *PF ED]D] 2+*EDU‘EDUH’21EHUULG ELORQM¬‘WZLJEUDQFK SUHWW\JLUORU\RXQJZRPDQ’ (3$ E OQM DGHULYDWLYHRI E OD *NHWNQP‘OHDI’ JDERQM¬‘HDJOH’ (3$ JDEQMUHODWHGWRVKNDE¬LG PLVKNRQM¬PXVKNRQM¬‘PLGJHJQDW’GHULYHGIURP PXVKN¬ZKLFK LVERUURZHGIURP/DWPXVFD‘IO\’ ,QRQHZRUGZHDOVRILQG DQM G¬OOLQM¬G¬OO¬QM¬‘MXQLSHU’ (3$ GDLVODQMUHODWHGWRGHOO‘VLQHZ’ GDLVO
7KH ROG ,QGR(XURSHDQ SUHVHQW DFWLYH SDUWLFLSOH VXIIL[ QWL FDQEHGHWHFWHGLQVHYHUDO$OEDQLDQQRXQV
EDQ¬‘GZHOOLQJ’ (3$ EDQWLGHULYHGIURPE¬M‘WRPDNHWRGR’ U¬QG¬~UDQG¬‘KHDY\’ (3$ UDXQWLGHULYHGIURPWKHYHUEDOVWHP RIDRUUDVK¬ UDXVD‘WRIDOO’ WKLQG‘EHDNQLSSOH’ (3$ LQWL ,( L‘WRVKDUSHQ’ 6NWyyWL ‘WRZKHWWRVKDUSHQ’$UPVRZU‘VKDUS NQLIH’ 6HYHUDOQRXQVDUHIRUPHGZLWK(3$ XQN EDOOXQJ¬ ‘EXPS VZHOOLQJ’ (3$ EDOXQN GHULYHG IURP EDOO¬ ‘IRUHKHDG’ (3$ EDO 6NWEKODLG23UXVEDOORLG VKW¬OOXQJ¬‘IORFNRIZRRO’ (3$ VWHOXQNGHULYHGIURPVKWMHOO‘WR WKURZ’ (3$ VWHOD *NUVGNNY‘WRSXWWRVHW’2+*VWHOOHQ ‘WRSXW’23UXVVWDOOW‘WRVWDQG’
morphonology and word-formation
167
VKWUXQJ¬ ‘PLONLQJ HQFORVXUH’ (3$ VW H UXQN GHULYHG IURP VKWULM ‘WR VSUHDG WR VWUHWFK’ (3$ VWULQMD 6NW VWQdWL ‘WR VSUHDG WR VFDWWHU’ *N UVQTPWOK ‘WR VSUHDG WR VWUHWFK’ /DW VWHUQALG 6XIIL[HVLQ
7KHSURGXFWLYH3URWR$OEDQLDQVXIIL[ MD~ MJRHVEDFNWR ,( R FI 6NW J¢Y\D ‘ERYLQH’ *N FK`QX ‘KHDYHQO\ JORULRXV’ 6ODY
RYÚ¨Ú‘EHORQJLQJWRWKHVKHHS’
HQM¬~êM¬‘GDLU\JRDW’ (3$ DJQM *NCOPQX‘ODPE’/DWDJQXV LG JMD]¬ ‘ULYHUVLGH IRUHVW’ (3$ VHGMD D GHULYDWLYH RI ,( VHG ‘WR VLWWREHVHWWOHG’FI6ODY VDGÙ‘JDUGHQJURYH’ NHT‘EDGHYLO’ (3$ NDNMD *NMCMQX‘EDG’ PHV¬‘VNLQ RIRQLRQ PLONVNLQILOP’ (3$ PDWhMGHULYHGIURP PDN¬ ‘JOXH VFXP VNLQ RQ WKH PLON RU RWKHU OLTXLGV ’ (3$
PDN /LWK PDN©QWL ‘WR ZDON WKURXJK D VZDPS’ 6ODY PRNUÙ ‘ZHW’ PRNQ_WL‘WREHFRPHZHW’ WHVK¬ ‘VSHFN RI GXVW OLWWOH VSOLQWHU’ (3$ WDNVM ,( WHV 6NW WDN¿DWL‘WRFDUSHQWHUWRFXW’/DWWH[A‘WRZHDYH’/LWKWDhØWL‘WR KHZ’ YHU]¬ ‘JLOO EUDQFKLD’ (3$ ZDUGM /LWK YDUO| ‘IURJ’ YDUG| /DWYYUGHLG YLVH ‘SODFH’ (3$ ZWVM ,( ÆHL *N QKMKC ‘GZHOOLQJ KRXVH’
3UHIL[DWLRQ 3UHIL[HV DUH ZLGHO\ XVHG LQ $OEDQLDQ ZRUGIRUPDWLRQ HVSH FLDOO\LQWKHGHULYDWLRQRIYHUEV+LVWRULFDOO\LQ3URWR$OEDQLDQSUHIL[HV ZHUH VWLOO VHSDUDWH FOLWLFV ZKLFK V\QWDFWLFDOO\ SUHFHGHG QRXQV 7KH\ JUDPPDWLFDOL]HG DW D ODWHU VWDJH DV D UHVXOW RI XQLYHUEDWLRQ DQG RI FKDQJHVLQWKHQDWXUHRI$OEDQLDQVWUHVV /LWHUDWXUH ;+89$1,Ç$%(- 3DUDVKW SDVVLP &$0$- $OE :RUWE 25(/ /LQJXLVWLFD ;;,9 SUHIL[ ND ~ JD SUHIL[ DZD +$03)HVWVFKU.QREORFK SUHIL[]
168
chapter two
9HUEDO SUHIL[ DPEL FRQWLQXHV ,( DPEKL ‘DURXQG RQ ERWK VLGHV’ *NCOHK*DXODPELDQGWKHOLNH PEDWK‘WRSXWRQ VKRHV ’ (3$ DPE L DXWVD ,( DX~ RXLG $UPDJDQLP‘WRSXWRQ FORWKHV ’/LWKDXQ¸DWL6ODY XWL PEHV‘WRUHPDLQWRVWD\’ (3$ DPE L HWMD GHULYHG IURP MHV‘WR UHPDLQ’ (3$ HWMDDGHQRPLQDWLYHRIMHW¬‘OLIH’ (3$ HWD WKHLVRODWHGJURXSRI*NGVGQX‘WUXHUHDO’G VC C NJSJ`C ICSC +HV GVC\Y‘WRWHVW’ PE¬VKWHW‘WRVWDQGWRSURS’ (3$ DPEKLVWDWDEDVHGRQ VWDWD ,( VWiWRV‘VWDQGLQJ’FI6NWVWKLW¢*NUVCVQXLG/DWVWDWXV LG PEOHGK‘WRJDWKHUWRFROOHFW’ (3$ DPELOHG]D *NNGIYLG/DW OHJA‘WRUHDG’ ,( OH½‘WRJDWKHU’ PE\OO ‘WR VKXW WR IDVWHQ’ (3$ DPELZHOD RULJLQDOO\ ‘WR HQFLUFOH’ 6NW YDODWL ‘WR WXUQ’ *N GK NGY ‘WR UROO WLJKW XS WR FORVH’2,UILOOLG‘WREHQG’ PE\V ‘WR VWUDQJOH WR GURZQ WR NLOO’ (3$ DPELZWMD 6NW Y\¢WKDWH‘WRVZD\WRURFN’*RWKZLÈRQ‘WRSRXU’
7KH YHUEDO SUHIL[ HQ FRQWLQXHV ,( HQ L ‘LQ’ *N GP /DW LQ *RWKLQ
PEDM‘WRKROGWRFDUU\’ (3$FDXVDWLYH HQEDUQMD ,( EKHU‘WR EHDU’ QGDM~QGDˆM‘WRGLYLGHWRVHSDUDWH’ (3$ HQGDQMD 6NWG¢\DWHLG GdWL‘WRFXWWRGLYLGH’*NFCKQOCK‘WRGLYLGH’ QGH] ‘WR VHW DOLJKW WR LJQLWH’ (3$ HQGDGÊMD FDXVDWLYH ,( GKRÞKHA ,( GKHÞK‘WREXUQ’ QJDM‘WRUXQ’ (3$ HQJDQMD UHGXSOLFDWHG6NWM¢KWL‘WROHDYHWR DEDQGRQ’2+*JQJQ‘WRJR’ QJUH ‘WR OLIW WR UDLVH’ (3$ HQJUDGD /DW JUDGLRU ‘WR VWHS WR ZDON’ *RWK DFF JULG ‘VWHS’ 2,U LQJUHQQ ‘WR SXUVXH’ 6ODY
JU?G_ JU?VWL‘WRZDON’ QJXV‘WRXUJHWRIRUFH’ (3$ HQNXWMD /LWKN¢XWL‘WRVWULNH’6ODY
NRYDWL‘WRIRUJH’/DWF GA‘WRVWULNH’2+*KRXZDQLG QJMLV ‘WR VWLFN WR’ (3$ HQJOHLWMD /LWK JOLHM¸ JOLWL ‘WR VPHDU’ JOLW¸V‘VWLFN\’*NINQKQX‘VWLFN\VWXII’
morphonology and word-formation
169
7KHQRPLQDOSUHIL[ NDFRQWLQXHV,( NRP‘QHDUE\ZLWK’ /DW
FXP 6ODY NÙ ,Q 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LW GHYHORSHG WZR PDLQ SKRQHWLF YDULDQWV $OEN ¬ ~ ND&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV NDçHO ‘ODPH’ (3$ NDhWhDOD GHULYHG IURP çDO¬ ‘ODPH’ (3$
hWhDOD *NUMQNKQX‘FURRNHG’/DWVFHOXV NDOHVK ‘KDLU\’ (3$ NDODLVD GHULYHG IURP OHVK ‘ZRRO IOHHFH KDLU’ (3$ ODLhD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK WKH %DOWR6ODYLF ZRUG IRU ‘IROLDJH’ /LWK OD&hNDV ‘OHDI’ /DWY OD&VND ‘OHDI RQ D OLQHQ VWDON VWDON’6ODY OLVWÙ‘OHDI’ N¬QG¬ ~ NDQG¬ ‘SOHDVXUH DSSHWLWH’ (3$ NDDQW GHULYHG IURP ¬QG¬~DQG¬‘DSSHWLWHGHVLUHZLVK’ (3$ DQWFI*NCPVCK CPGOQKCPVCX RPQCX+HV NOODS¬‘SXGGOH’ (3$ NDODSIXUWKHUUHODWHGWROODS‘WRODSXS’ RI DQLPDOV (3$ ODSD *NNCRVY‘WRJXOSWRGULQNJUHHGLO\’ /LWKODS©QWL‘WRVZDOORZIRRG’ RISLJV 6ODY ORSDWL‘WRHDWXS’ NU¬QG ~ NUDQGH‘IROLDJH EUXVKZRRG OHDYHV XVHG DV IRGGHU FKLSV EUDQFK ZLWKRXW OHDYHV’ (3$ NDUDQGD D SUHIL[ IRUPDWLRQ FRQQHFWHGZLWK,( UHQGK‘WRWHDU DVXQGHU ’DQGLQSDUWLFXODU ZLWK2+*ULQGDULQWD‘ULQG’2(ULQGHLG 2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG LQ PDQ\ ZRUGV ND \LHOGHG J ¬ DQG JD ZLWK DQ XQH[SODLQHG YRLFLQJ RI WKH LQLWLDO N 6RPHWLPHV ERWK YDULDQWV RI WKH SUHIL[FRH[LVWLQRQHZRUG&IWKHIROORZLQJZRUGV JDODPVK ‘ODPH SHUVRQ’ (3$ JDOHPHVMD GHULYHG IURP O¬PVK ~ ODPVK ‘EDOO RI ZRRO WKUHDG JOREH RI HDUWK SRRO VSHOOHW’ /DWY OHPHVLV ‘VKDUS HGJH RI WKH SORXJK’ 6ODY OHPHhÚ ‘SORXJKVKDUH’ JGKH~JGKê ‘JQDUONQRW’ (3$ JDGDLQD 6NWG¢\DWH‘WRGLYLGH’ *NFCKQOCKLG J¬VKWDOO¬ N¬VKWDOO¬ ‘VSOLQW SLHFH RI ZRRG’ (3$ JDVWDOQ ,( VWHO J¬WKHS‘JDUGHQ VFLVVRUV FODZ QLSSHU RI D VFRUSLRQ ’ (3$ JD WVDLSD WKHS ‘SHDN SRLQW FRJ WRRWK’ (3$ WVDLSD 6NW y©SD ‘WDLOSHQLV’/DWFLSSXV‘SROH’ JOHS¬‘PDWWHUIURPWKHH\HVUKHXP’ (3$ NDODLSGHULYHGIURP ,( OHLS‘WRVPHDUZLWKIDW’ JUHSJ¬UMHS¬‘KRRNILVKKRRN’ (3$ JDUHSDUHODWHGWRUMHS‘WR VWULSRII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’ (3$ UHSD ,( UHS *N
170
chapter two
GTGRVQOCK‘WRHDW’/DWUDSLA‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’/LWKU{SWL‘WR JUDVS’ JORT‘PDWWHUIURPWKHH\HVUKHXPWHVWLV’ (3$ NDOXNMDWR,(
OHXN‘WRVKLQH VKLQLQJZKLWH’ 7KHVDPH ND~ JDLVDOVRXVHGLQ PRVWO\GHQRPLQDWLYH YHUEV JGKHQG ‘WR SODQH’ (3$ JDGDLQWD GHULYHG IURP JGKH ~ JGKê ‘JQDUO NQRW’ (3$ JDGDLQD 6NW G¢\DWH ‘WR GLYLGH’ *N FCKQOCKLG JGKLM~JGKîM‘WRVWD\DZDNHDWQLJKW’ (3$ JDGHLQMD ,( GLQR ~ GHLQR‘GD\’ JMDM‘WRUHVHPEOHWREHOLNH WRVXLWWREHFRPH WRVHHP WRKDSSHQ’ (3$ JDODEQMDEDVHGRQ ODE /LWKO¦EDV‘JRRG’/DWYODEV LG N¬T\U‘WRORRNWRREVHUYH’ NDNHZLUDGHULYHGIURPT\U‘WRORRN’ (3$ NHZLUD *N MQGY ‘WR QRWH’ /DW FDYHA ‘WR EH DZDUH’ *RWKKDXVMDQ‘WRKHDU’ ,QVRPHFDVHV ZKHUHRULJLQDOH[SUHVVLYLW\FDQEHVXVSHFWHG WKHSUHIL[
NDGHYHORSHGDQRQHW\PRORJLFDOHSHQWKHWLFU N¬UELVKW‘VDFUXPVDFUDOERQH’ (3$ NDUE VWDGHULYHGIURPELVKW ‘WDLO’ (3$ E VWD ,( EK ‘WRJURZ’ N¬UOHVK ‘WR VWDQG RQ HQG RI KDLU ’ NDUODLVD GHULYHG IURP OHVK ‘KDLU’ N¬UW\O‘WRILOOXSWRVDWLDWH’ (3$ NDUW OD /LWKWgODV‘PDQ\’*N VWNQX‘FRUQ’ N¬UYHVKHP‘WRJULQWRSXOOIDFHV’ (3$ NDUZHVMDGHULYHGIURP YHVK‘WRSXWRQ’
7KH SUHIL[ DZD FRQWLQXHV ,( RÆR ~ DÆR FI 6NW ¢YD
‘RXW’ 6ODY X ,Q 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LW QRUPDOO\ DSSHDUV LQ YHUEV ,W GHYHORSHGLQWR$OEYH[FHSWEHIRUHOZKHUHLW\LHOGVI IOH~IOê ‘WRVOHHS’ (3$ DZDOHMD 6ODY OpM_ OpMDWL‘WRGR]HWR VOXPEHU’ YGHV ‘WR GLH’ (3$ DZDWDNMD WR WHá ‘WR UXQ WR IORZ’ 2,U WHFKLP‘WRIOHH’/LWKWHN¸WHN{WL‘WRUXQ’6ODY WHN_ WHNWL‘WR IORZWRUXQ’
morphonology and word-formation
171
Y¬VKWMHOO‘WRZUDS’ (3$ DZDVWHODGHULYHGIURPVKWMHOO‘WRWKURZ’ (3$ VWHOD *NUVGNNY‘WRSXWWRVHW’2+*VWHOOHQ‘WRSXW’ 23UXVVWDOOW‘WRVWDQG’ YUDS‘WRUXQWRKDVWH’ (3$ DZDUDSDGHULYHGIURPUMHS‘WRVWULS RII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’ YUDV‘WRNLOO’ (3$ DZDUDXWMD ,( UHX‘WRWHDUWRGHVWUR\’ 6NW UXW¢‘EURNHQ’/DWUXA‘WRIDOOGRZQWRUXVKGRZQ’ 7KHVDPHSUHIL[LVDWWHVWHGLQVHYHUDOGHYHUEDWLYHQRXQV IOHJ¬‘VSOLQWHU’ (3$ DZDODJ ,( OHJK‘WROLH’FI*NNQZQX ‘DPEXVK’ IOHW¬‘ZLQJOHDI’ (3$ DZDOHNWDGHULYHGIURP,( OHN‘WRIO\’ /LWKOHNL¸O|NWL/DWYOªNW2+*OHFNHQ‘WRMXPSWRNLFN’ IOXJ¬ ‘VKLQJOH’ (3$ DZDOXJD ,( OHX½ FI 6NW UXM¢WL ‘WR EUHDN’/DWO JHA‘WRPRXUQWRGHSORUH’ Y¬VKWLU¬‘KDUGGLIILFXOWEDGHYLO’ (3$ DZDVWLUDUHODWHGWRVKWLH ‘WRSRXULQWRSXWLQWRWKURZ’ (3$ VWHUDFI6NWVWodWL‘WR VSUHDG WR VFDWWHU’ *N UVQTPWOK ‘WR VWUHWFK WR VSUHDG’ /DW VWHUQA‘WRVSUHDG’6ODY VWÚU_ VWHUWLLG YU¬QG¬ ‘GUL]]OH’ (3$ DZDUHQWD GHULYHG IURP UHQG ‘WR UXQ WR KXUU\’ (3$ UHQWD *RWKULQQDQ‘WRUXQ’21ULQQDLG YU¬U¬W~YUDQ¬W‘FORXG\’ (3$ DZDUHQDEDVHGRQUH‘FORXG’ YUXJ‘UXVWPLOGHZEOLJKW’ (3$ DZDUXJD $YUDRJQD‘EXWWHU’ 21UM·PL‘FUHDP’
7KH,QGR(XURSHDQDGYHUEV SHUL 6NWS¢UL*NRGTK DQG SUR
6NW SU¢ ‘IRUZDUG’ 2,U UR *RWK IUD GHYHORSHG LQWR (3$ SHU DQG
SUDODWHUPHUJLQJLQWR$OES¬U,QVRPHFDVHVZHFDQQRWH[FOXGHWKH IDFWWKDW/DWSHUDQGSUAWKDWPD\DOVRKDYHWDNHQSDUWLQWKHIRUPDWLRQ RI $OE S¬U 7KH ODWWHU LV TXLWH SURGXFWLYH DQG QRUPDOO\ DSSHDUV LQ YHUEV S¬UJMRM ‘WR SU\ WR SHHS WR VS\’ (3$ SHUMJQMD GHULYHG IURP JMXDM~JMXHM‘WRKXQW’ (3$ MJQMDFI2+*MDJAQ‘WRKXQW’ S¬UNXO‘WREHQG’ (3$ SHUNXOD ,( áHO‘WRWXUQ’ S¬UPMHUU ‘WR XULQDWH’ (3$ SHUPHG]UD ,( PHL½K LG 6NW P©KDWL*NQOGKZY/DWPHLA21PJD S¬USXVK ‘WR SRNH WR VWLU XS’ (3$ SHUS U XVD GHULYHG IURP SUXVK‘KRWDVKHV’
172
chapter two
S¬UTHOO‘WRGHULGHWRPRFN’ (3$ SHUNHODGHULYHGIURPTHOO‘WR KDOWWRKROGXSWRFDUU\’ (3$ NHOD 6NWNDO¢\DWL‘WRLPSHO’ *NMGNQOCK‘WRGULYHRQ’ S¬UYMHO ‘WR IOLQJ RXW WR OHW IO\ WR WXUQ RYHU WR UROO XS WR FXW WKH IOHHFH RQ D VKHHS’V EHOO\’ (3$ SHUZHOD GHULYHG IURP YMHO ‘WRSOXFN IUXLW WRYLQWDJH’ (3$ ZHOD *NGKNY‘WRVKXWLQ WRSUHVV’/LWKVXYDOØWL‘WRKDUYHVWWRUHDS’ 7KHSUHIL[S¬ULVRFFDVLRQDOO\XVHGWRIRUPDGYHUEV S¬UPEL ‘RYHU’ (3$ SHUDPEL ZLWK WKH ILUVW HOHPHQW LGHQWLFDO ZLWKS¬UDQGWKHVHFRQGUHSUHVHQWLQJ(3$ DPEL S¬USMHW¬‘ULVLQJXSKLOOULVHVORSH’ (3$ SUDSHWD *NRTQRGVJX ‘SURPLQHQW’ RTQRGVQOCK‘WR IO\ IRUZDUGV’ DQG IXUWKHU WR 6NW S¢WDWL‘WRIO\WRVRDU’*NRGVQOCK‘WRIO\’ ,QDQXPEHURIFDVHVS¬UZDVSKRQHWLFDOO\WUDQVIRUPHGLQWRU U ¬ U¬SMHW¬‘VWHHS’~S¬USMHW¬‘ULVLQJXSKLOO’ U¬SRVK‘EHORZXQGHUQHDWK’~ S¬USRVKLG
,QDOLPLWHGQXPEHURIQRXQV(3$ WVD!WK ¬ LVDWWHVWHG,WV
VRXUFHLV,( RP 6ODY VÙQ
WK¬QJMLOO ‘KRW DVKHV’ (3$ WV D DQJLOD /LWK DQJO®V LG 23UXV DQJOLVLG6ODY _JOÚLG6NW¢JUDLG WKMHVKW¬‘VLPSOHHDV\’ (3$ WV D HNVWDEDVHGRQ HNVWD!MDVKW¬ ‘RXWVLGH’ WKQHJ¬O ‘DQW’ (3$ WV D DQJXO /DW DQJXLV ‘VQDNH’ /LWK DQJ®V LG 2+* DQJDU ‘NLQG RI PDJJRW’ HQJLULQH ‘ODUYD’ /LWK DQNhWLUæ~‘PDJJRW’ WKXS¬U‘WZLJURG’ (3$ WV D XSHUD‘XSSHU’ 2+*REDURLG/DW VXSHULG
,( GLV SUHVHUYHG LQ /DW GLV *RWK GLV \LHOGHG (3$ GLV !
GLh +DYLQJ ORVW LWV XQVWUHVVHG YRZHO Gh ! Wh ! $OE V EHIRUH XQYRLFHGSKRQHPHV ~ ] EHIRUHWKHYRLFHG (3$ GLVLVPDLQO\FRQ QHFWHGZLWKWKHIRUPDWLRQRIYHUEV
morphonology and word-formation
173
VTDT ‘WR PDNH ZHDN’ (3$ GLVNHNMD /LWK N{NRV ‘VZLQJ’ /DWY NG HNXW‘WRVZLQJ’ VWHSHP‘WREHVORZWRVWRS’ (3$ GLVWDSD 21ÈHIMD‘WRVWDPSWR UDP’ ]EHM‘WRPDNHSDOH’ (3$ GLVEDQMD 6NWEKdWL‘WRVKLQH’2,UE¢Q ‘ZKLWH’ ]GUDM‘WRVZHOOWRPDNHVZHOO’ (3$ GLVG H UDQMD 6NWGodWL‘WR EXUVW’*NFGTY‘WRVNLQWRIOD\’ ]YMHUGK‘WRZHDQ’ (3$ GLVYHUG]D /LWKYHUÊL¸YH¼ÊWL‘WRODFHWR WLH’/DWYYU]W‘WRWXUQ’6ODY YHU]WL‘WRELQG’ +RZHYHUWKHSUHIL[ GLVLVDOVRXVHGLQQRPLQDOIRUPDWLRQ ]JDUE¬ ‘KROORZ LQ D WUHH ’ (3$ GLVJDUE GHULYHG IURP JDUE¬ ‘QRWFK QLFN’ (3$ JDUE 2,U JHUEDFK ‘ZULQNOHG’ 21 NRUSQD ‘WR JHW ZULQNOHG’ 23UXV JDUELV ‘PRXQWDLQ’ 6ODY
JÙUEÙ‘KXPS’ ]JDY¬U ‘KROH’ (3$ GLVJDZLU ,( JHXU JRXU ‘EHQW FURRNHG’ ]JULS‘VLGHHGJHULP’ (3$ GLVJULSD 2+*NUDSIR‘KRRN’21 NUDSSU‘QDUURZ’ ]JMHGK¬‘R[\RNH’ (3$ GLVJDGUHODWHGWRJMHGK‘FDWWOH’ ]YHUN ‘RFFLSXW’ GLVZDUND EDVHG RQ YMHUU ‘WR KDQJ’ (3$
ZHUD *N C GKTY ‘WR UDLVH XS’ /LWK YHUL¸ Y©UWL ‘WR ZHLJK’ VYHUL¸VYH¼WL‘WRRSHQWRWKUHDG’
,( H½KV DV DQ DGYHUE EHFDPH (3$ LWV ! LWK ‘EHKLQG’
+RZHYHU DV D SUHYHUE LWV ORVW WKH ILUVW HOHPHQW RI LWV DIIULFDWH DQG EHFDPH LV ! Lh ! VK 7KLV SUHIL[ LV RQH RI WKH PRVW SURGXFWLYH LQ $OEDQLDQ&IH[DPSOHVRIVKLQYHUEV VKNHS VKNUHS ‘WR UHVHPEOH’ (3$ LVNUHSD ‘ERG\’ 6NW NS ‘VKDSH EHDXWLIXO DSSHDUDQFH’ /DW FRUSXV ‘ERG\’ 2+* KUI ‘ERG\ODS’ VKNPHV ‘WR FOLS WR SUXQH EXVKHV WUHHV ’ (3$ LVNDPHWM GHULYHGIURPNPHV¬‘ELOOKRRNVLFNOH’ VKSLH ‘WR EULQJ DZD\’ LVEHUD GHULYHG IURP ELH ‘WR EULQJ WR FDUU\’ VKSLK ~ VKSLI ‘WR VODQGHU WR FDOXPQLDWH’ (3$ LVSHLNVND 2+* IHKDQ‘WRKDWH’/LWKSHLNL¸SH&NWL‘WREODPH’
174
chapter two
VKSRUU‘WRPRYHDZD\WRGULYHDZD\’ (3$ SUD 6NWSSDUWL‘WR EULQJRYHUWRVDYH’*NRGTCYRGKTY‘WRSHQHWUDWH’ VKTXDM~VKTXHM‘WRGLVFHUQWRVWUHVVWROHDUQ’ (3$ LVNOXVQMD GHULYHG IURP TXDM ~ TXHM ‘WR FDOO WR JLYH D QDPH’ (3$
NOXVQMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH EDVHG RQ ,( OHÆRV ‘JORU\ ZRUG’ 6NWyU¢YDV*NMNGQX6ODY VORYR 7KHVDPHSUHIL[LVDWWHVWHGLQQXPHURXVQRXQV VKNDUGK¬‘GRJFKDLQ ORQJVWLFNDWWDFKHGWRDGRJ’VQHFNWRSUHYHQW LW IURP ELWLQJ LWV PDVWHU’ (3$ LVJDUG FRQQHFWHG ZLWK JDUGK¬‘IHQFH’ VKNOHS¬‘PDWWHUIURPWKHH\HVUKHXP’ (3$ LVJDODLSGHULYHG IURPJOHS¬LG (3$ JDODLS ,( OHLS‘WRVPHDUZLWKIDW’ VKNUXPE‘EODFNDVKHVDQ\WKLQJEXUQHGWRDVKHV’ (3$ LVNUXPD ,( NUHPDWWHVWHGLQ/DWFUHPA‘WREXUQ’ VKSDUGK‘RDN’ (3$ LVSDUG]D 21IRUNU‘VWLFNSROH’FRQWLQXLQJ ,( SHU½ VKSDW‘SUHFLSLFHPRXQWDLQIRUHVW’ (3$ LVSDWD 6NWS¢WDWL‘WRIO\ WRVRDU’*NRKRVY‘WRIDOO’
$ IHZ $OEDQLDQ ZRUGV SUHVHUYH WKH SULYDWLYH SUHIL[ D ,(
6NWD*NC/DWLQ
DPXOO ‘VWDJQDQW RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ DPXOZD /LWK PXËY^ ‘VLOW PDUVK’P¸OWL‘WRJHWGLUW\’ HJM¬OO ‘RQ DQ HPSW\ VWRPDFK’ (3$ DVDOZD JMHOO ‘IRRG’ JMDOO¬ ‘DOLYH’ HV¬OO ‘RQ DQ HPSW\ VWRPDFK’ (3$ DWhLOQD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK VLOO¬ ‘EUHDNIDVW’
1XPHURXV SUHIL[HV LQ $OEDQLDQ DUH RI H[SUHVVLYH RULJLQ
7KHLUHW\PRORJLHVDUHXQFHUWDLQ+HUHRQO\VRPHRIWKRVHSUHIL[HVDUH DGGXFHG NDFD GUH‘GHHU’¾NDFDGUH~NDFDGUê ‘VWDJEHHWOHJUDVVKRSSHU’ JMHO‘URRVWHU’¾UULNDFDJMHO‘WREUDJ’ PLW¬ ] ‘URH’¾NDFDPLW‘VWDJ’
morphonology and word-formation
UURM‘WROLYHWRVWD\’¾NDFDUURM‘WRFOLPEWRFODPEHU’ UUXP‘PDL]HFREVWULSSHGRIFRUQV’¾NDFDUUXP‘FRUQFRE’ NDOD~ NDOL KXPE‘WROHDYHWRORRVHWRVSRLO’¾NDOLKXP‘GRZQZDUGV’ PDM‘WRIHHG’¾NDODPDQ‘FKLOG WLOOWKHDJHRI ’ PHQG‘PLQG’¾NDODPHQG‘WRFRQIXVH’ TDI¬‘QHFN’¾NDODTDI¬‘SLJJ\EDFN’ YDU‘WRKDQJ’¾NDOLYDUH‘WULFNOLQJGRZQ’ YHVK‘JUDSH’¾NDODYHVKLG NDUUD ELVKW‘WDLO’¾NDUUDELVKW‘HDUZLJ’ YHVK‘JUDSH’¾NDUUDYHVK‘VWLFN’ OD~ O¬ NXT‘UHG’¾ODNXT‘UHG RIHDUWK ’ WUHGK‘WRFDVWUDWH’¾ODWUHGK‘XQFDVWUDWHGUDP’ EDUGK¬‘ZKLWH’¾OEDUGK‘WRPDNHZKLWH’ EDUN‘EHOO\’¾O¬EDUNH‘G\VHQWHU\’ I\W‘WKURDWJXOOHW’¾O¬I\W‘SLSHWXEH’ PD]¬‘PLONVNLQ’¾O¬PD]¬‘WKLQVNLQVKHOO’ P¬ N¬PE¬~ NDPE¬‘OHJIRRW’¾P¬N¬PE~ P¬NDPE‘WRVHWXS’ NU\H‘KHDG’¾P¬NUHV¬‘WRPEVWRQH’ VKTHUU¬‘KHLIHU’¾P¬VKTHUU¬LG NHT‘EDG’¾PNHTHP‘WRJHWZRUVH’ SLOL NRU¬‘FUXVWEDUN’¾SLOLNXUL‘EDUHQDNHG’ SL]J¬‘ZLQGLQVWUXPHQW’¾SLOLSL]J¬‘NLQGRISLSH’ YHYRH‘HJJ’¾SLOLYHV¬SLOLYRHV¬‘GUDJRQIO\’
&IWKHH[SUHVVLYHSUHIL[ ODLQ6ODYLF
175
176
chapter two
VKDUD QGXN‘WRSOXFNRXW’¾VKDUDQGXN‘WRSLQFK’ VK¬Q GULW¬‘OLJKW’¾VK¬QGULW‘WRVKLQH’ JMDK‘KXQWFKDVH’¾VK¬QJMHW¬‘EHVWSDUWRIKXQWLQJWURSKLHV’ W¬ DP¬‘VRXUFHULYHUEHG’¾WDP¬‘ZDWHUVRXUFH’ EDQ¬‘GZHOOLQJ’¾W¬EDQ¬‘VKHSKHUG’VKXW’ ¬PE¬O~ DPE¬O‘VZHHW’¾W¬PE¬O~ WDPE¬O‘VZHHWQHVV’ O¬QG¬~ODQG¬‘ZRRGWLPEHUPDWHULDO’¾WODQG¬U‘EXQGOH’ W¬U~ WHU IXUN¬‘IRUN’¾W¬UIXUN‘SLWFKIRUN’ KHT‘WRSXOOWRGUDZ’¾W¬UKHTLG SORW¬‘IXOO’¾WHUSORW¬‘ZLQQRZLQJVKRYHO’ SRVKW¬‘GRZQEHORZ’¾W¬USRVKW¬‘VORSH’ )RU VRPH RI WKH DERYH SUHIL[HV HW\PRORJLFDO FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV FDQ EH WHQWDWLYHO\ VXJJHVWHG $OE O¬ PD\ ILQG D SDUDOOHO LQ 6ODY OD $OE W¬ PD\EHFRPSDUHGZLWK6NWWDW
&RPSRXQGV $QFLHQW ,QGR(XURSHDQ FRPSRXQGV DUH LQ VRPH FDVHV SUHVHUYHG LQ $OEDQLDQ HYHQ WKRXJK WKH\ DUH QR ORQJHU SHUFHLYHG DV VXFK3URWR$OEDQLDQFRPSRXQGVKDYHDOVRDGGHGWRWKHYRFDEXODU\WKDW DOVREHFDPHOHVVWUDQVSDUHQW /LWHUDWXUH &$0$-$OE:RUWE OREL ZfBalk XXIII/1 67, 7273.
7KH IROORZLQJ FRPSRXQGV DUH LQKHULWHG IURP ,QGR(XURSHDQ
DQGRU3URWR$OEDQLDQ
E¬UU\O ‘HOERZ IRUHDUP’ (3$ EAUHL DO H Q WKH VHFRQG FRPSRQHQWLVDWWHVWHGLQOO¬U¬~ OODQ¬‘DUP’
morphonology and word-formation
177
WK¬QXN¬O ‘GRJEHUU\’ WK¬QXE¬O (3$ WVXQXDEAOD ‘GRJ’V DSSOH’ 'DF κινου´βοιλα ‘SODQW %ULRQLD DOED’ 'LRVF DQG/LWKh·QREXRODV‘GRJ’VSXPSNLQ’ Y¬OOD‘EURWKHU’ (3$ VZHODXGFRPSRVLWHRISURQRPLQDO,( VÆH DQG ODXG ,( OHXGK 2+*OLXW‘SHRSOH’6ODY OMXGÙLG \OEHU ‘UDLQERZ’ (3$ DO H Q EKAUD ‘UDLQERZ’ ‘FXUYH’ D PLUURUUHIOHFWLRQRI(3$ EKAUHLXO H Q!E¬UU\O ]RW‘ORUGPDVWHUJRG’ (3$ Z L WVSDWL 6NWYLySDWL‘ORUGRIWKH KRXVH’
9DULRXV VWUXFWXUDO DQG VHPDQWLF W\SHV RI FRPSRXQGV DUH DWWHVWHGLQPRGHUQ$OEDQLDQ$OORIWKHPDUHUHFHQWLQQRYDWLRQV GLW¬]L‘XQOXFN\’½GLW¬‘GD\’]L‘EODFN’ GRU¬]DQ¬‘SOHGJH’½GRU¬‘KDQG’]DQ¬‘WDNHQ’ GUHGKDOHVK‘VSLQGOH’½GUHGK‘WRWXUQ’OHVK‘ZRRO’ JRM¬OLGKQL‘ZROI’½JRM¬‘PRXWK’OLGKXQ‘ERXQG’ JXQ¬GKLU¬ ‘FORDN PDGH RI JRDW ZRRO’ ½ JXQ¬ ‘FORDN’ GKLU¬ ‘RI JRDW’ JM\VDPL‘EDW’½JM\V¬‘KDOI’PL‘PRXVH’ PDQDIHUU¬‘NLQGRIFKHUU\’½PDQ‘EHUU\’IHUU¬‘WKRUQ’
0253+2/2*< 9HUE 9HUEVWHPV 7KH$OEDQLDQYHUEV\VWHPLVIRXQGHGXSRQWKHRSSRVLWLRQRIWZR
PDLQ VWHPV SUHVHQW DQG DRULVW 7KHUH LV DOVR D WKLUG VWHP WKDW RI WKH LPSHUIHFWDQGSOSUHVHQW+LVWRULFDOO\WKLVVWHPLVFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKDW RIWKHSUHVHQWWKRXJKGLVSOD\LQJH LXPODXW
3UHVHQWVWHPV 7KH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SUHVHQW VWHPV GLUHFWO\ UHIOHFW WKH ,QGR
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´ *6.$ &;/9,,, GHULYHV VJ SUHV _ LQ 6ODYLF IURP LQMXQFWLYH
RP 6&+0,'%DOW GLVDJUHHVZLWK 0(,//(7 0(,')OH[LRQ
179
morphology
SDVVLP VHFRQGDU\ HQGLQJV LQ &HOWLF FRQMXQFW SUHVHQW ÇABEJ +\UMH &,02&+2:6., 67,( VWHPVLQ QM +$03$QF,( VXSSRUWV 0(,//(7 :$7.,16 *HVFKLFKWH &HOWLF SUHVHQW %$'(5 %6/ /;;, RQ 7RFK $ VJ SUHV DP RP .257/$1'7 /LQJXD ;/,; 6ODY _ IURP SHUIHFWLYH D IROORZHG E\ P 0$11 +LVW *U 25(/ /LQJY LVVO ,, =I%DON;;,,
&ODVV , DWKHPDWLF URRW VWHPV PLFRQMXJDWLRQ 7KLV FODVV LV
YHU\VPDOODQGDUFKDLF,WLQFOXGHVWKHIROORZLQJYHUEV MDP‘WREH’NDP ‘WRKDYH’WKRP‘WRVD\’DQGYHWH~ YHWHP‘WRJR’ 7KH YHUE MDP ,( HVPL FI 6NW ¢VPL *N GKOK FRQWLQXHV WKH ,QGR (XURSHDQSDUDGLJPRIWKHURRWSUHVHQWLQPRVWRILWVIRUPV
VJ
SO
MDP HVPL MH HVVL ¬VKW¬~ DˆVKW HQVWL
MHPL HVP©L >MHQL@ MDQ¬ HVQWL
VJ FRQWDLQV DQ HSHQWKHWLF Q SUREDEO\ WKH UHVXOW RI WKH DQDORJLFDO SUHVVXUH IURP WKH SO SO FRUUHVSRQGV H[DFWO\ WR WKH %DOWLF SO HQGLQJ 2/LWK HVPL HVPLH HVPHL SO HVQWL UHIOHFWV DQ DQDORJLFDOEDFNIRUPDWLRQRQWKHEDVLVRIWKHVLQJXODURSSRVHGWRRWKHU ,QGR(XURSHDQ FRQWLQXDQWV RI HV UHIOHFWLQJ D WKHPDWL]HG VRQWL 6NW V¢QWL/DWVXQW 7KH DWKHPDWLF SUHVHQW RI NDP NDSPL UHODWHG WR WKHPDWLF /DW FDSLA ‘WR VHL]H WR JUDVS’ *RWK KDEDQ ‘WR KDYH’ PD\ EH D 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LQQRYDWLRQ7KHUHH[LVWVWKHPDWLFNDS‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’ (3$ NDSD ,WVHHPVSUREDEOHWKDW NDSDZDVGUDZQLQWRWKHVSKHUHRIWKHDWKHPDWLF FRQMXJDWLRQ EHFDXVH LW UHSODFHG DQRWKHU ORVW SUHVHQW VWHP RU ZDV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK RWKHU DWKHPDWLF YHUEV RI WKH VDPH VHPDQWLF ILHOG 7KH WKLUG DWKHPDWLF YHUE LV WKRP ‘WR VD\’ WVQVPL FRQQHFWHG ZLWK /DW FQVHA ‘WR DVVHVV WR YDOXH’ ,Q ,UDQLDQ 23HUV SWL\ WKLV VWHP LV DWKHPDWLF 7KHODVWDWKHPDWLFYHUELVYHWH~ YHWHP‘WRJR’7KRXJKWKHHW\PRORJLFDO FRQQHFWLRQVRIWKLVYHUEDUHPRUHRUOHVVFOHDU FI/DWYGA‘WRJRWR
180
chapter three
ZDON’,21YDÔDLGDQGSUREDEO\$UPJDP‘ , FRPH’ WKHVWUXFWXUHRI WKHSDUDGLJPLQVLQJXODULVSHUSOH[LQJ7KHRULJLQDOIRUPLVUHWDLQHGLQ SOYHPL ZDGPHL,QWKHVLQJXODUKRZHYHUZHKDYHWRVXSSRVHDQ DGGLWLRQDOPRUSKHPHWHKLVWRULFDOO\LGHQWLFDOZLWKWH‘WRZKHUHWKHUH’ (3$ WDLUHIOHFWLQJ,( WRL7KXVWKHRULJLQDOSDUDGLJP RQO\SDUWO\ DWKHPDWLF DV WKH VJ FDQQRW EH SKRQHWLFDOO\ GHULYHG IURP ZDGVL DQG ZDGWL LQWKHVLQJXODUZDVDVIROORZV
YHP ZDGPL
YH ZDGHVL
YHW ZDGHWL
7KHQDQHZPRUSKRORJLFDOHOHPHQWZDVDGGHG
YHPWH
YHWH
YHWWH
,QWKHSOWKHDERYHIRUPVGHYHORSHGLQWRWKHDWWHVWHGYHWH,Q*HJ WKHVJHYROYHGIURP YHPWHWRYHWH+RZHYHULQ7RVN YHPWHZDV WUDQVIRUPHGLQWRYHWHP ,WLVSUREDEOHWKDWWKHYHUELN‘WRJRDZD\WRUXQDZD\’ HLND ZLWKLWV YDULDQWLN¬MQRZEHORQJLQJWRWKH9,,DFODVV ZDVDWKHPDWLFLQ$OEDQLDQ DQG LWV RULJLQDO SUHVHQW ZDV HLPL LGHQWLFDO ZLWK *N GK?OK ,WV FXUUHQW SUHVHQWIRUPZDVGHULYHGIURPWKHDWKHPDWLFLPSHUDWLYHVJLN HL ND FRQQHFWHG ZLWK /LWKXDQLDQ LPSHUDWLYH H&N H&NL ‘JR’ 7KLV VXEVWL WXWLRQ LV UHPDUNDEO\ VLPLODU WR WKDW RI WKH DWKHPDWLF HLPL LQ 6ODYLF +HUH HLPLZDVUHSODFHGE\WKHLQQRYDWLYHSUHVHQW MÚG_‘ , JR’EDVHG RQ LGKLDQROGLPSHUDWLYHRI HLFI6NWLKL*NKSK
&ODVV ,, WKHPDWLF URRW VWHPV 7KLV FODVV LQFOXGHV GR]HQV RI YHUEVZLWKHJUDGHLQSUHVHQW&IDIHZW\SLFDOH[DPSOHV EUHGK‘WR MXPS WR VSULQJ’ (3$ EUHGD 6ODY EUHG_ EUHVWL‘WR ZDGHWRIRUG’/LWKEUHQG¸EU®VWLLG GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ (3$ GHJD ,( GKHÞK ‘WR EXUQ’ 6NW G¢KDWL 7RFK$%WVDNWV¥N/LWGHJ¸GªJWL JMHVK‘WRNQHDG’ (3$ MHVMD 6NW\¢V\DWL‘WRERLO’*N\GY‘WRERLO WRFRRN’
morphology
181
SMHN‘WREDNHWRFRRN’ (3$ SHND ,( SHáLG 6NWS¢FDWL*N RGUUY/DWFRTXA6ODY SHN_ SHNWL SMHOO‘WREHJHWWRSURGXFHWREHDU’ (3$ SHOD /DWSHOOA‘WRGULYH WRSXVK’*NRCNNY‘WRSRLVHWRVZHOOWRVZLQJ’ UMHS‘WRVWULSRII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’ (3$ UHSD ,( UHS *NGTGRVQOCK‘WRHDW’/DWUDSLA‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’/LWKU{SWL ‘WRJUDVS’ WMHUU ‘WR VSLQ’ (3$ WHUND 7RFK % W¥UN ‘WR WXUQ’ RQO\ DV SDUW SUHW /DWWRUTXHALG YGMHUU‘WROHDYH’ (3$ DZDGHUD‘WROHDYH’ ,( GHU‘WRUXQ’ 6NW GUdWL‘WRUXQWRKDVWHQ’*NDRUGFTC P‘WRUXQDZD\’ YMHGK ‘WR VWHDO’ (3$ ZHG]D ,( ÆH½K 6NW Y¢KDWL ‘WR GULYH’ /DWYHKA‘WREHDUWRFDUU\’*RWKJDZLJDQ‘WRVWHDO’ ]YMHUGK ‘WR ZHDQ’ (3$ YHUG]D /LWK YHUÊL¸ YH¼ÊWL ‘WR ODFH WR WLH’/DWYYU]W‘WRWXUQ’6ODY YHU]WL‘WRELQG’ 2WKHUDEODXWJUDGHVLQWKHWKHPDWLFVWHPVDUHPXFKUDUHU,QRQHXQLTXH FDVHOHQJWKHQHGJUDGHLVDWWHVWHG VKSRUU‘WRPRYHDZD\WRGULYHDZD\’ (3$ SUD 6NWSSDUWL‘WR EULQJRYHUWRVDYH’*NRGTCYRGKTY‘WRSHQHWUDWH’ 7KH]HURJUDGHWXG¢WLW\SHLVUDWKHUIUHTXHQWWKRXJKLWVHHPVWRFRQVLVW PDLQO\RI3URWR$OEDQLDQLQQRYDWLRQV GDO‘WRJRRXW’ (3$ GDOD *NSCNNY‘WREORRP’ IODN‘WRWKURZWRIOLQJ’ (3$ DZDODNDGHULYHGIURP,( ON~
OiNWREHQGWRMXPS’ 0+*OHFNHQ‘WRWKURZEDFNWRVSULQJ’ /LWKOHNL¸O|NWL‘WRIO\’/DWYOªNW‘WRVSULQJWRMXPS’ JULVK‘WRLQYLWH’ (3$ JULVDD]HURJUDGHRI,( ÞHUiVFI6NW JodWL‘WRFDOOWRLQYRNH’/LWKJLUL¸J®UWL‘WRSUDLVH’ OHK~OHI‘WREDUN’ (3$ ODMD 6NWUd\DWLLG/LWKO²MXO²WLLG6ODY
ODMDWL QGXN ‘WR SOXFN RXW WR SXOO RXW WR WHDU’ (3$ HQGXND *RWK WLXKDQ‘WRSXOO’/DWG FALG QGXONHP‘WRULSHQ’ (3$ HQWXOND /LWKWHONL¸WHËNWL‘WRJDWKHUWR EULQJ WRJHWKHU’ 6ODY WHONWL ‘WR EHDW WR SRXQG’ WÙONDWL ‘WR SXVK’
182
chapter three
WKHN ‘WR URDVW WR WRDVW EUHDG ’ (3$ WVDND ,( N FI *N MGIMGK RGKPC`^ MCIMQOGPJX EJTC`X VY`^ HQDY^ +HV RQNWMCIMJX‘EXUQLQJVWURQJO\’ +RP 1XPHURXV YHUEV KDYH WKHPDWLF SUHVHQWV LQ RJUDGH EXW RQO\ VRPH RI WKHPFDQEHGHVFULEHGDVGHQRPLQDWLYHIRUPDWLRQV NDOE ‘WR OHW URW’ (3$ NDOED GHULYHG IURP THOE ‘SXV’ NDOED VLQJXODUL]HGSOXUDO PEDU ‘WR EULQJ EDFN ’ (3$ HQEDUD EDVHG RQ WKH QRXQ EDUD UHODWHGWRELH‘WRFDUU\’ ,QPDQ\RWKHUYHUEVWKHRJUDGHLVXQPRWLYDWHG GHUGK‘WR SRXU RXW’ (3$ GDUGDFORVH WR /LWK GDUG{WL‘WR UDWWOH’ /DWYG#UGêW‘WRFUHDN’:JRG\UGGX‘WRPXPEOHWRJUXPEOH’ KDS‘WRRSHQ’ (3$ VNDSD ,( VNHS‘WRFXWWRVSOLWWRGLJ’ ODJ ‘WR ZHW WR VRDN WR EDWKH WR ZDVK’ (3$ ODXJD ,OO\U GNQX .QW IGQP MCNQW OGPQP 6WUDER /LWK OL
JDV ‘PDUVK’ 6ODY
OXÊD‘SRRO’ VKNHO ‘WR PDNH D VWHS WR ZDON’ (3$ VNDOD 6NW VNK¢ODWH ‘WR VWXPEOHWRWULS’ XO ‘WR ORZHU’ (3$ ZDOD *N GKNY ‘WR VKXW LQ WR SUHVV’ /LWK YDOØWL‘WRFOHDQ’LhYDOØWL‘WRFDUU\DZD\’ YUDS‘WRUXQWRKDVWH’ (3$ DZDUDSDGHULYHGIURPUMHS‘WRVWULS RII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’
&ODVV ,,, QDVDO SUHVHQWV 7KLV W\SH KDV EHFRPH UHODWLYHO\
OLPLWHGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,Q RQH FDVH ZH ILQG D ]HUR JUDGH RI D QDVDO SUHVHQWDWWHVWHG DVDIXOOJUDGH LQ%DOWLF THN‘WRPHQWLRQWRTXRWH’ (3$ NDND ,( NNRP /LWKNDQN¸ N£NWL‘WRVHL]HWRUHDFK’/DWYNDFW‘WRJUDVS’6ODY ¨HNDWL‘WR H[SHFWWRZDLW’ 7KHUH DOVR VHHPV WR EH DQ LQQRYDWLYH QDVDO LQIL[ LQ RQH GHQRPLQDWLYH IRUPDWLRQ
morphology
183
P¬QG‘WRVXFNOHWRIHHG’ (3$ PDQ]GDEDVHGRQPDM~PDˆM‘WR IHHGWRIDWWHQ’ (3$ PD]GQMDFI,( PD]G‘IHHGLQJ’ 2+* PDVW6NWP©GDV‘IDWPDUURZ’ 7KH PDMRULW\ RI 3URWR$OEDQLDQ QDVDO SUHVHQWV JR EDFN WR YHUEDO URRWV ZLWK D GLSKWKRQJ &RUUHVSRQGLQJ QDVDO SUHVHQWV LQ IDFW VHHP WR EH LQQRYDWLRQVUHSODFLQJROGWKHPDWLFVWHPVFRQWDLQLQJGLSKWKRQJV ELQG ‘WR FRQYLQFH WR SHUVXDGH’ (3$ ELQGD ,( EKHLGK ‘WR SHUVXDGHWRIRUFH’ KXPE‘WROHDYHWRORVHWRVSRLOWRPLVVWRGURZQ’ (3$ VNXPED QDVDOSUHVHQWRI,( VNHXEK *RWKDIVNLXEDQ‘WRSXVKDZD\WR UHMHFW’/LWKVNXPE¸VN¸EWL‘WRKXUU\WRKDVWHQ’ OLQG ‘WR EHDU WR EHJHW WR EH ERUQ’ OLQGD UHODWHG WR OHM ‘WR JLYH ELUWK’ ODLGQMD /LWKO©LVWL‘WROHW’/DWYODîVWLG PXQG ‘WR EH DEOH’ (3$ QDVDO SUHVHQW PXQGD /LWK PXG£ ‘SRVVLELOLW\’ PXG·RWL ‘WR WU\ WR DWWHPSW’ 6NW P²GDWH ‘WR UHMRLFHWREHPHUU\’ VKNXQG ‘WR VKDNH WR VZLQJ’ (3$ VNXQWD ,( VNHXW 0,U VFRWKDLG‘WRFXWRII’/LWKVNXW¸VN¸VWL‘WRVFUDSH’ WXQG‘WRPRYHWRVWLUWRVZLQJ’ (3$ WXQGD 6NWWXQGDWH‘WRSXVK WRVWULNH’/DWWXQGA‘WRSXVK’
&ODVV ,9 VWHPV LQ VN 2OG SUHVHQW VWHPV LQ VHR RUL JLQDOO\-LWHUDWLYHV DQG GXUDWLYHV ZHUH ZLGHVSUHDG LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ZKHUH WKH VXIIL[ EHFDPH (3$ VN ! [ ! K ~ I ,Q $OEDQLDQ VWHPVLQ VHRDUHIRUPHGIURPURRWVHQGLQJLQRFFOXVLYHVRUYRZHOV WKRXJKQRWVRQRUDQWVZLWKWKHRQO\H[FHSWLRQRIQMHK 0RVWRIWKHVHSUHVHQWVKDYHHJUDGHYRFDOLVP GHK ‘WR LQHEULDWH’ (3$ GHJVND UHODWHG WR GMHJ ‘WR EXUQ’ (3$
GHJD ,( GKHÞK‘WREXUQ’ 6NWG¢KDWL7RFK$%WVDNWV¥N /LWGHJ¸GªJWL IVKHK ~ PVKHI PçHI ‘WR KLGH’ (3$ VNHSVND *N UMGRY ‘WR FRYHUWRVKLHOGWRVFUHHQ’ JULK ‘WR VKDUSHQ’ (3$ JUHLVND *N ZTKY ‘WR UXE WR DQRLQW WR SULFN’ /LWK JULHM¸ JULWL ‘WR VFRRS FUHDP IURP PLON WR WDNH KROGRI’
184
chapter three
NUHK~NUHI‘WRFRPE’ (3$ JUHEVND /LWKJU{EWL‘WRUDNH’6ODY
JUHE_ JUHEWL‘WRURZWRUDNH’ PHK ~ PHI ‘WR VRDN’ (3$ PHXVND /DWY PDXl W ‘WR GLYH’ 6ODY
P\WL‘WRZDVK’ QGLK ~ QGLI ‘WR KHOS’ (3$ HQGHLVND *N FKGOCK ‘WR KXUU\ WR GULYH’6NWG\DWL‘WRIO\WRVRDU’ QMHK ~ QMHI ‘WR FRXQW WR FRQVLGHU’ (3$ QHPVND *N PGOY ‘WR GLYLGH’*RWKQLPDQ‘WRWDNH’/DWQXPHUXV‘PHPEHUHOHPHQW QXPEHU’DQGQXPPXV‘FRLQPRQH\’ VKSLK ~ VKSLI ‘WR VODQGHU WR FDOXPQLDWH’ (3$ LVSHLNVND 2+* IHKDQ‘WRKDWH’/LWKSHLNL¸SH&NWL‘WREODPH’ ,Q RQH DUFKDLF FDVH OHQJWKHQHG HJUDGH ! LV DWWHVWHG LQ FRQWUDVW ZLWKRWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHV VKRK~VKRI‘WRVHH’ (3$ VNVND ,( VHá‘WRIROORZWRVHH’ 6NW V¢FDWH ‘WR DFFRPSDQ\ WR IROORZ’ *N GRQOCK /DW VHTXRU FILQSDUWLFXODU*RWKVDLxDQ‘WRVHH’ 7KHUHDUHWZRFDVHVZLWKWKH]HURJUDGHYRFDOLVP JUDK~JUDI‘WRVSXURQWRFDOOWRURDU’ (3$ JUDVND 6NWJodWL ‘WRFDOOWRLQYRNH’/LWKJLUL¸J®UWL‘WRSUDLVH’ UUDK‘WREHDWWRVWULNH’ (3$ ZUDJVND *NT CUUYLG $QXQXVXDOYRFDOLVPLVIRXQGLQQMRK~ QMRIZKLFKFDQEHH[SODLQHGDV DQH[WUHPHDUFKDLVPFRUUHVSRQGLQJWR$QDWROLDQGDWD QMRK~QMRI‘WRNQRZ’ (3$ JQVND ,( ½HQi~ ½QALGFI*N IKIPYUMY(SLGDXUIPYUMY/DW J QAVFAEXW2+LWWJDQHHV ]L‘WRILQGWRUHFRJQL]HWRNQRZ’ ½QH+VWL $PRQJWKHYHUEVLQ VHRZHILQGVHYHUDORJUDGHGHQRPLQDWLYHVDQG GHYHUEDWLYHV HK‘WRVKDUSHQ’ (3$ DNVNDGHULYHGIURP,( DRV‘VKDUS’ SODK~SODI‘WRFRYHU’ (3$ S H ODVND WR *N RGNCX ‘VNLQ’ /LWK SDO£ ‘OLQHQ NHUFKLHI’ SOHQ| ‘WKLQ VNLQ PHPEUDQH’ 21 IMDOO ‘VNLQ’ SUHK‘WRVKDUSHQ’ SHUDNVNDFIHK
morphology
185
VKNUHK ‘WR UHOHDVH VDIHW\ GHYLFH WULJJHU ’ LVNUDSVND GHULYHG IURPVKNUHS‘WRVWULNH ILUH WRUHOHDVH WULJJHU ’NUHS‘URFN’ (3$ NUDSD VKSUHK ‘WR H[SUHVV WR VSHDN’ (3$ LVSHUDNVND IXUWKHU FRQQHFWHGZLWKHK
&ODVV 9 VWHPV LQ M 6HYHUDO GLIIHUHQW ,QGR(XURSHDQ W\SHV
\LHOGHG 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SUHVHQW VWHPV LQ M 7KH ILUVW VRXUFH DUH WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ LWHUDWLYHVFDXVDWLYHV LQ HHR XVXDOO\ ZLWK RJUDGH RWKHUFDXVDWLYHVZHUHUHSODFHGE\LQQRYDWLYHVWHPVLQ QMVHHEHORZ YRFDOLVP GKH]‘WRVHWRQILUHWREXUQ’ (3$ GDGÊMDFRQQHFWHGZLWKGMHJ‘WR EXUQ’ ,( GKHÞK IDˆM ‘WR ILOO WR FUDP WR VXUIHLW’ (3$ VSDQMD *PF VSDQQMDQ ‘WR WLJKWHQ’ 21VSHQQDDQGWKHOLNH QGH]‘WRVHWDOLJKWWRLJQLWH’ (3$ HQGDGÊMDFIGKH] VKSHUU‘WRZLQ PRQH\ WRJDLQ’ (3$ VSDUMD *PF VSDUAMDQ‘WR OHDYHXQKDUPHGWRNHHS’ 21VSDUD2+*VSDUAQ2(VSDULDQ WHU‘WRPDNHGU\’ (3$ WDUVMD 6NWWDU¿¢\DWLLG/DWWRUUHALG21 ÈHUUDLG YHVK‘WRSXWRQ FORWKHV WRFRYHU’ (3$ ZHVMD 6NWYV¢\DWLDQG *RWKZDVMDQLG
$QRWKHUJURXSLVUHSUHVHQWHGE\,QGR(XURSHDQYHUEVLQ HR6RPH RI WKHP DUH LQKHULWHG IURP ,QGR(XURSHDQ 2WKHUV VHHP WR EH LQQRYD WLRQV,QWKLVJURXSHJUDGHYRFDOLVPLVH[WUHPHO\FRPPRQ ELH ‘WR EULQJ’ (3$ EHUMD ,( EKHU ‘WR EULQJ WR FDUU\’ 6NW EK¢UDWL*NHGTY/DWIHUA GKMHV‘WRGHIHFDWH’ (3$ G]HGWMD 6NWKDGDWLLG*NZG\YLG ¬M~ DˆM‘WREORZWRVZHOO’ (3$ DQMD 6NW¢QLWL‘WREUHDWKH’*RWK XVDQDQ‘WREORZRXW’ IWRK ~ IWRI ‘WR FRRO WR PDNH FROG’ (3$ DZDWMD ,( W ‘WR PHOW’ 6ODY WDM_ WDMDWL2VVHWWDM\QLG QGHM ~ QGêM ‘WR VWUHWFK RXW WR VSUHDG’ (3$ HQWHQMD *N VGKPY ‘WRVWUHWFK’GP-VGK PY‘WRVWUHWFKRXW’DQGIXUWKHUWR6NW WDQ²WL ‘WRH[SDQG’2+*GHQHQ‘WRVWUHWFK’ TDV ‘WR DSSURDFK’ (3$ NHWMD FRQQHFWHG ZLWK WKH LVRODWHG /LWK NH¨L¸N|VWL‘WRVWUHWFK’
186
chapter three
6RPHRIWKHPVKRZ]HURJUDGHRURJUDGHYRFDOLVP E¬M~EDˆM‘WRGRWRPDNH’ (3$ EDQMD *NHCKPY‘WRDSSHDU’ IXV ‘WR SXW LQ WR WKUXVW LQ WR LQVHUW WR SODQW’ (3$ VSXWMD /DW SXWA‘WRWULPWRSUXQH’7RFK$%SXWN‘WRGLYLGH’ NHS‘WRKHZ’ (3$ NDSMD *NMQRVY‘WRKLWWRKHZ’/LWKNDSL¸ N£SWL‘WRKHZ’ UULV‘WRSXOOXSWRPRYHXSWRLQFUHDVHWRJURZ’ (3$ ZULWMD ,( ÆHUW ‘WR WXUQ’ 6NW YDUWDWH /DW YHUWA *RWK ZDLUÈDQ ‘WR EHFRPH’ $OEDQLDQ DOVR KDV QXPHURXV GHQRPLQDWLYH YHUEV LQ M VLPLODU WR %DOWLFDQG6ODYLFGHQRPLQDWLYHVLQ/LWK,WL~ Slav M_ LWL JGKLM~JGKîM‘WRVWD\DZDNHDWQLJKW’ (3$ JDGLQMDEDVHGRQ,(
GLQR ~ GHLQR ‘GD\’ 6NW GQD ‘GD\’ 6ODY GÚQÚ LG /LWK GLHQ£LG/DWYG®HQDLG MHV ‘WR UHPDLQ’ (3$ HWMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH RI MHW¬ ‘OLIH’ (3$
HWD WKH LVRODWHG JURXS RI Gk GVGQX ‘true, real’, G VC C NJSJ` C ICSC(Hes.), GVC\Y ‘to test’. OR]‘WRPRYHWRVKDNHWRSOD\’ (3$ OGMD 6ODY ODGLWL‘WRPDNH RUGHUWRPDNHSHDFH’EDVHGRQ ODGÙ‘RUGHUSHDFH’ QGHV ‘WR KDYH WURXEOHV’ (3$ HQGDWhMD UHIOHFWLQJ ,( GHá DQG UHODWHG WR WKH GHQRPLQDWLYH /LWK G£N\WL ‘WR PL[ XS WR SXW LQ GLVRUGHU’ SHOT‘WRVWLUXS ZDWHU ’ (3$ SHONMD S©ON^‘PDUVKVZDPS’/DWY SHËFH‘SXGGOH’ SODV ‘WR EXUVW WR VSOLW’ (3$ SODWMD D GHQRPLQDWLYH YHUE 6NW SWK·‘EURDGZLGH’*NRNCVWXLG/LWKSODW¸VLG WUHV ‘WR PHOW WR ORRVHQ WR GLVVROYH’ (3$ WUAWMD 6ODY WUDWM_
WUDWLWL‘WRVSHQGWRZDVWH’ ]¬M~]DˆM‘WRFDOO’ (3$ GÊDQMD 6ODY ]YRQM_ ]YRQLWL‘WRULQJ’ FI ]¬ ~ ]Dˆ ‘YRLFH’ (3$ GÊDQD $UP MDLQ ‘YRLFH’ 6ODY
]YRQÙ‘ULQJLQJVRXQG’ ,( ½KÆHQ
&ODVV 9, VWHPV LQ Q 7KHVH VWHPV FRQWLQXH ,QGR(XURSHDQ
SUHVHQWVLQ QHR2QO\WZRRIWKHPKDYHHJUDGHYRFDOLVP
morphology
187
çHP ‘WR EULQJ WR OLJKW WR GLVFORVH WR UHYHDO WR EURDFK’ (3$
hWhHSQD ,( VHS‘WRFXWWRVSOLW’ ]¬ ~ ]Dˆ ‘WR VHL]H WR JUDVS WR WRXFK’ (3$ GÊHLQD EDVHG RQ ,(
ÞHi‘WRRYHUSRZHU’ 6NWM\d‘IRUFHSRZHU’M¢\DWL‘WRZLQWR FRQTXHU’*NDKJ‘SRZHU’ 6HYHUDO YHUEV LQ Q KDYH RYRFDOLVP 6RPH RI WKHP FRXOG EH LQWHU SUHWHG DV UHSODFLQJ ROGHU FDXVDWLYHV RU GHQRPLQDWLYHV LQ HR RU RULJLQDOYHUEVRI,,FODVV KDUU ‘WR ZHHG WR FXW GRZQ’ (3$ VNDUQD D GHQRPLQDWLYH RI ,(
VNHU ‘WR FXW’ FI *RWK XVVNDUMDQ ‘WR WHDU RXW’ /LWK VNLUL¸ VN®UWL NDOO ‘WR LQVHUW WR WKUXVW WR SODFH WR LQFLWH WR VHW RQ ILUH’ (3$
NDOQDFIVMHOO áHO O¬~ODˆ‘WROHW’ (3$ ODLGQD /LWKO©LVWLLG/DWYODîVWLG*RWKOHWDQ LG WDOO ‘WR ULGLFXOH WR GHULGH’ (3$ FDXVDWLYH WDOQD 2,U WXLOLG ‘WR VOHHS’ /LWK W\O¸ W®OWL ‘WR EHFRPH VLOHQW’ 6ODY WROLWL ‘WR SHUVXDGHWRPDNHTXLHW’ 7KHIROORZLQJ$OEDQLDQLQQRYDWLRQLVDQREYLRXVGHQRPLQDWLYH PDUU ‘WR WDNH WR JUDVS’ (3$ PDUQD EDVHG RQ WKH KHWHURFOLWLF ZRUGIRU‘KDQG’SUHVHUYHGLQ*NOCTJ/DWPDQXV $QRWKHULQQRYDWLRQLVEDVHGRQDQ,QGR(XURSHDQDGYHUE Y¬~Yê‘WRSXW’ (3$ DZHQDEDVHGRQ,( DÆH‘GRZQRII’ 6NW ¢YDLG 7KHUHDSSHDUVWREHRQHOHQJWKHQHGJUDGHQVWHP GXD ~ GXH ‘WR ORYH’ (3$ GXVQD ,( ½HXV ‘WR WDVWH’ FI 6NW M²¿DWL‘WREHIRQGRI’*NIGWQOCK
&ODVV9,, VWHPVLQ QM7KLVQHZFODVVRISUHVHQWVZDVYHU\
SURGXFWLYH LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,W UHSODFHG VHYHUDO ROG W\SHV RI SUHVHQW ,Q D IHZ FDVHV YHUEV LQ QM FRQWLQXH ,QGR(XURSHDQ FDXVDWLYHV LQ
HHR
188
chapter three
PEDM‘WRKROGWRFDUU\’ (3$ HQEDUQMDDFDXVDWLYHGHULYHGIURP
EHUD!ELH ]LHM‘WRERLOWRFRRN’ (3$ GÊHUQMDGHULYHGIURP,( ÞKHU‘KRW’ 6RPHSUHVHQWVLQ QMJREDFNWR,QGR(XURSHDQVWHPVLQ QHRDQG SUHVHQWVZLWKDQDVDOLQIL[ EUHM ~ EUêM ‘WR JQDZ’ (3$ EUDLQMD ,( EKUHL ‘WR FXW’ 6NW EKUodWL‘ KH LQMXUHV’/DWIULA‘WRUXE’6ODY EULWL‘WRVKDYH’ EXM ~ EûM ‘WR DFFRPRGDWH D JXHVW WR VWD\ RYHUQLJKW’ (3$
EXGQMD /LWKEXQG¸‘WRZDNHXS’6ODY EÙGQ_‘WREHDZDNH’ JMHM ~ JMêM ‘WR ILQG’ (3$ JDGQMD JKG *N ZCPFCPY DRU GZCFQP‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’/DWSUHKHQGALG21JHWDLG VKWULM‘WRVSUHDGWRVWUHWFK’ (3$ VWULQMD 6NWVWQdWL‘WRVSUHDGWR VFDWWHU’*NUVQTPWOK‘WRVSUHDGWRVWUHWFK’/DWVWHUQALG YHM ‘WR ZHDYH’ (3$ ZHEQMD 6NW XEKQdWL ‘WR ODFH XS’ 2+* ZHEDQ‘WRZHDYH’7RFK%ZSLG &HUWDLQ YHUEV LQ QM LQ IDFW JR EDFN WR YHUEV LQ HR LQFOXGLQJ GHQRPLQDWLYHV GDM ‘WR GLYLGH’ (3$ GDQMD *N FCKQOCK ‘WR GLYLGH’ 6NW G¢\DWH LG GUXDM~GUXHM‘WREHDIUDLG’ (3$ GUQMDGHULYHGIURPGUHGURH ‘IHDU’ 3$OE GUZ JMDM‘WRUHVHPEOHWREHOLNH WRVXLWWREHFRPH WRVHHP WRKDSSHQ’ (3$ JDODEQMDEDVHGRQ ODE /LWKO¦EDV‘JRRG’/DWYODEV LG OXDM~ OXHM‘WRPRYHWRVKDNHWRSOD\’ OGQMDFRQQHFWHGZLWKOR] LG (3$ OGMD 6ODY ODGLWL ‘WR PDNH RUGHU WR PDNH SHDFH’ EDVHGRQ ODGÙ‘RUGHUSHDFH’ TDM~TDQM‘WRFU\WRZHHS’ (3$ NODXQMD *NMNCKY MNC®KY LG VKWRM ‘WR LQFUHDVH’ (3$ VWQMD /LWK VW²MX VW²WL LG 6ODY VWRM_
VWRMDWLLG WKDM‘WRGU\’ (3$ VDXVQMDD GHULYDWLYHRI,( VDXVR‘GU\’ *N CW=QX0+*VôU/LWKVD-VDV6ODY VX[Ù ,QRWKHUFDVHVYHUEVLQ QMJREDFNWRWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWV
morphology
189
ERMERKHW‘WRPDWH’ (3$ EJQMD /LWKE{JWL‘WRUXQ’/DWYEêJW LG23UXVEHJH\WHLG6ODY EpJWLLG*NHGDQOCKLG çDM ‘WR VSOLW WR FOHDYH WR VPDVK WR EDWWHU WR FKRS XS’ (3$
hWhHGQMD ,( VNHG‘WRVSOLW’ 6NWVNKDGDWHLG*NUMGFCPPWOK LG NUHM‘WRSXOORXW’ (3$ NUHEQMD ,( JKUHEKFINUHK ODM~OâM‘WRZDVK’ (3$ ODXQMD *NNQWYLG/DWODYALG QJDM‘WRUXQ’ (3$ HQJDQMD UHGXSOLFDWHG6NWM¢KWL‘WROHDYHWR DEDQGRQ’2+*JQJQ‘WRJR’ QJLM~QJîM‘WRVDWHWRVXFNOH’ (3$ JOHLQMD /LWKJOLHM¸JOLHWL‘WR VPHDU’2+*NO¬QDQLG
&ODVV9,,D VWHPVLQ DQM HQM LQM+LVWRULFDOO\DFODVV RI VHFRQGDU\ IRUPDWLRQV PDQ\ RI WKHP GHQRPLQDWLYHV EDVHG RQ WKH VXIIL[ QMRI&ODVV9,, IVKDˆM‘WRVLJK’ (3$ SXhDQMD /LWKS¸hNLQWL‘WRSXII’SXhN©QWL‘WR VSODVK’6ODY S\[DWL‘WREORZWRSXII’ J¬UGKLM‘WRVFUDWFK’ (3$ JUDGQMD ,( JKUGKFI2(JULQGDQ ‘WRJULQG’/LWKJU©QGÊLXJU©VWL‘WRVFUDSHWRVFUDWFK’ K\M ~ K\HM ‘WR HQWHU’ (3$ HLZLQMD 6NW ©YD ‘VSHHG\’ /LWK DW H&YLV DW©LYD ‘QHZFRPHU VWUDQJHU’ SHUHLYLV S©UHLYD ‘WUDPS YDJUDQW’ N¬VHQ ‘WR DFKH RI WKH VWRPDFK WR KDYH JULSLQJ SDLQV’ (3$
NDQWhHQMD /LWKNHQNL¸NH±NWL‘WRGDPDJHWRKDUP’21K¢‘WR WRUPHQW’ *PF [DQ[AQ NLM‘WRSUXQHWRWULP’ N¬LQM (3$ NDGLQMDDGHQRPLQDWLYHYHUE GHULYHGIURPNDGK¬‘SUXQLQJNQLIHELOOKRRNZLWKORQJKDQGOH’ (3$ NDG O\HM ‘WR VPHDU WR RLO’ (3$ HODLZDQMD EDVHG RQ HODLZ ERUURZHGIURP*NGNCKQP‘RLO’ PSLM ~ PSîM ‘WR EHQXPE WR PDNH VWLII’ (3$ HQSJLQMD *N RJIPWOK ‘WR PDNH ILUP WR PDNH VWLII’ /DW SDQJA LG *RWK IKDQ‘WRFDWFK’ U\HM‘WRVXIIHU’ (3$ UDXGLQMD 6NWU²GLWL‘WRZHHSWRURDU’/DW U GA ‘WR VKRXW WR FU\’ /LWK UDXG£ ‘ZHHSLQJ’ 6ODY U\GDWL ‘WR ZHHS’ UUHM~UUêM‘WRGHFHLYH’ (3$ DUQHQMD *NC TPGQOCK‘WROLH’
190
chapter three
&ODVV 9,,E VWHPV LQ QM 7KLV VXIIL[ LV D PRGLILFDWLRQ RI ,QGR (XURSHDQ VWHPVFI*NVKOCY‘WREULQJWRVKDPH’/DWSODQ WUH‘WRSODQW’FRUUHVSRQGWR6DQVNULWIRUPVLQ\D,Q$OEDQLDQ QM ZDVZLGHO\ XVHG WR DGDSW ORDQZRUGV VHH EHORZ ,QKHULWHG ,QGR(XUR SHDQYRFDEXODU\IRUPVGHQRPLQDWLYHVZLWKVWHPVLQ QM KDUP L ‘EURNHQZLQGSXUVLQHVV’¾KDUPRM‘WRH[KDXVW’ NDOOD‘VODQGHUFDOXPQ\’¾NDOORM‘WRVODQGHUWRWHOOVWRULHV’ ODU¬‘ZKLWHVSRW’¾ODURM‘WRVSHFNOHWRYDULHJDWH WRIODWWHU’ O¬YRU]¬‘SHHOVNLQ’¾O¬YRU]RM‘WRSHHO’ ORG¬U‘JDPHSOD\’¾ORGURM‘WRVSULQJWRGDQFHWRSOD\’ SDU¬‘ILUVW’¾PEDURM‘WRHQGWRFRPSOHWH’ VKWHJ‘SDWKZD\’¾VKNRMVKWHNRM‘WRJR’
&ODVV 9,,, VWHPV LQ W $ IHZ SUHVHQW VWHPV W SUREDEO\ RULJLQDOO\ FRPLQJ IURP SDUWLFLSOHV LQ WR DQG ODWHU XVHG LQ GHQRPLQDWLYHV JGKHQG ‘WR SODQH’ (3$ JDGDLQWD GHULYHG IURP JGKH ~ JGKê ‘JQDUO NQRW’ (3$ JDGDLQD 6NW G¢\DWH ‘WR GLYLGH’ *N FCKQOCKLG PEDUW ‘WR EHDU WR FDUU\ EDFN ’ (3$ HQEDUWD GHULYHG IURP PEDU‘WREULQJ EDFN ’ (3$ HQEDUD UHQG ‘WR UXQ WR KXUU\’ (3$ UHQWD *RWK ULQQDQ ‘WR UXQ’ 21 ULQQDLG
&ODVV,; VWHPVLQ WM,QFRQWUDVWWRVWHPVLQ WWKLVLVD
SURGXFWLYHFODVV6RPHYHUEVUHWDLQWKHRULJLQDOHJUDGHYRFDOLVPRIWKH WKHPDWLFVWHPV çDUV‘WRGHVWUR\WRVSRLO’ (3$ hWhHUWMD ,( VNHU 21VNHUD‘WR FXW’/LWKVN®UWLLG QJU\V ‘WR GDUNHQ’ (3$ HQNU WMD 6ODY NU\WL ‘WR FRYHU’ /LWK NU¢XMXNU¢XWL‘WRSLOH’ QJMLV ‘WR VWLFN WR’ (3$ HQJOHLWMD /LWK JOLHM¸ JOLWL ‘WR VPHDU’ JOLW¸V‘VWLFN\’*NINQKQX‘VWLFN\VWXII’ ,Q VHYHUDO YHUEV FRQWLQXLQJ WKH WXG¢WL W\SH" ]HUR JUDGH YRFDOLVP LV DWWHVWHG
morphology
191
OXV‘WRSUD\WRLQYRNHWREHJ’ (3$ OXJWMD /LWKO J²WL‘WRDVNWR SUD\’/DWYO¸G]XO¸JW‘WRDVNWRLQYLWH’2+*ORFNAQ‘WROXUH WRHQWLFH’IXUWKHUFRQQHFWHGZLWK,( OHXJK‘WROLHWRFKHDW’ PDV‘WRPHDVXUH’ (3$ PDWMD ,( PLG 6NWPPWL7RFK$ PH QJXV‘WRXUJHWRIRUFH’ (3$ HQNXWMD /LWKN¢XWL‘WRVWULNH’6ODY
NRYDWL‘WRIRUJH’/DWF GA‘WRVWULNH’2+*KRXZDQLG UUDV‘WRVTXHH]HWRSUHVVWRJHWKHU’ (3$ ZUDJWMD *NT CU UYLG UHIOHFWLQJ,( ÆUJK 4XLWHRIWHQVWHPVLQ WMIXQFWLRQDVFDXVDWLYHV QJDV ‘WR XUJH WR LQFLWH WR DQQR\’ (3$ HQJDWMD QJDM ‘WR UXQ’ FI6NWM¢KWL‘WROHDYHWRDEDQGRQ’2+*JQJQ‘WRJR’ QLV‘WRVWDUWWREHJLQWRSUHSDUHIRUMRXUQH\’ (3$ QHLNWMD /LWK VXQ®NWL‘WRVHWXSRQWRDWWDFN’6ODY QLNQ_WL‘WRULVHWRJURZ’ *NPGK`MQX‘TXDUUHOVWUXJJOH’ Q[LW‘WRXUJHWRVWLPXODWHWRKXUU\’ (3$ GÊLWD ,( Þ‘WROLYH’ 6NWMÀYDWL/DWYYA TLV‘WRSXOORXW’ (3$ NLWMD *NMKY ‘WRJRWRPRYH’/DWFLHA‘WR PRYH’
&ODVV,;D VWHPVLQ HWM LWM DWM7KHUHDUHWKUHHNQRZQ YHUEVZKRVHGHULYDWLRQLVEDVHGRQWKHVXIIL[HV HWMDQG LWM ODSV ‘WR H[KDXVW WR ZDU\’ (3$ ODSLWMD *N NCRCTQX ‘ZHDN’ NCRα´ \Y‘WRZHDNHQ’ ODSV‘WRZLVKWRZDQW’ (3$ ODXELWMD 6NWO·EK\DWL‘WRZLVK’6ODY
O’XELWL‘WRORYH’ SUHV‘WRFXW’ (3$ S H UHWMD /LWKSHUL¸SH¼WL‘WREHDWWRWKXPS’ *NRTKY‘WRVDZ’ 6WHPVLQ DWMRQWKHFRQWUDU\UHSUHVHQWDSURGXFWLYHW\SHHYHQWXDOO\ FRQQHFWHG ZLWK YHUEV LQ W 7KLV W\SH LQFOXGHV GHYHUEDWLYHV ZKLFK KDYHUHSODFHGVRPHRULJLQDOWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWVWHPV7KLVLVSDUWLFXODUO\ FOHDUDVPDQ\RIWKHVHYHUEVUHWDLQDRULVWVIRUPHGIURPSULPDU\VWHPV ZKLFK DUH XQDWWHVWHG LQ WKH SUHVHQW HJ IODV ZKLFK VKRXOG QRUPDOO\ FRUUHVSRQGWRSUHV IMHORU IDO
192
chapter three
HF L HF¬M ‘WR JR WR UXQ’ HW¬V (3$ DLWDWMD EDVHG RQ D GHULYDWLYHLQ WRRI,( HL‘WRJR’ IODV‘WRVSHDN’ (3$ VSDODFIIMDO¬‘ZRUG’ VSHO J¬UVKDV‘WRLQYLWH’ JULVDWMD JULVKLG (3$ JULVDD]HURJUDGH RI,( ÞHUi 6NWJodWL‘WRFDOOWRLQYRNH’/LWKJLUL¸J®UWL‘WR SUDLVH’ N¬OODV ‘WR SXW LQWR WR LQVHUW WR GLJ WR LQVWLJDWH’ (3$ NDOQDWMD GHULYHGIURPNDOO‘WRLQVHUWWRWKUXVWWRSODFHWRLQFLWHWRVHWRQ ILUH’ (3$ NDOQD WUDV ‘WR SXOO D ERDW WR WKH FRDVW ’ (3$ W H UDWMD 6NW W¢UDWL ‘WR FURVVRYHU’ XPDV‘WREDUN’ (3$ ZDPDWMD 6NWY¢PLWL‘WRYRPLW’$YYDP‘WR VSLW’*NG OGY‘WRVSLWRXW’/DWYRPHA‘WRYRPLW’ Y¬UUDV ‘WR VKRXW WR EOHDW’ (3$ ZHUDWMD *N GKTY ‘WR VD\’ +LWW ÆHULD‘WRVRXQG’ YLODV ‘WR FXW GRZQ WUHHV ’ (3$ ZLODWMD GHULYHG IURP YMHO ‘WR SOXFN IUXLW WR YLQWDJH’ (3$ ZHOD *N GKNY ‘WR VKXW LQ WR SUHVV’/LWKVXYDOØWL‘WRKDUYHVWWRUHDS’
&ODVV ; VWHPV LQ U $OEDQLDQ KDV D IHZ SUHVHQW VWHPV LQ
U ZKLFK KDYH QR FOHDU HW\PRORJLFDO FRQQHFWLRQV HOVHZKHUH 7KHR UHWLFDOO\ WKHLU GHULYDWLRQ FRXOG EH IURP URVWHP QRXQV DOWKRXJK WKH ORQJYRFDOLVPRIVRPHRIWKHPPDNHVWKLVVFHQDULRXQOLNHO\ NRUU ‘WR UHDS WR KDUYHVW’ (3$ NVUD /LWK NDV¸ N£VWL ‘WR GLJ’ 6ODY NRVD‘VF\WKH’ S¬UPMHUU ‘WR XULQDWH’ (3$ SHUPHJUD ,( PHL½K LG 6NW P©KDWL*NQ OGRKZY/DWPHLA21PJD T\U‘WRORRN’ (3$ NHZLUD *NMQGY‘WRQRWH’/DWFDYHA‘WREH DZDUH’*RWKKDXVMDQ‘WRKHDU’ VKRUU ‘WR SUHVV WRJHWKHU WR VTXHH]H’ (3$ VMUD +LWW LhLD ‘WR ELQG’6NWV\¢WL‘WRELQG’/LWKVHLM¸VLWLLG ;, FODVV 6WHPV LQ VM 7KLV LV DQRWKHU VPDOO FODVV RI YHUEV ZKRVH SUHVHQW VHHPV WR EH GHULYHG IURP RULJLQDO DRULVWLF RU IXWXUH VWHPV LQ
V MRVK‘WRFXUOWRIRQGOHWRFDUHVV’ (3$ MXGVMD ,( HXGK 6NW \·GK\DWH‘WRILJKWWRVWUXJJOH’7RFK$\XWN‘WRWDNHFDUHRIWR WURXEOHDERXW’/LWKM¢XGLQWL‘WRH[FLWHWRDURXVH’
morphology
193
QGHVK‘WRPHHW’ (3$ HQGDVMD *NFJY‘WRILQG’ THVK‘WRODXJK’ (3$ NDNVMD 6NWN¢NKDWLLG*NMCZC\YLG
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
V ,9$129 6ODY SDUDGLJP RI GKDVK¬ /,1'(0$1 )HVWVFKU .QREORFK *HUPDQLF SO SUHWHULW ZLWK OHQJWKHQLQJ + 8/' 3URF,;8&/$
&ODVV, VLJPDWLFDRULVWV7KHVLJPDWLFVXIIL[DSSHDUVLQ$OED QLDQDVVK (3$ VGXHWRWKHJHQHUDOL]DWLRQRI V! hGHULYHG XQGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKH“UXNL” UXOHLQVXFKDRULVWVDV UDXVD! UDXhD !UDVK¬,QVHFRQGDU\VLJPDWLFDRULVWVGHULYHGIURPSUHVHQWVWHPVZKLFK HQGLQRFFOXVLYHVVKEHFDPHç
$VLQRWKHU,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHVWKHVLJPDWLFDRULVWZDVDWKHPDWLF LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ 7KLV LV FOHDU IURP WKH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH SDUD GLJP’V VLQJXODU IRUPV ,Q WKH SOXUDO WKH IRUP RI WKH QG SHUVRQ LV DVLJPDWLFDQGDWKHPDWLF,WLVQRWFOHDUZKHWKHUWKHVWDQGGSHUVRQV HYHU KDG WKH VLJPDWLF VXIIL[ &I WKH UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH DRULVW SDUDGLJPRIGKDVK¬‘JDYH’
194
chapter three
VJ GKDVK¬ HGDVD HGiV GKH HGA V HGAVV GKD HGDVW HGiVW
SO GKDP¬ HGDPH HGi V PH GKDW¬ HGDWH HGiWH GKDQ¬ HGDQWL HGi V QWL
7KHDERYH SDUDGLJP LV VWULNLQJO\ FORVH WR WKH 6ODYLF VLJPDWLF DRULVW RI
GDWL‘WRJLYH’ LQWKHVLQJXODU VJ GD[Ù GAVVJ GD GAVV VJ GD GAVW =HURJUDGH ZKLFK DSSHDUV LQ WKH PDMRULW\ RI $OEDQLDQIRUPVLVOLNHO\WREHDQLQQRYDWLRQ :KLOH LQ VRPH GLDOHFWV VHFRQGDU\ VLJPDWLF DRULVWV EHFDPH YHU\ SURGXFWLYHRQO\DIHZVXFKIRUPVDUHROGDQGFRQWLQXH3URWR$OEDQLDQ VLJPDWLFIRUPV5HPDUNDEO\PDQ\RIWKHPDUHVXSSOHWLYHDVUHODWHGWR WKHSUHVHQWVWHPV GKDVK¬‘JDYH’ DRURIMDS (3$ HGDVD ,( GA‘WRJLYH’ ODVK¬‘OHIWOHWJR’ DRURIO¬~ ODˆ (3$ ODVD&RQQHFWLRQVIRUWKLV ZRUGDUHXQFHUWDLQ SDVK¬ ‘VDZ’ DRU RI VKRK ~ VKRI (3$ SDVD ,( S ‘WR SDVWXUHWRJXDUG’ UDVK¬ ‘IHOO’ DRU RI ELH (3$ UDXVD ,( UHX ‘WR WHDU’ 6NW U¢YDWH‘WRVPDVK’/DWUXA‘WRWHDUWRGLJRXW’ WKDVK¬ ‘VDLG’ DRU RI WKRP WVDQVD /DW FQVHA ‘WR DVVHVV WR YDOXH’ ,QRQHFDVHZKHUHWKHVLJPDWLFDRULVWLVZHOODWWHVWHGZHPXVWKRZHYHU LQWHUSUHWLWDVDQLQQRYDWLRQUHSODFLQJDQROGHUZDRULVWDVDWWHVWHGE\ ,WDOR$OEDQLDQ FRPSDUDWLYH HYLGHQFH 7KH LUUHJXODU YRFDOLVP DQG WKH XQXVXDO WKHPDWL]DWLRQ RI WKH VLJPDWLF DRULVW PDNH WKLV VFHQDULR PRUH OLNHO\ THVK¬‘ZDV’ DRURIMDP NOHVD ,( áHO‘WRWXUQ’&I,WDOR $OENOHYD‘ZDV’ NOHZD
&ODVV ,, DVLJPDWLF DRULVWV $VLJPDWLF DRULVWV LQ $OEDQLDQ DUH WKHPDWLF 7KLV IRUPDWLRQ LV KLJKO\ SURGXFWLYH RIWHQ UHSODFLQJ ROGHU DRULVWIRUPDWLRQV2QO\LQDIHZFDVHVFDQZHEHFHUWDLQWKDWDVLJPDWLF DRULVWVDUHRI3URWR$OEDQLDQRULJLQ
195
morphology
SUHVHQW
DRULVW
GXD~GXH NDP YLM~YLQM
GHVKD SDWD HUGKD
‘WRORYH’ ‘WRKDYH’ ‘WRFRPH’
7KLVLVDOVRWUXHRIDVLJPDWLFDRULVWVFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRYDULRXVSUHVHQWV LQ M&IWKHSUHVHQWVLQ WM SUHVHQW
DRULVW
çDUV N¬SXV PDV PEHV SUHV TLV VKHV XPDV
çDUWD N¬SXWD PDWD PEHWD SULWD TLWD VKLWD XPDWD
‘WRGHVWUR\WRVSRLO’ ‘WRWHDURIIWRSOXFN’ ‘WRPHDVXUH’ ‘WRUHPDLQWRVWD\’ ‘WRZDLWWRH[SHFW’ ‘WRSXOORXW’ ‘WRVHOO’ ‘WREDUN’
7KHVDPHLVWUXHRIYHUEVLQ QM ZLWKRUZLWKRXWWKHSUHFHGLQJYRZHO LQWKHVXIIL[ ZLWKROGDVLJPDWLFDRULVWV SUHVHQW
DRULVW
*HJ IVKDˆM *HJ JGKîM K\M~K\l M LN¬M SULM~SUîM
IVKDQD JGKLQD K\UD~K\QD LN¬QD SULQD
‘WRVLJK’ ‘WRVWD\DZDNHDWQLJKW’ ‘WRHQWHU’ ‘WRJRDZD\WRUXQDZD\’ ‘WROHDG’
9HUEV LQ DWM UHWDLQ WKHLU LQQRYDWLYH SUHVHQWV DQG WKH ROG IRUP RI DRULVWWRR SUHVHQW
DRULVW
J¬UVKDV N¬OWKDV N¬OODV S¬OFDV
JULVKD NOLWKD NDOOD SODVD
‘WRLQYLWH’ ‘WRFU\’ ‘WRSXWLQWR’ ‘WREXUVWWRH[SORGH’
196
chapter three
S¬OODV S¬UNDV Y¬UUDV
SDOOD SUHND YLUUD
‘WREUD\’ ‘WRWRXFK’ ‘WRVKRXW WREOHDW’
6HFRQGDU\ DVLJPDWLF DRULVWV DUH IDLUO\ SURGXFWLYH DQG FRUUHVSRQG WR VHYHUDO SUHVHQW FODVVHV 1XPHURXV DVLJPDWLF DRULVWV DUH IRUPHGIURPWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWVZLWKHJUDGHYRFDOLVP SUHVHQW
DRULVW
FHUN çHO GKHPE JMHUE JMHVK MHV YHVK
FHUND çHOD GKHPED JMHUED JMHVKD MHWD YHVKD
‘WRKLW’ ‘WRRSHQ’ ‘WRDFKH’ ‘WRJXOSWRGULQN’ ‘WRNQHDG’ ‘WRUHPDLQ’ ‘WRSXWRQ FORWKHV ’
$VLJPDWLF DRULVWV DUH SDUWLFXODUO\ IUHTXHQW LQ YHUEV KDYLQJ WKHPDWLF SUHVHQWVZLWKRWKHUDEODXWJUDGHVPDLQO\ZLWK]HURJUDGH SUHVHQW
DRULVW
FXUU ILN NUXS QGXN SLN SXWK XO
FXUUD ILND NUXSD QGXND SLND SXWKD XOD
‘WRSULFNXS HDUV ’ ‘WRH[WLQJXLVK RIILUH ’ ‘WRORDWKH’ ‘WRSOXFNRXW’ ‘WRILOOKROHVWRSLHUFH’ ‘WRNLVV’ ‘WRORZHU’
$OOQDVDOSUHVHQWVKDYHVHFRQGDU\DVLJPDWLFDRULVWV SUHVHQW
DRULVW
ELQG G\QG IHQG KXPE OLQG
ELQGD G\QGD IHQGD KXPED OLQGD
‘WRFRQYLQFHWRSHUVXDGH’ ‘WRVKDNH’ ‘WRIDUW’ ‘WROHDYH’ ‘WREHDUWREHJHW’
197
morphology
PXQG WXQG
PXQGD WXQGD
‘WREHDEOH’ ‘WRPRYHWRVWLU’
$OOSUHVHQWVLQ VNGHYHORSHGDVLJPDWLFDRULVWVZKLFKLQFRUSRUDWHGWKH VXIIL[ SUHVHQW
DRULVW
IVKHK~PVKHI JUDK~JUDI NUHK~NUHI PLK~PLI QGLK~QGLI QMHK~QMHI QMRK~QMRI SODK~SODI SUHK~SUHI
IVKHKD~PVKHID JUDKD~JUDID NUHKD~NUHID PLKD~PLID QGLKD~QGLID QMHKD~QMHID QMRKD~QMRID SODKD~SODID SUHKD~SUHID
‘WRKLGH’ ‘WRVSXURQ’ ‘WRFRPE’ ‘WRGLJWRKRH’ ‘WRKHOS’ ‘WRFRXQW’ ‘WRNQRZ’ ‘WRFRYHU’ ‘WRVKDUSHQ’
,QQRYDWLYH DRULVWV IRUPHG IURP SUHVHQWV LQ WM UHWDLQ WKH SUHVHQW VXIIL[WRR SUHVHQW
DRULVW
ODSV QGHV S¬UPE\V SODV TDV TRV UUDV
ODSVD QGHVD S¬UPE\VD SODVD TDVD TRVD UUDVD
‘WRH[KDXVWWRZDU\’ ‘WRKDYHWURXEOHV’ ‘WRRYHUWXUQ’ ‘WREXUVWWRVSOLW’ ‘WRDSSURDFK’ ‘WRHQGWRILQLVK’ ‘WRVTXHH]H’
&ODVV ,,, DVLJPDWLF DRULVWV ZLWK OHQJWKHQLQJ $QRWKHU YDULHW\
RI WKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DVLJPDWLF DRULVW LV FKDUDFWHUL]HG E\ WKH ORQJ JUDGH RI WKH URRW YRZHO ,( +LVWRULFDOO\ LW LV FRPSDUDEOH WR VRPHRIWKH,WDOLFSHUIHFWVUHIOHFWLQJWKHVDPHDEODXWJUDGHFI/DWHGA ‘WR HDW’ ~ G DV ZHOO DV *HUPDQLF DQG &HOWLF SUHWHULWV WKH *HUPDQLF IRUPV KRZHYHU PLJKW EH WKHU UHVXOW RI ROG UHGXSOLFDWHG IRUPV ,Q FHUWDLQ FDVHV WKLV VLPLODULW\ FDQ EH FRUURERUDWHG E\ DQ HW\PRORJLFDO HTXDWLRQFIIRUH[DPSOHPEOHGKDRUPEORGKD‘WRJDWKHUWRFROOHFW’
DPE L OHG]DDRUDPELOG]D /DWOHJADRUOJLG QGMHNDRUQGRTD
198
chapter three
ZLWK VHFRQGDU\ T ‘WR IROORZ’ HQWHND DRU HQWND 2,U WHFKLG ‘WRUXQ’SUHWW¢LFK 9HUEVHQGLQJLQYHODUVKDYHGHYHORSHGDVHFRQGDU\SDODWDOL]DWLRQRIWKH YHODU LQ WKHVH OHQJWKHQHG DRULVWV 2QH YHUE KDV JHQHUDOL]HG LW WR WKH SUHVHQWVWHP GHUJM DRUGRUJMD‘WROLHGRZQWROD\VLFNWREHLOO’,Q RQHFDVHDSUHVHQWVWHPZLWKH AZDVODWHUUHDQDO\]HGDVDOHQJWKHQHG JUDGH DRULVW NUHGK NUAGD ~ DRU NURGKD ‘WR SOXQJH WR LPPHUVH WR VWHHSWRVPRWKHUWREHVSDWWHU’ $RULVWV ZLWK OHQJWKHQLQJ DUH IRUPHG IURP WKHPDWLF SUHVHQWV ZLWK H JUDGH LQRQHFDVHZLWK]HURJUDGHFIGDO SUHVHQW
DRULVW
EMHUU EUHGK GDO GMHJ GMHUU GUHGK KHGK KHT~ KHN PEMHOO PEOHGK PMHO SMHN SMHN SMHOO SMHUGK SMHUU UMHS UUMHGK VMHOO VKTHUU VKWMHOO WMHUU WUHGK YGMHUU YMHGK
ERUUD‘WRORVH’ EURGKD‘WRMXPSWRVSULQJ’ GROD‘WRJRRXW’ GRJMD‘WREXUQ’ GRUD‘WRGHVWUR\’ GURGKD‘WRWXUQWRURWDWH’ KRGKD‘WRWKURZWRVKRRW’ KRTD~KRND‘WRGUDZWRSXOO’ PEROOD‘WRVRZ’ PEORGKD‘WRJDWKHUWRFROOHFW’ PROD‘WRPLON’ SRTD‘WREDNHWRFRRN’ SRTD‘WRWRXFKWRPHHW’ SROOD‘WREHJHWWRSURGXFHWREHDU’ SRUGKD‘WRIDUW’ SRUDSRUUD‘WREHQGWRLQFOLQH’ URSD‘WRVWULSRII VNLQRUEDUN WRWHDURII’ UURGKD‘WRIORZ’ VROOD‘WREULQJ’ VKTRUUD‘WRWHDU FORWK ’ VKWROOD‘WRWKURZ’ WRUUD‘WRVSLQ’ WURGKD‘WRFDVWUDWH’ YGRUUD‘WROHDYH’ YRGKD‘WRVWHDO’
199
morphology
YMHO YMHOO YMHUU ]YMHUGK
YROD‘WRSOXFN IUXLW WRYLQWDJH’ YROOD‘WRYRPLW’ YRUUD‘WRKDQJ’ ]YRUGKD‘WRZHDQ’
2QH DUFKDLF GHQRPLQDWLYH YHUE IURP DQ QVWHP IRUPV LWV DRULVW E\ OHQJWKHQLQJWKHURRWYRZHO SUHVHQW
DRULVW
PDUU
PRUD
‘WRWDNHWRJUDVS’
1RWHWKDWZKLOHSUHVHQWKDVUU UQWKHDRULVWRQO\KDVU,QRWKHU ZRUGVWKHDRULVWGRHVQRWUHWDLQWKHVXIIL[RIWKHSUHVHQWVWHP
&ODVV,9 DRULVWVLQ Z7KHVHIRUPVDUHJHQHWLFDOO\LGHQWLFDO
ZLWK/DWLQSHUIHFWVLQXY)XUWKHUFRQQHFWLRQVDUHQRWDVFOHDUEXW PD\LQFOXGHWKHVJ RIVRPH7RFKDULDQSUHWHULWVOLNH$yZ¥%yZD WKHVJRI6DQVNULWUHGXSOLFDWHGSHUIHFWVOLNHSDSDX‘WRGULQN’DVZHOO DVYDULRXVSUHWHULWVWHPVLQ%DOWR6ODYLFDQG*HUPDQLF 6ODY GDYDWL‘WR JLYH’ 2( ÈU¢ZDQ ‘WR GUDZ’ ,Q D IHZ FDVHV WKHVH SDUDOOHOV FDQ EH FRUURERUDWHG E\ HW\PRORJLFDO FRUUHVSRQGHQFHV FI IRU H[DPSOH DRU QMRYD‘WRNQRZ’ JQZD /DW J QAY2(FQ©RZ $RULVWVLQ ZDUHIRUPHGIURPSUHVHQWVLQ QMDVZHOODVVHFRQGDU\ SUHVHQWVLQ HQM LQM QMDQGWKHOLNH SUHVHQW
DRULVW
ERM GDM J¬ORM N¬UFHM NLM NUHM ODM~ODˆM PELM~PEîM UXDM~UXHM U\HM WKDM WK\HM
ERYD GDYD J¬ORYD N¬UFHYD NLYD NUHYD ODYD PELYD URYD UHYD WKDYD WKHYD
‘WRPDWH’ ‘WRGLYLGH’ ‘WREXUVWRXW’ ‘WRGDQFHWRMXPS’ ‘WRSUXQHWRWULP’ ‘WRSXOORXW’ ‘WRZDVK’ ‘WRWKULYHWRJURZ’ ‘WRJXDUGWRNHHS’ ‘WRVXIIHU’ ‘WRGU\’ ‘WREUHDN’
200
chapter three
,Q D IHZ SUHVXPDEO\ DUFKDLF FDVHV DRULVWV LQ Z FRUUHVSRQG WR SUHVHQWLQ WM SUHVHQW
DRULVW
GKMHV SUHV YUDV
GKMHYD SUHYD YUDYD
‘WRGHIHFDWH’ ‘WRFXW’ ‘WRNLOO’
7ZRYHUEVKDYHGHYHORSHGVHFRQGDU\DRULVWVLQ ZDVWKHLUSUHVHQWV ZHUHHUURQHRXVO\DQDO\]HGDVIRUPVLQ QM SUHVHQW
DRULVW
JGKLM~JGKîM SLSLM
JGKLYD~JGKLQD SLYD
‘WRVWD\DZDNHDWQLJKW’ ‘WRGULQNWRVXFN’
7KH YHUE QMRK ~ QMRI KDV DQ ROG DRULVW LQ Z QMRYD ZKLFK ILQGV SDUDOOHOV LQ RWKHU ,QGR(XURSHDQ ODQJXDJHV VHH DERYH ,W LV SUREDEOH WKDW DW RQH WLPH DOO SUHVHQWV LQ VN KDG DRULVWV LQ Z EXW ORVW WKHP ZKHQ WKH SUHVHQW VWHP LQ VN ZDV JHQHUDOL]HG DQG WUDQVIHUUHG WR WKH DRULVWV\VWHP
&ODVV9 DRULVWVLQ W7KLVVXIIL[LVKLVWRULFDOO\LGHQWLFDOZLWK WKHPDUNHURIWKH*HUPDQLFGHQWDOSUHWHULWRIZHDNYHUEVDQGWKH&HOWLF GHQWDO SUHWHULW 'HVSLWH WKH SUH$OEDQLDQ RULJLQV RI DRULVWV LQ W ROG IRUPVRIWKLVFODVVDUHYHU\UDUH2OGDRULVWVLQ WZHUHGHULYHGIURP WKHPDWLFSUHVHQWVZLWKVXIIL[ MEDVHGRQURRWVHQGLQJLQYRZHOV7KH DUFKDLVP RI WKHVH IRUPV LV VWUHVVHG E\ WKH IDFW WKDW RQH RI WKH DRULVWV IOHW¬ DZDOH L WD RÆROH L W LVDWKHPDWLF SUHVHQW
DRULVW
GL IOH~IOê QJUH
GLWD IOHW¬IMHWD QJULWD
‘WRNQRZ’ ‘WRVOHHS’ ‘WROLIWWRUDLVH’
7KH VXIIL[ W EHFDPH H[WUHPHO\ SURGXFWLYH LQ DRULVWV IRUPHG IURP SUHVHQWVLQ QM,WZDVDGGHGGLUHFWO\WRWKHVXIIL[RIWKHSUHVHQWDQG DVDUHVXOWDQHZVXIIL[RIDRULVWMWLQZKLFKVXIIL[HVRISUHVHQWDQG DRULVWPHUJHGZDVFUHDWHG
201
morphology
SUHVHQW
DRULVW
EXM~EûM F¬ULM GUXDM~GUXHM JMDM OXDM~OXHM TXDM~TXHM U\M UUHM~UUêM
EXMWD~EûMWD F¬ULWD GUXDMWDGURMWD JMDYDJMDMWD ORMWD~OXHMWD TXDMWD~TXHMWD U\MWD UUHMWD
‘WRDFFRPRGDWH DJXHVW ’ ‘WRPHOWEXWWHU’ ‘WREHDIUDLG’ ‘WRUHVHPEOH’ ‘WRPRYHWRVKDNH’ ‘WRFDOOWRJLYHDQDPH’ ‘WRHQWHU’ ‘WRGHFHLYH’
9HUEVWHPVRIORDQZRUGV 9HUEVERUURZHGWR/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQIURPRWKHUODQJXDJHV ZHUH PRUSKRORJLFDOO\ DGDSWHG WR H[LVWLQJ SDWWHUQV RI $OEDQLDQ PRUSKRORJ\ 7KHPDMRULW\RI/DWLQYHUEVLQUHZHUHWUDQVIRUPHGWRVWHPV LQ QMFIIRUH[DPSOH G¬IWRM‘WRVKRZWRSRLQW’Õ5RP LQGLFWUHLG I¬UNRM‘WRUXE’Õ/DWIULFUHLG JXOWRM‘WRJHWULGRII’Õ/DWFROOXFWUL‘WRVWUXJJOHWRFRQWHQG’ N¬QGRM‘WRVLQJ’Õ/DWFDQWUHLG O¬VKRM‘WROHWWROHDYHWRIUHH’Õ/DWODVVUH‘WRUHQGHUIDLQWWRWLUH
WROHW’ P¬QJRM‘WRULVHHDUO\’Õ/DWPQLFUH‘WRFRPHLQWKHPRUQLQJ’ QGLNRM‘WRLQIOXHQFH’Õ/DWLQGFUH‘WRLPSRVHWRLQIOLFW’ SHQGRM‘WRUHSHQW’Õ/DWSRHQLWHUHLG VKNDUNRM‘WRXQORDG’Õ GLVFDUULFUHLG XURM‘WRZLVKOXFNWRFRQJUDWXODWHWRDGRUH GHLW\ ’ $PXFKVPDOOHUJURXSRIYHUEVLQUH XVXDOO\ZLWKWKHVWHPHQGLQJLQ OLTXLGVRULQ/DWLM DSSHDUVLQ$OEDQLDQZLWKWKHVXIIL[ HQM VK¬IUHMVKXIUHM‘WRVXIIHU’Õ/DWVXIIHUUHLG P¬U]HM ‘WR UHVW DW QRRQ RI DQLPDOV ’ Õ /DW PHULGLUH ‘WR WDNH D PLGGD\QDS’ VKHPE¬OOHM‘WRUHVHPEOH’Õ/DWVLPLOUHLG
202
chapter three
VKN¬PEHM‘WRFKDQJHWRH[FKDQJH’Õ5RP H[FDPELUHLG VKS¬UHM‘WRKRSH’Õ/DWVSHUUHLG WXUVKHM‘WREUHDNWRGHVWUR\’Õ5RP WU VLUH‘WRSXVKWRVWLU’ ,QRQHFDVHDYHUELQUHZDVDGDSWHGDVDWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWGHVSLWHWKH IDFWWKDWLWDOVRKDVDYDULDQWLQRM G¬OLUG¬OLURM‘WRFOHDQWRFOHDQVHWRGHOLYHU’Õ5RP GHOLEHUUH ,QDQRWKHU SUHVXPDEO\ODWH FDVH/DWUHZDVVXEVWLWXWHGE\DV VKW¬UUDVVKW¬UURM‘WRGLPLQLVKWRVKULQN’Õ/DWH[WHQXUH‘WRPDNH VPDOOHU’
2OGHU ORDQZRUGV FRQWLQXLQJ /DWLQ YHUEV LQ UH UHSODFH WKH VXIIL[ZLWKRM çRM‘WREULQJWRULVHWRVHQG’Õ/DWH[FUHH[FLUH‘WRFDOORXWWR FDXVHWRZDNH’ PEORM‘WRILOO’Õ/DWLPSOUHLG TRM‘WRZDNHXS’Õ/DWFLUH‘WRPRYHWRDJLWDWH’ /DWHUYHUEVLQUHZHUHDGDSWHGDVVWHPVLQ HQM QGMHM QG¬OHM ‘WR SDUGRQ WR IRUJLYH’ Õ /DW LQGXOJUH ‘WR EH LQGXOJHQWWRFRQFHGH’ S¬OTHM‘WRSOHDVH’Õ/DWSODFUHLG UU¬QJMHM‘WRVKLQH’Õ/DWUHQGUH‘WRVKLQH’ XUUHM‘WRKDWH’Õ/DWKRUUUH‘WREHDIUDLGWREHDVWRQLVKHG’ YMHM~YLM‘WRQHHG’Õ/DWYDOUH‘WREHDEOHWREHKHDOWK\’
7KHPDMRULW\RI/DWLQYHUEVRIWKH,,,FRQMXJDWLRQDVVXPHGWKH
VXIIL[ QMLQ$OEDQLDQ
EHNRM‘WREHQHGLFW’Õ/DWEHQHGFHUHLG I¬UJRM‘WRURDVWWRIU\’Õ/DWIUJHUHLG NDIVKRM‘WRELWH’Õ/DWFDSHVVHUH~FDSLVVHUH‘WRVHL]HWRVQDWFKDW’ PDOONRM‘WRFXUVHWRH[FRPPXQLFDWH’Õ/DWPDOHGFHUHLG P¬UJRM‘WRH[LOHWRGULYHDZD\’Õ/DWPHUJHUH‘WRWKUXVWWRSXVK’
morphology
203
QJXUURM‘WRKHVLWDWHWRIDOWHUWRVWRS’Õ/DWLQFXUUHUH‘WRFRPPLW D IDXOW ’ SUHPWRM‘WRSURPLVH’Õ/DWSUAPLWWHUH‘WRIRUERGHWRSURPLVH’ VKWU¬QJRM‘WRSUHVVWRVTXHH]H’Õ/DWVWULQJHUH‘WRVWUHWFKWRSUHVV WRVTXHH]H’ WUDVK¬JRM‘WRLQKHULW’Õ/DWWUQVLJHUH‘WRUHDFKDQDFFRUGWRFDUU\ RXWWUDQVDFWLRQ’ ,QDIHZ ROG FDVHVHUHLVUHQGHUHGDVHM PDOO¬QJMHM ‘WR WRXFK WR PRYH WR VWLU’ Õ /DW PDOXP DQJHUH ‘WR FDXVHSDLQ’ UU¬PEHM‘WRUREWRVHL]H’Õ/DWUXPSHUH‘WRWHDUWRWHDUDZD\’
/DWLQ YHUEV LQUH DUH XVXDOO\ UHSUHVHQWHG E\ $OEDQLDQ VWHPV LQ LQM SULM~SUîM‘WROHDG’Õ/DWSUDHUH‘WROHDGWRSUHFHGH’ TLM‘WRFRSXODWHWRKDYHVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH’Õ/DWFRUHLG VK¬OOLM~VK¬OOî‘WRVDOW’Õ/DWVDOUHLG YLM~YLQM‘WRFRPH’Õ/DWYHQUHLG 2QFHUHLVVXEVWLWXWHGE\HM VK¬UEHM‘WRVHUYH’Õ/DWVHUYUHLG
1HDUO\DOO6ODYLFYHUEVZHUHWUDQVIRUPHGLQWRSUHVHQWVWHPVLQ
WM1XPHURXV6ODYLFYHUEVLQ LWLDSSHDULQ$OEDQLDQDVYHUEVLQLV
JUDELV‘WRVWHDOWRURE’Õ6ODY JUDELWLLG PROLV‘WRPDNHWLUHGWRZHDNHQ’Õ6ODY PÙGÚOLWLLG QHYHULV‘WRGHVHUWWRQHJOHFW’Õ6ODY QHYpULWL‘QRWWREHOLHYH’ SRQLV‘WRKRQRUWRUHVSHFW’Õ6ODY SRPÚQLWL‘WRUHPHPEHU’ UDGLV‘WRSUHSDUHWRPDNHUHDG\ RIIRRG ’Õ6ODY UDGLWL‘WRVHWWOH WRDUUDQJHWRPDNHUHDG\’ VW¬UYLV‘WRWUDLQ’Õ6ODY VWÚUYLWL‘WREDLWWROXUHWRWUDLQ’ WXULV ‘WR IULJKWHQ RII DQLPDOV ’ Õ 6ODY WXULWL ‘WR GULYH DZD\ WR FKDVH’ YDGLV‘WRZDWHUWRLUULJDWH’Õ6ODY YDGLWLLG
204
chapter three
2QHYHUELQLWLZDVPRYHGWRWKHSUHVHQWFODVVLQDV JRGDV‘WRVWULNHWREHDW’Õ6ODY JRGLWLLG
7KH PDMRULW\ RI 6ODYLF YHUEV LQ DWL EHFDPH VWHPV LQ DV LQ $OEDQLDQ EXçDV‘WRURDUWRWKXQGHU’Õ6ODY EX¨DWLLG GLKDV‘WRSDQW’Õ6ODY G\[DWL‘WREUHDWKH’ KLWDV‘WRKXUU\’Õ6ODY [\WDWLLG NDUNDV‘WRTXDFN’Õ6ODY NÙUNDWL‘WRFDZWRFURDNWRTXDFN’ OXKDV‘WRURFNWRVZD\WRVZLQJ’Õ6ODY O’X[DWL‘WRVWULNH’ QXKDV‘WRVPHOOWRVQLII’Õ6ODY Q’X[DWLLG SLVNDV‘WRVKRXWWRFU\’Õ6ODY SLVNDWL‘WRSHHS’ $ IHZ YHUEV LQ DWL ZHUH WUDQVIHUUHG WR WKH PRUH SURGXFWLYH W\SH RI VWHPVLQLVLW OHEHWLV‘WRWUHPEOHWRVKXGGHUWREHIULJKWHQHG’Õ6ODY OHEHWDWL‘WR WUHPEOH’ P¬UP¬ULV‘WRPXUPXUWRPXWWHU’Õ6ODY PÙUPÙUDWLLG VK¬WLW‘WRJRIRUDZDON’Õ6ODY h?WDWL‘WRZDON’
6HYHUDOVPDOOHUJURXSVRI6ODYLFYHUEVDOVRDSSHDULQ$OEDQLDQ DVVWHPVLQLVLW YHQLWHP‘WRSDOHWRZDQH’Õ6ODY Y?Q_WLLG Y¬UWLW‘WRWXUQ’Õ6ODY YÚUWpWLLG Y¬UYLW‘WRKXUOWRIOLQJ’Õ6ODY YÚUYpWLLG 7KHROGHVWOD\HURI6ODYLFORDQZRUGVLQFOXGHVWZRYHUEVZLWKWKHVXIIL[
QM JDWXDM ~ JDWXHM ‘PDNH UHDG\ SUHSDUH’ Õ 6ODY JRWRYDWL JRWRYLWL ‘PDNHUHDG\SUHSDUH’ S¬J¬M~SXJDˆM‘WRPDNHGLUW\WRVRLO’Õ6ODY SRJDQLWLLG
morphology
205
&RQMXJDWLRQ 7KH $OEDQLDQ FRQMXJDWLRQ LV RI JUHDW LPSRUWDQFH IRU WKH KLVWRULFDO JUDPPDU RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ 7RJHWKHU ZLWK PXOWLSOH LQQRYDWLRQV LW FRQWDLQVDUFKDLVPVWKDWDUHVFDUFHO\DWWHVWHGHOVHZKHUH
3UHVHQW Two types of present conjugation are known in Albanian and Proto-Albanian: thematic and (rarely attested) athematic. /LWHUDWXUH %(/,C´ *6.$&;/9,,, LQMXQFWLYHDVDVRXUFHRI VJ SUHVHQW :$7.,16 *HVFKLFKWH VJ LQ &HOWLF DQG *HUPDQLF +$03$QF,( DWKHPDWLFSUHVHQW 6<729*UVWU WKHPDWLF YRZHO LQ DQG SO 0 $11 +LVW *U SO QL FRPSDUHG ZLWK +LWW SO ZHQL SO WHQL %$'(5 %6/ /;;, SUHVHQW RI WKH YHUEXP VXEVWDQWLYXP ,9$129 6ODY VRXUFHV RI WKH HQGLQJ RI VJ . 257/$1'7 /LQJXD ;/,; %DOWR6ODYLF SUHVHQW 25(/ /LQJY LVVO ,, ÈWLPRORJLMD %DOWLVWLFD;;,=I%DON;;,,
The thematic present in Albanian cannot continue the IndoEuropean thematic present with its primaryHQGLQJV,( ARIWKHVJ ZRXOGKDYHJLYHQ$OEH LIVWUHVVHG RU¬ LIXQVWUHVVHG ,( HWLRIWKH VJ ZRXOG KDYH JLYHQ $OE HW 7KH PDMRULW\ RI IRUPV LQ WKH SUHVHQW SDUDGLJPLQ$OEDQLDQJREDFNWRDGLIIHUHQWVRXUFH,QSDUWLFXODULQWKH IRUPV RI WKH VLQJXODU RQH FDQ RQO\ UHFRQVWUXFW 3URWR$OEDQLDQ VKRUW YRZHOVIROORZHGRUQRWIROORZHGE\DFRQVRQDQW 7KHPRVWSODXVLEOHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUVJNDS‘WRVHL]H’LV(3$ NDSD 7KHHQGLQJ DLVGHULYHGIURP,( RPDGHVLQHQFHFORVHWR7RFK$ DP GLDOHFWDO,( RPFIDOVRTXLWHSUREDEO\6ODYVJSUHV _ :HDNHUDOWHUQDWLYHH[SODQDWLRQVLQFOXGH(3$ D ,( ARUSHUIHFWLYH
ZLWK D VHFRQGDU\ P DGGHG YLD DQDORJ\ $V WR WKH VJ NDS LW PLJKWEHGHULYHGIURP(3$ NDSHV WKRXJKQRW NDSHVL 7KHVJ NDS OLNHZLVH FRQWLQXHV NDSHW ,Q RWKHU ZRUGV DOO WKH IRUPV RI WKH VLQJXODU LQ WKH $OEDQLDQ WKHPDWLF SUHVHQW KDYH WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ secondary HQGLQJV7KH\GRQRWFRQWLQXHWKH,QGR(XURSHDQSUHVHQWDW OHDVWDVLWLVUHFRQVWUXFWHGLQWKHFODVVLFDOYHUVLRQRI,QGR(XURSHDQ ,QWKHSOXUDOWKHVLWXDWLRQLVVRPHZKDWPRUHFRPSOLFDWHG7KHHQGLQJRI WKHSOP ¬ FDQFRQWLQXHHLWKHU PHRU PHV7KHSOHQGLQJQ ¬
206
chapter three
FDQRQO\UHIOHFWWKHprimaryHQGLQJ QWL YDULDQWVP~ P¬DQGQ~ Q¬ DUHFRQGLWLRQHGE\WKHDXVODXWVRXQGRIWKHYHUEDOVWHP ,QERWKIRUPV WKHRULJLQDOWKHPDWLFYRZHO RZDVUHSODFHGE\LWKRXJKWKHUHDVRQLV XQFOHDU$VWUXFWXUDOIDFWRUFDQQRWEHH[FOXGHGKHUH DQROGRSSRVLWLRQ EHWZHHQWKHPDWLFYRZHOV HDQG RFRXOGKDYHEHHQUHSODFHGE\DQHZ DOWHUQDWLRQ H L $QRWKHU SRVVLEOH H[SODQDWLRQ LV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK WKH LQQRYDWLYH IRUPV RI SUHVHQWV LQ QM FI N¬UNRM ‘WR ORRN IRU’ - SO N¬UNRMP¬SON¬UNRMQ¬ZLWKRMRIWKHVJWUDQVIHUUHGWRWKHSOXUDODV D QHZ WKHPDWLF HOHPHQW 7KHPDWLF L PLJKW WKHQ EH GHULYHG IURP WKH SOXUDOVRIYHUEVLQLFISL‘WRGULQN’SOSLP¬SOSLQ¬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‘JHW WLHG’ DUH HTXDOO\ SRVVLEOH ,W VHHPV WKDW QL PXVW RULJLQDOO\ KDYH EHHQ D V\QWDFWLFDOO\ DXWRQRPRXV HOHPHQW D FOLWLF ZKLFK ZDV DW D FHUWDLQ VWDJH LQFRUSRUDWHG LQWR WKH YHUE7KHYHUEIRUPLWVHOIPXVWKDYHEHHQ OLGK,QRWKHUZRUGVWKH VJ DQG SO RI WKH WKHPDWLF SUHVHQW ZHUH LGHQWLFDO 7KLV FRXOG EH LQWHUSUHWHGDVD3URWR$OEDQLDQLQQRYDWLRQWKDWPHUJHGWKHVJDQG SOE\UHSODFLQJWKHODWWHUZLWKWKHVLQJXODUIRUP 7KH RULJLQ RI QL LV QRW FOHDU 2QH FRXOG GHULYH LW IURP WKH 3URWR $OEDQLDQ DGYHUE Q ‘QRZ’ LGHQWLFDO ZLWK ,( Q 6NW Q *N PW DQG WKH OLNH 2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG ZH FDQQRW LJQRUH D FHUWDLQ DV\PPHWU\ LQ WKHVWUXFWXUHRISSUHVHQWRIWKHPDWLFVWHPVDQG QMVWHPV VJ
SO
OLGK N¬UNRQ
OLGKQL N¬UNRQL
morphology
207
,I WKH IRUP N¬UNRQL GRHV QRW FRQWLQXH HDUOLHU N¬UNRQQL RQH FRXOG DVVXPHWKDWLWVRULJLQDOVWUXFWXUHZLWKILQDOLZDVUHLQWHUSUHWHGDQGWKH QHZO\FUHDWHGPRUSKHPHQLZDVWUDQVIHUUHGWRRWKHUW\SHVRISUHVHQW 7KH HOHPHQW L FRXOG WKHQ JR EDFN WR DQ DOOHJUR YDULHW\ RI (3$ MX V ‘\RX’QRUPDOO\DWWHVWHGDVMXLGFRUUHVSRQGLQJWR/LWKM
VLG*RWKMXV LG*NW OGK`XLG6NWDFF\X¿PdQLG 7KHSDUDGLJPRIWKHWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWRIWKHYHUENDS‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVS’ FDQEHUHFRQVWUXFWHGDVIROORZV
VJ
SO
NDSD NDSRP
NDSH V NDSHV
NDSHW NDSHW
NDSDPH V NDSRPH V
NDSH V Q NDSH V MX
NDSDQWL NDSRQWL
The athematic present has been described in 3.1.1.1. Most of its
forms (1-3 sg. and 1, 3 pl.) stem from the primary HQGLQJV ZLWK WKH HQGLQJ RI WKH SO ILQGLQJ DQ LQWHUHVWLQJ SDUDOOHO LQ %DOWLF DQG FRUUHVSRQG WR WKH DWKHPDWLF FRQMXJDWLRQ RI RWKHU ,QGR(XURSHDQ ODQJXDJHV&IWKH3URWR$OEDQLDQSDUDGLJPUHFRQVWUXFWHGIRUWKHYHUE MDP‘WREH’
VJ
SO
HVPL
HVVL
HQVWL HVWL
HVPHL
HVVLQ HVVLMX
HVQWL
2WKHUDWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWVIROORZWKHVDPHSDWWHUQ7KHRQO\LQWHUHVWLQJ H[FHSWLRQ LV WKRP ‘WR VD\’ ZKRVH SO WKRW¬ FDQQRW EH GHULYHG IURP
WVQVWL EXW UDWKHU FRQWLQXHV WV Q WL ZKLFK LV KLVWRULFDOO\ LGHQWLFDO ZLWK23HUVSWL\LG ,Q FRQWUDVW WR WKH $OEDQLDQ WKHPDWLF SUHVHQW ZKLF RULJLQDWHV IURP DQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ SDUDGLJP WKDW KDV QRWKLQJ WR GR ZLWK WKH SUHVHQW WKH DWKHPDWLF SUHVHQW LQ $OEDQLDQ GRHV FRQWLQXH WKH ROG ,QGR(XURSHDQ SUHVHQWFRQMXJDWLRQ
208
chapter three
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¬ /$0%(57= ,) /; VRXUFHVRI VJDRU D IROORZV 0(<(5 LQ WKH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI WKH LPSHUIHFW '20, 5(6O ;/9 VJ DRU D DV DQ LQQRYDWLRQ UHSODFLQJ¬ 6<729*UVWU LPSHUIHFWRIMDP 0$11 +LVW*U LPSHUIHFW FRPSDUHV DVLJPDWLF DRULVW ZLWK WKH ,WDOLFSHUIHFW VJLPSIWHH[SODLQHGDVDSURQRPLQDOHOHPHQW '(0,5$- )HVWVFKU .QREORFK RQ WKH RULJLQV RI SHUIHFW RI WKH KDEHRVFULSWXPW\SH
7KH LQLWLDO GK RI GKDVK¬ DRULVW RI MDS ‘WR JLYH’ FDQ RQO\ EH
H[SODLQHGDVWKHUHVXOWRILQWHUYRFDOLFVSLUDQWL]DWLRQ,WV3URWR$OEDQLDQ DQFHVWRU PXVW KDYH EHHQ SUHFHGHG E\ D YRZHO 7KLV YRZHO ZDV OLNHO\ (3$ H ,( HWKHDXJPHQWDWWHVWHGLQ,QGR,UDQLDQ*UHHN3KU\JLDQ DQG$UPHQLDQ,QRWKHUDRULVWLFIRUPVLWZDVORVWDQGLWVSKRQHWLFHIIHFWV ZHUHREOLWHUDWHG 6LQJXODUIRUPVRIWKHDVLJPDWLFDRULVWDUHQRWYHU\RSDTXH,QPRGHUQ VWDQGDUG$OEDQLDQWKHDVLJPDWLFDRULVWKDVWKHIROORZLQJHQGLQJVLQWKH VLQJXODU DHLHJWKHYHUE‘WRJUDVSWRVHL]H’ZLOODSSHDULQ WKHDRULVWDVNDSDNDSHNDSL VJDFDQKDUGO\EHSURMHFWHGWRWKH3URWR$OEDQLDQSDUDGLJP,QGHHG HYHQ WKRXJK WKH SDUDGLJP RI WKH LPSHUIHFW UHSHDWV WKH HQGLQJV RI WKH DVLJPDWLFDRULVWLWKDVDGLIIHUHQWHQGLQJLQVJQDPHO\¬7KDWPD\ EHEHWKHROGHUIRUPRIWKHVJDRULVWWRR 2QO\WKHVJLVOLNHO\WREHLQKHULWHGGLUHFWO\IURP3URWR$OEDQLDQ$V IDUDVWKHVJLVFRQFHUQHGWKHUHDUHIRUPVZLWKRXWLDPRQJGLDOHFWV LH NDS LQVWHDG RI NDSL DQG VRPH YDULDQWV RI WKH OLWHUDU\ VWDQGDUG
209
morphology
PRUL DQG PXDUU VJ DRULVW RI PDUU ‘WR WDNH’ GROL DQG GXDO VJ DRULVWRIGDO‘WRJRRXW’ 0RUHRYHUWKHUHLVQRLLQWKHZDRULVWDQG WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ PHGLRSDVVLYH ,Q VKRUW WKHUH DUH VHULRXV UHDVRQV WR EHOLHYHWKDWWKHLLVVHFRQGDU\LQWKHVJDQGWKDWLWVEDVLFIRUPKDGD ]HURHQGLQJLHNDSUDWKHUWKDQNDSL$VWRWKHRULJLQRIWKHPRUSKHPH L LW KDV EHHQ VXJJHVWHG WKDW LW EH GHULYHG IURP (3$ LV LQGLUHFWO\" IURP,( LV ,QWKHDQGSOWKHDVLJPDWLFDRULVWKDVHQGLQJVZKLFKFRLQFLGHZLWK WKRVHRIWKHSUHVHQW7KHSOP ¬ FRQWLQXHVWKHPDWLF(3$ DPH ,( RPH SO Q ¬ JRHV EDFN WR primary (3$ DQWL ,( RQWL UHPDUNDEO\ HQRXJK $OEDQLDQ KDV QR WUDFHV RI D secondary HQGLQJ LQ WKHSODQ\ZKHUH 8QOLNHWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJSUHVHQWIRUPWKHSORI WKHDVLJPDWLFDRULVWKDVW¬GHULYHGGLUHFWO\IURP(3$ HWH ,( HWH 7KHSDUDGLJPRIWKHDVLJPDWLFDRULVWLVRSSRVHGWRWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWLQ WZR ZD\V DFFHQWXDOO\ DV LW UHIOHFWV D PRELOH DFFHQWXDO SDUDGLJP LWV PRELOLW\ FDXVHG E\ WKH DXJPHQW" DQG VWUXFWXUDOO\ LQ YLHZ RI WKH DXJPHQW DQG D GLVWLQFW DRULVW VWHP DW OHDVW LQ WKH PRUH DUFKDLF VWHPV SDUDGLJPFDQEHUHFRQVWUXFWHGDVIROORZV VJ
SO
HNDS¢ HNDS R P HNDSDPH HNDSRPH
HNDS© V HNDSHV HNDSHWH HNDSHWH
HN¢SHW HNDSHW HNDSDQWL HNDSRQWL
7KH SDUDGLJP RI WKH VLJPDWLF DRULVW LV DWKHPDWLF $V DOUHDG\ PHQWLRQHG DERYH LWV VLQJXODU LV UHPDUNDEO\ FORVH WR WKDW RI WKH 6ODYLF VLJPDWLFDRULVWZLWKRQHLPSRUWDQWH[FHSWLRQDGLIIHUHQWDEODXWJUDGH =HUR JUDGH LQ WKH PDMRULW\ RI $OEDQLDQ IRUPV FDQ EH H[SODLQHG DV WKH LQIOXHQFHRIFRUUHVSRQGLQJSDUWLFLSOHVFIWKHSDUWLFLSOHRIMDS‘WRJLYH’ GK¬Q¬~ GKDQ¬ (3$ GDQWL ,( GiQWL $W OHDVW RQH IRUP LQ WKH SDUDGLJP LV DVLJPDWLF WKH SO 2WKHU SOXUDO IRUPVFRXOGEHVLJPDWLFRUDVLJPDWLFDVZHFDQQRWPDNHDGHWHUPLQD WLRQDERXWLWE\SKRQHWLFPHDQV $W\SLFDOSDUDGLJPLVUHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHDRULVWRIMDS
210
chapter three
VJ GKDVK¬ HGDVD HGiV GKH HGA V HGAVV GKD HGDVW HGiVW
SO GKDP¬ HGD V PH HGi V PH GKDW¬ HGDWH HGiWH GKDQ¬ HGD V QWL HGi V QWL
7KH SDUDGLJP RI WKH VLJPDWLF DRULVW LQ $OEDQLDQ FRPELQHV IHDWXUHV VSHFLILFWR%DOWR6ODYLFZLWKDWWULEXWHVRI6RXWKHDVWHUQ,QGR(XURSHDQ VXFKDVDXJPHQW
7KH HQGLQJV RI WKH LPSHUIHFW DUH LGHQWLFDO ZLWK WKRVH RI DVLJPDWLF DRULVW $W WKH VDPH WLPH WKH LPSHUIHFW VWHP ZDV RULJLQDOO\ LGHQWLFDOZLWKWKDWRIWKHSUHVHQW+RZHYHUDWDODWHVWDJHWKLVVWHPZDV PRGLILHGGXHWRWKHH[SDQVLRQRIWKHQHZXPODXWDOWHUQDWLRQH L7KH PDMRULW\ RI LPSHUIHFW VWHPV DVVXPHG D QHZ YRZHO L UHSODFLQJ WKH RULJLQDO YRZHO (3$ H 7KH DUFKDLF YRZHO KDV EHHQ SUHVHUYHG LQ GLDOHFWV 7KXV LQ WKH LPSHUIHFW RI MDP ZH ILQG VWDQGDUG $OEDQLDQ LVKD ZLWKLQQRYDWLYHLRSSRVHGWR&KDPLDQMHVK¬ZLWKRULJLQDO H!MH 7KHLPSHUIHFWRIMDPFRQWLQXHVWKH,QGR(XURSHDQLPSHUIHFWRI HV,WV VJLVKDLVDWKHPDWLFDQGFDQEHGLUHFWO\FRPSDUHGZLWK6NWVDP*N J_C EXW WKH UHVW RI WKH SDUDGLJP LV WKHPDWLF +HQFH WKH VJ LVK¬ UHSUHVHQWV D WKHPDWL]DWLRQ RI HHVV ! 6NW V 7KH FRQMXJDWLRQ RI WKH LPSHUIHFW FDQ EH UHFRQVWUXFWHG DV IROORZV WKH VHFRQG IRUPV DUH &KDPLDQ LVKDMHVK¬ HVD HV LVK¬MHVK¬ HVH V HVHV LVK WH HVHW HVHW
LVKLPMHVK¬P HVDPH HVRPH LVKLWMHVK¬W¬ HVHWH HVHWH LVKLQLVKQ¬ HVDQWL HVRQWL
,Q WKH VJ WZR YDULDQWV RI WKH LPSHUIHFW FRH[LVW LVK DQG LVKWH 7KH ODWWHU LV REYLRXVO\ VHFRQGDU\ DQG UHVXOWV IURP WKH XQLYHUEDWLRQ RI WKH RULJLQDOLPSHUIHFWIRUPZLWKDSURQRPLQDOHOHPHQWWH7KHODWWHUFDQEH GHULYHGIURP(3$ WAG ,( WAGZKLFKDSSHDUVLQDVLPLODUIXQFWLRQ LQWKHIXWXUHLPSHUDWLYHFI6NW¢MDWG‘ \RXKH PXVWOHDG’/DWDJLWA 7KH GHYHORSPHQW RI V WR VK LQ WKH LPSHUIHFW RI MDP LV SKRQHWLFDOO\ LUUHJXODU +RZHYHU WKHUH DUH QR UHDVRQV WR UHFRQVWUXFW V KHUH $SSDUHQWO\ VFKDQJHGWRVKLQWKRVHLPSHUIHFWV ODWHUUHSODFHGE\ QHZ LPSHUIHFW IRUPV ZKHUH LW IROORZHG L DQG X $ VLPLODU SURFHVV
211
morphology
FDQ EH REVHUYHG LQ 6ODYLF ZKHUH WKH [ V RI DRULVWV DQG LPSHUIHFWVZDVJHQHUDOL]HGIDUEH\RQGWKHRULJLQDOOLPLWVRIWKH“UXNL” UXOH ,Q VHYHUDO YHUE FODVVHV WKH RULJLQDO LPSHUIHFW HJ SLTD RI SMHN ‘WR FRRN’ QGLTD RI QGMHN ‘WR IROORZ’ ZDV UHSODFHG E\ QHZ IRUPV ZLWK VXIIL[M SLTMDQGLTMD7KLVVXIIL[LVWKHUHVXOWRIDQHZPRUSKRORJLFDO VHJPHQWDWLRQRILPSHUIHFWVRIQMYHUEVLQZKLFKMZDVUHLQWHUSUHWHG DV DQDX[LOLDU\PRUSKHPHRIWKHLPSHUIHFW VJSUHV
VJLPSI
N¬UNRM N¬UNRM
N¬UNRMD N¬UNRMD
,Q *HJ WKHUH H[LVWV DQRWKHU SDUDGLJP RI DQ LPSHUIHFW LQ VK 7KLV VXIIL[LVDWWHVWHGLQDOOIRUPVH[FHSWIRUVJZKHUHLWRQO\DSSHDUVLQ VRPH RI WKH GLDOHFWV 7KH VXIIL[ VK FRPHV IURP WKH SDUDGLJP RI WKH VLJPDWLFDRULVWDVWKH D[ÙRIWKH6ODYLFLPSHUIHFW
0RRGV ,PSHUDWLYHVXEMXQFWLYHRSWDWLYH $OEDQLDQQRQLQGLFDWLYHPRRGVDUHPRVWO\LQQRYDWLRQV2QO\D VPDOOSDUWRIWKHLUVWUXFWXUHUHIOHFWVLQKHULWHG,QGR(XURSHDQIRUPV /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5 $OE *U H[SODLQV RSWDWLYH IURP /DWLQ SOXVTXDPSHUIHFWXP *21'$ 0RRGV 2OG ,QGLDQ VXE MXQFWLYH .85</2:,&= ,QIO &DW 0$11 +LVW *U VXEMXQFWLYHH[SODLQHGIURPWKHROGRSWDWLYH RSWDWLYH LPSHUDWLYH ,9$129 6ODY LPSHUDWLYHHMDWR/XZLMD‘FRPH’ -$6$12)) *HGHQNVFKU &RZJLOO RQ ,( DQG 7RFKDULDQ LPSHUDWLYHV
7KH LPSHUDWLYH LV IRUPHG IURP WKH VWHP RI WKH LPSHUIHFW DQG WKHSOSUHVHQWLQRWKHUZRUGVLWUHIOHFWVWKHDOWHUQDWLRQH LWKDWKDV WR EH HOLPLQDWHG LQ WKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ 7KH ROG SOXUDO IRUPV RI WKH LPSHUDWLYH KDYH FRPSOHWHO\ GLVDSSHDUHG DQG KDYH EHHQ UHSODFHG E\ D SO SUHVHQW LQQL +RZHYHU VLQJXODU IRUPV PD\ HYHQWXDOO\ EH GHULYHG IURP 3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQ LI RXU 3URWR $OEDQLDQ UHFRQVWUXFWLRQV GR QRW LQFOXGH WKH DERYH PHQWLRQHG DOWHU QDWLRQ DV ZHOO DV WKH FORVHO\ FRQQHFWHG DOWHUQDWLRQ RI YHODUV DQG
212
chapter three
SDODWDOL]HG YHODUV ,I ZH GHULYH EMHU ¬ DQG SLT LPSHUDWLYHV RI ELH ‘WR EULQJ’ DQG SMHN ‘WR FRRN’ IURP (3$ EHUH DQG SHNH ZKLFK FRPHV IURPWKHSKRQHWLFDOO\H[SHFWHG SHWhH WKH\FDQEHFRPSDUHGZLWKVXFK IRUPVDV/DWIHUDQG6NWSDFD 7KH VXSSOHWLYH LPSHUDWLYHV RI YLM ‘WR FRPH’ DUH RI JUHDW LQWHUHVW (MD JRHV EDFN WR (3$ MD ZLWK D VHFRQGDU\ H XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI HF HF¬M‘WRZDON’" 7KLV3URWR$OEDQLDQIRUPLVZLWKRXWDGRXEWFRQQHFWHG ZLWK,( $QRWKHULPSHUDWLYHRIYLMLV7RVNMDNZKLFKJRHVEDFNWR WKH VDPH ,QGR(XURSHDQ URRW WKRXJK XVHV WKH LPSHUDWLYH SDUWLFOH N DOVRDWWHVWHGLQLNLN¬MVHHDERYH
7KHSUHVHQWRIVXEMXQFWLYHKDVDIRUPDOH[SUHVVLRQLQDFOLWLFW¬ RISURQRPLQDORULJLQ IURP(3$GDWVJ WDL" $FRQVLGHUDEOHSDUWRI WKH ROG SDUDGLJP ZDV ORVW DQG UHSODFHG E\ IRUPV RI WKH SUHVHQW LQGLFDWLYHZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIVJZKHUHWKHROGHQGLQJV¬VKDQG ¬ ZHUH UHWDLQHG 7KHVH PRUSKHPHV UHIOHFW D UHPDUNDEOH FRQIXVLRQ RI primary DQG secondary HQGLQJV DV WKH VJ OLGK¬VK FRQWLQXHV (3$
OLG]VL LGHQWLFDOZLWK/DWVJIXWOLJV ZKLOHVJOLGK¬FDQRQO\ UHIOHFW OLG]HW ,I ZH IROORZ WKH ZLGHO\ DFFHSWHG YLHZ RI WKH DUFKDLF QDWXUH RI secondary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
MHP HVDPL MHVK HVHVL MHW¬ HVHWL
SO
MHQ¬ HVRQWL
213
morphology
7KHSUHVHQWRIRSWDWLYHLVDQ$OEDQLDQLQQRYDWLRQ,QIDFWLWLV LQ RULJLQ DQ LPSHUIHFW LQ VK EDVHG RQ DQ DRULVW VWHP RU LQ FDVH RI WKHPDWLFSUHVHQWVRQWKHSUHVHQWVWHP N¬QGRYVKD!N¬QGRIVKD 7KH RQO\ LPSRUWDQW IHDWXUH RI WKH RSWDWLYH ZKLFK LV GLIIHUHQW IURP WKH EDVLF LPSHUIHFW SDUDGLJP LV WKH ZD\ LQ ZKLFK WKH SO LV IRUPHG ,WV HQGLQJ VKL LV GHULYHG IURP WKH VJ LQ VK XVLQJ D VHFRQGDU\ SURQRPLQDOHOHPHQWLDVLQWKHVJSUHVHQW Q L
9RLFHV 0HGLRSDVVLYH 2QO\ WKH SUHVHQW DQG LPSHUIHFW RI WKH PHGLRSDVVLYH DUH
V\QWKHWLF IRUPV 7KH UHVW RI WKH PHGLRSDVVLYH SDUDGLJP LV IRUPHG DQDO\WLFDOO\ DQG XVHV D FOLWLF X D UHJXODU UHIOH[ RI (3$ VZD P ,( DFF VÆRP /LWHUDWXUH %233 RQ WKH RULJLQ RI X 0(<(5 $OE *U GHULYHVSUHVHQWPHGLRSDVVLYHIURPDQDO\WLFDOIRUPVFRQVLVWLQJRIWKH YHUE VWHP DQG SUHVHQW RI MDP '20, 5(6O ;/9 HQGLQJV RI WKH PHGLRSDVVLYH 6<729*UVWU IROORZV0(<(5 0$11+LVW*U
,QWKHSUHVHQWRIWKHPHGLRSDVVLYHWKHVJDQGSOGLUHFWO\ RU LQGLUHFWO\ FRQWLQXH WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ PLGGOH 7KH $OEDQLDQ SKRQRORJ\ GRHV QRW DOORZ XV WR ILQG RXW ZKHWKHU WKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SDUDGLJP XVHG primary RU secondary HQGLQJV RI PLGGOH 7KH RULJLQ RI WKHWKHPDWLFYRZHOLQDOORSWDWLYHIRUPVUHPDLQVXQNQRZQ7KHRULJLQDO VWUXFWXUHORRNHGDVIROORZV
VJ
SO
OLGKHP OLG]HPD L OLGKHVK OLG]HVR L OLGKHW OLG]HWR L
OLGKHQ OLG]HQWR L
7KH IRUP RI WKH SO LQ PL VHHPV WR KDYH EHHQ LQIOXHQFHG E\ WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJIRUPRIWKHDWKHPDWLFSUHVHQWRIDFWLYH7KHSOLQQL ZKLOH L KDV EHHQ LQIOXHQFHG E\ WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ IRUPV RI DFWLYH %HVLGHV WKH IRUP LQ HVK WKH VJ DOVR KDV D SDUDOOHO IRUP LQ H FRUUHODWHGZLWKWKHSOLQHQL:HPLJKWDOVRH[SHFWD]HURHQGLQJLQ
214
chapter three
WKHVJWDNLQJLQWRDFFRXQWWKHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHWKHSOLQL OLGKL NDSL $OOWKHVHYDULDQWVUHPDLQTXLWHXQFOHDU 7KH LPSHUIHFW RI WKH PHGLRSDVVLYH LV D QHZO\ IRUPHG SDUDGLJP IROORZLQJWKHSDWWHUQRIVKLPSHUIHFWRIDFWLYH $QDO\WLFDOIRUPVRIPHGLRSDVVLYHDUHEXLOWXVLQJWKHUHIOH[LYHSURQRXQ X‘VHOI’ (3$ ZD ,( VÆRP
3DUWLFLSOHV ,Q $OEDQLDQ SDUWLFLSOHV WKH RSSRVLWLRQ RI YRLFH KDV EHHQ QHX
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¬IURP ,( QR -2./ ,) ;;;9,, XU ~ XQ ,( RQR &,02 &+2:6., 'XVKPDQL RQSDUWLFLSOHVLQXDU~ XHP 6&+0,'7,) /;,; $QDWROLDQSDUWLFLSOHV . 85</2:,&= ,QIOFDW 0$03 %DOWLVWLFD ,; IROORZV0(<(5 SDVVLP H[WHUQDOFRQQHFWLRQV RI $OEDQLDQSDUWLFLSOHVLQP 25(/=I%DON;;,,
3DUWLFLSOHV LQ Q¬ JR EDFN WR ,QGR(XURSHDQ DFWLYH SDUWLFLSOHV LQ QW 6NWEK¢UDQW*RWK EDLUDQGV 7KH\ DUH IRUPHG IURP VLJPDWLF DRULVWV H[FHSWIRUSDVK¬
‘WRJLYH’ ‘WROHDYH’ ‘WREH’ ‘WRIDOO’ ‘WRVD\’
VJDRU
SDUWLFLSOH
GKDVK¬ ODVK¬ THVK¬ UDVK¬ WKDVK¬
GK¬QH~ GKDQ¬ GDQWL O¬Q¬~ ODQ¬ ODQWL T¬Q¬~ NOHQWL U¬Q¬~ UDXQWL WK¬Q¬~ WVDQ V QWL
morphology
215
3DUWLFLSOHLQQ¬LVIRUPHGIURPKDQJUD WRKD‘HDW’ QJU¬Q¬~ QJUDQ¬
HQJUDQWL ,W LV DOVR TXLWH SUREDEOH WKDW RQFH WKHUH H[LVWHG D VLPLODU DWKHPDWLF SDUWLFLSOH RI ELH ‘WR EULQJ’ E¬Q¬ EHUQWL 7KLV LV VXJJHVWHGE\WKHGHULYDWLYHRIELHVKSLH‘WREULQJDZD\’ZKLFKKDVD SDUWLFLSOHVKS¬Q¬ LVEHUQWL 7KH RQO\ UHOLDEOH FDVH WKDW FDQ EH LQWHUSUHWHG DV D SDUWLFLSOH GHULYHG IURP DQ ROG YHUEDO DGMHFWLYH LQ WD WR LV UDW¬ UDXWD FRUUH VSRQGLQJ WR DRU UDVK¬ ‘WR IDOO’ 5HPDUNDEO\ WKLV DRULVW KDV DQRWKHU SDUWLFLSOH LQ $OEDQLDQ U¬Q¬ ~ UDQ¬ 7KLV SDLU RI SDUWLFLSOHV PD\ ZHOO UHIOHFWWKHRULJLQDOVLWXDWLRQLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQZKHUHDFWLYHSDUWLFLSOHV LQ QWZHUHRSSRVHGWRSDVVLYHSDUWLFLSOHVLQ WR
,Q D IHZ FDVHV 7RVN SUHVHUYHV SDUWLFLSOHV LQ U¬ QD ,(
QR *N UVWIPQX ‘KDWHG’ URCTPQX ‘VFDWWHUHG’ FI YUDV ‘WR NLOO’ YUDU¬EOHM‘WRVHOO’EOHU¬,WLVEHOLHYHGE\VRPHWKDWDSURGXFWLYHW\SH RISDUWLFLSOHVLQXU~ XQLVUHODWHGWRSDUWLFLSOHLQ QRJRLQJEDFNWR
RQR+RZHYHUWKLVZRXOGEHSKRQHWLFDOO\LPSRVVLEOH 9DULRXV DVLJPDWLF DRULVWV GHQWDO DRULVWV DV ZHOO DV DRULVWV LQ Z SURGXFHSDUWLFLSOHVLQXU~ XQ7KHPRUSKHPHDSSHDUVWRFRQWLQXHWKH ]HURJUDGHRIWKHQRPLQDOVXIIL[ ÆHQDVSUHVHUYHGLQ6NWd\XQ‘OLIH’ YVIXOOJUDGHSÀYDQ‘IDW’ 9HUEV LQ QM DV ZHOO DV YHUEV ZLWK D YRFDOLF DXVODXW KDYH GLIIHUHQW W\SHVRISDUWLFLSOHVLQ7RVNDQG*HJ,Q7RVNU QRLVDGGHGWRWKH DRULVWVWHP SXQRYU! SXQXDU ,Q *HJ WKH VDPH VWHP LV IROORZHG E\ PFRQWLQXLQJGHYHUEDWLYHDGMHFWLYHVLQ PR SXQRYP!SXQXHP,W VHHPVSUREDEOHWKDWZKLOH*HJUHWDLQVDQDUFKDLFSDUWLFLSOHLQWKLVFDVH 7RVN KDV VXEVWLWXWHG LWV IRUPV LQ PR ZLWK QHZHU IRUPV LQ QR ,Q *HJ KRZHYHU WKHUH H[LVWHG D VLPLODU WHQGHQF\ WKDW OHG WR WKH FRQWDPLQDWLRQRISDUWLFLSOHVLQ PRDQGSDUWLFLSOHVLQXU~ XQFIIRU H[DPSOH WKH SDUWLFLSOH RI SL ‘WR GULQN’ SLPXQ EDVHG RQ SLP ¬ $OEDQLDQ SDUWLFLSOHV LQ PR DUH FORVH WR WKH SDVVLYH SDUWLFLSOHV RI %DOWR6ODYLF FI /LWK QhDPDV 6ODY QHVRPÙ ‘EURXJKW’ DV ZHOO DV WR WKH/XZLDQSDUWLFLSOHVLQ D PD FI/XZNHhDPD‘FRPEHG’
,Q$OEDQLDQWKHUHH[LVWVRFDOOHG“VKRUW”SDUWLFLSOHV7KH\HQG
LQ¬DQGKDYHWKHYRFDOLVPRIWKHSUHVHQW GMHJ‘WREXUQ’GMHJ¬E¬M‘WR GR WR PDNH’- E¬U¬ 6XFK IRUPV VHHP WR FRQWLQXH R[\WRQLF 3URWR
216
chapter three
$OEDQLDQ QRXQV ZLWK HJUDGH YRFDOLVP GMHJ¬ (3$ GHJ¢ ,W LV SRVVLEOH KRZHYHU WKDW WKH URRW YRZHO LQ VXFK QRXQV LV VHFRQGDU\ DQG PXVWEHH[SODLQHGDVDUHVXOWRIWKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHILQLWHIRUPV,I(3$
GHJ¢LVGHULYHGIURP,( GKRÞK²VWKH“VKRUW”SDUWLFLSOHVFRXOGUHIOHFW ,QGR(XURSHDQR[\WRQLFQRPLQDDJHQWLVVLPLODUWR*NVQOQX
1RXQ The Albanian nominal system has radically reduced the original Indo-European declension types and lost several important grammemes typical of Indo-European paradigms. On the other hand, new grammatical meanings were developed in Proto-Albanian (such as the opposition of definite and indefinite) and new productive types of nouns came to dominate the formation of substantives and adjectives.
1RPLQDOVWHPV 6HYHUDO ,QGR(XURSHDQ VWHP W\SHV ZHUH DOWRJHWKHU ORVW LQ
3URWR$OEDQLDQ2WKHUW\SHV—HYHQWKRXJKSURGXFWLYH—ZHUHVXEMHFWHG WRUHVKXIIOLQJDQGPHUJHGZLWKOHVVSURGXFWLYHW\SHVDWWKHYHU\EHJLQ QLQJRIWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI3URWR$OEDQLDQ
,Q 3URWR$OEDQLDQ WKHUH UHPDLQHG WKUHH W\SHV RI QRPLQDO VWHPV R VWHPVVWHPVDQGLVWHPV7KHODWWHUZKRVHUHFRQVWUXFWLRQFDQRQO\EH RFFDVLRQDOO\ FRUURERUDWHG E\ VXFK IHDWXUHV DV XPODXW RU WKH UHIOHFWLRQ RIWKHURRWYRZHO HPHUJHGZLWKRDQGVWHPVDWDYHU\HDUO\VWDJH 2WKHUW\SHVRIVWHPVZHUHQRWSUHVHUYHGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQDWOHDVWQRW LQWKHLULPPHGLDWHIRUP /LWHUDWXUH 3('(56(1 .= ;;;,9 ,QGR(XURSHDQ RULJLQ RI $OEDQLDQQHXWHU -2./ 6WXGLHQ VWHPVLQUHIOHFWHGDV$OE L /.8%$ LVWHP LQ QDW¬ 6$1')(/' /%DON QHXWHU QRXQV LQ%DONDQODQJXDJHV 72*(%< &DKLHUV3X×cariu II 121-131 (neuter in Albanian and Rumanian);&,02&+2:6., /3,,, LVWHPVFKDQJLQJ WR VWHPV LQ $OEDQLDQ ,9 IROORZV -2./ 6WXGLHQ 3,6$1, 6DJJL UHFRQVWUXFWV ALQ$OEDQLDQUDQGQVWHPV Ç$%(-/39,, 9,,, VLQJXODUL]DWLRQ LQ $OEDQLDQ 0$11 +LVW *U +$03 .= /;9,, LVWHP LQ QDW¬ '(0,5$- 3UREO KLVW 5RPDQFH LQIOXHQFH RQ WKH IRUPDWLRQ RI $OEDQLDQ QHXWHU '(61,&.$-$ *U VWU RQ QDW¬ QRXQV LQ L i SDVVLP VLQJXODUL]DWLRQ *(25*,(97UDNLWH IROORZV3,6$1, Û$5$329$ 5% QHXWHULQ%DONDQ5RPDQFHDQG$OEDQLDQ
morphology
217
,QYHU\UDUHFDVHVDFRQVRQDQWVWHPUHPDLQHGPRUSKRORJLFDOO\ LQWDFWLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQ GKH ‘HDUWK ODQG’ (3$ G]A UHIOHFWLQJ ,( GK½KAP ‘HDUWK’ +LWW WHNDQ7RFK$WNDP%NHP6NWN¿DP*NZSYP 7KH PDMRULW\ RI ROGHU FRQVRQDQW VWHPV ZHUH UHGLVWULEXWHG EHWZHHQ R DQGRVWHPVRQWKHRQHKDQGDQGVWHPVRQWKHRWKHU7KHIROORZLQJ FDVHVDUHH[DPSOHVRIQHZRDQGRVWHPVUHSODFLQJFRQVRQDQWVWHPV GUX‘WUHH ZRRG’ (3$ GUXZD ,( GUXLG 6ODY GUÙYR‘ZRRG’ 6NWGUXLG$YGUXLG*NFTW`X‘WUHHRDN’ JM¬ ~ JMDˆ ‘WKLQJ’ (3$ VDQD VDQ V *PF V¢QÈ ‘WUXH’ 21 VDQQUVDÔU2(V²Ô PDGK ‘ELJ ODUJH’ (3$ PDG]D 6NW P¢KL ‘JUHDW ODUJH’ Gk OGICXLGQHXWOGIC PXDM ~ PXHM ‘PRQWK’ (3$ PAVQMD IURP WKH PHWDWKHVLV RI ,(
PQV‘PRRQPRQWK’ 6NWPV*NOJP/DWPQVLV2,UP QMHUL2$OEQMHU‘PDQSHUVRQKXPDQEHLQJ’ (3$ QHUD 6NWQ¢U ‘PDQ’GkCPJTLG ,QRWKHUFDVHVZHILQGVWHPVVXEVWLWXWLQJURRWVWHPVLQ$OEDQLDQ GHU¬ ‘GRRU’ (3$ GZAU ,( GKÆHU LG 6NW GYdU *N SWTC 7RFK%WZHUH GRU¬ ‘KDQG’ (3$ G V U ,( ½KHVU LG *N ZGK`T +LWW NHhhDU $UPMHUQ GKDOO¬‘EXWWHUPLON’ (3$ G]DO G]DODNW *NICNCLG NU\H‘KHDG’ (3$ NU V Q *NMTCPC MGHCNJ WK¬UL~WK¬QL‘ORXVH’ (3$ WVDQLGD WVDQLGFIGkMQPKX‘QLW’ +HWHURFOLWLFVWHPVFKDQJHGWRLVWHPV HOE‘EDUOH\’ (3$ DOEL GkCNHK‘NLQGRIJUDLQ’ HVKW¬‘ILEUHPXVFOHILEUH’ (3$ DVWL 6NW¢VWKLLG 7KH FDVH RI WKH ZRUG IRU ‘QLJKW’ ZKLFK EHFDPH DQ LVWHP LV GLVFXVVHG EHORZWRJHWKHUZLWKWKHRWKHULVWHPV7KHFKDQJHRIWKHPRUSKRORJLFDO W\SHWRRNSODFHRQWKHDUHDO,QGR(XURSHDQ VFDOH UDWKHU WKDQ LQ 3URWR $OEDQLDQLWVHOI
218
chapter three
6WHPVLQVRQRUDQWVEHFDPHRVWHPV,QDOOVXFKFDVHVWKHVXIIL[
LVDWWHVWHGLQWKHHJUDGHLHZLWKWKHYRFDOL]DWLRQRIREOLTXHFDVHV
GLP¬U ~ GLP¬Q ‘ZLQWHU’ (3$ GHLPHQD 6NW K©PDQ ORF ‘LQ ZLQWHU’GkZGK`OC‘ZLQWHU’ GK¬QG¬U ~ GKDQG¬U ‘EULGHJURRP VRQLQODZ’ (3$ G]DQUD ,( ½HQiU‘VRQLQODZ’ /DWJHQHU HP¬U~HP¬Q‘QDPH’ (3$ HQPHQDFORVHWR6ODY MÚP?LG JMDUS¬U ~ JMDUS¬Q ‘VQDNH’ (3$ VHUSHQD ,( VHUS ‘WR FUDZO’ /DWVHUSQV‘VQDNHVHUSHQW’VHUSA‘WRFUDZO’ NHW¬U ‘VTXLUUHO GRUPRXVH’ (3$ NANWHU /LWK NXRNDV ‘GDQFH’ UHFRQVWUXFWHGIURPNXRN®Q^‘GDQFLQJSDUW\’ DQG6ODY VNDNDWL ‘WRMXPSWRVSULQJ’ 2QO\IHPLQLQHDQLPDWHVXEVWDQWLYHVUHWDLQHGWKHLURULJLQDO VHPDQWLFDOO\ PRWLYDWHG JHQGHUDQGDSSHDUDV$OEDQLDQVWHPV PRW¬U‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU‘PRWKHU’ 6NWPW¢U*N OJVJT/DWPWHU ,Q RQH FDVH WKH IRUP RI WKH QRPLQDWLYH RI D VWHP LQ D VRQRUDQW ZDV JHQHUDOL]HGDQGWKHZRUGPHUJHGZLWKWKHVWHPV UU\P¬ ‘IORZ RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ VU P UHSODFLQJ VU PD ,(
VU P *N TGW`OC ‘VWUHDP’ 21 VWUDXPU LG /LWK VUDXPX¶ ‘IDVWVWUHDP’
6WHPVLQHVZHUHORVW,QWKHQRPLQDWLYHWKH\ORRNHGOLNHR VWHPV ZKLFK OHG WR WKHLU FRPSOHWH PHUJHU ZLWK WKH ODWWHU &I WKH IROORZLQJH[DPSOHV DQJ‘IHDUQLJKWPDUH’ (3$ DQJD V FRUUHVSRQGLQJWR6NW¢PKDV ‘IHDU’/DWDQJRU‘XQUHVWIHDU’ DQ½KRV HQG ‘SROOHQ’ (3$ DQGD V 6NW ¢QGKDV ‘KHUE’ Gk CPSQX ‘IORZHU’ HWKH‘IHYHU’ (3$ DLGD V 6NW©GKDV‘ILUHZRRGIXHO’GkCK?SQX ‘ILUH’ KL~Kî‘DVK’ (3$ VNLQD V /DWFLQLV‘GXVWDVK’ FHQHV YLWYMHW‘\HDU’ (3$ ZHWD V GkGVQXLG
morphology
219
]MDUU ‘ILUH’ (3$ GÊHUD ,( ÞKHUHV 6NW K¢UDV ‘IODPH KHDW’ *NSGTQX‘VXPPHU’$UPÎHULG
6WHPVLQXDQG LQ ZHUH QRW SUHVHUYHG HLWKHU 7KH\ ZHUH VXEVWLWXWHGE\RDQGVWHPV DFDU ‘VWHHO’ (3$ DWVDUD ‘VKDUS’ DWVDUX /LWK DhU¸V ‘VKDUS’ 6ODY RVWUÙLG PMHN¬U‘FKLQEHDUG’ (3$ VPHNU VPHUX 6NWyP¢yUXLG 7KH ZRUG IRU ‘PRWKHULQODZ’ ZDV PRUSKRQRORJLFDOO\ FKDQJHG XQGHU WKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHPDVFXOLQHIRUP VZHWVXUD!YMHK¬UU‘IDWKHULQODZ’ YMHK¬UU ‘PRWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZH[XU ZLWK DVVLPLODWLRQ IURP H[SHFWHG VZHWVXU ,( VÆHU 6NWyYDyUgPRWKHULQODZ’ /DWVRFUXVLG
$V ZH KDYH PHQWLRQHG DERYH LVWHPV SUHVXPDEO\ H[LVWHG LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ HYHQ WKRXJK ZH FDQ RQO\ LGHQWLI\ VRPH RI WKHP E\ WUDFHVRIXPODXWDQGRWKHUSKRQHWLFIHDWXUHV,Q/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQL VWHPV ZHUH UHGLVWULEXWHG EHWZHHQ R DQG OHVV IUHTXHQWO\ VWHPV &I VHYHUDOH[DPSOHVRILVWHPVFKDQJHGWRRVWHPV JXU‘VWRQHURFN’ (3$ JXUD JXUL ,( ÞHUi‘PRXQWDLQ’ 6NW JLU $Y JDLUL /LWK JLUL£ ‘ZRRG’ /DWY G]LULD LG 6ODY JRUD ‘PRXQWDLQZRRG’ NUL ~ NUî ‘ZRRGZRUP PRWK’ (3$ NULZD NULZL WR ,( áÆL 6ODY ¨ÚUYÚ‘ZRUP’ NULPE ~ NU\P ‘ZRUP’ (3$ NULPD NULPL ZLWK XQH[SODLQHG *HJ\ ,( áPLLG 6NWN¤PL/LWKN®UPLV OHGK‘PXGDOOXYLXPFOD\ ZDOOHDUWKPRXQG ULYHUPRXWKEDON’ (3$ ODLGD 23UXVOD\GLV‘FOD\’ PRW ‘WLPH ZHDWKHU VWRUP WKXQGHUEROW’ (3$ PWL 6NW PWL ‘PHDVXUH’*NOJ`VKXLG YHVK‘HDU’ (3$ ZDXVD ZDXVL /DWDXULV/LWKDXV®V/DWY£XVV ]RW ‘ORUG PDVWHU JRG’ (3$ Z L WVSDWD Z L WVSDWL 6NW YLy SDWL‘ORUGRIWKHKRXVH’ 6RPHRWKHULVWHPVFKDQJHGWRVWHPV
220
chapter three
EHV¬ ‘SOHGJH WUXFH WUXVW’ (3$ EDLWh EDLWhL Gk RKUVKX ‘IDLWKIXOWUXVWZRUWK\’ ERW¬ ‘ZRUOG’ (3$ EZW EZWL 6NW EK W ‘H[LVWHQFH’ /LWK E W®VLG,UEXLWKLG JMROO¬‘FOHDULQJRUSDVWXUHZKHUHVDOWLVVWUHZQIRUVKHHS SDWFKRI JURXQGIRUVRZLQJ’ (3$ VO VOL 6ODY VROÚ‘VDOW’ GLW¬‘GD\’ (3$ GW GW *PF WGL]‘WLPH’ 2+*]W2(WG DQG6NWGWL‘EULJKWQHVVVSOHQGRU’ QDW¬ ‘QLJKW’ (3$ QDNW QDNWL FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR /LWK QDNW®V /HWWQDNWV23UXVQDNWLQ6ODY QRNW’Ú ERW¬ (3$ EZWLFI6NWEK W‘H[LVWHQFH’/LWKE W®VLG,UEXLWK LG JMROO¬SOJMROO¬‘FOHDULQJRUSDVWXUHZKHUHVDOWLVVWUHZQIRUVKHHS SDWFKRIJURXQGIRUVRZLQJ’ (3$ VOLFI6ODY VROÚ‘VDOW’ 3URWR$OEDQLDQLVWHPVLQFOXGHGDJURXSRIQXPHUDOVLQW¬ WLZKLFK FRUUHVSRQG WR 6DQVNULW GHFDGV LQ WL ¿D¿WL ‘VL[ WHQV’ DQG WKH OLNH DV ZHOODVWKHZRUGIRU‘WZHQW\’ JMDVKW¬‘VL[’ (3$ VHNVWLFORVHWR6NW¿¢¿*NGE/DWVH[ WHW¬‘HLJKW’ (3$ DNWAWL 6NWD¿bd$UPRZ*NQMVY Q¬QW¬ ~ QDQG ‘QLQH’ (3$ QHXQWL ZLWK DQDORJLFDO UHVWUXFWXULQJ LQ7RVN WR6NWQ¢YD/DWQRYHP*RWKQLXQ GKMHW¬‘WHQ’ (3$ GHWV D WL 6NWG¢yD*NFGMC/DWGHFHP VKWDW¬ ‘VHYHQ’ (3$ VHSWDWL FRUUHVSRQGLQJ WR 6NW VDSW¢ *N GRVC/DWVHSWHP ]HW ‘WZHQW\’ (3$ Z L WVDWL ,( ÆLWL LG 6NW YiPyDW *N GKMQUK/DWYJLQW ,QGR(XURSHDQVWHPVLQ DUHUHSUHVHQWHGLQ(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQDV VWHPVLQ EX]¬ ‘OLS HQG HGJH EDQN VWLWFK URFN’ (3$ EXGM /LWK EXG| ‘WUHHIXQJXVWLQGHUZKHWVWRQH’
2QHRIWKHPRVWSURGXFWLYHPRUSKRORJLFDOW\SHVLQ$OEDQLDQLV UHSUHVHQWHG E\ WKH PDVFXOLQH RVWHPV 0DQ\ RVWHPV KDYH EHHQ LQKHU LWHGIURP,QGR(XURSHDQ&IVHYHUDOW\SLFDOH[DPSOHV
morphology
221
GDVK ‘UDP’ (3$ GDXhD ,( GKRXVR ~ GKHXVR *RWK GLXV ‘ZLOG DQLPDO’ /LWK SO GD-VRV ‘SDUDGLVH’ 6ODY GX[Ù ‘EUHDWK VSLULW’ GHP ‘\RXQJ EXOO’ (3$ GDPD 2,U GDP ‘R[’ DQG *N FCOCNQL ‘FDOI’ GK¬PE~GKDPE‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPED ,( ½RPEKR‘SHJWRRWK’ 6NWM¢PEKD‘ELWSHJ’*NIQOHQX‘SHJ’7RFK$NDP‘WRRWK’ %NHPHLG/DWY]¸REVLG6ODY ]_EÙLG JDUGK ‘IHQFH’ (3$ JDUGD *RWK JDUGV ‘KRXVH’ /LWK JD¼GDV ‘IHQFH’6ODY JRUGÙ‘WRZQIHQFH’ JMDN‘EORRG’ (3$ VDND *NQRQX‘MXLFH’/LWKVDND&‘UHVLQ’6ODY
VRNÙ‘MXLFH’ MHUP ‘GHOLULXP DEVHQWPLQGHGQHVV’ (3$ HUPD /LWK H¼PDV ‘PRQVWHU’/DWY?UPV‘ZRQGHUIXODSSDULWLRQ’ N¬UU‘GRQNH\DVVIRDOJUD\’ (3$ NDUD 6NWNK¢UD‘GRQNH\’$Y [DUALG6F\WK [DUD2VVHW[æUæJLG VKWHJ‘SDWKURDG (3$ VWDLJD ,( VWRLJKR‘ZD\’ *NUVQK`ZQX ‘URZ OLQH’ *RWK VWDLJD ‘ZD\’ /DWY VWD&JD ‘ZDONLQJ’ VWîJD ‘SDWK’6ODY VWÚ]DLG XMN‘ZROI’ (3$ Z XOND ,( ÆâáRVLG 6NWY¤ND*NNWMQX/DW OXSXV*RWKZXOIV 6WHPV LQ R DUH D SURGXFWLYH VXEJURXS RI RVWHPV 7KH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHVLOOXVWUDWHWKLVW\SH GHUU‘SLJ’ (3$ GDUMD *NZQK`TQXLG ,( ½KRURV GXDM ~ GXHM ‘VKHDI’ (3$ GAQMD 6NW GKQd ‘JUDLQ FHUHDOV’ GKQ\¢‘JUDLQ’/LWKG·RQD‘EUHDG’ KXDM ~ KXHM ‘IRUHLJQ VWUDQJH’ (3$ NVAQ Z MD *N EG PQX 'RU EG P®QX‘VWUDQJHUJXHVW’ KX ~ Kû ‘SLFNHW VWDNH SROH SHQLV’ (3$ VNXMD 6ODY [XMÚ ‘SHQLV’ NHT‘EDGHYLO’ (3$ NDNMD *NMCMQX‘EDG’ P¬]~ Pâ]‘IRDO’ (3$ PDQGMDGHULYHGIURPP¬QG‘WRIHHGWR VXFNOH’ ,( PD]G QXV‘WKUHDGVWULQJ’ (3$ VQXWMD 6NWVQdYDQ‘EDQGVLQHZ’
0DQ\$OEDQLDQVWHPVFRQWLQXHVLPLODU,QGR(XURSHDQIRUPV
222
chapter three
KDO¬ ‘ILVK ERQH VSOLQWHU SLQH’ (3$ VNDO /LWK VNDO£ ‘VWLFN RI ILUHZRRG’/DWYVNDOD‘VSOLQWHU XVHGWRIXUQLVKOLJKW ’ NURGK¬‘EHHKLYH’ (3$ NUG 6ODY NUDGD‘KHDSSLOH’ O¬QG¬~ODQG¬‘ZRRGWLPEHUPDWHULDO’ (3$ OHQW *PF OHQGWA ‘OLQGHQ’ 2+*OLQWD2(OLQG /LWKOHQW£‘ERDUG’6ODY OO¬U¬ ~ OODQ¬ ‘IRUHDUP HOO’ (3$ DOHQ *N YNGPJ ‘HOERZ’ /DW XOQD2+*HOLQD PMHJXOO‘FORXG’ (3$ PHJO *NQ OKZNJ ‘IRJ PLVW’ /LWK PLJO£ LG6ODY PÚJOD‘GDUNQHVVPLVW’ UUXGK¬‘ZULQNOH’ (3$ UXG] /DWU JDLG WROO¬‘EDOGVSRW GUXPPHPEUDQH’ (3$ WVO WVO /DWWOD ‘FORWK’2+*GHKVDOD‘D[H’6ODY WHVODLG WKHN¬‘IULQJH’ (3$ WVDN 6NWydNK‘EUDQFK’/LWKhDN£LG YH ‘ZLGRZ’ (3$ ZLGHZ 6NW YLGK¢Y LG /DW YLGXD LG *RWK ZLGXZRLG 6WHPV LQ DUH DOVR ZHOO DWWHVWHG LQ $OEDQLDQ &I WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV GRV¬‘SLJVRZ’ (3$ G L WM ,( GK L ‘WRVXFNOH’ HQM¬‘MXQLSHU\HZ’ (3$ DLJQMUHODWHGWRWKH*HUPDQLFZRUGIRU ‘RDN’ 21HLN2+*HLK HQM¬~êM¬‘GDLU\JRDW’ (3$ DJQM *NCOPQX‘ODPE’/DWDJQXV LG PMDOF¬‘EHH’ (3$ PHOLWM *NOGNKUUC OGNKVMCLG YLVH ‘SODFH’ (3$ ZWVM ,( ÆHL VLPLODU WR *N QKMKC ‘GZHOOLQJKRXVH’ $ IHZ ROG PDVFXOLQH RVWHPV FKDQJHG WR VWHPV LQ $OEDQLDQ 7KLV SURFHVVPD\EHVRPHKRZFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHIDWHRIROGQHXWHURVWHPV LQ$OEDQLDQ VHHEHORZ &IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV NRK¬‘WLPH’ (3$ N[ 6ODY ¨DVÙLG ODS¬ ‘KDUG SLHFH RI PHDW RU VNLQ SHULWRQHXP OHDI’ (3$ ODS /LWKO¦SDV‘OHDI’*NNQRQX‘VKHOOKXVNEDUN’ 7KHUHDUHDOVRH[DPSOHVRIWKHUHYHUVHGHYHORSPHQWDQVWHP\LHOGLQJ DQRVWHPLQ$OEDQLDQ DJ‘WZLOLJKWGXVN’ (3$ DXJD ,( DXJ *NCWIJ‘UD\RIOLJKW’
morphology
223
NXOS NXOS¬U ~ NXOS¬Q ‘LY\ FOHPDWLV’ (3$ NXOSD /LWK N®OSD ‘ORRS’/DWYFLËSDLG SLGK‘IHPDOHSXGHQGD’ (3$ S H L]GD 6ODY SL]GDLGDQG23UXV SHLVGD‘ERWWRP’
,QGR(XURSHDQ QHXWHU SOXUDO RVWHPV ZHUH UHLQWHUSUHWHG DV IHPLQLQHVWHPVLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQ EDOW¬ ‘VZDPS PDUVK GLUW HDUWK’ (3$ EDOW ,( EKROiWRP LG 6ODY EROWRFI/LWKE¢OWDV‘ZKLWH’ ELP¬‘SODQW’ (3$ E P ,( EK PRP *NHW`OCLG GDUN¬‘VXSSHU’ (3$ GDUN ,( GRUáRPUHIOHFWHGLQ*NFQTRQP LG ¬QG¬UU ~ DQG¬UU ‘GUHDP VOHHS’ (3$ DQUM ,( RQHURP *N QPGKTQPQPGKTQX$UPDQRZUÎ IMDO¬ ‘ZRUG VSHHFK WDOH’ (3$ VSHO *PF VSHOODQ *RWK VSLOO ‘VWRU\IDEOH’21VSMDOO‘VWRU\VSHHFK’2(VSHOOLG2+*VSHO VSHOOLG DQG$UPDàDVSHO‘IDEOH’ KLUU¬‘ZKH\’ (3$ NVLU 6NWN¿U¢‘PLON’2VVHWæ[hLULG KXGK¬U‘JDUOLF’ (3$ VNXUG *NUMQTQFQPLG 8QGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI (DVW %DONDQ 5RPDQFH /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ GHYHORSHG D QHZ JUDPPDWLFDO V\QWDFWLF FDWHJRU\—QHXWHU RI VXE VWDQWLYHV 7KHVH QRXQV ZKRVH VLQJXODUV ZHUH PDVFXOLQH EXW SOXUDOV IHPLQLQH DEVRUEHG VRPH RI WKH ROG ,QGR(XURSHDQ QHXWHUV +RZHYHU WKHUH ZDV QR GLUHFW FRQQHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ QHXWHU DQG WKH QHZ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ QHXWHU LQVRIDU DV PDQ\ PDVFXOLQHV DQG IHPLQLQHV ZHUH LQYROYHG LQ WKH IRUPDWLRQ RI WKH QHZ QHXWHU FRUUH VSRQGLQJ WR WKH VHPDQWLF FDWHJRU\ RI “GHILQLWH PDVV” IURP WKH YHU\ EHJLQQLQJ&IDIHZH[DPSOHVRIROGQHXWHUVIXQFWLRQLQJDVQHXWHUVLQ $OEDQLDQ EDOO¬‘IRUHKHDG’ (3$ EDOWR6NWEKODLG23UXVEDOORLG GULWK¬ ‘JUDLQ’ (3$ GULWV ,( ½K]G /DW KRUGHXP ‘EDUOH\’ 2+*JHUVWDLG JUXU¬ ~ JUXQ¬ ‘ZKHDW’ (3$ JUXQ ,( ½¹QRP ‘JUDLQ’ /DW JUQXP2,UJU¢Q*RWKNDXUQ/LWKÊ®UQLV6ODY ]ÚUQR
1XPHURXVSOXUDOVWHPVZHUHVLQJXODUL]HGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQDV D UHVXOW RI /DWH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ XPODXW 8PODXW FUHDWHG SDUDGLJPV LQ
224
chapter three
ZKLFKWKHVWHPRIWKHSOXUDOZDVGLIIHUHQWLDWHGIURPWKDWRIWKHVLQJXODU 6XFK LUUHJXODULW\ ZDV RIWHQ QHXWUDOL]HG E\ PHDQV RI JHQHUDOL]DWLRQ SOXUDO VWHPV RIWHQ RXVWHG WKHLU VLQJXODU FRXQWHUSDUWV 7KLV SURFHVV FDQ EHLOOXVWUDWHGE\WKHKLVWRU\RIWKHZRUGWHU‘EXOO’ VJ 6WDJH, 6WDJH,, 6WDJH,,,
WDXUD
WDUD
WDUD WHU
SO
WDXUDL
WDUDL
WHUDL WHU¬
/LNHZLVH VLQJXODU VWHPV RXVWHG SOXUDO VWHPV LQ WKH VDPH IDVKLRQ WKRXJKWKLVSURFHVVZDVOHVVIUHTXHQW&IWKHKLVWRU\RIWKHZRUGGUDQJ ‘SROH’
6WDJH, 6WDJH,,, 6WDJH,9
VJ
SO
GUDQJD
GUDQJD GUDQJ
GUDQJDL
GUHQJDL GUDQJM
+RZHYHUERWKWHQGHQFLHVGLGQRWFRYHUDOO$OEDQLDQQRXQVZLWKXPODXW 6RPHRIWKHPUHWDLQHGWKHSDUDGLJPZLWKYRFDOLFDOWHUQDWLRQFIJDUGK ‘IHQFH’ VJ 6WDJH, 6WDJH,,, 6WDJH,9
JDUGD
JDUGD JDUGK
SO
JDUGDL
JHUGDL JMHUGKH
7KH PDMRULW\ RI /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV ZHUH PRUSKRORJLFDOO\
DGDSWHGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUGHFOHQVLRQW\SHV1RXQVRI WKHVWGHFOHQVLRQDSSHDUDVVWHPVLQ$OEDQLDQ DUP¬‘ZHDSRQ’Õ/DWDUPDLG ELVK¬‘EHDVWZLOGDQLPDO’ Õ /DWEVWLDLG EXN¬ ‘EUHDG PHDO PHDOWLPH’ Õ /DW EXFFD ‘PRXWK’ LQ %DONDQ 5RPDQFH‘IRRG’
morphology
225
EXO¬‘EXG’ Õ /DWEXOOD‘EXEEOHERVVNQRE’ GHW\U¬‘GXW\GHEW’Õ5RP GHELW UDLG I¬PLM¬‘FKLOGIDPLO\VSRXVH’Õ/DWIDPOLD‘IDPLO\’ IXUN¬‘GLVWDIIIRUN’Õ/DWIXUFD‘IRUN’ IXVK¬ ‘SODLQ RSHQ ILHOG PHDGRZ’ Õ /DW IRVVD ‘GLWFK WUHQFK JXWWHU’ OXIW¬‘ILJKWZDU’Õ/DWOXFWD‘ZUHVWOLQJ’FI5XPOXSW:‘ILJKW’ SMHUJXOO ‘YLQHDUERU SHUJROD’ Õ /DW SHUJXOD ‘VKHG ERRWK YLQH DUERU’ 0DVFXOLQHQRXQVRIWKHQGGHFOHQVLRQEHFDPHRVWHPVLQ$OEDQLDQ DUN‘ERZ’Õ/DWDUFXVLG IORN‘KDLU’Õ/DWIORFFXV‘ORFNIORFN’ IXQG‘ERWWRPHQG’Õ/DWIXQGXV‘ERWWRP’ JXVKW‘$XJXVW’Õ/DWDXJXVWXVLG PDUV‘0DUFK’Õ/DW0DUWLXVLG PRGK‘EXVKHO’Õ/DWPRGXV‘PHDVXUH’ PXUJ~PXQJ‘PRQN’Õ/DWPRQDFKXVLG SXV‘ZHOOIRXQWDLQ’Õ/DWSXWHXV‘ZHOO’ VKHVK‘SODLQSODQHIODWQHVVVTXDUH’ Õ /DWVHVVXV‘VHDW’ YHV‘EDGKDELW’Õ/DWYLWLXP‘IDXOWGHIHFWYLFH’ 0RVWQHXWHUQRXQVRIWKHQGGHFOHQVLRQEHFDPHRVWHPVWRR G¬P~GDP‘GDPDJH’Õ/DWGDPQXP‘KXUWKDUPGDPDJH’ IDW‘IDWH EULGHJURRPKXVEDQGIULHQG’Õ/DWIWXPLG IVKDW‘YLOODJH’Õ/DWIRVVWXP‘GLWFK’ ‘VXUURXQGHGE\DGLWFK’ JD]‘MR\ODXJKWHU’Õ/DWJDXGLXP‘MR\’ NDQJMHO‘VRQJ’Õ5RP FDQWLFHOOXPLG ODUGK‘IDWODGHQEDFRQ’Õ/DWOULGXPOUGXPLG TLHOO‘VN\KHDYHQ’Õ/DWFDHOXPLG VKT\W‘VKLHOG’Õ/DWVF WXPLG ([FHSWLRQVDUHUDUH JU¬P¬UDW¬ ‘EHHVWLQJV FORWV RI FXUGOHG PLON’ Õ /DW JORPHUWXP SDUWLFLSOH RI JORPHUUH ‘WR ZLQG LQWR D EDOO WR JDWKHU LQWR D URXQGKHDS’ N¬QJ¬~NDQJ¬‘VRQJ’Õ/DWFDQWLFXPLG SHVK¬‘ZHLJKW VWRQHERXOGHU’Õ/DWSHQVXPLG
226
chapter three
/DWLQ QHXWHU LQDQLPDWH VXEVWDQWLYHV RIWHQ WXUQHG LQWR QHZ $OEDQLDQ QHXWHUIRUPV&IDW\SLFDOH[DPSOH YDM~ YRM‘RLO’Õ/DWROHXPLG 1HDUO\DOOQRXQVRIWKHGGHFOHQVLRQEHFDPHRVWHPVLQ$OEDQLDQ EXOE¬U‘VWUHHWGXVW’Õ/DWSXOYHUHP‘GXVW’ GUDJXD~GUD Q JXH‘GUDJRQ’Õ5RP GUDQFAQHPFI/DWGUDFAQHP LG JULJM‘IORFNKHUG’Õ/DWJUHJHPLG OLJM‘ODZ’Õ/DWOJH P LG PHQG‘PLQG’Õ/DWPHQWHPLG SDT‘SHDFH’Õ/DWSDFHPLG SULQG‘IDWKHUSDUHQW’Õ/DWSDUHQWHPLG T\WHW‘FLW\’Õ/DWFYLWWH P LG WPHUU‘KRUURUIULJKW’Õ/DWWLPAUHPLG WXUS‘VKDPH’Õ/DWWXUSHLG &IDQH[FHSWLRQDOFDVHRIDQRXQRIWKHGGHFOHQVLRQDGDSWHGDVDQ VWHP VKWLM¬‘VSHDUUD\’Õ/DWKDVWOH‘VSHDU’
,Q VRPH FDVHV WKH PRUSKRORJLFDO W\SH RI WKH ORDQZRUG ZDV GHWHUPLQHGQRWE\WKHVWHPRIWKHVRXUFHZRUGEXWE\LWVUHLQWHUSUHWHG QRPLQDWLYH,QRWKHUFDVHVQRPLQDWLYHVHQGLQJLQUDQGQZHUHHUUR QHRXVO\ WUHDWHG DV $OEDQLDQ SOXUDOV 1HZ QRPLQDWLYH VLQJXODUV ZHUH WKHQEDFNIRUPHG&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV MDY¬‘ZHHN’Õ/DWKHEGRPDVLG NXOP‘ULGJHSHDN ZDYH’Õ/DWFXOPHQLG PEUHW‘NLQJ’Õ/DWLPSHUWRU‘HPSHURU’ VKDW‘KRH’Õ/DWVHFWRU‘FXWWHU’ VKHP¬‘VZDUP RIEHHV ’Õ/DWH[PHQ‘VZDUP’
6ODYLF ORDQZRUGV ZHUH PRUSKRORJLFDOO\ DGDSWHG LQ D ZD\
TXLWHVLPLODUWRWKDWRI/DWLQ6ODYLFIHPLQLQDDSSHDULQ$OEDQLDQDV VWHPV
morphology
227
QHYRM¬‘QHHG’Õ6ODY QHYRO’D‘ODFNRIIUHHGRPQHFHVVLW\’ SHOHQ¬‘GLDSHU’Õ6ODY SHOHQD‘FRYHUQDSNLQ’ SMDYLF¬‘OHHFK’Õ6ODY SLMDYLFDLG UDTLW¬‘EURRP EXVK ’Õ6ODY RUN\WDLG UHN¬‘EURRNULYXOHW’Õ6ODY UpND‘ULYHU’ UHS¬‘WXUQLS’Õ6ODY UpSDLG VHU¬‘WDU’Õ6ODY VpUD‘VXOSKXU’ YHULJ¬‘FKDLQULQJ’Õ6ODY YHULJD‘FKDLQ’ Y¬UV¬~Y¬UF¬‘DJH’Õ6ODY YÚUVWD‘DJHNLQGNLQ’ 6ODYLFPDVFXOLQHRVWHPVUHPDLQHGRVWHPVLQ$OEDQLDQ NDç‘ZHDYHU’Õ6ODY WÙND¨ÚLG OLN‘OHYHO’Õ6ODY OLNÙ‘IDFHVXUIDFH’ QHPHF‘GXPEVWXWWHULQJSHUVRQ’Õ6ODY QpPÚFÚLG RERUU‘\DUGFRXUW’Õ6ODY REYRUÙLG SHOLQ‘ZRUPZRRG’Õ6ODY SHO\QÙLG UHG‘URZ’Õ6ODY U?GÙLG UUDVROO‘SLFNOHV’Õ6ODY RU]VROÙ‘SLFNOHV EULQH’ VKDS ‘GLVHDVH RI WKH FDWWOH $SKWD HSL]RRWLFD’ Õ 6ODY VDSÙ ‘JODQGHUV’ XJDU‘ODQGXQXVHGIRUWZR\HDUV’Õ6ODY XJDUÙ‘IDOORZJURXQG’ ]DEHO‘OLWWOHZRRG’Õ6ODY ]DEpOÙLG ]KHJ‘KHDW’Õ6ODY ÊHJÙLG 1HXWHUVXEVWDQWLYHVERUURZHGIURP6ODYLFEHFDPH$OEDQLDQVWHPV OLM¬‘VPDOOSR[’Õ6ODY OL[R‘HYLO’ PHWDOH‘VQRZGULIW’Õ6ODY PHWDGOR‘KHDS’ PLW¬‘EULEHWLS’Õ6ODY P\WR‘SD\PHQW’ VDQ¬‘KD\’Õ6ODY VpQRLG VLW¬‘VLHYH’Õ6ODY VLWRLG XOLVKW¬ ‘VPDOO WXE’ Õ 6ODY XOLh¨H GHULYDWLYH RI XOÚMÚ ‘KLYH WURXJK’ YHG¬U‘SDLO IRUPLON ’Õ6ODY YpGUR‘SDLO’ ,Q D IHZ FDVHV HVSHFLDOO\ LQ HDUO\ ORDQZRUGV WKH JHQGHU RI 6ODYLF ZRUGVZDVFKDQJHG
228
chapter three
OORK¬ ‘UDLQ ZLWK VQRZ VQRZ EURWK GDPSQHVV’ Õ 6ODY ORMÚ
‘DQ\WKLQJOLTXLG’!‘IDWODUG’ SOHQJ‘EDQGDJH’Õ6ODY SHO H QÙNDLG UDY¬‘SDWK LQPRXQWDLQVRUVQRZ ’Õ6ODY URYÙ‘GLWFK’ UDYJ¬‘SDWK LQPRXQWDLQV ’Õ6ODY URYÙNÙ‘GLWFK’ 2FFDVLRQDOO\WKHSOXUDOIRUPVRI6ODYLFORDQZRUGVZHUHUHDQDO\]HGDV VLQJXODUVDVLQWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOH YLUXD ~ YLUXH ‘EURRN ULYXOHW’ Õ 6ODY SO YLURYH RI YLUÙ ‘ZKLUO SRROZDWHUSLW’
)RUPDWLRQRIWKHSOXUDO ,Q 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DV ZHOO DV LQ PRGHUQ $OEDQLDQ WKH SOXUDO VWHPV RI PRVW VXEVWDQWLYHV DUH LGHQWLFDO ZLWK WKH VLQJXODU VWHPV DQG EHORQJWRWKHVDPHSDUDGLJP VHH ,Q3URWR$OEDQLDQQRXQVRIWHQ GHYHORSHG QHZ SOXUDO VWHPV E\ WKH UHDQDO\VLV RI ROG GHULYDWLRQDO VXIIL[HV6XFKQHZSOXUDOVZHUHGHULYHGIURPWKHRULJLQDOVLQJXODUVE\ PHDQVRIVSHFLDOVXIIL[HV /LWHUDWXUH 0(<(5$OE6W,SDVVLP -2.//.8%$ SOXUDOVLQ] RQ SOXUDOV LQ LQM 0©ODQJHV 3HGHUVHQ SOXUDO LQ P &,02&+2:6., %86K7 ;,,, ,OO\ULDQ SDUDOOHOV WR SOXUDOV LQ LQM &$0$- $OE :RUWE SOXUDO LQ ] Ç$%(- 6W ,,, '(61,&.$-$*UVWU UD~ QDFUHDWHGRQWKHEDVLVRISO HP¬UD~ HP¬QDUHVWUXFWXUHGDVHP¬UD~ HP¬QD SOXUDOLQ¬U~ ¬Q RI /DWLQ ORDQZRUGV 0$11 +LVW *U /$==(521, 66/ 9, RQ,( LGR
2QHRIWKHPRVWSURGXFWLYHSOXUDOVXIIL[HVLVUD~ QD,WIRUPV SOXUDOV ZKLFK FRQVLVW RI WZR VHPDQWLF JURXSV ERG\ SDUWV DQG material substantives. The first group is relatively small: DVKW¾HVKWUD~HVKW¬QD‘ERQH’ JLVKW¾JLVKW¬UD~JLVKWQD‘ILQJHUWKXPE’ SLGK¾SLGK¬UD~SLGKQD‘IHPDOHSXGHQGD’
morphology
229
7KH VHFRQG JURXS LQFOXGHV D FRQVLGHUDEOH QXPEHU RI VXEVWDQWLYHV GHQRWLQJYDULRXVPDWHULDOVDQGRWKHUXQFRXQWDEOHV EDU¾EDU¬UD~EDU¬QD‘JUDVV’ ERU¬¾ERU¬UD~ERUQD‘VQRZ’ GMDWK¬¾GMDWK¬UD~GMDWKQD‘FKHHVH’ GULWK¬¾GULWK¬UD~GULWKQD‘JUDLQ’ GKH¾GKHUD~GKHQD‘HDUWKODQG’ GKMDP¬¾GKMDP¬UD~GKMDPQD‘ DQLPDO IDWODUGVXHWWDOORZ’ HOE¾HOE¬UD~HOE¬QD‘EDUOH\’ HU¬¾HU¬UD~HU¬QD‘ZLQG’ IODN¬¾IODN¬UD~IODN¬QD‘IODPH’ IUDT¾IUDTUD~IUDTQD‘ELWLQJFROGIURVW’ IVKDW¾IVKDWUD~IVKDWQD‘YLOODJH’ JUDP¾JUDPUD~JUDPQD‘FRXFKJUDVVNQRWJUDVV’ JMDN¾JMDNUD~JMDNQD‘EORRG’ NULS¬~NU\S¬¾NULS¬UD~NU\SQD‘VDOW’ OHVK¾OHVKUD~OHVKQD‘ZRROIOHHFHKDLU’ P¬QGDIVK¾P¬QGDIVKUD~P¬QGDIVKQD‘VLON’ PLHOO¾PLHOOUD~PLHOOQD‘IORXU’ PLVK¾PLVKUD~PLVKQD‘IOHVKPHDW’ PXW¾PXWUD~PXWQD‘H[FUHPHQW’ SOHK~SOêK¾SOHKUD~SOêKQD‘VZHHSLQJVGXQJUXEELVK’ THOE¾THOEUD~THOEQD‘SXV’ VKL¾VKLUD~VKLQD‘UDLQ’ VKSLUW¾VKSLUW¬UD~VKSLUWQD‘VRXOVSLULW’ VKWDW¾VKWDWUD~VKWDWQD‘ILJXUHLPDJH’ XM¬¾XM¬UD~XMQD‘ZDWHU’ YDM~YRM¾YDMUD~YRMQD‘RLO’ 7KLV PRUSKHPH PLJKW EH GHULYHG IURP DQ ROG FROOHFWLYH VXIIL[ Q ZKLFK LV DWWHVWHG LQ *N ,RQ$WW KPJ /DW QD /LWK \QD 6ODY LQD 7KXV WKH SOXUDO RI EDU ‘JUDVV’ EDU¬UD ~ EDU¬QD FRXOG EH KLVWRULFDOO\ LGHQWLFDOZLWK/DWIDUQD‘IORXU’GHULYHGIURPIDU‘VRUWRIJUDLQVSHOW’
$QRWKHULPSRUWDQWW\SHRISOXUDOLVFKDUDFWHUL]HGE\WKHVXIIL[ ¬U ~ ¬Q 7KLV W\SH LQFOXGHV QXPHURXV PDVFXOLQH /DWLQ DQG 6ODYLF ORDQZRUGVGHQRWLQJKXPDQEHLQJV GUHT¾GUHT¬U~GUHT¬Q‘GHYLO’
230
chapter three
NDç¾NHç¬U~NHç¬Q‘ZHDYHU’ NXQDW¾NXQHW¬U~NXQHW¬Q‘EURWKHULQODZ’ ODE¾OHE¬U~OHE¬Q‘/DELQKDELWDQWRI/DEHULD’ PEUHW¾PEUHW¬U~PEUHW¬Q‘NLQJ’ QLS¾QLS¬U~ QLS¬Q‘QHSKHZJUDQGVRQ’ SULQG¾SULQG¬U~SULQG¬Q‘IDWKHUSDUHQW’ 6RPHZKDWUDUHUDUHWKRVHQRXQVRIWKHVDPHVHPDQWLFFDWHJRU\ PRVWRI WKHP—NLQVKLS WHUPV ZKLFK EHORQJHG WR WKH RULJLQDO ,QGR(XURSHDQ OH[LFRQ DW¬¾HW¬U~DW¬QHW¬Q‘IDWKHU’ JM\VK¾JM\VK¬U~JM\VK¬Q‘JUDQGIDWKHU’ Y¬OOD¾Y¬OOH]¬U~Y¬OOD]¬Q‘EURWKHU’ :RUGVRIGLIIHUHQWVHPDQWLFFDWHJRULHVDUHIHZ ULV¾ULV¬U~ULV¬Q‘O\Q[’ VKWUDW¾VKWUHW¬U~VKWUHW¬Q‘EHG OD\HU’ XMN¾XMT¬U~XMT¬Q‘ZROI’ ,W VHHPV WKDW WKH ROGHVW IRUPV RI WKLV NLQG DUH UHSUHVHQWHG E\ WKH ROG NLQVKLS WHUPV LQKHULWHG IURP ,QGR(XURSHDQ HYHQ WKRXJK LQY¬OOD WKLV W\SH RI SOXUDO LV FOHDUO\ VHFRQGDU\ FI EHORZ ,Q WKHVH ZRUGV WKH HQGLQJ ¬U ~ ¬Q VHHPV WR VWHP IURP (3$ LQD ,( LQR *N DWDNKPQX ‘PDGH RI SDS\UXV’ ZWVTKPQX ‘RI FOD\’ /LWK ¢XNVLQDV ‘JROGHQ’ 6ODY Yp¨ÚQÙ ‘HWHUQDO’ 3KRQHWLFDOO\ WKH HQGLQJ ¬U ~ ¬Q FDXVHV XPODXW $ FORVH SDUDOOHO RI WKLV W\SH RI SOXUDO FDQ EH IRXQG EHWZHHQHW¬U~ DW¬QHW¬Q‘IDWKHUV’ (3$ DWLQDDQGWKH6ODYLFUHODWLYH DGMHFWLYH RWÚQÙ‘IDWKHU’VSDWHUQDO’FRUUHVSRQGLQJWR RWÚFÚ‘IDWKHU’
,QVHYHUDOQRXQVZHILQGSOXUDOVLQLQM ERVKW¾ERVKWLQM‘VSLQGOHD[LVD[OH’ GUDS¬U~GUDS¬Q¾GUDSLQMG¬US¬QM‘VLFNOH’ NRF¾NRFLQM‘ERQHVNXOO’ NULPE~NU\P¾N¬UPLQM‘ZRUP’ SULIW¾SULIWLQM‘SULHVW’ VWDS¾VWDSLQM‘VWLFNVWDII’
morphology
231
$UDUHIRUPRIWKLVSOXUDOVXIIL[LV¬QMHQM O¬P¬ ~ ODP¬ ¾ O¬P¬QM ~ ODP¬QM O¬PHQM ~ ODPHQM ‘WKUHVKLQJ IORRU’ OXP¬¾OXPHQM‘ULYHU’ SODI¾SO¬I¬QM‘ZRROEODQNHWUXJ’ 7KLV VXIIL[ FDQ EH FRPSDUHG ZLWK /DWLQ FROOHFWLYH QRXQV LQ LQLXP DV ZHOODVZLWK,OO\ULDQLQLXPDWWHVWHGLQSODFHQDPHVFI'HOPLQLXP 7KHUHJXODUSOXUDORIQRXQVZLWKVWHPVHQGLQJLQQKDVQMLQPRGHUQ $OEDQLDQGXHWRWKH/DWH3URWR$OEDQLDQSDODWDOL]DWLRQRI QDL! QL !QM VHH $VDUHVXOWQMKDVEHFRPHDSOXUDOVXIIL[,WFOHDUO\ KDVQRKLVWRULFDOFRQQHFWLRQZLWKLQM EOL~EOî¾EOLQM‘OLQGHQ’ GUDJXD~GUD Q JXH¾GUDJRQM~GUDQJRM‘GUDJRQ’ NDWXD~NDWXH¾NDWRQM‘VWDEOHEDVHPHQWFHOODU’ PL~Pî¾PLQM‘PRXVH’ S¬UUXD~S¬UUXH¾S¬UUHQMS¬UURQM‘EURRN ULYHUEHG’ U¬P¬U~U¬PHQ¾U¬P¬QM‘9DODFKLDQ VKHSKHUG’ WKXD~WKXH¾WKRM~WKRQM‘ ILQJHU QDLO’
6HYHUDOSOXUDOVXIIL[HVDUHYHU\UDUH,QWZRZRUGVSOXUDOVDUH IRUPHGE\PHDQVRI¬]~ H]~ D] QMHUL¾QMHU¬]‘PDQSHUVRQKXPDQEHLQJ’ Y¬OOD¾Y¬OOH]¬U~Y¬OOD]¬Q‘EURWKHU’ 7KLVVXIIL[FDQEHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHVXIIL[RIDEVWUDFWD]¬ ,QRQHFDVHSOXUDOLW\LVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHVXIIL[P (3$ PD ,( PR GMDO¬¾GMHPGMHOP‘ER\\RXWK’ 7KH DGMHFWLYDO GHULYDWLYH LQ KDV EHHQ UHDQDO\]HG DV WKH SOXUDO PDUNHULQWKHIROORZLQJFDVH VKSHQG¾VKSH]¬‘IRZO’
232
chapter three
'HFOHQVLRQ 7KH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ GHFOHQVLRQDO V\VWHP LV UHIOHFWHG LQ WKH PRGHUQ $OEDQLDQ “LQGHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ WKRXJK QRW WKH “definite” GHFOHQVLRQ ZKLFK KDV D GLIIHUHQW RULJLQ $GMHFWLYHV ORVW WKH HQWLUH GHFOHQVLRQDOV\VWHPUHWDLQLQJRQO\WKHRSSRVLWLRQRIVLQJXODUDQGSOXUDO IRUPV LQ2OG$OEDQLDQWKHGHFOHQVLRQRIDGMHFWLYHVFRUUHVSRQGHGWRWKDW RIQRXQV 7KH “LQGHILQLWH”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¡%.( DSXG -2./ ,) ;;;9,, R[\WRQHVLV LQ QRPVJ RI RVWHPV LQ ¬ 3('(56(1 .= ;;;9, JHQDEO V ! JHQGDW VJ VWHPV H REO X LQIOXHQFHG E\ QRP VJ RI WKH “GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ REO L ,( GDW AL DJUHHVZLWK0(<(5$OE6W,,, -2./,);;;9,, QRPVJRIR VWHPV LQ ¬ DV D JHQHUDOL]DWLRQ RI WKH ROG DFFXVDWLYH LQ RP ! ¬ )HVWVFKU .UHWVFKPHU ]HUR HQGLQJ RI SOXUDO 6 .2. $$UE6W ,,, DJUHHVZLWK3('(56(1 GHULYHVYHIURP ÆAPRIXVWHPV &$3,'$1$URP YRFDWLYHLQ%DONDQ5RPDQFH % 8%(1 0) ;;,; 6ODYLF RULJLQV RI WKH $OEDQLDQ YRFDWLYH % $5,Ç +\PMH JHQGDW VJ VWHPV IURP DEO RI VWHPV LQ V ORF SO HVK VAP ,VW JHQGDW VJ H AP YH AP DIWHUDYRZHO 3,6$1,6DJJL IROORZV%ARIÇ +\PMH IROORZV 0(<(5$OE6W,,, +$03 .=/;;9 QRPSOH FROOHFWLYH,(
5,=$ %86K7;,,, H[SODLQVREOXSKRQHWLFDOO\ NDX‘EXOO’ NDYL NDL 32/.2UELV;,, IROORZV% 8%(1 '20,5(6O ;/9 IROORZV %ARIÇ); 6&+0,77%5$1'7 .UDW\ORV ;,, UHFRQVWUXFWV DWKHPDWLF DV D VRXUFH RI DFF VJ LQ RVWHPV '(61,&.$-$36)LO HQGLQJVRISOXUDO *UVWU QRPSOØ ,( RLQRPSO¬ IURPROGFROOHFWLYHV QRPVJVWHPV =Y VWURM PRUSKRQRORJ\RIREOL X '(0,5$-ǬVKWMH ]HUR HQGLQJRISOXUDO 0RUIKLVW QRPSOLQ H ,( V JHQ
morphology
233
GDW VJ VWHPV IURP L H YH RLV 92521,1$ *U VWU 2OG $OEDQLDQ GHFOHQVLRQ RI DGMHFWLYHV 0$11 +LVW *U 25(/ 6RY VODY =I%DON ;,; UHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKH$OEDQLDQQRPLQDOLQIOH[LRQ
RVWHPV ,QWKHVLQJXODUWKH3URWR$OEDQLDQRVWHPQRPLQDWLYHHQGHGLQ
D ,( RV,QWKHPDMRULW\RIQRXQVWKLVHQGLQJZDVXQVWUHVVHGDQG WKHUHIRUHLWZDVDOWRJHWKHUORVWLQ$OEDQLDQ QRPVJGHP‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ G¢PD ,( GDPRV QRPVJJMDN‘EORRG’ (3$ V¢ND ,( VRáRV QRPVJSODN‘ROGPDQ’ (3$ S H O¢ND ,( S H OiNRV QRP VJ SUXVK ‘HPEHU JORZLQJ FRDO’ (3$ SU·hD ,(
SUXVRV QRPVJVKL‘UDLQ’ (3$ VgMD ,( V RV nom. sg. WUDS‘IHUU\’ (3$ WU¢SD ,( WURSRV ,Q D IHZ FDVHV KRZHYHU $OEDQLDQ UHIOHFWV D 3URWR$OEDQLDQ R[\WRQLF VWUHVV ZKLFK SUHVHUYHG WKH HQGLQJ DV ¬ QRW WR EH FRQIXVHG ZLWK WKH SDVVDJHRIVRPHRIROGRVWHPVWRVWHPV nom. sg. EUXP¬‘GRXJK’ (3$ EUXP¢ ,( EKÖPRV nom. sg. EXUU¬ ‘PDQ KXVEDQG’ /3$ EXU¢ *HUPDQLF ORDQ ZRUG nom. sg. GMDO¬‘ER\\RXWK’ (3$ GHO¢ ,( GK L ORV nom. sg. JMXP¬‘VOHHS’ (3$ VXSQ¢ ,( VXSQRV nom. sg. OXP¬‘ULYHU’ (3$ OXP¢ ,( OXPRV $OEDQLDQ KDV D YRFDWLYH IRUP LQR XVHG ERWK E\ R DQG VWHPV QHQR ‘RK PRWKHU’ EXUUR ‘RK KXVEDQG’ $ VLPLODU IRUP H[LVWV LQ %DONDQ 5RPDQFHFI5XPIDWR‘RKJLUO’7KLVYRFDWLYHKDVEHHQERUURZHGIURP 6RXWK6ODYLFZKHUHRFKDUDFWHUL]HVWKHYRFDWLYHRIVWHPV GpYR‘RK PDLGHQ’ ÊHQR‘RKZRPDQ’
)RUPVRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHRIRVWHPVFRLQFLGHZLWKWKHQRPLQD
WLYH 7KH\ KDG DOUHDG\ EHFRPH LGHQWLFDO LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ ZKHUH WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ HQGLQJ RP PHUJHG ZLWK WKH QRPLQDWLYH RV LQWR (3$ D$FFHQWXDOO\WKHDFFXVDWLYHGLGQRWGLIIHUIURPWKHQRPLQDWLYH
234
chapter three
KHQFHWKHVDPHGLVWULEXWLRQRIWKHPRUHIUHTXHQW]HURHQGLQJDQGOHVV IUHTXHQW¬ DFFGHP‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ G¢PD ,( GDPRP DFFJMDN‘EORRG’ (3$ V¢ND ,( VRáRP DFFSODN‘ROGPDQ’ (3$ S H O¢ND ,( S H OiNRP DFFSUXVK‘HPEHUJORZLQJFRDO’ (3$ SU·hD ,( SUXVRP DFFVKL‘UDLQ’ (3$ VgMD ,( V RP acc. WUDS‘IHUU\’ (3$ WU¢SD ,( WURSRP 2[\WRQLFIRUPV acc. EUXP¬‘GRXJK’ (3$ EUXP¢ ,( EKÖPRP acc. GMDO¬‘ER\\RXWK’ (3$ GHO¢ ,( GK L ORP acc. JMXP¬‘VOHHS’ (3$ VXSQ¢ ,( VXSQRP acc. OXP¬‘ULYHU’ (3$ OXP¢ ,( OXPRP
$OOWKHREOLTXHFDVHVRIWKHVLQJXODURVWHPSDUDGLJPPHUJHG LQWR RQH IRUPDQW L X 7KH FKRLFH RI WKH SDODWDO RU ODELDO YDULDQW LV GHWHUPLQHG E\ D VLPSOH FRPSOHPHQWDU\ GLVWULEXWLRQ ZKRVH FRQGLWLRQV FDQYDU\LQGLIIHUHQWGLDOHFWV XIROORZVYRZHOVDQGYHODUVLDSSHDUV DIWHUDQ\RWKHUSKRQHPH7KHODELDOHQGLQJVHHPVWRKDYHGHYHORSHGDV DVHFRQGDU\YDULDQWRIL(YHQWKRXJKWKHH[DFWFRQGLWLRQVDQGWLPHRI WKLV SURFHVV DUH XQNQRZQ KLVWRULFDOO\ ZH KDYH RQO\ WR GHDO ZLWK WKH PRUSKHPHL 7KH JHQLWLYH GDWLYH DQG DEODWLYH HQGLQJ L FRQWLQXHV (3$ HL UHIOHFWLQJ WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ ORFDWLYH HL FI WKH WUDFHV RI WKH ROG ORFDWLYH LQ WKH SOXUDO ,Q PDQ\ RWKHU ,QGR(XURSHDQ ODQJXDJHV WKLV IRUPRIWKHORFDWLYHFHGHGWRWKHPRUH“regular” WKHPDWLF RL JHQGDWDEOGHPL‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ GDPHL ,( GDPHL JHQGDWDEOJMDNX‘EORRG’ (3$ VDNHL ,( VRáHL JHQGDWDEOSODNX‘ROGPDQ’ (3$ S H ODNHL ,( S H OiNHL JHQGDWDEOSUXVKL‘HPEHUJORZLQJFRDO’ (3$ SUXhHL ,(
SUXVHL JHQGDWDEOVKLX‘UDLQ’ (3$ V MHL ,( V HL gen.-dat.-abl. WUDSL‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSHL ,( WURSHL
morphology
235
,Q1RUWK*HJWKHUHH[LVWVDVSHFLDOIRUPRIWKHDEODWLYHLQW DEOPRWLW ‘\HDU’ ,WKDVEHHQWUDQVIHUUHGIURPWKH“GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ
,Q SOXUDO WKH RVWHP QRPLQDWLYH KDV VHYHUDO HQGLQJV H ¬
]HURDQGD7KHVHHQGLQJVUHIOHFWDQLQWHUDFWLRQRIWZRGLVWLQFW3URWR $OEDQLDQHQGLQJVLQGLIIHUHQWDFFHQWXDOFRQGLWLRQV (3$ AFRQWLQXLQJ ,( AV DQG WKH LQQRYDWLYH (3$ DL FRQWLQXLQJ ,( RL RULJLQDOO\ FKDUDFWHULVWLF RI WKH SURQRPLQDO GHFOHQVLRQ 7KH ILUVW HQGLQJ H FDQ UHIOHFWERWKVWUHVVHG(3$ ADQG DL QRP SO GUDQJMH ‘EDUJHSROH’ (3$ GUDQJA GUDQJDL ,(
GKURQJKAV GKURQJKRL QRP SO JDUGKH ‘IHQFH’ (3$ JDUGA JDUGDL ,( ½KRU GKAV ½KRUGKRL QRPSOJMDTH‘EORRG’ (3$ VDNA VDNDL ,( VRáAV VRáRL QRPSOKHOOH‘VSHDUVSLW’ (3$ VNAOA VNAODL ,( VNAOAV
VNAORL QRPSOUULPH‘UDLQZRUP’ (3$ ZULPA ZULPDL ,( ÆÖ PAV ÆÖPRL nom.pl. WUHSH ‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSA WUDSDL ,( WURSAV
WURSRL 8QVWUHVVHG A\LHOGHG¬ QRPSOEULU¬~EULQ¬‘KRUQ’ (3$ EULQA ,( EKÖQAV QRP SO GK¬PE¬ ~ GKDPE¬ ‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPEA ,(
½KRPEAV QRPSOGK¬QGXU¬~GKDQGXU¬‘EULGHJURRPVRQLQODZ’ (3$
G]HQUA ,( ½HQiUAV QRPSOHVK¬‘KHGJHKRJ’ (3$ HG]MA ,( H½KAV QRPSOJM\VK¬‘JUDQGIDWKHU’ (3$ V VA ,( V VAV QRPSOWHU¬‘EXOO’ (3$ WDXUA ,( WDXUAV 8QVWUHVVHG DLDSSHDUVDVD]HURHQGLQJ QRPSOJML~JMî‘EUHDVWFKHVW’ (3$ VLQDL ,( VLQRL QRPSOOXJM‘WURXJK’ (3$ OXJDL ,( OXJKRL QRPSOSOHT‘ROGPDQ’ (3$ S H ODNDL ,( S H OiNRL QRPSOXMT‘ZROI’ (3$ Z XONDL ,( ÆâáRL QRP SO YMHK¬UU ‘IDWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZHVXUDL ,(
VÆHXURL
236
chapter three
QRPSOGLDO]MHUP‘ILUH’ (3$ GÊHUPDL ,( ÞKHUPRL $VWRWKHHQGLQJDLWUHSODFHGWKHRULJLQDOHQGLQJHLQPDQ\RVWHPV XQGHUWKHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHVWHPV QRPSODUD‘EHDU’ (3$ DU ,( ÖWV QRPSOGHPD‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ GDP ,( GDPV QRPSOGHUUD‘SLJ’ (3$ GDUM ,( ½KRUV QRPSON¬UED‘WXEEDUUHO’ (3$ NDUE ,( NRUEKV QRPSONUHSD‘URFN’ (3$ NUHS NUHSV QRPSOWKHSD‘SHDNSRLQW’ (3$ WVDLS ,( RLSV 7KHDERYHGLVWULEXWLRQRIHQGLQJVLVFRUURERUDWHGE\WKHIDFWWKDWERWK XPODXW DQG WKH SDODWDOL]DWLRQ RI YHODUV DUH PXFK PRUH W\SLFDO RI VXEVWDQWLYHVZLWKD]HURSOXUDO IURP/3$ L (3$ DL WKDQRIIRUPV ZLWKRWKHUHQGLQJV
7KHIRUPRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHLQSOXUDOLVLGHQWLFDOZLWKWKDWRIWKH QRPLQDWLYH SOXUDO $FFXVDWLYHV LQ ¬ DQG LQ ]HUR FRLQFLGH ZLWK WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJQRPLQDWLYHV7KHHQGLQJRIWKHRVWHPDFFXVDWLYHSOXUDO
RQVORVWLWVILQDOFOXVWHUDQG\LHOGHG(3$ D VWUHVVHGRUXQVWUHVVHG !$OE¬RU]HUR DFFSOEULU¬~EULQ¬‘KRUQ’ (3$ EULQD ,( EKÖQRQV DFF SO GK¬PE¬ ~ GKDPE¬ ‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPED ,(
½KRPERQV DFFSOHVK¬‘KHGJHKRJ’ (3$ HG]MD ,( H½KRQV DFFSOWHU¬‘EXOO’ (3$ WDXUD ,( WDXURQV DFF SO YMHK¬UU ‘IDWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZHVXUD ,(
VÆHXURQV DFFSOGLDO]MHUP‘ILUH’ (3$ GÊHUPD ÞKHUPRQV 7KHDERYHSURFHVVOHGWRWKHDQDORJLFDOH[WHQVLRQRIQRPLQDWLYHSOXUDO IRUPDWLRQV LQWR DOO DFFXVDWLYH SOXUDOV $FFXVDWLYHV FRLQFLGHG ZLWK QRPLQDWLYHV UHSURGXFLQJ WKH SKHQRPHQD SKRQHWLFDOO\ MXVWLILHG RQO\ LQ WKHQRPLQDWLYH SDODWDOL]DWLRQRIILQDOYHODUVXPODXW DQGUHSHDWLQJVXFK HQGLQJVRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHDVHDQGD DFFSOGUDQJMH‘EDUJHSROH’IURPQRPSOGUDQJMH DFFSOJDUGKH‘IHQFH’IURPQRPSOJDUGKH
morphology
237
DFFSON¬UED‘WXEEDUUHO’IURPQRPSON¬UED DFFSONUHSD‘URFN’IURPQRPSONUHSD acc. pl. WUHSH‘IHUU\’IURPnom. pl. WUHSH DFFSOWKHSD‘SHDNSRLQW’IURPQRPSOWKHSD
7KHJHQLWLYHGDWLYHKDVWZRIRUPDQWVLQWKHSOXUDO2QHRIWKHP
LVHZKLFKLVDGLUHFWFRQWLQXDWLRQRIWKHVWUHVVHG,(JHQSO AP 6NW Y¤NP/DWGHXP !(3$ A JHQGDWSOGHPH‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ GDPA ,( GDPAP gen.-dat. pl. GMDOH‘ER\\RXWK’ (3$ GHOA ,( GK L OAP JHQGDW SO GK¬PEH ~ GKDPEH ‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPEA ,(
½KRPEAP JHQGDWSOJDUGKH‘IHQFH’ (3$ JDUGA ,( ½KRUGKAP JHQGDWSOSUXVKH‘HPEHUJORZLQJFRDO’ (3$ SUXVA ,(
SUXVAP JHQGDWSOWKHSH‘SHDNSRLQW’ (3$ WVDLSA ,( RLSAP 7KH RWKHU JHQLWLYHGDWLYH HQGLQJ LV YH ,W LV SUREDEOH WKDW WKLV PRU SKHPH LV IURP WKH ROG XVWHP GHFOHQVLRQ ZKHUH WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ HQGLQJ APIROORZHGWKHDEODXWLQJVWHPIRUPDQW H X ,( ÆAP! (3$ ZA!$OEYH/DWHUYHZDVH[WHQGHGWRWKHRVWHPVZKHUHLW ZDVDPDOJDPDWHGZLWKRULJLQDOH!HYH JHQGDWSOJDUGKHYH‘IHQFH’UHSODFLQJJDUGKH JHQGDWSOKHOOHYH‘VSHDUVSLW’UHSODFLQJKHOOH JHQGDWSOUHQGHYH‘URZ’UHSODFLQJUHQGH JHQGDWSOUULPHYH‘UDLQZRUP’UHSODFLQJUULPH JHQGDWSOWUHSHYH‘IHUU\’UHSODFLQJWUHSH JHQGDWSO]DMHYH‘ULYHUVDQGULYHUEDQN’UHSODFLQJ]DMH
7KHRVWHPDEODWLYHSOXUDOPDUNHULVHVK (3$ DLVX ,(
RLVX 6NW H¿X *N QKUK /DW LV 6ODY p[Ù &I WKH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHV DEOSOGHPHVK‘\RXQJEXOO’ (3$ GDPDLVX ,( GDPRLVX DEOSOGK¬PEHVK~GKDPEHVK‘WRRWK’ (3$ G]DPEDLVX ,(
½KRPERLVX DEOSOJDUGKHVK‘IHQFH’ (3$ JDUGDLVX ,( ½KRUGKRLVX DEOSOKHOOHVK‘VSHDUVSLW’ (3$ VNAODLVX ,( VNAORLVX
238
chapter three
DEOSOSUXVKHVK‘HPEHUJORZLQJFRDO’ (3$ SUXhDLVX ,(
SUXVRLVX DEOSOWUDSHVK‘IHUU\’ (3$ WUDSDLVX ,( WURSRLVX
VWHPV 7KHVWHPQRPLQDWLYHVLQJXODUHQGVLQ¬ (3$ ,( FI6NW¢yY*N$WWZYTC&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV nom. sg. EDUU¬‘ORDGEXUGHQ’ (3$ EDU ,( EKRU nom. sg. JULP¬‘FUXPEELW’ (3$ JULP ,( ÞÖP nom. sg. KXUE¬ ‘VZDOORZ PRXWKIXO’ (3$ VNXUE ,(
VNÖEK nom. sg. NDUS¬‘URFN’ (3$ NDUS ,( NRUS nom. sg. SDO¬‘SDLU IROG’ (3$ SDO ,( SRO nom. sg. ]RUU¬‘JXW’ (3$ GÊUQ ,( ÞUQ
7KH DFFXVDWLYH VLQJXODU RI WKH VWHP GHFOHQVLRQ LV LGHQWLFDO ZLWKLWVFRUUHVSRQGLQJQRPLQDWLYH7KHIRUPJRHVEDFNWR(3$ ,(
P 6NW SUL\dP *N $WW ZYTCP 6/DY ÊHQ_ 7KH IROORZLQJ H[DPSOHVLOOXVWUDWHWKLVGHYHORSPHQW acc. sg. NURGK¬‘EHHKLYH’ (3$ NUG ,( NUGP acc. sg. O¬QG¬~ODQG¬‘ZRRGWLPEHUPDWHULDO’ (3$ OHQW ,( OHQWP acc. sg. OO¬U¬~OODQ¬‘IRUHDUPHOO’ (3$ DOHQ ,( ROHQP acc. sg. UUXGK¬‘ZULQNOH’ (3$ UXG] ,( UX½P acc. sg. WROO¬ ‘EDOG VSRW GUXP PHPEUDQH’ (3$ WVO ,(
WVOP acc. sg. WKHN¬‘IULQJH’ (3$ WVDN ,( RNP
7KHJHQLWLYHGDWLYHDQGDEODWLYHVLQJXODUVKDUHWKHHQGLQJH ZKLFKFRQWLQXHVWKH,QGR(XURSHDQGDWLYHORFDWLYHHQGLQJ L
gen.-dat.-abl. sg. DUH‘ILHOG’ (3$ DUL ,( DUL gen.-dat.-abl. sg. KDOH ‘ILVK ERQH VSOLQWHU’ (3$ VNDOL ,(
VNROL gen.-dat.-abl. sg. PMDOFH‘EHH’ (3$ PHOLWML ,( PHOLWL gen.-dat.-abl. sg. UU\PH‘IORZ RIZDWHU ’ (3$ VU PL ,(
VU PL
morphology
239
gen.-dat.-abl. sg. YHUH ~ YHQH ‘ZLQH’ (3$ ZDLQL ,(
ÆRLQL gen.-dat.-abl. sg. ]RQMH‘ZLIH’ (3$ Z L WhSDWQML ,( ÆL SRWQL
'HSHQGLQJRQWKHSODFHRIVWUHVVLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQ,( V! (3$ RI WKH QRPLQDWLYH SOXUDO FRXOG JLYH ¬ RU D ,Q QRXQV RI WKH DFFHQWXDOW\SH$WKHHQGLQJLV¬
QRPSOEDUU¬‘ORDGEXUGHQ’ (3$ EDU ,( EKRUV QRPSOEDWK¬‘EURDGEHDQ’ (3$ EDWV ,( EKDV QRPSOIDU¬‘VHHGVHPHQNLQ’ (3$ VSDU ,( VSRUV QRPSOJU\N¬‘WKURDW’ (3$ JUZN ,( ÞUÆNV QRPSOO¬QG¬~ODQG¬‘ZRRGWLPEHUPDWHULDO’ (3$ OHQW ,( OHQWV QRPSOQ¬P¬~QDP¬‘FXUVH’ (3$ QDP ,( QRPV 1RXQVRIWKHDFFHQWXDOW\SH%KDYHD nom. pl. JULPD‘FUXPEELW’ (3$ JULP ,( ÞÖPV nom. pl. KXUED ‘VZDOORZ PRXWKIXO’ (3$ VNXUE ,(
VNÖEKV nom. pl. NDUSD‘URFN’ (3$ NDUS ,( NRUSV nom. pl. NURGKD‘EHHKLYH’ (3$ NUG ,( NUGV QRPSOOHUD‘KHDSRIVWRQHVSHEEOHEDQN’ (3$ ODXUV nom. pl. OO¬UD~OODQD‘IRUHDUPHOO’ (3$ DOHQ ,( ROHQV ,Q WKH DFFXVDWLYH SOXUDO $OEDQLDQ IRUPV FRLQFLGH ZLWK WKRVH RI WKH QRPLQDWLYH SOXUDO (3$ ,( V FI /DW HTXV *RWK JLERV 7KH DFFHQWXDOSDWWHUQRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHSOXUDOZDVWKHVDPH 7KH REOLTXH SOXUDO FDVHV RI WKH VWHP GHFOHQVLRQ DUH RI DQDORJLFDO RULJLQ 7KH\ KDYH EHHQ EXLOW DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH SDWWHUQV RI WKH RVWHP SDUDGLJP7KXVLQWKHJHQLWLYHGDWLYHSOXUDOVWHPVHQGLQDYHZKLOH WKHDEODWLYHSOXUDOVKRZVWKHHQGLQJDVK
7UDFHVRIRWKHUGHFOHQVLRQVDUHUDUHLQ$OEDQLDQ,QDOOFDVHV
WKH\DUHLQWHUWZLQHGZLWKRDQGVWHPIRUPDQWV7KHQRPLQDWLYHSOXUDO RIWKHZRUGQDW¬LVQHWFOHDUO\JRLQJEDFNWR(3$ QDNWHMH ,( QRáW
240
chapter three
HHV DQ ROG LVWHP $W WKH VDPH WLPH WKH UHVW RI WKLV QRXQ’V QRPLQDO SDUDGLJPVKRZVRQO\VWHPWHUPLQDWLRQV 7KH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ R DQG VWHP SDUDGLJPV FDQ EH VXPPDUL]HG DV IROORZV ([DPSOHV ]MDUP ‘ULYHU’ GÊDUPD HVK ‘KHGJHKRJ’ HG]MD NDUS¬ ‘URFN’ NDUS RVWHPV VJ QRP DFF JHQGDW DEO
GÊDUPD
GÊDUPD
GÊDUPHL
GÊDUPHL
SO
HG]MD
HG]MD
HG]MHL
HG]MHL
GÊDUPDL
GÊDUPD
GÊDUPA
GÊDUPDLVX
HG]MA
HG]MD
HG]MA
HG]MDLVX
VWHPV
QRP DFF JHQGDW DEO
VJ
SO
NDUS
NDUS
NDUSL
NDUSL
NDUS
NDUS
3URQRXQV 3URWR$OEDQLDQLQKHULWHGWKHEDVLFSHUVRQDODQGGHPRQVWUDWLYH
SURQRXQV RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ $W WKH VDPH WLPH QHZ V\QWDFWLF 3URWR $OEDQLDQVWUXFWXUHVGHYHORSHGZKLFKUHSODFHGWKHLQKHULWHGSRVVHVVLYH SURQRPLQDOV\VWHPDQGFUHDWHGDQHZJUDPPDWLFDOFDWHJRU\RIGHILQLWH LQGHILQLWHSURQRXQV,QVLPLODUFRQGLWLRQVDQHZSDUWRIVSHHFKDUWLFOH ZDVGHYHORSHG /LWHUDWXUH %233 UHIOX VÆRP X‘,’ H½KRP RULJLQVRI DLDMR '2=21 ,WDOR$OEXWK 0(<(5=IURP3K ;,— DIURP/DWDWTXH $OE6W,,, DFFRINXVK :E
morphology
241
NXVK ERUURZHG IURP /DW TXLV H LQ PHMH WHMH IURP DEO RI VWHPV X ERUURZHG IURP 5RP HR /DW HJR ‘,’ 3('(56(1 $OE 7H[WH REOLTXH FDVHV RI NXVK )HVWVNU 7KRPVHQ .=;;;9, VJDFFW\ WÆH MRIURP,(
V “GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ SRVVHVVLYH SURQRXQV LQWHUURJDWLYHSURQRXQV RULJLQRI LP~ HP 3URQ DIURP ,( DX /$3,$1$ 6W 9DULD X ,( VÆH -2./ ,) ;;;9,, “GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ ;/,; RULJLQ RI PXD ~ PXH 6SUDFKH ,; GDWQDH ,( QRVAP 6WXGLHQ DIURP/DWDG /.8%$ D IURP ,( DG 0(,//(7 ,GJ -E , RQ NXVK ;+89$1, Ç$%(- %86K7 ;, SDUWLFOH D LQ VJ ,( H R 3,6$1, 6DJJL HQFOLWLF Q¬ DUFKDLF GDW QDH 6&+0,77%5$1'7 .UDW\ORV ;,, GHI DFF VJ JXULQ JXUWRP 0$11 +LVW JU LGHQWLILHVQ¬ZLWK*NGIY-PJ ÇABEJ%86K7 ;9,,, SRVVHVVLYHSURQRXQV 6W, ODFNRIDSKHUHVLVLQVJ SURQRXQV 92521,1$ 0HVKDUL “GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ 25(/ 6RY VODY 3ULW SRVVHVVLYHSURQRXQV /%;;; 7RFKDULDQ SDUDOOHO WR NXVK +$03 55/ ;;, VLPLODULW\ LQ YRFDOLVPEHWZHHQXDQG+LWWXJJD‘,’ .257/$1'766*/; MR ,( LMRU HM '(0,5$-$( NXVKIURP áXV
3HUVRQDOSURQRXQV $OEDQLDQ ORVW WKH RULJLQDO ,QGR(XURSHDQ QRPLQDWLYH IRUP RI
WKH VJ SHUVRQDO SURQRXQ ZKDWHYHU LWV H[DFW SKRQHWLF VKDSH DFWXDOO\ ZDV FI/DWHJA*NGIY6.WDKDP+LWWXJJD ,WZDVUHSODFHGE\X (3$ VZD ,( VÆRP D UHIOH[LYH SURQRXQ VHH EHORZ :KLOH WKLV X KDVEHHQSUHVHUYHGLQVRPHGLDOHFWVWKHFOLWLFQ¬ LGHQWLFDOZLWK*NPCK PJ UHLQIRUFHVLWLQWKHOLWHUDU\ODQJXDJHDQGPRVWGLDOHFWV XQ¬ ,WDOR $OEDQLDQKDVVXEVWLWXWHGWKHGLPLQXWLYHXWKIRULW 2WKHU IRUPV RI WKH VJ SHUVRQDO SURQRXQ DUH GHULYHG IURP ,( PH 7KH DFFXVDWLYH DQG GDWLYH KDYH PHUJHG DV PXD ~ PXH (3$ PP ZKLFKLVLGHQWLFDOZLWKWKH,QGR(XURSHDQDFFXVDWLYH PP 6NWPP $YPuP23UXVPLHQ6ODYP?7KHFRUUHVSRQGLQJDWRQLFIRUPP¬FRQ WLQXHVXQVWUHVVHG(3$ PPRUWKH,(HQFOLWLF PH 7KHVJDEODWLYHLVPHMH,WLVFOHDUWKDWWKLVIRUPLVUHODWHGWRWKH,QGR (XURSHDQ ORFDWLYH PHL ZKLFK LV DWWHVWHG LQ 6NW PH PD\L +RZHYHU
242
chapter three
WKHGHYHORSPHQWRI(3$ MVHHPVWREHSKRQHWLFDOO\LUUHJXODU)LQDOH PXVWEHDQDORJLFDOWRWKHDEODWLYHGHVLQHQFHHRIWKHRVWHPV
,QWKHVJWKHQRPLQDWLYHLVWLFRQWLQXLQJ(3$ W ,( W FI 6NW Wg $Y W *N UW /DW W 2,U W· 2+* G 6ODY W\ DQG RWKHU VLPLODU IRUPV *HJ DWWHVWV DQ DOWHUQDWH IRUP WLQ¬ ZKLFK KDV EHHQ DQDORJLFDOO\IRUPHGLQGXFHGIURPWKHVJXQ¬
7KHIRUPRIWKHGDWLYHDFFXVDWLYHLV W\ (3$ W X Z ,(DFF WÆP 6NW WYdP $Y SZuP 23UXV WLHQ DQG 6ODY W? DWWHVW DQ DOWHUQDWH WP 7KHDEODWLYHWHMHLVWREHH[SODLQHGDVDUHVXOWRILQIOXHQFHRIPHMH7KH RULJLQDOIRUPPXVWKDYHEHHQ WHLRU WÆHL
7KHDUFKDLFIRUPRIWKHQRPLQDWLYHSOLVQD (3$ QD ,(
QRVFI6NWQDV,WZDVKRZHYHUUHSODFHGE\QHZKLFKUHIOHFWV(3$
QA ,( QAVZKHUHWKHOHQJWKHQHGRJUDGHLVWKHUHVXOWRIDQDORJLFDO SUHVVXUHIURPWKHDFFXVDWLYH7KHDFFXVDWLYHQHUHIOHFWV(3$ QAV ,(
QAVFI$YQA6ODY Q\7KHDWRQLFDFFXVDWLYHIRUPQDFRQWLQXHV(3$
QD ,( QRVFIHQFOLWLF6NWQDV7KHDWRQLFDFFXVDWLYHPD\EHFRP SDUHGZLWK23UXVDFFPDQV QRQV 7KHGDWLYHDQGDEODWLYHIRUPVQHYHDQGQHVKDUHUHFHQWIRUPDWLRQVEXLOW XSRQ WKH VXEVWDQWLYH’V SDUDGLJPV ,Q 2OG $OEDQLDQ ZH ILQG DQ DUFKDLF GDWLYHQDH QRVAPFI23UXVQRXVRQ6ODY QDVÙ
7KHSOQRPLQDWLYHMXKDVERUURZHGWKHVKRUWYRFDOLVPRIWKH
DFFXVDWLYH7KHODWWHU—ERWKWRQLFDQGDWRQLF—LVMX (3$ MXZKLFKLV LGHQWLFDOZLWK/LWKDFFM¸V
7KH VXEVWDQWLYH SDUDGLJP KDV LQIOXHQFHG WKH GDWLYH MXYH $ PRUH DUFKDLFIRUPLVX (3$ ZDV ,( ÆRV7KHDEODXWJUDGHLVIURPWKH SURQRPLQDO VWHP ÆHV 7KLV IRUP KDV EHHQ RXVWHG RQ DFFRXQW RI KRPRSKRQ\ ZLWK WKH VJ DQG UHIOH[LYH SURQRXQV 7KH DEODWLYH MXVK KRZHYHU FDQ JR EDFN GLUHFWO\ WR (3$ MXVX D IRUP QHDUO\ VXSHULP SRVDEOHXSRQWKH/LWKORFMgVX7KH$OEDQLDQIRUPWKRXJKKDVXQGHU JRQHDQDORJLFDOVKRUWHQLQJRIWKHRULJLQDO
7KH UHIOH[LYH SURQRXQ X XVHG LQ SDUWLFXODU LQ DQDO\WLFDO IRUPV RI WKH PHGLRSDVVLYH JRHV EDFN WR (3$ ZD ,( VÆRP DFF ‘VHOI’
243
morphology
7KHVJSHUVRQDOSURQRXQVD\~ DLDW¬FRQVLVWRIWZRSDUWV SURFOLWLFD (3$ D DQG SURQRXQV SURSHU 7KH IDFW WKDW D ZDV QRW ORVW GXH WR DSKHUHVLVSURYHVWKDWLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQWKLVPRUSKHPHIXQFWLRQHGDVD VHSDUDWH ZRUG +LVWRULFDOO\ LW LV FRQQHFWHG ZLWK WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ SDUWLFOH H R 6NW DV¢X ‘WKDW’ 6ODY RQÙ LG 7KH DFFXVDWLYH DQG DEODWLYH VJ SURQRXQV DSSHDU ZLWKRXW D ZKHQ IROORZLQJ FHUWDLQ SUHSRVLWLRQV 7KH SURQRPLQDO PDVFXOLQH IRUPV FRQWLQXH ,( HL 6NW D\¢P ‘KH’ /DW LV 2/DW HLV 7KH IHPLQLQH VWHP FRQWLQXHV ,( WKH IHP VJ RI WKH GHPRQVWUDWLYH R 7KH REOLTXH FDVHV FRQWLQXH ,( WR DQG R 7KHSDUDGLJPRIWKHSHUVRQFDQEHUHFRQVWUXFWHGDVIROORZV
QRP DFF JHQGDW DEO
PDVFQHXW
IHP
D\~ DL (3$ HL L LG DW¬~ DWê, DWDˆ (3$ WD DWLDWLM (3$ WHL DWLDWLM (3$ WHL
DMR (3$ M DW¬~ DWê, DWDˆ (3$ WP DVDMDVDMH (3$ WVMDL DVRDFR (3$ WVMV
7KHGSOSDUDGLJPLVGHULYHGIURPWKHSURQRPLQDOVWHPV WR
DQG R 7KH RULJLQDO IRUP RI WKH PDVFXOLQH QRPLQDWLYH KDV EHHQ LQIOXHQFHG E\ DFFXVDWLYH 7KH SDUDGLJP LV WR EH UHFRQVWUXFWHG DV IRO ORZV PDVF
QRP DFF JHQGDW DEO
IHPQHXW
DWD>IURPDFF@ DWR (3$ W WV W DWD (3$ WD WRQV DWR (3$ W WV W DW\UH~ DW\QH>RIXQNQRZQRULJLQ@ DVLVKDFLVK (3$ WVM D LVX DVRVKDFRVK (3$ WVMVX
3RVVHVVLYHSURQRXQV (YHU\SRVVHVVLYHSURQRXQLVFRPSRVHGRIDGHPRQVWUDWLYHSUR QRXQDQGDSHUVRQDOSRVVHVVLYHHOHPHQW7KHGSHUVRQSRVVHVVRUIRUPV DUH RSDTXHO\ DQDO\WLFDO 7KH\ FRQVLVW RI DQ DUWLFOH GHPRQVWUDWLYH SUR QRXQ FRXSOHGZLWKWKHJHQLWLYHRIWKHSHUVRQDOSURQRXQ7KHSRV VHVVRU IRUPDWLRQV DUH DOVR WKH UHVXOW RI JUDPPDWLFDOL]DWLRQ WKRXJK RI
244
chapter three
ROGHU PRUSKRORJLFDO VWUXFWXUHV ,Q WZR FDVHV ROG SRVVHVVLYH SURQRXQV KDYHEHHQSUHVHUYHGLQIRUPDQGIXQFWLRQ ,QRUGHUWRH[SUHVVWKHVJSRVVHVVLYH$OEDQLDQHPSOR\VWKHIROORZLQJ IRUPVVJIRUPV PDVFLP~ HPIHPLPH~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~ PRLHKLFKLV DWWHVWHGLQ/DWPHXV23UXVPDLV6ODY PRMÚ
7KHVJSRVVHVVLYHVKRZVWZRIRUPV PDVF\WDQGIHPMRWH
VHFRQGDU\ DQDORJLHV DFFRXQW IRU PDVF MRW DQG IHP \WH 7KHVH FRQ WLQXH(3$ HLLWH HLVLVWHDQG MWH MVWHZKHUH WHLVWKHDWRQLF DFFXVDWLYHRIWKHVJSHUVRQDOSURQRXQ7KHLQLWLDOHOHPHQWRIWKHVHWZR IRUPV DUH ROG GHPRQVWUDWLYH SURQRXQ JHQLWLYHV 7KH UHPDLQLQJ PDVFXOLQH FDVH IRUPV FRLQFLGHG LQ W¬QG ~ WDQG ZKLFK UHIOHFWV WKH DFF
WDPWH WRPWH7KHIHPLQLQHDFFXVDWLYHW¬QGH~ WDQGHZLWKLWVVHF RQGDU\HUHIOHFWV WPWH LQERWKFDVHVWKHDXVODXWQDVDOLVSUHVHUYHG EHFDXVHRIWKHXQLYHUEDWLRQ 7KHIHPLQLQHJHQLWLYHGDWLYHDEODWLYHVDWH WVMWHZKLFKRULJLQDOO\ZDVWKHJHQLWLYDOIRUPDWLRQ VWH ,Q FDVH LI WKH SRVVHVVLYH VKRXOG EH LQ WKH SOXUDO WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ IRUPVDUHPDVFWXDQGIHPWXD7KH\IXQFWLRQVLPLODUO\WRPLPLDDQG JREDFNWR(3$ WXZDDYDULDQWRI,( *W H ÆRV, cf. Gk VGQX, Lat WXXV /LWKW¦YDV
7KH SO SRVVHVVLYH SURQRXQV DUH PDVF \Q¬ IHP MRQ¬ FRQ WLQXLQJ HLL QD HLLV QRV DQG M QD V QRV ZLWK QRV UHSUH VHQWLQJWKHDWRQLFIRUPRIWKHDFFXVDWLYHRIWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJSHUVRQDO SURQRXQ,QWKHPDVFXOLQHRWKHUFDVHVPHUJHGLQWRQ¬ (3$ WDQD
WRQVQRVZLWKRLQGXFHGE\WKHSDUDGLJPRIIHPLQLQH,QWKHIHPLQLQH DFF WRQ¬ LV D UHJXODU UHIOH[ RI (3$ W QD WP QRV 2WKHU FDVHV
morphology
245
JHQLWLYHGDWLYHDQGDEODWLYH KDYHVRQ¬FRQWLQXLQJ(3$ WVMQD L QRV :KHQWKHSRVVHVVHGLVSOXUDOWKHIRUPVDUHPDVFWHQ¬~ WDQ¬DQGIHP WRQD$VWRWRQDZLWKLWVDERUURZHGIURPWKHDGMHFWLYDOSDUDGLJPLWV RULJLQDO IRUP PXVW KDYH EHHQ WRQ¬ (3$ W QD WV QRV 7KH PDVFXOLQH IRUP FRQWLQXHV WD QD WRV QRV &RUUHVSRQGLQJ PDVFXOLQH DQGIHPLQLQHDFFXVDWLYHVDUHWDQ¬ (3$ WDQD WRQVQRVDQGWRQ¬ (3$ WQD WVQRV7KHVHIRUPVZHUHWKHQH[WHQGHGWRRWKHUFDVHV
7KHSOSURPRXPDWWHVWVWKHIROORZLQJIRUPV PDVFMXDM~
MXHMMXMLIHPMXDM~ MXHMMXMD*HJMXMLDQGMXMDDUHREYLRXVO\VHFRQGDU\ DQG DUH QRWKLQJ EXW “GHILQLWH” IRUPV RI MXHM WUHDWHG DV DGMHFWLYHV 7KH RULJLQDOIRUPVMXDM~ MXHMJREDFNWR(3$ LZD HLLÆRVDQG MZD
VÆRV7KHILQDOMWKDWUHPDLQVXQH[SODLQHG
:KHQWKHSRVVHVVHGLVSOXUDOZHKDYHPDVFWXDM~ WXHMDQGIHPWXDMD~ WXHMD 7KH IHPLQLQH IRUP KDV EHHQ PRGLILHG DV DQ DGMHFWLYH ,Q PDVFXOLQHWKHQRPLQDWLYHJRHVEDFNWR WDZDDQG WZDIURP WRVÆRV DQG WVÆRV
'HPRQVWUDWLYHDQGUHODWLYHSURQRXQV'HILQLWHIRUPV $VLQGLFDWHGEHIRUHGHPRQVWUDWLYHVZLWKSURFOLWLFDDUHXVHG LQ $OEDQLDQ DV SHUVRQDO SURQRXQV RI WKH G SHUVRQ 7KHVH VDPH IRUPV FDQEHXVHGDVGHPRQVWUDWLYHVRIGLVWDQWGHL[LV)RUSUR[LPDOGHL[LVWKH VDPHVWHPVDUHXVHGEXWSUHFHGHGE\WKHHQFOLWLFN¬ PDVFN\ M IHP NMRN¬MR7KHPRUSKHPHN¬FRQWLQXHV(3$ ND ,( áRFI6NWN¢ ‘ZKR"’*RWKxDVLG ,QWHUURJDWLYHNXVK‘ZKR"’LVDFRPSRXQGRI(3$ NXVDFRQVLVWLQJRI,(
áX D PRUSKRQRORJLFDO YDULDQW RI áR DQG WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ GHPRQVWUDWLYH VR 7KH $OEDQLDQ IRUP LV WKXV YHU\ FORVH WR WKDW RI 7RFK $ NXV LG % NXVH LG áXVR $FFXVDWLYH YDULDQWV VKRZ TXLWH FOHDUO\ WKDW 3URWR$OEDQLDQ SRVVHVVHG WZR SDUDOOHO IRUPV DQ LQWHUUR JDWLYH SURQRXQ SURSHU DQG D V\QWDFWLF FRPSRXQG LQFOXGLQJ D GHPRQ VWUDWLYH2QWKHRQHKDQGZHILQGDFFN¬~ NDˆUHIOHFWLQJLQGHSHQGHQW (3$ NDP ,( áRP2QWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHVDPHPRUSKRORJLFDOUROH LVH[SUHVVHGE\WKHDFFN¬QG~ NDQG (3$ NDQWDQ ,( áRPWRP 7KHVDPHN¬QG~ NDQGIXQFWLRQVDVDQLQGHILQLWHSURQRXQ‘VRPHERG\’
246
chapter three
$OO REOLTXH FDVHV KDYH PHUJHG LQWR RQH IRUP KDYLQJ WKH IROORZLQJ YDULDQWV NXMNXMWNXMQDM2IWKHVHIRUPVNXMWDQGNXMQDMDUHVHFRQGDU\ LQQRYDWLRQV LQIOXHQFHG E\ WKH “GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ $V WR NXM LWV DXVODXWMDSSHDUVWRJREDFNWRLVRWKDWNXMFDQEHH[SODLQHGIURP NXL NXGL FRQWLQXLQJ ,( áXGKL RU IURP NXL NXHL ,( áXHL VLPLODUWR23UXVTXHL‘ZKHUH’ 7KH SURQRXQ ç ¬ ‘ZKDW"’ LV QRW GHFOLQHG ,W FRQWLQXHV (3$ WhL ,(
áLGFI+LWWNXLW*NVK/DWTXLG7KHUHODWLYHLQWHUURJDWLYHVHZKLFK LV XVHG DV D FRQMXQFWLRQ DQG DV DQ LQWHUURJDWLYH SURQRXQ DIWHU FHUWDLQ SUHSRVLWLRQVUHIOHFWV(3$ Wh M A DEO áAG7KHVDPHVWHPLVIRXQG LQ VD ‘KRZ PDQ\’ (3$ Wh H MD DFF áHRP DQG VL ‘KRZ’ (3$
WhHL LQVWU áHL %HVLGHV NXVK WKH VDPH VWHP NX áX LV UHIOHFWHG LQ WZR PRUH SURQRPLQDOIRUPV NX‘ZKHUH"’ áXZKLFKLVFORVHWR6NWNgLG$Y N LG0:FZLGDQGNXU‘ZKHQ"’ZKLFKFDQEHFRPSDUHGZLWK/LWK NX¼ ‘ZKHUH"’ DQG $UP RZU LG 7KLV IRUP LV LQ IDFW D FRPSRXQG RI
áXDQGDORFDWLYDOSDUWLFOH U Ö
7KH“GHILQLWH”GHFOHQVLRQDOUHDG\H[LVWHGLQLWVIXOO\GHYHORS
HG IRUP LQ 2OG $OEDQLDQ ,W HYROYHG RXW RI 3URWR$OEDQLDQ V\QWDFWLF FRQVWUXFWLRQV FRQVLVWLQJ RI QRXQV IROORZHG E\ SRVWSRVLWLRQHG GHPRQ VWUDWLYHSURQRXQV6LPLODUVWUXFWXUHVH[LVWLQVHYHUDOQHLJKERXULQJODQ JXDJHV 5XPDQLDQ 0RGHUQ *UHHN DQG %XOJDULDQ ,W LV FOHDU WKDW “GHILQLWH”GHFOHQVLRQLVDQDUHDOIHDWXUHEXWLWKDVQRWEHHQHVWDEOLVKHG ZKDW ODQJXDJH ZDV WKH FHQWUH RI LWV LUUDGLDWLRQ ,W FDQQRW EH H[FOXGHG WKDW 5XPDQLDQ *UHHN DQG %XOJDULDQ GHYHORSHG “GHILQLWH” GHFOHQVLRQ XQGHUWKH$OEDQLDQLQIOXHQFH,ILQGHHGWKHSKHQRPHQRQRISRVWSRVLWLRQ DO GHPRQVWUDWLYHV ZDV RULJLQDOO\ FKDUDFWHULVWLF RI $OEDQLDQ LW LV UHPDUNDEOHWKDWVLPLODU EXWQRWLGHQWLFDO SURFHVVHVRIXQLYHUEDWLRQRI DGMHFWLYHVDQGGHPRQVWUDWLYHVDUHDWWHVWHGLQ%DOWLFDQG6ODYLF
,QWKHRVWHPVWKH“GHILQLWH”GHFOHQVLRQFDQEHH[SODLQHGLQWKHIROORZ LQJ ZD\ 1RP VJ PDOL ‘WKH PRXQWDLQ’ FRQWLQXHV (3$ PDOD L
PRORP LV $FF VJ PDOLQ LV DQ DQDORJLFDO WUDQVIRUPDWLRQ RI PDO¬Q H[SODLQHG IURP (3$ PDODP WD P PRORP WRP ,Q RWKHU FDVHV ZH KDYH PDOLW (3$ PDOHL WHL PROHL WHL 6WHPV HQGLQJ LQ YRZHOV RU YHODUV KDYH L UHSODFHG E\ X D VHFRQGDU\ PRUSKRQRORJLFDOO\ FRQ GLWLRQHG YDULDQW ,Q SOXUDO WKH YRZHO RI WKH HQGLQJ RI WKH QRPLQDWLYH
morphology
247
ZDV JHQHUDOL]HG DQG LV QRZ UHSHDWHG WKURXJK WKH ZKROH SDUDGLJP +HQFH QRP SO PDOHW DQG GHVKW¬ ‘UDPV’ JR EDFN WR (3$ PDOA WDL
PDOAV WRL DQG (3$ GDXVDL WDL GKRXVRL WRL 7KH $OEDQLDQ DFFXVD WLYHVFRQWLQXH(3$ PDODWDDQG GDXVDWD PRORQVWRQVDQG GKRX VRQVWRQV2EOLTXHFDVHVKDYHDQREYLRXVO\LQQRYDWHGPDOHYHW ,Q WKH VWHPV WKH QRP VJ KDOD UHSUHVHQWV D FRQWUDFWHG IURP (3$
VNDOM VNRO$VWRWKHDFFVJKDO¬QLWUHIOHFWV(3$ VNDOP W P VNROPWP7KHIRUPRIREOLTXHFDVHVLVKDO¬V (3$ VNDOL WVML VNROLL,QWKHSOXUDOQRPLQDWLYHDQGDFFXVDWLYHKDODWNHHSV WKHROGIRUP(3$ VNDOW VNROVWV2EOLTXHFDVHVDUHSUHVHQWHG E\DQLQQRYDWLRQ—KDODYH W 7KH ,QGR(XURSHDQ GHPRQVWUDWLYHV ZHUH DOVR XVHG LQ WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI $OEDQLDQ LVRODWHG DQG OLQNLQJ DUWLFOHV ZKLFK IXQFWLRQ FRUUHVSRQG LQJO\DVGHWHUPLQHUVDQGV\QWDFWLFHOHPHQWVFRRUGLQDWLQJWKHQRXQZLWK LWVDWWULEXWH7KHOLQNLQJDUWLFOHPXVWKDYHEHHQIRUPHGQRWORQJEHIRUH WKHILUVWZULWWHQWH[WVLQ$OEDQLDQDVLQ2OG$OEDQLDQLWHLWKHUPLVVLQJ RUVWLOOIXQFWLRQVDVDQRSWLRQDOHOHPHQW
1XPHUDOV $OEDQLDQQXPHUDOVKDYHFKDQJHGFRQVLGHUDEO\IURPWKHLU,QGR (XURSHDQSUHGHFHVVRUV,PSRUWDQWLQQRYDWLRQVDQGVWUXFWXUDOSULQFLSOHV KDYHEHHQERUURZHGIURPRWKHUODQJXDJHV /LWHUDWXUH %233 LGHQWLILHV SDU¬ ‘ILUVW’ ZLWK SDU¬ ‘EHIRUH’ 0(<(5$OE6W ,, :E NDW¬U IURP/DW TXDWWXRU QM¬FRPSDUHGZLWK6NWDQ\¢‘RWKHU’*N ε{´PKQK‘VRPH’ SDU¬FRPSDUHGZLWKWKH,QGR(XURSHDQZRUGIRU‘ILUVW’ SHV¬
SHQáW 0(<(5/¡%.( ,GJ $Q] ,, RQ VDQGKL LQ GKMHW¬ 3('(56(1 .= ;;;9, G\ ,( GÆAH -2./ ,) ;;;9,, SDU¬WR6NWSgUYDLG 6.2.$$UE6W,, G\ GXL %$5,Ç$56W - QM¬ VHP Ç$%(-=I3KRQHWLN,; ]HWIURP HXJ WUHODWHGWR XJRP‘\RNH’ 6W,,, QRQ,QGR(XURSHDQVRXUFHRI WKH YLJLWHVLPDO V\VWHP -8&482,6 /H 0XV©RQ /;;9,,, QXPHUDOV ‘’‘ ’ FRPSDUHG ZLWK 6DQVNULW FROOHFWLYHV LQ WL 6=(0(5É1<, 1XPHUDOV +8/' QM¬DVDEDFNIRUPDWLRQ IURPIHP VPH+ +$03$QF,( IROORZV0(<(5DQGFRQQHFWV QM¬ZLWK0HVVDSHQQDQ 1XPHUDOV
248
chapter three
7KHILUVWWHQFDUGLQDOQXPEHUVFDQEHGLYLGHGLQWRWKUHHJURXSV DFFRUGLQJ WR WKHLU RULJLQ DQG VWUXFWXUH 7KH ILUVW JURXS LQFOXGHV WKH QXPHUDOQM¬‘RQH’,WUHSUHVHQWVWKHDGMHFWLYH(3$ DLQMDGHULYHGIURP WKH ,QGR(XURSHDQ ZRUG IRU ‘RQH’: ,( RLQR LG FI /DW QXV *RWK DLQV23UXVDLQV 7KHVHFRQGJURXSLQFOXGHVWKHQXPEHUVIURP‘WZR’WR‘ILYH’7KH\DUH GLUHFWFRQWLQXDQWVRIWKHFRUUHVSRQGLQJ,QGR(XURSHDQQXPHUDOV G\ ‘WZR’ (3$ GXZA WR ,( GÆA X LG 6NW GY¢X $Y GYD *N FWY/DWGXR WUH‘WKUHH’ (3$ WUHMH ,( WUHHVLG 6NWWUD\Då*NVTGK`X/DW WUV NDW¬U‘IRXU’ (3$ NDWXU ,( áHWXU~ áHWÆHULG 6NWFDWYdUD *NVGUUCTGX/DWTXDWWXRU SHV¬~SHl V¬‘ILYH’ (3$ SHQWhH ,( SHQáH‘ILYH’ 6NWS¢±FD*N RGPVG/DWTXQTXH ,QWKHWKLUGJURXSQXPEHUVIURP‘VL[’WR‘WHQ’DUHGHULYHGIURP,QGR (XURSHDQ QXPHUDOV ZLWK D VXIIL[ W¬G¬ WL LQ 7RVN Q¬QW¬ W¬ LV UHVWRUHG E\ DQDORJ\ ZLWK RWKHU IRUPV 7KLV VXIIL[ LV VRPHWLPHV FRP SDUHGZLWK6NWWLIRXQGLQYDULRXVGHFDGIRUPDWLRQV JMDVKW¬‘VL[’ (3$ VHNVWLGHULYHGIURP,( V Æ HV‘VL[’ 6NW ¿¢¿*NGE/DWVH[ VKWDW¬ ‘VHYHQ’ (3$ VHSWDWL GHULYHG IURP ,( VHSW LG 6NW VDSW¢*NG R VC/DWVHSWHP WHW¬ ‘HLJKW’ (3$ DNWA WL WR,( RWA‘HLJKW’ 6NWD¿bd$UPRZ *NQMVY Q¬QW¬~QDQG‘QLQH’ (3$ QHXQWLWR,( QHÆLG 6NWQ¢YD/DW QRYHP*RWKQLXQ GKMHW¬ ‘WHQ’ (3$ GHWV W L ,( GH ‘WHQ’ 6NW G¢yD *N FGMC /DWGHFHP
7KH QXPEHUV IURP ‘HOHYHQ’ WR ‘QLQHWHHQ’ KDYH WKH IROORZLQJ
VWUXFWXUH QM¬PE¬GKMHW¬ ‘RQHRQWHQ’ G\PE¬GKMHW¬ ‘WZRRQWHQ’ DQG VR RQ 7KLV SDWWHUQ LV DQ LQQRYDWLRQ WKDW FDQ EH SODXVLEO\ H[SODLQHG DV D FDOTXH RI WKH FRUUHVSRQGLQJ 6ODYLF H[SUHVVLRQV FI HGLQÙ QD GHV?WH
morphology
249
‘HOHYHQ’ ‘RQHRQWHQ’ GÙYDQDGHV?WH‘WZHOYH’ ‘WZRRQWHQ’DQGVR RQ 'HFDGVDUHSDUWO\FRPSRVHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHSDWWHUQRIWULGKMHW¬‘WKLUW\’ ‘WKUHHWHQV’SDUWO\ DFFRUGLQJWRWKHSDWWHUQRI QM¬ ]HW‘WZHQW\’ ‘RQH WLPH WZHQW\’ WKH VDPH VWUXFWXUH LV VKDUHG E\ G\]HW ‘IRUW\’ ZLWK ]HW FRQWLQXLQJ(3$ ZG]DWDQGUHSUHVHQWLQJDQROG,QGR(XURSHDQZRUG IRU‘WZHQW\’,( ÆW 6NWYLayDW*NGKMQUK/DWYJLQW :RUGV IRU ‘KXQGUHG’ DQG ‘WKRXVDQG’ ZHUH ERUURZHG IURP /DWLQ TLQG ‘KXQGUHG’Õ/DWFHQWXPLGPLM¬‘WKRXVDQG’Õ/DWPOLDLG
7KHRUGLQDOQXPEHUV—ZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHQXPHUDOSDU¬ ‘ILUVW’—DUH IRUPHG E\ WKH DGMHFWLYDO VXIIL[ W¬ (3$ WD WR FI G\W¬ ‘VHFRQG’ VKWDW¬ ‘VHYHQWK’ DQG VR RQ 7KH VDPH SDWWHUQ LV ZHOO DWWHVWHGLQ*HUPDQLFDQG%DOWR6ODYLF 2UGLQDO QXPEHU SDU¬ ‘ILUVW’ LV KLVWRULFDOO\ LGHQWLFDO ZLWK DGYHUESUH SRVLWLRQSDU¬SDUD‘EHIRUH’,WFRQWLQXHV(3$ SDUD ,( SHU‘EHIRUH IRUZDUG’ 2+*IXUL/DWSUDH
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Ç$%(- 6W ,9 $OEDQR6ODYLF DQG $OEDQR&HOWLF LVRJORVVHV 25(/ .ROO ,GJ *HV $('SDVVLP
,VRJORVVHVZLWK1RUWK(DVWHUQ,QGR(XURSHDQODQJXDJHV
7KLV JURXS RI LVRJORVVHV LV RI H[WUHPH LPSRUWDQFH IRU WKH SRVLWLRQ RI $OEDQLDQ 7KH\ DUH QXPHURXV PXFK PRUH QXPHURXV WKDQ DQ\ RWKHU JURXSZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRI*UHHNVHHEHORZ DQGWKH\VHHPWRUHIOHFW WZR EDVLF IHDWXUHV RI WKH $OEDQLDQ OH[LFRQ LWV RXWVWDQGLQJ GHJUHH RI SUR[LPLW\ WR %DOWLF DQG D ORQJ SHULRG RI FRPPRQ H[LVWHQFH WRJHWKHU ZLWK%DOWR6ODYLFVRPHZKHUHLQ &HQWUDORU6RXWKHDVWHUQ" (XURSH
Common Germanic-Balto-Slavic (including Germanic-Baltic and Germanic-Slavic) isoglosses with Albanian are fairly numerous. Quite a few of them are connected with wood or objects made of wood. EHUU‘VKHHSJRDW’~21ERUJU‘KRJ’2+*EDUXJEDUXKLG~ 6ODY
ERUYÙ‘ERDU’ EOHKXU¬‘SDOH’~2(EOWLG~ 6ODY EOpGÙLG EUXVKWXOO ‘KHDWKHU’ ~ 26 EUXVWLDQ ‘WR VKRRW WR VSURXW’ ~ 6ODY
EUÙVWÚ‘VSURXWEXG’
vocabulary
251
GDVK ‘UDP’ ~ *PF GWHX]DQ ‘ZLOG DQLPDO’ ~ /LWK SO GD-VRV ‘SDUD GLVH’~6ODY GX[Ù‘EUHDWKVSLULW’ GHUJM‘WROLHGRZQWROD\VLFNWREHLOO’~ *PF WDUJMDQ‘WRWHDU’~ /LWKG®UJLQWL‘WRPRYH’G®UJWL‘WRORVHHQHUJ\WREHFRPHZHDN’ ~6ODY GÚUJDWL‘WRSOXFNWRSXOO’ GUD ~ GUDˆ ‘RLOFDNH PHOWHG EXWWHU’ ~ 21 SO GUHJJLDU ‘\HDVW’ ~ 23UXV GUDJLRV ‘\HDVW’ 2/LWK GUDJ^V LG /HWW GLDO GUDG]L ‘VHGLPHQWLQPHOWHGEXWWHU’~6ODY GURÊGÊL‘\HDVW’ GUDQJ‘EDUJHSROHSXQWLQJSROH \RXQJFUHDWXUHFXE’~ 21GUDQJU ‘VWRQH SLOODU’ ~ /LWK GU¢QJD ‘SHUFK SROH’ ~ 6ODY GU_JÙ ~
GU_JD HW ‘WKLUVW’ ~ 2+* LOJL ‘KXQJHU’ ~ /LWK ¢ONWL ‘WR EH KXQJU\’ ~ 6ODY
RONDWLLG IOHW¬‘ZLQJOHDI’~ 2+*OHFNHQ‘WRMXPSWRNLFN’~/LWKOHNL¸O|NWL /DWYOªNW J¬UGKLM‘WRVFUDWFK’~2(JULQGDQ‘WRJULQG’~/LWKJU©QGÊLXJU©VWL ‘WRVFUDSHWRVFUDWFK’ JMHWK ‘IROLDJH JUHHQ OHDYHV’ ~ 2+* TXHVWD ‘WXIW’ 21 NYLVWU ‘EUDQFK’~ 6ODY JYR]GÚ‘ZRRGIRUHVW’ JMXK¬ ‘WRQJXH ODQJXDJH’ ~ 21 NDOO ‘VKRXW’ ~ /LWK JDËVDV ‘HFKR’ ~ 6ODY JROVÙ‘YRLFH’ KLU‘JUDFHIDYRUPHUF\’~ *RWKVNHLUV‘FOHDU’~ 6ODY h¨LUÙ‘FOHDQ’ KXPE ‘WR OHDYH WR ORVH WR VSRLO WR PLVV WR GURZQ’ ~ *RWK DI VNLXEDQ ‘WR SXVK DZD\ WR UHMHFW’ ~ /LWK VNXPE¸ VN¸EWL ‘WR KXUU\WRKDVWHQ’ N¬VHQ‘WRDFKH RIWKHVWRPDFK WRKDYHJULSLQJSDLQV’~ 21K¢‘WR WRUPHQW’~/LWKNHQNL¸NH±NWL‘WRGDPDJHWRKDUP’ NULS¬ ~ NU\S¬ ‘VDOW’ ~ /LWK NUDXS¸V ‘URXJK’ NUDXSLV ‘VFDE’ /DWY NUD-SLV‘IUDLOEULWWOH’~ 6ODY NUXSD‘JURDWV NURGK¬‘EHHKLYH’~*RWKKURW‘URRI’~ 6ODY NUDGD‘KHDSSLOH’ O¬QG¬ ~ ODQG¬ ‘ZRRG WLPEHU PDWHULDO’ ~ *PF OHQGWA ‘OLQGHQ’ ~ /LWKOHQW£‘ERDUG’~6ODY O_WÙ‘EDVW’ O¬P¬~ODP¬‘WKUHVKLQJIORRUZLQHSUHVV’~ 2+*ODP‘ODPH’~ 6ODY
ORPÙ‘EUHDNLQJ FURZEDU EURNHQEUDQFKHV’ OXV‘WRSUD\WRLQYRNHWREHJ’~ 2+*ORFNAQ‘WROXUHWRHQWLFH’~ /LWKO J²WL‘WRDVNWRSUD\’/DWYO¸G]XO¸JW‘WRDVNWRLQYLWH’ PLHOO‘IORXU’~2+*P¬ORLG21PM_OLG~ 6ODY PHOYR‘JUDLQIRU JULQGLQJ’ VKSLK ~ VKSLI ‘WR VODQGHU WR FDOXPQLDWH’ ~ 2+* IHKDQ ‘WR KDWH’ ~ /LWKSHLNL¸SH&NWL‘WREODPH’
252
chapter four
VKT\PE‘WRH[WLQJXLVKWRGHVWUR\’~ *RWKDIVNLXEDQ‘WRSXVKEDFN WR UHMHFW’ ~ /LWK VNXPE¸ VN¸EWL ‘WR KXUU\ XS’ ~ 6ODY VNXE_
VNXEDWL‘WRSXOOWRWHDU’ VKWDOE¬U ‘ZRRGHQ VQDUH’ ~ 21 VWROSL ‘EHDP JLUGHU’ /LWK VWXËEDV ‘SRVWSROH’6ODY VWÙOEÙLG VKWDQJ‘KDUG’~21VWLQJD‘WRSXWWRVWLFN’~/LWKVW©QJLXVW©QJWL‘WR EHDEOH’VWL±JWL‘WREHFRPHKDUG’/DWYVWL±JWLG VKWUDS ‘VWDJQDQW JUHHQ RQ SRQGV’ ~ 0+* VWUDI ‘WLJKW’ ~ /LWK SDU VWUDS®QWL‘WRGUDJRQHVHOIEDFN’ ]L‘EODFN’~0+*TXW‘GLUW’2(FZ©DG‘EDG’~ /LWKJ{GD‘VKDPH’ ~ 6ODY JDGÙNÙ‘GLVJXVWLQJ’ JDGÙ‘UHSWLOHZRUP’
The most important and significant group of isoglosses represents the connection of Albanian to Baltic and Slavic. The following are isoglosses attested both in Baltic and Slavic. EDOW¬‘VZDPSPDUVKGLUWHDUWK’~ /LWKE¢OWDV‘ZKLWH’~ 6ODY EROWR ‘VZDPSPDUVK’ EUHGK ‘WR MXPS WR VSULQJ’ ~ /LWK EUHQG¸ EU®VWL ‘WR ZDGH WR IRUG’ 6ODY EUHG_ EUHVWLLG GDQJ¬‘EHOO\’~ /LWKGDQJ£‘WDEOHFORWKFRYHU’/DWYGD±JD‘SXGGOH PDUVKODQG’~ 6ODY G_JD‘DUF’ GLN¬‘GHVLUHOXVW’~/LWKGmNDV‘LGOHHPSW\’~ 6ODY GLNÙ‘ZLOG’ HQG‘WRZHDYH’~/LWKL±GDV‘YHVVHO’/DWYHQGDV‘SDUWRIVOHGJH’~ 6ODY _GD‘ILVKLQJURG’ IODVKN¬W‘VOXJJLVKODPH’~/LWKSO²Nh¨LDV‘IODW’~ 6ODY SORVNÙLG 6ODY SOR[Ù‘IODWEDGHYLOSRRU’ JDPXOH‘KHDS’~ /LWKJ¦PXODV‘EDOHOXPS’~ 6ODY JRPRODLG JUHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH’ ~ /LWK JXUNOmV ‘FURS’ 23UXV JXUFOH ‘WKURDW’ ~ 6ODY JÙUGORLGFIDOVR ÊHUGOR‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’ NHW¬U ‘VTXLUUHO GRUPRXVH’ ~ /LWK NXRNDV ‘GDQFH’ UHFRQVWUXFWHG IURP NXRN®Q^ ‘GDQFLQJ SDUW\’ ~ 6ODY VNDNDWL ‘WR MXPS WR VSULQJ’ NROO¬‘FRXJK’~/LWKNRVXOmVLG~ 6ODY NDhOÚLG NUHK~NUHI‘WRFRPE’~/LWKJU{EWL‘WRUDNH’~6ODY JUHE_ JUHEWL ‘WRURZWRUDNH’ ODW¬‘VPDOOD[H’~ /LWKO²SHWDLG23UXVORSWR~ 6ODY ORSDWDLG OHVK ~ OHVKQD ‘ZRRO IOHHFH KDLU’ ~ /LWK ODæhNDV ‘OHDI’ /DWY ODæhND ‘OHDIRQDOLQHQVWDON VWDON’~6ODY OLVWÙ‘OHDI’ O¬JDW¬‘PDUVK’~ /LWKOL
JDVLG~ 6ODY OXÊD‘SRRO’
vocabulary
253
O¬PVK~ODPVK‘EDOO RIZRROWKUHDG JOREH RIHDUWK SRROVSHOOHW’ ~ /DWY OHPHVLV ‘VKDUS HGJH RI WKH SORXJK’ 6ODY OHPHhÚ ‘SORXJKVKDUH’ OO¬QM¬]‘PXGVLOW’~ /LWKVOLQDV‘VDOLYDPXFXVVOLPH’~6ODY VOLQD ‘VDOLYD’ PDN¬ ‘JOXH VFXP VNLQ RQ WKH PLON RU RWKHU OLTXLGV ’ ~ /LWK PDN©QWL ‘WR ZDON WKURXJK D VZDPS’ ~ 6ODY PRNUÙ ‘ZHW’
PRNQ_WL‘WREHFRPHZHW’ QGXONHP‘WRULSHQ’~/LWKWHONL¸WHËNWL‘WRJDWKHUWREULQJWRJHWKHU’ ~ 6ODY WHONWL‘WREHDWWRSRXQG’ SLGK ‘IHPDOH SXGHQGD’ ~ 23UXV SHLVGD ‘ERWWRP’ ~ 6ODY SL]GD ‘IHPDOHSXGHQGD’ SMHUU‘WREHQGWRLQFOLQH’~/LWKSHUL¸SH¼WL‘WRVWULNH’~ 6ODY SÚU_
SHUWL‘WRSUHVV’ UDQJ¬‘KRPHZRUN’~/LWKUDQN£‘KDQG’SDUDQN£‘JDWKHULQJ’UHQN¸ UL±NWL‘WRJDWKHU’~ 6ODY U_ND‘KDQG’ VKTDUU‘PDUWHQ’~/DWYVNDUD‘FXUO\IXU’~ 6ODY VNRUD‘KLGH’ VKWURK¬~VKWURI¬‘NHQQHO’~ /DWYVWUDMD‘VWDOOFRYHUHGZLWKVWUDZ’ 6ODY VWURMÚ‘FRQVWUXFWLRQ’ ]YMHUGK ‘WR ZHDQ’ ~ /LWK YHUÊL¸ YH¼ÊWL ‘WR ODFH WR WLH’ /DWY YU]W ‘WRWXUQ’~ 6ODY YHU]WL‘WRELQG’
Separate Albanian-Germanic isoglosses are rather rare: EDUU¬‘IHWXV’~*PF EDUQDQ‘FKLOG’ ELU‘VRQ’~*RWKEDXU‘VRQ’ GHW ‘VHD’ ~ *PF GWHXSLÈA ‘GHSWK’ 0'X GLHSGH 0/* GSHGH ( GHSWK * IDˆM ‘WR ILOO WR FUDP WR VXUIHLW’ ~ *PF VSDQQMDQ ‘WR WLJKWHQ’ 21VSHQQD KDOO ‘WURXEOH PLVHU\ SOLJKW VRUURZ’ ~ *PF VNDOOD] ‘WKLQ GU\ VKDOORZ’ ( VKDOORZ DQG [DOOD] ‘ZHDN WLUHG’ 0+* KHO KHOOHF KHGK‘WRWKURZWRVKRRW’~ 21VNM²WD2+*VFLRfDQLG N¬QDT‘WRSOHDVHWRVDWLVI\’~*RWKJDQDK‘WREHHQRXJK’2+*JL QDKLG ODVKW¬ ODVK¬ ‘ROG HDUO\ SUHPDWXUH RI IUXLW ’ ~ *RWK ODXV ‘HPSW\ ORRVH’ THQJM¬‘EHHKLYH’~*PF [XQDJDQ‘KRQH\’ 21KXQDQJ2(KXQLJ 2+*KRQDJ
254
chapter four
T\H‘VXPPLWSHDN’~ *RWKJHQSOKODLQH‘KLOO’ UHQG‘WRUXQWRKXUU\’~*RWKULQQDQ‘WRUXQ’21ULQQDLG VKSHUU ‘WR ZLQ PRQH\ WR JDLQ’ ~ *PF VSDUAMDQ ‘WR OHDYH XQKDUPHGWRNHHS’ 21VSDUD2+*VSDUAQ2(VSDULDQ W\P‘VPRNH’~ *PF ÌXPD]‘EUHDWK’
Lexically, Albanian proves to be particularly close to Baltic. The following isoglosses demonstrate the specifically close AlbanianBaltic relations. DPXOO‘VWDJQDQW RIZDWHU ’~/LWKPXËY^‘VLOWPDUVK’P¸OWL‘WRJHW GLUW\’ EOL~EOî‘OLQGHQ’~ /LWKEOLQG®VEOHQG®V‘6DOL[FDSUHD’ EUH]‘EHOW’~/LWKEULDXQ£‘HGJH’ EX]¬ ‘OLS HQG HGJH EDQN VWLWFK URFN’ ~ /LWK EXG| ‘WUHHIXQJXV WLQGHUZKHWVWRQH’ GDN‘ELJUDP’~/LWKGY|NWL‘WREUHDWKH’GY¦NDV‘EUHDWK’ GUXDM ~ GUXHM ‘WR EH DIUDLG’ ~ /DWY GUXYDV ‘IHDU’ /LWK GUDXGÊL¸ GUDVWL‘WRIRUELGWRGHWHUWRVFDUHRII’ GUXGKH ‘FUXPE’ ~ /LWK GU¸]JDV ‘VSOLQWHU IUDJPHQW’ GU¸ÊWL ‘WR EHFRPHZHDN’ ILN‘WRH[WLQJXLVK RIILUH WREULQJPLVIRUWXQHWRUXLQ’~ /LWKSH&NWL ‘WR GHVSLVH WR VFROG’ SmNWL ‘WR EH DQJU\’ /DWY SHæNW ‘WR EH VSRLOW’ JDQG ‘DFFLGHQW YLFH GHIHFW’ ~ /LWK JD±GDV ‘UXPRU’ JD±GLQWL ‘WR IULJKWHQ’/DWYJD±GêW‘WRVSRLO’ JDUJXOO‘IXOO’~ /LWKJD¼JDODVJDUJ¶ODV‘WKLFNHQLQJNQRWWHGWKUHDG WKUHDG’ JUDY¬ ‘FDYH GHQ ODLU’ ~ /LWK JULRY£ /DWY JUDYD JP U¨DYD ‘UDYLQH SUHFLSLWRXVYDOOH\’23UXVJUDXZXV‘VLGH’ JMLMH‘VWDEOHKRXVH’~/LWKVHQD‘ZDOO’/DWYVLHl QDLG KDO¬‘ILVKERQHVSOLQWHU SLQH’~/LWKVNDO£‘VWLFNRIILUHZRRG’/DWY VNDOD‘VSOLQWHU XVHGWRIXUQLVKOLJKW ’ LN¬M‘WRJRDZD\WRUXQDZD\’~/LWKH&NH&NLLPSHU‘JR’ MHUP ‘GHOLULXP DEVHQWPLQGHGQHVV’ ~ /LWK H¼PDV ‘PRQVWHU’ /DWY ?UPV‘ZRQGHUIXODSSDULWLRQ’?UPL‘ZRQGHUVPLUDFOHV’ NDSWK‘SDWKPRXQWDLQSDWK’~/LWKN¦SDV‘JUDYH’NRS£‘GXQH’/DWY N¦SD‘GXQH’ N¬SXUGK¬‘IXQJXVPXVKURRP’~/LWKNªSXU^‘FDS’/DWYF?SXUHLG NRW‘XVHOHVVYDLQ’~/LWKNRNW¸V‘GLVJXVWLQJ’
vocabulary
255
NUXS‘WRORDWKH’~/LWKNUDXS¸V‘HDVLO\VFDUHG’NUXS¸VLGNUgSWL‘WR VFDUH’ NXOS¬U~NXOS¬Q‘LY\FOHPDWLV’~/LWKN®OSD‘ORRS’/DWYFLËSDLG NXQJXOO‘PDUURZSXPSNLQERWWOH’~/LWKNX±NXODV‘EXEEOH OH SDUWLFOH RI MXVVLYH ~ /LWK OD& SDUWLFOH RI RSWDWLYH DQG SHUPLVVLYH /DWYO£LOHî23UXVODL OHU¬‘GLUWPXG’~/LWKOD-U^‘GLUW\SHUVRQ’ OLO¬ ‘VPDOO LURQ ULQJ ORRSULQJ OLQN’ ~ /LWK OH&ODV ‘WKLQ VXSSOH IOH[LEOH’ ORTH‘SHQLV WHVWLFOHV’~ /LWKOLDXN£‘JODQG’ PDO‘PRXQWDLQ’~ /LWKPDO£‘ODQG’/DWYPDOD‘EDQNVKRUH’ PLV‘OLPEPHPEHU’~/LWKP®NODV‘VXSSOH’PLWU¸VLG PRGKXOO‘YHWFKFKLFNOLQJFKLFNSHD’~/LWKPDʸOLV‘VPDOO’ PXJXOO ‘VKRRW EXG VSURXW’ ~ /LWK PXJXODV RQ ZKLFK PXJXOL·RWL ‘WRPRYH’ PXUJ ‘GDUN JUH\’ ~ /LWK P¢UJDV ‘PXOWLFRORUHG’ PLUJ·RWL ‘WR VSDUNOHWRVKLQH’/DWYPLUJD‘JOHDP’P¸UJV‘IDQWDVWLFLPDJH’ QGHV‘WRKDYHWURXEOHV’~ /LWKG£N\WL‘WRPL[XSWRSXWLQGLVRUGHU’ G£NQ\WLLGG£NDQRWLLG QJU\GK~QJULGK‘WRZRUNXSWRIRPHQWWRIHUPHQW’UHIO‘WREHLQ KHDW RIKRUVHV ’~/LWKJUgÊLXJUgVWL‘WRVWDPSWRSXQFK’/DWY JUûVWLG QJXO‘WRWKUXVWLQWRVWLFNLQ’~ /LWKN¸OWL‘WRWKUHVK’/DWYNXËW‘WR VWULNH’ SHOT ‘WR VWLU XS ZDWHU ’ ~ /LWK SHON{WL ‘WR EHFRPH PDUVK\’ S©ONH• ‘PDUVKVZDPS’/DWYSHËFH‘SXGGOH’SHOFêW‘WRXULQDWH’ SOLVK‘NLQGRIUHHG3KUDJPLWHVFRPPXQLV’~/LWKSO L h®V‘UHHG’ TDV‘WRDSSURDFK’~ /LWKNH¨L¸N|VWL‘WRVWUHWFK’ TLN¬O‘SRLQWVSLNHSHDN’~ /LWKNNXODV‘OXPSFOXVWHU’/DWYF?NXOV ‘IRUHORFNFOXVWHU’ TXUUD‘VQRWVQLYHO’~ /LWKhOL¸UWL‘WREHFRPHGLUW\’ UUDJ‘DSURQ’~ /LWKVU·RJD‘VNHLQKDQN WXIWKDLUORFN’VUDXJDLG UUHN‘WRVWUDLQWRERWKHU’~ /LWKUHLN£‘QHHGQHFHVVLW\’UHæNWL‘WREH QHFHVVDU\’ UURM‘WROLYHWRVWD\’~ /LWKU²MXU²WL‘WRFRSHWREHUHDG\’ VXUP¬‘GDUNJUH\’~/LWKhL¼PDV‘JUH\’ WHVKD ‘EHORQJLQJV XWHQVLOV WKLQJV’ ~ /LWK WLHVL¸ WLVWL ‘WR PDNH ULJKWWREXLOGWRVHW’WHLV¸V‘ULJKW’ W¬U¬ ~ WDQ¬ ‘ZKROH DOO’ ~ /LWK WY®QWL ‘WR ULVH WR VZHOO RI ZDWHU ’ WY¦QDV‘IORRG’
256
chapter four
WUDVK¬‘WKLFNIDW’~/LWKWUuh¸V‘IDWIHUWLOH RIVRLO ’ WKLUU‘VRRW’~/LWKhL¼YDV‘JUD\’ YHU]¬‘JLOOEUDQFKLD’~/LWKYDUO|‘IURJ’ YDUG|/DWYYUGH ]RUU¬‘JXW’~ /LWKÊDUQ£LG
Separate Albanian-Slavic isoglosses are not as frequent as Baltic ones: EDF ‘HOGHU EURWKHU XQFOH’ ~ 6ODY EDW’D EDWMD ‘HOGHU EURWKHU IDWKHU’ EDKH‘VOLQJ’~6ODY ERMÚ‘ILJKW’ EUHGK‘ILUWUHH’~6ODY EUHGÙ‘ZLOORZ’ EUX]‘EOXHLQGLJR’~ 6ODY EUXGÙ‘GLUW’ EUXGÚQÙ‘GLUW\’ GU\GK¬W ‘HDV\ WR SODQH RI ZRRG ’ ~ 6ODY GU\]JDWL GUX]JDWL ‘WR VTXHH]HWRFUXVK’ IOH~IOê‘WRVOHHS’~ 6ODY OpM_ OpMDWL‘WRGR]HWRVOXPEHU’ KX~Kû‘SLFNHWVWDNHSROHSHQLV’~6ODY [XMÚ‘SHQLV’ NDOOL‘HDURIJUDLQ’~ 6ODY NROVÙ‘HDURIJUDLQ’ NHGK‘NLG’~ 6ODY NR]D‘VKHJRDW’ NRK¬‘WLPH’~6ODY ¨DVÙLG OR]‘WRPRYHWRVKDNHWRSOD\’~6ODY ODGÙ‘RUGHUSHDFH’ ODGLWL ‘WRPDNHRUGHUWRPDNHSHDFH’ OXJ ‘WURXJK ZDWHUWURXJK ORQJ JXWWHU SLSH’ OXJ¬ ‘VSRRQ’ ~ 6ODY
OÙJD‘VSRRQEODGH’ OÙÊLFDLG PDUGK¬‘FKLOOIURVWLFH’~ 6ODY PRU]Ù‘IURVW’ PDUUW¬‘PXUN\FORXG\GLPGXOO’~6ODY PRU[Ù‘GXVNIRJ’ PLU¬‘JRRG’~6ODY PLUÙ‘SHDFH’ QJH‘WLPHOHLVXUHFKDQFHRSSRUWXQLW\’~6ODY JRGÙ‘WLPH\HDU’ QJURK~QJURI‘WRZDUP’~ 6ODY JUpM_ JUpWLLG VKNDUGK¬ ‘GRJ FKDLQ D ORQJ VWLFN DWWDFKHG WR D GRJ’V QHFN WR SUHYHQWLWIURPELWLQJLWVPDVWHU’~ 6ODY MÚ]JRUGD‘IHQFH’ VKWUHS‘PDJJRWODUYD’~ 6ODY VWUXSÙ‘ZRXQGVFDESRLVRQ’ WMHW¬U‘RWKHU’~6ODY HWHUÙ‘VRPHVRPHERG\’ WUDS‘IHUU\’~ 6ODY WURSD‘SDWK’ WUHV‘WRPHOWWRORRVHQWRGLVVROYH’~ 6ODY WUDWM_ WUDWLWL‘WRVSHQG WRZDVWH’
,VRJORVVHV ZLWK :HVWHUQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ /DQJXDJHV
7KHVH DUH UDWKHU UDUH 6HSDUDWH *HUPDQLF$OEDQLDQ LVRJORVVHV DUH LQ
vocabulary
257
IDFWXQNQRZQ7KHUHLVRQO\RQH,WDOR&HOWLF$OEDQLDQLVRJORVV&HOWLF $OEDQLDQLVRJORVVVHVDUHQHDUO\DVUDUH
The only isogloss where both Italic and Celtic are engaged is the following: EOHUW¬ ‘JUHHQ’ ~ /DW IOAUXV ‘VKLQLQJ EULJKW’ 2,U EO¢U ‘JUD\’ : EODZULG
The following are the known Celtic-Albanian parallels: * E¬UVKê‘MXQLSHU’ HEXUXVD~2,ULEDULG*DXOLVKHEXUR GHP ‘\RXQJ EXOO’ ~ 2,U GDP ‘R[’ SUREDEO\ DOVR Gk FCOCNQX ‘FDOI’ UUD‘EHOO\ZRUP’~ 2,UIULJH‘YHUPLQIOHVKZRUP’ K¬Q¬ ~ KDQ¬ ‘PRRQ’ ~ &HOW NDQGR : FDQQ ‘ZKLWH’ 0%UHW FDQQ ‘IXOOPRRQ’ VKRW¬‘ELJGXFN’~ :KZ\DGLG2&RUQKRHWLG%UHWKRXDWLG YHUU ‘DOGHU’ %UHW JZHUQ LG : JZHUQHQ LG 0,U IHUQ LG FI DOVR $UPJHUDQ‘EHDPWLPEHU’
,VRJORVVHV ZLWK 6RXWKHDVWHUQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ ODQJXDJHV
7KHVH LVRJORVVHV LOOXVWUDWH WKH LQWHUPHGLDU\ SRVLWLRQ RI $OEDQLDQ EHWZHHQ%DOWR6ODYLFDQGWKHODQJXDJHVRIWKH6RXWKHDVWHUQDUHD0DQ\ RI WKHP OHDYH DQ LPSUHVVLRQ RI EHLQJ VHFRQGDU\ EHWWHU H[SODLQHG E\ ODWHU OLQJXLVWLF FRQWDFWV EHWZHHQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ DQG LQ SDUWLFXODU 3URWR*UHHNSUREDEO\VRPHZKHUHLQWKHQRUWKHUQSDUWRIWKH%DONDQV
Isoglosses connecting Albanian with the whole South-Eastern group are very few: QMHUL‘PDQSHUVRQKXPDQEHLQJ’~6NWQ¢U‘PDQ’~ GkCPJTLG~ $UPD\ULG EXWFI/DW1HUA VKTHUUDVKWMHUUDSO‘ODPEV’~6NWVWDUÀå‘EDUUHQFRZ’~$UPVWHUÎ ‘VWHULOHEDUUHQ’~GkUVGK`TCLG
Indo-Greek parallels to Albanian are also not very numerous: HQG‘SROOHQ’~6NW¢QGKDV‘KHUE’~ GkCPSQX‘IORZHU’
258
chapter four
IHQG‘WRIDUW’~6NWVSDQGDWH‘WRVKLYHU’~GkUHCFC\Y‘WRVKLYHU WRWUHPEOH’ JMHU‘WLOO’~$YD\DU‘GD\’~ GkJ?TK J?GTK ‘HDUO\’ FIDOVR*PF
DLUL]‘EHIRUHHUH’ JMHVK‘WR NQHDG’ JMHVK‘WR NQHDG’ ~6NW \¢V\DWL‘WR ERLO’ ~ Gk\GY ‘WRERLOWRFRRN’ NROP¬ ‘SUHWW\ ZLQVRPH’ ~ 6NW NDO\¢ ‘KHDOWK\’ ~ Gk +RP MC NQX ‘EHDXWLIXO’ QGDM~QGDˆM‘WRGLYLGHWRVHSDUDWH’~6NWG¢\DWHLGGdWL‘WRFXWWR GLYLGH’~ GkFCKQOCK‘WRGLYLGH’ YHUU¬ ‘KROH’ ~ 6NW XU· ‘ZLGH’ Y¢UDV ‘VSDFH ZLGWK’ ~ Gk GW TWX ‘ZLGH’ ]¬~]Dˆ ‘WRVHL]HWRJUDVSWRWRXFK’~6NWM\d‘IRUFHSRZHU’M¢\DWL ‘WRZLQWRFRQTXHU’~GkDKJ‘SRZHU’
Greco-Armenian isoglosses with Albanian are as follows: GKL‘VKHJRDW’~$UPD\FLG~ GkCKELG GKXQ¬‘ODERUSDLQVVKDPHGLVJUDFH’~$UPHUNQ‘ODERUSDLQV’~Gk QFWPJLG ¬QG¬UU ~ DQG¬UU ‘GUHDP VOHHS’ ~ $UP DQRZUÎ LG ~ Gk QPGKTQP QPGKTQXLG PH ‘LQVXIILFLHQFH ODFN LQVXIILFLHQW VFDQW\ QRW IXOO’ ~ $UP PDQU ‘VPDOO WKLQ’ ~ Gk OCPW OKMTQP #SCOC`PGX +HV OCPQX ‘WKLQ’ P\N¬‘EDFNHGJH RINQLIH ’~ $UPP[HP‘WRSXWLQWRWRLQVHUW’~ GkOWZQX‘LQQHUPRVWSDUW’
The amount of Greek-Albanian separate isoglosses is surprisingly high, especially if compared with similar Indo-Albanian and Armeno-Albanian lists. This particular proximity can be probably explained by intense secondary contacts of two proto-dialects. DJ‘WZLOLJKWGXVN’~GkCWIJ‘UD\RIOLJKW’ DUU¬ ‘ZDOQXWWUHH ZDOQXW’ ~ *N CTWC VC> * TCMNGYVKMC> MCTWC +HV EDMJ¬‘GXQJ’~GkDQNDKVQP‘FRZGXQJ’ EDWK¬‘EURDGEHDQ’~ GkHCMJ`‘GLVKRIOHQWLOV’HCMQX‘OHQWLO’ E¬M~EDˆM‘WRGRWRPDNH’~GkHCKPY‘WRDSSHDU’
vocabulary
259
ELP¬‘SODQW’~ GkHW`OC‘SODQW’ EOL~EOî‘VWXUJHRQ’~GkDNGPPQXLG çDQG¬U‘SURSVXSSRUW’~GkMGPVTQP‘JRDGVSXU’ GDO‘WRJRRXW’~GkSCNNY‘WREORRP’ ‘WRDSSHDUWRFRPHRXW’ GDUN¬‘VXSSHU’~GkFQTRQPLG GHUL‘WRXSWRWLOO’~GkFGW`TQFGW`TGFGWTK ‘KHUH’ GHUU‘SLJ’~ GkZQK`TQXLG G\OO¬‘ZD[’~GkZWNQX‘MXLFH’ GKDOO¬~GKDOOW¬‘EXWWHUPLON’~GkICNC‘PLON’ HOE‘EDUOH\’~GkCNHK‘NLQGRIJUDLQ’ HUGKDDRU‘FDPH’~ GkGTZQOCK‘WRFRPH’ ¬QG¬ ~ DQG¬ ‘DSSHWLWH GHVLUH ZLVK’ ~ Gk CPVCK CPGOQK CPVCX RPQCX+HV IDU¬‘VHHGVHPHQNLQ’~GkURQTC‘VHHG’ JUXD~JUXH‘ZRPDQZLIH’GkITCW`X‘ROGZRPDQ’ KHT ~ KHN ‘WR GUDZ WR SXOO’ ~ Gk QNMGY FDXVDWLYH RI GNMY ‘WR GUDZ’ KXGK¬U‘JDUOLF’~GkUMQTQFQPLG MHW¬ ‘OLIH’ ~ Gk GVGQX ‘true, real’, G VC C NJSJ` C ICSC (Hes.), GVC\Y ‘to test’. NHP‘LQFHQVH’~GkMCRPQX‘VPRNH’ NHT‘EDGHYLO’~GkMCMQX‘EDG’ DQG3KU\JNDNRVLG NU\H‘KHDG’~GkMTC PKQP‘VNXOOKHDG’ OHU¬‘KHDSRIVWRQHVSHEEOHEDQN’~GkNCWTC ‘DOOH\SDVVEHWZHHQ URFNV’ OXP¬‘ULYHU’~GkNW`OC‘GLUW’ PMDOF¬‘EHH’~GkOGNKUUCLG PRV‘QRW’~GkOJVG‘DQGQRW’ QGHVK‘WRPHHW’~GkFJY‘WRILQG’ QG\M~QG\HM‘WRPDNHGLUW\WRVRLOWRGLSWRLPPHUVH’~ GkFWY ‘WRVLQNWRFDXVHWRVLQNWRSOXQJHLQ’ S¬USMHW¬ ‘ULVLQJ XSKLOO ULVH VORSH XS’ ~ Gk RTQRGVJX ‘SURPL QHQW’RTQRGVQOCK‘WRIO\IRUZDUGV’ SULVK‘WRGHVWUR\WRVSRLOWRZDVWH’~GkRTKY‘WRVDZ’ SXT‘WRILWWRJHWKHU’~GkRWMC‘WKLFNO\VWURQJO\’RWMPQX ‘WKLFN VWURQJ’ UUHM~UUêM‘WRGHFHLYH’~GkCTPGQOCK‘WROLH’ UUXP‘FODSSHU PDL]HFREVWULSSHGRIFRUQV’~GkTCOPQX‘WKRUQ\ EXVK’ UUXVK‘JUDSH’~GkTCELG
260
chapter four
WKHN ‘WR URDVW WR WRDVW EUHDG ’ ~ Gk MGIMGK RGKPC`^ MCIMQOGPJX EJTC`X VY`^ HQDY^ (Hes.), RQNWMCIMJX ‘burning strongly’ (Hom.). WKHOO¬‘GHHS GDUN RIFRORU ’~GkMQK`NQX‘KROORZ’ XM¬‘ZDWHU’ XGUM~GkWFTKC‘ZDWHUEXFNHW’
The number of Armeno-Albanian separate parallels is insignificant. HUJM¬]‘\RXQJORXVH’~ $UPRUÎLO‘ORXVH’ JMLWK¬‘DOO’~ $UPH]LG ERWKIURP VHP½KR SDK‘VFDEGXVW’~ $UPKRJL‘EUHDWK’ ERWKIURP SRÆR WULP‘KHUR’‘EUDYHFRXUDJHRXV’~ $UPDUP‘\RXQJIUHVKJUHHQ’
Indo-Iranian parallels to Albanian are more numerous. Remarkably, some of them are connected with horse-keeping, horsebreeding and milk products: EDG¬U‘QDUFLVVXVGDIIRGLO’~6NWEK¢VWU‘EHOORZV’ ¬PE¬O~DPE¬O‘VZHHW’~6NWDPO¢‘VRXU’ JMHP‘EULGOH’~ 6NW\¢PDLG JM\VK‘JUDQGIDWKHU’~6NWV ¿d‘SURJHQLWRU’ KLUU¬‘ZKH\’~6NWN¿U¢‘PLON’2VVHWæ[hLULG N¬UU ‘GRQNH\ DVV IRDO JUD\’ ~ 6NW NK¢UD ‘GRQNH\’ $Y [DUA LG 6F\WK [DUD2VVHW[æUæJLG PXW‘H[FUHPHQW’~6NWPXNW¢‘UHOHDVHG’ WUX~WUû‘EUDLQ’~ 6NWW¢UXoD‘\RXQJWHQGHU’$YWDXUXQD‘\RXQJ’ FIDOVRGkVGTJP‘WHQGHU’VGTW CUSGPGXNGRVQP+HV WKDG¬U‘DNLQGRIGRXEOHVLGHGD[H’~ 6NWyDVWU¢‘NQLIHVZRUG’ ]RW‘ORUGPDVWHUJRG’~6NWYLySDWL‘ORUGRIWKHKRXVH’
,VRJORVV ZLWK 7RFKDULDQ 7KHUH LV RQO\ RQH OH[LFDO LVRJORVV
OLQNLQJ$OEDQLDQWR7RFKDULDQEXWLWLVYHU\LPSRUWDQW
NXVK‘ZKR’~ 7RFK$NXVLG%NXVHLG ERWKIURP áXVR
vocabulary
261
6HOHFWHGVHPDQWLFILHOGVLQ$OEDQLDQ 6RPHRIWKHOH[LFDOILHOGVFDQEHRILPSRUWDQFHIRUWKHDQDO\VLVRI WKH3URWR$OEDQLDQFXOWXUHLWVRULJLQDOKRPHODQGDQGHDUOLHVWFRQWDFWV %HORZVHYHUDOVXFKOH[LFDOJURXSVDUHGHVFULEHG /LWHUDWXUH 3,6$1,6DJJLSDVVLP 7$*/,$9,1,6WUDWLILFD]LRQHSDVVLP
.LQVKLS WHUPV 7KH HQWLUH V\VWHP RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ NLQVKLS WHUPVZDVFRPSOHWHO\UHVKDSHGLQ3URWR$OEDQLDQ DSSDUHQWO\UHIOHFWLQJ D UDGLFDO VRFLDO FKDQJH 7KH RQO\ UHPDLQLQJ WHUPV NHHSLQJ WKHLU RULJLQDOIXQFWLRQDUHWKRVHRIWKHSDUHQWVLQODZDQGVRQLQODZ YMHK¬UU ‘PRWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZH[XU ZLWK DVVLPLODWLRQ IURP H[SHFWHG VZHWVXU ,( VÆHU 6NWyYDyUgPRWKHULQODZ’ /DW VRFUXV LG 3UREDEO\ PRUSKRORJLFDOO\ LQIOXHQFHG E\ WKH PDVFXOLQHIRUP YMHK¬UU ‘IDWKHULQODZ’ (3$ VZH[XUD ZLWK DVVLPLODWLRQ ,( VÆHXURVLG 6NWyY¢yXUD‘IDWKHULQODZ’*NGMWTQXLG GK¬QG¬U ~ GKDQG¬U ‘EULGHJURRP VRQLQODZ’ (3$ G]DQUD ,( ½HQiU‘VRQLQODZ’ /DWJHQHU $ GDXJKWHULQODZ LV VLPSO\ GHVFULEHG DV ‘QHZ’ H UHMD FI IURP WKLV SRLQWRIYLHZ6ODY QHYpVWD LIUHODWHGWR QHÆ‘QHZ’ 2OGWHUPVIRUSDUHQWVZHUHUHSODFHGZLWKQHZ/DOOZµUWHURIZKLFKWKH ZRUGIRUIDWKHUFDQEHKRZHYHUWUHDWHGDVDQ,QGR(XURSHDQGLDOHFWDO WHUP Q¬Q¬~ QDQ¬ ‘PRWKHU’ D /DOOZRUWRI %DONDQLF RULJLQ FI 6&U QDQD LG5XPQDQ:LG ¬P¬~ DP¬‘PRWKHU’. DW¬‘IDWKHU’ (3$ DWD +LWWDWWDLG/DWDWWDLG6ODY RWÚFÚLG 7KHROGWHUPIRU‘PRWKHU’ZDVUHWDLQHGEXWFKDQJHGVHPDQWLFDOO\ PRW¬U‘VLVWHU’ (3$ PWHU ,( PWHU‘PRWKHU’ 6NWPW¢U*N OJVJT/DWPWHU
262
chapter four
7KLV FKDQJH ZDV REYLRXVO\ D SDUW RI D VWUXFWXUDO VKLIW LQ WKH NLQVKLS V\VWHPDIIHFWLQJIHPDOHUHODWLYHVLQVRIDUDVWKHRULJLQDO,QGR(XURSHDQ WHUPIRU‘VLVWHU’EHFDPHDJHQHUDOWHUPIRU‘JLUO’LQJHQHUDO YDM]¬ ‘JLUO’ EDVHG RQ YDU¬ (3$ VZHVDU 6NW VY¢VDU $UP R\U/DWVRURU 7KHZRUGIRU‘EURWKHU’ZKLFKUHSODFHG,( EKUWHUPLJKWLQIDFWEHD YHU\ROGDUFKDLVPXVLQJWZRDQFLHQWVRFLDOWHUPV VÆHDQG OHXGK Y¬OOD‘EURWKHU’ (3$ VZHODXGFRPSRVLWHRISURQRPLQDO,( VÆH DQG ODXG ,( OHXGK 2+*OLXW‘SHRSOH’6ODY OMXGÙLG $GGLWLRQDO ZRUGV IRU ‘HOGHU EURWKHU’’XQFOH’‘IDWKHU’ VHHPV WR EH LQQRYDWLYH/DOOZµUWHU DS¬‘HOGHUEURWKHU GDG’ (3$ DS EDF ‘HOGHU EURWKHU XQFOH’ (3$ EDWMD FORVH WR 6ODY EDW’D ~
EDWMD‘HOGHUEURWKHUIDWKHU’ 7HUPVIRU‘VRQ’DQG‘GDXJKWHU’UHSUHVHQWDQ,QGR(XURSHDQORFDOLVP ELU‘VRQ’ (3$ ELUD *RWKEDXU‘VRQ’ ,( EKHUR ELO¬ELM¬‘GDXJKWHU’ (3$ ELU L OGHULYHGIURPELU‘VRQ’ &IDOVRDFORVHO\UHODWHGDQFLHQWZRUGIRU‘FKLOG’DV‘VXFNOLQJ’ GMDO¬ ‘ER\ \RXWK’ (3$ GHOD ,( GKL ‘WR VXFN’ /DWY G?OV ‘VRQ’/DWIOLXVLG 6HFRQG GHJUHH EORRG NLQVKLS ZDV DSSDUHQWO\ LUUHOHYDQW LQ WKH 3URWR $OEDQLDQVRFLDOVWUXFWXUH$OOFRUUHVSRQGLQJWHUPVKDYHEHHQERUURZHG IURP/DWLQ XQJM‘XQFOH’Õ/DWDYXQFXOXV‘PDWHUQDOXQFOH’ HPW¬‘DXQW’Õ/DWDPLWD‘SDWHUQDODXQW’ QLS‘QHSKHZJUDQGVRQ’Õ/DWQRPQHSAV‘JUDQGVRQ’ PEHV¬‘QLHFHJUDQGGDXJKWHU’Õ/DWQHSAWLDLG
vocabulary
263
6RFLDO RUJDQL]DWLRQ ,Q 3URWR$OEDQLDQ VRPH EDVLF WHUPV ZHUHSUHVHUYHG WKRXJKZLWKUDGLFDOFKDQJHVLQIXQFWLRQ ZKLFKUHIOHFW D VRFLDO VWUXFWXUH LQ ZKLFK WKH QRWLRQ RI ‘KRXVH’ DV ‘NLQXQLILHU’ LV RI SDUWLFXODULPSRUWDQFH YLVH ‘SODFH’ (3$ ZWVM ,( ÆHL VLPLODU WR *N QKMKC ‘GZHOOLQJKRXVH’ ]RW‘ORUGPDVWHUJRG’ (3$ Z L WVSDWL 6NWYLySDWL‘ORUGRIWKH KRXVH’ ]RQM¬ ‘ODG\’ (3$ Z L WhSDWQM IHPLQLQH IRUPDWLRQ UHODWHG WR ]RW 1RWKLQJ FDQ EH VDLG DERXW WKH SROLWLFDO RUJDQL]DWLRQ RI WKH 3URWR $OEDQLDQV $OO $OEDQLDQ SROLWLFDO WHUPLQRORJ\ LV ERUURZHG PDLQO\ IURP /DWLQ +RZHYHU LPSRUWDQW HOHPHQWV RI $OEDQLDQ YHQGHWWD DQG UHODWHG FRPPRQ ODZ PD\ ZHOO UHIOHFW FHUWDLQ DUFKDLF ,QGR(XURSHDQ SDWWHUQV 7KH OH[LFRQ RI HFRQRPLF H[FKDQJH LQ 3URWR$OEDQLDQ LV HQWLUHO\ VHFRQGDU\%DVLFZRUGVVXFKDV‘WREX\’DQG‘WRVHOO’DUHORDQZRUGVRU QHZO\EXLOWPHWDSKRUV EOHM‘WREX\’Õ5RP DEOHYUH‘WROLIWXSWRUHOLHYH IURP ’ VKHV‘WRVHOO’ (3$ LhDJWMD ,( D½‘WRGULYH’ $OEDQLDQ UHOLJLRXV QRWLRQV DUH KDUGO\ RSHQ WR UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ
*HRJUDSKLF WHUPLQRORJ\ 5LYHUV DQG ZDWHU EDVLQV 7KLV VHPDQWLFJURXSLVRIREYLRXVUHOHYDQFHIRUDOOFRQVLGHUDWLRQVUHODWHGWR WKHRULJLQDO3URWR$OEDQLDQKRPHODQG7KHPRVWVWULNLQJIHDWXUHRIWKH JHRJUDSKLF YRFDEXODU\ LV WKH OLPLWHG QXPEHU RI ZRUGV RI ,QGR (XURSHDQRULJLQLQ$OEDQLDQUHODWHGWRVHD DQGVHDIDULQJ 7KLVVHFWRU RIWKHOH[LVDERXQGVLQ5RPDQFHDQG*UHHNORDQV7KHQDPHRIWKHVHD
264
chapter four
LWVHOIVHHPVWREH,QGR(XURSHDQEXWUDWKHULWDSSHDUVWREHDFRPPRQ $OEDQR*HUPDQLFLQQRYDWLRQIRUDQ\GHSWK GHW ‘VHD’ (3$ GHXEHWD ‘GHSWK’ ,( GKHXE ‘GHHS’ FI *PF
GWHXSLÈA‘GHSWK’!0'XGLHSGH0/*GSHGH(GHSWK 6R IDU ZHUH WKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQV IURP PDULWLPH LQWHUHVWV WKDW HYHQ DQ ROG *UHHN ORDQZRUG IRU ‘VHD’ KDV FRPSOHWHO\ FKDQJHG LWV PHDQLQJ LQ $OEDQLDQ SHOOJ‘SRQGSRROGHSWK’Õ*NRGNCIQX‘KLJKVHD’ 2WKHUK\GURQ\PVUHIOHFWDPRUHFRPSOLFDWHGSLFWXUH%HVLGHVWZREDVLF ZRUGVIRU‘ULYHU’DQG‘VWUHDP’ OXP¬‘ULYHU’ (3$ OXPD *NNW`OC‘GLUW’ ,( OHX i ‘GLUW’ UU\P¬ ‘IORZ RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ VU P *N TGW`OC ‘VWUHDP’ 21 VWUDXPULG/LWKVUDXPXR‘IDVWVWUHDP’ $OEDQLDQ VHHPV WR XVH UHODWLYHO\ UHFHQW ORDQZRUGV WR GHVFULEH PRXQWDLQRXV EURRNV UXVKLQJ WKURXJK UDYLQHV RU ODUJHU ULYHUV IDOOLQJ LQWRDVHD+HQFHWKHIROORZLQJERUURZLQJV ODN¬‘GHILO©YDOOH\’Õ*PF ODND]‘EURRNULYHUVZDPS’FI2+* ODKKD2(ODFX S¬UUXD~S¬UUXH‘EURRN ULYHUEHG’Õ6ODY SRURYÙ~ SDURYÙFI 3ROSDU²Z‘UDYLQH’QDPHRIDVRXUFHLQ*UHHFH2QTQ DQX ]DOO‘ULYHUVDQGULYHUEDQN’ (3$ DLJMDODÕ*NCKIKCNQX‘ULYHU EDQN’ UU¬NH‘VWUHDP RIUDLQ PRXQWDLQEURRN’Õ6ODY UpND‘ULYHU’ 2QWKHRWKHUKDQGZRUGVIRUTXLHWHUFXUUHQWVDQGVRPHWLPHVVWDJQDQW SRROVDUHRI,QGR(XURSHDQRULJLQ E¬UUDN¬‘PXGG\SRROSRQGVZDPS’½ELU¬‘KROH’ KXUGK¬‘SRQGSRRO’ (3$ ZXUG 6ODY YLUÙ‘ZKLUOSRRO’ YDULWL ‘WRFRRN’/LWKY©UGXY®UWLLG OHGK‘PXGDOOXYLXPFOD\ ZDOOHDUWKPRXQG ULYHUPRXWKEDON’ (3$ ODLGD 23UXVOD\GLV‘FOD\’ PDN¬UU‘VWDJQDQWJUHHQRQSRQGV’½PDN¬‘JOXHVFXPVNLQ’
vocabulary
265
DPXOO ‘VWDJQDQW RI ZDWHU ’ (3$ DPXOZD /LWK PXËY^ ‘VLOW PDUVK’P¸OWL‘WRJHWGLUW\’ VKWUDS‘VWDJQDQWJUHHQRQSRQGV’ (3$ VWUDSD 0+*VWUDI‘WLJKW’ /LWKSDUVWUDS®QWL‘WRGUDJRQHVHOIEDFN’ 0DUVKHVZHUHDXVXDOSDUWRIWKHODQGVFDSHWRR EDOW¬ ‘VZDPS PDUVK GLUW HDUWK’ (3$ EDOW ,( EK²OiWRP LG 6ODY EROWRFI/LWKE¢OWDV‘ZKLWH’ O¬JDW¬ ‘PDUVK’ (3$ OHXJDW ,OO\U GNQP .QW IGQX MCNQO GPQP /LWKOL
JDVLG6ODY OXÊD‘SRRO’ YXUJ ‘PDUVK VZDPS’ (3$ ZXUJD *N QTICY ‘WR EH VRDNHG’ Q TIC X‘PDUVKPHDGRZ’ 5LYHUVDVGHVFULEHGDERYHZHUHHDV\WRFURVVE\IRRWDWOHDVWDWIRUGV EUHGK‘WRMXPS WR VSULQJ’ (3$ EUHGD 6ODY EUHG_ EUHVWL‘WR ZDGHWRIRUG’/LWKEUHQG¸EU®VWLLG VKW\U~VKWLU‘WRSXVK WRFURVV DULYHU ’½VKW\M‘WRSXVK’ EXWFIWKHZRUGIRU‘IRUG’RI5RPDQFHRULJLQ YD‘IRUG’Õ/DWYDGXPLG 5LYHUV RI WKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQ KRPHODQG DERXQGHG LQ GDQJHURXV GHHS SODFHVDQGZKLUOSRROV XUHO¬ ‘ZDWHUSLW’ (3$ XUHO 21 U ‘GUL]]OH’ 23UXV ZXUV ‘SRRO’ QJMLUH‘ZKLUOSRRO’½JMHU¬‘EURDGZLGH’ JUHOO¬ ‘GHHS SODFH’ (3$ JULWO /LWK JXUNOmV ‘FURS’ 23UXV JXUFOH ‘WKURDW’ 6ODY JÙUGOR LG FI DOVR ÊHUGOR ‘ULYHUEHG RSHQLQJ’ 7KHEDQNVRIULYHUVZHUHFRYHUHGZLWKIRUHVWV JMD]¬ ‘ULYHUVLGH IRUHVW’ (3$ VHGMD ,( VHG ‘WR VLW WR EH VHWWOHG’FILQSDUWLFXODU6ODY VDGÙ‘JDUGHQJURYH’
*HRJUDSKLFWHUPLQRORJ\ )RUHVWVDQGEXVK,WLVFOHDUWKDW
WKH 3URWR$OEDQLDQV ZHUH QRW DFTXDLQWHG ZLWK IRUHVWV 7KH ZRUG IRU
266
chapter four
‘IRUHVW’ZDVERUURZHGIURPD5RPDQFHWHUPIRU‘VZDPS’SUHVXPDEO\ ZKHQWKH3URWR$OEDQLDQVUHDFKHGWKHORZODQGVRIWKH$GULDWLFVKRUH S\OO‘IRUHVW’Õ%DON5RP SDG OHP /DWSDO GHP‘VZDPS’ 2QWKHFRQWUDU\WKHRULJLQDOZRUGIRU‘EXVK’ZDVQRWERUURZHG VKNRUUHW VKNXUUH ‘EXVK’ (3$ VNU GHULYHG IURP VKTHUU ‘WR WHDU’ (3$ VNHUD 6RPH ROG ,QGR(XURSHDQ QDPHV RI WUHHV LQFOXGLQJ EDVLF FRQLIHUV VXUYLYHGLQ$OEDQLDQ DK‘EHHFKWUHH’ (3$ DNVD ,( RVN *NQEWC‘EHHFK’$UPKDÓL ‘DVKWUHH’21DVNULG0DFHGCEQX WNJ EOL~EOî‘OLQGHQ’ (3$ EOLQD /LWKEOLQG®VEOHQG®V‘6DOL[FDSUHD’ EUHGK‘ILUWUHH’ (3$ EUDGD 6ODY EUHGÙ‘ZLOORZ’ GXVKN GUXVKN ‘RDN’ (3$ GUXhND GHULYDWLYH RI GUX ‘WUHH’ ,(
GUHX ‘WUHH RDN’ &I DOVR OHQG ‘DFRUQ’ (3$ OHQWD ,( OHQW‘OLQVH’ /DWOQVOQWLV2+*OLQVL6ODY O?WMD SLVK¬‘SLQH’ (3$ SVD *NRKVWX/DWSQXV EXWFIDOVRYJMH~ YJMê ‘SLQH’ Õ /DW DELHJQXP ‘UHODWHG WR ILU’ GHULYDWLYH RI DELHWHP‘ILU’ YHUU ‘DOGHU’ (3$ ZHUQD %UHW JZHUQ LG : JZHUQHQ LG 0,U IHUQLG YLGK ‘HOP’ (3$ ZG]D .XUG YL] LG 2( ZF LG DQG ZLWK QDVDOL]DWLRQ/LWKY®QNhQDLG6ODY Y?]ÙLG 7KHDERYHOLVWLVRSSRVHGWRWKHIROORZLQJ/DWLQORDQVZKLFKLQFOXGHD QHZZRUGIRU‘ELUFK’ IUDVK¬U~IUDVK¬Q‘DVKWUHH’Õ/DWIUD[LQXVLG J¬VKWHQM¬‘FKHVWQXW’Õ/DWFDVWDQHDLG P¬VKWHN¬U ~ P¬VKWHN¬Q ‘ELUFK’ Õ /DW PDVWLFLQXV ‘UHODWHG WR WKH PDVWLFWUHH’ SDOQM¬‘PDSOH’Õ5RP SO¢WDQLDGHULYHGIURP/DWSODWDQXV‘SODQH WUHH’ SOHS‘SRSODU’Õ5RP SOASXVPHWDWKHVLVRI/DWSASXOXVLG UUREXOO ‘PRXQWDLQ SLQH’ Õ /DW UAEXU ‘RDN’ ZLWK D GLVVLPLODWLRQ RI VRQRUDQWV
vocabulary
267
VKHOJ‘ZLOORZ’Õ/DWVDOL[LG 7KH JHQHUDO LPSUHVVLRQ RI WKLV VHPDQWLF JURXS LV WKDW QHZO\ DFTXLUHG WUHHQDPHVPRVWO\UHIHUWRSODQWVKLVWRULFDOO\ORFDWHGLQPRUHVRXWKHUQ DQGVRXWKHDVWHUQJHRJUDSKLF]RQHV
*HRJUDSKLF WHUPLQRORJ\ 0RXQWDLQV ,Q WKLV JURXS EDVLF
QRWLRQVDUHRIGLVWLQFWO\3URWR$OEDQLDQRULJLQ
JXU‘VWRQHURFN’ (3$ JXUD ,( ÞHUi‘PRXQWDLQ’ 6NWJLU$Y JDLUL/LWKJLUL£‘ZRRG’/DWYG]LULDLG6ODY JRUD‘PRXQWDLQ ZRRG‘ PDO ‘PRXQWDLQ’ (3$ PDOD /LWK PDO£ ‘ODQG’ /DWY PDOD ‘EDQN VKRUH’ +RZHYHUDOOVSHFLILFWHUPVUHODWHGWRWKHPRXQWDLQRXVUHOLHIRUWROLIH LQWKHPRXQWDLQVDUHERUURZHG&IWKHIROORZLQJH[DPSOHV EMHVKN¬ ‘PRXQWDLQ SDVWXUH’ Õ 5RP SDVWLFD EDVHG RQ /DW SDVWXV ‘SDVWXUH’ N¬VK\UH‘PRXQWDLQSDWKSDWKLQWKHUDYLQH’Õ/DWFODXV UDFO V UD ‘ORFNEDUEROW FDVWOHIRUW’ NROLEH‘KXW LQWKHPRXQWDLQV ’Õ6ODY NRO\EDLG UDYJ¬‘SDWK LQPRXQWDLQV ’Õ6ODY URYÙNÙ‘GLWFK’ 6XPPLQJXSWKHGDWDRIZHPD\VD\WKDWWKH3URWR$OEDQLDQV OLYHG LQ D VZDPS\ DUHD RI VSDUVHO\ JURZLQJ WUHHV DQG UHODWLYHO\ VPDOO ULYHUVEXWGHILQLWHO\QRWLQWKHKLJKPRXQWDLQVRIWKH%DONDQVZLWKWKHLU UDYLQHVDQGYDOOH\V
'RPHVWLFDQLPDOV3URWR$OEDQLDQVZHUHFDWWOHEUHHGHUV7KH FRUUHVSRQGLQJWHUPVDUHZHOOSUHVHUYHG GHP ‘\RXQJ EXOO’ (3$ GDPD 2,U GDP ‘R[’ DQG *N FCOCNQL ‘FDOI’ GKL‘VKHJRDW’ (3$ DLG]LM *NCKELG HGK‘KHJRDW’ (3$ DLG]D *NCKE ‘JRDW’$UPD\FLG NHGK‘NLG’ (3$ NDG]D 6ODY NR]D‘VKHJRDW’ ORS¬‘FRZ’ (3$ OS /DWYOX¶SV‘FDWWOH’
268
chapter four
PMHO‘WRPLON’ (3$ PHOJD *NCOGNIYLG/DWPXOJHALG/LWK P©OÊLXP©OÊWLLG WHU‘EXOO’ (3$ WDXUD *NVCW`TQXLG/DWWDXUXVLG/LWKWD-UDV LG6ODY WXUÙLG YLç ‘FDOI’ (3$ ZHWXhD IXUWKHU UHODWHG WR ZHWD ! YLW ‘\HDU’ FI 6NWYDWV¢‘FDOI’ 7KH ERUURZHG QDWXUH RI WKH ZRUGV IRU ‘GRJ’ THQ IURP /DWLQ VKDN¬ IURP,UDQLDQ PD\LQGLFDWHWKDW3URWR$OEDQLDQVZHUHEHWWHUDFTXDLQWHG ZLWKODUJHFDWWOHEUHHGLQJWKDQZLWKWKHFXOWLYDWLQJRIJRDWVDQGVKHHS $W WKH VDPH WLPH $OEDQLDQ VHHPV WR SUHVHUYH D IHZ YHU\ LPSRUWDQW WHUPVFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHGRPHVWLFDWLRQRIWKHKRUVHHYHQWKRXJKVXFK EDVLFZRUGVDV‘KRUVH’ZHUHERUURZHG NDO¬Õ/DWFDEDOOXVLG JMHP‘EULGOH’ (3$ MDPD 6NW\¢PDLG SHO¬‘PDUH’ (3$ SAXO *NRY`NQX‘IRDO’*RWKIXODLG UUHWK ‘KRRS ULP RI ZKHHO FLUFOH’ GHPLQXWLYH LQ WK RI UDW ‘ZKHHO’ FI 6NW U¢WKD ‘ZDJRQ’ /DW URWD ‘ZKHHO’ 2,U URWK 2+*UDG
3+21(7,&7$%/(6∗ 9RZHOV )URP,QGR(XURSHDQWR3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ
D
R
i
H
L
X
A
DL
RL
HL
DX
RX
HX
∗
(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ
r w q
D
D
D
H UDUH Ø DIWHUDVWUHVVHGYRZHO
H
L
X
!
A
DL
DL
HL
DX
DX
HX
Not all combinatorial changes are included. For the development of clusters see the main text. Modern Albanian is represented by the Tosk dialect.
270
phonetic tables
)URP3URWR$OEDQLDQWRPRGHUQ$OEDQLDQ 7RVN (DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ
$OEDQLDQ 7RVN
D
r w q
H
r u u w u u q
L
8
X
A
DL
HL
DX
HX
r w q r w q r w q r w q
D H E\XPODXW ¬Ø XQVWUHVVHG ¬ EHIRUHQDVDOV MHLH H EHIRUH G] WV QG QW PE H DIWHUFçJMTOU MD EHIRUH LRIWKHQH[WV\OODEOH D MD DIWHUJM L EHIRUHPVLELODQWRUDIIULFDWH L GXHWRPRUSKRQRORJLFDOIDFWRUV ¬ LUUHJXODUO\EHIRUHQDVDOV L \ EHIRUHDODELDO X R XD EHIRUHUDQGQDVDOV \H EHIRUHQODQGDIURQWYRZHO H YH LQDQODXW XD EHIRUHUDQGQDVDOV L \ L LQDXVODXW L EHIRUHDQGDIWHUODELDOV L EHIRUH MDQG LRIWKHQH[WV\OODEOH H L D H E\XPODXW ¬Ø XQVWUHVVHG H
phonology
271
6RQRUDQWV )URP,QGR(XURSHDQWR3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ
(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ
8 8
â
M
Æ
P
Q
O
U
D
D
LO EHIRUHFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV L M
XO
LU EHIRUHFRQVRQDQWDOFOXVWHUV L M
XU
M
Z
P
Q
O
U
)URP3URWR$OEDQLDQWRPRGHUQ$OEDQLDQ 7RVN (DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ
$OEDQLDQ 7RVN
LO
XO
LU
XU *j
*w *m
Q
r w q
8 8 r w q
LOOL XOOX LUUL XUUX JM DQODXWEHIRUH D H A M DQODXWEHIRUH X Ø LQODXWDIWHUIURQWYRZHOV [ LQODXWDIWHUQRQIURQWYRZHOV Y DQODXW Ø (inlaut, absorbed by long vowels) P PE DXVODXWLUUHJXODUO\ Q DQODXW U LQODXWDIWHUXQVWUHVVHGYRZHOV Ø LQODXWDIWHUVWUHVVHGYRZHOV
272
phonetic tables
*l
U
8
r w q
O DQODXWDQGFOXVWHUV OO LQODXW UUU U LQFOXVWHUV Ø (DXVODXWDIWHU H
phonology
273
&RQVRQDQWV )URP,QGR(XURSHDQWR3URWR$OEDQLDQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ
(DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ
r V DQODXWDQGFOXVWHUV w [ EHWZHHQYRZHOV q h DIWHU L X
V
S
E
EK
W
G
GK
N
J
JK
8 8 8 8 8 8
½
½K
á
Þ
ÞK
S
E
E
W
G
G
N
J
J
WV
Wh EHIRUH X
G]
GÊ EHIRUH X
G]
GÊ EHIRUH X
N
Wh EHIRUHIURQWYRZHOVDQG M
J
GÊ EHIRUHIURQWYRZHOVDQG M
J
GÊ EHIRUHIURQWYRZHOVDQG M
)URP3URWR$OEDQLDQWRPRGHUQ$OEDQLDQ 7RVN (DUO\3URWR$OEDQLDQ
V
[
h
S
$OEDQLDQ 7RVN JM KØ VK S
274
phonetic tables
E
W
G
N
J
WV
G]
Wh
GÊ
8 8
E W G GK EHWZHHQYRZHOVDQGDIWHUU N J WK GK GDQODXWLIIROORZHGE\VLELODQWV V ]
,1'(;2)$/%$1,$1)2506 DFDU DFLVK DFR DFRVK DGKXURM DI¬U DIW¬ DJ DJMH DJM¬QRM DJM¬URM DK DL âM DMN¬ DN¬ DPE¬O DP¬ DP¬] DPXOO DQG¬ DQG¬UU DQGUUD DQ¬ DQ¬PLN DQ¬]¬ DQJ DQJ¬UU DS DS¬ DU DUD DUE¬Q DUE¬U DU¬ DUJ¬VK DUL DUN DUP¬ DUPLN DUQRM DUTLW¬ DUU¬ DUU¬]¬
DUULM DUV\H DUV\HVK¬P DVDM DVR DVLVK DVRVK DVKN¬ DVKW DVKW¬ DW DWD DWê DW¬ DW¬Q DWL DWLM DWR DW\QH DW\UH DWK¬W DYXM DYXOO D\ EDF EDG¬U EDGK¬U EDJ¬P EDJ¬WL EDKH EDˆ M EDMJ¬ EDNWL EDOç¬P EDOJ¬ EDOVK¬P EDOW¬ EDOO¬ EDOOXQJ¬ EDQ¬ EDU EDUGK¬ EDU¬QD
276
index of albanian forms
EDU¬UD EDUL EDUN EDUN¬ EDUP¬ EDUTH EDUXN¬ EDUU¬ EDVKN¬ EDWK¬ EH EHNRM EHOE¬ EHUN EHURQM¬ EHUU EHUUD EHVD EHV¬ E¬M E¬UUDN¬ E¬U¬ E¬UVKê E¬UWDV E¬UWHW E¬UU\O ELH ELJ¬ ELM ELM¬ ELM¬] ELO¬ ELORQM¬ ELP¬ ELQG ELQGD ELU ELUD ELU¬ ELUT ELUWK ELUWKD ELVK¬ ELVKW ELVKWDM¬ ELVN
EMHU ¬ EMHUU EMHVKN¬ EODW¬ EOHKXU¬ EOHM EOHU¬ EOHUW¬ EOHW¬ EOL EOî EOLQM EOLVKW¬ EORU¬ EORYD EOR]¬ EOXDM EOXHM ERKHW ERM EROOH EROO¬ ERQ ERU¬ ERU¬UD ERULJ¬ ERUQD ERUUD ERVKW ERVKWLQM ERWD ERW¬ ERYD EUDP EUHGK EUHJ EUHJMH EUHM EUêM EUHMWD EUHN¬ EUHQ EUHQGD EUHQJ¬ EUHVK¬Q EUHVK¬U
index of albanian forms EUHVKN¬ EUHVKW¬ EUHWN EUH] EUL EUî EULJMH EULP¬ EULQ¬ EULQM EULU¬ EULUWK EULUWK¬ EULVN EURGKD EUXP¬ EUXVKWXOO EUXVKWXOOD EUX] EU\GK EU\P¬ EXDM EXDOO EXçDV EXHM EXHOO EXM EûM EXMN EXMWD EûMWD EXN¬ EXN¬O EXNXU EXOE¬U EXO¬ EXON EXOORJ EXQJ EXQJD EXUGK¬ EXUU¬ EXVK EXVKW¬U EXW EXW¬ EX]¬
277
FHPW¬ F¬ULM F¬ULO F¬ULWD FHUN FHUND FHUP¬ FLW¬ FXE FXS FXUU FXUUD çDM çDO¬ çDQG¬U FDUH çDUV çDUWD ç¬ çHO çHOD çHP çHUGKH çLPN¬ çMHUU çPRM çRM GDF GDFD GDGDQ GDM GDN GDO GDOW¬ GDP GDQJ¬ GDUND GDUN¬ GDUVP¬ GDVP¬ GDVK GDYD G¬IWRM
278
index of albanian forms
GHJ¬ GHK GHM GHO GHOO GHP GHPD GHPHVK GHPL GHQG GHQM¬ GHUGK GHU¬ GHUJM GHUL GHUN GHUU GHUUD GHVK GHVKD GHVKW¬ GHW GHW\U¬ G¬NRM G¬OLU G¬OLURM G¬OO¬QM¬ G¬OOLQM¬ G¬P G¬US¬QM G¬UUDV¬ G¬VKLURM G¬VKPRM GL GLHM GLHOO GLJMD GLJMQL GLKDV GLN¬ GLOMD GLOQL GLP¬Q GLP¬U GLPQD GLPUD GLUT
GLVKN¬ GLVKW¬ GLW GLWD GLW¬ GLW¬]L GMDO¬ GMDOO GMDWK¬ GMDWK¬UD GMDWKQD GMDWKW¬ GMH GMHJ GMHJ¬ GMHO GMHOP GMHOP¬] GMHP GMHUU GMHUV¬ GRJMD GROD GROL GRUD GRU¬ GRU¬]DQ¬ GRUJMD GRV¬ GUD GUâ GUDJRQM GUDJXD GUDQJ GUDQJMH GUDQJRM GUD Q JXH GUDS¬Q GUDS¬U GUDSLQM GUH GUê GUHGK GUHGKDOHVK GUHJ¬
index of albanian forms GUHMW¬ GUHN¬ GUHT GUHT¬Q GUHT¬U GU¬QM¬ GULQM¬ GULWD GULW¬ GULWK¬ GULWK¬UD GULWKQD GUL]¬ GURGKD GURH GURMWD GURPF¬ GURYD GUX GUû GUXDM GUXDMWD GUXGKH GUXHM GUXVKN GU\GK¬W GU\VKN GXD GXDM GXDO GXDU GXH GXHM GXHU GXURM GXVKN GXVKTH G\ G\HU G\OO¬ G\PE¬GKMHW¬ G\QG G\QGD G\W¬ G\]HW GKD
279
GKDOO¬ GKDOOW¬ GKDPE GKDPEH GKDPEHVK GKDPE¬ GKDP¬ GKDQG¬U GKDQGXU¬ GKDQ¬ GKDVK¬ GKDW¬ GKH GKHPE GKHPED GKHQD GKHUD GKH] GK¬PE GK¬PEH GK¬PEHVK GK¬PE¬ GK¬QG¬U GK¬QGXU¬ GK¬QH GK¬Q¬ GKL GKLU¬ GKMDP¬ GKMDP¬UD GKMDPQD GKMHV GKMHW¬ GKMHYD GKXQ¬ GKXURM HF HF¬M HFL HGK HJM¬OO HJM¬U HK HKXM HKXOO HMD
280
index of albanian forms
êM¬ HOE HOE¬QD HOE¬UD HP HPH HP¬Q HP¬U HPQD HPUD HPW¬ HQG HQJM¬OO HQM¬ HUGKD HU¬ HU¬QD HU¬UD HUJM¬] HUU HV¬OO HVK HVK¬ HVKNH HVKWD HVKW¬ HVKW¬QD HVKWQD HVKWUD HW HW¬Q HW¬U HWKH ¬M ¬PE¬O ¬P¬ ¬QG¬ ¬QG¬UU ¬QGUUD ¬VKW¬ IDM IâM IDMH IDMNRQM IDMNXD
IDMNXH IDP¬ IDPXOO IDTH IDU¬ IDUN¬ IDW IDWR IH I¬MHM IHO¬ IHP¬Q IHP¬U I¬PLM¬ IHQG IHQGD I¬QG\HO I¬UJRM I¬UNRM IHUU IHUU¬ I¬QG\HOO ILDOH ILN ILND ILVKNHP IMDO¬ IMHWD IODN IODN¬ IODN¬QD IODN¬UD IODV IODVKN¬W IOH IOê IOHJ¬ IOHW IOHW¬ IOL IOî IORN IOXJ¬ IOXWXURM IRUW¬ ITLQM¬ IUDT
index of albanian forms IUDTQD IUDTUD IUDVK¬Q IUDVK¬U IUH IUê IUXHU IU\HM IU\M IU\W IVKâM IVKDQD IVKDW IVKDWQD IVKDWUD IVKHK IVKHKD IVKLN¬ IWRI IWRK IWXD IWXH IXQG IXTL IXTLVK¬P IXUN¬ IXUU IXUU¬ IXUULN IXUULT IXV IXVK¬ I\HOO I\OO I\VKNHP I\W I\W\U¬ JDERQM¬ JDMJ¬ JDN JDODPVK JDPXOH JDQG JDUEH JDUE¬ JDUGK
JDUGKH JDUGKHVK JDUGK¬ JDU¬ JDUJXOO JDUULV JDVKW¬ JDW¬ JDWRYD JDWXDM JDWXHM JD] JGKH JGKê JGKHQG JGKLM JGKîM JGKLQD JGKLYD JHU JHUD J¬OED]¬ J¬ORM J¬ORYD J¬UçDN J¬UGKLM J¬UKDV J¬UMHS¬ J¬UPDGK¬ J¬UUHV¬ J¬UU\HM J¬UVKDQ¬ J¬UVKDV J¬UVK¬U¬ J¬VKWDOO¬ J¬VKWHQM¬ J¬WKHS JLVKW JLVKW¬UD JLVKWQD JODW¬ JOHGK¬ JOHS¬ JO¬PE JORT JOXK¬ JREHOO¬
281
282
index of albanian forms
JRGDV JRM¬ JRM¬OLGKQL JRP¬ JRUULF¬ JRV¬ JUD JUDED JUDE¬ JUDELV JUDI JUDK JUDP JUDPQD JUDPUD JUDWK JUDWK¬ JUDY¬ JUHK JUHKXOO JUHN JUHOOD JUHOO¬ JUHQ]¬ JUHS JUHUD JUHUD] JUHU¬ JUHU¬] JU¬P¬UDW¬ JULIVK¬ JULJM JULK JULM JUîM JULOO JULPD JULP¬ JULVK JULVKD JURVK¬ JUXD JUXH JUXQ¬ JUXU¬ JUXVKW JU\ND
JU\N¬ JXDM JXDOO JXOçRM JXOWRM JXQ¬ JXQ¬GKLU¬ JXU JXU¬ JXUWK JXUWKD JXV JXVKW JXW¬ JMâ JMDK JMDM JMDMWD JMDN JMDNQD JMDNUD JMDNX JMDOO¬ JMDOP JMDOS¬ JMDQD JMDQG¬U JMDQ¬ JMDTH JMDUS¬Q JMDUS¬U JMDVKW¬ JMDW¬ JMDYD JMD]¬ JMHGK JMHM JMêM JMHO JMHOE¬Q JMHOE¬U JMHOO¬ JMHOO¬] JMHP JMHPE JMHQ
index of albanian forms JMHU JMHUE JMHUED JMHUGKH JMHU¬ JMHVK JMHVKD JMHVKW¬U JMHWD JMHWK JMH]GLV JM¬ JM¬PRM JM¬QG¬U JM¬U JM¬UD JML JMî JMLGK¬ JMLQGH JMLQRQM JMLWK¬ JMROO¬ JMRYD JMX JMû JMXDM JMXHM JMXK¬ JMXP¬ JMXUP¬ JMXYHQJ¬ JM\NRM JM\P ¬ V¬ JM\PW\U¬ JM\VDPL JM\V¬ JM\VP¬ JM\VK JM\VK¬ JM\VK¬Q JM\VK¬U KD KDN¬ KDOD KDODYH W
283
KDO¬ KDO¬Q KDOO KDOWK KDOWKD KDPXOO KDQ¬ KDQ¬]¬ KDQJUD KDS KDUDEHO KDUN KDUP L KDUP¬VKRU KDUPRM KDUU KDUURM KDUURN KH Kê KHGK KHMH KHN KHOP KHOT KHOO KHOOH KHOOHVK KHT KHUGKH KHU¬ KHUPRM KHVKW¬ KHWRM K¬ K¬Q¬ KL Kî KLGKHP KLGK¬W KLMH KLN¬UU KLPH KLQJ¬O KLS ¬M KLU
284
index of albanian forms
KLUU¬ KLV¬OO KîV¬OO KLV¬OOD KîV¬OOD KLWDV KRGKD KRMH KRND KRTD KRUU KX KXl KXDM KXDOO KXGK¬U KXGKUD KXHM KXHOO KXPE KXPED KXQM KXUED KXUE¬ KXUGK¬ KXW K\HM K\M K\l M K\OO K\SL K\UD LM¬ LM¬] LN LN¬M LN¬QD LP LPH LPW¬ LU¬ LULT LVK LVKD LVK¬ LVKLP
LVKLQ LVKLW LVKQ¬ LVKWH LVKXOO LWK MDN MDP MDQ¬ MDS MDUJ¬ MDVKW¬ MDY¬ MH MHP MHPL MHQ¬ MHQL MHUP MHV MHVK MHVK¬ MHVK¬P MHVK¬W¬ MHWD MHW¬ MHW¬U MRQ¬ MRVK MRWH MX MXDM MXHM MXMD MXML MXVK MXYH ND Nâ NDELVKW NDFDGUH NDFDGUê NDFDJMHO NDFDPLW NDFDUURM
index of albanian forms NDFDUUXP NDç NDçHO NDçLOH NDçXE¬ NDçXOH NDIVK¬ NDIVKRM NDODPDQ NDODPHQG NDODTDI¬ NDODYHVK NDOE NDOHVK NDO¬ NDOLKXP NDOLKXPE NDOLYDUH NDOW¬U NDOO NDOOD NDOOL NDOORM NDP NDPE¬ NDQG NDQGHOO¬ NDQG¬ NDQG¬UU NDQJ¬ NDQJMHO NDQS NDQXVK¬ NDS NDSD NDSH NDS¬ NDSL NDSRQM NDSURM NDSUXDOO NDSUXHOO NDSWK NDSWKD NDSXD NDSXH NDUDYHO¬
NDUNDV NDUPD NDUP¬ NDUSD NDUS¬ NDUUDELVKW NDUUDYHVK NDUU¬ NDUULJ¬ NDUUXS NDUUXW¬ NDVKLOH NDVKQMHW NDVKW¬ NDW¬U NDWRQM NDWXD NDWXH NHç¬Q NHç¬U NHGK NHGKD NHGK¬ NHP NHS NHT NHW¬U NH]¬ N¬ N¬OERTH N¬OTHUH N¬OWKDV N¬O\VK N¬OODV N¬PE¬ N¬PERQ¬ N¬PERU¬ N¬QDT N¬QG N¬QG¬ N¬QGHOO¬ N¬QGRIVKD N¬QGRM N¬QJ¬ N¬SXUGK¬ N¬SXV N¬SXWD
285
286
index of albanian forms
N¬T\U N¬UED N¬UELVKW N¬UF N¬UFDV N¬UFHM N¬UFHYD N¬UNRM N¬UNRMD N¬UNRMP¬ N¬UNRMQ¬ N¬UNRQ N¬UNRQL N¬UOHVK N¬UP¬ N¬UPLOO N¬UPLQM N¬US N¬UU N¬UUD N¬UUDE¬ N¬UUO¬ N¬UUXW¬ N¬UVK¬QGHOOD N¬UW\O N¬UYHVKHP N¬VHQ N¬VKLOO N¬VKLOOD N¬VKWDOO¬ N¬VKW¬Q N¬VKW¬U N¬VKWMHOO¬ N¬VK\UH NLM NLVK¬ NLYD NMR NOLWKD NOXP¬VKW NOODS¬ NRF NRFLQM NRIVK¬ NRK¬ NROHVKN¬ NROLEH
NROPH NROP¬ NROO¬ NRSVKW NRUE NRUEXOO NRUEXOOD NRUGK NRUGK¬ NRU¬ NRUU NRV NRW NUDK NUDKLQ¬ NUDKLV NUDQG NUDQGH NUDQWK NUDQWKD NUHGK NUHI NUHID NUHK NUHKD NUHM NUHN¬ NUHO NUHQ¬ NUHS NUHSD NUHSXOO NUHU¬ NUHVKN¬ NUHVKP¬ NUHVKS¬ NUHYD NU¬QG NUL NUî NULPE NULPED NULS¬ NULS¬UD NURGKD NURGK¬ NURMH
index of albanian forms NURQM NURYD NUXD NUXDM NUXH NUXHM NUXS NUXSD NUXVKN NU\H NU\P NU\PD NU\S¬ NU\SQD NU\T NUURNXOO NXM NXMW NXMWRM NXNXW¬ NXODU NXOE¬ NXO¬ NXOP NXOS NXOS¬Q NXOS¬U NXOWH NXOW¬U NXOORM NXOORVKW¬U NXPHUT NXPW¬U NXQDW NXQG¬U NXQGRM NXQHW¬Q NXQHW¬U NXQJRM NXQJXOO NXQRU¬ NXQM NXQMRM NXT NXURU¬ NXUW NXUWK
287
NXUWKH NXUU¬ NXUUL] NXVK NXVK¬UL NXVK¬Uî NXVKXOO NXYHQG N\ M Oâ ODE ODIVKD ODIVK¬ ODJ ODJVKW¬ ODM OâM ODMWKL ODN ODN¬ ODN¬Q ODN¬U ODNVKWH ODNWK ODNWKD ODNWKH ODNXT ODNXU ODPHQM ODP¬ ODP¬QM ODPVK ODPVKH ODQ ODQG¬ ODQ¬ ODS ODSD ODS¬ ODSV ODSVD ODU ODUGK ODU¬ ODURM
288
index of albanian forms
ODUXVKN¬ ODVK¬ ODVKW¬ ODW¬ ODWUHGK ODW\U¬ ODYD OEDUGK OH OHE¬Q OHE¬U OHEHWLV OHGK OHI OHK OHKW¬ OHM OHP]¬ OHQG OHS¬U OHSW\U¬ OHSXM OHSXU OHT OHTH OHUD OHU¬ OHVK OHVKQD OHVKUD OH] OH]¬ O¬ O¬EDUNH O¬IWRM O¬I\W O¬JDW¬ O¬NXU¬ O¬PDTH O¬PD]¬ O¬P¬ O¬PHQM O¬PVK O¬QG¬ O¬QGLQ¬ O¬Q¬
O¬QJDW¬ O¬QJRM O¬SHF O¬SLM O¬SLWN¬ O¬SMHW¬ O¬SXVK¬ O¬UXVKN¬ O¬VKRM O¬WL O¬Wî O¬YRU]¬ O¬YRU]RM OL Oî OLGK OLGKHP OLGKHQ OLGKHVK OLGKHW OLGK¬ OLGK¬VK OLGKL OLGKQL OLGKQLX OLGKXQ OLGKXQL OLITDU OLITHU OLJ OLJDW¬ OLJM OLM¬ OLN OLNW\U¬ OLO OLO¬ OLQG OLQGD OLQJD OLQJ¬ OLQM¬ OLT OLVP¬ ORG¬U ORGURM ORGK
index of albanian forms ORMWD ORS¬ ORTH ORW ORWL OR] OWHU OX OXDM OXF¬ OXHM OXHMWD OXIW¬ OXJ OXJM OXKDV OXKHW OXKLWL OXP OXPDN OXPHQM OXP¬ OXSHVK OXTHU¬ OXV OXW OXWD O\HM O\S O\WK O\WK¬ OODQD OODQ¬ OODS OO¬QM¬] OO¬UD OO¬U¬ OORK¬ OOXN¬ OOXS OOXUE¬ PDGK PDM PâM
289
PDMD PDM¬ PDMWD PDMW¬ PâMW¬ PDN¬ PDN¬UU PDNXW PDO PDOFRM PDOHW PDOHYH PDOL PDOLQ PDOLW PDOO PDOO¬QJMHM PDOONRM PDQ PDQDIHUU¬ PDQGLOH PDQJ¬ PDQJML PDUDM PDUGK¬ PDUV PDUWHV¬ PDUU PDUUW¬ PDV PDVKNXOO PDW PDWD PDWXN¬ Pâ] PD]¬ PEDM PEDU PEDURM PEDUW PEDV PEDWK PEHV PEHV¬ PEHWD PE¬VKWHW PEL
290
index of albanian forms
PELM PEîM PELYD PEMHOO PEOHGK PEORGKD PEORM PEROOD PEUHW PEUHW¬Q PEUHW¬U PEURGK PEXIDV PEXIHW PEXILWL PEXORM PE\OO PE\V PçHI PH PHI PHK PHKHP PHMH PHN PHN¬W PHNVK PHO PHQç¬P PHQG PHQGVK¬P PHV¬ PHVK¬ PHWDOH P¬ P¬GKHQM P¬JDVKW¬U P¬NDPE P¬NDW P¬N¬PE P¬NUHV¬ P¬OO¬ P¬OOHQMD P¬OOHQM¬ P¬OOH]¬ P¬QG P¬QGDIVK
P¬QGDIVKQD P¬QGDIVKUD P¬QJ¬ P¬QJRM P¬QJML P¬QMLOO P¬UGKLM P¬UJRM P¬UNRVK P¬UP¬ULV P¬UVK¬ P¬U]HM P¬VRM P¬VKHUH P¬VKLN¬ P¬VKLU¬ P¬VKRM P¬VKTHUU¬ P¬VKWHN¬Q P¬VKWHN¬U P¬] PL Pî PLD PLHOO PLHOOD]¬ PLHOOQD PLHOOUD PLI PLID PLK PLKD PLM¬ PLN PLO¬ PLOO PLQM PLUD PLUH PLU¬ PLV PLVK PLVKNRQM¬ PLVKQD PLVKUD PLWD PLW¬
index of albanian forms PLW¬] PL]¬ PL]RM PMDOFD PMDOF¬ PMDOW¬ PMHGK¬U PMHJXOO PMHJXOOD PMHN PMHN¬U PMHNUD PMHO PMHU¬ PMHVKW¬U PNHTHP PO\ç PO\VK PRGK PRGKXOO PRGKXOOD PRN¬Q PRN¬U PROD PROLV PROO¬ PRUD PRUL PRUU PRUUD PRV PRVK¬ PRW PRWH PRW¬U PRWLW PRWUD PSLM PSîM PUHNXOO PVKHI PVKHID PXD PXDM PXDUU PXH PXHM
PXJ PXJXOO PXOO¬ PXOOL PXOOî PXQG PXQGD PXQJ PXQJRM PXUJ PXUWDM¬ PXUU¬W PXUUL] PXVKN PXVKN¬OO\HU PXVKNRQM¬ PXVKOOLQ]¬ PXVKW PXW PXWQD PXWUD PX]J P\M¬ P\N¬ P\OO P\VKN P]LWK QD QDH QDP¬ QDQG QDQ¬ QDS¬ QDW¬ QDW\U¬ QGDM QGâM QGDMWD QGDQ QGDYD QGHM QGêM QGHV QGHVD QGHVK QGH]
291
292 QGH]D QG¬OHM QG¬U]HM QG¬UURM QGLI QGLID QGLK QGLKD QGLNRM QGLTMD QGMHM QGMHN QGRTD QGULNXOO QGULNXOOD QGUL]¬ QGU\VKNXOO QGU\VKNXOOD QGXD QGXN QGXND QGXONHP QG\HM QG\M QH QHPHF QHQR QHV¬U QHVK QHW QHW¬ QHYH QHYHULV QHYRM¬ Q¬P¬ Q¬P¬URM Q¬Q¬ Q¬QW¬ QJD QJDM QJDMWD QJDV QJH QJHW QJLM QJîM QJRUGK
index of albanian forms QJUDQ¬ QJUH QJU¬Q¬ QJULGK QJULWD QJULWL QJURI QJURK QJU\GK QJU\V QJXMRM QJXO QJXUURM QJXV QJXW QJXWD QJM¬URM QJMHVK QJMLUH QJMLV QL QLS QLS¬Q QLS¬U QLV QRIXOO QRIXOOD QRVKW¬U QRWRM QR]LN¬ QXKDV QXN QXOO¬ QXV QXVH Q[LW Q\HM Q\HOO Q\MH Q\W¬URM QMHI QMHID QMHK QMHKD QMHU QMHU¬]
index of albanian forms QMHUL QM¬PE¬GKMHW¬ QMRI QMRID QMRK QMRKD QMRYD RERUU RSLQJ¬ RUHQGL RUUO RUWHN RUWLTH SD SDJ¬]RM SDK SDMWRM SDN SDO¬ SDOQM¬ SDOO SDOOD SDOO¬ SDT SDU¬ SDUUL] SDV SDVXQ SDVXU SDVK SDVK¬ SDVKWUDN SDWD SDWNXD SDWNXH SH Sê SHM]¬ SHOHQ¬ SHO¬ SHOLQ SHOT SHOO¬ SHOOJ SHP¬
SHQGDU SHQG¬ SHQGRM SHQGXOO SHQJ SHU¬QGL SHU¬QGRM SHV¬ SêV¬ SHVK¬ SHVKN SHVKNRS SHVKT SHW¬ SHWN S¬J¬M S¬OFDV S¬OTHM S¬OODV S¬U S¬UJMRM S¬UNDV S¬UNXO S¬UPEL S¬UPE\V S¬UPE\VD S¬UPMHUU S¬USMHW¬ S¬USRVK S¬USXVK S¬UTHOO S¬UYMHO S¬UUDOO S¬UUDOO¬ S¬UUHQM S¬UURQM S¬UUXD S¬UUXH S¬VRM SL SLGK SLGKH SLGK¬UD SLGKQD SLM SLN SLND
293
294
index of albanian forms
SLOLNXUL SLOLSL]J¬ SLOLYHV¬ SLOLYRHV¬ SLOOMD SLOOQL SLP¬ SLPXQ SLQ¬ SLT SLTMD SLTQL SLU¬ SLVK¬ SLVKT SLVNDV SLWH SLW¬U SLYD SL]J¬ SL]JXOO SMDOP SMDYLF¬ SMHN SMHOO SMHS¬Q SMHS¬U SMHUGK SMHUJXOO SMHUU SMHV¬ SMHVKN¬ SODI SODID SODJ¬ SODK SODKD SODN SODNX SODV SODVD SOHK SOêK SOêKQD SOHKUD SOHQJ SOHS
SOHT SO¬I¬QM SOLT SOLV SOLVK SORJ SORMH SORW¬ SOODM¬ SROOD SRQLV SRSXM SRSXOO SRTD SRUD SRUGKD SRUGK¬ SRUHQG SRURVLW SRUUD SRUULT SRVWDKH SRVXOO¬ SRVKW¬ SUDQGYHU¬ SUH SUHI SUHID SUHK SUHKD SUHK¬Q SUHK¬U SUHND SUHPWRM SUHV SUHVK SUHYD SUHY¬ SU¬QGYHU¬ SU¬QMN¬ SULIW SULIWLQM SULM SUîM SULOO SULQD SULQG
index of albanian forms SULQG¬Q SULQG¬U SULVK SULWD SURGK SURGKRM SURN¬ SURVKPRM SUR]KPRM SUXVK SUXVKH SUXVKHVK SUXVKL SUUDOO¬ SXIW¬ SXJâM SXO¬ SXOT\HU SXQXDU SXQXHP SXS¬ SXT SXUWK SXUU¬ SXV SXVK SXVKWHW SXWK SXWKD S\HV S\ON¬ S\OO TDI¬ TDM TDQM TDUN TDUU TDUW¬ TDV TDVD THIXM THIXOO THN THO THOE THOEQD
THOEUD THOT THOO THP THQ THQ¬ THQJM THQJMD THQJM¬ THS THUU THUV¬ THVK THVK¬ THWD THW¬ THWK T¬Q¬ TLHOO TLIW TLM TLN¬O TLPN¬ TLSL TLV TLVK¬ TLWD TRM TRV TRVD TXDM TXDMWD TXHM TXHMWD TXN TXOO TXP¬VKW TXUUD T\H T\O T\U T\WHW UDGLV UDJDO UDQG¬ UDQ¬
295
296
index of albanian forms
UDQJ¬ UDTLW¬ UDVK¬ UDW¬ UDY¬ UDYJ¬ UH UHJM UHN¬ UHQG UHQGHYH UHS¬ UHYD U¬PHQ U¬P¬U U¬QG¬ U¬Q¬ U¬Q[RM U¬SMHW¬ U¬SRVK U¬U¬ UL Uî ULM ULV ULV¬Q ULV¬U UMHS URSD URVD URV¬ URYD UX UXDM UXD]¬ UXHM UXQJRM U\HM U\M U\MWD U\V U\W U\WD UUD UUDEH
UUDJ UUDK UUDQM¬ UUDV UUDVD UUDVKW UUDVROO UUDWK¬ UUHJM UUHJXOO UUHM UUêM UUHMWD UUHN UUHP UUHPE UUHWK UUH]H UU¬IHVKN UU¬NH UU¬PDç UU¬PEHM UU¬QJMHM UU¬QM¬ UU¬SLU¬ UU¬VKDM¬ UU¬VKLQ¬ UU¬VKLU¬ UULE¬ UULOO¬ UULPH UULPHYH UULS UULS¬ UULT¬Q UULT¬U UULV UULW UULWD UUMHGK UUMHW¬ UUREXM UUREXOO UURGKD UURM UURW¬ UUXGK¬
index of albanian forms UUXIH UUXJ¬ UUXP UUXPEXOO UUXVK UUXVKNXOO UU\O¬ UU\PD UU\P¬ UU\S V’ VDP¬ VDQ¬ VDUN¬ VHPE¬U VHU¬ VLOOMD VLOOQL VLW¬ VLYMHW VMHOO VNXQGLM VNXQGLOO VRGLW VROOD VRQ¬ VRQWH VRUUD VRUU¬ VRW VS¬UNHW VS¬UNLWL VTDS VTDT VTHS VTHSH VTXIXU VWDS VWDSLQM VWHSHP VW¬UYLV VXN¬ VXNXM VXNXOO VXPEXOO VXQGRM
VXS VXUP¬ VXW¬ V\ V\WK V\WK¬ VKDJ VKDO¬ VKDS VKDUDQGXN VKDU¬ VKDUN VKDUU¬ VKDUWRM VKDW VKHNXOO VKHOJ VKHPE¬OOHM VKHP¬ VKHP¬U VKHP¬UN VKHQM¬ VKHQMW¬ VKHV VKHVK VKHWH VK¬IUHM VK¬OERM VK¬OOî VK¬OOLM VK¬QGRVK VK¬QGULW VK¬QJMHW¬ VK¬UEHM VK¬WLW VKL VKî VKLM VKLM¬ VKLQD VKLUD VKLWD VKLX VKNDE¬ VKNDJRM VKNDN
297
298
index of albanian forms
VKNDO VKNDOO¬ VKNDPE VKNDUGK¬ VKNDUNRM VKNDV VKNHO VKNHS VKN¬OER]¬ VKN¬PE VKN¬PEHM VKN¬QGLM¬ VKN¬UGKHF VKNOHS¬ VKNOHV¬ VKNPHV VKNRM VKNRS VKNRUUHW VKNRUV¬ VKNR]¬ VKNUDE¬ VKNUHK VKNUHS VKNURYD VKNUXDM VKNUXHM VKNUXPE VKNU\HM VKNXO VKNXQG VKNXUUH VKRI VKRK VKRN VKRT VKRUHWN¬ VKRUU VKRVK VKRW¬ VKSDOO VKSDUGK VKSDUU VKSDW VKSDWXOO VKSHQG VKSHUU
VKSH]¬ VKS¬Q¬ VKS¬QHWN¬ VKS¬UHM VKSLH VKSLI VKSLK VKSLUW VKSLUW¬UD VKSLUWQD VKSRUU VKSUHK VKSUHWN¬ VKSX]¬ VKTD VKTDUU VKTHSRM VKTHUU VKTHUUD VKTH]¬ VKTLSRM VKTRS¬ VKTRUUD VKTXDM VKTXHM VKTXIXU VKT\HM VKT\PE VKT\W VKWDJD VKWDJ¬ VKWDOE¬U VKWDON¬ VKWDOO¬ VKWDOS VKWDQJ VKWDW VKWDW¬ VKWDWQD VKWDWUD VKWD]¬ VKWâ]¬ VKWHJ VKWHJMH VKWHNRM VKWHNWK
index of albanian forms VKWHNWKD VKW¬OOXQJ¬ VKW¬UUDV VKW¬UURM VKW¬]¬ VKWLH VKWLJMH VKWLM¬ VKWLU VKWMHOO VKWRM VKWROOD VKWUDS VKWUDW VKWUHJ¬ VKWUHN VKWU¬QJRM VKWUHQMW¬ VKWUHS VKWUHW¬Q VKWUHW¬U VKWULM VKWURID VKWURI¬ VKWURKD VKWURK¬ VKWUXQJ¬ VKW\U VKXIUHM VKXOOâ VKXOO¬ VKXP¬ VKXU VKXUGK¬U VKXUXNRM VKXVKXQM¬ WDIW WDIWDU WDOO WDOO¬ WDPE¬O WDP¬ WDQG WDQGH WDQ¬ WDQJ¬
299
WDURN WH WHMH WHQ¬ WHQM¬ WHU WHUD WHU¬ WHUP WHUSORW¬ WHVKD WHVK¬ WHW¬ W¬ W¬EDQ¬ W¬PE¬O W¬QG W¬QGH W¬U¬ W¬UIRM¬ W¬UIXUN W¬UKHT W¬UPHW W¬USRVKW¬ W¬UVLU¬ WL WLP¬Q WLP¬U WLQ¬ WLWXM WLWXOO WMHJXOO WMHUU WMHW¬U WODQG¬U WPHUU WRJ WRJMH WROO¬ WRQD WRQ¬ WRUUD WRUXD WRUXH WUD WUDMWRM
300
index of albanian forms
WUDS WUDSD WUDSHVK WUDSL WUDU¬ WUDV WUDVK¬ WUDVK¬JRM WUDWK WUDWK¬ WUH WUHGK WUHJ WUHPE WUHQM WUHSH WUHSHYH WUHU¬ WUHV WULGKMHW¬ WULP WULVKH WURGKD WURIW¬ WURNDV WURNHW WURNLWL WUX WUû WUXQJ WU\HO¬ WU\V WXD WXDM WXDMD WXHM WXHMD WXO WXOD WXOH WXQG WXQGD WXULV WXUP¬ WXUS WXUVKHM WXV
WXW WXWD W\P WKDG¬U WKDM WKDQ¬ WKDUE¬W WKDUN WKDUT WKDUTH WKDVK¬ WKDYD WKHN WKHN¬ WKHOE WKHOO¬ WKHPE¬U WKHS WKHSD WKHSH WKHU WKHURN¬ WKHYD WK¬OO¬]¬ WK¬Q¬ WK¬QJMLOO WK¬QL WK¬QLD WK¬QXN¬O WK¬UL WK¬ULD WKL WKLN¬ WKLPWK WKLPWKD WKLQG WKLQGD WKLQM¬ WKLUTH WKLUU WKMHUP¬ WKMHUU¬ WKMHVKW¬ WKQHJ¬O WKRM WKRP
index of albanian forms WKRQM WKRQM¬] WKRW¬ WKXD WKXH WKXPE WKXPEXOO WKXS¬U WKXU WK\HM X XGK¬ XJDU XM¬ XM¬UD XMN XMQD XMT XMT¬Q XMT¬U XO XOD XOLVKW¬ XO]¬ XOOL XOOî XPDV XPDWD XPE XQD]¬ XQG\U¬ XQ¬ XQJM XQJMLOO XSHVKN XU XUGK¬Q XUGK¬U XUHO¬ XU¬ XUL XULQM XULWK XULWK¬ XURM XUUHM
301
XVKWRM XVKûM XVKXQM¬ XW XWK XWK¬W XWKXOO YD YDGLV YDGK¬ YDM YDM¬ YDMUD YDM]¬ YDO¬ YDOONXD YDOONXH YDQJ YDQJMH YDU YDUI¬U YDUJ YDUU YDUUD] YDUUH YDVKD YDVKD] YDVK¬ YDVK¬] YDW¬U YDY¬U YGHV YGLT YGLTL YGLVMD YGLVQL YGMHUU YGRUUD YH Yê YHG¬U YH¬] YHKWH YHM YHMD
302
index of albanian forms
YHQG YHQ¬ YHQLWHP YHS¬U YHUE YHUE¬U YHUGK¬ YHUH YHU¬ YHULJ¬ YHUU YHUU¬ YHU]¬ YHV YHVK YHVKD YHVK¬ YHVK¬] YêVKW YHWH YHWHP YHWK YHWK¬ YH] Y¬OOD Y¬OOD]¬Q Y¬OOH]¬U Y¬QHU Y¬QJ Y¬QJMH Y¬UF¬ Y¬UUDV Y¬UUL Y¬UUî Y¬UV¬ Y¬UWLW Y¬UYLW Y¬VKW Y¬VKWMHOO Y¬VKWLU¬ Y¬WK Y¬WK¬ YJMH YJMê YLç YLGK
YLGKD YLJMH YLM YLODV YLQM YLUJM¬U YLUJMLQ YLUUD YLUXD YLUXH YLVH YLW YLWH YLWRUH YMHGK YMHK¬UU YMHM YMHO YMHOO YMHUU YMHUVK¬ YMHVKW¬ YMHW YMHW¬U YQHVKWD YREHNW¬ YRGKD YRGK¬ YRH YRJ¬O YRM YRMQD YROD YROOD YRQ¬ YRUE¬ YRUI¬Q YRUUD YRVKW¬U YRW¬U YUDQ¬W YUDS YUDU¬ YUDV YUDYD YUHU
index of albanian forms YUHVKWD YU¬QG¬ YU¬U¬W YULJXOO YUXJ YXDM YXHM YXOOQHW YXUJ YXUNROODN \OEHU \OO \Q¬ \W ]â ]DEHO ]DEXD ]DEXH ]âM ]DMHYH ]DOO ]DQD ]DQ¬ ]EHM ]GUDM ]HW ]¬ ]¬M ]¬UD ]¬U¬ ]JDUE¬ ]JDY¬U ]JULG ]JMHGK¬
303
]JMXD ]JMXH ]JM\U¬ ]L ]LH ]LHM ]MDUP ]MDUPH ]MDUU ]MDUUH ]MHM ]MHUP ]MHUP¬ ]PRMOH ]RJ ]RJM ]RNWK ]RNWKD ]RQMD ]RQMH ]RQM¬ ]RUU¬ ]RW ]RWD ]RW¬U ]RW¬ULQM ]XO¬ ]YHUN ]YMHUGK ]YRUGKD ]KHJ ]KXPELQ¬ ]KXU ]K\V
,1'(;$7(5*2 JUDED GKHPED NULPED KXPED JMHUED N¬UED KXUED GDFD PMDOFD IHQGD EUHQGD ELQGD OLQGD WKLQGD PXQGD WXQGD G\QGD GKD NHGKD YLGKD KRGKD PEORGKD EURGKD GURGKD NURGKD WURGKD UURGKD YRGKD HUGKD SRUGKD ]YRUGKD SODID QMHID NUHID SUHID PVKHID QGLID PLID QMRID VKWURID VKWDJD QJD OLQJD EXQJD GLJMD
THQJMD GRJMD GRUJMD KD SODKD QMHKD NUHKD SUHKD IVKHKD QGLKD PLKD QMRKD VKWURKD PLD WK¬QLD WK¬ULD PDMD WXDMD HMD WXHMD YHMD GLOMD SLOOMD VLOOMD N¬UNRMD QGLTMD SLTMD YGLVMD MXMD ND SUHND ILND SLND KRND GDUND FHUND QGXND JU\ND KDOD çHOD NDOOD SDOOD N¬UVK¬QGHOOD JUHOOD KLV¬OOD
index a tergo KîV¬OOD Y¬OOD N¬VKLOOD PEROOD SROOD VROOD VKWROOD YROOD NRUEXOOD PRGKXOOD QRIXOOD PMHJXOOD QGULNXOOD QGU\VKNXOOD EUXVKWXOOD GROD PROD YROD XOD WXOD GHPD JULPD NDUPD NU\PD UU\PD QD JMDQD OODQD IVKDQD ]DQD THOEQD SLGKQD GKHQD HOE¬QD IODN¬QD LN¬QD EDU¬QD HU¬QD HVKW¬QD SOêKQD JGKLQD SULQD VKLQD YRMQD XMQD JMDNQD PLHOOQD
GKMDPQD JUDPQD HPQD GLPQD WRQD NU\SQD IUDTQD ERUQD OHVKQD P¬QGDIVKQD PLVKQD IVKDWQD VKWDWQD VKSLUWQD HVKWQD JLVKWQD PXWQD GMDWKQD GULWKQD K\QD P¬OOHQMD ]RQMD SD NDSD ODSD WUDSD NUHSD WKHSD URSD NDUSD NUXSD QGRTD KRTD SRTD VKTD DUD THOEUD GUD KXGKUD GKHUD JHUD OHUD JUHUD WHUD HOE¬UD SLGK¬UD JM¬UD
305
306 XM¬UD IODN¬UD OO¬UD GKMDP¬UD NULS¬UD EDU¬UD HU¬UD ERU¬UD VKSLUW¬UD JLVKW¬UD GMDWK¬UD GULWK¬UD ]¬UD JUD KDQJUD SOHKUD ELUD PLUD VKLUD YDMUD JMDNUD PMHNUD PLHOOUD JUDPUD HPUD GLPUD GRUD PRUD SRUD IUDTUD OHVKUD P¬QGDIVKUD PLVKUD WUD IVKDWUD VKWDWUD PRWUD HVKWUD PXWUD K\UD UUD DQGUUD ¬QGUUD EHUUD GHUUD VKTHUUD N¬UUD
index a tergo YLUUD ERUUD YGRUUD PRUUD SRUUD VKTRUUD VRUUD WRUUD YRUUD FXUUD TXUUD SODVD TDVD UUDVD EHVD QGHVD TRVD URVD ODSVD S¬UPE\VD YDVKD GHVKD JMHVKD WHVKD YHVKD ODIVKD N¬QGRIVKD LVKD JULVKD DWD PDWD XPDWD SDWD PEHWD JMHWD MHWD IMHWD THWD GLWD PLWD TLWD GULWD F¬ULWD QJULWD SULWD UULWD VKLWD
index a tergo QGDMWD QJDMWD JMDMWD PDMWD TXDMWD GUXDMWD EUHMWD UUHMWD OXHMWD TXHMWD ORMWD GURMWD EXMWD EûMWD U\MWD ERWD ]RWD çDUWD HVKWD YQHVKWD YUHVKWD QJXWD OXWD N¬SXWD WXWD U\WD NOLWKD ODNWKD VKWHNWKD ]RNWKD KDOWKD WKLPWKD NUDQWKD NDSWKD ELUWKD JXUWKD SXWKD ]DEXD GXD QGXD GUDJXD ]JMXD IDMNXD YDOONXD SDWNXD PXD NDSXD
JUXD YLUXD NUXD WRUXD S¬UUXD WXD NDWXD IWXD WKXD YD GDYD QGDYD JMDYD ODYD YUDYD WKDYD N¬UFHYD GKMHYD UHYD NUHYD SUHYD WKHYD PELYD JGKLYD NLYD SLYD ERYD JMRYD EORYD J¬ORYD QMRYD URYD GURYD NURYD VKNURYD JDWRYD QGH]D JMâ Nâ Oâ VKXOOâ GUâ ]â ODE NDOE
307
308 HOE THOE WKHOE GKDPE P¬NDPE VKNDPE GKHPE JMHPE WUHPE UUHPE GK¬PE P¬N¬PE VKN¬PE JO¬PE NULPE XPE KXPE NDOLKXPE VKNUXPE WKXPE VKT\PE JMHUE YHUE NRUE FXE EDF GDF HF VKN¬UGKHF QHPHF O¬SHF NRF N¬UF NDç UU¬PDç YLç PO\ç ]JULG JDQG NDQG QDQG NUDQG WDQG HQG
index a tergo GHQG JGKHQG IHQG OHQG PHQG NDODPHQG VKSHQG UHQG SRUHQG YHQG NXYHQG N¬QG P¬QG NU¬QG W¬QG ELQG OLQG SULQG WKLQG IXQG VKNXQG PXQG WXQG G\QG PDGK HGK JMHGK KHGK UUMHGK YMHGK NHGK OHGK PEOHGK EUHGK GUHGK NUHGK WUHGK ODWUHGK OLGK SLGK QJULGK YLGK ORGK PRGK PEURGK SURGK
index a tergo OEDUGK JDUGK ODUGK VKSDUGK GHUGK SMHUGK ]YMHUGK QJRUGK NRUGK EU\GK QJU\GK QDH EH UUDEH NROLEH GKDPEH GK¬PEH JDUEH NUDQGH WDQGH W¬QGH JMLQGH GKH JGKH SLGKH JDUGKH çHUGKH JMHUGKH KHUGKH GUXGKH IH UUXIH QJH DJMH EUHJMH VKWHJMH EULJMH VKWLJMH YLJMH GUDQJMH YDQJMH Y¬QJMH WRJMH YJMH KH EDKH
SRVWDKH ELH VKSLH VKWLH ]LH MH IDMH GMH KHMH PHMH WHMH KLMH KRMH SORMH NURMH Q\MH UU¬NH O¬EDUNH HVKNH OH ILDOH PHWDOH IOH NDçLOH PDQGLOH NDVKLOH ]PRMOH KHOOH EROOH NDçXOH JDPXOH WXOH PH HPH LPH KLPH UULPH NROPH ]MDUPH QH GK¬QH DW\QH ]RQMH GURH YRH SH NDSH
309
310 VTHSH WUHSH WKHSH IDTH JMDTH O¬PDTH OHTH RUWLTH N¬OERTH ORTH EDUTH WKDUTH WKLUTH GXVKTH UH FDUH NDOLYDUH GUH NDFDGUH N¬OTHUH P¬VKHUH YHUH IUH QJUH QJMLUH PLUH YLWRUH SUH WUH N¬VK\UH DW\UH ]MDUUH YDUUH VKNXUUH YLVH QXVH WULVKH ODPVKH SUXVKH WH VKHWH YHWH YHKWH SLWH YLWH NXOWH VRQWH
index a tergo MRWH PRWH LVKWH ODNVKWH HWKH ODNWKH NXUWKH ]DEXH GXH GUD Q JXH ]JMXH IDMNXH YDOONXH SDWNXH PXH NDSXH JUXH YLUXH NUXH WRUXH S¬UUXH NDWXH IWXH WKXH YH UHQGHYH ]DMHYH PDOHYH UULPHYH QHYH WUHSHYH MXYH T\H NU\H DUV\H UUH]H JGKê YJMê Kê IOê Sê GUê NDFDGUê IUê E¬UVKê DWê
index a tergo Yê VKNDE¬ JUDE¬ VKNUDE¬ N¬UUDE¬ UULE¬ EHOE¬ NXOE¬ GKDPE¬ NDPE¬ GK¬PE¬ N¬PE¬ JDUE¬ ]JDUE¬ YRUE¬ KXUE¬ OOXUE¬ NDçXE¬ JRUULF¬ SMDYLF¬ PMDOF¬ GURPF¬ Y¬UF¬ OXF¬ ç¬ DQG¬ NDQG¬ ODQG¬ UDQG¬ SHQG¬ ¬QG¬ N¬QG¬ O¬QG¬ U¬QG¬ YU¬QG¬ J¬UPDGK¬ YDGK¬ ]JMHGK¬ NHGK¬ JOHGK¬ JMLGK¬ OLGK¬ NURGK¬ YRGK¬ EDUGK¬ JDUGK¬
VKNDUGK¬ PDUGK¬ YHUGK¬ NRUGK¬ SRUGK¬ EXUGK¬ KXUGK¬ N¬SXUGK¬ XGK¬ UUXGK¬ TDI¬ NDODTDI¬ VKWURI¬ SODJ¬ VKWDJ¬ GHJ¬ GMHJ¬ IOHJ¬ GUHJ¬ VKWUHJ¬ ELJ¬ YHULJ¬ ERULJ¬ NDUULJ¬ EDMJ¬ JDMJ¬ EDOJ¬ GDQJ¬ NDQJ¬ PDQJ¬ UDQJ¬ WDQJ¬ EUHQJ¬ JMXYHQJ¬ N¬QJ¬ P¬QJ¬ OLQJ¬ RSLQJ¬ EDOOXQJ¬ VKW¬OOXQJ¬ VKWUXQJ¬ MDUJ¬ IOXJ¬ UUXJ¬ UDYJ¬ SL]J¬ SLOLSL]J¬
311
312 JM¬ THQJM¬ K¬ NRK¬ OORK¬ VKWURK¬ JMXK¬ JOXK¬ SOODM¬ PDM¬ UU¬VKDM¬ PXUWDM¬ ELVKWDM¬ YDM¬ êM¬ LM¬ ELM¬ VKN¬QGLM¬ OLM¬ PLM¬ I¬PLM¬ VKLM¬ VKWLM¬ W¬UIRM¬ JRM¬ QHYRM¬ XM¬ P\M¬ N¬ DN¬ KDN¬ ODN¬ IODN¬ PDN¬ E¬UUDN¬ UHN¬ EUHN¬ GUHN¬ NUHN¬ WKHN¬ GLN¬ P¬VKLN¬ IVKLN¬ WKLN¬ QR]LN¬ DMN¬ VKWDON¬
index a tergo S\ON¬ çLPN¬ TLPN¬ SU¬QMN¬ WKHURN¬ SURN¬ EDUN¬ GDUN¬ IDUN¬ VDUN¬ IXUN¬ DVKN¬ EDVKN¬ EMHVKN¬ SMHVKN¬ NROHVKN¬ EUHVKN¬ NUHVKN¬ GLVKN¬ ODUXVKN¬ O¬UXVKN¬ VKS¬QHWN¬ VKRUHWN¬ VKSUHWN¬ O¬SLWN¬ EXN¬ OOXN¬ EDUXN¬ VXN¬ PDWXN¬ P\N¬ JU\N¬ O¬ çDO¬ KDO¬ GMDO¬ IMDO¬ NDO¬ SDO¬ VKDO¬ YDO¬ IHO¬ SHO¬ XUHO¬ NDUDYHO¬ WU\HO¬ ELO¬
index a tergo OLO¬ PLO¬ EDOO¬ GKDOO¬ JMDOO¬ VKNDOO¬ SDOO¬ S¬UUDOO¬ SUUDOO¬ WDOO¬ VKWDOO¬ J¬VKWDOO¬ N¬VKWDOO¬ JREHOO¬ NDQGHOO¬ N¬QGHOO¬ JMHOO¬ N¬VKWMHOO¬ SHOO¬ JUHOO¬ WKHOO¬ P¬OO¬ UULOO¬ EROO¬ JMROO¬ NROO¬ PROO¬ WROO¬ PXOO¬ QXOO¬ SRVXOO¬ VKXOO¬ G\OO¬ N¬UUO¬ EXO¬ NXO¬ SXO¬ ]XO¬ UU\O¬ P¬ DP¬ GKDP¬ IDP¬ GKMDP¬ ODP¬ QDP¬ VDP¬
WDP¬ SHP¬ VKHP¬ ¬P¬ O¬P¬ Q¬P¬ ELP¬ SLP¬ EULP¬ JULP¬ N¬UNRMP¬ NROP¬ JRP¬ DUP¬ EDUP¬ NDUP¬ FHUP¬ WKMHUP¬ ]MHUP¬ N¬UP¬ JMXUP¬ VXUP¬ WXUP¬ GDVP¬ OLVP¬ GDUVP¬ JM\VP¬ NUHVKP¬ JMXP¬ OXP¬ EUXP¬ VKXP¬ EU\P¬ UU\P¬ DQ¬ EDQ¬ W¬EDQ¬ GKDQ¬ JMDQ¬ KDQ¬ MDQ¬ ODQ¬ OODQ¬ QDQ¬ UDQ¬ QJUDQ¬ VDQ¬
313
314 J¬UVKDQ¬ WDQ¬ WKDQ¬ ]DQ¬ GRU¬]DQ¬ MHQ¬ SHOHQ¬ THQ¬ NUHQ¬ WHQ¬ YHQ¬ GK¬Q¬ K¬Q¬ O¬Q¬ Q¬Q¬ VKS¬Q¬ T¬Q¬ U¬Q¬ QJU¬Q¬ WK¬Q¬ ]KXPELQ¬ O¬QGLQ¬ NUDKLQ¬ SLQ¬ EULQ¬ UU¬VKLQ¬ WLQ¬ N¬UNRMQ¬ N¬PERQ¬ MRQ¬ VRQ¬ WRQ¬ YRQ¬ LVKQ¬ XQ¬ GKXQ¬ JXQ¬ JUXQ¬ \Q¬ UUDQM¬ HQM¬ GHQM¬ P¬OOHQM¬ VKHQM¬ WHQM¬ J¬VKWHQM¬ G¬OO¬QM¬
index a tergo GU¬QM¬ UU¬QM¬ OLQM¬ G¬OOLQM¬ ITLQM¬ GULQM¬ WKLQM¬ SDOQM¬ JDERQM¬ PLVKNRQM¬ PXVKNRQM¬ ELORQM¬ EHURQM¬ ]RQM¬ XVKXQM¬ VKXVKXQM¬ DS¬ NDS¬ ODS¬ NOODS¬ QDS¬ J¬UMHS¬ JOHS¬ VKNOHS¬ UHS¬ NULS¬ UULS¬ JMDOS¬ ORS¬ VKTRS¬ NDUS¬ NUHVKS¬ SXS¬ NU\S¬ DU¬ IDU¬ JDU¬ ODU¬ SDU¬ WUDU¬ YUDU¬ VKDU¬ HU¬ GHU¬ JMHU¬ KHU¬ EMHU ¬
index a tergo PMHU¬ OHU¬ EOHU¬ OXTHU¬ JUHU¬ NUHU¬ WUHU¬ VHU¬ WHU¬ YHU¬ SUDQGYHU¬ SU¬QGYHU¬ E¬U¬ OO¬U¬ U¬U¬ J¬UVK¬U¬ W¬U¬ ]¬U¬ LU¬ ELU¬ GKLU¬ JXQ¬GKLU¬ PLU¬ SLU¬ UU¬SLU¬ EULU¬ W¬UVLU¬ P¬VKLU¬ UU¬VKLU¬ Y¬VKWLU¬ ERU¬ N¬PERU¬ GRU¬ NRU¬ EORU¬ NXQRU¬ NXURU¬ XU¬ GKDQGXU¬ GK¬QGXU¬ JXU¬ EOHKXU¬ O¬NXU¬ JUXU¬ XQG\U¬ ]JM\U¬ ODW\U¬
QDW\U¬ GHW\U¬ OLNW\U¬ JM\PW\U¬ OHSW\U¬ I\W\U¬ DUU¬ EDUU¬ NDUU¬ VKDUU¬ IHUU¬ PDQDIHUU¬ WKMHUU¬ P¬VKTHUU¬ YHUU¬ KLUU¬ VRUU¬ ]RUU¬ EXUU¬ IXUU¬ NXUU¬ SXUU¬ G¬UUDV¬ EHV¬ PEHV¬ SMHV¬ VKNOHV¬ PHV¬ SLOLYRHV¬ SHV¬ P¬NUHV¬ J¬UUHV¬ PDUWHV¬ SLOLYHV¬ SêV¬ JM\P ¬ V¬ GRV¬ JRV¬ URV¬ GMHUV¬ THUV¬ Y¬UV¬ VKNRUV¬ JM\V¬ GKDVK¬ ODVK¬ SDVK¬
315
316 UDVK¬ WUDVK¬ WKDVK¬ YDVK¬ HVK¬ MHVK¬ PHVK¬ SHVK¬ THVK¬ WHVK¬ YHVK¬ NDIVK¬ ODIVK¬ JULIVK¬ NRIVK¬ LVK¬ ELVK¬ NLVK¬ SLVK¬ TLVK¬ PRVK¬ JURVK¬ YMHUVK¬ P¬UVK¬ IXVK¬ NDQXVK¬ O¬SXVK¬ JM\VK¬ W¬ DW¬ GKDW¬ JDW¬ O¬JDW¬ OLJDW¬ O¬QJDW¬ JMDW¬ ODW¬ EODW¬ JODW¬ QDW¬ UDW¬ JU¬P¬UDW¬ VKWDW¬ VK¬QJMHW¬ MHW¬ GKMHW¬ QM¬PE¬GKMHW¬
index a tergo G\PE¬GKMHW¬ WULGKMHW¬ O¬SMHW¬ U¬SMHW¬ S¬USMHW¬ UUMHW¬ EOHW¬ IOHW¬ QHW¬ SHW¬ THW¬ WHW¬ MHVK¬W¬ DIW¬ WURIW¬ OXIW¬ SXIW¬ OHKW¬ FLW¬ GLW¬ PLW¬ UDTLW¬ DUTLW¬ GULW¬ VLW¬ PDMW¬ PâMW¬ GUHMW¬ YREHNW¬ EDOW¬ GDOW¬ PMDOW¬ GKDOOW¬ HPW¬ FHPW¬ LPW¬ Q¬QW¬ VKWUHQMW¬ VKHQMW¬ ERW¬ SORW¬ WHUSORW¬ UURW¬ VKRW¬ WKRW¬ TDUW¬ EOHUW¬
index a tergo IRUW¬ PDUUW¬ DVKW¬ JDVKW¬ JMDVKW¬ MDVKW¬ NDVKW¬ ODVKW¬ HVKW¬ GHVKW¬ KHVKW¬ WKMHVKW¬ YMHVKW¬ EUHVKW¬ ¬VKW¬ ODJVKW¬ GLVKW¬ EOLVKW¬ XOLVKW¬ SRVKW¬ W¬USRVKW¬ GMDWKW¬ EXW¬ JXW¬ NXNXW¬ NDUUXW¬ N¬UUXW¬ VXW¬ G\W¬ EDWK¬ GMDWK¬ JUDWK¬ WUDWK¬ UUDWK¬ YHWK¬ Y¬WK¬ JMLWK¬ GULWK¬ XULWK¬ EULUWK¬ O\WK¬ V\WK¬ MDY¬ UDY¬ JUDY¬ SUHY¬ ]¬
J¬OED]¬ JMD]¬ PLHOOD]¬ PD]¬ O¬PD]¬ XQD]¬ VKWD]¬ UXD]¬ VKWâ]¬ NH]¬ OH]¬ P¬OOH]¬ VKSH]¬ VKTH]¬ WK¬OO¬]¬ DQ¬]¬ KDQ¬]¬ DUU¬]¬ VKW¬]¬ PL]¬ GUL]¬ QGUL]¬ YDM]¬ SHM]¬ XO]¬ OHP]¬ JUHQ]¬ PXVKOOLQ]¬ VKN¬OER]¬ VKNR]¬ EOR]¬ YHU]¬ O¬YRU]¬ EX]¬ VKSX]¬ SODI JUDI PçHI OHI PHI QMHI NUHI SUHI PVKHI QGLI
317
318 PLI VKSLI QMRI QJURI VKRI IWRI DJ ODJ UUDJ VKDJ GMHJ EUHJ WUHJ VKWHJ ]KHJ OLJ VKHOJ SHOOJ DQJ GUDQJ VKWDQJ YDQJ SOHQJ SHQJ Y¬QJ EXQJ PXQJ WUXQJ EXOORJ SORJ WRJ ]RJ YDUJ PXUJ YXUJ OXJ PXJ YUXJ PX]J UHJM UUHJM OLJM JULJM THQJM XQJM
index a tergo ]RJM GHUJM OXJM DK JMDK SODK SDK JUDK NUDK UUDK HK GHK OHK SOHK PHK QMHK JUHK NUHK VKNUHK SUHK VKSUHK IVKHK SOêK QGLK PLK VKSLK JULK QMRK QJURK VKRK IWRK DL PEL S¬UPEL HFL GL RUHQGL SHU¬QGL GKL OLGKL JML PDQJML P¬QJML KL MXML
index a tergo OL PDOL EOL IOL NDOOL XOOL PXOOL GROL PL JM\VDPL GHPL MHPL KDUP L QL OLGKQL JRM¬OLGKQL MHQL WK¬QL GLJMQL GLOQL SLOOQL VLOOQL N¬UNRQL SLTQL YGLVQL OLGKXQL SL NDSL WUDSL TLSL K\SL YGLTL IXTL UL DUL EDUL EUL GHUL QMHUL NXVK¬UL WK¬UL NUL PRUL XUL SLOLNXUL Y¬UUL VKL
SUXVKL WL DWL EDJ¬WL O¬WL PEXILWL OXKLWL WURNLWL VS¬UNLWL QJULWL EDNWL ORWL WKL ODMWKL ]L GLW¬]L JMî Kî Oî EOî IOî VK¬OOî XOOî PXOOî Pî Uî EUî NXVK¬Uî NUî Y¬UUî VKî O¬Wî PEDM çDM GDM QGDM IDM QJDM JMDM ODM PDM TDM PDUDM ]GUDM DVDM
319
320 WKDM EXDM GXDM JXDM JMXDM KXDM MXDM OXDM EOXDM PXDM TXDM VKTXDM UXDM GUXDM NUXDM VKNUXDM WXDM JDWXDM YXDM YDM âM EâM QGâM IâM SXJâM OâM PâM IVKâM ]âM VKN¬PEHM UU¬PEHM VK¬UEHM ]EHM N¬UFHM GHM QGHM JMHM PDOO¬QJMHM UU¬QJMHM GLHM ]LHM QGMHM I¬MHM YMHM ]MHM OHM EOHM
index a tergo QG¬OHM VKHPE¬OOHM S¬OTHM EUHM VKS¬UHM VK¬IUHM VKXIUHM NUHM UUHM XUUHM WXUVKHM EXHM GXHM JMXHM KXHM MXHM OXHM EOXHM PXHM TXHM VKTXHM UXHM GUXHM NUXHM VKNUXHM WXHM JDWXHM YXHM YHM QG\HM K\HM O\HM Q\HM VKT\HM U\HM IU\HM VKNU\HM J¬UU\HM WK\HM QG¬U]HM P¬U]HM QGêM JMêM EUêM UUêM ¬M E¬M
index a tergo HF¬M S¬J¬M LN¬M KLS ¬M ]¬M ELM PELM VNXQGLM JGKLM J¬UGKLM P¬UGKLM QJLM NLM VK¬OOLM SLM O¬SLM PSLM TLM ULM F¬ULM JULM SULM VKWULM DUULM VKLM DWLM YLM PEîM JGKîM QJîM PSîM JUîM SUîM ERM VK¬OERM PDOFRM çRM JXOçRM SHQGRM N¬QGRM SHU¬QGRM NXQGRM VXQGRM SURGKRM VKNDJRM WUDVK¬JRM GUDQJRM
O¬QJRM P¬QJRM VKWU¬QJRM NXQJRM PXQJRM UXQJRM I¬UJRM P¬UJRM S¬UJMRM QJXMRM EHNRM VKWHNRM G¬NRM QGLNRM PDOONRM VKNDUNRM I¬UNRM N¬UNRM VKNRM VKXUXNRM JM\NRM PEORM J¬ORM NDOORM NXOORM PEXORM çPRM JM¬PRM KDUPRM KHUPRM G¬VKPRM SURVKPRM SUR]KPRM DJM¬QRM DUQRM NXQMRM VKTHSRM VKTLSRM TRM PEDURM ODURM ORGURM DJM¬URM QJM¬URM Q¬P¬URM Q\W¬URM G¬OLURM
321
322 G¬VKLURM NDSURM XURM GXURM GKXURM DGKXURM IOXWXURM UURM NDFDUURM KDUURM QG¬UURM VKW¬UURM QJXUURM P¬VRM S¬VRM O¬VKRM P¬VKRM NDIVKRM KHWRM G¬IWRM O¬IWRM SDMWRM WUDMWRM NXMWRM JXOWRM SUHPWRM QRWRM VKDUWRM VKWRM XVKWRM WKRM YRM U¬Q[RM SDJ¬]RM PL]RM O¬YRU]RM EXM UUREXM THIXM HKXM NXM VXNXM OHSXM SRSXM WLWXM DYXM EûM
index a tergo XVKûM QG\M K\M N\ M U\M IU\M J¬UçDN GDN JDN JMDN MDN VKNDN ODN IODN YXUNROODN SODN OXPDN SDN SDVKWUDN KHN QGMHN PMHN SMHN PHN THN JUHN VKWUHN UUHN RUWHN WKHN LN ILN OLN PLN DQ¬PLN DUPLN SLN IXUULN XMN EXMN EXON IORN WDURN KDUURN VKRN DUN
index a tergo EDUN KDUN TDUN VKDUN WKDUN EHUN FHUN GHUN ]YHUN VKHP¬UN W¬UIXUN ELVN EULVN UU¬IHVKN SHVKN XSHVKN GXVKN PXVKN GUXVKN NUXVKN P\VKN GU\VKN SHWN EUHWN QGXN VKDUDQGXN QXN TXN GDO UDJDO VKNDO PDO GXDO KDUDEHO ]DEHO çHO NDçHO GHO JMHO NDFDJMHO NDQJMHO GMHO PMHO YMHO S¬UYMHO VKNHO
PHO THO NUHO I¬QG\HO DPE¬O WDPE¬O ¬PE¬O W¬PE¬O WKQHJ¬O KLQJ¬O YRJ¬O TLN¬O EXN¬O WK¬QXN¬O OLO F¬ULO KDOO GMDOO NDOO PDOO SDOO VKSDOO S¬UUDOO WDOO EXDOO JXDOO KXDOO NDSUXDOO ]DOO GHOO KHOO GLHOO PLHOO TLHOO PEMHOO SMHOO VMHOO VKWMHOO Y¬VKWMHOO YMHOO THOO S¬UTHOO EXHOO KXHOO NDSUXHOO I¬QG\HOO
323
324 I\HOO Q\HOO HJM¬OO HQJM¬OO HV¬OO KLV¬OO KîV¬OO VNXQGLOO WK¬QJMLOO XQJMLOO PLOO N¬UPLOO P¬QMLOO JULOO SULOO N¬VKLOO UUDVROO UUXPEXOO VXPEXOO WKXPEXOO UUREXOO NRUEXOO SHQGXOO PRGKXOO THIXOO QRIXOO PMHJXOO WMHJXOO UUHJXOO YULJXOO NXQJXOO JDUJXOO SMHUJXOO PXJXOO SL]JXOO HKXOO JUHKXOO PUHNXOO VKHNXOO QGULNXOO NUURNXOO PDVKNXOO UUXVKNXOO QGU\VKNXOO VXNXOO DPXOO IDPXOO
index a tergo KDPXOO NUHSXOO SRSXOO TXOO LVKXOO NXVKXOO VKSDWXOO WLWXOO EUXVKWXOO XWKXOO DYXOO \OO PE\OO I\OO K\OO P\OO S\OO RUUO XO QJXO S¬UNXO VKNXO WXO T\O E¬UU\O N¬UW\O GDP MDP NDP EUDP JUDP HP çHP GHP KLGKHP OLGKHP JMHP PHKHP MHP GMHP NHP QGXONHP ILVKNHP I\VKNHP VWHSHP THP
index a tergo PNHTHP UUHP N¬UYHVKHP YHWHP YHQLWHP SXQXHP EDOç¬P PHQç¬P G¬P EDJ¬P PHQGVK¬P MHVK¬P DUV\HVK¬P IXTLVK¬P EDOVK¬P LP WULP LVKLP JMDOP SMDOP KHOP GMHOP NXOP WKRP ]MDUP MHUP ]MHUP WHUP NDOLKXP OXP UUXP NDFDUUXP NU\P W\P QGDQ ODQ PDQ NDODPDQ OLGKHQ JMHQ U¬PHQ THQ EUHQ N¬VHQ OHE¬Q JMHOE¬Q
DUE¬Q NHç¬Q SULQG¬Q XUGK¬Q YRUI¬Q SUHK¬Q ODN¬Q P¬VKWHN¬Q PRN¬Q KDO¬Q HP¬Q IHP¬Q GLP¬Q WLP¬Q GUDS¬Q SMHS¬Q QLS¬Q NXOS¬Q JMDUS¬Q GUHT¬Q UULT¬Q XMT¬Q ULV¬Q IUDVK¬Q EUHVK¬Q JM\VK¬Q DW¬Q HW¬Q NXQHW¬Q PEUHW¬Q VKWUHW¬Q N¬VKW¬Q Y¬OOD]¬Q YLUJMLQ PDOLQ SHOLQ LVKLQ ERQ N¬UNRQ OLGKXQ SLPXQ SDVXQ TDQM P¬GKHQM ODPHQM O¬PHQM
325
326 OXPHQM WUHQM S¬UUHQM SO¬I¬QM ODP¬QM G¬US¬QM NRFLQM EOLQM PLQM N¬UPLQM GUDSLQM VWDSLQM EULQM ]RW¬ULQM XULQM SULIWLQM ERVKWLQM YLQM GUDJRQM IDMNRQM JMLQRQM NDSRQM NURQM S¬UURQM NDWRQM WKRQM KXQM NXQM DFR NMR QHQR DVR DWR IDWR DS KDS MDS NDS ODS OODS VTDS WUDS VKWUDS YUDS VKDS
index a tergo VWDS UMHS NHS VKNHS SOHS THS VTHS JUHS NUHS VKNUHS VKWUHS WKHS J¬WKHS QLS UULS VKWDOS NXOS NDQS VKNRS SHVKNRS N¬US WXUS FXS OOXS NUXS NDUUXS VXS O\S UU\S N¬QDT SDT VTDT IUDT KHT W¬UKHT NHT OHT SOHT GUHT YGLT OLT SOLT SLT LULT SRUULT IXUULT
index a tergo XMT KHOT SHOT THOT JORT VKRT WKDUT NXPHUT ELUT GLUT SHVKT SLVKT NXT ODNXT SXT NU\T DU EDU PEDU DFDU SHQGDU XJDU ODU NXODU OLITDU WDIWDU GXDU SXQXDU YDU \OEHU JHU JMHU Y¬QHU QMHU OLITHU YUHU WHU OWHU WKHU GXHU IUXHU G\HU PXVKN¬OO\HU SXOT\HU OHE¬U VKWDOE¬U
JMHOE¬U EXOE¬U VHPE¬U WKHPE¬U DUE¬U YHUE¬U NHç¬U EDG¬U WKDG¬U YHG¬U çDQG¬U GKDQG¬U JMDQG¬U WODQG¬U GK¬QG¬U JM¬QG¬U SULQG¬U NXQG¬U ORG¬U EDGK¬U PMHGK¬U XUGK¬U VKXUGK¬U KXGK¬U DI¬U YDUI¬U JM¬U HJM¬U YLUJM¬U SUHK¬U ODN¬U PMHN¬U P¬VKWHN¬U PRN¬U HP¬U IHP¬U VKHP¬U U¬P¬U GLP¬U WLP¬U S¬U GUDS¬U SMHS¬U OHS¬U YHS¬U QLS¬U NXOS¬U
327
328 JMDUS¬U WKXS¬U GUHT¬U UULT¬U XMT¬U QHV¬U ULV¬U IUDVK¬U EUHVK¬U JM\VK¬U NDW¬U YDW¬U HW¬U MHW¬U WMHW¬U YMHW¬U NHW¬U NXQHW¬U PEUHW¬U VKWUHW¬U SLW¬U NDOW¬U NXOW¬U NXPW¬U PRW¬U YRW¬U ]RW¬U P¬JDVKW¬U JMHVKW¬U PMHVKW¬U N¬VKW¬U NXOORVKW¬U QRVKW¬U YRVKW¬U EXVKW¬U ]JDY¬U YDY¬U Y¬OOH]¬U ELU KLU G¬OLU VKWLU KDUP¬VKRU XU VTXIXU VKTXIXU JXU
index a tergo ODNXU EXNXU OHSXU SDVXU VKXU WKXU ]KXU T\U N¬T\U VKW\U KDUU ]MDUU PDUU VKSDUU TDUU VKTDUU PXDUU YDUU HUU EHUU GHUU IHUU EMHUU çMHUU GMHUU YGMHUU S¬UPMHUU SMHUU WMHUU YMHUU WPHUU VKSHUU THUU VKTHUU YHUU DQG¬UU NDQG¬UU ¬QG¬UU DQJ¬UU YMHK¬UU N¬UU PDN¬UU KLN¬UU WKLUU RERUU KRUU
index a tergo NRUU PRUU VKSRUU VKRUU FXUU IXUU V
PEDV S¬OFDV N¬UFDV EXçDV JRGDV PEXIDV QJDV GLKDV J¬UKDV OXKDV QXKDV WURNDV NDUNDV S¬UNDV SLVNDV VKNDV IODV YLODV N¬OODV S¬OODV SODV PDV XPDV SDV TDV WUDV YUDV UUDV VKW¬UUDV Y¬UUDV J¬UVKDV KLWDV E¬UWDV N¬OWKDV PEHV QGHV YGHV MHV GKMHV
VKNPHV SUHV WUHV VKHV YHV S\HV JUDELV UDGLV YDGLV JMH]GLV QJMLV NUDKLV PROLV SOLV PLV QLV SRQLV TLV ULV QHYHULV P¬UP¬ULV WXULV UULV JDUULV OHEHWLV VW¬UYLV NRV PRV TRV ODSV çDUV PDUV IXV JXV QJXV OXV QXV SXV N¬SXV WXV PE\V S¬UPE\V U\V QJU\V WU\V ]K\V
329
330 GDVK SDVK HVK GKDPEHVK GK¬PEHVK GHVK QGHVK OLGKHVK JDUGKHVK JMHVK QJMHVK MHVK OHVK GUHGKDOHVK NDOHVK KHOOHVK N¬UOHVK GHPHVK QHVK WUDSHVK OXSHVK THVK SUHVK VKHVK SUXVKHVK YHVK NDODYHVK NDUUDYHVK OLGK¬VK DUJ¬VK P¬QGDIVK LVK DFLVK SOLVK PLVK JULVK SULVK DVLVK PHNVK ODPVK JDODPVK O¬PVK DFRVK VK¬QGRVK MRVK P¬UNRVK U¬SRVK
index a tergo S¬USRVK DVRVK VKRVK EXVK MXVK NXVK SXVK S¬USXVK SUXVK UUXVK JM\VK N¬O\VK PO\VK DW IDW P¬NDW PDW NXQDW VKSDW VKWUDW VKDW IVKDW VKWDW HW GHW OLGKHW PEXIHW QJHW ERKHW OXKHW YMHW VLYMHW WURNHW VS¬UNHW PDOHW IOHW W¬UPHW QHW YXOOQHW NDVKQMHW PEUHW VKNRUUHW E¬UWHW PE¬VKWHW SXVKWHW T\WHW
index a tergo KDODYH W ]HW G\]HW WKDUE¬W KLGK¬W GU\GK¬W PHN¬W IODVKN¬W YUDQ¬W YU¬U¬W PXUU¬W DWK¬W XWK¬W WDIW TLIW SULIW GLW VRGLW PDOLW NDFDPLW VK¬QGULW UULW SRURVLW LVKLW VK¬WLW PRWLW Y¬UWLW YLW Y¬UYLW Q[LW NXMW NRW ORW PRW VRW ]RW PEDUW VKSLUW NXUW DVKW UUDVKW âVKW YêVKW NOXP¬VKW TXP¬VKW Y¬VKW ELVKW
NDELVKW NDUUDELVKW N¬UELVKW JLVKW ERVKW NRSVKW JXVKW PXVKW JUXVKW XW EXW QJXW KXW PDNXW OXW PXW WXW \W I\W O¬I\W VKT\W U\W IU\W PEDWK JUDWK WUDWK JMHWK THWK UUHWK YHWK Y¬WK LWK XULWK P]LWK ODNWK VKWHNWK ]RNWK KDOWK WKLPWK NUDQWK NDSWK ELUWK EULUWK JXUWK NXUWK SXUWK
331
332 XWK SXWK O\WK V\WK X JMX KX OLGKQLX VKLX MX JMDNX SODNX OX UX GUX WUX JMû Kû GUû WUû D\ G\ V\ JD] JUHUD]
index a tergo YDUUD] YDVKD] Pâ] QGH] GKH] OH] EUH] YH] YH¬] HUJM¬] LM¬] ELM¬] JMHOO¬] P¬] DP¬] GMHOP¬] OO¬QM¬] WKRQM¬] QMHU¬] JUHU¬] YDVK¬] YHVK¬] PLW¬] SDUUL] NXUUL] PXUUL] OR] EUX]
