Shintaro Okazaki (Ed.) Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2)
GABLER RESEARCH European Advertising Academy Executi...
88 downloads
4132 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Shintaro Okazaki (Ed.) Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2)
GABLER RESEARCH European Advertising Academy Executive Board Members: Sandra Diehl, University of Klagenfurt Robert Heath, University of Bath Tobias Langner, University of Wuppertal Peter Neijens, University of Amsterdam Shintaro Okazaki, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid Patrick de Pelsmacker, University of Antwerp Edith Smit, University of Amsterdam Ralf Terlutter, University of Klagenfurt
The objective of the European Advertising Academy (EAA) is to provide a professional association to academics and practitioners interested in advertising and its applications that will promote, disseminate and stimulate high quality research in the field.
Shintaro Okazaki (Ed.)
Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2) Breaking New Ground in Theory and Practice
RESEARCH
Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de.
1st Edition 2011 All rights reserved © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011 Editorial Office: Ute Wrasmann | Nicole Schweitzer Gabler Verlag is a brand of Springer Fachmedien. Springer Fachmedien is part of Springer Science+Business Media. www.gabler.de No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the copyright holder. Registered and/or industrial names, trade names, trade descriptions etc. cited in this publication are part of the law for trade-mark protection and may not be used free in any form or by any means even if this is not specifically marked. Umschlaggestaltung: KünkelLopka Medienentwicklung, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper Printed in Germany ISBN 978-3-8349-3134-4
Preface
It is my great pleasure to present Advances in Advertising Research Vol. II— Breaking new ground in Theory and Practice, published by the European Advertising Academy (EAA). This volume consists of extended versions of papers presented at the 9th ICORIA (International Conference on Research in Advertising) held at Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain, from June 24-26, 2010. The conference was sponsored by the European Advertising Academy. The editor served as chairperson of the conference. The authors of this book chose the papers, which examine a wide-ranging view of issues that address how we can understand advertising and its role in our society. Both distinguished and junior scholars from around the globe contributed to this book. As the subtitle indicates, the book is intended to provide a unique opportunity to stimulate and generate new ideas in a diverse range of research topics. I believe that such efforts will help us, both directly and indirectly, to guide the future research of both present and emerging advertising scholars. The book has five sections. Part 1 examines one of the hottest topics, product placement and gaming; Part II addresses generational issues in advertising; Part III examines the interaction between social issues and advertising; Part IV examines issues related to corporate organization, publicity and reputation; Part V explores branding issues in advertising; Part VI explains the roles of media and agency; and, finally, Part VII scrutinizes advertising content, appeals and execution. All these chapters consider cutting-edge issues that offer important insights that advance our knowledge. This book would never have been possible without the willingness of the contributors who traveled to Madrid to participate in the 9th ICORIA, and later agreed to make generous extensions and refinements of their work. I owe them a great deal of gratitude, for making this volume so exceptional. I would like to thank the Yoshida Hideo Memorial Foundation (Tokyo, Japan) for their generous financial support of the publication of this book. A special mention of appreciation must go to the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (National Plan for Research, Development and Innovation EC02008-
VI
Preface
01557), Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, and the KDDI Foundation (Tokyo, Japan), for their financial support for the 9th ICORIA. I am also indebted to my colleagues, Sara Campo, Javier Oubiña, and Natalia Rubio for their superb job of planning, coordinating, and implementing the numerous tasks that made the conference successful. Finally, my grateful appreciation goes also to my student employee, Anne Schmitz, who compiled and formatted the chapters. I strongly hope this volume will prove to be a useful, enjoyable, and stimulating reference for academics, practitioners, and graduate students in this field.
Shintaro Okazaki Editor Madrid, April 2011
The European Advertising Academy (EAA)
The objective of the European Advertising Academy (EAA) is to provide a professional association to academics and practitioners interested in advertising and its applications that will promote, disseminate and stimulate high quality research in the field. The association particularly serves as a meeting and communication forum for its members. It offers a network for the exchange of knowledge on an international level and constitutes a framework allowing for a better dissemination of information on research and teaching. The EAA is closely related to the yearly International Conference on Research in Advertising (ICORIA). The purpose of this conference is to create a forum where people studying advertising in the academic world could exchange ideas, and where they could meet with practitioners who have experience with advertising in the commercial world. Every natural person that I professionally concerned with or interested in research or teaching in the field of advertising is, irrespective of nationality, eligible to become a full member of the organization. The EAA was founded in 2005. The current board members are: Peter Neigens (president, University of Amsterdam), Ralf Terlutter (president elect, University of Klagenfurt), Sandra Diehl (treasurer, University of Klagenfurt), Robert Heath (School of Management, Bath), Shintaro Okazaki (Autonomous University of Madrid), Patrick De Pelsmacker (University of Antwerp), Edith Smit (information manager, University of Amsterdam) and Tobias Langner (University of Wuppertal).
For further information please visit our website: www.icoria.org
Table of Contents
Preface
I.
Product Placement and Gaming Enrique Bigné, Inés Küster, Asunción Hernández, Torpong Suemanotham and Natalia Vila Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy: An Attempt to Analysis in Disney Company
II.
VI
3
Yves Van Vaerenbergh, Dieneke Van de Sompel, Neal Van Loock and Iris Vermeir The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes: Does the Attitude toward the Artist Matter?
21
Martin K. J. Waiguny and Ralf Terlutter Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
35
Social Issues and Advertising Martine Lewi and Patrick De Pelsmacker Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
55
X
III.
Contents
Nieves García de Frutos and José Manuel Ortega Egea Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behavior Aimed at Fighting Climate Change: Main and Moderating Effects
75
María José Miquel-Romero and Franco Manuel Sancho-Esper The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption: Affective Responses and Advertising Effectiveness
91
Erlinde Cornelis, Leen Adams and Verolien Cauberghe The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages for a Fair Trade Campaign
107
Marlize Terblanche-Smit and Nic S. Terblanche The Impact of Personality Differences on Efficacy, Attitude and Behavioural Intention in HIV/AIDS Fear Appeal Advertising
119
Generation Katarina Panic, Verolien Cauberghe and Delphine Verhoye The (B)old and the Beautiful: Investigating the Preference of Senior Consumers Concerning (the Age of) Models Used in Advertising
133
Julia Spielvogel and Ralf Terlutter Children’s Advertising Literacy: Do BMI, Body Shape Perception, Self-Esteem and TV Exposure Matter?
145
XI
Contents
Andrea Leopold and Sandra Diehl The Relevance of Life Changing Situations for Media Usage and their Relevance as a Segmentation Strategy for Media Companies and Advertisers
IV.
V.
161
Social Interaction and Advertising Shu-Chuan Chu and Sara Kamal An Investigation of Social Media Usage, Brand Consciousness, and Purchase Intention towards Luxury Products among Millennials
179
Rafael Currás-Pérez, María José Miquel-Romero, Carla Ruiz-Mafé and Silvia Sanz-Blas The Role of Parasocial Interaction and Teleparticipation on Teleshopping Behavior
191
Manuela Lopez and Maria Sicilia The Impact of e-WOM: Determinants of Influence
215
Shintaro Okazaki and María Ángeles NavarroBailón Who’s Afraid of Ubiquitous Promotion? Exploring the Effects of Privacy Concerns
231
Organization, Publicity and Reputation An-Sofie Claeys, Verolien Cauberghe and Patrick Vyncke Determinants of the Impact of Crises on Organizational Reputation: An Experimental Test of Crisis Communication Strategies and the Moderating Impact of Locus of Control
247
XII
VI.
Contents
Luisa Andreu, Anna S. Mattila and Joaquin Aldás Effects of Message Appeal when Communicating CSR Initiatives
261
Martin Eisend and Franziska Küster The Effectiveness of Publicity versus Advertising: A Meta-Analysis
277
Branding Sophie C. Boerman, Edith G. Smit and Lex van Meurs Attention Battle; the Abilities of Brand, Visual, and Text Characteristics of the Ad to Draw Attention versus the Diverting Power of the Direct Magazine Context
295
Marieke L. Fransen and Thomas J. L. Van Rompay Living Brands: Consumer Reactions toward Online Experienced-based Marketing Communication
311
María Ángeles Navarro-Bailón What is the best Communication Strategy (Integration vs. Repetition) to persuade Consumers? An Analysis across Levels of Brand Familiarity
325
Nathalie Dens, Patrick De Pelsmacker and Bianca Puttemans Text or Pictures? Effectiveness of Verbal Information and Visual Cues in Advertisements for New Brands versus Extensions
341
XIII
Contents
VII.
VIII.
Media and Agency Sheila Sasser, Scott Koslow and Mark Kilgour Assessing the Quality of Self-reported Measures and the Reliability of Empirical Findings: Exploring Creativity Differences across Worldwide Agency Creatives and Managers
359
Charles R. Taylor and George R. Franke Public Opinion towards Digital Billboards in the United States: An Analysis of Recent Polls
373
Edward C. Malthouse and Don Schultz The Response Surface Process for Optimal Allocation of Media Budgets
393
Shintaro Okazaki, Morikazu Hirose and Hairong Li QR Code Mobile Promotion: An Initial Inquiry
405
Advertising Content, Appeals and Execution Lotte M. Willemsen, Peter C. Neijens and Fred E. Bronner Perceived Expertise vs. Perceived Trustworthiness: The Suppressed Effect of Source Type on Review Attitude
423
Günther Silberer, Sascha Steinmann, Inga Blohm and Julia Vetter A Study on the Impact of TV Advertising Contacts During Dinner
437
XIV
Contents
Tobias Langner and Martin Eisend Effects of Celebrity Endorsers’ Attractiveness and Expertise on Brand Recall of Transformational and Informational Products
451
Sandra Diehl, Shintaro Okazaki, and Barbara Mueller A Procedure for the Development of Fictitious Advertisements in Multi-country Research: Crafting Messages with Hard-sell and Soft-sell Appeals
461
Ioannis G. Theodorakis and Christos Koritos Figuratively Bleeding or Just Bleeding? Exploring Consumers’ Personal Values and Emotions within Simple and Rhetorically Constructed Violent Ad Contexts!
473
Part I
Product Placement and Gaming
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy: An Attempt to Analysis in Disney Company
Enrique Bigné, University of Valencia, Spain Inés Küster, University of Valencia, Spain Asunción Hernández, University of Valencia, Spain Torpong Suemanotham, University of Valencia. Spain Natalia Vila, University of Valencia, Spain
1
Introduction
What is the best marketing strategy in video games? The literature is not unanimous in upholding the best strategy. Researchers investigating advertising effectiveness disagree on the value of product placement in video games and the methods firms should use with product placement strategies. The state of the question now must figure out the dichotomy between two perspectives: to identify the differences in the effectiveness of product placement in video games when using “traditional placement approaches” compared to the “branded entertainment approach”. The “traditional approach” to product placement in video games involves the product appearing as a visual object that is passive, used by characters and players or mentioned in the audio, which functions as an advertisement for the product (Shrum, 2004). The “branded entertainment approach” to product placement in video games involves integrating a proprietary character into the theme or plot, with the branded product anthropomorphised (Winkler and Buckner, 2006). “Branded entertainment” differs from the “traditional approach” because the plot of the entertainment is fully focused on the branded product. Because of the growth in popularity of video games, advertisers are increasingly attracted to the medium as a means of reaching targeted age demographics that include children, young adults and adults between the ages of 18 and 34. Advertising expenditures for product placement in video games is forecasted at $733 million by 2010, with the majority of the advertising aimed at the target market of adult males who are the most common users of video games (Gerdes, 2006).
S. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_1, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
4
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
Nevertheless, while advertisers are increasingly attracted to video games, the effectiveness of the medium and placement strategy remains uncertain. Also, even some evidence suggests that product placement in video games can increase brand and product awareness, previous results support that theses kind of product placement strategies are not useful to motivate the final purchasing the product (Nelson et al., 2004; Winkler and Buckner, 2006). The general attitude of the consumer toward advertising may also influence the effectiveness of product placement in video games (Beirne, 2008). In addition, the effectiveness of “branded entertainment approaches” to developing video game content used by the large multimedia firms, has not been extensively investigated (Winkler and Buckner, 2006). However, and despite what is mentioned in the preceding paragraph, we can assert that the way in which the placement occurs in a video game may be more critical for achieving the desired outcomes of increased awareness and motivating purchase decisions than with product placement in other types of media. The case study will focus on the Walt Disney Corporation (Disney), which uses product cycling in branded entertainment types of video games. Disney was selected for the case study because it has created numerous proprietary characters that can be considered product franchises because the characters appear in many different media and types of products. Because of the increased popularity in video games, Disney has also produced video games incorporating these characters. The product placement strategy of the firm in its video games is part of its integrated advertising and marketing strategy (Gilbert, 2005). So, the research design used a case study approach, which is suitable for investigating research questions intended to provide exploratory or descriptive information about a topic (Yin, 2003). The purpose of this research is to investigate the perceptions of marketing staffs and consumers towards product placement in video games and the effectiveness of the placement. The purpose of the research is exploratory and intended to determine whether marketing staffs and consumers perceive differences in the effectiveness of traditional product placement strategies and branded entertainment.
3
The Product Placement in Marketing. What’s the Effectiveness in Video Games?
Product placement is traditionally defined as ‘a paid product message aimed at influencing movie (or television) audiences via the planned and unobtrusive entry of a branded product into a movie (or television programme)’ (Balasubramanian, 1994: 29). It is a composite type of messages involving visual, auditory (Newell et al., 2006), and plot components that can potentially
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
5
overcome some of the problems associated with traditional advertising in media such as television in which the viewer can delete or avoid advertising with zipping or zapping (Kuhn et al., 2004). From this perspective, product placement is related to branding theory because it is intended to increase awareness of the product and knowledge about product attributes (Haugtvedt et al., 2005). The implication of branding theory for product placement is the opportunity for the consumer to gains greater awareness of the subjective product attributes. Linking the product with the consumers’ positive perception about the entertainment character’s use of the product increases the subjective knowledge of the consumers’ about the product’s non-functional attributes (Shrum, 2004). The consumer is generally aware of the persuasive purpose of an advertising message and can easily ignore the message or engage in mental counterarguments reducing the effectiveness of the persuasion (Panda, 2004). With product placement advertising, however, the consumer theoretically has greater difficulty ignoring the message because it is intertwined with an entertainment communication in which the consumer has interest. Actually, the development of new forms of entertainment media requires an extension of the definition to include video games and other forms of computermediated entertainment. A video game can be broadly defined as a game based on software played on an electronic device allowing the presentation of graphical imagery and the interaction of the player with the software (Wolf, 2008). When the player becomes fully engaged with the gaming experience, the video game is considered as an immersive virtual environment (IVE) (Grigorovici and Constantin 2004). Galician (2005) indicated that the level of brand immersion within the IVE can range from associations to illustrations about use of the product depending on the way the brand is integrated into the tasks required for game play. The perceived quality of the video game by the player can affect the general attitude towards the game, which is analogous to the attitude of individuals towards other entertainment products (Ozer et al., 2009). Russell (1999) proposed a three-tiered framework for assessing the way in which a product is placed in a video game. The first tier involves screen placement in which the brand or product is visible in the screen frame. The second tier uses script placement in which the audio content mentions the brand or product. The third tier involves plot placement in which the brand or product is incorporated into the plot. These placements are analogous to the way in which product placement occurs in film. Because of the nature of the video game, a fourth tier to the
6
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
framework includes the degree of interaction between the game player and the brand. In effect, the video game adds an additional dimension to product placement by allowing the user to interact with the product, which theoretically increases engagement and awareness. While the traditional approach to product placement in video games is to embed the product in the game play, content or motif, it is also possible to create a game solely around a brand or a branded character. These types of video games are referred to as ‘branded entertainment’ and ‘advergames’ (Winkler and Buckner, 2006). These games are often provided to consumers without cost and are played on the internet, although sometimes the firm owning the brand makes a nominal charge for the product (Mathieson, 2005). Yang et al. (2006) identified an emerging practice in video games played on the internet or requiring a periodic internet connection of rotating product placement. In effect, the branded products placed in the background of the game can change over time as the promotional contracts with the game sponsors change. This type of approach has also been used to promote new gaming products in the run-up to launch based, with the relatively short life-cycle of video games requiring firms to continuously develop new gaming products.
3.1
Effectiveness of Product Placement in Video Games
The evidence from research investigating product placement in video games has produced mixed findings. Effectiveness for product placement in video games is defined in various ways, which may account for the mixed findings. It is defined in terms of improving brand equity or the favourable impression of the brand (Nelson et al., 2004). Effectiveness is also defined as prompting the consumer to take an action such as an information search or the purchase of the product (Beirne, 2008). The approaches to determining effectiveness of product placement in video games are similar to the approaches used to assess product placement effectiveness in other media (Galician, 2005; Haugtvedt et al., 2005). Several researches have been made in this sense (Beirne 2008, Yang et al., 2004; Nelson et al., 2004) with different and contradictory results. Research conducted by Lee and Faber (2007) determined that many different factors can influence brand awareness with product placement in video games. The position of visual placements in the game must be sufficiently prominent to attract the notice of the gamer when engaged in a high involvement task. Experienced players are more likely to observe and assimilate the product placement message because they are less engaged with gaming tasks. The findings also showed that the degree of continuity or relationship between the
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
7
product and the game content was a critical factor for the gamer to become aware of the placement. Hernandez et al. (2004) also determined that product placements in video games involve a fantasy or a deviation from the simulated reality of the game had a negative effect on the player’s attitude toward the brand. Grigorovici and Constantin (2004) determined that the level of engagement of the video game player with the IVE influences brand recall, with greater involvement reducing recall. Brand preference tends to increase with greater player engagement. The finding of Grigorovici and Constantin (2004) suggest that a subliminal process occurs during high engagement video game play increasing brand preference without increasing awareness or knowledge about the brand. According to Mathieson (2005), firms offering branded entertainment products via the internet to fixed or mobile playing platforms measure effectiveness based on the number of downloads. This approach solely examines the reach of the advertising and branding effort, with a download considered a customer contact. In addition, ratings agencies such as Nielson and game producers such as Activision have established tracking methods for internet game players to obtain information about the degree of engagement with the game and the type of brand information they have been exposed to because of play. This approach for determining effectiveness adopts the premise that exposure to the product information will lead to greater brand awareness and a favourable image.
4
Research Questions and Objectives
In view of above, the objective of this qualitative research is to answer the main research question: RQ: What are the differences in the effectiveness between” traditional product placement in video games” and the “branded entertainment approach to product placement in video games”? The question of this study aims to address the differences between two types of products placement: a traditional strategy (Winkler and Buckner, 2006) commonly used by advertisers, and a new one based on the central role that brand plays in entertainment (Hudson and Hudson, 2006). To compare the degree of effectiveness between both types of product placement, it is necessary to asses a subsidiary research question: RQ1: What are the strategies used for product placement in video games?
8
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
In this sense, for product placement in film media, placement strategies include visual placement allowing the viewer to observe the produce, mention of the brand or product, and use of the brand or product by a character (Russell, 2009). These traditional techniques have been used in video games, but may involve different approaches to factors such as prominence or repetition (Yang et al., 2006). Video games may include other types of placement strategies including branded entertainment in which the game is played using a branded product as a theme or character (Mathieson, 2005). The different types of strategies may have an influence on the effectiveness of product placement in video games. Additionally, a second subsidiary research question is: RQ2: What are the perceptions of marketing staffs and consumers of the effects of “traditional product placement strategies” versus “branded entertainment in video games” on the general brand awareness? Product placement has influences on brand awareness, although uncertain exists in research concerning the degree of the influence (Beine, 2008; Ivory and Kalyanaraman, 2007; Shrum, 2004). Brand awareness has been assessed through recall measures (Galician, 2005; Law and Braun, 2000). Variability exists, however, in the way in which recall is assessed, with some approaches examining independent recall of the placement with no secondary stimulus (Law and Braun, 2000) and other approaches examining recall following a stimulus (Lehu and Bressoud, 2007). The branded entertainment approach to product placement may result in differences in perceptions concerning awareness of the brand in addition to merely recalling or recognizing the brand after the entertainment product has been used. Also, and as a consequence of the main research question, a third subsidiary research question could be: RQ3: What are the perceptions of marketing staffs and consumers of the effects of “traditional product placement strategies” versus “branded entertainment in video games” on the awareness of specific brand attributes? This aspect of product placement has not been extensively examined in previous research. Winkler and Buckner (2006) as well as Yang et al. (2004) determined that product placement in video games increased brand knowledge, but did not examine the difference in effects between traditional placement and branded entertainment. The “branded entertainment approach” to product placement may provide the consumer with greater knowledge about the range of attributes the company desires to associate with a product.
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
9
A final research question is: RQ4: How do demographic factors influence perception of the effectiveness of “traditional product placement strategies” versus “branded entertainment in video games”? Demographic factors can influence responsiveness and attitudes toward product placements in entertainment media (Galician, 2005). Culture can also influence attitudes towards product placement and the effectiveness of various placement strategies (Gould et al., 2005). The general theoretical model is based on the assumption that a relationship exists between product placement strategies in video games and the effectiveness of the placement for increasing brand recognition, awareness of the brand’s attributes, and a favourable impression of the brand. The theoretical model also presumes that many intervening factors can influence the relationship between product placement strategies and effectiveness such as the perceived entertainment value of the game, the degree of immersion in game play, and the thematic content of the game. As a result demographic factors function as moderating variables, influencing the relationship between product placement strategies and effectiveness.
5
Methodology
The selection of Disney for the case study was based on defined criteria and the information-oriented selection process recommended by Flyvbjerg (2006). The criteria included the use of product placement by the firm as a marketing strategy, the use of “branded entertainment approach” as part of the product placement approach, and sufficient video game products to allow consumers to be familiar with the content and product placement in the products. An additional criterion was the willingness of marketing staffs from the firm to provide data for the study. The information-oriented selection process sorts firms meeting the initial inclusion criteria based on a specific characteristic intended to provide the desired type of information. Because of its size and planned marketing procedures, Disney was considered a critical case in which conclusions about the use of product placement in the firm could be considered representative of product placement in the video gaming industry. The data collection consisted of (1) interviews with marketing staffs from the firm, (2) a focus group conducted with consumers of Disney video games, and (3) review of information available to the public from secondary sources about Disney video games. The interview is appropriate for data collection in qualitative research because it allows the interviewees to establish the direction taken when answering open-ended questions (Darlington and Scott, 2002). The
10
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
focus group is also appropriate for gathering qualitative data because it allows the participants to discuss theoretical issues using the language and terms that construct meaning from their perspective (Darlington and Scott, 2002). Defined criteria were used to identify individuals to participate in the interview and focus group segments of the study. Because of the inclusion criteria, a purposive sampling approach using a snowball methodology was used to identify participants in the study (Gliner and Morgan, 2000). The selection process resulted in four interviewees agreeing to participate in the study and nine participants in the focus group. Table 1 and Table 2 shows some information related to the participants. Table 1. Demographic Information Interviewees
________________________________________________________________ Interviewee Number 1 2 3 4 ________________________________________________________________ Date of Interview 7/7/2009 7/7/2009 9/7/2009 12/7/2009 Position Marketing Product Production Marketing Team Manager Team Team Assistance DIMG DIMG DIMG DIMG Gender M M M M Age 37 41 29 33 Exper. at Disney 8 years 3 years 4 years 6 years ________________________________________________________________
The data analysis procedure involved synthesising the data obtained from the interviews, focus group, and secondary sources to create the case study. The primary data from the interviews and focus group was initially analysed using a thematic content approach. Content analysis is an appropriate method for analysis when the research design is qualitative and the purpose of the research is to obtain information about factors that may be causally related to the phenomenon under investigation (Creswell, 2007). The content analysis identified the themes and patterns within the data related to the research questions. It consisted of the three stages of open coding, axial coding and narrative as recommended by Daymon and Holloway (2002). The findings of the content analysis was combined with the secondary data to develop the case study of Disney’s use and perceived effectiveness of product placement and branded entertainment in video games. The reliability and validity of the data was established based on the trustworthiness criteria used in qualitative research as recommended by Daymon and Holloway (2002). Trustworthiness in
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
11
qualitative research is composed of the elements of credibility and dependability of the methods, and applicability to the research problem, and ability to confirm the findings of the study. Table 2. Participants in the Focus Group
________________________________________________________ Participant Age Gender Occupation ________________________________________________________ 1 32 F Shop Worker 2 37 F County Council Employee 3 27 M Shop Worker 4 39 F Estate Agent 5 42 M IT specialist 6 23 M Student 7 29 F Junior School Teacher 8 36 F Shop owner 9 34 F Chef ________________________________________________________
5
Results and Discussion
The results of the study were organised in four sections (1) a description and content analysis of the interviewees from Disney staff, (2) a description and content analysis of the focus group participants, (3) the case study of Disney based on a synthesis of the data, and (4) the discussion linking the findings to the literature review. Only some results from fourth section are shown due to space limitations. In this sense, the findings suggest that Disney uses a subtle approach to product placement involving the use of branded characters rather than placing specific products into the background or incorporating the product into the game play. Based on the framework for assessing product placement developed by Russell (1999), Disney uses the most sophisticated product placement strategy by incorporating the product, which is the branded character, into the action of the game play. The effect is to create closer alignment between the entertainment product in the form of the video game and the branded product in the form of the character, which is the outcome of branded entertainment proposed by Hudson and Hudson (2006).
12
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
The interviewees indicated that the current strategy is to use video games as an extension of a branded entertainment product based on the assumption that increasing the number of game players increases the general market awareness of the branded character, and therefore leads to sales of other products associated with the character. The results also suggest that the “branded entertainment approach” to product placement may be more effective for increasing brand awareness and a favourable impression of the brand than the more “traditional product placement approaches” of depicting a product in the background or the use or mention of a product by a character. Previous researchers have also found that carefully managed product placement in video games can increase brand awareness among gamers (Kuhn et al., 2004; Winkler and Buckner, 2006; Yang et al., 2004). The concern of many focus group participants that product placement in all entertainment media including video games has a stronger effect on children conforms to the findings of Calvert (2008). The participants suggested that children do not recognise a product placement incorporated into the theme or content of the game as advertising or marketing. The results further suggest that Disney does not excessively use product placement in video games (is not intrusive); with the participants in the focus group indicating that the use of branded characters in the game is appropriate. The findings also suggested that determining the effectiveness of product placement strategies in video games is complex because product placement interacts with other variables such as the degree of general engagement with the game. These results are similar to those of Grigorovici and Constantin (2004) who determined that the perceived entertainment value of the video game influences the gamers’ attitudes toward product placement. The participants of the focus group reached no conclusion concerning the perceived effect of the video game on the purchase intentions of the children playing the games. The participants also suggested that the purchase intentions are driven by the affinity of the child for the branded character, with any product associated with a likeable character considered desirable. The results provide evidence to refute the argument of Winkler and Buckner (2006) that branded entertainment should be considered an advergame under all situations. The interviewees and participants in the focus group considered the video games to be primarily an entertainment medium with some advertising or branding elements incorporated into the game. The participants in the focus group distinguished between a video game created around an existing product and a video game using a character created for entertainment purposes.
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
6
13
Conclusions and Recommendations
The findings of the study supports the conclusion that the branded-entertainment approach to product placement in video games is more effective for achieving greater brand awareness and positive brand perceptions than the traditional product placement approach of placing the product into the content of the video game. The traditional approach to product placement in video games is to embed an audio or visual reference to the brand in the game or to have the player use a branded product to perform a task associated with game play (Russell, 1999). This approach appears to be a direct transfer of the techniques used in film, television and other passive entertainment media. In the brandedentertainment approach in video games, the entire game functions as a product placement, with the gamer interacting with the branded character (Winkler and Buckner, 2006). The findings of the study indicated that Disney, the producer of the video games using the branded entertainment approach, believed that it was more effective for increasing awareness among consumers of the attributes associated with both the branded character and the overall Disney brand. The findings of the study also indicated that consumers of the video games find the use of a branded character less objectionable than the use of a direct product placement as occurs in other entertainment media and video games that do not use branded entertainment. The findings of the study also support the conclusion that the strategy used for product placement in video games can have an influence on brand awareness. Prior research has determined that product placement in video games affects brand awareness because the gamer becomes immersed in play of the game and reduces mental barriers to processing advertising and brand information (Yang et al., 2006). The findings of the study suggested that branded entertainment in which the brand is the subject of all video game activities may be highly effective for indirectly or implicitly communicating information about brand attributes to the game player. The interviewees from Disney indicated that the approach was effective for communicating the attributes of both the character and the Disney brand. The participants in the focus group also indicated that they had a positive perception of the Disney brand because of its use of branded characters in video games. An additional conclusion of the study is that product placement in video games has the potential to generate negative brand equity if the placement is intrusive or perceived as a deceptive advertising practise. If the brand placement is incongruent with the content of the video game and if the brand is excessively repeated in the game, it contributes to the perception that the brand placement is intrusive (Hernandez et al., 2004). The perception of intrusiveness results in negative attitudes toward the brand and an ultimate reduction in brand equity. In
14
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
a worst-case situation, gamers become so annoyed with the brand placement that they avoid purchasing the brand. The findings of the study, however, indicated that this type of problem with the perception of intrusiveness is less likely to occur with branded entertainment. The gamer has an expectation that the brand in the form of the character will be an integral aspect of game play. In effect, the gamer accepts that a character product will be part of the gaming activity before engaging in play. The study, however, did not provide sufficient information to determine the degree that this expectation of encountering a branded character during the course of play affects the way in which the gamer processes the implicit marketing message. Theoretically, consumers process product placement information differently from other forms of advertising (Shrum, 2004). The mechanisms that consumers used to process branded entertainment messages may also differ from the mechanisms used to process information conveyed by traditional product placements. The issue of greater acceptability among consumers of product placement in video games by using a branded entertainment approach is particularly relevant to large multinational firms that create video game products for international distribution. Cultural differences can have a significant influence on the perception of the appropriateness of product placement strategies (Stafford and Faber, 2005). As a result, the branded character approach with no other brands placed in the video game may provide multinational firms developing products for international sales with a general product placement strategy that is acceptable across cultures. Disney uses only a branded entertainment approach to product placement in video games and very sparingly places brands not already associated with the branded character into the video game. As a result, the firm increases the marketability of the product in all geographic regions where the video game is distributed. The conclusion that can be drawn from the findings is that a branded entertainment approach in which the only placement involves a branded character may be more effective for firms in international markets for increasing acceptance of the product than the traditional approach of video or audio insertions of a product into a video game. An additional conclusion of the study is that the demographics of the target market for a video game should influence the product placement strategy. The Disney video games are targeted at a child and young adolescent demographic. In theory, this demographic is more susceptible to marketing messages using product placement (Calvert, 2008). At the same time, video games aimed at this market have to ensure they conform with regulations in different nations concerning marketing to children as well as the perceptions of the adults that often make the purchases of video games. The findings of the study support the conclusion that the adults involved with video gaming with children find the
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
15
branded entertainment approach an acceptable marketing method. Although playing the video game reinforces the interest of the child in the entertainment and other products related to the character, the adults perceive the marketing aspects as secondary or subordinate to the entertainment value. In addition, findings indicated that Disney designs its video games to market its branded characters to children in a manner that adults deem acceptable. The findings of the study also support the conclusion that the branded entertainment approach to product placement can be used to increase existing brand knowledge and to introduce the brand to consumers that have no prior knowledge of the brand. In theory, product placement in video games as well as other media functions as a means to communicate information about the attributes of the brand by associating the brand with the content of the game (Pardun and McKee, 2000). The purchase or internet play of a video game with a specific character depends to some degree on the prior awareness of the consumer of the attributes of the branded character. In most cases, the consumer is initially attracted to the branded entertainment video game because of a preexisting affinity for the branded character as well as the presumed entertainment value of the game. As a result, the consumer often has some level of knowledge and awareness of the attributes associated with the character. The video game functions to reinforce and build on an existing knowledge base. Ideally, the outcome is for the consumer to have a positive gaming experience, increasing awareness and affinity for the branded character. At the same time, the video game has to be designed to provide some information about character attributes to consumers that have no prior knowledge of the character. This dual process suggests that the branded entertainment approach to video game content is more complex than the traditional approaches in which products are merely placed into the game environment. As noted by the interviewees from Disney, the development of a video game using a branded character requires close coordination among software developers, game content planners, and marketing.
6.1
Limitations of the Research
The findings and conclusions of this research are limited by the use of the case study approach, which focused on the video game products produced by Disney. The Disney brand is well-established in the market for children’s and young adult entertainment products. As a result, the firm has a strong emphasis on protecting its existing brand equity and avoids using product placement strategies that the firm perceives as representing a risk to its brand equity. The findings and conclusions of the study may not reflect the attitude of consumers towards product placement and branded entertainment products of firms that do not have a well-established reputation in the marketplace. In addition, the
16
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
conclusions and findings of the study may not reflect the perspectives of adult gamers toward product placement in video games. In addition, Disney does not use a range of different product placement strategies in video games, which limits the ability to assess the perception of differences among consumers of the product.
6.2
Recommendations for Future Research
While the findings and conclusions of this study indicated that the branded entertainment approach to product placement in video games is more effective in a children’s target market than the traditional approaches to product placement, it did not assess product placement strategies among other demographic groups. Future research should examine the specific attitudinal, awareness, and recall responses of consumers through a direct comparison of the different types of product placement strategies used in video games. This type of research should assess the response of consumers in carefully defined demographic segments to products placed in video games using various combinations of audio, visual and character use of the product to more carefully determine the differences between these product placement strategies and the branded entertainment product placement strategy. Future research should also examine the extent that branded entertainment approaches to product placement in video games can be linked to traditional product placement methods. The combination of branded characters and traditional product placement has been successful in film for creating brand awareness for the product when it is associated with the branded character and the product is relevant to the plot of the film. It is not certain, however, whether this same effect would occur with a video game.
7
References
Auty, S. & Lewis, C. (2004). Exploring children’s choices: The reminder effect of product placement. Psychology & Marketing, Vol. 21, No. 9, 699-716. Balasubramanian, S. (1994). Beyond advertising and publicity: hybrid messages and public policy issues. Journal of Advertising, Vol. 23, No. 4, 29-46. Beirne, M. (2008). Study: Gamers respond to ads. Brandweek, Vol. 49, No. 32. Available at:http://www.technologymarketing.com/bw/content_display/news-andfeatures/digital/e3ibd93dba87a9330a3ed295b7ba76e8e25. [Accessed 19 June 2009]. Brookey, R.A. & Westerfelhaus, R. (2005). The digital auteur: Branding identity on Monsters Inc. DVD. Western Journal of Communications, Vol. 69, No. 2, 109-128. Calvert, S. (2008). Children as consumers. The Future of Children, Vol. 18, No. 1, 205-232.
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
17
Chiou, J. (2000). Antecedents and moderators of behavioural intention: Differences between U.S. and Taiwanese students. Genetic, Social and General Psychology Monographs, Vol. 26, No. 1, 105-124. Cowley, E. & Barron, C. (2008). When product placement goes wrong: The effects of program liking and placement prominence. Journal of Advertising, Vol. 37, No. 1, 89-98. Creswell, J.W. (2007). Qualitative inquiry and research design. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage Publications Croteau, D. & Hoynes. W. (2005). The business of media. Thousand Oaks CA: Pine Forge Press. Darlington, Y. & Scott, D. (2002). Qualitative research in practice. Crows Nest NSW: Allen & Unwin. Daymon, C. & Holloway, I. (2002). Qualitative research methods in public relations and marketing communications. London: Routledge. Flyvbjerg, B. (2006). Five misunderstandings about case study research. Qualitative Inquiry, Vol. 12, No. 2 Galician, M. (2005). Handbook of product placement in the mass media. Binghamton NH: Haworth Press. Gerdes, L. (2006). Ads People Play. Business Week, No. 401. Gilbert, J. (2005). Jazz, gestalt and the year ahead for marketers. Journal of Advertising Research, Vol. 45, No. 3, 294-295. Gliner, J. & Morgan, G. (2000). Research methods in applied settings. Mahwah NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Grigorovici, D. & Constantin, C. (2004). Experiencing interactive advertising beyond rich media. Journal of Interactive Advertising, Vol. 5, No. 1. Available at: http://jiad.org/article53. [Accessed 12 July 2009]. Gould, S., Gupta, O. & Grabner-Krauter (2000). Product placement in movies: A cross-cultural analysis of American, French and Austrian consumer attitudes. Journal of Advertising, Vol. 29, No. 4, 41-58. Haugtvedt, C., Machleit, K. & Yalch, R. (2005). Online consumer psychology. New York: Routledge. Hernandez, M., Chapa, S., Minor, M., Maldonado, C., & Barranzuela, F. (2004). Hispanic attitudes toward advergames. Journal of Interactive Advertising, Vol. 5, No. 1. Available at: http://jiad.org/article57. [Accessed 13 July 2009]. Hill, L. (2007). From one franchise to another: CSI spawns video game series. Television Week, Vol. 26, No. 18. Homer, P.M. (2009). Product placements: The impact of placement type and repetition on attitude. Journal of Advertising, Vol.38, No. 3, 21-32. Hudson, S. & Hudson, D. (2006). Branded entertainment: A new advertising technique of product placement in disguise? Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 22, nos. 5-6, 489-504. Ivory, J. & Kalyanaraman, S. (2007). The effects of technological advancement and violent content in video games on players’ feeling of presence, involvement, physiological arousal and aggression. Journal of Communications, Vol. 57, 532-555. Keller, K. (2003). Brand synthesis: The multidimensionality of brand knowledge. Journal of Consumer Research, Vol.29, No.4, 595-600. Kreuger, R.A. (1998). Analysing and reporting focus group findings. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage Publications. Kuhn, K., Love, A. & Pope, N. (2004). Brand placements in video and computer games: An overview and research questions. Available at: http://www98.griffith.edu.au/dspace/bitstream/10072/2325/1/26471_1.pdf. [Accessed 13 July 2009].
18
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
Law, S. & Braun, K. (2000). I’ll have what she’s saying: Gauging the effect of product placement on viewers. Psychology and Marketing, Vol. 17, No. 12, 1059-1075. Lee, M. & Faber, R. (2007). Effects of product placement in on-line games on brand memory. Journal of Advertising, Vol. 36, No. 4, 75-90. Lenderman, M. (2006). Experience the message. New York: Carroll & Graf. Lehu, J.-M., & Bressoud, E. (2007). Viewers and brand placement in movies. La Londe Seminar in Marketing Communications and Consumer Behaviour, La Londe, 5-8 June. Available at: http://hal.archivesouvertes.fr/docs/00/34/45/35/PDF/Lehu_Bressoud_2007_Brand_PLacement_viewers_La_Londe .pdf. [Accessed 14 July 2009]. MacDonald, E. & Sharp, E. (2003). Management perceptions of the importance of brand awareness as an indicator of advertising effectiveness. Marketing Bulletin, Vol. 14, 1-11. Mathieson, R. (2005). Branding unbound. New York: Amacom. Milberg, S.J., Park, C.W. & McCarthy, M. (1997). Managing negative feedback effects associated with brand extension: The impact of alternative branding strategies. Journal of Consumer Psychology, Vol. 6, No. 2, 119-140. Nelson, M., Keum, H., & Yaros, R. (2004). Advertisement or adcreep: Game players attitude toward advertising and product placement in computer games. Journal of Interactive Advertising, Vol. 5, No. 1. Available at: http://www.jiad.org/article52. [Accessed 19 June 2009]. Newell, J., Salmon, C., & Chang, S. (2006). The hidden history of product placement. Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media, Vol. 50, No. 4, 575-603. Ozer, A., Argan, M., Suher, H., Akin, E., & Argan, M. (2009). Game Quality: A Study on Turkish Game Players. Available at: http://bildiri.anadolu.edu.tr/papers/bildirimakale/102_923y83.pdf. [Accessed 8 July, 2009]. Panda, T. (2006). Consumer responses to brand placement in films. South Asian Journal of Management, Vol. 11, No. 4, 7-25. Pardun, C. & McKee, K. (2000). Product placements as public relations. Public Relations Review, Vol. 25, No. 4, 481-493. Reijmersdal, E., Niejens, P., & Smit, E. (2007). Effects of television brand placement on brand image. Psychology and Marketing, Vol. 24, No. 5, 403-420. Rosini, J., Mash, M., & Rupp M. (2008). Hot licensing issues in the video game industry The Licensing Journal, (February), 14-23 Russell, C. (1998). Toward a framework for product placement: Theoretical propositions. In Alba, J. & Hutchinson, J. (Eds.) Advances in consumer research, Vol. 25. Provo UT: Association for Consumer Research. Sargent, J., Tickle, J., Beach, M., Dalton, M., & Ahearns, M. (2001). Brand appearances in contemporary cinema films and contribution to global marketing of cigarettes. The Lancet, Vol. 357, No. 9249, 29-32. Schultz, M., Antonini, Y., & Csaba, F. (2005). Corporate branding. New York: CBS Press. Shrum, L. (2004). The psychology of entertainment media. Mahwah NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Stafford, M. & Faber, R. (2005). Advertising promotion and the new media. Armonk NY: M.E. Sharpe. Turner, C. (2004). Product placement of medical products. Journal of Promotional Management, Vol. 10, No. 1, 159-170. Vorhaus, M. (2009). Ad presence in console games has little effect on purchase. Advertising Age, Vol. 80, No. 5. Walsh, P., Kim, Y. & Ross, S. (2008). Brand recall and recognition: A comparison of television and sport video games as presentation modes. Sport Marketing Quarterly, Vol. 17, 201-208.
Product Placement in Video Games as a Marketing Strategy
19
Walt Disney Company. (2009). Annual report 2008. Available at: http://amedia.disney.go.com/investorrelations/annual_reports/WDC-AR-2008.pdf. [Accessed 18 June 2009]. Winkler, T. & Buckner, K. (2006). Receptiveness of gamers to embedded brand messages in advergames. Journal of Interactive Advertising, Vol.7, No. 1. Available at: http://jiad.org/article85. [Accessed 19 June 2009]. Wolf, M. (2008). The video game explosion. Westport CT: Greenwood Press. Yang, M., Roskos-Ewolden, D., Dinu, L. & Arpan, L. (2006). The effectiveness of in-game advertising. Journal of Advertising, Vol. 4, No. 4, 143-152. Yaveroglu, I. & Donthu, N. (2008). Advertising repetition and placement issues in online environments. Journal of Advertising, Vol. 37, No. 2, 31-43. Yin, R. (2003). Case study research: design and methods. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage Publications.
20
Bigné, Küster, Hernández, Suemanotham and Vila
Appendix A. Interview Questions 1. What is Disney’s approach to product placement in its entertainment products? 2. How does Disney’s approach to product placement in video games differ from product placement in its films or other entertainment products? 3. How does Disney use branded entertainment? (Explain: Branded entertainment refers to the use of a branded character as the central character of the story line or content in a video game.) 4. How does Disney assess the effectiveness of product placement and branded entertainment in video games? 5. What is the relationship between product placement in video games and consumer awareness of the Disney brand and its attributes? 6. In what ways can product placement in video games create negative attitudes towards brands among the players of the games? 7. What methods does Disney use to ensure that product placement and branded entertainment video games result in a positive attitude toward the Disney brand among players?
Appendix B. Focus Group Guidelines Moderator will initially define the meaning of the product placement and branded entertainment concept. The moderator will also ensure that the participants understand the concepts. 1. What is your attitude toward product placement in video games? 2. Do you have a different attitude towards product placement in video games than in films or television shows? 3. What type of product placement in video games do you find annoying? 4. Have you ever played a Disney video game online? If so, which ones? 5. What do you remember about your experiences playing these games? 6. Have you ever played a Disney video game offline? If so, which ones? 7. What do you remember about your experiences playing these games? 8. What is your attitude towards Disney games that are based on a Disney character such as Hannah Montana or Bolt? 9. If you played a Disney video game with children, do you think that the characters or products used in the game had an influence on their attitudes? 10. Did playing a Disney video game motivate you to purchase another Disney product related to the character in the video game?
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes: Does the Attitude toward the Artist Matter? Yves Van Vaerenbergh, University College Ghent, Belgium Dieneke Van de Sompel, University College Ghent, Belgium Neal Van Loock, University College Ghent, Belgium Iris Vermeir,Ghent University, Belgium
1
Introduction
As the overload of advertising in traditional media is causing annoyance with the audience (Fennis and Bakker, 2001) leading to advertising avoidance (Woltman-Elpers et al., 2003), marketers are exploring various new ways to convey brand-related messages to consumers. One of the proposed techniques is product or brand (name) placement, which is defined as the incorporation of a brand name into an entertainment vehicle (Ferraro and Avery, 2000). Past research concerning product placement mainly focused on product and brand name placement in movies (Babin and Carder, 1996; d’Astous and Chartier, 2000; Wiles and Danielova, 2009; Yang and Roskos-Ewoldsen, 2007), television programs (Gould and Gupta, 2006; La Ferle and Edwards, 2006; Matthes et al., 2007; Russell, 2002; Russell and Stern, 2006; Van Reijmersdal et al., 2007), music videos (Schemer et al., 2008), games (Lee and Faber, 2007; Mackay et al., 2009; Nelson, 2002; Schneider and Cornwell, 2005) or novels (Brennan, 2008; Friedman, 1985). Recent academic research suggests that brand placement can be implemented by including brand names in song lyrics (Delattre and Colovic, 2009), which often occurs in practice. Agenda Inc. created the American Brand Stand, which tracked all the mentions of brand names in the lyrics of the Billboard Top 20 singles chart in 2003 and 2004. In 2003, Mercedes was the most-mentioned brand name with 114 mentions in lyrics, and in 2004 Cadillac was mentioned 70 times. Other oftenmentioned brands were Hennessy, Rolls Royce, Gucci, to name but a few (Agenda Inc, 2004). These results indicate that the use of brand names in song lyrics is a common practice. For example, McDonald’s cooperated with Maven Strategies, a professional agency which sought rappers to incorporate “Big Mac” in their texts. McDonald’s was prepared to pay 1 to 5 dollar each time the brand name was mentioned on the radio in their song lyrics (Graser, 2005). On the other hand, the hip-hop band Outkast advised their audience to “Shake it Like a Polaroid Picture” and Busta Rhymes wrote a song called “Pass the CourS. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_2, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
22
Van Vaerenbergh, Van de Sompel, Van Loock and Vermeir
voisier”, which led to a significant increase in sales for the Courvoisier brand. Important to note is that these artists were not paid at first for this action, but a settlement was arranged afterwards (Debruyne, 2007, Holloway, 2002). Consequently, organizations cannot always exert control over which artists include their brand name in song lyrics. If organizations select the artists themselves, they can pick artists who are positively perceived by the audience, whereas artists who include brand names freely might be negatively perceived by the audience. In this paper, we investigate the moderating role of the attitude toward the artist on the relationship between the amount of brand name repetitions in song lyrics and the attitude toward the brand. Our study contributes to the literature in the following ways. First, prior research only demonstrated a link between the amount of brand name repetitions in song lyrics on brand recall and recognition (Delattre and Colovic, 2009). Second, we extend prior research by examining the moderating role of attitude toward the artist. To date, research on brand name placement in song lyrics did not yet address this issue, although highly relevant given that organizations are faced with the potential danger that their brand name is included in a song by an artist which is negatively evaluated by the audience. Prior research demonstrated evaluative conditioning effects for product placement in music videos. Schemer et al. (2008) found that the pairing of a brand with positively evaluated artists produces positive attitudes toward the brand, while the pairing of a brand with negatively evaluated artists produces negative attitudes toward the brand. However, to date it remains unknown whether the same evaluative conditioning effects hold for brand name placement in song lyrics instead of music videos. Moreover, Schemer et al. (2008) did not investigate evaluative conditioning effects across a different number of pairings, although research on evaluative conditioning shows that evaluative conditioning effects become stronger across multiple pairings (De Houwer et al., 2001, 2005; Hoffman et al., 2010). In order to assess the impact of the amount of brand name placement in song lyrics on brand attitudes and the moderating role of attitude toward the artist, we rely on an experimental design making use of a song especially developed for the purpose of this study. In order to test whether brand placement effects become stronger with different numbers of brand exposures, three different versions of the song were created, with zero, two or five brand name placements.
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes
2
23
Theoretical Background and Hypothesis Development
To the authors’ knowledge, only one study investigated the effectiveness of brand name placement in song lyrics. Delattre and Colovic (2009) selected two well-known songs (over 300,000 units sold) for the purpose of their research, namely ‘Tes Parents’ by Vincent Delerm and ‘Wonderbra’ by MC Solaar. In both songs, 17 brand names were included. Their results indicate that listeners recalled and recognized brands in both songs, especially in cases where the brand name placement was prominent (occurred at least twice) and pronounced slowly. However, their research did not address the impact of brand name placement in song lyrics on brand attitudes. Addressing this issue is important given that past literature often found an absence of correlations between memory (brand recall and recognition) and attitude measures (Cowley and Barron, 2008; Petty et al., 1983). Therefore, recall and recognition measures might be poor predictors of persuasion (Mackie and Asuncion, 1990). As a result, investigating brand attitudes might enhance our understanding of the effectiveness of brand name placement in song lyrics. In a broader context, research in the area of product and brand name placement found that a placement has the ability to positively influence brand attitudes. For example, Matthes et al. (2007) found that the frequency of placement has a positive impact on the evaluation of the brand in a TV show: the more frequent a brand is placed within a television show, the more favorable the attitudes toward that brand become. In a similar vein, Van Reijmersdal et al. (2007) showed that the image of brands placed in a TV show changed after two or more exposures. These results indicate that the brand attitudes should become more favorable with an increasing number of repetitions. This paper proposes that the effect of brand name repetition on brand attitude in song lyrics will vary depending on audiences’ attitude toward the artist. Theoretical anchoring for this expected effect can be found in conditioning theory. The most well-known experiment in classical conditioning is the one from Pavlov, who paired an unconditioned stimulus (dog food) with a conditioned stimulus (a ringing bell). After repeated pairings of unconditioned and conditioned stimulus, responses which only occur after the unconditioned stimulus also occur after the conditioned stimulus. That is, the dogs in Pavlov’s experiment already started salivating when hearing bell ringing (Schiffman and Kanuk, 2006). A variation on classical conditioning theory is evaluative conditioning, which is defined as the changes in the evaluation of a stimulus that result from pairing that stimulus with other positive or negative stimuli (De Houwer et al., 2001, 2005; Hoffman et al., 2010). The basic idea is that if a certain object is associated with a positive stimulus, a person might have a
24
Van Vaerenbergh, Van de Sompel, Van Loock and Vermeir
positive evaluation of that object. In contrast, if a certain object is associated with a negative stimulus, a person’s evaluation of that object might become negative. Consumer research investigated how evaluative conditioning can be used to influence brand attitudes. For example, an experiment by Sweldens et al. (2010) paired a brand with positive and neutral images and found that a brand associated with positive images was evaluated more positively by the participants than the same brand which was associated with neutral images. In an advertising context, conditioning has been applied to explain the effectiveness of celebrity endorsement (Till et al., 2008). If a product is paired with a fameous celebrity, it is expected that the celebrity can transfer meaning to the product (McCracken, 1989). In contrast, if a product is paired with a negatively perceived celebrity, this might have a negative impact on the brand attitude (Till and Shimp, 1998). To date, only one study investigated the impact of evaluative conditioning in a product placement context. Schemer et al. (2008) investigated how the evaluation of a brand placed in a music video differed depending on the audience’s attitude toward the artist. Their findings indicated that the pairing of a brand with a negatively perceived artist led to lower brand attitudes than the pairing of a brand with a positively perceived artist. In this research, we aim to replicate the findings of Schemer et al. (2008) in a different product placement context (song lyrics versus music video) and extend them by investigating different amounts of brand exposures. Prior research on evaluative conditioning indicated that evaluative conditioning effects become stronger when multiple pairings of conditioned and unconditioned stimuli occur (Baeyens et al., 1992; McSweeney and Bierley, 1984). In our research context, we might expect that the more a brand name is mentioned in a song lyric by a positively evaluated artist, the more positive the brand attitude might become. In contrast, the more a brand name is mentioned in a song lyric by a negatively evaluated artist, the more negative the brand attitude might become. This leads to the following hypothesis: H1: The attitude toward the artist moderates the relationship between brand name repetition in song lyrics and the brand attitude.
3
Method
Two hundred and two undergraduate students (43.6% male, Mage=19.94) participated in a 3x2 between-subjects experiment, in which we manipulated the occurrence of a brand name (mentioned zero, two or five times) and the attitude toward the artist (positive or negative). As Martin and Collins (2002) found that brands or products were mostly depicted in hip-hop and rap music videos, we
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes
25
used a hip-hop song as stimulus in our research. A study by Herd (2005) indicated that between 1979 and 1997, the number of hip-hop songs that include alcohol beverage brand name references increased from 0% to 71%, indicating that brand name placement is common in hip-hop songs. Given that youngsters are the privileged targets of the music industry (Delattre and Colovic, 2009; Schemer et al., 2008) and thus students represent a large part of the hip-hop audience, the use of a student sample in this study is justified. In this research, we applied the Theater Methodology as introduced by Russell (2002). This involved the creation of a stimulus (in this case, a song) that is completely under the experimenters’ control instead of using existing songs. This way, we rule out unwanted noise which might challenge the internal validity of results. Consequently, a hip-hop song was especially developed for the purpose of this study, for which we cooperated with an experienced but to the participants’ unknown hip-hopper. Three identical versions of the song were recorded which only differed on the number of brand name repetitions. All three versions of the song were sung in the native language of the hip-hopper (and respondents) and had duration of 2’13. The production of the stimulus material applied to professional standards, which ensured that the song did not raise the audiences’ suspicion of lacking authenticity (Yang and Roskos-Ewoldson, 2007). In the song, the artist sang about his life as hip-hopper and his devotion to hip-hop music. In case no brand name was added to the text, the artist mentioned listening to music on a “MP3 player”. In case a brand name was added to the text, “MP3 player” was replaced by “Jo-Box!”, which acts as a fictitious brand name for a MP3 player. By using an unknown brand name, potential confounding elements such as prior brand knowledge, attitude and usage could not influence our results. In a procedure similar to Schemer et al. (2008), participants’ attitude toward the artist was manipulated by using two different texts which provided background information about the artist. In the “negative attitude toward the artist”condition, the hip-hopper was depicted as greedy by exploiting his fans and overpricing his CDs. Moreover, he has been arrested for several crimes such as acts of violence and the use of drugs. In the “positive attitude toward the artist”condition, the hip-hopper was depicted as authentic, altruistic and loyal to his fans. Moreover, he gives donations for projects of public utility and gives guidelines to other young hip-hoppers who want to make a career. A pretest (n=71 undergraduate students) was conducted to assess whether the developed scenarios induced a positive or a negative attitude toward the artist. This variable was measured using a three-item seven-point Likert scale (α=0.94) adopted from Till and Shimp (1998). Results demonstrated that our manipulation was successful, as respondents who read a positive scenario had a significantly higher attitude
26
Van Vaerenbergh, Van de Sompel, Van Loock and Vermeir
toward the artist (M=5.21, SD=0.75) in comparison to respondents who read the negative scenario (M=2.43, SD=1.39) (t(23.94)= 7.356, p<0.001).
3.1
Measures
Dependent variables Respondents rated their attitude toward the brand (α=0.86) on a seven-item seven-point semantic differential scale developed by Stuart et al. (1987). Manipulation checks Similar to the pretest, the attitude toward the artist (α=0.95) was measured by using a three-item 7-point Likert scale adopted from Till and Shimp (1998). Covariates As attitude toward the music genre might be a confounding factor, we decided to measure the respondent’s attitude toward hip-hop music using a single-item measure as in Schemer et al. (2008). Furthermore, as the song was sung in a local dialect, we found this might potentially confound our results. As such, we controlled for this potential bias by calculating the distance between the hip-hoppers’ and respondent’s hometown which was added as covariate to our analysis. Therefore, the postal code of the respondent’s hometown was asked.
3.2
Procedure
Questionnaires were administered in small groups (+/- 20 respondents per group). Participants were first randomly assigned to one of the two scenarios, in which a positive or negative description about the artist was given. After reading the scenario, respondents were questioned about their attitude toward the artist. Afterwards, the respondents listened twice to one of the three versions of the song and subsequently were asked to rate their attitude toward Jo-Box!, their attitude toward hip-hop and to provide some socio-demographic data. After completing the experiment, respondents were debriefed and thanked for their participation.
27
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes
4 4.1
Main Study Manipulation Check
A manipulation check revealed that respondents who read the positive scenario had a positive attitude toward the artist (M=5.34, SD=0.95); respondents who read the negative scenario had a negative attitude toward the artist (M=2.08, SD=0.95) (t(198)=24.229, p<0.001). Hence, we conclude that the manipulations of the attitude toward the artist work as intended.
4.2
Results
Our hypothesis predicted that the attitude toward the artist would moderate the relationship between brand name repetition in song lyrics and the brand attitude. We expect that the evaluation of a brand which is paired with a positively perceived artist will become more and more positive as the number of brand name repetitions increases, whereas the evaluation of a brand which is paired with a negatively perceived artist will become more and more negative as the number of brand name repetitions increases. An ANCOVA was run in order to test our hypothesis, of which results are provided in Table 1. First, attitude toward hip-hop significantly influences the attitude toward the brand (p<0.001), while distance between the hip-hopper’s hometown and the respondent’s hometown was marginally significant as covariate (p=0.071). However, it is important to note that our results, which will be discussed in subsequent section, did not alter with the inclusion or exclusion of both covariates. In the remainder of this manuscript, we report results using both attitude toward hip-hop and distance as covariates. Table 1: ANCOVA results of brand attitude
Source Attitude toward hip-hop Distance Level of placement Attitude toward the artist Level of placement x Attitude toward the artist
F 16.532 3.296 3.567 10.648
df 1 1 2 1
p <0.001 0.071 0.030 0.001
η² 0.079 0.017 0.035 0.052
0.145
2
0.865
0.001
28
Van Vaerenbergh, Van de Sompel, Van Loock and Vermeir
Table 1 reveals that the main effects of brand name placement and attitude toward the artist had a significant impact on brand attitude, but the interaction between the brand name placement and the attitude toward the artist was not significant (p=0.865). The interaction was plotted in Figure 1.
4,2
Brand attitude
4,0
Negative attitude toward artist
3,8 3,6
Positive attitude toward artist
3,4 3,2 3,0 0
4
10
Number of brand name repetitions Figure 1: Interaction between brand name placement and attitude toward the artist
Our results indicate an evaluative conditioning effect: if a brand name is associated with an artist who is negatively perceived by the audience, this will result in lower brand attitudes. Contrary to our hypothesis, an increasing number of brand repetitions or associations between the brand name and the artist has a positive impact on the brand attitude regardless of the attitude toward the artist. Figure 1 shows that when a brand is associated with an artist who is negatively perceived, the brand attitude of respondents was lowest with zero (M=3.46) or four repetitions (M=3.37) but increased with ten repetitions (M=3.73). A similar pattern was found for associations between a brand name and artists who are positively perceived. The brand attitude was higher after ten repetitions (M=4.02) when compared to zero (M=3.75) or four repetitions (M=3.83).
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes
29
Interesting to note is that the amount of repetitions of the brand name has a significant impact on brand attitude. More specific, when the brand name was not mentioned, respondents had a mean brand attitude of 3.60. Respondents who heard the brand name four times did not have a significant higher brand attitude (M=3.62). If the brand name was mentioned ten times, the mean brand attitude increased significantly to 3.87. These findings suggest that overall, brand name placement in song lyrics can be an interesting advertising strategy, when the brand is sufficiently repeated.
5
Discussion
This study experimentally explores the impact of the amount of brand repetitions in song lyrics on the brand attitude and tests whether this relationship is moderated by the attitude toward the artist. Contrary to our expectations, our results indicate that for both artists who are either positively or negatively perceived by the audience, higher repetitions of the brand name have a higher positive influence on the brand attitude. These results contradict prior research on the moderating effects of attitudes toward the artist in a product placement context. Research by Schemer et al. (2008) on product placement in music videos found that pairing a brand with positively evaluated artists produced positive attitudes toward the brand, whereas pairing a brand with negatively evaluated artists produced negative attitudes toward the brand. A possible explanation for these contradictory results could be that our pairing with a negatively evaluated artist did not result in a negative brand attitude, although the brand attitude was less positive compared to the positive pairing condition. This could be explained by the context in which this research was conducted. Given the high prevalence of brand name placements in hip-hop and rap songs (Herd, 2005; Martin and Collins, 2002), we examined the effectiveness of brand name placement in song lyrics in a hip-hop context. However, many people in the hip-hop nation were condemned by the government or have been locked up (Butler, 2004). As a result, it might be the case that respondents took the negative attitude toward the artist into account to a lesser degree when evaluating the brand name placement, as a negatively perceived artist is an integral part of the hip-hop scene. Our results are in line with mere exposure research. Mere exposure research shows that repeated exposure to a stimulus enhances attitudes toward that stimulus (Zajonc, 1968) often explained by perceptual fluency or ease of processing (Lee and Labroo, 2004). Respondents had positive brand attitudes in both posi-
30
Van Vaerenbergh, Van de Sompel, Van Loock and Vermeir
tive and negative ‘attitude toward the artist’ conditions resulting in enhanced attitudes after repeated exposure. When considering the main effect of brand name repetitions in song lyrics, our findings demonstrate that the attitude toward the brand significantly increases after ten brand name placements. This provides further support for the impact of repetition on brand attitudes, an issue which received only very limited attention in prior product placement research (Van Reijmersdal et al., 2009). Following our results, managers might consider brand name placement in song lyrics as a potential context for product or brand name placement, next to more researched areas as movies, television shows, games or novels. When considering brand name placement in song lyrics as an advertising strategy, managers should be aware of the differential effects of brand name placement on brand recall, recognition and attitudes. Delattre and Colovic (2009) argued that at least two repetitions of a brand name should be included in the song lyrics, as this has a positive impact on brand recall and recognition. Results of our research clearly demonstrate that the brand name should be repeated at least ten times in order to enhance brand attitudes. This finding also differs from prior research on the number of repetitions that is necessary in order to increase brand evaluations with product placements. Van Reijmersdal et al. (2007) found that in a TV show, at least two repetitions were necessary in order to increase brand attitudes. The reason for this difference might be due to the use of visual versus auditory stimuli. In Van Reijmersdal et al.’s (2007) study, the product placement was both auditory and visual, while in our study the brand name placement was only auditory. Research shows that visual images or pictures tend to be more memorable than their verbal counterparts, because pictures are coded with both pictorial and verbal codes (dual coding theory, Paivio, 1986). The extra code associated with pictures gives them an advantage during retrieval. This stronger memory trace could also explain why fewer exposures are necessary for visual versus auditory product placement in order to influence respondents’ attitudes. Another important managerial implication emerges from this study. We did not find a significant interaction between brand name placement in song lyrics and the attitude toward the artist, leading to the conclusion that the impact of brand name placement in song lyrics on brand attitudes is similar for artists who are positively evaluated by the audience and artists who are negatively evaluated by the audience. As a result, marketers benefit from brand name placement in song lyrics, regardless of the artist who mentions the brand name. Given our current findings, managers can try to stimulate artists to include brand names in their song lyrics, even if the artists are not always positively perceived.
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes
5.1
31
Limitations and Future Research
Although our research provides evidence for the effectiveness of brand name placements in music songs, some limitations remain. First, our research is situated within the specific context of hip-hop- and rap songs which opens up the question whether our results would also apply in other music genres. Second, the number of brand name repetitions was limited to ten in our manipulations. Future research might explore whether an overload of brand name repetitions might cause irritation with respondents (see Cowley and Barron, 2008), resulting in negative effects of brand name placement in song lyrics on brand attitudes. Third, in our manipulation the hip-hopper sang about his life as hiphopper, while the brand we included involved a MP3 player. As such, congruence between song lyrics and the brand name might exist. Future research might also explore whether incongruent brand name placements might yield different results. Fourth, given that some artists voluntarily include brand names in their song lyrics whereas others include brand names based on a contract with an organization, question remains whether different effects might be obtained if the audience is aware of the fact that an artist might be paid to include brand names. Finally, brand name placement in song lyrics differs from product placement in movies or television programs because songs might be broadcasted multiple times a day. As such, future research might explore whether time intervals between the exposure to the brand name (for example, five times a day versus once a day for five sequential days) influence the effectiveness of brand placement in song lyrics.
6
References
Agenda Inc. (2004), “American Brandstand 2004”, http://www.brandchannel.com/images/Papers/245_brandstand04_final.pdf Babin, L.A. & Carder, S.T. (1996). “Viewers’ recognition of brands placed within a film”, in: International Journal of Advertising, 15(2), 140-151. Baeyens, F.; Eelen, P.; Van den Bergh, O. & Crombez, G. (1992), “The content of learning in human evaluative conditioning: Acquired valence is sensitive to US-revaluation”, in: Learning and Motivation, 23, 200-224. Brennan, I. (2008) “Brand placement in novels: A test of the generation effect”, in: International Journal of Advertising, 27(4), 495–509. Butler, P. (2004), “Much respect: Toward a hip-hop theory of punishment”, in: Stanford Law Review, 56, No. 983. Cowley, E. & Barron, C. (2008) “When product placement goes wrong – The effects of program liking and placement prominence”, in: Journal of Advertising, 37(1), 89-98. d’Astous, A. & Chartier, F. (2000) “A study of factors affecting consumer evaluations and memory of product placement in movies”, in: Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 22(2), 31-40.
32
Van Vaerenbergh, Van de Sompel, Van Loock and Vermeir
Debruyne, B. (2007), “Hiphopmarketing is bling bling”, in: Bizz, March 2007, 30-31. Delattre, E. & Colovic, A. (2009) “Memory and perception of brand mentions and placement of brands in songs”, in: International Journal of Advertising, 28(5), 807-842. De Houwer, J.; Baeyens, F. & Field, A.F. (2005), “Associative learning of likes and dislikes: Some current controversies and possible ways forward”, in: Cognition and Emotion, 19, 161-174. De Houwer, J.; Thomas, S. & Baeyens, F. (2001), “Associative learning of likes and dislikes: A review of 25 years of research on human evaluative conditioning”, in: Psychological Bulletin, 127(6), 853-869. Fennis, B.M. & Bakker, A.B. (2001) “Stay tuned - We will be back right after these messages: Need to evaluate moderates the transfer of irritation in advertising”, in: Journal of Advertising, 30(3), 15-25. Ferraro, R. & Avery, R.J. (2000) “Brand appearances on prime-time television”, in: Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising, 22(2), 1-15. Friedman, M. (1985) “The changing language of a consumer society: Brand name usage in popular American novels in the post-war era”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 11(4), 927-938. Gould, S.J. & Gupta, P.B. (2006) “Come on down: How consumers view game shows and the products placed in them”, in: Journal of Advertising, 35(1), 65-81. Graser, M. (2005), “McDonald’s buying way into hip hop song lyrics”, in: Advertising Age, March 23, 2005. Herd, D. (2005), “Changes in the prevalence of alcohol use in rap song lyrics, 1979-1997”, in: Addiction, 100, 1258-1269. Hoffman, W., De Houwer, J., Perugini, M., Baeyens, F. & Crombez, G. (2010), “Evaluative conditioning in humans: A meta-analysis”, Psychological Bulletin, 136(3), 390-421. Holloway, L. (2002), “Hip hop sales pop: Pass the Courvoisier and count the cash”, in: New York Times, September 2, 2002. La Ferle, C. & Edwards, S.M. (2006) “Product placement: How brands appear on television”, in: Journal of Advertising, 35(4), 65-86. Lee, A. & Labroo, A.A. (2004), “The effect of conceptual and perceptual fluency on brand evaluation”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 31, 151-165. Lee, M. & Faber, R.J. (2007) “Effects of product placement in on-line games on brand memory: A perspective of the limited-capacity model of attention”, in: Journal of Advertising, 36(4), 75-90. Mackay, T., Ewing, M., Newton, F. & Windisch, L. (2009) “The effect of product placement in computer games on brand attitude and recall”, in: International Journal of Advertising, 28(3), 423-438. Mackie, D.E. & Asuncion, A.G. (1990) “On-line and memory-based modification of attitudes: Determinants of message recall-attitude change correspondence”, in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 59(1), 5-16. Martin, B.A.S. & Collins, B.A. (2002) “Violence and consumption imagery in music videos”, in: European Journal of Marketing, 36(7/8), 855-873. Matthes, J., Schemer, C. & Wirth, W. (2007) “More than meets the eye – Investigating the hidden impact of brand placements in television magazines”, in: International Journal of Advertising, 26(4), 477-503. McCracken, G. (1989), “Who is the celebrity endorser? Cultural foundation of the endorsement process”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 16(3), 310-321. McSweeney, F.K. & Bierley, C. (1984), “Recent developments in classical conditioning”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 11, 619-631. Nelson, M. R. (2002) “Recall of brand placements in computer/video games”, in: Journal of Advertising Research, 42(2), 80-92. Paivio, A. (1986) “Mental representations”. New York: Oxford University Press.
The Impact of Brand Name Placement in Song Lyrics on Brand Attitudes
33
Petty, R.E., Cacioppo, J.T. & Schumann, D. (1983) “Central and peripheral routes to advertising effectiveness: The moderating role of involvement”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 10(2), 135-146. Russell, C.A. (2002) “Investigating the effectiveness of product placements in television shows: The role of modality and plot connection congruence on brand memory and attitude”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 29(3), 306-318. Russell, C.A. & Stern, B.B. (2006) “Consumers, characters and products: A balance model of sitcom product placement effects”, in: Journal of Advertising, 35(1), 7-21. Schemer, C., Matthes, J., Wirth, W. & Textor, S. (2008) “Does ‘Passing the Courvoisier’ always pay off? Positive and negative evaluative conditioning effects of brand placements in music videos”, in: Psychology & Marketing, 25(10), 923-943. Schiffman, L.G. & Kanuk, L.L. (2006), “Consumer behavior”, ninth edition, Pearson Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ. Schneider, L.-P. & Cornwell, T.B. (2005) “Cashing in on crashed via brand placement in computer games”, in: International Journal of Advertising, 24(3), 321-343. Stuart, E.; Shimp, T.A. & Engle, R.W. (1987), “Classical conditioning of consumer attitudes: Four experiments in an advertising context”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 15, 334-349. Sweldens, S.; Van Osselaer, S.M.J. & Janiszewski, C. (2010), “Evaluative conditioning procedures and the resilience of conditioned brand attitudes”, in: Journal of Consumer Research, 37, 473489. Till, B.D. & Shimp, T. (1998) “Endorsers in advertising: The case of negative celebrity information”, in: Journal of Advertising, 27(1), 67-74. Till, B.D., Stanley, S.M. & Priluck, R. (2008), “Classical conditioning and celebrity endorsers: An examination of belongingness and resistance to extinction”, in: Psychology & Marketing, 25(2), 179-196. Van Reijmersdal, E.A., Neijens, P.C. & Smith, E.G. (2007) “Effects of television brand placement on brand image”, in: Psychology & Marketing, 24(5), 403-420. Van Reijmersdal, E.A., Neijens, P.C. & Smith, E.G. (2009) “A new branch of advertising: Reviewing factors that influence reactions to product placement”, in: Journal of Advertising Research, 49(4), 429-449. Wiles, M.A. & Danielova, A. (2009) “The worth of product placement in successful films: An event study analysis”, in: Journal of Marketing, 73(4), 44-63. Woltman-Elpers, J.L.C.M., Wedel, M. & Pieters, R.G.M. (2003) “Why do consumers stop viewing television commercials? Two experiments on the influence of moment-to-moment entertainment and information value”, in: Journal of Marketing Research, 40 (4), 437-453. Yang, M. & Roskos-Ewoldson, D.R. (2007) “The effectiveness of brand placements in the movies: Levels of placements, explicit and implicit memory, and brand-choice behavior”, in: Journal of Communication, 57(3), 469-489. Zajonc, R.B. (1968), “Attitudinal Effects of Mere Exposure”, in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Monographs, 9, 1-27.
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials Martin K. J. Waiguny, University of Klagenfurt, Austria Ralf Terlutter, University of Klagenfurt, Austria
1
Introduction
Advergames are a new and fast-growing category of interactive advertising tools (Faber et al, 2004). Most of the common advergames can be described as casual browser games constructed around one particular brand, and in most cases they are available for free either on the manufacturer’s own site or on a high-traffic website (Lee and Youn, 2008; Svahn, 2005; Waiguny and Terlutter, 2009). Like TV advertising, advergames are part of marketing communications and usually promote only one brand. From the advertisers’ point of view, the main objectives of marketing communications are to foster brand awareness, to emotionalize brand attitude, and to foster brand relationships. However, advergames are different from TV advertising in several key ways (active vs. passive reception, non/low vs. high interactivity while exposed to the brand, exposure time etc.).The basic research question addressed by this study is: In terms of advertising effects, how do advergames differ from traditional TV advertising? A further research aim was to gain a better understanding of the ways in which children recognize the commercial and persuasive intent of marketing media (Eagle, 2007; Singer and Singer, 1998). Children from age 8 or so start to develop cognitive defense capabilities against commercial persuasion (Nairn and Fine, 2008). But little is known as to whether these defense mechanisms are effective when children are confronted with new and convergent forms of persuasive media (Wright, Friestad and Boush, 2005). The insights into this question gained from this research would have implications for media literacy education (Turnipseed and Rask, 2007; Wollslager, 2009). Therefore a further research focus of this study is: Do children understand the commercial intent of advergames as compared to TV adverts? Does children’s persuasion knowledge influence their perception of advergames?
S. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_3, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
36 2
Waiguny and Terlutter
Differences between Advergames and TV Commercials
Playing an advergame is very different from watching television. Nakatsu et al. (2005) characterize playing games as an integrated experience of physical and mental presence which leads to a higher degree of activation and arousal than is the case with regular TV advertising (Nakatsu et al., 2005). While playing an advergame, children are likely to be more active and their cognitive efforts will be greater than when watching a TV commercial (Grodal, 2000). Hence, we propose our first hypothesis: H1: Advergames will be perceived as more exciting than TV ads. With regard to cognitive efforts, the cognitive process is constrained by individuals’ limited information processing capacity (Eyseneck and Keane, 2000; Kahneman, 1973; Annie Lang, 2000; A. Lang, 2006). Gamers have to use this limited capacity to process the gameplay and anticipate the ongoing gaming situation (Grodal, 2000), which might distract players from the featured brand (Grigorovici and Constantin, 2004; Nelson, 2005). TV ads are constructed around a single strong brand message supported by audiovisual elements (Maher et al., 2006) which are probably not as distracting as the gameplay. A comparison between sponsorship (brand placement) in a gaming environment and in a TV setting of an NASCAR race found that brand recall in the TV setting was higher than brand recall in the game setting (Walsh et al., 2008). Hypothesis H2 reads: H2: Brand recall will be lower in the advergame setting than in the TV ad setting. However, encouraging brand recall is not the only aim of an advergame. Fostering associations with the brand or the product is a further important objective as the brand will become embedded in a network of mental associations (e.g., Sutherland and Sylvester, 2000). Games thus make it possible to convey messages through simulation and direct interaction (Ritterfeld and Weber, 2006) as well as through the rhetoric of the gameplay (Bogost, 2007). In consequence, an incidental and implicit learning effect occurs (Auty and Lewis, 2003; Ritterfeld and Weber, 2006) as the associative networks in children’s procedural memories are extended or strengthened by the showing of a brand or a product in a special scene (Auty and Lewis, 2003). Thus it is not only brand recall which is important, various episodes, characters, rhetorical scenes (like scenes of what you can do when consuming the product) assume a significance. Gamers spend much more time on and have more exposure to message elements than is the case when viewers watch a scripted TV commercial. Moreover, gamers pay a lot of attention to the game as learning the gameplay is the major
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
37
task in this situation (van Lankveld et al., 2010). As a consequence, if elements of the brand or product are placed within the gameplay area rather than outside the main gameplaying area, these elements will be recognized to a higher extent than from watching a TV commercial although in the case of TV no distracting elements feature in the commercial. H3: The recognition of product related elements will be higher in the advergame setting than in the TV ad setting. In most cases, entertainment leads to positive emotions and a feeling of control of and excitement regarding the situation (Früh, 2003). It can be expected that such feelings will tend to be stronger with advergames than in the TV viewing situation (Grodal, 2000). Gamers are active and are more likely to enter into a flow experience (Csikszentmihalyi, 1988; Sherry, 2004), whereas watching TV is more likely to be a passive task (Nakatsu et al., 2005). According to the excitation transfer theory (Zillmann, 1971; Zillmann et al., 1972), this excitement is likely to be transferred to the current situation and to other stimuli (i.e. the brand). Hence, we expect that gamers will like an advergame more than a TV ad (treatment liking, i.e. the attitude towards the ad). Given the fairly robust link between attitude towards the ad (in terms of cognitive and affective judgement) and attitude towards the brand (Edell and Burke, 1987; MacKenzie and Lutz, 1989; Shiffman and Kanuk, 2007, p. 247f), especially in the fast-moving consumer goods markets (FMCG), we also expect that gamers will thus have a more positive attitude towards the brand. Youn and Lee (2005) have already demonstrated this relationship in the context of advergames. Ahn (2008) showed that liking the game positively influenced perception of the brand (brand beliefs, brand personality). Hence, also a choicepreference for the brand directly after watching or playing should be influenced more strongly by an advergame than by a TV commercial. We further analyze WOMI (Word Of Mouth Intention) – the intention to recommend the advergame/TV ad - as well as the intention to reuse the advergame or the intention to view the TV ad again. Most children at elementary school level do not actually make buying decisions themselves, but rather influence their parents’ buying decisions through pestering (McNeal, 1992; Valkenburg and Cantor, 2001). Pestering intention on behalf of the brand is included in the study and we expect higher pestering intention in the advergame setting than in the TV ad setting due to more positive brand attitudes. Thus we derive the following hypotheses: H4: Children in the advergame setting as compared to children in the TV ad setting will show higher values in all of the following areas:
38
Waiguny and Terlutter
Liking of the treatment (TL) Intention to recommend the treatment to others (WOMI) Intention to reuse the treatment (RUI) Attitude towards the promoted brand (ATTB) Intention to pester for the brand (PI) Preference for the brand (PREF)
In this study, research is conducted not only into the affect-driven effects of the entertainment provided by the different media, but also into children’s more cognition-driven persuasion knowledge (PK). Children develop their PK of advertising as they grow older and receive more education (Boush et al., 1994; Friestad and Wright, 1994; John Roedder, 1999a; John Roedder and Cole, 1986; Roedder and Whitney, 1986). According to the Persuasion Knowledge Model (Friestad and Wright, 1994), individuals typically understand the persuasive purpose of a message if they recognize the agent, if they have a general awareness that a message is being delivered with the intention of persuading them, and if they know about the tactics and structures employed by the persuasive message. PK is also related to attitudes towards advertising in general: PK comes into play as skepticism and counterargument if an individual’s attitude towards advertising is more negative (Campell and Kirmani, 2008). In an advertising context, PK only then becomes activated and leads to coping behavior if the ad is recognized as such (Wei et al., 2008). However, very young children are not able to distinguish between the different forms and intentions of commercial, informational or entertaining TV programs. This type of cognitive ability develops between the ages of 4 and 7. Children aged from 8 to 10 are more likely to identify commercials and understand both the commercial content and the persuasive intent. At 10, they will probably be able to understand both the persuasive intent and various persuasion tactics which are being employed, whereas children older than 12 will generally understand the full range of advertising tactics (John Roedder, 1999b; John Roedder, 2002; John Roedder and Whitney, 1986; Robertson and Rossiter, 1974; John Roedder, 1981; Valkenburg and Cantor, 2001). However, PK is not only influenced by children’s physical and cognitive development but also by the education they have received regarding media and media impact (Friestad an Wright, 1994; Kunkel, 2001). Above all, training in media literacy, i.e. a special educational focus that encourages children to review TV programmes critically (Singer and Singer, 1998), especially commercials (Eagle, 2007), influences their PK. Hence, we expect that children’s PK will negatively influence their liking of the treatment and the outcome variables related to brand attitude. H5: Active persuasion knowledge will negatively influence the
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
39
Liking of the treatment (TL) Intention to recommend the treatment to others (WOMI) Intention to reuse the treatment (RUI). Attitude towards the promoted brand (ATTB)
However, most media literacy training is tailored to support understanding of the persuasive intent of TV commercials. New forms of persuasive techniques and subliminal communication tools such as advergames are frequently not included in children’s media literacy education. Hence, we expect that PK will have less of an impact on responses to advergames than is the case with TV advertising. An expected consequence is that psychological coping behaviors such as a more negative and skeptical evaluation of the message sender or the brand which is being promoted (Brown and Krishna, 2004; Campbell and Kirmani, 2000; Wood, Nelson, Atkinson, and Lane, 2008) will have a lower impact on advergames than on TV advertising. The expectation is that children are likely to have been educated to decode TV advertising, but not to decode advergames. In addition, as a result of the more engaging gaming situation the cognitive resources available to identify commercial content in a game are more limited (Annie Lang, 2009; Nairn and Fine, 2008). Hence we expect practically no PK influence, even when it is activated, on the variables analyzed in this study in the advergame setting. Recent studies focusing on advergames and PK indeed have found no PK influence on the evaluation of the advergame and the brand in question (Mallinckrodt and Mizerski, 2007), or only very weak influence (Waiguny et al., 2010). This means that children - even if they already have high PK - will evaluate the treatment (advergame vs. TV), the brand, and the behavioral measures more favorably in the advergame setting than in the TV ad setting. H6: Active persuasion knowledge will moderate the dependent variables. In the TV ad setting, children with high persuasion knowledge will evaluate the game and subsequently all game-related and brand-related attitudinal and intentional variables less favorably than children with low persuasion knowledge, whereas in the advergame setting, persuasion knowledge will not have a moderating effect.
3
The Role of Challenge in Influencing Children through Games
To gain a deeper insight into what actually happens when children are playing advergames and its relationship to persuasion, we finally investigate the role of challenge in the game. In general, we predict that advergames will be more entertaining than TV commercials; but it is also necessary to understand what
40
Waiguny and Terlutter
happens if an advergame itself is not complex enough to truly challenge the gamer. On the one hand, if the level of game challenge is low, gamers will not pay full attention to the gameplay, and will also need less time and feel bored by the game (Chen, 2007; van Lankveld et al., 2010). On the other hand, if a game is too challenging or hard to use or interact with, children might feel overchalleged and even feel negative emotions. However, as they engage in trying to understand the game, they will have a much longer exposure time. If the challenge of a game matches kids’ expectations and skills, they will feel positive emotions, and the time spent on playing the game will be perceived as passing very quickly (Gilleade et al., 2005). In terms of persuasion, the level of challenge is important as it, firstly, regulates the focused attention and the time spent on the advergame. As mentioned previously, learning effects via advergames are somewhat incidental, not conscious (Bogost, 2007), and the more a player engages with the game the stronger such effects are. Hence we predict that if the challenge level is low, children will need less time to finish the advergame and subsequently will remember fewer elements of the game since they do not focus on the gameplay to the same extent as optimallychallenged or over-challenged children. Drawing on the perceptual fluency theory (e.g., Reber et al., 2004; Reber et al., 1998) and the mere exposure effect (Zajonc, 1968, 2001; Zajonc et al., 1974), attitudes will increase by the repetition of exposure and an associative learning effect will occur. Secondly, attitude towards the brand is also regulated by the affect transfer, as only in the case of optimal challenge do positive affects occur. Over- and underchallenged children will thus show a negative affect transfer (Lazzaro, 2008). To sum up, optimally challenged children will show the highest level of influence on the attitude towards the brand. As over-challenged children need more time to complete the advergame, they will remember most of the game elements. However, the persuasive effect will be diminished by the negative affect. The last hypothesis therefore reads: H7: The level of challenge is related to time, recognition and attitude towards the brand. Under-challenged children will need less time, remember the fewest elements and will have the least favourable attitude towards the brand. Optimally-challenged children will display the most favourable level of attitude towards the brand, needing a moderate amount of time for the game and subsequently exhibiting a moderate degree of recognition of gaming elements. Over-challenged children will need much more time and recognize the most elements, but will only have a moderately favourable attitude towards the brand.
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
4
41
Study
In order to test the proposed hypotheses, a study involving 51 children was carried out in January 2010 in an elementary school. To control for developmental factors in the understanding of the intentions underlying advertising, only children aged between 8 and 10 were included in the study, all of whom, according to the literature, can be expected to be at roughly the same developmental stage of knowledge about advertising (John Roedder, 2002; Livingstone and Helsper, 2006).
4.1
Method and Measures
Design and Treatment: A 2 (TV vs. advergame) x 2 (high vs. low PK) quasiexperimental design was chosen. First demographic questions about gaming, TV and eating habits were asked by trained interviewers in one-to-one interviews. Afterwards the children were randomly divided into two groups: one group (29 children) was asked to play an advergame and the second group (22) children were shown a TV advertisement. The brand “Nesquik Duo” was chosen for the purposes of the study. Nesquik Duo broadcasts a TV spot in which the Nesquik mascot runs on a brown-and-white (brown and white chocolate) colored table, finds a package of the product, which it jumps into using a spoon made of chocolate. Then the cereal is poured into a bowl and the mascot also falls into the bowl, whereupon everything turns into a swirl and the mascot wakes up from a dream and starts a breakfast featuring the product and children. The corresponding advergame uses the same content elements. The player has to collect the product in the brown-and-white environment of a table with a breakfast bowl. This part of the game is offered at 4 levels with time limits (between 35 and 25 seconds); each level ends when the player locates a swirl, which is the exit to the next level. At the end, the player is allowed 3 chances to jump into a package with the aid of a brown spoon. The children were to play the game to the end in order to exclude the negative influence of interrupting a pleasurable experience. Afterwards the children were questioned by the interviewers about their perceptions of the game and then about their knowledge of advertising tactics. The time taken to complete the game was recorded for the individual gamers. During the questioning of the children, terms such as advergame or advertisement were deliberately not used to refer to the treatment. Measures of independent variables: Knowledge about the persuasive tactics employed in advertising and beliefs about advertising in general were measured using a simplified version, specially adapted for this age group, of the scale of beliefs about advertiser tactics used by Boush et al. (1994), This scale consists of beliefs about how credible advertising is, beliefs about the intention and
42
Waiguny and Terlutter
persuasive character of advertising, and the selling intent of advertising. Identification of commercial character was measured by asking: “Did any brand appear in the game/film?” If the child named any brand, this was coded as 1, and if not as 0. In addition, general attitude towards advertising was measured by asking: “Please indicate how much you like advertising in general!” In addition, in the case of the advergame group, the level of challenge was measured by four variables, namely “The time passed rather quickly”, “The game was difficult”, “I quickly understood what I was meant to do in the game”, “I quickly found out how to handle the game”. Measures of the dependent variables: Brand recall (BR) was measured by asking the children an open-ended question: “Did any brand appear in the game?” If the child named Nesquik, this was coded 1, any other or no brand was coded 0. Brand attitude (ATTB) was measured using the brand attitude scale for children (Pecheux and Derbaix, 1999). Excitement (EX) was measured by asking whether “The game/film was exciting.” Recognition was measured by 18 elements, some of which appeared in the game/ TV ad, whereas others did not. If the child recognized the element correctly (i.e. correctly identified whether or not it had been featured in the game or ad) it was coded with +1. If recognized incorrectly, it was coded -1. An index (RECOG) ranging from -18 to +18 was calculated, the higher the index score the higher the correct recognition of elements. The time taken was measured in seconds. All question-scales were measured on a 6-point Likert scale supported by a visual classification of the end-points of the scale continuum by using a hook and a cross (indicating right or wrong) (Tinson, 2009). Liking advertising (AL) in general and liking the treatment (TL) were measured by using a 6-point smiley scale, ranging from “like it very much” to “don’t like it at all”.
4.2
Results
26 male and 25 female children aged 8 (33.3%), 9 (45.1%), and 10 (21.5%) took part in the study. 98% of the children stated that they have access to a computer. Table 1 provides an overview of the children’s TV viewing and computergaming habits. First, after correcting the data for input errors and missing values, it was checked whether there are significant differences in the independent variables in the groups with regard to gender, age, TV viewing and videogame habits. These checks indicated that there was no significant difference on p<.1. Due to low loadings, three items of the attitude scale had to be removed. From the remaining items, a mean index was calculated.
43
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
4.2.1
Results of the Mean Comparisons
On average it took the children 4:50 minutes (min: 3:06, max: 13:50) to complete the advergame. The length of the TV ad was 0:31 minutes, hence the average exposure to brand-related stimuli is 8½ times longer in the advergame setting. To test the first set of hypotheses (H1-H4) one-way ANOVA and χ²analysis were conducted. Table 1 reports the findings that hypotheses H1, H2, H3 and H4 are all supported by the data at least at p<.1 level. Children perceive the advergame as more exciting (Madvergame: 4.72; MTV: 2.68) but in the advergame setting significantly fewer children (advergame: 44.8%, TV: 81,8%) were able to recall the brand unaided. Furthermore, as demonstrated in Table 1, both liking the treatment and brand-related measures are higher in the advergame setting than in the TV ad setting. This indicates that children’s perception of the advergame is more favourable than their perception of the TV ad and also the related behavioral intentions are higher. In terms of recognition (RECOG), children can remember far more elements correctly in the advergame setting (Madvergame: 7.03) than in the TV ad setting (MTV: 4.09). Table 1: Results of the One Way-ANOVA and Cross-Tabs Analysis Dependent Variable EX RECOG TL ATTB RI WOMI RC of brand PI PREF
4.2.2
M (overall)/ % (overall) 3.84 5.76 4.88 4.08 3.55 3.24 60.8% 26.5% 28.6%
M (TV)/ % (TV) 2.68 4.09 4.32 3.48 2.37 2.59 81.8% 13.6% 18.6%
M (Advergame)/ % (Advergame) 4.72 7.03 5.31 4.54 4.45 3.72 44.8% 37.0% 37.0%
F/ χ² 13.70 14.04 9.58 4.55 16.23 4.25 7.18 3.41 2.11
p .00** .00** .00** .04** .00** .05** .01** .06* .16n.s.
Results of the Interaction with Activated Persuasion Knowledge
To introduce PK in the context of the study, beliefs about the tactics employed in advertising (credibility of advertising, persuasive intent of advertising, selling intent of the advertiser), attitude towards advertising, and the identification of the commercial character of the game/ad were used to divide the group of subjects into an activated PK and a non-activated PK group by using two-step cluster analysis. The results indicate that for children with activated PK the knowledge about advertising tactics was higher and the attitude towards
44
Waiguny and Terlutter
advertising in general was less favourable. Hence ability to identify the commercial character is related to the level of persuasion knowledge. A twoway MANOVA for the dependent variables was computed, with the grouping variable and the calculated cluster variable as independent variables. Table 4 reports the results. Table 2: Means of the dependent variables of the 2x2 design Grouping Variables TL TV ad PK act PK inact Total adver- PK act game PK inact Total total PK act PK inact Total ATTB TV ad PK act PK inact Total adver- PK act game PK inact Total total PK act PK inact Total
m std.dev. 4.06 1.11 5.50 0.58 4.32 1.17 5.38 0.77 5.25 1.34 5.31 1.11 4.61 1.17 5.30 1.22 4.88 1.23 3.03 1.86 5.50 0.61 3.48 1.95 4.62 1.52 4.48 1.74 4.54 1.62 3.69 1.87 4.69 1.62 4.08 1.83
n Grouping Variables 18 RUI TV ad PK act 4 PK inact 22 total 13 adver- PK act game PK inact 16 29 total 31 total PK act 20 PK inact 51 total 18 WOMI TV ad PK act 4 PK inact 22 total 13 adver- PK act game PK inact 16 29 total 31 total PK act 20 PK inact 51 total
m std.dev. 1.83 1.34 4.75 1.5 2.36 1.76 5.23 1.01 3.81 2.2 4.45 1.88 3.26 2.08 4.00 2.08 3.55 2.09 2.22 1.63 5.25 0.96 2.77 1.93 5.23 1.24 5.50 1.37 5.38 1.29 3.48 2.1 5.45 1.28 4.25 2.05
n 18 4 22 13 16 29 31 20 51 18 4 22 13 16 29 31 20 51
On the inclusion of PK in the model, the main effect of the grouping variable becomes insignificant except for recommendation intention and re-usage intention, which indicates that all brand-related dependent variables are significantly influenced by PK except for the beliefs that the brand is healthy, and the re-usage intention regarding the treatment. Hence, H5 is partly supported. The interaction effects between the treatment groups and PK showed that all dependent variables interact as predicted, indicating that children with activated PK who watch the commercial will evaluate it less positively and will also be more skeptical regarding the brand, whereas no differences are observable between high and low PK in the gaming group. Table 5 reports the means and tests of the MANOVA analysis.
45
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
Table 3: Main and Interaction Effects Source Group
PK
Group X PK
4.2.3
Dependent Variable TL ATTB RUI WOMI TL ATTB RUI WOMI TL ATTB RUI WOMI
df
F 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
2.195 .260 5.239 11.910 3.235 4.353 1.944 12.192 4.701 5.382 16.270 8.535
p .15n.s. .61n.s. .03** .00** .08* .04** .17n.s. .00** .04** .03** .00** .01**
Results of the Influence of Challenge on Recognition and Persuasion
To analyze the level of challenge, a centroid cluster analysis was used to divide the children who played the advergame into three groups. Table 4 reports the distribution and the mean values. Using this grouping variable a MANOVA was calculated. As predicted under-challenged (M: 248 sec.), need significantly (F=5.867, p=.008) less time than optimally- (M: 411 sec.) and over-challenged (M: 607 sec.) children, to finish the game. In terms of recognition underchallenged subjects (M: 4.40) remember less than optimally- (M: 7.48) and over-challenged kids (M: 7.00), however this effect was only significant on p<.1 level (F=2.500, p=.100). Checking the influence of challenge on attitude towards the brand, the predicted pattern that the optimally-challenged (M: 4.58) will show higher values than under-challenged (M: 3.77) and over-challenged (M: 4.05) children was found, but the influence was not on a statistically significant level (F=.513, p=.605). Hence H7 is partially supported by our data.
46
Waiguny and Terlutter
Table 4: Results of the Challenge Grouping Item
The time passed rather quickly I quickly found out how to use the game. The game was difficult. I quickly understood what I was meant to do in the game.
4.3
underchallenged (n=5) 2.80
optimallychallenged (n=18) 5.94
overchallenged (n=6) 3.33
5.80
5.44
3.33
1.40
1.94
4.67
5.80
5.61
3.17
Selected Limitations
This study is limited by several factors. First only one game (with the same content elements as the corresponding TV ad) was tested. Moreover the sample was very small and only from one school, thus factors like social environment, and peer and family influence on PK could not be evaluated. Finally, the lowPK group in the TV advertising setting was very small because of the high recognition rate of persuasive intent in the case of the TV ad.
5
Discussion and Implications
This is the first study which directly compares the effects of an advergame with the effects of a comparable TV commercial in the field of advertising to children. The results clearly indicate that children perceive the game as more exciting. Moreover, evidence was found of the impact of limited information processing capacity on responses as the children who played the game were less likely than those in the TV group to recall the brand promoted in-game because they had been distracted by the gameplay. Furthermore, the children indicated that in the advergame setting they tended to rate the advergame and subsequently also all brand-related measures more positively. This could be the end of the story, but this more positive evaluation of the advergame is not only a direct result of the entertainment provided by the game. It is also the result to some extent of the fact that some of the children were not aware that an advergame is a form of advertising. Even in the case of those children who did realize that they had encountered a type of advertising, commercial PK is not activated to anything like the same extent as with TV advertising. In the case of the TV ad, the activated PK leads to a more skeptical
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
47
evaluation as a coping behavior. An obvious conclusion is that effective education is needed to help kids cope with these new forms of branded entertainment which target children. As Wollslager (2009) and also Stern and An (2009) have demonstrated, even brief training/induction to product placement in games leads to enhanced rates of identifying the commercial character of the advergame. But merely identifying the underlying character of the game is not enough. Like persuasive games in education (Bogost, 2007), advergames employ a lot of hidden persuasive content. The more the gameplay conveys the brand message (congruence of game goals and brand communication goals) and the higher the integration of the product, the stronger the persuasive attempts become (Smith and Just, 2009). We also showed that exposure time to the advergame is much longer than exposure to a TV ad. With the advergame experience thus much stronger than the experiencing of a TV ad, the persuasive power of advergames could well be rather strong. Also the level of challenge relates to persuasion, as optimally challenged children play longer and remember more message elements. Thus associative networks are built. However, no evidence for the relationship between challenge and persuasion in terms of brand attitude was found in this data. This may well be due to the small sample size. The general tendency for the relationships followed the predictions. The results of the study have clear implications for media literacy issues. Thus it would seem advisable to train children to be able to identify the persuasive elements of advergames. In addition to being able to recognize the bare fact that a brand or product is being placed in a game, media literacy training should also aim to help clarify more complex relationships such as typical messages delivered by the gameplay like: “If you eat the product, you’ll be able to jump higher.”
6
References
Ahn, D. (2008). The Interpretation of the Messages in an Advergame: The Effects on Brand Personality Perception. Paper presented at the Annual meeting of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication. Retrieved from http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p272095_index.htm Auty, S. & Lewis, C. (2003). The "Delicious Paradox": Preconscious Processing of Product Placements by Children. In L. J. Shrum (Ed.), The Psychology of Entertainment Media: Blurring the Lines Between Entertainment and Persuasion (pp. 117-133). Mahawah: Lawrence Erlbaum. Bogost, I. (2007). Persuasive Games: The Expressive Power of Video Games. Cambridge: MIT Press.
48
Waiguny and Terlutter
Boush, D. M., Friestad, M. & Rose, G. M. (1994). Adolescent Skepticism toward TV Advertising and Knowledge of Advertiser Tactics. Journal of Consumer Research, 21(1), 165-175. Brown, C. L. & Krishna, A. (2004). The skeptical shopper: A metacognitive account for the effects of default options on choice. Journal of Consumer Research, 31(3), 529-539. Campbell, M. C. & Kirmani, A. (2000). Consumers' Use of Persuasion Knowledge: The Effects of Accessibility and Cognitive Capacity on Perceptions of an Influence Agent. Journal of Consumer Research, 27(1), 69-83. Campell, M. C. & Kirmani, A. (2008). I Know What You're Doing, and Why You're Doing it: The Role of Persuasion Knowledge Model in Consumer Research. In C. P. Haugtvedt, F. Kardes & P. M. Herr (Eds.), Handbook of Consumer Psychology (pp. 549-572). New York: Lawrence & Erlbaum. Chen, J. (2007). Flow in Games (and everything Else). Commnications of the ACM, 50(4), 31-34. Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1988). The flow experience and its significance for human psychology. In M. Csikszentmihalyi & I. S. Csikszentmihalyi (Eds.), Optimal experience: Psychological studies of flow in consciousness (pp. 15-35). New York: Cambridge University Press. Eagle, L. (2007). Commercial Media Literacy What Does it Do, to Whom-and Does it Matter? Journal of Advertising, 36(2), 101-110. Edell, J. A. & Burke, M. C. (1987). The Power of Feelings in Understanding Advertising Effects. Journal of Consumer Research, 14(3), 421-433. Eyseneck, M. W., & Keane, M. T. (2000). Cognitive Psychology a Student's handbook. Hove: Psychology Press. Faber, R. J., Lee, M. & Nan, X. (2004). Advertising and the Consumer Information Environment Online. American Behavioral Scientist, 48(4), 447-466. Friestad, M. & Wright, P. (1994). The Persuasion Knowledge Model: How People Cope with Persuasion Attempts. The Journal of Consumer Research, 21(1), 1-31. Früh, W. (2003). Triadisch-dynamische Unterhaltungstheorie (TDU). In W. Früh & H.-J. Stiehler (Eds.), Theorie der Unterhaltung: Ein interdisziplinärer Diskurs (pp. 27-56). Köln: Herbert von Halem Verlag. Gilleade, K.M., Dix, A. & Allanson, J. (2005). Affective Videogames and Modes of Affective Gaming: Assist Me, Challenge Me, Emote Me. DiGRA, 1-7. Grigorovici, D. M. & Constantin, C. D. (2004). Experiencing Interactive Advertising beyond Rich Media: Impacts of Ad Type and Presence on Brand Effectiveness in 3D Gaming Immersive Virtual Environments. Journal of Interactive Advertising, 5(1), 1-18. Grodal, T. (2000). Video Games and the Pleasures of Control. In D. Zillmann & P. Vorderer (Eds.), Media Entertainment: The Psychology of its Appeal (pp. 197-213). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum. John Roedder, D. (1999a). Consumer Socialization of Children: A Retrospective Look at Twenty Five Years of Research. Journal of Consumer Research, 26(3), 183-213. John Roedder, D. (1999b). Through the Eyes of a Child. Children’s Knowledge and Understanding of Advertising. In M. C. Macklin & L. Carlson (Eds.), Advertising to children. Concepts and controversies (pp. 3-26): Thousand Oaks. John Roedder, D. (2002). Consumer socialization of children: A retrospective look at twenty-five years of research. In F. Hansen (Ed.), Children - Consumption, Advertising and Media (pp. 2589). Copenhagen. John Roedder, D. & Cole, C. A. (1986). Age Differences in Information Processing: Understanding Deficits in Young and Elderly Consumers. Journal of Consumer Research, 13(3), 297-315. John Roedder, D. & Whitney, J. C. (1986). The Development of Consumer Knowledge in Children: A Cognitive Structure Approach. Journal of Consumer Research, 12(4), 406-417. Kahneman, D. (1973). Attention and Effort. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
49
Kunkel, D. (2001). Children and Television Advertising. In D. G. Singer & J. R. Singer (Eds.), Handbook of Children and the Media (pp. 375-394). Thousand Oaks: Sage. Lang, A. (2000). The Limited Capacity Model of Mediated Message Processing. Journal of Communication, 50(1), 46-70. Lang, A. (2006). Using the limited capacity model of motivated mediated message processing to design effective cancer communication messages. Journal of Communication, 56. Lang, A. (2009). The Limited Capacity Model of Motivated Mediated Message Processing. In R. L. Nabi & M. B. Oliver (Eds.), The SAGE Handbook of Media Processes and Effects (pp. 193204). Los Angeles: SAGE. Lazzaro, N. (2008). Why we play: Affect and the Fun of Games: Designing Emotions for Games, Entertainment Interfaces and Interactive Products. In A. Sears & J. A. Jacko (Eds.), The HumanComputer Interaction Handbook: Fundamentals, Evolving Technologies, and Emerging Applications (pp. 679-700). New York: Lawrence Erlbaum. Lee, M. & Youn, S. (2008). Leading National Advertisers' Uses of Advergames. Journal of Current Issues & Research in Advertising, 30(2), 1-13. Livingstone, S. & Helsper, E. J. (2006). Does Advertising Literacy Mediate the Effects of Advertising on Children? A Critical Examination of Two Linked Research Literatures in Relation to Obesity and Food Choice. Journal of Communication, 56(3), 560-584. MacKenzie, S. B. & Lutz, R. J. (1989). An empirical examination of the structural antecedents of attitude toward the ad in an advertising pretesting context. (advertising). Journal of Marketing, v53(n2), p48(18). Maher, J. K., Hu, M. Y. & Kolbe, R. H. (2006). Children's recall of television ad elements: an examination of audiovisual effects. Journal of Advertising, 35(1), 23(11). Mallinckrodt, V. & Mizerski, D. (2007). The Effects of Playing an Advergame on Young Children's Perceptions, Preferences, and Requests. Journal of Advertising, 36(2), 87-100. McNeal, J. U. (1992). Kids as Customers: a Handbook of Marketing to Children. New York: Lexington Books. Nairn, A. & Fine, C. (2008). Who's Messing with My Mind? The Implications of Dual-process Models for the Ethics of Advertising to Children. International Journal of Advertising, 27(3), 447-470. Nakatsu, R., Rauterberg, M. & Vorderer, P. (2005). A New Framework for Entertainment Computing: From Passive to Active Experience Entertainment Computing - ICEC 2005 (pp. 112). Nelson, M. R. (2005). Exploring Consumer Response to "Advergaming". In C. P. Haugtvedt, K. A. Machleit & R. Yalch (Eds.), Online Consumer Psychology: Understanding and Influencing Consumer Behaviour in the Virtual World (pp. 167-194): Lawrence Erlbaum. Pecheux, C. & Derbaix, C. (1999). Children and Attitude toward the Brand: A New Measurement Scale. Journal of Advertising Research, 39(4), 19-27. Reber, R., Schwarz, N. & Winkielman, P. (2004). Processing Fluency and Aesthetic Pleasure: Is Beauty in the Perceiver's Processing Experience? Personality and Social Psychology Review, 8(4), 364-382. Reber, R., Winkielman, P. & Schwarz, N. (1998). Effects of Perceptual Fluency on Affective Judgments. Psychological Science, 9(1), 45-48. Ritterfeld, U. & Weber, R. (2006). Video Games for Entertainment and Education. In P. Vorderer & J. Bryant (Eds.), Playing Video Games: Motives, Responses and Consequences (pp. 399-412). Mahwah: Lawrence Erlbaum. Robertson, T. S. & Rossiter, J. R. (1974). Children and Commercial Persuasion: An Attribution Theory Analysis. The Journal of Consumer Research, 1(1), 13-20.
50
Waiguny and Terlutter
Roedder, D. L. (1981). Age Differences in Children's Responses to Television Advertising: An Information Processing Approach. Journal of Consumer Research, 8, 144-153. Sherry, J. L. (2004). Flow and Media Enjoyment. Communication Theory, 14(4), 328-347. Shiffman, L. G. & Kanuk, L. L. (2007). Consumer Behavior (9 ed.). New Jersey: Pearson. Singer, D. G. & Singer, J. L. (1998). Developing Critical Viewing Skills and Media Literacy in Children. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 557, 164-179. Smith, J. H. & Just, S. N. (2009). Playful Persuasion: The Rhetorical Potential of Advergames. Nordicom Review, 30(2), 53-68. Stern, S. & An, S. (2009). Increasing Children’s Understanding of Advergames’ Commercial Nature: Does an Advertising Literacy Lesson or Ad Break Make a Difference? Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Communication Association. Retrieved from http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p298021_index.html Sutherland, M. & Sylvester, A. K. (2000). Advertising and the Mind of the Consumer: What Works, What Doesn't, and why. St. Leonards: Allen & Unwin. Svahn, M. (2005). Future-proofing Advergaming: a Systematisation for the Media Buyer Proceedings of the second Australasian Conference on Interactive entertainment (Vol. 123, pp. 187-191). Tinson, J. (2009). Conducting Research with Children and Adolescents: Design, Methods and Empirical Cases. London: Goodfellow Publishing. Turnipseed, T. & Rask, A. (2007). Children’s Health and Advergaming: A Theoretical Study of Advertisement Driven Video Games, Product Placement, and Integrated Marketing Communication. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the NCA 93rd Annual Convention. Retrieved from http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p193018_index.html Valkenburg, P. M. & Cantor, J. (2001). The Development of a Child into a Consumer. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 22(1), 61-72. van Lankveld, G., Spronck, P., van den Herik, H. & Rauterberg, M. (2010). Incongruity-Based Adaptive Game Balancing. In H. van den Herik & P. Spronck (Eds.), Advances in Computer Games (Vol. 6048, pp. 208-220): Springer Berlin / Heidelberg. Waiguny, M. K. J., Nelson, M. R. & Terlutter, R. (2010). Persuading Playfully? The Effects of Persuasion Knowledge and Positive Affect on Children's Attitudes, Brand Beliefs and Behaviors. In W.-N. Lee (Ed.), Proceedings of the 2010 Conference of the American Academy of Advertising (pp. 67-70). Minneapolis: AAA. Waiguny, M. K. J. & Terlutter, R. (2009). Advergames: The Role of Entertainment in BrandRelated Outcomes for Children. In R. Terlutter, S. Diehl, M. Karmasin & E. Smit (Eds.), Proceedings of the 8th ICORIA. Klagenfurt: Alpen-Adria-University Klagenfurt. Walsh, P., Kim, Y., & Ross, S. D. (2008). Brand Recall and Recognition: A Comparison of Television and Sport Video Games as Presentation Modes. Sport Marketing Quarterly, 17, 201208. Wei, M. L., Fischer, E. & Main, K. J. (2008). An Examination of the Effects of Activating Persuasion Knowledge on Consumer Response to Brands Engaging in Covert Marketing. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 27(1), 34-44. Wollslager, M. E. (2009). Children's Awareness of Online Advertising on Neopets: The Effect of Media Literacy Training on Recall. SIMILE, 9(2), 31-53. Wood, M. L. M., Nelson, M. R., Atkinson, L. & Lane, J. B. (2008). Social Utility Theory: Guiding Labeling of VNRs as Ethical and Effective Public Relations. Journal of Public Relations Research, 20(2), 231-249. Wright, P. Friestad, M., & Boush, D. M. (2005). The Development of Marketplace Persuasion Knowledge in Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults. Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 24, 222-233.
Differences in Children’s Processing of Advergames and TV Commercials
51
Youn, S. & Lee, M. (2005). Advergame Playing Motivations and Effectiveness. In M. R. Stafford & R. J. Faber (Eds.), Advertising, Promotion and New Media (pp. 320-347). Armonk: M.E.Sharpe. Zajonc, R. B. (1968). Attitudinal Effects of Mere Exposure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 9(2 PART 2), 1-27. Zajonc, R. B. (2001). Mere Exposure: A Gateway to the Subliminal. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 10(6), 224-228. Zajonc, R. B., Markus, H. & Wilson, W. R. (1974). Exposure Effects and Associative Learning. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 10(3), 248-263. Zillmann, D. (1971). Excitation Transfer in Communication-mediated Aggressive Behavior. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 7(4), 419-434. Zillmann, D., Katcher, A. H. & Milavsky, B. (1972). Excitation transfer from physical exercise to subsequent aggressive behavior. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 8(3), 247-259.
Part II
Social Issues and Advertising
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages Martine Lewi, University of Antwerp, Belgium Patrick De Pelsmacker, University of Antwerp, Belgium
1
Introduction
Alzheimer’s disease is a devastating, incurable disease. The disease pathway is typically characterised by a long preclinical phase in which patients experience mild cognitive impairments (Visser et al, 2002). Medical research states that through early diagnosis of symptoms the disease process can be slowed down (Seltzer, 2007; Bain et al., 2008). The main concern is then to make the population at risk aware of the importance of early diagnosis and stimulate them to take responsible actions at the earliest stage of the onset of the disease. Very little is known about the efficacy of health communication in the domain of a fatal disease, where one can merely intervene in order to lengthen the time period in which the patient can still enjoy a reasonable quality of life. However, results of previous research on the emotional and cognitive responses to various message formats of (health) communication can serve as frameworks to analyze different types of health messages (Williams-Piehota et al., 2006; Morris et al., 2002; Bagozzi et al., 1999; Brown and Stayman, 1992; Petty et al., 1993; Mitchell, 1988; Petty and Cacioppo, 1986; Chaiken, 1980). The present study extends prior work in the area of emotional and rational persuasive communication to the domain of health communication, especially in the domain of Alzheimer’s disease. More particularly, this study aims at entangling the role of affect in the information processing and at investigating how affective reactions of older people to Alzheimer awareness messages varying in argument strength and affective tone of visuals are processed through affective and cognitive responses. Further, we investigate differences between men and women and between lowly and highly educated individuals.
2
Conceptual Framework and Research Questions
An Alzheimer awareness message may be processed either peripherally or centrally, depending on the involvement with the issue. Standard expectations (Petty and Cacioppo, 1986) imply that in high-involvement situations people S. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_4, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
56
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
would centrally process message arguments, while in low-involvement situations, peripheral processing would take place, and affective reactions to the message would drive responses. However, the question remains to what extent rational and affective message elements and affective and cognitive responses to these message formats play a role in central or peripheral message processing and judgment formation.
2.1
The Role of Affect in Developing Cognitive Responses about Alzheimer Awareness Messages
Forgas’ Affect Infusion Model (AIM) distinguishes four judgmental strategies, two low-affect infusion strategies (direct access and motivated processing) and two high-affect infusion strategies (heuristic and substantive processing). The AIM predicts that affect is unlikely to influence judgments during direct access or motivated processing. Affect should have an effect when heuristic or substantive processing is used (Schwarz and Clore, 2003; Fiedler, 1988, 1990; Fiedler et al., 1991; Forgas, 1991, 1992, 1995; Schwarz and Bless, 1991). Two underlying mechanisms of affect infusion are affect-as-information and affect priming. The affect-as-information theory suggests that rather than computing a judgment on the basis of recalled features of a target, individuals may ask themselves: 'How do I feel about it?' and in doing so, may be guided by their feelings to judge a message (Schwarz,1990; Schwarz and Clore, 2003). In the affect priming theory, affect can indirectly inform judgments by facilitating access to related cognitive categories (Bower, 1981; Isen, 1987). Hence, affect can prime the encoding, retrieval, and selective use of information in the constructive processing of judgments. Affect-priming is considered a broad and parsimonious principle that has implications for a variety of cognitive processes and suggests multiple avenues through which indirect affect infusion into judgments may occur (Forgas and Bower, 1988; Singer and Salovey, 1988). Within the AIM model, it is implied that it is in the course of substantive, constructive processing that affect is most likely to play a significant informational role in what is perceived, learned, and recalled and how stimulus information is interpreted. Thus stimuli that are perceived as positively affective should lead to paying closer attention to positive information, better learning such details, and making more positive interpretations of ambiguous information (Forgas, 1995). The AIM also implies that judgments about more complex stimuli (substantive processing context), requiring more elaborate processing and made without the benefit of objective evidence, should show greater affective effects. According to this research, substantive processing is more likely when the message is personally relevant or ambiguous. Previous research (e.g., Petty et al., 1993) reported that positive affect produces more positive judgments in both high- and
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
57
low-elaboration conditions. Several studies have found significant affect congruence in judgments and thoughts about persuasive messages, mostly under conditions of substantive processing (i.e., high elaboration likelihood; Petty et al., 1993). The fact that cognitive approaches to persuasive messages are mediated by affective message components is a prominent theme in advertising research (e.g., Ray and Batra, 1983; Batra and Ray, 1986; Edell and Burke, 1987; Cohen and Areni, 1991; Geuens and De Pelsmacker, 1999; Raghunathan and Pham, 1999). Their results indicate that affectively valenced messages can be important triggers of cognitive responses to messages. Applied to the domain of health, Salovey and Birnbaum (1989) found that affective reactions had a major influence on people's perceptions of symptoms of illness, their health efficacy judgments, and their expectations of future disease. Salovey also concluded that these effects are due to affect-priming mechanisms operating during substantive processing (Salovey et al., 1991). Affective responses to messages that are processed in a heuristic or a substantive way are expected to at least partly mediate the effect of message components on the cognitive reactions (thoughts) about the message. Since the role of the message components studied her (argument strength and affective tone of the visual) are unclear, we formulate a research question: RQ1: Does the affective reaction to Alzheimer messages mediate the effect of message components (the strength of the arguments and the affective valence of the visual in the message) on thoughts about the message?
2.2
The Role of Cognitive Responses about the Message in Developing Responses to the Alzheimer Issue
Message-evoked affective responses can influence subsequent evaluations of the (Alzheimer) issue in different ways. On the one hand, message-evoked affect may directly transfer to the evaluation of and the responses to the message and the issue, due to peripheral transfer or assimilation processes, such as the Affect Transfer Mechanism (e.g., Coulter, 1998). On the other hand, a message may be processed more centrally, in which case message-evoked thoughts may play a greater role, leading to a more systematic evaluation of the ad. This systematic evaluation is often assumed to be objective, but could be biased as well. The latter is the case, for example, when message-evoked feelings bias the viewers’ message thoughts in a feeling-congruent way and the viewers base their evaluation of the message and the issue on these thoughts (Cfr. ELM, Petty and Ca-
58
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
cioppo, 1981, 1986). The Alzheimer issue may for most people be a serious concern and therefore a simple transfer or assimilation effect seems less likely. People may be motivated to process the message more centrally because the message effectively transports them into a serious reality (Jeandrain 2001, 2004; Coyle and Thorson, 2001). Consequently, biased processing may be expected in which case message-evoked thoughts will substantially mediate the effect of message-evoked affect on the overall judgments about the message and the issue, and will bias these judgments in a communication-thoughts consistent way. Since it is unclear to what extent these mechanisms will prevail, we again formulate a research question: RQ2: Do thoughts about the Alzheimer awareness message mediate the effect of the affective response to the message on the attitude towards the message, perceived message substance and thoughts about Alzheimer disease? An overview of the mechanisms studied is given in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Conceptual framework of the study
Additionally, we explore to what extent these mechanisms differ across demographic groups. More particularly, we investigate whether men and women and low and high education segments of the population differ with respect to the mediating mechanism of affect and message thoughts.
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
3 3.1
59
Method Stimulus Development
Six Alzheimer awareness messages were developed in which two levels of argument strength (weak and strong) were combined with three pictures of different affective valence, i.e. negative, neutral and positive. These messages were aimed at convincing people to seek early treatment. Initially, nine Alzheimerrelated images were selected eliciting positive, neutral and negative affective reactions and six weak (but still realistic) and strong message texts were prepared. The message texts were based on the medical literature (Lopez et al., 2002). In a first pre-test, these images and texts were tested among a group of 326 individuals. The objective of the first pre-test was twofold: 1) test what images were perceived as affectively most negative, positive and neutral; 2) test which message wordings and combination of arguments received the lowest and highest score on argument strength. In a second pre-test, we tested one extra fine-tuned weak message text and three additional strong message texts. The three images used in the main study obtained the following significantly different scores on a seven-point affective valence scale: negative image (M=3.44), neutral image (M=4.65), positive image (M=5.88). After the second pre-test, two message texts were selected that obtained the following significantly different ratings on the seven-point message strength scale: weak message (M=4.23) and strong message (M=5.68). The resulting three images and two texts were then combined into six Alzheimer’s disease awareness building messages and used in the main study (see Appendix for examples).
3.2
Procedure and Measures
A 2 (message strength: weak – strong) X 3 (affective valence of image: negative - neutral – positive) between subjects design was used to collect the data. The survey was conducted in Belgium and Spain (n=495). Two hundred and fifty Belgian and 245 Spanish individuals of between 55 and 65 years old were recruited by InSites, an Internet research company (240 females and 255 males). They received an e-mail with a link to a web survey. After answering a number of demographic questions, they viewed one of the six Alzheimer’s disease messages, to which they were randomly assigned. Subsequently, they answered questions on scales evaluating their responses to the message. The two independent variables, namely valence of the image in the message and argument strength, were manipulated in the experiment. Perceived message affect was measured on a 5-item 7-point scale (happy-sad, hopeful-desperate,
60
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
assured-worried, warm hearted-cold hearted, secure-unsafe) (α=.805). Perceived message substance was measured with a 5-item 7- point scale (persuasive-not persuasive, informative-not informative, credible-not credible, strong-weak, important-unimportant) (α=.904). The attitude towards the ad (Aad) was measured through a 3-item 7-point scale (I find the health communication strong/weak; this communication makes a good/bad impression on me; I like/dislike this communication) (α=.915). After exposure to the message, participants were asked to freely elicit their thoughts about the message and Alzheimer’s disease. All thoughts were coded according to the valence (negative, neutral, positive) and the focus (message or Alzheimer’s disease) of the thoughts by two independent judges. They agreed on 94% of the ‘Message thoughts’ and 91% of the ‘Alzheimer thoughts’. Disagreement was solved by a third judge. The variables ‘Message thoughts’ and ‘Alzheimer thoughts’ used in the analyses were defined as the sum of the number of positive (+1), negative (1) and neutral (0) thoughts. Finally also gender and education level were measured. Education level was recoded into a dichotomous variable, with ‘low’ education defined as equal as or less than high school.
4 4.1
Results Analysis on the Complete Data Set
In the first part of the analysis (RQ1), the mediating role of the affective reaction to the message on the relation between argument strength (STR) and image valence (IMA) on message thoughts is investigated using the Baron and Kenny approach (1986).
61
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
Table 1: Mediating role of message affect on the effect of argument strength and image valence on message thoughts (ANOVA) Baron &Kenny
Relation
F
Partial Eta2
Step1
Argument strength Image valence Strength x valence -> Message thoughts
F(1, 481) = 16.835 F(2,481) = 2.467 F(2,481) = .284
.034 .010 .001
<.001 .086 .753
Step2
Argument strength Image valence Strength x valence -> Message affect
F(1,489) = 6.043 F(2,489) = 3.553 F(2,489) = .029
.012 .014 .000
.014 .029 .971
Step3
Argument strength Image valence Strength x valence Message affect -> Message thoughts
F(1, 480) = 12.117 F(2,480) = 2.445 F(2,480) = .252 F(1,480) = 49.026
.025 .010 .001 .093
.001 .088 .778 <.001
p
In the first step, the effects of the independent variables STR and IMA on the dependent variable ‘message thoughts’ are estimated by means of ANOVA. The results show a significant main effect of STR (F(1,481)= 16.835, p<.001) and a marginally significant main effect of IMA (F(2, 481)= 2.467, p=.086). The interaction effect is not significant (F(2,481)= .284, p=.753) (Table 1). Strong messages (M=1.208) lead to a significantly better score on the thoughts about the message than weak messages (M=.351). Messages with a positive image (M=1.012) score as well as messages with a neutral image (M=.869). Both score marginally significantly better than messages with a negative image (M=.465). In the second step of the procedure, the effect of the independent variables on the mediating variable (message affect) is investigated. The ANOVA results show two significant main effects of STR (F(1,489)= 6.043 p=.014) (strong arguments generate more positive affective reactions than weak arguments) and IMA (F(2,489)= 3.553, p=.029). Messages with a neutral image (M=4.524) score significantly better than messages with a negative (M=4.251) or a positive (M=4.346) image. The latter two do not generate significantly different affective reactions. The interaction of affect and strength is not significant (F(2,489)=.029, p=.971). In the third step the effect of the mediating and the independent variables on the dependent variable is simultaneously esti-
62
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
mated. Therefore, message affect was added as a covariate in the step 1 ANOVA. The results demonstrate that message affect has a strong significant positive effect on message thoughts (F(1,480)= 49.026, p<.001). The main effect of argument strength remains significant (F(1,480)= 12.117, p=.001). The main effect of affect remains marginally significant (F(2,480)= 2.445, p=.088). The interaction effect of STR and IMA is again not significant (F(2,480)= .252, p=.778). Partial eta squares show that the impact of message affect (.093) is substantially stronger than that of message strength (.025) and image affect (.010). Message affect thus partially but substantially mediates the effect of message strength and image valence on message thoughts. The mediating role of message thoughts on the relationship between message affect and the dependent variables Aad, perceived message substance and Alzheimer thoughts was tested by means of three regression analyses (RQ2) (Tables 2-4). Step 1 shows a significant positive effect of the independent variable (message affect) on the dependent variable Alzheimer thoughts (β=.153, p=.001). The second step shows a significant positive impact of message affect (independent variable) on message thoughts (mediator) (β=.318, p<.001). In the third step, the effect of message affect and message thoughts on Alzheimer thoughts are simultaneously assessed. The impact of message affect on Alzheimer thoughts is significant (β=.142, p=.003), while the effect of message thoughts is not significant (β=.060, p=.206). Message thoughts do not mediate the effect of message affect on Alzheimer thoughts. Table 2: Mediating effect of message thoughts on the effect of message affect on Alzheimer thoughts (regression analysis) Baron &Kenny
Relation
R2
E
P
Step1
Message affect -> Alzheimer thoughts
.023
.153
.001
Step2
Message affect -> Message thoughts
.101
.318
<.001
Step3
Message affect Message thoughts -> Alzheimer thoughts
.029
.142 .060
.003 .206
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
63
Table 3: Mediating effect of message thoughts on the effect of message affect on perceived message substance (regression analysis) Baron &Kenny
Relation
R2
E
P
Step1
Message affect -> Perceived message substance
.181
.425
<.001
Step2
Message affect -> Message thoughts
.101
.318
<.001
Step3
Message affect Message thoughts -> Perceived message substance
.318
.298 .393
<.001 <.001
The same mediating analysis is conducted for the dependent variable perceived message substance. The results of step 1 indicate a significant positive effect of message affect on perceived message substance (β=.425, p<.001). In the previous analysis, we observed in the second step a significant positive effect of message affect on message thoughts (β=.318, p<.001). The third step shows that the effect of message affect on perceived message substance is significant (β=.298, p<.001). Also the effect of message thoughts is significant (β=.393, p<.001). Message thoughts partially mediate the effect of message affect on perceived message substance. Table 4: Mediating effect of message thoughts on the effect of message affect on the attitude towards the ad (regression analysis) Baron &Kenny
Relation
R2
E
P
Step1
Message affect -> Attitude towards the ad (Aad)
.269
.519
<.001
Step2
Message affect -> Message thoughts
.101
.318
<.001
Step3
Message affect Message thoughts -> Attitude towards the ad (Aad)
.390
.401 .368
<.001 <.001
64
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
Finally, the test is carried out for the dependent variable Aad. The results of step 1 indicate a significant positive effect of message affect on Aad (β=.519, p<.001). The results of the third step show that the effect of message affect (β=.401, p<.001) and message thoughts (β=.368, p<.001) on Aad are significant. Message thoughts partially mediate the effect of message affect on Aad.
4.2
Gender Differences
We have tested for gender effects in these mediation mechanisms by conducting an additional analysis in which a gender dummy variable and interaction variables between gender and the original independent variables in the basic analysis are added. In the first step of analysis 1, gender does not have a significant main effect on message thoughts (F(1,477)=.085, p=.770). The interaction effects are not significant for gender with STR (F(1,477)=.190, p=.663) and for gender with IMA (F(2,477)=.285, p=.752). From step 2 we can conclude that gender does not have a significant main effect on the mediating variable message affect (F(1, 485)=.029, p=.864). In the third step, where we analyse the effect of the mediating and the independent variables on the dependent variable simultaneously, we observe that gender does not have a significant main effect (F(1,475)=.180, p=.672). In addition, the interaction effects between gender on the one hand and argument strength and image valence on the other, are not significant [STR*gender: (F(1,475)=.613, p=.434); IMA*gender: (F(2,475)= .529, p=.589)]. The overall conclusion is that there is no significant effect of gender on the mediation role of message affect between argument strength and image valence on message thoughts. To test the moderating role of gender in the second model, we also repeated the mediating analysis for the dependent variables Alzheimer thoughts, message substance and the attitude towards the ad, again by adding a gender dummy variable and interaction effects between this variable and the other independent variables in the equations. Gender has no significant main effect on Alzheimer thoughts (β=.065, p=.728) or message thoughts (β=.020, p=.913). There is no significant effect of gender on the relation between message affect and Alzheimer thoughts (β=.013, p=.947). The interaction effects of gender with message thoughts and message affect were also not significant [message thoughts*gender: (β=-.017, p=.800); message affect*gender: (β=.131, p=.521)]. The same mediating analysis is conducted for the dependent variable perceived message substance. Again, gender has no significant main effect on perceived message substance (β=-.060, p=.731) and on message thoughts (β=.020, p=.913). Gender has no significant effect on the relation between message affect and perceived message substance (β=-.116, p=.480). The interaction effects of gend-
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
65
er with message thoughts and message affect were also not significant [message thoughts*gender: (β=-.082, p=.152); message affect*gender: (β=.157, p=.360). Finally, we test whether there is a difference between the gender groups when the analysis is carried out for the dependent variable Aad. Gender has no significant main effect on Aad (β=.152, p=.351) and on message thoughts (β=.020, p=.913). Gender has no significant effect on the relation between message affect and Aad (β= .123, p=.424). The interaction effects of gender with message thoughts and message affect were not significant either [message thoughts*gender: (β=-.048, p=.376); message affect*gender: (β=-.007, p=.968). Summing up, the mediating role of message thoughts for the relationship between message affect on the one hand and Alzheimer thoughts, message substance perception and Aad is not any different between men and women. All in all, the two mediating mechanisms of message affect and message thoughts found are not different between gender groups. They play the same role for men and women.
4.3
Differences in Education Level
We have tested for the effect of level of education in a similar way as for gender. The two defined groups consist of a low education group (high school or less) and a high education group (higher education) (variable EDU). First, we investigate the moderating effect of the education level on the mediating role of message affect (model 1). Education does not have a significant main effect on message thoughts (F(1,477)=.736, p=.392). The interaction effects are not significant for education with STR and for education with IMA either [STR*EDU (F(1,477)=.363, p=.547); IMA*EDU (F(2,477)=.066, p=.936)]. From step 2 we can conclude that education level does not have a significant main effect on the mediating variable message affect (F(1,485)=.179, p=.673). In the third step of the analysis, where we analyse the effect of the mediating and the independent variables on the dependent variable simultaneously, we observe that education level does not have a significant main effect (F(1,475)=.321, p=.571). In addition, the interaction effects are not significant [STR*EDU (F(1,475)=.307, p=.580); IMA*EDU (F(2,475)=.096, p=.909)]. In conclusion, there is no significant moderating effect of education on the mediating role of message affect on message thoughts. We now proceed with the analysis of the mediating role of message thoughts on the relationship between message affect and the dependent variables Alzheimer thoughts, perceived message substance and Aad. Again the education
66
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
dummy variable and the interaction between this variable and the independent variables in the original analysis were added to the model. First, the analysis was carried out for the dependent variable ‘Alzheimer thoughts’. Education level has no significant main effect on Alzheimer thoughts (β=-.189, p=.313) nor on message thoughts (β=-.071, p=.629). In the third step, education level has no significant effect on Alzheimer thoughts either (β=-.131, p=.499), and none of the interaction effects with education is significant [message thoughts*EDU: (β=.037, p=.624); message affect*EDU: (β=.114, p=.573)]. Education does not significantly change the mediating role of message thoughts on the relation between message affect and Alzheimer thoughts. The same analysis is conducted for the dependent variable perceived message substance (Table 5). Education level has a marginally significant main effect on perceived message substance (β=-.325, p=.058). Also the interaction effect between education level and affect is significant (β=.391, p=.025). Education level has no significant main effect on message thoughts (β=-.071, p=.692), but in the third step has a significant main effect on perceived message substance (β=-.424, p=.008). The interaction effects of education level with message affect and of education level with message thoughts are also highly significant (message affect*EDU: β=.518, p=.002; message thoughts*EDU: β=.195, p=.002). Higher educated individuals generally perceive Alzheimer messages as having less substance than lower educated individuals. The mediating role of message thoughts is still there, but highly educated people appear to be less influenced by message thoughts and more by their affective reaction to the message than lowly educated ones in developing perceptions of message substance. Finally, we test whether there is a difference between the education level groups when the analysis is carried out for the dependent variable Aad (Table 6). Education level has a marginally significant main effect on Aad (β=-.267, p=.098). Also the interaction effect between education level and affect is marginally significant (β=.315, p=.057). Education level has no significant main effect on message thoughts (β=-.071, p=.692). In step 3, education level has a marginally significant main effect on Aad (β=-.277, p=.070).
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
Table 5: Mediating effect of message thoughts on the effect of message affect on perceived message substance (regression analysis) – Moderating role of education level Baron &Kenny Step1
Step2
Step3
Relation Message affect EDU EDU x message affect -> Perceived message substance Message affect EDU EDU x message affect -> Message thoughts Message affect Message thoughts EDU EDU x message affect Edu x message thoughts -> Perceived message substance
R2
E
p
.191
.336 -.325 .391
<.001 .058 .025
.105
.289 -.071 .131
<.001 .692 .476
.339
.177 .532 -.424 .518 -.195
.001 <.001 .008 .002 .002
Table 6: Mediating effect of message thoughts on the effect of message affect on Aad (regression analysis) – Moderating role of education level Baron &Kenny Step1
Step2
Step3
Relation Message affect EDU Edu x message affect -> Attitude towards the ad Message affect EDU EDU x message affect -> Message thoughts Message affect Message thoughts EDU EDU x message affect EDU x message thoughts -> Attitude towards the ad
R2
E
p
.275
.446 -.267 .315
<.001 .098 .057
.105
.289 -.071 .131
<.001 .692 .476
.395
.327 .410 -.277 .317 -.060
.<.001 <.001 .070 .048 .316
67
68
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
The interaction effect between education level and message thoughts is not significant (β= -.060, p=.316). Partially consistent with the results for message substance, higher educated individuals generally perceive Alzheimer messages as less positive. The partially mediating role of message thoughts is still there, but highly educated people are less influenced by message thoughts and more by their affective reaction to the message (message affect x EDU: β= .317, p=.048) than lowly educated ones in their attitude towards the message.
5
Conclusions, Implications and Further Research
The role of affective and cognitive responses in processing Alzheimer awareness messages is mixed. The first analysis reveals that message thoughts are strongly driven by people’s affective response to Alzheimer messages. The more positive the affective responses to the message, the more positive message thoughts are. This is consistent with the affect priming and the affect-asinformation principle (Isen, 1987; Schwarz, 2003; Forgas, 1995). However, argument strength also remains a strong determinant of message thoughts, regardless of the affective response it evokes. Stronger arguments evoke more positive message thoughts than weaker ones. All together, this suggests a process of substantive and central processing that is partly mediated by the affect infusion mechanism. Indeed, both image valence and argument strength appear to lead to affective reactions that shape message thoughts, above and beyond the direct impact of argument strength. A remarkable result is that messages with images of neutral valence lead to more positive affective reactions and message thoughts than negatively or positively valenced images. Negatively valenced images may cause fear and distress that subsequently lead to negative affect and thoughts. Apparently also a positively valenced image leads to more negative responses than a neutral one. An explanation could be that people feel that a positive image does not fit with a serious problem like Alzheimer disease and dismiss it as inappropriate. Affect transfers to evaluative judgments about the message and the Alzheimer issue in different ways, but again the process is largely affect-driven. One part of the second analysis suggests that the development of Alzheimer thoughts is a peripheral affect transfer process (Coulter, 1998), since communication thoughts do not mediate the impact of affective response on Alzheimer thoughts. However, the effect of message affect on Aad and perceived message substance is partially mediated by message thoughts which points at more centrally but biased processing (Petty and Cacioppo, 1986).
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
69
These processes do not seem to be moderated by gender differences. The mediating role of message affect and message thoughts is essentially the same for men and women. However, the level of education does seem to have a significant moderating effect, at least on the perception of message substance and the appreciation of the message (Aad). In general, more highly educated individuals like the messages less and are less convinced about their substance. Highly educated people may be more prone to scrutinizing the message, and as a result may be more critical and skeptical about them. In developing perceptions about messages, these highly educated people appear to be significantly more influenced by their affective reactions to the message than by their thoughts about the message than their more lowly educated counterparts. This is, in a way, surprising. One might expect highly educated individuals to be more thought-oriented and cognitive in developing message evaluations. The contrary appears to be the case. The results of the present study have implications for health communication professionals. Processing health messages and forming health issue judgments following these messages is largely an affect-driven process. Positive affective reactions are an important prerequisite for the development of positive attitudes and thoughts. Nevertheless, argument strength remains an important driver of positive message processing too. Second, various message components may evoke positive affective reactions. Argument strength is one of them, but also the type of visual is an important driver of affective responses. Remarkably, there is no straightforward relationship between image valence and affective message response. On the basis of the present study, neutrally valenced images seem to be the optimal choice in this type of message. On the basis of these results, the same communication strategies can be used for different demographic groups based on gender and education, albeit that in case of highly educated groups, there could be more focus on the affective quality to the message. However, this result needs further confirmation. Further research should confirm these findings for different types of health messages. Target groups other than seniors, such as caregivers or doctors, may process various types of messages differently. Individual differences have been shown to moderate the effects of persuasive communication (e.g., Haughtvedt et al., 1992; Geuens and De Pelsmacker, 1999). Next to socio-demographic differences, a particularly important factor may be the level of experience an individual has with the disease. Caregivers, or people who have experience with Alzheimer due to contacts with a member of the family or a close friend developing Alzheimer may process Alzheimer messages differently from people who only have a vague idea of what Alzheimer does to people. One might assume that
70
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
more experienced people would also be more affectively involved, thus increasing the role of affect in processing Alzheimer messages. On the other hand, they might know more about the disease, and pay more attention to the arguments and thoughts about it. This is an avenue for further research. Another next step is to study the impact of message components, and affective and cognitive responses to messages on various aspects of behavioural intention and behaviour, such as visit to a doctor, search for more information, vigilance about early warning signals, etc.
6
References
Batra, R. & Ray, M.L. (1986), “Affective responses mediating acceptance of advertising,” in: Journal of Consumer Research, 13 (2), 234-249. Bagozzi, R.P., Gopinath, M. & Nyer, P.U. (1999), “The role of emotions in marketing,” in: Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 27(2), 184-206. Bain, L.J., Barker, W., Loewenstein, D.A. & Douara, R. (2008), “Towards an Earlier Diagnosis of Alzheimer Disease,” in: Proceedings of the 5th MCI Symposium 2007, Alzheimer Disease & Associated Disorders, 22(2), 99-110. Baron, M. R. & David A. Kenny (1986), “The Moderator-Mediator Variable Distinction in Social Psychological Research: Conceptual, Strategic, and Statistical Considerations,” in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 51 (6), 1173-1182. Bower, G.H. (1981), “Mood and memory,” in: American Psychologist, 36, 129-148. Brown, S.P. & Stayman, D.M. (1992), “Antecedents and consequences of attitude towards the ad: A meta-analysis,” in: Journal of Consumer Research, 19, 34-51. Chaiken, S. (1980), “Heuristic versus systematic information processing and the use of source versus message cues in persuasion,” in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39, 752766. Cohen, J. B. & Areni, C. S. (1991), “Affect and Consumer Behavior,” in: T.S. Robertson, H.H. Kassarjian (Eds.): Handbook of Consumer Behavior, Englewood Cliffs NJ: Prentice-Hall, 188240. Coulter, K.S. (1998), “The effects of affective responses to media context on advertising evaluations,” in: Journal of Advertising, 27(4), 41-51. Coyle, J.R. & Thorson, E. (2001), “The effects of progressive levels of interactivity and vividness in web marketing sites,” in: Journal of Advertising, 30(3), 65-77. Edell, J. A. & Burke, C. M. (1987), “The power of feelings in understanding advertising effects,” in: Journal of Consumer Research, 14(3), 421-433. Fiedler, K. (1988), “Emotional mood, cognitive style, and behaviour regulation,” in: K. Fiedler, J. Forgas (Eds.): Affect, cognition and social behavior, Gottingen/Germany: Hogrefe, 100-119. Fiedler, K. (1990), “Mood-dependent selectivity in social cognition,” in: W. Stroebe, M. Hewstone (Eds.): European review of social psychology, New York: Wiley, Vol. 1, 1-32. Fiedler, K., Asbeck, J., Nickel, S. (1991), “Mood and constructive memory effects on social judgment,” in: Cognition and Emotion, 5, 363-378. Forgas, J. P. (Ed.). (1991), “Emotion and social judgments,” Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press. Forgas, J. P. (1992), “Affect in social judgments and decisions: A multiprocess model,” in: M.
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
71
Zanna (Ed.): Advances in experimental social psychology, San Diego, CA: Academic Press, Vol. 25, 227-275. Forgas, J.P. (1995), “Mood and Judgment: The Affect Infusion Model (AIM),” in: Psychological Bulletin, Vol. 117, 1, 39-66. Forgas, J. P. & Bower, G. H. (1988), “Affect in social judgments,” in: Australian Journal of Psychology, 40, 125-145. Geuens M. & De Pelsmacker, P. (1999), “Individual differences and the communication effects of different types of emotional stimuli: "affect intensity" revisited,” in: Psychology and Marketing, 16(3), 195-209. Haugtvedt, C. P., Petty, R. E. & Cacioppo, J.T. (1992), “Need for cognition & advertising: Understanding the role of personality variables in consumer behavior,” in: Journal of Consumer Behavior, 3(1), 239-260. Isen, A. (1987), “Positive affect, cognitive processes and social behaviour,” in L. Berkowitz (Ed.): Advances in experimental social psychology, San Diego, CA: Academic Press, Vol. 20, 203253. Jeandrain, A.C. (2004), “Why and how do the telepresence dimensions influence persuasive outcome?,” in: Proceedings of the 7th International Workshop on Presence, Valencia, 73-79. Lombard, M. & Ditton, T. (1997), “At the heart of it all: The concept of presence,” in: Journal of Computer Mediated Communication, 3 (2), 1-42. Lopez, O.L., Becker, J.T., Wisniewski, S., Saxton, J., Kaufer D.I. & DeKosky, S.T (2002), “Cholinesterase inhibitor treatment alters the natural history of Alzheimer’s disease,” in: Journal of Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry, 72: 310–314. Mitchell, A.A. (1988), “Current perspectives and issues concerning the explanation of feelings advertising effects,” in: Hecker, S., Stewart, D.S. (eds.): Non-verbal communication in advertising, Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 122-144. Morris, J.D., Woo, C., Gaeson, J.A. & Kim, J. (2002), “The power of affect: predicting intention,” in: Journal of Advertising Research, 42(3), 7-17. Petty, R.E. & Cacioppo J.T. (1981), “Attitudes and persuasion: Classic and contemporary approaches,” Dubuque, IA: William C. Brown. Petty, R.E. & Cacioppo J.T. (1986), “Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to Attitude Change,” New York: Springer-Verlag. Petty, R.E.; Schumann, D.W., Richman, S.A. & Strathman, A.J. (1993), “Positive mood and persuasion: Different roles for affect under high and low elaboration conditions,” in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 64(1), 5-20. Raghunathan, R. & Pham, M.T. (1999), “All negative moods are not equal: Motivational influences of anxiety and sadness on decision making,” Organizational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes, 79(1), 56-77. Ray, M. L. & Batra, R. (1983), “Emotion and persuasion in advertising: What we do and don't know about affect,” in: Advances In Consumer Research, 10. Salovey, P. & Birnbaum, D. (1989), “Influence of mood on health-related cognitions,” in: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57, 539-551. Salovey, P., O'Leary, A., Stretton, M., Fishkin, S., & Drake, C.A. (1991), “Influence of mood on judgments about health and illness,” in: J.P. Forgas (Ed.): Emotion and social judgments, Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press, 241-262. Schwarz, N. (1990), “Feelings as information: Informational and motivational functions of affective states,” in: Higgins, E.T., Sorrentino R. (Eds.): Handbook of motivation and cognition: Foundations of social behavior, New York: Guilford Press, Vol. 2, 527-561.
72
Lewi and De Pelsmacker
Schwarz, N. & Bless, H. (1991), “Happy and mindless, but sad and smart? The impact of affective states on analytic reasoning,” in: J. P. Forgas (Ed.): Emotion and social judgments, Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press, 55-71. Schwarz, N. & Clore G.L. (2003), “Mood as information: 20 years later,” in: Psychological Inquiry, 14 (3&4), 296-303. Seltzer, Ben (2007), “Early detection of Alzheimer’s disease,” in: Aging Health, 3(4), 449-456. Singer, J.A. & Salovey, P. (1988), “Mood and memory: Evaluating the network theory of affect,” in: Clinical Psychology Review, 8, 211-251. Visser, P.J., Verhey, F.R.J., Scheltens, Ph., Cruts, M., Ponds, R.W., Van Broeckhoven, C.L. & Jolles, J. (2002), “Diagnostic accuracy of the Preclinical AD Scale (PAS) in cognitively mildly impaired subjects,” in: Journal of Neurology, 249, 312-319. Williams-Piehota, P., Pizarro, J., Navarro Silvera, S.A., Mowad, L. & Salovey, P. (2006), “Need for cognition and message complexity in motivating fruit and vegetable intake among callers to the cancer information service,” in: Health Communication, 19(1), 75-84.
Affect is an Important Factor in Processing Alzheimer Disease Awareness Messages
Appendix
Translation Tr rannsllat ation ion fr ffrom rom om Dutch Dut utch ch to to English: Engl Engl En glish: Alzheimer Alz zhei eiimer m disease d sea di eaasee – Treeatm ment ent im mpro p ves pr veess daily d il da ily ly y fu funct n ion nc nct ioning oning ing and an and alleviates alleviatess behavioural beehav av viou io oural raal symptoms. syympt mptoms mp om oms ms. ms. Treatment improves functioning Eldderlly Elderly
73
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour Aimed at Fighting Climate Change: Main and Moderating Effects Nieves García de Frutos, University of Almería, Spain José Manuel Ortega Egea, University of Almería, Spain
1
Introduction
Climate change arguably represents the most challenging environmental threat of our time, owing to its magnitude, complexity, and irreversible effects (European Commission, 2008; Moser, 2010). This issue has garnered increased attention since the late eighties (Nerlich et al., 2010). At first, a great deal of media and public debate centered on the existence of climate change; later, the discussion shifted to the origins of climate change and global warming, be it anthropogenic (ie, human-induced) or part of the natural cycle of the Earth’s climate (Moser, 2010). Nowadays, there is general agreement in the scientific community regarding the existence and anthropogenic causes of climate change (Nerlich et al., 2010). In the last decade, intensified media coverage of climate change and global warming issues has substantially raised public awareness and concern for global environmental degradation (Mobley et al., 2010). For the most part, perhaps best exemplified by the film ‘An Inconvenient Truth’, communication efforts have been directed towards the dissemination of scientific knowledge on the existence, wide-ranging consequences, and human causes of climate change to the general public. Recent data from the European Union (EU) suggest that, despite continued attempts to promote more environmentally-friendly citizen and consumer behavior, there is still much room for improvement in most EU countries (European Environment Agency, 2010). This situation warrants further work (especially cross-national studies) into the precursors of environmentally responsible behaviors (Maibach et al., 2008). Individual ecological behavior is a function of a wide variety of internal and external influences. Psychographics consistently stand out as (direct or indirect) determinants of pro-environmental behavior (Bamberg and Möser, 2007). However, the predictive value of psychological factors can vary significantly across situations and population groups (Thøgersen, 2007). The links in proenvironmental behavior models may be contingent upon various sorts of “nonvolitional, socio-cultural” factors (Kaiser et al., 1999), including demographics (Diamantopoulos et al., 2003), risk perceptions (O’Connor et al., 1999), nationality (Franzen and Meyer, 2010), or the type of behavior assessed (Barr, 2007). Relatively few studies have examined individual actions specifically aimed at fighting climate change. S. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_5, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
76
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
The present study provides a better understanding of the factors that lead EU citizens to fight climate change. For this purpose, citizens’ level of information, motivations, and attitudes towards climate change are evaluated as potential determinants of pro-environmental behavior. Based on expectancy-value theory (Ajzen 1991; Fishbein and Ajzen, 1975), the research model proposes a direct link between environmental attitudes and pro-environmental behavior, and examines the role of (altruistic and egoistic) ecological motivations and level of information about climate change in developing favorable attitudes towards the environment. Four additional influences (threat perceptions, gender, age, and country value orientation) are examined as possible moderators of the hypothesized effects of (externally controllable) environmental information on ecological motivations and attitudes towards climate change. Hence, this work extends the available evidence in environmental research by assessing both the main and moderating effects of internal and exogenous factors on an ‘aggregate’ measure of pro-environmental behaviors. 2
Theory and Hypotheses
‘Green’ behavior is usually conceptualized as a mixture of self-interest and prosocial concerns (Bamberg and Möser, 2007). Researchers seeing individual ecological behavior as motivated by the desire to ‘do good’ for society often use Schwartz’s norm-activation model (NAM) (Schwartz, 1977) as a theoretical framework. In contrast, researchers regarding self-interest as the most important factor driving pro-environmental behavior tend to rely on Ajzen’s theory of planned behavior (TPB) (Ajzen, 1991; Bamberg and Möser, 2007). In addition, the TPB and NAM frameworks have been successfully combined to provide a more thorough analysis of pro-environmental decisions (Bamberg and Möser, 2007). 2.1
‘Core’ Research Model
A considerable amount of research has been devoted to assessing the impact of psychological variables on ecological behavior (eg, Leiserowitz, 2006). The predictive importance of psychographics has remained fairly stable over time (Bamberg and Möser, 2007), suggesting their potential role as determinants of individual pro-environmental behaviors. In the ‘core’ research model, three psychographics (i.e., level of information / knowledge, motivations, and attitudes towards climate change) are modeled as interrelated precursors of proenvironmental behavior aimed at fighting climate change.
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
77
Figure 1. Research model: main and moderator effects
Attitude represents an individual’s positive o negative feelings about a psychological object (Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). Such psychological objects comprise a wide array of discriminable aspects of the physical world, such as a physical entity, a person or group of people, an abstract concept, or a behavior (Ajzen and Gilbert, 2008). Environmental studies often include attitude as a contributing factor to ecological intention and behavior (Bamberg and Möser, 2007; Kaiser et al., 1999). Consistent with expectancy-value models (eg, Ajzen, 1991) and previous analyses of the ‘attitude–environmental behavior’ linkage (Bamberg and Möser, 2007; Kaiser et al., 1999), individuals with positive attitudes towards the environment will be more likely to engage in environmentally responsible behavior (Kaiser, et al., 1999; Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). Nonetheless, the association between environmental attitudes and proenvironmental behavior is rather inconsistent (at best, moderate) across studies (Bamberg and Möser, 2007; Kaiser et al., 1999). Two factors suggest the importance of direct attitude effects on ecological behavior: the corresponding level of measurement generality in attitudes and behaviors, both being linked to the climate change issue; and the moderate to high degree of volitional control over performance of the behaviors, which are modeled as the ‘aggregate’ of eleven self-reported pro-environmental activities (Ajzen, 1991). H1: Attitudes towards climate change will have a positive effect on proenvironmental behavior aimed at fighting climate change. Motivation is understood as the inner driving force behind behavior (Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). Environmental studies have explored a number of values underlying people’s motivation for environmentally responsible behavior (Schultz and Zelezny, 1999). Following Schwartz’s value model
78
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
(Schwartz, 1977), many authors have distinguished between altruistic and egoistic values. Stern et al., (1993) further separated altruistic values into social and biospheric values. Gagnon-Thompson and Barton (1994) made a distinction between ecocentric and anthropocentric values. Ecocentric individuals are concerned about the environment for its own sake, and tend to undertake proenvironmental actions, even if it involves some sacrifice on their part (Gagnon Thompson and Barton, 1994); to a large extent, this behavioral pattern is anchored in biospheric values (Stern et al., 1993). Anthropocentric people’s behavior is grounded more in egoistic and social-altruistic values; accordingly, these individuals would engage in pro-environmental activity, to the extent it has positive consequences for mankind and does not decrease their quality of life or wealth (Gagnon-Thompson and Barton, 1994). Different motivational mechanisms (eg, altruistic and egoistic environmental motivations) may be operative in a person’s environmentally responsible decision-making (Maibach et al., 2008; Schultz and Zelezny, 1999). The available empirical evidence suggests that both ecocentric (biospheric) and anthropocentric (social or egoistic) values can result in pro-environmental behavior (Stern et al., 1993), particularly when different types of ecological values come into play in a coherent way (De Young et al., 1993). However, the motivational complexity of environmentally-friendly behavior may cause conflicts between an individual’s selfish and altruistic motives. Based on expectancy-value theory (Ajzen 1991; Fishbein and Ajzen, 1975), which postulate that attitude develops from salient beliefs about the outcomes of the behavior (eg, altruistic vs. selfish beliefs), and considering the ‘value/belief’ nature of ecological motivations (Grunert and Juhl, 1995), attitude will mediate the effect of (altruistic and egoistic) ecological motivations on proenvironmental behavior aimed at combating climate change. H2. Motivations to combat climate change will have a positive effect on attitudes towards climate change. The level of information or knowledge about environmental issues is regarded as a necessary (but not sufficient) antecedent of ecological awareness and behavior (Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). Attitudes are not innate, but are acquired and altered in response to external stimuli, such as people’s access to various sources and types of information (Ajzen and Gilbert, 2008). The level and type of environmental information (and knowledge) can affect the attitudinal and behavioral responses to environmental information (Kaiser and Fuhrer, 2003; Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). Basic knowledge is necessary to correctly interpret environmental threats and motivate pro-environmental actions (Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). However, excessive information or very detailed technical data, concerning a complex and global-scale environmental issue such as climate change, can bring about frustration or denial of the issue (Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). With respect to the type of environmental information or knowledge, information about the nature and causes of environmental problems, and information on ecological action strategies, appear
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
79
to be especially useful in promoting pro-environmental behavior (Kaiser et al., 1999). Consequently, it seems reasonable to expect that better-informed citizens concerning the causes, ways of fighting, and consequences of climate change will behave in more environmentally responsible ways, compared to badlyinformed individuals. In line with social psychology literature (Ajzen and Gilbert, 2008) and most environmental studies (Bamberg and Möser, 2007; Kaiser et al., 1999), the ‘core’ model posits that respondents’ level of information about climate change has indirect effects on pro-environmental behavior, through environmental attitudes. H3a: Environmental information level will have a positive effect on attitudes towards climate change. Environmental information is also hypothesized to exert a significant effect on individual motivations for engaging in ecological behaviors (Thøgersen, 1994). Previous studies suggest that the ‘information–motivation’ linkage will be stronger for people with lower environmental concern, lacking the internal motivation to act ecologically (Schultz et al., 1995). Thus, providing highquality information about relevant climate change issues should be a powerful instrument for raising people’s levels of environmental motivation (Schultz et al., 1995; Young et al., 2010). Environmental information and messages appealing to both egoistic and altruistic ecological motivations should be more effective in encouraging pro-environmental behaviors (De Young et al., 1993). H3b: Environmental information level will have a positive effect on motivations to combat climate change. 2.2
Moderating Effects on ‘Environmental Information’ Linkages
The importance of analyzing moderation effects has been acknowledged in environmental research (Kaiser et al., 1999). Moderation analyses are consubstantial to social science; their abundance reflects the degree of maturity and sophistication of a research field (Frazier et al., 2004). Moderating effects are often examined when there are unexpectedly weak or inconsistent relationships between predictor and outcome variables across settings and population groups. In particular, moderation analyses help to clarify the questions of ‘when’ and ‘for whom’ a given variable is significantly or more strongly predictive of an outcome variable (Frazier et al., 2004). As depicted in Figure 1, the present study examines moderating effects on ‘environmental information’ linkages; that is, the moderation analyses will clarify some conditions and socio-demographic segments for which the hypothesized effects of environmental information on ecological motivations and attitudes towards climate change vary in magnitude. A deeper understanding of the predictive conditions of environmental information (about climate change) is important for interventions aiming to promote environmentally-friendly behavior patterns, owing to the ‘externally
80
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
controllable’ character of environmental information and messages. The consistency of ‘environmental information–attitudes’ and ‘environmental information–motivation’ links is likely to be contingent on a variety influences (Diamantopoulos et al., 2003; Kaiser et al., 1999; O’Connor et al., 1999). Potential moderators include not only information traits (e.g., type of environmental content, or tone of messages), but also psychological and sociodemographic characteristics of the target audience (von Borgstede and Anderson, 2010). In this work, three external traits (gender, age, and country value orientation) and one internal constraint (perceived threat of climate change) are examined as moderating variables. Perceived threat of climate change. Many studies on pro-environmental behavior have included some measure of perceived risk or threat of environmental problems (eg, climate change or global warming) to explain differences between more and less environmentally proactive people (Leiserowitz, 2006; O’Connor et al., 1999). Theoretical and empirical evidence exists to suggest moderating influences of perceived threat of climate change: environmental knowledge and value orientations may relate to increased and lowered risk perceptions (O’Connor et al., 1999; Withmarsh, 2008); research also suggests that the relative importance of internal reasons (eg, ecological motivations) for pro-environmental behaviors, such as those aimed at fighting climate change, will be higher for people high in perceived environmental threat (Schultz et al., 1995). This latter argument suggests, somewhat exploratively, that individuals rating climate change as a more serious problem (ie, high threat perceptions) will be less influenced by external stimuli in their proenvironmental decision-making. H4a: For respondents with ‘high’ perceived threat of climate change, the effect of environmental information level on attitudes towards climate change will be ‘attenuated’. H4b: For respondents with ‘high’ perceived threat of climate change, the effect of environmental information level on motivations to combat climate change will be ‘attenuated’. Gender. In most analyses of gender differences in pro-environmental behavior, women have displayed lower levels of environmental knowledge than men (Diamantopoulos et al., 2003; Kollmus and Aygeman, 2002). This pattern has been attributed to women’s traditional roles and socialization process (Straugham and Roberts, 1999); for instance, the traditional ‘wife and housekeeper’ role has kept women away from scientific and technological fields (Olli et al., , 2001). However, women have been found to be more responsive to ‘green’ advertising (Haytko and Matulich, 2010). Hence, female respondents will more likely be influenced by environmental information than men (von Borgstede and Anderson, 2010). Consistent with this pattern, gender should be an important moderator of the environmental information links in the ‘core’ research model.
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
81
H5a: For female respondents, the effect of environmental information level on attitudes towards climate change will be ‘intensified’. H5b: For female respondents, the effect of environmental information level on motivations to combat climate change will be ‘intensified’. Age. There is much controversy concerning the effects of age on environmental knowledge, attitudes, and pro-environmental behavior. There is some agreement that younger people tend to be more aware and concerned about environmental issues (Diamantopoulos et al., 2003; Olli et al., 2001; Straugham and Roberts, 1999), mostly due to overlapping lifecycle and cohort effects (Franzen and Meyer, 2010). Regarding environmental knowledge, it is not possible to find clear age patterns, with age having either non-significant (Cottrell, 2003), or weak negative relations to knowledge (Diamantopoulos et al., 2003). In line with these findings, younger individuals were found to be more knowledgeable about an environmental problem such as acid rain, compared to their older counterparts (Arcury et al., 1987). Based on the available evidence, two preliminary hypotheses are developed for the moderating effects of age on ‘environmental information/knowledge’ linkages. H6a: For younger respondents, the effect of environmental information level on attitudes towards climate change will be ‘intensified’. H6b: For younger respondents, the effect of environmental information level on motivations to combat climate change will be ‘intensified’. Country value orientation. It is widely believed that differences in environmental knowledge, concern and behavior may be a consequence of shared values within a culture (Schultz and Zelezny, 1999). Thereby, most studies have relied on ‘postmaterialism’ to explain country differences (see Franzen and Meyer, 2010). Postmaterialist theory posits that environmental concern emerges only once basic individual needs are fulfilled (Dunlap and Mertig, 1995). Consistent with this, people from countries with a predominant postmaterialist value orientation would be more concerned and engage more often in pro-environmental behaviors (Franzen and Meyer, 2010). ‘Postmaterialist’ countries are also expected to show higher levels of environmental knowledge; these societies put greater emphasis on immaterial resources, such as providing citizens with improved education and freedom of information (Dunlap and Mertig, 1995). On this basis, the following hypotheses are proposed suggesting a greater predictive importance of respondents’ environmental information level in countries with predominant postmaterialist values. H7a: For ‘postmaterialist’ countries, the effect of environmental information level on attitudes towards climate change will be ‘intensified’. H7b: For ‘postmaterialist’ countries, the effect of environmental information level on motivations to combat climate change will be ‘intensified’.
82 3 3.1
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
Methods Sample
The empirical analyses are conducted on the survey database ‘Eurobarometer 69.2 – Europeans’ attitudes towards climate change’. This cross-national dataset covers a representative sample of the population (aged 15 and over) of the EU27 member states, plus three candidate countries (Croatia, Turkey, and the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia) and the Turkish Cypriot Community. The fieldwork was carried out between March 25th and May 4th 2008 through face-to-face interviews in people’s homes, and in the appropriate national language. In all countries, a stratified, multistage probability design was used for selection of sampling units. A total of 30,170 responses were collected (with few exceptions, approximately 1000 per country). The questionnaire addressed European citizens’ attitudes, motivations, level of knowledge, and engagement in proenvironmental behaviors aimed at fighting climate change; other relevant measures were available, including materialist/post-materialist values, perceived seriousness of climate change, and socio-demographic indicators, such as gender, age, education level, political ideology, and country. Access to the Eurobarometer data was provided by the GESIS Data Archive for the Social Sciences (Cologne, Germany). 3.2
Statistical Procedures
3.2.1
‘Core’ Model Tests
First, exploratory factor analysis (EFA) is used to check the dimensional structure of the ‘core’ research model. Next, confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and structural equation modeling (SEM), using the EQS v6.1 statistical software, are respectively applied to examine the psychometric properties of the scales and test the hypothesized relations in the ‘core’ model. In addition, several statistical tests and criteria (such as Cronbach’s alpha values, composite reliabilities, the average variance extracted (AVE), and chi-square difference tests) are used to analyze measurement reliability and convergent and discriminant validity. 3.2.2
Moderation Analyses
Two common methods for testing moderating effects have been described: multiple regression and multi-group analysis (multi-group SEM). Owing to the characteristics of the ‘core’ research model and moderator variables (i.e., perceived threat of climate change, gender, age, and country value orientation), the multi-group SEM approach is used in this work. Hence, differences in the hypothesized ‘environmental information / knowledge’ effects were assessed
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
83
between the following groups of respondents: ‘high’ vs. ‘low’ perceived threat of climate change (median split defined groups); ‘male’ vs. ‘female’ gender categories; three age groups split into terciles: ‘15–38 years’, ‘39–56 years’, and ‘more than 57 years old’; and three country groups based on materialist vs. postmaterialist values: ‘materialist countries’, ‘countries with mixed values’, and ‘post-materialist countries’. 4
Results
From the initial sample of 30,170 cases, the authors selected those respondents who ‘agreed’ or ‘tended to agree’ with the statement ‘You personally have taken actions aimed at helping to fight climate change’, with the aim of testing the hypotheses of the study. In the year 2008, EU citizens undertaking some form pro-environmental activity accounted for 51.7% of the sample (n=17,233); only these individuals were included in subsequent analyses. 4.1
‘Core’ Model Results
4.1.1
Psychometric Properties of the Scales
The dependent factor (pro-environmental behavior) captures respondents’ level of individual environmental proactivity, through the aggregation of eleven specific pro-environmental actions into a single, unidimensional construct. Both exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses suggested the distinction between positive and negative attitudes toward climate change. Consistent with previous literature (eg, Thøgersen, 2007), the analyses supported a second-order factor of motivations to combat climate change, formed by altruistic and egoistic ecological motivations. The obtained Cronbach’s alpha and Raykov’s rho coefficients were well above 0.8 for the construct of ‘environmental information level’ (Straub, 1989). For both positive and negative attitudes towards climate change, and ecological motivations, Cronbach’s alphas were around 0.5, but all Raykov’s rho coefficients exceeded the more lenient cut-off of 0.6 (Hair et al., 1998). These results were expected, owing to the use of Eurobarometer data with ‘predetermined indicators’. Thus, the internal consistency of the multi-item scales may be acceptable in this study (Hair et al., 1998). Two separate tests were sequentially performed to assess the discriminant validity of each pair of constructs. First, following Anderson and Gerbing’s (1988) recommendations, a confidence interval test was used to assess the discriminant validity of each pair of factors. Next, chi-square difference tests were applied only to those pairs of factors showing problems of discriminant validity, according to the confidence interval test. All tests indicated that discriminant validity exists between the analyzed pairs of factors.
84 4.1.2
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
Explaining Pro-environmental Behavior
The results provided support for all the hypothesized relationships in the ‘core’ model (see Figure 2). Despite accounting for only 15.3% of the variance, positive attitude towards climate change was the single direct predictor of proenvironmental behavior (std. β=0.389; p<0.01), thus providing support for H1. Conversely, negative attitude did not significantly detract from ecological behavior aimed at fighting climate change. The results also supported the positive, direct effects of ecological motivations and environmental information level on respondents’ attitudes towards climate change (support for H2 and H3a); these effects were larger on positive than on negative environmental attitude. Motivation had a greater impact than information level on positive attitude (std. β=0.758; p<0.01 vs. std. β=0.438; p<0.01), both explaining a large percent of the variance. As expected, ecological motivations exerted a negative influence on negative environmental attitude (std. β=-0.265; p<0.01). Surprisingly though, the effect of information level (about climate change) on negative attitude was positive, but weak (std. β=0.093; p<0.01). In line with H3b, the level of information about climate change had a positive, though modest, impact on (altruistic and egoistic) motivations to combat climate change (std. β=0.189; p<0.01). The final version of the ‘core’ model showed a very good fit to the data. The final version of the ‘core’ model showed a very good fit to the data. The assessment of absolute fit revealed that the scaled chi-square (S-B χ2) was significant at p<0.01. Owing to the sensitivity of the chi-square statistic to large sample sizes, alternative indices were assessed (Hair et al., 1998). RMSEA (0.033) fell below the recommended level of 0.08. Incremental fit measures also indicated a good model fit, with all values (NNFI, NFI, CFI, IFI, and MFI) exceeding the rigorous threshold of 0.95. 4.2
Moderation Results
The four moderating variables examined here (threat perceptions, gender, age, and country value orientation) significantly intensified or attenuated at least one causal effect flowing from ‘environmental information level’, according to chisquare difference tests between constrained and unconstrained pairs of models – ie, paths constrained to be equal vs. paths freely estimated across subgroups. Moreover, two variables (age and country value orientation) moderated all three structural paths from environmental information level to positive and negative attitudes, and to ecological motivations, as included in the final ‘core’ model (see Figure 2).
85
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
Table 1: Multi-group results Information level → Moderating Positive attitude variables / subgroups Std. β t-value Perceived threat of climate change High threat 0.301 18.792*** Low threat 0.321 18.792*** Gender Male 0.305 12.288*** Female 0.336 16.600*** Age 15–38 years 0.318 15.007*** 39–56 years 0.292 15.007*** 57+ years old 0.352 13.521*** Country value orientation Post-materialist 0.380 12.090*** Materialist -0.004 -0.062 n.s. Mixed values 0.448 12.090***
Information level → Negative attitude Std. β t-value
Information level → Ecological motivations Std. β t-value
-0.001 0.156
-0.002 n.s. 8.795***
0.163 0.198
10.956*** 10.956***
0.082 0.085
6.772*** 6.772***
0.190 0.194
11.865*** 11.865***
0.038 0.113 0.116
1.787 n.s. 7.555*** 7.555***
0.142 0.231 0.212
5.251*** 11.636*** 11.636***
-0.020 -0.042 0.103
-0.807 n.s. -1.477 n.s. 5.109***
0.193 0.371 0.200
9.462*** 5.825*** 9.462***
*p<0.05, **p<0.01, ***p<0.001.
As shown in Table 1, perceived threat of climate change moderated only the non-hypothesized and, unexpectedly, positive relationship between environmental information level and negative attitude towards climate change. This path became non-significant for respondents with ‘high’ threat perceptions; thus, neither H4a nor H4b were supported. Concerning gender differences, the ‘information level–positive attitude’ effect was intensified for female respondents (partial support for H5a), but no significant differences were found between men and women in the paths from environmental information level to negative environmental attitude and to ecological motivations (lack of support for H5b). The environmental attitudes (particularly, negative ones) and ecological motivations of younger EU citizens appear to be shaped, to a lesser extent, by their level of environmental information or knowledge; the opposite effects were preliminarily proposed in H6a and H6b. As for respondents’ country, the path from environmental information level to positive environmental attitude was significantly attenuated in the ‘materialist’ country group, compared to the ‘post-materialist’ and ‘mixed’ countries; this finding is partly in line with H7a. Non-significant influences of information level on negative environmental attitude were observed both in ‘materialist’ and ‘post-materialist’ countries. By contrast, negative attitude was most strongly (positively) influenced by environmental information in countries with a ‘mixed’ value orientation. Finally, the ‘information–motivation’ linkage was attenuated in the ‘postmaterialist’ country group; this pattern is contrary to that hypothesized in H7b.
86
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
Figure 2: Assessment of the final ‘core’ model and moderation results. Note: The figure shows the standardized path coefficients and t-values in the final ‘core’ model and depicts the significant moderation effects.
5
Discussion
The findings of this study shed light on individual pro-environmental behavior aimed at fighting climate change. The analyses examined the role of EU citizens’ level of information, motivations, and attitudes towards climate change in their pro-environmental decision-making. Moreover, three external traits (gender, age, and country value orientation) and one internal constraint (perceived threat of climate change) were examined as possible moderators of ‘environmental information level’ influences. The ‘core’ research model was consistent with expectancy-value theory (Ajzen, 1991; Fishbein and Ajzen, 1975), and supported the idea that environmental attitudes are important precursors of individual behavior aimed at fighting climate change. Unlike most other studies, two attitudinal factors were differentiated –ie, positive and negative attitudes; on the positive side, only positive environmental attitude was significantly (and positively) predictive of pro-environmental behavior. The modest explained variance (approximately 15%) points to unmodeled antecedents of pro-environmental activity (most notably, behavioral intentions). Respondents’ (altruistic and egoistic) ecological motivations and level of information about climate change were respectively identified as internal and external factors influencing both positive and negative attitudes towards climate change. Environmental information level was also found to have a positive direct effect on ecological motivations to combat climate change. Based on the findings, informing about environmental issues, such as climate change, may undesirably contribute to negative environmental
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
87
attitudes. Although this effect was rather weak, it suggests that not all types of environmental messages and information (eg, information about the causes, ways of fighting, and consequences of climate change) can be assumed to be equally effective in promoting environmentally responsible behaviors. Further understanding of the predictive conditions and socio-demographic segments for which environmental information and messages (about climate change) are more or less effective is important for interventions and campaigns aimed at promoting more environmentally-friendly citizen and consumer behavior. The analyses provided preliminary evidence of significant moderating influences of various internal and exogenous variables on ‘environmental information’ linkages (ie, ‘information level–attitudes’ and ‘information level– motivations’). Variations in environmental information effects between respondent groups, defined by threat perceptions, gender, age, and country value orientation, may be partly attributed heterogeneous interest and concern about environmental issues –eg, women typically show higher levels of environmental concern (Haytko and Matulich, 2010). Moderation results also highlight the importance of carefully designing environmental information and messages to account for socio-demographic and psychological influences (Leiserowitz, 2006). In this regard, there may be special challenges in environmental awareness campaigns targeted at ‘younger’ population segments and ‘materialistic’ countries. 5.1
Implications for Environmental Awareness Campaigns
The assessment of main and moderating effects on ‘environmental information level’ linkages provides important insights for promoting pro-environmental activity at the individual level. Overall, environmental information and knowledge appear to be necessary, but not sufficient, preconditions for environmentally responsible behavior. To a lesser extent, the findings warn of unintended effects of environmental information and messages, eliciting negative environmental attitudes. The effectiveness of environmental messages (and information) is dependent on its alignment with people’s attitudes, motivations and current goals (Maibach et al., 2008; von Borgstede and Anderson, 2010). However, a great deal of environmental communication appeals to ‘global well-being’ and the ‘preserving the Earth for the young and future generations’. Such environmental messages will be adequate for population segments with predominant altruistic and self-transcendent values, but not for individuals with an egoistic value orientation. Targeting environmental messages to egoistic ecological motivations, such as climate change dangers to personal health and safety or the monetary benefits of saving resources, may have greater effect on certain population groups, such as countries with a predominant ‘materialistic’ value orientation.
88
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
In climate change communication, ‘what’ is said is as important as ‘how’ is it said (Moser, 2010). Thus, visual imagery, colors, music, and other non-verbal cues can be very effective in eliciting motivational and attitudinal responses towards climate change and global warming issues. The choice of communication channel and spokesperson can be used to target tailored environmental information and messages to the characteristics of specific sociodemographic and psychographic segments, in accordance with the identified moderating effects on ‘environmental information level’ relationships. Widely available reports on international media use will greatly aid in this process. Finally, environmental awareness campaigns on climate change and global warming issues should avoid vague, contradictory, and complex ecological messages. On the contrary, the arguments used in environmental information and messages need to be clear and simple; in addition, different kinds of environmental information (eg, about the causes, ways of solving, and consequences of climate change) “must work together in a convergent manner” (Kaiser and Fuhrer, 2003). Research on climate change communication has found that environmental messages tend to be more effective when focused on the serious environmental consequences from climate change, while at the same time clarifying that each person can do something about it (Maibach et al., 2008). 5.2
Limitations and Future Research
This study is not free of limitations. Maybe the most important one relates to the use of Eurobarometer data. Despite its benefits, such as providing a rich, crossnational source of information, using this type of data had restrictive effects on research design. Thus, the authors could not participate in the development of questionnaire items. In addition, the use of Eurobaromenter data precluded the inclusion of other relevant factors, such as behavioral intentions, subjective norm, or perceived behavioral control (Ajzen, 1991). A social desirability effect may also bias the results of survey research focusing on ecological behavior –ie, respondents might have exaggerated their responses to project a socially desirable image of themselves. The proposed research model aims to explain complex and dynamic human behaviors with ethical and ecological implications. Thus, future studies should consider including ‘unmodeled’ factors such as citizens’ perceptions of selfrelevance or involvement with environmental issues. In addition, alternative theoretical frameworks, such as Fazio’s MODE model (Fazio, 1990), could be used to assess the consistency of the links between motivations, attitudes, and pro-environmental behavior. Further research should also considerate additional socio-demographic variables as moderators; among other traits, political ideology and level of education tend to be related with higher commitment to
Environmental Information Influences on Pro-environmental Behaviour
89
pro-environmental behaviors. For instance, political ideology may be useful in selecting the most appropriate spokesperson and media (Straugham and Roberts, 1999).
6
References
Arcury, T.A.; Scollay, S.J. & Johnson, T.P. (1987), “Sex Differences in Environmental Concern and Knowledge: the Case of Acid Rain,” in: Sex Roles, Vol. 16 (9/10), 463-472. Ajzen, I. (1991), “The Theory of Planned Behavior,” in: Organizational behavior and human decision processes, Vol. 50 (2), 179-211 Ajzen, I. & Gilbert, N. (2008), “Attitudes and the Prediction of Behavior,” in: W. D. Crano and R. Prislin (eds.): Attitudes and Attitude Change, Psychology Press, New York, NY, 289-311. Anderson, J.C. & Gerbing, D.W. (1988), “Structural Equation Modelling in Practice: A Review and Recommended Two-step Approach,” in: Psychological Bulletin, Vol. 103 (3), 411-423. Bamberg, S. & Möser, G. (2007), “Twenty Years after Hines, Hungerford and Tomera: a New Meta-analysis of Psychosocial Determinants of Pro-environmental Behavior,” in: Journal of Environmental Psychology, Vol. 27 (1), 14-25. Barr, S. (2007), “Factors Influencing Environmental Attitudes and Behaviors: a U.K. Case Study of Household Waste Management,” in: Environment and Behavior, Vol. 39 (4), 435-473. Cottrell, S. P. (2003), “Influence of Sociodemographics and Environmental Attitudes on General Responsible Environmental Behaviour Among Recreational Boaters,” in: Environment and Behavior, Vol. 35 (3), 347-375. De Young, R.; Duncan, A.; Frank, J.; Gill, N.; Rothman, S.; Shenot, J.; Shotkin, A. & Zweizig, M. (1993), “Promoting Source Reduction Behavior. The Role of Motivational Information,” in: Environment and Behavior, Vol. 25 (1), 70-85. Diamantopoulos, A.; Schlegelmilch, B. B.; Sinkovics, R. R. & Bohlen, G. M. (2003), “Can sociodemographics Still Play a Role in Profiling Green Consumers? A Review of the Evidence and an Empirical Investigation,” in: Journal of Business Research, Vol. 56, 465-480. Dunlap, R. E. & Mertig, A. G. (1995), “Global Concern for the Environment: Is Affluence a Prerequisite?” in: Journal of Social Issues, Vol. 51, 121-137. European Commission (2008). Europeans’ Attitudes Towards Climate Change. Available as 30112009 from http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/archives/ebs/ebs_300_full_en.pdf European Environment Agency (2010). Tracking Progress Towards Kyoto and 2020 targets in Europe. EEA Report No 7/2010. EEA, Copenhagen, 2010. Available as 16102010 from http://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/progress-towards-kyoto/at_download/file Fazio, R. H. (1990), “Multiple processes by which attitudes guide behavior: The MODE model as an integrative framework,” in: M. P. Zanna (ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology, Vol. 23, Academic Press, New York, NY, 75-109. Fishbein, M. & Ajzen, I. (1975), “Belief, attitude, intention, and behavior: an introduction to theory and research,” Addison-Wesley Reading, MA. Franzen, A. & Meyer, R. (2010), “Environmental Attitudes in Cross-national Perspective: A Multilevel Analysis of the ISSP 1993 and 2000,” in: European Sociological Review, Vol. 26 (2), 219-234 Frazier, P.; Tix, A. P. & Barron, K. E. (2004), “Testing Moderator and Mediator Effects in Counseling Psychology Research,” in: Journal of Counseling Psychology, Vol. 51 (1), 115-134 Gagnon Thompson, S. & Barton, M. (1994), “Ecocentric and Anthropocentric Attitudes Toward the Environment,” in: Journal of Environmental Psychology, Vol. 14 (2), 149-157. Grunert, S.C. & Juhl, H.J. (1995), “Values, Environmental Attitudes and Buying of Organic Foods,” in: Journal of Economic Psychology, Vol. 16 (1), 39-62.
90
García de Frutos and Ortega Egea
Hair, J.F.Jr., Anderson, R.E., Tatham, R.L., Black, W.C. (1998). “Multivariate data analysis,” 5th edition, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs. Haytko, D. L. & Matulich, E. (2010), “Green Advertising and Environmentally Responsible Consumer Behaviors: Linkages Examined ,” in: Journal of Management and Marketing Research, Vol. 1, 1-11. Kaiser, F.G. & Fuhrer, U. (2003), “Ecological behavior’s dependency on different forms of knowledge,” Applied Psychology: An International Review, Vol. 52 (4), 598-613. Kaiser, F. G.; Wölfing, S. & Fuhrer, U. (1999), “Environmental Attitude and Ecological Behavior,” in: Journal of Environmental Psychology, Vol. 19 (1), 1-19. Kollmuss A. & Agyeman, J. (2002), “Mind the Gap: Why do People act Environmentally and What are the Barriers to Pro-environmental Behavior?,” in: Environmental Education Research, Vol. 8 (3), 239-260. Leiserowitz, A. (2006), “Climate Change Risk Perception and Policy Preferences: The Role of Affect, Imagery, and Values,” in: Climate Change, Vol. 77, 45-72. Maibach, E., Roser-Renouf, C. & Leiserowitz, A. (2008), “Communication and Marketing as Climate Change Intervention Assets: A Public Health Perspective,” in: American Journal of Preventive Medicine, Vol. 35, 488-500. Mobley, C., Vagias, W.M., & DeWard, S.L. (2010), “Exploring Additional Determinants of Environmentally Responsible Behavior: The Influence of Environmental Literature and Environmental Attitudes,” in: Environment & Behavior, Vol. 42 (4), 420-447. Moser, S.C., (2010), “Communicating Climate Change: History, Challenges, Process and Future Directions”, in: Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, Vol. 1 (1), 31-53. Nerlich, B.; Koteyko, N. & Brown, B. (2009), “Theory and Language of Climate Change Communication,” in: Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change, Vol. 1 (1), 97-110. Olli, E.; Grendstand, G. & Wollebaek, D. (2001), “Correlates of Environmental Behaviors: Bringing Back Social Context,” in: Environment and Behavior, Vol. 33 (2), 181-208. O’Connor, R. E.; Bord, R. J. & Fisher, A. (1999), “Risk Perceptions, General Environmental Beliefs, and Willigness to Address Climate Change,” in: Risk Analysis, Vol. 19, 461-471. Schultz, P. W.; Oskamp, S. & Mainieri, T. (1995), “Who Recycles and When: a Review of Personal and Situational Factors,” in: Journal of Environmental Psychology, Vol., 15 (2), 105-121 Schultz, P.W. & Zelezny, L. (1999), “Values as Predictors of Environmental Attitudes: Evidence for Consistency Across 14 Countries,” in: Journal of Environmental Psychology, Vol. 19 (3), 255265. Schwartz, S. H. (1977), “Normative Influences on Altruism,” in: L. Berkowitz (ed.), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 10, Academic Press, New York, 221-279. Stern, P. C.; Dietz, T. & Kalof, L. (1993), “Value Orientations, Gender and Environmental Concern,” in: Environment and Behavior, Vol. 25 (5), 322-348. Straub, D.W. (1989), “Validating Instruments in MIS Research” in: MIS Quarterly, Vol. 13(2), 147168. Straughan, R.D. & Roberts, J.A. (1999), “Environmental Segmentation Alternatives: a Look at Green Consumer Behavior in the New Millennium,” in: Journal of Consumer Marketing, Vol. 16, 558-575. Thøgersen, J. (1994), “A model of recycling behaviour, with evidence from Danish source separation programmes,” International Journal of Marketing Research, Vol. 11 (2), 145-163. Thøgersen, J. (2007), “The Motivational Roots of Norms for Environmentally Responsible Behavior,” in: Proceedings of the Nordic Consumer Policy Research Conference. von Borgstede, C. & Andersson, K. (2010), “Environmental Information. Explanatory Factors for Information Behavior,” in: Sustainability, 2 (9), 2785-2798. Whitmarsh, L. (2008), “Are flood victims more concerned about climate change than other people? The role of direct experience in risk perception and behavioural response,” in: Journal of Risk Research, Vol. 11 (3), 351-374. Young, W., Hwang, K., McDonald, S., & Oates, C. J. (2010), “Sustainable consumption: Green consumer behaviour when purchasing products,” Sustainable Development, Vol. 18 (1), 20-31.
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption: Affective Responses and Advertising Effectiveness Mª José Miquel-Romero, University of Valencia, Spain Franco Manuel Sancho-Esper, University of Alicante, Spain
1
Introduction
It is widely accepted that a framework is necessary to regulate advertising activities. Advertising has a responsibility within our economic system, to provide information on new and existing products and services. Economic health of both buyers and competitors is affected if the advertising system is injected with false or misleading claims. Thus, Government and self-regulation associations should create a set of rules which define and control the behaviour of the advertising companies. Taking into account the power attributed to advertising for influencing consumer behaviour, some of those mentioned rules are established to protect the audience. In this sense, broad social issues have been raised for decades, concerning the role of advertising. Questions such as whether it is ethical to advertise cigarettes or to engage in alcohol advertising, which might persuade young people to start smoking or drinking, have become topics of controversial debate for years. For these products in several countries, severe measures have been applied, like tax increase, prohibition of broadcasting tobacco/alcohol advertising in specific mass media or specific public places, prohibition of its consumption and/or sale in specific public places, or even a clear identification in the product packaging of the health problems caused by the consumption of the product (tobacco), or the recommendation of a responsible consumption (alcohol). Alcohol consumption is nowadays a generalised behaviour, and although its consumption has occurred for thousands of years, many of the varied health effects have been discovered fairly recently (WHO, 2010). It has health and social consequences via intoxication (drunkenness), dependence (habitual, compulsive and long-term drinking), and other biochemical effects, and its harmful use causes an estimated 2.5 million deaths every year, of which a significant proportion occur in the young.
S. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_6, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
92
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
According to the World Health Organization (2010), globally alcohol consumption has increased in recent decades, especially in developing countries. It is the third leading risk factor for poor health globally. The consideration of “risky” factor is even more notorious among youth: automobile crash injury and death, suicide and depression, missed classes and decreased academic performance, loss of memory, blackouts, fighting, property damage, and so forth, are some of the consequences directly related to drinking in adolescents (Bonomo et al., 2001). Adolescents are frequent users of alcohol and they increasingly consume it in a risky fashion. In the Spanish context, and according to the Spanish Ministry of Health and Consumption (2007), alcohol consumption has been trivialized and the perceived risk associated to its consumption has diminished. Two main reasons are identified for this situation: easy access to alcoholic drinks by adolescent and under eighteen young people, and a higher presence of stimulus promoting its consumption, such as advertising. A lot of studies have demonstrated the relationship between persuasive messages through mass media (alcoholic drinks ads) and young people consumption decision (e.g. Atkin et al., 1984; Wallack et al., 1990; Collins et al., 2003). Anderson et al. (2009) concluded that alcohol advertising and promotion increases the likelihood that adolescent will start to use alcohol, and to drink more if they are already drinking alcohol. However, there is not enough research about how these messages affect their decisions. Although in different countries law protects adolescents forbidding advertising targeting this group, we cannot obviate that youths are exposed to ads, and in some way, ads influence them. In fact, several studies have shown that alcohol advertising contains elements that appeal to underage youth (Austin et al., 2006; Chen et al., 2005; Waiters et al., 2001). This reality makes necessary to analyse how this advertising influences on both, adolescents and young adults, in order to work on their effect to minimize the likelihood of having potential future problems. From these evidence, the purpose of this study is to analyse how alcoholic beverages advertising can influence young people consumption, and whether that influence is the same between people over and under eighteen years old, the legal age in Spain to buy and drink alcoholic drinks, as well as to target alcohol advertising. The specific advertising measures into consideration are ad liking, ad recognition, brand recall and slogan recall.
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
2
93
Literature Review
Although the study of factors determining alcohol consumption among young people comes from different fields, it could be argued that it is the psycho-social perspective the one that has shed light towards understanding how the social context affects the young person decision. There are three main key agents, parents, peers and mass media (Moore et al., 2002), that influence the social development of an individual (Hurrelman, 1988). In this paper, we focus our analysis on the influence of alcohol advertising, as part of the mass media influence. If we take into account that adolescents spend less time with their parents in favor of media - what makes them vulnerable to any commercial message -, that they have greater vulnerability to alcohol than adults - as they have no context or reference point for assessing or regulating their drinking -, and, furthermore, that they have built up no tolerance to alcohol (Anderson et al., 2009; Dotson and Hyatt, 1994), it is imperative that law protects this segment of population.
2.1
Advertising Influence: Affective Responses and Ad Effectiveness
Consumer’s affective responses to ads have increased its interest to both academics and practitioners in advertising. Ad liking experienced by the individual is an affective response which contributes to the efficient delivery of the message, leveraging the advertiser’s media investment (Walker and Dubitsky, 1994). Likeability of an advertisement may be attributed to its creativity (Stone et al., 2000), its perception as meaningful and relevant (Biel and Bridgewater, 1990), or by using special elements such as the characters, action, storyline, music, and visual elements (Walker and Dubitsky, 1994). In the specific case of alcohol advertising, Chen et al. (2005) found that youth’s perceived likeability of beer ads was a function of the positive affective responses evoked by elements more closely related to humour and story than to music, animal characters, and people characters, cues also identified in other researches (eg. Waiters et al., 2001). There is a solid and positive relationship between ad liking and persuasion. Research evidence has offered strong support to the belief that better liked ads lead to more positive evaluations of what it is engaged in them, and even a higher purchase intention of the advertised brand. In fact, literature suggests that ad liking is one of the best indicator of advertising effectiveness (Biel, 1990; Haley and Baldinger, 1991). According to this and considering that if people
94
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
like an ad become involved with it (Brown, 1991), we propose the following hypotheses: H1: There is a positive relationship between the ad liking of alcoholic beverages and the brand recall of alcoholic beverages. H2: There is a positive relationship between the ad liking of alcoholic beverages and the advertising recognition of alcoholic beverages. H3: There is a positive relationship between the ad liking of alcoholic beverages and the slogan recall of alcoholic beverages. Alcohol advertising is one of the many factors that can potentially encourage youth drinking, as recent studies have evidenced (e.g., Anderson et al., 2009; Collins et al., 2007; Henriksen et al., 2008; Smith and Foxcroft, 2009; Snyder et al., 2006). Much of this existing literature derives from a pioneer research developed by Grube and Wallack in 1994. In that study, the authors showed that alcohol advertising does have effect on the brand and slogan knowledge, the expectancies (beliefs), the consumption intention, and consequently on the actual alcohol consumption of young people, but only if it is attended and recalled. Grube and Wallack’s ideas about the relationship between alcohol advertising and brand knowledge are supported by the increasing role that brands play on young people daily life. Brand knowledge and preferences are becoming fundamental, even for very young children (Dotson and Hyatt, 2000). In fact, brand awareness is usually one of the main goals that advertisers look for, and that awareness is reinforced by the use of a slogan, which tries to tie the name of the brand in the memory of the consumer, associating the brand, in many cases, with positive feelings. Based on these ideas, the following two hypotheses are proposed: H4: There is a positive relationship between the advertising recognition of alcoholic beverages and the brand recall of alcoholic beverages. H5: There is a positive relationship between the advertising recognition of alcoholic beverages and the slogan recall of alcoholic beverages. If alcoholic beverage advertising is analyzed, it is easy to identify in their messages that social acceptance achieved by means of consuming alcohol is related with several successful roles, values and traits (sexual success, sex appeal, romance, adventure, rebelliousness, elegance, sociability, and so forth) Those roles, values and traits (many of them explicitly forbidden by law) are admired by young adults but also by adolescents. As mentioned before, brands
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
95
would try to associate their products with these values or ideas by means of the brand names or brand slogans, in order to increase the positive expectancies and reduce the negative expectancies of alcohol consumption. So, we propose that: H6: There is a positive relationship between alcoholic beverage brand recall and the positive expectancies towards alcohol consumption. H7: There is a negative relationship between alcoholic beverage brand recall and the negative expectancies towards alcohol consumption. H8: There is a positive relationship between alcoholic beverage slogan recall and the positive expectancies towards alcohol consumption. H9: There is a negative relationship between alcoholic beverage slogan recall and the negative expectancies towards alcohol consumption. In addition, in most alcohol beverages advertising, human roles are young attractive people. Hence, it could be stated that these alcohol advertisements try to communicate young people the social value of drinking (Henrinksen et al., 2008); values that the young individual will try to adopt in order to “behave properly” in the marketplace (social legitimacy). Departing from the process explained by Grube and Wallack (1994), that has been largely contrasted in several contexts (e.g. Smith et al., 1995; Williams and Clark, 1998; Dunn and Yniguez, 1999; Fleming et al., 2004), the positive expectancies towards alcohol consumption have an influence, both direct and positive, over the final alcohol consumption intention. In spite of the fact that there is less empirical support for stating the direct relationship between the negative expectancies and the consumption intention (Austin et al., 2006; Armeli et al., 2005), it is finally considered since this relationship plays a key role at the classical low-involvement information processing model (Krugman, 1965; Ray, 1982). In those cases, cognitive changes, for instance over expectancies or beliefs, have direct effect on behavioral aspects, such as purchase or intention to do it. For these reasons, the following hypotheses are stated: H10: There is a positive relationship between the positive expectancies towards alcohol consumption and the actual alcohol consumption (over 18 years) / consumption intention (under 18 years) of the young man/woman. H11: There is a negative relationship between the negative expectancies towards alcohol consumption and the actual alcohol consumption (over 18 years) / consumption intention (under 18 years) of the young man/woman.
96
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
Evidence shows that children who are more aware of alcohol advertising have greater intention to drink (Grube, 1999). In fact, one of the main goals of alcoholic beverage companies is to create valuable brand equity, and one of the main tools for achieving this objective is by means of advertising, where they try to create positive associations between their brands (and slogans) and the final product consumption. This idea supports the last two hypotheses: H12: There is a direct and positive relationship between alcoholic beverage brand recall and the actual alcohol consumption/consumption intention of the young man/woman. H13: There is a direct and positive relationship between alcoholic beverage slogan recall and the actual alcohol consumption/consumption intention of the young man/woman. The stated framework previously described is depicted in figure 1. Moreover, a further research question is proposed: The analysis of the possible difference in terms of influence, in the specific variables considered (ad liking, advertising recognition, brand and slogan recall, positive and negative expectancies, and alcohol consumption/consumption intention) according to the age of the audience: underage versus overage individuals.
3
Methodology
To obtain data, a self-administered questionnaire was used. The two populations were defined, on one hand as underage students (12-17 years old) and, on the other hand, overage students (18-40 years old). Convenience quota sampling methods were used1, which intended to reflect the socio-economic diversity of the young people of the city under study. The questionnaires were administered, for the underage sample at two private highschools and one public high-school and, for the overage sample at the Main Public University of the Province. The total sample size was 667 questionnaires, 304 among under aged and 363 among over aged students.
1
The relevant control variables which defined the quotas were: sex and age. The selected sample did not statistically differ from the population proportions in any of them (Source: INE, Spanish National Statistics Institute).
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
97
Figure 1.- Suggested model
The procedure was as follows: in a classroom, the individuals were shown a set of images, of five alcoholic beverages ads, which were representative of each alcoholic beverage ad or brand (without showing either the brand or the logo); for each ad, the subjects had around ten seconds to recall if they had seen the ad, and if the answer was positive, to write the corresponding brand and slogan. After that, two 5-likert scales were used to measure both the positive and the negative expectancies towards alcohol consumption. Consumption intention was measured by means of a dichotomous variable (yes/no) one for each alcoholic beverage studied (beer, liquor). In order to measure ad liking, five ads of alcoholic beverages were broadcasted to the students. Afterwards, they had to rate them into a 5-item likert scale. The final consumption intention indicator was an ordinal variable which derived from the addition of two dichotomous variables. Given that it is not legal and ethically possible to ask for actual alcohol consumption to people under eighteen, for the youngest sub-sample, the alcohol consumption intention was considered, and for the oldest, the actual alcohol consumption. All the scales used (table 1) had been widely used within the literature.
98
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
Table 1: Variables and scales used in the questionnaire: underage and overage Variables: Indicators and Constructs
Authors
Scale description
Brand Recall (indicator)
Grube & Wallack, 1994
Aggregation of two items of suggested brand recall: beer and spirits (range 010)
Slogan Recall (indicator)
Grube & Wallack, 1994
Aggregation of two items of suggested slogan recall: beer and spirits (range 0-10)
Ad Recognition (scale)
Grube & Wallack, 1994
Three items related to ad recognitions: ad, product and brand. 5-likert scales.
Ad Liking (scale)
Chen, Grube, Bersamin, Waiters & Keefe, 2005
Five items to assess ad liking: music, actors, humour, and so on. 5-likert scales.
Positive Expectanc. Austin, Chen, & Grube, (scale) 2006
Ten items related to positive expectancies towards consuming alcohol. 5likert scales.
Negative Expectanc. (scale)
Austin, Chen, & Grube, 2006
Seven items related to negative expectancies towards consuming alcohol. 5likert scales.
Consumption Intention* (scale)
Flemming, Thorson & Atkin, 2004
Two-items of consumption intention: beer and spirits. 5-likert scales.
Actual Consumption** (scale)
Flemming, Thorson & Atkin, 2004
Two-items of consumption intention: beer and spirits. 5-likert scales.
Source: Own elaboration. * only at underage model, ** only at overage model.
4 4.1
Results Validation of the Measurement Instruments
For assessing reliability and validity of measurement instruments, several steps were followed. Firstly, the maximum-likelihood estimation of the Confirmatory Factor Analysis over the four factors previously defined was done. Those items with factorial loadings lower than 0.6 (Bagozzi and Baumgartner, 1994;
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
99
Bagozzi and Yi, 1988), or those suggested by the Lagrange multiplier test (Hatcher, 1994), were deleted in order to assure the convergent validity of the instrument. Almost all the factorial loads were statistically significant and greater than 0.6 (Bagozzi and Yi, 1988), which confirms the convergent validity of both instruments. Related to the reliability, Cronbach Alphas (Cronbach, 1951), the Compound Reliability Index and the Average Extracted Variance (Fornell and Larcker, 1981), were calculated for each factor, supporting that used instruments presented acceptable levels of reliability and convergent validity. The discriminant validity was also analyzed and supported2.
4.2
Hypotheses Testing
After identifying the models (underage and overaged), they were estimated by the maximum likelihood procedure using EQS 6.1. The results of the initial model estimation for the two groups are presented in table 2, and show a reasonable adjustment level in each sub-sample. In table 2 is shown that, for the under aged audience, all the hypotheses are supported except those connecting slogan recall with expectancies (positives and negatives), and with alcohol consumption intention. When considering the over aged audience, positive as well as negative expectancies are influenced only by brand recall; there is no relationship between slogan recall and positive or negative expectancies on the one hand, and actual alcohol consumption, on the other hand. The main differences compared to under aged audience arise when analyzing the effect of advertisement liking on recognition and recall. While all the relationships hold for under aged students, there is only a direct and positive relationship between ad liking and ad recognition, but neither there is relationship between ad liking and brand recall nor slogan recall for over aged students. According to these results and the analysis of the standardized loadings, we can affirm that the way advertising influences on young audience varies depending on the age of the individual. Advertisement liking (affective response) has a higher influence on recall and recognition at a younger age. Moreover, advertising recognition influences more on brand recall and less on slogan recall for under aged students than over aged; in addition, the influence of positive expectancies on alcohol consumption intention/actual consumption is higher for under 2
Contact the correspondence author for further details on validation process.
100
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
aged than over aged individuals, but the influence of the negative ones on alcohol consumption intention/actual consumption is higher for over aged individuals With these comments the research question proposed is also answered.
Table 2: Hypotheses testing Under aged samplea
Over aged sampleb
Standard loading
t-value
Standard loading
t-value
H1: Ad likingÆBrand recall
0.242**
4.11
0.041ns
0.76
H2: Ad likingÆAd recognition
0.147*
2.35
0.245**
4.45
H3: Ad likingÆSlogan recall
0.161*
2.86
0.073ns
1.40
H4: Ad recognitionÆBrand recall
0.292**
5.20
0.208*
3.92
H5: Ad recognitionÆSlogan recall
0.397**
7.07
0.349**
6.94
H6: Brand recallÆPositive expectancies
0.165*
2.65
0.137*
2.533
H7: Brand recallÆNegative expectanc.
-0.333**
-5.15
-0.248**
-4.54
H12: Brand recallÆConsump. intention
0.161*
2.69
0.231*
3.90
H8: Slogan recallÆPositive expectanc.
-0.065ns
-1.05
-0.089ns
-1.65
H9: Slogan recallÆNegative expectanc.
0.001ns
0.01
0.049ns
0.90
H13: Slogan recallÆConsump. intention
-0.050ns
-0.91
-0.037ns
-0.72
H10: Positive expect.ÆConsum. intent.
0.445**
7.04
H11: Negative expect.ÆConsum. intent.
-0.189*
-2.95
H10: Positive expect.ÆActual consump.
0.168*
2.95
H11: Negative expect.ÆActual consum.
-0.309**
-4.69
Hypotheses
2
(a) Adjustment under age model: Chi : 609.3 (288 dof, p<0.01); BBNFI: 0.839; BBNNFI: 0.895; CFI: 0.907; AGFI: 0.840; RMSEA: 0.061 (b) Adjustment over age model: Chi2: 746.1 (241 dof, p<0.01); BBNFI: 0.882; BBNNFI: 0.904; CFI: 0.916; AGFI: 0.820; RMSEA: 0.076 ** p<0.1; *p<0.05; ns non-significant
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
5
101
Discussion and Conclusions
The present research has shown the role of advertising as a key factor which determines youth alcohol consumption and consumption intention. According to our results, it is possible to affirm that this influence is different depending on the age of the audience. Although alcohol beverages advertisers are not legally able to target their products and commercials to under aged individuals, several studies have previously shown that young children are aware of alcohol advertising and this awareness increases with age (Aitken. 1989; Aitken et al.,1988). These results become more relevant if we consider one of the realities identified in the Global Strategy To Reduce The Harmful Use Of Alcohol report (WHO, 2010), which exhibits that the degree of risk for harmful use of alcohol varies with age. One of the main conclusions to be mentioned is that alcohol advertising has a clear positive influence in alcohol consumption/consumption intention, through expectancies, an those expectancies play an important role in alcohol consumption. However, it is really important to point out that the influence of advertising is more powerful for under aged audience (which is not the legal target of the product) than for over aged. As a starting point and taking into consideration the affective responses to advertisements, the role of the ad execution is very important. It could be affirmed that the influence of ad liking has, in general, much more power on underage individuals; in this sense, ad liking for younger people influences the three advertising effectiveness measures analyzed (brand recall, ad recognition and slogan recall), whereas for older people only influences in one of them (ad recognition). Although the influence of ad liking on ad recognition is higher for older ones, the direct influence on expectancies comes from brand recall, which is only influenced by ad liking in underage people. Moreover, the influence of advertising recognition on brand recall is higher for underage students, and that brand recall influences in both types of expectancies, positives and negatives, as well as on alcohol consumption intention in both sub-samples. It has to be taken into consideration that brand recall, for both types of audiences, has a higher influence on negative expectancies than on the positive ones; but when comparing the sub-samples, the influence of brand recall on both types of expectancies is higher for younger people. It is also necessary to add that the direct relationship between brand recall and consumption is higher for older audience. Considering the task played by expectancies, it is especially relevant to mention that the influence of those expectancies (determined by brand recall) in
102
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
alcohol consumption/consumption intention is different depending on the audience; for underage people, positive expectancies have a higher positive influence in alcohol consumption intention than for over age students. However, negative expectancies have a higher negative influence in alcohol consumption than that for underage individuals. Moreover, positive expectancies have a higher influence than negative expectancies for underage people, and the opposite happens to over age individual: negative expectancies have a higher influence in alcohol consumption than positive expectancies. This can be due to the fact that under age audience likes to emulate the roles and lifestyles presented at alcoholic beverages advertising (Austin and Knaus, 2000), what makes them to assign higher positive expectancies to alcohol drinking; but they have less experience with alcohol what decreases their negative expectancies. On the other hand, older people are used to have more experience with alcohol, what makes them judge what advertisements show (imageries, roles, and so forth); for this reason, their positive expectancies influences alcohol consumption in a less extent than the negative ones. Although brand recall becomes an essential mediating variable between advertising recognition and actual consumption/consumption intention, given that it has a direct influence on them, and also an indirect influence through expectancies, this cannot be said with respect to slogan recall; although there is a clear influence from ad recognition to slogan recall for both audiences considered, no other hypotheses related to slogan recall stand statistically significant for none of both groups, what lead us to say that slogan plays a poor role in alcohol consumption. On the light of this evidence, there are many ideas and proposals to be made. Firstly, it is shown that advertising restrictions undertaken by public regulators on media are useful for reducing alcohol consumption intention among young people. In fact, in many countries there should be much more restrictive regulation, as it is extended the time and ways that underage individuals are exposed to mass media. The significant relationship between advertising and brand recall increases the likelihood of youth alcohol consumption, both enhancing motivations which increase positive expectancies of younger people, and reducing the constraints that generate the negative expectancies for both, younger and older individuals. Therefore, unless it is obvious that advertising is not the only socialization agent, a responsible self-control among professional and creative executives should be implemented in order to restrict the different roles shown at advertisements, and also a wider restriction on the media and contexts where alcohol ads can be displayed. Secondly, for advertisers, creative executives and product managers whose target group is individuals over eighteen years old, the marginal role of slogan recall on the attitude modification process does not have
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
103
a direct effect on alcohol consumption but is a useful tool for positioning a brand at the mind of the customer. Since alcohol advertising processing, in this product category, seems to be peripheral (Petty and Cacioppo, 1981; 1986), slogans should emphasize tactical aspects and associate the brand with positive aspects of execution, such as roles, locations, colors, special effects, and so on. Nevertheless, and considering that for underage people the level of ad liking influences in all advertising effectiveness measures analyzed in this paper, creative executives should separate from cues specially relevant for adolescents and towards which they respond positively, such as animals, humor or musical elements as Waiters et al (2001) have proved. To conclude, it is worthy to remark the fact that although law throughout different countries gives special attention to protecting young consumers from alcoholic beverages advertising, parents should explain, as much as possible, what are the goals of advertising and how they have to be interpreted. Moreover, information programs should be implemented in both primary and secondary schools, in order to reduce positive expectancies and increment the negatives ones related to alcohol consumption. The results obtained in this study, as well as the proposed actions, are in line of the suggestions made by the World Health Organization (WHO, 2010) about the policy options and interventions wished for reducing the harmful use of alcohol, in the marketing context (Area 6 of the policy options and interventions, pp.15). The WHO considers the necessity to reduce the impact of marketing, particularly on young people and adolescents, and recognizes the difficulty to target young adult consumers without exposing cohorts of adolescents under the legal age to the same marketing, so the content of alcohol marketing as well as the amount of exposure of young people to that marketing are crucial issues. The World Health Organization (2010, pp.15) proposes setting up regulatory or co-regulatory frameworks, preferably with a legislative basis, and supported when appropriate by self-regulatory measures for alcohol marketing by: (i) regulating the content and the volume of marketing, as well as (ii) regulating direct or indirect marketing in certain or all media, between other measures.
6
References
Aitken, P.P. (1989), “Television alcohol commercials and under-age drinking”, in: International Journal of Advertising, Vol. 8, 133-150. Aitken, P.P., Leathar, D.S. & Scott, A.C. (1988), “Ten- to sixteen-year-olds’ perceptions of advertisements for alcoholic drinks”, in: Alcohol and Alcoholism, Vol. 23, 491-500. Anderson, P., Bruijn, A., Angus, K., Gordon, R. & Hasting. G. (2009), “Impact of Alcohol Advertising and Media Exposure on Adolescent Alcohol Use: A Systematic Review of Longitudinal Studies”, in: Alcohol & Alcoholism, Jan., 1-15.
104
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
Armeli, S., Mohr, C., Todd, M. & Maltby, N. (2005), “Daily evaluation of anticipated outcomes from alcohol use among college students”, in: Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, Vol. 24 (6), 767-792. Atkin. C.K., Hocking, J. & Bolck, M. (1984), “Teenage drinking: does advertising make a difference?”, in: Journal of Communication, Vol. 34 (2), 157-167. Austin, E.W., Chen, M.J. & Grube, J.W. (2006), “How does alcohol advertising influence underage drinking? The role of desirability, identification and skepticism”, in: Journal of Adolescent Help, Vol. 38 (4), 376-384. Austin, E.W. & Kanaus, C. (2000), “Predicting the potential for risky behavior among those “too young” to drink as the result of appealing advertising”, in: Journal of Health Communication, Vol. 5 (1), 13-27. Bagozzi, R.P. & H. Baumgartner (1994),”The evaluation of structural equation models and hypothesis testing”, at Bagozzi. R. (eds). Principles of Marketing Research. Blackwell Publishers. Cambridge. MA, 386-422. Bagozzi, R.P. & Y. Yi (1988), “On the evaluation of structural equation models”, in: Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 16 (1), 74-94. Biel, A.L. (1990), “Love the ad. Buy the product? Why liking the advertising and preferring the brand aren’t such strange bedfellows after all”, in: Admap, Vol. 26 (9), N. 299, September, 21-25. Biel, A.L. & C.A. Bridgewater (1990), “Attributes of likeable television commercials”, in: Journal of Advertising Research, 30, 38-44. Bonomo, Y., Coffey, C, Wolfe R., et al. (2001), “Adverse outcomes of alcohol use in adolescents”, in: Addiction, 96, 1485–96. Brown, G. (1991), “How advertising affects the sales of packaged goods brands: A working Hypothesis for the 1990s”, Warwick, Millward Brown International plc. Cited by McDonald (1992) op. cit. Chen, M., Grube, J.W., Bersamin, M., Waiters & E. Keefe (2005), “Alcohol advertising: what makes it attractive to youth?”, in: Journal of Health Communication, Vol. 10 (6), 553-565. Collins, R.L., Ellickson, P.L., McCaffrey, D. & K. Hambarsoomians (2007), “Early adolescent exposure to alcohol advertising and its relationship to underage drinking”, in: Journal of Adolescent Health, Vol. 40 (6), 527-534. Collins, R.L., Schell, T., Ellickson, P. & D. McCaffrey (2003), “Predictors of beer advertising awareness among eighth graders”, in: Addiction, 93, 1297-1306. Cronbach, L.J. (1951), “Coefficient alpha and the internal structure of tests”, in: Psychometrika, Vol. 16, (3), 297-334. Currie, C., Roberts, C., Morgan, A., et al. (2004), “Health Behaviour in School-Aged Children (HBSC) Study”, in: International Report from the 2001/2002 Survey. Copenhagen: WHO. Dotson, M.J. & E.M. Hyatt (1994), “The Impact of changes in the household on the consumer socialization process”, in: Proceedings of the Southern Marketing Association, New Orleans. LA. November, 156-60. Dotson, M.J. & E.M. Hyatt (2000), “A comparison of parents' and children's knowledge of brands and advertising slogans in the United States: implications for consumer socialization”, in: Journal of Marketing Communications, Vol. 6 (4), 219-30. Dunn, M.E. & R.M. Yniguez (1999), “Experimental demonstration of the influence of alcohol advertising on the activation alcohol expectancies in memory among fourth- and fifth-grade children”, in: Experimental and Clinical Pharmacology, Vol. 7 (4), 473-483. Fleming, K., Thorson, E. & C.K. Atkin (2004), “Alcohol adverting exposure and perceptions: Link with alcohol expectancies and intentions to drink or drinking in underage youth and young adults”, in: Journal of Health Communication, Vol. 9 (1), 3-29. Fornell, C. & D.F. Larcker (1981), “Evaluating structural equations models with unobservable variables and measurement error”, in: Journal of Marketing Research, 18 (February), 39-50. Grube, J.W. (1999), “Alcohol Advertising and Alcohol Consumption: A review and Recent Research”, in: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism 10th Special Report to Congress on Alcohol and Health. Bethesda (MD): National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism.
The Influence of Alcohol Advertising in Underage versus Overage Alcohol Consumption
105
Grube, J.W. & L.Wallack (1994), “Television beer advertising and drinking knowledge, beliefs and intentions among schoolchildren”, in: American Journal of Public Health, Vol. 84 (2), 254-259. Haley, R.L. & A.L. Baldinger (1991), “The ARF Copy Research Validity Project”, Journal of Advertising Research, 31 (2), 11-32. Hatcher, L. (1994), “A Step by Step Approach to Using the SAS System for Factor Analysis and Structural Equation Modeling”, in: Cary. NC: SAS Institute Inc. Henriksen, L., Feighery, E.C., Scheleicher, N.C. & S.P. Fortmann (2008), ”Receptivity to Alcohol Marketing Predicts Initiation of Alcohol Use”, in: Journal of Adolescent Health, 42, 28-35. Hurrelman, K. (1988), “Social Structure and Personality Development: the individual as productive processor”, New York: Cambridge University Press. Krugman, H.E. (1965), “The impact of television advertising: learning without involvement”, in: The Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol. 29 (3), 349-356. McDonald, C. (1992), “How Advertising Works. A review of current thinking”, NTC PublicationsLimited. The Advertising Association, Biddles Ltd, Guilford and Kings Lynn, Great Britain. Moore, J.N., Raymond, M.A., Mittelstaedt, J.D. & J.F. Jr. Tanner (2002), “Age and consumer socialization agent influences on adolescents' sexual knowledge, attitudes and behavior: Implications for social marketing initiatives and public policy”, in: Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, Vol. 21 (1),37-52. Petty, R. E. & J. T. Cacioppo (1981), Attitudes and Persuasion: Classic and Contemporary Approaches. Dubuque, IA: Wm. C. Brown. Petty, R. E. & J. T. Cacioppo (1986), “Communication and Persuasion: Central and Peripheral Routes to Attitude Change”, New York: Springer-Verlag. Ray, M.L. (1982), “Advertising and communication management”, Englewood Cliffs. NJ: Prentice Hall. Smith, G.T., Goldman, M.S., Greenbaum, P.E. & B.A. Christiansen (1995), “Expectancy for facilitation from drinking: The divergent paths of high-expectancy and low-expectancy adolescents”, in: Journal of Abnormal Psychology, Vol. 104 (1), 32-40. Smith, L.A. & D.R. Foxcroft (2009), “The Effect of Alcohol Advertising, Marketing and Portrayal on Drinking Behaviour in Young People: Systematic review of Prospective Cohort Studies”, in: BMC Public Health, Vol. 9 (51). Available from: http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/9/51. Snyder, L.B., Milici, F.F., Slater, M., Sun, H. & Y. Strizhakova (2006), “Effects of Alcohol Advertising Exposure on Drinking Among Youth”, in: Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 160 (January), 18-24. Spanish Ministery of Health and Consumption (2007), “Ministerio de Sanidad y Consumo. Anteproyecto de Ley de medidas sanitarias para la protección de la salud y la prevención del consumo de bebidas alcohólicas por menores”. Available at http://www.msc.es/novedades/docs/Anteproyecto_de_ley_de_medidas_sanitarias.pdf Stone, G., Besser, D. & L.E. Lewis (2000 ), “Recall, liking and creativity in TV commercials: A new approach”, in: Journal of Advertising Research. Vol. 40, 7-18. Strasburger, V.C. (2004), “Children, Adolescent, and the Media”, in: Current Problems in Pediatric and Adolescent Health Care, 35, 54-113. Unger, J.B., Schuster, D., Zogg, J., Dent, C.W. & A.W.Stacy (2003), “Alcohol advertising exposure and adolescent alcohol use: A comparison of exposure measures”, in: Addiction Research and Theory, Vol. 11 (3), 177-193. Waiters, E., Treno, A. & J. W. Grube (2001), “Alcohol advertising and youth: A focus-group analysis of what young people find appealing in alcohol advertising”, in: Contemporary Drug Problems, Vol. 28 (4), 695. Walker, D. & T.M Dubitsky (1994), “Why liking matters”, in: Journal of Advertising Research, 34, 9-18. Wallack, L.; Cassady, D. & J.W. Grube (1990), “Tv beer commercials and children: Exposure, attention, beliefs, and expectations about drinking as an adult”, Falls Church, VA: AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety. Mentioned by Chen, Grube, Bersamin, Waiters and Keefe (2005) op.cit..
106
Miquel-Romero and Sancho-Esper
Williams, A. & D. Clark (1998), “Alcohol consumption in university students: The role of reasons for drinking, copying strategies, Expectancies and personality traits”, in: Addictive Behavior, Vol. 23 (3), 371-378. WHO (2010), World Health Organization. “Global Strategy to reduce the harmful use of alcohol”. WHO Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data. Available at : http://www.who.int/substance_abuse/publications/en/ in 20th Decemb. 2010.
The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages for a Fair Trade Campaign Erlinde Cornelis, Ghent University, Belgium Leen Adams, Hogeschool-Universiteit Brussel, Belgium Verolien Cauberghe, Ghent University, Belgium
1
Introduction
According to research on message framing, messages that are factually equivalent, but framed differently, often lead to differences in persuasion (Yi and Baumgartner, 2009). Most previous research on message framing has compared message frames that differ in overall valence, i.e., positive frames versus negative frames (Rothman and Salovey, 1997; Levin et al., 1998). Message framing in terms of a prevention versus promotion outcome focus lately received an increased academic interest. This way of framing is based on the self-regulatory focus theory of Higgins (1997), stating that people can be classified as either relatively more promotion-focused or relatively more prevention-focused. Furthermore, this theory proposes that message (frame) effectiveness depends on consumers’ underlying motivational orientations (e.g., Aaker and Lee, 2001). That is, when the message frame is congruent to the viewer’s self-regulatory focus, the message is assumed to be more effective (Higgins, 2002). Although ample evidence supporting this regulatory congruency principle has been found (e.g., Latimer, et al., 2007; Yi and Baumgartner, 2008), the boundaries of this principle are still insufficiently studied. So far, studies have mainly focused on differently framed rational messages. To our knowledge, no studies were conducted yet to scrutinize the effectiveness of differently framed emotional messages despite the importance of emotions in consumer decision-making and their use in realistic ads (Pham, 1998). Therefore, the current study wants to complement prior academic research by examining the moderating role of message type (i.e., rational vs. emotional) on the effectiveness of regulatory congruent versus incongruent messages.
2
Hypotheses
Higgins’ self-regulatory focus theory (1997) describes a promotion focus as a tendency to focus on the presence or absence of positive outcomes and a prevenS. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_7, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
108
Cornelis, Adams and Cauberghe
tion focus as a tendency to focus on the presence or absence of negative outcomes. The self-regulatory focus can be either measured as a personality trait or can be temporarily induced (Higgins, 1997). An important finding in the framework of the self-regulatory focus theory is the congruency principle (Higgins, 2000). That is, people experience regulatory congruency when exposed to a message that matches with their inner selfregulatory focus (Higgins, 2000). Regulatory congruency has been found to boost message effectiveness (e.g., Zhao and Pechmann, 2007; Aaker and Lee, 2001). However, it is questionable whether a congruency effect always holds. Previous studies did found mixed results concerning the congruency effect: in certain contexts, an incongruency effect or no effect at all was found. For example, schema congruity theory argues that sometimes, incongruency between the message and its receiver can be more effective than congruency (Mandler, 1982). Also, building on the self-regulatory focus, Wang and Lee (2006) found a regulatory congruency effect in a low involvement context, but not in a high involvement context. Moreover, previous studies have mainly addressed the regulatory congruency principle in a merely rational context (e.g., Yi and Baumgartner, 2009), while, to our knowledge, an emotional context has been neglected so far. Therefore, the current study will assess the moderating role of the message type (i.e., rational versus emotional messages) on the effectiveness of regulatory congruent versus incongruent messages. According to the ‘affect-as-information’ heuristic, when a message is emotional, respondents can use emotions as a valuable input for their subsequent evaluations (Pham, 1998; Schwarz, 1990). However, not all people are naturally inclined to rely on their emotions. It has been shown that reliance on affect (versus cognition) depends on one’s self-regulatory focus (Pham and Avnet, 2004). More precisely, prevention-focused individuals are less likely to rely on affect than promotion-focused individuals. They tend to be more vigilant and externally rather than internally focused (Pham and Avnet, 2009). As a result, it is expected that affect is less salient to prevention-focused than to promotion-focused individuals (Kramer and Yoon, 2007). However, the salience of emotional arguments could also be determined by the characteristics of the message itself. More precisely, affect could be more salient by making the message frame incongruent to the self-regulatory focus of the receiver (Kramer and Yoon, 2007). This is in line with schema congruity theory, postulating that people make judgments by evaluating new stimuli against existing expectations (Mandler, 1982). While congruency results in little arousal, incongruency results in higher
The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages
109
levels of arousal (Mandler, 1975, 1982) and, as a result, attracts more attention and is more salient than congruent information (Mandler, 1982). Based on the above, we expect that salience, created by regulatory incongruency, will be especially important for prevention-focused people when processing an emotional message, as they are not used to rely on affect (Pham and Avnet, 2004, 2009; Kramer and Yoon, 2007). Therefore, we hypothesize the following: H1: When the message is emotional, prevention-focused individuals will indicate a more positive Aad, Ab and PI when the message is incongruent with their self-regulatory focus than when the message is incongruent with their self-regulatory focus. This effect will be less pronounced for promotionfocused individuals. When a message is rational (instead of emotional), comprehensibility, rather than salience, will be of crucial importance for message effectiveness (Eagly, 1974). Prior research has found that messages being congruent (versus incongruent) with one’s self-regulatory focus could enhance comprehensibility, processing fluency and subsequently result in more favourable judgments (Lee and Aaker, 2004). Following this reasoning, we can expect that, when exposed to a rational message, people will prefer a message to be congruent (as opposed to incongruent) to their self-regulatory focus. In line with this, Avnet and Higgins (2006) suggested that the regulatory congruency effect might be especially important in a rational condition. Again, we expect a difference between promotion- and prevention-focused individuals, as Pham and Avnet (2004, 2009) found that prevention-focused individuals are naturally more inclined to rely on message substance than on affect, whereas the reverse is true for promotion-focused individuals. So, we could assume that promotion-focused individuals rely less on message substance than prevention-focused individuals. Therefore, when exposed to a rational message, there will be stronger congruency effects for promotion-focused people (as opposed to prevention-focused people), as promotion-focused people are not used to rely on message substance (Pham and Avnet, 2004, 2009; Lee and Aaker, 2004). Hence, we hypothesize the following: H2: When the message is rational, promotion-focused individuals will indicate a more positive Aad, Ab, and PI when the message is congruent with their regulatory focus than when the message is incongruent with their regulatory focus. This effect will be less pronounced for prevention-focused individuals.
110 3 3.1
Cornelis, Adams and Cauberghe
Method Design and Stimuli
A 2 (chronic self-regulatory focus: prevention vs. promotion) x 2 (message’s regulatory focus: prevention vs. promotion) x 2 (message type: rational vs. emotional) between-subject factorial experimental design was used. Message frame and message type were manipulated into four different messages. In addition, each respondent’s chronic self-regulatory focus was measured using a selfreported scale. The stimuli were pretested among 53 respondents. The results show that the emotional message (M = 5.21) scored significantly higher on the emotionality (versus rationality) scale than the rational message (M = 2.84), (t (51) = 5.83, p < .001). Similarly, respondents rated the promotion focused message (M = 5.96) significantly higher on promotion focus (versus prevention focus) scale than the prevention focused message (M = 2.75), (t (51) = 7.26, p < .001). For this study, ads for fair trade bananas were chosen, because fair trade is a suitable topic for developing rational as well as emotional campaigns. In reality, both rational and emotional fair trade campaigns have been launched with success, indicating that fair trade is a topic fitting both in a rational as well as an emotional persuasion context.
3.2
Participants and Procedures
Data were collected from 284 participants by an online questionnaire. The sample consisted of 54.6 % women, with an average age of 33.12, ranging between 16 and 74 years. The participants were randomly assigned to the four experimental conditions.
3.3
Measures
Chronic self-regulatory focus was measured using the 18 items seven-point Likert scale of Lockwood et al. (2002), containing a promotion dimension (e.g., “I typically focus on the success I hope to achieve in the future.”) (α = .73) and a prevention dimension focus (e.g., “I often imagine myself experiencing bad things that I fear might happen to me.”) (α = .64). Message’s regulatory focus was measured by means of one single item on a seven-point semantic differential scale (i.e., “This advertisement mainly focuses on the avoidance of negative results for the farmers in the South.” versus “This advertisement mainly focuses
The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages
111
on the achievement of positive results for the farmers in the South.”). Message type (rational versus emotional) was measured by a four-item seven-point semantic differential scale by Liu and Stout (1987) (e.g., “I think this advertisement is logical versus emotional.”) (α = .801). Aad was measured by the semantic scale of Mitchell and Olson (1981) (e.g., “I like versus dislike this message”) (α = .92). Ab was assessed by seven bipolar items of Bower and Landreth (2001) (e.g., “I consider the brand to be good versus bad”) (α = .94). The scale of Petrevu and Lord (1994) was used to asses purchase intention (e.g., “It is very likely that I will purchase Oxfam Fairtrade”) (α = .89).
4 4.1
Results Manipulation Check
The manipulation check revealed that the emotional message (M = 4.37) was considered significantly more emotional (versus rational) than the rational message (M = 2.91), (t (282) = 12.51, p < .001). In addition, the respondents rated the promotion focused message (M = 5.58) significantly higher on promotion focus (versus prevention focus) scale than the prevention focused message (M = 4.27), (t (282) = 7.49, p < .001).
4.2
Test of the Hypotheses
To assess the hypotheses, three one-way ANOVA’s were performed. A significant three-way interaction effect appeared among respondents’ regulatory focus, the message’s regulatory focus, and message type on Aad (F (1, 262) = 6.29, p < .05), on Ab (F (1, 262) = 3.92, p < .05), and on PI (F (1, 262) = 9.68, p < .005).
4.2.1
Emotional Messages
Prevention-focused respondents reported a significantly higher Aad towards the incongruent (i.e., promotion-focused) emotional message (M = 5.47) than towards the congruent (i.e., prevention-focused) emotional message (M = 4.53), (t (69) = 4.29, p < .001), while for promotion-focused respondents, no distinct preference for the incongruent (M = 5.32) over the congruent emotional message (M = 5.38) was found (t (62) = 0.27, p = 0.78) (see figure 1). Preventionfocused people also indicated a significantly higher Ab after exposure to the incongruent (i.e., promotion-focused) emotional message (M = 5.74) than to the congruent (i.e., prevention-focused) emotional message (M = 4.89), (t (69) =
112
Cornelis, Adams and Cauberghe
3.84, p < .001), while for promotion-focused respondents, no different response was found after exposure to the incongruent emotional message (M = 5.49) versus after exposure to the congruent emotional message (5.75), (t (62) = 1.03, p = 0.31) (see figure 2). Finally, prevention-focused people also indicated a significantly higher PI after being exposed to the incongruent (i.e., promotionfocused) emotional message (M = 4.69) than after being exposed to the congruent (i.e., prevention-focused) emotional message (M = 3.56), (t (69) = 3.96, p < .001). While again, for promotion-focused respondents, no difference in reaction was found after seeing the incongruent emotional message (M = 4.75) versus after seeing the congruent emotional message (M = 4.41), (t(62) = -0.94, p = 0.35) (see figure 3). Hence, hypothesis 1 was fully supported.
Figure 1: Attitude toward the ad (Aad) for an emotional message
The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages
Figure 2: Attitude toward the brand (Ab) for an emotional message
Figure 3: Purchase intention (PI) for an emotional message
113
114 4.2.2
Cornelis, Adams and Cauberghe
Rational Messages
Promotion-focused respondents reported a significantly higher Aad towards the congruent (i.e., promotion-focused) rational message (M = 5.10) than towards the incongruent (i.e., prevention-focused) rational message (M = 4.51), (t (66) = 2.10, p < .05). While for prevention-focused respondents, no preference between the congruent rational message (M = 4.40) or the incongruent rational message (M = 4.59) was found (t (58) = 0.69, p = 0.49) (see figure 4). Promotion-focused people also indicated a significantly higher Ab for the congruent (i.e., promotion-focused) rational message (M = 5.55) than for the incongruent (i.e., prevention-focused) rational message (M = 4.96), (t (66) = 2.18, p < .05), while for prevention-focused respondents, no preference between the congruent rational message (M = 4.85) or the incongruent rational message (M = 5.00) was found (t(58) = 0.59, , p = 0.56) (see figure 5). Furthermore, promotion-focused people indicated a significantly higher PI towards the congruent (i.e., promotionfocused) rational message (M = 4.50) than towards the incongruent (i.e., prevention-focused) rational message (M = 3.75), (t (66) = 2.58, p < .05), while for prevention-focused respondents, no preference between the congruent rational message (M = 4.23) or the incongruent rational message (M = 4.46), (t(58) = 0.69, p = 0.49) was found (see figure 6). Hence, hypothesis 2 was fully supported.
Figure 4: Attitude toward the ad (Ad) for a rational message
The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages
Figure 5: Attitude toward the brand (Ab) for a rational message
Figure 6: Purchase intention (PI) for a rational message
115
116 5
Cornelis, Adams and Cauberghe
Discussions and Conclusions
The regulatory congruency principle (Higgins, 2000) emphasizes the importance of regulatory congruency in order to obtain more effective messages. However, this study found that the effectiveness of regulatory congruency depends on the message type (i.e., rational or emotional messages). For emotional messages, the results show that, an incongruency effect appeared for prevention focused individuals, who do not generally monitor their internal states. For them, in order for emotions to be relied on by and to be effective for prevention-focused individuals, these emotions should be made salient by making the message’s regulatory frame incongruent to the viewers’ chronic self-regulatory focus (Kramer and Yoon, 2007). In line with schema congruity theory (Mandler, 1982), this result appears to be driven by the salience of incongruent versus congruent information. Furthermore, our finding that promotion-focused people have no significant preference in terms of Aad, Ab, or PI for congruent or incongruent emotional messages, supports the idea that promotion-focused individuals tend to rely on emotions in general, regardless of the message’s regulatory frame (Pham and Avnet, 2004; Kramer and Yoon, 2007). Looking at rational messages, we rather found the opposite. Promotionfocused people reacted more favourably to a rational message that is congruent (versus incongruent) with their self-regulatory focus, whereas congruency or incongruency was of no importance for prevention-focused people. We believe that, as promotion-focused people are less used to rely on the substance of a message, it is more difficult for them to process rational messages (Pham and Avnet, 2004). Matching the rational message’s regulatory focus with viewers’ self-regulatory focus enhances comprehensibility, processing fluency and could, therefore, result in more positive evaluations. Hence, the finding that promotionfocused individuals indicate a more positive Aad, Ab, and PI when a rational message is congruent (as opposed to incongruent) to their self-regulatory focus, supports earlier found congruency effects (Latimer, et al., 2007; Zhao and Pechmann, 2007). Our finding that prevention-focused people have no distinct preference in terms of Aad, Ab, or PI for congruent or incongruent rational messages, supports the idea that prevention-focused people have less difficulties with processing and relying on substance, and are, therefore, also less influenced by the message’s regulatory frame (Pham and Avnet, 2004; Kramer and Yoon, 2007).
The Effectiveness of Emotional and Rational Regulatory (In)congruent Messages
6
117
Limitations and Further Research
In this study, only one type of emotions, namely positively valenced emotions, are examined. This limitation provides possibilities for further research to assess the effect of different types of emotions, including negatively framed emotions. Also, the use of mixed-emotions within prevention- or promotion framed messages could be an interesting direction for further research. Secondly, only one message topic is examined in the current study, namely “fair trade”. Further research can look at other topics as well. For instance, an advertisement for products that are considered more utilitarian versus hedonic could evoke different preferences in terms of regulatory orientation of the ad (Pham and Avnet, 2006). Next, based on Feldman and Lynch’s (1988) accessibility-diagnosticity model, further research should also measure the ‘accessibility’ and the ‘perceived diagnosticity’, to examine the underlying mechanism of the congruency effect. In addition, it would also be highly relevant for further research to unravel the underlying mechanism supporting the incongruency effect. Lastly, the sample in this study was based on the snowball method. Further studies should enlarge the sample size and use different sampling methods.
7
References
Aaker, J.L. & Lee, A.Y (2001). “I” Seek Pleasures and “we” Avoid Pains: The Role of SelfRegulatory Goals in Information Processing and Persuasion. Journal of Consumer Research, 28, 33-49. Avnet, T. & Higgins, E.T. (2006). How Regulatory Fit Affects Value in Consumer Choices and Opinions. Journal of Marketing Research, 43, 1-10. Bower, A. B. & Landreth, S. (2001). Is Beauty Best? Highly versus Normally Attractive Models in Advertising. Journal of Advertising, 30, 1-12. Cesario, J. & Higgins, E.T. (2008). Making Message Recipients “Feel Right”. How Nonverbal Cues Can Increase Persuasion. Psychological Science, 19 (5), 415-420. Chandy, R.K., Gerard, J.T., Macinnis, D.J. &. Thaivanich, R. (2001). What to Say When: Advertising Appeals in Evolving Markets. Journal of Marketing Research, 38, 399-414. Eagly, A.H. (1974). Comprehensibility of Persuasive Arguments as a Determinant of Opinion Change. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 29 (6), 758-773. Feldman, J.M. & Lynch, J.G.Jr. (1988). Self-Generated Validity and Other Effects of Measurement on Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior. Journal of Applied Psychology, 73, 421-735. Higgins, E.T. (1997). Beyond Pleasure and Pain. American Psychologist, 52 (12), 1280-1300. Higgins, E.T. (2000). Making a Good Decision: Value From Fit. American Psychologist, 55, 121-1230. Kramer, T. &. Yoon, S. (2007). Approach-Avoidance Motivation and the Use of Affect as Information. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 17 (2), 128-138. Latimer, A.E. Rivers, S.E., Rench, T.A., Katulak, N.A., Hicks, A., Hodorowski, J.K.; Higgins, E.T. & Salovey, P. (2007). A Field Experiment Testing the Utility of Regulatory Fit Messages for Promoting Physical Activity. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 44, 826-832.
118
Cornelis, Adams and Cauberghe
Lee, A. & Aaker, J. (2004). Bringing the Frame into Focus: The Influence of Regulatory Fit on Processing Fluency and Persuasion. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 86, 205-218. Liu, S. S. & Stout, P.A. (1987). Effects of Message Modality and Appeal on Advertising Acceptance. Psychology & Marketing, 4 (3), 167-187. Lockwood, P.; Jordan, C. H. & Kunda, Z. (2002). Motivation by Positive or Negative Role Models: Regulatory Focus Determines Who Will Best Inspire Us. Journal of Personality & Social Psychology, 83, 854-864. Mandler, G. (1975). Mind & Emotions, New York: Wiley. Mandler, G. (1982). The Structure of Value: Accounting For Taste, in Margaret, H.; Clarke, S. and S. T. Fiske (eds). Affect and Cognition: The 17th Annual Carnegie Symposium on Cognition, 336. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Petrevu, S. & Lord, K.R. (1994). Comparative and Noncomparative Advertising: Attitudinal Effects Under Cognitive and Affective Involvement Conditions. Journal of Advertising, 23 (2), 77-90. Pham, M. T. & Avnet, T. (2004). Ideals and Oughts and the Reliance on Affect versus Substance in Persuasion. Journal of Consumer Research, 30, 503-517. Pham, M. T. & Avnet, T. (2009). Contingent Reliance on the Affect Heuristic as a Function of Regulatory Focus. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 108 (2), 267-278. Pham, M. T. & Avnet, T. (2009). Rethinking Regulatory Engagement Theory. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 29 (2), 115-123. Schwarz, N. (1990). Feelings as Information: Informational and Motivational Functions of Affective States. In R. M. Sorrentino & E. T. Higgins (Eds.), Handbook of Motivation and Cognition (521- 561). New York: Guilford. Wang, J. & Lee, Y.A. (2006). The Role of Regulatory Focus in Preference Construction. Journal of Marketing Research, 43 (1), 28-38. Yi, S. & Baumgartner, H. (2008). Motivational Compatibility and the Role of Anticipated Feelings in Positively Valenced Persuasive Message Framing. Psychology & Marketing, 25 (11), 10071026. Yi, S. & Baumgartner, H. (2009). Regulatory Focus and Message Framing: A Test of Three Accounts. Motivation & Emotion, 33 (4), 435-443. Zhao, G. & Pechmann, C. (2007). The Impact of Regulatory Focus on Adolescents’ Response to Anti Smoking Advertising Campaigns. Journal of Marketing Research, 44, 671-687.
The Impact of Personality Differences on Efficacy, Attitude and Behavioural Intention in HIV/AIDS Fear Appeal Advertising Marlize Terblanche-Smit, University of Stellenbosch, South Africa Nic S. Terblanche, University of Stellenbosch, South Africa
1
Introduction
Social advertising campaigns address anti-social behavior and pandemics, like HIV/AIDS, with the intention to bring about social change. The effectiveness of advertising is strongly influenced by its ability to target a specific, preferably homogeneous, target market. Advertising in South Africa is often targeted at a heterogeneous audience with a standardized message. The HIV/AIDS pandemic in South Africa is a major concern, especially amongst adolescents, and the main advertising campaign LoveLife does not seem to be producing the desired results. The use of fear as an advertising appeal raises the question on the appropriate severity of the threat. Furthermore theory points out that external influences should be included when evaluating beliefs. These influences include cultural background, perceived vulnerability to HIV/AIDS infection and personality traits, which may have a mediating influence on attitudes, norms and selfefficacy beliefs (Fishbein, 2000). This study investigated whether the use of fear in HIV/AIDS communication increases the likelihood of adopting appropriate behavior amongst adolescents. The influence of personality traits on efficacy beliefs, attitude and behavioral intention were examined.
2
Contextualisation and Literature Overview
Fear is one of the most important secondary drivers of human action (Hergenhahn and Olson, 2003). Fear appeal literature indicate that fear can be described by mood adjectives, including feeling frightened or anxious, and also via ratings of concern or worry (Henthorne et al., 1993; LaTour and Tanner, 2003; LaTour and Rotfeld, 1997; Rogers, 1983). Fear is caused by a threat that is perceived to S. Okazaki (Ed.), Advances in Advertising Research (Vol. 2), DOI 10.1007/978-3-8349-6854-8_8, © Gabler Verlag | Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden GmbH 2011
120
Terblanche-Smit and Terblanche
be substantial and personally relevant to individuals (Easterling and Leventhal, 1989; Ortony and Turner, 1990). The question often raised in fear appeal advertising is the appropriate severity of the threat. (Rotfeld, 2000). Different models to improve the effectiveness of fear appeal have been proposed. Tay, Ozanne and Santiono (2000) recommend the utilization of fear appeals should be segment specific as fear appeals have been found to influence various population segments differently (Burnett and Wilkes, 1980; Burnett and Oliver, 1979; Quinnet al., 1992). According to the EPPM (Extended Parallel Process Model), based on previous fear appeal theoretical approaches (Janis, 1967; Leventhal, 1971; Rogers, 1983), threat motivates action, and perceived efficacy determines whether the action taken controls the danger (protective behavior) or controls the fear (inhibits protective behavior), as indicated in Figure 1. Perceived response efficacy refers to an individual's beliefs that a response effectively prevents the threat (i.e. “I believe condoms prevent HIV contraction”), and perceived self-efficacy refers to an individual's belief in his or her ability to perform a recommended response (i.e. “I think that I can use condoms to prevent HIV contraction”) (Rogers, 1983). If the results of a survey indicated high threat and high efficacy, then it could be stated that the intervention was producing the desired actions (Witte and Allen, 2000). Individual differences however influence the assessment of threat and efficacy. Individuals evaluate the components of a message relative to their prior experiences, culture, and personality characteristics (Witte, 1992). Fishbein (2000) pointed out that self-efficacy is one variable that can be seen as a function of underlying determinants that include beliefs about the outcome of behaviour, social and normative prescriptions within a population, and specific barriers to such actions. Therefore, external influences should be included when evaluating the following beliefs: cultural background, perceived vulnerability to HIV infection and personality traits that may have a mediating influence on attitudes, norms and self-efficacy beliefs.
The Impact of Personality Differences on Efficacy, Attitude and Behavioural Intention
121
Action: Control danger Control fear
Threat
Perceived efficacy
Figure1: The Extended Parallel Process Model (EPPM) (adapted from Witte and Allen, 2000)
HIV/AIDS research shows that about 50 percent of HIV infections in South Africa are transmitted to people before the age of 20, with more than 5 million HIV positive people in a country with a population of 48 million (Avert, 2008). LoveLife is South Africa’s foremost multi-million dollar HIV/AIDS prevention campaign (US$12 million/annum) that does not seem to be producing the desired results in changing social behaviour. Subsequently, the campaign became the world's first organisation to have its funding discontinued by the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, during December 2005. The discontinuance of monetary support reflects debate about the effectiveness of LoveLife's HIV-prevention programme and the viability of behaviour-changing AIDS education (Peng, 2006).
3
Purpose of the Study
The focus of this research study is on the use of fear appeal advertising pertaining to HIV/AIDS and whether the use of fear increases the likelihood of adopting appropriate safe sexual behavior among adolescents. It examines the influence of high, medium, and low/no fear appeal based advertising on fear for HIV/AIDS infection. The influence of personality traits as an external influence on efficacy beliefs, attitude and behavioral intention are also examined. Based on the research objectives, the following hypotheses were proposed when using low-, medium- and high-fear appeal advertising stimuli respectively. H01 Fear arousal is positively influenced by the level of fear appeal; H02 Attitude towards the advertisement is positively influenced by the level of fear appeal; H03 Intention to adapt sexual behaviour is positively influenced by the
122
Terblanche-Smit and Terblanche
level of fear appeal; H04 Efficacy level is negatively influenced by the level of fear appeal. H05 Personality characteristics positively influence efficacy, fear, attitude and intention.
4
Research Method
Exploratory qualitative research was conducted to select appropriate advertisements to be used in the study. This was followed by an experimental research study to measure individual constructs.
4.1
Exploratory Qualitative Research
Advertisements selection was made from various sources including fifty different websites using a key word search for ‘HIV/AIDS advertising’. The age of the actors in the advertisement (18-30 years) were used as principle selection criteria. Nine print advertisements and ten television commercials were selected for the qualitative research, and used as experimental stimuli. The different advertisements were ranked on