Volume
1
Advances in Doctoral Research in Management
This page intentionally left blank
Volume
1
Advances in
D oct o r a l R e s earch
in Management Editor Luiz Moutinho University of Glasgow,UK
Associate Editors Graeme Hutcheson Manc h e s t Un e r i v e rt sy,i U K
Paulo Ritra ISCTE Business School, Lisbon, Portugal
World Scientific NEW JERSEY • LONDON • SINGAPORE • BEIJING • SHANGHAI • HONG KONG • TAIPEI • CHENNAI
Published by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. 5 Toh Tuck Link, Singapore 596224 USA office: 27 Warren Street, Suite 401-402, Hackensack, NJ 07601 UK office: 57 Shelton Street, Covent Garden, London WC2H 9HE
British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
ADVANCES IN DOCTORAL RESEARCH IN MANAGEMENT Vol. 1 Copyright © 2006 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. All rights reserved. This book, or parts thereof, may not be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or any information storage and retrieval system now known or to be invented, without written permission from the Publisher.
For photocopying of material in this volume, please pay a copying fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. In this case permission to photocopy is not required from the publisher.
ISBN 981-256-044-0
Typeset by Stallion Press Email:
[email protected]
Printed in Singapore.
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (ADRM) is a refereed academic research book series which publishes an annual volume devoted to disseminate excellence in doctoral research in management. It publishes seminal and challenging international doctoral research that could be seen as a benchmark in academic effectiveness which embraces the whole spectrum of academic research philosophies (from phenomenological/ ideographic to positivistic/nomothetic research).
Aims and Scope • To provide a robust refereed outlet for doctoral researchers in the management/business field. • To encourage doctoral candidates to disseminate their work and receive positive and constructive feedback on their research projects. • To create a “focused forum and stage” in which some of the new and (potentially important) future research paradigms will be presented and tested among academics. • To become a most relevant academic publication in terms of the introduction of methodological issues, techniques and approaches which will ultimately benefit doctoral students, their supervisors and other researchers. The planned scope will entail the following perspectives: • The annual volume’s coverage is cross-disciplinary since it entails all doctoral research output in the broad areas of management and business. • The main management disciplines from which it is expected to derive submissions will include marketing, strategy, international business, operations management, organisational behaviour, human resource management, organisational systems, finance, managerial economics and technology management.
v
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editor Luiz Moutinho (University of Glasgow, UK)
Associate Editors Graeme Hutcheson (Manchester University, UK) Paulo Rita (ISCTE Business School — Lisbon, Portugal)
Editorial Review Board Enrique Bigne (University of Valencia, Spain) Eduard Bonet (University of Barcelona, Spain) Hilary Bradbury (Case Western Reserve University, USA) Charles Chien (Feng Chia University, Taiwan) Kaye Chon (The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong) Tom Elfring (Free University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands) Evert Gummerson (Stockholm University School of Business, Sweden) John Kraft (University of Florida, USA) Michel Laroche (Concordia University, Montreal, Canada) Robert Lawson (University of Otago, New Zealand) Barbara Lewis (Manchester School of Management, UK) Roderick Martin (University of Southampton, UK) Josef Mazanec (Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration, Austria) Robert Morgan (University of Cardiff, UK) Keith Punch (University of Western Australia, Australia) Hiroaki Sandoh (Kobe Gakuin University, Japan) Stephen Shugan (University of Florida, USA) Richard Thorpe (University of Leeds, UK) Keith Whitfield (University of Cardiff, UK) Arch Woodside (Boston College, USA)
vi
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
ABOUT THE EDITORS
Luiz Moutinho Professor of Marketing, University of Glasgow. He completed his PhD at the University of Sheffield in 1982 and held posts at Cardiff Business School, University of Wales College of Cardiff, Cleveland State University, Ohio, USA, Northern Arizona University, USA and California State University, USA, as well as visiting Professorship positions in New Zealand and Brazil. Between 1987 and 1989 he was the Director of the Doctoral Programmes at the Confederation of Scottish Business Schools and at the Cardiff Business School between 1993 and 1996. He was Director of the Doctoral Programme at the University of Glasgow, School of Business and Management between 1996 and 2004. He is the Editor of the Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (ADRM), and the Journal of Modelling in Management. One of Professor Moutinho’s primary areas of academic research is related to modelling processes of consumer behaviour. He has developed a number of conceptual models over the years in areas such as tourism destination decision processes, automated banking, supermarket patronage, among other areas. The testing of these research models has been based on the application of many different statistical computer modelling techniques ranging from multidimensional scaling, multinomial logit and linear structural relations to neural networks, ordered probit and tabu search. He has published 19 books: Problems in Marketing — Analysis and Applications (2004), second edition, co-authored (lead author) with Charles S Chien. Published by SAGE. Strategic Marketing (2003), co-authored with Laszlo Jozsa (Elsevier) Strategic Management in Tourism (2000). Published by CABI.
vii
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
viii
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
About the Editors
Contemporary Issues in Marketing, co-authored with Martin Evans (MacMillan Business 1999) Strategic Planning Systems in Hospitality and Tourism, co-authored with Paul Phillips (CABI 1998). Quantitative Analysis in Marketing Management, co-authored with Mark Goode and Fiona Davies (Wiley 1998). Financial Services Marketing — A Reader, co-edited with Arthur Meidan and Barbara Lewis (The Dryden Press 1997). Applied Consumer Behaviour (1996), co-authored with Martin Evans and Fred van Raaif. Published by Addison-Wesley. Expert Systems in Tourism Marketing (1996), co-authored (lead author) with Paulo Rita and Bruce Curry. Published by the International Thomson Business Press. Tourist Marketing and Management Handbook (1995), Student Edition, co-edited with Stephen F Witt. Published by Prentice-Hall International. Cases in Marketing Management (1995), second edition. Published by Addison-Wesley. Computer Modelling and Expert Systems in Marketing (1994), co-authored (lead author) with Bruce Curry, Fiona Davies and Paulo Rita. Published by Routledge. Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook (1994), second edition, co-edited with Stephen F. Witt. Published by Prentice-Hall International. Cases in Marketing of Services — An International Collection (1993), co-edited with Arthur Meidan. Published by Addison-Wesley. Applied Marketing Research (1992), co-authored (lead author) with Martin Evans. Published by Addison-Wesley. Problems in Marketing: Analysis and Applications (1991). Published by Paul Chapman Publishing. Managing and Marketing Services in the 1990’s (1990), co-edited with Richard Teare and Neil Morgan. Published by Cassell plc, England. Cases in Marketing Management (1989). Published by Addison-Wesley. Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook (1989), co-edited with Stephen F. Witt. Published by Prentice-Hall International. He has over 350 refereed international publications. In addition to presenting papers at many international conferences, he also has had a vast number of articles published in journals such as
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
About the Editors
ix
Journal of Business Research, Journal of Marketing Management, European Journal of Marketing, Journal of Strategic Marketing, Service Industries Journal, Journal of EuroMarketing, Journal of International Consumer Marketing, International Journal of Advertising, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Journal of General Management, European Management Journal, Journal of Professional Services Marketing, International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management, Irish Marketing Review, Journal of Marketing Channels, International Journal of Service Industry Management, Quarterly Review of Marketing, Marketing Intelligence and Planning, Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services among others. He is also a member of the Editorial Board of several international academic journals. Professor Moutinho has also received a number of awards for excellence in academic research in the USA, UK and Portugal. Luiz Moutinho has been a full Professor of Marketing since 1989 and was appointed in 1996 to the Foundation Chair of Marketing at the University of Glasgow. He holds Visiting Professorships at the University of Vilnius, Lithuania, Bled School of Management, Slovenia and Feng Chia University, Taiwan. Has run teaching courses and research seminars in Denmark, France, Holland, USA, Brazil, Mexico, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Croatia, Slovenia, Hungary, Greece, Lithuania, Finland, Taiwan, Australia, New Zealand, Austria, Mozambique and Mongolia.
Graeme D Hutcheson Dr Graeme Hutcheson is currently director of the MSc in Educational Research programme and postgraduate methodology training in the School of Education at Manchester University. He obtained his doctorate at Manchester University and subsequently worked at Strathclyde and Glasgow Universities. His current specialism is in the teaching and application of generalised linear models, and more generally, in the application of research methodology to social science data. He has worked in a number of areas including psychology, education, linguistics, artificial intelligence (AI), marketing and management. He is the author of numerous journal articles and books, including a book on generalised linear models (The Multivariate Social Scientist. Introductory Statistics using Generalised Linear Models).
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
x
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
About the Editors
In collaboration with Professor Moutinho from Glasgow University, Dr Hutcheson has taught research methods and data analysis at a number of institutions across the world.
Selected publications Hutcheson, G. D., Henderson, M. M. and Davies, J. B. (1995). Alcohol in the workplace: costs and responses. Department of Education and Employment Research Series No. 59. Henderson, M. M., Hutcheson, G. D. and Davies, J. B. (1996). Alcohol and the workplace. WHO Regional Office for Europe, World Health Organization Regional Publications, European Series, 67. Hutcheson, G. D. and Sofroniou, N. (1999). The Multivariate Social Scientist: Introductory Statistics using Generalized Linear Models. Sage Publications. Hutcheson, G. D., Baxter, J. S., Telfer, K. and Warden, D. (1995). Child witness statement quality: general questions and errors of omission. Law and Human Behaviour, 19(6), 631–648. Hutcheson, G. D. and Moutinho, L. (1998). Measuring preferred store satisfaction using consumer choice criteria as a mediating factor. Journal of Marketing Management, 14, 705–720. Moutinho, L. and Hutcheson, G. D. (2000). Modelling store patronage using comparative structural equation models. Journal of Targetting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing, 8(3), 259–275. Davies, F., Moutinho, L. and Hutcheson, G. D. (2001). Exploring key neo marketing directions through the use of an academic think tank: A methodological framework. European Journal of Marketing, 36, 4. Sofroniou, N. and Hutcheson, G. D. (2002). Confidence intervals for the predictions of logistic regression in the presence and absence of a variancecovariance matrix. Understanding Statistics: Statistical Issues in Psychology, Education and the Social Sciences, 1(1), 3–18.
Paulo Rita Dr Paulo Rita is currently Director of the Management Research Centre (MRC) and Associate Professor of Marketing at ISCTE Business School — Lisbon, Portugal. He obtained his PhD in Marketing at Cardiff Business School, University of Wales, UK, and subsequently a Post Doctorate on Web Marketing at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, USA.
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
About the Editors
xi
He was Director of the Doctoral Programme in Marketing at ISCTE Business School in 2000–2001. He is Associate Editor of the Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (ADRM). His current research interests are focused on Web Marketing and E-Commerce, Intelligent and Decision Support Systems in Marketing, Neuromarketing and Consumer Behaviour, and Marketing for Hospitality and Tourism. Dr Rita has published three books, including Expert Systems in Tourism Marketing (1996) co-authored with Luiz Moutinho and Bruce Curry (published by the International Thomson Business Press), and Computer Modelling and Expert Systems in Marketing (1994) co-authored with Luiz Moutinho, Bruce Curry and Fiona Davies (published by Routledge). In addition to presenting over 50 papers at international conferences, he also has had six book chapters and 23 articles published in journals such as Service Industries Journal, European Journal of Marketing, Journal of International Consumer Marketing, Annals of Tourism Research, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Marketing Management, among others. He is also a member of the Editorial Board of five academic journals, and has supervised three PhD theses and 21 master dissertations, and examined six PhD theses and 22 master dissertations. Dr Rita has taught Research Methods at both Doctoral and Master programmes, E-Business and Information Management (Master programmes) Web Marketing & E-Commerce (Postgraduate courses, Executive education) Marketing Decision Support and Expert Systems (Postgraduate courses), Marketing Management & Strategy (Master programmes, Executive education), Consumer Behaviour (Master programmes), Tourism Marketing (Postgraduate courses), International Marketing (Postgraduate courses) in Portugal, Spain, Czech Republic, Mozambique, Cape Verde and Brazil.
Selected publications Águas, Paulo, Paulo Rita, Jorge Costa (2006). Performance as a classification criterium of tourist origins and destinations, Service Industries Journal, 26(3) (April). Moutinho, Luiz, Paulo Rita, Shuliang Li (2006). Strategic diagnostics and managerial judgement: a hybrid knowledge-based approach, Intelligent Systems in Accounting, Finance and Management.
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
xii
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
About the Editors
Pires, Guilherme, John Stanton, Paulo Rita (2006). The Internet, consumer empowerment and marketing strategies, European Journal of Marketing. Rita, Paulo (2000). Marketing, Internet et services en ligne: une application à l’industrie du tourisme, Marketing Management, No. 4, 32–40. Rita, Paulo (2000). Tourism in the European union, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management. Costa, Jorge, Paulo Águas, Paulo Rita (2000). A tourist market portfolio for Portugal, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management. Moutinho, Luiz, Paulo Rita, Bruce Curry (1996). Expert Systems in Tourism Marketing. International Thomson Publishing. Moutinho, Luiz, Bruce Curry, Paulo Rita, Fiona Davies (1994). Computer Modeling and Expert Systems in Marketing, Routledge. Rita, Paulo, Luiz Moutinho (1994). An expert system for promotion budget allocation to international markets. In Muzzaffer Uysal (ed.) Global Tourist Behavior. International Business Press. Moutinho, Luiz, Paulo Rita (1994). Expert systems in tourism. In Stephen Witt and Luiz Moutinho (eds.) Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook (Second Edition). Prentice Hall International. Rita, Paulo, Luiz Moutinho (1994). Promotion budget allocation for national tourist offices using an expert system. In Stephen Witt and Luiz Moutinho (eds.) Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook (Second Edition). Prentice Hall International. Rita, Paulo (1994). Acquiring expertise for a knowledge-based system in tourism marketing. In Vicky Wass and Peter Wells (eds.) Principles and Practice in Business and Management Research. Gower. Rita, Paulo, Luiz Moutinho (1994). An expert system for promotion budget allocation to international markets, Journal of International Consumer Marketing, 6(3), 101–121. Rita, Paulo, Luiz Moutinho (1994). An expert system for national tourist offices, Annals of Tourism Research, 20(1), 143–145. Rita, Paulo, Luiz Moutinho (1992). Allocating a promotion budget, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 4(3), 3–8.
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The editors express kind thanks to the reviewers, who assisted with the reviews involved in this book. Chris Burke (University of Wales, Bangor, UK) Margarida Cardoso (ISCTE Business School — Lisbon, Portugal) David Carson (University of Ulster, UK) Arnaldo Coelho (University of Coimbra, Portugal) Carlos Lucas de Freitas (Instituto Superior Técnico — Lisbon, Portugal) Llyod Harris (University of Cardiff, UK) Kunhuang Huarng (Feng Chia University, Taiwan) Michael Humphreys (University of Nottingham, UK) John Kraft (University of Florida, USA) Michel Laroche (Concordia University, Canada) Barbara Lewis (University of Manchester, UK) Wouter De Maeseneire (Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands) Donald MacLean (University of Glasgow, UK) Robert McIntosh (University of Strathclyde, UK) Rui Menezes (ISCTE Business School — Lisbon, Portugal) Robert Morgan (University of Cardiff, UK) James O’Kane (University of Northumbria, UK) Clara Raposo (ISCTE Business School — Lisbon, Portugal) Richard Thorpe (University Leeds, UK) James Wilson (University of Glasgow, UK) Arch Woodside (Boston College, USA) Tiffany Hui-Kuang Yu (Feng Chia University, Taiwan)
xiii
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006 14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian) fm
This page intentionally left blank
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
CONTENTS
Aims & Scope
v
Editorial Board
vi
About the Editors
vii
Acknowledgements
xiii
Editorial
xvii
DOCTORAL RESEARCH PAPERS Knowledge Transfer: A Review to Explore Conceptual Foundations and Research Agenda Sajjad M. Jasimuddin Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory Mark Tadajewski, Jaqueline Pels, Michael Saren
3
21
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase Using Consumers’ Psychographic Characteristics Elena Fraj, Eva Martínez, Teresa Montaner
47
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model for the Forecasting of Product Life Cycle Segments Mladen Sokele, Vlasta Hudek
77
xv
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
xvi
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Contents
Defensive Strategies and Consumers’ Bounded Rationality: An Artificial Market Simulation Josef A. Mazanec, Ulrike Schuster, Jürgen Wöckl A User Evaluation of Web Recommender Systems Ulrike Bauernfeind The Determinants of Relationship Marketing: An Application to Thermal Spas Joaquim Antunes Supermarket Site Assessment and the Importance of Spatial Analysis Data Armando B. Mendes, Margarida G. M. S. Cardoso, Rui Carvalho Oliveira
107
137
153
171
DOCTORAL RESEARCH NOTES A Framework for Corporate Crisis Management: Applications to SMEs in Australia Mohammed Aba-Bulgu, Sardar M. N. Islam
199
Option Games, Asymmetric Information and Merger Announcement Returns Hongbo Pan, Xinping Xia
211
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY PAPERS Analysing Data Using GLM Models Graeme D. Hutcheson The Issue of Missing Values, their Presence and Management: A Relevant Demonstration of Data Analysis in Marketing Using CaRBS Malcolm J. Beynon
223
245
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
EDITORIAL
Part 1 After having been involved with doctoral research for many years (I have been Director of Doctoral Programmes for 17 years), I can clearly say that I have developed a passionate linkage with this particular scholarly activity. So much so that, a few years ago, I had the idea of launching a Journal of Doctoral Research in Management, although I never had any particular inclination to take on a job as an editor of an academic refereed outlet. Despite many views reinforcing the idea that doctoral research is normally published in specialised academic channels, and according to the different topics and management areas of research, I have persevered and grateful to World Scientific Publishing (WSP) for believing in the project. WSP offered to publish my idea of the Journal but in the format of a book series, although all the editorial and refereeing policies would be the same as traditional robust academic journal. Hence, the scholarly launch of Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (ADRM)! Because ADRM is striving for very high standards in terms of paper reviewing and the subsequent refereeing process, as well as a relatively moderate submission rate which can be understandable in the case of a new academic publication, the previously planned inception into the academic market of ADRM for 2005 had to be delayed and re-scheduled for 2006. But finally, my project comes to fruition and I really hope that the quality of submissions and the level of acceptance by the doctoral research community are both going to be sustainably higher in the future and that ADRM can play an important dissemination role in terms of the most outstanding doctoral research in management. I would like to thank a number of people at World Scientific Publishing, namely Kim Tan for trusting my ideas right from the beginning; Chean Chian Cheong, my Editor, for the excellent work carried out at the Editorial Office of ADRM; and Hooi Yean Lee and Serene Fong of the marketing xvii
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
xviii
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
department for all their help and support to the project. I have also to thank Sylvia Kerrigan for her initial tremendous aid as an Editorial Administrator at the University of Glasgow. In addition, I can only show my gratitude to both of my Associate Editors, Graeme Hutcheson and Paulo Rita, for all the encouragement, assistance, advice and friendship all of which have been proven critical and essential for the successful launch of ADRM. A final big thank you to all the authors, reviewers and Editorial Board members who have endorsed ADRM with their contributions! I sincerely hope that the intended audience of ADRM — doctoral researchers and academics — provide us with the necessary feedback related to the scientific robustness of ADRM so that this book series can be constantly improved. To all, please accept my sincere gratitude. Professor LUIZ MOUTINHO Editor, ADRM
Part 2 In the knowledge-based society, knowledge transfer is the key issue of an organisation’s competitive advantage. The topic of knowledge transfer within the knowledge management discipline is an emerging research field with many issues yet to be explored. Knowledge transfer is widely emphasised as an important issue for competitive advantage of an organisation. However, there is little or no research on determinants of choice of knowledge transfer media, and the integration of knowledge transfer and storage are two potential research areas. Jasimuddin attempts to provide a roadmap of the existing literature in knowledge transfer. The purpose of the paper is to identify valuable directions for new research into knowledge management, particularly knowledge transfer. In this regard, the rationale for selecting a particular knowledge transfer mechanism is one of the key organisational problems that firms encounter, and that warrants further addressing. The important point is that it will be easier to conceptualise and utilise knowledge if we can recognise the appropriate mechanism to transfer knowledge. The paper undertakes a comprehensive review of the relevant knowledge management literature so as to understand the existing literature within the area and to position the research questions within the context of that literature. This discussion is actually
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
xix
taking a first step towards developing some arguments about determinants of mechanism selection of knowledge transfer, and the connectivity of knowledge transfer and storage in order to broaden our understanding of the notion of knowledge transfer. It is also hoped that such an effort will engender interest in the topic of knowledge management, and knowledge transfer in particular, and, in so doing stimulate other researchers to address some of the research questions in more direct studies. Furthermore, the research framework presented here provides linkages between different topics and sub-topics reviewing numerous studies which helps to assist prospective researchers in identifying areas where considerable progress has been made and also in organising the considerable number of the existing studies. Tadajewski, Pels and Saren review the recent paradigm debates in marketing and reflect on the current pluralism of paradigms. It make the case that a future important direction for marketing theory is multiple paradigm research; an avenue that has been widely explored in organisation studies, but as yet has had little extended treatment in marketing or consumer research. As a first movement in this direction they review the debates that have taken place in organisation studies showing how the so-called “paradigm mentality” has been seen to hamper constructive debate across paradigms, whereby researchers from different paradigms can fail to agree on inter-paradigm standards of evaluation so that theory choice between the divergent outputs of two different paradigms cannot easily be resolved. Then they question the veracity of the early incommensurability thesis apparent in Kuhn’s writing and the subjectivism that follows from Feyerbend’s interpretation of incommensurability, negotiating these arguments by drawing upon the Kuhnian concept of taxonomical lexicon, to suggest that learning alternative paradigms is similar to learning another natural language. By way of a conclusion they also reflect on the possibilities and possible problems associated with undertaking doctoral research using a multiple paradigmatic team brought together to contribute the distinct insights that each paradigm brings to the project. Fraj, Martinez and Montaner identify the characteristics of the consumer willing to purchase ecological products and consider their disposition to buy these products even when their price is higher than the non-ecological products. They consider in their study variables relating to ecological behaviour such as values, lifestyle, personality and attitude. Their results confirm that the psychographic variables used differentiate the consumer profile who is willing to purchase ecological products at different prices. These results reveal
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
xx
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
that companies face a wide demanding market and considering the environmental principles consistently in their global and marketing strategies may give them a sustainable competitive advantage which is critical today, given that consumers increasingly appreciate ecological issues. Proper forecast of product market diffusion enables optimal planning of resources, investments, revenue, marketing and sales. Quantitative forecasting methods for this purpose rely on sigmoidal growth models such as logistic growth and the Bass model, which are acceptable for the first adoption interval of product life cycle (PLC). Modelling of other PLC segments requires complex models that need large set of input data that limits their application for the forecasting purposes. Sokele and Hudek present extensions of the logistic growth model that combine the principle of sigmoidal growth and the concept of interpolation splines. In addition, the adaptation of the logistic model is shown to be congruent with the Bass model. Applications of developed models for the forecasting of PLC segments are analysed and examined, together with possible ways of interaction between different products. Developed models and interaction types enable forecasting of the entire PLC with a minimum set of input data, or assessment of qualitative forecasting results. In the case of a minimum set of input data, the introduced logistic spline model is proposed for the forecasting of product life cycle segments with monotone growth or decline. The whole product life cycle modelling, that includes a combination of growth and decline, should be achieved by combining logistic splines and sigmoidal envelopes described within the interaction between products on a market. Mazanec, Schuster and Wöckl explore new ways of exposing defensive strategy recommendations to varying market conditions. This experiment analyses the consequences of changes in three factors: (1) a consumer population pursuing noncompensatory brand choice rules; (2) distinctive versus indistinctive (nonsegmented) preference structures; and (3) low versus high responsiveness to advertising. The consumer’s response is simulated on an Artificial Consumer Market (ACM). The ACM assists in constructing the surface of the incumbent’s profit function under a fixed-entry scenario and for experimentally varied market characteristics. The expected influence of consumers’ noncompensatory choice rules on defensive strategy is clearly demonstrated. Quite remarkably, this most amazing of the original gametheoretic results from “Defender” receives new support from findings gained with a completely different methodology of agent-based simulation.
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
xxi
Decision-aid systems like web recommenders are an appropriate means to reduce this abundance of information by filtering out relevant items according to the user’s previously stated preferences. Therefore, the impact of recommender systems is scarcely researched. Bauernfiend proposes a model covering the factors impacting consumer satisfaction with recommender systems in her article. The model itself is designed empirically tested using three recommender systems. Respondents will be asked to simulate a real system user interaction and to evaluate the recommender systems afterwards. The objective will be to identify factors having the most significant impact on recommender system satisfaction. The conceptualisation relates to the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). Trust, hedonic benefits and experience are important constructs belonging to the research model depicting this particular interaction with a website. Relationship marketing has become a decisive approach for the new marketing context organisations face. It is defined as an interactive process which allows an organisation to establish stable, long-lasting relationships with their customers. The study by Antunes is centred on the analysis of the different roles performed by the determinants of relationship marketing and the environmental factors in the satisfaction and customer loyalty. The importance of satisfaction, trust and commitment as mediating variables are analysed in the process of relationship marketing. The empirical study is carried out with 346 people who patronise Portuguese thermal spas, using quota sampling process. In order to validate this theoretical model and to test the hypotheses a structural equation model is used. The role of the mediating variables: satisfaction, trust and commitment in the relationship marketing process, is unmistakable. These variables are considered fundamental to bather loyalty. Trust in the organisation plays a crucial role as it is a prerequisite to commitment. This model has the particularity of including a simultaneous analysis of relationship marketing variables and environmental factors and their direct and indirect effects on the loyalty of spa customers. In this way this study validates the various dimensions of relationship marketing and its influence on bather satisfaction and loyalty. It contributes with the development of new measurement instruments (the scales used), validated through different statistical methods. As it is a fairly recent area of knowledge, an added difficulty, it has an innovating character.
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
xxii
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
Mendes, Cardoso and Oliveira in their paper explored the supermarket site assessment problem. This work proposes a 3-step method for stores’ site turnover forecast. In order to deal with demographic and competition data related to each supermarket, they use neighbourhood delimitation techniques. Three alternative delimitation techniques and two allocation procedures are compared. Results are evaluated based on the proportion of sales turnover variance that the alternative predictors are able to explain. Finally, they compare the relative importance of spatial data predictors in site assessment evaluation, using Dominance Analysis. As a result, the relevance of spatial analysis predictors clearly emerges being only dominated by the “sales area”. At ADRM, we are also planning to introduce a section on doctoral research notes. These full double- or triple-blind refereed papers which can be (i) shorter versions of an extended monograph; (ii) doctoral research papers already submitted as a research note; or (iii) a conventional doctoral research paper which has been shortened following a decision by the ADRM editors and with the full acquiescence of the author(s). In this first issue of ADRM, we are including one of these such doctoral research notes. Bulgu and Islam developed a general framework for the design of corporate crisis management strategies. The focus here is on the identification and analysis of stages of corporate crisis management, the analysis of the implications of various communication strategies, as well as the identification and analysis of appropriate promotional strategies during various phases of business interruption. The authors apply this conceptual model and subsequent considerations to the realm of small and medium size enterprises (SMEs). They claim that it is essential to understand the impact of the reconstruction of tangible and intangible assets. Under the circumstance of industry-wide uncertainty, the paper by Pan and Xia models the intuition that returns to the acquiring firm rely on the different stock market valuations between managers and investors of merging firms which result from the asymmetric information on the merging synergism between them. In their paper the authors present a dynamic model of mergers based on stock market valuations of merging firms with industry-wide uncertainty. The model incorporates asymmetric information and determines the terms and timing of mergers by solving cooperative option games between
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
xxiii
acquiring shareholders and target shareholders. The model predicts that (1) returns to acquiring shareholders can be negative if the managers of participants are much more optimistic over merging synergism than outside investors; (2) returns to acquiring shareholders are negatively correlated with the size of the acquirer; and (3) returns to target shareholders are negatively correlated with the size of the target. At ADRM, we will strive to introduce in each volume, a selected number of research methodology papers that could trigger new research insights and benefit doctoral researchers. In this first volume, we are presenting two of such articles. In the first of these research methodology papers, Hutcheson introduces a focus on analysing data using generalised linear models (GLMs). He discusses several generalised linear modelling techniques according to the type of response variable under study. The analytical presentation starts with the modelling approach used for continuous data — OLS regression (simple and multiple), followed by modelling binary data (simple logistic regression). The proportional odds model for ordered categorical data and multinomial logistic regression for unordered categorical data are also presented. Missing values are an often-alleged incumbency to the effectiveness of successful data analysis. Their presence able to be explained or not may be the issue, the very least acknowledges. In this second research methodology paper, Beynon discusses the extant issues of the presence of the missing values in data analysis, with particular attention to their management, including imputation. Following this discussion, the nascent Classification and Ranking Belief Simples (CaRBS) system for data analysis (object classification) is presented which has the distinction of not requiring the a priori consideration (management) of any missing values present. Moreover, they are treated as ignorant values and retained in the analysis, a facet of CaRBS being associated with the notion of uncertain reasoning. A problem on the classification of standard and economy food products is considered, with knowledge on their inherent nutrient levels used in their discernment. The visualisation of the intermediate and final results offered by the CaRBS system allows a clear demonstration of the effects of the presence of missing values, within an object classification context. We sincerely hope that you will find ADRM a useful and academically robust source and outlet for doctoral research in management, and we look forward to receiving your comments, constructive feedback, suggestions and,
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
14:42
xxiv
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Editorial
above all, submissions so that we can continually enhance the quality and scope of Advances in Doctoral Research in Management. Luiz Moutinho Graeme Hutcheson and Paulo Rita
fm
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
DOCTORAL RESEARCH PAPERS
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006 11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian) ch01
This page intentionally left blank
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
1 KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER: A REVIEW TO EXPLORE CONCEPTUAL FOUNDATIONS AND RESEARCH AGENDA Sajjad M. Jasimuddin School of Management and Business University of Wales, Aberystwyth Cledwyn Campus Ceredigon SY23 3DD, UK
[email protected] Received October 2004 Accepted October 2005 The topic of knowledge transfer within the knowledge management discipline is an emerging research field with many issues yet to be explored. Knowledge transfer is widely regarded as important for enhancing the competitive advantage of an organisation. Researchers have shown much interest in various aspects surrounding knowledge transfer, including factors affecting knowledge transfer, knowledge transfer for innovation, and knowledge transfer process. However, there are little or no research on determinants of choice of knowledge transfer media and the integration of knowledge transfer and storage. This paper attempts to provide a roadmap of the existing literature in knowledge transfer. Its purpose is to identify valuable directions for new research into knowledge management, particularly knowledge transfer. This is done by reviewing the relevant literature to develop research questions. The research framework presented here provides linkages between different topics and sub-topics reviewing numerous studies, which will help researchers sketch future research phenomenon and, in so doing stimulate other researchers to address some of the research questions in more directed studies.
Keywords: Knowledge management, knowledge transfer, organisational memory, innovation, knowledge transfer mechanism.
3
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
4
S. M. Jasimuddin
1.
Introduction
The term “Knowledge Management” refers to the efforts of managing knowledge of an organisation so as to enhance its competitive advantage. As a key concern in the “post-industrial” society, organisations need to emphasise the importance of the creation, acquisition, transfer, retention, retrieval, and use of organisational knowledge, which seems to be the major tasks of knowledge management. The majority of the existing knowledge management literature tends to focus on various issues including knowledge typology (Polanyi, 1958; Nonaka, 1994; Spender, 1995; Blackler, 1995; Jasimuddin, 2005a), knowledge transfer (Albino, 1999; Argote and Ingram, 2000; Smith and McKeen, 2003; Connell et al., 2003; Pan and Scarbrough, 1999; Huber, 2001), knowledge creation (Nonaka, 1994; Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1995; Nonaka and Kanno, 1998; Jenkins and Balogun, 2003), and knowledge storage and retrieval (Walsh and Ungson, 1991; Olivera, 2000; Stein and Zwass, 1995; Sherif, 2002; Anand et al., 1998; Scarbrough, 1995; Jasimuddin et al., 2005a). Most specifically, knowledge transfer has been identified as a major focus area for knowledge management (Hendriks, 1999). In a survey result, McAdam and McCreedy (1999) show that knowledge transfer is considered as the key element of knowledge management by the majority of the respondents. Knowledge transfer is widely emphasised as a strategic issue for the competitive advantage of an organisation (Cohen and Levinthal, 1990; Albino, 1999; Argote and Ingram, 2000). Realising the significance of knowledge transfer as an important research topic, Holtshouse (1998, p. 227) suggests that research on how to transfer knowledge between seekers and providers is one of the three priority areas for further research. Researchers within the knowledge management field have shown interest in various issues surrounding knowledge transfer, including factors influencing knowledge transfer (Argote and Ingram, 2000; Hendriks, 1999; Kalling, 2003; van den Hoff and van Weenen, 2004), knowledge transfer for innovation (Hogberj and Edvinsson, 1998; Gilbert and Cordey-Hayes, 1996) and knowledge transfer process (Szulanski, 1996; Huber, 1991). However, it is also acknowledged as a major challenge among the researchers (Argote, 1999; Argote et al., 2000). Argote (1999), for example, argues that successful knowledge transfer is still difficult to achieve. This has prompted the author to review the existing knowledge management literature in order to focus on several issues relating to the notion of
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
5
knowledge transfer. The goal of this paper is to identify research opportunities relevant to knowledge transfer. This is done by reviewing the relevant literature to develop research questions. Therefore, this paper is organised as follows. First, the importance of knowledge transfer in an organisation is discussed. Next, a navigation process of the emerging theories of knowledge transfer is presented. Then the available literature is reviewed to explore the future research agenda concerning knowledge transfer and to set out research questions. Finally, conclusions are made.
2.
The Notion of Knowledge Transfer
Knowledge transfer is the process by which such transfer is accomplished between the contributor and the user of knowledge through some communication channels. Despite the fact that knowledge transfer within the knowledge management discipline is a relatively recent topic, several researchers, most notably Hendricks (1999), Nonaka and Hedlund (1991), Szulnaski (2000), and Kalling (2003), have produced a variety of its definitions. Argote et al. (2000, p. 3), for example, define knowledge transfer in organisations as “the process through which one unit (e.g., group, department, or division) is affected by the experience of another”. In parallel with this, knowledge transfer involves the exchanging of knowledge from one person to another (Lind and Persborn, 2000; Bender and Fish, 2000; Albino et al., 1999; Jasimuddin, 2005b). The knowledge transfer among employees in an organisation is considered to be a crucial process in business (Szulanski, 1996; Kalling, 2003; van den Hoff and van Weenen, 2004; O’Dell and Grayson, 1998; Osterloh and Frey, 2000). Gibert and Cordey-Hayes (1996) argue that the organisation’s success depends upon its ability to improve its capabilities by assimilating new technology through knowledge transfer. The Gibert and Cordey-Hayes’s argument (1996) is developed by Cohen and Levinthal (1990) who suggest that knowledge transfer is a critical factor for a firm’s ability to respond to changes, innovate and achieve competitive success. In the emerging knowledge-based society, the ability to transfer knowledge within an organisation has been found to contribute to the performance of the organisation in both manufacturing (Galbraith, 1990) and service sectors (Darr et al., 1995). Parallel to this, Barrett et al. (2004, p. 1) contend along similar lines noting that the major emphasis of organisations is placed on the processes of knowledge transfer, which are increasingly seen as crucial
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
6
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
S. M. Jasimuddin
to organisational success. Reflecting this view, Argote et al. (2000, p. 1) argue that knowledge transfer is becoming increasingly important in organisations, pointing out that organisations which are able to transfer knowledge effectively from one employee to another are more productive and more likely to survive than organisations that are less adept at knowledge transfer. Due to its potentialities to enhance competitive advantage, it is argued that the question that becomes prevalent is not whether, but how quickly an organisation can accomplish knowledge transfer among its members. Although remarkable increases in organisational performance is evident by knowledge transfer, such transfer is also acknowledged as a major challenge among the researchers and practitioners. Several scholars (i.e., Arogate, 1999; Argote et al., 2000; Szulanski, 1996, 2000) assert that the effectiveness of knowledge transfer varies considerably among organisations. Szulnaski (2000), for example, points out that intrafirm transfers of knowledge are often labourious, time consuming, and difficult. Our understanding of the theory of knowledge transfer is still in its most emergent stages. Similarly, Smith and McKeen (2003) contend that the knowledge transfer theory is still in its most rudimentary stages. This has encouraged the researcher to focus on issues surrounding successful knowledge transfer. The issues relating to the notion of knowledge transfer are discussed in the following sections.
2.1. Motivators and barriers of knowledge transfer Van den Hoff and van Weenen (2004) argue that determining the factors that promote or impede the knowledge transfer per se constitutes an important area of knowledge management research. It is found that the majority of the existing literature tends to focus on factors influencing knowledge transfer. In reviewing the literature, a very broad range of the forces that may influence the knowledge transfer in organisations is found available. A growing body of empirical studies conducted by scholars (e.g., O’Dell and Grayson, 1998; Szulanski, 1996; Connelly and Kelloway, 2001; Hendricks, 1999; Pan and Scarbrough, 1999; Davenport and Prusak, 1998; Kelloway and Barling, 1999; Cross et al., 2001; Rush, 2001; McDermott and O’Dell, 2001; Argote and Ingram, 2000; Kalling, 2003; van den Hoff and van Weenen, 2004; Smith and McKeen, 2003) provide some light on factors that stimulate or inhibit knowledge transfer. Having reviewed the literature, the forces that possibly influence the knowledge transfer initiatives can be categorised under five broader groups, namely, cognitive factors, motivational
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
7
and psychological factors, managerial factors, technical factors, and social factors. However, Szulanski (1996), for example, claims that the biggest barrier to knowledge transfer is negligence on both ends of the transfer, followed by the absorptive capacity of the user and the lack of social ties between the actors as the second barrier and the third barrier respectively.
2.2. Knowledge transfer for innovation Viewing knowledge transfer as a major focus area for knowledge management, the limited but growing literature on various aspects concerning the knowledge transfer for innovation are currently found available. Academics namely, Hogberj and Evinsson (1998), Gilbert and Cordey-Hayes (1996), Nonaka and Takeuchi (1995), and Hall (2001) recognise the importance of knowledge transfer and making that knowledge available for innovation. The relevant literature reveals that the existing knowledge in an organisation may be utilised for further development of knowledge which is popularly termed as knowledge creation (Hall, 2001; Gilbert and Cordey-Hayes, 1996; Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1995) or to reuse for decision making and other business purpose (Walsh and Ungson, 1991; Connell et al., 2003).
2.3. Knowledge transfer process Most researchers in the knowledge management field tend to view knowledge transfer either as “an act of transmission and reception” or to think in terms of “a process of reconstruction”. Putting it differently, Albino et al., (1999) argue that the knowledge transfer process can be conceptualised in terms of an operational level of analysis (the information system), a conceptual level of analysis (the interpretative system) or a combination of both. From an operational point of view, the knowledge transfer is a communication process with information processing activities in which a contributor can transfer knowledge to others conveyed by an appropriate mechanism (Lind and Persborn, 2000; Bender and Fish, 2000; Albino et al., 1999; Kalling, 2003), whereas from the conceptual viewpoint, the knowledge transfer is strictly connected to the concept of learning organisation (Gilbert and Cordey-Hayes, 1996; Huber, 1991; Baranson and Roark, 1985; Steensma, 1996). According to Davenport and Prusak (1998, p. 1), knowledge transfer process involves both the transmission of information to a recipient and absorption and transformation from one person to another person.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
8
S. M. Jasimuddin
3.
Narrowing Down a Researchable Topic to Explore Future Research Agenda
Prior to conducting any research, a researcher needs to review the existing literature to avoid duplicating previous work (Bailey, 1997; Smith and Biley, 1997), and to show how and why the current study could add to knowledge. Reflecting this view, Webster and Watson (2002, p. xiii) argue that a review of prior literature is an essential feature of any academic research in order to create a foundation for advancing knowledge and facilitating theory development. Taking as an example the broad area of knowledge management, the relevant management literature has been surveyed so as to show how a research topic can be narrowed down to a workable size (see Figure 1). The map provides a reasonably thorough coverage of core themes and issues in knowledge management. It pulls the issues together in order to narrow down to a research topic and subsequently explore research gaps that still exists in the knowledge management’s repertoire. As mentioned earlier, the majority of the existing knowledge management literature tends to focus on knowledge typology, knowledge transfer, knowledge creation, and knowledge storage and retrieval. In the meantime, knowledge transfer has been identified as the critical element of successful knowledge management implementation. The fact is that scholars have already shown interest in factors influencing knowledge transfer, knowledge transfer for innovation, and knowledge transfer process. The narrowing down process is elaborated to identify unexplored issues for future research. Although the knowledge transfer process seems to be explained in terms of an operational level of analysis, a conceptual level of analysis, or a combination of both, the research topic can be narrowed down by looking at only one perspective, for example, the operational level of analysis in which the knowledge transfer is a communication process. However, the majority of the literature on knowledge transfer has ignored the issues with respect to how knowledge is transferred in organisations and why a particular mechanism is chosen to knowledge transfer. We believe that the knowledge transfer process seems to accomplish well when an appropriate mechanism of knowledge transfer is selected. Viewing knowledge transfer within the operational perspective, there is a research gap in understanding why people select one particular means to carry out the transfer of knowledge. Against this backdrop, the factors that may influence the determination of a particular mechanism of knowledge transfer warrant further research.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
9
Knowledge Management
Knowledge Transfer
Knowledge Typology (Polanyi, 1958; Nonaka, 1994; Spender, 1995; Blackler, 1995; Jasimuddin, 2005a)
(Albino et al., 1999; Connell et al., 2003; Hendriks, 1999; Szulanski, 1996; Argote et al., 2000; McEvily and Zaheer, 1999; Kalling, 2003; Argote and Ingram, 2000; Huber, 2001; Darr and Kurzberg, 2000; Pan and Scarbrough, 1999; Smith and McKeen, 2003; Jasimuddin, 2005b)
Factors Influencing Transfer (Argote, 1999; Argote and Ingram, 2000; Hendriks, 1999; Kalling, 2003; van den Hoff and van Weenen, 2004; Szulanski, 1996; Smith and McKeen, 2003)
Knowledge Creation (Nonaka, 1994; Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1995; Nonaka and Kanno, 1998; (von Krogh, 1998; Jenkins and Balogun, 2000)
Transfer Process (Albino et al., 1999; Hunschild and Miner, 1997; Baum and Ingram, 1998; Darr and Kurzberg, 2000; Darr et al., 1999; Larsson et al., 1998; McEvily and Zaheer, 1999; Connell et al., 2001)
Operational level of Analysis
Knowledge Storing and Retrieval (Walsh and Ungson, 1991; Olivera, 2000 Stein, 1995 Sherif, 2002; Anand et al., 1998; Stein and Zwass, 1995; Hansen, 1999; Scarbrough, 1995; Marsh and Morris, 2001; Jasimuddin et al., 2005a)
Transfer for Innovation Hogberj and Evinsson, (1998), Gilbert and Cordey-Hayes, (1996), Hall, (2001)
Conceptual level of Analysis
(Albino et al., 1999; Bender and Fish, 2000; Kalling, 2003)
(Albino et al., 1999; Gilbert and CordeyHayes, 1996; Huber, 1991; Steensma, 1996)
Knowledge Transfer Mechanism (Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1995; Hansen et al., 1999; Davenport and Prusak, 1998; Pan and Scarbrough, 1999; Bhatt, 2001; Huber, 2001, Roberts, 2000; Jasimuddin et al., 2004; Dixon, 2000; Alavi and Leidner, 2001)
Intra-organizational Transfer (Szulanski, 1996; Kalling, 2003; van den Hoff and van Weenen, 2004; O’Dell and Grayson, 1998; Osterloh and Frey, 2000; Connell et al., 2003)
Knowledge currently in use (Argote and Ingram, 2000; Cohen and Levinthal, 1990; Hansen, 1999; Hogberj and Evinsson, 1998; Hendriks, 1999; Connell et al., 2003)
Inter-organizational Transfer (Albino et al., 1999; Hunschild and Miner, 1997; Darr and Kurzberg, 2000; Darr et al., 1999; Larsson et al., 1998; McEvily and Zaheer, 1999; Connell et al., 2001)
Knowledge of the past (Marsh and Morris, 2001; Argote and Ingram, 2000; Walsh and Ungson, 1991; Olivera, 2000; Stein, 1995 Sherif, 2002; Ackerman and Malone, 1990; Anand et al., 1998; Goldstein, 1991; Huber, 1991)
The determinants in selecting an appropriate mechanism of knowledge transfer and the linkage between knowledge transfer and knowledge storage Figure 1. Topics of knowledge management research.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
10
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
S. M. Jasimuddin
Meanwhile, knowledge transfer is important both within an organisation, i.e., intra-organisational (Szulanski, 1996; Kalling, 2003; van den Hoff and van Weenen, 2004; O’Dell and Grayson, 1998; Osterloh and Frey, 2000) and between different organisations i.e., inter-organisational (Albino et al., 1999; von Hipple, 1988; Darr and Kurzberg, 2000; Larsson et al., 1998; McEvily and Zaheer, 1999). The research may concentrate on intraorganisational knowledge, inter-organisational knowledge, or a combination of both. Focusing on the knowledge within an organisation, the majority of the existing literature on knowledge transfer tends to focus on current knowledge, i.e., the knowledge which is now being used by the organisational members. There have been few studies where academics have stressed the importance of past knowledge in knowledge transfer process (Goldstein, 1991; Marsh and Morris, 2001; Walsh and Ungson, 1991; Stein, 1995; Jasimuddin et al., 2005a). It is argued that past knowledge is a kind of knowledge which is available in various locations of an organisation. The most important point is that the moment it is applied or as soon as some inputs are added to it, it also becomes current knowledge. Knowledge is distributed asymmetrically across the organisation. Distributed knowledge has to be integrated through knowledge transfer process and then stored into a knowledge repository for future use. The Web-based technology allows for storage of the transferred knowledge. Unfortunately, the importance of integrating storage of knowledge within knowledge transfer processes has been ignored in the knowledge transfer literature.
4.
Future Research Agenda
Having identified the importance of the two unexplored issues, namely knowledge transfer mechanisms and the integration of knowledge transfer and storage, these issues will be elaborated and research questions will be set out in the following sections.
4.1. Knowledge transfer mechanisms There have been few studies where researchers have addressed the importance of knowledge transfer mechanisms (e.g., Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1995; Hansen et al., 1999; Davenport and Prusak, 1998; Argote, 1999;
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
11
Newell et al., 1999; Roberts, 2000; Dixon, 2000; Scarbrough et al., 1999; Bhatt, 2001; Huber, 2001; Alavi and Leidner, 2001). To date, the mechanisms of knowledge transfer that are mentioned in the relevant literature can be classified into two dominant camps. Focusing on knowledge-as-acategory perspective, two very different mechanisms for knowledge transfer have emerged, labelled as soft mechanism and hard mechanism. This view is an extension of Hansen et al. (1999), who contend that the personalisation strategy is an approach where knowledge is closely tied to the person who create and share mainly through direct person-to-person interaction; while in the codification strategy, knowledge is carefully codified and technology plays a central role in the knowledge transfer. Although the present literature on knowledge transfer has discussed in isolation the mechanisms used in transferring knowledge, it fails to address the rationale underlying the selection of a particular mechanism to transfer knowledge. Viewing knowledge transfer within an organisation from the operational perspective, there is a research gap in understanding why people select one particular mechanism for knowledge transfer. Our understanding is that the knowledge transfer process seems to accomplish well when a suitable mechanism of knowledge transfer is selected. While discussing mechanisms of knowledge transfer, several researchers (most notably, Kalling, 2003; Day, 1994; Albino et al., 1999; Connelly and Kelloway, 2001; Hansen et al., 1999; Jasimuddin et al., 2005c; Zack, 1999) argue that the mechanism selection of knowledge transfer goes with the tacitness of knowledge. But they have not considered other factors that might influence the selection of a particular mechanism to carry out the transfer of knowledge. While considering the transfer of tacit knowledge between individuals in a synchronised way, the personalisation approach is prescribed (Connell et al., 2003; Lam, 1997; Storey and Barnett, 2001; Davenport and Prusak, 1998; Huysman and De Wit, 2004; Brown and Duguid 1998). On the other hand, the transfer of explicit knowledge can be facilitated through the adoption of codification approach using technologies (Scarbrough et al., 1999; Alavi and Leidner, 1999; Bhatt, 2001; Huber, 2001). But the tacitness of knowledge cannot be the only factor that can influence the choice of knowledge transfer media. There must have been other variable(s) that may also affect the selection of a particular mechanism. Against this backdrop, the identification of factors that influence the selection of a mechanism
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
12
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
S. M. Jasimuddin
for successful knowledge transfer warrants further research. Reflecting this view, the following research question can be set out: What are the determinants of an appropriate mechanism selection for knowledge transfer within an organisation?
4.2. The integration of knowledge transfer and knowledge storage The fact is that knowledge that resides in human brain has less value to an organisation if it is not transferred to other organisational members to use. Organisational knowledge that is transferred among the members within an organisation without storage also has limited value. The value of knowledge increases when it is transferred, retained, and reused among the organisational members. Douglas (2002, p. 74) comments along similar lines noting that “knowledge that is in the head of a person has limited value, while the value of knowledge can increase exponentially when it is networked, stored, and reused, and quickly integrated into business practices and processes”. Most of the studies mentioned earlier on are involved in knowledge transfer but have unintentionally ignored the issues concerning the storage of transferred knowledge and the transfer of stored knowledge (Jasimuddin, 2005c). Gray and Chan (2000, p. 13) contend that knowledge that is created but not stored in a knowledge repository, that is, either simply forgotten or passed on to a knowledge user directly without being stored, represents a waste of resources, because a prospective user will have to solve old problems again (Stein, 1995). There is a heightened interest in the storage of organisational knowledge which is commonly termed as Organisational Memory (Marsh and Morris, 2001; Walsh and Ungson, 1991; Olivera, 2000; Stein and Zwass, 1995; Sherif, 2002; Jasimuddin et al., 2005a). For example, Stein and Zwass (1995) define organisational memory as “the means by which knowledge from the past is brought to bear on present activities, thus resulting in organisational effectiveness”. Despite the fact that there is, however, vast literature relating to the knowledge transfer and knowledge storage in an organisation, it is noticable that the two literatures have largely developed independently of each other. Most of the studies mentioned above seem to have consciously or unconsciously failed to link knowledge transfer with knowledge storage. However, a few studies (e.g., Gray and Chan, 2000; Argote and Ingram, 2000; Douglas, 2002; Connelly and Kelloway, 2001; Kalling, 2003) that already
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
13
exist are isolated descriptions of the significance of having the integration of the knowledge transfer and the knowledge storage. The fact is that organisations should recognise the need for and advantages of the integration of knowledge transfer and knowledge storage, in order to reuse knowledge for present and future business needs. Reflecting this view, Ruggles (1998) points out that organisational members contribute their expertise electronically to their organisation so that it can be accessed by other members of the organisation. This is further supported by Connelly and Kelloway (2001) who observe that many organisations attempt to facilitate knowledge transfer among their employees through the creation of a database or “knowledge repository”. Gray and Chan (2000, p. 13) reinforce this point of view by suggesting that knowledge stored in a repository can be reused for solving future problems. Similarly, Argote and Ingram (2000, p. 152) contend that the knowledge repositories play a dual role in knowledge transfer in organisations: “On the one hand, the knowledge repositories are changed when knowledge transfer occurs. Thus, changes in the knowledge repositories reflect the outcomes of knowledge transfer. On the other hand, the state of the knowledge repositories affects the processes and outcomes of knowledge transfer”. In line with Connelly and Kelloway (2001) and Argote and Ingram (2000), it is arguable that “knowledge storage” needs to be incorporated within the knowledge transfer process so as to ensure successful knowledge management implementation. Whilst there is clear indication of the interactions between knowledge transfer and knowledge storage, however, there is a research gap in understanding the relationships between knowledge transfer and storage. It is believed that the knowledge transfer process seems to accomplish well when knowledge is transferred, stored and retrieved for future reuse in complementary ways. Since the process of integrating knowledge transfer and knowledge storage is largely unexplored, future study may fill partially that gap. Reflecting this view, the following research question can be set out: What is the relationship between knowledge transfer and knowledge storage? Determinants of choice of knowledge transfer media, and the integration of knowledge transfer and storage are two potential research areas that have not been explicitly addressed in top management journals. Using the insights
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
14
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
S. M. Jasimuddin
from the existing studies, this paper proposes the above two research questions relating to knowledge transfer that demand empirical work.
5.
Conclusion
In a knowledge-based society, knowledge transfer is the key issue of an organisation’s competitive advantage. Academics and practitioners have shown a significant interest in understanding knowledge transfer in the management literature (Kogut and Zander, 1992; Prahalad and Hamel, 1990; Starbuck, 1992; Nonaka, 1994; Nonaka and Takeuchi, 1995; Szulanski, 1996). However, there are many gaps in our understanding of the topic of knowledge transfer within the knowledge management field and some questions still remain unresolved. The purpose of this paper is to identify valuable directions for new research into knowledge management, particularly knowledge transfer. In this regard, the rationale for selecting a particular knowledge transfer mechanism is one of the key organisational problems that firms encounter, and that warrants further addressing. The important point is that it will be easier to conceptualise and utilise knowledge if we can recognise the appropriate mechanism to transfer knowledge. As discussed previously, there is also a vast literature in knowledge management that has addressed the issues of knowledge transfer and knowledge storage independently of each other. However, the majority of the literature on knowledge transfer has neglected issues concerning the connectivity of knowledge transfer and knowledge storage for successful implementation of knowledge management initiatives. The paper undertakes a comprehensive review of the relevant knowledge management literature so as to understand the existing literature within the area and to position the research questions within the context of that literature. This discussion has actually taken a first step towards developing some arguments about determinants of selecting a mechanism for knowledge transfer, and the connectivity of knowledge transfer and storage in order to broaden our understanding of the notion of knowledge transfer. It is also hoped that such an effort will create interest in the topic of knowledge management, and knowledge transfer in particular, and, in so doing stimulate other researchers to address some of the research questions in more directed studies. Furthermore, the research framework presented here provides linkages between different topics and sub-topics reviewing numerous studies. It will help to assist researchers in identifying areas where
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
15
considerable progress has been made, and in organising the considerable number of existing studies and thereby exploring potential areas for future research. However, the framework is not meant to be the definitive roadmap of knowledge management research. Although this paper focuses on the literature relating to knowledge transfer, the proposed navigating map provides insights for researchers to set out research questions in other disciplines.
References Alavi, M. and D. Leidner (1999). Knowledge management systems: Issues, challenges, and benefits, Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 7(1), 1–28. Albino, V., G. A. Claudio and G. Schiuma (1999). Knowledge transfer and inter-firm relationships in industrial districts: The role of the leader firm. Technovation, 19, 53–63. Anand, V., C. Manz and W. H. Glick (1998). An organisational memory approach to information management. Academy of Management Review, 23(4), 796–809. Argote, L. and P. Ingram (2000). Knowledge transfer: A basis for competitive advantage in firms. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes, 82(1), 150–169. Argote, L., P. Ingram, J. M. Levine and L. Moreland (2000). Knowledge transfer in organisations: Learning from the experience of others. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes, 82(1), 1–8. Argote, L. (1999). Organisational Learning: Creating, Retaining, and Transferring Knowledge. Nowell, MA: Kluwer. Bailey, P. (1997). Finding your way around qualitative methods in nursing research. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 25, 18–22. Baranson, J. and R. Roark (1985). Trends in north-south transfer of high technology. In N. Roberberg and C. Frischtak (eds.), International Technology Transfer: Concepts, Measures, and Comparisons. New York: Preaeger. Barrett, M., S. Cappleman, G. Shoib and G. Walsham (2004). Communities: Managing technology and context. European Management Journal, 22(1), 1–11. Bender, S. and A. Fish (2000). The transfer of knowledge and the retention of expertise: The continuing need for global assignments. Journal of Knowledge Management, 4(2), 125–137. Blacker, F. (1995). Knowledge, knowledge work and organization: An overview and interpretation, Organization Studies, 16(6), 1021–1046. Bhatt, G. D. (2001). Knowledge management in organizations: Examining the interaction between technologies, techniques, and people. Journal of Knowledge Management, 5(1), 68–75. Brown, J. and P. Duguid (1998). Organizing knowledge. California Management Review, 40(3), 90–111.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
16
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
S. M. Jasimuddin
Cohen, W. M. and D. A. Levinthal (1990). Absorptive capacity: A new perspective on learning and innovation. Administrative Science Quarterly, 35, 128–152. Connell, N. A. D., J. H. Klein and P. L. Powell (2003). It’s tacit knowledge but not as we know: Redirecting the search for knowledge. Journal of Operational Research Society, 54, 140–152. Connelly, C. E. and E. K. Kelloway (2001), Predicators of employees’ perceptions of knowledge sharing cultures. WP 01-06, Ontario, Canada, Queen’s Centre for Knowledge-Based Enterprises. Cross, R., L. Prusak and S. P. Borgatti (2001). Knowing what we know: Supporting knowledge creation and sharing in social networks. Organisational Dynamics, 30(2), 100–120. Darr, E. D., L. Argote and D. Epple (1995). The acquisition, transfer and depreciation of knowledge in service organizations: Productivity in franchises. Management Science, 41, 1750–1762. Darr, E D. and T. R. Kurtzberg (2000). An investigation of partner similarity dimensions on knowledge transfer. Organisational Behaviour and Human Decision Processes, 82(1), 28–44. Davenport , T. H. and L. Prusak (1998). Working Knowledge: How Organisations Manage What They Know. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Day, G. S. (1994). Managerial representations of competitive advantage. Journal of Marketing, 58, 31–44. Dixon, N., (2000). Common Knowledge: How Companies Thrive by Sharing What They Know. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Douglas, P. H. (2002). Information technology is out — knowledge sharing is in. The Journal of Corporate Accounting and Finance, May/June, 73–77. Galbraith, C. S. (1990). Transferring core manufacturing technologies in high technology firms. California Management Review, 32(4), 56–70. Gilbert, M. and M. Cordey-Hayes (1996). Understanding the process of knowledge transfer to achieve successful technological innovation, Technovation, 16(6) 301–312. Goldstein, I. L. (1991) Training in work organisations. In M.D. Dunnette and L. M. Hough (eds.), Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press. Gray, P H. and Y. E. Chan (2000). Integrating knowledge management practices through a problem-solving framework. Working Paper WP 00-03. Kingston: Queen’s Centre for Knowledge-Based Enterprises. Hall, B. P. (2001). Values development and learning organizations. Journal of Knowledge Management, 5(1), 19–32. Hansen, M. T., N. Nohria and T. Tierney (1999) What’s your strategy for managing knowledge? Harvard Business Review, March–April, 106–116. Hendriks, P. (1999). Why share knowledge? The influence of ICT on the motivation for knowledge sharing. Knowledge and Process Management, (6)2, 91–100. Hogberg, C. and L. Edvinsson (1998). A design for futurizing knowledge networking. Journal of Knowledge Management, 2(2), 81–92.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
17
Holtshouse, D. (1998). Knowledge research issues. California Management Review, 40(3), 277–280. Huber, G. P. (1991). Organizational learning: The contributing process and the literatures. Organization Science, 2(1), 88–115. Huber, G. P. (2001). Transfer of knowledge in knowledge management systems: Unexplored issues and suggested studies. European Journal of Information Systems, 10, 72–79. Huysman, M. and D. De Wit (2004). Practices of managing knowledge sharing: Towards a second wave of knowledge management. Knowledge and Process Management, 11(2), 81–92. Jasimuddin, S. M., N. A. D. Connell and J. H. Klein (2005a). Understanding organisational memory. In D. Schwartz (ed.), The Encyclopaedia of Knowledge Management. Hershey, P. A.: Idea Publishing Ltd, 870–875. Jasimuddin, S. M., J. H. Klein and N. A. D. Connell (2005b). The paradox of using tacit and explicit knowledge: Strategies to face dilemmas. Management Decision, 43(1), 102–112. Jasimuddin, S. M. (2005a). Knowledge of external sources’ knowledge: New frontier to actionable knowledge. In M. A. Rahim, R. T. Golembiewski and K. D. Mackenzie (eds.), Current Topics in Management, Vol. 10. New Brunswick, N.J.: Transaction Publishers, 39–50. Jasimuddin, S. M. (2005b). Towards an integrated framework for the knowledge transfer process. Unpublished PhD. Thesis, University of Southampton, UK. Jasimuddin, S. M. (2005c). Storage of transferred knowledge or transfer of stored knowledge: Which direction? If both, then how? Proceedings of the 38th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, The IEEE Computer Society. Jenkins, M. and J. Balogun (2003). Re-conceiving change management: A knowledgebased perspective. European Management Journal, 21(2), 247–257. Kalling, T. (2003). Organization-internal transfer of knowledge and the role of motivation: A qualitative case study. Knowledge and Process Management, 10(2), 115–126. Kelloway, E. K. and J. Barling (2000). Knowledge work as organizational behaviour. International Journal of Management Reviews, 2, 287–304. Kogut, B. and U. Zander (1992). Knowledge of the firm, combinative capabilities, and the replication of technology. Organisation Science, 3, 383–396. Lam, A. (1997). Embedded firms, embedded knowledge: Problems in collaboration and knowledge transfer in global cooperative ventures. Organization Studies, 21(3), 487–513. Larsson, R., L. Bengtsson, K. Henriksson and J. Sparks (1998). The interorganizational learning dilemma: Collective knowledge development in strategic alliances. Organization Science, 9(3), 285–305. Lind, M. and M. Persborn (2000) Possibilities and risks with a knowledge broker in the knowledge transfer process. University of Wales, Swansea. McAdam, R. and S. McCreedy (1999). The process of knowledge management within organisations: A critical assessment of both theory and practice. Knowledge and Process Management, 6(2), 101–113.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
18
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
S. M. Jasimuddin
McDermott, R. and C. O’Dell (2001). Overcoming cultural barriers to sharing knowledge. Journal of Knowledge Management, 4(3), 204–212. McEvily, B. and A. Zaheer (1999) Building ties: A source of firm heterogeneity in competitive capabilities. Strategic Management Journal, 20, 1133–1156. Marsh, C. H. and E. C. Morris (2001). Corporate memory and technical communicators: A relationship with a new urgency. Proceedings of the Professional Communication Conference, 24–27 October, 2001. Newell, S., H. Scarbrough, J. Swan and D. Hislop (1999). Intranets and knowledge management: Complex processes and ironic outcomes. Proceedings of the 32nd Hawaii Conference on System Sciences, Los Alamitos, CA. Nonaka, I. (1994). A dynamic theory of organisational knowledge creation. Organisation Science, 5(1), 14–37. Nonaka, I. and C. Hedlund (1991). Models of knowledge management in the West and in Japan. Working paper, Institute of International Business, Stockholm School of Economics. Nonaka, I. and N. Kanno (1998). The concept of “Ba”: Building a foundation for knowledge creation. California Management Review, 40(3), 40–54. Nonaka, I and H. Takeuchi (1995). The Knowledge Creating Company. Oxford: Oxford University Press. O’Dell, C. and C. J. Grayson (1998). If only we knew what we know: Identification and transfer of internal best practices. California Management Review, 40, 154–174. Olivera, F. (2000). Memory systems in organisations: An empirical investigation of mechanisms for knowledge collection, storage and access. Journal of Management Studies, 37(6), 811–832. Osterloh, M and B. S. Frey (2000). Motivation, knowledge transfer, and organisational forms. Organization Science, 11(2), 538–550. Pan, S. L. and H. Scarbrough (1999). Knowledge management in practice: An exploratory case study. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 11(1), 359–374. Polanyi, M. (1958). Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post Critical Philosophy. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul Ltd. Prahalad, C. K. and G. Hamel (1990). The core competition of the corporation. Harvard Business Review, May–June, 79–91. Roberts, J. (2000). From know-how to show-how? Questioning the role of information and communication technologies in knowledge transfer. Technology Analysis and Strategy Management, 12(4), 429–443. Ruggles, R. (1998). The state of the notion: Knowledge management in practice. California Management Review, 40(3), 80–89. Rush, D. (2001). Measuring connectivity at Aventis Pharmaceuticals. KM Review, 5(2), 10–13. Scarborough, H. (1995). Blackboxes, hostages and prisoners. Organisation Studies, 16(5), 991–1019. Scarbrough, H., J. Swan and J. Preston (1999). Knowledge Management: A Literature Review. London: Institute of Personnel and Development.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Knowledge Transfer
19
Sherif, K. (2002). Barriers to adoption of organisational memories: Lessons from industry. In S. Barnes (ed), Knowledge Management Systems. London: Thompson Learning, 210–221. Smith, K. and F. Biley (1997). Understanding grounded theory: Principles and evaluation. Nurse Researcher, (4), 17–30. Smith, H. A. and J. D. McKeen (2003). Instilling a knowledge-sharing culture. WP 03-11, Queen’s Centre for Knowledge-Based Enterprises, Queen’s University at Kingdom, Ontario. Spender, J. C. (1995). Organisational knowledge, collective practice and Penrose rents. International Business Review, 3(4), 1–5. Starbuck, W. R. (1992). Learning by knowledge intensive firms. Journal of Management Studies, 29(6), 713–740. Steensma, K. H. (1996). Acquiring technological competencies through interorganisational collaboration: An organisational learning perspective. Journal of Engineering and Technology Management, 12, 267–286. Stein, E. W. (1995). Organisational memory: Review of concepts and recommendations for management. International Journal of Information Management, 15(2), 17–32. Stein, E. W. and V. Zwass (1995). Analyzing organisational memory with information systems. Information Systems Research, 6, 285–314. Storey, J. and E. Barnett (2001). Knowledge management initiatives: Learning from failure. Journal of Knowledge Management, 4(2), 145–156. Szulanski, G. (1996). Exploring internal stickiness: Impediments to the transfer of best practice within the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 17 (Winter Special Issue), 27–43. Szulanski, G. (2000). The process of knowledge transfer: A diachronic analysis of stickiness. Organisational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 82(1), 9–27. van den Hoff, B. and F. De L. van Weenen (2004). Committed to share: Commitment and CMC use as antecedents of knowledge sharing. Knowledge and Process Management, 11(1), 13–24. von Hipple, E. (1988). The Sources of Innovation. New York: Oxford University Press. Walsh, J. P. and G. R. Ungson (1991) Organizational memory. Academy of Management Review, 16(1), 57–91. Webster, J and R. T. Watson (2002) Analyzing the past to present for the future: Writing a literature review. MIS Quarterly, 26(2), xiii–xxiii. Zack, M. H. (1999). Developing a knowledge strategy. California Management Review, 41(3), 125–145.
ch01
FA1
May 20, 2006 11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian) ch02
This page intentionally left blank
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
2 NEGOTIATING INCOMMENSURABILITY IN MARKETING THEORY Mark Tadajewski∗ Department of Accounting, Finance and Management University of Essex, Wivenhoe Park Essex, C04 3SQ, UK
[email protected]
Jaqueline Pels Universidad Torcuato Di Tella, Saenz Valiente 1010 (1428 ATG) Capital Federal, Argentina
Michael Saren Management Centre, University of Leicester University Road, Leicester, LE1 7RH, UK Received May 2005 Accepted January 2006 This paper reviews the recent paradigm debates in marketing and reflects on the current pluralism of paradigms. It makes the case that a future important direction for marketing theory is multiple paradigm research; an avenue that has been widely explored in organisation studies, but as yet has had little extended treatment in marketing or consumer research. As a first movement in this direction, we review the debates that have taken place in organisation studies showing how the so-called “paradigm mentality” has been seen to hamper constructive debate across paradigms, whereby researchers from different paradigms can fail to agree on inter-paradigm standards of evaluation so that theory choice between the divergent outputs of two
∗ Corresponding
author. 21
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
22
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren different paradigms cannot easily be resolved. We then turn to the incommensurability thesis. We question the veracity of the early incommensurability thesis apparent in Kuhn’s writing and the subjectivism that follows from Feyerabend’s interpretation of incommensurability, negotiating these arguments by drawing upon the Kuhnian concept of taxonomical lexicon, to suggest that learning alternative paradigms is similar to learning another natural language. By way of a conclusion, we reflect on the possibilities and problems associated with undertaking doctoral research using a multiple paradigmatic team brought together to contribute the distinct insights that each paradigm brings to the project.
Keywords: Marketing theory, multiple paradigm research, paradigm incommensurability, pluralism, politics.
1.
Introduction
It is becoming routine to describe marketing theory in terms of its plurality (Thompson et al., 1998). Over the past twenty years this plurality has been seen to emerge as a response to the limitations of logical empiricism as the epistemological basis for marketing theory (Arndt, 1985a, 1985b). In response to the supposed strictures imposed by this philosophy of science and the comparative neglect of subsequent advances in philosophy, a small, but vocal group of marketing scholars, made the compelling case for a relativist turn in marketing theory and sought to demonstrate that a philosophical movement towards critical relativism would broaden the basis on which the foundations of marketing theory could be developed (cf. Anderson, 1983; Hunt, 1984). More recently, the focus of attention has again shifted, except this time ontological appeals are more prevalent, with Easton (2002) calling for critical realism as the appropriate stance from which we can generate marketing theory. These are technical and complex issues that continue to be debated and will, no doubt, remain contested for many years to come (e.g., Brown, 2005; Davies and Fitchett, 2005; Donaldson, 2005; Lowe et al., 2004; Lowe et al., 2005). While we can only gesture towards these changes here, they point to a sea change in the way that we view the production of knowledge. No longer limited to logical empiricism, the marketing theorist is confronted by a diverse literature that offers a plurality of paradigms applicable to a variety of research topics (Davies and Fitchett, 2005; Tadajewski, 2004). Paradigms, for Kuhn (1962), represented a set of assumptions that influenced our way of viewing the world and they are, in Kuhn’s parlance, theoretical structures comprised of a network of conceptual, theoretical and instrumental commitments that provide models for future research. These
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
23
“local epistemologies” provide the foundation upon which we base our research (Grimes and Rood, 1995). The recent emergence of a plurality of seemingly incommensurable, “mutually exclusive” paradigms (Burrell and Morgan, 1979/1992) has led some to make the case that the use of a single paradigm to produce theory, as has been common to date, may result in intellectual provincialism with the researcher biased, either consciously or unconsciously, against alternative accounts of the phenomena they investigate (Gioia and Pitre, 1990). Here, the paradigm we subscribe to becomes an ideological force directing the way we view the world and our relationship to it (Deetz, 1996; Hirschman, 1986; Jackson and Carter, 1991, 1993). This “paradigm mentality” encourages us to limit possible dialogue between incommensurable paradigms and fosters the polarisation of theory production (Reed, 1990, 1992, 1993, 1999; McKelvey, 1997, 1999, 2003a, 2003b). From these initial movements towards greater epistemic pluralism in marketing sprang research based on phenomenology, hermeneutics, critical theory, post-structuralism and post-modernism. More recently, we are witnessing a new shift in this epistemological turn with various calls for research that supplements, but does not replace, mono-paradigm research, that is, for research that adopts multiple paradigms in a single study (Davies and Fitchett, 2005; Foxall, 2002; Hirschman, 1987; Lowe et al., 2004; Lowe et al., 2005; Tadajewski, 2004, forthcoming; Tynan, 2002; Wilk, 2001). The rationale behind this use of multiple, rather than mono-paradigm analysis in developing marketing theory, is that it is seen to facilitate conversations across research paradigms, and in so doing provides a more comprehensive view of the foci phenomena than would ordinarily be available. Despite the widely acknowledged support for multiple paradigm analysis among a burgeoning cadre of organisational theorists, marketing theorists have yet to examine the theoretical warrant for this approach in any detail. In an effort to introduce the various forms that multiple paradigm research can take, it is worthwhile briefly reviewing this area. In acknowledgement of the theory-laden nature of intellectual inquiry, we examine the theoretical support for the proposal that multiple paradigm analysis can be undertaken, that is, the incommensurability thesis is questioned and a case is made that Kuhn, in actual fact, suggests a means by which we can evaluate the content of different paradigms (cf. Hunt, 2003; McKelvey, 1997, 1999, 2003a, 2003b). While this task of negotiating the incommensurability thesis is not unproblematic due to the nature of the politics that underwrite the paradigm
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
24
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
debate more generally, i.e., arguments made in the organisation studies literature in relation to the apparent tendency towards “paradigm imperialism” (Jackson and Carter, 1991). “Paradigm imperialism” signifies the attempts made to subsume less well supported or developed paradigms beneath the “dominant” paradigm in organisation studies — functionalism (see, Donaldson, 1985, 1988). Making the case for multiple paradigm research and providing the theoretical warrant by which theory-adjudication can be undertaken would, it appears, constitute a means to enact discursive closure (cf. McKelvey, 2003a, 2003b; McKinley, 1995). In acknowledging this, we realise in more pragmatic terms that discipline wide, social and intellectual consensus is perhaps unrealistic given the values incommensurability that under-grid intellectual labour (see, Hoyningen-Huene and Schaber, 2003). Registering this, we simply want to point to the deficiencies of our existing understanding of the treatment of the incommensurability thesis in the literature to date and by highlighting how Kuhn moved away from his earlier strict incommensurability thesis suggest one possible theoretical innovation — team-research pluralism — that we believe can be useful in the development of a comprehensive understanding of marketing related phenomena. Before we proceed with our examination of the incommensurability thesis, given that the aim of this paper is to provide the theoretical justification for pursuing multiple paradigm research by drawing upon the work of the later Kuhn, we do not presume to attempt to outline the empirical research that is a result of this theoretical work due to space limitations. In this way, this paper represents a contribution towards the paradigm debate in that it develops the extant understanding of the incommensurability thesis beyond that currently in circulation in either marketing, management, finance or organisation studies. As a response, we provide a detailed discussion of an issue alluded to, but not yet expounded in a forthcoming paper, where Brodie et al. maintain that “the issue [of] paradigm incommensurability [is]. . . overstated” (Brodie et al., forthcoming).1 Having outlined our aim, we now turn to examine the potential contribution of multiple paradigm analysis and then outline the problematic of the incommensurability thesis in detail.
1 The
interested reader looking for further discussion of the empirical research is directed towards Brodie et al. (forthcoming), Pels et al. (2004), Tadajewski (2005b) and Tadajewski and Wagner-Tsukamoto (forthcoming).
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
2.
25
Intellectual Politics
Of course, as we have already gestured, the growth in the number of available paradigms has not been uncritically welcomed in either marketing or, for that matter, a theoretically diverse discipline such as organisation studies (see, Donaldson, 1985, 2005; McKelvey, 2003a, 2003b). In terms of a pertinent marketing example, we might consider the comments made by Greenley (1995), who implies that a certain lack of credibility can be attached to new and emerging paradigms; credibility that can only be established by recourse to epistemological warrant that coheres with his own philosophical cosmology. This kind of criticism is echoed in organisation studies where a number of recent commentators have argued that pluralism can be equated with the genealogical, conceptual and methodological fragmentation (Pfeffer, 1993), but these opinions remain marginal commentary on a process of paradigmatic expansion that is widely attributed with enhancing the theoretical richness and diversity of debate across a range of subjects from organisational culture (Daymon, 2000; Martin, 1992; Schultz and Hatch, 1996), work organisation (Hassard, 1991, 1993), multidivisional organisations (Clegg, 1991), work and technology design (Grint, 1991), performance appraisals (Gioia et al., 1989) advanced manufacturing technology (Lewis, 1997; Lewis and Grimes, 1999), total quality management (Kelemen, 1995), organisational structure (Gioia and Pitre, 1990), small-firm strategy (Graham-Hill, 1996), organisational politics (Bradshaw-Camball and Murray, 1991) and power (Gaventa, 1980). Likewise, we find Kuhn (1989, 1991a) echoing, in his last publications, and in material that has not to our knowledge been used to philosophically and theoretically contribute to advance the paradigm debate, that paradigmatic fragmentation is beneficial, arguing that it increases the problemsolving abilities of a scientific community. The review and contribution of this latter material is important, for even if we do not hold Kuhn’s contribution in high regard — and certainly not all do — it is still highly relevant if we are quick to bemoan the strictures that Kuhn’s early work is said to enact, because he is seen to reinforce incommensurability and restrict theorycomparison and theory-choice, that we actually examine what Kuhn does have to say on issues such as the incommensurability thesis. Only then can we move past assertions that the paradigm debate(s) are philosophically bereft and that this has prevented the debate from moving beyond Kuhn’s original 1962 statements regarding theory-choice and paradigm incommensurability (see, McKelvey, 1997, 1999, 2003a, 2003b; McKinley and Baum, 2002).
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
26
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
In contrast to this premise, we follow Jones (2002, 2003), who makes the very important case that all too often we are quick to move beyond certain theoretical contributions without pausing to see how they might be read otherwise. This, of course, signals some distance from positivistic readings of texts which assume that there might be one correct interpretation of such material; a position problematised by the interpretive turn and the associated view that what is interpreted does not ultimately represent an essential and inviolable nature, but is to some extent guided by those motives and needs that guide research. Thus, in our view, and again not all will agree (see, Collins, 2000, 2002), once we move past the need for apodictic foundations for our knowledge base, and once we see our practices as contingent products whose encounter with changing epistemic conditions necessitates continual adjustment, clarification, and justification, then the role of theory in the process of critical reflection on practice appears secure. “. . . what would be the value of the passion for knowledge if it resulted only in a certain amount of knowledgeableness and not, in one way or another and to the extent possible, in the knowers’s straying afield of himself? There are times in life when the question of knowing if one can think differently than one thinks, and perceive differently than one sees, is absolutely necessary if one is to go on looking and reflecting at all.” Foucault (1984/1992, p. 8) As the quote from Foucault above indicates, the role that we see for philosophy and social theory here is that of a sensitising device that enables us to better understand and negotiate our own ingrained biases towards a single paradigmatic perspective (see, Gioia and Pitre, 1990; Lewis, 1997; Tadajewski, 2004). Thus, we see the possible contribution of multiple paradigm research as the facilitation of dialogue across paradigms. But before we turn to the exposition of our empirical interests, and the way that these appear to offer a fruitful object for multiple paradigm analysis, we must confront what Feyerabend (1975, 1978) thought was the “swamp” of the philosophy of science — incommensurability. The incommensurability thesis is of such importance, various commentators have argued, given the structures that it enacts on our ability to produce, debate and compare alternative forms of knowledge (Aldrich, 1992; Gioia and Pitre, 1990; Grimes and Rood, 1995; Hassard, 1991; Reed, 1990, 1992, 1993, 1999; Willmott, 1993). Paradigm
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
27
incommensurability becomes problematic for the multiple paradigm analyst because each different framework will necessarily rest on a diverse range of ontological, epistemological and axiological foundations (see, Hirschman, 1986). Taking Burrell and Morgan’s framework as our exemplar here, in view of its popularity among marketing theorists (Arndt, 1985a; Hudson and Ozanne, 1988; Morgan, 1992, 2003), the differences between paradigms becomes clear when we compare what are broadly called the “positivist” and “interpretive” paradigms (cf. Szmigin and Foxall, 2000). The “positivist” paradigm, for example, is the orthodox stance from which research is undertaken in marketing (Easton, 2002). The premises underpinning research conducted according to the tenants of this paradigm are that, ontologically, the world assumes a concrete existence that remains independent of the observers’ perception. Epistemologically, “positivist” research takes a reductionist orientation to its research object in that it is assumed that the foci of attention, no matter what the domain of study, can be broken down into its various constituent parts and subject to analysis, with a desirable output of this analytic strategy being knowledge that takes the form of general laws which can be extrapolated across environments. In the process of knowledge discovery, the researcher is seen to be an external observer vis-à-vis the phenomena of interest which remains phenomenologically distanced via the careful application of the scientific, hypothetico-deductive method. Research undertaken using this paradigm is usually subject to empirical corroboration or refutation of the hypotheses under examination (Hunt, 1976, 2002, 2003). In contrast, the “interpretive” paradigm questions the ontological status of reality that “positivist” researchers accord it, by emphasising that the social world exhibits a precarious ontological status. Everyday life, Burrell and Morgan suggest, is accorded the status of a miraculous achievement. In terms of research, emphasis is placed not on ascertaining the empirical structure of reality, those natural laws that frame everyday life, instead the social world is investigated at the level of social experience with social reality seen to be inter-subjectively created by the interaction of interpreting human beings. Knowledge cannot be apprehended from the standpoint of an external, objective position, rather the interpretive researcher is fully implicated in the co-constitution of their research project. Typically, their description of co-participant lived experience is generally, but not exclusively, elicited through the use of qualitative methods (Burrell and Morgan, 1979/1992; Lewis and Grimes, 1999). For Burrell and Morgan, the axiological, ontological and epistemological bases for these two paradigms are so distinct that they are “mutually
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
28
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
exclusive” (Burrell and Morgan, 1979/1992; cf. Alvesson, 1994). Kuhn (1962), on the other hand, and in a different context, has postulated that paradigms are incommensurable because there was no neutral way that they could be compared on a point-by-point basis. What this has meant for practice of producing marketing theory is that much theory is currently being produced on an either/or basis (Hudson and Ozanne, 1988). Either we use one paradigm, or we adopt another, with the productive dialogue that might otherwise be fostered between different paradigms apparently stultified (Davies and Fitchett, 2005; Lowe et al., 2004; Gareth Morgan, 1983). This is problematic because it limits the theoretical foundations from which we approach the subject of interest, i.e., the way particular research problems are framed will often restrict and potentially bias the research, all of which constrain our ability to construct comprehensive theory (Lewis and Grimes, 1999): a feature of the paradigm debate that is widely lamented (e.g., Donaldson, 1985, 1988, 1995, 2003, 2005; Lewis and Grimes, 1999; McKelvey, 1997, 1999, 2003a, 2003b; Pfeffer, 1982, 1993; Reed, 1985, 1990, 1992, 1993, 1999). In an attempt to deflate the incommensurability thesis and clarify a “seriously neglected” topic of research (Bristor, 1985, p. 300; see Brodie et al., forthcoming; Davies and Fitchett, 2005; Lewis and Kelemen, 2002; Kilduff and Kelemen, 2003; Tadajewski, 2004, forthcoming; Weaver and Gioia, 1994), we turn first to the incommensurability thesis in Feyerabend (1975, 1978). This is done in order to highlight the belief that paradigm choice becomes a matter of subjective “taste” for Feyerabend. Following this, we detail Kuhn’s (1962, 1970, 1977, 1989) understanding of the incommensurability thesis as one which ultimately allows him to assume a meta-theoretical view of paradigm debate (see, Phillips, 1977). These views are subject to scrutiny, and a case is made that we can debate the merits of different paradigms when a group of researchers with a variety of paradigm affiliations are involved in a joint research project. This, we suggest, is possible even when we acknowledge the politics involved in this process (cf. Burrell and Morgan, 1979/1992; Donaldson, 1985; Jackson and Carter, 1991; Gareth Morgan, 1985, 1990).
3.
Incommensurability
According to Feyerabend, the idea that science will be dominated by one paradigm during a period of normal science is wrongheaded (see, Preston, 1997 for a full review). Moreover, the thesis propounded by Kuhn that
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
29
research is governed by one set of paradigmatic values borders on scientific monomania (Feyerabend, 1970). It is perhaps not surprising that, given this sentiment, Feyerabend refuses Kuhn’s conception of the normal science/revolutionary science/normal science distinction. Via a careful excavation of the historical record, Feyerabend problematises this distinction by making the case that the historical record demonstrates that science has been characterised by a history of pluralism: a plurality of competing theories with any one individual theory being constantly subject to criticism from the point of view of other theories. This is not only the case during scientific revolutions when Kuhn (1962) suggests that all fundamental ontological and epistemological assumptions are subject to radical revision and disavowal. There needs to be no crisis in the extant practice of science — a view which Feyerabend equates with Kuhn — for scientists to be motivated to produce competing theory that could destabilise the existing paradigm. It is only when there are competing theories that the weaker points of the currently popular theory can be assessed and subject to empirical study. Taking the Copernican revolution as his exemplar, Feyerabend questions the assumption that Ptolemaic thought was even in any difficulty. It certainly was not falsified in the Popperian sense (e.g., Popper, 1963) he asserts, but instead Copernicanism served as a counterpoint for Ptolemaic theory by demonstrating the limitations of it (Feyerabend, 1975). While these debates between Kuhn and Feyerabend (and also Popper) are interesting in and of themselves, the point that Feyerabend was attempting to justify, in this instance, was his principle of tenacity, i.e., the argument that scientists should defend the theories that they subscribe to, even in the face of often compelling evidence refuting them (Feyerabend, 1975). By doing this, science would be characterised by a plurality of competing theories — theoretical pluralism. The virtue of theoretical pluralism is, for Feyerabend, unrelated to the question of whether this state-of-affairs will necessarily lead to the progress towards truth Popper sees as desirable. Nor is Feyerabend convinced that pluralism can be equated with a progressive movement in knowledge development because, like Kuhn, Feyerabend sees these competing theories as incommensurable with one another. This is not to suggest that incommensurability is necessarily seen as wholly problematic for knowledge development; far from it. Feyerabend (1970) is explicitly concerned with avoiding the kind of intellectual stagnation that the paradigmatic dominance of one research style could encourage, and signals his belief that theoretical pluralism is of central import in the task of questioning established conceptions of theory
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
30
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
and practice, so that understanding is not circumscribed by the “tyranny of unexamined systems” (Feyerabend, 1970, p. 203). Assuming a similar position to Kuhn, Feyerabend makes the case that because theories emanating from different paradigms are incommensurable, our only recourse for theory adjudication are aesthetic judgements, our own personal theoretical tastes and subjective preference (Feyerabend, 1970, 1975). Of course, this proposal is a function of the liberalist sentiment that Feyerabend was prone to support, which, while relatively appealing, becomes extremely problematic when we factor in the politics of knowledge production (see, Belk, 1995; Burrell and Morgan, 1979/1992; Donaldson, 2005; Jackson and Carter, 1991). Clearly, Feyerabend’s proposal can be interpreted as somewhat unreflexive, presupposing as it does that all scholars will be free to voice their own opinion in the appropriate channels of academic distribution — peer reviewed publications. As Belk (1995) reminds us, this is a problematic assumption. We therefore need to see if some appropriate means of negotiating the incommensurability thesis presents itself, but also whether we can find some method of assuaging the concerns of official gatekeepers regarding the validity of multiple paradigm research. In this regard, Kuhn offers us some further purchase on the incommensurability thesis, and moreover, suggests a process of negotiation that undermines the incommensurability thesis and paves the way for multiple paradigm research using a team of researchers affiliated with different paradigms. It is to Kuhn’s shifting position that we now turn.
4.
Kuhnian Incommensurability
Kuhn’s initial formulation of incommensurability suggested the idea that there is no “neutral algorithm of theory-choice, no systematic decision procedure which, properly applied, must lead each individual in the group to the same decision” (Kuhn, 1970a, p. 200). This view raises the question that if paradigms are indeed rivals as Kuhn (1962) likes to assert, such rivalry would seem to require a shared perspective that identifies them as rivals and this demands that there will be some semantic and methodological continuity — a degree of translation — and therefore of reference or meaning between theoretical terms. While we will go into this issue in some depth later, let us briefly gesture towards the direction in which we are heading here. Perhaps the most important issue arising out of the incommensurability thesis is if there are important and incommensurable differences between
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
31
paradigms, then how is it possible for Kuhn himself to understand and explicate the transition from Newtonian to Einsteinian physics (Kuhn, 1962). Davidson takes a somewhat wry glance towards Kuhn’s history of science noting Kuhn’s own ability to translate what scientific practice was like before a scientific revolution using a post-revolutionary idiom (Davidson, 2001). Nor has this difficulty escaped Bernstein (1983) who argues that despite all the discussion of incommensurability Kuhn was well aware that there might be some commonality between paradigms, even though Kuhn objected to the manner that philosophers of science had attempted to defend this common point of reference. While still reluctant to go beyond his subscription to methodological incommensurability Kuhn’s own philosophical inconsistency increasingly makes itself apparent, particularly in his discussion of taxonomical lexicons.
5.
Taxonomical Lexicons
In his later work, Kuhn (1990) further undermines the incommensurability thesis. Drawing the relationship between language learning and paradigm education even closer, Kuhn stresses the similarities between the practice of science and leaning and using an everyday language. Engaging in scientific research, he suggests, raises similar issues to those we face in day-to-day interaction such as rules pertaining to correct use of vocabulary, grammar, translation and so forth. As an example, Kuhn points out that in a manner similar to the incommensurability we experience when we attempt to translate one word in English to Japanese where no equivalent may exist, it is equally possible for the scientist to learn and entertain two distinct languages, with their concomitant theories. This is possible, Kuhn opines, because our theories share the characteristics of natural languages, and in as much as we move from one language to another, so too can the same strategy be achieved when we talk about different theories in different language communities. These languages are not directly translatable word-for-word but, by being able to understand both lexicons, we can begin to translate the ideas from one language into the other. While admittedly Kuhn gives us little indication of how a scientist may actually move from one language to the other, he nonetheless emphasises that we learn new scientific languages as we undergo our initial process of socialisation (i.e., doctoral training etc.) which continues as we progress through the academic lifecycle. In introducing this new, more dynamic process of paradigm education and the less
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
32
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
deterministic relationship between the (paradigm) language and the way a scientist can view the world, the dogmatic scientist that Popper (1970) bemoans is invested with a latitude of agency by which they can evaluate their framework in some limited fashion (Kuhn, 1990, 1991a; Sankey, 1994, 1997). This agency is limited precisely because Kuhn sees these languages as clustered around a certain class of taxonomic terms which form the basis for the seeable and sayable in scientific research; they enforce a certain view of the world albeit one that is more plastic than was the case with the original (1962) paradigm concept and incommensurability thesis. If the scientist is to understand the meaning of the particular group of taxonomic terms and successfully converse with the targeted scientific community, they will quite naturally have to learn the language of their interlocutors. Here, Kuhn (1989, 1991a) is trying to grope towards the idea that unlike the previous revolutionary, gestalt shift where the practice of science was entirely dependent on incommensurable paradigms, now scientific practice becomes dependent on the learning of shared languages which, in turn, form the basis for the scientific theories invoked in their name. Rather than incommensurability being the complete absence of any available means to translate the lexicon of a different language into the other, Kuhn proposes that we are better off thinking about incommensurability as a kind of untranslatability of specific aspects of the language we are using. Drawing from Wittgenstein, he suggests that the limits of language set the parameters of our world. They define what is it possible to know and understand (Kuhn, 1983a, 1991a). This understanding of different languages presents us with a translation problem. We cannot simply translate the language of one taxonomical lexicon into that of another, instead, what this requires is that we learn a new language entirely — even if the terms may appear the same — because the meaning system in which these terms are embedded will differ (Sankey, 1997). What Kuhn suggests here is not that incommensurability poses intractable problems, but that scientists actually try to learn languages that would otherwise appear foreclosed to them, assuming of course that paradigm subscription were really as ideologically binding as some believe (e.g., Hirschman, 1986). There is more pragmatism to knowledge production and on occasion we have no choice but to shift paradigms (Tsoukas and Knudsen, 2003). In this case, what Kuhn suggests is desirable here, are (marketing) scientists who are lexically bilingual and understand the historical development of the debates they comment upon — as Kuhn (1962) did — and can help themselves, and others, to understand alternative modes of thought
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
33
(Kuhn, 1989). Talking about the transmission of theoretical concepts from one generation to another, Kuhn says we inherit our current theory and practices from our immediate predecessors and these concepts are “a historical product, embedded in the culture to which current practitioners are initiated by training” (Kuhn, 1991b, p. 122). It should come as no surprise that these concepts in the later Kuhn’s work are not wholly incommensurable; we can understand them and there will be some degree of translation. This is possible by virtue of the lexicons that we learn through doctoral training and which enable researchers to become adept at the hermeneutic decoding of a range of taxonomical lexicons in much the same way as anthropologists and historians immerse themselves in alien cultures. Again, we may run into incommensurability by virtue of the systematic differences which exist between two different taxonomies, as Kuhn demonstrates with his example of Ptolemaic and Copernican celestial taxonomies which ultimately share a similar domain of investigation and yet are based on different lexicons and whose adherents thereby view their objects of inquiry differently (see, Tadajewski, 2005a). What he suggests, using the Ptolemaic and Copernican example, is that the changes between these different lexicons are in fact far more subtle and restricted than he had previously thought, being primarily related to changes in certain elements of the lexical code. The main challenge for the historian in this example is the identification of the part of the lexical code that has been modified. This is as far from the gestalt shift of the early Kuhn as is conceivable. Far from being embedded in one paradigm, and on occasion shifting to another totally different “world”, a paradigm shift is no longer seen by Kuhn to be a move from one paradigm to another in one direction. Rather, we retain the ability to shift forwards and backwards, from one lexicon to the other and back again (Kuhn, 1987), with the consequence that his incommensurability thesis has itself been transformed from the way it is generally depicted in marketing theory where a strict incommensurability is generally assumed (e.g., Lowe et al., 2004; Lowe et al., 2005), to his later revision — the more nuanced semantic incommensurability (Sankey, 1994).
6.
Semantic Incommensurability
In diluting his methodological incommensurability thesis so that some comparison of frameworks is possible, Kuhn moves us closer to comparing different paradigms. His point in his later works is not that incommensurable
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
34
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
languages are untranslatable, but instead that this process is extremely complex (Sharrock and Read, 2002). In making this case, Kuhn asks us to consider the differences between incompatibility, incomparability and incommensurability (Kuhn, 1983b). No longer does he place the (implicit) stricture on theory comparison that this must take place through the use of a theory neutral algorithm or be otherwise reducible to a common language as he did in his earlier work (e.g., Kuhn, 1962, 1970a). Instead, Kuhn continues to assert a weak version of semantic incommensurability, whereby there may be some limited meaning variance between extant and historical taxonomical lexicons in which a certain class or group of terms may be untranslatable within the wider language (Kuhn, 1989). Nonetheless, even if this is so, it still remains the case, says Kuhn (1990, 1991a) drawing upon the natural language analogy, that despite the untranslatability of certain terms on a one-to-one correspondence, it is still possible to understand the general thrust of the statement made (Kuhn, 1991a). A failure to translate one language into another does not necessarily mean that we fail to understand what has been said (Sankey, 1994). Simply, that this process of translation and understanding is complicated, since if an attempt is made to provide, as evidence of untranslatability various examples, as Kuhn does, of expressions of the untranslatable language, then such an attempt will undermine the claim of untranslatability because providing examples in one’s own language necessarily shows that translation can take place (Davidson, 2001). In practice, what this and much of the preceding close reading of early, middle and late Kuhnian thought appears to suggest is that in actuality scientists have a substantial number of ways by which they can compare competing theories. These will range from the various values that Kuhn (1977, p. 322) discusses (accuracy, consistency, scope, fruitfulness and simplicity) to the use of older theory that can also be used to assess the approximate contribution of new ways of seeking knowledge — Kuhn’s so-called “standards of responsibility” (1989, p. 12). Such values, Kuhn suggests, are not exhaustive, but given in order to indicate those that he thinks are collectively important for determining theory choice in the natural sciences and form the collective values that are seen to be present in “good” theory (Kuhn, 1977). This again returns us to Kuhn’s view that there are certain values underwriting the debates between different paradigm communities that can be used to adjudicate between the choices offered by different theories. For Kuhn, this allows us to move back from relativism and regain some of the inter-subjective ground that the original incommensurability thesis removed from beneath
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
35
our feet (Kuhn, 1970a). What this enables is a certain degree of productive dialogue although ultimately, Kuhn laments, this dialogue can be stultified. As an example, Kuhn cites the debates between Einstein and Bohr, which he believes highlights the fundamental epistemological and ontological differences that may delimit debate. His use of the paradigmatic transformation of classical physics to quantum physics is of interest here, precisely because what it highlights contradicts what Kuhn proposes, in that it gives us an exemplar case of the kind of productive dialogue that can be encouraged by paradigm debate. Indeed, Bohr and Einstein discussed every step in this debate: “Einstein raised an objection; Bohr was mortified, thought intensely, found an answer, told Einstein, and Einstein accepted the answer. Einstein raised another objection; Bohr was again mortified, though intensely — and so on” (Feyerabend, 1999, p. 267). All of this leads Feyerabend, and the later Kuhn, to move towards the view that, in actuality, while the incommensurability thesis may continue to pose difficulties for the philosopher of science, particularly if they are interested in retaining the idea of wholly rational theory choice, incommensurability “disappears when we use the concepts in the way that scientists use them, in an open ambiguous and often counter-intuitive manner. Incommensurability is a problem for philosophers not for scientists” (Feyerabend, 1993, p. 211; emphasis in original). Incommensurability of scientific values, moreover, can be subject to a process of negotiated attempts to understand and comprehend the output of different paradigms in that, “anything which can be said in one language can, with imagination and effort, be understood by a speaker of another. What is a prerequisite to such understanding, however, is not translation but language learning” (Kuhn, 1989, p. 11). The benefit that Kuhn sees accruing from such a process of debate and negotiation is “the shock generated by substituting . . . [alternative] conceptual spectacles for own [with the result that] . . . We have learned, against our own deep-seated ethnocentric resistance, to take shock for granted” (Kuhn, 1991a, p. 21). Thus, in contrast to recent comments made by a number of organisation theorists that conceptual ambiguity and definitional ambiguity precludes paradigm comparison and evaluation leading them to call for the development of a rigid conceptual dictionary (cf. McKinley, 1995, 2003; McKinley and Mone, 1998), we suggest, following Feyerabend, that the uncritical acceptance of rigid criteria for evaluation emplaces strictures on theory development that will not ultimately be productive. As Van Maanen maintains: “the more we try to be precise and exact, the less we are able to say” (Van Maanen, 1995, p. 139).
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
36
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
Incommensurability, on this reading, can be negotiated by a process of iterative debate. What our foregoing examination of Kuhn and Feyerabend’s discussion means is that it is theoretically justifiable to engage in research based on multiple paradigms in a single study — justification that has not yet been provided in the literature. Importantly, by outlining the philosophical basis for multiple paradigm research, we have provided the basis for the legitimisation of multiple paradigm analysis as a tenable and credible research strategy; something that has long been seen as desirable in theory building in marketing and consumer research (Foxall, 2002; Hirschman, 1986; Lutz, 1989; Tadajewski, 2004; Tynan, 2002; Wilk, 2001). As a gesture beyond the very theoretical discussion so far, we want to briefly discuss the way in which we are presently trying to overcome the incommensurability thesis in practice. We see this project as representing the kind of reflexive conversation that Morgan (1983) and Lewis and Grimes (1999) broadly support.
7.
Toward Multiple Paradigm Marketing Theory
It has long been noted that marketing and consumer researchers need to remain open to a range of paradigmatic positions, by refusing to close down what might otherwise be a potentially fruitful discussion because of paradigmatic disagreement. Our own personal experience with multiple paradigm research leads us to a very different conclusion to that of Czarniawska (2003) who appears to suggest that academic debates across paradigms are usually unbeneficial because researchers are unwilling to tolerate the views of researchers from alternative paradigms (see, Belk, 1995; Donaldson, 2005; McKelvey, 1997, 1999, 2003a, 2003b; McKinley, 1995). We think this overstates the actual difficulties of inter-paradigm discourse and in an ongoing research project we have used a research team whose members subscribe to different, but complimentary paradigms. For the purposes of our research, we have begun to undertake sequential multiple paradigm research which holds that the available paradigms are mutually complimentary and that the representations developed from one paradigm can be used to inform the research undertaken from an alternative paradigmatic stance. This process is said to provide sequential levels of understanding that build up on each other, or otherwise cast a critical perspective on the previous analysis (Gioia et al., 1989; Lewis and Grimes, 1999; Lewis and Kelemen, 2002; Schultz and Hatch, 1996). Of course, the refrain can be offered that Kuhn has previously
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
37
argued that there are certain methodological principles that are valid within the paradigm community and that the dialogic process that we support will be stultified by the lack of transcendental methodological guidance. As we have already indicated, Kuhn no longer supports this assumption despite the widespread belief within the management, marketing and organisation studies literature to the contrary (e.g., McKelvey, 1997, 1999, 2003a, 2003b). In contrast, Kuhn outlines a series of values that he believes can be useful heuristics when comparing theories from different paradigms. Theories are valued, Kuhn (1970a) maintains, because they can yield predictions which should, for Kuhn, be accurate and preferably quantitative; they permit the continued development of puzzle-formation and problem solution; they are relatively simple vis-à-vis a competing theory and they are plausible in relation to existing knowledge. Continuing in this vein, Kuhn (1977) supplements these values, adding: scope (the theory can be extended beyond its existing domain) and fruitfulness (encourage new ways of seeing as yet unknown facts). Now, in outlining these values, we are in no way suggesting that they can determine theory-choice, that is, determine once and for all which theories drawn from different paradigms is (or are) correct. Rather, the methodological injunction to select theories on the basis of their simplicity requires the individual to make a decision regarding which theory they select and these are necessarily underdetermined by the available empirical evidence. Thus, we need to recognise that these values leave a range of options open regarding how these are interpreted, and the weight given to each value is likely to differ according to the primary paradigm that is subscribed to. In terms of our project, those involved subscribe to a variety of epistemological positions which, in turn, reflect their own substantive interests ranging from positivist research concerned with transactional marketing and interpretive research primarily oriented to the study of relationship marketing activities and while it makes for interesting debates — as the paradigm debate literature itself stands as testament — nonetheless some degree of inter-subjective consensus can usually be reached. This is perhaps not so surprising, despite the occasional tendency of researchers to talk past one another, common ground is generally obtainable as Nola and Sankey (2000: 27) maintain: “Thus Kuhn does not mention that inductivists and Bayesians put high store on high degree of hypotheses by evidence . . . Again constructive empiricists put high value on theories that are empirically adequate; in contrast realists wish to go further and value not only
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
38
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
this but truth, or increased verisimilitude, about non-observational claims. Given what Kuhn says elsewhere we may view him as not endorsing the realists’ value of truth, though the constructivists’ value of empirical adequacy is one he could adopt. Finally some methodologists’ would downplay some of the values Kuhn endorses, such as external consistency or social utility.” Again, to state our claim most explicitly, the values that Kuhn provides are only a guide to theory choice. In certain respects they are extremely functionalist. They are, however, only a first movement towards developing a more comprehensive heuristic through which multiple paradigm analysis can be guided. At this moment, they provide a touchstone to enable discussion across paradigms and enable us, to paraphrase Foucault, to stray afield of ourselves as researchers to look at our research foci in new ways. In our various attempts to effectively communicate across our respective paradigms, a number of common-sense recommendations, which may offer some guidance for those undertaking multiple paradigm analysis in future, have presented themselves, which we believe will contribute to the successful completion of (given the nature of this medium of communication) doctoral research. The first and most important point is that for multiple paradigm analysis to be successful, each of the team members should, ideally, be competent researchers’ in their own paradigmatic style. Their ability to demonstrate this in the research output is of primary importance in convincing the appropriate gatekeepers that the output generated from this research strategy has been produced in a manner commensurate with each paradigm adopted (see, Davies and Fitchett, 2005). Of equal importance, or perhaps more so, each team member should, regardless of their academic position, appreciate and respect each others’ opinions and have a desire to contribute to the research inquiry. This is in addition to being willing to listen and recognise how they may best compliment each other and will require that they share, at some fundamental level, a mutual understanding of the nature of the research problem, but not, as we might generally expect, for this to be framed in a paradigmatic relative terminology. What we believe is a more fruitful way of framing research questions is to state them in terms of problem orientation. By adopting a problem orientation researchers can contribute their own insights as they relate to the problem at hand, drawing from the contributions offered by each paradigm similar to the sequential strategy outlined in detail by Schultz and Hatch (1996) without the potential correct responses being
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
39
delimited by the use of any paradigm specific terminology. It is by recognising the potential for paradigm interplay and the facilitation of dialogue between paradigm communities that the kind of reflexive conversation indicated by Morgan (1983) is theoretically warranted and multiple paradigm analysis therefore justifiable, as the foregoing examination of the incommensurability thesis has illustrated. In contrast to the frequent reiteration that the Kuhnian incommensurability thesis precludes the possibility for multiple paradigm analysis, this chapter has shown that Kuhn himself provides the theoretical warrant for multiple paradigm analysis, and offers some (admittedly vague) criteria for reflexive conversation between different paradigm communities. It only remains for these criteria to be debated and further extended by being put into practice: a project which, we submit, represents an important future avenue for theory development in marketing.
8.
Conclusion
The project we have outlined in this paper is likely to be contentious, given the diverse argumentation surrounding the incommensurability thesis. We violate, with reason, the paradigm incommensurability thesis in recognition that the incommensurability thesis as it was represented in the work of the early Kuhn no longer stands. What this means for those interested in marketing theory is that multiple paradigm research can be supported theoretically, but not necessarily put into practice in a wholly unproblematic fashion. Registering this, we have demonstrated Kuhn’s own distancing from the original incommensurability thesis and, following this, the type of multiple paradigm study that marketing scholars are beginning to undertake. We should not, however, underplay the political nature of knowledge production within marketing or its sister disciplines. This said, the appearance of journals such as Marketing Theory and the increasing turn towards alternative paradigmatic positions evinced by the Journal of Consumer Research and, of equal importance, this vehicle for doctoral students, all suggest that research which negotiates established convention is likely to be further developed by virtue of the opportunities provided by these prestigious outlets.
Acknowledgement The authors would like to thank the helpful comments of both reviewers on an earlier draft of this paper.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
40
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
References Alvesson, M. (1994). Critical theory and consumer marketing. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 10, 291–313. Anderson, P. F. (1983). Marketing, scientific progress, and the scientific method. Journal of Marketing, 47, 18–31. Arndt, J. (1985a). On making marketing science more scientific: Role of orientations, paradigms, metaphors, and problem solving. Journal of Marketing, 49, 11–23. Arndt, J. (1985b). The tyranny of paradigms: The case for paradigmatic pluralism in marketing. In N. Dholakia and J. Arndt (eds.), Changing the Course of Marketing: Alternative Paradigms for Widening Marketing Theory. Greenwich: JAI Press, 3–25. Baker, M. J. (2001). Introduction. In M. J. Baker (ed.), Marketing: Critical Perspectives on Business and Management. London: Routledge, 1–25. Belk, R. W. (1995). Studies in the new consumer behaviour. In D. Miller (ed.), Acknowledging Consumption: A Review of New Studies. London: Routledge, 58–95. Bernstein, R. (1983). Beyond Objectivism and Relativism: Science, Hermeneutics and Praxis. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. Bradshaw-Camball, P. and V. V. Murray (1991). Illusions and other games: A trifocal view of organizational politics. Organization Science, 2, 379–398. Bristor, J. M. (1985). Consumer behavior from a contemporary philosophy of science perspective: An organizational framework. In E. C. Hirschman and M. B. Holbrook (eds.), Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 12. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 300–306. Brodie, R. J., J. Pels and M. Saren (forthcoming). From goods towards servicecentered marketing: Dangerous dichotomy or an emerging dominant logic. In R. F. Lusch and S. L. Vargo (eds.), The Service-Dominant Logic of Marketing: Dialogue, Debate and Directions. Armonk: M.E. Sharp. Brown, S. (2005). Writing Marketing. London: Sage. Burrell, G. and G. Morgan (1979/1992). Sociological Paradigms and Organisational Analysis. Aldershot: Ashgate. Clegg, S. (1991). Modern Organizations. London: Sage. Collins, R. (2000). The sociology of philosophies: A precis. Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 30, 157–201. Collins, R. (2002). On the acrimoniousness of intellectual disputes. Common Knowledge, 8, 47–69. Combe, I. A. (1999). Multiple strategy paradigms: An integrational framework. Journal of Marketing Management, 15, 341–359. Combe, I. A. and G. Botschen (2004). Strategy paradigms for the management of quality: Dealing with complexity. European Journal of Marketing, 35, 500–523. Czarniawska, B. (2003). This way to paradise: On creole researchers, hybrid disciplines, and pidgin writing. Organization, 10, 430–434.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
41
Davidson, D. (2001). Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation, Second Edition. Oxford: Clarendon. Davies, A. and J. A. Fitchett (2005). Beyond incommensurability? Empirical expansion on diversity in research. European Journal of Marketing, 39, 272–293. Daymon, C. (2000). Culture formation in a new television station: A multi-perspective analysis. British Journal of Management, 11, 121–135. Deetz, S. (1996). Describing differences in approaches to organization science: Rethinking Burrell and Morgan and their legacy. Organization Science, 7, 191–207. Donaldson, L. (1985). In Defence of Organization Theory: A Reply to the Critics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Donaldson, L. (1988). In successful defence of organization theory: A routing of the critics. Organization Studies, 9, 28–32. Donaldson, L. (1995). American Anti-Management Theories of Organization: A Critique of Paradigm Proliferation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Donaldson, L. (1998). The myth of paradigm incommensurability in management studies: Comments by an integrationist. Organization, 5, 267–272. Donaldson, L. (2005). Vita contemplativa: Following the scientific method: How I became a committed functionalist and positivist. Organization Studies, 26(7), 1071–1088. Easton, G. (2002). Marketing: A critical realist approach. Journal of Business Research, 55, 103–109. Feyerabend, P. (1975). Against Method. London. New Left Books. Feyerabend, P. (1978). Science in a Free Society. London: New Left Books. Feyerabend, P. (1993). Against Method, Third Edition. London: Verso. Feyerabend, P. (1999). Conquest of Abundance. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Feyerabend, P. K. (1970). Against method: Outline of an anarchistic theory of knowledge. In M. Radner and S. Winokur (eds.), Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science Vol. 4: Analyses of Theories and Methods of Physics and Psychology. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 76–160. Foucault, M. (1984/1992) The Use of Pleasure: The History of Sexuality: 2. London: Penguin. Foxall, G. R. (2002). Introduction. In G. R. Foxall (ed.), Consumer Behaviour Analysis: Critical Perspectives on Business and Management. London: Routledge, 1–31. Gaventa, J. (1980). Power and Powerlessness: Quiescence and Rebellion in an Appalachian Valley. Urbana: University of Illinois Press. Gioia, D. A and E. Pitre (1990). Multiparadigm perspectives on theory building. Academy of Management Review, 15, 584–602. Gioia, D. A., A. Donnellon and H. P. Sims Jr. (1989). Communication and cognition in appraisal: A tale of two paradigms. Organization Studies, 10, 503–530. Graham-Hill, S. (1996). Small-firm business strategy: A search for relevant theory. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Kentucky.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
42
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
Greenley, G. (1995). A comment on the commodification of marketing knowledge. Journal of Marketing Management, 11, 665–670. Grimes, A. J and D. L. Rood (1995). Beyond objectivism and relativism: Descriptive epistemologies. In W. Natter, T. R. Schatzki and J. P. Jones (eds.), Objectivity and Its Other. New York: The Guilford Press, 161–178. Grint, K. (1991). The Sociology of Work: An Introduction. London: Polity Press. Gutting, G. (1980). Introduction. In G. Gutting (ed.), Paradigms and Revolutions: Appraisals and Applications of Thomas Kuhn’s Philosophy of Science. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 1–21. Hassard, J. (1991). Multiple paradigms and organization analysis — A case study. Organization Studies, 12, 275–299. Hassard, J. (1993). Sociology and Organization Theory: Positivism, Paradigms and Postmodernity. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Hirschman, E. C. (1986). Humanistic inquiry in marketing research: Philosophy, method, criteria. Journal of Marketing Research, 23, 237–249. Hoyningen-Huene, P. and P. Schaber (2003). Incommensurability of knowledge: theories and values. http://www.unics.uni-hannover.de/zeww/pub.phh.html [20/10/2005]. Hudson, L. A. and J. L. Ozanne (1988). Alternative ways of seeking knowledge in consumer research. Journal of Consumer Research, 14, 508–521. Hunt, S. D. (1976). The nature and scope of marketing. Journal of Marketing, 40, 17–26. Hunt, S. D. (1984). Should marketing adopt relativism? In M. Ryan and P. F. Anderson (eds.), Marketing Theory: Philosophy and Sociology of Science Perspectives. Chicago: American Marketing Association, 30–34. Hunt, S. D. (1991). Positivism and paradigm dominance in consumer research. Journal of Consumer Research, 18, 32–44. Hunt, S. D. (2002). Foundations of Marketing Theory: Towards a General Theory of Marketing. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe. Hunt, S. D. (2003). Controversy in Marketing Theory: For Reason, Realism, Truth and Objectivity. Armonk: M.E. Sharpe. Jackson, N. and P. Carter (1991). In defense of paradigm incommensurability. Organization Studies, 12, 109–128. Jackson, N. and P. Carter (1993). “Paradigm wars”: A response to Hugh Willmott. Organization Studies, 14, 721–727. Jones, C. (2002). Foucault’s inheritance/inheriting Foucault. Culture and Organization, 8, 225–238. Jones, C. (2003). Theory after the postmodern condition. Organization, 10, 503–525. Kelemen, M. L. (1995). The role of leadership in achieving total quality management in the UK service sector: A multi-paradigm study. Unpublished D.Phil. Thesis, Oxford University. Kilduff, M. and M. Kelemen (2003). Bringing ideas back in: Eclecticism and discovery in organizational studies. In E. A. Locke (ed.), Postmodernism and Management: Pros, Cons and the Alternative. Amsterdam: JAI Press, 89–109.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
43
Kuhn, T. S. (1962). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Kuhn, T. S. (1970a). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, Second Edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Kuhn, T. S. (1970b). Logic of discovery or psychology of research? In I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds.), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1–23. Kuhn, T. S. (1970c). Reflections on my critics. In I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds.), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 231–278. Kuhn, T. S. (1971). The relations between history and the history of science. Daedalus, 100, 271–304. Kuhn, T. S. (1977). Objectivity, value judgment, and theory choice. In T. S. Kuhn (ed.), The Essential Tension: Selected Studies in Scientific Tradition and Change. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 320–339. Kuhn, T. S. (1983a). Rationality and theory choice. The Journal of Philosophy 80, 563–571. Kuhn, T. S. (1983b). Commensurability, comparability, communicability. In P. D. Asquith and T. Nickles (eds.), PSA 1982 Volume 2. East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association, 2–13. Kuhn, T. S. (1987). What are Scientific Revolutions? In L. Kruger, L. J. Daston and M. Heidelberger (eds.), The Probabilistic Revolution. Cambridge: MIT Press, 7–22. Kuhn, T. S. (1989). Possible worlds in history of science. In S. Allén (ed.), Possible Worlds in Humanities, Arts and Sciences: Proceedings of Novel Symposium 65. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 9–32. Kuhn, T. S. (1990). Dubbing and redubbing: The vulnerability of rigid designation. In C. W. Smith (ed.), Scientific Theories. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 298–318. Kuhn, T. S. (1991a). The road since structure. In A. Fine, M. Forbes and L. Wessels (eds.), PSA 1990 Vol 2. East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association, 2–13. Kuhn, T. S. (1991b). The natural and the human sciences. In D. R. Hiley, J. F. Bohman and R. S. Schusterman (eds.), The Interpretive Turn: Philosophy, Science and Culture. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 17–24. Kuhn, T. S. (2000). A discussion with Thomas S. Kuhn. In J. Conant and J. Haugeland (eds.), The Road Since Structure. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 256–323. Lewis, M. W. (1997). Advanced manufacturing technology design: A multiparadigm study. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Kentucky. Lewis, M. W. (1998). Managing the paradoxes of multiparadigm research: An illustrative study and self-reflection. Proceedings for the International Academy of Business Disciplines April, 669–673. Lewis, M. W. and A. J. Grimes (1999). Metatriangulation: building theory from multiple paradigms. Academy of Management Review, 24, 672–690.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
44
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
Lowe, S., A. N. Carr and M. Thomas (2004). Paradigmapping marketing theory. European Journal of Marketing, 38, 1057–1064. Lowe, S., A. N. Carr, M. Thomas and L. Watkins-Mathys (2005). The fourth hermeneutic in marketing theory. Marketing Theory, 5, 185–203. Lutz, R. J. (1989). Presidential address: Positivism, naturalism and pluralism in consumer research: Paradigms in paradise. In T. Scrull (ed.), Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 16. Provo, UT: Association for Consumer Research, 1–8. Martin, J. (1992). Cultures in Organizations: Three Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press. McKelvey, B. (1997). Quasi-natural organization science. Organization Science, 8, 352–380. McKelvey, B. (1999). Toward a Campbellian realist organization science. In J. A. C. Baum and B. McKelvey (eds.), Variations in Organization Science: In Honor of Donald T. Campbell. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 383–411. McKelvey, B. (2003a). Postmodernism versus truth in management theory. In E. A. Locke (ed.), Postmodernism and Management: Pros, Cons and the Alternative. Amsterdam: JAI Press, 113–168. McKelvey, B. (2003b). From fields to science: Can organization studies make the transition? In R. Westwood and S. Clegg (eds.), Debating Organization: PointCounterpoint in Organization Studies. Oxford: Blackwell, 47–73. McKelvey, B. and J. A. C. Baum (1999). Donald T. Campbell’s evolving influence on organization science. In J. A. C. Baum and B. McKelvey (eds.), Variations in Organization Science: In Honor of Donald T. Campbell. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 1–15. McKinley, W. (1995). Commentary: Towards a Reconciliation of the TheoryPluralism in Strategy Management — Incommensurability and the Constructivist Approach of the Erlangen School (Andreas Georg Scherer and Michael J. Dowling). In P. Shrivastava and C. Stubbert (eds.), Advances in Strategic Management: Challenges from the Outside the Mainstream. Greenwich: JAI Press, 249–260. McKinley, W. (2003). Postmodern epistemology in organization studies: A critical appraisal. In E. A. Locke (ed.), Postmodernism and Management: Pros, Cons and the Alternative. Amsterdam: JAI Press, 203–226. McKinley, W. and M. A. Mone (1998). The re-construction of organization studies: Wrestling with incommensurability. Organization, 5, 169–189. Morgan, G. (1992). Marketing discourse and practice: Toward a critical analysis. In M. Alvesson and H. Willmott (eds.), Critical Management Studies. London: Sage, 136–158. Morgan, G. (2003). Marketing and critique: Prospects and problems. In M. Alvesson and H. Willmott (eds.), Studying Management Critically. London: Sage, 111–131. Morgan, G. (1983). Knowledge, uncertainty, and choice. In G. Morgan (ed.), Beyond Method. Beverly Hills: Sage, 383–391.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Negotiating Incommensurability in Marketing Theory
45
Morgan, G. (1985). Journals and the control of knowledge: A critical perspective. In L. L. Cummings and P. J. Frost (eds.), Publishing in the Organizational Sciences. Homewood: Richard D. Irwin, 63–75. Morgan, G. (1990). Paradigm diversity in organizational research. In J. Hassard and D. Pym (eds.), The Theory and Philosophy of Organizations. London: Routledge, 13–29. Murray, J. B and J. L. Ozanne (1991). The critical imagination: Emacipatory interests in consumer research. Journal of Consumer Research, 18, 129–144. Nola, R. and H. Sankey (2000). A selective survey of theories of scientific method. In R. Nola and H. Sankey (eds.), After Popper, Kuhn and Feyerabend: Recent Issues in Theories of Scientific Method. Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1–65. Pels, J., M. Saren and R. J. Brodie (2004). Investigating multiple marketing practices: Exploring the role of paradigms. Paper presented at the Irish Academy of Marketing Conference. Peter, J. P. and J. C. Olson (1983). Is science marketing? Journal of Marketing, 47, 111–125. Pfeffer, J. (1982). Organizations and Organization Theory. Boston: Pitman. Pfeffer, J. (1993). Barriers to the advance of organization science: Paradigm development as dependent variable. Academy of Management Review, 18, 599–620. Popper, K. R. (1963). Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Popper, K. R. (1970). Normal science and its dangers. In I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds.), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 51–58. Preston, J. (1997). Feyerabend: Philosophy, Science and Society. Cambridge: Polity. Reed, M. (1985). Redirections in Organizational Analysis. London: Tavistock. Reed, M. (1990). From paradigms to images: The paradigm warrior turns postmodernist guru. Personnel Review, 19, 35–40. Reed, M. (1992). Introduction. In M. Reed and M. Hughes (eds.), New Directions in Organization Theory and Analysis. London: Sage, 1–16. Reed, M. (1993). Organizations and modernity: Continuity and discontinuity in organization theory. In J. Hassard and M. Parker (eds.), Postmodernism and Organizations. London: Sage, 163–182. Reed, M. (1999). Organizational theorizing: A historically contested terrain. In S. R. Clegg and C. Hardy (eds.), Studying Organization: Theory and Method. London: Sage, 25–50. Reed, M. I. (1997). In praise of duality and dualism: Rethinking agency and structure in organizational analysis. Organization Studies, 18, 21–42. Sankey, H. (1994). The Incommensurability Thesis. Aldershot: Avebury. Sankey, H. (1997). Rationality, Relativism and Incommensurability. Aldershot: Avebury. Scherer, A. G. (1998). Pluralism and incommensurability in strategic management and organization theory. Organization, 5, 147–168.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
46
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Tadajewski, J. Pels & M. Saren
Schultz, M. and M. J. Hatch (1996). Living with multiple paradigms: The case of paradigm interplay in organization culture studies, Academy of Management Review, 21, 529–557. Sharrock, W. and R. Read (2002). Kuhn: Philosopher of Scientific Revolutions. Cambridge: Polity. Szmigin, I. and G. Foxall (2000). Interpretive consumer research: How far have we come. Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, 3, 187–197. Tadajewski, M. (2004). The philosophy of marketing theory: Historical and future directions. The Marketing Review, 4, 307–340. Tadajewski, M. (2005). Multiple paradigm analysis and green consumer behavior. Working Paper, University of Essex. Tadajewski, M. (2005a). Confrontations of philosophy, management and politics. Ephemera: Theory and Politics in Organization, 5, 499–518. Tadajewski, M. (forthcoming). The ordering of marketing theory: The influence of McCarthyism and the Cold War. Marketing Theory. Tadajewski, M. and S. Wagner-Tsukamoto (forthcoming). Cognitive anthropology and consumer research. Qualitative Market Research. Thompson, C. J., E. J. Arnould and B. B. Stern (1997). Exploring the Différence: A postmodern approach to paradigmatic pluralism in consumer research. In S. Brown and D. Turley (eds.), Consumer Research: Postcards from the Edge. London: Routledge, 150–189. Tsoukas, H. and C. Knudsen (2003). Introduction: The need for metatheoretical reflection in organization theory. In H. Tsoukas and C. Knudsen (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Organization Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1–36. Tynan, C. (2002). Academy of Marketing Conference 2002. The marketing landscape: Signposts for the future. Journal of Marketing Management, 18, 441–443. Van Maanen, J. (1995). Style as theory. Organization Science, 6, 133–143. Weaver, G. R and D. A. Gioia (1994). Paradigms lost: Incommensurability vs. structurationist inquiry. Organization Studies, 15, 565–590. Wilk, R. R. (2001). The impossibility and necessity of re-inquiry: Finding middle ground in social science. Journal of Consumer Research, 28, 308–312. Willmott, H. (1993). Breaking the paradigm mentality. Organization Studies, 14, 681–719.
ch02
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
3 EXPLAINING ECOLOGICAL PRODUCT PURCHASE USING CONSUMERS’ PSYCHOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS Elena Fraj∗ , Eva Martínez and Teresa Montaner Departamento de Economia y Direccion de Empresas Facultad de Ciencias Economicas y Empresariales Gran Via, 2. Zaragoza, Spain ∗
[email protected] Received July 2004 Accepted May 2005 This paper identifies the characteristics of the ecological product consumer, and considers their disposition to buy those products even when the price is higher than non-ecological products. Variables relating to ecological behaviour such as values, lifestyle, personality and attitude (Straughan and Roberts, 1999; Kotchen and Reiling, 2000; Chan, 2001; Laroche et al., 2001) are considered. To achieve our purpose, a survey with a random sample of 573 consumers was designed. Several exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses were conducted and a logistic regression analysis was applied on the obtained data. The results confirm that the psychographic variables used differentiate the profile of the consumer who is willing to buy ecological products at different prices.
Keywords: Ecological consumer behaviour, psychographic variables, ecological purchase, willingness to pay more, logit analysis.
1.
Introduction
Consumers committed to nurturing a healthy environment encourage companies to replace their usual practices with others that are more respectful to the environment. Company executives are interested to know such
47
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
48
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
consumers’ behaviour, especially what they like and what they think. To satisfy that interest, researchers of consumers’ behaviour have decided to study the ecological consumer. Nevertheless, this is not an easy task since the first problem they find is the difficulty in defining this type of behaviour due to the several dimensions that are involved (purchase, use, consume, reuse, disposal). Furthermore, there is no fully ecological behaviour since there is no fully ecological product. Thus, Kaiser and Wilson (2000) explain that the concept of ecological behaviour includes “all those actions which contribute to protect and preserve the environment”. For this reason, various conducts have been considered by the literature when analysing the profile of the ecological consumer (Kinnear et al., 1974; Grunert and Røhme, 1992; Stone et al., 1995; Sánchez et al., 1998; Kotchen and Reiling, 2000; Chan, 2001; Laroche et al., 2001; Fraj and Martínez, 2002; Fraj et al., 2004). Actions like recycling energy and water saving, political activism and commitment to environmental organisations, and purchase, consumption and willingness to pay more for ecological products, reflect a consumer concerned for the environment. This paper examines several factors intervening in the final development of the ecological consumer’s behaviour. These factors refer to the following groups of variables: demographic, socio-economic, psychographic and environmental knowledge. For the first two groups, there is no consistent relationship in their use to explain the ecological consumer’s behaviour and, although they would solve some specific questions, they would be useless to identify this market segment properly (Kassarjian, 1971; Daniere and Takahashi, 1999; Laroche et al., 2001). For this reason, researchers have realised that the analysis of the ecological behaviour requires some other variables, like psychographic ones, in an attempt to guarantee the understanding of this type of behaviour (Bigné, 1997; Laroche et al., 2001; Fraj and Martínez, 2002). The analysis of values and lifestyles, personality and attitudes has been one of the most important aims of social and behaviour researchers over the last decades. The aim of the present study is to analyse the profile of the ecological consumer who would be willing to buy ecological products even if they were more expensive than non-ecological ones. With this purpose, this study is organised as follows: we will first review the main literature on the subject, which will be the base for the development of the hypotheses in the study; secondly, we will explain the methodology and the analyses performed; thirdly, we will describe the results obtained; and finally, the main conclusions will be presented.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
2.
49
Review of the Literature and Hypotheses
Taking the existing literature as a starting point, this section describes the most relevant findings for every psychographic variable (values and lifestyles, personality and attitude) which will allow us to develop our study hypotheses. Therefore, this section establishes the hypotheses on the association of values and lifestyles with ecological behaviour; the hypotheses on the relationship between personality features and that behaviour; and the hypotheses on the relationship between environmental attitudes and behaviour.
2.1. Values and lifestyles Values and lifestyles are the most used variables by researchers to identify the ecological consumer’s profile. Alonso (1999) observed that, among the consumer’s new habits, ecological values and respect for nature have a crucial relevance. The author explains that consumer tries to care for natural areas as a part of their leisure time and feels concerned about their eating habits and physical appearance. On the other hand, De Young (1985–1986) observed that an austere and moderate lifestyle would be associated with a positive behaviour towards glass and paper recycling. Equally, Lievers et al. (1986) proved that people with conservative and religious values and lifestyles participate actively in society. McCarty and Shrum (1993) found that values such as goal achieving, self-respect, others’ respect and self-fulfilment encouraged individuals to consider recycling. Schwartz (1992, 1994) observed that those values existing in dimensions like self-transcendence and self-exaltation had an influence on the ecological behaviour. Thus, those values in the dimension of self-exaltation (power and capacity) were less inclined to environmental actions. Schultz and Zelezny (1999) related Schwartz’s values with environmental attitudes, finding that the value of power (a value of the self-exalted ones) was negatively associated with the eco-centred vision of attitudes. Thøgersen and Ölander (2002) reach the same conclusions. These authors report strong ties between universal values (contained in the dimension of self-transcendence) and the adoption of sustainable behaviour patterns. However, this relationship was not so significant for those values reflecting power (self-exaltation). Therefore, values and lifestyles may act as determining factors for the ecological behaviour. Thus, consider the following relationships about the
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
50
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
influence of values and lifestyles on the ecological behaviour: H1a : Individuals with high versus low self-fulfilment values show a higher ecological behaviour. H1b : Individuals with little versus great interest for power show a higher ecological behaviour. H1c : Individuals with an austere or moderate versus easy-going lifestyle show a higher ecological behaviour. H1d : Individuals with high versus low interest for ecological matters show a higher ecological behaviour. H1e : Individuals who are concerned versus unconcerned for their health and body show a higher ecological behaviour.
2.2. Personality Personality is another psychographic variable which affects the consumer’s behaviour. Personality is a specific and unique variable for each individual, conditioned by the individual’s value system. The most relevant results on this issue found in the literature refer to personality features such as extroversion, solidarity with the others, responsibility and order, emotional stability and imagination. Anderson and Cunningham (1972) and Webster (1975) analyse social responsibility according to people’s availability to help others with no profit motive in mind. These authors concluded that those consumers with a high degree of social responsibility are more inclined to buy environment-friendly products. Later, Ramanaiah et al. (2000), in order to analyse the personality profile of individuals with a certain degree of environmental responsibility, found that this type of people distinguish themselves by their extrovert character, their open-mindedness and their solidarity with the others. Díaz and Beerli (2003) observed that people who were less involved in glass recycling showed less responsibility and emotional receptiveness. And those who did not recycle were characterised by being scarcely grouporiented and thinking that they could do nothing to improve the environment (external locus of control). Fraj and Martínez (2005b) found that personality was positively related to the fact that individuals buy ecological products, attend different environmental conferences and join pro-environmental groups. They obtained that consumers who were aware and conscientious had bought ecological products or had switched products for ecological reasons. Moreover, those
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
51
who were extrovert and care about the others were more likely to attend some ecological conference and join an environmental group. Nevertheless, literature on personality and ecological behaviour is limited. Consequently, some of the hypotheses we present have an exploratory character. Firstly, although we might expect that those individuals with an extrovert character would tend to have a respectful behaviour towards the environment due to their sociability and their need of approval from the people around them (Costa and McCrae, 1992), in the Big-Five Factor scale this characteristic mainly reveals vanity and the result might be just the opposite. In other words, this type of extroversion would reflect conceited individuals, more interested in attracting people’s attention than in being respectful to the environment. Secondly, those individuals who are supportive and concerned about others will also be concerned about the future of society and thus the planet’s sustainability, which will make them behave in an ecological way. Thirdly, emotionally stable individuals will adopt an ecological behaviour in a positive way since they will feel better of themselves. Fourthly, responsible and meticulous individuals will try to achieve all their goals and observe the rules, thus they will tend to follow ecological behaviour patterns. Finally, educated people with a high interest for new experiences will be characterised by their open and liberal mind and will probably follow new trends of consumption and ecological behaviour. H2a : Individuals with a less extrovert and vain personality show a higher ecological behaviour. H2b : Individuals with a personality characterised by solidarity with the others show a higher ecological behaviour. H2c : Individuals with an emotionally stable personality show a higher ecological behaviour. H2d : Individuals with a personality characterised by order and responsibility show a higher ecological behaviour. H2e : Individuals with an imaginative and intellectual personality show a higher ecological behaviour.
2.3. Attitude Now, we will review the last element of the classic structure, which refers to the relationship between attitudes and ecological behaviour. We have
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
52
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
found several studies in the literature which obtained relevant results from different perspectives. For example, Ling-Yee (1997) concluded that a more ecological attitude was connected with a higher environmental involvement. Kotchen and Reiling (2000) also stated that highly favourable attitudes towards the respect for the environment lead consumers to pay some extra money which may redound to the environment’s improvement. Laroche et al. (2001), in the same vein, suggested that those who were willing to pay more for ecological products had no objection to having an environmental behaviour; on the contrary, they considered it as an important thing. On the other hand, although not many studies have followed the tridimensional approach of attitude to relate it with ecological behaviour, some of them have proved that affective commitment has a positive influence on the relationship between verbal commitment (behaviour intention) and ecological behaviour, and that verbal commitment has a greater influence on that behaviour, since it is its nearest antecedent (Kaiser et al., 1999). In this respect, Chan (2001), in his study of the determinants of ecological product purchase in China, found that affection had a positive influence on environmental attitude which also influenced ecological product purchase. Fraj and Martínez (2005a) found that ecological behaviour was mainly determined by environmental affect. It seemed that ecological behavior was better explained by affect than by environmental attitude, and, at the same time, affect appeared quite significant in determining environmental attitudes. From these researchers’ perspective, and for each element which constitutes attitude, we establish that those individuals concerned and interested in environmental issues, those who are willing to change their shopping and consume habits and those who are already following these behaviour patterns will all show a responsible behaviour towards the environment, as hypothesised below. H3a : Individuals with a more affective attitude (concern, interest) to the environment show a higher ecological behaviour. H3b : Individuals with a higher attitude of verbal commitment to the environment show a higher ecological behaviour. H3c : Individuals with a higher attitude of actual commitment to the environment show a higher ecological behaviour. To contrast these three groups of hypotheses we will explain the methodology used and the empirical analyses performed.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
3.
53
Methodology
3.1. Data collection The information was obtained from a survey performed in March and April 2001 with a random sample of 595 individuals in a city of Spain of these, 573 were valid (96%). Table 1 contains the sample’s technical specifications. We verify that for a trust level of 96%, an infinite population1 and for the rest of parameters defined in the sample calculation, there is a sample error of 4.2% in the 573 valid surveys. Prior to the final questionnaire we performed a pre-test so as to detect any problem before the design of the final survey.2 The final questionnaire was divided into three main sections with the following questions: first, questions on the recycling behaviour with some products, on the purchase of three types of ecological products (food, cleaning products and electrical appliances) and the willingness to buy them at the same price as the non-ecological ones and at a higher price; secondly, questions on psychographic variables and the individuals’ degree of knowledge and information of environmental issues; finally, we asked about the individuals’ socio-economic and demographic variables. From the demographic and socio-economic characteristics of the sample we may conclude that about 57% of the respondents are women, mostly between age of 15 and 55, 40% with higher education, 36.6% have a family income of 1,000–1,800 euro and most respondents belong to 2/3-member families. Table 1. Universe Sample size Sample error Proportions Trust level Sample design Fieldwork date Pre-test
1A
Technical specifications. Population over 14 573 surveys +/− 4,18% p = q = 0,5 95,5% Simple random sample March 2001 135 surveys / January 2001
large population (over 100,000) as the subject of a survey is usually considered as an infinite population. 2 In the pre-test we reworded some items from the original scales and some were eliminated because we found they were not relevant in our cultural context.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
54
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
3.2. Variable measurement Several scales were used to measure the variables. First, the second version of the VALS (Values and Lifestyles Scale) scale obtained from an international inventory (SRI) was used to measure values and lifestyles. It is a methodology tested in several countries which includes several American lifestyles in 35 items (Kahle et al., 1986; Novak and MacEvoy, 1990; Schwartz, 1992). Nevertheless, this scale encompasses general values and lifestyles which do not reflect ecological tendencies (Appendix 1). Consequently, we have also used the scale on lifestyles proposed and used by Sánchez et al. (1998a), which is designed to measure lifestyle in specific studies of ecological behaviour. The scale contains 18 items including questions on the importance of having a healthy life and being respectful towards nature (Appendix 2). Secondly, personality is analysed with the approach of the five features considered in Goldberg’s Big-Five Factor Structure (1990). These characteristics are: extroversion, agreeableness and solidarity with others, conscientiousness and responsibility, emotional balance and imagination and intelligence. Each of these characteristics is measured with 10 items, thus the scale contains a total of 50 (Appendix 3). It belongs to the International Personality Inventory (IPI) and it is a scale which has been frequently used, although not specifically to determine ecological behaviour (Saucier and Goldberg, 1996; Sadowsky and Cogburn, 1997; Bonner, 2000; Witt, 2002). Thirdly, attitude has been measured with a subscale of the revised EAKS (Environmental Attitude and Knowledge Scale) scale proposed by Maloney et al. (1975). It gathers the three elements of attitude (Appendix 4): affective (affective commitment), intentional (verbal commitment), cognitive (environmental knowledge), to which they added behaviour (actual commitment). Despite being an old scale, it is one of the most widely used in the literature of the ecological consumer’s behaviour, although sometimes only one of its dimensions is considered (Alwitt and Pitts, 1996; Ling-yee, 1997; Kaiser et al., 1999a, 1999b; Chan, 1999; 2001; Fraj and Martínez, 2002). The three scales measure the individuals’ level of agreement or disagreement in a seven-point Likert scale. Before designing the final survey we applied a qualitative validation by analysing the level of cross-cultural equivalence (Usunier, 2000) in the scales which came from other cultures (VALS; The Big-Five, EAKS). This analysis consisted of examining the construct’s operative, scalar and linguistic equivalences (Bhalla and Lin, 1987). This analysis allows comparing the results
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
55
obtained in our study with those from other international studies which may have used the same measurement instruments. Ecological behaviour is measured in this study through ecological product purchase, since it is the individual’s expression of their interest and concern for environmental improvement. Consequently, we considered three types of product: two perishable (food and cleaning products) and one lasting (white-goods). Given that in many stores of our country ecological products are not fully available, the respondents were questioned about their willingness to buy this type of product at the same price as non-ecological ones and at 10%, 15% and 20% higher prices. The individuals had to answer whether they were willing or not to buy each product. The description of the frequencies on the studied variable showed that, at the same price, all the consumers would be willing to buy ecological products. When the price was 10% higher, nearly 70% of the respondents were willing to buy them. Nevertheless, this percentage decreased when the price was 15% or 20% higher.
4.
Results
4.1. Scale validation analysis To validate the scales, several exploratory factor analyses were carried out with the statistical applications SPSS and EQS 5.7b for Windows. These analyses allowed us to analyse first the scales’ reliability and unidimensionality and secondly their fit, final reliability and validity (Grande and Abascal, 1999; Del Barrio and Luque, 2000). In this respect, for the VALS scale we obtained four dimensions which reflected a reduced version of the original (Table 2): the first one formed by five items on the individuals’ liking for the latest fashion (FASHION); the second one had five items and referred to the adventurous spirit of those people who are keen on knowing new things and undertake new experiences which allow self-fulfilment (AVENT); the third one was formed by two items and was related to the value of power and authority reflected in the individuals’ aspiration to organise and lead other people (LEADER); and the fourth one, with two items, shows the respondents’ interest for engineering and communication issues (KNOWLEDGE). The dimensions in the VALS scale showed an excellent reliability, but the composite reliability coefficient was below the optimum in the case of LEADER and KNOWLEDGE, maybe as a result of the reduced number of
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
56
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner Table 2.
CONSTRUCTS Latest Fashion (FASHION)
Confirmatory analysis for the values and lifestyles scale “VALS”. — — — — —
Adventurous Spirit (AVENT)
— — —
— — Leader Spirit (LEADER)
— —
Engineering and communications knowledge (KNOWLEDGE)
—
—
Reliab.(a) αc = 0.85 fc = 0.80
E.V.A(b) 0.45
αc = 0.84 fc = 0.79
0.43
0.73 0.84
αc = 0.76 fc = 0.67
0.5
0.66 0.83
αc = 0.71 fc = 0.63
0.46
ITEMS I follow the latest trends and fashions. I dress more fashionably than most people. I must admit that I like to show off. I like to dress in the latest fashions. I want to be considered fashionable.
(λ) 0.74
I like a lot of variety in my life. I like trying new things. I like the challenge of doing something I have never done before. I am always looking for a thrill. I like doing things that are new and different.
0.63
I like being in charge of a group. I like to lead others. I am very interested in how mechanical things, such as engines, work. I like to look through hardware or automotive stores.
0.76 0.56 0.83 0.76
0.63 0.64
0.84 0.82
Note: The table shows the standardised loads for each indicator of each construct (λ), all of them above 0.50 and significant, the Cronbach’s alpha reliability coefficients (αc ) and composite reliability (fc ), and the coefficients from the extracted variance analysis (E.V.A). (a) Cronbach’s alpha is very sensitive to the number of indicators in the scale. The more indicators in a scale, the more reliable it will be (Peter, 1979). Composite reliability coefficient is used as another measurement of the scales’ internal consistence. Its optimum threshold is on 0.7 (Hair et al., 1999) and its interpretation may be flexible (Del Barrio and Luque, 2000). (b) The coefficient from the extracted variance analysis allows to know the global variance of the items explained by the latent variable. Its value should be ideally above 0.50 (Del Barrio and Luque, 2000).
items, although the extracted variance analysis is better than in FASHION and AVENT. However, fit measurements are within the adequate parameters (χ2 = 220.92 g.l. = 71; GFI = 0.95; RMSEA = 0.06; CFI = 0.95; NFI = 0.99; AGFI = 0.92).
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase Table 3. CONSTRUCTS Ecological Patterns (ECOEV)
57
Confirmatory analysis for the lifestyles scale “Lifestyles”. ITEMS — I prefer consuming recycled products. — I throw garbage in selective containers. — I participate in environment conservation tasks. — I worry about the human activity consequences on the climatic change and act consistently.
(λ) 0.6 0.65
Healthy food (ALISANA)
— — — — —
Healthy way of life (SALUDEV)
— I try to reduce stress. — Regularly, visit the dentist. — I try to take an arranged and methodical life. — I try to find the balance between work and my private life.
I control the salt ingestion. I try not to eat pre-cooked food. I eat red meat moderately. I try to eat food without additives. Periodically, I check my health voluntarily.
Reliab. αc = 0.82 fc = 0.76
E.V.A 0.44
0.64 0.57 0.59 0.69 0.63
αc = 0.76 fc = 0.71
0.33
0.62 0.58 0.68
αc = 0.71 fc = 0.66
0.32
0.82 0.82
0.57
Note: See note in Table 2.
As for the scale of ecological “Lifestyles”, we obtained three dimensions (Table 3) on several ecological behaviours with four items (ECOEV), on healthy eating habits with five items (ALISANA) and on a healthy, balanced and relaxed lifestyle with four items (SALUDEV). In this scale the three dimensions present good reliability but the variance analysis coefficient is below the threshold. Nevertheless, we did not consider the elimination of more items because the last confirmatory factor analysis does not recommend it. Furthermore, as in the previous case, these data’s goodness of fit is within the established parameters (χ2 = 261 g.l. = 62; GFI = 0.94; RMSEA = 0.08; CFI = 0.91; NFI = 0.90; AGFI = 0.91). In the case of “The Big-Five” personality scale, we obtained the five expected dimensions (Table 4): extroversion, with three items, (EXT); solidarity with the others, with six items, (SOL); responsibility and order, with eight items, (RES); emotional stability, with four indicators, (EMO); and intellect and imagination, with six indicators, (INT). The final reliability of the personality scale is excellent according to Cronbach’s alpha. In this case, the dimensions SOL, EMO and
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
58
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner Table 4.
Confirmatory analysis for the personality scale “The Big-Five”.
CONSTRUCTS EXTROVERSION & VANITY (EXT_)
ITEMS — Am the life of a party. — Start conversations. — Keep in the background. (+)
(λ) 0.76 0.62 0.67
Reliab. αc = 0.82 fc = 0.66
E.V.A 0.39
AGREEABLENESS (AGR_)
— Am interested in people. — Sympathise with others’ feelings. — Have a soft heart. — Take time out for others. — Feel others’ emotions. — Make people feel at ease.
0.73 0.86
αc = 0.89 fc = 0.85
0.49
0.83 0.76 0.78 0.66
— — — — — —
Am always prepared. Pay attention to details. Like order. Follow a schedule. Am exacting in my work. Leave my belongings around. (+) — Make a mess of things. (+) — Often forget to put things back in their proper place. (+)
0.58 0.69 0.77 0.60 0.64 0.61
αc = 0.85 fc = 0.81
0.35
EMOTIONAL STABILITY (EMO_)
— — — —
0.67 0.84 0.66 0.88
αc = 0.81 fc = 0.79
0.49
INTELLECT OR IMAGINATION (INT_)
— — — —
0.69 0.73 0.66 0.62
αc = 0.84 fc = 0.78
0.81
CONSCIENTIOUSNESS (CONS_)
Am easily disturbed. (+) Get upset easily. (+) Change mood a lot. (+) Get irritated easily. (+)
Have a rich vocabulary. Have a vivid imagination. Have excellent ideas. Am quick to understand things. — Use difficult words. — Am full of ideas.
0.65 0.58
0.61 0.69
Note: See note in Table 2; (+) Indicates that the sense of the scale has been changed so that all the items may have the same sense.
INT present an AVE of 0.5 or above, and it is inferior for EXT and RES. Equally, we neither remove nor add any indicators from these dimensions because the model would worsen. In this case, although some parameters are within the recommended levels, others do not reach that level (χ2 = 1327 g.l. = 314; GFI = 0.84; RMSEA = 0.08; CFI = 0.85; NFI = 0.99;
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
59
AGFI = 0.81). This may be explained by the influence of the sample size and the number of indicators (Hair et al., 1999; Del Barrio and Luque, 2000). Finally, the attitudes scale “EAKS” gathers the intentional component, with two items (VC), the behavioural one, also with two items (AC) and the affective one, with five items (AF). All of them refer to aspects related with the individuals’ disposition to reduce air pollution, the activities to achieve that purpose and the feeling of frustration and anger experienced by individuals about environmental problems (Table 5). Regarding the final reliability of the scale, considering that VC and AC dimensions include two items each, their internal consistence is enough. On Table 5.
Confirmatory analysis for the environmental attitude scale “EAKS”.
CONSTRUCTS AFFECT COMMITMENT (AF)
ITEMS — It frightens me to think that much of the food I eat is contaminated with pesticides. — It genuinely infuriates me to think that the government doesn’t do more to help control pollution of the environment. — I become incensed when I think about the harm being done to plant and animal life by pollution. — I get depressed on smoggy days. — When I think of the ways industries are polluting, I get frustrated and angry.
(λ) 0.59 0.75
VERBAL COMMITMENT (VC)
— I’d be willing to ride a bicycle or take the bus to work in order to reduce air pollution. — I would be willing to use a rapid transit system to help to reduce air pollution
ACTUAL COMMITMENT (AC)
— I make a special effort to buy products in recyclable containers. — I have switched products for ecological reasons
Note: See note in Table 2.
Reliab. αc = 0.83 fc = 0.78
E.V.A 0.42
0.76 0.72
αc = 0.7 fc = 0.62
0.45
0.72 0.76
αc = 0.63 fc = 0.62
0.45
0.83
0.61 0.77
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
60
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
the other hand, the extracted variance analysis is around 0.5 in the VC and AC dimensions, and it is below that value for AF. In this case, the data fit has been nearly perfect (χ2 = 67.20 g.l. = 24; GFI = 0.97; RMSEA = 0.06; CFI = 0.97; NFI = 0.96; AGFI = 0.95). Moreover, successive factor analyses were also conducted to guarantee all these constructs convergent validity. This validity is proved because indicators present significant factor loadings (over 0.5) (Anderson and Gerbing, 1988). We will proceed to contrast the hypotheses by applying several logit analyses, in the next section.
4.2. Logit analysis In order to contrast the three groups of the established hypotheses, on values and lifestyles, personality and attitudes, we have included the dimensions resulting from the previous analysis as variables which may explain the individuals’ disposition to buy ecological products. This expression of ecological behaviour has been measured by four price categories for the three considered products (food, cleaning products and white-goods): the same price, 10% higher, 15% higher and 20% higher. Because in the literature the influence of these variables on different ecological behaviours has not been studied as a whole but individually, a logit analysis has been applied for each group of variables. Tables 6, 7, 8 and 9 show the results on the relationship of each group of variables with ecological product purchase. The variables which have proved to be significant in the first regression3 (Table 6) have been FASHION at the same price for food and even paying 15% and 20% more for three ecological products. This reveals some relationship between the disposition to buy ecological products at different price ranges and the importance to follow the latest trends and fashion. The individuals’ adventurous spirit and satisfaction of trying out new things (AVENT) also shows a relationship with this behaviour although with 3 Within
the resulting factors of the VALS scale in confirmatory analysis, none of them reflects an austere or moderate lifestyle, thus H1c cannot be contrasted. However, other factors whose influence on ecological behaviour will be analysed, although no hypotheses have been established since there is no literature on the matter. These factors are: the tendency to follow the latest fashion trends (FASHION) and the interest for engineering and communication issues (KNOWLEDGE).
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006 11:53
Table 6.
Logit analysis results about values and lifestyles (VALS).
Price Level Ecological Food
C
At the same price 10% 15% 20%
2.508∗∗ 0.018 −1.114∗∗ −3.167∗∗
FASHION 0.084∗ 0.043∗∗ 0.044∗
ADVENT −0.191* 0.075∗∗ 0.050*
LEADER
KNOWLED.
−0.074*
%
−2LL
G
χ2
95.3 74.9 61.6 81.5
209.213 625.24 736.9 525.98
7.325* 11.29* 11.61* 10.40*
8.273* 14.72∗∗ 7.96∗∗ 12.39∗∗
96.5 73.6 68.5 84.9
650.88 691.22 471.01
9.80* 4.32* 8.47*
4.92* 12.11∗∗ 6.40*
96.3 70.7 66.8 80.6
683.27 709.89 549.01
19.92 4.22* 9.61*
5.50* 5.89* 3.91*
Ecological cleaning products 3.316∗∗ 0.166 −1.555∗∗ −2.485∗∗
0.055∗∗ 0.052∗
0.043*
Ecological white-goods At the same price 10% 15% 20%
3.265∗∗ −0.003 −1.24∗∗ −1.957∗∗
0.038∗ 0.037∗
0.044*
Note: C = constant; the estimated regression coefficients (β) are presented under each variable; −2LL = −2 Log of the verisimilitude function; χ 2 = Chi-square of the model to contrast the global significance of the coefficients; G = Chi-square on the significance of Hosmer-Lemeshow goodness of fit contrast to see whether the model conforms to the observed data; * = 5% significant and ∗∗ = 1% significant.
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
At the same price 10% 15% 20%
61
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
VALS
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
Price Level Ecological Food
C
At the same price 10% 15% 20%
0.816 −1.537∗∗ −2.058∗∗ −4.056∗∗
ECOEV
ALISANA
0.183∗∗
SALUDEV
%
−2LL
G
χ2
0.168∗∗
95.3 78.1 63.2 81.5
204.77 574.47 721.16 505.62
12.94* 8.184* 13.66* 9.70*
12.71∗∗ 65.49∗∗ 23.71∗∗ 32.75∗∗
96.5 78.2 68.3 84.9
169.66 576.22 676.54 449.88
8.56* 7.81* 17.06 4.14*
3.70* 79.57∗∗ 26.79∗∗ 27.67∗∗
96.3 75 68.2 80.1
173.66 612.6 679.9 508.5
5.46* 10.82* 5.27* 10.12*
6.28* 76.17∗∗ 35.89∗∗ 44.83∗∗
0.101∗∗ 0.160∗∗
Ecological cleaning products At the same price 10% 15% 20%
1.967∗∗ −2.166∗∗ −2.533∗∗ −4.312∗∗
0.094* 0.175∗∗ 0.114∗∗ 0.160∗∗
1.59* −1.897∗∗ −2.895∗∗ −4.945∗∗
0.190∗∗ 0.080∗∗ 0.114∗∗
0.039*
Ecological white-goods At the same price 10% 15% 20%
Note: See note in Table 6.
0.054∗∗
0.132* 0.112∗∗
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Lifestyles
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Logit analysis results about the Lifestyles.
11:53
62
Table 7.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006 11:53
Logit analysis results about personality (The Big-Five). The Big-Five
Price Level Ecological Food
C
At the same price 10% 15% 20%
1.057 −0.233 −1.223∗∗ −2.963∗∗
EXT
AGR
CONS
EMO
0.058* −0.068*
INT
%
−2LL
0.058∗∗ 0.054∗∗ 0.062∗∗
95.3 75.1 62.1 81.5
211.37 628.62 733.38 528.61
5.70* 7.10* 2.77* 10.40*
6.12* 11.35∗∗ 11.48∗∗ 9.75∗∗
0.076∗∗ 0.037* 0.049*
96.5 73.4 68.1 84.9
162.54 637.32 698.12 472.2
5.095* 6.60* 10.05* 4.82*
10.82∗∗ 18.48∗∗ 5.205* 5.35*
0.062∗∗ 0.051∗∗ 0.077∗∗
96.3 70.3 66.6 81
174.3 672.34 701.54 534.91
5.16* 12.12* 14.48* 12.96*
5.67* 16.44∗∗ 12.25∗∗ 18.42∗∗
G
χ2
Ecological cleaning products −0.415 −0.026 −1.635∗∗ −2.902∗∗
0.076∗∗ −0.086*
0.114*
Ecological white-goods At the same price 10% 15% 20%
1.175 0.28 −1.081∗∗ −2.256∗∗
Note: See note in Table 6.
−0.103∗∗ −0.104∗∗ −0.128∗∗
0.062*
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
At the same price 10% 15% 20%
63
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Table 8.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
Price Level Ecological Food
C
AF
At the same price 10% 15% 20%
0.921 −0.364 −1.67∗∗ −3.408∗∗
0.112∗∗
VC
%
−2LL
G
χ2
0.195∗∗ 0.301∗∗
95.3 75.1 64.2 81.5
205.99 595.89 714.66 495.11
7.87* 14.30* 5.525* 5.48*
11.50∗∗ 44.06∗∗ 30.21∗∗ 43.25∗∗
0.281∗∗ 0.196∗∗ 0.282∗∗
96.5 76.8 68.1 84.9
596.17 675.19 444.56
22.06 5.12* 1.61*
59.6∗∗ 28.14∗∗ 32.99∗∗
0.306∗∗ 0.247∗∗ 0.267∗∗
96.3 73.8 69.1 80.6
175.76 627.17 671.38 517.27
12.58* 8.77* 9.80* 7.81*
4.18* 61.61∗∗ 44.41∗∗ 36.05∗∗
AC
0.269∗∗
Ecological cleaning products At the same price 10% 15% 20%
3.316∗∗ −1.172∗∗ −1.95∗∗ −3.54∗∗
0.088*
Ecological white-goods At the same price 10% 15% 20%
1.815 −0.801∗∗ −2.205∗∗ −3.114∗∗
Note: See note in Table 6.
0.076*
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
(EAKS)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Logit analysis results about the environmental attitude (EAKS).
11:53
64
Table 9.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
65
a different sign according to the price. Thus, while individuals who face new experiences and exciting challenges in an attempt to achieve self-fulfilment would not be willing to buy ecological products at the same price, they would pay 10% more in all the products and even 20% more in the case of food. This behaviour might reinforce these individuals’ interest for the environmental improvement or their commitment towards environmental protection. In this sense, H1a , which stated that “individuals with high self-fulfilment values will show a higher ecological behaviour”, would be valid for those cases. On the other hand, the value which reflects the individuals’ interest or curiosity for engineering or communication issues (KNOWLEDGE) only presents relationship with the disposition to buy ecological food when paying 10% more. This is a negative relationship, which means that people concerned for these issues would not be willing to pay more for ecological products. H1b is not confirmed because no significant coefficient for the value of power factor (LEADER) was found. In the second regression (Table 7), where the variables from the Lifestyles scale have been considered, the results obtained about the individuals who follow an ecological lifestyle and like to buy ecological products and participate in environmental improvement actions (ECOEV) are remarkable, since this variable is positively related in all the behaviours and for all the products. Thus, H1d , “individuals with high interest for ecological matters will show a higher ecological behaviour”, would be clearly confirmed. On the other hand, in some cases lifestyles related with having healthy eating habits (ALISANA) and having a healthy lifestyle (SALUDEV) have also showed a positive and significant relationship. Consequently, those people who try to have healthy eating habits would be willing to buy 10% more expensive cleaning products and a 15% more expensive white-goods. And those who are concerned for their health and try to have a balanced and relaxed lifestyle (SALUDEV) would buy ecological products at the same price and would even pay 20% more for ecological white-goods. Therefore, in these cases H1e : “individuals who are concerned for their health and body will show a higher ecological behaviour”, would be verified. The regression analysis which studies the relationship between the willingness to buy ecological products and the five personality characteristics is shown in Table 8. As for the characteristic of extroversion (EXT), the relationship is significant and negative in all the cases where it occurs, specifically in the disposition
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
66
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
to buy at 10%, 15% and 20% more. This shows that the less extrovert or vain the individuals are, the more willing they are to buy ecological products at these price ranges. On the other hand, the characteristic of responsibility (RES) is positively related to ecological product purchase at the same price as non-ecological ones, but it shows no relationship in the other cases. That is, the more responsible the person, the more willing to buy this type of products at the same price as non-ecological ones. The characteristic of emotional stability (EMO) has proved to be related only to cleaning product purchase at the same price. It is not relevant in any other case. Finally, the characteristic of intellect and imagination (INT) shows a relationship with this behaviour for all price and product ranges except at the same price. Therefore, those individuals characterised by this type of personality would be more willing to buy ecological products 10%, 15% and 20% more expensive. We may conclude then that H2a , which stated that individuals with a less extrovert and conceited personality would show a higher ecological behaviour, and H2e , which postulated that individuals with an imaginative and intellectual personality would show a higher ecological behaviour, are verified. Finally, the characteristics of emotional stability and responsibility only increase purchase likelihood at the same price for cleaning products in the first case and for the three products in the second one. Therefore, H2c and H2d, which referred to those people with high emotional stability and responsibility respectively, would be verified only in these cases. H2b is not verified in any case, since the characteristic of solidarity to the others does not present significant coefficients. Regarding the relationship between the three components of attitude and ecological product purchase, in Table 9 we can observe that the variable of real ecological commitment (AC) has shown a regular relationship with the purchase disposition since this association occurs for the three levels of higher price and the three products. However, the variables of verbal ecological commitment (VC) and affective commitment (AF) only appear associated to this behaviour in the disposition to buy cleaning products 10% more expensive and buy ecological food and white-goods at the same price. Consequently, H3a : “individuals with a more affective attitude (concern, interest) to the environment will show a higher ecological behaviour”, would
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
67
be confirmed only for the disposition to buy ecological food and white-goods at the same price, therefore we cannot fully conclude that people interested and concerned for the environment would be more willing to buy ecological products at different price ranges. The same could be said for H3b , which is only confirmed when the consumers are willing to buy ecological cleaning products at a 10% higher price. Finally, H3c , which stated that individuals with a higher attitude of actual commitment to the environment would show a higher ecological behaviour, is clearly verified since in all the cases the individual would pay more for ecological products. Those consumers willing to buy ecological products at different price ranges are characterised by values which reflect the enterprising spirit of those people who feel self-fulfilled when facing exciting challenges and having new experiences. Furthermore, they highly appreciate the ecological attributes or benefits of products, a healthy lifestyle and healthy eating habits. Among the personality characteristics which have described this behaviour best are the individuals’ scarce extroversion or vanity and the level of intellect and imagination. Finally, as for environmental attitudes, real ecological commitment is the most determining factor in the disposition to buy at different price ranges.
4.3. Discussion and managerial implications This paper contributes to improve the knowledge of the ecological consumer’s behaviour and we offer an analysis of the psychographic profile of that consumer. This research has proved, first, that psychographic variables are crucial for the environmental behaviour and, second, that some values, lifestyles, personality characteristics and attitudes increase the likelihood that consumers concerned for the environment have no objection to pay more for less polluting goods. The knowledge of these characteristics may be extremely useful for those companies whose commercial decisions involve market segmentation and those who want their products to have a pre-eminent place in the consumer’s mind. If environmental concern maintains this upward trend, the number of ecological consumers will equally grow. Therefore, the company’s continuity in the market will depend on meeting the consumers’ needs. Obviously, the consumers’ needs will determine the company’s launch of new products and its management. But the question is, how does the company address this group of consumers? And what kind of actions do they have to take?
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
68
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Before giving an answer to these questions, managers need to know the consumer’s personality and mind so as to draw their attention. This study provides companies with the knowledge of the psychographic characteristics of the consumer who is willing to pay different price range when purchasing ecological products and, indirectly, their way of thinking. First, self-fulfilment has a prominent place in the value structures of these individuals. They are people who enjoy challenges and new experiences which satisfy them. They also like new fashion trends. In this respect, companies may persuade them by highlighting the original and distinctive character of their products and attributing new benefits to their use so that these consumers consider trying out these products as a new adventure. Second, they have an ecological lifestyle, consuming recycled products and participating in environmental activities. They also like having a balanced life and healthy eating habits. Therefore, companies should be interested in highlighting the environmental attributes of their products, mainly through labelling and packaging. On the other hand, in the case of organic farming products, their healthy aspects should be emphasised. Third, the personality characteristics which best describe the ecological consumer are two: scarcely extrovert or conceited character and imagination. Thus, these consumers, when purchasing ecological products, do not intend to prove to the others or themselves that they are contributing to the improvement of the environment. Therefore, the message that a company sends to the market, either about their environmental behaviour or to present their products, should contain no trace of vanity or leadership which may intimidate consumers. Finally, the attitude which best defines this type of consumers is an attitude of actual commitment towards the protection of the environment. This attitude is directly related to a proactive attitude from the company. In other words, the marketing managers of companies have to transmit a serious and responsible image of their activity in the market. Furthermore, that image has to be globally reflected by means of the company’s internal (management commitment) and external (commercial strategies) environmental organisation. Although this study has provided some knowledge of the ecological consumer’s profile, these results refer to a specific ecological behaviour: the disposition to purchase ecological products at different price levels. Hence, it would be convenient to analyse these characteristics for other expressions of the ecological behaviour.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
5.
69
Conclusions
This study contributes to the knowledge of the ecological consumer’s behaviour. More exactly, it presents the psychographic profile of the consumers who would be willing to purchase ecological products even if they were more expensive than non-ecological ones. Consequently, it has been proved that psychographic variables (values, lifestyles, personality and attitude) are determining in the ecological behaviour in general and, more particularly, in the consumers’ disposition to pay more for ecological products. These results reveal that companies face a wide demanding market and considering the environmental principles consistently in their global and commercial strategies may give them a sustainable competitive advantage which is crucial today. In this respect, they may design suitable commercial policies to draw the ecological consumer segment’s attention. Given that consumers increasingly appreciate ecological issues and enjoy taking risks and trying out new things, it should be in the companies’ interest to reflect their commitment towards the environment in their products/services, thus transmitting the measures they take to maximise the impact of their products. This may be done through the product’s labelling or advertising campaigns to inform consumers about these aspects. Furthermore, advertising campaigns should be aimed at people who are highly involved in environmental protection and those who do not like to be outstanding and have a great imagination. This could justify an increase of price for their less polluting products. The results of this study may be generalised cautiously, since the sample is relatively small and the researchers propose the application of this study to a wider sample in other countries in order to compare the results and analyse if culture is a relevant moderating variable.
Acknowledgements The authors express their gratitude for the financial help received from the Government of Aragon through the projects (PM 062/2004) and GENERES (Ref: S09/26779), and from the Ministry of Science and Technology by means of the CICYT project (Ref: SEC 2002-03949).
References Alonso, J. (1999). Comportamiento del Consumidor. Madrid: ESIC Editorial. Alwitt, L. F. and R. E. Pitts (1996). Predicting purchase intentions for an environmentally sensitive product. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 5(1), 49–64.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
70
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Anderson, W. T. and W. Cunningham (1972). The socially conscious consumer. Journal of Consumer Research, 2, 188–196. Anderson, J. C. and D. W. Gerbing (1988). Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach. Psychological Bulletin, 103(3), 411–423. Bhalla, G. and L. Lin (1987). Cross-cultural marketing research: A discussion of equivalence issues and measurement strategies. Psychology and Marketing, 4(4), 275–285. Bigné, J. E. (1997). El consumidor verde: bases de un modelo de comportamiento. ESIC MARKET, abril-junio, 29–43. Bonner, B. L. (2000). The effects of extroversion on influence in ambiguous group tasks. Small Group Research, 31(2), 225–244. Chan, R. Y. K. (1999). Environmental attitudes and behaviour of consumers in China: Survey findings and implications. Journal of International Consumer Marketing, 11(4), 25–52. Chan, R. Y. K. (2001). Determinants of Chinese consumers’ green purchase behaviour. Psychology and Marketing, 18(4), 389–413. Costa, P. T. and R. R. McCrae (1992). Revised NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PIR) and NEO Five-Factor Inventory (NEO-FFI). Professional Manual, Psychological Assessment Resources, Odessa, FL. Daniere, A. G. and L. M. Takahashi (1999). Environmental behaviour in Bangkok, Thailand: A portrait of attitudes, values and behaviour. Economic Development and Cultural Change, pp. 525–557. De Young, R. (1985–86). Encouraging environmentally appropriate behaviour: The role of intrinsic motivation. Journal of Environmental Systems, 15(4), 281–292. Del Barrio, S. and T. Luque (2000). Análisis de ecuaciones estructurales. In T. Luque (ed.), Técnicas de Análisis de Datos en Investigación de Mercados. Madrid: Ediciones Pirámide. Díaz, G. and A. Beerli (2003). Cómo son las personas resistentes a reciclar: Una aplicación empírica al reciclaje de vidrio. Cuadernos Aragoneses de Economía. En prensa. Fraj, E. and E. Martínez (2002). Comportamiento del Consumidor Ecológico. Madrid: ESIC Editorial. Fraj, E., E. Martínez and T. Montaner (2004). La compra de productos ecológicos explicada a través de las características psicográficas del consumidor. Proceedings of The XIV ACEDE Conference, Murcia, Spain. Fraj, E. and E. Martínez (2005a). Ecological consumer behaviour: An empirical analysis. International Journal of Consumer Studies. In press. Fraj, E. and E. Martínez (2005b). Influence of personality on ecological consumer behaviour. Journal of Consumer Behaviour. In press. Grande, I. and E. Abascal (1999). Fundamentos y Técnicas de Investigación Comercial, 4th Edición. Madrid: ESIC Editorial. Grunert, S. C. and N. Røhme (1992). Consumers’ environmental concern: Are we really tapping true concern that relates to environmentally ethic behaviour? The Environment, 159–177.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
71
Hair, J. F., R. E. Anderson, R. L. Tatham and W. C. Black (1999). Análisis Multivariante. 5th Edición. Madrid: Prentice Hall. Kahle, L. R., S. E. Beatty and P. Homer (1986). Alternative measurement approaches to consumer values: The List of Values (LOV) and Values and Life Style (VALS). Journal of Consumer Research, 13, 405–409. Kaiser, F. and M. Wilson (2000). Assessing people’s general ecological behaviour: A cross-cultural measure. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30(5), 952–978. Kaiser, F., S. Wölfing and U. Fuhrer (1999a). Environmental attitude and ecological behaviour. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 19, 1–19. Kaiser, F., M. Ranney, T. Hartig and P. Bowler (1999b). Ecological behaviour, environmental attitude, and feelings of responsibility for the environment. European Psychologist, 4(2), 59–74. Kassarjian, H. H. (1971). Personality and consumer behaviour: A review. Journal of Marketing Research, VIII, 409–418. Kinnear, T. C., J. R. Taylor and S. A. Ahmed (1974). Ecologically concerned consumers: Who are they? Journal of Marketing, 38, 20–24. Kotchen, M. J. and S. D. Reiling (2000). Environmental attitudes, motivations, and contingent valuation of nonuse values: A case study involving endangered species. Ecological Economics, 32, 93–107. Laroche, M., J. Bergeron and G. Barbaro-Forleo (2001). Targeting consumers who are willing to pay more for environmentally friendly products. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 18(6), 503–520. Lievers, S., P. Serra and J. Watson (1986). Religion and visiting old people: Sex differences. Psychological Reports, 58, 705–796. Ling-yee, L. (1997). Effects of collectivist orientation and ecological attitude on actual environmental commitment: The moderating role of consumer demographics and product involvement. Journal of International Consumer Marketing, 9(4), 31–53. Maloney, M. P., M. P. Ward and G. N. Braucht (1975). A revised scale for the measurement of ecological attitudes and knowledge. American Psychologist, Jul, 787–792. McCarty, J. A. and L. J. Shrum (1993). A structural equation analysis of the relationships of personal values, attitudes and beliefs about recycling, and the recycling of solid waste products. Advances in Consumer Research, 20, 641–646. Mitchell, A. (1983). The Nine American Life Styles. New York: Warner. Novak, T. P. and B. MacEvoy (1990). On comparing alternative segmentation schemes: The List of Values (LOV) and Values and Life Style (VALS). Journal of Consumer Research, 17, 105–109. Peter, J. P. (1979). Reliability: A review of psychometric basics and recent marketing practices. Journal of Marketing Research, 16, 6–17. Ramanaiah, N. V., M. Clump and J. P. Sharpe (2000). Personality profiles of environmentally responsible groups. Psychological Reports, 87, 176–178. Sadowski, C. J. and H. E. Cogburn (1997). Need for cognition in the Big-Five Factor structure. The Journal of Psychology, 13(3), 307–312.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
72
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Sánchez, M., I. Grande, J. M. Gil and A. Rodríguez (1998a). Evaluación del potencial de mercado de los productos de agricultura ecológica. Revista Española de Investigación de Marketing ESIC, No. Marzo, 135–150. Sánchez, M., J. M. Gil and A. Gracia (1998b). Frenos al crecimiento del mercado ecológico: El precio o la actitud hacia el medio ambiente? Revista Española de Investigación de Marketing ESIC, 103–114. Saucier, G. and L. R. Goldberg (1996). Evidence for the Big-Five in analyses of familiar English personality adjectives. European Journal of Personality, 10, 61–77. Schultz, P. W. and L. Zelezny (1999). Values as predictors of environmental attitudes: Evidence for consistency across 14 countries. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 19, 255–265. Schwartz, S. H. (1992). Universals in the content and structure of values: Theoretical advances and empirical tests in 20 countries. In Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, Vol. 25. Ontario: Academy Press, Inc., 1–64. Schwartz, S. H. (1994). Are there universal aspects in the structure and contents of human values? Journal of Social Issues, 50(4), 19–45. Stone, G., J. H. Barnes and C. Montgomery (1995). ECOSCALE: A scale for the measurement of environmentally responsible consumers. Psychology and Marketing, 12(7), 595–612. Straughan, R. D. and J. A. Roberts (1999). Environmental segmentation alternatives: A look at green consumer behavior in the new millennium. The Journal of Consumer Marketing, 16(6), 558. Thøgersen, J. and F. Ölander (2002). Human values and the emergence of a sustainable consumption pattern: A panel study. Journal of Economic Psychology, 23, 605–630. Usunier, J. C. (2000). Marketing Across Cultures, 3rd Edition. Essex: Pearson Education Limited. Webster, F. E. (1975). Determining the characteristics of the socially conscious consumer. Journal of Consumer Research, 2, 188–196. Witt, L. A. (2002). The interactive effects of extraversion and conscientiousness on performance. Journal of Management, 28(6), 835–850.
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
Appendix 1: Values and Lifestyles Scale (VALS) Items I am often interested in theories I Iike outrageous people and things I like a lot of variety in my life I love to make things I can use everyday I follow the latest trends and fashions Just as the Bible says, the world literally was created in six days I like being in charge of a group I like to learn about art, culture, and history I often crave excitement I am really interested only in a few things I would rather make something than buy it I dress more fashionably than most people The Federal government should encourage prayers in public schools I have more ability than most people I consider myself an intellectual I must admit that I like to show off I like trying new things I am very interested in how mechanical things, such as engines, work I like to dress in the latest fashions There is too much sex on television today I like to lead others I would like to spend a year or more in a foreign country I like a lot of excitement in my life I must admit that my interests are somewhat narrow and limited I like making things of wood, metal, or other such material I want to be considered fashionable A woman’s life is fulfilled only if she can provide a happy home for her family I like the challenge of doing something I have never done before I like to learn about things even if they may never be of any use to me I like make things with my hands I am always looking for a thrill I like doing things that are new and different I like to look through hardware or automotive stores I would like to understand more about how the universe works I like my life to be pretty much the same from week to week Source: Based on the International Survey of Mitchell (1983). Obtained from http://future.sri.com/vals/ [14/03/03].
73
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
74
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Appendix 2: Lifestyles Scale (Lifestyles) Items The current civilisation is destroying the nature. I prefer consuming recycled products. I throw garbage in selective containers. The environment deterioration will be irreversible if the necessary measures are not taken. I participate in environment conservation tasks. I worry about the human activity consequences on the climatic change and act consistently. I control the salt ingestion. I practise a vegetarian diet. I regularly do exercise. I try not to eat pre-cooked food. Often eat fruits and vegetables. I eat red meat moderately. I belong to a pro-environmental association. I try to eat food without additives. Periodically, I check my health voluntarily. I try to reduce stress. Regularly, I visit the dentist. I try to take an arranged and methodical life. I try to find the balance between work and my private life. I read the products labels. Source: Sánchez et al. (1998a).
Appendix 3: Personality Scale “The Big-Five Factor Structure” EXTROVERSION Am the life of the party. Feel comfortable around people. Start conversations. Talk to a lot of different people at parties. Don’t mind being the centre of attention. Don’t talk a lot. (+) Keep in the background. (+) Have little to say. (+) Don’t like to draw attention to myself. (+) Am quiet around strangers. (+) AGREEABLENESS Am interested in people. Sympathise with others’ feelings. Have a soft heart. (Continued)
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Explaining Ecological Product Purchase
75
(Continued) Take time out for others. Feel others’ emotions. Make people feel at ease. Am not really interested in others. (+) Insult people* (+) Am not interested in other people’s problems. (+) Feel little concern for others. (+) CONSCIENTIOUSNESS Am always prepared* Pay attention to details. Get chores done right away. Like order. Follow a schedule. Am exacting in my work. Leave my belongings around. (+) Make a mess of things. (+) Often forget to put things back in their proper place. (+) Shirk my duties* (+) EMOTIONAL STABILITY Am relaxed most of the time. (+) Often feel blue* (+) Get stressed out easily. Am easily disturbed. Get upset easily. Change mood a lot. Get irritated easily. Seldom feel blue. Am not easily bothered by things. (+) Rarely get irritated. (+) INTELLECT OR IMAGINATION Have a rich vocabulary. Have a vivid imagination. Have excellent ideas. Am quick to understand things. Use difficult words* Spend time reflecting on things. Am full of ideas. Have difficulty in understanding abstract ideas. (+) Am not interested in abstract ideas. (+) Do not have a good imagination. (+) Note: * = we changed the wording of these items to make them easily understood; (+) = indicates items that are inverted in their meaning. Source: http://ipip.ori.org/ipip [24/01/01].
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
76
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
E. Fraj, E. Martínez & T. Montaner
Appendix 4: Environmental Attitudes Scale (EAKS) Affect Commitment (AF) — It frightens me to think that much of the food I eat is contaminated with pesticides. — It genuinely infuriates me to think that the government doesn’t do more to help control pollution of the environment. — I become incensed when I think about the harm being done to plant and animal life by pollution. — I get depressed on smoggy days. — When I think of the ways industries are polluting, I get frustrated and angry. — The whole pollution issue has never upset me too much since I feel it’s somewhat overrated. (+) — I rarely ever worry about the effects of smog on myself and family. (+) Verbal Commitment (VC) or “Environmental Attitude” — I’d be willing to ride a bicycle or take the bus to work in order to reduce air pollution. — I would be willing to use a rapid transit system to help to reduce air pollution — I would donate a day’s pay to a foundation to help improve the environment. — I would be willing to stop buying products from companies guilty of polluting the environment, even though it might be inconvenient. — I’d be willing to write my congressman weekly concerning ecological problems. — I wouldn’t go house to house to distribute literature on the environment. (+) — I would not be willing to pay a pollution tax even if it would considerably decrease the smog problem. (+) Actual Commitment (AC) or “Ecological Behaviour” — I guess I’ve never actually bought a product because it had a lower polluting effect. (+) — I keep track of my congressman and senator’s voting records on environment issues. — I have contacted a community agency to find out what I can do about pollution. — I make a special effort to buy products in recyclable containers. — I have attended a meeting of an organisation specifically concerned with bettering the environment. — I have switched products for ecological reasons. — I have never joined a cleanup drive. (+) — I have never attended a meeting related to ecology. (+) — I subscribe to ecological publications. Note: Scale used in the final questionnaire. After passing the pre-test, we found some of these items problematic so we decided to take it off. The original scale can be obtained from Maloney et al. (1975).
ch03
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
4 EXTENSIONS OF LOGISTIC GROWTH MODEL FOR THE FORECASTING OF PRODUCT LIFE CYCLE SEGMENTS Mladen Sokele∗ and Vlasta Hudek Department of Telecommunications Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Computing University of Zagreb Unska 3, HR-10000 Zagreb, Croatia ∗
[email protected] Received February 2006 Accepted February 2006 Proper forecast of product market diffusion enables optimal planning of resources, investments, revenue, marketing and sales. Quantitative forecasting methods for this purpose rely on sigmoidal growth models such as logistic growth and Bass model, which are acceptable for the first adoption interval of product life cycle (PLC). Modelling of other PLC segments requires complex models that need large set of input data that limits their application for the forecasting purposes. This paper presents extensions of the logistic growth model that combine the principle of sigmoidal growth and the concept of interpolation splines. In addition, adaptation of the logistic model is shown to be congruent with Bass model. Applications of developed models for the forecasting of PLC segments are analysed and examined, together with possible ways of interaction between different products. Developed models and interaction types enable forecasting of entire PLC with minimum set of input data, or assessment of qualitative forecasting results.
Keywords: PLC, logistic growth model, Bass model, forecasting.
1.
Introduction
During its life cycle, every product or service passes through the following phases: growth, saturation and decline. The understanding and forecasting of 77
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
78
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
each segment of product life cycle (PLC) for the business planning purposes has become more and more important in the competitive market environment and for product/services resulting from emerging technologies, such as telecommunications. Forecasting is important to entrepreneurs and governments, but usually suffers from market fluctuation and uncertainty. The scope of this paper is the development of suitable models for forecasting of market adoption of products/services based on sigmoidal growth models such as logistic growth and Bass model. Focus is on products/services such as: diffusion of new technology, consumer durables, subscription services (e.g., telecom services), allocations of restricted resources, i.e., products/services that not include repeat sales. In the paper, these products/services are simply called products. There is a wide variety of existing methods that are used for the purpose of forecasting of market adoption of products. However, the typical practitioner’s problem: how to bridge the gap between known data and anticipated value in the future, is still dominant and pending due to the lack of reliable input data.
2.
Technological Forecasting — A Literature Review
Many studies have focused on market forecasting from the perspective of technological forecasting, for example, related costs of innovation and learning (e.g., Albright, 2002); competitive intelligence and the innovation process (e.g., Lemos and Porto, 1998); simulation of emerging technologies (e.g., Bers et al., 1999); technology management, technology mapping and innovation indicators (e.g., Zhu and Porter, 2002); technological progress and the technology cycle time indicator (e.g., Kayal, 1999); product/service prelaunch forecasting (e.g., Bass et al., 2001), etc. Comprehensive overviews of models appropriate for technological forecasting and their forecasting performance are made in Meade and Islam (1998) and Fildes and Kumar (2002). The pace of technological progress is a construct that has evolved from technological change theories. Measuring the pace of technological progress is believed to be important for both technology management and technology forecasting. Kayal (1999) developed a new objective measure of the pace of technological progress called the technology cycle time indicator (TCT). The TCT indicator was used in two comparison analyses: (1) assessing the pace of progress of technologies; and (2) assessing the position of various countries patenting in a particular technology field. The findings revealed
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
79
that the TCT provided a valid assessment in each situation. Bass et al. (2001) conducted research to plan the launch of a satellite television product, leading to a prelaunch forecast of subscriptions of satellite television over a five-year horizon. The forecast was based on the Bass model. They derived parameters of the model in part from stated-intentions data from potential consumers and in part from guessing by analogy. The forecast of the adoption and diffusion of satellite television proved to be quite good in comparison with actual subscriptions over the five-year period. Meade and Islam (1998) identified 29 models that the literature suggests are appropriate for technological forecasting. These models are divided into three classes according to the timing of the point of inflexion in the innovation or substitution process. Faced with a given data set and a choice of models, the issue of model selection needs to be addressed. Evidence used to aid model selection was drawn from measures of model fit and model stability. An analysis of the forecasting performance of these models using simulated data sets showed that it is easier to identify a class of possible models rather than the “best” model. This leads to the combining of model forecasts. The performance of the combined forecasts appeared promising with a tendency to outperform the individual models. The observed patterns of product life cycles indicate the “stage” concerns. Such concerns include stage identification, stage-based strategies and, a new concept of “stage modelling” introduced by Chang and Chang (2003). Stage modelling is concerned with modelling as well as aggregating individual stages in an overall inter-influence manner. Thus, stage modelling not only preserves the respective characteristics of the stages but also may be explored for the stage-related strategies. To date, this issue has not yet been explored in the product life cycle (PLC) literature. Chang and Chang proposed an approach to modelling PLCs by addressing the stage characteristicpreserving aspect. The new product diffusion was also demonstrated which was improved by this new approach. Funk (2004) applied the product life cycle theory to the issue of product line management with two goals in mind: (1) to understand how product line management evolves over the life of an industry and (2) to compare modelling approaches which emphasise economies of scale with the traditional model of the product life cycle, which emphasises dominant designs. This author found that some models of the product life cycle theory in combination with the concept of product line management provided a better explanation for the evolution of competition in the mobile phone industry than the traditional product life cycle model. In order to model the market evolution and the resulting changes, the concept
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
80
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
of technological paradigms and the concept of technological regimes were integrated by Werker (2003) into a product life cycle model. The simulations performed with this model helped to understand how the dynamics of market evolution shapes market performance and competition. The results of the simulation runs showed a much more differentiated picture than economic intuition suggests and therefore give useful hints for companies’ strategies and innovation policy. The most striking result of the simulation runs for entrepreneurial strategies was that there were markets that firms would be interested to enter to realise some profits and then exit again, and there were other markets that companies would want to survive in the long-run. The product life cycle theory explains how the high degree of uncertainty, as regards product designs and production methods — which is connected to the early stages of the product life cycle, requires a high level of knowledge-intensity. Since uncertainty decreases over the product life cycle, less knowledge is needed in production during later stages of the product life cycle. This implies that knowledge-intensity differs for firms that exit and enter in different stages of the product life cycle. The empirical results found by Karlsson and Nystrom (2003) showed that entrants in the early stages of the product life are more knowledge-intensive than incumbent companies. These authors have also found that firms exiting in early stages of the product life cycle are more knowledge-intensive than companies exiting in later stages. The best known model for a full description of the genesis and extensions of new-product diffusion is the Bass model. As discussed in Fildes and Kumar (2002), the basic Bass model has many apparent limitations, the most important of which is the calibration of the parameters when limited data are available as is the case with new products. Unfortunately, the parameters of a Bass diffusion model cannot be estimated, either because there are too few data points available or alternatively, unconstrained estimation leads to implausible results. Generalised Bass model incorporates marketing or economic variables, such as pricing and advertising, and expands model usage not only for early phases of the PLC, but also for the phases when product faces the change of its market potential.
3.
Product Life Cycle
A product life cycle closely resembles the profile of the technology life cycle and its associated market-growth profile. According to Khalil (2000),
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
81
30 000
20 000
10 000
2002
2000
1998
1996
1994
1992
1990
1988
1986
1984
1982
1980
1978
1976
0
Figure 1. Number of telex subscribers in Portugal 1976–2003. Source: ITU (2005).
product-market life cycle consists of six phases: Concept design prototype, Product launch, Product growth, Mature stage, Substitution products and Product obsolescence. For example, market adoption of telex service (i.e., number of telex subscribers) in Portugal presented in Figure 1 is bell-shaped. PLC passes phases of introduction (before 1976, not presented in Figure 1), growth, maturity, saturation, and decline due to the strong competition of other similar but more attractive products (fax and e-mail). Market adoption of product is not always so simple. In the case of number of payphones in Finland (Figure 2), market adoption consists of several growth and decline phases. Moreover, the number of payphones will not fade out soon, although it should be a sensible decline. The reason is the universal service regulatory framework for telecommunications. To summarise the above mentioned, a typical product during its life cycle passes through the following specific phases of market adoption, which are also described in Figure 3. T1 — Product is unique and new on the market. Its market capacity M1 is identical to the current total market capacity. T2 — New market opportunities for that product emerge (economical or technological). Its market capacity is increased to M2 .
ch04
FA1
11:53
82
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
30 000
20 000
10 000
2002
2000
1998
1996
1994
1992
1990
1988
1986
1984
1982
0 1980
May 20, 2006
Figure 2. Public pay phones in Finland 1980–2003. Source: ITU (2005).
Figure 3. Typical market adoption of product during entire PLC. N(t) — number of the consumers; Mi — market capacities.
T3 — Product is confronted with competition in unchanged market capacity. T4 — Attack from competitive product(s), which leads to the number of consumers N(t) decreasing. Competitive product can be identical product but offered by other provider, or similar but technologically more advanced product.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
83
Only at the beginning of the PLC, logistic law of growth or the basic Bass model can successfully be applied to represent the product consumer growth. The logistic growth model (other names: Pearl growth curve, Verhulst growth curve) is congruent with the growth of the number of product consumer observed over time in a closed market, without the presence of any other product. Model is defined with three parameters: M — market capacity, a — growth rate parameter, and b — time shift parameter. To emphasise the dependence of the model on its parameters, it is convenient to indicate model as L(M, a, b; t) or shortly L(t): L(M, a, b; t) =
M 1 + e−a(t−b)
(1)
The Bass diffusion model B(M, p, q, ts ; t) of new products is defined with four parameters: M — market capacity, p — coefficient of innovation, q — coefficient of imitation, and ts — time when product is introduced. B(M, p, q, ts ; t) = M
1 − e−(p+q)(t−ts ) q 1 + e−(p+q)(t−ts ) p
(2)
During the whole PLC, market capacity changes in hops and resembles a series of stairs. In a specific time frame, adoption of product follows an S shape curve growth/decline. A particular set of conditions determines market capacity in a specific time frame: product attractiveness, product features, marketing (advertising); product availability (supply); competition (market share); technology improvements; balance between purchase power and product pricing. Due to the complexity of these conditions, the estimation of market capacity and duration of observed time frame, where these conditions are stable, is usually performed by qualitative forecasting methods. Quantitatively, it can be concluded that the adoption dynamics is the composite function compounded of the series of the smoothly joined S-curves. Analysis of a typical market adoption of product during the entire PLC gives the following conclusions: • No single regression model (logistic, Gompertz, Richards, MMF, Weibull and Bass) can describe adoption of product (penetration) in its entire range. • Penetration consists of (sub)curves, i.e., a set of sigmoidal curves. Each curve is modelling one segment.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
84
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
• Transitions between (sub)curves are smooth, i.e., (at least) 1st derivative is preserved. The modelling of the adoption of product during the entire PLC could be done by using the Norton-Bass model or multi-logistic growth function. The Norton-Bass model describes sales of multiple generations of products and it is an extension of the Bass model (1969) on the diffusion of a singlegeneration product. This model deals with the sales of successive generations of products in cases where adopters continue buying the product at a constant rate and buyers of earlier generations gravitate to later generations according to the Bass model cumulative distribution. Modelling of each product generation requires four parameters to be determined. This is similar with the multi-logistic growth (3), which is a composite function consisting of the sum of simple logistic growth models, and requires three parameter per item: ML(t) =
M2 − M1 Mn − Mn−1 M1 + + ··· + −a (t−b ) −a (t−b ) 1 1 2 2 1+e 1+e 1 + e−an (t−bn )
(3)
For illustration, adoption of product described in Figure 3 is decomposed into 4 simple logistic growth models and shown in Figure 4. Modelling with the above mentioned complex functions requires the determination of the values of numerous free parameters, which requires a large set of known data that limits their application to the forecasting purposes.
Figure 4. Multi-logistic function consisting of 4 simple logistic growth models. N(t) — number of the consumers; Mi — market capacities (in increments).
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
4.
85
Interaction between Products in the Market
Only at the beginning of the product life cycle would there be no interaction with other product in terms of market diffusion, therefore its growth may be approximated with simple growth models such as logistic or Bass model. In real cases, interaction between different products is evident, and can be divided into three types: • Product competition — Both products are competing in an unchanged total market capacity. • Product co-evolution — Complementary products change the total market capacity, as a result there is no decrease of existing product penetration. • Product revolution — New attractive product almost completely eliminates the existing one, total market capacity is noticeably increased. The three types of interaction between products are illustrated in Figures 5–7. Corresponding expressions (4)–(12) describe these interaction types numerically. Equations are based on the assumption that the logistic model of growth L(Mi , ai , bi ; t) satisfactorily models the components of product market diffusion.
Figure 5.
Product competition.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
86
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Figure 6.
Figure 7.
Product co-evolution.
Product revolution.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
87
4.1. Product competition Ntot (t) = N1 (t) + N2 (t) = L(Mt , at , bt ; t)
(4)
N2 (t) = L(M2 , a2 , b2 ; t)
(5)
N1 (t) = Ntot (t) − N2 (t) = L(Mt , at , bt ; t) − L(M2 , a2 , b2 ; t)
(6)
4.2. Product co-evolution Ntot (t) = N1 (t) + N2 (t)
(7)
N1 (t) = L(M1 , a1 , b1 ; t)
(8)
N2 (t) = L(M2 , a2 , b2 ; t)
(9)
Ntot (t) = L(M1 , a1 , b1 ; t) + L(M2 − M1 , a2 , b2 ; t)
(10)
N2 (t) = L(M2 , a2 , b2 ; t)
(11)
4.3. Product revolution
N1 (t) = Ntot (t) − N2 (t) = L(M1 , a1 , b1 ; t) + L(M2 − M1 , a2 , b2 ; t) − L(M2 , a2 , b2 ; t)
5.
(12)
Possible Cases for Using Logistic Model of Growth for Forecasting Purposes
In the following five cases from the forecasting praxis, the use of logistic model of growth and its adaptations will be analysed and discussed.
5.1. Case 1 — Extensive set of input data Known: n points, n ≥ 4 (ti , N(ti )), i = 1, 2, . . . , n; ∃tj , tj > b (among them exist at least one point after inflexion). Assumed: No need for assumptions. Parameter determination: Least-squares method — finding the minimum of sum S: 2 n M N(ti ) − (13) S= 1 + e−a(ti −b) i=1
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
88
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Finding the minimum gives the system of three nonlinear equations which lead to determination of parameters M, a and b: ∂S = 0; ∂M
∂S = 0; ∂a
∂S =0 ∂b
(14)
System of equations has no exact analytical solution and for its solution an iterative numerical method should be deployed. Usability: The fit of the model is usually very strong on the whole part of the product life cycle, where product is the only one on the market and can be measured with correlation coefficient R. It is also possible to test (via standard errors and t-ratios) confidence of the resulting parameter estimates. But, due to the fact that extensive set of data have to be already known, Case 1 has low usability for the practical forecasting purposes. However, it would be useful for an accurate determination of market capacity and product diffusion dynamics — for the forecasting by analogy of a subsequent product.
5.2. Case 2 — Sufficient set of input data with assumed market capacity Known: n points, n ≥ 3 (ti , N(ti )), i = 1, 2, . . . , n. Assumed: Market capacity Ma (index a stands for assumed). Ma is usually estimated by market research and/or market segmentation techniques. Parameter determination: Least-squares method — finding the minimum of sum S: 2 n Ma N(ti ) − (15) S= 1 + e−a(ti −b) i=1 Finding the minimum gives two nonlinear equations which leads to the determination of parameters a and b: ∂S = 0; ∂a
∂S =0 ∂b
(16)
These equations have no exact analytical solution and for their solution an iterative numerical method should be deployed. Usability: Suitable for wide-ranging forecasting purposes (for new products that are similar with previous ones on the same market; or for new products, which are identical to existing ones on comparable markets). The fit of the model can be measured with correlation coefficient as well as the confidence of the resulting parameter estimates.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
89
5.3. Case 3 — Minimum set of input data Known: 3 points, (ti , N(ti )), i = 1, 2, 3. Assumed: No assumptions. Parameter determination: System of three nonlinear equations which leads to determination of parameters M, a and b: M , i = 1, 2, 3 (17) 1 + e−a(ti −b) The system has no exact analytical solution and an iterative numerical method should be deployed. Usability: Values of obtained parameters are uncertain (i.e., their confidence could not be tested), but it has application for the forecasting purposes, when market capacity is difficult to obtain from other sources or for non-long range forecasting. N(ti ) =
5.4. Case 4 — Assumed market capacity and only two known points Known: 2 points, (ti , N(ti )), i = 1, 2. Assumed: Ma market capacity. Parameter determination: System of two nonlinear equations which has exact analytical solution for parameters a and b: Ma Ma 1 ln − 1 − ln −1 (18) a= t2 − t1 N(t1 ) N(t2 ) Ma 1 −1 (19) b = t1 + ln a N(t1 ) Usability: Similar to Case 2 — regularly used for forecasting when little data are available. Values of obtained parameters a and b are uncertain, but assumed market capacity Ma can be relatively good estimate for market research and/or market segmentation techniques, which improves accuracy.
5.5. Case 5 — Assumed market capacity and characteristic duration Known: ts — time when product has perceptible penetration, u — level of perceptible penetration (product introduction on market, start) and v (product maturity) — level of saturation. Values for levels u and v are conventional and are usually symmetric, i.e., u = 1 − v. Generally accepted values for u are 5% or 10% and for v, 95% or 90%, respectively. Condition that should be satisfied is 0 < u < v < 1.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
90
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Figure 8. Logistic model of growth defined via time when product observable starts ts , characteristic duration t and penetration levels u and v.
Assumed: Ma market capacity and characteristic duration t. Characteristic duration is the time interval from ts to product maturity time te = ts + t, see Figure 8. Parameter substitution: Parameters a and b in (1) should be replaced with expressions (20) and (21), which are dependant on input parameters u and v: 1 1 1 ln − 1 − ln −1 (20) a= t u v 1 −1 ln u b = ts + t (21) 1 1 − 1 − ln −1 ln u v Modified logistic model needs five parameters (M, ts , t, u and v) against three needed for ordinary logistic model, but the reason lays in dependence between t and u and v. In case of symmetrical u and v, i.e., u = 1 − v, the equations become more simple: 1 2 ln −1 (22) a= t u t b = ts + (23) 2
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model Table 1.
t = 2 yearsa t = 5 yearsb t = 10 yearsc t = 15 yearsc
91
A framework for forecasting of new services/products prior to launch. u = 5%, u = 95% M N(t) = 1 + e−2.944(t−ts −1) M N(t) = 1 + e−1.178(t−ts −2.5) M N(t) = 1 + e−0.589(t−ts −5) M N(t) = 1 + e−0.393(t−ts −7.5)
u = 10%, v = 90% M N(t) = 1 + e−2.197(t−ts −1) M N(t) = 1 + e−0.879(t−ts −2.5) M N(t) = 1 + e−0.439(t−ts −5) M N(t) = 1 + e−0.293(t−ts −7.5)
a Adjusted
according to Modis (1998). Products consist of units sold that have typical life cycle of six to ten quarters. b Product families consist of related products that have a typical business cycle of five years. c Basic technologies consist of a set of related product families that have a typical cycle of ten to 15 years.
Therefore this model needs four parameters (M, ts , t and u) against three needed for ordinary logistic model, because of dependence between t and u: M (24) L(M, ts , t, u; t) = 1−2(t−ts )/t 1 −1 1+ u Used simplification gives a framework for the forecasting of new product diffusion when little or no data are available. Table 1 presents resulting models for typical values of characteristic duration t for products, product families and basic technologies according to Equation (24) but uniformed on the same natural logarithm base e. Usability: Regularly used for forecasting of new product diffusion when little or no data are available. In cases of product diffusion forecasting prior to product launch, a pair characteristic duration — level of saturation for product maturity is assumed by means of analogy with existing products.
6.
Deficiency of Logistic Model of Growth — Linear Transformed Logistic Model
Although the logistic model is widely used for the forecasting purposes, it is not suitable for modelling product diffusion when the number of consumers grows at a fast pace immediately after product is introduced. The reason is in the shape of the logistic growth: “hardly starts to grow up”. This problem is visible from the discussion of Case 5: it is not possible to model time
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
92
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
when product is introduced, and its penetration is 0 (i.e., u = 0), because Equation (20) will give an infinity value for parameter a. Therefore, in Case 5, when product starts ts , it is anticipated that it has perceptible penetration u, which is higher than 0. One of the possible solutions is to perform linear transformation of the logistic model, in the way that in time ts penetration is 0. Starting from the basic logistic model (Figure 8), the idea of above mentioned linear transformation is described on Figures 9 and 10.
Figure 9. Linear transformation of logistic model — shifting on y-axis.
Figure 10. Linear transformation of logistic model — stretching to M.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
93
If subtraction of L(ts ) = u · M from L(t) is made, the obtained model is shifted on the y-axis, so penetration for t = ts is 0, as it was required. However, asymptotic value for t → ∞ is not M (market capacity), but (1 − u) · M, see Figure 9. Therefore, multiplication by 1/(1 − u) will stretch the model in a way that asymptotic value for t → ∞ will be M, as required, see Figure 10. Obtained model LTL(t) is linear transformed logistic model L(t): LTL(t) =
M [L(t) − L(ts )] M − L(ts )
(25)
With the following characteristics: LTL(ts ) = 0 lim LTL(t) = M
t→∞
u M M · L(ts ) =− M = − −a(t −b) M − L(ts ) 1−u e s M v−u M =w·M LTL(te ) = [L(te ) − L(ts )] = M − L(ts ) 1−u lim LTL(t) = −
t→−∞
(26)
Where w, 0 < w < 1 represents a level of saturation in time te (product maturity) in linear transformed logistic model LTL(t). As a difference with logistic model defined with three parameters M, a and b, LTL(t) needs additional parameter which is the consequence of y-axis shift L(ts ) for its full definition. Since L(ts ) = u · M, 0 < u < 1 on which depends growth gradient in ts , u should be used as an additional parameter. According to this, the linear transformed logistic model LTL(M, a, b, u; t) has the following analytical form: M 1 LTL(M, a, b, u; t) = −u 1 − u 1 + e−a(t−b)
(27)
Model LTL(M, a, b, u; t) is fully defined with four points (ti , N(ti )), i = 1, 2, . . . , 4 that are the basis for the system of four nonlinear equations. Their solution gives values of parameters M, a, b and u. For forecasting purposes, the modified LTL model LTL(M, ts , t, u, w; t) is more convenient where parameters are: market capacity M, product start time ts , characteristic duration t, parameter u, (see Figure 11) and w is the level of saturation in time te = ts + t. At first sight, it seems that the modified LTL model needs one more parameter, five instead of four, but the reason lays again in the dependence between t and w.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
94
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Figure 11. Example of linear transformed logistic model for different values for u with fixed M = 50 000, ts = 2005, t = 10 years and w = 80%.
Following the definition of parameters a and b in (27) through ts , t, u and w, model LTL(M, ts , t, u, w; t) becomes fully defined: 1 1 1 a= ln − 1 − ln −1 t u w + u(1 − w) 1 −1 ln u b = ts + t 1 1 − 1 − ln −1 ln u w + u(1 − w)
(28)
(29)
It is interesting that expressions (28) and (29) allows u > w (see Figure 11, u = 90%) which has no practical explanation.
7.
Forms of Linear Transformed Logistic Model of Growth — Introduction of Logistic Spline
Denoting the value for LTL(t) when t → −∞ as c, expression for L(ts ) is obtained: lim LTL(t) = −
t→−∞
M · L(ts ) =c M − L(ts )
⇒
L(ts ) = −
cM M−c
(30)
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
95
By putting substitution for L(ts ) in expression (25) for LTL(t) model, new form for LTL(t) is obtained: cM M−c c M L(t) + = L(t) + LTL(t) = cM M−c M M−c M + M−c M−c M−c L(t) + c = +c (31) M 1 + e−a(t−b) This form of LTL(t) is called logistic spline LS(t) and it is defined by four parameters M, a, b and c: =
M−c +c (32) 1 + e−a(t−b) Relation between parameters of linear transformed logistic model and logistic spline is: LS(M, a, b, c; t) =
LTL(M, a, b, u; t) ≡ LS(M, a, b, c; t) ⇔ c ; or c−M u·M c= u−1 1 M − u LTL(M, a, b, u; t) = 1 − u 1 + e−a(t−b) u=
(33)
(34)
Continuing with applying substitutions, now by extracting c from (32) utilising the fact that here are LTL(ts ) = LS(ts ) = 0: c=−
LS(t) =
M+
M
1 + e−a(t−b) 1 + e−a(ts −b) − e−a(ts −b) = M 1 + e−a(t−b)
M
M e−a(ts −b) − 1 + e−a(t−b) e−a(ts −b)
(35)
e−a(ts −b) 1
e−a(t−b) 1 − e−a(t−ts ) e−a(ts −b) = M =M 1 + e−a(t−b) 1 + e−a(ts −b) · e−a(t−ts ) Progressing with substitutions: 1−
(36)
p+q = a q = e−a(ts −b) p
(37)
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
96
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
We get well known Bass model: B(t) = M
1 − e−(p+q)(t−ts ) 1 + qp · e−(p+q)(t−ts )
(38)
This is the proof that linear transformed logistic model LTL(t) [or logistic spline LS(t)] is identical to Bass model B(t). Here are the set of equations that establish full link between of logistic spline LS(M, a, b, c; t) and Bass model B(M, p, q, ts ; t): LS(M, a, b, c; t) ≡ B(M, p, q, ts ; t) ⇔ aM M 1 ac p= , q=− , ts = b − ln − ; or c−M c−M a c q 1 p a = p + q, b = ts + ln , c=− M p+q p q
(39)
(40)
It is emphasised that the Bass model is obtained here by linear transformation of simple logistic model. The Bass model became famous because of introducing the coefficient of innovation (p), that corrected the deficiency of the simple logistic growth (the “hardly starts to grow up” problem), and its form is resulted from the solution of specific (Bass) differential equations. Now, it is shown here of its congruence with and genesis from simple logistic growth! Note: The Bass model in form (38) requires that p and q have the same sign (p > 0 and q > 0, or p < 0 and q < 0) as seen from the equation for b (40). This has the consequence that c yielded from the Bass model must be c < 0 (40). Although the logistic spline model is identical to the Bass model, it has no limitation on c, so spline can be unrestrictedly shifted on y-axis depending on the case.
8.
Conditions for Using Logistic Splines Model for the Forecasting Purposes
Composite regression models that can represent the adoption of product over the whole PLC need extensive sets of observations, which makes their use for practical forecasting purposes very difficult. This obstacle forces the change of our expectations — what can be obtained from PLC modelling for the forecasting purposes. The consequence could be a shift from dealing with historical data to dealing with future. On the other hand, an insufficient set of input historical data cannot provide confidence measure of forecasting
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
97
results. It will be shown that the minimum set of input data consisted of: • • • •
the last known data point N(ts ); the gradient in the last known data point N (ts ); assumed market capacity M in observed time interval t ∈ [ts , te ]; assumed number of consumers at the end of the observed time interval N(te ).
And they could provide us forecasting results and certain measure of confidence. By combining the principle of logistic growth (adoption curve is consisted of a set of S curves) similarity with splines gives the idea about a new interpolation method — logistic splines. Regular spline functions are used for the interpolation purposes, but originally they were strips of elastic material used to draw smooth curves through a given set of points. The most common type of spline is the cubic spline, which is formed by joining polynomials of third degree together at fixed points called knots. Cubic spline curve fitting ensures that each spline is equal to the data points, the 1st derivatives are continuous at the knots, and the 2nd derivatives are continuous at the knots. It is expected that logistic splines ensure forecasting of adoption dynamics during the whole-observed time interval [ts , te ] where monotone growth (logistic spline — Type-1) or monotone decline (logistic spline — Type-2) is anticipated. In continuation, it will be shown that the concept of logistic splines could be used for testing of consistency of assumptions with known data, too. Logistic spline is the function LS(t) that smoothly joins the latest (known) data about the number of consumers N(ts ) with the assumed number of consumers N(te ), and locally has a form of logistic law of growth — Figures 12 and 13. Function LS(t) has the form given in (32). Unknown parameters a, b and c can be calculated from conditions: • starting point of the logistic spline is identical to the latest known data (41); • last point of a logistic spline is identical to the (given) assumed value N(te ) (42); • logistic spline smoothly extends the existing data (43). N(ts ) = LS(ts )
(41)
N(te ) = LS(te )
(42)
N (ts ) = LS (ts )
(43)
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
98
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Figure 12. Logistic spline — growing (Type-1).
Figure 13. Logistic spline — declining (Type-2).
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
99
Derivation N (ts ) cannot be determined analytically, only by numerical calculation and/or the data are not accurate enough, i.e., they usually contain a certain level of noise (seasonal and sales campaign fluctuations), so the condition (43) should be modified to finding the minimum:
2 (44) min N (ts ) − LS (ts ) Froms (41) and (42), expressions (46) and (47) for a and b can be obtained, with parameter c as a dependant variable. Parameter c cannot be achieved analytically, however iterative minimisation of F(c) using golden section is a suitable procedure for obtaining parameter c (45): 2
2 a · (M − c) · e−a(ts −b) (45) F(c) = N (ts ) − LS (ts ) = N (ts ) − 2 1 + e−a(ts −b) The procedure is as follows: (1) Choose the interval which lays possible values for c, cmin ≤ c ≤ cmax (which will be discussed later, in detail). (2) Take c1 = cmin and c4 = cmax . (3) Calculate two inside values for c, c2 = c4 − φ(c4 − c1 ) and c3 = c1 + φ(c4 − c1 ) according to golden section minimisation procedure, where φ is golden section ratio (φ = 0.618 . . . ). (4) Calculate F(ci ), i = 1, 2, 3, 4 using the following equations for ai and bi : M − N(ts ) N(te ) − ci 1 · ai = ln (46) te − ts M − N(te ) N(ts ) − ci M − N(te ) 1 (47) bi = te + ln a N(te ) − ci (5) According to calculated values for F(ci ), i = 1, 2, 3, 4 decision is made about narrowing interval for c from [c1 , c4 ] to [c1 , c3 ] or [c2 , c4 ]. Golden section minimisation procedure is repeated from the 3rd phase to 5th phase until resulting interval for c becomes satisfactory narrow. In practical applications, number of iterations is around 40 or less. As stated before, there are two types of logistic spline: • logistic spline grows, iff N (ts ) > 0 and N(ts ) < N(te ) < M (as in Figure 12); and • logistic spline declines, iff N (ts ) < 0 and N(ts ) > N(te ) > M, (as in Figure 13).
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
100
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
The model (32) can satisfy conditions (41) and (42) only if c < N(ts ) for the Type-1, and if the c > N(ts ) for the Type-2 of logistic spline. If the mentioned conditions for c are fulfilled, Equations (46) and (47) have solutions. These conditions on c reflect on the determination of the interval which should lay possible values for c, cmin ≤ c ≤ cmax in the beginning of minimising F(c): • Type-1, initial interval is c ∈ (−∞, N(ts )) since c < N(ts ) < N(te ) < M, but in practical applications (−10 · M, N(ts )) is a satisfactory large initial interval for c. • Type-2, initial interval is c ∈ (N(ts ), +∞) since M < N(te ) < N(ts ) < c, but in practical applications (N(ts ), +10 · M) is a satisfactory large initial interval for c. In an ideal set of circumstances, the result of minimisation should be parameters a, b and c, thus LS (ts ) = N (ts ). Logistic splines cannot satisfy Equation (43) if N (ts ) is too high — for Type-1, or too low — for Type-2, which will be discussed in the following section.
9.
Limits of Logistic Splines
From equation for LS (t) it is possible to find interval where its value lays, depending on c, N(ts ), N(te ) and M. The first step is transforming expression for LS (t) in form without a and b parameters: LS (ts ) =
a · (M − c) · e−a(ts −b)
2 1 + e−a(ts −b)
(48)
(M − c) +c 1 + e−a(ts −b)
(49)
From: LS(ts ) = follows: (M − c)2
[LS(ts ) − c]2 = [N(ts ) − c]2 =
1 + e−a(ts −b)
2
(50)
and e−a(ts −b) =
M−c −1 N(ts ) − c
(51)
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
101
By putting Equation (46) for a, we get expression for LS (ts ), depending only on c, N(ts ), N(te ) and M, which is suitable for further analysis: 1 M − N(ts ) N(te ) − ci [N(ts ) − c] · [M − N(ts )] · · ln LS (ts ) = te − ts M − N(te ) N(ts ) − ci M−c (52) In case of logistic spline Type-1, LS (ts ) lays in range (53). It moves towards 0 when c approaches N(ts ) and move towards its upper limit for c → −∞. M − N(ts ) M − N(ts ) (53) ln 0 < LS (ts ) < te − t s M − N(te ) In case of logistic spline Type-2, LS (ts ) lays in range (54). It moves towards 0 when c approaches N(ts ) and move towards its lower limit for c → +∞. M − N(ts ) M − N(ts ) ln (54) < LS (ts ) < 0 te − t s M − N(te ) Described restricted ranges for possible values of LS (ts ) have, for the forecasting purposes, the following consequence: depending on known values for N(ts ) and N (ts ), and assumed values of M and N(te ), in case of unfulfilled conditions (53, 54), logistic spline cannot smoothly bridge the gap between known data and anticipated value in the future. Unsmooth joint of the logistic spline represents a warning to a forecaster that input assumptions are inadequate, such as: • Predicted values for M and/or N(te ) are wrong. Namely, values for M and N(te ) in forecasting practice are obtained usually as a result of qualitative forecasting, which can be now assessed by logistic spline concept. • Interval [ts , te ] is consisted of more than one sigmoidal curve (example in Figure 14). Examples of unsmooth joint of the logistic spline is shown in Figure 14, while a proper (smooth) joint is shown in Figure 15.
10.
Example of Forecasting by Logistic Splines
Application of logistic splines1 is shown in the example of expired analogue mobile service in Croatia (NMT-450). The service started in 1991 very slowly 1 Additional
information about usage of logistic splines and LOgistic Spline Trend (LOST) program tool can be found in http://lost-a.notlong.com.
ch04
FA1
11:53
102
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
100%
80%
60%
Derivative window 40%
20%
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
0%
Figure 14. Example of unsmooth joint of the logistic spline (screen shoot from LOST-A program). 100%
80%
60%
Derivative window 40%
20%
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
0% 1991
May 20, 2006
Figure 15. Example of proper (smooth) join of the logistic spline (screen shoot from LOST-A program).
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
103
because of high prices of service and mobile handsets. In the period from 1994 to 1997 it had significant growth. In 1998, the service was seriously confronted by new GSM service, and went into saturation. As a counterattack, NMT operator decreased service price (cost of call per minute) on the level of approximately 15% of GSM service price. This attempt was shortlived because GSM operators offered a pre-paid system of payment and cheap mobile handsets. As a result, the number of NMT users continued to decline. NMT service in Croatia went extinct in Q2 2005. Two different phases of the product life cycle of NMT will be examined by logistic splines for forecasting purposes: growth (Figure 16) and decline (Figure 17) phase. Given information are: number of users of the NMT-450 service from the EOY 1991 till EOY 2004. Logistic spline Type-1 (Figure 16) is used in forecast time interval from ts = 1995 to te = 1997. Values for N(ts − 1) and N(ts ) are taken as known, and assumed are values for M and N(te ). From N(1994) and N(1995), N (1995) is obtained. Forecasting results are checked with real data in period from 1995 to 1998. Standard statistical measure — MAPE (mean absolute percentage error) is used for this purpose (55). 1 LS(t) − N(t) · 100% MAPE = n t N(t)
(55)
Known: ts = 1995 N(ts-1) = 21 664 N(ts) = 32 948 Chosen end time te = 1997 Assumptions: M = 70 300 N(te) = 64 189 Resulting logistic spline: M = 70 300, a = 1.440, b = 1995.6, c = 16 629 Forecast: Time interval 1995-1998 MAPE = 0.244 %
Figure 16. Growth of analogue mobile service in Croatia (logistic spline Type-1).
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
104
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Known: ts = 2000 N(ts-1) = 85 130 N(ts) = 73 292 Chosen end time te = 2004 Assumptions: M=0 N(te) = 5 000 Resulting logistic spline: M = 0, a = 1.042, b = 2001.24, c = 93 347 Forecast: Time interval 2000-2004 MAPE = 3.78 %
Figure 17. Expiring analogue mobile service in Croatia (logistic spline Type-2).
Table 2. Forecasting results for logistic spline Type-1 (LS-1) and Type-2 (LS-2). t [year] 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
N(t) 1 669 6 320 11 239 21 664 32 948 51 857 64 189 68 987 85 130 73 292 56 600 27 000 13 400 5 000
LS-1(t) 16 704 16 940 17 914 21 664 32 948 51 428 64 189 68 714 69 916 70 208 70 278 70 295 70 299 70 300
LS-2(t) 93 346 93 342 93 330 93 299 93 208 92 954 92 240 90 274 85 130 73 292 52 570 29 181 12 905 5 000
Logistic spline Type-2 (Figure 17) is used in forecast time interval from ts = 2000 to te = 2004. Again, values for N(ts − 1) and N(ts ) are taken as known, and assumed are values for M and N(te ). From N(1999) and N(2000), N (2000) is obtained. Forecasting results are checked with real data in this period by MAPE. Results of forecasting are presented in Table 2, and values for calculated parameters are shown in Figures 16 and 17.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Extensions of Logistic Growth Model
11.
105
Conclusion
The extensions of the logistic growth model for forecasting purposes are developed, analysed and discussed. Specific linear transformation of the logistic model is shown to be identical to the well-known Bass model. In cases with minimum set of input data, the logistic spline model is proposed for the forecasting of product life cycle segments with monotone growth or decline, or assessment of qualitative forecasting results. Whole product life cycle modelling, that includes combination of growth and decline, should be achieved combining logistic splines and sigmoidal envelopes described within interaction between products on market section.
References Albright, R. E. (2002). What can past technology forecasts tell us about the future?. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 69(5), 443–464. Bass, F., K. Gordon, T. L. Ferguson and M. L. Githens (2001). DIRECTV: Forecasting diffusion of a new technology prior to product launch. Interfaces, 31(3), S82–S93. Bass, P. I. and F. M. Bass (2001). Diffusion of technology generations: A model of adoption and repeat sales. Working paper, Bass Economics. Bers, J. A., B. S. Lynn and C. Spurling (1999). Acomputer simulation model for emerging technology business planning and forecasting. International Journal of Technology Management, 18(1–2), 31–45. Chang, P. T. and C. H. Chang (2003). A stage characteristic — Preserving product life cycle modelling. Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 37(12–13), 1259–1269. Fildes, R. and V. Kumar (2002). Telecommunications demand forecasting — A review. International Journal of Forecasting, 18(2002), 489–522. Funk, J. L. (2004). The product life cycle theory and product line management: The case of mobile phones. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 51(2), 142–152. ITU (2005). World Telecommunication Indicators Database 1960–2004. Geneva: International Telecommunication Union. Karlsson, C. and K. Nystrom (2003). Exit and entry over the product life cycle: Evidence from the Swedish manufacturing industry. Small Business Economics, 21(2), 135–144. Kayal, A. (1999). Measuring the pace of technological progress: Implications for technological forecasting. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 60(3), 237–245. Khalil, T. (2000). Management of Technology: The Key to Competitiveness and Wealth Creation. Boston: McGraw-Hill.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
106
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
M. Sokele & V. Hudek
Lemos, A. D. and A. C. Porto (1998). Technological forecasting techniques and competitive intelligence: Tools for improving the innovation process. Industrial Management and Data Systems, 98(7–8), 330–337. Meade, N. and T. Islam (1998). Technological forecasting model selection, model stability, and combined models. Management Science, 44(8), 1115–1130. Modis, T. (1998). Conquering Uncertainty: Understanding Corporate Cycles and Positioning Your Company to Survive the Changing Environment. New York: McGraw-Hill. Werker, C. (2003). Innovation, market performance, and competition: Lessons from a product life cycle model. Technovation, 23(4), 281–290. Zhu, D. H. and A. L. Porter (2002). Automated extraction and visualisation of information for technological intelligence and forecasting, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 69(5), 495–506.
ch04
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
5 DEFENSIVE STRATEGIES AND CONSUMERS’ BOUNDED RATIONALITY: AN ARTIFICIAL MARKET SIMULATION Josef A. Mazanec Institute for Tourism and Leisure Studies Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration Augasse 2-6, A-1090 Vienna, Austria
[email protected]
Ulrike Schuster and Jürgen Wöckl Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration Austria Received July 2004 Accepted October 2005 Twenty years after the Defender model, it is tempting to explore new ways of exposing defensive strategy recommendations to varying market conditions. This experiment analyses the consequences of changes in three factors: (1) a consumer population pursuing noncompensatory brand choice rules; (2) distinctive versus indistinctive (nonsegmented) preference structures; and (3) low versus high responsiveness to advertising. The consumers’ response is simulated on an Artificial Consumer Market (ACM). The ACM assists in constructing the surface of the incumbent’s profit function under a fixed-entry scenario and for experimentally varied market characteristics. The expected influences of consumers’ noncompensatory choice rules on defensive strategy is clearly demonstrated. A defensive reaction by increasing the advertising budget is recommended for most of the market scenarios. A price reduction is required for all but one immature (nonsegmented) market. A price increase pushes the incumbent’s profit in all except one of the distinct-preferences scenarios; quite remarkably, this most amazing of the original game-theoretic results from the Defender model
107
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
108
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
J. A. Mazanec, U. Schuster & J. Wöckl receives new support from findings gained with the completely different methodology of agent-based simulation.
Keywords: Defensive strategy models, micro simulation.
1.
Introduction
As demonstrated by the literature survey in the next section the strategy recommendations derived from the Defender model (Hauser and Shugan, 1983) are notably robust. Twenty years later, it is tempting to expose defensive strategy models to variations of market conditions more fundamental than those explored so far. But there is a price to pay. Such models may no longer be analytically tractable and lose their property of a game-theoretic exercise. Computer simulation methodology will have to be applied instead. Micro simulation models date back to the 1960s and 1970s (Topritzhofer, 1974). From a contemporary perspective the early attempts to mimic consumer market phenomena by computer simulation were bound to fail. The all-encompassing simulation models (Nicosia, 1966; Amstutz, 1967; Lavington, 1970; Klenger and Krautter, 1972) were over-ambitious as they did not focus on a reasonably sized and manageable sector of market reality. As a consequence the simulation model builders were forced to introduce many ad hoc parameters making them unable of unambiguously tracing back the model output. Unfortunately, there is an inverse relationship between model complexity and interpretability of the results (Mazanec, 1978, p. 32; Rangaswamy, 1993, p. 744). The situation was characterised by Ehrenberg (1968) in a JMR review of Nicosia (1966): “The book illustrates the modern model-builders syndrome of falling over himself by trying to run before he can walk.” The defensive strategy models since the Defender model have followed a different view seeking non-critical abstraction and parameter parsimony. The analyst, whether relying on game theory or computer simulation, faces the problem of deciding on where abstraction and simplification threaten to destroy the homomorphic relation between the market reality and the model. In other words, there is a representation threshold. This experiment tries to respect this threshold while analysing the consequences of three experimentally varied factors (i.e., consumers’ decision rules, distinctness of preferences, advertising response) for a simplified mix of marketing instruments (advertising and price). The article starts with a review of defensive strategy findings, then introduces the extensions and limitations assumed for
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Defensive Strategies and Consumers’ Bounded Rationality
109
this experiment, adds more information about the simulation environment, proceeds with constructing smooth surfaces of the profit functions, comments on the results, and draws conclusions on how to continue the series of experiments.
2.
The Defender Model and its Descendants: A Review of Findings
The Defender model developed by Hauser and Shugan (1983) triggered off a series of articles dealing with the elaboration of optimal defensive strategies for firms facing a new competitor entering the market. Over the last 20 years, the Defender model has been extended by relaxing assumptions and exploring the ensuing profit-maximal strategies. The contributions to the Defender research tradition assume a mature market settled in a Nash equilibrium. After the new competitor has entered the market a new equilibrium is sought. This implies that the firms must have followed their optimal strategies not only after but also before a new entry. They change prices and their marketing expenditures for advertising and distribution to defend their competitive position. In some investigations they are allowed to change their brand position in the perceptual space too. The optimisation task is performed stepwise; first the optimal prices are determined then the marketing expenditure is optimised given the prices. The main focus has been on those brands adjacent to the new entrant. The rest of the firms are considered to be only marginally affected and, therefore, assumed to show no competitive reaction but maintain their past strategies. The firms are profit maximisers and act rationally. The entry position is assumed to be fixed exogenously and is known to all brands. The customers seek to maximise utility and choose the product nearest to their ideal point, where choice usually is deterministic. Hauser and Shugan (1983) employ a utility function which is linear in the price-scaled product features. In most of the suggested models only two product features are considered. Kumar and Sudharshan (1988) used a Cobb-Douglas utility function where the product features are not price-scaled and ADBUDG functions for modelling the response to advertising and distribution. Advertising and distribution response functions are always concave, but may be coupled or decoupled. The price strategy is independent of the advertising and distribution expenditures. A firm’s marketing spending has no effect on the sales of any other brand. Since Gruca et al. (1992), only coupled response functions have been
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
110
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
J. A. Mazanec, U. Schuster & J. Wöckl
considered in all subsequent investigations. When coupled response functions are introduced, lower and upper bounds for price and marketing expenditure are required to guarantee the existence of a Nash equilibrium. Usually prices must be greater than or equal to the marginal costs and lower than or equal to the market reservation price. Advertising and distribution expenditures are assumed to be greater than or equal to a predetermined minimum and also an upper bound is fixed. All defensive strategy articles reviewed here formulate market share models which are used in the profit maximisation function. Under the coupled response functions multiplicative attraction models are applied, such as MCI models in Gruca et al. (1992), or MNL models in Basuroy and Nguyen (1998). This means that the elements of the marketing mix are allowed to interact. For the attraction models the brands are assumed to be symmetric exhibiting equal attraction coefficients. Until Gruca et al. (2001), a continuous distribution of demand was assumed. Then, for the first time, the influence of segmentation was investigated by defining a discrete preference distribution. The consumers’ preferences were assumed to remain constant over time. The authors work with segment-specific ideal points representing the average ideal points of all segment members. The utility follows from the distance between the brand position and the segment ideal point and from the size of the segment’s choice set. Considering probabilistic choices made by the customers it is not only the product closest to the individual ideal combination of features that may enter the buyer’s choice set. The optimal defensive strategies of the Defender model by Hauser and Shugan (1983) proved to be remarkably robust under varied assumptions. If the market size does not change, the profits of any brand in the market will always decrease in the course of a new entry. For an optimal strategy a price reduction and a decrease in advertising and/or distribution expenditure is suggested. If the market is highly segmented and the entrant attacks one of the incumbent’s segments the price should be increased. Also, if one accounts for weakly threatened market participants, the brands far away from the entrant should raise their prices (e.g., in Gruca et al., 2001). Gruca et al. (1992) considered dominant brands (with a market share exceeding 50%) and non-dominant brands separately, as in markets with coupled response functions the optimal reaction is affected by the relative market share. The Defender results were confirmed for coupled response functions and non-dominant brands. Dominant brands, however, should
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Defensive Strategies and Consumers’ Bounded Rationality
111
raise their advertising expenditures, unless they risk losing their dominance as a consequence of the new entry. For a market growing in volume an increase in the advertising and/or distribution spending can be optimal provided that the market growth is strong enough (Kumar and Sudharshan, 1988; Basuroy and Nguyen, 1998). Under a constant market volume, both for decoupled and coupled response functions, it is advisable to cut prices, particularly for the brand nearest to the new entrant. However, if the market is highly segmented or, if the incumbent is dominant, a price increase is recommended. Similarly, brands far away from the entrant’s position should increase their prices. In general, a growing market demands an increase in marketing spending. But, depending on the market growth rate, the presence of a new competitor may call for a reduction of the advertising budget. According to the results available so far the strategy recommendations concerning the marketing effort in expanding markets are ambiguous (Kumar and Sudharshan, 1988; Basuroy and Nguyen, 1998).
3.
Simulation Models and the Agent-Based Framework
Despite the long tradition of simulation models in economics and management science their epistemological foundations are still poorly understood. While simulation models provide access to many ambitious research questions the problems of validation often lack an in-depth treatment. The issue of validation has been discussed more actively in other fields than management science. In economics, for example, there is a rich tradition of philosophical arguments and also a new thread of literature on the justification of simulation methodology. Recent examples are provided by the researchers of the Evolutionary Economics Unit at the Max Planck Institute who use simulation methods for modelling learning processes (Brenner, 1999). Other researchers considering simulation models as miniature theories resort to views expressed by philosophers such as Popper, Kuhn or Lakatos and seek to formulate validation criteria from positivist and even hermeneutic perspectives (Kleindorfer et al., 1998; Kleijnen, 1993; Ostrom, 1988). The epistemological status of models simulating social systems has been thoroughly discussed by Troitzsch (1996, 1999). This author relates simulation modelling to the “non-statement view” of theories originally introduced into the philosophy of science by Sneed (1971) and further propagated by Stegmüller (1973; for an early appraisal in consumer behaviour theory, see
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
112
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
J. A. Mazanec, U. Schuster & J. Wöckl
Mazanec, 1978). In this structuralist interpretation a computer simulation programme is regarded as “a complete model of its theory” (Troitzsch, 1999). In simple words, the “non-statement view” does not consider a theory as a falsifiable entity (Stegmüller, 1973). However, a set of “intended applications” is part of each theory and it remains an empirical question whether one such application belongs to this set or not. To model systems with a high degree of interactions between different and partly or fully autonomous subsystems an agent-based simulation approach is preferable. This approach is particularly suited for modelling dynamic behaviours of decision making and learning in an organisation of agents (Hatakama and Terano, 1997; Beyer and Smieja, 1996; Meyer et al., 2003). The most widely known projects on simulating the behaviour of economic and social agents originate from the Santa Fe Institute (http://www.santafe.edu/). Recent agent-based approaches to studying typical management science issues have tackled problems of innovation and new product planning, segmentation and positioning strategy, or advertising budgeting (Natter et al., 2001; Bauer et al., 2003; Schuster and Wöckl, 2005). In agent-based simulation a “model” may range between the two extremes of a “reference model” mimicking the behaviours of real objects and a “virtual world” claiming no analogy to real systems (see the discussion at the Agent-based Simulation 5 Workshop 2004, http://www.scseurope.org/conf/abs2004/agent_sciences.html). The epistemological value judgments underlying the following simulation experiment are cautious and modest. The Artificial Consumer Market underlying the simulation is thought to be “realistic” in terms of consumers’ decision rules and perceptual dynamics through advertising-induced learning. These are crucial aspects of bounded rationality where the simulation environment may approximate real consumer “agents” more closely than their utility-maximising counterparts of the choice modelling tradition. Nevertheless, there is no claim of emulating a particular real market. Hence, the statements of theoretical guidance are not called “hypotheses” but “propositions”. If they get confirmed by the simulation results the empirical researcher receives strong motivation for pursuing the same hypotheses about the profit consequences of the defensive strategies in real product classes and markets exhibiting the perceptual and preferential characteristics similar to the experimental scenarios. The candidates that come to mind immediately are classes of technologically indistinguishable brands where the marketing strategy rests on emotions-based and advertising-driven differentiation.
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Defensive Strategies and Consumers’ Bounded Rationality
4.
113
An Artificial Consumer Market to Accommodate Boundedly Rational Behaviour
4.1. Differences compared to previous defensive strategy models This section addresses the changes made in comparison with the preceding models of the Defender research tradition. One of the assumptions not yet relaxed in previous defensive strategy models relates to the consumer decision rule. This study analyses the consequences of a noncompensatory cognitive algebra. According to Gilbride and Allenby (2004) who employed Markov Chain Monte Carlo estimation methods for analysing consumers’ decision making on real markets, 92% of the consumers applied a noncompensatory screening rule at some stage of the brand decision process. Abandoning the compensatory utility function, however, renders the profit optimisation analytically intractable and simulation methods are required. The micro simulation environment named the Artificial Consumer Market (ACM) will be used. It mimics the behaviours of disaggregate consumers and firms and was elaborated in a seven years’ research programme on “Adaptive Systems and Modelling in Economics and Management Science”. The relevant algorithmic features of the ACM are outlined in the Appendix. Other assumptions besides the consumers’ decision styles were relaxed for this micro simulation study. They relate to how the positions in the brand space are established and to the preferential market structure. Discrete time and periodicity. Unlike the game-theoretic analyses the simulation experiment operates in discrete time steps. They are defined by the series of advertising exposures and subsequent choices. The simulation requires a decision on the duration of the pre-entry period and the post-entry phase of combat. It aims at elaborating the consequences of market entry in the short run. The number of pre-entry periods is set to two, which allows for a sufficient increase in product knowledge. The time span of the entry battle is limited to two periods t = 3 and 4, i.e., two advertising exposures and two choice occasions. In this post-entry period the incumbent tries to maximise its cumulative profits. Note, however, that the incumbent cannot immediately react, but continues with his strategy in t = 3 while preparing a defensive advertising budget and price for t = 4. Advertising-generated brand positions. The Defender model analysed the incumbent’s response to various predetermined positions of an attacking brand (Hauser and Shugan, 1983). Ansari et al. (1994) examined “competition in positions” where the firms react directly by changing brand
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
114
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
J. A. Mazanec, U. Schuster & J. Wöckl
locations in product space without incurring positioning costs. In Gruca et al. (2001) the brands’ locations in the attribute space were optimally chosen according to the PRODSRCH procedure (Sudharshan et al., 1987; Green and Krieger, 1989). In this micro simulation the brand positions are derived indirectly by letting them evolve according to the firms’ advertising efforts in periods t = 1 and 2. The more they invest the faster they travel through the perceptual space. If they consistently promote the product attributes linked to an attitudinal dimension they advance into the desired direction along this dimension. Hence, the brand positions are subject to perceptual dynamics during the pre-entry as well as the entry phases. Utility function and brand choice. The consumers are allowed to depart from rigorous rationality. In the original Defender model and the series of modifications it triggered off the consumers’ utility function is based on a measure reflecting a brand’s “closeness” to the consumers’ ideal brand position. This may be achieved by using Hauser and Shugan’s arctan of the attribute weights ratio (Hauser and Shugan, 1983; Ansari et al., 1994) or the Euclidean distance between the brand positions and the ideal points (Gruca et al., 2001). The consumers then aim at maximising their chosen brand’s attribute values in the proportion preferred or by minimising distance to the ideal brand profile. The overall utility originates from a compensatory decision rule. Both maximisation and attribute trade-off are strong assumptions that may be debatable for many product classes and/or consumer segments. Though their relevance for real markets is unquestioned (Bettman, 1971; Wright, 1975; Bettman et al., 1998) marketing research has channelled very little effort in building models that allow for noncompensatory decision rules. West et al. (1997) and Gilbride and Allenby (2004) are notable exceptions. This study introduces two kinds of rationality bounds. First, consumers do not strictly optimise. Rather they stick to a satisficing rule. They do no longer differentiate among brands once a satisfactory level (“aspiration level”) of product attributes has been reached. The second deviation from perfect rationality regards trade-offs among product attributes. A noncompensatory brand choice rule will be admitted and the share of consumers practicing a variant of noncompensatory decision making becomes one of the experimental factors. Under the modified ideal point model the total attractiveness (“utility”) of a product brand b for consumer c is the sum of the utility contributions
ch05
FA1
May 20, 2006
11:53
WSPC/SPI-B398: Advances in Doctoral Research in Management (Ed: Chean Chian)
Defensive Strategies and Consumers’ Bounded Rationality
115
of the R attitudinal dimensions: ub,c =
R
max(0, min(qc,r