Approaches to Phonological Complexity
≥
Phonology and Phonetics 16
Editor
Aditi Lahiri
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · ...
29 downloads
1646 Views
51MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Approaches to Phonological Complexity
≥
Phonology and Phonetics 16
Editor
Aditi Lahiri
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
Approaches to Phonological Complexity
edited by
Franc¸ois Pellegrino Egidio Marsico Ioana Chitoran Christophe Coupe´
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
Mouton de Gruyter (formerly Mouton, The Hague) is a Division of Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin.
앝 Printed on acid-free paper which falls within the guidelines 앪 of the ANSI to ensure permanence and durability.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Approaches to phonological complexity / edited by Franc¸ois Pellegrino … [et al.]. p. cm. ⫺ (Phonology and phonetics ; 16) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-3-11-022394-1 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Complexity (Linguistics) 2. Phonetics. 3. Grammar, Comparative and general ⫺ Phonology. I. Pellegrino, Franc¸ois, 1971⫺ P128.C664A77 2009 414⫺dc22 2009043030
Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de.
ISBN 978-3-11-022394-1 ISSN 1861-4191 쑔 Copyright 2009 by Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, D-10785 Berlin. All rights reserved, including those of translation into foreign languages. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Cover design: Christopher Schneider, Laufen. Printed in Germany.
Table of contents Introduction François Pellegrino, Egidio Marsico, Ioana Chitoran and Christophe Coupé
1
Part 1: Complexity and phonological primitives Complexity in phonetics and phonology: gradience, categoriality, and naturalness Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
21
Languages’ sound inventories: the devil in the details John J. Ohala
47
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels René Carré
59
Part 2: Typological approaches to measuring complexity Calculating phonological complexity Ian Maddieson Favoured syllabic patterns in the world’s languages and sensorimotor constraints Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset Structural complexity of phonological systems Christophe Coupé, Egidio Marsico and François Pellegrino Scale-free networks in phonological and orthographic wordform lexicons Christopher T. Kello and Brandon C. Beltz
85
111
141
171
vi Table of contents
Part 3: Phonological representations in the light of complex adaptive systems The dynamical approach to speech perception: From fine phonetic detail to abstract phonological categories Noël Nguyen, Sophie Wauquier and Betty Tuller
193
A dynamical model of change in phonological representations: The case of lenition Adamantios Gafos and Christo Kirov
219
Cross-linguistic trends in the perception of place of articulation in stop consonants: A comparison between Hungarian and French Willy Serniclaes and Christian Geng
241
The complexity of phonetic features’ organisation in reading Nathalie Bedoin and Sonia Krifi
267
Part 4: Complexity in the course of language acquisition Self-organization of syllable structure: a coupled oscillator model Hosung Nam, Louis Goldstein and Elliot Saltzman
299
Internal and external influences on child language productions Yvan Rose
329
Emergent complexity in early vocal acquisition: Cross linguistic omparisons of canonical babbling Sophie Kern and Barbara L. Davis
353
Index
377
List of Contributors
383
Introduction François Pellegrino, Egidio Marsico, Ioana Chitoran and Christophe Coupé 1. The study of complexity in phonology and phonetics What is complex? What is not complex, or simple? Is there a gap between simple and complex? Or is complexity gradient? While universal answers to these questions are probably of limited relevance, their resolution in specific fields of research may be crucial, especially in biology or social sciences, where complexity factors may play a highly significant role in the emergence and the evolution of systems, whatever they are (Edmonds, 1999). In phonetics and phonology, these questions have been present for more than a century. For example, according to Zipf (1935:49), “there exists an equilibrium between the magnitude or degree of complexity of a phoneme and the relative frequency of its occurrence”. In this controversial work, he thus tried to evaluate the magnitude of complexity of phonemes from articulatory effort (Zipf, 1935:66; but see also Joos, 1936) under the assumption that it plays a major role in phonetic changes as well as in the structure of phonological systems. Soon afterwards, Trubetzkoy reanalysed this interaction in terms of markedness (1938:282), leading the way to a long-lasting tradition of intricate relationships between the notions of markedness, frequency, complexity and functional load, well exemplified by this quotation from Greenberg, forty years later: “Are there any properties which distinguish favored articulations as a group from their alternatives? There do, as a matter of fact, appear to be several principles at work. [There is one] which accounts for a considerable number of clusters of phonological universals (…) This is the principle that of two sounds that one is favored which is the less complex. The nature of this complexity can be stated in quite precise terms. The more complex sound involves an additional articulatory feature and, correspondingly, an additional acoustic feature which is not present in the less complex sound. This additional feature is often called a “mark” and hence the more complex, less favored alternative is called marked and the less complex, more favored alternative the unmarked. (…) It may be noted that the approach outlined here avoids the circularity for which earlier formulations, such as those of Zipf,
2
François Pellegrino et al. were attacked. (…) In the present instance, panhuman preferences were investigated by formulating universals based in the occurrence or nonoccurrence of certain types, by text frequency and other evidence, none of which referred to the physical or acoustic nature of the sounds. Afterward, a common physical and acoustic property of the favored alternatives was noted employing evidence independent of that used to establish the universals” (Greenberg, 1969:476-477).
Indeed, the notion of phonological complexity is implicitly present in numerous works dealing with linguistic typology and universals (as in Greenberg’s quotation), language acquisition (e.g. Demuth, 1995) and historical linguistics. Articulatory cost, perceptual distinctiveness and systemic constraints have thus been proposed as driving forces for explaining sound changes (Lindblom & Maddieson, 1988; Lindblom, 1998:245), beside an undisputed social dimension. The role of such mechanisms has also been extended to the structure of language systems, leading some linguists to postulate a balance of complexity within language grammar, a lack of complexity in one component being compensated by another more complex component (e.g. Hockett, 1958:180-181). However, this assumption is highly debated and still unsolved (Fenck-Oczlon & Fenk, 1999, 2005; Shosted, 2006). However, one must acknowledge that the word complexity itself has not been often explicitly referred to, even if it underlies several salient advances in phonetics and phonology. For example, when Ohala pointed out that an ‘exotic consonant inventory’ such as { ɗ k’ ts ɬ m r | } is not observed in languages with few consonants, he suggested that a principle of economy is at work at the systemic level (Ohala, 1980; but see also, Ohala, this volume). Consequently, one can infer that the above system is too complex to be viable; but too complex with respect to what? And how to measure this complexity; is it a matter of global number of articulatory features, of intrinsic phonemic complexity, of the overall size of the phonetic space used in this language? Contrary to what Greenberg said, measuring complexity is not straightforward, even when the problem is narrowed, for instance to articulatory complexity (e.g. Ohala, 1990:260) and we still lack relevant tools. Lindblom and Maddieson (1988) began to address this question and proposed to divide consonants into three sets (simple, elaborated and complex) according to their articulatory complexity. They analysed the distribution of these segments among the UPSID database (Maddieson, 1984) and they suggested that languages have a tendency to use consonants and vowels picked
Introduction
3
from an adaptive phonetic space according to the number of elements in their inventories. This influential paper combined a typological survey and a theoretical attempt to decipher the mechanisms responsible for the observed patterns (see also, Lindblom, 1998; Lindblom, 1999). In this sense, it threw a bridge between the bare issue of complexity measurement and the use of methods fostered by physics and cybernetics to account for the general behaviour of languages, viewed as dynamical systems. In a late work, Jakobson judged that: “Like any other social modelling system tending to maintain its dynamic equilibrium, language ostensively displays its self-regulating and selfsteering properties. Those implicational laws which build the bulk of phonological and grammatical universals and underlie the typology of languages are embedded to a great extent in the internal logic of linguistic structures, and do not necessarily presuppose special 'genetic' instructions” (Jakobson, 1973:48).
Phenomena such as self-organisation, evoked above, and emergence, which also comes to mind in this view, are commonly found in the study of complex adaptive systems, a subfield of the science of complexity. These approaches connect the microscopic level (the components and their interactions) to the macroscopic level (the system and its dynamic behaviour), and they aim at explaining complex patterns with general mechanisms without any teleological considerations1. As far as phonetics and phonology are concerned, these perspectives have already generated a noteworthy literature (e.g. Kelso, Saltzman & Tuller, 1986; Lindblom, 1999) and several recent developments are described in this book (mostly in Part 3). The next paragraph provides some landmarks necessary to grasp the aims and content of this book.
2. Complex adaptive systems and the science of complexity Since the middle of the twentieth century, scientists from numerous fields of research, ranging from physics to graph theory, and from biology to economics and linguistics, have built a web of theories, models and notions, known today as the Science of Complexity. This paradigm pertains to our everyday experience, and has provided us with insights in phenomena as distinct – at first glance – as properties of ferromagnetic materials with respect to temperature, motion patterns of persons on crowded sidewalks or of fish schools, social behaviour of ants or termites, fluctuations of finan-
4
François Pellegrino et al.
cial markets, etc (e.g. Markose, 2005; Theraulaz et al., 2002; Gazi and Passino, 2004). The strength of this approach probably dwells in its protean capacity, an adaptability that has been described by Lass (1997:294) as “a syntax without a semantics” preventing any “ontological commitment”. The exact scope of disciplines and methodologies which can potentially benefit from this new science is therefore not restricted, and a reanalysis of long-lasting open issues in the light of complexity leads to exciting connections to most areas of research, and linguistics is not an exception. The main focus of the Science of Complexity is the study of complex systems. A system is said to be complex when its overall behaviour exhibits properties that are not easily predicted from the individual description of the parts of the system. Hence, a car is not really complex but just complicated: it consists of many interacting parts, but the behaviour of the car is predictable from its components (and that is why we can safely drive it). On the contrary, when the same car is caught in a traffic jam, it becomes very difficult to predict the evolution of the blockage and even the individual trajectory of this particular car: the interaction of the cars (and of their respective drivers) generates a complex collective pattern. An essential element of complex systems lies in the interaction between each component and its environment. Systems may differ in terms of the reactivity of their components – an ant cannot match a human being when it comes to analyzing and reacting to the environmental input – but a minimal threshold has to be exceeded for complex behaviours to appear. Besides, complex systems are generally explained by recourse to the notions of nonlinearity and emergence. Nonlinearity refers to phenomena for which the effect of a perturbation is not proportional to its initial cause, due to the complex network of interactions in which it is entangled. The famous butterfly effect, popularized in chaos theory, illustrates the sensitivity to the initial conditions that derives from this condition. Emergence refers to the appearance of structures at the overall level, from the interactions of the components of a dynamic complex system. Such structures can apply to relevant dimensions of the system – like its spatial organization – but also unroll in time with the consistent occurrences of transient or stable states. These emergent properties often result from trade-off between conflicting constraints and from selforganizing processes that can stabilize the system enough for such regularities to appear. Most complex systems do not follow deterministic paths because of the existence of degrees of freedom leading to a wide range of possible states
Introduction
5
in answer to internal and external constraints. Thus, various evolutionary trajectories may be observed, and from a given initial state, these systems may reach various final configurations, whose likelihood is a function of the self-organizing forces at hand. In other words, it is impossible to predict the evolution of a single system, but it is possible to draw reliable conclusions for a large enough set of them: a collection of complex systems may indeed exhibit a diversity of states, with some more frequent than others, and some very unlikely but still explainable in terms of probability laws for “rare events”, etc2. The human language faculty is a complex system, both as an outcome of interacting linguistic components within each individual and as a collective set of conventions resulting from the interactions among individuals. On the one hand, linguistic products themselves – words, sentences, sets of sentences – are the outputs of a cognitive system composed of linguistic components, as well as a set of complex relationships between them. Competing pressures over lexicon and grammar (such as articulatory/auditory constraints mentioned above) widely influence language production and understanding by human beings, and dynamical processes (e.g. activation propagation and decay in the mental lexicon, or interactive meaning construction of sentence from lexicon and grammar). On the other hand, language seen as a dynamical distributed system of conventions in a community can also be analysed as a complex system, given the intricacy of the linguistic interactions taking place between the speakers. Indeed, the science of complexity has successfully addressed tremendous challenges in our understanding of the human language faculty. Theoretical approaches that integrate self-organization, emergence, nonlinearity, adaptive systems, information theory, etc., have already shed new light on the duality between the observed linguistic diversity and the human cognitive faculty of language. Most of the recent literature written in this framework focuses either on the syntactic level addressed through computational complexity (Barton et al., 1987; Ristad, 1993; among others) or performance optimization (e.g. Hawkins, 2004), or explicitly on the emergence and evolution of language as a communication convention (e.g. Galantucci, 2005; Steels, 2005, 2006; Ke, Gong and Wang, 2008). Other linguistic components have been less thoroughly investigated, Dahl (2004) and Oudeyer (2006) providing noteworthy exceptions offering stimulating approaches to long-lasting questions. However, no unified framework has yet come into sight, and the field is characterized by a wide variety of approaches.
6
François Pellegrino et al.
3. Goal and contribution of the present volume This book is the first one to propose an outline of this multi-faceted field of research in the general framework of phonetics and phonology. It is organized in four parts and covers a large spectrum of issues addressed by the community of specialists in two directions shaped by the concepts of complexity and complex systems. The first branch ranges from the measurement of complexity itself to the assessment of its relevance as an explanation to typological phonology and to phylogenetic or ontogenetic trajectories. The second branch ranges from the quest for phonetic/phonological primitives to the dynamical modelling of speech communication (perception and/or production) as a complex system in an emergent and self-organized attempt to explain phonetic and phonological processes. Beyond this diversity, all the contributors of this book consider that the notions of complexity and complex adaptive systems offer today a huge potential for developing groundbreaking research on language and languages, to the extent that they may partially reveal the “invisible hand” for the organization and evolution of speech communication – a metaphor borrowed from Adam Smith’s work in economics and already developed in Keller (1994) in a diachronic perspective. As said above however, no unified framework exists yet, and the contributions gathered here bring together different pieces of the puzzle investigated from several points of view and methodologies. Consequently, a reflection on phonological complexity is present in all chapters to some degree, and the analyses are always based on experimental data or cross-linguistic comparison. In Part I, the questions of the nature of the relevant primitives in sound systems is addressed in the light of complexity at the phonetics/phonology interface. In chapter 1, Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn bring together a number of different notions that correspond to interpretations of phonological complexity (e.g., markedness, naturalness), building on them a clear and comprehensive overview of the main points of debate in phonetics and phonology. These debates revolve around: (i) the interaction between phonetics and phonology; (ii) their gradient vs. categorical nature; (iii) the role of phonetic naturalness in phonology; (iv) the nature of units of representation. Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn argue that a clear and complete understanding of what complexity is in phonetics and phonology must necessarily engage these four points, and must take into account phenomena that have generally been interpreted as lying at the interface between pho-
Introduction
7
netics and phonology. As such, it must crucially take into account variability. Chapters 2 (John J. Ohala) and 3 (René Carré) in this section both address the issue of variability and challenge traditional representations of phonetic primitives. Ohala further develops the idea that the degree of complexity of a sound system should not be limited to the number and combination of distinctive features. Rather, one has to consider the balance between symmetry and economy as described in phonology, and asymmetry and absence of categorical boundaries, as found in phonetics. Starting from the idea that distinctive phonetic features in language X can be present non-distinctively in language Y, Ohala argues that phonetic variation must be included in a measure of phonological complexity, because it is part of a speaker’s knowledge of the language. The concept of coarticulation, for example, is not entirely relevant for a phonological system, but the systematic variation it introduces in the speech signal can, over time, affect the composition of segmental inventories. Carré (chapter 3) presents results from production and perception experiments suggesting that the identification of vowels in V1V2 sequences is possible based exclusively on dynamic stimuli, in the absence of static targets. Carré proposes that reliable information on vowel identities in V1V2 sequences lies in the direction and rate of transitions. He connects this finding to the known importance of transition rate in the identification of consonants. The implication of this connection is a possible unified theory of consonant and vowel representation, based on the parameter of transition rate: consonants are characterized by fast transitions and vowels by slow transitions. Carré’s dynamic approach thus presents an intriguing challenge to more traditional views of phonetic specification, based primarily on static primitives. Part II starts with a contribution by Ian Maddieson where he proposes several factors contributing to phonological complexity, departing from the traditional counts of consonant and vowel inventories, tone systems or syllable canons. The approach benefits from tests on a large representative sample of the world’s languages and from a thorough analysis of the literature. The first factor deals with “inherent phonetic complexity”. The author proposes various ways of establishing a scale of complexity for the segments, on which we can then base the measure of the system complexity by summing the complexity of its particular components. The second factor assesses the combinatorial possibilities of the elements (segments, tones,
8
François Pellegrino et al.
stress) present in a given phonological system, and one possibility suggested by the author is to calculate the number of possible distinct syllables per language. The third factor focuses on the frequency of types of the different phonological elements of a system. The idea put forward by the author is that the complexity of a language regarding a particular element is the inherent complexity of that element weighted by its frequency of occurrence in the lexicon. In other words, the more a language uses a complex element, the more complex it is. The major concern then lies in the way one calculates the type frequencies for a large sample of languages: shall it be based on lexicons or texts? The last potential complexity factor is called “variability and transparency”. It has to do with phonological processes and no more with inventories. The author suggests evaluating the motivations behind phonological alternations; these variations can be ranked from more conditioned ones, (highly motivated, thus less complex) to free variations (no motivations, thus more complex). This complexity value can be weighted against the number of resulting variants in the alternation, giving a combined score of variability and transparency. The author concludes by reckoning that even if all the proposed complexity factors are proved to be relevant, the main problem will remain how to combine all of them in one overall measure of complexity. The second contribution of part II is by Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset. It echoes the second factor proposed by Ian Maddieson regarding combinatorial possibilities of segments. The authors analyze some languages’ preferred sound sequences (syllabic or not) using a 17-language syllabified lexicon database (ULSID) in the light of the frame/content theory (MacNeilage, 1998). They focus on the alternations of consonants and vowels looking at their place of articulation. They confirm previous findings stating preferred associations like coronal consonants with front vowels, bilabial consonants with central vowels, and velar consonants with back vowels. They also examine the so-called “labial-coronal effect” according to which CV.CV words are predominantly composed of a labial first consonant and a coronal second one. Their data extend this result by showing the existence of the labial-coronal effect in other syllabic patterns as well. Finally, they look at sequences of plosive and nasal consonants, revealing that preferred associations question the validity of the sonority scale. To account for all their typological findings, the authors put forward convincing arguments from articulatory, acoustic and perceptual domains; they conclude that the patterns of sound associations encountered
Introduction
9
in the world’s languages find their source partly outside of phonology in the sensorimotor capacities that underlie them. The third contribution by Christophe Coupé, Egidio Marsico and François Pellegrino departs from the two previous papers, as it does not aim at proposing any measure or scale of phonological complexity for phonological segments or sound patterns. The contributors rather consider phonological systems as complex adaptive systems per se and consequently, they propose to characterize their structure in the light of several approaches borrowed from this framework. The main rationale is that, by applying models designed outside phonology and linguistics to a typological database of phonological systems (namely UPSID), the influence of theoretical a priori is limited and consequently allows the emergence of data-driven patterns of organisation for the phonological systems. They propose two different approaches. The first one, inspired from graph theory, consists in analysing the structure of phonological systems by constituting graphs in which phonemes are nodes and connections receive weights according to the phonetic distance between these phonemes. Using a topological measure of complexity, this approach is used to compare the distribution of the structural complexities among broad areal groups of languages. In the second approach, they model the content of phonological inventories by considering the distribution of co-occurrences of phonemes in order to define attraction and repulsion relations between them. These relations are then used to propose a synchronic measure of coherence for the phonological systems, and then diachronically extended to a measure of stability. Emergent patterns of stability among phonological systems are demonstrated, supporting that this approach is efficient in extracting a part of the intrinsic information present in the UPSID database and avoiding as much as possible the use of any linguistic a priori. The last contribution of this second part is by Christopher T. Kello and Brandon C. Beltz who propose an exciting hypothesis on the dynamical equilibrium leading to a relationship between phonological systems and phonotactics on the one hand, and the process of word formation in the lexicon on the other. Their approach, like the one by Coupé, Marsico and Pellegrino, imports the mathematical theory of graph into linguistics. Phenomena that exhibit behaviour described by power-laws are widespread in physics, biology and social systems. When observed, these laws generally signify that a principle of least-effort is operating, and that a dynamical equilibrium results from the interaction between several competing constraints. Christopher T. Kello and Brandon C. Beltz observe power-law
10
François Pellegrino et al.
behaviours in word forms and phonological networks of American English, built according to inclusion relation between the lexical items (in contrast with semantic or purely morphological rules). As endorsed by the contributors, this result may stem from a trade-off between distinctiveness and efficiency pressures. In other words, a ”valid” language deals both with the need to maintain a sufficient distance between the words of its lexicon and with a constraint of parsimony leading to the reuse of existing phonotactic or orthographic sequences. Their assumption is extended to the lexical networks of four other languages, and then assessed by comparison with artificial networks. While power-laws were first shown in lexical networks in Zipf’s seminal work a half-century ago (Zipf, 1949), Kello and Beltz’ work goes further by demonstrating that several kinds of constraints interact and generate the same type of behaviour in word formation mechanisms. In a sense, this study fills a part of the gap between the lexicon and the phonology of a language, and provides a convincing link that will be essential for developing a systemic view of languages able to take all linguistic components into account. Part III is specifically dedicated to approaches that aim at revealing the nature and organisation of human phonological representations in a multidisciplinary framework and in the light of complexity. Noël Nguyen, Sophie Wauquier and Betty Tuller’s contribution develops a dynamical approach to explore the nature of the representations activated during speech perception. In the first section, they set the debate between abstractionist and exemplar-based models of speech perception. Since arguments exist in favour of these two antagonistic hypotheses, they argue that these statements result from the dual nature of speech perception. In this view, phonetic details are retained, not as exemplars but as a dynamical tuning of a complex and continuous “shape”, and an abstractionistlike behaviour is also possible, based on the existence of several stable attractors. A dynamical model is developed and a review of several tasks of speech categorization is proposed. The existence of a hysteresis cycle in the behavioural performances observed during the task indicates that perception does not operate in a basic deterministic manner since it is sensitive to the previous state of the system in a way typical of nonlinear dynamical systems. These results strongly support the proposal of a hybrid and dynamical model of speech perception bringing together the properties of both exemplar and abstractionist models.
Introduction
11
In connection with John Ohala’s contribution in the first part of this book, and with the dynamical model of speech perception detailed in the previous chapter (Nguyen, Wauquier and Tuller), Adamantios Gafos and Christo Kirov implemented a nonlinear dynamical model of phonetic change illustrated with the case of lenition. They assume that phonological representations consist of feature-like components that could be theoretically modelled using activation fields borrowed from the dynamic field theory, and ruled by differential equations. In their view, production/perception loops self-generate the well-known word frequency effect reported for lenition. More specifically, the interaction between field activation (biased toward the inputs of the perception stage) and memory decay is the backbone that enables gradual phonetic change. Production/perception loops are thus responsible for both the potential shift of the phonetic realization and the positive feedback that lead to the emergence of a new stable variant of the phonetic parameters. The third contribution of this part, from Willy Serniclaes and Christian Geng, investigates the bases of categorical boundaries in the perception of the place of articulation of stop consonants. It compares the perceptual boundaries of Hungarian and French, using artificial stimuli differing in terms of formant transitions and generated with the DRM model (see René Carré’s contribution in the first part of this volume). Four places of articulation are distinctive in Hungarian, while only three are phonologically relevant in French. Consequently, comparing the positions of their boundaries is informative on the influence of universal phonetic predispositions on the organisation of phonological categories. Results show that the perceptual boundaries are similar for the two languages, dividing the formant transition space into three salient areas. It happens that the palatal-alveolar boundary is not as salient as the other boundaries and that an additional feature (besides burst and formant transition) probably plays a role. These results are discussed in the perspective of the emergence of distinctive boundaries from coupling between natural phonetic boundaries; they also echo John Ohala’ contribution on the importance of so-called secondary features in language evolution (see the first part of this book). Nathalie Bedoin & Sonia Krifi’s contribution deals with the fundamental issue of the organisation of phonetic features, as revealed in the context of reading tasks. They provide a thorough review of this literature, and a series of visual priming and metalinguistic experiments. These experiments explore the temporal course of reading by manipulating not only phonetic feature similarity between primes and targets, but also the nature of these
12
François Pellegrino et al.
features. Taken as a whole, their results suggest that voicing, manner and place are processed at different rates and that a complex pattern of activation propagation and lateral inhibition is involved. More specifically, voicing seems to be processed first but, depending on the experimental conditions, a prominent impact of manner over place and voicing may also be evidenced when processing time is no more a relevant factor. Nathalie Bedoin & Sonia Krifi’s contribution thus highlights the complexity of the organisation of phonetic features both in the temporal and the hierarchical dimensions. Additional information is provided by the replication of these experiments with second and third grade children, revealing a gradient setting of the underlying processes during language acquisition and development. The relevance of the approaches to phonology borrowed from the science of complexity can only be assessed by evaluating whether such models succeed in tackling some of the challenges that limit our knowledge and understanding of human language capacity and linguistic diversity. If granting a significant role to complexity is correct, one of the most salient fields in which it will radically change our comprehension is the domain of language acquisition, and especially along two directions. First, computational dynamical models of emergence of linguistic patterns may assess hypotheses related to the mechanisms of linguistic bootstrapping (e.g. Morgan & Demuth, 1996; Pierrehumbert, 2003). Second, cross-linguistic comparison of courses of language acquisition may reveal universal tendencies, not necessarily in terms of phonological units (gestures, features, segments or syllables) but in terms of their intrinsic complexity and of their interactions in the communication system. In the longer run, these two approaches will probably give rise to unified models of phonological acquisition, and they already have reached significant results on the balance between universal and language specific constraints in acquisition, as shown in Part IV. In the first paper, Hosung Nam, Louis Goldstein and Elliot Saltzman promote a dynamical model of the acquisition of syllable structures, compatible with what is attested in the world’s languages. More specifically, the emergence of asymmetries between the frequencies of syllables with onsets (CV structure) versus syllables with codas (VC structure) is observed with their model which avoids the partially circular notion of the unmarkedness of the CV structure. These effects emerge as a consequence of the interaction between the ambient language and the intrinsic characteristics of the oscillators that control the phasing of the articulatory gestures
Introduction
13
in the “child model”. By implementing a nonlinear coupling between these oscillators, multiple stable modes can emerge as attractors, given the generic assumption that in-phase and anti-phase coordination of gestures are preferred. Without additional hypotheses, differences between the duration in the acquisition processes of CV and VC structures also emerge, regardless of the target ambient distribution. Next, the computational model is proved to efficiently model the faster acquisition of VCC over CCV. Hence, the model successfully manages to reproduce two seemingly contradictory phenomena regarding the course of acquisition of CV vs. VC structures on the one hand and of CCV vs. VCC on the other. In this framework, the contributors demonstrate that data from linguistic typology and from longitudinal studies of language acquisition can foster methodologies inspired from complex adaptive systems in an extraordinarily fruitful approach. The two last chapters of this book (contributed by Yvan, and Sophie Kern & Barbara L. Davis) do not implement any computational models. However they thoroughly explore the driving forces underlying phonological acquisition in a multi-language framework. Yvan Rose argues for the necessary synthesis between diverging approaches and he urges development of a multi-faceted approach in order to overcome some failures of current approaches in accounting for patterns observed during early phonological acquisition. Reanalysing several papers from the literature on early acquisition, he suggests that the role of the statistical patterns of the ambient language has been overestimated and an alternative explanation based on structural complexity is introduced. In the rest of the chapter, the contributor discusses a series of phonological patterns taken from data published on early acquisition in terms of interactions of driving forces grounded in several potentially relevant “facets” (articulation, perception, statistics of the ambient language, child grammar as a cognitive system). Yvan Rose’s contribution thus offers a strong argumentation in favour of the multi-faceted approach and a rich and stimulating interpretation of existing data built upon factors of phonological complexity. Sophie Kern & Barbara L. Davis’s contribution tackles the issue of cross-linguistic variability in canonical babbling, thanks to an unprecedented amount of empirical data from five languages. The contributors take advantage from this unique material to investigate the universality and/or language-specificity of canonical babbling. The theoretical bases supporting the existence of universal driving forces are introduced and developed in the vein of the Frame/Content perspective, and the impact of the ambient
14
François Pellegrino et al.
language is discussed from a review of the literature. More specifically, Sophie Kern and Barbara L. Davis highlight that the lack of common ground strongly limits the cross-linguistic relevance of these studies (because of the different procedures applied in different languages). Then, they analyse the similarities and differences observed in their data, at the segmental level and in terms of subphonemic and phonemic co-occurrences in the babbling structures. The discussion of these results draws a coherent scheme that emphasizes the role of speech-like prelinguistic babbling as a first step into language complexity, but predominated by universal characteristics of the production system. The editors would like to warmly thank all the authors of this volume. We are also greatly indebted to the colleagues who have contributed as reviewers for the submitted chapters: René Carré, Barbara Davis, Christian DiCanio, Christelle Dodane, Emmanuel Ferragne, Cécile Fougeron, Adamantios Gafos, Ian Maddieson, Noel Nguyen, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer, Gérard Philippson, Yvan Rose, Willy Serniclaes, Caroline Smith, Kenny Smith (in alphabetic order), and to the participants of the Workshop “Phonological Systems & Complex Adaptive Systems”, held in Lyon in July 2005, and more specifically Didier Demolin, Björn Lindblom and Sharon Peperkamp, for their comments. We also thank Aditi Lahiri for her thorough and fruitful suggestions and Mouton de Guyter’s anonymous reviewer. The editors fully acknowledge the financial support from the French ACI “Systèmes complexes en SHS” and from the French Agence Nationale de la Recherche (project NT053_43182 CL², P.I. F. Pellegrino).
Notes 1. It may be more correct to state that these approaches imply a limited teleology, in the sense that they are often based on the optimization of a given criterion and thus can be seen as ‘targeted’ to this optimization. See Blevins, (2004:71-78) for a thorough discussion about the nature of teleological and functional explanations in sound change. 2. This statement can obviously be put in perspective with considerations on language universals and the distribution of patterns among languages, e.g. see Greenberg (1968): “In general one may expect that certain phenomena are widespread in language because the ways they can arise are frequent and their stability, once they occur, is high. A rare or non-existent phenomenon arises only by infrequently occurring changes and is unstable once it comes into existence. The two factors of probability of
Introduction
15
origin from other states and stability can be considered separately” (Greenberg, 1978:75-76).
References Barton, G. Edward, Robert Berwick & Eric Sven Ristad 1987 Computational Complexity and Natural Language. The MIT Press: Cambridge, MA, USA. Blevins, Juliette 2004 Evolutionary phonology: the emergence of sound patterns. Cambridge University Press: New York. Dahl, Östen 2004 The Growth and Maintenance of Linguistic Complexity. Studies in Language Companion Series 71. John Benjamins. Demuth, Katherine 1995 Markedness and the Development of Prosodic Structure. In Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society. Jill N. Beckman (ed.). Amherst: Graduate Linguistic Student Association. pp. 13-25. Fenk-Oczlon Gertraud & Fenk August 1999 Cognition, quantitative linguistics, and systemic typology. Linguistic Typology 3.2: 151-177. 2005 Crosslinguistic correlations between size of syllables, number of cases, and adposition order. In Sprache und Natürlichkeit, Gedenkband für Willi Mayerthaler. G. Fenk-Oczlon & Ch. Winkler (eds). Tübingen. Galantucci, Bruno 2005 An experimental study of the emergence of human communication systems. Cogn. Sci. 29: 737–767. Gazi, Veysel & Kevin M. Passino 2004 Stability analysis of social foraging swarms. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics Part B, 34.1: 539- 557. Greenberg Joseph. H. 1969 Language Universals: A Research Frontier. Science 166: 473-478. 24 October 1969. 1978 Diachrony, synchrony, and language universals. in Universals of human language. J. H. Greenberg, C. A. Ferguson & E. A. Moravcsik (eds.). Vol. 1. Stanford University Press: Stanford. pp. 61-93. Hawkins, John A. 2004 Efficiency and Complexity in Grammars, Oxford University Press: Oxford. Hockett, Charles F. 1958 A Course in Modern Linguistics. The MacMillan Company: New York.
SWIN|KCrEIB1Qqc8svpQueSEh0w==|1282027849
16
François Pellegrino et al.
Jakobson, Roman 1973 Main trends in the Science of Language. Main trends in the social Sciences Series. Harper & Row: New-York. Joos, Martin 1936 Review: The Psycho-Biology of Language by George K. Zipf, Language 12.3: 196-210. Ke Jinyun, Tao Gong & William S-Y Wang 2008 Language Change and Social Networks. Communications in computational physics 3.4: 935-949. Keller, Rudi 1994 On language change : the invisible hand in language. Routledge, London ; New York. Kelso, J. A.S., Saltzman, E.L. &Tuller, B. 1986 The dynamical perspective on speech production: Data and theory. Journal of Phonetics 14.1: 29-59. Lass, Roger 1997 Historical Linguistics and Language Change, Cambridge University Press: Cambridge. Lindblom, Björn 1998 Systemic constraints and adaptive change in the formation of sound structure. In Approaches to the evolution of language. Hurford J.R., Studdert-Kennedy M. & Knight C. (eds). Cambridge University Press: Cambridge. pp. 242-264. 1999 Emergent phonology. Perilus. XXII: 1-15. Lindblom, Björn & Maddieson, Ian 1988 Phonetic universals in consonant Systems. In Language, Speech, and Mind. Hyman L.M. & Li C.N. (eds). Routledge: New York. pp. 62-78. MacNeilage, Peter F. 1998 The Frame/Content Theory of Evolution of Speech Production. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21: 499-511. Maddieson, Ian 1984 Patterns of Sounds. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge. Markose, Sheri M. 2005 Computability and Evolutionary Complexity: Markets as Complex Adaptive Systems (CAS). The Economic Journal 115.504: F159–F192. Morgan, James L. & Katherine Demuth 1996 Signal to Syntax: Bootstrapping from Speech to Grammar in Early Acquisition, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah. Ohala, John J. 1980 Moderator’s summary of symposium on ‘Phonetic universals in phonological systems and their explanation’. Proceedings of the 9th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences Vol. 3. Institute of Phonetics: Copenhagen. pp. 181-194.
Introduction 1990
17
The phonetics and phonology of aspects of assimilation. In Papers in Laboratory Phonology I: Between the grammar and the physics of speech. J. Kingston & M. Beckman (eds). Cambridge University Press: Cambridge. pp. 258-265. Oudeyer, Pierre-Yves 2006 Self-Organization in the Evolution of Speech. Studies in the Evolution of Language. Oxford University Press. (Translation by James R. Hurford) Pierrehumbert, Janet B. 2003 Phonetic diversity, statistical learning, and acquisition of phonology. Language and Speech 46.2-3: 115-154. Ristad, Eric S. 1993 The Language Complexity Game. The MIT Press: Cambridge, MA. Shosted, Ryan K. 2006 Correlating complexity: A typological approach. Linguistic Typology 10.1: 1-40. Steels, Luc 2006 Experiments on the emergence of human communication. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10.8: 347-349. 2005 The emergence and evolution of linguistic structure: from lexical to grammatical communication systems. Connection Science 17.3:213-230. Theraulaz, Guy, Eric Bonabeau, Stamatios C. Nicolis, Ricard V. Solé, Vincent Fourcassié, Stéphane Blanco, Richard Fournier, Jean-Louis Joly, Pau Fernández, Anne Grimal, Patrice Dalle, & Jean-Louis Deneubourg 2002 Spatial patterns in ant colonies. PNAS 2002 99: 9645-9649. Trubetzkoy, Nikolai. S. 1938 Grundzüge der phonologie. French Edition. 1970., Klincksieck: Paris. Zipf, George.K. 1935 The Psycho-Biology of Language: An Introduction to Dynamic Philology. MIT Press: Cambridge. First MIT Press paperback edition, 1965 1949 Human behaviour and the principle of least effort: an introduction to human ecology. Addison-Wesley: Cambridge.
Part 1: Complexity and phonological primitives
SWIN|KCrEIB1Qqc8svpQueSEh0w==|1282027863
Complexity in phonetics and phonology: gradience, categoriality, and naturalness Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn 1. Introduction In this paper, we explore the relationship between phonetics and phonology, in an attempt to determine possible sources of complexity that arise in sound patterns and sound systems. We propose that in order to understand complexity, one must consider phonetics and phonology together in their interaction. We argue that the relationship between phonology and phonetics is a multi-faceted one, which in turn leads us to a multi-faceted view of complexity itself. Our goal here is to present an overview of the relevant issues in order to help define a notion (or notions) of complexity in the domain of sound systems, and to provide a backdrop to a constructive discussion of the nature of complexity in sound systems. We begin in §2 by considering possible definitions of phonological complexity based on the different interpretations that have been given to this notion. The issue of complexity has previously been addressed, implicitly or explicitly, through notions such as markedness, effort, naturalness, information content. Concerns with a measure of phonological or phonetic complexity are therefore not new, even though the use of the term “complexity” per se to refer to these questions is more recent. In this section we survey earlier endeavors in these directions. We then turn to the multi-faceted nature of the relationship between phonology and phonetics. In this regard, we address two main questions that have traditionally played a central part in the understanding of the phonetics-phonology relationship. The first of these, addressed in §3, is the issue of gradience vs. categoriality in the domain of linguistic sound systems, and its implications for the question of an adequate representation of linguistic units. In §4 we discuss the second issue: the role of phonetic naturalness in phonology. These are major questions, and we do not attempt to provide a comprehensive treatment here. Rather, our goal is simply to consider them in framing a broader discussion of phonological complexity.
22
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
In §5 we return to the question of complexity and consider the ways in which measures of complexity depend on the type of unit and representation considered. The conclusion of our discussion highlights the multifaceted nature of complexity. Thus more than one type of unit and more than one type of measure are relevant to any characterization of complexity.
2.
Definitions of complexity
In our survey of earlier implicit and explicit definitions of complexity, we review past attempts to characterize the nature of phonological systems. We discuss earlier concerns with complexity in §2.1; then we turn in §2.2 to the issue of theoretical framing in typological surveys, where we compare two types of approaches: theory-driven and data-driven ones. The first type is illustrated by Chomsky and Halle’s (1968) The Sound Pattern of English (SPE), and the second by Maddieson’s (1984) Patterns of Sounds. 2.1. Early approaches to complexity A concern with complexity in phonetics and phonology can be traced back to discussions of several related notions in the literature: markedness, effort, naturalness, and more recently, information content. While none of these notions taken individually can be equated with complexity, there is an intuitive sense in which each one of them can be considered as a relevant element to be included in the calculation of complexity. Studies of phonological complexity started from typological surveys, which led to the development of the notion of markedness in phonological theory. The interpretation of markedness as complexity is implicit in the original understanding of the term, the sense in which it is used by Trubetzkoy (1939, 1969): the presence of a phonological specification (a mark) corresponds to higher complexity in a linguistic element. Thus, to take a classic example, voiced /d/ is the more complex (marked) member of an opposition relative to the voiceless (unmarked) /t/. Later, the interpretation of markedness as complexity referred to coding complexity (see Haspelmath, 2006 for a detailed review). Overt marking or coding is seen to correspond to higher complexity than no coding or zero expression. This view of complexity was adopted and further developed
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
23
into the notion of iconicity of complexity, recently critiqued by Haspelmath (to appear). What is relevant for the purposes of our paper is noting the actual use of the terms complex and complexity in this literature. Several of the authors cited in Haspelmath (2006; to appear) use these terms explicitly. Thus, Lehmann (1974) maintains the presence of a direct correlation between complex semantic representation and complex phonological representation. Givón (1991) treats complexity as tightly related to markedness. He considers complex categories to be those that are “cognitively marked”, and tend to be “structurally marked” at the same time. Similarly, in Newmeyer’s formulation: “Marked forms and structures are typically both structurally more complex (or at least longer) and semantically more complex than unmarked ones” (Newmeyer, 1992:763). None of these discussions includes an objective definition of complexity. Only Lehmann (1974) proposes that complexity can be determined by counting the number of features needed to describe the meaning of an expression, where the term feature is understood in very broad, more or less intuitive terms. The study of complexity through the notions of markedness or iconicity has not been pursued further, and as highlighted by both Hume (2004) and Haspelmath (2006), neither notion constitutes an explanatory theoretical tool. Discussions of complexity in the earlier literature have also focused on the notion of effort, which has been invoked at times as a diagnostic of markedness. It is often assumed, for example, that phonetic difficulty corresponds to higher complexity, and things that are harder to produce are therefore marked. While many such efforts are informal, see Kirchner (1998/2001) for one attempt to formalize and quantify the notion of effort. Ironically, however, Jakobson himself criticized the direct interpretation of this idea as the principle of least effort, adopted in linguistics from the 18th century naturalist Georges-Louis Buffon: “Depuis Buffon on invoque souvent le principe du moindre effort: les articulations faciles à émettre seraient acquises les premières. Mais un fait essentiel du développement linguistique du bébé contredit nettement cette hypothèse. Pendant la période du babil l’enfant produit aisément les sons les plus variés… ” (Jakobson, 1971:317) [“Since Buffon, the principle of least effort is often invoked: articulations that are easy to produce are supposedly the first to be acquired. But an essential fact about the child’s linguistic development strictly contradicts this hypothesis. During the babbling stage the child produces with ease the most varied sounds…”]1
24
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
Jakobson’s critique is now substantiated by experimental work showing that articulatory effort is not necessarily avoided in speech production. Convincing evidence comes from articulatory speech error experiments carried out by Pouplier (2003). Pouplier’s studies show that speech errors do not involve restricted articulator movement. On the contrary, in errors speakers often add an extra gesture, resulting in an even more complex articulation, but in a more stable mode of intergestural coordination. Similarly, Trubetzkoy cautions against theories that simply explain the high frequency of a phoneme by the less difficult production of that phoneme (Trubetzkoy, 1969, chapter 7). He advocates instead a more sophisticated approach to frequency count, which takes into account both the real frequency of a phoneme and its expected frequency: “The absolute figures of actual phoneme frequency are only of secondary importance. Only the relationship of these figures to the theoretically expected figures of phoneme frequency is of real value. An actual phoneme count in the text must therefore be preceded by a careful calculation of the theoretical possibilities (with all rules for neutralization and combination in mind)” (Trubetzkoy, 1969:264).
We return to this view below, in relation to Hume’s (2006) proposal of information content as a basis for markedness. In general, however, the usefulness of insights gained by considering speculative notions such as effort, described in either physical or processing terms, has been limited. Nevertheless these attempts have at least served to show, as Maddieson (this volume) points out, that: “difficulty can itself be difficult to demonstrate”. Another markedness diagnostic that has been related to complexity is naturalness. Even though the term naturalness is explicitly used, it overlaps on the one hand with the diagnostic of effort and phonetic difficulty, and on the other hand with frequency. The discussion of naturalness can be traced back to Natural Phonology (Donegan and Stampe, 1979, among others). A natural, unmarked phenomenon is one that is easier in terms of the articulatory or acoustic processes it involves, but also one that is more frequent. In the end it becomes very difficult to tease apart the two concepts, revealing the risk of circularity: processes are natural because they are frequent, and they are frequent because they are natural. Information content is proposed by Hume (2006) as an alternative to markedness. In her proposal she accepts Trubetzkoy’s challenge, trying to determine a measure of the probability of a phoneme, rather than just its frequency of occurrence. She argues that what lies at the basis of marked-
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
25
ness is information content, a measure of the probability of a particular element in a given communication system. The higher the probability of an element the lower its information content, and conversely, the lower its probability the higher its information content. Markedness diagnostics can thus be replaced by observations about probability, which can be determined based on a number of factors.2 While the exact nature of these factors, their interaction, and the specific definition of probability require further empirical investigation, it is plausible to hypothesize a relationship between complexity and probability. For example, if low probability correlates with higher information content, then it may in turn correlate with higher complexity. At the same time, a related hypothesis needs to be tested, one signalled by Pellegrino et al. (2007): it is possible that information rate (the quantity of information per unit per second) may turn out to be more relevant than, or closely related to information content (the quantity of information per unit). 2.2. Theory-driven vs. data-driven approaches Overall we identify two main types of studies of phonological complexity, which we refer to as theory-driven and data-driven, respectively. The theory-driven approach is well illustrated by Chomsky and Halle’s (1968) SPE, where counting distinctive features is considered to be the relevant measure of complexity, not unlike Lehmann’s (1974) proposal, albeit restricted to phonology. In chapter 9 of SPE, Chomsky and Halle develop a complexity metric. Starting from the assumption that a natural class should be defined with fewer distinctive features than a non-natural (or less natural) class, Chomsky and Halle observe some contradictions. For example, the class of voiced obstruents is captured by more features than the class of all voiced segments, including vowels. Nevertheless, the first class is intuitively more natural than the second one, and would therefore be expected to have the simpler definition. The solution they propose is to include the concept of markedness in the formal framework, and to “revise the evaluation measure so that unmarked values do not contribute to complexity” (Chomsky and Halle, 1968:402). This adjustment allows them to define complexity, and more specifically the complexity of a segment inventory, in the following way: “The complexity of a system is equal to the sum of the marked features of its members” (Chomsky and Halle, 1968:409), or in other words, “related to the sum of the complexities of the
26
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
individual segments” (Chomsky and Halle, 1968:414). Thus, a vowel system consisting of /a i u e o/ is simpler (and therefore predicted to be more common) than /æ i u e o/. By counting only the marked features, the first system has a complexity of 6, while the second one has a complexity of 8. The authors themselves acknowledge the possible limitations of their measure: summing up the marked features predicts, for example, that the inventory /a i u e / is as simple and common as /a i u e o/, both with a complexity of 6. One potentially relevant difference between these systems, which the measure does not consider, is the presence vs. absence of symmetry, the first inventory being more symmetrical than the second one. In general in theory-driven approaches, complexity is defined through a particular formal framework, and thus the insights gained are inevitably limited by the set of operational assumptions. A data-driven study of phonological complexity is Maddieson’s (1984) Patterns of Sounds and the UPSID database that it is based on. The database focuses on the segment, so the implicit measure of complexity involves counting segments. This raises the crucial issue of representation, which we will return to later. In Maddieson’s survey “each segment considered phonemic is represented by its most characteristic allophone” (Maddieson, 1984:6). The representative allophone is determined by weighing several criteria: (i) the allophone with the widest distribution, when this information is available; (ii) the allophone most representative of the phonetic range of variation of all allophones; (iii) the allophone from which the others can be most easily derived. Maddieson thus codifies an atheoretical, descriptive definition of the segment, adopting a somewhat arbitrary, intermediary level of representation between phonology and phonetics, that is in between the underlying contrastive elements, and the phonetic output characterizable as a string of phones. The database captures the output of the phonology, a discrete allophonic representation, which is neither purely phonemic nor purely phonetic, and described as: “phonologically contrastive segments (…) characterized by certain phonetic attributes” (Maddieson, 1984:160). Following Maddieson’s example, linguists have continued to make sophisticated use of typological surveys for many purposes, including that of evaluating complexity (e.g., Lindblom and Maddieson, 1988; Vallée, 1994; Vallée et al., 2002; Marsico et al., 2004).
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
27
2.3. Summary Both theory-driven and data-driven approaches can offer useful insight in the nature and organization of phonological systems. It is also important to bear in mind the implicit assumptions even in what are taken to be “datadriven” approaches. (See also Hayes and Steriade, 2004, pp. 3-5 discussion of inductive vs. deductive approaches to the study of markedness.) One critical aspect of these efforts is the question of the relevant linguistic units in measuring complexity. This question is addressed explicitly by Marsico et al. (2004) and Coupé et al. (this volume). Feature-hood and segment-hood can both tell us something about complexity. But neither concept is as clear-cut as often assumed. Under many views (such as SPE), features are taken as primitives. Segments are built out of bundles of features. Other views take the segment to be primary, or even suggest that segments are epiphenomenal, as is argued by some exemplar theorists. We take the view that in adult grammar, both segments and features have a role to play in characterizing the inventories and patterns of sound systems. As seen above, the question of the nature of segments is also a complex one: do we mean underlying contrastive units, do we mean something more concrete, such as Maddieson’s surface allophones? The question about the nature of segments leads to broader questions about the nature of phonology and phonetics and their relationship. In the next section, we turn to this relationship.
3. The relationship between phonology and phonetics Chomsky and Halle provided an explicit answer about the nature of representations, drawing a distinction between underlying representations, captured in terms of bundles of binary feature matrices, and surface forms, which were the output of the phonology. At this point in the derivation a translation of binary values to scalar values yielded the phonetic transcription. They assumed a modular relationship between phonology and phonetics, where phonology was categorical, whereas phonetics was gradient and continuous. It was also assumed that phonology was the domain of the language specific and phonetics the domain of universal (automatic) aspects of sound patterns. Research since that time has investigated this relationship from many angles, enriching the view of phonetics in the grammar, showing that the dichotomy between phonology and phonetics is not as
28
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
sharp as had been assumed. (See Cohn, 1998, 2006a & b for discussion). We briefly review the nature of this relationship. First, as discussed by Cohn (2006b), there are actually two distinct ways in which phonology and phonetics interact. A distinction needs to be drawn between the way phonology affects or drives phonetics–what Cohn terms phonology in phonetics and the way that phonetics affects phonology–what Cohn terms phonetics in phonology. In the first, the nature of the correlation assumed by SPE, that is, that phonology is discrete and categorical, while phonetics is continuous and gradient – is important. In the second, the place of naturalness, as internal or external to the grammar, is central. From both of these perspectives, we conclude that phonology and phonetics are distinct, albeit not as sharply delineated as implied by strictly modular models. 3.1. Phonology in Phonetics Phonology is the cognitive organization of sounds as they constitute the building blocks of meaningful units in language. The physical realization of phonological contrast is a fundamental property of phonological systems and thus phonological elements are physically realized in time. Phonology emerges in the phonetics, in the sense that phonological contrast is physically realized. This then is the first facet of the relationship between phonology and phonetics: the relationship between these cognitive elements and their physical realization. Implicit in the realization of phonology is the division between categorical vs. gradient effects: phonology captures contrast, which at the same time must be realized in time and space. This leads to the widely assumed correlations in (1). (1)
The relationship between phonology and phonetics: phonology = discrete, categorical ≠ phonetics = continuous, gradient
The correlations in (1) suggest the following relationships: (2)
a. Categorical phonology c. Categorical phonetics
b. Gradient phonology d. Gradient phonetics
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
29
If the correlation between phonology and categoriality on one hand and between phonetics and gradience on the other were perfect, we would expect there to be only categorical phonology (a) and gradient phonetics (d). There are reasons why the correlation might not be perfect, but nevertheless strong enough to re-enforce the view that phonology and phonetics are distinct. On the other hand, perhaps there is in fact nothing privileged about this correlation. In §3.2, we review the evidence for categorical phonology and gradient phonetics. We consider categorical phonetics and gradient phonology in §3.3. 3.2. Categorical phonology and gradient phonetics A widely assumed modular view of grammar frames our modeling of more categorical and more gradient aspects of such phenomena as belonging to distinct modules (e.g. phonology vs. phonetics). We refer to this as a mapping approach. Following a mapping approach, categorical (steady state) patterns observed in the phonetics are understood to result from either lexical or phonological specification and gradient patterns are understood to arise through the implementation of those specifications. Growing out of Pierrehumbert’s (1980) study of English intonation, gradient phonetic patterns are understood as resulting from phonetic implementation. Under the particular view developed there, termed generative phonetics, these gradient patterns are the result of interpolation through phonologically unspecified domains. Keating (1988) and Cohn (1990) extend this approach to the segmental domain, arguing that phenomena such as long distance pharyngealization and nasalization can be understood in these terms as well. Within generative phonetics, the account of gradience follows from a particular set of assumptions about specification and underspecification. It is generally assumed that categoriality in the phonology also follows directly from the nature of perception and the important role of categorical perception. The specific ways in which perception constrains or defines phonology are not well understood, although see Hume and Johnson (2001) for recent discussions of this relationship. A modular mapping approach has been the dominant paradigm to the phonology-phonetics interface since the 1980’s and such approaches have greatly advanced our understanding of phonological patterns and their realization. The intuitive difference between more categorical and more gra-
30
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
dient patterns in the realization of sounds corresponds to the division of labor between phonology and phonetics within such approaches and this division of labor has done quite a lot of work for us. Such results are seen most concretely in the success of many speech synthesis by rule systems both in their modeling of segmental and suprasegmental properties of sound systems. (See Klatt, 1987 for a review.) A modular approach also accounts for the sense in which the phonetics, in effect, acts on the phonology. In many cases, phonological and phonetic effects are similar, but not identical. This is the fundamental character of what Cohn (1998) terms phonetic and phonological doublets, cases where there are parallel categorical and gradient effects in the same language, with independent evidence suggesting that the former are due to the phonology and the latter result from the implementation of the former. For example, this is seen in patterns of nasalization in several languages (Cohn, 1990); palatalization in English (Zsiga, 1995); vowel devoicing in Japanese (Tsuchida, 1997, 1998); as well as vowel harmony vs. vowel-to-vowel coarticulation and vowel harmony, investigated by Beddor and Yavuz (1995) in Turkish and by Przezdziecki (2005) in Yoruba. (See Cohn, 2006b for fuller discussion of this point.) What these cases and many others have in common is that the patterns of coarticulation are similar to, but not the same as, assimilation and that both patterns cooccur in the same language. The manifestations are different, with the more categorical effects observed in what we independently understand to be the domain of the phonology and the more gradient ones in the phonetic implementation of the phonology. To document such differences, instrumental phonetic data is required, as impressionistic data alone do not offer the level of detail needed to make such determinations. Following a mapping approach, assimilation is accounted for in the phonological component and coarticulation in the phonetic implementation. Such approaches predict categorical phonology and gradient phonetics, but do they fully capture observed patterns? What about categorical phonetics and gradient phonology? 3.3. Categorical phonetics and gradient phonology We understand categorical phonetics to be periods of stability in space through time. These result directly from certain discontinuities in the phonetics. This is precisely the fundamental insight in Stevens’s (1989) Quan-
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
31
tal Theory, where he argues that humans in their use of language exploit articulatory regions that offer stability in terms of acoustic output.3 There are numerous examples of this in the phonetic literature. To mention just a few, consider Huffman’s (1990) articulatory landmarks in patterns of nasalization, Kingston’s (1990) coordination of laryngeal and supralaryngeal articulations (binding theory), and Keating’s (1990) analysis of the high jaw position in English /s/. There are many ways to model steady-state patterns within the phonetics without calling into question the basic assumptions of the dichotomous model of phonology and phonetics. To mention just one approach, within a target-interpolation model, phonetic targets can be assigned based on phonological specification as well as due to phonetic constraints or requirements. Such cases then do not really inform the debate about the gray area between phonology and phonetics. The more interesting question is whether there is evidence for gradient phonology, that is, phonological patterns best characterized in terms of continuous variables. It is particularly evidence claiming that there is gradient phonology that has led some to question whether phonetics and phonology are distinct. The status of gradient phonology is a complex issue (for a fuller discussion see Cohn, 2006a). Cohn considers evidence for gradient phonology in the different aspects of what is understood to be phonology – contrast, phonotactics, morphophonemics, and allophony – and concludes that the answer depends in large part on what is meant by gradience and which aspects of the phonology are considered. The conclusions do suggest that strictly modular models involve an oversimplification. While modular models of sound systems have achieved tremendous results in the description and understanding of human language, strict modularity imposes divisions, since each and every pattern is defined as either X or Y (e.g., phonological or phonetic). Yet along any dimension that might have quite distinct endpoints, there is a gray area. For example, what is the status of vowel length before voiced sounds in English, bead [bi:d] vs. beat [bit]? The difference is greater than that observed in many other languages (Keating, 1985), but does it count as phonological? An alternative to the types of approaches that assume that phonology and phonetics are distinct and that there is a mapping between these two modules or domains are approaches that assume that phonology and phonetics are understood and modeled with the same formal mechanisms— what we term unidimensional approaches. A seminal approach in this regard is the theory of Articulatory Phonology, developed by Browman and
32
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
Goldstein (1992 and work cited therein), where it is argued that both phonology and phonetics can be modeled with a unified formalism. This view does not exclude the possibility that there are aspects of what has been understood to be phonology and what has been understood to be phonetics that show distinct sets of properties or behavior. This approach has served as fertile ground for advancing our understanding of phonology as resulting at least in part from the coordination of articulatory gestures. More recently, a significant group of researchers working within constraint-based frameworks has pursued the view that there is not a distinction between constraints that manipulate phonological categories and those that determine fine details of the representation. This is another type of approach that assumes no formally distinct representations or mechanisms for phonology and phonetics, often interpreted as arguing for the position that phonology and phonetics are one and the same thing. The controversy here turns on the question of how much phonetics there is in phonology, to what extent phonetic detail is present in phonological alternations and representations. Three main views have been developed in this respect: (i) phonetic detail is directly encoded in the phonology (e.g., Steriade, 2001; Flemming, 1995/2002, 2001; Kirchner, 1998/2001); (ii) phonetic detail (phonetic naturalness) is only relevant in the context of diachronic change (e.g., Ohala, 1981 and subsequent work; Hyman, 1976, 2001; Blevins, 2004); (iii) phonetic detail is indirectly reflected in phonological constraints, by virtue of phonetic grounding (e.g., Hayes, 1999; Hayes and Steriade, 2004). While there is general agreement on the fact that most phonological processes are natural, that is, “make sense” from the point of view of speech physiology, acoustics, perception, the three views above are quite different in the way they conceptualize the relationship between phonetics and phonology and the source of the explanation. The first view proposes a unidimensional model, in which sound patterns can be accounted for directly by principles of production and perception. One argument in favor of unidimensional approaches is that they offer a direct account of naturalness in phonology, the second facet of the relationship: phonetics in phonology, a topic we will turn to in §4. Under the second view the effect of naturalness on the phonological system is indirect. Under the third view, some phonological constraints are considered to be phonetically grounded, but formal symmetry plays a role in constraint
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
33
creation. The speaker/learner generalizes from experience in constructing phonetically grounded constraints. The link between the phonological system and phonetic grounding is phonetic knowledge (Kingston and Diehl, 1994). An adequate theory of phonology and phonetics, whether modular, unidimensional, or otherwise needs to account for the relationship between phonological units and physical realities, the ways in which phonetics acts on the phonology, as well as to offer an account of phonetics in phonology. We turn now to the nature of phonetics in phonology and the sources of naturalness.
4.
Naturalness
In this section we consider different views of the source of naturalness in phonology (§4.1). We then present evidence bearing on this question (§4.2). The case we examine concerns patterns of consonant timing in Georgian stop clusters (Chitoran et al., 2002; Chitoran and Goldstein, 2006). 4.1. Sources of naturalness Many understand naturalness to be part of phonology. The status of naturalness in phonology relates to early debates in generative phonology about natural phonology (Stampe, 1979, Donegan and Stampe, 1979). This view is also foundational to Optimality Theory (e.g. Prince and Smolensky, 2004), where functional explanations characterized in scalar and gradient terms are central in the definition of the family of markedness constraints. Contrary to the view that “the principles that the rules subserve (the “laws”) are placed entirely outside the grammar […] When the scalar and the gradient are recognized and brought within the purview of theory, Universal Grammar can supply the very substance from which grammars are built.” (Prince and Smolensky, 2004:233-234.) Under such approaches the explanations of naturalness are connected to the notion of markedness. It is sometimes argued that explicit phonological accounts of naturalness pose a duplication problem. Formal accounts in phonological terms (often attributed to Universal Grammar) parallel or mirror the phonetic roots of such developments, thus duplicating the phonetic source or historical de-
34
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
velopment driven by the phonetic source (see Przezdziecki, 2005 for recent discussion). We return to this point below. Others understand naturalness to be expressed through diachronic change. This is essentially approach (ii), the view of Hyman (1976, 2001). Hyman (1976) offers an insightful historical understanding of this relationship through the process of phonologization, whereby phonetic effects can be enhanced and over time come to play a systematic role in the phonology of a particular language. Under this view, phonological naturalness results from the grammaticalization of low-level phonetic effects. While a particular pattern might be motivated historically as a natural change, it might be un-natural in its synchronic realization (see Hyman, 2001 for discussion). Phonetic motivation is also part of Blevins’s (2004) characterization of types of sound change. According to this view only sound change is motivated by phonetic naturalness, synchronic phonology is not. A sound change which is phonetically motivated has consequences which may be exploited (phonologized) by synchronic phonology. Once phonologized, a sound change is subject to different principles, and naturalness becomes irrelevant (see also Anderson, 1981). Hayes and Steriade (2004) propose an approach offering middle ground between these opposing views, worthy of close consideration. They argue that the link between the phonetic motivation and phonological patterns is due to individual speakers’ phonetic knowledge. “This shared knowledge leads learners to postulate independently similar constraints.” (p. 1). They argue for a deductive approach to the investigation of markedness: “Deductive research on phonological markedness starts from the assumption that markedness laws obtain across languages not because they reflect structural properties of the language faculty, irreducible to non-linguistic factors, but rather because they stem from speakers’ shared knowledge of the factors that affect speech communication by impeding articulation, perception, or lexical access.” (Hayes and Steriade, 2004:5).
This view relies on the Optimality Theoretic (OT) framework. Unlike rules, the formal characterization of an OT constraint may include its motivation, and thus offers a simple way of formalizing phonetic information in the grammar. Depending on the specific proposal, the constraints are evaluated either by strict domination or by weighting. Phonetically grounded constraints are phonetically “sensible”; they ban structures that are phonetically difficult, and allow structures that are phonetically easy, thus relying heavily on the notion of “effort”. Such constraints are induced by speakers based on their knowledge of the physical conditions under which speech is pro-
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
35
duced and perceived. Consequently, while constraints may be universal, they are not necessarily innate. To assess these different views, we consider some evidence. 4.2. Illustrating the source of naturalness and the nature of sound change We present here some evidence supporting a view consistent with phonologization and with the role of phonetic knowledge as mediated by the grammar, rather then being directly encoded in it. We summarize a recent study regarding patterns of consonant timing in Georgian stop clusters. Consonant timing in Georgian stop clusters is affected by position in the word and by the order of place of articulation of the stops involved (Chitoran et al., 2002; Chitoran and Goldstein, 2006). Clusters in word-initial position are significantly less overlapped than those in word-internal position. Also, clusters with a back-to-front order of place of articulation (like gd, tp) are less overlapped than clusters with a front-to-back order (dg, pt). (3)
Georgian – word-initial clusters Front-to-back bgera ‘sound’ h h ‘hair lock’ p t ila dg-eb-a ‘stands up’
Back-to-front g-ber-av-s thb-eb-a gd-eb-a
‘fills you up’ ‘warms you’ ‘to be thrown’
The authors initially attributed these differences to considerations of perceptual recoverability, but a subsequent study (Chitoran and Goldstein, 2006) showed that this explanation is not sufficient. Similar measures of overlap in clusters combining stops and liquids also show that back-to-front clusters (kl, rb) are less overlapped than front-to-back ones (pl, rk), even though in these combinations the stop release is no longer in danger of being obscured by a high degree of overlap, and liquids do not rely on their releases in order to be correctly perceived. The timing pattern observed in stop-liquid and liquid-stop clusters is not motivated by perceptual recoverability. Consequently, the same explanation also seems less likely for the timing of stop-stop clusters. It suggests in fact that perceptual recoverability is not directly encoded in the phonology after all, but rather that the systematic differences observed in timing may be due to language-specific coor-
36
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
dination patterns, which can be phonologized, that is, learned as grammatical generalizations. Moreover, in addition to the front-to-back / back-to-front timing patterns, stop-stop clusters show overall an unexpectedly high degree of separation between gestures, more than needed to avoid obscuring the release burst. Some speakers even tend to insert an epenthetic vowel in back-tofront stop clusters, the ones with the most separated gestures. While this process of epenthesis is highly variable at the current stage of the language, it occurs only in the “naturally” less overlapped back-to-front clusters, suggesting a further step towards the phonologization of “natural” timing patterns in Georgian. The insertion of epenthetic vowels could ultimately affect the phonotactics and syllable structure of Georgian. This would be a significant change, especially in the case of word-initial clusters. Word-initial clusters are systematically syllabified as tautosyllabic onset clusters by native speakers. The phonologization of the epenthetic vowels may lead to the loss of wordinitial clusters from the surface phonology of the language, at least those with a back-to-front order of place of articulation. Although the presence of an epenthetic vowel is not currently affecting speakers’ syllabification intuitions, articulatory evidence shows that the syllable structure of Georgian is being affected in terms of articulatory organization. In a C1vC2V sequence with an epenthetic vowel the two consonants are no longer relatively timed as an onset cluster, rather C1 is timed as a single onset relative to the epenthetic vowel (Goldstein et al., 2007). In the model recently developed by Browman & Goldstein (2000) and Goldstein et al. (2006) syllable structure emerges from the planning and control of stable patterns of relative timing among articulatory gestures. A hypothesis proposed in this model states that an onset consonant (CV) is coupled in-phase with the following vowel. If an onset consists of more than one consonant (CCV), each consonant should bear the same coupling relation to the vowel. This would result in two synchronous consonants, which would make one or the other unrecoverable. Since the order of consonants in an onset is linguistically relevant, it is further proposed that the consonants are also coupled to each other in anti-phase mode, meaning in a sequential manner. The result is therefore a competitive coupling graph between the synchronous coupling of each consonant to the vowel, and the sequential coupling of the consonants to each other. Goldstein et al. (2007) examined articulatory measures (using EMMA) which showed that in Georgian, as consonants are added to an onset (CV – CCV – CCCV) the
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
37
time from the target of the rightmost C gesture to the target (i.e., the center) of the following vowel gesture gets shorter. In other words, the rightmost C shifts progressively to the right, closer to the vowel. This is the predicted consequence of the competitive coupling. In this study, two Georgian speakers produced the triplet rial-i ‘commotion’ – k’rial-i ‘glitter’ – ts’k’rial-a ‘shiny clean’. One of the speakers shows the rightward shift of the [r], as expected. This effect has previously also been observed in English, and is known as the ‘c-center’ effect (Browman and Goldstein, 1988, Byrd, 1996). The second speaker, however, did not show the shift in this set of data. This speaker produced an audible epenthetic vowel in the back-to-front sequence [k’r] in all forms. This suggests that [k’] and [r] do not form an onset cluster for this speaker, and in this case no rightward shift is predicted by the model. The rightward shift is absent from this speaker’s data because the competitive coupling is absent. Instead, [r] is coupled in-phase with the following [i], and [k’] is coupled in-phase with the epenthetic vowel. The longer separation observed in Georgian back-to-front clusters may have been initially motivated by phonetic naturalness (perceptual recoverability in stop-stop clusters). But the generalization of this timing pattern to all back-to-front clusters, regardless of segmental composition, and the further development of epenthetic vowels in this context can no longer be attributed directly to the same phonetic cause. An appropriate conclusion to such facts is the phrase coined by Larry Hyman: “Diachrony proposes, synchrony disposes” (Hyman, 2005). Once phonologized, synchronic processes become subject to different factors, therefore the study of phonetic naturalness is relevant primarily within the context of diachronic change. Phonology is the intersection of phonetics and grammar (Hyman, 1976). The naturalness of phonetics (in our example, the reduced gestural overlap in back-to-front clusters) thus interacts with grammatical factors in such a way that the phonetic naturalness observable in phonology (the insertion of epenthetic vowels) is not the direct encoding of phonetic knowledge, but rather phonetic knowledge mediated by the principles of the grammar. This suggests that, as with the case of phonology in phonetics, here too, phonetics and phonology are not reducible to one and the same thing. Processes may be natural in terms of their motivation. In terms of their effect they can be more categorical or more gradient. Studies such as the one outlined above suggest that examining phonetic variability, both within and across languages, may reveal additional facets of complexity, worthy
38
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
of investigation. This brings us back to the two facets of the relationship between phonology and phonetics. As discussed above, it is not the case that coarticulation and assimilation are the same thing, since these patterns are not identical and the coarticulatory effects are built on the phonological patterns of assimilation. It is an illusion to say that treating such patterns in parallel in the phonology and phonetics poses a duplication problem as has been suggested by a number of researchers focusing on the source of naturalness in phonology. Rather the parallel effects are due indirectly to the ways in which phonology is natural, not directly in accounting for the effects through a single vocabulary or mechanism. Thus we need to draw a distinction between the source of the explanation, where indeed at its root some factors may be the same (see Przezdziecki, 2005 for discussion), and the characterization of the patterns themselves, which are similar, but not the same. Since assimilation and coarticulation are distinct, an adequate model needs to account for both of them. The view taken here is that while assimilation might arise historically through the process of phonologization, there is ample evidence that the patterns of assimilation and coarticulation are not reducible to the same thing, thus we need to understand how the more categorical patterns and the more gradient patterns relate. In the following section we consider how the issues discussed so far relate to the question of the relevant units of representation.
5.
The multi-faceted nature of complexity
Based on our discussion of the relationship between phonetics and phonology, it becomes increasingly clear that the notion of complexity in phonology must be a multi-faceted one. As discussion in this chapter highlights, and as also proposed by Maddieson (this volume), Marsico et al. (2004) and subsequent work, different measures of complexity of phonological systems can be calculated, at different levels of representation, notably features, segments, and syllables. The question of the relevant primary units is therefore not a trivial one, as it bears directly on the question of the relevant measure of complexity. Moreover, it brings to the forefront the triad formed by perception units – production units – units of representation. The following important questions then arise:
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
-
39
in measuring complexity, do we need to consider all three members of the triad in their interrelationship, or is only one of the three relevant? does the understanding of the triad change depending on the primary categories chosen? In this section we briefly formulate the questions that we consider relevant in this respect, and we provide background to start a discussion. We distinguish here between units at two levels: units at the level of cognitive representation, and units of perception. The fact that these two types of representations may or may not be isomorphic suggests that a relevant measure of complexity should not be restricted to only one or the other. We propose that the choice of an appropriate unit may depend on whether we are considering: (i) representations, (ii) sound systems, or (iii) sound patterns. For example, when considering exclusively sound systems, the segment or the feature has been shown to be appropriate (Lindblom and Maddieson, 1988; Maddieson, 2006; Marsico et al., 2004), but when considering the patterning of sounds within a system, a unit such as the gesture could be considered equally relevant. The number of representation units proposed in the literature is quite large.4 So far, concrete measures of complexity have been proposed or at least considered for features, segments, and syllables. The most compelling evidence for units of perception has been found also for features, phonemes, and syllables (see Nguyen, 2005 for an overview). A clear consensus on a preferred unit of perception from among the three has not been reached so far. This suggests that all three may have a role to play. In fact, recent work by Grossberg (2003) and Goldinger and Azuma (2003) suggests that different types of units, of smaller and larger sizes, can be activated in parallel. Future experiments will reveal the way in which multiple units are needed in achieving an efficient communication process. If this is the case, then multiple units are likely to be relevant to computations of phonological complexity. Obviously, this question cannot be answered until a fuller understanding of the perception of the different proposed units has been reached. Although more representation units have been proposed in the literature, other than features, segments, and syllables, we will limit our discussion to this subset, which overlaps with that of plausible perception units. The relevance of features for complexity has already been investigated. Marsico et al. (2004) compare measures of complexity based on different sets of not so abstract phonetic dimensions, for example features of the type “high”,
40
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
“front”, “voiced”, etc. Distinctive features as such have not been considered in calculations of complexity, but their role has been investigated in a related measure, that of feature economy (Clements, 2003). The hypothesis based on feature economy predicts that languages tend to maximize the number of sounds in their inventories that use the same feature set, thus maximizing the combinatory possibilities of features. Clements’ thorough survey of the languages in the UPSID database confirms this hypothesis. Speech sounds tend to be composed of features that are already used elsewhere in a given system. The finding that is most interesting relative to complexity is that feature economy is not a matter of the total number of features used per system, but rather of the number of segments sharing a given feature. This is interesting because feature economy can be seen as a measure of complexity at the feature level. Nevertheless, this measure makes direct reference to the segment, another unit of representation. This again brings up the possibility that more than one unit, at the same time, may be relevant for computations of phonological complexity. As pointed out by Pellegrino et al. (2007), the relevance of segments is hard to ignore. While the authors agree that the cognitive relevance of segments is still unclear, they ask: “if we give up the notion of segments, then what is the meaning of phonological inventories?” Thus, at least intuitively, segments cannot be excluded from these considerations. As discussed earlier, this is the level of unit used by Maddieson (1984), and has been the level at which many typological characterizations have been successfully made. More recent approaches to complexity have considered the third unit, the syllable. Maddieson (2007; this volume) has studied the possible correlations between syllable types and segment inventories, and tone contrasts. Other units have not yet been considered in the measure of complexity. Their relevance will depend in part on evidence found for their role in perception and cognitive representation. In addition to this aspect, we believe that relevant measures will also depend on the general context in which the interaction of these units is considered: sound inventories or phonological systems including processes. Moreover, within processes, we expect that the measures will also differ depending on whether we are considering synchronic alternations or diachronic change. Finally, to return to the interaction between phonetics and phonology, the topic with which we started this paper, we believe that understanding phonological complexity may also require an understanding of the relevance of phonetic variation – for example the phoneme-allophone relation – for a measure of phonological complexity.
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
41
Notes 1. Authors’ translation. 2. See Jurafsky et al., (2001) for discussion of the role of predictability of language processing and production. 3. Pierrehumbert et al., (2000) make similar observations. 4. Here we only consider abstractionist models, acknowledging the importance of exemplar models (Johnson, 1997, Pierrehumbert, 2001, 2002, among others). At this point in the development of exemplar models the question of complexity has not been addressed, and it is not easy to tell what, in an exemplar model, could be included in a measure of complexity.
References Anderson, S. 1981 Why phonology isn't “natural”. Linguistic Inquiry 12: 493-539. Beddor, P. and H. Yavuz 1995 The relationship between vowel-to-vowel coarticulation and vowel harmony in Turkish. Proceedings of the 13th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences, volume 2, pp. 44-51. Blevins, J. 2004 Evolutionary Phonology. The Emergence of Sound Patterns Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Browman, C. and L. Goldstein 1988 Some notes on syllable structure in articulatory phonology. Phonetica 45: 140-155. 1992 Articulatory Phonology: an overview. Phonetica 49: 155-180. 2000 Competing constraints on intergestural coordination and selforganization of phonological structures. Bulletin de la Communication Parlée 5: 25-34. Byrd, D. 1996 Influences on articulatory timing in consonant sequences. Journal of Phonetics 24:209-244. Chitoran, I., L. Goldstein, and D. Byrd 2002 Gestural overlap and recoverability: Articulatory evidence from Georgian. In C. Gussenhoven and N. Warner (eds.) Laboratory Phonology 7. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. pp. 419-48. Chitoran, I. and L. Goldstein 2006 Testing the phonological status of perceptual recoverability: Articulatory evidence from Georgian. Poster presented at Laboratory Phonology 10, Paris, France, June-July 2006.
42
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
Chomsky, N. and M. Halle 1968 The Sound Pattern of English. New York, NY: Harper and Row. Clements, G. N. 2003 Feature economy in sound systems. Phonology 20.3: 287–333 Cohn, A.C. 1990 Phonetic and Phonological Rules of Nasalization. UCLA PhD dissertation. Distributed as UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 76. 1998 The phonetics-phonology interface revisited: Where’s phonetics? Texas Linguistic Forum 41: 25-40. 2006a Is there gradient phonology? In G. Fanselow, C. Fery, R. Vogel and M. Schlesewsky (eds.) Gradience in Grammar: Generative Perspectives. Oxford: OUP, pp. 25-44 2006b Phonetics in phonology and phonology in phonetics. To appear in Working Papers of the Cornell Phonetics Laboratory 16. Coupé, C., E. Marsico, and F. Pellegrino this volume Structural complexity of phonological systems Donegan, P. and D. Stampe 1979 The study of natural phonology. In D.A. Dinnsen (ed.) Current approaches to phonological theory. Bloomington: Indiana University Press Flemming, E. 2001 Scalar and categorical phenomena in a unified model of phonetics and phonology. Phonology 18: 7-44. 2002 Auditory Representations in Phonology. New York, NY: Routledge. [Revised version of 1995 UCLA Ph.D. dissertation.] Givón, T. 1991 Markedness in grammar: Distributional, communicative and cognitive correlates of syntactic structure. Studies in Language 15.2: 335-370. Goldinger, S. and T. Azuma 2003 Puzzle-solving science: the quixotic quest for units in speech perception. Journal of Phonetics 31: 305-320 Goldstein, L., D. Byrd, and E. Saltzmann 2006 The role of vocal tract gestural action units in understanding the evolution of phonology. In M. Arbib (ed.) From action to language: The mirror neuron system. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 215-249. Goldstein, L., I. Chitoran, and E. Selkirk 2007 Syllable structure as coupled oscillator modes: Evidence from Georgian vs. Tashlhiyt Berber. Proc. of the 16th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences, Saarbrücken, Germany, August 6-10, 2007. pp. 241-244. Grossberg, S. 2003 Resonant neural dynamics of speech perception. Journal of Phonetics 31: 423-445.
Complexity in phonetics and phonology
43
Haspelmath, M. 2006 Against markedness (and what to replace it with). Journal of Linguistics 42: 25-70. to appear Frequency vs. iconicity in explaining grammatical asymmetries. Cognitive Linguistics 18:4. Hayes, B. 1999 Phonetically-driven phonology: The role of optimality theory and inductive grounding. In M. Darnell, E. Moravscik, M. Noonan, F. Newmeyer, and K. Wheatly (eds.) Functionalism and Formalism in Linguistics, Volume I: General Papers, Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 243-285. Hayes, B. and D. Steriade 2004 Introduction: the phonetic bases of phonological markedness. In B. Hayes, R. Kirchner, and D. Steriade (eds) Phonetically Based Phonology. Cambridge: CUP, pp. 1-33. Huffman, M. 1990 Implementation of Nasal: Timing and Articulatory Landmarks. UCLA PhD dissertation. Distributed as UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 75. Hume, E. 2004 Deconstructing markedness: A predictability-based approach. To appear in Proceedings of The Berkeley Linguistic Society 30. 2006 Language Specific and Universal Markedness: An InformationTheoretic Approach. Paper presented at the Linguistic Society of America Annual Meeting, Colloquium on Information Theory and Phonology. Jan. 7, 2006. Hume, E. and K. Johnson 2001 The Role of Speech Perception in Phonology. San Diego: Academic Press. Hyman, L. 1976 Phonologization. In A. Juilland (ed.) Linguistic Studies Offered to Joseph Greenberg. Vol. 2. Saratoga: Anna Libri, pp. 407-418. 2001 The limits of phonetic determinism in phonology: *NC revisited. In E. Hume and K. Johnson (eds.) The Role of Speech Perception in Phonology. San Diego: Academic Press, pp. 141-185. 2005 Diachrony proposes, synchrony disposes – Evidence from prosody (and chess). Talk given at the Laboratoire Dynamique du Langage, Université de Lyon 2, Lyon, March 25, 2005. Jakobson, R. 1971 Les lois phoniques du langage enfantin et leur place dans la phonologie générale. In Roman Jakobson : Selected Writings, vol. 1. Phonological Studies. 2nd expanded edition. The Hague: Mouton. pp. 317-327.
44
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
Johnson, K. 1997 Speech perception without speaker normalization. In K. Johnson and J. Mullinix (eds.) Talker Variability in Speech Processing. San Diego: Academic Press, pp. 146-165. Jurafsky, D., A. Bell, M. Gregory and W. D. Raymond 2001 Probabilistic relations between words: Evidence from reduction in Lexical Production. In J. Bybee and P. Hopper (eds) Frequency and the Emergence of Linguistic Sstructure. Amsterdam: John Benjamins, pp. 229-254. Keating, P. 1985 Universal phonetics and the organization of grammars. In V. Fromkin (ed.) Phonetic Linguistic Essays in Honor of Peter Ladefoged. Orlando: Academic Press, pp. 115-132. 1988 The window model of coarticulation: articulatory evidence. UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 69: 3-29. 1990 The window model of coarticulation: articulatory evidence. In Kingston and Beckman (eds.) Papers in Laboratory Phonology I: Between the Grammar and the Physics of Speech. Cambridge: CUP, pp. 451-470. Kingston, J. 1990 Articulatory binding. In J. Kingston and M. Beckman (eds.) Papers in Laboratory Phonology I: Between the Grammar and the Physics of Speech. Cambridge: CUP, pp. 406-434. Kingston, J. and R. Diehl 1994 Phonetic knowledge. Language 70: 419-53. Kirchner, R. 1998/2001 An Effort-Based Approach to Consonant Lenition. New York, NY: Routledge. [1998 UCLA Ph.D dissertation] Klatt, D. 1987 Review of text-to-speech conversion for English. JASA 82.3: 737-793. Lehmann, C. 1974 Isomorphismus im sprachlichen Zeichen. In H. Seiler (ed.) Linguistic workshop II: Arbeiten des Kölner Universalienprojekts 1973/4. München: Fink (Structura, 8). pp. 98-123. Lindblom, B. and I. Maddieson 1988 Phonetic universals in consonant systems. In C.N. Li and L.H. Hyman (eds.) Language, Speech and Mind: Studies in Honor of Victoria H. Fromkin. pp. 62-78. Beckenham: Croom Helm. Maddieson, I. 1984 Patterns of Sounds. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 2006 Correlating phonological complexity: Data and validation. Linguistic Typology 10: 108-125.
Complexity in phonetics and phonology 2007
45
Issues of phonological complexity: Statistical analysis of the relationship between syllable structures, segment inventories and tone contrasts. In Solé, M-J.,P.S. Beddor, M. Ohala (eds.) Experimental Approaches to Phonology. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York. this volume Calculating Phonological Complexity. Marsico, E., I. Maddieson, C. Coupé, F. Pellegrino 2004 Investigating the “hidden” structure of phonological systems. Proceedings of The Berkeley Linguistic Society 30: 256-267. Newmeyer, F. 1992 Iconicity and generative grammar. Language 68 : 756-796. Nguyen, N. 2005 La perception de la parole. In Nguyen, N., S. Wauquier-Gravelines, J. Durand (eds.) Phonologie et phonétique: Forme et substance. Paris : Hermès. pp. 425-447. Ohala, J.J. 1981 The listener as a source of sound change. In C. Masek, R. Hendrick, and M. Miller (eds.) Papers from the Parasession on Language and Behavior. Chicago : CLS. pp. 178-203. Pellegrino, F. , C. Coupé, and E. Marsico 2007 An information theory-based approach to the balance of complexity between phonetics, phonology and morphosyntax. Paper presented at the Linguistic Society of America, LSA Complexity Panel, January 2007. Pierrehumbert, J. 1980 The Phonology and Phonetics of English Intonation. MIT Ph.D. dissertation. 2001 Exemplar dynamics: Word frequency, lenition and contrast. In J. Bybee and P. Hooper (eds.) Frequency and the Emergence of Linguistic Structure. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. pp. 137-157. 2002 Word-specific phonetics. In C. Gussenhoven and N. Warner (eds.) Laboratory Phonology 7. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. pp. 101-139. Pierrehumbert, J. M. Beckman, and D. R. Ladd 2000 Conceptual foundations in phonology as a laboratory science. In N. Burton-Roberts, P. Carr and G. Docherty (eds.) Phonological Knowledge: Conceptual and Empirical Issues, New York: Oxford University Press. 273-304. Pouplier, M. 2003 Units of phonological encoding: Empirical evidence. PhD dissertation, Yale University. Prince, A. and P. Smolensky 2004 Optimality Theory: Constraint Interaction in Generative Grammar. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
46
Ioana Chitoran and Abigail C. Cohn
Przezdziecki, M. 2005 Vowel Harmony and Coarticulation in Three Dialects of Yorùbá: Phonetics Determining Phonology, Cornell University PhD dissertation. Stampe, D. 1979 A Dissertation in Natural Phonology. New York: Garland Press. [1973 University of Chicago Ph.D dissertation] Steriade, D. 2001 Directional asymmetries in assimilation: A directional account. In E. Hume and K. Johnson (eds.) The Role of Speech Perception in Phonology. San Diego: Academic Press, pp. 219-250. Stevens, K. 1989 On the quantal nature of speech. Journal of Phonetics 17: 3-45. Trubetzkoy, N.S. 1939 Grundzüge der Phonologie. Publié avec l’appui du Cercle Linguistique de Copenhague et du Ministère de l’instruction publique de la République Tchéco-slovaque. Prague. 1969 Principles of Phonology [Grundzüge der Phonologie] translated by C. Baltaxe. Berkeley: University of California Press. Tsuchida, A. 1997 Phonetics and Phonology of Japanese Vowel Devoicing. Cornell University, PhD dissertation. 1998 Phonetic and phonological vowel devoicing in Japanese. Texas Linguistic Forum 41: 173-188. Vallée, N. 1994 Systèmes vocaliques : de la typologie aux prédictions. PhD dissertation, Université Stendhal, Grenoble. Vallée, N., L-J Boë, J-L Schwartz, P. Badin, C. Abry 2002 The weight of phonetic substance in the structure of sound inventories. ZAS Papers in Linguistics 28: 145-168. Zsiga, E.C. 1995 An acoustic and electropalatographic study of lexical and postlexical palatalization in American English. In B. Connell and A. Arvaniti (eds.) Phonology and Phonetic Evidence: Papers in Laboratory Phonology IV. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 282-302.
Languages’ sound inventories: the devil in the details John J. Ohala 1. Introduction In this paper I am going to modify somewhat a statement made in Ohala (1980) regarding languages’ speech sound inventories exhibiting the ‘maximum use of a set of distinctive features’. In that paper, after noting that vowel systems seem to conform to the principle of maximal acousticperceptual differentiation (as proposed earlier by Björn Lindblom), I observe:
SWIN|KCrEIB1Qqc8svpQueSEh0w==|1282027947
... it would be most satisfying if we could apply the same principles to predict the arrangement of consonants, i.e., posit an acoustic-auditory space and show how the consonants position themselves so as to maximize the inter-consonantal distance. Were we to attempt this, we should undoubtedly reach the patently false prediction that a 7 consonant system should include something like the following: , k’, ts, , m, r, . Languages which do have few consonants, such as the Polynesian languages, do not have such an exotic inventory. In fact, the languages which do possess the above set (or close to it) such as Zulu, also have a great many other consonants of each type, i.e., ejectives, clicks, affricates, etc. Rather than maximum differentiation of the entities in the consonant space, we seem to find something approximating the principle which would be characterized as “maximum utilization of the available distinctive features”. This has the result that many of the consonants are, in fact, perceptually quite close – differing by a minimum, not a maximum number of distinctive features.1
Looking at moderately large to quite large segment inventories like those in English, French, Hindi, Zulu, Thai, this is exactly the case. Many segments are phonetically similar and as a consequence are confusable. Some data showing relatively high rates of confusion of certain CV syllables (presented in isolation, hi-fi listening condition) (from Winitz et al. 1972) are given in Table 1.
48
John J. Ohala
Table 1. Confusion matrix from Winitz et al. (1972). Spoken syllables consisted of stop burst plus 100 msec of following transition and vowel; high-fidelity listening conditions. Numbers given are the incidence of the specified response to the specified stimulus.
Stimulus:
Response: /pi/ /pa/ /pu/ /ti/ /ta/ /tu/ /ki/ /ka/ /ku/
/p/ .46 .83 .68 .03 .15 .10 .15 .11 .24
/t/ .38 .07 .10 .88 .63 .80 .47 .20 .18
/k/ .17 .11 .23 .09 .22 .11 .38 .70 .58
I do actually believe that the degree of auditory distinctiveness plays some role in shaping languages’ segment inventories—especially when auditory distinctiveness is low. Sound change, acting blindly (i.e., nonteleologically), weeds out similar sounding elements through confusion which results in mergers and loss. The loss in some dialects of English of // and // and their merger with either /f/ and /v/ (respectively) or with /t/ and /d/ (respectively) is a probable example. I also believe it is sound change, again acting blindly, which is largely responsible for the introduction of new series of segments which involve re-use of some pre-existing features. In some cases there is historical evidence of this. Proto-IndoEuropean had only three series of stops: voiced, voiceless, and breathyvoiced (i.e., among labials: /b/, /p/, /b/). The voiceless aspirated series, /p/, exemplified in Sanskrit and retained in many of the modern Indo-Aryan languages (like Hindi) developed by sound change from the (simple) voiceless series. And a fifth (!) series of stops, the voiced implosives, /©, ∫, etc./ in Sindhi developed from geminated versions of the (simple) voiced stops. Similarly we know that the nasal vowels in French and Hindi developed out of the pre-existing oral vowels plus following nasal consonant (with the nasal consonant lost). (E.g., French saint [sɛ̃] < Latin sanctus “holy”; Hindi dant “tooth” [d)t] < IE dont-, dent- “tooth”.) It is also relevant to my case that historically French once had as many nasal as oral vowels and then over the centuries reduced the nasal vowel inventory due to, I have argued, auditory similarity (Ohala and Ohala, 1993).
Languages' sound inventories: the devil in the details
49
But the point that I want to revise or distance myself from somewhat is the idea that re-use of distinctive features always results in a cost-minimal augmentation, vis-à-vis the introduction of segments that are distinguished by virtually all new distinctive features. I suppose the basic message I am emphasizing here is that the apparent symmetry found in many languages’ segment inventories (or possibly the symmetry imposed by the analyst who put segments in matrices where all rows and columns are uniformly filled) obscures a more complicated situation. There is a great deal of what is referred to as allophonic variation, usually lawful contextual variation. What this means is that the neat symmetrical matrices of speech sound inventories are really abstractions. The complications – the devilish details referred to in my title – have been ‘swept under the rug’! Can we ignore this variation when speculating about common cross-language tendencies in the form of languages’ segment inventories? I say ’no’ since in many cases the same principles are at work whether they lead to apparent symmetry or asymmetry, and I’ll give some examples in the following sections.
2. Some examples of devilish details 2.1. [p] is weaker than other voiceless stops Among languages that have both voiced and voiceless stops, the voiceless bilabial [p] is occasionally missing, e.g., Berber, and this gap is much more common than a gap at any other place of articulation among voiceless stop series.2 In Japanese the /p/ has a distribution unlike other voiceless stops: it doesn’t occur in word-initial position except in onomatopoeic vocabulary (e.g., /patapatSa/, ‘splash’) or medially as a geminate (e.g., /kap˘a/ ‘cucumber sushi’) or in a few other medial environments. Phonetically in English and many other languages the burst of the /p/ has the lowest intensity of any of the voiceless stops. The reason, of course, is that there is no downstream resonator to amplify the burst. We should see that the latter phonetic fact is the unifying principle underlying all these patterns. (And this is, in part, the reason why the sequence [pi] is confused with [ti], as documented in Table 1.)
50
John J. Ohala
2.2. Voicing in stops and place of articulation Among voiced stops, the velar, [g], is often missing in languages stop inventory even though they may have a voicing contrast in stops articulated at more forward places of articulation, e.g., in Thai, Dutch, and Czech (in native vocabulary). In some languages, morphophonemic variations involving the gemination of voiced stops shows an asymmetry in their behavior depending on how far front or back the stop is articulated. E.g., in Nubian (see Table 2), the geminate bilabial stop retains its voicing; those made further back become voiceless. Table 2. Morphophonemic variation in Nubian (from Bell, 1971) Noun stem /fab/
Stem + “and” /fab˘çn/
English gloss father
/sd/
/st˘çn/
scorpion
/kadÉ/
/katɢçn/
donkey
/m/
/mkːçn/
dog
The usual descriptions of the allophonic variation of “voiced” stops in English (/b d g/) is that they are voiceless unaspirated in word-initial position but voiced between sonorants. In my speech, however, and that of another male native speaker of American English, I have found that // is voiceless even intervocalically. See Figure 1 (subject DM) which gives the waveform and accompanying pharyngeal pressure (sampled with a thin catheter inserted via the nasal cavity). The utterance, targeted as /´»gA/ is manifested as [´»kA]. However, as shown in Figure 2, when the pharyngeal pressure was artificially lowered (by suction applied via a second catheter inserted in the other side of the nasal cavity), the // was voiced!
Languages' sound inventories: the devil in the details
[
ˈɡ ̥
51
]
Figure 1. Acoustic waveform (top) and pharyngeal pressure (bottom) of the utterance /´/ spoken by subject DM, a male native speaker of American English. Condition: no venting of pharyngeal pressure. Phonetically the realization of the intervocalic stop was voiceless.
[
]
Figure 2. Acoustic waveform (top) and pharyngeal pressure (bottom) of the utterance /´g/ spoken by subject DM, a male native speaker of American English. Condition: artificial venting of pharyngeal pressure. Phonetically the realization of the intervocalic stop was voiced (evident in the pressure signal).
52
John J. Ohala
All of these patterns, from the absence of [] in Thai to the voiceless realization of // intervocalically in American English speakers are manifestations of the same universal aerodynamic principle: the possibility of voicing during stops requires a substantial pressure drop across the glottis and this depends partly on the volume of the cavity between the point of articulation and the larynx and more importantly on the possibility of passive expansion of that cavity in order to ‘make room’ for the incoming air flow. Velars and back-articulated stops have less possibility to accommodate the incoming airflow and so voicing is threatened.
3. On the various cues for obstruent “voicing” in English Lisker (1986) listed several features in addition to presence/absence of voicing or differences in VOT by which the so-called ‘voicing distinction’ in English obstruents is differentiated perceptually. 3.1. F0 perturbations on vowels following stops The vowels immediately after voiced and voiceless obstruents show a systematic F0 variation. Figure 3 shows data from Hombert et al. (1979). These curves represent unnormalized averages of 100 msec of the F0 contours following /b d g/ (lower curve) and /p t k/ (upper curve) from 5 speakers of American English. Each curve is the average of 150 tokens. (Given that /p t k/ have a positive VOT whereas /b d g/ has VOT close to zero, the onset of the curves are phase shifted with respect to moment of stop release.)3 Such F0 differences can be explained as being mechanically caused due to differences in vocal cord state, i.e., they seem not to be purposeful on the part of speakers; see Ohala et al. (2004). Nevertheless Fujimura (1971) has presented evidence that such F0 contours are used by native speakers of English to differentiate this contrast when all other cues have been neutralized. Does this mean that English is a tone language? We would probably answer ‘no’ since the speaker doesn’t have to separately produce and control the tension of the laryngeal muscles to implement these F0 differences. So it is English listeners, if not the speakers, that have the added complexity in their perceptual task of recognizing F0 differences just as native speakers of tone languages do. It is not much of a simplification of the sound system of a language if the language users (in their role as
Languages' sound inventories: the devil in the details
53
listeners) have to have skill in categorical recognition of short-term F0 contours in addition to recognizing voicing itself or VOT differences.
F0 (Hz)
140
p
130
b
120
20
Time (ms)
100
Figure 3. Average fundamental frequency values of vowels following English stops (data from five speakers). The curves labelled [p] and [b] represent the values associated with all voiceless and voiced stops, respectively – regardless of place of articulation. The zero point on abscissa represents the moment of voice onset; with respect to stop release, this occurs later in real time in voiceless aspirated stops (from Hombert et al., 1979).
3.2. Secondary cues to voicing in coda obstruents As is well known, the class of supposedly voiced and voiceless obstruents in coda position are reliably differentiated by vowel duration, longer duration of the vowel before ‘voiced’ obstruents than before voiceless ones (by ratios of up to 3:2). Since this ratio is so large and there is no apparent “me-
54
John J. Ohala
chanical” cause of this difference, as Lisker (1974) concluded, this means that in this case both speaker and listener have to have distinctive vowel length in their grammars. 3.3. Vowel-influenced variations in VOT Several studies have shown that the positive VOT of the voiceless aspirated stops in English show vowel-specific variations (Lisker and Abramson 1964, 1967; Ohala 1981a): VOT is longer before (actually when the stop is coarticulated with) high close vowels than before open vowels. These variations are probably an automatic consequence of differences in degree of aerodynamic resistance to the exiting airflow. The higher resistance offered by the close vowels delays the decay of Po and thus the onset of voicing. Figure 4 (from Ohala, 1981a) gives data from English and Japanese (from unpublished studies by Robert Gaskins and Mary Beckman, respectively). The English data provide further evidence on the tendency of backarticulated “voiced” stops to be voiceless since here, even the so-called “voiced” velar has a positive VOT. Lisker and Abramson (1967) have shown that listeners are sensitive to these vowel-specific variations: crossover points in the identification of the two categories of stops when presented in a VOT continuum also vary with the quality of the following vowel. This phonetic detail therefore must be part of the English-speaking listener’s knowledge about the sound pattern of the language. I could add many other examples where there are numerous acoustic features characteristic of specific consonant-vowel sequences or at least specific classes of sounds in the context of other specific classes. The net result of this is to add complexity to the signaling system of language that goes beyond what is implied by simply adding another row or column to the language’s phoneme inventory.
Languages' sound inventories: the devil in the details
a)
VOT (ms)
100
ENGLISH
55
k_ t_ p_
50 g_
0
i
eI E
Q AI
A
oU u
‘
Postconsonantal Vowel JAPANESE k_
50
p_ VOT (ms)
b)
t_ 0
i
e
A
o
μ
Postconsonantal Vowel
Figure 4. VOT variation for stops as a function of following vowel in English (a) and Japanese (b) (from Ohala, 1981a).
4. Conclusion If we conceive our task as phonologists as one of characterizing and understanding the function of speech to serve as a medium of communication then we want to know the implications for this function of the differences between the phonological system of, say, Rotokas with its 11 phonemes and !Xu with its 141 phonemes. Just by listing the segmental inventories in the traditional articulatory matrix does not tell the whole story. Adding new columns or rows can complicate the task of the language’s speakers. The evidence that experimental phonetics has uncovered about so-called ‘sec-
56
John J. Ohala
ondary distinctive features’ in virtually every language whose sound system has been studied in some detail, especially the findings that these features may be different in different contexts, makes it clear that a language’s phonological complexity is itself a complex issue. In the model of sound change that I have proposed (Ohala 1981b, 1993) the so-called ‘secondary’ features are very important for understanding why change takes place and why it takes a particular direction. A feature that was secondary can become one of the primary distinctive features of a phonological contrast if the primary feature(s) are not detected or are misinterpreted. The important point in this model is that some of the elements of the “after” state were already present in the “before” state, without being explicitely listed in the inventory. What type of (re)presentation would correct the deficiencies found in the familiar matrices of languages’ segment inventories that I have argued reduce their utility? To begin with, to the extent that the detailed phonetic character of sounds has been uncovered through empirical means, then segment inventories should show that. E.g., when presenting the English stops, rather than labeling them as [voiced] and [voiceless], they should be given with more accurate labels: [voiceless unaspirated] and [voiceless aspirated], respectively. Another example: if certain dialects of Swedish have an alveolar or apical-retracted voiced stop vs. a dental voiceless stop (Livijn and Engstrand, 2001), then they should not both appear in the same “place of articulation” column. Many other languages show the same pattern, i.e., where the voiced coronal stop has a place of articulation that is more posterior than that of its voiceless “counterpart” (Sprouse, Solé and Ohala, 2008). Of course, systematic contextual variation should also be noted, e.g., that the voiced apical stop in English is often realized as a tap [] in some contexts. Also, an elaborated but much more useful account of the contrasts in a language should reflect in some way whether there is any evidence that there are differences in the cognitive task/abilities required of speakers vs. listeners in processing allophonic differences due to phonetic context. For example, as mentioned above, the slight differences in VOT before different vowels (close vowels showing slightly longer VOT than those before more open vowels) is probably not something the speaker has to implement purposefully; they will occur due to physical constraints (the greater impedance to the exiting airflow delays the achievement of the transglottal pressure difference necessary to initiate voicing). Nevertheless, listeners are no doubt aware of these differences and use them when identifying pre-vocalic stops. Thus the “knowledge” of the speaker and hearer
Languages' sound inventories: the devil in the details
57
about contextual variation may be different and the “compleat” psychologically valid phonological grammar of a language should reflect this. Thus we need to pay more attention to the devilish details in the implementation of phonological contrasts. It may help us to understand better both sound change and the communicative function of speech.
Notes 1. The IPA symbols in this quote conform to current conventions, not those in 1980. 2. For a survey of gaps in consonant inventories, see Sherman (1975). 3. See also Ohala (1974) for similar data on F0 following the release of /s/ and /z/.
References Bell, H. 1971
The phonology of Nobiin Nubian. African Language Review 9: 115139.
Fujimura, O. 1971 Remarks on stop consonants: synthesis experiments and acoustic cues. In: L. L. Hammerich, R. Jakobson and E. Zwirner (eds.), Form and substance: phonetic and linguistic papers presented to Eli Fischer-Jørgensen. pp. 221-232. Copenhagen: Akademisk Forlag. Hombert, J.-M., Ohala, J. J., & Ewan, W. G. 1979 Phonetic explanations for the development of tones. Language 55: 37-58. Lisker, L. 1974 On ‘explaining’ vowel duration variation. Glossa 8: 233-246 1986 ’Voicing’ in English: A catalogue of acoustic features signaling /b/ vs. /p/ in trochees. Language and Speech 29. pp. 3-11. Lisker, L., & Abramson, A. 1964 A cross-language study of voicing in initial stops: Acoustical measurements. Word, 20: 384-422. 1967 Some effects of context on voice onset time in English stops. Language and Speech, 10: 1-28. Livijn, P. & Engstrand, O. (2001) Place of articulation for coronals in some Swedish dialects. Proceedings of Fonetik 2001, the XIVth Swedish Phonetics Conference, Örenäs, May 30 - June 1, 2001. Working Papers, Department of Linguistics, Lund University 49, pp. 112-115.
58
John J. Ohala
Ohala, J. J. 1974
Experimental historical phonology. In: J. M. Anderson & C. Jones (eds.), Historical Linguistics II, Theory and description in phonology: Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Historical Linguistics, Edinburgh. pp. 353-389. Amsterdam: North-Holland. 1980 Moderator's summary of symposium on 'Phonetic universals in phonological systems and their explanation.' Proc., 9th Int. Cong. of Phon. Sc. Vol. 3. Copenhagen: Institute of Phonetics. pp. 181-194. 1981a Articulatory constraints on the cognitive representation of speech. In: T. Myers, J. Laver, and J. Anderson (eds.), The Cognitive Representation of Speech. Amsterdam: North Holland. pp. 111-122. 1981b The listener as a source of sound change. In: C. S. Masek, R. A. Hendrick, & M. F. Miller (eds.), Papers from the Parasession on Language and Behavior. Chicago: Chicago Ling. Soc. pp. 178 - 203. 1993 The phonetics of sound change. In Charles Jones (ed.), Historical Linguistics: Problems and Perspectives. London: Longman. pp. 237-278. Ohala, J. J., A. Dunn, & R. Sprouse. 2004 Prosody and Phonology. Speech Prosody 2004, Nara, Japan. Ohala, J. J. & Ohala, M. 1993 The phonetics of nasal phonology: theorems and data. In M. K. Huffman & R. A. Krakow (eds.), Nasals, nasalization, and the velum. San Diego, CA: Academic Press. pp. 225-249. Sherman, D. 1975 Stop and fricative systems: a discussion of paradigmatic gaps and the question of language sampling. Stanford Working Papers in Language Universals. 17: 1-31. Sprouse, R, Solé, M-J. and Ohala, J. 2008. Oral cavity enlargement in retroflex sounds. Paper delivered at the 8th International Seminar on Speech Production, Strasbourg. Winitz, H., Scheib, M. E. & J. A. Reeds. 1972 Identification of stops and vowels, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 51.4: 1309-1317
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels René Carré Vowels can be produced with static articulatory configurations represented by dots in acoustic space (generally by formant frequencies in the F1-F2 plane). But because vowel characteristics vary with speaker, consonantal environment (co-articulation) and production rate (reduction phenomena), vowel formant frequencies can also be represented by their mean values and standard deviations, according to different categories (language, age and gender of speaker). The use of ‘targets’ means that they are generally studied from a static point of view. But several questions can be raised: How are vowel representations set up if vowel realizations rarely reach their targets in running speech production (vowel reduction (Lindblom, 1963))? Is representation the same from one person to another? How is a given vowel, produced several times with different acoustic characteristics and in different environments, identified? By using contextual information? By normalization? These questions lead to studying vowels from a dynamic point of view. Here, we first propose a theoretical deductive approach to vowel-tovowel dynamics which leads to a specification in terms of vocalic trajectories in the acoustic space characterized by their directions. Then, results on V1V2 transitions produced and perceived by subjects will be presented. In production, measurements of the F1 and F2 transition rates are represented in the F1 rate/F2 rate plane. In perception, direction and rate of synthesized transitions are studied for transitions situated outside the traditional F1/F2 vowel triangle. This situation enables the study of transitions characterized only by their directions and rates without relation to any vowel targets of the vowel triangle. Such experiments show that these transitions can be perceived as V1V2. Several issues can then be revisited in the light of this dynamic representation: vocalic reduction, hyper and hypo speech, normalization, perceptual overshoot, etc. A fully dynamic representation of both vowels and consonants is proposed.
60
René Carré
1. Introduction Vowels are generally characterized by the first two or three formant frequencies. Each of them can be represented in the acoustic space (F1-F2 plane) by a dot (Peterson and Barney, 1952). This specification is static. Vowels can be produced in isolation without articulatory variations, but in natural speech such cases are atypical since their acoustic characteristics are not stable. They vary with the speaker and with the age and gender of the speaker, with the consonantal context (coarticulation), with the speaking rate (reduction phenomena), and with the language (Lindblom, 1963). So, vowels are classified into crude classes, first according to the language, and then according to speaker categories. Within each category, vowels can be specified in terms of underlying ‘targets’ corresponding to the contextand duration-independent values of the formants as obtained by fitting “decaying exponentials” to the data points (Moon and Lindblom, 1994). The point in focus here is that this specification is static and, significantly, may be taken to imply that the perceptual representation corresponds to the target values (Strange, 1989). At this point, several questions can be raised: How is the perceptual representation obtained if the vowel targets depend on the speaker, and are rarely reached in spontaneous speech production? Are the representations the same from one person to another (Johnson, et al., 1993; Carré and Hombert, 2002; Whalen, et al., 2004)? How is this perceptual representation built: by learning, or is it innate? How is the vowel perceived with its different acoustic characteristics according to the context and the speaker: by normalization (Nordström and Lindblom, 1975; Johnson, 1990; Johnson, 1997)? Why is vowel perception less categorical than consonant perception (Repp, et al., 1979; Schouten and van Hessen, 1992)? Many studies have been undertaken to answer these questions. The results are generally incomplete and contradictory. They cannot be used to set up a simple theory explaining all the results. But they help highlight the importance of dynamics in vowel perception (Shankweiler, et al., 1978; Verbrugge and Rakerd, 1980; Strange, 1989). In view of the fact that sensory systems have been shown experimentally to be more sensitive to changing stimulus patterns than to purely steady-state ones, it appears justified to look for an alternative to static targets - a specification that recognizes the true significance of signal time variations. One possibility is that dynamics can be characterized by the direction and the rate of the vocalic transitions:
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 61
•
Vowel-vowel trajectories in the F1/F2 plane are generally rectilinear (Carré and Mrayati, 1991). So they can be characterized by their direction. Moreover, privileged directions are observed in the production of vowels (in single-vowel or CV syllables) called ‘vowel inherent spectral changes, VISC’ (Nearey and Assmann, 1986). Moreover, perception experiments show the importance of VISC in improving vowel identification (Hillenbrand, et al., 1995; Hillenbrand and Nearey, 1999). • On the topic of transition rate, we recall the results of Kent and Moll (1969): “the duration of a transition – and not its velocity – tends to be an invariant characteristic of VC and CV combinations”. Gay (1978) confirmed these observations with different speaking rates and with vowel reduction: “the reduction in duration during fast speech is reflected primarily in the duration of the vowel,… the transition durations within each rate were relatively stable across different vowels…”. If the transition duration is invariant across a set of CV’s with C the same and varying Vs, it follows that the transition rate depends both on the consonant and the vowel to be produced. So the time domain could play an important role in the identification of vowels (Fowler, 1980). For example, to discriminate the sequences [ae], [a], and [ai], what acoustic information does the listener need? The answer is that the second vowel V2 can be detected by using the transition rate as a cue. This parameter can be specific to the speaker and/or related to the syllabic rate. At the very beginning of the transition and throughout the transition there is sufficient information to detect V2. There are no privileged points in time (for example the middle of V2 to measure the formant frequencies) for V2 detection. The rate measure is therefore very appropriate in a noisy environment. It can also explain the perceptual results obtained by Strange et al. (1983) in ‘silent center’ experiments that replaced the center of the vowel by silence of equivalent duration. This manipulation preserves the direction and the rate of the transition as well as the temporal organization (syllabic rate). Also relevant are experiments by Divenyi et al. (1995) showing that, in V1V2 stimuli, V2 was perceived even when V2 and the last half of the transition was removed by gating. Finally, it can be observed that both Arabic (Al-Tamimi, et al., 2004) and Vietnamese subjects (Castelli and Carré, 2005) have difficulties in producing and perceiving isolated vowels.
62
René Carré
In this paper, a deductive theoretical approach to the study of vowel-tovowel dynamics is proposed. It leads to a specification of vocalic trajectories in the acoustic space characterized by their directions. Then, results of the production and the perception of V1V2 transitions by French subjects are presented. Production measurements of the F1, F2 transition rates are represented in a F1 rate / F2 rate plane. In a perceptual study, we focus on the direction and rate of synthesized transitions situated outside the traditional F1/F2 vowel triangle. This situation enables the study of transitions characterized only by their directions and rates without reference to any vowel targets in the vowel triangle.
2. Deductive approach and vowel-to-vowel trajectories Here, we try to infer vowel properties, not from data on vowel production and perception, but by a deductive approach starting from general physical properties of an acoustic tube. If the goal is to build an efficient device for acoustic communication, i.e. a device that gives maximum acoustic contrast for minimum area shape deformation, then the tube must be structured into specific regions leading to a corresponding organization of the acoustic space (Carré, 2004; Carré, 2009). A recursive algorithm using the calculation of the sensitivity function (Fant and Pauli, 1974) deforms “efficiently” the shape of the tube in order to increase (or decrease), step by step, the formant frequencies. By “efficiently” we mean that a small or minimal area shape deformation gives maximum formant variations in the F1/F2 plane The acoustic space automatically obtained corresponds to the vowel triangle (which is, consequently, maximal in size; it cannot be larger) (Carré, 2009). [a] is obtained with a back constriction and a front cavity; [i] with a front constriction and a back cavity; [u] with a central constriction and two lateral cavities. In the first two cases, the front end of the tube is open; in the last case the front end is almost closed. The specific regions automatically obtained correspond to the main places of articulation (front, back and central) used to produce vowels (Carré, 2009). The shape deformations can be represented by deformation gestures corresponding to three different “tongue” gestures and one “lip” gesture. The three different tongue gestures are: a transversal deformation gesture from front to back places of articulation (and vice-versa) producing [ia] (or [ai])), a longitudinal deformation gesture from front to central constriction producing [iu] and a longitudinal displacement gesture from back to central place of articulation producing
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 63
[au] (Carré, 2009). The lip gesture is used to reach [u] (low F1 and F2). The deformations can easily be modelled by the Distinctive Region Model (DRM) (Mrayati, et al., 1988; Carré, 2009). F1-F2 Plane 300
[i]
[e]
[] [y] [ø] [æ] [œ] [] [a] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [o] [u]
200 F2 (Hz)
100
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
F1 (Hz)
Figure 1. Vocalic trajectories obtained by deduction from acoustic characteristics of a tube and corresponding vowels. Dotted lines are labialized trajectories (Carré, 2009).
From the DRM model, eight more or less rectilinear trajectories structuring the acoustic space were obtained: [ai], [u], [iu], [ay], [], [uy], [i], [yu] (Figure 1). The maximum acoustic space obtained by this approach fits well with the vowel triangle. The use of the DRM does not lead to characterising vowels first, but rather privileges vocalic trajectories. A maximum acoustic contrast criterion (Carré, 2009) would select the endpoints, and intermediate points on the trajectories which correspond well with the vowels given for example by Catford (1988). Recall that the recursive algorithm calculates, from an initial shape of the area function of a tube, a new shape according to a minimum of energy criterion (minimum deformation leads to maximum acoustic variation) (Carré, 2004). This operation is repeated until the maximum acoustic limits of the tube are reached. Thus, the algorithm simulates an evolutionary process (the goal is not pre-specified at the beginning of the process), by simply increasing acoustic contrast, step by step, according to a minimum
64
René Carré
of energy criterion. The resulting trajectories in the acoustic plane can be characterized by their directions. On the basis of the above discussion stressing the importance of the formant trajectories we hypothesize that the perception of vowels might be understood, not in terms of static targets, but in terms of a dynamic measure of the direction and rate of spectral change characterizing such trajectories. We will test this hypothesis in a series of studies of vowel-to-vowel sequences.
3. Vowel-vowel production [V1V2] sequences were produced 5 times by 5 male and 5 female speakers, all French, at 2 different rates (normal and fast). In the following experiments, V1 is always /a/ and V2 is one of the French vowels situated on the [ai] ([i, , e]), [ay] ([y, œ, ø]) or [au] ([u, o, ]) trajectories. A French word containing V2 appears on the computer screen with alphabetic representation to help the subject who may have no phonetic knowledge. To exemplify, the instructions were the following: at ‘fast’ rate: say ‘a-i’ as in the word ‘lit’. The recording process was controlled by PC software that randomly presented the succession of the items to be recorded. In the case of bad pronunciation, or hesitation, the speaker had the possibility of pronouncing the item again. Formant frequencies were measured using Praat software every 6.25 ms. The formant variations were smoothed with a 43.75 ms time window by calculating the mean values of the formants obtained for 7 successive frames (running mean value). Then, the derivation was taken to obtain the formant transition rate. The formant rate was also smoothed with a 43.75 ms window (running mean value). Figure 2 shows, for [ai] as produced by speaker RC at normal rate, the formant transitions, the formant transition rate, the formant transition acceleration, in the time domain and in the plane defined by the F2/F1 parameters. Maxima and minima of the F1 and F2 frequencies, rates and accelerations were measured to characterize the formant transitions.
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 65 [ai] N(rc1)
[ai] N(rc1) 3000
2000
F1
1000
F2
F2 (Hz)
F (Hz)
3000
2000 1000
0
0
0
200
400
0
500
a)
b) 8 6 4 2 0 -2 0 -4 -6
[ai]
N(rc1)
10 F1 F2 200
400
Δ F2 (Hz/ms)
Δ F (Hz/ms)
[ai] N(rc1)
5
-5
-4
-3
-2
0 -1 0 -5
1
2
3
4
5
-10 Δ F1 (Hz/ms)
t (ms)
c)
d) [ai] N(rc1)
D2 (Hz/ms/ms)
0.6 0.4 0.2
F1
0
F2
-0.2 0
200
400
D2F2 (Hz/ms/ms)
[ai] N(rc1)
-0.4
1 0.5 0 -0.5
-0.5
0
0.5
-1 D2F1 (Hz/ms/ms)
t (ms)
e)
1000
F1 (Hz)
t (ms)
f)
Figure 2. [ai] production, at normal rate, for speaker RC, a) F1 and F2 formant transition in the time domain, b) corresponding formant trajectory in the F1-F2 plane, c) F1 and F2 rate in the time domain, d) formant rate trajectory in the F1 rate-F2 rate plane, e) F1 and F2 acceleration in the time domain, and f) formant acceleration trajectory in the F1 acceleration-F2 acceleration plane.
66
René Carré
3.1. Vowel formants The vowel formant frequencies for [aV] as produced by speaker EM are represented in the F1/F2 plane (figure 3). The data points are the mean values of the 5 occurrences for normal and fast production (N and F). Standard deviations for F1 and F2 are also indicated. There are no significant differences between normal and fast productions which could be expected because, in V1-V2 production, the target V2 is always reached. The vowels can be easily separated.
F2 (Hz)
Max F1-F2 for V, for normal and fast production
N(em) F(em)
2500
[ai]
[ai]
2000
[ae]
[ae]
[a]
[a]
1500
[ay]
[ay]
1000
[aø]
[aø]
500
[aœ]
[aœ]
[au]
[au]
[ao]
[ao]
[a]
[a]
[a]
[a]
0 0
200
400
600
800
F1 (Hz)
1000
Figure 3. Mean F1 and F2 frequencies and standard deviations plotted in the F1/F2 plane for [aV] tokens produced by speaker EM, at normal (N) and fast (F) rates. Each item is produced 5 times (45 times for [a]).
3.2. [aV] transitions 3.2.1. [aV] characteristics in the F1-F2 plane Figure 4 shows the different formant trajectories for [ai], [ae], [a], [ay], [aœ], [aø] and [au], [ao], [a] in the F1-F2 plane for one speaker EM. Each trajectory is a single production pronounced at normal rate. The trajectories are rather rectilinear and follow, as far as [ai] and [au] are concerned, the basic trajectories obtained by deduction (figure 1): [e], [] are situated
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 67
along the formant movement of [ai]; [o] and [] on the [au] trace. Figure 4 also shows that the end parts of the trajectories corresponding to V can be characterized by small changes along the rectilinearity of the trajectory. This result corresponds to the “vowel inherent spectral changes” observed by Nearey and Assmann (1986) for the final vowel in VCV sequences and by Carré et al. (2004) for isolated vowels. These characteristics are also observed for the other speakers. [aV] trajectories 2500
[i]
[e] []
F2 (Hz)
2000 [y]
1500
[ø] [u]
500
[a]
[œ]
1000 [o]
[]
0 0
200
400
600
800
1000
F1 (Hz)
Figure 4. [aV] formant trajectories for speaker EM (normal rate). The small changes at the ends of the trajectories corresponding to V do not deviate significantly from the rectilinearity of the trajectories.
3.2.2. [aV] transition rate The representation of the F1-F2 transition rate as in figure 2d is used to compare the [aV] transitions for all V. Figure 5a shows the results for speaker EM with one utterance of each [aV]. It can be observed that: if, for example, [ai], [ae], [a] are compared, three distinct rate trajectories can be discriminated. The rate trajectory of [ai] is longer than that of [ae] and still longer than that of [a]. In other words, the maximum rate of [ai] is greater than the maximum rates of [ae] and of [a]. Figure 5b shows, for [ai], [ae], [a] and for one production by speaker EM, the first formant rates in the time domain. The three vowels can be discriminated according to the maximum rates corresponding more or less to the middle of the transition ([ai] maximum rate > [ae] maximum rate > [a] maximum rate). Discrimi-
68
René Carré
nation can also be obtained throughout the transition and especially from the very beginning of the transition (from the very beginning of the production task). Figure 5b shows that the three transitions (for [ai], [ae], [a]) synchronized at the beginning (corresponding to about t=50ms), stop at t=about 150ms. Because of the more or less constant duration of the transition, the 3 rates, throughout the transition, follow the inequality: [ai] rate > [ae] rate > [a] rate. In principle, discrimination between the three final vowels is thus possible throughout the transition and especially at its beginning. [aV] rates 2
[e]
[i] [y]
[]
[ø]
[u]
[a] [o]
[œ]
[]
[]
F1 rate (Hz/ms)
F2 rate (Hz/ms)
[aV] trajectory rates
0 -2
0
100
200
[ai] [ae]
-4
[a]
-6 -8 time (ms)
F1 rate (Hz/ms)
a)
b)
Figure 5. a) [aV] trajectory rates in the F1 rate-F2 rate plane for speaker EM (normal rate) and b) F1 rates in the time domain for [ai], [ae], [aε].
Figure 6a shows the formant transition rates (mean data and standard deviations for the 5 productions) in the F1 rate/F2 rate plane for the speaker EM, for normal and fast production. The rates indicated are the maximum rates of the transitions. We do not observe large differences between normal and fast production and the vowels can be discriminated according to their rates. According to the vowel target approach, identification would be based on formant frequency information at the end of the transition. It would not be necessary to know the characteristics of the preceding vowel (here [a]). In contrast, the dynamic approach assumes that directions and slopes of the transitions are important parameters. The identification of the vowel V would depend on the departure point in acoustic space. Standard deviations can be reduced by normalization based on the formant values of the initial [a] (Figure 6b). If we compare the two results: vowel targets (Figure 3 with F1, F2) and formant transition rates (Figure 6 with F1 rate, F2 rate), the difference in
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 69
distinctiveness is not evident. However, in this experiment at normal and fast rates of V1V2 production, the vowel targets V2 are always reached. A further analysis on items such as V1V2V1 with possible vowel reduction effect at fast rate production is thus necessary. Max F1-F2 rate from [a] to V, for normal and fast production
F2 rate (Hz/ms)
10 5 0 -6
-4
-2
0 -5 -10
F1 rate (Hz/ms)
N(em) F(em) [ai]
[ai]
[ae]
[ae]
[a]
[a]
[ay]
[ay]
[aø]
[aø]
[aœ]
[aœ]
[au]
[au]
[ao]
[ao]
[a]
[a]
a)
F2 rate (Hz/ms)
Max F1-F2 rate from [a] to V, for normal and fast production
[ai]
[ai]
10
[ae]
[ae]
5
[a]
[a]
[ay]
[ay]
[aø]
[aø]
[aœ]
[aœ]
[au]
[au]
[ao]
[ao]
[a]
[a]
0 -6
-4
-2
0 -5 -10
F1 rate (Hz/ms)
N(em) F(em)
b) Figure 6. a) Vowel transition maximum rates of the transition [aV] for normal (N) and fast production (F) (speaker EM); b) Same data but the formant frequencies F1 and F2 of each [a] vowel at the beginning of the transition are taken into account to normalize the rates.
70
René Carré
3.2.3. [aV] transition duration The preceding results suppose that the transition durations are more or less constant for all the [aV] produced by a same speaker. Figure 7 shows the transition durations for the speaker EM at normal and fast production. The transition duration is defined as the interval between the maximum and minimum of the acceleration curve for F1 (see Figure 2e). The duration of the transition is around 10% smaller for faster production. The standard deviation is small for both. Our results correspond to those of Kent and Moll (1969) and Gay (1978), but have to be confirmed with data from more speakers. Transition Duration (em)
Duration (ms)
100 80 60
Normal
40
Fast
20 0
Figure 7. Transition durations for all the [aV] produced by speaker EM at normal and fast rate.
3.2.4. [aV] transition for 10 speakers Our first results on [aV] production for a single speaker lead us to hypothesize that transition rates ought to be invariant across speakers (male and female). To test the hypothesis, the first two formants of the [aV] tokens as produced by 10 speakers (5 males and 5 females) were calculated with the Praat software. The formants of the V are represented in Figure 8 in the F1F2 plane. The standard deviations indicate that these static target representations show significant variability. However representations of transition maximum rates exhibit even more variability which is the opposite of our hypothesis (Figure 9)! These findings raise two questions: a) How accurate
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 71
is the formant using classical estimation techniques, (e.g., linear prediction), especially for female voices, and b) Would it be possible to reduce variability by taking syllable rate or transition rate into account?
[aV]-F1/F2 plane
N
F
[i]
[i]
[e]
[e]
2000
[]
[]
1500
[y]
[y]
1000
[ø]
[ø]
500
[œ]
[œ]
0
[u]
[u]
[o]
[o]
[]
[]
3000
F2 (Hz)
2500
0
200
400 F1 (Hz)
600
800
Figure 8. F1-F2 plane representation of the vowels [V] from [aV] produced at normal (N) and fast (F) rate by 10 speakers (5 males and 5 females).
First, good formant estimation is very difficult to obtain especially for female voices. Furthermore formant measurement errors are emphasized by the present derivative process of computing transition rates. For example, a formant frequency error of 10% can lead to an error in transition rate of 100%. Using a large time window to compute mean values can reduce these errors, but delays rate measurement. Problematic aspects of formant detection will be discussed further below. Second, each of the speakers has his own transition rate which might also change slightly with the syllable rate (normal/fast production), for instance see the transition rate for normal and fast production for speaker EM in figure 7.
72
René Carré
[aV] Transition Rate
N
F2 rate (Hz/ms)
15
-10
-8
-6
-4
F
[i]
[i]
[e]
[e]
10
[]
[]
5
[y]
[y]
0
[ø]
[ø]
[œ]
[œ]
[u]
[u]
[o]
[o]
[]
[]
-2
0 -5 -10
F1 rate (Hz/m s)
Figure 9. Maximum transition rates in the plane F1 rate versus F2 rate for [aV] uttered by 10 speakers (5 males and 5 females) for normal (N) and fast (F) production; b) same data after normalization using the transition duration.
[aV] Transition Rate
F2 rate (Hz/ms)
15 10
-10
-8
-6
-4
F
[i]
[i]
[e]
[e]
[]
[]
5
[y]
[y]
0
[ø]
[ø]
[œ]
[œ]
[u]
[u]
[o]
[o]
[]
[]
-2
0 -5 -10
F1 rate (Hz/m s)
N
Figure 10. Maximum F2 and F1 transition rates for [aV] uttered by 10 speakers (5 males and 5 females) for normal (N) and fast (F) production after normalization based on transition durations.
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 73
In view of these considerations we decided to normalize the rate measurements with respect to transition duration. Transition durations were obtained from the time interval between the maximum and minimum of the acceleration curve for F1 (see Figure 2e). Figure 10 shows the new results (the reference transition duration was 100ms). The standard deviations are clearly reduced but are still greater than the ones obtained with the target formant measurements.
4. Transition perception Since direction and rate of transitions provide discriminating acoustic information on the vowel identities in vowel to vowel sequences, it seems possible that these two attributes could be used in perception. In fact, the rates of F1 and F2 give the direction in the plane F1/F2. With such an hypothesis, the starting point must be known (Carré et al., 2007) but, it can also be considered that, for example, high negative F1 rate and high positive F2 rate leads to /ai/ without prior information on the first vowel. To test this hypothesis, trajectory stimuli outside the vowel triangle were chosen. So, the use of normal target values for the vowels was abandoned but typical rates and directions in the acoustic space were retained. Four different stimuli (A, B, C, D) were synthesized with 2 formants. The trajectories of these sequences are shown in the F1/F2 plane Figure 10, and in the time domain Figure 11. F0 is 300 Hz at the beginning of each sequence, held constant during the first quarter of the total duration, decreasing to 180 Hz at the end. Possible responses for identification tests were chosen during a pre-test, i.e. [iai], [u], [aua], [aoa]. A fifth case, labelled “????”, was offered in case of impossible identification (no response). Twelve subjects took part in the perception tests.
74
René Carré
Formant Transitions 3000 F2 (Hz)
A
B
C
2000 D
1000 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
F1 (Hz)
Figure 11. The four trajectories (A, B, C, D) in the plane F1-F2 and the vowel triangle. The trajectories are outside the vowel triangle. Their directions and sizes in the acoustic plane vary.
F (Hz)
3000 2500
F1 (A)
2000
F2 (A) F1 (B)
1500
F2 (B)
1000
F1 (C)
500
F2 (C) F1 (D)
0 0
100
200
300
400
500
F2 (D)
t (ms)
Figure 12. F1 and F2 in the time domain for the four sequences (A, B, C, D). The duration of the first part of each sequence was 100 ms, the duration of the transition was constant and equal to 100 ms. The duration of the last part was 150 ms. The rates of the transitions in Hz/ms vary. The first and last parts of each sequence were stable and equal in formant frequency. The transitions of the four sequences reached more or less the same point in the acoustic plane.
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 75
The responses (in %) are given in Figure 13. The sequence A is identified 71% of the times as [iai]. B is identified 87% as [u]. C is identified 95% and D 96% as [aua] or [aoa] and the long trajectory corresponding to a faster rate of transition is more [aua] than the short one which is more [aoa]. The option of “no response” is generally avoided. The sequence A which has the same direction in the acoustic plane and transition rate as [ai] is perceived as /iai/; B which has more or less the same direction and rate as [u] is perceived as /uu/; C which has the same direction and rate as [au] is perceived as /aua/ and D which has the same direction as [au] but at lower rate is more often perceived as /aoa/. These results can be summarized by saying that the region where the 4 trajectories converge (acoustically close to [a]) is perceived as /a/ or /u/ or /o/ depending on the direction and length (i.e. rate of the transition) of the trajectories.
100 80
60
/aoa/
%
/aua/
40
/u/
20 0
/iai/ A
B
C
D
Figure 13. Results of the perception tests. The sequence A is mainly perceived as [iai], B as [iui], C as [aua] (long trajectory), D as [aoa] (short trajectory).
5. Discussion At different levels our preliminary results raise several problems and questions about the dynamic approach and its consequences for the theory of speech production and perception. Also the findings motivate a closer examination of current speech analysis techniques and the methodology of perception tests. The dynamic approach is very attractive because it may permit consonants and vowels to be integrated within a single theory. Conceivably, us-
76
René Carré
ing the parameter of transition rate, one might propose that fast transitions tend to produce consonants, whereas slow transitions produce vowels. In the case of perceiving V1V2 sequences, we have reported acoustic measurements indicating that signal information on V2 is available throughout the transition and especially at its very beginning. This strategy presupposes that the identity of the previous V1 has been determined. The question is: How is this information to be obtained? According to a target theory of speech perception, V2 can only be identified on the basis of its target, the goal being to reach the target irrespective of the starting point. One of the aims of the present study has been to suggest that dynamic parameters such as direction of spectral change in acoustic space and transition rate could be more invariant across males, females and children than vowel targets. This hypothesis would make normalization in terms of static targets unnecessary. However, normalization of transition rate with respect to the different transition durations observed in production would seem necessary. Such normalization could be readily available perceptually, thanks to temporal coding and the sensitivity of the auditory system to rate (derivatives) and acceleration (Pollack, 1968; Divenyi, 2005). Hyper-hypo speech, and reduction phenomena (Lindblom, 1963; Lindblom, 1990) of fast and normal speech (Kent and Moll, 1969; Gay, 1978; van Son and Pols, 1990; van Son and Pols, 1992; Pols and van Son, 1993) should be further studied with respect to the parameters of transition direction and rate. The results obtained from experiments with ‘silent center’ (Strange, et al., 1983) can be explained in terms of ‘dynamic specification’ in the sense that it is not necessary to compensate for ‘undershoot’ at the production level (target not reached because of coarticulation, fast speech or hypo speech) by perceptual ‘overshoot’ (Lindblom and StuddertKennedy, 1967) calculated ‘not solely by the formant-frequency pattern at the point of closest approach to target, but also by the direction and rate of adjacent formant transitions’. This finding is compatible with the assumption that, given a specification of their point of origin in phonetic (acoustic) space, direction and rate of formant transitions could be sufficient to specify the following vowel. Our preliminary results on vowel production represent a first few steps in support of a full dynamic approach. More studies on the normalization process must also be undertaken. It is well known that predictive coding based on a model of speech production is not well adapted for analyzing speech signals with high fundamental frequencies or with noise. Furthermore, such a technique is ill-
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 77
suited to measuring spectral variations. A dynamic approach necessitates a reconsideration of analysis techniques in light of our knowledge of the auditory system. The spikes observed in auditory nerve fibers are statistically synchronized by the time domain shape of the basilar membrane excitation around the characteristic frequencies (Sachs et al., 1982). So they can give information not only on the amplitudes of spectral components but also on the shape in the time domain of the components and thus on the phases. The phase variation (-180° around formant frequencies for second order filters describing the transfer function of the vocal tract (Fant, 1960)) could be used to measure the rate of the transitions. To attain some of these goals new tools would be needed. For example Chistovich et al. (1982) described a model of the auditory system which detects spectral transitions without specific formant detection. These considerations make it evident that in order to test the hypothesis of ‘greater invariance in transition rates than in formant targets’, it would be necessary both to improve current analysis techniques and to study more deeply the normalization of transition durations. Perception tests of formant transitions outside the vowel triangle encourage us to study general dynamic properties of the auditory system that may be used in speech. Formant transitions can be converted into sinewaves: preliminary tests have shown results close to those obtained with formants. Differences have to be explained. Many experiments must be undertaken with such a tool creating speech illusions.
6. Conclusions This paper follows up on results previously published on the deductive approach (Carré, 2004) proposing a dynamic view of speech production, on acoustic modelling (Mrayati et al., 1988), on structuring an acoustic tube into regions corresponding to the main places of articulation, and on the prediction of vocalic systems (Carré, 2009). The preliminary results presented here on vowels must be extended to consonants, many of which are intrinsically dynamic. At the same time, the evident importance of dynamic characteristics does not mean that static targets are not used in perception. The limits of the dynamic approach and the balance between the use of static and dynamic parameters in perception must be known. But the dynamic approach needs to develop new ways of thinking and new tools. Formant transitions cannot be obtained from a succession of static values
78
René Carré
but from directions and slopes. It means that a new tool able to measure these characteristics directly has to be developed. The dynamic approach is not a static approach plus dynamic parameters taken into account, it must be an approach intrinsically dynamic. It calls for an epistemologic study of the dynamic nature of speech (Carré et al., 2007).
Acknowledgements The author thanks for their very helpful comments and stimulating discussions Eric Castelli, Pierre Divenyi, Björn Lindblom, Egidio Marsico, François Pellegrino, Michael Studdert-Kennedy, Willy Serniclaes. He thanks also Claire Grataloup for the efficient management of the perception tests.
References Al-Tamimi, J., Carré, R. and Marsico, E. 2004 The status of vowels in Jordanian and Moroccan Arabic: insights from production and perception. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 116: S2629. Carré, R. 2004 From acoustic tube to speech production. Speech Communication 42: 227-240. 2009 Dynamic properties of an acoustic tube: Prediction of vowel systems. Speech Communication, 51: 26-41. Carré, R. and Hombert, J. M. 2002 Variabilité phonétique en production et perception de parole : stratégies individuelles. In Invariants et Variabilité dans les Sciences Cognitives J. Lautrey, B. Mazoyer and P. van Geert, (Eds.). Presses de la Maison des Sciences de l'Homme: Paris. Carré, R. and Mrayati, M. 1991 Vowel-vowel trajectories and region modeling. Journal of Phonetics 19: 433-443. Carré, R., Pellegrino, F., Divenyi, P. 2007 Speech dynamics: epistemological aspects. In: Proc. of the ICPhS, Saarbrücken, pp. 569-572. Castelli, E. and Carré, R. 2005 Production and perception of Vietnamese vowels. In: ICSLP, Lisbon, pp. 2881-2884.
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 79 Catford, J. C. 1988 A practical introduction to phonetics. Clarendon Press: Oxford. Chistovich, L. A., Lublinskaja, V. V., Malinnikova, T. G., Ogorodnikova, E. A., Stoljarova, E. I. and Zhukov, S. J. 1982 Temporal processing of peripheral auditory patterns of speech. In The representation of speech in the peripheral auditory system R. Carlson and B. Grandström (Eds.). Elsevier Biomedical Press: Amsterdam. pp. 165-180. Divenyi, P., Lindblom, B. and Carré, R. 1995 The role of transition velocity in the perception of V1V2 complexes. In: Proceedings of the XIIIth Int. Congress of Phonetic Sciences, Stockholm, pp. 258-261. Divenyi, P. L. 2005 Frequency change velocity detector: A bird or a red herring? In Auditory Signal Processing: Physiology, Psychology and Models D. Pressnitzer, A. Cheveigné and S. McAdams (Eds.). Springer-Verlag: New York, pp. 176-184. Fant, G. 1960 Acoustic theory of speech production. Mouton: The Hague. Fant, G., Pauli, S., 1974 Spatial characteristics of vocal tract resonance modes. In: Proc. of the Speech Communication Seminar. Stockholm, pp. 121–132. Fowler, C. 1980 Coarticulation and theories of extrinsic timing. Journal of Phonetics 8: 113-133. Gay, T. 1978 Effect of speaking rate on vowel formant movements. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 63: 223-230. Hillenbrand, J. M., Getty, L. A., Clark, M. J. and Wheeler, K. 1995 Acoustic characteristics of American English vowels. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 97: 3099-3111. Hillenbrand, J. M. and Nearey, T. M. 1999 Identification of resynthesized /hVd/ utterances: Effects of formant contour. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 105: 35093523. Johnson, K. 1990 Contrast and normalization in vowel perception. Journal of Phonetics 18: 229-254. 1997 Speaker perception without speaker normalization. An exemplar model. In Talker Variability in Speech Processing K. Johnson and J. W. Mullennix (Eds.) Academic Press: New York, pp. 145-165.
80
René Carré
Johnson, K., Flemming, E. and Wright, R. 1993 The hyperspace effect: Phonetic targets are hyperarticulated. Language 69: 505-528. Kent, R. D. and Moll, K. L. 1969 Vocal-tract characteristics of the stop cognates. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 46: 1549-1555. Lindblom, B. 1963 Spectrographic study of vowel reduction. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 35: 1773-1781. 1990 Explaining phonetic variation: a sketch of the H and H theory. In Speech Production and Speech Modelling A. Marchal and W. J. Hardcastle (Eds.). NATO ASI Series. Kluwer Academic Publishers. Dordrecht, pp. 403-439. Lindblom, B. and Studdert-Kennedy, M. 1967 On the role of formant transitions in vowel perception. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 42: 830-843. Moon, J. S. and Lindblom, B. 1994 Interaction between duration, context and speaking style in English stressed vowels. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 96: 4055. Mrayati, M., Carré, R. and Guérin, B. 1988 Distinctive regions and modes: A new theory of speech production. Speech Communication 7: 257-286. Nearey, T. and Assmann, P. 1986 Modeling the role of inherent spectral change in vowel identification. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 80: 1297-1308. Nordström, P. E. and Lindblom, B. 1975 A normalization procedure for vowel formant data. In: 8th International Congress of Phonetic Science, Leeds. Peterson, G. E. and Barney, H. L. 1952 Control methods used in the study of the vowels. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 24: 175-184. Pollack, I. 1968 Detection of rate of change of auditory frequency. J. Exp. Psychol. 77: 535-541. Pols, L. C. W. and van Son, R. J. 1993 Acoustics and perception of dynamic vowel segments. Speech Communication 13: 135-147. Repp, B., Healy, A. F. and Crowder, R. G. 1979 Categories and context in the perception of isolated steady-state vowels. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance 5: 129-145.
Signal dynamics in the production and perception of vowels 81 Sachs, M., Young, E. and Miller, M. 1982 Encoding of speech features in the auditory nerve. In The Representation of Speech in the Peripheral Auditory System C. R. and G. B. (Eds.) Elsevier Biomedical: Amsterdam. pp. 115-130. Schouten, M. and van Hessen, A. 1992 Modeling phoneme perception. I: Categorical perception. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 92: 1841-1855. Shankweiler, D., Verbrugge, R. R. and Studdert-Kennedy, M. 1978 Insufficiency of the target for vowel perception. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 63: S4. Strange, W. 1989 Evolving theories of vowel perception. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 85: 2081-2087. Strange, W., Jenkins, J. J. and Johnson, T. L. 1983 Dynamic specification of coarticulated vowel. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 74: 695-705. van Son, R. J. and Pols, L. C. W. 1990 Formant frequencies of Dutch vowels in a text, read at normal and fast rate. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 88: 16831693. 1992 Formant movements of Dutch vowels in a text, read at normal and fast rate. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 92: 121-127. Verbrugge, R. R. and Rakerd, B. 1980 Talker-independent information for vowel identity. Haskins Laboratory Status Report on Speech Research SR-62: 205-215. Whalen, D. H., Magen, H. S., Pouplier, M. and Kang, A. M. 2004 Vowel production and perception: hyperarticulation without a hyperspace effect. Language and Speech 47: 155-174.
Part 2: Typological approaches to measuring complexity
Calculating phonological complexity Ian Maddieson 1. Introduction Several simple factors that can be considered to contribute to the complexity of a language’s phonological system have been investigated in recent papers (including Maddieson, 2006, 2007). The object in these papers was to see whether, in a large sample of languages, these factors positively correlated with each other or displayed a ‘compensatory’ relationship in which the elaboration of one factor was counterbalanced by greater simplicity in others. In general, the factors examined tended to show a pattern of positive correlation. That is, languages tended to be distributed along a continuum from lesser to greater phonological complexity, with several factors simultaneously contributing to the increase in complexity. The factors considered in these studies only involved the inventories of consonant and vowel contrasts, the tonal system, if any, and the elaboration of the syllable canon. It is relatively easy to find answers for a good many languages to such questions as ‘how many consonants does this language distinguish?’ or ‘how many types of syllable structures does this language allow?’ — although care must be taken to ensure that similar strategies of analysis have been applied so that the data are comparable across languages. It is reasonable to suppose that a language which requires its speakers to encode and to discriminate between a larger number of distinctions is in this respect more complex than one with fewer distinctions. However, these properties of a language’s phonological system are far from the only ones that might be considered. Some might even argue that they are not among the most important. In this paper, a number of other aspects that plausibly contribute to phonological complexity will be discussed. The factors that will be considered are: the inherent phonetic complexity of elements in the phonological inventory, the role played by freedom vs limitation of combinatorial possibilities, the contribution of the frequency of occurrence of different properties, and the relative ‘transparency’ of the relationships between phonological variants. The discussion of each factor will consider the cur-
86
Ian Maddieson
rent feasibility of establishing a basis for multi-language comparisons. A final section will consider possible ways of demonstrating that these intuitively plausible contributors to complexity are actual contributors to complexity. Before proceeding with this discussion, however, it might be valuable to reiterate why measures of phonological complexity are of interest. Many linguists assert in one way or another that all natural human languages are equally complex. Such a view seems primarily to be based on the humanistic principle that all languages are to be held in equal esteem and are equally capable of serving the communicative demands placed on them. In rejecting the notion of ‘primitive’ languages linguists seem to infer that a principle of equal complexity must apply. For example, in a widely-used basic linguistics textbook Akmajian et al. (1979:4) state that “all known languages are at a similar level of complexity and detail — there is no such thing as a primitive human language.” A common corrolary derived from this view is that languages vary in the complexity of parts of their grammar but trade off complexity in one sub-part of the grammar against simplicity elsewhere. The introduction to a recent book on language complexity (Miestamo et al., 2008) asks “is the old hypothesis true that, overall, all languages are equally complex, and that complexity in one grammatical domain tends to be complensated by simplicity in another?” Several of the contributors (e.g. Fenk-Oczlon and Fenk, Sinnemäki) answer in the affirmative. This view is not shared by all. In particular, McWhorter has argued in a number of places (e.g. 2001a, b) that languages vary considerably in their complexity, and it is especially a mark of languages that have passed through a stage of creolization to exhibit reduced complexity. Everett (2004) argued that compared to other languages Pirahã is a language with a substantial number of elements missing from its grammar and lexicon. Several commentators on this paper construed this as a suggestion that Pirahã was in fact a ‘primitive’ language. If indeed it is true that languages differ substantially in complexity, then it follows that such tasks as on-line processing of language input as well the initial acquisition of language abilities as a child would place quite variable demands on individuals, depending on the language involved. Performance might be expected to vary commensurate with task difficulty. If languages today vary in complexity then hypotheses positing an original evolution of language through the elaboration over time of a less complex pre-language gain plausibility (see Bickerton, 2007 and contributions to Givón & Maile, 2002).
Calculating Phonological Complexity
87
These are among a number of significant scientific issues that arise in connection with linguistic complexity. However, it is not possible to address these questions without some prior consideration of how to define and how to measure complexity in linguistic systems. This paper is offered as one contribution to this discussion.
2. Inherent phonetic complexity The studies mentioned above looked at the number of consonants, the number of basic vowel qualities, the total number of vowels and the number of tonal contrasts, as well as the syllable canon. The number of basic vowel qualities is the number of vowel distinctions involving the primary properties of height, backness, and rounding as well as tongue root, but not including any distinctions which depend only on such features as length, nasalization or phonation type. The total number of vowels includes any additional vowels distinguished by these features. Only in the case of the syllable canon was any account taken of what might be called ‘inherent’ complexity. Languages were classified as belonging to one of three groups based on the maximally elaborated syllable type permitted. Languages allowing nothing more elaborate than a CV structure were classified as Simple with respect to their syllable structure. Languages permitting no more than a single consonant in the coda and/or onsets of the most common Obstruent + Sonorant types (such as stop + liquid or glide) were classed as Moderately Complex, and those allowing a sequence of two or more consonants in the coda and/or other types of onset sequences, such as Obstruent + Obstruent, Sonorant + Sonorant or Sonorant + Obstruent or any clusters with three or more members were classed as Complex. This particular division into three classes reflects a judgment that in CC onsets it is not just the number of consonants in the sequence that contributes to complexity, but also the nature and order of those consonants. This judgment is based on the likelihood that the constituents of onsets such as /tw, bl, fr/ etc can be more readily recognized than the constituents of onsets such as /sf, tk, ln/ because they display a greater acoustic modulation than the latter (cf. Ohala & Kawasaki, 1984, Kawasaki-Fukumori, 1992). This judgment is indirectly supported by the relative frequency of the two types across the languages of the world. A similar principle of taking into account some evaluation of inherent phonetic complexity might be extended to other do-
88
Ian Maddieson
mains. This is easy to imagine with consonant and vowel inventories, as well as with tones. A more refined evaluation of the complexity of a consonant inventory would thus take into account both the nature and the number of the consonants, rather than simply the number. Each consonant type can be assigned a complexity score, and the complexity of the consonant inventory calculated by summing the complexity scores of the consonants it contains. What would be the basis of such scores? A possible scheme was proposed by Lindblom and Maddieson (1988). Consonants were assigned to one of three categories — Basic, Elaborated and Complex. Elaborated consonants have one of a set of 'complicating' properties, Complex consonants have more than one of these properties; the residue are Basic. These assignments were made in a largely intuitive way which primarily took into account estimations of the articulatory complexity of a prototypical production of the consonant in question, but which was also influenced by factors made less explicit in the article. According to the scheme proposed, any action of the larynx other than simple voicing or voicelessness co-occurring with the oral articulation, such as breathy voicing, aspiration, or ejective articulation is a complicating factor. In addition, because of the aerodynamic difficulty of producing local friction in the oral cavity with the reduced air-flow that occurs with voicing, voiced fricatives and affricates are also classed as Elaborated. Voiceless sonorants are also considered elaborated as they depart ‘from a default mode of phonation’. Any superposition or sequencing of different oro-nasal articulatory configurations is also a complicating factor. For example, prenasalization, lateral release, and secondary articulations are all complicating factors, although simple homorganic affrication is not. Clicks and doubly-articulated consonants such as /k͡p, g͡b/ which require two sets of oral articulatory gestures for their production, are also (at least) in the Elaborated class. Perhaps the least satisfactory part of this classification is the treatment of place of articulation. In principle, ‘configurations representing departures from the near-rest positions of the lips, tongue-tip and tongue-body components of an articulatory model’ are Elaborated. The list of places so defined was given as ‘labio-dental, palato-alveolar, retroflex, uvular and pharyngeal’ (Lindblom and Maddieson, 1988:67). While labiodental and retroflex articulations involve displacements of an articulator toward a surface not opposite that articulator’s rest position, it is unclear that this is equally the case for the remaining places in this list. In standard phonetic textbooks (e.g. Ladefoged, 2006) they are not treated as ‘dis-
Calculating Phonological Complexity
89
placed’ articulations whose articulatory dynamics are for this reason inherently more complex. The classification may well have been influenced by the relative frequency of these places, since retroflex, uvular and pharyngeal consonants are all globally quite rare. Consideration of the interactions between place and manner also seem to have implicitly played a role. Labio-dental fricatives and palato-alveolar fricatives and affricates are common, but plosives at either of these places are rare. Thus, /f/ and /tʃ/ were counted as Basic segments, as was /w/ which has a double articulation. While this scheme could undoubtedly be improved — for example, by finding a more uniform basis for evaluating articulatory complexity or by taking into account considerations of perceptual salience — it provides a basis for a demonstration of cross-language differences in inherent phonetic complexity of consonant systems. In the sample of languages used in Maddieson (2005), the modal number of consonants in the inventory is 22. Three of the languages with this consonant inventory size are Indonesian (Alwi et al., 1998), Birom (Wolff, 1959, Bouquiaux, 1970) and Kiowa (Watkins, 1984, Sivertsen1956). The consonant inventories of these three languages, based on the references cited above, are given in Table 1. The lateral in Kiowa is interpreted as a voiced affricate, although it only has this realization in coda position. Table 1. Consonant inventories of three languages with 22 consonants Indonesian (Austronesian) p t k b d
g tʃ dZ
f s ʃ x h z m n ɲ N lr w j
Birom (Niger-Congo; Nigeria) p t k kp b d
g gb tʃ dZ
f s v z m n N lr w j
h
Kiowa (Kiowa-Tanoan; USA) p t1 k ʔ pʰ t1ʰ kʰ b d1 g p' t1' k' ts ts' s z
m n1 d1L
h
j
Numeric values for each segment corresponding to a consonant class in the Lindblom & Maddieson scheme can be substituted such that Basic =1,
90
Ian Maddieson
Elaborated = 2, and Complex = 3 as in Table 2. For the purposes of this exercise it is stipulated that /f, S, tS, w/ are among the Basic consonants. Otherwise the definitions given above are applied. A summed score for each inventory can then be calculated. Indonesian has a score of 24, Birom a score of 27, and Kiowa, a score of 32. The three languages are thus quite well differentiated when the phonetic content of the inventories enters, however imperfectly, into the picture. These relative rankings correspond quite well with linguistic intuitions. For example, it seems likely that the Kiowa consonant system would be harder for learners to master if prior experience of particular languages could somehow be eliminated from influencing the results (perhaps by selecting a pool of learners with a wide variety of language backgrounds). Table 2. Complexity scores for the consonants of the three languages Indonesian = 24
Birom = 27
1 1
1
1 1
1 2
1 1
1
1 1
1 2
12 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 11
1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 11
1
1
1
1
Kiowa = 32 1 2 1 2
1 2 1 2
1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2
1
1
1
1 1 3 1
A different approach to defining a scale of elaboration based on phonetic content has been proposed by Marsico et al. (2004). Their approach proceeds through an analysis of the structure found in the classification of segments by phonetic categories or phonological features. One principle explored in this work is that a segment is Basic if, when any term is removed from its phonetic description, the remaining properties no longer define an existing segment. Thus, /p/ is a basic segment because, if any one of the terms ‘voiceless, bilabial, plosive’ is removed from the description, the remaining terms define a class of segments, rather than an individual one. Applied in this way, the procedure divides segments into just two sets, Basic and Complex, and therefore produces a considerably larger class of Basic segments than the one used by Lindblom and Maddieson. It is, inter-
Calculating Phonological Complexity
91
estingly, dependent on choices made concerning the set of phonetic properties or features used to define segments. For example, in the classification scheme of the IPA, ‘nasal’ is a primitive term applied to segments with an oral closure and a lowered velum so that all air-flow is directed out through the nose. But in some other feature schemes, any segment with nasal airflow is defined as ‘nasal’. Consequently, nasals, in the IPA sense, must be distinguished from all other segments with a nasal air-flow component by some additional feature such as ‘stop’. If /m/ is defined in the IPA as a ‘voiced bilabial nasal’, it is a Basic segment. However if /m/ is defined as a ‘voiced bilabial nasal stop’ (and ‘nasal’ is taken as a privative feature), then this segment is no longer Basic, because the term ‘nasal’ can be removed, leaving ‘voiced bilabial stop’ which defines the valid segment /b/. An advantage of the Marsico et al. procedure is that, once a feature system has been settled on, the assignment of degree of complexity can proceed algorithmically. Decisions on segmental complexity are not made directly by a linguist, but are derived indirectly from feature assignment, making the procedure more ‘hands-off’. A list of ‘legal’ segments with featural descriptions is required though. Marsico et al. (2004) used the set of 900-odd distinct consonant types listed in the expanded UPSID database (Maddieson and Precoda, 1990) and a slightly modified version of the feature set used in Maddieson (1984). The ‘default’ application of the procedure to the three languages compared above, assigning 1 to Basic and 2 to non-Basic segments, results in complexity scores for their consonant inventories of 22, for both Indonesian and Birom, and 26 for Kiowa. Only the aspirated stops and the lateral affricate of Kiowa are non-Basic, since ejective-stop, ejective-affricate and labial-velar are treated as single features in the default analysis. A reduced feature set in which each is split into two gives scores of 22 for Indonesian, 24 for Birom and 30 for Kiowa, which seems closer to an intuitively-appropriate ranking. This method could easily be extended to include additional levels of complexity. For example, one could take the maximum number of successive removal steps that can be applied as the index of the starting segment’s complexity, or one could jointly factor in some of the other indices discussed by Marsico et al. (2004), like the Derivationality index. The latter measures the number of different legal segment types that can be built by adding features to a given segment’s description. The more segments that can be derived, the more Basic the starting segment. There seems to be no decisive advantage overall to one of these two approaches over the other. A drawback of the Marsico et al. scheme is that it
92
Ian Maddieson
is based on a finite list of segments — those which happen to occur in the languages in a particular sample. The addition or deletion of a language with unique segments (from the point of view of the sample) will change some rankings of remaining segments. In Lindblom and Maddieson’s scheme, any newly encountered segment is evaluated on the basis of its production. Its value is independent of other segments. On the other hand, the approach based on Lindblom and Maddieson gives a, perhaps, unwarranted priority to articulatory aspects of complexity over perceptual ones. The procedure used by Marsico et al. is more neutral in this regard, as different features may be based on the articulatory, acoustic or perceptual properties of segments. It is easier to visualize an intuitively-satisfying extension to vowel inventories in the latter approach, as articulatory complexity does not seem to clearly distinguish among the set of oral modally-voiced vowels in the way that acoustic/perceptual factors can, as employed in the Quantal Theory of Stevens (1972, 1989) or in the definition of the ‘focalization’ parameter of Schwartz et al. (1997). In any event, it is not hard to envisage ways of extending these approaches to include the computation of a measure of the inherent complexity of vowel inventories as well as a language’s inventory of tones. We note that ‘non-peripheral’ or ‘interior’ vowels and those with secondary characteristics such as nasalization are generally considered more complex than plain, peripheral vowels (Crothers, 1978). Unitary contour tones are generally considered more complex than level tones, those that rise more complex than those that fall, and those that include both a rising and a falling component the most complex (see, e.g. Gandour & Harshman, 1978). The calculation of the inherent inventory complexity would be expected to build on these insights. The question remains as to whether any scale of inherent segmental or tonal complexity which seems intuitively appropriate is measuring something real about the complexity of a language’s phonology. There are two main sides to this question. One relates to the underlying concept of what complexity is, the other to the problems of demonstrating in some empirical fashion that what is intuitive has some reality. Since the problems are parallel in regard to the various potential complexity-related factors being considered in this paper, the discussion will be deferred until the final section.
Calculating Phonological Complexity
93
3. Combinatorial possibilities Phonological systems consist, of course, not only of an inventory of segments (and, for some languages, tones), but of patterns of combinations of these elements within larger structures. Languages differ sharply in how freely such elements combine and this again seems to provide a natural scale of complexity. For example, consonant contrasts are typically more limited in coda than onset position, but the degree of limitation varies considerably. In a quasi-random subsample of 25 languages which permit CVC structures, 21 allow fewer of their consonants as singleton codas than as singleton onsets (more complex structures including clusters were not counted), but the number of singleton coda possibilities ranges from 1 (/m/ in Kiliva) to 32 in Tlingit. To a small degree, differences in combinatorial possibility enter into the syllabic complexity scale mentioned above, but the number of different ways that a structure such as CVC can be constituted played no role. One proposal for a more elaborate scale attempts to calculate the number of possible distinct syllables allowed by the language. In a simple case this is given by the number of permitted onsets x number of permitted nuclei x number of permitted codas x number of tones and/or contrastive accent placements. However, almost all languages impose some broad-based constraints limiting the combinatorial freedom between onsets and nuclei, nuclei and codas, tones and rhyme structures, and so on. For example, in some languages with nasalized vowels in their inventory, the contrast between oral and nasalized vowels is absent or limited after an onset nasal (e.g. in Yoruba and Yélî Dnye); in numerous languages with labialized consonants there is no contrast with their plain counterparts before rounded vowels (e.g. in Hausa and Huastec). Frequently, there are also limitations constraining the pairing of particular nuclei and codas. It is essential that such limitations be known and factored into the calculation in order to avoid potentially large errors. Since this calculation is multiplicative, errors compound exponentially. To see how far astray calculations can go, consider Standard Thai. There are 21 consonants in the inventory, only 9 of which can occur as codas (to which zero coda must be added); /ʔ/ occurs only in coda. A limited number of onset clusters consisting of a stop plus a liquid or /w/ increase the number of onsets to 38 (including zero) (Li, 1977). There are also 21 vowel nuclei, made up of 9 vowel qualities which occur long or short, plus the three diphthongs /iə uə ɯə/. Finally, the language has 5 tones — 3 level, one rising and one falling. A stress contrast must also be
94
Ian Maddieson
added. If we assume no further combinatorial limitations, this would produce the estimate of 79800 (38 x 21 x 10 x 5 x 2) as the number of distinct possible syllables. However, short vowels cannot occur without a coda except in unstressed syllables, where only three vowels are distinctive and no coda is permitted. In stressed syllables with a short vowel and an obstruent coda, only two, not five tones contrast. Taking just these limitations into account, the number of unstressed syllables is not over 648, the number of stressed syllables with short vowels not over 1520, and the number of stressed syllables with long vowels or diphthongs not over 22800, for a total of 24968 — less than a third of the original estimate. This number is still an over-estimate because other regularities are not yet incorporated, such as the absence of rhymes containing a long vowel and a glottal stop coda or with a final glide following a cognate vowel (such as /-uuw, -uw/). An advantage of the syllabic computation is that since the numbers of consonants, vowels and tonal/accentual patterns enter into the calculation, it gives a single measure which might substitute for all of these, as well as the syllable complexity measure. It also sidesteps some of the often difficult decisions on segmentation. For example, whether the onset in the Hausa word ƙwai ‘egg’ is analyzed as a sequence of /k’/ and /w/ or as a single labialized segment /kW’/ does not affect the number of onsets computed for the language. On the other hand, decisions must be made regarding syllabification, which can be equally or even more problematical. In Hausa, one question would concern the status of geminates. All consonants in Hausa can occur as geminates in word-medial position between vowels, but few consonants are permitted as singleton codas. Given that /k/ never surfaces as a singleton coda (Newman, 2000:404), is it appropriate to syllabify a word such as bukkàa ‘grass hut’ as /buk.kàa/ rather than as /bu.kkàa/? In this case, tonal patterns help decide in favor of the former, since falling tones are only permitted on syllables containing a long vowel or a coda, and they do occur preceding geminates. But decisive arguments are not always available. A few languages were compared with respect to their syllable count in Maddieson (1984), with Hawaiian having the smallest number of possible syllables among the 9 languages in the set, namely 162, and Thai the largest at 23638. Shosted (2006) made a similar computation for a sample of 32 languages, selected to represent the areal-typological groupings established by Johanna Nichols in Nichols (1992) and later work. Shosted estimates Egyptian Arabic as the highest with 108400 possible syllables, and assigns the lowest total to Koiari with 70 syllables, though Tukang Besi with 115 is
Calculating Phonological Complexity
95
not far behind. Since Dutton (1996:11) indicates that “word stress ... is phonemic in Koiari” (albeit with some strong regularities), the Koiari total should probably be doubled to 140, leaving Tukang Besi with the smallest syllable inventory in the set. There are probably other totals that need adjustment in Shosted’s data, as a number of uncertainties are clearly identified and some factors may have escaped attention altogether. However, if the maximum and minimum values of 115 and 108400 are accepted, this should not be taken as an indication that Egyptian Arabic is over 900 times as complicated as Tukang Besi in its phonological patterning. A better comparison is based on the log transform, given the multiplicative nature of the calculation, which produces exponentially rising values of the syllable total for any increase of any single component of the input. This transform also yields a normal distribution for the index, instead of heavy rightward skewing, making it amenable to analysis by statistical methods that assume normality. The log ratio between Tukang Besi and Arabic is 2.44. Syllable counts of this kind can only be reliably computed for a given language if there is either a careful enough statement of the combinatorial possibilities in an accessible linguistic description, or if a sufficiently large lexicon is available which can be searched for the patterns. The lexicon must be syllabified and transcribed, or at least in a form that enables syllable boundaries and phonemic structure to be determined in the entries. For the economically more important languages of the world, such material is readily available, but for many ‘minor’ languages, no reliable distributional statements have been published and a lexicon of only a few hundred words may be all that is available. At present, it would be impossible to calculate the combinatorial possibilities for a large and diversified sample of languages. However, in some traditions of language description, such as the French structuralist model, the required information is regularly provided and the number of languages for which suitable data is available continues to increase.
4. Frequency of types If segments and sequential patterns differ in complexity, then it is reasonable to propose that the complexity of a phonological system varies according to the relative frequency of more versus less complex elements. That such frequency differences occur is relatively easy to demonstrate. For example, in many of the languages for which segment frequency counts are
96
Ian Maddieson
available the most frequent consonant is one of the most basic ones, such as /k/ as in Andoke (Landaburu, 1979), Kuku Yalanji (Patz, 2002), Hawaiian (Pukui and Elbert.1979), and Northern Khmu/ (Svantesson, 1983), or /t/ as in Russian (Kuc#era and Monroe, 1968), Japanese (Bloch, 1950), Tulu (Bhat, 1967) and Maori (Bauer, 1993). However in the frequency counts for French in Delattre (1965) and Malécot (1974) as well as in more recent computational counts (Pellegrino, p.c.) the most frequent consonant is /ʁ/, which would be considered a Complex consonant in the scheme of Lindblom and Maddieson (1988) (as it is a voiced fricative with a ‘displaced’ articulation). Since a speaker of French is called on not merely to produce this Complex consonant but to produce it quite frequently, French might be considered more complex in this respect than German, say, which has a similar consonant in its inventory, but where the most common consonant is Basic /n/ (Kuc#era and Monroe, 1968). Similarly, the frequency of syllabic patterns also varies. Both Noon (Soukka, 2000) and Maybrat (Dol, 1999) seem to allow CVC as the maximally elaborate syllable type but whereas in Noon this is the predominant pattern (at least in the case of monosyllabic stems, which form a very large part of the vocabulary), in Maybrat CV, not CVC, is the predominant syllable structure. In this respect, therefore Noon might be evaluated as more complex than Maybrat. The problem is how to develop a generally applicable method of comparing a large number of languages, given that the data are incomplete for the majority of them. The frequency data cited above were not distinguished as to whether these frequencies were calculated on the basis of frequency in the lexicon or frequency in text. The two are broadly correlated but far from identical. However, a lexicon is available for more languages than a large body of reliably-transcribed texts, which is required to avoid the biases that text styles and content can introduce. Hence, lexical frequencies provide a better opportunity for large-scale comparison. The size of available lexicons is also very variable. When it is relatively small, an analysis of the total set of frequency patterns is impossible; the relative frequencies of types with lower frequency will be unreliably represented and rare types may be altogether absent. A feasible comparison might, therefore, be based on only the consideration of patterns which are among the most frequent. With respect to segments, it would be feasible to compile a count of, say, just the ten most frequent in lexical forms. This also provides a solution to the problem posed by the variation in the number of segments across
Calculating Phonological Complexity
97
languages (the smallest phonemic inventory reported is 11 segments in Rotokas and Pirahã). A sample comparison is provided in Table 3. The columns on the left show the frequencies of the 10 most frequent consonant segments in English (British RP dialect), as reported by John Higgins of the University of Bristol, based on an analysis of the lexicon included in a popular learner’s dictionary (Hornsby et al., 1973). The columns on the right provide comparable data for Totonac extracted from the considerably smaller lexicon provided by Reid & Bishop (1974). Table 3. Comparison of segment frequency by rank in English and Totonac English (RP) segment
Totonac frequency
segment
frequency
t
34260
t
2138
s
33922
n
2123
n
31934
q
1629
l
27373
k
1529
ɹ
23069
l
1278
k
22453
ʂ
1032
d
21275
p
996
z
19972
m
994
p
15553
s
777
m
14823
tʃ
471
To compare these data, it is useful to calculate some kind of index. There are a number of ways this might be done. One possibility is to calculate a summed frequency x complexity score over the top ten segments, in which each segment contributes decreasingly according to its rank, and increasingly according to its complexity. A simple procedure would be to take the level of complexity of each segment suggested by Lindblom and Maddieson (1988), and multiply it by its rank, expressed as decreasing decimal fractions of 1 (i.e. 1, 0.9, 0.8, 0.7, etc). For instance, the segment /n/ of English would contribute 0.8 x 1 to the score and the segment /z/ would add 0.3 x 2, i.e. 0.6. If all of the top ten segments by frequency are Basic, then the score on this index would be 5.5. Assuming that /ɹ/ is Basic
98
Ian Maddieson
(which is perhaps debatable), this variety of English scores just 5.8. On the other hand, Totonac has two segments in its ‘top ten’ which count as Elaborated, namely /q/ and /ʂ/. The score for this language is 7.1. This method is somewhat crude, but its appeal is that it can be easily applied to a large sample of languages despite differences in their inventory size and the quantity of lexical forms available for counting. A lexicon can also be used to calculate relative frequency of syllable types. A simple procedure would be to calculate the proportion of each of the three categories of syllabic complexity used in Maddieson (2006, 2007) that occur in the lexicon. An index summing the proportions multiplied by the complexity level would then provide a more gradient estimate of a language’s complexity at the syllabic level. All languages whose (native) vocabulary contains only Simple syllables with the pattern (C)V (including syllabic nasals in the V position in some cases) would have an index of 1. This set would include, for example, Fijian, Yoruba and Guarani. But even at the next level of syllabic complexity, different languages would have a considerable range of values. Eight languages which allow only single coda consonants were compared with respect to the proportion of closed versus open syllables found in the lexicon available for counting. The languages are Yup’ik (Jacobson, 1984), Kadazan (Lasimbang & Miller, 1995), Gbaya (Blanchard & Noss, 1982), Darai (Kotapish & Kotapish, 1975), Mandinka (Tarawale et al., 1980), Lhasa Tibetan (Goldstein & Nornang, 1984), Comanche (Wistrand-Robinson & Armagost, 1990) and Wa (Yunnan Minzu Chubanshe, 1981). These languages either have no onset clusters or allow a limited set of common onset clusters (C + liquid or glide) which only occur infrequently. A syllable complexity x frequency index was calculated by multiplying the proportion of open syllables by 1 and the proportion of syllables with codas by 2 and summing the products. The closer the index is to 2, the greater the share of closed syllables in the lexicon. The mean number of syllables per word was also calculated. The results are shown in Table 4.
Calculating Phonological Complexity
99
Table 4. Open syllable frequency in the lexicon of selected languages. Language Comanche
# syllables counted
% open syllables
index
mean syllables per word
17485
85.7
1.14
3.63
Lhasa Tibetan
4698
84.5
1.16
1.84
Darai
5597
77.6
1.22
2.34
Mandinka
9795
78.2
1.22
2.73
10342
75.8
1.24
2.35
Kadazan (Dusun)
5339
63.0
1.37
2.64
Yup’ik
7973
52.7
1.47
3.40
Wa (Parauk)
3180
22.7
1.77
1.00
Gbaya
Comanche, which allows no word-final codas, has an index not much above 1 (and it might be even lower if a different interpretation of the role of /h/ in the phonology was adopted), whereas Yup’ik approaches 1.5, and Wa is over 1.7. If the assumption that CVC syllables are more complex than CV syllables is correct, then it is reasonable to argue that Yup’ik or Wa is more complex than Comanche or Tibetan because a larger proportion of their syllables have the more complex structure. It is interesting to note that these results cannot be predicted from word length. A lower proportion of (C)VC structures might be expected to require words to be longer in order to create sufficiently rich lexical resources. This expectation is not borne out by the comparison of the index and the mean number of syllables per word, as these are not significantly correlated with each other — regardless of whether or not the low wordlength value for Wa (see below) is included. Comanche and Yup’ik have the greatest mean word length but are at opposite ends of the open syllable frequency index. Similarly, Tibetan and Wa have the two lowest index scores but have the shortest mean word length. Rather, the relative frequencies of longer versus shorter words might be considered to be another independent, contributing factor in evaluating the complexity of phonological forms. A major caution in using lexical lists must be noted. The choice of what form is entered as the lemma can have a major impact on the segment and syllable frequencies in the lexicon for the many languages in which wordforms vary according to case, tense, gender, phonological environment, etc.
100
Ian Maddieson
For example, in the dictionary by Pogonowski (1983), which was used to obtain frequency counts of Polish segments, the conventional choice of entering verbs in their infinitive form was made. The vast majority of infinitives end in the affricate /tɕ/ and hence, this segment has a much higher frequency than if some other choice had been made. It accounts for over 12% of the codas in this count, whereas the next most frequent segment in this position, /t/, accounts for only about 3% of the codas. In some languages with elaborate polymorphemic structures, such as those in the Iroqoian family (see Chafe (1967) on Seneca or Doherty (1993) on Cayuga) more fundamental problems arise over what to consider a word and hence, how to select any single form for a lexical entry. Choice of the form of lexical entries obviously also affects the word length calculation. For example, the compilers of the Wa dictionary consulted for this study made the decision to treat all lexical entries as consisting of one or more monosyllabic words. An orthography in use in Burma (Myanmar) instead writes a number of these items as disyllabic words (Watkins & Kunst, 2006), which would yield a mean word-length slightly greater than 1 syllable. A final comment on frequency is in order. It might be argued that as the frequency of any segment or pattern in a given language increases, the more familiar speakers become with it. This familiarity reduces the complexity of the item. While it is undoubtedly true that (over-)learned behaviors require less ‘effort’ than novel behaviors in various ways (e.g. less attention, less time) this does not constitute an argument that different learned behaviors are all equally complex. Any spoken language behavior is highly learned, but specific patterns can differ in the amount of muscular coordination required, the difficulty of identifying them, or other factors that can reasonably be considered as making one more complex than another.
5. Variability and Transparency A further plausible assumption about phonological complexity is that languages for which the patterns of variation in the phonology are more ‘transparent’ are simpler than those for which the variations are more arbitrary. For example, consider patterns of tonal variations in two Chinese languages. In Cantonese, the tone found in the isolation form of a word remains unchanged in context in most cases. The only regular phonological alternation is that the mid-high fall [53] becomes level high [55] when it
Calculating Phonological Complexity
101
precedes a syllable with a high tone onset (Chao, 1947, Hashimoto, 1972) (although some more recent analyses describe this variation as free rather than conditioned). In Fuzhou, an Eastern Min variety, on the other hand, the nonfinal elements of a disyllabic or longer sequence often have a different tone from their isolation tones, and in some cases, the vowel will also differ (Maddieson, 1975, Chan, 1985). A couple of examples are given in Table 5 with tones represented by numbers where 5 is the highest. These changes in vowel quality and tone shape are not straightforwardly explicable in terms of adaptation to the phonological environment, for example via assimilation, as is the case for Cantonese. Surely in this respect, Fuzhou is more complex than Cantonese. Table 5. Tone sandhi examples from Fuzhou Chinese Isolation forms sei 2 ‘ten’
+ Nuo 5 ‘month’
sei 24 + tsʰiu 22 ‘lose’
‘hand’
Combined form sei 2 Nuo 5 ‘October’ si 35 tsʰiu 22 ‘slip from hand’
The most serious attempt to establish a basis for comparison of a significant number of languages at the level of phonological alternation was the compilation of phonological rules undertaken for the Stanford Phonology Archive (see Vihman, 1977 for a general description), a major component of the Language Universals Project conducted at Stanford University under the direction of Joseph Greenberg and Charles Ferguson. Although a few studies were made of particular processes, such as reduplication (Moravcsik, 1978), or alternations between [d] and [D] (Ferguson, 1978), no method of comparing the phonological systems in a more global way was developed and the data remained little exploited. The problem is a formidable one. Very likely the only practicable way to develop a measure would be to tightly circumscribe the scope of the comparison. A standardized basic vocabulary, say of 100 words similar to the Swadesh list employed to get rough-and-ready genetic groupings, but perhaps more carefully selected, might be used. The number of variant forms of these words that arise strictly from different phonological conditions might then be countable and the level of ‘transparency’ of the proc-
102
Ian Maddieson
esses which create these variants could also be rated. A combined score taking into account the number and nature of the variants could then be computed over this restricted wordlist. Unlike the situation with the other suggestions in this paper, no preliminary studies of this kind have been carried out, and a major problem would be to separate strictly phonological processes from those with a morphological or syntactic basis. This proposal, of course, begs the question of whether such a separation is actually possible.
SWIN|KCrEIB1Qqc8svpQueSEh0w==|1282028120
6. Defining and demonstrating complexity In the discussion so far an essentially informal or intuitive sense of relative complexity has been appealed to. In this final section, I want to briefly consider the issues of seeking a more explicit definition, and finding ways to demonstrate the appropriateness of a definition and directly measure the relevant properties. Methods that can be widely applied across different fieldwork settings will be especially considered. One basic understanding of the meaning of the word ‘complex’ is a straightforwardly quantitative one: any structure or system that contains more elements than another is the more complex of the two. This is easy to apply in comparing, say, length of syllables or number of consonants in an inventory. However it does not answer many questions — for example, whether CCV or CVC is a more complex syllable pattern. A more comprehensive approach may be sought by making the common equation of complexity with difficulty. In this view a given linguistic element or pattern is more complex than another if it is more difficult to execute, more difficult to process, more difficult to learn, or more difficult to retain in memory. Difficulty can itself be hard to demonstrate, but there are a number of accepted ways of operationalizing a test for difficulty. One frequently used way to measure the difficulty of human tasks is to compare reaction times for different tasks or different variants of a task. A task that takes longer is assumed to be more difficult. Reaction time experiments can be designed for a range of linguistic execution and processing tasks, and can be adapted for use in remote locations and under a variety of cultural conditions. For example, whether CCV or CVC syllable structures are more difficult might be tested by picture identification or naming tasks using either appropriately structured real words or nonsense forms taught in pre-test training sessions. If the time to react to presentation of a target is slower in one case
Calculating Phonological Complexity
103
than another, it may be taken as evidence of greater difficulty. For purposes of comparing complexity, it may not be necessary to demonstrate the source of the difficulty — problems of execution, recognition, or recall can all be taken as marks of higher complexity. Slowness of learning a task is also commonly equated with its degree of difficulty, and this perspective is often appealed to in explaining the order of acquisition of phonological contrasts and patterns by children. However, observing natural first-language acquisition is a demanding process. There are many idiosyncracies in individual children and we are never likely to have broad enough data on the large number of languages which would be required in order to come up with, say, an overall scale of segmental difficulty covering all segment types and motivated by actual learning difficulty. However, ease of learning for adults can be explored with experimental paradigms in which the measure of difficulty is error rate or a similar variable. Demonstrations that arbitrary phonological alternations are harder to learn than regular ones have been made by Pycha et al. (2003,, 2007) and Wilson (2003) using limited artificial languages. This approach draws on earlier experimental work with children, such as the famous ‘wug test’ of Jean Berko Gleason (1958). The protocols used in the artifical grammar learning paradigm seem adaptable enough to be employed outside the university settings in which they have been developed, and the example provided by research with children confirms that subjects do not need to be familiar with formal experimental settings to participate. A somewhat different notion of complexity might be based on measures reflecting amount of work done. Lindblom and colleagues (Lindblom & Moon, 2000, Davis et al., 1999) have considered whether levels of oxygen consumption can provide an index of effort levels during speech production. Whalen and his co-workers have proposed that brain activation levels revealed by fMRI can indicate which syllable structures are more complex than others (Whalen, 2007). These techniques demand technological tools that are not widely available or portable, but potentially provide direct measures of complexity independent of experimenter judgments. They are unlikely to be applied to speakers of a large number of languages, but could furnish a basis for generalization to untested conditions. One of the most problematic issues concerns how to integrate the various facets of discussed phonetic and phonological complexity into more inclusive measures. At a simple level, the question might be taken as one of finding appropriate weights for each facet considered. However, assigning these weights is problematic. In an inventory, does increasing the number
104
Ian Maddieson
of vowels contribute more complexity than increasing the number of consonants? One more vowel typically increases the number of potential syllables more than one more consonant, but consonants typically require greater articulatory effort than vowels. With respect to phonotactics, are more constrained combinatorial patterns more complex than free combination? One contributes more constraints to learn, but the other increases the total number of possible syllables. These kinds of issues are unlikely to be resolved soon. In the mean time, the best procedure might be to treat each evaluated variable as equivalent to every other, assigning index values for languages, respectively at, above, and below an average complexity level and then summing the results for an overall score. This procedure is crude, but readily achievable. As Nichols (2007) has shown, a similar procedure can be applied to incorporate measures of morphological or syntactic complexity into more global estimates of the complexity of individual languages.
References Akmajian, Andrew, Richard A. Demers, & Robert M. Harnish. 1979 Linguistics: An Introduction to Language and Communication. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. Alwi, Hasan, Soenjona Dardjowidjojo, Hans Lapoliwa and Anton M. Moeliono. 1998 Tata Bahasa Baku Bahasa Indonesia: Edisi Ketiga. Balai Pustaka, Jakarta. Bauer, Winifred 1993 Maori. Routledge, London. Berko Gleason, Jean 1958 The Child's Learning of English Morphology. Word 14: 150-177 Bhat, D. N. S. 1967 Descriptive analysis of Tulu. Deccan College Postgraduate and Research Institute, Poona [Pune]. Bickerton, Derek. 2007 Language evolution: A brief guide for linguists. Lingua 117: 510-526. Blanchard, Yves and Philip A. Noss 1982 Dictionnaire Gbaya-Français: Dialecte Yaayuwee. Centre de Traduction Gbaya, Mission Catholique de Meiganga et Eglise Evangélique Luthérienne du Cameroun, Meiganga. Bloch, Bernard 1950 Studies in colloquial Japanese, IV: Phonemics. Language 26: 86-125.
Calculating Phonological Complexity
105
Bouquiaux, Luc 1970 La Langue Birom (Nigeria septentrional) Phonologie, Morphologie, Syntaxe. Bibliotheque de la Faculte de Philosophie et Lettres de l'Universite de Liege, Liege. Chafe, Wallace L. 1967 Seneca Morphology and Dictionary. Smithsonian Institution, Washington, DC. Chan, Marjorie K-M. 1985 Fuzhou Phonology: A Non-Linear Analysis of Tone and Stress. Ph. D. dissertation, University of Washington, Seattle. Chao, Yuan-Ren. 1947 Cantonese Primer. Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA. Crothers, John. 1978 Typology and universals of vowel systems. In J. H. Greenberg, ed., Universals of Human Language, Volume 2: Phonology. Stanford University Press, Stanford: 93-152. Davis, J. H., B. Lindblom, R. Spina and Z. Simpson. 1999 Energetics in phonetics. Paper presented at Speech Communication and Language Development Symposium. Stockholm University. Delattre, Pierre 1965 Comparing the Phonetic Features of English, German, Spanish and French. Julius Groos Verlag, Heidelberg. Doherty, Brian 1993 The Acoustic-Phonetic Correlates of Cayuga Word-Stress. Ph. D. dissertation, Harvard University, Cambridge MA. Dol, Philomena 1999 A Grammar of Maybrat. University of Leiden, Leiden. Dutton, Tom E 1996 Koiari. Lincom Europa, München and Newcastle. Fenk-Oczlon, Gertraud and August Fenk. 2008 Complexity trade-offs between subsystems of language. In Miestamo et al, 2008: 43-66. Ferguson, Charles A. 1978 Phonological processes. In J. H. Greenberg, C. A. Ferguson, and E. A. Moravcsik (eds.), Universals of Human Language, vol. 3, Stanford, Stanford University Press, 403–442. Gandour, Jackson, T. and Richard A. Harshman. 1978 Crosslanguage differences in tone perception: A multi-dimensional scaling investigation. Language and Speech 21: 1-33. Givón, T and Bertram F. Maile, editors. 2002 The Evolution of Language out of Pre-language. John Benjamins, Amsterdam.
106
Ian Maddieson
Goldstein, Melvyn C. and Nawang L. Nornang. 1984. Modern Spoken Tibetan: Lhasa Dialect, 3rd edition. Ratna Pustak Bhandar, Kathmandu. Hashimoto, Oi-Kan Yue. 1972 Studies in Yue Dialects 1: The Phonology of Cantonese. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Hornsby, A. S., E. V. Gatenby and H. Wakefield. 1973 Advanced Learner’s Dictionary of English (Oxford Text Archive edition). Longman, London. Jacobson, Steven A. 1980 Yup’ik Eskimo dictionary. Alaska Native Language Center, University of Alaska, Fairbanks. Kawasaki-Fukumori, Haruko. 1992 An acoustic basis for universal phonological constraints. Language and Speech 35:73-86. Kotapish, Carl and Sharon 1975 A Darai-English, English-Darai Glossary. Summer Institute of Linguistics, and Institute of Nepal and Asian Studies, Tribhuvan University, Kathmandu. Kuc#era, Henry and George K. Monroe 1968 A Comparative Quantitative Phonology of Russian, Czech, and German. American Elsevier, New York. Ladefoged, Peter 2006 A Course in Phonetics, Fifth Edition. Thompson/Wadsworth, Boston. Landaburu, Jon 1979 La Langue des Andoke (Amazonie colombienne) Grammaire. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Paris. Lasimbang, Rita and John Miller 1995 Kadazan Dusun - Malay - English Dictionary. Kadazan Dusun Cultural Association, Kota Kinabalu. (pre-publication version actually consulted) Li, Fang-Kuei 1977 A Handbook of Comparative Thai. University Press of Hawaii, Honolulu. Lindblom, Björn and Ian Maddieson 1988 Phonetic universals in consonant systems. In Language, Speech and Mind (ed C. Li and L.M. Hyman). Routledge, London. 62-78. Lindblom, Björn. & Seung-Jae Moon 2000 Can the energy costs of speech movements be measured? A preliminary feasibility study, Journal of the Acoustical Society of Korea 19.3E, 25-32. Maddieson, Ian and Kristin Precoda 1990 Updating UPSID. UCLA Working Papers in Phonetics 74: 104-114.
Calculating Phonological Complexity
107
Maddieson, Ian 1975 The intrinsic pitch of vowels and tone in Foochow. San Jose State Occasional Papers in Linguistics 1: 150-161. (Proceedings of the Fourth California Linguistics Conference). 1984 Patterns of Sounds. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. 2005 Consonant inventories. In M. Haspelmath, M. S. Dryer, D. Gil, & B. Comrie, eds., World Atlas of Language Structures, Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York: 10-13. 2006 Correlating phonological complexity: data and validation. Linguistic Typology 10: 108-125. 2007 Issues of phonological complexity: Statistical analysis of the relationship between syllable structures, segment inventories and tone contrasts. In M-J. Solé, P. Beddor and M. Ohala, (eds), Experimental Approaches to Phonology. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York: 93-103. Malécot, André 1974 The frequency of occurrence of French phonemes and consonant clusters. Phonetica 29: 158-170. Marsico, Egidio, Ian Maddieson, Christophe Coupé, and François Pellegrino. 2004 Investigating the “hidden” structure of phonological systems. Proceedings of the 30th Berkeley Linguistic Society Meeting: 256-267. McWhorter, John H. 2001a The Power of Babel: A Natural History of Language. Times Books, New York. 2001b The World's Simplest Grammars Are Creole Grammars. Linguistic Typology 5:125-166. Miestamo, Matti, Kaius Sinnemäki and Fred Karlsson, editors 2008 Language Complexity: Typology, Contact, Change. John Benjamins, Amsterdam. Moravcsik, Edith A. 1978 Reduplicative constructions. In J. H. Greenberg, C. A. Ferguson, and E. A. Moravcsik (eds.), Universals of Human Language, vol. 3, Stanford, Stanford University Press, 297–334. Newman, Paul 2004 The Hausa Language: An Encyclopedic Reference Grammar. Yale University Press, New Haven and London. Nichols, Johanna 1992 Linguistic Diversity in Space and Time. University of Chicago Press, Chicago 2007 The distribution of complexity in the world’s languages. Paper presented at symposium on Approaches to Language Complexity. Annual Meeting of the Linguistic Society of America, Anaheim.
108
Ian Maddieson
Ohala, John J. and Kawasaki-Fukumori, Haruko 1997 Alternatives to the sonority hierarchy for explaining segmental sequential constraints. In Stig Eliasson & Ernst Håkon Jahr (eds.), Language And Its Ecology: Essays In Memory Of Einar Haugen. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. 343-365 Patz, Elisabeth 2002 A Grammar of the Kuku Yalanji Language of North Queensland (Pacific Linguistics 526). Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, Australian National University, Canberra. Pogonowski, Iwo 1983 Dictionary Polish-English, English-Polish. Hipprocrene Books, New York. Pukui, M. K. and Elbert, S. H. 1979 Hawaiian Grammar. University Press of Hawaii, Honolulu. Pycha, Anne, P. Nowak, E. Shin and R. Shosted 2003 Phonological rule-learning and its implications for a theory of vowel harmony. G. Garding and M. Tsujimura (eds) Proceedings of WCCFL 22. Somerville, Cascadilla Press: 423-435. Pycha, Anne, Eurie Shin, and Ryan Shosted 2007 Directionality of assimilation in consonant clusters: An experimental approach. Paper presented at Symposium Towards an Artificial Grammar Learning Paradigm in Phonology. Linguistic Society of America Annual Meeting, Anaheim, CA. http://www.linguistics.berkeley.edu/~shosted/dacc.pdf Reid, Aileen A. and Ruth G. Bishop 1974 Diccionario Totonaco de Xicotepec de Juárez, Puebla. Instituto Lingüístico de Verano, Mexico. Schwartz, J-L., L.-J Boë, N. Vallée, & C. Abry 1997 The dispersion-focalization theory of vowel systems. Journal of Phonetics 25: 255-286. Shosted, Ryan K. 2006 Correlating complexity: a typological approach. Linguistic Typology 10: 1-40. Sinnemäki, Kaius. 2008 Complexity trad-offs in core argument marking. In Miestamo et al, 2008: 67-88. Sivertsen, Eva 1956 Pitch problems in Kiowa. International Journal of American Linguistics 22: 117-130 Soukka, Maria 2000 A Descriptive Grammar of Noon: A Cangin Language of Senegal. Lincom Europa, München.
Calculating Phonological Complexity
109
Stevens, Kenneth N. 1972 The quantal nature of speech: evidence from articulatory-acoustic data. In E. E. David & P. B. Denes (eds) Human communication: A unified view. London: Academic Press. 51-66. 1989 On the quantal nature of speech. Journal of Phonetics 17: 3-45. Svantesson, Jan-Olof 1983 Kammu phonology and morphology. (Travaux de L'Institut de Linguistique de Lund, 18.) Lund: Gleerup. Tarawale, Ba, Fatumata Sidibe and Lasana Konteh 1980 Mandinka-English Dictionary. National Literacy Advisory Committee, Bathurst. Vihman, Marilyn 1977 A Reference Manual and User's Guide for the Stanford Phonology Archive. Part I. Department of Lingujistics, Stanford University, Stanford. Watkins, Justin and Richard Kunst 2006 Writing the Wa language. On-line document at http://mercury.soas.ac.uk/wadict/wa_orthography.html Watkins, Laurel 1984 A Grammar of Kiowa. University of Nebraska, Lincoln. Whalen, Douglas H. 2007 Brain activations related to changes in speech complexity. Paper presented at symposium on Approaches to Language Complexity. Annual Meeting of the Linguistic Society of America, Anaheim. Wilson, Colin 2003 Experimental investigation of phonological naturalness. In G. Garding and M. Tsujimura (eds). Proceedings of WCCFL 22. Cascadilla Press, Somerville, MA: 533-546. Wistrand-Robinson, Lila, and James Armagost 1990 Comanche Dictionary and Grammar. Summer Institute of Linguistics and The University of Texas at Arlington, Arlington. Wolff, Hans 1959 Subsystem typologies and area linguistics. Anthropological Linguistics 1/7: 1-88. Yunnan Minzu Chubanshe [Yunnan Minorities Publishing House] (Yan Qixiang, Zhou Zhizhi et. al., compilers) 1981 Pug lai cix ding yiie si ndong lai Vax mai Hox (A Concise Dictionary of Wa and Chinese). Kunming.
Favoured syllabic patterns in the world’s languages and sensorimotor constraints Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset The general aim of this study is to investigate the linear organization of speech sound sequences in natural languages. Using a 17-language syllabified lexicon database (ULSID), we examine several preferred syllabic and lexical patterns and we discuss them in light of data from speech production and perception experiments. First, we observe that some of the preferences found for tautosyllabic relations were consistent with the predictions of the Frame/Content Theory, while others extended them. Then, we investigate trends in the coocurrence of prevocalic and postvocalic consonants that appeared in the same syllable or in the onset of two consecutive syllables. We discover that the Labial-V-Coronal sequence was widespread in many lexica of ULSID. Our results not only confirm the presence of the so-called Labial-Coronal (LC) effect found by MacNeilage et al., (1999) in dissyllabic words, but also show that it occurs in various syllabic patterns. Then, we report results of two experiments which provide phonetic bases for the LC effect. Finally, we focus on consonant sequences involving plosive and nasal, showing that the preferred sequences were inconsistent with the sonority hierarchy. We claim that the disfavored patterns can be predicted by a more complex gesture of the velum due to aerodynamic constraints. More broadly, to better understand the complexity of sound sequences in languages we discuss the relationship between human sensorimotor capacities and phonology.
SWIN|KCrEIB1Qqc8svpQueSEh0w==|1282028144
1. Introduction Although there is no unambiguous definition on what a complex system is, some key aspects like evolution, adaptation, interaction, dynamics and self-organization are common characteristics. These aspects are examined in studies on speech production, speech comprehension and speech acquisition. They therefore make it possible to regard human speech processing as a complex system (for discussion on complexity in phonetics and phonology see the Introduction of this volume by Pellegrino, Marsico, Chitoran,
112
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
and Coupé). Speech is known to be structured at many different levels and, at each level, preferred types of organization are found, both within and across languages. There is no doubt that the description and the analysis of a common organization to many languages of different genetic groups allows us to gain a better understanding of such a complex system. This research attempts to answer the following questions: Why are some structures very common in the world’s languages, regardless of linguistic affiliation and geography? Where do these structures come from? How can they be explained? Since Trubetzkoy’s classification of speech sound systems in the 30’s (Trubetzkoy, 1939), several typological studies have demonstrated that languages do not structure their sound systems arbritrarily. According to the approach introduced by Liljencrants and Lindblom (1972), typological analyses associated with advances in predictive models have shown that human languages do not make random use of both the vocal apparatus and the auditory system to organize their phonological structures. Several studies have contributed to building a theory for predicting most of the vowel systems of the world’s languages from principles based on perceptual distinctiveness (Lindblom, 1986 and later; Schwartz, Boë, Vallée and Abry, 1997; Vallée, Schwartz, and Escudier, 1999; De Boer, 2000). To our knowledge, no general theory accounts for predicting consonant structures, though certain works have provided natural phonetic bases for preferences in consonant inventories. According to these works, consonant structures are shaped by acoustic and aerodynamic constraints that provide sufficient auditory contrast (Kingston and Diehl, 1994; Kingston, 2007; Mawass, 1997; McGowan, Koenig and Löfqvist, 1995; Ohala, 1983; Ohala and Jaeger, 1986; Stevens, 1989; 2003; Stevens and Keyser, 1989), and for some of them, by visual contrast (Mawass, Badin and Bailly, 2000; Vallée et al., 2002; Boë, et al., 2005). Moreover, physiological constraints regarding possible or impossible gestures have also been suggested (Lindblom and Maddieson, 1988). Beyond the segmental level, languages structure the linear order of sounds at other levels, within syllables and grammatical units such as morphemes, words, clauses, sentences. It is widely accepted that the syllable is a structural unit of speech, in production and perception. Derwing (1992) specified that the speakers of many languages are able to count the number of syllables of a word, and obtain significant and consistent results in a syllabification task, even for words with geminated consonants. However, even if relevant studies have shown that speakers and listeners are generally
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
113
able to agree on the number of syllables in an utterance, sometimes their syllabification differs (e.g. Content, Kearns and Frauenfelder, 2001). Be that as it may, many psycholinguistic studies have found that syllables arise spontaneously when speakers and listeners have to segment the speech stream (e.g. Morais, Cary, Alegria and Bertelson, 1979; Segui, Dupoux, and Mehler, 1990; Treiman, 1989; Sendlmeier, 1995; Treiman and Kessler, 1995). Moreover, the syllable is invoked in speech errors and word games (e.g. Treiman, 1983; Bagemihl, 1995; MacNeilage, 1998) and in secret languages e.g. Verlan, derived from French (Plénat, 1995). It has been also proposed as a processing unit in visual word recognition (Carreiras, Álvarez and De Vega, 1993) and in handwriting production (Kandel, Álvarez and Vallée, 2006). In addition, neurophysiological works have suggested that the syllable is a central unit of language, specifically in its emergence, acquisition and function (MacNeilage and Davis, 1990; MacNeilage, 1998; MacNeilage and Davis, 2000). Despite its well-established role in all these studies, the syllable is an enigmatic linguistic unit. The question of its nature is still unresolved because its definition remains a problem at both the phonetic (see Krakow, 1999 for a review) and phonological (Ohala and Kawasaki, 1984; Kenstowicz, 1994) level. Whatever the linguistic status of the syllable is, the detailed examination of prevalent cross-linguistic sound combinations within syllables, and combinations of syllables within morphemes and words, provides knowledge of the syllabic organization of segments, on both phonetic and phonological levels (Blevins, 1995), and can contribute to defining of the syllable. As for sound systems that are found in a wide range of languages, attempts have been made to explain them in terms of human capacities of perception (distinctiveness), production (vocal gestures) or both (Kawasaki, 1982; Janson, 1986; Krakow, 1999; Redford and Diehl, 1999; Maddieson and Precoda, 1992; Lindblom, 2000). In this paper, we present results on phonotactic regularities found in lexical and syllabic patterns from several languages. The study was conducted using the ULSID (UCLA Lexical and Syllabic Inventory Database), partly provided by Ian Maddieson (Maddieson and Precoda, 1992). This database was created like UPSID (UCLA Phonological Segment Inventory Database) (Maddieson, 1984; Maddieson and Precoda, 1989), for the understanding of speech sound structures in the world’s languages. ULSID is being developed in our laboratory and currently has syllabified lexicons from 17 languages which are representative of the major language families and fairly well distributed geographically. In line with Maddieson (1993:1):
114
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
“Recent loan words, especially those of wide international currency relating to modern technological, political or cultural concepts (‘telephone’, ‘democracy’, ‘football’), have been excluded wherever recognizable”. The database currently contains more than 90,000 words, from 2,000 in Ngizim to 12,200 in French. The mean number of words per language is 5,908. The other languages included in the study are Afar, Finnish, Kannada, Kanuri, Kwakw’ala, Navaho, Nyah kur, Quechua, Sora, Swedish, Thai, Vietnamese, Wa, Yup’ik and !Xòõ. Each lexical entry consists of an IPA transcription with marks indicating its syllabic structure, representing the following information: the division in syllables and, for each syllable, its conventional sub-syllabic components, such as onset and rhyme. In addition to Maddieson and Precoda’s (1992) database, other languages were included using similar sources of information. The syllabification was done either from published (printed or computer-readable) syllabified lexicons (French: BDLEX-Syll from BDLEX 50.000, Pérennou and de Calmès, 2002; Swedish: Berlitz, 1981) or manually by at least two native speakers of the language (as in Vietnamese). The lexical entries consisted of lemmas only. We investigated the sound organization in the lexical units by considering the syllable boundaries. Adjacent sounds in the same syllable (tautosyllabic) and those of two consecutive syllables within lexical items were examined according to the nature of the segments involved. Clear patterns emerged from the statistical analyses and showed that syllables, like phonemes, are not arbitrary linguistic units. Three favored combinations of C and V were found by using computed ratios between observed and expected values in CV syllables, but also in both ( )CV( ) and ( )VC( ) templates, with a stronger link in the last one. This provides evidence favoring sequences where the articulators do not make extensive movements between the consonant and vowel gestures. The results, presented in Section 1, are discussed with respect to the predictions of the Frame/Content Theory (MacNeilage, 1998). We also confirmed the presence of the “LC effect” (MacNeilage and Davis, 2000) in our data. This effect refers to a strong preference for a specific intersyllabic pattern: disyllabic word starts more often with a labial stop consonant preceding the vowel or nucleus, which is itself followed by a coronal stop consonant (MacNeilage, et al., 1999). In Section 2 we show that this tendency, strongly attested in ULSID, occurred in several syllabic patterns. We outline the results of two recent experimental studies, suggesting an articulatory explanation for the existence of a perceptual correlate of the LC effect in French adults.
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
115
This last point concerns the asymmetry we observed in sequences involving a nasal (Nasal+Plosive (NP) and Plosive+Nasal (PN) consonant sequences). Results from a preliminary study using EMA® (Carstens, electromagnetic articulography) and EVA® (S.Q.LAB) measurements (Rossato, 2003) are given. They suggest a possible explanation for the preferred VNP pattern (V = syllable nucleus) compared to PNV (though following the Sonority Sequencing Principle) and these results are discussed in Section 3. Thus, our work attempts to provide explanatory reasons for several preferred sound sequences, showing that the widespread patterns in many natural languages are structured from aerodynamic, articulatory and/or perceptual constraints. More precisely, it reveals a preference for simple speech movements such languages favour patterns that require less effort and provide sufficient perceptual distintiveness over those that require effort. More broadly, our findings are relevant to the relationship between sensorimotor capacities and phonology.
2. Interaction between tautosyllabic segments Our first objective was to estimate the role of the syllabic frame in the lexical organization of ULSID’s languages. According to MacNeilage’s Frame, then Content Theory (1998), the universal alternation of consonants and vowels in speech sound sequences is a consequence of jaw movement. Consonants and vowels are articulated during one of the two phases of the mandibular oscillation (raising and lowering of the jaw). Consonants are produced during the closing of the mouth, while vowels are articulated during the opening phase. “Pure frames” are CV syllables produced by only one basic movement of the jaw (elevation then lowering) without any action of other articulators throughout the syllable and they are the simplest syllables. They correspond to the most economical sound sequences. According to MacNeilage and Davis (2000), “pure frames” are the most frequent CV-like articulations in babbling and the most frequent syllables in first words, languages, and proto-languages. Are the simplest syllables (in the sense of the MacNeilage’s Theory) the most widespread in ULSID’s lexicons? What are the favored tautosyllabic sequences in ULSID? The database contains almost 250,000 syllables. We first looked at the most common type of syllable in all languages. A basic CV structure accounted for almost 54% of the ULSID’s syllables. To facilitate the observa-
116
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
tion of syllabic content, we created co-occurrence matrices. In order to be able to compare our results with previous studies (MacNeilage, 1998; MacNeilage and Davis, 2000), we grouped segments according to their phonetic features (Vallée et al., 2002): six manners (plosive, fricative, nasal, affricate, approximant and trill/tap/flap), ten places of articulation for consonants (bilabial, labio-dental, coronal, palatal, labial-palatal, labialvelar, velar, uvular, pharyngeal, glottal), and three places of articulation for vowels (front, central, and back). The coronal class grouped apical consonants together i.e. dentals, alveodentals, alveolars, postalveolars and retroflexes (following Keating, 1990). Vowel height was not considered here because we did not find any clear tendencies between vowel aperture and consonant manner. We counterbalanced the observed syllable frequency with the expected frequency estimated from its segments. For example, the frequency of C1V1 was divided by the product of the individual frequencies of C1 and V1. These ratios, calculated for each language on an individual basis, showed what type of syllable was favored (ratio > 1) in our data (see Table 1 for Afar and Table 2 for Thai). Table 1. Ratios between observed and expected frequencies of CV syllables in Afar. Afar
Coronal
Bilabial
Velar
Front
1.16
0.68
0.84
Central
0.88
1.22
0.98
Back
0.99
1.08
1.31
Table 2. Ratios between observed and expected frequencies of CV syllables in Thai. Thai
Coronal
Bilabial
Velar
Front
1.07
0.99
0.71
Central
0.94
0.94
1.08
Back
1.01
1.04
1.22
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
117
Three favored onset-nucleus combinations emerged for Afar: coronal-front, bilabial-central, velar-back (Table 1) whereas in Thai, velar-back was clearly preferred and coronal-front was slightly favored (Table 2). The mean value of the ratios for the 17 languages was worked out for each simple CV combination. Three favored onset-nucleus patterns emerged: coronal-front, bilabial-central and velar-back (Table 3). All three favored CV patterns occurred in seven languages, while both bilabialcentral and velar-back combinations were found in twelve languages; the coronal-front was found in eleven. Our results were consistent with previous observations in the babbling utterances of infants, and in a database of ten natural languages which share French and Quechua data with ULSID (MacNeilage and Davis, 2000; MacNeilage, Davis, Kinney and Matyear, 1999). In previous studies, only simple CV sequences were observed and we decided to examine whether the presence or absence of a coda influenced the relationship between the onset and the nucleus in a syllable. The observed/expected ratios for onset-nucleus combinations were calculated for CVC syllables in each language. Figure 1 shows the mean onset-nucleus ratios across languages obtained on CV with CVC syllables, on simple CV syllables and on CVC syllables. No significant influences of the coda on the preferred onset-nucleus pattern were observed: all three favored cooccurrence patterns between onsets and nuclei were also found in CVC structures. Table 3. Mean value of the 17 ratios between observed and expected frequencies of CV syllables (χ2significant, p < 0.001 for each column). CV syllables
Coronal
Bilabial
Velar
Front
1.15
0.82
0.90
Central
0.92
1.11
0.99
Back
1.02
1.01
1.19
We extended our analysis to the interaction between nuclei and codas in the VC syllabic structure. VC syllables accounted for only 2.5% of ULSID’s syllables. Although VC syllables were disfavored, Table 4 shows that there was the same relationship as in CV structures. The three favored cooccurrence patterns were front-coronal, central-bilabial and back-velar. All
118
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
three patterns occurred in five languages, the central-bilabial combination emerged in eleven languages, the front-coronal was found in eleven and the back-velar in nine. This result demonstrates that the preferred VC sequences were “pure-frames” like the preferred CV sequences. 1.2
1.2
Bilabial Onset 1
1
0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2
Coronal Onset
0 Front
Central
Back
Front
Central
Back
1.4 1.2
Velar Onset
1
CV + CVC
0.8
CV
CVC
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Front
Central
Back
Figure 1. Mean expected/observed ratios across individual languages according to the places of onset: bilabial on the upper left, coronal on the upper right and velar on the bottom row. X-axis indicates the place of the nucleus: front, central, back. Each group of three bars represents the mean ratio for respectively: CV with CVC syllables (left bar), CV syllables (middle bar), CVC syllables (right bar).
We also noticed that the link between vowel and consonant had a tendency to be more important in VC than in CV syllables. This result is in line with the concept of the rhyme proposed by phonologists who claim that
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
119
the structure of the syllable is hierarchical rather than linear (Selkirk, 1982). In this approach, the relationship between the syllabic constituents are represented by a tree-like diagram in which the nucleus and the coda are linked together in a node located at the same level of structuring than the onset. Blevins (1995:214-215) makes a strong case for the rhyme constituent based on i) syllable weight, ii) restrictions on the number of segments occurring in the syllable rhyme, and iii) the close relationship between nucleus and coda. Bagemihl (1995:707), reviewing the interaction of language games with lingusitic theory, points out that the rhyme was one of the linguistic units manipulated in word games. All of these observations converge and substantiate that the rhyme is a subsyllabic constituent. Table 4. Mean ratios across the individual languages between observed and expected frequencies of VC syllables (χ2significant, p < 0.001 for each column). VC syllables
Front
Central
Back
Coronal
1.24
0.91
0.95
Bilabial
0.54
1.28
1.13
Velar
0.76
0.84
1.37
Regarding the stronger effect of the frame on VC syllables, the properties of the jaw cycle could help explain this trend. Redford (1999) points out inherent asymmetries in the jaw cycle. From experiments carried out in the framework of the Frame/Content Theory, she shows that the closing phase of the mouth was articulated with greater velocity peaks and shorter durations than in the opening phase. In complex syllables the opening phase was articulated with greater displacement (distance between min and max opening within a phase) than the closing phase. Finally, the degree of articulatory stiffness (slope between distance and velocity) was smaller at the opening phase than at the closing phase. If these trends were assessed in additional cross-linguistic studies, they could explain the following crosslinguistic preferences: vowels and consonants are more strongly connected in VC than in CV sequences; CV are more frequent than VC or CVC sequences; single consonants are preferred over consonant clusters or complex consonants; clusters or complex consonants are more frequent in onset position compared to in coda position. Redford claims that “… the mechan-
120
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
ical and temporal constraint of the jaw cycle is manifested in the phonological and phonetic sound patterns that are perceived as syllables. […] jaw cycle may provide an articulatory basis for the syllable in language” (Redford 1999:25). According to this view, the dominance of the jaw cycle in adult speech, as described by MacNeilage in the Frame/Content Theory, seems not to be weakened by within and across language phonological asymmetries and co-occurrence constraints in VC patterns. On that account, our results are in line with MacNeilage and Davis study (2000). Languages of ULSID favor pure-frame syllables (over 30% of the all ULSID’s syllables) which correspond to economical sound patterns. According to MacNeilage (1998), such less complex syllabic patterns originate from a simple mandibular cycle (a frame), the vowel, and the adjacent consonant adopting a quite similar position of the tongue. Our final analysis examined tautosyllabic combinations between nuclei and consonants in the ( )CV( ) and ( )VC( ) templates (the brackets indicate that one or more consonants can appear in this position). All the syllabic structures of the 17 languages were considered (except the minimal syllable V which accounted for less than 5% of the ULSID syllables). We conducted statistical analyses taking into account the prevocalic consonant and the postvocalic one, as long as they appeared in the same syllable. Our results (Tables 5-6) clearly showed that front vowels were strongly related to coronals, central vowels to bilabials and back vowels to velars. Thus, regardless of the complexity of the syllabic structures (the degree of complexity is estimated from the number of consonants in the onset or coda position), languages seem to favor consonant-vowel or vowel-consonant combinations where the tongue does not make great displacement in the front-back dimension between the vowel gesture and the gesture of the immediately preceding or following consonant. Our analyses confirmed that the syllabic frame was one of the aspects of the sound organization in lexical units. In a next step, we will extend our analyses to other consonants, by grouping bilabials and labiodentals in a labial category, dorsopalatals, uvulars, and velars in a dorsal category (since we noticed that palatal consonants were very frequently combined with back vowels, as in Vietnamese; ratio observed/expected = 1.9).
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
121
Table 5. Mean value of the 17 ratios between observed and expected frequencies of ( )CV( ) combinations (χ2 significant, p < 0.001 for each column). CV patterns
Coronal
Bilabial
Velar
Front
1.09
0.94
1.05
Central
0.87
1.10
0.70
Back
1.01
0.93
1.32
Table 6. Mean value of the 17 ratios between observed and expected frequencies of ( )VC( ) combinations (χ2 significant, p < 0.001 for each column). VC patterns
Front
Central
Back
Coronal
1.11
1.00
0.89
Bilabial
0.53
1.32
1.18
Velar
0.92
0.86
1.22
3. The Labial-Coronal Effect We explored other prevocalic and postvocalic consonants that appeared in the same syllable, or in two consecutive syllables, within lexical items. Regarding structures with less complex onset and coda, we focused on the relation between the initial and the final consonants in CVC syllables or in the consecutive onsets in CV.CV words (the dot indicates the syllable boundary). We observed that various places of articulation for the two consonants were favored. For example, [pap] and [tat] syllables were less frequent than [tap] or [pat], although coronals were the most frequent consonants in onsets, as well as in coda positions (Rousset, 2004). In the favored patterns, there were no place repetitions between onset and coda in the CVC structures. The mean observed/expected ratios for the ULSID’s languages were below 0.9 for the CVC syllables when the two consonants
122
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
shared the same place of articulation. This result contrasts with the place assimilation between C and V found in both the favored CV and VC structures. The more widespread CVC patterns in ULSID’s lexica were in descending order: Bilabial-V-Coronal, Coronal-V-Velar, Coronal-V-Bilabial, Velar-V-Coronal. While no difference was observed between the ratios of the two inverse patterns Coronal-V-Velar and Velar-V-Coronal (respective ratios observed/expected = 1.18 and 1.2), this was not the case for BilabialV-Coronal and Coronal-V-Bilabial (respective ratios = 3 and 1.13). We observed the same findings for the two consecutive open syllable patterns, except that repetition of coronal is the most common CV.CV sequences. The predominance of the Bilabial-V-Coronal-V combination over the Coronal-V-Bilabial-V pattern is strongly attested in CV.CV sequences. We calculated the same ratios as for CVC patterns, and found an LC effect in 15 languages (at statistically significant levels for 13 of them, p < 0.005), either in CVC structures (12 languages, significant for 9) or in CV.CV sequences (14 languages, significant for 13), regardless of their position within the word. In 3 languages (Kanuri, Navaho, Thai), the trend was present only in disyllabic patterns and was not found in CVC syllable structures. The Vietnamese lexicon has few compounded words with the CV.CV structure (less than hundred). The ratio of LC to CL was 0.92. In addition, Wa and !Xòõ had no LC effect in any of the observed structures (Wa has only CVC). Finally, French, Finnish and Quechua had a stronger LC effect in intra-syllabic patterns than in disyllabic sequences. However, their basic syllabic structure is CV. When we took into account only the bilabial consonants, the mean ratio of LC to CL was 2.77 for all the dissyllabic words of ULSID’s languages. Concerning bilabials and labiodentals, the ratio was 2.79. The mean values of LC/CL as a function of the syllable type and its position within the word were also examined. Table 7 shows that the trend appeared not only at word onsets but also elsewhere in the words, both in intersyllabic and intrasyllabic patterns. Nevertheless, the mean ratio was higher for disyllabic words and CV.CV disyllabic sequences at word onset position. These results confirmed the presence in ULSID of the so-called LabialCoronal (LC) effect (MacNeilage and Davis, 2000). According to the authors, there is a strong preference for a specific intersyllabic pattern such that the onset of the first syllable of a disyllabic word CV.CV is a labial stop consonant and the onset of the second syllable is a coronal stop consonant. This pattern is absent during babbling, but appears during the first word stage (MacNeilage, Davis, Kinney and Matyear, 1999). This trend is
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
123
so strong that infants produce LC patterns even if the words in the adult language are CL. The authors reported, for example, that “soup” was pronounced with the inverse sequence “pooch” [pu:t]. In a review of seven previous studies, MacNeilage and Davis (1998) noted the predominance of the LC patterns in infants from five different language communities (French, American-English, Dutch, Spanish, Czech). In MacNeilage et al., (1999), the authors observed both CVC and CVCV words produced by 21 English-speaking infants during the first-50-word stage (12-18 months). They calculated the overall occurrences of the two opposite patterns and found a ratio of LC to CL equal to 2.55. They observed also the LC effect in samples of words of ten natural languages. In this cross-linguistic study, the mean ratio of LC to CL was 2.23. In a previous study carried out by Locke (1983), this effect of "anterior-to-posterior progression" was observed in the utterances of children and also in the vocabularies of English and French. Table 7. Mean values of LC/CL ratios for all word lengths as a function of syllable type and position within the word: (1) Bilabial consonants (2) All labial consonants (bilabials + labiodentals). Position
Word Onset
Elsewhere
Sequences
CVC
CV.CV
CVC
CV.CV
LC/CL (1)
1.53
2.41
1.68
1.75
LC/CL (2)
1.73
2.28
1.89
1.68
MacNeilage and Davis (2000) propose developmental arguments, based on the biomechanical properties of the vocal apparatus, to explain the LC effect in infants and adults. The authors put the LC preference within the context of the Frame/Content Theory. Findings from investigations in neurophysiology and clinical neurology led the authors to suggest that the LC effect could be a consequence of articulatory properties and more precisely, a consequence of selecting the simplest gestures first. They argue that LC patterns begin with a less complex task than CL patterns due to the fact that labials are easier to produce than coronals: labials are produced with a basic movement of the jaw while coronals require an additional movement of the tip of the tongue. It can be assumed that velars, which involve both the
124
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
backward movement of the tongue body and the raising of the tongue dorsum toward the soft palate, are also more complex to articulate than labials. In addition, many previous studies on tendencies in babbling and early speech across languages have observed that the emergence of the velar closing phase followed the emergence of both labial and coronal closures (Locke, 1983; Davis and MacNeilage 1994; Robb and Bleile, 1994; StoelGammon, 1985). However, comparing three articulatory models, Vilain, Abry, Brosda and Badin (1999) showed that the frame can produce labial or coronal closure, where the place of the closure depends on the position of the tongue at the beginning of the mandibular cycle. So, in this study, coronal closure seemed just as easy as labial closure to produce. In a recent study, Rochet-Capellan and Schwartz (2005a,b) proposed an original explanation of the LC effect. They analyzed the gestural overlap of the consonant closures (both occlusion and constriction) in a task of accelerated repetition of a given CVCV sequence (V = /a/ C = {/p/, /t/, /f/, /s/}) pronounced by thirty-two French subjects. The articulatory and acoustic measurements revealed that the effect of accelerating the repetition put the LVCV sequences in phase with a single jaw-opening gesture; in contrast, there were two jaw cycles when producing CVLV sequences (one cycle for each syllable). At slow speech-rate (2.5 Hz), the lower lip and the tongue tip in LVCV sequences were in phase with the mandibular gestures, but acceleration to five cycles per second prompted a loss of phasing for the tongue apex. At a fast rate, the labial release fit with the preparation phase or launching and the coronal release fit with the jaw-lowering phase. Their results show that LVCV sequences requires more economical mandibular gestures than the CVLV sequences. This is due to the fact that there is stronger articulatory cohesion between the jaw oscillations and lip and tongue movements in LVCV sequences. The authors conclude that the overlap of the two consonantal gestures is easier because, in LC patterns, the coronal closure could be prepared during the labial gesture, making LC simpler to produce than CL. Another recent study, exploiting the Verbal Transformation Effect (Warren, 1961), is in line with this idea (Sato, Vallée, Schwartz and Rousset, 2007). The Verbal Transformation Effect refers to the perceptual changes experienced while listening to a speech form cycled in rapid and continuous repetition. Sato et al. assumed that LC percepts would be more stable (lasting longer before the next transformation) than CL percepts. They proposed two experiments using either voiced or voiceless plosive
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
125
consonants, which confirm a greater stability and attractiveness for LC percepts. Several recorded CV syllables with C = {/p/, /t/, /b/, /d/} and V = {/a/, /i/, /o/} were paired with respect to both the vowel quality and the ±voiced consonant feature. The pairs of CV syllables were selected meticulously, taking into account their acoustic similarities (duration, intensity, formant and pitch values). The dissyllabic stimuli were /pata/, /tapa/, /piti/, /tipi/, /poto/ and /topo/ for experiment A; /bada/, /daba/, /bidi/, /dibi/, /bodo/ and /dobo/ for experiment B. For each stimulus, different lexical factors were calculated in order to eliminate a possible lexical effect on verbal transformations: the dissyllabic frequencies, the bigram frequencies, and the neighborhood density. The twenty-four participants heard the reverse disyllabic LVCV sequences (such as "pata" or "tapa") repeated 300 times with no interval between repetitions. They had to report what they perceived as soon as the sequence seemed to change into another form (even if it changed into one they had heard previously). The authors estimated the perceptual stability duration by measuring the time spent perceiving a given form before switching to another one. The results showed that the stability durations of /pV.tV/ were significantly higher than in /tV.pV/ sequences, regardless of the stimulus, with an average of 1.40 more /pV.tV/ than /tV.pV/. The same trend was observed for the patterns involving voiced plosives: the stability durations of /bV.dV/ were significantly higher than in /dV.bV/ sequences, with an average of 1.36 more /bV.dV/ than /dV.bV/. Sato et al. noted that, in the French lexicon, the number of lexical entries beginning with /p/ was twice as high as the ones beginning with /t/. In turn, the number of lexical entries beginning with /b/ was half the number of entries beginning with /d/. Thus, they observed a clear perceptual preference for the LC forms over the CL forms, even when the dissyllabic patterns heard by the subjects contained voiced consonants. Although this finding cannot account completely for the LC effect in languages, it clearly indicates that in a (…)CLCLCLCLC(…) sequence, the listener more naturally segmentes a sequence into LC chunks. This may suggest a possible perceptual correlate of the LC effect in French adults.
4. Consonant sequences with nasal and plosive Languages with similar phoneme inventories may have distinct phonotactic and distributional patterns in order to shape syllables, morphemes, and
SWIN|KCrEIB1Qqc8svpQueSEh0w==|1282028181
126
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
words, utterances. Within syllables, it is generally accepted that speech sounds are linearly ordered according to their intrinsic sonority, with the nucleus as the most sonorous element. Although languages permit that the syllabic constituents to be organized in a hierarchical structure, based on the famous Sonority Sequencing Principle (SSP), there is still no accepted universal scale of sonority. As pointed out by Ohala and Kawasaki (1997), the main reason is that there is no clear definition of sonority, not even one based on phonetic properties, like the correspondence between jaw openness and the sonority scale suggested by Lindblom (1983). On the other hand, it is well established that the SSP is unable to account for some sound sequences within and across languages (see Blevins (1995: 211) for /sp st sk/ onsets in English; Broselow (1995: 177) for prenasalized stops in syllable onsets; Montreuil (2000) for negative slope sonority in two consonant onset clusters in Raeto-Romance, Gallo-Italic, also Slavic). Most of the proposed sonority scales or other sound hierarchies (since Saussure, 1916 to Steriade, 1982, or Selkirk, 1984; Anderson and Ewen, 1987; Klein, 1993; Angoujard, 1997) fail to predict Nasal+Plosive sequences at the onset of syllables, and each time predict the inverse pattern Plosive+Nasal (see Clements (1990) for a detailed and well documented discussion on the role of the sonority in syllabification). As a result, the SSP cannot explain the observed combinations between nasals and plosives. In order to account for the favoured sound sequences involving nasals and plosives, we investigated the phonetic properties of the segments in the sequences. We attempted to estimate the role of both articulatory and aerodynamic factors in preferred and non-preferred sound sequences with a plosive and a nasal in ULSID’s languages. First, the distribution of both liquids and nasals with adjacent plosives were analyzed within the words and within the syllables. Our choice to observe liquids adjacent to nasals was justified in that the sonority ranking of nasals and liquids are similar (irrespective of the selected sonority scale) while their articulatory features are very different. The distributions of both Plosive+Nasal and Plosive+Liquid sequences within the words and within the syllables and the inverse combinations (Nasal+Plosive and Liquid+Plosive) were surveyed using 15 syllabified lexicons from the ULSID database. The segments under analysis were described in terms of manner: Plosive (P), Fricative (F), Nasal (N), and Liquid (L) (‘Liquid’ groups type of voiced lateral approximants and rhotics). The number of observed syllables was compared to the number of expected syllables. For example, the number of expected NPV( ) syllables was calculated using the number of CCV( ) syllables weighted by both the
Favoured syllabic patterns and sensorimotor constraints
127
probability of occurrence of the Nasal manner and of the Plosive manner. The same calculation was carried out for all the sequences under analysis. Thus, the number of expected NPV( ) sequences was estimated using the number of CCV( ) sequences in each syllabified lexicon. Within syllables, both complex onsets and complex codas were analyzed (complex syllables accounted for 2.7% of all ULSID’s syllables). As no complex syllables were observed in their lexicons, both !Xòõ and Yup’ik were not considered in this analysis. Three other languages were also ruled out (Afar, Navaho and Ngizim) because the expected frequencies for a given syllable was too low, generating artefactual large difference (when the ratio of observed and expected frequencies was calculated, a small difference on low values generated a high difference on the resulting value). Therefore, we needed a sufficient number of complex syllables for computing the ratio and pursuing the analyses. When a lexicon contained less than 30 complex syllables, it was excluded from the analyses. According to this limit, 9 languages with complex onsets (Finnish, French, Kannada, Kanuri, Nyah kur, Quechua, Sora, Thai, Wa) and 5 languages with complex codas (Kanuri, Nyah kur, Quechua, Thai and Wa) were retained for the analysis. It is worth noting that Kwakw’ala had complex codas without complex onsets. Table 8 presents the mean values of the ratios observed in tautosyllabic sequences involving either a nasal or a liquid contiguous to a plosive consonant. The results revealed that the patterns involving a liquid consonant followed the SSP: PLV sequences were mainly favored while LPV sequences were not found in ULSID’s languages. Complex codas with falling sonority (VLP) were more widespread than VPL rhymes. The latter pattern was found only in the French lexicon, without however being favored (ratio = 0.52 < 1). We observed different patterns in the distribution of nasals. PN sequences in onset position were rare, but followed SSP. Most of the languages studied did not have NPV sequences except two of them (Kanuri and Nyah kur). Besides, both languages favored this type of sequence (the ratios were, respectively, 3.24 and 1.65). Some NPV syllables were present in Ngizim, with 11 tokens out of the twenty CCV syllables. With respect to complex codas, VPN sequences were disfavored while VNP sequences were favored, in accordance with the SSP.
128
Nathalie Vallée, Solange Rossato and Isabelle Rousset
Table 8. Mean value of the observed/expected ratios for each tautosyllabic combination. Underscores indicate the position of the consonant (nasal or liquid) in the sequence. The sound sequences predicted by the SSP are in the gray columns. Complex onset (9 languages)
Complex coda (5 languages)
P_V
_PV
VP_
V_P
Nasal
0.01
0.54
0.03
3.89
Liquid
6.93
0
0.10
1.66
Analyses were extended to Nasal+Plosive and Liquid+Plosive sequences (and opposite combinations) across syllable boundaries. In the 15-language ULSID database, Wa has a monosyllabic lexicon and !Xòõ has too few clusters. So, they were excluded from the following analysis. For each combination, we calculated the mean ratio value among the 13 languages. The results presented in Table 9 reveal that both the VL.P and the L.PV sequences were widely favored across syllable boundaries when compared to the other sequences (VP.L and P.LV). With respect to nasals, the distributional patterns across syllable boundaries revealed another clear preference: N.PV was widely preferred to P.NV for 11 of the thirteen languages (except for both French and Yup’ik), and a similar tendency was found between VN.P and VP.N patterns (the respective values of the ratios were 2.14 and 0.21). Table 9. Mean value of the observed/expected ratios for each combination analyzed across syllable boundaries. The underscore gives the position of the consonant (nasal or liquid). P._V
_.PV
VP._
V_.P
Nasals
0.27
2.34
0.21
2.14
Liquids
0.32
1.09
0.17
1.50
The ratios indicated that both Nasals and Liquids demonstrated a clear preference for coda position, while Plosives tended to appear in onsets. This result follows the Syllable Contact Law which predicts that sonority drops maximally across syllable boundaries (Clements, 1990). Similar t