LIMITS? BEYOND LIMITS? DEALING WITH CHEMICAL RISKS AT WORK IN EUROPE
Related books AHMED, LIM & LO
Learning through Knowledge Management
FRICK
Systematic Occupational Health and Safety Management
HALE, HOPKINS & KIRWAN (eds.)
Changing Regulation: Controlling Risks in Society
HALE & BARAM
Safety Management and the Challenge of Organisational Change
HALE, WILPERT & FREITAG
After the Event: From Accident to Organisational Learning
PRUSAK
Knowledge in Organisations
VINCENT & DE MOL
Safety in Medicine
WILPERT & FAHLBRUCH
System Safety: Challenges and Pitfalls of Intervention www.elsevier.com
Related Journals Accident Analysis and Prevention Editors: R. Elvik and Karl Kim
Journalof Processing O p e r a t i o and ns Management Information Editor: R. T. Saracevic Hanfield Journal of Operations Management Editors:R.R.Hanfield Hanfield Editor: Journal of Safety Research Editors: T.W. Planek and M.-L. Lin Safety Science Editor: A.R. Hale
SCIENCE
R Dl R ECT®
LIMITS? BEYOND LIMITS? DEALING WITH CHEMICAL RISKS EUROPE AT WORK IN EUROPE
By DAVID WALTERS KAROLA GRODZKI
ELSEVIER Amsterdam -– Boston -– Heidelberg -– London -– New York -– Oxford Paris -– San Diego -– San Francisco -– Singapore -– Sydney -– Tokyo
ELSEVIERB.V. ELSEVIER B.V. Radarweg29 29 211,1000 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street Suite 1900, San Diego CA 92101-4495, USA
ELSEVIER Ltd. The Boulevard Langford Lane, Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB, UK
ELSEVIER Ltd. 84 Theobalds Road WC1X8RR London WC1X 8RR UK
© 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. copyiight by Elsevier Ltd., and the following This work is protected under copyright following terms and conditions apply to its use:
Photocopying copyiight laws. Permission Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright of the Publisher and payment of aa fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, adveitising or promotional puiposes, copying for advertising purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available non-profit educational classroom use. for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Elsevier's Rights Department in in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) 1865 843830, 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. permissions @elsevier.com. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier fax (+44) 1865 (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). homepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). Copyiight Clearance Center, Inc., 222 In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK Copyiight Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London through the Copyright W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 20 7631 5555; fax: 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have aa local fax: (+44) 20 reprographic rights agency for payments.
Derivative Works of contents may be be reproduced for of the Publisher is is required for Tables of for internal circulation, but permission of for or distribution of of such material. Permission of of the Publisher is is required for all other derivative external resale or for all works, including compilations and translations. orUsage Electronic Storage or of the Publisher is is required to store or or use electronically any material contained in in this work, including Permission of of aa chapter. any chapter or part of of this work may be reproduced, stored in in aa retrieval system or or transmitted in Except as outlined above, no part of in or by by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or or otherwise, without prior written any form or permission of the Publisher. Elsevier's Rights Department, at at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier’s
Notice is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as as aa matter of No responsibility is orotherwise, or from oroperation of of any methods, products, instructions or products liability, negligence or from any use or or in the of rapid advances in in the in particular, ideas contained in the material herein. Because of the medical sciences, in independent verification verification of of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First edition 2006 of Congress Cataloging in in Publication Data Library of A catalog record is is available from from the Library of of Congress. British Library Cataloguing in in Publication Data is available from the British Library. A catalogue record is
ISBN-13: 978-0-08-044858-9 978-0-08-044858-9 ISBN-10: 0-08-044858-5 @ The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Printed in The United Kingdom.
Working together to grow libraries in developing countries www.elsevier.com | www.bookaid.org | www.sabre.org
ELSEVIER
BOOK AID International
Sabre Foundation
v
Acknowledgements The research that went into writing this book was made possible by funding from two separate sources. First, the UK Health and Safety Executive supported a study into systems and practices for setting and using occupational exposure limits in selected EU countries. Second, the Long-range Research Initiative (LRI) of the European Chemical Industry Council (CEFIC) funded an on-going study focused on the management of chemical risks in smaller enterprises in several EU countries. Material from both these studies has been used in the completion of the present volume. The authors are grateful for the assistance of numerous individuals, from both organisations that have been helpful throughout the research and writing of the book. We would especially like to thank members of the HSC Advisory Committee on Toxic Substances, Judy Caute, Carole Sullivan and Michael Topping of the HSE and Chris Money of CEFIC and the LRI. In preparing this book we have also been reliant on the aid of a substantial number of persons in each country in which our investigations have been undertaken. Representatives of trade unions, labour inspectorates, health and safety policy makers, employers' organisations, researchers and observers were not only willing subjects for interview but often played a key role establishing further contacts with important informants in each country. Although these people are too numerous to mention by name, the authors would like to acknowledge their debt to their active co-operation and help. Without it, this book would not have been possible. In addition, we would like especially to thank Ann-Beth Antonsson, Kaj Flick, Mat Jongen, Alex Karageorgiou, Gtinther Kittel, Jan Popma, Andrea Tozzi, Remco Visser, Janneke Waage, Kerstin Wahlberg and Henning Wriedt for facilitating contacts in the countries of the study and for helping with the content of the country chapters, Martin Axon and Ian Bartlett both formerly of South Bank University for assisting with organising the early part of the work and for stimulating discussion on the scientific/technical aspects of the subject. Hazel Slavirt and Nick Bailey provided additional editorial support and last but by no means least we are especially grateful to Sandra Bonney for her help in preparing the final version of the book and for working on the Index, While acknowledging the help of all these sources, the responsibility for the content and views expressed in the following pages and any inaccuracies or misrepresentations therein remains that of the authors.
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION: HAZARDS, RISKS AND LIMITS
1
2
1
Hazardous Substances - A Defining Concern of Occupational Health and Safety Why Focus on OELs? The Countries The Structure of the Book
2 5 9 11
THE PROBLEM OF CHEMICAL RISKS
13
Introduction Chemicals at Work in the EU Mortality, Morbidity and Occupational Exposure to Hazardous Substances in Europe Issues for the Role of OELs in Managing Work With Chemical Risks What are Occupational Exposure Limits and How Have They Developed? The Meaning and Use of Exposure limits New Directions in Regulating Risk Management of Hazardous Substances and the Role of OELs Conclusions: But What About Using OELs?
13 13
EXPOSURE LIMITS AND INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTURES FOR HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE REGULATION IN THE EUROPEAN UNION , Introduction EU Legislative Frameworks for Minimising Health and Safety Risks of Dangerous Substances Requirements Regulating Chemical Risks Generally in the EU European Legislation With A Special Focus On Protecting Workers from the Risks Arising from Hazardous Chemicals OEL Setting at the European Level Effectiveness of the Existing Legislation and the Future Approach at Community Level
15 19 21 25 30 35
37 37 38 40 47 53 56
viii Beyond Limits
REACH and Worker Protection Conclusion
60 62
SYSTEMS FOR SETTING AND USING OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMITS IN EU 15 COUNTRIES
65
Introduction Regulatory Systems and Responsible Bodies Implementing EU Requirements in EU 15 Member States Occupational Exposure Limit Values in the EU 15 Countries Procedures for Setting OELs Enforcement and Surveillance of Compliance with OELs in EU 15 Countries Austria Belgium Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Ireland , Italy Luxembourg Portugal Spain Sweden The Netherlands United Kingdom Conclusions
94 94 95 96 97 99 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 Ill 112
THE UNITED KINGDOM
119
,
,
Introduction Background: Legislative Reforms from the 1970s Regulating Risk Management of Hazardous Chemicals Using OELs at the Workplace New Approaches to Chemical Controls: A New Role for OELs? OELs and COSHH Essentials in Practice
65 67 72 73 84
119 120 123 135 147 152
Table of Contents ix
Summary of WEL Setting Procedures (After HSC 2003)
159
Conclusions: Applying the New Framework in Practice
161
GERMANY
171
,
Introduction The Background The Extent of the Problem of Chemical Exposure in Germany Regulating Chemical Risks - The Germany Health and Safety System in Outline The Legislative Framework for OELs Wood Dust Toluene Discussion: The role of OELs in Monitoring Compliance with Requirements to Manage the Use of Chemicals Safely GREECE Introduction The Regulatory Infrastructure Setting Exposure Limits The Role of OELs in Achieving Compliance - in Theory The Role of OELs in Regulating the Management of Risk in Practice Challenges for Regulating the Management of Chemical Risks in Greece Enhancing Competence in Relation to Hazardous Substances Qualifications of Safety Engineer Sector Specific Experience of Wood Dust and Toluene Conclusions: The Limited Role of OELs in Controlling Risks of Hazardous Chemicals in the Workplace
171 173 173 175 182 193 205 217 227 227 229 233 235 237 240 241 244 245 254
ITALY
261
Introduction , The Italian Model for Regulating Health and Safety at Work Legislative Background , Measures Regulating Chemical Risks Application in Practice
261 264 265 268 276
x Beyond Limits
8
9
10
Conclusions
286
THE NETHERLANDS
289
Introduction
289
The Infrastructure and Processes Involved in Setting OELs Political and Legislative Contexts Operating the Dutch Approach to OELs , Conclusions
291 296 303 315
SWEDEN
319
Introduction The Use of Chemical Substances at Work in Sweden Economic and Legislative Background The Swedish Approach to Regulating the Work Environment Setting OELs Achieving Compliance with OELs Conclusions
319 320 321 322 324 327 335
BEYOND LIMITS?-THE PLACE OF OELs IN THE NEW REGULATION OF CHEMICAL RISKS IN EUROPE
341
Introduction What are OELs for? The Changing Role of OELs in Regulatory Approaches to Achieving Chemical Risk Management The Way Forward?
341 343 .347 357
REFERENCES
367
INDEX
407
xi LIST OF FIGURES Figure 4.1 Figure 4.2 Figure 4.3 Figure 4.4 Figure 5.1 Figure 5.2 Figure 5.3 Figure 6.1
HSE'sTolerabilityofRisk Framework and OELs Setting OELs in the UK (after Topping 2001) Mechanism of actions involving OELs Summary ofWEL setting procedures (after HSC 2003) The German OHS system Aggregated data for Toluene Exposure measurements of Toluene Number of inspection visits and sanctions distributed by economic activity
131 133 144 159 179 210 211 239
xii
LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1 National institutions with responsibilities for developing occupational exposure limits and with their surveillance. 68 Table 3.2 Some common features of OEL terminology in EU 15 country lists 76 Table 3,3 Summary of procedures for setting OELs in EU 15 countries 84 Table 5.1 Number of businesses in woodworking and furniture 196 Table 5.2 Number of employees in woodworking and furniture 196 Table 6.1 Number of inspection visits 238 Table 6.2 Number of sanctions 238 Table 6.3 Qualification Requirements for Safety Engineers According to the Risk Classification of Enterprises 244
xiii LIST OF ANNEXES
Annex 1 Websites of Ministries and other bodies involved in Health and Safety
379
Annex 2 Transposition of Main European Chemical Legislation (workers protection against hazardous chemicals)
386
Annex 3 Source of legislative provisions and occupational exposure level lists
388
Annex 4 National Institutions responsible for setting OELs.
398
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
1
INTRODUCTION: HAZARDS, RISKS AND LIMITS This book is a study of strategic approaches to managing the risks of working with hazardous substances in the European Union. Its central theme addresses developments at national and international levels concerning safety in the use of chemical substances at work. Its primary focus is the role of occupational exposure limits (OELs) in these developments and their translation - again with particular reference to OELs - into practices within workplaces and especially within the small and medium sized workplaces that constitute the vast majority of establishments in which people work in Europe. It sets out to answer two linked questions -
What drives informed and competent risk management in chemical health and safety? What is the role (if any) of OELs in this process?
In seeking the answers to these questions and contextualising them within wider approaches to occupational health and safety (OHS) management in Europe, the book explores the challenges hazardous substances pose for effective OHS management. It grew out of a research project commissioned by the Health and Safety Commission (HSC) Advisory Committee on Toxic Substances (ACTS) in the UK in 2002.1 The aim of that project was to inform discussion of reform of the UK system for setting occupational exposure limits (OELs) by providing information on systems adopted for this purpose in other EU countries and on how such OELs are used in practice at workplaces in these countries. The contents of the present volume represent a considerable development of these aims. They encompass an overview of the legislative frameworks and responsible bodies involved in setting OELs at EU level and in all EU 15 countries and a detailed study of policy and practice in the use of OELs in risk management of hazardous substances at national, sectoral and workplace levels in six of these countries. Based on this material, they further include the identification and analysis of the issues confronting strategic approaches to regulating risk management of
The full report of this research project is available from HSE Books. See Walters et al (2003).
2 Beyond Limits
hazardous substances, ways in which they are addressed at EU level and in the countries that are the focus of the study. Nevertheless the research that was undertaken for the ACTS study remains the basis for much of the empirical material included here. It has been updated and further developed since it was originally collected in 2002/3 and also includes additional material derived from a current study funded by the European Chemical Industry Council (CEFIC)2 concerned with approaches to risk management of hazardous substances in small enterprises across most of the same range of European countries covered by the original project. As we explore in Chapter 2, the subject is particularly topical in the light of current strategies on chemical risks at EU level. Although the focus of the book is on the EU 15 countries,3 the recent expansion of the Community to include a range of new member states with reconstituted health and safety systems that are considerably younger and less sophisticated than those presently found in northern European member states, makes its findings especially timely in relation to these countries too.
HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES—A DEFINING CONCERN OF OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH AND SAFETY. For most people, the effects of exposure to hazardous substances are prominent amongst risks that they commonly associate with the work environment. From earliest times, ill effects of work on health have been linked with exposure to chemical substances in their various physical forms and especially to airborne chemicals in the form of dusts, fumes and gases. These associations, the need to find out more about them, and to avoid or control their effects, have been fundamental to the growth of the subject of occupational health and safety as a research and professional concern, to the role of regulation in the work environment and to both the development of organised labour and its health and safety strategies. There are historical inter-relationships between these various elements that have helped to define the way in which professional, regulatory and interest group approaches to the broad subject of health and safety has developed over the last two
This research project titled, 'A Review of Workplace Management Strategies for Chemicals in Small Enterprises" is funded by the CEFIC Long Range Research Initiative (LRI). It will be completed by mid-2006 and will be the subject of further publications. That is, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, The Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and the United Kingdom.
Introduction 3 centuries in market economies. Central to them has been concern about hazardous substances. A further dimension of the role of hazardous substances in health and safety is the part they have played in the development of attitudes and awareness of risk and risk regulation in wider society. Interlinked with occupational concerns but encompassing both consumer and environmental interests, public concern about hazardous substances in the economy is now deeply engrained in civil society and has wide-reaching political, economic and regulatory dimensions embracing for example, the governance of risk from hazardous installations, consumer safety, and environmental contamination as well as healih and safety at work. The unchecked activity of chemical polluters and the effects of their pollution were amongst the formative concerns of environmental movements internationally from the late 1960s. They remain central to the concerns of both these social interest groups and the wider public. Parenthetically, the development of much of the ideas behind modern radical support for the reform of health and safety regulation has its roots in the same formative issues. Linked to them are also the changes that have taken place in public awareness of the role of government, industry and the scientific establishment in addressing the regulation of the risks of hazardous substances. Perceived failures in exercising such control effectively account to no small extent for the current low levels of public trust in these actors and their policies. At the same time, policy makers and regulators at sectoral, national and international levels, as well as interest groups that are engaged with policy and regulation at these levels, have all struggled to effect strategies for safe use of hazardous substances at work that are both rigorous and transparent. The current frameworks for setting OELs and the thinking behind them in different EU countries and at EU level are themselves products of such efforts. This is in part because although there is substantial concern about the hazardous nature of many substances that are used at work, it is equally self-evident that the economic worth of producing and using such substances and their value to society dictates their continuing and even increasing presence in the workplace. As a consequence, the risks of working with them, as well as the need to better understand and control their use, have been a primary focus for the scientific and engineering basis of monitoring and controlling the working environment that has guided the emergence of professional disciplines such as those of occupational hygiene, elements of safety engineering and occupational medicine, toxicology and related fields during their development over the past century and a half. In post-industrialised market economies organised labour has evolved strategic positions on achieving the regulation and control of the risks of
4 Beyond Limits hazardous substances that are themselves deeply rooted in the experiences of labour including the suffering of victims and their families - and which are not so much aimed at contributing to the science, engineering and technology of safe chemical usage as they are at ensuring the representation of the views and experiences of those affected by chemical hazards. At the same time, in most social democracies the structures and processes for regulating occupational risks share some common ground in as much as there is a place within them for social dialogue. Since the 1970s tripartitism in decision making on regulating health and safety has been increasingly the pattern in most EU member states and at European level reflecting, amongst other things, the orientation of regulatory provisions towards the processes of managing health and safety in which the participation of workers is seen as central to successful health and safety management. Representatives of industry and labour and their advisers therefore meet together with those of the state to decide on ways in which improvements are to be achieved in regulating occupational risks. The structures and procedures for setting OELs and deciding their regulatory status are constituted along these lines in most EU countries. In such forums issues of cost and practicability are central to decisions about control and this is as true for the regulation of the risks of hazardous substances as it is for health and safety matters generally. In these forums therefore, as well as organised labour the role of capital is a significant presence and both the chemical industry itself and representatives of employers that use chemicals provide a powerful lobby advocating the benefits of chemical substances they produce and use. In all of this an approach to safeguarding workers' health and safety has emerged where the moral high ground has been dominated by precautionary principles of control in which essentially ethical considerations demand a preferred sequence for the selection of appropriate controls to ensure maximum safety in the use of hazardous substances and where safety should not be assumed in the absence of proven risk. Within the hierarchy of control thus envisaged, for example removal of the risk of harm through substitution of unsafe substances with a safe one, is preferable to controlling the use of the substance though physical containment to prevent human contact. This in turn is preferred to minimising the risk of human contact with airborne contamination through provision of exhaust ventilation at source, itself a strategy that is seen as preferable to minimising human contact by behavioural controls for workers and the provision of protective equipment. Juxtaposed with such ethics are the essentially economic considerations behind the use to which the hazardous substance is being put and their value to wider society, as well as the economic and technical feasibility of the
Introduction 5
introduction of suitable health and safety control. Thus compromise situations result in which notions of managing risk to acceptable or tolerable levels are pursued within whichever value system is operational in the social, legal, political and economic context of the society and time in question.
WHY FOCUS ON OELS? Achieving such controls requires good quality information concerning the properties and known health effects of exposure to substances, as well as on the technical issues of achieving appropriate environmental control, in order that the feasibility of introducing particular control measures can be weighed against the consequences of exposure. Ideally, since the toxicity of a particular substance is usually dependent on a combination of its (toxic) properties and the quantity (dose) to which the subject is exposed, it should be possible to protect the health of workers by determining levels of exposure below which the risks to health are reduced to negligible levels. The idea of exposure limits for hazardous substances in workplace health and safety developed from this. First proposed by individuals in the late 19th century, subsequently developed into nationally applicable lists in the first half of the 20th century and most conspicuously represented by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists' (ACGIH) list of Threshold Limit Values (TLVs) that originally dated from 1946, as we discuss in Chapter 1, OELs became prominent in professional approaches to monitoring and controlling occupational exposures during the second half of the 20* century.4 Indeed, it could be argued that especially in North America and the UK, their understanding and use played a significant role in the development of the occupational hygiene profession.5 Although originally conceived as technical standards to be used as guidance for professional occupational hygienists, within in the EU such limits became increasingly incorporated into regulatory systems at national and EU level from the 1980s onwards. It is probable that there was a mixture of drivers behind this development. They would
According to Cook (1985 and 1987) the first 'official' list of OELs was issued by the USSR Ministry of Labour in 1930. See Piney (1989 and 1998) for a more detailed account of the interrelationship between the role of early OELs and the development of the occupational/industrial hygiene profession in the US and UK during the first half of the 10b century.
Limits 6 Beyond Limits have included the more structured and systematic approaches to regulating OHS management that began to emerge at national and European Community level during the 1980s, culminating in the Framework Directive 89/391 its daughter directives and the national measures that transpose them (Walters, 2002:41-47). Parallel approaches in relation to managing the risks of hazardous substances were emerging at national level (for example, the COSHH Regulations in the UK) and at EU level (such as the Directive 2004/37/EC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens and the Directive 98/24 on the protection of workers from the risks related to chemical agents at work). The demand for standards to control the use of a number of specific and highly toxic substances such as vinyl chloride, asbestos, benzene and lead in combination with the drive towards systematic management of OHS generally may have also fuelled the perceived need for greater systematicity in the regulation of the management of occupational exposure to hazardous substances. This may in turn have created pressure for a more developed regulatory role for OELs. At the same time that a number of European countries were setting up national bodies to set their own OELs instead of adopting the American list of TLVs produced by the ACGIH, European Community level institutions such as the Scientific Committee on Occupational Exposure Limits (SCOEL) were created with the intention to contribute to the process of setting OELs at EU level. The Chemical Agents Directive 98/24 and the Indicative Occupational Exposure Limit Value (IOELV) Directive made under it continued the institutionalisation of OELs within the legislative process, adding an international dimension to the pressure to incorporate OELs into regulatory systems. Incorporation of OELs into these systems however was not inevitable. It would seem that the decision making bodies internationally within Europe were desirous of adopting 'good occupational hygiene practice' in giving some regulatory significance to establishing the hierarchy of control practices referred to previously. Since OELs were fundamentally reference standards that were used by hygienists in exposure measurement they too would become part of the package of 'good occupational hygiene practice* that was being incorporated into regulatory systems. Additionally their incorporation seems also to have been driven by a desire to use numerical values to make judgements about risk and to guide practice in ways that may in hindsight appear, if not ill-considered, then at very least to underestimate the problems for risk communication that would be created by the need for a proper understanding of the meaning of such values.
Introduction 7 Somewhat paradoxically, by the time these developments were underway and 'good occupational hygiene practice* was achieving a level of regulatory incorporation that included a place for OELs, hygienists themselves were beginning seriously to question their value, as it was becoming more widespread knowledge that OELs were not without their limitations. As Hanson (1998:12) has observed, for a host of good reasons, there is in fact no reliable scientific basis for drawing a fine line between hazardous and non-hazardous concentrations of a toxic substance. Understanding the scientific meaning of an OEL and most importantly, its reliability as a measure of risk is therefore fundamental to its proper use. As we explore a little further in the following chapter, such an understanding requires a reasonably sophisticated appreciation of the scientific limitations of both the methodology for deriving OELs and the evidence on which they are based. In addition, as the prominence of OELs has increased, critics have pointed to serious shortcomings in both these fundamental elements in the derivation of such limits and the assumptions surrounding them, especially in relation to the most influential and widely used American ACGIH list of TLVs.6 The significance of these limitations of course becomes considerably more serious when they are incorporated into regulatory systems and this no doubt helped focus attention on them. In addition, a further set of doubts were growing, at least in some countries, concerning the practical use of OELs at the level of the workplace. To an extent these practical concerns were related to the complexities involved in understanding the meaning of OELs and thereby being able to use them in an informed and appropriate manner. However, they were also based on evidence emerging in the UK for example which indicated that despite them being quite central to the prevention principles that were the basis of regulatory measures such as the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations - they were in fact little understood by the majority of employers who were duty holders under the Regulations and required to implement their measures (HSE 1997). These developments and the debates that surround them were largely the reasons for undertaking the research project on which the following chapters are based. They raise some fundamental questions about the way in which OELs are understood by employers and workers and the use to which they are put in the practice of managing risks from Articles in the scientific literature in the late 1980s and early 1990s questioned the completeness of the evidence on which they were based and also pointed to corporate bias in the standard setting bias of the committee (Casteleman and Ziem 1988). See also Ziem and Castleman (1989) and Roach and Rappaport (1990).
Limits 8 Beyond Limits hazardous substances in European workplaces. Equally, they have implications for strategic decisions taken at national and sectoral levels about the role of OELs in regulating these practices. We explore these issues and assess their implications. There are indications of recent shifts in the function of OELs in regulatory strategies in some EU countries. We also examine the extent to which these changes reflect awareness of the possible limitations of the role of OELs in previous strategies and therefore represent more informed approaches. Fundamental to our approach, is the idea that such change cannot be understood in isolation from other aspects of regulating health and safety management in the EU. They are an integral part of this wider scenario and therefore affected by the pressures and constraints that have an impact upon it. The essential elements of current regulatory strategies aimed at the work environment in the EU - with their focus on employers' responsibilities for systematic OHS management through the adoption preventive principles in which risk evaluation and control in their workplaces are undertaken with the support, if necessary, of prevention services and through informing and consulting workers and their representatives - apply as much to managing the risks of hazardous substances as they do to all other aspects the work environment. Moreover, the same challenges to regulating the work environment in the modem world of work apply to hazardous substances as they do to regulating health and safety more generally. Any significant understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of role of OELs in managing health and safety regulation must be one that accounts for a world of work in which for example, a large proportion of work takes place in small enterprises where there is low trade union density and poor access to prevention services, as well as a very low likelihood of experiencing any proactive regulatory inspection visits. Such 'hard to reach' situations are by no means confined to small enterprises but are also found in what were formerly large organisations where the structure of work has become increasingly fragmented and where outsourcing, casualisation and the use of contractors and contractor labour on multi-employer worksites, all contribute challenges to the systematicity and penetration of management arrangements, especially where issues of information, communication and supervision are concerned. Arguably the relevance of approaches to using OELs in strategies to regulate the management of the risks of hazardous substances must account for the realities of the experiences of the most vulnerable workers in these situations if they are to be deemed to be effective. Relatedly, they need to take account of the levels of resourcing of regulatory inspection, the extent of effective worker consultation and representation, the presence and competence of prevention services in health and safety and the levels of use employers
Introduction 9 make of such services in supporting their approaches to managing the risks of hazardous substances in their workplaces. These are issues that we will examine in further detail in the chapters that deal with the approaches to setting and using OELs in the six countries that were the focus for detailed investigation. Our choice of these countries was based on several criteria as we outline in the following section.
THE COUNTRIES Resource constraints meant we could not study in detail all 15 countries that were member states of the EU at the time the fieldwork was undertaken. Countries were therefore selected on the basis of them providing a variety of national situations that reflected the full range of approaches used in relation to setting and using OELs - from highly developed OEL systems to minimal ones and therefore the range of different frameworks for the setting and use of OELs identified across all EU 15 countries. Our choice was also intended to be representative of the range of regulatory and socioeconomic systems in these countries and reflect some consideration of the size, complexity and economic importance of the countries. We selected: -
The UK - as the "benchmark' country in which there is a well-documented role for OELs within the regulatory system that has been subject to considerable and on-going reform in the light of experience. It is also a country in which the wider regulatory system for OHS reflects a particular approach to process regulation as well as to the use of more multidimensional approaches to regulatory intervention and one in which the strategy for reaching small enterprises is clearly articulated.
-
Sweden - as a representative Nordic country with advanced regulatory provisions for OHS and a long involvement in setting and using national OELs.
-
The Netherlands - because of the innovative approaches that appear to be in use in relation both to managing chemical risks and in OHS more widely. Also because in many respects it represents a hybrid of Nordic and Germanic approaches to labour relations and to regulating OHS (as well as being influenced by British pragmatism and the recommendations of the Robens Committee).
10 Beyond him its 10 Limits -
Germany - because of its size, economic importance and complexity, its dual system for OHS regulation, its approach to labour relations and its long history of setting and using exposure limits,
-
Italy - because it is a large and economically important southern European country with some unique regulatory features in its OHS system with interesting differences in approach to that of northern Europe. It also had a traditional approach to exposure standards that was different to that required under the Chemical Agents Directive.
-
Greece - as an example of a smaller and economically weaker southern European country with underdeveloped systems for the wider regulation of OHS as well as for setting and using OELs.
In each country we undertook to identify and review available literature, focusing on: -
-
issues in securing improved management of chemical health and safety, including: - perceptions of the problem - risk assessment - employer/worker awareness - securing compliance with OELs the status of controls for airborne exposures in each country degree to which such controls are applied measures used to achieve and monitor compliance and the extent of compliance itself.
It was anticipated that the literature would be rather limited in most countries and would not deal directly with many of these issues. This was indeed the case and other sources of information were sought including a number of key informants in each country. These informants were a mixture of regulatory agency personnel, trade union officials, industry spokespersons and specialist researchers/professionals, all of whom were considered to be well informed and well placed to comment on the realities of workplace practices. Their views were compared with documented policy as well as with existing literature on the issues under investigation in order to enhance and develop
Introduction 11
the picture of national practice. Specific information was sought from interviews concerning:7 -
theroleofOELs in determining what control measures were in use in OHS management at the workplace the extent to which reference was made to OELs in monitoring OHS management by the labour inspectorate what other measures were used in addition to or instead of OELs to determine control measures and good OHS management practice.
THE STRUCTURE OF THE BOOK Chapter 1 presents a brief overview of current understanding of occupational exposure to hazardous substances and its effects in terms of mortality and morbidity amongst workers. The role of chemicals in the economy and the extent of their production and use in the European Union are outlined before a discussion of the relevant key approaches to regulating health and safety health and safety management of hazardous substances in the European Union is presented. Since the book is concerned with their role in regulation, specific aspects of what OELs are and how they have developed and some key issues in understanding their meaning and appropriate use are explored. Their positions in current strategies to regulate chemical risk at European and national levels are outlined. Current issues for the use of OELs in the regulation of chemical risks emerge as a result and the chapter concludes with a discussion of their implications that sets the scene for the chapters that follow. In the original study on which this book is based, two substances were chosen for the main focus of the country studies. They were toluene and wood-dust, for which, all EU member states have exposure limits. It was intended that attention would be paid especially to sectors in which there was relevant experience of exposure to these substances and in which a reasonable range of workplace size, work processes and health and safety risks were represented. The main sectors where we thought it most likely we would find such things were the furniture industry, printing and metal manufacture. In practice, we found it necessary not to restrict the study to experiences associated only with these substances and sectors to explain and understand national approaches and a more general view of practice in relation to OELs was in feet sought. The present volume reflects this experience, however, some of the detailed examples of practices in relation to these two substances in the sectors mentioned have been retained.
12 Beyond him its 12 Limits
Chapter 2 is concerned the structures and procedures for setting and applying OELs at European level. It opens with a description of the development of the relevant EU provisions for regulating health and safety in relation to hazardous substances and describes the structures and procedures for setting OELs at the European level. It goes on to describe current changes taking place in regulatory policies on chemical substances, focusing especially on the proposals for new chemicals regulation known as REACH (Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation, of Chemicals), to Chapter 3 we turn to the regulatory provisions, institutions and procedures for setting OELs within the health and safety systems of each of the EU 15 member states. Chapters 4 to 9 detail these matters for the six countries listed above, to each country the mam focus concerns the practice of using OELs and is especially concerned with the role of OELs in regulating OHS management at the level of the enterprise. Each chapter therefore considers the role of OELs at the workplace level in each of the six countries. Using information from interviews with enforcement agencies, employers, trade unionists and other key stakeholders in each country, as well as documentary sources, the chapters offer a detailed analysis of strengths and weaknesses in the role of exposure limits in compliance strategies on chemical risk management at the workplace, to addition they report on a variety of current strategies that are undertaken in different countries to improve the management of the risks associated with working with hazardous chemicals and examine where OELs fit into these strategies. They discuss the practicability of these approaches, their application and coverage in relation to the emerging policies on chemical risks at national and international levels. In doing so they also take into account wider perspectives both in relation to perceptions of the value of OELs in managing chemical risks and in terms of structures and processes for OHS regulation more generally and the challenges they face. The national variations in these structures and processes are of direct relevance to the strategic significance or otherwise of OELs in the process of regulation and this significance cannot be appreciated fully without an understanding of the wider regulatory scenario. In Chapter 10, the concluding chapter, the information from the previous chapters is drawn together in a discussion in which the two themes of policy and practice that nm throughout the study are linked and the lessons that have been drawn from the analysis are presented.
13 13
THE PROBLEM OF CHEMICAL RISKS
INTRODUCTION In this Chapter we first present a brief outline of the role of chemicals in the economy of the European Union. We note the consequences of their use in terms of the effects of occupational exposure to hazardous substances on mortality and morbidity amongst workers. We then turn to a discussion of the relevant key approaches to regulating health and safety management of hazardous substances in the European Union. Since the book is concerned with the role of OELs in this regulation, the positions of OELs in current strategies to regulate chemical risk at European and national levels are outlined. This leads us to a reflection on some specific aspects of what OELs are and how they have developed and some key issues in understanding their meaning and appropriate use are identified and discussed. The chapter concludes with a discussion of the implications of these issues for the regulation of chemical risks that sets the scene for the chapters that follow.
CHEMICALS AT WORK IN THE EU According to the European Commission's White Paper on the strategy for a future chemicals policy, the global production of chemicals had increased from lmillion tonnes in 1930, to 400 million tones by the time the White Paper was published in 2001 (EC, 2001:4). The chemical industry in the EU produces about one third of total international chemical output and as such is collectively the largest chemical industry in the world, with an estimated turnover of some €556 billion in 2003 (for the EU 25 countries) (CEFIC 2004).
14 Beyond Limits 14
About 100,000 different chemical substances are registered in the EU, of which 10,000 are marketed in volumes of more than 10 tonnes and 20,000 marketed at volumes of between 1-10 tonnes. In 1998 world chemical production was estimated to be valued at €1,244 billion, of which the largest share (31 per cent) was produced by the EU chemical industry. It is Europe's third largest manufacturing industry, employing 1.7 million people directly with a further 3 million jobs dependent on it. Although large multinational corporations are prominent in the industry, in Europe there are also 36,000 SMEs (over 95 per cent of the total number of chemical firms in Europe) that between them are responsible for 28 per cent of chemical production (CEC 2001). The chemical industry itself is mainly concentrated in Germany, France, the UK and Italy. The largest share is in Germany with 26 per cent of total EU production, followed by France (17 per cent) the UK (14 per cent) and Italy (12 per cent). Chemical production is however only one aspect. The European Union remains the single largest market for the chemicals industry. Chemicals are used in vast numbers of workplaces across the whole spectrum of economic sectors, both private and public. In addition to the direct industrial users of chemicals supplied by their original manufacturers and importers, there are also formulators that use chemicals supplied by original manufacturers or importers in various combinations in their own products before marketing them to further users and there are distributors of these products as well as those of the original manufacturers and importers. There are several consequences of this for workers' health and safety and its regulation. First, it obviously means that the workers who may be at risk of exposure to hazardous chemicals will be found throughout the economy and not just amongst the employees of the chemical industry and its dependents. The most recent information provided by the series of surveys conducted by the European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions found that 22 per cent of respondents in the EU thought themselves to be exposed to dangerous substances for at least a quarter of their working time while sixteen percent thought they handled dangerous substances daily (European Foundation 2001). In an earlier study it was estimated that some 32 million workers in EU countries were exposed to occupational carcinogens (Kogevinas 1998) and there were between 35,000 to 45,000 per year.1 If these
As well as the direct products of the chemical industry occupational carcinogens identified in this estimation included environmental tobacco smoke, radon, diesel exhaust and crystalline silica. See also Finnish Institute for Occupational Health, 1998.
The Problem of Chemical Risks 15
experiences are typical for European workers generally it suggests that millions of workers across Europe as a whole are exposed to hazardous chemicals at work. Secondly, there is a huge gap in knowledge concerning the potential risks to human health associated with the enormous numbers of substances produced and marketed in the EU and only limited data on the exposure of large number of persons involved in using the substances and the situations in which they do so. Thirdly, the role of intermediaries in the downstream supply chain from manufacture to use contributes to the remoteness of some users from the original suppliers of the substances they are using. This may complicate, alter or obstruct the quality of information flow concerning safe use of chemical substances from supplier to end-user. Such potential effects on the consequent ability of users to use hazardous substances safely, therefore pose challenges for the chemical industry to fulfil its statutory obligations to the users of its products effectively and at the same time presents a problem for appropriate regulation.
MORTALITY, MORBIDITY AND OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE TO HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES m EUROPE It has been estimated from EU aggregate data9 that nearly one third of all occupational diseases recognised annually in the EU are related to exposure to chemical substances (Musu 2004).10 Data on death and disease associated with occupational exposure to hazardous substances is available from a variety of sources such as those based on for example: -
National statutory reporting requirements for occupational diseases, injuries and fatalities Registries of specific conditions such as cancer, skin or respiratory diseases associated with occupational exposure Available from Occupational Diseases in Europe in 2001, Statistics in Focus, Population and Social Conditions No 15 Eurostat, 2004, http://eiiropa.eu.int/connn.eurostaP-Publications. A substantial proportion of these are caused by chemical dusts such as asbestos.
16 Beyond him its 16 Limits
— Household surveys of self-reported sickness absence — Epidemiologieal studies in relation to specific forms of ill-health and their occupational causes Despite the current widespread concern about the risks of hazardous substances in the workplace, there are considerable problems in defining the proportion of death and disease in society that can be accurately attributed to occupational exposure to hazardous substances. There are many reasons for the difficulties researchers have encountered in attempting such calculations. They include the limited completeness of officially reported data, which is often defined by laws that were put in place for reasons that are at odds with the collection of comprehensive data on occupational disease." Such data in some systems is known to under-report the occurrence of the conditions it records because of failure to report them on the part of duty-holders. There are national variations in the nature of what is required to be reported and in the administrative systems for recording it. These lead to further variation in the quality and comprehensiveness of the national data and make aggregation and consistency of such material problematic at a European level. There is often a time lag between exposure and onset of disease, which in some cases may be considerable and which means that the current information about health effects may, in fact, refer to exposures that took place at times in the past when such exposure may have been of a different character to that experienced at present. Other measures of the extent of the experience of ill-health may be derived from workers' own self-reporting such as undertaken in the Labour Force Survey in the UK for example. Such measures usually result in substantially larger estimations of the extent of work-related ill-health and may be useful in calculating time lost to economic production and burdens on the health care and social welfare systems, but as measures of the nature and extent of illhealth they are problematic for a number of other reasons to do with respondents' self-diagnosis and memory of their work experiences. Estimations of mortality and morbidity based on these sources or on extrapolations from specific studies are themselves also controversial in terms of the methodology adopted and the assumptions made about what is or is not included as indications of the extent of the harm being estimated, hi acknowledgement of such problems many current estimations provide lower and In some cases, such as in the UK for example such requirements have had more to do with limiting the number of claimants eligible for social welfare benefits than a desire to document the extent of a particular association between work and ill-health.
The Problem of Chemical Risks 17
higher limits to their figures according to the different elements of methodology and coverage in deriving them.12 Although detailed discussion of all these problems is beyond the scope of the present volume, the significance of the uncertainty to which they contribute is central to the strategic development of regulatory approaches to risk management of hazardous substances and the position of OELs in such processes. It is also central to a second important issue that current more systematic regulation of chemical substances at the EU level is attempting to cover - reducing the burden of mortality and morbidity associated with occupational exposure to chemicals whose health effects are little known and with situations in which exposure is unknown or unspecific. The approach of Doll and Peto (1981) to estimating the extent of mortality from cancer that is due to occupational causes has been the basis for several subsequent estimations.13 m one of the most recent of these, a study undertaken to inform the European Commission in its deliberations on current regulatory strategies on controlling hazardous chemicals, Postle et al (2003) estimate that 3.5 per cent of the total cancer mortality in the EU was associated with occupational exposure to chemicals and the authors suggest that about 20 per cent of such mortality may stem from exposure to currently unknown chemical carcinogens. Spokespersons for the chemicals industry have disputed these figures. They point out, amongst other things, that the authors of this study confuse the more general situation of working with hazardous substances with working with chemicals in the chemical industry. Based on evidence from large German chemical companies, they further argue that there is evidence to show that, in fact, measured exposure to carcinogens in large plants in the industry has declined (CEFIC 2003). On this basis they suggest that exposure to chemicals in similar plants in the industry is also likely to have declined and argue that this indicates the success of OHS management measures in the industry.14 "While these may be valid criticisms of the particular study undertaken by Postle et al for the European Such is the case in most of the sources referred to in subsequent paragraphs. However, in some cases the range between upper and lower limits is so great that such estimates are of limited practical use. See for example Kogeninas et al 1998; Morrell et al 1998; ILO 2000; Postle et al 2003. Also, more generally see Greenberg et al 2001; Leigh et al, 1999. See also Kromhout and Vermeulin (2000) for a more general discussion of long term trends in occupational exposure to hazardous substances.
18 Beyond him its 18 Limits
Commission, they do nothing to negate the wider evidence of the relationship between known hazardous substances and the extent of deaths from cancer, nor do they contradict the proposition that a substantial though unknown proportion of these deaths result from exposure to hazardous substances that are not yet identified as carcinogens. Cancer is by no means the only condition caused by exposure to hazardous substances. Other diseases, of the respiratory system, the skin and the central nervous system are also associated with such exposures, as are allergies and reproductive, developmental and endocrine disorders. They add up to a formidable burden of fatal and non-fatal illness caused by exposure to hazardous substances at the workplace. However, there are no reliable data concerning the full occurrence of such conditions on a European scale. Nor is there anything like complete data on exposure - although here again there are specific cases of very good exposure data-bases at national sectoral level.15 Although there are plenty of specific detailed studies that support both the idea that the health effects of occupational exposure to hazardous substances are substantial and a cause for concern, the full extent of this occupational exposure and its health consequences remains unknown. All this is a major challenge for regulatory strategies aimed at helping to reduce it. Indeed, if the logic of the argument applied by the chemical industry apologists outlined above is followed, the dimensions of the problem become apparent, for it is not the diminishing number of large chemical manufacturing firms that define its parameters. Rather, it is experiences of hazardous substances amongst users in the much larger and increasing numbers of small or fragmented workplaces in which sophisticated control measures such as those that result in reduced exposures in large chemicals firms are not in evidence and where contact with regulatory intervention is also unlikely. It is the reality of regulating the safe use of chemicals in this far more diverse environment that has exercised poEcy makers at national and European levels in recent years and it is to the role of exposure standards in this process that we will turn next. Before doing so however we need to say something about the nature of such standards.
Such as the database DOK.-MEGA run by the BGIA and the BGen in Germany for example - see Chapter 5).
The Problem of Chemical Risks 19
ISSUES FOR THE ROLE OF O E L S IN MANAGING WORK WITH CHEMICAL RISKS The main concern of this book is the role of OELs in the regulation of the risks of hazardous substances. Exposure limits are prescriptive standards in as much as they set specific requirements concerning the precise measures of particular substances that are allowed in the air of the workplace. They are based on scientific evidence concerning what is known about the biological effects of certain chemical substances combined with what is considered to be technically and economically feasible in achieving their control. Such standards are themselves not new. They had been used as technical guidance in occupational hygiene for several decades before being incorporated in the regulatory systems in many countries. However, incorporation gave them a different status to the one they held previously and at the same time has led to questions and concerns about their role. These concerns have become more prominent over the last decade as evidence questioning their usefulness within the system for regulating selfregulation has mounted, indicating the very limited degree to which duty holders understand them.16 Clearly, if many employers, especially those in small enterprises, do not know how to determine whether exposure levels in their workplaces comply with the relevant OELs, (or even that they should determine such matters) the role of limits, in the practice of managing the risks of hazardous substances at the workplace level, is open to question. Even more fundamental are questions concerning the meaning of OELs especially ones that address the extent to which they are misconceived to represent 'safe limits' by users. Such questions penetrate to the core of current thinking on risk communication and risk regulation. If the definition of the level of risk represented by an exposure limit for a 'hazardous substance' is prone to a misinterpretation concerning its meaning and limitations, then the whole system is also likely to suffer a loss of both sense and credibility in terms of risk communication. One of the major shifts that has occurred in public policy in In the UK the results of HSE commissioned research showed that only 16 per cent of a sample of respondents from establishments manufacturing or using chemicals mentioned complying with COSHH or OELs as legal requirements for work in such situations. They demonstrated an almost complete absence of detailed knowledge or understanding of the duties associated with OELs and Maximum Exposure Limits (MELs) (HSE 1997).
20 Beyond Limits
recent years has been the greater attention paid to societal perception of risk that has followed fiom the (somewhat belated) realisation that public perceptions of risk and especially of risk regulation are essential considerations if strategies on the governance of risk are to be successful. Following the catastrophic loss of public trust precipitated by governmental and 'expert' handling of issues such as nuclear power, BSE, foot and mouth disease and genetic manipulation, taking account of public trust has become a more significant aspect of regulation of risk in public policy. To do so, at very least, requires a participatory approach and a blend of clarity and transparency in both the decision-making processes and their end results. As well as the economic considerations that often affect whether substances have an OEL, there are also technical questions concerning problematic details such as the difficulties encountered in applying its criteria to certain substances, so that it is not possible to give them an OEL despite their known hazards. Such problems have contributed to a growing recognition of the need for reform. A further matter is the need for compatibility in standard setting procedures between EU Member States and procedures at the level of the EU. There are several reasons for this including the obvious requirement for general harmonisation in OHS regulation. More specifically, the question of the meaning of exposure limits, their toxicological basis and the issue of economic and technical feasibility of achieving best practice in the workplace have taxed regulators and practitioners for decades. There is consequently a history of standard setting structures, processes and outcomes at European level, the consequences of which policy makers and regulators are obliged to take account at national level. In the following section we sketch out some of these issues and provide some background to understanding the development of the role of OELs in chemical regulation. We begin with a brief outline of what occupational exposure limits are and how they have developed from scientific/technical standards to regulatory ones. In doing this we also consider some of the key issues that have exercised participants in the process of setting limits and in particular, questions of technical and economic feasibility that lie at the core of many of the debates surrounding regulating the risks of chemical substances. This leads to consideration of some relevant aspects of the relationship between societal risk perception and regulating the management of hazardous chemicals at work. Finally, we draw these various threads together by returning to the likely role of OELs in modern European
The Problem of Chemical Risks 21
approaches to regulating the management of hazardous chemicals at the workplace and the policy questions for regulating the (systematic) management of workplace chemical risks in the EU.
WHAT ARE OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMITS AND HOW HAVE THEY DEVELOPED? Occupational exposure limits for airborne concentrations of hazardous substances are essentially measurable values of airborne (and therefore breathable) contamination by chemical substances that are points of reference for the development of workplace strategies to protect workers from health risks associated with inhalation of chemical substances. Beyond this general definition lie a number of levels of complexity and contradiction. Exposure limits have been proposed by individual researchers for particular substances and classes of substances since the late 19th and early 20th centuries (Hanson 1998). Several lists were published in Europe and the US in the 1920s and 1930s but the most influential was that of the American Conference of Governmental Hygienists (ACGIH) which published its first TLVs in 1946. The list was adopted by the US federal government as its official standard in 1969. Although from the outset certain other countries such as the USSR and the Federal Republic of Germany have determined their own limits, the dominant role that the ACGIH TLVs have played as a reference list for exposure standards in industrialised countries is well documented," The development of single figure exposure limits such as were found in the ACGIH list has been well described by Piney (1998) who applies Kuhn's (1970) theoretical explanation of the role of the paradigm concept in scientific communities to trace the development of TLVs in the US. He suggests that in the 1940s the history of science-based exposure standard setting, which until then could be characterised as being in a (pre-scientific) pre-paradigmatic stage, changed into a (scientific) paradigmatic period that was shared by both the See for example, Cook 1985, Hanson 1998, Mendeloff 1988, Piney 1998, Stokinger 1984, 1988 and Ziem and Castleman 1988 for accounts of the history of the development and use of TLVs.
22 Beyond Limits
science-based professions of industrial hygiene and industrial toxicology.18 Fundamental to this approach was the notion that it was theoretically possible to prevent risks to health through a combination of industrial toxicology and occupational hygiene that could quantify exposure levels of hazardous substances in workplace atmospheres with an exactness that would enable distinguishing between those atmospheres in which there was no risk to health and those in which levels of contamination with hazardous chemicals posed a threat. Unfortunately, reality has proved to be more complicated than this. While the approach and the ACGIH TLV list itself have been enormously influential in industrialised countries worldwide, for many reasons, it is an approach now recognised to have considerable flaws. From the 1970s, other countries, notably those in the EU, began to develop their own lists, although the influence of the ACGIH list was still widely felt in these separate national approaches. It is generally acknowledged that the TLV list is the most widely circulated and significant set of exposure standards in the industrialised world and its formal and informal influence on various national policies and practice is considerable, as is evident in most of the countries we studied. Germany's limits (Maximale Arbeitsplatzkonzentmtionen — MAKs) have developed separately from ACGIH and are said to be based exclusively on scientific information about health effects. Its documentation states that 'scientific criteria for the prevention of adverse effects on health are decisive, not technical
What this means essentially is that prior to the 1940s several approaches to exposure standards can be traced, in particular the use of specification standards in which controls were specified but control effectiveness was not The development of the profession of industrial hygiene was strongly linked to the measurement of the effectiveness of controls and hence to the use of exposure standards. Combined with the professional concerns of industrial toxicology (health effects of exposures) such standards could be used to achieve (theoretically) risk free atmospheres. Thus the paradigm of single value exposure limits was a powerful binding notion for the two science-based professions to develop a truly preventive approach to preventing damage to workers' health. While acknowledging oversimplification (which does not account for the criticism of the OEL paradigm from within the industrial hygiene community), this explanation of the mutually reinforcing growth of the profession of occupational hygiene and that of the status of the TLV list is nevertheless persuasive (see also Piney 1989).
The Problem of Chemical Risks 23
or economical feasibility'.19 Carcinogens and genotoxic substances are given TRK values because it is accepted that such limits cannot be based exclusively on health considerations.20 However, since 1 January 2005, technically based TRK values have been replaced by a new type of value (Arbeitsplatzrichtwerte or ARWs) which is not any longer health but risk based. The consequences of this will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 5 on Germany. There is no longer any explicit influence of the ACGIH on the development of exposure limits although they were used historically. In Greece, occupational exposure limits are a relatively late addition to national regulation of occupational health and safety. There is an agreement between the Greek national health and safety institute (ELINYAE) and the ACGIH and since 1997 the latter's list is translated and published in Greece. Italy has a history of not including limit values in national legislation, preferring a general requirement on employers to reduce levels of workers' exposure to as low as is technically feasible.11 However, certain collective agreements such as for example the one that exists in the chemical industry provides for the adoption of the exposure limits in the ACGIH list. Since such agreements have legal status in Italy this means that the standards in the list are also legally binding. In the Netherlands until 1977, the ACGIH TLV list was used. The first official Dutch list of MACs was published in 1978 but it consisted largely of the ACGIH TLV list of 1977. Since then, new MACs and changes in existing MACs have been established according to a procedure which separates evidence on health effects from issues of economic and technical feasibility. However a large number of current OELs remain those adopted from the ACGIH list of (around 300 such substances are currently under review).22 See Senatskommission 1996:9. "The present theory of chemical carcinogenesis indicates that even the lowest doses will produce some genotoxic damage irrespective if the observation or non-observation of tumour formation in finite experimental conditions" (Henschler 1991:15 quoted in Hanson 1998:37). But implementation of the IOELV Directive clearly changes this. A similar situation exists in the UK. where something like 350 substances have an OES that is unchanged since the last TLV list of 1980 and have not been assessed by the ACTS/WATCH committee to see if the OBS criteria are met.
24 Beyond Limits
Sweden also has had its own system since 1969 - although the list issued at this time was based almost entirely on the TLVs of the ACGIH. Since 1978 it has made a concerted effort to separate the decision-making processes dealing with scientific issues concerning the health effects of chemicals from those that deal with economic and technical feasibility. This has had an effect of gradually reducing the levels of exposure limits. According to Hanson (1998) there has been a 3.9 per cent average yearly reduction of the values of exposure limits overall, a 5 percent reduction for solvents and a 10 per cent reduction for carcinogens, generally giving Sweden the lowest limit values in Europe. In the UK the ACGIH list of TLVs was the basis for exposure limits until the 1980s when a UK provision of control limits and exposure standards was developed and incorporated into the regulatory approach encompassed by the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH) Regulations. Despite this British regulatory position however, the majority of the limits adopted remained unchanged from those of the ACGIH list of TLVs. Discussion on exposure limits at EU level was an inevitable development of Directives intended to address the control of hazardous chemical agents that made their appearance during the 1970s and 1980s.23 Stemming from such legislative actions came moves towards setting European exposure limits during the 1990s. Reflecting national concerns about the meaning of exposure limits, debate about the scientific basis and meaning of limit values (see below) was a central feature, hi the following chapter we examine the extent to which national structures and processes reflect these requirements and their legal status. In subsequent chapters we look in greater detail at the effects of these regulatory systems and strategies to improve the management of occupational health and safety for hazardous For example, in 1974 the European Council initiated a Social Action Programme that included specific reference to health and safety. It led to new Directives on safety signs, and vinyl chloride monomer. In 1978 the first Action Programme specifically on health and safety was announced. The most significant legislation made under this programme was a framework Directive on the control of chemical physical and biological agents at work, (Directive 80/1107/EEC, later amended by Directive 88/642/EEC). There were further directives on asbestos, lead and noise. Outcomes that were achieved at this level had a significant impact within Member States, where the approach of the directives towards the assessment of risk, was arguably an influence on the development of national strategies in the UK on the control of substances hazardous to health.
The Problem of Chemical Risks 25
substances. Before doing this we outline some of the debates and issues surrounding the application of OELs in the regulation of risk management of hazardous substances.
THE MEANING AND USE OF EXPOSURE LIMITS OELs have moved from the domain of occupational hygiene and industrial toxicology, where they were originally conceived essentially as reference materials for specialists involved in monitoring occupational exposures to hazardous chemicals, to legally enforceable limits that feature in regulatory strategies. This has meant that the key issues involved in understanding the meaning and use of OELs, have both increased in significance and altered in nature. Such issues are critical aspects that influence the development of policies on OELs and in the user and public understanding of such policies. The predominant ways in which these changes have been interpreted and applied in different countries has helped to shape the way that OELs are perceived, valued and used. An outline of the general background to some of the key issues of meaning and application of OELs is therefore relevant. Health based values and what is technically feasible. Recent discourse on the OELs that are used in practice in the countries of the EU, goes to some lengths to be clear that they do not represent 'safe levels' of exposure for all workers, nor is it intended that they should set a limit below which it is unnecessary or undesirable to reduce exposures further. The Scientific Committee on Occupational Exposure Limits (SCOEL) is quite clear about this, stating for example: "It should however be emphasised that it is always prudent to reduce exposure as far below OELs as can reasonably be achieved, in order to provide the greatest degree of health protection" The introduction to the ACGIH TLV list explains that TLVs are intended for use in the practice of industrial hygiene, they do not represent fine lines between safe and dangerous concentrations of hazardous chemicals. However, the originators of the list were confident that TLVs would protect the majority of workers from harm and they have been thus extensively promulgated as essentially safe levels
26 Beyond Limits
of exposure under which "nearly all workers may he repeatedly exposed, day after day, without adverse health effects. "M There are a number of well-documented reasons to believe that it is a fundamental misconception to regard TLVs as 'safe levels'. The evidence on which they are based has in many cases been shown to be alarmingly incomplete. Historically it has been reliant on a substantial amount of unpublished (and unevaluated) corporate information, and the ACGIH committee itself has been accused of being prone to corporate bias (Castleman and Ziem 1988). Since TLVs are intended to protect 'normal' workers but not those that may be particularly sensitive to chemical exposures, it is clear that 'normality' excludes a substantial proportion of workers. Perhaps most tellingly, harmful effects at levels below TLVs are easily found in the ACGIH's own documentation (Roach and Rappaport 1990), as well as elsewhere in the scientific literature and (Ziem and Castleman 1989), One reason why the US ACGIH system attracted so much criticism once it took on a degree of federal regulatory significance, is the considerable blurring in its approach between the procedure used to derive a so called 'health based' standard and the question of technical and economic feasibility.25 Modem civil society demands far more clarity and transparency on issues of risk assessment than was evident in the ACGIH procedures which, at best, could be described as a form of expert risk assessment in which the expert's own socially constructed assumptions about risk (that is those influenced by their own social as well as scientific experiences) remained unquestioned and at worst, a system in which key economic considerations of industry covertly determined levels that purported to be scientifically derived health based standards. Once OELs started to play a role in regulatory policies, European policy makers attempted to avoid this confusion Quoted from the preamble to the TLV List still appearing in the 1990s (ACGIH 1996: 3, in Hanson 1998: 21). Technical and economic feasibility are terms that appear frequently in the literature qualiflying and explaining the setting of OELs. Within a UK context the terms largely equate with notions of reasonable practicability such as defined by British case-law. Where technical feasibility appears alone it might appear to mean something that could be technically possible to achieve without regard to cost. However in practice, it is seldom used to mean this as it is almost impossible to distinguish something that is technically feasible from consideration of the costs involved in its technical achievement. We have therefore tried to reflect this by using the term "technically and economically feasible wherever possible.
The Problem of Chemical Risks 27
by creating clearer demarcations between the procedures that deal with the science of deriving a health-based limit and those that deal with setting a value that is believed to technically and economically achievable. The first of these procedures involves the scientific assessment of evidence of the harmful effects of a substance, undertaken by persons judged to possess the scientific competence to do so. The second engages the involvement of stakeholders in debate about the extent to which it is possible to agree measures to protect workers, that are at the same time economically and technically feasible to implement in the workplaces affected. One size fits all and the 'dirty end'. Different processes (and sometimes industries) cause different distributions of exposure. The major problem for standard setters in setting single all encompassing figures as limits is how to deal with those processes (industries) causing the greatest exposure. If single level exposure limits are set to accommodate, for example, a powerful lobby from a particular branch of industry that argues it is not economically or technically feasible to reduce exposure below a certain point in that industry, the same OEL is likely to apply to exposures in other industrial sectors, even though in such sectors it may be technically and economically possible to reduce levels of exposure to well below this OEL. Critics of existing OEL systems point out that in many cases it is the so-called 'dirty end' of industry (i.e. the sector of industry in which exposures are greatest and most difficult to control) that in fact plays a powerful role in determining the value that is eventually agreed to be economically and technically feasible, despite this sector of industry only accounting for the exposure of a relative minority of workers. While it may be argued that there is nothing that prevents the rest of industry reducing the level of exposure to as low as possible below the OEL, and in many cases regulatory agencies recommend building safety factors into the use of the limits (such as working to a percentage of the value that represents the actual limit), the message that is conveyed by the legal status of the limit is that employers are only required to do as much as is necessary to demonstrate they are within it. There is often no legal incentive to do more than this. Since exposure limits do not represent safe levels for the health of workers, this approach potentially has the effect of unnecessarily increasing the risks faced by the majority of workers to suit the technical and economic needs of a minority of employers in parts of industry in which exposures are greatest. Participatory approaches to standard setting. The European approach is also a product of a regulatory strategy for occupational risks in which an orientation
28 Beyond Limits
towards process regulation has been a feature characterising regulatory systems for OHS in northern European countries since the 1970s. This is especially the case in the Netherlands, the UK and in Scandinavian countries, but latterly it is also true more generally across the EU, as EU Directives based on this approach are implemented and operationalised in all EU countries. In efforts to 'regulate the self regulation' of risks at work the characteristic elements of defining the extent of employers' duties, information and consultation rights for workers and levels of competence for support services are (more recently) coupled with measures to ensure that the management of risks is undertaken in a manner in which employers discharge their duties competently (with the assistance of competent prevention services for example), systematically (by integrating OHS management into the core management of the enterprise and through assessing and controlling the risks of their activities) and involving workers and their representatives in participative approaches to OHS management. At the sectoral and national levels, risk assessment and control is also largely envisaged as a participatory process in which stakeholders, primarily employers and trade union representatives, (that is, those that 'create the risks and those that work with them'),26 engage with representatives of regulatory bodies in both developing and implementing strategies of risk assessment and control. The means and structures by which OELs are discussed and defined are part of this approach and are therefore probably better understood as an aspect of this wider development rather than as unique structures and procedures for dealing with the regulation of chemical risks. Chemical hazards and 'risk society'; OELs, the social construction of risk and risk communication. Whatever the infrastructural context of OELs-in-the-making, the importance of the status, clarity and transparency of the decision-making involved has become fundamental in societies in which concepts of risk, governmental roles and responsibilities in its regulation and accountability of duty holders to the public have all gained increased prominence. In the 'risk society* described by social analysts of late modernity" it is often the 'invisible risks' of life that characterise societal concerns. Issues of trust and public understanding of the scientific reasoning behind decision-making in environmental matters have become such that regulators and decision-makers have been forced to rethink their approaches to risk analysis and take both public perceptions of their activities and To paraphrase the words of one of the significant harbingers of this system, Lord Alfred Robens (Robens 1972). See especially Beck (1992).
The Problem of Chemical Risks 29
public engagement with them more seriously. The political consequences of not doing so have been shown to be of sufficient significance to force governmental policy makers to give at least some consideration of the notion that expert risk analysis is itself not free from social constructions of reality and to move towards systems for decision-making on public policy on risk regulation in which such considerations can be addressed. Debate on the relationship between regulation and risk has burgeoned in recent years and discourse has become increasingly sophisticated as analysis of the subject has deepened.28 As Hutter elaborates, regulation is a form of control in which risk itself is not prohibited, rather it is an attempt to manage it, in which structures, routines and procedures are constituted 'which will be incorporated into organisational routines and also become part of everyday individual activity. Where this fails the law can intervene through more overt forms of control, notably external regulation and sanctions.' (Hutter 2001:5). In the case of OELs, what this seems to mean is that the participants in the processes of setting limits and the information generated as a result of the process should be more representative of users as well as experts. They should be clear that what is being set by their contribution to the process, is not a 'safe limit' but rather a tool in the assessment and management of risk, which, if it properly applied should contribute to more effective and systematic management of health and safety in the use of hazardous chemicals. Unfortunately (even if this were true) it does not necessarily follow that actual users of OELs will be in the same position. Indeed, one of the most significant problems with the current British system for example, is the considerable absence of understanding amongst employers and managers, especially in smaller firms, about OELs and how to comply with them (HSC 2002:19) coupled with a widely held belief that they are See for example, Ayres and Braithewaite 1992, Gunningham and Johnstone 1999, Hutter, 1997 and Hutter 1999, in relation to the development of regulation on occupational health and safety and the environment. More generally see Colebateh 1989, Bardach and Kagan 1982, Hancher and Moran 1989 and Selznick 1980 for the theoretical analysis of the role and meaning of regulation in advanced industrial societies. See Ericson and Haggarty on the relationship between risk and regulation, Jaasanoff et al 1995, Nelkin 1992 and Wynne 1994 and 1996 on the relationship between risk and science and for a more specific attempt to relate the theoretical analyses of risk and regulation to occupational health and safety management see Hutter 2001:2 -23.
30 Beyond Limits
"safe' limits. As the HSC points out this latter view is probably reinforced by the fact that once a limit has been met the employer has fulfilled his/her legal obligations. As we shall see, such problems are also much in evidence in systems that do not share either the particular history or the features of the present British approach. While it may be that some of these problems of user understanding could in practice be tempered by a revision of the system to include a clearer obligations on employers to reduce risks to as low as technically feasible below the OEL for example, it is far from certain that they would dispel the myth that the OEL represents a safe level. A much broader question which also needs to be asked is: to what extent has the introduction of a system of limit values with the legitimacy of legality, contributed to the development of totemic significance for the notion of a numerical value that can delimit one state such as safety from another, such as danger, in the use of hazardous chemicals. Clearly, if this is the case it is part of a much wider problem of perception in which the notion of measurement implies the existence of numerical values that can distinguish precisely between one such state and another. This is a misrepresentation of reality, but one likely to require widespread re-education and policy reorientation to dispel. The extent to which these issues are a feature of national systems in Europe and to what extent alternative conceptualisations occur are questions to which we will return in the final chapter.
NEW DIRECTIONS IN REGULATING RISK MANAGEMENT OF HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES AND THE ROLE OF O E L S It is important to consider the development of the role of OELs in regulation in relation to the evolving features of current approaches to regulating the management of hazardous substances at work more generally in EU member states. Although they differ in the details of their systems for regulating OHS, since the adoption and transposition of the Framework Directive 89/391, most EU 15 countries have a broadly similar approach to regulating the process of managing health and safety (Walters 2002). Their regulatory requirements aim to provide a structure within which employers and workers can be encouraged towards achieving self-regulation of the risks of their workplaces. As one observer of the development of this international trend in the regulation of the working
The Problem of Chemical Risks 31
environment has put it, they are measures that aim to regulate self-regulation.19 These frameworks provide structures and processes applied to the management of all hazardous chemical substances at work, as well as dealing with specific substances such as lead, benzene, and named carcinogenic substances. OELs feature in both. Indeed, if OELs were not already incorporated into these regulatory systems, the adoption by the European Community of the Chemical Agents Directive and its first Indicative Occupational Exposure Limit Value (IOELV) daughter directive and their transposition into national requirements should have brought this about in all Member States. At the workplace level OELs are standards against which employers can measure the extent to which their risk management strategies are controlling the occupational exposure of workers to airborne hazardous substances. However, the extent to which employers undertake the fundamental health and safety management procedures such as risk assessment in relation to chemical as well as other hazards has been shown to be far from universally complete. It has for example been shown to be, inversely proportional to the size of the enterprises for which they are responsible. This has been demonstrated in a wide range of studies concerning the implementation of the measures of the Framework Directive 89/391 .M Additionally however - and as we document in greater detail in the following chapter - despite the many measures aimed at controlling the risks of chemical substances in Europe, gaps in coverage and limitations in orientation have become increasingly apparent. For example there is a general lack of knowledge about the properties and uses of existing chemical substances.31 There is little information concerning the scale of use or levels of exposure occurring to downstream users of such substances and only limited information on the extent and detail of associated ill-effects. Nor do we know the most effective ways in which such ill effects can be prevented or reduced in practice in the complex work environments in which they occur.
See Ayres and Braithewaite (1992). For a more recent discussion of this point see Walters (ed) 2002:271-275. See Walters 2001 for a review of such evidence. Traditionally the regulation of chemicals in the EU has distinguished between new substances for which there have been quite detailed provisions concerning the assessment of the risks they pose to human health and the existing substances that make up the vast majority of chemicals used in European workplace for which no such provisions exist.
32 Beyond Limits
At the present time therefore a further dimension to regulating risk management in relation to chemical substances is in the process of unfolding as renewed efforts are being made to provide a more comprehensive approach to regulating risk and to deal with some of the complexities and uncertainties outlined above. At its core is an effort to adopt a more holistic view of the role of regulatory intervention in relation to working with hazardous substances and it is important to understand the role perceived for OELs in these emerging regulatory strategies, as well as in existing approaches to regulating systematic OHS management. The White Paper heralding the introduction of the REACH principles made this clear. In 1998 following concerns expressed by the Council of Environment Ministers, the Commission undertook an assessment of the operation of the four main legal instruments regulating safe use of chemicals in the European Community.32 Its report and the consultation that followed pointed towards the piecemeal approach of existing regulatory policy, noting the distinction in its approach towards the large number of 'existing substances', for which there was little information concerning their properties and use, and the much smaller number of 'new substances' for which more thorough information was available. It noted the slowness and resource intensiveness of the risk assessment processes in relation to substances as well as the inappropriate distribution of responsibilities involved - with too much focus on the responsibilities of the authorities and not enough on those of enterprises producing importing and using substances - leading to poor quality of information on use of chemicals and its consequences, especially in relation to downstream users. It found that existing regimes in place to address the liability of duty holders for damage caused by chemical substances were inappropriate and insufficient to provide effective remedies because of their emphasis on the need for causal connections that in practice were impossible to establish because of the remoteness of the parties concerned (CEC 2001). For the Commission the solution was to propose the new regulatory strategy announced in its White Paper. Prominent amongst the principle elements of the new approach encapsulated in REACH is the aim to achieve realignment of the responsibilities of duty-holders for ensuring the safe use of chemical substances in Council Directive 67/548/EEC and Directive 88/379/EEC, on classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances and preparatins; Directive 76/769/EEC restricting the marketing and use of certain dangerous substances and preparations and Council Regulation 793/93 on the evaluation and control of risks of existing substances.
The Problem of Chemical Risks 33
ways that encourage a more joined-up approach through influencing supply chain relations and promoting product stewardship, covering the full range of manufacturers, suppliers and users involved with chemical hazards. Additionally, through the same broad framework of realigned responsibilities, the strategy encompassed the regulation of chemical hazards in relation to the wider environment. A detailed description of the provisions foreseen under REACH (at least as it was foreseen in the proposal presented by the Commission in October 2003) will be provided in the next chapter. In the context of the present discussion it is worth noting that REACH intends to establish a system which will trigger different testing requirements based on the annual production or imported volume of a substance (independent whether of being a new or an existing substance) before the substance can be marketed in Europe. In a nutshell that means that the higher the amount of a substance, the higher the test requirements. However, the whole system will only start from a production / import volume of above 1 tonne and the test requirements for substances produced / imported between 1 and 10 tonnes per year are less severe than those currently applied for new substances of the same intended production volume. With respect to setting OELs for substances which do not have a limit value assigned so far, these distinctions are important because the test requirements for the lower tonnage are very limited. Only physio-chemical data33; on skin and eye irritation, skin corrosion and skin sensitisation, one in vitro mutagenicity test and basic environmental tests will be required for these substances (which are assumed to represent two thirds of the total number of substances) which will fall under the scope of REACH. There is however agreement about the fact that a minimum of data must be available to derive health based OELs (which should be in any case the basis for an OELs, even if technical and economical feasibility factors are taken into account afterwards). This minimum set of data comprises the above mentioned physical and chemical data, but also data on acute, subchronic and chronic toxicity using different exposure routes (via inhalation, dermal, oral). If available, genotoxic data, sensitising properties, reprotoxic data should also be taken into consideration. If the available data allows to derive a socalled NOAEL (a no adverse effect level), then a threshold or limit value can be Melting and freezing point, boiling point, vapour pressure, water solubility, flammability etc.
34 Beyond Limits
arrived at. This is the procedure used for effects which normally only occur above a certain concentration or in other words for substances which do not have an adverse effect on human health below a certain concentration.34 This means that the data set required for substances between 1 and 10 tonnes will not be enough to derive OELs. However, REACH will at least generate some data for substances for which no data is publicly available today." Even if this data might not necessarily be usable for establishing OELs, it will nevertheless be helpful in providing information concerning the risks of substances to be used in European workplaces. What is even more important with respect to OELs and workers' protection is that for all substances produced / imported in quantities above 10 tonnes so-called Chemical Safety Reports (CSR) will be obligatory. A CSR will be based on a Chemical Safety Assessment and contain a description of the manufacturer's or importer's exposure scenario(s), (including exposure scenario(s) they recommended to be implemented) for the identified use(s) of the substance in question. The exposure scenarios contain a description of the risk management measures which the manufacturer or importer has implemented and recommends to be implemented by downstream users. If the substance is placed on the market, these exposure scenarios including the risk management measures shall be summarised in an annex to the safety data sheet. This will provide downstream users in particular with more targeted information with respect to the intended uses and this is, for most substances, far more information than is currently available to users. So in theory, the new system will improve the situation at the work place.36 However, as we discuss in the final chapter of this book, regulatory provisions require proper implementation and surveillance. As we shall see, experience with existing legislation has not been encouraging in this respect.
For other effects like carcinogeniciry such a threshold does not exist. For those substances if considered to be not substitutable for the time being - risk based limit values are established, taking technical and economical feasibility into account. And this is the majority of substances used in Europe. 'In theory' also because at the time of writing, the final version of REACH had not been decided and there remains the possibility of further changes being made.
The Problem of Chemical Risks 35
CONCLUSIONS: BUT WHAT ABOUT USING OELS? Despite some success at reducing measured exposure in large chemical plants through introducing more systematic approaches to risk management, it seems clear that the scale of the problem represented by the quantity and range of chemical substances in use as well as by the variety of situations in which they are used remains formidable. There are major challenges for the control of prevention in relation to known health effects of hazardous substances, arguably even greater obstacles represented by the uncertainties about the health effects of large numbers of substances in current use and concerning the ways in which they are used. Therefore the challenge for regulation of risks associated with the use of hazardous substances at work in the European Union continues to be significant. Systematicity of risk management strategies in relation to hazardous substances requires good quality information concerning their health effects and the extent and nature of their use as well as on the economic implications of control. Generating OELs is part of this process and they have been agreed for a limited number of chemical substances. In this chapter we have summarised some of the issues of meaning and usage that have beset the processes involved in reaching agreement in setting OELs, especially since they have assumed a form of regulatory status. We have further outlined the role perceived for OELs in chemical risk management at the workplace level, both in the regulatory approaches towards systematic OHS management that have been the leitmotif'of the EU approach since the early 1990s and also in the newer and more holistic approaches that are aspired to by current EU approaches to regulating chemical risks. In all of this we find a wealth of material analysing the origins, development and status of occupational exposure limits. There is also much critical discussion of the reliability of the evidence on which different kinds of exposure limits have been set as well as what they actually mean in terms of protecting workers' health. It is beyond the scope of the present chapter to present anything more than an outline of some of the salient aspects of this material. Similarly, there is a substantial field of literature dealing with approaches to regulating risks in society, dealing inter alia with assessing risks, the social construction of risk and risk communication, all of which are relevant to strategies on setting exposure limits. There is also a growing literature on changing approaches to regulation of
36 Beyond Limits
the occupational environment. Again we have outlined a few of the relevant issues from these fields that have a bearing on our interests in occupational exposure limits. However, while there is an abundance of material that considers the issues surrounding OELs at the level of their making, status and meaning, the same cannot be said about literature that analyses their use at the workplace. Indeed, matters such as how OELs are actually used (or if they are actually used) are conspicuously absent from the extensive literature on OELs and on the management of chemical hazards generally. It is disconcerting to discover that such limited attention appears to have been devoted to what is actually done in practice with OELs following the extensive debate that has taken place concerning their status and meaning. This is especially so given that what little information that does exist suggests that at least in the UK there are a majority of employers who neither understand their meaning nor use OELs appropriately, despite being significant users of chemicals in their work operations (HSE, 1997; Piney, 2001). It was with these limitations in mind that we set out to explore the practices at the workplace level to which the remainder of this book is largely devoted. First however it is important to outline in more detail the main existing European legislation addressing dangerous substances in general and the structures and processes for setting and using OELs at EU and national levels as well as the regulatory contexts in which they operate in the various EU 15 countries. These are the subjects of the following two chapters.
37
EXPOSURE LIMITS AND INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTURES FOR HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE REGULATION IN THE EUROPEAN UNION.
INTRODUCTION In this chapter an overview is presented of the various structures that have developed at European Union level in which OELs are determined and used in the process of regulating chemical risk management. Its aim is to provide the reader with some understanding of the regulatory context for OELs at this level and their role as instruments in regulatory strategy for risk management of hazardous substances. To do so first requires an account of relevant EU legislative arrangements that provide the legal framework within which chemical risk management operates, as well as information on particular provisions relating to the specific status and role of OELs. In addition information is necessary on the EU structures and processes involved in setting OELs. This makes for the presentation of a complex legal and institutional story. To facilitate it, while at the same time providing a route map to aid readers' understanding of the key issues that relate to setting and using exposure limits and the dynamics of their development at this level, the focus of the chapter is more concerned with the rationale behind the regulation of chemical hazards than with its detailed requirements. It begins with an account of the logic behind the array of Community level provisions that make up the legislative framework in which the protection of workers' health and safety from damaging workplace exposure to
3 8 Beyond Limits him its 38
chemical and biological agents is currently embedded. It includes an indication of the relationship between instruments relating to the control of risks from chemical and biological substances and those dealing with risk management at the workplace more generally. Following this outline, the chapter focuses on the position of exposure limits within the framework for regulating chemicals. Again, it is necessary to understand a little of the situation in previous times if the current position is to be properly appreciated. The existence of key institutions at EU level are outlined and their past and present roles in establishing OELs explained before some of the features of the documentation of exposure limits are described. On-going change in policy development behind the whole framework for regulating risk from hazardous chemicals however, means that not only is it important to describe its historical underpinnings and the relationships between instruments in the existing system but it is also necessary to note some of the major changes currently under discussion in this field, whose outcomes may have implications for the future determination and use of exposure limits. A brief account is therefore included concerning the identified weaknesses in the existing system and the rationale behind the current proposals on the development of the integrated system of chemical regulation, the elements of which - (Registration, (Evaluation and (Authorisation of (CH)emicals - have given rise to the now well known acronym REACH that is the subject of widespread current international debate.
EU LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORKS FOR MINIMISING HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS OF DANGEROUS SUBSTANCES Existing EU health and safety legislation aims at minimising the health risks from dangerous substances in the workplace. The control measures to protect workers focus on principles of elimination and substitution. The most important pieces of European legislation in this field are listed below where they have been separated into two broad groups - those generally concerned with requirements on the producers of chemicals and those mat are more specifically related to the workplace. Their requirements represent the three main European methods for dealing with chemical risks, through hazard identification, risk assessment and in a final step, risk reduction. As we have pointed out elsewhere in this book, in terms of their operation at the workplace level all these measures also need to be understood in relation to the
Exposure Limits in in the the EU EU 39 broad requirements of the Framework Directive, 89/391 which although it does not deal with hazardous substances directly, contains the basic provisions for managing health and safety at work generally, thus providing the regulatory context into which all specific provisions on managing particular risks fit including those from using chemical substances.
Important Directives with special significance for the protection of workers: Directive 98/24/EC37 on the protection of the health and safety of workers from the risks related to chemical agents at work Directive 04/97/EEC38 as amended on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens at work Directive 2000/54/EC39 as amended on the protection of workers from risks related to exposure to biological agents at work. Other important pieces of European legislation on controlling trade in chemicals that contribute to the framework for regulating chemical risks in the EU: Directive 67/548/EEC40 and Directive 1999/45/EC4' on the classification and labelling of dangerous substances and preparations and their adaptations to technical progress
Council Directive 98/24/EC of 7 April 1998 cm the protection of the health and safety of workers from the risks related to chemical agents at work (fourteenth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Directive 89/391/EEC). Directive 2004/37/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens or mutagens at work (Sixth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Council Directive 89/391/EEC) (codified version) (Text with EEA relevance) (OJL158 30.04.2004p. SO). Directive 2000/54/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of 18 September2000 on the protection of workers fiom risks related to exposure to biological agents at work (seventh individual directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Directive 89/391/EEC). Council Directive 67/548/EEC of 27 June 1967 on the approximation of laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances Official Journal No P 196,16708/1967, p. 0001-0098.
40 Beyond Limits Regulation (EEC) 793/934Z on the evaluation and control of the risks of existing substances Directive 76/769/EEC43 on restricting the marketing and use of certain dangerous substances and preparations and its amendments.
REQUIREMENTS REGULATING CHEMICAL RISKS GENERALLY INTHEEU In the series of Directives beginning with Council Directive 67/548/EEC, and following through Directive 1999/45/EC and Directive 91/155/EEC (as amended) that have been made to harmonise and control the marketing of dangerous substances, two central elements are evident - requirements on hazard identification and assessment. In addition, the requirement on producers to deliver these elements has a universality of application, distinguishes new substances from existing ones and places a major emphasis on responsibilities of producers to communicate information to users. It also utilises, where necessary, measures that restrict the marketing and use of certain dangerous substances and preparations. Responsibilities of Producers to Identify Hazards. The first Community legislation regulating chemical risks was Council Directive 67/548/EEC on the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous substances (known as the Dangerous Substances Directive or DSD). Its aim was to identify so-called intrinsic hazardous properties of substances that were either already on, or were intended to be, placed on the European market. Although originally designed to cover in particular hazards which might pose a risk when 41
42
43
Directive 1999/45/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 May 1999 concerning the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous preparations Official Journal No L 200,30/07/1999, p. 0001-0068. Council Regulation (EEC) No 793/93 of 23 March 1993 on the evaluation and control of the risks of existing substances Official Journal No L 0S4,05/04/1993, p. 0001-0075. Council Directive of 27 July 1976 on the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions of the Member States relating to restrictions on the marketing and use of certain dangerous substances and preparations (76/769/EEC).
Exposure Limits in the EU 41
handling hazardous substances at the workplace, additional concerns like those for the environment or for consumers were included when brought under the scope of the Directive over the years — in a similar way as they were perceived to be threats to human health and the environment at Community level. Another equally important reasoning for the directive was the elimination of technical barriers to trade, to be achieved by harmonised and legally binding obligations for manufacturers, producers and importers of hazardous chemicals to classify and label them according to the hazards identified under the Directive. The Directive covers fifteen classes of danger for human health and the environment. It has been amended eight times and its annexes have been adapted to technical progress 29 times. Since 1981, it has discriminated between so-called new and existing substances (by which is meant substances either on the European market before or after a specific point in time (1981). Those that were on the market before that date are listed in the so-called EINECS list.44 Substances which are not on this inventory and which are produced in volumes as low as 10 kg per year are subject to a formal hazard assessment procedure*5 before they can be marketed in Europe. Only about 3000 new chemicals underwent this procedure after 1981. Generally, for substances that existed before 1981, there is no such provision. However, a small number of these existing substances have to undergo a risk assessment, but only those which are produced in high volumes (about 140 out of the 100,000 substances listed in EINECS - for further details see below). Communicating information to users. Once identified as dangerous, a substance is listed in Annex I to the Directive, and its hazardous properties have to be communicated to the user via information provided in a very condensed form on the label of the package,46 and in a more detailed form in so-called Safety Data Sheets.4' Under Directive 91/155/EEC as amended48 (the Safety Data Sheet
European Inventory of Existing Commercial Substances. The higher the production volume, the higher the risk assessment requirements In the form of pictograms, symbols and R(isk) and S(afcty) phrases. These data sheets, however, have only to be supplied to such users of a substance or preparation. Directive 2001/58/EC of 27 July 2001 amends Directive 91/155/EEC on the detailed arrangementi for specific information on dangerous preparations in Article 14 of European Parliament and Council Directive 1999/45/EC and relating to dangerous substances in
42 Beyond Limits
Directive) industrial/occupational users49 are entitled to receive additional information via Safety Data Sheets (SDSs). SDSs provide the user with basic information on the physical-chemical and toxicological properties of a substance / preparation as well as information on how to handle, use, transport and dispose of the chemicals in a safe way at enterprise level. In addition, information on first aid measures hi case of fire, accidents or other emergencies has to be provided. Existing substances that are dangerous but not listed in Annex I have to be classified and provisionally labelled by the manufacturer, distributor or importer. The corresponding provisions for mixtures of substances (preparations) were originally laid down in Directive 88/379/EEC, which was replaced by Directive 1999/45/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the approximation of the laws, regulations and administrative provisions relating to the classification, packaging and labelling of dangerous preparations (the Dangerous Preparations Directive or DPD). The vast number of preparations50 in existence makes it uneconomical to classify each of them on the basis of laboratory testing. Since this would also mean in most cases animal tests, animal welfare considerations would further render such a task nearly impossible (or politically and ethically highly controversial). Preparations are therefore normally classified with the help of calculation methods, based on the concentration of the various components of the preparation and their intrinsic hazardous properties established under the DSD. Once the appropriate classification has been established, the DPD uses, in general, the same classes of danger and the same labelling requirements as the DSD. However as is clear from the evidence presented in Box 2.1, while classification, labelling and SDSs may be the most important (and often the only) information sources for downstream users of dangerous substances and preparations, they are in fact far from universally either correct or complete.
implementation of Article 27 of Council Directive 67/548/EEC (safety data sheets) (Text with EEA relevance), Official Journal L 212 ,07/08/2001 P. 0024 - 0033. And under certain circumstances also non-industrial/occupational users. Estimates talk about 2,000,000 and more.
Exposure Limits in the EU 43
1 Box 2.1
Compliance with the provisions for classification and labelling and SDSs at EU level Trade unions and practitioners have frequently suggested that SDSs are seldom the useful and accurate sources of information that they are meant to be. Recent survey evidence supports this view. A report of the ECLIPS (European Classification and Labelling Inspections of Preparations, including Safety Data Sheets) project51 undertaken by the Chemical Legislation European Enforcement Network (CLEEN)52 to assess the extent of compliance with the classification and labelling legislation in Member States found that in practice such compliance was quite restricted. The project focused on the DPD'3 and in particular on preparations classified as dangerous for the environment, and / or classified as carcinogenic, mutagenic and / or toxic for reproduction (CMR), and / or containing substances with sensitising properties, and / or containing substances assigned the Risk Phrase R67.S4 In order to keep the results comparable, it was also decided to focus on a limited number of product groups, i.e. paints and varnishes, cleaning agents (e.g. solvent based), detergents, preparations to be used in construction of buildings and photo chemicals. It found that not more than 40 per cent of the preparations currently on the market, and only 30 per cent of the SDSs complied with legal provisions. The labelling of about 60 per cent of the preparations it examined was incorrect and two third of the SDSs were either incorrect or incomplete.
http://www.cleen-eu.nefprojects/Press_release_ECLIPS.pdf/ http://www.umweltbundesamt.at/fileadniin/site/umweltthemen/chemikalien/ECLIPS_Final _Report.pdf. CLEEN is a network of national chemicals inspectorates that coordinates and improves the enforcement of EU chemicals legislation (enforcement is the responsibility of the Member States). Is central task is the exchange of information between national enforcement authorities and it sets, in collaboration with the Member States, priorities for enforcement projects in the EU. Because most of the chemicals on the market are preparations. Vapours may cause drowsiness and dizziness.
44 Beyond Limits
The Universality of the Requirements. A classification under the DSD and the DPD can have a significant impact on the way in which substances are addressed in other Community legislation, hi at least 60 other pieces of Community legislation, reference is made either to the criteria for hazard identification of the Directives themselves or provisions for additional risk reduction measures at Community level are based on the classification of substances listed in Annex I to the DSD. For example, substances and preparations classified as category one or two carcinogens or mutagens are subject to more stringent control and protective measures at the workplace than other (hazardous) substances and preparations. The provisions for the treatment of waste are based on the hazard classification as well as the provisions under the Seveso Directive on the control of major-accident hazards. Finally, the classification of dangerous substances and preparations can have repercussions on the marketing and use of a chemical (see the following section on Directive 76/769/EEC), ranging from the prohibition of the marketing to the general public to a complete ban of a substance. Dealing with Existing Substances. Recognition of the problem of existing substances led the European Council in 1993 to adopt Regulation (EEC) 793/93 on the evaluation and control of the risks of existing substances (Existing Substances Regulation or BSR).This Regulation set the framework for the evaluation and control of existing substances, namely those listed on the EINECS list. Because the number of chemicals listed in EINECS (more than 100,000) was far too big to evaluate, a prioritisation took place at European level primarily based on production volumes55 and on the potential risk to man and the environment, resulting in four lists of about 140 substances of high concern.56 S7 5S 59 Substances on priority lists must undergo an
The Regulation was initially concerned with so-called High Production Volume Chemicals (HPVCs), imported or produced in quantities exceeding 1000 tonnes per year, followed by those of lower volumes (between 10 and 1000 tonnes). Commission Regulation (EC) No 1179/94 of 25 May 1994 concerning the first list of priority substances as foreseen under Council Regulation (EEC) No 793/93 Official Journal NO. L 131,26705/1994 P. 0003 - 0004. Commission Regulation (EC) No 2268/95 of 27 September 1995 concerning the second list of priority substances as foreseen under Council Regulation (EEC) No 793/93 Official Journal NO. L 231,28/09/1995 P. 0018 - 0019.
Exposure Limits in the EU 45
in-depth risk assessment,60 following the framework set out in Commission Regulation (EC) 1488/94" and implemented in the detailed TGD on Risk Assessment for New and Existing Substances.62 A Member State (the so-called rapporteur) is responsible for compiling the data, which is discussed at European level aiming at a consensus on conclusion of the risk assessment amongst the various stakeholders. Before the report and the conclusions are finally adopted and published, it is peer-reviewed by a Scientific Committee officially established at European level. Possible results of the risk assessment for existing substances are; (i) (ii)
(iii)
There is need for further information and/or testing. There is at present no need for further information and/or testing and no need for risk reduction measures beyond those which are being applied already, There is a need for limiting the risks; risk reduction measures that are already being applied shall be taken into account.
If the risk assessment comes to the conclusion that further risk reduction measures beyond those already in place are necessary, a risk reduction strategy must be developed. Directive 76/769/EEC on the restrictions in marketing and use of dangerous substances is one of the legal frameworks, which could be invoked to manage the risks identified by the risk assessment.
Commission Regulation (EC) No 143/97 of 27 January 1997 concerning the third list of priority substances es foreseen under Council Regulation (EEC) No 793/93 (Text with EEA relevance) Official Journal NO. L 025 ,28/01/1997 P. 0013 - 0014. Commission Regulation (EC) No 2364/2000 of 25 October 2000 concerning the fourth list of priority substances as foreseen under Council Regulation (EEC9 793/93 (Text with EEA relevance) Official Journal NO. L 273,26/10/2000 P. 005-008. Covering the risks to man (covering workers, consumers and man exposed via the environment) and the environment (covering the terrestrial, aquatic and atmospheric ecosystems and accumulation through the food chain). Commission Regulation (EC) No 1488/94 of 28 June 1994 laying down the principles for the assessment of risks to man and the environment of existing substances in accordance with Council Regulation (EEC) No 793/93 (Text with EEA relevance). Official Journal No L 161,29/0671994, p. 0003-0011. http://ecb.jrc.it/php-bin/reframer.php?B=/TGD.
46 Beyond Limits
Restricting the Marketing and Use of Certain Dangerous Substances and Preparations. Directive 76/769/EEC was introduced in 1976 to deal with situations where classification and labelling of chemicals were not sufficient to protect health and the environment and Member States were introducing national restrictions of the marketing and use of chemicals thus creating barriers to trade. The directive sets out detailed rules for restrictions on marketing and use, harmonising the legislation throughout the Community. It creates a framework for bans or restrictions by means of an Annex, where the controlled substances and/or products are listed. These can only be placed on the market subject to the conditions specified. Two different general concepts of restrictions on marketing and use exist, which can be designated as "ban with exemptions" and "controlled use". A ban with exemptions means that marketing and use of the substances are prohibited except for applications that are explicitly allowed. Controlled use means that marketing and use of a substance and the preparations and products containing it are allowed except those that are specifically forbidden. In practice, the concept of "controlled use" is predominant, i.e. a ban limited to e.g. the general public (e.g. benzidine, chlorinated, hydrocarbons) and/or certain applications (e.g. cadmium). The provisions may be related to concentration limits for the substance in a preparation or a product (e.g. emission limit for nickel in jewellery). There are also requirements for specific labelling and other safety measures (e.g. asbestos). A special mechanism for risk reduction in the Directive, that links the directive with Council Directive 67/548/EEC is provided by the 14th amendment in 1994. This allows substances classified as carcinogenic, mutagenic or toxic to reproduction (category 1 and 2) to be banned for consumer use. The provisions in Directive 76/769/EEC do not cover areas where harmonised legislation already exists, e.g. risks to human health from cosmetics and medicinal products. Before any proposal for measures under Directive 76/769/EEC was made, the Commission consults the various stakeholders and is obliged to present an Extended Impact Assessment (ExIA) on the advantages and drawbacks of such a measure, normally undertaken by an independent consultant.
Exposure Exposure Limits in the EU 47
EUROPEAN LEGISLATION WITH A SPECIAL FOCUS ON PROTECTING WORKERS FROM THE RISKS ARISING FROM HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS In addition to measures that are focussed on the responsibilities of producers to identify and assess the hazards of their chemical products discussed above, there are several instruments amongst the array of regulatory provisions at Community level that are of particular significance for worker protection. They include: Directive 98/24/EC
-
Directive 2004/37/EC Directive 2000/54/EC -
protection of workers from the risks related to chemical agents at work protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens at work protection of workers from risks related to exposure to biological agents at work.
As we have already noted, these provisions also need to be understood in relation to the requirements regulation health and safety management generally that are found hi Directive 89/39 I/EEC - the so-called Framework Directive. The Framework Directive 89/391/EEC. The directive sets out the principles for further legislation on workers* safety and health. A number of more specific directives (some fourteen all together) have been adopted with reference to this directive. There are no specific rules regarding chemical agents in the directive. However, Article 6 lists the general principles of prevention. They include: — — -
avoiding risks evaluating the risks which cannot be avoided combating the risks at source adapting the work to the individual, especially as regards the design of work places, the choice of work equipment and the choice of working and production methods, - adapting to technical progress — replacing the dangerous by the non-dangerous or the less dangerous
48 Beyond Limits
— developing a coherent overall prevention policy which covers technology, organisation of work, working conditions, social relationships and the influence of factors related to the working environment — giving collective protective measures priority over individual protective measures — giving appropriate instructions to the workers. The Directive not only establishes a framework of general rules for workers' safety and health protection, but also implemented Europe-wide the concept of a modern, comprehensive approach to occupational health and safety, that should be embedded in the overall management of a company. Individual Directives adopted on the basis of Article 16 (1) of the Directive are all based on the same main principles regulating OHS management but establish, in addition, specific and further going provisions, for example, for: — certain vulnerable groups (e.g. pregnant workers) — special working conditions (e.g. working with computers or on fishing vessels) — particular risks (e.g. chemical agents in general or carcinogens and mutagens in particular) — the design of workplaces and the equipment used (e.g. personal protective equipment). With respect to the protection of workers from chemicals, the three Directives, briefly described in the following, are the most important. Directive 98/24/EEC, sets the frame for preventing the risks from chemical agents in general. Its requirements are outlined below followed by those for carcinogens and for biological agents. The Chemical Agents Directive 98/24/EC. The first comprehensive framework for Community legislation on chemicals in the workplace was included in Council Directive 80/1107/EEC, which set out measures for the control of risks due to chemical, physical and biological agents. It was amended in 1988 by the adoption of Directive 88/642/EEC that focused on the mechanism for setting exposure limits for hazardous chemicals. This directive was repealed on 5 May 2001 with
Exposure Limits in the EU 49
the adoption of Directive 98/24/EEC. Besides Directive 80/1107/EEC,63 a number of other earlier Directives (on metallic lead and ionic compounds (82/605/EEC)64 and Directive 88/364/EEC on banning certain specific agents and/or work activities65 which set the scene for protecting workers from chemical and other risks before the Framework Directive came into force, were also repealed at this time. Directive 98/24/EEC lays down minimum requirements for work with hazardous chemical agents. Its provisions apply without prejudice to the more stringent and/or specific requirements of the Carcinogens Directive 2004/3 7/EC as amended. Here again can be found a link to DSD and the DPD, because the scope of the Directives covers any chemical substance and preparation that either is already classified or meets the criteria to be classified as hazardous in the meaning of those Directives. The Chemical Agents Directive also covers chemical substances which, although they do not meet these criteria, may present a risk to safety and health of workers due to their physio-chemical, chemical or toxicological properties. Importantly for our purposes, it provides a framework for setting occupational exposure limit values and biological limit values at European level. It requires: -
that risks arising from chemical agents are identified by employers through risk assessment that exposure should be prevented or at least adequately controlled that exposure should be monitored regularly in those instances where a national OELV is exceeded, the employer is to remedy the situation through preventative and protective measures. Council Directive 80/1107/EEC of 27 November 1980 on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to chemical, physical and biological agents at work, Official Journal L 327 , 03/12/1980 P. 0008 - 0013. Council Directive 82/605/EEC of 28 July 1982 on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to metallic lead and its ionic compounds at work (first individual Directive within the meaning of Article 8 of Directive 80/1107/EEC), Official Journal L 247 ,23/08/1982 P. 0012 - 0021. Council Directive 88/364/EEC of 9 June 1988 on the protection of workers by the banning of certain specified agents and/or certain work activities (Fourth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 8 of Directive 80/1107/EEC), Official Journal L 179 , 09/07/1988 P. 0044 - 0047.
50 Beyond Limits
hi addition: -
workers have to be informed and trained when handling dangerous substances they are subject to regular health surveillance individual exposure record have to be made and kept up-to date employers have to draw up detailed procedures for dealing with accidents, incidents and emergencies that involve hazardous substances.
The principles set out in the Directive (also found in the Carcinogens Directive see below) are based on substitution, prevention, protection and control. Directive 2004/37/EC (as amended). The Carcinogen Directive. Community action on prevention of exposure to occupational carcinogens began in 1990, when the Council adopted Directive 2004/37/EC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens at work (sixth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Directive 89/391EEC). This Directive was amended twice,66 and its scope extended to cover mutagens. On 30 April 2004, a consolidated version of the Carcinogen Directive and its amendment was published in the Official Journal (Directive 2004/3767) The Directive has as its main objective to protect workers' health and safety against risks specifically arising or likely to arise from exposure to carcinogens and mutagens at work which meet the criteria for carcinogens and mutagens (category 1 and 2) under the DSD and the DPD. It lays down minimum requirements concerning carcinogens and mutagens, including limit values.
Council Directive 97/42/EC of 27 June 1997 amending for the first time Directive 2004/37/EC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens at work (Sixth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16 (1) of Directive 89/391/EEC), Official Journal L 179 , 08/07/1997 P. 0004 - 0006. Council Directive 1999/38/EC of 29 April 1999 amending for the second time Directive 2004/37/EC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens at work and extending it to mutagens, Official Journal L 138 , 01/06/1999 P. 0066 - 0069. Directive 2004/37/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens or mutagens at work (Sixth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Council Directive 89/391/EEC) (codified version) (Text with EEA relevance) (OJL 158 30.04.2004p. 50).
Exposure Limits in the EU 51
According to the Directive, it is the duty of the employer to reduce the use of a carcinogen or mutagen by replacing it with a substance, preparation or process less dangerous or not dangerous. If it is not technically possible to carry out such substitution, the employer must ensure that the carcinogen is manufactured and used in a closed system. Where neither of these precautions is possible, the employer must reduce the level of exposure to a carcinogen or mutagen to as low a level as is technically possible. Furthermore, the Directive lists a number of measures to which the employer must adhere when a carcinogen or mutagen is used: -
-
-
-
limitation of the quantities of a carcinogen or mutagen at the place of work keeping as low as possible the number of workers exposed or likely to be exposed design of work processes and engineering control measures so as to avoid or minimise the release of carcinogens or mutagens into the place of work evacuation of carcinogens and mutagens at source, local extraction system or general ventilation, all such methods to be appropriate and compatible with the need to protect public health and the environment use of existing appropriate procedures for the measurement of carcinogens and mutagens, in particular for the early detection of abnormal exposures resulting from an unforeseeable event or an accident application of suitable working procedures and methods collective protection measures and/or, where exposure cannot be avoided by other means, individual protection measures hygiene measures, in particular regular cleaning of floors, walls and other surfaces information for workers demarcation of risk areas and use of adequate warning and safety signs including 'no smoking' signs in areas where workers are exposed or likely to be exposed to carcinogens and mutagens drawing up plans to deal with emergencies likely to result in abnormally high exposure means for safe storage, handling and transportation, in particular by using sealed and clearly and visibly labelled containers.
The employers shall, when requested, make available to the competent authority appropriate information on:
52 Beyond Limits
-
the activities and/or industrial processes carried out, including the reasons for which carcinogens and mutagens are used the quantities of substances or preparations manufactured or used which contain carcinogens or mutagens the number of workers exposed the preventive measures taken the type of protective equipment used the nature and degree of exposure the cases of replacement.
The employer shall also ensure that workers and/or workers' representatives receive sufficient and appropriate training on the basis of all available information concerning the potential risks to health and the precautions to be taken to prevent exposure, etc. In particular, the employer shall inform workers of installations and related containers containing carcinogens or mutagens, ensure that all containers, packages and installations containing carcinogens or mutagens are labelled clearly and legibly and display clearly visible warning and hazard signs. Reinforced health surveillance is foreseen and the practical recommendations for the health surveillance are given in Annex II. Annex III sets limit values on the basis of the available information, including scientific and technical data. At present, Annex III includes only limit values for benzene, vinyl chloride monomer and inhalable hardwood dust. Directive 2000/54/EC (as amended), The Biological Agents Directive. Although it is not of particularly direct relevance to the subject of this account, the third element of the triumvirate of important Community measures with special significance for protecting workers against hazardous chemicals is the Biological Agents Directive. On 17 October 2000, a consolidated version of the Directive and its amendment was published in the Official Journal (2000/54/EC68). It covers the protection of workers from risks related to exposure to biological agents. Biological agents include micro-organisms, cell cultures and human endoparasites that may be able to provoke infection, allergy or toxicity. They are classified into four groups according to their level of risk of infection. It prescribes measures to Directive 2000/54/EC of the European Parliament and the Council of 18 September2000 on the protection of workers from risks related to exposure to biological agents at work (seventh individual directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Directive 89/39 I/EEC).
Exposure Exposure Limits in the EU 53
be taken to avoid risks and dangers resulting from work with biological agents such as equipment, hygiene, handling of agents, reduction of exposure, vaccination of employees etc. An annex contains a classification of organisms.69
OEL SETTING AT THE EUROPEAN LEVEL Since the central focus of this book is on the determination and use of OELs, arrangements at the level of the EU are clearly of particular interest. As noted above, directives such as the Chemical Agents Directive that have a special focus on risk management strategies for hazardous substances in relation to workplaces make provisions for OELs. To appreciate the significance of these provisions it is helpful to first outline the institutional development of approaches to these issues at the level of the EU. Approaches in the past. The objective of setting OELs in the European Union (EU) was introduced into EU legislation by Council Directive 80/1107/EEC, as amended by Directive 88/642/EEC.70 Under this Directive, two types of OELs were defined, binding limit values and indicative limit values (ILVs). Member States were asked to take the ILVs into account when establishing national OELs, but there was no legal obligation to do so. In 1990, at the request of the European Council, the European Commission set up an informal group of scientists, known as the Scientific Expert Group (SEG), to give advice on setting limit values, after having reviewed the different approaches in the Member States. In 1991, the first set of 27 ILVs was proposed by the EC and agreed by Member States on the basis of pre-existing national positions (Directive 91/322/EEC).71
http://agency.osha.eu.int/publications/factsheets/41/en/FACTSN41-EN.PDF. Council Directive 88/642/EEC of 16 December 1988 amending Directive 80/1107/EEC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to chemical, physical and biological agents at work, Official Journal L 356 , 24/12/1988 P. 0074 - 0078. Commission Directive 91/322/EEC of 29 May 1991 on establishing indicative limit values by implementing Council Directive 80/1107/EEC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to chemical, physical and biological agents at work, Official Journal L 177 , 05/07/1991 P. 0022 - 0024.
54 Beyond Limits
In 1995, the status of the SEG was formalised, becoming the SCOEL.72 Today the committee has 21 members from all Member States7* with full scientific expertise needed for this task.74 The SCOEL provides the Commission with recommendations on 'health based' OELs. Based on those recommendations, a second list of ILVs was published in 1996 (Directive 96/94/EC).75 Current approaches and types of OELs. With the introduction of the Chemical Agents Directive in 1998, the concept of OELs changed. In Article 3, the Directive introduced: -
Indicative Occupational Exposure Limit Values (IOELVs) Binding Occupational Exposure Limit Values (BOELVs) Binding Biological Limit Values (BBLVs).
IOELVs are supposed to be health based, whereas BOELVs take technical and / or economical feasibility considerations into account. With respect to the IOELVs, Member States had no longer an option whether or not to take them into account. They now have to set a national exposure limit value to implement the IOELV. They can however — under certain conditions - exceed at national level the value of the OEL set at Community level.
95/320/EC: Commission Decision of 12 July 1995 setting up a Scientific Committee for Occupational Ejqsosure Limits to Chemical Agents , Official Journal L 188 ,09/08/1995 p. 0014-0015. The Commission appoints these members after consulting the respective Member States, having regard to the need to cover all relevant aspects of the committee's work. The term of office for SCOEL members is three years and their names are published in the Official Journal of the European Union. Meetings of the committee normally take place four times a year and individuals with particular expertise in the subject under study are sometimes invited to participate. The SCOEL comprises experts in chemistry, toxicology, epidemiology, occupational medicine and industrial hygiene and has general competence in setting OELs. Commission Directive 96/94/EC of 18 December 1996 establishing a second list of indicative limit values in implementation of Council Directive 80/1107/EEC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to chemical, physical and biological agents at work (Text with EEA relevance), Official Journal L 338 , 28/12/1996 P. 0086-0088.
Exposure Limits in the EU 55
For any chemical agent for which a binding value is set at Community level, Member States have to set a corresponding national binding value. The national binding limit value can only be stricter, but cannot exceed the Community limit value. A first list of IOELVs was established in Commission Directive 2000/39/EC of 8 June 2000.76 Procedures and bodies involved. The SCOEL starts its work by evaluating criteria documents from different sources. The Commission, through publication in the Official Journal, announces the identified base document with the request for further data, especially that which is unpublished, to be provided to the Commission, to guarantee the completeness of the data for the chemical agent concerned. The SCOEL evaluates the scientific dossier and the supplementary data for the identification of the critical health effects and then proposes a recommendation for a health-based limit value in a summary document, which in addition to the recommendation for an OEL, also contains further information on the basic data, a description of the critical effect, the extrapolation techniques used, and any data on possible risks to human health. The technical feasibility of monitoring exposure is also noted. Furthermore the SCOEL identifies important gaps in the data and the need for more research. Once the Committee agrees the summary document the Commission makes it public to interested parties with the request for health based scientific comments and eventually further data. After a period of about six months allowed for comments, the SCOEL rediscusses the document in the light of the comments received and adopts the final version, which is then published by the Commission. When the Commission services have received recommendations from the SCOEL they are in a position to develop legal proposals for OELs. At this stage and according to the type of OEL, the Commission services will seek relevant technical and socio-economic data. If any of the interested parties is aware that there are such data which can be shown to be pertinent to the development of a
Commission Directive 2000/39/EC of 8 June 2000 establishing a first list of indicative occupational exposure limit values in implementation of Council Directive 98/24/EC on the protection of the health and safety of workers from the risks related to chemical agents at work (Text with EEA relevance), Official Journal L 142 , 16/06/2000 P. 0047 - 0050.
56 Beyond Limits
Commission's proposal then these should be made known to the Commission services. The Commission's proposal for a legislative text is submitted to the Advisory Committee for Safety, Hygiene, and Health at Work, (ACSHH), a tripartite committee consisting of representatives from governments, employers' organisations and trade unions. At this stage all the interested parties have a further opportunity, through the ACSHH structure, to contribute to the opinion adopted by the Committee. The opinion delivered by the ACSHH is available through its minutes and is also published in the ACSHH's annual report. Once these consultations have been completed the Commission services will finalise their preparation of a proposal to be agreed by the Commission. According to the type of OEL (binding or not binding) and the legal procedure selected, further consultation on the Commission's proposal, within the appropriate European Union institutions, will take place, before the final adoption and publication in the Official Journal of an OEL.77
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE EXISTING LEGISLATION AND THE FUTURE APPROACH AT COMMUNITY LEVEL Despite the quantity and detail of existing provisions at Community level, effective risk management of hazardous substances and preparations at Community and national level is far from guaranteed. Indeed, there is widespread recognition that its regulatory instruments have turned out to be fairly inefficient in particular because the processes they invoke are operationally time consuming and because they set different risk assessment obligations for so-called new and existing substances they have resulted in substantial data gaps for the majority of substances78 marketed in Europe.
OELs are measured or calculated for a reference period of eight-hour time weighted average (TWA). For a number of substances, short-term exposure limit values (STEL) are also given, representing a limit value above which exposure should not occur and which is related to a 15-minute period, unless otherwise specified. They are expressed either in mg/m3 of air at 20 °C and 101,3 KPa or in ppm. In addition, a skin notation can be assigned to the OEL, indicating the possibility of significant uptake through the skin. Most of the estimates speak about 99 per cent.
Exposure Limits in the EU 57
A Commission report on the operation of the main instruments was published in 1998,79 leading to the conclusion that the existing legal framework was not adequate (CEC 1998). As a consequence, the Commission developed its White Paper on a Strategy for a Future Chemicals Policy, which was adopted in 2001. It argued:80 -
There is a lack of knowledge about the dangers of many chemicals on the EU market. This makes it difficult to assess their risks properly and to make informed decisions about controlling those risks.
-
The current process of risk assessment is much too slow. Only a handful of chemical substances are assessed at EU level each year.
-
Resources are concentrated too much on the assessment of "new substances" which make up less than 1 per cent of the total volume of substances on the market and not enough on "existing substances". This has the effect of stifling innovation in new chemical products.
In May 2003, after additional impact studies and various discussions at Council level and with different stakeholders, the Commission published a draft proposal that was then subject to consultation resulting in more than 6,000 Stakeholder Representations including those from Member State Governments, Competent Authorities, the Chemicals Industry and other interested parties. Following the consultation, the Commission adopted a proposal for the 'Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council concerning the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals' otherwise known as REACH. It modified several of its initial requirements in what several commentators have seen as concessions to a powerful industrial lobby (Epstein 2005). The legislative proposal was put before the European Parliament and the Council where it remains subject to intensive discussions.81 http://eviropB.eu.int/coniin/eiivironni8nt/cheinicals/pd&report-4-instiuiBents_en.pdfi'. Commission Working Document: Report on the operation of Dir, 67/548, Dir. 88/379, Reg 793/93 and Dir. 76/769. http://europB.eu.int/smartapi/cgi/sga_doc?smartapi!celexapi!prod!CELEX numdoc&lg=EN&aumdoo=52001DC0088&model=guichett. The Commission proposal is subject to the co-decision procedure.
58 5 8 Beyond BeyondLimits him its
The main element of the new Regulation as proposed by the Commission can be summarised as follows:82 REACH will replace the main pieces of European chemical legislation by an integrated system. It will eliminate the current distinction between 'existing' and 'new* chemicals and their respective testing requirements.83 In outline it consists of several interlinked requirements on chemical producers concerning the registration, evaluation and authorisation of their chemical products. They are: (1) Registration - Registration requires all chemicals manufactured in or imported into the EU in a volume of 1 tonne or more per year to be registered with the competent authority within a new European Chemicals Agency (ECA). The ECA will manage a central, EU-wide database. - Companies will have to submit basic information including a brief description of the uses of the substance and any uses that the manufacturer advises against84, as well as a technical dossier of test data and future testing proposals. - Data requirements vary according to the production volume and suspected toxicity of the substance. - Registration will be undertaken in several stages, with deadlines varying with production volumes: - Substances supplied in excess of 1,000 tonnes a year and some substances of so-called 'high concern' (e.g. CMRs,85 PBTs,16 or vPvBs87) will be registered within 3 years of the law coming into force - those in excess of 100 tonnes within 6 years - those in excess of 1 tonne and 10 tonnes within 11 years. - For chemicals that raise no particular concerns or annual production of which usually remains below a ceiling of 100 tonnes, registration will be 82 83
http://europa.eu.int/comin/entBrprise/reach/. Certain chemicals are exempted from the proposals; these include polymers, intermediates in chemical processes that never leave the factory, pharmaeeuticals a n d foods. If a company wishes to employ a chemical for an unregistered use the registration dossier must be updated to reflect this. Substances being carcinogenic, mutagenic or toxic to reproduction. Substances being persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic. Substances being very persistent and very bioaccumulative.
Exposure Limits in the EU 59
sufficient. All substances produced or marketed in greater volumes, or which are more sensitive, will be subject to evaluation. (2) Evaluation - National authorities on the basis of the registration data will undertake evaluation. Two types of evaluation are proposed: - Dossier evaluation - all registrations that propose further animal tests will be evaluated to ensure that such tests are strictly necessary. The evaluation process checks if test data for the substance in question are already available, and whether alternative tests could be employed to prevent unnecessary animal testing. - Substance evaluation - carried out if a competent authority suspects that a substance poses a risk to human health or the environment (for example because of its structural similarity to a known dangerous substance). This involves examining the dossiers of all registrations for a substance to clarify the risks and may result in the authority requesting further information from those registering the substance. (3) Authorisation - Substances identified through registration and/or evaluation as being of high concern (CMRs, PBTs, vPvBs) cannot be used or placed on the market without authorisation. Authorisation will be granted to the producer / importer of a substance only (one for each use and user) if they can demonstrated that they can control, in an appropriate way, the risks posed by the chemical or that the socio-economic benefits of the substance outweigh the risks. This type of decision may take into account whether industry is actively researching to find an alternative substitute. Authorisations granted for socio-economic reasons will be time-limited and reviewed on a case-by-case basis. The use of other substances that pose unacceptable risks, but are not classified as of high concern, could be restricted if requested by a Member State. Restriction may ban use in certain products, by consumers, or even any use at all.
60 Beyond Limits
REACH AND WORKER PROTECTION In summary, it is intended that the measures in REACH will increase the effectiveness of existing provisions to protect workers exposed to dangerous substances and combat risks of ill-health caused by work-related exposure to chemicals by: -
-
providing information that is currently not available on the properties of chemical substances and ways of minimising the risks associated with using them improving the communication of such information throughout production and supply chains promoting substitution of the most harmful chemicals with less hazardous ones by means of its authorisation and restriction provisions.
The extent to which this will actually occur however depends on several issues for which the prognosis is at present unclear. Partly because of this, REACH has generated considerable debate. For the social and economic interests involved this debate has been polarised around issues of costs versus benefits, with the former being emphasised by industry and the benefits for human health and the environment championed by social interest groups such as environmental NGOs and most of the trade unions.88 The assumptions made by or on behalf of all the interest groups involved regarding such costs and benefits, coupled with the additional problem that it is as yet unclear what form the final implementation of the regulation will take, or how it will work in practice, make it very difficult to predict outcomes either with regard to workers" protection in general or the particular future for OELs in this process. Nevertheless some things seem clear. First, while the requirements in REACH will undoubtedly contribute to increasing knowledge and information concerning the hazardous properties and safe use of far more chemicals in use in Europe than is currently the case, the extent to which the communication of such information and its usefulness in practice will be enhanced by the Regulation is less certain. The policy rhetoric behind REACH places considerable emphasis on not only how the measures will involve greater requirements on chemical producers to exercise responsible stewardship of their products, but also how such duties will
See for example Musu (2004).
Exposure Limits in the EU 61
extend though the supply chain with the result that formulators and users will also be bound to engage in a far more active way in ensuring the safety of chemical substances than is currently the case. However, such reasoning seems to be based on a particularly optimistic way of looking at how supply chains actually operate in relation to health and safety of workers as well as on a fairly limited assessment of what prevents users from either understanding or using the information on the safe use of chemicals that is currently available. These are issues to which we will return in our discussion in the final chapter of this book, but it is sufficient to note that the existence of business networks for production, supply and demand do not automatically lend themselves to a role in enhancing health and safety - indeed in some cases they owe their existence to attempts by business organisations to off-load responsibilities for health and safety.89 Furthermore, current research findings on risk communication in relation to chemical hazards suggest that user's understanding and use of safety information is the result of a more complex set of factors than merely the failure to supply the information in the first place.90 This is of course especially important in relation to the role of OELs in risk management strategies at the workplace level. Again, we shall return to this discussion in the concluding chapter of this book. A final point is that (at least as far as the current proposal is concerned) REACH will probably have little immediate effect on the current situation at the work places with regards to OELs, because test requirements on suppliers in REACH are based on the annual production or importation volume of a substance and for substances between 1 and 10 tonnes they will not - for the reasons outlined in Chapter 1 - allow the development of OELs for substances which don't already have one. This might change in the long term, after all substances have been registered and the data evaluated.
For example business organisations frequently out-source both services and goods to wider supply networks in attempts to reduce the costs of these functions to their core organisation. See for example, the findings of the recent ECLIPS (2004) study in the light of British based research findings such as those of Briggs (2000); Kigston-Howlett (2001); Wiseman and Gilbert (2002)and Middlesex University Business School,(2004) that will be discussed further in ChapterlO.
62 Beyond Limits
CONCLUSION It should be evident from the preceding pages that there has been a substantial system for regulating risk management of hazardous chemicals in place at the level of the EU for some considerable time. It emanates from two overlapping sources, one that deals with trade and the other for the protection of workers. The system is based upon sound prevention principles, including those of hazard identification, risk assessment and communication as well as principles of safe practice that emphasise substitution and control at source and is vested with sufficient authority to deem certain substances too dangerous to be marketed unless under strict and specified conditions. The outline presented here demonstrates how regulating the risks from occupational exposures to hazardous chemicals forms a special part of this system overall and needs to be understood in this context, as well with reference to other measures regulating health and safety management such as those in place in all member states as a result of their transposition of the Framework Directive 89/391. Structures and procedures for setting exposure limits at EU level have developed as part of this subsystem for regulating chemical risks in relation to the workplace. However, the current view of the existing system is that its burgeoning regulatory requirements are failing in the degree to which they could be deemed to be effectively operational and contributing significantly and cost effectively to minimising the risks to health and the environment posed by hazardous substances at work, in consumer products and elsewhere in the environment. As a consequence, a new regulatory strategy is under discussion and likely to become effective in whole or in part over the coming decade. As we have indicated, it is unlikely that the immediate effects of the new strategy on the position and role of OELs will be particularly significant. However the thinking behind it is important and several aspects of the new proposals and the assumptions on which they are based could be particularly significant in relation to managing risks associated with hazardous substances in the medium to longer term. This is especially so in relation to the position of users of chemicals in small and medium sized enterprises where, as we shall see in subsequent chapters, the failures of existing provisions in relation to the role of OELs have been felt most acutely. We will return to this discussion in our concluding chapter, which follows the detailed exposition of the extent of the problem presented in the country chapters later in the book. Before doing so it is necessary to consider the position of OELs
Exposure Limits in the EU 63
in the legislative systems of the EU 15 countries, the extent to which such positions are comparable and the effects that approaches to OELs at the level of the EU have had on them. It is to these issues that we turn in the following chapter.
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
65
SYSTEMS FOR SETTING AND USING OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMITS IN EU15 COUNTRIES
INTRODUCTION
This chapter continues our analysis of the nature and role of requirements on setting and using OELs within regulatory systems that we started in Chapter 2 in relation to European Community institutions. In the present chapter however we are concerned with the position at the level of the member states, and specifically with that in the EU 15 member states. The primary intention here is to document comparable and distinguishing features of the various national level institutional and legislative frameworks in which exposure limits are developed and used. To these ends a considerable amount of detailed information on different national structures and systems was gathered, both in the original research project on which the book is based (Walters et al 2003) as well as more recently in updating that material and adding to it new elements. The main aspects of the various systems for setting and using OELs have of course not changed within the last two years. However, there have been changes to the lists of OELs in some countries as well as to many of the Internet links identified in the previous published report (Walters et al 2003). Also significant for accurate documentation of national systems is the tendency to reshuffle responsibilities within governments after an election, resulting in changes in the ministries responsible for the establishment of occupational health and safety legislation in general and for publishing/issuing the OELs in particular. We have therefore attempted to reflect these changes in the current chapter. We believe it to be a fair snapshot, but it is important to caution
66 Beyond Limits
that the details of the administrative and regulatory systems described here are subject to continuing change. In order to avoid cluttering the text with too much detail, to maintain clarity in terms of highlighting major points of comparison and difference, and for ease of reference to the material itself, much of this information has been presented in tabular form. In addition, further relevant information in tabulated in Annexes I to IV that can be found at the end of the book." The tables presented in the following pages and in the related annexes therefore outline current information, that while not essential for the understanding of the principles behind the development and operation of various systems they describe, provides the necessary tools to dig deeper into the subject, if this is required. The chapter begins with an overview of the institutional framework regulating occupational health and safety in each of the EU 15 countries. This is followed by an outline of the basic legislative frameworks governing occupational health and safety generally, and chemical substances specifically, in each country. This information is supported by further material on responsible institutions and on the transposition of EU provisions into national laws in the EU 15 countries in Annexes I, n and III. The chapter continues with the tabulation of comparative aspects of the features of systems for setting limit values, including the main types of limit values set, their origins, the number in each country, notations used, the frequency with which they may be updated and other relevant information for all the EU 15 countries. This is followed by a tabulated comparison of the procedures for setting exposure limits in each country, including the involvement of social partners and other bodies in these processes. We outline the systems for enforcement and surveillance of compliance with OELs in each country. Finally we conclude the chapter by identifying and briefly discussing some of the main issues concerning the role of OELs in national systems. These issues will be pursued in greater depth in subsequent chapters on the six countries that are the subject of our detailed study.
Additional details can also be found in Walters et al (2003), the published research report of the original study on which this book is based.
Occupational Exposure Limits in in the EU 67 67 Occupational
REGULATORY SYSTEMS AND RESPONSIBLE BODIES Table 3.1 gives an overview on the institutional framework for occupational health and safety in each country. It lists the: -
responsible ministry and its sub-department(s) scientific and / or other bodies and institutions involved in developing OELs at national level authorities responsible for surveillance and enforcement.
Names are only provided in English where translation was provided in one of the official or semi-official documents and websites used for compiling the data. In all other cases, the original name has been kept. Relevant web-site addresses where they exist for the ministries and the other bodies and institutions mentioned below are listed in Annex I (Websites of Ministries and other bodies involved in H&S).
68 Beyond Limits ON
00
Table 3.1:
National institutions with responsibilities for developing occupational exposure limits for surveillance.
Country
Ministry
Sub-Department(s)
Austria
Federal Ministry of Economics and Labour Le Service public federal Emploi, Travail et Concertation sociale (SPF) Ministry of Employment
Department III - Labour Law and Labour Inspectorates Direction generate Controle du bien-etre au travail Division du controle des risques chimiques
Ministry of Social Affairs and Health
Occupational Safety and Health Department
Belgium
Denmark
Finland
Working Environment Authority
Scientific and other bodies / institutions involved Arbeitnehmerschutzbeirat
Surveillance Authority Central Labour Inspectorate Inspection du Travail et des mines
National Institute of Occupational Health; Working Environment Council and its Committee on Limit Values Advisory Committee for Occupational Health and Safety on Chemicals; Finnish Institute of Occupational Health
Working Environment Authority
Occupational Safety and Health Inspectorates
Ministry
France
Ministere de I 'Emploi, Secteur emploi / travail du Travail et de la Direction des relations du travail Cohesion sociale
Germany
Federal Ministry of Economics and Labour
Greece
Ireland
Ministry of Employment and Social Protection Ministry of Health and Welfare Minister for
Sub-Department(s)
Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (Bundesanstalt fiir Arbeitsschutz und Arbeitsmedizin)
General Directorate of Working Conditions and Health; Centre of Occupational Health and Safety Health and Safety Authority
Scientific and other bodies / institutions involved Conseil superieur de la prevention des risques professionnel; Institut National de Recherche et Securite Caisse nationale de I'Assurance Maladie des travailleurs salaries Regional Offices for Industrial Safety (Landesamter fur Arbeitsschutz); Institutions for statutory accident insurance and prevention for trade and industry (Berufsgenossenschaften); Committee for Hazardous Substances (Ausschuss fur Gefahrstoffe)
Surveillance Authority L 'inspection du travail
Trade Supervisory Offices (Gewerbeaufsichtsdmter) Technical Inspection Services (Technische Aufsichtsdienste)
National Council for Health and Soma Epitheorisis Safety at Work; National Health Ergasiss (Joint State and Safety Institute Technical Inspectors)
Advisory Committee on
Health and Safety
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU
Country
I I
3
69
70 Beyond Limits -J
o
CO
Country
Italy
Ministry
Sub-Department(s)
Enterprise, Trade and Employment Ministero della Sanita Ministere del Lavoro e delle Politiche Sociali
Luxembourg Ministere du Travail etdul'Emploi Portugal Ministeria do Trabalho e da Solidartedade
Scientific and other bodies / institutions involved Dangerous Substances
Surveillance Authority Authority's inspectorate
Istituto Superioreper la Ispettorato del Lavoro Prevenzione e la Sicurezza del Lavoro; Istituto Superiore di Sanita; Commissione consultiva tossicologica nazionale; Instituto Nazionale per L 'Assicurazione contra gli Infortuni sul Lavoro Istituto Italiano di Medicina Sociale; Commissions consultiva permanente per la prevenzione degli infortuni e I'igiene del lavoro
Direccao-General das Condigiones de Trabalho — DGCT
Instituto para a Seguranca, Higiene e Saude no Trabalho
L'Inspection du Travail et des Mines Inspecgao Geral do Trabalho-IGT
I
Ministry
Spain
Ministerio de Trabajo Commission Nacional de y Asuntos Societies Seguridad y Salud en el Trabajo (Ministry for Labour and Social Affairs) Ministry of Industry, Swedish Work Environment Employment and Authority Communication Ministerie van Sociale Directoraat-Generaal Zaken en Arbeidsverhoudingen en Werkgelegenheid Internationale Betrekkingen
Sweden
The Netherlands
United Kingdom
Department of Work and Pensions
Sub-Depart nient(s)
Health and Safety Commission/Health and Safety Executive
Scientific and other bodies / institutions involved Instituto Nacional de Seguridad e Higiene en el Trabajo
Surveillance Authority Inspection de Trabajo
Swedish National Institute for Work Environment Working Life; Swedish Criteria Inspection Department Group Health Council of the Labour Inspectorate Netherlands Expert Committee on Occupational Standards DECOS; the Social and Economic Council Sub-Committee on MAC values of the Social and Economic Council Advisory Committee on Toxic Substances (ACTS)
Health and Safety Executive
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU
Country
§•
•3
I
71
72 Beyond Limits
IMPLEMENTING EU REQUIREMENTS IN EU15 MEMBER STATES All EU 15 Member States claim to have transposed relevant European legislation dealing with occupational health and safety in general and with hazardous chemicals in particular into national legislation. However, some indication of the extent to which this is a reality is provided by the annual reports of the Commission monitoring the application of Community law.*2 According to the most recent of these reports for example, a decision has been taken to refer France and Italy to the European Court of Justice because they have not yet notified measures transposing Directives 98/24/EC and 2000/39/EC respectively. Moreover, following the judgment given by the Court of Justice against Austria for failure to notify Ml measures transposing Directives 95/30, 97/59 and 97/65 (risks of exposure to biological agents at work), Article 228 proceedings are in motion as regards the first two directives. Several infringement proceedings have also been commenced or continued regarding problems of incorrect transposal of the Framework Directive 89/39 I/EEC and its specific directives. Reasoned opinions were sent to Austria, France and Spain regarding the transposition of this Directive. Proceedings are also still in motion against Ireland, Sweden and the United Kingdom and the cases against the Netherlands and Luxembourg have reached the Court of Justice. On 7 February 2002 judgment was given against Germany for incorrect transposal of the obligation imposed by the directive for a health and safety risk evaluation to be available in documentary form at all times. When European Directives dealing with the protection of workers from risks arising from hazardous chemicals have been transposed into national legislation, in most cases they have been integrated into existing national chemicals legislation. The Framework Directive 89/3 9 I/EEC, however, which was somewhat of a milestone in health and safety legislation at European level, provided for so many obligations for all stakeholders that in many countries a separate law was needed to transpose it into national legislation.93
See for example, the 20th Annual report on monitoring the application of Community law (2002), Brussels 21.11.2003, COM(2003) 669 final http://europa.eu.int/eurlex/en/com/rpt/2003/ actO669en03/l.pdf, For details see Walters et al 2002 and also Vogel 1993 and 1998.
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU 73
In addition, in all countries there is legislation (either as an individual enactment or as part of another piece of legislation) that transposes EU directives on: -
carcinogenic and rnutagenic substances in general and on asbestos in particular biological agents lead and vinyl chloride monomers banning certain substances / work procedures94 safety data sheets95 occupational exposure limit values.
In Annex If an overview on the transposition in each country of the main pieces of European legislation dealing with hazardous chemicals and workers protection is provided. In Annex HI, are found the names and the source of the basic legislation, transposing the Framework Directive (89/39 I/EEC), the Chemical Agents Directive (98/24/EC), and the Carcinogen Directive (2004/37/EC) into national law in each country. A Unk to a web page where the most recent OEL list can be found is also provided (if existent).
OCCUPATIONAL EXPOSURE LIMIT VALUES IN THE EU IS COUNTRIES Table 3.2 compares the various Emit value lists from each country in terms of: 94
95
acronyms and names/types (health based/economically-technically based) of OEL listed source of OELs (own system or based mainly on other systems like the US, the German or Nordic systems) information given on forms of notations etc. number of substances listed
Transposition o f Directive 88/364/EEC banning o f certain agents and activities (01.01.90) repealed by 98/24. The Directive on Safety data Sheets as amended has a different legal basis than the other Directives on health and safety. Nevertheless, this Directive is an important tool for providing information on hazardous chemicals at the workplace, and it is therefore listed here.
74 Beyond Limits -
other information provided regularity of updates (yes or no/last update).
In general, all OELs are established for single substances96 and fulfil the following requirements. Their underlying basic assumptions are that they are established for healthy people of employable age. Definitions for OELs include those for: -
Health-based OELs. "Maximum allowable concentration in the workplace / in the breathing zone of a worker of a working material in the form of gas, vapour, or air-suspended matter which, according to the present state of knowledge, generally does not impair the health of the workers even through repeated and prolonged exposure."
-
Technically/economically based OELs. "Concentration of a dangerous working material in the form of gas, vapour, or air-suspended matter in the air at the workplace, which can be achieved according to the state of the art in technology/the best available technology.
-
Biological limit values. Maximum value for the content of the substance or of one of its metabolites in biological media (i.e. blood, urine).
There are three different kinds of units in which the OEL concentrations are presented: -
-
ppm (number of cubic centimetres of pollutant per cubic metre of air — independent from temperature and air pressure), for gases and vapours (volatile substances) mg/m3 (milligrams of pollutant per cubic metre of air) at 20°C and 101.3 hPa for non-volatile substances and airborne particles Fibres/m3 for substances that occur as airborne fibres (e.g. asbestos).
There are several reference periods for which OELs may be established (if they are established) that are commonly used. They include: -
TWA: time-weighted average, for a shift average of normally 8 hours daily, in an average weekly working-time of 40 hours" Provisions on how to deal with mixtures are described in the lists.
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU -
-
75
STEL: Short-term exposure limit values measured over a duration of maximum 15 minutes, normally only allowed for a maximum of one hour within the 8hour period C; Ceiling values98 - STELs that must not be exceeded at any time.
Most lists and/or the relevant legislation contain: -
notations for skin provisions on how to deal with mixtures.
Fca: a 4-shift-premise, the basis is 42 hours per week on average for four consecutive weeks. Normally established for substances which are so fest-acting that the level of exposure to them can never be permitted to exceed the limit value.
Country
notations etc
other information
"S" (and sub-groups) for sensitising
Provisions on how to
- ACGIH / German MAK Commission. Currently own system in place
substances "H" for substances, which can penetrate the
calculate the OELs for mixtures
- MAK list: ~ 700 main entries102 plus ~ 540 entries for synonyms of the main entries; = 210 of these
skin easily
Provisions for specific (groups of) substances
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating OELs - MAK;99 TRK100
Austria
101
entries are referring to either Annex II (TRK list) or Annex III (carcinogens) or both Annexes - Yes (2003) Belgium
99
100 101 102
103 104 105
(carcinogens, volatile substances, wood dust etc.)
- VLEP;103 VLB104
A - for substances which release a gas
Provisions on how to
- Principally based on the US ACGIH list of 1993105 and the EU lists of OELs - = 670 entries (no entries with synonyms etc); = 100 entries for carcinogens & mutagens
which is not toxic but reduces the amount of oxygen in the air C - recognised carcinogens or mutagens D - risk of absorption of the substance via
calculate the OELs for mixtures
Maximale Arbeitsplatzkonzentration - Maximum Workplace Concentrations. Technische Richtkonzentrationen -Technical Guidance Concentrations. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Individual substances or group entries either specifying the individual substances within the group entry or like xyz and its salts or xyz compounds or xyz and its compounds. Valeurs limites d'expositionprofesionnelles — professional exposure limit values. Valeurs limites biologiques - biological limit values. Information given by the Belgian member of the SCOEL and the representative of the Belgian Government in the AHG Limit Values.
76 Beyond Limits
Table 3.2 Some common features of OEL terminology in EU 15 country lists
<5
Country
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating OELs
notations etc
- No clear structure for a systematic revision (2003)
other routes than inhalation (via skin, the
other information
eyes or by swallowing) F - exposition occurs in the form of fibres M - risk of irritation or acute intoxication Denmark
"H" for substances known to be capable of uptake via the skin "K"110 for carcinogens "L" for substances that have been assigned a ceiling value
At least every two years (2002) Finland
112
- sitovat raja-arvot; values.114
HTP -arvot;
Organic solvents are given a specific list of limit values111 Provisions on how to calculate the LV for mixtures. Particular provisions for dust
113
biological limit
skin notations ("Skin" or "Iho")
Provisions on how to calculate the limit values
Limit Value — legal status: administrative instructions. Biological Exposure Value. SCOEL (EU), ACGIH (US), MAK (Germany), DECOS (Netherlands) and Nordic Expert Group (NEG). Individual substances or group entries either specifying the individual substances within the group entry or like xyz and its salts or xyz compounds or xyz and its compounds. Krceftfremdkaldende. /fttp://www.arbejdstilsynet.dk/graphics/at/engelsk-pdf/at-vejledninger/gvlisteuk.pdf. Legal status: binding limit values, exeeding them obliges the employers to take immediate actions for lowering the exposure level.
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU
LV;106 BEV107 Own system in place but using criteria documents developed by other scientific bodies108 ~ 700 entries109 plus ~ 340 entries for synonyms of the main entries; ~ 330 entries for organic solvents; ~ 600 entries for carcinogens
8 a
I
I <5
77
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating OELs
notations etc
other information for mixtures
system in place. — ~ 500 substances of which ~ 40 are group entries, specifying about 200 additional individual substances. The binding limit values are identical with those established at EU level.115 - Regularly (at least every two years) -
VLEP; 116 VL;' 17 VR; 118 IBE 119
- Limit Values recommended by the CNAM — Own scientific and committee review system in place. ~ 550 main entries and ~ 90 entries for synonyms of the main entries; = 80 entries
114
Differentiation between CMR120 substances according to the classification in Annex I to Directive 67/548/EEC general or specific allergic risks121 related to the substances are indicated
Reference to the recognised occupational disease related to a substance. Additional information on standards
Haitalliseksi tunnetut pitoisuudet - legal status: orientation values, but have to be taken into account by the employers for risk management measures. Have to be taken into account when assessing exposure of workers.
115
e.g. for asbestos, benzene, venylchloride monomers etc.
116
Valeurs limites d'exposition professionnelle. Valeurs limites admises — indicative, are considered as minimum objectives.
117 118
Valeurs limites reglementaire - mandatory 8established for asbestos, benzene, venylchloride, lead, silica, wood dust and inhalable and respirable dust).
119
Indicateurs biologiques d"exposition.
120
Carcinogenic, mutagenic and toxic to reproduction. Related to the route of exposure.
121
oo Co
- Originally based on US ACGIH list, now own
France
78 Beyond Limits
-J
Country
I
Country
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating
notations etc
other information
OELs identified as CMRs - Revised regularly based on new available data.
for measurement techniques. Provisions on how to calculate the LV for mixtures
Germany
"H" for substances which might be
Special provisions on
- since 1 Jan. 2005: AGW;125 TGW126 - Own system in place, but also using meanwhile OELs established in other countries, the origin127 of which is indicated in the list. MAK-list ~ 670 main entries of which ~ 65 are group entries128, covering more than one substance, about 80 of these entries are TRK. values. BAT-list = 50 entries; CMRs12* « 160 entries and group entries
absorbed via the skin "Y" for substances for which a developmental risk is not to be expected if the Bruit value is respected
how to deal with hydrocarbon mixtures, dieses engine emissions, different types of fibres or dust provisions on how to calculate the OELs for mixtures
Maximale Arbeitsplatzkonzsntrationen (Maximum Workplace Concentrations). Teehnische Richtkonzentrationen (Technical Guidance Concentrations), Biologische Arbeitsstoffiolercmzwerte (Biological Tolerance Value for occupational exposures). Arbeitsplatzgrenzwerte (workplace limit values). Teehnische Qrenzwerte (technical
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU
- Until 31 Dec. 2004: MAK;122 TRK;123 BAT124
8 a
I
I <5
79
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating
notations etc
other information
OELs - AnnuaEy (2004) Greece
- OELs;130BLVs131 - ACGIH. EUlistoflOELVs — ~ 560 substances with indicative OELs — No clear structure for updates
Skin notation
Ireland
- OELVs;132 BOELVs;133 BBLVs134 - Originally based on the US ACGIH list and the UK EH40. Today additional OEL lists form other European Countries + EU. = 800 OELVs 1 BOELV; 1 BBLV
Skin notations and notations for
Provisions on how to
carcinogens, reproductive hazards, mutagens and sensitising agents
calculate the OELs for mixtures
Same as in the ACGIH and the EU lists
No further information
- Bi-annually (2003) Italy
- EU IOELVs; EU BOELVs — Reference in collective agreements to the US ACGIH TLV list; EU Limit Value Lists - Corresponds to the number established at EU/ level - No further information
Occupational Exposure Limit Values. Biological Limit Values. Occupational Exposure Limit Values. Binding Occcupational Exposure Limit Values. Binding Biological Limit Values.
80 Beyond Limits
Country
00
o
Country
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating
notations etc
other information
see German & EU system
ditto
Same as in the ACGIH list
As in the ACGIH list
Skin notations and notations for carcinogens, reproductive hazards, mutagens, and sensitising agents
Provisions on how to calculate the OELs for mixtures. R Phrases according to Directive 67/548/EEC
OELs Luxembourg
- EUIQELVsjEUBQELVs - German MAK and TRK lists; EU LV lists. Corresponds to the number established at EU/level. - No further information
Portugal
- TLVs - Based on the US ACGIH list. — » 630 entries. — Yes (yearly) - Own system in place. ~ 620 main VLA entries (either VLA-EDs or VLA-ECs) of which » 50 are group entries, covering more than one substance - ~ 290 entries or group entries for carcinogenic and mutagenic substances. 35 VLB entries - Yes (2004)
Sweden
- LLVs;
138
CLVs;
STVs
140
Valor Limite Ambiental Exposition Diaria.
136
Valor Limite Ambiental Exposicidn de Corta Duracion. Valor Limite Bioldgico.
138
Level Limit Values.
o
§a
I
Skin notations and notations for
81
Ceiling Limit Values.
O
<5
139
135
137
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU
- VLA-ED; Hi VLA-EC; I36 VLB; 137
Spain
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating
notations etc
OELs - Based on the US ACGIH list now own system in
carcinogens, reproductive hazards, and
place. - = 350 main entries including group entries
other information
<5
sensitising agents
- Yes but not clear what the time schedule is The Netherlands
- MACs;141 OELs - Own system in place
Skin notations, risk-based limit values for carcinogens
— ~ 770 main entries - Regularly United Kingdom142
- WELs143 - Own system in place - Around 100 previous OES deleted. Leaving nearly 400 substances with WELs. — Regular updates
Detailed in Environmental Hygiene Guidance Note EH 40, April 2005
Adequate control of exposure requires employers to apply principles of good practice, ensure the WEL is not exceeded and exposure to substances causing asthma, cancer
Short Term Values. Maximaal Aanvaarde Concentraties - Maximum Allowable Concentration. The UK system was subject to a major review at the time of writing of this book. It resulted in a new framework for OELs that came into effect with revised regulations in 2005. The entries in this table are based on the new system. However details of the previous system and its antecedents may be found in Chapter 4. Workplace Exposure Limit.
82 Beyond Limits
Country
Country
Type, origin, number and frequency of updating OELs
notations etc
other information or damage to genes is reduced as low as is reasonably practicable.
Occupational Exposure Limits in the EU
I I
s
83
Beyond Limits Limits 84 Beyond
PROCEDURES FOR SETTING OELS Table 3.3 provides an overview of the various procedures in place to establish OELs in the EU 15 countries. One interesting point of comparison is the extent to which social partners and other stakeholders are involved when setting national OELs. A more detailed description of the composition and the tasks of the various committees / institutes etc. involved in the development of OELs is provided in Annex IV. Table 3.3 Summary of procedures for setting OELs in EU 15 countries Country 144
Austria
Procedure Limit values are developed and adopted in a three-step procedure involving a scientific expert group, the Central Labour Inspectorate and the Advisory Committee for Workers Protection (Arbeitnehmerschutzbeirat). The scientific expert group evaluates available data in the scientific literature. The Committee takes case-by-case decisions: for example when it has more up-to-date data available than those on which the German MAK values are based or if for example the Nordic countries publish criteria documents justifying lower limit values. This is the place where socio-economic aspects are taken into consideration including technical feasibility and the possible economic consequences for industry. Based on its evaluation, the Committee develops a list of criteria documents (Begriindungen), which the Central Labour Inspectorate (ZentralArbeitsinspektorai) presents to the Advisory Committee for Workers Protection. The list is normally not further discussed in the Committee because the interest groups are also represented in its expert group on OELs. The changes of the OEL values or changes in the content (e.g. in criteria, definition, the text etc.) then undergo a type of legal 'screening' by Section i n in order to make them compatible with other laws and legislation. After having been sent out for the final comments of Social Partners, other interest groups and all other Ministries, the Minister of Economy and Labour
Die Arbeitsinspektion im Blickpunkt— Organisation, Rechte und Pftichien. Http://www.bmwa.gv.at/NR/idonlyres/0FEAA6D4-30FE-4713-8F2160B171119D3C/0/arbig_br.pdf.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 85
publishes them in the Official Gazette, Proposals for changes/amendments/new OELs are submitted by either the Ministiy (Section III) or by social partners and less often by members of the scientific expert group itself. The agenda is prepared by the Central Labour Inspectorate or Zentrales Arbeitsinspektorat (as part of the Ministry and Section IX) which also chairs the meetings. Belgium
Members of the Federal Labour administration prepare modifications to adapt the Belgian list, mostly following changes in the EU. There is no official commission and no direct input either from scientific experts or the social partners.145 Nevertheless there are certain consultative bodies in which employers and workers are amongst those represented.
Denmark146
As a general rule, limit values are set and revised on the basis of scientific evidence (relating both to health aspects and control methods) from the EU (SCOEL), the US (ACGIH, NIOSH, OSHA), Germany (MAK), the Netherlands (DECOS), the Nordic countries, the Nordic Expert Group (NEG) and findings at Danish workplaces, compiled and analysed by the Danish Working Environment Authority. Limit values are set after notice has been given and any objections have been considered. The list of proposed new or revised limits is prepared by the Danish Working Environment Authority. The evidence relating to health aspects is assessed by a scientific quality committee. However, this stage is omitted in the case of proposals based on limit values adopted in the US or Germany or recommendations from the EU. The Danish Working Environment Council's Committee on Limit Values, which consists of representatives of employers* and employees* organisations, then performs a technical/economic evaluation of the limit value levels. Based on this, the Danish Working Environment Council submits a recommendation to the Director General of the Danish Working Environment Authority, who in turn lays down the limit values and publishes them in a list of limit values (Appendix to the Guide to work Environment Act). In the event of disagreement in the Danish Working Environment Council, the Director General lays down the limit value based on the following guidelines: -
In principle, a limit value should not be stricter than in those countries with which Denmark can normally be compared - primarily the
Information given by the Belgian member of SCOEL. Http://www.arbejdstilsYnet.dk/graphics/at/engelsk-pdf/at-vejledninger/gvlisteuk.pdf.
86 Beyond Limits
Nordic countries, but also Germany and the US. -
Information that affected enterprises will incur considerable extra costs as a consequence of the change should be considered together with any uncertainties concerning the medical documentation.
In special cases the Director General of the Danish Working Environment Authority may set limit values without following the general procedure. This applies where there is information concerning a particular risk in using the substances. Finland"7
The Advisory Committee for Occupational Health and Safety on Chemicals together with the Ministry's Occupational Safety and Health Department prepares the list of harmful concentrations. The Committee selects a Sub-Committee of Exposure Limits (HTP- jaos), which does the actual preparation work for setting OELs. Sub-Committee members are from the Ministry, chemical industry, employers' organisations and the trade union movement. The Sub-Committee prepares drafts for recommendations. The process is started by the preparation of a short documentation on the use and chemical-physical properties of the agents and the observed health effects with a specific emphasis on the dose-response relationships. The critical effect is selected and the exposure limit recommended. The documentation is not publicly available, it is delivered only to the Advisory Committee together with the proposed list When drafting MAC values not only adverse health effects but also socioeconomic and technical feasibility factors are taken into consideration. The discussion on HTP values is restricted to adverse health effects and measurement techniques for the substance. During the preparation of the recommendations, standards of other countries including OELs set at European level148 and the reasoning given for these standards are taken into consideration. The Ministry of Social Affairs and Health decides on Occupational Exposure Limits according to the proposal of the Advisory Committee for Occupational Health and Safety of Chemicals.
Information is taken from the website of the Ministry Http://www.vn.fi/stm/english/mdex.htm. SCOEL, Nordic Expert Group, ACGIH, MAK-Komission, DECOS, IPCS Health Criteria, HSE and Swedish limit value documents.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 87
France
Recommendations for Limit Values {Valeurs limites) and their revisions are developed and up-dated by an scientific expert group under the direction of the Ministry in Charge of Work {Groups, scientifique pour la surveillance des atmospheres de travail - Scientific Group for the Surveillance of the Working Atmosphere/Environment) The OELs are based on a review of the international scientific literature and studies (toxicological and epidemiological data) undertaken by the regional authorities. Then the technical and economical feasibility of the proposed health-based OEL is studied mostly by the industry participating in the limit setting and reviewing. The same scientific expert group also elaborates the document dealing with the scientific basis and the principles for the application of Biological Exposure Indicators {Indicateurs biologiques d'exposition - IBE). Some values are also recommended by the National Health Insurance Fund for Salaried Employees (CNAMTS). After having being published by the Ministry, the National Institute of Research and Safety (Institut National de Recherche et de Securite - INSR), publishes regularly consolidated lists of admissible limit values including their definitions and other additional information on standards for measurement techniques, procedures for mixtures etc.
Germany
The following summarises the situation before the new Ordinance on Hazardous Substances came into force (1 January 2005). It is not clear how the system will look in the future but it is assumed that it will in principle meet similar criteria. The Technical Rules for Hazardous Substances are developed and adapted by the Committee on Hazardous Substances {Awsckufifiir Gefahrstoffe - AGS). Within the relevant sub-cormnittee(s), the MAK and BAT recommendations of the MAK Commission are discussed, as well as OELs established by other bodies (e.g. the EU). Based on these discussions, the sub-committee(s) propose(s) MAK and BAT values to the plenary meeting for final approval. TRK values are developed within a specific sub-committee and also forwarded to the plenary meeting for final approval. Both types of recommendations are finally discussed, and may be again changed and approved by the plenary meeting of the Committee for Hazardous Substances. After having been adopted by the plenary meeting of the Committee on Hazardous Substances, the Federal Ministry of Economics and Labour announces the Technical Rules in the Federal Labour Gazette (Bundesarbeitsblatt - BArbBl.).
88 Beyond Limits
See Chapter 5 for further detail.
Greece
The OELs are the products of a compromise reached after considering health, administrative, political and economic issues. There is a two tier system in place to set OELs, comprising a scientific advisory committee and a second level in the form of the National Council for Health and Safety at Work (SYAE) in which stakeholder interests are able to take account of these issues. Negotiations take place within SYAE. SYAE deliberates on all matters pertaining to occupational health and safety and is effectively an institutionalised forum for national consultation: 17 bodies are represented on the Council, The General Directorate of Working Conditions of the Ministry of Employment and Social Protection through its Directorate of Working Conditions has the task of sending the summary information report of the emerging decision as a Presidential Decree (P.D.) and attaching to it a copy of the state journal containing the relevant list of OELs. Copies of the official journal are sent to the social, administrative, economic and scientific bodies participating in and represented in SYAE. See Chapter 6 for further details.
Ireland
The Health and Safety Authority (HSA) is responsible for producing, disseminating and enforcing Occupational Exposure Limits in the Republic of Ireland. The national list, when introduced in 1994, was based on the occupational exposure standards for some 700 chemicals applicable in the United Kingdom (EH 40), with the inclusion of additional chemicals contained in the US (ACGIH) list but not in the UK list. The procedures used in the revision of the list are similar to those used in the establishment of the first list in 1994. The scientific staff of the HSA prepare the initial draft list, it is then placed before the Authority's Dangerous Substances Advisory Committee (DSAC). Following discussion by an expert subgroup of the DSAC and consequent approval by the full DSAC the list is submitted to the Legislation and Guidance subcommittee of the Board of the Authority and thence to the tripartite Board for further consultation. Following this, the Board recommends the revised Code of Practice to the Minister for Enterprise and Employment for written consent, in accordance with section 30 (4) of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act, 1989 Periodic revisions are done on a biennial basis. The approach to revision of the Code of Practice has been to consider recent changes in OELs in both the
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 89
US and the UK and also in other European countries, with a view to amending the national list in parallel. Revision also takes account of those OELs that have been harmonised at European Community level via a European Directive (see above) Italy
In Italy, no national system exists for establishing OELs. Legislation limiting exposure to hazardous chemicals generally comes in the form of decrees by the Italian Government or the Ministries of Health and Labour.14* In addition, TLVs of the ACGIH have sometimes been included in sectoral collective agreements between trade unions and employers' organisations.150 In Italian law such agreements have a legal status. Until recently there was no national committee/advisory board or other regulatory body dealing exclusively with the establishment of OELs. The only (historical) example of such a body existed in 1975, when the former ENPI (Ente Nazionale Prevenzione Infortuni - National Agency for Prevention of Accidents at Work) issued a provisional list of recommended OELs, which was never approved at national level. Although historically there was no specialised body at national level dealing exclusively with OELs, a number of committees and bodies existed that dealt with H&S issues in general or including OELs. Some of them are multi-partite bodies. The most important ones are: -
The National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health {Istituto Superioreper la Prevenzione e la Sicurezza del Lavoro - ISPESL)
-
The National Institute of Health (Istituto Superiore di Sanita - ISS)
-
The National Advisory Committee on Toxicology (Commissione consultiva tossicologica nazionale)
-
The National Institute of Insurance against Accidents at Work (Instituto Nazionale per L'Assicurazione contra gli Infortuni sul Lavoro -ENTAIL)
-
The Italian Institute of Social Medicine (Istituto Italiano di Medicina Sociale -HMS)
-
The Permanent Advisory Committee for Accidents Prevention and Occupational Hygiene {Commissione consultiva permanente per la prevenzione degli infortuni e Vigiene del lavoro).
Implementing the EU Chemical Agents Directive and the 1OELVDirective —
Information given by the ISPES. Information given by members of the trade unions, in Italy and the TUTB and an epidemiologist from the University of Turin.
90 Beyond Limits
In order to implement the transposition of the EU Chemical Agents Directive and the IOELV Directive made under it, several new committees and working groups have been set up. One is composed of nominees of the various ministries and is responsible for implementation of indicative values in the IOELV Directive. The Ministries of Labour and of Industry have defined the need for a Working Group, with membership of about 25 persons representing wide ranging interests, in order to assist with guidance on the definition of risk. It is particularly charged with dealing with the needs of small enterprises. At the same time there is a committee with regional representation that is working on the same issue. See Chapter 7 for further details. Luxembourg
No specific committee (scientific or other) exists to discuss limit values at the national level but Social Partners and other interest groups are consulted during the general procedure of proposing and adopting legislation in Luxembourg,
Portugal
There is no special body officially involved in the development of OELs at national level. Consultation of Social Partners and other interest groups takes place in Portugal via the Economic and Social Council {Conselho Economico e Social - CES). Within the CES, the Permanent Commission of Social Consultation (Comissao Permananete de Cancertacao Social) deals with topics related to H&S. A consultation procedure for legislation in the pipeline takes place regularly via a bulletin of the Ministry,151 which is published four times a month and which gives all interest groups the possibility to respond with comments.
Spain152
Since 1998, limit values have been developed and published by the National Institute of Safety and Hygiene at Work (Institute) National de Seguridad e Higiene en el Trabqjo — INSHT) as reference values. They are approved by the National Commission of Security and Health at Work (Comision National de Seguridady Salud en el Trabajo).
)53154
Sweden135
Since 1978 the procedure of setting standards (OELs) in Sweden has been
Boletim do Trabaiko e Emprego BTE; http://www.dgeUnts.go¥.pt/avisos_lsem_02.hta. http://www.prevenciona.cara/descargas/toxicos/limites_exposicion.doc. http://www.cgtesAegislacion/textos/Limites-Exposicioii-Profesional-Agentes-Quimicos.pdf. http://www.mtas.es/mshtf en/index_en.htm.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 91
structured in a multi-step manner. There is a separation of the scientific (risk identification and risk estimation) from the political issues (risk evaluation and risk aceeptance).Two working groups are involved in the process, the Criteria Group and the Regulation Group. The task of the Criteria Group is to collect and evaluate the available information on substances that the Regulation Group selects for their consideration. The findings of the Criteria Group are summarised in a consensus report published in both Swedish and English. The Criteria Group bases its conclusions on the evidence available in the scientific literature and has no resources for commissioning new epidemiological or experimental studies. The Criteria Group does not propose an OEL or a numerical limit value. Instead these are proposed by the Regulation Group, within the National Board of Occupational Safety and Health and with representatives from the NBOSH and from the employees' and employers' confederation. The Regulation Group makes use of the consensus report and performs a costbenefit analysis, furthermore, technical feasibility criteria are taken into consideration and an analysis of consequences is discussed. Final decisions are made by the Board of Directors of the NBOSH.
The Netherlands1*
See Chapter 9 for further details. There are two main procedures for establishing an OEL in the Netherlands. 1. Procedure for establishing a statutory OEL The procedure has three stages: A group of independent experts (currently the Dutch Health Council Expert Committee on Occupational Standards, or Commissie WGD) makes a recommendation for an OEL for a given substance, based on toxicological considerations. A tripartite committee (the OEL Subcommittee) then considers this recommendation in the light of its socioeconomic and technical consequences and the practical feasibility of introducing it as an OEL, and makes a recommendation to the Minister of Social Affairs and Employment. The Minister may then decide to set the
The role of human neurobehavioural tests in regulatory activity on chemicals. - A Swedish view on the interpretation of tests and their application to the regulation of chemicals; Christer Edling MD,PhD Department of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, University Hospital, S-851 85 Uppsala, Sweden, Per Lundberg, PhD Department of Toxicology, National Institute for Working Life, S-171 84 Solna, Sweden. http://www.ser jil/default.asp?desc=en_oel_toel_proc.
92 Beyond Limits
proposed limit as the statutory OEL on the basis of both recommendations. Since 2002, OELs established by the SCOEL have been incorporated into the Dutch procedure for setting statutory OELs. 2. Procedure for establishing an administrative OEL The procedure for establishing an administrative OEL has two stages: The OEL Subcommittee selects for assessment an OEL currently in use in a foreign country. After satisfying itself that the OEL is appropriate and can be feasibly implemented in the Netherlands, the OEL Subcommittee may then recommend to the Minister that it be adopted as an OEL in the Netherlands. On the basis of the OEL Subcommittee's recommendation, the Minister may then decide to approve this foreign OEL as an administrative OEL for the substance. The Dutch Health Council Expert Committee on Occupational Standards is not involved in setting an administrative OEL. In choosing foreign OELs for assessment, the OEL Subcommittee draws primarily on the OEL lists of Germany, Sweden and the UK, as the procedures for setting OELs in these countries are very similar to the procedure used in the Netherlands. In assessing a proposed (statutory or administrative) OEL, the Subcommittee first assigns the proposed OEL to a particular Working Programme, according to its country of origin. The OEL Subcommittee then seeks the involvement of relevant groups (e.g., employers' and employees' organisations, trade associations, Occupational Health & Safety Services and other organisations). Trade associations and Occupational Health & Safety Services are specifically invited to register an interest in contributing to a feasibility study concerning the implementation of proposed (statutory or administrative) OELs, in order to ensure that, before it is adopted, any proposed OEL can realistically be implemented in practice. The Subcommittee then invites industrial sector organisations to submit information on the feasibility of implementing the proposed (statutory or administrative) OEL. If the Subcommittee receives no information or reports, it assumes that the proposed OEL is acceptable and its implementation will be possible. The Subcommittee then recommends to the Minister that the proposed (statutory or administrative) OEL should be adopted. See Chapter 8 for further details
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 93
United Kingdom
The UK. introduced a new framework for OELs in 2005. The two limit level system (occupational exposure standards - OES and maximum exposure limits - MEL) of the previous decade was replaced with a single limit (Workplace Exposure Limit -WEL) system in a revised legislative framework for chemical hazards. Under the old system, if the HSE believed a substance merited an OEL, and there was no relevant EU limit, it supplied information on a substance to the Working Group for the Assessment of Toxic Chemicals (WATCH), a sub-committee of the HSC's tripartite Advisory Committee on Toxic Substances (ACTS): -
-
if WATCH considered the substance satisfied the OES criteria, it recommended an OES (8-hour TWA or 15-minute short-term limit), to ACTS if ACTS agreed to the recommendation, the proposals were published in a consultation document following consultation and HSC agreement, the OES was published in the annual guidance note on OELs (EH40).
If WATCH did not recommend an OES, it referred the substance back to ACTS, normally for setting a MEL (because it involved socio-economic judgements, balancing risk to health against the cost and effort of reducing exposure). If ACTS agreed, the HSE issued a Chemical Hazard Alert Notice (CHAN) as an interim measure to inform industry of the serious health risks associated with the use of the substance. If a MEL was to be set, the HSE collected information on good occupational hygiene practice for the use of the substance and made proposals to ACTS for the MEL, accompanied by a regulatory impact assessment. The process was then the same for an OES. Where ACTS rejected an MEL, employers were still expected to establish appropriate control regimes based on the CHAN. Where an EU OEL had to be transposed, the Working Group on European Exposure Limits (WEELS) would take account of the scientific evaluation of the SCOEL. WEELS considered whether an OES or a MEL was appropriate, whether any existing limit complied with the EU limit and whether there were reasons to recommend a substantially different limit. If a new or revised OEL was required, WEELS made recommendations to ACTS. WEELS could also recommend to ACTS the referral of a substance to WATCH for a scientific opinion. The new system has transferred all previous MELs and all but 102 of existing
94 Beyond Beyond Limits Limits 94
OES to WELs. Procedures for setting new WELs are likely to be essentially the same as those involved in setting previous MELs. See Chapter 4 for further details.
ENFORCEMENT & SURVEILLANCE OF COMPLIANCE WITH OELS IN EU15 COUNTRIES All countries in Europe have the legal basis for enforcement and surveillance procedures. In each case regulatory authorities for health and safety are (at least theoretically) engaged with securing compliance with the standards set by OELs and in monitoring their role in risk assessment anrol of chemical hazards. Breach of requirements relating to binding values is either a criminal or administrative offence (or both) depending on the national regulatory system and the seriousness of the breach. Penalties are most commonly fines, the levels of which are defined usually in the relevant legislation.
AUSTRIA Enforcement Authority:
Central Labour Inspectorate (Zentral Arbeitsinspektorat) and its departments
Enforcement powers. The legal basis of the Labour inspectorate's powers is found in the Law on Labour Inspection of 1993 (Arbeitsinspektionsgesetz) - ArbIG, BGB1 Nr. 27 / 1993. There are 19 regional Labour Inspectorates and 1 Labour Inspectorate for building works directly subordinated to the Central Labour Inspectorate. It employs about 550 persons in total of which about 300 are workplace labour inspectors. They look after about 210,000 work places and monitor compliance with safety regulations for about 2.4 million employees. Most of the Labour Inspectorates have a technical department and a safety department to protect various groups (pregnant women, young people etc.). Each Labour Inspectorate has a special medical service. The Central Labour Inspectorate does not perform measurements on its own, but depending on results of the visits of the local labour inspectors, it asks the Central
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 95 Office for Accidents and Occupational Diseases157 (of the Federal Accident Insurance Institution) to perform measurements.158 The results of these measurements are kept at the local offices of the Labour Inspectorate but are not publicly available because they are the result of an official legal procedure. In some cases (e.g. for wood dust, solvents or isdcyanates), the Central Office performs - within the framework of research projects - systematic measurements in order to get an overview of a specific type of exposure. The results of these research projects are published as technical reports and are publicly available. Most of the Labour Inspectorates have a technical department and a safety department to protect various groups (pregnant women, young people etc.).
BELGIUM 159 Enforcement Authority:
The Labour Inspectorate Q'lnspection du Travail) is responsible for monitoring and enforcing the H&S legislation including that on OELs
Enforcement powers. Under Lot du 16 novembre 1972 concernant Vinspection du travail au plan national et la Convention O.I.T. n° 81 au niveau international. The technical inspection section of the Labour Inspectorate is responsible for safety surveillance whilst the medical section monitors health. Visits should be performed (in general) once a year in each enterprise although special visils are made if there is a request, a complaint or a particular incident which causes concern. The ordinary visit consists of a general check of the application of the laws and regulations in the company. The shortcomings are registered and kept in a record. The purpose of these general visits is to check the general performance of a company with respect to occupational health and safety obligations. The procedure and the measures taken during a special visit depend mainly on the reason for this special visit. If the special visit takes place because of a complaint, it is important to notice the person behind the complaint remains anonymous. Special visits are not announced and the inspector can take all the measures within his/her competence he/she thinks are necessary (including measurements etc.).
Bmqnstelleftir Unfall- und Berufskrankheitenbek&npfiing - HUB. AllgEtneine UnfallversicherungsanstaU. Http://www.meta,fgov.be/pa/paa/ftamesetftiOO.htm.
96 96 Beyond Beyond Limits Limits Based on the results of the visit, all possible measures (from simple information up to the issue of penalties) can be performed.
DENMARK 160 Enforcement Authority:
The Danish Working Environment Authority (WEA) supervises whether Acts and rules in the field of safety and health at work are observed, inter alia through inspection visits and guidance of the enterprises and their safety organisations.
Enforcement powers. The Working Environment Authority applies, in particular, six methods of inspection: — Screening, which is a quick review of the working environment at the enterprise with a view to assessing whether it should be subjected to adapted inspection. - Adapted inspection, in which the Danish Working Environment Authority targets its resources on the enterprises which have the most hazardous working environment conditions. - Detailed inspection takes the form of inspection of problems or problem areas, including examination of work-related accidents, diseases and ailments. — Supplier inspection takes the form of inspection of safety and health for the users of one or more of the suppliers' products. — Project and counselling inspection, includes inspection of the rights and duties of the project and counselling parties in compliance with the Danish Working Environment Act. - Special inspection includes inspection of lifts, boilers, containers, pipeline systems, natural gas plants, risk enterprises and genetics laboratories. Manufacturing controls are performed in the case of boilers for the purpose of export and import. The WEA has the power to issue administrative fines in the case of clear violations of the substantive rules of the Working Environment Act. In cases of extreme danger, the WEA may also order the work to be suspended.
http://www.at.dk/swl2159.a8p.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 97 The different forms of sanctions, i.e. improvement notices, legal charges, administrative fines and guidelines - will depend on both the enterprise's actual working environment standards and on its own efforts. Complaints against decisions made in compliance with the working environment Act by the WEA may be brought before a working environment appeal board. These boards include representatives of the social partners. The inspection of enterprises is integrated into four regional Inspection Centres, each with approximately 100 employees. The inspectors of the local units of the Work Environment Service are responsible for carrying out inspection.
FINLAND"' Enforcement Authority
The Occupational Safety and Health Inspectorates of Finland, supervised by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health, are the enforcing authorities for occupational safety and health.
Enforcement powers. The powers given to the OHS inspectors and OHS Districts are defined in the Labour Inspection Act (1973) - Laki tydsuojelun valvotmasta ja muutoksenhausta tyosuojeluasiaoksa, Act of 16.2.1973/171. The Inspectorates give instructions and advice on applying regulations concerning working conditions, employment and equality and supervise that they are observed in workplaces. The Occupational Safety and Health Inspectorates also give employees advice on matters concerning occupational safety and health and employment. The occupational safety and health inspector has the right to visit all workplaces and other places under supervision and to look at the necessary documents as regards occupational safety and health enforcement. The Occupational Safety and Health Inspectorates can, if necessary, oblige the employer to redress defects in occupational safety and health in the workplace. The inspector is obligated to secrecy concerning business secrets and employees' health and the possible inspection requests made from the workplace.
http://www.dOHSnet.fi/hallinto/english/piirit/default.htm.
98 Beyond Limits The district authorities for occupational safety and health carry out the practical supervision and other activities in the field of OHS. The country is divided into eleven OHS districts. Each District has one central office and several local offices. The Occupational Safety and Health Inspectorates employ approximately 460 people; about 360 of these do field surveys at workplaces. There are experts in different professional areas (engineering, chemistry, law, construction engineering, nursing). Normally the OHS Districts are organised into group structures. Each group has responsibility for one or more sectors of industry and services. Inspectors are specialised in those industries they have been assigned. The most important target of OHS inspection visits in the past was to observe any defects in working conditions, to eliminate hazards in the working environment and, by that means, to reduce accidents and work-related diseases. Nowadays the inspection methods are more sophisticated. The central task of the OHS District is to monitor that the provisions of OHS legislation are observed, and to support and encourage the development of OHS management systems at working places. Guidance is given to both employers and employees. OHS inspectors and OHS Districts have the power to: -
-
-
issue an inspection protocol or improvement notice. The notice identifies the law that is broken, describes the nature of the deficiency, may suggest how the deficiency can be rectified (although this is not necessary), and stipulates the time limit by which the employer must respond to the OHS District indicating the action he or she has taken issue a legally binding enforcement notice under the authority of the Head of the District if the inspection protocol has not had the desired effect. The notice stipulates a time limit by which the required work must be completed and may, although this is not obligatory, set a fine, which must be paid if the deadline is not met. The employer has the right of appeal to the regional Administrative Court. issue a prohibition notice in cases where an inspector believes there is an imminent risk to life or health (about 30-40 per year). The notice comes into force immediately. The initiating inspector submits a copy of the notice to the Head of the District, who decides whether to support the notice or rescind it. The employer again has the right to appeal to the Administrative Court. Should the employer not comply with the notice, the matter is put in the hands of the police, who have the powers necessary to ensure that compliance is achieved. This procedure is used rarely.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 99
In cases of wilful intent or negligence, and normally following an accident, the inspector may draw up a report for the public prosecutor who will initiate an investigation by the police (about 300 are initiated per year). Any prosecution which follows may lead to the offender being fined or sent to prison. The prosecution will be taken against an individual or individuals within the enterprise since there is no possibility in the law for proceedings to be taken against the company itself. According to the senior civil servant of the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health interviewed, "The district offices of the labour protection inspection are responsible for the enforcing the limit values. The inspectors seldom study the compliance with the OELs as a separate issue from other issues. I do not remember a case here [in which] the sole excess of an OEL would have been the[exclusive] reason for enforcement measures by the authority. The air concentration values in excess of the OELs are usually used as evidence of failure of the safety programme of the employer".
FRANCE 1 6 2
m
Enforcement Authorities
The Labour Inspectorate (/ 'Inspection du Travail) of the Ministry of Labour is responsible for the surveillance and enforcement of the legislation. In addition, the organisations for social security exert, within the framework of their function as insurance companies, a system of specific control and incentives to ensure the application of the legislation at enterprise level.
Enforcement powers. Measures on hygiene, safety and working conditions and on the functioning of workers' representation on health and safety are part of the Labour Code which is the main instrument on which the Labour Inspectorate relies to perform its tasks. With two complementary external intervention systems at enterprise level with respect to surveillance and enforcement of legislation in the field of health and safety and the prevention of occupational risks, the French system is a dual one. There is, on the one hand, the Labour Inspectorate as part of the Ministry of Labour, and on the other
http://www.sante-securite.fravail.gouv.fr/pdf/InspectioiiTravailFrance2002.pdf. http://www.8ante-aecurite.travail.gouv.fr/systeme/institations.html, http://fr.OHSa.eu.int/publications/acteurs.stm. http://www.inrs.fr/actualites/chsctl .htm.
100 Beyond Limits 100 hand are the institutions of the social security system (regional and national) and their surveillance systems. Both the Labour Inspectorate and the surveillance and enforcement bodies of the social security organisations not only control the application of the labour law but also advise the companies in areas related to H&S. Labour inspectors have the right to enter enterprises at any time. They must be given access to documents they need and can perform measurements and take samples. If they register infringements of regulations, they may: -
remind the employer of his obligations issue improvement or enforcement notices impose fines in urgent cases, apply for a provisional legal order at court to stop the work.
The difference between the two types of French limit values, their enforcement, and the possibilities labour inspectors have becomes clear when looking at the power of the Labour Inspectorate with respect to these two OELs.164 Air quality control measurements by the labour inspectors are only possible for substances for which a binding limit value exists, which are those for dust/fibres of asbestos, lead, benzene, vinyl chloride monomers etc. For substances for which indicative limit values have been adopted and published, the order of 9 October 1987 does not allow the labour inspectors to enforce these OELs directly by issuing improvement or enforcement orders. The nature of these limit values ('indicative/guidance') does not permit prescription of exact measures to 'enforce' them. The only possibility to 'enforce' them is via indirect sanctions on failures of the ventilation system and similar offences. The Labour Inspectorate monitoring function has been extended to include compliance with provisions deriving from collective agreements. In addition to this, it also performs advisory and information functions, has responsibilities in the settlement of disputes and possesses certain decision-making powers. It may take part in the meetings of the CHSCT.16S At enterprise and establishment level, the labour inspector is the official who has direct dealings with enterprise managers, unions and workforce representatives and
http://www.inrs.fr/dossiers/ed773.pdf. Le Comiti d'hygiine, de sicurtte et des conditions de travail - the OHS advisory committee of management and workers at enterprise level.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 101 employees. They are supported by other experts like the occupational physician and the safety engineers) who are part of the OHS system the employer has to establish. The National Health Insurance (Caisse National d'Assurance Maladie - CNAM).1* lm 168 Since 1945, CNAM, under the supervision of the Ministry of Health, has been responsible for the compensation of industrial accidents and the administration of occupational risks and occupational diseases. Its mission is also to prevent occupational accidents and occupational diseases by technical and financial means. CNAM administers the national fund for prevention which is based on contributions levied from enterprises. The prevention service and its regional offices and services is financed from this fund, as well as the work of the INRS, the National Institute of Research and Safety. At regional level,169 its inspectors and consulting engineers have the same access and inquiry right as the national labour inspectors have. They perform risk assessments and give advice on prevention and protection measures in consultation and co-operation with the Committee for Hygiene, Security and Working Conditions - CHSCT. They can also refer to specialised laboratories.' If an employer fails to follow the advice given, the inspectors have the right to take all the necessary measures they consider justifiable under the circumstances and, if necessary, they can issue improvement or enforcement notices. CRAM is able to impose higher contributions on whole sectors or individual enterprises based on health and safety performance outcomes such as raised injury rates. Reductions in contributions reflecting improved health and safety performance are also possible. CRAM organises information and training courses for employers and employees, campaigns to tackle specific problems and publishes journals and brochures. The data about occupational injuries, accidents and diseases as well as all other data gathered and collected during the visits are taken into consideration when designing policy priorities in the field of occupational health and safety at ministerial level.
http://www.crain-bfc.fr/preventioii/page-preventioii.htni. http://machines-dangereuses.drt.travail.gouv.fr/ct5/rainitra.htm. http://www.sante-securite.travail.gouv.fr/systeme/ministere.html. CRAM'— Caisse regional d'assurance maladie.
102 Beyond Limits 102 GERMANY Enforcement Authorities
Trade Supervisory Offices (Gewerbeaufsichtsamter) or the Regional Offices for Industrial Safety (Landesdmter fiir Arbeitsschutz) of the Lander Technical Inspection Service (Technischer Aufsichtsdienst) of the Berufsgenossenschaften
Enforcement powers. The legal basis for inspection is found in the Industrial Code (Gewerbeordnung (GewO)) in der Fassung der Bekanntmachung vom 22. Februar 1999 (BGBl. I S. 202). The inspectors have the same powers as the local police for the execution of their duties. In cases of lack or violation of laws and regulations, inspectors can issue orders and make use of the compulsory measures/sanctions they are entitled to use according to the relevant State laws. Normally this covers the remedy of the situation at the expense of the employer or the establishment and/or the setting of fines. Additionally, they can order the suspension/cessation of parts or the whole of the production process or initiate ongoing penalties.
Powers of the Technical Inspection Service. The institutions for statutory accident insurance and prevention and their Technical Inspection Service are also responsible for the surveillance of the Hazardous Substances Regulation and its Technical Rules. Both surveillance authorities also offer special support for small and medium sized enterprises with respect to training and measurement techniques. See Chapter 5 for further details.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 103 GREECE Enforcement Authority
Greek Labour Inspectorate (SEPE). Legal basis. Presidential Decree 136/99
Enforcement powers. The SEPE is organised on the basis of a central service and regional services SEPE Occupational Risk Prevention Centres and local departments when in need of extra expert assistance in enforcing the OELs have access to the scientific and technical support of the Centre of Health and Safety at Work (KYAE). The basic objective of the Labour Inspectorate is to monitor the implementation of the provisions of labour legislation in respect of terms and conditions of employment (such as working time limits and pay); the legality of employment; the investigation of workers' social insurance coverage as well as workers' health and safety conditions. The labour inspector may impose sanctions on any employer, manufacturer, producer, importer or supplier who infringes the provisions of the health and safety laws or the provisions of the presidential decrees or ministerial decisions issued under the terms of these laws, which ranges from: -
advice improvement notices administrative sanctions penal sanctions
The Minister of Labour may impose the following sanctions, after receiving a reasoned report from the labour inspector: -
temporary cessation of the operations of the particular production process or section or of the entire undertaking for a period of more than three days. complete cessation of the operations of the particular production process or section or the entire undertaking
Imprisonment or a fine of at least €300 shall punish any employer, manufacturer, producer, importer or supplier who wilfully violates the Act or the rules promulgated by
104 Beyond Limits 104 it. Offences committed due to negligence (on conviction) carry the full sanction of a fine or a prison sentence not exceeding one year. See Chapter 6 for further details.
IRELAND Enforcement Authority
The HSA is responsible for producing, disseminating and enforcing Occupational Exposure Limits in the Republic of Ireland. The Chemical Agents Regulations and the related OELs are enforced by the workplace inspectors employed by the HSA
Enforcement powers. Inspector may: -
-
-
In addition to rights of entry, inspection and sampling an
issue an Improvement Direction, to which an employer is required to respond with an Improvement Plan in relation to activities to which the inspector considers may involve risk to safety or health of persons issue an Improvement Notice stating his opinion that an employer has broken a provision of an Act or Regulation issue a Prohibition Notice in relation to an activity, which the inspector is of the opinion has been, or is likely to be, a risk of serious personal injury to persons at work. This might require an immediate stoppage of work in certain cases recommend the initiation of prosecutions give directions or instructions.
It should be noted that the above list is non-exhaustive and powers of inspectors are listed in no particular order. In certain circumstances, the Authority may apply under Section 39 of the 1989 Act to the High Court for an Order in relation to certain activities. This can be obtained on an ex parte basis, that is, without notice to the employer concerned. These orders are usually obtained where physical hazards and significant deficiencies in health and safety management cause the Authority to consider the risk to persons to be very serious.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 105 ITALY Enforcement Authorities
Labour Inspectorate (Ispettorato del Lavoro) Local Health Agencies (L'unita sanitaria locale)
Enforcement powers. Between 1955 and 1978 the Labour Inspectorate {Ispettorato del Lavoro) as an office of the Ministry of Labour, decentralised to regional and provincial level, was the main body responsible for monitoring the application of labour legislation and collective agreements and the functioning of social insurance, welfare and health arrangements. In 1978, the Health Services Act (Law 833/78) instituted the National Health Service structured in Local Health Agencies (L'unita sanitaria locale - USL) at regional level under the Ministry of Health, In each USL, among the traditional health services (Aziende sanitarie locali - ASL) a unit for Occupational Health and Safety (Servizio di Prevenzione e Sicurezza negli Ambient! di Lavoro - PSAL) was established. The law gave some of the powers of the Labour Inspectorate to the PSAL. They were provided with regulatory powers on health and safety and enabled them to use these powers in addition to their preventive advisory activities. In the context of the implementation of the EU Framework Directive 89391/EEC a more significant inspection role for the Labour Inspectorate was introduced in the late 1990s. The decree DPCM 14.10.1997 n.4121™ identified higher risk sectors where control can be undertaken jointly by Labour Inspectorate and the prevention service of the USL. PSAL activities include: -
sectoral prevention plans controls on OHS legislation controls on medical surveillance carried out by the 'Competent Doctor' of the company examining plans for the removal of asbestos preventive assessment of new activities, plants and work-sites criminal investigations on work accidents and occupational diseases providing information to workers on control activities
Decreto del Presidente del Consiglio del Mlnistri, Reingresso delVispettorato del Lavoro nett'attivita di vigilanza; http://www.626.cisl.if/doconlJne/Legislazione/Leggi%20 Decreti/Dec%20pres%20consiglio%20ministri.htm.
106 Beyond Limits 106 — giving information and training on legislation and authority policies to workers, trade unionists, employers and experts. See Chapter 7 for further details.
LUXEMBOURG™ Enforcement Authority
With the reorganisation of the Labour and Mines Inspectorate in 1974, it (L'Inspection du Travail et des Mines - ITM) was given responsibility for ensuring the implementation of all legislation relating to the working conditions and protection of all employees subject to a contract of employment, except those in the public service.
Enforcement powers. ITM has responsibility for many other matters apart from health and safety. Its inspectors are empowered to: — issue an order requiring rectification of faults caused by a failure to comply with the requirements of the relevant legislation within a given time period — issue an order requiring immediate action when there is an imminent threat to the health and safety of an employee — issue an order requiring an installation to be inspected within a time limit set by the inspector by a specialist body approved by the Minister of Labour. The cost of inspection falls to the employer. The Inspectorate has close co-operation and collaboration with other organisations and government departments which also have an interest in the subject of health and safety at work. These are: — Association d'Assurance contre les Accidents (AAA)
http://www.itm.etat.lu/#sec_au_travail.
107 Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 107 The Ministry of Health, particularly with a small group of doctors whose interest lies in occupational medicine and the problems of health and hygiene at work The Ministry of Public Affairs which has a small Inspectorate with the responsibility of overseeing the safety of employees in the public sector including those at work in the health service and education Approved technical organisations - organismes agrees - appointed by the Minister of Labour to carry out inspections and surveys in their designated areas of competence The Customs Service whose officers are increasingly being used to assist the Labour Inspectorate in its work The Consultative Committee for Labour Inspection.
PORTUGAL 172
m
Enforcement Authority
The Labour Inspectorate {Inspecgao Geral do Trabalho IGT) is responsible for the surveillance and enforcement of H&S regulations.
Enforcement powers. The IGT is a department directly under the Ministry of Employment but endowed with administrative autonomy, possessing powers to ensure compliance with legal provisions on working conditions and the system of employee protection at work and during unemployment. Its inspectors have the requisite powers and may call on the intervention of other authorities such as the police where necessary. Structurally, it comprises both central and peripheral offices, including regional services and co-ordinating centres. Its activities include education and guidance, enforcement and inspection. It may also dictate how contraventions should be rectified, as well as any changes necessary to ensure strict application of the legal provisions on health and safely at work and including immediate measures in cases where the life, health or safety of employees is in imminent danger.
172
™
http://www.idict.gov.pt/desteques/igt_dne/igthtm. Decreto-Lein."219/93, de 16 deJunho.
108 Beyond Limits 108 SPAIN Enforcement Authority
Monitoring and enforcement of the legislation is performed by the Labour Inspectorate
Enforcement powers. Labour Inspectors have rights of access to workplaces and to certain information kept by the enterprise and can issue official notifications (of infringement, settlement, etc.) and propose administrative or penal sanctions for violations of social legislation Administrative offences, which are subject to sanctions imposed at the proposal of the Labour Inspectorate, are covered mainly by the Labour Offences and Sanctions Act, first implemented in 1988,"'' the Workers' Statute'" and the Prevention of Occupational Hazards A c t . m The 1988 Act describes various violations of labour legislation (particularly as regards work, health and safety, employment and social security) and categorises them as minor, serious or very serious offences. The same Act states that administrative sanctions may include the imposition of fines of varying magnitude and even temporary or permanent closure of the workplace. Offences which have greater social impact are categorized as criminal labour offences in the Penal Code and are subject to penal sanctions. They perform their functions by visiting enterprises or workplaces; they are also officially empowered to institute legal proceedings and to act as mediators or conciliators in industrial and legal disputes.
Ley8/1988de 7 de abril (B.O.E. 15-04-1988), sobre infracciones y tantiemes en el Orden Social; Botetin. Oficlal del Estado de 15/04/19881 http://www.ccoo.es/legislacion/leyorden.litm. Estatuto de las Trabajadores, Real decreto Legislativo 1/1995 de 24 marza. http://www.satse.es/juridico/e_trabajo/estrindi.htm. http://noticias.juridioas.com/base_datos/Labaral/131-1995.html.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 109 SWEDEN 1 7 7 Enforcement Authority
The Work Environment Inspectorate within the Swedish Work Environment Authority (SWEA) is responsible for enforcement of the exposure limits.
Eenforcement powers. Until 2001 the Health and Safety Agency consisted of the central Occupational Health and Safety Board and regional Labour Inspectorates. The Labour Inspectorate had been set up as long ago as 1890 in connection with the adoption of the 1889 Act on Protection against Occupational Risk in Private Industry, and was divided into 10 Labour Inspectorate districts in 2000, Since the amalgamation of the Board and the Inspectorates in 2001 to form the Work Environment Agency, the Inspectorates have ceased to exist as independent authorities. However, they are now local bodies of the Agency and called lokal arbetsmiljoinspektion (Local Work Environment Inspectorates). Within the SWEA, the ten districts of the Work Environment Inspectorate supervise employers' compliance with the requirements laid down in the Work Environment Act and in the Provisions which are issued. This supervision normally takes the form of inspection. In the course of inspection the working environment is most often assessed in a holistic perspective relating to the hazards of the working environment (physical, mental and social hazards) but there are instances of inspection focusing on a single risk (e.g. a particular type of task). In the selection of workplaces for inspection, priority is given to those presenting the greatest risk of ill-health and accidents. Usually the visit is announced in advance by a phone call or letter but the inspector is entitled to come unannounced. Procedure varies, depending on the branch of activity concerned, the size of the organization and other matters. In one undertaking, detailed inspection may be the most important part, in another undertaking systematic work environment management may command most attention. The inspection can also include market control, (e.g. of machinery). The safety delegate must normally be present during the inspection. The inspector gives an appraisal of the working environment and any deficiencies which have been observed. If attention has been
http://www.av.se/english/Files/h367eng.pdf.
110 Beyond Limits 110 drawn to any deficiencies of the working environment, these will also be described in writing, in what is termed an inspection notice. In the inspection notice the employer is given a time limit to report how the work environment deficiencies which have been described have been dealt with or what plans exist for dealing with them. The inspection notice is not a formal decision by the authority but an appeal to the employer to take the measures which work environment legislation requires. The inspection notice cannot be appealed against. If the employer does not rectify the deficiencies mentioned in the inspection notice, the SWEA can issue an injunction or prohibition, an order to remedy the deficiencies or prohibit a certain handling or other operation. The SWEA can also issue an injunction or prohibition of this kind under penalty of a fine. An injunction or prohibition is a formal decision made by the authority and can be appealed against. The record of decision gives the time limit for appeal and indicates where the appeal can be submitted. See Chapter 9 for further details.
T H E NETHERLANDS1™ Enforcement Authority
The Labour Inspectorate, as part of the Ministry, is responsible for surveying and enforcing the OELs.
Enforcement powers. In order to monitor compliance with the Working Conditions Act, the Inspectorate visits premises for inspection purposes, with or without prior announcement. Inspectors may also be requested to make such a visit by a trade union, or the workers' representatives within an enterprise. In most cases, the Labour Inspectorate will first summon the employer to comply with the obligations (eis tot naleving) before imposing an administrative fine. Only in severe violations of the obligations of the Working Conditions Act, will the Labour Inspectorate immediately impose an administrative fine. With respect to specific violations of the obligations as inserted in the Working Conditions Act, the Labour Inspectorate can impose an administrative fine, for example, if the employer (with the support of the Arbodienst) has not made an inventory of the dangerous substances or does not have a working conditions policy. It is empowered to detect contraventions of the law and to draw up
http://www.rninszw.nl/Doci3menten/lTxfonnatie/Arbo/arbeidsinspec/arbeidsinspec.htm.
OELs in in EU EU countries countries 111 111 Systems for setting OELs official reports on them. Under the Working Conditions Act, the Inspectorate may stipulate the manner in which general provisions and technical regulations in the Act must be complied with in practice and may order the cessation of dangerous activities (right of summary enforcement). Apart from this, employees themselves are also entitled to discontinue an activity in cases of imminent serious danger where it is not possible for the Inspectorate to act on the matter in time, hi such cases the employee concerned must then inform the Inspectorate of what has happened. The Labour Inspectorate monitors the level of exposure only in exceptional cases, if reasonable doubt exists about the situation in a company, and the employer is not willing to take measures. Only a small number of companies, mostly larger chemical industries, monitor levels of exposure in everyday practice. The frequency of monitoring varies from business to business. Monitoring mainly takes place within the framework of obtaining background information, to check if the measures taken are satisfactory. However, according to the MAC Commission, when data can be obtained from corresponding situations in other companies in the Netherlands or even abroad, the companies and OHS Services do not undertake monitoring themselves. The reasons given for not monitoring extensively are: that it is too expensive, labour-intensive and it can be unreliable. When the results of monitoring are checked, threshold limit values such as MACs are not used in all cases. See chapter 8 for further details.
UNITED KINGDOM Enforcement Authority
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE)
Enforcement powers. Compliance with OELs is a legal requirement under the COSHH Regulations. Under the HSW Act 1974 HSE inspectors have powers to issue two types of enforcement notice - an improvement notice or a prohibition notice - as well as powers to prosecute for criminal offences in the courts. Improvement notices are normally used to instruct duty holders to remedy a situation in which an inspector believes that there has been a breach of the law resulting in a risk to the health or safety of persons that the law is intended to protect. The duty-holder is normally required to remedy the situation within a specified time period in accordance with the requirements laid out in the notice. Prohibition notices are normally issued where inspectors fell there is an imminent and serious risk to health and safety. They have the effect of prohibiting
112 Beyond Limits 112 the continuation of the activity that is the cause of the risk as well as requiring it to be corrected in accordance with requirements identified in the notice. Failure to comply with either notice is a criminal offence that may result in prosecution. HSE's own analysis of its enforcement record shows that despite their centrality to monitoring and control under COSHH, OELs played only a minor role in the enforcement of the Regulations. Enforcement of chemicals falls within the HSC's enforcement policy statement (HSC 2004)™. The consultative document on WELs stated that in determining the benchmark against which to decide on enforcement action, if duty holders were applying the principles of good practice they would not be exceeding the WEL. But although the WELs would be useful in determining benchmarks - and their breach would indicate a substantial risk gap and enforcement action - the increased emphasis on good practice meant that the judgement would not depend on measured exposure against the WEL. It would also take into account the condition and maintenance of any control measure provided; the provision of adequate instruction, training and supervision, and the consequences of limited health surveillance. COSHH accounted for between 12 per cent and 21 per cent of all enforcement notices each year between 1997 and 2000 (most were improvement notices). Substances with MELs dominated the substances cited in notices, although the enforcement often focused on the process rather than the substance, but the existence of an OEL meant that the substance was likely to become a focus of attention by inspectors. See Chapter 4 for further details.
CONCLUSIONS There are strong similarities between the various systems for setting and achieving compliance with OELs in the EU. This is hardly surprising since these practices mostly derive from the same small number of historical sources. The ACGIH list of TLVs has clearly been of major influence as, to a lesser extent, have been practices in Nordic countries and in Germany. Latterly, the influence of the EU has been responsible for further convergence. These similarities, by no means always override the national
HSC (2004) HSC Enforcement Policy Statement HSC 15, Sudbury: HSE Books.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 113 differences that are apparent in the setting, status and use of OELs as well as in their legal context. Regulatory system and responsible bodies. There is legislation on health and safety in the use of chemical substances in all countries. In most cases it is in the form of some kind of framework provision supplemented by more specific requirements relating to chemical substances. The influence of both the EU Framework Directive and EU Directives on chemical agents is evident in the structure and content of these provisions and in their increased emphasis on process-based approaches to the management of risk. There is further similarity in the broad nature of the responsible bodies involved. National organisations for monitoring compliance with legal requirements on health and safety are present in all countries. They are variously titled - Labour Inspectorates, Work Environment Authorities etc. They usually operate under the authority of a central Government Department or Ministry and mostly have some form of overall responsibility in the setting and enforcement of OELs. There are differences between countries in the extent to which such national authorities: — are regionalised in their operation — deal exclusively with health and safety or with labour inspection of other aspects of working conditions more generally - have specialised field inspectors and support services in relation to chemical safety - are sole enforcing authorities or share this function with other agencies. Similarities are also evident in the role of national research institutes for health and safety, which appear to play a strong, independent, advisory role in the setting and adoption of OELs in most countries. One significant difference between countries is found in the role of social insurance associations. Their engagement in regulation is most marked in German model (also evident in Austria), where they have both rule making and enforcement authority in addition to that of the state inspectorate, The French approach and the role of the CNAM/CRAM share some of these features in its emphasis of the powers of the social insurance bodies. Another departure from the predominant pattern of organisation of regulatory structures is found in Italy where in practice the responsibilities for seeking compliance with health and safety provisions lies with regional and local structures of the public health system (although the Labour Inspectorate has some national responsibilities as well as some residual shared role in especially hazardous sectors).
114 Beyond Limits 114 What impact, if any, these differences have on regulatory practices in relation to OELs will be explored in the following chapters covering five countries that together display most of the range of these features.180 A further difference is seen in the role of external prevention services in matters concerning OELs. It is clear that in countries where there is a legislative requirement or strong tradition for integrated occupational health services as part of the national health and safety system, it is anticipated that they will play a significant role in helping firms achieve compliance with requirements that involve OELs. This would appear to be the case in Nordic countries and in the Netherlands. It also appears to be the aspiration in some southern European countries such as Spain and in Greece (although it is questionable whether there is sufficient infrastructure in place to allow this). At the opposite extreme, in terms of the formal arrangements governing the role of prevention services, is the situation found in the UK and to a great extent also in the Republic of Ireland, where formal provisions are minimal and considerable discretion is wielded by employers in the use of such services or otherwise. In these latter cases the issue of competence of prevention services and personnel is largely determined through the role of professional bodies and the market rather than formal legislative interventions such as in countries like France and Germany.' Despite this largely voluntaristic approach, it is clear that the role of OHS professionals in the development of OELs in the UK has been considerable. Their role in implementation and use at the workplace level is more difficult to determine. Nevertheless, at least in large workplaces where chemicals are used, there are strong indications of their significance. The primary reasons for the prominence of professionals in this respect are related to the history of the development of the profession of occupational hygiene in the UK and its close association with parallel professional development in the US, rather than with the development of professional interests in occupational health and safety in continental Europe. The rise of the occupational hygiene profession in Britain was supported by the development of large industrial establishments with centralized support services with both sufficient resources and demonstrable market based need to employ occupational hygiene specialists. This in turn allowed the professional bodies representing their interests to achieve prominence in industry and national bodies. Change in the structure and management of organisations has led to fragmentation, downsizing and the outsourcing of services, alongside a major decline in the size of the engineering and manufacturing industries in countries such as the UK. This means that there is no longer Unfortunately it has not been possible to include France in the examples of countries chosen for more detailed study and therefore it is not possible to comment on the significance of the involvement of the CNAM/CRAM.
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 115 such a large niche for occupational hygienists that can be supported by industry on either a structural or economic basis. The resulting decline in the size of the profession in the UK is evidence of this. The implications of these changes will be discussed in subsequent chapters that inter alia explore the evidence for the role of prevention services and professionals in supporting enterprises in chemical risk management and especially in relation to the use of OELs. Procedures for setting OELs. Another strong similarity is seen between countries in the way in which they have set up their structures for setting or adopting OELs to allow for considerable stakeholder participation. These structures are mostly based on tripartite models, with the addition of 'independent' expertise. Other agencies such as insurance associations also may play a greater or lesser role depending on the broader national health and safety system. In countries in which OELs are set there are also broad similarities in the procedures involved. Mostly there is a two stage processes in which the scientific/health-based issues are dealt with, usually by 'experts* (sometimes representing economic interests sometimes not, and sometimes a mixture of both) and a second process in with economic/technical issues of feasibility are considered. Here economic interests are always represented and the social partners are much in evidence. There are two broad patterns evident in the 15 countries studied. There is a group of countries in which there are detailed procedures in place for both setting and complying with OELs. These are essentially the larger northern European countries, the Nordic countries and the Netherlands. These too are the major players when it comes to setting limits at the level of the EU. There are several other countries for which this is far less the case. Their systems vary in detail, but generally they consist of structures and procedures in which expert and stakeholder representation is in place although the nature of the decisions they take may be different to those in the countries with more developed systems. There was clearly some concern in countries with less developed systems about adequate scrutiny of the meaning of values adopted from the EU. There was also concern about the continuation in force of values that could be traced to older lists of the ACGIH and for which there is now new scientific evidence concerning the effects of exposure. Indeed, such has been the widespread historic use of TLVs that the speed with which these can be reviewed and, if necessary, replaced is of concern in most countries regardless of whether or not they currently set their own new standards. At the same time, in countries such as Italy there seems to be another level of concern about the meaning and use of OELs as legal standards. This derives from a fear that adoption at national level of EU 'pragmatic* standards that take economic considerations into account will undermine the Italian workers' constitutional right to healthy and safe workplaces. According to this argument the assumption of a risk level
116 Beyond Limits 116 that is implicit in such standards is fundamentally at odds with workers' rights to health that are enshrined in the constitution. We return to this issue in greater detail in Chapter 7, which deals in greater detail with the Italian situation. Occupational Exposure Limits, As far as the limits themselves are concerned there are differences of detail in the values adopted. We have not explored the reasons for such differences or their practical significance. Terminology used to define them is international such as time weighted averages, short-term exposure limits, ceiling values and annotations for special risks such as carcinogenicity, skin absorption, allergenic substances etc. but there are differences in the detail of its application to different substances in different countries. Further comparative study would be required to explain the significance of such detail. Legal status of Occupational Exposure Limits. In most countries there are a number of OELs that are legally binding limits. Sometimes they are restricted to those that are in force as a result of compliance with EU Directives but in many cases the list is larger. In the guidance that accompanies OELs in all countries in which it was available, it is made clear that they are not regarded as safe limits and they are frequently accompanied by recommendations to reduce exposures to as low as is possible below the limit. In some countries there is more than one kind of limit with legal meaning as in the situation until recently in UK (although not necessarily with the same definition applying), m others there is only one limit that has a legal definition but there may be others that have the status of guidance. It is not clear from information available whether this has a significant or measurable impact on the use and enforcement of limits. Nor is it clear whether it affects the understanding of the meaning of limits by users. These are issues to which we shall return in the more detailed country studies that follow. Further differences reflect broader variation in the regulatory systems of the countries. Thus in Italy, older OELs derived from the ACGIH list may be legally binding in some sectors because they are referred to in collective agreements which themselves have a legal status within the Italian labour relations system. In the Nordic countries, the long tradition of Nordic corporatism also means that the detail of OELs that apply may be found in collective agreements. In the Netherlands the social partners have achieved an agreement on the controversial use of OELs in relation to nonsubstitutable carcinogens in which a certain level of risk is accepted in exchange for the likelihood of increased safe working environments overall. The social partners agreed to strive for TLVs corresponding to risks not larger than 10"6 per year (or 4 x 10"5 for the working-life as a whole). However for the time being, as such low risks are not achievable for many carcinogens, TLVs that correspond to risks up to 10"4 per year (or 4
Systems for for setting OELs in EU countries 117
x 10 for the working-life as a whole) are tolerated at present. (A risk of 10 per year roughly equates to the average risk for a fatal work accident in the Netherlands.) Since 1996, about 15 TLVs have been derived under this scheme (Wilders 2002). In Germany so-called TRK values have been derived for more than 70 carcinogens. Only recently has the decision for a systematic review of these limit values been taken. It is likely that more than 10 years will be needed to revise all of them and therefore such review will tend to become a permanent feature of the German system (Wriedt 2003) Who enforces the exposure limits, enforcement activity and what is meant by compliance? As already pointed out it is the national labour inspectorates (or their equivalent) that have enforcement authority in all countries although this may be supplemented in various ways by other agencies. The extent of the use of these powers and penalties is much more difficult to determine. Enforcement activity in general has proven difficult to document from the sources available to us. We have been imable to obtain a detailed picture of enforcement practice from any of the countries studied. In the chapters that follow we document, as far as is possible, the situation from information available. What is clear from the overview in this chapter is that while OELs are part of the enforcement scenario, in most countries the way in which such enforcement is undertaken varies. In some cases the emphasis of inspectorates is on firms achieving compliance with requirements concerning the management of the overall processes of production. Compliance with OELs as such, is therefore evidence of health and safety management working effectively, as lack of compliance would indicate the opposite. They are also enforced (at least in theory) in their own right, where there is evidence that they may be exceeded. Again, it has not been possible to determine from records, with what frequency such action takes place. There are situations in which measurement of airborne pollution will be required to assess and manage risks. While this is the responsibility of employers, in practice it is often undertaken by external expertise and the role of prevention services to which we have already referred is important in several countries. Generally, it seems that regulatory inspectorates rarely engage in proactive acts of monitoring compliance with specific OELs themselves. However, where there is concern over workplace airborne pollution that may be approaching or exceeding limits, there are requirements in some countries to inform and involve the regulatory agencies in monitoring. The extent to which technical aspects of monitoring actually take place, either with the involvement of the regulators or the prevention services (or their equivalents) is not clear. These issues are discussed in the specific cases of the countries that are the subjects of the following six chapters.
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
119 119
THE UNITED KINGDOM
INTRODUCTION The UK chemical industry is the third largest in Europe, after Germany and France, accounting for some 14 per cent of production in the EU. Chemical substances are also used by large numbers of workers in other industrial sectors as well as in services. HSC has estimated that there are some 1.3 million firms that use chemicals and chemical products. Many of these are small and micro enterprises. According to the European Foundation's survey of working conditions about 20 per cent of British respondents thought they were exposed to breathing in fumes, dusts or dangerous substances for a quarter or more of their work-time which is slightly less that the average for the EU 15 countries as a whole (22 per cent). While somewhat more than the average for the EU 15 countries (nearly 20 per cent) thought they handled dangerous products or substances in their work (EU 15 - 15.6 per cent) (European Foundation 2001). In this chapter we consider the role of OELs in the system for regulating the management of risks of hazardous substances in UK workplaces. As in several other countries, regulatory status was attributed to OELs in the 1980s in the UK. But perhaps more than in other countries, the limitations of this regulatory role have been the subject of considerable scrutiny and policy change. In seeking to understand the recent shifts in the position of OELs in regulatory policy it is necessary to trace several related narratives in the story of their use in the UK. They include the history of their application, first as non-regulatory tools to inform good occupational hygiene practice, through their acquisition of regulatory status and a role in regulating the management of hazardous substances, to the gradual recognition of their limitations and that of the system in
120 Beyond Limits 120
which they were incorporated. There is a body of research available in the UK that explicitly addresses the ways in which OELs are perceived within workplaces and their role in the management of chemical risks. There is also some evidence available on the extent to which OELs have featured in enforcement actions undertaken by regulatory inspectors in the UK. Additionally, approaches to the role of OELs have been much discussed in the specialist and practitioner literature in the UK and in particular, the views of senior regulatory policy makers have been articulated. Equally significant in the UK is the synchronicity of strategies on OELs with wider policy considerations in health and safety regulation generally. It is evident that the regulation of risk management in relation to hazardous substances resonates with such wider considerations and a proper understanding of recent reforms in relation to the role of OELs is therefore incomplete without its contextualisation within this wider scenario. These related themes are the basis of this chapter. It begins with the development of the regulatory background to chemical risk management in the UK. Then it focuses on the system for setting of OELs and their role within regulatory strategies. A discussion of the empirical evidence of the understanding and use of OELs in Britain follows before some consideration is given to recent shifts in policy approaches.
BACKGROUND: LEGISLATIVE REFORMS FROM THE 1970S The UK has the longest history of legislative intervention in occupational health and safety in the world. It is hardly surprising therefore that it has deeply rooted and characteristically British features. They include a high degree of voluntarism and discretion afforded to actors in the system and a relatively low level of regulatory intervention on the part of the state. In contrast with the other countries in this study, the legal framework for regulation is affected by, amongst other things, the common-law basis of English law and the relative absence of a preventive role for social insurance. For the past thirty years the framework for prevention has been dominated by the requirements of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (HSW Act). This Act, widely regarded as a radical departure from previous prescriptive requirements at the time of its introduction, is still viewed by government and national level policy makers as a success, having 'stood the test of time' with its style and requirements regarded as relevant today as they were when they were introduced in 1975. Regulating the management of
Y2\ The United Kingdom 121
the risks of hazardous substances, while the subject of separate and detailed Regulations, occurs within the framework provided by the Act. It is therefore important to outline something of this framework and the thinking behind it. In 1972 the Committee of Inquiry on Safety and Health at Work - the Robens Committee - produced a report which heralded a significant change of approach in British health and safety regulation (Robens 1972). It recommended the introduction of measures that would: — provide a more self-regulating system for health and safety — ensure wider coverage of all affected by the risks associated with work — clarify duties and obligations for health and safety in a single comprehensive framework — enable a greater degree of involvement of employers, workers and their organisations in organisation of health and safety — provide a national authority for health and safety. Prior to these recommendations, health and safety regulation in Britain had, since the previous century been essentially based around piecemeal prescriptive measures. They were complex and sometimes incomprehensible to the people affected by them, often with incomplete and overlapping coverage, produced with little involvement from either those they were intended to protect or those whose activities they were meant to regulate and with limited procedures for their enforcement. It was largely for these reasons that the Robens recommendations were much vaunted as a radical departure from traditional approaches to health and safety regulation. The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 (HSW1974) introduced a reform in which the prescriptive standards of older and more narrowly focused legislation were replaced by goal setting approaches, based around regulating the processes of self-regulation.181 Its main requirements were a set of general duties found in Sections 2 to 9 covering employers, employees, the self employed, controllers of
However, not all ita provisions were the result of the Robens Recommendations. For example, the measures in the Act concerning the rights of recognised trade unions to appoint health and safety representatives (Sections 2(4) and 2 (7) ) derived not from the recommendations of the Robens Committee, but from an undertaking to the trade unions on the part of the Labour Government to introduce them following a long trade union campaign on the matter (Walters 2004).
122 Beyond Limits 122
premises, and manufacturers and suppliers of articles and substances used at the workplace. These general duties were mostly based on principles of common law concerning the duty of care established over the years through damages litigation in the courts, rather than being drawn from previous statutes. Their inclusion in the Act gave them a preventive function. The rationale of this approach was to give everyone concerned with health and safety at work clear, concise and accessible notions of their basic legal obligations. It was also intended to facilitate greater attention to the management of health and safety. The obligations on employers were detailed in Section 2 and required them to provide, so far as reasonably practicable, for the health safety and welfare of their employees. The means by which they were required to do this was identified in general terms with regard to such things as the provision of plant, systems of work, information, training, supervision, access and egress, the working environment and the use of articles and substances. The latter measures were supplemented by the duties of suppliers found in Section 6 of the Act, which laid duties on the designers, manufacturers importers and suppliers of articles and substances for use at work and were intended to introduce protective measures at source. Since the Act came into force this principle has been strengthen by amendments introduced by the Consumer Protection Act 1987, and more specifically in relation to hazardous substances by the Chemicals (Hazard Information and Packaging for Supply) Regulations. Employers were required further under Section 2 (3) to have a written policy in which the organisation and arrangements with which they intend to carry out their duties were identified. The Act enabled the Secretary of State to approve Regulations in which the details of specific legislative standards could be spelt out. An innovation of the Act was its provision for the use of Approved Codes of Practice (ACOPs), instruments that do not impose legal duties, but which set out the means by which a legal duty may be accomplished. ACOPs generally accompany major new sets of Regulations and their provisions relate to those in the Regulations, hi the event of a breach of one of the Regulations made under the Act that is accompanied by an ACOP, the normal direction of the burden of proof is in effect reversed and the defendant is required by the court to show that the means used to discharge the relevant duty were equivalent to those laid down in the ACOP. In the case of hazardous substances, the main requirements controlling their use in British workplaces (and giving OELs regulatory status) are found in the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002, accompanied by an ACOP that details the way in which duty-holders must implement them. The Regulations were originally introduced in 1987 by the Secretary of State under the powers in the HSW. They
123 The United Kingdom 123
have been revised and re-enacted several times. As we shall outline subsequently their most recent revisions have been the subject of discussions over the past two years and new COSHH Regulations, including a revised position for OELs are anticipated by April 2005. Other relevant sections of the Act (Sections 10 -14) concerned the creation of the HSC and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE). The HSC, a tripartite body on which the interests of governance, capital and labour were represented, itself spawned a structure of advisory committees with a similar tripartite composition.182 Of particular relevance to hazardous substances and OELs is the Advisory Committee on Toxic Substances, and its sub-committees, including the Working Group for the Assessment of Toxic Chemicals (WATCH), in which deliberations on setting OELs took place (see below). The Act concentrated the previously disparate structure and operation of inspection and control of health and safety, into one central Authority, the HSE and gave its inspectors greater range of formal enforcement actions. There is some evidence in the UK concerning the extent to which OELs have featured in such actions.
REGULATING RISK MANAGEMENT OF HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS Although the HSWAct was generally concerned with the regulation of the process of managing health and safety at work, it contained little in the way of specific requirements on duty holders on exactly how such management was to be undertaken. Moreover, in 1979, several years after its introduction, a Conservative government took office. Throughout the seventeen years that followed, when a succession of Conservative Governments remained in power in the UK, a neoliberal and deregulatory political agenda was pursued, in which there was little room for further development of home grown legislative innovations on OHS management. Instead, the stimulus for reform in this direction was taken over by the European Community, which played a dominant role in instigating the legislative development of process regulation.
The approach to representation on such committees as on the HSC itself has broadened somewhat since their original creation in 1975, with representation from other stakeholders being included in addition to the representatives of trade unions and employers in many of the committees.
124 Beyond Limits 124
How much this influence was truly extra-territorial in its origins is difficult to document. The extent to which national influences on European Community regulatory strategies can be traced is limited by the lack of transparency of the forums in which decisions were taken.183 However, at a time of intransigent political opposition to further legislative development in the UK, senior HSE policy makers and regulators would have been aware of other avenues of influence (Rimmington 2003). Their role in the consultative machinery of the European Community certainly gave them an opportunity to exercise influence at this level and it is likely that they would have used it to promote a British version of process regulation in the various legislative measures being developed at this time. Amongst the most prominent of these was the EEC Directive 80/1107/EEC on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to chemical, physical and biological agents at work. Hazardous substances therefore became one of the first subjects on which the further development of the regulatory approach to mandating more detailed requirements along the lines initiated by the approach of the HSW Act was focused. In 1984 the HSE produced draft regulations seeking to control substances hazardous to health and initiated a protracted period of public consultation that was to lead to the eventual adoption of the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (COSHH) in 1987. There were several features of the regulations and the consultation that are central to understanding the British approach. To begin with the influence of the EC was clear. The Regulations were a response required to by British membership of the European Communities to the EEC Directive 80/1107/EEC. At the same time, the main thrust of the requirements was to regulate the management of hazardous substances at the workplace. This was to be achieved through incorporation of general principles of good occupational hygiene practice, and requiring assessment of the risks of exposure, It is further complicated by the extent to which the 'diplomacy' of Commission officials obscures the realities of influence in deciiions at this level. As Walters shows in his analysis of the development of the content of the Framework Directive many national representatives that took part in this process, often with opposing views were led by Commission officials to believe the emerging Community strategies in relation to the content and purpose of the Directive reflected their particular input and interests (Walters, ed. 2002).
The United United Kingdom Kingdom 125 125 The
use of adequate control measures and their maintenance as well as instruction, information and training for workers184. Indeed such was the profile of the debate surrounding many of these issues that the proposed COSHH Regulations became the defining health and safety legislation of the 1980s, as significant in that decade as the Act had been for the 1970s. Although the COSHH Regulations have been the subject of several subsequent revisions (for example in 1994,1999, 2002 and again in 2005), their basic message remains the same. While thinking from within the European Community may have been a strong influence on the orientation of the content of the proposed Regulations, it was by no means the only stimulus for their introduction. The HSW Act was gradually introduced to repeal and replace the largely prescriptive existing British provisions with modernising measures. Existing chemical regulation was of this kind and there was a widely held view that it was outdated, over-complex and obscure. The proposed regulations were therefore also part of this modernising process. hi addition, the quasi-technical nature of the approaches to risk assessment and management that regulations on the control of hazardous substances required, reflected notions concerning the demarcation of the subject matter of health and safety with which British regulators felt comfortable. Chemical substances, good occupational hygiene practice, assessment of exposure, use and maintenance of control measures and health monitoring were all issues that seemed to be unequivocally concerned with technical aspects of health and safety and uncontroversial in this respect.lss
These kinds of requirements were to become a famiKar refrain in UK regulatory measures over the next decade as the UK. sought to implement a succession of EEC Directives in which the regulation of the process of OHS management was increasingly specified. Early examples dealt with particular physical and chemical hazards such as asbestos and noise. The approach was later consolidated in the requirements of the Framework Directive 89/391 where it was applied to employers' duties to manage health and safety more generally and in the succession of daughter directives that were made under it (see Walters ed., 2002). In contrast with the debates that were to come over the wider remit of risk assessment that would be used in relation to future more generic directives on OHS management such as the Framework Directive 89/391.
126 Beyond Limits 126
Our particular interest in the subject matter of the regulations focuses mainly on assessment of exposure. It was in relation to such assessment that OELs were to assume regulatory status. In the following section we explore the way this came about. Before doing so it is also important to account for a second and related element in the evolving British regulatory approach to managing the risks of hazardous substances at work. This concerns the development of requirements on manufacturers and suppliers to provide information concerning the safe use of their products. They had general obligations to do so under Section 6 of the HSW Act and their obligations were further detailed in a series of regulations that at the same time sought to implement European Community requirements. The Regulations dealing with suppliers' information that were developed contemporaneously with COSHH were the Chemicals (Hazard Information and Packaging for Supply) Regulations 1994 (CHIP). Amongst their features was their implementation of the EC classification system for the toxicology of chemical substances. This system, based on clearly defined criteria agreed throughout the Community, offered an internationally recognised and accepted means to classify the nature of the toxicological hazard represented by individual substances supplied for use at work. As we mentioned in the previous chapter, its approach used a codification system (Risk Phrases) that was based on toxicological evidence of harm arising from exposure to substances. Criteria for codification were set out in Annex VI to the Dangerous Substances Directive (67/548/EEC) as amended by its Seventh Amendment (92/32/EEC). Annex I to the Dangerous Substances Directive included risk phrases (R-phrases) for all substances with an agreed hazard classification in the EU. This information was reproduced in the UK in the Approved Classification and Labelling Guide (Third Ed.) whilst specific substances and their R-phrases were listed in the Approved Supply List. If any substance supplied to a workplace within the European Community was not listed in Annex I to the Directive, the supplier was required to consider whether a hazard classification was appropriate and if so, based on the classification criteria, apply the appropriate R-phrases as well as other information. Amongst other things then, CHIP required that suppliers classified the substances they supplied according to the extent of hazard they represented to human health. It required they used the R-phrase rating system to do so and that suppliers state the appropriate R-phrase on the Safety Data Sheets they were obliged to provide when supplying chemicals or preparations for use at work. These measures were to be of considerable significance in relation to the future policy expectations
The United Kingdom 127
concerning the role of OELs at the workplace level, particularly in small enterprises. COSHH and the development of the regulatory status ofOEL. Prior to 1984 the HSE used the ACGIH list of TLVs as the basis for a non-regulatory Guidance Note on exposure limits. A condition of the use of the ACGIH list was that it could not be altered in any way. As Silk (1987) pointed out during the discussion concerning the draft COSHH regulations, this condition created several difficulties for the UK regulatory strategy on hazardous substances. Different values had in fact already been adopted for a small number of substances. Time weighted averages were sometimes based on different periods and legally binding Control Limits for some substances, created further difficulties in using the list as voluntary recommendations. A consequence of these difficulties was the decision taken in 1980 to publish an independent British list of exposure limits with its own notes on the thoughts behind their adoption and application. The first edition of this list was produced in HSE Guidance Note EH40/84 that appeared in the same year as the consultative document on the future COSHH Regulations. It contained two categories of exposure limits - Control Limits for a small number of substances (about 20 in the first list) that had exposure limits with some regulatory status and Recommended Limits for the remainder of the 500 or so substances that were contained in EH 40/84'86. Control Limits represented limits that should not normally be exceeded and should be achieved by application of appropriate plant and process control techniques - although it was recognised that there may be special circumstances (such as maintenance operations for example) where such measures were not reasonably practicable. Under such circumstances the guidance indicated that 'the use of suitable personal protective equipment was acceptable in order to achieve compliance.' Recommended Limits were ' . . . considered to represent good practice and realistic criteria for the control of exposure, plant design, engineering control and if necessary the selection and use of personal protective equipment.' Of particular relevance to our interest in the use of such limits was the statement:
Although 'an independent British list' it was nevertheless largely based on the adoption of limits from the TLV list of the ACGIH. This was coupled with the commitment of WATCH to gradually review the evidence for these limits and to replace them and establish new limits for additional substances as appropriate.
128 Beyond Limits 128
'HSE inspectors will use these exposure limits as part of their criteria for assessing compliance with the HSW Act and other relevant statutory provisions'. Both types of limits were adopted on the advice of ACTS. In order to be able to keep the list under regular review, the previously mentioned WATCH subcommittee of ACTS was required to consider changes to recommended exposure limits already listed and to propose limits for further toxic substances that had significant use in the occupational environment. Such was the situation between 1984 and the time that the COSHH Regulations came into force in 1988. The Regulations represented a significant milestone in the history of the use of OELs in the UK because they gave them a clear role in requirements on duty-holders to manage occupational risks of hazardous substances. OELs were thereby transformed from mainly voluntary standards intended primarily for professional use into standards with an unambiguous legal status. The rationale for this was essentially that regulating control of exposure to hazardous substances would require duty holders to maintain control measures to the extent necessary to give adequate protection for the health of workers. Within the COSHH requirements therefore there would be a legal framework for workplace OELs. As an HSE spokesperson stated in a paper presented to the Annual Conference of the BOHS (Rolt, 1986): "The obvious way of setting clear standards in respect of one aspect of control is by means of occupational exposure limits' However, he acknowledged that there were a number of difficulties in doing so that were presented by the definitions of Control Limits and Recommended Limits then in use and argued that the nascent COSHH Regulations represented an opportunity to review policy and rationalise the definitions and legal status of OELs. That was in effect what happened, hi a letter to the Annals of Occupational Hygiene in 1989 seeking to clarify the position with regard to the new occupational exposure limits and the indicative criteria used to set them, following the implementation of the COSHH Regulations, the HSE Chairman of ACTS stated (Carter 1989):
United Kingdom 129 129 The United
'The COSHH Regulations introduce two new classes of occupational exposure limits: maximum exposure limits (MELs) and occupational exposure standards (OESs). Both of these new limits apply to exposure via the inhalation route and will be used in determining whether exposure has been adequately controlled, if it is not feasible to prevent it altogether. For substances that have been given MELs, the level of exposure should be reduced so far as is reasonably practicable and in any event should not exceed the MEL. For substances with OESs it will be sufficient to ensure that the level of exposure is reduced to the OES.' The so called indicative criteria that would be used to as a guide to assist WATCH and ACTS in deciding whether to recommend an OES or MEL for a particular substance to HSC, were also defined: For a substance to be assigned an occupational exposure standard it was required to meet all of the following: i. The ability to identify, with reasonable certainty, a concentration averaged over a reference period, at which there is no indication that the substance is likely to be injurious to employees if they are exposed by inhalation day after day to that concentration ii. Exposure to concentrations higher than that derived under criterion 1 and which could reasonably occur in practice are unlikely to produce serious short or long term effects on health over the period that it might be reasonably taken to identify and remedy the cause of excessive exposure iii. The available evidence indicates that compliance with the OES, as derived under criterion 1 is reasonably practicable. For a substance to be assigned a maximum exposure limit it was required to meet either of the following: i. A substance not able to satisfy the criteria for an OES and which has, or is liable to have, a serious risk to man including acute toxicity and/or potential to cause serious long-term health effects; or ii. Socio-economic factors, which indicate that, although the substance meets the criteria for an OES, a numerically higher value is necessary if certain uses are to be reasonably practicable. The two types of OEL introduced by COSHH, - the OES and MEL - were both expressed as airborne concentrations averaged over a period, either a long term
130 Beyond Limits Limits 130
exposure limit (an eight hour time weighted average) or a short term exposure limit (with a 15 minute reference period). OESs would be set for substances for which it was possible to identify with reasonable certainty a concentration of exposure at which it was judged there was no significant risk to health and with which it was reasonably practicable for industry to comply. Where such a concentration could not be identified and the chemical had serious health implications an MEL would be considered. Because the OES was considered a 'safe' concentration employers were required to meet this standard for each substance for which one was set but not necessarily control the concentration of such substances in workplace air to levels below the standard. It was also permissible for them to exceed the standard provided steps were taken to remedy this as soon as reasonably practicable. In contrast a MEL indicated a concentration that must not be exceeded. Furthermore, duty-holders were required to reduce concentrations in workplace air of substances with MELs to as low as reasonably practicable below the MEL. HSE spokespersons such as Michael Topping (2001) referred to the notion of 'tolerability of risk' that could be applied to aid understanding of the role of OELs in policy on controlling the risks from chemical hazards.187 In his conceptualisation, the nature of risk increases from what is negligible to that which cannot be ethically justified (except in extraordinary circumstances). In this process the social acceptability of the risk passes through a range from being broadly acceptable through being tolerable to becoming completely unacceptable. As Figure 4.1 shows the notion of tolerability is not a single point on this scale but a broad band through which what society might deem tolerable decreases as risk increases. In this scenario the definitions used to set OESs would place them at the end of high tolerability because by definition they are intended to represent 'safe levels.' However, MELs are set at a point where a much greater level of risk is acknowledged. They are therefore at the boundaries of tolerability, must not be exceeded and are borne in conjunction with the requirement that control measures are required to drive the risk in the direction of greater acceptability. If a residual risk remains in this region and at the same time society desires the benefits of the activity causing it, the residual risk is only tolerable if further risk reduction is
Although originally developed to explain policy on controlling the risks of major hazards such as those of the nuclear industry in the light of societal concern, Topping argued it could equally well be applied to to aid understanding of the role of OELs in policy on controlling the risks from chemical hazards
The United Kingdom 131 131
impracticable or requires action that is grossly disproportionate in comparison with the risk reduction so achieved.188
Figure 4.1: HSE's Tolerability of Risk Framework and OFXs (after Topping 2001)
Risk cannot be justified except in extraordinary circumstances
Unacceptable region
Maximum exposure limit Control measures must be introduced to drive residual risk towards acceptable region. IF residual risk emains and the henefit of the activity is desired it is tolerable only rf further sk reduction is impracticable or equires grossly disproportionate esources.
Tolerable region
Occupational exposure standard Broadly acceptable region
Level of residual risk is insignificant. Further efforts to reduce risk are likely to be grossly disproportionate to the risk reduction achieved.
Negligible risk
Of course this sentence is laden with value judgements that as critics of the risk tolerability framework have pointed out are socially determined and imply an equal distribution of information, power, influence and control in decision making processes and their social and economic underpinnings that critics also argue to be a far cry from reality.
132 Beyond Limits 132
Under the COSHH Regulations the statutory status of OELs in the UK was complete. They defined adequate control of risk by inhalation of the hazardous substances to which they applied. Processes that had evolved over the previous decade or so for setting and adopting OELs were now linked to a legal framework for their use. Thus, according to Topping (2001) the limit setting process involved the HSC, ACTS and its sub-group WATCH - representing the interests of the regulator, employees and employers as well environmental interests - and were supplemented by a further public consultation on the limits derived from this process. As shown in Figure 4.2 the process for setting limits for any particular substance would be initiated by a package of information supplied by the HSE to WATCH. If the committee considered that the substance met the criteria for an OES, a value would be recommended to ACTS. If the recommendations were agreed they were published in a widely circulated consultation document. Following this public consultation HSC would endorse the proposal, publishing it in the annually revised Guidance Note on OELs. If WATCH were unable to recommend an OES for a particular substance it would be referred to ACTS for further consideration, normally for setting an MEL. If ACTS agreed to set a MEL the HSE was required to issue a Chemical Hazard Alert Notice (CHAN) as an interim measure to inform industry of the serious health risks associated with the use of the substance (if eventually ACTS decided not to issue a MEL because for example, the resources required to do so were not justified, employers would nevertheless be expected to establish appropriate control regimes based on the CHAN). If a MEL were to be set for a particular substance, the HSE was required to gather information on good occupational hygiene practice in relation to its use, and make proposals for the MEL. A regulatory impact assessment would be undertaken, setting out the socioeconomic factors balancing risks to health against costs of reducing exposure. These proposals would then be considered by ACTS and subsequently also the subject of public consultation before being endorsed by HSC and published in EH40.
The United Kingdom 133 Figure 4.2 Setting OELs in the UK (after Topping 2001)
HSE prepares data package
WATCH propose values for OES or or refers substance to ACTS for further consideration YOU AREto normally set toHERE set MEL
on ACTS (2001) Interests represented on Employees — — Four TUC nominees
Employers — — Four CBI nominees ACTS endorses OEL OEL proposals Agrees to to issue CHAN is is MEL MEL is is considered appropriate and and proposes value for for MEL
Public consultation on on OES OESand and MEL
— Local authorities — Two Two local government nominees
— Environmental interests — by HSE) representative (selected by
One One
Consumer interests —One representative by HSE) (selected by
Independent experts — — by HSE) representatives (selected by
Five
HSC endorses OES MEL OES and and MEL proposals. They are are then EH 40 published in in EH 40 occupational occupationalexposure exposurelimits limits
In practice this meant that when COSHH was adopted, the existing list of Control Limits became MELs.189 The Recommended Limits were reviewed to identify and remove any substances with limits that did not meet the new criteria for OESs and the remainder (around 500) became OESs without any further scientific review. Except those for lead and asbestos, which are covered by separate Regulations.
134 Beyond Limits 134
The ones that had been removed were subject to further review in the years following. Problems with OELs under the COSHH system. Although the COSHH Regulations were a landmark development in regulatory approaches to OHS management and an important milestone in the history of the use of OELs, this is not to say that they were without problems. Significantly, several of these problems, which gradually came to light in the years following the implementation of the regulations, were directly associated with the process for setting the two kinds of OEL. To begin with, in the application of the indicative criteria for setting an OES, WATCH operated on the principle that for the first criterion to be met (that is for an OES to be set at a level based on an average concentration over a specific reference period at which there is no indication that the substance is likely to be injurious), it must be possible to identify a 'safe' concentration from the available data. However, in practice what was actually known about the toxicity by inhalation of some substances was relatively limited and it was found increasingly difficult to identify with any certainty a level that was of no concern to human health for such substances. At the same time not all such substances would have serious health implications for those exposed and would not warrant a MEL on such grounds. There was therefore a gap into which an increasing number of substances fell that could not be awarded an OEL of either kind. Moreover, as we have indicated previously, as time passed the whole concept of a so-called 'safe limit' became increasingly insecure. In reality it was not possible to give such a guarantee for substances, because of gaps in knowledge about their properties and also because of the extent of human variability. Further problems arose as a result of the parallel standard setting process developed at the European level during the 1990s. The emergence of the Chemical Agents Directive, obliging member states to set limits at levels taking into account of those in the IOELV Directives, was not entirely congruent with the British OES/MEL approach. While most substances identified in the IOELV Directives were considered by WATCH to meet the criteria for an OES, there were some that did not and as a consequence would have to be considered for an MEL even though the European SCOEL had concluded that a health based limit could not be set for such substances. Such problems added weight to the growing feeling that the criteria used to decide which limit was appropriate were insufficient in scope.
135 The United Kingdom 135
As a result a growing number of substances met neither criteria for an OES or MEL and it was not possible to establish an OEL for them. However all these problems associated with setting OELs were relatively minor compared with the implications of evidence that began to emerge in research on what actual use was made of them by duty holders under the COSHH Regulations. Such findings indicated that despite the sophistication of the standard setting processes for OELs and the efforts to make the process of decision making as representative as possible of user interests, knowledge and appropriate use of OELs in risk management at enterprise level could not be taken for granted.
USING O E L S AT THE WORKPLACE The view was widely held that the COSHH Regulations was a major feature of the regulatory framework in the UK by the end of the 1980s. They went a long way to meet the views of practitioners, trade unions and regulators that a workable regulatory framework to control the risks of hazardous substances had been put in place in which a British conceptualisation of OELs was firmly embedded.190 However, there were clearly several preconditions that would need to apply before the COSHH Regulations were going to be entirely successful in practice. These could be divided into three broad areas. The first and most obvious of them concerned the understanding of their requirements amongst users. Nowhere was this more apparent than in relation to OELs. A level of competence would be necessary to enable duty holders to discharge their duties properly. This would be particularly important in relation to the implementation of the principles of occupational hygiene that were central to the approach of the Regulations to chemical risk management. Second, a flow of information concerning the risks of chemicals and how to manage them that was suitable and sufficient to enable duty
The Regulations were of course not without their detractors amongst the organisations representing employers and especially those representing the chemical industry. However, even here the criticism and concern wag not so much directed at the role of OELs as it was more widely directed: at for example, the notion that under COSHH all chemical substances were treated as 'dangerous' because the regulations concerned themselves with hazards rather than raks and therefore placed unnecessary and unacceptable burdens on the resources of the chemicals industry and the users of chemicals.
136 Beyond Limits 136
holders to carry out their duties was required. As well as employers being provided with this information, as duty holders, they too would need mechanisms in place to ensure its receipt, understanding and use by employees and their representatives if those who worked with hazardous chemicals were to play their part in ensuring the application of the requirements of the Regulations in their own work. Third, the extent to which OELs featured in the enforcement actions on management and control of the risks of chemical substances would help to determine the seriousness with which they were regarded by duty-holders. Initial reviews of the implementation of the COSHH regulations broadly suggested that they had been effective in alerting many employers to the health risks of hazardous substances used in their workplaces (HSE 1993). However, such reviews did not assess users' understanding of OELs or the way they were actually used in controlling chemical risks. During the 1990s there was mounting scepticism about whether OELs were really being widely used in the way they were intended to be under the COSHH Regulations. Several aspects of this concern related to all three areas of the preconditions identified above. Access to information. As already noted, under the HSW Act there is a legal framework governing the flow of information concerning safe use of hazardous chemicals that begins with the supplier of chemical products - flows to the employer but is also intended to inform the workers who are the end users to enable them to use chemical products safely. Both suppliers and employers have specific duties on the provision of information. There are further requirements on training and supervision that supplement those on information. Additionally, trade union health and safety representatives have rights to information in the employers' possession (and employers have obligations (to provide it) to enable them to carry out their representative functions. Under Regulation 7 (2) of the Safety Representatives and Safety Committees Regulations, the information includes: 'Information of a technical nature about hazards to health and safety and precautions deemed necessary to eliminate or minimise them in respect of.. . substances in use at work, including any relevant information provided by . . . .the manufacturer, importer or supplier of any article or substance used or proposed to be used at work by their employees'. Section 6 of the HSW Act and Regulation 6 of the CHIP Regulations define what information suppliers are required to provide in the suppliers' safety data sheets
The The United United Kingdom Kingdom 137 137
that represent the form in which the most detailed information on safe use of substances is likely to reach workplaces. The data sheets should describe the hazardous properties of the substances, how they should be handled, stored and disposed of safely as well as describe procedures in the event of an accident or a fire, hi addition information on hazards is required on the labels of containers of chemical substances and as we discussed previously, the CHIP (Amendment) Regulations 1997 detailed requirements on the classification of substances, symbols to indicate hazards and requirements on using risk phrases selected on the basis of physiochemical properties, health and environmental effects. Despite the quite detailed legislative requirements on provision of information, in practice they were often not met and only rarely enforced (Hudspith and Hay 1998). Problems occurred at the interface between the supplier and the workplace and within workplaces between employers and workers and their representatives. Research evidence showed that although suppliers' information was probably the major source of employers' knowledge on chemical risk management, this knowledge was quite weak, especially amongst employers in smaller enterprises and that in relation to OELs it was severely limited. Surveys of the contents of safety data sheets indicated that while there had been improvements over time they rarely delivered information that was useful to users and enabled dutyholders to carry out a suitable and sufficient risk assessment. As Hudspith and Hay suggested: 'Primary producers of chemicals produce comprehensive information for their safety data sheets but many have little idea about the end use of the chemicals they supply. Advice on control procedures is even more limited by the fact that most data sheets are now generated electronically, according to a standard formula. This means that most sections that deal with control procedures simply reproduce stock phrases on safety and risk. Further down the supply chain products are put to more specific uses. This ought to prompt some changes in advice about control procedures. In practice however, there is often no change in the advice proffered. At the end of the supply chain, control advice should be specific and suppliers ought to know more precisely how their products are to be used. Regrettably many suppliers do not know.' Of course, even if the information was of a suitable and sufficient quality this did not mean that employers would use it appropriately or that they made it available to their workers and their representatives. There is, for example, a considerable
138 Beyond Limits 138
body of research on the role of health and safety representatives that shows that while good information is one prerequisite for their successful engagement in improving health and safety arrangements and outcomes at the workplace, it is an area in which representatives have frequently complained they have problems in their relations with employers and managers.'91 Overall then, while information requirements under health and safety law to facilitate the safe use of hazardous substances were considerable, there was good circumstantial reasons to suppose that neither employers nor their workers were making the best use of such information following the implementation of the COSHH Regulations.192 It seems particularly unlikely that under such circumstances there would be widespread understanding of the significance attributed to the role of OELs in the principles of occupational hygiene central to the proper operation of risk management under COSHH. Therefore it was also unlikely that OELs would have been used in this way by anything like the Ml range of users of hazardous chemicals in the UK. The role of OELs in enforcement actions. Compliance with OELs is a legal requirement under the COSHH Regulations. Under the HSW Act 1974 HSE inspectors have powers to institute a range of formal enforcement actions. These include two types of enforcement notice - an improvement notice or a prohibition notice - as well as powers to institute prosecution for criminal offences in the Nevertheless as the research reported in the next section shows, trade union health and safety representatives surveyed in the study commissioned by the HSE (Research International 1997) were considerably better informed about OELs than were employers. The explanation the researchers offered for this finding was that the safety representatives in their survey were mostly drawn from larger enterprises. A further factor would have been the extent of health and safety training received by the representatives — which is considerably greater than that received by the average small enterprise owner manager and which deals specifically with representing workers that use hazardous substances. It is interesting to note in this context however that amongst UK respondents to the European Foundation's Third Survey of Working conditions were the highest proportion of those who felt themselves to be very well informed about the risks resulting from the use of materials, instruments or products they handled in their jobs (52.8 per cent compared with an EU average of 40.2 per cent) (European Foundation 2001). This contrasts with the more detailed evidence from the UK studies reported here which suggests that whatever the respondents to the Foundation's survey may feel, the provision and understanding of information on chemical hazards in British workplaces is generally poor.
The United Kingdom 139
courts. Improvement notices are normally used to instruct duty holders to remedy a situation in which an inspector believes that there has been a breach of the law resulting in a risk to the health or safety of persons the law is intended to protect. The duty-holder is normally required to remedy the situation within a specified time period in accordance with the requirements laid out in the notice. Prohibition notices are normally issued where inspectors feel there is an imminent and serious risk to health and safety. They have the effect of prohibiting the continuation of the activity that is the cause of the risk as well as requiring it to be corrected in accordance with requirements identified in the notice. Not surprisingly, because of its power to stop work processes, the prohibition notice is generally regarded as the more serious of the two forms of enforcement action. However, failure to comply with either notice is a criminal offence that may result in prosecution. All these kinds of formal enforcement actions were possible actions for HSE inspectors seeking compliance from duty holders in relation to the COSHH Regulations. An indication of the role of enforcement in improving risk management of hazardous substances should be given by examination of records of the extent and nature of enforcement actions involving OELs that have been taken under the Regulations. This is theoretically possible because the Statistics Unit of the HSE records overall figures for enforcement actions by HSE on all aspects of health and safety. In addition HSE has an operational database (FOCUS) that provides further detail on the nature of enforcement notices and prosecutions, including a record of the Regulations under which they have been issued and notes on them filed by the inspector involved. Although not undertaken until sometime after the introduction of a changed role for OELs towards the end of the 1990s, HSE's own analysis of its enforcement record showed that despite their centrality to monitoring and control under COSHH, OELs played only a minor role in the enforcement of the Regulations. The HSE study was actually undertaken as part of the background information HSE produced to inform the Discussion Document on the OEL Framework (HSC 2002a). Nevertheless it analysed records of formal enforcement actions under the COSHH Regulations undertaken by the Field Operations Directorate (FOD) and the Hazardous Installations Directorate (HID),1'1 from the first full year in which
The two main units within the HSE inspectorate that were likely to have undertaken enforcement on chemical hazards. Although other HSE operational arms such as the Nuclear Inspectorate were not included in the study, its author believed such enforcement
140 Beyond Limits 140
they were in force (1990/91) and looked in more detail at the enforcement figures for 1997-2000. The aim of the study was to analyse the extent and type of enforcement action taken to control exposure to substances hazardous to health and in particular to evaluate the role of OELs in them. Its results do not present a comprehensive analysis of all forms of enforcement action in relation to managing chemical hazards, they nevertheless provide an indicative picture of the extent to which OELs featured in such actions."4 The analysis also identified the number of 'contacts' that mentioned COSHH recorded on the operational data base between 1997 and 2000. 'Contacts' is a generic term including all kinds of inspectorate field activities, from simple informative ones that might, for example, include providing a leaflet on COSHH during a general inspection to major investigations and prosecutions. An average of over 10,000 per year of contacts was found, suggesting that the general level of inspectorate activity involving COSHH was quite high during the 1990s.19* But such information tells us nothing about the nature of the action involved. Only a small proportion (between 1-3 per cent) of prosecutions taken during the period concerned COSHH. Between April 1996 and March 1999, there were 47 prosecutions covering a wide range of hazardous substances. The largest group were substances with OELs (over 50 pert cent of the total). However, less than half of the prosecutions mentioning these substances appeared to have concerned situations in which exposure by inhalation was the problem. Of the ones that did, the majority (13) involved incidents in which exposure was very much in excess of the OEL - generally resulting in serious (often fatal) acute effects. The author of the HSE research concluded that these cases represented situations in which
actions that may have been missed as a result were negligible in number compared with those undertaken by FOD and HID. As its author points out, although the COSHH Regulations are specifically concerned with chemical hazards, they are not the only Regulations under which an inspector might lake an enforcement action in relation to processes involving chemicals. For example it is likely that some of the situations addressed under the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations and the Workplace (Health Safety and Welfare) Regulations would also involve remedying health and safety management defects in relation to chemical risks. Indeed, the researcher's further interrogation of the database in relation to two common workplace substances 'indicated that the true number of COSHH contacts could be up to four times this figure*.
The United Kingdom 141
catastrophic loss of control had occurred and the type of limit had not been relevant in influencing the decision to prosecute. The data on enforcement notices was considerably more extensive and demonstrated several features of the role of OELs in regulatory intervention. They confirmed that regulatory action under COSHH was a significant activity for inspectors during the period of the review, accounting for between 12-21 per cent of all enforcement notices issued.196 As would be expected from the pattern of notices served generally, the majority of COSHH notices were improvement notices. There had been a decline in the number of notices issued annually during the 1990s. There had also been a shift in the proportion of notices issued under different Regulations with an decline in those issued under Regulation 6 on risk assessment and an increase in those issued under Regulation 7 on control and under Regulation 9 on maintenance of control measures. Prohibition notices had increased in overall numbers and in relation to their proportion in comparison with improvement notices. The explanation for the fall in absolute numbers of notices issued and changes in the proportions of notices issued under different Regulations was largely thought to reflect changes in FOD inspection policy priorities during the period. In the early 1990s, while the Regulations were still new, such policy focussed on risk assessments. As many employers had not yet undertaken them and issuing a notice to deal with this breach was a relatively straightforward matter, significant numbers were issued. At the time there was also considerable publicity given to the need for 'COSHH Assessments'. As time passed, there was a change in FOD policy with greater emphasis placed on control measures and their maintenance. The overall number of improvement notices issued under Regulation 6 declined significantly as a result.197 While there was a proportionate rise in the number of In 1990/91 a total of 2,518 improvement notices were issued under COSHH. Their annual number declined gradually during the 1990s to 1007 in 1999/00. In 1990/91 there were 136 prohibition notices issued. The numbers issued over the next ten years fluctuated between 80 to 150 per year until 1996/97, but increased significantly after this time, reaching 278 by 1999/00. A contributory reason for the decline after 1993 may have been the introduction of the MHSW Regulations 1992, which required risk assessment and some notices for failure to undertake risk assessment in relation to hazardous substances may have been served under Regulation 3 of these Regulations. A further influence on the overall decline of notices served under COSHH was also likely to be the decline in the numbers of notices issued on
142 Beyond Limits 142
notices issued under the Regulations dealing with control and its maintenance, their numbers did not entirely compensate for the fall in risk assessment notices. An additional factor in the decline of improvement notices in the mid-1990s was the introduction of requirements on inspectors to issue a notice of intent before an improvement notice was issued. This may have had the effect of obviating the need to issue an improvement notice in some cases since duty-holders would have made the necessary improvements under the notice of intent. This requirement was removed in 1997. A further influence on the decline of notices served under COSHH would have been the decline in the overall numbers of notices issued on all aspects of occupational health and safety. This was a reflection of the reduced resourcing for health and safety regulation and a general deregulatory drive that was Conservative Government policy during the 1990s (James and Walters 1998). However, the HSE research shows in its analysis that in fact improvement notices issued under COSHH maintained their profile of between 22-30 per cent of health and safety notices overall during this period. Paradoxically they declined in significance following the increase in general inspection activity that occurred from 1998 after the election of the Labour Government in 1997. Although in comparison with improvement notices the number of prohibition notices issued under COSHH was relatively small, they increased in overall number during the 1990s and also therefore in proportion to improvement notices. The explanation for this is most likely to be the planned inspection activities of the FOD in particular industry sectors. Here, clear guidance would have been provided to inspectors on control standards and level of enforcement required, thus increasing their confidence to take this more serious enforcement action in circumstances in which it was felt to be warranted. The detailed examination of the subject matter of enforcement notices issued between 1997 and 2000 looked at both the substances and processes that had been all aspects of occupational health and safety. This was part of the deregulatory drive and reduced resourcing for health and safety regulations that was Conservative Government policy during the 1990s (James and Walters 1998). It included instruction to inspectors to issue a notice of intent before an improvement notice was issued — this may have obviated the need to issue an improvement notice since duty-holders would have made the necessary improvements under the notice of intent. However, this requirement was removed in 1997.
The United Kingdom 143
of concern. It showed that substances with MELs dominated those that had featured in these regulatory interventions but at the same time there was considerable amount of COSHH enforcement activity in which it was the process involved that was the focus of enforcement rather than specific substances. However, even here, it was substances with MELs that were usually central to these processes. The two processes that featured most often in enforcement actions were sheep dipping and cement handling. Neither are particularly relevant to our interest in the role of OELs because cement handling essentially concerns dermatitis risks and in sheep dipping there was only one substance with an OEL198 and again the greatest concern there was with skin absorption. Their frequency in the enforcement statistics however, is further evidence of how COSHH enforcement was driven in relation to planning objectives since both had the subjects of planned enforcement campaigns during the period. In terms of understanding the position of OELs in relation to COSHH enforcement, the detailed analysis of substances and processes referred to in notices drew several conclusions. It showed that enforcement of control issues under Regulation 7 depended on evidence of the general inadequacy of control rather than on specific evidence of non-compliance with OELs. However, the existence of an OEL for a substance meant that the substance was likely to become a focus of attention by the enforcing authorities even if inspectors did not often concern themselves specifically and directly with OELs in individual workplaces. The HSE study argued that these observations suggested a probable explanatory mechanism of action as shown in Figure 4.3 and it would be anticipated that this mechanism would be stronger when the OEL was a MEL.
Diazonin
144 Beyond Limits 144
Figure 4.3 Mechanism of actions involving OELs
OEL established
HSE and industry examine what is required to achieve compliance
i r
Good practice guidance is published
Inspectors enforce adequate control under COSHH that is based on this guidance
The role of the type of OEL in influencing enforcement on control. The HSE research suggested that the confidence of inspectors that they were enforcing appropriately was an important factor in determining whether they took action. For example, an additional reason that helps to explain the high frequency of sheep dipping and cement handling in COSHH enforcement actions is that as well as being the subject of planned enforcement, they were both situations in which relatively straightforward effective and inexpensive control measures could be implemented and therefore ones in which inspectors would be confident about taking actions to insist on such measures. Planned enforcement campaigns also provided inspectors with much clearer guidance both on the level and type of enforcement required and on the technical issues in relation to control. In routine inspections on more complex situations inspectors would be likely to be less confident. While it might be anticipated that this would mean that in such situations they would resort to establishing whether OELs were being exceeded, perhaps by calling upon specialist assistance to determine this and to advise on
The United Kingdom 145
appropriate control, the HSE analysis of enforcement did not show this. Rather, the author of the research report argued, it demonstrated that in fact what was more likely to happen in such complex situations was that instead of taking action under Regulation 7 on control, the inspectors would be more inclined to take enforcement action under Regulation 6 on risk assessment, which was simpler.1" Employers' understanding, competence and use of OELs. The most significant issue concerning the role of OELs to emerge during this period was the extent to which they really featured in employers' strategies for managing the risks of hazardous substances under the COSHH Regulations, hi 1997, HSE published a commissioned market research study that measured perceptions and understanding of OELs amongst employers and to what extent they were useful and influenced industry in controlling exposure to hazardous airborne substances (Research International, 1997). The study population had been drawn from both light and heavy users of chemicals across a range of establishment size from less than ten employees to more than 200. A representative sample of managers responsible for health and safety in these establishments were interviewed by telephone. The results demonstrated that there was real cause for concern over the understanding and use of OELs by all users of chemicals and that, not surprisingly, the level of understanding and appropriate use of OELs was related to establishment size, and increased as size increased. The results of the survey suggested that most chemical users were taking some steps to control the risks of chemicals they used, in keeping with findings of previous research (OHR 1993). However they also showed that in doing so, little regard was paid to either information from the HSE or the core messages of the COSHH regulations concerning the preferred hierarchy of such control. Notions of substitution of hazardous substances for safer ones were rarely considered and the use of personal protective equipment was advocated by users with at least as much frequency as the preferred methods detailed in COSHH such as control at source through process modification or ventilation systems. The survey demonstrated that most users of chemicals relied on suppliers and on their personal experience for information on chemicals, with relatively few using sources such as the HSE. Most respondents indicated that their assessment of risks was based on 'common sense judgement' about the health effects of substances and how they are used at 199
It might also imply of course that inspectors did not have sufficient access to such resources for technical advice and support.
146 Beyond Limits 146
work. Concentrations of substances in workplace air were scarcely mentioned in this respect. Real knowledge of OELs was shown to be extremely low and very few respondents knew anything of the different types of limits defined by OES and MELs. Nearly half of the respondents did not know how they would go about finding out if an OEL was being met in their workplace. The survey showed clearly that OELs played very little part in either risk assessment or risk management in small and medium sized enterprises. Commenting on the survey's findings in a subsequent paper, policy staff from the Health Directorate of the HSE (Topping200 et al 1998) suggested that it raised important questions concerning the value of continuing to attempt to generate ever-increasing lists of OELs - already viewed by some as a somewhat Sisyphean task.201 Instead they argued that the survey's demonstration of the very low understanding and use of OELs called for a reappraisal of the system. They noted that although OELs were originally developed as technical standards against which to monitor the adequacy of controls - and large chemical firms may indeed have continued to use them effectively in this way - it was quite clear that most chemical users (including many heavy users) did not. They suggested that in the light of this evidence of poor understanding and limited use, it would be appropriate to consider the development of the role of OELs in more useful directions, arguing that they could also be utilised in other ways - such as, for example, in identifying appropriate control measures for users of chemicals without detracting from their original role. At the same time they suggested that the low awareness of OELs among most chemical users meant it was sensible in future to restrict the list of OELs to widely used substances where their toxicity was of concern.
Michael Topping was chairperson of ACTS. As Topping et al pointed out, there were well over 100,000 substances in use in Europe and only around 600 had OELs in the UK. A mere 10-20 were added or revised each year, meaning that setting limits for anything like the number of chemical substances in regular use was widely perceived to be impossible.
147 The United Kingdom 147
NEW APPROACHES TO CHEMICAL CONTROLS: A NEW ROLE FOR OELS? A new policy perspective on regulating the management of chemical hazards was beginning to emerge in the UK at the end of the 1990s, in which it was recognised that employers generally and especially those in smaller enterprises were unlikely to have the capacity to utilise the occupational hygiene approaches required by COSHH to control risks of the hazardous substances they used. There were two major points of departure for policy makers in relation to a continued role for OELs in the UK. One advocated an approach in which OELs would be utilised in identifying appropriate control measures that could be recommended to users of chemicals in addition to their traditional functions standards for checking the control of risks. The other called for a pragmatic recognition that it was entirely unrealistic to pursue policy based on the notion that all toxic substances likely to pollute the air of British workplaces could be given an OEL that would be understood and used appropriately.202 The paper by Topping et al referred to earlier was an introduction to this new approach from the HSE. The issue of the Annals of Occupational Hygiene in which it appeared in 1998 was devoted to the role of OELs in the risk management of hazardous substances. The three papers that followed it in the same issue, were all written by members of the HSE Health Policy directorate and its occupational hygiene support staff. In combination they introduced a scheme for helping small firms control chemical risks and outlined the hygiene and toxicological thinking behind it (Russell et al 1998; Maidment 1998; Brooke 1998). The papers presented an approach developed by HSE specialists in conjunction with a working party set up by ACTS, on which the interests of trade unions and
This was the pragmatic view of reality under the UK health and safety system, in which expert occupational hygiene advice was restricted to discretionary use by a diminishing number of large employers that were significant users of hazardous substances. Commentators on the suggested policy implications by Topping et al, pointed out that the UK was virtually the only country in Europe that did not have any statutory requirements on the quality and use of prevention services. Such suggestions for policy s might be less persuasive under arrangements that required employers to make use of qualified expertise (Ogden 1998).
148 Beyond Limits 148
employers had been represented as well as that of independent expertise. They began by acknowledging that the research findings on the level of understanding and use of OELs by most employers showed that such limits played only a minor role in controlling chemical risks in the majority of workplaces and especially in smaller workplaces. They contended that if employers in these smaller enterprises did not have the capacity to use OELs in the way intended, other ways of utilising information and approaches to managing the risks of hazardous substances that were within their capacities to access and understand needed to be found. In particular the approach they wished to advocate built on the observation in the original research reported by Topping et al - that the single most used source of information by employers in SMEs was that provided by suppliers. Therefore they proposed an approach in which this information - and particularly the R-phrases used on suppliers' safety data sheets and on labels required under CHIP - could be utilised to better effect in establishing generic and accessible control criteria.203 In this way, in most cases the need for detailed understanding and use of OELs would be obviated. This was not an entirely new concept in occupational hygiene circles. Since the early 1990s the scientific literature had contained a detailed discussion of some of the ideas that underpinned the HSE proposals. For example, several methods for grouping substances into different risk categories of seriousness (exposure banding) and developing appropriate controls for their use that could be applied generically across such groups (control banding) had been the subject of analysis and comment in previous years, hi addition some industry associations and professional bodies had produced their own guidance to the COSHH requirements based on a similar conceptualisation.204 The significance of the scheme proposed by the HSE was that it was not only building on these earlier industry approaches to setting in-house limits but also The further advantage they identified in using such R-phrases was that they were based on the classification system required at EU level and would in time be harmonised across the whole of the EU member states. These approaches had been outlined for example in relation to aromatic amines and related compounds (Money 1992); for pharmaceutically active substances (Nauman et al 1996) for volatile organic substances (Gardner and Oldershaw 1991) and for laboratory chemicals (Royal Society of Chemistry 1996), on occupational exposure bands for colourants (CIA 1993) and subsequently by the Chemical Industries Association in guidance to its members covering a wider range of hazardous substances (CIA 1997; Guest 1998).
The United Kingdom 149
that it was particularly geared to the needs of SMEs. Consequently, it emphasised accessibility and ease of understanding as well as use of hazard information that was most readily available. Rather than setting in-house limits or control bands its objective was to provide clear advice on good practice in relation to appropriate controls and their selection. A simple system of generic assessment based on readily available suppliers' hazard information (R phrases etc) combined with likely use scenarios was outlined. It was argued that it was possible to determine a range of adequate control strategies and advice based on analogy with substances with similar hazardous properties to which OELs were already assigned. In essence therefore, the model represented a process in which hazards and exposure potential (based on the extent of their likely-use) could be grouped in various combinations that would generate appropriate control measures. The R-phrases defined under the CHIP Regulations were grouped into five bands covering the range of seriousness of health effects resulting from inhalation (and a sixth covering skin and eye contact). Each band signified a different level of seriousness of health effect - and therefore different level of control measure required. Although the scheme was not entirely comprehensive - it could not cover substances outside the scope of CHIP such as pesticides and Pharmaceuticals for example, it was nevertheless sufficiently wide ranging in its coverage to be thought to be a useful improvement on existing approaches.205 Having established a means of grouping potential health hazards of substances, the second element of the scheme was to establish similar system for grouping potential exposure - that is - how much of the substance was likely to be in the breathing zone of workers. Two factors were thought to broadly determine this: the physical properties of substances (their dustiness or volatility) and the amount in use. Simple definitions of physical properties and usage were therefore proposed (high, medium or low dustiness and volatility and usage of small, medium or large amounts of substances (by weight or volume)).
It was also recognised that the scheme could not apply to process generated hazards such as fume and wood dust for example nor did it fully take into account the duration of exposure in its predictive approach to exposure potential. Its control strategies therefore were most relevant to shorter-term exposures. Commentary on the occupational hygiene aspects of the model recognised that little was known of the actual exposure of workers in small enterprises and it was possible that actual exposures may in some cases be of longer duration than originally thought (Maidment 1998).
150 Beyond Limits 150
These generic approaches to health hazards and potential exposure were matched by equally generic approaches to exposure utilising three basic control methods general ventilation, engineering control, containment and a fourth approach that signalled that special controls needing expert advice were required - to help achieve levels of exposure in line with the exposure ranges deemed to be acceptable risks for the previously identified hazard bands A-D.206 The scheme would be operationalised through the provision of simple, good practice advice on the form of controls applied to particular operations through a series of operationbased guidance sheets. Access to these guidance sheets was to be supported by exploiting existing information routes used by owner managers of SMEs such as suppliers, trade associations, trade union representatives and OHS professionals. The basic scheme was presented as simple step-by-step guidance with checklists to guide the reader through the process of assessment necessary to identify the appropriate control for the substance in question and a means of identifying the appropriate control guidance sheet for whatever operation the user required. Each control guidance sheet was intended to provide users with sufficient information to check the adequacy of existing control measures or to install appropriate new controls. They were written in a jargon free style covering basic information on setting up specific controls and good operational practice and supporting advice on personal protective equipment, training needs, maintenance examination and testing. The HSE proponents of the scheme argued that OELs were fundamental to the technical basis for its existence. They maintained that following its guidance would result in controls being put in place that would achieve compliance with OELs for substances in work place air, where OELs existed for such substances. The papers that detailed the scientific reasoning and experimentation behind the scheme's development went to some lengths to describe the extent to which its approach built upon the existing role of OELs and had been evaluated against toxicological and occupational hygiene considerations of the same order as those employed in setting OELs (Brooke 1998; Maidment 1998). Brooke (1998) showed how the use of R-phrases as the basis for the identification of appropriate The fifth band, E, included substances that present the most serious health risks such as carcinogens and signalled very tight control and specialist advice, and the sixth related to skin and eye contact for which separate measures of control were to be proposed.
The United Kingdom 151
control strategies in the scheme led to recommendations for controls that were equivalent to or more stringent than that required by the health based OEL for 98 per cent of substances tested that possessed them. For the two substances where the scheme would have resulted in a level of control lower than that indicated by their OELs, in both cases the results could be explained by anomalies in the information on the OEL and it was argued that even for these substance the controls that would be set under the scheme would in practice be adequate. In addition it was maintained that the scheme was aimed at small firms in which there was little chance of OELs being used appropriately. Therefore it did not in any way serve to undermine the role of OELs in determining the adequacy of workplace controls in establishments in which there was dedicated health and safety expertise to do so. Nevertheless, there seems little doubt in hindsight that these developments were important milestones in the changing conceptualisation of the role of OELs in what was seen to be the achievement of pragmatic and practicable approaches to risk management of for all users of hazardous substances in the UK. In essence the proponents of the scheme were suggesting that its pragmatic approach recognised the realities of work in small enterprise and offered practicable strategies for risk assessment and control of hazardous substances in these premises. They maintained that such strategies were in keeping with the legislative principles of risk assessment and control under the HSW Act and the COSHH Regulations. However they achieved their ends without requiring duty holders to have recourse to the little understood technical basis for such control that was required to implement the monitoring, evaluation and control principles of occupational hygiene that were part of the original conceptualisation of COSHH and in which OELs played a direct role in the workplace. Instead, in the new approach, OELs while still fundamental, were returned to their more appropriate position in the domain of the expert. Secondly, this revised role for OELs as part of the specification process for control strategies, in combination with the acknowledgment of the evidence of their poor understanding by users generally, and the large number of chemical substances on the market, was also a reason for arguing that setting more OELs were not necessarily the most effective way forward. Rather, it was suggested that it would be more appropriate to restrict the list of OELs to widely used substances of concern (Topping et al 1998). As Ogden (1998) speculated with the title to his editorial in the issue of the Annals of Occupational Hygiene in which these proposals first appeared, they
152 Beyond Limits 152
seemed to suggest the 'Sunset of Exposure Limits. . . .' but as he pointed out in the editorial itself, whether they were to represent the '. . Dawn of Something Better?' would remain to be seen. In a subsequent editorial in the same journal some two years later he further pointed out that the real test of the proposals would be research evidence on the extent and success if their use (Ogden 2000).
OELS AND C O S H H ESSENTALS IN PRACTICE In the last five years two related themes have been pursued in regulatory policy on chemical risk management in the UK. Both have antecedents in the developments discussed in the previous two sections. First, there has been the continued evolution of the regulatory position of OELs, in the course of which public consultation has taken place concerning a new Framework for OELs that was finally agreed in 2004. Second, implementation of the strategy for regulating the management of the risks of hazardous substances described in the previous section has taken place with a much publicised rolling out of the HSE scheme known as COSHH Essentials. This scheme, based on the ideas discussed in the previous section was intended to provide a practicable approach to achieving improved risk management across the full range of users of chemicals at the work and not just those in a position to utilise appropriate expertise. In this section we look at the inter-relationship between these two parallel developments as well as the other factors that have influenced the thinking behind the British position in relation to the current and future role of OELs in improving the work environment. COSHH Essentials. The HSE COSHH Essentials scheme provided guidance to chemical users - especially those in small and medium sized firms - through making available materials as aids to risk assessment and control along the lines described in the previous section. It was a simple, checklist based risk assessment that led the user to a control approach deemed suitable for their chemicals or tasks through users entering information about the chemicals they used onto a checklist. As noted previously the information required concerned the hazard group to which substances belonged - the 6 groups described previously (A-E and group S for substances causing harm through skin contact), based on the Risk Phrases for chemicals that
The United Kingdom 153
should be identified on the suppliers' data sheet. The amount used (small, medium, large) was noted as was the physical properties in terms of dustiness for solids and volatility for liquids. A table then directed the user to one of four generic control approaches: i. general ventilation ii. engineering control iii. containment iv. when very hazardous chemicals and risky tasks were identified, the guidance directed users to seek specialist advice. The guidance included practical advice on using the approaches to control and on how to obtain specialist help. There were 60 illustrated control guidance sheets giving good practice advice for common tasks such as weighing, mixing and sieving chemical substances and additional sheets on avoiding skin and eye contact and on protective equipment. In 2001 the HSE commissioned a survey of the use of COSHH Essentials amongst the small and medium sized companies (with fewer that 249 employees) that had purchased it (Wiseman and Gilbert 2002). The sample showed a marked bias towards firms in manufacturing and although it and COSHH Essentials were aimed at SMEs, it was the larger of these firms that predominated amongst the purchasers and users of the guidance. Of the 500 firms in the survey approximately three fifths had taken some action since purchasing the pack and the majority of these thought they now knew how to do risk assessments, were confident of their risk assessments and thought they now knew how to control chemical health risks at the workplace. Although COSHH Essentials was initially introduced as a paper system an interactive electronic version soon followed using the same checklist based approach. Uptake of this version is monitored and recent results available from HSE indicate that its site has received a substantial number of visits since its launch (over 400,000 visits made by over 170,000 visitors and with over 165,000 COSHH Assessments completed by September 2004). While these limited findings indicate something of the uptake and opinions of users of COSHH Essentials about their use they unable to provide objective information concerning the nature of use and they are therefore of little help in evaluating the effectiveness of the guidance in comparison with other approaches
154 Beyond Limits 154
to risk assessment and control of chemical hazards in which OELs might feature more centrally. Nor are they particularly helpful in measuring the scale of use. OELs for the new millennium? The emerging understanding of the limitations to the role of OELs and their place in occupational hygiene 'best practice' in chemical risk management for the majority of users was a problematic issue for the strategic approach to regulating chemical risk management. Coupled with the technical, scientific, legal and economic problems associated with the setting and meaning of OELs, it was enough to give regulatory policy makers pause for thought over the appropriateness of the existing system. If such concerns were not sufficient, there were further problems caused by the compatibility of the UK system with the requirements of EU Directives. In particular the British system was out of step with that required by the Chemical Agents Directive, in which member states were obliged to set limits at levels taking into account those in the IOELV Directives. In 2002 a Discussion Document was published in which views were sought on a set of proposals for a revised UK Framework for OELs. Essentially they identified a set of seven key objectives for OELs. They were: 1. OELs should control risks to health — They should provide standards that could be used along with other information to decide on appropriate control measures and to assess the adequacy of measures in place 2. OELs should be readily understood and accessible — The OEL framework should be based on a clear and coherent set of concepts that employers and employees understand, but application at the workplace needs professional input 3. OELs should be legally enforceable - They should provide legally enforceable standards for the adequacy of control by inhalation and they are for use when prevention of exposure is not reasonably practicable 4. OELs should be comprehensive — The OEL Framework must be comprehensive and capable of application to all substances. It should be capable of application to generic groups of substances. The Framework must be developed and presented in such a way that it will not encourage employers to use substances without OELs that are not adequately evaluated 5. OELs should comply with EC legislation
United Kingdom 155 155 The United
6. OELs should be flexible and able to take on board new developments in science and technology 7, OELs should provide incentives to reduce exposures. Three models were proposed in which a modified UK system might provide a framework within which these objectives for OELs might be achieved. One involved minor tinkering with the existing system - an option that the Discussion Document indicated would not solve the problems it identified. The remaining two proposals required somewhat more radical change. They outlined a system of exposure limits that were linked to regulatory requirements concerning good practice. The second proposal was based around a system of single limits while the third retained a dual-limit system but proposed similar links to good practice as the second. For substances with exposure limits both proposals recommended that the definition of 'adequate control' in Regulation 7 of the COSHH Regulations should consist of two components that employers must operate together to 'apply the principles of good occupational hygiene practice; and comply with the limit value*. Compliance under the new definition would mean: 'The good practice requirement would represent what a good employer does to ensure that exposure to a substance with an exposure limit is not exceeded'. These principles of good practice were to be amplified in guidance for particular substance-task combinations. As a default the COSHH Essentials approach was to be specified - making use of the HSE's work relating exposures to different levels of control specified under COSHH Essentials. All but two of the respondents to the Discussion Document207 were supportive of one or other of these two proposals. HSE concluded from its analysis of responses and of additional views received during its efforts to disseminate and discuss material on these issues that there was overwhelming support for a single limit system that was coupled to good advice on controlling chemicals (HSC 2003:9).
There were 58 responses received. According to the HSE's analysis only two did not support either the second or third proposal (HSC 2003). See also http://www.hse.gov.iik/aboutus/hsc/iacs/211102Zpaper43.pdf for the full analysis of the responses to the Discussion Document.
156 Beyond Limits 156
Based on these conclusions a Consultation Document was published that made proposals to introduce a new OEL Framework (HSC 2003) that was a combination of the second and third options described in the Discussion Document. It reiterated the belief that many employers, particularly in small firms, did not know about OELs and of those that did, very few understood how to work out whether the chemicals in the air at their workplaces were above or below the relevant OELs. Because of this and other work on small firms it argued that a new approach was necessary. It advocated the replacement of the two types of OELs that had been in use since the mid-1980s (the OES and MEL) with a single type of OEL to be known as a workplace exposure limit (WEL). Employers would be required to ensure that the amount of chemical in workplace air did not exceed the WEL. However, since it was recognised that only for very few chemicals was there sufficient information to be able to say with certainty that harm would not occur to anyone exposed at the WEL, it was not possible to regard them as 'safe limits'. Since it was essential that such uncertainties be accounted for in any system that aimed to protect workers properly a new COSHH Regulation 7 (7) replaced the COSH 2002 Reg. & (7) and 7 (8). It stated: 7 (7)
Without prejudice to the generality of paragraph (1) , where there is exposure to a substance hazardous to health, control of that exposure shall only be treated as adequate if(1)
(2) (3)
the principles of good practice for the control of exposure to substances hazardous to health set out in Schedule 2 A208 are applied;^ any workplace exposure limit approved for that substance is not exceeded for a substance which carries the risk phrase R45, R46 or R49209 or for a substance or process which is listed in Schedule 1, the level of exposure is reduced so far as is reasonably practicable.
These are the 'principles of good occupational hygiene practice' previously referred to which were now to be introduced as a schedule to the Regulations (and therefore have the force of law). R45 — substances that may cause cancer. R46 —substances that may cause heritable genetic damage. R49 — substances that may cause cancer by inhalation.
The United Kingdom 157
A key feature of the new proposals therefore was to link principles of good practice with compliance with the WEL. In so doing the proposed regulations would require employers to both apply principles of good practice and not exceed the WEL. hi addition specific requirements to reduce the amounts of carcinogens in workplace air to as low as is reasonably practicable (ALARP) were to be specified. To deal with the issue of employers' understanding, the consultative document proposed: - ' For each substance that has a WEL, HSE will produce practical advice that will tell employers what they have to do to control for their use of the chemical. For chemicals that can cause cancer HSE's advice will explain what ALARP means in practice. Thus employers will not simply be left with a number, as in the present OEL system but will have information on what they have to do to comply with the law'. The practical advice that it proposed would 'link together information on WELs, COSHH Essentials - which gives practical advice - and more in depth information on individual chemicals and the COSHH Regulations'. However, the consultative document also suggested that the existing list of over 500 OELs contained many for which the evidence on which they had been set was no longer considered reliable. Initially it was proposed that only existing OELs that were considered to be scientifically robust would be transferred to the new system of WELs. HSE estimated that this would reduce the list of substances with regulatory OELs to around 150. This proposal was greeted with consternation by respondents to the Consultative Document, and especially by the representatives of the occupational hygiene practitioner community who viewed many of the original OESs as useful standards, even if they were adopted from earlier TLV lists in which the evidence on which they had been set was incomplete by current standards.210
Indeed such concern was recognised by ACTS and the HSC and the final version of the new OEL Framework modified this proposal to that of withdrawing only those OESs for which there was concern that about whether human health is protected at the level of the OES. This in effect meant that only 100 of the 322 OESs that were not transferable under the original proposals, would not be transferred into the new system as WELs.
158 Beyond Limits 158
New WELs would be set according to a new set of criteria that would: -
allow WELs to be set for any substance of concern and enable Indicative Occupational Exposure limit Values (IOELVs) and Binding Occupational Exposure Limit Values (BOELVs) to be implemented as WELs without lengthy debate as to whether they should be implemented as OESs or MELs.
The WEL setting process was summarised in the diagram reproduced in Fig 4.4. It was acknowledged in the Consultative Document, that although it was possible to identify a 'threshold' of effect for some substances in the context of OEL setting, for others it was not. Therefore the concepts of No Observed Adverse Effect Level (the highest point on the exposure response curve at which no adverse health effects are observed - NOAEL) and Lowest Observed Adverse Effect Level (the lowest point on the exposure-response curve at which adverse effects are observed- LOAEL) only have practical relevance for OEL setting for those substances or toxicological mechanisms that have a threshold effect. For others such as DNA reactive chemicals that cause cancer by a genotoxic mechanism, although in theory a threshold may exist, currently available techniques do not allow reliable identification of the NOAEL. Additionally there are further substances, such as those that cause asthma for example, or mixtures of substances of variable compositions such as found in metal fumes for which it is not possible to define a single NOAEL for human health. Moreover the balance of doubt and uncertainty about likely human health effects for substances for which toxicological data is inadequate means that a threshold of effect cannot be predicted with any certainty for substances for which such data is incomplete. Finally, even when such a threshold can be confidently predicted there are some substances for which the costs involved in its achievement mean that it is not reasonably practicable to set an OEL at the level that would result in no adverse human health effects. For all such substances therefore the Consultative Document makes it clear that the WEL would be derived by identifying a level of exposure that would represent a standard of control that was commensurate with good occupational hygiene practice and as far as possible would not be set at a level at which there was positive evidence of adverse effects on human health. Although many of these caveats concerning the limits of toxicological understanding in relation to NOAELs and LOAELs and their application to OEL setting are familiar from previous approaches to setting OELs, the generally
159 The United Kingdom 159
greater emphasis on explicitly distancing OELs from the idea that they could be taken as 'safe levels' - such as was exemplified in the frank acknowledgement of the limits of scientific knowledge that characterised the procedures outlined for setting limits - distinguished the approach taken in Consultative Document. Figure 4.4: Summary of WEL setting procedures (after HSC 2003)
Assessment of Toxicology Toxicology Assessment
Assessment of Occupational Occupational Assessment Exposure Exposure
Identify exposure exposure level at which which no Identify adverse health health effects effects would be expected expected adverse known and/or and/or to occur based based on the known predicted effects effects of the substances substances and predicted that is also reasonably reasonably practical practical to achieve achieve
possible, identify identify exposure exposure If this is not possible, level achievable achievable with good control taking into account account nature/severity nature/severity of health health hazards and costs/efficacy of control hazards costs/efficacy control solutions solutions
Recommend WEL at this level Recommend
SUMMARY OF WEL SETTING PROCEDURES (AFTER HSC 2003) On the need for monitoring to ensure compliance in the case of substances with OELs the Consultative Document indicated that the circumstances in which monitoring was required remained unchanged from those set out in the COSHH Regulations 2002. However it also made it clear that if employers were following good practice advice and ensuring controls were functioning correctly (for example by monitoring airflow into local exhaust ventilation) it may not be necessary to monitor for hazardous substances, since such good practice should have served to keep their concentrations below the relevant WELs. On the question of enforcement the Consultative Document referred to the current enforcement strategy of the HSE for health and safety issues generally. It drew attention to the HSC enforcement policy statement setting out the principles inspectors should apply when determining what enforcement action to take in
160 Beyond Limits 160
response to breaches of statutory duty (HSC 2004). It went on to outline the HSE's Enforcement Management Model, developed by HSE to enable its inspectors to make enforcement decisions consistent with the Policy Statement. This approach was intended to operate by comparing the risk associated with a particular set of circumstances with a relevant benchmark to ascertain the 'risk gap' - that is, the level of residual risk once actions required by law were met. In the area of health risks both the principle of good practice for the control of substances hazardous to health and the existence of OELs were seen as critical in determining the relevant benchmark. If duty holders were applying the principles of good practice, then they should not exceed the relevant WEL. However, although WELs would be useful in determining benchmarks for certain substances and their breach indicate a substantial risk gap which by definition would anticipate some form of enforcement action, the Consultative Document also made clear: ' The increased emphasis on these principles of good practice for the control of substances hazardous to health reinforces the message that a judgement on the potential extent of exposure should take into account a variety of elements including: the condition of any control measure provided; the maintenance of any control measures provided; the provision of adequate instruction, training, and supervision and the consequences of limited health surveillance. The judgement is not necessarily dependent on measured exposure against limits.' (our italics) To understand the statements on enforcement in the Consultative Document they need to be viewed in the context of existing evidence on the role of OELs in inspectorate strategies seeking compliance with regulatory measures on risk management for hazardous substances. These in turn need to be understood within the context of evidence on the role of enforcement generally in health and safety in the UK. As we saw earlier, the evidence on enforcement practice gathered before the introduction of COSHH essentials and the consultation on the new OEL framework suggested that OELs did not normally feature directly in regulatory interventions to improve the management of chemical risks. Instead, their most significant influence was more indirect. The existence of an OEL and especially a MEL (signifying a serious risk to health) was most likely to act as a signal to regulatory inspection that attention should given to compliance with approaches to
The United Kingdom 161
control. Since guidance on such approaches was increasingly likely to have been documented in the case of substances with MELs, regulatory inspectors could refer to them with reasonable confidence. MELs and guidance on control in processes in which substances with MELs are involved might also for the same reasons feature in planned inspections and sectoral inspection campaigns, themselves powerful determinants of quantitative trends in the nature of enforcement. Taken together all these factors would be likely to reduce the necessity of measurement to check compliance with OELs in the majority of cases as there would be other more obvious means of determining the extent to which processes complied with the relevant guidance. In situations in which this was not the case, but where substances with OELs were present, there may be good theoretical reasons for anticipating that inspectors might undertake, order or commission measurements, but enforcement statistics suggest that the resources and time involved in doing so were more likely to result in inspectors switching to a different focus for regulatory action and requiring simpler risk assessment measures from employers. In some cases this might demand that the duty holder organise monitoring and checking compliance with OELs but in most cases probably required more preliminary levels of risk assessment. The evidence on enforcement practice therefore resonates with the approaches to control of hazardous chemicals developed by the HSE outlined in previous sections and with the proposed OEL Framework. Here again, while monitoring airborne concentrations of hazardous chemicals in relation to their OELs was not ruled out for duty-holders with the resources to do so, it was not central to the broader strategy. In this strategy OELs functioned most significantly both in signalling the need for control and in specifying the most appropriate means of achieving it. The new Framework was therefore unlikely to require significant change in the role of OELs in existing inspection practices.
CONCLUSIONS: APPLYING THE NEW FRAMEWORK IN PRACTICE At the time of writing the new OEL Framework is not yet in force. However, as the preceding pages have outlined, a UK model for controlling the risks of hazardous substances at work that has developed over the past 20 years and in which the Framework sits is now well established. The role of OELs has
162 Beyond Limits 162
undergone a particular evolution within this model. Starting with the incorporation of what was essentially the ACGIH list of TLVs into UK regulation and guidance in the early 1980s, the regulatory position of OELs was central to the introduction of principles of good occupational hygiene practice that characterised the COSHH Regulations. At this point as well as putting in place mechanisms for setting new OELs, the Regulations introduced two categories of OEL, the OES and the MEL. However, evidence of the lack of understanding and use of OELs, coupled with concerns about aspects of the process of setting them, what they represented in terms of safety, and the growing evidence that they played only a limited role in enforcement, as well as the recognition that substances with OELs were only ever likely to represent a small proportion of all substances in use at the workplace, led to a reorientation of the thinking behind their role in regulating the control of substances hazardous to workers' health at the workplace. The new thinking combined some of the generic approaches that had emerged to managing risks of hazardous substances in specific industries and processes, with suppliers' information requirements on the health risk of their products and the production of official guidance on control. It gave the generic control solutions that resulted more widespread application. Such approaches, it was argued, largely obviated the necessity for monitoring airborne concentrations of hazardous substances to ensure compliance in comparison with OELs (although it did not prevent them from being undertaken in situations where this could be carried out competently). It also shifted the position of OELs from being tools involved in monitoring compliance to being indicators of specification in the design and implementation of control techniques in a scenario in which regulatory emphasis was on linking principles of good practice with compliance with OELs through requiring employers both to apply principles of good practice and not exceed the relevant OEL. Their current role, as defined by the Framework, as well as relating to the development of the approach to regulating chemical risk also has several features that resonate with the wider profile of regulation of the work environment generally in the UK. This wider profile includes emphasis on the 'network of production* in which suppliers, users and regulators are involved in a mesh of economic, social and regulatory relationships. The emphasis on the role of the supply chain as a major source of information and influence in relation to chemicals fits with the wider perspective on regulating health and safety management generally.
United Kingdom 163 163 The United
It is also clear that policies aimed at achieving improvements in health and safety in relation to small firms, and in increasingly fragmented work organisations, no longer rely solely on traditional means of informing and enforcing compliance with regulatory standards. It is now broadly accepted that such approaches have limited relevance to the experience of work in these situations and additionally are insufficiently resourced to reach any more than a small element of the vast array of work situations that can be thus categorised. These conclusions have underpinned a major shift in the focus of regulatory strategies on health and safety in the UK in recent years. They are prominent for example in the HSE Small Firms Strategy211 in which levers and pressures in the socio-economic environment, as well as intermediary actors and organisations are identified as important elements that can be exploited to achieve better compliance with regulatory standards amongst small firms. As well as making advice and information more relevant to the needs of small firms generally, the use of intermediary actors, partnerships and processes is identified as an important element in the social amplification of the necessity for relevant risk management strategies in these situations. The problem of understanding and use of OELs was most extreme amongst small firms. Measures to address this through utilising the intermediaries and sources of information that evidence points to owner managers in small firms using and trusting most, coupled with simplified and generic approaches to control is therefore best understood within the above broader strategy for regulatory intervention in these firms. Additionally, recent regulatory policy places considerable emphasis on a 'multidimensional' approach to regulatory intervention in which inspection and enforcement is viewed as but one of a number of strategies to improve compliance with standards.212 Others include education and awareness raising, working with those most at risk, using intermediaries, finding ways to motivate senior managers and using sector wide initiatives, partnership, the supply chain and design as See for example HSE Small Firms Strategy (http://www.hse.gov.uk/aboutus/hse/policy/ strategy.htm). Also Walters (2001) and James et al (2004) for a critique of these approaches. See for example the Consultative Document on this strategy (HSE 2004a) and the 'HSE statement on providing accessible advice and support', www.hse.gov.uk/aboutus/plans/ index/htm.
164 Beyond Limits Limits 164
means to increase health and safety standards. According to HSE's own analysis OELs have played no more than a very minor role in formal enforcement actions. They are however probably significant as triggers for the consideration of 'multidimensional interventions' by inspectors and the new OEL Framework, with its reduced number of OELs about which more reliable evidence has been gathered, may prove even more useful in this respect, as well as providing clearer and more accessible information for owner managers, higher risk enterprises and at sectoral levels. While OEL framework and its reorientation of emphasis for OELs resonate well with this wider strategic outlook, it is also important to note that both it and the wider outlook can be seen as essentially pragmatic responses on the part of poorly resourced regulators to a situation in which their limited means dictates recourse to other players and processes to intervene in their stead. Moreover, while there is relatively strong evidence that the traditional means of regulation such as inspection is successful, one criticism of the 'multidimensional' strategy is that there is far less reliable evidence that such other means as those identified above have anything like the same degree of success.213 At the moment the same might be said of the role of OELs in chemical risk management - that is - there is long-standing evidence to suggest that where they are used properly they are effective in the application of the principles of good occupational hygiene to manage the risks of hazardous substances. The fact that it has been shown that many employers, and especially those in small enterprises, do not use them properly is evidence of their lack of access to good advice and support. There is some evidence that when used appropriately the guidance on control that is now distributed as COSHH Essentials will provide the same level of good occupational hygiene standards but in much simplified and less resourceintensive ways gathered by practitioners in controlled circumstances (Russell et al 1998; Maidment 1998; Russell 1998; Tischer et al 2003). There is also some This point is made in relation to small firms in Walters (2001:3 80-84) and in James et al (2004). A report commissioned by the HSE also points out that many of the new ways of accessing contacting and influencing employers are untested (Greenstreet Berman 2004). A study for the Centre for Corporate Accountability provides an extensive review of the international literature and strongly supports the role of enforcement, as does a more analytical Canadian study on the international literature which argues that there is strong evidence that enforcement action improves health and safety performance with better effect than other approaches ( Davis 2004; Tompa et al 2004).
The United Kingdom 165
evidence of the uptake of the COSHH Essentials guidance by users. However, there is little evidence that COSHH Essentials is reaching the full extent of the number and spread of potential users. Equally important, there is little evidence that COSHH Essentials is used properly by the firms that have accessed it. Just as the application of good occupational hygiene principles rely on preconditions such as the availability of expertise, resources to support it and incentives that influence employers' willingness to utilise it, there are preconditions that will determine the effective uptake of the current COSHH approach. They probably include: -
incentives for employers to use COSHH Essentials, including the role of enforcement if they fail to sufficient OHS competence on the part of employers to appreciate why the approach is necessary good access to COSHH Essentials advice access to good quality suppliers' information dissemination of this information to workers, their supervisors and representatives.
There is so far very little information concerning the extent to which such preconditions are in fact in place. Critics of the current UK strategy have pointed out that one of its aims is to obviate the need for occupational hygiene expertise by firms that do not think they have access to it - this is particularly so in relation to measurement and control issues especially in relation to the role of OELs. Yet, under UK and European regulatory requirements employers are required to discharge their OHS duties competently or through the use of competent advice. Conventionally in relation to OELs competent expertise exists in the form of occupational hygiene practitioners who are employed in the safety, health and environment departments of large organisations or act as consultants operating independently or as part of more comprehensive external prevention services. In the UK, unlike in most other EU countries, the regulatory requirements on the role of such competent advice loosely interpret the measures of the Framework Directive and leave a considerable degree of discretion to employers as to whether they choose to use this expertise. Furthermore, unlike some other EU countries, in the UK the role of consultants and prevention services is entirely market based. There are virtually no legislative requirements concerning the composition or quality of prevention
166 Beyond Limits Limits 166
services, nor are there any means with which firms can access their services without having to pay for them directly.214 Under such circumstances it is therefore not surprising that they are mainly the preserve of large organisations that have both the awareness and resources available to utilise them. Furthermore in such an unregulated environment those services that are available to smaller, less well-resourced clients may not themselves actually have the relevant occupational hygiene expertise to be able to advise on issues involving the measurement and control of chemical hazards and the use of OELs competently.215 An alternative approach therefore would be one in which there was greater specialist support for employers, including those in small firms, who are significant users of hazardous chemicals. This would probably require the implementation of some elements of a more 'European' approach to external prevention services. Such views were quite forcefully expressed during the consultation exercise on the new OEL Framework. As a former president of Institute of Occupational Hygienists (one of the professional bodies accrediting occupational hygienists in the UK) put it (Allen 2004:9): 'Defining and implementing effective exposure controls appropriate for the task and affordable to the employer, is crucial to avoiding harm to Many EU countries have explicit requirements on employers to use occupational health and safety advice (Vogel 2001). Many also have requirements concerning the competency of the services that provide such servies and some (such as the Netherlands and Denmark for example) have certification requirements for occupational health and safety services, without which such services cannot function. Arguably, the vision of prevention services projected by the Framework Directive is an integrated service that provides a range of expertise that is capable of addressing the multi-dimensional range of elements frequently encounters in current work environment issues. This includes occupational hygiene (Walters, ed. 2002). An additional problem that is not unique to the UK may be that regulatory inspectors themselves do not have the necessary expertise to feel sufficiently confident to require monitoring and control measures involving the understanding and use of OELs from employers. This may be a factor in the low level of enforcement involving the use of OELs, which in turn fails to provide the incentives to employers to seek sufficient access to expertise to enable the competent use of OELs in monitoring and control of chemical hazards.
United Kingdom 167 167 The United
individuals. Getting it right isn't always simple and easy, especially for small and medium sized enterprises. The best way to do this is to provide an effective occupational health and hygiene service to SMEs and for HSE to rigorously enforce the law where necessary...'
The special interest group on exposure monitoring of the British Occupational Hygiene Society expressed further concern that the effects of the new OEL Framework would be damaging to the collection of data on workplace exposures and to the survival of the professions that support preventive approaches to occupational health (Allen 2004:9): 'Occupational hygienists together with occupational physicians, occupational nurses, ergonomists, health and safety officers and others play a crucial role in the prevention of occupationally related disease. Without occupational hygiene it will be much more difficult to achieve this. Unfortunately [the Consultative Document on the OEL Framework] is set to undermine the foundation of occupational hygiene: the ability to define new workplace hazards by collecting and interpreting exposure measurements'. and 'Rather than diminishing the need for collecting exposure data the HSE should be encouraging collection of good quality exposure data for use in future epidemiological studies especially in SMEs.' That such notions are not merely a reflection of the protectionist approaches of professional interest groups is indicated by the expression of similar concerns by the Engineering Employers Federation (EEF), which according to Allen (2004:9) noted in response to the Consultative Document on the OEL framework, that: 'OELs appear to be blamed as being too complicated for companies to understand, leading to a failure of COSHH. However, the issue is in fact far broader and the failure of COSHH is basically down to a lack of knowledge within companies and a lack of proper enforcement.'
168 Beyond Limits 168
The same body pointed out that contrary to the thinking of HSE over the past several years COSHH Essentials would not be an effective solution on anything like the scale envisaged; "There are many areas where COSHH Essentials simply does not work, for example in the construction industry, for peripatetic workers, and in maintenance activities.' The hygienists added that although COSHH Essentials was a useful tool it was 'not the panacea claimed by some' and it was insufficiently tried and tested to be accorded the role identified for it by the HSE. Notions of a greater role for occupational health professionals and more integrated preventive approaches that utilise their expertise are frequently dismissed as unrealistic in the UK because of the additional resources that are perceived to be required, because of the scale of regulatory change necessary and because current demographic realities suggest that there would anyway be insufficient expertise to meet demand. It is, for example, doubtful whether sufficient qualified hygienists still exist in the UK. The decline of the industries in which their skills were required has significantly reduced the number of existing hygienists and at the same time reduced demand for them has in turn led to reduced provision of the necessary specialist education and training thereby reducing their supply. Arguably however, such an approach to prevention services is necessary to meet the requirements of Directives such as the Framework Directive. Indeed, in the recent past the HSE has come some way to acknowledge the need to make special provision for specialist occupational health and safety advice for small firms and has supported several new initiatives in this area.216 While the OEL Framework and COSHH Essentials suggest a possible way forward, it is important to point out that it is only one way forward and that its critics have suggested other approaches. The strategy currently favoured by the
For example, there have been a series of pilot projects such as one for small enterprises in Scotland, one for the construction industry in Leicestershire and an occupational health, safety and rehabilitation service in Kirklees all of which involve access to third party problem solvers and signposting to specialist services. At the same time it also should be noted that the HSE's own national occupational health advisory service has been reduced to almost nothing and the post